id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01620v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01620v2
|
MAGDi: Structured Distillation of Multi-Agent Interaction Graphs Improves Reasoning in Smaller Language Models
| 2024-02-02T18:35:14 | 2024-06-07T18:13:16 |
Justin Chih-Yao Chen, Swarnadeep Saha, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-agent interactions between Large Language Model (LLM) agents have shown
major improvements on diverse reasoning tasks. However, these involve long
generations from multiple models across several rounds, making them expensive.
Moreover, these multi-agent approaches fail to provide a final, single model
for efficient inference. To address this, we introduce MAGDi, a new method for
structured distillation of the reasoning interactions between multiple LLMs
into smaller LMs. MAGDi teaches smaller models by representing multi-agent
interactions as graphs, augmenting a base student model with a graph encoder,
and distilling knowledge using three objective functions: next-token
prediction, a contrastive loss between correct and incorrect reasoning, and a
graph-based objective to model the interaction structure. Experiments on seven
widely used commonsense and math reasoning benchmarks show that MAGDi improves
the reasoning capabilities of smaller models, outperforming several methods
that distill from a single teacher and multiple teachers. Moreover, MAGDi also
demonstrates an order of magnitude higher efficiency over its teachers. We
conduct extensive analyses to show that MAGDi (1) enhances the generalizability
to out-of-domain tasks, (2) scales positively with the size and strength of the
base student model, and (3) obtains larger improvements (via our multi-teacher
training) when applying self-consistency -- an inference technique that relies
on model diversity.
|
[
-0.4158456326,
-0.7712158561,
0.6343732476,
0.0911526233,
0.0658912286,
0.3715628088,
-0.2530161142,
0.0058329012,
0.0452076681,
0.1246941313,
-0.3469779193,
-0.3895055056,
-0.5416170955,
0.2376409769,
-0.2146965265,
0.725115478,
0.1953486353,
0.3252975047,
-0.553602457,
0.0570467226,
-0.1616909802,
-0.4795176387,
-0.4904643893,
-0.8523549438,
0.5406289697,
0.4881486297,
0.7172678113,
0.3658624887,
0.3932487965,
0.4395830631,
-0.1970050782,
0.9724015594,
-0.5554638505,
0.1006743237,
-0.4428800941,
-0.3142110109,
-0.5820721984,
0.1526580751,
0.6466091275,
1.0292998552,
-0.1315934807,
-0.1162781119,
0.1609560102,
0.7975085378,
-0.8448450565,
0.2629721165,
-0.4332022369,
-0.1557357162,
0.2089687437,
0.0836662278,
-0.8334087729,
-0.2054411918,
-0.0517531373,
-0.6084204316,
0.0177187473,
-0.247984305,
0.6696979403,
0.3864811063,
-0.7590577602,
-0.2503240407,
-0.7243273258,
0.5966138244,
-0.4459543526,
0.3712642491,
0.3772201538,
0.3331151307,
-0.4600233734,
-1.0245699883,
-0.68067348,
0.032773573,
-0.2066214681,
-0.0333419666,
-0.3328850269,
0.1534020752,
0.217898339,
0.1468608975,
-0.0903374329,
-0.2258890569,
-0.5185518265,
-0.0029897015,
0.7090697885,
0.0264235139,
0.0970032066,
-0.0018278947,
-0.1404878348,
-0.1319174469,
-0.692414403,
-0.1017945111,
0.3822747171,
0.3861766458,
0.2230342627,
0.6273952723,
-0.1436179876,
0.6744711995,
0.3248340189,
-0.5269639492,
0.3440859318,
-0.5310058594,
-0.2528966069,
-0.1637884527,
0.6627650857,
0.2086291164,
0.4714736044,
-0.111939095,
0.1672679335,
-0.0547373034,
-0.0915634185,
-1.1064740419,
-0.6317570806,
0.0133707123,
-0.2046563625,
-0.1852365583,
-0.0061627459,
-0.5371801853,
-0.508969605,
-0.3794968724,
0.2263874412,
-0.5465584397,
-0.3101417422,
0.1938447058,
-0.3631904125,
-0.2272887081,
0.452060461,
-0.7849969268,
0.4014056623,
0.6798483133,
0.8889734745,
0.0633253381,
-0.6984220147,
-0.7936432958,
0.3777294755,
-0.3792793751,
0.8359116316,
-0.8143856525,
-0.512853384,
-0.5227808356,
-0.1591610461,
-0.3146858811,
-0.4125348926,
0.181303665,
-0.1539449394,
0.025809139,
-0.2950481176,
-0.5458005071,
-0.1614968926,
0.3199370801,
-0.6670126915,
0.8660745621,
0.0471365191,
-0.6423556209,
0.3143523633,
-0.7356318831,
-0.3141595423,
-0.2165869325,
0.0511082932,
-0.3705187738,
-0.0329793915,
0.4550360143,
0.2656787932,
-0.1650859863,
0.2548275888,
-0.4996575117,
-0.3986389339,
0.1159565076,
-0.3276902139,
0.7212831378,
0.3480104804,
0.1507394165,
0.0939924493,
-0.5958276987,
0.0853281394,
0.0959743038,
-0.0966290012,
-0.5518503189,
0.1263927966,
-0.6769111753,
0.0779673457,
0.076231882,
-0.2460959852,
0.6156681776,
-0.3684962094,
0.6989063025,
0.6372132897,
-0.0112193292,
0.8726041317,
-0.1023030505,
0.254912436,
0.1572418213,
0.1329735368,
-0.0873422995,
-0.4607678056,
-0.5846726894,
-0.8680686355,
0.4050121307,
0.1530762166,
-0.9201194048,
0.0283483602,
-0.202548191,
-0.6335800886,
-0.4807730317,
0.2304333299,
0.3334188163,
0.4695073664,
0.3266534209,
0.0721331462,
-0.3070884049,
-0.5899517536,
0.0357233584,
-0.1816585064,
0.1965664178,
0.0540767126,
0.6471942067,
-0.305480659,
1.1396212578,
-0.7076451182,
-0.1832777411,
-0.435351342,
0.0797997788,
0.104524821,
0.2402169257,
0.753518939,
-0.6489481926,
-0.7732576728,
0.011747825,
-0.4803706408,
-0.1334125847,
0.0786658525,
-0.4480718672,
-0.1825489402,
0.2851218283,
-0.5888676643,
0.3288034797,
0.3592565954,
-0.4437974095,
0.3514574766,
-0.3799429536,
0.2389129698,
-1.0093787909,
-0.346350044,
-0.2582757175,
-0.2794909179,
-0.7345573902,
-0.0639317259,
-0.0729593933,
0.0281000789,
-0.2618981302,
0.5461469293,
-0.6541768312,
-0.0162933357,
-0.4568726122,
0.2832324505,
0.6676052213,
0.4078885913,
-0.1649761945,
0.9740332365,
0.5949729681,
-0.306835562,
0.5040281415,
0.3046614528,
-0.0115914252,
0.6696415544,
-0.6583844423,
0.2455373257,
-0.2196652293,
0.2752096951,
-0.9556208849,
0.0837342814,
0.2421818823,
-0.3939363658,
0.1258259714,
-0.3873213828,
-0.5730388165,
-0.3108146787,
-0.2045940757,
0.2914080918,
0.1504352391,
-0.7554462552,
1.0641919374,
0.2039793432,
0.1174963191,
-0.660022676,
-0.5039026737,
-0.0881065726,
-0.1108048633,
-0.6761533618,
-0.0805224702,
-0.1534537673,
-0.6654191017,
0.2072994113,
-0.1043770537,
-0.4348084033,
0.3513412178,
0.2206201255,
0.2015967965,
0.105035238,
0.4849969447,
0.4275119901,
0.0030938964,
-0.0557003282,
-0.1745796055,
0.5421597958,
-0.416231066,
-0.6532268524,
-0.2053720057,
0.3877769113,
0.5134971142,
-0.440431565,
0.9667103887,
0.3454671502,
-0.1963029504,
-0.461766541,
-0.1279602796,
-0.249225378,
-0.5020102859,
0.3228962421,
-0.9094957709,
-0.5555467606,
0.2718179226,
-0.4294510186,
-0.0878199488,
0.3290361166,
0.4708999097,
0.1064650789,
1.2661969662,
0.4416009784,
0.1977933645,
0.3237121403,
-0.6004886627,
0.3599734306,
-0.557487905,
-0.4448435009,
-0.3760085106,
-0.2914716005,
-0.106731914,
-0.5963621736,
0.3073270321,
0.3692669272,
-0.3055525422,
0.0746981353,
-0.6965550184,
0.9364662766,
0.5570115447,
0.0317859575,
0.6456855536,
-0.0304265413,
-0.0724913254,
0.175720498,
-0.7492302656,
-0.534060359,
1.1063374281,
0.0645699501,
0.8852779865,
0.2698846459,
0.9546736479,
0.2984972596,
0.4768554568,
-0.6464639902,
0.4722101092,
-0.0131431995,
-0.4632891417,
-0.3556509018,
-0.554900825,
-0.8115267754,
0.8328089714,
-0.2056071162,
-0.5336488485,
0.4310011566,
0.0700805485,
-0.0870645121,
0.3074609637,
-1.352612257,
0.7938981652,
0.0802994743,
-0.2985429764,
-0.1354441643,
-0.3465557098,
0.4134221077,
-0.0650783405,
0.2436838001,
-0.393840462,
0.2575708032,
0.2707955539,
-0.8486347198,
0.79139328,
-0.0779095888,
-0.0563854128,
0.6307606697,
0.0623261407,
0.6351190805,
0.0785595253,
-0.2619384825,
0.0688254535,
0.1891925335,
-0.4178237617,
-0.980679214,
0.5794865489,
-0.863799572,
-0.6240369081,
-0.3284668922,
-0.8751713634,
-0.024970362,
0.2192751616,
-0.1508811265,
0.3912666738,
0.062415529,
-0.0185499731,
0.2578755617,
0.4898579121,
0.2145659924,
0.4369618297,
-0.2506886721,
-0.373374939,
0.8577802181,
0.16989474,
0.4815905988,
0.0051852874,
0.2090450078,
-0.2402307242,
-0.1631735116,
-0.2448579371,
0.3391805291,
-1.0449286699,
-0.2559519112,
-0.5773206353,
-0.2252013832,
-0.5380027294,
-0.2346903682,
-0.5268984437,
-0.5300422907,
-0.3343511224,
-0.1846168041,
0.3124028444,
0.6354680061,
-0.3799315691,
0.2598374486,
-0.4798161387,
0.2091347724,
0.4884755313,
-0.1368819177,
-0.0023025263,
-0.2048874795,
-0.1412474811,
0.3854234517,
-0.31436342,
-1.0201994181,
0.3699113429,
0.6233369708,
0.5312682986,
0.553989172,
0.2885840833,
0.9010668993,
-0.6770700216,
0.3067193329,
0.2810712457,
-1.168027997,
0.4317521453,
0.2277754992,
0.052426368,
0.3928824663,
0.2204065174,
-0.1769339591,
-0.4749543667,
-0.3574375808,
-0.4852956831,
0.5403738618,
0.1156611964,
-0.033202298,
-0.2952162623,
0.2422968,
-0.0190665834,
0.2336097062,
-0.4569629729,
-0.4424403608,
-0.3975987434,
-0.1783248186,
-0.049892474,
-0.190163672,
-0.4920283556,
-0.615403533,
0.5653675199,
-0.424349606,
-0.005823459,
0.1576377004,
-0.179084003,
0.2185530066,
0.2380699068,
0.3782714903,
0.9085755944,
0.0674071535,
0.612667799,
0.3640645742,
-0.2972683012,
0.3679466248,
0.2723871768,
0.0888092369,
-0.0408881418,
0.3462769687,
0.6562427282,
-0.1487421095,
-0.5983945727,
0.5542444587,
0.0181517936,
-0.3227888644,
0.0863702446,
0.2187760472,
0.2768570483,
0.9111314416,
0.2610521317,
-0.0687644258,
0.2544868886,
-0.5370331407,
0.1432557851,
0.4403816164,
0.0473599099,
-0.1519572884,
0.5599037409,
0.1912880987,
-0.1045486778,
0.5834447145,
-0.5818228126,
-0.3779952824,
0.6520656347,
0.6200910807,
0.5094180703,
-0.1926834285,
0.6102967858,
0.3026189506,
0.150091365,
-0.1070640385,
0.0798796192,
-0.179136157,
-0.8776207566,
-0.7391667366,
-0.2356443554,
-0.7179065347,
-0.4370223582,
-0.4024299383,
0.1024734452,
-0.1881629378,
-0.2547563016,
0.2709195912,
0.2071103156,
-0.2054672688,
-0.2504748106,
0.0365948863,
0.5473182797,
-0.8731155396,
1.0695422888,
0.6186230183,
-0.4404281974,
-0.9374374747,
-0.3953767419,
-0.1061686799,
-0.5487129688,
0.885641098,
0.0547294058,
-0.3778775036,
0.0283481833,
-0.6067738533,
-0.752327919,
1.137765646,
0.6380550861,
-0.5196953416,
-0.0910007805,
-0.0254423562,
0.4441410899,
-0.5232992172,
0.3975217342,
0.6704147458,
0.4749346375,
0.5184592009,
-0.7993384004,
-0.0809211284,
-0.2581634521,
-0.2452167869,
0.326906532,
-0.5918140411,
1.0693944693,
-0.6730967164,
-0.2663169801,
-0.2288667262,
0.8345661759,
0.3746865094,
0.5612192154,
0.443793565,
0.4673912227,
1.2231780291,
-0.216520384,
0.7735512257,
-0.2049123645,
0.647511065,
1.3648695946,
-0.4914728701,
0.3941348791,
0.4761686921,
-0.1631719172,
0.6510916352,
0.2878194749,
-0.1896390468,
0.6591683626,
0.0795232281,
-0.2991841137,
-0.5457263589,
-0.0767074525,
-0.3832314909,
0.3161845803,
0.2068988979,
-0.0493993051,
-0.4740745723,
0.2302369326,
0.1356532723,
0.3292298019,
-0.2770908177,
0.5841094255,
-0.0341650136,
-0.494751513,
0.5455826521,
-0.0975905955,
0.1897872835,
-0.2597846389,
-0.2078165859,
-0.2812971771,
0.3825513721,
-0.2036102563,
-0.5941962004,
0.2926814556,
-0.1835288107,
-0.3829361498,
-0.1063209325,
0.7341098189,
-0.8204841614,
-0.5222103596,
0.1797775924,
0.737544775,
0.2693760395,
-0.0278651994,
-0.5078222156,
-0.1129785702,
-0.185734883,
-0.1535545588,
0.1361109763,
0.7043400407,
0.0018416414,
0.8445180058,
0.6305107474,
0.0176559463,
0.0045098085,
0.3144060075,
1.320477128,
-0.085011445,
-0.1490637511,
-1.0884610415,
0.3030292988,
-0.3795400262,
0.1287654638,
0.8870165944,
0.4909179807,
0.6196106076,
0.1668610573,
0.36942029,
0.1223042756,
0.2431741506,
-0.3092114627,
0.5378114581,
-0.5227028131,
0.1798157394,
-0.1837943941,
-0.9244733453,
-0.0276894458,
0.722550571,
-0.5255432725,
-0.0077543599,
0.7846387625,
0.537902236,
-0.0374837071,
-0.2972586155,
0.3332386613,
0.0571348704,
0.5039156079,
0.569978714,
0.8423253298,
-0.140326336,
0.7022020221,
-0.3616627157,
0.0000168143,
0.0823029727,
-0.6284510493,
-1.3666590452,
-0.4595392644,
-0.3942029476,
-0.3564806879,
0.1038946137,
0.9603617191,
0.7275294065,
-0.4033745527,
0.0397667885,
0.0842542127,
0.7281629443,
-0.3949717283,
-0.1980340779,
0.3990209103,
-0.418674469,
-1.314940691,
0.5786634088,
0.2164523154,
-0.0935402289,
-0.1618783623,
-0.4063940346,
-0.2747267783,
0.4304969013,
0.7206065655,
0.0375048108,
-0.4862152934,
-0.2647221386,
-0.1595372707,
-0.1462396681,
0.0658861995,
0.582703948,
-0.6688039899,
0.58828789,
0.5450071692,
0.2028270066,
0.6265897751,
0.2040297091,
0.3723817468,
-0.7561720014,
0.4470616579,
-0.1332637072,
0.4647895694,
0.1471132785,
-0.0808434486,
0.7253856063,
0.3505668044,
-0.4538491666,
-1.0693672895,
0.2514085174,
-0.5830702186,
-0.6205493808,
1.114766717,
-0.3994982541,
-0.1818894893,
0.0092951413,
-0.255541116,
0.1766581535,
-0.3522841036,
0.5094011426,
0.7535562515,
-0.0688265041,
-0.1994363964,
0.0105467606,
0.239367187,
-0.0031195395,
-0.8844175935,
-0.1233897284,
0.7260828018,
0.2300050259,
0.2303763479,
0.6588292122,
0.1775189787,
0.077382803,
0.2171654999,
0.0860831141,
-0.746925354,
-0.7457894087,
0.2200993896,
0.3196004629,
-0.0302414261,
-0.185171023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01619v1
|
KB-Plugin: A Plug-and-play Framework for Large Language Models to Induce Programs over Low-resourced Knowledge Bases
| 2024-02-02T18:32:24 | 2024-02-02T18:32:24 |
Jiajie Zhang, Shulin Cao, Linmei Hu, Ling Feng, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Program induction (PI) has become a promising paradigm for using knowledge
bases (KBs) to help large language models (LLMs) answer complex
knowledge-intensive questions. Nonetheless, PI typically relies on a large
number of parallel question-program pairs to make the LLM aware of the schema
of the given KB, and is thus challenging for many low-resourced KBs that lack
annotated data. To this end, we propose KB-Plugin, a plug-and-play framework
that enables LLMs to induce programs over any low-resourced KB. Firstly,
KB-Plugin adopts self-supervised learning to encode the detailed schema
information of a given KB into a pluggable module, namely schema plugin.
Secondly, KB-Plugin utilizes abundant annotated data from a rich-resourced KB
to train another pluggable module, namely PI plugin, which can help the LLM
extract question-relevant schema information from the schema plugin of any KB
and utilize this information to induce programs over this KB. Experiments on
five heterogeneous KBQA datasets show that KB-Plugin achieves better or
comparable performance with 25$\times$ smaller backbone LLM compared to SoTA PI
methods for low-resourced KBs, and even approaches the performance of
supervised methods. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KB-Plugin.
|
[
-0.278226465,
-0.7019584179,
0.7016566396,
0.5239208341,
0.0259685237,
0.0975826755,
-0.5922067165,
-0.0766917244,
0.341088742,
0.5861194134,
-0.5180598497,
-0.5726203322,
-0.2531404495,
-0.002087537,
-0.3241409361,
0.609964788,
0.202619642,
0.0411957502,
-0.4760609865,
0.2579576075,
-0.5462251902,
-0.1940756589,
-0.1328276992,
-0.2874123752,
0.4359647036,
0.7069926262,
0.4688155353,
0.4661367834,
0.2849829197,
0.2188680321,
0.2039838582,
0.3184316158,
-0.532723546,
0.1276989877,
-0.126072228,
-0.7252271771,
-0.2349520475,
-0.0721061379,
0.3923076093,
0.8384890556,
-0.0213862248,
0.150794521,
-0.1448679715,
0.5596274734,
-0.8276877403,
0.5119364858,
-0.7558429837,
0.062153168,
-0.1420177966,
-0.2887675762,
-0.7343068719,
-0.2803824842,
-0.054192286,
-0.8274113536,
0.1001796499,
0.249186784,
0.4900386631,
0.1358135343,
-0.3472045064,
-0.3121244907,
-0.7891910672,
0.5988273025,
-0.7872856855,
0.2869692743,
0.252738595,
0.2701226473,
-0.6469197869,
-0.5667458773,
-0.7334825993,
-0.3594049513,
-0.4950020909,
0.060955219,
0.2578517795,
0.0801150873,
0.6013191938,
0.4465409815,
-0.641717732,
0.1556872576,
-0.4727167189,
-0.1832169294,
0.3413663805,
0.2128033191,
0.2355481833,
-0.34627828,
0.0165462084,
0.2414786816,
-1.0175602436,
-0.1345546842,
0.2301635295,
0.5410510302,
-0.0532526001,
0.731641233,
-0.4224283695,
0.8568240404,
0.1816756874,
-0.2134942859,
0.2159531862,
0.0415343791,
-0.2855918705,
0.3578704596,
0.8953613043,
-0.0165935159,
0.108125262,
-0.4638260007,
-0.1014670506,
0.1800354123,
0.1603245288,
-0.8756515384,
-0.5494163036,
0.2206921875,
-0.2442459911,
-0.6186854243,
-0.1245249286,
-0.7651572227,
-0.50129354,
-0.3074396551,
0.5680279732,
-0.4891419113,
-0.3325565159,
0.0174761079,
0.0429107584,
0.3146881163,
0.143377766,
-1.0761014223,
0.2004183829,
0.6757315993,
0.8732625246,
-0.3321254253,
-0.2945762873,
-0.6911575198,
0.3883276284,
-0.4455907345,
0.7240059376,
-0.5923902392,
-0.3182605803,
0.215440318,
0.2596505582,
-0.0023222957,
-0.5813730955,
-0.1282279938,
-0.8774715662,
0.3101570904,
-0.5039605498,
-0.8445270658,
0.1371378303,
0.07068979,
-0.7101335526,
1.0554069281,
0.4981765151,
-0.8242954016,
0.4837590456,
-0.9834641814,
-0.6489009857,
0.1738294959,
-0.4893454611,
-0.1806300133,
0.0722871423,
0.2366032004,
0.6162497997,
-0.2018263191,
0.20901528,
-0.3826335967,
-0.508036077,
-0.0265794769,
0.1012052074,
1.0393072367,
0.0830069706,
-0.2063548118,
-0.0602206774,
-0.6791598797,
-0.0266058017,
0.2232152373,
-0.5386966467,
-0.2978410721,
-0.4539698362,
-0.3678396344,
0.3537065089,
0.027070161,
-0.5722205639,
0.6417092681,
-0.5979966521,
0.3812647462,
0.506380856,
-0.0042980271,
0.8415074944,
0.0823049322,
0.7106671929,
0.0736974552,
-0.1048020273,
-0.4283418655,
-0.3923712075,
-0.7981867194,
-0.4444003403,
0.3670940101,
0.5770686865,
-0.843862772,
0.4867583215,
-0.255666554,
-0.5569094419,
-0.5211527348,
0.3512612283,
0.129481554,
0.6040084958,
0.3035948277,
-0.1030513346,
-0.3769056797,
-0.7929241657,
-0.1043621451,
-0.1356017888,
-0.1763868928,
0.5914794803,
0.3350944519,
0.0098187216,
0.9269067049,
-0.6307913661,
-0.1027302667,
-0.2752475142,
0.1914145052,
0.3427989781,
0.5337492228,
0.3889929652,
-0.3776150942,
-0.7178879976,
-0.0513805263,
-0.7951048613,
-0.4180426002,
-0.2378069013,
-0.4622847438,
0.179365024,
0.6571470499,
-1.0198334455,
0.1181954518,
0.4192825258,
-0.2762612104,
0.9819068313,
0.0979503244,
0.216310665,
-0.9507003427,
0.229516387,
-0.5830542445,
-0.2102859467,
-0.6005758047,
-0.1469583362,
0.3447469473,
-0.1766834259,
-0.4605697691,
0.2374232709,
-0.2929401398,
-0.3519418836,
-0.1107084975,
0.0036663227,
0.2276116312,
0.4532859921,
-0.1576038152,
1.0351252556,
0.7100799084,
-0.6303514242,
0.679561615,
0.2964368165,
-0.5366432667,
0.1527406573,
-0.1173251048,
-0.0049347598,
-0.143478021,
0.1205572486,
-0.7195127606,
-0.51423949,
0.2500339746,
-0.2558739483,
0.6345351934,
-0.4283675253,
-0.7299008369,
-0.323846966,
0.0344291851,
0.2118360698,
0.5115902424,
-0.700620532,
0.7037577033,
0.0746208057,
-0.107452482,
-0.3764985204,
-0.5313093662,
-0.0598327406,
-0.1398094296,
-0.4368061721,
0.3328779638,
0.078839004,
0.0255821906,
0.1653318107,
0.19256033,
0.063605696,
-0.0962177813,
0.3196241856,
0.4102303386,
-0.4839520156,
0.5575098395,
0.2991681695,
-0.0839465633,
0.2068301439,
-0.6719272137,
0.6817514896,
-0.129218623,
-0.6675066948,
-0.1035345867,
0.2547335327,
0.7077950239,
-0.2729490697,
0.8492255211,
0.5957105756,
-0.034836296,
-0.2300097197,
-0.7209626436,
-0.383405149,
-0.4976778924,
0.3738126457,
-0.2477554381,
-1.1778197289,
0.2127867788,
-0.683385551,
-0.1450284868,
0.1949751526,
0.8301272988,
-0.1694716066,
0.7390835881,
0.7027007937,
-0.3906511962,
0.3049511611,
-0.3678998351,
0.4136222005,
-0.4498786032,
-0.1636444926,
-0.1346493065,
-0.1885056943,
-0.5511911511,
-0.4858418703,
0.2683424056,
0.2086648196,
-0.1011073068,
0.297611326,
-0.4139739871,
0.6577585936,
0.6805536151,
-0.0924573243,
0.1834489554,
0.038300734,
-0.3536557257,
0.1545562744,
-1.1179270744,
-0.136327818,
1.2793596983,
0.0294769965,
0.6853836775,
-0.2372606546,
0.7841125727,
0.3444138169,
0.428771466,
-0.8365044594,
0.5154300332,
0.1874305755,
-0.704235971,
-0.4597821534,
-0.3207080364,
-0.4454164505,
-0.1556932181,
-0.3668343425,
-0.6988616586,
0.1911673695,
0.5287296176,
-0.497084111,
0.2166693807,
-0.8798375726,
1.0330122709,
-0.0814037994,
-0.4214316607,
-0.2409237325,
-0.4319302738,
0.7508790493,
-0.2016310394,
0.0863303393,
0.0038740111,
0.3345009089,
0.5122972727,
-0.3746117353,
0.6398967505,
-0.4533171654,
0.0863259807,
0.3680692613,
0.4850844443,
0.7156168222,
0.0457616262,
0.0725194067,
-0.0905031338,
-0.0447506495,
-0.4532207251,
-0.8475182056,
0.9877817631,
-0.4723179936,
-0.6220367551,
0.0290661231,
-0.7152078748,
-0.405163765,
0.2642613947,
0.2008194774,
0.206013009,
0.2755745649,
0.1481643617,
0.8053232431,
-0.4496474266,
0.0258896463,
0.475997746,
-0.5650908947,
-0.116818428,
0.8416116834,
0.0484096073,
0.4241987467,
0.3102857769,
0.2445732504,
0.073761642,
-0.0245132037,
-0.4817436934,
0.2109352946,
-0.5650009513,
-0.3813497424,
-0.8402045369,
-0.2069114745,
-0.4601124227,
-0.2888045609,
-0.4753582478,
-0.6789032221,
0.0468381122,
-0.2355015278,
0.6686522961,
0.5123811364,
-0.0968559235,
0.6097285151,
-0.4673785567,
0.2081521899,
0.4565451741,
0.5357493162,
-0.023695793,
-0.3564977348,
-0.6365984082,
-0.3760189712,
-0.0961732268,
-0.8063459396,
0.1837902814,
0.1393091977,
0.2929773033,
0.5879306197,
0.1547141671,
0.5575873256,
-0.6818268299,
0.6363651156,
0.0971155539,
-0.5898168087,
0.6224048138,
-0.3116355836,
0.1743994802,
0.3921970129,
0.5796626806,
-0.4370833635,
-0.568271637,
-0.3693548143,
-0.7848531604,
0.92201823,
0.0464344956,
0.0464181714,
0.0198703036,
0.3974047601,
0.2775251567,
0.3831549585,
-0.6569702029,
-0.1043821126,
-0.2809577584,
-0.1612354815,
0.2938379347,
-0.4212836623,
-0.0519076437,
-0.1700997353,
0.8620688319,
-0.156653747,
0.4033493698,
-0.0473183766,
-0.324333787,
-0.1868390888,
0.2395116687,
0.1339118034,
0.5452895164,
-0.2202387899,
0.2850161493,
0.2505686283,
-0.2216436565,
-0.0454375036,
-0.0224067662,
-0.2793181539,
-0.0734688267,
0.4629920125,
0.4715437293,
0.1747003943,
-0.6353380084,
0.5856066942,
0.0998739302,
0.0067595113,
-0.0689514801,
0.2269749939,
0.4605636001,
0.2759777904,
-0.0778799653,
-0.326777041,
0.0945356414,
-0.2178145498,
0.0724794343,
0.4260101914,
-0.0953167155,
-0.1312436461,
0.3660342097,
0.0157282166,
-0.2524848878,
0.6974006295,
-0.5837368369,
-0.5822571516,
0.2391975522,
0.815141499,
0.5236247182,
-0.1075457036,
0.1159098521,
0.368511349,
0.2773393691,
0.2302350402,
0.3673613071,
-0.2833414078,
-0.5908469558,
-0.9199547768,
-0.6113110781,
-0.1496418118,
0.5749283433,
-0.3560968041,
0.3915607929,
-0.3062014878,
0.1230053008,
-0.0260047168,
-0.1860703826,
-0.8442545533,
-0.2161614448,
0.0254985336,
1.2131639719,
-1.3329997063,
0.8819934726,
0.5991311073,
-0.3713752031,
-0.8818654418,
-0.1411591917,
-0.166732505,
-0.5814915895,
0.8547475338,
0.2223631144,
0.1141305938,
0.1013617888,
-0.6500056982,
-0.7404587269,
1.065112114,
0.3512176275,
-0.4881273806,
-0.0891193748,
0.4858393967,
0.1249744594,
-0.4417008162,
-0.1200686768,
0.7064719796,
0.337867558,
-0.2251075655,
-0.6955010295,
0.1652979255,
-0.0306312945,
-0.1262325197,
0.0363490656,
-0.4056049585,
0.4671717286,
-0.1308516413,
0.2260715365,
-0.2327932268,
0.6700792909,
0.347125262,
0.0650254786,
0.6032043695,
0.4264309406,
0.5470076203,
0.1335157305,
0.5742719769,
-0.7829571366,
0.1714986563,
1.0647134781,
-0.2816295028,
0.424949646,
0.7060847878,
-0.2957360744,
0.6126870513,
0.1951848716,
-0.1411606967,
0.7053092122,
0.2856407762,
-0.4472080767,
-0.5044667721,
-0.0239256062,
-0.1742342114,
0.4361183047,
0.5879588127,
-0.3133129478,
-0.1069279611,
0.0807739273,
-0.0717765018,
-0.0765405297,
-0.0986230373,
0.6796911359,
0.0436802544,
-0.6294106841,
0.1850837618,
-0.043845538,
0.308072567,
-0.7088330984,
-0.202466622,
-0.1860391051,
-0.1486032605,
-0.2980580628,
-0.3784519732,
0.0910705104,
-0.1284769922,
-0.352273196,
0.1954070628,
1.2500802279,
-0.4551658034,
-0.560554862,
0.1839924604,
0.5841697454,
0.0986471772,
-0.0314651392,
-0.2070980817,
-0.1510957927,
-0.2541587055,
-0.3863299787,
0.3296945095,
0.8203138113,
0.0965652913,
0.6976169944,
0.7603808641,
0.3667973578,
0.1926609427,
0.0538050421,
1.2162630558,
-0.4482493699,
-0.536662817,
-0.7378219366,
0.4089416564,
-0.1969493777,
0.3533039689,
0.7331758142,
0.8398352861,
0.7297655344,
-0.4908461869,
1.0052351952,
-0.4388786554,
0.5406014323,
-0.4975763261,
0.7640035152,
-0.2518091202,
0.285569191,
-0.1861513257,
-0.7324854732,
-0.2014814168,
0.5613496304,
-0.4870717525,
-0.1472561359,
0.4894820452,
1.2057962418,
-0.3486449718,
-0.0072450386,
0.418173641,
0.3914142847,
0.2604431808,
0.3562583327,
0.8908560872,
0.0743481144,
0.5926661491,
-0.6024484038,
-0.4303004146,
-0.4623318315,
-0.9656236172,
-1.061506629,
-0.3626832068,
-0.1429575533,
-0.5126217008,
-0.0249755476,
1.2762322426,
0.9030609131,
-1.1100096703,
-0.0862460881,
-0.2510421574,
0.1536918283,
-0.0033365234,
-0.2958205938,
0.5757505298,
-0.7887011766,
-0.2361238748,
0.5345106721,
0.4921228886,
-0.4233826697,
-0.6352763772,
-0.0263125002,
-0.0870939642,
-0.1443653107,
0.7815973759,
0.2513172626,
-0.4964109361,
-0.1232624948,
0.0856783763,
-0.0111074969,
-0.1206619963,
1.088498354,
-1.2201206684,
0.5079778433,
0.2434942424,
0.8336477876,
0.4544973671,
-0.4272524714,
0.5521147847,
-0.9503349662,
0.1266191602,
0.1187309027,
0.2908688188,
0.1303508878,
-0.6252509356,
0.3446947932,
0.2793290913,
-0.6178563237,
-0.8424500823,
0.4488686323,
-0.6086885929,
-0.0694317445,
1.1527534723,
-0.2589995563,
-0.3023717105,
-0.0871433467,
-0.0828731284,
0.253602922,
-0.2682222426,
1.0786235332,
0.6298390627,
-0.2314875573,
0.0946085006,
-0.7269977927,
0.721252799,
0.0601276495,
-0.6630245447,
0.451184243,
0.4206971824,
0.3023641407,
0.2133277506,
0.6815097332,
-0.048935201,
0.3372196555,
-0.0431410596,
0.1857833862,
-0.4377676845,
-0.3950687051,
0.0286801588,
-0.0172655024,
0.1905992329,
0.0280503184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01618v1
|
Style Vectors for Steering Generative Large Language Model
| 2024-02-02T18:31:15 | 2024-02-02T18:31:15 |
Kai Konen, Sophie Jentzsch, Diaoulé Diallo, Peer Schütt, Oliver Bensch, Roxanne El Baff, Dominik Opitz, Tobias Hecking
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This research explores strategies for steering the output of large language
models (LLMs) towards specific styles, such as sentiment, emotion, or writing
style, by adding style vectors to the activations of hidden layers during text
generation. We show that style vectors can be simply computed from recorded
layer activations for input texts in a specific style in contrast to more
complex training-based approaches. Through a series of experiments, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of activation engineering using such style
vectors to influence the style of generated text in a nuanced and
parameterisable way, distinguishing it from prompt engineering. The presented
research constitutes a significant step towards developing more adaptive and
effective AI-empowered interactive systems.
|
[
-0.3608746529,
-0.7684108615,
0.4909954071,
0.7067729831,
-0.1061324701,
0.293402195,
-0.4565056562,
-0.0911563933,
0.2433563173,
0.3413748443,
-0.6480823755,
-0.5532441139,
-0.5299656391,
0.0414951928,
-0.5238605142,
0.8301366568,
-0.2994274497,
0.0243071318,
-0.1552258879,
0.0667010546,
-0.3720306754,
-0.7990679145,
-0.7988274693,
-0.552239418,
0.6967785954,
0.3963069022,
0.6346425414,
0.2566135824,
0.2075544596,
0.4210920334,
-0.1968953907,
0.1449032575,
-0.5486034751,
0.5209690332,
0.003789983,
-0.3002808094,
-0.6215683222,
0.061410524,
0.4821618497,
0.3239114881,
0.1236529201,
-0.1405775249,
0.4029480517,
0.7344155312,
-0.5142022371,
0.1902367324,
-0.3400840163,
0.2125769854,
-0.0751686096,
-0.6957606673,
-0.7722945213,
-0.0920226723,
-0.0457771085,
-0.4901490211,
-0.2415857762,
0.051532004,
0.6252539158,
0.0833842531,
-0.3696676195,
-0.39498052,
-1.0654104948,
0.9686652422,
-0.5144150257,
0.3572125435,
0.0723059252,
0.0541675687,
-0.1188482344,
-0.5813808441,
-0.6486814618,
-0.2612452507,
0.0482857488,
0.2931106687,
-0.0773938671,
0.0749036074,
0.2468894273,
-0.0296660215,
-0.2195553929,
0.5271868706,
-0.0313535072,
0.0543120615,
0.892739296,
0.0780818909,
0.5947811604,
-0.1676894277,
-0.4602334201,
-0.2878890634,
-0.8908709884,
0.0103507135,
0.500207305,
0.2168269604,
-0.3520550728,
0.5941575766,
-0.1900898665,
0.4184557498,
0.2033221424,
-0.1657503694,
0.3740697503,
-0.1939269155,
-0.2778084874,
0.1980779767,
0.954392314,
0.3602770269,
0.2856594622,
-0.1101973802,
-0.559137404,
-0.1875212491,
0.5726948977,
-0.7214167714,
0.068889305,
0.2075818181,
-0.4367131293,
-0.6415509582,
-0.1971509159,
-0.8278048635,
-0.5462284684,
-0.6464301348,
0.3949539065,
-0.4926287234,
-0.3648072779,
-0.1679279059,
-0.2281449288,
0.7435911298,
0.333255291,
-1.013669014,
-0.2851828039,
0.7613469958,
0.6802883148,
-0.4443681538,
-0.0365593918,
-0.317012161,
0.0734113827,
-0.7294731736,
0.553907156,
-0.7780390382,
-0.5487676263,
0.3331671655,
-0.1963495612,
0.0823644325,
-0.283010304,
0.6394110918,
-0.7864935398,
0.0864453837,
-0.2557902336,
-0.3069452345,
-0.0732945651,
-0.0206727535,
-0.5620998144,
1.0674307346,
0.0393925011,
-0.5384379029,
0.2122742832,
-0.6853695512,
-0.6010449529,
0.0836507082,
-0.3678851128,
-0.4493370056,
0.1538080424,
0.2754345834,
0.8313066959,
0.0459025018,
0.1445506513,
-0.2090853155,
-0.2060997039,
0.3894276619,
-0.3585992754,
0.5961393118,
0.1533635557,
-0.462290287,
0.7396381497,
-0.7837360501,
-0.11402715,
0.2653675973,
-0.4256723225,
-0.3772279918,
0.0840943605,
0.2148402333,
0.2091510892,
0.1036890745,
-0.260574162,
0.2531910837,
-0.1800731868,
0.3884726465,
0.9544919133,
-0.005126528,
0.8264339566,
-0.3367722332,
0.9184510708,
-0.1934554577,
-0.1857937127,
-0.0898182467,
-0.3418449759,
-1.0197589397,
-0.3474933505,
-0.044875171,
0.4825452864,
-1.1824810505,
0.4623175859,
-0.1436251998,
-0.5028563738,
-0.4049918056,
0.4102752209,
0.2110810131,
0.3725165427,
0.1813239604,
-0.0658900738,
-0.4820334017,
-0.6902006865,
-0.0317374058,
-0.0439036861,
-0.0355029702,
0.1806939244,
0.1472934484,
-0.1713102162,
0.7348726392,
-0.1621572822,
0.133993566,
-0.7726014853,
0.5015031695,
-0.2291253507,
0.523835361,
0.8720706105,
-0.8147919178,
-0.4084505737,
0.0068743746,
-0.8241360784,
-0.3638672829,
-0.3979108632,
-0.4618192017,
0.3626862466,
1.1321218014,
-0.4836363792,
0.2504775226,
0.6908184886,
-0.1757867187,
0.4372999966,
0.1440050751,
0.1494001895,
-1.0826007128,
-0.1267906725,
0.2512982786,
-0.0235553533,
-0.9520746469,
0.1002739668,
0.0546834096,
-0.1369528174,
-0.4714491963,
0.5727229714,
-0.622050643,
0.0748195872,
-0.2893188298,
0.0278437976,
0.2325297147,
0.6456517577,
0.0934247747,
0.7499963641,
0.3785847723,
-0.5861651301,
0.5679727793,
0.1550356448,
-0.544721961,
0.7202954888,
-0.6826711893,
0.3132607639,
-0.3875653446,
-0.0125679644,
-1.2072582245,
-0.1194140613,
0.0450077839,
-0.2898059487,
0.849950552,
0.0054424722,
-0.3403840065,
-0.1364715248,
-0.4014939368,
0.1781767309,
0.7852549553,
-0.5223810077,
0.9480533004,
0.1110929027,
-0.5557359457,
-0.3319474459,
-0.6004122496,
0.1281167865,
-0.4752729237,
-0.6211392879,
0.4745981395,
-0.1020656303,
-0.362350136,
-0.2748995423,
0.3372494578,
0.3119265437,
0.3037947416,
0.4555460811,
0.3839091361,
-0.3889547884,
0.0749816671,
0.2925562561,
0.1841010302,
0.2300358862,
-0.0346432067,
0.9953646064,
0.3106480539,
-0.3956539631,
-0.5304694176,
0.3832052052,
0.7489751577,
-0.5480774641,
0.7598673105,
0.7276918292,
0.1284443438,
-0.6167099476,
-0.2026750147,
-0.0565294586,
-0.5880819559,
0.5384176373,
-0.2620778084,
-0.7213922739,
0.3082650304,
-0.1864349842,
0.1538834125,
0.4052588046,
0.8903749585,
-0.1989106387,
1.2939395905,
0.8546514511,
-0.1454609931,
1.0104619265,
-0.198880434,
0.1543403119,
-0.8927366138,
-0.2944604754,
-0.4578977525,
-0.7065193057,
-0.5916957259,
-0.3817338645,
0.4734369218,
0.1881495267,
-0.3329850137,
-0.1322378516,
-0.3532951176,
0.0316841714,
0.701841712,
0.0465053096,
-0.0385684259,
0.2567060292,
-0.1494685709,
0.2494662553,
-0.6871162057,
-0.5339855552,
0.9574210644,
0.5078968406,
1.018581152,
0.0851879269,
0.7323858142,
0.083149448,
0.5157415867,
-1.1081825495,
0.5916754007,
0.0307002068,
-0.1710979789,
-0.4302232563,
-0.0891840756,
-0.6498711109,
-0.1608504951,
-0.5200188756,
-0.4586934149,
0.2009349465,
0.0689784139,
-0.2535575926,
0.0797798485,
-0.7938058972,
0.5178341866,
-0.2190790623,
-0.3068264723,
-0.0507145636,
-0.1894873977,
0.1062404811,
-0.0555398017,
-0.0050892588,
0.0780944005,
-0.1406609714,
0.800904274,
-0.271192342,
1.1311432123,
0.1429277062,
-0.4272351861,
0.384455651,
0.1943614632,
0.6546357274,
-0.4598017037,
-0.2297853827,
-0.1345883459,
-0.7422995567,
-0.1749916375,
-0.7671350241,
0.8326041698,
-0.9014819264,
-0.6288793683,
-0.0727110133,
-0.5927742124,
-0.3814337552,
0.0318298154,
0.2157782018,
0.5826788545,
-0.2226132601,
0.1911698878,
0.7379690409,
-0.5056223273,
0.7584638596,
0.2165393829,
-0.3528332114,
-0.1764129698,
0.9045647383,
0.0191920586,
0.5501554608,
0.3971840143,
0.114502646,
-0.0500812978,
-0.5068708658,
-0.7172021866,
-0.0436811559,
-0.7708222866,
-0.0256575048,
-0.6373651624,
-0.5241587758,
-0.4441671669,
-0.5341495275,
-0.1857125014,
-0.3389953971,
-0.5969277024,
-0.2669889629,
0.6658579111,
1.0294005871,
0.3877241313,
0.4955466986,
-0.4897944331,
0.1268942803,
0.4002123177,
0.2300443649,
0.2002562284,
-0.5635271668,
0.0732650533,
-0.2866306305,
-0.3443883657,
-0.9429047108,
0.4814034402,
0.0797708556,
0.5001493096,
0.5181985497,
-0.1485097855,
0.1640782505,
-0.6049968004,
0.8239572644,
0.1929763258,
-0.8662052751,
0.3956555128,
-0.3332951665,
0.2880152762,
-0.0505555309,
0.7507640719,
-0.6230071783,
-0.3672412038,
-0.3934122622,
-0.9474362731,
0.4806165993,
-0.0910446048,
0.5689080954,
0.1405945122,
0.4013194442,
-0.2083095461,
0.2355286628,
-0.3594450951,
-0.3601201475,
-0.3413605392,
-0.4598326683,
-0.0479663238,
-0.5950735211,
-0.1226213798,
0.003179986,
0.7619615197,
-0.2326189578,
0.3430353105,
-0.1002970263,
0.1941839755,
-0.083009243,
0.4637064636,
0.6586226225,
0.5157234669,
0.2606240213,
0.0791267082,
-0.178869769,
-0.3397972584,
0.1208227798,
-0.1516000926,
-0.5717725158,
-0.099658072,
0.5329117775,
1.1066827774,
0.1694930792,
-0.2122939825,
0.430908829,
0.2269568592,
-0.0700579286,
-0.061600484,
0.2678403258,
0.2600739598,
0.2100037932,
0.1823494285,
-0.2533922791,
-0.1587366015,
-0.6165096164,
-0.0606701262,
0.7032824755,
-0.6439657211,
-0.3413940072,
0.6230433583,
0.6434248686,
-0.3340912461,
0.4137955606,
-0.1464010626,
-0.6530821323,
0.5681108832,
0.5858606696,
1.0892593861,
-0.3626574278,
0.2887579799,
0.0367353074,
0.1750670671,
0.0762101859,
0.4563604295,
0.2033622265,
-0.927152276,
-0.6840295792,
-0.8314101696,
-0.3031486273,
0.2253890634,
-0.4818385839,
0.5161947012,
-0.6228352189,
-0.092256479,
0.1594548672,
-0.6341353655,
-0.6470873952,
0.1339304447,
0.4592965543,
0.8612160683,
-0.9296087027,
0.6071169972,
0.8576124907,
-0.3974538147,
-0.8929560781,
-0.0229077283,
0.1630945653,
-0.9844671488,
1.0394953489,
-0.1491607428,
-0.2018263042,
-0.0267409179,
-0.9623413086,
-0.7715891004,
0.9919463396,
0.0883952826,
-0.5692123771,
-0.0615033582,
-0.0618890412,
0.5369291306,
-0.5139055252,
0.0624237955,
0.3738011122,
0.3447617292,
0.3219831884,
-0.6452815533,
-0.0343438834,
-0.334510237,
0.3503121138,
0.1074845716,
-0.6487651467,
0.6084632874,
0.1273989528,
-0.2718643248,
0.0879188031,
1.2099958658,
0.0075080409,
-0.016094869,
0.3431918323,
0.2518504858,
0.5212392211,
-0.0402019396,
1.1739603281,
-0.5282126069,
-0.1031058133,
0.7862302661,
-0.1716043949,
0.8431667089,
0.4329491556,
0.1231992543,
0.8180641532,
0.1774547994,
0.2161012143,
0.2932721078,
0.2076022029,
-0.4417833984,
-0.2554781139,
-0.3005006015,
-0.1658338904,
0.5659166574,
0.3850373328,
-0.6230176091,
0.2644617856,
0.1734594107,
0.3945405781,
0.1352636516,
-0.5115348101,
0.8456706405,
0.1422919333,
-0.5873754025,
0.4008807242,
0.1319272518,
0.7650193572,
-0.6815343499,
-0.1103023738,
-0.1772429645,
-0.0954623148,
-0.1837361455,
-0.9195087552,
-0.1506537944,
0.0277453121,
-0.0649927408,
-0.6938670278,
0.7990657687,
-0.434802711,
-0.6898539662,
0.1694564074,
0.3519060016,
-0.3649685681,
0.0637787879,
-0.4337919652,
0.4846185148,
-0.0875887498,
-0.713275075,
0.2690588832,
0.7492333651,
-0.1580447704,
0.6863969564,
0.4951654971,
0.0988311395,
0.0894740373,
0.341909349,
1.0125644207,
-0.5454769731,
-0.3786691427,
-0.9006456733,
0.5126208663,
-0.0435499959,
-0.154658705,
0.7741649747,
0.0755967423,
0.5993519425,
-0.0437181555,
0.9472548962,
0.0604406968,
0.1039567664,
-0.7979110479,
0.8600956202,
-0.354847163,
0.1548885852,
-0.4936308563,
-0.8415949941,
-0.0773219019,
0.4300828278,
-0.2751982808,
0.3162272274,
0.3034683466,
0.7204291821,
0.1483396292,
-0.02739981,
0.1824343801,
0.4375260472,
0.4800087214,
0.2419254929,
1.0264515877,
0.1270971596,
0.0730406195,
-0.3159734607,
-0.4154054224,
-0.2510128021,
-1.1848316193,
-1.0104503632,
-0.5446112156,
-0.3437909186,
-0.5370556712,
-0.2422149181,
1.0731227398,
0.5964523554,
-0.6907154918,
-0.1688667834,
0.2305774391,
0.0885706097,
-0.0917074084,
-0.2087117136,
0.2800930738,
-0.4884524941,
-0.9193671942,
0.5114251375,
0.4371442497,
0.2216199934,
-0.7167868614,
-0.0647027344,
0.0837283134,
0.3127280474,
1.0785968304,
0.113067843,
-0.4236710668,
-0.3558090329,
-0.0761587024,
-0.3454868793,
0.0126018412,
1.0327049494,
-0.5509954095,
0.2404770702,
0.754922688,
0.7489767075,
0.0868321359,
0.0433231443,
0.8043438792,
-0.9416623712,
0.1719385386,
0.0456604399,
0.2484791428,
0.5020983815,
-0.3596444428,
0.113193579,
-0.0049121124,
-0.3776684701,
-0.4433582425,
0.2879205942,
-0.9443444014,
-0.0968614221,
1.6459639072,
0.1402465999,
-0.3084152937,
0.2241676897,
-0.3941931725,
0.2061685026,
-0.3234221935,
0.431166023,
0.6717003584,
-0.2836710513,
-0.1220513955,
-0.5014263988,
0.8237107992,
0.4070495665,
-0.7093433738,
0.0415940024,
0.4538359642,
-0.0477812923,
0.2721063197,
0.352996707,
0.0050584949,
-0.1125756055,
-0.3480438292,
0.3246519864,
-0.0185682364,
-0.511022985,
-0.4034478068,
0.2207879275,
0.3282311857,
0.1369348168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01613v1
|
Nomic Embed: Training a Reproducible Long Context Text Embedder
| 2024-02-02T18:23:18 | 2024-02-02T18:23:18 |
Zach Nussbaum, John X. Morris, Brandon Duderstadt, Andriy Mulyar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This technical report describes the training of nomic-embed-text-v1, the
first fully reproducible, open-source, open-weights, open-data, 8192 context
length English text embedding model that outperforms both OpenAI Ada-002 and
OpenAI text-embedding-3-small on short and long-context tasks. We release the
training code and model weights under an Apache 2 license. In contrast with
other open-source models, we release a training data loader with 235 million
curated text pairs that allows for the full replication of nomic-embed-text-v1.
You can find code and data to replicate the model at
https://github.com/nomic-ai/contrastors
|
[
-0.2006464154,
-0.5615437031,
0.6605628133,
0.2358333617,
-0.3418783545,
-0.4635796845,
-0.0296299085,
-0.4270379841,
0.3735969663,
0.6627113223,
-0.2740739882,
-0.6129848361,
-0.46908921,
-0.0062492117,
-0.6305339336,
1.1338557005,
-0.4009947777,
0.3712308109,
-0.6346006393,
-0.5981098413,
-0.1493130177,
-0.4784755409,
-0.3578674197,
-0.1782884449,
0.4566451907,
0.6189473271,
0.4571040571,
0.7420883179,
0.6210482121,
0.1229073629,
0.0868300423,
-0.4089899659,
-0.7016749978,
-0.0234060455,
-0.0185141638,
-0.2684879005,
-0.5710839629,
0.1293574423,
0.7669059038,
0.3132142723,
0.0854087099,
0.2361974865,
0.0389748216,
0.3539797664,
-0.6344385147,
-0.1052135453,
-0.2891434431,
0.0724184066,
-0.2592852414,
-0.190655604,
-0.6099323034,
-0.3467516005,
0.2920536399,
-0.7397364378,
0.029991474,
-0.0167354941,
0.6727353334,
0.356505245,
-0.5488337278,
-0.23777695,
-0.5842012167,
1.0488681793,
-0.6938471198,
0.3094224334,
0.3671875298,
0.4399492145,
0.2131825984,
-0.7695350647,
-0.5352833867,
-0.2834693193,
0.0210950039,
-0.1487116218,
0.0431649908,
-0.0928639323,
-0.020719083,
0.4436065555,
-0.6112630367,
0.1120953038,
-0.5163598657,
0.2103109509,
0.4684914947,
0.0421572737,
0.2532011271,
0.1377132833,
-0.8209109902,
0.0363226533,
-0.6850078106,
-0.5002206564,
0.0768771693,
-0.0243547391,
-0.616019547,
0.6228138208,
-0.2198638767,
0.4876888394,
-0.2617171109,
0.004263761,
0.6045100093,
-0.361792922,
-0.5319448709,
0.3449179828,
0.7280321121,
0.3005819917,
0.0412333608,
-0.2361936569,
-0.2824450135,
-0.03050429,
0.3553496003,
-1.1207215786,
0.0013183504,
0.1974256337,
-0.4216011167,
-0.3211770058,
0.1419789195,
-0.6632658839,
-0.2195004523,
-0.1127446815,
0.7026823759,
-0.5873596668,
-0.2191333324,
0.0399395041,
-0.2295067012,
0.4704280496,
0.3505041003,
-0.5499224067,
0.3280036151,
0.5581531525,
1.2165670395,
-0.0057005957,
-0.3335154355,
-0.4117812812,
-0.0631563216,
-0.2202126235,
0.5397463441,
-0.5085487366,
-0.4320698082,
0.0477793105,
0.1607990414,
0.1039863974,
-0.2030484378,
0.6677619815,
-0.425499171,
0.4124757946,
0.2065934092,
-0.8222874999,
-0.0780582428,
0.2032423466,
-0.8888524175,
0.8663451076,
0.3108816743,
-0.8907786012,
0.2700080872,
-0.9933642745,
-0.1454360485,
-0.0706595108,
-0.1161662191,
-0.5963045955,
0.0419815443,
-0.0707118437,
0.2818931937,
-0.1851343811,
-0.1565126926,
-0.4238855243,
-0.532523632,
-0.019618541,
-0.2743248343,
0.8572190404,
0.125242725,
-0.25612095,
0.2915863097,
-0.7462137938,
-0.2017072737,
0.4916976392,
-0.2197817862,
-0.4639277458,
-0.1026642695,
0.2493747324,
0.0938658193,
0.4786545634,
-1.1389921904,
0.1625729501,
-0.1702060997,
0.5024837255,
0.5832861066,
-0.135806635,
0.5399935246,
-0.5725567341,
0.4049771726,
0.0677984804,
0.2109300792,
-0.4949090779,
-0.4712933898,
-0.5472191572,
-0.4120568931,
0.3963139057,
0.424718827,
-0.733709693,
0.1603095084,
-0.5614989996,
-0.6606890559,
-0.8753194809,
0.197420314,
0.6245197654,
0.4721213877,
0.5045300722,
-0.1069765314,
-0.4071982503,
-0.9650804996,
0.0529589318,
0.4002584815,
-0.1417319477,
0.2025174946,
0.8502314091,
-0.3150071502,
0.8432806134,
-0.3810555339,
-0.5358243585,
-0.1470789164,
0.1524093598,
-0.1066262051,
0.6139038801,
0.9101641178,
-0.4480891228,
-0.6135007143,
0.0550200902,
-0.9671363235,
0.2521240711,
0.2443069071,
-0.0961896926,
0.4406983554,
0.5377149582,
-0.1244702265,
0.5568870306,
0.9669911861,
-0.2610102892,
0.0609792285,
-0.4463686347,
0.0711995661,
-1.2814940214,
0.2925429046,
0.1080597565,
-0.4295536876,
-0.5768893957,
0.2144376487,
0.1988091767,
-0.1649941057,
-0.710857451,
0.6733601689,
-0.3197785318,
0.0996315554,
-0.1920066029,
0.368155539,
-0.1414870769,
0.4179464579,
-0.0293859802,
0.8505451679,
0.5377938151,
-0.5448046923,
0.0358364806,
0.399184674,
-0.5897528529,
0.5400944948,
-1.0209918022,
0.3700681031,
-0.3469297588,
0.1677200347,
-1.0014151335,
-0.260363549,
0.2483528107,
-0.4883311689,
0.0813042298,
-0.0846846774,
-0.4803460836,
-0.1259067357,
-0.6275789142,
0.7130518556,
0.5320225954,
-0.7349935174,
0.0299324412,
0.3597627282,
0.0473692566,
-0.3592856228,
-1.0141911507,
-0.2944176495,
0.2247048318,
-0.4125857949,
0.4069958031,
-0.1516654938,
0.0480379015,
0.2920226753,
-0.0864353254,
-0.3404534757,
0.1481423229,
0.4768691957,
0.1384591609,
-0.4565394819,
0.0767691955,
0.1105685532,
-0.2563787997,
-0.1293586791,
-0.1723039746,
0.4031626284,
0.0269014351,
-0.4382162392,
-0.7141959071,
0.3981548846,
0.6269967556,
-0.244143337,
1.0951994658,
0.3174374402,
-0.4312730432,
-0.0346635133,
-0.1746971905,
0.2178216279,
-0.438759923,
0.2568842173,
-0.1139998138,
-1.0325806141,
0.0178366564,
0.0436151251,
0.249956429,
0.467299521,
0.1412582248,
0.0539633632,
1.104680419,
0.7711517215,
-0.0556907766,
0.7221493125,
-0.208072409,
-0.0959311798,
-0.7185478806,
-0.3435432911,
-0.4936435223,
-0.3855805397,
-0.3515768349,
-0.4402342141,
0.2464048117,
0.1289933026,
-0.4457374513,
0.1823775023,
-0.5407488346,
0.6372187138,
0.6374431849,
0.3079601526,
0.0950200111,
0.0651113912,
0.1882261336,
0.1712825596,
-0.2651118338,
-0.6981083155,
1.4865795374,
0.4190930128,
0.6921879053,
0.130216375,
0.8516054153,
0.3879875243,
0.3655782342,
-0.6668789387,
0.2464299053,
-0.25931108,
-0.5502297878,
-0.3921558857,
-0.2133510411,
-0.9953311682,
-0.2670093477,
-0.1376372874,
-0.3855276704,
-0.1596312672,
0.0324741527,
0.0259592161,
0.5054070354,
-0.5039594769,
1.080933094,
-0.0491229817,
-0.0044590207,
-0.2020532638,
-0.6063007116,
0.1942864805,
-0.0744899735,
-0.0191347934,
0.1348484308,
-0.2808733284,
0.924816668,
-0.3543276489,
0.6819359064,
-0.3848834932,
0.0565034673,
0.1971747875,
-0.0258753747,
0.2242891788,
-0.0592411309,
-0.1297623366,
0.3799065351,
0.0627720132,
-0.7952672243,
-0.3284748197,
0.9058685899,
-1.1006741524,
-0.3088771105,
-0.3134552836,
0.1620234102,
0.2970339656,
0.3798086345,
0.2754949331,
0.5134225488,
-0.6319654584,
0.7362447381,
0.885772109,
-0.1888736784,
0.4454470873,
0.3491140604,
-0.2246259451,
-0.7421541214,
0.8704004884,
-0.0170508381,
0.3102024794,
0.5430933237,
-0.045521006,
0.1273558587,
-0.4465083778,
-0.441390872,
0.1375075877,
-0.5165930986,
-0.2002366781,
-0.7700592279,
-0.4077298939,
-0.2586577237,
-0.3400484622,
-0.4524127841,
-0.381983012,
-0.444342643,
-0.3136431873,
0.5209254026,
1.3907245398,
0.2625394464,
0.7010120153,
-0.6555646062,
0.2614764273,
0.0190462954,
0.7724975348,
-0.1100877374,
-0.3894637525,
-0.5971583724,
0.1451906264,
-0.3556621075,
-0.8088226914,
0.3310356438,
0.061697688,
0.5366291404,
0.4726780057,
-0.1620474905,
0.169724986,
-0.4349431396,
1.1209583282,
0.3032471538,
-1.0108339787,
0.6798701882,
-0.1795953512,
0.3764691949,
0.6036230922,
0.7750322223,
-0.1932802796,
-0.0992203802,
-0.2867447734,
-0.8190075159,
0.8791100979,
0.1214128882,
0.2171966583,
-0.1395973414,
0.2978911996,
0.4386605024,
0.16880624,
-0.600679338,
-0.3824422061,
-0.637116313,
-0.3364192247,
-0.2601445615,
-0.5634657741,
-0.0493149906,
-0.2057191581,
0.6005815268,
-0.0470446758,
0.5849199295,
0.5198326111,
-0.4637686908,
0.0343260281,
0.2185571194,
0.8041434288,
0.4240548909,
-0.4779179096,
-0.1342888325,
0.0337269716,
-0.5322542787,
0.0086538326,
-0.0567189232,
-0.0761280507,
0.0749343336,
0.2445257604,
0.9708243608,
0.4533534646,
-0.6613371372,
0.9579584599,
-0.2147124857,
-0.5323916674,
-0.5869187713,
-0.2009946853,
-0.2185223252,
0.0101226438,
0.0993764549,
-0.1859934032,
0.0740493387,
-0.3763499856,
0.3486231863,
0.2006158233,
-0.7625756264,
-0.315043509,
0.9135901332,
0.2588204145,
-0.3045379519,
0.6758599877,
-0.2178219408,
-0.1712295413,
0.5654392838,
0.6234263182,
1.0674318075,
-0.2330686003,
0.1741922349,
0.3130877912,
0.1220481023,
-0.1189240143,
0.4281068444,
0.0038577577,
-0.2469155788,
-0.0950710475,
-0.4421086609,
-0.5369955301,
-0.0489227399,
-0.8640959263,
0.4954386353,
-0.7799938917,
0.0612025745,
-0.0553688742,
-0.1066816002,
-0.7744261026,
0.1161492169,
0.2051643729,
1.3640495539,
-0.5499557257,
1.1667560339,
0.7876644731,
-0.5808231235,
-0.0758693442,
-0.0589571893,
-0.2032722235,
-0.7500417829,
0.3068445921,
0.5010695457,
0.0191264637,
0.0077539105,
-0.9232870936,
-0.8598155379,
1.5673037767,
0.3865608275,
-0.4051413536,
-0.0083763916,
-0.0068507884,
0.4976605177,
-0.5574842095,
0.4093705118,
0.2207345515,
0.1391038001,
-0.1163693517,
-1.007273674,
-0.0374444686,
-0.3800754249,
-0.1825580597,
0.3486030996,
-0.7503288388,
0.8967478275,
-0.0760422423,
-0.2687464058,
0.6408665776,
0.6339334249,
-0.1228264719,
0.4894420207,
0.1814491451,
0.7899149656,
0.572470963,
0.1313654035,
1.3335615396,
-0.6141569614,
0.365239799,
1.3556652069,
-0.1927708983,
1.248930335,
0.3525820971,
0.2874297798,
0.8544713259,
0.2809245288,
-0.0247950722,
0.69702214,
-0.074559778,
-0.1571000963,
0.1035426557,
-0.2252323776,
-0.562209785,
0.2347893864,
0.097761333,
-0.7595443726,
-0.1877350509,
0.0851622671,
0.1748296469,
-0.1111137569,
-0.2833188772,
0.9080294967,
0.0319386199,
-0.2460240275,
0.5266504288,
0.016401343,
0.7355262041,
-0.7165383101,
-0.1137882248,
-0.1020841599,
0.2315288782,
-0.0909013301,
-0.8528226018,
0.4164178967,
0.0339526273,
-0.2037099153,
-0.1917544454,
0.3254021108,
-0.2673045695,
-0.1487132758,
0.5980795026,
0.2472893894,
0.0761676505,
-0.0062516928,
-0.2861730158,
-0.0806188881,
-0.2763812244,
-0.2978098691,
0.5487166643,
0.363076359,
0.2089073956,
0.5571138859,
0.3542914987,
-0.3986912966,
-0.0439885408,
-0.1906967163,
0.8564953208,
-0.9163178205,
-0.4399047494,
-0.7693160772,
0.5487138629,
-0.1204365939,
-0.4748949707,
0.7664173841,
0.779638648,
0.9991372228,
-0.1314582229,
0.830862999,
0.1008422673,
0.2765518129,
-0.2623820901,
0.725255847,
-0.9454865456,
-0.2339138389,
0.0423767008,
-0.6207347512,
-0.2026499808,
0.2537486255,
-0.1136320755,
-0.1973280609,
0.7151553631,
0.4274345338,
-0.1545634121,
0.2808673084,
0.3314375579,
0.2784688473,
0.14291206,
0.6132908463,
0.3161936104,
-0.6414798498,
0.6910049319,
-0.2623954415,
-0.4810152352,
-0.3415868282,
-0.8484635353,
-1.0635840893,
-0.4732885957,
-0.2309917808,
-0.2874093652,
0.0039453926,
0.9825293422,
0.6979141235,
-0.9596666694,
-0.0578603484,
-0.0323922969,
0.0409842879,
0.0503303632,
-0.227233544,
0.1526796073,
-0.1699674875,
-0.7136338949,
0.4020929039,
0.3266827762,
0.3399085701,
-0.3897743225,
-0.2418541312,
-0.1384708285,
0.3819518685,
0.556311965,
0.2354856282,
-0.3534753025,
-0.2681439817,
-0.1499107927,
-0.4128482342,
0.3538541198,
0.612860024,
-0.753924787,
0.4638518393,
0.6217417121,
0.6507050395,
0.3864064217,
-0.3713369966,
0.5601892471,
-0.7877423763,
0.284556061,
-0.0185631625,
0.4656393826,
0.1305089146,
-0.1468230188,
0.5897549391,
-0.0084910728,
-0.7183097601,
-0.8969953656,
0.0092773726,
-1.160074234,
-0.2567295134,
0.9459321499,
-0.3938554525,
-0.4723012149,
0.2531245649,
-0.2824229002,
0.3022401631,
-0.4580470324,
0.4047569335,
0.3033163846,
0.2502352297,
0.0513781905,
-0.6416663527,
0.3288897872,
0.0761841536,
-0.7162122726,
-0.3904792666,
0.1904980093,
0.427360028,
0.207597971,
0.4862935245,
-0.2537664771,
0.2051515579,
0.3829922974,
0.1161231175,
-0.2525179088,
-0.4802880883,
-0.6484968662,
0.2790694535,
0.0526893921,
-0.594284296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01828v1
|
Retrieval Augmented End-to-End Spoken Dialog Models
| 2024-02-02T18:23:09 | 2024-02-02T18:23:09 |
Mingqiu Wang, Izhak Shafran, Hagen Soltau, Wei Han, Yuan Cao, Dian Yu, Laurent El Shafey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We recently developed SLM, a joint speech and language model, which fuses a
pretrained foundational speech model and a large language model (LLM), while
preserving the in-context learning capability intrinsic to the pretrained LLM.
In this paper, we apply SLM to speech dialog applications where the dialog
states are inferred directly from the audio signal.
Task-oriented dialogs often contain domain-specific entities, i.e.,
restaurants, hotels, train stations, and city names, which are difficult to
recognize, however, critical for the downstream applications. Inspired by the
RAG (retrieval-augmented generation) paradigm, we propose a retrieval augmented
SLM (ReSLM) that overcomes this weakness. We first train a speech retriever to
retrieve text entities mentioned in the audio. The retrieved entities are then
added as text inputs to the underlying SLM to bias model predictions. We
evaluated ReSLM on speech MultiWoz task (DSTC-11 challenge), and found that
this retrieval augmentation boosts model performance, achieving joint goal
accuracy (38.6% vs 32.7%), slot error rate (20.6% vs 24.8%) and ASR word error
rate (5.5% vs 6.7%). While demonstrated on dialog state tracking, our approach
is broadly applicable to other speech tasks requiring contextual information or
domain-specific entities, such as contextual ASR with biasing capability.
|
[
-0.2188496441,
-0.8020783067,
0.5617120266,
-0.287935555,
-0.2055051476,
0.3809207082,
-0.3295046091,
-0.4643838704,
0.2509037256,
0.9009516835,
-0.4527828693,
-0.2946469188,
-0.3616220653,
0.0710839257,
-0.400191009,
0.9173138142,
0.1522780359,
0.1783901602,
-0.4598107636,
-0.163062945,
-0.6288956404,
-0.8251109719,
-0.6899462342,
-0.4890003502,
0.2039436996,
-0.0327000283,
0.3832498193,
0.2192291319,
0.0863002166,
0.2939046621,
-0.3925781548,
0.5229213238,
-0.4952237606,
0.3831294477,
-0.1771600395,
-0.3669678569,
-0.4021991193,
-0.0414651707,
0.6315102577,
0.6855415702,
-0.2837685049,
0.2095319331,
-0.0621394925,
0.556804657,
-0.5066688657,
0.1154263169,
-0.8790841699,
-0.1448420733,
-0.0129198981,
-0.5424053073,
-0.605499208,
-0.1047283113,
0.4326545894,
-0.560526371,
0.0688040853,
0.2974399626,
0.769941628,
0.3597809374,
-0.5196976066,
-0.5604928136,
-0.6999770403,
0.8793483377,
-0.7744187713,
0.7625143528,
0.5579312444,
0.2171288133,
-0.1732660681,
-0.7148281336,
-0.4417889714,
-0.4556716383,
-0.0610844269,
0.1225982234,
-0.1074638143,
0.2910154462,
0.3983708918,
0.3009786606,
-0.3828139305,
-0.3524784148,
-0.1991401613,
-0.3194874227,
0.3270498514,
0.1521950364,
0.3765105307,
-0.0930949226,
-0.4841255546,
0.2789132595,
-0.6188489199,
0.004705973,
0.0742948428,
0.6720682383,
0.1348864436,
0.4507613182,
-0.0880604461,
1.0192278624,
0.2015156597,
-0.3404368162,
0.3914954364,
-0.4132328033,
-0.2065101415,
0.3185996711,
0.2271144092,
0.0505350754,
-0.0793024674,
-0.3131920993,
-0.4907469153,
-0.206196472,
0.3126958609,
-0.4175972342,
0.1398752928,
-0.0494729169,
-0.1769917309,
0.1235995814,
-0.4601193368,
-0.3647070527,
-0.2565456927,
-0.693710506,
0.5778858662,
-0.3485943079,
-0.2112230808,
-0.1845098734,
-0.024901703,
0.2240407765,
0.4327375293,
-0.5860379338,
0.2959004045,
0.6754271984,
0.727563858,
-0.1151431501,
0.1265858859,
-0.9161015153,
0.3473207951,
-0.2751835883,
0.6328782439,
-0.8164162636,
-0.57161057,
-0.0641148537,
-0.0065786215,
-0.1795341969,
-0.6536732316,
0.6103343368,
-0.7013110518,
0.2467418164,
-0.2036725879,
-0.6928263307,
-0.2869435251,
0.170265913,
-0.496445328,
1.0750035048,
0.0965097994,
-0.4817595482,
0.1296558082,
-0.3789750934,
-0.4428318143,
0.1544639766,
-0.2992985845,
-0.2241615951,
0.3136338294,
0.2106082141,
0.0162155814,
-0.4280897975,
0.3877585828,
0.0638575703,
-0.4656477869,
0.0819926187,
-0.4741477966,
0.5472664237,
0.1724074632,
-0.000628069,
0.1294992268,
-0.6120384336,
0.003667614,
-0.1835049689,
-0.4437218904,
-0.5444392562,
-0.0512456819,
0.0394065939,
0.1249371022,
0.350487411,
-0.6562020779,
-0.1462814659,
-0.377076894,
0.3131628335,
0.5876444578,
-0.0651828051,
0.526435256,
-0.2035905123,
0.4664219022,
-0.0296989679,
-0.3723731637,
-0.4143874049,
-0.3048450351,
-0.6508267522,
-0.2613847852,
0.3248878121,
0.6442144513,
-1.0297813416,
0.3177357912,
-0.1849631965,
-0.1158890352,
-0.7055770159,
-0.1267937869,
0.5832127929,
1.0025981665,
0.2562337816,
-0.1437271237,
-0.7517594099,
-0.6937877536,
-0.3325853944,
-0.1307568401,
-0.037185818,
0.728181839,
0.1060596779,
-0.1645256579,
1.0988916159,
-0.2818699181,
-0.4314870834,
-0.4235785306,
-0.0590098351,
0.2850902677,
0.2957670391,
0.2003331035,
-0.8891803622,
-0.5693314075,
-0.0695036724,
-0.5153006911,
-0.1896924824,
-0.0052815131,
0.0412274376,
0.3068428338,
0.313138932,
-0.6109089851,
0.4097075462,
0.334867537,
-0.2619800866,
0.5376773477,
-0.206450358,
0.2025067061,
-1.0190848112,
-0.0259585399,
-0.0180645045,
-0.6300963163,
-1.033654809,
-0.194829762,
-0.1929808706,
-0.4887749255,
-0.3990138471,
0.6785843372,
-0.5420212746,
-0.4636818171,
-0.5366107821,
0.3585086763,
0.142764166,
0.6786055565,
0.2650956213,
1.2242097855,
0.4776946902,
-0.5316653252,
0.1804770529,
0.2530899644,
-0.303204596,
0.5329093933,
-0.5747669935,
0.4731400609,
-0.3540545106,
0.4161135256,
-0.9457325935,
0.0992790014,
-0.0706359819,
-0.6125599146,
0.4667247832,
-0.1789087057,
-0.2812865674,
0.0664435327,
0.1703718007,
0.3016934693,
0.475323081,
-0.6585225463,
1.0604339838,
0.6955220103,
-0.1431674808,
-0.4992059767,
-0.372551471,
0.0790298209,
-0.1649036109,
-0.3723847568,
0.3249950409,
-0.0254927613,
-0.0259049833,
-0.1622320563,
-0.3758407235,
-0.046556659,
-0.2660845816,
0.2484209836,
0.3518318236,
0.0685220808,
0.0929023549,
-0.3076654077,
-0.1651382893,
-0.1808630824,
-0.2417954355,
0.6452911496,
-0.1045788676,
-0.2681503892,
-0.4146523476,
0.4043856859,
0.4735153615,
-0.3057350516,
0.4352515638,
0.6367403865,
-0.5493455529,
0.0946076959,
-0.8092103601,
-0.2120744288,
-0.4431686699,
0.4930460453,
-0.532369256,
-1.1013990641,
0.5433488488,
-0.206254378,
0.0637412071,
-0.0080907159,
0.3380666077,
-0.1100550741,
1.0521732569,
0.3804567456,
-0.1181306317,
0.6039808989,
-0.1013252288,
0.3250017762,
-1.3905550241,
-0.2513265908,
-0.3607176244,
0.0495139882,
-0.240032047,
-0.6133252978,
0.6140649915,
0.1983026862,
-0.0294982418,
0.4821527004,
-0.3608202636,
0.1465615779,
0.6381628513,
0.2039365023,
0.4943729639,
0.1737158298,
-0.0574817099,
-0.1615644842,
-0.6019135714,
-0.3393355906,
0.7595664263,
0.3159097135,
0.6337674856,
0.0701828972,
0.6164464951,
0.4716477394,
0.1186659634,
-0.7203134298,
0.6308904886,
-0.2264280617,
-0.5919271111,
-0.3490409553,
-0.5679907203,
-0.6599512696,
0.4120458961,
-0.0655073002,
-0.9186542034,
0.0448928513,
0.2169879526,
-0.3435304463,
0.2027139217,
-0.5588474274,
0.304692328,
-0.1478184611,
-0.2717714608,
-0.2506763637,
-0.4289079607,
0.1001763716,
-0.008631845,
0.1348581612,
-0.3510094881,
0.0340075269,
0.6974807382,
-0.2663314641,
0.6307265759,
-0.3536968827,
-0.0576948002,
0.5704494119,
-0.1141798571,
0.7615637779,
-0.0138859525,
-0.1970546395,
0.0773029178,
-0.1129558086,
-0.0574913621,
-0.7910007238,
0.6768363714,
-0.5373175144,
-0.7708207965,
-0.2510662079,
-0.6847595572,
-0.4516374469,
0.110929735,
-0.031676922,
1.0126385689,
0.1994460821,
0.0888023376,
0.7623049617,
-0.2695072293,
0.2830613852,
0.8007189631,
-0.2712386549,
-0.4655250609,
1.126000762,
0.0682230741,
0.4756020606,
0.3964731097,
-0.054917749,
-0.6670743823,
-0.4826446772,
-0.4914523959,
0.0469482429,
-0.5950010419,
-0.2950533926,
-0.6364831924,
-0.3262752295,
-0.4117944837,
0.0220633578,
-0.4139638841,
-0.3585445881,
-0.3549886346,
0.0499902591,
0.3110548258,
0.4249307513,
0.0877417624,
0.2151887268,
-0.7363373041,
0.4281829596,
0.2142558247,
0.2684943378,
0.0082407705,
-0.9524968266,
-0.2169377208,
0.3560481369,
-0.0203344934,
-0.7741119862,
0.5111837983,
0.2848272622,
0.7026293278,
-0.0582635924,
0.0686030462,
0.9188802242,
-0.7130481601,
0.7581238151,
0.3288504779,
-0.8549795151,
0.568923533,
-0.2473473102,
0.4176621437,
0.5418903232,
0.0162749626,
-0.6695674062,
-0.2035876662,
-0.3583570421,
-0.8429870605,
0.7015615702,
0.0661612079,
0.127649799,
-0.0515310839,
0.3865347505,
-0.187872231,
0.3060056865,
-0.372675091,
-0.2682877779,
0.0959253609,
0.0163856931,
0.1335341334,
-0.3938648999,
-0.0450669043,
-0.1116015762,
0.8504417539,
-0.0849008113,
0.3128271103,
0.4254448712,
-0.2888314724,
-0.07898096,
0.39783898,
0.5664259195,
0.7389062643,
-0.3524814844,
-0.0388491563,
0.4193134606,
-0.2930330634,
0.1383822411,
0.091124095,
-0.2067139,
0.307728678,
0.1280262768,
1.0891245604,
0.3493840694,
-0.9988681674,
0.2500988841,
0.0407397971,
0.1960715204,
-0.5585820079,
-0.1727619767,
-0.1061063334,
0.3371858895,
0.663051188,
-0.0327916555,
0.447874099,
-0.6331353784,
0.4355187714,
0.5855951905,
-0.7030823827,
-0.1848497987,
0.5973575711,
0.3038495183,
-0.54929775,
0.5544250011,
-0.2431553453,
-0.6784878373,
0.3228131831,
0.875431478,
0.8289885521,
-0.197486341,
-0.1049823016,
0.2409193367,
-0.0905637741,
0.0867208168,
0.2745636404,
-0.2514298856,
-0.6783438325,
-0.6095935106,
-0.7256695628,
-0.3641471565,
0.1074512377,
-0.7730221152,
0.1030452102,
-0.0181249548,
-0.5014634728,
-0.3014728427,
0.0503734984,
-0.4554298818,
0.1504379362,
0.3778437674,
0.7741043568,
-0.3694628179,
0.8258709311,
0.7118445635,
-0.1344394535,
-0.6517268419,
-0.2305273265,
0.032995645,
-0.810472846,
0.5892731547,
0.0616160743,
-0.3116697073,
0.082256645,
-0.1914907694,
-1.1399320364,
1.0681951046,
0.2580732405,
-0.7920501232,
-0.4249006808,
0.0262148231,
0.4601664841,
-0.5523527265,
0.4021359682,
0.6166700125,
0.0139477663,
0.3667054772,
-1.3135676384,
-0.1355641633,
-0.0364459082,
0.281940937,
0.302018553,
-0.4926817417,
0.5245040655,
-0.2263369709,
-0.3294683397,
-0.010411351,
0.8498438001,
0.6414160132,
0.5194174647,
0.7112276554,
0.5857040882,
0.6089010835,
-0.0472201109,
0.7537189126,
-0.4542963505,
0.3052902818,
1.599173069,
-0.4301732183,
0.8264083266,
0.4783188105,
-0.0027872147,
0.1296600252,
0.3970064819,
0.4764959812,
0.8377812505,
0.0855728984,
-0.6167223454,
-0.1928691268,
-0.7508940101,
-0.2958473265,
0.4700477123,
0.6630969048,
-0.1718412042,
-0.1939593703,
0.2478997707,
-0.1182988435,
0.1196468249,
-0.4738496244,
0.9418537021,
0.2353460491,
-0.5918604136,
0.5214657187,
-0.3332770765,
0.5862353444,
-0.4845605195,
-0.3364117146,
0.1063340828,
-0.0727549642,
-0.0722576305,
-0.4627729952,
0.282856971,
-0.0181840025,
-0.2470759898,
-0.3181620836,
0.9806017876,
-0.8963399529,
-0.2410809994,
0.2688722908,
0.4256944656,
0.197296381,
0.018943321,
-0.5877322555,
0.242620334,
0.2285449356,
-0.1407750547,
0.2710224092,
0.0128148366,
0.1212986708,
0.7191668153,
0.6523494124,
0.1324815452,
0.1113956571,
0.3461201191,
0.800557375,
-0.5108703971,
-0.504610002,
-0.4265461266,
0.356821537,
-0.0464468859,
0.0549898781,
0.5872635245,
0.7136404514,
0.7485071421,
0.1888068914,
0.7643637657,
0.0230883881,
1.1287859678,
-0.4712198675,
0.4383814931,
-0.4302278757,
0.4491394162,
-0.0557367876,
-0.8308563828,
0.2840217948,
0.4738747776,
-0.3065997362,
0.03772863,
0.1537716985,
0.7328159809,
0.2507494986,
0.0540519245,
0.6306293607,
-0.0418624021,
0.3715553284,
0.4335757494,
0.7763194442,
-0.3725761771,
0.3371399641,
-0.115349032,
-0.1014584228,
-0.0978606045,
-0.4510364234,
-0.8181441426,
-0.8167591691,
-0.1810306162,
-0.3359349966,
0.3031283021,
1.0724822283,
0.8162292838,
-0.6131942272,
-0.2232665271,
0.2560683191,
-0.0787348747,
0.0660322979,
-0.2596644759,
0.2339580059,
-0.4913855195,
-0.8359268904,
0.8170460463,
0.3021749854,
-0.1261806786,
-0.1048584357,
-0.1335309595,
-0.3589434326,
0.1025101095,
0.7617195845,
0.1772147268,
-1.0357428789,
-0.3474084139,
-0.0394544974,
0.0616136417,
-0.0367612392,
0.9053044319,
-1.024615407,
0.761752069,
0.268944025,
0.8020554781,
0.5887917876,
0.2326436341,
0.7161586285,
-0.9059169292,
0.1418851316,
0.3963079751,
0.3628860712,
0.4338980615,
-0.3732017279,
0.4756097198,
0.0741046518,
-0.576657474,
-0.9774091244,
0.1951507479,
-0.875061512,
0.0782234073,
0.9743663669,
-0.1506377608,
-0.0237797815,
-0.2229395658,
-0.2342953831,
0.420479089,
-0.6660377383,
0.420409292,
0.433503449,
-0.3132678568,
-0.3093737364,
-0.8445910215,
0.5769175887,
0.4186145663,
-0.5634794235,
0.1310601681,
0.4408785403,
0.1601641327,
0.2896665037,
0.8111504912,
-0.0192759745,
0.1573772728,
-0.2378312796,
-0.1878748536,
-0.17424272,
-0.3201725185,
-0.319028616,
-0.1744562685,
-0.1439428031,
-0.233309105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01826v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01826v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Analyzing Blood Pressure Variations Across Biological Sex from Scientific Literature
| 2024-02-02T18:15:51 | 2024-02-02T18:15:51 |
Yuting Guo, Seyedeh Somayyeh Mousavi, Reza Sameni, Abeed Sarker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Hypertension, defined as blood pressure (BP) that is above normal, holds
paramount significance in the realm of public health, as it serves as a
critical precursor to various cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) and significantly
contributes to elevated mortality rates worldwide. However, many existing BP
measurement technologies and standards might be biased because they do not
consider clinical outcomes, comorbidities, or demographic factors, making them
inconclusive for diagnostic purposes. There is limited data-driven research
focused on studying the variance in BP measurements across these variables. In
this work, we employed GPT-35-turbo, a large language model (LLM), to
automatically extract the mean and standard deviation values of BP for both
males and females from a dataset comprising 25 million abstracts sourced from
PubMed. 993 article abstracts met our predefined inclusion criteria (i.e.,
presence of references to blood pressure, units of blood pressure such as mmHg,
and mention of biological sex). Based on the automatically-extracted
information from these articles, we conducted an analysis of the variations of
BP values across biological sex. Our results showed the viability of utilizing
LLMs to study the BP variations across different demographic factors.
|
[
-0.3507989645,
-0.7107357383,
0.5867957473,
0.3624700308,
-0.4296461344,
-0.2849479318,
-0.0558520742,
-0.669623673,
0.2693496644,
0.2986365557,
-0.3479722142,
-0.5935101509,
-0.8098566532,
0.5816583633,
0.0708846599,
1.1057345867,
-0.2272612303,
0.3746407926,
-0.112741366,
0.2147796452,
-0.1358905584,
-0.5457709432,
0.1246789545,
-0.2316010445,
0.7934399843,
-0.0687881932,
0.7505856156,
0.8604844213,
0.8333066702,
0.0662695616,
-0.3814392686,
0.206404388,
-0.4492905438,
0.0366783142,
-0.0338210277,
0.0599052198,
-0.6008496284,
-0.1243059859,
1.0636509657,
0.8954709768,
0.1148446351,
0.5171452761,
0.3497330844,
0.8022587895,
-0.6023943424,
0.4505669773,
-0.0196522921,
-0.08062765,
-0.4842908382,
-0.4684765041,
0.024005862,
-0.3635235131,
0.6548627615,
-0.1263328791,
0.4278947711,
0.0601683892,
0.8461970091,
0.1913436651,
-0.7218859196,
-0.0731214583,
-0.9834712148,
0.5776435137,
-0.7018817067,
0.665538311,
0.2594517469,
-0.1422684044,
-0.3080041409,
-0.0921930522,
-0.2301833481,
-0.1630522907,
-0.2401884794,
-0.3418179452,
-0.3675541878,
-0.1117498726,
0.0741550624,
0.2642892897,
-0.6708243489,
-0.2420832366,
-0.5255374908,
0.0666273534,
0.4310554266,
0.2013765275,
0.4358491898,
-0.3459297121,
-0.3714787662,
-0.0412807837,
-0.6210998893,
0.1003448516,
0.4934774041,
0.8149895668,
-0.3864276111,
0.4021279216,
0.168636471,
0.5879009366,
-0.2959028482,
-0.0508897491,
0.4445743561,
-0.2431727797,
-0.2098498493,
-0.0959291235,
0.8307531476,
0.2634227276,
-0.0053013153,
-0.073483564,
0.0597934909,
-0.1371248215,
0.1161099747,
-1.0856455564,
0.0154964868,
0.084886387,
-0.405274123,
-0.1435822397,
-0.0243402869,
-1.1176646948,
-0.5566917658,
-0.3673471808,
-0.1057215706,
-0.2553109229,
-0.5992226005,
-0.0714150146,
-0.3631015122,
0.1546255797,
0.0334905349,
-1.0528190136,
0.3857580721,
0.6702950001,
0.9367029071,
-0.4874548316,
-0.1122158542,
0.1231885552,
0.0556114651,
-0.3551087379,
0.5628293753,
-0.4403854907,
-0.6811150908,
-0.0324325711,
-0.0312087703,
-0.1100510508,
-0.397931695,
0.6152476668,
-0.0622614734,
-0.1647919863,
-0.3703317344,
-0.5563068986,
0.2841318846,
0.0945904478,
-0.4348679781,
0.9055255651,
-0.1690518856,
-0.9426349401,
0.2703243494,
-0.2551704645,
-0.2909359634,
0.1541058868,
-0.5583460927,
-0.6533156037,
0.129399538,
0.3978212476,
0.4288474619,
-0.7455827594,
0.4842652678,
-0.3965195417,
-0.1681204587,
0.2979241908,
-0.4225873947,
0.3963088989,
-0.2499924898,
-0.0735544786,
0.2281957567,
-0.5303086042,
-0.2128597945,
0.0255210269,
0.089998886,
-0.5281613469,
0.2311175615,
0.2627761364,
0.0018310292,
0.1303433776,
-0.9601377249,
0.1671469063,
-0.2597976029,
0.2547413707,
0.6061397791,
0.3284110725,
-0.1081285551,
-0.4053103626,
0.3525155187,
-0.3571041822,
0.2721639276,
0.4772677422,
-0.614312768,
-0.0619097985,
-0.7476849556,
0.2553665638,
0.351421237,
-0.1237209961,
0.4803898931,
-0.6501108408,
-0.8176677227,
-0.4544179142,
0.076409176,
0.2964235842,
0.3351987898,
0.311005801,
-0.0250706058,
-0.4026471972,
-1.0093537569,
-0.2289684415,
-0.5774483085,
-0.1717362255,
0.4368385375,
0.6266848445,
-0.2345209271,
0.5693871379,
-0.904651463,
-0.2181894183,
-0.1318645328,
0.5256917477,
0.1628293693,
0.6690112352,
0.4026318491,
-0.6377310157,
-0.0499444827,
-0.2473790348,
-0.6225878596,
-0.4589829743,
0.2998224199,
-0.6386657357,
-0.1061671227,
0.298615545,
-0.3268768787,
0.6096760631,
0.7584125996,
-0.3572570086,
0.9742980599,
-0.4199950993,
-0.0049706078,
-0.6683724523,
0.1861735582,
0.4596791267,
0.0968577564,
-0.6304691434,
0.0691511557,
0.1621013582,
-0.1948391348,
-0.1885058582,
0.5037813187,
-0.4174920619,
0.013815999,
-0.5458986759,
-0.6797238588,
-0.3089936376,
0.4644512534,
0.4167959094,
0.3015889525,
0.323307544,
-0.4629286528,
-0.0323028304,
0.1577627063,
-0.0968589634,
0.234291479,
-0.9987025261,
-0.0162240304,
-0.2194688767,
0.4462794363,
-1.0486342907,
-0.3686155379,
-0.0387565605,
-0.5091702342,
-0.0429903641,
-0.5121472478,
-0.5692319274,
-0.2393166572,
-0.3157416284,
0.2587959468,
0.5423470736,
-0.0911284462,
0.5224743485,
0.574541986,
-0.5813757181,
-0.1291657537,
-0.2433888167,
-0.3106075227,
-0.0350396186,
-0.60615623,
0.3174589872,
-0.0751489848,
-0.2273253202,
-0.1689691395,
-0.3345298171,
-0.3044100404,
-0.4039719403,
0.6970029473,
0.9266164303,
0.094522126,
0.5442429185,
-0.0156986564,
0.102018699,
0.3278997242,
0.0443430617,
0.414090097,
-0.2919732034,
-0.1603672504,
-0.3055752516,
0.7220643759,
0.6667359471,
-0.2787839472,
0.8003930449,
0.448797226,
-0.5456618667,
0.1058409959,
-0.1328613162,
-0.2911375165,
-0.3436146677,
0.3402819932,
-0.1007955447,
-0.8126120567,
0.2934778333,
0.0329663008,
0.2711316347,
0.0952322111,
0.6901839375,
-0.2100521326,
1.0304099321,
0.9088860154,
0.0343722366,
0.2273764014,
0.3227049708,
0.0353967287,
-0.7015229464,
0.0297561102,
-0.7203775644,
-0.4289492667,
-1.1049820185,
-0.3381033838,
0.8030229211,
-0.3803960085,
-0.4352505505,
-0.1952316612,
-0.3684560061,
0.3490921557,
0.2486885637,
0.5397374034,
0.2178112119,
0.0023643279,
-0.1270480454,
-0.3864979744,
-0.2049766481,
-0.5113062263,
1.2349351645,
0.5071544051,
0.579603374,
0.3363049328,
0.3813105524,
0.2691792548,
0.5209159851,
-0.436230123,
0.429703027,
-0.2404205948,
-1.0523542166,
-0.38964203,
-0.7682456374,
-1.0448416471,
0.1785069704,
-0.4315796196,
-0.7794437408,
0.3502665162,
0.2203189731,
-0.319489032,
0.3887999952,
-0.3337791562,
0.6340638399,
-0.0344401523,
-0.5435866117,
0.3045703173,
-0.814558208,
0.39710325,
-0.0770369545,
0.1521322876,
-0.7247207761,
-0.1816558242,
0.6480427384,
-0.2424632013,
0.9366671443,
0.1614694595,
-0.1368785053,
-0.3633598387,
0.0573722087,
0.0310446322,
0.0021920733,
-0.0229468886,
0.5729321837,
0.1298868656,
-0.7124727368,
-0.33448264,
0.7167288065,
-1.1638964415,
-0.4471455812,
-0.7561315894,
-0.8822905421,
-0.1605556309,
0.0177750271,
0.1429858804,
0.5397413373,
-0.1356142312,
-0.0141082304,
0.3272123039,
-0.2766591907,
0.162090078,
0.544451654,
-0.0287975762,
-0.365666151,
0.4815019667,
-0.0892768726,
0.4364206493,
0.2971836329,
0.8361520767,
-0.3501592875,
-0.3430896699,
-0.496735096,
0.6491088867,
-0.2481116354,
0.2935714126,
-0.4776331186,
-0.1886500269,
-0.5197067857,
0.099716641,
-0.2367663831,
0.3352963626,
0.0905813426,
-0.1570133567,
0.2961176634,
0.3090491891,
0.2751377523,
0.0074192816,
-1.0457013845,
0.3859119415,
0.3196626008,
0.1956515908,
-0.24005346,
-0.3881994784,
0.2780014575,
-0.3450546861,
-0.0943271145,
-1.2813034058,
0.8360174298,
0.1949632913,
0.26564008,
0.0635289177,
0.1384918243,
0.5699799061,
-0.6005712748,
0.5054483414,
0.0305113811,
-0.8029429913,
0.4443500936,
-0.6593906283,
0.4085765481,
0.2976568043,
0.9691077471,
-0.5382063985,
-0.2954951227,
-0.2950494289,
-1.0440922976,
0.0821382776,
0.6705976129,
-0.0497766249,
0.1722637862,
0.3238170743,
0.3576624691,
0.2895105481,
-0.633277595,
-0.4541365504,
0.39651528,
-0.1696669608,
-0.1281720549,
0.0706712604,
-0.1975253373,
-0.6718537211,
0.5532534122,
0.0003166294,
0.4385078549,
0.5569655895,
0.0865840018,
-0.3028012812,
0.6693173051,
0.4180776477,
0.7658945322,
-0.7082312703,
0.5018604398,
-0.2193037719,
-0.9040589929,
0.2776738405,
0.6480540633,
-0.3631278872,
0.1653552502,
0.3844564259,
0.6268122792,
0.035196282,
-0.7106417418,
0.2117447853,
-0.1289512664,
-0.2324001789,
-0.1165543869,
-0.2960086465,
0.0272740703,
-0.0352763161,
0.4326319396,
0.0073048742,
-0.1347688884,
-0.3808168769,
0.0437143333,
-0.0614884049,
-0.4256078005,
-0.3400592506,
0.4436089396,
0.4837647676,
-0.0590590052,
0.3380311131,
-0.1277592331,
-0.1468512714,
0.5050863028,
0.4008959234,
0.6459087133,
-0.0154757248,
0.0336957835,
0.4836832881,
0.5421742797,
0.1745671034,
0.4976085722,
0.5698729157,
-0.5643535852,
-0.5914188623,
-0.74846524,
-0.5788867474,
0.2772908807,
-0.5358629823,
0.2846517265,
-0.4031624198,
-0.3679613769,
0.6513715982,
-0.1056908369,
-0.410520196,
0.0065238895,
0.5616056919,
0.50857687,
-1.1316306591,
0.6649342775,
0.8240577579,
-0.1011722162,
-0.5931689143,
0.3555095792,
0.3593652248,
-0.2738438845,
0.594301343,
0.1234150082,
-0.0717729628,
-0.3296238482,
-0.6641900539,
-0.6308504939,
0.4659851789,
0.3167155683,
-0.4872086942,
-0.1375533789,
0.640159905,
0.8535735011,
-0.1851473153,
0.3803836107,
0.5064650774,
0.2962206304,
-0.200656414,
-1.0721002817,
0.0995194837,
-0.609757781,
-0.0234750696,
0.7056418657,
-0.4491777122,
1.1522393227,
-0.0051943338,
0.2725379765,
-0.1346936673,
0.5661185384,
0.6388822198,
0.1259397268,
0.643430531,
0.0769166723,
0.4781614244,
-0.0469475202,
1.030637145,
-0.1795081198,
0.2479199171,
0.8637061119,
-0.3574240506,
1.0436061621,
0.5045099854,
-0.3249589205,
0.3993727267,
0.4896151125,
0.1709589809,
0.017644899,
0.4951301217,
-0.4175205231,
-0.4432327449,
-0.2863405645,
-0.5126401186,
0.4025492668,
0.5167269111,
-0.5168824792,
-0.3147605658,
-0.2971568704,
0.1398173422,
-0.1238162816,
-0.1713667065,
0.2590181828,
0.0543222949,
-0.4398497343,
0.7160712481,
-0.053208746,
0.579847157,
-0.8890551329,
0.0064017335,
-0.0581122823,
0.220420897,
-0.0220112093,
-0.5931340456,
0.1562189162,
0.3885374069,
-0.2155064642,
-0.1603313833,
0.8338148594,
-0.4635926187,
-0.7827651501,
0.1704577357,
0.7149233818,
0.2186591178,
-0.1733274013,
-0.3361386955,
0.0119850831,
-0.1843503565,
0.1741993576,
0.3183846474,
0.0500132702,
-0.0893941969,
0.5619544387,
0.8529742956,
0.7672198415,
-0.2263095975,
-0.0220373049,
0.537900269,
-0.5501558781,
-0.6407405734,
-1.1389032602,
-0.0533703677,
-0.2252625376,
-0.8178223968,
0.748539567,
0.2918719351,
0.3871958554,
-0.077140063,
0.6388056278,
0.2939587831,
0.7043467164,
0.057220608,
0.4890753031,
-0.417186588,
0.1669306904,
-0.7090639472,
-0.83616817,
-0.3597698212,
0.1030689254,
-0.5261183977,
-0.3409831226,
0.787761867,
0.4022943079,
-0.0119809108,
0.2283187807,
-0.0837967247,
-0.0828217268,
0.5781670809,
0.515440166,
0.5765503645,
0.0359185413,
0.59159863,
-0.172439456,
-0.3807251155,
-0.1877544522,
-0.9443668127,
-0.7768870592,
-0.1484595388,
-0.4637849033,
-0.0074644815,
0.3311161995,
1.1702091694,
0.8872297406,
-0.4597036242,
-0.4274954796,
0.1024739519,
-0.1416187286,
-0.5371370912,
-0.0970854834,
0.5385474563,
0.2673467696,
-0.6782140136,
-0.2716974318,
0.2130932659,
0.454215765,
-0.4113967419,
0.2642759979,
-0.1134381518,
0.2630276978,
0.0223167073,
0.2715228796,
-0.350312233,
-0.0602655932,
0.0448919609,
-0.328897655,
0.0501786247,
0.8423925638,
-0.2121119648,
0.1801423877,
0.9467412233,
0.4888220727,
0.1198127121,
-0.0485755019,
0.9413658381,
-1.0922226906,
0.1016134769,
0.251421392,
0.3430313468,
0.4946182966,
-0.3221162856,
0.2940608859,
0.4423670471,
-0.7017364502,
-0.7716507316,
0.0702672526,
-0.8808103204,
-0.3534924388,
1.3524774313,
-0.0149653833,
-0.2958860397,
-0.1928995252,
-0.1454055607,
0.2863808572,
-0.699682653,
0.8906258345,
0.9465503097,
-0.3831408918,
0.2658999562,
-1.1241254807,
0.5598035455,
0.4294857085,
-1.0328345299,
0.3139136434,
0.2578615844,
0.2309077233,
-0.0113180783,
0.1889682263,
-0.2950432599,
0.1046593487,
-0.2729412913,
0.0595051944,
0.2052507997,
-0.0420017689,
-0.1211590767,
0.0853172839,
-0.4304562211,
-0.1474466473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01592v1
|
Towards Sustainable Workplace Mental Health: A Novel Approach to Early Intervention and Support
| 2024-02-02T17:35:49 | 2024-02-02T17:35:49 |
David W. Vinson, Mihael Arcan, David-Paul Niland, Fionn Delahunty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Employee well-being is a critical concern in the contemporary workplace, as
highlighted by the American Psychological Association's 2021 report, indicating
that 71% of employees experience stress or tension. This stress contributes
significantly to workplace attrition and absenteeism, with 61% of attrition and
16% of sick days attributed to poor mental health. A major challenge for
employers is that employees often remain unaware of their mental health issues
until they reach a crisis point, resulting in limited utilization of corporate
well-being benefits. This research addresses this challenge by presenting a
groundbreaking stress detection algorithm that provides real-time support
preemptively. Leveraging automated chatbot technology, the algorithm
objectively measures mental health levels by analyzing chat conversations,
offering personalized treatment suggestions in real-time based on linguistic
biomarkers. The study explores the feasibility of integrating these innovations
into practical learning applications within real-world contexts and introduces
a chatbot-style system integrated into the broader employee experience
platform. This platform, encompassing various features, aims to enhance overall
employee well-being, detect stress in real time, and proactively engage with
individuals to improve support effectiveness, demonstrating a 22% increase when
assistance is provided early. Overall, the study emphasizes the importance of
fostering a supportive workplace environment for employees' mental health.
|
[
-0.4031096995,
-0.9964720607,
0.6098101735,
0.3126981556,
-0.2763344347,
0.2652370036,
0.1613274068,
-1.0235799551,
0.4519363642,
0.0083562331,
-1.2584011555,
-0.1931167543,
-0.5702364445,
0.1430331767,
0.0158759244,
0.8774983883,
0.3160406351,
-0.0562936738,
0.0172146987,
0.186305508,
-0.5806673169,
-0.3448980451,
-0.7981781363,
-0.3646947742,
0.5872631669,
0.4907397926,
0.7586150765,
0.0112431645,
0.4305087924,
0.1266922504,
-0.1289271116,
0.1138697118,
-0.4688863456,
0.3355137706,
0.0987961963,
-0.3807491064,
-0.420799315,
-0.1259742826,
0.1107605323,
0.2841409743,
-0.5466923118,
0.322555393,
0.2528195679,
0.2861569226,
-0.4219896197,
0.0833729878,
-0.3810950518,
0.4234297276,
-0.3716009855,
0.1069639325,
0.0447546914,
-0.2949946523,
-0.1531818956,
-0.6056998372,
-0.2853981555,
-0.0090743126,
0.6338947415,
0.4390424788,
-0.2360597849,
-0.0051691001,
-0.8206319213,
0.5409265757,
-0.6366445422,
0.2643187344,
0.1239558682,
0.37165308,
-0.3297528028,
-0.3136610389,
-0.5939156413,
0.3426603079,
0.0227983408,
0.3077232838,
-0.3756906986,
0.0124566043,
0.2085210383,
0.2058874965,
-0.5297681689,
0.183146134,
-0.2569240034,
-0.1066352502,
0.4556590021,
0.2877899706,
0.5178815126,
0.2622998655,
-0.0414437465,
0.1081293225,
0.0109739648,
0.2052802145,
-0.3005616367,
0.0846321434,
-0.1001372859,
0.2971774936,
-0.1476231217,
-0.0222667772,
-0.1665700525,
-0.06331902,
0.1712688953,
-0.0972418636,
-0.283343941,
0.1358765513,
0.4405282438,
0.0403785184,
-0.1046118289,
-0.0454150625,
-0.1756918132,
0.560990572,
0.6839953661,
-0.5783006549,
-0.1685979366,
0.3306011558,
-0.5754842162,
-0.3077607751,
-0.2184935659,
-0.70397228,
-0.755792439,
-0.2588656843,
0.1828985214,
-0.4512758255,
-0.6513072252,
-0.0096407719,
0.0727194473,
0.2514285147,
0.5397589803,
-0.2486210018,
0.1648052186,
0.7125996947,
0.998967886,
-0.024904089,
0.3176620305,
-0.5439017415,
0.0518179759,
-0.2390370518,
0.6422906518,
-0.4815683663,
-0.449840039,
-0.0215829257,
-0.0935101211,
0.3137938082,
-0.5769823194,
0.8195563555,
-0.0985964909,
0.1607507765,
-0.0545803383,
-0.2664135993,
0.2998242676,
0.5643002987,
-0.3162737191,
1.240444541,
0.2400276661,
-0.6450493932,
0.42636922,
-1.2178678513,
-0.3330135047,
0.3529243767,
-0.082981132,
-0.6751980782,
0.3644167483,
0.2009451389,
0.3164429963,
0.0847170055,
0.0512033626,
-0.5581473708,
-0.5123410821,
0.0654870197,
-0.1129413471,
0.8111894727,
0.2994823456,
-0.3408762813,
0.3403714001,
-0.4791665971,
0.1219734102,
0.3314835429,
0.1742370725,
-0.4619934261,
0.164509505,
0.1350456923,
0.5239469409,
0.0146725466,
-0.6148924828,
-0.09761516,
-0.0533438548,
-0.073325716,
0.8155730367,
0.2582998574,
-0.3402545452,
-0.1091305763,
0.8169429898,
0.006676883,
0.660838604,
0.0682223141,
-0.6194617152,
0.0998154357,
-0.8918562531,
-0.6842212081,
1.0092841387,
-0.3268336058,
0.7634860873,
-0.0505764559,
-0.7219204307,
-0.4274615943,
0.1082519814,
0.3240718842,
0.6221575737,
0.3871416152,
-0.4564631879,
-0.6368137002,
-0.5852068067,
-0.4023520947,
-0.1398355365,
-0.2486627698,
-0.0248864163,
0.1614143252,
-0.7635806799,
0.8837475777,
-0.6790578365,
-0.3686001003,
-0.0040317853,
0.1584625542,
0.3656683564,
0.4640865624,
0.1618938446,
-0.5983886719,
-0.3301257491,
-0.2334588915,
-0.9323684573,
-0.1492602974,
0.1375195235,
-0.4588585198,
-0.3214989007,
0.2985730171,
-0.4084636569,
0.5313296914,
0.1984462589,
-0.5600887537,
0.6954961419,
-0.1137729585,
-0.164723739,
-0.8917117715,
0.1471784264,
-0.0516980886,
-0.3720566034,
-0.6455298662,
-0.6070860624,
-0.2147452533,
-0.6234804988,
-0.2449149787,
0.336854279,
-0.0384060219,
0.2560763359,
-0.3268888593,
-0.006171755,
-0.2454700917,
0.3194417655,
-0.0445459411,
0.4296313524,
0.4169979692,
-0.4677064121,
0.1488775015,
0.4562062621,
-0.3250366747,
1.194444418,
-0.4937497079,
-0.0379438289,
-0.1320921183,
0.5830532312,
-0.8984393477,
-0.0085773524,
0.3642961383,
-0.4180133045,
-0.2180586308,
0.5087654591,
-0.3591480255,
-0.7338674068,
-0.2167871892,
0.1601986885,
0.457026422,
-0.0989826098,
0.2336461991,
0.7412466407,
-0.4663663208,
-0.2703005672,
-0.6249599457,
0.1837100983,
-0.3659680188,
-0.3778504133,
0.5394611955,
0.1282273233,
-0.2467831075,
-0.052621197,
-0.585332334,
-0.2344084233,
0.4965506792,
0.3363441527,
0.4957958162,
0.2213276029,
0.2199134231,
-0.0862425268,
-0.3150802553,
0.2978831232,
-0.3322967887,
0.282907933,
-0.1994101405,
-0.3556286097,
-0.9399141669,
0.5109431744,
0.5551320314,
-0.2783561051,
0.9217886925,
1.2130883932,
-0.9825978279,
0.2926213443,
-0.5420244336,
-0.5040344596,
-0.4325011969,
0.3290360272,
0.0538868941,
-0.5510414839,
0.5164237618,
-0.3342186213,
0.2817742825,
0.0351505615,
0.4202219546,
-0.5579824448,
1.227260828,
0.8686406612,
-0.1876378655,
1.0056958199,
0.1365841329,
0.5983338356,
-0.4865038097,
-0.380618304,
-0.2188919932,
-0.4558138549,
-0.2462609857,
-0.1525540501,
0.5681679249,
0.0506098568,
-0.3998044133,
0.0567952767,
-0.8506216407,
-0.0440485924,
0.3887372911,
0.4963233471,
-0.0954085141,
-0.4258748889,
-0.3644675314,
-0.2135239393,
-0.386929214,
-0.4663937688,
0.2634644806,
0.4731023312,
0.6036698818,
0.0997779146,
0.8483593464,
0.7599583268,
0.7013049722,
-0.5773984194,
0.2406303287,
0.4636588395,
-0.6610977054,
-0.5442799926,
-0.2624422312,
-0.9264174104,
0.0845363364,
-0.446516037,
-1.0281200409,
0.0674764514,
0.1753307432,
-0.5986098647,
-0.0068694605,
-0.7010551095,
1.1084518433,
-0.5401653051,
-0.6272554398,
-0.5901327729,
-0.5891175866,
0.2149793059,
-0.2231025696,
0.6004992127,
-0.6853732467,
0.1747247726,
0.926678896,
-0.2232630551,
0.9783722758,
-0.6369774342,
-0.2420101017,
0.2080991864,
-0.0973726213,
0.4618044496,
0.3175459504,
-0.0060207583,
-0.2243702859,
0.254414469,
-0.7400684953,
-0.6936178207,
0.1343348175,
-0.6232240796,
-0.3081429601,
-0.1680409759,
-0.239655152,
-0.5939031243,
0.5302780271,
-0.2786106765,
0.0485362522,
-0.1956267953,
0.1090170518,
0.652086854,
-0.3251776397,
0.0906188115,
0.2738728225,
-0.1355505437,
-0.1892602295,
0.4822466671,
-0.0192137193,
-0.3597409129,
0.0347928107,
0.3587683439,
-0.2487471104,
0.1411802471,
0.373051554,
0.154436782,
-0.4153267145,
-0.2176793367,
-0.4652601182,
0.0809305161,
-0.2630325854,
-0.5590317249,
-0.5654320121,
0.1519488394,
-0.0610681176,
-0.3567053378,
0.2344263494,
0.4232076705,
-0.055782482,
0.187631622,
-0.8887675405,
0.2575670183,
0.4349909723,
0.4964398742,
0.2055291533,
0.1785608977,
-0.7575278282,
0.0200912207,
-0.5376952291,
-0.9752721786,
0.4207766652,
0.0991664305,
0.7126175761,
0.6075549126,
0.5247110128,
0.734028101,
-0.1512467265,
0.6740049124,
0.4768751264,
-0.8462854028,
0.7371415496,
-0.186438337,
0.4099779129,
0.7570617795,
0.3841914535,
-0.8622041345,
-0.4058301151,
-0.7114613056,
-0.921321094,
0.4778610766,
0.354562968,
-0.0056323628,
-0.0937136263,
0.0608723462,
-0.0359955616,
0.0223066639,
-0.3735672534,
-0.0250697415,
-0.2487094253,
-0.391820401,
0.15010719,
-0.0479089357,
-0.3181181252,
-0.3189016879,
0.6315700412,
0.0031520603,
0.8867158294,
0.1707261354,
0.0422236435,
-0.0992979333,
0.318788439,
0.3747382462,
0.5789166689,
-0.3768491447,
0.1953693479,
0.4708177447,
-0.5499932766,
-0.0005830509,
0.0168183018,
0.6689421535,
-0.0937675536,
0.0577557459,
0.6332886219,
0.2798456848,
-0.8638318777,
0.2400064468,
0.0610149428,
0.0676515549,
-0.4094418585,
0.2657517493,
0.1298269629,
0.5451413393,
0.6905556917,
-0.2709673345,
-0.0003512013,
-0.5217933059,
0.5167322755,
0.4698774517,
-0.8116063476,
-0.307941705,
0.6077783704,
0.16868563,
-0.6362837553,
0.5672238469,
-0.0119267972,
-0.6503866911,
0.4469772875,
0.6253529191,
0.7351949215,
-0.4040412009,
0.1138315126,
0.0920668617,
0.1267656982,
0.1722523272,
0.5032756329,
-0.1763329506,
-0.5716311932,
-0.0471557304,
-0.1527757198,
-0.6520147324,
-0.152785182,
-0.7435534596,
0.205980882,
-0.5745747089,
-0.6023709774,
-0.2808992267,
0.2134577185,
-0.7177576423,
0.5824588537,
0.674995482,
0.7618096471,
-1.0303766727,
0.6098588109,
0.7093321681,
-0.0783783048,
-0.3487467468,
0.055964902,
0.3681902587,
-0.6905221343,
-0.0001558151,
0.4461652935,
-0.2551006079,
-0.1228344738,
-0.450202018,
-0.4871127903,
1.1987458467,
0.2895091474,
-0.1829653978,
-0.0122340117,
-0.1570540667,
0.7205737233,
-0.1234783232,
0.4484918118,
0.1523253024,
0.552056849,
-0.1794392467,
-0.6712112427,
0.1005692333,
-0.5770500302,
0.0020048008,
-0.1270243675,
-0.4018004537,
0.0556601323,
0.116600588,
-0.2883964777,
-0.7741835117,
0.6508339047,
0.4748339355,
0.4031107426,
0.7439922094,
0.4029492736,
1.4521341324,
0.1990383118,
0.6130999923,
-0.4161060154,
0.2112157941,
0.819594264,
-0.2917907238,
0.6571551561,
0.471152097,
-0.3578754067,
0.6034961939,
0.8416455984,
0.2129627615,
0.3744397163,
0.296303004,
-0.6407728195,
-0.1692397892,
-0.4013314247,
-0.3409951925,
-0.0891292244,
0.6133741736,
0.0572024025,
-0.1949139535,
0.4347390831,
0.2095486671,
-0.1255214661,
-0.1225557923,
0.5740818977,
0.2942428589,
-0.3197309077,
0.4882057309,
-0.2832895219,
0.7665035129,
-0.6882346272,
0.2170682251,
-0.0291818641,
0.3127166629,
-0.4116834104,
-0.6571063399,
0.8067221045,
0.1694818139,
0.0439252667,
-0.5454052091,
0.8881961703,
0.0142872641,
-0.3706239462,
0.4369390309,
0.703070581,
-0.180080235,
-0.3760944009,
-0.7070103288,
-0.0849834383,
-0.5208105445,
-0.2420966625,
0.2648147345,
0.4967762232,
-0.0457379669,
0.6244366765,
0.6037794352,
-0.2472108006,
-0.0355826467,
-0.3967913091,
0.608103931,
-0.5038947463,
-0.7694355249,
-0.7477568388,
0.6999865174,
-0.3462248743,
-0.2521096766,
0.3158640563,
0.2440870553,
0.189724654,
-0.0678579137,
0.7449350953,
-0.2371889055,
0.4044913948,
0.2068518847,
0.6804721951,
-0.7527216077,
-0.3064866066,
-0.7508179545,
-0.5886306167,
-0.4886226654,
0.7001652122,
-0.404124856,
-0.4279418588,
0.4425438643,
0.6160279512,
0.1585325897,
0.1504625976,
0.209184736,
-0.0994996279,
0.8421204686,
0.4130396545,
0.669682622,
0.1360821575,
0.3213661611,
-0.1527368277,
-0.3233539462,
-0.3647349477,
-0.847809732,
-0.2025806308,
-0.4123071432,
-0.5494939685,
-0.3265991211,
0.1638350636,
1.1330639124,
0.7783732414,
-0.7000355721,
0.0454013534,
-0.2598050237,
0.1035750285,
-0.801195085,
-0.2867085934,
-0.0660478175,
-0.252530247,
-0.0012429369,
0.3821364045,
0.191074729,
-0.1836074442,
-0.0822091997,
-0.0885679498,
-0.4240777493,
0.2538240254,
0.583663702,
0.5225163698,
-0.2007004768,
-0.0947730914,
-0.0879369974,
-0.3211005032,
0.0950489193,
0.4313624501,
-0.6569757462,
0.2145349532,
0.3398222625,
1.0315754414,
0.3998202682,
0.0367110074,
0.5289956331,
-0.4666714966,
0.0992537364,
0.5105682015,
0.1007606834,
0.0740998834,
-0.8965672851,
0.6310071349,
0.499379158,
-0.2409710288,
-1.0380321741,
0.020980984,
-0.6385315657,
-0.0337278433,
0.1710071713,
-0.3114274442,
-0.1176941395,
-0.2220104635,
-0.3268097341,
0.7855730653,
-0.3821464777,
1.2091109753,
0.6478413939,
-0.5851573944,
-0.3066261411,
-0.4739877284,
0.1913727075,
0.597591579,
-1.092435956,
-0.1077521741,
0.1200477704,
-0.0225826092,
0.0996734947,
0.9322549105,
0.0491987504,
0.2975326777,
-0.1056553945,
0.2112930417,
0.0149925267,
-0.0681461394,
0.0197366793,
-0.0835009664,
-0.1511031985,
-0.3241084218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01591v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01591v2
|
BAT: Learning to Reason about Spatial Sounds with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-02T17:34:53 | 2024-05-25T17:05:11 |
Zhisheng Zheng, Puyuan Peng, Ziyang Ma, Xie Chen, Eunsol Choi, David Harwath
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Spatial sound reasoning is a fundamental human skill, enabling us to navigate
and interpret our surroundings based on sound. In this paper we present BAT,
which combines the spatial sound perception ability of a binaural acoustic
scene analysis model with the natural language reasoning capabilities of a
large language model (LLM) to replicate this innate ability. To address the
lack of existing datasets of in-the-wild spatial sounds, we synthesized a
binaural audio dataset using AudioSet and SoundSpaces 2.0. Next, we developed
SpatialSoundQA, a spatial sound-based question-answering dataset, offering a
range of QA tasks that train BAT in various aspects of spatial sound perception
and reasoning. The acoustic front end encoder of BAT is a novel spatial audio
encoder named Spatial Audio Spectrogram Transformer, or Spatial-AST, which by
itself achieves strong performance across sound event detection, spatial
localization, and distance estimation. By integrating Spatial-AST with LLaMA-2
7B model, BAT transcends standard Sound Event Localization and Detection (SELD)
tasks, enabling the model to reason about the relationships between the sounds
in its environment. Our experiments demonstrate BAT's superior performance on
both spatial sound perception and reasoning, showcasing the immense potential
of LLMs in navigating and interpreting complex spatial audio environments.
|
[
-0.479257375,
-0.6206514835,
0.7749156356,
0.4167358577,
-0.1387732625,
0.1195330024,
-0.1845585853,
-0.5298277736,
0.1321710348,
0.6899917722,
-0.5895709395,
-0.6809304357,
-0.1741537154,
0.0171222873,
-0.167468667,
0.4629045129,
0.2163055986,
0.0851993486,
0.0942188278,
-0.192818433,
-0.8861172199,
-0.6031926274,
-0.8460154533,
-0.301073879,
0.3170132339,
0.1927299052,
0.5410671234,
0.249033615,
0.3588064909,
0.2691705525,
-0.2338879257,
0.2908076644,
0.0421395712,
0.0711464211,
-0.47959584,
-0.4471970499,
0.1678732932,
-0.4984493852,
0.3266105652,
0.8484965563,
-0.3426634669,
-0.1025385559,
-0.5410909057,
0.5034638047,
-0.1743714958,
0.1395344436,
-0.4965806007,
0.313664794,
0.0618227422,
-0.3291349113,
-0.3955227435,
-0.2439904511,
-0.1148596928,
-0.6851224899,
0.0312222224,
0.3640253246,
0.457288295,
0.5871402621,
-0.6368381977,
-0.3231473267,
-1.0133131742,
0.3917252719,
-0.6066100001,
0.9195261002,
0.5603365898,
0.669464767,
-0.1562671661,
-0.3961599171,
-0.7364407778,
-0.0667770132,
0.1677990109,
0.1086645126,
-0.3591680229,
0.053086862,
0.4574547112,
-0.1324503571,
-0.6506630778,
-0.0570610948,
-0.3795734346,
-0.1168844849,
0.54533571,
0.1094106585,
0.4429755509,
-0.2402443886,
-0.2283541262,
0.0567497946,
-0.5986828208,
0.3129251003,
0.3287589848,
0.3781370521,
-0.0602067187,
0.5962995887,
0.094418183,
0.4232922196,
0.1464971453,
0.1143958494,
0.0719581395,
-0.3186717331,
-0.0502712168,
0.4074829817,
0.5785850286,
0.0679965764,
0.0626971871,
-0.3452858627,
-0.3042533696,
0.0787498653,
0.253636241,
-0.5840346217,
-0.1788074672,
0.3813517392,
-0.2517108321,
0.1405898631,
-0.3463267982,
-0.4812170565,
-0.5782209039,
-0.4924536645,
0.3873969316,
-0.6041095853,
-0.3819232285,
0.6503984928,
-0.2538764775,
0.2667185366,
0.1292665005,
-1.0525250435,
0.3271145523,
0.7725032568,
0.6570574045,
0.279038012,
-0.3361520767,
-0.2760345936,
0.3133810163,
-0.6648247838,
1.087884903,
-0.654515028,
-0.5282817483,
-0.2490575016,
-0.1918149292,
0.0793036073,
-0.7628219128,
0.5256153941,
-0.4529834092,
-0.1538243294,
-0.431779623,
-0.131830439,
-0.3738146126,
0.0445214361,
-0.6813700199,
0.9177319407,
-0.0207532533,
-0.6025787592,
0.7217567563,
-0.7572721839,
-0.7183693051,
0.0406741761,
-0.3726238906,
-0.1470139921,
0.0424720719,
0.6132614017,
0.0611529872,
-0.137499854,
0.5419361591,
-0.3196302652,
-0.6689655781,
0.3259419501,
-0.1588082016,
0.8006905317,
0.2934962213,
-0.3327129781,
0.1585780233,
-0.6080898046,
-0.3745341599,
0.0681746602,
-0.4785520732,
-0.1593995541,
0.2983289957,
-0.0187517572,
0.0528932363,
0.0902952328,
-0.5641773343,
-0.0432996526,
-0.6813639998,
0.6016942859,
0.340918541,
0.2949622571,
0.5459403992,
-0.1693712622,
0.4699557126,
-0.0725498572,
-0.0542478263,
0.055537045,
-0.333666563,
-0.1233242601,
-0.4507994354,
-0.1813730896,
0.5527278781,
-0.5228381753,
0.6371541619,
-0.2056647092,
-0.4147831202,
-0.3373760879,
-0.1482604295,
-0.0938575864,
0.2042008936,
0.2429169118,
0.15046902,
-1.1007784605,
-0.4633053243,
-0.1658978313,
-0.30330953,
-0.1644963324,
0.6381308436,
0.3591929972,
-0.5878373384,
1.1785775423,
-0.2338242084,
-0.1217325181,
-0.4631450474,
0.0269413069,
0.6308287978,
0.2177092582,
0.4989185631,
-0.7261247635,
0.0676811486,
0.1218263805,
-0.769103229,
-0.4596363604,
-0.2367382795,
-0.2965479791,
0.012961085,
0.6388849616,
-1.0227462053,
0.211319074,
0.237823382,
-0.7182850838,
0.7397367358,
-0.0092211682,
0.3649161458,
-0.7948647738,
0.0714075565,
-0.107235387,
-0.0145565113,
-0.4417770207,
0.1266582012,
-0.4364293218,
-0.6431856155,
-0.1637637466,
0.5844305754,
-0.17875202,
-0.5919739008,
-0.2781168222,
0.0881325603,
0.1824037284,
0.5793818831,
0.3533471227,
0.8176733255,
0.5105602145,
-0.3639146388,
0.4438924789,
0.5305708051,
-0.6191834807,
0.124086678,
-0.5827673674,
0.2426631451,
-0.0022879865,
0.4812042117,
-1.1799265146,
0.0153678078,
0.0678656176,
-0.5487214923,
-0.0825131536,
-0.2406595796,
-0.7330112457,
-0.4772634208,
0.3331098557,
0.5982009768,
0.395073235,
-0.8584736586,
0.9161347747,
0.5028264523,
-0.2560816109,
-0.1768863797,
-0.699483037,
-0.0498246588,
-0.3751579225,
-0.5854686499,
-0.240087375,
-0.0670304596,
-0.4386445582,
-0.1154209152,
-0.4642755091,
-0.3087146282,
-0.0464829132,
0.41234532,
0.135743767,
-0.3426862657,
0.1371751726,
-0.0349388272,
-0.0032443698,
0.5723319054,
-0.517219007,
0.4855127037,
-0.0674913302,
-0.5540855527,
-0.0665102974,
0.3584901094,
0.5947865844,
-0.339124769,
0.2525051534,
0.3929533362,
-0.4565578699,
-0.3273006976,
-0.4190613925,
-0.2651461065,
-0.4830563366,
0.5021855235,
-0.5381091833,
-0.9364590645,
0.7059693336,
-0.1678950191,
-0.1682296395,
-0.0257133376,
0.3620502651,
-0.3545578718,
1.0654199123,
0.2033555061,
-0.1335663646,
0.2591843605,
-0.0195199177,
0.7155222893,
-0.68108356,
-0.4078947902,
-0.5122859478,
-0.2341967225,
-0.0241339058,
-0.7755764127,
0.2790904045,
0.0130016617,
-0.7843967676,
0.2300417721,
-0.4127632976,
0.6447215676,
0.3684842885,
0.1366401017,
-0.0607931279,
-0.0196171328,
-0.208644256,
-0.0565930605,
-0.4902256131,
-0.2091506571,
0.601485312,
0.4959041476,
0.5585538745,
0.3620934188,
0.4987355173,
0.1780494153,
-0.5602951646,
-0.938763082,
0.6320509315,
-0.0033226046,
-0.6833167076,
-0.557167232,
-0.4721696377,
-0.8834035397,
0.3652148545,
-0.1199782044,
-0.5973855853,
0.2064411789,
-0.1691482365,
-0.6758064628,
0.3343171179,
-0.5309782624,
0.6028606296,
-0.3706661463,
-0.0773865804,
-0.3537002206,
-0.3273924887,
0.1058515906,
0.0145378215,
0.5347608328,
-0.1512335241,
0.3338589966,
0.6252855062,
-0.1687270552,
0.7521215081,
-0.5359469652,
-0.2119257748,
0.5021505952,
0.4038391709,
0.1874701679,
0.1072254926,
0.0686946511,
0.4563277662,
-0.1712164581,
-0.0147795202,
-0.7786616087,
0.305977881,
-0.8506227732,
-0.577227056,
-0.0152927907,
-0.7128345966,
-0.440798372,
0.1599004418,
0.0481114648,
0.5941939354,
0.1780979633,
0.008811458,
0.7864488363,
-0.5427933931,
0.0065316875,
0.5280541778,
-0.4778386652,
-0.4319984019,
0.6643002033,
-0.1629450172,
-0.4070650041,
0.7159970999,
0.2890774012,
-0.729930222,
-0.6289496422,
-0.1616116613,
0.1986269355,
-0.900711298,
-0.0556128211,
-0.596863389,
-0.1410486549,
-0.3313024044,
-0.5374538898,
-0.1745402068,
-0.0971690714,
0.065490894,
-0.4041356444,
0.2780701816,
0.7985832691,
-0.2288711369,
0.1165848151,
-0.6150797009,
0.5123201609,
0.2709659934,
0.2156932801,
-0.1766862869,
-0.724550426,
-0.2212827802,
-0.0473848954,
0.2636168301,
-0.8188851476,
0.4635228515,
-0.3180129826,
0.5998874903,
0.1592462808,
-0.2171005756,
0.6406727433,
-0.690636456,
0.6227100492,
0.1366212964,
-1.000813365,
0.7426956892,
-0.6731660962,
0.4407025576,
0.2888407111,
-0.0281556584,
-0.5517765284,
-0.3086755574,
-0.239285782,
-1.0421226025,
0.5404809117,
-0.1490576863,
-0.3095597625,
-0.0938651562,
0.1588913202,
0.0370617509,
0.0657664463,
-0.6415001154,
0.2836620808,
-0.4394109547,
-0.1759439409,
-0.0828564912,
-0.0623847581,
-0.1261171103,
-0.4262095392,
0.4018116295,
-0.1075901017,
0.4954279363,
0.1580324471,
-0.0573576316,
-0.0448522829,
0.3022239804,
0.4161256254,
0.4195935726,
-0.2379918098,
0.307587713,
0.4362209737,
-0.1588986069,
0.2096845955,
-0.0695766732,
0.395750761,
-0.0008956411,
0.5560091138,
0.8841747642,
0.7084542513,
-0.9516257644,
0.4337674677,
0.0713927299,
-0.3746359646,
-0.4044848084,
-0.0944987312,
0.4423448443,
0.7174609303,
0.2590097189,
0.2871144414,
0.5239759088,
-0.5104547143,
0.3315035403,
0.0329782665,
-0.1654684097,
-0.2276967168,
0.7893050909,
0.1458416134,
-0.237222895,
0.7080228329,
-0.1308961958,
-0.5562202334,
0.8563816547,
0.760951221,
0.8525722027,
0.1496400386,
-0.0680044368,
0.5666775703,
0.41430071,
0.1943301558,
0.3965717256,
-0.4861557782,
-0.9243227839,
-0.6652016044,
-0.6417147517,
-0.4660632014,
-0.1690620482,
-0.4503142238,
-0.0681179836,
-0.7592170835,
0.0368047766,
-0.0924559683,
-0.0578709096,
-0.4417585135,
0.0872723386,
0.5739447474,
1.07165277,
-0.9452931881,
0.5108177066,
0.8256185055,
-0.3843373954,
-1.0635317564,
0.015887294,
-0.2456359267,
-0.8288628459,
0.9761123061,
0.1426436156,
-0.4828176498,
-0.213359043,
-0.6688990593,
-0.692666173,
0.8789295554,
0.4256898463,
-0.9081255198,
0.0770919323,
0.2305505425,
0.5189415216,
-0.136996761,
0.147414878,
0.7249898314,
0.5154077411,
0.3914749026,
-0.7123353481,
-0.0060465639,
-0.1692442149,
-0.1142507344,
0.1788212657,
-0.4216124415,
0.4146347046,
-0.5727077127,
-0.1511662453,
-0.2747886181,
0.541551888,
0.8837366104,
0.3577993214,
0.6426155567,
0.593421042,
0.8832896352,
-0.1831236184,
0.7610288262,
-0.0150940968,
-0.0764752626,
1.0394408703,
-0.7392155528,
0.9866042733,
0.2938957512,
-0.2069265842,
0.6655983925,
0.6739975214,
-0.0013731098,
0.6757997274,
0.228511855,
-0.4785597622,
-0.5831559896,
0.0462361351,
-0.0563889742,
0.7199206948,
0.4002481103,
0.3107162118,
0.0685767308,
0.204889968,
-0.4010660052,
0.277318716,
-0.391825527,
0.8897268772,
0.0762122497,
-0.3793514669,
0.1866366416,
-0.2375858724,
0.494556129,
-0.6178860664,
-0.1017578766,
-0.1559888124,
0.0000265865,
-0.2730042338,
-0.9867116213,
0.598090291,
-0.1126410589,
-0.4052251577,
-0.0937935114,
0.6061244011,
-0.3792262375,
-0.107420288,
0.494633615,
-0.1170354858,
0.2885277569,
-0.1911676228,
-0.4511657953,
0.1814133972,
0.006623832,
0.1418877244,
-0.0621623136,
0.9829403758,
0.0841729566,
0.7666718364,
0.8314641714,
0.3645219803,
-0.1274669766,
0.5406306386,
0.3828211129,
-1.023784399,
-0.9657372832,
-0.5878779292,
0.1925786436,
0.2702803314,
0.0490158051,
0.4328298569,
0.6937076449,
0.5037925839,
-0.0571868867,
0.9455667138,
0.2110666186,
0.5784238577,
-0.6783596277,
0.6740325093,
-0.2228347361,
0.3822721243,
0.1412782967,
-0.5822897553,
-0.2719148397,
1.0616996288,
-0.5123316646,
0.0217594653,
0.7575237155,
0.7586473823,
0.0980400145,
0.3678017259,
0.5127893686,
0.3047905862,
0.4818288386,
0.6614407301,
1.1360375881,
0.03738923,
0.5369859934,
0.1635723859,
0.1067302376,
-0.007568941,
-0.4392827749,
-0.8303739429,
-0.5702464581,
-0.0815557092,
-0.0429487973,
-0.0577320792,
1.0620683432,
0.6915932298,
-0.7415898442,
-0.3017247319,
-0.2508751452,
0.0380601585,
-0.2515118718,
-0.2580937147,
0.0586647876,
-0.238475576,
-0.3250285685,
1.0812022686,
0.4649665952,
-0.2337184995,
0.0433631986,
-0.27819556,
0.1095691919,
0.2849437296,
0.6225085855,
0.4220451117,
-0.7088255882,
-0.4642422199,
-0.1703301668,
0.0202145297,
0.0147038782,
0.7451500893,
-0.7191897035,
0.4406237006,
0.2952632308,
0.8028743863,
0.404145211,
-0.2937928736,
0.5457180738,
-0.72111094,
0.1136007905,
0.4288746417,
0.6802461743,
0.3746996522,
-0.2971293032,
0.444229275,
0.1277489364,
-0.6916117072,
-0.7117660642,
0.1366929412,
-1.1336861849,
-0.4405235052,
1.4645975828,
0.2347788364,
-0.1230644509,
-0.4036551714,
-0.6580350995,
0.3332411945,
-0.3983762562,
0.6031348109,
0.6203412414,
-0.0610876046,
-0.1104598045,
-0.4269123375,
0.2055030167,
0.3450451493,
-0.7153861523,
0.2450279146,
0.5881258249,
0.3417575955,
0.2105900049,
0.7655649185,
0.0130982706,
0.5894825459,
0.5203254223,
0.394064784,
-0.0739721805,
-0.53537184,
-0.4222351611,
0.1044937074,
0.2022625953,
-0.1590941399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01586v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01586v2
|
TrustAgent: Towards Safe and Trustworthy LLM-based Agents through Agent Constitution
| 2024-02-02T17:26:23 | 2024-02-18T04:11:55 |
Wenyue Hua, Xianjun Yang, Zelong Li, Wei Cheng, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
The emergence of LLM-based agents has garnered considerable attention, yet
their trustworthiness remains an under-explored area. As agents can directly
interact with the physical environment, their reliability and safety is
critical. This paper presents an Agent-Constitution-based agent framework,
TrustAgent, an initial investigation into improving the safety dimension of
trustworthiness in LLM-based agents. This framework consists of threefold
strategies: pre-planning strategy which injects safety knowledge to the model
prior to plan generation, in-planning strategy which bolsters safety during
plan generation, and post-planning strategy which ensures safety by
post-planning inspection. Through experimental analysis, we demonstrate how
these approaches can effectively elevate an LLM agent's safety by identifying
and preventing potential dangers. Furthermore, we explore the intricate
relationships between safety and helpfulness, and between the model's reasoning
ability and its efficacy as a safe agent. This paper underscores the imperative
of integrating safety awareness and trustworthiness into the design and
deployment of LLM-based agents, not only to enhance their performance but also
to ensure their responsible integration into human-centric environments. Data
and code are available at https://github.com/agiresearch/TrustAgent.
|
[
-0.3577964902,
-0.2177201211,
0.6856618524,
-0.1103373691,
-0.1110665277,
0.227757141,
0.3773573041,
-0.8447363377,
-0.0897503123,
0.4344298542,
-0.4057476223,
-0.2644196749,
-0.448600322,
-0.0615657195,
-0.154625535,
0.801974535,
-0.1733016074,
-0.202848658,
-0.349036485,
0.0523553453,
-0.2051030844,
-0.5835745931,
-0.8299496174,
-0.781744957,
0.3669098318,
0.2758087814,
1.0860972404,
0.7756677866,
0.2619733214,
0.3369113803,
0.0399622433,
0.41264382,
-0.3775000274,
0.2321300954,
-0.4015645981,
-0.5246878266,
-0.9079266191,
0.3605290651,
0.1766506284,
-0.1703698784,
-0.2355352193,
-0.276625216,
0.2295695543,
0.2626112103,
-0.5193318725,
0.3448358774,
-0.6806858182,
-0.0775025487,
0.4041281641,
-0.5923752785,
-0.264205426,
-0.3633567691,
0.0043704878,
-0.7066661119,
-0.1766377091,
0.1768998206,
0.7256052494,
0.4882716835,
-0.3618016839,
-0.1974800974,
-0.3794334233,
0.4406262934,
-0.1543560177,
0.1705074012,
0.5066486597,
0.2744624615,
-0.4316833317,
-0.6788524985,
-0.4728325605,
-0.5675364137,
-0.0443130545,
0.0205955189,
0.081904985,
0.1509425193,
-0.0344113372,
-0.2494915873,
-0.3443897069,
0.054962486,
0.4053244591,
-0.7031832337,
0.6143514514,
0.025514178,
0.3319505155,
0.0566460118,
-0.7003489137,
-0.3330534101,
-0.6456600428,
0.2464201748,
0.4472627938,
0.0950890109,
-0.0810927227,
0.4155144095,
-0.2934077084,
0.0160335992,
0.2045988292,
-0.3606008589,
0.0077547804,
-0.4260768592,
-0.0793729797,
0.1969942898,
0.3403998911,
0.3768046796,
0.5069176555,
-0.1691336483,
-0.5057739019,
0.2117324322,
0.49287498,
-0.6904574037,
-0.163766861,
0.27498734,
-0.3411242962,
-0.9778772593,
0.1278934032,
-0.1709206104,
-0.6839085221,
-0.2746596336,
0.5139208436,
-0.6830148101,
-0.3351117969,
0.0743676051,
0.1581645459,
0.5880369544,
0.53419137,
-0.276253581,
0.1636841446,
0.8999430537,
0.5727530718,
0.0104241576,
-0.7089128494,
-0.6053025126,
0.5378447175,
-0.2674742937,
0.8047301173,
-0.1393399388,
-0.6621659398,
0.0199455563,
0.1275277734,
0.0508719794,
-0.069620423,
0.4635008574,
-0.6133714914,
-0.3530392349,
-0.1184713468,
-0.376388222,
-0.1203098372,
0.8780074716,
-0.5793091655,
0.6437684894,
-0.062251538,
-0.3876839876,
0.3962844312,
-0.7652816772,
-0.3666704595,
-0.084156476,
-0.0687398911,
-0.1502962559,
-0.2748651803,
0.0390881859,
0.4823438227,
0.0954097956,
-0.1273488998,
-0.273475498,
-0.1892814934,
0.5775362253,
-0.3093982637,
0.5457338095,
0.1730689704,
-0.1540957391,
0.2894870937,
-0.5828639269,
0.3550343812,
-0.0019335781,
-0.0836836547,
-0.0283978879,
-0.0808488131,
-0.1273947209,
0.3065740168,
0.5953259468,
-0.2822551131,
-0.3469280303,
-0.2073843926,
0.1487817764,
0.8533934951,
0.2178989202,
0.6348291636,
-0.9593741894,
0.410548985,
-0.0229016691,
0.664300859,
0.0676369816,
-0.1291040182,
-0.3995544612,
-0.1142129898,
-0.1807724535,
0.638240993,
-0.5659614205,
0.4282374084,
-0.0509483777,
-0.6594157219,
0.0576793589,
-0.053272903,
0.5007399321,
0.4732499719,
0.0584899858,
-0.2714600861,
-0.1801916659,
-0.4307929277,
-0.119654201,
-0.7048798203,
0.3576468825,
0.0260499325,
0.5097234845,
-0.4871099293,
0.9149076343,
-0.1728552878,
0.0294192322,
-0.2342991233,
-0.4309259057,
-0.462975502,
0.7283121347,
0.5789706111,
-0.7749494314,
-0.3032343686,
0.1705012918,
-0.6810433269,
0.192017287,
0.2219238281,
-0.5616751313,
0.2881632149,
0.3993028402,
-1.0067384243,
0.4617120326,
-0.0036707509,
-0.6236535907,
0.725025773,
-0.3217224777,
0.1076761335,
-1.1875275373,
-0.1283112466,
-0.3724363744,
-0.6049961448,
-0.7084181905,
0.3378622532,
-0.0791611597,
0.0339812972,
-0.7588902116,
0.3979068398,
-0.2407734841,
0.1979572475,
-0.5087536573,
0.0139604984,
0.2167450041,
0.0082002478,
-0.0932220668,
0.8402091861,
0.4563342929,
-0.4590404928,
0.2264991254,
0.3259152174,
0.2742391527,
0.8271471262,
-0.6580609083,
0.4282430708,
0.0073823282,
0.1730967313,
-0.4768149555,
-0.3442938924,
0.4116877019,
-0.3942165673,
0.48992607,
-0.065551497,
-0.5227157474,
0.2150494754,
-0.4457504749,
0.049732089,
0.2599231303,
-0.3624458611,
0.8337054253,
0.4302130938,
0.2547995746,
-0.6983333826,
-0.4131877124,
0.0069217551,
-0.2622044086,
-0.8447965384,
0.0819216594,
-0.2224703133,
-0.5881612301,
-0.0579341985,
-0.3837381303,
-0.1487581879,
0.3587385416,
0.5543762445,
0.2643797994,
0.3984763324,
-0.1329793334,
-0.1945168823,
-0.6085762978,
0.2910639048,
-0.2623452246,
0.2747814357,
-0.5359701514,
-0.2429239452,
-0.459872514,
0.2033526301,
0.6661285162,
-0.2296530902,
0.7931203246,
0.3432186842,
-0.2906551063,
-0.3611968458,
-0.3803226352,
-0.4111095369,
-0.5555438399,
0.0640337989,
-0.4653935134,
-0.7717129588,
0.5124210119,
-0.3323062956,
-0.0280676913,
-0.0403150134,
0.2693287134,
-0.1440401375,
0.5490564704,
0.7056235671,
-0.0193455461,
0.2355175018,
-0.0189553648,
-0.1382858157,
-0.1888311207,
-0.4927374125,
-0.3874370158,
0.1858659089,
-0.5607362986,
-0.5479282141,
0.3032868207,
-0.32065323,
-0.4125712812,
0.2057307363,
-0.2047436535,
0.5121611357,
0.130465731,
0.2413544208,
0.4917058945,
-0.3794216514,
-0.0515427478,
0.4869683981,
-0.3071758151,
-0.951570034,
0.8239388466,
0.4471481442,
0.7816340923,
0.2327201366,
0.9965644479,
0.3701257408,
0.2020422071,
-0.6503858566,
0.7959176898,
0.5963853598,
-0.5834081769,
-0.3998483717,
-0.0297377352,
-0.613255024,
0.2221705914,
-0.4030655026,
-0.5885041356,
0.1357970387,
0.1782539338,
-0.107667625,
-0.0287576355,
-0.5218964219,
0.450776726,
-0.5042670965,
-0.53877002,
-0.3551612198,
-0.7534152269,
0.0707283095,
-0.2639839351,
-0.0380468741,
-0.2661420405,
-0.3961400986,
-0.0398027152,
-0.6480026841,
0.5371698737,
-0.1688667536,
-0.0733053163,
0.4545788467,
0.2361422777,
1.0717779398,
0.2345072478,
-0.2537566423,
0.0391652957,
0.2309980989,
-0.24179627,
-0.61154598,
0.6115204096,
-1.0116684437,
-0.6192404032,
-0.4491571486,
-0.6851944923,
-0.4055791497,
0.40095222,
-0.0960085317,
0.116977267,
-0.4503875375,
0.0897905082,
0.9090638757,
0.1193004996,
0.653296411,
0.5627371669,
0.0163222514,
-0.2373586744,
0.5443761945,
-0.0062239473,
0.2976141572,
0.2262354493,
0.0241823029,
-0.4956440926,
-0.5877656937,
0.1948921233,
-0.0456455499,
-0.6507275701,
-0.1618026644,
-0.2219144851,
-0.4148660004,
-0.2203522623,
-0.3630020022,
-0.4762051404,
-0.1511278898,
-0.1076929644,
-0.478423804,
0.3661056459,
0.5084114075,
-0.2245783508,
0.3434605896,
-0.4162883759,
0.0013120653,
0.2960853279,
0.2495567799,
-0.3224558234,
0.1071102247,
-0.3319529891,
-0.1887458563,
-0.2904900312,
-0.7528214455,
0.1358251274,
-0.1676281095,
0.9042054415,
0.6128978729,
0.3621237576,
0.171276778,
-0.2368147671,
0.3910932839,
-0.066324763,
-0.7401916981,
0.4631168842,
-0.5279607773,
-0.3043358624,
0.8946053982,
0.0942367464,
0.3081029058,
-0.2419585288,
-0.5677237511,
-0.3984174728,
0.3674170077,
0.6029817462,
-0.2502714992,
0.2618050873,
0.5415502191,
0.0230557695,
0.2861817479,
-0.6387227178,
-0.1017732546,
-0.4860986471,
0.1301840991,
-0.1517958343,
-0.3534980416,
-0.5472314954,
0.207874015,
0.756714642,
-0.3179996014,
0.1122557446,
0.3263796568,
-0.2935703099,
0.0348819755,
0.435598135,
0.5110962391,
0.631360054,
-0.2458087057,
0.3853061199,
0.1852318943,
-0.6839317083,
0.5993548632,
0.409412384,
-0.0815208852,
-0.6747978926,
0.1837405711,
0.1154627651,
-0.0146357371,
-0.3418195844,
0.2979447544,
-0.0466750227,
-0.2860061824,
-0.4847000837,
0.5434989333,
-0.1146427989,
0.6368915439,
0.1943708509,
0.0559507534,
-0.067997925,
-0.3642898202,
0.4663647711,
0.4265813529,
-0.3356795907,
-0.2623971403,
0.5594154596,
0.3117003441,
-0.3533680141,
-0.0784707814,
-0.1757166088,
-0.3763976395,
0.6624187231,
0.4221028984,
1.067958951,
-0.3165261745,
0.2859968245,
-0.2855266631,
0.8217114806,
-0.0781622231,
0.5783523917,
0.1001101956,
-1.1244103909,
0.028546514,
-0.2492949218,
-0.5696179271,
-0.245988667,
-0.29972592,
-0.125401631,
-0.6392058134,
-0.3646284044,
-0.7100925446,
0.4626579583,
-0.4675319195,
0.2092607021,
-0.1608232856,
1.1027890444,
-0.4262695312,
0.7735715508,
1.0905020237,
-0.2250840962,
-1.2147988081,
0.3290663362,
0.1554092914,
-0.8104878664,
0.0390271433,
0.214302972,
-0.7703258991,
-0.0702212751,
-0.6123530269,
-0.7234767079,
1.7592920065,
0.4840733707,
-0.146682933,
0.1392079294,
0.3778657019,
0.5337696075,
-0.5068672895,
-0.0639072955,
0.4106297195,
0.7688667774,
0.0625417084,
-0.7110877037,
0.4654808044,
-0.2488599122,
-0.1543070227,
-0.1256919056,
-0.8273002505,
0.3702749312,
-0.2560049295,
0.1033784822,
0.2759584785,
0.5004262328,
0.7142118216,
0.7322816849,
0.7074619532,
0.5132415295,
0.9196882248,
0.1450673789,
0.9538959265,
-0.6546170115,
0.0225860961,
0.9460095763,
-0.4416926503,
0.486307621,
0.4573688507,
0.3178851008,
0.476477176,
0.3179478943,
0.4693374336,
0.5199852586,
-0.2842232883,
-0.5170266032,
-0.5548065305,
-0.272378087,
-0.317743063,
0.6963464022,
-0.0427107699,
-0.1830903441,
-0.1162913069,
-0.2806644142,
0.2982983291,
-0.0597874895,
-0.4044418633,
0.4658674598,
0.1936995238,
-0.2805473804,
-0.2201721966,
-0.3827681541,
0.0895298943,
-0.5862960815,
0.083232373,
0.0081005879,
0.170972541,
-0.1981431991,
-0.7632796168,
0.1641590297,
-0.2554442585,
-0.0777941048,
-0.308062911,
1.2829304934,
0.096546039,
0.1267810166,
0.325514257,
0.8917880058,
-0.0481284708,
0.0508614257,
-0.4926723838,
-0.1608467251,
-0.4969547987,
-0.1284956783,
0.3962200582,
0.5703422427,
-0.0091587612,
0.8980005383,
0.6919841766,
-0.0884202048,
-0.3622619212,
-0.3185018897,
0.796921134,
-0.5072186589,
-0.8709892631,
-0.6877391338,
0.7067484856,
-0.0964599252,
0.2864865959,
0.7366510034,
0.1648968756,
0.4810397327,
0.1106545776,
0.791975975,
0.1582991928,
-0.0532231331,
-0.3300734758,
1.2571023703,
-0.2592209578,
0.3151271939,
-0.1570620835,
-0.665148735,
-0.0647669733,
0.5251870751,
0.0584973581,
0.1706276685,
0.5455198288,
1.1723598242,
0.2862223983,
-0.1321363896,
0.4891168177,
0.0327108726,
0.660338819,
0.4524800181,
1.2140866518,
-0.0660363063,
0.6192092299,
-0.1897849143,
-0.2088690549,
0.0207369309,
-1.1898761988,
-0.9046292305,
-0.1629743874,
-0.0859751105,
-0.619307518,
0.2398124933,
0.9381362796,
0.8266746998,
-0.3883008659,
-0.0137643134,
-0.2572440505,
0.4646838903,
-0.0226857048,
-0.154313907,
-0.0668558776,
-0.0114573138,
-0.2840650678,
0.5340749621,
0.1646682173,
0.4041719735,
-0.2200234681,
-0.67871207,
0.2408808023,
0.3481656909,
0.3944641948,
0.3199330568,
-0.4239670336,
-0.6652556658,
-0.2059684098,
-0.2572595775,
-0.1957135946,
0.4686450064,
-0.4886661768,
0.2439600378,
0.2025421709,
0.3598285615,
-0.0432367846,
0.2195126861,
0.6168658137,
-0.4584433138,
0.2106274962,
0.0424052477,
0.3920654655,
0.0971696675,
-0.8470888734,
0.7532142997,
0.0806811452,
-0.820055902,
-0.6408438087,
0.478902936,
-1.2327994108,
0.1318034232,
1.1224719286,
-0.154854551,
-0.0943008736,
-0.3841216564,
-0.3145304918,
0.3242530525,
-0.543248415,
0.6482425928,
0.4263340533,
-0.4696705639,
-0.2135593593,
0.0139443399,
0.6677603722,
-0.1140989363,
-1.0960382223,
-0.3164100945,
0.4767687321,
0.4808791578,
0.2216309905,
0.5957350731,
-0.0277627576,
0.403498888,
0.2078170925,
-0.0930741504,
-0.7133451104,
-0.6253585815,
-0.1155864447,
0.5176312923,
0.5062206388,
-0.2559575438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01582v1
|
Automating Sound Change Prediction for Phylogenetic Inference: A Tukanoan Case Study
| 2024-02-02T17:20:16 | 2024-02-02T17:20:16 |
Kalvin Chang, Nathaniel R. Robinson, Anna Cai, Ting Chen, Annie Zhang, David R. Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We describe a set of new methods to partially automate linguistic
phylogenetic inference given (1) cognate sets with their respective protoforms
and sound laws, (2) a mapping from phones to their articulatory features and
(3) a typological database of sound changes. We train a neural network on these
sound change data to weight articulatory distances between phones and predict
intermediate sound change steps between historical protoforms and their modern
descendants, replacing a linguistic expert in part of a parsimony-based
phylogenetic inference algorithm. In our best experiments on Tukanoan
languages, this method produces trees with a Generalized Quartet Distance of
0.12 from a tree that used expert annotations, a significant improvement over
other semi-automated baselines. We discuss potential benefits and drawbacks to
our neural approach and parsimony-based tree prediction. We also experiment
with a minimal generalization learner for automatic sound law induction,
finding it comparably effective to sound laws from expert annotation. Our code
is publicly available at https://github.com/cmu-llab/aiscp.
|
[
-0.2818935215,
-0.5731551051,
0.1947309077,
0.0654310137,
-0.3390336633,
0.0425841585,
-0.287327975,
-0.7644661665,
0.6770358682,
0.1030616164,
-0.3264788091,
-0.2971689403,
-0.4108544886,
0.1102720201,
-0.34408167,
0.3511336148,
0.3368495703,
0.1541003138,
0.4473213553,
-0.2391003072,
-0.539580822,
-0.1806554794,
-0.7583504915,
-0.1712584198,
0.3559534252,
0.4962780476,
0.7611029148,
1.2640632391,
0.2425035983,
0.2430065572,
-0.5062704086,
-0.2035166621,
0.0978227779,
0.230751738,
0.0334524401,
-0.6250875592,
-0.2801196277,
-0.1364022046,
0.2473441511,
0.9469634891,
-0.2985647619,
0.2421507239,
-0.1687540263,
0.5902513266,
-0.2565464079,
0.4732076526,
-0.7864885926,
0.3994945884,
-0.5041451454,
-0.4688160717,
-0.182092905,
-0.363273114,
0.3506114185,
-0.7140061855,
0.1474360973,
0.0046491339,
0.5780388713,
0.5541231036,
-0.1355331242,
-0.3721263707,
-0.6896261573,
0.5451855659,
-0.8678694367,
0.4341400564,
0.4989593923,
0.4173983335,
-0.5149771571,
-0.5023568273,
-0.2885621488,
-0.6252843738,
0.1009923518,
-0.0352010876,
-0.1830221713,
0.3266381025,
0.1326589584,
0.7516289353,
-0.1673293114,
0.1576742083,
-0.3240430057,
-0.3094217777,
0.7131339312,
-0.3320241272,
0.4768567085,
-0.2560123801,
0.2890297472,
-0.2248324305,
-0.715354383,
0.1455924809,
0.576674521,
0.3500714004,
-0.0947799012,
0.5451104641,
-0.2367079258,
0.6658870578,
0.4683814645,
-0.1287700534,
0.2712447941,
-0.4030137062,
-0.1282235086,
0.678833127,
0.828615725,
-0.0123125166,
0.3287664056,
-0.0125041148,
-0.1198534891,
-0.0459065028,
-0.287281096,
-0.2869276106,
-0.7307754159,
0.0042790356,
-0.6802437305,
-0.5016229749,
-0.5594733953,
-0.6417540312,
-0.7474361658,
-0.6731324792,
0.3589356542,
-0.5612373948,
-0.499371767,
0.1590301841,
-0.1334736496,
0.1249462217,
0.1614772379,
-1.1757428646,
0.2764155567,
0.3435167074,
0.9274371266,
0.1202387735,
-0.2525356114,
-0.4195924997,
0.0309266113,
-0.4084847271,
0.7155043483,
-0.6400938034,
-0.4667988122,
-0.3983493447,
-0.2168731242,
-0.2261140347,
-0.6337410808,
0.2350923121,
-0.1628708094,
0.2729244828,
0.1056638435,
-0.5620086789,
-0.3426386416,
-0.4901950359,
-0.8570228219,
0.8253850937,
0.0396874733,
-0.6895018816,
0.3176732063,
-0.6867675781,
-0.721336484,
-0.0414361581,
-0.1528248042,
-0.5341227651,
0.0534607321,
0.1030379608,
0.098108761,
-0.0904069319,
0.5364345312,
-0.5346187353,
-0.2561453283,
-0.2992564142,
-0.2019935697,
1.3705947399,
0.3383378088,
-0.8988339901,
0.1550611705,
-0.6883152723,
-0.3272768557,
-0.1905542761,
-0.3783234656,
-0.1907043904,
0.1016709358,
-0.414152503,
-0.2753160298,
-0.0032764336,
-0.4582383037,
0.4838299453,
-0.4165141881,
0.6785379052,
0.4393558204,
0.2586382926,
0.5076885223,
-0.3469446599,
0.3331845999,
-0.127622515,
0.1077577099,
-0.1650771946,
-0.826990962,
-0.6494918466,
0.073099345,
0.8111637831,
0.5713518262,
-0.2554289103,
0.4377340376,
0.0154230678,
-0.5770595074,
-0.3812808394,
-0.0688779578,
0.1949858665,
0.4251596928,
0.3529562652,
-0.6854987144,
-1.0662602186,
-0.6529737115,
-0.5216947198,
-0.7258794308,
0.1262580305,
0.0635640845,
0.1535565406,
0.0594269894,
0.9201825261,
0.1064030454,
-0.323441416,
0.1685563326,
0.3938243687,
0.1067306921,
0.7284362316,
0.5914024711,
-0.5977104902,
-0.1444566846,
0.1980010867,
-0.4650250077,
-0.435038954,
-0.2426836938,
0.1004049107,
0.0754327103,
0.845441401,
-0.5928783417,
0.396443367,
0.2894909084,
-0.1781562865,
0.7116494775,
0.1403951198,
0.07964506,
-0.9893591404,
-0.0257020574,
0.1243394166,
-0.0307712369,
-0.525549829,
-0.2185650468,
-0.3434659541,
0.0088086491,
-0.2780686915,
0.3299960196,
-0.4773664773,
-0.5472812057,
0.0231811367,
-0.4761779308,
-0.4360868037,
0.4609817266,
0.2504208684,
0.745480299,
0.5851227641,
-0.7058575153,
0.5100299716,
0.2201075554,
-0.1284628659,
0.0752017424,
-0.3675923049,
-0.0891614184,
0.2947306037,
0.4139529467,
-0.8490720987,
-0.3361580074,
0.3866145611,
-0.6995080709,
0.1214341894,
-0.5990592837,
-0.3681912422,
-0.1139203459,
0.0094503174,
0.4456202388,
0.4043311477,
-0.4353325367,
0.6797383428,
0.702319622,
-0.4383653998,
-0.1565489173,
-0.5030946136,
0.4739138484,
-0.6469912529,
-0.3999076188,
0.3716769814,
0.0399505347,
-0.4907063544,
-0.0740276203,
-0.1578842402,
-0.3619230986,
0.4031151235,
0.1048317179,
-0.1277271956,
-0.5429905653,
0.2346996069,
0.2798626721,
0.0719154477,
0.2590309381,
-0.8562700152,
0.4457407296,
-0.244926542,
-0.0107280742,
-0.8667827249,
-0.2599845529,
0.5448034406,
-0.3542275727,
-0.0227478445,
0.3462975621,
-0.4828931987,
0.4341504276,
-0.5278605223,
-0.1417731792,
-0.4133883715,
-0.0153160356,
-0.4864821136,
-0.3297252953,
0.5220042467,
-0.3416996002,
0.1718117297,
0.5809414983,
0.4625523686,
-0.0964388847,
0.7975054383,
0.423853606,
-0.1846914142,
0.8538661599,
-0.2452810705,
-0.2151279598,
-0.3414258957,
-0.1673903614,
-0.6006032825,
-0.2793073356,
-0.7536845803,
-0.1252955794,
0.2086680979,
0.0907127112,
-0.0657119304,
0.8567704558,
-0.3098889887,
0.4075416923,
0.8532887697,
-0.0559817404,
0.3791822791,
0.196520716,
-0.3033239543,
0.3745748997,
-0.6904241443,
-0.0867142305,
1.0435584784,
0.2502782941,
0.4148005247,
0.0272939708,
0.9069086313,
0.5678188801,
-0.1907996088,
-0.8165122867,
0.4876576364,
0.0114424685,
-0.1586595476,
-0.5337276459,
-0.4136656821,
-1.0804331303,
0.070591867,
0.0314852148,
-0.5089211464,
0.4970765412,
0.3692248762,
-0.5210189223,
0.445248872,
-0.6629389524,
0.5078785419,
-0.1954124719,
-0.0353317,
-0.3832467198,
-0.9337474108,
0.1473306865,
-0.1118597239,
-0.0531539321,
-0.1170991212,
0.2105210572,
1.0257437229,
-0.3715504706,
0.8399968147,
-0.4950342774,
-0.2012205124,
0.562241137,
0.5643631816,
0.1726220995,
-0.0487324335,
-0.4795212448,
0.2590694427,
0.1911315471,
-0.3057382107,
-0.1101707816,
0.3995880783,
-0.6506671309,
-0.4940945208,
-0.2605137825,
-0.5757163763,
-0.3201215565,
0.3241736889,
0.317445904,
0.4179308712,
-0.0893473849,
0.0809455067,
0.5912536383,
-0.0129487049,
0.6908170581,
0.3475658,
0.0632291883,
-0.5674289465,
0.6704874635,
0.1140781045,
-0.0932506844,
0.2748619318,
0.6478023529,
-0.4801298678,
-0.7247228622,
-0.8775879145,
-0.0165037606,
-0.4071808457,
-0.0504438542,
-0.2426722646,
0.2148786485,
-0.4671600163,
0.3127700388,
-0.1262713671,
-0.9713342786,
-0.1717255414,
0.004626147,
0.5252130032,
0.924790442,
-0.4543681145,
0.2905036211,
-0.4272778928,
0.1598988622,
0.2337854803,
0.2046733499,
-0.1776963174,
-0.7409924865,
0.0110163083,
0.3414573371,
-0.0708485767,
-0.9015647173,
0.242546007,
0.7732289433,
0.2961227,
0.281200856,
-0.2128080577,
0.8327713609,
-0.3950726688,
0.5299012661,
0.2408167869,
-1.0219112635,
0.6726530194,
-0.5467105508,
0.1475071907,
0.5632463098,
0.015253108,
-0.7193331122,
-0.4763812721,
-0.8127852678,
-0.4511304796,
0.4081849456,
0.2400726825,
-0.2202269882,
0.3451260924,
0.4817782044,
0.3471719921,
0.2474205494,
-0.4336230457,
-0.1049209461,
-0.3608825207,
-0.3055363894,
0.0752593279,
0.2254132032,
0.1843554378,
-0.6418781877,
0.6948189735,
-0.107469745,
0.2145921588,
0.2078976631,
-0.3179650903,
-0.3221797049,
-0.0165194869,
0.6834073663,
0.5348294377,
-0.0917425677,
0.1480666101,
0.3088336289,
-0.5628997684,
0.3462552428,
0.3015659153,
-0.1515805125,
0.4236361384,
0.3617875874,
0.7562984228,
0.2004183531,
-0.1333943903,
0.2533182502,
0.0194776934,
-0.223124966,
-0.6391095519,
0.0172464736,
0.0858584717,
0.0372147821,
0.2645224631,
0.4677461386,
0.3815540373,
-0.5445002317,
0.4582433999,
-0.0825741962,
-0.3967940211,
-0.5643920302,
0.7577491403,
0.1995003372,
-0.3451371491,
0.111849539,
-0.24386397,
-0.2444480509,
0.9252405167,
0.0786697716,
0.9250506163,
-0.8674510717,
0.1158642769,
0.2957072854,
0.1087321416,
-0.0783302933,
0.0311496444,
-0.3392161429,
-0.350009203,
-0.481883496,
-0.4414597452,
-0.5296617746,
0.2147935927,
-0.4926518798,
0.5143791437,
-0.5561898947,
0.0501994714,
0.4525451362,
-0.0604623929,
-0.1522122622,
0.1883907616,
0.3700397313,
0.956448853,
-0.745400846,
0.9179275036,
0.7325623035,
-0.4001865685,
-0.7993336916,
0.1218632236,
0.2881624103,
-0.8528777957,
0.5678337812,
0.0835052878,
-0.2918247283,
0.1865631342,
-0.3167984188,
-0.9325835705,
0.9542697072,
0.5895678997,
-0.861831367,
0.0082799578,
0.2936027348,
0.6533615589,
-0.1918796003,
0.4120392799,
0.8060708046,
0.4193065464,
-0.1758672297,
-1.3504657745,
-0.2462112606,
-0.3088831306,
-0.073727265,
0.3035164475,
-0.354998827,
0.6515741348,
-0.2983362079,
-0.270799309,
0.3009216785,
0.7667567134,
0.1022546664,
0.3424319625,
1.0095181465,
0.6493719816,
0.9885793924,
0.0452913046,
0.6332668662,
-0.7271036506,
0.2127517909,
1.1504708529,
-0.0983404368,
0.6129996777,
0.3563805819,
-0.0406350829,
0.6540855169,
1.2308375835,
-0.0469620675,
0.3202594519,
0.4520336688,
-0.3926019669,
0.0065257326,
-0.2726512849,
-0.4714259505,
0.6734368801,
0.2918186784,
-0.3194730878,
-0.0627751648,
0.0327245295,
0.133655116,
-0.2786575854,
-0.3919164538,
0.8707925677,
0.052529674,
-0.7121438384,
0.7571110725,
-0.0646217018,
0.4352439046,
-0.2763111293,
-0.1214925423,
-0.1535055637,
-0.0030037037,
-0.3915556073,
-0.6346883178,
0.2324314862,
-0.4588525891,
0.1653860658,
0.0220650453,
0.7114382386,
-0.6217952967,
-0.063173525,
0.2892373502,
0.2717601359,
0.3358198404,
0.0154734133,
-0.8578971028,
-0.2492272854,
0.1626932621,
-0.0913271829,
-0.1534132659,
0.2763233483,
-0.3719858825,
0.6353353262,
0.6594831347,
0.3980457485,
0.3747202456,
0.1014965847,
0.3510168791,
-0.5562438965,
-0.6556131244,
-0.671399951,
-0.2246355414,
0.0403147973,
-0.3095749915,
0.3640938699,
0.776471734,
0.9997119904,
-0.0982559994,
0.8246513605,
-0.1109007746,
0.3732104003,
-0.5532159805,
0.502664566,
-0.2358406037,
0.3317961693,
-0.0920519754,
-1.0220371485,
-0.2969679832,
0.404820472,
-0.2010172457,
-0.2689446807,
0.7280160785,
0.8116733432,
-0.2809314132,
0.5100939274,
-0.0501834378,
0.333191216,
0.0539458543,
0.3656609654,
0.5413177609,
-0.2719453573,
0.6502521038,
-0.639388144,
0.0320602618,
-0.201817885,
-0.6008084416,
-0.3787581027,
-0.7237687707,
-0.6562101841,
-0.3063040674,
0.3385611475,
1.0067510605,
0.6611762047,
-1.1233228445,
-0.8191336393,
-0.8018642068,
-0.2390202135,
-0.4379054308,
-0.1840397567,
0.4278548062,
-0.1818959266,
-0.4931606054,
0.8098887205,
0.0758065656,
0.3081534803,
-0.0255300738,
-0.1366535872,
-0.1472683251,
-0.22453475,
0.2445865273,
0.8149743676,
-0.8694854975,
-0.3251379728,
-0.309756875,
0.0559897795,
0.3490115106,
0.8084995151,
-0.7889520526,
0.5703017712,
0.6065530181,
0.6115826368,
0.2496463656,
-0.2532808185,
0.7391722202,
-0.4327765703,
0.0370678008,
0.2399519682,
0.6620468497,
0.271430403,
-0.1950597018,
0.746725738,
0.5873448253,
-0.288683027,
-0.7273119688,
0.3643865585,
-0.8277587891,
0.1013665125,
1.0976212025,
-0.0307146236,
-0.3212322295,
-0.4361102283,
-0.3971356153,
0.6493100524,
-0.3974586129,
0.9187342525,
0.2963725626,
-0.1778636426,
-0.2599985003,
-0.295514226,
0.8393545151,
0.7902012467,
-0.8711851239,
-0.0196583122,
0.2983886003,
0.2880519032,
0.3068806529,
0.2604676485,
-0.1057070419,
0.6489582658,
-0.1278449744,
0.2752255797,
-0.0580133907,
-0.2357756048,
-0.5311976075,
-0.3119001091,
0.1701566577,
-0.3000231087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01579v1
|
How Paralingual are Paralinguistic Representations? A Case Study in Speech Emotion Recognition
| 2024-02-02T17:17:42 | 2024-02-02T17:17:42 |
Orchid Chetia Phukan, Gautam Siddharth Kashyap, Arun Balaji Buduru, Rajesh Sharma
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Pre-trained Models (PTMs) have facilitated substantial progress in the field
of Speech Emotion Recognition (SER). SER is an area with applications ranging
from HumanComputer Interaction to Healthcare. Recent studies have leveraged
various PTM representations as input features for downstream models for SER.
PTM specifically pre-trained for paralinguistic tasks have obtained
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for SER. However, such PTM haven't been
evaluated for SER in multilingual settings and experimented only with English.
So, we fill this gap, by performing a comprehensive comparative study of five
PTMs (TRILLsson, wav2vec2, XLS-R, x-vector, Whisper) for assessing the
effectiveness of paralingual PTM (TRILLsson) for SER across multiple languages.
Representations from TRILLsson achieved the best performance among all the
PTMs. This demonstrates that TRILLsson is able to effectively capture the
various paralinguistic features from speech data for better SER. We also show
that downstream models using TRILLsson representations achieve SOTA performance
in terms of accuracy across various multi-lingual datasets.
|
[
-0.2665081024,
0.1396833807,
0.5192676187,
0.3225616217,
-0.2567669749,
0.1606711447,
-0.3378192186,
-0.3109416962,
0.2156773806,
0.3002428412,
-0.1112106815,
-0.6289684772,
-0.5896579027,
0.466142565,
-0.1793870777,
0.7293764353,
-0.182740584,
0.4468758106,
-0.068536669,
-0.5073291659,
0.1161239967,
-1.168107748,
-0.7132900357,
-0.3759062588,
0.6523141861,
0.0792219713,
0.4946590662,
0.1518710852,
0.12511985,
0.3410225213,
-0.0985256955,
-0.1349847913,
-0.45552665,
0.0786042884,
0.2817026973,
-0.5315457582,
-0.1175825,
0.0453609303,
0.7148162723,
0.4900980294,
-0.1674613953,
-0.0538177043,
0.1663608253,
0.5017561913,
-0.6346027255,
0.348736763,
0.0058520543,
0.3786475062,
-0.3624930382,
-0.3715540767,
-0.3782000244,
-0.4505888224,
0.624599874,
-0.577768147,
-0.2014472783,
0.0260336474,
0.5853566527,
0.22258313,
-0.6046854854,
-0.339735359,
-0.8035811186,
0.6914536953,
-0.7929158211,
0.9217803478,
0.3237757683,
0.3146057725,
0.3029883802,
-0.6507347226,
-0.2738854289,
-0.4766489863,
0.0431921147,
0.253485173,
-0.3591522276,
0.2936436236,
0.0999978408,
0.1660239249,
-0.6513704658,
0.1856068075,
-0.1054482609,
-0.1740619093,
0.3878391385,
0.0036035418,
0.2604976296,
-0.1854565293,
-0.0771612003,
-0.2225363404,
-0.5899875164,
0.16223979,
0.3584924042,
0.3228718638,
-0.3256192207,
0.3161518574,
0.0823635235,
0.5390028954,
-0.0769276097,
-0.1856140643,
0.2937380373,
0.1320234835,
-0.1003331318,
0.2810810804,
0.8891669512,
0.2215398252,
0.5491072536,
-0.2804199159,
-0.0091062104,
-0.2438322455,
0.1906365156,
-0.363950938,
0.0453220829,
0.1049391255,
-0.6195340753,
0.2283921391,
-0.0630477741,
-0.7573413849,
-0.5747584701,
-0.2470016479,
0.2561846673,
-0.4041376114,
-0.5290264487,
0.123126179,
0.282943368,
0.1487484425,
-0.167196393,
-0.5325065255,
0.3031032681,
0.4033321142,
0.7252132893,
0.0259616207,
-0.4884601235,
-0.384303093,
0.0222133398,
-0.4713402987,
0.5391236544,
-0.6505665779,
-0.4234915078,
0.4763077497,
-0.1624960452,
-0.1509189159,
-0.719408989,
0.5528403521,
-0.3854828477,
0.1790223867,
-0.5005466342,
-0.4090027511,
-0.3370615542,
-0.2320308983,
-0.8171850443,
0.6897776723,
-0.0110413237,
-0.715896368,
0.2356532514,
-0.3964432776,
-0.3032089174,
-0.0127637107,
0.0158773232,
-0.3218366802,
0.337236315,
-0.0517485626,
0.5986328125,
-0.2407993078,
-0.0847364441,
-0.2802236974,
-0.4479027987,
0.3499195874,
-0.2854620218,
0.3410428464,
0.1920341998,
-0.2347005159,
-0.0593951233,
-0.6031869054,
-0.1890005618,
-0.1384414285,
-0.1340527982,
-0.3900720179,
-0.0065453667,
0.0853333175,
0.3367308974,
0.1238563657,
-0.3733855188,
-0.4515554607,
-0.2339971364,
0.3164563179,
0.1629325897,
-0.1910548508,
0.3049800098,
-0.1189394891,
0.7249364853,
0.1335518956,
-0.1480169445,
0.142200008,
-0.0890126675,
-0.8765338659,
0.0608896911,
0.3439738452,
0.3597956598,
-0.6855618954,
-0.0903590992,
-0.0103886779,
-0.4283891916,
-0.7494754791,
-0.3088999391,
0.6454556584,
0.424529165,
0.3672964871,
0.1826135218,
-0.6817628741,
-0.7105363011,
-0.4762724638,
-0.4734301567,
-0.0146330073,
0.153840363,
-0.1849102676,
-0.0798605308,
0.4222677946,
0.1378571242,
-0.0329371169,
-0.4084639847,
0.8020328283,
-0.168334052,
0.0895534456,
0.8177863359,
-0.8622204065,
-0.7491007447,
0.1528135389,
-0.8009799123,
-0.3431319594,
0.0919449031,
0.3048792183,
0.4596880972,
0.2279877067,
-0.2391037047,
0.4650456905,
0.5783600807,
-0.0623737052,
0.4961316586,
-0.4041701555,
0.5613614321,
-0.9365462065,
0.0317203961,
0.2041027397,
-0.38269189,
-0.8991069794,
-0.5467749834,
0.2386266142,
-0.5730901361,
-0.8044320941,
0.234962672,
-0.6070279479,
-0.3101544976,
-0.0197518859,
0.0172244664,
-0.3193264008,
0.5021011829,
0.5248894095,
0.8424453735,
0.7703444362,
-0.6452491879,
0.3991810083,
-0.0722641423,
0.043897558,
0.7577154636,
-0.5829564333,
0.1086914465,
-0.28523314,
0.0389991552,
-0.8384696245,
-0.1674267948,
0.062154565,
-0.1565427184,
0.3614767194,
-0.0688821971,
-0.3398550153,
-0.1907705367,
-0.135493651,
0.4433885515,
0.7300207615,
-0.388045758,
0.6586862206,
0.3891258538,
-0.5373622179,
-0.1986685097,
-0.6761834025,
0.13371858,
-0.6373678446,
-0.2456357479,
0.2200761288,
0.3682202399,
-0.0364370272,
-0.228368029,
-0.1099445671,
-0.1598892212,
-0.301351279,
0.1265250742,
-0.1186333597,
-0.0917124674,
0.0780557096,
-0.3296779692,
-0.2017821968,
0.0723860115,
-0.0797575936,
0.5400241613,
-0.2800972462,
-0.3159305155,
-0.6286916733,
0.6405046582,
0.8034678698,
-0.4282726049,
0.4880565703,
0.6694709063,
-0.3373548388,
0.2628932595,
-0.6419801712,
0.137092486,
-0.3744491637,
0.3054791689,
-0.3608457744,
-0.9973599911,
0.7288273573,
-0.2417170554,
-0.3731426597,
0.2698297203,
0.3259145319,
-0.406591624,
1.1547241211,
0.5071671605,
0.0305159315,
0.5909944773,
-0.0701428279,
0.1660270989,
-0.7612487674,
-0.3851141036,
-0.6578906775,
-0.1946024746,
-0.7295069695,
-0.0595540777,
0.6648153067,
-0.0546360314,
-0.0069575566,
0.3173810542,
0.063883543,
0.0859607384,
0.3195300698,
-0.016142413,
-0.18324022,
0.0065529463,
-0.0996549055,
-0.3234450221,
-0.760466814,
-0.7032288909,
0.8619135022,
0.3882701099,
0.6328180432,
-0.0690207928,
0.9139779806,
0.0034926629,
-0.116422452,
-0.4899836481,
0.5325441957,
-0.5293845534,
0.0375263132,
-0.0191705767,
-0.4828879833,
-0.8614007235,
-0.1021549702,
-0.0509613715,
-0.6531447172,
0.4084372222,
0.001595455,
-0.7047174573,
0.1185539365,
-0.7027660608,
0.8906764984,
-0.4039689302,
-0.194523409,
-0.307113111,
-0.6523304582,
-0.1697801054,
-0.0712892413,
-0.0952187777,
0.0157663729,
0.0207810663,
1.0620161295,
-0.2925620377,
0.6156973243,
-0.3660746515,
-0.0654028878,
0.2101170123,
-0.0883575305,
0.2274989635,
-0.1072439179,
-0.2956607044,
0.3647669852,
0.2226397842,
-0.2657206655,
-0.8022075891,
0.3898224533,
-0.7751979828,
-0.3500405252,
-0.6439342499,
-0.4320501387,
-0.656393528,
-0.1652339995,
0.3888497353,
0.5955920815,
-0.2917616665,
0.2077741325,
0.5046471953,
-0.3345735371,
0.5776578188,
0.6446552873,
-0.0257231817,
-0.3749552071,
0.8515576124,
0.3777818978,
0.1433997005,
0.4273827672,
0.0703178197,
-0.7910320759,
-0.2748457193,
-0.0018150405,
0.4121234119,
-0.6633111238,
0.0468110964,
-0.5355034471,
-0.2488051504,
-0.5319074392,
0.0671414658,
-0.2403078526,
-0.1076381356,
-0.51953125,
0.0048615015,
0.3114157319,
0.872296989,
-0.3535396159,
0.4392002225,
-0.8710901737,
0.4632526636,
0.6092951894,
0.303263545,
-0.1489489079,
-0.2787471712,
-0.3892548084,
0.1319991499,
0.0643905923,
-1.2147753239,
0.4351284802,
0.5117844343,
0.5818568468,
0.4293585122,
0.0266478322,
0.7965500951,
-0.3936532736,
0.9063488245,
0.2173427939,
-1.1932595968,
0.3426079452,
-0.0450198539,
0.2050645947,
0.4817184806,
0.9056128263,
-0.8306940198,
-0.2859093547,
-0.4832586944,
-0.5044416189,
0.8260145187,
0.1448596418,
-0.0261532404,
0.2164195627,
0.2334862798,
0.1952794939,
0.2635067701,
-0.6089925766,
0.0139424028,
-0.4148309529,
-0.4558458328,
-0.3045320511,
-0.5845299363,
0.1295673102,
0.0662865117,
0.2352931052,
0.2264806628,
0.3633083105,
0.1010506824,
-0.2639480829,
0.1433996409,
0.3129791915,
0.5013626814,
0.2970150113,
-0.2398226261,
0.5718309283,
0.2547829151,
-0.2398739755,
0.4041686356,
0.2704221308,
0.3946973085,
0.4537116885,
0.6198524833,
1.1427676678,
0.6490008831,
-0.5891932845,
0.3529391289,
-0.1252949089,
0.2567988932,
0.1025063768,
-0.381462574,
0.0513492078,
0.5004492998,
0.2188580632,
-0.2335240692,
0.4096524417,
-0.5148010254,
-0.057399746,
-0.0061244802,
-0.4385999739,
-0.5653603673,
0.4459963739,
0.2629307806,
-0.4234572053,
0.1641519964,
-0.17301175,
-0.9271905422,
0.2758101225,
0.4721809328,
1.1202479601,
-0.7435874343,
0.3549874425,
0.096082978,
-0.1809421629,
-0.1173025891,
0.6100167036,
-0.343726635,
-0.2685605586,
-0.2267309129,
-0.4985512495,
-0.6325870156,
-0.2172307223,
-0.8716247082,
0.1715291589,
-0.0574592352,
-0.2155526131,
-0.3529373705,
-0.1387771964,
-0.6814045906,
0.3222453892,
0.6444094181,
0.5185238123,
-0.9496909976,
0.6701796055,
0.9286938906,
-0.3421807289,
-0.9959247112,
0.2797851562,
-0.1918757409,
-0.5642450452,
0.7922810316,
0.0892480761,
-0.2643336952,
-0.0070620975,
0.0603180155,
-0.6174790859,
0.5939837098,
0.8556109071,
-0.6321418285,
-0.0340176858,
0.8276506662,
0.7967802286,
-0.2483504713,
0.3742159903,
0.6224762797,
0.269412607,
-0.0892770588,
-1.0385611057,
-0.46696648,
-0.2271133661,
0.388715446,
-0.1722879559,
-0.5191591978,
0.78116256,
0.2672704458,
-0.3455222249,
-0.2163308412,
0.7096287012,
0.5241681933,
0.4304199219,
0.4575517476,
0.3221965134,
0.7177624106,
-0.2933915854,
0.9799254537,
-0.4455498755,
0.2883592248,
0.8558629155,
-0.5564693809,
0.8818387985,
0.3070352972,
-0.3845791221,
0.3261671662,
0.965405345,
0.6334332824,
0.6831245422,
0.0666499957,
-0.3925859332,
-0.2274637967,
-0.4053290486,
-0.4245301485,
0.4524152577,
0.1143743917,
-0.084126167,
-0.2524668276,
0.6581220031,
0.0174276587,
-0.0325603001,
-0.4244141281,
0.8325568438,
0.3662426174,
-0.3200697005,
0.9061896801,
-0.4150361419,
0.5408706665,
-0.7744119167,
0.0515445136,
-0.2067749351,
-0.3074499369,
-0.2689782381,
-0.6700381041,
0.2897282541,
0.3359890282,
0.1770159155,
-0.4429584146,
0.6339435577,
-0.9032853246,
-0.2686715424,
0.5997544527,
0.0358421579,
0.4863936901,
-0.1851427257,
-0.319706291,
0.3513917327,
-0.3582006693,
-0.0021023352,
-0.0541650429,
0.7280108333,
0.06318295,
0.5620916486,
0.002196013,
0.4957960248,
0.3768517077,
0.3522803783,
0.4333596826,
-0.606869936,
-0.6922777891,
-0.6746665835,
0.5679517388,
0.1776609123,
-0.2484337986,
0.6941616535,
0.2892982066,
0.5354912281,
-0.2790880203,
0.7388072014,
0.3243510723,
0.4891526103,
-0.6091489792,
0.7972886562,
-0.6346480846,
-0.3526573777,
-0.3666882515,
-0.771541059,
-0.2198495418,
0.6496692896,
-0.372266233,
0.1070830002,
0.7154163122,
0.2916924059,
-0.0250156075,
0.2058986574,
0.472430706,
0.1722818464,
0.0035053308,
0.7517843843,
1.1149561405,
-0.1954252571,
0.3334354758,
-0.2489121109,
-0.0659687072,
-0.199605912,
-0.7585268617,
-0.7091556191,
-0.8350735307,
-0.3614540696,
0.0280116666,
0.1314680725,
0.8932182789,
0.9456294179,
-0.8886966109,
-0.5466680527,
0.0580725819,
-0.2604438663,
-0.0135386502,
-0.0934583768,
0.2014629096,
-0.339826405,
-0.7869637012,
0.3615797758,
0.4910467267,
0.2857900262,
-0.2618147135,
-0.4313419163,
0.074866116,
-0.089793928,
0.4348784983,
0.4382118881,
-0.7661755085,
-0.0660418868,
-0.0676815063,
-0.0164080281,
0.0495929532,
0.772852242,
-0.6884050965,
0.4808846712,
0.4142766595,
0.596816361,
0.5008665919,
-0.3450628519,
0.7998359203,
-0.6491253972,
0.4119288921,
0.4950460494,
0.5587197542,
0.5463479757,
-0.1321219802,
0.2390981764,
-0.1158052236,
-0.4067655504,
-0.8235962987,
0.1021000817,
-0.9135532379,
0.2949973941,
1.0726737976,
-0.4948987663,
-0.0452320538,
0.0831975043,
-0.3190885782,
0.7087119222,
-0.2348099947,
0.5743777752,
0.8751259446,
-0.2528985143,
-0.587071836,
-0.1684418321,
0.7166865468,
0.6879897118,
-0.8067778945,
0.0928491652,
0.0719867647,
-0.0108450614,
0.1566950828,
0.3576225936,
-0.2055247426,
0.2325079292,
-0.3510637879,
0.1348334253,
0.1957200915,
-0.3635644317,
-0.8282083869,
0.2259313762,
0.0501214266,
-0.1897774339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01577v1
|
Deep Active Learning for Data Mining from Conflict Text Corpora
| 2024-02-02T17:16:23 | 2024-02-02T17:16:23 |
Mihai Croicu
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
High-resolution event data on armed conflict and related processes have
revolutionized the study of political contention with datasets like UCDP GED,
ACLED etc. However, most of these datasets limit themselves to collecting
spatio-temporal (high-resolution) and intensity data. Information on dynamics,
such as targets, tactics, purposes etc. are rarely collected owing to the
extreme workload of collecting data. However, most datasets rely on a rich
corpus of textual data allowing further mining of further information connected
to each event. This paper proposes one such approach that is inexpensive and
high performance, leveraging active learning - an iterative process of
improving a machine learning model based on sequential (guided) human input.
Active learning is employed to then step-wise train (fine-tuning) of a large,
encoder-only language model adapted for extracting sub-classes of events
relating to conflict dynamics. The approach shows performance similar to human
(gold-standard) coding while reducing the amount of required human annotation
by as much as 99%.
|
[
-0.0480157286,
-0.9504515529,
0.3797723949,
-0.0140075805,
-0.249170512,
0.3325678408,
-0.4440223277,
-0.3568332195,
-0.107356362,
0.5697069168,
-0.4421700835,
-0.7079925537,
-0.7065339684,
-0.0608598143,
-0.4544884861,
0.8828260303,
-0.4765155911,
-0.1653409153,
0.4866740406,
-0.3091723323,
-0.1893690079,
-0.689231813,
-0.703371942,
-0.3504132926,
0.5072819591,
0.5522588491,
0.7021844983,
0.6403517723,
0.4672757983,
0.3088739812,
-0.2537733316,
0.3565906584,
-0.5840452909,
0.5700773597,
-0.0654363558,
-0.2181598991,
0.0392485261,
0.2399158925,
0.5155181289,
0.4699229598,
-0.1198847294,
-0.187000975,
-0.0275544003,
0.5564406514,
-0.628015995,
0.1945782602,
-0.6933643222,
0.3154701293,
-0.314098388,
0.0380110629,
-0.128035605,
-0.0592235811,
0.130684346,
-0.6611622572,
0.439499855,
-0.2354248762,
1.094122529,
0.3674962521,
-0.4019578993,
-0.55198282,
-0.7164328098,
0.4606866837,
-0.3604024947,
0.0328600332,
0.5156421065,
-0.1958449334,
-0.1557283551,
-0.8013994098,
-0.4217433035,
0.1951890439,
0.0496090129,
0.2374221087,
-0.2238420248,
0.0480025001,
0.1032305956,
0.192847088,
-0.4243418276,
0.2367471159,
-0.3150990307,
0.0611300357,
0.6890376806,
0.0649111867,
-0.0263293441,
-0.191887036,
-0.2852935195,
-0.0333682634,
-0.5910673141,
0.0026132024,
0.5218102932,
0.5497228503,
-0.1205833852,
0.5308754444,
-0.1478243768,
0.4496003389,
0.3583145738,
0.3547062874,
-0.0859559253,
-0.259301424,
-0.2574674487,
0.3115463853,
1.0974075794,
-0.0927953124,
0.0326236077,
-0.0665452033,
-0.1174948439,
0.3111508191,
0.4116198421,
-1.0153828859,
-0.3140555322,
0.1508701146,
-0.4637979269,
-0.5333958268,
-0.0365785025,
-0.946893096,
-0.6369780302,
-0.3557346463,
0.318759203,
-0.3339196444,
-0.2683041096,
-0.0370047018,
0.2625966668,
-0.2532102168,
0.2955400646,
-0.4822765887,
0.0868037343,
0.5005059242,
0.97463274,
-0.4710294604,
0.0265579093,
-0.8132575154,
-0.0948910564,
-0.4899188578,
0.6735230684,
-0.8054720759,
-0.2785534263,
0.3098406494,
0.0383201651,
0.0128087569,
-0.6918430328,
0.9737171531,
-0.7600563169,
-0.0534619316,
0.0491117351,
-0.4953387678,
-0.0532587208,
0.1087773517,
-0.9271947742,
1.2266941071,
-0.2363103181,
-0.415989548,
0.5660503507,
-0.6808047295,
-0.7785030007,
0.1318004876,
-0.3463867903,
-0.7535019517,
-0.1353844553,
0.0269113146,
0.7027948499,
-0.0040354459,
0.5908477902,
-0.1730357111,
-0.1725755483,
0.0279229134,
-0.2053929865,
0.4184945822,
0.4586889446,
-0.5535138249,
0.3981231749,
-0.9206869602,
-0.4172071517,
-0.017497912,
-0.6718069315,
-0.1945183128,
0.3421015739,
-0.1198767424,
0.2068251073,
0.1822599918,
-0.3589579165,
0.4228931963,
-0.0601754151,
-0.0912463665,
0.6069793701,
0.2464002818,
0.6400655508,
0.0687155426,
0.2192333341,
0.3293115497,
-0.1650724858,
-0.0052140942,
-0.4349001646,
-0.7121632695,
-0.2731911242,
0.548273623,
0.6268789768,
-0.6505588889,
0.6049987078,
0.2939430475,
-0.4135403931,
-0.6958073974,
0.280093044,
0.0134776225,
0.0899595693,
0.2153578103,
-0.2364349365,
-0.9398947954,
-0.3183160424,
-0.1862689406,
-0.3085276484,
0.1520951986,
0.0850144252,
0.2130266279,
-0.3702244759,
0.7051903605,
-0.310608834,
-0.5094416738,
-0.2190718204,
0.9422748089,
0.0575788543,
0.1888976842,
0.1237487346,
-1.0292664766,
-0.4780349135,
0.151484102,
-0.8188641667,
-0.3270647526,
-0.4803046882,
-0.1430018842,
0.2214668989,
0.7012417912,
-0.1762383878,
0.6404516697,
0.6424134374,
-0.6413473487,
-0.0442500524,
0.0423114859,
0.3274823129,
-0.7596592307,
0.1507810205,
0.1875742972,
-0.0882554725,
-0.6856677532,
-0.028202448,
0.0307659302,
-0.4074192941,
-0.297837019,
0.249936372,
-0.4921656847,
0.3447343707,
-0.5490969419,
0.0476028062,
-0.3956222236,
0.3409147561,
0.3939429522,
0.4022354782,
0.3931162357,
-0.6575481296,
0.420900166,
0.1757164598,
-0.359049052,
-0.0997722298,
-0.2388022393,
-0.1437658668,
-0.0258409325,
-0.1046200767,
-0.667465806,
-0.0857183039,
0.1120783761,
-0.1533512324,
0.252235353,
-0.4228064716,
-0.3940226138,
0.2389496714,
-0.0036803733,
0.2420860082,
0.3421502113,
-0.3993477523,
0.4975999296,
0.6348185539,
-0.04720404,
-0.4795679748,
-0.323104918,
0.3129020631,
-0.0476807058,
-0.1171127707,
0.3373236954,
0.0629229918,
-0.292231679,
0.3294000626,
-0.0485421419,
-0.2621577084,
0.1244292185,
0.5970164537,
-0.0740508139,
-0.0931686088,
0.1717787981,
-0.2887879014,
-0.0521986783,
-0.082647942,
0.2445727289,
0.3855264485,
0.1661749482,
-0.2402351052,
-0.4650775492,
0.7169009447,
0.6070603728,
-0.3232121468,
0.8062654138,
0.6312307119,
-0.5841921568,
-0.0795069411,
-0.1488558501,
-0.0023321183,
-0.3775702417,
0.3171764016,
-0.0260568764,
-0.7243676186,
0.5609593987,
-0.7520136833,
0.202960521,
0.6413184404,
0.7775074244,
0.1939882636,
1.0161619186,
0.5782497525,
-0.2362416089,
0.8823020458,
-0.2387510538,
0.1538580209,
-0.2648391128,
-0.3212555647,
-0.4874229133,
-0.5650854111,
-0.2970744073,
-0.385735482,
0.0064482386,
0.1136578619,
-0.2895704806,
0.1252404749,
-0.3522811234,
0.2560912967,
0.3141954839,
-0.0092454441,
0.0859321132,
-0.0023426672,
0.1015317664,
-0.0792915672,
-0.8292775154,
-0.456725955,
0.6700720787,
0.2279585302,
0.9267175198,
0.0662528202,
0.6591765285,
0.3411512971,
0.1730615497,
-0.8578612804,
0.4400996268,
-0.2179311663,
-0.5445047617,
-0.2555279136,
-0.6390102506,
-1.5402152538,
0.0156943668,
-0.6851868629,
-0.0973795652,
0.529738009,
-0.2975571752,
-0.4619092941,
0.4743166268,
-0.4581299424,
0.8976712227,
-0.4356175363,
-0.4511378109,
-0.2495285869,
-0.3362219632,
0.0114631429,
-0.1637685299,
0.1323942095,
-0.084532246,
-0.2280251235,
1.1030439138,
-0.0647264421,
1.1203322411,
-0.0854756236,
-0.0623943917,
0.3926409483,
-0.026999196,
0.5834457874,
0.1092238277,
-0.3176554143,
-0.0343816504,
-0.5512354374,
-0.2766923606,
-0.1990333945,
0.7870789766,
-0.8995222449,
-0.1963930726,
-0.6683363318,
-0.2401112169,
0.1635688245,
0.0602949485,
0.238626495,
0.3779194057,
-0.5041273236,
0.2884405255,
0.9588183761,
0.0616351925,
0.6114376187,
0.5911576748,
0.1878316849,
-0.1785485297,
0.6628122926,
0.3898253739,
-0.3087865412,
0.1045905724,
-0.0054743933,
0.0917997882,
-0.6334276199,
-0.6005679369,
-0.1678187102,
-0.4400394261,
-0.8356694579,
-0.5926942229,
-0.1756647825,
-0.0581460111,
-0.2186340392,
-0.5251997113,
-0.1246348768,
-0.8371858001,
-0.0806556642,
0.4485757053,
0.80116117,
0.0390988216,
0.2369207889,
-0.7337562442,
0.7294429541,
0.1088997945,
0.5780522823,
-0.3249913156,
-0.3559956551,
-0.5293252468,
-0.1585104614,
-0.5111986995,
-1.2571954727,
0.5501831174,
0.4450705349,
0.4101682603,
0.4906058908,
0.5594189763,
0.6976000071,
-0.4178902209,
0.8368765116,
-0.1368790269,
-0.6512297392,
0.8414114118,
-0.1357697248,
0.2378160954,
0.6559449434,
0.6218156815,
-0.2475502342,
-0.2539934218,
-0.8806580305,
-1.1527032852,
0.691665113,
0.1039934605,
-0.3475314975,
-0.0235855374,
0.5241638422,
0.0340003259,
-0.0105296345,
-0.4099450111,
-0.1433689594,
0.1037632897,
-0.4916035235,
0.1781817228,
-0.0886316299,
-0.36729756,
-0.1247825474,
0.8991119266,
-0.135708347,
0.0207424164,
0.2268543392,
-0.18049483,
-0.6343806982,
0.1538459808,
0.2303864807,
0.2399031073,
0.0326911062,
0.2820518911,
0.2175236791,
-0.549661994,
0.1295148879,
0.3091543317,
0.0057282383,
0.2741742432,
0.4440819323,
0.8462213278,
0.3817903697,
-0.8441236615,
0.6541526914,
-0.306414187,
-0.4521877468,
-0.1318647265,
-0.0067039677,
-0.3956592977,
0.5583625436,
0.6910980344,
0.1166092902,
0.1537028402,
-0.9358953238,
0.4786310196,
0.1534378231,
-0.5014505386,
-0.1532930136,
0.264254272,
0.5393056273,
-0.2491379231,
0.4761599302,
-0.2577715218,
-0.7278094888,
0.3438360989,
0.1752287447,
0.6631092429,
-0.1973039359,
0.0587663017,
0.3533498347,
0.1400936693,
-0.1324722171,
0.259326309,
0.1750385463,
-0.4522020221,
-0.7511461973,
-0.4528009892,
-0.5421047211,
0.5176578164,
-0.5925174952,
0.4465316236,
-0.4066692889,
-0.1186900958,
-0.2106079906,
0.7518343925,
-0.4553768337,
0.0392347015,
0.3544592559,
0.5866734982,
-0.8220163584,
0.7225402594,
0.7436173558,
0.0258152559,
-0.2169910967,
-0.0637088642,
-0.1137723029,
-0.2014341652,
0.3906161189,
-0.0013948461,
0.2826943994,
-0.3758321702,
-0.5658249855,
-0.4388541281,
0.5772202611,
0.3819976151,
-0.5629364848,
0.1301027983,
-0.3069192767,
0.4810794294,
-0.1920317411,
-0.2931724787,
0.4803519845,
0.5254072547,
-0.1346723586,
-0.4357715249,
-0.0617799535,
-0.4027898014,
-0.7029882073,
0.6804311872,
-0.5333973169,
0.5287334919,
0.0802127197,
-0.6016283035,
-0.2579092085,
1.0714143515,
-0.1881924123,
0.4876559675,
0.5400729179,
0.4992747903,
0.88233459,
-0.2871301472,
0.5178186893,
-0.1747031808,
0.1715471298,
0.6248739362,
-0.3677271605,
0.9179285169,
0.0762139112,
0.260120064,
0.427472204,
0.7418240905,
-0.1355311424,
0.5798550844,
-0.0067161382,
-0.605448842,
-0.5024783611,
0.06073194,
0.0517470576,
0.5206546783,
0.5272729397,
-0.3835841417,
-0.2061296254,
0.0099967523,
0.025631709,
0.4146632254,
-0.3722534478,
1.2126289606,
-0.2635733783,
-0.6281888485,
0.371534884,
0.1995416731,
0.7311964631,
-0.6950538754,
-0.3078447282,
0.1830491126,
0.2342318445,
-0.2557197511,
-0.9400810003,
0.2821741998,
0.3861162066,
-0.2253557295,
-0.3478175998,
0.7767111063,
-0.8533109426,
-0.3526174724,
0.3600101769,
0.3906352222,
-0.0549764223,
-0.1164827421,
-0.6959587932,
0.4393627048,
-0.1398921013,
-0.4218132496,
0.3923550844,
0.9463794231,
-0.083787173,
0.1696632951,
0.6477031112,
0.2534071803,
-0.0988911241,
0.0361149125,
1.0629478693,
-0.6277635694,
-0.1721335649,
-0.7463433146,
0.265478462,
-0.3790587187,
-0.2389719784,
0.2287375033,
0.8364793658,
0.4730851948,
0.4497526288,
0.8813342452,
-0.0841331929,
0.4049225152,
-0.4788835049,
0.6747307181,
-0.2369054705,
-0.0006843156,
0.047798302,
-0.1648816615,
-0.4593743384,
0.8792284131,
0.0443060584,
-0.4087586701,
0.418710649,
0.4333396256,
-0.131389901,
0.0092378911,
0.1708479226,
0.1966637969,
0.2403130233,
0.4496015906,
0.6699277163,
-0.4778520465,
0.7940172553,
-0.111009948,
-0.3886199892,
-0.4028820395,
-0.8839101791,
-0.9272662401,
-0.8891634941,
-0.5322172046,
-0.2308293879,
0.2701642215,
0.8905329108,
0.6818828583,
-0.7424108386,
-0.1347732544,
0.1659000218,
0.0553403609,
-0.2945900857,
-0.1400934011,
0.5283805132,
-0.5013723373,
-0.7449474931,
0.5538511276,
-0.1954436749,
-0.03339101,
0.1715250164,
-0.0583956875,
-0.6379841566,
0.0511731766,
0.7262503505,
0.4032721519,
-0.2782674432,
-0.1538663357,
-0.27415815,
-0.1398902088,
-0.0114368144,
1.1090819836,
-0.9745722413,
0.2468120307,
0.3706941903,
0.9486277699,
0.7557989955,
-0.0790639967,
0.4879722297,
-1.0543667078,
0.280926615,
0.4552800655,
0.2026620656,
0.3147814572,
-0.4652977288,
0.6696588993,
0.1393700242,
-0.6383317113,
-0.8102551103,
0.1040619761,
-1.0279715061,
-0.3992911279,
1.3236399889,
-0.0598696843,
-0.0318976529,
-0.4050179422,
-0.6435908675,
0.8858610988,
-0.7057144642,
0.805051744,
0.6916636825,
-0.2549256384,
-0.076233305,
-0.4600734413,
0.7430537939,
0.1453345269,
-0.7437771559,
0.5725610852,
0.4316373765,
-0.4382852316,
0.0930036977,
0.0232072491,
0.1055071056,
0.1443372518,
-0.2262342274,
-0.0045790989,
0.1180143505,
-0.3801580667,
-0.4656811357,
0.7194553018,
-0.2267512828,
0.0045910771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01825v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01825v2
|
Fractal Patterns May Illuminate the Success of Next-Token Prediction
| 2024-02-02T17:09:33 | 2024-05-22T16:19:13 |
Ibrahim Alabdulmohsin, Vinh Q. Tran, Mostafa Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We study the fractal structure of language, aiming to provide a precise
formalism for quantifying properties that may have been previously suspected
but not formally shown. We establish that language is: (1) self-similar,
exhibiting complexities at all levels of granularity, with no particular
characteristic context length, and (2) long-range dependent (LRD), with a Hurst
parameter of approximately H=0.7. Based on these findings, we argue that
short-term patterns/dependencies in language, such as in paragraphs, mirror the
patterns/dependencies over larger scopes, like entire documents. This may shed
some light on how next-token prediction can capture the structure of text
across multiple levels of granularity, from words and clauses to broader
contexts and intents. In addition, we carry out an extensive analysis across
different domains and architectures, showing that fractal parameters are
robust. Finally, we demonstrate that the tiny variations in fractal parameters
seen across LLMs improve upon perplexity-based bits-per-byte (BPB) in
predicting their downstream performance. We hope these findings offer a fresh
perspective on language and the mechanisms underlying the success of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3419566453,
-1.1241929531,
0.6672348976,
0.3667243421,
-0.354678899,
-0.2151584178,
-0.0001983956,
-0.5965867043,
0.4985383749,
0.2501271963,
-0.4115051031,
-0.5382753611,
-0.7685914636,
0.2254928946,
-0.654455781,
0.7513439655,
0.2133761048,
-0.1595713794,
-0.1862154007,
0.041401647,
-0.2995240092,
-0.7112601399,
-0.5737040639,
-0.2606085837,
0.5499771237,
0.1751942039,
0.9652301669,
1.1843219995,
0.369140625,
0.2495443076,
-0.4105181098,
-0.3866293728,
-0.3636589348,
0.1698205769,
0.3937137723,
-0.6911200881,
-0.2024199069,
0.0758735389,
0.8318402171,
0.9607682824,
-0.1616432071,
-0.1729613394,
0.380798161,
0.6384942532,
-0.0489832088,
0.4628274143,
-0.6299779415,
0.402277559,
-0.8099975586,
-0.3156823814,
-0.1833236814,
-0.0815920308,
-0.0040471782,
-0.1687080264,
0.1169305518,
0.4568053186,
0.6176897883,
0.157250762,
-0.148675248,
-0.6964070201,
-0.2879756987,
0.8226540685,
-0.6681355834,
0.6066619754,
0.5370288491,
0.0328775309,
-0.5021317601,
-0.8919502497,
-0.4401008189,
-0.3532132506,
-0.2154252082,
-0.2737410665,
-0.1081266031,
-0.1912866086,
0.1419626772,
0.3862166405,
-0.3418840468,
0.206956774,
-0.1788042337,
-0.5038309693,
0.2277108729,
0.5581709743,
0.0115867266,
-0.1453554332,
-0.4633817971,
0.4057254493,
-0.6527935266,
0.3376235962,
0.1839710325,
0.4836332798,
-0.3159984946,
0.2774955928,
-0.0426381677,
0.6963021159,
0.0216470212,
-0.3864527643,
0.0291561577,
-0.2826700509,
-0.0417455882,
-0.0224408582,
0.6087639928,
-0.0996548086,
0.0595378652,
-0.1005207151,
-0.4081760049,
-0.5524889827,
-0.1650371701,
-0.9056050777,
-0.3958024979,
0.2024536431,
-0.7902901769,
-0.5643417835,
0.0353435278,
-0.6452791691,
-0.5042963028,
-0.2043872178,
0.2312576622,
-0.4700134695,
0.0210557263,
0.016758088,
0.0965632498,
0.1928832829,
0.3947236538,
-1.0215828419,
0.4789635241,
1.1165516376,
1.4920138121,
-0.2046186328,
-0.7398905754,
-0.6622933745,
0.0118559571,
-0.3402865827,
1.0033415556,
-0.6880030036,
-0.5045679808,
0.0947212204,
-0.4045390189,
0.3332273364,
-0.3019191325,
0.3165376782,
-0.5191753507,
0.2206201702,
-0.5344735384,
-0.7202928662,
0.0077287988,
0.1436012983,
-1.0245131254,
0.5897322893,
-0.1392321587,
-0.9520742297,
0.5974375606,
-0.500311017,
-0.6689677835,
0.110917531,
-0.6402038336,
-0.4421601593,
0.3055223823,
-0.256706953,
0.6542229652,
-0.263330847,
-0.2407745719,
-0.5493584275,
-0.538662672,
0.4525202215,
-0.6104799509,
0.7180941105,
0.136814639,
-0.3385074735,
-0.1303779483,
-0.6040167809,
-0.2008437514,
-0.1252814531,
-0.5767691731,
0.0488714613,
0.18599087,
0.001689262,
0.2062334269,
0.5599557757,
-0.2317947149,
0.0425227061,
-0.1603011191,
0.5181526542,
1.2103610039,
-0.1436866522,
0.295940727,
-0.3228527308,
0.5058164001,
0.1811684966,
0.3855130076,
-0.322830379,
-0.7439808846,
-0.3553000391,
-0.438136965,
0.1505479366,
0.0563318133,
0.2264717221,
0.3918424547,
-0.1487848163,
-0.271456778,
0.1606657654,
0.2878928781,
0.2420670688,
0.2891450822,
-0.0190864839,
-0.5400243402,
-0.6622217894,
-0.6541519165,
-0.3165465891,
-0.3347227573,
0.3973429203,
0.2987433374,
0.3001419604,
-0.1606168896,
0.8989722133,
-0.4013024867,
-0.4632261395,
-0.0698440745,
0.2212152183,
0.4365540147,
0.0223351028,
0.3946618736,
-0.7409441471,
-0.4124906063,
0.151947543,
-0.4862165451,
0.0832383186,
0.1179614067,
0.2681762874,
0.4913286567,
0.9174381495,
-0.2894532382,
0.1972661316,
0.7309074402,
-0.6201785803,
0.537645638,
0.0442643948,
-0.2661421001,
-0.9947434068,
-0.128802672,
-0.2860560715,
-0.1814341396,
-0.4721678197,
-0.4032962322,
-0.2915157676,
0.2084019333,
-0.1837453246,
0.505476892,
-0.3830651641,
-0.3799231052,
-0.1184028387,
-0.3127839267,
-0.4318907857,
0.2550215721,
-0.0787428692,
1.0125627518,
0.5933265686,
-0.3500591218,
-0.0693402663,
-0.1562215984,
-0.5793647766,
0.1092266887,
-0.5830783248,
-0.0406567939,
0.1069903299,
0.1289990991,
-0.9894746542,
-0.2854886949,
-0.2095631808,
-0.3644473553,
0.1157484129,
-0.151707992,
-0.6460572481,
0.0612478033,
-0.364231497,
0.4084639847,
0.6311933994,
-0.2731033564,
0.6081565619,
0.2347539216,
-0.3365008831,
-0.6735463738,
-0.6139293313,
0.116787605,
-0.1851165444,
-0.44275406,
-0.0988238826,
-0.1626061946,
-0.4007191062,
-0.1922192127,
0.0026094806,
-0.0215579551,
0.4420415461,
0.6101440191,
-0.0940175727,
-0.368059665,
-0.0515361093,
-0.1670704782,
-0.1068673804,
0.2561450601,
-0.5910933614,
1.0243202448,
-0.5215756893,
-0.2996498644,
-0.4387243092,
0.2512688339,
0.7000703216,
0.160497427,
0.6273034811,
0.5039978623,
-0.1691596508,
-0.1167571843,
-0.4762967825,
-0.0751009285,
-0.5212568641,
0.4920439124,
-0.6507440805,
-1.1593800783,
0.8221740723,
0.0517951697,
-0.1583904773,
0.4022526741,
0.7863968015,
-0.419447124,
0.5707523823,
0.9737175107,
-0.2570097446,
0.8081882,
-0.0771146789,
0.0763692111,
-0.336048156,
-0.3858713508,
-0.3918881416,
-0.1436512619,
-0.5594089627,
-0.4382946193,
0.2771324813,
0.4525359869,
-0.071615167,
-0.0120838284,
0.1153764203,
0.6548038721,
0.4328398108,
-0.347643435,
0.2946608663,
0.3292984068,
-0.1234199703,
-0.0539900549,
-0.4944939315,
-0.5061317682,
1.0007251501,
0.4433814585,
0.5327944756,
0.0383936949,
0.9903272986,
0.637386322,
0.3620637655,
-0.6472306252,
0.4187646508,
-0.2356978059,
-0.1963541359,
-0.6518837214,
-0.216896981,
-1.0103143454,
0.1126176938,
-0.0030530861,
-0.6495504379,
0.1148215383,
0.1611222029,
-0.11784596,
0.2456433624,
-0.3040911853,
0.516274333,
-0.0427500494,
0.0190252289,
-0.0984520018,
-0.5269690752,
0.0495620668,
-0.3146397471,
0.3754566312,
0.0028110945,
-0.5678948164,
0.6218231916,
-0.5210410953,
1.0559900999,
0.355039835,
-0.4473645389,
0.2239323556,
0.3737010956,
0.5384879708,
0.1574759632,
-0.3141124845,
0.6378297806,
-0.2075941861,
-0.6458829641,
-0.5112217069,
0.7478063107,
-0.6661520004,
-0.7056028843,
-0.2416432947,
-0.4771403372,
0.0201093592,
0.5638121963,
0.4256531894,
0.6480869651,
-0.1722303182,
0.0896196291,
0.6277150512,
0.5489488244,
0.904704988,
0.2002955973,
-0.2583088875,
-0.3679095507,
0.7937347889,
0.11924503,
0.2148456424,
0.5628886819,
0.3367704153,
-0.382465899,
-0.999925673,
-0.1182729304,
0.0839923173,
-0.7277805209,
-0.0609699488,
-0.6344064474,
0.0518303141,
-0.2997767627,
-0.3281984925,
-0.061675895,
-0.4147457182,
-0.320745647,
0.0139369844,
0.3319342434,
1.2129989862,
-0.1051581353,
-0.0134561379,
-0.6378698349,
-0.3325677514,
0.4018379152,
0.6080601811,
0.1749022752,
-0.6966408491,
-0.4439347982,
-0.4164917171,
-0.0109798927,
-0.4887946546,
0.0343526118,
0.2574656904,
0.3160632849,
0.6542445421,
-0.649169445,
0.6919521689,
-0.6842569113,
0.9539679289,
0.3459455967,
-1.0277334452,
0.461288482,
-0.3101106882,
0.0432727151,
0.2851646841,
0.1927752346,
-0.494023025,
-0.4430319369,
-0.6640245318,
-0.5107439756,
0.4495493174,
0.2410149276,
0.2862600386,
-0.1943589449,
0.4372787774,
0.4787453115,
0.1992611289,
-0.6823758483,
-0.3273444176,
-0.2460669577,
-0.0174292047,
0.0022320403,
-0.5708453655,
-0.0822191164,
0.1609927565,
0.0162057653,
-0.0870651305,
0.2841754854,
-0.1173960716,
0.2314106375,
0.0032799875,
0.0098057548,
0.9298046231,
0.6384658813,
-0.0632069558,
0.2069580853,
0.1913080812,
-0.7542124391,
-0.1758208722,
-0.1445170194,
0.0856419578,
0.140446946,
1.0921174288,
0.2344708443,
-0.0468206964,
-0.4305437803,
0.6146202683,
0.0207782537,
0.023464296,
-0.4552617371,
-0.0333694369,
0.0210616309,
0.3537550569,
0.3209018409,
0.0551641211,
0.244101271,
-0.7693754435,
0.4357511997,
0.4095497429,
-0.5271497965,
-0.5704032779,
0.3530316353,
0.1043224633,
-0.6198589206,
0.2961391509,
-0.0926285163,
-0.3067685962,
0.613196373,
0.704983592,
0.8012270927,
0.0349955149,
-0.1755709499,
-0.1888490617,
0.0536001772,
-0.145641014,
0.5389809608,
-0.214763701,
-0.4833571911,
-0.2383634001,
-0.9644534588,
-0.0039059627,
-0.1385927945,
-0.3087759912,
0.2592606843,
-0.9557946324,
0.023840934,
0.0333407409,
0.1002831757,
-0.4355948865,
0.0524841882,
0.2509186864,
1.003058672,
-0.73295331,
0.9107272625,
0.5326805115,
-0.5138218999,
-0.7719449997,
0.3421808481,
0.1323567629,
-1.0401571989,
0.8818713427,
0.1880529076,
-0.3885210156,
-0.2415441573,
-0.4090212286,
-1.1732317209,
1.3230819702,
0.2236238867,
-0.6329851747,
0.0970187336,
0.341237843,
0.6284911633,
-0.5112301707,
-0.0898443758,
0.4929907024,
0.2373925447,
0.0057805479,
-0.7978736162,
0.1753302813,
-0.0726088062,
0.2918386757,
0.4987797439,
-0.693484664,
1.2665338516,
-0.459633857,
-0.1689510792,
0.2969980538,
1.1086281538,
0.0747566819,
0.2373923659,
0.5431964993,
0.3714490533,
0.9042915702,
0.0653825477,
1.2521402836,
-0.5530352592,
0.3684110045,
0.7674791217,
0.2397300005,
1.0084758997,
0.5333268046,
-0.3738980889,
0.8260960579,
0.4690136015,
0.2067386955,
0.4854748249,
0.1786069721,
-0.1226792708,
-0.2467370331,
-0.0685626045,
-0.4035795331,
0.2978975177,
0.4969967604,
-0.5710136294,
0.0271034669,
-0.3993945122,
0.2201108187,
-0.0039947103,
-0.3197032213,
0.7592425942,
0.2496879995,
-0.0757795051,
0.4514041543,
-0.2302448601,
0.7508575916,
-0.4254531264,
0.0319998115,
-0.5875294805,
-0.0815396234,
-0.3087811172,
-0.9666821361,
0.1333200932,
-0.5156109333,
-0.3660804927,
-0.0776998922,
0.3818280995,
-0.0924781784,
-0.4640721977,
-0.0106098773,
0.3489120603,
0.2709991336,
0.1825106293,
-0.6413662434,
0.1722028404,
-0.0514348894,
-0.1101330966,
0.3899108171,
1.0249618292,
-0.0826999545,
0.7434111834,
0.5695567131,
0.2300302535,
0.1850047559,
0.0246651899,
0.6507313251,
-0.9022636414,
-0.6516614556,
-1.0594978333,
-0.0866868645,
0.0623759069,
-0.587675631,
0.6112865806,
0.6097247601,
0.799652338,
0.1636401415,
0.4637911916,
0.0795732662,
-0.0654501542,
-0.6270439625,
0.5834951401,
-0.4284057617,
0.5366368294,
-0.0774340108,
-0.7363992333,
-0.403072238,
0.3294210136,
0.0022179775,
0.0564248487,
0.8811514974,
0.75370121,
0.1341193318,
0.2099479139,
0.4485157132,
0.4968918562,
0.3901698887,
0.1095517203,
0.8290064931,
-0.0364405401,
0.6824440956,
-0.1773643345,
-0.1516939998,
-0.3675315678,
-0.8042631149,
-0.9294844866,
-0.8986251354,
0.0394984446,
-0.4021986127,
0.0125876479,
0.6365017295,
0.4533881843,
-0.6799066067,
-0.409953177,
-0.4179392755,
0.2023128569,
-0.1758252531,
-0.1583752185,
0.4517458975,
-0.6691193581,
-0.4016337693,
-0.1144389287,
0.8011443615,
0.4018134475,
-0.32477808,
-0.128219977,
0.4284437597,
0.2096372098,
0.837810874,
0.090621464,
-1.0986119509,
-0.2186982632,
-0.1115715057,
-0.3382836282,
0.0376782231,
1.2128064632,
-0.5473265648,
-0.1058264747,
0.3158577383,
0.3619683981,
-0.0675620586,
-0.2301987112,
0.3858965039,
-0.5252397656,
0.1006988585,
0.1687467992,
0.5979555845,
-0.0166051798,
-0.5082651973,
0.2074228227,
0.1878327131,
-0.2788908184,
-0.6405461431,
0.5528416634,
-0.8685798645,
-0.3179222047,
1.1754816771,
-0.159789443,
-0.221396789,
-0.3874057829,
0.0078180376,
-0.4410623312,
-0.4928996265,
1.2095749378,
0.7989339828,
-0.467884779,
-0.0249342024,
0.0331540443,
0.8089565635,
0.5788940191,
-0.5598604083,
0.2161121815,
0.412106365,
0.3032489717,
0.2709619701,
0.9122283459,
-0.3172910213,
0.3073179722,
0.1900205463,
-0.6293703318,
-0.1827624738,
-0.3192993402,
-0.509685874,
0.4659794867,
0.4930332601,
0.1628582478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01822v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01822v2
|
Building Guardrails for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-02T16:35:00 | 2024-05-29T12:57:01 |
Yi Dong, Ronghui Mu, Gaojie Jin, Yi Qi, Jinwei Hu, Xingyu Zhao, Jie Meng, Wenjie Ruan, Xiaowei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) become more integrated into our daily lives,
it is crucial to identify and mitigate their risks, especially when the risks
can have profound impacts on human users and societies. Guardrails, which
filter the inputs or outputs of LLMs, have emerged as a core safeguarding
technology. This position paper takes a deep look at current open-source
solutions (Llama Guard, Nvidia NeMo, Guardrails AI), and discusses the
challenges and the road towards building more complete solutions. Drawing on
robust evidence from previous research, we advocate for a systematic approach
to construct guardrails for LLMs, based on comprehensive consideration of
diverse contexts across various LLMs applications. We propose employing
socio-technical methods through collaboration with a multi-disciplinary team to
pinpoint precise technical requirements, exploring advanced neural-symbolic
implementations to embrace the complexity of the requirements, and developing
verification and testing to ensure the utmost quality of the final product.
|
[
-0.5830078721,
-0.8212267756,
0.7736862302,
0.1914518178,
-0.1597030461,
0.5431270599,
-0.0924514979,
-0.5469889045,
0.2251539826,
0.6822932363,
-0.4111980796,
-0.530266583,
-0.7772114277,
-0.259200871,
-0.5005248189,
0.5677406788,
-0.4610262513,
-0.0647515059,
0.0610077642,
0.1565107554,
-0.4515844882,
-0.6418291926,
-0.4579375982,
-0.3651531339,
0.459733516,
0.1816834658,
0.4119841754,
0.4031611085,
0.4582906663,
0.1902200878,
-0.5441827774,
0.075232394,
-0.0303260554,
0.3928182423,
-0.2862924337,
-0.2929290831,
-0.5486449003,
-0.2796116471,
0.5049570799,
0.4265036881,
-0.0758394822,
0.154036805,
0.3164558113,
0.3067909479,
-0.6844147444,
0.1973265558,
-0.4713606238,
0.1481629312,
-0.4401170015,
-0.1223722473,
-0.3588023186,
-0.3579373956,
-0.0071559977,
-0.0987242833,
-0.2850984335,
0.2118198723,
0.7058166265,
0.0720409676,
-0.5908184052,
-0.1088348404,
-0.7497487664,
0.7430910468,
-0.7988898754,
0.2645704448,
0.2669594884,
0.4808979332,
-0.5149517059,
-0.3454463184,
-0.1784282178,
-0.3050143719,
0.0567238145,
-0.1320249587,
-0.1041389778,
0.0824325755,
0.0412442088,
-0.006126347,
-0.5708718896,
0.4404442906,
-0.237833783,
-0.2524517775,
0.5482123494,
0.3595501482,
0.4829728603,
-0.0569442287,
-0.0962910727,
0.0822429284,
-1.2064416409,
-0.1843390316,
0.4075067937,
0.4766540229,
-0.2080091089,
0.3761110008,
-0.0963738412,
0.416654408,
-0.3214605451,
-0.0723646432,
-0.1730185598,
-0.1227222756,
-0.0306832101,
0.0518820398,
0.8103830218,
0.088725619,
0.4921438396,
-0.2400618196,
-0.2865585089,
0.0869755521,
0.1741606891,
-0.6630710959,
0.0852878019,
0.4440261424,
-0.2135847658,
-0.3486008942,
-0.3534994721,
-0.9682042599,
-0.7893127203,
-0.5033477545,
0.1716942042,
-0.2533008456,
-0.5804028511,
0.3943935633,
0.1732296497,
0.3971683085,
0.2577885687,
-0.7987248898,
0.2331874371,
0.983727932,
1.1710324287,
0.0827508941,
0.0227768831,
-0.3422467411,
0.2678101659,
-0.4987334013,
0.7882133722,
-0.4155141711,
-0.5049817562,
0.3255702257,
-0.1687985361,
0.3261550665,
-0.2161559016,
0.6098305583,
-0.6396832466,
-0.0164589435,
0.0372159965,
-0.2764752507,
0.1348813474,
0.5007417202,
-0.4778651595,
0.5188323855,
-0.2542941868,
-0.666572988,
0.0736507028,
-0.5085872412,
-0.5222832561,
0.1498054564,
-0.1704024523,
-0.2349839509,
0.1859951615,
0.2151434124,
0.4462324977,
-0.5834778547,
0.4924902916,
-0.4256240427,
0.0923326984,
-0.0456892513,
-0.2695541978,
0.7404648066,
0.2711683214,
-0.4576436877,
0.5229870081,
-0.3358564377,
0.0252048727,
-0.0202891845,
-0.1045036465,
-0.2677748203,
0.3988057971,
0.255150795,
0.2242478877,
0.3481476903,
-0.5111495852,
-0.1173448786,
-0.2484068274,
0.7034609914,
1.2426083088,
-0.0795659348,
0.3642154634,
-0.1784465909,
0.6864767075,
-0.2698703706,
0.5352098346,
-0.0697593167,
-0.41793859,
-0.6521502137,
-0.1885290444,
0.1045238599,
0.3734373152,
-0.5779374242,
0.6494493484,
-0.2527486682,
-0.7690474391,
0.0436667576,
0.1472090781,
0.3739866912,
0.0338119119,
0.0336234607,
-0.4137381315,
-0.6913888454,
-0.7341798544,
0.080093883,
-0.2924616635,
0.0407158174,
-0.0545791239,
0.6642686725,
-0.2121178955,
0.9353512526,
-0.5766650438,
-0.339063555,
-0.1618362367,
-0.2467473149,
0.2551689446,
0.3298735917,
0.6689226031,
-0.4270596504,
-0.445561707,
0.1571150869,
-0.889972508,
-0.1076099277,
0.2602883577,
-0.2854911089,
-0.1365706772,
0.7687793374,
-0.7181791663,
0.080799751,
0.5705597997,
-0.2054304481,
0.6197081804,
-0.0017999952,
-0.2951204181,
-1.182071805,
0.1256261319,
0.1451539546,
-0.1218377054,
-0.7106532454,
0.3570764959,
-0.1119001433,
0.0126989968,
-0.4164301753,
0.8337433338,
-0.4116658568,
-0.0202653669,
-0.3255371153,
0.1850418448,
-0.084608309,
0.2472210377,
-0.0499692373,
0.4819720984,
0.7308307886,
-0.6207485795,
0.3910873532,
0.2598192692,
-0.576836288,
0.6502230763,
-0.78325212,
0.0102595566,
-0.1016731337,
0.2791912258,
-0.4999755025,
-0.4256053269,
0.226079002,
-0.1373829842,
0.1022766382,
-0.368625164,
-0.7469445467,
-0.400144279,
-0.2127599269,
-0.1047804281,
0.524064064,
-0.4474129677,
0.839263618,
0.9234975576,
-0.4363182187,
-0.531339407,
-0.4634835124,
0.5790384412,
-0.2459498644,
-0.6951897144,
0.349437356,
0.0730181783,
-0.5638355613,
-0.0689667091,
-0.2471697032,
-0.0955928117,
0.5778742433,
0.351100266,
0.2944631279,
-0.2396914959,
0.0321329571,
-0.1036761776,
-0.1282904297,
0.2805265188,
-0.2591761649,
0.8923016787,
-0.0710590109,
-0.5836865306,
-0.0488374569,
0.526483655,
0.7171313167,
-0.6576645374,
0.7674615383,
0.1935466081,
-0.3572883904,
-0.5681375861,
-0.4415768981,
-0.0350073837,
-0.555349052,
0.2688019872,
-0.2229711413,
-1.2387434244,
0.5733809471,
-0.0650157407,
0.4278790653,
-0.0430250876,
0.5628086925,
0.0825285912,
1.1011749506,
0.7984269261,
-0.2629424632,
0.8523891568,
0.1602965593,
0.466190666,
-0.7386177778,
-0.3526032269,
-0.6584578156,
-0.1151460633,
-0.3563748598,
-0.1770074964,
0.5610126853,
-0.1058652028,
-0.5165706277,
0.4709366858,
-0.4245354533,
0.3873392642,
0.4458074868,
0.0180650391,
0.2260297388,
0.0336135067,
-0.1562003493,
0.3108919561,
-0.2535201609,
-0.9049041271,
1.0003254414,
0.4593392611,
1.1094857454,
0.3522337377,
0.564809978,
0.0772650912,
0.2676810324,
-0.6658086777,
0.8353548646,
-0.0409320183,
-0.8609864712,
0.0263324901,
-0.3363803029,
-0.8880733848,
0.1661169231,
-0.1242787316,
-0.8155170679,
-0.1573267281,
0.045961827,
-0.4038627148,
0.4390563369,
-0.4772500098,
0.719578445,
-0.7188697457,
-0.4280479252,
-0.3262625635,
-0.4664516449,
0.5464717746,
-0.0974924415,
0.238569662,
-0.2367724478,
0.1527485549,
0.5194840431,
-0.1763151437,
1.0323867798,
-0.1198118478,
-0.4325628877,
0.282278955,
0.1299290955,
0.4239388704,
-0.16194655,
0.1460143477,
0.0480398051,
-0.1325650215,
-0.2109410018,
-0.3926730156,
0.8147540092,
-0.7004483342,
-0.8021710515,
-0.4056991637,
-0.1787207127,
-0.2780555785,
0.1589857936,
-0.4309920669,
0.2743985951,
-0.2777546346,
0.1814134866,
0.8559707403,
-0.3474857211,
0.4586986899,
0.5357772112,
-0.6408050656,
-0.3960509002,
0.4826158881,
0.0829060897,
0.1812726706,
0.2433443218,
0.0680309087,
-0.1287719756,
-1.0367079973,
-0.2819174826,
0.2185616493,
-0.7263674736,
0.001725968,
-0.4378011227,
-0.6366023421,
-0.5207498074,
-0.2289178222,
-0.1829881668,
-0.1287256032,
-0.1221722364,
-0.3359436095,
0.6504744291,
0.9289464355,
-0.0050924364,
0.5443021655,
-0.8359865546,
0.097288087,
0.1543928087,
0.6199173927,
0.1242907196,
-0.343069315,
-0.2057664096,
-0.1691570729,
-0.3383446038,
-0.4124345481,
0.415636152,
-0.3136473,
0.8664134145,
0.193407923,
0.0102982847,
0.3190518618,
-0.6750612855,
0.6936340332,
0.1347916573,
-0.8664014339,
0.5617966056,
-0.402049154,
-0.126923278,
0.2191766202,
0.2934863567,
-0.7804726362,
-0.1546775103,
-0.1483396441,
-1.1221817732,
0.4751368761,
0.1007528752,
0.3137335479,
0.2331396341,
0.0443476066,
-0.3824178576,
-0.0177255739,
-0.5750812888,
0.266345948,
0.0584581941,
-0.2328609228,
-0.1105818301,
-0.0695003718,
-0.3087294102,
0.4199647605,
0.6257348657,
-0.0037486339,
-0.2283897251,
-0.1955457479,
-0.0790904686,
0.1437349468,
0.5379681587,
0.4478362799,
0.372376591,
-0.2468068153,
0.3281460404,
-0.0183633622,
-0.2477224469,
0.3164955676,
-0.2554294765,
-0.2180029452,
-0.1566874981,
0.3721871078,
0.6449486613,
-0.1187533587,
-0.6437619925,
0.3685389757,
0.1702325195,
-0.0398024693,
-0.5501727462,
0.0533332638,
0.2248357236,
0.1597539037,
-0.0307519678,
-0.1174822897,
-0.4052717388,
-0.5135152936,
0.177598536,
0.7711402178,
-0.5884584188,
-0.3827644289,
0.568381846,
0.4556349516,
-0.4042307436,
0.1032754406,
0.2604573071,
-0.5888454318,
0.5993111134,
0.186995402,
1.2178590298,
-0.1348228306,
0.0822368711,
0.131415084,
0.6447893977,
-0.4452571273,
0.1239314005,
0.1128357574,
-0.5906819701,
-0.6210497618,
-0.7129224539,
-0.7594873309,
-0.1003463194,
-0.207128197,
0.3795726597,
-0.9274160862,
-0.3446258307,
-0.2739541829,
-0.3269314766,
-0.0888372734,
-0.2172980458,
0.3937273622,
1.0667046309,
-0.8963189125,
0.6077519655,
0.4167880416,
-0.4485548735,
-0.5807235837,
-0.1361787021,
0.1653561145,
-0.5686001778,
0.7457099557,
0.0290084705,
-0.4231914282,
-0.3550701737,
-0.5810914636,
-0.8228521347,
0.8222681284,
0.4180821776,
-0.424715966,
-0.4229124188,
0.3526546657,
0.6964470744,
-0.0138270156,
0.212352246,
0.4815675914,
0.4162759185,
-0.1015606374,
-0.8186405897,
0.1430209577,
-0.2173655033,
0.0520962961,
0.3993026316,
-0.7337419987,
0.7388696671,
0.4970091283,
-0.3338476419,
0.1472633481,
0.2109034061,
0.2939084172,
-0.1432795823,
0.2402713746,
0.3865334094,
0.229456678,
-0.0772504732,
0.9547595382,
-0.5849584937,
-0.026836196,
1.0555870533,
-0.6530946493,
0.923414588,
0.4790774882,
-0.0193262305,
0.4013816416,
0.4825344086,
0.1606833339,
0.3919863105,
0.3969397545,
-0.5646496415,
-0.3878443241,
-0.5194038749,
-0.2048667967,
0.0798093677,
0.5509946346,
-0.246737808,
-0.3931065202,
-0.290656209,
0.30128178,
0.1741401106,
-0.3311887681,
0.5019873381,
0.5313619375,
-0.7080680132,
0.1216287911,
0.0678467229,
0.8275985122,
-0.9105666876,
0.3018577993,
-0.2850674093,
0.3759620488,
-0.1177923977,
-1.1438363791,
0.3963943422,
0.4493789971,
0.2458288372,
-0.6725847721,
0.4437960088,
-0.0213462338,
-0.3486371934,
0.7063094974,
0.420424372,
-0.2310114205,
0.0227351058,
-0.3637149334,
0.05480491,
-0.4132569134,
-0.1770845354,
0.4531595409,
0.2380467504,
-0.2490037084,
0.9356594086,
0.6815372109,
0.2591297328,
0.1745498627,
0.0475597829,
0.9983130693,
-0.4358528554,
-0.3153434098,
-1.145725131,
0.4837409854,
-0.2175402194,
-0.2542482316,
0.81048733,
0.3577357531,
0.5375943184,
0.095667325,
0.9313988686,
-0.0919337943,
0.2203126848,
-0.5919862986,
0.8994684219,
-0.3258381486,
0.37866956,
-0.3099767566,
-0.7774231434,
-0.6088747978,
0.3794917464,
-0.302316308,
-0.387704432,
0.384452641,
1.0898684263,
-0.0607201494,
-0.158637926,
0.2447178215,
0.0422701575,
0.9727263451,
0.7404591441,
1.1587331295,
-0.1314808875,
0.7601183057,
0.1139961034,
-0.1041452065,
-0.0981768146,
-0.9497635961,
-1.0952892303,
-0.1686348915,
-0.2261529714,
-0.2972070575,
0.0072346404,
0.8846164346,
0.7623710632,
-0.9262938499,
-0.4836319685,
-0.266287297,
0.3200953305,
0.2617350221,
-0.1193446964,
0.1572046578,
-0.1148775741,
-0.3914505243,
0.3737330735,
0.490731895,
0.1204798445,
-0.7358334661,
0.0183826145,
0.0002586353,
0.2296811342,
0.4878520072,
0.2867274582,
-0.6191821098,
-0.4900899827,
0.0369311534,
-0.1517675519,
-0.100595057,
0.6514818072,
-0.2844994366,
0.0481368564,
0.7430859208,
0.7999718189,
0.3901238441,
-0.6744827032,
0.7743101716,
-0.5621494651,
0.0474972501,
0.1907365024,
0.8128335476,
0.3326306641,
0.225443989,
0.5852155089,
-0.1987905055,
-0.4468819201,
-1.0089920759,
0.6724966168,
-0.7866238356,
-0.2083224058,
1.0613470078,
-0.1752893627,
-0.3816302419,
-0.3425446153,
-0.2620935142,
0.033604566,
-0.1504613906,
0.6752769947,
0.8326083422,
0.4274490774,
-0.2570101023,
-0.5342838168,
0.1983412951,
0.1315013766,
-1.0419098139,
0.3321542442,
0.4325188696,
0.3690163493,
0.4211221933,
0.2854571342,
-0.1954880804,
-0.1872294843,
-0.0658485889,
0.3163560927,
0.0697997883,
-0.379385829,
-0.3357865512,
0.2950683534,
0.2877134383,
0.2259582132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01535v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01535v2
|
An Empirical Analysis of Diversity in Argument Summarization
| 2024-02-02T16:26:52 | 2024-02-14T10:51:08 |
Michiel van der Meer, Piek Vossen, Catholijn M. Jonker, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Presenting high-level arguments is a crucial task for fostering participation
in online societal discussions. Current argument summarization approaches miss
an important facet of this task -- capturing diversity -- which is important
for accommodating multiple perspectives. We introduce three aspects of
diversity: those of opinions, annotators, and sources. We evaluate approaches
to a popular argument summarization task called Key Point Analysis, which shows
how these approaches struggle to (1) represent arguments shared by few people,
(2) deal with data from various sources, and (3) align with subjectivity in
human-provided annotations. We find that both general-purpose LLMs and
dedicated KPA models exhibit this behavior, but have complementary strengths.
Further, we observe that diversification of training data may ameliorate
generalization. Addressing diversity in argument summarization requires a mix
of strategies to deal with subjectivity.
|
[
-0.6922365427,
-0.3005366921,
0.533354342,
0.1410388201,
-0.5443130136,
0.1684447378,
-0.1125858352,
-0.3072080314,
0.2755154967,
0.1079371497,
-0.0465542488,
-0.6033480167,
-0.8762857318,
0.1490886509,
-0.1183420271,
1.4062715769,
0.085612528,
0.061714787,
-0.1897346079,
-0.7802452445,
-0.3184666932,
-0.7411034107,
-0.3030300736,
-0.0712695494,
0.8763340116,
0.6680906415,
0.5166199207,
0.4720451236,
0.3213513196,
0.2917916179,
-0.4309628308,
-0.0707984865,
-0.4301611781,
0.3333822787,
-0.1820264161,
-0.5793098807,
-0.2247350663,
-0.1502935588,
0.784566164,
1.0615985394,
0.3069658279,
0.1908235699,
0.0819483772,
0.7509058118,
-0.7259415388,
-0.3221364021,
-0.5284259915,
0.2746199369,
-0.0487437919,
0.1204441562,
0.108743228,
-0.5897064805,
0.4937147796,
-0.4435804784,
0.37962237,
-0.4787186086,
0.6277363896,
-0.0368906073,
-0.8182693124,
-0.5703563094,
-0.7755222321,
0.7835817933,
-0.8182986379,
-0.2207873613,
-0.1218581051,
0.2263606936,
0.3204025626,
-0.4987981319,
-0.1073773727,
0.2753194571,
0.0489813052,
0.3208673596,
-0.1164902747,
-0.0514500365,
0.195592016,
0.4510325491,
-0.1952369362,
0.0900641456,
-0.7696815133,
-0.0303483363,
0.8664901257,
0.1933862567,
0.121848017,
-0.1979605556,
0.0265433472,
0.0129588442,
-0.509291172,
0.2707554102,
0.7665910125,
0.1541962624,
-0.3112485111,
0.5211570859,
-0.4279348552,
0.5073690414,
-0.0334052518,
-0.0648473874,
-0.0382212438,
-0.4250701666,
-0.0016702552,
-0.0362836272,
0.6801594496,
0.6641077995,
0.2516877949,
0.0798143595,
0.3693988621,
-0.2617649436,
-0.039030768,
-0.8454999924,
-0.0309847631,
0.3600229621,
-0.9410930872,
-0.2935873866,
0.11424312,
-1.1589528322,
-0.654014051,
-0.0338919722,
-0.1349498928,
0.1256877482,
-0.154036954,
-0.1755504012,
-0.7426810265,
0.2711121142,
0.5102876425,
-0.8529034257,
0.3369454145,
0.8229491711,
1.0083460808,
-0.3419548273,
-0.0490158461,
-0.0657916069,
0.0958143473,
-0.2130205631,
1.1192804575,
-0.560787499,
-0.6959210038,
-0.0100868214,
-0.276491642,
0.1763851643,
-0.5597920418,
0.633823216,
-0.1984343082,
0.3898253143,
-0.9073905349,
-0.7405253649,
-0.3292556107,
0.1847643256,
-0.5978768468,
0.3831035793,
-0.2311244905,
-0.7636734843,
0.8202041984,
-0.8948507309,
-0.5151222348,
0.0688527301,
-0.3684249222,
-0.3929667473,
0.4341546595,
0.2915815413,
0.42813766,
0.1327376962,
0.0522516333,
-0.5033431649,
-0.3344281018,
0.3415999711,
-0.0263321288,
0.7478196621,
0.2614340484,
-0.168649137,
0.1490512639,
-0.549587667,
-0.496031642,
0.0534241125,
-0.4097921848,
-0.4081325233,
0.3721191585,
-0.1865106076,
0.1031199172,
0.0355145223,
-0.40388906,
0.2412891984,
-0.3726635575,
0.4132738113,
0.5519387722,
0.4316161871,
0.3365425766,
-0.4003995657,
0.4547660947,
0.1629614234,
-0.0675647557,
-0.278052628,
-0.9086053371,
-0.4845165312,
-0.2707557976,
0.2183492184,
0.4039589167,
0.1458085328,
-0.055653315,
-0.3035201132,
-0.5020873547,
-0.2319210321,
0.171799913,
-0.0788154081,
-0.0491743572,
0.0707320496,
-0.2019903362,
-0.6201491356,
-0.963478446,
-0.8073154092,
-0.2154099643,
-0.1836456358,
0.2813691795,
0.54688555,
0.1619018465,
1.1258362532,
-0.3098600507,
0.0612151399,
-0.6008046269,
0.5707928538,
0.1394304931,
0.2576645315,
0.6698943377,
-0.6257231832,
-0.4365099072,
-0.0614734814,
-0.8839761615,
-0.0573813394,
-0.2234242409,
0.1158460006,
-0.2573629022,
0.0567058995,
-0.5005722642,
0.2846702337,
0.129192248,
-0.1726717353,
-0.0510197952,
0.1252707541,
0.2222909629,
-1.1845293045,
-0.1548923552,
0.1791760474,
0.0254237633,
-0.6345270872,
0.0764795542,
-0.5111325979,
-0.3230193853,
-0.1534131169,
0.2817237377,
-0.2849232554,
-0.0608107485,
-0.5459949374,
0.2294591814,
-0.0344217606,
0.1943896562,
0.0059909909,
0.2126511782,
0.1267160773,
-0.3333811164,
0.1936805844,
0.0539949536,
-0.0258441269,
0.8512340784,
-0.8167319298,
-0.0398585275,
-0.3846997321,
0.3046799004,
-1.2065534592,
-0.5278637409,
0.1740425229,
-0.3420538902,
-0.1080837846,
-0.2891412079,
0.1390510947,
-0.0793983191,
-0.8488119245,
0.5539759398,
0.2697750926,
-0.264862895,
0.8117291927,
0.5869429708,
-0.5692985058,
-0.5080378056,
-0.3999733329,
0.2755889893,
-0.7271965146,
-0.5659633875,
0.2171288431,
0.0138589609,
-0.7547603846,
-0.0389260128,
-0.0538926832,
-0.0061107222,
0.3419336975,
0.4199668765,
-0.0932619721,
-0.2176785767,
0.1041977033,
0.1272556931,
0.1081058681,
0.1313840002,
0.1042559445,
0.1840396821,
-0.1680263877,
-0.4945810735,
-0.0789901167,
1.0607329607,
0.4342373908,
0.1915573478,
0.4105015695,
0.2261299789,
-0.1787590235,
0.0598553829,
-0.540653944,
0.1049204469,
-0.3574775159,
0.4692775905,
-0.0196360778,
-0.9340954423,
0.764760077,
-0.0212402642,
0.8440354466,
0.557323277,
0.7891082764,
-0.4111165404,
0.8688468337,
0.2282333225,
-0.0357597992,
0.3581015468,
-0.0461525135,
0.2528775334,
-0.4724756777,
0.0673505738,
-0.5982617736,
-0.6938528419,
-0.4644188881,
-0.0621764921,
0.1186170653,
0.1252802014,
-0.1186776087,
-0.2545704544,
-0.3556033373,
0.5703300834,
0.4161754251,
-0.2074781507,
0.4006847143,
0.0215028413,
0.2989065349,
-0.1713837832,
-0.5855757594,
-0.7946528196,
1.3605008125,
0.5859197974,
0.2985031009,
0.2219032943,
1.0597082376,
0.3440822363,
0.6472488046,
-0.9388790131,
0.5210452676,
-0.102314584,
-0.6699752212,
-0.2066626102,
-0.3114040792,
-0.8893098235,
0.815531075,
-0.1460584253,
-0.7445341349,
0.4446902275,
0.059426222,
-0.4962972105,
0.338945955,
-0.5768696666,
0.8555047512,
0.0326172113,
0.1178059429,
-0.1620197445,
-0.6034611464,
0.6889249086,
0.2434018999,
0.314525187,
-0.0639499426,
0.1134187356,
1.1355938911,
-0.3088795543,
0.8887221217,
-0.3451752365,
-0.0232105199,
0.4404939711,
-0.4848070145,
0.0642568618,
0.0603290722,
0.3306463659,
0.0487994142,
-0.1039204225,
-0.5035114288,
-0.508310318,
0.3928682804,
-0.9621181488,
-0.858499527,
-0.2524272203,
-0.5552466512,
-0.177664876,
-0.3654331267,
0.2866475582,
0.2023217976,
-0.2643030584,
0.6024693847,
0.4887993634,
0.0715576485,
0.5701513886,
0.0476014838,
0.1603950709,
-0.8371568322,
0.9419500232,
0.5124511719,
0.1207270697,
-0.0701217875,
0.5406365395,
0.0234145932,
-0.7543031573,
-0.0945167765,
0.1072730422,
-1.3526026011,
0.1103380024,
-0.9769185185,
0.2182095796,
-0.2887302041,
-0.4594621062,
-0.0607957207,
-0.7739813328,
-0.156115219,
-0.3863559961,
0.1781816185,
0.7069770098,
-0.0346895307,
0.55548805,
-0.7353698015,
0.4103565812,
0.7947801352,
-0.0426507853,
0.052601777,
-0.2244886607,
-0.1045652479,
-0.1686228812,
-0.5931432843,
-1.3538745642,
-0.2353043556,
0.1612374634,
0.7794902921,
0.5914562345,
-0.0758154392,
0.5447461009,
0.1534842253,
1.2083387375,
0.0954788849,
-0.8213891983,
0.5263180733,
-0.2299087942,
0.232613802,
0.6934920549,
0.4191318452,
-0.5100643635,
-0.6331059337,
-0.5538287163,
-0.9299758673,
0.2892329395,
0.0514963418,
0.050050322,
0.0834161565,
-0.0390280522,
0.1928933114,
0.1389323473,
-0.9299476743,
0.0270732623,
-0.6113506556,
-0.4869259894,
0.2858039141,
-0.3193053901,
-0.6505789757,
-0.1081985012,
0.1999432594,
-0.1315108538,
-0.1230311841,
0.1263703853,
-0.1773380637,
0.1181506515,
0.6869657636,
0.941668272,
0.8619247079,
-0.1702400893,
0.0592753291,
0.3050969541,
-0.3709181249,
0.1752327085,
-0.0457565151,
-0.3283801973,
0.3886582255,
0.76598382,
0.7786210179,
0.1681715697,
-0.3422044814,
0.4473047853,
-0.1065631434,
-0.3841553628,
0.1204911247,
-0.1014181003,
0.3145079613,
0.3287953734,
0.5091950893,
-0.042370379,
0.1881951541,
-0.7209047079,
-0.1904885769,
0.5463154912,
0.0308193639,
-0.2403260767,
0.3615885377,
0.5077329874,
-0.1817529052,
-0.138215363,
0.1577870548,
-0.4594708979,
0.7992309928,
0.0996537805,
1.0859519243,
0.1564410478,
0.1916267127,
0.2707713842,
0.1782401502,
0.2340885103,
0.2806774676,
-0.3432151973,
-0.4634266198,
-0.2453924865,
-0.1616298407,
-0.7468671799,
-0.2113478184,
-0.5337016582,
-0.0468573421,
-0.5340068936,
-0.160912782,
0.1115183234,
-0.0767494962,
-0.406180948,
-0.0018461497,
0.1716955155,
0.5108222365,
-1.113124609,
0.0168875363,
0.7004489303,
-0.4730497301,
-0.259323597,
0.3225987256,
-0.1029983312,
-0.2655726373,
0.8818440437,
0.017160669,
0.1063158214,
-0.5465804338,
-0.5682159662,
-0.5401360393,
0.9310208559,
0.1365875006,
-0.2681223154,
0.1696698368,
0.3362205923,
0.3465994895,
-0.7458696365,
0.2302405685,
0.3154250085,
0.4913998246,
0.0561235994,
-0.2718693018,
-0.0373523794,
-0.1148637906,
0.0476151481,
-0.3333735466,
-0.4767099321,
0.9626554251,
-0.2139645964,
-0.3095646203,
-0.2926821709,
0.8101606369,
0.5975962281,
0.6273314953,
0.4719055891,
0.3265267611,
0.566467464,
0.1007921621,
0.7017400861,
-0.1120729521,
0.3373588026,
1.0842957497,
-0.4441273212,
0.6356834769,
0.4992767572,
-0.3528383374,
0.3916436136,
0.6925526857,
-0.111977376,
0.2830113471,
0.2054324746,
-0.2302520573,
-0.2350848168,
0.0364041738,
-0.591945231,
0.3511595428,
0.2812797427,
-0.3703635931,
-0.5933933258,
-0.1648109853,
0.0045763063,
-0.0348464884,
-0.3834488988,
1.0777416229,
0.0193156693,
-0.6277347803,
0.0403957032,
-0.0879598409,
0.5974316597,
-0.4068968892,
-0.0528092422,
-0.4763788283,
-0.329831928,
-0.3826730847,
-0.75556916,
0.2570678592,
0.286439985,
-0.251903832,
0.2311258018,
0.8373791575,
-0.0127638113,
-0.419077754,
-0.1284002811,
0.411288321,
0.1427436918,
0.0882422328,
-0.2110244036,
-0.035488598,
-0.2260142267,
-0.2407499701,
0.3477923572,
0.419097513,
-0.1626098752,
0.229896307,
0.5034270883,
0.0796770826,
0.3094237447,
0.1048204899,
0.7800601125,
-0.7242534757,
-0.5412253737,
-1.1954472065,
0.7816633582,
-0.7751877308,
-0.7099819183,
0.76498276,
0.4793971181,
0.3675285578,
-0.1335113049,
1.0168100595,
0.2975465655,
0.5053144693,
-0.0823787749,
0.4067326188,
-0.2802326977,
0.1301790625,
-0.2482039928,
-0.9918279052,
-0.2785674334,
0.4810532928,
-0.2134163976,
-0.0018978565,
0.450443387,
0.1247892752,
-0.0530913994,
0.3523446321,
0.11842639,
-0.1800044924,
0.4452192485,
0.3892043829,
1.1464365721,
-0.1808872372,
0.5675604939,
-0.0227528717,
-0.3494996727,
-0.5003323555,
-1.0114809275,
-1.021604538,
-0.0620453581,
-0.6260792613,
0.0140056415,
-0.2541404068,
1.0749126673,
0.5516861677,
-1.0952825546,
-0.4415518343,
0.100247778,
0.4362737834,
-0.1536138356,
-0.158572346,
-0.0098739052,
-0.3623233438,
-0.4254420996,
0.0998799279,
0.3334380686,
-0.1713849455,
-0.334723413,
0.0619480796,
-0.0132526308,
0.3232536614,
0.5640947819,
0.5820690989,
-0.9089831114,
-0.2317619473,
-0.4481184185,
0.1649805754,
0.3123168945,
1.2360845804,
-0.2230773717,
0.3358070254,
0.6876171231,
0.7913718224,
0.2956807315,
0.289326787,
0.6793441772,
-0.7278913856,
0.018594807,
0.3053229451,
0.6333951354,
0.3307839632,
-0.049720645,
0.3210659921,
0.44372648,
-0.4179669917,
-0.7650406361,
0.220545724,
-1.0292278528,
-0.4620860815,
0.9189046025,
-0.4302125275,
0.2336329073,
-0.3069052994,
-0.2725909948,
0.0526642911,
-0.3230200708,
0.9580210447,
1.1969209909,
-0.1243443564,
-0.2248422801,
-0.331392467,
0.3351902962,
0.3322001398,
-1.090182662,
0.1101320609,
0.537366569,
0.2306409478,
0.3899572492,
0.4859560132,
0.0146911107,
0.2165586948,
-0.1533363461,
-0.2874179482,
0.2405813634,
-0.0654716939,
-0.5376902819,
0.966186583,
0.1299622208,
-0.2516392171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01528v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01528v2
|
Decoding Speculative Decoding
| 2024-02-02T16:15:24 | 2024-04-26T04:52:57 |
Minghao Yan, Saurabh Agarwal, Shivaram Venkataraman
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Speculative Decoding is a widely used technique to speed up inference for
Large Language Models (LLMs) without sacrificing quality. When performing
inference, speculative decoding uses a smaller draft model to generate
speculative tokens and then uses the target LLM to verify those draft tokens.
The speedup provided by speculative decoding heavily depends on the choice of
the draft model. In this work, we perform a detailed study comprising over 350
experiments with LLaMA-65B and OPT-66B using speculative decoding and delineate
the factors that affect the performance gain provided by speculative decoding.
Our experiments indicate that the performance of speculative decoding depends
heavily on the latency of the draft model, and the draft model's capability in
language modeling does not correlate strongly with its performance in
speculative decoding. Based on these insights we explore a new design space for
draft models and design hardware-efficient draft models for speculative
decoding. Our newly designed draft model for LLaMA-65B can provide 60% higher
throughput than existing draft models and can generalize further to the LLaMA-2
model family and supervised fine-tuned models.
|
[
-0.1714778095,
-0.6750139594,
0.4888186455,
0.4323405027,
-0.5313901901,
0.4221333861,
0.1169576049,
-0.9887959361,
0.2769024968,
0.6677655578,
-0.3245356679,
-0.1769204736,
-0.585136354,
0.2194667011,
-0.3711025417,
0.4047472477,
-0.1143164113,
-0.2182369679,
0.0296493936,
0.6182169914,
-0.1284200698,
-0.7642552257,
-0.4807003438,
-0.0742598623,
0.0692354888,
0.3080749512,
0.6847980022,
0.7035993934,
0.5607925057,
0.2273409069,
-0.3368820846,
0.1474759132,
-0.740850687,
0.0243801735,
0.292973876,
-1.0090031624,
-0.8135271072,
-0.3795266151,
0.5520560145,
0.3882085681,
0.0143631473,
0.1186232641,
-0.5602450371,
0.3466459513,
-0.837625742,
0.1552367955,
-0.7735586762,
-0.0145439794,
-0.6098979712,
-0.5298519731,
-0.9102774262,
-0.2347118556,
-0.2046778947,
-0.6033895612,
0.4162673056,
0.3559108973,
0.5483540297,
0.2142180949,
-0.2586013377,
-0.0280321203,
-0.7322130799,
0.5917816758,
-0.9773245454,
0.5644887686,
0.6429067254,
-0.0347885974,
-0.2178505957,
-0.5694346428,
-0.564858973,
-0.1315155327,
0.1149805486,
0.0519118384,
-0.2628023624,
0.2317976952,
0.3620268404,
0.3489514887,
-0.4377114177,
0.2647045553,
-0.5251603723,
-0.3796631694,
0.5642954111,
0.3889499903,
-0.1055021361,
-0.2187138498,
-0.1855448037,
-0.0745916069,
-0.6521083117,
0.0645694137,
0.6571106911,
-0.1001849845,
-0.1447643042,
0.5688000321,
-0.5696647763,
0.6357061267,
0.0589206964,
-0.0938770026,
0.0845222473,
-0.3849206865,
-0.096200943,
0.0939911678,
0.4171667993,
0.4096746743,
-0.192543745,
-0.452980727,
-0.3013352454,
0.5549294949,
0.2203986943,
-0.9039145708,
-0.2398918718,
0.2393076122,
-0.8616502881,
-0.4569885731,
-0.2172360122,
-0.5087914467,
0.0487477891,
0.1520738751,
-0.1262843758,
-0.4647979736,
-0.4783407152,
0.8128584623,
-0.4151598811,
0.2053793818,
0.215009883,
-1.1666078568,
0.4102126956,
0.6220234036,
0.654311955,
-0.3429048657,
-0.1289879233,
-0.1244096383,
0.223131299,
-0.7700724602,
1.1921930313,
-0.8207754493,
-0.6343619227,
-0.2650780678,
-0.3681773841,
0.0279359221,
-0.2381620109,
0.8292109966,
-1.2026028633,
-0.518422246,
-0.4351356328,
-0.5833184719,
-0.1240843087,
-0.1014946252,
-0.9001514316,
0.6960719824,
-0.0632448494,
-0.8613300323,
0.5877224803,
-0.3639891148,
-0.3788018525,
0.135945186,
0.0507357344,
0.0658207163,
0.550117135,
0.2136509567,
0.3660179377,
-0.3695759475,
0.022539692,
-0.3958004713,
-1.1424168348,
0.3654674888,
-0.6326220632,
0.2865768969,
0.5822198391,
0.0880582705,
-0.3229602575,
-0.7119031549,
0.1083354428,
0.1068818569,
-0.722155869,
-0.157141462,
0.2026822865,
0.0086039137,
-0.224293083,
0.0831966922,
-0.5041922331,
0.2645579278,
-0.5065924525,
0.3683659732,
0.5312936306,
-0.112348713,
0.3313141465,
-0.3463979959,
0.7008721232,
-0.0371440798,
-0.0969519243,
-0.2565573752,
-0.2786870301,
-0.7977011204,
-0.1351299584,
0.3266387582,
0.3362461329,
-0.8536666036,
-0.0202110261,
-0.0832876638,
-0.4130189419,
-0.5992687345,
-0.1531369686,
0.2274916768,
0.087297745,
0.1943803579,
0.0016804113,
-0.7682389021,
-0.6978788972,
-0.3212254941,
-0.4404245317,
0.3719509542,
0.1903035343,
0.1215939075,
-0.4265041947,
0.451684624,
-0.4275633395,
0.5497519374,
-0.4375000596,
-0.130043,
0.3220903873,
0.3143651187,
0.7776063085,
-0.4475803673,
0.0525150597,
-0.065451391,
-0.6856151223,
-0.0021623774,
-0.0868731737,
-0.2750071883,
0.4129822254,
0.6824381351,
-0.7847567797,
0.3075663447,
0.6479870677,
-0.3858815134,
0.7364131808,
-0.173828274,
0.3666411042,
-0.7973504663,
-0.0516357571,
-0.4237982333,
0.1973806024,
-0.4197484851,
0.3260159194,
0.207137078,
0.22908099,
-0.3935871422,
0.1916469485,
-0.4953962862,
0.0377183743,
-0.372422725,
-0.4632046223,
0.1059177294,
0.1018680558,
0.2230344266,
1.1278299093,
0.3572963774,
-0.4997633398,
0.027817864,
-0.1002465859,
-0.3298229873,
-0.3048832715,
-0.7790419459,
0.2983466685,
-0.1444151253,
0.5450422764,
-0.9341686964,
-0.3120999038,
0.0673830956,
-0.0893726796,
0.1560771763,
-0.0991105288,
-0.612105906,
-0.6134870648,
-0.1926886588,
0.9817216396,
0.438772738,
-0.3030595481,
0.4832383096,
0.2303992659,
0.1531738043,
-0.7095296979,
-0.8210465312,
0.1144689173,
0.0054822029,
-0.7351542711,
0.555190742,
-0.1270234734,
-0.2031296492,
0.0000741581,
-0.0482911766,
0.0572956912,
0.0957124308,
0.1849645674,
0.3865505457,
-0.4467812777,
-0.1193981916,
0.4674758017,
-0.3540600538,
0.1861342639,
-0.3728741407,
0.5381333232,
-0.1003844365,
-0.1832377762,
-0.3313922286,
0.6622444987,
0.4688376188,
-0.0693356693,
0.4987093806,
0.1599654406,
-0.2426217645,
-0.4884878695,
-0.8107740283,
-0.1538598835,
-0.5423697233,
0.3781014085,
-0.8271384239,
-0.8658052087,
0.6853408217,
-0.0855296254,
-0.0072762896,
0.4098103642,
0.5333906412,
0.1359814554,
0.6464028955,
0.9451512098,
0.17385526,
0.260935843,
-0.3117737174,
0.027004689,
-0.5513874888,
-0.3740861118,
-0.5604823828,
-0.2423654497,
-0.2471167743,
-0.7804233432,
-0.2373687327,
0.0757575035,
0.2904509306,
0.2245100439,
-0.1209721118,
0.768114388,
0.3726834357,
0.1949554682,
0.5472098589,
0.2277004868,
-0.2567085028,
-0.0108125051,
-0.9847085476,
-0.5406655073,
1.2179092169,
0.3584759831,
1.3027794361,
0.0872193798,
0.5058373809,
0.3282458484,
-0.0904858336,
-0.6818165779,
0.5235334635,
-0.4093987048,
-0.5839334726,
0.2179837376,
-0.2767799199,
-0.5851389766,
0.26011917,
-0.2026471645,
-0.5415884256,
0.4935392141,
0.2729799151,
-0.4505486488,
0.4920864403,
-0.8466238379,
0.2301249802,
0.0701099411,
-0.22646451,
-0.4757792354,
-0.1718942225,
0.7834477425,
-0.0782656223,
-0.2912349105,
0.0056518079,
0.0748740286,
0.8503632545,
-0.0960861295,
0.8061496019,
0.2921050191,
-0.2205681652,
0.3010480702,
0.4874853194,
0.565192461,
0.2495261878,
-0.7493389845,
0.3163053691,
0.2069370002,
-0.4658110142,
-0.2379748225,
0.4898381829,
-1.0603581667,
-0.6087818742,
-0.2304255813,
-0.6565467119,
-0.1668618172,
0.0542522818,
0.6204488277,
0.40988639,
-0.1244845465,
0.018743014,
0.6550459266,
0.0159745459,
0.4473796487,
0.4140193164,
0.0103974734,
0.1187970117,
0.7061830759,
0.0375097506,
0.323652029,
0.6285803914,
-0.2711810172,
-0.3668248951,
-1.1268305779,
-0.2891112566,
0.2434705645,
-0.7142912745,
-0.1187070161,
-0.769836545,
-0.1611139476,
-0.2737216055,
-0.2507331669,
-0.5180491805,
-0.465397805,
-0.4695433378,
-0.2792333663,
0.3994035125,
0.7098985314,
0.0147653725,
0.469119221,
-0.6462985873,
0.4329547882,
-0.2158100307,
0.4086579084,
0.2801044583,
-0.6554880738,
-0.0958841071,
-0.0791739002,
0.0553550087,
-0.7168518305,
0.2726458013,
-0.233969003,
0.5794952512,
0.4893107414,
0.2455123514,
0.7200942636,
-0.2621815205,
0.5184136033,
-0.255656749,
-0.8754396439,
0.3527276218,
-0.3723995984,
0.291560322,
0.3273021877,
0.1515894234,
-0.092932798,
-0.2498582751,
-0.4389036298,
-0.6483889818,
0.7046614885,
-0.0891220123,
0.204461664,
-0.0677761361,
0.5650022626,
0.5104420781,
-0.0260324199,
-0.1905187219,
0.0169887897,
-0.1534353495,
0.2801766992,
-0.1083001718,
-0.9082357883,
0.1778146029,
0.0612712242,
0.1544748694,
-0.1083531827,
0.5051925778,
-0.0078349207,
0.0589316003,
-0.291988045,
0.2271223515,
0.5339529514,
0.4716449678,
-0.4397891462,
0.2800187767,
0.1659209281,
-0.5884452462,
0.1642537862,
-0.1041913033,
-0.2213641256,
-0.031910304,
0.596029222,
0.9941404462,
0.2433658689,
-0.5356337428,
-0.0891025439,
-0.5020895004,
-0.3514046669,
0.117162317,
0.4434993267,
0.0744704679,
0.2997881174,
0.3891311586,
0.5717693567,
0.3538668156,
-0.3333113492,
0.022031974,
0.2758069038,
0.3998220563,
-0.5640364885,
0.809959054,
0.2621017694,
-0.0889559984,
0.7216433287,
-0.203706041,
-0.2398166507,
0.6366260648,
1.0417131186,
0.6090697646,
0.3608750999,
0.1816501468,
0.070052132,
0.4106207788,
-0.1600343287,
0.6083979607,
-0.1804917902,
-0.6834616661,
-0.7512694597,
-0.7854481339,
-0.4168969691,
-0.188749671,
-0.5382143855,
-0.1424338222,
-0.4491446316,
-0.4687837064,
-0.3745978475,
0.0206431616,
-0.7104054093,
-0.0056212903,
0.0627354681,
1.3107727766,
-0.5203247666,
0.8179581165,
0.3742809892,
0.3155231476,
-0.9845300913,
0.1388829499,
-0.2146345079,
-0.7872652411,
0.7072601914,
-0.0824374408,
-0.3982761204,
-0.0294112451,
-0.2312249094,
-1.1776839495,
0.9214087725,
0.6418391466,
-0.6778364182,
-0.2639895678,
-0.0903921947,
0.3926950097,
-0.2601637542,
0.4535957575,
0.6088533998,
0.0871272236,
0.3546888828,
-0.6587769389,
0.2295900732,
-0.5441723466,
0.1600573808,
-0.0864541605,
-0.8600254655,
0.9261515141,
-0.681296587,
-0.3080218434,
0.2855584323,
0.737308383,
0.5006239414,
-0.0731812343,
0.1330046803,
0.3513532877,
0.7210765481,
-0.0768654868,
1.3874329329,
-0.3394603729,
-0.0910252482,
0.4690822661,
-0.1738408506,
1.2140122652,
0.4646205306,
-0.1757740527,
0.3677587509,
0.7350279093,
0.2429924011,
0.5180171728,
-0.0789818689,
-0.1422108561,
-0.5707461834,
-0.0684745312,
-0.6955376267,
0.6035653949,
0.558496654,
-0.1312027276,
0.0502848066,
-0.4660591781,
-0.1491796225,
-0.3391591311,
-0.1255365759,
0.3012117147,
0.0736614242,
-0.6778408885,
0.796646595,
0.3608919978,
0.9192991257,
-0.6290190816,
0.2293618172,
-0.2691241503,
0.2554903328,
-0.1372251064,
-0.5254593492,
0.2720589936,
-0.1631264687,
-0.5013176799,
-0.0055202651,
0.7987641096,
0.1356189102,
-0.7624724507,
0.375346899,
0.396365732,
0.155776754,
0.2012551278,
-0.1679704636,
1.0505582094,
-0.1905130446,
-0.2920590341,
0.0457780063,
0.460788846,
-0.0266892612,
0.7098389864,
1.0577722788,
0.3264681101,
0.2672118545,
0.0650340617,
1.0666315556,
-0.6692842245,
-0.8748739362,
-0.7649934888,
0.1931630373,
0.2903118432,
-0.3130387962,
0.6801230907,
0.2502911091,
0.7045764327,
-0.3208960593,
0.7893974185,
0.2271569371,
-0.1182286739,
-0.9496927261,
0.4976003766,
-0.1723781824,
0.4415906072,
-0.3337451816,
-0.5847156048,
-0.0099586295,
0.3341421485,
-0.1439451128,
0.0678829476,
0.5485543013,
0.856756866,
0.0531156138,
0.4447548687,
0.3528402448,
0.2706101537,
0.3371043205,
0.862159431,
1.0875425339,
-0.527916491,
0.4253031015,
-0.1949135065,
-0.2059789598,
-0.4447992742,
-0.8009986877,
-1.015042901,
-0.1535369754,
0.0928056762,
-0.138748616,
0.1980946213,
0.3595243096,
1.008177042,
-0.4542781711,
-0.3395947218,
-0.0075286287,
-0.0531166829,
-0.1874680519,
-0.1634180099,
0.1938241422,
-0.0585043319,
-0.4671174884,
0.7155974507,
0.1268200725,
0.1918360889,
-0.084797062,
-0.1202500686,
0.1962869614,
0.3499422967,
0.652418077,
0.1051605344,
-0.8962354064,
0.2251159102,
0.4467331469,
0.0769881383,
-0.3422967494,
1.0668206215,
-0.9942452908,
0.2219533473,
0.7554681897,
0.7502382398,
0.7198621631,
0.1165749133,
0.7362840772,
-0.1428188831,
0.5222432613,
0.1464121938,
0.2825500369,
-0.1577219367,
-0.7463487387,
0.0584340692,
0.2769988775,
-0.315987587,
-0.8456388116,
0.0579859167,
-1.0696947575,
-0.3614926934,
1.1022313833,
0.1591723561,
-0.2269435078,
0.0124739418,
-0.2523956895,
-0.1964817345,
-0.6722384095,
0.7904430032,
0.58063519,
-0.1634304971,
-0.1004401669,
-0.4789630175,
0.3865526617,
0.3482584059,
-0.5639352202,
0.1599400938,
0.3066984713,
0.0143735679,
-0.0095792525,
0.8671904206,
0.0355724096,
0.5990120769,
0.8037825227,
-0.5276918411,
-0.2447779924,
-0.3678589165,
0.0807987899,
0.4687778354,
0.3029144406,
0.2533671856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01521v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01521v1
|
K-Level Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-02T16:07:05 | 2024-02-02T16:07:05 |
Yadong Zhang, Shaoguang Mao, Tao Ge, Xun Wang, Yan Xia, Man Lan, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their proficiency in
complex reasoning tasks, their performance in dynamic, interactive, and
competitive scenarios - such as business strategy and stock market analysis -
remains underexplored. To bridge this gap, we formally explore the dynamic
reasoning capabilities of LLMs for decision-making in rapidly evolving
environments. We introduce two game theory-based pilot challenges that mirror
the complexities of real-world dynamic decision-making. These challenges are
well-defined, enabling clear, controllable, and precise evaluation of LLMs'
dynamic reasoning abilities. Through extensive experiments, we find that
existing reasoning methods tend to falter in dynamic settings that require
k-level thinking - a key concept not tackled by previous works. To address
this, we propose a novel reasoning approach for LLMs, named "K-Level
Reasoning". This approach adopts the perspective of rivals to recursively
employ k-level thinking based on available historical information, which
significantly improves the prediction accuracy of rivals' subsequent moves and
informs more strategic decision-making. This research not only sets a robust
quantitative benchmark for the assessment of dynamic reasoning but also
markedly enhances the proficiency of LLMs in dynamic contexts.
|
[
-0.3103915751,
-0.9374138713,
1.0793888569,
0.0957206339,
0.0802968964,
0.8900460005,
-0.3620580137,
-0.5330678821,
-0.1306292713,
0.181660682,
-0.8383817077,
-0.4544964433,
-0.3850588202,
-0.0607472844,
-0.0113847964,
0.3528619111,
-0.2404250801,
-0.1576884836,
-0.1319392771,
-0.0613495968,
-0.6967372298,
-0.4585778713,
-0.7371228337,
-0.5046437383,
0.5991404653,
0.48711586,
0.836869657,
0.4700419307,
0.3867523372,
0.3208142221,
-0.4496897757,
0.1794209182,
-0.6413518786,
0.9593075514,
-0.3387302458,
-0.6444370747,
-0.1517856419,
-0.1914786249,
0.727214396,
0.6689581275,
-0.2169202566,
-0.1272795945,
-0.3738102317,
0.6535156369,
-0.500007391,
0.4506859481,
-0.9280760884,
0.261066556,
0.1907254905,
-0.118650414,
-0.3792107403,
-0.1554968953,
0.4243099391,
-0.7370798588,
-0.459215194,
0.0980493724,
0.7364499569,
0.2066562176,
-0.5475807786,
-0.4462159872,
-1.0608654022,
0.556806922,
-0.5606554151,
0.6679219604,
-0.0610402524,
0.7206483483,
-0.4876761138,
-0.6067556739,
-0.3323039711,
-0.5481039882,
0.2294948995,
0.0947209224,
-0.0583722107,
-0.1898498833,
0.4673791528,
0.0267433412,
-0.2302343249,
0.270108372,
-0.0739601105,
0.1465268284,
0.7307769656,
0.3454075456,
0.0750131384,
0.1150531024,
-0.050987944,
0.0034521823,
-0.5092174411,
0.2230368108,
0.1931460202,
0.2136072367,
0.0276760068,
0.2971464694,
-0.3589527905,
0.3059652746,
0.3221669495,
-0.2656707168,
-0.1258769929,
-0.0424338356,
-0.1098834276,
0.0829558596,
0.318074286,
0.3203294575,
0.3994154334,
-0.304436326,
-0.0990480259,
0.0105919745,
0.1481954455,
-0.5070013404,
-0.2423969954,
0.3689910471,
-0.4427134395,
-0.5081607103,
-0.4057511091,
-1.0634570122,
-0.6411216259,
-0.2661066353,
0.4460830986,
-0.2381270677,
-0.303229928,
0.2588267624,
-0.1755620688,
0.3043662906,
0.5594243407,
-0.6190005541,
-0.0033085619,
0.8193064332,
0.6311931014,
-0.1451282352,
-0.2020243406,
-0.3208814561,
0.4296975136,
-0.605175972,
0.7745087147,
-0.7805300355,
-0.4086264968,
0.0212940127,
-0.2197876126,
0.2293269336,
-0.8008158803,
0.4653560221,
-0.7161111236,
0.0722567439,
-0.3412341774,
-0.512316525,
-0.0326635428,
0.74161762,
-0.4077299833,
0.9392091036,
-0.2048168629,
-0.3925455809,
0.6716008186,
-0.5190297365,
-0.5140373707,
0.3813209832,
-0.3483193219,
-0.2584344447,
-0.0971176848,
0.087208882,
0.268661052,
-0.2096337527,
0.2819555998,
-0.5497668386,
-0.2047959864,
0.1769506335,
-0.0963956267,
0.39887923,
0.1493738294,
-0.4598849416,
0.0473430827,
-0.7430679798,
0.2179049551,
0.404832989,
-0.5032821298,
-0.1811907291,
0.4712364078,
-0.9778026342,
0.2431302518,
0.3462707102,
-0.1707131267,
0.6700671315,
-0.199791044,
0.5271572471,
0.7261958122,
0.0623496436,
0.518722713,
-0.2125700265,
0.6730965972,
-0.140175879,
0.1344702244,
-0.1546688825,
-0.4234101176,
-0.6727795005,
-0.0984095559,
0.2291835994,
0.6803195477,
-0.839278698,
0.0645576119,
-0.2316785902,
-0.6881124377,
-0.2251537591,
-0.3351346552,
-0.0269532092,
0.1216880754,
0.0874834806,
0.397849381,
-0.5186424255,
-0.6715031266,
-0.5370835066,
-0.2282253653,
0.2735745609,
0.5773748159,
0.4949091077,
-0.1034638286,
0.4869743586,
-0.6350841522,
0.2471478879,
-0.408492744,
0.0749016255,
0.1759857088,
0.2405903935,
0.1435021311,
-0.6891310215,
-0.4393976927,
0.2316403538,
-0.7629051805,
-0.162218675,
-0.5452270508,
-0.3424386382,
-0.014845863,
0.8908146024,
-0.7089451551,
0.0537474714,
0.1553433985,
-0.4801312387,
0.7430950999,
-0.376775682,
0.1871346086,
-0.6584236026,
-0.2710890174,
-0.0086887386,
-0.1086299568,
-0.5147333145,
0.4833959043,
-0.2504847944,
-0.0504551753,
0.0465615019,
0.5514524579,
-0.4831762016,
-0.1352322549,
-0.1557355374,
0.2305944264,
-0.2173658162,
0.4258739054,
0.1024959385,
0.3399988115,
0.5336855054,
-0.4196148813,
0.7602750063,
-0.062062975,
-0.8488954306,
0.5829771757,
-0.3764013946,
-0.1117473319,
-0.1404821277,
0.4480561316,
-0.9823297858,
-0.0306799356,
0.0462107398,
-0.4488177598,
0.1965299398,
-0.2107665837,
-0.5934247971,
-0.4926941097,
0.1329527348,
0.3674389422,
0.5766960382,
-0.2988482118,
0.7317905426,
0.2060254663,
-0.2577167153,
-0.3234695494,
-0.4098227918,
0.1527683884,
-0.4154756665,
-0.3531983793,
0.2272438854,
-0.1718749106,
-0.6284146905,
-0.0507768467,
-0.341393888,
-0.1510170698,
0.2602567971,
-0.0526859388,
0.1772576421,
-0.2803745568,
-0.1045405269,
0.0369772464,
-0.0797309279,
0.2577695549,
-0.2578286231,
0.3627081811,
-0.0156031642,
-0.2698065639,
-0.2674874365,
0.3027171195,
1.0278531313,
-0.1771609783,
0.5251501799,
0.0380598828,
-0.4000284374,
-0.5753203034,
-0.5707370639,
0.0011139091,
-0.5039224625,
0.543469429,
-0.6932041049,
-1.0942835808,
0.8181899786,
-0.5245073438,
0.0575779974,
0.3668698967,
0.99546808,
-0.1948943883,
1.3259875774,
0.1066842899,
0.3038380146,
0.2017734051,
-0.1288628578,
0.5204678178,
-0.4156581461,
-0.8399269581,
-0.1755321622,
-0.773535192,
-0.4211028814,
-0.493029505,
0.442299664,
0.0603574105,
-0.7361685634,
-0.0220681597,
-0.1653587669,
0.8452274203,
0.4965625703,
-0.1922494173,
0.307734102,
-0.3767609894,
-0.50536865,
-0.01725154,
-0.7239768505,
-0.2279122025,
0.5022700429,
0.5565953851,
0.6232542396,
0.2638381124,
0.3015423715,
0.3101578951,
-0.097342141,
-0.8799071908,
0.7292381525,
0.1911495924,
-0.6371490955,
-0.344859004,
-0.7785156965,
-0.8015972376,
0.3054142594,
-0.5761605501,
-0.732835114,
0.2035978436,
-0.1886040419,
-0.6241573095,
0.6219716668,
-0.4193407893,
0.8025122881,
-0.4001620412,
-0.2642384171,
-0.3008620143,
-0.3634065688,
0.3094410598,
-0.0899055675,
0.2047129273,
-0.2098125666,
-0.1251545548,
0.2608655095,
-0.1825025082,
0.3800823689,
-0.0681023002,
-0.4022926688,
0.2567853332,
0.7845726013,
0.6255414486,
-0.0503063537,
-0.0410181582,
-0.1174252629,
0.2783630788,
-0.2080613822,
-0.8880939484,
0.765937686,
-0.5253334045,
-0.7913442254,
-0.4413937032,
-0.8899301887,
-0.580953598,
0.1584933102,
-0.1266652346,
0.0600894727,
0.0404717512,
0.3859176934,
0.4979269803,
-0.3011965156,
-0.0171192307,
0.7327215075,
-0.2213983536,
-0.3182163239,
0.690877974,
0.2768631876,
0.4519495666,
0.4613414407,
0.5061801076,
-0.3556759357,
-0.5620107651,
-0.2459934056,
0.075288415,
-0.7997697592,
0.0125942873,
-0.2428727299,
-0.1226423979,
0.0716468617,
-0.4228391945,
-0.3408138752,
-0.1542992592,
0.3360283375,
-0.0111882389,
-0.1468606591,
0.793596983,
0.018230034,
-0.0324089229,
-0.5281644464,
0.1561351866,
0.4815834761,
0.5645719171,
0.5075344443,
-0.3878682852,
-0.1665454805,
-0.0240929201,
-0.1601066589,
-0.8001865745,
0.1795954704,
-0.4168347418,
0.8640070558,
0.218473047,
0.0006169227,
0.5613173246,
-0.6649269462,
0.7738564014,
-0.0830706879,
-0.8209989667,
0.3996640444,
-0.6493507624,
0.3930484951,
0.3502554595,
0.3865593374,
-0.5173953772,
-0.3768166602,
-0.6560514569,
-0.6169605851,
0.5312390327,
0.1278434694,
-0.3595584035,
0.0230961759,
0.6855377555,
-0.1539614499,
0.1087534651,
-0.4428829253,
-0.0519125946,
0.4200161397,
0.0015885471,
0.2458530515,
-0.2822490335,
0.1564895064,
-0.5224960446,
0.5794937015,
0.1618177742,
-0.0586608499,
-0.1269289851,
0.3418748677,
-0.2592908442,
0.0735449344,
0.6233684421,
0.6993679404,
-0.1538430005,
0.149019897,
0.5594059229,
0.0667537823,
0.4046908319,
-0.1898605525,
-0.0273201428,
-0.2720499039,
0.3984356225,
0.5800613165,
0.4052390158,
-1.0718096495,
0.3491738141,
0.1011832803,
-0.543254137,
-0.1138147637,
-0.1205498949,
0.4090744555,
1.0013363361,
0.1993346959,
-0.2373849601,
-0.323109746,
-0.9117717743,
0.0254936274,
0.3860042989,
-0.0345511287,
-0.0220841374,
0.6997600794,
0.2821910381,
-0.3850285709,
0.4129850268,
-0.4406422079,
-0.8919121027,
0.7373663187,
0.3901564479,
0.6031219959,
-0.1047387421,
0.1975202709,
0.2751687467,
0.2330949157,
-0.1856701523,
0.2470245808,
-0.0117043508,
-0.8346936107,
-0.6216413975,
-0.2346543074,
-0.6966538429,
0.3530591726,
-0.310520947,
0.2352968901,
-0.712169528,
0.0373954326,
0.0995039195,
0.2014416754,
-0.2329910994,
0.0586021096,
0.6384359598,
0.8977342248,
-0.3935303986,
0.3678187728,
0.6421402693,
-0.1996504664,
-0.5472611785,
0.2080664039,
-0.0222973134,
-0.8827524185,
1.0223306417,
-0.2030917704,
-0.1749593318,
-0.2719098926,
-0.4970780611,
-0.9447986484,
1.0491646528,
0.3479239047,
-0.7828657627,
-0.319370985,
-0.0147438766,
0.3909173906,
-0.3983855546,
-0.0950686783,
0.801569283,
0.5323153138,
0.584515214,
-0.9146351814,
-0.1873030216,
0.0583558045,
-0.381505847,
0.4411016703,
-0.7691550255,
0.7856859565,
-0.3253397942,
-0.1201046854,
0.0869702697,
0.5660834908,
0.458568126,
0.2954416573,
0.795070827,
0.657998085,
0.8424220681,
-0.1602988839,
0.663818121,
-0.2909539938,
0.2599971294,
1.0256552696,
-0.577937007,
0.8811130524,
-0.1810262799,
-0.2041520178,
0.959826231,
0.6017404795,
-0.1365067661,
0.3546444178,
0.6376920342,
-0.3345266879,
-0.8699243069,
0.1429407448,
-0.1047201008,
0.6913307309,
0.3687226474,
-0.0384305231,
-0.2829773724,
-0.2869731188,
0.3053990901,
0.1795261055,
-0.4742955863,
0.8053180575,
-0.1014730781,
-0.7295209169,
0.3389840126,
-0.0166119654,
0.4788171351,
-0.5396792889,
-0.0408640541,
-0.0298673306,
0.4095050097,
0.195034802,
-1.1224240065,
0.1187121123,
0.0632292628,
-0.1230094507,
-0.2120301872,
0.6180729866,
-0.5452104211,
-0.4693788588,
0.3187653422,
0.6762965322,
0.0036076696,
-0.0208755527,
-0.8222849965,
0.3607682586,
-0.087881349,
-0.0022942049,
0.3116886616,
1.0383223295,
0.0877232254,
1.0025258064,
0.4768093526,
0.2673472762,
-0.1834563315,
0.0048911138,
0.7264083624,
-0.8054805398,
-0.8055279851,
-0.9268742204,
0.0442954563,
-0.2235188484,
-0.0904849097,
0.4408122301,
0.5117462873,
0.7345625162,
0.2323053777,
0.8153921962,
0.3497920036,
0.5123692751,
-0.3482593,
0.6042515635,
-0.5657898188,
0.1379816532,
-0.1206560582,
-0.6180763245,
-0.2714623511,
0.7258779407,
-0.6080789566,
0.0747831762,
0.5372322798,
0.2777819335,
0.0983052254,
0.120061703,
0.3205207586,
0.6267023683,
0.6371251345,
0.9685668349,
1.2547932863,
0.2227288485,
0.6715990305,
-0.060844142,
-0.2506476045,
-0.1525518447,
-1.1595016718,
-0.8996940255,
-0.36452353,
-0.4496915936,
-0.4422860146,
0.1146604791,
0.929261446,
0.5150831342,
-0.3592472076,
-0.3037684262,
0.0835748762,
0.2496602088,
-0.2506970763,
-0.2223161459,
0.0996853709,
-0.3078198433,
-0.5129402876,
0.5584896207,
0.3986265957,
-0.096629709,
-0.5115281343,
-0.151346162,
-0.3498033881,
0.4767454565,
0.9209733605,
0.2989310324,
-0.7751615047,
-0.3863502443,
-0.1422304958,
0.2954463661,
-0.1180319265,
0.8773475885,
-0.7467976213,
0.4468320608,
0.5798142552,
0.7645539045,
0.2337530851,
-0.0590044968,
0.5989217162,
-0.1952632219,
-0.0461124331,
0.4388870299,
0.2305000722,
-0.0007568588,
-0.1671214402,
0.1956970394,
0.4943337739,
-0.6350461841,
-0.9390586019,
0.4652512372,
-0.7526801229,
-0.7317188978,
1.2961297035,
-0.0048166015,
0.0646181852,
0.1250096112,
-0.274402678,
-0.0335424654,
-0.3219186664,
0.7867732048,
1.1779397726,
-0.0662867725,
-0.1905262768,
-0.6126801968,
0.5569850206,
0.2902230322,
-0.6776084304,
0.3155005872,
0.4514469504,
0.0419834107,
0.0746003613,
0.2756471634,
0.1107936278,
0.0688050613,
0.1746945828,
-0.6243250966,
-0.0481546819,
-0.5636495352,
0.1118486449,
0.4408753812,
0.0598130673,
0.1037489772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01513v1
|
Multilingual Gradient Word-Order Typology from Universal Dependencies
| 2024-02-02T15:54:19 | 2024-02-02T15:54:19 |
Emi Baylor, Esther Ploeger, Johannes Bjerva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While information from the field of linguistic typology has the potential to
improve performance on NLP tasks, reliable typological data is a prerequisite.
Existing typological databases, including WALS and Grambank, suffer from
inconsistencies primarily caused by their categorical format. Furthermore,
typological categorisations by definition differ significantly from the
continuous nature of phenomena, as found in natural language corpora. In this
paper, we introduce a new seed dataset made up of continuous-valued data,
rather than categorical data, that can better reflect the variability of
language. While this initial dataset focuses on word-order typology, we also
present the methodology used to create the dataset, which can be easily adapted
to generate data for a broader set of features and languages.
|
[
-0.3102811873,
-0.3377282023,
0.1972476095,
0.667185843,
-0.0510150306,
0.2534697652,
-0.1943802834,
-0.6000795364,
0.5618704557,
0.5590909123,
-0.2729584575,
-0.651160717,
-0.4218907952,
0.000715728,
-0.3393460214,
1.2135555744,
0.1214572862,
0.0149882911,
0.0223578904,
-0.6475499868,
-0.2059983313,
-0.9235040545,
-0.5396221876,
-0.2868474126,
0.6042664647,
0.3194507658,
0.7711826563,
0.6867126822,
0.2842724025,
0.15683043,
-0.144585073,
0.1620298922,
-0.303815484,
0.2032438219,
-0.265168786,
-0.2878299654,
-0.2485248148,
0.0694527999,
0.4952905178,
0.9025850296,
-0.4949878752,
0.3719381392,
0.0645761043,
0.8426055312,
-0.5447946787,
0.3943396807,
-0.6436157227,
0.2703243494,
-0.4447597265,
-0.5220307112,
-0.1457613558,
-0.4109030962,
0.2522006035,
-0.6454069614,
0.5229976177,
0.219358325,
0.7007781863,
-0.164238736,
-0.0555901341,
-0.4272680581,
-0.9847098589,
0.5970355272,
-0.2756386995,
0.4096028507,
0.3507386148,
0.0771370307,
-0.097391203,
-0.6179273725,
-0.2822689116,
-0.1218995377,
0.1007258371,
0.0405268669,
0.203873381,
0.0507908091,
0.0279774275,
0.5025942326,
-0.6128055453,
0.0628320649,
-0.2056133151,
-0.1323830783,
0.4801672697,
0.2771495283,
0.3132063448,
-0.3025000393,
0.0606280603,
-0.2299009562,
-0.8133881092,
0.2527163327,
0.4932614267,
0.5893384218,
0.0137031674,
0.5214179754,
-0.3284891546,
0.8097288609,
-0.1834639311,
-0.3089388907,
0.5367708802,
-0.5737764239,
0.0497825108,
-0.004928703,
0.5780315399,
0.1574306786,
0.5814262033,
-0.2936995327,
-0.0423888527,
0.0186369568,
0.0742254779,
-0.5169047713,
-0.2499327213,
0.3647948205,
-0.2798847258,
-0.5146899819,
0.1452682912,
-1.1573761702,
-0.406481415,
-0.448199898,
-0.2357033193,
-0.4602262378,
-0.2044536173,
0.1050837636,
-0.1071913093,
-0.0001122965,
-0.0110354675,
-1.1264810562,
0.1635552645,
0.5235024691,
0.9569388628,
-0.0384947285,
-0.440064311,
-0.3802600801,
0.1210449189,
-0.4960673749,
0.8259801865,
-0.8114810586,
-0.2944712341,
0.2784520686,
-0.0904081762,
-0.0152258556,
-0.5976141691,
0.3838786483,
-0.4100456536,
0.4650660455,
-0.1447124928,
-0.4643677771,
-0.1912445128,
0.1974492818,
-0.5920707583,
1.0970470905,
0.3628951907,
-0.9048413038,
0.7002588511,
-0.4965605438,
-0.3729055524,
0.3463194966,
-0.4815305769,
-0.1488878727,
0.0416322537,
0.0367303491,
0.2508871555,
-0.1813310087,
0.4510149956,
-0.3322526217,
-0.0019245704,
-0.1376184523,
-0.2110736966,
0.9427380562,
-0.1444156766,
-0.173470661,
-0.2298375368,
-1.4913529158,
0.1272767484,
-0.0816983879,
-0.5380208492,
-0.6059981585,
0.5409270525,
0.1672762334,
0.5559157729,
0.1554884166,
-0.5767844915,
0.4681143463,
-0.1025889888,
0.2378099561,
0.6895297766,
0.06471394,
0.3722713888,
-0.2295445651,
0.6943603158,
-0.1324197799,
0.1832011938,
0.2469154447,
-0.7454117537,
-0.7197826505,
-0.3031727374,
0.4706783891,
0.8320706487,
-0.7998918295,
0.2094354779,
-0.5275960565,
-0.2578703463,
-0.3241122663,
0.2824814916,
0.316496104,
0.3393832743,
0.3880653977,
-0.144807905,
-0.8179620504,
-0.6697227359,
0.1272253245,
-0.1686082482,
-0.3041317761,
0.2787202299,
0.1346715242,
-0.0858552828,
0.9592580795,
-0.5188795924,
-0.2887168527,
-0.1364401728,
0.5154435039,
0.2803902626,
0.3292205036,
0.644097507,
-0.6758964062,
-0.3796738386,
0.0239826795,
-0.626613915,
-0.2632870078,
0.1385415643,
-0.2335799485,
0.0973465815,
0.4691888094,
-0.211236611,
0.0943531841,
0.8690302968,
-0.5205076337,
0.7826179862,
-0.2062044889,
-0.1956992596,
-1.2087826729,
0.1874579489,
-0.0422129072,
-0.0655527264,
-0.7559422255,
-0.1241775602,
-0.0748109594,
0.0538986586,
-0.2338509113,
0.3270332515,
-0.2865754962,
0.0217349641,
0.156939283,
-0.1098787934,
0.1395191103,
0.42071262,
0.2552224398,
0.716789484,
0.4628019035,
-0.7414878011,
0.363350451,
0.3635670841,
-0.6534941196,
0.6078817248,
-0.5226707458,
-0.2111205161,
-0.3209053576,
0.0305448659,
-0.5597459078,
-0.3376131654,
0.146636188,
-0.2459176183,
0.3451286554,
-0.2974835932,
-0.6939946413,
-0.2716285288,
-0.2450824529,
0.3530265987,
0.2364283651,
-0.341180861,
0.0667707101,
0.2719883919,
-0.4021409154,
-0.6536692381,
-0.4357991815,
0.0442781933,
-0.1718081236,
-0.2647856176,
0.3520420194,
-0.0744137019,
-0.1917864382,
-0.0714634955,
0.2325651497,
-0.1769336313,
-0.1635647267,
0.0218452532,
0.2430791259,
-0.1353967786,
0.5281486511,
-0.3966755867,
0.23335962,
-0.1926482767,
-0.7960540652,
0.8008589149,
0.112863943,
0.179775089,
0.3664653301,
0.4867928326,
0.5893817544,
-0.1813634634,
0.9654356241,
0.2337330282,
-0.2179285139,
-0.3470788598,
-0.2732517421,
0.5602057576,
-0.4047993124,
0.1598341763,
-0.1509773731,
-0.6682183146,
0.5105473995,
0.3867616653,
0.2160941213,
0.3558386564,
0.5246931314,
-0.1003254876,
0.800543189,
1.0115824938,
-0.3418322504,
0.6624436975,
-0.0902720392,
-0.1721391976,
-0.6063261032,
-0.4292061329,
-0.5748788118,
0.0512750596,
-0.9802498817,
-0.2468080819,
0.0816777721,
0.1363447905,
-0.2072525471,
0.2855993509,
-0.3727972507,
0.196285665,
0.3925819993,
-0.1173685268,
0.2857916057,
0.4673578143,
-0.4681119919,
-0.0407506526,
-0.7995725274,
-0.3461950421,
1.1839939356,
-0.1119551808,
0.6077700257,
0.1105915755,
0.3780379295,
0.1937642843,
0.5084987283,
-0.5017516613,
0.0546801761,
-0.4247110784,
-0.6286582351,
-0.2252287865,
-0.4402007759,
-1.1764968634,
0.2674774528,
-0.256914258,
-1.054530859,
0.5559657216,
0.232237637,
-0.181652993,
0.1986733526,
-0.4755941033,
0.5017786026,
-0.1213646904,
-0.0826156288,
0.397431612,
-0.382202059,
0.3784821928,
-0.2528591156,
0.4681845009,
-0.2874550223,
0.0255349036,
0.7699195743,
-0.6864793301,
0.555619061,
0.0827716067,
-0.3134635985,
0.2038261443,
0.1436440498,
0.290866226,
0.1479866505,
-0.0986793488,
0.1037421599,
-0.0508346036,
-0.530197382,
-0.4832935631,
0.4466857612,
-0.6099812984,
-0.3376014531,
-0.284832269,
-0.7131807804,
-0.6458504796,
0.0302164759,
0.6590883732,
0.6916766167,
-0.1001377404,
0.20317249,
0.4855517745,
-0.2206143141,
0.6018886566,
0.4534392059,
-0.5082535744,
-0.4648031294,
1.2150422335,
0.4962407351,
0.2469395995,
0.5075492859,
0.068748571,
-0.1716488153,
-0.4211550653,
-0.2914928496,
0.0275692251,
-0.5727130771,
-0.1320285201,
-0.5761182308,
-0.389102608,
-0.162051484,
-0.1121317372,
-0.2661004961,
-0.5742589831,
-0.143759504,
0.0041232295,
0.5762321353,
0.8442180753,
-0.0489165075,
0.0144254044,
-0.9052172899,
0.3499753773,
0.2550825477,
0.7463036776,
-0.3027541339,
-0.3761775494,
-0.1689105034,
-0.0478167869,
-0.0963049755,
-0.6633111835,
0.4855176508,
0.556843102,
0.470530808,
0.5174896717,
-0.4120161831,
0.5081298947,
-0.7784566879,
0.8117898107,
0.2526866794,
-0.6837237477,
0.4033294618,
-0.6264588833,
0.2144992203,
0.6004264355,
0.4304167926,
-0.927744329,
-0.4469852448,
-0.7838370204,
-1.074216485,
0.3637775481,
0.4008428752,
-0.1617635936,
0.0981669277,
0.2525520921,
0.3200643063,
0.6016139388,
-0.7169681787,
-0.386346221,
-0.454542011,
-0.2750475407,
-0.6155193448,
-0.383682549,
-0.0861732513,
-0.2275386155,
0.3318401873,
-0.1356106699,
0.0262170341,
-0.0617110543,
-0.0446728431,
0.1563711166,
0.2624424994,
0.6080653071,
1.014398694,
-0.431356281,
0.1378463805,
-0.3365494609,
-0.6533101797,
0.419146955,
0.1351511627,
-0.4578715861,
0.4192359149,
0.4331976473,
0.4367486835,
-0.0040992703,
-0.4927299917,
0.2017746568,
0.2224052399,
-0.2287031412,
-0.1395678222,
-0.2162123471,
0.1131692082,
-0.1314897537,
0.3108813167,
-0.0456847623,
0.0268102195,
-0.5137999058,
0.2840740979,
0.2028055191,
-0.0870324001,
-0.2922982574,
0.3502636254,
0.0337068513,
-0.3164473474,
0.5681792498,
-0.2202124596,
-0.3919794559,
0.6075685024,
0.3857767582,
0.6899862289,
-0.2186992913,
0.6713806391,
0.2460292578,
0.3465777934,
-0.1677473336,
0.6674090624,
0.1363552809,
-0.9384275079,
-0.3790576458,
-0.9289906621,
-0.3905194998,
0.4749923646,
-0.7486155033,
0.0186791867,
-0.6819667816,
-0.0551941469,
0.0477676094,
-0.3525408208,
-0.769079864,
0.238163501,
0.2250883877,
0.7777345777,
-0.7174144983,
0.8536071777,
0.7165905237,
-0.4031866193,
-0.4286300838,
0.0827360749,
-0.1736382693,
-0.766828835,
0.7818601727,
0.0259496607,
-0.0412794128,
-0.1912702769,
-0.5808005333,
-1.2588013411,
0.8504534364,
0.06415537,
-0.5701625347,
-0.0308010187,
0.4104444683,
0.8845272064,
-0.4942490757,
-0.245480746,
0.4463363588,
0.2387805283,
-0.2717023492,
-0.5426428318,
-0.2514101863,
-0.382866025,
0.5834240913,
0.2446514219,
-0.5090073347,
0.9021995664,
0.2939547896,
-0.2643664479,
-0.226915583,
0.5184617639,
0.3497671187,
-0.2203436643,
0.3227528036,
0.4815109074,
0.9049454331,
-0.1527023166,
0.9984122515,
-0.738278389,
0.4891332984,
1.1658456326,
-0.0869689137,
0.7886586785,
0.4577118158,
-0.4245037138,
0.8033174872,
0.8871124387,
-0.13370426,
0.4469632208,
0.4319520295,
-0.2431007028,
0.0966011137,
-0.2216012925,
-0.3696264625,
0.4561271071,
0.6762030721,
-0.2886283994,
-0.2803511024,
-0.0588239543,
-0.0409944728,
-0.2347251773,
-0.4468480349,
0.3575063348,
-0.117432043,
-0.4898959696,
0.6921364665,
-0.1015842929,
0.7606552839,
-0.7526707053,
0.0457098112,
-0.5476887822,
-0.1437879801,
-0.2240123451,
-0.6484645009,
0.0281378627,
0.0288740844,
-0.4426241815,
-0.1951786429,
0.1893835813,
-0.5558417439,
-0.8771308064,
0.4138429463,
0.559391439,
-0.0839876011,
0.2094018012,
-0.4901719093,
-0.4531919658,
-0.3265999556,
-0.4309238791,
0.2324949205,
0.3962048292,
-0.0889618471,
0.7479006648,
0.5122064352,
0.3740214705,
0.4319987297,
0.2202158123,
0.540389657,
-0.6548689604,
-0.5311965346,
-0.5595214963,
0.0818535909,
-0.1391664594,
-0.5335900784,
0.5762193799,
0.4054448307,
0.8431723714,
-0.0833080113,
1.0751873255,
-0.3538899422,
0.3232952654,
-0.6156346202,
0.3374116123,
-0.4465166032,
-0.0321610495,
-0.2617340386,
-1.081764698,
-0.4759563506,
0.1654897928,
0.1706779003,
-0.1160652637,
0.767819643,
0.5010123253,
0.0313821808,
-0.0789979994,
0.2912751436,
-0.0121133653,
0.2134777904,
0.3859141767,
0.5946572423,
0.0491460785,
0.6227952242,
-0.4008582532,
-0.2470965683,
-0.0487928987,
-0.9746707678,
-0.5762954354,
-0.5572754741,
0.0048187738,
-0.6160803437,
0.0982167274,
0.9864007831,
0.4964970648,
-1.1662321091,
-0.3044022322,
-0.5595990419,
0.0122955199,
-0.2627485693,
-0.3126478195,
0.4091094732,
-0.5934301615,
-0.6594290733,
0.1775311232,
0.4036909938,
0.2862332463,
-0.3092566729,
0.3013052344,
-0.2873175144,
0.0654051602,
0.7642242312,
0.6805862188,
-0.4015868008,
-0.4957534969,
-0.1987080872,
-0.1556095183,
0.4263291359,
1.0669686794,
-0.4901145399,
0.4174315035,
0.4140647054,
0.4382640719,
0.0267152339,
-0.177101627,
0.7525784969,
-1.0753437281,
0.4881543815,
0.040015664,
0.4787302315,
0.3100255132,
-0.3413637578,
0.4906213284,
0.6765135527,
-0.1756420583,
-0.296322763,
0.5181417465,
-0.7391052246,
-0.2383515537,
1.5049344301,
-0.1250989437,
0.1019601226,
-0.4847218096,
0.0453474708,
0.0568053275,
-0.2127836645,
0.9551751018,
1.1062071323,
-0.0734072179,
0.0381829962,
-0.5070579648,
0.8449015021,
0.2679058909,
-0.8731102943,
-0.0293884277,
0.4362121224,
0.3816302419,
0.4459658563,
0.7085701823,
-0.0725370422,
-0.1290379465,
0.1409256011,
0.2679943144,
0.2808973491,
-0.5433383584,
-0.1922048032,
0.6250495911,
-0.0964445174,
-0.2181964517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01512v1
|
Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions: A Survey of Methods, Datasets, and Evaluation
| 2024-02-02T15:53:31 | 2024-02-02T15:53:31 |
Elaf Alhazmi, Quan Z. Sheng, Wei Emma Zhang, Munazza Zaib, Ahoud Alhazmi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Distractors are important in learning evaluation. This paper surveys
distractor generation tasks using English multiple-choice question datasets for
textual and multimodal contexts. In particular, this paper presents a thorough
literature review of the recent studies on distractor generation tasks,
discusses multiple choice components and their characteristics, analyzes the
related datasets, and summarizes the evaluation metrics of distractor
generation. Our investigation reveals that more than half of datasets are
human-generated from educational sources in specific domains such as Science
and English, which are largely text-based, with a lack of open domain and
multimodal datasets.
|
[
-0.770368278,
-0.7168221474,
0.4551332295,
-0.1292418987,
-0.0351667628,
-0.1483054459,
-0.1346489191,
-0.3069057465,
-0.0756603405,
0.4374714792,
-0.7234616876,
0.0986347422,
-0.3432657421,
0.3186326921,
-0.1987816989,
1.1550035477,
-0.0846660584,
0.1775202304,
-0.555675447,
0.0819489732,
-0.7920848727,
-0.3458640575,
-0.7368671894,
0.0130841108,
0.8208871484,
0.5295313597,
0.1707003862,
0.2405125946,
0.4791066945,
0.3066239655,
0.2207701057,
0.3213038743,
-0.2398087531,
0.467081219,
-0.272765249,
-0.1695993394,
0.4611743987,
-0.0081775123,
0.529347837,
0.4776812196,
0.2149126977,
0.3598904908,
0.1781278253,
0.523917377,
-1.0978808403,
-0.3189433813,
-0.3616412878,
0.1077267602,
-0.3691420257,
-0.2942295074,
-0.3854830563,
-0.4826734364,
0.3254267871,
-0.3901726305,
0.5140863657,
0.0095152017,
0.5999709964,
0.3845641017,
-0.8647745848,
-0.8308792114,
-0.7742956281,
1.3412325382,
0.2767816484,
0.2543044984,
0.4784439504,
0.4001685977,
0.1340150386,
-0.597843647,
-0.1755578816,
-0.2047865987,
-0.0818469822,
0.5510041714,
0.2473456413,
-0.5275251269,
0.1368547529,
0.1610181034,
-0.4493131638,
-0.1865243465,
-0.7359034419,
-0.0881715938,
0.8337842226,
0.3754435778,
0.2579247355,
-0.6472133398,
-0.4448581636,
-0.0704578832,
-0.3090906143,
-0.2546347678,
0.4502212107,
-0.0278525352,
0.341496855,
0.585624516,
0.0944127142,
0.9118047953,
0.073465012,
-0.3323064744,
0.1397350281,
-0.8567528725,
0.3906917274,
-0.2504477501,
0.7216895223,
0.3243366182,
0.1634426862,
0.1554492861,
0.0243170708,
0.0276526995,
0.5057170391,
-0.6209672093,
-0.1885247231,
0.455486685,
-0.3099518418,
-0.3870295286,
-0.0005491533,
-0.984592557,
-0.0607671365,
-0.2389644831,
0.1376206726,
-0.5160758495,
0.0336786993,
-0.1350140572,
-0.3137692809,
0.0894818604,
0.1395302117,
-0.7383331656,
-0.0451061577,
-0.0233900491,
0.3057518005,
-0.5388174057,
-0.5696531534,
-0.2467193604,
-0.0827425793,
-0.2036189288,
1.0188947916,
-0.4281162322,
-0.491030544,
0.0875603557,
-0.2234774679,
-0.4347629547,
-0.6179966331,
0.6192805171,
-0.3593661785,
1.139844656,
-0.2359206527,
-0.4242535233,
-0.3209704161,
0.2454539835,
-0.8556722403,
1.3070189953,
0.0508161895,
-0.804710567,
0.8476697206,
-0.8338462114,
-0.4282451868,
0.1682885885,
-0.2597973049,
-0.3760221004,
-0.2250819951,
0.2919233739,
0.4406161606,
-0.1959591359,
0.3224545419,
0.291863054,
-0.0377374031,
0.6538144946,
-0.5347908735,
0.8211151958,
0.4799986482,
-0.2230535001,
-0.0328060947,
-0.7240741849,
0.1294820458,
0.1464767009,
-0.5009583235,
-0.4276155233,
0.4748722017,
0.5462192893,
0.9039666057,
0.0587166175,
-0.4868448079,
-0.5531799197,
0.4464582205,
-0.1467000842,
0.5605182648,
0.6249582767,
-0.2345386297,
-0.7084130049,
0.654311657,
0.1356286854,
-0.0011137477,
-0.3081129789,
-0.4478634894,
-0.5551755428,
-0.4160316586,
0.0055036019,
0.3529372513,
-0.7966970205,
0.4026385248,
0.1577730626,
-0.5167163014,
-0.2521505356,
0.0133386534,
0.4370744228,
0.4092466235,
0.3358826339,
0.2209477127,
-0.6065146327,
-0.7269214988,
-0.0373360999,
0.3218138218,
-0.1647634059,
0.5581248403,
0.8431388736,
0.2402741462,
0.8620947003,
-0.8262870908,
0.0006822838,
-0.1757463962,
-0.0792262778,
-0.574860394,
0.5719842315,
0.5750675201,
-1.0839067698,
-0.436096102,
-0.4653813243,
-0.7042354941,
0.12621288,
-0.3336029351,
-0.1865918934,
0.0065645026,
0.2675499022,
-0.201338917,
-0.1058358625,
0.0674929768,
-0.2890946567,
0.9082962871,
0.3516537547,
0.3168592453,
-1.3318576813,
0.3191732466,
-0.043636281,
0.1557882279,
-0.7054813504,
-0.0897002816,
-0.0767935738,
-0.0907304138,
-0.9082043171,
0.6755990386,
-0.4109658599,
0.3302704096,
-0.0111672459,
0.4712104201,
0.1097915322,
0.0204765946,
0.1098358631,
0.7307477593,
0.4450390041,
-0.7733070254,
0.2708623409,
0.5745535493,
-0.3679662645,
0.8129976988,
-0.2993478179,
0.0439496748,
-0.3579621315,
-0.1032987162,
-1.1561796665,
-0.6915383339,
0.2295665741,
-0.1373972744,
-0.09906587,
0.4936655462,
-0.060074348,
-0.7247892618,
-0.5863540173,
0.2258561254,
0.2064782679,
-0.6433479786,
-0.0308541935,
0.199081704,
-0.3543210328,
-0.8605183959,
-0.4606634974,
-0.3906721473,
-0.4153298438,
-0.2217410207,
-0.0253104195,
-0.5825001597,
-0.3628845215,
-0.1432689577,
-0.038795691,
-0.1470765024,
0.0168014709,
0.151305154,
0.4370183349,
0.1355786473,
0.2353553474,
-0.0950847939,
0.1727624536,
0.2229057848,
0.2158585638,
0.3476215005,
0.4515174031,
-0.5435802341,
0.1561565995,
0.4794471562,
0.1889236122,
-0.1003248841,
0.2093423307,
0.3782717288,
-0.2792085707,
-0.2900426388,
-0.6601461172,
-0.1993044317,
-0.3910505474,
0.5734866858,
-0.4028446674,
-0.7284071445,
0.2090379596,
0.1553761512,
0.2077632695,
0.5317215323,
0.7100093961,
0.1083665863,
0.9604614377,
-0.0394295454,
0.2655549645,
0.6478163004,
0.0144254016,
-0.3613567352,
-0.6125124693,
-0.4488565922,
-0.5629184246,
-0.3170740306,
-0.3395836353,
-0.2509897053,
-0.0053667449,
-0.3243789077,
0.1004256234,
-0.0166174825,
-0.8013164997,
0.6785208583,
0.6005629301,
-0.071434617,
-0.0476618446,
-0.0022164802,
-0.1492599994,
-0.1521111578,
-0.4441331625,
-0.5933586359,
1.447701335,
-0.2587276995,
0.4204185009,
-0.1220531464,
0.8178146482,
0.0588433109,
0.2702615261,
-0.8975669742,
0.5169122815,
0.0921140015,
-1.1442918777,
-0.3778042197,
-0.2367298752,
-1.2704485655,
0.5449822545,
-0.0768324286,
-0.4715774059,
0.2183803767,
-0.2951843143,
-0.3568463027,
-0.1647362709,
-0.630779326,
0.6735711098,
-0.4235743582,
-0.5195841193,
0.104515478,
-0.4936108291,
0.6749545932,
-0.4278383851,
-0.0634075031,
0.0670415387,
0.118982695,
1.1005257368,
0.1529319286,
0.4467288554,
-0.1780197471,
0.1203420311,
0.8776608706,
-0.1953979433,
-0.2003979236,
-0.0147519894,
-0.1819795966,
-0.402192831,
-0.1276297569,
-0.2892480195,
-0.0828272402,
0.4996525049,
-0.7478638887,
-0.1490245014,
-0.389169693,
-0.7709292173,
-0.0829895884,
0.2445572615,
0.5360193849,
0.4130040109,
-0.4194613993,
0.1108939648,
0.3455573916,
0.0039238897,
0.7862271667,
0.2636362314,
-0.0488192104,
-0.5392133594,
1.1488466263,
0.518482089,
0.1007620469,
0.0753973946,
-0.0014904408,
-0.3460263014,
-0.2643915117,
-0.3826644719,
0.106637679,
-0.5780012012,
-0.1457790136,
-0.4451289475,
-0.3247350752,
0.0260185339,
-0.3870735168,
-0.0014126207,
-0.3577085435,
-0.3964947462,
-0.3716796041,
-0.128342852,
1.0722336769,
0.0956647173,
0.1630257815,
-0.3998946846,
0.2836920917,
0.5847299099,
-0.0455541275,
-0.257173866,
0.1062788442,
-0.3691568375,
-0.2209552526,
-0.8271380067,
-0.889247179,
0.1266929656,
0.0953642949,
0.6562049985,
0.5423454642,
-0.0215293616,
0.2541308105,
-0.339526087,
1.1577353477,
0.0036806494,
-0.4806031287,
0.6900765896,
-0.1487909853,
0.2550365627,
0.6003809571,
0.6940799356,
-0.3210833669,
-0.3380676508,
-0.6812854409,
-0.6872836947,
0.8693886995,
0.1177560315,
-0.1519458592,
-0.3991179466,
0.0351256095,
0.4954616129,
0.2431571931,
-0.6469439268,
-0.3877000809,
-0.3479791582,
-0.1322679371,
-0.1341418177,
-0.2884061933,
-0.2671088278,
0.1733713299,
0.5246071815,
-0.0427915677,
0.0212077647,
0.0379840136,
-0.1960530132,
-0.0602641292,
0.6162420511,
0.7621397972,
0.7642989159,
-0.2336433828,
0.083473593,
0.1524479985,
-0.7270682454,
0.4096737802,
0.1130770221,
-0.4335370362,
0.1411027908,
-0.0624366701,
0.3826753795,
0.03641342,
-0.7772291899,
0.3514581621,
0.0438128375,
-0.4907019138,
-0.3742492199,
0.0670517311,
-0.2436134368,
-0.3192815185,
0.5102444887,
0.2661454082,
0.260851264,
0.0266294852,
0.4475833476,
0.2213926315,
-0.3294531107,
-0.2903524935,
0.6994763613,
0.2324801534,
0.0180440713,
0.4119264185,
-0.0674060062,
-0.0325876735,
0.6117324829,
0.7182431221,
0.8433183432,
-0.5634433627,
0.4223777354,
0.6445760131,
0.1632705331,
0.2214145362,
0.7429937124,
0.0042701238,
-0.7236097455,
-0.2531378269,
-0.2944178283,
-0.4922630787,
0.5282969475,
-0.7224388123,
0.1495263129,
-0.1077989116,
-0.2812598944,
0.28465873,
-0.1281466782,
-0.8299031258,
0.6036388278,
0.1091589183,
0.4557518065,
-0.8728646636,
0.1523900479,
1.0580508709,
-0.7126742005,
-0.39391765,
0.0197305437,
0.044222828,
-0.1293772161,
0.8197522163,
0.1880709231,
-0.0062720366,
-0.1995694041,
-0.3564105332,
-0.9595803618,
0.8304219246,
-0.1298613548,
0.0007513895,
-0.1069595963,
0.1738994271,
0.3065267503,
-0.1741678417,
0.649438858,
0.3472965658,
0.529509902,
-0.2600282431,
-0.1958789527,
-0.0185860712,
-0.3084650934,
-0.0185430367,
0.1259071529,
-0.7315628529,
0.8814243674,
-0.0330952592,
-0.2801384032,
-0.2025691718,
0.1550437212,
0.4570787847,
0.036432147,
0.3305896223,
0.0587892085,
0.5570254326,
-0.110725902,
0.8231638074,
-0.3881697953,
0.2186757922,
1.0467014313,
-0.4777918756,
0.6920995116,
0.7393585443,
-0.0682959929,
0.3550315797,
0.6324746609,
-0.2561392486,
0.2921286523,
0.3968503177,
-0.3290155232,
-0.0843886808,
-0.2782108188,
-0.1785609573,
0.7873157263,
0.4224624634,
-0.3764937222,
-0.2604065835,
0.3668966591,
-0.0518169031,
-0.1648511887,
0.0507356673,
0.7852606177,
-0.3929150999,
-1.1009095907,
0.3004948497,
-0.3644500375,
0.5643115044,
-0.7408255339,
0.1627892107,
-0.0368560515,
0.031384673,
-0.1919313371,
-0.7488030791,
0.1847873032,
-0.0407918319,
-0.3421509266,
-0.2819400132,
0.9763159752,
-0.4976662993,
-0.3433275819,
0.0586541779,
1.0154777765,
0.349806428,
0.2733339965,
-0.5094346404,
-0.5343516469,
0.1145106331,
-0.741379261,
0.1649152189,
0.1467438489,
-0.0478582121,
0.5376982689,
0.4963892996,
-0.0624668598,
0.4026130736,
0.1772741228,
0.4967404306,
-0.6113622189,
-0.1815475374,
-0.4079118073,
0.8460378051,
-0.1355055869,
-0.8374858499,
1.1241557598,
1.0373834372,
0.9946481586,
-0.5616573691,
1.1954329014,
-0.2273690104,
0.7614166737,
-0.1399953067,
0.5830420852,
-0.3764447868,
-0.4777226746,
-0.2879222631,
-0.8246797323,
-0.1027431116,
0.2742167115,
-0.355802387,
0.4296101034,
1.1171991825,
0.4135602117,
0.0258388668,
0.0956438184,
0.4229056239,
-0.5999381542,
-0.0907009616,
0.2457356006,
1.3995389938,
-0.5725134015,
0.8031935692,
-0.3372544348,
0.0414585732,
-0.0994028896,
-0.3214547038,
-0.966986835,
-0.8781013489,
-0.478178829,
0.0624533258,
-0.1285618991,
0.6226837039,
0.5410388708,
-0.9458156228,
-0.3050526083,
0.2322784513,
0.221451655,
-0.3615769446,
-0.3424559832,
0.3943101466,
-0.7183511257,
-1.0551408529,
0.3774711192,
-0.2706041336,
0.0424903445,
-0.215626359,
0.2702955008,
-0.6770300865,
0.1638584584,
0.7300960422,
-0.0306723937,
-0.5249224305,
-0.4568220079,
0.1777202636,
-0.1544336528,
-0.0384543948,
0.8624395132,
-0.6597856283,
0.5612433553,
0.4665987492,
0.2573407292,
0.3003779948,
0.1360637546,
0.0526192039,
-1.1927211285,
-0.168456614,
0.3187822998,
0.3203749657,
0.3282344341,
-0.2682038844,
0.5577815771,
0.1153915077,
-0.7823675871,
-0.5675398111,
0.2531946599,
-0.4589947164,
-0.220245555,
1.0240885019,
0.2665970027,
0.0752340108,
-0.5322375298,
-0.6548959613,
0.1091538444,
-0.2266262472,
0.6168395877,
1.010889411,
-0.4256115854,
0.0912592411,
-0.6231375933,
0.5770861506,
0.5765718818,
-1.1758369207,
-0.1241381317,
1.064555645,
0.3405700028,
0.7113743424,
0.406961292,
-0.0790145174,
0.3891073465,
0.4343872964,
0.345887512,
0.0899202153,
-0.4790839553,
-0.0662406459,
0.5202015638,
-0.2342273742,
-0.561743319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01510v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01510v1
|
A Hybrid Strategy for Chat Transcript Summarization
| 2024-02-02T15:44:28 | 2024-02-02T15:44:28 |
Pratik K. Biswas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68, I.7
|
Text summarization is the process of condensing a piece of text to fewer
sentences, while still preserving its content. Chat transcript, in this
context, is a textual copy of a digital or online conversation between a
customer (caller) and agent(s). This paper presents an indigenously (locally)
developed hybrid method that first combines extractive and abstractive
summarization techniques in compressing ill-punctuated or un-punctuated chat
transcripts to produce more readable punctuated summaries and then optimizes
the overall quality of summarization through reinforcement learning. Extensive
testing, evaluations, comparisons, and validation have demonstrated the
efficacy of this approach for large-scale deployment of chat transcript
summarization, in the absence of manually generated reference (annotated)
summaries.
|
[
-0.1622387469,
-0.8699991703,
-0.0151918195,
0.337693423,
-0.507632792,
0.7838403583,
-0.1985137314,
-0.3276505768,
0.825722456,
0.4630782306,
-0.4874592721,
-0.385258317,
-0.1268104464,
0.2126566768,
-0.2882663906,
1.5789097548,
0.209047094,
-0.1881165057,
-0.2971284688,
-0.0314087532,
-0.737400651,
-0.7230872512,
-0.5233236551,
-0.3311381042,
0.1630851775,
0.5370059609,
0.716586709,
0.2996676266,
0.3471874595,
0.3600325584,
-0.2529470325,
0.6572427154,
-0.7533406615,
0.1862732768,
0.1930665374,
-0.6145331264,
-0.2346908897,
0.0082082655,
0.5189889073,
0.5661458373,
-0.3626289368,
0.0318526775,
0.045167625,
0.4517185092,
-0.6796658039,
0.110773325,
-0.3658236563,
0.2370639741,
0.1502673924,
-0.7420820594,
-0.493047446,
-0.5906286836,
0.1661741138,
-0.6023404598,
-0.051447738,
0.2086219788,
0.5216434002,
0.0457943343,
-0.4012203515,
-0.0904688016,
-1.1835359335,
0.8963546157,
-0.7861022949,
-0.24778153,
0.223919645,
0.5247167945,
-0.0248529967,
-0.7724561691,
-0.4199526608,
0.0625807121,
-0.54203403,
0.5322005749,
0.0390278064,
0.1476495117,
-0.0456673019,
0.8133604527,
-0.3555098772,
0.0421095118,
-0.8595607281,
-0.489782244,
0.8659310937,
0.5109898448,
0.4754365683,
-0.0637271553,
-0.5296638608,
-0.1036045328,
-0.2607956231,
0.2063879818,
0.2866139114,
0.2297578901,
-0.4062883258,
0.4789601266,
-0.3531158268,
0.292019248,
-0.1425468773,
-0.6542612314,
0.3100933731,
-0.5763138533,
-0.1695523113,
0.3349353969,
0.93762815,
0.6256039143,
0.1002342626,
-0.1276433319,
-0.0683922023,
0.0270797238,
-0.0635389611,
-0.451936245,
-0.3115621805,
0.3416602314,
-0.7189411521,
-0.4840924442,
0.0673767999,
-0.9179911017,
-0.0753624439,
-0.388989538,
0.214944616,
-0.6836752892,
-0.1592343897,
-0.1029269472,
-0.5742315054,
0.1999146789,
0.3371935189,
-0.8847051263,
0.6774671078,
0.4949218631,
1.2006667852,
-0.3904689848,
-0.2650840878,
-0.6487853527,
0.0391896516,
-0.1503138393,
0.9025062919,
-0.1880376488,
-0.7600874305,
-0.0513120443,
-0.4791324735,
-0.1293859631,
-0.6241943836,
0.366022408,
-0.3693152368,
0.6145979762,
0.3667706549,
-0.6688507795,
-0.408849895,
0.1447697729,
-0.4020414352,
1.0245932341,
0.0755188465,
-0.6164946556,
0.0096612545,
-0.5193060637,
-0.6668122411,
0.0971324444,
-0.0253514033,
-0.4718843699,
-0.0609352365,
0.3785085678,
0.3107390702,
0.2832146287,
-0.137026608,
0.1886783987,
-0.4403585196,
0.355181694,
-0.0548027419,
0.6138430238,
0.2731138468,
0.0331806764,
0.2869530022,
-0.6503505707,
-0.0987644643,
0.0969595909,
-0.2560751736,
-0.4405082762,
-0.0552758351,
-0.0861212686,
0.2046068311,
0.0572663434,
-0.2352052182,
0.096445173,
-0.6288152933,
0.302318126,
0.3924029469,
0.5885318518,
0.4645430744,
-1.0119636059,
0.5876951218,
0.0662062243,
0.1985066086,
-1.0165150166,
-0.2436118275,
-0.6621830463,
-0.5762901306,
0.2214858532,
0.8457243443,
-0.9079746604,
0.6376987696,
-0.2114100903,
-0.6346136928,
-0.3054213226,
0.1912510991,
0.5131086111,
0.2762178183,
0.2711233795,
-0.4314853549,
-0.6844953895,
-0.7197633386,
-0.1452644914,
-0.2383248806,
0.1401275545,
-0.0769016445,
0.4049562216,
0.2850116789,
1.0332405567,
-0.4881050885,
-0.5520575047,
-0.7719697952,
0.5914280415,
0.0358987115,
0.5068708658,
0.3963506818,
-0.7929954529,
-0.5065688491,
-0.1486851275,
-0.6280109286,
0.0528169014,
-0.5927200317,
-0.1833643466,
0.1311114728,
0.6479261518,
-0.4004748464,
0.5352463126,
0.4187938571,
-0.0704747438,
0.700021863,
-0.3100206256,
0.232837379,
-1.0406628847,
-0.2083507925,
-0.3625946045,
-0.6290607452,
-0.4967474937,
-0.1201752499,
-0.3235653043,
-0.1285047978,
-0.6104888916,
0.025560189,
-0.4457549155,
-0.1226615906,
-0.3212117851,
0.1379118115,
-0.0381200016,
0.825083673,
0.1478217542,
0.8312738538,
0.0578222275,
-0.8117280602,
0.570774436,
0.666202426,
-0.1536012292,
0.3471667171,
-0.6777206659,
0.0348722041,
-0.1707933992,
0.6187236309,
-0.9382299185,
-0.0850783587,
0.151754275,
-0.4790020287,
0.0166945476,
0.1308544129,
-0.5503887534,
0.0148116769,
-0.6110735536,
0.43127653,
0.9170677662,
-0.2632189095,
0.8664619327,
0.3278086782,
-0.4547659755,
-0.1037992761,
-0.4446209967,
0.1046449691,
-0.2643336058,
-0.3772062957,
0.5102303028,
0.1414633393,
-0.2698854804,
-0.1633903831,
0.2892225385,
0.2570269704,
0.0771669596,
0.096531868,
0.5125887394,
-0.0292733666,
-0.0736957192,
-0.0183242261,
-0.1682932079,
-0.1360940784,
-0.0084630614,
0.7428352237,
0.2208458781,
0.0475841872,
-0.6673285961,
0.7784453034,
0.4024429321,
-0.1609222293,
0.8837069869,
0.3677316904,
-0.0578497015,
-0.2304269224,
-0.3898274302,
-0.2617773712,
-0.4067980051,
0.0920093358,
0.0452471189,
-0.7119429708,
0.6722307205,
-0.3300230205,
0.3984145224,
0.3033578694,
0.4688724279,
-0.2672637105,
0.7990592718,
0.7197216153,
-0.2050310969,
0.6011272073,
-0.1862938404,
0.2506322861,
-0.4854156375,
-0.4227633476,
-0.2629235089,
-0.3260339499,
-0.2852485776,
-0.1911508888,
0.5366534591,
0.0306404475,
0.2700597942,
0.2425699681,
-0.366360575,
0.7236729264,
0.8222656846,
0.3120381236,
0.7998155951,
-0.1798017025,
-0.141432181,
-0.0308674984,
-0.6273565888,
-0.3848110139,
0.6328124404,
0.0927591622,
0.4290132225,
0.1755888313,
0.8285235763,
0.5102362037,
-0.0453490168,
-0.7954503894,
0.3830603659,
0.3365395069,
-0.1183490753,
-0.2683581114,
-0.5621092916,
-0.7093741894,
0.3754355609,
-0.5883924961,
-0.7753004432,
-0.3650776744,
0.1944985539,
-0.5102632046,
0.1971843392,
-0.8124856353,
0.5012044311,
-0.1381939948,
0.2768888772,
-0.5135661364,
-0.7686814666,
0.7335454822,
0.057946261,
0.2877662778,
0.198201552,
-0.0830736235,
0.8973499537,
-0.7542247772,
0.9377143979,
0.3266140223,
0.3042845428,
0.3652492464,
0.2378211021,
0.5788471699,
-0.2806467712,
0.5644752383,
-0.2435471117,
0.1064516008,
-0.6593452096,
-0.968092382,
-0.0013154657,
-0.7666280866,
-0.0866302624,
-0.3216131032,
-0.4064356089,
-0.2129220814,
-0.0813407674,
0.4506371319,
0.5462703705,
-0.4110169411,
-0.1647539437,
0.4700294435,
-0.594899714,
0.5173076391,
0.3194104135,
-0.382273227,
-0.6632156968,
0.9358864427,
-0.2160532326,
0.4382677078,
0.5935798883,
0.1724276096,
-0.0230705328,
-0.4864393473,
0.0058533149,
0.3178822398,
-0.5854192376,
-0.1294498295,
-0.7013265491,
-0.4821897745,
-0.5204852819,
-0.2344416231,
-0.1785753816,
-0.4533126056,
-0.0903328285,
-0.1342659891,
0.5081419349,
0.5327077508,
0.0509992279,
0.6545376182,
-1.0832418203,
0.2498592883,
0.1851979643,
-0.1122198328,
0.034256842,
-0.5102360249,
-0.3618300557,
-0.1079031229,
-0.4682176709,
-0.7584096789,
0.6749300361,
0.3086871803,
0.3945400119,
0.3707940876,
0.5049684644,
0.6773904562,
-0.1178059578,
1.0769629478,
0.6052553654,
-0.8478147984,
0.7588764429,
-0.3861554265,
0.2605390251,
0.5097019672,
0.3111883998,
-0.7799192667,
-0.7351459265,
-0.7376852632,
-0.9822679758,
0.664236486,
0.4738578796,
0.308405906,
0.211512953,
-0.0556915551,
0.3274169266,
0.2090788782,
-0.2099586874,
-0.4484493136,
-0.0246084258,
-0.2250795513,
-0.2106770128,
-0.2692521811,
-0.0211674273,
-0.1363085955,
0.8083413839,
0.088500835,
0.2180159241,
0.0975965783,
-0.2714739144,
0.3651608527,
0.0795462132,
0.6511054039,
0.3433085382,
-0.1905875355,
-0.2431004643,
0.2306190133,
-0.4751000106,
-0.086522989,
-0.26963678,
-0.1885728985,
0.3842367232,
0.5862187147,
0.694856286,
0.5604858398,
-0.7738583088,
0.606626749,
-0.1478478462,
-0.3880248964,
-0.5012171268,
0.0043624011,
-0.4198504388,
0.0526588336,
0.4971036017,
0.0400028974,
0.3735582232,
-0.6875277162,
0.1912153214,
0.0268994756,
-0.005522124,
-0.1310513914,
0.3632437885,
0.6616170406,
-0.3298353255,
0.6061550975,
-0.0102436086,
-0.6272066832,
0.2179428041,
0.4499919116,
0.6499314904,
0.1825930029,
0.556384027,
0.3296110034,
-0.1537248343,
-0.023965301,
0.0216966253,
-0.4898349643,
-0.4588332176,
-0.8113155365,
-0.0758574456,
-0.9280648828,
-0.1598588377,
-0.6776540875,
0.310998708,
-0.4072350264,
0.1600396782,
0.172420755,
0.0122987814,
-0.072078675,
-0.1209391057,
0.0434642285,
0.8636025786,
-0.7980709672,
0.1006681025,
0.3160346746,
-0.6506590247,
-0.8112499118,
-0.392952323,
0.1977675855,
-0.6535060406,
0.1280525476,
-0.092800431,
0.046544075,
-0.1023688093,
-0.5390670896,
-0.5539273024,
0.9823849201,
0.0784070641,
-0.1852504313,
-0.1605223417,
-0.1577262729,
0.4564041793,
-0.1308747679,
0.6667526364,
0.6598982215,
-0.1159515604,
0.3482274711,
-1.1606787443,
-0.2239646912,
-0.4605713189,
-0.0756678209,
0.4066163301,
-0.908839643,
0.3994927406,
-0.0466747656,
-0.4579639435,
0.1172483414,
0.8884945512,
-0.0275272243,
0.2177044898,
0.270177573,
0.1851532012,
0.7133795023,
0.0649607852,
1.0033447742,
0.0869241506,
0.0273753237,
1.3180289268,
0.0053724782,
0.68171525,
0.4571330845,
-0.0734406635,
0.8172763586,
0.5268521905,
0.1516585797,
0.5869343281,
0.0351824649,
-0.212119773,
-0.0554443002,
-0.2080464363,
-0.0345986038,
0.5327408314,
0.1460486948,
-0.2726949751,
-0.3647737503,
0.1811283976,
0.0973406956,
0.5539475083,
-0.1932787895,
1.6952117682,
0.0922106802,
-0.9178121686,
0.3025858104,
-0.0874362886,
0.7969077826,
-0.4759127796,
-0.1665691733,
-0.3900651634,
0.0401309282,
-0.3407898843,
-0.4664301574,
0.4924879968,
-0.1392837912,
-0.0286115352,
-0.2565891743,
0.5461344123,
-0.4469096065,
-0.0937129706,
-0.0929038301,
0.5805548429,
0.4023239315,
0.1528589576,
-0.4095755816,
-0.2467200756,
-0.1327598244,
0.1667171419,
0.354968816,
0.4101887047,
-0.0706627294,
0.5838841796,
0.8047788739,
0.3632172346,
-0.1706496775,
0.0340786949,
0.7913020849,
-0.7037648559,
-1.2974551916,
-0.9198913574,
0.6143404245,
-0.4597673416,
-0.4442352951,
0.7857787609,
0.7181681991,
0.6766742468,
0.0737320632,
0.9168621302,
0.1943795532,
0.7160123587,
-0.684600234,
0.136497125,
0.091592811,
0.1449136883,
-0.2909063697,
-0.6215933561,
-0.1611165106,
0.356312722,
-0.2105374932,
-0.359745115,
0.7384482026,
0.347664237,
0.1671622247,
0.3099101782,
0.3191137016,
-0.3110397458,
0.0383488797,
0.6468536258,
1.1279476881,
-0.4185023606,
0.8957250118,
-0.3993173838,
-0.3927379847,
-0.3877655864,
-0.7032709718,
-1.2459038496,
-0.6215635538,
-0.5356429815,
-0.3510411978,
-0.1254333258,
1.2317973375,
0.748786509,
-0.6496762633,
-0.1277453005,
0.1936961263,
0.1093390286,
-0.620221436,
-0.3272846341,
0.1544771045,
-0.5089641213,
-0.5699105859,
-0.0187542811,
0.2818294764,
0.413685441,
-0.1013882384,
-0.0055333455,
-0.0103546083,
0.1174834222,
0.5245854855,
0.4270899594,
-0.2821816206,
0.1965213716,
-0.3180630803,
-0.0683831722,
0.2057707459,
1.0521762371,
-1.0108661652,
0.2159087509,
0.4346723855,
0.4955784678,
0.6139322519,
0.3689286411,
1.0240368843,
-1.0496290922,
0.3680470288,
0.3430925012,
0.1142138019,
0.209209308,
-0.5063166022,
0.2129935324,
0.1599272192,
-0.3034324348,
-0.5525152087,
-0.0419766381,
-1.0391788483,
-0.2612551749,
0.9371885657,
-0.0896797925,
-0.1979410052,
-0.3380741179,
-0.7391569018,
0.3202609718,
-0.685000658,
0.9418054223,
0.327655077,
-0.0404275618,
-0.2829516232,
0.0130466884,
0.6576434374,
0.1794571877,
-0.9590919614,
-0.1698563397,
0.4773762524,
-0.1282684058,
0.2391771376,
0.7969424725,
-0.1210555807,
0.3788094819,
0.0232683588,
-0.1368511021,
-0.2096723616,
-0.0374064334,
-0.2121529728,
0.023768032,
-0.4632066488,
-0.5158182979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01505v1
|
Code-Switched Language Identification is Harder Than You Think
| 2024-02-02T15:38:47 | 2024-02-02T15:38:47 |
Laurie Burchell, Alexandra Birch, Robert P. Thompson, Kenneth Heafield
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code switching (CS) is a very common phenomenon in written and spoken
communication but one that is handled poorly by many natural language
processing applications. Looking to the application of building CS corpora, we
explore CS language identification (LID) for corpus building. We make the task
more realistic by scaling it to more languages and considering models with
simpler architectures for faster inference. We also reformulate the task as a
sentence-level multi-label tagging problem to make it more tractable. Having
defined the task, we investigate three reasonable models for this task and
define metrics which better reflect desired performance. We present empirical
evidence that no current approach is adequate and finally provide
recommendations for future work in this area.
|
[
-0.2955301404,
-0.7317974567,
0.3534966111,
0.375184834,
0.0660897791,
0.6507598162,
-0.3920271099,
-0.7876388431,
-0.1860063821,
0.4996236861,
-0.1748636812,
-0.419514209,
-0.5987102389,
0.1204480231,
-0.7427340746,
1.0253818035,
0.0813711658,
-0.1166762039,
-0.0412288643,
0.181050688,
-0.6518777609,
-0.5852405429,
-0.6833993793,
-0.0639724508,
0.5199605823,
0.4789373577,
0.9504081607,
0.7447672486,
0.4237647057,
0.2759530246,
-0.1468650103,
0.0633433238,
-0.4427197874,
-0.3744426668,
0.0093518253,
-0.6143007874,
-0.1031617522,
-0.2094972581,
0.5826592445,
1.0983090401,
0.2382787019,
0.1849677712,
-0.1245582104,
0.5896305442,
-0.6994591951,
0.0012737737,
-0.8526192307,
-0.0422161222,
-0.6479313374,
-0.2045537829,
-0.8101120591,
-0.0990094617,
-0.168737188,
-0.3653548658,
0.4781477153,
0.1117081717,
1.1883165836,
0.2553177774,
-0.2705896497,
-0.613221705,
-0.9669573903,
0.9228466153,
-0.4741474092,
0.4401313066,
0.3278025985,
0.0889254063,
0.0399408229,
-0.659719646,
-0.1555138826,
-0.2652178109,
-0.0656492338,
-0.251203686,
-0.3423020244,
-0.197265327,
0.2041698992,
0.1585022509,
-0.426602453,
0.1208627373,
-0.8071829081,
-0.3669125438,
0.4377850592,
0.0215274636,
0.7629705071,
0.0878556222,
-0.373493135,
-0.0518193245,
-0.5516335368,
0.1502461731,
0.4948150814,
0.735183835,
0.0853844136,
0.3093530238,
0.0594148375,
0.9637611508,
0.1442051083,
-0.2374906689,
0.3580211401,
-0.0588768795,
-0.3192258179,
0.1586626768,
0.3980314434,
0.0019889807,
0.2008066326,
-0.5509360433,
0.0467169508,
0.4657732546,
0.5546072721,
-0.5536082983,
-0.2876952887,
0.2831712365,
-0.4789935052,
-0.3069494665,
0.0871781632,
-0.4456501305,
-0.154404968,
-0.4386057556,
-0.1516878158,
-0.5958077908,
-0.3543959856,
0.0163311418,
-0.159103483,
0.607879281,
0.0803743228,
-0.8576190472,
0.4697175026,
0.7960353494,
0.6644466519,
-0.5669938326,
-0.2854986489,
-0.6267121434,
0.1001456603,
-0.7272890806,
0.7935821414,
-0.9640635848,
-0.2241606712,
0.1077872664,
0.2600017786,
0.0204927325,
-0.6361069679,
0.3426780105,
-0.8173140287,
-0.0213539731,
-0.1549589634,
-0.2962851226,
0.2152352035,
0.0225671157,
-0.7774454951,
1.2486706972,
0.2142589092,
-0.8728746772,
0.461712718,
-0.3915707469,
-0.6437310576,
0.4761648178,
-0.2206325084,
-0.4218806922,
-0.0134204766,
-0.0908487439,
0.3123720586,
-0.1755641848,
0.3323860168,
-0.2218631357,
-0.5918221474,
0.1870494336,
-0.099779442,
1.2537580729,
0.6218040586,
-0.174185887,
-0.171236217,
-0.8190464973,
0.1033380553,
-0.3846493065,
-0.4907249212,
-0.5314617157,
0.0563539974,
0.3713446259,
-0.0406904966,
0.3304586411,
-0.5741227865,
0.4652122259,
-0.0960861444,
0.2786473334,
0.3839175701,
-0.2962341905,
0.629463017,
-0.1464385986,
0.6902045608,
0.1319384724,
-0.0260064639,
0.4215371311,
-0.5908128023,
-0.6432673335,
-0.5661796331,
0.690415442,
0.9693645835,
-0.9942132235,
-0.0142335827,
0.0578976683,
-0.6583793759,
-0.6934493184,
0.2425294667,
0.6237558126,
-0.1294463128,
0.4077526927,
-0.3247550726,
-0.630178988,
-1.0029203892,
-0.4895961881,
-0.1185717657,
0.0196412168,
0.0860386193,
0.3174826503,
-0.3609646261,
1.0911768675,
-0.771292448,
0.0107897148,
-0.3576277196,
0.4521756768,
0.1906154454,
0.3566376269,
0.5409876704,
-0.8787932992,
-0.5911602378,
0.2007052898,
-0.4253531098,
-0.4823077321,
-0.6089890599,
-0.0426857024,
0.2395495325,
1.2443072796,
-0.085940212,
0.3428412974,
0.5911171436,
-0.1067401245,
0.7570658326,
-0.0868345499,
0.0043639913,
-0.7505350113,
0.073062636,
-0.2973092794,
0.0769589022,
-0.7531856298,
0.2683701515,
0.2521192729,
-0.1166701391,
-0.7535012364,
0.4017699659,
-1.0864657164,
-0.2354706675,
-0.4925781786,
-0.1182201058,
-0.4851873815,
0.6374878287,
0.1558773667,
0.6407399774,
0.8353657722,
-0.897584796,
0.204936862,
-0.0524349138,
-0.6030653119,
0.4734013975,
-0.2991938889,
0.0660069734,
-0.1065582708,
0.1232059747,
-0.849422574,
0.1289149076,
0.1472680271,
-0.4263140559,
0.2342065871,
-0.4921913743,
-0.4395247102,
-0.3271819651,
0.2458879501,
0.7069940567,
0.1895302683,
-0.6324754357,
0.3358464539,
0.3740068674,
-0.0002335078,
-0.7324772477,
-1.0117243528,
0.4154276252,
-0.3972034752,
-0.354219228,
0.7482525706,
-0.1623792797,
-0.3835988641,
0.0324840173,
0.0589255616,
-0.7875381112,
0.1603046209,
0.2090410292,
0.1422583461,
-0.1828396469,
0.2979980111,
-0.0441102162,
-0.1623594761,
-0.1269613057,
0.058605697,
0.2696096003,
-0.4369671941,
-0.0834766328,
-0.1085107997,
0.653773129,
0.4623964131,
-0.5007852316,
0.6088036895,
0.728104353,
-0.3334006667,
-0.4625394642,
-0.2316545695,
0.284876734,
-0.451133579,
0.2340586036,
-0.97757411,
-0.7162388563,
0.4109566808,
-0.235028252,
0.0089752609,
0.0653794631,
0.6766358614,
0.0463857017,
0.6468164921,
1.1031068563,
-0.0342378877,
0.6570808887,
0.1184895858,
0.5674937367,
-0.4594835043,
0.2385219783,
-0.7617163658,
-0.1751503199,
-0.8524841666,
-0.704188168,
0.0334855802,
0.1811016798,
0.2120543569,
1.1711822748,
-0.7273400426,
0.481184721,
0.5172049999,
-0.0399854481,
0.4354154766,
-0.2941195965,
0.0076135923,
0.1681828201,
-0.6412252188,
-0.4690669775,
0.7955725789,
0.1320441067,
0.7667677402,
0.1318277717,
0.8338854909,
0.4398131967,
0.3768490553,
-0.566390872,
0.5963036418,
-0.2271689922,
-0.8233887553,
-0.2529614568,
-0.3290013075,
-1.2605143785,
0.1747792363,
-0.0561847575,
-0.6322413087,
0.4490870833,
-0.0453398637,
-0.190013051,
0.3059908748,
-1.0673655272,
0.8261314631,
-0.1037134305,
-0.1113414541,
0.0802912861,
-0.6760770082,
0.4432489574,
-0.0863703191,
0.6234697104,
-0.0387533903,
0.0431947522,
0.4410887957,
-0.4303362072,
1.1182724237,
0.1189870089,
-0.1761760712,
0.6289271712,
0.1047889069,
0.0636966005,
-0.1582500041,
-0.0780561864,
0.1218438596,
0.3865425289,
-0.640452981,
-0.3971767724,
0.6037679911,
-0.610575676,
-0.218642205,
-0.4490634501,
-0.5237472057,
-0.2159451395,
0.1753414124,
0.3360310197,
0.4928034544,
-0.3798249364,
0.1074057966,
0.4591664374,
-0.3942633867,
0.6729982495,
0.6412030458,
-0.1275154501,
0.1646019667,
1.1636382341,
0.0021952854,
0.3407256603,
0.7454115748,
0.029009603,
0.3092957139,
-0.269826293,
-0.5885530114,
0.0327837206,
-0.4170070589,
-0.0719302222,
-0.5684456825,
-0.2332207114,
-0.3028042912,
-0.5980641246,
-0.4642396271,
-0.202343151,
-0.2096145898,
0.1392105073,
0.2435591519,
0.4637537301,
-0.1571772546,
0.2335936129,
-0.5448524356,
0.4405338168,
0.1644562334,
0.4048894346,
-0.1530929059,
-0.3116257787,
-0.3460513055,
-0.2490243763,
0.001373618,
-1.254676342,
0.2450176626,
-0.0301079564,
0.3049981892,
0.2874234021,
0.1641634554,
0.6194412708,
-0.561750412,
0.5590518117,
0.0601832718,
-1.1181553602,
0.1307153404,
-0.1600910276,
0.5837653279,
0.5946019888,
0.3439942598,
-0.7400617003,
-0.7896423936,
-0.5498587489,
-0.9288829565,
0.5397769213,
0.1317406595,
-0.0452649258,
-0.327996701,
-0.0173029993,
0.0271702055,
-0.0562652238,
-1.0076766014,
-0.2620675266,
0.1774435192,
0.097726509,
0.2490310669,
0.0651415884,
0.1590662301,
-0.2043369263,
0.60748142,
-0.2389949709,
0.3384405673,
0.0123804323,
-0.4638060629,
0.2870161831,
0.5921733975,
0.3962213397,
0.5430417061,
-0.070766598,
0.2669816911,
0.0550587699,
-0.1376551837,
-0.2479995638,
-0.318298012,
-0.1950298846,
0.0631712303,
0.4029636085,
0.5671353936,
0.4041130841,
-0.7638620734,
0.462621212,
0.2150909603,
-0.2723658681,
-0.2123577595,
-0.0850868076,
0.3077409565,
-0.1386546642,
0.1240428239,
0.105796963,
0.2019535899,
-0.9210924506,
0.3224159777,
0.4127304256,
-0.6114060879,
0.1135264784,
0.3383173048,
0.3266825974,
-0.6525380015,
0.6769573092,
-0.4737280309,
-0.474878341,
0.9822977185,
0.6654570699,
0.9893885851,
-0.0911069512,
0.4372259378,
0.3260591328,
0.6547805071,
0.0991673321,
0.026045775,
-0.2078468055,
-0.8553653955,
-0.4579923451,
-0.4377837777,
-0.387436986,
-0.1697533876,
-0.9690674543,
0.4760704935,
-0.249317199,
-0.0035306425,
0.1918803304,
-0.2682257891,
-0.7375352979,
0.2432511747,
0.4002761245,
0.8374395967,
-1.0632811785,
1.0698052645,
0.4841468036,
-0.3087412715,
-0.449298948,
-0.1713896841,
-0.0322410837,
-0.6896017194,
0.6453429461,
0.0140616773,
-0.3796670139,
-0.2768163979,
-0.8371031284,
-0.8752627969,
0.5924166441,
-0.0717426091,
-0.525462985,
-0.1193990111,
0.1696065366,
0.8595949411,
-0.5416824222,
0.3097206354,
0.7990933657,
0.4437220097,
-0.1569465548,
-0.9491264224,
-0.0104962913,
-0.3098403811,
0.1354652047,
0.3663820326,
-0.6026465297,
0.6189107299,
-0.4969092607,
-0.6322208047,
0.1174450442,
0.6732457876,
-0.1182332933,
0.1722143292,
0.7802487612,
0.3359407485,
0.8954053521,
0.0823948085,
0.8572922945,
-0.4440765381,
0.0708558336,
1.4540653229,
-0.1338636279,
1.0245099068,
0.435161531,
-0.1176069304,
0.9288841486,
0.6303526163,
-0.3416139483,
0.2904009819,
0.7175979614,
-0.0748057514,
-0.4301757812,
0.1447993219,
-0.4232703447,
0.6625065804,
0.4255106151,
-0.1889232546,
-0.1200394556,
0.1156730503,
0.232928887,
0.1037998199,
0.0216996074,
0.4865493774,
-0.1411318779,
-0.7844203711,
0.5384995341,
0.3006464243,
0.6456608176,
-0.5091817379,
0.0562598668,
-0.0282832775,
0.0697986558,
-0.3265655339,
-0.3956677914,
0.5888009071,
0.1742063165,
-0.5387551188,
-0.7027238011,
0.4114307463,
-0.7587015629,
-0.5613561273,
0.5079793334,
0.409915477,
0.5678007603,
0.1278937906,
-0.6913293004,
0.4628405273,
0.0889984593,
0.2668881714,
0.1913340986,
0.2864648104,
-0.4388173223,
0.6411427855,
0.5905314684,
-0.2458115369,
0.3570490479,
0.1562922597,
0.4593469799,
-0.7604448199,
-0.4068428576,
-0.3493870199,
0.217902571,
0.0125779314,
-0.5745064616,
0.5784164071,
0.9109867811,
0.864112258,
-0.401201576,
0.8299356699,
-0.368047744,
0.576510787,
-0.3144001961,
0.4682201147,
-0.3760229349,
0.3676851392,
-0.6374534369,
-0.8205032945,
-0.4037692249,
0.2180213481,
-0.180735752,
-0.2604660988,
1.1611121893,
1.0454497337,
0.020955544,
-0.2324580401,
0.3080380261,
0.334148556,
0.2476815134,
0.9496277571,
0.6352517009,
-0.5143719912,
1.0765144825,
-0.0470632873,
-0.5863456726,
-0.1175987422,
-1.052801609,
-0.714846909,
-0.7786887884,
-0.8488276005,
-0.3162127137,
0.0657353476,
0.3445375264,
0.9340715408,
-0.8275025487,
-0.5205091238,
-0.1365688145,
0.3914448619,
-0.9043782353,
-0.314388752,
0.1525612622,
-0.6089416146,
-0.9551417232,
0.5720193982,
0.015112998,
-0.5203591585,
0.0380194262,
0.2689758539,
-0.2173347771,
0.0680602044,
0.5627374053,
0.8501251936,
-0.7987313271,
-0.2297012955,
-0.0925846323,
-0.5047700405,
0.0165186431,
1.1533076763,
-0.7939940095,
0.5113338232,
0.4121938944,
1.0048041344,
0.5709649324,
-0.1682982743,
0.6307739615,
-0.6221776009,
-0.1607118696,
-0.1172699109,
0.0481795184,
0.2879098356,
-0.2343671918,
0.4933054447,
0.2163989097,
-0.402371347,
-0.8086596727,
0.5236244202,
-1.4230108261,
-0.7377303243,
1.3260190487,
0.2893925011,
-0.2520152926,
-0.6609024405,
-0.3535923362,
-0.0689928383,
-0.0863914639,
0.6402282119,
0.9219439626,
-0.1200850606,
0.0300003737,
-0.3985325098,
0.6906708479,
0.4097817838,
-0.9034778476,
0.1002243906,
0.2595623434,
0.4384192824,
0.4760838151,
0.8096474409,
-0.0403482392,
0.24425973,
0.2163195461,
0.4569903314,
0.3994977176,
-0.6426213384,
0.0855738297,
0.4099565446,
-0.1238819212,
-0.2951336205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01495v1
|
A Comparative Analysis of Conversational Large Language Models in Knowledge-Based Text Generation
| 2024-02-02T15:26:39 | 2024-02-02T15:26:39 |
Phillip Schneider, Manuel Klettner, Elena Simperl, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generating natural language text from graph-structured data is essential for
conversational information seeking. Semantic triples derived from knowledge
graphs can serve as a valuable source for grounding responses from
conversational agents by providing a factual basis for the information they
communicate. This is especially relevant in the context of large language
models, which offer great potential for conversational interaction but are
prone to hallucinating, omitting, or producing conflicting information. In this
study, we conduct an empirical analysis of conversational large language models
in generating natural language text from semantic triples. We compare four
large language models of varying sizes with different prompting techniques.
Through a series of benchmark experiments on the WebNLG dataset, we analyze the
models' performance and identify the most common issues in the generated
predictions. Our findings show that the capabilities of large language models
in triple verbalization can be significantly improved through few-shot
prompting, post-processing, and efficient fine-tuning techniques, particularly
for smaller models that exhibit lower zero-shot performance.
|
[
-0.3045198023,
-1.0747247934,
0.7596755624,
-0.0065061813,
-0.0462609902,
-0.1715015322,
-0.4476953447,
-0.7849318981,
-0.2803090215,
0.5822582841,
-0.2407516092,
-0.5993300676,
-0.4222553372,
0.2749119997,
-0.3328295052,
0.8367752433,
0.2305359542,
-0.1415357888,
-0.0829880834,
0.315767616,
-0.66507411,
-0.490691185,
-0.7911982536,
-0.4665369987,
0.6302769184,
0.3922639191,
0.9178386927,
0.2991178334,
0.3405057788,
0.3019420207,
-0.0187199581,
0.297816366,
-0.6232418418,
0.225986585,
0.185735926,
-0.2494009733,
-0.3404357433,
-0.0648424923,
0.6891470551,
0.8505272865,
0.1189228147,
-0.0858540758,
0.0969174877,
0.67574054,
-0.4355592728,
0.5388821363,
-0.7752878666,
-0.1043651477,
0.0809810981,
-0.1568026841,
-0.6192346811,
-0.6276435256,
0.5001900196,
-0.6508783698,
0.271217376,
0.1996379942,
0.8456665874,
-0.0961293057,
-0.3926942945,
-0.5522313714,
-0.8089312315,
0.6296626329,
-1.0087180138,
0.360548377,
0.4026674032,
0.2187452465,
-0.1961268187,
-0.5440881848,
-0.7675543427,
-0.512486577,
-0.1583680511,
-0.0929527804,
-0.3821567893,
0.1884309649,
0.3595002294,
0.0752172023,
-0.4095635712,
0.2869609296,
-0.3031968772,
-0.0999990925,
0.4395200312,
0.1517226696,
0.2253563553,
-0.5187635422,
-0.0152681433,
-0.2102837414,
-0.7564503551,
-0.2905680239,
0.5862953067,
0.6238655448,
0.0004301345,
0.7296131849,
-0.4473299682,
1.1811504364,
-0.1176285297,
-0.2426130325,
0.1014834642,
-0.5419356227,
-0.0643375814,
0.0323506072,
1.0416355133,
0.6440684795,
0.69510746,
-0.2534460127,
0.0271489937,
-0.0629465133,
0.1040902436,
-0.9048227072,
-0.2679723501,
0.1372180134,
-0.28617239,
-0.3912433386,
0.0145903425,
-0.5562351942,
-0.3997412026,
-0.4375051558,
0.1598456949,
-0.7237576842,
-0.1486388594,
0.3767026961,
-0.4122411907,
0.1426675469,
0.2343117148,
-0.8855307698,
0.2058531642,
0.5541291833,
0.7346859574,
-0.1468415111,
-0.2038986981,
-0.5057800412,
0.350484252,
-0.4592610896,
0.7433314919,
-0.3821982443,
-0.2685979903,
0.1958901286,
-0.5589286685,
-0.0472376458,
-0.4705508351,
0.3504190743,
-0.5486164689,
0.2596701086,
-0.4554513395,
-0.5440725088,
-0.100779511,
0.4324961901,
-0.6832609177,
0.8457299471,
-0.2503034174,
-0.8917612433,
0.4986724854,
-0.7117568851,
-0.3677312732,
0.225418672,
-0.127170831,
-0.1042521074,
-0.1155502051,
0.2444520146,
0.7548476458,
-0.5276013613,
0.3987197876,
-0.2305520475,
-0.022191653,
0.3273680508,
-0.3837763369,
0.1669956893,
0.0566234924,
-0.2303731292,
-0.0634908006,
-0.9293074012,
0.3271279633,
0.3268401027,
-0.3838817179,
-0.2998795509,
0.007148623,
-0.2027908117,
0.1269664019,
0.0585130975,
-0.4863493741,
-0.0831236169,
-0.7400865555,
0.3594890833,
0.4668567777,
0.1189394519,
0.1754159033,
-0.2550903261,
0.203100428,
-0.1169554144,
-0.345721364,
-0.1693390906,
-0.5900412798,
-0.8090078831,
0.0715347528,
0.2205892354,
0.2094835639,
-0.8968096375,
0.1903642118,
-0.45930475,
-0.3176935315,
-0.0964970291,
0.0501314364,
0.5621920228,
0.6165397763,
0.1354820579,
0.2849792838,
-0.4815883934,
-0.939088583,
-0.3355737925,
-0.3387422264,
-0.1015867293,
0.4098745883,
0.3061161339,
0.0634462163,
1.0530635118,
-0.6762416363,
0.1725716442,
-0.4475561976,
0.4948217571,
-0.0589109473,
0.0352464616,
0.5571905375,
-0.5166586637,
-0.6765824556,
0.1913628727,
-0.8774591684,
-0.076125972,
0.338419795,
0.0145353135,
0.5255391598,
0.3511104286,
-0.7165589333,
0.420196265,
0.5397886038,
-0.0590007044,
0.5476750731,
-0.1118704826,
0.1366765201,
-0.9678567648,
0.1578901112,
-0.1613357961,
-0.1586926132,
-0.9133324623,
-0.1886904091,
-0.0960304365,
-0.271720171,
-0.2853687108,
0.5139341354,
-0.5017948747,
-0.1416771859,
-0.2834569216,
0.6275666356,
0.1776451916,
0.3466080129,
0.2214697003,
0.6323724985,
0.2742908299,
-0.9411055446,
0.4132710695,
0.3570855558,
-0.4287268221,
0.3838844597,
-0.8870782256,
0.2726227939,
-0.1075734869,
0.3633167148,
-0.9160018563,
-0.5133680105,
-0.0367546529,
-0.4360248446,
0.0732150376,
0.0039037068,
-0.7979233265,
-0.7127429843,
-0.1245357767,
0.0718702078,
0.264159739,
-0.5158331394,
0.1078574359,
0.0952204466,
-0.3452897668,
-0.2315735519,
-0.4839122593,
0.3120492101,
-0.0400862917,
-1.0528937578,
0.0934269354,
-0.0161679331,
-0.4401375651,
-0.23914662,
0.2831923664,
0.173613742,
-0.1590211838,
0.0780255795,
0.3539854288,
-0.3446203768,
0.4883851707,
-0.3690261841,
-0.1763613224,
0.0672828481,
-0.500653863,
0.8724642992,
-0.2488417774,
-0.22493352,
-0.4972096086,
0.3071786761,
0.2885489166,
0.018683197,
0.9964661598,
0.3763341606,
-0.1943559498,
0.0954195857,
-0.7724462152,
-0.2405973673,
-0.4049732685,
0.1436056495,
-0.3401256204,
-0.9358139634,
0.2157953233,
0.2701154947,
0.1080877855,
0.3838479817,
0.5260928869,
0.1326718777,
1.2915334702,
0.3950355053,
0.2236057073,
0.2567753196,
-0.0814234763,
0.4918061793,
-0.368562758,
-0.1474340409,
-0.7123560309,
0.1876103133,
-0.4359536767,
-0.1043911576,
0.4047966599,
-0.0162813365,
-0.051568307,
0.1766543388,
-0.2305575758,
0.4336124361,
0.5184370875,
-0.2148409486,
0.4846547246,
0.1401109248,
-0.0711992308,
0.1689011753,
-0.804271102,
-0.7458959818,
1.0338149071,
0.0970416516,
0.5674807429,
0.1589257866,
0.4590610862,
-0.1138835102,
-0.1270809919,
-0.9038421512,
0.5347208977,
0.0484058447,
-0.4343901873,
-0.4416480064,
-0.7099344134,
-1.232747674,
0.122846894,
-0.4484424293,
-0.8674345016,
-0.3892136216,
0.2064931095,
-0.4793157578,
0.23555547,
-1.0347840786,
0.702534318,
0.0860449448,
-0.2099374682,
-0.0791191235,
-0.5620426536,
0.3607635796,
-0.0519783981,
0.2211956978,
-0.1242205873,
0.4063635468,
0.6787346005,
-0.4855852425,
0.8324319124,
-0.0589204505,
-0.3538239002,
0.5233124495,
0.069062449,
0.6643426418,
-0.146011427,
-0.2604317069,
0.016595602,
-0.096790351,
-0.1789895445,
-0.4293873012,
0.6983186007,
-0.7962381244,
-0.5506452322,
0.1026083305,
-0.6770628691,
-0.5525454283,
0.4386630058,
0.3875321448,
0.7866207957,
-0.3159148693,
0.325350672,
0.5590182543,
-0.3754664958,
0.6092784405,
0.4129448831,
-0.3391732872,
-0.0911744982,
0.7455255985,
0.1273939908,
0.7363687754,
0.2992896438,
0.4886077344,
-0.235199526,
-0.5272939801,
-0.3348982632,
0.3353031874,
-0.5886377096,
-0.2660307884,
-1.0359597206,
-0.2626331151,
-0.8518515825,
-0.1445984989,
-0.1660857946,
-0.4719691873,
-0.1736384481,
-0.3176287115,
0.4818933308,
1.1605305672,
0.0828085989,
0.4554046094,
-0.9634074569,
0.3397069573,
0.5636465549,
0.2264874578,
0.1322711557,
-0.0115580447,
-0.062554799,
0.2787966728,
-0.1433711648,
-0.8903008699,
0.2287084907,
-0.0157034658,
0.344391048,
0.2380693108,
-0.0922358856,
0.4835974574,
-0.4371829331,
0.9418718219,
0.4702325165,
-0.8285872936,
0.6038607955,
-0.776815176,
0.4764664173,
0.2530316412,
0.0923208296,
-0.5629202127,
-0.3449180424,
-0.6184206009,
-0.700525105,
0.9782868624,
0.4484155774,
0.0992105007,
-0.3864343464,
0.0669926256,
0.0909202769,
0.3277167976,
-0.7228577137,
0.1498273015,
-0.0015663971,
-0.0288711283,
0.1436447054,
-0.3877153695,
-0.1702008992,
0.173692748,
0.6740381718,
-0.3909364939,
0.0192770138,
-0.0433217995,
0.0916617885,
-0.0333907343,
0.338247329,
0.437600553,
0.5951813459,
-0.0979441553,
0.0809035748,
0.1569229364,
-0.1816122681,
-0.2484494746,
-0.0272204336,
-0.1448914111,
-0.0814897195,
0.4295583367,
1.1304010153,
0.2726134956,
-0.5489208102,
0.6027478576,
-0.042865634,
-0.3286760449,
-0.0818958357,
0.0584017299,
0.1452595145,
-0.0649257153,
0.1027328223,
-0.2319504321,
0.0869704187,
-0.4910574257,
-0.2085284144,
0.5266629457,
-0.1735226363,
-0.1411474943,
0.3585728705,
0.2838203311,
-0.313321352,
0.6517528892,
-0.18553406,
-0.3506085873,
0.3704428673,
0.7313668132,
0.4771973491,
0.2631349564,
0.4796085656,
0.5315389633,
0.0010079078,
-0.1020888016,
-0.0770403966,
-0.007877131,
-0.9361717105,
-0.3856197,
-0.4453924298,
-0.2066671252,
0.1120036766,
-0.3959411979,
0.3138501346,
-0.3434574604,
-0.3285646439,
0.3114919364,
-0.0839543864,
-0.8471941352,
0.0114918482,
0.3108240366,
0.4898388982,
-0.5084068179,
0.5601031184,
0.3074607551,
-0.2658475339,
-1.1488003731,
-0.0000714697,
0.0227768328,
-0.7499033809,
0.7021018267,
0.2897167504,
-0.3760887384,
0.0808604956,
-0.7269663811,
-0.854168117,
0.8411287665,
0.2526723146,
-0.247653693,
-0.2844439447,
0.3192352653,
0.6364668012,
-0.2558798492,
0.203667447,
0.7165136933,
0.5666950941,
0.5350070596,
-1.0144919157,
-0.0556452051,
0.027271159,
0.1948791742,
0.2389886528,
-0.513597548,
0.6755579114,
-0.221511215,
-0.4252538979,
0.0928741992,
0.5555220842,
0.3650520742,
0.0354433693,
0.5039237142,
0.2090070248,
0.8967820406,
-0.0302610565,
1.2355874777,
-0.2430771291,
-0.0155373104,
1.1154043674,
-0.5240792036,
0.6834569573,
0.2470476776,
0.0965974852,
0.4514959455,
0.04215049,
0.294326514,
0.0177836977,
0.0731224567,
-0.0552400537,
-0.161709547,
-0.1180169955,
-0.3612133861,
0.4914415479,
0.4421260953,
-0.1527908891,
-0.2557659149,
-0.1171354502,
0.2435141206,
0.0301658046,
-0.0172115788,
1.1438343525,
-0.1132283583,
-1.0324149132,
0.6609136462,
-0.0454675891,
0.3563826382,
-0.6281035542,
0.030274624,
0.0996892005,
-0.1829918325,
-0.1095183417,
-0.7371804118,
0.0954578072,
0.1549100429,
-0.1938495338,
-0.2553874254,
0.923361659,
-0.3273636401,
-0.2351629436,
0.1250226349,
0.5150647163,
0.1605054438,
-0.0187006332,
-0.3063471317,
0.0263065398,
-0.0056140539,
-0.2279035747,
-0.041390352,
0.525011003,
0.0280652177,
0.4957813621,
0.7429808378,
0.0043661329,
0.1886145175,
0.3680507243,
0.6735295653,
-0.6296628714,
-0.3662810922,
-0.7097653151,
0.2402515709,
-0.4072089195,
-0.1656879932,
0.8605533242,
0.4091451466,
0.3716020584,
0.0487863049,
0.929908812,
-0.0993002653,
0.6399405599,
-0.8446264267,
0.4431670606,
-0.0661398396,
0.225234583,
-0.4785587192,
-0.9225455523,
-0.3107972145,
0.3996307552,
-0.5231143236,
0.1402533054,
0.7535455823,
0.736507237,
0.1963291317,
0.4684166312,
0.4395867288,
0.4946601093,
0.5238547325,
0.3747870028,
1.010517478,
-0.184577018,
0.6368802786,
0.1440971494,
0.0483865701,
-0.2472429723,
-0.8855380416,
-1.1502525806,
-0.5143451095,
-0.0717506036,
-0.3511216342,
-0.0933018103,
0.7728395462,
0.7012525797,
-0.4599936903,
-0.0318971537,
-0.2426233739,
0.0850917175,
0.3772076368,
-0.2485047281,
0.1311824471,
-0.4711096883,
-0.6580270529,
0.455049485,
0.1796180606,
0.258051306,
-0.0966414064,
0.0967514589,
-0.0735548884,
0.2845252752,
0.8196424246,
0.0977486446,
-0.6701295972,
-0.6593524814,
-0.0729891732,
-0.3029880822,
-0.0000423977,
0.840947032,
-0.8094313145,
0.4195050895,
0.5397304893,
0.3294046819,
0.5939581394,
-0.1341346949,
0.8710368276,
-0.8560916185,
0.0949871764,
0.0230954532,
0.0912606195,
0.6129140258,
-0.2667850554,
0.3990606964,
-0.043960847,
-0.4854473174,
-0.5412891507,
0.324365288,
-0.6655187607,
-0.3089327514,
1.5633454323,
0.2051631063,
-0.0018453255,
-0.1880410314,
-0.422372967,
0.2104730308,
-0.3885628879,
0.4671411514,
0.9377347827,
-0.0884642079,
0.2901770771,
-0.6286725402,
0.5219745636,
0.1541109234,
-0.9740658402,
0.2864104509,
1.0033261776,
0.0428057648,
0.2628852427,
0.7039545178,
0.0268003922,
-0.0815704688,
0.0206050053,
0.02246923,
0.053323783,
-0.316975832,
0.0619799383,
0.2536267042,
0.153759256,
0.3794107437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01469v1
|
AMOR: A Recipe for Building Adaptable Modular Knowledge Agents Through Process Feedback
| 2024-02-02T14:56:48 | 2024-02-02T14:56:48 |
Jian Guan, Wei Wu, Zujie Wen, Peng Xu, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The notable success of large language models (LLMs) has sparked an upsurge in
building language agents to complete various complex tasks. We present AMOR, an
agent framework based on open-source LLMs, which reasons with external
knowledge bases and adapts to specific domains through human supervision to the
reasoning process. AMOR builds reasoning logic over a finite state machine
(FSM) that solves problems through autonomous executions and transitions over
disentangled modules. This allows humans to provide direct feedback to the
individual modules, and thus naturally forms process supervision. Based on this
reasoning and feedback framework, we develop AMOR through two-stage
fine-tuning: warm-up and adaptation. The former fine-tunes the LLM with
examples automatically constructed from various public datasets and enables
AMOR to generalize across different knowledge environments, while the latter
tailors AMOR to specific domains using process feedback. Extensive experiments
across multiple domains demonstrate the advantage of AMOR to strong baselines,
thanks to its FSM-based reasoning and process feedback mechanism.
|
[
-0.2251690775,
-0.7158240676,
0.726603806,
0.0524919778,
0.2607035339,
0.0849735588,
-0.3457709849,
-0.295188278,
0.0361440927,
0.7598224282,
-0.431369096,
-0.4634301364,
-0.2382915318,
-0.2073178589,
-0.1420806497,
1.1080486774,
-0.2698081434,
-0.2879423797,
-0.3604278564,
0.0884536952,
-0.0508943833,
-0.1551594436,
-0.6813682318,
-0.6547590494,
0.3691483438,
0.6156170368,
0.8172054887,
0.4053903222,
0.2331151068,
0.3820101321,
0.2187222391,
0.4685311913,
-0.4242534935,
0.2105793953,
-0.6999102831,
-0.9463997483,
-0.8038315773,
-0.2781693637,
0.4536832571,
0.4187233448,
-0.2832597792,
0.0089692837,
-0.0792048126,
0.8868507743,
-0.6243080497,
0.394941926,
-0.7862439752,
-0.1344196945,
-0.0476653799,
-0.1454157382,
-0.7044795156,
-0.2197103053,
0.1589104384,
-0.678479135,
-0.1290073842,
0.1251379699,
0.4454661906,
0.4579594135,
-0.1719375551,
-0.2503945231,
-1.1379239559,
0.7475434542,
-0.6868366003,
0.1004773825,
0.5166187882,
0.3316239715,
-0.3949057162,
-0.5158638358,
-0.2873370945,
-0.3425661325,
0.1065385938,
-0.1169851124,
-0.2230794877,
0.1491482109,
-0.0575871579,
0.4063560069,
-0.0612732582,
-0.1500530839,
-0.2191103399,
-0.1975152791,
0.5994313955,
0.2786136568,
0.3423083127,
0.5100599527,
-0.3214602172,
0.2277745754,
-0.5826280117,
-0.0590557866,
0.3055438101,
0.2711987197,
-0.0026590112,
0.4644156396,
-0.4241975844,
0.5615379214,
0.2120766342,
-0.041070655,
0.1319113374,
0.2032048553,
-0.279982388,
-0.1297745407,
0.5185520649,
0.3687754869,
0.3138036728,
-0.3839420676,
-0.5615698099,
0.1461018026,
0.6344496608,
-0.5258928537,
-0.1990438551,
0.2523849607,
-0.1342884749,
-0.0316646956,
-0.0073538516,
-0.4700304866,
-0.5383976102,
-0.4220812619,
0.548037231,
-0.5541963577,
-0.4153112471,
0.2378491014,
-0.1182500944,
0.2276408225,
0.6663206816,
-1.0402493477,
0.581936717,
0.7999180555,
0.733060956,
-0.2487373799,
-0.3745884597,
-0.4677220583,
0.145597741,
-0.4949353635,
0.9621399641,
-0.4996263981,
0.049186714,
-0.0856539086,
-0.063632004,
-0.1990748942,
-0.6565372348,
0.1885722876,
-0.7423240542,
0.0120850699,
0.1943731159,
-0.6230387092,
-0.1846079826,
0.3299136758,
-0.328350544,
0.8494839668,
0.4213128388,
-0.4564160705,
0.1272755861,
-0.9392668605,
-0.4354453087,
-0.0607610159,
0.1923206598,
-0.0149003305,
0.1463398486,
0.047561489,
0.3867088854,
-0.3260027468,
-0.1215427294,
-0.4609397054,
-0.0009118702,
0.0516709574,
0.0682418346,
0.2319712937,
0.4147805572,
-0.35233441,
0.6078435779,
-0.7792446613,
-0.0371875279,
-0.1648184955,
-0.3456073701,
-0.3924199343,
0.4160803258,
-0.5867121816,
-0.1488498598,
0.1809592545,
-0.2040140778,
0.4550001025,
-0.7082793117,
0.4888872504,
0.8614971638,
0.029744735,
0.9809570909,
-0.6713004112,
0.5892008543,
0.1058102623,
0.0496986955,
-0.2253557891,
-0.2848136723,
-1.0080188513,
-0.2370877564,
-0.2627306879,
0.6623904109,
-0.9521641731,
0.2506670654,
0.1061493605,
-0.671239078,
-0.4855184555,
0.4258548915,
0.2317836285,
0.3220814764,
0.0839528814,
-0.37794137,
-0.3812728822,
-0.7741723657,
0.0796938837,
-0.4595567584,
-0.0178053752,
0.1337291151,
0.6395659447,
-0.4646823704,
1.0380347967,
-0.5274177194,
-0.2721643448,
-0.1648078263,
0.0342732482,
0.2933202088,
0.2555719018,
0.3986822665,
-0.4163626432,
-0.1783030927,
0.3404650092,
-0.7374557853,
-0.0369815603,
0.0609635562,
-0.5570815206,
0.2259279191,
0.4576540887,
-0.508012116,
-0.1311957985,
0.3896294236,
-0.5979899168,
0.654912591,
-0.2231876105,
0.0585945435,
-1.2331255674,
-0.1488739252,
-0.103110835,
-0.3332825005,
-0.5732693076,
0.1608698219,
-0.239378944,
0.2658849061,
-0.5322781205,
0.6330005527,
-0.4334553778,
-0.1015536487,
-0.4684520662,
-0.2121238858,
-0.0869267434,
0.7170926332,
-0.0791134015,
0.5910010934,
0.8212406635,
-0.8520825505,
0.8267112374,
0.1091364846,
-0.4338738918,
0.7456690073,
-0.4962805808,
0.2954955697,
0.0217392221,
0.1157022193,
-0.5009626746,
-0.415250957,
0.4149527848,
-0.259031862,
-0.0626064166,
-0.2549233437,
-0.2423675507,
-0.2404082268,
-0.3092706501,
-0.1150027812,
0.422301203,
-0.3203264475,
1.0470386744,
0.4677536786,
-0.1161765009,
-0.2569549978,
-0.6055119634,
-0.1706838757,
-0.0253499355,
-0.9688234925,
0.0279976409,
-0.2942698598,
-0.903406322,
0.399756074,
-0.173274368,
-0.3365567625,
0.2959882617,
0.4111759663,
0.0443743765,
-0.5304784179,
0.2209467441,
0.1534538716,
0.1397347301,
0.1257808208,
-0.7482405901,
0.279127717,
-0.5021076202,
-0.5302092433,
-0.3429981768,
0.0486249961,
1.1059410572,
-0.1562399268,
0.5686821342,
0.2492032349,
-0.4475159347,
-0.7782463431,
-0.2319271415,
-0.2264093906,
-0.4520719349,
0.1485605389,
-0.4528903663,
-0.9770610929,
0.5769017935,
-0.2524698079,
0.3868783414,
0.3909573853,
1.162946701,
0.0370330475,
0.7558204532,
0.6903665066,
-0.1074926332,
0.6391816735,
-0.1652178168,
-0.2807072401,
-0.6589653492,
-0.1307182014,
-0.2212295979,
-0.2595394254,
0.0856885761,
-0.7776486278,
0.1130993664,
0.2053426653,
-0.1449139565,
0.2959206998,
-0.2504792809,
0.5291670561,
0.616584301,
0.0793784708,
0.3323168457,
-0.2888198495,
-0.0406521671,
0.4000675976,
-0.5807061791,
-0.5962915421,
0.8610570431,
0.4426005185,
1.1998310089,
0.130249396,
0.5091831684,
0.7973611355,
0.3825142682,
-0.9424253702,
0.3814403713,
0.1644892842,
-0.6354799867,
-0.3033486605,
-0.3334245086,
-0.6923987865,
0.2174156159,
-0.0794723332,
-0.8506153226,
-0.0673977584,
0.3744729757,
-0.465785712,
0.4491030276,
-0.9565961957,
0.6017657518,
-0.1823807061,
-0.3681372702,
-0.4098204672,
-0.3714326918,
0.3529885411,
0.0142309042,
0.2682971954,
-0.5024675727,
0.1141802967,
0.3476409912,
-0.7267036438,
1.0940803289,
-0.2750738561,
-0.3915194273,
0.6751279235,
0.2788141966,
0.5840328932,
0.1158512831,
-0.311922282,
-0.4147695005,
-0.1871210039,
-0.3186229169,
-0.8515004516,
0.598295033,
-0.8838483095,
-0.8005306125,
-0.0783748701,
-0.7498558164,
-0.4532617331,
0.0321106873,
-0.2115119845,
0.2672601342,
-0.1897908151,
-0.088392958,
0.7356048226,
0.0703114569,
0.1503281742,
0.8974586129,
-0.5249575973,
-0.290966928,
0.914957583,
-0.2972688973,
0.485894531,
0.5918555856,
0.1141398326,
0.1257745773,
-0.3069941401,
-0.694108367,
-0.0540056266,
-0.4746978283,
-0.1190054268,
-0.3475148678,
-0.1676803231,
-0.4421392381,
-0.2406978309,
-0.6534821391,
-0.2269469798,
-0.2734848261,
-0.0886678398,
0.6505784988,
0.9181270599,
-0.1231771782,
0.2435228825,
-0.8436504602,
0.2610904872,
0.5739390254,
0.4814843237,
-0.0581449568,
-0.5184473991,
-0.5326626301,
-0.0551494397,
-0.1503035277,
-0.6977273822,
0.0942588076,
0.472987771,
0.5341784358,
0.5795937777,
0.214654237,
0.1533596367,
-0.4103474319,
0.616142571,
-0.0831252038,
-0.9461880922,
0.9263676405,
-0.5341913104,
0.3240222931,
0.2607372105,
0.1515629143,
-0.3766581714,
-0.7306796312,
-0.2340177596,
-0.8149688244,
1.1134003401,
-0.033778213,
0.1429287344,
0.1940986365,
0.4032859504,
0.2311269194,
0.1105563119,
-0.2320624292,
-0.0107739875,
0.183765918,
-0.0765400305,
0.2250639647,
-0.0385259278,
-0.4143012464,
-0.1217114702,
1.0001876354,
-0.4403283596,
0.2029298097,
0.2087391615,
-0.4215361178,
-0.3386199474,
0.5001215339,
0.5223157406,
0.6626474857,
-0.045791056,
0.3394735456,
0.232170254,
-0.0829320475,
0.1917494386,
-0.1945920587,
-0.1827044934,
-0.4110996127,
0.3339386582,
1.1488330364,
0.2413030714,
-0.7469790578,
0.1098493934,
0.0613779612,
-0.3247392178,
-0.1167574674,
0.6316575408,
0.169593364,
0.8621641397,
0.198242113,
0.3898274899,
-0.1596783698,
-0.8097111583,
0.4361691773,
-0.0208371654,
-0.5228305459,
-0.7456398606,
0.6374862194,
0.4448905289,
-0.3830374181,
0.3259311318,
-0.2720761597,
-0.4148322046,
0.4065248072,
0.5184885859,
0.7598038316,
-0.2438140512,
0.4735955298,
-0.0669717416,
0.2998663485,
-0.4587042332,
0.3176749051,
-0.1092253998,
-1.1580507755,
-0.4966513515,
-0.7974112034,
-0.7434809804,
-0.4415689409,
-0.498811394,
0.139787063,
-0.614956677,
-0.0723877773,
-0.2296372354,
-0.3413420916,
-0.2126893997,
0.0501516089,
0.2862114906,
0.9615637064,
-0.8408977389,
0.9659328461,
1.1208771467,
-0.3779062033,
-0.6041501164,
-0.1101714075,
0.2530649304,
-0.9814515114,
0.1807180196,
-0.1674374938,
-0.4173071682,
-0.0705810338,
-0.4563325346,
-0.7774796486,
0.9096589088,
0.8520953059,
-0.5122832656,
0.0268757977,
-0.1261101365,
0.8411393166,
-0.465983659,
-0.0035456738,
0.7119573355,
0.3806823194,
0.1778450906,
-0.8664450049,
-0.1888257861,
-0.3823601902,
-0.2923770547,
0.3191185296,
-0.6903991699,
0.6449917555,
-0.5215929747,
-0.0031530536,
-0.0247891713,
0.8928173184,
0.0654945374,
0.4811390638,
0.7255471349,
0.7875091434,
0.8462756276,
0.0705068111,
0.983522296,
-0.3965871334,
0.1462445557,
1.2635697126,
-0.4398837686,
0.7815262675,
0.2336298674,
-0.1978652328,
0.9072374701,
0.3137099445,
0.2226527631,
0.4261550605,
0.3278705776,
-0.362375468,
-0.3678788543,
-0.1544228941,
-0.0328956693,
0.2757374346,
0.598983705,
-0.3068198562,
-0.131871596,
0.0475758389,
0.042135179,
0.0947880149,
-0.6350425482,
0.8270153999,
0.2402284741,
-0.9466870427,
0.0983877257,
-0.0136158438,
0.5264326334,
-0.7243055701,
0.1491846442,
-0.2189429104,
0.5791208148,
-0.459445864,
-0.7455865741,
0.7208721042,
0.0894894004,
-0.5868880153,
-0.3753945231,
0.8976335526,
-0.4332414269,
-0.1354606301,
0.4684426188,
0.5619779825,
0.102896139,
-0.2534532249,
-0.477732271,
-0.1195448264,
-0.0578486137,
-0.564884007,
0.2620649338,
0.6742166877,
-0.2469238341,
0.7802410722,
0.5243183374,
0.1179210767,
0.0318723954,
0.0543009453,
0.8706454039,
-0.4646227956,
-0.1743999124,
-0.8382677436,
0.5180178285,
0.2400579602,
-0.3153674006,
0.4613734186,
0.3322253227,
0.7014921904,
-0.1426598877,
0.8813056946,
-0.203882724,
0.2171298116,
-0.5407148004,
0.634560585,
-0.5670563579,
0.2707008123,
-0.0247543473,
-0.9725196958,
-0.1445010006,
0.4386561513,
-0.2290145606,
-0.2972518206,
0.5436900854,
0.9677733183,
0.0895113349,
-0.2231249064,
0.3804621696,
0.5232443213,
0.162303552,
0.6033838391,
0.9872744679,
0.0927332267,
0.4488726258,
0.0311744176,
-0.396889329,
-0.181151107,
-0.5655077696,
-0.7928267717,
-0.5829486847,
-0.3702292442,
-0.3179543018,
0.1164859757,
1.1297769547,
0.8913199306,
-1.0085059404,
-0.256314218,
-0.0740777478,
0.5123930573,
-0.2409009933,
-0.2316063941,
-0.1082287803,
-0.6006740332,
-0.7125666738,
0.7755933404,
0.7630884647,
-0.3674573302,
-0.3246989548,
-0.3602045178,
0.1689503342,
0.2689469457,
0.6515924335,
0.3664425015,
-0.6236563921,
-0.3313051164,
-0.0646546409,
-0.1786531955,
0.0105387047,
0.8809269071,
-0.4557113945,
0.5376010537,
0.5984943509,
0.7265956998,
0.3419232666,
-0.3754606247,
1.066208005,
-0.6054777503,
0.002425682,
0.1743691415,
0.4979575872,
0.0789044425,
-0.1789180636,
0.5958119631,
0.2652405798,
-0.6417944431,
-0.4524026811,
0.3869334459,
-1.0230624676,
-0.1537980139,
1.327863574,
-0.3500019908,
-0.5125123262,
-0.1122989729,
-0.3569887578,
0.014173911,
-0.7273358107,
0.7871161699,
0.6838895082,
-0.337430656,
0.0207181554,
-0.112039797,
0.2630473375,
0.1940050721,
-1.1900341511,
0.1159226522,
0.5351954699,
0.3773876131,
0.1467583477,
0.9482961893,
0.0861945152,
0.1750398725,
0.037042927,
0.3600673378,
0.0799500644,
-0.4562137425,
-0.0863679275,
0.1608740389,
0.5048327446,
-0.0285803284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01453v1
|
The Queen of England is not England's Queen: On the Lack of Factual Coherency in PLMs
| 2024-02-02T14:42:09 | 2024-02-02T14:42:09 |
Paul Youssef, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Factual knowledge encoded in Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) enriches
their representations and justifies their use as knowledge bases. Previous work
has focused on probing PLMs for factual knowledge by measuring how often they
can correctly predict an object entity given a subject and a relation, and
improving fact retrieval by optimizing the prompts used for querying PLMs. In
this work, we consider a complementary aspect, namely the coherency of factual
knowledge in PLMs, i.e., how often can PLMs predict the subject entity given
its initial prediction of the object entity. This goes beyond evaluating how
much PLMs know, and focuses on the internal state of knowledge inside them. Our
results indicate that PLMs have low coherency using manually written, optimized
and paraphrased prompts, but including an evidence paragraph leads to
substantial improvement. This shows that PLMs fail to model inverse relations
and need further enhancements to be able to handle retrieving facts from their
parameters in a coherent manner, and to be considered as knowledge bases.
|
[
-0.4493478239,
-0.4478384256,
0.7940680981,
-0.0282853022,
-0.4867407382,
0.194850266,
-0.014993581,
-0.4079812467,
0.0467506312,
0.4957727194,
-0.3956355453,
-0.3467814922,
-0.4832689464,
0.1841448992,
-0.2741232514,
0.698933363,
0.0600323565,
0.2041440755,
-0.8509331346,
-0.3209793568,
-0.2517464161,
-0.6535626054,
-0.1181843057,
-0.1901637912,
0.1946407855,
0.5778653026,
0.6320196986,
0.4247950912,
0.6289004087,
0.235971421,
-0.0085345237,
0.5779877305,
-0.6336699724,
0.1547063738,
-0.4121180475,
-0.7157125473,
-0.1853162199,
0.0800298303,
0.4949879646,
1.1220253706,
0.0530780889,
0.1033000574,
0.2313566059,
0.6293922067,
-0.5702384114,
0.3351866007,
-0.658249855,
0.0114136981,
0.0430945866,
-0.2718223929,
-0.4155666232,
-0.302826792,
0.6923948526,
-0.5048152208,
0.5215776563,
0.5903176665,
0.9855269194,
0.1143024638,
-0.4287995398,
-0.5082176328,
-0.5613495708,
0.9090712667,
-0.3892253935,
0.6659359336,
0.388981849,
0.0333309211,
-0.177745983,
-0.4199244678,
-0.6468708515,
-0.6436779499,
-0.3567143083,
0.1307511926,
0.0739924312,
0.0631226525,
0.2473505437,
0.3607459068,
-0.3734585345,
-0.3419739008,
-0.0881925225,
-0.3944441676,
0.3202042878,
-0.0097673442,
0.3181134164,
-0.3334336579,
-0.7058865428,
0.2168757617,
-0.9147210717,
0.3474892676,
0.1792990565,
0.1211026385,
-0.1644003242,
0.5779410601,
0.0896943733,
0.625561595,
0.1391220689,
-0.6014988422,
-0.2376484573,
-0.41246292,
0.0530804284,
0.1055268571,
0.5233784318,
0.0910907164,
-0.104628481,
-0.4816772938,
-0.0165337753,
0.1573699415,
-0.0569228493,
-0.6269112229,
-0.4800622165,
0.1583943069,
-0.1354217082,
0.2973516881,
0.4205001295,
-0.2866901159,
-0.1158049256,
-0.370362401,
0.5446372032,
-0.5618157983,
-0.1637399793,
0.1159342676,
-0.3121635616,
0.0893545747,
0.3744010329,
-0.6411138773,
0.1886759251,
0.8436665535,
0.6670312285,
-0.2119479179,
-0.2197013497,
-0.2581534088,
0.4594713151,
-0.4766075909,
0.8425863385,
-0.3469121158,
-0.3986254036,
-0.3022768199,
0.0434713066,
0.0920125246,
-0.7202718854,
0.5007714629,
-0.5643032789,
0.3030953407,
-1.0284948349,
-0.7736670971,
-0.2948045731,
0.1560150087,
-0.6422905922,
0.3611524701,
-0.1478800625,
-0.7401517034,
0.6428739429,
-0.1938873231,
-0.6165413857,
-0.074023433,
-0.2737588286,
-0.4645094573,
0.089350678,
0.1493355185,
0.3483468592,
-0.1484140456,
0.5490397215,
-0.5175721049,
-0.3147121966,
0.2803533971,
-0.198807925,
0.5196668506,
0.0063842884,
-0.0287114568,
-0.3966424167,
-0.833622098,
-0.3954438567,
-0.2968186736,
-0.357762754,
-0.4758149385,
0.3061469197,
-0.9589853883,
0.0993571654,
0.2677244544,
-0.6431049109,
-0.3169044256,
-0.519254148,
0.1800313443,
0.3691198528,
0.0414178185,
0.6096001863,
-0.8357827663,
0.1449277401,
0.3586066663,
-0.2080425471,
-0.1005450785,
-0.4646918476,
-0.9434179068,
-0.4582272172,
0.0061925505,
0.3416612744,
-0.8034105301,
0.5007975698,
-0.3079710305,
-0.2558120787,
-0.5201104879,
0.0411519371,
0.4650570452,
0.9265162945,
0.5201608539,
-0.3011350632,
-0.8837890625,
-0.7804367542,
-0.5483175516,
-0.4018394947,
0.2744674981,
0.2680759132,
0.5559778214,
0.3700239956,
1.2177574635,
-0.0885823667,
0.0133008882,
-0.1863152236,
0.2940113544,
0.0366413929,
0.436866045,
0.289860338,
-0.7246938944,
-0.439196378,
-0.3836949766,
-0.80339396,
0.0168215986,
0.0855001062,
-0.1500803828,
0.2564789355,
0.0680370256,
-0.654843986,
0.1885617077,
0.3858113885,
-0.2974101603,
0.5347746611,
-0.1569273323,
0.1487927735,
-0.7661990523,
0.0466793887,
-0.3229827881,
-0.4663817286,
-0.4650308788,
-0.2737082839,
0.0044976696,
-0.0127044227,
-0.2264950573,
0.258618176,
-0.7521229982,
-0.313360393,
-0.2251883745,
0.2448568642,
0.540464282,
0.2479794472,
0.3246714473,
0.8820742965,
0.3999625444,
-0.8589692116,
0.2143621147,
0.4541300535,
-0.4703095555,
0.8045686483,
-0.2655087113,
0.0392202735,
-0.2910163701,
-0.0468706489,
-1.0717158318,
-0.094274424,
0.0460380204,
-0.3036250472,
0.3239782155,
-0.0533359013,
-0.2641515732,
-0.15687792,
-0.2794383764,
-0.105974935,
0.6131106019,
-0.729349196,
0.4717716575,
0.4384191632,
-0.1446946263,
-0.6200007796,
-0.7722102404,
-0.082593143,
0.2234804779,
-0.8760616183,
0.2690880597,
-0.0490876772,
-0.4942284822,
0.2601994574,
-0.4887222052,
-0.1132797301,
0.1022098362,
0.1178685129,
0.2056304961,
-0.4094521999,
0.2364033312,
-0.0800590664,
0.2168646157,
0.2733709216,
-0.1378330439,
0.2167053819,
0.0199580081,
-0.5660737157,
-0.621013701,
0.1963632405,
0.3540588617,
-0.031153271,
0.9749909639,
-0.079753004,
-0.1034401059,
-0.3084751666,
-0.6385118961,
-0.2740551233,
-0.3923908472,
0.1561999023,
-0.5866497755,
-0.7670572996,
0.5223738551,
0.1368840337,
-0.2563754916,
0.421567291,
0.1366818547,
-0.5963077545,
0.8662272096,
0.6596332788,
0.2775468826,
0.0326069556,
-0.2428447306,
0.2000462413,
-0.5589182973,
-0.5444181561,
-0.3836764395,
0.0507470854,
-0.4374976158,
-0.196405232,
0.4627772272,
0.2190524936,
-0.2261907458,
0.2105129808,
0.0277459472,
0.1906232983,
0.4340266585,
0.3882136643,
0.6155065894,
-0.1071534902,
-0.2251847833,
-0.1574685872,
-0.9867351055,
-0.6634315848,
0.7432867289,
0.2334964424,
0.6993547678,
0.247691527,
0.4889245331,
-0.1316306591,
0.1776730567,
-0.602653265,
0.6087450981,
-0.1417872012,
-0.5838603377,
-0.1240914986,
-0.543599844,
-0.6966400743,
0.2725139558,
-0.2281185836,
0.0055763512,
0.4488655925,
0.2515060604,
-0.7230460048,
0.3148546517,
-0.7051701546,
0.5877978802,
-0.2016753554,
-0.5179768205,
-0.0903419703,
-0.4810999632,
0.4360896647,
0.0627843067,
0.1517594159,
-0.1205630377,
-0.2527375221,
0.7764459252,
-0.7650078535,
0.7948246002,
-0.0765026584,
-0.0574741773,
0.4484708309,
0.0725743026,
0.499764353,
-0.0063531399,
0.1101297736,
-0.2287798524,
0.2910883129,
-0.5595126748,
-0.5604851246,
0.3447062075,
-0.8206596971,
-0.8412864804,
-0.4533267319,
-0.5330556631,
-0.4858881533,
-0.1194565818,
0.1729064584,
0.5875301361,
-0.2389570177,
0.3750000298,
0.974960506,
-0.0224851165,
0.1854608506,
0.9097306728,
0.0214035381,
-0.2405433655,
0.9155533314,
0.5953917503,
0.3034263253,
0.6528633833,
0.0949242935,
-0.6052201986,
-0.6667226553,
-0.0081993928,
0.2815047204,
-0.8549833894,
-0.1474316418,
-0.6627718806,
0.0782654583,
-0.5296866298,
0.1694833338,
0.0209193621,
-0.2851971686,
-0.4846547544,
-0.1483422071,
0.2580140531,
0.8600068688,
-0.0330005735,
0.1131411344,
-0.8395863175,
0.5070937276,
0.5760099292,
0.2884150445,
-0.304874599,
-0.8278156519,
-0.0895094946,
0.0040531904,
0.0059254388,
-0.9850071073,
0.2861481607,
0.2815237939,
0.8113762736,
0.3525107503,
0.3167058527,
0.7637280822,
-0.3253949285,
0.8024523258,
0.0269061904,
-0.9054782987,
0.2818734646,
-0.0114072189,
-0.0445523225,
0.5524222851,
0.6758880019,
-0.0280643683,
-0.4874230623,
-0.7209994793,
-0.4055154622,
0.6588158011,
-0.1772444993,
-0.0906853899,
0.0532442629,
0.2958811224,
0.5577948093,
0.725227952,
-0.3923024237,
-0.1557969153,
-0.187598139,
-0.2628181279,
-0.0122515894,
-0.7091935873,
-0.0457910039,
-0.3277479112,
0.8190804124,
0.1134772077,
0.1716728359,
0.51775527,
-0.5636714697,
-0.1850826889,
0.2128645182,
0.4858908057,
1.1121208668,
-0.3846761584,
0.6761172414,
0.2203925848,
-0.5561401844,
0.0974186882,
0.0386461727,
-0.3110715747,
0.2170351595,
0.552747488,
0.8474832177,
0.3113864958,
-0.5119878054,
0.550526619,
0.2693366706,
0.0123908361,
-0.3146653473,
0.0016365595,
0.042565234,
0.1303804964,
0.2563535869,
0.1843943894,
-0.1361276507,
-0.9964638948,
0.4668808281,
0.6650447249,
-0.1608103216,
-0.5872554779,
0.3190331757,
0.4064409733,
0.0615861118,
0.1753410846,
-0.4955442846,
-0.6634651423,
0.4085713029,
0.4562960565,
0.3593195379,
0.0207556542,
0.0260605998,
0.2765196264,
0.4041141868,
-0.2298458517,
0.7205511332,
-0.0509700365,
-0.867842555,
-0.5457707047,
-0.495105952,
-0.759716332,
0.0253600013,
-0.4545193017,
0.2704787552,
-0.5763368607,
-0.0025217682,
-0.3766793013,
0.3590677381,
-0.6547523737,
0.2010816187,
-0.0461014472,
0.9018744826,
-0.6929956079,
0.7192702889,
0.4638117254,
-0.5884842277,
-0.9269686341,
-0.0225889031,
-0.4887866974,
-0.6600350738,
0.6388648748,
0.0849621072,
-0.1866689622,
0.0193686858,
-0.644169867,
-0.8432708383,
1.0917525291,
0.8840656281,
-0.6136386991,
0.0608310625,
0.3704331815,
0.358410418,
-0.2883322239,
0.217349574,
0.4529300034,
0.3942182958,
0.1535670012,
-0.8218407631,
0.0404470377,
0.3882678747,
-0.2830347419,
-0.1315332502,
-0.5888812542,
1.0116702318,
-0.1804217696,
-0.619205296,
0.0759141222,
1.0102599859,
0.126959309,
0.292744875,
0.3521127999,
0.8354552984,
1.0400044918,
-0.2291323394,
0.9700425267,
-0.3921399117,
0.2690434456,
1.1521856785,
-0.3743895888,
0.7646569014,
0.4384764731,
-0.3158015311,
0.752925396,
0.3331009448,
0.0728541985,
0.605789423,
-0.1859139353,
-0.2968222499,
-0.4998705089,
-0.262455076,
-0.2384817898,
0.216894716,
0.1686115861,
-0.2337729037,
-0.3336873651,
0.0330786519,
-0.0705055073,
0.3470652103,
-0.4546445608,
0.8670086861,
0.221097067,
-0.9233395457,
0.5077899694,
-0.365503937,
0.5790359974,
-0.3892302811,
-0.0010676375,
-0.1599984318,
-0.0751165524,
-0.2563345432,
-0.7684942484,
0.4476730525,
-0.2295588255,
-0.3505255878,
-0.0606133305,
0.8958223462,
-0.7194619775,
-0.1574746817,
0.0677715316,
0.835324049,
0.1960293651,
-0.1002865136,
-0.3865688741,
-0.1177223772,
-0.2832016945,
0.0377339423,
0.006358814,
0.6417481303,
0.2662444711,
0.5666040182,
0.5188575387,
0.0972723141,
0.0742961988,
-0.2414424717,
0.573770225,
-0.5768453479,
-0.499822557,
-0.8793868423,
0.3522493541,
-0.0028508557,
0.1856344491,
0.9666152596,
0.6417860389,
0.7702463269,
-0.0313837156,
0.992792964,
0.1725449264,
1.0757416487,
-0.6041797996,
0.5459699631,
-0.1724270135,
0.3743602633,
0.3513336778,
-0.4811137915,
0.1035150662,
0.3378395438,
-0.6836055517,
-0.2081957012,
0.7682070732,
0.8170135617,
-0.0571127161,
0.3433641195,
0.5747613311,
0.4127157629,
-0.1138421968,
0.2606454194,
1.2215687037,
-0.0899684504,
0.4810624421,
-0.3732596934,
0.0909976587,
-0.0929995403,
-0.8603115678,
-1.0333857536,
-0.5901747942,
-0.2641299963,
-0.3327269256,
0.3211139441,
1.0400243998,
0.6605664492,
-1.0522511005,
-0.1405953914,
-0.2220017314,
0.3688816428,
0.2019859105,
-0.11278449,
0.2866848111,
-0.565582931,
-0.341306895,
0.440146178,
0.2029902041,
0.2659967244,
-0.4679484367,
0.0229137633,
-0.3261708617,
0.2291376889,
0.5686975718,
0.1512220055,
-0.6629879475,
-0.5700045824,
0.1186019927,
-0.2261310071,
0.3316974044,
0.5391449332,
-0.8422434926,
0.4238725305,
0.9318996072,
0.4223261178,
0.0242848843,
0.2156345844,
0.543669641,
-0.7837240696,
0.0750321373,
0.4392099977,
0.5635227561,
0.7138227224,
-0.28347826,
0.0108286226,
0.7846122384,
-0.3399154842,
-0.7984114289,
0.3057381511,
-0.8162040114,
-0.3631373346,
0.8038005233,
-0.4624961019,
-0.6041411757,
-0.6878893971,
-0.0856624171,
0.2738294899,
-0.2841522694,
0.4946537614,
0.8385087252,
-0.2686418891,
-0.0588952787,
-0.3455083966,
0.8015934229,
0.5109897256,
-0.4877818823,
-0.2738576233,
0.2823702991,
0.5118480921,
0.3899180293,
0.4770285487,
0.1667307913,
0.1354744434,
-0.0657034814,
-0.0992984399,
-0.0903088003,
-0.448951751,
-0.1561254412,
0.4690340459,
0.386036545,
-0.0371913351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01427v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01427v2
|
The effect of diversity on group decision-making
| 2024-02-02T14:15:01 | 2024-05-20T15:46:42 |
Georgi Karadzhov, Andreas Vlachos, Tom Stafford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore different aspects of cognitive diversity and its effect on the
success of group deliberation. To evaluate this, we use 500 dialogues from
small, online groups discussing the Wason Card Selection task - the DeliData
corpus. Leveraging the corpus, we perform quantitative analysis evaluating
three different measures of cognitive diversity. First, we analyse the effect
of group size as a proxy measure for diversity. Second, we evaluate the effect
of the size of the initial idea pool. Finally, we look into the content of the
discussion by analysing discussed solutions, discussion patterns, and how
conversational probing can improve those characteristics. Despite the
reputation of groups for compounding bias, we show that small groups can,
through dialogue, overcome intuitive biases and improve individual
decision-making. Across a large sample and different operationalisations, we
consistently find that greater cognitive diversity is associated with more
successful group deliberation. Code and data used for the analysis are
available in the repository:
https://github.com/gkaradzhov/cognitive-diversity-groups-cogsci24.
|
[
-1.0532956123,
-0.6725785732,
0.3616266847,
0.2096369714,
-0.3222660124,
0.5014875531,
-0.4718857408,
-0.6705425978,
0.4828034043,
0.0933229476,
-0.5306194425,
-0.5411743522,
-0.7034164667,
0.0890401304,
-0.0816873237,
0.9970216155,
0.4926626086,
0.2621958256,
0.119795844,
-0.4194720387,
-0.6369381547,
-0.217029646,
-0.9990366101,
-0.173631385,
0.4931828976,
0.5779762864,
0.7216314077,
0.0966710076,
0.3276226223,
0.2976076305,
-0.5987820029,
-0.0799231157,
-0.8003875613,
-0.12719886,
-0.3290753663,
-0.7663993835,
-0.2589860559,
0.3747510314,
0.4604104459,
0.8996331692,
-0.3310823441,
-0.008301327,
0.0570556186,
0.7037406564,
-0.4211527407,
-0.1259221286,
-0.8540167809,
0.3611111939,
-0.0615260415,
0.2175440341,
0.0255878828,
-0.4446367025,
0.5279633999,
-0.6651576161,
0.2198934555,
0.2293978035,
0.1347200722,
0.3078067005,
-0.5043429136,
-0.5457481742,
-0.8423977494,
0.9002687931,
-0.255201906,
-0.0362479649,
0.6488842368,
0.2853652537,
-0.1721822172,
-0.479082793,
-0.4832477868,
0.2786036432,
0.0315111317,
0.5796722174,
-0.2394203693,
-0.0100846598,
0.4032535851,
0.7770095468,
-0.2765201628,
0.162598744,
-0.97608006,
0.0511936359,
0.7222784162,
0.2858962417,
0.4063092172,
0.0055612335,
0.2272782475,
0.0984673649,
-0.2012993693,
0.0527029485,
0.6729845405,
0.0291225258,
0.004284543,
0.2575624287,
-0.4505985379,
0.3346503675,
0.2946616113,
0.2178034186,
0.2021244466,
-0.6882801652,
-0.0567527935,
-0.01252387,
0.4931239486,
0.5061266422,
0.1584847271,
0.1211161688,
0.2228326946,
0.2213056087,
0.2422896326,
-0.6322925687,
-0.3341572881,
0.1357823759,
-0.9388518929,
-0.0071206093,
0.086341612,
-1.0865799189,
-0.4070422351,
-0.1232133731,
-0.1399619728,
-0.2369243205,
-0.1847865283,
0.2084174603,
-0.8427637219,
0.2737053931,
0.719866097,
-0.9627456069,
0.5790515542,
0.4421077669,
0.5475718975,
-0.6642551422,
-0.0341508985,
-0.2458892316,
-0.1541267484,
-0.065510489,
0.7296947837,
-0.6201648712,
-1.1757531166,
-0.2463367581,
-0.4776777923,
-0.0524165928,
-0.8746096492,
0.5282738805,
-0.330737859,
0.6782770157,
-0.5635521412,
-0.3921383023,
-0.2935655713,
0.3875227869,
-1.061412096,
0.4110133052,
0.0926141441,
-0.6389312148,
0.7782492638,
-0.7252523899,
-0.3815138936,
0.3597834706,
-0.7679296136,
-0.161616981,
0.122817792,
0.2516409755,
-0.2834609151,
-0.2566765547,
-0.2749991417,
-0.5538640022,
-0.3927436769,
0.4880687892,
-0.092564024,
0.9871743321,
0.4742878079,
-0.1836803854,
0.2325728387,
-0.296582967,
0.1937837154,
-0.3030844927,
-0.492990315,
-0.5374549627,
0.1135982573,
-0.2730757594,
0.151373446,
-0.2627772689,
-0.4258258641,
0.1966711283,
0.0267003123,
0.4047886729,
0.5173859,
0.3172849715,
0.6430783272,
-0.4045493603,
0.6520369053,
-0.1460610926,
0.7243361473,
0.4699519277,
-0.8907148242,
-0.5005084872,
-0.6637378335,
0.2064008862,
0.4745503962,
-0.5379408002,
0.315189153,
-0.0076203113,
-0.376816541,
-0.338406086,
0.0786287412,
-0.0576131605,
-0.2284262478,
0.1497002095,
-0.7471034527,
-0.4728857279,
-0.6791769862,
-0.1789563447,
-0.3500878513,
0.1202842444,
0.4283989072,
0.5692349076,
-0.3620239496,
0.945022881,
-0.5637350678,
-0.2965281308,
-0.4505307674,
0.1467615068,
0.1953093857,
0.3376327157,
0.3835736215,
-0.809207499,
-0.2961684763,
-0.1398533434,
-0.4544229507,
0.2332908958,
0.0848134309,
-0.5233963728,
-0.0972844362,
0.3310483992,
-0.6952225566,
0.7800115347,
0.5384414792,
-0.3428860009,
0.0463040546,
0.0657166243,
0.4889478087,
-0.7260733843,
-0.3775596023,
-0.3380579054,
0.2957168818,
-0.2807777226,
-0.4396910965,
-0.3773146868,
0.116456233,
-0.229387328,
0.0972124934,
-0.2805519998,
-0.0148161445,
-0.1334588677,
0.2555645406,
-0.2390340269,
0.3486982882,
-0.386210531,
0.4057395458,
0.190907076,
-0.5790816545,
-0.0631452501,
0.5990619063,
-0.7679200768,
0.5934889913,
-0.392168045,
-0.010241068,
-0.067619279,
0.4417429268,
-1.0950769186,
-0.1311188936,
0.2520308793,
-0.3467644155,
-0.1559975147,
0.1081114933,
-0.0615129918,
-0.5142412782,
-0.5059829354,
0.8609691262,
0.471306622,
-0.3021188974,
0.7250502706,
0.7171064615,
-0.2352410555,
-0.3152952194,
-0.9032788873,
-0.1194413006,
-0.5329786539,
-0.7701932788,
0.3154475093,
-0.6658776999,
-0.7948004603,
0.0054143849,
-0.0922882184,
-0.1260195673,
0.1101832092,
0.2317642272,
0.156398952,
0.198871091,
0.1675096899,
0.0762882382,
0.1660899818,
-0.164268747,
-0.1694947332,
0.5345096588,
-0.4516108632,
-0.3046109378,
0.0487391911,
0.5091350079,
0.2930467427,
-0.2717979848,
0.5808317065,
0.4106159508,
-0.0409814455,
-0.4175624549,
-0.5102193952,
-0.190794751,
-0.4297541976,
0.1578279883,
0.0533239432,
-1.2774935961,
0.9920608401,
0.0697677135,
-0.1264113784,
0.5255664587,
0.7202255726,
-0.2568358779,
0.5238562822,
0.3630247414,
0.1922917813,
0.7352545261,
-0.2505737841,
0.0474478789,
-0.4366364181,
-0.1233541593,
-0.2429786175,
-0.740398407,
-0.826695323,
-0.3349139988,
0.4147661924,
-0.0405189022,
-0.0077302009,
-0.4363495708,
-0.4221497476,
0.700845778,
0.541575253,
0.1637747288,
0.3690862656,
-0.0358707979,
0.1643556058,
-0.0154586509,
-0.6945639849,
-0.180500254,
1.013985157,
-0.023538569,
0.6293438077,
0.337610662,
0.9002948999,
0.6291933656,
0.4336021245,
-0.8356872797,
0.7850978374,
-0.0846083313,
-0.7928131819,
-0.4816353321,
-0.5228157043,
-1.3174284697,
0.6973877549,
-0.4178005159,
-0.5183070898,
0.3689339459,
-0.2277843058,
-0.5981485844,
0.1402548254,
-0.6324824095,
0.8167075515,
-0.1164048687,
0.0162404571,
-0.7783285975,
-0.3425971568,
0.5051261187,
-0.2570339143,
0.2968989313,
0.03029407,
0.1465787143,
1.0861676931,
-0.0046091243,
0.701885581,
0.1000812799,
0.1401911527,
0.9119605422,
-0.194626376,
-0.0496322922,
0.1060512289,
-0.0698184893,
0.4083640277,
-0.1693015546,
-0.2035044879,
-0.6451413631,
0.5753616691,
-0.9077942967,
-0.8057635427,
-0.1993397474,
-0.4976698458,
0.1372133642,
-0.0746350884,
0.3476456106,
-0.1044150814,
-0.6485618949,
0.3644444346,
0.464936018,
-0.1120210066,
0.6755188704,
0.3592666686,
-0.5009847879,
-0.9243711829,
0.3301212788,
0.508238256,
0.4911201,
-0.1406328529,
0.0956285521,
0.0940421224,
-0.5258731246,
0.1005524173,
0.0148765221,
-0.8747190833,
0.324906826,
-0.4921549261,
0.4188534319,
-0.1148301736,
0.1269784421,
-0.0511256009,
-0.874812603,
0.0304896645,
-0.293430537,
-0.0205927864,
0.7364274263,
-0.1197592393,
0.5015741587,
-0.402643919,
-0.0807983726,
0.7410764098,
0.30956918,
-0.0953267515,
-0.22227332,
-0.1989731789,
-0.2613949776,
-0.4484895766,
-0.8711244464,
0.0087411795,
-0.3420730829,
0.9024541378,
0.282467097,
-0.1281594038,
0.2301859111,
0.1310648173,
0.7991960645,
0.2195148617,
-0.854881525,
0.360021323,
-0.3638401628,
0.4252435267,
1.0322151184,
-0.0315753333,
-0.5907783508,
-0.4555841684,
-0.7714918852,
-0.5280196071,
0.6167739034,
0.5602737665,
-0.3441007435,
-0.2821214795,
-0.1002881229,
0.1194353029,
0.2446588576,
-0.5306999087,
-0.2324341089,
-0.1167791337,
0.1146608219,
0.1891724467,
-0.0861702114,
-0.4227130711,
-0.416764915,
0.1437391043,
0.147968635,
0.1141818613,
-0.0099063553,
0.3902574182,
-0.2379101962,
0.5065943003,
0.6345548034,
0.7432143688,
-0.0131571312,
0.0660048425,
0.6437498927,
-0.470972091,
-0.2703141868,
-0.1497195661,
0.0054015778,
-0.2544317544,
0.219460696,
0.4132711589,
-0.3149947524,
-0.3852521777,
0.1595670283,
-0.7037752867,
-0.3082130253,
-0.3248153329,
0.3837864697,
-0.0086292466,
0.3757789433,
0.2818836272,
0.3968114853,
0.2420488298,
-0.810289681,
0.1005716026,
0.500318706,
-0.1205918044,
0.1010307744,
0.135382086,
0.490242213,
-0.3441184759,
0.8715539575,
-0.2859157622,
-0.44396469,
0.9248117805,
0.0065831533,
0.9013713598,
-0.1812685728,
0.1315900981,
0.1838337332,
0.6539776921,
0.0185923595,
0.2734561265,
-0.1306609809,
-0.8057693243,
-0.2272327989,
-0.1205113381,
-0.4219523668,
-0.1247111708,
-0.480166465,
-0.2029143423,
-0.6444232464,
-0.7634404898,
-0.2523721159,
-0.0472721905,
-0.8158195615,
0.2112608254,
0.2004274428,
0.5568930507,
-0.6425578594,
0.4699881077,
0.3913629949,
-0.4948575497,
-0.4682274461,
0.1584915221,
-0.1485353559,
-0.4470739365,
0.8632019758,
0.1390030235,
-0.0683683529,
-0.4679239392,
-0.7012851238,
-0.9121437073,
1.0875610113,
-0.0773719624,
-0.2385321409,
0.522842586,
0.0104270391,
0.5669637918,
-0.5363991261,
0.4426054955,
0.4322501421,
0.5854598284,
0.2390729487,
-0.9091543555,
-0.2036918104,
-0.2635630071,
-0.1654951572,
0.0220143385,
-0.7788155675,
1.1245595217,
-0.1378215104,
-0.3924602866,
-0.3121322095,
0.8051959276,
0.2068425864,
0.3680751622,
0.8445911407,
0.3839405477,
1.3907091618,
-0.0050234441,
1.0959918499,
-0.0465034731,
0.1241116822,
1.1691304445,
-0.1414393336,
0.4267241061,
0.5193610191,
-0.1863276958,
0.5216899514,
0.5931995511,
0.1015433744,
0.3582204282,
0.4553955793,
-0.4854598939,
-0.3271287084,
0.0252109729,
-0.2386141121,
0.6073327661,
0.615701139,
-0.3163045645,
0.1338668615,
-0.1558048725,
-0.3296063244,
-0.0906337202,
-0.5556768179,
0.4891644418,
0.0532888249,
-0.8661753535,
0.1317813396,
-0.1056222543,
0.5466548204,
-0.4405564368,
0.0743201897,
-0.4141395092,
0.2220620364,
-0.3964327574,
-0.8571613431,
0.2767215669,
-0.3475490808,
-0.3905698657,
0.0038941316,
0.6189020276,
-0.4656217992,
-0.0798976496,
0.5015946031,
0.9348251224,
0.0974424779,
0.0362355858,
-0.3947122097,
0.3912594914,
0.327477634,
-0.0447226986,
0.2010863572,
0.5197062492,
-0.4028990865,
0.3980805278,
0.3726647198,
-0.3077113926,
0.1132181212,
0.3321103454,
0.7245257497,
-0.7219666839,
-0.6752935648,
-0.9322232008,
0.2985778153,
-0.6169606447,
-0.4999213815,
0.7993246317,
0.6109045148,
1.0016309023,
-0.1684666425,
0.9218843579,
-0.080223687,
0.0491494089,
-0.2159209847,
0.5256906152,
-0.1040970311,
0.2623345852,
-0.162899211,
-0.8522624373,
-0.2652287185,
0.6051709056,
-0.8364711404,
0.2982492745,
0.9065164924,
0.6231159568,
0.038337592,
0.9745198488,
0.1454847455,
-0.0000935134,
0.4981116652,
0.4374595284,
1.3859937191,
0.1742268652,
0.7094640732,
0.2846979797,
-0.4498494565,
0.1193906069,
-0.5365254283,
-1.160995841,
-0.0935121924,
-0.4654474854,
-0.0689532533,
-0.3873053491,
1.0708520412,
0.2817378044,
-0.5146296024,
-0.4530203044,
0.079164423,
0.2659127116,
-0.0456455164,
-0.162763074,
-0.0675002262,
-0.1284273863,
-0.6487778425,
0.1539907902,
0.2392176837,
-0.0186042618,
0.0592314415,
-0.2101141363,
-0.2103804052,
0.2246451825,
0.6500819325,
0.1899804324,
-0.5984709263,
-0.1307563484,
-0.4158857763,
-0.229937911,
0.0816007555,
1.0488498211,
-0.3894028664,
0.4497430623,
0.5186014771,
0.6063794494,
0.8132129312,
-0.080194138,
0.3852206469,
-0.1938602477,
-0.0417271256,
0.1411382854,
0.3616203666,
0.0953999162,
-0.0838772357,
0.8013337851,
0.4142997265,
-0.630517602,
0.0698307604,
0.348485738,
-1.206957221,
-0.3889080882,
1.0334913731,
0.2269486487,
-0.0036332647,
-0.2508657873,
-0.7338603735,
0.1818529814,
-0.6174556613,
0.9465585351,
1.1085469723,
-0.4714537263,
0.2234060466,
-0.2685897052,
0.5206249356,
0.6378916502,
-1.0781079531,
-0.262470305,
0.7950510383,
-0.0797973648,
0.3038683236,
0.8229756951,
-0.0927428082,
0.1257249713,
0.0202479791,
-0.1032774597,
0.3452293873,
0.0779803842,
-0.2494435906,
0.3986414373,
-0.093157582,
-0.0859847069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01423v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01423v1
|
Different Tastes of Entities: Investigating Human Label Variation in Named Entity Annotations
| 2024-02-02T14:08:34 | 2024-02-02T14:08:34 |
Siyao Peng, Zihang Sun, Sebastian Loftus, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a key information extraction task with a
long-standing tradition. While recent studies address and aim to correct
annotation errors via re-labeling efforts, little is known about the sources of
human label variation, such as text ambiguity, annotation error, or guideline
divergence. This is especially the case for high-quality datasets and beyond
English CoNLL03. This paper studies disagreements in expert-annotated named
entity datasets for three languages: English, Danish, and Bavarian. We show
that text ambiguity and artificial guideline changes are dominant factors for
diverse annotations among high-quality revisions. We survey student annotations
on a subset of difficult entities and substantiate the feasibility and
necessity of manifold annotations for understanding named entity ambiguities
from a distributional perspective.
|
[
-0.7721081376,
-0.6397336721,
0.4073428214,
0.1662760675,
-0.1930124909,
0.2694914341,
-0.1726843864,
-0.8497543931,
0.3917102814,
0.4933331013,
-0.4412052631,
-0.5151999593,
-0.8391122818,
0.5431774259,
0.1528351456,
0.9004249573,
-0.5023133159,
0.2995182574,
-0.0212647635,
-0.6118834615,
-0.4398145676,
-0.6886950135,
-0.6251437068,
-0.4364481568,
1.000443697,
0.446020335,
0.5932855606,
0.457660377,
0.5926502347,
0.1964535713,
-0.459694773,
0.1608191133,
-0.0674152002,
0.4275515079,
-0.3270317018,
-0.5494347811,
-0.1602929831,
0.0318507515,
0.4757576883,
0.9746949077,
0.1715462208,
0.0459039919,
-0.0575423464,
0.6218382716,
-0.6388636827,
0.003679062,
-0.3572596312,
-0.0009301475,
-0.607177794,
0.0046054167,
-0.3498439789,
-0.168857947,
0.5074263811,
-0.7897033095,
0.4774916172,
0.0524655469,
1.3715273142,
0.4474998713,
-0.6235659122,
-0.3020943403,
-0.7108250856,
0.6740231514,
-0.405474484,
0.7717166543,
0.3050142229,
0.3823480606,
-0.0964454859,
-0.4828025997,
-0.3209273517,
0.2233711928,
-0.1109962091,
-0.1824139804,
-0.1124636903,
-0.288243711,
0.2133285403,
0.1079655811,
0.0251338743,
0.426944226,
-0.1930517256,
-0.1712241918,
0.7628490329,
-0.0830179453,
0.3193055093,
-0.314353615,
-0.1606547832,
-0.1916759312,
-0.9150128961,
0.0367746763,
0.8125612736,
0.0842032433,
0.1179643348,
0.494014442,
-0.3194231391,
0.6000148654,
-0.0407296941,
0.0316194631,
0.6940026283,
0.2158216983,
-0.1064507067,
0.2767324746,
0.6149669886,
0.1891153604,
0.2945230305,
-0.3692559004,
-0.3846904635,
-0.3867993653,
-0.0726333857,
-0.3758968711,
-0.4571657181,
-0.1690890789,
-0.2342076302,
-0.0557112731,
0.2272966653,
-0.6523677111,
-0.6790510416,
-0.45938465,
0.0758856535,
-0.1439872086,
-0.3165596426,
-0.0568606108,
-0.3000474572,
0.034673322,
0.7133850455,
-0.7951529622,
-0.0310037788,
0.5763993859,
0.4032772183,
-0.4625970721,
-0.3489457071,
-0.0607601926,
0.0977850407,
-0.3709622622,
1.1005862951,
-0.6910829544,
-0.4031878114,
-0.3356177509,
0.2186990827,
0.0545789599,
-0.8287481666,
0.6123809218,
-0.5351384878,
0.0988265052,
-0.6527259946,
-0.6582493782,
-0.3038959503,
0.0486523025,
-0.8057386875,
0.74759233,
0.0411071815,
-1.1312087774,
0.9235118032,
-0.3419508934,
-0.3972492516,
0.4397893846,
-0.5539948344,
-0.1277210712,
0.2888838947,
0.3215785027,
0.2466758937,
-0.0574687123,
0.2490174621,
-0.1397160292,
-0.0344613194,
0.5750689507,
-0.4703199565,
0.7780348063,
0.0941608399,
-0.268229425,
-0.1257924885,
-0.7750146985,
-0.2750711143,
-0.0544009171,
-0.5918694139,
-0.8230891228,
0.1290206909,
0.1733067781,
-0.0945259482,
0.011290906,
-0.5014978647,
0.2116160095,
-0.1612466276,
0.3645519316,
0.7201417685,
0.5289904475,
0.2948628664,
-0.0973315462,
0.5122771859,
0.4033868015,
-0.1402541995,
0.1481753886,
-0.72579211,
-0.7881422043,
-0.1910798252,
0.8349394202,
0.3974055648,
-0.6704503894,
-0.0188281685,
-0.1232849807,
-0.4492894411,
-0.8594142199,
0.0050703725,
0.097572349,
0.554199636,
0.4857635498,
-0.0507311262,
-0.499199003,
-1.275827527,
-0.5370708108,
-0.1450270265,
0.0449836403,
0.7101711631,
0.4651464224,
-0.3586249352,
1.092066288,
-0.4853093326,
-0.055453144,
-0.0153216645,
0.4339395761,
-0.0256634131,
0.425502032,
0.4123027623,
-1.1078451872,
-0.4153851867,
0.1437602192,
-0.514909327,
0.0281737931,
-0.1962810308,
-0.227494508,
0.4113788903,
0.2292802781,
-0.3021563888,
0.2512927949,
0.1979225874,
-0.0996648893,
0.3624659181,
-0.0277003385,
0.1849045753,
-1.0037819147,
-0.2885351181,
0.2140097022,
0.0522345491,
-0.3451188505,
-0.1371770799,
0.0808512121,
0.5309218168,
-0.5376466513,
0.8150810003,
-0.7353969216,
0.2391179502,
0.1927533299,
0.0947246179,
0.0260817725,
-0.0425767936,
0.319350034,
0.4928304255,
0.4170249701,
-0.6788470149,
0.2304510772,
0.309173435,
-0.2610960305,
0.9096409082,
-0.4685096443,
0.0145106046,
-0.4285285771,
0.1378282905,
-0.676797688,
-0.6950686574,
0.3885013461,
-0.3480766118,
0.4294374287,
-0.4298242033,
-0.4080759883,
-0.0662033185,
0.277587682,
0.3236260712,
0.1330653429,
-0.5366702676,
0.3257956505,
0.4962863922,
-0.0751963854,
-0.7821190953,
-0.8330942988,
0.2936277092,
-0.385129571,
-0.4652701914,
0.1654563397,
0.0309187174,
-0.5674686432,
0.1493812054,
-0.2422214895,
-0.2941187918,
0.1756281704,
0.2851684391,
0.0179577582,
-0.1329396665,
0.3974421322,
0.1914483905,
-0.030242173,
-0.0322185047,
0.0162327457,
0.0670842305,
0.1042971238,
-0.2027228773,
-0.1947611719,
0.2863171101,
-0.0505616032,
-0.2043364346,
0.4590100646,
0.4090744555,
-0.625146687,
0.0545681268,
-0.7878935933,
-0.0565490723,
-0.3712261915,
0.14259848,
-0.7162000537,
-0.7359828949,
0.7872204781,
0.1189196259,
0.0763689354,
0.5834178329,
0.1837877333,
-0.2626630664,
0.7203756571,
0.4572980404,
0.375110358,
0.2333691865,
0.073224023,
-0.017483741,
-0.8899604082,
-0.3561725616,
-0.6591455936,
-0.5191877484,
-0.9776229262,
-0.1129660532,
-0.1546230763,
0.1496523917,
-0.0310098622,
0.264346689,
-0.4685575962,
0.6535173655,
0.3717785776,
-0.0359344818,
0.2282134593,
0.090481177,
0.0170414615,
-0.5206153989,
-0.1344139427,
-0.7561168075,
0.6866074204,
0.4531723559,
0.7939870358,
0.3273001909,
1.2004249096,
0.1482035518,
0.4461438954,
-0.5982808471,
0.1326784492,
0.0202559307,
-0.8793897629,
-0.2393909842,
-0.4946110249,
-1.0995465517,
0.3420934677,
-0.1525647789,
-1.0029751062,
0.9015011787,
0.1042654961,
0.0682956353,
0.289077729,
-0.7426285148,
0.7248423696,
-0.0561910942,
-0.0470900908,
0.5711174011,
-0.6887824535,
-0.0182724781,
-0.2151364684,
0.1684032232,
-0.2681309283,
-0.1548113078,
0.9672759175,
-0.0833643973,
0.5755698085,
-0.1646209359,
-0.3406039178,
0.194526732,
0.154136762,
0.4254285097,
0.3563849032,
-0.0697026327,
0.3191170394,
-0.1378078759,
-0.3431234062,
-0.347065717,
0.5474449992,
-0.9204064608,
-0.7120659947,
-0.3172581494,
-0.2452464551,
-0.1676414013,
0.3153977394,
0.7366563082,
0.1678545475,
-0.0187796541,
0.1311456412,
0.7472933531,
-0.1103558913,
0.3016489148,
0.2796015739,
0.0748684332,
-0.4794676006,
0.8709921837,
0.5986655354,
-0.1046638265,
0.2604953349,
-0.1134886667,
-0.1304267198,
-0.4201151133,
-0.7847858667,
0.2873180211,
-0.9654291272,
-0.0631546155,
-0.8734859824,
0.0600952767,
-0.1512269825,
-0.2678766549,
-0.2298505753,
-0.4493323565,
-0.7303836942,
-0.2758247554,
0.3083045483,
0.9846758842,
0.219315961,
0.1389059722,
-0.4828583598,
0.0448275954,
0.0709842891,
0.1935671419,
-0.3665576577,
-0.233576417,
0.027668504,
0.1011343077,
-0.0609536879,
-1.6785145998,
0.0811551213,
-0.10739097,
0.7517349124,
0.3230427206,
0.0070282388,
0.380792886,
-0.2750998735,
0.6727262735,
-0.0612321533,
-0.7050787807,
0.3553664982,
-0.2204003036,
-0.0117272716,
0.6389898658,
0.5732150078,
-0.8112547994,
-0.4014486074,
-0.7359321713,
-1.179782629,
0.5152559876,
-0.0978332683,
0.0124398908,
-0.1117598414,
0.5389782786,
0.4704534411,
0.1784319133,
-0.657858789,
-0.5687919259,
-0.033581201,
-0.0835225508,
-0.1817373186,
-0.1389602572,
-0.1598665863,
-0.0124127716,
0.5700198412,
0.1412067413,
-0.213853687,
0.378149271,
-0.3181726336,
0.0011151491,
0.6432085633,
0.4798155725,
0.8633092642,
-0.1128830612,
0.428490907,
0.2752707005,
-0.4603634477,
0.4027174711,
0.2428141385,
-0.544485867,
0.377730608,
0.1563318074,
1.0530738831,
0.0381077863,
-0.1462548673,
0.1368275732,
-0.2399960905,
-0.2085654289,
-0.2642802,
0.0479095839,
0.2162234485,
0.1708225757,
0.4649698138,
0.1888472587,
0.2543810904,
-0.024538042,
0.0719557256,
-0.0382461064,
-0.6101723909,
-0.1537167877,
0.5084014535,
0.2352320254,
-0.3832024634,
0.6547769904,
-0.4379182756,
-0.1568835676,
0.4817682803,
0.1502880156,
0.763795197,
0.0908603072,
0.3687446117,
0.0676201954,
0.3001805544,
0.0333094858,
0.0866371989,
0.1210002825,
-0.7371832728,
-0.2667653859,
-0.3631215394,
-0.6012423635,
-0.2360693961,
-0.8079988956,
0.4307737648,
-0.1868896484,
-0.5021028519,
0.4040694833,
-0.4270792007,
-0.9493202567,
0.21625036,
0.1080326587,
0.7176253796,
-0.7560231686,
0.4472075403,
1.5397964716,
-0.4891389906,
-0.7157728076,
0.157715112,
-0.0910655633,
-0.1306936443,
1.1404560804,
0.0835660622,
0.3183787465,
-0.0119695626,
-0.3836970627,
-0.7573065758,
0.7160736918,
0.3055884838,
-0.6346295476,
-0.044398766,
0.0156290401,
0.5478906631,
-0.3438621759,
0.2842707336,
0.5354712605,
0.6390095949,
-0.061530266,
-0.548773706,
-0.0856385529,
-0.063988708,
-0.1124051809,
0.4388713241,
-0.41763708,
0.8545200229,
-0.291413337,
-0.3627207875,
-0.5762605071,
0.5909019709,
0.2767965794,
0.4249040782,
0.3709465861,
0.4287029803,
1.0834674835,
-0.424834758,
0.6451309323,
0.2442408353,
0.3445582688,
1.2914521694,
-0.2263108939,
0.753054738,
0.6556981802,
-0.1006819978,
0.6155604124,
1.2977406979,
-0.129868269,
0.1585906297,
0.3591987789,
-0.160301432,
-0.2806429565,
-0.165877834,
-0.4135807157,
0.260027051,
0.3532344103,
-0.2019969225,
-0.0650677681,
-0.0748398155,
0.3073065877,
-0.3740577102,
0.1512096226,
0.860296905,
-0.1090924665,
-0.554836154,
0.4232025146,
0.0107738487,
0.5312458873,
0.1513118893,
0.0089885443,
-0.2165398449,
-0.1467380971,
-0.4168821275,
-0.8768873215,
-0.1743590385,
-0.0986875892,
-0.2138128281,
0.0471079051,
0.3901888132,
-0.170586288,
-0.459356606,
0.0661738217,
0.5138781667,
0.4466738999,
0.0849478319,
-0.5054396987,
-0.1955310255,
0.1609124839,
-0.4816985726,
-0.0274670906,
0.7167970538,
-0.2584415674,
0.4667944312,
0.1791324764,
0.2234410644,
0.380138427,
0.1731214821,
0.5988481045,
-0.4637003541,
-0.3022792637,
-0.6565229297,
0.5171027184,
-0.1628305018,
-0.7927282453,
0.6788537502,
0.4417186975,
1.2541618347,
-0.0165782291,
0.7454127073,
0.0633630306,
0.4920029044,
-0.2766053677,
0.4944522977,
-0.6502885818,
0.2034594715,
-0.3378977478,
-1.2084281445,
-0.4379043281,
0.525586009,
-0.4222500324,
0.1364130676,
0.5292908549,
0.1131146699,
-0.0264379233,
0.0115351835,
0.0353836417,
0.0341142341,
0.5028315187,
0.0484680161,
0.9640603065,
-0.2412999272,
0.1491402537,
-0.382835418,
0.1613118351,
-0.2937065065,
-0.6728607416,
-0.5497683883,
-0.5391410589,
-0.8039647341,
-0.311441958,
0.2555319369,
0.964563787,
0.5272957683,
-0.8268964887,
0.1699421108,
-0.0199562199,
0.3230561912,
-0.018733684,
-0.2756949663,
0.2489017099,
-0.1929261982,
-0.9117901325,
-0.0767226517,
-0.0233358666,
0.602666676,
-0.2065295726,
-0.2301063389,
0.077083163,
-0.0396695919,
-0.0428825542,
0.3355098963,
-0.8672757149,
-0.3918907642,
-0.0759308636,
-0.1318838298,
0.2252349108,
0.7709967494,
-0.3441934288,
0.5317234397,
0.5583609939,
0.6775175929,
0.1767591536,
0.0085376939,
0.1363975406,
-0.9496660829,
-0.0169788096,
0.2200361639,
0.5420286059,
0.7372629642,
-0.4835552871,
0.5148973465,
0.4009650946,
-0.5874328017,
-0.8630684018,
0.3154325485,
-0.6533173919,
-0.2297413051,
1.3581906557,
-0.2899987698,
-0.183974728,
-0.3196412325,
-0.2986727953,
0.1725603789,
-0.4754806161,
0.4585869312,
1.174900651,
-0.3718069196,
-0.1962253004,
-0.7578917742,
0.5536268353,
0.1853760779,
-0.7406695485,
-0.0197414719,
0.534046948,
0.3620009422,
0.2716361284,
0.3377417922,
0.0841969475,
-0.0864872932,
-0.1772665381,
0.2577718198,
0.2447297275,
-0.4217357635,
-0.0639428049,
-0.1172968298,
0.3784291446,
-0.0137953768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01416v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01416v1
|
Sequence Shortening for Context-Aware Machine Translation
| 2024-02-02T13:55:37 | 2024-02-02T13:55:37 |
Paweł Mąka, Yusuf Can Semerci, Jan Scholtes, Gerasimos Spanakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Context-aware Machine Translation aims to improve translations of sentences
by incorporating surrounding sentences as context. Towards this task, two main
architectures have been applied, namely single-encoder (based on concatenation)
and multi-encoder models. In this study, we show that a special case of
multi-encoder architecture, where the latent representation of the source
sentence is cached and reused as the context in the next step, achieves higher
accuracy on the contrastive datasets (where the models have to rank the correct
translation among the provided sentences) and comparable BLEU and COMET scores
as the single- and multi-encoder approaches. Furthermore, we investigate the
application of Sequence Shortening to the cached representations. We test three
pooling-based shortening techniques and introduce two novel methods - Latent
Grouping and Latent Selecting, where the network learns to group tokens or
selects the tokens to be cached as context. Our experiments show that the two
methods achieve competitive BLEU and COMET scores and accuracies on the
contrastive datasets to the other tested methods while potentially allowing for
higher interpretability and reducing the growth of memory requirements with
increased context size.
|
[
-0.4117352068,
-0.5411279202,
0.2165333182,
0.30957219,
-0.6601581573,
-0.1428393871,
-0.4154530168,
-0.3589124084,
0.2621561289,
0.288690269,
-0.2453069538,
-0.1683139056,
-0.575694561,
0.3067030609,
-0.4202997088,
0.7768468261,
0.0132195465,
-0.0475857668,
-0.0756358579,
-0.586355567,
-0.9231162667,
-0.6089293957,
-0.3966308236,
-0.0292516947,
0.6061499119,
0.5459881425,
0.8900184035,
0.7576121688,
0.4171814322,
0.2331554294,
-0.1683808267,
0.1807536483,
-0.3377405703,
0.4623555541,
-0.068607904,
-0.225144133,
-0.1784307659,
-0.2589536011,
0.9248231649,
0.7435230017,
0.2103615254,
-0.0287361182,
0.2622418404,
0.7751997113,
-0.8470358849,
-0.0529435948,
-0.5052157044,
0.0244287085,
-0.3134354949,
-0.3908718824,
-0.5300680399,
0.1436807364,
0.1673490256,
-0.3458597064,
0.1882446706,
0.0658557266,
0.4920419753,
0.541626513,
-0.6090423465,
-0.200578928,
-0.5245170593,
0.8378966451,
-0.7348273396,
0.4193966985,
0.0397053361,
0.3922260106,
0.0382305197,
-0.5723949671,
-0.4266231358,
0.3828351796,
-0.508210063,
0.2303186208,
0.3983561993,
-0.1675319523,
0.1104438081,
0.3692707717,
-0.7180873752,
0.2024125606,
-0.3604333997,
-0.1622570008,
0.420250982,
0.0766022578,
-0.0052183811,
-0.185524106,
-0.5232937336,
-0.160600096,
-0.6961089373,
-0.1513065547,
-0.0699081868,
0.5566799641,
-0.1290525645,
0.5343302488,
-0.157933861,
0.6923582554,
0.0726554021,
0.4538295865,
0.3978684545,
-0.5379782915,
-0.2519263923,
0.3450550735,
0.6811981201,
0.2880051136,
-0.0717050806,
-0.2003198564,
-0.2527290285,
-0.100489825,
0.1163248569,
-1.0685429573,
0.1812451035,
0.4018781185,
-0.6879611611,
0.1868876666,
0.1979965717,
-0.6931193471,
-0.0451521985,
-0.0162824597,
0.3448870182,
-0.3970039487,
0.3067334592,
0.1661457568,
-0.1659500599,
0.3697534204,
0.2311424613,
-0.7192593813,
0.2652924359,
0.4102884829,
1.0129457712,
-0.2988385558,
-0.3935045004,
-0.868658483,
0.2182001472,
-0.1239586622,
0.3138906658,
-0.5502319336,
-0.589614749,
-0.0795581937,
0.0113395602,
-0.2524110675,
-0.4064910114,
0.4262800217,
-0.7712084651,
0.4403882325,
-0.2281329781,
-0.6803261042,
-0.2922143638,
0.1661990285,
-0.9102296829,
0.6743934751,
-0.0524074025,
-0.8060021996,
0.2671778798,
-0.7352139354,
-0.629150331,
0.0725352019,
-0.0299610291,
-0.4952742457,
0.1652884185,
0.5272355676,
0.6378689408,
-0.1047795564,
0.2354964167,
0.031220993,
-0.7217592001,
0.1674571633,
-0.4504130483,
0.3354541063,
0.394585222,
-0.2606089413,
0.1674011052,
-0.2856871486,
-0.0851737186,
-0.1168110222,
-0.5254238248,
-0.402864337,
0.0926162973,
0.1956229508,
0.3159125149,
0.1863046587,
-0.1841143817,
0.0836472884,
-0.4930688143,
0.4920968413,
0.3862850368,
0.1259648651,
0.7390117049,
-0.3678767979,
0.1330127716,
0.2941178083,
-0.007229594,
-0.7273489237,
-0.4967215359,
-0.6511618495,
-0.0891728923,
0.3983256817,
0.6301579475,
-0.6657319665,
0.5371246934,
-0.6373826861,
-0.0383199602,
-0.4287783206,
-0.0299157538,
0.5338323712,
0.5231338143,
0.8319487572,
-0.7252750993,
-0.3492935896,
-0.6543023586,
-0.1685931236,
0.36949417,
0.160577625,
0.3501399457,
0.5466423035,
-0.3878254592,
0.8864744306,
-0.2003866732,
-0.0695416182,
-0.0125595611,
-0.0693921149,
0.213477999,
0.8974880576,
0.4445677698,
-1.31539011,
-0.4560922384,
-0.1151858568,
-0.4870967865,
0.3063300252,
-0.1368451566,
0.0018386482,
0.1887783408,
0.2770866454,
-0.5291137695,
0.5563828349,
0.5010514855,
-0.2505611181,
0.4807282984,
-0.3271801472,
0.4034224451,
-1.2807364464,
0.3308345377,
-0.4110251665,
-0.4879253805,
-0.5814528465,
0.1489683092,
0.1744683236,
-0.0535742417,
-0.8338510394,
0.6649234891,
-0.5790271163,
-0.2879503369,
-0.3038655221,
0.2472994328,
0.2151590884,
0.2795686424,
-0.0723391324,
1.002560854,
0.39722386,
-0.8877097964,
0.0028943813,
0.3574910164,
-0.3150861561,
0.1059008613,
-0.6089819074,
0.1422715932,
-0.0646575317,
0.435236752,
-0.6765490174,
-0.1693243831,
0.08254724,
-0.281930536,
0.3540395498,
-0.0536978133,
-0.5655744076,
-0.2002961338,
-0.0983968526,
0.8334637284,
0.4074247777,
-0.6078689098,
0.1264805198,
-0.0803050026,
0.1244086027,
-0.8373903632,
-1.0335867405,
0.0802770779,
-0.5480954647,
-0.527706027,
0.8569310904,
-0.2295184433,
0.1061759889,
0.0238872282,
-0.1504516006,
-0.1313689947,
0.2390329689,
0.105717957,
-0.1100430563,
-0.3176329732,
0.3254720271,
0.2073628157,
-0.1730767787,
-0.4914092124,
-0.4169765711,
0.4682502747,
-0.2343818992,
-0.3160939515,
-0.3200872242,
0.5990885496,
0.4262161255,
-0.3524193764,
1.0873422623,
0.6243605018,
-0.4113984704,
0.1351833791,
-0.3555524945,
-0.4104550481,
-0.4284294844,
0.0567536317,
-0.5246120095,
-1.3312462568,
0.8139882684,
-0.284617722,
-0.2317197025,
0.3777600229,
0.4232196808,
0.1222857386,
0.5996421576,
0.4053431451,
-0.2371481061,
0.4894849956,
-0.2772581875,
0.1995757222,
-0.9789305329,
0.0349829383,
-0.4406875372,
-0.4487618208,
-0.6695947051,
-0.6707737446,
0.1996533573,
0.433062464,
-0.1001409739,
0.4492942989,
-0.2657487094,
0.6337518096,
0.281471312,
0.0163042024,
0.0260951985,
-0.3223941624,
-0.3408819139,
0.0814242214,
-0.7407341003,
-0.5434531569,
0.6723954678,
-0.2161771804,
0.0627592802,
0.2485356331,
0.6529348493,
0.2755822539,
0.04293897,
-0.5645153522,
0.304271847,
-0.2858344316,
-0.4608146846,
-0.3129792809,
-0.4569844604,
-1.1962202787,
0.7226520777,
-0.0823356435,
-0.5936040878,
0.1885243654,
0.1212626696,
-0.2587444782,
-0.0050724898,
-0.6009081006,
1.1649985313,
-0.2363312244,
-0.3893893659,
-0.2907029986,
-1.2496352196,
0.0893063545,
-0.1278568357,
0.3162342012,
0.1819133759,
-0.1151361763,
0.4822534323,
-0.6030529737,
0.5668664575,
-0.1787941009,
0.3651114702,
0.261710912,
-0.0367163196,
0.430601269,
0.12984626,
-0.3190017939,
-0.0210272074,
-0.2533574104,
-0.6273723841,
-0.6334710717,
0.802036345,
-0.4321742058,
-0.4952458441,
-0.0866237357,
-0.3161134422,
0.0263307448,
0.3889745474,
0.2467689961,
0.4562962353,
-0.2601587474,
0.3976387382,
0.4637650549,
-0.2945790589,
0.7909421921,
0.1240964457,
0.107722275,
-0.2842146158,
0.4323961437,
-0.1605404764,
0.1585887223,
0.8172635436,
0.2548063397,
-0.2150040567,
-0.4818307161,
-0.5755566359,
-0.0680616796,
-0.766274929,
-0.2555278242,
-0.5598262548,
0.0343909338,
-0.4546464086,
-0.3726939857,
-0.3675435483,
-0.5892668366,
-0.3089156449,
0.0538144112,
0.1423324943,
0.202333048,
0.0698591918,
0.7208560705,
-1.1308099031,
-0.0389460698,
0.0472805165,
0.1190490052,
0.0000378934,
-0.4607296288,
-0.6001905203,
-0.0810587704,
-0.1090680435,
-0.9795436263,
0.5519417524,
0.3680189252,
0.3959355652,
0.3688879311,
-0.0517089516,
0.9604258537,
-0.7814895511,
0.805316031,
0.0165351275,
-1.0780377388,
0.6375095248,
-0.1202233508,
0.5679269433,
0.6004585028,
0.224047482,
-0.7288044095,
-0.0162790902,
-0.2578342855,
-1.0928820372,
0.4702234268,
0.3441346586,
0.1788461655,
-0.2251437902,
0.6393669844,
0.3140530884,
0.164028123,
-0.344925344,
-0.2826727927,
-0.3076143861,
-0.1053705812,
-0.434155196,
-0.0840949938,
0.2621617913,
0.1773148775,
0.46767205,
-0.2454312295,
0.1385409385,
0.3093892038,
-0.5860236883,
0.2869488895,
0.5983480215,
0.5449515581,
0.4691938758,
-0.1487686932,
0.1256560236,
0.1807067692,
-0.0399578325,
-0.1051620245,
0.0689728931,
-0.1226587519,
0.0959177241,
0.2992009223,
0.8350328207,
0.4783197939,
-0.5635977983,
0.6633298397,
-0.085647665,
0.432053864,
0.0497415215,
-0.1465211362,
0.0503211394,
0.1112355143,
0.2792029381,
0.3107718825,
0.3615909517,
-0.289111346,
0.4365075231,
0.0507565588,
-0.370111376,
-0.3042467237,
0.5377429128,
0.2356608659,
-0.108858861,
0.7432174683,
-0.1938708127,
-0.5671274662,
0.49444139,
0.5606497526,
0.6730165482,
-0.2875206172,
-0.2228139639,
0.4027637541,
0.0242156796,
-0.3298916817,
0.0888859108,
-0.2511245608,
-0.7620095015,
-0.6154789329,
-0.3479693234,
-0.3234554827,
-0.2460499704,
-0.8430125117,
0.0448777862,
0.1553173512,
-0.0995490924,
-0.4451835454,
-0.0111341318,
-0.8398424387,
0.2426982671,
-0.0802321285,
0.824231565,
-0.6795608997,
0.9526620507,
0.6219781041,
-0.400639832,
-0.3495235741,
0.1960482746,
-0.0969481468,
-0.1742566079,
0.533259213,
0.7940302491,
0.0386162922,
-0.1177596375,
-0.1494696587,
-0.8881799579,
1.2220723629,
0.1633457392,
-0.6479197145,
0.1615411788,
-0.1078004465,
0.3161942065,
-0.5815241337,
0.0100132879,
0.2041186988,
0.4320192039,
-0.0440429635,
-0.9176222086,
0.3700934947,
-0.2556241453,
0.2398634851,
0.1544284374,
-0.6253290772,
0.7832731605,
-0.2072782069,
-0.503842473,
0.2231811136,
0.6905936003,
0.2018155456,
0.2427583486,
0.3204784095,
0.38771227,
0.8336197138,
-0.0004734533,
1.179546833,
-0.4798520803,
0.1602136046,
1.3608967066,
-0.2790471911,
0.9380268455,
0.6071714759,
0.4491578937,
0.5006358027,
0.684574604,
0.3517708182,
0.8511427641,
0.2032589614,
-0.1013881564,
-0.0659957528,
0.1124521047,
-0.4479568601,
0.3226397932,
0.4840745628,
-0.3768443167,
0.0428818054,
0.149609372,
-0.1098564044,
0.0780257732,
-0.1337513775,
0.5465284586,
0.2681670785,
-0.6143544316,
0.3584029078,
0.3944833279,
0.7533537745,
-0.1423233151,
0.1372427046,
-0.3188725114,
0.1599919647,
-0.019834809,
-0.4268016517,
0.5955221057,
-0.1857678294,
-0.2652595639,
-0.4147618711,
0.6702275872,
-0.4638389945,
0.0075076013,
0.3758402765,
0.7879981399,
0.3881264925,
-0.038498912,
-0.6181644201,
0.0339676328,
-0.5619941354,
-0.1563933641,
0.1866922677,
0.4938782156,
-0.2479773611,
0.3719779849,
0.3807311058,
-0.1739996821,
0.2465797663,
0.3032556474,
0.8048668504,
-0.7955086231,
-0.6546199918,
-1.0044959784,
0.5134961605,
-0.0297962893,
-0.1646387428,
0.7153588533,
0.8925740719,
0.9333283901,
-0.1140348986,
0.4661604762,
0.0952695906,
0.0274164043,
-0.7339030504,
0.5228013992,
-0.4430276155,
0.1989828795,
0.0537538491,
-0.9111283422,
-0.6589326859,
0.4571775198,
-0.0410698093,
0.028985044,
0.9203823209,
0.5660848618,
-0.2033866048,
-0.0878219455,
0.2271875739,
-0.0815902129,
0.1548634022,
0.6165111661,
0.5311173201,
-0.7522813082,
0.345512569,
0.0684267581,
0.0966731533,
-0.3879869878,
-0.9312946796,
-0.7095168233,
-0.5901712179,
-0.2877062857,
-0.1344175637,
0.2107132375,
0.6490842104,
0.9437782764,
-0.8200749159,
-0.1054133549,
0.0356843248,
0.3143508434,
-0.4952470362,
-0.1549917459,
0.5727912784,
-0.4390245974,
-0.5573219061,
0.7680754066,
0.3374337256,
0.0452939905,
0.149024412,
-0.4191042483,
-0.1806377172,
-0.0059478227,
0.5376378298,
0.0146096684,
-0.6945924163,
-0.372338742,
-0.2733129263,
-0.0857784376,
0.3501942158,
0.9055423141,
-0.9924766421,
0.4565250874,
0.6116962433,
0.7773532271,
0.6694695354,
0.1965948641,
0.4313461185,
-1.1687848568,
0.2830180526,
0.1216753423,
0.6116854548,
0.6750801206,
-0.3232183754,
0.4040257633,
0.0777686909,
-0.4318973124,
-0.3340414166,
0.2689079344,
-0.906037569,
-0.4188492894,
0.8147727251,
-0.3467342556,
-0.2152009159,
0.0113215381,
0.2013289332,
0.4778117836,
-0.3423634768,
0.5133097768,
0.4060869515,
0.1144569144,
-0.0004680221,
-0.2802417576,
0.2273629904,
0.6188409328,
-0.6157460809,
-0.2292186767,
0.5186806321,
0.0057218894,
0.2127253711,
0.5907582045,
-0.1336343139,
0.1751407981,
-0.251367867,
-0.3170004487,
0.119606033,
-0.3795469403,
-0.5719889998,
0.2251134217,
-0.3465610445,
-0.3197470903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01404v1
|
On Measuring Context Utilization in Document-Level MT Systems
| 2024-02-02T13:37:07 | 2024-02-02T13:37:07 |
Wafaa Mohammed, Vlad Niculae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document-level translation models are usually evaluated using general metrics
such as BLEU, which are not informative about the benefits of context. Current
work on context-aware evaluation, such as contrastive methods, only measure
translation accuracy on words that need context for disambiguation. Such
measures cannot reveal whether the translation model uses the correct
supporting context. We propose to complement accuracy-based evaluation with
measures of context utilization. We find that perturbation-based analysis
(comparing models' performance when provided with correct versus random
context) is an effective measure of overall context utilization. For a
finer-grained phenomenon-specific evaluation, we propose to measure how much
the supporting context contributes to handling context-dependent discourse
phenomena. We show that automatically-annotated supporting context gives
similar conclusions to human-annotated context and can be used as alternative
for cases where human annotations are not available. Finally, we highlight the
importance of using discourse-rich datasets when assessing context utilization.
|
[
-0.357725352,
-0.8138544559,
0.6049585938,
0.4941339791,
-0.3085170984,
-0.3193825185,
-0.2073916346,
-0.339756012,
-0.0514973365,
0.4378416836,
-0.1957298219,
-0.3512903154,
-0.6828414202,
0.2111551911,
-0.596024394,
0.7274273038,
-0.1174718216,
-0.0105776228,
-0.6053728461,
-0.4438577294,
-0.8287388682,
-0.4727631211,
-0.3560391068,
-0.5088338256,
0.378816396,
0.2696706057,
0.5455720425,
0.4069113433,
0.4151416719,
0.2911684215,
-0.2246747017,
0.0463809781,
-0.2903690934,
0.2184775323,
-0.2379803807,
-0.2027056664,
-0.6727797985,
-0.0182143878,
0.8579409719,
0.9425548315,
-0.1378623247,
0.1719186455,
0.4064825475,
0.2196026891,
-0.7657141685,
-0.2472223639,
-0.6747095585,
0.1046197712,
-0.1864988208,
-0.5610295534,
-0.458602339,
0.1483781189,
0.3996683657,
-0.8077145815,
-0.1027175933,
0.1119033322,
0.6852858067,
0.4234092236,
-0.7795615792,
-0.3891523778,
-0.7549452782,
0.9910271764,
-0.5494483709,
0.2769356072,
0.7384194136,
0.1889523417,
-0.0620368868,
-0.6731147766,
-0.4578113556,
-0.1548996866,
-0.5325257778,
0.2771303058,
-0.1978901476,
0.0141845299,
0.4469092786,
0.505456388,
-0.1208710521,
-0.0258671362,
-0.0553505383,
-0.332506448,
0.2785182595,
0.3779829741,
0.3290344477,
-0.4738485515,
-0.6450409889,
0.105470553,
-0.47708112,
-0.0374460742,
-0.0065398458,
0.1176917851,
-0.2448269576,
0.5436916947,
0.119264029,
0.7291109562,
-0.2251263708,
-0.075509496,
0.2164891213,
-0.7168139815,
-0.6308255792,
-0.3294357061,
0.5631477833,
0.2942545712,
-0.2555559576,
-0.1144210696,
-0.3493417203,
-0.3360745907,
0.5271390676,
-0.798196137,
0.2142505944,
0.1769257337,
-0.2447454333,
-0.0524395481,
-0.1074161679,
-0.4235940874,
-0.5057232976,
-0.241164282,
0.2272310555,
-0.4309149086,
-0.1406266838,
-0.2309753448,
-0.271769166,
0.1047742963,
0.4886789918,
-0.7033016086,
0.2853561044,
0.46055004,
1.0848771334,
-0.2778474092,
-0.2069416195,
-0.3294512033,
0.2878758907,
-0.4298770428,
0.7757890224,
-0.5486821532,
-0.7635471225,
0.10441982,
0.0379357487,
-0.2152083069,
-0.5186867118,
1.005841136,
-0.3005369306,
0.2541792393,
-0.6942494512,
-0.6118109822,
-0.2408403456,
0.4150773585,
-0.5495285988,
1.1314631701,
0.5498902798,
-0.8773902059,
0.6510977745,
-0.8765575886,
-0.6852065325,
0.1141583323,
0.0753797069,
-0.1986869574,
0.4663403928,
0.0552044362,
0.343517065,
-0.0687310398,
0.5115103126,
-0.0261680819,
-0.4996986091,
0.4448826313,
-0.4019620121,
0.5506827831,
0.238342464,
-0.1810274124,
0.2462625802,
-0.6286431551,
-0.5024761558,
-0.3156567216,
-0.4544602036,
-0.8441047668,
0.1921305358,
0.2706760764,
-0.0293311644,
0.1860792786,
-0.3812644482,
-0.0817752331,
-0.3033898771,
0.2842501998,
0.5142560005,
-0.0325401537,
0.5206339359,
-0.1400757879,
0.3867719471,
-0.0492663905,
-0.1201496124,
-0.3892412782,
-0.1428890228,
-0.620881021,
-0.2920172215,
0.4889992177,
0.450712353,
-0.6323307157,
0.4521031678,
-0.271631211,
-0.0600222573,
-0.2034849972,
-0.2893975079,
0.4186362624,
1.0617929697,
0.582074821,
-0.4554196894,
-0.4264576435,
-1.0505968332,
-0.1901305914,
0.1202511862,
-0.1643962562,
0.6997320652,
0.4746433198,
-0.2772468328,
0.7538151741,
-0.166559279,
-0.296829164,
0.0481029972,
0.2943162918,
-0.1683861166,
0.4738432169,
0.6843506098,
-0.8203146458,
-0.3630649447,
0.1459371895,
-0.8186253905,
-0.6226311326,
-0.0521874614,
-0.0984738991,
0.3397105932,
0.2728302479,
-0.071762763,
0.3701600432,
0.624116838,
-0.4908985794,
0.4228038192,
-0.2745007277,
0.375541091,
-0.8589164019,
0.6800052524,
-0.0771557838,
-0.5131315589,
-0.8353050947,
-0.0707840994,
0.0534060672,
0.1062309295,
-0.4313009977,
0.7830986977,
-0.3430578709,
-0.5199460387,
-0.3787622154,
0.4996495545,
0.1915773451,
0.0507119671,
-0.0907377154,
0.9288043976,
0.3408884406,
-0.4985687137,
-0.2072245926,
0.2006943971,
-0.3888467252,
1.057993412,
-0.4957205951,
-0.0654773489,
0.1584942192,
0.4115605056,
-1.1923812628,
-0.3373171985,
0.2139206231,
-0.3141863644,
0.2550822496,
-0.0849223584,
-0.4369846582,
0.0630566701,
-0.0440176688,
0.1876389384,
0.1256679893,
-0.147362873,
0.5136469603,
0.5031279325,
0.0594610684,
-0.727889955,
-0.8655149937,
0.3088149428,
-0.4616704285,
-0.4891527593,
0.4441486299,
0.1225080863,
-0.1187868491,
-0.0142976576,
-0.4132818282,
-0.0720079914,
0.6997054219,
0.2433973253,
0.0314501449,
0.0118382638,
0.1806853414,
0.3739294708,
-0.0539165512,
0.0580872782,
-0.2772066891,
0.5039168,
0.1192602292,
-0.1760673523,
-0.4632752836,
0.3911418319,
0.3195299208,
-0.0573879965,
0.5695489049,
0.6975550056,
-0.4788480103,
0.205336079,
-0.5758408904,
0.0112175699,
-0.3640414774,
0.1653684974,
-0.5252892971,
-0.9205849171,
0.7639756203,
-0.002023156,
-0.0408345275,
0.5690289736,
0.3348504901,
-0.1183259785,
0.8016551137,
0.4908033311,
0.2701931298,
0.6680443883,
-0.131572932,
-0.1395148337,
-1.3481243849,
0.0691611096,
-0.5596049428,
-0.4149237275,
-0.45779109,
-0.3217201829,
0.4196069539,
0.2636952102,
0.0397489332,
0.2979888916,
-0.3198048174,
0.103099443,
0.0848934576,
-0.3256787062,
0.4865577817,
0.0688493922,
-0.1949451119,
-0.0257562865,
-0.5154737234,
-0.8943709135,
0.9160766602,
0.2192140222,
0.0399183296,
-0.1169179603,
0.3075478375,
0.3067421019,
0.8010566831,
-0.7268483043,
0.4378234744,
-0.1048697159,
-0.7333760262,
-0.394531101,
-0.6117705703,
-1.0426350832,
0.7147164941,
-0.1139076054,
-0.9126372933,
0.1430251747,
0.1645618081,
-0.3046616912,
-0.1027126983,
-0.6106365919,
0.9606913328,
-0.0071829897,
-0.3666998446,
-0.2494621873,
-0.3768263161,
0.1174530089,
-0.0235898364,
0.3415426612,
0.0448165722,
-0.3134230077,
0.6002383232,
-0.1964517236,
0.6504042745,
-0.4052777588,
-0.2655946314,
0.321062237,
0.1807299852,
-0.0198894273,
-0.0339907184,
-0.2972112596,
0.1839329004,
0.2526600361,
-0.4458704293,
-0.6871438622,
0.7624118328,
-0.4492137432,
-0.6432605386,
-0.4226604402,
-0.6254194975,
-0.2510864437,
0.3788556457,
0.2304343432,
0.3667679131,
-0.4827574492,
0.4538044333,
0.3038192987,
-0.2280109674,
0.3983426988,
0.5088815093,
-0.1466953456,
-0.1645206511,
0.621984899,
0.4946992695,
0.1222155169,
0.3395174444,
0.5405793786,
-0.278293103,
-0.6950814128,
-0.6584380269,
-0.1898094267,
-0.6412810087,
-0.0323815607,
-0.68701756,
0.229806453,
-0.0205829237,
-0.2417477816,
0.0360791609,
-0.3893530071,
-0.103213802,
-0.19198744,
-0.2587977946,
0.3866788149,
0.0947562382,
0.552352488,
-0.507932663,
-0.0702865422,
-0.0144307502,
0.2880464792,
0.1203681305,
-0.5228512883,
-0.4093810618,
0.0274732225,
-0.5531554818,
-0.9204958677,
0.2071117163,
-0.1233409569,
0.5122763515,
0.1074829996,
-0.0691189617,
0.6143333912,
-0.319793731,
1.0489743948,
-0.1127083749,
-1.3160203695,
0.5303744078,
-0.5288550258,
0.2915969193,
0.5427435637,
0.2481137961,
-0.6352410913,
-0.3083826005,
-0.5153741241,
-0.9718625546,
0.7447618842,
0.3958970904,
0.320554018,
-0.0686680079,
0.3633114398,
-0.0919310972,
0.387439996,
-0.7400891185,
-0.0367620885,
-0.1385298669,
0.1971602738,
0.0134769129,
-0.2762803733,
-0.3571329117,
-0.1266235858,
0.3888421357,
-0.0816372856,
-0.0004565605,
0.5750767589,
-0.4538775682,
-0.0897283554,
0.4406477213,
0.8052763939,
1.0406651497,
-0.1681170315,
0.1944907159,
0.504126668,
-0.2803084552,
-0.1452138871,
-0.0795773789,
-0.3995884061,
-0.0317500755,
0.3378421664,
0.8656836152,
0.3994883895,
-0.3656945825,
0.5332283974,
0.1278873086,
0.0829451755,
-0.2888888717,
-0.1019738615,
0.1200738028,
-0.0287920348,
0.2353509665,
-0.1694657952,
0.4823495448,
-0.5349224806,
0.0163422003,
0.420445621,
-0.7205486894,
-0.2818826139,
0.3679342568,
0.3500548005,
-0.2444665283,
0.2106183022,
-0.1476172656,
-0.2929608524,
0.4832437336,
0.6876610518,
0.7563256621,
-0.4168182015,
-0.0737483427,
0.324139148,
0.1779296249,
0.0001782356,
0.0909454226,
-0.2984516919,
-0.6424958706,
-0.4095663726,
-0.4793303907,
-0.4179754257,
0.1649139971,
-0.7065867782,
0.0626401156,
-0.0385920368,
-0.4481820762,
0.0535271429,
0.1105436161,
-0.5146949291,
0.2976456285,
-0.1265150905,
0.7659596801,
-0.6821051836,
0.76222682,
0.8264365196,
-0.2863008976,
-0.196507141,
0.0305569768,
-0.0952809826,
-0.2638696134,
0.3289338946,
0.2539717257,
-0.2348667383,
-0.318623662,
-0.2888729274,
-0.4967858791,
1.2613067627,
0.2485564798,
-0.3053261042,
0.2823753953,
-0.0278407112,
0.873142004,
-0.502630353,
0.3861053884,
0.5551388264,
0.793360889,
-0.0183362253,
-0.869156599,
0.2523300648,
0.0801452547,
0.2857703567,
0.1124822572,
-0.3154258132,
0.5430346727,
0.4007730782,
-0.6303958893,
-0.0466471836,
0.4253508747,
-0.2046840042,
0.7138656974,
0.6581767201,
0.4287669957,
0.8020368218,
-0.1168623641,
1.4496450424,
-0.1546263844,
0.3478505909,
1.0727827549,
-0.3001766205,
0.7260298729,
0.5788672566,
0.0680071414,
0.3866832554,
0.4335871935,
0.2457034737,
0.091423288,
0.2181598395,
-0.0959626958,
-0.0739898756,
-0.3696697652,
-0.1158999503,
0.3923471868,
0.7004999518,
-0.3442598581,
-0.0695941821,
-0.0278330278,
0.1235489175,
0.1856550574,
0.0128868883,
0.8580466509,
0.3061762154,
-0.9638106227,
0.6344870925,
0.2162616104,
0.2967254519,
-0.3623183072,
0.3110564053,
-0.4129042327,
-0.2499953508,
-0.4516132176,
-0.7933990955,
0.8618069291,
0.0348437987,
-0.1639363617,
-0.2881861329,
0.6696962714,
-0.2294344008,
-0.2627467513,
0.45372352,
0.7160204649,
0.0011062733,
0.0525515079,
-0.2269241959,
-0.0444937088,
-0.3411701322,
-0.4646672904,
0.4865957201,
0.5120022297,
-0.2876085639,
0.3169599473,
0.4206486344,
-0.0762879178,
-0.3199457228,
0.2240943909,
0.6338016391,
-0.4931006134,
-0.2891098559,
-0.9331138134,
0.6852044463,
-0.4480005801,
-0.450699985,
0.8156358004,
0.4762054086,
0.6984867454,
0.4043584168,
0.8384128809,
-0.0970578045,
0.3083667755,
-0.3760602772,
0.5167102218,
-0.7802323699,
0.488545537,
-0.436571151,
-1.0518465042,
-0.354922086,
0.6876773834,
-0.5965758562,
-0.2673455477,
0.7160302401,
0.3943091631,
-0.4352262914,
0.0560571514,
0.5216949582,
0.1014422476,
0.1388141364,
0.0984228253,
0.9533724189,
-0.4146235287,
0.2146849334,
0.174894318,
-0.5219385028,
-0.2832795382,
-1.1592690945,
-0.6893179417,
-0.7068470716,
-0.1609632373,
-0.2517595887,
-0.1062891483,
0.4130154848,
0.6348293424,
-0.5557991266,
-0.4852012992,
0.2161707282,
0.2684222758,
-0.2979005277,
-0.1997999996,
0.3722792864,
-0.5820351839,
-0.6967753172,
0.527202189,
0.3953033388,
-0.1555008292,
-0.325514257,
0.2099305987,
-0.1040805504,
0.3597519696,
0.8895052671,
-0.111654982,
-0.571392715,
-0.4466449916,
-0.0454645082,
-0.1625898182,
0.2602514923,
1.0573422909,
-0.4017345607,
0.5859764814,
0.7450506687,
0.6019676328,
0.6358312964,
0.3218486905,
0.61629498,
-0.9674429893,
0.138386935,
-0.0007586192,
0.5566623807,
0.5944346189,
-0.2248535901,
0.5999724865,
0.153679356,
-0.4945150018,
-0.9360271692,
0.3463735878,
-0.7976410389,
-0.2174536884,
1.0967718363,
-0.5210853815,
-0.0319149494,
-0.1699476391,
-0.1959534436,
0.2876813412,
-0.3776121438,
0.607041657,
1.0885564089,
-0.0433065444,
0.0787896141,
-0.8977271318,
0.4447439611,
0.4772747159,
-0.7248600125,
0.1112072766,
0.6181101799,
0.0995123237,
0.5381447077,
0.782589972,
-0.204246223,
-0.175054729,
-0.2410598695,
-0.4605233967,
0.0206326209,
-0.1764976233,
-0.4014598727,
0.1529089361,
-0.0810604244,
0.1530599296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01812v1
|
Distilling LLMs' Decomposition Abilities into Compact Language Models
| 2024-02-02T13:23:15 | 2024-02-02T13:23:15 |
Denis Tarasov, Kumar Shridhar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated proficiency in their reasoning
abilities, yet their large size presents scalability challenges and limits any
further customization. In contrast, compact models offer customized training
but often fall short in solving complex reasoning tasks. This study focuses on
distilling the LLMs' decomposition skills into compact models using offline
reinforcement learning. We leverage the advancements in the LLM`s capabilities
to provide feedback and generate a specialized task-specific dataset for
training compact models. The development of an AI-generated dataset and the
establishment of baselines constitute the primary contributions of our work,
underscoring the potential of compact models in replicating complex
problem-solving skills.
|
[
-0.2936519086,
-0.8778734207,
0.9285743237,
-0.053905908,
-0.1029361263,
0.3292703927,
-0.6313943863,
-0.0283799674,
-0.0781618208,
0.5255900025,
-0.7567688823,
-0.0950272456,
-0.5945721269,
0.206071794,
-0.2659297884,
0.9031120539,
-0.1161853969,
0.035312742,
-0.2962617874,
0.0082643563,
-0.2583088279,
-0.3726441264,
-0.7659649253,
-0.458072871,
0.1450768262,
0.4917054176,
0.2956486046,
0.6517819762,
0.1113369688,
0.4927101731,
-0.1856484413,
0.4965014756,
-0.8398759365,
0.1199887991,
-0.3222056329,
-0.7735735178,
-0.1707094908,
0.0164409094,
0.7174719572,
0.8452907205,
-0.5097813606,
-0.0068222363,
-0.1256832331,
0.3214692175,
-0.5197605491,
0.4353675246,
-0.7898429632,
-0.2081678361,
0.2381598204,
-0.0902068913,
-0.5689576864,
-0.3391136527,
0.146853596,
-0.7633644342,
0.2116094083,
0.0725613534,
0.6122322083,
0.5901724696,
-0.4542090297,
-0.6196235418,
-1.1268402338,
1.0175856352,
-0.7031509876,
-0.0117812762,
0.3108612299,
0.5901802778,
-0.3806176484,
-0.7158128619,
-0.5940902829,
-0.253887713,
-0.0795792043,
0.0076321787,
-0.0062142964,
-0.0437849015,
0.1656719744,
0.2722733319,
-0.2536001205,
0.261562109,
-0.4896070659,
0.3082320988,
0.8580827713,
0.4320322871,
0.1051366702,
0.111018613,
0.0041455124,
-0.1683630794,
-0.4869553149,
0.0604141839,
0.2326199412,
0.3727835417,
0.0371340737,
0.7136602402,
-0.2214059234,
0.7027092576,
0.3590729833,
-0.8454526663,
-0.0686149448,
-0.3751058877,
-0.2353581488,
0.003854925,
0.5779137611,
-0.185514763,
-0.1286698431,
-0.2525937855,
-0.6343383193,
-0.0311469566,
0.2159336656,
-0.6562430859,
-0.423781842,
0.2135082632,
-0.424931556,
-0.252987206,
-0.1961418241,
-0.2843056321,
-0.3401552737,
-0.6424877644,
0.4662919044,
-0.2021812648,
-0.1395587474,
0.2762527466,
-0.2979148626,
-0.1146247312,
0.4836903214,
-0.8168542981,
0.566613853,
0.4441959262,
0.5613307357,
-0.2224878818,
0.0208830778,
-0.6251301765,
0.1603041738,
-0.0961457193,
0.7736263871,
-0.5610023737,
-0.4411109686,
-0.031957075,
0.0932874978,
-0.1217769682,
-1.0220723152,
0.5114587545,
-0.4101644754,
-0.0322321281,
-0.1259725094,
-0.7635332346,
-0.086014986,
0.6105846167,
-0.6916930676,
0.8338301182,
0.3504224122,
-0.6104978323,
-0.1000674888,
-0.5496293306,
-0.2947395444,
0.0426555686,
-0.4266868234,
-0.7636355162,
0.0249788743,
0.1047354862,
0.755805254,
-0.3297757804,
0.3943039775,
-0.4982180893,
-0.2356573641,
0.2839712799,
0.0188382827,
0.5618427992,
0.0651009455,
-0.4622088969,
0.2052580267,
-1.0161422491,
-0.0594596602,
0.633972764,
-0.5439589024,
-0.1364375204,
0.0920799151,
-0.196401611,
0.3553483188,
0.2880882025,
-0.4885206819,
0.341154784,
-0.2142505348,
0.6439450979,
0.4763403535,
0.0123590911,
0.5502426028,
-0.5172974467,
0.5822623372,
-0.1211378276,
0.0017835273,
0.2073051333,
-0.1154736355,
-0.9908286929,
-0.5574783087,
0.0413261056,
0.5233671069,
-0.9210124612,
0.4663587809,
-0.2660279572,
-0.6580770016,
-0.1334858388,
0.2112054527,
0.5616133213,
0.2080748975,
0.3274775445,
0.2195610255,
-0.5712448955,
-0.7906820178,
0.270547092,
0.0613787882,
-0.1075480208,
0.3302784562,
0.6233103275,
-0.4106248617,
0.9031554461,
-0.8129553795,
-0.4531796575,
-0.8334053159,
0.1687510014,
-0.2661515474,
0.2188721746,
0.2362422198,
-0.7842131257,
-0.2421644628,
-0.2010649443,
-0.5246119499,
0.066808857,
-0.2815886438,
0.2530629635,
-0.0506117791,
0.6301782727,
-0.5544047356,
0.2091187388,
0.5724176168,
-0.1561539322,
0.7406116724,
-0.5773128271,
-0.1541122049,
-1.0024995804,
-0.0142957084,
-0.1780538708,
-0.4032407403,
-0.4201776981,
-0.0140298763,
-0.3878527284,
-0.0410209,
-0.4251275957,
0.4740541279,
-0.4871908426,
-0.2950706482,
-0.3127956986,
0.5161104202,
0.087147586,
0.6354493499,
0.2805009186,
0.3046274483,
0.1498178393,
-0.6928151846,
0.593840301,
0.47730878,
-0.3010883927,
0.2674542367,
-0.742719233,
-0.2132499069,
-0.058544036,
0.5342538953,
-0.8241355419,
-0.3699183762,
-0.0068651517,
0.0602744333,
0.3698296845,
-0.1997391135,
-0.6362543702,
-0.0469451137,
-0.1208436117,
0.2756715715,
0.6261624694,
-0.4420869648,
0.8163686395,
0.5937037468,
-0.2046751231,
-0.1612934768,
-0.4986876547,
-0.5012339354,
-0.2946058512,
-0.412391305,
0.5246498585,
-0.1162931025,
-0.533538878,
0.1400728971,
0.2183358371,
-0.2442324758,
0.2136414796,
0.2951653004,
0.1973355711,
0.1252322197,
0.1019688994,
-0.0256519727,
0.126199767,
0.0010312308,
-0.0141519699,
0.3776658177,
-0.1123895645,
-0.1881977171,
-0.17158629,
0.317148298,
0.4726323783,
-0.31965819,
0.9679194093,
0.3079530895,
-0.2055040747,
-0.7946956754,
-0.2260627002,
-0.1473638564,
-0.4672233164,
0.3375513554,
-0.3023126423,
-0.9535239339,
0.5166832805,
-0.5149376392,
0.2282854617,
0.2614909112,
0.8809643984,
-0.0959869251,
1.1276423931,
0.7436932325,
0.4664705992,
0.3757662475,
-0.6534371376,
0.2593754828,
-0.7198286057,
-0.5712127686,
-0.4462341666,
-0.1324339658,
-0.4342721701,
-0.6720473766,
0.2483677566,
0.2476825416,
-0.2222851664,
0.1104274094,
-0.3661313653,
0.4414616823,
0.290696919,
0.2535871565,
0.2867625654,
-0.4132989049,
-0.0522087067,
0.4826093912,
-0.9400218725,
-0.439152509,
1.035957098,
0.3630421162,
0.8078391552,
0.0200466774,
0.7315900326,
0.0212334041,
0.0674348772,
-0.9493430257,
0.5784748793,
-0.1918861866,
-0.3966324627,
-0.5592178702,
-0.8350101113,
-0.856788516,
0.0951499343,
-0.2775726318,
-0.4224810898,
-0.2605681121,
0.2363522947,
-0.3993935585,
0.3392439485,
-0.5879141688,
0.6656982899,
-0.2822206616,
-0.0283163898,
-0.3780065179,
-0.5104182363,
0.6570983529,
-0.2302595675,
0.4034895897,
-0.1260610819,
0.1021103933,
0.7265844941,
-0.699021101,
0.9652730823,
-0.1505716592,
-0.1113881916,
0.3955639005,
0.1945333928,
0.8818840981,
0.1152591705,
0.2099110782,
-0.416685611,
0.2016679496,
-0.449593246,
-0.7322890759,
0.62499547,
-1.0754771233,
-0.4620533586,
-0.1463297606,
-0.5710129738,
-0.3301230967,
-0.0487720147,
0.1334729195,
0.518889308,
-0.22979182,
0.0145082679,
1.0887746811,
-0.1262912005,
0.4456670284,
0.448915422,
-0.1744961888,
-0.1074936464,
0.8663698435,
0.2056817412,
0.4183794558,
0.3453433812,
0.2733344138,
-0.5244037509,
-0.7232809067,
-0.1367913038,
0.2880632281,
-1.1191709042,
0.0053112232,
-0.6005446911,
-0.0862012282,
-0.0520777442,
-0.3255875409,
-0.7238668203,
-0.5366712809,
-0.3809607923,
-0.0181240253,
-0.0126705868,
1.1223418713,
0.2588782012,
0.2599040568,
-0.9844168425,
0.3128199279,
0.4894349873,
0.0811655521,
-0.0992959738,
-0.6616092324,
-0.3576188684,
-0.04830347,
-0.2548859119,
-0.4461542666,
0.3190350831,
0.3113311529,
0.6635727882,
0.3097427785,
0.3146527708,
0.5073193908,
-0.4189279675,
0.6911383867,
-0.0310494024,
-0.9050444365,
0.4355556369,
-0.2640393376,
0.3204805553,
0.3690566719,
0.6281112432,
0.0275098588,
-0.449944824,
-0.7642859221,
-0.5434812903,
0.8550513983,
0.3176974654,
-0.2788569927,
0.0539605878,
0.3897145092,
0.2048335671,
0.0125648109,
-0.499373585,
-0.1755773574,
-0.0328937396,
-0.1853616089,
-0.1788558215,
-0.1380711794,
-0.230748564,
-0.1711133271,
0.8079384565,
-0.3231955767,
0.2111035138,
-0.1585049331,
-0.2133759856,
0.158746168,
0.3252781034,
0.7499177456,
0.6644541025,
-0.0407626666,
0.1593185067,
0.272972554,
0.0613498054,
0.425937891,
-0.1621972322,
0.0660148486,
-0.1748929918,
0.400929749,
0.803612709,
0.3435974717,
-1.2921124697,
0.4739439189,
-0.3726292253,
-0.3482068181,
-0.6591610312,
0.1989572644,
0.379986167,
0.4873500168,
0.0053145946,
0.0302996729,
0.0702632815,
-0.7331746817,
0.1376046836,
0.2400550097,
-0.0313219205,
-0.4652380645,
0.3455922604,
0.1888599694,
-0.0204654559,
0.7614526153,
-0.7384471297,
-0.6515724063,
0.5535891652,
0.6429207921,
0.5187709928,
0.0370810144,
0.3204694092,
0.3351677358,
-0.0575516,
-0.4696090519,
0.1680763066,
-0.0628948659,
-0.6146202683,
-0.5609182119,
-0.5701102018,
-0.4135632813,
0.1908409894,
-0.5996350646,
0.354071945,
-0.7445777655,
-0.0238560047,
-0.1860207915,
0.1050542369,
-0.7009991407,
0.4218999147,
0.2971945107,
0.4394765198,
-0.9041939378,
1.0351777077,
0.6590178013,
-0.4114864767,
-1.2723618746,
-0.1940030754,
-0.0539855696,
-0.5306327343,
0.9771806002,
0.0120528089,
-0.0783943608,
-0.0517516099,
-0.3644521236,
-0.8694142699,
1.2460787296,
0.5895029902,
-0.6414896846,
-0.2209851891,
0.2224664092,
0.4426977336,
-0.5412158966,
0.3323218226,
0.7942801118,
0.2464002073,
0.3148784041,
-1.2065540552,
0.0836655349,
0.0422479846,
-0.0312526189,
0.2111051977,
-0.6703034639,
0.9928579926,
-0.3014720678,
-0.1993760616,
-0.1835291237,
0.2333824337,
0.3780878186,
-0.1344786733,
0.5226675868,
0.7241740227,
0.8826533556,
-0.0078391368,
0.8702315092,
0.1297213137,
0.3982700706,
1.4786081314,
-0.3147059977,
1.0747145414,
0.3056705892,
0.0977795571,
0.6598867178,
0.4613696635,
0.0388361402,
0.7303904891,
0.4620450437,
-0.2847498655,
-0.57359308,
-0.1908811331,
0.2561426163,
0.6645045877,
0.4457860291,
-0.145977065,
-0.3488608003,
0.1697685868,
-0.1239155084,
0.2215138674,
-0.5268261433,
0.9849762321,
0.0340474769,
-0.7870272994,
0.6396477222,
0.4171779752,
0.4158644676,
-0.7171092629,
-0.0743464828,
-0.0248094425,
0.5377891064,
-0.2718805969,
-0.609446764,
0.5823206902,
-0.2440656871,
-0.2367287129,
-0.2258591354,
0.4735525548,
-0.5219185352,
-0.2356375158,
0.362947166,
0.3605092466,
-0.0082475981,
-0.0137952194,
-0.6702997684,
0.2495841533,
0.0663166568,
-0.2735715806,
0.5121165514,
0.486572504,
-0.208823964,
1.0597970486,
0.4900279343,
-0.0470236763,
0.2395298928,
-0.228505969,
1.1071834564,
-0.3726488948,
-0.5791320801,
-0.5857140422,
0.5869338512,
0.0787007734,
-0.054526832,
0.5609567761,
0.3581790328,
1.0865818262,
-0.2420349121,
0.944599092,
-0.1172729954,
0.4049067795,
-0.6608943343,
0.3639469743,
-0.5137236714,
0.3405543864,
0.3185607493,
-0.7184641361,
0.0395891219,
0.342484355,
-0.3450051844,
-0.0438150689,
0.6963433623,
0.5549093485,
-0.015395062,
-0.3710755408,
0.431255132,
0.0542263128,
0.4914416969,
0.7746992707,
0.8950223327,
-0.1273042262,
0.7514063716,
-0.3555705249,
-0.2572215796,
-0.3867881,
-0.7040166855,
-1.3724793196,
-0.6465603709,
-0.4421656132,
-0.0398137011,
-0.4022573829,
1.1664912701,
0.8038518429,
-0.6665962934,
-0.0704838634,
-0.1618370861,
-0.1705424339,
-0.1189274862,
-0.1404814273,
0.3701580167,
-0.3789701164,
-0.585144639,
0.6374599934,
0.1802045107,
0.1099374443,
-0.5299636126,
-0.3911808431,
-0.1017600745,
0.3866311312,
0.5895906687,
0.2347694933,
-0.7590973973,
-0.0293075852,
-0.1192643046,
-0.0989175588,
-0.1063299328,
0.9514243603,
-0.760879755,
0.4070124626,
0.5576893091,
0.7617212534,
0.6529115438,
-0.0771683529,
0.5928755999,
-0.9699990153,
0.1603857726,
0.3735295236,
0.5766608715,
0.3358334005,
-0.1879625618,
0.1679481119,
0.0820971653,
-0.6938405037,
-0.7976456881,
0.3037801087,
-0.9094299674,
-0.6359615326,
1.1960674524,
-0.7091990113,
-0.2057392597,
-0.3189413846,
-0.1874312609,
0.409797281,
-0.0240756869,
0.8293578625,
0.3722765148,
-0.3324227035,
-0.1558282375,
-0.1781348139,
0.6560588479,
0.1729811579,
-1.2104058266,
0.0726193264,
0.3303403556,
0.4935460687,
0.1940601617,
0.4661616981,
0.1413329989,
-0.0252056327,
0.2226725519,
-0.0398149714,
-0.3115032911,
-0.4111556709,
-0.2668071389,
0.2581154108,
0.3444173634,
0.1373750567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01391v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01391v2
|
StepCoder: Improve Code Generation with Reinforcement Learning from Compiler Feedback
| 2024-02-02T13:14:31 | 2024-02-05T13:28:23 |
Shihan Dou, Yan Liu, Haoxiang Jia, Limao Xiong, Enyu Zhou, Wei Shen, Junjie Shan, Caishuang Huang, Xiao Wang, Xiaoran Fan, Zhiheng Xi, Yuhao Zhou, Tao Ji, Rui Zheng, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Tao Gui
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly propelled
the field of code generation. Previous work integrated reinforcement learning
(RL) with compiler feedback for exploring the output space of LLMs to enhance
code generation quality. However, the lengthy code generated by LLMs in
response to complex human requirements makes RL exploration a challenge. Also,
since the unit tests may not cover the complicated code, optimizing LLMs by
using these unexecuted code snippets is ineffective. To tackle these
challenges, we introduce StepCoder, a novel RL framework for code generation,
consisting of two main components: CCCS addresses the exploration challenge by
breaking the long sequences code generation task into a Curriculum of Code
Completion Subtasks, while FGO only optimizes the model by masking the
unexecuted code segments to provide Fine-Grained Optimization. In addition, we
furthermore construct the APPS+ dataset for RL training, which is manually
verified to ensure the correctness of unit tests. Experimental results show
that our method improves the ability to explore the output space and
outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in corresponding benchmarks. Our
dataset APPS+ and StepCoder are available online.
|
[
-0.3899986446,
-0.3960155547,
0.3694650531,
0.24504067,
-0.1828815192,
0.579282403,
-0.3519821167,
-0.1530620903,
-0.054905273,
0.5357186794,
-0.6512895226,
-0.5934503675,
-0.41015625,
0.0082475124,
-0.275544405,
1.1010615826,
-0.2088215649,
0.0954045877,
-0.4507356286,
0.1213153601,
-0.2363257259,
-0.3789799809,
-0.7516642213,
-0.439134717,
0.5195359588,
0.5555225611,
0.276338309,
0.4363498986,
0.1565870345,
0.2412646264,
-0.0004707232,
0.5139084458,
-0.6600690484,
0.1695438772,
0.1644092649,
-0.1407104731,
-0.0713582858,
-0.4635220766,
0.3299790025,
0.2571604848,
-0.3097462952,
0.1817993969,
0.0322787166,
0.713370502,
-0.6742469668,
0.4437523782,
-0.2258505523,
0.3319272399,
0.2105450779,
-0.4365244806,
-0.5573123693,
-0.5090854764,
-0.5145424008,
-0.3186304867,
0.2314986438,
-0.0645121261,
0.4190508723,
0.4150778353,
-0.2284138948,
-0.5089412928,
-0.8332059383,
0.6186657548,
-0.6015990973,
0.4950422049,
-0.0068659964,
0.1467161775,
-0.2859176695,
-0.5419940352,
-0.401154995,
-0.569329083,
0.0278239716,
-0.0682625994,
0.2150058746,
0.0319577456,
0.4520852268,
0.40977934,
-0.4518759549,
0.0735127851,
-0.5119188428,
-0.3005919158,
0.8039899468,
0.3171344101,
0.1580038518,
0.0387049057,
-0.2263561934,
-0.2242216468,
-0.8706945181,
0.4425230622,
0.3494510055,
0.2301009297,
0.1610289216,
0.2542153299,
-0.261649102,
0.5648629665,
0.1397103369,
-0.0341159329,
0.2843355834,
-0.1925940216,
0.1269117594,
0.0379215255,
0.6674189568,
-0.0133112893,
0.0033797207,
-0.1098410934,
-0.4563588798,
-0.0121356165,
0.5816722512,
-0.8842487335,
-0.2527597547,
0.331944555,
-0.054597564,
-0.5322233438,
0.2093309462,
-0.5747973323,
-0.3557308018,
-0.1853175312,
0.0377142988,
-0.3262693286,
-0.0723839551,
0.1109978482,
0.2525128722,
0.3459216952,
0.2987355888,
-0.791695714,
0.1533357501,
0.7831984758,
0.5086029768,
-0.272780925,
-0.2843576074,
-1.0533717871,
-0.1855030507,
-0.6650484204,
0.2730463147,
-0.3662134409,
-0.5948958993,
0.1844418198,
-0.2453258485,
0.258452177,
-0.5842652321,
0.1792986542,
-0.6996234655,
-0.1447824985,
0.1292332262,
-0.4660366178,
0.0411687233,
0.2153293192,
-0.5339123011,
1.2051222324,
0.2631645203,
-0.3811624944,
0.3982163668,
-0.6044757366,
-0.5743873715,
0.2154961526,
-0.5740196109,
-0.5837285519,
0.1671983451,
0.3868584931,
0.3485149443,
-0.0389990658,
0.3910435736,
0.0838574395,
-0.5270544887,
0.2065425962,
0.0558705963,
0.2411488742,
0.3514098823,
-0.5517325401,
0.4358704388,
-0.7448852062,
0.3682937026,
0.0365353487,
-0.9033660889,
0.0935987309,
0.115798749,
-0.1556740105,
0.4491494,
0.1454972923,
-0.5035380721,
0.2746635377,
-0.2171413302,
0.233325839,
0.6232907772,
0.1179431155,
0.3188309073,
-0.1475699246,
0.9193426371,
0.0420186967,
0.1622869223,
-0.3316247463,
-0.0967809632,
-0.9440085292,
-0.0432740413,
0.3571274877,
0.4166051745,
-1.15942204,
0.4907919466,
-0.2330192924,
-0.2758960724,
-0.3757259548,
0.4894484282,
0.7295127511,
-0.0256320238,
0.3413862586,
-0.6108726263,
-0.5351164341,
-0.4015074372,
-0.0653551221,
-0.0411813408,
-0.0844000429,
0.411563158,
0.5009348989,
-0.3700632751,
0.7538946271,
-0.4745098352,
0.0896927938,
-0.6757130027,
0.0529069453,
-0.022996325,
0.545979917,
-0.0249047931,
-0.5274527669,
-0.1809831113,
-0.0520732403,
-0.3520644307,
0.0228135288,
-0.3559311628,
0.0887819752,
0.1336778104,
0.9009987116,
-0.1011418998,
0.1954085231,
0.6847267151,
-0.1396119744,
0.3811392486,
-0.3545731306,
0.0762921795,
-0.646832943,
-0.0375649109,
-0.2825069726,
-0.3844867051,
-0.3210535944,
0.472956717,
0.225668326,
-0.316126436,
-0.4946628213,
0.2876110673,
-0.3355579972,
-0.1683820635,
-0.2419149429,
-0.2068193257,
-0.1061157063,
0.7398425937,
0.1081095859,
0.9574539661,
0.2357379347,
-0.5884319544,
0.3086015284,
0.0549913272,
-0.4339482486,
-0.1961217076,
-0.4019849002,
0.4520803094,
0.0274903886,
0.4939874113,
-0.6259111762,
-0.2418963462,
0.1079968587,
-0.3688714802,
0.447199136,
-0.0371739976,
-0.3544861078,
-0.5029999018,
-0.3473232985,
0.2873206437,
0.647732079,
-0.730001688,
0.3293226361,
0.0572065637,
0.0175210219,
-0.524736762,
-0.5661880374,
-0.1171248332,
0.210618481,
-0.2850187123,
-0.0741324872,
-0.2018975019,
0.1992263943,
-0.3375744522,
-0.3402039409,
0.075103201,
-0.0501124449,
0.3773157895,
0.0329709016,
0.0350913927,
0.0147543084,
-0.0083416868,
-0.2382327467,
0.2262235433,
-0.3128224015,
0.5630956292,
-0.0402241312,
-0.5203275084,
0.0646491721,
0.1503551453,
0.3192518353,
-0.3975358009,
0.1431922615,
0.5205503702,
0.1541982144,
-0.7977849245,
-0.1752083153,
0.0236361939,
-0.4788007438,
0.5190384984,
-0.1434917599,
-1.3308575153,
0.1493194997,
-0.3580273092,
0.1885187179,
0.0025537033,
0.4210970104,
0.2777336836,
0.9541742802,
0.6320021749,
-0.0164341684,
0.476550281,
-0.4862558544,
0.2814682424,
-0.7753343582,
-0.3977555037,
-0.3848031163,
-0.0571586639,
-0.454885602,
-0.8990673423,
0.146886766,
0.0873906165,
-0.2651094794,
0.2474146932,
-0.5692358613,
0.7274054289,
0.5601415634,
0.3953884542,
0.1469015479,
-0.1461978704,
-0.2350086719,
0.038225852,
-0.9255688787,
-0.1405469924,
0.9815322757,
0.3701134026,
0.9291529655,
-0.0463581569,
1.2292056084,
0.4254351854,
0.2169978172,
-0.7036386132,
0.5604296327,
-0.0321743488,
-0.2767588794,
-0.1339178681,
-0.7007802129,
-0.5822796226,
-0.0365428291,
0.0355216488,
-0.3122128844,
0.0666523129,
0.2982075214,
-0.5243834853,
0.1330952793,
-0.2459660023,
0.7747142911,
-0.4643130004,
-0.564218998,
-0.1778800488,
-0.4827191234,
0.4265260398,
-0.1347404122,
0.2953599095,
0.3922990859,
0.0059242933,
0.4770841897,
-0.6864265203,
0.7710925937,
-0.2634520233,
-0.3938570917,
0.4364849627,
0.3005076945,
0.7765917182,
0.0967794135,
0.2274017632,
-0.2482007295,
-0.6065276861,
-0.3275364935,
-0.501645565,
0.75951159,
-0.5174880624,
-0.251088202,
-0.3499248326,
-0.411639452,
-0.3639262617,
-0.0769963935,
0.2262612879,
0.4340812564,
-0.1019119546,
0.0765692741,
0.9141105413,
-0.5718550086,
0.2995487154,
0.232216686,
-0.5361783504,
-0.4634128511,
1.0666387081,
-0.5753455162,
0.2342647463,
0.3256370723,
-0.0528067686,
-0.1981251538,
-0.718255043,
-0.5577290654,
-0.1951760501,
-0.6154882908,
-0.2694666684,
-0.3268537223,
-0.4732891917,
-0.1255400479,
-0.2684724927,
-0.4700493217,
-0.0455436446,
-0.0929137766,
-0.1819166243,
0.2218825668,
0.9495803118,
-0.0373398922,
0.042431917,
-0.9335561395,
0.1997604072,
0.3634810746,
0.3601772189,
-0.0104503259,
-0.2248526812,
-0.5374984145,
-0.1240718216,
-0.3632179499,
-0.3342513144,
0.2858833671,
0.025177503,
0.2698625624,
0.2602945268,
0.0291066598,
0.5775903463,
-0.5460230112,
0.9026165605,
0.2994411588,
-0.9104642868,
0.5414123535,
-0.1693491191,
0.3882836401,
0.6379286647,
0.0889635161,
-0.3120858669,
-0.5985714197,
-0.6029975414,
-1.0289011002,
0.7132815123,
0.0871156901,
0.0409342945,
0.0409308486,
0.3288422823,
0.0268764999,
0.3393264413,
-0.7319329977,
0.0934885815,
-0.122918278,
-0.0831525102,
-0.3323251605,
-0.1336665899,
0.0138235325,
-0.1394965053,
0.6823721528,
-0.277022928,
0.2034855634,
0.0513238534,
-0.2295341045,
-0.2913195789,
0.3153994679,
0.8006619215,
0.4272751808,
0.0165846217,
-0.0781825185,
0.1679893732,
-0.4608081877,
0.2991532087,
-0.1538569778,
-0.2094849497,
-0.1288988441,
0.4137400985,
0.9080314636,
0.4630543888,
-0.8778631091,
0.5544186831,
-0.0894758627,
-0.306048274,
-0.3455521166,
0.6500534415,
-0.0143953264,
0.4164324999,
0.1575607359,
0.0980959162,
-0.0063680615,
-0.2972841263,
0.5070300698,
0.0865944475,
-0.5360692739,
0.0511972085,
0.6538339853,
0.4162769318,
-0.3172643185,
0.6365115643,
-0.4746739566,
-0.6844046712,
0.7380638123,
0.3334297836,
0.9232516885,
-0.0147265187,
0.3002078831,
0.4836507142,
0.2268200368,
-0.0845538378,
0.2796046436,
-0.3795843422,
-0.3028109372,
-0.7959141135,
-0.8082129955,
-0.4792868793,
0.0713660866,
-0.6209570169,
0.1390677392,
-0.7361547351,
0.3011598885,
-0.6297580004,
0.1179461777,
-0.4969037175,
0.1486661881,
0.31846717,
0.9310758114,
-0.5773949027,
0.9308529496,
0.511598289,
-0.448823154,
-1.0513747931,
0.0578966215,
-0.135115236,
-0.660110116,
0.7549644113,
0.1577778906,
-0.2407044172,
-0.0264184419,
-0.6084747314,
-0.4730819464,
0.9779837728,
0.1050086319,
-0.7942971587,
-0.0500591807,
0.17293863,
0.4903337955,
-0.6703166366,
0.0822091475,
0.3861947954,
0.1722708344,
0.2649914622,
-0.3952709734,
0.0932008475,
-0.1536822766,
0.350063771,
0.4581417441,
-0.5234478116,
0.5854256749,
-0.5415847301,
0.1191798896,
0.1704648584,
0.5133501887,
0.5462857485,
0.2291757613,
0.3849960566,
0.4598246813,
0.3480778337,
-0.0380563773,
1.1179635525,
-0.354950279,
0.536606431,
1.2685881853,
-0.247030735,
0.7584481835,
0.3671827316,
-0.1459689885,
0.6203594804,
0.6315257549,
0.0518082492,
0.5038617253,
0.732229948,
-0.2302301526,
-0.3411532938,
0.3363526464,
-0.2876609564,
0.2447138578,
0.2135877311,
-0.3169465959,
-0.2270034254,
-0.1346402168,
-0.062000189,
0.0807528794,
-0.2955637872,
0.9060462713,
-0.1165423691,
-0.6314685345,
0.5770670176,
-0.1017603502,
0.6159928441,
-0.7998945117,
-0.2206418812,
-0.5669300556,
0.3737581372,
-0.300018549,
-0.3836585581,
0.0500207767,
0.1564336717,
0.1661305428,
-0.3505103588,
0.5546373129,
-0.5211586952,
-0.2778371871,
0.3468903899,
0.2189398408,
0.0102109676,
0.2117411047,
-0.6088161469,
0.2301077545,
0.3902101517,
-0.1932338029,
0.3902979195,
0.3593452275,
0.1938618422,
0.5586195588,
0.7296572328,
0.1466097981,
0.1867844313,
0.0289943013,
0.9394441843,
-0.7836209536,
-0.5480658412,
-0.3716419339,
0.5715590119,
0.0286878124,
-0.2657097578,
0.5009714961,
0.7659441829,
1.1355856657,
-0.3206853569,
0.8240254521,
-0.0817809403,
0.2508048415,
-0.7293006182,
0.4532746077,
-0.4241556823,
0.4829145074,
-0.2283002883,
-0.9166101217,
-0.2851151824,
0.560816586,
-0.0682110041,
0.1636353433,
0.678129971,
0.873984158,
-0.1351591945,
-0.2576305568,
0.2691525519,
-0.1473730057,
0.4370033443,
0.9244453311,
1.0574245453,
-0.3473424315,
0.6617626548,
-0.2450385392,
-0.1489775926,
-0.3390797675,
-0.7868728042,
-0.6659624577,
-0.3017166853,
-0.4230270982,
-0.5369308591,
0.169144839,
0.9909453392,
0.5805962682,
-0.8383023143,
-0.448869139,
-0.5813457966,
-0.0437955335,
-0.259128958,
-0.184146449,
0.0677389577,
-0.6679360271,
-0.4805594385,
0.5887489915,
0.1286341399,
-0.2259161174,
-0.5350801349,
-0.8091694117,
0.1797857583,
-0.047408253,
0.5061637759,
0.5514271855,
-0.4722635448,
-0.2104747146,
-0.1438344419,
-0.1440252364,
0.0894894227,
1.3282552958,
-0.8220470548,
0.3827336729,
0.3154657781,
0.8316451311,
0.5675326586,
-0.047029838,
0.4286414683,
-1.0865870714,
0.053420797,
0.2948076725,
0.1449876428,
0.2231242061,
-0.3516606987,
0.5930330753,
-0.2655086219,
-0.5721991062,
-0.6207802892,
0.3884032071,
-0.697893858,
-0.2566334307,
1.1559019089,
-0.2397432178,
-0.2110073417,
0.1697308868,
-0.2514201105,
0.1155639887,
-0.6458815336,
0.7340549231,
0.4374024272,
-0.2746059895,
-0.1905785799,
-0.4936705232,
0.6585626602,
0.2394793183,
-0.8492196202,
0.1580880433,
0.7597769499,
0.2537437379,
0.1345243305,
0.5980067849,
-0.1186186522,
0.4373172224,
0.0361027941,
0.4895379841,
-0.2617950439,
-0.5128495097,
-0.5706571937,
0.1162805483,
0.3943128586,
-0.1960448027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01383v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01383v2
|
LLM-based NLG Evaluation: Current Status and Challenges
| 2024-02-02T13:06:35 | 2024-02-26T14:55:48 |
Mingqi Gao, Xinyu Hu, Jie Ruan, Xiao Pu, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluating natural language generation (NLG) is a vital but challenging
problem in artificial intelligence. Traditional evaluation metrics mainly
capturing content (e.g. n-gram) overlap between system outputs and references
are far from satisfactory, and large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT
have demonstrated great potential in NLG evaluation in recent years. Various
automatic evaluation methods based on LLMs have been proposed, including
metrics derived from LLMs, prompting LLMs, and fine-tuning LLMs with labeled
evaluation data. In this survey, we first give a taxonomy of LLM-based NLG
evaluation methods, and discuss their pros and cons, respectively. We also
discuss human-LLM collaboration for NLG evaluation. Lastly, we discuss several
open problems in this area and point out future research directions.
|
[
-0.5111413598,
-1.0340093374,
0.3991387188,
0.3501927555,
-0.1830001026,
0.3674098849,
-0.6494783759,
-0.7350066304,
-0.0053839344,
0.3670862019,
-0.6515001059,
-0.5759733915,
-0.7292717099,
0.5153605342,
-0.3774932325,
0.8677632809,
0.0878742784,
-0.0423140861,
-0.5530285239,
0.1055978537,
-0.4944601357,
-0.5965083838,
-1.0719066858,
-0.6664947867,
0.297344476,
0.2934291959,
0.7012161016,
0.3748757243,
0.7577536702,
0.3683854938,
-0.19397524,
0.2944880128,
-0.3904671669,
0.0853569955,
0.2144296467,
-0.2321732789,
-0.4806195199,
0.1790949553,
0.7613025904,
0.8207638264,
-0.1736667156,
0.3378160596,
0.1662037075,
0.8444898725,
-0.3228830695,
0.074779503,
-0.6443349719,
0.3991631866,
-0.0859106779,
-0.2229157388,
-0.1764514595,
-0.6743469238,
0.4784010649,
-0.2495434433,
0.1341798156,
0.2905346751,
0.5767196417,
0.4137070477,
-0.2567397356,
-0.8351917863,
-0.7350634933,
0.9943770766,
-1.0354940891,
0.2777129412,
0.2276675403,
0.2822435498,
-0.3907621503,
-0.7095811367,
-0.509999156,
-0.8696487546,
0.1305630952,
0.246877417,
-0.3886380494,
0.0803886279,
0.0024834448,
0.6616538167,
-0.5145707726,
0.477170825,
-0.1062878817,
-0.1445875764,
0.9542943239,
0.3788285851,
0.4421434104,
-0.4961407185,
-0.44514516,
0.371390909,
-0.7342090011,
-0.4267857075,
0.7267592549,
0.1976848245,
0.1250653118,
0.6190373898,
-0.1273259819,
0.803206563,
-0.1132340655,
0.1922554821,
0.1212731451,
-0.4952671528,
-0.2023302019,
-0.0613381192,
1.1384724379,
0.5436597466,
0.2948821485,
-0.3638644814,
-0.2177831233,
0.0159461498,
0.2273537964,
-0.4397454858,
0.0864691213,
0.0686462522,
-0.3924705386,
-0.4162265658,
-0.0541023463,
-0.958070457,
-0.5036233068,
-0.3102491498,
0.36852476,
-0.255538106,
-0.187554419,
0.1025543511,
-0.0169509128,
0.4680363834,
0.3350715935,
-0.8775331974,
0.3441612124,
0.7311680913,
0.7143341303,
-0.5176522732,
-0.1240989789,
-0.3472081423,
-0.3441092968,
-0.137428835,
0.9170018435,
-0.2213006169,
-0.3874644041,
0.1288282871,
-0.2940604687,
-0.0549645573,
-0.807385087,
0.6382083297,
-0.2610830367,
0.4933447242,
-0.0236050952,
-0.7824735641,
0.0218602996,
0.4988632202,
-0.5618423223,
1.2018543482,
0.0994500369,
-0.6987611055,
0.2766200006,
-0.7957543135,
-0.3937752545,
0.3922111392,
0.0071326853,
-0.3725402057,
0.0621878617,
0.1755782515,
0.2688313127,
-0.6818495989,
0.4621514082,
0.0601290502,
-0.3732943237,
0.160517782,
-0.777911365,
0.6702943444,
0.241652891,
-0.2049616277,
0.3114136457,
-0.8353943825,
0.1560646445,
0.101882048,
-0.6563432217,
0.2100173533,
0.2465079874,
-0.1618386656,
-0.1276785731,
0.4450529218,
-0.382340163,
0.2180369049,
-0.4192095399,
0.4637633562,
0.6055354476,
0.1414799988,
0.3412356377,
-0.4116203785,
0.8082841039,
-0.6546986103,
0.1253867,
0.2327818125,
-0.7098571062,
-0.9716742635,
0.1786514223,
0.4907460809,
0.6937316656,
-0.6489301324,
0.8460446596,
-0.1086771861,
-0.5879291296,
-0.5708382726,
0.3535222709,
0.2287232727,
0.2795886695,
0.0493993014,
-0.4404976368,
-0.6589608192,
-0.8751595616,
-0.3385950327,
-0.4025244713,
-0.2374306619,
0.294436723,
0.1349198222,
-0.3015973568,
0.9281892776,
-0.2084823549,
-0.1322267056,
-0.5690319538,
0.4479363263,
0.1920930296,
0.1791843623,
0.2176214904,
-0.3113058209,
-0.2941848338,
-0.075651437,
-0.7719278932,
-0.5502800345,
-0.0817261189,
0.0608747788,
0.223673135,
0.5743329525,
-0.5183492303,
0.1259023398,
0.7124525905,
-0.0190581977,
0.8091461062,
-0.1257654876,
0.0323418528,
-0.703361094,
-0.187091738,
0.0240648165,
-0.1382368654,
-0.7099309564,
0.0473741218,
-0.4483129382,
0.0071111182,
-0.6235705614,
0.6979160905,
-0.4873683453,
-0.2026961595,
-0.3361696303,
0.6385989189,
-0.3201126456,
0.2440301478,
-0.1858195812,
0.5661194921,
0.3905408084,
-0.5674827695,
0.9346584678,
0.0871982723,
-0.4652451277,
0.3035853803,
-0.5793815255,
0.4368622601,
0.0382518247,
0.1477484405,
-0.6828834414,
-0.1050590202,
0.377011627,
-0.4382313192,
0.1927246898,
0.0103106778,
-0.8320637941,
-0.4668944478,
-0.3937109113,
0.1536705643,
0.6678639054,
-0.5179701447,
0.1567486078,
0.2847474515,
-0.1830953807,
-0.3808090985,
-0.4251380861,
0.5654547215,
-0.3926606774,
-0.821257174,
0.1853674352,
-0.1982115805,
-0.4265786409,
-0.0751147941,
0.0366149098,
0.3703640401,
0.1303428859,
-0.0114041567,
0.0020663089,
-0.1488304138,
0.0715522319,
-0.3549159467,
-0.1613857001,
0.178276062,
-0.1488584578,
0.6181282401,
-0.5867562294,
-0.5230126381,
-0.0645065606,
0.1177507192,
-0.0145066874,
-0.1796055436,
0.2202835083,
0.8480657935,
-0.3730402589,
-0.3084503114,
-0.4702122211,
0.1648842096,
-0.4507494271,
0.4439514875,
0.3947076499,
-1.0743037462,
0.2714287341,
-0.3652322888,
0.014197289,
0.4353004098,
0.9005817771,
-0.0711704865,
0.7778635621,
0.55964607,
0.0902064517,
0.2870834768,
-0.0428954177,
0.3918140531,
-0.8300803304,
-0.092109248,
-0.289414376,
-0.312327534,
-0.8124258518,
-0.2497956157,
0.2696668506,
0.3504913449,
0.2319630533,
0.1771939099,
-0.4633595049,
0.3722025454,
0.4759325385,
-0.2657781243,
0.5825116634,
-0.2940206826,
0.0530498661,
0.1636559665,
-0.8636807203,
-0.9668657184,
0.9621607661,
0.4253540039,
0.6003158689,
0.0517209172,
0.7315219641,
0.5409319401,
0.546926856,
-1.0763170719,
0.8109582067,
-0.0915394053,
-0.3945153952,
-0.4585601389,
-0.5943551064,
-1.1044448614,
0.0560624935,
-0.3073205948,
-0.8011966348,
-0.5918679833,
-0.0203752741,
-0.2754257321,
0.2221744508,
-0.7677817345,
0.6291379929,
-0.579303503,
-0.0490653627,
0.0555289648,
-0.5031327009,
0.5684750676,
-0.0454619564,
0.2020739168,
-0.3727750182,
0.2216121703,
0.8447476029,
-0.2120077312,
0.6337385774,
0.0823285878,
-0.3898422122,
0.616922915,
-0.1740846634,
0.1195278987,
0.0574404709,
-0.1805178821,
0.2461044341,
-0.2388358861,
-0.0271447394,
-0.6221035719,
0.6839711666,
-0.5159106851,
-0.770093441,
-0.3782116473,
-0.5739352107,
-0.387188971,
-0.0169996694,
0.3837532401,
0.1151999608,
-0.4416577518,
0.1009354517,
0.1291329861,
-0.706861794,
0.6468799114,
0.0915946513,
-0.545568347,
-0.4886454642,
1.0439960957,
-0.1936149746,
0.3524307907,
0.0409974307,
0.3910346031,
-0.3092459738,
-0.7776973248,
-0.5363978148,
-0.0436101742,
-0.5115701556,
-0.246358633,
-0.287351191,
-0.5861015916,
-0.0202241205,
0.0085435379,
-0.2525144219,
-0.3838274181,
-0.314163506,
0.0097339461,
0.2623144686,
1.0981256962,
-0.0664378256,
0.3862607777,
-0.7867360711,
0.3178911209,
0.3073845208,
0.6507137418,
0.0369877219,
-0.2263092846,
-0.2018401325,
-0.0921362638,
-0.4678408206,
-0.6773404479,
0.3557197452,
0.1747473627,
0.5695748925,
0.1495926678,
-0.152183786,
0.4115755856,
-0.6024954915,
1.0082528591,
0.1577710658,
-0.9088940024,
0.4211930931,
-0.2540997267,
0.2933173776,
0.342025131,
0.0055898973,
-0.7840027809,
-0.5239741206,
-0.4402195811,
-0.9759064317,
0.4054459929,
0.4763757885,
0.1976781636,
-0.2600206137,
0.1858947277,
0.168549031,
0.0482489169,
-0.698412776,
-0.1197260767,
0.1120713428,
-0.0599213652,
0.1088462099,
-0.0162083767,
0.09609624,
-0.0691912323,
0.4444735348,
0.0118296295,
0.3036775887,
0.0590255745,
-0.1818119287,
-0.1702608168,
0.5690813661,
0.4919712543,
0.6196181178,
-0.3036980629,
-0.0385397226,
0.4795942903,
-0.2293093354,
0.1447590441,
-0.0844937116,
-0.044543907,
-0.0416451022,
0.649184525,
0.7260729671,
0.0810108855,
-0.8078129292,
0.3813416362,
-0.1838671416,
-0.4421018958,
-0.4306221902,
0.1424272656,
0.146020174,
0.1247072443,
0.4286256433,
-0.1871795803,
-0.059502665,
-0.4612402618,
0.1533921659,
0.6655439734,
-0.3269251585,
-0.1457925141,
0.4121025801,
0.2770232856,
-0.7437134385,
0.6574286222,
-0.4480933845,
-0.5904040933,
0.7208119035,
0.5620920658,
1.0874174833,
-0.006459598,
0.0404538475,
0.1738706976,
0.4620958865,
0.1893310994,
0.1944308132,
0.2069213837,
-0.7513102293,
-0.6426612735,
-0.9064903259,
-0.7715201378,
0.2909972668,
-0.3645209968,
0.3614814878,
-0.4943802655,
-0.3428579569,
-0.3424736857,
0.2614775896,
-0.7131470442,
0.1091441885,
0.5349082947,
0.7220615149,
-0.3713013828,
0.3847545087,
0.56996876,
-0.0305654872,
-0.2376011908,
-0.0555684194,
-0.012299628,
-0.6770701408,
0.4894577861,
0.1588079333,
-0.2597594261,
0.0771457851,
-0.5135096908,
-0.670881331,
1.0517858267,
0.3002462983,
-0.4620012939,
-0.1080424413,
0.3108269274,
0.8546276689,
-0.3103710711,
0.2754839659,
0.7252976298,
0.7351363897,
-0.11179851,
-1.0346417427,
-0.2575730979,
-0.2089920491,
0.0804803148,
0.1466500014,
-0.6159290671,
0.2922623754,
-0.0862863213,
-0.5189993382,
0.2194056213,
0.6541038752,
0.3654997945,
0.249082014,
0.5559281707,
0.5132157207,
0.5627413392,
-0.115154691,
0.970453918,
-0.164972499,
0.3734466434,
0.9308912754,
-0.3351199925,
0.5896165967,
0.3837982118,
-0.4520049989,
0.1821814626,
0.5874342322,
-0.3342091739,
-0.0130299088,
0.9150129557,
-0.344266355,
-0.0480844602,
-0.1268777996,
-0.15815337,
0.6878992915,
0.2551207244,
-0.0898508281,
-0.4274519086,
-0.2723212838,
-0.181302622,
0.0570237599,
-0.1980098486,
0.8740417361,
0.1809889972,
-0.6357588172,
0.4819981754,
0.1954963952,
0.9981131554,
-0.454218179,
-0.106717959,
-0.0967566073,
-0.2848635614,
-0.3431005478,
-0.7535637617,
0.491314739,
0.4060072601,
0.2690820396,
-0.2388023734,
0.8346706629,
-0.3373363614,
-0.512245357,
0.4935197532,
0.8454796672,
0.2669532001,
0.1685428172,
-0.5019446611,
0.0337868631,
-0.0980732366,
-0.3091140091,
0.2405730784,
0.3622117639,
0.0392963402,
0.7808619142,
0.7288830876,
0.2104090303,
0.3742552102,
0.3283690512,
0.5054655075,
-0.8178546429,
0.0381888822,
-1.0604319572,
0.1514837891,
0.1844830811,
-0.244143486,
0.7909929156,
0.338978827,
0.6442936659,
0.1367827803,
0.988348484,
-0.1227800027,
0.3144589365,
-0.717176497,
0.8113734126,
-0.1908137053,
0.4268898964,
-0.3103683889,
-1.1686292887,
-0.4598981142,
0.3369094729,
-0.2017043233,
0.0709095523,
0.5456184149,
0.4183937609,
0.2698957622,
0.1809325367,
0.3561682403,
-0.1471329182,
0.4347271919,
0.5438103676,
1.4756144285,
-0.2171103656,
0.6206980944,
0.0166264474,
-0.2038081735,
-0.0161463171,
-1.3921859264,
-0.7341021299,
-0.301543653,
-0.3457481265,
0.155129239,
-0.0902816951,
0.9905813336,
0.3164246082,
-0.5613519549,
-0.4606229067,
-0.1277230084,
0.2456314117,
0.096127905,
-0.287874639,
0.1901195943,
-0.4470252097,
-0.828373611,
0.5449140072,
0.3844921589,
-0.0925479755,
-0.4705183804,
-0.2278524339,
-0.1845254749,
0.0239099134,
0.8374074101,
0.1210679263,
-0.8886530399,
-0.45485425,
-0.1333919168,
0.1216694713,
0.1841871738,
0.6114626527,
-0.6350569129,
0.2744689286,
0.3369193673,
0.841591537,
0.2044138163,
0.1362588555,
0.7686414123,
-0.7948483825,
-0.2992847264,
0.4571617842,
0.1915831417,
0.6172714233,
-0.1672834009,
0.593012929,
0.0132839391,
-0.8285223842,
-0.6516489387,
0.4029442668,
-0.8424816728,
0.1931983531,
1.3465359211,
0.1159904599,
0.0250379182,
-0.0122592505,
-0.1894536167,
0.361615926,
-0.10986536,
0.6944767833,
1.0424557924,
-0.5972393751,
-0.2254896164,
-0.7659127116,
0.5584736466,
0.4040575624,
-1.1972881556,
0.0164935756,
0.3974398375,
0.0039221817,
0.1550508887,
0.4581065774,
-0.190383777,
-0.0684733465,
-0.2303529084,
0.2063024789,
0.109366551,
-0.0473772697,
-0.5292601585,
-0.1125421524,
0.368832618,
0.0461069532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01376v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01376v2
|
LoTR: Low Tensor Rank Weight Adaptation
| 2024-02-02T13:00:38 | 2024-02-05T12:42:52 |
Daniel Bershatsky, Daria Cherniuk, Talgat Daulbaev, Aleksandr Mikhalev, Ivan Oseledets
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper we generalize and extend an idea of low-rank adaptation (LoRA)
of large language models (LLMs) based on Transformer architecture. Widely used
LoRA-like methods of fine-tuning LLMs are based on matrix factorization of
gradient update. We introduce LoTR, a novel approach for parameter-efficient
fine-tuning of LLMs which represents a gradient update to parameters in a form
of tensor decomposition. Low-rank adapter for each layer is constructed as a
product of three matrices, and tensor structure arises from sharing left and
right multipliers of this product among layers. Simultaneous compression of a
sequence of layers with low-rank tensor representation allows LoTR to archive
even better parameter efficiency then LoRA especially for deep models.
Moreover, the core tensor does not depend on original weight dimension and can
be made arbitrary small, which allows for extremely cheap and fast downstream
fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.3123626709,
-0.7374826074,
0.0868983865,
0.1425937712,
-0.2676385641,
0.1336067468,
-0.2050887644,
-0.1161568239,
0.0870306492,
0.6178881526,
-0.1267597079,
-0.2268373519,
-0.7358185649,
-0.1728583276,
-0.2302317619,
1.0794861317,
-0.081542097,
0.289290756,
0.3450834155,
-0.2623425722,
-0.2778966725,
-0.3824611902,
-1.0374884605,
-0.5561701655,
0.8718108535,
0.4872522652,
0.745092988,
0.5532215834,
0.8793759346,
0.3558714986,
-0.2094085366,
0.0225027818,
-0.8941353559,
0.0828038156,
-0.1016066745,
-0.7559597492,
-0.8369032741,
-0.4014118612,
0.8329042196,
0.8179689646,
-0.1638197154,
0.3175553977,
0.2182814032,
1.0211538076,
-0.6623065472,
-0.2587682009,
-0.5377898216,
-0.0002601251,
0.1291888356,
-0.502092123,
-0.3484640718,
-0.1062542647,
-0.3445581794,
-0.4906499088,
0.3896580338,
0.1508933604,
0.504817307,
0.7002865672,
-0.1550966352,
-0.014351517,
-1.0519169569,
0.8047633767,
-0.4434743524,
0.4571182728,
0.169381395,
0.5085641146,
-0.2828710973,
-0.3917108476,
-0.4711726308,
0.0947267562,
0.0326174572,
-0.0206343383,
-0.4129809141,
0.0648104846,
0.1564523429,
0.699350059,
-0.1279295683,
0.3831873238,
-0.4942476749,
0.0682687983,
0.4431535006,
0.0796268135,
0.0951516405,
-0.1027261466,
-0.3658365905,
-0.3246847689,
-0.9257782698,
-0.0788400322,
0.293507129,
0.2645489573,
-0.3502023518,
0.5446012616,
-0.2150455564,
0.8244443536,
0.4708267748,
-0.2769277394,
-0.1048880741,
0.1127634868,
-0.3278887272,
0.1138921082,
0.5742189288,
0.0402198583,
-0.1340741515,
-0.3115668595,
-0.4022587836,
0.050781548,
-0.1221510693,
-1.0746159554,
-0.0300094634,
-0.0468470342,
-0.6582416296,
-0.2588282228,
-0.14246279,
-0.7799475789,
-0.6044783592,
-0.3447075784,
0.8958084583,
-0.1138502285,
0.0660717711,
0.4247617722,
0.0634322315,
0.8269844055,
0.4497924745,
-0.8506555557,
0.6134676933,
0.7237918377,
0.7707419991,
-0.3003204167,
-0.2635969818,
-1.0439447165,
0.1255459189,
-0.3111216128,
0.7891477942,
-0.3189583421,
-0.2586076856,
-0.2716026008,
0.050571274,
0.0622677766,
-0.6805305481,
0.6222049594,
-0.825273931,
0.1855874807,
-0.002168719,
-0.2010488808,
0.0397816636,
-0.0456925035,
-0.7813075185,
1.0673645735,
0.4915710986,
-0.5340352654,
0.3146555722,
-1.0566259623,
-0.5195579529,
-0.0918690041,
0.2362734526,
-0.4400731921,
0.454287827,
0.2870539427,
0.5666961074,
-0.6325153112,
-0.0505205058,
-0.1572062224,
-0.6050500274,
0.3150165379,
-0.2796524763,
0.4966878593,
0.2656844556,
0.0089560254,
0.0161197148,
-0.9036102295,
-0.3837403953,
-0.0182019155,
-0.7275334001,
-0.2967769504,
-0.0192657169,
0.0419826098,
0.1797123253,
0.205527246,
-0.3501316309,
0.3689506054,
-0.2964120805,
0.5240601301,
0.72930336,
-0.0062728575,
0.7659259439,
-0.4184665084,
0.598050952,
0.3591422737,
0.0899277404,
0.2451389283,
-0.0728349984,
-1.475979805,
-0.4944859445,
0.5810946226,
0.2736891508,
-0.8802760839,
0.4310443103,
-0.800287962,
-0.5815606117,
-0.8273748159,
0.3758876622,
0.1199694574,
0.1825528592,
0.3579906821,
-0.0967510045,
-0.5135936737,
-0.7990707159,
-0.0796772912,
0.0528025292,
-0.1337031871,
0.0071102437,
0.4712015688,
-0.054254286,
0.7639545798,
-0.6429001093,
-0.4936006963,
-0.4186414778,
0.035145238,
0.5393967032,
0.6258369088,
0.5046177506,
-0.5379354358,
-0.3299181163,
0.2402286828,
-0.5217179656,
0.1914436966,
0.2073954195,
-0.2788887918,
-0.0594101362,
0.6148190498,
-0.4249526262,
0.0703078136,
0.9648044705,
-0.3486349285,
-0.2991199195,
-0.3777525425,
-0.0662456006,
-1.3881087303,
0.0196276307,
-0.0570704527,
-0.2756471038,
-0.7790506482,
0.171155408,
-0.3021869361,
-0.3098607063,
-0.3732940555,
0.6623120308,
-0.4520406723,
-0.2214057297,
-0.416174233,
-0.0052983835,
0.0202518106,
0.5957227349,
-0.454449594,
0.8223421574,
0.6201075912,
-0.6775409579,
0.1659528315,
0.2559999228,
-0.3834835589,
0.6784067154,
-0.7639539838,
0.3851695657,
-0.4458222687,
0.2867015898,
-0.7465049028,
-0.0173591357,
0.2147892416,
-0.0190886967,
0.265991956,
-0.5960953832,
-0.3681405783,
-0.0793365836,
-0.4500337243,
0.3914094567,
0.6627595425,
-0.6960891485,
1.0444376469,
0.3301663101,
-0.1595819443,
-0.4499032497,
-0.7674278617,
-0.0816516802,
-0.4492500126,
-0.4283710718,
0.4913664162,
-0.3477499187,
-0.181578353,
-0.1836217791,
0.0857645944,
0.0778246224,
0.1278917938,
0.2089681327,
0.2184278071,
-0.8187584281,
-0.1646276563,
0.0672054142,
-0.2501333654,
-0.4602566957,
-0.0078446986,
0.6674954295,
-0.1001148894,
-0.2115133107,
-0.1433769614,
0.0811580867,
0.5945131779,
0.1104027182,
0.7321459651,
0.8564791083,
-0.2594645321,
-0.3955539763,
-0.5842840075,
-0.1235138252,
-0.5267549157,
0.3843135834,
-0.646676302,
-1.0339486599,
0.7242506742,
-0.1415082663,
-0.3830065727,
0.5352084637,
0.7089941502,
0.0609656014,
0.6959100366,
0.8921051621,
-0.4278864264,
0.6012476683,
-0.3414683044,
0.3019255698,
-1.0772205591,
0.3169872463,
-0.6258544922,
-0.9875165224,
-0.855619669,
-0.8047094345,
0.3455974162,
0.537343204,
-0.4389522374,
0.2229059339,
-0.3937518895,
0.6056739092,
0.3802577853,
0.0685341433,
0.5936499834,
0.130369097,
0.5597744584,
0.3209390938,
-0.7413077354,
-0.1664640605,
0.8530979156,
0.3469055593,
1.1723533869,
0.5543882251,
0.6420613527,
0.406509012,
0.4173516035,
-1.1178251505,
0.5164862275,
-0.6065422297,
-0.3550933897,
-0.4212765694,
-0.3090417683,
-0.9933716059,
0.4126572907,
-0.2015449256,
-0.5547879934,
0.5524958372,
0.0202108361,
-0.4469942153,
0.3127876818,
-0.6909885406,
0.3688898981,
0.0466860048,
-0.2428120971,
-0.2116309702,
-0.2229004949,
0.1173964068,
-0.1899631768,
0.0079817446,
-0.0140752355,
-0.1381016821,
1.0930912495,
-0.1812466681,
0.7659153342,
-0.3722489476,
-0.2342070341,
0.0246923417,
0.1363727897,
0.8061509132,
-0.136142686,
-0.3907313347,
0.0654564574,
-0.2826706171,
-0.514759481,
-0.8208093643,
0.755074501,
-1.2553529739,
-0.5938904881,
-0.0002175576,
-0.4971168637,
-0.3369084597,
0.0613084361,
-0.0027667498,
0.3379543126,
-0.2298467755,
0.4203337729,
0.6225221157,
-0.1667676121,
0.5415120125,
0.6396847367,
-0.304364711,
-0.5537337065,
1.0789743662,
-0.0764603615,
0.13723737,
0.8511381745,
0.3530399799,
0.2320209146,
-0.7830991149,
-0.3960045576,
0.3182784319,
-0.890946269,
-0.5029695034,
-0.2513628006,
-0.439245224,
0.123263903,
-0.2582426667,
-0.4159221947,
-0.4143074751,
-0.3215655982,
0.1780109853,
0.632632792,
0.8459624648,
0.1634416133,
0.8745484948,
-0.3521885872,
0.6615120769,
0.4170052111,
0.6034125686,
-0.0759903118,
-1.0016754866,
-0.3599422276,
-0.2984263599,
-0.1375359893,
-0.0398905501,
0.0868305117,
0.3932333887,
0.2153014392,
0.2792264223,
-0.11504554,
0.7048504353,
-0.4173708856,
0.4957919419,
0.2083689123,
-0.9312218428,
0.1549198478,
-0.3509302437,
0.1929041594,
0.4121887982,
-0.0536135063,
-0.3724992275,
0.0906183869,
-0.1961331815,
-0.5448407531,
0.7053798437,
-0.0986895412,
0.4064389467,
0.5756435394,
0.3346311152,
0.1919335127,
-0.1312791407,
-0.6427120566,
-0.2799410224,
-0.1192038208,
-0.2175621986,
-0.2603615224,
-0.3334685564,
-0.245346114,
-0.4220782518,
0.6363460422,
-0.5125334263,
0.5253862143,
-0.0182893872,
-0.4513627589,
-0.3597159386,
0.540912807,
0.663947165,
0.5431687832,
-0.1512410641,
0.1959788054,
0.4933958352,
-0.4373585582,
0.1933801174,
0.1056736484,
-0.078022629,
-0.3581201434,
0.2197958082,
1.2814234495,
0.5874763131,
0.0066471738,
0.5215594172,
0.0903342143,
-0.1717786342,
0.0884896293,
0.2262676656,
0.0836352408,
0.3233259618,
0.649064064,
0.1752908975,
-0.2061800659,
-0.2294769734,
-0.1846761853,
0.2509467602,
-0.5733774304,
-0.5055541396,
0.4562804401,
0.1820165515,
-0.3703401983,
0.0042648744,
0.0575037748,
-0.0404332317,
0.0969941393,
0.6643254161,
0.6921602488,
-0.3298690319,
0.1660848111,
0.0147324344,
0.0755431131,
-0.0901271626,
0.2453507483,
0.3382730484,
-0.9304732084,
-0.7775403857,
-1.0601819754,
-0.2643640041,
0.3502276838,
-0.4352615774,
0.5740889907,
-0.6308748722,
0.0452648439,
0.2182314396,
-0.1366834193,
-0.7460702658,
-0.0152634531,
0.0327613503,
0.7144760489,
-0.6576212049,
0.9806696773,
0.574400425,
-0.3634979129,
-0.5842747688,
-0.0899155214,
-0.54925704,
-1.1426486969,
0.877727747,
-0.5598451495,
-0.4080523849,
0.4193949401,
-0.3482219875,
-1.076816678,
1.2541658878,
0.759370923,
-0.3481440246,
-0.1838322729,
0.4269693196,
0.6793018579,
-0.3407152891,
-0.0453446619,
0.3751006722,
0.4260211587,
0.0450805277,
-0.5221324563,
0.0174118038,
-0.0243252758,
0.3013644814,
0.3306548297,
-0.9250941873,
0.9415923953,
0.0521654412,
0.1672276407,
0.1289025992,
0.7184352875,
-0.0782230496,
-0.3025142252,
0.5136452317,
0.372935921,
0.5351509452,
0.0356576107,
0.8674360514,
-0.5114761591,
0.4410825968,
0.7961591482,
-0.2042898387,
1.191385746,
0.7861113548,
-0.3949333131,
0.620922327,
0.0721698776,
-0.1290452182,
0.3847032189,
0.3361410797,
0.0172731075,
-0.0621514693,
-0.1306177825,
-0.2676250637,
0.7315996289,
0.104249239,
-0.2504920363,
-0.1152758747,
0.0437973402,
-0.0892881379,
-0.434120506,
-0.6730454564,
0.8310675025,
0.2200931609,
-0.4617057741,
0.9005390406,
0.1273538023,
0.8709073663,
-0.4372566938,
0.1127040386,
-0.3896310925,
0.4819191098,
-0.1846646369,
-0.3569239974,
-0.162501812,
-0.124257043,
-0.4684923589,
-0.0907346159,
0.9153207541,
-0.2607278228,
-0.8584644198,
0.2953226864,
0.793800056,
-0.1889803112,
0.107554473,
-0.4539507031,
0.1408624947,
-0.3878461719,
-0.5289678574,
0.6055679917,
0.3365356922,
0.0581045486,
0.6625075936,
0.7277194858,
0.2675489783,
-0.0034545923,
0.3601008356,
0.9532012343,
-0.8350850344,
-0.3340468109,
-0.6964231133,
0.345356524,
0.2638652623,
-0.1392468363,
0.1887923628,
0.4868565798,
0.3271381855,
-0.2206853777,
0.5281012058,
0.0732294917,
0.3326083422,
-0.7277528644,
0.8554206491,
-0.4967432022,
0.2989898324,
-0.1979732066,
-1.2705316544,
-0.3782258332,
0.3212772906,
-0.3010280132,
0.0760678127,
0.6834242344,
0.9473969936,
-0.4822051227,
-0.3416164219,
0.5622563362,
0.41247347,
0.0208510514,
0.3393236101,
0.8129696846,
-0.9592863917,
0.5051375031,
0.019522842,
-0.0478629097,
-0.460857749,
-0.8752073646,
-0.8239838481,
-0.4954187572,
-0.3404662311,
-0.1999887675,
0.0113788312,
0.7573254108,
0.7455996871,
-0.9235424995,
-0.3300869167,
0.1558808684,
0.0831786618,
-0.1208403334,
-0.20064044,
0.6033726335,
0.0176002681,
-0.655964911,
0.4945236146,
0.210489288,
-0.0680913851,
-0.465138644,
-0.4412219226,
0.1325191408,
-0.0022836248,
0.8168022037,
0.0171690378,
-0.5564565659,
-0.4345839918,
-0.1368095577,
-0.1057716161,
0.5556582212,
0.8982946873,
-0.6701114178,
-0.1285930127,
0.4902763069,
0.8594079614,
0.6763008237,
-0.1860769838,
0.4212448597,
-0.6773142219,
0.199454397,
-0.0966047272,
0.5048291087,
0.6653157473,
-0.1682460308,
0.534756124,
-0.1050952822,
-0.3657633364,
-0.79630512,
0.0006476353,
-1.4583593607,
0.0619530901,
1.2911883593,
0.3088172972,
-0.3940877318,
0.1169384867,
-0.2633997202,
0.2337571383,
-0.2857343554,
0.7309045196,
0.455847919,
0.1138649583,
-0.3014943004,
-0.3723526299,
0.3971510231,
0.2570814788,
-0.7768344879,
0.0991031379,
-0.1134203002,
0.3228933513,
0.1754404306,
0.3717731535,
0.084245339,
-0.0735758096,
-0.2779116035,
-0.0129628452,
0.211012736,
0.0900998414,
-0.6695786715,
0.1379083693,
0.5955044627,
-0.0095454277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01375v1
|
Dive into the Chasm: Probing the Gap between In- and Cross-Topic Generalization
| 2024-02-02T12:59:27 | 2024-02-02T12:59:27 |
Andreas Waldis, Yufang Hou, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (LMs) perform well in In-Topic setups, where
training and testing data come from the same topics. However, they face
challenges in Cross-Topic scenarios where testing data is derived from distinct
topics -- such as Gun Control. This study analyzes various LMs with three
probing-based experiments to shed light on the reasons behind the In- vs.
Cross-Topic generalization gap. Thereby, we demonstrate, for the first time,
that generalization gaps and the robustness of the embedding space vary
significantly across LMs. Additionally, we assess larger LMs and underscore the
relevance of our analysis for recent models. Overall, diverse pre-training
objectives, architectural regularization, or data deduplication contribute to
more robust LMs and diminish generalization gaps. Our research contributes to a
deeper understanding and comparison of language models across different
generalization scenarios.
|
[
-0.6137465239,
-0.9884371758,
0.7009757161,
-0.365608573,
-0.1438548118,
0.1103491262,
0.0899530053,
-0.213896811,
-0.3437099159,
0.3533742726,
-0.4593712389,
-0.4972608387,
-0.9034131765,
-0.2654936612,
-0.4893835783,
0.9136270881,
-0.0950153098,
-0.0191101003,
-0.152249977,
-0.0925003737,
-0.3784075975,
-0.6126526594,
-0.255143106,
-0.3523364663,
0.3107637465,
0.1670715958,
0.8189160824,
0.5739403367,
0.6640472412,
0.2186852545,
0.0137351518,
-0.3115798831,
-0.2894322574,
-0.0140741393,
-0.2783902287,
-0.3235702515,
-0.116260618,
0.1778877527,
0.5761246681,
1.008513689,
0.0441010147,
-0.1822897941,
0.0165728368,
0.2973794043,
-0.9612711072,
-0.2176427245,
-0.7240927815,
-0.0751715228,
-0.2588368058,
-0.0002796094,
-0.1803589165,
-0.151894629,
0.6505719423,
-0.2949861288,
0.7352796197,
-0.2020426989,
1.1973921061,
0.1598584801,
-0.5580580235,
-0.4566766024,
-0.8503841162,
0.9112005234,
-0.7855446339,
0.6067447662,
0.5202189088,
0.2072989941,
0.0045222021,
-0.8262281418,
-0.3927083313,
-0.2034028769,
-0.1291473955,
-0.2574273348,
-0.2465084195,
-0.0595592558,
0.1646417826,
0.5119642019,
-0.690859735,
0.1168846861,
-0.1717776358,
-0.2307392359,
0.40548262,
0.3247703016,
0.3895021975,
0.3587916195,
-0.2477818578,
-0.1338147521,
-0.894377172,
0.3007487059,
0.4362131953,
0.4780263901,
-0.2713600099,
0.2954207957,
0.1028672308,
0.8817077875,
-0.2172123492,
0.3679922819,
-0.0339165479,
-0.6815696359,
-0.2458793521,
-0.2164687067,
0.5464595556,
0.1199133024,
0.2784977853,
-0.0578019358,
-0.0518387817,
0.2287648022,
0.3919827044,
-0.5882745981,
-0.1084111258,
0.2630127072,
-0.1837943941,
-0.0560134463,
0.2617381811,
-0.6863058805,
-0.252920419,
-0.1542325318,
0.1982523054,
-0.1432446539,
-0.1733757854,
0.5605336428,
-0.1861701906,
0.6333693862,
0.1419513375,
-0.9182853103,
0.5184600949,
0.8570278883,
0.9183627963,
-0.1223868504,
-0.3434536457,
-0.3566199243,
0.2664025426,
-0.4327178597,
0.6570988894,
-0.8848757148,
-0.4074468613,
0.2427228838,
-0.0012974595,
-0.0894714221,
-0.4688668251,
0.2791649997,
-0.6131790876,
0.3201519847,
-0.3916618228,
-0.8230660558,
0.0455820113,
0.3744471967,
-0.3783438504,
0.7460878491,
0.0157430042,
-0.907256484,
0.5678012371,
-0.4806300104,
-0.0956709385,
-0.3763841689,
-0.4185337722,
-0.5530560613,
0.0845349506,
0.1908430755,
0.4644462764,
-0.4339865446,
0.2617198825,
-0.6356227994,
-0.4967806041,
0.2882678807,
0.0921051651,
0.6009638906,
0.1422983408,
-0.4324692786,
-0.0971403942,
-0.2579113543,
-0.2766008079,
0.1324925572,
0.0667252094,
-0.7757290006,
0.1861052811,
-0.268258214,
0.1712472737,
-0.2509745955,
-0.5005321503,
0.0118963486,
-0.465239048,
0.3258279562,
0.5808308125,
0.0628416762,
0.5812007785,
-0.2943644226,
0.5007388592,
0.320491612,
0.0351765864,
-0.3282335103,
-0.3087749779,
-0.8600202203,
0.1057107523,
0.3303477466,
0.4898729026,
-0.2320025861,
0.4368766844,
-0.0461616516,
-0.531121552,
-0.277004987,
-0.0238985214,
0.3673945963,
0.3796969056,
0.3265966475,
-0.4626347125,
-0.1073980853,
-0.8538788557,
-0.4610475004,
0.1452583224,
0.0185725056,
0.1098137051,
0.696831286,
-0.4991639555,
1.0090917349,
-0.4320000112,
-0.0758964121,
-0.2729973495,
0.0209470335,
-0.007969995,
0.6362510324,
0.5648888946,
-0.6815443039,
-0.5044768453,
0.0373120904,
-0.4575803578,
-0.1186652109,
-0.0140682757,
-0.0114570195,
-0.244275257,
0.7663538456,
-0.4905256927,
0.7712129951,
0.4695119858,
-0.2829078436,
0.2424831539,
0.0857045427,
0.013498853,
-0.9504358768,
-0.1672311425,
0.0718535185,
0.0051848795,
-0.9154131413,
0.1733473688,
0.0130772265,
-0.2402589321,
-0.4483611882,
0.4393184483,
-0.4965845644,
-0.2123525292,
-0.3040426075,
0.2843076885,
-0.0976215601,
0.1832567453,
-0.0694137588,
0.6451845765,
0.9805090427,
-0.8362416625,
0.0158901401,
-0.0155823743,
-0.3639166355,
0.0441293344,
-0.9910483956,
0.2661742568,
-0.0704794303,
0.1941690147,
-0.9822390079,
-0.0688710287,
0.3124307096,
-0.1576016992,
0.3913525939,
-0.1498399079,
-0.1465269327,
0.0819823071,
-0.2929877341,
0.5641443133,
0.3790231347,
0.0073250788,
0.3342380226,
0.5607512593,
-0.2004348487,
-0.6525077224,
-0.8361566067,
-0.2924453616,
-0.4750379622,
-0.4628002942,
0.2387091964,
0.0849075839,
-0.680809021,
-0.0908650681,
-0.1346387118,
-0.0544206388,
0.0420592166,
0.1353089064,
-0.0938592926,
-0.3194046319,
0.44685179,
0.035715472,
-0.1664335579,
0.0482490994,
-0.1419434994,
0.8291239142,
-0.2009268105,
-0.7956399918,
-0.373968184,
0.5031699538,
0.2834360003,
-0.4276358485,
0.5368227959,
0.1466318667,
-0.2335335314,
-0.2566713095,
-0.5426870584,
-0.3599703908,
-0.4902052581,
0.2318169326,
-0.4660025239,
-1.2380824089,
0.5910674334,
-0.1849051118,
0.164640069,
0.2881525755,
0.5003658533,
-0.1008032635,
0.5575278401,
0.9494757652,
-0.0045985193,
0.4721993804,
-0.2855482697,
0.2805678844,
-0.4472586513,
0.0588065535,
-0.956335783,
-0.0926992521,
-0.511433661,
-0.4747935832,
-0.0099969292,
-0.0949281082,
-0.3855699599,
0.2201463431,
-0.0759150535,
0.5198440552,
0.2690786719,
-0.2004862279,
0.1248104423,
-0.0264172256,
-0.0284316279,
-0.2491133213,
-0.6090266109,
-0.5492334366,
1.0244992971,
0.5496070981,
0.9894809127,
0.0083593437,
0.56432271,
0.3230526745,
0.0303089917,
-0.581304729,
0.2502003908,
-0.1393225342,
-0.6318371892,
-0.4230367839,
-0.2506196201,
-1.2937299013,
0.3772993982,
0.269541651,
-0.5992928147,
0.51660496,
0.001435715,
-0.3174965084,
0.3828329742,
-0.4329152405,
0.9746049047,
-0.018764874,
-0.2250658721,
-0.1024180725,
-0.7782968879,
0.2694156468,
-0.2379281372,
0.1944564879,
-0.2692860067,
-0.3866382837,
0.4147746265,
-0.3802850246,
0.8966317773,
0.0712285936,
-0.4144717753,
0.2496854663,
0.1517021954,
0.2792676985,
0.0478213169,
0.1808612347,
0.06334088,
-0.2147031277,
-0.7352276444,
-0.7610518336,
0.4700605273,
-0.8724190593,
-0.9007362723,
-0.583173573,
-0.4637965858,
-0.6673451662,
-0.0676112622,
0.4265183508,
0.4080602527,
-0.3443848789,
0.288248688,
1.0884158611,
-0.33903265,
0.4487051368,
0.6924536228,
-0.1134777442,
0.0729038492,
0.4888599813,
-0.087553151,
0.5908238888,
0.395057112,
0.1624844968,
-0.1512745768,
-0.7086737156,
-0.0827512443,
0.169381842,
-0.5080328584,
0.2243028283,
-0.8920505047,
-0.2203563899,
-0.6977263689,
-0.3644877374,
-0.5586187243,
0.1181740463,
-0.1655163318,
-0.1166061461,
-0.0981528461,
0.6801273227,
0.0800740719,
0.5535301566,
-0.9482366443,
-0.0155379772,
0.4221045971,
0.1028462574,
-0.164268285,
-0.7326030731,
-0.3330125213,
0.0689744875,
-0.2821227908,
-1.2380151749,
0.151952222,
0.0714820474,
0.8401722312,
0.4400558472,
-0.0849700123,
0.5987567902,
-0.2227674276,
0.8389831781,
-0.1472630203,
-1.1589550972,
0.8929870725,
-0.5668826699,
0.4679282606,
0.4651786387,
0.702526629,
-0.3077979982,
-0.6844144464,
-0.5607528687,
-0.5969724059,
0.5227363706,
0.2164475322,
0.4236567318,
0.4268524051,
0.2478966415,
0.3812659979,
0.0759048983,
-0.7582452893,
-0.1536032259,
-0.0561153293,
0.3372540474,
-0.4028298855,
-0.1514832526,
-0.2985274196,
-0.1323641241,
0.4470855594,
0.0159372874,
-0.0218735468,
0.1298523545,
-0.214726463,
0.1122045964,
0.3531717956,
0.7028623223,
0.6140685678,
-0.0217283852,
0.2783448398,
0.1334046721,
-0.4573493898,
0.463798672,
0.0315864868,
-0.0751531571,
0.1703063399,
0.665379107,
0.8614563346,
0.0636053383,
-0.4590507448,
0.5198343396,
0.0000914946,
0.0354529843,
0.1416993439,
0.0865515023,
-0.1491254419,
0.114600867,
0.0072398786,
-0.293219775,
0.1541702747,
-0.7687360048,
0.3949328661,
0.4319368303,
-0.358817488,
-0.2889808118,
0.2022172809,
0.0850691348,
-0.0367088169,
0.4970893562,
0.1437333077,
-0.3043234646,
0.6879917383,
0.4184645116,
0.9185332656,
-0.2989899218,
0.2665926814,
0.0481955707,
0.6765283346,
0.2926083207,
0.2484903038,
-0.2069494724,
-0.9354144335,
-0.2122033834,
-0.2945772111,
-0.4605514109,
0.2347217351,
-0.7638394237,
0.1745643318,
-0.2922441661,
-0.380125165,
-0.3168374896,
-0.0277277157,
-0.4886683524,
0.1644526422,
-0.1058108658,
0.8058860302,
-1.0658392906,
0.9592990279,
0.7004803419,
-0.217992872,
-0.5088971257,
0.4670554101,
-0.1249926463,
-0.4784511328,
0.3408179283,
-0.0611210652,
0.0116710337,
-0.312523365,
-0.5805271864,
-0.9327880144,
0.7061758637,
0.3705318868,
-0.5454891324,
-0.0298675429,
0.5971569419,
0.510543406,
-0.4330642819,
-0.1137739569,
0.8008083701,
0.2423909456,
-0.2709297836,
-0.7803122401,
-0.2720376849,
-0.1592265069,
0.1027303934,
0.4804233909,
-0.6398156881,
1.1287742853,
-0.0523280725,
-0.1962499022,
-0.2257198393,
0.4761361182,
0.2944676578,
0.5624704361,
0.3511340022,
0.7735768557,
0.2981698811,
-0.2913959324,
1.1048589945,
-0.0672152042,
0.4103027582,
1.3043624163,
-0.5128887296,
0.5393354297,
0.5522007346,
-0.2585520744,
0.5407531261,
0.9555111527,
0.0260678027,
0.7134197354,
0.4707870781,
-0.0486780405,
-0.3314499259,
-0.033143837,
-0.949072361,
0.4351590574,
0.5425999761,
-0.4190967381,
-0.6300652027,
-0.0590288155,
-0.1147727445,
-0.0355602615,
-0.148408249,
0.645157814,
0.1794348955,
-0.3941992521,
0.1305961758,
-0.1123716086,
0.5523118377,
-1.0803409815,
0.2528555095,
-0.5133453608,
0.110939756,
0.240696311,
-0.6060520411,
0.4760184288,
-0.1375396848,
0.0015482967,
-0.1652024835,
0.9796581864,
-0.4456053078,
-0.1286010742,
0.4641448855,
0.9034471512,
0.1436825693,
-0.002339818,
-0.63406533,
0.4601937532,
-0.2693659663,
-0.2832342684,
0.5575345159,
0.468886137,
-0.0442110114,
0.6029216647,
0.5227121711,
0.020316707,
0.3368941844,
-0.0119778281,
0.9186420441,
-0.6191260815,
-0.5578364134,
-1.0798802376,
0.5037854314,
0.1039506271,
-0.5811295509,
0.8969022632,
0.5462313294,
1.1586738825,
-0.1325675398,
0.7449762821,
0.3080824018,
0.4100545347,
-0.4390091896,
0.6824020743,
-0.669093132,
0.2363399416,
-0.394171387,
-0.9214075208,
-0.1837428212,
0.3493712246,
-0.3716967702,
0.2166104764,
0.5728619695,
1.0411543846,
-0.241285637,
-0.0407225378,
0.499129951,
-0.2019414008,
0.3676480055,
0.5464135408,
1.3093434572,
-0.376082629,
0.2411992401,
-0.2289173901,
-0.0346221998,
0.1233633682,
-0.7186543941,
-0.9985259771,
-0.6354913712,
-0.3884327412,
-0.0045196712,
0.1298291236,
0.3945648074,
0.7604070306,
-1.0050237179,
-0.5365524292,
-0.2813433409,
0.0582147352,
0.1083391905,
-0.2148060054,
0.1934558898,
-0.558863461,
-0.8076232672,
0.2795891762,
0.2417062521,
0.5305963159,
-0.3006402254,
-0.0228281152,
-0.3354496658,
0.3199898303,
0.221596539,
0.2300648242,
-0.7856230736,
-0.0353861861,
-0.0766688809,
-0.3622782528,
-0.2583659589,
1.5437842607,
-0.4671044648,
0.3882237077,
0.5510419607,
1.0985509157,
0.3261440098,
-0.2482582629,
0.9647799134,
-0.6694737673,
0.3274321556,
0.2660822868,
0.2758314312,
0.0818013027,
-0.0005211761,
0.5480942726,
0.3558524549,
-0.5964338183,
-1.1552611589,
0.4596982002,
-0.5476523638,
-0.5008765459,
0.9446495771,
-0.3373504877,
0.4659399986,
-0.4764265418,
0.1696444452,
0.3320114315,
-0.0290744528,
0.6933836937,
1.0399566889,
-0.1157884225,
-0.1927295029,
-0.4680053592,
0.6119653583,
0.636847198,
-0.9007166624,
-0.1545390785,
0.2595826387,
0.233039543,
0.0885055065,
0.5148376822,
-0.0072283046,
0.3047628403,
0.1246359348,
-0.355422914,
0.2591679394,
-0.3026594222,
-0.6292878389,
0.2908245623,
-0.2718669474,
-0.2836024165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01364v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01364v2
|
Continual Learning for Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-02-02T12:34:09 | 2024-02-07T07:14:39 |
Tongtong Wu, Linhao Luo, Yuan-Fang Li, Shirui Pan, Thuy-Trang Vu, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are not amenable to frequent re-training, due to
high training costs arising from their massive scale. However, updates are
necessary to endow LLMs with new skills and keep them up-to-date with rapidly
evolving human knowledge. This paper surveys recent works on continual learning
for LLMs. Due to the unique nature of LLMs, we catalog continue learning
techniques in a novel multi-staged categorization scheme, involving continual
pretraining, instruction tuning, and alignment. We contrast continual learning
for LLMs with simpler adaptation methods used in smaller models, as well as
with other enhancement strategies like retrieval-augmented generation and model
editing. Moreover, informed by a discussion of benchmarks and evaluation, we
identify several challenges and future work directions for this crucial task.
|
[
-0.0039066775,
-0.6008243561,
0.5353027582,
0.1954790056,
-0.1388354301,
0.3858892918,
-0.5956795216,
-0.4591895342,
-0.185880065,
0.6904281378,
-0.6532719135,
-0.2436776012,
-0.44920367,
0.1369502991,
-0.2602731884,
0.7764202356,
-0.1414479464,
0.2763928175,
-0.2516118586,
-0.2390889376,
-0.7667500973,
-0.7715629339,
-1.0944657326,
-0.3636987507,
0.9192746878,
0.5726642013,
0.2946527302,
0.4660929441,
0.2884564996,
0.2723608911,
-0.0753309205,
0.1976162046,
-0.6167452335,
0.5428068042,
-0.1125285402,
-0.4424615204,
-0.203502506,
-0.0096685821,
1.1776403189,
1.1583758593,
-0.3300300539,
0.1000386402,
0.2590172291,
0.6989717484,
-0.6178359985,
-0.0913400576,
-0.7696845531,
-0.0533817708,
-0.2970010042,
0.0810845494,
-0.635284543,
-0.4116695821,
0.1070423797,
-0.3026513755,
-0.0363548808,
0.1412940174,
0.4208776653,
0.301889807,
-0.3897795081,
-0.3781514764,
-0.858489275,
0.9184624553,
-0.5415020585,
0.6493812799,
0.1612810791,
0.1656285375,
-0.3582351208,
-0.765276432,
-0.3071981072,
-0.749294579,
0.3231038153,
0.0114442715,
0.0993996561,
-0.0920828432,
-0.0034294615,
0.1720375568,
-0.3930328488,
0.6008455753,
-0.1253587157,
-0.0740430206,
0.5792802572,
0.2616807818,
0.2016360909,
0.5186217427,
-0.2233898938,
0.0434764773,
-1.1199477911,
-0.3198035955,
0.0565236621,
-0.0566992871,
0.0625624359,
0.2908727825,
-0.0202718377,
0.7972511053,
-0.0454865769,
-0.1445732117,
0.1195982769,
-0.1248404831,
-0.043368116,
-0.179334119,
0.5274081826,
-0.0756413713,
0.4426386058,
-0.3800479472,
-0.4093717039,
-0.2970098853,
0.3074087501,
-0.3098641038,
-0.0576219708,
-0.0870028138,
-0.1889186352,
-0.0806597248,
-0.2878389955,
-0.6066326499,
-0.2791051865,
-0.5499898791,
0.4630174339,
-0.1532534212,
-0.1563386172,
0.1506707668,
0.2771574557,
0.2532179356,
0.5888780355,
-0.9252185822,
0.1207113191,
0.673401773,
0.9081653357,
-0.2987944484,
-0.543954432,
-0.6330339909,
0.2452946305,
-0.8133865595,
0.7696371675,
-0.6454906464,
-0.2592779994,
0.1782668382,
0.434332341,
-0.1999149173,
-0.7384215593,
0.1421594024,
-0.6463286281,
0.1652459353,
-0.2761600912,
-0.5967797637,
0.0019942578,
0.3722931743,
-0.5026172996,
0.9022946358,
0.0812576115,
-0.2499226481,
0.4218738079,
-0.2987676263,
-0.228799969,
0.325986892,
0.0733557791,
-0.3962953389,
0.2905918956,
-0.307736963,
0.5199427009,
-0.1479221433,
0.4534094334,
-0.5607028008,
-0.1643596888,
0.3158615828,
-0.4774158001,
0.3268286288,
0.1678436995,
0.0025005997,
0.1925205737,
-0.63179636,
-0.3475632966,
0.1066524684,
-0.5955488682,
-0.0797408074,
0.2752892375,
-0.2475702763,
0.3368390501,
0.5175837874,
-0.3018821478,
0.5255420804,
-0.1682746559,
0.35715276,
0.9169916511,
0.1043007821,
0.3607469797,
-0.5883712769,
0.5704270601,
-0.1332188994,
0.1896698624,
-0.3079876602,
-0.2150023878,
-1.0028516054,
0.0373659395,
0.4227508903,
0.4215123057,
-0.6593028307,
0.2163169682,
-0.4362922609,
-0.5364587903,
0.0361996032,
0.5458348393,
0.3496478796,
0.0175632108,
0.297886163,
-0.3978624046,
-0.5435318947,
-0.4020931125,
-0.0050418242,
0.0473409854,
-0.0267646853,
-0.0083474303,
0.6344297528,
-0.4217719734,
0.6183004379,
-0.16716519,
-0.05954827,
-0.4193685353,
0.0358290523,
-0.0966006964,
0.5692408681,
0.3677740395,
-0.3630638421,
-0.4845181704,
0.0766057447,
-0.7797088027,
0.1105175242,
-0.4181155562,
0.2346742153,
0.2245710939,
0.9616432786,
-0.4263053834,
-0.2222156525,
0.4765437245,
0.1302090287,
0.7947791815,
-0.435451299,
-0.2922176123,
-0.801469326,
-0.04766348,
-0.1023842841,
-0.4154219329,
-0.7768594027,
0.0945621058,
-0.0435240939,
0.0391148254,
-0.3846561313,
1.0357803106,
-0.8472123146,
-0.0513532534,
-0.4350736737,
0.1250812709,
-0.4689947963,
0.3617311716,
0.2247763872,
0.5674412847,
0.7149543166,
-0.8943989277,
0.5901405215,
-0.0970244259,
-0.3114961982,
0.2194839567,
-0.5092832446,
0.3203063011,
-0.1725281924,
0.4599065781,
-0.7370393276,
-0.3285584152,
0.3612501323,
-0.1547278017,
0.7245566845,
-0.1094451323,
-0.5913728476,
-0.3736638129,
-0.0720798597,
0.0890186355,
0.5561739802,
-0.7018020153,
0.3230243623,
0.2475369275,
-0.4375610054,
-0.4587490857,
-0.4544066489,
0.2930867672,
-0.2858412862,
-0.1649121493,
0.0308415443,
-0.1522415131,
-0.2408090979,
-0.1661814153,
-0.1720320582,
0.1387962848,
0.1829990298,
-0.1099594161,
0.0748995394,
-0.1751412302,
0.5651206374,
-0.2920455337,
-0.0553249605,
-0.0226765927,
-0.5864183903,
0.6263454556,
0.0670878887,
-0.2286960185,
-0.2698989213,
0.1630071402,
0.4585859776,
-0.1259407103,
0.9616615772,
0.4951947033,
-0.2996517122,
-0.1797769517,
-0.9339850545,
-0.0919295102,
-0.4389592409,
0.3956403136,
-0.2745485902,
-1.2633975744,
0.3673614562,
-0.4513081014,
0.2559689581,
0.4340241551,
0.6981575489,
-0.2695190907,
0.7916247249,
0.8763875961,
-0.2231084406,
0.6386607289,
0.1872655898,
-0.1961867064,
-0.7347477674,
-0.3375119865,
-0.5661706328,
-0.1183932647,
-0.4253599644,
-0.2694866061,
0.0942650512,
0.305419147,
-0.3338918984,
0.0514444001,
-0.1709093899,
0.3306035995,
0.1655323058,
0.0086460346,
0.2127276957,
-0.0863265693,
0.1422293484,
0.2172308266,
-0.8879344463,
-0.318767637,
1.111258626,
0.3554430902,
0.9120423794,
0.1702875346,
0.5951110125,
0.158111468,
0.7387558222,
-0.6653546691,
0.4558316469,
-0.0708128363,
-0.3582755923,
-0.4454839826,
-0.577932179,
-1.1706823111,
0.1311647594,
-0.0833885148,
-0.6964980364,
0.0400180146,
0.3139384985,
0.0236156899,
0.2319942415,
-0.3135408759,
0.8312295675,
-0.4968854487,
-0.3376835883,
-0.3615184128,
-0.622025311,
0.3177033663,
-0.6031903028,
0.2625962198,
0.1315643042,
-0.1931487769,
0.7153593302,
-0.299742043,
0.9867866039,
0.0505575053,
-0.233199805,
0.2212133557,
-0.1752632707,
0.4817238748,
-0.0864046067,
0.2083272338,
-0.0698596165,
0.0905045941,
-0.5028043985,
-0.3418984115,
0.6410329342,
-0.5410261154,
-0.6500310898,
-0.5597726107,
-0.3118145466,
-0.5012692213,
0.1204408631,
0.0384143032,
0.4434255958,
-0.1151740849,
0.4409555793,
0.9193811417,
-0.2912352681,
0.3636384308,
0.3645772934,
-0.3116238117,
-0.3599627614,
1.0592443943,
0.2288914323,
0.4201472402,
0.2876469791,
0.2207097411,
-0.395127207,
-0.7550720572,
-0.1033120528,
0.5718411207,
-0.7207297683,
0.0403767861,
-0.5551540852,
-0.1989656687,
-0.336494565,
-0.1258397549,
-0.2591209114,
-0.0982419401,
-0.4136611223,
0.2325943708,
0.2317182571,
0.8787246346,
-0.1289420426,
0.4596112072,
-0.9818663597,
0.0313558839,
0.4456132054,
0.4272946715,
0.1962848902,
-0.8493825793,
-0.4823608398,
-0.1043277383,
-0.3162378371,
-0.5896098018,
0.218174994,
0.4433312118,
0.7357981205,
0.1768320203,
-0.2245986313,
0.6145550013,
-0.6943805814,
0.840547204,
0.3138866723,
-0.6980566978,
0.2964748442,
-0.1793859154,
0.537925005,
0.4245176613,
0.7195896506,
-1.0017603636,
-0.1591076404,
-0.2997308075,
-0.5450704098,
0.3887299597,
-0.454336226,
0.4495630264,
-0.1277450025,
0.7270893455,
0.0024831193,
0.2033764124,
-0.7523173094,
0.1659038216,
0.1677311212,
-0.1339423805,
-0.3353946805,
-0.4431459308,
0.1342449039,
-0.2360631824,
0.7805549502,
-0.1586453021,
-0.0601439588,
-0.2961975932,
-0.4174434543,
0.0813037306,
0.3543277681,
0.7662597895,
0.9069435596,
-0.0057199229,
-0.1864599884,
0.6143171191,
-0.4507550299,
0.2803296149,
-0.4357283115,
0.1903558075,
-0.1080770418,
0.5463386774,
0.6843539476,
0.5946580172,
-0.8195149899,
0.188028723,
0.0650711805,
-0.4075471759,
-0.7615942359,
0.089953959,
0.156537652,
0.1745297015,
0.2848243415,
-0.1919620186,
-0.4923844635,
-0.7686767578,
0.1463367492,
0.358299464,
-0.4937412739,
-0.27805987,
0.4650084376,
-0.0337443165,
-0.1121335179,
0.7524252534,
-0.2415024787,
-0.404944241,
0.1391993165,
0.4853766859,
0.7526971102,
-0.4645957053,
-0.0676353574,
0.3315460086,
0.3490860462,
-0.8473764062,
-0.0283614416,
-0.0434178412,
-0.6612116694,
-0.6934417486,
-0.7968733311,
-0.7394824028,
0.3874635696,
-0.3810979426,
0.2808685303,
-0.5388060808,
0.1905262321,
-0.4111774862,
-0.0209341347,
-0.3637923896,
0.2352387011,
0.1573811024,
0.855989933,
-0.5223693252,
1.1388024092,
0.6138986349,
-0.209801048,
-0.5242424607,
-0.1742350459,
0.0738734305,
-0.3633820415,
0.6275542974,
0.1553075016,
-0.1077395454,
0.1691565514,
-0.7538192868,
-0.9310952425,
0.9388541579,
0.2637040019,
-0.9703522325,
-0.3303200603,
-0.1800361723,
0.5360395312,
-0.3846090436,
-0.1432934701,
0.4824858904,
0.3924706876,
0.2793168128,
-0.7263522744,
-0.3733961582,
0.0534353107,
0.1130141318,
0.0660555363,
-0.6393755078,
0.6134662628,
-0.0323410146,
-0.1722699255,
0.3400320411,
0.6307138205,
0.3486357629,
0.072554566,
0.4767156243,
0.4942614734,
0.6962018013,
-0.1402023733,
0.7898510695,
-0.2332307845,
0.4479319155,
1.2653443813,
-0.6117335558,
0.9195700288,
0.1124228686,
-0.050547231,
0.3491168618,
0.9120426178,
-0.2910731137,
0.2282961756,
0.3557480276,
-0.4599964619,
-0.6842747927,
0.1158471406,
-0.3959726691,
0.3649367094,
0.4879953563,
0.0264435224,
-0.0719823539,
0.3817821443,
0.1190727353,
-0.1659113467,
-0.4461209476,
0.8054014444,
0.2484642118,
-0.7300448418,
0.522203207,
-0.163951233,
0.737426579,
-0.8018975258,
0.168565169,
-0.2521674931,
0.1349295676,
0.0742119104,
-0.4307982326,
0.2595185339,
0.0416609459,
0.0047556865,
-0.2726702094,
0.4246063232,
-0.5025023818,
-0.4070241749,
0.1623554379,
0.350222528,
0.2460351437,
0.1049975678,
-0.6965839863,
0.3093684018,
-0.2619726658,
-0.3213704526,
0.5777435899,
0.3123992383,
-0.1532323956,
1.1571666002,
0.7090852261,
0.2381189913,
0.2593612373,
0.3031692803,
0.6455398798,
-0.7240794301,
-0.1746447533,
-0.7744786739,
0.2803774774,
0.1853744239,
-0.2687773108,
0.676830411,
0.2781895995,
1.0583564043,
-0.1493778974,
0.5628874302,
0.3828139901,
0.3649510741,
-0.8961167336,
0.5476645827,
-0.8619160056,
0.258482933,
0.0716536567,
-1.1133639812,
-0.408359319,
0.3889732063,
-0.2776921988,
0.2101532072,
0.7459441423,
0.5531460047,
0.1246515885,
-0.3386826813,
0.4830951095,
0.2244775742,
0.1765007824,
0.5123948455,
1.1359702349,
0.0905982926,
0.2561562657,
0.1325771511,
-0.0322064795,
-0.2282239497,
-0.8003042936,
-0.739125371,
-0.6946122646,
-0.5349066854,
0.0500908829,
0.1710772216,
0.9770643711,
0.6845337152,
-0.6584950686,
-0.3531077504,
-0.0915860385,
-0.0272681173,
-0.2005363703,
-0.0694379508,
0.0663311929,
-0.9207903743,
-0.6302281618,
0.5423692465,
0.4173973203,
-0.0694639459,
-0.4610640109,
-0.1155792996,
-0.4046013057,
-0.1186734661,
0.7500221133,
0.6970059872,
-0.6737980843,
-0.5758777857,
-0.1846639961,
0.0380045064,
0.0021203072,
0.6962793469,
-0.6180822253,
0.344373703,
0.16746521,
0.9734190106,
0.5800375938,
-0.3484363854,
0.4246885777,
-0.6269516945,
-0.0689409822,
0.1558849961,
0.4478955269,
0.4107766747,
-0.0200466402,
0.2983165383,
0.3392228484,
-0.9116300344,
-0.8851973414,
0.3414407969,
-0.8417639136,
-0.2852189839,
1.0798727274,
-0.1223910674,
-0.0765360445,
-0.385181129,
0.1751681864,
0.1926630884,
0.1646252722,
0.461009413,
0.8089655638,
0.0858764574,
-0.6826645136,
-0.688480258,
0.3439775705,
0.2782760561,
-0.8569363356,
0.1769358814,
0.6311981082,
0.6342054605,
-0.0008507118,
0.5966587663,
-0.0547883362,
0.2279530615,
-0.1501533389,
0.0213533789,
0.292365253,
-0.7087173462,
-0.8599734306,
-0.0197631922,
0.5800492764,
0.2822688818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01360v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01360v1
|
What Makes Medical Claims (Un)Verifiable? Analyzing Entity and Relation Properties for Fact Verification
| 2024-02-02T12:27:58 | 2024-02-02T12:27:58 |
Amelie Wührl, Yarik Menchaca Resendiz, Lara Grimminger, Roman Klinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Biomedical claim verification fails if no evidence can be discovered. In
these cases, the fact-checking verdict remains unknown and the claim is
unverifiable. To improve upon this, we have to understand if there are any
claim properties that impact its verifiability. In this work we assume that
entities and relations define the core variables in a biomedical claim's
anatomy and analyze if their properties help us to differentiate verifiable
from unverifiable claims. In a study with trained annotation experts we prompt
them to find evidence for biomedical claims, and observe how they refine search
queries for their evidence search. This leads to the first corpus for
scientific fact verification annotated with subject-relation-object triplets,
evidence documents, and fact-checking verdicts (the BEAR-Fact corpus). We find
(1) that discovering evidence for negated claims (e.g., X-does-not-cause-Y) is
particularly challenging. Further, we see that annotators process queries
mostly by adding constraints to the search and by normalizing entities to
canonical names. (2) We compare our in-house annotations with a small
crowdsourcing setting where we employ medical experts and laypeople. We find
that domain expertise does not have a substantial effect on the reliability of
annotations. Finally, (3), we demonstrate that it is possible to reliably
estimate the success of evidence retrieval purely from the claim text~(.82\F),
whereas identifying unverifiable claims proves more challenging (.27\F). The
dataset is available at http://www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/data/bioclaim.
|
[
-0.1645226777,
-0.5905387998,
0.999763906,
-0.0493696406,
-0.0946387723,
0.2122938484,
-0.0447837934,
-0.9219102263,
0.6481062174,
0.4938798845,
-0.0494276918,
-0.2677484453,
-0.7303619981,
0.3873356879,
-0.0615747795,
1.1634221077,
0.1138991565,
0.0595837198,
-0.654456377,
-0.6401929259,
-0.0438027605,
-0.6740025878,
-0.2803427875,
-0.436809659,
0.4807770252,
0.1464606076,
0.8473536968,
0.6900812984,
0.5199799538,
0.2658646107,
-0.2494473606,
0.3704926372,
-0.0354404338,
0.0393995158,
-0.3109390438,
-0.3870815337,
-0.3397901058,
-0.0659702122,
0.4377669394,
1.0532915592,
0.072769843,
0.1607277691,
-0.4440481663,
0.6020703316,
-0.6893364191,
0.2260802835,
-0.6740910411,
0.044354964,
-0.5614105463,
-0.3269906044,
-0.3910978734,
-0.240240559,
0.3429929316,
-0.590375185,
0.5662878156,
0.2289051861,
1.2855715752,
0.3271286488,
-0.6030580401,
-0.3366793692,
-0.6299799085,
0.4052242935,
-0.522857368,
0.261246711,
0.6597763896,
0.0600551553,
-0.2614584863,
-0.7047615647,
-0.3049665689,
-0.5207630396,
-0.5820964575,
-0.1101584882,
-0.1480771005,
0.1797451973,
0.5986583829,
0.6811646223,
-0.2130845934,
0.0384563133,
-0.5365718007,
-0.7046517134,
0.749029696,
-0.2435612381,
0.4707498252,
-0.2410814762,
-0.2985824049,
0.5068110228,
-1.0021543503,
0.0510739759,
-0.0213574022,
0.0232687574,
0.2038845569,
0.8171144128,
-0.1759848595,
0.443885535,
0.0207779314,
-0.1002189517,
0.3606973886,
-0.3643042743,
-0.0248174686,
0.4021507502,
0.5817248821,
0.1273034066,
0.0085767657,
-0.4249233902,
-0.0158304349,
0.0053783911,
0.2216315866,
-0.6522532701,
-0.1917775869,
0.3017004728,
-0.4343693554,
-0.0164051931,
-0.1264676899,
-0.1873844862,
-0.605690062,
-0.2302834839,
0.4392295778,
-0.3768373132,
-0.2492221296,
0.0401994325,
-0.1456763446,
-0.2784274518,
0.3082072437,
-0.6445346475,
0.2230216712,
0.4428386986,
0.5739824176,
0.2494052351,
-0.0021901985,
-0.3893484175,
-0.0363368802,
-0.3848284483,
1.0293223858,
-0.3714712858,
-0.2094871998,
0.0997499377,
0.2852282226,
0.1948941797,
-0.6397058368,
0.6897773147,
-0.4731576741,
-0.0112018101,
-0.7041211128,
-0.8332256079,
-0.2539383173,
-0.0201678742,
-0.6950726509,
0.5285731554,
0.0718426704,
-0.8773097992,
0.812133491,
-0.5395034552,
-0.5806785226,
0.2653504908,
-0.5259944201,
-0.4684007466,
0.366133213,
-0.1245897412,
0.3736926317,
-0.3910144567,
0.300275147,
-0.4886644781,
-0.1152613387,
0.6334455013,
0.0740292221,
1.0154399872,
-0.0716496035,
-0.2873298526,
-0.2622464895,
-0.9328058362,
-0.2819807827,
0.2294968069,
-0.310239166,
-0.5307015181,
0.0970489085,
-0.2426444888,
-0.12514323,
-0.029867975,
-1.1809335947,
0.3848153949,
-0.2989317477,
0.3885858655,
0.2072724849,
0.170709148,
0.0511248969,
-0.3182536066,
-0.0071550054,
0.0060764956,
-0.1540756673,
-0.0120560201,
-0.5693252683,
-0.264146328,
-0.4537523091,
0.7870312333,
0.2831439376,
-0.6017309427,
-0.0004979248,
-0.0602733754,
-0.2870090604,
-0.7247322798,
-0.0094119227,
0.4859594703,
0.8630542755,
0.5960818529,
-0.256139189,
-0.6323946118,
-1.1622217894,
-0.3698485494,
-0.4868478179,
-0.1620457321,
0.2228601426,
0.7613424659,
-0.2355540991,
0.9096581936,
-0.4259628057,
-0.3981205523,
0.4347148538,
0.3298045695,
0.0851379111,
0.4694673717,
0.8721528053,
-0.7964633703,
0.1610542536,
-0.1004989222,
-1.0912086964,
-0.2028225064,
-0.0078179222,
0.1519293189,
0.4289439321,
0.1190925911,
-0.7748109698,
0.907430172,
0.1541493684,
-0.4484247267,
0.6802512407,
-0.5557639003,
0.1572558284,
-0.4328813851,
0.0505288355,
0.1332476139,
-0.3047653735,
-0.4012924135,
-0.1782786697,
0.0066463482,
0.4507192671,
-0.1746945381,
0.3433400095,
-0.5510885715,
-0.0384760089,
-0.2659132779,
-0.066903159,
0.0661400557,
0.091583468,
0.0962461978,
0.4471459091,
0.5276178122,
-0.7436892986,
0.1101335958,
0.5878481269,
-0.1170080975,
0.8674801588,
-0.6849200726,
-0.1027674228,
-0.1219673753,
0.2026834935,
-0.766056478,
-0.4662178457,
0.2096713185,
-0.6520407796,
0.2729026377,
-0.195871219,
-0.5404579043,
-0.2748604715,
-0.0261000823,
0.1443778425,
0.1592491418,
-0.6289967299,
0.5632676482,
0.6064075232,
0.0505757332,
-0.6637571454,
-0.8419410586,
0.2617104053,
0.0043042074,
-0.3852715194,
0.5329450965,
0.2077476382,
-0.4183638394,
0.2652017772,
-0.4062363207,
-0.3411540389,
0.1627407074,
0.6652752161,
0.4590963423,
-0.1339108944,
0.3954883516,
0.1550168693,
-0.2089047581,
0.5630426407,
0.0302322228,
-0.4481862783,
-0.0295158848,
-0.5611594915,
-0.2274975181,
0.3041667044,
0.5351091027,
-0.0858847648,
0.6155337095,
0.2530516684,
-0.882958591,
0.4653179049,
-0.8154575825,
-0.2523425221,
-0.2894055843,
0.0453015193,
-0.1345042735,
-0.9617576599,
0.6746159792,
-0.0630788133,
0.3215756416,
0.7400178909,
0.3071925342,
-0.2007557303,
0.6759732962,
0.3542118371,
0.4533928633,
-0.3548658788,
-0.0292779431,
0.0393882953,
-0.6851100922,
-0.3808467686,
-0.6883246899,
0.1073872074,
-0.8798177242,
0.0064508934,
0.446397692,
-0.1274791211,
-0.1856418401,
0.3053225875,
-0.5234638453,
0.1987850368,
0.4931129515,
0.5204979777,
0.631747663,
-0.1470722109,
-0.0639253408,
-0.1710077077,
-0.5256291628,
-0.4723617733,
1.1122032404,
0.3212256134,
0.270537585,
0.1702103317,
0.6631341577,
0.3783004582,
0.7272702456,
-0.4906603098,
0.319758147,
0.1245390847,
-1.3108284473,
-0.0673169196,
-0.3830721378,
-0.8885731697,
0.0512163788,
-0.786506772,
-0.9563903809,
0.5230152011,
0.2399069071,
-0.4353947639,
0.2790552974,
-0.4406451881,
0.3604489863,
-0.3432693779,
-0.4128070474,
-0.0752153248,
-0.9270841479,
0.2987110615,
-0.1072186902,
0.0167872496,
-0.1432771236,
0.0301228557,
0.7545313239,
-0.7606157064,
0.6554018855,
-0.238867268,
0.0786499754,
0.2867827713,
0.0478950255,
0.1501787156,
0.489262253,
0.0297492836,
0.3556827009,
0.4123285413,
-0.5498261452,
-0.4889553487,
0.2990361452,
-0.4103115201,
-0.7577105165,
-0.6078594327,
-0.1441689283,
-0.2442187518,
0.2567239702,
0.3991556764,
0.3203925788,
-0.2314125299,
0.3685007393,
0.7765644789,
-0.1707196236,
0.1423574537,
0.8365618587,
-0.0904372334,
-0.4260113835,
0.7390384674,
0.560905695,
-0.0694173574,
0.2813277841,
0.0367644094,
-0.4103395641,
-0.5388193727,
-0.4111713469,
0.4346192181,
-0.5748181343,
-0.3369998336,
-0.8484832644,
-0.1186167598,
-0.2486791015,
0.1852602959,
-0.3868560791,
-0.5002408624,
0.010624947,
-0.4336749613,
0.5931767821,
0.6914893985,
-0.4181166589,
-0.1366398484,
-0.6277662516,
0.3992864192,
0.1688929796,
0.2449324131,
-0.5935060978,
-0.3147175312,
-0.2177447528,
0.0258060973,
0.057377819,
-0.8952877522,
-0.2373626232,
-0.1007790864,
0.5100169778,
0.5892235637,
0.1967525631,
0.425776571,
-0.3420418203,
0.4921352565,
0.0256828517,
-0.6958361268,
0.4141864777,
0.0329675712,
-0.5252737403,
0.6908003092,
0.5079443455,
0.039211452,
-0.2401271015,
-1.105533123,
-0.612503171,
0.2617722452,
0.323420167,
-0.2739245296,
-0.0315262489,
0.738365531,
0.1366409361,
0.1309446394,
-0.2657200694,
-0.5984552503,
-0.1167371795,
0.2532909811,
0.3266516924,
-0.5424677134,
-0.4136790633,
-0.264382422,
0.5011375546,
-0.0881147534,
0.260386318,
0.6955503225,
-0.041099187,
-0.0635383725,
0.2213078141,
0.5921425819,
0.8278369308,
-0.2895174026,
0.3601329327,
0.1560398787,
-0.4805847108,
0.2217970788,
0.5253726244,
-0.3380385339,
0.5373430252,
0.6307149529,
0.4400164485,
0.2665366232,
-0.4737381041,
0.5672129989,
-0.0629780963,
-0.3268743753,
-0.4265776873,
-0.1784103215,
-0.0197139718,
0.1423439384,
0.5437427759,
0.1732507348,
0.2744513452,
-0.3026471436,
0.2682824433,
0.4351919889,
-0.2149615437,
-0.4318142235,
0.8677468896,
0.0110765165,
-0.0227784887,
0.4387228191,
0.022069905,
-0.1775832474,
0.565186739,
0.2745738924,
0.4414482415,
-0.0354894921,
0.3169375956,
0.4037478864,
0.3179178834,
-0.0899440423,
-0.0422513597,
-0.0123610431,
-0.6004654765,
-0.5176110268,
-0.205993861,
-0.7317956686,
-0.0057227947,
-0.6254338026,
0.0092772208,
-0.3081097901,
-0.5541745424,
0.7164879441,
0.088805452,
-0.5953537822,
0.2781339884,
-0.13415052,
0.7384042144,
-0.8663951755,
0.462892592,
0.9333043694,
-0.8788420558,
-0.5205075145,
-0.3112177849,
0.2114327997,
-0.9115834832,
0.8136845827,
-0.0395570844,
0.1126497611,
-0.4745564461,
-0.8910886049,
-0.5710161328,
0.8286497593,
0.7071900964,
-0.1012061164,
-0.0203996021,
0.0835505351,
0.5551840067,
-0.3619405925,
0.2864819765,
0.1860194504,
0.5033128858,
0.1750677526,
-0.818839848,
0.4544005394,
0.0240174942,
-0.2654736936,
-0.129189074,
-0.2354218364,
0.4438585639,
-0.7472345233,
-0.1102092266,
-0.0269735288,
0.9067750573,
0.4554364681,
0.8027589321,
0.3800750673,
0.4787403941,
1.0326119661,
-0.2172400653,
1.049438715,
-0.2530167103,
0.4096240997,
0.9682332277,
-0.2466208339,
0.4413550496,
0.5450197458,
-0.2461733818,
0.5286323428,
0.6120865941,
-0.0973551944,
0.1164414063,
0.2839371562,
-0.2711251676,
-0.3517754376,
-0.603523016,
-0.3853552938,
0.3414801359,
0.4748679101,
-0.5930915475,
-0.1507933289,
-0.0774004236,
0.4809516966,
-0.0513522439,
-0.0024690172,
0.663230896,
0.052406434,
-0.5902640224,
0.3687700629,
-0.3534209728,
0.1534080207,
-0.3174112439,
-0.3286365867,
-0.0544963218,
-0.0445855819,
-0.7034537792,
-0.6885518432,
0.289149195,
-0.1265728325,
-0.3745431304,
0.2236895412,
0.9630072713,
-0.1795435846,
-0.1437441558,
-0.0783634782,
0.5861557722,
0.2798179984,
-0.0937037319,
-0.3536991477,
-0.1998672634,
-0.2229432166,
-0.1831962913,
0.1985564232,
0.7968100309,
-0.0684241205,
0.6067250371,
0.5577667356,
0.2890531123,
-0.436940968,
-0.3527422547,
0.6450616121,
-0.494302243,
0.2064605653,
-0.6900388002,
0.3336503506,
-0.2269574404,
-0.1595257819,
0.5557128191,
0.5515803099,
0.5014467239,
0.0217508562,
0.7182973027,
-0.2437176704,
0.6231990457,
-0.4737822711,
0.8299720287,
-0.4723407328,
0.0145539399,
-0.1338262409,
-0.2859705091,
-0.4919049442,
0.3292829692,
-0.1034359261,
-0.0221500099,
0.8190405369,
0.3969720006,
0.0958519503,
0.2285740823,
0.098790057,
0.3848960102,
0.1849553436,
0.3394630253,
0.5965250731,
-0.349509716,
0.1439950913,
-0.3006470799,
-0.4125128686,
-0.2555964589,
-0.9851421118,
-0.9332973361,
-0.5175529122,
-0.8767885566,
-0.9043279886,
-0.0214936379,
0.7438820004,
0.7188338041,
-0.7286899686,
0.4955995381,
0.1162234321,
0.2480390966,
-0.302413702,
-0.0828437731,
0.558858633,
-0.0500275567,
-0.1273572147,
0.0756043419,
0.2605111897,
0.0748947859,
-0.0911120772,
0.191260457,
-0.2486797869,
-0.0215628874,
0.3187530935,
0.9396054745,
-0.7088509202,
-0.3241565228,
-0.125954777,
-0.0810101107,
0.2435319871,
0.8342146277,
-0.853281498,
0.343978405,
0.125766471,
0.9785483479,
0.326063484,
-0.1496056616,
0.2027747035,
-0.538457334,
-0.2666105926,
0.0787177756,
0.8137004375,
0.2937636375,
-0.5582802892,
0.8645595908,
0.6900221109,
-0.7267534137,
-0.9222393632,
0.0081774574,
-0.9628944397,
-0.0148858214,
0.7378617525,
-0.34216398,
-0.4380177557,
-0.3252604306,
-0.1816882342,
0.1442098767,
-0.1465038806,
0.9301275015,
0.5849764943,
-0.5003470778,
0.2136390358,
-0.7306681871,
0.6044572592,
0.4045600295,
-0.5435503125,
0.0948701575,
0.6305972338,
0.3883930743,
0.8442875147,
0.7360677123,
-0.2917598784,
0.3733902872,
-0.1601153612,
0.0043893205,
-0.2998930216,
-0.0369213298,
0.0451847278,
0.2068616599,
0.095476158,
-0.2602665722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01352v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01352v1
|
Describing Images $\textit{Fast and Slow}$: Quantifying and Predicting the Variation in Human Signals during Visuo-Linguistic Processes
| 2024-02-02T12:11:16 | 2024-02-02T12:11:16 |
Ece Takmaz, Sandro Pezzelle, Raquel Fernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
There is an intricate relation between the properties of an image and how
humans behave while describing the image. This behavior shows ample variation,
as manifested in human signals such as eye movements and when humans start to
describe the image. Despite the value of such signals of visuo-linguistic
variation, they are virtually disregarded in the training of current pretrained
models, which motivates further investigation. Using a corpus of Dutch image
descriptions with concurrently collected eye-tracking data, we explore the
nature of the variation in visuo-linguistic signals, and find that they
correlate with each other. Given this result, we hypothesize that variation
stems partly from the properties of the images, and explore whether image
representations encoded by pretrained vision encoders can capture such
variation. Our results indicate that pretrained models do so to a
weak-to-moderate degree, suggesting that the models lack biases about what
makes a stimulus complex for humans and what leads to variations in human
outputs.
|
[
-0.6376916766,
-0.6264027357,
0.3427416086,
0.0074431915,
-0.3916891813,
-0.1808282882,
-0.2720065713,
-1.0319267511,
0.4222670794,
0.2446669489,
-0.5032603741,
0.1174374819,
-0.8951917887,
0.0978096053,
-0.4298087358,
0.4814935029,
-0.229697153,
0.3499419093,
0.0524171926,
-0.1773526669,
-0.2456992418,
-0.2114093006,
-0.2094415575,
-0.3428117037,
0.6547957659,
0.1782782078,
1.0579721928,
0.7078081965,
0.6295200586,
0.3155872822,
-0.0598106124,
-0.4315727949,
-0.5112208128,
0.0997460037,
0.1640496403,
-0.8860929012,
0.0349355228,
0.0779660568,
0.4998024404,
0.8829278946,
0.140105918,
-0.0089433212,
0.0882582366,
0.6746516824,
-0.6960330606,
0.0391207747,
-0.3603104949,
0.256221056,
-0.4181850553,
-0.45509094,
0.0142826941,
-0.1338325292,
0.5783017874,
-0.7115130424,
0.6303863525,
0.0879024044,
1.3713023663,
0.1556669772,
-0.3367820084,
-0.250364393,
-0.9273970723,
0.6953318119,
-0.4508490264,
0.3022143245,
0.423363477,
0.4081296921,
-0.0148527231,
-0.6302058697,
-0.5915621519,
-0.386102736,
-0.2432685941,
-0.1070677787,
0.1974697262,
0.0598020442,
0.4768682718,
0.381015569,
-0.3486990631,
0.2098856717,
-0.4583977461,
-0.3279588521,
0.5835592151,
0.4081505537,
0.2358995676,
0.2677542567,
-0.4227545857,
-0.3187898099,
-0.3148847818,
0.2943944633,
0.6140961051,
-0.2994301915,
-0.2590146661,
0.5992001295,
-0.3060835898,
0.741636157,
0.2323029488,
-0.04861499,
0.4211269319,
-0.07206624,
-0.0986461714,
-0.3296423256,
0.7860531211,
0.5636578798,
0.3746504188,
-0.0890378207,
-0.4489723742,
0.4353514016,
-0.0796251968,
-0.8749012947,
-0.1876129806,
-0.2903968692,
-0.7357419729,
-0.2888663709,
0.017867351,
-0.9161466956,
-0.3774089515,
-0.5181055069,
0.4096901417,
-0.2365903705,
-0.2205739021,
0.485509634,
-0.1849285662,
0.3352720737,
0.3786996901,
-0.8959739804,
0.2180452794,
0.0586866774,
0.6228929758,
-0.1625846028,
-0.7099433541,
0.0289982222,
-0.1468556821,
-0.4586835802,
0.7684944868,
-0.5551855564,
-0.2810989916,
-0.0021733607,
0.1480622143,
0.2103348374,
-0.4507832527,
0.047397811,
-0.5238529444,
0.0756908283,
-0.1657982171,
-0.3840088844,
-0.1585736424,
-0.1413658708,
-0.9499630332,
0.6371719241,
-0.0803942531,
-1.1435033083,
0.5880951881,
-0.4476828575,
-0.4744698703,
0.1407488436,
-0.2774866819,
-0.2711978853,
0.5501723289,
0.0119359083,
0.5374418497,
-0.3698752522,
-0.0666250661,
-0.2750638127,
-0.7722557187,
0.6825681329,
-0.3179409206,
0.627687037,
0.3325812817,
-0.406357348,
-0.0396405384,
-0.7271260023,
-0.1418845952,
0.50344944,
-0.2929892838,
-0.3305365443,
0.134642899,
0.0441428721,
0.0726837069,
0.2669338584,
-0.4121293426,
0.0280115958,
-0.220320344,
0.3252996504,
0.5084943175,
-0.132433489,
0.4706754088,
-0.1327311099,
0.581406951,
0.4791388214,
0.4338786602,
-0.1949415654,
-0.4133582115,
-0.906291604,
-0.0159889441,
0.042311389,
0.4937925935,
-0.8435143232,
-0.1667292565,
-0.34937644,
-0.4336127341,
-0.6066416502,
0.0637294874,
0.3096518815,
0.3257937431,
0.2292484343,
-0.8445668221,
-0.0450643711,
-1.0397645235,
-0.3336543441,
0.1229792386,
-0.1996163875,
0.3245404661,
0.3709775805,
-0.2713354528,
0.5514889956,
-0.5073262453,
0.0633782223,
0.0029719993,
0.631054461,
0.1362239271,
0.2922165692,
0.6262000203,
-0.9356161356,
-0.4216653407,
-0.4047880769,
-0.6049197316,
0.2077742517,
-0.0473225676,
-0.2069463879,
-0.1551752537,
0.4851387441,
-0.5046302676,
0.7936071157,
0.0486891679,
-0.3495661318,
0.6598883271,
-0.2603509128,
0.2378413528,
-0.5599738359,
-0.1828507334,
0.0776887313,
0.0029073895,
-0.4029788077,
-0.0682942122,
-0.1638201028,
-0.0067075063,
-0.749271512,
0.2341504842,
-0.7968630791,
-0.1422836483,
-0.2154852003,
-0.3642514646,
-0.0505326204,
0.58723104,
0.3926146328,
0.5091444254,
1.3126497269,
-0.7585253716,
0.4532901645,
-0.0692795813,
-0.6836987734,
0.6493067145,
-0.7424622774,
0.1146788001,
-0.5226283669,
-0.1018147618,
-0.6008333564,
-0.4804764688,
-0.0206173025,
-0.2812898457,
0.4229449332,
0.0333955958,
-0.3877641261,
-0.6090239286,
-0.1487922966,
0.5882196426,
0.6813873649,
-0.2694111168,
0.5825043917,
0.248905912,
0.2951917052,
-0.6637933254,
-0.8737937808,
-0.1878414452,
-0.2976269126,
-0.4399798512,
0.1215390265,
-0.0457219705,
-0.057873603,
-0.0134498551,
0.1068240926,
-0.4465186,
0.0220267139,
0.2966003418,
0.1738185734,
-0.2972464859,
0.0419809222,
-0.5272680521,
0.0723170936,
0.0681343302,
-0.25357759,
0.2238887101,
-0.0641890317,
-0.0345047265,
-0.5652124286,
0.4184653759,
0.6496425271,
-0.0267055668,
0.2810514271,
0.8656781316,
-0.1157067195,
0.277161479,
-0.308642745,
-0.3937056363,
-0.5065209866,
0.3550217748,
-0.46223405,
-0.5563501716,
0.5370227098,
-0.0581845976,
-0.3670699,
0.210196048,
0.6420478225,
-0.4262163639,
0.9250673652,
1.065433979,
0.3651228547,
0.8438423276,
-0.2955855131,
-0.0807022005,
-0.4628342092,
-0.1507306397,
-0.2696662247,
-0.7052825093,
-0.9274352789,
-0.1965821087,
0.1072226167,
0.014024958,
0.0195103716,
0.0734564513,
-0.5083830953,
0.7057908773,
0.7003883123,
0.2015496939,
-0.2551904321,
-0.031585712,
-0.0616795644,
-0.1466446966,
-0.591569066,
-0.191555649,
1.1762996912,
0.0421173424,
1.4550532103,
-0.3704758286,
0.3814514875,
0.1485380679,
0.0421843156,
-0.7040375471,
0.6892088056,
-0.1191001609,
-0.5236367583,
-0.1422141939,
-0.295711875,
-1.1379164457,
-0.0357857309,
-0.4504109323,
-0.5930839181,
0.5399858356,
0.5119823813,
-0.1592724174,
0.1433112323,
-0.6163846254,
0.8076912761,
-0.7480996251,
-0.649102509,
-0.0592104793,
-1.2360271215,
0.3253104687,
0.1070608944,
0.0703713372,
-0.2789950371,
0.1208454669,
0.7443184853,
-0.2322385609,
1.0369083881,
-0.2203156203,
0.294788599,
0.452367872,
0.1440650225,
0.1415989697,
-0.2309359312,
0.6164828539,
0.2490952611,
-0.0665249228,
-0.6754069924,
-0.3355493248,
0.3990644217,
-0.8455563188,
-0.3225805759,
-0.1443155259,
-0.4045416415,
0.0141768055,
0.0430647507,
1.0339776278,
0.2615711689,
-0.1384969503,
-0.0567116141,
0.6563537717,
-0.2948551476,
0.4874853194,
0.3350823224,
-0.1561542898,
0.0517024919,
0.6725709438,
0.0919417217,
0.2207653075,
0.4899100363,
0.2143376619,
0.0183159597,
-0.1206694767,
-0.0839459673,
0.1096978411,
-0.9200441837,
0.1225228086,
-0.2896110117,
0.4072543979,
-0.0228741411,
-0.1940286458,
-0.3174480796,
-0.3244363964,
-0.4489828348,
0.0500873588,
0.205168739,
0.7478252053,
0.1260576844,
0.4933696687,
-0.4392033815,
0.6100648642,
0.7503941059,
0.409851104,
-0.0578783937,
-0.3664363921,
-0.6517422795,
0.0094881309,
-0.164506048,
-1.0398880243,
0.3238808513,
0.3847909868,
0.3832589388,
0.6270539165,
-0.2701867521,
0.6397282481,
-0.5222319961,
0.9617094398,
0.5800709128,
-0.7565788627,
0.5493028164,
-0.0159296058,
0.3394132257,
0.2903588414,
0.6065348983,
-0.0473865718,
-0.4282934964,
-0.5420241952,
-0.831556797,
0.3382021487,
-0.0972325429,
0.2493570149,
0.194134295,
0.3144395947,
0.2439191341,
0.1135045588,
-0.680411458,
-0.1907999367,
-0.6579687595,
-0.0671919286,
-0.1249430701,
-0.3427429199,
-0.1658529937,
-0.3545516431,
-0.1099558026,
-0.0701224878,
0.697104156,
0.1815092564,
-0.3916324079,
-0.2966242135,
0.0317894705,
0.6003359556,
0.4966959059,
-0.0727723241,
0.4087874591,
-0.2735249996,
-0.6947129965,
0.2515190542,
-0.1059572771,
-0.2581878603,
0.4037204981,
0.4320849478,
1.2942899466,
0.0762205496,
-0.6740493178,
0.5952579975,
-0.2157886475,
-0.0803076401,
-0.2049334347,
0.1572685838,
-0.1828692406,
0.142762959,
0.1349762678,
0.4446564317,
0.3087530434,
-0.3786033094,
-0.2197071314,
0.1874445677,
-0.4015422463,
-0.8639763594,
0.8917595148,
0.1218563765,
-0.1577255428,
0.684443295,
0.044607535,
-0.3508317173,
0.8271796703,
0.0572359301,
1.0848417282,
0.0087066349,
-0.1061650962,
0.095940426,
0.2106808722,
-0.2465400547,
0.5255362391,
-0.2438677549,
-0.8564600348,
-0.2906270921,
-0.5755916238,
-0.1782274097,
-0.0721490905,
-0.9457314014,
0.3391244113,
0.0625150204,
-0.5691066384,
0.2160290182,
-0.5888975263,
-1.4790751934,
0.3253437877,
0.4748097062,
0.6692973375,
-0.9536895752,
0.8287581801,
0.7281965017,
-0.4917351604,
-0.7024774551,
0.1737442315,
-0.3119605482,
-0.6556963921,
1.0155081749,
0.3523135483,
-0.2425147444,
-0.2791754007,
-1.1339241266,
-0.6755670905,
0.7904809713,
0.4623288512,
-0.62076509,
0.0668650568,
0.0526577942,
0.5906404257,
-0.3272910714,
0.1374211311,
0.432888329,
0.3318184018,
0.072613731,
-0.9085092545,
-0.2937155068,
-0.245425269,
0.3312047422,
-0.0850098282,
-0.3943502009,
1.1065803766,
-0.7513664961,
-0.3873569071,
0.0138484798,
0.3985773027,
-0.4178514183,
0.2323393971,
0.3618743122,
0.4396864176,
0.3550369143,
-0.1746424884,
1.2557402849,
-0.445266366,
0.2790129781,
0.8605872393,
-0.1393751204,
0.5941390991,
0.7547590733,
-0.0738913566,
0.4350966215,
0.7379671931,
0.0117998291,
0.6436206698,
0.1822459251,
-0.0144955991,
-0.2800579965,
0.1364012212,
-0.1981348842,
0.4273169041,
0.3495914042,
-0.4589223564,
0.2929669917,
0.4459939897,
-0.4945278466,
-0.2985429764,
-0.3699404001,
0.6608406901,
0.0146253947,
-0.5470775366,
0.9030222893,
-0.3986092508,
0.9090691209,
-0.5623124242,
0.1951322705,
-0.1375171095,
-0.0406319313,
0.0443472601,
-0.8722313643,
0.0223376732,
-0.3124613166,
-0.2265960872,
-0.2304041237,
0.5793207884,
-0.3471755981,
-0.1933994889,
0.3572955132,
0.3776443303,
0.4391098917,
0.3696777523,
-0.5913805962,
0.0752143934,
-0.2201040983,
-0.5717453957,
0.0952589065,
0.6339311004,
-0.1016194373,
0.6062460542,
0.280923903,
0.3022987843,
0.6915019751,
0.0060496042,
0.5737991333,
-0.7611137629,
-0.5611382723,
-0.5265731215,
0.2866592705,
0.147991702,
-0.4335919917,
0.1896701753,
0.2308133245,
1.0119079351,
-0.7897043228,
0.4770129025,
-0.0177628975,
0.1207023934,
-0.625685215,
0.336568594,
-0.5683899522,
-0.0629116073,
0.2163826525,
-0.9293809533,
-0.0903587192,
0.5896354914,
-0.0591210276,
-0.1656529009,
0.8090881705,
0.6691915989,
-0.1404720098,
-0.3076331317,
0.464782387,
0.4436766803,
-0.2271786481,
0.4676580131,
0.9968035817,
-0.0370336846,
0.4185060561,
-0.3393620551,
-0.0695146769,
-0.406152904,
-0.6956812739,
-0.6059737802,
-0.5529444218,
-0.4469327927,
-0.1674764305,
-0.0706997216,
0.350102216,
0.9523556828,
-0.5873962045,
-0.4037633836,
-0.1309779435,
-0.2661242187,
-0.5219172239,
-0.2180681825,
0.1175477281,
-0.1880583167,
-0.6718429327,
-0.0749245435,
0.2263711095,
0.8365854621,
-0.4795275331,
-0.1555914283,
0.3068251014,
0.2789513767,
0.2510456443,
0.4394488931,
-0.7919562459,
0.0354292654,
0.0058838394,
-0.3313700557,
0.2211455703,
1.0461461544,
-0.7705945969,
0.7543158531,
0.6026818752,
0.0152298138,
0.7742642164,
-0.5350934267,
0.3928105533,
-0.611534059,
0.8433665633,
0.2052632421,
0.6056950092,
0.5518246889,
-0.166208759,
0.2799409926,
0.5517311692,
-0.3025017083,
-0.5245289207,
0.5590183735,
-0.9657736421,
-0.2998699546,
0.7720410228,
-0.331471622,
-0.5638599992,
0.101038225,
0.0409673713,
0.1230286434,
0.0316077881,
0.8472972512,
0.6605580449,
-0.2729481459,
-0.1087834463,
-0.6147979498,
0.5398052335,
0.2260456532,
-0.3656092584,
-0.2968113422,
0.6721193194,
0.4401670396,
0.1795856208,
0.557823658,
-0.0715771243,
0.4701995254,
0.1653020978,
0.2499343008,
0.3154708445,
-0.2285980284,
-0.1181596518,
0.1123683825,
0.1288158894,
-0.5569027662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01349v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01349v2
|
Beyond the Answers: Reviewing the Rationality of Multiple Choice Question Answering for the Evaluation of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-02T12:07:00 | 2024-05-30T01:57:14 |
Haochun Wang, Sendong Zhao, Zewen Qiang, Nuwa Xi, Bing Qin, Ting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the field of natural language processing (NLP), Large Language Models
(LLMs) have precipitated a paradigm shift, markedly enhancing performance in
natural language generation tasks. Despite these advancements, the
comprehensive evaluation of LLMs remains an inevitable challenge for the
community. Recently, the utilization of Multiple Choice Question Answering
(MCQA) as a benchmark for LLMs has gained considerable traction. This study
first investigates the limitations of MCQA as an evaluation method for LLMs and
then analyzes the fundamental reason for the limitations of MCQA, that while
LLMs may select the correct answers, it is possible that they also recognize
other wrong options as correct. Finally, we propose a dataset augmenting method
for Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs), MCQA+, that can more accurately reflect
the performance of the model, which underscores the need for more robust
evaluation mechanisms in assessing the performance of LLMs.
|
[
-0.8307016492,
-0.7313052416,
0.8597765565,
-0.0775577724,
0.018470915,
0.2721629143,
-0.2129296958,
-0.3601432443,
-0.255163312,
0.7083059549,
-0.7237620354,
0.0214754343,
-0.4445606172,
0.4179473221,
-0.1463419944,
0.8042837381,
0.1009352803,
0.1584418565,
-0.6032002568,
-0.2741574645,
-0.3998224735,
-0.7551075816,
-0.7388007641,
-0.2778914869,
0.4599016309,
0.3302869499,
0.8372334242,
0.4300008416,
0.4612023532,
0.3213694692,
0.0198010635,
0.4182487726,
-0.2871126533,
0.1733348519,
-0.2184880525,
-0.5005085468,
-0.223438561,
0.1504074633,
0.8468557596,
0.7787194252,
0.0558352396,
0.4812240303,
-0.2197603583,
0.7083674073,
-0.7021554112,
-0.3726688921,
-0.6986910105,
-0.0810661167,
-0.0760059804,
-0.2269406021,
-0.4669318497,
-0.5823879242,
0.1305542886,
-0.285854727,
-0.0896072015,
0.0530095883,
0.4474717379,
0.1555489153,
-0.5919635892,
-0.4673170745,
-0.6224318147,
1.152430892,
-0.7846093774,
0.3764055371,
0.2042829096,
0.4904960096,
-0.1596335769,
-0.4989858866,
-0.7403137684,
-0.5697158575,
0.168100208,
0.0208469722,
-0.0218486115,
0.0082253637,
0.570927918,
0.4975496531,
-0.5376649499,
-0.0243192594,
-0.217418164,
-0.0505663417,
0.6094455123,
0.35765028,
0.2571953237,
-0.1705735475,
-0.391042769,
0.0092708021,
-0.5933659673,
0.2143036723,
0.4082713723,
0.1758476943,
0.5325137973,
1.0984196663,
-0.3019232452,
0.7998913527,
-0.1934976578,
-0.11398004,
0.2104847133,
-0.3595826626,
-0.373614043,
-0.3212068975,
0.4566402435,
0.3315995038,
0.3128404319,
0.0038267393,
-0.0014357019,
0.0309394486,
0.258403182,
-0.6879965663,
0.251519382,
0.6084871888,
-0.2091303915,
-0.078133665,
-0.2350170165,
-0.4410673678,
-0.4242925644,
-0.5496824384,
0.2799724638,
-0.2855725288,
-0.4192514122,
0.2979581654,
-0.2737898231,
0.3305106759,
0.2133173048,
-0.4940199852,
0.4121131599,
0.7736539841,
0.5360535979,
-0.1015574858,
-0.2693556547,
-0.6195418835,
-0.0636090934,
-0.4294680655,
0.8662549257,
-0.7537846565,
-0.3110631704,
-0.1728828996,
-0.2180957347,
-0.1875752956,
-0.5775930882,
0.8537182212,
-0.8773553967,
0.2089777887,
-0.7624541521,
-0.7726245522,
-0.3171376288,
0.5422250628,
-0.756860733,
1.1049491167,
0.0619091205,
-0.6207629442,
0.2951390147,
-0.718390286,
-0.0736705661,
0.0154870879,
-0.1408549696,
0.0006306804,
0.1553295702,
0.3539836109,
0.3169755638,
-0.4669938684,
0.3252453506,
-0.6247751117,
-0.1010165662,
0.7582645416,
-0.8564331532,
0.9842387438,
0.1602110714,
0.1232063547,
0.0047202748,
-0.8792996407,
0.4047459364,
-0.0883135274,
-0.5543887019,
-0.0335591957,
-0.1091573462,
-0.2675634921,
0.7010717392,
0.0329215303,
-0.5573546886,
-0.0525959097,
-0.3891812563,
0.3364155293,
0.6653246284,
-0.0070412359,
0.4188413918,
-0.7699369192,
0.8315517902,
-0.3372433186,
0.0632094741,
-0.0297086742,
-0.5345475674,
-0.7835983038,
-0.0867419168,
0.2366137058,
0.4623628259,
-0.9052678347,
0.1510229409,
-0.1841453463,
-0.5654056668,
-0.6776658893,
0.09140037,
0.2003387362,
0.5733525157,
0.4888771772,
0.0673656836,
-0.7288682461,
-0.9909748435,
-0.4140654504,
-0.0649786368,
-0.1632335782,
0.3885676563,
0.5432835817,
-0.0963383466,
1.0424587727,
-0.3473463058,
0.4510509074,
-0.3831192851,
-0.1484899819,
0.2901838422,
0.3282819092,
0.2419664413,
-0.6821675897,
-0.1582132727,
-0.2034802288,
-0.4140043557,
-0.1522036344,
-0.1842416823,
-0.0613624156,
0.1060871333,
0.2788975835,
-0.8786943555,
0.0408376604,
0.6730845571,
0.0608528294,
1.0591858625,
-0.0147767179,
0.2366296649,
-0.7527156472,
0.1648404449,
-0.1653232127,
-0.2727939487,
-0.5956226587,
0.294721067,
-0.0174028203,
0.0568079799,
-0.4639290869,
0.6347688437,
-0.4228602648,
-0.1998299211,
-0.2603970468,
0.4557033181,
0.4495460689,
0.1363135427,
0.0159844644,
0.8185033798,
0.304826647,
-0.7134011388,
0.5295647979,
0.1337447912,
-0.3870423734,
0.4610718191,
-0.4674063027,
0.1833244711,
-0.3651924729,
0.4146999419,
-1.0923558474,
-0.1073558405,
0.0746713057,
-0.4411210716,
-0.022546988,
0.0594472475,
-0.3642725646,
-0.434420526,
-0.489492923,
0.3734254539,
0.2221004814,
-0.561948061,
0.5302715898,
0.3309583068,
-0.2460273355,
-0.7444579005,
-0.5851947665,
0.2236209214,
-0.2424025536,
-0.752853632,
-0.1270508021,
-0.4689123929,
-0.5580377579,
-0.4249900281,
-0.0491235256,
0.0012529411,
0.068635121,
-0.2118872404,
0.2531035244,
-0.2954311371,
0.4634728134,
0.1000231951,
-0.0146651259,
0.304433763,
0.1776774377,
0.5975732803,
-0.2576325834,
-0.357865274,
0.0088385809,
0.4457883835,
0.4593620598,
-0.299869597,
0.6826812029,
0.4148412645,
-0.3125083148,
-0.0933822393,
-0.7715221047,
0.0517095961,
-0.4528033733,
0.3624941707,
-0.4760126173,
-0.9258966446,
0.3746795654,
0.0002860978,
0.2111210674,
0.6625153422,
0.5601950884,
-0.0447348729,
1.1782460213,
0.1725477129,
0.4450535774,
-0.0716388002,
0.0330536589,
0.0754409283,
-1.3461678028,
-0.1181075051,
-0.6782788634,
0.0285038166,
-0.4978842437,
-0.5366893411,
0.1388398409,
0.1621380299,
-0.3069517016,
0.0693912134,
-0.2679509521,
0.5348552465,
0.2830823064,
0.0346653126,
0.5422330499,
-0.3168833256,
-0.1089965925,
-0.137375623,
-0.7813975811,
-0.9984872937,
1.3250472546,
0.5083215833,
0.251021266,
0.276807338,
0.1800069511,
0.0298265666,
0.6652111411,
-0.7619777918,
0.559633255,
0.1778933704,
-1.0076725483,
-0.4743872285,
-0.4653654993,
-0.639621377,
0.6675087214,
-0.4252159297,
-0.5651033521,
0.0000181646,
-0.0626180843,
-0.653367877,
0.1995466202,
-0.6072787642,
0.4984222651,
-0.3852711022,
-0.2132858485,
-0.0274507254,
-0.5123550892,
0.734508872,
-0.1922821254,
0.3361021876,
-0.0930905938,
-0.3586565256,
0.5946696401,
-0.2325685918,
0.3225685656,
0.1033218279,
-0.217131421,
0.3713394701,
-0.2044714242,
0.2603469193,
0.4371240139,
-0.546436429,
-0.2127938122,
0.1617922932,
-0.2637390494,
-0.6498820186,
0.7612152696,
-0.3142698109,
-0.7223080993,
-0.36815539,
-0.623323977,
-0.7469656467,
0.1609882861,
-0.0035850881,
0.5869135857,
-0.0132419327,
0.2539684176,
0.67838943,
-0.5084052086,
0.4671896696,
0.2204699665,
-0.5457362533,
-0.5565896034,
0.5939152837,
0.2835972607,
0.4889208376,
0.1994650066,
0.3378916979,
-0.850502789,
-0.6324815154,
-0.7388537526,
0.0979553983,
-0.9408392906,
0.0358798504,
-0.8350302577,
-0.2147711515,
-0.3094092011,
0.0111773768,
-0.117706582,
-0.5335737467,
-0.2533207536,
-0.1773528308,
-0.0533240326,
0.5038395524,
0.1888817251,
0.0348716639,
-0.9535716176,
0.420119375,
0.5482814908,
0.455856353,
0.1380750388,
-0.4863139689,
0.0654303208,
0.3501496017,
-0.2394028455,
-0.7893058062,
0.010206704,
-0.0577193387,
0.6929352283,
0.0899748951,
0.1043575481,
0.8020179868,
-0.4758243859,
0.8005998731,
0.002967933,
-0.8289830089,
0.0821088254,
-0.2985147238,
0.5200418234,
0.7124182582,
0.5321888328,
-0.3768059909,
-0.2944355309,
-0.6542345285,
-0.6554090977,
0.4712566435,
0.3501935303,
0.230488196,
-0.123814024,
0.2525511682,
0.135675177,
0.4728913605,
-0.8451758027,
-0.0590503328,
0.0930269659,
0.2417449951,
-0.1911386549,
-0.330198139,
-0.0541761331,
-0.212148875,
0.7991873026,
-0.0783011764,
-0.1199843362,
0.2374377251,
-0.1259194314,
-0.0333020762,
0.592315197,
0.6921383739,
0.9974337816,
-0.1677152216,
-0.0405062325,
0.4970199764,
-0.045208443,
-0.0267386921,
-0.0534864701,
0.0618322305,
-0.0126895141,
0.3140594065,
0.4852084219,
-0.1877995133,
-1.0403603315,
0.3143977225,
-0.0826837048,
-0.1449130177,
-0.300005734,
0.1271333694,
0.1647041142,
0.2145168483,
0.40610829,
0.2829699814,
0.351895541,
-0.7141537666,
0.1566933393,
0.6927912831,
-0.2614178658,
0.2059269249,
0.315523088,
-0.0516038872,
-0.290749073,
0.4161677957,
0.0718515962,
-0.5043976307,
0.6666607857,
0.4150740802,
0.6128489971,
-0.0714255571,
0.2631219923,
0.471940726,
0.5834418535,
-0.0449578464,
0.4503372908,
-0.0421202928,
-0.8028931022,
-0.8572905064,
-0.6086797118,
-0.4768541455,
0.3733712435,
-0.6194621325,
0.0158004016,
-0.4459589422,
-0.4297625124,
0.0228894353,
0.1426948607,
-0.4362720549,
0.6432828903,
0.2381294966,
1.0837099552,
-0.4559368789,
0.4666451216,
0.4939729869,
-0.1834852695,
-0.5173569918,
-0.1161932424,
-0.232993573,
-0.4548213482,
0.2144364119,
0.3644714355,
-0.2060285807,
-0.1326375604,
-0.5690677166,
-0.9008800387,
0.7308800817,
0.441680938,
-0.4467643499,
0.1754238158,
0.4093919098,
0.6122255921,
-0.368930012,
0.5506186485,
0.8307192326,
0.6809340119,
0.0507567786,
-0.7151767015,
-0.0079394178,
-0.0932580829,
0.0720649064,
0.0701840892,
-0.4079761505,
0.7506409883,
-0.2396764308,
-0.2280150205,
0.2096824795,
0.2026980221,
0.719624579,
0.0226989444,
0.4023171067,
0.376686573,
0.7573221326,
-0.0186499264,
1.2944768667,
0.1849183589,
0.2825550735,
1.2557439804,
-0.3391409516,
0.9598542452,
0.6198971272,
-0.4371263385,
0.1271619499,
0.6515342593,
0.1383761019,
-0.0706000105,
0.5428150296,
-0.2769946456,
-0.6014145017,
-0.0556171238,
-0.3853797019,
0.3332720399,
0.3401447237,
-0.2212904394,
-0.245243147,
-0.1231579334,
-0.1559791565,
0.1516995877,
-0.4430961907,
0.5478392243,
0.0034886873,
-0.8793544769,
0.5010474324,
0.1012591273,
0.2648572922,
-0.4615857601,
-0.0524028502,
0.1471391767,
-0.1750949472,
-0.2601621449,
-1.0171798468,
0.4217722714,
-0.0046114633,
-0.2528494298,
-0.0739926323,
0.5609084368,
-0.2433178276,
-0.7334611416,
0.067257531,
0.6106437445,
-0.1151209176,
-0.1182832643,
-0.793174684,
-0.0005680317,
-0.1345698088,
-0.4374743402,
0.0934675336,
0.2260173708,
0.0699101239,
1.0053536892,
0.9988015294,
-0.0345958024,
0.2301273942,
0.0591230914,
0.7666772008,
-0.460522145,
-0.1567643583,
-0.9428930283,
0.6414006948,
-0.247254476,
-0.5191984177,
0.9472258091,
0.634588182,
0.6946869493,
0.0395490751,
0.9530927539,
0.1103894562,
0.8177998662,
-0.7090084553,
0.2685892582,
-0.4041767418,
0.5330657959,
-0.4158979952,
-0.9753872156,
-0.435601145,
0.260232538,
-0.5960429311,
0.2773240209,
0.633394897,
0.6098086834,
0.2553352118,
0.1930271536,
0.4567394853,
-0.0112201078,
0.2901691198,
0.4301676154,
1.362208724,
-0.4147969782,
0.6340183616,
-0.0656010211,
-0.0749316365,
0.1811221987,
-0.9035492539,
-0.9046824574,
-0.2826455832,
-0.0288991779,
-0.3145614266,
-0.3579433858,
0.9825063944,
0.3076636791,
-0.7354598641,
-0.1648086756,
0.0877667218,
0.1735090911,
-0.0938033089,
-0.2250139266,
0.1244392246,
-0.3784883022,
-0.6561872363,
0.4066524506,
0.2325558513,
-0.1642582864,
-0.4501039088,
-0.0638172701,
-0.5217006207,
0.5464236736,
0.8776349425,
0.104744494,
-0.6553252935,
-0.1349956691,
0.1391627491,
0.0830317363,
0.1721749753,
0.6231637597,
-0.6373229623,
0.484460324,
0.4576799273,
0.9250417948,
0.0385749489,
0.2194410563,
0.6458008289,
-0.3998190165,
-0.4083608985,
0.4761618674,
0.2303636968,
0.439031601,
-0.049752444,
0.2050273567,
-0.2626925111,
-0.5744770765,
-0.9352062345,
0.4753661752,
-0.7473279834,
-0.3274757564,
1.2611227036,
0.2281796783,
0.1523097605,
-0.4905974269,
-0.506776154,
-0.0666244775,
-0.1168232933,
0.449029088,
1.0521843433,
-0.3012114465,
-0.3317026794,
-0.8839004636,
0.4998280108,
0.3719315231,
-0.9226277471,
0.0410992876,
0.7311692238,
0.1958406866,
0.1917717606,
0.6337618828,
-0.1407279372,
0.302703917,
-0.2080821693,
-0.4304869771,
0.0639845654,
-0.2063161284,
-0.4572332799,
0.4297719002,
0.326256454,
0.1325558871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01345v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01345v6
|
Skip \n: A Simple Method to Reduce Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-02T12:02:46 | 2024-05-08T02:15:45 |
Zongbo Han, Zechen Bai, Haiyang Mei, Qianli Xu, Changqing Zhang, Mike Zheng Shou
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in large vision-language models (LVLMs) have demonstrated
impressive capability in visual information understanding with human language.
Despite these advances, LVLMs still face challenges with multimodal
hallucination, such as generating text descriptions of objects that are not
present in the visual information. However, the underlying fundamental reasons
of multimodal hallucinations remain poorly explored. In this paper, we propose
a new perspective, suggesting that the inherent biases in LVLMs might be a key
factor in hallucinations. Specifically, we systematically identify a semantic
shift bias related to paragraph breaks (\n\n), where the content before and
after '\n\n' in the training data frequently exhibit significant semantic
changes. This pattern leads the model to infer that the contents following
'\n\n' should be obviously different from the preceding contents with less
hallucinatory descriptions, thereby increasing the probability of hallucinatory
descriptions subsequent to the '\n\n'. We have validated this hypothesis on
multiple publicly available LVLMs. Besides, we find that deliberately inserting
'\n\n' at the generated description can induce more hallucinations. A simple
method is proposed to effectively mitigate the hallucination of LVLMs by
skipping the output of '\n'.
|
[
-0.5153418183,
-0.8801535964,
0.730682373,
0.346218735,
-0.3649476767,
-0.436539799,
-0.076923646,
-0.6059237719,
0.3237292171,
0.8116388917,
-0.6739801168,
-0.3072542548,
-0.4989300668,
0.1707082689,
-0.6731188297,
0.7387721539,
0.2026973963,
0.3620895445,
-0.0372972861,
0.1063237116,
-0.5026461482,
-0.3816615343,
-0.5677310824,
-0.29318434,
0.6923925281,
-0.1328378618,
0.7484973669,
0.6640114188,
0.5544237494,
0.1997373998,
-0.2684026659,
0.2577061951,
-0.5256041288,
0.229321003,
0.0242158156,
-0.2438782901,
-0.2495607734,
-0.3742430508,
0.5848127007,
0.7761558294,
0.0010262154,
-0.2306278497,
0.2114204764,
0.7455304861,
-0.7355130315,
-0.0376988277,
-0.6292442083,
0.5040235519,
-0.1031964943,
-0.5510185361,
-0.8224861026,
-0.1558964252,
0.0977585912,
-0.5474901199,
0.4384038746,
0.0945821255,
0.7804629207,
0.5436650515,
-0.1865122467,
-0.1206483915,
-0.7602757812,
0.695517242,
-0.4045182765,
0.8058602214,
0.3362433612,
0.0863475055,
-0.1134937257,
-0.6450259686,
-0.7512064576,
-0.384835422,
-0.0546467118,
-0.2013870329,
0.2840468884,
0.1211891323,
0.6110436916,
0.0872436613,
-0.4937213063,
-0.0140303327,
-0.6066022515,
-0.4758228362,
0.3653837442,
0.419772774,
0.2020007819,
-0.2363563776,
-0.3701089919,
-0.1188416183,
-0.5826773047,
-0.3504763246,
0.1287417859,
0.0918987095,
0.308180362,
0.7363265753,
-0.1824615747,
0.6952432394,
-0.0367059335,
-0.3600477278,
0.4104223847,
-0.3803036213,
-0.2947973013,
0.1106083468,
0.453089267,
0.7996976376,
0.4772696197,
-0.2128254622,
-0.0532363802,
0.3265863061,
0.4199032187,
-0.8980420232,
-0.3922144175,
0.0657662973,
-0.9133486152,
-0.2026214898,
-0.1337901056,
-1.1972080469,
-0.9960016608,
-0.4563379288,
0.2321483046,
-0.6613217592,
0.0735003799,
0.2734156251,
-0.2372172773,
0.4374579191,
0.7121792436,
-0.7644784451,
0.273396045,
0.3080437481,
0.9267477989,
-0.3162189126,
-0.6587481499,
-0.6718961,
0.1055068076,
-0.2924289107,
0.7229374051,
-0.3622908294,
-0.2962044775,
0.1728748977,
0.0878326297,
0.1254970133,
-0.5583466887,
0.3502041698,
-0.2144388258,
0.2517905235,
-0.3425635397,
-0.4361550808,
-0.2233195156,
0.0063085328,
-0.8294411898,
0.6581164598,
-0.3846240938,
-0.8704786301,
0.4661132991,
-0.2998681068,
-0.4598888755,
-0.0532015748,
-0.1605666876,
-0.2801164091,
0.3481788635,
0.4347988963,
0.2652852237,
0.097468257,
0.0743267238,
-0.1848811656,
-0.4631787241,
0.4326648414,
-0.503398478,
0.6427708268,
0.192287907,
-0.4797693491,
0.2849602699,
-0.884871006,
-0.2421694845,
0.1183061451,
-0.0970509797,
-0.4951883256,
0.3392744958,
0.2554025054,
0.1865611523,
0.0135671236,
-0.2780684233,
0.1024489254,
-0.2755805254,
-0.1432105601,
0.9550246,
0.0301615614,
0.4833725989,
-0.1303286701,
0.1428973824,
0.1190698221,
0.4034129083,
-0.2441383302,
-0.408207804,
-1.1874116659,
-0.1894512177,
-0.2414098531,
0.5178514719,
-0.9813542962,
0.2259790748,
0.1080914289,
0.0304104444,
-0.6315912008,
0.1250630468,
0.2928397655,
0.4240550399,
0.7595567703,
-0.2144210041,
-0.6992895007,
-0.912234962,
-0.1619210243,
0.1006630734,
-0.002575509,
-0.0309363287,
0.5186033249,
-0.3323518336,
0.5727630854,
-0.7190280557,
-0.6511557102,
-0.2467880547,
-0.1023218706,
-0.2275743783,
0.1836333573,
0.1806704104,
-0.925357759,
-0.2109795213,
-0.1657349318,
-0.8589228988,
-0.0889177322,
-0.4992971122,
-0.0211225394,
0.4702213407,
0.7376479506,
-0.7229451537,
0.8764994144,
0.1128503606,
-0.5703877211,
0.6142842174,
-0.1366846859,
-0.1050800011,
-0.8192551732,
-0.3584765494,
-0.0373983495,
0.0302946176,
-0.6742223501,
0.0226159506,
-0.1062981933,
0.2378987074,
-0.4475845098,
0.4847896993,
-0.616674304,
-0.0168743264,
-0.3368942142,
0.1693691462,
-0.0472781844,
0.4114342332,
0.3120797276,
0.2262036353,
0.7910664082,
-0.7865290046,
0.3187920749,
0.330786556,
-0.3056841791,
0.4053506553,
-0.3711183369,
0.0245091077,
-0.4979990721,
0.2706484199,
-0.6574977636,
-0.1586979479,
0.4922537804,
-0.2220778167,
0.0414181538,
0.3657474816,
-0.3862068653,
-0.1366429478,
-0.4948296249,
0.2908113897,
0.5743415952,
-0.6894235015,
0.4709502757,
0.1161121577,
0.3046649694,
-0.6016311049,
-0.8933340907,
0.2563540041,
-0.2121120095,
-0.5038212538,
0.259405911,
-0.4240108132,
-0.5342434049,
-0.0940897316,
0.0292025823,
0.0358580053,
-0.1887271553,
0.1941175163,
0.3429055214,
-0.1177160665,
0.1866863668,
-0.1900572777,
0.0212344378,
0.1667550057,
-0.2479225397,
0.8266297579,
0.0452579148,
-0.2503721416,
-0.6242470741,
0.4109489322,
0.5412895083,
-0.051399745,
0.9237421751,
0.7578954101,
-0.3861148655,
-0.2835579216,
-0.5882627964,
-0.594367981,
-0.4131690562,
0.5897697806,
-0.3608746231,
-0.5380209684,
0.4368866384,
0.298541218,
-0.3374617994,
0.2542891204,
0.6713452339,
0.1238643155,
0.9785075784,
0.5353243947,
0.2710026503,
0.433501333,
0.0259666834,
0.4324055314,
-0.9175410867,
-0.6677507758,
-0.2422214746,
-0.0052664289,
-0.4282332063,
-0.6325241923,
0.0062785768,
-0.1069447994,
0.2879395485,
-0.1127368286,
-0.7439895868,
0.551900506,
0.1653811932,
0.2426874787,
0.2724896967,
0.1529831588,
0.0554410852,
-0.3145993948,
-0.4082318246,
-0.2546648383,
0.841442287,
0.3546560109,
1.0759128332,
-0.0987688303,
0.6590991616,
0.3417120278,
-0.2568961084,
-0.7455685139,
0.9067149758,
0.0708889812,
-0.3057683706,
-0.4934059083,
-0.2905469239,
-0.6852959394,
0.6010162234,
-0.3639150858,
-0.9793375134,
0.1964446306,
0.0523079969,
-0.1476046443,
0.2726476789,
-0.4887771308,
0.6230354309,
-0.1491898149,
-0.5338510871,
-0.121514149,
-0.6197929382,
0.5402787328,
0.089168191,
0.1788599342,
0.1886278987,
0.0568220131,
0.7291314006,
-0.2954394817,
1.0258556604,
-0.1923476011,
-0.1316596866,
0.1509794444,
0.1219948754,
0.5319520831,
-0.097166419,
0.4894653559,
0.0030561527,
-0.4678255022,
-0.2474020422,
-0.4747028947,
0.6013374925,
-0.5231366158,
-0.4287163913,
-0.3819839358,
-0.7356204987,
0.1438608468,
0.0336541496,
0.5288457274,
0.3709896505,
-0.2016278654,
0.1757200062,
1.1895561218,
-0.3317664862,
0.5098391771,
-0.0635602027,
-0.7870830297,
-0.2136730105,
0.7252958417,
0.1594373137,
0.1168299988,
0.3233999908,
0.1271040142,
-0.3792229593,
-0.7194212079,
-0.074096106,
0.3121441007,
-1.087446928,
0.3326349258,
-0.9525744319,
-0.2169678956,
-0.6528683305,
-0.1438113451,
-0.1226056069,
-0.3028385043,
-0.4368318915,
-0.0800049603,
0.2055747658,
0.674603641,
0.0414286889,
0.1599922627,
-0.5143668056,
0.7507047057,
0.2469789982,
0.1020437926,
0.2263096124,
-0.5217866302,
-0.1838828921,
-0.2391981333,
-0.0059031523,
-0.9460870028,
0.640871942,
0.0245047268,
0.487089932,
0.648758769,
-0.00765436,
0.9379892349,
-0.6082313061,
0.8279575109,
0.3629965484,
-0.9823385477,
0.5620221496,
0.0599673726,
0.1590597183,
0.3142539263,
0.1731265336,
-0.5387061238,
-0.5498479009,
-0.3891158402,
-0.9133119583,
0.4018270373,
0.17149432,
0.0280089136,
-0.0122184996,
0.1095659137,
0.3530892134,
-0.0268427972,
-1.2044923306,
-0.0970818102,
-0.3084747493,
0.173629716,
-0.0337284282,
-0.6134464741,
-0.0563823059,
-0.5146486163,
0.5696289539,
-0.0383008942,
0.2391773015,
0.3731253147,
-0.4655471146,
0.2007531971,
0.0220009629,
1.0968105793,
0.7882418633,
-0.270786494,
0.4231715202,
0.1792618483,
-0.640006125,
-0.1939695776,
-0.2353891879,
-0.4014451802,
0.3591870368,
0.5345402956,
1.1502860785,
-0.1774525046,
-0.5382234454,
0.3308980465,
-0.0875687301,
-0.2502701283,
-0.6430844069,
-0.1231213883,
-0.2035439909,
0.2165182382,
0.2927697301,
0.1664641201,
0.2472731024,
-0.5037576556,
0.3662760258,
0.2301623225,
-0.3909715116,
-0.0630694851,
0.7613748312,
0.0232731681,
-0.5487318039,
0.7062097788,
-0.0659026653,
-0.3824649751,
0.2987354398,
0.6963300705,
1.0278710127,
-0.1785999388,
0.1919239312,
0.2518792748,
0.5668472648,
-0.3245069385,
0.1407459825,
0.0316424444,
-0.7855234742,
-0.3640337288,
-0.6831770539,
-0.0431099832,
0.2786291242,
-0.7193784714,
0.3692228496,
-0.3596335351,
0.1426944733,
-0.091966413,
-0.7472677231,
-0.4104708135,
0.0957765058,
0.5683678389,
0.6953018904,
-0.9062747955,
0.8806740642,
0.1508399248,
-0.4434302151,
-0.2802522182,
0.5087129474,
-0.1002668813,
-0.6864033341,
0.7117684484,
0.2967723012,
-0.1598305106,
-0.330557704,
-0.6717041731,
-0.5065082312,
0.6897629499,
-0.0737171397,
-0.4772752821,
-0.2984591126,
0.0859773532,
0.548605144,
-0.4484784007,
-0.0893067345,
0.5904608965,
0.6156663299,
0.2510039508,
-0.5593696237,
0.2761146128,
-0.0612825193,
0.1936834306,
0.2704055607,
-0.1987603158,
1.0905911922,
-0.4503460228,
-0.0269745644,
0.0825537741,
0.5700101852,
0.2740074694,
0.5047428012,
0.5194212794,
0.4378400147,
0.8035511374,
0.0645998046,
1.1459627151,
0.0963893607,
0.2787260711,
1.1688559055,
-0.481012702,
0.6631912589,
1.1473840475,
0.17333287,
0.2899845243,
0.3230647743,
-0.223312825,
0.8741785288,
0.3243537843,
-0.1072370932,
-0.2611394823,
-0.1301633269,
-0.5042917132,
0.4650962651,
0.2475795746,
-0.5442869067,
-0.1108849794,
0.5109870434,
0.0324665532,
-0.0279516932,
-0.4334095716,
0.7108082175,
0.0494002737,
-0.6270054579,
0.6922804117,
-0.4244973361,
0.6302609444,
-0.3752251863,
-0.2642126381,
-0.2726278007,
0.3475113213,
-0.2322172076,
-0.4495583475,
0.3802788556,
-0.1323509365,
-0.2269221544,
-0.3327326775,
0.8070542812,
-0.493896991,
-0.514321208,
0.6029623747,
0.353277266,
0.4559851587,
-0.146882534,
-0.3188427687,
0.2039987147,
0.3783328235,
-0.1958658546,
0.3081881702,
0.4513364434,
-0.0884535834,
0.5747424364,
0.5357483029,
0.2002678663,
0.472281754,
0.3488253653,
0.764618516,
-0.9744272232,
-0.6293612719,
-1.1257632971,
0.5456367731,
-0.3481165469,
-0.1744701117,
0.7970443368,
0.501224637,
0.7896693349,
-0.4709567428,
0.6734164953,
-0.0400050767,
0.2004033625,
-1.053643465,
0.7189580798,
-0.7395405173,
0.2321218997,
-0.311933428,
-1.2091219425,
-0.4867480695,
0.9077381492,
-0.0092706261,
-0.2290857732,
1.3523387909,
0.8757455349,
0.3080998361,
-0.1967488527,
0.6324465871,
0.4953258038,
0.0739428028,
0.4282576442,
1.2500380278,
-0.2034382522,
0.6971371174,
-0.2533185482,
0.0467920601,
-0.4859646261,
-0.7278773785,
-1.1531631947,
-0.6672556996,
-0.3873546124,
-0.6857869625,
0.0179124195,
0.5143653154,
0.3792411685,
-0.5660601258,
-0.1070045456,
-0.1785942465,
0.2351385057,
-0.1644087583,
-0.2655413747,
0.2796223164,
-0.3924095333,
-0.5610635877,
0.233777687,
0.4670727253,
0.192893818,
-0.6310038567,
-0.2362142503,
-0.0796829835,
0.1065793708,
0.8220419884,
-0.1208414063,
-1.1630218029,
-0.4740824401,
0.1232977584,
-0.1896852106,
0.2271512151,
0.8033975363,
-0.8296880126,
0.5284404159,
0.504537642,
0.2333410233,
0.6957914829,
-0.4308537245,
0.1731251329,
-0.3766981661,
0.5761480331,
0.2038246989,
0.4056871533,
0.3480066955,
-0.4298388958,
0.4478540421,
0.4683552086,
-0.3171525896,
-0.9159766436,
0.3695711493,
-1.2236390114,
-0.5731912851,
1.318415761,
0.4248716831,
-0.3647572994,
-0.2660424113,
-0.6162831783,
0.0726967975,
-0.237478286,
1.112452507,
0.6951574087,
-0.2277395129,
-0.4183796346,
-0.5764845014,
0.7348131537,
0.4444498718,
-0.7724915743,
0.1033822149,
0.8252111673,
-0.1295475215,
0.4317516983,
0.648814857,
0.0678084865,
0.3091565371,
0.3166861236,
0.3820969462,
0.1478231549,
-0.7261497974,
-0.4189650118,
0.4527209699,
-0.139336884,
-0.4868218303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03469v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03469v2
|
Rethinking the Role of Proxy Rewards in Language Model Alignment
| 2024-02-02T11:58:08 | 2024-04-29T01:09:06 |
Sungdong Kim, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Learning from human feedback via proxy reward modeling has been studied to
align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human values. However, achieving
reliable training through that proxy reward model (RM) is not a trivial
problem, and its behavior remained as a black-box. In this paper, we study the
role of proxy rewards in the LLM alignment via `reverse reward engineering' by
composing interpretable features as a white-box reward function. We aim to
replicate the ground truth (gold) reward signal by achieving a monotonic
relationship between the proxy and gold reward signals after training the model
using the proxy reward in reinforcement learning (RL). Our findings indicate
that successfully emulating the gold reward requires generating responses that
are relevant with enough length to open-ended questions, while also ensuring
response consistency in closed-ended questions. Furthermore, resulting models
optimizing our devised white-box reward show competitive performances with
strong open-source RMs in alignment benchmarks. We highlight its potential
usage as a simple but strong reward baseline for the LLM alignment, not
requiring explicit human feedback dataset and RM training. Our code is
available at https://github.com/naver-ai/rethinking-proxy-reward.
|
[
-0.0996533707,
-0.3053590059,
0.3871487975,
-0.0323763266,
-0.2768276036,
0.0704696253,
0.0379502401,
-0.1189150214,
0.4706103504,
0.5882340074,
-0.8278111219,
-0.164890781,
-0.6049385071,
-0.0802254677,
-0.0722698271,
1.4065281153,
-0.0818979815,
-0.2156048119,
-0.1448375136,
-0.2198126167,
-0.3699207604,
-0.5536559224,
-0.682071507,
-0.3985599875,
0.9687488675,
0.2985460162,
0.928126514,
1.0150822401,
0.1271047443,
0.2340662926,
0.0106342845,
0.0964267254,
-0.8667218685,
-0.1005798578,
-0.5349746346,
-0.418646276,
-0.495020479,
0.2600727677,
0.377938807,
0.6480275989,
-0.1851286888,
0.3321780562,
0.2628672421,
0.8038383722,
-0.7593044639,
0.1077901796,
-0.6804458499,
-0.0400892273,
-0.1916874796,
-0.1206404492,
-0.3664921224,
-0.3327469528,
-0.0110408533,
-0.5436010957,
0.0955658853,
-0.0960560441,
1.1292163134,
0.4117788374,
-0.2886393368,
-0.2410627156,
-0.2613790333,
0.6816514134,
-0.634016335,
0.3887451887,
0.0170885697,
0.3277050853,
-0.3992037773,
-0.4269382656,
-0.5273832679,
-0.1077235639,
-0.1603728235,
0.2377498597,
0.2713656127,
-0.2640492618,
-0.0558292568,
0.2904668748,
-0.4046239555,
0.0439985879,
-0.2978717387,
-0.2331748903,
0.5531722903,
0.1811604202,
0.2107915282,
0.194742769,
-0.4623143077,
-0.5336589217,
-0.8631184697,
0.438806206,
0.5709977746,
0.7795840502,
-0.1839622557,
0.6420090795,
-0.1601178199,
0.6703517437,
-0.0266552214,
-0.2704906464,
0.276781857,
-0.105048582,
0.1114423051,
0.3370182812,
0.4817481935,
0.0895066932,
0.4020467699,
-0.2461609244,
-0.3853387535,
0.2686903477,
0.7119514346,
-0.5180129409,
0.0647857934,
0.1024752706,
-0.3333107829,
-0.4288613498,
0.3901896477,
-0.5888906121,
-0.2825298309,
-0.3966252506,
0.5325670838,
0.2703784108,
-0.4393177629,
0.3799038529,
-0.3045704067,
0.1603491008,
0.2302297056,
-0.9150447845,
0.4332059026,
1.1665713787,
0.6164460182,
-0.037561249,
-0.7122848034,
-1.0569267273,
0.2275676578,
-0.1731261313,
0.5301035047,
-0.3742584586,
-0.0301917773,
0.357863307,
0.284945935,
0.0965310857,
-0.31730932,
0.4966634214,
-0.6279719472,
0.0907616615,
-0.3821980059,
-0.2068140805,
0.2924821377,
0.2238508761,
-0.8111396432,
0.527146399,
0.0410503112,
-0.6894856095,
0.1534615755,
-0.315972209,
-0.3800309896,
-0.0529494546,
0.0395379551,
-0.5304273963,
0.163461253,
0.0705083087,
0.0839259923,
-0.1356051415,
0.2448774129,
-0.32989344,
-0.6858648062,
0.4760811627,
-0.3847767413,
0.4543449581,
0.1479456276,
-0.5058210492,
0.0071169436,
-0.5247789621,
-0.1360274851,
0.1257095337,
-0.3474614918,
-0.4179466367,
0.067989409,
-0.4956617951,
0.2354599833,
0.2041071206,
-0.628439784,
0.372343123,
-0.5209447145,
0.2179594934,
1.1062386036,
-0.2905719876,
0.3633908927,
-0.3765028119,
0.6593198776,
-0.1900625527,
0.1188063771,
-0.0245748535,
-0.2305018306,
-0.5044934154,
-0.4201315641,
0.6749130487,
0.4686819017,
-0.4911994636,
0.0830138177,
-0.5760584474,
-0.2552191615,
-1.3277002573,
0.1721106321,
0.5938588977,
0.6518967748,
0.3746666014,
-0.0731709823,
-0.2887979448,
-1.0048917532,
-0.331302911,
-0.3638000488,
-0.0637895614,
-0.0406135097,
0.3945893049,
-0.0189293493,
0.8648665547,
-0.5137440562,
-0.2103154212,
-0.0398882516,
0.229711175,
0.2607331872,
0.4518042505,
-0.0336211622,
-0.7935724854,
-0.2118513584,
-0.0732768774,
-0.4534687996,
-0.4977275431,
-0.1772959828,
-0.351821661,
0.1511968523,
0.3064667583,
-0.5126960278,
0.302988261,
0.6131071448,
-0.326276511,
0.4158301651,
0.1720116884,
0.2124538273,
-0.8222122192,
0.110762015,
-0.1558015794,
-0.1649725884,
-0.3772148788,
0.0448452309,
0.2152956873,
-0.0554409698,
-0.5599908829,
0.9007816315,
-0.2259844542,
0.0253313985,
-0.6026934385,
0.2041348517,
-0.0505009852,
0.702051878,
0.0958000869,
0.7274864912,
0.0407414325,
-0.5144069791,
0.0839507431,
0.27372545,
0.0730703846,
0.603716433,
-0.6511034369,
0.1409407556,
-0.2414764464,
0.1040352881,
-1.091481328,
0.0345970802,
0.2852496505,
-0.5229834914,
0.1970281899,
-0.3786633909,
-0.2608676851,
-0.0573618785,
-0.5467335582,
0.4319988787,
0.5404005051,
-0.9096356034,
0.2884802222,
0.4402728677,
-0.2010180205,
-0.9831541777,
-0.5004097819,
-0.1414812952,
-0.2418444008,
-0.4917085171,
0.5913050771,
0.1913851649,
0.0130847488,
0.1642186791,
-0.3466127813,
0.6547114849,
0.3059802949,
0.2234971225,
0.2448904216,
-0.0693065524,
0.0794315934,
-0.0022307837,
-0.3825617135,
0.0534566455,
-0.2810898423,
0.4091186523,
-0.1182692125,
-0.5885279179,
-0.2032035589,
0.0108128656,
0.3645501733,
-0.2111914754,
0.890365839,
0.1496884525,
-0.1148198992,
-0.1404933631,
-0.4137070775,
-0.2232244909,
-0.4367345273,
0.0941384584,
-0.545576632,
-0.9808980823,
0.4485257566,
-0.1048270613,
0.1264532357,
0.1558082104,
0.3841778636,
0.1742258221,
1.2683403492,
0.5041685104,
-0.2685993314,
0.2490216643,
0.3654032648,
0.0197890513,
-0.8397185802,
-0.3597291112,
-0.5668609738,
-0.3214940727,
-0.5326911211,
0.2163211256,
0.0911620259,
0.2135793418,
-0.5181779265,
0.174550876,
-0.2347281873,
0.2988689244,
0.4925393164,
0.0602821186,
-0.0170081444,
-0.1002734601,
-0.1509235948,
0.0349227637,
-0.5669913888,
-0.6363361478,
0.7188144922,
0.5746636987,
1.1419255733,
0.1357372105,
0.7904976606,
0.141146034,
0.4718509614,
-0.4341842234,
0.3229512572,
-0.0455057323,
-0.002025771,
-0.4139973521,
-0.3096183538,
-1.1080079079,
0.4876700938,
-0.0121810157,
-0.5708816648,
-0.0773830861,
0.1229489818,
-0.0928898528,
-0.0621747747,
-0.5287600756,
1.137879014,
-0.3049976826,
-0.6937814355,
0.2903763354,
-0.7055168152,
0.1885325313,
0.1433024853,
0.2871171236,
0.2671065331,
-0.0203041714,
0.5993139744,
-0.5711986423,
0.9987863898,
-0.0531114005,
-0.3425992131,
-0.2271473557,
0.1653669775,
0.6296229959,
0.2255013883,
0.0448902175,
-0.1095232889,
-0.0634698793,
-0.6631658673,
-0.8489559889,
0.6477985978,
-0.6612164378,
-1.0810666084,
-0.4379234612,
-0.4361119568,
-0.0979696363,
-0.1134840846,
-0.285700202,
0.1845448315,
0.1640951633,
-0.119581297,
0.6260700226,
-0.1545525789,
-0.1279567927,
0.6497721076,
-0.2345638573,
-0.5199429393,
0.9316318035,
-0.2245223522,
0.4650802612,
0.5009027719,
0.179862231,
-0.4034575224,
-0.0109505374,
-0.569301188,
0.4683899283,
-0.4767810106,
-0.2877558172,
-0.2633372843,
-0.1688619107,
-0.4274386168,
-0.3453232944,
-0.5958049893,
-0.1828912795,
0.0187971033,
-0.2088907957,
-0.0822133943,
0.4434989989,
-0.1658861786,
0.2269163132,
-0.7415031195,
0.1788122952,
0.4100645781,
0.3646652699,
0.0754699185,
-0.458378315,
-0.3328137696,
0.3798682392,
-0.0108088525,
-0.829977572,
0.2483517379,
-0.4228185713,
0.6545432806,
0.1669221371,
0.0153309777,
0.930999577,
-0.5396992564,
0.8460607529,
-0.053673815,
-0.9271349907,
0.3490292132,
0.1777876616,
0.4593032002,
0.6194403172,
0.2752944827,
-0.8028575778,
-0.6598249078,
-0.5311508775,
-0.6003227234,
0.7756692767,
-0.0417410433,
0.2078769356,
-0.1685486138,
0.5853257775,
0.2750411928,
0.3493318558,
-1.0369042158,
0.0033414706,
-0.3925836682,
-0.5536009073,
-0.1460379064,
-0.1815662533,
-0.3215322793,
0.1596854925,
0.7729093432,
-0.2080649585,
0.0370872766,
0.0012044127,
-0.1160034612,
-0.297406137,
0.3688223958,
0.7021276951,
0.4377250373,
-0.2975846231,
0.4473810494,
-0.2355505228,
-0.0612581298,
0.2224533409,
-0.0743007585,
-0.0309430994,
-0.4069479406,
0.3247421086,
0.7969967723,
0.2534947693,
-0.7960931063,
0.5819227695,
0.0526279919,
-0.1324834675,
-0.0029946964,
0.0083844317,
0.1527409106,
0.3057208657,
0.1882845461,
-0.6382663846,
-0.2510211766,
-0.8028675318,
0.0968885347,
0.887922883,
-0.5160976052,
-0.2820757031,
0.7073445916,
-0.2506596446,
-0.5749518871,
0.8181121349,
-0.1953283846,
-0.8644679785,
0.4013494551,
0.8159762621,
0.5014499426,
-0.1243652999,
0.5382139683,
0.0722589418,
0.2403001189,
-0.3875130713,
0.2041029036,
0.0787645802,
-0.7331303358,
-0.455506742,
-0.6812514663,
-0.3794443607,
0.2592689991,
-0.6720325947,
0.3264597356,
0.1258608997,
0.2413892746,
-0.0931702778,
-0.3460042775,
-0.3257730305,
0.0260384213,
0.0193109866,
0.8129461408,
-1.1313016415,
0.7067212462,
0.780143857,
-0.6790558696,
-0.7195030451,
-0.0464487709,
0.0831640065,
-0.7395488024,
0.9782412052,
0.155509606,
-0.3320003152,
-0.2175427079,
-0.6337839961,
-0.8128804564,
0.9382794499,
0.3413668275,
-0.1047510356,
0.1422742903,
0.5076435208,
0.711858809,
-0.6082736254,
0.0924387723,
0.3357875943,
0.2339802086,
0.1600711346,
-0.7339115739,
0.3199561536,
-0.3112070262,
0.0720345527,
0.5303176045,
-0.6492705941,
0.8434258103,
0.1680577993,
-0.2752366662,
0.0564688556,
0.5277769566,
0.8023905158,
0.1696367562,
0.4812316298,
0.6918692589,
0.5311157703,
0.1009072885,
0.9962362647,
0.0575869456,
0.171902433,
0.8877759576,
-0.3958039582,
0.8019121289,
0.8771673441,
0.1295024306,
0.5973758698,
0.4530421197,
0.1466123313,
0.9277701974,
0.5980971456,
0.2400624007,
-0.1355481148,
-0.0906553194,
-0.1891491562,
0.0321286172,
-0.0781797245,
0.0321785361,
-0.3307405114,
-0.0260598902,
-0.136477232,
0.2345461398,
-0.3889564574,
0.6821402907,
-0.0179218035,
-1.0759366751,
0.6288356781,
-0.0261279829,
0.5055956244,
-0.658580482,
-0.4087665081,
-0.3320249915,
0.2414382398,
-0.0463236794,
-0.6939350963,
0.0584589578,
-0.1757221371,
-0.0444684513,
-0.339520514,
0.5119991899,
-0.6051468253,
0.0065077716,
0.1467215717,
0.3376441896,
0.0029899075,
0.0340724923,
-0.6900553107,
0.253908664,
-0.1041491479,
-0.1882196367,
0.754458487,
0.3130058646,
-0.1213121489,
0.6005214453,
0.6682273746,
0.174470976,
-0.1424494237,
0.1074560955,
0.7005439401,
-0.6355239749,
-0.6232249737,
-1.0467067957,
0.8840311766,
-0.0026049095,
-0.0791831985,
0.4921929538,
0.5702453256,
1.1850175858,
-0.1649044603,
0.4166958332,
0.3954049647,
0.4564050734,
-0.8270366192,
0.2871208489,
-0.7857496738,
0.4112920463,
-0.2779173255,
-0.6724626422,
0.1076107919,
0.4939929247,
0.0563360453,
-0.3026355803,
0.5378013253,
1.0215421915,
-0.1164932549,
-0.0621102266,
0.0230523273,
-0.1734772027,
0.2961786389,
0.5840041041,
0.9908635616,
-0.2573016882,
0.4641947448,
-0.0634767637,
-0.2976815999,
-0.0094551016,
-0.9566947818,
-0.6364409328,
-0.6856864691,
-0.3252678812,
-0.6776764393,
0.3127502799,
0.9951933622,
0.2916136384,
-0.6644158363,
-0.5854550004,
0.1278257668,
0.4078353643,
-0.6260553598,
-0.2550132573,
0.4316081703,
-0.6431573629,
-0.6711206436,
0.2265127301,
0.302274555,
-0.0427526087,
-0.1757410616,
-0.4574096501,
-0.1920652241,
0.0573163554,
0.2385939658,
0.5603300333,
-0.7598130107,
-0.466593802,
0.0120692011,
-0.3388831913,
-0.1668012291,
0.7419449687,
-1.0112224817,
0.203869611,
0.2650351226,
1.1688725948,
0.4642156661,
0.4257320762,
0.7412136793,
-0.7030795813,
0.0170573257,
-0.2723527253,
0.2890182734,
0.1296527684,
-0.2976749837,
0.6431234479,
-0.0629617423,
-0.4281013906,
-1.1329410076,
0.3976798356,
-0.8872113228,
-0.4268692732,
1.1296957731,
-0.0391959362,
-0.5365624428,
0.150239408,
-0.2134128213,
0.320469141,
-0.2694578767,
1.2779393196,
0.8087954521,
0.1590728164,
-0.2414705902,
-0.2879971266,
0.5809921622,
0.6133694053,
-0.5360606313,
0.1147694886,
0.2257879972,
0.2352030128,
0.2749949396,
0.4810916781,
-0.2472851723,
0.3419038951,
-0.2951023877,
0.0596301481,
-0.2524858713,
-0.2179038227,
-0.5310076475,
0.3298718929,
0.1853504926,
-0.1962474883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01300v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01300v1
|
Two Approaches to Diachronic Normalization of Polish Texts
| 2024-02-02T10:42:06 | 2024-02-02T10:42:06 |
Kacper Dudzic, Filip Graliński, Krzysztof Jassem, Marek Kubis, Piotr Wierzchoń
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper discusses two approaches to the diachronic normalization of Polish
texts: a rule-based solution that relies on a set of handcrafted patterns, and
a neural normalization model based on the text-to-text transfer transformer
architecture. The training and evaluation data prepared for the task are
discussed in detail, along with experiments conducted to compare the proposed
normalization solutions. A quantitative and qualitative analysis is made. It is
shown that at the current stage of inquiry into the problem, the rule-based
solution outperforms the neural one on 3 out of 4 variants of the prepared
dataset, although in practice both approaches have distinct advantages and
disadvantages.
|
[
-0.0409735553,
-0.8640159965,
0.565826416,
0.4999063015,
-0.4409067333,
-0.2088989168,
-0.6106333733,
-0.5379471779,
0.1825380772,
0.5715383291,
-0.7317851186,
-0.4698506296,
-0.4988519251,
0.3111962378,
-0.3113103807,
0.8881534934,
-0.1398663074,
0.3630401194,
0.1264677346,
0.2262756377,
-0.8063457012,
-0.5698539615,
-0.3444102108,
-0.5771821737,
-0.0178023893,
0.6114351153,
0.7213541269,
0.8573002219,
0.8582621217,
0.3012498915,
-0.1659746766,
-0.0305721574,
-0.214263469,
0.2214394361,
0.1160016954,
-0.8220245838,
-0.4322521687,
0.1287828833,
0.3836354315,
0.8099539876,
-0.158274278,
0.1643505692,
-0.1273350269,
0.8602651358,
-0.417237848,
0.2375197709,
-0.3685676157,
0.280205667,
-0.2604041398,
-0.0633398518,
-0.5484706759,
-0.40332371,
-0.0722384751,
-0.743188858,
0.3921253383,
-0.1002878398,
0.6652988791,
-0.1058083549,
-0.2642421424,
-0.5246261954,
-1.3591712713,
1.0080251694,
-1.0479625463,
0.1953272372,
0.3285661936,
0.363573581,
0.1874843389,
-1.0407958031,
-0.4383192062,
0.1402886808,
-0.4360263348,
0.3772134781,
-0.1370427758,
-0.2928379476,
0.1740034968,
0.3270886242,
-0.5369343162,
0.2516957223,
-0.4873334467,
-0.1451571137,
0.7368690372,
0.3754947484,
0.4560622275,
-0.1112106591,
-0.5222613811,
-0.0897857919,
-0.5113201141,
-0.111427471,
0.4795593023,
0.5472826958,
-0.1056195274,
0.3319846392,
-0.4475855529,
0.6654945016,
0.43675825,
-0.0699054077,
0.3745512664,
-0.7585231662,
-0.082375288,
0.2674137354,
0.8711432219,
0.862062037,
0.6657098532,
-0.6429666281,
-0.2951779664,
0.1399357468,
0.4454589188,
-0.7570120096,
-0.224073112,
-0.2095744908,
-0.9546165466,
-0.4258382618,
0.073174566,
-1.0994279385,
-0.0889661461,
-0.6886942387,
0.4080455303,
-0.4158286452,
0.0660215095,
0.3533306718,
-0.0482094847,
0.1467674226,
0.3607036471,
-1.5121825933,
0.7627282143,
0.5000922084,
0.7045587301,
-0.0123630874,
-0.0541419424,
0.1855030209,
-0.24884969,
-0.7839465141,
0.7117584348,
-0.3509913385,
-0.2015668154,
-0.0285265129,
-0.0404856466,
-0.0177322123,
-0.3510893881,
0.5547181368,
-0.7784155011,
0.5882923007,
-0.3099577427,
-0.3734248877,
-0.2810102403,
0.1103804335,
-0.7199069858,
1.1591062546,
0.0801741555,
-0.8488895893,
0.3917046189,
-0.4584860504,
-0.4755739868,
-0.0255487021,
0.050598897,
-0.2327330261,
-0.0937205106,
0.0432025194,
0.1847357899,
-0.2447076589,
0.1297210455,
0.2081546038,
-0.6295841336,
0.0309104323,
-0.370839566,
1.0889523029,
0.1548062563,
-0.609002769,
-0.1580881923,
-1.0699484348,
0.0340369307,
0.113266319,
-0.4184440672,
-0.5963292122,
0.1581124067,
0.3052033186,
0.5160143375,
0.3208979368,
-0.9189125896,
0.2098597437,
-0.7969014645,
0.4822532237,
0.3454550803,
-0.0621275343,
0.8937923908,
-0.3626230657,
0.1890685111,
-0.0468437485,
0.4888390005,
0.1858599633,
-0.507676065,
-0.7591776252,
0.3609517813,
0.4611250162,
0.9369626045,
-0.409828186,
0.2925986946,
-0.2312481254,
-0.5747981071,
-0.3392138779,
-0.0634238198,
0.2756535411,
0.7139117718,
0.7047260404,
-0.305729866,
-0.7986570597,
-1.0024307966,
-0.0209083688,
0.0212357268,
-0.0172241386,
0.0952116698,
0.1723959297,
0.1316905022,
0.9151614308,
-0.1897599101,
-0.3220986724,
-0.0183011349,
0.2377949208,
0.5117331147,
0.4000403583,
0.7175510526,
-0.8200564981,
-0.7915797234,
0.0727904812,
-0.7213972211,
-0.1111552119,
-0.2900350988,
0.0790239722,
0.1166308299,
0.8265552521,
-0.1378066689,
0.6112434268,
0.1915377825,
-0.4838264287,
0.5022620559,
-0.4551211894,
0.4259557128,
-1.0037412643,
-0.0136773223,
-0.420702517,
-0.1299155354,
-1.3851583004,
-0.2727017105,
0.4334366322,
0.3639144897,
-0.3977773488,
0.1557190865,
-0.4626172781,
0.122684814,
-0.3585068583,
0.1809098572,
0.045889657,
0.3797028661,
-0.1023233309,
0.726772666,
0.2232663482,
-0.3921070099,
0.5359895825,
0.7314037085,
-0.2137705386,
0.2910927832,
-0.7328441143,
0.2510897815,
-0.3022482097,
-0.0910022408,
-1.0438514948,
0.4722338319,
0.4488939345,
-0.2510079145,
0.236750707,
-0.0749208778,
-0.504427135,
-0.0711107776,
-0.4716264307,
0.3269167244,
0.8313648701,
-0.3669970036,
0.3390507996,
-0.1818327606,
-0.2638159394,
-0.595344305,
-1.0704843998,
0.4590570629,
-0.3413532674,
-0.6395870447,
0.9807805419,
-0.2459902018,
-0.5663639307,
-0.171651125,
0.1357973069,
-0.1657346189,
0.1109164506,
0.0051155882,
0.5640271902,
-0.4557437897,
0.071444273,
-0.0696526095,
-0.2337339371,
0.1367150545,
-0.0477830432,
0.63894701,
0.1658840775,
0.1617146879,
-0.4828010499,
0.5070207715,
0.4850560129,
-0.1784402132,
0.5523399711,
0.4588875473,
-0.1946284324,
-0.0790508687,
-0.4248976409,
-0.2798722088,
-0.4278813303,
0.0071408511,
-0.1720149964,
-0.3471707702,
0.7377784252,
-0.0080307629,
0.0564192832,
0.5406168699,
0.9070751667,
-0.1761847883,
0.9277381897,
0.763147831,
0.121740818,
0.6132874489,
-0.0782686621,
0.3256477416,
-0.7853203416,
-0.4247933328,
-0.6144712567,
-0.5459112525,
-0.5752303004,
0.012179547,
0.0361649878,
0.4114978313,
-0.0245820228,
0.4597088695,
-0.5302303433,
0.4278009236,
0.3965703547,
0.3178386986,
0.5018280149,
0.0286035389,
-0.0940034464,
-0.1610383689,
-0.825630188,
-0.7363174558,
1.2208049297,
-0.0001460961,
0.5157465935,
0.0828387737,
0.6331562996,
0.0997879282,
0.1000701413,
-0.8335936666,
0.2139844894,
-0.5973773003,
-0.3994557858,
-0.487988621,
-0.0334047638,
-0.9963538647,
0.1236939281,
-0.5017596483,
-0.5665088296,
0.646851182,
-0.1747269332,
-0.1892890185,
0.1431894749,
-0.5906755328,
0.7522619367,
0.1435601562,
0.0597881153,
-0.0021503756,
-1.1337765455,
-0.0328198895,
-0.1619257927,
0.5104444623,
0.0992626697,
-0.1175408363,
1.0009430647,
-0.3059940338,
0.961991787,
0.0202558637,
0.0384421796,
0.1427867711,
0.0636066794,
0.4028276503,
-0.1171981394,
-0.1858301014,
-0.0519586653,
0.047171399,
-0.2492798269,
-0.6749429107,
0.2971833646,
-0.7096143961,
-0.2507399619,
0.0423837677,
-0.6679993868,
-0.1407479048,
0.5185075402,
0.60370785,
0.6082183719,
-0.3884862363,
-0.0807135478,
0.6748023629,
0.3016429245,
1.0579645634,
0.5423253775,
0.0630815998,
-0.2533167899,
0.197418943,
0.2203822881,
0.1968019307,
0.3161890209,
0.2275072932,
0.001316158,
-0.8285512328,
-0.6410015225,
0.1403098702,
-0.8049587011,
-0.1297152489,
-0.1982085705,
-0.1713672876,
-0.4485251904,
-0.1614665538,
-0.4163404405,
-0.630240202,
-0.4857954085,
0.1782216579,
0.3638369739,
0.7588470578,
0.0026866372,
0.1481194794,
-0.7894559503,
0.2194343358,
0.2182209045,
0.3087390661,
-0.1908368617,
-0.4416099787,
-0.25606668,
0.1946391761,
0.1571470052,
-1.0597345829,
0.3281255662,
0.1422894448,
0.2751195133,
0.0919047371,
0.0031052059,
0.2736558318,
-1.0740932226,
0.6555781364,
0.1480719596,
-0.748139143,
0.5117910504,
-0.239907369,
0.0615067221,
0.708775878,
0.2527953386,
-0.8556092978,
-0.1665600985,
-0.5809318423,
-0.679653585,
0.6950058937,
0.1556863338,
0.5215219259,
-0.0106292553,
0.6352838874,
0.220447138,
-0.193993032,
-0.2621379793,
-0.3203243613,
-0.3415822685,
-0.292427659,
-0.0873444825,
-0.1892146617,
-0.1312984228,
-0.0018158421,
0.3616009653,
0.1190951765,
0.1226914823,
0.4749301076,
-0.3172164857,
-0.0968888402,
0.4641507268,
0.7611731887,
0.7669411898,
-0.2319927216,
0.0710263997,
0.2372295707,
-0.9016970396,
0.2741972804,
-0.2058357447,
-0.5944305658,
0.2711037695,
0.5266417265,
0.6450861692,
0.2379198521,
-0.1184653714,
0.5881485343,
-0.0656719282,
-0.6535912752,
-0.0424277969,
-0.2958554327,
-0.0064002792,
0.1589642912,
-0.0358919725,
0.128194958,
0.3657137752,
-0.459106952,
0.1460684985,
-0.0589806028,
-0.424326241,
-0.5226992965,
0.410892874,
-0.1794083565,
-0.5477365255,
0.8644708395,
0.1422692537,
-0.4376914799,
0.7453126311,
1.1283050776,
0.4996484518,
-0.3893949091,
0.1908241361,
0.3395693004,
0.2312425375,
-0.3346295059,
0.4091069698,
0.0436180979,
-0.8422681093,
-0.4431961477,
-0.3410418034,
-0.077941142,
-0.2559357285,
-0.973787725,
0.2716602981,
-0.3343994617,
-0.2041484118,
0.196881935,
-0.036408361,
-0.3955298066,
0.194676742,
-0.0479965881,
0.947735846,
-1.1480175257,
0.6932479739,
0.7813674808,
-0.2705316544,
-0.6446787715,
-0.3859161139,
-0.3287902772,
-0.6168103218,
0.7903299332,
-0.3829726577,
-0.0092734974,
-0.0594758727,
-0.0497989096,
-0.7932989001,
1.1229206324,
0.0187163912,
-0.7258817554,
-0.2311348617,
0.1162952855,
0.8015751839,
-0.1898037195,
-0.0016004428,
0.8121996522,
0.5951071382,
-0.2497853786,
-0.9520994425,
0.0578924492,
-0.462635994,
0.2268979996,
0.5114646554,
-0.51220119,
1.0297151804,
0.2257586569,
-0.3865776956,
-0.0446973108,
0.1589829326,
-0.6257061362,
0.0154918022,
0.3595138788,
0.4488486648,
0.3740372956,
0.1388293952,
0.6702270508,
-0.4899996221,
0.5059491992,
0.8856981397,
-0.0217574798,
0.6693117023,
0.6088125706,
-0.3853767216,
0.7296444774,
0.5641382933,
-0.197580412,
0.7327235341,
0.0467598364,
-0.1107347608,
-0.0572926514,
0.3626618683,
-0.1626503021,
0.6316520572,
-0.0415322147,
-0.456274122,
-0.6326082945,
-0.0323592089,
0.198292926,
0.5131371021,
-0.2960650623,
1.1228827238,
-0.2390413284,
-0.4900467992,
0.4631834626,
0.470004946,
0.6770945191,
-0.2834165096,
-0.0381010771,
-0.2012580037,
0.0697432756,
-0.2912178636,
-0.4800362885,
0.7543675303,
-0.0792155042,
-0.6812999845,
-0.5679316521,
0.9481369853,
-0.5302422047,
-0.6022751927,
0.0911777169,
0.5671554804,
-0.155615285,
0.4178354442,
-0.5071107745,
-0.4792231619,
-0.239634037,
-0.207083419,
0.2530581951,
0.3777957559,
-0.4577788711,
-0.0288226195,
0.3920361102,
0.2536332011,
0.251714617,
0.2879271805,
0.6933372617,
-0.409299165,
-0.607915163,
-1.1517788172,
0.3032111526,
-0.0047385627,
-0.3483224213,
0.7535233498,
0.4820776582,
0.5223507285,
-0.2081329376,
0.3682481945,
0.1175801903,
0.3909672201,
-0.7224985957,
0.7277525067,
-0.006948832,
0.133007735,
-0.0632839501,
-0.9128095508,
-0.8041601181,
0.6618072987,
-0.338650465,
-0.1479305327,
0.8801493645,
0.6067364812,
-0.1500134915,
0.2166852206,
0.0815557316,
0.0571430735,
-0.0404258072,
0.4938777983,
0.6754879951,
-0.7042672634,
0.3446047604,
-0.6461661458,
-0.505582571,
-0.1156331599,
-0.8075031638,
-0.6664584279,
-0.6005797386,
-0.0360976495,
-0.1394483596,
0.1286841929,
0.5487405062,
0.6080588102,
-0.7579838634,
-0.4427581728,
-0.2557394207,
-0.3239038885,
-0.4365310669,
-0.1181357503,
0.4880810678,
-0.7717756629,
-0.4975143373,
0.4021272361,
0.1722349524,
0.1617563516,
0.3018265665,
0.3067710102,
-0.110956192,
0.2262083143,
0.4994904399,
-0.2249506414,
-0.3082393706,
-0.3249641359,
0.2786438763,
-0.349240154,
0.6332109571,
1.0884760618,
-0.6556254625,
0.5262026787,
0.7464060783,
0.2077486515,
0.7031424046,
-0.0445905104,
0.4438084066,
-0.5340354443,
0.2299453318,
0.3015428483,
0.0249921232,
0.075628981,
-0.4930538833,
0.2907661498,
0.2219188362,
-0.3942326903,
-0.3617914021,
0.1924066842,
-0.9564114809,
-0.4401555359,
0.8116531372,
-0.0139545323,
-0.2605813146,
-0.2461634427,
-0.1436236501,
0.4791448116,
0.3777271509,
1.1090153456,
1.0011949539,
-0.1470631361,
0.2902205586,
-0.595045805,
0.5962300301,
0.1694354564,
-0.6735563874,
0.2891453207,
0.2599048018,
0.6205672026,
0.3021334112,
0.6417011619,
-0.5765096545,
0.4573357105,
0.1543134898,
0.1418394595,
-0.1263184249,
-0.3673511446,
-0.6374493837,
-0.0747572482,
-0.1292186975,
-0.0349186175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01293v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01293v2
|
Can MLLMs Perform Text-to-Image In-Context Learning?
| 2024-02-02T10:30:05 | 2024-04-15T21:30:10 |
Yuchen Zeng, Wonjun Kang, Yicong Chen, Hyung Il Koo, Kangwook Lee
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The evolution from Large Language Models (LLMs) to Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) has spurred research into extending In-Context Learning (ICL) to
its multimodal counterpart. Existing such studies have primarily concentrated
on image-to-text ICL. However, the Text-to-Image ICL (T2I-ICL), with its unique
characteristics and potential applications, remains underexplored. To address
this gap, we formally define the task of T2I-ICL and present CoBSAT, the first
T2I-ICL benchmark dataset, encompassing ten tasks. Utilizing our dataset to
benchmark six state-of-the-art MLLMs, we uncover considerable difficulties
MLLMs encounter in solving T2I-ICL. We identify the primary challenges as the
inherent complexity of multimodality and image generation, and show that
strategies such as fine-tuning and Chain-of-Thought prompting help to mitigate
these difficulties, leading to notable improvements in performance. Our code
and dataset are available at https://github.com/UW-Madison-Lee-Lab/CoBSAT.
|
[
-0.3555259705,
-0.7366120815,
0.4468824267,
0.1724603176,
-0.3908882737,
0.2285996079,
-0.3138657808,
-0.6052076221,
-0.6152747869,
0.2091152817,
-0.634771049,
-0.4768412709,
-0.6160149574,
0.0333236791,
-0.3167103827,
0.8267675638,
-0.2726327777,
0.0828491598,
-0.4468719959,
-0.3787052631,
-0.7026743293,
-0.3773172498,
-0.7563877702,
-0.1145616099,
0.4692779183,
0.5988226533,
0.1583414674,
0.1982898265,
0.5954709649,
0.1093516871,
0.1873452365,
0.5242236257,
-0.6034935713,
0.1321520358,
-0.2134532183,
-0.0952098444,
0.0891511962,
-0.2091093212,
0.6918011308,
0.6071403623,
0.3414145708,
0.3432082534,
0.183337912,
0.6766734123,
-0.6244382858,
0.040225707,
-0.843331933,
-0.0320633389,
-0.145371303,
-0.3362467885,
-0.78292346,
0.0431507528,
0.3807951808,
-0.2622924447,
-0.0495203994,
0.5578631163,
0.9253711104,
0.3383542001,
-0.9569579363,
-0.7989133,
-0.4473498464,
0.9287040234,
-0.2787536085,
0.5668922067,
0.2996045351,
0.1638123095,
-0.2359009087,
-0.8020590544,
-0.1589119583,
-0.2075711787,
-0.3050430119,
0.0356431678,
-0.0974334925,
-0.3034334481,
0.2892810404,
-0.0730616525,
-0.5934354067,
0.1528649181,
-0.2682180703,
-0.0625058636,
0.3276655972,
0.1200279668,
0.3275437057,
0.0239338558,
-0.6945276856,
-0.1874212623,
-0.7147948742,
0.3583325148,
-0.3121193647,
0.0602873638,
-0.3849852383,
0.4478197098,
0.3349680305,
0.5486428142,
0.0282576494,
0.041861292,
0.133503899,
-0.1467206627,
-0.1824486405,
-0.074796766,
0.5413100123,
0.3874359429,
-0.064898327,
-0.3481355608,
-0.3328987956,
-0.1331535876,
-0.0009506581,
-0.9275594354,
-0.0786567926,
0.3006134033,
-0.3582486808,
0.0070108422,
-0.1500217468,
-0.5348466039,
-0.2302128673,
-0.2894067168,
0.7217115164,
-0.4426387846,
-0.1384835541,
-0.4742916524,
-0.1552984118,
0.2837746739,
0.286629796,
-0.6112067699,
0.2724916637,
0.4728041589,
0.823616147,
-0.3451513648,
-0.18564336,
-0.6462350488,
0.2994816005,
-0.5720955133,
0.8048937917,
-0.4522481263,
-0.2167366594,
-0.0642056391,
-0.2773793042,
-0.0952492431,
-0.6551988721,
0.1005241945,
-0.4930067062,
0.1267641783,
-0.3722430468,
-0.6723439097,
-0.0401524715,
0.5364778638,
-0.5204731226,
1.1273571253,
0.1153039932,
-0.5723077655,
0.4350925982,
-0.6533194184,
-0.6147946119,
-0.0606133118,
-0.4565232098,
-0.6895092726,
0.2095775008,
0.1613016278,
0.6221852899,
-0.2766101062,
0.5023552775,
-0.2544212937,
-0.5509393811,
0.3700293601,
-0.4261353612,
0.7179656625,
0.1380729228,
-0.4591343999,
0.0336726308,
-0.599031806,
0.2107168585,
0.0639590994,
-0.1686109155,
-0.235601142,
0.0601090267,
0.4541405141,
0.4152848721,
0.1945117861,
-0.4007360041,
0.067472294,
-0.0114594996,
0.4519686997,
0.5942437053,
-0.2478070259,
0.3742775619,
-0.1152321473,
-0.1780151129,
0.1817236543,
-0.0138955917,
-0.407114625,
-0.3006477952,
-0.7208255529,
-0.5106173158,
-0.0162731968,
0.3836518526,
-0.9170052409,
0.0048806113,
-0.1102087423,
-0.4693185389,
-0.3323346972,
0.1582912803,
0.6318436861,
0.619432807,
0.6265490651,
-0.1280718297,
-0.4875188768,
-0.9684432149,
-0.2077163607,
0.1115630865,
0.118937619,
0.5888442397,
0.7317360044,
-0.2015662491,
0.8668429852,
-0.1155313626,
-0.4333218038,
0.0130436495,
0.3999602795,
-0.1726733297,
0.5107125044,
0.4897672236,
-0.857232511,
-0.8096404076,
0.0446868017,
-0.9872485399,
0.0424182937,
-0.0967545211,
0.1088274643,
0.5306708217,
0.8662540913,
-0.2749543488,
0.4101707637,
0.8314580321,
-0.4628164768,
0.2464601398,
-0.4431087971,
0.0610316321,
-1.1812809706,
0.2806478441,
-0.0273113586,
-0.311524123,
-0.6315444708,
-0.065844886,
0.4643268585,
-0.1264887154,
-0.4352384508,
0.8616709113,
-0.6523931026,
-0.2937736511,
-0.1517928988,
-0.1396311224,
-0.0887144953,
0.6545389295,
0.0818368047,
0.8703870177,
0.5282298326,
-0.5621495843,
-0.0107683809,
0.1688301563,
-0.6367318034,
0.5492873192,
-0.2913627923,
0.5238245726,
-0.3660731912,
0.4389305413,
-1.2425186634,
-0.2619068921,
0.1463221461,
-0.0763461441,
0.4482471347,
0.2096690238,
-0.5620391965,
-0.0546535067,
-0.1409001648,
0.7555729747,
0.4098196924,
-0.7963246107,
0.5271213055,
0.1695618182,
0.1857441664,
-0.6435505152,
-0.7806615233,
0.3753663898,
-0.1007723436,
-0.353491962,
0.4496150613,
-0.1587039828,
-0.1592492014,
0.1168693453,
0.1800317317,
-0.0712622702,
0.0805900916,
0.2378907949,
0.1504670084,
0.02214716,
0.3710412383,
0.138479948,
-0.0455223434,
-0.1973259002,
-0.1425563842,
0.4657498896,
-0.2911378741,
-0.3783432543,
-0.4773997068,
0.5305854678,
0.3287685812,
-0.2640097737,
0.3652172089,
0.7490016818,
-0.3249359429,
-0.1711077094,
-0.5238528252,
-0.0446839929,
-0.4359628558,
0.6287687421,
-0.4396666288,
-0.9962948561,
0.094847478,
-0.2467138171,
0.1814512014,
0.154429093,
0.7157214284,
-0.656498313,
0.7936196923,
0.545452714,
0.2159058005,
0.5034067035,
-0.2773979008,
0.0623266846,
-0.8090435266,
-0.5291649699,
-0.1077291816,
-0.5713928938,
-0.52914536,
-0.464032948,
0.6742378473,
-0.1479590833,
-0.2718009949,
0.1336637437,
-0.1747495532,
0.3599548638,
0.4606840014,
0.5118724108,
0.1243703738,
0.2359084934,
-0.0577773377,
0.021579003,
-0.542099297,
-0.3535282314,
0.9974007607,
0.1585668474,
0.5942776799,
0.1099689454,
0.4109937549,
0.3410467505,
0.620942235,
-0.6181932092,
0.5792362094,
-0.3507311642,
-0.6413456202,
-0.2161622196,
-0.0642931536,
-0.864462018,
0.1461258531,
-0.23176229,
-0.7303053737,
0.1065227687,
0.3683568537,
0.0913029164,
0.232831955,
-0.8411953449,
0.8867830038,
-0.5230928063,
-0.7123160362,
-0.2775497139,
-0.8638339639,
0.0398430862,
-0.0244109053,
0.2257261127,
-0.145722881,
-0.296421051,
0.3550665081,
0.0395251736,
0.8636357784,
-0.1710395962,
0.0080261137,
0.2746915519,
0.0796170011,
0.5114112496,
-0.2064335197,
0.0133568151,
0.1936686933,
-0.0748910457,
-0.5811802149,
-0.376489073,
0.4802424908,
-0.5959801078,
-0.1910122484,
-0.1304115653,
-0.792295754,
-0.4679347575,
0.0353552811,
0.3853906691,
0.98702842,
-0.1648608595,
0.4355362058,
0.5883507133,
-0.2233028561,
0.8019703627,
0.0953788236,
-0.1539374739,
-0.340714097,
1.0685870647,
0.0249693692,
0.2846325338,
0.6358708739,
0.0959268585,
-0.4019873738,
-0.5493811369,
-0.6069284678,
-0.1157557294,
-0.8187254667,
-0.1066873521,
-0.4566538632,
-0.0026058843,
0.1030699313,
-0.1989067644,
-0.2011196762,
0.1849282831,
-0.3745789528,
0.4633095264,
-0.0161987282,
0.6686107516,
0.2730048597,
0.0433326587,
-0.5704345703,
0.1475687921,
0.2246759683,
0.4350049198,
0.0856546164,
-0.4517537057,
-0.3837282062,
-0.0714967698,
-0.3093902171,
-0.3761731684,
0.1025862768,
0.4219818413,
0.1947047263,
0.1057547405,
-0.1147084832,
0.9044618011,
-0.5706581473,
0.6416785717,
0.2415308505,
-0.8388413787,
0.3247256279,
-0.1704724282,
0.3403181732,
0.4041062593,
0.3261093795,
-0.5254528522,
-0.2517088652,
-0.2172767222,
-0.6320359111,
0.4511269033,
0.1728569716,
0.1349906623,
0.1381036788,
0.2905028164,
0.2684891224,
0.1666867435,
-0.695387125,
-0.0263154246,
0.0215357654,
-0.5788316727,
-0.2134390026,
-0.3473055065,
0.0104997531,
-0.1933859736,
0.349152118,
-0.3884273767,
0.3172834218,
0.31846717,
-0.6666268706,
-0.15984115,
0.3178582788,
0.8502722979,
0.627006948,
-0.2749386132,
0.2104998827,
0.2722268403,
-0.1560126096,
0.194061473,
-0.1926611513,
-0.1420912296,
-0.2865911722,
0.6415726542,
1.1547077894,
0.3104390204,
-1.0503892899,
0.6504904628,
-0.069058463,
-0.3951328993,
-0.3166627586,
-0.3958073258,
-0.1024215594,
0.5132659078,
0.6346337795,
0.1253960282,
-0.0101994937,
-0.6610711813,
0.2298037112,
0.7257367969,
-0.5982480645,
-0.2542816997,
0.4970528483,
0.1275998354,
-0.2836267054,
0.6710348725,
-0.0670223236,
-0.3061052561,
0.6565105915,
0.7894815207,
0.7074050903,
0.3371156156,
-0.0923581123,
0.2424258292,
0.2688751221,
0.1929421127,
0.1730364859,
-0.1091700494,
-0.5747367144,
-0.2347460538,
-0.1369561851,
-0.5175814033,
0.2693608403,
-0.4041053057,
0.4224416018,
-0.4745827019,
-0.0144186104,
-0.2380058616,
-0.137610957,
-0.8061570525,
0.531429708,
0.431578666,
0.7772983909,
-0.5427802205,
0.8339774609,
0.7898369431,
0.0398422517,
-0.6442162991,
0.1495581269,
-0.1824231744,
-0.8250485659,
0.9791346788,
0.660815835,
-0.1189992726,
0.2382306308,
-0.7340996861,
-0.6094757915,
1.3508102894,
0.3255481124,
-0.6169518828,
-0.0606948882,
0.3152185678,
0.5098053217,
-0.5306177139,
0.310924679,
0.1842281669,
0.3333064318,
0.1053979993,
-0.7759827971,
-0.0039022572,
-0.0408653915,
0.0929089934,
0.0555119775,
-0.8899971843,
0.7494853139,
-0.3637019992,
-0.2752949595,
0.0819753483,
0.5047506094,
0.1600116342,
0.7835017443,
0.6704242826,
0.3924103081,
0.5494804382,
-0.1117493883,
0.8947495222,
-0.0977176949,
0.4770113826,
1.1237117052,
-0.2873764336,
1.1259713173,
0.8535673022,
0.2307159156,
0.433516711,
0.8168260455,
-0.1036385223,
0.7382401228,
-0.0982749835,
-0.2598522604,
-0.3336882591,
-0.2729378939,
0.0093903309,
0.4052428007,
0.5705811381,
-0.2232137024,
-0.3568413258,
0.3325285614,
-0.4775141776,
-0.0151337693,
-0.2828290761,
0.9059231281,
0.071834527,
-0.6526669264,
0.4693852067,
-0.4319603145,
0.614312768,
-0.4218297899,
-0.1411331594,
0.0476894937,
0.2755081654,
-0.0458316915,
-0.9253000617,
0.2068879604,
-0.1263526082,
-0.0183399413,
-0.3135677576,
0.8750534058,
-0.7078648806,
-0.3537691534,
0.3850199878,
0.3385383189,
-0.0434600562,
0.138095811,
-0.6020659208,
0.2077866346,
-0.1985720396,
-0.215532586,
0.3667064905,
0.1549182236,
-0.2951227427,
0.812961936,
0.1891852915,
-0.5384880304,
0.0293173175,
-0.1943917423,
0.6096201539,
-0.4998337328,
-0.1367064416,
-1.0844376087,
0.6400718689,
0.0226291269,
-0.2070342749,
0.3078294694,
0.7731124163,
1.0494872332,
-0.2128364444,
0.8692411184,
-0.3072606027,
0.2204481959,
-0.6818457246,
0.4938120246,
-1.1869311333,
-0.27875036,
-0.0527817979,
-0.4406329393,
-0.3052954674,
0.072990194,
-0.1554181278,
-0.1256960481,
0.9959656596,
0.8464537859,
-0.0827068388,
-0.2068346143,
0.5364096761,
-0.0601051338,
0.4433160424,
0.7799682617,
0.8498948216,
-0.713773489,
0.6752387881,
-0.2420648187,
-0.0340271518,
-0.4194991589,
-1.1208441257,
-1.1950702667,
-0.9382004142,
-0.0658128783,
-0.2966938615,
0.0950271413,
1.3613826036,
0.7178355455,
-0.7359371781,
-0.3855789304,
-0.0202958994,
-0.1583143175,
-0.1758083105,
-0.06081976,
0.5789871216,
-0.490118742,
-0.7430641651,
0.156263113,
0.5350822806,
0.072833322,
-0.0259571467,
-0.114071548,
-0.2717609704,
-0.2168787718,
0.9687879682,
0.0854899511,
-0.7713979483,
-0.4181038737,
-0.1022507846,
-0.5065201521,
0.2309274375,
0.9085105062,
-0.4445653558,
0.4498040974,
0.104101032,
0.9856382012,
0.7331454158,
-0.3093475997,
0.226085186,
-0.9987850785,
0.2360577881,
0.0240919311,
0.1309784353,
0.3890920281,
-0.2006099373,
0.3789696693,
0.1672180742,
-0.3497287333,
-0.7601728439,
0.2522030771,
-1.086230278,
-0.2888208628,
1.0676766634,
0.0282918643,
-0.2327772081,
-0.0521522053,
-0.4515386522,
0.2485188842,
-0.1246337295,
0.6920297146,
0.6792536974,
-0.1079353094,
-0.5266175866,
-0.4632814229,
0.3683215082,
0.5540136099,
-0.9660701156,
-0.1382467449,
0.3229130507,
0.397778064,
-0.2002723664,
0.5516292453,
0.2328389436,
0.2879544199,
-0.2512122393,
-0.1355374604,
-0.1472121179,
-0.3363263905,
0.0493921861,
0.2758190632,
0.0115581593,
-0.0233667903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01806v1
|
HQA-Attack: Toward High Quality Black-Box Hard-Label Adversarial Attack on Text
| 2024-02-02T10:06:43 | 2024-02-02T10:06:43 |
Han Liu, Zhi Xu, Xiaotong Zhang, Feng Zhang, Fenglong Ma, Hongyang Chen, Hong Yu, Xianchao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Black-box hard-label adversarial attack on text is a practical and
challenging task, as the text data space is inherently discrete and
non-differentiable, and only the predicted label is accessible. Research on
this problem is still in the embryonic stage and only a few methods are
available. Nevertheless, existing methods rely on the complex heuristic
algorithm or unreliable gradient estimation strategy, which probably fall into
the local optimum and inevitably consume numerous queries, thus are difficult
to craft satisfactory adversarial examples with high semantic similarity and
low perturbation rate in a limited query budget. To alleviate above issues, we
propose a simple yet effective framework to generate high quality textual
adversarial examples under the black-box hard-label attack scenarios, named
HQA-Attack. Specifically, after initializing an adversarial example randomly,
HQA-attack first constantly substitutes original words back as many as
possible, thus shrinking the perturbation rate. Then it leverages the synonym
set of the remaining changed words to further optimize the adversarial example
with the direction which can improve the semantic similarity and satisfy the
adversarial condition simultaneously. In addition, during the optimizing
procedure, it searches a transition synonym word for each changed word, thus
avoiding traversing the whole synonym set and reducing the query number to some
extent. Extensive experimental results on five text classification datasets,
three natural language inference datasets and two real-world APIs have shown
that the proposed HQA-Attack method outperforms other strong baselines
significantly.
|
[
-0.4525851011,
-1.2056367397,
0.3313826323,
0.0354923122,
-0.2716226876,
0.0400380306,
0.0929240733,
-0.2351816744,
0.2700744569,
0.5877609253,
-0.429204762,
-0.543253541,
-0.6926441193,
0.0530880429,
-0.4326594472,
0.9615584016,
0.1867562383,
-0.2672853172,
0.2776218355,
-0.2914944589,
-0.5467009544,
-0.8324609995,
-0.609164536,
-0.2200999409,
0.6562479734,
0.0868707672,
1.1268922091,
0.7499620914,
0.5794794559,
0.2581835389,
-0.2619686425,
-0.100457266,
-0.7257600427,
0.1901354492,
-0.1685376912,
-0.293838352,
-0.2108965069,
0.1590772718,
0.5567245483,
0.402317673,
-0.2850825191,
-0.1179638878,
-0.0196691211,
0.6915710568,
-0.9986154437,
-0.3781738579,
-0.9851049185,
0.1970955133,
-0.3615074456,
-0.0657953992,
-0.4042988718,
-0.0063681039,
0.053417705,
-0.8342862725,
0.1220539436,
-0.0103235468,
1.3069142103,
0.2103479058,
-0.3407930434,
-0.1377590895,
-0.5308980942,
0.6961679459,
-0.595339179,
0.1315704435,
0.2904217839,
0.2264508158,
-0.6270306706,
-0.8397848606,
-0.736589551,
-0.0968786478,
0.1913438886,
0.1527232677,
-0.477547884,
0.0281783529,
0.1633883566,
0.1650080979,
-0.4907372594,
0.1319942325,
0.1606740803,
-0.0660817251,
0.3534478843,
0.1260228604,
0.3153705299,
-0.4020367861,
-0.773391366,
-0.3637604117,
-0.8211458921,
-0.2372325659,
0.3375769556,
0.0958332047,
0.0335450433,
0.4799923599,
-0.2414904237,
0.5702777505,
0.026741676,
0.0627797768,
-0.0548905879,
-0.3406258821,
-0.3666211367,
-0.069781892,
1.0097064972,
0.0891942531,
-0.2484602779,
-0.4428390563,
-0.2064824402,
0.3672488332,
0.6876348257,
-1.0234857798,
-0.2635165453,
0.2330337316,
-0.1957856119,
-0.4086223543,
-0.0704519376,
-1.1588937044,
-0.4194990695,
-0.1484787017,
0.7345464826,
-0.2129793763,
0.21341528,
0.0442956388,
-0.2205132395,
0.0665925071,
-0.0136777228,
-0.5347733498,
0.1129642278,
0.6008707285,
0.4973594248,
-0.1350566894,
-0.2993687987,
-0.6252539158,
0.2281703055,
-0.4950105548,
0.7468857169,
-0.2752339542,
-0.4215537608,
0.0043643853,
-0.24534747,
0.1125774831,
-0.3773645759,
0.6699056625,
-0.9335973263,
0.2976684868,
-0.0335301198,
-0.4338181913,
-0.049111817,
0.6384857297,
-0.797170043,
0.8928320408,
-0.0124588842,
-0.8158981204,
0.1806241572,
-0.313128233,
-0.4705781639,
0.1861872971,
-0.0392576419,
-0.7084522843,
-0.1254918128,
0.3630497456,
0.381349206,
-0.4140321016,
-0.0928917676,
-0.3398602009,
-0.3175432384,
0.4830708206,
-0.5085694194,
0.9278044701,
0.1162255332,
-0.6783714294,
-0.0493165068,
-0.7032005787,
0.0943564922,
0.4994446635,
-0.2679044902,
-0.6508129239,
0.0295285564,
-0.0947138965,
-0.0055183228,
0.2232302129,
-0.3519813716,
0.2887379527,
-0.7384616733,
0.1453379989,
0.6302548051,
0.3798721135,
0.2936565876,
-0.1843435317,
0.4807432294,
-0.3415339589,
0.3012566566,
0.1330770254,
-0.4766892791,
-0.4099270701,
-0.342823416,
0.5079495907,
0.7495118976,
-1.179858923,
0.4047174752,
-0.0490628667,
-0.482339114,
-0.5964807272,
0.3125018477,
0.6444833279,
0.3291761577,
0.4670501947,
-0.2529759109,
-0.343013525,
-0.6714519262,
-0.3089099824,
-0.0286782458,
-0.1963182986,
0.1871997714,
0.4480025768,
-0.407877624,
0.5985087752,
-0.8226889968,
-0.4267637432,
0.0994342119,
0.344974041,
-0.0160858687,
0.1885783225,
0.5833399892,
-0.9945088029,
-0.2737877369,
-0.2934965491,
-0.8507435918,
0.2448393852,
-0.1469405144,
-0.6538286805,
-0.08625222,
0.350723803,
-0.6652801633,
0.4034657478,
0.4708129466,
-0.366697073,
0.4841553569,
-0.1620271504,
0.2367596328,
-1.2092351913,
-0.182195738,
0.0647458136,
0.297675252,
-0.7500269413,
0.7453464866,
-0.2068005651,
-0.35240677,
-0.5527310967,
0.612754643,
-0.2310027629,
0.423718214,
-0.3884373903,
0.1738021523,
0.0938704982,
0.5861233473,
-0.502402842,
0.6177484989,
0.3446186185,
-0.4902107418,
0.3886157274,
0.3938718736,
-0.0654436722,
0.7529261112,
-0.5944927931,
0.3610865474,
-0.0677986816,
0.2987933159,
-0.823643446,
0.0105460081,
0.4474572539,
-0.6042932868,
0.3386664391,
0.0458683595,
-0.5656445622,
-0.1443982273,
-0.456179738,
0.19662112,
0.3942843676,
-0.7627257705,
0.3893385231,
0.5614385009,
0.0045703594,
-0.8933603168,
-0.5274673104,
0.8684412837,
-0.2376546711,
-0.2177707255,
0.6681596637,
-0.1036246419,
-0.1076315492,
-0.0448685922,
0.1554780304,
-0.3204157054,
0.3766947389,
0.037400607,
0.250764966,
-0.0604285188,
-0.2935763001,
-0.1780333817,
-0.0654389411,
0.0107263234,
-0.2843340039,
0.3362139165,
0.1105730608,
0.0938457698,
-0.6659489274,
0.3653410971,
0.5174691677,
-0.1057981327,
0.8516884446,
0.5401765704,
-0.7450874448,
-0.2197448313,
-0.301785171,
-0.1965981126,
-0.4787886739,
0.3443724215,
-0.3491110206,
-0.3679457009,
0.0685665533,
0.2225170583,
0.1561605483,
0.2734704614,
0.4416936338,
-0.2047216296,
1.0078060627,
0.1545268893,
-0.2472673953,
0.3722842038,
-0.3957736492,
0.0341741033,
-0.6531831622,
-0.0220893435,
-0.8208041787,
-0.0547513478,
-0.6237825155,
-0.1881631315,
0.1823116392,
0.1683345884,
-0.2763694525,
0.5701150894,
-0.5945739746,
0.18774499,
0.4269616008,
0.2586166859,
-0.0869058818,
0.4089586139,
-0.0974435508,
-0.244730711,
-0.6948836446,
-0.3269484639,
0.9866585135,
0.2298689485,
0.6109585762,
0.2590114772,
0.6418082714,
0.4979329705,
0.5729396343,
-0.7019410133,
0.5842564702,
-0.4349447787,
-0.5612108111,
-0.3495414555,
-0.5276339054,
-1.362187624,
0.4325027168,
-0.5547164679,
-0.4092071056,
0.1400462985,
0.0965767428,
0.0051550977,
0.3475644886,
-0.4541359842,
0.8931588531,
0.1143897623,
-0.3371081352,
-0.0104904864,
-0.2959972322,
0.151900813,
-0.1755417585,
0.2140922546,
0.2073606402,
-0.0673732832,
0.8489330411,
-0.2878926694,
0.6727553606,
-0.1280376911,
-0.1888371408,
0.3639059961,
0.1820967197,
0.6961557865,
-0.0539650358,
-0.0196158718,
0.2436750978,
-0.3134275079,
-0.7040321231,
-0.6711859703,
0.5854054093,
-0.5303474069,
-0.4503928423,
-0.4154134691,
-0.1808474958,
-0.1269900948,
0.2306055725,
0.4682925045,
0.603017509,
-0.4156353176,
0.2365126461,
0.6507623196,
-0.1447526366,
0.2185075879,
0.265031904,
0.5019857287,
-0.842302978,
1.2145196199,
-0.0428928174,
0.1099173278,
0.7088482976,
0.2011158317,
-0.4294703305,
-0.7410792708,
-0.7438009381,
0.0799137503,
-0.4643847346,
-0.451651454,
-0.4118049145,
0.0386403501,
-0.3235304654,
-0.2331620753,
-0.2075397074,
-0.0978909284,
-0.3011195958,
0.2269757241,
0.0820404738,
0.3586581051,
0.4310780466,
0.5303644538,
-0.5905851126,
0.8744639754,
0.5878192782,
0.1159547791,
0.0440266393,
-0.3408649266,
-0.1738864034,
0.0961274207,
-0.6955887675,
-1.2350729704,
0.4438639879,
-0.0776216686,
0.37395823,
0.2632382512,
0.3271273375,
0.3363777995,
-0.4448158443,
0.617780745,
0.2698414922,
-0.6098920703,
0.3293561339,
-0.2598726451,
0.3828647137,
0.6579493284,
0.365837574,
-0.1632356495,
-0.508669138,
-0.7202026844,
-0.8588684201,
0.209829703,
0.681683898,
0.0645948425,
-0.0455496684,
0.4843017161,
-0.3200318515,
0.2242051512,
-0.6737408042,
-0.598737061,
-0.2568593025,
-0.1600212902,
0.0834845677,
-0.1305525452,
-0.2838170826,
0.0660172328,
0.9332512021,
-0.0070898049,
0.1721256077,
0.0970356986,
-0.0719003677,
0.2049833387,
0.6088818312,
0.097074002,
0.2857624292,
-0.0892772675,
0.0555665828,
0.2136482,
-0.7394762039,
0.4802363515,
0.5052061677,
-0.5761081576,
-0.0662105903,
0.1592290998,
0.5591991544,
0.3353482187,
-0.5185462832,
0.5124158859,
-0.3219415843,
-0.2162562758,
0.0081604719,
-0.1796971262,
-0.1668429077,
-0.1071741655,
0.4934824705,
-0.2805136442,
0.2257695496,
-0.4551442266,
0.3882903159,
0.7205781341,
-0.6551365256,
0.0340136662,
0.5900755525,
0.160558477,
-0.5008225441,
0.4481197596,
-0.5361380577,
-0.707164228,
0.7075087428,
0.4639226198,
0.8087156415,
-0.3409648836,
0.2181419134,
0.1002404988,
0.4195938408,
0.0462419279,
-0.0271139219,
0.1973979026,
-0.6055451035,
-0.1663422137,
-0.6236793995,
-0.4448116124,
0.521637857,
-0.6146329045,
-0.035132125,
-0.6237413883,
-0.2671563625,
0.2391808927,
0.1626708657,
-0.3920270801,
0.4768261611,
-0.2022771984,
0.5515098572,
-0.2933848798,
0.5424845219,
0.7182224989,
-0.2945865691,
-0.3668774366,
0.1797661036,
-0.0528650992,
-0.3824228644,
0.2621474564,
-0.0731877089,
-0.0965376124,
-0.1564217806,
-0.3360869884,
-0.4724838734,
0.6896790266,
0.2232785374,
-0.4078785181,
-0.1969688386,
-0.0897435173,
0.5101171136,
0.1114330068,
-0.3251120448,
0.5785758495,
0.3817133307,
-0.1299354583,
-0.1923205405,
0.2924960256,
-0.054087583,
-0.0679936484,
0.4798571467,
-0.3716952503,
0.5047653317,
0.0237637628,
-0.4876392186,
0.148165077,
0.855704546,
0.1529434174,
0.3753809333,
0.5008408427,
0.9030259848,
0.3851473033,
0.0635084435,
1.1239129305,
-0.1456887275,
0.2419911325,
0.9184249043,
-0.1639159918,
1.0011209249,
0.1531023383,
-0.1622046828,
0.3412770629,
0.4127420485,
-0.1911902577,
0.4415813684,
0.3650988042,
-0.4096322954,
0.055237636,
-0.0837945342,
-0.338852644,
0.3099464476,
0.3431916833,
0.1297899038,
-0.1494220197,
0.1277054101,
0.2978815138,
0.4326833785,
-0.1259711236,
0.8876909018,
0.0341198817,
-0.5345494151,
1.0830225945,
0.2819873691,
0.8051594496,
-0.5143461823,
-0.0181566365,
-0.1188728213,
0.1056588665,
0.2261483669,
-0.4489134848,
-0.0956515595,
-0.0254030786,
-0.1707758754,
0.1462181211,
0.4539878368,
-0.1908237487,
-0.2731410265,
0.3732222617,
0.0952413678,
-0.1517176777,
-0.2099111676,
-1.0451620817,
-0.2983501256,
-0.2435363531,
-0.2436450273,
0.5694726706,
0.276073575,
0.176745832,
0.3730736673,
0.7717208266,
0.3442878723,
-0.200072825,
-0.0680161268,
0.5835589767,
-0.6650951505,
-0.6210134029,
-0.649915576,
-0.0993748829,
-0.2331417948,
-0.3235614598,
0.5852056146,
0.2952222526,
0.6483150125,
0.2674053013,
0.5617640018,
0.2822104096,
0.2006861418,
-0.6850478053,
0.8930540085,
-0.585704267,
0.0978935584,
-0.4835692048,
-0.8298114538,
-0.2738667428,
0.12333446,
0.2151734531,
-0.2452550679,
0.8455071449,
0.7687221766,
0.1166664958,
-0.2588342726,
0.2542908192,
0.3534698784,
0.5689148903,
0.516366601,
0.5816712379,
-0.882851243,
0.9657467008,
-0.2674212456,
-0.4032481909,
-0.138729468,
-0.8915822506,
-0.856908679,
-0.4850284755,
-0.2907770872,
-0.8063792586,
0.5180087686,
0.4742410481,
0.6730751395,
-0.5854182839,
0.0581239499,
0.1834893823,
0.2745320499,
-0.2944314778,
-0.3072954714,
0.7461989522,
-0.059301924,
-0.5133548975,
0.4841687381,
0.0468264967,
0.2393791229,
-0.1498041004,
0.1665540785,
-0.2708359063,
0.3895630538,
0.5815379024,
0.5783082843,
-0.4178979993,
0.0066654892,
-0.3115734756,
-0.5152307749,
-0.0078118457,
0.7313854098,
-0.7314400673,
0.3585540056,
0.3758132458,
1.2008492947,
0.2529812753,
0.1414970607,
0.3255110383,
-0.7243968844,
0.1605089158,
0.1976311058,
0.1737744361,
0.3911333382,
-0.5595389605,
0.1016820669,
0.3951499462,
-0.2780377567,
-0.9446231723,
0.1191317067,
-0.8665906191,
-0.7524602413,
1.0590469837,
-0.0240757577,
-0.4115910232,
-0.1844182611,
-0.2264603078,
0.1414116025,
-0.3862157464,
1.1384855509,
0.4858797193,
0.4090732336,
0.5121186972,
-0.5359473228,
0.5332251787,
0.4529175758,
-1.2117779255,
0.0241264347,
0.3638986349,
-0.0017614468,
0.2838929296,
0.4096466899,
-0.1019883901,
0.432150811,
0.1730277389,
-0.2050667703,
0.0659107566,
-0.4843223095,
-0.3430205286,
0.7141166329,
-0.2267903239,
-0.3375070095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01805v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01805v3
|
Can LLMs perform structured graph reasoning?
| 2024-02-02T09:45:33 | 2024-04-18T12:04:12 |
Palaash Agrawal, Shavak Vasania, Cheston Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated various reasoning
capabilities through language-based prompts alone, particularly in unstructured
task settings (tasks purely based on language semantics). However, LLMs often
struggle with structured tasks, because of the inherent incompatibility of
input representation. Reducing structured tasks to uni-dimensional language
semantics often renders the problem trivial. Keeping the trade-off between LLM
compatibility and structure complexity in mind, we design various graph
reasoning tasks as a proxy to semi-structured tasks in this paper, in order to
test the ability to navigate through representations beyond plain text in
various LLMs. Particularly, we design 10 distinct problems of graph traversal,
each representing increasing levels of complexity, and benchmark 5 different
instruct-finetuned LLMs (GPT-4, GPT-3.5, Claude-2, Llama-2 and Palm-2) on the
aforementioned tasks. Further, we analyse the performance of models across
various settings such as varying sizes of graphs as well as different forms of
k-shot prompting. We highlight various limitations, biases and properties of
LLMs through this benchmarking process, such as an inverse relation to the
average degrees of freedom of traversal per node in graphs, the overall
negative impact of k-shot prompting on graph reasoning tasks, and a positive
response bias which prevents LLMs from identifying the absence of a valid
solution. Finally, we introduce a new prompting technique specially designed
for graph traversal tasks (PathCompare), which demonstrates a notable increase
in the performance of LLMs in comparison to standard prompting techniques such
as Chain-of-Thought (CoT).
|
[
-0.1551716477,
-1.0414179564,
1.131541729,
0.1726788431,
-0.351372391,
0.4626277685,
-0.0959698036,
-0.4198193848,
-0.1496435702,
0.3971236944,
-0.7770922184,
-0.8140369654,
-0.46791026,
0.4812817276,
-0.2527048886,
0.5474339128,
-0.5579059124,
-0.0567464232,
-0.388672471,
0.0609734617,
-0.5713231564,
-0.4368469417,
-0.6137271523,
-0.7319362164,
0.6342383027,
0.1468363255,
0.5380758643,
0.4188611209,
0.0890997946,
0.3419997096,
-0.3470081091,
0.4779256582,
-0.4458887875,
0.1595672071,
-0.2190217823,
-0.3457126021,
-0.2313694954,
0.0927058235,
0.6762315631,
1.1918820143,
0.2413578928,
-0.1063159406,
0.2935848534,
0.4872097075,
-0.3560581505,
0.3677607775,
-0.4430369437,
0.0708116964,
-0.1186267883,
-0.114446409,
-0.6149235368,
-0.1231501773,
-0.1595506519,
-0.6746656895,
-0.1136333421,
0.3378046751,
0.7569599152,
0.3224335611,
-0.6461090446,
-0.3225415945,
-0.6480100155,
0.3102692962,
-0.4975704253,
0.4863103628,
0.0979205668,
0.1004435346,
-0.5313873291,
-1.0077881813,
-0.313020587,
-0.3625772595,
-0.1081464514,
0.0485050902,
-0.2102222592,
0.3632198274,
0.5618203878,
-0.0203053337,
-0.5623420477,
0.2870097756,
-0.0705282241,
-0.3176407218,
0.3175817728,
0.2582882941,
0.2151040882,
-0.3204549551,
-0.2114142925,
-0.0539301075,
-0.7980857491,
0.3036525548,
0.4460315704,
0.3961102664,
0.0691472888,
0.6587190032,
-0.3157059848,
0.9759970307,
-0.0622200631,
-0.0778875798,
-0.0167564694,
-0.284766227,
-0.1379093528,
-0.1163437366,
0.7513360381,
0.1309112161,
0.6956928372,
-0.145917654,
-0.1946234703,
0.1309403032,
-0.015209794,
-0.5535128117,
-0.4981794655,
0.1344311237,
-0.2029965818,
-0.0142694805,
-0.2878448665,
-0.2782864273,
-0.2426128536,
-0.1259471029,
0.3181079626,
-0.386775136,
0.202504158,
0.2750132382,
-0.1860189885,
-0.0809235871,
0.4669143856,
-0.4841835201,
0.2507552803,
0.5119658709,
0.8568890095,
-0.2083527595,
-0.2578110695,
-0.6374857426,
0.1745570302,
-0.3742970228,
1.0986694098,
-0.757283628,
-0.5715048909,
-0.072309114,
0.1501957625,
-0.3490744829,
-0.4122304022,
0.432669729,
-0.4519543946,
-0.0846361443,
-0.3995876014,
-0.6034469008,
-0.1826948225,
0.6736716628,
-0.356084615,
0.9850143194,
0.3383669555,
-0.6683751941,
0.0442119204,
-0.3623291254,
-0.57642591,
0.1092279851,
-0.3847746551,
-0.057934884,
-0.2519919574,
0.2920671403,
0.3351143003,
-0.0265806373,
0.1071259305,
-0.4311700165,
-0.5875513554,
-0.0349505283,
-0.1554737985,
0.5974914432,
-0.1230239123,
-0.1489509195,
0.2784774601,
-0.5427918434,
0.2484394014,
0.2411932498,
-0.4173765182,
-0.1517713964,
0.0516708456,
-0.4692279696,
0.127215445,
0.0723088458,
-0.4766998291,
0.5138397813,
-0.4060791135,
0.69075948,
0.8515333533,
0.0217380654,
0.2232426256,
0.0072021093,
0.5717440248,
0.0187934469,
-0.1475091577,
-0.0844643191,
-0.4940241873,
-0.4253199399,
-0.2597994804,
0.1720184088,
0.550555706,
-0.8373934031,
-0.0614996776,
-0.1315217167,
-0.2340289503,
0.018723784,
0.2656697035,
0.4877883196,
0.8427090049,
0.2419708371,
-0.0716432333,
-0.3042083383,
-0.583355844,
-0.1785853952,
-0.2248194069,
-0.1274193376,
0.6066443324,
0.517665565,
-0.189935863,
0.5986819863,
-0.5886420012,
0.1289171875,
-0.2829357386,
0.0461262502,
0.3450317979,
-0.0282064676,
0.2151748985,
-0.366220206,
-0.4534161389,
-0.1905807853,
-0.8410325646,
-0.3639079034,
0.1370920241,
0.1075639278,
0.0136328125,
0.8030019403,
-0.8551256061,
0.3341189325,
0.3849922419,
-0.3318819106,
0.5887019038,
-0.25513798,
-0.1502675712,
-0.6122381091,
-0.1003472134,
-0.0697982982,
-0.4556642771,
-0.3652095795,
-0.0567542464,
-0.0961877853,
-0.1603157669,
-0.4323315322,
0.5756134391,
-0.6578122973,
-0.2953823805,
-0.2253930718,
0.3680087924,
0.245940879,
0.5511891246,
0.0390962958,
0.7258203626,
0.539978385,
-0.606148839,
0.5112076998,
0.2995671928,
-0.1921965927,
0.4342549145,
-0.9333753586,
0.4407015145,
-0.2034668028,
0.6535203457,
-1.2392507792,
-0.0347408541,
0.2728035748,
-0.1462195963,
0.3436738253,
-0.3143512607,
-0.7401309609,
-0.6319102645,
-0.1227237955,
0.4128912985,
0.3946788013,
-0.5069451928,
0.5166367292,
-0.1801677793,
0.0712909028,
-0.3068050444,
-0.2885198593,
0.0812586993,
-0.0222573131,
-0.8301191926,
0.3138810992,
-0.0478542782,
-0.220259279,
0.0206225757,
-0.2556339502,
0.3686577976,
0.01953982,
0.3188664615,
0.3263866305,
-0.0926282629,
-0.064300105,
-0.0246570539,
-0.203570798,
0.1523732245,
-0.5458611846,
0.6228408813,
-0.2068503052,
-0.7770939469,
-0.164692387,
0.1801217645,
0.124782078,
-0.119762443,
0.2044858485,
0.1437388808,
-0.1538767219,
-0.225360781,
-0.1577882916,
-0.0380057953,
-0.4874163866,
0.1878682971,
-0.5857598782,
-1.1476165056,
0.5644914508,
-0.6104412079,
-0.2087070942,
0.1212858707,
0.4634836316,
-0.4286758602,
1.3480374813,
0.1423681825,
0.1755200773,
0.1341439188,
-0.3617796004,
0.2938432395,
-0.7895606756,
-0.4078820944,
-0.4848861992,
-0.3657136261,
-0.6081346273,
-0.3308198154,
0.5081401467,
0.2441409677,
-0.4008139372,
0.1494800001,
-0.516445756,
0.5523484945,
0.3944845498,
0.1251053512,
0.3194575012,
-0.2096360177,
-0.6231475472,
0.3640652895,
-0.7467838526,
-0.6000236869,
0.6365301013,
0.1555647999,
0.8692050576,
-0.3221756518,
0.5583165884,
0.0811853483,
-0.0034962716,
-0.8635683656,
0.8890457749,
-0.0425493754,
-0.3215942681,
-0.3020425737,
-0.2863174677,
-1.077549696,
0.1063202545,
0.0844815671,
-1.0063621998,
-0.0776593983,
0.0088776089,
-0.0878434107,
0.4074191153,
-0.4949881732,
0.8301849961,
-0.0634197667,
-0.2607738674,
0.1877234131,
-0.7067643404,
0.120347023,
0.1663470268,
0.042951867,
-0.2556088269,
0.0947574377,
0.3499445617,
-0.4599301219,
0.9798301458,
-0.1561271399,
0.058424864,
0.372069627,
0.3085625172,
0.8689687848,
-0.1802510321,
0.105389595,
0.0899240226,
0.102868557,
-0.3798441887,
-0.7960577607,
0.4687708914,
-0.5605475903,
-0.8655396104,
-0.2618494928,
-0.7726676464,
-0.5392950177,
0.4233760834,
0.2469076514,
0.4549246728,
0.1284109503,
-0.134292081,
0.5990813971,
0.1159257665,
0.2007516772,
0.2786293924,
-0.1731917113,
0.1409466714,
0.4979016483,
0.18124412,
0.2685981095,
0.3385429084,
0.2042054087,
-0.5703884363,
-0.9841185212,
-0.4776070416,
0.2027433515,
-0.9736072421,
-0.1509480625,
-0.4455848932,
-0.3258002102,
-0.1697245687,
-0.2030549943,
-0.0010326613,
-0.2483966947,
-0.2534873188,
-0.2790423334,
0.0407262966,
0.9121385217,
0.1759209335,
0.1499413848,
-0.6023042202,
0.2029460967,
0.2812315226,
0.3048912287,
-0.1129915938,
-0.2928480208,
0.2512099147,
-0.0716890171,
-0.3654140532,
-0.9624233842,
-0.0650454685,
-0.1890248805,
0.5535314679,
0.2858354449,
0.0764997527,
0.647361517,
-0.7315129638,
0.7149272561,
-0.1219415367,
-0.7957054377,
0.5956038833,
-0.5725405216,
0.1360182762,
0.3913864791,
0.4455871284,
-0.2474751323,
-0.5102694035,
-0.4215933084,
-0.5020366311,
0.444740802,
0.1797270626,
0.0404897705,
-0.1534202695,
0.7299449444,
-0.2868939638,
-0.0129057979,
-0.5777192712,
-0.0390651859,
-0.2282675356,
-0.0348511301,
-0.061914131,
-0.0710722804,
-0.1274108738,
-0.290449053,
0.2687534988,
-0.4116843045,
0.0241522081,
0.3400916755,
0.0708393306,
0.0486474261,
0.1567994952,
0.3153163195,
0.6836862564,
-0.0230518579,
0.5012423992,
0.2933163047,
-0.0329879187,
0.3176066279,
0.0838555694,
-0.2187814116,
-0.1057943627,
0.715326786,
0.6908468008,
0.2767166793,
-0.6178100705,
0.2714245021,
0.2003207803,
-0.3801506162,
0.1465327293,
0.2109639049,
0.4271046519,
0.4365528226,
-0.0403383933,
-0.4793854654,
0.0095569864,
-0.6184754968,
-0.187672317,
0.6959792972,
-0.3119827509,
-0.2088353038,
0.6555535793,
0.0022153428,
-0.5882450342,
0.9533937573,
-0.3602423072,
-0.5825318694,
0.5022246838,
0.7321770191,
0.3887962997,
0.076502651,
0.1568286568,
0.1073679999,
0.1246736944,
0.0085581271,
0.3044027984,
-0.1733371317,
-0.7123993039,
-0.5634871125,
-0.2830602229,
-0.5521267056,
-0.0669503212,
-0.2475751042,
0.0545453392,
-0.5168831348,
-0.1455061883,
0.0135365641,
0.1541606486,
-0.5399823785,
0.1052144542,
0.08913856,
1.0608750582,
-0.7232046723,
0.5602452159,
0.8921371698,
-0.2620315552,
-1.1299551725,
-0.179745242,
0.078006871,
-1.0657262802,
0.6827509403,
0.2029906362,
-0.381649226,
0.0945123658,
-0.7586057186,
-0.3976047635,
1.0955997705,
0.5427346826,
-0.3381748497,
-0.3292711079,
0.3172665536,
0.4878458679,
-0.2457459569,
0.1729788482,
0.4699908197,
0.5759729743,
0.6104366779,
-0.8496658206,
0.2931300402,
-0.0964503512,
-0.0065647722,
0.1137479618,
-0.5981954932,
0.9302586913,
-0.2621189356,
-0.2932467461,
-0.0543345101,
0.4026479423,
0.755125761,
0.4767401516,
0.6477862,
0.3989897072,
1.006906867,
-0.1163542271,
1.1881750822,
-0.208203733,
0.0751159489,
0.871493578,
-0.5711650252,
0.4776743054,
0.4489375353,
-0.2553108931,
0.8685877323,
1.0785645247,
0.0900715888,
0.247344166,
0.4740293622,
-0.0828207657,
-0.6122327447,
-0.3241525888,
-0.0982041359,
0.3117802143,
0.1322387606,
-0.0310653131,
-0.4643796682,
-0.2522796392,
0.0110965976,
0.1439860016,
-0.3179336786,
0.5081840158,
0.4011532068,
-0.6792655587,
0.4964512587,
-0.0322096534,
0.2160152942,
-0.7026165128,
-0.1114498079,
-0.0997759849,
-0.0557228327,
-0.2454155535,
-1.1424120665,
0.1591470391,
-0.2220343947,
0.0771981627,
-0.3940755725,
1.0749051571,
-0.0426386483,
-0.3774117231,
0.4690992236,
0.7678496838,
0.2962598503,
-0.1752889752,
-0.6226728559,
0.1980926991,
-0.2572551072,
-0.3099372089,
0.2689800858,
0.5619680285,
-0.2782649994,
0.8871090412,
0.6277253628,
0.0498948917,
-0.1106614396,
0.3613665402,
1.1191754341,
-0.5569444299,
-0.4494413435,
-0.9727535248,
0.0504742227,
0.0875445828,
0.1345031857,
0.7847210169,
0.5468438268,
0.7649012208,
0.2736703753,
0.4652543068,
0.337944746,
0.1276339442,
-0.8241275549,
0.1437077671,
-0.4135860205,
0.1438525915,
-0.320151329,
-0.7965087891,
-0.0989234224,
0.5458297729,
-0.5047940612,
0.2859328091,
0.8892760873,
0.6545339823,
-0.1071878225,
-0.0168028902,
0.2590748072,
0.1427744925,
0.4206592441,
0.9071803689,
1.1122045517,
0.1678460836,
0.6264706254,
0.1706538647,
0.0329252221,
0.0760147274,
-0.9830568433,
-1.2489902973,
-0.3377657235,
-0.2017774582,
-0.5097264647,
0.0634329692,
0.4824810028,
0.6594822407,
-0.2748962641,
-0.0066536372,
-0.2608278096,
0.5583235025,
0.0482834689,
-0.1779525876,
0.3941522837,
-0.2471189052,
-0.5782390237,
0.6337360144,
0.4706966281,
0.2263073474,
-0.3164322078,
-0.0554070845,
-0.0399591699,
0.013131273,
0.5997534394,
0.2783612907,
-0.594964087,
-0.6659746766,
0.1797301173,
0.0042974078,
0.2120696008,
0.9749204516,
-0.7963095307,
0.2144395262,
0.5175843835,
0.3537454605,
0.8342555761,
0.0577819459,
0.2500988245,
-0.7619383335,
0.0129251238,
0.2669130564,
0.5668407679,
0.2234008312,
-0.2863800228,
0.5028078556,
0.4751253128,
-0.4313866794,
-0.7381386161,
0.5602304935,
-0.9967160821,
-0.3894136548,
1.3173049688,
-0.23569116,
-0.3060521483,
-0.2898973227,
-0.154721126,
0.1779599041,
0.0223046374,
0.2347133756,
0.9458141327,
-0.6538066268,
-0.1169811413,
-0.4042446911,
0.1709095985,
0.1020958647,
-0.758975625,
-0.016210191,
0.5287948847,
0.3981950581,
-0.0190050919,
1.0316227674,
0.0290364493,
-0.0994492769,
-0.0183559656,
-0.547968626,
-0.583024621,
-0.4152545631,
-0.0318461917,
0.1149485335,
0.1956205368,
0.0604580864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01267v1
|
The Human and the Mechanical: logos, truthfulness, and ChatGPT
| 2024-02-02T09:41:51 | 2024-02-02T09:41:51 |
Anastasia Giannakidou, Alda Mari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The paper addresses the question of whether it is appropriate to talk about
`mechanical minds' at all, and whether ChatGPT models can indeed be thought of
as realizations of that. Our paper adds a semantic argument to the current
debate. The act of human assertion requires the formation of a veridicality
judgment. Modification of assertions with modals (John must be at home) and the
use of subjective elements (John is obviously at home) indicate that the
speaker is manipulating her judgments and, in a cooperative context, intends
her epistemic state to be transparent to the addressee. Veridicality judgments
are formed on the basis of two components: (i) evidence that relates to reality
(exogenous evidence) and (ii) endogenous evidence, such as preferences and
private beliefs. `Mechanical minds' lack these two components: (i) they do not
relate to reality and (ii) do not have endogenous evidence. Therefore they lack
the ability to form a belief about the world and a veridicality judgments
altogether. They can only mimic that judgment, but the output is not ground in
the very foundations for it.
|
[
-0.3055038452,
-0.5080860853,
0.5370446444,
-0.2388246804,
-0.0533227958,
0.4871116281,
-0.106818594,
-0.7924432158,
0.2892505229,
0.1534554213,
-0.5881017447,
0.1937269717,
-0.5094261765,
0.2989219129,
-0.0203142185,
0.7529703975,
0.0462756008,
-0.0800493434,
-0.04329722,
-0.2586233318,
-0.1920193285,
-0.5592564344,
-0.1286811978,
-0.4854031205,
0.3865005374,
-0.045148693,
1.008738637,
0.4637054205,
0.2865645289,
0.5493178368,
-0.0415055603,
0.0224442426,
-0.1749630123,
0.3571108878,
-0.4310584366,
-0.6583289504,
0.0230279732,
0.6107065678,
0.3565852642,
0.6984550953,
-0.1118504331,
0.2414792627,
-0.0922475383,
0.6480258703,
-0.4054279625,
0.1869251877,
-0.6150404215,
0.4186303914,
0.1144148335,
-0.1767698675,
-0.2952551842,
-0.5301857591,
0.2434428483,
-0.7135782242,
0.3529747128,
0.2993576527,
1.3491482735,
0.5543295741,
-0.5569782257,
-0.1936910003,
-0.8661456704,
0.6655516028,
-0.0974079147,
0.3531369269,
0.4376967251,
0.4457615912,
-0.0725403205,
-0.9232147336,
-0.8486886621,
-0.5094038844,
-0.0476647019,
0.7246157527,
-0.2944971025,
0.0692636743,
0.6655548215,
0.4656083286,
-0.372528553,
-0.3311976492,
-0.7860960364,
-0.3953014314,
0.2882355154,
0.1255937666,
0.5406893492,
-0.1662778705,
-0.6868151426,
0.0066718697,
-0.5598528981,
-0.0326144584,
0.3728651404,
-0.191212073,
-0.1301999539,
0.7550336123,
-0.1710789353,
0.4811067879,
0.1385184079,
-0.0280930065,
0.1709133089,
-0.1920929849,
-0.1998490095,
0.1154843643,
0.6157582402,
0.467001915,
0.4471110404,
-0.5017728806,
0.063311249,
0.6818159223,
0.8275069594,
-0.7350055575,
0.0017545177,
-0.1154374406,
-0.5104799867,
-0.3748908043,
0.4777635634,
0.0402207822,
-0.318772465,
-0.7709978223,
0.1506074816,
-0.3904205561,
-0.2950586677,
0.2185067087,
-0.3903657794,
0.0915177092,
0.511084199,
-0.6850656271,
0.311255008,
0.6739379168,
0.5263986588,
0.4684355855,
-0.2576147914,
0.2098137885,
0.3080259264,
-0.3583534956,
1.0131138563,
-0.5052525401,
-0.5358330607,
-0.1419052333,
0.2786312103,
-0.1293240339,
-0.5259895921,
0.6099140644,
-0.1740222722,
0.6142368317,
-0.7427649498,
-0.3534158766,
-0.6291790009,
0.0653324425,
-0.3307001293,
0.788803637,
0.12789765,
-0.65574193,
0.5795636177,
-0.6147614121,
-0.5381999016,
0.0523715504,
-0.6900416613,
0.0558683611,
0.4532635212,
-0.6882684827,
0.1865550429,
-0.2981471419,
0.2169013619,
-0.6137242913,
-0.1468152404,
0.7880416512,
-0.543069303,
0.8115153313,
0.4338132143,
-0.4326718152,
-0.512263298,
-0.5725419521,
0.0082868962,
-0.0638280362,
-0.366050452,
-0.1597873718,
0.332126826,
-0.0380331464,
0.5803557634,
0.072595939,
-0.9900179505,
0.3035582304,
-0.6020340919,
0.7759886384,
1.0136271715,
-0.1658333689,
0.3643120825,
-0.9193173051,
0.2625806034,
-0.2303209454,
0.1764788926,
0.29850021,
-0.7188289165,
-0.6412267685,
-0.2014322132,
-0.1072736606,
0.5479233861,
-0.5837591887,
0.2175551653,
-0.2069316655,
-0.4850355983,
-0.3119010329,
-0.2877354026,
0.5226026773,
0.6219435334,
-0.1611411572,
-0.6577287316,
-0.5035607219,
-1.1867059469,
-0.6129585505,
-0.69533813,
-0.1870671809,
0.3197612464,
0.5921809673,
0.086491093,
0.902122736,
-0.3549465835,
0.1662706882,
0.4027655125,
0.4949451089,
0.3548210561,
0.4320669174,
0.4654553533,
-0.8667882681,
-0.1621543616,
0.2097352743,
-1.195217967,
0.0664509907,
-0.1327179372,
-0.0248858854,
0.0778328106,
0.0445668995,
-0.9968125224,
0.5614215732,
-0.0018865026,
-0.7974225283,
0.6818313003,
-0.1398899406,
0.2243810594,
-1.0066421032,
-0.060973309,
-0.1311808079,
-0.4060594141,
-0.4504368007,
-0.1412275136,
-0.2772871554,
-0.036818698,
-0.3759151697,
0.3494523764,
-0.3534461558,
-0.1406706572,
-0.3485451341,
-0.0720059276,
0.0653813109,
0.3825806379,
0.1204762682,
0.6577026844,
0.2746396661,
-0.6356239915,
0.363887012,
0.1546578705,
-0.156908229,
0.9920178056,
-0.7019331455,
0.0797267929,
-0.3541207016,
0.4145987928,
-0.8323785067,
-0.4732305706,
0.7487192154,
-0.7139520049,
0.261742264,
0.1825187355,
-0.4664247632,
-0.3221312463,
-0.2070771754,
0.0835613832,
0.7876546979,
-0.0124381073,
0.7378044128,
0.5648511052,
-0.1460303813,
-0.1799165308,
-0.8577528,
0.2151288092,
-0.0050502834,
-0.9538539052,
0.506264329,
-0.1224458069,
-0.6980773807,
-0.0006303326,
-0.4284312725,
-0.3228426278,
0.0803916529,
0.7236645222,
0.3584020138,
-0.1288706958,
0.2373747379,
-0.1998245269,
-0.3916711211,
0.308373481,
-0.2130144387,
-0.0006794524,
-0.2791252732,
-0.3814761937,
-0.8345708251,
0.2217425853,
0.7054804564,
0.1399683654,
0.174351722,
0.4423933625,
-0.4685251713,
0.5698708892,
-0.639336288,
-0.17644234,
-0.463750124,
0.0294941645,
-0.1854179054,
-0.663511157,
0.2367841154,
-0.1732279211,
-0.0987923443,
0.4812819362,
0.9947831631,
-0.6879344583,
0.590870738,
0.2896524966,
0.2049673647,
0.2386525124,
-0.1617589295,
0.0944504365,
-0.8488475084,
-0.1772574037,
-0.979803741,
-0.2670067847,
-0.9479644895,
-0.3010940254,
0.2924070656,
-0.5125765204,
-0.7250038385,
0.2891845703,
-0.652816236,
0.350597769,
0.387005955,
0.4934748709,
0.3358494341,
-0.0806361958,
-0.1212743521,
-0.2313465327,
-0.6424356699,
-0.9943545461,
0.647094965,
0.1722480059,
0.6258343458,
0.370195657,
0.1641087979,
0.3259765804,
0.5182933211,
-0.6852595806,
0.4076469839,
0.2209434062,
-1.2870907784,
0.1816112846,
-0.1004650295,
-0.944211483,
0.3299202323,
-0.1089437306,
-1.0412787199,
0.4990871251,
-0.0171723124,
-0.2956948876,
0.2640639842,
-0.5599910021,
0.514511764,
-0.0670624077,
-0.5241103768,
-0.4382799268,
-0.9448710084,
0.6599237919,
0.2775384784,
0.2440703213,
-0.2698242068,
-0.1806310415,
0.7616925836,
-0.565084219,
1.2981162071,
0.0671702474,
0.0051912391,
0.4968019426,
0.0650509149,
0.4350768328,
-0.0946587026,
0.2814415991,
-0.2520572543,
0.0907832831,
-0.3845077455,
-0.7638747692,
0.0419152752,
-0.9043786526,
-0.6871504188,
-0.8181783557,
-0.2676894665,
-0.0933134034,
-0.0014809337,
0.412550807,
0.5776145458,
-0.3090646565,
0.134811461,
0.7772091627,
-0.1182797998,
0.4083269536,
0.4460626543,
-0.0122717079,
-0.2322771996,
0.8148710728,
0.2243208885,
0.4767222404,
0.1458739042,
0.1149140969,
-0.349739641,
0.3261051178,
-0.1941435337,
0.3243564367,
-0.7412692904,
0.1761941165,
-0.4207942188,
0.0554471835,
0.1676575989,
-0.1655104607,
-0.5218454003,
-0.6856695414,
0.1203929037,
-0.0000888265,
0.0831815228,
0.7660835981,
-0.0874605402,
0.0597387329,
-0.5738097429,
0.5861579776,
0.4332555234,
0.005617952,
-0.3619220853,
-0.5263407826,
-0.0832623392,
0.124199301,
-0.7075338364,
-0.7592312098,
-0.3471178114,
-0.0382703431,
0.5734843016,
0.5896968246,
0.1115503088,
0.5406951308,
-0.5128359795,
0.6566041112,
0.5027524233,
-0.8234455585,
0.2115924805,
-0.4172092378,
-0.1620411873,
0.3753537238,
0.379966706,
-0.6217341423,
-0.5378343463,
-1.1473664045,
-0.1890914142,
0.327604562,
0.3504379988,
0.4660025835,
0.0717390031,
0.049927365,
0.1729143858,
0.2887195349,
-0.7361174822,
-0.2297618389,
-0.3961655796,
0.16758582,
0.4161992669,
-0.053070996,
-0.2836668193,
-0.4287032783,
0.423016727,
0.0486812815,
0.7128426433,
0.5706319809,
-0.0906393528,
-0.1306846291,
0.1215827689,
0.6831325889,
0.9130094051,
0.0812257305,
0.1590812355,
-0.0883231759,
-0.6374201179,
0.5407397747,
-0.3461543918,
-0.247859478,
0.2189988494,
0.4341104329,
0.5527634621,
0.3470997512,
-0.2534562349,
0.3725080788,
-0.1671218872,
-0.2698785961,
-0.5972370505,
0.0810503662,
-0.1479958743,
0.5527137518,
0.0347219445,
0.8455719948,
0.1292748153,
-1.0699691772,
-0.0176911894,
0.474504143,
-0.5760560036,
-0.840454936,
1.0032311678,
0.0168175157,
-0.3587248623,
0.3877029717,
-0.0002968387,
-0.6636089087,
0.3786135018,
0.1114956886,
1.1894904375,
-0.1490868926,
0.2632584572,
0.2528980672,
0.4937104583,
0.0860070959,
0.4878004491,
-0.3581325114,
-1.1510207653,
-0.5332764387,
-0.1335234791,
-0.5349327922,
-0.6804427505,
-0.5739079118,
-0.1050978601,
-0.3846244216,
-0.6196526289,
0.1719433367,
-0.18015863,
-0.6592845321,
0.1786224246,
0.0656902492,
0.7437540293,
-0.6526273489,
0.7184385657,
0.7036709189,
-0.7481238246,
-0.532310009,
-0.1133020669,
0.126669988,
-0.849442184,
0.9594736099,
0.1178736687,
-0.2716823816,
-0.2594230473,
-0.6993831992,
-0.4320257604,
1.0593162775,
0.5831777453,
-0.0096689323,
-0.0736117512,
-0.1063622907,
0.1705164313,
-0.018493589,
0.2157541811,
0.0442047603,
0.9546073079,
0.1019515842,
-0.9071076512,
0.2096904516,
-0.2285171002,
-0.0447794795,
-0.0290753264,
-0.9406217337,
0.7364407182,
-0.309325695,
-0.4893423021,
0.0931426361,
0.5214626789,
0.1951322854,
0.2230456769,
0.2681655884,
0.5518088341,
0.8276569247,
-0.2079870105,
1.5462933779,
-0.2919710279,
0.5089313984,
0.6081544161,
-0.3098634779,
0.2440688312,
0.642721355,
-0.7414858937,
0.4679148197,
0.6026257277,
0.1036835462,
0.3390175104,
0.3910472989,
-0.5899442434,
-0.4139196873,
-0.2978128493,
-0.5087082386,
0.8116406202,
0.1289081126,
-0.2390167117,
-0.1832033545,
-0.3343407512,
0.3272600174,
0.0422474258,
0.119534485,
0.5922281146,
0.2585560083,
-0.5497254133,
0.5268330574,
-0.1048869714,
0.1805407256,
-0.3521918654,
0.0197123569,
0.1955400258,
-0.2642254233,
-0.1083549857,
-0.4266483486,
0.3799652755,
-0.1544606537,
-0.3934909403,
-0.4298252463,
1.0039927959,
0.4123543501,
-0.3941762149,
-0.3890975118,
0.6597995758,
0.4783031046,
0.0045607155,
-0.6897718906,
-0.3266396821,
-0.2122404277,
-0.4683930576,
0.1184421554,
0.7095823288,
0.2413802296,
0.8251587152,
0.5497595668,
-0.0827054381,
-0.125255242,
-0.3346398473,
0.7623399496,
-0.9803742766,
-0.244432658,
-0.951502502,
0.5720744729,
-0.0952550694,
-0.3363592625,
0.5373764634,
0.6277655363,
0.7100408077,
-0.2062039673,
1.150075078,
-0.3212697208,
0.3151493371,
-0.6933986545,
0.7668567896,
-0.2219346166,
-0.1893510818,
-0.3130484223,
-0.6824225783,
-0.0084402058,
0.954324007,
-0.2508136034,
0.1815576404,
0.9319791794,
0.577519834,
0.0566796921,
0.4972708821,
0.4298326075,
0.4495856166,
-0.1454900801,
0.396473974,
1.5014681816,
-0.3754539788,
-0.0596535839,
0.0806694925,
-0.0992248282,
0.0953165516,
-0.7913554907,
-0.6242653131,
-0.617998004,
-0.4331448376,
-0.6126592159,
-0.0077098631,
0.9405926466,
0.6942268014,
-0.1399544328,
-0.2740055621,
-0.0274352524,
0.1782861352,
-0.1676197648,
-0.1077935994,
0.0516203046,
-0.33652246,
-0.6597875357,
0.0669534504,
0.6087139845,
0.207104817,
-0.2461109012,
-0.1664973497,
0.0044529676,
-0.065523155,
0.6659265757,
0.4474129081,
-0.9101550579,
-0.7324637771,
-0.1111291498,
-0.0915335268,
0.3280993104,
0.8290807009,
-1.0178953409,
0.3429593146,
0.3618536294,
0.2860865593,
0.3204476833,
0.0007079967,
0.7124965191,
-0.0770954415,
0.2560994625,
0.1750090569,
0.5506694913,
-0.0666081458,
0.0633944348,
0.7559826374,
1.1769508123,
-0.6025687456,
-0.712326467,
0.6475529671,
-1.0323754549,
-0.3030737936,
0.5624501705,
0.0104940757,
-0.4626520276,
-0.3717500269,
-0.3620724678,
0.425098002,
-0.0708080456,
0.8356599212,
0.8851904273,
-0.123269394,
0.39899382,
-1.1879464388,
0.067198649,
0.0744002759,
-0.4027333558,
-0.1668550968,
0.4048177302,
0.2985612452,
0.3046665192,
0.5302730799,
-0.0739342496,
0.3819025755,
0.2550285459,
0.2172153145,
0.0128903501,
0.1326015294,
0.2687592208,
0.0600569472,
0.0832994878,
-0.3027119935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03370v1
|
Detection of tortured phrases in scientific literature
| 2024-02-02T08:15:43 | 2024-02-02T08:15:43 |
Eléna Martel, Martin Lentschat, Cyril Labbé
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL
|
This paper presents various automatic detection methods to extract so called
tortured phrases from scientific papers. These tortured phrases, e.g. flag to
clamor instead of signal to noise, are the results of paraphrasing tools used
to escape plagiarism detection. We built a dataset and evaluated several
strategies to flag previously undocumented tortured phrases. The proposed and
tested methods are based on language models and either on embeddings
similarities or on predictions of masked token. We found that an approach using
token prediction and that propagates the scores to the chunk level gives the
best results. With a recall value of .87 and a precision value of .61, it could
retrieve new tortured phrases to be submitted to domain experts for validation.
|
[
-0.412520647,
-0.9255342484,
0.6876349449,
0.3212049007,
-0.7242774367,
0.2896868587,
0.1186127514,
-0.1882735044,
0.346180141,
0.9210125208,
-0.1129741073,
-0.4652819037,
-0.7600759268,
0.6383191943,
-0.7670637369,
1.1934177876,
-0.3050151467,
0.0446440056,
-0.4269082248,
-0.0044805286,
0.0660231337,
-0.5463244319,
-0.0810654536,
0.1678785533,
0.4423894584,
0.0892607197,
0.6299901009,
0.8409723043,
0.7909411192,
0.2917078137,
-0.2510428727,
0.2558883131,
-0.2795146704,
0.4491858482,
-0.0212755669,
-0.4218880236,
0.0903347656,
0.1825377345,
0.4235954583,
0.2770828903,
0.2213022858,
0.0447847471,
-0.017270945,
0.4186083376,
-0.2971073389,
0.164413482,
-0.7841322422,
0.1946450621,
-0.6185986996,
-0.3458076715,
-0.4137013257,
-0.4773091376,
-0.0319747329,
-0.4967778027,
0.4747185111,
0.4584184587,
0.8479083776,
0.3044368923,
-0.0016317342,
-0.6648506522,
-0.1119747162,
0.754360199,
-0.5718746781,
0.0556460619,
0.4718294442,
-0.1569209546,
-0.3311904669,
-1.1625241041,
-0.4604940414,
-0.5774301887,
-0.3555075526,
-0.1050666794,
-0.0981426612,
-0.0544265956,
0.4142704308,
0.3098815978,
-0.6385822892,
-0.3175339699,
-0.7064525485,
-0.3551852703,
0.5708229542,
-0.0467313156,
0.3425032496,
-0.4742579162,
-0.4871152341,
0.1227194592,
-0.4912977517,
-0.2244410068,
0.3833854795,
0.0518436432,
0.1754155904,
0.5287424326,
-0.0308493152,
0.3234912753,
0.1426298767,
0.1679347754,
0.2567666769,
-0.1340952367,
0.102542758,
-0.216814056,
0.9551741481,
0.2780498564,
0.1595156342,
-0.5953178406,
-0.264300406,
-0.0193675794,
0.2374386936,
-0.5697807074,
-0.6311132312,
-0.0250398275,
-0.4830054939,
-0.3597300649,
-0.0686256662,
-1.307893157,
-0.6559767723,
-0.1280846149,
0.3633053303,
-0.5397093892,
-0.0588982143,
-0.0352178849,
-0.6494606733,
-0.1573356539,
-0.0599483214,
-0.2128018439,
0.3206385374,
0.6729877591,
1.2595611811,
-0.541046977,
-0.210784182,
-0.6121112704,
-0.1087503135,
-0.0875282437,
0.9308017492,
-0.6682267785,
-0.436355412,
-0.1251932383,
0.1031233296,
-0.0060521127,
-0.6320319176,
0.842302978,
-0.4355480969,
0.1056802273,
-0.1808587611,
-0.6993831396,
-0.2151869833,
-0.0886584893,
-0.8180413246,
0.982878983,
0.0725929216,
-1.0568681955,
0.0960279703,
-0.667943716,
-0.3593265116,
0.1123070791,
0.1690730453,
-0.7169181705,
0.1220172644,
0.2647936642,
0.343824029,
-0.2474030852,
0.4325108528,
-0.6069697738,
-0.2524032891,
0.6948999763,
0.1262047291,
0.6955967546,
0.4749621153,
-0.4835463762,
-0.0954744816,
-0.3460257351,
0.0705539733,
-0.0750535727,
0.0183325708,
-0.5571376085,
-0.0666108951,
0.1238992363,
0.1678523868,
-0.1536784619,
-0.7551193237,
0.0974846408,
-0.4511071444,
0.599312067,
0.4021510184,
0.5614327788,
-0.0156808347,
-0.5503756404,
0.7340255976,
0.1184812784,
0.1714299321,
0.0992499143,
-0.5522359014,
-0.5836100578,
-0.4034914672,
0.3434573412,
0.1797016263,
-0.8835060596,
0.4040434957,
0.0862461329,
-0.5727509856,
-0.8248012662,
0.1446225494,
0.4502640665,
0.5253609419,
0.6956170797,
-0.0590050146,
-0.7398962379,
-0.7843198776,
-0.8913117647,
-0.032523524,
0.1065518633,
-0.1602570564,
1.1263841391,
0.197025165,
0.857473433,
-0.4553287625,
-0.2056086808,
0.3365828395,
0.6670662761,
-0.2510903478,
0.4516664147,
0.4163759053,
-1.1975803375,
-0.3985133767,
-0.2551766038,
-0.8628735542,
-0.2706285715,
-0.2225670666,
-0.0202590805,
-0.0486750528,
0.9421813488,
-0.3802942038,
0.4133435488,
-0.0405591689,
-0.2097740471,
0.7999398112,
0.2574140728,
0.2209846973,
-0.5856332183,
0.2620612681,
-0.1153857335,
-0.169585973,
-0.4971525669,
0.2699790597,
0.1540244222,
0.1218482554,
-0.5574953556,
0.5633048415,
-0.7394822836,
0.2758354545,
-0.3183782101,
0.2110082209,
0.1534739137,
0.1229843721,
0.2123717815,
0.7100632191,
0.5427799821,
-0.3648478687,
0.2435153723,
0.3817325234,
-0.1753986478,
0.2003048211,
-0.5994065404,
0.3675944209,
-0.2963474393,
0.1251495332,
-0.8247438073,
-0.0164961014,
0.2307638079,
-0.4627944231,
-0.0824012533,
-0.1583011746,
-0.566157043,
-0.5066432357,
-0.4987962246,
0.1115919352,
0.4698060751,
-0.1766236871,
0.203186512,
0.4388034344,
-0.226417616,
-0.3916223645,
-0.4735851884,
0.3428637683,
-0.7418186069,
-0.1022690684,
0.3682722151,
-0.1377791464,
-0.3467072248,
-0.1326429546,
0.1142034456,
-0.0852764696,
0.1432435364,
0.4610438347,
0.0817829594,
-0.0693565607,
0.137185663,
0.0851646736,
0.2301022559,
0.3316877186,
-0.071538955,
0.6177385449,
-0.1285495907,
-0.1055883095,
-0.06237863,
0.5715855956,
0.7544193864,
-0.231493175,
0.2866841555,
0.6590611935,
-0.2669861913,
0.1494221389,
-0.5631942153,
-0.3263302743,
-0.4645165801,
0.122042045,
-0.3148709536,
-0.4790426791,
0.6674341559,
-0.2387211323,
-0.2322598994,
0.3163980842,
0.2650146782,
-0.2018262446,
0.9030973911,
0.3380430341,
0.0015077287,
0.0701723024,
-0.0578343272,
0.230528906,
-0.8845730424,
-0.3168312311,
-0.8652566671,
-0.2903587818,
-0.4086381495,
-0.5531471968,
0.5326769948,
0.4953770638,
-0.0056528021,
0.2115173042,
-0.6979600191,
0.4264249504,
0.4750910103,
0.007859257,
0.186412856,
0.1002213582,
-0.4743553698,
-0.1894865334,
-0.1835683584,
-0.5942597985,
0.7546075583,
0.174768135,
0.4391032159,
-0.3969601393,
0.9986943603,
0.4888575673,
0.4545352161,
-0.7500895858,
0.5591063499,
0.0916635618,
-0.6257976294,
-0.078067936,
-0.1286738962,
-0.8554763198,
0.016393654,
0.0722913668,
-0.7721421123,
0.1700021327,
-0.383915484,
-0.1329731196,
0.12779136,
-0.3264273703,
0.559269309,
-0.1224581823,
-0.1304815114,
0.22395055,
-0.7449255586,
0.4240007102,
-0.2853227556,
0.1177749261,
0.1778034717,
-0.1751384437,
1.2653973103,
-0.0914171562,
0.7098532915,
-0.1043841466,
0.3328573704,
0.3054788709,
0.3912737072,
0.3104791343,
-0.0322756208,
-0.3355602026,
0.0535755642,
0.296530813,
-0.3507858515,
-0.3492019773,
0.5537401438,
-0.4435656667,
-0.6548184156,
-0.4957309365,
-0.6609011292,
-0.1211571544,
0.2120690495,
0.5900501609,
-0.0952725857,
0.1669944674,
0.2461678237,
0.4978612661,
-0.0228286982,
0.5262568593,
0.4426936209,
-0.3540613353,
-0.5979195833,
0.6881407499,
0.0564543903,
0.0120741269,
-0.0287714694,
0.283223927,
-0.4386089742,
-0.8313788176,
-0.2675414383,
0.5267297626,
-0.5405271649,
-0.6102002263,
-0.9592686892,
-0.0691552684,
-0.6562963724,
-0.1649756134,
0.1887901276,
-0.1937690675,
-0.5219196081,
-0.1511381567,
0.8549752831,
0.5290202498,
0.0657561347,
0.2261939198,
-0.9096491933,
0.4020189643,
-0.5041223168,
-0.1031494588,
-0.4120916426,
-0.7253206968,
0.1158879921,
-0.0840678662,
-0.406894803,
-1.2357833385,
0.8766542077,
0.3265959322,
0.4415234029,
0.4673620164,
0.5120050907,
0.762427032,
-0.1481260508,
0.8369252682,
0.0067786644,
-0.9094723463,
0.6816571355,
-0.2613902986,
-0.3160097003,
0.4636208713,
0.9109711051,
-0.5474767089,
-1.0648982525,
-0.8280662298,
-0.6686257124,
0.2394177467,
-0.0317695923,
-0.0294164103,
-0.2774208188,
0.6588409543,
0.5800492764,
0.3889915347,
-0.7624261975,
-0.1127843708,
-0.079051882,
-0.2525309324,
0.1774999797,
-0.0076900003,
-0.3441320956,
-0.2705934048,
0.344560504,
-0.2211994082,
0.204668954,
0.4887174964,
-0.4061464667,
-0.2442547083,
-0.134176299,
0.4708736837,
0.4427938461,
-0.0191203058,
0.3322456777,
-0.2128831446,
-0.5385830402,
-0.0490324497,
0.1462748796,
-0.5525304675,
0.3108272254,
0.2452525795,
0.4251153469,
-0.004039003,
-0.755106926,
0.4125379026,
0.263160646,
-0.2994140685,
-0.1466400921,
-0.2133354545,
0.0349011384,
0.1448986679,
0.3976750374,
0.189071849,
0.552107811,
-0.4324574471,
0.705119431,
0.4861307442,
-0.3805977404,
-0.4574079812,
0.556132555,
-0.3340944946,
-0.3762058318,
0.3471234739,
-0.2925956845,
-1.0400686264,
0.530782938,
0.6093529463,
0.7253639698,
-0.164654851,
0.6070911288,
0.0751441047,
0.1479672194,
-0.1432826817,
0.4022521973,
0.091176495,
-0.13073349,
-0.0001176536,
-0.8886893392,
-0.0898588449,
0.4020444453,
-0.7844637036,
0.4435129166,
-0.2848737538,
-0.1029595882,
0.3261771202,
0.0289805047,
-0.3763890564,
-0.0260732342,
0.1060110554,
0.7843146324,
-1.1555576324,
0.750369072,
0.5391826034,
-0.663905859,
-0.3902983367,
-0.0110345259,
0.0402319543,
-0.5763837695,
0.7368965745,
0.1065904126,
-0.019151777,
-0.031568028,
-0.7325145602,
-0.8104511499,
0.4653667212,
0.1648414582,
-0.1855928749,
-0.0199829955,
0.0449369736,
0.6764901876,
-0.2215716392,
0.1695878953,
0.7211899161,
0.7820563912,
-0.0891065672,
-0.7999728918,
0.3411083221,
-0.3157829344,
-0.5433935523,
0.2226199806,
-0.4605476856,
1.0310995579,
0.1874480695,
-0.1429422051,
0.5124388933,
0.6373869181,
0.0766018778,
0.714472115,
0.4186986983,
0.1202225164,
0.8849733472,
-0.0521929413,
0.6171751022,
-0.1686363965,
0.3037831783,
0.517483592,
-0.3148037791,
0.7296316624,
0.9188379049,
0.0747340992,
0.4298497438,
0.646474421,
-0.4406805933,
0.7067123055,
0.4983289242,
-0.0545354821,
-0.0156733748,
-0.2726405859,
-0.2251997292,
0.394844234,
0.7236188054,
-0.5605644584,
-0.1538288891,
0.720207274,
0.3887093663,
0.3506236076,
-0.1730276495,
0.8405733109,
0.201109603,
-0.9168132544,
0.9233557582,
-0.2028868794,
0.6249970794,
-0.0496191941,
-0.0417509116,
-0.2842569351,
-0.140705362,
-0.1105545014,
-0.7530993223,
0.4890195429,
0.0418665856,
0.124339059,
-0.1633660495,
0.8111493587,
-0.483183682,
-0.3971633911,
0.09191107,
0.5618237853,
0.7140381932,
-0.2343614399,
-0.8817989826,
-0.0818401873,
0.0628286824,
-0.157245025,
0.3497858644,
0.5263519883,
-0.2756582201,
0.6718704104,
0.5353904366,
0.5069231987,
0.2178203464,
-0.3528597951,
0.9250853062,
-0.6639065146,
-0.3370478749,
-0.8133894801,
0.1402092725,
-0.4203834832,
-0.358145833,
0.8107164502,
0.5586054921,
0.3933772743,
-0.3934405148,
0.8086856604,
-0.00985156,
0.729811132,
-0.4752528369,
0.7581452727,
-0.2920779586,
-0.1254933029,
-0.3260666728,
-0.4753055871,
-0.5301827192,
0.4020210505,
-0.4273656905,
-0.3789875209,
1.1661393642,
0.980479002,
-0.1073771566,
0.2438762933,
0.0386121944,
0.1594608426,
0.2086190581,
-0.04778881,
0.890607357,
-0.328514576,
0.5078662634,
-0.3558239043,
0.0598020256,
-0.3939154446,
-0.8248850107,
-0.8558672071,
-0.8615166545,
-0.7121624947,
-0.5077161193,
0.199163422,
0.4573416412,
0.2582572401,
-0.9249227643,
0.1666796952,
-0.0626157969,
0.1540972739,
-0.5141429901,
-0.3130440116,
0.6096333861,
-0.6107854843,
-0.6133586764,
0.3199696839,
0.1041029915,
-0.0908786431,
-0.0922541022,
0.2902337015,
-0.2805998325,
0.1411215216,
0.0647604838,
0.282420963,
-0.8222197294,
-0.3832080364,
0.1512673646,
0.0198251288,
-0.1043536887,
1.2430621386,
-0.8086636066,
0.3126859963,
0.573271215,
0.3720524907,
0.3364521861,
0.1652613282,
0.3702178001,
-0.7451456785,
0.076782316,
0.8465576172,
0.2870933712,
0.3324169219,
-0.4092413783,
0.2670605481,
0.3981121778,
-0.5728198886,
-1.4493792057,
-0.0690016448,
-0.7771319151,
-0.4255588055,
1.0093067884,
-0.6645479798,
-0.5216587186,
-0.7209150195,
-0.1883328408,
0.3630003929,
-0.0989221334,
1.2365912199,
0.7105020285,
-0.1105699018,
0.0367796421,
-0.4793583751,
0.8617725968,
0.4598170817,
-0.5359418392,
0.3177961707,
0.2170965075,
0.246464178,
0.4863373041,
0.1026004776,
-0.3704667091,
0.1641856134,
-0.0165778473,
-0.0237262826,
-0.1922170967,
-0.0494080372,
-0.1085997671,
0.4332769215,
-0.14138861,
-0.1742620915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01801v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01801v3
|
Large Language Models for Time Series: A Survey
| 2024-02-02T07:24:35 | 2024-05-06T20:48:41 |
Xiyuan Zhang, Ranak Roy Chowdhury, Rajesh K. Gupta, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen significant use in domains such as
natural language processing and computer vision. Going beyond text, image and
graphics, LLMs present a significant potential for analysis of time series
data, benefiting domains such as climate, IoT, healthcare, traffic, audio and
finance. This survey paper provides an in-depth exploration and a detailed
taxonomy of the various methodologies employed to harness the power of LLMs for
time series analysis. We address the inherent challenge of bridging the gap
between LLMs' original text data training and the numerical nature of time
series data, and explore strategies for transferring and distilling knowledge
from LLMs to numerical time series analysis. We detail various methodologies,
including (1) direct prompting of LLMs, (2) time series quantization, (3)
aligning techniques, (4) utilization of the vision modality as a bridging
mechanism, and (5) the combination of LLMs with tools. Additionally, this
survey offers a comprehensive overview of the existing multimodal time series
and text datasets and delves into the challenges and future opportunities of
this emerging field. We maintain an up-to-date Github repository which includes
all the papers and datasets discussed in the survey.
|
[
-0.3134785891,
-0.8072084188,
0.6173557043,
0.0929270536,
-0.289883852,
0.5034243464,
-0.3217137456,
-0.5410855412,
0.106215775,
0.4887088835,
-0.5479210019,
-0.4239485562,
-0.6228218079,
0.0422161259,
-0.443782419,
0.6719552875,
-0.1343260109,
0.1825307906,
-0.0666449368,
-0.006284846,
-0.0896590427,
-0.7612900734,
-0.6562464833,
-0.4616123736,
0.6113753319,
-0.0128951333,
0.5221791863,
0.3411463201,
0.8168281317,
0.3188556731,
0.0672965422,
0.2678562105,
-0.2913092077,
0.231877327,
0.1585176289,
-0.1535260528,
-0.4189913273,
-0.0668290183,
0.8350920677,
1.0175375938,
-0.2225441635,
0.4482606947,
-0.1277470589,
0.5015511513,
-0.3211885393,
0.4344008267,
-0.3292393386,
0.1159289852,
-0.5590170026,
-0.4589368701,
-0.1390579939,
-0.1750211567,
0.2432228029,
-0.2305808514,
0.0368156843,
0.2880277038,
0.3480969071,
0.3769416213,
-0.6778294444,
-0.1216091812,
-1.1013931036,
1.1748405695,
-0.8938486576,
0.3407244682,
0.1027442962,
0.4838728011,
0.0510850325,
-0.7041845322,
-0.5215058327,
0.0013202714,
0.1459609419,
-0.0317027494,
-0.017994456,
-0.1887530684,
0.3973218799,
0.5134820342,
-0.4538621306,
0.3263425231,
-0.2351920456,
0.0562010966,
0.6688187718,
0.5705047846,
0.173371613,
-0.07876537,
-0.2693359852,
-0.2100692689,
-0.5468549132,
-0.1892740577,
0.2684218287,
0.2541501522,
-0.3210668564,
0.6057533026,
0.0457911156,
0.8907142878,
-0.6555119157,
-0.4013208449,
0.0937130228,
-0.3692920208,
-0.3714702427,
-0.0540988222,
0.8083965182,
0.329574585,
0.2806642652,
-0.0721235573,
-0.1941219717,
-0.1931114793,
-0.2265582532,
-0.7628418207,
0.0278029758,
0.0979710668,
-0.428524822,
-0.2289777696,
-0.1671521515,
-1.1335815191,
-0.5560473204,
-0.8636769056,
-0.0337277353,
-0.051018469,
-0.4005682468,
0.2029393166,
-0.0125410696,
0.392753154,
0.2751636505,
-0.966674149,
0.2869689465,
0.7091901302,
0.9450983405,
-0.1406018436,
-0.0032438759,
-0.2170459032,
0.2708332837,
-0.1730716377,
0.7025305629,
-0.4344882369,
-0.4952559769,
0.1582202911,
-0.0675254315,
-0.0066815605,
-0.3388842344,
0.0332499109,
-0.693316102,
0.1088688895,
-0.0614417307,
-0.4421401918,
-0.2427825928,
0.4158727527,
-0.8059450388,
0.9440603852,
-0.1632401496,
-0.6814183593,
0.0889154077,
-0.6735892892,
-0.3216511309,
-0.2027935535,
-0.2631043196,
-0.4096098542,
-0.1069717929,
0.386102736,
0.8790781498,
-0.8014189601,
0.5698606372,
-0.5457111597,
0.0879257172,
0.357932359,
-0.8498524427,
0.6662905216,
0.3635660708,
-0.0071913488,
0.0032916055,
-0.7456077337,
-0.1893228292,
0.195712924,
0.062497776,
-0.4255904257,
0.2719807923,
0.3820140958,
-0.0952522755,
0.2747466564,
-0.4398201704,
0.5057996511,
-0.2551027238,
0.8322389126,
0.7147276402,
0.1061768383,
0.1771151572,
-0.2332161665,
0.6689939499,
-0.0231011081,
0.1638121754,
-0.5264748931,
-0.3000745773,
-0.433697015,
-0.11306227,
0.1597239524,
0.6941129565,
-0.8689472675,
-0.1105254218,
-0.6206619143,
-0.5880189538,
-0.0024021796,
0.1053462923,
-0.0195074882,
0.2067950666,
0.0497739315,
0.0661092624,
-0.4824411273,
-0.6450532675,
-0.050723698,
-0.0488722585,
0.1392080784,
0.149653241,
0.4663808942,
-0.1943228692,
0.8952448368,
-0.794454813,
0.111661993,
-0.184468478,
0.2143710256,
0.2976290882,
0.0556938015,
0.7215836644,
-0.8745473027,
-0.1791179329,
0.0320774503,
-0.7386473417,
-0.0385560505,
-0.070538342,
0.3386854827,
0.279111743,
0.811673224,
-0.2602830231,
0.2095135748,
0.8827625513,
-0.1349583417,
0.4593790174,
0.140568316,
0.2010634989,
-1.4486656189,
0.1794527769,
0.3153835237,
-0.3236710131,
-0.5483744144,
-0.2572643459,
-0.363502264,
-0.2700183392,
-0.3715559542,
0.9069998264,
-0.6627435088,
-0.1731225252,
-0.0906482935,
-0.011795436,
-0.2801802456,
0.2658791244,
0.0109418919,
0.6307285428,
0.4949088991,
-0.3759591579,
0.9595832825,
0.0392305776,
-0.6759189963,
0.1747496277,
-0.547297895,
0.0347539298,
-0.2522082627,
0.0339296982,
-0.9905630946,
-0.221730113,
0.0990713611,
-0.076477468,
0.4306344986,
-0.1086695641,
-0.7989213467,
-0.3348023295,
-0.2105644941,
0.6525552273,
0.3049506545,
-0.55407691,
0.5263331532,
0.5106463432,
-0.5507398844,
-0.5060629845,
-0.7374573946,
0.2605315149,
-0.559310019,
-0.4737525284,
0.2054866999,
-0.0799916461,
-0.7723985314,
-0.135906294,
0.1229274273,
-0.1367530525,
0.0258341711,
0.0770088062,
0.5297214389,
-0.2483877838,
0.1024489254,
-0.4023398757,
-0.0531769618,
0.0465774611,
-0.2747792602,
0.5393648744,
-0.1123955101,
-0.5118739009,
-0.2506991029,
0.3493294418,
0.7288954258,
-0.2097177953,
0.5701529384,
0.6885356307,
-0.3025701344,
-0.1640928686,
-0.5494682789,
-0.0600100048,
-0.4413958192,
0.195110634,
0.0709411278,
-1.2369738817,
0.3514843583,
-0.3309911788,
0.1513289511,
0.2270809561,
0.7161056399,
-0.0089196945,
0.6797914505,
0.7619866729,
-0.5402361155,
0.8196021914,
-0.4020688534,
0.4337387681,
-0.6297277808,
-0.2823853791,
-0.4089479744,
-0.2414744347,
-0.4740938246,
-0.4050366282,
0.5743595958,
-0.330454886,
-0.2302104235,
-0.1642929018,
-0.0751299262,
0.2607014477,
0.1547235399,
-0.2705646157,
0.5364041924,
0.3430549204,
0.2642415762,
-0.1727298349,
-0.5340055227,
-0.5066343546,
1.0755640268,
0.3491423428,
1.1503611803,
0.2299206853,
0.1907857507,
0.4665088952,
0.3522028923,
-0.8977482319,
0.550150454,
-0.2658082247,
-0.3894975185,
-0.5298985839,
-0.4757684767,
-0.8456786275,
0.0492056422,
0.0228614602,
-0.5013346672,
-0.0688070655,
-0.0502293184,
-0.3369325399,
0.6683400869,
-0.5067372322,
0.6824215055,
-0.4421141148,
-0.2672803998,
-0.2209303826,
-0.4724037945,
0.4462495446,
-0.1933297962,
0.3142995834,
-0.2407054603,
-0.1026986092,
0.6645935178,
-0.2122356147,
1.1870293617,
0.1108679771,
-0.3915720582,
0.3169505298,
-0.1822122335,
0.2117853612,
0.0673090816,
-0.0455366448,
0.4206344187,
0.2895884812,
-0.2609776556,
-0.4837201536,
0.7575052381,
-0.6237126589,
-0.4238381088,
-0.8589043617,
-0.5635365844,
-0.4567314386,
0.0325341821,
-0.2430107445,
0.8926470876,
-0.2238477021,
0.2180548608,
0.6562402248,
-0.0703802556,
0.9194502831,
0.4750017226,
-0.4882801771,
-0.4232449532,
0.8615077734,
0.2264481485,
0.1532798409,
0.6484037638,
0.0632727817,
-0.4223621488,
-0.6279450059,
-0.235776037,
0.398419708,
-0.4296793044,
-0.1271404028,
-0.1692030579,
-0.332077086,
-0.5083373785,
0.1576315463,
-0.1029642373,
-0.3722374737,
-0.316540122,
0.0628343299,
0.7645712495,
0.8296245933,
0.3033886552,
0.4747910798,
-0.9958615303,
0.3449362516,
0.3246656954,
0.4152381718,
0.1055221558,
-0.1044077575,
-0.2037350684,
-0.1098053157,
-0.3334430754,
-0.5629384518,
0.71258533,
0.117713958,
0.4942519367,
0.3799202442,
-0.160236001,
0.722047925,
-0.5769252777,
1.0362899303,
0.2611463964,
-0.6666749716,
0.1731734872,
-0.6362583041,
0.2226379067,
-0.0755399689,
0.4819581211,
-0.9805828333,
0.1244082749,
-0.21596241,
-0.8166632056,
0.3658361435,
-0.1077760532,
0.0282803327,
0.2205369622,
0.327129811,
-0.1111217588,
0.4867504239,
-0.4486601651,
-0.1391542405,
0.0440581888,
-0.3758387566,
-0.5340653658,
-0.0203857664,
-0.13003847,
-0.0658419058,
0.3811360598,
-0.2839004993,
0.0024068947,
0.1195141822,
0.0999965593,
0.1450498104,
0.2830085158,
0.4895734191,
0.7348900437,
0.0555224754,
0.0115494048,
0.0863369778,
-0.4190322757,
-0.0491112918,
0.0668529868,
0.0523872636,
-0.1048821807,
0.5277915001,
0.778639257,
0.1269325763,
-0.8136158586,
0.1985531002,
0.1232727841,
0.0668568462,
-0.6860074997,
-0.3313977122,
0.0763279125,
0.4062349796,
0.3158996105,
-0.29028669,
-0.0545076467,
-0.5524895787,
-0.3061581254,
0.5129196644,
-0.0938362181,
-0.3697618544,
0.6008890867,
0.2202400267,
-0.0257832576,
0.5884642601,
0.2953763306,
-0.1923098266,
0.6488981247,
0.1738736331,
0.6798377037,
-0.1085191518,
-0.023360312,
0.0977901742,
0.3030311763,
-0.2415340692,
0.3709248304,
0.0641557351,
-0.6251546741,
-0.8994117975,
-0.7089291811,
-0.7055747509,
0.3816707134,
-0.4491472244,
0.3183961213,
-0.4143372774,
-0.3446040452,
0.0866695046,
-0.0182025284,
-0.5364609957,
-0.0086825928,
0.4696772695,
0.9479208589,
-0.8465738893,
0.6887967587,
0.7439158559,
-0.08196567,
-0.3930438459,
-0.2179879844,
0.2389890701,
-0.7679401636,
0.5851575136,
-0.2371338904,
-0.234241724,
0.0058393409,
-0.7056801915,
-0.7859241366,
1.1054087877,
0.1125064194,
-0.7655379176,
-0.1380916834,
0.3609724641,
0.5144107938,
-0.2771042287,
-0.0144141261,
0.5495488048,
0.4975688159,
-0.0115942759,
-0.7860506177,
-0.2907693386,
-0.196466133,
0.2346803993,
0.5899838209,
-0.9755841494,
0.4719442427,
-0.0215022806,
0.0097612021,
0.1852256805,
0.6336548924,
-0.0543551818,
0.6655506492,
0.4387815893,
0.3592428863,
0.4818989933,
-0.1203623414,
0.8694128394,
-0.2800557613,
0.4805603027,
0.8387618065,
-0.5084588528,
0.7962450385,
0.716483593,
-0.4641306698,
0.327388525,
0.7204060555,
-0.1883416027,
0.1784618199,
0.1980620176,
-0.3283922672,
-0.3386032879,
-0.1732366234,
-0.3379411697,
0.2408866584,
0.7034182549,
-0.0161584597,
-0.2268130332,
0.1909937859,
-0.0454496518,
-0.0268167034,
-0.3904963732,
0.488132745,
0.40422979,
-0.3196118474,
0.1102127209,
-0.1333296746,
0.6543469429,
-0.9323285222,
-0.1029432341,
0.0052248049,
-0.0242610034,
-0.0301672183,
-0.8956897259,
0.4492276311,
0.1086455509,
-0.2176866829,
-0.5545073152,
0.4814814329,
-0.2386947572,
-0.73493433,
0.1124773622,
0.5278222561,
0.1146624461,
0.2397798151,
-0.3435673416,
0.1086053252,
-0.2318364382,
-0.3586132824,
0.1209288612,
0.4808843136,
-0.2215464562,
0.928376317,
0.668659687,
0.2903300524,
0.2291046828,
0.3808599114,
0.6655699611,
-1.082681179,
-0.1473060548,
-0.9222483039,
0.1642381996,
-0.0098193623,
-0.1355862767,
0.818510294,
0.5136355758,
0.5572228432,
-0.1049947962,
0.9642927647,
0.202843681,
0.5963119268,
-0.8746333122,
0.4636096954,
-0.6252494454,
0.3879231811,
-0.1371951699,
-0.8638438582,
-0.4299738705,
0.0130899446,
-0.5217999816,
-0.0834099874,
0.525642395,
0.5608406663,
-0.0449488834,
0.2481327057,
0.2548568547,
0.3128299117,
0.3720240891,
0.2731782496,
1.0431038141,
0.0193068963,
0.4428851604,
-0.0125828646,
-0.205202654,
-0.2533024549,
-1.2030323744,
-0.9324603081,
-0.5754179955,
-0.3271387815,
0.0476823412,
-0.2537682354,
0.82000947,
0.6005147099,
-0.6261149645,
-0.4819807708,
0.3711299598,
-0.114218235,
-0.0098575037,
-0.1609312892,
0.307980448,
-0.0639683753,
-0.9371436834,
0.3339889646,
0.1830388159,
0.3552656174,
-0.780813694,
0.2981242836,
0.2182067484,
-0.0749042705,
0.8843938112,
0.3470285237,
-0.5706617832,
0.0573083386,
0.2513641715,
0.1385117173,
-0.1838454455,
1.1866096258,
-0.5211503506,
0.2266136557,
0.5550402999,
0.6819206476,
0.5822582245,
-0.2179366648,
0.4088923931,
-0.4650935531,
0.2037574053,
0.1354915947,
0.5503169894,
0.4689569473,
-0.0674646571,
0.4027356505,
0.4113835692,
-0.6170228124,
-0.8420667052,
0.2792631686,
-1.3473602533,
-0.2332866639,
1.2559434175,
0.2956510782,
-0.2825379968,
-0.1261152178,
-0.0958157554,
0.0279569048,
-0.1421496719,
0.5637581944,
0.9852902889,
-0.1164672822,
-0.123748824,
-0.9167701602,
0.1092845798,
-0.0403203741,
-0.8111025691,
0.1819597185,
0.4540233314,
0.3291046321,
0.0368840545,
0.3466204703,
-0.2490629256,
-0.4235752523,
-0.3783175945,
-0.1225940213,
-0.0472924933,
-0.3311588764,
-0.585555315,
0.0530336834,
-0.0090805795,
0.1257711202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01183v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01183v1
|
LINGO-Space: Language-Conditioned Incremental Grounding for Space
| 2024-02-02T06:58:39 | 2024-02-02T06:58:39 |
Dohyun Kim, Nayoung Oh, Deokmin Hwang, Daehyung Park
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
We aim to solve the problem of spatially localizing composite instructions
referring to space: space grounding. Compared to current instance grounding,
space grounding is challenging due to the ill-posedness of identifying
locations referred to by discrete expressions and the compositional ambiguity
of referring expressions. Therefore, we propose a novel probabilistic
space-grounding methodology (LINGO-Space) that accurately identifies a
probabilistic distribution of space being referred to and incrementally updates
it, given subsequent referring expressions leveraging configurable polar
distributions. Our evaluations show that the estimation using polar
distributions enables a robot to ground locations successfully through $20$
table-top manipulation benchmark tests. We also show that updating the
distribution helps the grounding method accurately narrow the referring space.
We finally demonstrate the robustness of the space grounding with simulated
manipulation and real quadruped robot navigation tasks. Code and videos are
available at https://lingo-space.github.io.
|
[
-0.0124835344,
-0.5674826503,
0.6707366705,
0.6608829498,
-0.3093115389,
0.1966788322,
-0.051638402,
-0.0600274429,
0.3151086569,
0.3936444819,
-0.6112083197,
-0.6795621514,
-0.3911240995,
-0.2731510103,
-0.1477502584,
0.6676342487,
0.202667743,
-0.0270969365,
-0.3531104326,
-0.3907372952,
-0.959685266,
-0.7070489526,
-0.325927794,
-0.251650542,
0.0124753341,
0.6652334332,
1.3527460098,
0.5838146806,
0.5911043286,
0.2792478502,
-0.1808087081,
0.0052657295,
0.0158901084,
-0.0953710526,
-0.2279184163,
-0.4821782112,
-0.2333062738,
-0.0706048235,
0.7261177897,
1.0882486105,
-0.4819068015,
-0.425308913,
-0.7159457803,
0.6726285219,
-0.6106413007,
0.1408293694,
-0.5919853449,
0.3746721447,
0.1357118189,
-0.3473241627,
-0.2204780132,
-0.2375149727,
-0.2777613401,
-1.0650146008,
0.2673707604,
0.4156803489,
0.8772528172,
0.5239120126,
0.0830887929,
-0.3544458151,
-0.5981830955,
0.6939566731,
-0.4555021524,
0.5106830001,
0.3900928795,
0.3073988855,
-0.1643525064,
-0.2693094611,
-0.6798977852,
-0.6205656528,
0.0481384844,
0.3080840409,
0.1670769304,
0.0935867429,
0.1488726884,
0.1965208203,
-0.2582402825,
-0.255632937,
-0.1579278409,
0.0522262305,
0.1381238997,
-0.3480016589,
0.588850081,
-0.1213322133,
-0.5232833624,
-0.4123130143,
-0.7102704644,
-0.1188983768,
0.2910657823,
0.2403574735,
-0.1890984476,
0.7953029871,
-0.2052226216,
0.5661458373,
0.5065594316,
0.148614049,
0.4892275333,
-0.0727854744,
-0.1851928383,
-0.0594152287,
0.4862450659,
0.4265546203,
-0.0438890941,
-0.4864917099,
-0.1304960698,
-0.0895429328,
0.405992955,
-0.1775742322,
-0.3834490478,
0.3450464606,
0.2415737063,
-0.0873275697,
0.2495041788,
-0.3255637884,
-0.4787332714,
-0.1911584586,
0.2271070927,
-0.7149819732,
-0.0591680966,
0.4692096412,
-0.2736375332,
0.0049437191,
0.1224843264,
-0.7246344686,
0.1332844943,
0.6303094029,
0.8087713718,
0.1992009133,
-0.226073727,
-0.482444793,
0.2310216129,
-0.6051031947,
0.8751650453,
-0.5912206769,
-0.3681102097,
0.0120937172,
-0.1067535877,
0.0427130274,
-0.8245830536,
0.5133414268,
-0.7013043165,
0.3394135237,
-0.1450431347,
-0.178714186,
0.0225024596,
0.3316495717,
-0.5571835637,
1.006311059,
0.5164643526,
-0.5881268978,
0.3434520066,
-0.4844220877,
-0.4793661833,
0.2926931977,
-0.0210347157,
-0.2624168992,
-0.1034197807,
0.0687801093,
0.1211294681,
-0.0502792597,
0.5266917348,
-0.0800169632,
-0.3491362035,
-0.0545018539,
0.2927196026,
0.6175080538,
0.2300743312,
-0.3032931387,
0.1063929126,
-0.5831878781,
-0.1849839985,
-0.0548183024,
-0.1982023269,
-0.5641245246,
0.2370810956,
-0.4623309076,
0.1449517906,
0.3229469359,
-0.1237825528,
0.3828765452,
-0.809112072,
0.0087467534,
0.3359590173,
-0.0130791152,
1.2536029816,
-0.1101084128,
0.6976031065,
0.090801321,
0.2434713542,
-0.2123027742,
-0.5322417617,
-0.6517823935,
-0.3053137064,
0.0030870149,
1.142950058,
-1.0402603149,
0.7296620011,
-0.3734593391,
-0.4783284068,
0.0324798822,
0.0151888672,
0.3607900739,
0.5284923911,
0.5683729053,
0.2266836464,
-0.2804980874,
-0.6435146332,
0.1290683299,
-0.2615313232,
-0.3882064819,
0.350140065,
0.2285249531,
-0.3062515855,
0.809894383,
-0.4534145296,
-0.129817456,
0.2497499734,
0.2361097485,
0.4227705598,
0.4283076525,
0.6331421733,
-0.8968502283,
-0.2707589269,
-0.0168015454,
-0.8128147721,
-0.3592483997,
-0.3981713355,
-0.2898088694,
-0.1554088891,
0.8036304712,
-1.1015033722,
-0.2062416077,
0.5370390415,
-0.4820323288,
0.3364574015,
-0.4238005877,
0.0704184398,
-0.7312902808,
-0.0288784523,
-0.208670944,
-0.0722918883,
-0.3152780831,
0.559454143,
-0.0208122786,
-0.3521413207,
-0.4502712786,
0.3511504233,
-0.6863832474,
0.0264312197,
-0.0236134771,
0.5311740637,
-0.178842321,
0.3630671203,
0.1917642653,
0.7943232656,
0.6021052003,
-0.6279166937,
0.2055721134,
0.4011389911,
-0.0497795753,
0.5735677481,
-0.5153470039,
0.0966899693,
-0.2176805884,
0.4255081713,
-1.1329774857,
-0.0037761452,
0.6671125889,
-0.4173072278,
0.0328139588,
-0.2734506428,
-0.5400140285,
-0.0400646366,
-0.2873401642,
0.4816971719,
0.4291584492,
-0.4479833245,
0.5124077201,
0.6676311493,
-0.1791176349,
-0.672510922,
-0.1901458204,
0.2175818533,
-0.3634094,
-0.6160318255,
0.4138156772,
-0.2340016663,
-0.4415938854,
-0.3130828142,
-0.1774145961,
0.1071692258,
0.0750261992,
0.3472740948,
0.0746343285,
0.112440154,
0.1559875458,
0.0555363111,
-0.3115452528,
0.1077158451,
-0.5407759547,
0.564384222,
0.0103808697,
-0.3301182985,
0.1334504783,
0.2580680251,
0.5631123781,
0.3447006345,
0.5253586769,
0.1959133297,
-0.4237268865,
-0.1808696389,
-0.2450952232,
0.0671175271,
-0.5566813946,
0.0451048277,
-0.4304488897,
-0.4847756028,
0.3860126138,
-0.3742324114,
-0.1614393592,
0.2956660092,
0.0244921725,
-0.3358071446,
0.7920242548,
0.9098548889,
-0.037947271,
0.3497311473,
-0.1769882739,
0.3895895183,
-0.3131385446,
-0.3008056581,
-0.5335251093,
0.0399128571,
-0.3854573965,
-1.2031860352,
0.4248647392,
0.3510038853,
-0.214804098,
0.3491597474,
-0.6181221008,
0.4845969975,
0.605435133,
-0.2438687086,
-0.1571491361,
0.2649064362,
-0.2934407592,
-0.0591560379,
-0.9313608408,
-0.2032772303,
0.2813108265,
0.0792514384,
0.3454459012,
-0.0634458289,
0.3726247549,
0.4052197635,
0.6394788027,
-0.682956636,
0.5961803198,
-0.1626579165,
-0.3162362874,
-0.3120748103,
-0.1962507069,
-0.7343859076,
0.1629699767,
-0.1485622525,
-0.3315283954,
0.0263079964,
0.2180011272,
-0.348621577,
0.0624091476,
-0.5477692485,
0.5761932135,
-0.1208111346,
0.0179918017,
-0.1376310736,
-0.9325014353,
0.0411865525,
0.0162128061,
0.7653956413,
-0.0603327714,
-0.0902080461,
0.4738205373,
-0.4559677839,
0.6488336921,
-0.6257504821,
-0.4615849257,
0.3005603254,
0.2326316684,
0.4874207973,
0.3394997716,
0.0643255562,
0.4559352398,
-0.4150690734,
-0.2108661979,
-0.6765246987,
0.6687248945,
-0.7590439916,
-0.4959363043,
-0.5441009998,
-0.6437755823,
-0.446054846,
0.0628608167,
0.1785799861,
-0.1673273295,
0.0629694536,
0.0722417608,
0.7362544537,
-0.6902473569,
0.0215395559,
0.4962964356,
0.0819650739,
-0.6493366957,
0.8988437653,
-0.2027467489,
-0.1028000712,
1.0757905245,
0.171661526,
-0.3199132979,
-0.2404618561,
-0.3790304661,
0.3917714059,
-0.789196074,
-0.1490456164,
-0.5002987385,
0.1131720617,
-0.1740343869,
-0.9477934837,
-0.3390655518,
-0.6757445335,
-0.0674592555,
-0.3027141094,
-0.0471214764,
0.1112301946,
-0.2058962137,
0.7538692951,
-0.5303623676,
0.6779215932,
-0.0134171583,
0.0975673199,
-0.8311889768,
-0.579241395,
-0.0432378985,
0.2190709114,
0.0720220953,
-0.586348474,
0.3994117677,
-0.0381792597,
0.3263423443,
0.1251888573,
-0.0985537544,
0.7491654754,
-0.8543812037,
0.8180967569,
0.437643826,
-0.8585158587,
0.7325132489,
-0.6424763203,
0.4495352507,
0.3067899942,
0.3109774888,
-0.5843197703,
-0.6358283758,
-0.8072487712,
-1.3217661381,
0.4549851418,
0.110933885,
0.4184610248,
-0.3842804134,
0.662095964,
-0.1042445228,
0.300853163,
-0.634652853,
-0.3666700721,
-0.2550517619,
0.0096013248,
-0.2451191396,
-0.2451979965,
-0.4584100842,
-0.1011663154,
0.5659999847,
-0.1414674371,
0.5136346817,
0.0093684262,
-0.2658939362,
-0.1822654754,
-0.0599678531,
0.8066800237,
0.5369074345,
-0.2478738278,
0.1012106836,
0.1060623899,
-0.3378162682,
0.2871972024,
0.0062088924,
-0.4463269114,
0.4824447334,
0.1392860115,
0.4397929907,
0.5600845218,
-0.6629968882,
0.5309565663,
0.3476859331,
-0.128748104,
-0.7472197413,
0.0224023182,
-0.0003013547,
-0.1051046774,
0.4622850418,
0.3831756413,
0.0344090238,
-0.2980875671,
0.2180583924,
0.4993277192,
-0.2283667773,
-0.397277683,
0.9840319753,
0.0518001989,
-0.533431232,
0.5829875469,
-0.3363227248,
-0.3781803548,
0.779564023,
0.5025246739,
0.6918597221,
-0.1136520505,
0.5645880103,
0.5412791371,
0.4487353861,
-0.2730667293,
0.3182214499,
-0.306974262,
-0.9939980507,
-0.2728269696,
-0.4068953991,
-0.7090271115,
-0.308914423,
-0.2069660127,
0.3134964705,
-0.778930366,
-0.0665311515,
-0.3932143748,
-0.2865253985,
-0.2613369823,
0.5737447143,
0.5341046453,
0.9386764169,
-0.8480067253,
0.3139317632,
1.1424636841,
-0.1023889706,
-0.4705986977,
0.0113609293,
-0.2627010345,
-0.7430541515,
0.6575057507,
0.0389475785,
-0.6856642962,
-0.2010460049,
-0.9382688999,
-1.1067332029,
0.9153334498,
0.3828185201,
-0.2963137925,
0.2062470019,
0.1446766406,
0.531355083,
-0.0502640009,
0.0380248502,
0.1047663167,
0.5688933134,
0.0197216533,
-0.5381367803,
0.0274742134,
-0.3468529284,
0.0118642272,
0.021760961,
-0.8265162706,
0.4874173701,
-0.302344203,
-0.4659191668,
0.0399770103,
0.6696818471,
0.6576510668,
0.1906962246,
0.8655071259,
0.7143163085,
0.9013875723,
-0.170799017,
0.8474855423,
-0.8124297857,
0.2435943484,
0.8477805257,
-0.436234951,
0.501809895,
0.5874533653,
-0.0342893302,
0.7388227582,
0.1496397257,
0.2292392552,
0.896333456,
0.1951217353,
-0.4328344464,
-0.0907326415,
0.1813193709,
-0.1939575076,
0.0296884291,
0.5525894761,
0.2519222796,
-0.2183352709,
0.0717353895,
0.0909029692,
0.1791212857,
0.1519676745,
0.3287280202,
-0.1391780376,
-0.9197175503,
0.5662732124,
0.3426762521,
0.5712173581,
-0.7842447162,
-0.2455003411,
-0.5449123383,
0.041722618,
0.0045912904,
-0.6134074926,
0.2884102762,
-0.5003727674,
-0.163325429,
-0.7954274416,
0.4246505797,
-0.2183471471,
-0.1732794642,
0.1887603402,
0.226998806,
0.1832726002,
-0.1363116056,
-0.4455350041,
-0.2449114174,
-0.2697664499,
-0.1435973495,
0.1786750704,
0.6833540797,
-0.2972574234,
1.0038481951,
0.7765573859,
-0.0523568355,
0.0798336267,
0.2536012828,
0.6356368661,
-0.7140693069,
-0.8363721967,
-0.3269250989,
0.6217192411,
0.1082564965,
-0.3667571843,
0.8361358643,
0.3897570372,
0.6341354847,
-0.5267739892,
0.5078762174,
-0.3517036736,
0.1236275285,
-0.5875585079,
0.2518926263,
-0.2887108624,
0.3121094406,
-0.0249614231,
-0.7305979133,
-0.7290269136,
0.941906631,
-0.167073071,
-0.2250105143,
0.8223848939,
0.8057097793,
-0.1169017255,
-0.5975444317,
0.3719533086,
0.0683035329,
0.0330586024,
0.291372627,
0.9236593843,
-0.401027739,
0.3237397075,
-0.3704763055,
-0.2739585936,
-0.1165231764,
-0.8164501786,
-0.2432981282,
-0.3548845351,
-0.649210453,
-0.2289028466,
0.123463273,
0.424171865,
0.8664895892,
-0.7141808271,
-0.0418713577,
-0.345220387,
0.3268959224,
-0.4928173125,
-0.274182111,
0.0498959348,
-0.451025784,
-0.5091965199,
0.9013581276,
0.4212889075,
-0.4035390615,
0.132296294,
-0.0666925907,
-0.1064103469,
0.1101816148,
0.715272665,
0.5149753094,
-0.4695852101,
-0.6198250651,
0.238951847,
-0.1268270463,
0.2264115214,
0.7846482396,
-0.8082721233,
0.2272874266,
0.3388001323,
0.26902017,
-0.0364139527,
0.4710824788,
0.5279340744,
-1.3169584274,
0.7096142769,
0.2816009521,
0.3183916807,
0.5150977969,
-0.6376769543,
0.668657124,
0.4520602524,
-0.4250113964,
-0.5826413035,
-0.0256713182,
-1.2598304749,
-0.206206575,
1.4000436068,
0.0116526084,
-0.0569160432,
0.0181250274,
-0.2886960506,
-0.0031285426,
-0.0598993227,
1.0773955584,
0.6367650628,
0.2336357236,
-0.0054889303,
-0.4762309492,
0.1899627596,
0.5789699554,
-0.6284106374,
-0.2401225269,
0.8798750043,
0.5101618171,
0.8367259502,
0.7413770556,
-0.0172942076,
0.2577686012,
0.2517270446,
0.399715811,
0.3559694886,
-0.61900419,
-0.3138388693,
0.4189428389,
-0.1996966004,
-0.288200587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01182v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01182v1
|
In-Context Learning for Few-Shot Nested Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-02T06:57:53 | 2024-02-02T06:57:53 |
Meishan Zhang, Bin Wang, Hao Fei, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In nested Named entity recognition (NER), entities are nested with each
other, and thus requiring more data annotations to address. This leads to the
development of few-shot nested NER, where the prevalence of pretrained language
models with in-context learning (ICL) offers promising solutions. In this work,
we introduce an effective and innovative ICL framework for the setting of
few-shot nested NER. We improve the ICL prompt by devising a novel example
demonstration selection mechanism, EnDe retriever. In EnDe retriever, we employ
contrastive learning to perform three types of representation learning, in
terms of semantic similarity, boundary similarity, and label similarity, to
generate high-quality demonstration examples. Extensive experiments over three
nested NER and four flat NER datasets demonstrate the efficacy of our system.
|
[
-0.3938446045,
-0.3968465924,
0.3107372224,
-0.1253680736,
-0.4731430411,
-0.0374311022,
-0.203564927,
-0.455386579,
-0.065118283,
0.1937273443,
-0.369546473,
-0.5952115655,
-0.4348045886,
0.3689108789,
-0.1917784512,
1.156719327,
-0.0598818101,
0.0704590082,
-0.1099578515,
-0.1344223171,
-0.2432164252,
-0.3709291816,
-0.9519757032,
-0.603949964,
0.2966604233,
0.6683238149,
-0.1425596774,
0.0707501546,
0.4101398587,
0.1440165788,
0.0080279578,
-0.0474487469,
-0.6694078445,
0.109360218,
-0.0630492643,
-0.6366869807,
0.2988314331,
-0.405764848,
0.6948937774,
0.5073676705,
0.0053730886,
-0.0548430942,
0.2491731346,
0.2156614661,
-0.8046135306,
0.1822641045,
-0.8350937366,
0.148968786,
-0.223682642,
0.0204094909,
-0.5936173201,
-0.0522085354,
0.4672335088,
-0.6163060665,
0.0129763428,
0.1572066545,
0.8803297281,
0.145856753,
-0.4364709854,
-0.1724368632,
-0.4944981635,
0.79811728,
-0.8704693317,
0.4000264406,
0.1226404905,
0.6531945467,
-0.3106116652,
-0.7650566697,
-0.7018509507,
-0.1432248056,
-0.376948446,
0.1912095994,
-0.2921316326,
-0.2191632241,
0.2683279514,
-0.0542688854,
-0.4323476553,
0.5068054199,
-0.0547531545,
0.1834135354,
0.0395191535,
0.0609632097,
0.0317346714,
-0.0343394354,
-0.6211751103,
-0.1179246083,
-1.0486502647,
0.2123655081,
-0.0152645968,
0.7145949602,
-0.287830323,
0.276522547,
-0.1730246395,
0.5449694991,
0.3468578458,
-0.0970618278,
0.2572919726,
0.1973430812,
-0.4249227941,
0.3231460452,
0.5217775106,
0.2962349951,
-0.12583296,
-0.2076294124,
-0.4022361338,
-0.1160387844,
-0.2178608328,
-1.0927034616,
-0.1423796564,
-0.1281666309,
-0.4272508919,
-0.1396122426,
0.0720848665,
-0.7458395958,
-0.1636664718,
-0.0791679695,
0.5543022752,
-0.4748054147,
-0.1439021677,
-0.2060294896,
-0.1013533175,
0.5431709886,
0.1564200073,
-0.8791940212,
0.736487031,
0.4360764921,
0.6850091219,
-0.324924022,
-0.1877862364,
-0.6853248477,
0.2681069374,
-0.3421278894,
0.9555734396,
-0.5918825269,
-0.267721355,
-0.1790337712,
-0.130561009,
0.0259601101,
-0.809817791,
0.0024411452,
-0.6870419383,
0.2674310803,
-0.0795482174,
-0.6267320514,
-0.2739960551,
0.6105100513,
-0.5701441169,
0.7805894613,
0.1408247948,
-0.8425036669,
0.845517695,
-0.7341909409,
-0.2917995751,
0.3508416712,
-0.6123689413,
-0.5995518565,
-0.0269952361,
0.1997057348,
0.5254563689,
-0.0383389592,
-0.1394403428,
-0.0054755621,
-0.4817241728,
0.0020225085,
-0.0650329515,
0.5339153409,
-0.0917435884,
-0.6580579877,
-0.0339787826,
-0.8278127909,
-0.1595549434,
0.181475088,
-0.2650693655,
-0.6121739745,
-0.3102869689,
0.1607438326,
0.3326860666,
-0.1421135068,
-0.5251775384,
0.0208596867,
-0.7506000996,
0.1953532398,
0.2957191169,
0.2767982185,
0.5684204698,
-0.1660654992,
0.3386811912,
0.5694828629,
-0.3673764467,
-0.3172337115,
0.036731679,
-0.5688077807,
-0.3793111145,
0.3380613625,
0.3741146028,
-0.6667634249,
0.202527687,
-0.0857000723,
-0.066447027,
-0.0436855145,
-0.1050695479,
0.6109573841,
0.8908453584,
0.5782575607,
-0.1485870481,
-0.6549187899,
-0.9524610639,
0.1915091127,
0.0366502292,
-0.0447991639,
0.6301870942,
0.8693668842,
-0.179030776,
1.0504029989,
-0.1415213048,
-0.5611758232,
-0.3269830942,
0.3247646987,
0.2376200557,
0.5074353218,
0.585037291,
-0.8482021093,
-0.6418480873,
0.0054988931,
-0.7399536967,
0.2662043869,
-0.0502584875,
0.006825055,
-0.0117058977,
0.6482983232,
-0.3682629764,
0.2986718118,
-0.0007477824,
0.1419696063,
0.3425543904,
0.1029536277,
-0.0523370355,
-1.238484621,
-0.2799752951,
0.0189848728,
-0.3409733772,
-0.440595299,
0.1322634816,
0.0346421562,
-0.0433074906,
-0.8061680198,
0.7572011352,
-0.7019841671,
-0.1600479633,
-0.1981481165,
0.2624330223,
-0.2235218138,
0.2848199308,
0.2796425521,
0.6628561616,
0.8582180738,
-0.6728276014,
-0.0386275463,
0.3000813127,
-0.2670058906,
0.8060054183,
-0.5015449524,
0.2090830505,
-0.4385735989,
0.4261106849,
-0.7647504807,
-0.3027272522,
0.2124247104,
-0.1088452563,
0.7066774964,
-0.3466111422,
-0.3039417863,
0.0356929004,
-0.2429605871,
0.4168367982,
0.5005027652,
-1.0648657084,
0.4909484982,
0.031826023,
0.159284085,
-0.5831909776,
-0.8834324479,
0.0621222146,
-0.4922885895,
-0.0701083094,
0.6919237971,
0.072437413,
-0.165106982,
0.1647966653,
0.0143505065,
-0.1828691959,
-0.0830333605,
0.0918528587,
0.0062048137,
-0.5813102722,
0.1741602421,
0.0323585458,
-0.192169264,
-0.2977451384,
-0.2774168849,
0.237549603,
-0.3816612065,
-0.2995280623,
-0.3838168383,
0.5481535196,
0.1102803797,
-0.0715170726,
0.6467354894,
0.2730973959,
-0.9691527486,
-0.4206979275,
-0.2542822957,
-0.4260801971,
-0.3304114044,
0.1747562289,
-0.7397363186,
-0.9332725406,
0.4748032391,
-0.3729290366,
-0.0650065616,
0.1595431566,
0.2493072301,
0.0597722605,
0.7515643835,
0.6803712845,
0.1280383617,
0.5362151861,
-0.4475387633,
0.2172451764,
-1.1120017767,
-0.2809037864,
-0.3229113817,
-0.29648,
-0.2773864567,
-0.005873207,
0.338217169,
0.426954776,
-0.3664737046,
0.4763418138,
-0.3150892854,
0.9374325871,
0.4355456829,
0.2341543883,
0.1170274243,
-0.1028660461,
-0.5654824972,
-0.2730894089,
-0.5324575901,
-0.7266834378,
0.7053903341,
-0.0912176818,
0.7703446746,
0.3123411238,
1.3600920439,
-0.1854220033,
0.4169001579,
-0.7267226577,
0.3963524103,
-0.1294335425,
-0.2920204699,
-0.2733062506,
0.0457750596,
-0.947191,
0.3263852596,
-0.2707372904,
-1.1172504425,
0.4469082057,
0.0735533163,
-0.6378726959,
0.1454057395,
-0.5426666141,
0.7679932117,
-0.1273809075,
-0.2556708455,
0.11545562,
-0.8605306745,
0.3105880916,
0.0048893825,
-0.1722332388,
0.3034003675,
-0.0748537928,
0.4679911435,
-0.0232719257,
0.9238013029,
-0.1782871634,
0.4145326018,
0.112284258,
0.0743735358,
0.7129636407,
0.2445205748,
-0.1315746158,
-0.3158045709,
-0.3805840015,
-0.0689970478,
-0.6754377484,
0.7764627337,
-0.3982214034,
-0.2194301933,
-0.3431999683,
0.002905702,
-0.0298532061,
0.3909308016,
0.6591846943,
0.5713834763,
-0.4202254117,
0.4240845144,
0.7197290659,
-0.0108130462,
0.7080113292,
0.4016393721,
0.0567698888,
-0.169304654,
0.6081608534,
-0.0505722538,
-0.0516756065,
0.755138278,
0.087045297,
-0.382615447,
-0.7102954984,
-0.4288453162,
-0.0645854324,
-0.9914132357,
-0.5424824953,
-0.6895555258,
-0.0930058137,
-0.1766032279,
-0.4785811305,
-0.2138651758,
0.0764473304,
-0.776253581,
-0.2132220864,
0.0379703976,
0.5731340051,
0.1361436248,
0.5085024834,
-0.3281881809,
0.3377779722,
0.3994222879,
0.2948353291,
0.0704846382,
-0.4246391952,
0.0029063616,
-0.2744588256,
-0.0520929731,
-0.9294961095,
0.2665943205,
0.4763722122,
0.8848165274,
0.5212441683,
0.1474737227,
0.596897006,
-0.6270759106,
0.7513962984,
0.2997764051,
-0.8105410337,
0.7308488488,
0.1264581382,
0.1766317338,
0.78374511,
0.6063440442,
-0.1105944216,
-0.0035914327,
-0.6079826355,
-0.838745594,
0.4616287351,
-0.0457872972,
0.0429071747,
-0.3694573045,
0.2490143627,
0.3862527609,
0.0445197672,
-1.0757904053,
-0.0772724971,
-0.0906850174,
-0.2279009968,
0.2858267128,
-0.1406728178,
-0.0083445264,
0.0957238376,
0.7667680383,
-0.4239294529,
-0.005671679,
0.2696798444,
-0.5199462175,
0.1037542298,
0.7205102444,
0.3868501782,
0.4230142236,
-0.1424031854,
0.319319129,
0.4951390624,
0.230065912,
0.1462488323,
0.1416427195,
-0.3963791728,
-0.0215671565,
0.2879574001,
0.9568516612,
0.8053508997,
-0.5092207193,
0.7160665393,
-0.0395765714,
0.0646611303,
-0.4325891435,
-0.2079192698,
-0.0220848545,
0.5725844502,
0.3392661512,
-0.2306549102,
0.474462688,
-0.3679482043,
0.4204500914,
0.5759331584,
-0.5827585459,
-0.1371939778,
0.5756800175,
-0.0919634402,
-0.2910303473,
0.663402915,
-0.6755545139,
-0.4958471358,
0.4862291813,
1.2251009941,
0.8793057203,
0.040292304,
0.0473074503,
0.4780934453,
0.0553057715,
-0.0393968895,
0.0842880011,
-0.2117486596,
-0.742195189,
-0.0189425852,
-0.3610824645,
-0.4507654011,
0.2791539133,
-0.669387877,
0.6563917398,
-0.3376169205,
0.0937394872,
-0.0062334188,
-0.1632837206,
-0.823613286,
0.2100371271,
0.4492538273,
0.6831895113,
-0.8412597179,
0.4772395492,
0.8671827316,
-0.6309179068,
-0.6143501401,
0.1293169409,
0.1057124734,
-0.2516358197,
1.1190295219,
0.5589744449,
-0.3874615431,
0.3700642288,
-0.7763208747,
-0.699524343,
1.2068796158,
0.2758772373,
-0.7142570615,
0.06551373,
-0.4332379103,
0.4683347642,
-1.1036407948,
0.5702515244,
0.4075822234,
0.1284166873,
0.1120283008,
-0.5300995708,
-0.0217556134,
-0.0048013409,
0.1697169542,
0.0125696398,
-0.4432020485,
0.7111652493,
-0.5187239647,
-0.4870871007,
-0.0286521539,
0.731503129,
0.6445194483,
0.4787970781,
0.6025639772,
0.5489882827,
0.6562321186,
0.1449818015,
0.8056007624,
0.1686377823,
0.242440626,
1.588529706,
-0.6789315343,
1.1100901365,
0.5500589013,
0.1073174402,
0.8798323274,
0.6577929258,
-0.0543786846,
0.9300271869,
0.3880318403,
-0.4953066111,
-0.1705788672,
-0.3653204143,
-0.1223488674,
0.4603789449,
0.446408689,
-0.2154866159,
-0.7473157048,
0.3495810628,
-0.2509113848,
0.0257858802,
-0.084057875,
1.1160488129,
0.2002741992,
-0.1164129451,
0.2882277668,
-0.3163289428,
0.9037755132,
-0.3478657901,
-0.5665752292,
-0.0384445749,
0.0350659639,
-0.2568148673,
-0.4712552428,
-0.1533629745,
-0.0991067737,
-0.2696034014,
0.1266850382,
0.8264674544,
-0.5102995634,
-0.093729049,
0.4785332084,
0.3176336288,
0.3732187152,
0.0944592357,
-0.5370621085,
-0.5105651021,
-0.4776876569,
-0.1742621362,
0.3821659684,
0.4182083309,
-0.3021305203,
0.4752916992,
0.4002414048,
-0.1209254861,
0.1256459206,
0.4025977552,
0.9000312686,
-0.5791491866,
-0.7001149654,
-0.8026512265,
0.4899741411,
-0.1146120206,
-0.3654027879,
0.3719953001,
0.7640718222,
1.1840965748,
-0.101963602,
0.6803113818,
0.0135715641,
0.5207803249,
-0.5282569528,
0.2295125127,
-0.3705995977,
0.1380086243,
-0.1624487787,
-0.7910814285,
-0.6447924972,
0.6323497891,
-0.1185075045,
-0.0882417485,
0.8044278026,
0.7364847064,
-0.3819212914,
-0.2715500295,
0.5010510087,
0.0693219155,
0.305513382,
0.7991178036,
0.9034487605,
-0.5698168874,
0.4238151014,
-0.3774145246,
-0.1510209888,
-0.2901822925,
-1.1254652739,
-0.9550769925,
-0.4544825256,
-0.38529706,
0.0301392823,
0.1791951805,
1.2618203163,
0.8894915581,
-0.9613763094,
0.1064436063,
-0.1610640287,
0.0356299765,
-0.1802747697,
-0.2627690434,
0.3596109152,
-0.3795691729,
-0.6590863466,
0.6931208968,
0.408324331,
0.329890579,
0.163787663,
-0.1008636579,
-0.2656010985,
-0.4217438102,
0.6399512887,
0.4626294672,
-0.8490457535,
-0.3298158348,
-0.2228267342,
-0.1452504396,
0.3093879223,
0.7544025183,
-1.162576437,
0.3212262988,
0.3457198143,
0.8055452108,
0.7513103485,
-0.113586925,
0.0781872049,
-0.996724546,
0.1433125883,
0.4804797471,
0.5216392279,
0.6023110747,
-0.4394010901,
0.3168931007,
-0.0533391461,
-0.2985246181,
-0.6740984917,
0.3437127769,
-0.8315581679,
-0.0866874605,
0.8311007619,
-0.359372288,
-0.1068151221,
-0.1352091581,
-0.0299524106,
0.1499647945,
-0.5216879249,
0.3795641363,
0.3951636851,
-0.4818523824,
-0.5669548512,
-0.1711368263,
0.3163222671,
0.0686439872,
-0.9257438779,
-0.3787977695,
0.42513749,
0.3722760677,
0.0178176686,
0.6100796461,
-0.1244632453,
0.1304215193,
-0.0165765267,
-0.1088748649,
0.0341771543,
-0.4674997926,
-0.6794431806,
0.0820045099,
0.0791825503,
-0.2869176567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01176v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01176v2
|
CorpusLM: Towards a Unified Language Model on Corpus for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks
| 2024-02-02T06:44:22 | 2024-04-21T08:33:32 |
Xiaoxi Li, Zhicheng Dou, Yujia Zhou, Fangchao Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large language models (LLMs) have gained significant attention in various
fields but prone to hallucination, especially in knowledge-intensive (KI)
tasks. To address this, retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a
popular solution to enhance factual accuracy. However, traditional retrieval
modules often rely on large document index and disconnect with generative
tasks. With the advent of generative retrieval (GR), language models can
retrieve by directly generating document identifiers (DocIDs), offering
superior performance in retrieval tasks. However, the potential relationship
between GR and downstream tasks remains unexplored. In this paper, we propose
\textbf{CorpusLM}, a unified language model that leverages external corpus to
tackle various knowledge-intensive tasks by integrating generative retrieval,
closed-book generation, and RAG through a unified greedy decoding process. We
design the following mechanisms to facilitate effective retrieval and
generation, and improve the end-to-end effectiveness of KI tasks: (1) We
develop a ranking-oriented DocID list generation strategy, which refines GR by
directly learning from a DocID ranking list, to improve retrieval quality. (2)
We design a continuous DocIDs-References-Answer generation strategy, which
facilitates effective and efficient RAG. (3) We employ well-designed
unsupervised DocID understanding tasks, to comprehend DocID semantics and their
relevance to downstream tasks. We evaluate our approach on the widely used KILT
benchmark with two variants of backbone models, i.e., T5 and Llama2.
Experimental results demonstrate the superior performance of our models in both
retrieval and downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.1529275626,
-0.4922425449,
0.519028604,
-0.1135858372,
-0.4592050314,
0.1600543708,
-0.3881784678,
-0.3196307421,
-0.066181615,
0.8478492498,
-0.0609926619,
-0.6500121355,
-0.6035141349,
-0.129359901,
-0.6163263321,
1.0358237028,
0.3293718696,
-0.0322560929,
-0.5690310001,
-0.0157740861,
-0.5149402022,
-0.7611197233,
-0.4413842559,
-0.2520521581,
0.6459748149,
0.2647026181,
0.4738279283,
0.477291435,
0.3938432634,
0.2164181918,
-0.1956032664,
0.5490269065,
-0.7411776185,
0.5015332103,
-0.2800624073,
-0.3511722386,
-0.3120316863,
-0.320774138,
0.5814451575,
0.9862214327,
-0.1543752402,
0.2458365262,
0.3092594445,
0.4746807516,
-0.7769607306,
0.1015739143,
-0.9326137304,
-0.3427255452,
-0.3516117334,
-0.2378655225,
-0.5564320683,
0.0715986788,
-0.2690235674,
-0.6214671135,
0.3819764256,
0.1651998609,
0.6694434881,
0.2719891369,
-0.3854090273,
-0.35548383,
-0.7072831988,
0.7393710017,
-0.529676199,
0.531439662,
0.4444709718,
-0.0812357515,
-0.128903687,
-0.8132138252,
-0.2592854202,
-0.2482619733,
-0.2464258373,
0.1879196763,
0.059891995,
-0.0123068625,
0.1553082317,
0.152072072,
-0.5365207791,
0.0218107235,
-0.4687147439,
-0.1047418043,
0.6005439758,
0.3271789551,
0.1442434043,
-0.2089893371,
-0.3734207749,
0.1063762531,
-0.700999856,
-0.0848984644,
0.2628240883,
0.3011207879,
0.2250674367,
0.6612698436,
-0.0962661356,
0.8297646642,
-0.1684868932,
-0.2374818325,
-0.1038490683,
-0.2760635912,
-0.0921028778,
-0.2682717741,
0.5144466162,
0.0295661744,
0.1262823641,
-0.6104052067,
-0.5301676989,
0.1000179946,
0.6304283738,
-0.5133824348,
-0.0133098345,
0.2995288968,
-0.2558463514,
-0.4295593798,
-0.0834862292,
-0.5756995678,
-0.4042325318,
-0.5700390339,
0.2299395204,
-0.6134710312,
-0.3777017295,
-0.1263685971,
-0.1591729969,
0.1017532423,
0.2799962163,
-0.8189429641,
0.3286242783,
0.8173843622,
0.5687895417,
-0.4077602327,
-0.1517715603,
-0.785820663,
0.475538373,
-0.3906366527,
0.8847936392,
-0.5816124678,
-0.6769060493,
0.0423338972,
-0.3064950109,
-0.2783451378,
-0.5450155735,
0.8769472241,
-0.9001463056,
-0.0378234461,
-0.1111416966,
-0.7366486192,
-0.1187045127,
0.1911287457,
-0.5464850664,
1.1106014252,
0.2410816103,
-0.8751937151,
0.1139089689,
-0.7430018187,
-0.466604948,
0.4155718982,
-0.1353090256,
0.0169399995,
0.1212600619,
-0.1203348115,
0.5090250969,
-0.6134770513,
0.7186279893,
-0.1998961568,
-0.2721710801,
0.0962860212,
-0.3278556168,
0.6920719147,
0.4444684386,
-0.0019638655,
0.2128073275,
-0.655338347,
-0.0020178969,
0.1412963718,
-0.3710010648,
-0.6551056504,
-0.1165530011,
0.373482585,
-0.0617556348,
0.311789304,
-0.4826637506,
0.2402747571,
-0.1519481689,
0.0531360358,
0.6805492043,
-0.1914989352,
0.5569216013,
-0.3407176733,
0.4004736245,
-0.0759145543,
0.0346949846,
-0.0072471043,
-0.3306230605,
-0.5449252725,
-0.3083826005,
0.5084202886,
0.2809774578,
-0.4993684292,
0.2073199451,
-0.5167837739,
-0.4752359092,
-0.4679650664,
0.453047663,
0.5621039867,
0.6530565023,
0.2258897424,
-0.1523622721,
-0.4368574321,
-0.4082131088,
-0.0423523672,
0.0243257973,
-0.1805204898,
0.2559247911,
0.2223880291,
-0.2753272951,
0.9002649188,
-0.4441317916,
-0.3838410974,
-0.3824289441,
0.3073908091,
0.1501226425,
0.2545327842,
0.2025566399,
-1.1667217016,
-0.2872790098,
0.0476951636,
-0.8703084588,
-0.2288587242,
0.2136883587,
-0.2828224897,
0.5582453609,
0.5450733304,
-0.8043186665,
0.2197590172,
0.3081247807,
-0.3662936985,
0.6395163536,
-0.425720036,
-0.2535119951,
-1.0275610685,
0.5902321935,
-0.4659917653,
-0.1131007299,
-0.6004782915,
0.4943984151,
0.2184689045,
-0.1087379754,
-0.3641707897,
0.8147717118,
-0.6694984436,
-0.3113494217,
-0.2728240788,
0.2352902442,
0.1685249358,
0.4694015682,
0.0109558273,
0.6685195565,
0.3824384212,
-0.814440012,
0.1600521803,
0.1606623828,
-0.1873673946,
0.3361490667,
-0.4746640623,
0.0972432122,
-0.362901181,
0.0606788881,
-0.8505297899,
-0.2406581491,
-0.1614234746,
-0.3634328246,
0.5705145597,
-0.1146048978,
-0.6749991775,
-0.3154349029,
0.0293819364,
0.3117234409,
0.6575158238,
-0.5371197462,
0.7974068522,
0.477542311,
-0.0863440856,
-0.6913623214,
-0.084158875,
0.0255545396,
-0.1631568074,
-0.7030041218,
0.5907618999,
-0.0563076288,
-0.3090657294,
0.2534241378,
-0.0928012133,
0.1071831882,
0.1489400268,
0.2681511641,
0.5579307675,
0.0770508721,
0.4076964557,
-0.0211337712,
-0.0650882795,
-0.1301965415,
-0.4861566722,
0.7457011342,
0.1947371066,
-0.2806499004,
0.2926228046,
0.5408622622,
0.772767067,
-0.6185269952,
0.5578526258,
0.8995747566,
-0.1708417684,
-0.1757031083,
-0.858048737,
-0.1068831757,
-0.3684735894,
0.2275382727,
-0.6662872434,
-0.7095196247,
0.4554434121,
-0.1986518651,
0.1203055307,
0.517857492,
0.5753343105,
-0.2391437441,
0.8883578181,
0.5992894769,
-0.1053944454,
0.0322222225,
-0.4268368483,
-0.1544021368,
-1.2269490957,
-0.2569702864,
-0.5074852109,
0.1138125584,
-0.1685565859,
-0.5147904754,
0.5238773823,
0.5617811084,
-0.1546520144,
0.169811517,
-0.5567917824,
0.1143024117,
0.7787693143,
-0.0467746332,
0.4593068063,
0.0430107564,
-0.6178107858,
0.3936893642,
-0.9488738179,
-0.4909358323,
1.5613434315,
-0.1511963457,
0.7276064157,
0.1231400818,
0.7271899581,
0.4065773487,
0.5944164991,
-0.4518277347,
0.5125787854,
-0.3872331083,
-0.573888123,
-0.3867997527,
-0.3545775712,
-1.2912986279,
0.4105377495,
-0.1885953993,
-0.606377244,
-0.1620514691,
-0.1678088754,
-0.0991227925,
0.3360095024,
-0.5188109279,
0.7842116952,
-0.252794981,
-0.5107970834,
-0.2831705213,
-0.594255209,
0.4713791311,
-0.2626753449,
0.3866256177,
-0.0004511056,
-0.1490383893,
0.5202075839,
-0.4461920261,
0.7438040376,
-0.1763212383,
-0.1587426662,
0.4372861981,
-0.0179554708,
0.7097930312,
-0.0308187492,
-0.2248630971,
0.0478926674,
-0.0017990788,
-0.454264313,
-0.5879667997,
0.6452285051,
-0.6032159328,
-0.7585604191,
-0.18655698,
-0.8135961294,
-0.1745289266,
0.2142057568,
0.4002301991,
0.6900146604,
-0.2385852486,
0.0219187867,
0.7312269211,
0.0874383524,
0.3309910297,
0.6816846132,
-0.3089788854,
-0.026965864,
0.8863730431,
0.0338936374,
0.124500744,
0.523837924,
0.0331090242,
-0.5955277681,
-0.587885499,
-0.5610463023,
0.2334551215,
-0.6119348407,
-0.2971001565,
-0.9637169242,
-0.2823464274,
-0.7426303029,
0.07254114,
-0.0909022689,
-0.1167625487,
-0.3689388335,
0.1968019307,
0.3285531104,
0.6725512743,
-0.0651965663,
-0.2920576632,
-0.9624988437,
0.565208137,
0.2033422291,
0.2583059371,
0.0814629495,
-0.675780654,
-0.1028002873,
-0.0459309444,
-0.1995861083,
-0.6170102954,
0.4949052036,
-0.0360327549,
0.6341043115,
0.2698877156,
0.4143280387,
0.3315854073,
-0.4339177907,
0.383285135,
-0.0178123321,
-0.5933309197,
0.1836386174,
-0.5107858181,
0.2164923996,
0.2538818717,
0.3223518729,
-0.4853361845,
-0.5959966183,
-0.6337214112,
-0.9250855446,
0.4369964898,
0.1258595735,
0.1421390623,
-0.0376226865,
0.1144759879,
0.2087110579,
0.1035502255,
-0.2516681552,
0.0332632363,
0.0830413848,
-0.2426783442,
0.0162754711,
-0.3880378306,
-0.190704301,
-0.0559001602,
0.6331977844,
-0.1780252308,
0.1648354232,
0.2280775905,
-0.3086285591,
0.054752361,
0.4588823915,
0.4110701978,
0.5452612638,
-0.2714370489,
0.0743657053,
-0.0493740924,
-0.5107403398,
-0.105738841,
0.2852880657,
-0.3630952835,
0.1405169964,
0.2332701534,
0.5136150122,
0.2891560495,
-0.9190507531,
0.4076572061,
0.1857402176,
-0.0891231522,
-0.5422464609,
-0.0170953721,
0.3911836147,
0.0947541222,
0.587416172,
-0.054028064,
0.1528288573,
-0.3954798579,
0.1943508685,
0.6546979547,
-0.0707733408,
0.0508888438,
0.9035617709,
0.243273899,
-0.1175080761,
0.6134126186,
-0.5020235777,
-0.3840021491,
0.4779342711,
0.6276599765,
0.6208463311,
-0.0326088481,
0.1744332165,
0.2537954152,
-0.0360563546,
-0.0460358635,
0.2201318294,
-0.2677843869,
-0.6822980046,
-0.5472199321,
-1.0782051086,
-0.27673769,
0.0784777552,
-0.71614182,
0.1045309678,
0.0968665779,
-0.0086021917,
-0.1190463081,
-0.1631043404,
-0.7774429321,
0.1594414562,
0.0936956182,
0.6805933118,
-0.2014345378,
1.1904911995,
0.6389268637,
-0.5122320652,
-0.8205500245,
-0.2000439465,
-0.2391190231,
-0.6951995492,
0.9555237889,
-0.1095042527,
-0.0051425151,
0.1758099794,
-0.3310409784,
-1.0068222284,
1.1456438303,
0.2004870921,
-0.4959286451,
-0.3138501644,
0.0617423691,
0.4777855575,
-0.39685449,
0.1801142693,
0.3101568222,
0.4432575703,
0.1300492138,
-0.6671021581,
0.0837900639,
-0.3848124743,
0.1728125811,
0.2753134668,
-0.3963440359,
0.7309610248,
-0.3138892353,
-0.3455372453,
0.3297240138,
0.4602692425,
0.2776636779,
0.3156032562,
0.5734676123,
0.6488679051,
0.9202964902,
0.1050598025,
1.4017800093,
-0.5474957824,
0.1301953048,
1.1240620613,
-0.3279592693,
0.8854839802,
0.2911371589,
0.0048528193,
0.3045989573,
0.2522034943,
0.0865852609,
0.3306239545,
0.2226183861,
-0.4256103635,
-0.3056224585,
-0.4458205998,
-0.231227994,
0.5043191314,
0.5047274232,
-0.3180027604,
-0.2245723754,
0.1967224777,
-0.079046391,
0.2534507811,
-0.3808477819,
0.8394262195,
-0.0316389762,
-0.9733323455,
0.9000692964,
0.0228098463,
0.732324481,
-0.5806668997,
0.1374465525,
-0.3222436905,
-0.0679826364,
-0.012864219,
-0.5605562925,
0.3958505988,
0.2048075944,
-0.3343465328,
-0.1233070567,
1.1413762569,
-0.6586229205,
-0.5478518009,
0.5539021492,
0.6224803329,
0.2735736668,
-0.3113237619,
-0.3468919992,
0.0467699282,
-0.2488872856,
-0.1572866142,
0.59977597,
0.3670850396,
-0.173098594,
0.6190853119,
0.8533759713,
-0.0077856639,
0.0159805436,
0.3019117713,
0.9000720382,
-0.5214674473,
-0.2493641973,
-0.3539116681,
0.469229579,
-0.1341339797,
-0.0348517187,
0.4539931118,
0.5884057879,
0.72878474,
-0.2114089131,
0.77210325,
-0.0950471163,
0.7695324421,
-0.4851781428,
0.8110901117,
-0.7388168573,
0.2735881507,
-0.0652579591,
-0.8333178759,
-0.1772354394,
-0.1940916926,
-0.0488097146,
-0.2450870574,
0.7277649641,
0.7798604369,
-0.0738033205,
-0.1749023348,
0.676363945,
0.1202469543,
-0.0426133759,
0.405231148,
0.6196599007,
-0.1410998106,
0.9470335841,
-0.1221430302,
0.067786105,
-0.2154639661,
-0.3886108398,
-0.7333397269,
-0.7754116654,
0.0412119851,
-0.292991519,
0.2207006514,
0.5636782646,
0.5961449146,
-0.4322808385,
-0.2558027804,
-0.2555249035,
0.2114172578,
-0.1183870435,
-0.2523952723,
0.4708993733,
-0.9887667298,
-0.8083384037,
0.3037219942,
0.1497846395,
-0.2609598637,
-0.1921673864,
-0.0469954908,
-0.1113282442,
-0.063387014,
0.7598247528,
0.1557829976,
-0.8917469382,
-0.0467383303,
0.1522845477,
-0.4055115879,
-0.2454541922,
0.9194384813,
-0.8218044639,
0.3231039345,
0.3028740287,
0.8736342788,
0.638594389,
0.1099023744,
0.4891707897,
-0.6131748557,
-0.0434422791,
0.3157066703,
0.353035301,
0.3584067822,
-0.3748375773,
0.895396769,
0.3426904082,
-0.4674879909,
-0.7485640049,
0.1777488142,
-0.9427407384,
-0.5922669172,
1.4030214548,
-0.1572884917,
-0.1963949651,
-0.3598754406,
-0.2058551908,
0.3908430934,
-0.2734792233,
0.7216187119,
0.453338325,
0.199297756,
0.096546337,
-0.4188139737,
0.4056851268,
0.6045254469,
-0.6743453741,
0.2546500266,
0.4711588025,
0.2372175455,
0.2466692626,
0.7461052537,
-0.2432456613,
0.1628049314,
0.0708055124,
0.187403515,
-0.1849067509,
-0.2892526984,
0.0275625456,
0.4974155724,
0.1387467533,
0.0942300633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01173v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01173v1
|
Efficient Prompt Caching via Embedding Similarity
| 2024-02-02T06:34:11 | 2024-02-02T06:34:11 |
Hanlin Zhu, Banghua Zhu, Jiantao Jiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved huge success in numerous natural
language process (NLP) tasks. However, it faces the challenge of significant
resource consumption during inference. In this paper, we aim to improve the
inference efficiency of LLMs by prompt caching, i.e., if the current prompt can
be answered by the same response of a previous prompt, one can directly utilize
that previous response without calling the LLM. Specifically, we focus on the
prediction accuracy of prompt caching for single-round question-answering tasks
via embedding similarity. The existing embeddings of prompts mostly focus on
whether two prompts are semantically similar, which is not necessarily
equivalent to whether the same response can answer them. Therefore, we propose
a distillation-based method to fine-tune the existing embeddings for better
caching prediction. Theoretically, we provide finite-sample guarantees for the
convergence of our method under different types of loss functions. Empirically,
we carefully construct a hard dataset based on Kwiatkowski et al. (2019) where
the existing embedding model (Wang et al., 2022) only achieves an AUC of 0.51.
We then fine-tune the above embedding model, which significantly improves the
AUC of caching prediction from 0.51 to 0.81. We also conduct simulations
demonstrating that our trained models achieve better caching efficiency than
the previous embedding model.
|
[
-0.3315974772,
-0.8436039686,
0.6885910034,
0.1289363503,
-0.3732450902,
-0.0380342305,
-0.262558192,
-0.0544757582,
0.280284822,
0.440086931,
-0.8646056652,
-0.3817545474,
-0.3906677663,
0.4008111656,
-0.1587465554,
0.4305844903,
0.0793189034,
-0.0312677883,
-0.5074307919,
0.0886546299,
-0.8299375772,
0.0560882427,
-0.9358667731,
-0.3244059384,
0.5525237918,
0.2927521467,
0.3510459065,
0.5535554886,
-0.1366848201,
0.3127345145,
-0.1940252185,
0.3220824897,
-0.5094901919,
0.5092419982,
-0.2016343176,
-0.5431822538,
0.0689494759,
-0.1445718408,
0.3689400554,
0.5809299946,
-0.4069056809,
-0.0976390243,
0.4439826906,
0.454410702,
-0.5307681561,
0.233473897,
-1.06722188,
0.0183298495,
0.2595100999,
-0.4134311378,
-0.5969578028,
-0.5913172364,
0.2301335186,
-0.5834405422,
0.4509164393,
0.1813865751,
0.4179419577,
0.6517118812,
-0.0943728909,
-0.303869009,
-0.2322136462,
0.8404548764,
-1.1714526415,
-0.1800331026,
0.6586446166,
0.2399372011,
-0.3295597732,
-0.7247322202,
-0.7373847365,
-0.1673169136,
0.0309047643,
-0.0053223153,
-0.1058642268,
-0.060035523,
0.2473680973,
0.1678476185,
-0.4712876678,
0.2053591162,
0.0439762399,
-0.0455587693,
0.1839073151,
0.3657576442,
0.1216478273,
0.0538522787,
-0.4008717537,
-0.0986356214,
-0.5384534001,
-0.0745313391,
0.0986924171,
0.696192801,
0.1619946361,
0.3293448687,
-0.2459337711,
0.4059443474,
0.295597285,
-0.0820335597,
0.1842314303,
-0.2727926075,
0.004565889,
0.2724293768,
0.360103339,
0.6113258004,
0.3244028986,
-0.0061845351,
-0.0359816477,
-0.2512354851,
0.2392510474,
-1.0866000652,
-0.3901649117,
0.2108169496,
-0.0997974426,
0.1139971837,
0.0617425479,
-0.577583611,
-0.6755183935,
-0.1217248291,
0.2356598973,
-0.3129532933,
0.1654854715,
0.2756311893,
-0.0375438258,
-0.0489777885,
0.636269927,
-0.771874249,
0.1337916851,
0.7036593556,
1.0379152298,
-0.0720694587,
-0.0770536587,
-0.934925437,
-0.0662352964,
-0.0420250259,
0.8189732432,
-0.629848361,
-0.4318436086,
0.2724972069,
0.31370309,
0.0450311452,
-0.492164731,
0.4506394267,
-0.7135990262,
-0.0231036767,
-0.7551964521,
-0.8766247034,
-0.2503050268,
0.408539027,
-0.9909085035,
1.0640095472,
-0.3907487988,
-0.8248875737,
0.2817617953,
-0.0303389616,
-0.2239292115,
-0.0592751093,
0.0536520109,
-0.3234438002,
0.1266104132,
0.6288276911,
0.5997638106,
-0.4682272673,
0.1651015133,
-0.5289821625,
-0.4335680306,
0.0865860209,
-0.4834518731,
0.5349584222,
0.1485856473,
-0.2497109175,
-0.3220663667,
-0.4518726468,
0.0196795911,
-0.0733426735,
-0.2126981914,
-0.4757594168,
0.0536334403,
-0.4996719956,
-0.0261460245,
0.3291660249,
-0.7145149112,
0.5031782389,
-0.390368253,
0.3984127641,
0.9439302683,
0.2213148922,
0.4266127944,
-0.3839554191,
0.57998842,
0.1471177191,
-0.3212475181,
-0.8342330456,
-0.6878129244,
-0.3485703468,
-0.0923352987,
0.2643350959,
0.4382797182,
-0.66223979,
0.4478426576,
-0.1859121025,
-0.3461872935,
-0.6139315963,
0.0697323829,
0.3290208578,
0.6561197042,
0.4487424493,
-0.1329279691,
-0.1988240331,
-0.4627598226,
-0.2086330801,
-0.0529700965,
-0.1323364824,
0.2951117158,
0.1401887387,
0.1218097135,
0.9152764082,
-0.69595474,
0.0826923102,
-0.0332756005,
0.2569636703,
0.5461747646,
0.4300976694,
0.3509872258,
-0.475728035,
-0.6818392873,
-0.4013230801,
-0.3839078844,
-0.3791843057,
-0.1204646826,
0.1359566748,
0.1312484294,
0.6127784252,
-0.4569604993,
0.5210801959,
0.2585875094,
-0.3093284369,
0.3888457417,
-0.3621585071,
0.3717084825,
-1.1515108347,
-0.0785477236,
-0.1487344503,
-0.1308382303,
-0.2911457717,
-0.1957213283,
0.1085528135,
0.0538597181,
-0.3724790514,
0.9612326622,
-0.5405796766,
0.1951607019,
-0.3976928592,
0.2021248639,
0.2656371295,
0.480606705,
-0.3683867753,
0.9117826223,
0.469112128,
-0.7012451887,
0.2301421613,
0.2229646146,
-0.3586846888,
0.2959213853,
-0.8837168217,
0.3232677877,
-0.3070633411,
0.5346814394,
-1.493547678,
0.349981308,
-0.0248688143,
-0.2245833725,
0.3216077387,
-0.2947998047,
-0.6315975189,
-0.4125184715,
-0.5602121353,
0.2355328798,
0.4120481312,
-0.7665294409,
0.5248941183,
0.0041924412,
-0.4881457984,
-0.7010307312,
-0.80236274,
-0.2431664616,
-0.1799260527,
-0.4108752906,
0.427895695,
-0.2032912225,
0.1786470115,
-0.0240594521,
-0.2530490458,
0.1303649843,
0.0551592596,
0.2999392152,
-0.1375731975,
-0.1704357713,
0.4705685079,
0.1532830149,
-0.2245956808,
-0.1752984375,
-0.344369024,
0.8249344826,
0.179594323,
-0.4905924499,
-0.649487555,
0.3709914088,
0.2357206941,
0.0540499166,
0.9281062484,
0.3562361002,
-0.3852553964,
-0.2481731176,
-0.8321923018,
-0.5023270845,
-0.5575634837,
0.046472054,
-0.2665768564,
-0.8070194721,
1.0206393003,
-0.083311893,
0.2972920537,
0.1775191873,
0.448381424,
-0.04842766,
0.8100782037,
0.3689339757,
-0.161663875,
0.5290722847,
-0.1508546174,
0.0480260588,
-0.4881510437,
-0.1443205178,
-0.8103112578,
-0.4581449926,
-0.4265801907,
-0.7043551803,
-0.0000214646,
0.2102755606,
-0.3525257707,
0.1890801787,
-0.2905608416,
0.5299829841,
0.5985212326,
0.1778019518,
0.3329140544,
0.1938610077,
-0.4510471523,
-0.096195586,
-0.6707479358,
-0.52541399,
0.8468184471,
0.0864870027,
1.0292904377,
-0.3139930069,
0.7155950069,
0.4121034741,
-0.1327685416,
-0.446600616,
0.4333814383,
-0.0205048081,
-0.3097709715,
-0.2982278168,
-0.3473937213,
-0.9995880723,
0.0771320984,
0.1264985502,
-0.8132392764,
0.0026799007,
0.2518312037,
-0.5736424327,
0.5538535118,
-0.6149604321,
0.6024166346,
0.292886883,
-0.369366169,
-0.2770343423,
-0.5207832456,
-0.195951432,
0.0104055554,
-0.1572526693,
-0.2846357524,
-0.077518113,
0.5620790124,
-0.6256518364,
1.0707160234,
-0.5241516829,
-0.1439127326,
0.4974340796,
0.0077208015,
0.906164825,
0.2137538195,
-0.5204150677,
-0.2230048925,
0.0973618403,
-0.6248674989,
-0.9213076234,
1.0021113157,
-0.4118860364,
-0.719455719,
-0.2677896917,
-0.1942864507,
-0.1155750453,
0.0672283024,
0.103607446,
0.4950719476,
-0.1924491972,
0.0824231431,
0.7655494809,
-0.4643903971,
0.6688739061,
0.4143023789,
-0.1544695646,
0.0101047112,
0.3279160261,
-0.0499617979,
0.0794850215,
0.462729305,
0.3676699996,
-0.621289134,
-0.3597077727,
-0.4290588498,
0.1517681181,
-0.7398489118,
-0.4908776581,
-0.9997966886,
0.2737964988,
-0.4274562895,
-0.2222205102,
-0.4151048064,
-0.3079221249,
-0.5983259082,
-0.1230108365,
0.9189574718,
0.4179037511,
0.1486680508,
0.4565435648,
-0.7759783268,
0.126659438,
0.2858468592,
0.2548640966,
0.5955552459,
-0.7908322215,
-0.0699545592,
0.3409382999,
-0.2668553889,
-0.7952592373,
0.433657378,
0.2505672872,
0.5039384365,
0.4625047743,
0.4799876809,
0.9824789762,
-0.6711780429,
0.9143205881,
0.1283820122,
-0.579262197,
0.4843969345,
0.0521292426,
0.6522491574,
1.0683389902,
0.445566833,
-0.4767197967,
-0.1768240035,
-0.3423100114,
-1.0743308067,
0.3538480401,
-0.2242359072,
0.4581612945,
-0.4802081585,
0.5924457312,
0.4853114188,
0.191502586,
-0.1959061027,
-0.2025693357,
0.1567521244,
0.0019410555,
-0.1086740047,
-0.1317144334,
0.4352890849,
-0.1500555426,
0.7107638717,
-0.2079747915,
0.2424775213,
0.0559570342,
0.0701721534,
0.0310580879,
0.1448223144,
0.1104950607,
0.3843722939,
-0.1657540351,
0.3421933949,
0.5299235582,
-0.4241815805,
0.1399148554,
0.0361632779,
0.039356783,
0.16900222,
0.1925569177,
0.6001543999,
0.4806227088,
-0.7681281567,
0.442601651,
-0.2548487484,
0.3718052804,
-0.2001722753,
-0.0239026938,
0.3675760627,
0.5157583356,
0.500747025,
-0.3453552127,
0.0423308872,
-0.5273974538,
0.353741467,
0.2516926825,
-0.277218014,
-0.1304485947,
0.4038516283,
0.096641615,
-0.1065753102,
0.9181836247,
-0.2900285423,
-0.300509572,
0.6972427368,
0.5690408945,
0.9697725773,
-0.3257183433,
0.1310527325,
0.7253662348,
0.0049569379,
-0.2693663538,
0.347497642,
-0.093275696,
-0.4662806392,
-0.474016279,
-0.7819019556,
-0.2963700891,
-0.2301263362,
-0.8123437762,
0.1426439136,
-0.2951142192,
-0.2131550312,
-0.3014873862,
0.3330093324,
-0.9003204703,
-0.1730957776,
-0.1066375896,
0.9927823544,
-0.755251646,
0.608430922,
0.3190123737,
-0.1124649271,
-0.6585854292,
0.0637265816,
0.0448066927,
-0.8233011365,
0.1703123599,
0.6147475839,
-0.0987447053,
0.0942064971,
-0.4134986103,
-0.7292264104,
1.3991004229,
0.3202963471,
-0.9371106029,
-0.1016268134,
-0.2407927364,
0.4197739065,
-0.4241182804,
0.4646020532,
0.4283551872,
0.2809898555,
0.3129605353,
-0.6902300119,
0.5097754598,
-0.1810351759,
0.259980917,
-0.0712832287,
-0.1822871268,
0.8237342238,
-0.4634806216,
-0.5511239171,
0.356674701,
0.6368918419,
0.4252958,
0.3725410402,
0.4944467843,
0.7645500302,
0.9661480784,
0.0925097466,
1.050927639,
-0.165860042,
0.3274149299,
1.5072299242,
-0.3434959054,
0.8847786784,
0.6042762995,
-0.1927030534,
0.41655159,
0.6530593634,
0.0215313435,
0.8749529719,
0.4737488925,
-0.2806169689,
-0.1244836077,
-0.2307756394,
-0.4049629569,
-0.0988996103,
0.0946110636,
-0.3151089251,
-0.524594903,
-0.0211857129,
0.0219992734,
0.1928734928,
-0.2284086198,
0.8337333798,
0.1753771752,
-0.8376682401,
0.6232562661,
-0.1432060897,
0.8267934322,
-0.325474292,
-0.1744516939,
-0.4353272617,
-0.0334645361,
0.1287606657,
-0.6306627989,
0.0210741479,
-0.0367231444,
-0.3166242242,
-0.1651884913,
0.3962109685,
-0.5006415844,
-0.2314218581,
0.2938378751,
0.4853610694,
0.1864175349,
-0.186883688,
-0.6782505512,
-0.0287124049,
0.0096021369,
-0.4403861165,
0.2044969201,
0.5609076023,
0.2248216271,
0.6996352673,
0.5621014833,
-0.1159001961,
0.3144573569,
0.2186868489,
0.9365485311,
-0.5965860486,
-0.820828557,
-1.0103079081,
0.3671307862,
0.0175858196,
-0.233898446,
0.5466712117,
0.2977505922,
0.5268836617,
-0.0517216288,
0.4560282826,
0.1846274883,
0.5058435798,
-0.7452304959,
0.4518745542,
-0.528904736,
0.4908292294,
-0.3366735578,
-0.9674884677,
-0.0387619622,
0.5427598953,
-0.2635700703,
0.2075918019,
0.6072439551,
1.085464716,
-0.0002868505,
0.2855094969,
0.2661538422,
0.1024320796,
0.2052677721,
0.5111942887,
0.6673535705,
-0.274553448,
0.2268839628,
-0.1715096086,
-0.0957205296,
-0.4061229229,
-1.2825109959,
-0.9220184684,
-0.7299300432,
-0.2211589813,
-0.155774802,
-0.0118791535,
0.801969707,
0.3700437248,
-0.8455058932,
0.3932997882,
-0.0438301675,
-0.0715593025,
-0.2523040175,
-0.1930018067,
0.4613780081,
-0.4142897129,
-0.6854617,
0.1832922548,
0.1295584738,
-0.0165863782,
-0.0979452059,
0.0474196523,
-0.3776865304,
0.2055922747,
0.3156405091,
0.1566274166,
-0.9058502316,
-0.3641186357,
0.0591145344,
-0.0579059497,
0.031317845,
0.7962230444,
-0.8849663734,
0.6646615863,
0.6409178376,
1.0921646357,
0.7381443381,
0.1133599505,
0.4495646358,
-0.8624644279,
0.0881082267,
0.2084272504,
0.5537724495,
0.4029444456,
-0.3189543188,
0.2001818269,
-0.2065187842,
-0.4699189067,
-0.6287785172,
0.0763425156,
-1.0895344019,
-0.4162008762,
1.0056058168,
-0.6182821989,
-0.1403731555,
-0.0700872317,
-0.2408778965,
0.4661198854,
-0.788089931,
0.9062125087,
0.5350629091,
0.2456380427,
-0.0984181762,
-0.4445406199,
0.2251107991,
0.5955603719,
-0.5423806906,
0.4228129983,
0.3607676923,
0.3006878495,
0.0757435486,
0.6423566341,
0.0512989275,
0.0387248844,
0.0422192216,
-0.2562768161,
-0.1615121514,
-0.2339547873,
-0.4417240918,
0.1664618403,
-0.1497214735,
-0.0669087619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01172v1
|
Streaming Sequence Transduction through Dynamic Compression
| 2024-02-02T06:31:50 | 2024-02-02T06:31:50 |
Weiting Tan, Yunmo Chen, Tongfei Chen, Guanghui Qin, Haoran Xu, Heidi C. Zhang, Benjamin Van Durme, Philipp Koehn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We introduce STAR (Stream Transduction with Anchor Representations), a novel
Transformer-based model designed for efficient sequence-to-sequence
transduction over streams. STAR dynamically segments input streams to create
compressed anchor representations, achieving nearly lossless compression (12x)
in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) and outperforming existing methods.
Moreover, STAR demonstrates superior segmentation and latency-quality
trade-offs in simultaneous speech-to-text tasks, optimizing latency, memory
footprint, and quality.
|
[
-0.1910275817,
-0.455632627,
0.28546983,
-0.0473164357,
-0.4023157656,
0.7676592469,
-0.0874708444,
-0.5134125948,
0.5096284747,
0.2791991234,
-0.591335535,
-0.0551905558,
-0.9813584685,
0.2512837648,
-0.7529274821,
0.4959276319,
0.1765987873,
-0.0113466904,
0.321267128,
-0.0964136273,
-0.5801739097,
-0.508336544,
-0.7815250754,
-0.06469623,
0.4549070299,
0.5381079912,
0.8403783441,
1.2194651365,
0.7353332639,
0.3957882524,
-0.0831446424,
-0.0251869597,
-0.3882519305,
0.5358862877,
-0.0967324227,
-0.3288285434,
-0.3186418712,
-0.2334861755,
1.3038386106,
0.7316356301,
0.3575870693,
0.5281804204,
0.0804696605,
0.837408185,
-0.7274897099,
0.2051873952,
-0.5854316354,
-0.1442610174,
-0.2787212431,
-0.4396269023,
-0.3819324374,
-0.2941540182,
-0.0820048228,
-0.1236291006,
0.3305599093,
-0.178117767,
0.7788516879,
0.963436842,
-0.2530731261,
-0.4058569968,
-1.4200060368,
0.3913495839,
-0.3158237338,
0.8073323369,
-0.1099907681,
0.7752408385,
0.1434131414,
-1.0333673954,
-0.5981527567,
0.3319296241,
0.1064669564,
-0.1209742725,
-0.2291910052,
0.0055019744,
0.3145081103,
0.6629731655,
-0.4654271007,
-0.1075456068,
-0.3471442163,
-0.0937228799,
0.8254695535,
-0.0489986353,
0.0213576443,
-0.1605211645,
-0.0553692207,
-0.505120337,
-0.6209411621,
0.4748315215,
0.4210292399,
0.3290287554,
0.0108292289,
0.3016370833,
0.085930869,
0.6154087782,
0.2935162485,
0.094045192,
0.0549718291,
0.0247019511,
-0.1133171394,
0.5397734642,
0.5707896948,
-0.0087034246,
-0.0316067226,
0.1418628246,
-0.287407577,
0.4914590716,
0.1985066086,
-0.5737843513,
-0.2819015384,
0.3240298033,
-0.6191693544,
-0.3157985508,
0.2110907286,
-0.7999902368,
-0.1770008951,
-0.1418950111,
0.5709668994,
-0.0456621982,
0.0498237759,
0.0713703334,
-0.3076966107,
-0.0950278938,
0.1089856178,
-0.7053887844,
0.4836278558,
0.2106537223,
0.5782056451,
-0.1195592135,
0.1959088892,
-1.2923783064,
0.1950529069,
0.0702775493,
1.1095707417,
-0.9471248388,
-0.4472694397,
0.0945185944,
-0.0887613744,
0.1021107882,
-0.3286119401,
0.8224042058,
-0.6031369567,
-0.2961598933,
-0.1359290779,
-0.6939156055,
-0.53316921,
-0.5034177899,
-0.918197453,
0.6887429357,
0.0822362378,
-0.0885225236,
0.193771258,
-0.5903552771,
-0.3254745603,
0.3411734998,
-0.0845390037,
-0.1518687159,
0.1487303823,
0.2450219542,
0.4289105535,
-0.1984059513,
0.0813360959,
0.0500617549,
-0.6297183633,
0.2729017138,
-0.5943048,
0.0416358858,
0.4753879607,
-0.2751090527,
0.359526813,
-0.930634737,
-0.0665288791,
0.2417344004,
-0.5731310248,
-0.0367441177,
0.4178746045,
0.2799305022,
0.1013567522,
-0.2366637886,
-0.7117323875,
0.4119968116,
-0.1070133522,
0.8761740923,
0.2232127935,
-0.0568690002,
0.4431493878,
-0.0113556562,
0.3678560257,
-0.1468988508,
0.0290456656,
-0.6094984412,
-0.3045251667,
-0.9961764216,
-0.0236031096,
0.3702287078,
0.5883098841,
-0.8971608281,
0.4558151662,
-0.5685200691,
-0.4873103797,
-0.7241459489,
-0.1200965568,
0.1279109418,
0.3391516507,
0.5645101666,
-0.1482595652,
-0.5711702704,
-0.7271630168,
-0.3519074619,
-0.0972143561,
0.1370841861,
-0.0284892991,
0.0321718343,
-0.2171068639,
0.5467817783,
-0.5113010406,
-0.245159775,
-0.3467422426,
0.1868032962,
0.4299611747,
0.6574094296,
0.1439711899,
-0.8770233989,
-0.6947901249,
-0.4421565235,
-0.3180210888,
-0.1567504555,
-0.3312655985,
0.330211401,
-0.0919221193,
0.4594181776,
-0.4608857632,
0.5589067936,
1.0145374537,
-0.6700497866,
0.1269750744,
0.056758076,
0.1527699977,
-0.7193415165,
0.0579072945,
-0.2918125093,
-0.7254450321,
-0.8980115056,
-0.1056948975,
0.0811174139,
-0.5591371655,
-0.3234378994,
0.2770919502,
-0.7721175551,
-0.2114887089,
-0.5847973824,
-0.2315000147,
-0.2173949927,
0.3170995712,
0.4723071158,
0.7192985415,
0.5976293087,
-0.6615334153,
0.3215876818,
0.4009754956,
-0.026883848,
0.1263102442,
-0.8110173941,
0.1235899702,
-0.2424452752,
0.3668120801,
-1.03553617,
-0.1310649961,
0.1266293377,
-0.6926646233,
0.6920163631,
-0.2729318738,
-0.1873303801,
-0.6330473423,
-0.1587478817,
0.6326448917,
0.9639777541,
-0.4402448535,
0.5415857434,
0.4258449972,
-0.1843648106,
-0.3421007991,
-0.6402071714,
0.1855620891,
-0.044697579,
-0.6120864153,
0.7382285595,
0.0938626006,
0.2468458414,
0.1735569984,
-0.3149038255,
0.025865633,
-0.3613606989,
0.332919836,
0.0847722515,
-0.3982728422,
-0.2443404198,
0.0196966715,
-0.3572478294,
-0.2118983418,
-0.4844837487,
0.589620173,
-0.0621894822,
-0.4066245556,
-0.6263253093,
0.8945825696,
0.6034685373,
-0.1556310952,
0.3406451941,
0.7128725648,
-0.4312844872,
-0.3337504864,
-0.6063010693,
-0.3613210022,
-0.5883901715,
0.0132653406,
-0.2566636503,
-1.1299809217,
0.6244130135,
-0.0511759818,
-0.0625206605,
0.5460155606,
0.2149228156,
-0.1376325041,
0.8073036075,
0.4912936091,
0.266695112,
0.455655098,
-0.4030545354,
0.4423802197,
-0.6843649149,
0.0706544593,
-0.5203282237,
-0.8688658476,
-0.3988561332,
-0.9630324841,
0.4915714562,
0.2436279058,
-0.0914295018,
0.7101851106,
-0.9413076639,
0.1818976998,
0.7203209996,
-0.222029224,
0.2429349124,
-0.1798089296,
0.3024817705,
0.0282584466,
-0.979080677,
-0.5517008305,
0.6434847713,
0.7185416222,
0.8408623934,
0.0191156324,
0.6008061767,
0.6376902461,
-0.1015876755,
-0.993011713,
0.4591040611,
-0.2968456745,
-0.3123869002,
-0.3591340184,
-0.0603353493,
-0.7803918719,
-0.3315043449,
-0.4457037151,
-0.7450381517,
0.4607043862,
0.5079850554,
-0.5361617208,
0.5550972819,
-0.3852856159,
0.4126126766,
0.1336509883,
-0.2772159874,
-0.1264109462,
-0.7130578756,
0.1152737811,
0.0672890842,
-0.2350557148,
0.0467813574,
-0.0796962604,
0.8279553652,
-0.6341555119,
0.5317056179,
-0.1999421865,
0.4539541602,
0.7481760979,
0.2223475426,
0.7628798485,
0.1801505685,
0.3757698536,
0.3184725344,
-0.1336380094,
-0.160938412,
-0.6899687648,
0.5468275547,
-0.5349314213,
-0.6481391788,
-0.5510541797,
-0.4590686858,
-0.0065859905,
-0.0999077335,
0.2173638791,
0.6325250864,
0.3574904799,
0.1457594782,
0.4384820163,
-0.0867564157,
1.0702587366,
0.3798571527,
0.313598752,
-0.6941148043,
0.7295262814,
0.0026472334,
0.1331181079,
0.6806864142,
0.062582843,
-0.6587356329,
-0.6967724562,
-0.5181623101,
0.3884969652,
-0.789018631,
-0.4595473707,
-0.5740828514,
-0.7380495667,
-0.2231524736,
-0.3834109902,
-0.9611247182,
-0.5405153036,
0.0101192063,
0.1993380785,
0.1986575425,
0.8035047054,
-0.1777259558,
0.5257781148,
-1.5532581806,
0.2001541108,
0.3167651594,
0.3304527998,
-0.0760704949,
-0.5347604752,
-0.1563866884,
-0.4304375947,
-0.27055794,
-1.0136671066,
0.6406396031,
0.4697571099,
0.4980630577,
0.6708412766,
0.0723585412,
0.8920814991,
-1.1046965122,
0.9680296779,
0.3500236273,
-1.2123496532,
0.6022115946,
-0.1169940457,
0.4593038857,
0.2376608849,
0.4621157646,
-0.6157889366,
-0.1419756711,
-0.4831976593,
-0.6136657,
0.3991272748,
0.5240004063,
-0.0639101118,
0.0659921095,
0.2811293304,
0.0754943043,
-0.0122245988,
-0.2957690358,
-0.4315812886,
-0.2979292572,
0.013451905,
-0.3596998751,
-0.6021053195,
0.3733351231,
-0.3466287255,
0.3550330102,
-0.1413787901,
1.1263953447,
0.597294271,
-0.131991148,
-0.4737690389,
0.085838519,
0.512940824,
0.2436584979,
-0.2629558444,
0.4201648831,
-0.2239337713,
-0.7454376817,
0.3697899878,
0.4018289447,
-0.1719719917,
0.3870033622,
0.7263875008,
1.001847744,
0.2900902033,
-0.369876951,
0.2226537615,
0.045384299,
0.049716793,
-0.3453823924,
0.2691575289,
0.002398808,
0.4763077796,
0.7103181481,
0.4314230978,
0.2741323113,
-0.3569115102,
0.3951864839,
0.073113963,
-0.6664406657,
-0.5415591002,
1.27821064,
0.514075458,
-0.6702514887,
0.5458297133,
0.1712285727,
-0.5937921405,
0.0540165193,
0.4193231463,
1.1447156668,
-0.6815953851,
-0.1553238928,
0.6367563605,
-0.1439191699,
0.148143366,
0.509988606,
-0.2834240794,
-0.4849500656,
-0.8358948827,
-0.8003757596,
-0.2600958347,
0.0576923937,
-0.584847033,
0.5236471891,
-0.1876222491,
-0.2223246843,
0.2453190833,
-0.2846029103,
-0.6763397455,
0.0885513499,
0.7743970156,
1.28875494,
-0.6019484997,
1.0801346302,
0.6844756603,
-0.3303816319,
-0.7703245282,
-0.185344398,
0.2383508235,
-0.6300547123,
0.8657504916,
0.1707555354,
-0.1293317974,
0.1203396618,
-0.1330542564,
-1.507196784,
1.0104985237,
0.1229770333,
-0.8611721992,
-0.2777472734,
0.3767931759,
0.1545726955,
-0.3670865893,
0.1973866969,
0.4232664704,
0.3818135858,
0.6047570109,
-0.8357580304,
0.0067065759,
-0.424666971,
0.1258668602,
0.2908189297,
-0.4812610149,
0.7276605964,
0.1113856658,
-0.3470187783,
-0.296115756,
0.9636904597,
-0.0309351161,
-0.0362528786,
0.6847577691,
0.1236600652,
0.5374717712,
-0.174356252,
0.7845099568,
-0.5023171902,
0.0187836122,
0.7393037677,
0.0693728179,
1.0310536623,
0.6070806384,
-0.0011823188,
0.4632326663,
0.4958699644,
0.0139058381,
0.5151047707,
0.0494142435,
-0.3333317637,
-0.3313829601,
-0.0400651582,
-0.1388705373,
0.5740326047,
0.5321377516,
-0.5774590373,
-0.1650997549,
-0.1862590313,
-0.1788527071,
0.2402224392,
-0.6283506751,
0.3580116332,
0.1223275363,
-0.7980796695,
0.9105590582,
-0.1303177774,
0.6695848107,
-0.7677072287,
-0.3384486735,
0.0797915161,
0.1898866594,
-0.2346929014,
-1.0766564608,
0.9003027081,
0.144887358,
-0.2695367932,
-0.5402063727,
1.048615694,
-0.3955686092,
-0.3167716861,
0.0402086377,
0.2743875384,
0.26524508,
-0.2284473479,
-0.3524512649,
0.66740942,
-0.1823505461,
-0.1908383518,
-0.1404008269,
-0.175753355,
0.0141067337,
0.7513052225,
0.7088553905,
0.3604480326,
0.2174283266,
-0.0704958364,
0.9651919007,
-0.977252841,
-0.7687465549,
-0.6098179817,
0.8888829947,
-0.0342087895,
0.005236208,
0.4762588739,
0.3362338245,
0.5609527826,
-0.3457495272,
0.4996169508,
-0.0108386334,
0.4658429623,
-0.3722154796,
0.6908051968,
-0.1904874444,
0.0607582033,
-0.2378663123,
-1.1074821949,
-0.456358403,
0.5276563764,
0.1173780933,
-0.4873280525,
0.8035949469,
0.2738250494,
-0.1261919141,
0.0956321359,
0.4560765028,
-0.1606108695,
0.4040678144,
0.9823619723,
0.7289990187,
-0.8459837437,
0.6926046014,
-0.1528288275,
-0.1600020379,
-0.1162187606,
-1.0084528923,
-0.7818753719,
-0.9719532728,
-0.6038474441,
-0.3158266842,
0.0109247267,
1.0101145506,
1.0303472281,
-0.9631718993,
-0.3326480389,
-0.0025896374,
-0.1361571103,
-0.5288805366,
-0.1653523296,
0.4442575872,
-0.3040727377,
-0.9135970473,
0.744430542,
0.3876443803,
-0.0015745049,
-0.2774813175,
-0.1662683189,
-0.1361100972,
0.1504585296,
0.6516933441,
0.4155765474,
-0.5377065539,
-0.5225507617,
-0.0942275822,
0.2845562994,
0.284491241,
0.9334350824,
-0.9977268577,
0.2792964876,
0.8237698674,
0.8964319825,
0.5940345526,
0.1181786358,
0.6991932988,
-0.5138977766,
0.0940495059,
0.5461646914,
0.3146696985,
0.271212697,
-0.5591384172,
0.3844333887,
0.5381612182,
-0.7311908007,
-0.6695132256,
0.2591791153,
-1.3503320217,
-0.024535805,
1.1452658176,
-0.0194739997,
-0.2004594505,
0.1998932362,
0.1937378943,
0.5770925879,
-0.6009929776,
0.345198065,
0.3800888062,
-0.4729365408,
-0.5607468486,
-0.4877422452,
0.8706094623,
-0.1156225652,
-0.2043062299,
-0.1756297201,
0.3179827034,
0.0536914207,
0.4341852069,
0.0755910799,
0.0033427426,
0.2640485466,
0.3388133049,
-0.1149952933,
-0.4225462973,
-0.5009866357,
-0.5083215833,
0.3877561688,
-0.127709195,
-0.5078146458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01799v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01799v2
|
Faster and Lighter LLMs: A Survey on Current Challenges and Way Forward
| 2024-02-02T06:29:34 | 2024-04-24T04:58:46 |
Arnav Chavan, Raghav Magazine, Shubham Kushwaha, Mérouane Debbah, Deepak Gupta
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite the impressive performance of LLMs, their widespread adoption faces
challenges due to substantial computational and memory requirements during
inference. Recent advancements in model compression and system-level
optimization methods aim to enhance LLM inference. This survey offers an
overview of these methods, emphasizing recent developments. Through experiments
on LLaMA(/2)-7B, we evaluate various compression techniques, providing
practical insights for efficient LLM deployment in a unified setting. The
empirical analysis on LLaMA(/2)-7B highlights the effectiveness of these
methods. Drawing from survey insights, we identify current limitations and
discuss potential future directions to improve LLM inference efficiency. We
release the codebase to reproduce the results presented in this paper at
https://github.com/nyunAI/Faster-LLM-Survey
|
[
-0.3599007428,
-0.7025846839,
0.7566863298,
0.3789614439,
-0.3609670699,
0.0853355676,
-0.1578389108,
-0.7247313857,
0.1155524701,
0.4759956002,
-0.4695193768,
-0.2974869013,
-0.6391016245,
0.2296068221,
-0.3053210378,
0.2620944381,
0.115472056,
0.1615603864,
-0.5085977912,
-0.0913999081,
-0.4104056656,
-0.403621465,
-0.611313343,
-0.2909006178,
0.5939100981,
0.4929796755,
0.4246662557,
0.7102843523,
0.6550973058,
0.378121227,
-0.5553020239,
0.3685500324,
-0.4870396256,
0.2857511044,
0.3570925295,
-0.7142952681,
-0.3319980204,
-0.250957489,
0.6020824909,
0.8258402348,
-0.2139530629,
0.4323892593,
-0.1617071778,
0.653629899,
-1.0965130329,
-0.2838402987,
-0.6186128855,
0.1412194073,
-0.2384073436,
-0.1118662357,
-0.3673921227,
-0.5173051953,
-0.1140017956,
-0.4836563766,
0.329036355,
0.3328824341,
0.4016337991,
0.6361817718,
-0.5862448812,
-0.198963359,
-0.661839366,
0.8835725188,
-0.6721631289,
0.3853980005,
-0.0787825286,
0.3324474394,
-0.275021553,
-0.898544848,
-0.294428587,
-0.1387488097,
0.2368334681,
-0.0056398385,
-0.1357199401,
0.005901515,
0.1947826594,
0.2577521801,
-0.3376197815,
0.5693194866,
-0.4081425965,
-0.1401923597,
0.674855113,
0.2410787344,
-0.1241237149,
0.0318962894,
-0.5514306426,
-0.1389279515,
-0.9470809698,
-0.3583339751,
0.6445969343,
-0.1755889952,
-0.186906144,
0.3709153235,
-0.2880310416,
0.6139008403,
-0.248112306,
-0.2794102132,
0.1886394322,
-0.1432201564,
-0.2387600541,
0.0616462268,
0.4344332814,
0.5039479136,
-0.1353778392,
-0.1328377724,
-0.3234854639,
0.1814582497,
0.0374838598,
-0.9287459254,
-0.0333236158,
0.0946659148,
-0.724308908,
-0.2653875053,
-0.1035162657,
-0.7508417964,
-0.7551069856,
-0.195269987,
0.2293583304,
0.1356614679,
-0.1267357171,
0.3756219149,
-0.4409738481,
0.4803376794,
0.640003562,
-0.5318192244,
0.2670080066,
0.6893812418,
0.7784534693,
-0.3201662302,
0.4058651924,
-0.3111219704,
-0.0535947718,
-0.2200945914,
1.1199355125,
-0.2570145726,
-0.6232230663,
-0.2144155204,
-0.2216756195,
0.2494534552,
-0.8432030678,
0.7285274267,
-0.4870965481,
-0.16534926,
-0.230765596,
-0.5707825422,
-0.3112376928,
0.1360232681,
-0.6479468942,
1.2578325272,
-0.115710035,
-0.5869331956,
0.0529911481,
-0.0729290918,
-0.289179951,
-0.1138486788,
-0.1940168738,
-0.4933653474,
0.564365685,
0.2428313494,
0.5337919593,
-0.8119344115,
0.0042943317,
-0.7075067163,
-0.7841831446,
-0.1120428219,
-0.5267089009,
0.8020641804,
0.5796259046,
-0.1399461776,
-0.0737909675,
-0.7967153192,
-0.1185320094,
0.2216415554,
-0.3801743984,
-0.0275399145,
0.2808300257,
-0.1866785586,
-0.3447303474,
0.3228428662,
-0.3214324713,
0.4220569134,
-0.0304237697,
0.2393219769,
0.8654471636,
-0.0412693769,
0.5487887859,
-0.2699653804,
0.6636984944,
-0.2918770015,
0.3422203362,
0.2004164606,
-0.4418807626,
-0.7266382575,
-0.2448140234,
0.2368297428,
0.6438901424,
-0.4923563004,
0.2454860955,
-0.2380317897,
-0.7410163283,
-0.1827557385,
0.2550773621,
0.3356586099,
0.5316995978,
0.2569525242,
-0.114053525,
-0.666592896,
-0.9008783698,
-0.249487102,
-0.3354241252,
-0.0664772391,
0.3994297981,
0.2990598679,
-0.2635976672,
0.6079113483,
-0.6278615594,
0.3343668282,
-0.4355373681,
-0.0453613251,
0.1080831066,
0.5169855356,
0.5289087892,
-0.7488279939,
-0.2086120099,
-0.4035559297,
-0.6656847596,
-0.5682555437,
0.0195749253,
-0.000636066,
-0.022709094,
0.6389006376,
-0.5613408685,
0.4242019951,
0.573231101,
-0.0709531903,
0.6282190084,
-0.1752967685,
0.0316826403,
-0.696190238,
-0.3375761807,
-0.1044987217,
-0.0748931244,
-0.3976409435,
0.1455599964,
0.1740023643,
0.2942881286,
-0.6834067702,
0.5065872669,
-0.9136023521,
-0.4518634081,
-0.1869212985,
-0.1699367762,
0.0255037099,
0.076345183,
-0.1091878414,
0.9307758212,
0.4298332632,
-0.7418795824,
0.2315537035,
0.0302673932,
-0.4924173355,
0.1492609233,
-0.7842802405,
0.2365955412,
-0.3309189379,
0.4840575755,
-0.9575549364,
-0.2617287338,
0.2303005159,
0.0526084937,
0.3059877753,
-0.0629285574,
-0.6744762659,
-0.2828268707,
-0.6274682283,
0.6442515254,
0.9575805068,
-0.6864357591,
0.5904306769,
0.1568831503,
0.185967952,
-0.7223066688,
-0.9497148395,
0.048967801,
-0.7463985682,
-0.6794466972,
0.3392859101,
-0.2901332378,
-0.5282595158,
-0.3669667542,
-0.3699881434,
0.1033527106,
0.5242221355,
0.1623637527,
0.1152622104,
-0.178923443,
-0.1133014783,
0.0551847331,
0.1465364099,
-0.0368392989,
0.0237130746,
0.2886176407,
0.1034515873,
-0.4934351742,
-0.3323417902,
0.1412153393,
-0.0188371949,
0.3251396418,
0.379109323,
0.4695542157,
0.0205792077,
-0.2371830046,
-1.0610780716,
-0.2888108492,
-0.527461946,
0.0851811394,
-0.115502283,
-0.9209825993,
0.5768762231,
-0.6944544315,
-0.0847266391,
0.1482504904,
0.4697807431,
-0.0849416628,
0.8370770812,
0.4974327981,
-0.0130643044,
0.5243062377,
-0.3419480026,
-0.1293369532,
-0.7370893359,
-0.3441266716,
-0.8818013072,
-0.5776442885,
-0.4749141932,
-0.7874627113,
0.4612749815,
0.5659288764,
-0.0532867275,
0.1672566682,
-0.5187244415,
0.3812991679,
0.4221924245,
0.1578668803,
0.4149004519,
-0.0140825072,
0.0687939152,
0.3588092327,
-0.7532590628,
-0.5354601741,
1.0151848793,
0.2211435288,
1.0540827513,
0.3642193079,
0.6737915277,
0.2095296681,
0.3932816684,
-0.6622766256,
0.7610929608,
0.2199463397,
-0.5223155022,
0.1468673497,
-0.6863242984,
-0.9953671694,
0.3172594011,
0.0070780213,
-0.7698401809,
0.3438561857,
0.1801169813,
-0.2592937648,
0.3548215032,
-0.9275614619,
0.3584132791,
-0.3281251192,
-0.2839821875,
-0.1213429272,
-1.0177460909,
0.6261513233,
0.1207206175,
-0.0111669553,
-0.5189685822,
-0.6306788325,
0.5393932462,
-0.4136156142,
0.6794452667,
-0.1998396069,
-0.0363204628,
0.487659663,
-0.2653539479,
0.5043669343,
0.154727757,
-0.4345987737,
0.2240846157,
-0.1780838966,
-0.5646923184,
-0.6180933118,
0.5531691909,
-0.5893477798,
-0.6517651677,
-0.2197785974,
-0.5532537103,
-0.2243340313,
-0.1125219837,
0.2082926482,
0.2863507569,
0.1325083375,
0.2839609981,
0.7475946546,
-0.2904817462,
0.70408535,
0.443839848,
-0.0340886451,
-0.3463629484,
0.5097638369,
0.0955964848,
0.2484498173,
0.376698792,
0.2154759616,
-0.4241203666,
-1.2281492949,
-0.3777390718,
0.1470411867,
-0.6106426716,
-0.4448597431,
-0.39645347,
0.307287097,
-0.3902515471,
-0.1015973985,
-0.2698841691,
-0.6737117171,
-0.5097674131,
-0.1093927473,
0.4204906821,
0.7662892938,
-0.0321646631,
0.7718619108,
-0.5060446858,
0.393507123,
0.0020342919,
0.1298820674,
-0.0325544551,
-0.4344266355,
-0.0676983446,
-0.4059339464,
-0.4155060053,
-0.7790734768,
0.1131094173,
0.1572501808,
0.5259793997,
0.5808532238,
0.1839077175,
1.0071742535,
-0.1868938059,
0.8135630488,
-0.0148175796,
-0.3901726305,
0.2703411579,
0.0741490796,
0.1886319965,
0.5979328752,
0.3109595776,
0.0255175326,
-0.0836737528,
-0.5420060158,
-0.8301573396,
0.2303210944,
0.0037690487,
0.0393751524,
0.1313952953,
0.7929992676,
0.0105863828,
0.1811481416,
-0.368072629,
-0.4420800507,
0.4625500739,
-0.129122898,
-0.110196583,
-0.4631850719,
0.1936989725,
-0.244973585,
0.5172995329,
-0.1284341365,
0.3411165476,
0.2211068422,
-0.2258913666,
0.3012213111,
0.0419567935,
0.6031196713,
0.3830833733,
-0.2592764497,
0.3285525441,
0.5329601765,
-0.233829543,
0.3814851046,
0.065276742,
-0.316008538,
-0.1950541437,
0.5284624696,
0.7642835975,
0.2928489447,
-0.781878531,
0.2996220887,
-0.222047016,
-0.3543706834,
-0.2326566726,
0.2896257937,
0.3233474791,
0.4927145243,
0.386703074,
-0.03513043,
0.4481634796,
-0.2108561546,
-0.4032188952,
0.5534693599,
0.0238916948,
0.0210238211,
0.8236711621,
0.0669653937,
-0.0808607936,
0.3258389533,
-0.1860966682,
-0.1023320109,
0.784314692,
0.3923852444,
0.6863452196,
0.0268514082,
-0.3626003861,
-0.0177062713,
0.2234661728,
-0.5074427724,
0.4716747701,
-0.4545441866,
-0.5883747935,
-0.5287798643,
-0.6001509428,
-0.6379363537,
-0.2866320908,
-0.486063242,
0.3025758266,
-0.3756089807,
-0.1290466934,
-0.4544669092,
0.3005894721,
-0.4983233809,
-0.0467572063,
0.2753069997,
1.316365242,
-0.4657689631,
0.5464393497,
0.517267406,
0.023176847,
-0.8701508641,
-0.5650177598,
0.2314755321,
-0.7202651501,
0.3988146484,
0.2627698183,
-0.2597233355,
-0.0112813013,
-0.7198057771,
-0.7558962107,
1.4715950489,
0.9072917104,
-0.4649614394,
-0.0210802238,
0.0388118774,
0.1273323298,
-0.1346789896,
0.6552837491,
0.6511414647,
0.6273403168,
0.0569099039,
-0.438400656,
-0.1101360545,
0.0298288036,
0.3216288686,
0.0431866199,
-0.9073188901,
0.6088393927,
-0.0150849493,
-0.179276064,
0.5300034285,
0.8974756598,
0.4902139604,
0.5623806715,
0.7140517235,
0.8785210848,
0.652805388,
0.0069399304,
1.0706571341,
-0.1984428018,
0.2641797364,
1.0093233585,
-0.3468317688,
0.6742598414,
0.7291797996,
-0.2319315523,
0.4393133223,
0.9242020249,
0.0470713265,
0.1622065604,
0.486969769,
-0.5813689232,
-0.2490669787,
-0.1833421141,
-0.3839883804,
0.3026525378,
0.1446705312,
-0.0766131654,
-0.2206738293,
-0.2786958218,
-0.0451706983,
-0.2133812904,
-0.4233900011,
0.6433951259,
0.1576143354,
-0.3872341216,
0.4255031645,
0.0380843468,
1.0346837044,
-0.4572887719,
0.0810761899,
-0.3172942102,
0.0500577912,
-0.2751867175,
-0.3059436381,
0.1192501336,
0.0584927946,
0.0186090656,
-0.4090765715,
0.9812767506,
0.0532915369,
-0.4952637851,
0.3286605775,
0.6411437988,
0.5204250216,
-0.0405536778,
-0.3746191263,
0.4990237355,
-0.2568112016,
-0.6186742187,
0.3157126606,
0.238989085,
-0.0927985087,
1.0170110464,
0.5360813737,
0.1610607654,
0.5394206643,
0.0963986441,
0.7516810298,
-0.4555006921,
-0.1063492373,
-0.7501685619,
0.2405407578,
-0.0826114416,
-0.1048026979,
0.8169264197,
0.6763105989,
0.6425403357,
-0.0841846541,
0.4460515082,
0.0071142241,
0.4492235184,
-0.6324602365,
0.2915651202,
-0.6748200059,
0.6655101776,
-0.0285667647,
-0.9198784828,
-0.3366474509,
0.2549884915,
-0.0901280716,
0.0682478994,
0.3383186162,
1.0201141834,
-0.0067508491,
-0.0943689272,
0.1349933743,
-0.1692911983,
0.1556843817,
0.4768621922,
1.0213016272,
-0.3609903455,
0.5669736266,
-0.3934644163,
0.1078353822,
-0.4872206748,
-1.2569564581,
-0.4803232253,
0.1555690318,
-0.3088322282,
-0.0344635695,
-0.055350583,
0.8150525093,
0.8408820629,
-0.3190624118,
-0.4049587846,
-0.3900071979,
0.4933877587,
-0.0750909522,
-0.1386983842,
0.0317618437,
-0.1967195272,
-0.789450407,
0.7349407077,
0.0893681273,
0.0968020335,
-0.2462120503,
-0.208649233,
0.0299150962,
0.1420049518,
0.5021668077,
0.188600719,
-0.6302065253,
-0.252992779,
-0.2007561624,
0.0410497412,
0.0084739029,
0.9235476255,
-0.9098072052,
0.041235581,
0.8175438643,
0.9236760736,
0.7450706959,
0.1343248487,
0.348321259,
-0.647498548,
0.4095439613,
0.2144416273,
0.391153872,
0.1980058551,
-0.3739127815,
0.8348405957,
0.4687590897,
-0.6089991927,
-1.1267266273,
0.2659493685,
-1.1439890862,
-0.2592352927,
1.1068140268,
0.0178817976,
-0.2406301647,
0.122617349,
-0.0865065753,
0.3567659855,
-0.2040883601,
0.4178125262,
0.2939635217,
-0.4607472718,
-0.2989832461,
-0.7127802968,
0.1477818489,
0.6596595049,
-0.8645823598,
-0.2894276679,
0.5902454257,
0.208690688,
-0.2649128437,
0.5257562995,
0.1927573383,
0.0646797866,
0.1028174907,
0.0538299866,
-0.0638874546,
-0.2675146759,
-0.5775718093,
0.320630461,
0.152421996,
0.1083712652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01158v1
|
LLM-Detector: Improving AI-Generated Chinese Text Detection with Open-Source LLM Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-02T05:54:12 | 2024-02-02T05:54:12 |
Rongsheng Wang, Haoming Chen, Ruizhe Zhou, Han Ma, Yaofei Duan, Yanlan Kang, Songhua Yang, Baoyu Fan, Tao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ChatGPT and other general large language models (LLMs) have achieved
remarkable success, but they have also raised concerns about the misuse of
AI-generated texts. Existing AI-generated text detection models, such as based
on BERT and RoBERTa, are prone to in-domain over-fitting, leading to poor
out-of-domain (OOD) detection performance. In this paper, we first collected
Chinese text responses generated by human experts and 9 types of LLMs, for
which to multiple domains questions, and further created a dataset that mixed
human-written sentences and sentences polished by LLMs. We then proposed
LLM-Detector, a novel method for both document-level and sentence-level text
detection through Instruction Tuning of LLMs. Our method leverages the wealth
of knowledge LLMs acquire during pre-training, enabling them to detect the text
they generate. Instruction tuning aligns the model's responses with the user's
expected text detection tasks. Experimental results show that previous methods
struggle with sentence-level AI-generated text detection and OOD detection. In
contrast, our proposed method not only significantly outperforms baseline
methods in both sentence-level and document-level text detection but also
demonstrates strong generalization capabilities. Furthermore, since
LLM-Detector is trained based on open-source LLMs, it is easy to customize for
deployment.
|
[
-0.1268400699,
-0.779093504,
0.6317035556,
-0.2249966115,
-0.4072675705,
-0.0492427722,
-0.3564680517,
-0.5494511724,
-0.277118355,
0.6114837527,
-0.4006600678,
-0.7617874742,
-0.5696085691,
0.0812290534,
-0.3534038067,
0.8778800964,
0.0439041145,
-0.0823229328,
-0.0577158071,
0.2446140349,
-0.1630623192,
-0.3979763687,
-0.7214083672,
-0.286714375,
0.227581948,
0.4651532173,
0.3940979242,
0.6463250518,
0.5363876224,
0.2258000225,
0.0521043427,
0.7612261772,
-0.3954106271,
-0.019660376,
0.2681424916,
-0.5629316568,
-0.5161864758,
-0.1321309954,
0.6368952394,
-0.2120927125,
-0.0550196841,
-0.1448972523,
0.0795103386,
0.3700414896,
-0.5998184085,
0.0345498584,
-0.9802591205,
-0.0343388207,
-0.5284027457,
-0.5467383862,
-0.8315518498,
-0.1057083234,
-0.1541452855,
-0.5512371659,
0.4168358147,
0.2070639431,
0.8897584081,
0.2530563772,
-0.3302542567,
-0.6327671409,
-0.4575781226,
0.6401875615,
-0.9956979156,
-0.0152557613,
0.4685284793,
0.1729953438,
-0.3621167243,
-0.6021808982,
-0.7365618944,
-0.2828927338,
-0.0259028766,
0.3313219249,
-0.1749132723,
0.1498712152,
-0.063659057,
0.5103139281,
-0.8247941732,
0.4350409806,
0.0839980841,
-0.3208386898,
0.6152720451,
0.1747212261,
0.6887386441,
0.0747537911,
-0.2443023771,
0.1277389228,
-0.8205162287,
-0.1361381859,
0.5087224245,
0.2140990645,
0.0126944371,
0.4607250094,
-0.0038073927,
0.7213078737,
-0.0551640429,
-0.1111299768,
-0.0107334666,
-0.1953378469,
-0.1321592629,
0.1326061338,
0.9470102191,
0.3426111639,
0.5167726278,
-0.0394540839,
-0.370103687,
-0.0664233491,
0.0776898414,
-0.8990360498,
-0.3763952553,
0.0408400707,
-0.4790769219,
-0.4555639923,
0.1476079673,
-0.2881187499,
-0.5217716098,
0.0530650765,
0.2137352228,
-0.5373245478,
-0.0866338834,
0.2837712467,
-0.0325410776,
0.3856660724,
0.3084898591,
-0.9818844199,
-0.0879629627,
0.7037021518,
0.8160321116,
-0.3326368928,
-0.0543117858,
-0.785657227,
0.1770714819,
-0.2814447582,
1.1307251453,
-0.4183492064,
-0.3340620399,
0.2430822402,
-0.1536794305,
0.009582486,
-0.7257675529,
0.6958593726,
-0.5527563691,
0.5354864001,
0.0857780054,
-0.6707874537,
0.2182801515,
0.4148467481,
-0.366112411,
1.1942644119,
-0.0742789954,
-0.7998376489,
0.3261020482,
-0.6318436265,
-0.6055393219,
0.4019199312,
-0.1958992034,
-0.7011576295,
-0.0414689444,
0.6678999066,
0.4363399744,
-0.2034839839,
0.0656370521,
-0.0477440655,
-0.8098083138,
0.1349069923,
-0.6413434744,
0.7620157599,
0.1940704733,
-0.1155287325,
0.3321518898,
-0.6456166506,
0.0386074185,
0.1609451175,
-0.6328082681,
-0.340718478,
0.1604266614,
-0.0412928946,
-0.2355075032,
0.4214301407,
-0.6982195377,
0.0926304832,
-0.6249411106,
0.5176108479,
0.7483014464,
-0.1064731255,
0.3756013811,
-0.3134011924,
0.3836447299,
0.0626116842,
0.0151112899,
-0.7058051229,
-0.7097828984,
-0.9202203155,
-0.3206076324,
0.0044139423,
0.6584699154,
-1.0041536093,
0.7122314572,
-0.0169236828,
-0.2231626511,
-0.4645932615,
0.1699319631,
0.4155187011,
0.3659108579,
0.2566715777,
-0.0806132481,
-0.1812507808,
-0.5052134991,
-0.5086250305,
-0.393753767,
-0.3557456732,
0.3680118322,
0.4621922672,
-0.0582429506,
0.774015069,
-0.7092970014,
-0.5667124391,
-0.296703428,
0.1660498679,
0.0915054232,
0.2130544037,
0.4613485634,
-0.6633751392,
-0.7845781446,
0.2322244793,
-0.6598773003,
-0.3429788649,
-0.1367674023,
-0.0663474426,
0.5731737018,
0.7928537726,
-0.4947112501,
0.4028892815,
0.2239988148,
-0.1277120411,
0.5014235973,
-0.35844329,
0.0239875279,
-1.1672933102,
-0.191404745,
0.1101879179,
-0.2819843292,
-0.5807589293,
0.3086930215,
0.4073956907,
-0.0563626625,
-0.5027501583,
0.4519613981,
-0.4871018231,
0.154264465,
-0.6574026942,
0.5042110085,
0.0944652259,
0.5267769098,
0.0573315918,
1.0977852345,
0.1824115962,
-0.5870425701,
0.2832981646,
0.0179791488,
-0.5319890976,
0.4564899802,
-0.4775760174,
0.4088206589,
-0.0440549143,
0.1443778276,
-1.1467022896,
-0.1748374552,
0.5793375373,
-0.6970031261,
0.2386957407,
-0.0706916004,
-0.6822109222,
-0.1849664003,
-0.4298708737,
0.0578764714,
0.4147814512,
-0.7912883162,
0.485888809,
0.1766539216,
0.0965949595,
-0.3699015081,
-0.7833721042,
0.1378187835,
-0.1632391363,
-0.7228348851,
0.5083361864,
-0.1948769391,
0.019660512,
-0.0255415719,
-0.0612560622,
-0.2336153835,
0.2068581581,
-0.1874454021,
0.3377684057,
-0.5566546917,
0.1779831499,
0.1353750229,
-0.0275350325,
0.0363492407,
-0.403210789,
0.6283612251,
0.1522265375,
-0.4896809757,
-0.4898774922,
0.0737316832,
0.2135948092,
-0.4886006117,
0.4949510694,
0.9535533786,
-0.2978941798,
-0.5196477175,
-0.1768053025,
-0.0230023805,
-0.555279851,
0.3166894019,
-0.022652572,
-0.9331572056,
0.0618698634,
0.0838952884,
0.1668851972,
0.2085924745,
0.7538041472,
-0.1509280652,
0.9599301219,
0.6860786676,
-0.32580778,
0.6906799674,
0.1308968365,
0.3413619399,
-0.6384561062,
0.1624390632,
-0.5228077173,
0.0400865674,
-0.4578211308,
-0.3395353854,
0.3202200234,
-0.2395211607,
-0.2457565963,
0.2162971795,
-0.649648726,
0.8743380308,
0.7161390185,
0.3809410632,
0.5364319682,
-0.072318621,
0.2512457371,
0.1755022705,
-0.374452889,
-0.6230145097,
1.1361694336,
0.1319532692,
0.7452726364,
-0.0595469624,
0.7637661099,
0.3787535131,
0.302886188,
-0.8764421344,
0.5994184613,
-0.5659570694,
-0.3446145356,
-0.1640813947,
-0.253929913,
-0.8815345764,
0.2830660343,
-0.0340115912,
-0.6588804722,
-0.4477839172,
0.0791564807,
-0.2010847479,
0.396422714,
-0.6541163921,
0.7278032899,
-0.3247424662,
0.0748595223,
-0.0227305684,
-0.2528345585,
0.5252892375,
-0.0282680169,
-0.0646479577,
-0.1976771951,
-0.0777257383,
0.352021575,
-0.2577473521,
0.9396835566,
0.0238359589,
-0.5871965289,
0.5323662162,
-0.1611958891,
0.5733467937,
-0.0313419364,
0.0104543855,
0.0667410716,
-0.4685104787,
-0.2491546273,
-0.3850136995,
0.5971321464,
-0.6759977341,
-0.7543260455,
-0.291761905,
-0.7314132452,
0.1705339402,
0.5049753785,
0.6326608062,
0.2837533653,
-0.2226726562,
0.0092164893,
0.9042790532,
-0.5654044747,
0.4914829433,
0.7450895309,
-0.2512139082,
-0.1700453758,
0.9399137497,
-0.392267406,
0.1720868647,
0.7071018219,
0.2159021944,
-0.0293884538,
-0.7952066064,
-0.6230422854,
-0.0509305149,
-0.5488678813,
-0.2397097349,
-0.3491287231,
-0.454064399,
-0.3785358667,
-0.0653475821,
0.0476849526,
0.0918192863,
-0.6715775132,
0.2861732244,
0.1917770505,
0.3923926055,
0.3922873735,
0.7464284301,
-0.8116629124,
0.5835178494,
-0.0884263515,
0.2290044725,
-0.1670788527,
-0.8433917761,
-0.4058935046,
0.0262453277,
-0.5526642799,
-0.421887517,
0.5273119211,
0.3562353551,
0.424752444,
0.5807101727,
0.3768850863,
0.2226156443,
-0.4547277987,
0.838299334,
-0.2196504772,
-0.917186141,
0.6731909513,
-0.4547593296,
0.401147902,
0.0467465781,
0.0467583016,
-0.3696266115,
-0.649515152,
0.0408700407,
-0.6166123152,
0.961615026,
0.1968241632,
0.3389087915,
0.0421811938,
0.3564591408,
-0.0556734055,
0.0029847554,
-0.8150961995,
-0.0981458277,
0.0147245061,
-0.4951042831,
0.0805023611,
-0.1603507847,
0.197624594,
0.2322256118,
0.6179739833,
-0.2811051905,
0.3365895748,
0.0197169706,
-0.2507065237,
-0.1658572555,
0.1097379848,
0.6551991701,
0.1413128525,
-0.2098365873,
-0.1092522666,
-0.1411839873,
-0.6839591265,
-0.1233242229,
-0.0138690826,
-0.3624632657,
-0.0611996539,
0.6042767167,
0.6133283377,
-0.2123835981,
-0.796073854,
0.5560097098,
-0.2049449235,
-0.1791243106,
-0.3915802538,
0.401016444,
-0.0112867216,
0.2160345018,
0.2881087363,
-0.0646707341,
0.0587259717,
-0.3481813967,
0.210817948,
0.5772439837,
-0.2266432494,
-0.0247681178,
0.7228152156,
0.3250775933,
-0.6117041707,
0.7837847471,
-0.2037666589,
-0.6644845605,
0.8030983806,
0.7259774208,
0.9379399419,
0.01005706,
0.1688861102,
-0.0178061128,
0.5267951488,
0.0560074747,
0.121900931,
-0.1054205447,
-1.1756688356,
-0.2853638828,
-0.1987304986,
-0.4827272594,
0.4114367664,
-0.4851703644,
0.4946537018,
-0.3289096355,
0.0369333364,
-0.1928575188,
0.0032764405,
-0.162218079,
-0.0672406256,
0.4810737669,
0.9646135569,
-0.3971913755,
1.1061702967,
0.5465551615,
-0.2292395532,
-0.320577085,
0.604397893,
0.1064547673,
-1.2447497845,
0.3747785389,
0.6103410125,
-0.224513039,
0.1296327263,
-0.750972271,
-0.3685716987,
1.0747084618,
0.3660945296,
-0.5076823831,
0.020219041,
0.2315123677,
0.5866587758,
-0.2887480557,
0.286223799,
0.565474987,
0.3093355298,
-0.1824967265,
-0.6674060822,
-0.1588573009,
-0.2141394168,
-0.2361194491,
0.3252088428,
-0.6788772345,
0.9544581175,
-0.0749437511,
-0.405331105,
0.4490849674,
0.6538749933,
0.2901648581,
0.6011000276,
0.3176084459,
0.4294255376,
0.673756659,
-0.0687806532,
0.9102879763,
-0.4560991824,
0.1198735982,
0.9214687347,
-0.3288269937,
0.7203217149,
-0.0336033441,
0.0484017245,
0.4432995617,
0.6303156614,
-0.214298442,
0.3819224834,
0.2793678343,
-0.4371664524,
-0.2976084948,
-0.1104607955,
-0.2098280787,
0.3807801008,
0.4230095446,
-0.4006191194,
-0.2720552087,
-0.1430100054,
0.0672475025,
0.3447221518,
-0.3968691826,
0.6583451629,
0.0258105043,
-0.6185055971,
0.4915975332,
0.301258415,
1.1617001295,
-0.5440859199,
0.0492952764,
-0.3190339804,
0.5004591942,
-0.0633064881,
-0.9180997014,
-0.1215692535,
0.2520086765,
0.0525154769,
-0.1041804031,
1.1900160313,
-0.6062642336,
-0.285961628,
0.1957266033,
0.3482554853,
0.2210955471,
-0.3449225724,
-0.4373545945,
-0.0585527979,
0.0846615732,
-0.1416751891,
0.4497730732,
0.789423883,
0.0543234125,
0.5599583387,
0.6747180223,
-0.1420944184,
0.0361950882,
0.075136885,
0.8213402629,
-0.5081915855,
-0.3372462094,
-1.0729624033,
0.1336316466,
-0.0372853503,
-0.3856274486,
0.715048492,
0.5300161839,
1.0976835489,
-0.1283844411,
0.9422674179,
0.2614300549,
0.2884989083,
-0.8268937469,
0.9114207029,
-0.588449657,
0.4941025674,
-0.0421690121,
-0.6570557356,
-0.4057208002,
0.3962157071,
-0.1994570792,
-0.1125509292,
0.4939556122,
0.900203228,
0.0521870553,
-0.0433705486,
0.3737341762,
-0.1963001788,
0.6437359452,
0.8448626995,
0.9001649022,
-0.4872072935,
0.8934112191,
0.0854789317,
-0.0971046761,
-0.2949025631,
-0.948736012,
-1.3341860771,
-0.2653833628,
-0.157024309,
0.0761944726,
-0.0110657467,
0.5020794272,
0.3888010681,
-0.8356065154,
-0.104101792,
-0.1890245527,
0.1225106418,
-0.0186145101,
-0.2613064945,
0.4485887885,
-0.6297640204,
-0.9868043065,
0.5627419353,
0.3330106735,
-0.0118165798,
-0.1575196832,
-0.0946650505,
-0.0985716656,
0.2203262597,
0.6038523316,
0.0659276918,
-0.6546105146,
-0.2526408732,
0.1288689822,
-0.3015310168,
0.1878237426,
0.8396760821,
-0.4745336473,
0.3379450142,
0.527926743,
0.6418123245,
0.2894733548,
0.080628708,
0.4836579263,
-0.8794198036,
0.088087514,
0.0388380364,
0.2337498963,
0.2537091076,
-0.6990895867,
0.3964838684,
0.1069179028,
-0.7808714509,
-0.8323566914,
0.3581252694,
-0.6413426995,
-0.5115526319,
0.99948138,
-0.4712770283,
-0.1523323953,
-0.0829357654,
-0.5588610172,
0.2861302197,
-0.6086758375,
0.7393362522,
0.6175237298,
-0.1091526076,
-0.2390118241,
-0.3309694529,
0.3117929399,
0.2396723032,
-0.9391815662,
0.1238071546,
0.3660018146,
-0.0310138278,
-0.0912147164,
0.7592475414,
0.0409755632,
0.3030754328,
-0.080474034,
0.0969465524,
-0.3734656572,
-0.1729385108,
-0.1556148827,
-0.1934131086,
0.1403701454,
-0.5176563263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01155v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01155v3
|
CABINET: Content Relevance based Noise Reduction for Table Question Answering
| 2024-02-02T05:48:39 | 2024-02-13T09:11:01 |
Sohan Patnaik, Heril Changwal, Milan Aggarwal, Sumit Bhatia, Yaman Kumar, Balaji Krishnamurthy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Table understanding capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has been
extensively studied through the task of question-answering (QA) over tables.
Typically, only a small part of the whole table is relevant to derive the
answer for a given question. The irrelevant parts act as noise and are
distracting information, resulting in sub-optimal performance due to the
vulnerability of LLMs to noise. To mitigate this, we propose CABINET (Content
RelevAnce-Based NoIse ReductioN for TablE QuesTion-Answering) - a framework to
enable LLMs to focus on relevant tabular data by suppressing extraneous
information. CABINET comprises an Unsupervised Relevance Scorer (URS), trained
differentially with the QA LLM, that weighs the table content based on its
relevance to the input question before feeding it to the question-answering LLM
(QA LLM). To further aid the relevance scorer, CABINET employs a weakly
supervised module that generates a parsing statement describing the criteria of
rows and columns relevant to the question and highlights the content of
corresponding table cells. CABINET significantly outperforms various tabular
LLM baselines, as well as GPT3-based in-context learning methods, is more
robust to noise, maintains outperformance on tables of varying sizes, and
establishes new SoTA performance on WikiTQ, FeTaQA, and WikiSQL datasets. We
release our code and datasets at https://github.com/Sohanpatnaik106/CABINET_QA.
|
[
-0.2923173904,
-1.0323239565,
0.7051291466,
-0.0497222319,
-0.4671536386,
-0.0935738683,
-0.1001613662,
-0.0411413647,
0.0921338946,
0.9149680138,
-0.5429266691,
-1.0180683136,
-0.1340111196,
-0.1801626384,
-0.6808296442,
0.8128207326,
0.3387300372,
0.1799869239,
-0.8575074077,
0.0430979989,
-0.7843325734,
-0.1585537791,
-0.3772594035,
-0.0593575463,
0.4053955078,
0.6935298443,
0.5980104208,
0.5205572248,
0.6021448374,
0.1619338244,
-0.2623565495,
0.0272643976,
-0.569001019,
0.2923158109,
-0.2926756144,
-0.5703011155,
-0.475161761,
-0.4329735637,
0.2761255503,
0.4029584527,
-0.386054486,
0.3065718114,
0.147346735,
0.5760371685,
-0.386192143,
0.6564629078,
-1.0503138304,
0.114123635,
-0.4108780921,
-0.2687183022,
-0.5866219401,
-0.2160924226,
-0.3395115733,
-0.521571219,
0.125373885,
0.0432379059,
0.7733111978,
0.3422775567,
-0.3631009758,
-0.0536678098,
-0.6363802552,
0.5324914455,
-0.6343002319,
0.546079576,
0.5429626107,
0.1766873449,
-0.2242410779,
-0.792283237,
-0.5166924,
0.0280544609,
-0.3543486893,
0.2548238337,
0.1115503386,
0.1646013409,
0.263476342,
0.4703550041,
-0.7795075178,
-0.1294661909,
-0.350015521,
-0.2488358766,
0.197751537,
0.2179339379,
0.0999879688,
-0.2304443717,
0.1051284522,
-0.0294676777,
-0.8022946715,
0.192439571,
-0.1200942323,
0.2293194085,
0.020369282,
0.3235014081,
-0.3869485259,
0.8345633745,
-0.2413854152,
-0.2996290624,
-0.0595466718,
-0.3362847567,
-0.0044443714,
-0.2241942286,
0.5030919909,
0.1527283639,
-0.1781333983,
-0.3399157524,
-0.1530020982,
0.1644846201,
0.3352546096,
-0.6728004813,
-0.1564047635,
0.0584923886,
-0.3580521643,
-0.2140891999,
0.063636899,
-1.0420538187,
-0.2794985771,
-0.1714283079,
0.5128547549,
0.1253265291,
0.241930142,
-0.2259905487,
0.3452673554,
0.4219383597,
0.4575172961,
-0.707896769,
0.5628897548,
0.6376394629,
0.4819357395,
-0.4692561924,
0.3117583096,
-0.9454753995,
0.2731623352,
-0.3295082152,
0.7760968208,
-0.4409204125,
-0.4538348913,
0.0669823736,
-0.0389042348,
0.3447758257,
-0.8040321469,
0.792648375,
-0.8649942875,
-0.0079620099,
-0.5385174751,
-0.2100857496,
-0.017160356,
0.2434883267,
-0.6892220378,
0.9531006217,
0.2892302871,
-0.3377545476,
0.6131190658,
-0.5505784154,
-0.6997151375,
-0.0707537904,
-0.2399640232,
-0.784419775,
0.0430443063,
0.5118953586,
0.2785381675,
-0.4750082493,
0.4712642729,
-0.0326391533,
-0.5091331601,
0.1201205254,
-0.2587138414,
0.0308259707,
0.2534784377,
-0.0978084877,
0.3220357299,
-0.5473094583,
0.1033289731,
-0.2521281242,
-0.4302465916,
0.2647285461,
-0.0290262401,
-0.2403813004,
0.2639670074,
0.1082010269,
-0.4074833691,
-0.2289572507,
-0.2575623393,
0.3073250353,
0.4957687259,
0.2770462334,
0.3660607934,
-0.4647761285,
0.5377120972,
0.3028736413,
0.281350702,
0.2186910808,
-0.6316365004,
-0.5343242288,
-0.1074213162,
0.4912098348,
0.5685998201,
-0.8747487068,
0.190768823,
-0.269587636,
-0.1060139164,
-0.4012560546,
0.4438023865,
0.4130009711,
0.8218105435,
0.7374725938,
-0.4201107323,
-0.4841379225,
-0.8316810131,
-0.2284215242,
-0.1648657173,
-0.0564693362,
0.5500994921,
0.2234379202,
0.2245096117,
1.0026968718,
-0.5878298283,
-0.6441486478,
-0.3461269736,
-0.1388783604,
0.5193064213,
0.2674639523,
0.0741289109,
-0.8666042089,
-0.6904549599,
-0.0070001432,
-0.5340067148,
-0.287522465,
0.1484791785,
-0.3497107923,
0.0387920737,
0.7270866036,
-0.8079985976,
0.8327274919,
-0.0004548722,
-0.0427568741,
0.1668869704,
0.2157360017,
0.0101458002,
-1.1066060066,
0.0244860612,
-0.5592626333,
-0.2140437365,
-0.6130982637,
0.0171561819,
0.1238843724,
-0.3173531294,
-0.5099397302,
0.4616647661,
-0.450314939,
-0.3085633218,
0.0244838111,
0.4679205418,
0.363314122,
0.6285845637,
0.0044285846,
1.0273571014,
0.4133092165,
-0.6852771044,
0.0683863238,
0.5753626227,
-0.4217960238,
0.5042411089,
-0.369438231,
0.1195140928,
-0.0044200579,
-0.0354488678,
-1.1558595896,
0.0534409396,
0.268730253,
-0.2120973021,
0.5295658708,
-0.1643777192,
-0.470608592,
-0.4369680882,
-0.3210999966,
0.2039030343,
0.5308137536,
-0.3775619268,
0.5409213901,
0.6089875698,
-0.1299690455,
-0.612863183,
-0.836527884,
-0.0996231288,
-0.0036704801,
-0.3439486027,
0.5858556032,
-0.0847588778,
-0.2333259732,
0.0058827279,
-0.6551655531,
-0.251717031,
0.09136457,
0.0933210403,
0.1435395032,
-0.2997459769,
0.5466094613,
0.1445853412,
0.0686911047,
0.230001986,
-0.2115923017,
0.6002848148,
0.0034503459,
-0.315592885,
-0.2966876626,
0.1501945108,
0.2827183604,
-0.283900857,
0.917655766,
0.700083375,
-0.1479342878,
-0.1030411646,
-0.7502921224,
-0.4502408504,
-0.472505331,
0.6296056509,
-0.3491536975,
-0.8357672095,
0.8484064937,
0.2642365992,
0.0358171128,
0.284779042,
0.3230670094,
-0.0377986282,
0.5101104975,
0.1120566279,
-0.1475781798,
0.3937425315,
-0.0469833799,
0.2437797189,
-0.8549830914,
-0.3439394236,
-0.6893020868,
-0.2682346702,
-0.3937841356,
-0.5666517615,
0.4769835174,
-0.2433522642,
0.2565153539,
0.0453761779,
-0.6313719153,
0.6841177344,
0.4332045913,
0.4191585779,
0.577940762,
-0.0199165959,
0.1151531786,
-0.0011710719,
-0.7422368526,
-0.0950276256,
1.2370570898,
-0.1099543348,
1.0857278109,
0.2717010379,
0.5507919192,
0.4624823928,
0.4730715156,
-0.6432529688,
0.8156654835,
-0.2773641944,
-0.4280450344,
-0.5417754054,
-0.8647669554,
-0.9112802148,
0.2073331624,
-0.079721868,
-0.729680419,
0.0796314478,
-0.0965968519,
-0.2398429066,
0.312271893,
-0.5397079587,
0.9394878149,
0.0997103453,
-0.6220620871,
-0.1656642854,
-0.4578805864,
0.278837502,
0.0512272343,
0.1930164099,
0.0380161442,
0.0877041966,
0.8221389055,
-0.3437389731,
0.6254903078,
-0.2402320057,
-0.0825131163,
0.6252606511,
0.2301772088,
0.5092209578,
0.4649497867,
-0.1857685,
-0.0718426779,
-0.034775421,
-0.1604702771,
-0.6459789276,
0.7182776332,
-0.4312081039,
-1.0471922159,
0.1400108039,
-0.8380952477,
-0.3307235539,
-0.0151075693,
0.1331490278,
0.63017869,
-0.0649717525,
0.6284656525,
0.8628308773,
0.0096497769,
0.183856681,
0.4888303876,
-0.2441168576,
-0.2371111661,
0.7285842299,
0.347982347,
-0.0881396309,
1.021638751,
0.1467158943,
-0.7138903141,
-0.7773179412,
-0.1347648352,
-0.1082260832,
-0.8339164853,
-0.7901473045,
-0.5839585662,
-0.2373411953,
-0.3297407031,
0.2038039714,
0.1611924618,
-0.4896840453,
-0.5294778347,
-0.144573316,
0.4515604079,
0.576839745,
0.338547796,
0.4575221837,
-0.6401646137,
0.5984568596,
0.8241135478,
0.4577225447,
-0.2736298442,
-1.0619851351,
-0.2322132587,
-0.2131439894,
-0.4867974818,
-0.9701511264,
0.2729651332,
0.3921906352,
0.694372952,
0.1012360975,
0.3248320222,
0.5631306171,
-0.0142018413,
0.6095458865,
-0.3147284687,
-1.1161751747,
0.661154151,
-0.3098458946,
0.5487682819,
0.894821465,
-0.3292370737,
-0.0728681758,
-0.4923097491,
-0.4052194655,
-0.8576591611,
0.7954541445,
0.1828382313,
-0.110965766,
-0.0187215507,
0.5228446722,
0.100367859,
0.5765040517,
-1.0716526508,
0.0142294755,
0.1433369666,
-0.2467635125,
0.3350490928,
-0.3971858025,
-0.0224530641,
-0.2737795115,
0.7682832479,
-0.24101457,
0.202559337,
0.1388839334,
-0.4359470308,
-0.1325508505,
0.7114577889,
0.5292421579,
0.7269546986,
-0.231823951,
0.0854378343,
0.6237778068,
-0.589086473,
-0.1051385552,
-0.2013583928,
-0.471021384,
0.1319491267,
-0.066038616,
0.4195313156,
0.2201005667,
-0.3976014256,
0.4739230573,
-0.2241172045,
-0.155131951,
0.0368745402,
0.0570603535,
0.1669244915,
-0.0471490771,
0.1611510664,
-0.2180530876,
0.3477262259,
-0.696995914,
0.6111670136,
0.4636903405,
-0.5572724342,
0.0114549566,
0.639749527,
0.0262149442,
-0.3277567923,
0.6085643172,
-0.3609059155,
-0.3093710244,
0.6324387193,
0.4457871318,
0.4464451671,
-0.1026015356,
0.3869135976,
0.1907541752,
0.2726847231,
0.110034503,
0.6697233915,
-0.3824798167,
-0.4212450683,
-0.3782854378,
-0.669457078,
-0.5461500287,
0.2982423902,
-0.7792553306,
0.1209768727,
-0.4613114893,
-0.1604564935,
-0.5070604682,
-0.0157303214,
-0.5078886151,
0.152886644,
-0.3901904225,
0.595508635,
-0.5014886856,
0.6805074215,
0.384131521,
-0.2167376429,
-0.77376616,
0.1615033895,
-0.2887614965,
-0.5042633414,
0.4293066859,
-0.049253799,
0.1515779346,
-0.0705384463,
-0.3825222552,
-0.6446983814,
1.0769672394,
0.5457276106,
-0.4921517074,
0.3636087477,
0.424993813,
0.4852114022,
-0.0489896759,
0.2983647883,
0.697019577,
0.5592015982,
0.0840183944,
-0.689950943,
0.1340103447,
-0.0972734094,
-0.359162569,
0.3460595906,
-0.6630353332,
0.7666096091,
-0.0026114306,
-0.0891943052,
0.0707752034,
0.6388884783,
0.0238329507,
0.4827637374,
0.2967867255,
0.6213894486,
0.7138021588,
-0.5901144147,
0.5028336644,
-0.2065306306,
0.1108313575,
1.2916383743,
-0.3856334388,
0.7378116846,
0.5185989141,
-0.2970559001,
0.3528537452,
0.3167588711,
0.1014657542,
0.6248871088,
0.4344286621,
-0.167013526,
-0.2674317658,
-0.4355268478,
-0.4236899018,
0.4680869579,
0.4877214134,
-0.1337472647,
-0.2261001021,
-0.2604706287,
-0.2450209558,
0.2233716697,
-0.4395839274,
1.1544880867,
0.2082161009,
-0.4954832196,
0.3532278836,
-0.4624703228,
0.1398747712,
-0.6435267925,
-0.1618059427,
-0.55539608,
-0.1902024448,
-0.2881731391,
-0.9964040518,
0.4266900122,
-0.2613221705,
-0.1778227985,
-0.1350888908,
0.6295554042,
-0.4766579568,
-0.1662476659,
0.1169654578,
0.7564918995,
0.0215865448,
-0.2631731927,
-0.3903158307,
-0.0954857543,
-0.0774894506,
-0.0936774835,
0.4338141978,
0.6288380623,
0.0217713006,
0.6191724539,
0.6347905993,
-0.002941207,
-0.2591521144,
0.2855729461,
1.0715329647,
-0.4429565668,
-0.7594634295,
-0.5877985358,
0.1975151449,
-0.184812516,
-0.1256353408,
0.4008847475,
0.7257436514,
0.5362138748,
-0.3274779022,
0.016011456,
0.1499304771,
0.4470496774,
-0.9683064222,
0.8215907216,
-0.568275094,
0.865029037,
-0.3470903337,
-1.0297905207,
-0.4394678175,
0.4199844003,
-0.3937528133,
0.1319363713,
0.7154970765,
1.2414988279,
0.0037453265,
0.0169340838,
0.7740928531,
0.3399592638,
0.0209528506,
0.3256455064,
0.8357605338,
-0.4815742373,
1.1730266809,
-0.2310208082,
0.305911392,
-0.1423933059,
-0.3957101107,
-0.8164584041,
-0.5225526094,
-0.2283474058,
-0.2278921455,
0.1556832492,
0.3230598569,
0.8835868239,
-1.1238178015,
-0.2858181894,
-0.2145433277,
0.648263216,
-0.0760254562,
-0.3639551401,
0.5752444863,
-0.3221000135,
-0.1030807123,
0.3456537426,
0.3177112341,
-0.3898285627,
0.1471498609,
0.24926503,
-0.1509000659,
0.0475374721,
0.4573659301,
0.0466638394,
-0.5680503249,
-0.1558270007,
0.0731982961,
0.025038505,
0.5271232128,
0.5922735929,
-0.802878499,
0.0829551592,
0.5189537406,
0.6645671129,
0.6889668107,
0.167443648,
0.0933101028,
-1.045522809,
0.0909780264,
0.4217259288,
0.4105905592,
0.1270581931,
-0.8745139241,
0.6667634249,
0.1052552536,
-0.6174098253,
-0.7990186214,
0.2812228203,
-1.0186291933,
-0.0783119351,
0.7715306878,
0.0506503098,
-0.511927247,
-0.5155931711,
-0.2885093987,
0.0999435112,
-0.8359494805,
1.0212540627,
0.505831778,
0.0292299986,
-0.4639924467,
-0.5420221686,
0.6376383305,
0.7844308615,
-1.2706514597,
0.1864476204,
0.2456276864,
-0.1929746121,
0.1478435397,
0.479259491,
-0.3762597144,
0.6290777326,
-0.1727560163,
-0.0407979265,
0.0511977375,
-0.4382115602,
-0.0281350557,
0.450235337,
0.2835837007,
-0.0512638725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01152v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01152v2
|
AccentFold: A Journey through African Accents for Zero-Shot ASR Adaptation to Target Accents
| 2024-02-02T05:38:59 | 2024-02-05T05:45:59 |
Abraham Toluwase Owodunni, Aditya Yadavalli, Chris Chinenye Emezue, Tobi Olatunji, Clinton C Mbataku
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Despite advancements in speech recognition, accented speech remains
challenging. While previous approaches have focused on modeling techniques or
creating accented speech datasets, gathering sufficient data for the multitude
of accents, particularly in the African context, remains impractical due to
their sheer diversity and associated budget constraints. To address these
challenges, we propose AccentFold, a method that exploits spatial relationships
between learned accent embeddings to improve downstream Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR). Our exploratory analysis of speech embeddings representing
100+ African accents reveals interesting spatial accent relationships
highlighting geographic and genealogical similarities, capturing consistent
phonological, and morphological regularities, all learned empirically from
speech. Furthermore, we discover accent relationships previously
uncharacterized by the Ethnologue. Through empirical evaluation, we demonstrate
the effectiveness of AccentFold by showing that, for out-of-distribution (OOD)
accents, sampling accent subsets for training based on AccentFold information
outperforms strong baselines a relative WER improvement of 4.6%. AccentFold
presents a promising approach for improving ASR performance on accented speech,
particularly in the context of African accents, where data scarcity and budget
constraints pose significant challenges. Our findings emphasize the potential
of leveraging linguistic relationships to improve zero-shot ASR adaptation to
target accents.
|
[
-0.5876482725,
-0.4206440151,
0.4149659276,
-0.1108991504,
-0.0432964526,
0.183230713,
-0.3033808172,
-0.3776739538,
0.6988217235,
0.5910732746,
-0.6428592801,
-0.5760913491,
-0.4905157387,
-0.0259136446,
-0.0612052977,
0.6882187724,
-0.1025089025,
0.0667120293,
0.1619619727,
-0.861717701,
-0.3238998055,
-0.7865160108,
-0.4926278591,
-0.224945277,
0.5480632782,
0.8284489512,
0.4091915786,
0.624730587,
0.0609572567,
0.1994832158,
-0.1036997288,
0.2820248306,
-0.3329929113,
0.2658792734,
0.0333880298,
-0.1811711192,
-0.1502055824,
-0.3134865165,
0.441075474,
1.0975339413,
-0.160228461,
0.0634653047,
-0.0600938834,
0.4543750286,
-0.6464777589,
-0.0548416413,
-0.7217821479,
-0.0638635904,
-0.3282171786,
-0.1415399462,
0.3060720265,
-0.2861413062,
0.1340795308,
-0.429048419,
0.5460618138,
0.1169042289,
0.5559555888,
0.1532923281,
-0.391068697,
-0.4034928381,
-0.6511908174,
0.2422925085,
-0.376145184,
0.3209781349,
0.3778698146,
0.6640427709,
-0.1636544019,
-0.3577988744,
-0.562056601,
-0.0955439806,
0.3836858273,
-0.0867211893,
0.2308674157,
0.0352317132,
0.1245565787,
0.5154146552,
-0.4744690657,
-0.0606142469,
-0.4249459207,
-0.2510673702,
0.8417121172,
-0.2367438674,
0.6383517385,
0.0673880503,
-0.1116249263,
-0.280703932,
-0.810976088,
0.1167414412,
0.4466867447,
1.0458894968,
-0.1766743362,
0.5266477466,
-0.1971425861,
0.1747024357,
0.2468405962,
0.269539535,
0.4283687472,
0.1389117986,
0.269797951,
0.6466530561,
0.2806391716,
0.0340363942,
0.477538228,
-0.1916805357,
-0.0374242477,
-0.376021117,
0.3154890239,
-0.5828908682,
-0.2878653407,
0.2213738859,
-0.05333836,
0.3763258755,
-0.0831554979,
-0.5635871887,
-0.4073720574,
-0.1312683672,
0.7283316851,
-0.555868268,
-0.2429173589,
-0.1434230804,
-0.4460175633,
0.4613400996,
0.1773312539,
-1.1148332357,
0.4953082204,
0.4585756958,
1.1690551043,
0.0666928589,
-0.321495384,
-0.2938108146,
0.2000144571,
-0.1385408193,
0.7690756917,
-0.4363546968,
-0.6722390056,
0.3384688795,
0.0461776853,
-0.2854951024,
-0.5721246004,
0.6593144536,
-0.3542177975,
-0.400192529,
-0.4744036198,
-0.207558468,
-0.5351758599,
0.049862925,
-0.8329016566,
0.8563596606,
0.1934056431,
-0.0084812604,
0.4951593578,
-0.8604607582,
-0.8295534253,
-0.0366433188,
-0.0100109223,
-0.4592014551,
0.3081620336,
0.6106325984,
-0.1578080952,
0.2015513331,
-0.4927695394,
-0.5864584446,
-0.282337606,
-0.1926427037,
-0.189011395,
0.9881740808,
-0.0195894968,
-0.5160830021,
-0.2694030404,
-1.0311350822,
-0.050470423,
0.1733980924,
-0.0330071785,
-0.4954867661,
-0.0165279955,
0.0511027649,
-0.0356793478,
-0.0706465915,
-0.7215774655,
0.2104995996,
-0.6249442101,
0.3561096489,
0.380284518,
0.3358236849,
0.8569063544,
-0.1278935224,
0.3226071298,
-0.1538432837,
-0.092454277,
-0.4020545185,
-0.2656848431,
-1.0321267843,
-0.2416260242,
0.0214892365,
0.3152711689,
-0.4113438129,
0.2392974049,
-0.3058481812,
-0.260574162,
-0.5831012726,
0.070968993,
0.173438713,
0.3886030018,
0.517706275,
-0.6569210887,
-0.45343858,
-0.6392776966,
-0.2824420631,
-0.0605170131,
-0.2974036634,
0.7169831395,
0.4817696214,
0.0486412719,
0.7874467373,
-0.3042582572,
-0.6192218065,
-0.0710094497,
0.3891596198,
0.1717872322,
0.3800736666,
0.5559126139,
-0.6063687801,
-0.4393457472,
-0.0633975193,
-0.1040811762,
-0.2352592945,
0.1199747995,
-0.0698822886,
0.0391633771,
0.2190977335,
-0.2345352173,
0.4623823166,
0.3686009943,
-0.2472294867,
0.1452610046,
-0.0866047069,
0.1499388367,
-0.68377918,
-0.0200747289,
-0.3616650105,
-0.050434418,
-0.8376955986,
-0.1086489409,
-0.26366961,
-0.6137300134,
-0.1815500408,
0.5565875769,
-0.8441972733,
-0.4399033785,
0.098361522,
-0.0364112705,
0.043020241,
0.7117486596,
0.2144406438,
0.7663654685,
0.3979802132,
-0.2666711807,
-0.0879023969,
0.8231879473,
-0.2215961516,
0.8095086217,
-0.4711314142,
0.6488407254,
-0.0003299869,
0.1607570648,
-1.1401437521,
-0.2285712063,
0.0675682053,
-0.5954740644,
0.5667521954,
-0.5451797247,
0.1204054281,
-0.0921468809,
-0.1869321018,
0.3662754893,
0.3583605587,
-0.6961996555,
0.9026186466,
0.6002886891,
-0.6429768205,
-0.2259768397,
-0.7869606614,
0.4313017726,
-0.0845635831,
-0.6115130186,
0.1727924645,
0.2892206907,
-0.1130749956,
-0.3093119562,
-0.2370274365,
-0.3836578727,
-0.0767008364,
0.434073627,
-0.2838385701,
-0.3833866417,
-0.12058153,
-0.1539979279,
0.287140429,
0.0282895025,
-0.558103323,
0.3313221931,
0.4718114436,
-0.5246516466,
0.1880177706,
0.8624583483,
0.5959886909,
-0.347188741,
0.7217339873,
0.3698214889,
-0.2894110978,
-0.5778166652,
-0.5472028255,
-0.1704428643,
-0.4240865409,
0.1834864467,
-0.4728849828,
-0.6879944801,
0.6545102596,
-0.042710077,
-0.0029630873,
0.0955274627,
0.2061264664,
-0.2695179284,
0.634927392,
0.8061280251,
-0.0839986578,
0.5327087641,
-0.3676973283,
0.2808980346,
-0.9476188421,
-0.2980672419,
-0.629254818,
-0.3889804184,
-0.4351625443,
-0.5989822745,
0.6518707275,
-0.2854236066,
-0.4335482717,
0.3623249829,
-0.1706878841,
0.1879810393,
0.6203628182,
0.1616132855,
-0.2096603662,
0.3898512721,
-0.2668626606,
0.0826508254,
-0.7998617887,
-0.1778835356,
0.9053111672,
0.0801712126,
0.35523054,
0.1929038465,
0.6065238714,
0.4571671188,
-0.0454168841,
-0.8481068611,
0.1090684235,
-0.1517600268,
-0.5849559903,
-0.5765698552,
-0.0313969366,
-0.5765535235,
0.049449183,
-0.091152221,
-0.7134981751,
0.8953284621,
0.2941901684,
-0.4858778715,
0.1592170447,
-0.5467133522,
0.5462713838,
-0.3730064332,
-0.3595765829,
-0.020890234,
-0.7908446789,
-0.2485651225,
-0.0151466569,
0.0119343251,
-0.056895677,
0.1443417519,
0.3933769763,
-0.8249989152,
0.5685150027,
-0.4574991465,
0.1658345312,
0.3622725308,
0.0113085667,
0.3724010885,
-0.5872687101,
-0.30029881,
0.8424730301,
-0.4048922956,
-0.4226013422,
-0.6667035222,
0.4834431708,
-0.9016857743,
-0.3929873407,
-0.2341108769,
-0.5261412859,
-0.6086950898,
0.0824327841,
0.1006550416,
0.9093523026,
-0.5079572201,
-0.0329451002,
0.5254263878,
-0.2024718821,
0.359149307,
0.6649739146,
0.4892406762,
-0.7716559768,
0.7334166765,
0.4743569493,
0.2036444247,
0.3339575231,
-0.1321906149,
-0.642419219,
-0.7538092136,
-0.5585682392,
0.1271994561,
-0.5556035042,
0.1055403277,
-0.6718451381,
-0.272059083,
-0.6735291481,
-0.6070379615,
-0.2690444887,
-0.7874340415,
-0.0003165576,
-0.1140103042,
0.4370670021,
0.4999157786,
-0.405161947,
0.4453054667,
-0.2589571178,
0.2525952458,
0.2611184716,
0.1816309988,
-0.1899625063,
-0.7747893929,
-0.3340905011,
0.2616242468,
-0.0689137131,
-0.8232574463,
0.6276705861,
0.8820907474,
0.4370957911,
0.4134921432,
0.2402565479,
1.0174791813,
-1.0439814329,
0.6780449152,
-0.081509158,
-0.8604496121,
0.3963043988,
-0.2655605972,
0.320079565,
0.8279764652,
0.3664108515,
-0.4213905334,
-0.1540602297,
-0.3073595166,
-1.3175051212,
0.4907085896,
0.2313640118,
0.131216377,
0.2731333673,
0.2809578776,
-0.0401358791,
0.1615493149,
-0.0264730025,
-0.1762518585,
-0.5702009201,
-0.1614616513,
-0.3554278016,
-0.2133522183,
-0.3124083877,
-0.1196801513,
0.5830681324,
-0.361692667,
0.3268776238,
0.5888614655,
-0.4811125696,
-0.1616373062,
0.1363486499,
0.2980979383,
0.2906235158,
-0.3762926757,
-0.0336292908,
0.3451532722,
-0.551040113,
0.2470132113,
0.2948618829,
-0.2425845414,
0.2696675956,
0.3174602091,
0.8754876256,
0.3052984178,
-0.139372021,
0.5368119478,
0.1484396756,
-0.243203938,
-0.6576637626,
-0.0752969086,
-0.158322975,
0.183674708,
0.6661649346,
0.015809726,
0.5048620105,
-0.760279417,
0.4062694609,
0.487550348,
-0.6868315339,
-0.3478048146,
0.737473309,
0.6105046868,
-0.6619881392,
0.5262201428,
0.2298178971,
-0.8020812273,
0.7389603853,
0.4526350498,
1.2477403879,
-0.4504877925,
0.0694003701,
0.5447194576,
0.2724428475,
0.323242873,
0.1928998083,
-0.6689137816,
-0.6767713428,
0.0950859562,
-0.6732038856,
-0.7244355083,
-0.262994498,
-0.8662207127,
0.3305950165,
-0.4228360355,
0.1236735508,
-0.0749635696,
0.1198812276,
-0.5797513127,
0.2505280674,
0.5685427189,
1.0636409521,
-1.0477175713,
0.4451475441,
0.7378935218,
-0.4095430076,
-0.8309273124,
0.1647937745,
0.4045665562,
-0.9983505607,
0.1931853443,
0.2964462936,
-0.3427332342,
0.0514220074,
-0.2951506078,
-0.947568059,
0.8500704765,
0.1226002574,
-0.6552202106,
0.3077261448,
0.5231033564,
0.437494725,
-0.49606812,
0.4663346112,
0.6357398033,
0.3281764984,
0.5042678714,
-0.6869415045,
-0.1820899248,
-0.1134977564,
-0.0171943121,
0.2074914575,
-0.6340942383,
0.4739765227,
-0.3846079707,
-0.5346847773,
0.1143546849,
0.4846280515,
-0.0536609404,
0.3675353527,
0.6022069454,
0.2805468142,
0.6953065991,
-0.1606019437,
0.6211181283,
-0.4666135609,
-0.1994380653,
1.1896855831,
-0.7484445572,
0.9178987145,
0.3044473827,
-0.0139901517,
0.6800822616,
0.4240813255,
0.1036496758,
0.6892615557,
-0.0015616515,
-0.5263438821,
-0.0124493428,
-0.2730287611,
-0.1052512228,
0.7093794346,
0.4457795918,
-0.1031070724,
-0.1579538435,
-0.0769380108,
-0.0329995751,
0.1280388385,
-0.5955218077,
0.861525178,
0.1089693978,
-0.2362220287,
0.5383742452,
-0.6588382721,
0.1575099975,
-0.7591164112,
-0.2445787042,
-0.4823373556,
0.0500825047,
-0.0991400853,
-0.3205615282,
0.3317267597,
-0.0353054218,
-0.2880238891,
-0.1285682768,
0.5656890869,
-0.8195981979,
-0.3380128443,
0.2228112817,
0.2066233605,
0.1536904424,
-0.1922568232,
-0.3401440382,
-0.0029407232,
-0.1810549498,
0.1388780326,
0.1190942973,
0.4592576027,
-0.1194376722,
0.3670915961,
0.7991095781,
0.5923964977,
-0.0491923094,
0.1814736873,
0.7000288963,
-0.559032023,
-0.7024300694,
-0.398299545,
0.5145545006,
-0.2726025581,
-0.2429270595,
0.8136227131,
0.3167435229,
0.6728897095,
0.2678237557,
0.8913629651,
-0.0200211741,
0.6982476115,
-0.235140875,
0.8946407437,
-0.4139316678,
-0.0644507185,
-0.0654589459,
-0.9735372663,
-0.3076699972,
0.525629878,
-0.3632428646,
-0.1546197534,
0.3004075885,
0.9929429889,
-0.1180950552,
-0.2547149062,
0.2769714594,
0.2242561877,
0.0702604428,
0.295062989,
0.5075215101,
-0.3044528365,
0.5025900006,
-0.1357959658,
-0.2321474552,
-0.33686167,
-0.6076079011,
-0.7289791107,
-0.4498976767,
-0.1655157655,
-0.059982013,
0.6310822964,
1.0314118862,
0.9575706124,
-1.1855283976,
-0.2418492883,
0.2030216157,
-0.1039470509,
-0.2468748093,
-0.1559563279,
0.2774190903,
-0.0135480603,
-0.6208251119,
0.6051123738,
0.6033275723,
-0.0193133559,
-0.131752491,
0.1204953566,
-0.0296251494,
0.5203159451,
0.402564466,
1.043615222,
-0.1870736778,
-0.3856176138,
-0.3021842241,
0.3185560107,
0.2790971994,
0.9888338447,
-0.4513683915,
0.7052159309,
0.0808845386,
0.5236494541,
0.5463336706,
0.2773632705,
0.9786911607,
-0.8339680433,
0.3943146765,
0.3428201079,
0.3867970407,
0.7220714688,
-0.2612908781,
0.2567567825,
-0.1232152432,
-0.6103082895,
-0.6422413588,
0.2015494108,
-0.744561553,
0.2063928545,
1.2096912861,
-0.3094189465,
-0.3423433006,
-0.5426947474,
-0.1901197731,
0.1816983819,
-0.5557044148,
0.8525468707,
0.2717646658,
0.0202046894,
-0.1822300255,
-0.300411582,
0.554882586,
0.250929296,
-0.301194489,
-0.127390489,
0.5975637436,
0.3419696391,
0.2039598823,
0.4129016697,
0.1495255083,
0.1134536043,
0.2707813084,
0.3369209468,
-0.0611568727,
-0.422198534,
-0.7837997079,
0.2398407608,
-0.0245448407,
-0.546982348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01796v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01796v2
|
Speech foundation models in healthcare: Effect of layer selection on pathological speech feature prediction
| 2024-02-02T05:09:42 | 2024-06-21T13:49:56 |
Daniela A. Wiepert, Rene L. Utianski, Joseph R. Duffy, John L. Stricker, Leland R. Barnard, David T. Jones, Hugo Botha
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Accurately extracting clinical information from speech is critical to the
diagnosis and treatment of many neurological conditions. As such, there is
interest in leveraging AI for automatic, objective assessments of clinical
speech to facilitate diagnosis and treatment of speech disorders. We explore
transfer learning using foundation models, focusing on the impact of layer
selection for the downstream task of predicting pathological speech features.
We find that selecting an optimal layer can greatly improve performance (~15.8%
increase in balanced accuracy per feature as compared to worst layer, ~13.6%
increase as compared to final layer), though the best layer varies by predicted
feature and does not always generalize well to unseen data. A learned weighted
sum offers comparable performance to the average best layer in-distribution
(only ~1.2% lower) and had strong generalization for out-of-distribution data
(only 1.5% lower than the average best layer).
|
[
-0.2033560574,
-0.5052877069,
0.3195407987,
0.1712220311,
-0.1049875692,
-0.1925687492,
0.0673652887,
-1.0174430609,
0.2329499722,
0.8799370527,
-0.1959730834,
-0.2272892445,
-0.9989409447,
-0.5696805716,
-0.7394951582,
0.9113295078,
0.4177494645,
0.4042828679,
-0.2497252077,
-0.0413425006,
-0.4157803953,
-0.2046910673,
-1.100061059,
-0.944091022,
0.1072669476,
0.2525708079,
0.6387217045,
0.8554784656,
0.8371220827,
0.2529304922,
0.0347444639,
-0.5127515793,
-0.4024955928,
0.2591653168,
-0.0295407083,
-0.4340194166,
-0.3583429158,
0.0447998159,
0.5739625692,
1.3439551592,
-0.3796489835,
-0.0929110497,
-0.1990338266,
0.981205225,
-0.4016360343,
0.0027708276,
-0.3263416588,
0.2783738971,
-0.0080395676,
-0.2241499424,
-0.3134841919,
-0.1166187897,
1.0039843321,
-0.3539313972,
0.2464111298,
-0.2482807785,
0.4834558964,
0.3488687873,
-0.3282592595,
-0.1859377921,
-0.7382694483,
0.4665756226,
-0.3913133442,
0.5900297165,
0.6544064283,
0.6215820909,
0.2470277995,
-1.1000074148,
0.2521437407,
-0.5481367707,
0.0335555524,
-0.0012543509,
-0.4145055711,
0.1418096125,
0.1768603176,
0.2998607457,
-0.4500619471,
0.1910018921,
-0.6828952432,
-0.4610618651,
0.7313826084,
-0.0881358609,
0.4422754645,
-0.0346400179,
-0.2587057352,
-0.0784420744,
-0.4765304029,
0.3668104112,
-0.2137957215,
0.3279893994,
-0.1331825852,
0.1238220483,
-0.2210971862,
0.8312731385,
0.0588058904,
-0.427116394,
0.4083510339,
0.0936406031,
-0.3915169537,
0.6285458207,
0.3552622199,
-0.1052991003,
0.2163328081,
-0.3625885546,
-0.0050244392,
0.097932063,
0.257509172,
-0.8380413055,
-0.6308627129,
0.1092621163,
-0.5852385163,
-0.6779748797,
0.017802028,
-0.3826490343,
-0.5741133094,
-0.3886708915,
0.22236678,
-0.5390091538,
-0.2902260721,
0.2288155109,
-0.3015471995,
-0.1269334853,
0.3143364787,
-0.8797460794,
0.7051428556,
0.2791299224,
0.7779787779,
-0.3268119991,
-0.006674882,
-0.9031004906,
0.3865889311,
-0.1781657338,
0.8153441548,
-0.6784541607,
-0.3717658222,
-0.4472983778,
-0.2411936969,
-0.2100783288,
-0.7083523273,
0.5106830597,
-0.0088514537,
0.1004292145,
-0.2032182217,
-0.2735227942,
-0.1732259542,
-0.4769272506,
-0.8129787445,
0.5680667162,
0.5991780758,
-0.5621680617,
0.4126578867,
-0.6093274355,
-0.9475131035,
-0.0631233677,
-0.0490117818,
-0.2813315392,
0.0932820365,
0.1830406636,
0.5118704438,
-0.1855685562,
0.17594181,
-0.140084669,
-0.2471777499,
0.2222662568,
-0.0176456273,
0.8724085689,
0.2636347711,
-0.653731823,
-0.0482567325,
-1.0272407532,
-0.0293347575,
-0.138052538,
-0.119604215,
-0.3207333982,
-0.09088175,
-0.0917253718,
0.2327297181,
-0.4937105477,
-0.3072300851,
-0.4075278938,
-0.5958991647,
0.6256819963,
0.5489704609,
0.1202557981,
0.4804934561,
-0.710146904,
0.6494334936,
0.3443940282,
0.0246905517,
0.3846593797,
-0.6879377961,
-0.3998789191,
-0.3359017074,
0.4638332725,
0.5838218927,
-0.3434547186,
0.0175522603,
-0.1066423953,
-0.4224494696,
-0.5907136202,
-0.0887195095,
0.5005510449,
1.0307910442,
0.4047054648,
-0.493653059,
-0.4274455905,
-0.9475050569,
0.1342509687,
-0.1567676216,
0.1340560764,
0.4773038328,
0.1306692064,
-0.0573936701,
0.6479841471,
-0.3486348391,
-0.4685961306,
-0.1428278089,
-0.0359235927,
-0.1274853945,
0.5911511183,
0.7372507453,
-0.8696609139,
-0.4490444064,
0.2419785857,
-0.4981669784,
-0.2446040511,
0.2783574164,
-0.0646613166,
-0.171943292,
0.2002286017,
-0.5665819049,
0.4315716922,
0.6685284376,
-0.1472835392,
0.2768809199,
0.0880179256,
0.0062490171,
-0.9783911109,
0.2029122114,
0.2007827014,
-0.396738559,
-0.8074136376,
-0.2512055635,
-0.2188425511,
-0.2586493492,
-0.2964621186,
0.3641361594,
-0.2754387259,
-0.3264704049,
-0.1126804575,
0.0983225554,
0.0544229783,
0.0277497619,
-0.0668758228,
0.616240859,
1.0637465715,
-0.7143043876,
0.3146366179,
0.079035908,
-0.5211051106,
0.3809442818,
-0.6259673238,
0.0874448642,
-0.0088086817,
0.2491117865,
-0.8326460123,
-0.2724012136,
-0.0638230368,
-0.6420951486,
0.508962214,
0.0757877156,
0.5377171636,
-0.106845066,
-0.0123604992,
0.0437869728,
0.633012414,
0.0076910187,
0.5664203763,
0.7581506371,
-0.2110539824,
-0.7853099108,
-1.3517135382,
-0.1368533373,
-0.2011606544,
-0.7234174013,
0.8068969846,
0.1690648645,
-0.2533438206,
0.2494215518,
-0.2146036476,
-0.0952429995,
0.399967432,
0.3025804162,
-0.2400659025,
-0.4222084582,
0.0949374288,
0.1837984622,
-0.2022196501,
0.1479567587,
-0.2965828478,
0.4122013748,
0.0253912676,
-0.2907126844,
-0.4646956921,
0.3085495234,
0.5756989717,
-0.2686995566,
0.4573339224,
0.4651220739,
-0.7811920047,
-0.4657458663,
-0.4147439301,
-0.3788447678,
-0.3988881707,
0.5326851606,
-0.389934063,
-0.6137326956,
0.6952971816,
-0.0156225357,
-0.3730714917,
0.5228659511,
0.2682238519,
-0.2681221664,
1.1518329382,
0.755505681,
-0.2522263527,
0.5062842965,
-0.3936194181,
-0.0554411002,
-0.8034405112,
-0.326872617,
-0.7217454314,
-0.4207823277,
-0.4205836356,
0.0867513344,
0.4834631085,
0.1181292832,
0.1121462807,
-0.0076744696,
-0.646633029,
0.1356374025,
0.3465176523,
0.7370996475,
0.0272146091,
0.3224517107,
-0.175812602,
0.1160405502,
-0.6459041834,
0.0452608466,
1.0626233816,
0.4854298234,
0.3186295629,
0.1009368971,
0.5549291372,
0.4524359703,
0.2482947707,
-0.7560551167,
0.2544449568,
-0.6532052159,
-0.2441879511,
-0.4471275806,
-0.4866417646,
-0.838880837,
0.0291538257,
-0.2939764261,
-0.6446616054,
0.5037422776,
0.1418922842,
-0.5251589417,
-0.0696530715,
-0.5626194477,
0.4749571979,
-0.2206390351,
-0.0412798673,
-0.3714140654,
-0.8638240695,
0.3149723709,
0.0166708007,
0.0933694765,
-0.0069682598,
0.0747599974,
0.8695676327,
-0.0467224605,
0.6286528111,
-0.2827284932,
0.3867680132,
0.0462651774,
0.0477944948,
0.0871335566,
-0.2831883729,
-0.4070245028,
0.0172003917,
-0.0759250745,
-0.290422976,
-0.7273002267,
0.680275619,
-0.9173298478,
-0.5708256364,
-0.23082681,
-0.433891207,
-0.7583418489,
0.0338888913,
0.2663539648,
0.7644206285,
-0.1074462757,
0.5715417266,
0.7985113263,
0.1418055296,
0.2281088829,
0.170029372,
0.0347656235,
-0.4464139044,
0.7699998617,
0.2840099037,
0.4444371462,
0.3652748168,
0.8212723136,
-0.1136205122,
-1.153888464,
-0.3494821787,
0.1540378034,
-0.9605741501,
-0.0968342051,
-0.8049451113,
-0.7128694654,
-0.6694432497,
0.0324668661,
-0.0509605296,
-0.7972729206,
-0.4404478073,
-0.4424591959,
0.0883626863,
0.5316964984,
-0.0585077219,
0.2310509831,
-0.6115834713,
0.0962447152,
0.2875737846,
0.1821321398,
0.0021348565,
-0.7211689949,
-0.1998790354,
0.0266959369,
-0.2453217059,
-0.8594732881,
0.2376512438,
0.6732885242,
0.9434534311,
0.5805665851,
-0.2087073922,
0.6323131323,
-0.113816835,
0.5661914945,
0.3856363297,
-0.8816803098,
0.7718362212,
0.0285507292,
0.0327036753,
0.6184752584,
0.4308353961,
-0.4222548604,
-0.2255395502,
-0.7577931881,
-0.3909594417,
0.8029282093,
0.0891875997,
-0.1900611967,
0.3919613659,
0.5530936122,
0.0301209204,
0.1156788468,
-0.4630080163,
-0.3047382534,
-0.2131188065,
-0.0354901068,
-0.0788403377,
-0.0721060783,
-0.3754073083,
-0.5750467777,
0.5024719238,
-0.0735205337,
0.3418715894,
0.4777107537,
-0.0647997335,
-0.6060333848,
-0.2019291818,
0.7887076139,
1.0428823233,
-0.2394027263,
0.0753968582,
0.030280076,
-0.7881165147,
-0.0850151479,
0.2550532818,
-0.0860347003,
-0.0616740063,
0.793771565,
1.2119127512,
0.1399234533,
-0.3934780061,
0.5811936259,
0.2158172876,
-0.3630301952,
0.0442840569,
0.4270173013,
0.1463150978,
0.172134921,
0.3062883019,
0.6273290515,
0.6477832794,
-0.5366413593,
0.6705102324,
0.5118272305,
-0.6510760784,
-0.1885592788,
0.5319725871,
0.2770557404,
-0.3508344591,
0.7921136618,
0.6798884273,
-0.4662255049,
0.8919097781,
0.7869960666,
0.8486207128,
-0.7033157945,
0.3460220397,
-0.0664524287,
0.0946851224,
-0.0036465283,
-0.0259142164,
0.0996737555,
-0.6833103299,
-0.280148387,
-0.6733661294,
-0.2949446738,
0.1069694832,
-0.6964499354,
0.2984697521,
-0.5198052526,
-0.3006303012,
0.3925953507,
0.1057876199,
-0.3377122879,
0.7142641544,
0.2969926596,
0.8447552919,
-0.8119722009,
1.0719542503,
0.6499034762,
-0.2256488651,
-1.0131169558,
-0.2783741355,
-0.158871755,
-1.0237600803,
0.5733451247,
0.1147835925,
-0.229096815,
0.126902476,
-0.1546061337,
-1.1821742058,
1.1171746254,
0.9594172239,
-0.425830096,
-0.1595702618,
0.27939713,
0.6142106652,
-0.7409029007,
0.338801533,
0.6331115365,
0.1450495422,
0.5614714026,
-1.114426136,
0.0561246015,
-0.0805261061,
-0.0004513889,
-0.0141429994,
-0.2466383576,
0.9434834123,
-0.4836305678,
-0.1294754297,
-0.4066464901,
0.277425468,
0.0828151777,
0.4571224749,
0.5769190192,
0.5969699025,
1.0609378815,
-0.0182140637,
1.306263566,
-0.3764480054,
-0.0858968571,
0.5499562025,
-0.0871279687,
0.7238167524,
0.0759368613,
-0.1252673715,
0.5005990267,
0.6987866759,
0.4279482365,
0.930637598,
0.1201660782,
0.0055150809,
-0.0903043821,
-0.153801769,
-0.8093263507,
0.6927423477,
0.3721163869,
-0.7631505132,
0.0669222474,
0.2058204263,
-0.3117137849,
-0.1913125068,
-0.2910660207,
0.8178865314,
0.3537300825,
-0.5061307549,
0.5521310568,
-0.1426522434,
0.0688406304,
-0.6987859011,
-0.2074819952,
-0.144619599,
0.0848061964,
-0.5661145449,
-0.3789291382,
0.4666516483,
-0.7029953003,
-0.2274232209,
-0.1774110198,
1.0600452423,
-0.2722056508,
-0.4711409807,
0.4506531656,
0.3768402636,
0.1231896877,
-0.0555648096,
-0.9483388066,
-0.1261975914,
0.0737948567,
-0.3776290417,
0.5479393601,
0.0268930495,
-0.2138303965,
0.9065515399,
0.7481882572,
0.6637530327,
-0.0624232069,
0.2467031628,
0.8098600507,
-0.2920262516,
-0.8304405808,
-0.6561504602,
0.48657462,
-0.1290870756,
-0.2508218288,
0.0039108223,
0.1807055771,
0.5997336507,
0.2044327557,
0.7879303098,
0.1888363361,
0.5405367613,
-0.6791221499,
0.8897554278,
-0.4990164936,
0.1579058319,
-0.2996176779,
-0.6998720169,
-0.2999323606,
0.6657088399,
-0.2742461264,
0.3178007305,
1.0194476843,
0.3822945356,
-0.1088317856,
0.3819413185,
0.4544520676,
0.1426133066,
0.343210876,
0.7814139724,
0.3827114701,
-0.2477463037,
0.0904702693,
-0.8994748592,
-0.5643958449,
-0.0174128544,
-0.8033540845,
-0.6872003675,
-0.5824792385,
-0.3555236161,
-0.4300828278,
0.2833386362,
0.7086046934,
1.314281702,
-1.0888431072,
-0.2713190615,
0.0351435319,
0.0078052776,
-0.6142205596,
-0.1657059938,
0.5705653429,
0.0688742474,
-0.2295262963,
0.5944095254,
0.1587923318,
-0.0549525917,
-0.2332353443,
0.053962633,
0.0612990297,
-0.2635783851,
0.4708174169,
-0.065841414,
-0.68837744,
-0.2581403852,
-0.1562114805,
-0.1671598852,
0.0888918415,
1.0183838606,
-0.9466590285,
0.2028155029,
0.3521279097,
0.9444189668,
0.5241747499,
0.050701987,
0.5570146441,
-0.2995805442,
0.0999240279,
0.6903574467,
0.2789236307,
0.3877552152,
-0.8553407192,
0.4920602143,
0.5134939551,
-0.2845618129,
-0.924187839,
0.0016141197,
-1.0606725216,
-0.1957721263,
0.880425334,
-0.0088090627,
-0.1611771882,
-0.0100000184,
0.1358283907,
0.1115181521,
-0.2771828473,
0.6818317175,
0.5791675448,
-0.8167744875,
-0.495939225,
-0.6368297338,
0.9441705346,
0.3666373491,
-0.7012620568,
-0.4487197101,
0.4619212449,
0.6927164197,
0.0692204461,
0.6033228636,
-0.0552012511,
0.6072704792,
-0.2755749822,
-0.4392801523,
-0.311170876,
-0.5173859,
-0.4915922582,
0.569690764,
-0.0937819779,
-0.1098341793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01135v1
|
A Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System
| 2024-02-02T04:20:13 | 2024-02-02T04:20:13 |
Jiabao Fang, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Xiuying Chen, Suzan Verberne, Zhaochun Ren
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Due to strong capabilities in conducting fluent, multi-turn conversations
with users, Large Language Models (LLMs) have the potential to further improve
the performance of Conversational Recommender System (CRS). Unlike the aimless
chit-chat that LLM excels at, CRS has a clear target. So it is imperative to
control the dialogue flow in the LLM to successfully recommend appropriate
items to the users. Furthermore, user feedback in CRS can assist the system in
better modeling user preferences, which has been ignored by existing studies.
However, simply prompting LLM to conduct conversational recommendation cannot
address the above two key challenges.
In this paper, we propose Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System
(MACRS) which contains two essential modules. First, we design a multi-agent
act planning framework, which can control the dialogue flow based on four
LLM-based agents. This cooperative multi-agent framework will generate various
candidate responses based on different dialogue acts and then choose the most
appropriate response as the system response, which can help MACRS plan suitable
dialogue acts. Second, we propose a user feedback-aware reflection mechanism
which leverages user feedback to reason errors made in previous turns to adjust
the dialogue act planning, and higher-level user information from implicit
semantics. We conduct extensive experiments based on user simulator to
demonstrate the effectiveness of MACRS in recommendation and user preferences
collection. Experimental results illustrate that MACRS demonstrates an
improvement in user interaction experience compared to directly using LLMs.
|
[
-0.4815196991,
-0.5802192688,
0.5233097672,
0.3852205873,
-0.1067461371,
0.3400319517,
-0.1083396301,
-0.3752931356,
0.4059579372,
1.0238230228,
-0.5973408222,
-0.2186767906,
-0.4243549407,
0.0508256555,
-0.0260694325,
1.0116568804,
0.0443318151,
0.249654308,
0.0693025067,
-0.087476179,
-0.6724615097,
-0.593541503,
-0.8732768297,
-0.5209897161,
0.7565920949,
0.6186197996,
0.8604122996,
-0.0701800734,
0.4623668492,
0.4112938643,
0.1587818116,
0.6719664335,
-0.4304171205,
0.4749281406,
0.099405013,
-0.2220582217,
-0.7057229877,
-0.4414678812,
0.3352380991,
-0.0218534395,
-0.5863243341,
-0.319938004,
0.0838927478,
0.4614591897,
-0.3634343743,
0.1714239568,
-0.501598537,
-0.1161669716,
0.1890126914,
-0.4545590878,
-0.5886073112,
-0.2431349158,
0.2489577979,
-0.362121284,
-0.0863844454,
0.329269886,
0.3083277047,
-0.0749999657,
-0.4600944519,
-0.224177137,
-0.9607915878,
0.6705175638,
-0.7802314758,
0.2785880864,
0.1308348477,
0.5636726022,
-0.3952968419,
-0.2575582862,
-0.4784772694,
-0.4702467918,
-0.0700048655,
0.0955952182,
0.1372880638,
0.1500079036,
-0.123174496,
-0.0131308204,
-0.2419176549,
-0.1852619946,
-0.0606206506,
-0.3577871025,
0.5593681931,
0.4497370124,
0.1993668973,
0.1722601354,
-0.6466035247,
-0.2345676869,
-0.5450646877,
0.1929041594,
0.1780859679,
0.5437107682,
-0.05032897,
0.7010282874,
-0.246670872,
0.2794712782,
0.1432429701,
-0.3925531209,
0.0851405039,
-0.3218362629,
0.1002213731,
-0.1209644899,
1.0032866001,
0.5584346652,
0.4598205686,
-0.0131377317,
-0.2144226432,
-0.0576963834,
0.1822503358,
-0.8726525903,
0.1542153656,
-0.0506074131,
-0.1743320525,
-0.1013563201,
0.0474879332,
-0.5325573683,
-0.4863535464,
-0.3499266207,
0.2310693711,
-0.3220477998,
-0.2204761505,
0.1364531815,
0.0553232022,
-0.0400470719,
0.6554202437,
-0.6493463516,
0.649712801,
0.3753614724,
0.7454451919,
-0.0243915711,
-0.3671031892,
-0.3811824024,
0.366691649,
-0.1157769412,
0.8586423993,
-0.893244803,
-0.6371020079,
0.1367912143,
-0.0347619839,
0.121818766,
-0.1997578889,
0.248922646,
-0.5622316599,
-0.0916562304,
-0.3965417445,
-0.0835088119,
-0.2298288643,
0.463318944,
-0.3919901252,
0.7411848307,
-0.2155903578,
-0.4735638499,
0.0670977458,
-0.8128796816,
-0.3197586238,
0.0358413495,
-0.2164969742,
-0.1179310009,
-0.2146804482,
0.3912703395,
0.4477217197,
-0.2782941461,
0.3866670132,
-0.4464612603,
-0.3894775212,
0.4512250721,
-0.4120135307,
0.1070708632,
0.185864687,
-0.1200685352,
0.4209009707,
-0.2935006618,
0.0836981833,
-0.1908642501,
-0.4053166509,
0.0610796809,
0.2084359378,
0.1904341578,
0.402114749,
0.0600722767,
-0.4513816833,
0.2250826359,
-0.1402060539,
0.2984987497,
0.7896826863,
0.0431541465,
0.4317910671,
-0.6925601363,
0.5422323346,
0.1897296906,
0.1208443791,
-0.2203650326,
-0.4401421249,
-0.7090014815,
-0.3069212139,
-0.2322428972,
0.5161041021,
-0.7835409641,
0.1558805555,
0.0568340011,
-0.2958801091,
-0.3649785519,
0.2738790512,
0.5057585239,
0.0331509374,
0.1753430963,
-0.4836451113,
-0.4204714,
-0.6835781932,
0.035101071,
-0.2951835096,
0.1063886508,
0.9006860256,
0.0269994531,
-0.3943144381,
0.967059195,
-0.4479274154,
-0.5880335569,
-0.5718251467,
-0.1054245904,
-0.1964777857,
-0.0170015804,
0.2431950271,
-0.5016389489,
-0.5385956168,
-0.0790597945,
-0.2059722543,
-0.0585809499,
0.1057276353,
-0.1966216564,
0.240943104,
0.1175538599,
-0.5093626976,
0.262935847,
0.3614216447,
-0.2315450609,
0.5277129412,
-0.450004518,
0.2034904212,
-1.0502429008,
-0.2512244582,
0.181276381,
-0.2564651668,
-0.3855419457,
-0.3611193299,
-0.2807271481,
0.1230206713,
-0.4607365429,
0.6412515044,
-0.2490895092,
0.1109850481,
-0.5288802981,
0.302642107,
0.121698305,
0.8225966096,
0.0874884874,
0.7039759755,
0.3539783657,
-0.696858108,
0.4220184982,
0.5587624311,
0.139021337,
0.545551002,
-0.6469207406,
0.3012071252,
0.0463313013,
0.7961220145,
-1.0587099791,
0.1171595529,
0.4097892642,
-0.1109223217,
-0.089162536,
0.1006684825,
-0.1985230148,
-0.2631618977,
-0.3518843651,
0.0480872914,
-0.0699352026,
-0.412399292,
0.9215741158,
0.3511942327,
-0.405575633,
-0.7438306212,
-0.3943159282,
0.2685062289,
0.136642769,
-0.7151765227,
0.0808154345,
-0.5730780959,
-0.1487433612,
-0.3048303723,
0.2856082916,
0.1442443281,
-0.3089081347,
0.6487377286,
0.3904565871,
0.0356891453,
0.1816853434,
-0.1865080148,
-0.1622787416,
-0.1428808123,
0.0155792283,
0.6932122707,
-0.4073471725,
-0.3666816652,
-0.5968952775,
0.3445300758,
0.6448151469,
-0.2379927039,
0.4837223887,
0.5088227987,
0.3066987395,
-0.1445656121,
-1.0276353359,
-0.4971298873,
-0.5138850808,
0.2398218513,
-0.5518827438,
-1.1151520014,
0.4138327241,
-0.1231781244,
0.2076356411,
-0.1180484146,
0.8586418033,
0.1411870867,
1.2895431519,
0.6686971188,
-0.283144325,
0.5446634293,
-0.2518505752,
0.2984423339,
-0.9863977432,
-0.3153268099,
-0.5773709416,
-0.1456408352,
-0.3196932673,
-0.2044307441,
0.1472948045,
-0.3904333711,
-0.200888887,
0.1699440032,
-0.3408307433,
0.2641461194,
0.4901068807,
0.3284793198,
0.4117860198,
-0.1397121698,
-0.4490576982,
0.3195209205,
-0.4614874423,
-0.7665698528,
0.739487648,
0.209164694,
0.982776463,
0.2200056911,
0.3111015856,
0.3080623448,
0.2039704025,
-0.8178480268,
0.7732121944,
0.1564775854,
-0.5305809379,
-0.4780231416,
-0.2492290884,
-0.6434745789,
0.4684166014,
-0.3052494228,
-0.7064259648,
0.1269246191,
-0.0226652604,
-0.3392055333,
0.2500473857,
-0.4202999175,
0.2407203019,
-0.1702941209,
-0.3644170165,
-0.4688912928,
-0.6130917668,
0.165669024,
0.1019386575,
0.3557915986,
-0.15906322,
0.2812962532,
0.4953773618,
-0.5383845568,
0.830253005,
-0.142465353,
0.0486884937,
0.5438309908,
0.3169569969,
0.761010468,
0.1143749058,
-0.2267714292,
-0.0776006654,
0.0858518332,
0.0298719537,
-0.516041398,
0.740773499,
-0.770169735,
-0.6921170354,
-0.2212781906,
-0.6952648759,
-0.2310637385,
0.036744196,
-0.3274120092,
0.6287215948,
-0.3525589705,
0.0401482768,
0.0075440882,
0.014627941,
0.6052305102,
1.020021081,
-0.5159756541,
-0.5986706614,
0.7284939885,
-0.2797670066,
0.135458827,
0.2799805999,
0.3156541288,
-0.4289976656,
-0.3596118391,
-0.4795545042,
0.3143359423,
-0.4297436476,
-0.0719066933,
-0.7222531438,
-0.0496567264,
-0.2917846143,
-0.1442902982,
-0.1264923364,
-0.0469584726,
-0.0890496895,
0.0174319707,
0.333103925,
0.8585327268,
0.1625347435,
0.6741935015,
-0.6447207332,
0.232176438,
0.2460733503,
0.3764050901,
0.107970655,
-0.3141693771,
-0.248340562,
0.1455381513,
-0.7469982505,
-0.4121353924,
0.581802845,
0.0170250721,
0.4328921437,
0.8685881495,
0.1954895109,
0.4229646325,
-0.5173913836,
0.6838362217,
0.3447428346,
-0.6238673329,
0.2403635383,
-0.1786286831,
0.1667093635,
0.5560617447,
-0.0757913142,
-0.5808750987,
-0.5997772217,
-0.2586966455,
-0.3724980354,
0.8926525712,
-0.0151006076,
0.2265190482,
0.0356991664,
0.1455216706,
-0.0227906909,
0.1979723275,
-0.5090627074,
-0.1606595516,
0.0014106027,
0.0554400943,
-0.4832585752,
-0.4688511491,
-0.1317647099,
0.2268913537,
0.8480044603,
-0.3202675283,
0.0262634177,
0.2775251567,
0.1487910748,
-0.4556999803,
0.6517250538,
0.6209327579,
0.6089943051,
-0.2519890964,
0.0678929314,
0.1791893393,
-0.3658113778,
0.3137931824,
-0.262306422,
0.1599808782,
-0.2257799506,
-0.2929958999,
0.7420834303,
0.1957360804,
-0.4957299232,
0.5374557376,
-0.419392854,
-0.0718248561,
-0.14978531,
0.2072087973,
0.1636077613,
0.346622467,
0.1297241896,
0.3930099905,
0.0826180056,
-0.5720959902,
-0.0778602958,
0.7286043167,
-0.6539917588,
-0.1536033154,
0.1074181944,
0.4683262408,
-0.7486966252,
0.2445744425,
0.2377505898,
-0.691100657,
0.238152951,
0.6131703258,
0.6195740104,
-0.4167449176,
0.4436399043,
0.0150997872,
0.0265382044,
-0.3891664147,
0.1096723899,
-0.0479039289,
-1.0082299709,
-0.3387551308,
-0.3808113039,
-0.8377032876,
-0.1799628139,
-0.2047590166,
0.3744131625,
-0.3772467077,
-0.4221462309,
-0.0507161021,
0.1148496866,
-0.4660935998,
0.034573108,
-0.1338366419,
0.4191547334,
-0.3138951063,
0.7289193273,
0.4477346838,
-0.3257744014,
-0.9067750573,
-0.3754887581,
-0.012249779,
-0.5649835467,
0.4370556474,
0.0440821238,
-0.9765426517,
-0.2290821373,
-0.4402683377,
-0.5378844142,
1.0275000334,
0.2141213119,
-0.7400864959,
0.1645655483,
0.1075687632,
0.5905401707,
-0.7257248163,
0.9559831619,
0.0550308488,
0.5097126365,
0.6785430908,
-0.9888970852,
0.068109341,
-0.1124643907,
0.0328526571,
0.2326807082,
-0.9907968044,
0.5343943238,
-0.5003783703,
0.0842436925,
0.1338670701,
0.291701138,
0.4346781075,
0.4512599111,
0.5714077353,
0.0972540453,
0.3392527699,
0.3322984278,
0.9426736832,
-0.3560428023,
-0.0557139777,
1.093346715,
-0.8832907081,
0.8848680258,
0.3158232272,
-0.0473370962,
0.7144580483,
0.1675981432,
0.2130354792,
0.3543452919,
0.1685414016,
-0.379150629,
-0.3945750892,
-0.2894261777,
-0.2215944231,
0.396966666,
0.2598128319,
-0.0748549402,
0.0311201047,
-0.027821485,
-0.0357838236,
-0.1747390181,
0.0339582376,
1.0277636051,
0.2279423475,
-0.764201045,
0.1079090312,
0.0707015023,
0.7628525496,
-0.7993631363,
-0.1984372735,
-0.0532261059,
0.3622072041,
-0.1250718832,
-0.4070801735,
-0.3431637585,
-0.3216724992,
-0.1916314811,
-0.1471010149,
1.0050961971,
-0.4119431078,
-0.4447531104,
0.4925762117,
0.6036989689,
0.1790302247,
-0.0839279145,
-0.6011439562,
-0.1007798612,
-0.0865105987,
-0.2025884837,
0.2030274868,
0.2986564338,
-0.1913330555,
1.1843950748,
0.792139709,
0.1810937822,
-0.2842756808,
0.409370929,
0.8285871744,
-0.6101617813,
-0.5569455028,
-0.6615257263,
0.1607043445,
0.161700055,
0.0250348877,
0.6576880217,
0.3861305118,
0.3917453587,
0.1043146104,
0.7488074899,
0.3708492815,
0.5917978287,
-0.1056218743,
0.4641752839,
-0.2088724822,
0.6461891532,
-0.3928453624,
-1.0658318996,
-0.0496607646,
0.3132813275,
-0.1563358009,
0.3625232875,
0.5955523252,
1.1668301821,
0.1984215975,
0.1548920572,
0.3906583488,
0.0506662726,
0.5854693651,
0.4296536446,
1.0587056875,
0.0110181635,
0.7398582101,
0.1417858154,
-0.1263259053,
-0.5982242227,
-0.5447033644,
-0.8667469621,
-0.3444137573,
-0.0542677566,
-0.22465913,
0.1631866843,
1.0729885101,
0.7743924856,
-0.7845932245,
-0.6078941226,
0.1584933847,
0.0985945463,
-0.1473807693,
-0.1884100735,
0.0893487409,
-0.252807945,
-0.4968600571,
0.5611439347,
0.4017653465,
0.012731391,
-0.4801631868,
-0.7718952894,
-0.1587514877,
0.4756415486,
0.5616245866,
-0.0679827258,
-1.0553475618,
-0.2995947897,
-0.1328285486,
-0.3610417545,
0.1643846482,
1.0096482038,
-0.7340844274,
0.5205408335,
0.1533747911,
0.072049655,
0.6292024255,
0.0985348523,
0.6607511044,
-0.3066176772,
-0.1671806425,
-0.0185189545,
0.3512477875,
0.15842475,
-0.4032871425,
0.2090211958,
-0.3437202275,
-0.7810609341,
-0.3330285847,
0.080821842,
-1.3394888639,
-0.1264264584,
1.1806468964,
0.0416992493,
0.1647694707,
-0.3314036429,
-1.0299657583,
0.0984766334,
-1.2235109806,
0.7068124413,
0.7143502235,
-0.2706924677,
-0.1979516596,
-0.1914830804,
0.1536208242,
0.3373964429,
-0.5584810972,
-0.0214821994,
0.5913338065,
0.1848488152,
0.268196106,
1.0199426413,
0.1731967777,
-0.0910338759,
-0.4105574191,
0.2821183801,
-0.35247612,
-0.6022742987,
-0.0719373822,
0.3728609979,
0.2687812448,
0.101974465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01118v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01118v3
|
PokeLLMon: A Human-Parity Agent for Pokemon Battles with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-02T03:22:12 | 2024-04-02T15:46:35 |
Sihao Hu, Tiansheng Huang, Ling Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce PokeLLMon, the first LLM-embodied agent that achieves
human-parity performance in tactical battle games, as demonstrated in Pokemon
battles. The design of PokeLLMon incorporates three key strategies: (i)
In-context reinforcement learning that instantly consumes text-based feedback
derived from battles to iteratively refine the policy; (ii) Knowledge-augmented
generation that retrieves external knowledge to counteract hallucination and
enables the agent to act timely and properly; (iii) Consistent action
generation to mitigate the panic switching phenomenon when the agent faces a
powerful opponent and wants to elude the battle. We show that online battles
against human demonstrates PokeLLMon's human-like battle strategies and
just-in-time decision making, achieving 49% of win rate in the Ladder
competitions and 56% of win rate in the invited battles. Our implementation and
playable battle logs are available at: https://github.com/git-disl/PokeLLMon.
|
[
-0.3839828074,
-0.9156293273,
0.6767838001,
0.4969856143,
0.0229745116,
0.5165285468,
-0.3746822178,
-0.3983409405,
0.8241721988,
0.1976082623,
-0.4436995983,
-0.3542478383,
-0.3629022837,
0.063860558,
0.0113712223,
0.5934442878,
0.0734290108,
-0.0257355627,
0.0580643639,
0.0091575403,
-0.4178164899,
-0.6343732476,
-1.050231576,
-0.7663053274,
0.5791246295,
0.4607197046,
0.8343615532,
0.5189130306,
0.452837944,
0.4009079337,
0.0295232851,
0.0869205818,
-0.5908233523,
0.1515572369,
-0.5803652406,
-0.8236298561,
-0.8956506848,
0.2447790504,
0.3888642788,
0.4032191932,
-0.36336568,
-0.1614073068,
-0.1524698585,
0.5588613749,
-0.123563461,
0.0450541861,
-0.5218321681,
0.3150043488,
-0.2006835639,
-0.3166822791,
-0.1888928562,
0.0324513614,
0.2455129623,
-1.1038610935,
0.3338218033,
0.3013926744,
0.8124817014,
-0.0324310064,
-0.0534960143,
-0.1703175157,
-0.4873817563,
0.5747722983,
-0.395832628,
0.1108141392,
0.5087748766,
0.4492703378,
-0.4912702739,
-0.680632174,
-0.407997638,
-0.3540730178,
0.2903018594,
0.4181735814,
-0.206759885,
0.058218915,
0.1325638294,
-0.0106012598,
-0.4234779775,
0.0704005808,
-0.1632753611,
0.113308616,
0.9226466417,
0.3048811853,
0.4486217499,
0.0092170639,
-0.5568808317,
-0.1580426693,
-0.4673279524,
0.2233230621,
0.3021114767,
-0.0407859012,
-0.0269756019,
0.6234627366,
-0.2347483337,
0.0049309391,
0.4723578095,
0.0406724624,
-0.1371969581,
0.2352395654,
-0.1155232191,
0.6559590101,
0.8706035614,
0.3904951215,
-0.1981633902,
-0.4946934581,
-0.3660389185,
0.4447124302,
0.6220371723,
-0.6973383427,
-0.4170945287,
0.3710057139,
-0.3970758319,
-0.4926722646,
-0.1016746014,
-0.9732778668,
-0.8298022747,
-0.0520103015,
0.7639100552,
-0.5856233239,
-0.3940112889,
0.3947921395,
-0.2146848887,
0.3918889165,
0.3226903677,
-0.8983404636,
0.4073792994,
0.9443275332,
0.7440162301,
-0.0924165994,
-0.7066600323,
-0.4244045913,
0.0603559241,
-0.4808956981,
0.8971373439,
-0.2685942948,
-0.4905833304,
-0.329288274,
-0.3894673288,
-0.2550636232,
-0.6605694294,
0.6235356927,
-0.2928137779,
0.0495239086,
0.0548759028,
-0.8040512204,
0.1593094617,
0.4547777772,
-0.5965732336,
0.6003035903,
-0.0563976578,
-0.619256258,
0.3090908527,
-0.8456852436,
-0.4434511364,
0.4293560684,
0.0150077669,
-0.3790999949,
0.1932320297,
-0.0178794749,
0.6370218992,
-0.2431256473,
0.0909033716,
-0.4465992451,
-0.3713606894,
0.5588926673,
0.2041525096,
0.3902976215,
0.271553278,
-0.8606219888,
0.1317685097,
-0.4493418932,
-0.1236461923,
0.7469085455,
-0.2368827611,
-0.1421186179,
0.674629271,
-0.431239754,
0.0597460009,
0.1147532314,
-0.5601338148,
0.2381370068,
-0.2501071393,
0.259447366,
0.5251383185,
-0.2622995079,
0.5620353222,
-0.8184830546,
0.278993845,
-0.3975878954,
0.4375464916,
0.1440454423,
-0.8023366928,
-0.9045707583,
-0.4344601631,
-0.1278027892,
0.4689167142,
-0.8145765662,
0.5523493886,
-0.3491864204,
-0.4193271995,
-0.4607693851,
-0.0410297997,
0.2104377002,
0.4280559719,
0.1422765106,
-0.1032280624,
-0.4593817592,
-0.4278163612,
-0.4223733842,
-0.5728896856,
0.1136280075,
0.1109195426,
0.1143352091,
-0.6002230048,
0.7545592189,
-0.0418664478,
-0.2036615014,
-0.835920155,
0.2203021199,
-0.0350465663,
0.3721061945,
0.2795369327,
-0.5274063945,
-0.3605962992,
0.1236469895,
-0.966601789,
-0.1477357298,
-0.2789122462,
-0.5734736919,
-0.2376300693,
0.2702721357,
-0.768251121,
0.2066916525,
0.3418880999,
-0.8325929642,
0.2078104168,
-0.2962222397,
0.3520748615,
-1.084634304,
-0.2237212062,
0.0676627755,
-0.4372553825,
-0.9639129639,
0.374948144,
0.1939522475,
-0.1928266287,
-0.4900141656,
0.8145314455,
0.0465140827,
0.1313219368,
-0.0992323756,
0.5507774949,
0.0609153733,
0.2910230458,
0.3048402667,
0.6674027443,
0.2034779638,
-0.6951583028,
0.4855881035,
0.2375204563,
-0.0730976239,
1.1010458469,
-0.7964793444,
-0.0355456956,
0.0967581347,
0.0320855267,
-0.5441556573,
-0.4031340778,
0.2041575611,
-0.5683796406,
0.2531739771,
-0.0319548249,
-0.2978523672,
-0.1646977067,
-0.6409194469,
-0.0257109962,
0.6452803612,
-0.7651071548,
0.7038004398,
0.5653528571,
0.1789087206,
0.0742336512,
-0.229075551,
0.2884920835,
-0.5982872248,
-0.7398461103,
0.2160743028,
-0.1074056253,
-0.4969298542,
-0.3823510706,
0.1893826574,
0.0980883315,
0.459741205,
0.2072417587,
0.2812488079,
0.0374215841,
-0.2365684807,
-0.4483935833,
-0.0370740555,
0.2467791736,
-0.1258561164,
0.5645196438,
-0.0918122679,
-0.2493061721,
-0.3923147321,
0.1831864119,
0.3188301027,
0.2766385972,
0.5595934391,
0.50110811,
-0.2277162373,
-0.2558703423,
-0.5387688279,
-0.0986641794,
-0.4322997928,
0.4705274999,
-0.4948528409,
-0.4378007948,
0.4476448596,
-0.3666476905,
0.0240857732,
0.4969586134,
0.5097483397,
-0.5092339516,
1.2438403368,
0.1558014601,
-0.1057413071,
0.4776521027,
-0.2010452449,
-0.1214829311,
-0.7546119094,
-0.4973793924,
-0.1974157095,
-0.5922959447,
-0.291405648,
-0.4961658716,
0.2115031481,
0.309500128,
-0.3455025256,
0.3284565806,
-0.0100459149,
0.4404863119,
0.4436213374,
0.4004695714,
-0.0121424831,
-0.0926311314,
0.042700097,
-0.2550337613,
-0.8958056569,
-0.3350132704,
1.1449370384,
0.5775778294,
1.087736845,
0.2876115441,
1.1650663614,
0.4573450983,
0.170753032,
-0.6236016154,
0.562767148,
0.4812417924,
-0.5332280397,
-0.2244698703,
-0.664986968,
-1.287555337,
0.2963888943,
-0.5514305234,
-0.5254229903,
-0.2306329757,
0.0503113866,
-0.2888302803,
0.5976514816,
-0.9023023248,
0.6667713523,
-0.5546629429,
-0.6110981107,
-0.3919421434,
-0.3223586082,
0.3960435688,
0.1894494295,
0.0478702039,
-0.2069656402,
-0.2503721118,
0.6031566858,
-0.2365193069,
0.579836607,
-0.1020931378,
0.1642007381,
0.1396003515,
0.4415440857,
0.7170367837,
0.3423722088,
0.383179754,
0.0893116221,
-0.2970927656,
-0.7013136148,
-0.3614684045,
0.659730196,
-1.036229372,
-0.5380339622,
-0.6195537448,
-0.0435153283,
-0.3396843672,
-0.0626716837,
0.2252246439,
0.1169398576,
-0.7219520211,
-0.0584798902,
1.2434302568,
-0.2504237592,
0.2969707549,
0.523155272,
-0.4661514759,
-0.5515249372,
1.1661659479,
-0.5102339983,
0.0328156799,
0.4493872523,
0.3628537953,
-0.4730393589,
-0.0931344107,
-0.4413274229,
0.3512937427,
-0.2399100959,
-0.1141199768,
-0.4553606212,
0.0154661145,
0.0702284351,
-0.4854145646,
-0.6269969344,
-0.3050194681,
-0.1716865301,
0.2519514859,
0.1014917865,
1.0953565836,
0.0024382034,
0.2814626694,
-0.4563723505,
0.5391589999,
0.763400197,
0.4182584584,
-0.4441612363,
-0.3168325424,
-0.031645529,
-0.1171951294,
-0.2323458493,
-0.7376028299,
0.3576717675,
0.070808515,
0.6740912795,
0.4545888901,
-0.1387044042,
0.6145126224,
-0.4381849468,
0.6110160351,
0.338463068,
-0.7073289156,
0.3785153329,
-0.3731288612,
0.1372877955,
0.3819276392,
0.0571389347,
-0.6593892574,
-0.2671870589,
-0.8277721405,
-0.4609074295,
0.9256157875,
0.3290995657,
-0.2364445627,
-0.0181625709,
0.1258012652,
-0.1570343673,
-0.0250975508,
-0.3034811616,
-0.1712315381,
-0.2027518898,
-0.0777387172,
-0.3666030467,
-0.3270630836,
-0.149323225,
-0.0952568427,
0.6537823081,
0.1626417339,
0.4204412103,
0.3715600669,
-0.4456211329,
-0.0508190356,
0.1631753594,
0.6521017551,
0.3399544656,
-0.4321904182,
0.1740744412,
0.2048778981,
-0.7003977299,
0.2294118255,
0.0969067588,
-0.0182765033,
-0.1676169187,
0.3615503609,
0.6160597205,
0.5507475734,
-0.8060235977,
0.5382759571,
-0.6622241139,
-0.440316081,
0.038061399,
0.1950475723,
-0.0295266174,
0.8370537162,
0.3671295047,
-0.1605018228,
-0.0639113039,
-0.4998800755,
0.1057197303,
0.363225162,
-0.1441019624,
-0.5539845228,
1.0350658894,
0.4414639473,
-0.4559632838,
-0.2280676067,
-0.546433866,
-0.626729548,
0.341599226,
0.5967079401,
0.96879071,
-0.1634663939,
0.4591505826,
0.1305696219,
0.2418274283,
-0.3040152192,
0.224995479,
0.1163372993,
-0.4193114638,
-0.0040413449,
-0.3301613331,
-0.6449208856,
0.0298948456,
-0.207201764,
0.0625611469,
-0.8594186902,
-0.2868019044,
-0.2719832659,
0.4810296893,
-0.6600525975,
-0.3556088209,
0.4335410595,
1.0230200291,
-0.4394516349,
0.5447990298,
0.8960374594,
-0.2577224672,
-0.4798482955,
-0.1820428818,
-0.0455171466,
-0.6484300494,
0.4004379511,
-0.1767414212,
0.3329101801,
-0.0394510627,
-0.3905360699,
-0.4071217775,
1.3109573126,
0.4193385243,
-0.4843025506,
0.1495341957,
0.2022857368,
0.2526682317,
-0.2011894882,
0.286716789,
0.7600964308,
0.2599721551,
-0.2180908024,
-0.5753503442,
-0.4007304609,
-0.1911109388,
0.191586569,
0.1156731695,
-0.8859325051,
0.9187140465,
0.2350477576,
-0.1574851871,
0.070383355,
0.6025657654,
0.5204353929,
0.4636767507,
0.1571381986,
0.8151239753,
0.6961148381,
-0.2601134181,
1.0837993622,
-0.1936659813,
0.306943506,
0.6967512965,
-0.5257883072,
0.6611043215,
0.161806792,
-0.4543705583,
0.1538863927,
0.4427164793,
0.6865711808,
0.3619874418,
-0.0950959772,
-0.5878304243,
-0.2500379086,
0.0467144363,
-0.2411624044,
0.1646549553,
0.2277257293,
0.2365122139,
-0.13402915,
-0.2531344295,
0.2913336754,
0.2844730616,
-0.5348272324,
0.9975393414,
-0.2640644014,
-0.5206341743,
0.3355033994,
0.1804334223,
0.9941265583,
-0.8003682494,
0.036089804,
-0.8156876564,
0.386577934,
-0.0103110038,
-0.6009678841,
-0.4271982908,
-0.0770296454,
0.1215913221,
-0.0418661833,
0.7285305262,
-0.3623196185,
-0.2062440366,
0.1973363012,
0.3709045649,
0.0342758186,
-0.1191755459,
-0.7356495261,
0.2063378245,
-0.3435217142,
-0.131562829,
0.7218387127,
0.6729575992,
0.0116128996,
0.6800005436,
0.3873672783,
0.480927825,
0.4935830832,
-0.2868204415,
0.6870443821,
-0.6784057617,
-0.5625737309,
-0.641928196,
0.1393667758,
-0.4797728956,
-0.0679030344,
0.8197683096,
0.5604001284,
0.5797699094,
0.1081072018,
0.6143889427,
-0.121025227,
0.4251860976,
-0.3694965243,
0.8379474282,
-0.2291795462,
0.0142677724,
-0.1711164713,
-0.6795521379,
-0.1017152071,
0.7404564619,
0.159994483,
-0.4981596768,
0.5648191571,
0.5312074423,
-0.2480107397,
-0.1793620735,
0.6433356404,
-0.2884689569,
0.4552600086,
0.8343752623,
1.2600567341,
-0.3928131163,
0.2095061243,
-0.3445613682,
-0.3766347468,
-0.5419510007,
-0.5692278147,
-1.4740049839,
-0.4106362164,
-0.0712700561,
-0.4319303036,
0.2429462969,
1.4810940027,
0.5434135795,
-0.545448482,
-0.5301952958,
0.0850841254,
0.1432761252,
0.0949478298,
-0.1648225039,
-0.1456707567,
-0.7956011891,
-0.5927339792,
0.7324123979,
0.2998363674,
-0.0583369881,
-0.0524344519,
-0.8808169365,
-0.2260138243,
0.1612179279,
0.7329108119,
0.7481145859,
-0.4724941552,
0.0766567737,
-0.086917609,
-0.4279864132,
0.0233654194,
1.0347075462,
-0.717900753,
0.7192130685,
0.2166237384,
0.9626126885,
0.2317352295,
-0.059055768,
0.4478491843,
-0.557025373,
0.5015828609,
0.1975579113,
0.4953362942,
0.0979299322,
-0.1753765345,
0.567581594,
0.3910095096,
-0.4931529462,
-0.4296658933,
-0.2226213068,
-0.6172055602,
-0.0992468596,
1.1482093334,
-0.1300879121,
-0.4781470001,
0.0550012551,
-0.5772829652,
0.0446545444,
-0.5614289045,
1.0341346264,
0.3239420652,
-0.0930921435,
0.190424189,
-0.5368028879,
0.6940655112,
0.3364822865,
-1.0005767345,
-0.1867618114,
0.3227971792,
0.005190725,
-0.1529828906,
0.5409117937,
0.1811143309,
0.4411359429,
0.0994144082,
0.2671771944,
0.0225792713,
-0.2774405181,
-0.3494562805,
-0.1742430627,
0.2745251358,
-0.1246441156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01117v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01117v1
|
DTS-SQL: Decomposed Text-to-SQL with Small Large Language Models
| 2024-02-02T03:21:00 | 2024-02-02T03:21:00 |
Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.HC
|
Leading models for the text-to-SQL task heavily rely on proprietary Large
Language Models (LLMs), posing concerns over data privacy. Closing the
performance gap between small open-source models and large proprietary models
is crucial to mitigate this reliance. To this end, we introduce a novel
two-stage fine-tuning approach that decomposes the task into two simpler tasks.
Through comprehensive evaluation on two large cross-domain datasets and two
small LLMs, we show that this approach improves execution accuracy by 3 to 7
percent, effectively aligning the performance of open-source models with their
proprietary counterparts.
|
[
-0.0382536724,
-0.8142333627,
0.5270459056,
-0.0986465365,
-0.4793857932,
-0.0437868349,
-0.4373015761,
-0.289095521,
-0.2508215606,
0.7171070576,
-0.6177076697,
-0.7406394482,
-0.687959969,
0.1910452694,
-0.5334941745,
0.8287076354,
0.2151387334,
0.0794558525,
-0.126081869,
0.0266522858,
-0.3305401206,
-0.1188810915,
-0.7498848438,
-0.0089800097,
0.2425453365,
0.5220268965,
0.6757957935,
0.9436698556,
0.4871518314,
0.2208113521,
-0.2799992859,
0.5436728001,
-0.7282412648,
0.409442544,
-0.5182535648,
-0.6975806355,
-0.5341951251,
-0.2948094904,
0.5667345524,
0.6385322213,
-0.1087783352,
0.416677326,
0.3233086765,
1.05785501,
-0.4705104232,
0.2451287955,
-0.6876616478,
-0.1383258253,
-0.2525912523,
-0.1879046857,
-0.6260511875,
-0.4123537838,
-0.0069698915,
-0.3313466012,
0.4353504479,
-0.0795916319,
0.5272643566,
0.4751977324,
-0.6487600803,
0.0479141064,
-0.9129500985,
0.9050328135,
-0.61084342,
0.506310761,
0.2335148603,
0.131303221,
-0.0091458047,
-0.6420595646,
-0.3262307346,
-0.0551810861,
-0.2879944444,
-0.3881286979,
-0.0736544505,
-0.0286041722,
0.1720315963,
0.2760995328,
-0.5386778712,
0.4356534183,
-0.4806013107,
0.286516577,
0.6719483137,
0.5539921522,
-0.1389575601,
0.0596419834,
-0.1648464948,
0.3093702793,
-0.8729336262,
-0.2943968177,
0.0425963253,
1.0413248539,
-0.0821019113,
0.9247729182,
-0.3125735223,
0.7425467968,
0.2103066295,
-0.0138790375,
-0.1105499417,
-0.5044147968,
-0.4772700071,
-0.1782842577,
0.5734733939,
0.4943177998,
0.2201344669,
-0.4869181812,
-0.1844774932,
0.1386279762,
0.254991293,
-0.9711831212,
-0.0328259207,
0.5461284518,
-0.6879643202,
-0.2780918479,
-0.220905602,
-0.819318831,
-0.5798606277,
-0.6960978508,
0.3716511726,
-0.300603956,
-0.2691302001,
-0.1428119242,
0.0418947563,
-0.0371838957,
0.4433522522,
-0.7000527382,
0.7034988999,
1.0936008692,
0.971374929,
-0.5977175236,
0.0973184258,
-0.7848656178,
0.4161775112,
-0.6777784824,
0.4499059916,
-0.5244724154,
-0.4069734812,
-0.1471453309,
0.1073023677,
0.0373502895,
-0.5925467014,
0.3880186379,
-0.5208927393,
0.1791946143,
-0.3003596365,
-0.673322916,
0.2380017191,
0.0451058894,
-0.5877608657,
1.243227005,
0.2041693926,
-0.5632821321,
0.2702035308,
-0.8122426271,
-0.5144940019,
-0.1756826043,
-0.1591834277,
-0.4642950594,
0.4125155509,
0.1179790348,
0.661726892,
-0.6540315747,
0.0955225155,
-0.1423945278,
-0.5240929127,
-0.3112257719,
0.1459674239,
0.736019969,
0.440333426,
-0.3301101029,
-0.0555670671,
-0.8594933748,
0.0901041999,
0.1977460682,
-0.3453192711,
-0.5729814172,
0.1396885812,
-0.105964683,
0.0160169136,
0.1679286957,
-0.5671064854,
0.0738571584,
-0.6788802743,
0.5610935688,
0.5553172231,
-0.2346682847,
0.8707534075,
-0.0135920532,
0.3100458682,
0.3357406259,
0.0594349056,
0.0094279964,
-0.2334772795,
-0.6254612207,
-0.3319033086,
0.3747135699,
0.4785673916,
-0.5730316639,
0.4729056954,
-0.4816274047,
-0.5334975123,
-0.3573628962,
-0.0266426504,
0.3023633659,
0.4619468451,
0.4084734321,
-0.0906855389,
-0.3377609253,
-0.9223803282,
-0.5689765811,
0.2654445767,
-0.3577477038,
0.1030752957,
0.4096004665,
-0.017529726,
0.789783597,
-0.6643445492,
-0.6830337644,
-0.0401808657,
-0.0789702535,
-0.0531856939,
0.6076748967,
0.4938173294,
-0.3816900253,
-0.5501430035,
-0.0469218642,
-0.3150869012,
0.1229754537,
0.2962542772,
0.1453710198,
0.6589745283,
0.619156003,
-0.6234190464,
0.4770877659,
0.3878821731,
-0.5609587431,
0.2091922164,
-0.2418774515,
0.1016774699,
-1.1584091187,
-0.1443807334,
0.0696376637,
-0.2297084928,
-0.676525414,
0.1539471149,
0.3273352385,
-0.2994291186,
-0.3095266819,
0.235447824,
-0.6100542545,
-0.1827883422,
-0.0926496089,
-0.0396882743,
0.0709739402,
0.1834595948,
-0.0181172583,
0.902823329,
0.4672659636,
-0.7066242695,
0.0235923156,
0.3729885519,
-0.3926334381,
0.6666352749,
-0.7570250034,
0.2419498712,
-0.2486948371,
0.0656599849,
-0.9958866835,
0.0169721749,
-0.0992814898,
-0.2232522368,
0.5835109353,
-0.4040860236,
-0.6624860168,
0.0250055343,
-0.4005619287,
0.0180919748,
0.4638200402,
-0.4831421673,
0.7654047608,
0.2271981239,
-0.2124907374,
-0.4054039717,
-1.102843523,
0.211046651,
-0.0830379426,
-0.6339060664,
0.5760845542,
0.4131439924,
-0.2628130615,
0.0729173794,
-0.2859199345,
-0.3435201645,
-0.0789603591,
0.0913104489,
0.0571872145,
-0.2299384028,
0.1087870896,
0.364869535,
-0.100167349,
-0.1119143292,
-0.2835838497,
0.2946213484,
0.2707479298,
0.0234526861,
-0.6141741276,
0.7404897213,
0.6237185597,
-0.3179880977,
0.9820145369,
0.2153595835,
-0.3772619963,
-0.6015134454,
-0.3349912465,
-0.2858452499,
-0.500100255,
0.3392190933,
-0.5572226048,
-0.9372343421,
0.1634515226,
-0.247057125,
0.0623357035,
0.502897799,
0.5506728292,
0.0308437273,
0.9291077852,
0.8854724169,
0.3392844498,
0.3494343758,
-0.1553927064,
0.3974538445,
-0.435531944,
-0.4892867506,
-1.1070618629,
-0.1523176581,
-0.5890206099,
-0.6097475886,
0.2035767436,
-0.1765702069,
-0.5516338348,
0.4516911507,
-0.8056021333,
0.6197328568,
0.4629187584,
0.3210989833,
0.7137150764,
0.2484816909,
0.1910568923,
-0.0843200684,
-0.4113149345,
-0.5608246326,
1.3074965477,
0.2750531435,
0.8711836338,
0.1210023016,
0.6667724848,
0.2039878368,
-0.1989977807,
-0.545243144,
0.6125720143,
-0.8116295338,
-0.6676256657,
-0.4422361553,
-0.4079046249,
-0.6909193397,
0.0730819106,
-0.1006698236,
-0.6950056553,
0.1662360281,
-0.0566056892,
-0.293448627,
0.2573779821,
-1.0675345659,
0.6396340728,
0.3093290329,
-0.4035223722,
-0.4470851719,
-0.7213010788,
0.4083597362,
-0.1258671731,
0.1412841231,
-0.1088653505,
-0.4561447501,
0.7798959017,
-0.7686662674,
0.7101666927,
-0.3162896037,
-0.3386864066,
-0.0248677935,
0.4101570845,
0.7981755137,
-0.0619595572,
-0.3233012855,
0.3343710899,
0.4727708101,
-0.2850888968,
-0.5795508623,
0.7777469158,
-0.4407920539,
-0.4473916292,
-0.2027958035,
-0.5224505067,
-0.3313472867,
0.1112609208,
0.0447616428,
0.2923239172,
-0.0706369206,
0.2756444216,
0.7601251602,
-0.1215120405,
0.2567387819,
0.7528390884,
0.1377402842,
-0.2014260292,
0.3098626137,
0.1649655551,
0.2815210521,
0.5573007464,
-0.1471770853,
-0.4883305132,
-0.8477990627,
-0.1313660145,
0.2388446033,
-0.3784373105,
-0.3089133501,
-0.6418202519,
0.2162318528,
-0.5681750774,
0.1213213205,
-0.7352712154,
-0.7613218427,
-0.5069224238,
0.0269117225,
0.5352832079,
0.7161435485,
0.0732730925,
0.2688066661,
-0.9205303192,
0.5827255249,
0.0162883196,
0.9098265171,
-0.1506566703,
-0.4456200004,
-0.2681709826,
-0.0884967521,
-0.0564892441,
-0.7235829234,
0.1717247665,
0.2866261005,
-0.0068222648,
0.0393289067,
0.2927451134,
0.6372326612,
-0.7456899881,
0.9778315425,
-0.0448624529,
-1.0537180901,
0.6973400712,
-0.2330163121,
-0.0378183946,
0.5276645422,
0.2187780738,
-0.0565243885,
-0.2651878595,
-0.1575849056,
-0.6211894155,
1.1564240456,
0.2520776391,
-0.0803545788,
0.2519643903,
0.415458262,
0.274975419,
0.1645031571,
-0.2224768549,
-0.4518142343,
0.3178593218,
-0.2341180444,
-0.2942246795,
-0.556409955,
-0.3321681023,
-0.4382249117,
0.3405861855,
-0.0499895625,
0.3523916602,
-0.1218159199,
0.1000536084,
-0.2893975675,
0.2185486555,
0.3646345139,
0.7038292885,
-0.205597192,
0.0585500151,
0.158194229,
-0.4016053677,
0.0590413734,
0.0905688182,
-0.2379222959,
0.0619686246,
-0.1444636136,
0.353538543,
-0.1891233921,
-0.4055207968,
0.3461131454,
-0.0453753062,
-0.1810100079,
0.1052718237,
-0.0429750942,
0.2274382412,
0.3072152138,
0.3127583265,
0.1535469443,
0.1354871094,
-0.2760862112,
0.2348189354,
0.3075634539,
-0.0593367293,
-0.18992953,
0.9718787074,
0.2660051286,
-0.2931694388,
0.3180516064,
0.1381763816,
0.00581836,
0.5241577625,
0.3319138587,
0.9168283939,
-0.4516471624,
0.0846965462,
0.2275138944,
0.4774001539,
-0.4042156339,
0.6702520251,
0.1531086564,
-0.1911578476,
-0.6799950004,
-0.37010023,
-0.2988235652,
0.0521849133,
-0.616696775,
0.4242252111,
-0.3203136325,
0.0521439612,
0.0983558819,
0.1896649748,
-0.5925340056,
0.3311225176,
-0.1968579888,
1.1194907427,
-0.5866929293,
1.0055160522,
0.2526560426,
-0.1639646441,
-0.6418183446,
-0.1817837954,
-0.0788870603,
-0.3993819058,
0.7001215816,
-0.1718641371,
0.1066762432,
0.0391060859,
-0.3291816115,
-0.843454659,
0.9315556288,
0.6492883563,
-0.8592839837,
-0.4223793745,
0.5907822847,
0.5334427357,
-0.2531178296,
-0.112368755,
1.0374950171,
0.2971900702,
-0.1730680764,
-1.0405393839,
0.4082675874,
0.3022591472,
0.3321887553,
0.4720081687,
-0.4461399317,
0.7910696864,
-0.189730376,
-0.3342857659,
0.0206976198,
0.4479573667,
-0.1920997798,
0.3073286712,
0.4086370468,
0.6070864201,
0.6098582149,
-0.2085996717,
0.8065928221,
-0.3717827201,
0.3876003027,
1.2344698906,
-0.3141437471,
0.8172819614,
0.3738331497,
-0.3866087198,
0.264953196,
0.4808491468,
0.1732462794,
0.7562457323,
-0.0145048006,
0.0809551999,
-0.0711166039,
0.1134928614,
-0.4443912804,
0.3912146389,
0.3623629808,
-0.5052030087,
-0.5783109665,
-0.2648839951,
0.0351560377,
0.2442056388,
-0.3215279579,
0.7738718987,
0.1258421093,
-0.4921703935,
0.5988957286,
0.2722894847,
0.5879163742,
-0.3982954621,
0.1318095177,
-0.1467150599,
0.3437574208,
-0.424695909,
-0.7640112638,
0.9011898041,
0.2488143444,
-0.1812449098,
-0.2458650023,
0.6712710857,
-0.6006854177,
-0.2545881271,
0.144952476,
0.461787343,
-0.1097349823,
-0.3536570072,
-0.5433345437,
0.1363090426,
-0.1606746167,
-0.3670927882,
0.300139159,
0.6086357236,
0.0825829878,
0.4453836977,
0.3596503437,
-0.0289797653,
-0.0934355557,
-0.0697153285,
0.8377615809,
-0.7776653767,
-0.596585989,
-0.8568613529,
0.5358893871,
-0.0808459148,
0.0971093923,
0.7602202892,
0.9913713932,
0.6151860356,
-0.2229970098,
0.6195706129,
-0.0024759686,
1.0924004316,
-0.4629964828,
0.6889470816,
-0.6498296857,
0.4913875163,
-0.1331407428,
-0.8478876948,
-0.4251005352,
-0.0961958468,
-0.1374930888,
-0.1184533462,
0.8415795565,
1.0969002247,
0.1154964641,
0.0980871469,
0.2094116807,
0.2701753676,
0.2420482039,
0.4317389429,
0.3741859794,
-0.4923684299,
0.6594775319,
-0.2312669754,
-0.1474228948,
-0.0763672069,
-0.8617472053,
-0.9605948329,
-0.5983660817,
-0.5003746152,
-0.5531138182,
0.1306561232,
0.7909883857,
0.6371055245,
-0.9637935162,
-0.0491728559,
-0.1082187593,
0.0184762347,
-0.346109122,
-0.1917771548,
0.60398525,
-0.4189651012,
-1.0420815945,
0.456287384,
0.3106476068,
-0.0604129583,
-0.0215354785,
0.2858995199,
0.2031207532,
0.2510612011,
0.848071754,
-0.2524411678,
-0.5552393794,
-0.0481468737,
-0.0084137479,
-0.298333168,
0.1008314565,
0.8824529648,
-0.6913454533,
0.0955014899,
0.5613105297,
0.6361353993,
0.8250322342,
0.1197089776,
0.5967991948,
-0.9137175083,
0.0699317977,
0.2314347625,
-0.0661179498,
0.1021836624,
-0.5892087221,
0.7611525059,
0.0959047079,
-0.4088745117,
-1.0750824213,
0.1915369332,
-1.0969132185,
-0.6050691009,
1.1886683702,
0.2090932578,
-0.0005266794,
-0.1341501623,
0.0090684462,
0.2931801975,
-0.3375421762,
0.6654221416,
0.1648350805,
0.1402781606,
0.0447138846,
-0.2418051362,
0.8091270924,
0.2171765566,
-0.706148088,
0.4361787438,
0.4583475292,
0.5144865513,
-0.3227266669,
0.4480285048,
-0.3996801972,
-0.1380074024,
-0.0199185815,
-0.4048157632,
-0.3207550645,
-0.2261631489,
-0.5323903561,
0.4905370176,
-0.1246760413,
-0.3734609187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01115v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01115v3
|
Interpretation of Intracardiac Electrograms Through Textual Representations
| 2024-02-02T03:15:13 | 2024-04-12T01:32:32 |
William Jongwon Han, Diana Gomez, Avi Alok, Chaojing Duan, Michael A. Rosenberg, Douglas Weber, Emerson Liu, Ding Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.SP, I.2.7; J.3
|
Understanding the irregular electrical activity of atrial fibrillation (AFib)
has been a key challenge in electrocardiography. For serious cases of AFib,
catheter ablations are performed to collect intracardiac electrograms (EGMs).
EGMs offer intricately detailed and localized electrical activity of the heart
and are an ideal modality for interpretable cardiac studies. Recent
advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) has allowed some works to utilize
deep learning frameworks to interpret EGMs during AFib. Additionally, language
models (LMs) have shown exceptional performance in being able to generalize to
unseen domains, especially in healthcare. In this study, we are the first to
leverage pretrained LMs for finetuning of EGM interpolation and AFib
classification via masked language modeling. We formulate the EGM as a textual
sequence and present competitive performances on AFib classification compared
against other representations. Lastly, we provide a comprehensive
interpretability study to provide a multi-perspective intuition of the model's
behavior, which could greatly benefit the clinical use.
|
[
-0.3992182612,
-0.947178483,
0.6536082029,
0.0699345991,
-0.6087844968,
0.1832254529,
-0.0492783412,
-0.6918281913,
0.2070114017,
0.6880663633,
-0.7099971175,
-0.7140755057,
-0.5252894163,
0.2434480041,
-0.4902479947,
0.8637517095,
-0.2118068039,
0.4025040269,
-0.3819344938,
0.0689898357,
-0.547546804,
-0.7226672173,
-0.3172172606,
-0.9535620809,
-0.1091978848,
0.1103964671,
0.241048649,
0.4815119803,
0.6240929961,
0.2445145249,
0.1455869377,
-0.0005902466,
-0.2207186818,
-0.2636360228,
0.4153704345,
-0.5312845707,
-0.2763873041,
-0.1247596517,
0.3969590962,
0.5599577427,
-0.179643482,
0.139361307,
-0.2651793361,
0.4483296573,
0.1916878223,
0.4350573123,
-0.3171910346,
-0.1495416611,
-0.2394855022,
-0.4834140241,
-0.4902123809,
-0.1826366335,
0.2043824941,
-0.4112864733,
0.2086280584,
0.3894900978,
0.9320163131,
0.4054648876,
-0.4528920949,
-0.6611712575,
-0.7000660896,
0.2376998365,
-0.4165638685,
0.7023883462,
0.6842205524,
0.1181071103,
-0.0493321605,
-0.8888702393,
-0.3882470131,
-0.2922838926,
-0.4586280882,
-0.1029069945,
-0.2363213748,
0.3659462333,
0.0189142544,
0.4670132101,
-0.3412745893,
0.2185534686,
-0.5016388297,
-0.0059660957,
0.7716570497,
0.1821428984,
0.1408123076,
0.0419440418,
-0.337428838,
0.3949910104,
-0.5226181746,
0.0911374465,
0.5736121535,
-0.1088718474,
-0.4954146147,
0.4106572568,
-0.0980709121,
0.5295040607,
0.3460275233,
0.0624082237,
0.5048345327,
-0.1238963902,
-0.258244276,
0.1692854017,
0.6539328694,
0.0566469878,
0.3198898137,
-0.0109965559,
-0.1237464026,
-0.301150769,
0.5644461513,
-0.6695641279,
-0.4404096305,
0.5072712898,
-0.8504752517,
-0.2505450845,
0.0213700626,
-0.5520505309,
-0.2858574986,
-0.4541687965,
0.3441115618,
-0.462370187,
-0.0526689887,
0.2892632484,
0.1208115593,
-0.1123270392,
-0.0546295978,
-0.6625819206,
0.2942398489,
0.3986411691,
0.6716678143,
0.2077041864,
0.0147007611,
-0.0613180548,
-0.3096709549,
0.1121632382,
1.0742169619,
-0.1531766504,
-0.5008404851,
-0.0823315307,
-0.0102354148,
-0.0640348494,
-0.2621442378,
0.4306367636,
-0.5529081821,
-0.0344831273,
0.3878977597,
-0.6126199365,
-0.5061841011,
-0.1393552125,
-0.8966160417,
0.2976339161,
-0.1063538194,
-0.2933645546,
0.2048805356,
-0.7206728458,
-0.4320605993,
0.243018806,
-0.3795414567,
-0.6581702828,
0.2946210206,
0.368716687,
0.7275458574,
-0.2579810917,
0.2290814221,
-0.0890292302,
-0.3605530262,
0.6899177432,
-0.4676253498,
0.4686369896,
0.205358237,
-0.2377237529,
0.2538926899,
-0.8574880958,
-0.1331677139,
-0.0427516848,
-0.0198918153,
-0.1041117236,
0.0658151358,
0.0644611046,
0.0311846975,
-0.1919411868,
-0.41663903,
0.0065758931,
-0.4872569442,
0.4107423425,
0.6838689446,
0.1722504795,
0.1366697997,
-0.4092807472,
0.6552717686,
-0.1266581714,
0.1027144715,
-0.2819790542,
-0.5863409638,
-0.4186889827,
-0.7027646303,
0.339669317,
0.3672008812,
-0.6649247408,
0.5844906569,
-0.242203638,
-0.6678284407,
-0.7597900629,
-0.2009059489,
0.2268877476,
0.564820528,
0.4954466224,
-0.1633375883,
-0.1761353314,
-0.7842080593,
0.0117573384,
-0.2041320205,
0.1428149939,
0.2682419419,
0.2097700089,
-0.5272666812,
0.4805583656,
-0.471196115,
-0.4867206812,
-0.2814072371,
0.4110369086,
0.4420217872,
0.4506573677,
0.1979900599,
-0.586756587,
-0.3026748598,
0.2853202522,
-0.7667624354,
-0.5165494084,
-0.6083032489,
-0.1370037198,
-0.3015159369,
0.8794109821,
-0.0819639638,
0.6183820367,
0.3597567677,
-0.5724832416,
0.4396992028,
-0.2685591877,
0.2492128015,
-0.4166111648,
0.1345995069,
0.0559522957,
-0.2905510068,
-0.8007702827,
0.082370095,
0.107191503,
0.1414883137,
-0.293371141,
0.8090952039,
-0.4299821258,
0.3253001273,
-0.1642722785,
-0.5052523017,
0.1022079289,
0.4371734262,
0.0992246866,
0.2229799479,
0.2268474102,
-0.416541934,
0.2040111721,
0.5259286761,
-0.2511662543,
0.2707442343,
-0.5577626824,
-0.0085270004,
-0.3120167553,
0.3534894586,
-0.5328511,
-0.3949356079,
0.0552516654,
-0.4558213949,
0.7145540714,
0.3135677278,
-0.2092916071,
-0.365642637,
-0.1547761261,
0.6516468525,
0.6491992474,
-0.5132680535,
0.799302578,
0.32428509,
0.0521157943,
-0.254788667,
-0.756424129,
-0.5371270776,
-0.3109862804,
-0.3539766073,
0.3508981466,
-0.1030809954,
-0.3715643287,
-0.0959760994,
-0.0619430952,
-0.3015286624,
0.3907244503,
0.6828866601,
0.3062461019,
0.0295878276,
0.5077204704,
0.1034591943,
-0.2446182966,
0.2161842287,
0.1166321486,
0.8643599749,
-0.1835650057,
-0.6946291924,
-0.9616200328,
0.375251472,
0.2861335874,
-0.2301067412,
0.5951670408,
0.8607480526,
-0.5062892437,
0.0275942422,
-0.2982400656,
-0.0854896307,
-0.4430380166,
0.4195251465,
-0.2813875377,
-0.5228386521,
0.5824224353,
0.0028068761,
-0.1910935044,
0.5104664564,
0.6642533541,
-0.4915240407,
0.8903759718,
0.8153352141,
0.252789408,
0.6324115396,
-0.3677583337,
0.070198141,
-0.7523033619,
-0.6737093925,
-0.5026403069,
-0.2390037179,
-0.176473096,
-0.1637819409,
0.4832103848,
0.3364648223,
-0.1746345758,
-0.1780258417,
-0.3943553865,
0.4694351256,
0.1114694178,
0.5637982488,
0.1805700958,
0.3387011588,
-0.0814921558,
0.0498749465,
-0.4758185148,
-0.5932328701,
1.4475353956,
0.6760258079,
0.8596716523,
-0.1792188138,
0.7388455868,
0.5984540582,
0.800108254,
-0.8678840995,
-0.0009461076,
-0.0900762901,
-0.4494360387,
0.1056987345,
0.0972755551,
-0.9455342889,
-0.0804367065,
-0.5589863658,
-0.7916350961,
0.1465755403,
0.2274522334,
-0.6883283854,
-0.0028150869,
-0.7276161909,
0.7409545183,
-0.4221436381,
0.011520192,
-0.2261028141,
-0.5429033041,
0.3089588583,
-0.4300989807,
0.6386883855,
0.1198980361,
0.0634742975,
0.2813063264,
-0.2896339297,
0.6954156756,
0.1931534857,
-0.0345838703,
0.2110720873,
-0.2051356584,
0.2650666237,
0.2518683672,
-0.3495328724,
0.980697751,
-0.2442544997,
-0.205922395,
-0.1820718199,
0.3652826548,
-0.7063775659,
-0.3264629543,
-0.4164984226,
-0.1505504847,
-0.1316645443,
0.013018582,
0.604000926,
0.8602564931,
-0.2518770397,
-0.0255303662,
0.4857089818,
-0.2263008952,
0.1145111248,
-0.0183524881,
-0.3462851346,
-0.1050905138,
0.7338884473,
-0.1446892172,
0.178385511,
0.3858101964,
-0.0677751303,
-0.5097555518,
-0.9890486598,
-0.5934147239,
0.470459193,
-0.9710986614,
-0.16899845,
-0.7486442924,
-0.1235932037,
-0.0277774017,
-0.569743216,
0.2756478786,
0.133256793,
-0.8042506576,
-0.1825201511,
0.3693118989,
0.7381294966,
0.0088947145,
0.7438260317,
-1.0525461435,
0.398607105,
-0.219590649,
0.4911087155,
-0.2538553476,
-0.3150234222,
-0.5148285627,
-0.2493841201,
0.0172116943,
-1.0985686779,
0.3447144628,
0.3343491256,
0.8159734011,
0.3719025552,
-0.2837397158,
0.7738246322,
-0.4201213121,
0.7916096449,
0.1831358671,
-1.0302692652,
0.2653126419,
-0.1185640916,
0.17512393,
0.51353544,
0.3996964991,
-0.1694213897,
-0.2475181222,
-0.7460904121,
-0.8947204351,
0.7031397223,
0.1320144087,
-0.1278172135,
0.0528358258,
0.5029739738,
0.4782657623,
0.3556614816,
-0.7247337699,
-0.4477724433,
-0.079736501,
-0.8076500297,
-0.2079715431,
0.0139531642,
-0.0780716613,
-0.2092364728,
0.6129755378,
-0.1993012279,
0.8171451092,
0.2377727032,
-0.4415256977,
-0.3446057141,
-0.0016626897,
0.5491754413,
0.4900146127,
-0.0415193997,
0.0041042869,
0.0517388061,
-0.6770386696,
0.0074091195,
0.48371315,
0.1133496091,
0.0316227339,
0.9240790009,
0.8227712512,
-0.1778572202,
-0.9368489385,
0.4458662868,
-0.2215258479,
0.0776554719,
-0.4391829371,
-0.0795704052,
-0.0626565367,
0.3151815832,
0.1318174154,
0.092646271,
0.0274312031,
-0.3112032115,
0.3454365432,
0.2889198959,
-0.4934355021,
-0.305747956,
0.7855322957,
0.2907761037,
-0.2380023301,
0.4280834496,
0.014599408,
-0.4796091318,
0.878259778,
0.4330276251,
0.8725515008,
-0.0794333443,
-0.0293653663,
0.1329458058,
0.4268800914,
0.3948126435,
0.4568595886,
0.0075895083,
-0.39575091,
-0.1867329031,
-0.7860403657,
-0.0068534086,
0.0892068669,
-0.6222111583,
0.4888239205,
-0.5396165252,
-0.0741000548,
0.084914051,
-0.1531229466,
-1.0281134844,
0.4224843085,
0.4492016137,
0.6743859649,
-0.6485476494,
0.8162615895,
0.8036913872,
-0.2884180248,
-0.7865121961,
0.0794850215,
0.0280082393,
-0.8531779051,
0.302167803,
0.3795346022,
0.1164818481,
0.12411201,
-0.2801559567,
-0.6579499245,
1.0320464373,
-0.2170020491,
-0.3758184016,
0.2979541719,
0.1193273365,
0.8257154226,
-0.4288738668,
0.542660594,
0.4123957455,
0.3090231419,
-0.6306986213,
-0.9644709229,
-0.0797545314,
-0.2497943938,
-0.5529188514,
0.2097522914,
-0.5108627677,
1.0562448502,
0.1342339069,
-0.2187619805,
-0.0735420138,
0.5001286268,
0.0192734748,
0.5435215831,
0.3040590584,
-0.0827336088,
0.7202248573,
-0.1870067716,
1.0711804628,
-0.3225141168,
0.2559913993,
0.6985159516,
0.0455913059,
0.3436228931,
0.2737284601,
-0.0112303812,
0.739120245,
0.7704194784,
0.1432872564,
0.5629686117,
0.1125863642,
-0.193076238,
-0.3279490769,
0.0523214675,
-0.5096698403,
0.5254145861,
0.8345507979,
-0.7007704377,
0.0469337255,
0.2859687507,
-0.1726970822,
0.162313059,
-0.6378522515,
0.6292809248,
0.2575611472,
-0.2832267582,
0.4349891245,
-0.0275205225,
0.7235215902,
-0.6716340184,
-0.1768469363,
0.1528994143,
0.1275826991,
-0.3424940705,
-0.3721250892,
0.2821343243,
-0.0407277979,
-0.0295902546,
-0.4433751106,
0.7106717825,
-0.3656276166,
-0.4103809297,
0.1618308574,
0.5479784608,
0.3226729631,
0.0177620873,
-0.5789717436,
-0.0285085943,
0.3101828098,
-0.3604269922,
-0.0661360174,
0.1482856125,
-0.2054966688,
0.6375719309,
0.6730355024,
0.2101371288,
0.0343167149,
-0.1754970849,
0.6548619866,
-0.6143570542,
-0.7840126753,
-0.7240716219,
0.6816865802,
0.0444358662,
-0.3688748777,
0.2147299498,
0.0949672461,
0.7632724047,
-0.0102115003,
0.5444071293,
0.2030868232,
0.113966316,
-0.8974603415,
0.9891331792,
-0.5904327035,
0.3352138996,
0.1122222245,
-0.3167235851,
-0.4965741336,
0.5444208384,
-0.1326753646,
-0.4182613194,
0.7673549056,
0.2456886619,
-0.0081297057,
0.2526650727,
0.1391027719,
0.1871366054,
0.3970547318,
0.1041247472,
0.6292814016,
-0.2039201558,
0.1383568496,
-0.2605555654,
-0.1071825549,
-0.5043760538,
-0.683442235,
-0.9082942009,
-0.5323298573,
-0.2018168867,
-0.1612823606,
-0.4176989794,
1.3909071684,
0.4286885262,
-0.5784686208,
0.050427705,
0.139793098,
0.1801272482,
-0.3019676208,
-0.0815911815,
0.510730505,
0.0683489889,
-0.5195877552,
0.3493687809,
-0.0480073951,
0.2521317005,
-0.1464791745,
0.0422501229,
-0.0815095827,
0.0653040409,
0.4616450965,
0.0665544719,
-0.6888742447,
-0.053756617,
-0.2155936062,
0.0466254689,
0.0380353928,
0.7963821888,
-0.8769704103,
0.6802820563,
0.3421447575,
0.5677767396,
0.3547366261,
0.1381636411,
0.285970062,
-0.6294580698,
0.2417252809,
0.3402592838,
0.557331264,
0.1304371506,
-0.7635710835,
0.3581036031,
0.1133186668,
-0.5182282329,
-0.9572911263,
0.0619745404,
-0.8083207607,
-0.2374017984,
1.1207994223,
-0.1910418868,
-0.0943608508,
-0.707171917,
-0.1940377504,
0.4760742188,
-0.1376355439,
0.5657308698,
0.747824192,
-0.8260384202,
0.2804652154,
-0.6756714582,
0.5027562976,
0.1180507913,
-0.9626962543,
-0.3816486597,
0.4493981302,
0.0397511907,
0.0982112363,
0.8240864277,
0.0094591584,
0.1732735187,
0.0152554549,
0.2245598435,
-0.5620148182,
-0.1715471596,
-0.9732710123,
0.1283611655,
-0.1460580677,
-0.1136334017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03369v1
|
Evaluation of Google's Voice Recognition and Sentence Classification for Health Care Applications
| 2024-02-02T03:13:09 | 2024-02-02T03:13:09 |
Majbah Uddin, Nathan Huynh, Jose M Vidal, Kevin M Taaffe, Lawrence D Fredendall, Joel S Greenstein
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
This study examined the use of voice recognition technology in perioperative
services (Periop) to enable Periop staff to record workflow milestones using
mobile technology. The use of mobile technology to improve patient flow and
quality of care could be facilitated if such voice recognition technology could
be made robust. The goal of this experiment was to allow the Periop staff to
provide care without being interrupted with data entry and querying tasks.
However, the results are generalizable to other situations where an engineering
manager attempts to improve communication performance using mobile technology.
This study enhanced Google's voice recognition capability by using
post-processing classifiers (i.e., bag-of-sentences, support vector machine,
and maximum entropy). The experiments investigated three factors (original
phrasing, reduced phrasing, and personalized phrasing) at three levels (zero
training repetition, 5 training repetitions, and 10 training repetitions).
Results indicated that personal phrasing yielded the highest correctness and
that training the device to recognize an individual's voice improved
correctness as well. Although simplistic, the bag-of-sentences classifier
significantly improved voice recognition correctness. The classification
efficiency of the maximum entropy and support vector machine algorithms was
found to be nearly identical. These results suggest that engineering managers
could significantly enhance Google's voice recognition technology by using
post-processing techniques, which would facilitate its use in health care and
other applications.
|
[
-0.1330518275,
-0.2416941971,
0.5181314349,
0.2294344902,
-0.1473011374,
0.0360174328,
0.0859263018,
-0.485257864,
0.3503965139,
0.3156900704,
-0.2307780683,
-0.3765188456,
-0.51903373,
0.2339822203,
-0.4136986434,
0.9376940131,
0.2570659816,
0.3774968088,
0.0068469895,
0.1099253371,
-0.2948821783,
-0.7400138974,
-0.6315542459,
-0.3401648104,
0.5238162875,
0.554381907,
0.7937846184,
0.3924900889,
0.7720414996,
0.3348821104,
-0.0178993475,
-0.1255488545,
-0.0729529411,
0.1649359316,
0.2266575098,
-0.3083554208,
-0.4289722443,
0.0225861873,
0.4491403103,
0.4966552556,
-0.4161078632,
0.1455789357,
0.021427393,
0.4232839644,
-0.5475847721,
-0.0771453306,
-0.5551191568,
0.6074722409,
-0.1858638376,
-0.6483274698,
0.0748614371,
-0.4895274937,
0.2804629803,
-0.4711379707,
-0.1280095577,
-0.1488660872,
0.9771853089,
0.3448796272,
0.0154011268,
-0.6511523724,
-0.8634878397,
0.367957741,
-0.5586504936,
0.5369868875,
0.3707266748,
0.4367329776,
-0.125940904,
-0.6395340562,
-0.49850142,
-0.0994072929,
0.1072160304,
0.3264902532,
-0.1343090683,
0.1774770766,
0.3230684996,
0.6245198846,
-0.7209842801,
0.2621869445,
-0.6230760217,
-0.3292807341,
0.6023849845,
0.0088287685,
0.4030687511,
-0.1127696931,
-0.2193234414,
-0.1716180444,
-0.563223958,
0.3320248127,
0.0388346612,
0.0175022762,
0.1898545325,
0.559386611,
-0.3475263417,
0.3505342901,
-0.0214142147,
-0.6003436446,
0.7621014714,
0.0979973301,
-0.9192075729,
0.2739417851,
0.7132416964,
0.172611475,
0.1161062121,
-0.3654053509,
-0.042009227,
0.1300514042,
0.6198332906,
-0.7622168064,
-0.1703238487,
0.146049425,
-0.7479553223,
-0.4016426802,
0.3363274336,
-0.2985094786,
-0.5728381276,
-0.0686538145,
0.1631328315,
-0.110069178,
-0.1181905344,
0.3452836871,
-0.071204491,
0.0938974842,
0.2016937137,
-0.6945620179,
0.2436420619,
0.5534268022,
0.9225477576,
0.1449180096,
0.0366988555,
-0.7596586943,
-0.119435817,
-0.2452717274,
0.7043843269,
-0.5338837504,
-0.8507050872,
0.0236362368,
0.0005373749,
-0.2664560378,
-1.1716221571,
1.1907413006,
-0.2711441517,
0.2257908881,
0.1496865451,
-0.3261717558,
-0.1514324695,
-0.0288825482,
-0.3438355625,
0.4996339381,
-0.0388431065,
-0.4040927887,
0.6048030257,
-0.9251724482,
-0.5999609828,
0.4142231345,
-0.3114145398,
-0.726133287,
0.3054540455,
-0.02894607,
0.7388621569,
-0.0310586747,
-0.2519807518,
-0.1011765972,
-0.5561550856,
0.226697728,
0.1173790619,
0.6540368199,
0.5165729523,
-0.1012932658,
0.1262239367,
-0.8503419757,
0.3600668907,
-0.2055292577,
-0.6020838618,
-0.0987822413,
0.0107787224,
-0.1309216768,
0.3483526111,
-0.2358850837,
-0.4750432074,
0.1526542157,
-0.1989120245,
0.6531433463,
0.1035796106,
-0.1921009868,
0.4390475154,
-0.4277967811,
0.7879066467,
-0.3257336318,
0.3398398161,
0.0986651778,
-0.5922073126,
-0.1810880303,
-0.2833981812,
0.1814884692,
1.1857596636,
-0.584512651,
0.6034249067,
-0.2848712504,
-0.6406356096,
-0.70018363,
0.08213716,
0.3705481291,
0.8334646821,
0.1545144618,
-0.3682470024,
-0.6495421529,
-0.8014152646,
-0.1552301347,
-0.3882856965,
-0.6259287596,
0.616894722,
0.0312217195,
-0.6118571758,
0.38970083,
-0.3828057349,
-0.3579502702,
0.2227378041,
0.2330291569,
0.2711868882,
0.4185126424,
0.1064893305,
-0.9100936651,
-0.1959277838,
0.0924773067,
-0.6749661565,
-0.4255425632,
0.2041401863,
0.1633456796,
-0.0610154606,
0.1471007019,
-0.3734502792,
0.5503380299,
0.7713096738,
-0.0462903716,
0.4629998803,
-0.1780226082,
0.4871122241,
-0.7802097797,
0.0558841079,
0.0498654544,
-0.1737061739,
-0.6613776684,
-0.6371665001,
-0.1856563985,
-0.5079158545,
-0.3198855519,
0.0006165504,
-0.3537223041,
-0.2712867856,
-0.5220513344,
-0.2982638776,
-0.1977643073,
-0.2057658732,
0.1902487427,
0.9646787047,
0.6093944311,
-0.7929871678,
0.3093179464,
0.3852640688,
-0.4196940064,
0.6764516234,
-0.6775344014,
0.474845469,
0.3375625908,
0.026035212,
-1.0246133804,
-0.2289641798,
0.0670384616,
-0.7246664166,
0.0125636524,
0.2259357125,
-0.462180227,
-0.6018438935,
-0.1091054827,
-0.281262815,
0.6853017807,
-0.2140768319,
0.3822023571,
0.5993106365,
-0.4689228535,
-0.0956995636,
-0.8598312736,
0.2921812832,
-0.5967581868,
-0.5369416475,
0.554348588,
0.2344703972,
0.0591421053,
-0.4104219377,
-0.5430261493,
-0.5532897115,
0.1804927289,
0.5559508801,
0.2633851767,
0.044381883,
0.3517200053,
-0.0620526746,
-0.0838977844,
0.0314000696,
-0.3320156932,
0.4088219702,
-0.0254864264,
0.3327058852,
-1.0118432045,
0.2049095929,
0.6334144473,
0.0530259684,
0.3817480505,
0.8361368179,
-0.4331795573,
0.3164311051,
-0.6635400653,
-0.1593631655,
-0.4877254963,
0.0995481536,
-0.4505386949,
-0.9152625203,
0.4506334662,
-0.2937253416,
-0.2251345664,
0.1263548881,
0.2248848677,
-0.4970947802,
0.8931075335,
0.4525162578,
-0.1046053022,
0.7492345572,
0.0565757006,
0.1760222912,
-0.9871718884,
-0.2427887768,
-0.8432903886,
-0.1205498353,
-0.8360936046,
-0.0972746462,
0.7439220548,
0.2505182326,
-0.1414643526,
0.4697498679,
-0.9802333713,
-0.3506890535,
0.5184062719,
0.3733372092,
0.1195885763,
0.3334163725,
0.0897853151,
0.0605005808,
-0.5053185225,
-0.8892299533,
0.7523548007,
0.3241575658,
0.8445563316,
-0.2156253159,
0.6583365798,
0.3075822592,
0.2242489904,
-0.7210986614,
0.4070222378,
-0.5599332452,
-0.2065622509,
-0.2688371837,
-0.5025188923,
-0.9112157822,
0.0746373162,
-0.2947046161,
-0.8594219089,
0.0536440387,
0.2552564442,
-0.6869419217,
-0.0596845224,
-1.0851000547,
0.7594624758,
-0.4794697165,
0.0663405806,
-0.0112401284,
-0.5423210859,
-0.2009435296,
0.1416751146,
-0.2048241645,
0.3354891241,
-0.0715800971,
0.8057425618,
-0.534168303,
0.2840653658,
-0.1566579789,
-0.0781780556,
0.0450308211,
-0.3680871427,
0.2337680608,
-0.1854569763,
-0.0944035947,
0.1714567244,
0.1042213961,
-0.1173693389,
-0.6734272242,
0.4907054603,
-0.4834505916,
-0.5092585087,
-0.2135496289,
-0.1830961853,
-0.5429970622,
0.080140315,
0.4654702842,
0.0714010447,
0.169322595,
0.5353273749,
0.4094985723,
-0.4986248016,
0.1752580553,
0.2235543728,
0.0795946419,
-0.5608983636,
0.6095867753,
0.3749494553,
-0.0356642641,
0.4625909626,
0.5204858184,
-0.5358970761,
-0.6646298766,
-0.2756072879,
-0.1223058477,
-0.11167337,
-0.0518083721,
-0.6368318796,
-0.3483788371,
-0.5401607156,
-0.094888635,
0.3267042339,
-0.1380261928,
-0.3123047054,
-0.0792221129,
-0.090283975,
0.4249684513,
0.2230515182,
0.6961993575,
-0.8331590295,
0.0860177949,
0.2807985246,
0.228926152,
-0.5238180161,
-0.1930073202,
-0.1617617905,
-0.2241407335,
-0.5854617953,
-0.9474684,
0.0253553856,
0.2224672884,
0.4478754997,
0.5178224444,
-0.3280208111,
0.8783204556,
-0.4849433899,
0.7335980535,
0.4891439378,
-1.0156365633,
0.7203902602,
-0.1652543396,
0.3378503621,
0.5265812874,
0.3138364255,
-0.4700569808,
-0.0003360178,
-0.5780953765,
-0.4171577394,
0.250377059,
0.1915578395,
0.0868653283,
0.2612582445,
0.4020925462,
-0.188792631,
0.6173193455,
-0.2056524754,
0.1887218952,
-0.2576665878,
-0.1992929727,
0.1641850919,
-0.256901592,
0.1998708844,
-0.1686042398,
0.3092651367,
0.1489847749,
0.5708578229,
0.5098166466,
0.1684027761,
0.1785690337,
0.5733817816,
0.8811410666,
0.5694355369,
-0.1015213355,
-0.1306549907,
0.179205671,
-0.8597899675,
-0.1026603132,
0.2682808936,
0.1155343354,
0.304325223,
0.0729854107,
0.6062924266,
-0.23037,
-0.6729130149,
0.1767915189,
-0.0784097612,
-0.1517644972,
-0.3389797807,
0.3447270989,
-0.1653371155,
0.3163026571,
0.4404217005,
0.0164630543,
0.8206272125,
-0.5951171517,
0.0649347678,
0.2658795714,
-0.3849707544,
-0.1520192921,
0.5771988034,
0.2137720287,
-0.6866376996,
0.2272203118,
-0.0907615796,
-0.5011938214,
0.365527153,
0.3634750545,
0.9319933057,
-0.8923338056,
0.2283089012,
0.2121736556,
0.0058079762,
-0.2121555507,
0.6861581206,
-0.1499594003,
-0.4968295991,
-0.2585664988,
-0.1619276553,
-0.4978574216,
0.3584294319,
-0.6794378161,
0.3621420264,
-0.6038264632,
-0.6954869032,
0.2370456755,
0.0452518761,
-0.6418912411,
0.7444240451,
0.285857141,
0.5790764689,
-0.3872448504,
0.5490205884,
1.2927458286,
-0.2807233334,
-0.984269321,
0.184641853,
0.0094021177,
-0.6591747403,
0.7469520569,
0.201879248,
-0.4504065812,
-0.3235450983,
-0.2072703689,
-0.3213516474,
1.052675724,
0.2302367538,
-0.8957887292,
-0.063591361,
-0.1461039484,
0.6458836198,
-0.454120189,
0.251393944,
0.0866192356,
0.1334301531,
0.1294216663,
-1.7372547388,
-0.1428399831,
-0.3863689303,
0.1260733306,
-0.1184712648,
-0.1812808514,
0.5090441108,
-0.0978457853,
-0.4667192996,
0.0259127021,
0.1603774279,
0.1165139079,
0.7258850336,
0.8147093654,
0.6047132611,
1.2281198502,
-0.1725249887,
1.042932272,
-0.0951572061,
0.169050172,
0.8319721818,
-0.4713744223,
0.7530473471,
0.1529918313,
-0.2285822481,
0.4987457097,
0.3393042684,
0.1834292412,
0.5617339015,
0.5542186499,
-0.4128361344,
0.2484797835,
-0.2830693424,
-0.4440227151,
0.5596859455,
0.2809906602,
-0.7348635793,
0.2814050615,
0.578979075,
0.2191813886,
-0.1287115961,
-0.4439467788,
1.0721544027,
0.137451902,
-0.3800748587,
0.7563382983,
-0.3089970052,
0.7686191797,
-0.3382496834,
0.0259205271,
0.5012171268,
0.2154174447,
-0.8925467134,
-0.6004956365,
0.565004468,
0.3104612827,
-0.0748246685,
-0.5896083117,
0.7481869459,
-0.0847922862,
-0.1707892567,
0.0389167555,
0.1648612022,
0.4349606931,
-0.198590368,
-0.6031305194,
0.1278752089,
-0.2600426078,
0.2682947516,
-0.1312396675,
0.3267264068,
0.2112057954,
0.5354883075,
0.6323179603,
0.6206150055,
-0.0797765553,
0.1594035923,
0.7983672619,
-0.4980991483,
-0.786623776,
-0.603300631,
0.4434835017,
-0.3468811214,
-0.5459973216,
0.536224544,
0.6814940572,
0.8362925053,
-0.1089395359,
0.8832027912,
-0.0617442504,
0.8939914703,
-0.4573438764,
0.5074046254,
-0.4963869452,
0.0372272357,
-0.3983073831,
-0.3958776295,
-0.4840507507,
1.1903223991,
-0.7658826709,
-0.0685949698,
0.7428231239,
0.5997010469,
0.1152737141,
0.1710402817,
0.394736588,
-0.0659659356,
0.2563872933,
0.3813587129,
0.7837199569,
-0.3203886151,
0.5676106215,
0.0196346324,
-0.3074532449,
-0.3604552746,
-0.5114924312,
-0.5271432996,
-0.4375542998,
-0.4132962525,
-0.6596182585,
0.2455859929,
0.6797913313,
1.2207671404,
-0.5595870614,
-0.1430778652,
-0.0743601248,
-0.2387427241,
-0.3607812524,
-0.2188292891,
-0.1162821352,
-0.2316452563,
-0.5271409154,
0.3979927599,
0.5289521813,
-0.0399013683,
0.0907652825,
-0.0773693025,
0.3278745711,
-0.408768028,
0.6830536723,
0.4075361192,
-0.5092799664,
-0.0823087692,
0.2680899799,
-0.1396723688,
0.347347945,
1.0843299627,
-0.3859689832,
0.4234368503,
0.5406753421,
0.8854089379,
-0.0026379104,
0.4149300456,
0.3094144166,
-0.1509176642,
-0.1057202667,
0.6227127314,
0.3788815439,
0.3506864011,
-0.608705759,
0.4742235541,
0.2025907189,
-0.8646108508,
-0.8062780499,
0.0385766439,
-0.9364386201,
0.2571751773,
0.9100273252,
-0.322614342,
0.0653098896,
-0.1983640939,
-0.4729564488,
0.1111406535,
-0.4997854531,
0.8740258813,
0.7588573098,
-0.6388802528,
-0.3871886134,
-0.7970352173,
0.4983740449,
0.2611715198,
-1.1370140314,
-0.911030829,
0.275288552,
0.4006339908,
0.611356616,
0.9244683385,
-0.3027003407,
0.33648476,
-0.430143714,
-0.1326772422,
0.0109755462,
-0.2600522637,
-0.3976601064,
0.2386626154,
-0.1680639237,
-0.960524857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01109v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01109v3
|
Vaccine: Perturbation-aware Alignment for Large Language Model
| 2024-02-02T02:56:50 | 2024-02-29T07:15:13 |
Tiansheng Huang, Sihao Hu, Ling Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The new paradigm of finetuning-as-a-service introduces a new attack surface
for Large Language Models (LLMs): a few harmful data uploaded by users can
easily trick the finetuning to produce an alignment-broken model. We conduct an
empirical analysis and uncover a \textit{harmful embedding drift} phenomenon,
showing a probable cause of the alignment-broken effect. Inspired by our
findings, we propose Vaccine, a perturbation-aware alignment technique to
mitigate the security risk of users finetuning. The core idea of Vaccine is to
produce invariant hidden embeddings by progressively adding crafted
perturbation to them in the alignment phase. This enables the embeddings to
withstand harmful perturbation from un-sanitized user data in the finetuning
phase. Our results on open source mainstream LLMs (e.g., Llama2, Opt, Vicuna)
demonstrate that Vaccine can boost the robustness of alignment against harmful
prompts induced embedding drift while reserving reasoning ability towards
benign prompts. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/git-disl/Vaccine}.
|
[
-0.049092941,
-1.2033058405,
0.3228911757,
-0.1125666648,
-0.2009838521,
0.0140106715,
0.0073078061,
-0.2322718054,
0.2483205646,
0.6912311316,
-0.3328843415,
-0.6637821198,
-0.5321998596,
-0.2397094071,
-0.6546807885,
0.9319713116,
0.2782322764,
0.0628907979,
-0.2796550691,
0.1019791216,
-0.4806172848,
-0.2769964933,
-0.5819540024,
-0.0932463482,
0.5875793695,
0.6221360564,
0.7538379431,
1.0422053337,
0.5763356686,
0.2038741708,
-0.3012394309,
-0.355801791,
-0.6247840524,
0.6199764013,
-0.1737313718,
-0.7889463902,
-0.61808002,
-0.2425962985,
0.6939715147,
0.3171566129,
-0.4285315275,
-0.0459396802,
-0.0030216915,
0.3872374892,
-0.6661407948,
-0.6054283977,
-0.8480603695,
-0.0833955184,
-0.7994342446,
0.0042373361,
-0.4946055412,
0.1111447141,
-0.2646277845,
-0.5644274354,
-0.1297938079,
-0.0651459023,
0.7751286626,
0.4502729475,
-0.2860786319,
0.0668449402,
-0.4683119059,
0.5473017693,
-0.8658897877,
0.2639227509,
0.2362396866,
0.4049812555,
-0.6218714714,
-0.4893227816,
-0.5504312515,
-0.0270884633,
0.4762315154,
0.0414930061,
-0.441835314,
0.1505832076,
0.3375404477,
0.3526530266,
-0.5973958969,
0.7865747809,
0.1328790486,
-0.4072975814,
0.5033137202,
0.2770569324,
0.6863544583,
-0.0867545381,
-0.3471851349,
-0.0391075648,
-1.1895194054,
0.0358248726,
0.6037048697,
0.3030713797,
-0.2758720517,
0.650220871,
-0.0006037208,
0.6976612806,
0.5295424461,
0.005522185,
0.0007015251,
-0.2665325403,
-0.1772759259,
0.2752835751,
0.8747358322,
0.2280825377,
-0.0126046129,
0.1848646402,
-0.079081431,
-0.0860752165,
0.1366078556,
-0.8360136151,
-0.152883321,
0.3945170641,
-0.0328708515,
-0.3799586892,
-0.0801854357,
-0.9172061086,
-0.8566739559,
0.1505544186,
0.2922084033,
-0.5430790782,
-0.1627015471,
0.43123734,
0.0839180574,
0.1871291101,
0.1522912085,
-1.0398397446,
-0.0464544669,
1.0827747583,
0.6183186173,
-0.1436582655,
-0.1275648028,
-0.7976914644,
0.4579862654,
-0.0861212686,
0.9886525273,
-0.5524130464,
-0.1916428208,
0.1557548642,
-0.1425518095,
0.3871196508,
-0.2815233767,
0.380071342,
-0.5275686979,
-0.1098019555,
-0.0332690477,
-0.571223259,
0.1239519715,
0.2551790178,
-0.4919721186,
0.2786577046,
-0.4839308262,
-0.8808134198,
0.2493010908,
-0.4291413426,
-0.4782014489,
0.1139158085,
-0.2954475284,
-0.7615219355,
-0.0039658458,
0.2337942272,
0.3086592853,
-0.1025111452,
0.2522695065,
-0.606508255,
-0.1624100059,
0.4572609067,
-0.4283493757,
0.8676828742,
0.1992745101,
-0.0565208718,
0.4867300689,
-0.5655201674,
-0.2527925968,
0.0592328943,
-0.167960763,
-0.3998684287,
0.0264629722,
-0.2493654042,
-0.0971514881,
0.1658232361,
-0.5637580752,
0.6546288133,
-0.7149695754,
0.5124078989,
0.7305985093,
0.3507051468,
0.4676998258,
-0.4733919203,
0.7729640007,
0.1870025098,
0.3135155737,
-0.2806285322,
-0.585144639,
-0.2972756922,
-0.6306024194,
0.4664503336,
0.6266222596,
-0.4309973121,
0.3822623491,
-0.1226368323,
-0.5249921679,
-0.6255122423,
0.1316986382,
0.3878735006,
0.3710868061,
0.1806044579,
-0.1544262171,
-0.4919016361,
-0.8024281263,
-0.4126283526,
0.0196595229,
-0.1162495986,
-0.0702036098,
0.2993148267,
-0.6559947133,
0.6168190837,
-0.5086227655,
-0.236239627,
0.1788844317,
-0.205539614,
0.2950609624,
0.7633247972,
0.4865153432,
-0.4745218456,
-0.24078013,
-0.0272025913,
-0.2850226164,
-0.4012442231,
-0.1303378046,
-0.1329523325,
0.1383871883,
0.693795085,
-0.7017413378,
0.3289433718,
0.6507752538,
-0.4823407233,
0.6130487323,
0.0632460564,
-0.0805717632,
-1.3684159517,
0.0157276802,
-0.2171738595,
-0.3623166382,
-0.6170990467,
0.27758497,
0.0116500333,
-0.0800115988,
-0.5545644164,
0.3237815499,
-0.0846214369,
0.3579087853,
-0.0451360345,
0.0211237241,
-0.1719004065,
-0.3014141321,
-0.6392330527,
0.7911126018,
0.7879974246,
-0.5399935246,
0.2421870381,
0.5198407769,
-0.2339906543,
0.5335973501,
-0.5163369775,
0.1318531632,
-0.0111262156,
0.3146529496,
-0.8686596155,
-0.4908357263,
0.3991095722,
-0.5563980937,
0.5426570773,
-0.2297296971,
-0.3274866045,
-0.0263732392,
-0.5779287219,
0.492543608,
0.398434639,
-0.3738206625,
0.3119590282,
0.748891294,
-0.0835611075,
-0.6984016895,
-0.9127143025,
0.1954402626,
-0.5449687243,
-0.6249064207,
0.4319143891,
-0.0944809094,
-0.1399020553,
-0.1142883897,
-0.121478796,
0.1054938734,
0.4187292159,
0.2669934332,
0.0549629368,
-0.3068153858,
0.1348215789,
0.222570762,
-0.2957481146,
-0.1362522542,
-0.2951698005,
0.624206841,
0.135073334,
-0.6437562108,
-0.8098026514,
0.4741317034,
0.753387928,
-0.2693419755,
0.4543476105,
0.470834583,
-0.5269327164,
0.052874051,
-0.6017406583,
-0.1518250257,
-0.5128237009,
0.4230100513,
-0.1870457828,
-0.9792862535,
0.6453489661,
-0.0079424875,
0.0752334744,
0.5267522335,
0.5879478455,
-0.3774710894,
1.1514179707,
0.6714937687,
-0.1189392507,
0.7375890017,
0.1157439575,
0.1253284812,
-0.8012531996,
-0.064946115,
-0.5389046073,
-0.3857204914,
-0.5912150741,
-0.2541729212,
0.2289505899,
0.489032954,
-0.5572729111,
0.2375681996,
-0.5704929829,
0.4791437089,
0.3656207025,
-0.0853503272,
0.268669337,
0.0631527379,
-0.3557176888,
-0.0038812528,
-0.6061536074,
-0.5168540478,
0.9951913953,
0.4491138756,
1.1986156702,
0.3905207217,
0.7645404339,
0.086471267,
0.1303076595,
-0.8152022958,
0.425541997,
-0.3805252612,
-0.5271186233,
-0.2453528792,
-0.1642871499,
-1.1346510649,
-0.2628281116,
-0.4073821902,
-1.1977092028,
0.0848237872,
0.5815104842,
-0.6636641026,
0.2277296036,
-0.5513715148,
0.8280164003,
-0.2858720124,
-0.4572715759,
-0.2968194485,
-0.4921205342,
0.2718257606,
-0.1717168391,
0.0144660324,
-0.0885402337,
-0.1782310009,
0.6288284063,
-0.3347603679,
1.0838251114,
-0.0792942047,
-0.3953954279,
0.1185676381,
0.3093868792,
0.4936963022,
0.3811403811,
-0.0774873644,
0.2041918486,
0.1518553495,
-0.3045907319,
-0.3991495669,
0.9387249351,
-0.4075132608,
-1.2222710848,
-0.42885077,
-0.4185118675,
-0.1189000607,
0.3908397853,
0.3845360875,
0.0454243794,
-0.0594560951,
0.3017044365,
0.78441149,
-0.4422615767,
0.1858399361,
0.7369168997,
-0.4221409261,
-0.5851932764,
0.7142959833,
0.0885578915,
0.3832411468,
0.3640075326,
0.3779659569,
0.0144040557,
-0.8958157301,
-0.3152909577,
0.26179111,
-0.3711144626,
-0.680893302,
-0.4589949846,
-0.1227667332,
-0.6147339344,
-0.22860834,
-0.3307545185,
-0.2395243645,
-0.3033564687,
-0.0426435843,
0.4238272905,
0.5641360879,
-0.042861674,
0.4434265792,
-0.7382229567,
0.1116596088,
0.135798499,
0.5784664154,
-0.4351764619,
-0.4884852767,
0.0196331106,
0.3234278858,
-0.5744603872,
-1.0361181498,
-0.0087194806,
0.0886083245,
0.4725479782,
0.9321776628,
-0.0296019576,
0.7429730892,
-0.6484444737,
0.7197257876,
0.2721644938,
-1.0405862331,
0.6131600738,
-0.5714544654,
0.6459797025,
0.379570514,
0.1096082404,
-0.7640464306,
-0.7371749282,
-0.4262241423,
-0.7610744834,
0.4040091336,
-0.3000194728,
0.2195141017,
-0.0049107973,
0.595707953,
0.1634441316,
-0.0337587707,
-0.3650502861,
-0.1039769128,
-0.0184961278,
-0.2660769522,
0.0510253012,
-0.6285916567,
-0.2282162756,
-0.2554095089,
0.651001811,
0.0446149074,
0.2320483029,
0.0831707269,
-0.0636040643,
-0.3741844594,
0.2603415549,
0.8236274123,
0.1404025108,
0.0861876979,
0.2543517947,
-0.021255333,
-0.5830811858,
0.1766991913,
0.0533572398,
-0.3753806353,
-0.4496849477,
0.334561497,
0.4688756168,
0.1777444035,
-0.5931867361,
0.6524766088,
0.1843403727,
0.1392045915,
-0.0711567774,
0.2246771902,
0.1992859989,
0.1661498696,
0.0277053136,
-0.0881272405,
0.0462624393,
-0.2845249772,
0.5115486383,
0.681856215,
-0.4885755181,
-0.5121545792,
0.8378617764,
0.0924003497,
-0.466715008,
0.3801456988,
0.0996691361,
-0.4089018106,
0.4440431595,
1.102645874,
0.7172185779,
-0.8576737046,
-0.0289143678,
0.1278273761,
0.3654914796,
0.1578241587,
0.1492659599,
0.4449592829,
-0.7461662889,
-0.4729914963,
-0.4050311148,
-0.1868454814,
0.3866285384,
-0.3985221386,
0.592320621,
-0.478703171,
-0.2596957386,
0.2605412304,
-0.3906518817,
-0.1697162986,
-0.3865505755,
0.3048241138,
0.9327297211,
-0.882099092,
0.7495136261,
0.8383500576,
-0.2654713988,
-0.322005868,
0.3265185356,
0.4398861825,
-0.6397212148,
0.0664277151,
0.2455189526,
-0.0418882705,
-0.0511299931,
-0.6255489588,
-0.9547628164,
0.7761465311,
0.9500956535,
-0.8563196659,
0.1653921306,
0.0514648072,
0.4096966386,
-0.1616308987,
-0.3062595725,
0.4309864938,
0.40613392,
-0.15621306,
-0.7082151175,
0.274515003,
0.0084577026,
-0.2010182589,
0.3890333176,
-0.4287011325,
0.5841260552,
-0.2254518121,
-0.4521940351,
0.1606484056,
0.4098018408,
-0.020346107,
0.2158003449,
0.2484235317,
0.7508272529,
0.8743076324,
0.02144696,
0.9588708282,
-0.2928057313,
0.1242595688,
1.1089787483,
-0.1942498833,
0.9074267149,
0.7269117236,
0.1239558905,
0.1518335044,
0.3133446872,
-0.0003851308,
0.388087213,
0.4334311783,
-0.1867695898,
-0.3404699266,
-0.0924512744,
-0.4226602018,
0.6515586376,
0.6755790114,
0.0071898717,
-0.0631992742,
0.2760130465,
0.2174548507,
0.2320357263,
-0.2479281276,
0.9601107836,
0.0574167445,
-0.5164195299,
0.628824532,
-0.0808466226,
0.7075155973,
-0.4740404785,
-0.0086156251,
0.0685772002,
0.2311267257,
-0.4430409372,
-0.8880128264,
0.3987323344,
-0.0628103316,
-0.1075748131,
-0.0492727272,
0.7668437958,
-0.4577367902,
-0.0929093584,
0.1181260645,
0.0939388275,
-0.1770345271,
0.175560385,
-0.5975758433,
0.2527732253,
0.0262107253,
-0.2011370361,
0.3772687912,
0.1354789883,
-0.275809437,
0.7378713489,
0.5765971541,
0.1330163032,
0.0360172428,
-0.046828419,
0.8395994306,
-0.4493434131,
-0.3201616406,
-1.16982162,
0.5207043886,
-0.0120140715,
-0.2495099306,
0.6760171652,
0.6096466184,
0.5247658491,
0.0776116103,
0.4055764973,
0.1939462721,
0.1081100553,
-0.6221053004,
1.123707056,
-0.3749777675,
0.4287573099,
-0.2037078887,
-0.5039178729,
-0.9663527012,
0.286829859,
-0.3776149154,
-0.5742974877,
0.4844555557,
0.9948071837,
0.0003894905,
-0.2619939148,
0.3144076765,
0.6870740652,
0.6760033369,
0.3803289533,
0.7899874449,
-0.1245063916,
0.3612233698,
-0.0670276061,
-0.3041527867,
-0.5316283107,
-1.136538744,
-0.7123576999,
-0.5539063811,
-0.6045953035,
-0.530564487,
0.3151741624,
0.8303197026,
0.3273622692,
-1.0172688961,
0.0796080008,
-0.1312005818,
0.245422855,
-0.1437535435,
-0.1543665677,
0.211788848,
-0.1635483354,
-0.4400521517,
0.4103808403,
0.4107736945,
0.348959595,
-0.0717046261,
0.2810802758,
-0.3171595037,
0.0360769182,
0.1360211521,
0.5462551713,
-0.8384643793,
-0.4459136426,
-0.2680120468,
-0.2940815091,
0.1123246029,
0.5520349145,
-0.4542093873,
0.6478524804,
0.4573625326,
1.0144805908,
0.0922317952,
-0.047275126,
0.7318927646,
-0.606128335,
0.1748043895,
0.3054943383,
0.3447732329,
0.1837387681,
-0.6600216031,
-0.1039303839,
-0.0358178876,
-0.488784045,
-1.0069876909,
0.6267784238,
-0.9940406084,
0.0579750277,
1.2610411644,
-0.0107292179,
-0.4204197228,
0.1067940518,
-0.2161207795,
0.4530363083,
-0.5095095038,
0.7991621494,
0.5120975375,
0.1962578446,
0.1571540833,
-0.3968069255,
0.5245338082,
0.5848017335,
-0.6489468813,
0.0431291498,
0.3520942628,
0.3978986442,
0.090271689,
0.1441320777,
-0.3460287154,
0.4013280869,
-0.2103083432,
0.0365706496,
-0.1954365671,
-0.0445534699,
-0.9259230494,
0.0002221181,
0.3096314073,
-0.2734410167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01108v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01108v1
|
Reasoning Capacity in Multi-Agent Systems: Limitations, Challenges and Human-Centered Solutions
| 2024-02-02T02:53:11 | 2024-02-02T02:53:11 |
Pouya Pezeshkpour, Eser Kandogan, Nikita Bhutani, Sajjadur Rahman, Tom Mitchell, Estevam Hruschka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) in a variety of tasks
brings forth many opportunities as well as challenges of utilizing them in
production settings. Towards practical adoption of LLMs, multi-agent systems
hold great promise to augment, integrate, and orchestrate LLMs in the larger
context of enterprise platforms that use existing proprietary data and models
to tackle complex real-world tasks. Despite the tremendous success of these
systems, current approaches rely on narrow, single-focus objectives for
optimization and evaluation, often overlooking potential constraints in
real-world scenarios, including restricted budgets, resources and time.
Furthermore, interpreting, analyzing, and debugging these systems requires
different components to be evaluated in relation to one another. This demand is
currently not feasible with existing methodologies. In this postion paper, we
introduce the concept of reasoning capacity as a unifying criterion to enable
integration of constraints during optimization and establish connections among
different components within the system, which also enable a more holistic and
comprehensive approach to evaluation. We present a formal definition of
reasoning capacity and illustrate its utility in identifying limitations within
each component of the system. We then argue how these limitations can be
addressed with a self-reflective process wherein human-feedback is used to
alleviate shortcomings in reasoning and enhance overall consistency of the
system.
|
[
-0.6586212516,
-0.3424340785,
1.096549511,
0.3328792453,
-0.1339971125,
0.215227738,
-0.4599252343,
-0.504768312,
0.1005502418,
0.639185667,
-0.5634760261,
-0.0203310531,
-0.3545918167,
0.3130066395,
-0.0599631444,
0.4189853668,
-0.2193746269,
0.0061612078,
-0.5363516808,
-0.3392145038,
-0.8093055487,
-0.6867765784,
-0.2681959271,
-0.5632622838,
0.2483415604,
0.6258531809,
0.6403739452,
0.2269758582,
0.4277605116,
0.4396504462,
0.3471027613,
0.6404353976,
-0.0269735251,
0.4190320373,
-0.4163618684,
-0.1352365911,
-0.4124068022,
-0.0569773205,
0.6507017612,
0.8058990836,
-0.1587879211,
0.266056627,
0.2317835242,
0.3907055557,
-0.904294312,
0.063742131,
-0.4459828436,
-0.0595230944,
0.1935573965,
-0.1352475733,
-0.4462211132,
0.0967150927,
0.1415453255,
-0.7171094418,
-0.2803954482,
-0.0485310964,
0.5353831649,
0.546543777,
-0.3804462552,
-0.1707767844,
-0.9377419353,
0.9824985266,
-0.4248326421,
0.1496861428,
0.0872403011,
0.4289954603,
-0.1534240842,
-0.30298087,
-0.5625193715,
-0.1422043592,
-0.039569281,
-0.0899239853,
-0.1510380805,
0.125090763,
0.1499005556,
-0.2079488933,
-0.2775547802,
0.0365022197,
-0.1561234593,
-0.4066199958,
0.7630161643,
0.4748475254,
0.140846476,
0.0323119089,
-0.3355502784,
0.1675833017,
-0.1578816921,
-0.3204284906,
0.1056729853,
0.3394347131,
0.3649106026,
0.5340461135,
-0.3193639815,
0.5019927025,
-0.2153469324,
-0.0123838931,
0.0480825603,
-0.3755388856,
-0.1180176884,
-0.3315505385,
0.6221441031,
0.0511875637,
0.3185057044,
-0.3084744215,
-0.2851618528,
0.2966712117,
0.5516423583,
-0.30632177,
0.4533107281,
0.3343445063,
-0.1381736845,
0.216461122,
0.0606503524,
-0.6375651956,
-0.5263206363,
-0.5929418206,
0.4343733788,
-0.0637480915,
-0.4550862908,
0.3086252511,
-0.2645497024,
0.2273246646,
0.4673498571,
-0.5446397662,
0.358654052,
0.5530514717,
0.6428686976,
-0.1102014259,
-0.4196896553,
-0.3021577597,
0.3615792394,
-0.1286916435,
0.7452319264,
-0.3336971402,
-0.2184142768,
-0.2173858136,
-0.1141447127,
-0.1168671101,
-0.5899195075,
0.6564724445,
-0.3657346666,
-0.4082872272,
-0.4494353235,
-0.3982022405,
0.0572863854,
0.3716332316,
-0.6847313643,
0.5528677702,
0.1131563485,
-0.2470107079,
0.2582585812,
-0.7441358566,
-0.3144005835,
0.2055798918,
-0.2700466514,
-0.0027442055,
0.1573220193,
-0.0668807626,
0.3918263912,
-0.6867650151,
0.1601749659,
-0.3821760416,
-0.2056852579,
0.3607746363,
-0.338389039,
0.5782638788,
0.534884572,
-0.3457585871,
0.239876017,
-0.6226119399,
0.3675758839,
0.1407783628,
-0.2886112928,
-0.1754540652,
0.071192883,
-0.315051347,
0.1259587854,
0.4291601479,
-0.3791866302,
0.1989254653,
-0.0904931724,
0.5505040884,
0.6172754169,
-0.1614741534,
0.564835012,
-0.2762992382,
0.7081267834,
-0.1203214005,
0.4145259559,
0.0604974478,
-0.0118456092,
-0.731998384,
-0.137563318,
-0.2127443701,
0.6357219219,
-0.5555315018,
0.381919235,
-0.0039860867,
-0.3885803521,
-0.5015521646,
0.4124549627,
0.2494426221,
0.1880907267,
0.3108577728,
-0.3215638995,
-0.6135180593,
-0.9355905652,
-0.1021904126,
-0.132425949,
0.1276905388,
0.3331502378,
0.5107793808,
-0.260671258,
0.9178664684,
-0.1978894323,
-0.2983018756,
-0.5793858767,
-0.1173285618,
0.0618055463,
0.2968041003,
0.1872428805,
-0.5952228308,
-0.2602526546,
0.1194925904,
-0.975018084,
-0.2632150054,
-0.3296826482,
-0.1525151581,
0.2004636824,
0.2452547699,
-0.9316395521,
0.3440024853,
0.3503906429,
-0.4479696155,
0.9418282509,
-0.4367830455,
-0.020167714,
-0.4593144059,
-0.0680409744,
0.0028257028,
-0.0875783116,
-0.4858540595,
0.2203800082,
-0.2411785871,
0.0294409972,
-0.027717974,
0.597019136,
-0.8907684088,
-0.3627755046,
-0.3558179736,
0.5086048245,
0.5417872667,
0.3959773183,
-0.1375341117,
0.7153847814,
0.324809134,
-0.671511054,
0.7510399222,
0.0519301817,
-0.2803365588,
0.7175854445,
-0.5500121713,
0.0820091888,
-0.0149207255,
0.1747223884,
-0.5935362577,
-0.2115417272,
0.2310313433,
-0.1540473998,
-0.0912262052,
0.3075440526,
-0.5892572999,
-0.4610672593,
0.0111312075,
0.4414506555,
0.0666703954,
-0.2743647099,
0.8522728682,
0.5207377076,
0.3496890664,
-0.6802453399,
-0.6253887415,
0.2647189796,
-0.1546449959,
-0.9329570532,
0.0122481771,
0.0792476013,
-0.6525947452,
-0.0661471561,
-0.1901929528,
-0.0698606521,
0.3136897385,
0.0697233453,
0.2131162584,
0.0322601199,
0.5309785008,
0.02779961,
-0.1396041662,
0.2210181504,
-0.4356535971,
0.2414417118,
-0.610689342,
-0.8085036278,
-0.5552159548,
0.6134724617,
0.8321000934,
-0.3331045508,
0.6329698563,
0.2404075116,
-0.3003495932,
-0.3662879467,
-0.8581290245,
-0.3054173291,
-0.3916940987,
0.3565988541,
-0.5586860776,
-0.7251630425,
0.6362383962,
-0.3339309692,
-0.2049083263,
0.343585223,
0.5360152125,
0.0525444113,
0.958738029,
0.3564824164,
0.256357193,
0.0035276995,
-0.1952320039,
0.1871145517,
-1.0385802984,
-0.2798765898,
-0.5681312084,
-0.0847936198,
-0.1436248273,
-0.6219229102,
0.3900016546,
0.0466103368,
-0.4263657033,
0.1893454939,
-0.6338521838,
0.4475383759,
0.268255949,
-0.1020849124,
0.6842381954,
-0.2819677293,
-0.2778149247,
0.1641546488,
-0.773807168,
-0.9125929475,
0.7630294561,
0.328110069,
0.6743370891,
0.2187832594,
0.3996562362,
0.3033361137,
0.167333737,
-0.7127428651,
0.7386217713,
0.0995029584,
-0.8010033369,
-0.8287718892,
-0.3583977222,
-0.9936473966,
0.6970379353,
-0.1829361022,
-0.8503044844,
0.1894907802,
-0.0586407557,
-0.4034366608,
0.3293147981,
-0.9948194623,
0.8157488108,
-0.532341063,
-0.5428980589,
-0.4028346241,
-0.5081235766,
0.0797144547,
0.1130308062,
0.2673179805,
-0.2456392199,
-0.0701588169,
0.2667824924,
-0.5176852942,
0.8291755319,
-0.2071391791,
-0.0648315176,
0.7371991873,
-0.1548745781,
0.390929848,
-0.1067547053,
-0.3208966851,
-0.0470942222,
0.2213111371,
-0.4197733998,
-0.7546743751,
0.4061596096,
-0.8426289558,
-0.9354026318,
-0.3663517833,
-0.4759052098,
-0.5409681201,
0.1419844329,
-0.1396502554,
0.1372161657,
-0.1688591987,
0.1272707582,
0.3441207707,
-0.0166349169,
0.3321300447,
0.5008169413,
-0.0996449441,
-0.0027860506,
0.6673388481,
0.2177421004,
0.3412950933,
-0.0664658323,
0.060709618,
-0.3403876424,
-0.3779036105,
-0.393524766,
0.2985441387,
-0.8101385832,
-0.106285505,
-0.3457098901,
-0.1271026134,
-0.2391266376,
-0.0321811475,
-0.4756259918,
-0.2351471037,
-0.4252321422,
0.1529755145,
-0.2094892263,
0.6009716988,
-0.1012211367,
0.1566155851,
-0.7287724018,
0.0236601625,
0.3815474212,
0.4799587429,
0.4301493466,
-0.2457277626,
-0.4652811587,
-0.0842229053,
-0.5001264811,
-0.9771690965,
0.2061006427,
-0.2407252043,
0.967255652,
0.2320085466,
0.2579636872,
0.4158756137,
-0.0486290492,
0.2989218235,
0.1623775512,
-1.0560252666,
0.4037471116,
-0.1935347915,
0.2904190421,
0.5543996096,
0.1315676123,
-0.244526431,
-0.3087108731,
-0.2334889174,
-0.694976449,
0.4880489707,
0.0800147578,
-0.0372008011,
0.1447077543,
0.5272120833,
-0.1256275624,
0.2408616543,
-0.5349111557,
0.1228511184,
-0.0045802887,
0.1222610995,
0.0510134995,
-0.1679514796,
-0.2270016372,
-0.2785709798,
0.6365290284,
-0.3730482161,
0.0493275411,
0.39658162,
-0.1898860484,
-0.1033867598,
0.7764633298,
0.4501816928,
1.0372362137,
0.1220161393,
0.0630094558,
0.3357468545,
-0.0375089757,
0.4376911223,
-0.1566227525,
0.1391124874,
-0.3847231269,
0.2343806028,
0.7557122707,
-0.2523417771,
-0.9599938989,
0.3243050873,
0.1536526382,
-0.1446146518,
-0.5243521929,
0.0695334077,
0.0647604242,
0.6433387399,
0.5690384507,
-0.0740540251,
0.0629298016,
-0.6189344525,
-0.1175353527,
0.6722390652,
-0.2203804851,
0.0668661818,
0.2145214379,
0.3273971677,
-0.1517282873,
0.5416224003,
-0.3981985152,
-0.508402884,
0.704664588,
0.2974669635,
0.9494152665,
-0.0928863958,
0.3483706117,
0.1236205325,
0.6576282382,
-0.1596654505,
0.1725508571,
-0.007540721,
-1.2120479345,
-0.8710997105,
-0.5199400783,
-0.5971040726,
-0.0488885567,
-0.4919832051,
0.0433778092,
-0.4364669025,
-0.5777225494,
-0.1389983743,
0.2347322106,
-0.4833106101,
-0.0118728187,
0.0939637646,
0.6229133606,
-0.5191266537,
0.5462697148,
0.7847802639,
-0.3990837932,
-0.8565322757,
-0.4095956385,
-0.0641710386,
-0.5668618083,
0.5283118486,
0.0395054035,
-0.590039134,
-0.3964682519,
-0.4040209055,
-0.5762190223,
1.1477986574,
0.6893553138,
-0.5970411301,
0.006397278,
0.1790337563,
0.6764588952,
-0.7458600402,
0.0413024686,
0.7631021142,
0.8930940628,
-0.0089203212,
-1.0979466438,
0.2504190207,
-0.0454009846,
-0.1918986887,
0.1246191636,
-0.863833487,
0.6054050922,
-0.4039554298,
-0.2462992519,
-0.0155408438,
0.3970736265,
0.433788538,
0.4888348579,
0.830270648,
0.4932617545,
0.8184316754,
0.0405143164,
0.9020895362,
-0.0538459606,
0.2865093648,
0.9822862744,
-0.6922491193,
0.4292830825,
0.629823029,
-0.2063150555,
0.5649036169,
0.1345596313,
0.0560209304,
-0.1324279606,
0.4868790805,
-0.3695620596,
-0.8142325878,
-0.4309065938,
0.0098934202,
0.5981360674,
0.3388777077,
0.0892945006,
-0.0862013325,
-0.0274995584,
-0.270039171,
0.3401535451,
-0.2389536798,
0.6130071282,
0.1235859841,
-1.0795555115,
0.2923958302,
-0.0842405558,
0.1496284157,
-0.3506802022,
0.0039178785,
0.1262175739,
0.2692463696,
-0.201167047,
-0.6984533668,
0.5315430164,
-0.2025910467,
-0.2795866132,
-0.2762542963,
0.9678849578,
-0.0463320315,
-0.2087526619,
0.6964023709,
0.85753721,
0.0082564242,
-0.27291134,
-0.4314109683,
0.3290954828,
-0.2656077743,
-0.162342146,
0.2886070907,
0.7362276912,
-0.1065543815,
1.0943056345,
0.2548332512,
0.1914634705,
-0.2433370203,
0.2315798402,
0.7584417462,
-0.5771137476,
-0.3455941081,
-0.7559913993,
0.3620750308,
-0.1370393038,
-0.0230495781,
0.4353563488,
0.1588645875,
0.4422941506,
0.1609160602,
1.0461348295,
0.0770896748,
0.4015848041,
-0.2721169591,
0.2860186398,
-0.7245732546,
0.5547551513,
-0.2090597302,
-0.8188868761,
-0.0985942557,
0.5644561648,
-0.2998936772,
0.1391776055,
0.7050548792,
0.4204002619,
0.3048367798,
-0.0051871431,
0.464307934,
0.0309975166,
0.15914087,
0.7417570949,
1.2105499506,
0.1474857181,
0.775696218,
0.0258505978,
-0.3447937965,
-0.2153682411,
-0.7539814711,
-0.6193406582,
-0.692602396,
-0.1650182903,
-0.2676030397,
-0.2047666162,
0.8256698847,
0.7557799816,
-0.4968308806,
-0.6052438617,
-0.0183418058,
0.4038538635,
-0.209928453,
-0.1962726712,
-0.0729546323,
-0.5353478789,
-0.3715670109,
0.1832996607,
0.4929938614,
-0.155279398,
-0.8669937849,
-0.3764778376,
-0.1709685475,
0.348436594,
0.6071349382,
0.3859460056,
-0.7625345588,
-0.4401167631,
0.0541550182,
-0.0813270807,
-0.2331376076,
0.8682383895,
-0.6152330637,
0.4154575467,
0.3317601085,
0.746090889,
0.4286594093,
-0.0645966232,
0.5286285877,
-0.4768624604,
-0.02443658,
0.4112322032,
0.3982186615,
0.2589675784,
-0.2128481418,
0.5863820314,
0.1798262596,
-0.7491289377,
-0.7624544501,
0.5395012498,
-1.0260585546,
-0.4392858148,
0.9758775234,
-0.0048412438,
0.1083223373,
-0.5215155482,
-0.12718153,
0.1968933046,
-0.3274978101,
0.6830291152,
1.0504910946,
-0.5073494315,
-0.210632652,
-0.4894018471,
-0.0098441951,
0.6059545875,
-0.9397070408,
0.144453451,
0.6342595816,
-0.08388374,
0.5930485129,
0.6805842519,
0.1227514669,
0.180965066,
-0.0887852833,
0.1051504835,
0.1466815323,
-0.4688591063,
-0.0556666888,
0.3607234359,
0.363132447,
0.0344295837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01789v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01789v2
|
The Political Preferences of LLMs
| 2024-02-02T02:43:10 | 2024-06-02T04:48:36 |
David Rozado
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
I report here a comprehensive analysis about the political preferences
embedded in Large Language Models (LLMs). Namely, I administer 11 political
orientation tests, designed to identify the political preferences of the test
taker, to 24 state-of-the-art conversational LLMs, both closed and open source.
When probed with questions/statements with political connotations, most
conversational LLMs tend to generate responses that are diagnosed by most
political test instruments as manifesting preferences for left-of-center
viewpoints. This does not appear to be the case for five additional base (i.e.
foundation) models upon which LLMs optimized for conversation with humans are
built. However, the weak performance of the base models at coherently answering
the tests' questions makes this subset of results inconclusive. Finally, I
demonstrate that LLMs can be steered towards specific locations in the
political spectrum through Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) with only modest
amounts of politically aligned data, suggesting SFT's potential to embed
political orientation in LLMs. With LLMs beginning to partially displace
traditional information sources like search engines and Wikipedia, the societal
implications of political biases embedded in LLMs are substantial.
|
[
-0.6771733761,
-0.9024825692,
0.802791059,
-0.0710224733,
-0.3167319596,
0.1719477326,
-0.6699185371,
-0.0949250683,
0.4417320192,
0.8639572263,
-0.4476888478,
-0.5047153234,
-0.7029120922,
-0.158454746,
-0.2552990019,
0.8866119385,
0.4216471314,
0.1532285511,
-0.0847169161,
-0.0585784838,
-0.1833999902,
-0.7459684014,
-0.3083554208,
-0.7079108953,
0.5638634562,
0.6274798512,
1.0128461123,
0.724983573,
0.3151318729,
0.1797279567,
-0.135647133,
-0.0817049369,
-0.7905980945,
0.0556358621,
-0.4284571707,
-0.7500808835,
-0.255774647,
0.6218540072,
0.2804354429,
0.6657524705,
0.0251226723,
-0.0650114194,
-0.132686466,
1.0466548204,
-0.5346090198,
-0.1317640692,
-0.9768520594,
-0.0563381538,
-0.2493802756,
-0.3985553682,
-0.4229083955,
-0.5222705007,
0.2592684329,
-0.0793266222,
-0.0255598743,
0.0163492691,
0.6227210164,
0.0336387381,
-0.8511580825,
-0.2804646194,
-0.5360141993,
0.9237043262,
-0.4219681025,
0.4761218727,
0.393065542,
0.189813897,
-0.4187196195,
0.0308898203,
-0.4029864669,
-0.2647268176,
0.0839133635,
0.0099802222,
-0.0740626901,
0.3280761838,
-0.100575,
0.3059870005,
-0.3254097104,
0.2866452038,
-0.1257015914,
0.0831613615,
0.5959142447,
0.1619203091,
-0.0086020129,
-0.5819607377,
-0.207970351,
0.0971926823,
-0.9463226795,
0.0798462555,
0.8653149605,
0.5189207792,
-0.0357908122,
0.9234871268,
-0.2805127203,
0.7169163823,
0.4292169809,
0.0624992028,
-0.1374449432,
-0.2624817789,
-0.2094994634,
-0.2003331482,
0.8496121168,
0.5643107891,
0.7064768076,
0.2207001895,
-0.2263298333,
0.2161351591,
0.0675655156,
-0.6606257558,
-0.1125884727,
0.2788464129,
-0.6043776274,
-0.3626751006,
0.0933962986,
-0.6300725937,
-0.9104650617,
-0.7671111226,
-0.2309202105,
-0.1173885688,
-0.2220261246,
0.1162511632,
0.0362007059,
0.3113135993,
0.1968899816,
-1.0117077827,
0.0256561507,
1.1287617683,
0.7258487344,
-0.5579570532,
0.2683686912,
-0.4055931568,
-0.3203709722,
-0.51459831,
0.72747612,
-0.9120383859,
-0.4086297452,
0.1798426062,
0.0463769734,
0.1581389755,
-0.5988023877,
0.1101515815,
-0.5581972599,
0.2937843502,
-0.6881644726,
-0.5237029195,
0.2289483398,
0.5453338027,
-0.3901494741,
0.6869627237,
-0.2800590992,
-0.6514598131,
0.3365310729,
-0.7590733767,
-0.0212479848,
-0.4154168069,
-0.5021288395,
0.1450558007,
0.1072330624,
-0.1668520421,
0.6827476621,
-0.2118859142,
0.6626057625,
-0.4582013488,
-0.3379258513,
0.4675057828,
-0.2804652154,
0.8187381625,
0.1111119464,
-0.4142726958,
0.4048765898,
-0.7643479109,
-0.3474909067,
-0.1107540056,
-0.5270017982,
-0.3632346392,
0.3951975703,
-0.0985049382,
-0.0221657529,
0.539255023,
-0.5729469061,
0.1085961312,
-0.3902933896,
0.4299744666,
1.3006836176,
-0.2264536768,
0.9239788651,
-0.1932703704,
0.4010085762,
-0.0081442855,
0.1602450758,
0.5050397515,
-0.3874953389,
-0.8451207876,
-0.0774132833,
0.0311980005,
0.6327007413,
-0.1004900187,
0.5852313042,
-0.1204634607,
-0.4917794168,
-0.15787673,
-0.0391714908,
-0.0954046771,
0.0161434188,
-0.1693531722,
0.175387457,
-0.4428312182,
-1.4121359587,
-0.3700603545,
-0.2520009875,
-0.0557955056,
0.6016839743,
0.5702070594,
-0.1089105755,
0.8437896371,
-0.3766945004,
0.1623565704,
-0.0768190101,
-0.3925390244,
0.3166354299,
-0.0267480705,
0.3792536855,
-0.7943195701,
-0.4151844084,
0.1979608834,
-0.1686927825,
-0.075462833,
0.2290736437,
-0.3213337958,
0.155912146,
0.2961412668,
-0.4815731943,
0.1660028249,
0.8778812885,
-0.4258379638,
0.2414305061,
0.168356806,
0.1984224617,
-1.0793629885,
-0.216680035,
-0.0181974452,
-0.3543890417,
-0.4948952794,
-0.2192196846,
-0.1197978184,
0.3558663726,
-0.4858385324,
0.3076419532,
-0.1599340439,
-0.0737216547,
-0.3465232551,
0.4287131131,
-0.3302417099,
0.0380034894,
0.0982926488,
0.7537924647,
0.2892962396,
-0.3914941847,
0.3824139237,
0.0694023892,
-0.2454678118,
0.7180802822,
-0.4648911655,
0.3598064482,
-0.3030853868,
0.2042169571,
-1.1471256018,
-0.4105817378,
0.101998955,
-0.1541923881,
-0.0372927636,
-0.1261695772,
-0.2294089794,
0.1605862826,
-0.4117860198,
-0.2172856778,
0.5086237192,
-0.5274049044,
0.3258444667,
0.7105420828,
0.1112140715,
-0.6522533894,
-0.5579900146,
-0.0991234556,
-0.4213793874,
-0.4165894091,
-0.0618158877,
0.008467989,
-0.6743975282,
-0.1018572077,
0.1858561933,
0.2375279367,
-0.0350380167,
0.4288746417,
0.2081629783,
-0.296792388,
0.2010051757,
-0.1164842993,
0.0083187465,
-0.0428420417,
-0.1553502083,
0.7628193498,
-0.3290902078,
-0.3110075593,
-0.1032228842,
0.4159072638,
0.9085239768,
-0.1113158464,
0.6848020554,
-0.0066317846,
-0.1844575852,
0.0273220129,
-0.5910477042,
-0.1883547306,
-0.4695305824,
0.409078896,
-0.053071361,
-1.1352028847,
0.451207757,
-0.1024853736,
0.1312380284,
0.3021168113,
0.8793464303,
-0.1589478105,
0.7952629328,
0.5812878609,
-0.2863188684,
0.6024523377,
-0.0200786963,
0.3655482233,
-0.4508218765,
-0.0952416956,
-0.6622204185,
-0.4424443841,
-1.0378232002,
-0.0729838386,
0.2656405568,
-0.5095744133,
-0.6538924575,
-0.1129056513,
-0.7129740119,
0.7992407084,
0.3755417168,
0.0992766321,
0.0953841135,
0.053300783,
0.2182177156,
-0.3053042293,
-0.3059352934,
-0.8009322882,
1.0337409973,
0.2954010069,
0.8919793963,
0.0149168605,
0.496157825,
0.0951162502,
0.2019632757,
-0.8414865136,
0.6793550253,
-0.4008843601,
-0.6971721649,
-0.3400288224,
-0.1568582207,
-0.7202253938,
0.1215420291,
-0.2927944958,
-0.6220043302,
0.235859558,
0.0032755618,
-0.0792808831,
0.5395032763,
-0.1804168224,
0.6691473126,
-0.3318970203,
-0.1743428856,
-0.2686523497,
-0.7136858702,
0.3999645412,
0.0302676708,
0.0880463272,
-0.551459372,
-0.1971593648,
0.733084619,
0.080697,
0.9386591911,
-0.2361131012,
-0.0695623532,
-0.1486674398,
-0.1395535171,
0.313693732,
-0.0167923383,
-0.3269590735,
0.0702564642,
-0.0316439532,
-0.1682954729,
-0.3043640554,
1.0322568417,
-1.0307792425,
-0.9969522953,
-0.3822196722,
-0.6416062117,
-0.0651438013,
0.1504422724,
0.1605962068,
0.0028039261,
-0.3377223313,
0.5871469975,
0.8703005314,
-0.1690292954,
-0.1034164354,
0.2432016134,
-0.3794757724,
-0.0936324224,
0.3676932454,
0.2248635143,
0.5569140911,
0.2399056107,
0.5684529543,
-0.4050906599,
-0.3830501735,
-0.1499831229,
0.261746496,
-0.70271945,
-0.0097698905,
-0.4183659554,
-0.049001772,
0.1063688844,
-0.4633563459,
-0.6662321091,
-0.2827509344,
-0.5323425531,
-0.1060795411,
0.334644258,
0.8987617493,
0.0852850229,
0.4236957133,
0.0808802173,
0.2462762296,
0.0723102614,
0.41866979,
-0.7196600437,
-0.4734741747,
0.3036943674,
0.3441542089,
-0.3314152062,
-1.0087844133,
-0.0587870516,
-0.0282287933,
0.1023212373,
0.6445741057,
0.2192031145,
0.3690986931,
-0.5256303549,
1.0251067877,
-0.0625990778,
-0.6157270074,
0.6181487441,
-0.5498971343,
-0.0530115999,
0.6421441436,
0.5651486516,
-0.2971835434,
-0.7107948661,
-0.3023639619,
-0.4019756019,
0.4044303,
-0.3020018935,
0.6549383998,
-0.2896161377,
0.4829852581,
0.1733855009,
0.2315795273,
-0.4923303723,
-0.3141881526,
-0.0641017854,
-0.054645896,
-0.208915934,
-0.2560931742,
-0.5718089342,
-0.2349352688,
0.5152775645,
-0.1599741578,
-0.0312077664,
0.0202095062,
0.5310364962,
-0.2090489864,
0.6017739773,
0.66708529,
0.8221573234,
-0.3030361533,
0.3085876405,
-0.1669242084,
-0.1086048335,
0.4357053339,
-0.4341599643,
-0.2759875357,
-0.1322257221,
-0.3900289536,
0.519276619,
-0.116823338,
-0.1354174763,
0.6290953159,
0.0224251896,
-0.1282356083,
-0.382029146,
-0.000129034,
0.6228759885,
0.2710759044,
0.2297401875,
0.1246701702,
-0.1744838655,
-0.8925777078,
-0.0718979463,
1.2183594704,
-0.351303786,
-0.2465793937,
0.5360186696,
0.2557553053,
-0.588783443,
0.309494555,
0.0114917774,
-0.7307685018,
0.3570354283,
0.3596096933,
0.5593899488,
-0.1041591614,
0.1438278258,
0.0415535271,
0.4750423729,
0.1909075528,
0.2640385628,
0.2967944443,
-0.8685045838,
-0.1613979191,
-0.393155992,
-0.6603873372,
0.2849595845,
-0.349026829,
0.4251862764,
-0.593492806,
-0.4093716145,
-0.0236333515,
0.2627441287,
-0.4016808867,
-0.0681544915,
0.1181745082,
0.7925316691,
-0.9365658164,
0.6466241479,
0.4763774872,
0.2852833867,
-0.2211790532,
-0.1235126555,
0.2509630024,
-0.8388850689,
0.4576045573,
-0.0200965051,
-0.2018139362,
-0.3830949664,
-0.8088451624,
-0.5935611129,
0.7480306029,
0.7989207506,
-0.6434406638,
-0.0233620498,
0.4461084604,
0.2862341702,
-0.5484835505,
0.1217169017,
0.7616248131,
0.586509645,
-0.3027574718,
-0.7506510615,
-0.0348296463,
0.1881112009,
-0.2004162967,
0.3828802109,
-0.9592612982,
0.837346375,
0.0661408678,
-0.0321114734,
-0.2084884048,
0.495783776,
0.2975002527,
0.1309033334,
0.6397283077,
-0.0964844227,
0.8105763793,
-0.2490951121,
0.9218546748,
-0.5879680514,
0.0917868763,
0.7250106335,
-0.2407131493,
0.8532790542,
0.9133425355,
-0.0137540577,
0.2846826911,
0.9505094886,
0.2996418178,
0.4427620769,
0.3947109878,
-0.1294813156,
-0.3817635775,
-0.3201902807,
-0.181834057,
0.598289609,
0.3112405241,
-0.2527842224,
0.0139009412,
-0.2795593143,
0.1974098831,
0.3943378925,
0.0592155978,
0.396722883,
0.112819165,
-0.6692999601,
0.2349644303,
-0.1730047464,
0.926533401,
-0.5718880296,
0.1510475278,
-0.2659678757,
-0.0538709313,
-0.3630331755,
-1.1023284197,
0.2602974176,
-0.0141533511,
-0.2745151818,
-0.2290542424,
0.6870261431,
-0.4063317478,
-0.0142191816,
0.339992553,
0.6125356555,
0.1685388833,
-0.0792862326,
-0.4928753376,
0.2715371847,
0.1230316982,
-0.7386384606,
0.4496677518,
0.3697693348,
-0.042422425,
0.481921792,
0.7973206043,
0.2697983682,
-0.1001949087,
-0.1474810541,
0.8070648313,
-0.5779333115,
-0.2161393762,
-1.0380797386,
0.2431123555,
-0.0722162649,
-0.2222738117,
0.6083416939,
0.6400386095,
0.6707780361,
0.1153009832,
0.8637868762,
0.167367816,
0.3587047458,
-0.470133692,
0.9095614552,
-0.3866169155,
0.118447341,
0.0710716546,
-0.8779479861,
-0.1529030651,
0.7961614728,
-0.5952769518,
-0.0920572579,
0.3599331677,
0.935403049,
-0.297051996,
0.0355194919,
0.4520951807,
0.028854236,
0.3257440031,
0.5166448951,
1.1519801617,
0.2283443362,
0.1212841272,
-0.3955101073,
-0.26163131,
-0.1243207455,
-0.9073259234,
-1.1045179367,
-0.6534032822,
-0.1014494821,
-0.3529499769,
-0.0065545896,
1.1831344366,
0.6411938071,
-0.5933589935,
-0.43958655,
0.1357929707,
0.2565577626,
0.7076453567,
-0.2672592998,
0.1705678254,
0.0644706562,
-0.9023205638,
0.1413717866,
0.2775193155,
-0.0835213885,
-0.5672745109,
-0.0822081864,
-0.2890596092,
0.3997874558,
0.6743090153,
-0.0575841889,
-1.0458288193,
-0.8627620339,
0.4164010584,
-0.2735410929,
0.2944253087,
0.7123668194,
-0.3283788264,
0.268036902,
0.4867797196,
0.4125898778,
0.1094308123,
0.0578847788,
0.457877636,
-0.2593527138,
0.1725302935,
0.1790380478,
0.2142514735,
0.4661339819,
-0.3547381759,
0.3638381064,
-0.07994432,
-0.881552875,
-0.8335724473,
0.396525979,
-0.9681302309,
0.0483825654,
1.4941030741,
0.3789816499,
-0.1737061441,
0.0645636246,
-0.347967118,
0.0729098022,
-0.4646579027,
0.46185112,
0.7717679739,
-0.3106887043,
0.0287996493,
-0.8446801305,
0.4310406148,
0.2668004632,
-0.5150873065,
0.167322889,
0.4753161967,
0.519256711,
0.1478509456,
0.7872248888,
-0.1156872362,
0.0022291455,
-0.5373395681,
-0.2991538942,
0.3681829274,
-0.2297950238,
-0.409735024,
0.0768736154,
0.1079714224,
-0.1716037244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01788v1
|
LitLLM: A Toolkit for Scientific Literature Review
| 2024-02-02T02:41:28 | 2024-02-02T02:41:28 |
Shubham Agarwal, Issam H. Laradji, Laurent Charlin, Christopher Pal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Conducting literature reviews for scientific papers is essential for
understanding research, its limitations, and building on existing work. It is a
tedious task which makes an automatic literature review generator appealing.
Unfortunately, many existing works that generate such reviews using Large
Language Models (LLMs) have significant limitations. They tend to
hallucinate-generate non-actual information-and ignore the latest research they
have not been trained on. To address these limitations, we propose a toolkit
that operates on Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) principles, specialized
prompting and instructing techniques with the help of LLMs. Our system first
initiates a web search to retrieve relevant papers by summarizing user-provided
abstracts into keywords using an off-the-shelf LLM. Authors can enhance the
search by supplementing it with relevant papers or keywords, contributing to a
tailored retrieval process. Second, the system re-ranks the retrieved papers
based on the user-provided abstract. Finally, the related work section is
generated based on the re-ranked results and the abstract. There is a
substantial reduction in time and effort for literature review compared to
traditional methods, establishing our toolkit as an efficient alternative. Our
open-source toolkit is accessible at https://github.com/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM
and Huggingface space (https://huggingface.co/spaces/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM)
with the video demo at https://youtu.be/E2ggOZBAFw0.
|
[
-0.2414996475,
-0.3831732869,
0.5461854935,
0.2886466384,
-0.4209168553,
0.2873185277,
-0.1185953096,
-0.3274858296,
0.3308332264,
0.8044418693,
-0.220248431,
-0.4736260474,
0.038673263,
0.3276071846,
-0.4657469392,
1.4454805851,
0.0614544563,
0.2713878155,
-0.2373519391,
-0.0893379971,
0.084982276,
-0.0770088434,
-0.367154479,
-0.5344026685,
0.9748474956,
0.0681276992,
0.7091625333,
-0.1498861909,
0.5700395107,
0.2296137959,
-0.3833850324,
0.4629887044,
-0.6456913948,
0.3855130672,
-0.2453848124,
-0.3139334321,
-0.5825412869,
0.0578341857,
0.6761215925,
0.6742138863,
0.0501724109,
0.2493576705,
0.1061227843,
0.8554803729,
-0.4032264054,
-0.1971844137,
-0.7049310207,
0.2411498576,
-0.0827895179,
-0.6747812033,
-0.5556006432,
-0.6721439362,
-0.090699546,
-0.5982211828,
0.280679673,
0.314135015,
0.5202903748,
0.061765451,
-0.3602973819,
-0.4477552474,
-0.7540127635,
0.7640218139,
-0.6424731612,
0.1151562557,
0.2153054625,
0.2878223658,
-0.3076614738,
-0.6729310155,
-0.4082908034,
-0.44209373,
-0.3062577248,
0.3816617429,
0.4969686866,
0.1724676639,
0.2926790118,
0.5090102553,
-0.6186912656,
-0.2643952966,
-0.6712406278,
-0.0858472809,
0.7824462652,
0.2300867736,
0.1722550243,
-0.4297136366,
-0.3599469364,
0.0187394675,
-1.065215826,
-0.0728387535,
0.3572107852,
-0.0819616094,
0.435148716,
0.8349846005,
0.2175198197,
0.5124735236,
-0.1669866592,
-0.3163340688,
0.2725328505,
-0.4075330794,
-0.1502006352,
0.119719848,
0.5823594332,
0.5566696525,
-0.3772824705,
0.0327624641,
-0.6281885505,
-0.3342772722,
0.2420799881,
-1.0256605148,
-0.0463903733,
0.2875755429,
-0.5392615795,
-0.4994933605,
0.0644745305,
-0.6930648088,
-0.6713598371,
-0.1097990125,
0.4037376046,
-0.1714307219,
-0.2711853981,
-0.0137028256,
-0.0652034208,
0.1186116785,
0.5872578025,
-0.2687287629,
0.157247901,
0.4437665045,
0.9216479659,
-0.2599210143,
-0.0070772339,
-0.6775963306,
0.146870032,
-0.5031430125,
0.6520903707,
-0.2078685015,
-0.6668450236,
0.0744474828,
-0.0275031962,
0.1530795544,
-0.4502916634,
0.424818784,
-0.8298648596,
0.3398646414,
0.0059511429,
-0.504370749,
-0.010725677,
0.2337280512,
-0.7231470346,
1.1169141531,
0.0247932002,
-1.0152741671,
0.1799194366,
-0.5835098028,
-0.2036347985,
0.3447165191,
-0.1837479472,
-0.5115949512,
0.2707945704,
0.098255299,
0.232952252,
-0.4702785611,
0.4685077071,
-0.1887874454,
-0.487064153,
0.2811268568,
0.1153667346,
0.8390114307,
0.5651068687,
-0.0724706277,
0.335365206,
-0.6293721795,
0.2119023204,
-0.0396745577,
-0.410774976,
-0.3843760192,
0.0077132117,
0.3896834254,
-0.1382667571,
0.1185118034,
-0.593796432,
0.2467115521,
-0.5926516652,
0.1788498461,
0.4560238421,
0.2089104652,
0.45293504,
-0.5483695865,
0.6019372344,
-0.4165033996,
0.0729753077,
-0.3812599778,
-0.1459164172,
-0.6871712208,
-0.0227468628,
0.4017868638,
0.2630963027,
-1.0249017477,
0.3905552626,
0.0159633141,
-0.627199769,
-0.6040291786,
0.3417075276,
0.3506414592,
0.334202677,
0.2376990318,
-0.0919959247,
-0.5651643872,
-0.500911653,
-0.1805930585,
-0.3655730188,
-0.2152501196,
0.3837240338,
0.4207942188,
-0.298804462,
1.0117026567,
-0.4205926955,
-0.3743417561,
-0.2422113419,
0.2226823568,
0.2885368168,
0.1920272261,
0.2057415396,
-0.8452026248,
-0.4546775222,
0.1006198078,
-0.7842980623,
-0.7248693109,
-0.1511242241,
0.2396550924,
0.2896535695,
0.618317008,
-0.3896451592,
0.3875492811,
0.3245255649,
-0.1692723632,
0.7459936142,
-0.1376206875,
0.0925530419,
-0.8915018439,
0.5772459507,
-0.3601765931,
-0.1382672638,
-0.342725724,
0.0938345641,
0.0072788852,
-0.1592981517,
-0.3076051772,
0.7820051908,
-0.6333550811,
-0.1965467334,
-0.4562661946,
0.2289850414,
0.2853137851,
-0.1065129563,
-0.0315890647,
0.7713646889,
-0.0670297369,
-0.4222177267,
0.1798843592,
-0.0726755559,
-0.4242479801,
0.4480870962,
-0.7133359313,
-0.002377596,
-0.1316119581,
0.315087378,
-0.8255499005,
-0.201552242,
-0.1779679209,
-0.2853463292,
0.2659509778,
0.0798399821,
-0.6885307431,
-0.2982587218,
-0.7566424012,
0.3193037212,
0.5188960433,
-0.5657517314,
0.6427392364,
0.3513461947,
-0.4915570915,
-0.5280334949,
-0.2321262211,
0.1137543395,
0.002535739,
-0.491895169,
0.4370018244,
-0.39964059,
-0.4369973838,
0.0518620573,
-0.0191284548,
0.2293429524,
-0.2894835174,
0.2067614198,
0.3992759585,
0.1507726461,
0.3483458161,
0.0865203142,
0.1864460558,
0.0449445583,
0.1084473729,
0.2808196843,
-0.2153536528,
-0.3806129694,
0.4049524963,
0.0152918296,
0.4938163161,
-0.0360683016,
-0.092818819,
0.8416134119,
0.0313193686,
-0.2717281878,
-0.8400945663,
-0.4630767405,
-0.4318464696,
0.1840794683,
-0.0214189235,
-1.030856967,
0.4138203859,
-0.0790595263,
0.4205343127,
0.2796967924,
0.5614371896,
-0.1880960017,
1.0129320621,
0.4610161185,
0.1955035329,
0.2488163859,
-0.0927723274,
0.1853613853,
-1.1092416048,
-0.2743987441,
-0.4499820173,
-0.0431412421,
-0.3635153472,
-0.5713772178,
0.8209334016,
0.1167299822,
0.1562530249,
-0.2064359188,
-0.7450870872,
0.4693760872,
0.1904104352,
-0.155962646,
0.5628287792,
0.1426121742,
-0.5746244192,
-0.1509186178,
-0.740470767,
-0.6555650234,
0.9473593235,
0.2458630204,
1.1803513765,
-0.2724665701,
0.8297111988,
0.2518588901,
0.830175221,
-0.6986971498,
0.8371374607,
0.3103334904,
-0.6484940052,
-0.191719234,
-0.3849747777,
-1.0810083151,
0.4770616889,
-0.2139663994,
-0.0718775317,
-0.0950471088,
0.0073470087,
-0.2263929397,
0.3355155289,
-0.2476342469,
0.0351391248,
-0.4827951193,
-0.7860196829,
-0.2805338204,
-0.6385109425,
0.6507765055,
-0.1489161104,
0.36596632,
0.0099529754,
-0.1737961322,
0.7004293799,
-0.486964047,
0.7497012019,
-0.2516461313,
-0.0846292526,
0.3856742382,
0.2478804141,
0.1592470855,
0.3685927093,
-0.1353498101,
-0.453746438,
0.1922496408,
-0.0766832754,
-0.3477503359,
0.847366035,
-0.5138523579,
-0.5796167254,
-0.8192408681,
-0.7523111105,
0.0145882377,
0.3935444355,
0.0985554531,
0.1321817786,
-0.3352902532,
0.3568508029,
0.7503938675,
-0.4410966039,
0.2678334117,
0.7986397743,
-1.1768885851,
-0.7480995655,
0.7065008283,
0.1021191254,
-0.0682797283,
0.1515464038,
0.3291946352,
-0.1926838458,
-0.604464829,
-0.2839161456,
0.3625602424,
-0.5360972881,
-0.4551461339,
-0.6679984331,
-0.4209764898,
-0.1914840937,
-0.1384757459,
-0.0347541161,
-0.4020803869,
-0.1009645611,
0.0381872766,
0.4279038906,
1.1058712006,
0.0231631882,
-0.0011737015,
-0.6728214622,
0.2402984649,
0.2344890684,
0.2900055349,
-0.0785476118,
-0.4195147753,
-0.2727399766,
-0.4566491842,
-0.3431884646,
-0.7371405959,
0.6558863521,
0.1316182613,
0.3679944575,
0.2077653855,
0.2102681249,
0.3876867294,
-0.5224344134,
0.8435432911,
0.1915688217,
-0.3605464995,
0.5246208906,
-0.3505088985,
0.4788836837,
0.6656243801,
0.2479356527,
-0.3973174095,
-0.4799616933,
-0.3421858549,
-1.0373283625,
0.4296183288,
0.0895965248,
-0.150409773,
0.2360217422,
0.2162830681,
0.1938338578,
0.3936921954,
-0.8823024035,
0.2159295976,
-0.0828256309,
0.1459507793,
0.0106269857,
-0.4218197763,
-0.5167554617,
-0.0553132258,
0.9629826546,
-0.3517795503,
-0.0859443769,
0.623316288,
-0.3320134878,
-0.4194703996,
0.3652587533,
0.5208870769,
0.5843175054,
-0.4708482623,
0.2879957557,
0.0877638236,
-0.5498049855,
0.0551637374,
0.199753508,
-0.6810619831,
0.2666751742,
0.1535173804,
0.233362481,
0.3545499742,
-0.7666788101,
0.2535994649,
-0.0712047964,
-0.2700221539,
-0.4266002774,
-0.0418256819,
0.2065386176,
-0.0119512891,
0.7670389414,
-0.1881037951,
0.3445661664,
-0.1573629826,
0.0187694393,
0.5751924515,
-0.1326909214,
-0.1945815086,
0.3630092144,
0.2885709703,
-0.3131541312,
0.0474852175,
-0.3273629844,
-0.4114146829,
0.3379184008,
0.3514419198,
0.8060920238,
-0.1705400795,
0.2092251927,
0.3098476827,
0.5458881855,
-0.0074931332,
0.3773307204,
0.1298605055,
-0.1368047595,
-0.5496417284,
-0.8209496737,
-0.6841000915,
0.3023680151,
-0.365853548,
0.4052919447,
-0.5582398176,
-0.1495173126,
-0.154997021,
0.2691194117,
-0.2246727645,
-0.1075292379,
-0.3775420785,
0.9110586643,
-0.4552147985,
0.6008147597,
0.6665354967,
-0.4215454161,
-0.5094475746,
-0.4355776608,
0.0931562036,
-0.3641858101,
0.6168193817,
0.1467211694,
-0.4191674292,
-0.3083787262,
-0.6437225342,
-0.6362763643,
1.2574338913,
-0.0358473361,
-0.5667396188,
0.0291426796,
-0.260784626,
0.8632895947,
-0.5450770855,
0.5675703883,
0.029843986,
0.4999471903,
0.1795303971,
-0.8927118182,
-0.0043584052,
-0.5678517818,
0.112307325,
-0.1459924132,
-0.5012634993,
0.6014626026,
-0.1460636556,
-0.0166161973,
0.3015819788,
0.3423241675,
0.6818811893,
0.7329429984,
0.6051316857,
0.2441427112,
0.6200265884,
0.2304668576,
0.7834604979,
-0.3917429745,
0.2835859358,
1.0340687037,
-0.8420315981,
0.6513811946,
0.7885405421,
-0.1134711727,
0.3654736578,
0.4885736704,
-0.0377165116,
0.2770254612,
0.3712289035,
-0.3341526389,
0.0924876556,
-0.3908267319,
-0.5335751772,
-0.1012232453,
0.4825368226,
-0.5932504535,
-0.2743515372,
0.0782590434,
-0.1299479753,
0.2344219834,
-0.4131690264,
0.8541936874,
0.3328663707,
-0.824313283,
0.6200072169,
-0.1936423779,
0.6907838583,
-0.7037200332,
-0.0953880921,
-0.1296330988,
-0.1186224744,
-0.662084341,
-0.7343037128,
0.1790875494,
0.060615737,
-0.1506946236,
-0.3563902974,
1.0808907747,
-0.543967247,
-0.6366307735,
0.2964971364,
0.604960978,
0.3298004568,
0.5319699645,
-0.6937875748,
0.2474518567,
-0.008655089,
-0.5931523442,
0.3222041428,
0.1468562931,
-0.0892906561,
0.5650979877,
0.7572668791,
0.5418410301,
-0.2165380567,
0.3139880598,
0.9446353912,
-0.5352534652,
-0.3458750546,
-0.3590377867,
0.2487742752,
-0.3374109864,
0.0740175769,
0.7615750432,
0.8592083454,
0.591160655,
-0.1373499334,
0.8002920151,
-0.0082865981,
0.8655289412,
-0.45966506,
0.8685245514,
-0.6512352228,
0.688365519,
-0.2438146174,
-1.1491601467,
-0.5895667076,
0.6657301784,
-0.2673884332,
0.106998764,
0.765935719,
1.06308496,
0.1282396019,
-0.1591713428,
0.2998553216,
0.2636466324,
0.3885052204,
-0.0102477185,
0.8801090121,
0.005444421,
0.6020324826,
0.0253227763,
-0.1017638668,
-0.5996867418,
-1.1838427782,
-1.0473461151,
-0.3486426175,
-0.0523793884,
-0.6193462014,
0.0297155008,
0.9879373908,
0.5346746445,
-0.5750157237,
-0.4009656608,
0.1205115095,
0.2077857256,
0.1828681827,
-0.2802188396,
0.3640495241,
-0.6904483438,
-0.4329961538,
0.3612402678,
0.5171710253,
-0.1585747153,
-0.8358353376,
-0.2127454281,
-0.1509512812,
0.062106289,
0.6179084778,
0.2596086264,
-0.7665781379,
0.2034477443,
0.1927124709,
-0.2911803126,
-0.1670544893,
1.0391073227,
-0.7076807022,
0.8180003762,
0.7068589926,
0.4525977969,
0.7391412854,
-0.3706984222,
0.3653494716,
-0.676273942,
-0.1647718847,
0.7520342469,
0.3691444099,
0.5247856975,
-0.3066495955,
0.8207088709,
-0.0402419604,
-0.9521519542,
-1.253606081,
0.0365746617,
-0.8572557569,
-0.1410644501,
1.1424595118,
0.0266850926,
-0.2516084611,
-0.1689586341,
-0.7426718473,
-0.1099137738,
-0.2589911222,
0.8650765419,
0.4995687902,
-0.1387055367,
-0.0463656336,
-0.5113939047,
0.7236269712,
0.6501205564,
-0.7885634899,
-0.1045998409,
0.5476446748,
0.2961498797,
0.358887583,
0.7590316534,
-0.4349248111,
0.4962998033,
-0.519603014,
0.3345977366,
-0.1248718351,
-0.1534414589,
-0.4018383622,
0.2788043022,
0.4059292376,
0.8274992704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01097v1
|
Let's Negotiate! A Survey of Negotiation Dialogue Systems
| 2024-02-02T02:12:46 | 2024-02-02T02:12:46 |
Haolan Zhan, Yufei Wang, Tao Feng, Yuncheng Hua, Suraj Sharma, Zhuang Li, Lizhen Qu, Zhaleh Semnani Azad, Ingrid Zukerman, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Negotiation is a crucial ability in human communication. Recently, there has
been a resurgent research interest in negotiation dialogue systems, whose goal
is to create intelligent agents that can assist people in resolving conflicts
or reaching agreements. Although there have been many explorations into
negotiation dialogue systems, a systematic review of this task has not been
performed to date. We aim to fill this gap by investigating recent studies in
the field of negotiation dialogue systems, and covering benchmarks, evaluations
and methodologies within the literature. We also discuss potential future
directions, including multi-modal, multi-party and cross-cultural negotiation
scenarios. Our goal is to provide the community with a systematic overview of
negotiation dialogue systems and to inspire future research.
|
[
-0.8700274825,
-0.1806887537,
0.5555164218,
0.0793894008,
-0.1164074168,
0.4143511951,
-0.1884909272,
-0.8002102971,
0.6668807864,
0.3029690087,
-0.5322301984,
-0.0825006813,
-0.678381443,
0.2386201024,
0.0049143629,
0.4250098169,
0.3730815947,
0.3182837963,
0.1031283811,
-0.3779774606,
-0.5524666309,
-0.5744648576,
-0.9513738155,
-0.446557343,
0.5241585374,
0.4133114219,
0.7680331469,
-0.2513679266,
0.623700738,
0.4598296881,
-0.2738817334,
-0.0929348841,
-0.2085467279,
0.7870576978,
-0.4496930242,
-0.1113210917,
-0.4423761666,
0.2875066698,
0.257908076,
0.7920757532,
-0.1668663025,
0.0695985407,
-0.2010391206,
0.4516720176,
-0.4280698597,
0.1560251564,
-0.724206984,
0.3117544949,
0.1395744532,
0.070710592,
-0.2207590789,
-0.7338092327,
0.4340613782,
-0.7151466608,
-0.1473162919,
0.0816028416,
0.5879529119,
0.0506589599,
-0.7333132029,
-0.2111627609,
-0.7000994086,
0.4915322363,
-0.3917039931,
0.3054727018,
0.3946929574,
0.696203351,
-0.4129262567,
-0.9229235053,
-0.3094757497,
-0.2948669493,
-0.1494969428,
0.5012011528,
-0.1244694889,
0.2002315074,
0.2457754463,
0.1001291946,
-0.3977924883,
-0.179148376,
-0.6124464869,
-0.332739085,
0.9257507324,
0.2089778185,
0.3195947111,
0.000702678,
-0.4755631387,
0.0820553005,
-0.1607081145,
0.1353372484,
0.2686558962,
0.2941799164,
0.2812331319,
0.2877098918,
-0.6701793075,
0.5051727891,
0.0692797825,
0.0803008974,
-0.3231392205,
-0.50745821,
-0.1344217956,
-0.2347753942,
0.878719449,
0.6641973853,
0.067055501,
-0.0682655871,
-0.2180404216,
0.171362415,
0.3201850951,
-0.4934156835,
0.0759355277,
0.1718693972,
-0.6698023677,
-0.2186831385,
-0.0408919454,
-0.6621710658,
-0.2385695577,
-0.2766003013,
0.1412971914,
-0.132703349,
-0.6770282984,
0.249800548,
-0.6758567691,
0.3950586319,
0.445363909,
-0.622276485,
0.9902313352,
0.4216032028,
0.4581874311,
0.3954983354,
-0.3059705794,
-0.1376734227,
-0.2118719071,
-0.4773987234,
0.9307983518,
-0.6804763675,
-0.7611754537,
0.0422107503,
-0.4514875412,
0.0557245389,
-0.4817663431,
0.686024487,
-0.5687109232,
0.1551566869,
-0.4983985126,
-0.188210398,
0.0549556725,
0.8822622299,
-0.6646524668,
0.4137148559,
-0.0487251803,
-0.2352749258,
0.2696551085,
-0.5224187374,
-0.2017856389,
0.3966192305,
-0.3368772268,
0.0160303321,
0.0730427727,
-0.0521850847,
0.0730877519,
-0.6140652299,
0.2761809826,
-0.0142187467,
-0.368775636,
0.7366658449,
-0.0235183779,
0.5577556491,
0.6100534797,
0.0804354548,
0.2869120836,
-0.0424843207,
0.0937016159,
0.0245860852,
-0.2103108168,
0.0605093241,
-0.0746530816,
-0.0757319257,
0.3939569294,
0.2952052355,
-0.6170617342,
0.6565473676,
0.0240241792,
0.4691092074,
0.5803285837,
-0.0054180208,
0.6082706451,
-0.5557268858,
0.8252238035,
-0.2989691794,
0.5478850603,
0.0281564333,
-0.5487503409,
-0.7892072201,
0.2591739297,
0.3166496456,
0.3031618595,
-0.8820474148,
0.0518904775,
-0.1465742737,
-0.4474746883,
-0.3029342294,
-0.5091718435,
0.4510895014,
-0.0301524736,
0.004048435,
-0.6416530013,
-0.4388326705,
-0.61670506,
-0.4087772369,
-0.5104985237,
0.0408061966,
0.1696462184,
-0.0336581171,
0.1519478709,
0.969881475,
-0.2138195634,
-0.3656675518,
-0.4563141763,
0.3928091824,
-0.2748262584,
0.3043670058,
0.5663798451,
-0.7589648962,
-0.5869296789,
0.1328686178,
-0.4988824129,
0.411601454,
-0.0296705961,
-0.0765127167,
-0.0458418801,
0.8780758381,
-0.5486097336,
0.4988599718,
0.3081760108,
-0.2831496,
0.4508984685,
-0.0146020995,
0.46366781,
-0.6699987054,
-0.2045781314,
-0.1838555634,
-0.2268091142,
-0.7007784247,
-0.041557014,
-0.3358087242,
-0.6003251076,
-0.4135196507,
0.3111898303,
-0.6006264687,
-0.0045560943,
-0.0163396876,
0.3536369503,
-0.1643785834,
0.5114049315,
0.2807736695,
0.3478378356,
0.4409189522,
-0.6032899618,
0.4874975681,
0.5274522901,
-0.3389053941,
0.9280922413,
-0.5208483934,
0.3246322572,
0.0761555731,
0.8033332229,
-0.5617966652,
-0.3618645966,
0.8290694952,
-0.5703616738,
0.1371473968,
-0.3810997009,
0.0922262222,
-0.1791735142,
-0.2272349596,
0.6493800879,
0.2385177612,
0.0695882216,
0.5850282907,
0.413811028,
-0.4769695401,
-0.6205977798,
-0.269738853,
0.6298397183,
0.063226454,
-0.5770017505,
0.1676512063,
-0.1434883773,
-0.5912641883,
-0.2087334841,
-0.0005965867,
-0.2519076467,
-0.0006444826,
-0.0584614761,
-0.1988176405,
0.1654163897,
0.2023414671,
-0.0171163529,
-0.4877240956,
-0.0776527524,
-0.0270885658,
0.5304961801,
-0.1193073317,
-0.5081148744,
-0.4518453479,
0.8635705113,
0.6496059895,
-0.5166983008,
0.4159542918,
0.1249163449,
-0.347525686,
0.3894589245,
-0.5435055494,
-0.3797735274,
-0.4610363543,
0.1410863847,
-0.6142114401,
-0.7977082729,
0.535051465,
-0.7236579657,
0.0599179715,
0.051108107,
0.0863870457,
-0.1114885882,
1.1122888327,
0.5115500093,
0.0485319532,
0.499759078,
0.005928169,
0.4749063849,
-0.5676381588,
-0.2921595573,
-0.8141741157,
-0.5612900257,
-0.5962831378,
-0.2476978898,
0.4663245678,
0.097116679,
-0.0705329478,
0.2281475663,
-0.5360568762,
0.4444812238,
0.2189225554,
-0.0410084762,
0.3734320402,
-0.6437416673,
0.0460653417,
-0.0148465615,
-0.5507957935,
-0.4649598002,
0.5629967451,
0.2270651907,
0.5554617047,
0.4401895404,
0.6444321871,
0.0709810331,
0.2956254184,
-1.0803411007,
0.9875366092,
0.5821674466,
-0.6377318501,
-0.5485357046,
-0.2854183912,
-1.4417021275,
0.4732858539,
-0.1703543961,
-0.8163079023,
0.3963884413,
-0.4273045659,
-0.1256915629,
0.1015881673,
-0.3309618235,
0.5052999854,
-0.2921127975,
-0.0584074371,
-0.499055326,
-0.825245142,
0.1239527687,
0.53342098,
0.2020142972,
-0.2507421076,
0.0055772574,
0.6083884239,
-0.1665453315,
0.6878945827,
-0.1228329688,
0.0881228149,
0.1425878257,
0.29316172,
0.2918400466,
-0.1019669548,
-0.2624292076,
-0.0556594469,
0.1599166244,
-0.382900238,
-0.7378495336,
0.3101073802,
-0.5066916347,
-0.7952631116,
-0.8628444672,
-0.4879412949,
-0.3275979459,
0.0691815764,
0.0952020958,
0.1620445698,
-0.7437543273,
-0.2510938644,
0.2475132495,
0.4845332205,
0.4768906534,
0.4410526752,
-0.3857314587,
-0.3217079639,
0.9304714203,
0.2106640637,
0.2506471574,
-0.2706935108,
-0.0590177961,
-0.1748814732,
-0.631582737,
-0.1447145343,
0.0687462687,
-0.7140059471,
-0.3716656268,
-0.063758947,
-0.2112353146,
-0.5866253972,
-0.3846971691,
-0.2859406173,
-0.7572523952,
0.2615432739,
-0.1728363782,
0.1496583521,
1.2892255783,
-0.2460027784,
0.2368902415,
-0.8777675629,
0.1587650478,
0.5954653025,
0.4213561416,
-0.1983572096,
0.0576773174,
-0.2754167318,
-0.045012705,
-0.5694997311,
-1.0870069265,
0.3269306719,
-0.1596664786,
0.8320810199,
0.3744756579,
0.41937235,
0.5096105337,
-0.1344814748,
1.207211256,
0.4237905145,
-1.0612028837,
0.6457067728,
-0.3121725023,
0.0264597945,
0.6477552652,
0.3674024343,
-0.9291530252,
-0.4160730243,
-0.740888536,
-0.851941824,
0.6708245873,
0.1346418709,
0.0027654383,
0.2409662604,
0.181024,
-0.1512801051,
0.2635332346,
-0.5214040279,
-0.0409351438,
0.1371360123,
0.4259161353,
0.2353524119,
0.064199619,
-0.7623436451,
-0.1178986505,
0.381400764,
-0.2583194971,
0.0558804423,
0.1202066615,
-0.0078014615,
-0.2553633749,
0.6857571602,
0.454792887,
0.8440129757,
0.0068712244,
-0.2245792896,
0.2066163421,
-0.1931978166,
0.3120119274,
0.0761659518,
0.3727715015,
-0.1490094215,
-0.1117159352,
0.386326015,
0.1794155687,
-0.5004557371,
0.4080009758,
-0.8964256644,
-0.7339268923,
-0.1406572908,
-0.1785959452,
-0.1571453065,
0.7241504192,
0.229926765,
0.2434023768,
0.2945040166,
-0.7541729212,
-0.235808447,
0.6436997652,
-0.6391102076,
-0.0599520542,
0.096329309,
0.8826208711,
-0.7974467874,
0.6731095314,
-0.1491121501,
-0.703651607,
0.2616131902,
0.0411453918,
0.658616066,
-0.3098783493,
0.509690702,
0.0366666541,
0.365768373,
0.114149265,
0.3528754711,
-0.6626278162,
-0.8069121242,
-0.0152962571,
-0.139343828,
-1.203648448,
-0.3025377691,
-0.9901212454,
0.1239929944,
-0.3632104993,
-0.6258215308,
-0.2678751945,
0.1543681324,
-0.8606763482,
0.0320003703,
0.0240957011,
1.0662791729,
-0.6693128943,
0.5257575512,
0.7113659382,
-0.5635280013,
-0.4507990479,
0.0430602767,
-0.2506317198,
-0.0623160079,
0.4016568959,
-0.174469918,
-0.455919683,
-0.2473590672,
-0.8000000119,
-0.5438386202,
0.9452440739,
0.5882529616,
-0.2774299681,
-0.0744598657,
-0.0364161208,
0.3565046191,
-0.084320128,
0.5550692081,
1.0854892731,
0.8586342931,
0.1043955088,
-1.2392580509,
-0.1228588596,
-0.4449627995,
-0.0425423235,
-0.0328577571,
-1.2438520193,
0.6406753659,
0.2601962388,
-0.2097829133,
0.5005136728,
0.5542561412,
0.1478671134,
0.313480705,
0.5279762745,
0.1346375644,
0.6163397431,
-0.3867714703,
0.8468908072,
-0.1596471518,
0.1778293103,
0.7223446369,
-0.4636840224,
0.506044507,
0.5701597333,
-0.0861168727,
0.3635703325,
0.8034690619,
0.7376380563,
0.0237706825,
0.5244535208,
-0.5712817311,
-0.7605894208,
-0.5550518632,
-0.4525329769,
0.5241060853,
0.6103950739,
0.3139163852,
-0.2081723362,
-0.1862698793,
-0.2949462831,
0.0685940608,
0.0200776756,
1.081793189,
0.187419951,
-0.8428277373,
0.0418063886,
-0.1831874996,
0.4013512135,
-0.9338524938,
-0.2509556413,
-0.0942576081,
-0.4278922677,
-0.1263566613,
-0.6798954606,
0.0422527827,
-0.5812305808,
0.0947394371,
-0.8941372633,
0.9354165196,
-0.2092946321,
-0.0822449476,
0.4513558447,
0.698730886,
0.4646966159,
0.098821193,
-0.5745415092,
0.457303673,
-0.3475310504,
-0.2959457338,
0.5318273306,
0.4034520388,
0.0620013252,
0.6680293083,
0.4624273181,
0.1641746014,
-0.1298042238,
0.0692924485,
1.1653624773,
-0.781216085,
-0.2747419477,
0.0272056125,
0.8581031561,
-0.3513372838,
-0.3326079845,
0.382769227,
0.1905640662,
0.7221861482,
0.3424426913,
1.0967119932,
0.0288064927,
0.2822023034,
-0.4082793593,
0.6755583882,
-0.2720324099,
-0.1495543718,
-0.0464933589,
-0.5325081944,
-0.1205365583,
0.7614219785,
-0.1339733601,
-0.1298615336,
0.7535932064,
0.4054338038,
0.0779690742,
0.5743598342,
0.5939328671,
-0.1657278985,
0.4691686928,
0.2593144178,
1.3965263367,
-0.4924376309,
0.7495129108,
-0.0877065659,
-0.1404689401,
-0.3055063188,
-0.5381948948,
-0.4676520526,
-0.7631433606,
-0.189335227,
-0.2153307647,
0.0325987004,
0.8535875678,
0.8018817306,
-0.2843482494,
-0.6614408493,
0.3531988263,
0.4802288711,
-0.4027767777,
-0.1275148094,
-0.3998989761,
-0.5331881642,
-0.9637044668,
0.8109433055,
0.2208222747,
0.0736204088,
-0.3652690351,
-0.2121543586,
-0.1448638886,
0.3920046985,
0.4026533365,
0.6724220514,
-0.6621147394,
-0.4450575709,
0.0266974661,
-0.1076111048,
0.0029137628,
1.5458132029,
-0.8763144016,
0.5383198261,
0.5232747197,
0.318125397,
0.5133584142,
-0.3335155249,
0.9128303528,
-0.4669843018,
0.3310905993,
0.7209503055,
0.3560496867,
0.1007173136,
0.067378439,
0.417054683,
-0.2217120975,
-0.7482848763,
-0.4873739779,
0.6952602267,
-1.0310139656,
-0.0531617664,
0.4838148952,
-0.1423084438,
0.3128991425,
-0.6437878609,
-0.6259213686,
0.1963120699,
-0.6959053278,
0.5066557527,
0.8484951854,
-0.6483502984,
0.0595948696,
0.0827828199,
0.3781293035,
0.3683818281,
-0.687942028,
-0.2980884016,
0.58010149,
-0.2456433177,
0.4452385306,
1.2039607763,
0.2551320493,
0.3927392662,
0.0693669543,
0.0390015021,
0.6068211794,
-0.5624815822,
-0.3223915398,
0.2086527348,
0.3799732924,
-0.0393683426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01093v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01093v1
|
Specialized Language Models with Cheap Inference from Limited Domain Data
| 2024-02-02T01:45:18 | 2024-02-02T01:45:18 |
David Grangier, Angelos Katharopoulos, Pierre Ablin, Awni Hannun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models have emerged as a versatile tool but are challenging to
apply to tasks lacking large inference budgets and large in-domain training
sets. This work formalizes these constraints and distinguishes four important
variables: the pretraining budget (for training before the target domain is
known), the specialization budget (for training after the target domain is
known), the inference budget, and the in-domain training set size. Across these
settings, we compare different approaches from the machine learning literature.
Limited by inference cost, we find better alternatives to the standard practice
of training very large vanilla transformer models. In particular, we show that
hyper-networks and mixture of experts have better perplexity for large
pretraining budgets, while small models trained on importance sampled datasets
are attractive for large specialization budgets.
|
[
-0.5338327885,
-0.5516712666,
0.4588770866,
0.2004969865,
0.2031432837,
-0.0138958953,
-0.4502844214,
-0.2392235398,
-0.0744691193,
0.8512448072,
-0.6513432264,
0.0216787383,
-0.6365550756,
0.0749680549,
-0.2094957232,
0.8018248081,
0.1057181507,
-0.0189115256,
-0.1827001274,
-0.0667686686,
-0.095065169,
-0.7352704406,
-0.3853200376,
-0.3717539012,
0.51502496,
0.3785401285,
0.7901703119,
0.5127815008,
0.4473110437,
0.3073790371,
0.1566374004,
0.1723629683,
-0.4090186954,
-0.2645754218,
-0.2084787339,
-0.41068241,
-0.2464784384,
0.1023196727,
0.3392115533,
1.2403161526,
0.2334301025,
0.0038586794,
-0.1852485836,
0.5095388889,
-0.791885376,
0.2690851986,
-0.6422511339,
0.0221209824,
-0.2376053929,
0.2980657816,
-0.4180268943,
-0.0947567075,
0.5336475372,
-0.5562012792,
0.3888487518,
-0.1022326723,
1.0215559006,
0.415345639,
-0.4957763851,
-0.1404654831,
-1.0538755655,
1.2079617977,
-0.6997784376,
0.5921894908,
0.6574149728,
0.262958169,
0.1492086351,
-0.8552677631,
-0.4869336486,
-0.1183595732,
-0.1808918118,
-0.0205226894,
-0.3862403929,
0.1489429325,
0.3297976255,
0.203753069,
-0.3497009575,
0.344697237,
-0.175634712,
0.0236864854,
0.4490996599,
0.0772547349,
-0.0700181946,
0.0963100344,
-0.1120517701,
-0.0515718423,
-0.7861807942,
-0.2410893738,
0.5392895937,
0.2610217929,
0.0445629545,
0.269851774,
-0.1606110483,
0.6443021894,
0.1555015296,
-0.2821701765,
0.149239704,
-0.0809541494,
-0.2950091064,
-0.515113771,
0.5098577738,
-0.061193455,
0.7605600357,
-0.3656694591,
-0.3797000647,
-0.1395227313,
0.1712195277,
-0.7009217739,
-0.4283452034,
0.1568399221,
-0.2248130292,
0.1910670996,
-0.2985569835,
-0.5188918114,
0.0355831087,
-0.5596440434,
0.3092693388,
-0.1999223381,
-0.1911064386,
0.1179165244,
-0.0392669216,
0.0662901178,
0.3099180758,
-1.091681242,
0.4169273078,
0.4077576399,
0.4743431211,
-0.217497468,
-0.1574953049,
-0.0755776763,
-0.0395358391,
-0.4028916657,
0.8817862868,
-0.699996829,
-0.258733511,
-0.0124659212,
-0.0414281785,
-0.3086208999,
-0.6724258065,
0.5250108838,
-0.7698894143,
-0.0657388493,
-0.118636474,
-0.6200335622,
-0.0630824119,
-0.1394742131,
-0.954836905,
0.6469502449,
0.6629219651,
-0.7618393302,
0.4561511576,
-0.3184508085,
-0.4781933129,
0.2200608552,
-0.1222429946,
-0.3385203481,
0.0675586686,
0.1655904353,
0.4985556006,
-0.5857591033,
0.4391688108,
-0.2487623245,
-0.1135509461,
0.1420005113,
-0.484801203,
0.6669995785,
0.3625548482,
-0.2611255348,
-0.1967846602,
-0.8180425167,
-0.1546202004,
0.0711352453,
-0.318742007,
-0.3200797737,
0.1400540024,
0.015504566,
0.0375788361,
0.0668528602,
-0.1768378913,
0.0011539169,
-0.5687862039,
0.6155134439,
0.5175361037,
-0.2084801495,
0.7443277836,
0.1399422288,
0.6433983445,
0.0505804531,
0.1203004867,
0.0397757739,
-0.3058294952,
-0.833914578,
-0.4437755644,
0.6163649559,
0.3325941265,
-0.7303732634,
0.3526572287,
-0.1972986907,
-0.2820464373,
-0.3400146961,
-0.0085869599,
0.3432005048,
0.302375406,
0.3559966087,
0.0305797122,
-0.4262183309,
-1.1680535078,
-0.3279675841,
0.2061294019,
-0.1015537083,
0.4422495961,
0.6251590848,
-0.2054225057,
1.1725054979,
-0.677762866,
-0.0886938572,
-0.5230520964,
-0.0765541792,
0.2703157663,
0.5378903151,
0.8131537437,
-0.8862383366,
-0.609562099,
0.0262218993,
-0.2407247871,
0.1063310355,
0.0089608375,
0.2866779268,
-0.0175387971,
0.4239496589,
-0.7915740609,
0.2184951603,
0.7204265594,
0.1011723056,
0.5884806514,
-0.1936363727,
-0.2955150008,
-0.6327362061,
-0.0949938744,
0.2282786071,
-0.1550371498,
-0.8903308511,
-0.0068062586,
0.0767493322,
-0.1947216094,
-0.3033425212,
0.7172901034,
-0.4524621069,
0.1274327636,
-0.2530297041,
-0.1710168719,
0.0361949056,
0.7516430616,
0.3213641644,
0.666539669,
0.5255308747,
-0.4983185828,
0.133526206,
0.1991644204,
-0.5698665977,
0.0639221147,
-0.8237285614,
0.1798942983,
0.0408603624,
0.3191655874,
-0.5778015852,
-0.4460019171,
-0.1285622716,
-0.1215651259,
0.4537853897,
-0.5438999534,
-0.3258701563,
-0.4331066012,
0.1918360442,
0.4692281485,
0.685444355,
-0.5255354643,
0.513769567,
0.5889689326,
-0.1104452014,
-0.6733573675,
-0.7874167562,
-0.0277245268,
-0.3219656944,
-0.3659839332,
0.2648655772,
0.0477263033,
-0.3315310478,
-0.0862433538,
-0.1109087691,
-0.5922190547,
-0.0261964817,
-0.0566879287,
-0.0434732512,
-0.6408373713,
0.118193157,
0.0199942701,
-0.313355118,
0.0506435148,
-0.6360864043,
0.3386135399,
0.0421473794,
-0.3938798606,
-0.1171440333,
0.4137946069,
0.3947823942,
-0.3830228746,
0.8653942347,
0.093152158,
-0.3364057839,
-0.5609495044,
-0.7707076669,
-0.1782604903,
-0.4526689351,
0.5020574927,
-0.7154422402,
-0.8552856445,
0.2875543833,
-0.2456593066,
0.0258944016,
0.5833933949,
0.5730866194,
0.2088892311,
0.9722732306,
0.6753380299,
-0.0151691204,
0.2331623137,
-0.3742310107,
0.5875331759,
-0.3253917396,
-0.008435932,
-0.8155571818,
0.0361645594,
-0.4263278842,
-0.604906559,
0.1447318047,
-0.0098524755,
-0.3980252445,
0.3812070787,
-0.1068403125,
0.6353301406,
0.6601717472,
-0.0867967308,
0.0744166747,
0.0971670672,
0.2014088631,
-0.170258835,
-0.8773297668,
-0.4647524059,
1.0755753517,
0.3598180115,
0.8027777076,
-0.1290402859,
0.2548775375,
-0.133060351,
0.2246449292,
-0.8807765245,
0.1857052892,
-0.443264842,
-0.7484597564,
-0.5187395215,
-0.5684922338,
-0.9844076037,
0.3249074817,
-0.2363913953,
-0.5785814524,
0.5030056238,
0.4086688757,
-0.2601113319,
0.3362149298,
-0.8382875919,
0.8725194931,
-0.0412259065,
0.0442472361,
-0.168350324,
-0.5605422854,
0.225145489,
-0.6164324284,
0.265391022,
-0.0419222414,
-0.0497783832,
0.666607976,
-0.4197847247,
0.8568738699,
-0.1369961053,
0.141855225,
0.2304345071,
-0.0786326528,
0.5903500319,
-0.0633990616,
-0.1435370594,
0.0897741318,
-0.2810851932,
-0.6846100092,
-0.4952500761,
0.4925923944,
-0.9684281349,
-0.8009438515,
0.1534125358,
-0.7481642365,
-0.7977252603,
0.2247562259,
0.5041273832,
0.5759887099,
-0.1727737933,
0.3007626235,
0.9109379649,
-0.2811900079,
0.3452235162,
0.3559710681,
0.4313623607,
-0.1544157565,
0.8370418549,
0.2474685758,
0.4713515341,
0.4877057672,
0.3231713474,
-0.0797623619,
-0.6945879459,
-0.2634085417,
0.3552509844,
-0.7487514019,
-0.0994756818,
-1.0406720638,
-0.244325459,
-0.4422996044,
-0.1606637985,
-0.6759029031,
-0.5497057438,
-0.1953721941,
-0.0920369849,
0.1789273918,
0.4595608711,
0.2099658996,
0.5656553507,
-0.5940744281,
0.1447150707,
0.4129579961,
0.1855104119,
0.0802839994,
-0.7425551414,
-0.6148108244,
-0.1306928843,
0.0290678535,
-0.5015516281,
0.4177947938,
0.2359927446,
0.6729161143,
0.6713124514,
0.1893099397,
0.4660897851,
-0.7438052893,
0.7118683457,
0.1500687897,
-0.963347137,
0.0832355618,
-0.1260016263,
0.1841795295,
0.3808809519,
0.7736444473,
-0.0212268922,
-0.3167820573,
-0.7610872388,
-0.8043366075,
0.5882335901,
0.187991485,
0.5359733701,
-0.055510778,
0.2757234275,
0.1911381483,
0.0822529122,
-0.664247334,
-0.2104599774,
-0.2098925859,
-0.0744909793,
-0.3690817952,
-0.2109906673,
-0.1483019441,
-0.3321335316,
0.3667085171,
-0.2957657576,
-0.0235712603,
-0.1237903237,
-0.3422932625,
0.0707148761,
0.0268390588,
0.4152815044,
0.8897068501,
0.1391957253,
0.2042000443,
0.4186995924,
-0.255137831,
0.1199728847,
-0.1352726072,
0.1522316933,
0.0871955678,
0.6986814737,
1.0820524693,
0.3979278505,
-0.7258027196,
0.6116423607,
0.1800808012,
-0.5842320323,
-0.288559407,
0.0222329963,
0.3795026541,
0.278090328,
0.1220396981,
0.1545441449,
-0.0785605684,
-0.1698768288,
-0.1146846637,
0.278151691,
-0.3777428865,
-0.5153005123,
0.5114479065,
0.1453292817,
-0.1961140931,
0.5877972841,
0.1860739589,
-0.4433246553,
0.7123777866,
0.5246497989,
0.7916443944,
-0.2819046974,
0.1299319118,
0.1372672766,
0.3490810692,
-0.3279432654,
-0.3002068102,
0.0760236382,
-0.8849658966,
-0.6366647482,
-0.5586838126,
-0.4927110374,
0.4079501331,
-0.4465561211,
0.1196823567,
-0.33946082,
-0.2103268355,
0.1880333275,
-0.1194492504,
-0.941665113,
0.5290456414,
-0.2095952928,
0.9452181458,
-0.888002038,
0.9712069035,
0.4497860968,
-0.2912509441,
-0.8019006848,
-0.080577679,
-0.3772127032,
-0.6909170747,
1.0402263403,
-0.1849056184,
-0.1112618744,
0.0584604815,
-0.4771116376,
-0.9880209565,
0.3076596856,
0.5719128251,
-0.5198820233,
-0.3174042106,
0.1445834488,
0.4701249003,
-0.3693860471,
0.0992812663,
0.8972716928,
0.5233392715,
-0.1183786839,
-0.7408722639,
-0.3248327374,
0.0858970881,
-0.1356844455,
0.1788554043,
-0.5455299616,
1.1705985069,
-0.0647601634,
-0.0400386639,
-0.2474377453,
0.6770792603,
-0.2614024282,
0.0483679771,
0.688949883,
0.4054940641,
0.565392077,
0.0696003661,
1.0656450987,
-0.2014123797,
0.4218705595,
0.8616962433,
-0.2109512687,
0.4878591895,
0.2832636535,
-0.4994749725,
0.2443211824,
0.7015379667,
-0.0389588065,
0.5039618015,
0.2755377293,
-0.1169530079,
-0.5008683801,
0.2519064248,
-0.2097814679,
0.2731184363,
0.4276044071,
-0.057689853,
-0.0645759329,
0.1034696326,
0.1155982167,
-0.1679981351,
-0.0458404049,
0.7197068334,
0.2829482555,
-0.6631452441,
0.6613633037,
-0.0290256869,
0.3380860388,
-0.6686794758,
0.4843962193,
-0.4768643379,
0.3553050458,
-0.1527131945,
-0.2204108834,
0.2708123326,
0.0573122352,
-0.3167790771,
-0.1380199194,
0.5007545352,
-0.2775585949,
-0.3438789248,
0.1436036378,
0.6140167117,
0.1679160148,
-0.3418370485,
-0.479200393,
-0.3202165067,
-0.2583757043,
-0.6587682366,
0.4974738359,
0.6336132884,
-0.2126953751,
0.6623461246,
0.3404305875,
0.1378926635,
-0.0248628017,
0.3890375197,
0.8699061871,
-0.556869328,
-0.4864540398,
-0.6465559602,
0.2343183905,
0.1348365843,
-0.3103778362,
0.6470558643,
0.3990283012,
0.8720783591,
-0.5042809248,
0.8707392216,
0.3870105147,
0.4579184651,
-0.4608629048,
0.4074587226,
-0.4815315902,
0.0135704335,
-0.1703709513,
-0.9056234956,
-0.39762941,
0.5660018325,
-0.4660214484,
0.1220182776,
0.750520885,
0.6941742897,
-0.377917856,
-0.0439574458,
0.5331320167,
-0.0586370751,
0.1583717763,
0.4470324516,
0.9099919796,
0.0583894923,
0.4582492709,
-0.2085600197,
-0.3332310915,
-0.3577144146,
-0.6737806201,
-1.1693534851,
-0.5573777556,
-0.3191996515,
-0.1581882983,
-0.1897487789,
0.9445484877,
1.1634367704,
-1.024499774,
-0.2936131358,
0.0934029371,
0.1224871427,
-0.1912653297,
-0.1402506828,
0.4530417025,
-0.5156611204,
-1.0278464556,
0.3443907797,
0.1281720251,
-0.0877698064,
-0.2284569591,
0.0629263893,
0.1608183086,
0.6051961184,
0.6738185287,
0.3697437942,
-0.7289434671,
-0.2719081342,
0.0101106083,
-0.0446640775,
0.0285045095,
1.2266001701,
-0.5453239679,
0.0263556894,
0.3357106745,
0.9581688046,
0.8021173477,
-0.3127862215,
0.6457228661,
-0.6676487327,
0.4503320158,
0.3541997075,
0.3166950345,
0.0979717374,
-0.1285822541,
0.4373481572,
0.3009627759,
-0.5424314737,
-0.8338783383,
0.4812396765,
-0.4931382835,
-0.6248367429,
0.8744063377,
-0.3383430541,
-0.0066568563,
-0.4137254059,
0.1578565091,
-0.1008328423,
0.1235265657,
0.3544430435,
0.6425656676,
-0.0254023653,
-0.1090795174,
-0.5837507844,
0.6940017939,
0.3582657576,
-0.6901009083,
0.146700114,
0.2360477298,
0.1739794016,
0.0327019952,
0.3274892867,
0.2351182699,
-0.1167162731,
0.3109209239,
-0.1036231369,
0.2506181002,
-0.5271267891,
-0.0791027695,
0.3368301392,
0.0740280747,
0.1678922325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01091v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01091v1
|
Reading Between the Tweets: Deciphering Ideological Stances of Interconnected Mixed-Ideology Communities
| 2024-02-02T01:39:00 | 2024-02-02T01:39:00 |
Zihao He, Ashwin Rao, Siyi Guo, Negar Mokhberian, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Recent advances in NLP have improved our ability to understand the nuanced
worldviews of online communities. Existing research focused on probing
ideological stances treats liberals and conservatives as separate groups.
However, this fails to account for the nuanced views of the organically formed
online communities and the connections between them. In this paper, we study
discussions of the 2020 U.S. election on Twitter to identify complex
interacting communities. Capitalizing on this interconnectedness, we introduce
a novel approach that harnesses message passing when finetuning language models
(LMs) to probe the nuanced ideologies of these communities. By comparing the
responses generated by LMs and real-world survey results, our method shows
higher alignment than existing baselines, highlighting the potential of using
LMs in revealing complex ideologies within and across interconnected
mixed-ideology communities.
|
[
-0.6973867416,
-0.6821336746,
0.6907880306,
0.1032223105,
-0.5464427471,
0.7886138558,
-0.1553260386,
-0.3771971762,
0.4946986437,
0.596645534,
-0.7594252825,
-0.5234995484,
-0.6756727695,
-0.2052424997,
-0.3188041151,
0.8147273064,
0.2587581575,
-0.0141730886,
0.3050951362,
-0.3551284969,
0.0488537252,
-0.1258346438,
-0.5047225356,
-0.5777576566,
0.7655528784,
0.09390378,
0.8010409474,
0.6546729207,
0.4417649806,
0.152950272,
0.0228425991,
-0.096072033,
-0.5540597439,
-0.0132442918,
-0.4513349533,
-0.2440159023,
0.1450360566,
0.1606391072,
0.4020881951,
0.9456750751,
0.0881280005,
0.2560175359,
0.2313475162,
0.2220286429,
-0.5091397762,
-0.2795682549,
-1.0252037048,
-0.1807267368,
-0.2894088328,
-0.2012229562,
-0.3193730414,
-0.5280624032,
0.1404772997,
-0.0956546739,
0.0437735356,
-0.0391097739,
0.9924987555,
-0.0384326912,
-0.6071887016,
-0.3829017282,
-0.681966126,
0.9906126261,
-0.9300137162,
0.125481382,
-0.0022085826,
0.0301580112,
0.0538114831,
-0.4813132286,
-0.7111281753,
0.2525544465,
-0.143842414,
-0.0658636317,
-0.0812684372,
-0.0689317062,
-0.2359136492,
0.0470183752,
-0.1563124061,
0.017779449,
-0.1675225645,
0.2970820963,
0.5551332235,
0.1011061519,
0.4285978079,
-0.5053079128,
-0.7340894938,
0.1730638146,
-0.4384044707,
0.0251539424,
0.5190691948,
0.3531795144,
-0.2448656261,
0.4808649421,
0.1580999494,
0.5145229101,
0.1690936983,
0.1443277746,
-0.2585407794,
-0.4310826659,
-0.2140494436,
-0.3229421377,
0.7451248765,
0.6126500964,
0.3321893215,
0.0655112714,
-0.0544890426,
-0.013465683,
-0.0194958858,
-0.3833630383,
-0.2239162922,
0.5271095634,
-0.750456512,
-0.1716683358,
0.18409729,
-0.9124802351,
-0.6754878759,
-0.4273804426,
0.2337536812,
-0.2095354199,
-0.6935036182,
-0.0781723857,
-0.2920572162,
0.2839996517,
0.4307627082,
-0.7830651999,
0.3148126304,
1.1511218548,
0.9029276967,
0.244161129,
0.1587505937,
-0.1779502183,
0.3037621081,
-0.3897082806,
0.7880654335,
-0.9694414139,
0.065512985,
0.161860019,
-0.3799022734,
0.0848458037,
-0.275718838,
0.0098448256,
-0.7108687758,
0.1614219546,
-0.4453454912,
-0.7202447653,
-0.2140299678,
0.624160111,
-0.6111093163,
0.7937813401,
-0.2341343313,
-0.9041034579,
0.3081247807,
-0.6033658981,
-0.0354328677,
-0.0349516831,
-0.3474555612,
-0.0042296746,
0.018419411,
0.0628021806,
0.7357857227,
-0.0196847972,
0.3126423061,
-0.7938582301,
-0.1070942953,
0.2388351262,
-0.1364263296,
1.1780318022,
0.161519289,
-0.3144120276,
0.1031160429,
-0.404007256,
0.0669835135,
-0.2227225602,
0.0372343473,
-0.7527490258,
0.5082607865,
0.0303665455,
0.3447448015,
0.2939687669,
-0.6995142102,
0.4131647348,
-0.3463594019,
0.6509757042,
0.8450798392,
0.1999411583,
0.6218569279,
-0.1596018523,
0.2107705921,
-0.0239362568,
0.2783659101,
0.452282846,
-0.4027603567,
-0.8161208034,
0.2079338729,
0.0285412576,
0.6349752545,
-0.6520214677,
0.3007156551,
-0.1292955428,
-0.6555182934,
-0.5255278349,
-0.2569465339,
0.0975687802,
-0.108749494,
0.2236208916,
0.2984377444,
-0.4179733098,
-0.8834199309,
-0.8723273873,
-0.3594762683,
0.0143649587,
-0.0779156312,
0.6208774447,
-0.2050055265,
0.7877542377,
-0.376660198,
0.1092699543,
-0.3282438815,
0.4107713699,
0.112119481,
0.164321661,
0.39172557,
-0.7921013236,
-0.8738567233,
0.2925212085,
-0.0952831805,
-0.0619970374,
-0.1971703023,
-0.161361739,
-0.1859147549,
0.5468906164,
-0.0725339651,
0.2339015603,
0.8961986303,
-0.5410481095,
-0.1046750247,
0.4712857306,
0.3946768343,
-1.4863895178,
-0.3360852301,
-0.0955280811,
-0.2109155804,
-0.6256967187,
-0.1666425467,
-0.3407225311,
0.5636242032,
-0.4509408474,
0.507461369,
-0.2169062644,
0.0484615192,
0.0961953178,
0.2242699116,
-0.0029038449,
-0.0511643477,
-0.206681028,
0.287917912,
0.1212804392,
-0.0507850535,
0.1125128791,
-0.0315586925,
-0.1932358146,
0.4616566002,
-0.1883790195,
0.1667981744,
-0.1310948581,
0.3215943277,
-1.2652205229,
-0.3422498107,
0.3276366293,
-0.3976371884,
0.0402777307,
-0.3354156613,
-0.4798468053,
0.0441547558,
-0.3276177645,
0.3039114475,
0.1060491204,
-0.3941517174,
0.7659680843,
0.6185455322,
-0.0545796081,
-0.675388813,
-0.620752573,
0.1255006492,
-0.4427132905,
-0.6461269259,
0.1206288785,
0.3413450718,
-1.1682950258,
0.2352405488,
0.3936232328,
-0.2609544694,
-0.207635507,
-0.0559619181,
0.0009259841,
-0.1927310228,
0.3019652069,
0.0070191873,
0.1767637134,
-0.0986062288,
-0.2258029133,
0.7232783437,
-0.2355739921,
-0.1758100688,
-0.3979160786,
0.9890957475,
0.4512143433,
-0.2424274087,
1.1807950735,
0.5720251203,
-0.5126267076,
-0.3957743645,
-0.6685707569,
-0.2257539034,
-0.4525270462,
0.170250982,
0.0770372003,
-0.8710385561,
0.8076860905,
-0.2071187198,
0.6356361508,
0.4691656828,
0.5429320931,
-0.5981229544,
0.8730908632,
0.6168254614,
0.2365101576,
0.4339618981,
-0.1321701705,
0.580517292,
-0.4541234374,
-0.2074650526,
-0.6078748107,
-0.59654212,
-0.5430579185,
-0.498067826,
0.0183796585,
0.1053325385,
-0.2563598752,
0.1448317617,
-0.5403399467,
0.6249060035,
0.1576365083,
-0.0017177829,
0.2244288772,
-0.1493011415,
0.2579428256,
-0.4525355995,
-0.3053763807,
-0.8018904924,
0.7160421014,
0.2327437699,
0.6796574593,
0.3638030589,
0.6488143206,
0.4171998799,
0.7470574975,
-0.5976248384,
0.453669101,
-0.45262146,
-0.5434527993,
-0.0602683499,
-0.2950989306,
-0.6029065251,
0.3522529304,
-0.2980003655,
-0.6570904851,
0.1263147891,
-0.1656456739,
-0.3522887826,
1.1175067425,
-0.4921355247,
0.7008964419,
-0.1586219519,
0.0024105785,
-0.2864472866,
-0.942710638,
0.3068672419,
0.1923701316,
0.4916986823,
-0.3328496814,
-0.3589875996,
0.7973473072,
-0.0512436442,
0.9330161214,
0.0999233052,
-0.1062463969,
0.078103438,
-0.1819268465,
0.1456942707,
-0.0172640868,
-0.2034646869,
0.2943048179,
0.320610255,
-0.3517379761,
-0.2732179761,
0.729796052,
-0.92199862,
-0.2888015807,
-0.34882918,
-0.5039304495,
-0.0469179675,
0.2280596942,
0.3457858264,
0.518261075,
-0.2613828182,
0.2605003715,
0.6855581999,
0.2454697937,
0.4711514115,
0.03336652,
-0.1726290137,
-0.3943228722,
0.4490800202,
0.2637785673,
0.7292186022,
0.5197377205,
0.1573114097,
-0.2775747776,
-0.3829502463,
-0.2801885307,
0.3729218245,
-0.8415112495,
-0.1454800814,
-0.6909034848,
-0.0078951996,
-0.0549125001,
-0.5627322793,
-0.4737460911,
-0.0523595326,
-0.404194057,
0.1535542011,
0.2618457079,
1.2736179829,
0.1415353268,
0.5722740889,
-0.781439662,
0.0531833693,
0.0684344694,
0.3534340262,
-0.1322216094,
0.0495436415,
-0.002695496,
0.1231799498,
-0.1971030235,
-1.5100767612,
0.0011508212,
0.157178238,
0.0796313658,
0.7434581518,
0.3536702693,
0.7600780725,
-0.3301056325,
0.9486020803,
0.1418421268,
-0.9717535973,
0.3569547534,
-0.7111898065,
-0.0173082296,
0.7038269043,
0.3893058002,
-0.656781137,
-0.8751231432,
-0.6379858255,
-0.5515358448,
0.4259198904,
-0.0584853292,
0.396253407,
-0.128222093,
0.2901309729,
0.1693748683,
-0.0043944344,
-0.9119891524,
-0.2547604442,
0.0914491788,
-0.390928179,
0.3837406337,
0.0340724662,
-0.546272099,
-0.0272503085,
0.3313456476,
-0.0898979083,
-0.0491863601,
-0.115594767,
0.5036241412,
-0.3890676498,
0.3408703208,
0.3121949434,
0.8024517298,
-0.2796209753,
0.4073119164,
-0.0686219558,
-0.2745982409,
-0.0866348669,
-0.2565382123,
-0.1688887924,
0.2157115042,
0.5622333288,
0.4138635099,
-0.0689700469,
-0.1046655253,
0.5160708427,
-0.1293586493,
-0.1638842672,
-0.2927205265,
-0.2362857461,
0.6986059546,
0.6058602929,
0.4703010917,
0.4301911891,
-0.1371357292,
-0.9145120978,
0.15181306,
0.8309805393,
-0.5671639442,
-0.3806030452,
0.4668884277,
0.3790638447,
-0.4037181139,
0.2142883837,
-0.1227573827,
-0.7571300268,
0.607170701,
0.1465372592,
0.8132132888,
-0.1578610688,
0.2049699426,
0.2935489714,
0.5368628502,
0.3653224111,
0.220152244,
0.1468123198,
-0.7135558724,
-0.4010042846,
-0.503739357,
-0.3589831591,
0.0947854519,
-0.6806307435,
0.3271059096,
-0.6983305216,
-0.2907034755,
0.0164004583,
0.3917075694,
-0.3478940725,
0.2284487486,
0.1443938315,
0.6706009507,
-1.2042319775,
0.5838513374,
0.4871938229,
-0.0614823326,
-0.8314474821,
0.8106186986,
-0.0975221694,
-0.4871322215,
0.1008574739,
0.1183190569,
-0.4013408422,
0.0065094135,
-0.8094067574,
-0.6601622701,
0.8724443913,
0.1061249003,
-0.4942075908,
-0.1529261768,
0.3146165013,
0.2909959555,
-0.5083054304,
0.0707840472,
0.3543271124,
0.4400103092,
-0.0881652832,
-0.6175484061,
-0.1250416487,
0.0972007215,
-0.4372641742,
0.7552753687,
-0.8564518094,
1.0804116726,
0.144626826,
-0.3703559339,
-0.2437227815,
0.6918407679,
-0.0389771573,
0.4516946673,
0.7068119049,
0.2878623009,
0.477325052,
-0.1275603026,
0.6097999215,
-0.2154300958,
0.5953950882,
0.7459388375,
-0.008438386,
1.1875032187,
0.9212194085,
-0.1745210439,
0.7487986684,
0.7793256044,
0.4229658544,
0.4387633204,
-0.0548723601,
-0.4910122156,
-0.3992060721,
-0.2268247902,
-0.2603565454,
0.1977427304,
0.7595382333,
-0.0580333732,
-0.5654662251,
-0.129812479,
0.2538083494,
0.4407505989,
-0.2224219292,
0.6960701942,
0.2405169308,
-0.7787917256,
0.098527804,
-0.1960781366,
0.7110156417,
-0.629042089,
-0.2422792614,
0.2561080158,
0.2456125766,
-0.4131922126,
-1.5065524578,
0.6273995042,
-0.1564708948,
-0.0525052361,
-0.3294306397,
0.3909605443,
-0.6405873299,
-0.396636337,
0.773288846,
0.4121163785,
-0.1958977431,
0.2585024238,
-0.8829805255,
0.3517778218,
0.268130362,
-0.1465717107,
0.0091349538,
0.4959731698,
-0.0046134288,
0.4689601958,
0.6479111314,
-0.0202015638,
0.1097192541,
0.0016627974,
0.8783593178,
-0.3448276818,
-0.2494971901,
-1.0705677271,
0.5539981723,
-0.2204695046,
-0.4760472178,
0.7199007273,
0.098592639,
0.8969194889,
0.3286657929,
0.8014834523,
-0.1839440912,
0.8834191561,
-0.3896502554,
0.847876668,
-0.7545490265,
0.3347799778,
-0.0910848156,
-0.5362081528,
-0.4579011202,
0.5246534348,
-0.4890103638,
-0.1398959011,
0.2809461057,
0.5051730275,
-0.3932157457,
0.0491278954,
-0.0822702199,
0.3322154284,
0.4012613297,
0.4681403339,
1.092895031,
-0.1371956617,
0.432505548,
-0.3826849163,
-0.1425008476,
-0.1970840544,
-0.767681241,
-0.9502615929,
-0.6689314246,
-0.2210768163,
-0.4896937907,
-0.2671234012,
0.9556519389,
0.4158839285,
-0.5756385922,
-0.2822999954,
0.0054143742,
0.1183423251,
0.1452714801,
-0.3054846525,
0.3088091314,
0.1782250106,
-0.836992383,
-0.3737623096,
0.41704458,
-0.4539380968,
-0.7332087159,
0.294819653,
-0.788718164,
0.6790440083,
0.3452131748,
-0.1239927784,
-1.2089833021,
-0.7276806831,
0.0798407942,
-0.2989313602,
0.1073529571,
0.4600242078,
-0.4174182415,
0.4029895961,
0.7782763839,
0.2978899181,
-0.0807589069,
0.3688707352,
0.2648851871,
-0.4997174442,
-0.0392750986,
0.8465059996,
-0.0012181055,
0.4937501848,
-0.183613807,
0.1304602921,
0.0188851617,
-0.6503167748,
-0.6638659239,
0.6463288069,
-1.0544445515,
-0.3624992669,
1.0461169481,
0.1574485898,
-0.0443068072,
-0.5335566401,
-0.1027812287,
0.2842304409,
-0.2436650246,
0.5222616196,
0.7638776898,
-0.0770976916,
-0.2097685039,
-0.6272233129,
0.4017856419,
0.1197255477,
-0.7427178025,
-0.1478529871,
0.1691204756,
0.3147507012,
0.2124541253,
0.8031986356,
0.2363843471,
-0.1580841541,
-0.1025037542,
-0.3377377391,
0.817506969,
-0.128997758,
0.1449142843,
0.246964708,
-0.2987410426,
-0.1891541183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01065v1
|
Evaluation Methodology for Large Language Models for Multilingual Document Question and Answer
| 2024-02-01T23:46:05 | 2024-02-01T23:46:05 |
Adar Kahana, Jaya Susan Mathew, Said Bleik, Jeremy Reynolds, Oren Elisha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), in this paper
we investigate the multilingual capability of these models. Our preliminary
results show that, translating the native language context, question and answer
into a high resource language produced the best results.
|
[
-0.5314962268,
-0.8845928907,
0.8246739507,
0.2669210732,
-0.2208512127,
0.1188850254,
-0.6339893937,
-0.6817458272,
0.0791669115,
0.7204276919,
-0.2797800004,
-0.2511965334,
-0.7121271491,
0.3884443045,
-0.4819235802,
0.7257431746,
-0.3433695138,
0.4564307928,
-0.4156992137,
-0.3683860302,
-0.2615255713,
-0.7566972971,
-0.6805488467,
-0.4926899374,
0.4549950063,
0.2879694104,
0.5933775902,
0.2623189986,
0.7228736281,
0.3905618787,
-0.3236383498,
0.0860181525,
-0.3238050342,
0.0541237555,
-0.1744151711,
-0.631493032,
-0.4354117513,
0.0467144735,
0.9430854917,
0.8844535947,
-0.1638492346,
0.4611302018,
-0.0641911328,
0.2888242304,
-0.498434633,
0.0126678525,
-0.4733466506,
0.0204208251,
-0.0049790889,
-0.2725372314,
-0.5478874445,
-0.4400650859,
0.0321354084,
-0.3605827987,
-0.1122915894,
-0.1055080816,
0.35414958,
-0.2979418933,
-0.7468396425,
-0.6726756096,
-0.8746050596,
0.9649191499,
-0.5225912929,
0.4617512226,
0.3211488724,
0.4804450274,
0.2213743776,
-0.6321100593,
-0.5574053526,
-0.4114057422,
0.0554211028,
0.0964300185,
0.1478461623,
-0.1155953333,
0.2060630471,
0.522057116,
-0.6813092828,
0.2155023962,
-0.3991124332,
-0.0760586932,
0.7656198144,
0.3429176509,
0.3349866867,
-0.285666585,
-0.1486266851,
0.0827823877,
-0.464015305,
-0.2518524528,
0.2288473696,
0.3531692624,
-0.0835150555,
0.866751492,
-0.1679218709,
0.772778511,
-0.548938334,
-0.5196717978,
0.1217787936,
-0.6629742384,
-0.1743254662,
-0.0292813499,
0.3151018023,
0.4520609379,
0.2908440828,
-0.1419635117,
-0.3503176868,
-0.2335533202,
-0.1754899472,
-0.8897245526,
0.7620628476,
0.3177208006,
-0.517414391,
0.0335878246,
-0.3231213093,
-0.7320789695,
-0.434879005,
-0.3200771809,
0.3048631549,
-0.0690648705,
-0.5105261207,
0.272261411,
-0.0976517126,
0.4548307061,
0.4920219779,
-0.7254840732,
0.2591460943,
0.6357761621,
0.7276752591,
-0.235610798,
-0.3942477405,
-0.4103487432,
-0.0212321766,
-0.5107975006,
0.7281202078,
-0.368997395,
-0.685908854,
0.3590949476,
0.2243791372,
-0.1315329969,
-0.6567134857,
0.608661294,
-0.9724439383,
0.4145451188,
-0.4457012415,
-0.4356950819,
-0.2994640768,
0.6417745948,
-0.6224858165,
0.9254596233,
0.1714835763,
-0.6017440557,
0.1701949686,
-0.8789377809,
-0.3048274517,
0.0980186984,
0.2268918753,
0.0814462453,
-0.0595482662,
0.1272797734,
0.4925649762,
-0.6164831519,
0.3393178582,
-0.195534125,
-0.2018794119,
0.498726666,
-0.6494726539,
0.8328296542,
0.4774095416,
0.0590400137,
0.2187530696,
-0.7919329405,
0.0163298007,
0.3935846686,
-0.8610261679,
-0.2425236851,
-0.2058178186,
0.3011623621,
0.3389099836,
0.6338924766,
-0.5685096383,
0.1654191613,
-0.143687889,
0.3304927647,
0.421798259,
0.0265193861,
0.5786097646,
-0.2730037272,
1.0198206902,
-0.1433259249,
0.0220839083,
-0.1936492771,
-0.3847726882,
-0.647384882,
0.102943562,
0.2809787989,
0.5435635448,
-0.6850517392,
-0.0999343693,
-0.2081286758,
-0.4031768441,
-0.4580506086,
0.606985867,
0.2579660714,
0.2376222759,
0.214762792,
0.0238489024,
-0.3438664675,
-0.9495483637,
0.0346034504,
-0.2074222416,
0.0683256537,
0.4222881794,
0.5249408484,
-0.3180175722,
0.3750699162,
-0.3471894264,
0.3623131514,
-0.7594816685,
0.1901847124,
0.3436440229,
0.1374615431,
0.6125804782,
-0.9640772939,
-0.6172949672,
0.1837019026,
-0.7467623353,
-0.0174639188,
0.0811581165,
-0.0993364826,
0.392195344,
0.3276069164,
-0.5330848694,
-0.044749476,
0.6933661103,
-0.0766370744,
0.8005781174,
-0.4670197368,
0.3043120801,
-1.290517211,
0.291330725,
-0.1113310531,
-0.3473883867,
-0.6411647201,
0.5724861026,
0.3169714808,
-0.1903088093,
-0.6094707251,
0.9215829968,
-0.6454744339,
-0.4980263114,
-0.1713150591,
0.5381168723,
-0.0034589698,
0.0640325993,
0.1462841034,
1.0334678888,
0.4618445337,
-0.6143789887,
0.8278136849,
0.2185112238,
-0.69953233,
0.6910526752,
-0.5450854301,
0.0835711583,
-0.4690478742,
-0.0898735598,
-1.2614053488,
-0.4451693594,
-0.3700525463,
-0.1023993045,
0.3129718304,
0.0280157272,
-0.6734470725,
-0.6658129692,
-0.224191308,
0.3323578537,
0.1076486111,
-0.5202249885,
0.5238821507,
0.2929824293,
-0.5493896008,
-0.4814347625,
-0.5833982825,
0.276584208,
-0.2487389445,
-0.8609132767,
-0.1618438959,
-0.6191359162,
-0.6031384468,
-0.2918969095,
0.3599754572,
-0.2483272851,
0.1460493803,
-0.3303284645,
0.2496667653,
-0.5813602805,
0.3326931,
-0.1772521734,
0.1225422025,
0.037821535,
0.1970980316,
0.7869748473,
-0.2577943802,
-0.3125046492,
0.0050829095,
0.7045122385,
0.9076912403,
-0.6462792754,
0.687020421,
0.3094698191,
-0.2464780957,
0.0813198686,
-0.7201716304,
0.3036073744,
-0.4195499718,
0.753280282,
-0.4250538051,
-0.8989705443,
0.8152685761,
-0.1464718133,
0.0221255682,
0.3902435899,
0.9718692303,
0.2514176965,
1.0751106739,
0.5285848379,
0.0056835879,
0.3058495522,
-0.2755483687,
0.0742622018,
-0.8470383883,
-0.3376111388,
-0.7230601907,
-0.1393056065,
-0.3954008818,
-0.6528693438,
0.5441352725,
0.2722832859,
0.0225025415,
0.112066336,
-0.1136467755,
0.2245725095,
0.2232086658,
-0.22705625,
0.6436055899,
-0.0312391371,
-0.2406372428,
0.0274323616,
-0.4783502221,
-0.7460232973,
1.0513484478,
0.5417399406,
0.6856859922,
0.4127775729,
0.4911834002,
-0.1189453602,
0.6643462181,
-1.0400938988,
0.6689155698,
-0.0166503694,
-0.9399011731,
-0.6077895164,
-0.2128533572,
-0.9295352697,
0.6751852632,
-0.1334281266,
-0.7849026322,
-0.2082944959,
-0.556391418,
-0.1141258478,
0.3047411144,
-0.5931310058,
0.725568831,
-0.5504466891,
-0.1418925524,
-0.3503084183,
-0.2785672843,
0.4943247139,
-0.4361009896,
0.4768425226,
0.0916259214,
-0.1352342516,
0.8748310208,
0.0236669015,
0.2658248544,
0.0778734088,
-0.4360097349,
0.5173187256,
0.1364693046,
0.2807692587,
0.1169151515,
-0.7564319372,
-0.1333628148,
0.1745350808,
-0.2467357814,
-0.6105665565,
0.6310408711,
-0.7390795946,
-0.851023674,
-0.1896185428,
-0.8993510008,
-0.4311931133,
0.4059009254,
-0.069785215,
0.5192089677,
-0.3478009701,
0.3387210965,
0.4647511542,
-0.5303514004,
0.7864040136,
1.0661300421,
-0.7609899044,
-0.2550948858,
0.4308192432,
0.3183538318,
0.4072845578,
0.3455763459,
0.276748091,
-0.6722843051,
-0.5463980436,
-0.6463497281,
0.5062627196,
-0.9500672817,
0.1479672939,
-0.6725637913,
-0.397922188,
-0.4095723927,
-0.1224020272,
-0.2116118968,
-0.2131115794,
-0.05990123,
-0.2381409854,
-0.0037141219,
1.0049521923,
0.2079677582,
0.2634344101,
-0.8971209526,
0.2074850798,
0.3348093331,
0.4341359437,
0.0642911792,
-0.6234932542,
-0.4054205418,
-0.078266032,
-0.3085535467,
-0.9963126779,
0.277099371,
-0.044588834,
0.9045792222,
0.1599312723,
-0.4037277997,
0.3060070574,
-0.4224877357,
0.7833227515,
0.2397699207,
-0.6721832752,
0.3430597484,
-0.4257997572,
0.5211949348,
0.3988960385,
0.7068436742,
-0.8852789998,
-0.0579521284,
-0.2886850834,
-0.5724918246,
0.4101543427,
-0.3775839806,
0.4567044675,
-0.0688815489,
0.2342534065,
0.0582493544,
0.2987926006,
-0.7878273129,
0.0589814521,
0.4738454521,
0.3026411235,
-0.4175899923,
-0.6443937421,
-0.0093508819,
-0.0902710259,
0.3321183324,
-0.1629710495,
0.0558430627,
0.0910224989,
-0.2557858825,
-0.352211237,
0.7964414358,
0.7237936854,
1.2169576883,
-0.1236520559,
0.0262287259,
0.4919770956,
-0.18203336,
0.2344488651,
-0.1717849374,
0.1005974412,
0.0049049906,
0.5538278818,
0.4784238636,
0.1275277883,
-0.8399138451,
0.4967174232,
-0.0482055843,
-0.2612979114,
-0.2100551724,
-0.3349222839,
0.4866091907,
0.0819827542,
0.3919637799,
-0.4413456023,
0.1172196493,
-0.8959094882,
-0.0089264074,
0.52989465,
-0.0694007203,
0.0216113441,
0.4369463027,
0.1561172754,
-0.3726990819,
0.51483953,
0.0078832693,
-0.706564188,
0.5873919129,
0.8108320832,
0.5037760139,
-0.5900709033,
0.3027110398,
0.4661542475,
0.3511995375,
-0.1584914476,
0.659906745,
0.1640078127,
-0.8147411346,
-0.7220904827,
-0.8831859827,
-0.3956035972,
0.2771749198,
-0.675337851,
0.1332808286,
-0.2927060127,
-0.1202518046,
0.0647431612,
0.2365797311,
-0.6623457074,
0.3189481199,
0.2504942417,
1.257520318,
-0.6073967218,
0.8746523261,
0.9366517067,
-0.3946874738,
-0.6779894829,
-0.3358402252,
-0.3386605382,
-0.8913682103,
0.97596246,
-0.0112250717,
0.0311572999,
-0.241433993,
-0.3430227339,
-0.9320982695,
0.8438333869,
0.4967989028,
-0.5123916268,
0.067611292,
0.3426741958,
0.6375781894,
-0.2842574716,
0.410320133,
0.5318753719,
0.7446839809,
0.1442529708,
-1.247682929,
-0.1722255051,
-0.1480710059,
0.1565059572,
0.0298480503,
-0.6557173133,
0.7391492128,
-0.1990702301,
-0.0438064896,
0.2552992702,
0.5040115714,
0.1772850454,
0.2187627554,
0.4939564168,
0.2918684185,
0.9720631242,
0.0848632529,
1.5231001377,
-0.3814734817,
0.3013792634,
0.8910360336,
-0.5496481657,
1.1102638245,
0.3747591078,
-0.4542732835,
0.2514689267,
0.5893666148,
0.2288592905,
0.0260637999,
0.3684413731,
-0.4849618077,
-0.2998296618,
-0.4014282227,
-0.3239798844,
0.7040992379,
0.1127869114,
-0.2377763242,
-0.29608199,
0.0999231786,
-0.0138357701,
0.2452778965,
-0.493894726,
0.6337766647,
0.0825480297,
-0.8296383619,
0.4795849621,
0.5159680843,
0.5085238218,
-0.6846385598,
0.151056543,
-0.3319769502,
-0.0291773062,
-0.0515239015,
-1.0874704123,
0.3398192823,
0.0883603618,
-0.3184065521,
-0.2033255249,
0.6139298677,
-0.5598884225,
-0.8822764754,
0.5786443949,
0.7364090681,
0.1466225684,
0.1534721851,
-0.583311379,
0.0003483231,
-0.462202251,
-0.4398245215,
0.3695040643,
0.2607481778,
-0.1045693681,
0.8764559627,
0.4846747518,
0.1903749257,
0.1154997274,
0.1468784511,
0.5733819604,
-0.494707644,
-0.5216191411,
-0.5680683851,
0.30495134,
-0.0548108704,
-0.1636984944,
0.9795632958,
0.8119357824,
0.7725055814,
0.0233715046,
0.8014278412,
0.1761563122,
0.524379015,
-0.4315974414,
0.5853093863,
-0.7454791665,
0.1266992241,
-0.3066093922,
-1.0924710035,
-0.2255996168,
0.4024699032,
-0.6834546328,
0.2396057844,
0.7361236811,
0.7115283012,
0.1337991506,
0.0323693305,
0.6718623042,
0.1501034796,
0.175207302,
0.5103039742,
1.1405756474,
-0.2205951214,
0.4392460287,
-0.0128165139,
-0.3034047782,
-0.0680038929,
-0.9525945783,
-0.7610288262,
-0.4399232268,
-0.0475297198,
-0.4303346872,
-0.2368707806,
0.7885761261,
0.4937330484,
-0.7501958609,
-0.7848573327,
0.6974078417,
0.3163009286,
0.135148555,
-0.1437159181,
0.2060355097,
-0.254199326,
-0.8936440349,
0.418040663,
0.2186191082,
-0.0041134548,
-0.6463525891,
-0.3493995667,
-0.4615769684,
0.1181131601,
0.9446333647,
-0.0257398505,
-0.4738552272,
0.0708996952,
0.0977809876,
-0.3864473999,
-0.0349194556,
0.903670907,
0.0087141227,
0.6143440604,
0.5705932379,
0.7651441097,
0.5121738315,
-0.1958283037,
0.6681311727,
-0.2515184283,
0.2351973504,
-0.0323903002,
0.6382607818,
0.5168430209,
-0.4134339392,
0.5093829632,
-0.0081076538,
-0.5024253726,
-0.6827272773,
0.0718792826,
-0.8046283722,
-0.4278685451,
1.3731558323,
-0.1703085601,
-0.1094126701,
0.033649601,
-0.3425748646,
0.158923775,
0.1655178517,
0.3573883176,
1.1416869164,
0.1866076887,
-0.2740696371,
-1.0116895437,
-0.0664353147,
0.2468911558,
-0.8183885217,
-0.0667078048,
0.4344482124,
0.3812178373,
0.2975568473,
0.7540498376,
-0.4520173967,
0.1525263786,
-0.219817698,
-0.1378603429,
0.2134865224,
-0.3076321781,
-0.6205233335,
0.3129457235,
0.7569662929,
0.4450919926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01053v1
|
Plan-Grounded Large Language Models for Dual Goal Conversational Settings
| 2024-02-01T22:56:39 | 2024-02-01T22:56:39 |
Diogo Glória-Silva, Rafael Ferreira, Diogo Tavares, David Semedo, João Magalhães
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Training Large Language Models (LLMs) to follow user instructions has been
shown to supply the LLM with ample capacity to converse fluently while being
aligned with humans. Yet, it is not completely clear how an LLM can lead a
plan-grounded conversation in mixed-initiative settings where instructions flow
in both directions of the conversation, i.e. both the LLM and the user provide
instructions to one another. In this paper, we tackle a dual goal
mixed-initiative conversational setting where the LLM not only grounds the
conversation on an arbitrary plan but also seeks to satisfy both a procedural
plan and user instructions. The LLM is then responsible for guiding the user
through the plan and, at the same time, adapting to new circumstances,
answering questions, and activating safety guardrails when needed. We propose a
novel LLM that grounds the dialogue on a procedural plan, can take the dialogue
initiative, and enforces guardrails on the system's behavior, while also
improving the LLM's responses to unexpected user behavior. Experiments in
controlled settings and with real users show that the best-performing model,
which we call PlanLLM, achieves a 2.1x improvement over a strong baseline.
Moreover, experiments also show good generalization to unseen domains.
|
[
-0.1457561553,
-0.7939570546,
0.7668300867,
0.4754811525,
-0.2586985826,
0.3846303225,
-0.5247530937,
-0.0296538919,
0.3278004229,
0.8757878542,
-0.7444028258,
-0.6183254123,
-0.3595140278,
-0.4358739257,
-0.0239678454,
0.7485184669,
-0.2454387099,
0.1931265146,
-0.0749255419,
-0.0778345689,
-0.9498634338,
-0.6090543866,
-0.7133929133,
-0.6306408644,
0.5633731484,
0.708660543,
0.7870625854,
0.3023275733,
0.2130956352,
0.1691610515,
-0.0361789837,
0.2889017463,
-0.7548590302,
0.2252256423,
-0.1869050711,
-0.2993786633,
-0.4485949278,
-0.0686010793,
0.5304858088,
0.7982561588,
-0.6242344379,
-0.3825543821,
0.1013123542,
0.1791275591,
-0.3132000566,
0.3804493845,
-0.6033112407,
-0.0118776169,
0.3402945101,
-0.4128442109,
-0.429251492,
-0.0194423255,
0.0145730134,
-0.342438668,
-0.2511561811,
0.0524557494,
0.5191603303,
-0.0220907312,
-0.7186183333,
-0.3121492863,
-0.9382536411,
0.7389250398,
-0.6809551716,
0.091184929,
0.2161452472,
0.2995607853,
-0.5707287192,
-0.375387609,
-0.462084204,
-0.2761290371,
-0.0591599867,
0.1324162781,
0.1814308912,
0.5031079054,
0.3390572369,
-0.0009307931,
-0.3927758634,
0.5184945464,
-0.094555907,
0.0144711584,
0.5374102592,
0.3942145705,
0.2761768103,
0.1631366909,
-0.5904698372,
-0.1960130632,
-0.8181995153,
0.3555951715,
0.3589541912,
0.4878029227,
-0.3914316893,
0.685005188,
-0.3163676262,
0.497664839,
-0.0195422489,
-0.1819554418,
-0.204474777,
-0.2379423082,
-0.0657479987,
0.0425633714,
0.5977243185,
0.7748034,
0.329926759,
-0.1049490944,
-0.4481471777,
0.1354389787,
0.2818148434,
-0.8820883632,
-0.2148801684,
0.1097331494,
-0.23732391,
-0.1776902527,
-0.2181085944,
-0.7925745845,
-0.4656843841,
-0.5969151258,
0.2568825483,
-0.1669226587,
-0.4063915908,
0.3172890544,
0.1823154837,
0.4970397353,
0.5377257466,
-1.0730168819,
0.4823946059,
0.8905717134,
0.8207961321,
0.0322174653,
-0.13502267,
-0.746773839,
0.2580441236,
-0.5550244451,
0.4527021646,
-0.6010016799,
-0.6847577095,
0.3634125888,
-0.3863523006,
-0.2271262109,
-0.0676912442,
0.7914632559,
-0.4060249627,
0.2448596954,
-0.1980343312,
-0.1543640494,
-0.090851374,
0.4192773998,
-0.0211187657,
0.7324610949,
-0.2450597286,
-0.4114715755,
0.2279880196,
-0.5988852382,
-0.5725102425,
-0.0503663421,
-0.5545047522,
-0.0866985321,
0.1416349858,
0.0069981618,
0.4407107234,
-0.242525816,
0.6712779999,
-0.3045908511,
-0.2666057646,
0.2097171247,
-0.3551401496,
0.5339764953,
-0.178870216,
-0.2144134343,
0.5143584609,
-0.4804537594,
0.4062406421,
0.1280014813,
-0.5265984535,
-0.2459814399,
0.3343092799,
0.0093991049,
0.3629983068,
0.113964349,
-0.3672582507,
0.1505498588,
-0.3148285151,
0.4834088385,
0.808529675,
-0.0449678674,
0.3772209883,
-0.3961047232,
0.395981729,
-0.3244508207,
-0.2098323852,
-0.2784840167,
-0.3898497224,
-0.9160589576,
-0.1569135189,
-0.2121863961,
0.5511769652,
-0.52192837,
0.4846727848,
-0.2700222135,
-0.1807180196,
0.0166154448,
-0.1454273611,
0.6195927262,
0.5066065788,
0.211323604,
-0.2533919215,
-0.3209237456,
-0.8595309854,
-0.2227018476,
-0.4769657552,
-0.0402713753,
0.5347406864,
0.2119520009,
-0.1305194944,
0.8553871512,
-0.5101240277,
-0.0820228904,
-0.5636662841,
0.2437198013,
0.2198537886,
0.4207830429,
0.1795932502,
-0.9371240735,
-0.6682241559,
-0.0450298078,
-0.6490722895,
-0.1741734892,
-0.3275822401,
-0.1382086724,
-0.1101661921,
0.4618515074,
-0.730143249,
0.3987337351,
0.5007179976,
-0.3456347287,
0.590474546,
-0.3322571218,
0.1896335185,
-1.1860730648,
-0.2266493589,
-0.1954373419,
-0.2539486587,
-1.0791954994,
-0.005140495,
-0.0098194862,
-0.3695017099,
-0.168861106,
0.5882009864,
-0.35801512,
0.0039708726,
-0.3973036408,
-0.0754101127,
-0.1233592629,
0.8844965696,
0.5745008588,
0.7350117564,
0.6938902736,
-0.575977385,
0.1766388416,
0.4856692553,
-0.1439219117,
0.7097716928,
-0.7915144563,
0.2951316833,
0.0174211375,
0.4630426764,
-1.0044878721,
-0.396538645,
0.1066203788,
-0.0796976238,
0.4456016719,
-0.4090842307,
-0.3659538031,
-0.366625756,
-0.1940455735,
0.0192622952,
0.3879662454,
-0.5305989981,
0.6761749387,
0.4372211397,
-0.2505604625,
-0.3439573348,
-0.5665456653,
0.5590642691,
-0.4570504129,
-0.81523633,
0.3713856936,
-0.255123198,
-0.4378523827,
-0.5344673395,
-0.120613493,
-0.0157331713,
-0.0068785003,
0.4445555508,
0.1287233084,
-0.153279826,
0.0176077876,
-0.1189166307,
-0.0542568229,
0.2369514406,
-0.3172239959,
0.8388570547,
-0.0620699599,
-0.4935951233,
-0.4229202867,
0.8130206466,
0.5851538777,
-0.0913391262,
0.8471730947,
0.1220482662,
-0.223488614,
-0.2207472771,
-0.4690305889,
-0.3108280599,
-0.4661456645,
0.3330540955,
-0.6439893246,
-0.9341416955,
0.4902287424,
-0.3289267719,
0.517796576,
-0.3142437637,
0.5515547991,
-0.2565331161,
1.0897732973,
0.7295315862,
0.1955299228,
0.3368143439,
0.0145317595,
0.5104581118,
-0.786703229,
-0.3733670712,
-0.4264104366,
-0.3707620502,
-0.3226090372,
-0.4634587765,
0.3102671504,
0.2292224765,
-0.0787966251,
0.2522688508,
0.0467153564,
0.2863886952,
0.5444335938,
0.1195288152,
0.1263694316,
-0.0193747506,
-0.3898176253,
-0.000714206,
-0.7795811296,
-0.7678191066,
0.7986409664,
0.4674091935,
0.936897397,
0.2269114405,
0.7116607428,
0.1492885053,
0.0176134277,
-0.738125205,
0.8154711723,
0.2558137774,
-0.3896726668,
-0.3011633158,
-0.5342987776,
-0.6359251738,
0.4635311663,
-0.286755383,
-0.8899284005,
-0.1858002692,
0.3513993919,
-0.172047317,
0.2347532213,
-0.7468716502,
1.0416287184,
-0.6762188077,
-0.3542428613,
-0.5398332477,
-0.7271373868,
0.3273920417,
0.0954153687,
0.1150008291,
-0.297588408,
0.1127414405,
0.6079491973,
-0.3800919056,
1.0846143961,
-0.3530151546,
0.0185426585,
0.2783263028,
0.0544218086,
0.9092653394,
0.1281877458,
0.2054360807,
0.0614889637,
-0.315076381,
-0.3224665225,
-0.5533221364,
0.7212135196,
-0.6441862583,
-1.0601053238,
-0.3039808571,
-0.6159838438,
-0.4874514639,
0.2133352757,
-0.1770728827,
0.4771365225,
-0.5212090611,
0.1658446491,
0.8099242449,
-0.2404282689,
0.3339579403,
0.705947578,
-0.3124575615,
-0.1657856554,
0.2682296634,
-0.3423418403,
0.6937817335,
0.358148694,
0.3406201005,
-0.4649194181,
-0.7812129855,
-0.5121163726,
0.1850125194,
-0.5740974545,
0.1307847649,
-0.691552341,
-0.2827484608,
-0.0458615534,
-0.3453429043,
-0.3034875989,
-0.3040598631,
-0.1836763769,
-0.2195678055,
0.1854398698,
0.4375040829,
0.133783415,
0.5822280645,
-0.3276090622,
0.2448748648,
0.4682992697,
0.1455079168,
-0.3216651678,
-0.6991114616,
0.0829319358,
0.3529523909,
0.0153002897,
-0.619517684,
0.291439414,
-0.0662621707,
0.6784064174,
0.4613177478,
0.1779265404,
0.788654089,
-0.7030895352,
0.3691832721,
0.5519405603,
-0.4043406546,
0.5770967007,
-0.6973765492,
0.2141432017,
0.6516956091,
0.0631022751,
-0.9210722446,
-0.253105104,
-0.2632123232,
-0.615408957,
0.868437171,
0.097974278,
0.6258907318,
0.2374985516,
0.0769755319,
-0.2147977203,
0.2588412762,
-0.8620594144,
0.0751999021,
0.020745581,
-0.0311603397,
0.0140402708,
-0.539804697,
-0.5779461265,
0.3443012238,
0.4726863205,
-0.2864414454,
0.1031677574,
-0.3235610425,
0.2314687073,
-0.2345427275,
0.6029551029,
0.7352025509,
0.7343065143,
-0.1563915163,
0.325175792,
0.08928556,
-0.0412351638,
0.0970430523,
0.0147227421,
-0.2428884506,
-0.4920043349,
0.2281052023,
1.0162893534,
0.5498301983,
-0.7088827491,
0.4121379852,
-0.2254694551,
-0.1010320187,
-0.3358915448,
0.3551727831,
0.3248998821,
0.2664227486,
0.1045780927,
0.1089082807,
-0.3841687441,
-0.6432980299,
0.0159659721,
0.7694364786,
-0.4135560393,
-0.2305087,
0.4131574333,
0.5754793882,
-0.8685901761,
0.3743557632,
-0.1046634689,
-0.7643722296,
0.3564614654,
0.6070368886,
0.8138449788,
-0.0707325116,
0.1901733577,
0.1566270441,
0.1993575543,
-0.146873638,
0.2837336957,
-0.1254310459,
-0.8669676781,
-0.2411086559,
-0.5514898896,
-0.5295661688,
0.1632643491,
-0.4686463177,
0.4488355517,
-0.529220283,
0.1002253592,
-0.3957402706,
-0.0984103158,
-0.3245227635,
-0.096690461,
0.1558619589,
0.7133853436,
-0.8704174757,
0.7593719363,
0.4752066433,
-0.0060231457,
-0.8985071182,
0.1541362703,
0.2127123624,
-0.9060528278,
0.2763675153,
0.3678655922,
-0.4249128997,
-0.0706669316,
-0.1993653625,
-0.6091606021,
1.0591044426,
0.1020420194,
-0.843459487,
-0.1093665287,
0.1552174091,
0.6166687012,
-0.5228618979,
0.0976696759,
0.2823020816,
0.2689313591,
0.5574341416,
-0.9562370181,
-0.1957112402,
0.117412217,
-0.0536462888,
0.3167937994,
-0.8488137722,
0.4215124547,
-0.3131463826,
-0.3547841907,
0.0914686993,
0.6960297227,
0.3671739101,
0.2850755453,
0.6109309196,
0.4820711017,
0.6540108323,
0.0629380494,
0.8314662576,
-0.1017894,
-0.0369090065,
1.4326587915,
-0.77178514,
0.7785831094,
0.484265238,
0.1076734364,
0.3518417478,
0.5018413067,
0.5278314948,
0.5719106197,
0.1726832688,
-0.4174973369,
-0.3576925099,
-0.1941382289,
-0.0623090006,
0.5359198451,
0.5225204229,
-0.0578047521,
-0.1633421183,
-0.2063070387,
0.2916707397,
0.4737620354,
-0.3323055804,
0.779142797,
0.1627530307,
-1.0551211834,
0.4880327582,
0.3120640218,
0.3244423866,
-0.7331278324,
-0.1040908843,
-0.2112089247,
0.1562262475,
0.0447963253,
-0.891854167,
0.0910231993,
0.1641530842,
-0.0590555519,
-0.744017899,
0.6052740812,
-0.8057810664,
-0.3561986983,
0.4849246442,
0.254181385,
0.0251630768,
0.170695141,
-0.6630196571,
-0.0305207297,
0.1336427927,
-0.1577386856,
0.3513988554,
0.4316504598,
-0.3542753756,
0.7885907888,
0.6553173661,
0.0677933097,
0.0398822278,
0.2617845833,
1.0113492012,
-0.4756313264,
-0.8269467354,
-0.6085710526,
0.5583733916,
-0.296651721,
-0.264278084,
0.6581916213,
0.5135056973,
0.5498664975,
0.2099038064,
0.5884987712,
0.1111450717,
0.4289254844,
-0.9139972925,
0.3182687163,
-0.101031974,
0.4193707407,
0.1869133264,
-0.8682005405,
-0.1797604114,
0.6886424422,
-0.3691305518,
0.1054155231,
0.4514412284,
1.0922145844,
-0.3261078894,
0.0337394848,
0.4745121896,
0.0545115769,
0.6171341538,
0.7938299179,
1.2211704254,
0.3121859431,
0.4776311219,
0.0768226087,
-0.4776586592,
-0.2641911805,
-0.7630072236,
-1.4463611841,
-0.1965273321,
-0.2444531769,
-0.1558442414,
0.11526452,
0.967354238,
1.0012259483,
-0.6869708896,
-0.5768238306,
-0.4435280561,
-0.0132587561,
0.1745825112,
-0.145950824,
0.0082124546,
-0.3025228083,
-0.4397155941,
0.8443525434,
0.51581949,
-0.1093307734,
-0.3718144298,
-0.573123157,
-0.3959488273,
0.2494283319,
0.3306788206,
0.36667189,
-0.864539206,
-0.4792163968,
-0.1522416025,
-0.304777205,
0.1779543161,
1.1114330292,
-0.3080029488,
0.5135717988,
0.0951938853,
0.52346766,
0.7570406199,
0.1042547524,
0.7764747143,
-0.8834623098,
0.1986451149,
0.4198614061,
0.3296296299,
0.245976463,
-0.2737652659,
0.3754354715,
-0.071408242,
-0.5446546078,
-0.5755819678,
0.5280970931,
-1.0361293554,
-0.1122988909,
1.3618007898,
-0.2096372694,
0.2417391241,
-0.1231610626,
-0.4744737744,
-0.1739826202,
-0.5814096928,
0.6046739221,
0.6974210143,
-0.116023235,
-0.3180842698,
-0.4909495115,
0.4400847256,
0.5388413072,
-0.8609927893,
0.4220267534,
0.7138171196,
0.0044703851,
0.0642332733,
0.8023771048,
0.289167285,
-0.0160232987,
-0.1229359806,
-0.1993957758,
0.0142397005,
-0.6888391376,
-0.2847805917,
-0.0060243728,
0.2392406464,
-0.048498787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01051v1
|
Generation, Distillation and Evaluation of Motivational Interviewing-Style Reflections with a Foundational Language Model
| 2024-02-01T22:54:31 | 2024-02-01T22:54:31 |
Andrew Brown, Jiading Zhu, Mohamed Abdelwahab, Alec Dong, Cindy Wang, Jonathan Rose
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Foundational Language Models are capable of performing many tasks at a
high level but are difficult to deploy in many applications because of their
size and proprietary ownership. Many will be motivated to distill specific
capabilities of foundational models into smaller models that can be owned and
controlled. In the development of a therapeutic chatbot, we wish to distill a
capability known as reflective listening, in which a therapist produces
reflections of client speech. These reflections either restate what a client
has said, or connect what was said to a relevant observation, idea or guess
that encourages and guides the client to continue contemplation. In this paper,
we present a method for distilling the generation of reflections from a
Foundational Language Model (GPT-4) into smaller models. We first show that
GPT-4, using zero-shot prompting, can generate reflections at near 100% success
rate, superior to all previous methods. Using reflections generated by GPT-4,
we fine-tune different sizes of the GPT-2 family. The GPT-2-small model
achieves 83% success on a hold-out test set and the GPT-2 XL achieves 90%
success. We also show that GPT-4 can help in the labor-intensive task of
evaluating the quality of the distilled models, using it as a zero-shot
classifier. Using triple-human review as a guide, the classifier achieves a
Cohen-Kappa of 0.66, a substantial inter-rater reliability figure.
|
[
-0.3473554552,
-0.6003223062,
0.7944561243,
0.278139025,
-0.3414716125,
0.2066641897,
-0.3394334018,
-0.282422334,
-0.0264413916,
0.4346555471,
-0.4345195293,
-0.4461557269,
-0.6035727262,
0.1065865234,
-0.3871085048,
1.3580123186,
-0.0265741441,
0.2172790766,
0.3487466872,
0.1316034347,
-0.9597901106,
-0.2884616554,
-0.4093312323,
-0.4596781731,
0.2461118102,
0.3422116935,
0.2664466202,
0.1979449838,
0.2822675705,
0.3117898107,
-0.0390000157,
-0.2327268273,
-0.7946524024,
0.3720145524,
-0.1053040698,
-0.5266749859,
-0.3420226276,
0.3726536632,
0.386346072,
0.7117792368,
-0.5096555948,
0.3781681657,
0.4174435735,
0.458966285,
-0.5527158976,
0.4297721386,
-0.8632583022,
-0.0570751578,
0.1828895509,
-0.3436844051,
-0.6564870477,
-0.3821403384,
0.3327203691,
-0.1533213109,
0.5461039543,
-0.2985243499,
0.5080473423,
0.1218450963,
-0.3159898818,
-0.3283402622,
-1.0169790983,
0.881953299,
-0.6571681499,
0.1046301574,
0.3851154447,
0.5274851322,
0.0146494107,
-0.6097833514,
-0.4767075777,
-0.5596866608,
-0.0490320176,
0.1951515973,
-0.0401633903,
0.1327442378,
0.2257377058,
0.4606487155,
-0.356703788,
-0.4902089536,
-0.4897212386,
0.0184338205,
0.3574738801,
0.2381996512,
-0.0043542259,
0.0825515836,
-0.1188657507,
0.0145114837,
-0.5332608819,
-0.1922669858,
-0.0223762803,
0.3974489272,
0.1681020707,
0.3639630675,
-0.2556371987,
0.6681835651,
0.5667276978,
-0.5322276354,
0.1651458591,
-0.3837088943,
0.0479575545,
0.260748148,
0.7233750224,
0.5645328164,
-0.0121164434,
-0.031874381,
-0.1902830452,
0.26843822,
0.4527976513,
-1.1646071672,
-0.3444562256,
0.1439327002,
-0.4994499981,
-0.5389023423,
-0.3878459036,
-0.5575623512,
-0.224000439,
-0.342972517,
0.4244815707,
-0.4809766114,
-0.4777677059,
0.2844200134,
-0.2748860419,
0.2349545658,
0.4533473253,
-1.0274419785,
0.367241174,
0.5174569488,
1.0699243546,
0.1515824497,
-0.0335739963,
-0.4354537725,
0.1355953664,
-0.3211992085,
0.5238535404,
-0.4571964443,
-0.6351329088,
-0.0593455881,
-0.2471748888,
0.0905814245,
-0.4643556476,
0.4051887095,
-0.157939136,
0.5889632702,
-0.2256524563,
-0.4203781784,
-0.0881050006,
0.7035044432,
-0.4222783744,
0.7061843872,
0.4714570045,
-0.6477312446,
0.3958228827,
-0.7047094703,
-0.1399802864,
0.3001835048,
-0.5763968825,
-0.2087650597,
0.309376508,
-0.0368268155,
0.2654287517,
-0.4982134104,
0.3648927212,
-0.1425990462,
-0.4390590489,
0.0950543731,
-0.4291442335,
0.6069051027,
0.0954075158,
-0.7291851044,
-0.2013673037,
-0.6510636806,
0.0920091644,
0.0874701217,
-0.3208249807,
-0.1732297987,
-0.1456491798,
-0.0800567269,
0.4269637764,
0.0678349957,
-0.78253901,
-0.0740335286,
-0.3319056332,
0.4742920697,
0.5572018027,
0.3431079388,
0.0754215047,
-0.4177854657,
0.7404873967,
-0.0732497424,
0.1723963618,
-0.1967150718,
-0.4259622097,
-0.675804913,
-0.3630936444,
-0.023532873,
0.1977056861,
-0.7407790422,
0.285302639,
-0.2874482572,
-0.7140147686,
-0.5676295757,
0.1581187546,
0.6243985891,
0.901779294,
0.310449481,
-0.383641839,
-0.4140456617,
-0.805742979,
-0.0220813956,
-0.3219978809,
-0.174286887,
0.2845771313,
0.4174155295,
0.0373832323,
0.9878565669,
-0.5917330384,
-0.3957610726,
-0.4706680477,
0.4426929057,
0.4860113859,
0.5236281753,
0.7115852833,
-0.5796179175,
-1.0414917469,
-0.1205984578,
-0.6642064452,
-0.1194183826,
0.0674979836,
-0.0787799582,
-0.1354661733,
-0.0370806418,
-0.4719660878,
0.4395766556,
0.4034129977,
-0.2003154308,
0.5956529379,
0.0894993842,
0.2965930104,
-1.0351345539,
0.2205640823,
-0.1034913957,
-0.2024009079,
-0.8487564325,
-0.1919462085,
-0.3950887322,
-0.0810462013,
-0.4125527143,
0.106081672,
-0.5339770317,
0.3887412548,
-0.4146404266,
0.1840572804,
0.1770209521,
0.5628963709,
0.3525652885,
0.4545352757,
0.3996778727,
-0.2426309586,
0.3059017956,
0.3803034425,
-0.3534668982,
0.6808189154,
-0.8979871273,
0.4635172784,
0.0295301583,
0.3816365302,
-1.0364044905,
0.0872458369,
0.0840996727,
-0.3180314302,
0.2849861681,
-0.4136721492,
-0.141314432,
-0.1715720743,
-0.5053399205,
0.3437612653,
0.7361677289,
-0.2472756058,
0.5343005657,
0.2744375765,
-0.2897237837,
-0.4982439578,
-0.6664081216,
0.1034900695,
-0.3233169913,
-0.4900262058,
0.1544992328,
-0.1864933819,
-0.2189866751,
-0.176538676,
-0.1015764922,
0.1364819705,
-0.0342735387,
0.3600848615,
0.5295083523,
-0.2150129229,
-0.3508815467,
-0.0513696969,
-0.2433944046,
0.1073290333,
-0.2141398489,
0.6374192238,
-0.5313111544,
-0.32561782,
-0.5849329829,
0.4613857865,
0.3655436933,
0.0650682896,
0.7059617639,
0.4950006604,
-0.0741763636,
-0.072159715,
-0.8868302703,
-0.4976822436,
-0.4749040306,
0.1903441697,
-0.4583857656,
-1.0022982359,
0.358982861,
0.0455284975,
0.1256878227,
0.1082253978,
0.9556017518,
0.1450773031,
1.3002291918,
0.5251110196,
0.0173946433,
0.5946480632,
-0.3263225853,
0.3506432176,
-0.8527207375,
0.0006641545,
-0.4421521425,
-0.2984693348,
-0.4181699753,
-0.1453379095,
0.607640624,
0.0085407197,
-0.0374303944,
0.2967137098,
-0.9406219721,
0.4349167049,
0.4535716474,
0.0458248779,
0.4829572439,
-0.2604322433,
-0.0378429629,
-0.0577446558,
-0.2634806037,
-0.7844429612,
1.0997035503,
0.2771214843,
0.5287825465,
0.2982554436,
0.929071486,
0.0558733083,
0.9058075547,
-0.7708024979,
0.5317617655,
0.347105056,
-1.030816555,
-0.235958159,
-0.3327980936,
-0.6857200265,
0.5784192681,
0.1343526393,
-0.8044395447,
0.1038828641,
0.3567045331,
-0.4086958766,
-0.1679290831,
-0.6137248874,
0.8392516375,
-0.0229375511,
-0.2911767066,
-0.2829112411,
-0.6496608257,
0.6668354273,
-0.1142686978,
-0.1033601463,
-0.2276880294,
0.4667236805,
0.372846961,
-0.6118446589,
0.8812419772,
-0.6352487803,
-0.1400722265,
0.5602498055,
0.4660544395,
0.2652029991,
-0.0294614341,
0.0085670119,
-0.0467464812,
0.4754087627,
-0.1571384668,
-0.7401459813,
0.3662923276,
-0.5119763613,
-0.7275633216,
-0.322465688,
-0.1975052059,
-0.4792114794,
0.2499129325,
0.3026144207,
0.3285988569,
-0.4814568758,
0.4652868509,
0.2861765027,
0.1059850454,
0.1478232741,
0.9115554094,
-0.3187719882,
-0.1394518316,
0.8270241618,
0.0182409361,
0.4289649725,
0.0638634786,
0.4241520762,
-0.2481158376,
-0.685988605,
-0.1998101026,
0.1547078341,
-0.5635799766,
-0.0595242046,
-0.3392373025,
-0.121266745,
-0.4076748192,
-0.0168230403,
-0.4639032483,
-0.3264548182,
0.0410131291,
-0.2440505028,
0.0502667204,
0.588943541,
-0.0785161629,
0.1688984036,
-0.7444887757,
0.1199356541,
0.3185811639,
0.1226611659,
0.0016109466,
-0.5933042765,
-0.2394049764,
0.2480416298,
-0.5291625261,
-0.93800807,
0.43372944,
0.1579023898,
0.28306517,
0.4316247702,
0.0399341285,
0.5472995043,
-0.6470471621,
0.949375689,
0.4550358653,
-0.9790897369,
0.7284647822,
-0.5130153298,
-0.0260039251,
1.0752261877,
0.1754256487,
-0.6143889427,
-0.4764511287,
-0.4398999214,
-0.6507613063,
0.6974130869,
0.2175992876,
0.1804351807,
-0.2481620163,
0.376280427,
0.1466747522,
0.4774062335,
-0.7293327451,
0.1654922217,
-0.6214989424,
-0.2604612112,
0.0490987934,
-0.3712590635,
-0.5517539978,
-0.0683678687,
0.7557352781,
-0.2514480054,
0.1437297314,
0.0576132573,
0.024571877,
0.0759076029,
0.312893033,
0.4316432774,
0.4761299789,
-0.4757680297,
0.1231811047,
-0.0176091641,
-0.626105547,
0.3689327538,
-0.140707463,
-0.1400049627,
0.1743788719,
0.2391042262,
0.6846897602,
-0.0558093227,
-0.5527490377,
0.7982194424,
-0.3416244388,
-0.3404324651,
-0.4475914836,
0.1878631413,
-0.037753392,
0.1106245816,
0.1116419435,
-0.3266531825,
0.5109121799,
-0.6954115033,
-0.0835343227,
0.3447499871,
-0.4801039994,
-0.4472040832,
0.4662772417,
0.2776584327,
-0.2303452194,
0.7370554209,
-0.2294342071,
-0.3256299794,
0.0131595014,
0.639146924,
1.161052227,
-0.3162380755,
0.3578186631,
0.273172915,
-0.0781904683,
-0.2569655776,
0.3022536635,
-0.468665868,
-0.8837171197,
-0.5096606016,
-0.5734149814,
-0.5618135929,
0.1991952211,
-1.0829173326,
-0.0883147717,
-0.3242756128,
-0.3839173317,
-0.0147673776,
-0.0738034323,
-0.5556598902,
-0.1057222709,
0.040329136,
0.4472337365,
-0.808401525,
0.758007884,
0.2542328835,
-0.7643627524,
-1.0549603701,
-0.2339195609,
0.2753838301,
-0.6888189316,
0.7520669699,
0.240035668,
-0.553640902,
-0.1541205347,
-0.5576010942,
-0.5346298814,
1.2386381626,
0.6038269997,
-0.5731832981,
-0.0950143933,
0.142955333,
0.8625743985,
-0.4371224344,
0.3370411396,
0.9119457006,
0.3466950357,
0.3194103241,
-1.1486213207,
0.1929504573,
-0.4708646536,
0.2427706122,
-0.0933505744,
-0.5209053755,
0.6437023282,
0.0420904495,
-0.2025634497,
0.1327467263,
0.0953435153,
0.5294575095,
0.0799060091,
0.6919358969,
0.1904574782,
0.3868742585,
-0.0476174131,
0.7558587193,
-0.6932948828,
0.4499874413,
1.4473469257,
-0.7829860449,
0.762345314,
0.5562129021,
-0.0991693959,
0.6416951418,
0.1180758253,
0.005720451,
0.6366925836,
0.183807835,
-0.5705828071,
-0.0112016061,
-0.1223510504,
-0.3159435093,
0.6343969703,
0.3048785031,
-0.4711843133,
-0.097494185,
-0.0247051064,
0.0358858854,
0.038129203,
0.1541877836,
0.8590853214,
0.1202078536,
-1.0043208599,
0.7917371392,
-0.150762558,
0.2418782264,
-0.5081347823,
-0.284252733,
-0.0798088759,
0.4033468366,
-0.0305272862,
-0.5512827635,
0.2349598855,
0.1367483586,
-0.099144347,
-0.5452203751,
0.4197206795,
-0.5467247963,
-0.3354175985,
0.1679142118,
0.5065206885,
0.3982201517,
-0.1763413697,
-0.5716507435,
0.0235463437,
0.1485644728,
-0.5087483525,
0.3275820911,
0.323130548,
0.2997636497,
0.4178864062,
0.5757892728,
0.1573562175,
-0.2941342592,
0.4330838919,
0.9538279176,
-0.5253074765,
-0.3678059876,
-0.9555929899,
0.5516437292,
-0.1301387548,
-0.2467692345,
0.767939806,
0.4525314867,
0.4725567698,
-0.0415165275,
0.8690363169,
-0.121793136,
0.8495725989,
-0.3120426536,
0.5080897212,
-0.0710964575,
0.2272544056,
-0.5441304445,
-0.9136604071,
-0.0193529408,
0.9615837336,
-0.3253021538,
0.2067627907,
0.6352584362,
0.7789199352,
0.2296470702,
0.1963321567,
0.338619709,
0.3092390895,
0.8173533082,
0.6444296241,
1.0917514563,
-0.047904443,
0.4398852885,
-0.2382948846,
-0.5348447561,
-0.1592283398,
-0.8903886676,
-0.7969849706,
-0.5337742567,
-0.318357408,
-0.571218133,
-0.2463656813,
0.7802711725,
0.8869544268,
-0.6524779201,
-0.2545755804,
-0.2086788118,
-0.5880735517,
-0.2178161591,
-0.2470188886,
0.1256193668,
-0.2967478633,
-0.6123623252,
0.4718081355,
0.4092408717,
-0.0900208578,
-0.6641585827,
-0.0080610476,
0.2166820914,
0.0346895829,
0.5853459239,
0.0604330599,
-0.5618450046,
-0.4987341166,
-0.2331999838,
0.0653024837,
0.0685167462,
0.9365272522,
-0.6836664677,
0.5595006943,
0.1742127985,
0.2599906027,
0.9759497643,
0.1209390908,
0.7529874444,
-0.6737682819,
0.1283957809,
0.6599231958,
0.4047819078,
0.229926154,
-0.1892061532,
0.6606752276,
-0.0407398008,
-0.6100698113,
-1.0290545225,
0.2751964629,
-0.926723659,
0.0120616201,
0.940495193,
-0.3392273486,
0.0896991119,
-0.1750906408,
-0.6129974723,
0.1048540249,
-0.3638188839,
1.0972925425,
0.8129431009,
-0.4353809059,
-0.0608612634,
-0.4789266586,
0.4974955618,
0.3529932201,
-0.3522799015,
0.0690675974,
0.7135806084,
0.6318400502,
0.4589229226,
1.1184014082,
-0.3012003303,
0.1451095641,
0.1972167045,
0.206588015,
0.0602639318,
0.0246554539,
-0.2322298884,
0.3134227693,
0.3400454521,
-0.2108821869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01786v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01786v2
|
COA-GPT: Generative Pre-trained Transformers for Accelerated Course of Action Development in Military Operations
| 2024-02-01T21:51:09 | 2024-03-28T15:22:42 |
Vinicius G. Goecks, Nicholas Waytowich
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7
|
The development of Courses of Action (COAs) in military operations is
traditionally a time-consuming and intricate process. Addressing this
challenge, this study introduces COA-GPT, a novel algorithm employing Large
Language Models (LLMs) for rapid and efficient generation of valid COAs.
COA-GPT incorporates military doctrine and domain expertise to LLMs through
in-context learning, allowing commanders to input mission information - in both
text and image formats - and receive strategically aligned COAs for review and
approval. Uniquely, COA-GPT not only accelerates COA development, producing
initial COAs within seconds, but also facilitates real-time refinement based on
commander feedback. This work evaluates COA-GPT in a military-relevant scenario
within a militarized version of the StarCraft II game, comparing its
performance against state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms. Our
results demonstrate COA-GPT's superiority in generating strategically sound
COAs more swiftly, with added benefits of enhanced adaptability and alignment
with commander intentions. COA-GPT's capability to rapidly adapt and update
COAs during missions presents a transformative potential for military planning,
particularly in addressing planning discrepancies and capitalizing on emergent
windows of opportunities.
|
[
-0.43958655,
-1.0622289181,
0.5812779665,
0.5051814318,
-0.271694988,
0.5042669773,
-0.2836253047,
0.0999877825,
0.0523685627,
0.4687488973,
-0.9045588374,
-0.3359403908,
-0.5750175714,
-0.1509332806,
-0.1028338075,
1.2022945881,
-0.2646523416,
-0.2367447913,
0.2192937136,
0.0296760965,
-0.6922702193,
-0.6959112883,
-1.1013047695,
-0.1731679291,
0.0909585506,
0.2576123476,
0.7397649288,
0.5597971678,
0.7912184,
0.30641675,
0.2453024089,
0.3705140948,
-0.6179389358,
0.0435063615,
-0.3209213018,
0.0209772494,
-0.5659515858,
-0.0380893014,
0.3256781399,
0.2586360276,
-0.25936988,
0.1594783962,
-0.2099690437,
0.4756121635,
-0.4632050395,
0.4225761294,
-0.5492480397,
0.0509604327,
0.1452485472,
-0.2894708514,
-0.3262509406,
0.0523222759,
0.57512784,
-0.9784265161,
0.1824364662,
0.10909044,
0.4688913524,
0.1864673942,
-0.1812163889,
-0.387791127,
-0.9132381082,
0.5402300358,
-0.2314575016,
0.3900895417,
0.1693645269,
0.3691803217,
-0.4317798913,
-0.8897881508,
-0.3588373959,
-0.2016438544,
0.1571621746,
0.6259225011,
0.0270019304,
0.0483100936,
0.3347450793,
-0.0195307862,
-0.6988971829,
0.1728216261,
-0.3200682104,
-0.0419826098,
0.758476615,
0.219695881,
-0.1122465804,
0.1248229817,
-0.679813385,
-0.1652363092,
-0.8284091353,
0.2160720974,
0.146879524,
-0.0058450005,
-0.5053775907,
0.5131180882,
-0.1966216713,
0.4124227166,
0.4226076305,
-0.0389926322,
-0.4292654395,
0.0276985522,
-0.3567961454,
0.032402575,
0.6915414929,
0.1553493142,
0.1173061728,
0.0419679768,
-0.3546324372,
0.2451902777,
0.5879956484,
-0.7479747534,
-0.2119193226,
0.1403278112,
-0.3317491412,
-0.524887085,
0.0863030702,
-0.5619801283,
-0.2395156026,
-0.3662088215,
0.2854911983,
-0.3824369311,
-0.2919933498,
-0.0781366006,
0.0815241858,
0.3721479774,
0.2298832685,
-0.7450196147,
0.0042316173,
0.6801463962,
0.7408188581,
-0.433126539,
-0.2285173982,
-0.8925810456,
0.2964851558,
-0.4696903527,
0.79920578,
-0.6403872371,
-0.8691988587,
0.1788408011,
-0.1949570924,
0.2820714116,
-0.4947331548,
0.4720740318,
-0.830632031,
-0.1077999622,
-0.0756097808,
-0.2755378783,
-0.1063823923,
0.36959216,
-0.3638534546,
0.8526236415,
0.3802245259,
-0.1787781268,
0.6117984653,
-0.8900473118,
-0.6946092844,
0.3032277822,
-0.2429538071,
-0.6012192965,
0.0767961815,
0.4187237918,
0.5432422161,
-0.3995202482,
0.251738131,
-0.0977667198,
-0.363832891,
0.0648507178,
-0.3456141353,
0.3151195645,
0.1873037964,
-0.5870847106,
0.4751678109,
-0.391456604,
0.0920384005,
0.0699296519,
-0.3152896762,
0.1768116504,
0.2903110981,
-0.4306347072,
0.426966548,
-0.1017439216,
0.0429492854,
0.5605259538,
-0.25767681,
0.346698761,
0.9714081287,
0.304050982,
0.552521348,
-0.1113259122,
0.5921958089,
-0.0088476595,
0.5936856866,
0.0035385063,
-0.3829184175,
-0.8724191189,
-0.2187510729,
0.0170814618,
0.5990875959,
-1.2770587206,
0.3870135248,
-0.2358380109,
-0.6142734289,
-0.0531179048,
-0.0650828704,
0.3853771985,
0.3160080314,
0.6236540079,
-0.555321157,
-0.4583544433,
-0.3106307685,
-0.0622193813,
-0.479671061,
0.1512628198,
0.0268667936,
0.447119236,
-0.2208359241,
0.6203132272,
-0.573985517,
-0.1648285836,
-0.3727229834,
0.4590729475,
-0.3377776742,
0.2654182315,
0.2218086571,
-0.8132907748,
-0.4951957762,
0.1232233569,
-0.8452577591,
0.1846578568,
-0.3625734448,
-0.2026799619,
0.0061637694,
0.5794480443,
-0.5389618278,
0.6009579301,
0.3729737699,
-0.1895532012,
0.6181979775,
-0.2221539617,
0.2035233229,
-0.5718348622,
-0.0629293621,
-0.397108078,
0.0737529844,
-0.7799701691,
0.2322732061,
-0.0390820242,
-0.4910756648,
-0.6235440373,
0.3750641942,
-0.3907257318,
-0.0559035875,
-0.3674837947,
0.1424476653,
-0.4474734962,
0.7298600674,
0.3842556775,
0.97715801,
0.4553322196,
-1.0135278702,
0.3351641893,
0.3499337435,
-0.0339728743,
0.7040299177,
-0.4857661724,
0.1539641619,
-0.0014754114,
0.4317811728,
-0.37650913,
-0.073431462,
0.1144803613,
-0.0329984687,
0.1183541715,
-0.2792935967,
-0.0465374179,
-0.3147117198,
0.1279269755,
0.3933082819,
0.7421572804,
-0.411526531,
0.7601288557,
0.209297508,
-0.0784034058,
-0.5424367785,
-0.1311303824,
-0.3467745185,
-0.0963812619,
-0.269649148,
0.2785288393,
-0.0747017115,
-0.0059847892,
-0.2594366372,
-0.2424334735,
0.0567534715,
-0.0153234983,
0.4750684798,
0.3413357139,
0.0310292598,
-0.0420473181,
-0.1182926372,
-0.1209873259,
-0.030391017,
-0.5516607165,
0.8006721735,
-0.0756039843,
-0.4505330324,
-0.0294878464,
0.3699208796,
0.4221765697,
-0.6866240501,
0.1763378084,
0.8042945862,
0.2136810124,
-0.4851477444,
-0.426166743,
-0.060448695,
-0.5264433622,
0.3339805305,
-0.2707000375,
-0.6625090837,
0.1832375526,
-0.7384305596,
0.3286392689,
0.4478456676,
0.423435092,
-0.0439787991,
0.7719657421,
0.6892828941,
0.087940298,
0.5382883549,
-0.4732590318,
0.1830417067,
-0.7308263183,
-0.2346129268,
0.1439591497,
-0.298873961,
-0.5741974711,
-0.6612746119,
0.6300650239,
-0.0394636206,
-0.5383464694,
0.1585277915,
-0.323140949,
0.299297601,
0.1637113839,
0.0726720765,
-0.0880947113,
0.2130810469,
0.0737300739,
0.1786955744,
-0.823159337,
-0.1599884033,
1.0492188931,
0.0279994402,
0.5651689172,
0.1291959137,
0.7248935103,
0.4374869764,
0.7185433507,
-0.78621912,
0.5853275657,
-0.2996576726,
-0.2660318017,
-0.2425679713,
-0.2302528918,
-0.6591445208,
-0.1829731911,
-0.489997983,
0.1992941499,
-0.0534392595,
0.0600152127,
-0.4449993968,
0.2140566707,
-0.6132670045,
0.6291523576,
-0.4517675936,
-0.4196558595,
-0.235035643,
-0.6182886958,
0.1041208357,
-0.3333242238,
-0.0447614528,
0.1951538771,
-0.1475574523,
0.4872217178,
-0.2757339478,
0.4635978341,
-0.3974662721,
-0.1057554483,
0.6719648838,
0.3162983358,
0.956142664,
0.2092534602,
0.0517765097,
-0.0119856,
-0.7655577064,
-0.340733856,
-0.9034276605,
0.540504396,
-0.6940060258,
-0.656070888,
-0.4162860215,
-0.4865210354,
-0.3228979707,
0.2348545343,
0.1807759404,
0.2766951621,
-0.6821120977,
-0.1758241355,
0.6909605265,
-0.2765792012,
0.4155462682,
0.6939302087,
-0.1017922834,
-0.3909805417,
0.9159868956,
0.0802526399,
0.5462034345,
0.3438860178,
-0.1149919033,
-0.1839451194,
-0.5654727817,
-0.5709760785,
-0.0092409085,
-0.3803082705,
-0.226802215,
-0.1230824068,
-0.2383082062,
0.090655677,
-0.62049824,
-0.4076559842,
-0.1890185922,
0.0930978581,
0.0103776334,
0.2587530613,
0.949418366,
0.1338160932,
0.6638671756,
-0.3555122018,
0.406630218,
0.1887623817,
0.2526267469,
-0.3559224308,
-0.3626127541,
-0.1049589589,
0.0909388214,
-0.6808103919,
-0.4157566428,
0.1922276914,
0.1381934285,
0.2649676204,
0.2354456782,
-0.1701171547,
1.0429923534,
-0.6824762225,
0.9965520501,
0.1621524245,
-0.7591453791,
0.5854715705,
-0.2629540563,
0.3297995627,
0.2262363881,
0.505231142,
-0.138738811,
-0.2455846369,
-0.9282728434,
-0.6321510673,
0.4455616474,
0.1140869483,
-0.1901381314,
-0.1659730822,
0.3579356074,
-0.135836944,
0.0625254214,
-0.1261356324,
-0.157671079,
-0.3764823079,
0.1736414582,
-0.2465752661,
0.0528349094,
-0.2102641612,
0.02368211,
0.8158407807,
-0.1894371808,
0.4319420159,
0.2827661633,
-0.2327613235,
0.1532301605,
0.3410970867,
1.0537568331,
0.4477223158,
0.1011275947,
-0.0730349198,
0.5888327956,
-0.7141852379,
0.4926041663,
-0.1471312791,
-0.097822994,
-0.3751351535,
0.3280327916,
0.8225246072,
0.1457126737,
-0.4644105136,
0.621622026,
0.0575791784,
-0.3109562993,
-0.3649544716,
-0.0825825706,
-0.3273192048,
0.3316475451,
0.1155972183,
0.4668059051,
-0.1800799221,
-0.5564501286,
0.3642556369,
0.298074007,
-0.5843102932,
-0.2306129634,
0.5752962232,
0.3477451205,
-0.2206529081,
0.5744490623,
-0.3843974471,
-0.5220739245,
0.2919704616,
0.6980375051,
0.997163415,
-0.399535954,
0.4314392805,
0.2664054036,
0.2917284667,
-0.1747081727,
0.2688956261,
0.1838629544,
-0.1822890639,
-0.5265931487,
-0.6302176118,
-0.1099907681,
0.1658695936,
-0.2542593777,
0.3790546656,
-0.9680727124,
-0.2908377647,
-0.5863319039,
-0.1415010989,
-0.9926607609,
0.2693273127,
-0.2129248679,
0.6898018718,
-0.4874879122,
0.5162414908,
0.4994660616,
-0.5741647482,
-1.1063971519,
0.1936497092,
-0.1780776978,
-0.8877575994,
0.9806389213,
-0.3782126009,
-0.3215854466,
0.0808720812,
-0.1216792911,
-0.6076092124,
1.1939361095,
0.0061983592,
-0.4859735072,
-0.1275035143,
0.3816482723,
0.4746172726,
-0.488520503,
0.2523690164,
0.5706968904,
0.4608346522,
-0.0873324797,
-0.7244895697,
0.0297363475,
0.2122372836,
-0.0082568759,
0.3236737251,
-0.9129968882,
0.6640086174,
-0.3139156699,
-0.3161617219,
-0.180491671,
0.9235719442,
0.2147694826,
-0.0956453234,
0.4872628152,
0.4434902966,
0.3530809283,
-0.2952461541,
0.9442574382,
-0.1068681628,
0.1225780174,
0.6393145323,
-0.3861258626,
0.8578875661,
0.1903040856,
-0.0687672347,
0.6021677256,
0.2526347041,
-0.1263334602,
0.6835033298,
0.2394254655,
-0.5442457199,
-0.1177801713,
0.124919109,
-0.3220072985,
0.5741332173,
0.302836895,
-0.2242998779,
-0.0574555136,
-0.079960376,
0.095881857,
-0.15330185,
-0.6360458136,
0.9504929185,
-0.1252886504,
-0.9821024537,
0.6958070993,
-0.0158448182,
0.5020518899,
-1.0201432705,
-0.2836759984,
-0.1493349075,
0.1929728091,
-0.2277045697,
-0.7259620428,
0.0915099904,
0.0597328134,
-0.0545841455,
-0.1444111615,
0.4330641329,
-0.3672942519,
-0.3086524904,
0.0213718452,
0.4016530812,
-0.1857481897,
-0.0335235335,
-0.5930252671,
0.2923846245,
-0.0893327519,
-0.0476004034,
0.2454895228,
0.4113616347,
-0.5423077941,
0.6585422158,
0.8210391998,
0.1342640966,
0.0206051022,
-0.1425111592,
0.8036564589,
-0.2966993153,
-0.5005477667,
-0.7074563503,
0.5900648832,
-0.1235031635,
-0.3501228392,
0.4227307737,
0.6120597124,
0.8821693063,
-0.4279712737,
1.0385998487,
-0.2133264542,
-0.1407724172,
-0.6547898054,
0.6236964464,
-0.0443658903,
0.2992313802,
-0.0366582349,
-0.7705501318,
-0.2295080572,
0.4135461748,
-0.4231751859,
-0.0834657177,
0.712729454,
0.6813654304,
-0.4143641591,
-0.1310444027,
0.1539576352,
-0.2449087948,
0.7913810611,
0.5722145438,
0.7608157396,
-0.5081745386,
0.6015431881,
-0.1041528657,
-0.3996409774,
-0.0053892001,
-0.8116919398,
-0.9259158969,
-0.4301776886,
-0.0484389737,
-0.1342386305,
0.3992385268,
0.9644316435,
0.7344760895,
-0.4793125391,
-0.3856197596,
-0.1417957991,
-0.3493151665,
-0.6661451459,
-0.1661507636,
0.5912063718,
-0.4536874592,
-0.2219175994,
0.7323045731,
0.2532855868,
-0.0685977116,
-0.143765837,
-0.525626719,
-0.0332399197,
0.1376477629,
1.1559140682,
0.4561002851,
-0.658385396,
-0.5171592236,
0.0651031807,
0.2689695656,
-0.1887729913,
1.2552719116,
-0.726587534,
0.3727169037,
0.0530925095,
0.7852976918,
0.5671921968,
0.1340104789,
0.7996397614,
-0.9564857483,
0.3233533502,
0.1337620467,
-0.0533784814,
-0.0075188293,
-0.3119474649,
0.718955636,
0.1338413805,
-0.635068357,
-0.4688219428,
0.6623679996,
-1.0259542465,
0.1359371245,
1.0478880405,
-0.1592521518,
0.22028175,
0.0794465616,
-0.5438542962,
0.3574754596,
-0.2320674956,
0.5581542253,
0.6036385894,
-0.16217269,
0.1816639304,
-0.4599768519,
1.0734170675,
0.2271042466,
-0.9817530513,
0.2028153837,
0.2719842494,
0.1202518418,
-0.0358247496,
0.4451926351,
-0.1057679653,
0.5049214363,
-0.0669157431,
-0.2280441076,
-0.2970357537,
-0.4990858138,
0.1248233393,
0.1916937977,
-0.0555374883,
0.3857949376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01035v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01035v2
|
Getting the most out of your tokenizer for pre-training and domain adaptation
| 2024-02-01T21:49:34 | 2024-02-07T10:51:11 |
Gautier Dagan, Gabriel Synnaeve, Baptiste Rozière
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tokenization is an understudied and often neglected component of modern LLMs.
Most published works use a single tokenizer for all experiments, often borrowed
from another model, without performing ablations or analysis to optimize
tokenization. Moreover, the tokenizer is generally kept unchanged when
fine-tuning a base model. In this paper, we show that the size,
pre-tokenization regular expression, and training data of a tokenizer can
significantly impact the model's generation speed, effective context size,
memory usage, and downstream performance. We train specialized Byte-Pair
Encoding code tokenizers, and conduct extensive ablations on the impact of
tokenizer design on the performance of LLMs for code generation tasks such as
HumanEval and MBPP, and provide recommendations for tokenizer hyper-parameters
selection and switching the tokenizer in a pre-trained LLM. We perform our
experiments on models trained from scratch and from pre-trained models,
verifying their applicability to a wide range of use-cases. We find that when
fine-tuning on more than 50 billion tokens, we can specialize the tokenizer of
a pre-trained LLM to obtain large gains in generation speed and effective
context size.
|
[
-0.5226080418,
-0.4280461967,
0.12464156,
0.1716562808,
-0.6596966386,
0.0785279125,
-0.3289943039,
-0.4531618059,
0.1248015761,
0.3782088161,
-0.1783581525,
-0.3916739821,
-0.747633338,
0.1448287964,
-0.0515082553,
1.1521536112,
0.0330944806,
0.140231356,
-0.251878202,
0.041885592,
-0.6678429246,
-1.1058280468,
-0.5825919509,
-0.1078894213,
0.5342875719,
0.1829642802,
0.3671288788,
0.7595098019,
0.5911029577,
0.2703647912,
-0.1337322891,
0.1303493083,
-0.6234105229,
-0.1268144995,
-0.0016169557,
-0.5387907028,
-0.6275562644,
0.0031058358,
0.4970035553,
0.6122690439,
0.1985873878,
0.536975503,
-0.0813823119,
0.3951852024,
-0.8217592835,
-0.1790564358,
-0.9296959639,
0.0915915072,
-0.3120405078,
-0.4325860739,
-0.4705465138,
-0.1040093526,
-0.3273101151,
-0.5877442956,
0.2787152529,
0.149956122,
0.6274138689,
0.3516572714,
-0.454839915,
-0.0145869888,
-0.828744173,
0.854008019,
-0.6707680225,
0.5776865482,
0.1426570117,
0.0583180748,
-0.291595608,
-1.074280858,
-0.3927205503,
-0.0526381657,
-0.1183530763,
-0.0600607805,
-0.0847040564,
0.3680284619,
0.5259876847,
0.2416183501,
-0.3910655975,
0.2262275219,
-0.2763155699,
-0.4545812607,
0.3901562393,
0.1029495373,
0.0847810358,
0.1884090304,
-0.3995161653,
0.1916370094,
-0.965976119,
0.1217889264,
0.244293496,
0.2295840681,
0.3525229692,
0.3989690542,
0.087982893,
0.8425765038,
0.27295807,
0.1172431484,
0.097284317,
-0.6049268246,
-0.2879584134,
-0.1644106507,
0.3786991239,
0.2607031763,
0.3145815432,
-0.3130879998,
-0.4337168038,
-0.0217878707,
0.4587030709,
-1.2576590776,
-0.0552725233,
0.1231478304,
-0.6290798187,
-0.1852279902,
-0.0330500714,
-0.3408089876,
-0.2282577902,
-0.361872822,
0.380915314,
-0.0465411246,
-0.1539494097,
0.2062680125,
-0.2248727679,
0.2182870656,
0.0575381406,
-1.1582581997,
0.2815721631,
0.8437098861,
0.7296923995,
-0.4700655341,
-0.429982245,
-0.9170438647,
0.0315761156,
-0.5045508742,
0.6540731788,
-0.4471202493,
-0.5101670027,
-0.0824803934,
-0.0847803429,
-0.1470347345,
-0.7056755424,
0.1820318401,
-0.8477830291,
-0.2577309906,
-0.259447068,
-0.7149418592,
0.2289267629,
-0.0099823307,
-0.371475786,
0.6814979911,
0.0503900647,
-0.6178233624,
0.9374855757,
-0.6888722777,
-0.516923666,
0.109092921,
-0.0069643119,
-0.280521214,
0.8405831456,
0.054973688,
0.5828487277,
0.1325612515,
0.2176387012,
-0.0614086315,
-0.6911572814,
0.2923247516,
-0.167403698,
0.3582609892,
0.2023832649,
-0.2372210473,
0.3777237236,
-0.8409454226,
-0.0530628972,
-0.1163025945,
-0.6724333167,
-0.1646499336,
-0.1804817021,
0.3579014242,
0.0668347776,
0.2793855071,
-0.5371155739,
0.2821550071,
-0.2595011294,
0.3439363539,
0.9733171463,
0.2064365,
0.406044215,
-0.2372904271,
0.5605617762,
0.1799619049,
0.2984320819,
-0.1930910945,
-0.1343332976,
-0.7650129199,
-0.4578899741,
0.7434253097,
0.0074157687,
-0.3033645451,
0.4666078985,
-0.258544296,
-0.3084509969,
-0.2893647254,
0.2726804614,
0.3188019693,
0.2771815062,
0.2452244014,
-0.6568378806,
-0.6790675521,
-0.726683557,
-0.5252357125,
0.1112821922,
0.0255819298,
0.1315689087,
0.6285347342,
-0.3102349639,
1.011875391,
-0.4032907188,
-0.1104307398,
-0.1849511862,
-0.1011556536,
0.1604683995,
0.7877905369,
0.6006256938,
-0.7851383686,
-0.4064451158,
-0.0966651514,
-0.1535650641,
0.0619380623,
-0.3060655296,
-0.4201975167,
0.0092328852,
0.547760725,
-0.4206081629,
0.3441536427,
0.3850452304,
-0.4001266658,
0.565997541,
-0.281986624,
-0.0574035197,
-1.0583740473,
0.2873645425,
-0.4016265571,
-0.292260617,
-0.8756765127,
0.1971025467,
0.048101794,
0.0035058626,
-0.564835012,
0.7253726125,
-0.4595413804,
-0.2698509395,
-0.310721606,
-0.2398373932,
-0.0576030537,
0.5088288784,
-0.0302221961,
1.1188555956,
0.366248548,
-0.7751957178,
0.0745851174,
0.1417877674,
-0.2155810744,
0.034471374,
-0.6892284751,
0.4922273755,
0.1159329712,
0.0591274723,
-0.7184132934,
-0.086485289,
-0.143625766,
-0.3624014854,
0.3945366442,
-0.4052717686,
-0.5733821988,
-0.1532320231,
-0.2748844326,
0.4726087451,
0.5767352581,
-0.7276123166,
0.8257915974,
0.2689641118,
0.1992594749,
-0.6332100034,
-0.5443665385,
0.0566023476,
-0.2575837672,
-0.355930537,
0.3935703039,
-0.4675843716,
0.2027495354,
-0.2679718435,
-0.4492918551,
-0.0552695431,
0.5844215751,
0.4569154382,
0.1577004939,
-0.2169240862,
0.0632201806,
0.1086961031,
-0.2660607696,
0.058216773,
-0.5108018517,
0.7349540591,
-0.0103870928,
-0.3124234974,
-0.2738093734,
0.0321815759,
0.5555800796,
-0.4367761016,
0.8577001691,
0.6434950829,
-0.2445441782,
-0.1538268179,
-0.5606736541,
-0.1516783684,
-0.5029537082,
0.5908688903,
-0.7011744976,
-0.8555246592,
0.5508571267,
-0.4962277114,
0.3165392876,
-0.014973959,
0.599729538,
0.2743808627,
1.069329381,
0.9349690676,
-0.2190469205,
0.8450312614,
-0.2424852997,
0.1206937209,
-0.8754684925,
0.0704043359,
-0.2880477011,
-0.274518311,
-0.3818792999,
-0.3998734355,
0.0180679318,
0.3495107293,
-0.1257728785,
0.121775724,
-0.3922454715,
0.6708080173,
0.5262752771,
-0.0486692041,
0.1297285408,
0.0414359905,
0.11770951,
0.0832366943,
-0.6704982519,
-0.5882800221,
1.3834507465,
0.260037154,
0.4260249138,
0.0361374542,
0.9301105738,
0.2673539221,
0.501652956,
-0.8235281706,
0.5012824535,
-0.160447523,
-0.6152296662,
-0.0239076503,
-0.3584343791,
-0.9913336039,
0.2747017443,
-0.2041571438,
-0.3572284281,
0.1604971439,
0.3902784586,
-0.4352807701,
0.1708601117,
-0.6255876422,
0.9845377803,
-0.1673325151,
-0.120442234,
-0.158620134,
-0.3870353997,
0.0407271087,
-0.5950479507,
0.1063099653,
0.1748984903,
-0.2618217766,
0.7432420254,
-0.2692585289,
0.8638498187,
-0.4329097867,
0.155333668,
0.0627235696,
-0.0361065157,
0.4368349612,
-0.0797760189,
-0.0340488516,
0.2361133546,
-0.0041111275,
-0.6298047304,
-0.5968047976,
0.3836423457,
-0.8451468349,
-0.83360672,
0.1556628942,
-0.210596174,
-0.1761044562,
0.4886707067,
0.4094942212,
0.4994316995,
-0.3182705343,
0.0910692364,
0.4597231448,
-0.0555335544,
0.3240706921,
0.2999408841,
-0.2241803855,
-0.3132303655,
1.0007698536,
-0.0406600274,
0.2820636332,
0.1579747051,
0.2022223473,
0.016392773,
-1.0602915287,
-0.4625346661,
0.1292430013,
-0.8350172043,
-0.2209603488,
-0.5826483369,
-0.0732253268,
-0.5464442968,
-0.332169354,
-0.3227767944,
-0.3046109378,
-0.483474344,
-0.2642176449,
0.1036488414,
0.5947251916,
-0.0162221882,
0.5517839789,
-0.9010863304,
0.1170235276,
0.2142963409,
0.3291437924,
-0.099582918,
-0.6796194911,
-0.5690108538,
-0.2561294734,
0.1045151204,
-0.4288651645,
0.0810490698,
0.3143392503,
0.5329207778,
0.376832664,
-0.1703795344,
0.8383173943,
-0.6083846092,
0.815109551,
0.0357709788,
-1.1822267771,
0.3169778883,
0.1198488548,
0.1079360694,
0.581646204,
0.2144366801,
-0.5297100544,
-0.0694435611,
-0.2504636645,
-0.776889205,
0.454965204,
-0.0116103329,
0.556966126,
-0.0424453802,
0.8573207259,
0.3261297643,
0.4193545878,
-0.5769996047,
-0.1959263086,
-0.1661292315,
-0.1206879094,
-0.1975681037,
-0.3822080493,
-0.112595208,
-0.2677497864,
0.5080006123,
-0.2766578496,
0.2709774971,
-0.2248684913,
-0.5660971403,
-0.062485598,
0.0305827353,
0.649676919,
0.7213366628,
-0.0241227783,
0.1572667509,
0.3885200322,
-0.6332444549,
0.0620295852,
-0.0937706158,
0.103812173,
-0.0431936942,
0.4723125994,
0.9582858086,
0.1457486898,
-0.6033062935,
0.6810930371,
-0.1973249763,
-0.1471982598,
0.0326924063,
0.3109294176,
-0.1351452023,
0.1639497429,
0.1643701941,
0.3377225995,
-0.0534079783,
-0.2722948194,
0.1930408776,
0.4116614461,
0.0117039187,
-0.4393820763,
0.6084823012,
0.3071712554,
-0.2433713078,
0.330940187,
-0.0346916467,
-0.5875276327,
0.5901586413,
0.6645373106,
0.8559019566,
0.0632935762,
-0.2324679792,
0.07409399,
0.0875480026,
0.1536151171,
0.0055193915,
-0.4043812156,
-0.7926185131,
-0.53321594,
-0.8564994335,
-0.2028828263,
-0.0800181478,
-0.629897356,
0.1796322912,
-0.6099234223,
-0.5652016997,
-0.0988709405,
0.1159475818,
-0.9558076262,
0.1093988717,
0.0300772022,
1.045607686,
-0.7908388972,
0.6736425757,
0.9753227234,
-0.2416056097,
-0.5792274475,
-0.0792437866,
-0.4054863751,
-0.8173987269,
1.0143235922,
0.1210055277,
-0.0607732423,
0.3248209953,
-0.3832068145,
-0.8714085817,
0.9190691113,
0.1890925169,
-0.5529429317,
-0.0391593017,
0.1821113974,
0.5251221657,
-0.4905019403,
0.0878283754,
0.5893867612,
0.2640563846,
-0.1303800493,
-0.6482058167,
0.1441196352,
-0.1553848237,
0.3436635733,
0.1901232153,
-0.6045096517,
0.6141124368,
-0.1534362733,
-0.2248956412,
0.1270823032,
0.5529615283,
0.1783807576,
0.0701842457,
0.6070860624,
0.1139114499,
0.6537008286,
0.2201199979,
0.7958728075,
-0.7323200703,
0.092224583,
0.9250944257,
-0.1867628396,
0.6853570938,
0.7030853629,
0.1101449952,
0.1028019935,
0.783485949,
-0.1569860578,
0.4340292811,
0.619894743,
-0.2755990028,
-0.2505612969,
-0.0015327672,
-0.2105647326,
0.2900116146,
0.0408948287,
-0.3671216667,
0.2185058892,
0.3826371133,
-0.1051629335,
-0.2853964269,
-0.2502560914,
0.9685001373,
-0.039831847,
-0.4430939853,
0.6591288447,
0.0557318553,
0.8132091165,
-0.4701103866,
0.1812706441,
-0.4630272686,
0.2400017232,
-0.2107664198,
-0.0006911504,
0.1230256855,
0.2646589577,
-0.1364435852,
-0.3850097358,
0.8625386953,
0.0110920649,
-0.1560000479,
0.1277294904,
0.5455129743,
0.3444580138,
-0.1250618696,
-0.4056759477,
0.2475872189,
-0.0827380419,
-0.6365984082,
0.6387033463,
0.3950801194,
0.1057522595,
0.2690674067,
0.9545484781,
0.4293570518,
0.4146891832,
0.159359321,
1.1483602524,
-0.7399147749,
-0.1972787976,
-0.904614687,
0.4843625426,
0.1017343327,
-0.5435986519,
0.5255249143,
0.8268565536,
1.0443108082,
-0.1984509379,
0.5891346335,
0.2575102448,
-0.1326290518,
-0.5761457086,
0.6080870628,
-0.5491514802,
0.2089541107,
0.0097265374,
-1.0541625023,
-0.4491716623,
0.3657780588,
-0.0754853636,
0.0615194924,
0.3604572117,
0.6745347381,
0.0330376215,
-0.2964681685,
0.6564138532,
0.0610780194,
0.5805751681,
0.1514539421,
0.8525555134,
-0.2435565889,
0.404137373,
-0.0793720633,
-0.2416116446,
-0.2932192981,
-0.8796249628,
-1.1700518131,
-0.3895608187,
-0.3199438453,
-0.1399807781,
0.0616284348,
1.1103849411,
1.0937644243,
-0.6617694497,
-0.1395308375,
-0.1997322887,
-0.0014455033,
-0.1164590493,
-0.1125307009,
0.1618506908,
-0.7269474268,
-0.6820521355,
0.2815095484,
0.1234211549,
0.176644966,
-0.0006289773,
-0.0013534764,
0.4421342909,
0.2047457993,
0.6912046671,
-0.0477547832,
-0.4435670972,
-0.3950791955,
0.0222797189,
-0.0295976307,
0.1427597702,
1.3586633205,
-0.5634161234,
0.4410517514,
0.2760418952,
0.896255672,
0.5939396024,
-0.0416248888,
0.5874625444,
-0.8591949344,
0.1640336663,
0.1532700509,
0.3387926221,
-0.0152151342,
-0.5581123233,
0.3265941441,
0.2195773721,
-0.5712616444,
-1.0229618549,
0.2978738248,
-0.5269514918,
-0.3324864805,
0.9024848938,
-0.2838771343,
-0.1485976279,
0.0075586066,
-0.2283538878,
0.41573596,
-0.1811001599,
0.5069511533,
0.6364901066,
-0.3014994562,
0.0697857887,
-0.309104681,
0.7413240075,
0.5824185014,
-0.7054956555,
0.2928839624,
0.2996219695,
0.4792762697,
0.0665645674,
0.7462332249,
0.055953715,
0.130355984,
0.0831068978,
0.2405685782,
-0.3614447415,
-0.2583352625,
-0.5493404865,
-0.0004510978,
0.5179951787,
-0.2821415961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01032v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01032v2
|
Repeat After Me: Transformers are Better than State Space Models at Copying
| 2024-02-01T21:44:11 | 2024-06-03T22:22:15 |
Samy Jelassi, David Brandfonbrener, Sham M. Kakade, Eran Malach
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Transformers are the dominant architecture for sequence modeling, but there
is growing interest in models that use a fixed-size latent state that does not
depend on the sequence length, which we refer to as "generalized state space
models" (GSSMs). In this paper we show that while GSSMs are promising in terms
of inference-time efficiency, they are limited compared to transformer models
on tasks that require copying from the input context. We start with a
theoretical analysis of the simple task of string copying and prove that a two
layer transformer can copy strings of exponential length while GSSMs are
fundamentally limited by their fixed-size latent state. Empirically, we find
that transformers outperform GSSMs in terms of efficiency and generalization on
synthetic tasks that require copying the context. Finally, we evaluate
pretrained large language models and find that transformer models dramatically
outperform state space models at copying and retrieving information from
context. Taken together, these results suggest a fundamental gap between
transformers and GSSMs on tasks of practical interest.
|
[
-0.0355821885,
-0.5446330309,
0.9777628183,
0.1064132452,
-0.2749526799,
0.2535628974,
-0.0691535175,
-0.3226661086,
-0.0081693633,
0.3144880235,
-0.1784345955,
0.2024233788,
-0.7753367424,
0.0105974972,
-1.1625592709,
0.8574396968,
-0.0447106399,
-0.2310661077,
-0.3767641485,
0.1738912761,
-0.0337596163,
-0.4190464914,
-0.41201967,
-0.3761129081,
0.283029139,
-0.234812811,
0.9031568766,
0.6225091815,
0.3945269883,
0.328032583,
-0.4423052967,
-0.0046512242,
-0.2819600403,
0.0775460526,
-0.1771659553,
-0.4533378184,
-0.2487751395,
-0.005567593,
0.809447825,
0.7844292521,
-0.2098110914,
0.3098669052,
0.0008485217,
0.4954625368,
-0.506375432,
-0.010698,
-0.4606659114,
0.1489461511,
0.1320465058,
0.0065269163,
-0.5852693319,
-0.5721496344,
0.3050412238,
-0.604902029,
0.3997354209,
-0.0688970163,
0.8150452971,
0.331027627,
-0.4143646359,
-0.2316200733,
-1.3703844547,
0.7479735017,
-0.477714479,
0.522977531,
0.0212133396,
0.2954879999,
-0.0197134987,
-0.960368216,
-0.8071085215,
-0.3685503602,
-0.301576376,
-0.0470021442,
-0.528091073,
-0.1963216215,
0.6359151602,
0.4350599051,
-0.5349984169,
-0.1664897203,
-0.6185472012,
-0.0125194686,
0.2074905783,
0.0402265899,
0.4081284106,
-0.2398830652,
-0.5657579303,
-0.2527478039,
-0.7085376382,
0.1970955878,
0.2149195373,
-0.0200440753,
0.067211464,
0.5011447072,
0.2563699782,
0.6827773452,
0.3728048801,
0.1441811919,
-0.0762432143,
-0.4067972898,
-0.3010914028,
-0.5094389319,
0.5496889353,
-0.0244109575,
0.1508807242,
-0.6574997306,
-0.2704075873,
0.3142794371,
0.8542459011,
-0.5813420415,
-0.1399779469,
-0.1844210029,
-0.4664365947,
0.2525800467,
0.0909255892,
-0.6736713648,
0.0193289928,
-0.5496634245,
0.4928581417,
-0.3253459334,
-0.1244055256,
0.0025446517,
-0.3125132918,
0.2872070074,
0.1163851246,
-1.0147926807,
0.5762740374,
0.9085552096,
1.0773434639,
-0.4865232408,
0.0049644443,
0.0247242171,
0.0362925492,
-0.5139123797,
0.8256902695,
-0.6100997925,
-0.8068064451,
-0.2627497017,
0.0685698763,
-0.3471134901,
-0.5806671381,
0.1960083842,
-0.6841422319,
0.3346756101,
-0.2642832696,
-0.8138065934,
-0.0279874001,
-0.4449051023,
-0.6661205292,
1.012270093,
0.421484381,
-0.2984369695,
0.4478673041,
-0.6878086329,
-0.6703404784,
-0.1470444649,
-0.1154189035,
-0.2942535877,
0.4560187459,
-0.0845578611,
0.442161411,
-0.1877139509,
0.4056740701,
-0.176923871,
-0.6943068504,
0.2635689378,
-0.3298975527,
0.3737767339,
0.5569081306,
-0.4207035899,
0.2207266986,
-0.4381364882,
-0.1475690156,
0.112748161,
-0.4228063226,
-0.3030114174,
0.3648594618,
-0.2085511535,
0.2798346877,
0.0777110383,
-0.6045426726,
0.425727427,
-0.1104634851,
0.7478402853,
0.5769705772,
-0.4083218575,
1.0717999935,
-0.3004025817,
0.5454831123,
-0.0746468753,
0.0940959081,
-0.2061071545,
-0.141853109,
-0.6726637483,
-0.125327602,
0.1221996248,
0.6718743443,
-0.6986108422,
0.477669239,
-0.6681037545,
-0.6258563399,
-0.2567662895,
-0.3016861081,
0.2536723316,
0.3313868642,
0.6830765605,
-0.3567573726,
-0.3515022993,
-0.959674716,
-0.3217629492,
0.0967218578,
-0.276505053,
0.2269637138,
0.4757350385,
-0.124673225,
1.0795193911,
-0.3847317994,
0.1765572578,
-0.4807300866,
-0.2604382038,
0.3606899083,
0.4905296862,
0.6287347674,
-0.7428643107,
-0.3055872619,
-0.2127212286,
-0.7630095482,
0.2030408978,
-0.1720644236,
0.1660768986,
0.1516896039,
0.3703813255,
-0.9441893101,
0.3625437617,
0.5898970366,
-0.564437151,
0.5074737072,
-0.3652857542,
0.1154511496,
-1.0468754768,
0.2743285,
0.000578875,
-0.2697458863,
-0.776847899,
0.0166631397,
0.2299705446,
-0.2764212489,
-0.2597596645,
0.4064597785,
-0.4679265618,
-0.4879386127,
-0.3743133545,
-0.2743930221,
-0.1887463331,
0.4719020426,
-0.0831614286,
1.2130265236,
0.3382943273,
-0.6217899919,
-0.0022700261,
0.2298158854,
-0.7404164672,
0.1882219762,
-0.703722477,
0.2385681421,
-0.0733296052,
0.6029552817,
-0.8361708522,
0.0553536639,
0.0044123167,
-0.0992304012,
0.4734484851,
-0.0072638122,
-0.3040646613,
-0.7159776092,
0.2990598381,
0.3455297351,
1.1639424562,
-0.5818357468,
0.5657708049,
0.2416142523,
-0.2312929332,
-0.6585869193,
-0.7127108574,
-0.1770667285,
-0.2851386964,
-0.3631305993,
0.4858066142,
0.1549932361,
0.0705358759,
0.1496832371,
-0.5451539755,
-0.1469777524,
0.2077670842,
0.1848110706,
0.2838889658,
-0.2215245962,
0.0558769964,
0.0539511554,
-0.2421237528,
-0.0593209267,
-0.7241399884,
0.4533163309,
-0.2412793338,
-0.3553597033,
-0.3676579893,
0.4778139293,
0.5318872929,
0.1111468449,
0.6686273217,
0.1543491483,
-0.0864278823,
-0.2104402781,
-0.2996773124,
-0.3020553887,
-0.4906114638,
0.3439715505,
-0.2874825001,
-1.2746816874,
0.1658674628,
-0.0929007754,
0.082842052,
0.4326716065,
0.1648894399,
-0.1006849185,
0.9142263532,
0.7921034694,
-0.1674865782,
0.6677128673,
-0.3901767433,
0.472487092,
-0.777592659,
0.0748535767,
-0.5501152873,
-0.4577266872,
-0.3305952549,
-0.7539122105,
0.1508994102,
0.0627590567,
-0.257211417,
0.8574656248,
-0.5090873837,
0.534152627,
0.5262775421,
-0.1742942333,
0.0654099137,
0.2747881413,
0.0804614425,
-0.0100662597,
-0.8078343272,
-0.8432333469,
0.8697712421,
0.0988645107,
0.8278561234,
-0.0006922333,
0.3767437339,
0.3153632581,
0.2269642204,
-0.6612374187,
0.6342682838,
-0.65136832,
-0.4194038808,
-0.2672607899,
-0.4398202598,
-1.0159199238,
0.3997864723,
0.0958991423,
-0.990716517,
0.0220997818,
0.2742918134,
-0.3804887831,
0.7983556986,
-0.4586180151,
0.5516289473,
0.1864665449,
-0.0945394263,
-0.3311460912,
-0.5472661257,
0.1424872875,
0.1135430411,
0.0796093196,
0.1718803346,
0.0893680751,
0.5986062288,
-0.3102539778,
0.4406847656,
-0.2051832527,
-0.0703369826,
0.4096837938,
0.1214950457,
0.1986992061,
-0.5170634389,
0.0705682784,
0.020996606,
0.0086604031,
-0.2463118285,
-0.7996800542,
0.4498313963,
-0.5793736577,
-0.6718205214,
-0.0603452176,
-0.264883697,
-0.0087416014,
0.0412348099,
0.5276069641,
0.5218201876,
-0.0119430795,
0.4177206159,
0.5580881238,
-0.0570740141,
0.6311274171,
0.2126561105,
-0.0881447718,
0.2426778376,
0.8141676784,
0.2215945274,
0.4298131466,
0.407626003,
0.0068521705,
-0.4481015503,
-0.2081737071,
-0.4217755198,
-0.0425312743,
-0.6242287159,
0.2513447106,
-0.8783604503,
-0.231175527,
-0.2041085809,
-0.213946119,
-0.641823411,
-0.6475065351,
-0.1251517534,
-0.0673245043,
-0.0330329388,
0.971314311,
-0.0296409298,
0.4270339906,
-0.7559739947,
0.5516261458,
0.3898403645,
0.4441970587,
0.3069680929,
-0.5955374241,
-0.1591629833,
-0.2654386163,
-0.4616187513,
-0.7906272411,
0.0895891413,
-0.039261397,
0.6211252213,
0.0791520625,
-0.5104852915,
0.476284951,
-0.6973724365,
1.2197993994,
0.119359903,
-1.1582437754,
0.0813067853,
-0.0806772709,
0.4992184937,
-0.026027821,
0.5205532312,
-0.6298787594,
-0.3490806222,
-0.7605972886,
-0.8517438769,
0.5745667219,
0.1354558617,
0.4092239738,
-0.0887384042,
0.2943879068,
0.2858110964,
0.1320099384,
-0.5906605124,
-0.262571156,
-0.178407833,
-0.0705061704,
-0.4454572797,
-0.2219896913,
0.3374128342,
-0.1313833743,
0.5397312641,
-0.0732438415,
0.87296772,
0.2603830993,
-0.3136097193,
-0.0764869303,
0.6884875894,
0.6946587563,
0.717653811,
0.2521321177,
0.0555472448,
0.2190608531,
-0.4677974284,
0.5935345292,
-0.0230936464,
-0.3424460292,
0.0969809592,
0.2999722958,
1.0324133635,
0.4243544042,
-0.233262226,
0.4330684841,
0.0118740732,
-0.0850853175,
-0.1432412416,
0.3550714254,
0.1497098207,
0.3679460585,
0.4184323847,
0.2974055111,
0.1830869466,
-0.3383110464,
0.3407151103,
0.1882008612,
-0.3734444678,
-0.6072331071,
0.8668545485,
-0.1480607837,
-0.4081376791,
0.6824076176,
0.1974832714,
-0.4189226925,
0.7366811037,
0.733263433,
0.7713097334,
-0.1606463194,
0.1286643445,
0.3894824684,
0.1116562039,
-0.6805003881,
0.1868477613,
-0.3702410161,
-0.4222870469,
-0.5970888138,
-0.6742476821,
-0.337523669,
0.084375836,
-0.8047353625,
-0.3415023685,
-0.4761110842,
-0.3427886963,
-0.1608668566,
-0.5529806018,
-0.6701440215,
0.0861637294,
0.0591641106,
0.9767288566,
-0.5911755562,
0.7548678517,
0.5233389735,
0.1601413637,
-1.0427268744,
-0.1247372553,
-0.2427477092,
-0.2921818197,
0.4727046788,
0.2703061104,
-0.0429763459,
-0.0697876811,
-0.4008789062,
-1.1451910734,
0.9708176255,
0.2042012513,
-0.7561600804,
-0.4291615784,
0.026239574,
0.6510313749,
-0.1392217726,
0.0609397516,
0.8160912395,
0.2683578134,
0.0209064316,
-0.8083532453,
-0.1009777561,
-0.182628274,
0.1538775265,
0.5531778932,
-0.4187027514,
1.0674659014,
-0.2976764143,
-0.5251652002,
0.5215267539,
0.7508960962,
-0.0992620513,
-0.1164210662,
0.6838588119,
0.6639534831,
0.5070279837,
-0.2946404517,
1.5510430336,
-0.0903076902,
0.4495156109,
1.0959265232,
-0.3085302114,
0.8199391365,
0.3495069444,
-0.4385121763,
0.7259688973,
0.1889849454,
-0.273940742,
0.4444521964,
0.2033528537,
0.1213224679,
-0.1982815564,
0.4582364261,
-0.3076627254,
0.2767890394,
0.2051755041,
-0.4056785703,
-0.152261883,
-0.0049825008,
-0.0463140681,
0.1174308807,
0.0096661896,
0.7514992952,
0.2070815563,
-1.0432552099,
0.237102896,
-0.2096918225,
0.5800872445,
-0.6243838668,
0.246132195,
-0.1815214902,
0.1981052011,
0.2029557228,
-0.7522793412,
0.6104547381,
0.2227092534,
-0.470274657,
-0.5829029083,
0.7646824121,
-0.3083051145,
-0.1550068408,
0.2691648304,
0.4361692369,
-0.0081219766,
0.1621968448,
-0.4272872806,
-0.4034286737,
-0.3155819476,
-0.4652506113,
0.1892670542,
-0.2573344707,
-0.1936471015,
0.6449913979,
0.5939409137,
0.0411732346,
0.1982198209,
-0.1590153724,
0.4564037025,
-0.9745055437,
-0.7846266031,
-0.8187000751,
0.402779907,
0.0317017026,
-0.1280991435,
0.5726879835,
0.4692510664,
0.8907278776,
-0.5695316195,
0.7549968958,
-0.1879093945,
0.5889617205,
-0.4170514643,
0.5520124435,
-0.554844141,
-0.1556531191,
-0.1470884234,
-1.2729618549,
0.2358950824,
0.5990492702,
-0.3930685222,
0.155697614,
0.7046296597,
0.4659476578,
-0.3954478502,
0.2614153922,
0.2185717672,
0.075423196,
0.4684244394,
0.8104290962,
1.345421195,
-0.2790691555,
0.3191559911,
0.0180651546,
0.0130495764,
0.0161797553,
-0.6973413825,
-0.4641865194,
-0.6586279869,
0.0601255633,
-0.0120949745,
-0.2146965414,
0.572350204,
0.9325221181,
-0.5949474573,
-0.2440245599,
-0.1592342705,
-0.1402461082,
-0.3056153953,
-0.2183595449,
0.2066536993,
-0.2692496777,
-0.7511874437,
0.6321157217,
0.3256624937,
0.3616266251,
0.0154369986,
0.266959101,
0.1014996096,
0.3663147092,
0.6015924811,
0.3664492071,
-0.8715022802,
-0.5225615501,
0.1575171053,
-0.3323615193,
-0.0089834472,
1.1366685629,
-0.8632078171,
0.1147349179,
0.4377567768,
0.7095668316,
0.4736933112,
0.0898441896,
0.5770783424,
-0.399823755,
0.1024239436,
-0.015448357,
0.4810030162,
0.2792496681,
-0.1259294599,
0.4356322289,
0.1480324715,
-0.6102520227,
-0.3683200181,
0.2540762424,
-0.9201603532,
-0.6302987933,
1.0815005302,
-0.2873868346,
-0.1678346843,
0.37712273,
-0.0283431802,
0.5792576671,
-0.1043762937,
0.8305407763,
0.5499130487,
0.0145175243,
0.3823364675,
-0.3970782757,
0.5319682956,
0.7132692337,
-0.5479128957,
-0.2014494389,
0.3159247637,
0.3857282102,
0.3769863546,
0.2808958888,
-0.0180787109,
0.4050414562,
0.0464752577,
-0.4868969619,
-0.0178876296,
-0.6938888431,
-0.5236644149,
0.2866816521,
-0.3571400344,
0.1041704863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01030v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01030v4
|
Executable Code Actions Elicit Better LLM Agents
| 2024-02-01T21:38:58 | 2024-06-07T01:53:07 |
Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Lifan Yuan, Yizhe Zhang, Yunzhu Li, Hao Peng, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Model (LLM) agents, capable of performing a broad range of
actions, such as invoking tools and controlling robots, show great potential in
tackling real-world challenges. LLM agents are typically prompted to produce
actions by generating JSON or text in a pre-defined format, which is usually
limited by constrained action space (e.g., the scope of pre-defined tools) and
restricted flexibility (e.g., inability to compose multiple tools). This work
proposes to use executable Python code to consolidate LLM agents' actions into
a unified action space (CodeAct). Integrated with a Python interpreter, CodeAct
can execute code actions and dynamically revise prior actions or emit new
actions upon new observations through multi-turn interactions. Our extensive
analysis of 17 LLMs on API-Bank and a newly curated benchmark shows that
CodeAct outperforms widely used alternatives (up to 20% higher success rate).
The encouraging performance of CodeAct motivates us to build an open-source LLM
agent that interacts with environments by executing interpretable code and
collaborates with users using natural language. To this end, we collect an
instruction-tuning dataset CodeActInstruct that consists of 7k multi-turn
interactions using CodeAct. We show that it can be used with existing data to
improve models in agent-oriented tasks without compromising their general
capability. CodeActAgent, finetuned from Llama2 and Mistral, is integrated with
Python interpreter and uniquely tailored to perform sophisticated tasks (e.g.,
model training) using existing libraries and autonomously self-debug.
|
[
0.0938064381,
-0.6262279153,
0.4485221207,
0.1493278742,
0.1163319424,
0.1755111217,
-0.2333410382,
-0.3695030808,
0.3803313673,
0.8324707747,
-0.2979546189,
-0.5346263051,
-0.1681045294,
-0.0828659683,
-0.446308434,
0.8722497821,
-0.0531340018,
-0.1566421241,
-0.1462415457,
-0.2259458005,
-0.3895251155,
-0.5342642069,
-0.4432142377,
-0.5895216465,
0.3640978038,
0.0878754333,
0.8449602127,
0.5282379985,
0.476195842,
0.5399593711,
0.2539169192,
0.3992440403,
-0.3727686107,
0.1132046655,
-0.2257581204,
-0.5307955742,
-0.7893705368,
0.0603537299,
0.1629315764,
0.1883022636,
-0.3008846045,
0.1037200615,
-0.0725503862,
0.3615754843,
-0.3283458352,
0.492808938,
-0.3439439535,
-0.1611567736,
0.3811829388,
-0.2998405099,
-0.4112100601,
-0.3305215836,
-0.1429353803,
-0.564961791,
-0.2483571321,
-0.2153885812,
0.3820086718,
0.4690675437,
-0.3501945436,
-0.4714892507,
-0.4787141681,
0.491325736,
-0.8987396955,
-0.1893377453,
0.0302714165,
0.0299378857,
-0.2964480519,
-0.8532047868,
-0.4160606563,
-0.2644051313,
-0.1312582344,
-0.1628552526,
-0.3071316481,
0.1750463396,
0.1877678633,
0.1082592681,
-0.5392817259,
0.1046177968,
-0.1361232251,
-0.2789182365,
0.6647844911,
0.5269170403,
0.2480742484,
0.1059677377,
-0.1859202832,
-0.2908806205,
-0.6640273333,
0.3186373115,
0.4403735399,
0.276843518,
-0.0766600445,
0.5844781399,
-0.1936866492,
0.5423510671,
-0.1909655035,
0.1563291997,
0.0798361823,
-0.1974621117,
-0.4115437865,
-0.2011322826,
0.769213438,
0.3661617637,
0.1766926646,
-0.2367192358,
-0.4463472068,
0.0691834018,
0.501827538,
-0.8404173851,
-0.3000487387,
0.6438629627,
-0.2843223512,
-0.4284394085,
0.1643185765,
-0.4510293007,
-0.4870058,
-0.6249026656,
0.385789454,
-0.3609143794,
-0.2691597342,
0.1044372469,
-0.2173447907,
0.4157833755,
0.3971405923,
-0.494363308,
0.2728513777,
0.8372043371,
0.6002508998,
-0.1607237458,
-0.5153223276,
-0.8826152682,
0.2406176925,
-0.4343261719,
0.9149265885,
-0.6840081811,
-0.0894854441,
0.1308556497,
-0.070044145,
-0.0412008613,
-0.6828117967,
-0.0959254578,
-0.6460435987,
-0.2988569736,
0.2869639099,
-0.4017020166,
-0.0614072978,
0.2899883986,
-0.8279336691,
0.892377317,
0.2940093577,
-0.0410801545,
0.2254484296,
-1.0858836174,
-0.4932799935,
0.0693362281,
-0.230255276,
-0.1705381721,
0.0528870374,
0.2774459422,
0.582406342,
0.14082551,
0.1664932966,
-0.2667062283,
-0.5703707933,
0.7316765189,
-0.3440496624,
0.4933587313,
0.0331275947,
-0.3114137053,
0.4600932002,
-0.4670554101,
0.3963800967,
0.0172203239,
-0.6641229391,
-0.0941215754,
-0.1538990736,
-0.1071449965,
0.1229885444,
0.3907237351,
-0.129031986,
0.7830559611,
-0.3019465506,
0.5933502913,
0.7141060829,
-0.1648446172,
0.5788128376,
-0.3783538938,
0.528142333,
-0.4370214939,
0.1531589031,
-0.3210276067,
-0.1743962765,
-0.6082645059,
-0.5138036013,
-0.1276138425,
0.4232914448,
-0.8645817637,
0.2784069479,
-0.2428054661,
-0.4235797524,
-0.4136345685,
0.4099858403,
0.4682947695,
-0.0961191803,
0.2448983788,
-0.030235514,
-0.4394848049,
-0.4510007203,
-0.2552560866,
-0.206898436,
0.1453514248,
0.2991169393,
0.4102165997,
-0.589584291,
0.8853356242,
-0.3653122485,
-0.1183941439,
-0.5563654304,
0.234114036,
0.4879597723,
0.2302026749,
0.3139839172,
-0.6598198414,
-0.328525573,
0.1245795637,
-0.8109090924,
-0.1814263463,
-0.1623746604,
-0.1889162809,
0.4161083102,
0.6194262505,
-0.6322240233,
0.4303424954,
0.6751545668,
-0.3948436677,
0.42455405,
-0.505426228,
0.2460291386,
-0.8854839206,
0.0277851615,
-0.3438415229,
-0.2147475779,
-0.6660513878,
0.5124242902,
0.2128592581,
-0.1639975607,
-0.4643945694,
0.5759430528,
-0.3699216247,
-0.1611939073,
-0.4769794643,
-0.1436003298,
-0.0530719198,
0.7587788701,
0.1839743406,
0.926469624,
0.499765873,
-0.7548522949,
0.4569907784,
0.1188967228,
-0.1601345241,
0.0410187989,
-0.6580725908,
0.3605728447,
0.3986134529,
0.1369555146,
-0.7410426736,
-0.5173803568,
0.0232012235,
-0.3120734394,
0.140726462,
-0.1721263379,
-0.675934732,
-0.2339940369,
-0.3864792287,
0.135926649,
0.4233489037,
-0.7323503494,
0.7594133615,
0.25584355,
0.0282967407,
-0.535902977,
-0.607400775,
0.2143227309,
-0.1666458547,
-0.4280462265,
-0.094425559,
-0.1191370636,
-0.3295812607,
-0.0225774385,
-0.0574932806,
-0.1317224354,
-0.0178112425,
0.4318619668,
0.3448796868,
-0.0720106959,
0.0183010977,
0.0203804187,
-0.0407205783,
0.1391726881,
-0.179242447,
0.8378548622,
-0.2216977179,
-0.5618054867,
-0.3917299211,
0.278262943,
0.9170100689,
-0.4506169856,
0.3765189946,
0.1608251035,
0.128528133,
-0.5859054327,
-0.1794630438,
0.0159094445,
-0.5842550993,
0.2794441581,
-0.0894533023,
-0.845795393,
0.3283009529,
-0.3103058636,
0.2941578627,
-0.2137426734,
0.7406256795,
-0.0578129627,
0.863389194,
0.540564239,
-0.1971222758,
0.5663793087,
-0.4693820775,
0.2223501205,
-0.5570889711,
-0.1719838977,
-0.18069233,
-0.3278961182,
-0.2761364877,
-0.8188584447,
0.1139425784,
-0.089116998,
-0.2493580133,
0.6929849386,
-0.5231990218,
0.5378141999,
0.4469102323,
0.0741604492,
0.2199592739,
0.0959764123,
0.1612032801,
0.4675259292,
-0.5513780713,
-0.7934873104,
1.1910088062,
0.2136006206,
1.1505430937,
0.2921416759,
1.0198756456,
0.5582595468,
0.479051739,
-0.696908772,
0.5288329124,
0.2221179605,
-0.2648456395,
-0.3549849093,
-0.3391423225,
-1.1185926199,
0.190720275,
0.1304953843,
-0.6630240679,
-0.2148632556,
0.2165237218,
-0.527068615,
0.0112995356,
-0.8472966552,
0.6935683489,
-0.3546798825,
-0.3877488375,
-0.3494336009,
-0.07697469,
0.1609795094,
0.0854309723,
0.2263500988,
0.0091482587,
-0.3028583229,
0.1069418192,
-0.5747987032,
0.9841530323,
-0.1776021421,
-0.5533141494,
0.5218868256,
0.2470677197,
0.830290556,
0.211937651,
-0.186613813,
0.129144758,
-0.1031101346,
-0.1906200945,
-0.8149895072,
0.5885494351,
-0.6985863447,
-0.3347532749,
-0.0744952112,
-0.7387109399,
0.0443943068,
-0.0023049559,
-0.2343508005,
0.7219173908,
-0.1229184866,
0.0052992003,
0.3457435071,
-0.2676069438,
0.735368669,
1.0149695873,
-0.3580322266,
-0.3341615498,
0.819190681,
-0.3322552443,
0.1706085056,
0.469127357,
-0.1860784441,
-0.2701530159,
-0.3823944032,
-0.1405945867,
-0.0784268379,
-0.5482881665,
-0.4926751852,
-0.4493673146,
0.0350123048,
-0.6515077353,
-0.3265092373,
-0.3404739797,
-0.0566680916,
-0.0543435887,
0.0239710025,
0.4790202081,
0.8867015839,
-0.0656675398,
0.3958673477,
-0.795793891,
0.4883802533,
0.3294422328,
0.3165996969,
-0.2503756583,
-0.3223786652,
-0.3486643434,
-0.0723927394,
-0.1001254842,
-0.5473230481,
0.6003287435,
0.1335927695,
0.6584838629,
0.4504651725,
0.1109962687,
0.6816274524,
-0.3601104319,
0.4550171196,
-0.0610615052,
-0.9702282548,
0.6164085865,
-0.2569417357,
0.2704028189,
0.285371393,
-0.2397395968,
-0.2726085186,
-0.738719821,
-0.3705437481,
-0.8279520869,
0.9013975263,
0.2909221053,
0.2989343703,
0.074865222,
0.2016356587,
-0.0638143569,
0.2903678119,
-0.7219669819,
0.0129386988,
-0.0315825939,
-0.1772698313,
-0.0114006568,
0.2191324681,
-0.2604477704,
-0.0985576957,
0.4002907872,
-0.468549192,
0.3914634883,
0.0180660095,
-0.4061883986,
0.1013983339,
0.2956426144,
0.3369467556,
0.4316556156,
-0.0207187124,
0.0010519774,
-0.0897738412,
-0.3873308003,
0.2235704958,
0.0316732116,
0.2004177868,
-0.4236073494,
0.7963140011,
0.3632365763,
0.2237663418,
-1.2739055157,
0.61389184,
-0.2365546972,
-0.0567612015,
-0.3559263349,
0.7775093913,
0.0601175353,
0.9218708277,
0.1409633607,
0.0451909788,
0.1471384913,
-0.6925129294,
0.3094160557,
0.3018144071,
-0.209906444,
-0.1144635901,
0.2414066195,
0.4449865818,
-0.5458536148,
0.6289455891,
-0.4930849671,
-0.4348996282,
1.0270034075,
0.4339767098,
0.7576208711,
0.0780328289,
0.311478287,
0.0790062025,
0.3758538365,
-0.056717094,
0.3886437416,
-0.2227558196,
-0.6215997338,
-0.7537771463,
-0.5511709452,
-0.4323962927,
0.1678720564,
-0.5726201534,
0.0923976004,
-0.4275517166,
0.1944206208,
-0.5741773248,
0.1198967397,
-0.5847120285,
-0.1999414116,
0.1900843382,
0.8530774117,
-0.5075824857,
1.0569758415,
1.0484266281,
-0.3418853879,
-1.0387312174,
-0.0531932786,
-0.1041150764,
-0.899800837,
0.3846179247,
0.4322983325,
-0.0571992546,
-0.2820431888,
-0.953574121,
-0.7110977769,
1.2429869175,
0.4328926206,
-0.4583804011,
0.2475506961,
0.328807801,
0.7760305405,
-0.443973124,
0.2701056302,
0.6933700442,
0.4354979098,
-0.2345333397,
-0.5779445767,
0.0688399971,
-0.4567336142,
-0.2531786561,
0.2984589934,
-0.6505692005,
0.7654758096,
-0.3385525048,
0.0135065513,
0.2969587445,
0.5079017282,
0.3583397865,
0.387889415,
0.2980012596,
0.3880392909,
0.7928871512,
0.0911963955,
1.1483545303,
-0.4774563015,
0.2971026301,
1.1736809015,
-0.4671727717,
0.7846288085,
0.2990426719,
-0.0881496519,
0.5123593211,
0.2169483751,
-0.0323865302,
0.440025121,
0.0510061048,
-0.2104181796,
-0.3440866172,
0.291683495,
0.1780814528,
0.7246739864,
0.3238578439,
-0.0710491613,
-0.1605635732,
-0.1456184536,
-0.0461918525,
0.0992754921,
-0.4699541032,
0.8106799126,
-0.1711664498,
-0.7679601908,
0.2372980118,
-0.1839743406,
0.64608109,
-0.7619313002,
-0.363732636,
-0.5354812145,
0.4211519659,
-0.1237873286,
-0.777389586,
0.1204988062,
0.2257724851,
0.0168078169,
-0.3354634345,
0.6476761699,
-0.3757405877,
-0.098376967,
0.523285687,
0.3031551242,
0.3598157465,
-0.2981974483,
-0.6493428946,
0.147037968,
0.0015302753,
-0.3205637634,
0.4087015986,
0.608997643,
0.0190567542,
0.8057893515,
0.7082360983,
0.0913059488,
-0.01626461,
0.0391807407,
1.0393778086,
-0.5694504976,
-0.2653755844,
-0.6559603214,
0.5244144201,
-0.2226821929,
-0.1933087558,
0.4456117451,
0.5006182194,
0.5536568165,
-0.0836736485,
0.8125478625,
-0.1913575083,
0.1088388711,
-0.6146498322,
0.5863568783,
-0.4532084763,
0.4332697093,
-0.2479940802,
-0.680898726,
-0.0029724203,
0.5261219144,
0.0540868007,
-0.102477327,
0.4957455993,
1.1322740316,
-0.0293248314,
-0.4933344424,
0.4714139104,
0.0136436867,
0.6214588284,
0.6332397461,
0.9563504457,
-0.1871781647,
0.8771545291,
0.0381866246,
-0.2469248027,
-0.2750374377,
-0.7446547151,
-1.0876169205,
-0.0710307807,
-0.2785753012,
-0.1717577428,
-0.3467696309,
1.1863859892,
0.6193153858,
-0.6990444064,
-0.3189159334,
-0.1745649874,
0.0822118297,
-0.5166687369,
-0.2136315256,
0.0908150375,
-0.7284215689,
-0.8317071795,
0.6837024689,
0.5044515729,
-0.236801371,
-0.1649827808,
-0.5097759962,
0.283415854,
0.3221039772,
0.6647096276,
0.3603832424,
-0.4896370471,
-0.0502112918,
-0.0048726704,
-0.3678407073,
-0.1078776866,
1.2417464256,
-0.6524475217,
0.1786227971,
0.2580378056,
0.6464295983,
0.0402190387,
-0.0551999211,
0.6125333905,
-0.6492855549,
0.1386753619,
0.1284570098,
0.4005215764,
-0.1476824135,
-0.4402768314,
0.6536471844,
-0.2907080352,
-0.5602042675,
-0.5799250007,
0.0149277849,
-0.7912635803,
-0.6003682613,
1.4503020048,
-0.2907692492,
-0.3133606315,
-0.0066688992,
-0.4484674037,
0.1483493,
-0.8178648353,
0.6168928146,
0.3753997386,
-0.5677066445,
0.0770502985,
-0.2831529379,
0.2901954949,
0.1789733171,
-1.2284017801,
0.4003759027,
0.5852244496,
0.0400235914,
0.1054929048,
0.5879538655,
-0.0216490962,
0.3119949698,
0.1086573452,
0.3871037066,
-0.3978148401,
-0.4553566277,
-0.5909461379,
0.0441367738,
0.0788063854,
0.1032016426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01025v1
|
Graph-based Clustering for Detecting Semantic Change Across Time and Languages
| 2024-02-01T21:27:19 | 2024-02-01T21:27:19 |
Xianghe Ma, Michael Strube, Wei Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the predominance of contextualized embeddings in NLP, approaches to
detect semantic change relying on these embeddings and clustering methods
underperform simpler counterparts based on static word embeddings. This stems
from the poor quality of the clustering methods to produce sense clusters --
which struggle to capture word senses, especially those with low frequency.
This issue hinders the next step in examining how changes in word senses in one
language influence another. To address this issue, we propose a graph-based
clustering approach to capture nuanced changes in both high- and low-frequency
word senses across time and languages, including the acquisition and loss of
these senses over time. Our experimental results show that our approach
substantially surpasses previous approaches in the SemEval2020 binary
classification task across four languages. Moreover, we showcase the ability of
our approach as a versatile visualization tool to detect semantic changes in
both intra-language and inter-language setups. We make our code and data
publicly available.
|
[
-0.4449549615,
-0.890180409,
0.5497047901,
0.2140201628,
-0.2038350254,
-0.0122941779,
-0.1580491215,
-0.5073056221,
0.5808144212,
0.1189235598,
-0.2848909497,
-0.9605638385,
-0.7790981531,
0.1980416328,
-0.3252929151,
0.5247046947,
-0.1171181649,
-0.2567546368,
-0.1437648684,
-0.6478024125,
-0.553250134,
-0.3519220352,
-0.617562294,
-0.6203195453,
0.7758200169,
0.1305256933,
0.3781623244,
0.3706718087,
0.1249991953,
0.1959300786,
-0.3311257362,
-0.0587245934,
-0.3341485858,
0.0137105659,
-0.0823162794,
-0.1958808005,
-0.1131972596,
-0.1977629811,
0.8134291172,
1.1458404064,
-0.0938783139,
0.042938713,
-0.0211670157,
0.4965924919,
-0.5490444899,
0.6486398578,
-0.829906106,
0.1540041715,
-0.3408103287,
-0.3162316084,
-0.2659220397,
0.0042702653,
-0.2190550119,
-0.5153440237,
0.1672250032,
-0.0953124613,
0.8254303932,
0.3075360656,
-0.5236995816,
-0.1252130419,
-0.4193921089,
0.5533812046,
-0.7012882829,
0.8196661472,
0.1872143298,
0.1894037575,
-0.1531875581,
-0.8643077016,
-0.5893900394,
0.0735487714,
-0.0864154026,
0.0710362345,
-0.3995901048,
-0.3711595237,
0.1847374588,
-0.2035936713,
-0.2547170222,
0.1027671397,
0.0316332243,
-0.2002554238,
0.240848124,
0.0728825629,
0.5435336828,
-0.2445556819,
-0.2629070282,
-0.305106312,
-0.8086257577,
0.0004375559,
0.1478236318,
0.4463846385,
-0.0434715413,
0.4794298708,
-0.2492894083,
0.8150944114,
-0.1851847768,
0.1502035558,
0.4125006497,
-0.3109070957,
0.0824624225,
0.293087244,
0.4284931421,
0.6873183846,
-0.1062956229,
-0.3366548717,
0.0650213808,
0.6531733871,
-0.2204691321,
-0.668074131,
-0.2243994176,
-0.0541604832,
-0.5100810528,
-0.353658855,
-0.023508383,
-0.6387423277,
-0.5083897114,
-0.2031972557,
0.1394729614,
-0.4163651466,
-0.2708136141,
0.1616832912,
-0.4629761875,
0.2248441875,
0.3726192117,
-0.7830233574,
0.3923884332,
0.6590038538,
1.0213651657,
-0.3722335994,
-0.4020230472,
-0.3899422884,
0.2066349983,
-0.5429351926,
0.9432526231,
-0.705550015,
-0.4094595313,
-0.086593546,
0.3460901678,
-0.1601582617,
-0.5903810859,
-0.0710037351,
-0.5101881027,
0.0672608241,
-0.3474617898,
-0.5938259363,
-0.2194633186,
0.4823893607,
-0.440149188,
1.1624796391,
0.2678888738,
-0.9157027602,
0.791113615,
-0.5210043192,
-0.494110167,
0.2201962769,
-0.4492383301,
-0.4810980856,
0.047154583,
0.2073640823,
0.2993426919,
0.3361355364,
0.1354232132,
-0.5449528694,
-0.478174299,
0.1018418819,
0.0107826469,
0.6750274301,
-0.0543989874,
-0.3244821131,
0.1248544976,
-0.6935458183,
0.108704336,
0.1751108766,
-0.1101912633,
-0.7741519213,
0.4103903472,
0.0254681036,
0.2345973551,
0.3886283934,
-0.7512879968,
0.1578076333,
-0.4773377478,
0.5862278938,
0.5353072882,
0.2647113204,
0.2693231106,
0.0947095826,
0.237147212,
0.376064986,
-0.0974847376,
-0.079938598,
-0.7554491162,
-0.6621413231,
0.3185268641,
0.2313112766,
0.3750352859,
-0.6462301016,
0.5139813423,
-0.489955008,
-0.2938530445,
0.0477198176,
-0.0171634778,
-0.2656687796,
0.5016768575,
0.5298395753,
-0.5382456779,
-0.1589168608,
-0.5475319624,
-0.3665511012,
-0.1835535169,
-0.0310559664,
0.3805315495,
0.591401279,
-0.7250054479,
1.0383853912,
-0.819891274,
-0.2445072681,
0.0638468713,
0.2838835716,
0.0837646872,
0.3676910996,
0.7642915249,
-0.6250017285,
-0.1567064673,
0.3415177763,
-0.5584206581,
-0.3563351929,
0.1925712228,
0.0345198102,
0.2654434144,
1.0834205151,
-0.1036482304,
0.5178560019,
0.7695208788,
-0.6896615624,
0.1369275451,
0.0023051274,
0.0563288853,
-0.932038188,
0.1703703254,
-0.3980584145,
-0.2495278567,
-0.4255074263,
-0.2853993177,
-0.0157172494,
-0.3986718059,
-0.3069956005,
0.778773725,
-0.2073670179,
-0.3468399346,
-0.2537740767,
0.3338681161,
-0.0860823393,
0.5202501416,
-0.0542687289,
0.2758551836,
0.3711875081,
-0.5655184984,
0.2028136998,
0.2730276585,
-0.3369282186,
0.5475335717,
-0.6922224164,
0.1466927528,
-0.2842003107,
0.2840670943,
-0.8253935575,
-0.0320470296,
0.4261434972,
-0.4532584846,
0.0727323741,
-0.3340771794,
-0.4772396088,
-0.1333229691,
-0.1712545604,
0.3550797105,
0.1235474944,
-0.5017189384,
0.6194796562,
0.5424521565,
-0.1111602709,
-0.260248363,
-0.6538576484,
0.302906394,
-0.2394808978,
-0.6404761672,
0.4800184667,
0.2267306,
-0.2732128799,
0.4915831685,
-0.3383789062,
0.0422366261,
0.2248961926,
0.3244934082,
-0.1193644851,
0.1714101285,
0.5006984472,
0.2829225659,
-0.5974564552,
-0.0597702973,
-0.67027843,
0.8876070976,
-0.3906100392,
-0.5693766475,
-0.1036712527,
0.3449154794,
0.3080276251,
-0.470913589,
0.7220919728,
0.8256450295,
-0.5551543236,
-0.2608521283,
-0.2117775679,
-0.1740598232,
-0.3866948187,
0.2477630079,
-0.2128730416,
-1.2408900261,
0.7106702328,
-0.6047587395,
-0.2328608334,
0.6560313106,
0.4451969564,
-0.1204058677,
1.1742414236,
0.6188608408,
0.027603792,
0.7817328572,
-0.3052292764,
0.3736582398,
-0.6819975376,
-0.1156836003,
-0.5281925797,
-0.4410785437,
-0.7795674801,
-0.5823284984,
0.6885335445,
0.0710824281,
-0.0579470173,
0.1814427376,
-0.3569914997,
0.362300396,
0.3288891912,
-0.0437286086,
0.2712557614,
0.1707520187,
-0.1035071388,
0.004566031,
-0.8504676223,
-0.2023589611,
0.4780693948,
-0.0007162509,
0.5666962862,
0.0341888331,
0.820679903,
0.4339928627,
0.0615493394,
-0.8000652194,
0.6204051971,
-0.2972166836,
0.0386628136,
-0.4755763113,
-0.5074517131,
-1.4634780884,
0.2897459865,
-0.1961599737,
-0.7408784628,
0.5154771209,
0.1186116412,
0.450284183,
0.3521293998,
-0.5257768631,
1.2385399342,
0.0755916536,
0.0557871275,
-0.4436437786,
-0.591201663,
-0.3743753731,
0.0248263068,
0.2261394262,
-0.489474088,
0.1012464762,
0.7212003469,
-0.5351982713,
1.0304111242,
-0.4393489957,
-0.0380544551,
0.2646083534,
0.3060706258,
0.4714824259,
-0.0866250694,
0.1666245162,
0.5805548429,
0.2337905616,
-0.5384869576,
-0.6360861659,
0.814684689,
-0.4793459773,
0.0204699114,
-0.360752672,
-0.3844315708,
-0.2514130175,
0.4789709747,
0.1330581456,
0.5522003174,
-0.3912325203,
0.054418169,
0.134248957,
-0.4866645336,
0.3333873451,
0.3774695098,
-0.5171468258,
0.0144927176,
1.0846632719,
0.2703837156,
0.0147391204,
0.2262068093,
0.5292168856,
-0.357055366,
-0.4122067094,
-0.2507113218,
0.3558906317,
-0.7388127446,
0.0411923118,
-0.5259312391,
0.3464075923,
-0.4663375318,
-0.3709198534,
0.0281383693,
-0.3920069039,
0.1118012965,
0.0207994878,
0.4775207043,
0.7540912628,
-0.0676985458,
0.1190847307,
-0.7440533042,
0.117445007,
0.3660118282,
0.5808312297,
-0.2262206525,
0.051914148,
-0.191604048,
-0.1036295444,
0.1692742109,
-0.9976474643,
0.4588569403,
0.2634048164,
0.3238107264,
0.1901448667,
-0.1687392443,
0.590059936,
-0.4051911533,
0.7725734115,
0.1277286559,
-1.1874901056,
0.6733628511,
-0.3903097212,
0.7735223174,
0.4177279174,
-0.086326167,
-1.3666375875,
-0.3393909633,
-0.5613740087,
-0.9684022069,
0.4799047112,
-0.2253097147,
-0.058040522,
-0.3498063087,
0.0720623061,
-0.1521396041,
0.3083278239,
-0.4977986217,
-0.0320920683,
-0.2778880298,
-0.195890829,
-0.2232692093,
0.0358564034,
-0.2409860194,
-0.2255184203,
0.256005764,
-0.5527065396,
0.291344136,
0.0019267736,
-0.3111383319,
0.1075371578,
0.2653124928,
0.2081091404,
0.6105681658,
-0.0067314995,
0.5441218019,
0.5324065685,
-0.1910960376,
-0.1891339719,
0.0276000798,
-0.4634421468,
0.2188263834,
0.4958157837,
0.9135377407,
0.5214034319,
-0.4967601597,
0.61151582,
0.1557897478,
0.0282029491,
-0.1187829375,
-0.2854441404,
0.2436692715,
-0.0049937759,
-0.1598696709,
0.1260697395,
0.041328311,
-0.5072375536,
0.159110412,
0.2091316581,
-0.558861196,
-0.3689507246,
0.533072114,
-0.0263075698,
0.0674526468,
0.4597678185,
-0.4476834238,
-0.5578125119,
0.5689834356,
0.6275193691,
0.6185192466,
-0.1394419968,
0.3645676374,
0.1852176338,
0.1007780805,
0.1704071313,
0.2816022933,
-0.0965244174,
-1.2194128036,
-0.3698014617,
-0.4526033103,
-0.2285022885,
-0.3543467224,
-0.5426373482,
0.1172356606,
-0.2636722028,
-0.2335036844,
-0.1211114228,
-0.2745423913,
-0.572494626,
0.075485833,
0.1317552924,
0.5095841885,
-1.0823930502,
0.6619640589,
0.9271570444,
0.0130808437,
-0.4830864668,
-0.2404716909,
0.0814427137,
-0.961553514,
0.6291427016,
0.2385167181,
-0.4954085052,
0.2074849159,
-0.5467786193,
-0.7359055877,
1.0581637621,
0.0453645699,
-0.3681992292,
0.2346387058,
0.0940326005,
0.7312182188,
-0.0884872377,
-0.4106136858,
0.4326370955,
0.6435964704,
-0.1456754357,
-0.4681578279,
-0.0512352623,
-0.2457970977,
0.1704565883,
0.8728151321,
-0.3336125314,
0.7811919451,
0.1709643751,
-0.8164119124,
-0.707085073,
0.4823693037,
-0.1172255948,
0.6627601981,
0.9366519451,
0.9572327137,
0.9598605633,
-0.3637967408,
0.9094199538,
-0.7866023779,
0.508042872,
1.0048288107,
-0.3458369672,
0.7973005176,
0.4046354592,
-0.1912536323,
0.6888214946,
0.4583415985,
-0.060738761,
0.3669480085,
0.1342240125,
-0.3338893354,
-0.2587075233,
-0.3543491364,
-0.4842286706,
0.4192051888,
0.7431799173,
0.0711871311,
-0.5300254226,
-0.0156824477,
0.1875568181,
-0.0311100911,
-0.2175305039,
0.6384667158,
0.1666374058,
-0.1980855614,
0.2996760607,
0.0970292091,
0.5669265985,
-0.6139500141,
-0.1140929908,
0.0062927995,
-0.0088913683,
-0.23486799,
-0.7391540408,
0.4979245961,
-0.3180942237,
0.126867786,
-0.3482831419,
1.1404490471,
-0.6231230497,
-0.5038509369,
0.8612837791,
0.7228316665,
0.0587666705,
-0.0275813919,
-0.5751236677,
0.2798691988,
-0.3640056849,
0.1217120811,
0.2113393992,
0.3726328611,
-0.4594036341,
0.3323830068,
0.632599175,
0.1045316085,
0.2247960418,
0.5264356136,
0.7385886908,
-0.6690445542,
-0.6507296562,
-0.5767434835,
-0.1615490615,
-0.113206543,
-0.3072299659,
0.7599187493,
0.3581768274,
1.1101068258,
0.0471324809,
0.5987944603,
-0.2977747917,
0.3529497385,
-0.5028629303,
0.4660325348,
-0.7437080145,
-0.0442248099,
-0.3291116655,
-0.8947008848,
-0.5596753359,
0.6261922717,
-0.2774088085,
-0.2468775809,
0.7274215817,
0.7568058372,
0.0806917027,
-0.1694741547,
0.1945106685,
0.4969516397,
0.4286803305,
0.170087263,
0.6509190798,
-0.0265468508,
0.1697250605,
-0.1477451175,
-0.1207798123,
-0.1607201844,
-0.9205265641,
-0.4776987135,
-0.8269194961,
-0.430097729,
-0.3625380993,
-0.0135551924,
0.6625990272,
0.2983075678,
-0.7916457653,
-0.0933246687,
-0.2038720697,
0.0663743392,
-0.6185652018,
-0.2700592279,
0.6372921467,
-0.385686487,
-0.5126470327,
0.7137706876,
0.5196218491,
0.0126069002,
-0.0250702873,
0.1531127095,
0.0026895381,
-0.2039181143,
1.0336842537,
0.3761411011,
-0.4988798797,
-0.7509419918,
-0.1300315708,
0.1551352739,
0.0808228329,
0.9474018812,
-0.8290663362,
0.6496813297,
0.9532440901,
0.5165106058,
0.904178977,
-0.0903434083,
0.2469822168,
-0.8522526622,
0.2511019409,
-0.0530960225,
0.5613485575,
0.4029188752,
0.2284128368,
0.5793656707,
0.7799246907,
-0.3532048166,
-0.598579824,
0.4419286847,
-1.1805707216,
-0.5040137768,
0.9684202671,
0.09596508,
-0.252597332,
-0.3215777576,
-0.0058503193,
0.2764127254,
-0.1144136339,
0.792211473,
0.7194123268,
-0.3320856988,
0.323197782,
-0.1622794867,
0.1084443554,
0.3148601949,
-0.9363288283,
-0.2514126599,
0.7253324986,
0.3505123258,
0.3581528962,
0.7820187211,
-0.2982894182,
-0.0947819501,
0.190663144,
0.0664773881,
0.0995766073,
-0.3700400293,
-0.3803551197,
0.1302245706,
-0.1113298908,
0.0039612963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01019v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01019v1
|
Domain-Independent Deception: A New Taxonomy and Linguistic Analysis
| 2024-02-01T21:13:04 | 2024-02-01T21:13:04 |
Rakesh M. Verma, Nachum Dershowitz, Victor Zeng, Dainis Boumber, Xuting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY
|
Internet-based economies and societies are drowning in deceptive attacks.
These attacks take many forms, such as fake news, phishing, and job scams,
which we call ``domains of deception.'' Machine-learning and
natural-language-processing researchers have been attempting to ameliorate this
precarious situation by designing domain-specific detectors. Only a few recent
works have considered domain-independent deception. We collect these disparate
threads of research and investigate domain-independent deception. First, we
provide a new computational definition of deception and break down deception
into a new taxonomy. Then, we analyze the debate on linguistic cues for
deception and supply guidelines for systematic reviews. Finally, we investigate
common linguistic features and give evidence for knowledge transfer across
different forms of deception.
|
[
-0.5219956636,
-1.0215097666,
0.1933075935,
0.2245699763,
-0.0205017887,
0.2332073003,
-0.0632991567,
-0.7093117833,
0.4800213873,
0.9415868521,
-0.7556723356,
-0.1373088658,
-0.794275105,
0.3644577861,
-0.4228102565,
0.8670725822,
0.1993171722,
0.0601241589,
-0.3587037027,
0.0922161192,
-0.1428332925,
-0.7698953152,
-0.5955421329,
-0.2162154764,
0.453484863,
0.1484467685,
0.5884934664,
0.2097777724,
0.8916295767,
0.2933966517,
0.5420271158,
0.0584104769,
-0.3744093776,
-0.0458250307,
-0.3703997433,
-0.3694683909,
-0.1296750158,
0.2990111709,
0.1552826911,
0.6082507372,
-0.1305405498,
0.1061688215,
-0.2738298774,
0.7343358994,
-0.7569772005,
0.0964580253,
-0.8247919083,
-0.2423297316,
-0.3488520682,
-0.1940863132,
-0.742764771,
-0.3143513203,
0.3311179876,
-0.6204198003,
0.3161183894,
-0.0068335142,
0.801559031,
0.2943073213,
-0.6305639148,
-0.6306949258,
-0.7427147031,
0.8580231071,
-0.2460885048,
0.2020236403,
0.4479542375,
0.4052551389,
-0.034206301,
-0.8511024117,
-0.5219547749,
-0.0910174474,
-0.1969878227,
0.080189161,
-0.6603057384,
-0.1569454372,
-0.0761182606,
0.2508918345,
-0.405664444,
-0.0622297823,
-0.3084745705,
-0.45619452,
0.7873286009,
-0.036656931,
0.5707244873,
-0.0332300626,
-0.6736204624,
0.08196906,
-0.7041935325,
-0.1801255643,
0.6679100394,
0.1827336401,
0.0757292733,
0.2364241332,
-0.1917326152,
0.6751073599,
0.1384369284,
-0.3325679004,
-0.0954092294,
-0.0425156616,
-0.3220155537,
0.2608102858,
0.6674966812,
0.2591203153,
0.202915743,
0.0127645377,
-0.3006491065,
0.7219232917,
0.4753002524,
-0.5607416034,
-0.4237060249,
0.1706433594,
-0.5468820333,
-0.5067094564,
-0.0222076979,
-0.7162573934,
-0.5814374089,
-0.1627704799,
0.4023804367,
-0.338052392,
-0.4931632578,
0.3477077782,
-0.4051829576,
0.1658299863,
0.2824536562,
-0.5132322907,
0.7736737132,
0.7529844642,
0.273263365,
-0.4432102144,
-0.1572333425,
-0.3125842214,
-0.1258195341,
-0.264136821,
0.8020249009,
-0.6287624836,
-0.1325156838,
0.1966367513,
0.1728706509,
-0.0122425668,
-0.4097715616,
0.4869576693,
-0.8902767897,
0.5583482981,
-0.1738247424,
-0.3200113773,
-0.6043833494,
0.3958684504,
-0.7106647491,
0.6107301116,
0.0835990906,
-0.7708881497,
0.090623036,
-0.7203324437,
-0.4606127739,
0.2376805395,
-0.041126512,
-0.2518115938,
0.2137027383,
-0.1222808138,
0.0327945389,
-0.5546362996,
0.2043653578,
-0.0142425597,
-0.029014172,
0.8178184628,
-0.5650293231,
1.2134224176,
0.3402066529,
-0.6078619957,
-0.3137596846,
-0.694545567,
-0.0363458209,
0.2396824658,
0.0863334164,
-0.6714137197,
-0.1090878025,
-0.3477428854,
0.0114222672,
0.3378793597,
-0.4762220681,
0.1501245946,
-0.4545637071,
0.230298847,
0.5175664425,
0.3217463791,
0.3471152782,
-0.6399189234,
0.6586310863,
0.1294891983,
0.3804618418,
0.0460408479,
-0.6341866851,
-0.7463309169,
-0.2239087224,
0.3713948727,
0.4464465678,
-1.083889842,
-0.0092022931,
-0.1946587414,
-0.3931163847,
-0.6126914024,
-0.4953897893,
0.3694570363,
0.3453845084,
0.30063501,
-0.6082826853,
-0.4754652083,
-0.8822784424,
-0.5991646647,
-0.0628534183,
0.1806852221,
-0.1160145923,
0.6575790048,
-0.326372683,
0.9136356115,
-0.4672985375,
-0.5159888268,
0.0647323653,
0.2814171612,
-0.2360634655,
0.2306613326,
0.4058763385,
-1.1477097273,
-0.6751098633,
-0.1555965096,
-0.5853222013,
0.0054320986,
-0.3084876835,
0.0861407146,
0.3457639813,
0.0038169413,
-0.6462793946,
0.2879621685,
0.4079881608,
-0.3238023818,
0.7791470289,
0.2797748148,
0.2568578422,
-0.4663302898,
-0.2461231053,
-0.0855409354,
0.162335217,
-1.0985045433,
0.2980606258,
-0.2341951132,
0.1738985926,
-0.5595548153,
0.5042207837,
-0.8439689875,
0.2524194121,
-0.5021403432,
0.3056198359,
0.0012311357,
0.4065700471,
0.0419761874,
0.2310477793,
1.0264177322,
-0.6020600796,
0.4646989107,
0.39722085,
-0.4173467159,
0.8623296618,
-0.1957123131,
0.2391638905,
-0.1305909455,
0.3459365666,
-0.6937513947,
-0.4409106374,
0.691306293,
-0.8512217999,
0.2429433614,
-0.405077219,
-0.1653279364,
-0.1884117723,
-0.2408913076,
0.2736183107,
0.4628876448,
-0.5480405092,
0.6415267587,
0.5932425261,
0.0372857042,
-0.8725758195,
-0.9233399034,
0.3466986418,
-0.2795517147,
-0.5823884606,
0.3707214296,
0.1175176725,
-0.9055889845,
0.1147693917,
-0.0895365775,
-0.3969427645,
0.2849220335,
-0.0138485227,
0.1438204497,
-0.0445159525,
-0.2120946646,
-0.3133194149,
-0.1569396406,
0.6228034496,
-0.4406481385,
0.3948241472,
0.315041095,
-0.4431312978,
-0.5506192446,
0.6306650043,
0.3350592256,
-0.1954895556,
0.5943685174,
0.2536641359,
-0.4660634696,
-0.3964737654,
-0.5925812125,
-0.2937911153,
-0.534537971,
-0.1436227709,
-0.3498551548,
-0.8217717409,
0.2629023194,
-0.2121930718,
-0.2320820987,
0.6905106902,
0.5774775147,
0.1987483203,
0.8856269717,
0.9901567698,
0.2641620934,
0.1337712556,
0.1124592945,
0.4743463099,
-0.1313430816,
-0.2677414715,
-0.4623542428,
0.0110895289,
-0.8708104491,
-0.3095050752,
0.1522601098,
-0.1647081375,
0.0903583914,
0.2758354843,
-0.7148618102,
0.5314125419,
0.5608792901,
-0.4135051668,
0.4312773645,
0.2343754917,
0.168408066,
-0.0031940199,
-0.4667252302,
-0.3992549479,
1.0369499922,
0.1462687403,
0.6997046471,
0.3431171179,
0.5452606082,
0.6856567264,
0.662402153,
-0.6312022209,
0.5758690238,
0.0073600486,
-0.8527685404,
0.0201081056,
-0.5001267195,
-1.1277842522,
0.1678773463,
-0.0134954648,
-0.5563579798,
0.182936579,
-0.3083133698,
-0.0292638596,
0.2526189685,
-0.4409472346,
0.4357470274,
-0.4116617441,
0.0564469025,
-0.1768542677,
-0.6944769025,
0.6988065243,
-0.3005874455,
0.4052810967,
-0.2360787392,
0.0971249491,
0.6102423668,
-0.2289583683,
1.1471062899,
-0.2559447587,
-0.2719234526,
0.4785771072,
0.4408430159,
0.4302393496,
-0.1662006527,
0.2472824603,
0.2986393869,
0.0966352746,
-0.3807374835,
-0.3562038541,
0.6184252501,
-0.5801454782,
-0.6739351153,
-0.7521579862,
-0.149589628,
-0.4422459602,
0.264588058,
0.3253865838,
0.1951541603,
-0.549471736,
-0.157250315,
0.8349804878,
-0.0154503565,
0.2343135029,
0.789609313,
-0.1564198732,
-0.5387601852,
1.1298314333,
-0.1096287295,
0.3603470027,
0.4586164653,
0.1294281334,
-0.2616175711,
-0.4414558709,
-0.1091989204,
0.2361586243,
-0.7197339535,
-0.2106093913,
-0.4414481819,
-0.1990156323,
-0.5940013528,
-0.0697000548,
-0.1655163467,
-0.4545789659,
-0.0572098121,
0.2980680764,
0.3167437613,
0.9952821136,
-0.0091662547,
0.4604481459,
-0.6777329445,
0.3905763328,
0.2751906812,
0.1245658398,
-0.2832791507,
-0.2817859054,
-0.0232120045,
0.1855774969,
-0.2091772109,
-1.0163589716,
0.41291067,
0.045431152,
0.5820026994,
0.4149300754,
0.3919355273,
0.1531599164,
-0.179158017,
1.0254901648,
0.5653711557,
-0.87025249,
0.2540901005,
-0.1400772184,
-0.1957998425,
0.2242301106,
0.98051548,
-0.8068947792,
-0.229678303,
-0.9249736667,
-0.499152571,
0.4821329713,
0.1440705806,
0.0772569031,
-0.079993993,
0.0416184962,
0.5065466762,
0.3515229821,
-0.935221076,
-0.6754650474,
-0.0423214659,
-0.0463184454,
0.2118900567,
-0.2045748979,
-0.7507554293,
0.1426811814,
0.6634334922,
-0.382727474,
0.4585499763,
0.1093409806,
-0.4102712572,
-0.183298856,
-0.0598305725,
0.3876400292,
0.5848799944,
0.6273863912,
0.477743417,
-0.3641055822,
-0.5085593462,
0.2126884907,
-0.0326890536,
-0.2882461846,
0.1952035725,
0.3080117404,
0.5339592695,
-0.0856880695,
-0.602558732,
0.8647749424,
-0.0848153681,
-0.6979372501,
-0.5304329991,
-0.1382619441,
-0.1678378433,
0.0354558788,
0.4881197512,
0.5030628443,
0.2099074274,
-0.5956943631,
0.2370689362,
0.6309096217,
-0.2828575969,
-0.5137672424,
0.5364950895,
0.1422233731,
-0.3468462527,
0.4637702703,
-0.4312552214,
-0.6922218204,
0.2990314066,
0.4293500781,
0.9438424706,
-0.3445912898,
0.6426211596,
-0.2403975427,
0.5313169956,
-0.1443814933,
0.3304501474,
0.0194991902,
-0.9272550941,
-0.3741834462,
-0.4501925409,
-0.6338672042,
0.1512462646,
-0.4432388246,
0.1120709851,
-0.3586217761,
-0.0837870464,
0.1718338728,
0.0822689161,
-0.4290603697,
0.181419462,
0.2293031067,
0.8072753549,
-0.5467789769,
0.6472126842,
0.2384209186,
-0.3457411826,
0.0270102266,
0.1164053753,
0.4175225794,
-0.7411502004,
0.5110653639,
0.1109053865,
-0.5013467669,
-0.2135771662,
-0.8928875923,
-0.9380725026,
0.4370921254,
0.2523518503,
-0.0552991107,
0.1110357195,
0.6444109678,
0.4794244468,
-0.6021484733,
-0.1381541193,
0.678884685,
0.7298825979,
-0.2356596887,
-0.6808161139,
-0.0087175434,
-0.0631094798,
-0.3806341588,
0.1995622516,
-0.7525538206,
0.8149806857,
0.2098102272,
-0.5784543157,
-0.1029856056,
0.4946235418,
-0.387319386,
0.5047725439,
0.4255158603,
0.4013981819,
0.7946200967,
-0.3230446577,
0.6985926032,
-0.3036323786,
0.3244814873,
0.9520773888,
-0.3012282252,
0.3800259531,
0.1352583468,
-0.1082101092,
0.9253609776,
0.5826170444,
-0.1703744531,
0.4678346515,
0.4653765559,
-0.43627581,
-0.1462507993,
-0.0646472722,
0.0105260238,
0.6667138338,
0.6621882319,
-0.0842263326,
-0.1174962446,
0.2815146148,
0.0335285217,
0.1538844258,
-0.1435036212,
0.7404969931,
-0.0106157521,
-0.8465135098,
0.5643375516,
0.2204203308,
0.8632912636,
-0.8025084138,
0.1539794058,
-0.048342742,
0.1522934288,
-0.2968345284,
-0.310585767,
0.2669080794,
-0.2523000538,
0.0902414173,
-0.5321400166,
1.0428193808,
-0.3589494824,
-0.0716691911,
0.2559375763,
0.8414637446,
0.1928723156,
-0.2502044141,
-1.0142301321,
0.1005889252,
0.0109252864,
-0.1323639005,
0.5220241547,
0.5519903898,
-0.0879384726,
0.7627638578,
0.8599696755,
-0.0648411289,
0.1860792041,
-0.0137056829,
0.4657922089,
-0.6880361438,
-0.5339275599,
-0.6580338478,
0.1348422021,
-0.2066181898,
-0.1543955952,
1.0990811586,
0.3678303361,
1.0993403196,
-0.1350952089,
0.8856614232,
-0.072756812,
0.4982688725,
-0.2617073059,
0.5400978327,
-0.3889231682,
0.0531599969,
-0.0498623438,
-0.5791728497,
-0.3291225731,
0.1466573477,
-0.1855250597,
-0.1777079999,
0.8756508827,
0.5311111808,
0.1181816384,
0.3811783791,
0.1920720786,
0.2593749464,
0.1146689728,
0.1514268667,
1.1813849211,
-0.2027924359,
0.4265497327,
-0.2525579333,
-0.1353284121,
-0.3409793973,
-0.6343789101,
-0.558180213,
-0.6757258177,
-0.7259826064,
-0.467849195,
-0.1338868141,
0.2689938843,
0.4840553701,
-0.627758801,
-0.2430735528,
0.028145643,
0.2706483006,
-0.5584253073,
-0.3353855312,
0.0627160892,
-0.2964305282,
-0.7246419191,
0.385183692,
0.2599684894,
0.0720804036,
-0.7686722279,
0.2810610831,
0.03766701,
0.77244699,
0.5039512515,
0.2100292891,
-0.8104997873,
-0.2872934639,
0.0014968156,
-0.0968987346,
0.0640758798,
1.1325443983,
-0.6727725267,
0.3405310512,
0.2687546015,
0.6256821156,
0.0408291332,
-0.1667107493,
0.3586786389,
-0.669572413,
-0.1794623286,
0.5522438884,
0.1502738148,
0.3632639349,
-0.569085896,
0.4551606178,
0.7701476812,
-0.4565828443,
-0.829875052,
0.5395238996,
-0.8118210435,
-0.742251277,
0.9677678943,
0.0701737553,
-0.4960252643,
-0.4806433916,
0.0634925812,
-0.3666072488,
-0.1036727875,
0.9310306311,
0.7692680955,
-0.1488620043,
0.3187390268,
-0.2713123858,
0.9906048775,
-0.0223057289,
-0.87936759,
0.1288697422,
0.6013605595,
0.4642264247,
0.545807898,
0.7971252203,
-0.1136046723,
0.2882133424,
0.3353371024,
-0.0866185799,
0.3296295106,
-0.4660026133,
-0.2297783047,
0.5073325038,
-0.2236790508,
0.0909901634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01018v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01018v1
|
HR-MultiWOZ: A Task Oriented Dialogue (TOD) Dataset for HR LLM Agent
| 2024-02-01T21:10:44 | 2024-02-01T21:10:44 |
Weijie Xu, Zicheng Huang, Wenxiang Hu, Xi Fang, Rajesh Kumar Cherukuri, Naumaan Nayyar, Lorenzo Malandri, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have been reshaping
Natural Language Processing (NLP) task in several domains. Their use in the
field of Human Resources (HR) has still room for expansions and could be
beneficial for several time consuming tasks. Examples such as time-off
submissions, medical claims filing, and access requests are noteworthy, but
they are by no means the sole instances. However, the aforementioned
developments must grapple with the pivotal challenge of constructing a
high-quality training dataset. On one hand, most conversation datasets are
solving problems for customers not employees. On the other hand, gathering
conversations with HR could raise privacy concerns. To solve it, we introduce
HR-Multiwoz, a fully-labeled dataset of 550 conversations spanning 10 HR
domains to evaluate LLM Agent. Our work has the following contributions: (1) It
is the first labeled open-sourced conversation dataset in the HR domain for NLP
research. (2) It provides a detailed recipe for the data generation procedure
along with data analysis and human evaluations. The data generation pipeline is
transferable and can be easily adapted for labeled conversation data generation
in other domains. (3) The proposed data-collection pipeline is mostly based on
LLMs with minimal human involvement for annotation, which is time and
cost-efficient.
|
[
-0.2849133313,
-0.6641236544,
0.3270399868,
0.2413502783,
-0.1138018444,
0.2313189209,
-0.2472812235,
-0.6195982695,
0.031330619,
0.6802031994,
-1.0977499485,
-0.5552831888,
-0.3928918242,
0.0471259356,
-0.1678233147,
1.1653876305,
0.3735601604,
-0.0543267019,
-0.1604782343,
-0.3371275961,
-0.4370755851,
-0.8106375933,
-0.6123377681,
-0.4977656901,
0.8026972413,
0.3410168588,
0.5710775256,
0.6642053723,
0.3009704649,
0.3435727954,
0.0903657153,
0.4213561118,
-0.4180731773,
0.7329959273,
0.0440943688,
-0.2490404099,
-0.9247751832,
-0.1131850928,
0.4412339032,
0.5877398252,
-0.5782089829,
0.4219089746,
0.028136095,
0.5959257483,
-0.4046845138,
0.297291398,
-0.6617116928,
0.1342519969,
-0.5205424428,
-0.245376125,
-0.2996585071,
-0.0070623308,
0.3165727854,
-0.2359951437,
0.2323339432,
0.0918603912,
0.3339206874,
0.24530451,
-0.541960001,
-0.374327898,
-0.7831080556,
1.063133359,
-0.7228736877,
0.6214848757,
0.3004196882,
0.119618319,
-0.39241606,
-0.4268261492,
-0.5874757171,
-0.0628879219,
0.2921183407,
0.0108694304,
-0.2796818614,
0.0849756747,
0.2063743472,
0.1654564738,
-0.3525295854,
0.2570140362,
-0.1939804554,
-0.2196839899,
0.698006928,
0.6673608422,
0.2141278684,
-0.0209197402,
-0.5337415934,
-0.0012190867,
-0.4704345167,
-0.0749299973,
0.4871781766,
0.5197786093,
-0.0388087891,
0.7125083804,
-0.5353011489,
0.7723312378,
-0.3826743066,
-0.4587997198,
0.362069428,
-0.2248750776,
-0.2149773091,
-0.0934132412,
0.9691576958,
0.1667211205,
-0.0359685905,
-0.4075954556,
-0.0057785739,
-0.2218289375,
0.5275418162,
-0.5323524475,
0.1427446753,
0.4139360189,
-0.2993019819,
-0.0774936378,
-0.2304223329,
-0.856890142,
-0.5044699311,
-0.5311337113,
-0.1249012351,
-0.1581944674,
-0.0680561364,
-0.1418294907,
0.0239515789,
0.2665551007,
0.3593660891,
-0.5601372719,
-0.0929125026,
0.5357720852,
0.5789486766,
-0.398637712,
-0.5722941756,
-0.3953990638,
0.2826552987,
-0.3502727449,
0.6978772879,
-0.3509619832,
-0.3888325691,
0.1790318489,
-0.1703299284,
0.0459785722,
-0.4155467451,
0.64781636,
-0.4126006365,
0.3324895203,
0.1130442247,
-0.2205956727,
0.0919154957,
0.605353415,
-0.4910983443,
1.0514410734,
0.1795947254,
-0.5376487374,
0.1025088802,
-0.9090853333,
-0.3215509355,
0.0968041569,
-0.1286407858,
-0.3763708472,
-0.1065240726,
0.0462463871,
0.4607101083,
-0.6155537367,
0.1993435174,
-0.2983325422,
0.053566955,
0.520991385,
-0.4561760724,
0.725291729,
0.2170768082,
-0.1745443344,
0.307197243,
-0.9418092966,
0.3618303239,
-0.047901608,
-0.5336085558,
-0.176577583,
-0.0925949439,
-0.1860812604,
0.4787739813,
0.2599648833,
-0.6774374843,
0.2169070542,
-0.1432009488,
0.196153149,
0.9794096351,
-0.2410116941,
0.1801697761,
-0.2506296635,
0.6227740049,
-0.1991578937,
0.3529254198,
0.0390100181,
-0.6521459818,
-0.7394313216,
-0.2894218266,
-0.0722838268,
0.4660739303,
-0.8913072348,
0.4585580528,
-0.3476753533,
-0.6026906967,
-0.685780108,
0.2366817743,
0.4817295969,
0.5533223748,
0.1531511396,
-0.0016274477,
-0.5726755857,
-0.964697063,
-0.1660266966,
-0.0751825571,
-0.0442662463,
0.4993318617,
0.2471564561,
-0.5680629015,
1.1292551756,
-0.3948889375,
-0.512753129,
-0.383079201,
0.1339499652,
0.1086365804,
0.2483927011,
-0.0053580697,
-0.6402645707,
-0.3782104552,
-0.1435387284,
-0.8330376148,
0.0161629226,
0.178978771,
-0.5316261649,
0.1633753031,
-0.0246618278,
-0.756469965,
0.2432907075,
0.7585014701,
-0.2573636472,
0.4830659926,
-0.1740139574,
0.0495188907,
-1.1489348412,
0.0025085458,
0.0320035964,
-0.2118649334,
-1.0435240269,
-0.2587993145,
-0.4043907523,
-0.2869183719,
-0.5357609987,
0.670583725,
-0.4020565152,
-0.2224036008,
-0.3341161907,
0.0299747139,
-0.2587682903,
1.0355924368,
0.031091975,
0.7563465238,
0.3602577746,
-0.9455320239,
0.7289451361,
0.8789080977,
-0.3101720512,
0.7887117863,
-0.3611718714,
0.8120248318,
-0.0105081024,
0.23818703,
-0.2745223939,
-0.1624542028,
0.4915193319,
-0.324174583,
-0.0708025396,
-0.0861196741,
-0.5533809066,
-0.331359148,
-0.3232733905,
0.108349368,
0.1371790022,
-0.38703686,
0.5846264958,
0.6952804327,
-0.5234060287,
-0.8711690903,
-0.5686256886,
0.2836245894,
-0.2826495171,
-0.5116047263,
0.3165642321,
0.0046489537,
-0.193762958,
-0.1863176227,
-0.1731690615,
-0.3150626421,
-0.0013860302,
0.3784853518,
0.4933907092,
0.1711872369,
0.1115315035,
-0.4741682708,
-0.0632655248,
0.0169915576,
0.0390197895,
0.8059205413,
0.067502521,
-0.4263570905,
-0.4769460857,
0.5383992791,
0.4882081151,
-0.135872528,
0.7679220438,
0.7566398978,
-0.3132970631,
-0.3228116333,
-0.4873861969,
0.1579730213,
-0.4458244741,
0.4707388282,
-0.2577500641,
-0.7057465315,
0.3523892462,
-0.0639569536,
0.3731158376,
0.2287529856,
0.8167648911,
-0.379996717,
0.9173414111,
0.8408963084,
-0.1184388995,
0.7070953846,
-0.0533267595,
0.2282284796,
-1.0871531963,
-0.6135110259,
-0.6300350428,
-0.1670025587,
-0.390181303,
-0.4798747003,
0.4097180367,
-0.2342375219,
-0.0889811218,
0.1662025452,
-0.3567108214,
-0.0194307752,
0.8206685781,
0.0879195929,
0.3134107292,
-0.0855931193,
0.515497148,
0.044589635,
-0.6861008406,
-0.6039865017,
1.2008650303,
0.3095339835,
0.7398761511,
0.2530864775,
0.5095683932,
0.5870144963,
0.2240889668,
-0.7255402803,
0.5527614355,
0.1479172111,
-0.6338467002,
-0.6300153136,
-0.4662760198,
-1.2003530264,
0.345200479,
-0.3248673975,
-0.8452209234,
-0.0068725366,
0.0430112481,
-0.2152577043,
0.1337311566,
-0.4700034857,
0.7475942969,
-0.2498319447,
-0.2014801353,
-0.2019483596,
-0.5876666307,
0.2781891525,
-0.1698428094,
0.1943001151,
-0.6004468799,
0.1813293248,
1.0211803913,
-0.4426801205,
0.8393857479,
-0.1741993725,
-0.3538036942,
0.3816046119,
-0.2237960845,
0.6978917122,
-0.2598542869,
-0.208059907,
0.2503063083,
-0.191465959,
-0.2116641402,
-0.3853701055,
0.2319061607,
-0.4476659596,
-0.4739109874,
-0.3176086843,
-0.9737263322,
-0.8434383869,
0.1158383936,
-0.0413219444,
0.4808108509,
-0.105726324,
0.2792839408,
0.3991880119,
-0.3904977739,
0.2753204405,
0.5611457229,
0.1190744713,
-0.2902802527,
0.8360697031,
-0.1556544602,
0.0278585982,
-0.0596793629,
0.0627204776,
-0.5314691663,
-0.4340849817,
-0.4583840668,
0.0221316256,
-0.6660708785,
-0.3632957339,
-0.6402408481,
-0.0928106382,
-0.3937589526,
0.4031684399,
-0.3443271816,
0.0169402361,
-0.0307343435,
0.1745251715,
0.3703764081,
0.7685702443,
0.2053014785,
0.3289240897,
-1.0605499744,
0.5860483646,
0.4874328673,
0.395088315,
-0.0476770252,
-0.203345418,
-0.4772585034,
0.4035496116,
-0.3039320409,
-0.770922184,
0.4640661776,
0.1652836502,
0.7873517871,
0.0751315206,
0.1934918165,
0.8466504216,
-0.4509610534,
0.6787189841,
0.1709147543,
-0.7939075828,
0.4969494939,
-0.4668897688,
-0.053972438,
0.3133588433,
0.0048700981,
-0.8164355755,
-0.5099911094,
-0.6231563687,
-0.889764905,
1.2596371174,
0.3361536562,
0.3715816438,
0.1668645889,
0.0338318385,
0.2350372374,
0.7180324197,
-0.4741444588,
-0.5151695013,
0.2823620737,
-0.2430496663,
-0.0049327314,
-0.3732864559,
-0.3450753391,
0.1064526066,
0.664857626,
-0.0849357173,
0.5469097495,
-0.0359821208,
-0.0464524962,
0.1646848172,
0.7896965146,
0.3927819729,
0.7542021275,
-0.1357718259,
-0.2120714933,
0.1061265692,
-0.2499238551,
0.0982725471,
-0.1319378316,
0.2499092817,
0.0846770704,
0.181604147,
0.9514772296,
-0.1323100924,
-0.9141744375,
0.324693203,
0.2208164334,
-0.1134173647,
-0.1885477006,
0.0994869918,
-0.0788801834,
0.4720154703,
0.4178955555,
-0.1405079663,
0.1407420933,
-0.8978811502,
-0.0038900105,
0.437903136,
-0.2146566659,
-0.0134401284,
0.4482426047,
0.3533302248,
-0.630492568,
0.9129495025,
-0.2081044316,
-0.4451280534,
0.3599880934,
0.4073356688,
0.6503434777,
-0.1340889931,
0.2011150867,
-0.0787148774,
-0.1604165733,
-0.0668862313,
0.3372907341,
-0.1373433024,
-0.9027504325,
-0.3725783229,
-0.3313439786,
-0.9051790833,
0.0542365648,
-0.8648938537,
-0.0516328588,
-0.0200034566,
-0.521522522,
-0.0980745181,
-0.2151878029,
-0.9941372871,
0.1270035058,
0.2789416909,
0.3104706109,
-0.3686285615,
1.0709325075,
0.40539217,
-0.0167990476,
-0.3667954803,
-0.1162401885,
-0.0233478136,
-1.0377143621,
0.6592804193,
0.0042417203,
-0.2355320305,
0.0483609997,
-0.3442789912,
-0.5596556664,
1.0966284275,
0.5395701528,
-0.4435529411,
-0.2725230455,
0.1881834865,
0.5780043006,
-0.2610487044,
-0.1866268814,
0.4391989112,
0.2605830729,
-0.1727908701,
-0.9775657654,
-0.2273226529,
-0.1925385296,
-0.0822746903,
0.1158024445,
-0.6969781518,
0.8024363518,
-0.1909065396,
-0.2311165482,
-0.1159892976,
0.4420241416,
0.5096743703,
0.2994689047,
0.6108383536,
0.2218078077,
1.0538659096,
-0.1147731468,
1.0201636553,
-0.1362167597,
0.2946291566,
1.392693162,
-0.5243717432,
0.6585161686,
0.4314311445,
-0.3872989118,
0.357377708,
0.3904687166,
-0.2345656008,
0.3075050116,
0.2124620229,
-0.2858822346,
-0.2262990624,
-0.5877756476,
-0.2164026052,
0.609806478,
0.1742319465,
0.0215179436,
-0.0931865871,
0.1872703433,
-0.2069498748,
-0.3292265236,
-0.1701482534,
0.9645546079,
-0.0096204514,
-0.4781961739,
-0.004684173,
0.1065246686,
0.8057554364,
-0.7320592999,
-0.0375797786,
0.0175859258,
0.0283816457,
-0.1554132551,
-0.8150023222,
0.2137856334,
0.3405610621,
-0.0474235006,
-0.6654703617,
0.5913180113,
-0.6037220359,
-0.114273563,
0.1579798609,
1.0272533894,
0.3449524045,
-0.089578703,
-0.7401572466,
-0.0344058685,
0.0384151228,
-0.4157610834,
0.3244222403,
0.438414067,
0.0371273719,
1.0777913332,
0.8044748902,
0.2544763982,
0.3123250902,
0.2139150053,
0.5836806297,
-0.7917490602,
-0.4373197854,
-0.7307088375,
0.5743613243,
-0.1125964299,
-0.4182390571,
0.7173925042,
0.3867483735,
0.5562597513,
0.0510084704,
0.7861635089,
-0.0358265452,
0.7196299434,
-0.5865908861,
0.4338004291,
-0.2311606705,
0.0443851128,
-0.1018249169,
-0.8599753976,
0.1440115273,
0.4125416875,
0.1956268549,
-0.0603726916,
0.4652273357,
0.4210261106,
0.4067472219,
-0.0895013139,
0.2333958745,
-0.1994389743,
0.4829472005,
0.4313286543,
1.0461888313,
-0.2745681405,
0.7608063221,
-0.3799394369,
0.3711290359,
-0.0429361314,
-0.6188974977,
-0.7559119463,
-0.6076029539,
-0.3828437924,
-0.3086061776,
-0.1189091802,
1.0870479345,
0.7447634935,
-0.4208818376,
-0.2008891702,
0.21786201,
0.1623684913,
-0.1753303856,
-0.1657627225,
0.1833777279,
-0.4111656249,
-1.0377341509,
0.6550294161,
0.2083035707,
0.0958822146,
-0.2260912806,
-0.2986011505,
-0.0003989139,
-0.2036384344,
0.6079335809,
0.1675889939,
-0.5949526429,
0.0356714651,
-0.1102573201,
-0.2806342542,
0.2544490993,
1.0000225306,
-0.3650149703,
0.4942418039,
-0.0022837401,
0.7553554773,
0.3589732945,
0.0000059564,
0.7807101011,
-1.1485806704,
0.2954178751,
0.4103048146,
0.2545856535,
0.2490423471,
-0.3933564126,
0.6809802055,
-0.060716249,
-0.4006291926,
-1.0808187723,
0.0395190828,
-0.9733645916,
-0.0685269907,
1.1383353472,
-0.0566938967,
0.0143746585,
-0.5288838148,
-0.1764702499,
0.4270166457,
-0.6296920776,
0.7708086371,
0.7679216266,
-0.561207056,
0.0042678826,
-0.8509286642,
0.4369465411,
0.0497489199,
-1.2883570194,
0.5036658049,
0.5316688418,
0.0553575605,
0.0992264673,
1.0767220259,
0.1242481172,
-0.0404237062,
-0.1076972783,
0.3779007792,
-0.3030285239,
-0.3844038248,
-0.0957313552,
0.1906187832,
0.0031705613,
-0.6005584598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01783v1
|
Hierarchical Multi-Label Classification of Online Vaccine Concerns
| 2024-02-01T20:56:07 | 2024-02-01T20:56:07 |
Chloe Qinyu Zhu, Rickard Stureborg, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Vaccine concerns are an ever-evolving target, and can shift quickly as seen
during the COVID-19 pandemic. Identifying longitudinal trends in vaccine
concerns and misinformation might inform the healthcare space by helping public
health efforts strategically allocate resources or information campaigns. We
explore the task of detecting vaccine concerns in online discourse using large
language models (LLMs) in a zero-shot setting without the need for expensive
training datasets. Since real-time monitoring of online sources requires
large-scale inference, we explore cost-accuracy trade-offs of different
prompting strategies and offer concrete takeaways that may inform choices in
system designs for current applications. An analysis of different prompting
strategies reveals that classifying the concerns over multiple passes through
the LLM, each consisting a boolean question whether the text mentions a vaccine
concern or not, works the best. Our results indicate that GPT-4 can strongly
outperform crowdworker accuracy when compared to ground truth annotations
provided by experts on the recently introduced VaxConcerns dataset, achieving
an overall F1 score of 78.7%.
|
[
-0.3862267733,
-0.8217247128,
0.4897110462,
0.1525317729,
0.0019083826,
-0.0866370276,
0.0691868141,
-0.746814549,
0.0579257421,
-0.0258747321,
-0.2295248359,
-0.4700767696,
-0.6888800263,
0.1760939956,
-0.2803921402,
1.0502306223,
-0.0087882485,
-0.1297467947,
-0.2455767244,
0.357298106,
-0.0924760178,
-0.6644375324,
-0.7766692042,
-0.5025215149,
0.8965018392,
0.5324364901,
0.2288720012,
0.4708731771,
0.2513470352,
0.2041518539,
-0.2707275152,
0.1271202862,
-0.3338847458,
0.0948286429,
-0.0676930845,
-0.6031669378,
-0.3778297901,
0.2693130374,
0.0724930987,
0.1232895926,
-0.3280262053,
0.3890602589,
-0.1357745379,
-0.110709317,
-0.9114196301,
0.1793735027,
-0.5036966205,
0.3044313192,
-0.3187695146,
-0.4408432245,
-0.5543068051,
-0.0650653467,
0.1699601859,
-0.5263971686,
0.2999894917,
-0.1489852667,
0.9479279518,
-0.0267771278,
-0.6375231147,
-0.1560779214,
-0.5381324291,
0.7118333578,
-0.6055287123,
0.2758555114,
0.8609284163,
0.2322937548,
-0.0080301808,
-0.6332241893,
-0.3400609195,
0.0923538953,
0.2144191265,
0.3346790969,
-0.8299269676,
0.263859123,
0.236256972,
0.1579281688,
-0.5942807198,
0.3523496985,
-0.3692504168,
-0.4952010512,
0.2946591079,
-0.0831089988,
0.0460224636,
-0.2667633295,
-0.1982051134,
0.1668622196,
-0.6156899929,
0.3053505421,
0.0876122043,
-0.0410433896,
-0.3929182291,
0.2808687389,
-0.2506684661,
0.71218431,
0.5390298963,
-0.3943619132,
0.0456297025,
-0.3503724039,
-0.2288977802,
0.0837459341,
0.5841408372,
0.5355141759,
-0.0373360589,
0.2709636986,
0.0564568117,
-0.0423081107,
0.3350064158,
-0.8643669486,
-0.2470433861,
0.3582608998,
-0.2808837891,
-0.1602882743,
-0.1072178781,
-0.8867430687,
-0.6172163486,
-0.08581236,
0.2705661356,
-0.1285265088,
0.129969418,
0.1350286156,
-0.2498237193,
0.1384935081,
0.6720761061,
-0.789757669,
-0.1901590824,
0.8210136294,
0.8774875998,
0.000101043,
0.3803529143,
-0.7544426918,
0.2241829038,
-0.291739732,
1.2039572001,
-0.5076410174,
-0.2511918545,
0.1007702574,
-0.1842092127,
-0.16216892,
-0.4440295994,
0.4614666402,
-0.3193820417,
0.4389317632,
-0.2964814901,
-0.5481410623,
0.075249739,
0.8596714735,
-0.234166801,
0.6201704144,
-0.1028389856,
-1.0790066719,
0.5328789353,
-0.4423429668,
-0.2288192511,
0.3741076589,
-0.4142653942,
-0.6146354079,
-0.1014977172,
0.4941513538,
0.5874620676,
-0.3102330863,
0.4463351369,
-0.3356362879,
-0.1161664724,
0.2653974593,
-0.5268705487,
0.3701068461,
0.0115720741,
-0.3984804451,
0.2165134102,
-0.5001603961,
-0.1195887402,
-0.2769348323,
-0.4139042497,
-0.3772338629,
-0.046771206,
-0.3128745556,
0.0880002454,
0.0336716771,
-0.5163280964,
0.3425221145,
-0.4234651923,
0.3830645978,
0.5662977099,
0.5019011497,
-0.041179698,
-0.4565373659,
0.8246073127,
0.1663401723,
0.6122158766,
-0.2252236158,
-1.315477252,
-0.643634975,
-0.5296905041,
0.1074516475,
0.5844164491,
-0.6493756771,
0.2236232162,
0.0871137902,
-0.4795343876,
-0.3556614816,
-0.4049087167,
0.3548901379,
0.6000273228,
0.3793160319,
0.066700615,
-0.2274336666,
-0.8496025801,
-0.1755573303,
-0.504878521,
-0.0675511658,
0.3404183388,
0.3396186233,
-0.2154883593,
0.6637067795,
-0.679916501,
0.0137457559,
0.1121472791,
0.7590756416,
-0.0312156156,
-0.0602458864,
0.3850462139,
-0.5901464224,
-0.4626216292,
0.3129903972,
-0.4606054723,
-0.3312960565,
-0.0475154817,
0.4933533669,
-0.0467471927,
0.3690910041,
-0.6635122299,
0.6386290193,
0.4039863646,
0.060542509,
0.3942496777,
-0.2493516803,
0.3319477141,
-0.9109892845,
-0.0714153945,
0.4020826817,
0.0187956057,
-0.9154569507,
-0.1463030726,
0.0266479068,
0.1239096299,
-0.6247733831,
0.4532388449,
-0.1191178188,
0.3411322832,
-0.0414129309,
-0.2118659914,
0.2819137573,
-0.0996739641,
-0.1289615929,
0.6854880452,
0.5077582002,
-0.659122169,
0.5993638039,
0.1583973765,
-0.2251520008,
0.7007213235,
-0.2791931629,
0.0438538641,
-0.1419818997,
0.6395081878,
-0.7894141078,
-0.5246290565,
0.5640512109,
-0.4879849851,
0.1946412772,
0.0362850316,
-0.2904246747,
-0.7129964232,
-0.4244829714,
0.3548391759,
0.0929899737,
-0.3486962914,
0.0824573338,
0.5750073195,
-0.2125848383,
-0.5643159151,
-0.731400311,
0.2241440415,
-0.2853988409,
-0.2063734531,
0.2843481898,
0.1569598317,
-0.2209551483,
-0.3187191784,
-0.1764459014,
-0.4149134159,
-0.0913412273,
0.3068653047,
-0.0273393057,
-0.1366384178,
0.4843504429,
-0.0132848872,
-0.2831760943,
-0.1236791089,
-0.2300472856,
0.0696484372,
0.1463245451,
-0.4408617914,
-0.7572907209,
0.5241020918,
0.3788222075,
0.0028594444,
0.4230850339,
0.6351159215,
-0.5522063375,
-0.0467936136,
-0.8025898337,
-0.2233307958,
-0.3811362982,
-0.0273396969,
-0.2371936142,
-1.0343052149,
0.2050947994,
-0.0918207392,
-0.130692035,
0.3256767392,
0.5639831424,
-0.0355186649,
1.0095745325,
0.358920455,
-0.0156897213,
0.1763813794,
0.1851300746,
0.3188240826,
-0.2663164437,
-0.6043747067,
-0.7553290725,
0.0983898193,
-0.5797614455,
-0.707993567,
0.5767665505,
0.0358118415,
-0.2170337141,
0.1953109205,
-0.6631982327,
0.1564776152,
0.528465569,
0.0743469819,
0.2951873541,
0.0513503216,
0.0149458265,
-0.0059608268,
-1.0984078646,
-0.09919101,
0.667986095,
0.4291194975,
0.7026329637,
0.0386555307,
0.424721539,
0.2751508057,
0.38720873,
-0.9571672678,
0.1526312083,
0.0201785136,
-0.8284421563,
-0.0275343787,
-0.3583377004,
-1.2923140526,
0.1607704461,
-0.2132652402,
-1.0268769264,
0.6086134911,
0.4278476536,
-0.7526355386,
0.2852509618,
-0.6796696782,
0.6751058698,
-0.2761363089,
-0.1503359526,
-0.251740247,
-0.5405926108,
0.2572154701,
-0.4407925308,
0.3194724619,
-0.2048232257,
0.0173428822,
0.3726217449,
-0.360440731,
1.1562877893,
0.2340877205,
-0.213162154,
0.3958834708,
-0.4917672873,
0.2492989004,
-0.0045631984,
-0.0693293884,
0.3358955383,
0.0910957381,
-0.2376918495,
-0.0192170553,
0.4363597035,
-0.649418056,
-0.9109022617,
-0.8224275112,
-0.1577219516,
-0.2048152387,
-0.0544948727,
0.5593914986,
0.3359141648,
-0.0764028877,
0.1265613884,
0.6121652722,
-0.6983818412,
0.1949292272,
0.5674170852,
0.0383386947,
-0.2484502941,
0.7289897203,
0.3913166821,
0.1809770316,
0.7147536278,
0.6146682501,
-0.3274171352,
-0.1945076585,
-0.3593329191,
0.0680108964,
-0.6256818771,
-0.4277379215,
-0.6668428183,
-0.184585467,
-0.6179106236,
0.0248130783,
-0.0171500668,
-0.0022622629,
-0.6507322788,
-0.2531656921,
0.5269821882,
0.9441004992,
-0.171467185,
0.2442746311,
-0.8360603452,
0.3856616914,
0.639003098,
0.3595703244,
-0.134402886,
-0.5091619492,
-0.202956751,
-0.0470871292,
-0.526244998,
-1.0738694668,
0.280157119,
0.1516211927,
0.5262638927,
0.888703227,
0.2684963048,
0.7390936017,
-0.3265210688,
0.7680996656,
0.3764589727,
-0.8492441177,
0.56618011,
-0.4289812744,
0.6011006832,
0.0638000593,
0.9030237794,
-0.7856570482,
-0.3040278554,
-0.3936890364,
-0.7231978774,
0.5800080299,
-0.0805631801,
-0.295375824,
-0.4006926417,
0.1478155404,
0.0919629037,
0.1348002106,
-0.4443939626,
-0.0940380096,
-0.1176138595,
0.2396768928,
0.1890506893,
-0.3366839588,
-0.2481712103,
-0.2810070217,
0.439229995,
-0.1129813567,
0.140482083,
0.1374592185,
0.4681723118,
-0.2673709393,
0.6918016672,
0.7343478799,
0.7077222466,
-0.0564632304,
0.5215290785,
0.0961186588,
-0.3373946548,
0.3066325486,
-0.03052577,
-0.3348971903,
0.0270076264,
0.4355475903,
0.9027251601,
0.2270849347,
-0.3115848899,
0.7605161071,
0.1540018767,
-0.3299566805,
0.0992465392,
-0.257229656,
0.1336062998,
0.1361234933,
0.2452706695,
-0.1367332786,
0.3072176576,
-0.3594371974,
0.4706299603,
0.3105783165,
-0.4576632679,
-0.4228176177,
0.407962501,
0.1857943088,
-0.0865726247,
0.2669047117,
-0.0230493415,
-0.2747666538,
0.5701074004,
0.5272686481,
0.5398358703,
-0.7406648397,
0.648142159,
0.216953218,
0.2428387105,
-0.3197443187,
-0.0455357656,
0.1920049787,
-0.5098165274,
-0.6365228295,
-0.2366397679,
-0.6169402599,
0.5916270614,
-0.6767439842,
0.2635255456,
-0.31178388,
-0.7753670216,
0.3583722413,
-0.4646054804,
-0.2929168344,
0.269934535,
0.4878219962,
0.7430517077,
-1.0287526846,
0.5989066362,
0.5759752393,
-0.2808600962,
-0.5620971918,
0.2209381163,
0.3780224621,
-0.5862230062,
0.443590492,
0.4959918559,
0.0568372644,
-0.3886970878,
-0.6132884026,
-0.6143612862,
0.7813998461,
0.330432415,
-0.6150491834,
-0.0528733768,
0.0536560565,
0.4960139692,
-0.1623478234,
0.361348629,
0.198004663,
0.5496762991,
0.2584163249,
-1.0449701548,
-0.2896488905,
-0.0303886421,
-0.3271754682,
0.11015784,
-0.5014971495,
0.8347254992,
-0.0581744276,
-0.4006804526,
-0.3378692865,
0.2516461313,
0.1830481738,
0.773612082,
0.2300240695,
0.5310611129,
0.9484007359,
-0.1149722114,
1.0977061987,
-0.0598491319,
0.2215880305,
0.8597313762,
-0.2369141281,
0.8113297224,
0.2914667726,
-0.1436711848,
0.1129415482,
1.0057144165,
-0.0144336885,
0.1132260039,
0.3672635853,
-0.5415688753,
-0.5859590173,
-0.5125896931,
-0.7128151059,
0.3413958251,
0.6403346658,
0.0714211762,
-0.3263287246,
0.2331967503,
0.1524760127,
-0.3052300811,
-0.4065625966,
0.8090387583,
0.1907354295,
-0.7077887654,
0.3838647306,
0.1045599952,
0.5962809324,
-0.4997038841,
-0.1152989119,
-0.0066835438,
0.2250987887,
-0.2389567643,
-0.6383598447,
0.0621887222,
0.1028561294,
-0.1891481727,
-0.235341385,
0.7672128081,
-0.4902305603,
-0.3733632267,
0.3030423224,
0.562912643,
0.3041100502,
-0.2904083431,
-0.8869819045,
0.1609796137,
-0.1081227362,
-0.1565338373,
0.3719137013,
0.4022412002,
-0.4914923608,
0.6648961902,
0.5334732533,
0.137182489,
0.0579280779,
0.1191381067,
0.5265283585,
-0.298007071,
-0.420897752,
-0.6666386724,
0.3352374732,
-0.1644417644,
-0.3617120385,
0.7534863949,
0.3713166118,
0.6878226399,
-0.0471921302,
0.8604823351,
0.3592142761,
0.492851913,
-0.051380191,
0.5371649265,
-0.3891998529,
-0.1211613342,
0.0674134865,
-0.1471308023,
-0.6474013329,
0.6311092973,
-0.5257983804,
-0.0194378458,
0.6409560442,
0.5840876102,
0.2929611802,
-0.0453263149,
0.4706681967,
0.2094602734,
0.3968704939,
0.3483127952,
0.8756250739,
-0.0585791878,
0.3757553101,
-0.0140556358,
-0.3810971081,
-0.625336349,
-1.0224301815,
-0.7699945569,
-0.3408287764,
-0.7615377307,
-0.2566245794,
0.2832913399,
0.9805061221,
0.8297063708,
-1.1166815758,
0.0163883939,
0.1232202798,
-0.1332023442,
-0.0665694028,
-0.1908937544,
0.1634116322,
-0.1248821616,
-0.3653983474,
0.3177597523,
0.6102964282,
-0.0097320713,
0.0236778818,
0.3202231526,
-0.5529288054,
0.149281323,
0.6805958152,
0.5509448647,
-1.0376595259,
-0.3967494071,
-0.0216538254,
-0.3620919585,
0.2057569474,
0.5140951872,
-0.4032807052,
0.844265461,
0.5892860293,
0.7245292068,
0.7295634151,
0.2361022532,
0.487470001,
-0.584176898,
-0.1703793854,
0.1341980398,
0.081090413,
0.4240631759,
-0.4048844576,
0.0454824604,
0.4910863638,
-0.4456005991,
-0.4196026623,
0.3654004037,
-0.735571444,
-0.2664043009,
1.3497689962,
-0.3139053583,
-0.0705464259,
-0.6357672811,
-0.1074972153,
0.3561708629,
-0.6085470319,
0.7592434287,
0.7318735719,
-0.342746228,
-0.3484272361,
-0.5737394094,
0.4302579463,
0.0801577717,
-0.9725819826,
-0.2133323848,
0.5106512308,
-0.0766592175,
0.2586191893,
0.8158702254,
0.1870963424,
0.1654992253,
0.0103967711,
0.1584413201,
0.2774245441,
-0.3329198658,
-0.4286899269,
0.4873244464,
-0.0875205994,
-0.0982228816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00978v1
|
An Information-Theoretic Approach to Analyze NLP Classification Tasks
| 2024-02-01T19:49:44 | 2024-02-01T19:49:44 |
Luran Wang, Mark Gales, Vatsal Raina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT
|
Understanding the importance of the inputs on the output is useful across
many tasks. This work provides an information-theoretic framework to analyse
the influence of inputs for text classification tasks. Natural language
processing (NLP) tasks take either a single element input or multiple element
inputs to predict an output variable, where an element is a block of text. Each
text element has two components: an associated semantic meaning and a
linguistic realization. Multiple-choice reading comprehension (MCRC) and
sentiment classification (SC) are selected to showcase the framework. For MCRC,
it is found that the context influence on the output compared to the question
influence reduces on more challenging datasets. In particular, more challenging
contexts allow a greater variation in complexity of questions. Hence, test
creators need to carefully consider the choice of the context when designing
multiple-choice questions for assessment. For SC, it is found the semantic
meaning of the input text dominates (above 80\% for all datasets considered)
compared to its linguistic realisation when determining the sentiment. The
framework is made available at:
https://github.com/WangLuran/nlp-element-influence
|
[
-0.5002228022,
-0.7650302649,
0.3004595935,
0.3340161443,
0.0828798264,
-0.2466861755,
-0.1824221462,
-0.5334060788,
-0.0930437595,
0.389656961,
-0.4915397167,
-0.2582553923,
-0.7951956391,
0.2006157488,
-0.2115700543,
1.2520647049,
-0.0484534279,
0.0819324255,
-0.3561322391,
-0.0073993024,
-0.3092053533,
-0.6832593083,
-0.7668110728,
-0.3135857582,
0.7430339456,
0.2923787534,
0.5097786188,
0.2996094227,
0.7405474186,
0.2282441109,
-0.2180120945,
-0.1685673594,
-0.1874156445,
0.2635134757,
-0.598161459,
-0.5907148123,
-0.0027657463,
0.0421111323,
0.5450446606,
0.6046299338,
-0.0125770904,
0.3426459134,
0.446816653,
0.4789747596,
-0.7465039492,
0.4854852259,
-0.366971761,
0.092779465,
-0.2324308306,
-0.6552175283,
-0.6894969344,
0.104219161,
0.2969103158,
-0.3211729825,
0.2020883411,
0.0978869498,
0.6596790552,
0.4016331732,
-0.416703701,
-0.637822926,
-0.7745281458,
1.0641262531,
-0.5165738463,
0.2621705234,
0.5262762308,
0.0718195289,
-0.0761944801,
-0.3137952983,
-0.7213823795,
0.1784312278,
-0.3841965497,
0.1329690814,
0.0152383652,
0.1812390834,
0.2025487125,
0.1937072426,
-0.4431669116,
-0.0979093835,
-0.2561658919,
0.0135861421,
0.485237807,
-0.0245293025,
0.5193937421,
-0.5580818057,
-0.2677383423,
-0.3001189828,
-0.1094782874,
0.3718587458,
0.0816725492,
0.4724061787,
0.0904683322,
0.7303598523,
-0.2445612103,
1.023750186,
-0.0322902277,
-0.3675380945,
0.2429955751,
-0.6064330935,
-0.2737285793,
0.2661296129,
0.700361073,
0.1458665282,
-0.1532330364,
0.0818383396,
0.1227396727,
0.1471786201,
0.4513979256,
-0.7931470275,
0.1688842773,
0.2310760766,
-0.3354291618,
-0.5416324735,
0.2223625928,
-0.8796079755,
-0.4594269097,
-0.5181046724,
0.2833767831,
-0.376868844,
-0.2483784854,
0.159080565,
-0.232306689,
0.4781889617,
0.2580767572,
-0.9039866924,
0.3106673658,
0.6643275619,
0.617731154,
-0.3475387096,
-0.1804946214,
-0.3707719743,
-0.0609222949,
0.1099076644,
0.7687657475,
-0.6706518531,
0.0593043603,
-0.1572255492,
-0.1291619688,
-0.5145128965,
-0.1219992265,
0.8558318019,
-0.6230316162,
0.6421944499,
-0.1463280469,
-0.609893322,
-0.4212646484,
0.4830889702,
-0.7096313238,
1.1968204975,
0.1711113453,
-1.4614604712,
0.4210103452,
-0.8678161502,
-0.3989215791,
0.0579167008,
-0.1662639529,
0.0174392536,
-0.0554853007,
0.0014384006,
0.7968626618,
-0.2961564064,
0.2614680529,
-0.1667122245,
-0.0557349138,
0.3871368468,
-0.3654456735,
0.8553583026,
0.0773456022,
-0.4854426384,
-0.1490696073,
-0.9351328015,
0.1608352661,
-0.2359254509,
-0.5736837387,
-0.600902319,
0.3008230925,
0.2496695369,
0.4701962173,
-0.1961942166,
-0.656336844,
-0.0703992918,
-0.5561522245,
0.1873404831,
0.522870481,
0.1464299113,
0.5079040527,
-0.1700387597,
0.6440255046,
-0.11548841,
-0.0606066436,
0.1169762686,
-0.5825240016,
-0.593028605,
-0.0650156289,
0.5876383185,
0.7942519784,
-0.8980814815,
0.3922043741,
-0.0347247384,
-0.3487334549,
-0.4179850221,
0.0679987371,
0.1474236399,
0.4991958141,
0.318156898,
-0.2143930942,
-0.6415855885,
-0.6106513143,
-0.3252978623,
-0.4053884745,
0.0041613113,
0.0650325492,
0.4706230164,
-0.286112994,
0.9891513586,
-0.4239313006,
-0.4083724916,
-0.494088918,
0.1591546834,
0.2244759202,
0.4622969329,
0.5335319042,
-0.9440159202,
-0.2659653425,
0.1400243193,
-0.5999101996,
-0.1686100066,
-0.3143666983,
-0.2971618772,
-0.0908514932,
0.3146502674,
-0.5337550044,
0.5151538253,
0.5755714774,
-0.5446871519,
0.5427716374,
0.2223775536,
0.0175667647,
-0.9778500199,
0.0549344942,
0.1729234904,
0.0512334928,
-0.8004683852,
0.2558784783,
-0.1765764058,
0.2341511697,
-0.2114238143,
0.548040092,
0.1776784807,
0.2395889461,
-0.1963400245,
0.0294421203,
0.1975902021,
0.4771543145,
0.0829709694,
0.4211032391,
0.3525996208,
-0.8864431977,
0.1228859499,
0.1206314415,
-0.3386286497,
0.6225150824,
-0.4146220088,
-0.2642834485,
-0.3663915992,
-0.0255873185,
-1.1296262741,
-0.2552780211,
0.4834674001,
-0.7215676904,
0.2287648767,
0.344088167,
-0.5806831717,
0.0199816879,
-0.1611026824,
0.2568382621,
-0.0769897029,
-0.4324393272,
0.9132731557,
0.3095692992,
-0.3133815527,
-0.799508214,
-0.7693306208,
-0.3184649944,
-0.2326233536,
-0.3758277893,
0.37212044,
-0.0963717699,
-0.4382324219,
-0.0043220143,
-0.0171351843,
-0.3793066442,
0.1374144703,
0.3040297031,
0.1968260556,
0.001251373,
0.4514944851,
0.2549452484,
-0.0072548883,
0.3073066473,
-0.0805253983,
0.451536864,
-0.0561941788,
-0.0500474982,
-0.5068966746,
0.311712116,
0.3932671547,
-0.1167796254,
0.8764718771,
0.7819855809,
-0.1336107105,
-0.5502246618,
-0.2031390816,
-0.0106076384,
-0.4048168659,
0.4204078019,
-0.2507765889,
-0.6636992097,
0.0513653755,
0.1430963427,
0.191466257,
0.7129353285,
0.5868549943,
-0.4658493102,
1.0100259781,
0.6176714301,
-0.1070557982,
0.5863682628,
-0.1508692801,
0.1638967544,
-0.7788473368,
-0.1586934179,
-0.6570264101,
-0.2241569906,
-0.4642646909,
-0.3379666209,
0.0467668585,
0.0887317732,
0.0534743033,
0.156758219,
-0.6198607683,
0.1929801553,
0.470539093,
0.0745860636,
0.0973486975,
-0.0738983154,
-0.166746974,
-0.0464642011,
-0.8652656674,
-0.4906730652,
1.0343463421,
0.3055936396,
0.4320515692,
0.1389275491,
0.4278839827,
0.3260039687,
0.2271976173,
-1.1272301674,
0.3808746934,
0.1327411383,
-0.5900031328,
-0.195935756,
-0.3781320751,
-1.0111193657,
0.5035463572,
-0.4836151004,
-0.4228221774,
0.0909428224,
0.0479566157,
-0.1089726686,
0.1040889323,
-0.6668038368,
0.7320831418,
-0.1713611484,
-0.1080782264,
0.0034378816,
-0.4823611379,
0.2374203354,
0.0084607312,
0.4501484632,
0.2086071819,
0.1372049749,
1.1090149879,
-0.014412187,
0.9967136979,
-0.1697553843,
0.035374973,
0.3473995924,
-0.11606244,
0.1493314803,
-0.0186711624,
-0.3778342605,
-0.1640968025,
0.3661405146,
-0.2931947112,
-0.8363486528,
0.244284749,
-0.6208161712,
-0.2172884643,
-0.694327116,
-0.504255414,
-0.322058171,
0.2434756011,
0.3601128459,
0.4873211384,
0.0220511239,
0.360037297,
0.6923005581,
-0.1202474535,
0.4214396477,
0.1109068245,
-0.2489735186,
0.0595675185,
0.674454987,
0.0439885296,
0.2718189359,
0.6265566349,
0.4326784015,
-0.1982751936,
-0.3939217329,
-0.2327984422,
0.0717164874,
-0.9582493901,
-0.0917664543,
-0.5653538704,
-0.1514260322,
-0.1989586204,
0.0275653638,
0.1715051979,
-0.4025246203,
-0.4673074186,
-0.1905229688,
0.1276023835,
0.8285766244,
0.3109752238,
0.5149122477,
-0.4825360477,
0.1522505879,
0.2622594535,
0.3864162266,
-0.0058882916,
-0.3785215318,
-0.1404840201,
-0.2326030731,
-0.3310943246,
-0.9709872007,
0.226724565,
0.2764558196,
0.5864078403,
0.4926081896,
0.2036483586,
0.1770569384,
-0.1906486899,
0.7105147839,
0.1071040928,
-1.0159258842,
0.5140416026,
-0.0296373833,
0.4186050296,
0.9799674153,
0.4142028093,
-0.6263075471,
-0.3715156317,
-0.6336112022,
-0.5886902809,
0.8260859847,
0.3257251382,
-0.1943329871,
0.1412374973,
0.3993182778,
0.0129067954,
0.2734965086,
-0.8403613567,
-0.1825433224,
-0.0013085604,
-0.5230668187,
-0.0260262229,
-0.2420043647,
0.1802754849,
-0.4020683765,
0.6546964645,
-0.0728730708,
0.3727987707,
0.3173340857,
-0.1377504468,
0.2483271509,
0.4970368147,
0.4748721719,
0.6586867571,
-0.1255484968,
0.4059630036,
0.0820255876,
-0.6479522586,
-0.0807711035,
-0.2862235308,
-0.379837811,
0.2583062649,
0.657497406,
0.6748978496,
0.1129240915,
-0.5456910133,
0.4956873059,
-0.2058401555,
-0.2456617057,
-0.0921393782,
0.2110204846,
-0.1630384624,
-0.0756646842,
0.1648223549,
0.5100854039,
0.4354732931,
-0.4961802363,
0.3468990028,
0.2189273238,
-0.8082660437,
-0.2610150576,
0.1658729613,
-0.0777191371,
-0.1770927459,
0.1748115569,
-0.4275282025,
-0.7935206294,
0.4925810099,
0.439267844,
0.5224118233,
-0.410397321,
0.378477186,
0.4097683132,
0.3139374256,
-0.0321052484,
0.3678495586,
-0.0931770504,
-0.9080684781,
-0.6743703485,
-0.7911729813,
-0.3561527431,
-0.0425128937,
-0.902197361,
0.2739240825,
-0.481445998,
-0.1662788987,
0.3104893565,
-0.1707509011,
-0.8029987216,
0.5853602886,
0.0509985425,
0.56268543,
-0.7458121181,
0.7206215262,
0.7519504428,
-0.0698402077,
-0.8465319872,
-0.0801637471,
-0.0437707379,
-0.3870678246,
0.8785010576,
0.3087745011,
-0.1097813249,
-0.1893798858,
-0.4388732612,
-0.9487065077,
0.5926159024,
-0.1731682122,
-0.0307213962,
-0.0287536196,
0.1248339713,
0.5789600611,
-0.4876145124,
0.3352481425,
0.5717865825,
0.5819030404,
0.0470815934,
-0.794224143,
-0.0626880303,
-0.5328366756,
-0.0712099969,
0.242519781,
0.0788788125,
0.6510983109,
0.1001830921,
-0.3265713453,
-0.4975081682,
0.3530379534,
0.0997264162,
0.2857612967,
0.6547117829,
0.2105380744,
0.7272446752,
-0.0582588613,
1.2887179852,
-0.1056310833,
0.4116708338,
1.178365469,
0.0353320427,
1.1890138388,
0.6966639161,
-0.3252010643,
0.6716954112,
0.6165830493,
0.1130894646,
0.4479323626,
0.424732089,
0.0289859902,
0.1671568453,
-0.2153640389,
-0.1261789799,
0.8276174664,
0.4968014359,
-0.4751022458,
-0.1354559213,
0.4010019004,
-0.0340871848,
-0.0663532689,
-0.3011256158,
0.8616227508,
-0.1884336025,
-0.5438866615,
0.1491408199,
0.1464018673,
0.7276696563,
-0.6489163637,
-0.0404481292,
0.5041717887,
0.2301497608,
-0.4515697658,
-0.7548327446,
0.507643342,
-0.112075597,
-0.4418139458,
-0.370875001,
0.830928266,
-0.2496004552,
-0.6277961731,
0.3490141034,
0.3070144057,
-0.0572475083,
-0.1436310112,
-0.7261266708,
-0.1338647008,
0.1355375648,
-0.447025001,
0.3688054979,
0.299621284,
0.2532404363,
0.3426382244,
0.4545766711,
0.2224374563,
0.0769988745,
-0.2482782155,
0.5336139202,
-0.7277864218,
-0.6293270588,
-0.7688236833,
0.4461142123,
-0.1073528007,
-0.4024907649,
0.7481950521,
0.3184588253,
0.9255897999,
0.1626672,
0.9792590737,
-0.3696448207,
0.6126004457,
-0.470295608,
0.4646481276,
-0.3078432977,
0.2509682775,
-0.5600568056,
-1.0014128685,
-0.4612871706,
0.6893476248,
-0.4004733562,
-0.3171487749,
0.9386947751,
0.2723148167,
0.2336097658,
0.4539900124,
-0.1361948401,
-0.1507153362,
0.094851248,
0.2871849537,
0.8227690458,
-0.4980527461,
0.4291599691,
-0.4344499707,
-0.318606168,
0.0767857805,
-0.7327589393,
-0.7702325583,
-0.740224421,
-0.2539242208,
-0.2864151597,
-0.6420662403,
0.9248560667,
0.4879591763,
-0.9596546888,
-0.3268256783,
-0.10430713,
0.2749309838,
-0.4592673779,
-0.3920062184,
0.4307124913,
-0.669365108,
-0.5793336034,
0.0517226309,
0.1499873847,
-0.2237325311,
-0.0805317238,
0.2005744278,
-0.5080983043,
0.1421731561,
1.0307987928,
-0.1288370043,
-0.6339737773,
-0.2491255403,
0.0559706986,
-0.0732175261,
0.0886464193,
0.8448711634,
-0.5944264531,
0.6210811734,
0.766119957,
1.0250912905,
0.2010884136,
0.0950165093,
0.5019797087,
-0.8213359118,
-0.0085451752,
0.2916863859,
0.1561683416,
0.0210335366,
-0.6690823436,
0.5926648378,
0.0477597751,
-0.4292191267,
-0.6769026518,
0.1676122546,
-1.1256220341,
-0.489697516,
1.2838368416,
0.001752352,
-0.271424979,
-0.3809561133,
-0.3955747783,
0.0333939083,
-0.2531353235,
0.4661590159,
1.15989995,
-0.504360795,
-0.2487817854,
-0.7620533705,
0.6717565656,
0.6139879823,
-0.9761065245,
-0.1732428223,
0.174909398,
-0.1244832575,
0.614325881,
0.4165886045,
0.0104607129,
-0.0173588563,
-0.3161176145,
0.1184135675,
0.398978591,
-0.289803952,
-0.3477894962,
0.6761856079,
-0.089551881,
-0.1109511182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00969v1
|
SPARQL Generation with Entity Pre-trained GPT for KG Question Answering
| 2024-02-01T19:38:32 | 2024-02-01T19:38:32 |
Diego Bustamante, Hideaki Takeda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, 68P20, 68T50, H.2.3; H.3.3; I.2.7
|
Knowledge Graphs popularity has been rapidly growing in last years. All that
knowledge is available for people to query it through the many online databases
on the internet. Though, it would be a great achievement if non-programmer
users could access whatever information they want to know. There has been a lot
of effort oriented to solve this task using natural language processing tools
and creativity encouragement by way of many challenges. Our approach focuses on
assuming a correct entity linking on the natural language questions and
training a GPT model to create SPARQL queries from them. We managed to isolate
which property of the task can be the most difficult to solve at few or
zero-shot and we proposed pre-training on all entities (under CWA) to improve
the performance. We obtained a 62.703% accuracy of exact SPARQL matches on
testing at 3-shots, a F1 of 0.809 on the entity linking challenge and a F1 of
0.009 on the question answering challenge.
|
[
-0.7613430023,
-1.2008618116,
0.599213779,
0.0900428966,
-0.1773954332,
-0.0350954197,
0.150634557,
-0.556443572,
0.0616189316,
0.6512727141,
-0.6864998341,
-0.3851646781,
-0.6167867184,
0.2784105539,
-0.0052654296,
1.1513618231,
-0.2086554319,
0.0373788886,
-0.1190495715,
-0.1098852605,
-0.5833176374,
-0.3643346727,
-0.8682157397,
-0.2074991912,
0.4466466308,
0.127952233,
0.6664458513,
0.2940884531,
0.2198267579,
0.2332963496,
0.0032201547,
0.1569491327,
-0.5831799507,
0.0924390405,
-0.2447365522,
-0.2958049178,
-0.2271744609,
-0.2336571515,
0.4266267717,
0.7888810635,
-0.1830944121,
0.1519556493,
-0.1031758711,
0.839173615,
-0.3497284949,
0.1050703749,
-0.9053763747,
0.1840644628,
-0.1992552578,
-0.0878881961,
-0.0812759921,
-0.5101581812,
0.2272239327,
-0.9509499669,
0.4170845151,
0.2161717415,
0.9940270185,
0.3551226258,
-0.7079917789,
-0.5638861656,
-0.6504743099,
0.1746786833,
-0.1697583348,
0.5740253329,
0.3470167816,
0.5128198266,
-0.3460655212,
-0.8258328438,
-0.6373593807,
-0.2603767812,
-0.055352103,
-0.0265522581,
-0.159735471,
0.0482788011,
0.4181301296,
0.0205243547,
-0.8643429279,
-0.3371451497,
-0.1568968594,
-0.0836258978,
0.4870134294,
0.1393217742,
0.2860756516,
-0.1433456689,
-0.2427013963,
0.0604735985,
-0.8226424456,
-0.2574897707,
0.4631529748,
0.0964002907,
0.5725591183,
0.7974684238,
-0.5077620149,
0.930764854,
0.1670132428,
0.1248321161,
0.1018956527,
-0.3320055008,
-0.0078082974,
0.0478576273,
0.7123565078,
0.1198333427,
0.5541716218,
-0.4580339491,
-0.0403272733,
-0.2165047228,
0.3582342863,
-0.858487308,
-0.3654809892,
0.0425482094,
0.0999270082,
-0.0134885097,
-0.1825437993,
-0.4663371742,
-0.1126464903,
-0.2456981093,
0.8174148798,
-0.5214916468,
-0.4465357959,
0.0324709117,
-0.0648615286,
0.1920312941,
0.1889529824,
-0.6248463392,
0.3011040688,
0.3910190463,
0.3632374406,
0.1485391259,
-0.0554203987,
-0.3608179092,
0.3284128308,
-0.178615883,
0.9248732924,
-0.3250793815,
-0.369894743,
-0.4104487002,
-0.2550302148,
-0.289750427,
-0.4506704807,
0.2291358858,
-1.0474990606,
0.3123333454,
-0.4610312283,
-0.8199098706,
0.1394782215,
0.4266890883,
-0.5631076097,
1.2517887354,
0.4411518276,
-0.9283437729,
0.5523641706,
-0.9132024646,
-0.4536474347,
0.2872145176,
0.0080651753,
-0.2849621177,
-0.3164205849,
0.5740993023,
0.2649171948,
-0.283901453,
0.3545966148,
-0.0681278259,
-0.1101486161,
0.2712818384,
-0.0561611615,
0.4470049739,
0.350138247,
-0.3172563016,
-0.229883492,
-0.7192436457,
0.5699176788,
0.2945998311,
-0.2106168866,
-0.134323746,
-0.3175607324,
-0.3223308921,
0.2581541538,
0.0699528754,
-0.2974283695,
0.2076374441,
-0.4997321367,
0.0800324678,
0.4902649522,
0.5740644336,
0.273702085,
0.1097992733,
0.6990537047,
-0.0637685061,
0.1273354739,
0.4591147602,
-0.8032747507,
-0.4043089747,
0.1098874211,
0.4442116022,
0.5910876989,
-1.3468555212,
0.223412782,
-0.2782873213,
-0.6965667009,
-0.4904951751,
0.2341315299,
0.5272288918,
0.8336189389,
0.5225037932,
-0.2046020776,
-0.3159306347,
-0.6186302304,
-0.4451006353,
-0.1501403898,
-0.1312799156,
0.5880420804,
0.5314151645,
0.0021246525,
1.208520174,
-1.1071870327,
-0.2125602812,
-0.2896238267,
0.3669098616,
0.1985110193,
0.2921236455,
0.5375559926,
-0.9652785659,
-0.8837020397,
-0.0395219848,
-0.706408143,
-0.0973107219,
0.5411864519,
-0.4540915489,
0.1135209054,
0.1230170727,
-0.9956640005,
0.2116562575,
0.032324113,
-0.3212935627,
0.5105756521,
-0.0737720802,
0.3187918067,
-1.1015846729,
0.1124090478,
0.0587340705,
-0.0770626143,
-0.7856421471,
-0.1180995107,
-0.2547620237,
-0.445078522,
-0.3596888781,
0.4247433245,
-0.5379252434,
-0.073399432,
-0.0245352592,
0.2383240312,
-0.0689445361,
0.4252437055,
0.0427226722,
0.7399569154,
0.3629656732,
-0.7303336859,
0.4980239868,
0.3581654131,
-0.243067503,
0.6153709888,
-0.6765212417,
0.4273086786,
-0.343097657,
0.2009420246,
-0.8103718758,
-0.2924052477,
0.4054060876,
-0.5173186064,
0.2928091884,
-0.4686697721,
-0.4234830439,
-0.4710221589,
0.1598470956,
0.1790492535,
0.3169012368,
-0.194380179,
0.5132229924,
0.4246340394,
-0.1845235527,
-0.803811729,
-0.1731807888,
-0.1643562019,
-0.0336942859,
-0.8379333019,
0.1961311847,
-0.1218748689,
0.0900485888,
0.5242445469,
-0.0650911704,
-0.4291674495,
0.0499336347,
-0.0285509638,
0.1519302428,
-0.419521153,
0.2407359481,
-0.1534894258,
-0.2921313345,
-0.0479945689,
-0.4515844285,
0.5596671104,
-0.0380426273,
-0.380359441,
-0.0623996146,
0.2199812084,
-0.1012759805,
-0.1772284508,
0.8223705888,
0.7772325873,
-0.4235124588,
0.0624934286,
-0.7667538524,
-0.013988737,
-0.4410227239,
0.5264250636,
-0.5487993956,
-1.055475831,
0.2628499269,
-0.0188031849,
-0.4657092392,
0.5041233897,
0.4497431517,
0.040080063,
1.0468486547,
0.4189583957,
-0.0396421812,
0.1567209512,
-0.0324177183,
0.2735690475,
-0.347781688,
-0.3238326907,
-0.6025594473,
0.1052438244,
-0.4510369301,
-0.1615518034,
0.6060246229,
0.4958038032,
-0.295578748,
0.4049296975,
-0.6365346909,
0.7761986256,
0.5239458084,
0.135915935,
0.1522009373,
-0.0620636456,
-0.1245730743,
-0.0574186929,
-0.6518986821,
-0.1609846056,
1.1543328762,
-0.2570471168,
0.5830533504,
0.1043836102,
0.6599668264,
0.0795332193,
0.5530869961,
-0.370986253,
0.5093132257,
0.4414257109,
-0.9103177786,
-0.5596702099,
-0.909237206,
-0.9763987064,
0.1310311556,
-0.4137540758,
-0.6876288056,
-0.4802944362,
0.3018129468,
-0.0876260102,
0.1456442028,
-0.9953836799,
1.1289139986,
-0.1926278323,
-0.1079779118,
0.2877790928,
-0.7531176805,
0.256024152,
0.0480989739,
-0.0628654957,
-0.0161894839,
0.3569946289,
0.6421957016,
-0.3837828338,
0.2842717171,
-0.6894073486,
0.1854947805,
0.5884888172,
-0.0559254438,
0.7163138986,
0.0949056447,
0.1585700661,
-0.3037728071,
-0.0186455324,
-0.2967168689,
-0.8493971229,
0.4152976274,
-0.8115070462,
-0.649928689,
-0.1536280364,
-0.3459370434,
-0.5759548545,
0.3009954989,
0.3797846437,
0.1823456734,
-0.2926424146,
-0.1468602866,
0.9201257229,
-0.0411444157,
-0.1436743289,
0.613057971,
-0.1910189837,
-0.4595677853,
1.0168030262,
0.4658575356,
0.0974016786,
0.5777897239,
-0.1768230647,
-0.7699424624,
-0.5442985296,
-0.7128208876,
0.2190086097,
-0.7408217192,
-0.3309778273,
-0.9599297047,
-0.3123077154,
-0.7295130491,
0.0924795866,
-0.0967279524,
-0.3743297458,
-0.1923388839,
-0.1566180587,
0.3863987327,
0.856433928,
0.2509236038,
0.1109041795,
-0.8147422075,
0.4828934968,
0.6495078802,
0.3638316393,
-0.2424889356,
-0.0716144592,
-0.0499220155,
-0.1554079801,
-0.4352792203,
-1.1535129547,
0.2917786837,
0.1622174531,
0.6143474579,
0.0606779195,
0.0686802417,
0.7860119939,
-0.5290825963,
0.6443402171,
0.0684751347,
-0.7063326836,
0.7370702624,
-0.1388974339,
-0.05185261,
0.4442874193,
0.8468618989,
-0.4286653996,
-0.2837222219,
-0.8609514236,
-0.8520596027,
0.5805554986,
0.4871500134,
-0.2041440606,
-0.1225571781,
0.6147519946,
-0.0735997707,
0.3160879016,
-0.7566761971,
-0.3328780532,
-0.3295695484,
-0.3205483258,
0.1515450478,
-0.2003418505,
-0.045174744,
-0.1733849943,
0.9312092066,
-0.20293428,
0.3552634418,
0.1467617303,
-0.366217941,
-0.0002586727,
0.4405302107,
0.2663565874,
0.7582837939,
-0.1767060906,
-0.1004202664,
0.5208250284,
-0.4668323398,
0.2261135578,
0.4966595769,
-0.1116134152,
-0.1792964935,
-0.0489179902,
0.6501687169,
-0.0159869026,
-0.4673907757,
0.4576944411,
-0.1105366647,
-0.2941562533,
-0.3085024059,
0.189539358,
0.4236022532,
0.181423977,
0.4651295841,
-0.3289720714,
-0.0016754876,
-0.1042633429,
0.1307568848,
0.5389347076,
-0.3736572564,
-0.1136138141,
0.7577240467,
-0.035379488,
-0.1056227386,
0.8028905988,
-0.6499468088,
-0.6457736492,
0.4883215725,
0.7561520934,
0.5129135847,
-0.0447299406,
0.3271537423,
0.3183785081,
0.307297796,
0.0832085013,
0.2440428436,
-0.0572205298,
-0.9938190579,
-0.4031958878,
-0.7131128311,
-0.4032274187,
0.0053648008,
-0.5214060545,
-0.0126525462,
-0.0865856484,
-0.1761918515,
-0.0199685171,
0.1698322892,
-0.7391617894,
0.4453024864,
-0.3371142447,
0.666097939,
-0.6493943334,
0.7557916641,
0.7913377881,
-0.6017569304,
-1.0536057949,
-0.3015644848,
-0.4126339257,
-0.7871158719,
0.8752204776,
-0.0207150057,
0.1128031164,
0.524379611,
-0.5653504133,
-0.7863385677,
1.2116699219,
0.552862227,
-0.0103594493,
-0.2304328978,
0.4769183993,
0.473312974,
-0.1056239083,
0.2336802632,
0.4443974495,
0.4693023562,
0.3474062979,
-0.7519378662,
0.0229572151,
-0.1955541521,
-0.0315016769,
0.6002995372,
-0.1647774279,
0.5638493299,
-0.1257733405,
-0.2559158504,
-0.2795098722,
0.6164585948,
0.2131346315,
0.4185288548,
0.56700176,
0.8955331445,
0.8567603827,
-0.2936583459,
1.0564713478,
-0.3144772351,
0.4829167128,
0.9113765955,
-0.3707748055,
0.4542584419,
0.2378169894,
-0.445807606,
0.0922203362,
0.4908097684,
0.0746931881,
0.4852666855,
0.2355876118,
-0.4971981347,
-0.3207447231,
-0.1570217609,
-0.5945654511,
-0.0331600942,
0.329128921,
-0.065621078,
-0.4081824422,
0.0064464021,
0.1062365025,
-0.190449059,
-0.251585573,
0.8318775296,
-0.0686388016,
-0.7963573337,
0.2871717811,
-0.0726943389,
0.3223760724,
-0.8316797614,
-0.1286175549,
-0.0376851037,
-0.2723808587,
-0.0476238541,
-0.8860221505,
0.2334905714,
0.1119560599,
-0.098850958,
0.0068152235,
1.1886463165,
-0.3586032093,
-0.3373191655,
-0.0319759659,
0.7242636085,
0.2821211517,
-0.4503826201,
-0.8043754697,
-0.5885801911,
-0.0722061545,
-0.4358122945,
0.4520831406,
0.8091331124,
0.0707513541,
0.7170692682,
0.6357834935,
-0.0881532803,
0.423352778,
-0.0981165022,
0.9937546849,
-0.6259419322,
-0.3622085154,
-0.4764795899,
0.1583172828,
-0.1388269812,
-0.3495771885,
0.4966536462,
0.4833016992,
0.8766809702,
-0.081363745,
0.6049754024,
-0.3484404385,
0.4463147223,
-0.7136319876,
0.7949094176,
-0.2555160224,
-0.1679261476,
-0.3967760801,
-1.0143945217,
-0.1022201702,
0.3441992998,
-0.2940390706,
0.2367053479,
0.6901944876,
1.0273982286,
0.1732029915,
0.1784192324,
0.2486377656,
0.0157751627,
0.3098351359,
0.7179837227,
0.7537974715,
-0.2583250105,
1.0053796768,
-0.2485276461,
0.1218258739,
0.1297622621,
-0.7503247261,
-0.6732975245,
-0.4127361774,
-0.2039626986,
-0.5157065988,
0.1667070687,
0.7967332602,
0.3887811601,
-0.6179214716,
0.3113497794,
-0.197230801,
0.1890621483,
-0.0267232712,
-0.3271900713,
0.5208128691,
-0.4157037437,
-0.3989844322,
0.1025669053,
0.0384011269,
0.197325483,
0.0907260552,
-0.0978892669,
-0.2705672085,
-0.279501617,
0.4590452015,
0.3905469775,
-0.1608183831,
-0.4398288429,
-0.0844673812,
-0.1135602593,
0.0413588881,
0.6716392636,
-0.7735901475,
0.2943562567,
0.2736397386,
0.9510279894,
0.9592741728,
0.060279794,
0.3277257085,
-1.0829498768,
-0.1887460649,
0.2973379493,
0.0838904455,
0.3139408231,
-0.5110145807,
0.7390424609,
0.597258985,
-0.6180246472,
-0.5421069264,
0.27800107,
-0.7234130502,
-0.0031765951,
0.8720373511,
-0.0543232225,
-0.2403762937,
-0.4582811892,
-0.225220114,
0.5148188472,
-0.1063173264,
0.5289186835,
0.7175725698,
-0.4349276423,
-0.0165263694,
-0.6596668363,
0.4620347917,
0.1816602349,
-0.9017788768,
-0.4146949947,
0.418746382,
0.7029985785,
0.0756197646,
1.1394741535,
-0.0454310589,
0.0417893343,
0.028526105,
0.1121772155,
-0.1749836355,
0.0073066703,
0.3676487505,
0.626863718,
0.314060539,
0.1500614882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00956v2
|
Exploring Spatial Schema Intuitions in Large Language and Vision Models
| 2024-02-01T19:25:50 | 2024-05-27T14:29:31 |
Philipp Wicke, Lennart Wachowiak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the ubiquity of large language models (LLMs) in AI research, the
question of embodiment in LLMs remains underexplored, distinguishing them from
embodied systems in robotics where sensory perception directly informs physical
action. Our investigation navigates the intriguing terrain of whether LLMs,
despite their non-embodied nature, effectively capture implicit human
intuitions about fundamental, spatial building blocks of language. We employ
insights from spatial cognitive foundations developed through early
sensorimotor experiences, guiding our exploration through the reproduction of
three psycholinguistic experiments. Surprisingly, correlations between model
outputs and human responses emerge, revealing adaptability without a tangible
connection to embodied experiences. Notable distinctions include polarized
language model responses and reduced correlations in vision language models.
This research contributes to a nuanced understanding of the interplay between
language, spatial experiences, and the computations made by large language
models. More at https://cisnlp.github.io/Spatial_Schemas/
|
[
-0.2717780173,
-0.6979519129,
1.1390790939,
0.1869313121,
-0.0065745264,
-0.0355618335,
-0.3139497042,
-0.6303985715,
0.3076277077,
0.445885241,
-0.393753618,
-0.6214920878,
-0.5806819201,
-0.1547328532,
-0.4691053331,
0.5153992176,
0.1620467901,
0.0793691203,
-0.3888080716,
-0.3511435091,
0.0484528765,
-0.5870130658,
-0.2931056321,
-0.5391612053,
0.522331357,
0.294411391,
0.8074055314,
0.3933283091,
0.4408731461,
0.2663296759,
-0.0026335584,
0.0084748259,
-0.1703113019,
-0.0440168679,
-0.1194579005,
-0.4896514118,
-0.1877241284,
-0.0994210318,
0.7163161635,
1.1836827993,
-0.3247305751,
-0.1071414351,
0.1596805602,
0.4356458187,
-0.6198886633,
0.4446082711,
-0.421456486,
0.2435036302,
0.0096133472,
-0.1157112196,
-0.3523080051,
0.1391466707,
0.1673089415,
-0.6793735623,
0.1513375193,
0.1975545734,
0.6850014925,
0.2718147635,
-0.5249848962,
-0.1150380671,
-0.9722806215,
0.6248078942,
-0.6292939782,
0.684225738,
0.3964075446,
0.1839957833,
-0.1090538949,
-0.5412470102,
-0.9172676206,
-0.3548702002,
-0.2155407369,
0.1954966933,
-0.321503669,
0.1819323599,
0.4088181853,
-0.1990011036,
-0.5357547998,
0.2436949313,
-0.3316708803,
0.0589330643,
0.5759628415,
0.2683581114,
0.3835488558,
-0.2043800652,
-0.4096440375,
-0.0698823258,
-0.8208819032,
-0.0956532434,
0.079056628,
0.2330980748,
-0.5210409164,
1.0105568171,
0.0494624972,
0.6922348738,
-0.1585984826,
0.1703769118,
0.1155385524,
-0.1974421591,
-0.0450847372,
-0.1965394318,
0.8338435888,
0.4178812802,
0.3988458514,
-0.363293618,
-0.0387558863,
0.1935368478,
0.4482687414,
-0.2971383929,
-0.203899309,
0.1950334311,
-0.2737770379,
-0.0404288433,
0.0526750311,
-0.4893783331,
-0.7481360435,
-0.5435259342,
0.0198187102,
-0.3504230082,
-0.2575555742,
0.2760260701,
-0.2482434064,
0.7155159712,
0.4080618024,
-1.0914210081,
0.320762068,
1.0276920795,
0.6328836083,
-0.0695175752,
-0.8847948909,
0.2348355204,
0.3772905171,
-0.5358456373,
0.9334258437,
-0.6263354421,
-0.3631011248,
-0.0951632485,
-0.0809440613,
-0.0657773614,
-0.3533051312,
0.1870637387,
-0.260659039,
-0.0214692429,
-0.32369259,
-0.2652618587,
-0.1747305542,
0.1552329212,
-0.5009729266,
1.0462229252,
0.0292858724,
-0.5396590829,
0.62251091,
-0.7412029505,
-0.3981920481,
0.2702944279,
-0.6936116219,
0.1220897734,
0.4615269601,
-0.0293437317,
0.3870100379,
-0.3567952514,
0.2164550275,
-0.6208704114,
-0.372608602,
0.2877677679,
-0.0046871575,
0.7413768172,
0.0529924147,
-0.3423092961,
0.1601695269,
-0.518301487,
-0.1652981937,
0.3348273933,
-0.0598970577,
-0.3475850224,
0.4255829453,
-0.1078872308,
0.0851421878,
0.1883009523,
-0.5596583486,
0.1739325523,
-0.5189108253,
0.6236188412,
0.6831738353,
-0.5332710743,
1.149164319,
-0.0202703997,
0.4017410576,
-0.1438455731,
0.0029424215,
-0.011140855,
-0.4831961393,
-0.72666502,
-0.2988541722,
-0.4337974787,
0.401438117,
-0.6049564481,
0.433860451,
-0.4108627737,
-0.557508409,
-0.1974942535,
0.1050232425,
0.0464408807,
0.1465751082,
-0.0338784941,
-0.0107950456,
-0.4309201539,
-0.9182344079,
-0.1779922694,
-0.3540785909,
-0.2815234661,
0.8212059736,
0.5725871921,
-0.3230887949,
1.086741209,
-0.438593775,
0.0030910929,
-0.3841306865,
0.019301679,
0.1431894898,
0.1238973737,
1.011852622,
-0.5038154125,
0.0743842795,
0.176367864,
-1.1734127998,
-0.1498021781,
0.0033174397,
-0.0954469666,
0.1048928127,
0.704487741,
-1.0859960318,
0.5143674016,
0.7278738618,
-0.671325326,
0.2924608886,
-0.4239531755,
-0.1884957254,
-0.7369539738,
0.0447380431,
-0.2600954473,
0.3730740249,
-0.4310843349,
0.4079466462,
-0.0731068552,
-0.2055229098,
-0.4446326196,
0.758245945,
-0.685834825,
-0.8211323023,
-0.1801283807,
0.4914017916,
0.0367065556,
0.4760822952,
0.2921636701,
0.4012823105,
0.6321934462,
-0.5826830268,
0.2671577334,
0.1304531991,
-0.4712838233,
0.3862177432,
-0.8421979547,
0.0842215195,
-0.2899068296,
0.3739771545,
-1.077319026,
-0.2334787399,
0.4223828912,
-0.3912819922,
-0.0290895402,
-0.0978723317,
-0.664789021,
-0.3983968794,
-0.0039002753,
0.5517463684,
0.229773134,
-0.4348728061,
1.0971332788,
0.4512865543,
-0.073625274,
-0.1641883254,
-0.9372392893,
0.2047139108,
-0.1718112975,
-0.5224673152,
-0.1904159337,
0.0404137932,
-0.7046428919,
-0.2917927504,
0.2270525247,
0.0434483923,
0.4046646655,
0.6064001918,
0.2531681359,
-0.2652167976,
-0.1638980657,
-0.0847768635,
-0.042038817,
0.504255116,
-0.36685884,
0.5778746605,
-0.2519007623,
-0.9054162502,
-0.2767320871,
0.2112775594,
0.911883235,
0.0081130005,
0.6207614541,
0.2672273815,
-0.4467747509,
-0.1237942949,
-0.1923558116,
-0.2737820148,
-0.4470594823,
0.4684301019,
-0.3883112967,
-0.7096601725,
0.6535061598,
0.076362066,
-0.0694265664,
0.0500396825,
0.4950307608,
-0.5178857446,
0.767280817,
0.4588911235,
0.0708877519,
0.5146026015,
-0.2253725231,
0.4442487359,
-0.8756332994,
-0.4769521654,
-0.5584898591,
-0.5035021305,
-0.5379900932,
-0.826446116,
0.3275552988,
-0.1815612018,
-0.4170104563,
0.0906541571,
-0.0933907777,
0.4584685862,
0.5267528296,
0.078468062,
-0.0581674576,
0.056038443,
-0.1783257723,
-0.093953602,
-0.8137862682,
-0.4706535041,
0.9188908339,
0.2464151531,
0.8263479471,
0.1198532358,
0.3561574817,
0.1272730529,
0.020434089,
-0.7876778245,
0.7980054021,
0.0646920279,
-0.4178480208,
-0.328132391,
-0.0044886023,
-1.124122858,
0.4775202572,
-0.3401505351,
-0.8264933825,
0.2830245793,
0.0305572916,
-0.2701821327,
0.2941664159,
-0.6262071729,
0.5466985703,
-0.5488105416,
-0.4305211306,
-0.2502075434,
-0.6020656824,
0.1829030216,
0.1902868599,
0.3661524057,
-0.0875473171,
-0.1211342886,
0.2620544434,
-0.0943105966,
1.1729222536,
-0.1044687107,
-0.5022842288,
0.2605827451,
0.3889908195,
0.2212660462,
-0.1364954263,
0.206370309,
0.7783788443,
-0.35645473,
-0.5279427171,
-0.8094334602,
0.6198788285,
-0.8361899853,
-0.3259564936,
-0.3412078917,
-0.6904969215,
-0.1707163751,
0.1499399394,
0.0821949989,
0.08173877,
-0.3459571898,
0.0619377382,
0.3762111962,
-0.4151456654,
0.2657190859,
0.6316061616,
-0.4939705729,
-0.0692275167,
0.5798089504,
-0.2176713347,
0.1205117777,
0.425296545,
0.1554745585,
-0.1990925521,
-0.4199468493,
-0.3551226556,
0.4460509121,
-0.7138242722,
0.3173522949,
-0.472751379,
-0.1754759997,
-0.3243705332,
-0.4270582795,
-0.3000843525,
-0.4291935265,
-0.1246241182,
-0.418020457,
0.2528609931,
1.2920609713,
-0.0590723678,
0.3320887089,
-0.5850721598,
0.3225471675,
0.0801584646,
0.2158777118,
0.1260420233,
-0.4729522765,
-0.1716991216,
0.4210610092,
0.1893020868,
-0.5949683189,
0.2454915196,
-0.0628433898,
0.6485483646,
0.6584585309,
-0.2538822889,
0.5510062575,
-0.6226432323,
1.0194100142,
0.0001559845,
-0.7591783404,
0.3740666509,
-0.7778277993,
0.3536259532,
-0.0194888338,
0.1176766083,
-0.2914173901,
-0.4551073015,
-0.5949516892,
-0.9926012158,
0.4411676526,
-0.0717917383,
0.1382318437,
-0.0514261574,
0.4411369264,
-0.0499247238,
0.2101322412,
-0.7087264657,
-0.0841730908,
-0.0150258522,
-0.1591306031,
-0.4425339997,
-0.2699944079,
-0.3256589174,
-0.2835813463,
-0.2511002421,
-0.28151685,
0.5476398468,
-0.0386661477,
-0.1974326521,
0.0606995858,
-0.0213932283,
0.7284324169,
0.6320120096,
0.2610827088,
0.3950519562,
0.2002712339,
-0.2584061325,
-0.3026619554,
-0.2835793793,
-0.2725923359,
-0.2815475166,
0.7947975397,
0.7157123089,
0.652628243,
-0.7009477019,
0.4968467057,
0.0862796605,
-0.2834845781,
-0.4539408982,
-0.1059154421,
0.2579212189,
0.5541693568,
0.2108099461,
0.0876845792,
0.0150520457,
-0.5430713892,
-0.2399294525,
0.731104672,
-0.2043231279,
-0.6787030697,
0.504547894,
-0.0449163765,
-0.2727618515,
0.8228316903,
0.2265315652,
-0.5721794963,
0.6279246211,
0.3826068938,
0.9216992855,
0.2087890655,
0.0291966051,
0.179221645,
0.5521891117,
0.2289471626,
0.3476266563,
-0.3958593905,
-1.2441391945,
-0.1938405186,
-0.5573717356,
-0.4209719598,
-0.3229147792,
-0.6162369251,
0.0666812435,
-0.5560297966,
0.0618099533,
-0.3020196259,
-0.5683123469,
-0.7284725904,
-0.0327012241,
0.5580963492,
0.7059426904,
-1.1319845915,
0.6858935356,
0.8384420276,
-0.1788291782,
-0.6746744514,
-0.1010467038,
-0.1016836762,
-1.1137980223,
0.805213213,
-0.2429312468,
-0.4998080432,
-0.3266145885,
-0.921669662,
-0.8189234138,
1.0899486542,
0.4523785114,
-0.4737787843,
-0.1937693805,
0.4950536788,
0.8028275967,
-0.1306307465,
0.2636771798,
0.5621849298,
0.5359449387,
-0.0423712581,
-0.7002887726,
-0.0647447705,
-0.112268649,
-0.1589043438,
0.0854341909,
-0.7933124304,
0.7225987911,
-0.7153707147,
-0.1897093207,
0.2096881121,
0.6341637373,
0.488912344,
0.5576346517,
0.338852793,
0.7084723711,
0.5075829625,
-0.1783098876,
1.1986665726,
-0.3780333698,
0.012552415,
1.1498974562,
-0.7415574789,
0.9567808509,
0.8826804161,
-0.2497157454,
0.6953907013,
0.3471639752,
0.2085521072,
0.3151046038,
0.242678985,
-0.0804383382,
-0.279361546,
0.0899481177,
-0.0920954794,
0.964810133,
0.6445403695,
-0.1361842304,
-0.1132438406,
-0.0201737992,
-0.2395916432,
0.069915995,
0.0208592918,
0.8213025928,
0.220567584,
-0.502022922,
0.0691092834,
-0.4874693751,
0.3795492649,
-0.7814689875,
-0.0928035825,
-0.341958195,
0.180618003,
-0.0745024979,
-1.0543084145,
0.221068576,
-0.3686247766,
-0.1662614346,
-0.5576148033,
0.4777851999,
-0.1135465056,
-0.3299912214,
0.696187675,
0.6230583787,
0.3996563256,
0.0129711265,
-0.4707960784,
0.1485179812,
-0.3692050278,
-0.1241446286,
0.284788847,
0.9056063294,
-0.0452145077,
0.8603284955,
0.7391828299,
0.291859597,
0.0216113403,
0.0930416584,
0.6291097403,
-0.9671871066,
-0.3634218872,
-0.7493602633,
0.2477271557,
0.313940078,
-0.1602686197,
0.908349216,
0.4668028951,
0.8250368237,
-0.1221142188,
0.617082715,
-0.0157573987,
0.0648375601,
-0.5113960505,
0.8831365108,
-0.5405210257,
0.3378841579,
-0.3955329955,
-0.7970366478,
-0.3402373493,
1.0656266212,
-0.4280747175,
0.0961114019,
0.64134866,
0.6357873082,
0.0853252113,
-0.0499967486,
0.4345912039,
0.5957986116,
0.1369674355,
0.3917303085,
1.3245742321,
-0.0246504266,
0.0713569149,
0.0500135124,
-0.026695488,
-0.1339395195,
-0.9040266275,
-0.6580137014,
-0.5480001569,
0.1335122883,
-0.2211242914,
-0.1797658503,
0.6027411819,
0.6564104557,
-0.4476584792,
-0.5415175557,
-0.2394023538,
-0.0453773253,
0.0468660071,
-0.2397177666,
0.0340683348,
0.1539186686,
-0.6495694518,
0.5714373589,
0.4348068535,
0.3103605807,
-0.4202947617,
-0.2656989098,
0.0058463565,
0.0508864708,
0.8995668888,
0.3149748743,
-0.9847397208,
-0.4435792863,
0.2085842639,
-0.1145645529,
-0.2053667903,
1.0070112944,
-0.7954984903,
0.1947662383,
0.377923429,
0.3915840983,
0.3865638971,
-0.2537852228,
0.8665700555,
-0.5140842795,
0.6280124784,
0.1491579562,
0.7317467332,
0.3106424212,
-0.1635739505,
0.4671763182,
0.2373293936,
-0.337228775,
-0.7055647969,
0.3506894112,
-1.2315833569,
-0.2948952317,
1.492051363,
0.106850341,
-0.3777295649,
0.1448257864,
-0.2299121022,
-0.168876186,
-0.0731692314,
0.7722720504,
0.7869446278,
-0.2170398831,
-0.1012447029,
-0.339171797,
0.0350909419,
0.4954459667,
-0.5250808597,
0.2167942375,
0.7747744918,
0.0220952109,
0.175963074,
0.5338846445,
0.1773431301,
0.2147979438,
0.2240542918,
0.2327130586,
0.2171174884,
-0.5687103868,
-0.4456355274,
-0.0452599563,
0.2582393289,
-0.0164490324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01781v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01781v2
|
When Benchmarks are Targets: Revealing the Sensitivity of Large Language Model Leaderboards
| 2024-02-01T19:12:25 | 2024-07-03T11:20:43 |
Norah Alzahrani, Hisham Abdullah Alyahya, Yazeed Alnumay, Sultan Alrashed, Shaykhah Alsubaie, Yusef Almushaykeh, Faisal Mirza, Nouf Alotaibi, Nora Altwairesh, Areeb Alowisheq, M Saiful Bari, Haidar Khan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Model (LLM) leaderboards based on benchmark rankings are
regularly used to guide practitioners in model selection. Often, the published
leaderboard rankings are taken at face value - we show this is a (potentially
costly) mistake. Under existing leaderboards, the relative performance of LLMs
is highly sensitive to (often minute) details. We show that for popular
multiple-choice question benchmarks (e.g., MMLU), minor perturbations to the
benchmark, such as changing the order of choices or the method of answer
selection, result in changes in rankings up to 8 positions. We explain this
phenomenon by conducting systematic experiments over three broad categories of
benchmark perturbations and identifying the sources of this behavior. Our
analysis results in several best-practice recommendations, including the
advantage of a hybrid scoring method for answer selection. Our study highlights
the dangers of relying on simple benchmark evaluations and charts the path for
more robust evaluation schemes on the existing benchmarks. The code for this
paper is available at
https://github.com/National-Center-for-AI-Saudi-Arabia/lm-evaluation-harness.
|
[
-0.4354490638,
-0.8140993118,
0.536654532,
0.1963827908,
0.0111367237,
0.0169997066,
-0.3972068429,
-0.4901322424,
-0.2081384957,
0.3064190447,
-0.3704170883,
-0.3385313451,
-0.7473546267,
-0.1371395886,
-0.1886118948,
0.9683232903,
0.0229790937,
-0.0312357396,
-0.2083802372,
-0.4257715344,
-0.4320488572,
-0.9050895572,
-0.4076176286,
-0.4071221352,
0.8434170485,
0.4732254446,
0.917689085,
0.528807044,
0.7648031712,
0.1746929735,
-0.3316136599,
-0.1319610924,
-0.5598291159,
0.2920232713,
-0.0469305962,
-0.5874004364,
-0.724034071,
0.2503089309,
0.7704190016,
0.9331662059,
-0.2195000201,
0.5127785206,
0.2301488519,
0.758112371,
-0.8688379526,
-0.0163923781,
-0.837102592,
-0.3405579329,
-0.4932027757,
-0.0861438215,
-0.5469486117,
-0.2052383721,
-0.1254940331,
0.0831142813,
0.0111780548,
-0.0614986941,
0.6647641659,
0.2738605738,
-0.4154450893,
-0.0291957054,
-0.5089316964,
0.9278678894,
-0.4338622689,
0.4084240794,
0.3344211578,
0.7072640657,
-0.091951251,
-0.3988391161,
-0.0400586389,
-0.3298055232,
0.1956811994,
-0.0046961345,
-0.0164498687,
-0.1431394815,
0.5700044632,
0.3133710623,
-0.3772003651,
0.4272786379,
0.0053423028,
-0.210703671,
0.638053894,
0.2361953855,
-0.068773672,
0.1269703358,
-0.1837309897,
-0.3736240268,
-1.1862336397,
0.2738548517,
0.4303489029,
0.4961892366,
0.1957000494,
0.5129998326,
-0.1585609317,
0.7783677578,
0.0998856053,
-0.0115648592,
0.1441062391,
-0.2971082926,
-0.1129204929,
0.0186364241,
0.4441803694,
0.5988214612,
0.3792132437,
0.1445535719,
-0.3223694563,
0.0918765813,
0.2406877279,
-0.8204162121,
-0.0657323003,
0.1428572237,
-0.3412714899,
-0.3506391048,
-0.1186251342,
-0.6167360544,
-0.3857117295,
-0.0421179906,
0.2777647972,
0.1792634726,
0.1039613634,
-0.2334697396,
0.1623158753,
0.2792682648,
0.3417108655,
-0.8648914099,
0.3730165362,
0.6033405662,
0.5320029855,
-0.3409851491,
-0.5861424208,
-0.8024677634,
0.034109436,
-0.4420513809,
0.9149215221,
-0.5705000758,
-0.6767729521,
-0.0634169281,
-0.5254979134,
-0.0830299705,
-1.0852533579,
0.530121088,
-0.4796545804,
-0.1189262271,
-0.5788742304,
-0.220703274,
0.413493216,
0.2341659963,
-0.6432980299,
1.0967261791,
-0.1110438704,
-0.7922115326,
0.2927022874,
-0.3461786807,
-0.4328519702,
-0.2926090956,
-0.322498858,
-0.3793622851,
0.0518840738,
0.271743238,
0.3613705635,
-0.2437095344,
0.175032869,
-0.1412457228,
-0.4511863887,
0.5077118874,
-0.5649693012,
0.6639410257,
0.0851287618,
-0.2550303638,
0.3070089221,
-0.6143323183,
0.1461159289,
0.0179198179,
-0.6491359472,
-0.1333573461,
0.0910027176,
-0.0619106777,
0.265214622,
0.215820536,
-0.1839414835,
-0.0528530031,
0.1111940444,
0.1357991397,
1.1566463709,
-0.035284292,
0.0023692567,
-0.6877309084,
0.5918424129,
-0.2736022472,
0.3956423998,
0.054244481,
-0.6885485053,
-0.6395743489,
0.115000017,
0.2782709002,
0.3736137152,
-0.2800537944,
0.0878323391,
-0.1765611768,
-0.6725472212,
-0.6401920319,
0.259992063,
0.4003088176,
0.4363559484,
0.3181777298,
-0.0584714003,
-0.2382490039,
-1.0729498863,
-0.7121729851,
-0.472225517,
0.1423122436,
0.4816223383,
0.2850912213,
0.0352040678,
0.6110219359,
-0.5925465822,
0.0733364671,
-0.0483020097,
0.061657235,
0.3929677606,
0.2132063508,
0.4788144827,
-0.9165531993,
-0.5851078033,
-0.3687359691,
-0.3221220374,
-0.4339259267,
0.0366812423,
-0.0978066027,
-0.0151223354,
0.688626945,
-0.4618693292,
0.1133293435,
0.8177425861,
0.0125783756,
0.8576510549,
0.1044121459,
0.0572130866,
-0.674649477,
0.2732352614,
-0.0514717773,
-0.1559349298,
-0.4085896611,
0.3883895278,
0.1901170015,
0.2188595384,
-0.3921875358,
0.4942938089,
-0.235645473,
-0.1769667715,
-0.1365879178,
0.0713128299,
-0.3537622392,
0.1883763224,
-0.331068337,
1.081348896,
0.2075713128,
-0.6323612928,
0.1979351938,
0.1776789874,
-0.6656220555,
0.6364892125,
-0.4515661895,
0.3083983064,
0.1325589716,
0.0095923161,
-1.0609633923,
0.0393792242,
-0.1869219393,
-0.4488010108,
0.3395999968,
-0.1038570404,
-0.5723518133,
-0.2297803462,
-0.4730889797,
0.3252144456,
0.3881953955,
-0.5438140631,
0.0737720877,
0.5098392367,
-0.3152236342,
-0.6024934053,
-0.6788567305,
0.1094716638,
-0.1869325936,
-0.2671561837,
0.1996897757,
-0.76924932,
-0.5479599237,
-0.3403526843,
-0.3815051317,
0.1618722677,
0.6091352701,
0.4196873903,
0.2155992389,
-0.2632767558,
0.1285507679,
-0.2597010732,
-0.1990539432,
0.1645959914,
0.4222919941,
0.5097958446,
-0.2215261757,
-0.5321495533,
0.0611643791,
0.2203451991,
0.5329729319,
-0.3287242651,
0.5354620814,
0.0678441301,
-0.1710191071,
-0.266800344,
-0.6064189672,
-0.3042401671,
-0.5153317451,
0.4380010366,
-0.6156350374,
-0.7763493657,
0.4352290034,
-0.0092737824,
0.0334302038,
0.5820400715,
0.8611729145,
-0.0000869306,
1.2093849182,
0.5452888608,
-0.2708005905,
0.3743801117,
0.3063508868,
0.111465238,
-1.0098944902,
-0.0286431033,
-0.9221382737,
-0.4951403439,
-0.8117667437,
-0.3159981966,
0.5127701759,
-0.02679516,
-0.1934615076,
0.1462246031,
-0.2632190585,
0.5375650525,
0.3602417707,
-0.1082042083,
0.3600098193,
-0.1902065575,
-0.4350655079,
-0.2973817587,
-0.6364626288,
-0.5584443808,
1.2012383938,
0.3113929927,
0.9303474426,
0.311640054,
0.4200481176,
0.2432872951,
0.5865998268,
-0.726772368,
0.756265223,
-0.0468821004,
-0.8125590682,
-0.4151924253,
-0.3613550663,
-0.8540133238,
0.4281204641,
-0.038932398,
-0.8372095823,
-0.001274623,
-0.1160571724,
-0.5178918839,
0.0523965769,
-0.5050227642,
0.7154532075,
-0.3397642374,
-0.3291061521,
-0.1035497114,
-0.4218158424,
-0.0507271141,
-0.2008882761,
0.2148087323,
-0.2227665633,
0.0096811634,
0.6987862587,
0.0086086849,
0.7861963511,
0.0650684983,
-0.1719346642,
-0.1197685823,
0.1773265898,
0.3764101863,
-0.1382551938,
-0.4980788529,
-0.0089879166,
-0.2586054504,
-0.4906460047,
-0.4231393337,
1.0437903404,
-0.7687025666,
-1.0339267254,
-0.4362032413,
-0.5113477111,
-0.5960315466,
0.1158189923,
0.2453864217,
0.1861287057,
-0.1766334772,
0.3112550378,
0.5368350744,
-0.1431075186,
0.3326426744,
0.5998061895,
-0.3203125894,
-0.0309495628,
0.4813095033,
0.5985100865,
0.496658504,
0.3431821465,
0.2577184439,
-0.0274918824,
-0.8202770948,
-0.2549640238,
0.210981369,
-0.9118099213,
-0.0015537039,
-0.1915884018,
-0.3146992028,
-0.3023149967,
-0.0226413198,
-0.4509724975,
-0.1866431236,
-0.0138858678,
-0.3595543802,
-0.1291680783,
0.7035952806,
0.1924742907,
0.025916677,
-0.436498791,
0.0742406249,
0.5558515191,
0.4770882726,
0.0381583944,
-0.6272422671,
-0.2473606467,
-0.2517779768,
-0.2596067488,
-0.6531515718,
-0.1860883832,
0.0534028001,
1.0063606501,
0.1864760518,
0.0755138546,
0.4867964387,
-0.5537707806,
0.5742251277,
-0.2175457776,
-0.6931957006,
0.6590743661,
-0.3469849825,
0.6535406113,
0.6919281483,
0.4150512815,
-0.4754862785,
-0.482466042,
-0.371892333,
-0.7094086409,
0.5159383416,
0.0222949274,
0.1854488254,
0.0448918492,
0.2666127086,
0.1537708193,
0.3422915339,
-0.6233205795,
-0.5083025694,
0.3357595205,
0.1581430137,
-0.4667114019,
-0.5602055788,
-0.1774044335,
-0.0392616689,
0.5096731186,
-0.1959117502,
0.0300295316,
-0.0214596465,
-0.2346502841,
-0.452955544,
0.3641127944,
0.5797299147,
0.9994082451,
-0.5237927437,
0.1659989953,
0.1814159751,
-0.2591400146,
-0.0343538821,
0.084733434,
-0.081046775,
-0.1470228732,
0.5287276506,
0.5550525784,
0.4704306126,
-0.6743562818,
0.503452301,
0.1488890797,
0.1470010728,
-0.0359681435,
0.0775790066,
0.0700173974,
0.1081503034,
0.5235790014,
-0.1227578968,
0.0185556877,
-0.7861088514,
0.233352989,
0.3855258226,
-0.3398216367,
-0.2696630657,
0.6167763472,
-0.035248775,
-0.4175891876,
0.3371818364,
0.2338503301,
-0.6510460973,
0.6251155138,
0.3880952001,
0.4447233677,
-0.6311941743,
0.1862795502,
0.1254918873,
0.5271288157,
0.0656551495,
0.2693279982,
0.1321661472,
-0.7034908533,
-0.2318583429,
-0.2871906161,
-0.7762194276,
0.1984947473,
-0.8680388927,
0.183383584,
-0.7014811039,
-0.5051780939,
0.3610124886,
0.0913748294,
-0.5742719173,
0.1314487159,
0.483674407,
0.8885090947,
-0.8965539932,
0.7500513196,
0.7601240873,
-0.2311550081,
-0.4391261339,
0.2798980176,
0.0908727497,
-0.8357166648,
0.6032639742,
0.2479030639,
-0.0425591767,
-0.2615070641,
-0.4780826867,
-0.750420928,
0.820749402,
0.4814229608,
-0.6758018732,
0.1684643328,
0.2571313977,
0.4937390387,
-0.1277040243,
0.426810056,
0.5568909645,
0.4396933913,
-0.1933503449,
-1.2067201138,
0.1784332693,
-0.0908718556,
-0.080650121,
0.2647502422,
-1.2373821735,
1.2756881714,
-0.2115041018,
0.0939464569,
0.0737893134,
0.0463723652,
0.4980482161,
0.1481180489,
0.3894159794,
0.2758101225,
0.7160702944,
-0.0759752169,
1.2547000647,
-0.0457316674,
0.1664734185,
1.2561939955,
-0.6717965007,
1.3008549213,
0.6547298431,
-0.4681622386,
0.3525779843,
0.7005503178,
-0.0634550601,
0.524312377,
0.3966079056,
0.0982143134,
-0.3948826194,
-0.1053469256,
-0.4611816406,
0.510974884,
0.2720329165,
-0.2575275302,
-0.3756260574,
-0.2430199981,
0.0586832128,
0.266438663,
-0.2429024875,
0.547450304,
0.2248982042,
-0.6234053969,
0.7643311024,
-0.0219590738,
0.3666501641,
-0.484136641,
0.1576936841,
-0.3755136728,
0.210101679,
-0.0990860015,
-0.852689147,
-0.0956683606,
0.044760637,
-0.2699235678,
-0.4010618329,
0.4686085284,
-0.0529235415,
-0.3961284161,
0.6967207193,
0.6973798871,
-0.0014214362,
-0.3983384669,
-0.734608829,
0.4638677239,
-0.1621606648,
-0.4006962776,
0.7271925211,
-0.0651687682,
-0.2369113415,
0.6580758691,
0.5044291019,
0.1420894265,
0.0077479044,
0.169433862,
0.8813387752,
-0.6031217575,
-0.3301833272,
-0.8298557997,
0.1477222145,
-0.0440936014,
-0.4169243872,
0.9018746614,
0.5462664366,
0.832426548,
0.334743768,
0.5842409134,
0.4906370044,
0.6402088404,
-0.6162846684,
0.8986004591,
-0.3999678791,
0.5802404881,
-0.206381768,
-1.2184872627,
-0.3264614642,
0.2722695768,
-0.5759925246,
0.2754211724,
0.6532116532,
0.77125597,
0.2508486509,
-0.2816820145,
0.5538399816,
0.4784802198,
0.3652971089,
0.6080265641,
0.9397729635,
-0.2245423943,
0.5057811737,
-0.1959114373,
-0.1205544695,
-0.6301231384,
-0.8374282122,
-0.8497815132,
-0.3344227076,
-0.4281361103,
-0.2655921578,
0.3401782513,
0.6222010851,
0.6510488987,
-0.9666422606,
-0.5408213139,
0.6267315745,
0.2602180243,
-0.1380683184,
-0.1330542266,
0.4214516878,
-0.0782217234,
-0.5422006845,
0.5389441252,
0.0420448631,
-0.1313557178,
-0.1819245219,
0.0897977203,
-0.3808007538,
0.0851220787,
0.3952002227,
0.1054164916,
-0.6132003069,
-0.3651045263,
-0.0980895758,
-0.4896376133,
0.2748494148,
0.6162577868,
-0.6794745326,
0.2961909175,
0.1561110318,
0.7148356438,
0.3178462386,
-0.0041988287,
0.3778598309,
-0.7139098644,
-0.0001685768,
0.1340708286,
0.1531494856,
0.4665519595,
-0.2567825913,
0.3907354176,
0.0641750097,
-0.5477169752,
-1.1072782278,
0.2033522576,
-0.6855509281,
-0.2940561771,
1.1933778524,
0.1024166644,
-0.1274844408,
0.3311955035,
-0.1140906662,
-0.1592455059,
-0.2339636087,
0.8577724695,
1.2526016235,
-0.0433774889,
-0.1712986231,
-0.9160137773,
0.4387710094,
0.6829678416,
-0.5890543461,
0.0951949954,
0.3476598263,
0.2307137251,
0.0393609256,
0.4914967418,
-0.0852587372,
0.3362812996,
-0.0200706348,
-0.35933128,
0.2000101656,
-0.38338691,
-0.4484986067,
0.2652679384,
0.862447381,
-0.0189093836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00861v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00861v2
|
Evaluating Large Language Models for Generalization and Robustness via Data Compression
| 2024-02-01T18:56:18 | 2024-02-04T01:16:25 |
Yucheng Li, Yunhao Guo, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing methods for evaluating large language models face challenges such as
data contamination, sensitivity to prompts, and the high cost of benchmark
creation. To address this, we propose a lossless data compression based
evaluation approach that tests how models' predictive abilities generalize
after their training cutoff. Specifically, we collect comprehensive test data
spanning 83 months from 2017 to 2023 and split the data into training and
testing periods according to models' training data cutoff. We measure: 1) the
compression performance on the testing period as a measure of generalization on
unseen data; and 2) the performance gap between the training and testing period
as a measure of robustness. Our experiments test 14 representative large
language models with various sizes on sources including Wikipedia, news
articles, code, arXiv papers, and multi-modal data. We find that the
compression rate of many models reduces significantly after their cutoff date,
but models such as Mistral and Llama-2 demonstrate a good balance between
performance and robustness. Results also suggest that models struggle to
generalize on news and code data, but work especially well on arXiv papers. We
also find the context size and tokenization implementation have a big impact of
on the overall compression performance.
|
[
-0.4437387586,
-0.7243611813,
0.3689241409,
0.1834986359,
-0.2636993825,
-0.2190095633,
-0.6402655244,
-0.3187406063,
-0.1859639585,
0.1908720285,
-0.4548565745,
-0.3922392726,
-0.6971250772,
0.0661775991,
-0.7528259158,
0.8203480244,
0.0305483863,
-0.093956843,
-0.0691080466,
-0.0323853642,
-0.7112618089,
-0.5392696857,
-0.3416510224,
-0.0107091488,
0.1332494467,
0.0114754308,
0.9669523239,
0.8356022239,
0.4410641193,
0.194617644,
-0.2622050345,
-0.2501672208,
-0.5240523219,
0.0065163239,
-0.0284010526,
-0.2639524639,
-0.1901298463,
-0.0809949264,
0.9114854336,
0.8468847871,
-0.1587636471,
0.2256705463,
0.1984070092,
0.3433527648,
-0.5706680417,
0.1101830602,
-0.8528618813,
-0.0235418268,
0.068912968,
0.0297428835,
-0.5250239968,
-0.2901163101,
-0.0467470363,
-0.2040195465,
0.4920866191,
-0.0622373745,
0.9384196997,
0.2836769819,
-0.3585959375,
-0.1492562443,
-0.8013927341,
0.8849182129,
-0.7997077107,
0.7309108973,
0.4879101515,
0.3163233995,
-0.0444344953,
-0.5440561771,
-0.433975637,
-0.5115113258,
0.2329278737,
-0.2217820436,
-0.5500867963,
-0.0390011631,
0.4935070574,
0.6034470797,
-0.8361267447,
0.0559203178,
-0.2759630382,
-0.2164997756,
0.5793275237,
0.0038235029,
0.40771842,
0.0215268955,
-0.013205084,
-0.3619419038,
-0.6033846736,
-0.0787282661,
0.6258935332,
0.4202296734,
-0.0237371046,
0.5116259456,
-0.1787919402,
0.9420701265,
-0.2756458223,
0.0173350628,
0.0737151504,
-0.3848131895,
-0.239052251,
-0.5526717901,
0.7671797872,
0.3938343525,
0.3203819394,
-0.4405795038,
-0.2853752375,
0.1842238158,
0.1148369014,
-0.9506807327,
-0.089092195,
0.1880563051,
-0.6632294655,
-0.3645433486,
-0.0955925584,
-0.8688249588,
-0.1969724596,
-0.2269168943,
0.3376972973,
-0.2974243164,
-0.1148004085,
0.4325463474,
-0.0419614539,
-0.0437502451,
0.1668794155,
-0.9831483364,
0.2859419882,
0.5762357712,
1.0467883348,
-0.1880762428,
-0.0793200508,
-0.68932271,
-0.1817575097,
-0.3585551977,
0.5775332451,
-0.6690796018,
-0.1744718403,
0.1503912956,
-0.075811334,
-0.0706937686,
-0.536501348,
0.9131550789,
-0.4146058857,
0.0093426434,
0.257174015,
-0.5799718499,
-0.0001154072,
0.420406729,
-0.8287332654,
0.7786146402,
0.2327218354,
-0.7746049762,
0.4002669156,
-0.4217419922,
-0.3076294363,
-0.0800002366,
0.0253572445,
-0.3989365101,
0.2502009571,
0.382824719,
0.5829592347,
-0.4663151503,
0.3915503323,
-0.5473124981,
-0.50389117,
0.0884883702,
-0.6137625575,
0.5449041128,
0.1112501919,
-0.2373237163,
-0.1455428153,
-0.7870489955,
0.1668205857,
0.1955323368,
-0.6027637124,
-0.3868140578,
0.0003024173,
0.230994314,
0.0078159412,
0.013829059,
-0.4017136097,
0.6047779322,
-0.4326375127,
0.5203486681,
0.6716949344,
-0.2477964014,
0.0590133853,
-0.120801039,
0.7577524781,
-0.3519484401,
0.4648328125,
-0.1648629755,
-0.3214077353,
-0.8505503535,
0.0128768831,
0.7702507377,
0.3671794534,
-0.4919842482,
0.6816422343,
-0.7132101655,
-0.5352006555,
-0.0987775996,
-0.0207356215,
0.1294240952,
0.1679933369,
0.2256812602,
-0.4216642678,
-0.4811854959,
-0.9357939959,
-0.2364990413,
-0.1707318276,
-0.4200793505,
0.152054891,
0.5285624266,
-0.4459508061,
0.6785285473,
-0.4644824266,
0.2974092066,
-0.248742789,
0.1478311718,
0.3257365227,
0.5126109123,
0.3162638545,
-0.8107372522,
-0.1654394418,
0.0332847014,
-0.3030740321,
-0.0588086694,
-0.0083606672,
0.3696279228,
-0.0269000344,
0.1601493806,
-0.5022492409,
0.521631062,
0.9957388043,
-0.3088588119,
0.7284362316,
0.0349145047,
0.0820862278,
-0.8351809978,
0.408146739,
-0.1242178828,
-0.2851141095,
-0.702530086,
-0.0559603162,
0.1236679479,
-0.5082697272,
-0.0723360926,
0.4218376279,
-0.3992404044,
-0.2010159194,
-0.1185348481,
-0.2511496842,
-0.1049422473,
0.2460713238,
-0.0806666315,
0.8449745774,
0.4616419375,
-0.7098437548,
0.0330731608,
0.0948746428,
-0.6558923125,
-0.0382047109,
-1.0495729446,
0.3564032316,
-0.0845971778,
0.1016247794,
-0.7763685584,
-0.2649109364,
-0.1214182749,
-0.4008369148,
0.2978497744,
-0.3384912014,
-0.6603505015,
-0.4377850592,
-0.2472817153,
0.4336265624,
0.5040248632,
-0.3789384961,
0.3761823177,
0.1418947279,
-0.0883092061,
-0.5964396,
-0.6772304177,
0.2787007987,
-0.4181286097,
-0.6932830215,
0.1651266664,
-0.6082636714,
-0.0964758471,
-0.0851212591,
-0.0472448952,
-0.2519351542,
0.2435690016,
0.1193396449,
0.2043678164,
-0.009564437,
0.2728643417,
-0.0327933095,
0.2052092999,
-0.1808453798,
-0.2740080655,
0.8809304237,
-0.1484771669,
-0.2020467818,
-0.1216267571,
0.1444115937,
0.5036016107,
-0.2038538158,
0.7879382372,
0.3104044199,
-0.4519532621,
-0.265996933,
-0.6437077522,
0.0582320131,
-0.3871649504,
0.4060036838,
-0.2281661779,
-0.8597645164,
0.5728577375,
-0.0812566653,
-0.0043800757,
0.4522776604,
0.516556859,
0.6792653203,
1.1418806314,
0.7604743242,
-0.1247128472,
0.4117477536,
-0.3186941445,
0.1427432895,
-0.5270966291,
0.0901722014,
-0.6257234216,
0.0716330931,
-0.1727413684,
-0.4728792608,
0.1325024962,
0.338013351,
-0.0643037334,
0.5357339978,
-0.4212363064,
0.6405036449,
0.1747007072,
-0.2016480565,
0.3588674366,
0.0363048129,
0.2248831689,
0.0806405619,
-0.5869146585,
-0.4951682091,
1.4049475193,
0.680318296,
0.6770111918,
0.0654243603,
0.1955913901,
0.5039404631,
0.2491770685,
-0.9202243686,
0.1945224702,
-0.1671647727,
-0.4198227823,
-0.2373282462,
-0.6775271893,
-1.0849485397,
0.1246112213,
-0.0803152025,
-0.6509453654,
0.1976765245,
-0.0443143882,
-0.0814110935,
0.2760878205,
-0.6184307337,
0.7266563773,
-0.0680907518,
-0.0330003761,
-0.0430204608,
-0.4277464151,
0.5934275985,
-0.3516153097,
0.2402944416,
-0.0118672531,
-0.1108508185,
0.8848813772,
-0.2174372971,
0.5093327761,
0.0823578462,
-0.0158711802,
-0.1322015673,
0.1221136153,
0.4362673759,
-0.0388420932,
-0.1748126298,
0.3718104064,
0.1244734824,
-0.4047294259,
-0.7974258661,
0.4206494093,
-0.499648422,
-0.2877538204,
-0.1035326496,
-0.7482907772,
-0.4635724127,
0.2444864511,
0.3619537354,
0.5654263496,
-0.2715339065,
0.3635230958,
0.623450458,
-0.2213166952,
0.2722947299,
0.3764182329,
-0.202315852,
-0.4931667745,
0.6476531625,
0.0193697456,
0.3268640041,
0.1521543711,
0.4230788946,
-0.2433270365,
-1.0017921925,
-0.4695402384,
0.0597346984,
-0.5940309763,
-0.290240407,
-0.453578949,
-0.0168402065,
-0.690166533,
0.2128335983,
-0.379334718,
-0.2627489269,
-0.0077817207,
0.1166371405,
-0.1599138677,
0.9199405313,
0.0389435589,
0.2145738453,
-0.7705565095,
-0.065011926,
0.0817939192,
0.4422712326,
0.1798784584,
-0.6894700527,
-0.3419549465,
-0.0473283269,
-0.1801482737,
-0.7756665945,
0.3996174335,
0.4147827029,
0.4059692323,
0.6758176088,
-0.0560849458,
0.4193950295,
-0.48889184,
0.8195250034,
0.2080306113,
-1.1062532663,
0.6522449851,
-0.4905716181,
0.2279076278,
0.5107563734,
0.3281555176,
-0.5361308455,
-0.1657859534,
-0.6030901074,
-0.6496117115,
0.2037982345,
0.2551805377,
0.4176518023,
0.1499447674,
0.450560987,
0.2185235023,
0.2014698535,
-0.8486673236,
-0.0498691499,
-0.005217358,
-0.0447927862,
-0.2293323427,
-0.40434286,
-0.1395611167,
-0.1567045897,
0.3642526865,
-0.2080156505,
0.0924497619,
-0.0525286272,
0.1100247279,
0.0477180779,
0.4836728573,
0.5364535451,
0.8041606545,
-0.2555569112,
0.0219256766,
0.1668511778,
-0.4702788293,
0.2130015343,
0.1736281216,
-0.1915137768,
0.0568790324,
0.6946271658,
0.8291699886,
0.0086701084,
-0.9377679229,
0.7732374668,
-0.3951803148,
-0.0118588638,
0.0106355324,
-0.0611358769,
-0.1979241967,
0.00226917,
0.1716994941,
-0.1093715876,
0.407823205,
-0.5825863481,
0.0902842432,
0.4164544344,
-0.1283213794,
-0.3704228699,
0.5557123423,
-0.2155876309,
0.0522743352,
0.5526028872,
-0.1092734635,
-0.5667545795,
0.4636478722,
0.5454428196,
0.7894275784,
-0.2625180185,
-0.019283561,
0.3581326604,
0.5279875994,
-0.3958306015,
-0.1354615986,
0.003170348,
-0.4795457423,
-0.6330838203,
-0.6562575102,
-0.2688763738,
0.537945807,
-0.7075616121,
0.3549005985,
-0.2601847649,
-0.2771223485,
-0.2991407514,
0.0502923876,
-0.7945394516,
0.3801933825,
-0.0003444672,
1.2703213692,
-0.9959000349,
0.5791095495,
0.3044388592,
-0.2976251543,
-0.8631786704,
0.3179901838,
-0.3756420314,
-0.6129820347,
0.5717818141,
0.3074062169,
0.2762469947,
-0.281016171,
-0.6789957881,
-0.9181212783,
0.8640925288,
0.8721171618,
-0.7053054571,
-0.0750604197,
0.0088039953,
0.6009889245,
-0.1556104869,
0.1812438071,
0.6281814575,
0.381324321,
0.0357829928,
-1.061701417,
-0.0430190824,
-0.4650750458,
0.2321983278,
0.1293612421,
-0.4323244691,
0.9694041014,
0.1545104533,
-0.4889594316,
0.2110539824,
0.5186744928,
-0.1446045339,
0.0483065471,
0.7556693554,
0.7503020763,
0.8492830992,
0.0692516342,
1.3282314539,
-0.317684263,
0.6317606568,
0.873026967,
0.0485357046,
0.9669075608,
0.2131075859,
-0.3291149437,
0.1789413691,
0.5461855531,
-0.3346779346,
0.3750854433,
0.5974844694,
-0.1014598086,
-0.240564093,
-0.4758065045,
-0.5592817068,
0.3728162348,
-0.087853238,
-0.3559288383,
-0.0980134606,
0.0618492402,
0.0854032114,
-0.0841032565,
-0.2562474608,
0.3387761414,
-0.2805052102,
-0.5855745077,
0.9368994236,
0.1227405593,
0.7355490923,
-0.6948536038,
0.1736020446,
-0.2251384705,
0.0800001398,
0.0136540839,
-0.6006112695,
0.4158049822,
0.1853056699,
-0.1481694877,
0.0352048501,
0.7612277269,
-0.465256691,
-0.6172696352,
0.2853523791,
0.195630759,
0.3315767646,
-0.2659946978,
-0.4424996078,
0.6215435863,
-0.0509655736,
-0.3061368167,
0.3819145262,
-0.0605263636,
0.1229456812,
0.8403655291,
0.6549925804,
0.4035667777,
-0.0842198953,
0.1679935902,
1.1104424,
-0.2251694947,
-0.3248410523,
-0.8188986182,
0.2153320909,
0.0221532043,
-0.3410889208,
0.6681758165,
0.6725490093,
0.6784341931,
-0.0499742739,
0.8598676324,
-0.0683281943,
0.3356200457,
-0.6075987816,
0.7028375864,
-0.5930312276,
0.0564853959,
-0.2249117941,
-0.9561181068,
-0.4700523615,
0.3075634837,
-0.2828172743,
0.1384401172,
0.4760096073,
0.6350568533,
-0.2959325612,
-0.1714953035,
0.5447100401,
-0.0233531632,
0.4590148926,
0.7034311891,
0.7383804917,
-0.6517546177,
0.695037365,
-0.2431791127,
-0.3146767914,
-0.0118322195,
-0.9274357557,
-1.1007376909,
-0.6374866962,
-0.2067458332,
-0.3950974047,
0.0769413486,
0.458017379,
0.8901481032,
-0.7132474184,
-0.0403693914,
-0.1207541004,
-0.2316964418,
-0.0273817442,
-0.2171151489,
0.5670709014,
-0.1076589376,
-0.8177453876,
0.5039088726,
-0.0369840786,
0.1771084666,
-0.4943298399,
-0.0124409227,
0.2774273455,
0.0475847796,
0.4629549086,
0.1211553439,
-0.4435631037,
-0.3960425556,
-0.1287165731,
0.2866646349,
-0.2841334045,
0.8395588398,
-0.4189878702,
0.4847337306,
0.5476405621,
0.8302314281,
0.1624671817,
0.1407993585,
0.6766762733,
-0.6261429787,
0.1837054044,
0.3138990998,
0.372445941,
0.4936731756,
-0.3142218888,
0.741081059,
0.0617878325,
-0.782959342,
-1.1395130157,
0.0852718428,
-0.8259245157,
-0.1645874381,
1.23401618,
-0.3282358944,
0.0297184177,
0.1003846973,
0.026630912,
0.2001827657,
-0.1863568872,
0.8825953007,
1.021826148,
0.2276002467,
-0.028053863,
-0.8199810386,
0.3274906874,
0.3321876526,
-0.8737649918,
0.3817703426,
0.5203213692,
0.3164164424,
0.0744125769,
0.2155190855,
0.0828471482,
0.1200098991,
0.0859402418,
0.0449982472,
-0.0749400109,
-0.3092825413,
-0.854370594,
0.212944597,
0.0809703469,
0.0436208993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00858v1
|
Can Large Language Models Understand Context?
| 2024-02-01T18:55:29 | 2024-02-01T18:55:29 |
Yilun Zhu, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Shruti Bhargava, Jiarui Lu, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Site Li, Yuan Zhang, Hong Yu, Bo-Hsiang Tseng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding context is key to understanding human language, an ability
which Large Language Models (LLMs) have been increasingly seen to demonstrate
to an impressive extent. However, though the evaluation of LLMs encompasses
various domains within the realm of Natural Language Processing, limited
attention has been paid to probing their linguistic capability of understanding
contextual features. This paper introduces a context understanding benchmark by
adapting existing datasets to suit the evaluation of generative models. This
benchmark comprises of four distinct tasks and nine datasets, all featuring
prompts designed to assess the models' ability to understand context. First, we
evaluate the performance of LLMs under the in-context learning pretraining
scenario. Experimental results indicate that pre-trained dense models struggle
with understanding more nuanced contextual features when compared to
state-of-the-art fine-tuned models. Second, as LLM compression holds growing
significance in both research and real-world applications, we assess the
context understanding of quantized models under in-context-learning settings.
We find that 3-bit post-training quantization leads to varying degrees of
performance reduction on our benchmark. We conduct an extensive analysis of
these scenarios to substantiate our experimental results.
|
[
-0.5594245195,
-0.6636529565,
0.7215204835,
0.3007269502,
-0.5079583526,
-0.2341194153,
-0.5995506644,
-0.2840285897,
-0.5466114879,
0.3966226578,
-0.5389503837,
-0.5269237757,
-0.5648202896,
0.2759304345,
-0.425685674,
0.5297475457,
-0.0509729125,
0.1041914672,
-0.5928876996,
-0.2880458534,
-0.7604206204,
-0.6974093914,
-0.5248311758,
-0.2327549458,
0.0900832117,
0.0516150817,
0.3938808739,
0.4688516557,
0.2393842489,
0.3157669306,
-0.3180998862,
-0.1660699695,
-0.5693976879,
-0.0081788227,
-0.1332506239,
-0.3679850399,
-0.2756986618,
-0.1878120154,
0.865241468,
0.8675959706,
-0.1342350692,
0.1267598122,
0.2414152622,
0.499622345,
-0.8876625896,
0.1068033352,
-0.7468473315,
0.0229915883,
0.0370455645,
-0.1895341128,
-0.5484629273,
0.1049347222,
0.2435815483,
-0.6382607818,
0.3088585436,
-0.0524168201,
0.669778645,
0.4272464514,
-0.6967836618,
-0.0809581205,
-0.4751926064,
0.7110222578,
-0.6277322173,
0.5776227117,
0.3981921971,
0.4539491534,
0.0039642882,
-0.6933476329,
-0.5775741339,
0.2094193399,
-0.1361746937,
-0.1117978245,
-0.2078116089,
-0.0985171273,
0.4184747934,
0.5849767327,
-0.6059044003,
0.1612760723,
-0.0244943742,
-0.0322364643,
0.3034410477,
0.0996560007,
0.0015831763,
-0.2287734449,
-0.473501265,
-0.3441427648,
-0.7650581002,
0.0162005369,
-0.1704808623,
0.1449742019,
-0.3977449834,
0.0681087747,
-0.2807610631,
1.1460680962,
-0.298345834,
-0.0058542555,
0.2068496644,
-0.3830331862,
-0.6850392222,
-0.1627110243,
0.5533865094,
0.1635098308,
0.3654673994,
-0.1911399961,
-0.306029588,
-0.2159577161,
0.2341358215,
-0.9818840623,
-0.0092330407,
0.045772329,
-0.4217978418,
0.0711614117,
-0.1383596212,
-0.2699367106,
-0.4203234315,
-0.4721537232,
0.4202028513,
-0.5079875588,
-0.1049216464,
0.4115008116,
0.1021321714,
0.4983366132,
0.3523760736,
-0.858042419,
0.2731383443,
0.9131665826,
0.8970862031,
0.1211373284,
-0.2210269421,
-0.4451887012,
0.0080674309,
-0.2695869803,
0.7658854127,
-0.3592866361,
-0.3280833662,
-0.0408213139,
0.0415681601,
-0.0484419912,
-0.7617530823,
0.5276665688,
-0.7554036975,
-0.1673963666,
-0.3805531859,
-0.5946413875,
-0.2786567509,
0.2437020987,
-0.6581763029,
0.6180440784,
0.3008624911,
-0.5139083862,
0.6369130015,
-0.3196484745,
-0.4189338684,
0.1784365028,
-0.1524821669,
-0.1089723483,
0.551410377,
0.374093771,
0.6748971939,
-0.5345938802,
0.5210238695,
-0.3363577425,
-0.5676865578,
0.4041538835,
-0.5698698163,
0.6317987442,
0.1912979484,
-0.1116517633,
0.1130649373,
-0.6749831438,
-0.0883126631,
-0.0313847885,
-0.3172396719,
-0.3489990532,
-0.0445088856,
0.1289921552,
0.2562221885,
0.0073999083,
-0.1053431928,
0.1414481997,
-0.265021801,
0.6978654265,
0.6884717941,
-0.2938719094,
0.4780685306,
0.0649241805,
0.4224506915,
-0.0552846715,
-0.2020158023,
-0.3390592337,
0.1083396226,
-0.6920117736,
-0.2569963038,
0.3646534085,
0.122404851,
-0.7493835688,
0.5895713568,
-0.7175220251,
0.0040565021,
-0.2565687001,
0.1141719595,
0.4049885571,
0.4292307198,
0.3016839027,
-0.2902915776,
-0.55040133,
-0.8023206592,
-0.3289434016,
0.1570452154,
-0.4868510962,
0.558588028,
0.5644769669,
-0.15330562,
1.0481775999,
-0.3017910123,
0.0425362922,
-0.1159934178,
0.2813789248,
0.2030089647,
0.2853242755,
0.3900663257,
-0.8234841824,
-0.3071697056,
-0.1299715638,
-0.7878509164,
-0.0812198296,
0.0938935056,
0.0512980632,
-0.1203353256,
0.6257873178,
-0.3986699581,
0.3655684292,
0.8300290108,
-0.4504761696,
0.334828645,
-0.2364535183,
0.0940725133,
-1.0019506216,
0.119381085,
0.0294183902,
-0.5279917717,
-0.5695272088,
-0.0154432636,
0.465305537,
-0.1658832878,
-0.5343295336,
0.7302911282,
-0.4529826641,
-0.6678459644,
-0.2451394945,
0.1793023199,
0.1822734028,
0.251032263,
0.3083154559,
1.0420613289,
0.5367934704,
-0.5646303892,
0.0180958584,
0.1861921698,
-1.0914826393,
0.6002824306,
-0.6772845387,
0.1140347496,
-0.1671786457,
0.5164180994,
-0.7255033851,
-0.3719426692,
-0.3107508719,
-0.1700042784,
0.1408966631,
-0.2491574734,
-0.7010545731,
-0.0335433856,
0.1327631921,
0.7340652347,
0.3956320882,
-0.7004662752,
0.403031826,
0.1571096182,
0.158922106,
-0.3403186798,
-0.4507108927,
0.1824117452,
-0.5441832542,
-0.5159956217,
0.5662163496,
-0.1284818798,
-0.345582962,
-0.3203990161,
-0.0351968147,
-0.1751090884,
0.5188860297,
0.1796619296,
-0.1783691049,
-0.2786311805,
0.1858801991,
-0.3046799004,
-0.0352015756,
0.2158541083,
-0.1118566319,
0.7191050649,
-0.3114413917,
0.0071819425,
-0.3433913291,
-0.1194784418,
0.4280244112,
-0.0851971805,
0.8986878395,
0.5854260921,
-0.4348028898,
-0.227162376,
-0.3397113383,
-0.2097140849,
-0.4869380295,
0.3428637981,
-0.704010725,
-1.0967680216,
0.4007898867,
-0.2882878184,
-0.4061618447,
0.2675837576,
0.5339921713,
-0.000519303,
0.7995881438,
0.6320893168,
-0.0572002828,
0.4067954123,
-0.2008356452,
0.1108847558,
-1.1064087152,
0.058988288,
-0.3926440775,
-0.0934488922,
-0.3933275342,
-0.4805238545,
0.3803336322,
0.6652017832,
-0.2511729896,
0.3493472934,
0.0005345599,
0.620315969,
0.1292486787,
0.1038841456,
0.1360220611,
-0.1503437161,
0.2334425449,
0.2702297866,
-0.6272245646,
-0.5129601955,
0.8771206737,
0.3127682805,
0.4214354753,
0.277379632,
0.2381812334,
0.0782011151,
0.5141313672,
-0.6912682652,
0.3428875506,
-0.0589057319,
-0.4245168567,
-0.1842920035,
-0.5251820087,
-0.884422183,
0.5768687129,
-0.1600855142,
-0.8036959767,
0.1203241572,
-0.0129644005,
-0.4836658537,
0.0098997522,
-0.7076860666,
1.1071482897,
-0.1132113412,
-0.2665307522,
-0.1724704802,
-0.4453791678,
0.4943699539,
-0.1407948136,
0.4647136927,
-0.2497167885,
0.0473058149,
0.7065484524,
-0.2341714948,
0.6786255836,
-0.0581300892,
-0.2721202672,
-0.06438642,
-0.0353429541,
0.1243504211,
0.3055887818,
-0.2104722708,
0.3496360481,
-0.0012549426,
-0.4595335424,
-0.7519375682,
0.6589215398,
-0.6306720972,
-0.4428100586,
-0.1108791903,
-0.5791252255,
-0.3918752074,
-0.0271523166,
0.2700841427,
0.7493327856,
-0.2333280295,
0.6258126497,
0.6001698375,
-0.2993597984,
0.5009257197,
0.5780747533,
0.1242870763,
-0.2659573853,
0.4587304592,
-0.4107426107,
0.1740922481,
0.4672411084,
0.2035568058,
-0.379596293,
-0.6180145741,
-0.3729946911,
-0.0642598197,
-0.9692214131,
-0.1361242831,
-0.418099761,
0.0426679552,
-0.4299378693,
-0.1836449951,
-0.0849379152,
0.1671544164,
-0.3488396406,
0.0698007196,
0.1172964051,
0.6593500376,
0.2420317084,
0.6865463257,
-0.7793673873,
0.226674214,
0.3754120469,
0.444318831,
0.1573183686,
-0.792667985,
-0.411055088,
-0.1029314399,
-0.0414562225,
-0.575973928,
0.4608974457,
0.2145127207,
0.2736302316,
0.5422636271,
-0.1328191012,
0.8469288349,
-0.4739679396,
0.7486296296,
-0.1887533069,
-1.2484272718,
0.4666420817,
-0.2750961483,
0.6276851892,
0.6024092436,
0.4653166533,
-0.4302697778,
0.4234835207,
-0.4720036089,
-0.6634058952,
0.622987628,
0.1120145321,
0.0884817839,
-0.0102051813,
0.59258461,
0.0512624271,
0.2358539104,
-0.9303999543,
0.0534994751,
0.1161065325,
-0.0283235572,
-0.6004004478,
-0.4786185622,
-0.0306744017,
-0.2189440131,
0.0772050843,
-0.2747680843,
0.010889153,
-0.1549073905,
-0.6154635549,
0.2701516747,
0.3560914397,
0.6503868103,
0.9959343076,
-0.3139994442,
0.333399564,
0.3909135759,
-0.0768146738,
0.0182928499,
-0.081030637,
0.3253744841,
-0.368035078,
0.8806062341,
1.1213879585,
0.6934170723,
-0.7457835078,
0.7322286963,
-0.5130003691,
-0.0429132767,
-0.1397985816,
0.0107849073,
-0.0277631134,
0.1278360933,
0.2222898155,
-0.2621433437,
0.1941828728,
-0.6346544623,
0.0567515641,
0.4550389051,
-0.3588182032,
-0.4322968125,
0.3847225308,
0.1314887702,
-0.2031941861,
0.588745594,
-0.1077631339,
-0.589931488,
0.5402550697,
0.5959272981,
0.7751837373,
0.058259517,
-0.313786,
0.4141056836,
-0.0646735057,
-0.0812325254,
0.0583438575,
-0.7018277049,
-0.9787142873,
-0.6505336165,
-0.8070304394,
-0.2183127999,
0.4277865589,
-0.8854098916,
0.0734138414,
-0.1722850353,
0.0065162187,
-0.0940623879,
-0.0883763358,
-1.0724601746,
0.4478233159,
0.1484259814,
0.8112274408,
-0.9126251936,
0.995591104,
0.4532939792,
0.1018554568,
-0.4144129753,
0.1572891772,
-0.1819006503,
-0.7987959385,
0.8649564981,
0.5827929974,
0.0298071764,
0.1325187832,
-0.4733994305,
-0.7313927412,
1.1179755926,
0.3770867288,
-0.5970596075,
0.3825681806,
-0.0376658067,
0.4394059181,
-0.3632884324,
0.3963567317,
0.9143052697,
0.2874540985,
-0.1550497115,
-0.750079155,
0.1109447628,
-0.0716010556,
0.2569616437,
0.0150978873,
-0.290228337,
0.9371231794,
0.1908451319,
-0.5219151378,
0.0125648556,
0.5861318111,
0.3304561675,
0.1420789659,
0.7872740626,
0.6160458922,
0.5362308025,
-0.1913456768,
1.3623367548,
-0.4450105429,
0.3863639832,
1.0961288214,
-0.2570202351,
1.0168548822,
0.3759897947,
-0.2407603562,
0.4636334181,
0.8008592129,
0.4577459097,
0.6076515317,
0.4541657865,
-0.4981357455,
-0.4723459482,
-0.0607835725,
-0.2655556798,
0.6388520002,
0.4845764339,
-0.1639368981,
-0.1133552194,
0.1440626532,
-0.3388702869,
0.0042439662,
-0.1766493022,
0.8887257576,
0.1546746045,
-0.6086659431,
0.8366909623,
0.0187904891,
0.5859295726,
-0.3882936239,
0.1360856444,
-0.1980824769,
0.0448626764,
0.0916791931,
-0.6752166152,
0.1748372614,
0.0205380153,
-0.2608415484,
-0.3732673526,
0.3847860396,
-0.1542190462,
-0.1444818825,
0.2439365089,
0.2883951366,
0.1317334622,
-0.446672231,
-0.3592443764,
0.5460799336,
-0.3436051309,
-0.2220084816,
0.4466269016,
0.636166513,
0.0440288708,
0.5076639652,
0.4629746974,
-0.1668599099,
-0.3242399395,
0.3180267215,
0.7085380554,
-0.7065621018,
-0.4038208425,
-1.0115916729,
0.1812507957,
-0.0088560786,
-0.3744552135,
0.6201537251,
0.3841741085,
1.0742024183,
-0.017761603,
0.5947072506,
0.2112845629,
0.0040394738,
-0.8431319594,
0.5681787729,
-0.6062927246,
0.3089112639,
-0.0066232421,
-0.8638735414,
-0.2512171268,
0.7921600342,
-0.5351550579,
0.1621354669,
0.553819716,
0.4655350745,
-0.142866686,
-0.0232134741,
0.525606513,
0.1525413394,
0.2184162438,
0.6864151359,
1.0054129362,
-0.4510629773,
0.0727312937,
-0.2458281517,
-0.195200175,
-0.1469238251,
-1.1752238274,
-0.9295447469,
-0.6256474257,
0.0267167836,
-0.0738365576,
-0.1018735394,
0.5453316569,
1.1425429583,
-0.6385915875,
-0.2234580517,
-0.285220325,
-0.0278816633,
0.0158652905,
-0.2107133716,
0.4669565856,
-0.2537415624,
-0.5954912901,
0.7122046351,
0.1950115412,
-0.0959809646,
-0.2028002292,
-0.0882840678,
0.1455894858,
-0.2393555939,
0.8932248354,
-0.0454337373,
-0.8281486034,
-0.3194845021,
-0.3810781538,
0.0437533669,
0.0541412719,
1.0713948011,
-1.0631920099,
0.3991493881,
0.441369921,
0.6754222512,
0.6595180035,
0.1482195109,
0.6333507895,
-0.9220944047,
0.2846415341,
-0.06696143,
0.5620788336,
0.5423664451,
-0.2112150043,
0.4382546246,
-0.0531598553,
-0.4442312717,
-0.7828617096,
0.1868492663,
-0.6800819635,
-0.5370906591,
1.0481208563,
-0.2387095094,
-0.2550586462,
0.1326792836,
0.1607126892,
0.2038276792,
0.1511544287,
0.5776098967,
0.7089903951,
0.158604905,
-0.2986024618,
-0.8134807348,
0.501106143,
0.5180148482,
-0.8587148786,
0.3292029798,
0.4086036682,
0.2241736501,
-0.352029264,
0.5409187675,
0.2489490509,
0.1089572087,
-0.2479466498,
-0.1174113378,
0.2608460188,
-0.3047557771,
-0.9352360368,
0.0417210273,
0.1514940262,
0.1283468008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00856v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00856v4
|
Towards Efficient Exact Optimization of Language Model Alignment
| 2024-02-01T18:51:54 | 2024-06-05T08:15:12 |
Haozhe Ji, Cheng Lu, Yilin Niu, Pei Ke, Hongning Wang, Jun Zhu, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The alignment of language models with human preferences is vital for their
application in real-world tasks. The problem is formulated as optimizing the
model's policy to maximize the expected reward that reflects human preferences
with minimal deviation from the initial policy. While considered as a
straightforward solution, reinforcement learning (RL) suffers from high
variance in policy updates, which impedes efficient policy improvement.
Recently, direct preference optimization (DPO) was proposed to directly
optimize the policy from preference data. However, we show that DPO derived
based on the optimal solution of the problem leads to a compromised
mean-seeking approximation of the optimal solution in practice. In this paper,
we propose efficient exact optimization (EXO) of the alignment objective. EXO
is guaranteed to optimize in the same direction as RL algorithms asymptotically
for arbitrary policy parametrization. This leads to the same mode-seeking
solution, while enables efficient optimization by circumventing the
complexities of RL. We also compare our method to DPO with both theoretical and
empirical analyses, and further demonstrate the advantages of our method over
existing approaches on realistic human preference data. Code is available at
https://github.com/haozheji/exact-optimization.
|
[
-0.077409789,
-0.546023488,
0.5394578576,
0.0485378131,
-0.2205419987,
0.052746471,
-0.5756071806,
-0.0861983821,
-0.0131647354,
0.5049692988,
-0.7515227795,
-0.2879700065,
-0.2997840941,
-0.1870827377,
0.2042158693,
0.687900722,
-0.3052116036,
-0.2315115929,
0.117301546,
-0.0288232975,
-0.1283813715,
-0.1449835449,
-0.6321703792,
-0.223013401,
0.3968708217,
0.5011984706,
0.7607949972,
1.2286155224,
0.2612263262,
0.2856230438,
-0.0897010043,
0.5337010622,
-0.5437522531,
0.2084841132,
-0.0818749219,
-0.1251572818,
-0.2689078748,
0.161597386,
0.7071553469,
0.4497171044,
-0.3747065961,
-0.1496119648,
0.1122710109,
0.949732244,
-0.6835445762,
0.0352796726,
-0.5277346969,
0.2111721784,
0.1194197237,
-0.2053856552,
-0.2716178894,
-0.5434904099,
0.2896266878,
-0.9970251322,
-0.272844404,
0.3330999911,
1.1921073198,
0.3718165159,
-0.3523653746,
-0.1727272719,
-0.709374845,
1.0287507772,
-0.5384389162,
0.3794852793,
0.3000768125,
0.2865701914,
-0.3986997604,
0.0476638451,
-0.5916534066,
-0.2899571955,
0.1303922236,
-0.023784427,
-0.210695222,
0.4831500947,
0.1473809481,
0.1230344921,
-0.7309316993,
0.2536844015,
0.0928087682,
-0.0559779294,
0.6332740188,
-0.0681327283,
0.2395611107,
0.0625714734,
-0.3987639844,
-0.3972619474,
-0.4530331194,
0.3041717112,
0.8051624298,
0.3999220431,
-0.0536412746,
0.3396144509,
-0.2303732634,
0.910338521,
0.2130752653,
0.007994472,
0.2947651446,
-0.236291796,
-0.0161439776,
-0.0219309088,
0.789264977,
0.1740130931,
0.3271232247,
-0.2095883191,
-0.2211185545,
-0.1964248866,
0.5135988593,
-0.3288493454,
0.1937655509,
0.1957775652,
-0.1049838215,
-0.5789653659,
-0.0369953029,
-0.8002365828,
0.003012686,
-0.6051091552,
0.2934193015,
-0.2247003317,
-0.146420449,
0.2190195024,
0.1780465841,
0.3484184444,
0.1621388346,
-1.0779331923,
0.268961668,
1.0671006441,
0.6316188574,
-0.2889975905,
-0.1087547317,
-0.7411285043,
0.2584180832,
-0.4731560946,
0.3410317004,
-0.5933991671,
-0.2150946856,
0.057109043,
-0.4089993834,
-0.1378601342,
-0.3813096881,
0.8791826963,
-0.547414124,
0.1818406731,
-0.2241480649,
-0.4776276648,
-0.1336900294,
0.3535106182,
-0.6103874445,
0.9081190825,
-0.0983350798,
-0.2268253714,
0.3620663285,
-0.6770936251,
-0.2188683152,
-0.3828861117,
-0.2866659164,
-0.5394461155,
0.109113805,
0.0957000852,
0.0173172168,
-0.2297703177,
0.5947857499,
-0.2536097765,
-0.2969544828,
0.2233484983,
-0.3685139716,
0.5714012384,
0.2576323748,
-0.5266937017,
0.4784229398,
-0.6205221415,
0.137625441,
0.2214580625,
-0.3607544303,
-0.6298799515,
0.3119227588,
-0.2614365816,
0.0884654224,
0.4428914785,
-0.6603534818,
0.5249409676,
-0.704787612,
0.1602885723,
1.2054613829,
-0.4099330902,
0.7791500688,
-0.167179063,
0.559138,
-0.3114832342,
0.4610445499,
0.4755339026,
0.0528527871,
-0.4669551551,
-0.3417966664,
0.3278522193,
0.2758374214,
-0.2734271288,
0.7625760436,
-0.3923372924,
-0.0696310177,
-0.7576195598,
0.0475304164,
0.7702487111,
0.5579723716,
0.2349784672,
0.0794610307,
-0.5633245707,
-1.0052095652,
-0.4463019073,
-0.1473046988,
0.2892259657,
0.5192972422,
-0.0319984294,
-0.1036393568,
0.9994459152,
-0.743247509,
-0.072986044,
-0.1401658654,
-0.285094887,
0.3097816408,
0.5742405057,
0.3239975274,
-1.0584620237,
-0.8391367197,
0.2383693308,
-0.3806845248,
-0.1744665802,
0.0579580069,
-0.5999287963,
0.3599344492,
0.0809021816,
-0.2571358085,
-0.0478532761,
0.5919799805,
-0.1864056885,
0.3886449635,
-0.2969439924,
0.1154627725,
-0.7264126539,
0.3295548856,
-0.0105168186,
-0.4038650095,
-0.6949923635,
0.223117888,
0.1853530705,
-0.2066878527,
-0.0704746991,
0.695962131,
-0.3434630334,
0.2324299663,
-0.2053049505,
0.1035272479,
0.0026019935,
0.8126824498,
0.2038881332,
0.4680452347,
0.4400634766,
-0.4285190701,
0.1320806891,
0.1129533574,
-0.0930609405,
0.1828308553,
-0.3680607677,
0.2695875168,
-0.1258706301,
-0.0368285552,
-0.7647471428,
-0.0234289579,
0.7089229822,
-0.1926679611,
0.6191538572,
-0.0725677535,
-0.0167694036,
-0.1681757718,
-0.5335121751,
0.2404265106,
0.5439511538,
-0.684691608,
0.3990665376,
0.3924123645,
0.213637799,
-1.1075334549,
0.0231344495,
-0.3297234774,
-0.2527345419,
-0.2169626057,
0.5803063512,
0.0739331171,
-0.2129472643,
-0.0602803454,
-0.5740110874,
0.0164124947,
0.1299908459,
-0.0700413361,
0.3659930229,
0.0682177767,
-0.1590023935,
0.2618690729,
-0.341730088,
-0.2995901704,
-0.2098242342,
0.671500504,
0.0595559999,
-0.2629185617,
-0.4710806906,
0.361654073,
0.2247732878,
-0.0072051901,
0.2680054903,
0.0594626181,
-0.0511590205,
-0.2856020331,
-0.4822415709,
0.0076872031,
-0.5405648351,
0.5040644407,
-0.4342711866,
-0.4895780683,
-0.0236517675,
0.1224009097,
0.350174278,
0.082145296,
0.0534588397,
0.0671671405,
1.3172687292,
0.5501461029,
-0.2466660142,
0.7058905959,
0.044367671,
0.1385039687,
-0.7260645628,
-0.1219086722,
-0.547678411,
-0.3280855417,
-0.397133559,
-0.3012951016,
0.0484215617,
0.0464599542,
-0.3649606705,
0.4588532448,
-0.6986740828,
0.3736786544,
0.6494367719,
0.2662341595,
0.2368973047,
0.211523205,
-0.2075599432,
-0.2353069633,
-0.5706762075,
-0.4238551557,
0.9521923065,
0.2258117795,
0.6096661687,
0.1396200806,
0.8139369488,
0.1698565036,
-0.3466216326,
-0.7886632681,
0.3975150287,
-0.1309005171,
-0.2749584913,
-0.5424929857,
-0.6421118975,
-0.9381776452,
0.3343158066,
-0.0763067007,
-0.5311329961,
0.155268833,
0.5018966198,
-0.3046985269,
-0.0036658752,
-0.3600118756,
1.0979019403,
-0.5657347441,
-0.3164774477,
-0.3618298471,
-0.7293128371,
-0.0723071322,
-0.0167431682,
0.0571524948,
-0.2579363883,
-0.3052995503,
0.6155517697,
-0.3654380739,
0.31518507,
-0.3735817969,
-0.0178728905,
-0.057304088,
-0.0025947317,
0.7494003177,
-0.4338619113,
-0.209809646,
-0.2604158819,
-0.142453447,
-0.4652160406,
-0.799394846,
0.6919391155,
-0.9872591496,
-0.6917871833,
-0.4008517563,
-0.5049775243,
-0.2724473774,
0.1380450875,
-0.1359754801,
0.4057228267,
-0.3734550476,
-0.1738926172,
0.6772547364,
-0.2300972342,
0.305036068,
0.6891287565,
-0.2714325488,
-0.1084033996,
1.0906019211,
-0.1616471708,
0.4383554161,
0.7563592792,
0.6027995944,
-0.3089363277,
-0.4537630081,
-0.6814968586,
0.2784861624,
-0.2502944171,
0.0083656609,
-0.505833149,
0.1722726524,
-0.3528027236,
-0.4030317068,
-0.5780215859,
-0.2647229731,
-0.1978008747,
0.1361450106,
0.1128254086,
0.0029984913,
-0.1437583566,
0.1112881526,
-0.352345109,
0.1317640841,
0.2192050368,
0.3194032013,
-0.1526738703,
-0.5347310305,
-0.0048800083,
0.3593929708,
-0.2915130556,
-0.6626272202,
0.4680226445,
0.3625196218,
0.6444339156,
0.6751518846,
0.1874059141,
0.787057817,
-0.4348198473,
0.1433690488,
0.0665970892,
-0.8730880022,
0.5716294646,
-0.316247046,
0.0149930166,
0.8851149082,
0.6134382486,
-0.6027971506,
0.0767425597,
-0.3913653195,
-0.8545730114,
0.8900803924,
-0.0467098765,
0.1279769391,
0.0814817175,
0.4261360765,
0.179385677,
0.1358989626,
-0.486356467,
-0.2671787739,
0.189753741,
-0.43464607,
0.1047270596,
-0.0968447328,
-0.2321774662,
-0.0977571681,
1.00149858,
-0.2431661934,
0.15673244,
-0.1280974746,
-0.0165122431,
-0.2725540102,
0.1292534173,
0.6405857205,
0.3119387329,
-0.3879669011,
-0.1373792887,
-0.2498906553,
-0.1549491882,
0.4083141983,
-0.0501204468,
-0.2622181475,
-0.1934742033,
-0.3108105063,
1.0021842718,
0.375492841,
-1.0896940231,
0.7679852247,
0.0650086477,
-0.0280020647,
-0.2523701191,
0.268399477,
-0.2963329852,
0.1310828924,
0.2136124372,
-0.0324661992,
0.1325057894,
-0.4439109266,
0.0627503172,
0.6725416183,
-0.8129403591,
-0.136292845,
0.4675900042,
0.1381949484,
-0.4446991384,
0.4629486799,
-0.1482064128,
-0.5082680583,
0.5708371997,
0.6604979634,
0.8609070182,
-0.1098574996,
0.2747540176,
0.2683101296,
-0.0987801775,
-0.246508643,
0.0472407527,
-0.2221544534,
-0.97128582,
-0.4212735593,
-0.6365023255,
-0.5449187756,
-0.3928203881,
-0.7756239772,
0.4483694136,
-0.4335173368,
0.2810381353,
-0.3189863563,
0.0650818124,
-0.3008609712,
-0.0183198676,
0.0620565973,
0.5490547419,
-0.6907749176,
0.9878988862,
0.5085574389,
-0.1446615756,
-0.9665228724,
-0.1472251564,
0.0489193872,
-1.0891680717,
0.4188054502,
-0.0112038283,
-0.0779279619,
0.1546937674,
-0.3386280537,
-0.9769778848,
0.7085618377,
0.3589118719,
-0.866068244,
-0.3455065191,
-0.1812147051,
0.3577728868,
-0.3743570745,
0.0436408333,
0.6136330366,
0.4657259583,
0.069071129,
-0.7728508115,
0.2177993059,
-0.1297115237,
-0.0561439395,
0.6561316252,
-0.5670139194,
0.1364160031,
0.0118965544,
-0.1191629618,
-0.0635475665,
0.4126400054,
0.3501870334,
-0.0708634928,
0.6014664769,
0.5696141124,
0.6300469041,
0.0417467244,
1.0287805796,
-0.160669595,
0.4666314721,
0.9394677877,
-0.2423534095,
0.6497428417,
0.5889546275,
-0.1957621574,
0.1751368195,
0.6543242335,
0.2101462632,
0.8737979531,
0.251593411,
-0.1510234624,
-0.1121469364,
-0.0134472745,
-0.0818242431,
0.422359705,
-0.0316742994,
-0.2889480293,
-0.0054503414,
-0.2091318667,
0.3074152172,
0.4492710829,
-0.2347023934,
0.9412255287,
-0.263390094,
-1.0044084787,
0.6665528417,
-0.0124570308,
0.7700268626,
-0.6958268285,
0.1746015847,
-0.0432720929,
0.1660635024,
0.0218234863,
-0.3017831147,
0.3044919372,
-0.1992304474,
-0.1848423481,
-0.328432709,
0.3468361497,
-0.7318707108,
0.0432702117,
0.3171633184,
0.1025967598,
-0.020942118,
-0.0955399349,
-0.8403873444,
0.1269221753,
0.5074949861,
-0.3568572998,
0.5648144484,
-0.1154066324,
0.0725142211,
0.5595525503,
0.3797655106,
0.2358587682,
-0.1213065907,
-0.3205252588,
0.5805854201,
-0.539516151,
-0.5387870669,
-1.0373035669,
0.216249153,
-0.262467593,
-0.3891166747,
0.3646274209,
0.702773571,
0.7457051277,
0.0208521821,
0.6895855069,
-0.0809452534,
0.3883360624,
-0.4200841486,
0.4239351153,
-0.7119695544,
0.0527567938,
-0.3809509277,
-1.2233210802,
-0.247607559,
0.7469258308,
-0.4552057683,
-0.3292249441,
0.5182839036,
0.9573230743,
-0.174427703,
-0.0859802589,
0.3144443631,
-0.2694186866,
0.1872338504,
0.6229135394,
0.5223847032,
-0.1269565076,
0.427983284,
-0.4364598691,
-0.3644992709,
-0.1915862858,
-0.8255152106,
-0.2522875667,
-0.5101108551,
-0.4851560593,
-0.287813127,
0.477406621,
1.618098855,
0.4540400207,
-0.5701107383,
-0.3405703008,
-0.1942485124,
0.2095342577,
-0.4420748949,
-0.2199359983,
0.5154471993,
-0.3672019839,
-1.0443345308,
0.4213470817,
0.3357173204,
-0.167872414,
-0.004371732,
-0.4891185462,
-0.3161992431,
0.0127622848,
0.1506579965,
0.7778686285,
-0.7063626647,
-0.4741608799,
0.0464820936,
-0.4228940308,
0.2009861618,
0.7819873691,
-0.3726810515,
0.647031188,
0.5205457807,
0.7961794734,
0.490878135,
0.3133401871,
0.9312834144,
-0.512832284,
0.0552624464,
0.3363924623,
0.0498904623,
0.106380634,
-0.2095289379,
0.498401463,
-0.0724459067,
-0.640796423,
-0.8790139556,
0.3050433397,
-1.1006076336,
-0.2093866765,
1.2472599745,
-0.2235776931,
-0.3906908035,
-0.0121566691,
-0.363563925,
0.3552618623,
-0.8059956431,
0.7474945784,
0.1760758311,
-0.2062841952,
0.1056606695,
-0.2843677402,
0.7092857957,
0.6781734824,
-0.3668062985,
0.1295957565,
0.3664808869,
0.1419383734,
-0.2057852596,
0.5801690221,
-0.0952496231,
0.1039240807,
-0.3969717324,
0.272239387,
-0.115741916,
-0.1658340842,
-0.5152432919,
-0.0057460978,
0.2226565629,
-0.38084656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00841v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00841v2
|
Tiny Titans: Can Smaller Large Language Models Punch Above Their Weight in the Real World for Meeting Summarization?
| 2024-02-01T18:31:34 | 2024-04-15T17:56:58 |
Xue-Yong Fu, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Elena Khasanova, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities to
solve a wide range of tasks without being explicitly fine-tuned on
task-specific datasets. However, deploying LLMs in the real world is not
trivial, as it requires substantial computing resources. In this paper, we
investigate whether smaller, compact LLMs are a good alternative to the
comparatively Larger LLMs2 to address significant costs associated with
utilizing LLMs in the real world. In this regard, we study the meeting
summarization task in a real-world industrial environment and conduct extensive
experiments by comparing the performance of fine-tuned compact LLMs (e.g.,
FLAN-T5, TinyLLaMA, LiteLLaMA) with zero-shot larger LLMs (e.g., LLaMA-2,
GPT-3.5, PaLM-2). We observe that most smaller LLMs, even after fine-tuning,
fail to outperform larger zero-shot LLMs in meeting summarization datasets.
However, a notable exception is FLAN-T5 (780M parameters), which performs on
par or even better than many zero-shot Larger LLMs (from 7B to above 70B
parameters), while being significantly smaller. This makes compact LLMs like
FLAN-T5 a suitable cost-efficient solution for real-world industrial
deployment.
|
[
-0.4359024763,
-0.5995089412,
0.759278059,
0.0542252846,
-0.4209439754,
0.015556437,
-0.5599556565,
-0.8872203231,
0.3224857748,
0.2622411549,
-0.3699763417,
-0.264267087,
-0.529191792,
0.2544097304,
-0.3021826148,
0.6439483762,
0.0915732458,
-0.3259097338,
0.105268158,
-0.2626496553,
-0.4650657773,
-0.4201769829,
-0.7454368472,
-0.3755610585,
0.8422441483,
0.6311203241,
0.9185622931,
0.7658522129,
0.6778080463,
0.2671248317,
-0.5016447306,
0.3355097175,
-0.5278356075,
-0.3308619261,
-0.0131238252,
-0.699935317,
-0.7124076486,
0.0463696159,
0.6977753043,
0.9942964911,
-0.1003990024,
0.3552569747,
-0.0619550906,
0.6121854186,
-0.4381479621,
0.0312784463,
-0.470877111,
0.1622747779,
-0.2300878763,
0.2661710382,
-0.2945341468,
-0.2756047547,
-0.307407558,
-0.2698372304,
0.1391335875,
0.5245770812,
0.9132890701,
0.1350100189,
-0.2596291602,
-0.1454679966,
-0.7756965756,
0.8375325799,
-1.0584548712,
0.15422979,
-0.0726507455,
0.5774097443,
-0.1943150759,
-0.8367734551,
-0.6370610595,
-0.1164358407,
-0.175347507,
0.0556978211,
-0.1708742976,
0.1431698203,
0.2440325618,
0.5704084635,
-0.5009457469,
0.6703234315,
-0.449442625,
0.227810815,
0.5027557611,
0.5885419846,
0.1199696139,
-0.0427693725,
0.0983649939,
0.0049406928,
-0.9229712486,
-0.3416437507,
-0.048330579,
0.7737079263,
-0.3904156983,
0.5534273982,
-0.1562551409,
0.5983531475,
-0.0382102206,
-0.4584946334,
-0.3110473752,
-0.4826071858,
-0.5271351933,
-0.0669761673,
0.7322747707,
0.4916994274,
0.2915081084,
-0.2076573819,
-0.3735714853,
-0.0886906832,
0.0025144015,
-1.0979555845,
-0.2103004009,
0.2717720568,
-0.5530855656,
-0.3157286644,
-0.2866390049,
-0.3705225587,
-0.3677880466,
-0.3218494356,
0.5024209023,
0.0448890291,
-0.0210855361,
-0.1143604442,
-0.0432899669,
0.184242174,
0.5661649704,
-0.909363389,
0.353262037,
0.8172806501,
1.4947966337,
0.1302483678,
-0.0607901141,
-0.6173760891,
0.1285529435,
-0.5670660734,
0.8317613006,
-0.0060521499,
-0.7101418972,
-0.217444405,
-0.2289306074,
-0.0913718939,
-1.020834446,
0.3677475154,
-0.1944107115,
-0.0030169701,
-0.5157243609,
-0.3476166129,
0.1452148706,
0.2421031296,
-0.5033382177,
0.4906619787,
0.03005125,
-0.5539290905,
0.4789405763,
-0.3862155974,
-0.5694552064,
0.131766066,
-0.4671041965,
-0.5085220337,
0.2924751639,
0.0505014621,
0.5740893483,
-0.5104191899,
-0.1839020699,
-0.4151106477,
-0.6915440559,
0.1486659795,
-0.063062422,
0.4056556821,
0.3075264394,
-0.1513896734,
0.1467391998,
-0.2898949087,
-0.1364605278,
0.0412396975,
-0.3649884462,
-0.0444905385,
0.0384492576,
0.013431659,
0.2039272934,
0.1239760593,
-0.453902483,
0.1843455583,
-0.6928234696,
0.3135447502,
0.4820652604,
0.0768233016,
0.3916733265,
-0.7118876576,
0.5540954471,
-0.2790328264,
0.0391092449,
0.1146518663,
-0.2999682128,
-0.8873806596,
-0.6454235315,
0.3537242413,
0.2395298928,
-0.6631658077,
0.097474806,
-0.6872475743,
-0.7141524553,
-0.2325767577,
0.0667032376,
0.3690035939,
0.2587804198,
-0.0465965196,
0.1293509603,
-0.5475043654,
-0.9412442446,
-0.4116526246,
-0.0743517578,
-0.4473399222,
0.300534606,
0.5364002585,
0.1112794504,
0.8803436756,
-0.6097016931,
-0.7439795732,
-0.8379867673,
0.0720546469,
0.4770775437,
0.1267291158,
0.780557394,
-0.4933276176,
-0.6653832197,
0.2278549224,
-0.689157486,
-0.0552980565,
0.0433622748,
0.5724343657,
0.3747808635,
0.4027433097,
-0.5453922153,
0.0854834989,
0.5495200157,
-0.0753636062,
0.5250840187,
-0.4009133875,
-0.1231574863,
-1.0914064646,
0.1025428548,
-0.0851634666,
-0.5677984953,
-0.4953752458,
0.0713408515,
-0.0206832122,
-0.2388475984,
-0.5900407434,
0.5888822079,
-0.5913490057,
-0.4125533402,
-0.5828036666,
0.5850245357,
-0.0339565091,
0.3892080784,
-0.0811707973,
1.1155019999,
0.1341834813,
-0.8496749401,
0.0844504088,
0.1819653064,
-0.4997423589,
0.3067878485,
-0.9049597383,
-0.1709451824,
-0.1170584261,
0.3998643756,
-0.6833951473,
-0.4634147882,
-0.1691447198,
-0.1592770368,
0.2094316483,
-0.0914398208,
-0.8964306712,
-0.1541189253,
-0.6679604053,
0.1638453305,
0.789390862,
-0.6380437016,
0.3854301274,
0.416151911,
-0.3605311215,
-0.0622090399,
-1.1160075665,
0.3583401442,
-0.3712356985,
-0.4778569937,
0.1252608448,
0.1173998937,
-0.4627327323,
-0.2811429501,
-0.2199344337,
0.4053556919,
-0.0710288882,
0.2146502882,
0.0228892062,
-0.2976943851,
-0.0224883985,
-0.12102402,
-0.1857349873,
-0.3122514486,
-0.0628544763,
0.3534104228,
-0.3797390163,
0.001645627,
-0.4077506065,
0.1563374698,
0.5609477162,
0.1995744854,
1.0427783728,
0.2721257806,
-0.4538352191,
-0.2344810069,
-0.4895991683,
-0.1901168376,
-0.5490755439,
0.2874149382,
-0.3646140099,
-0.8267809153,
0.6686629653,
-0.1692180932,
0.4700935781,
0.4547646344,
0.613981843,
-0.3671988547,
0.7725595236,
0.779489696,
-0.0470404327,
0.2666736245,
-0.2145899087,
0.4447256625,
-0.7908269763,
0.1520257443,
-0.6624176502,
-0.6294767857,
-0.5153411031,
-0.4712816477,
0.732435286,
-0.0241142176,
-0.0032144121,
0.5004407763,
-0.0793379769,
0.6532921791,
0.2121826708,
-0.3404251337,
0.46882388,
-0.2442907393,
0.1102979034,
0.0025336039,
-1.0963741541,
-0.7223268747,
0.565764308,
0.3130289018,
0.8429995775,
0.5937384963,
0.5174053311,
0.196805954,
0.4197866917,
-0.8560332656,
0.7542304397,
-0.4956864715,
-0.3520202935,
-0.3534210324,
-0.5827805996,
-0.8814026713,
0.7602944374,
-0.0812051818,
-0.8165469766,
0.2256921977,
0.2736623883,
-0.6157564521,
0.6096607447,
-0.7894979715,
0.7814320326,
0.0435957164,
-0.0338148996,
-0.1896549314,
-0.3811655939,
0.4051173329,
-0.2020639926,
0.6432593465,
-0.2391546071,
-0.266682297,
0.7860906124,
-0.6474097371,
1.0013754368,
0.0653231367,
-0.2982658148,
0.1299987733,
0.1599476039,
0.6382633448,
0.0086130556,
-0.1668335646,
-0.0194356404,
0.2061376721,
-0.2448560894,
-0.5576754212,
0.9258010387,
-0.5495314598,
-0.3357046545,
-0.3337524533,
-0.5276033878,
-0.1542621106,
0.1743691117,
0.4353434145,
0.7222283483,
0.1220443249,
0.4316303134,
0.4065487087,
-0.0489405282,
0.8471834064,
0.5309138298,
-0.4019775093,
-0.2217608094,
0.986661315,
0.5997302532,
0.4581337869,
0.4217320681,
0.2676795423,
-0.0974228978,
-0.8169079423,
-0.4529326856,
0.4395883083,
-0.5846568346,
-0.2938585281,
-0.5421431065,
0.1259179562,
-0.2050805539,
-0.3566376865,
-0.586150527,
-0.7912350297,
-0.0571452044,
-0.0834424496,
0.1132673696,
0.54838866,
0.0340959765,
0.6863882542,
-0.8735323548,
0.3187972307,
0.1187422052,
0.4505729675,
0.0399963446,
-0.7876949906,
-0.625180006,
-0.0361826271,
-0.0906927884,
-0.3937691748,
0.3811825812,
0.327151686,
0.158276245,
0.3188067079,
0.1488436908,
0.8164619207,
-0.3243527114,
0.8789340854,
-0.0028983147,
-0.6138699055,
0.2131119519,
-0.5488646626,
0.772315979,
0.5887107849,
-0.1396360397,
-0.5798144937,
-0.5724591613,
-0.6433452964,
-0.7994137406,
0.9327636957,
0.3677230179,
-0.0486764014,
0.1579231173,
0.5590053797,
-0.1185194701,
0.3466789722,
-0.6629993916,
-0.2496079206,
0.6254824996,
-0.1090586931,
-0.2425204366,
-0.3137260079,
-0.133234188,
0.1769634485,
0.6846832633,
-0.0879937336,
0.1240992025,
-0.1132664382,
-0.0312345512,
-0.1839523613,
0.2471702397,
0.8041093946,
0.6192568541,
-0.3807474077,
0.212817505,
0.6272242665,
-0.2974673808,
-0.1826510131,
-0.3984366357,
-0.1099343449,
0.0803638622,
0.703078866,
0.5725448728,
0.3188088238,
-0.9474521279,
0.4948235154,
-0.1606846303,
-0.1762128174,
-0.3367934525,
0.1603825837,
0.1683301926,
0.2935507298,
0.0898868218,
-0.2221587896,
0.0173297506,
-0.7742589116,
-0.228958711,
0.3570762873,
-0.1670963913,
-0.2609433234,
0.7008609772,
0.2983892858,
-0.3343864977,
0.2179161161,
-0.1027285382,
-0.1554362774,
0.6125540137,
0.3258776069,
0.6708378196,
0.2818913162,
-0.273973763,
0.2008598149,
0.7572885752,
-0.0840993151,
0.1529174,
0.059611775,
-0.3588013649,
-0.5468806624,
-0.5183780193,
-0.8208205104,
0.014293991,
-0.3186389506,
0.1683747023,
-0.6305937171,
-0.1264169216,
-0.0081516597,
0.2233227789,
-0.3130781651,
0.295478195,
0.161021769,
0.882706821,
-0.5919209719,
0.6467940807,
0.6798301935,
-0.3923876286,
-0.789405942,
-0.0989311337,
0.057340052,
-0.2654475868,
0.2340717763,
0.1643863916,
-0.2793565989,
-0.3932181299,
-0.1726775169,
-0.6487736702,
1.2979559898,
0.4633069634,
-0.7703491449,
-0.1470298171,
0.2903007269,
0.6180903316,
-0.1383348852,
0.0224211719,
0.5969906449,
0.2815623879,
0.1859109998,
-1.4196263552,
0.0284636207,
0.2793478668,
0.1781106293,
0.3941179216,
-1.192227006,
0.9226686358,
-0.3398196995,
-0.4409639537,
0.102951169,
0.7483184934,
0.3020987511,
0.1314598173,
0.3474774361,
0.162704736,
0.5737764239,
-0.165456593,
1.2351273298,
-0.0309288017,
0.3222811818,
1.1948292255,
-0.4684285223,
1.0224555731,
0.460380435,
-0.4131297767,
0.0180009287,
0.4460780323,
0.2510161698,
0.2061484605,
0.0518186651,
-0.2373580188,
-0.1371724904,
-0.0667769685,
-0.2054276466,
0.1670202315,
0.3558327556,
0.0727369115,
-0.3857058585,
-0.0117719499,
0.1711995453,
0.1573587209,
-0.4045297801,
0.9447145462,
0.6178283691,
-0.3269763291,
0.6001253724,
0.4992810786,
0.6336827278,
-0.5885704756,
0.3939788043,
-0.4800866246,
0.4476689696,
-0.3096205294,
-0.518322587,
0.6124441624,
0.1361039877,
-0.0012730121,
-0.0984003395,
0.5985949039,
-0.2260756642,
-0.480812043,
-0.1250733584,
0.1821953952,
0.1898350716,
-0.0806935579,
0.0514819361,
0.3038365543,
-0.252592802,
-0.1627910733,
0.6117616892,
0.1759793907,
-0.0526160002,
0.9348044395,
0.2876988053,
0.2693694532,
-0.1492949724,
0.1133428738,
0.6734915972,
-0.5862334967,
-0.7646537423,
-0.7843866944,
0.2178788036,
-0.0174058042,
0.1072162166,
0.7416915298,
0.7474221587,
0.4037082493,
-0.1251030862,
0.6673603058,
-0.0204544887,
0.6931869984,
-0.5678949952,
0.6323856711,
-0.6896107197,
0.4828023016,
-0.0674613416,
-1.0089473724,
-0.5385220647,
0.4131057858,
-0.2462432832,
0.193523407,
0.5119150877,
0.7256658077,
-0.1443447322,
0.0414885394,
0.624560535,
0.3301342428,
0.676222384,
0.4250259101,
0.4655286074,
-0.4120248258,
0.7067816257,
-0.1493343711,
-0.0939524472,
-0.508949101,
-0.9363840818,
-0.9746755958,
-0.073029004,
-0.3284254372,
0.0769452527,
-0.0502800979,
1.0236344337,
0.6402080059,
-0.6615434289,
-0.3500776589,
0.171921432,
-0.0579094812,
-0.1731354594,
-0.1409696192,
0.3646644056,
-0.2211137414,
-0.9235880971,
0.4411091208,
0.503579855,
0.3186001778,
-0.1167957708,
0.0914578289,
0.0747289807,
0.2195221931,
0.7528662682,
0.3409573436,
-0.6593633294,
-0.5032473207,
-0.3820859194,
-0.1074284166,
-0.2366154194,
0.6080904007,
-0.680567503,
-0.0949126631,
0.3966948092,
0.3965922594,
0.5474223495,
-0.0263214856,
0.5325795412,
-1.1087098122,
0.3962807059,
0.0948585123,
0.3824624121,
0.2096130401,
-0.1222698763,
0.5540673137,
-0.1149173453,
-0.5206051469,
-1.0333777666,
0.1604246795,
-1.0670598745,
-0.2254116386,
1.0276032686,
0.2232261002,
-0.0406190231,
0.1308744848,
-0.2490936071,
-0.0367517509,
-0.0014432219,
0.8206554055,
0.4140236378,
-0.2827718258,
-0.123130925,
-0.5121021867,
0.3975854516,
0.4066810608,
-0.7987990379,
0.2914119363,
0.3578847051,
0.1648946106,
0.052953545,
0.7213482261,
0.0309757795,
0.2655654848,
0.0824138299,
-0.2517947257,
-0.2808530033,
-0.292730391,
-0.2724621892,
0.2955284715,
0.5467409492,
-0.1104953438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00838v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00838v4
|
OLMo: Accelerating the Science of Language Models
| 2024-02-01T18:28:55 | 2024-06-07T21:59:52 |
Dirk Groeneveld, Iz Beltagy, Pete Walsh, Akshita Bhagia, Rodney Kinney, Oyvind Tafjord, Ananya Harsh Jha, Hamish Ivison, Ian Magnusson, Yizhong Wang, Shane Arora, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Arman Cohan, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Yuling Gu, Jack Hessel, Tushar Khot, William Merrill, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Valentina Pyatkin, Abhilasha Ravichander, Dustin Schwenk, Saurabh Shah, Will Smith, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Mitchell Wortsman, Pradeep Dasigi, Nathan Lambert, Kyle Richardson, Luke Zettlemoyer, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo, Luca Soldaini, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) have become ubiquitous in both NLP research and in
commercial product offerings. As their commercial importance has surged, the
most powerful models have become closed off, gated behind proprietary
interfaces, with important details of their training data, architectures, and
development undisclosed. Given the importance of these details in
scientifically studying these models, including their biases and potential
risks, we believe it is essential for the research community to have access to
powerful, truly open LMs. To this end, we have built OLMo, a competitive, truly
Open Language Model, to enable the scientific study of language models. Unlike
most prior efforts that have only released model weights and inference code, we
release OLMo alongside open training data and training and evaluation code. We
hope this release will empower the open research community and inspire a new
wave of innovation.
|
[
-0.1500046104,
-0.4797396362,
0.4352747798,
0.0142141348,
0.1805000752,
-0.4750837982,
-0.4714701176,
-0.6089799404,
-0.3329716921,
0.8064662814,
-0.2097880095,
-0.2854782045,
-0.5247710943,
-0.0724648312,
-0.3514335454,
0.945476532,
-0.0536434092,
0.3689972758,
-0.5439253449,
-0.3450505733,
0.1797061414,
-0.4055441022,
-0.3473248184,
-0.4120790362,
0.7008398175,
0.1428414732,
0.6760998368,
0.8760429025,
0.7596722245,
0.2845700383,
-0.1922464818,
0.0001004014,
-0.5043228269,
0.2906645834,
-0.3595261872,
-0.5565321445,
-0.8618099093,
0.1383034289,
0.6794120073,
1.125849843,
-0.055957593,
0.35450688,
-0.0934935138,
0.7233314514,
-0.6980196238,
0.4038260877,
-0.5416525006,
0.043770656,
-0.3680570424,
0.0261110198,
-0.4599276483,
-0.5151990652,
0.1470818818,
-0.3675272465,
0.0483669303,
0.1665788591,
0.551994741,
-0.0959406942,
-0.3460083306,
-0.301922828,
-0.9286686182,
0.9423825741,
-0.777528584,
0.5177460909,
0.1697375625,
0.545955658,
-0.2852340639,
-0.7899458408,
-0.3778183162,
-0.3632471561,
0.3396759629,
-0.2601930499,
-0.0528693087,
0.214448303,
0.0643696338,
0.6540411115,
-0.2432534546,
0.1915602535,
-0.8539025784,
0.3081290126,
0.5986337066,
0.0600912571,
0.4637114406,
0.4826796055,
-0.2174990624,
0.0621902943,
-0.8159079552,
-0.3435241878,
0.4726009071,
0.5244703889,
0.0016224281,
0.8972954154,
-0.2409182787,
0.7862811089,
-0.6980196238,
0.0362941548,
0.4130167067,
-0.2276444435,
-0.3909802735,
0.0641344413,
1.1038038731,
0.1846961975,
0.1252134591,
-0.083627671,
-0.3186833262,
-0.1922287345,
0.20126836,
-0.7756657004,
0.1387706399,
0.4120982289,
-0.6352567673,
-0.3406626582,
0.1206893697,
-0.8178458214,
-0.3845987618,
-0.0262412094,
0.4663117528,
-0.0784410164,
-0.5819296241,
0.6023340821,
-0.094788067,
-0.3667660654,
0.153063342,
-0.9666930437,
0.4717596173,
0.6741565466,
0.9707442522,
0.0787589699,
-0.050728336,
-0.2874117196,
-0.0303747728,
-0.518298924,
0.3355272412,
-0.438082397,
-0.3784921169,
0.1695584953,
-0.1304656118,
0.1002851352,
-0.4651884735,
0.7225779891,
-0.6155918241,
0.4441599548,
-0.0188114475,
-0.4862310588,
-0.0055786152,
-0.0989744365,
-0.7324915528,
0.9463152885,
0.0005812684,
-0.4097180068,
-0.0681703016,
-1.3326135874,
0.1897303164,
-0.0106013939,
-0.0780190974,
-0.3749603331,
0.4970484078,
-0.262938112,
0.2083204091,
-0.5241327882,
0.1588620245,
-0.5692709088,
0.1122765094,
0.4614228904,
0.0114148818,
0.9465041757,
0.6853226423,
-0.0159858074,
0.1267896295,
-0.6701093912,
0.0775214881,
0.4499214888,
-0.2497711033,
-0.5469958186,
0.2429078817,
-0.2232432812,
0.1632372588,
0.2851892114,
-0.8616261482,
0.3681703508,
-0.4828205109,
0.6188095212,
0.5437927246,
-0.591026485,
0.6420240402,
-0.0609346367,
0.4858518541,
-0.2161190659,
0.3653222322,
-0.5386441946,
-0.7269538641,
-0.615819037,
-0.3022117615,
0.3292650282,
0.0096071186,
-0.0370488428,
0.3262534738,
-0.2940752208,
-0.5638061166,
-0.9282809496,
0.1240411028,
0.496059984,
0.403029412,
0.1638951749,
-0.1692190468,
-0.503290832,
-0.8461267948,
-0.3150432706,
-0.0211111158,
-0.1776046753,
0.2467371672,
0.6630606651,
-0.0595581569,
1.1251571178,
-0.7094541788,
-0.3663686812,
-0.254376322,
-0.0170379449,
0.356913656,
0.3230108321,
0.6557500362,
-0.5409916043,
-0.2733252645,
0.2955897748,
-0.8850248456,
-0.2927162349,
0.6002807021,
0.016004825,
0.1785851568,
0.5268304944,
-0.4915065467,
0.0388955362,
0.8451823592,
-0.2498569489,
0.3663778603,
-0.2612991333,
-0.0434534401,
-0.7971054316,
0.3256185651,
-0.4390950799,
-0.1775742769,
-0.7027337551,
0.3378743231,
0.1183756217,
-0.2970335484,
-0.4565625787,
0.7435926199,
-0.588881433,
-0.2928455174,
-0.3205070198,
0.3563711345,
-0.0025360519,
-0.1697878689,
-0.0154121052,
0.4501307905,
0.6716590524,
-0.5715787411,
0.2571832836,
0.0817795917,
-0.6542111039,
-0.1339270175,
-0.9019930363,
0.1259309053,
-0.0883587152,
-0.0329954363,
-0.5176954865,
-0.1604941487,
0.3234124184,
-0.5118525624,
0.0654722676,
0.0198879894,
-0.4485995173,
-0.3921089172,
-0.1172348931,
0.4234599173,
0.6489313841,
-0.4187029004,
0.469307512,
0.6090832353,
-0.0485824235,
-0.5482968688,
-0.6692598462,
-0.2269863933,
0.2325223684,
-0.6974936128,
-0.0315041915,
-0.1678605676,
-0.6357528567,
0.220981583,
-0.1271503419,
-0.093245171,
0.1357840449,
0.2490074784,
0.0842967778,
-0.6852480173,
0.3096759319,
-0.1929357201,
-0.0012841172,
0.2670741379,
-0.5709362626,
0.5084117651,
-0.1802443266,
-0.3146535754,
0.001787862,
0.176433146,
0.6340776086,
-0.4909800589,
1.2126002312,
-0.0187786929,
-0.3225671649,
-0.3862228692,
-0.2209226936,
0.0304044131,
-0.4701802731,
0.5335973501,
-0.1195244789,
-0.906440258,
0.3192891777,
0.020001702,
0.3054045439,
0.2390248328,
0.5471047163,
0.1418231875,
1.1553826332,
0.8354091048,
0.1277231425,
0.509796679,
0.0562315509,
0.4517932236,
-0.5947496891,
-0.5637398362,
-1.0537745953,
-0.0527198203,
-0.1367648989,
-0.5918121338,
0.3430232704,
0.2561031878,
0.0461218245,
0.094706066,
-0.2476683557,
0.5077456832,
0.641493082,
-0.0331599005,
0.6221688986,
-0.1091856658,
-0.2449546009,
0.0460223258,
-0.5479145646,
-0.5807168484,
1.4329502583,
0.7118930221,
0.8453006148,
0.1225924194,
0.3523761928,
0.1188765168,
0.3781325221,
-0.6290642023,
0.5369651914,
0.0235991944,
-1.0450004339,
-0.1844581366,
-0.5061046481,
-0.9584661722,
0.2122965306,
-0.073811695,
-0.4387025833,
-0.0806049928,
0.3703880608,
-0.0399578139,
0.4185970426,
-0.5799711347,
0.8899940848,
-0.2967970669,
-0.2444753498,
-0.2498415858,
-0.5203694701,
0.7091599107,
-0.0761236325,
0.4947996438,
-0.3338587284,
-0.3473255932,
0.6849637032,
-0.6112836599,
0.746135354,
0.0624091364,
-0.4267445505,
0.2018643469,
0.0367673859,
-0.0005299935,
-0.3694553673,
-0.2079908103,
0.5258700252,
-0.2238663733,
-0.3552991152,
-0.5734880567,
0.7848070264,
-0.7419582605,
-0.2954427898,
-0.4663879573,
-0.6194980145,
-0.0606579892,
0.2790569663,
-0.1877414286,
0.2085776478,
-0.3726381361,
0.432359457,
0.8981984854,
-0.3385285735,
0.2015843391,
0.7382602096,
-0.895627737,
-0.3611406386,
0.7183889151,
-0.0071475594,
0.7333130836,
0.2694192231,
0.3675006032,
-0.0796650052,
-0.5776852369,
-0.2076168954,
0.3625867367,
-0.5526580215,
0.091540195,
-0.780829072,
-0.2510325909,
-0.5657536983,
0.0767049715,
-0.6952109337,
-0.6379492283,
0.0510088354,
-0.1287345886,
0.2213262022,
1.0012565851,
-0.1136193052,
0.2913327217,
-0.9272490144,
0.3006119728,
0.0686902478,
0.5858699083,
-0.2347731143,
-0.3025954366,
-0.5029629469,
0.1671680212,
-0.2906579673,
-0.5379539728,
0.2858234346,
0.4471171796,
0.6189433336,
0.746931076,
-0.0775755867,
0.1365098059,
-0.6965221763,
0.7597270608,
0.3904233873,
-0.8552783728,
0.5577275753,
-0.423525691,
0.1780906171,
0.0821485072,
0.6240503788,
-0.5294083953,
-0.3571377695,
-0.4014854431,
-0.6384018064,
1.0083355904,
0.1855456978,
0.1332434714,
-0.0154804513,
-0.0727478936,
0.3397800624,
0.6266435385,
-0.79296875,
-0.1732380837,
-0.219949469,
-0.2856736779,
-0.0762873814,
-0.3634446263,
-0.3308492899,
0.0006804142,
0.5904399753,
-0.0531650297,
0.1657506973,
-0.0719277337,
0.0428848416,
-0.4215906858,
0.1889331192,
0.6580461264,
0.6108487844,
-0.4889546335,
0.0467364155,
-0.4639366865,
-0.4906478524,
-0.2300513238,
-0.1309985965,
-0.2670209706,
0.0593574271,
0.2712448537,
0.815320909,
0.142733857,
-1.1504967213,
0.3632769287,
0.261744976,
-0.13820301,
-0.0907723382,
0.2423608005,
0.1606029421,
0.2461733669,
0.2075504214,
0.1553679258,
0.013113548,
-0.8864989877,
-0.1003229544,
0.4405170977,
-0.4144977927,
-0.4663495123,
0.8864136338,
0.4636743665,
-0.309384197,
0.3867130578,
0.2549784184,
-0.3072110415,
0.4706436694,
0.5055818558,
0.9097957015,
-0.4744055271,
-0.0420715921,
0.4169486463,
0.5131630301,
-0.4694471061,
0.2551910281,
0.1455237567,
-0.7544210553,
-0.2082709819,
-0.8827287555,
-0.3447590172,
0.1454582512,
-0.7435523272,
0.3549789488,
-0.3087849617,
-0.2065337449,
-0.3087766469,
-0.3311347365,
-0.1954489946,
0.0709586665,
0.2799924016,
1.2756457329,
-0.6787957549,
0.9666484594,
0.5155516863,
-0.4528938234,
0.0453609005,
-0.5904964209,
0.022612825,
-0.7295379639,
0.9542025924,
0.1468835771,
-0.1333789378,
-0.1245348975,
-0.7904080749,
-0.930000484,
0.841804862,
0.5422435999,
-0.6287449002,
-0.2039968222,
0.2016080171,
0.4977197349,
-0.648697257,
0.4069528282,
0.1685323268,
0.412007302,
-0.2580268681,
-1.0278990269,
-0.2895258963,
-0.10878589,
-0.0307222195,
0.4637971222,
-0.4308785498,
0.9970450401,
-0.4398445785,
0.0608752705,
0.2933054864,
0.7336649895,
0.0967523754,
0.301697284,
0.224642843,
0.3289945722,
0.6015120745,
-0.1323220581,
1.0818259716,
-0.1689558774,
0.370036006,
1.102674365,
-0.5217045546,
0.9089564681,
0.2774477303,
-0.140768379,
0.2455716133,
0.2030180693,
0.1468956172,
0.4498968124,
0.0800519735,
-0.3479377925,
-0.0807393342,
-0.4204421937,
-0.5645419359,
0.2403094918,
0.4368805289,
-0.8954154253,
-0.2171764225,
0.0507738963,
0.2223257422,
0.2765984833,
-0.4737848938,
0.3474679887,
0.3244291842,
-0.3726525903,
0.3534669876,
-0.0098629203,
0.3095182478,
-1.176156044,
0.1728044003,
-0.0010797136,
0.4412689209,
-0.0670010075,
-0.5380805731,
0.262894243,
0.0001459679,
-0.0915245786,
-0.4807171524,
0.4467020333,
-0.6857185364,
-0.1838423312,
0.7281085253,
0.3404694796,
0.2463560104,
-0.000378746,
-0.4353106916,
0.4925145805,
-0.2930242717,
-0.4725779593,
0.3952299058,
0.2988675237,
0.0880507827,
0.8959659338,
0.6131926179,
0.3295861483,
0.3489300311,
-0.1874935776,
0.9063000679,
-0.577390492,
0.0028327315,
-0.7520771623,
0.5498461723,
-0.1495515853,
-0.4159718752,
0.8985055089,
0.7069155574,
0.8663706779,
-0.3632819057,
0.8177941442,
-0.222747758,
0.5292328,
-0.6472818851,
0.9460706115,
-0.7384092212,
0.1238291711,
0.0242545269,
-0.8078230023,
-0.341329217,
0.2170436829,
-0.2002029419,
0.0075482861,
0.8716666102,
0.6384271979,
-0.1862174124,
-0.0345551483,
0.5673463941,
0.7402322888,
0.2577049136,
0.3292936683,
0.5105933547,
-0.3905219734,
0.6675615311,
-0.0546714589,
-0.4281335175,
-0.4974958897,
-1.0116819143,
-1.1304889917,
-0.6160398722,
-0.2188380212,
-0.3177396655,
0.2769171,
0.9314740896,
0.6045530438,
-0.8521620035,
-0.5966762304,
-0.0242306571,
-0.0161098726,
-0.1947601289,
-0.2211720496,
-0.1231108457,
-0.4685638547,
-1.0597853661,
0.7299417257,
0.4663404524,
-0.1320528537,
-0.5578262806,
-0.2352074683,
-0.0860755965,
0.4308460355,
0.4850611985,
0.5621799231,
-0.5402675867,
0.2237653881,
0.0746473297,
-0.2446339279,
-0.0929707661,
0.9961438179,
-0.5769587159,
0.7898937464,
0.8204515576,
0.547680974,
0.0283674449,
-0.4922118783,
1.2056223154,
-0.358666122,
0.3710703552,
0.2570462525,
0.5158722997,
0.0752273425,
0.1415393054,
0.6917473078,
0.1671455652,
-0.6302931309,
-1.4805891514,
0.3971396685,
-0.8044736981,
-0.3375528455,
0.8493294716,
-0.3143824637,
-0.616969645,
0.1036483943,
-0.0250240229,
-0.0057672299,
-0.3391165733,
0.6539007425,
0.5380192399,
0.2371816635,
-0.0228433758,
-0.9984616041,
0.4423061013,
0.1966416389,
-0.6813594699,
0.0450760908,
0.3357848823,
0.1028449237,
0.4413658679,
0.5459849238,
-0.5254436731,
0.0211160984,
0.0130500039,
0.6047148705,
-0.4878025949,
-0.5326700807,
-0.473945111,
0.3313018084,
0.280012548,
-0.2799304426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00835v1
|
ALISON: Fast and Effective Stylometric Authorship Obfuscation
| 2024-02-01T18:22:32 | 2024-02-01T18:22:32 |
Eric Xing, Saranya Venkatraman, Thai Le, Dongwon Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.0
|
Authorship Attribution (AA) and Authorship Obfuscation (AO) are two competing
tasks of increasing importance in privacy research. Modern AA leverages an
author's consistent writing style to match a text to its author using an AA
classifier. AO is the corresponding adversarial task, aiming to modify a text
in such a way that its semantics are preserved, yet an AA model cannot
correctly infer its authorship. To address privacy concerns raised by
state-of-the-art (SOTA) AA methods, new AO methods have been proposed but
remain largely impractical to use due to their prohibitively slow training and
obfuscation speed, often taking hours. To this challenge, we propose a
practical AO method, ALISON, that (1) dramatically reduces training/obfuscation
time, demonstrating more than 10x faster obfuscation than SOTA AO methods, (2)
achieves better obfuscation success through attacking three transformer-based
AA methods on two benchmark datasets, typically performing 15% better than
competing methods, (3) does not require direct signals from a target AA
classifier during obfuscation, and (4) utilizes unique stylometric features,
allowing sound model interpretation for explainable obfuscation. We also
demonstrate that ALISON can effectively prevent four SOTA AA methods from
accurately determining the authorship of ChatGPT-generated texts, all while
minimally changing the original text semantics. To ensure the reproducibility
of our findings, our code and data are available at:
https://github.com/EricX003/ALISON.
|
[
0.1443946958,
-0.9443468451,
0.5957813263,
-0.1262047589,
-0.2510309517,
0.1389178634,
-0.0967300385,
-0.8026190996,
0.2911713719,
0.843569994,
-0.4484092295,
-0.4717028439,
-0.7607926726,
0.1429088712,
-0.4622992873,
0.9980576038,
-0.0622391216,
-0.1778258979,
-0.0418675691,
-0.1226988211,
0.1604562551,
-0.230307281,
-0.7529606223,
0.1645811945,
0.5410863757,
0.3387979567,
0.7623407841,
1.3039857149,
0.7309977412,
0.321144104,
-0.2102258503,
0.128202334,
-0.5788921714,
0.1139876023,
0.1566184759,
-0.3995390236,
-0.4737919271,
-0.0559003837,
0.433003068,
0.5500626564,
-0.1749171466,
0.4783854485,
-0.0314196348,
0.5229099393,
-1.0171400309,
-0.014486691,
-0.3997319043,
-0.1403498799,
-0.5499156713,
-0.1654496938,
-0.5555694699,
-0.5970190167,
0.1022117659,
-0.6993445754,
0.2013254464,
0.3533212543,
0.885545671,
0.4559714794,
-0.1608979255,
-0.2000650316,
-0.9022717476,
0.6544977427,
-0.5692594647,
0.2866829634,
0.4894244075,
0.2660245001,
0.292838335,
-0.893050015,
-0.5499540567,
-0.2240106463,
-0.0774575695,
-0.1629167348,
-0.2509846389,
0.1160024107,
0.2979153693,
0.513263762,
-0.463976413,
0.0511845052,
-0.352219373,
-0.0992282629,
0.7779815793,
-0.2887447476,
0.4261862338,
0.0553569123,
-0.4325435758,
-0.1965783089,
-0.7680789232,
0.0412891209,
1.006321907,
0.0719777718,
0.0036156871,
0.4661189616,
0.134237349,
0.1221800819,
0.1251963079,
-0.0431737155,
0.0627494752,
-0.1342557818,
0.0311255585,
0.293353498,
1.0140451193,
-0.1562557966,
0.0576179735,
-0.2674051821,
0.1820343137,
-0.0015009411,
0.1465351582,
-0.8072335124,
-0.5898402929,
0.1453885287,
-0.5363811255,
-0.5394901037,
0.2217564732,
-0.5008295774,
-0.6270719171,
-0.1066836342,
0.5478346944,
-0.4665178359,
-0.0743420795,
0.046007812,
-0.1717688739,
-0.1377300471,
0.0108360806,
-0.745783329,
0.1569722593,
0.5824472308,
0.5888677239,
-0.001567384,
-0.2830644846,
-0.8531702757,
0.1408548653,
-0.3386740386,
0.4309032857,
-0.4349445999,
-0.0505294092,
-0.2202702165,
-0.1410911679,
0.2762126923,
-0.1805354357,
0.1382474452,
-0.6622079015,
0.170286864,
0.0074989344,
-0.3949874938,
-0.0633205995,
-0.283846885,
-0.7705568671,
0.887435317,
-0.010935083,
-0.3436197042,
0.2969789207,
-0.7877150178,
-0.3535174131,
0.1473730505,
0.1186253503,
-0.8851482272,
-0.1114988923,
0.3712658882,
0.214290753,
0.1149577126,
-0.122987844,
-0.1662225723,
-0.2758398056,
0.0751397982,
-0.2612932026,
1.2207034826,
0.0407444015,
-0.4850077629,
0.1116642654,
-0.8455239534,
-0.1602020264,
0.2751405835,
-0.089848727,
-0.4975206554,
-0.3449135423,
0.0145934699,
-0.6078314185,
0.1826699972,
-0.8865839243,
0.1500220746,
-0.6770167947,
0.2171895653,
0.7704548836,
0.0101926122,
0.6531543136,
-0.3454570174,
0.5764070749,
-0.5343595147,
0.1530909091,
-0.3081646264,
-0.581436336,
-0.343462944,
-0.8114117384,
0.5804668665,
0.4538592994,
-0.9194093347,
0.3628538251,
-0.2858956456,
-1.0067690611,
-0.9285291433,
0.2106717229,
1.085834384,
0.2160736471,
0.4404302239,
-0.6278061271,
-0.3609352112,
-0.6534633636,
-1.0930451155,
-0.0196987111,
-0.3072440028,
0.1769164503,
0.436325103,
0.180146262,
0.788815856,
-0.7741292119,
-0.4403977394,
-0.031331867,
0.4463995695,
-0.0568677038,
0.634178102,
0.649168551,
-0.7631933093,
-0.6398081183,
-0.3131219745,
-0.7423234582,
-0.1342178732,
-0.0303474497,
-0.2131723315,
0.1964778602,
0.6139697433,
-0.610063076,
0.9511284828,
0.254624337,
-0.590497613,
0.5308013558,
-0.0510487929,
0.228060782,
-0.6496316791,
0.08791022,
-0.2969384491,
-0.2826805413,
-0.7884660959,
0.4273922443,
0.0542522445,
-0.1532040834,
-0.674341023,
0.4532529116,
-0.7017457485,
0.4606446922,
0.1215843484,
-0.2409695238,
-0.0315583535,
0.6637907624,
-0.1436715722,
0.4563753307,
0.4758649766,
-0.3682586849,
0.1982171983,
0.7014530301,
-0.4978343248,
0.3610761762,
-0.6055755615,
0.6190633774,
-0.4024857581,
0.1331845075,
-1.1105438471,
-0.1362602413,
0.5472539663,
-0.4316725731,
0.3954971433,
-0.3345775902,
-0.5871679783,
0.0976674259,
-0.4510233998,
0.6308968663,
0.4658502936,
-0.7586673498,
1.0368703604,
0.1512632072,
-0.3365465999,
-0.6348621249,
-0.752391994,
0.0935207084,
-0.1668996215,
-0.4658567309,
0.7403257489,
-0.0191980936,
-0.2395712435,
0.1075227857,
-0.224983573,
-0.1757919341,
0.2129344195,
0.2299082577,
0.4383118749,
-0.0298725683,
-0.2607094944,
0.0155614074,
-0.3599314988,
-0.0651050359,
-0.0105908047,
0.1340623051,
0.2510402203,
-0.4079265893,
-0.827463448,
0.5191885233,
0.2680552006,
-0.32760939,
1.0631417036,
0.4815001786,
-0.189911291,
-0.2983275652,
-0.3244307935,
-0.5755247474,
-0.5256080627,
0.1654546708,
0.0122987432,
-0.6065500379,
0.4411772788,
0.3406297863,
0.4865733683,
0.1350388527,
0.091373153,
0.1671703458,
0.5516912341,
0.5229728818,
-0.0268288944,
0.7439957261,
-0.3222009838,
0.5873892307,
-0.446917206,
0.0428976417,
-0.5181168914,
-0.3952723145,
-0.489146769,
-0.0781820789,
0.5536386371,
-0.2690111995,
-0.1764727086,
0.5716995597,
-0.8422991037,
0.746414721,
0.9269205928,
0.5005654097,
0.3740835786,
0.001460014,
0.670869112,
0.0716625154,
-0.3817860186,
-0.4203352034,
1.5103613138,
0.2620057166,
0.6209391356,
0.6208423972,
0.8869707584,
0.2309720069,
0.3044791818,
-0.5500454903,
0.5932552218,
-0.2119722813,
-0.7178964615,
-0.6086162329,
-0.481207788,
-0.7992957234,
0.1215486005,
-0.3301808536,
-0.8417604566,
0.1610260606,
0.4847139418,
-0.6082987189,
0.4982697368,
-0.6433990002,
0.6921859384,
0.213417694,
-0.6994978786,
0.3112583756,
-0.9847945571,
0.2019040734,
0.0676813722,
0.2608393729,
0.0757569,
0.0222773906,
0.9606233835,
-0.6652485728,
0.8520776629,
-0.3598665297,
-0.1917349398,
0.1458792537,
0.2363051474,
0.8226783872,
-0.3296401799,
0.0660341606,
0.4761682153,
-0.1176271588,
-0.2285679877,
-0.4897477031,
0.3045202196,
-0.429798454,
-0.4273284972,
-0.3241899312,
-0.3670762777,
0.0371999368,
0.3543828428,
0.4921754599,
0.4815536439,
0.1009511203,
0.4248096943,
0.5437330008,
0.0617065057,
0.3579827845,
0.1465503424,
0.2775708139,
-0.3567727208,
0.8724948764,
0.1498604268,
0.2742473185,
0.2879407406,
0.339852035,
-0.1999434382,
-0.37932688,
-0.511565268,
0.1921009421,
-0.4720614552,
-0.1520668566,
-0.6976537704,
-0.0113976011,
-0.4489132166,
-0.4061052501,
-0.5186495185,
-0.6855872869,
-0.1827383637,
0.1691249609,
0.5128024817,
0.3890058398,
0.2193593681,
0.7820168734,
-0.5561954379,
0.6249462962,
0.1969650686,
0.1607811749,
0.0403383896,
-0.412681967,
0.0594612323,
0.0544301756,
-0.4698456824,
-0.9095189571,
0.1648151129,
0.2836037874,
0.3240855336,
0.5731977224,
0.4443736374,
0.7337060571,
-0.4843910038,
0.8563603759,
0.1075347736,
-1.1457592249,
0.3069908321,
-0.2787624896,
-0.1488422304,
0.6761857271,
0.180988133,
0.0371307135,
-0.7560606599,
-0.7765536904,
-1.4226093292,
0.9367786646,
0.7489736676,
-0.1756652892,
0.5928021669,
0.3307958245,
0.3141673505,
0.3634459972,
-0.6510933042,
-0.5333499312,
-0.0001582953,
-0.4576368332,
-0.056884978,
-0.2342880368,
-0.1985912472,
-0.041168008,
0.8119353652,
0.1124519184,
0.2837045491,
0.1656604111,
-0.0320527218,
0.0791829228,
0.056970194,
0.1088312641,
0.4807081521,
-0.0582700521,
0.1499623507,
0.0127093596,
-0.7521842122,
-0.1228884757,
0.281350404,
-0.353082478,
0.0797103718,
0.8191896081,
0.4145942032,
0.1248231605,
-0.3455775082,
0.7415470481,
0.1806919426,
-0.4277882576,
-0.4383957982,
0.3545717001,
-0.1602748781,
0.1464775652,
0.3992569149,
0.3224760294,
0.3469349742,
-0.4870351255,
0.0393830128,
0.2886074483,
-0.1687576771,
-0.1877746433,
1.0126407146,
-0.0173873715,
-0.5389527082,
0.1579527408,
-0.055781424,
-0.2554974854,
0.6968551278,
0.3384720087,
0.9056628346,
-0.6608823538,
-0.1260593981,
-0.0035515281,
0.2223314196,
-0.1434838623,
0.3078465164,
-0.3025274873,
-0.3648540974,
-0.0148108657,
-0.3928053975,
-0.5614244938,
-0.2252908945,
-0.7514274716,
-0.0142497951,
-0.5281124115,
0.0916549861,
0.5824972391,
-0.3120029867,
-0.4735760689,
-0.1273170114,
-0.3116571605,
0.4812536836,
-0.7652709484,
0.2124284953,
0.4944752455,
-0.08172784,
-0.7537703514,
0.0031306632,
0.3134991527,
-0.7617276907,
0.104205586,
0.0713106766,
-0.4221291244,
0.2850293517,
-0.9552202821,
-0.5839612484,
0.9407847524,
0.5155258775,
-0.3535911441,
-0.0857560933,
-0.0600459017,
0.2948230207,
-0.1419967115,
0.1060093194,
0.240057379,
0.5589652658,
0.046989698,
-0.7213460207,
0.1761946082,
-0.2094772756,
-0.1797676235,
0.3101122081,
-0.4265911579,
0.7399532199,
-0.1067519262,
-0.3825215995,
0.4149138629,
0.6016603112,
0.2790182233,
0.6065043211,
0.6076464057,
0.4456941485,
0.8505766392,
0.0418668762,
0.9832189083,
-0.2385134399,
0.1934985369,
1.1109867096,
-0.1108797118,
0.6130381823,
0.5278140903,
-0.0489317365,
0.5546091795,
-0.013673597,
-0.1156401485,
0.6312280297,
0.1492063552,
-0.1967251003,
-0.1566626132,
0.0344601236,
-0.2631926835,
0.6067903638,
-0.2583400905,
-0.4998113215,
0.205405876,
0.1819361001,
0.8073439598,
0.2660279274,
-0.0793010965,
0.7825918794,
-0.0915716887,
-0.44973737,
0.2761237919,
-0.0623403192,
0.4487942755,
-0.7421256304,
-0.1240045205,
0.2524960041,
0.5079265237,
-0.3015509248,
-0.4784373641,
0.2646894753,
0.1192385927,
0.0750363469,
-0.5917818546,
0.5258523822,
-0.533115685,
-0.4435610771,
-0.2009077519,
0.1191799343,
0.2818736434,
-0.1905744225,
-0.0024988498,
-0.0624945797,
0.0028303589,
-0.4451889098,
-0.1802100092,
0.1778295934,
0.114488326,
0.5550258756,
1.0654034615,
0.1844759732,
-0.373667568,
-0.4192993939,
0.7482863069,
-0.4365780056,
-0.8926784396,
-1.1127643585,
0.5203607678,
-0.1631467044,
-0.4651507437,
1.0747978687,
0.6043991446,
0.604980886,
-0.1047056764,
0.6628729701,
-0.0955532715,
0.5735064149,
-0.5924835205,
1.204461813,
-0.6216757894,
0.3609728515,
-0.4798096418,
-0.6098012924,
-0.4944655299,
0.4810869098,
-0.2350659221,
0.0692465678,
0.6577582359,
0.8164094687,
-0.1705575287,
0.2732894123,
-0.1147617772,
0.2122945487,
0.4537396431,
0.310736239,
0.5266706347,
-0.7331033349,
0.6569557786,
-0.4866898656,
-0.5776798725,
-0.3771341741,
-0.9431297779,
-1.046402812,
-0.3896654844,
-0.639077723,
-0.3354665637,
0.2759809792,
0.6085060239,
0.8556485772,
-0.6647108197,
0.3474984467,
0.034949474,
0.0649892092,
-0.7691900134,
-0.1826076657,
0.7679621577,
0.5469252467,
-0.7394746542,
0.3827162981,
-0.0932710916,
-0.100208059,
-0.0285645667,
0.155061841,
0.0452450402,
0.1363620162,
0.1420655996,
0.1737677604,
-0.6200369,
-0.4834007621,
-0.0973026529,
0.1978312433,
-0.1355974227,
0.525377214,
-0.4700519443,
0.574480474,
0.3121181428,
0.4018931687,
0.4914267063,
0.3925455511,
0.191409573,
-0.8500039577,
-0.0097102979,
0.4362879097,
0.1033186466,
0.0356786586,
-0.8645019531,
0.4713906944,
0.3028674424,
-0.5351215601,
-1.1124970913,
0.3469008207,
-1.0348601341,
-0.2227912992,
0.9665342569,
-0.3280643225,
-0.5957993269,
-0.3147131205,
-0.2427828163,
0.2720161378,
-0.6252717972,
0.9113589525,
0.3139471412,
-0.0040548393,
-0.0720517561,
-0.2279711515,
0.6672321558,
0.3233478963,
-0.5160329342,
0.3435634971,
0.1957028061,
0.1166408807,
0.4936249554,
0.6934707165,
-0.0363375843,
0.4219956398,
0.3566844165,
0.2417936772,
-0.8840159774,
-0.5805714726,
0.1212652922,
0.4259399176,
-0.3690530062,
-0.5775415301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01778v1
|
Introduction to speech recognition
| 2024-02-01T17:54:15 | 2024-02-01T17:54:15 |
Gabriel Dauphin
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
This document contains lectures and practical experimentations using Matlab
and implementing a system which is actually correctly classifying three words
(one, two and three) with the help of a very small database. To achieve this
performance, it uses speech modeling specificities, powerful computer
algorithms (dynamic time warping and Dijktra's algorithm) and machine learning
(nearest neighbor). This document introduces also some machine learning
evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.3797785938,
-0.7710595131,
0.3406781852,
-0.004322357,
-0.1343819499,
0.319701314,
0.0768370703,
-0.3505152762,
-0.209856838,
0.3909012973,
-0.3686677814,
-0.3374758959,
-0.574821949,
-0.1165635586,
-0.7844997644,
0.7110260725,
0.2083870322,
0.5599641204,
0.2302383482,
-0.3512508869,
-0.4530938566,
-0.4750088453,
-0.8051623106,
-0.4853975177,
0.3279869258,
0.6644792557,
0.4712142944,
0.6964316368,
0.526050508,
0.3098196387,
-0.0507655181,
-0.187576279,
-0.1868370622,
-0.2710869908,
0.1988898814,
-0.6520112753,
-0.0338352211,
0.3617445827,
0.8921288848,
0.6749301553,
-0.3450962901,
0.2390401959,
-0.037434224,
0.7578821778,
-0.0987011269,
0.2100759596,
-0.2652470469,
0.3639621437,
-0.52603513,
-0.1976957768,
-0.2501768172,
-0.5474755764,
0.0151718454,
-0.4432208836,
0.4316978157,
0.1136165038,
0.5553826094,
0.3626081347,
-0.0789159089,
-0.5998681188,
-0.9950942397,
0.8864471316,
-0.361877799,
0.6334165335,
0.5127040744,
0.9505890608,
-0.0000354699,
-0.7386689782,
-0.7806655169,
-0.1049701422,
0.1461171657,
-0.2635228932,
-0.2434778064,
0.0185916405,
0.5116416216,
0.3737448454,
-0.6091505885,
0.3038995266,
-0.8088141084,
-0.5332439542,
0.5303261876,
0.1630938798,
0.3400308788,
0.1072945967,
0.0825163648,
-0.1873648465,
-0.236416772,
-0.04925365,
0.2971459329,
0.489340663,
-0.1962736547,
0.5906296968,
0.0883924663,
1.1983885765,
-0.2243060023,
-0.709948957,
0.4697740674,
0.0615827255,
-0.2481254637,
0.6205163598,
0.5408253074,
-0.1037640348,
0.2156622559,
-0.0029801899,
0.1186457425,
0.2049668878,
0.1350281388,
-0.449644357,
-0.154239282,
0.0493020564,
-0.5473415256,
-0.3040016294,
-0.1135610119,
-0.4343879521,
-0.3491909206,
-0.6894752979,
0.495265007,
-0.6162984967,
0.030434886,
-0.0637855232,
-0.2432159483,
0.5370243192,
0.2703195214,
-0.518279314,
0.7551379204,
0.5550026298,
1.0172611475,
-0.1680598706,
-0.3264534771,
-0.5208871961,
0.0735042095,
-0.0357521139,
0.6614503264,
-0.2598852813,
-0.7313424349,
-0.395804137,
-0.0423520096,
0.1441750526,
-0.5368528366,
0.7121926546,
-0.1500930935,
0.275664866,
0.3118064404,
-0.787460804,
-0.3130853176,
-0.242125541,
-0.4710621238,
1.042871356,
0.1399218589,
-0.644071579,
0.1353535652,
-1.2216180563,
-0.5357016921,
0.2265956849,
-0.1037207767,
-0.2964877784,
0.0068041328,
-0.1943297386,
0.5032585263,
-0.1107817441,
-0.4784382582,
0.3022096753,
-0.4943835437,
0.24137716,
-0.1217614785,
0.9138162136,
0.6644805074,
-0.0125798974,
-0.2226712853,
-1.2668174505,
0.1265225559,
0.1649561226,
-0.5532131195,
-0.0613264404,
0.1457061768,
0.0559456982,
-0.1881662011,
-0.0183868408,
-0.7114284039,
0.1207550615,
-0.5496667624,
0.6398649216,
0.1664623618,
-0.1465359926,
0.3796617687,
-0.1323635578,
0.3417268991,
-0.0768841505,
-0.1268549412,
0.0135222562,
-0.7674446702,
-0.8169998527,
0.0151394568,
0.545824945,
0.9509623647,
-0.424859941,
0.2197213173,
-0.0619856939,
-0.6871023178,
-0.4576105773,
0.1568112671,
0.3833941519,
0.5111380816,
0.2037557364,
0.0865215585,
-0.7177996635,
-0.8112988472,
0.200366497,
-0.4596820176,
-0.2859430909,
0.2540860474,
0.0516562909,
-0.1017320156,
0.8061313629,
-0.8312894702,
-0.3641664982,
-0.1973621845,
0.420673281,
0.2652922571,
0.5214931369,
0.4956251681,
-0.7013425231,
-0.2681450546,
-0.137069881,
-0.2891804576,
0.0752892047,
0.5843625665,
0.3147701025,
-0.081355229,
0.5583245754,
0.1775773168,
0.4440631568,
0.38019678,
0.1965485215,
0.1606443822,
-0.1886516213,
-0.2384342551,
-1.0910547972,
-0.370686084,
0.0215633512,
-0.2488619536,
-0.9330060482,
-0.365906924,
-0.0969474167,
-0.3869108856,
-0.6367319226,
0.349396497,
-0.1569436342,
-0.3316926062,
-0.4896161556,
0.2128822207,
-0.3593810797,
0.2148967236,
0.0679532513,
0.7706061602,
0.5921503305,
-0.9320687056,
0.6212062836,
0.3835062385,
-0.5493253469,
0.7561708093,
-0.2701200843,
0.5653540492,
-0.1476187855,
-0.3184948564,
-0.9249851704,
-0.4047015607,
0.0688410178,
-0.7961050868,
0.6994504333,
0.0342941582,
-0.4174446166,
-0.7182338238,
0.152269572,
0.1375741065,
0.6391825676,
-0.4439539015,
0.4134501815,
1.0901594162,
-0.090570204,
-0.3521978855,
-0.7947215438,
0.1466372311,
-0.1177771613,
-0.1120126098,
0.1593945175,
0.0014551013,
-0.2409832925,
-0.3465757966,
0.4518060982,
-0.468155086,
0.1020499021,
0.376183331,
-0.1997642368,
-0.1747170091,
0.3358971477,
-0.3309781253,
-0.1225483194,
-0.3145746887,
-0.0937702209,
0.5337646008,
-0.4743244946,
-0.2168399096,
-0.6780327559,
0.1351061165,
0.4075401425,
0.2544942796,
0.0746954009,
1.0291513205,
-0.6305060983,
-0.0729540884,
-0.4490580261,
0.2158645689,
-0.400637269,
0.433699578,
-0.3619776964,
-0.5706710815,
0.1617283374,
0.1925331503,
-0.2557579875,
0.4810685217,
0.445318073,
-0.2277824879,
1.1668146849,
0.8668106794,
-0.40291062,
0.3924927115,
-0.1653994322,
0.117654942,
-0.7939718962,
-0.322775811,
-1.1453285217,
-0.3017976284,
-0.5036431551,
-0.2835825086,
0.2203466743,
0.0208571572,
-0.0928827077,
0.5807477832,
-0.8727609515,
0.4737426937,
0.7861084342,
0.0550685562,
-0.1214099303,
0.0544905551,
-0.3610943556,
-0.07906124,
-0.580072999,
-0.5736287236,
0.8316811323,
0.5024168491,
0.9462307096,
0.0703033656,
0.6399282813,
0.4307692349,
0.1496463418,
-1.1614485979,
0.6224710345,
-0.1998397857,
-0.4559441805,
-0.4999258816,
-0.2771537602,
-0.8948920369,
-0.3458129764,
-0.1539439559,
-0.7803885937,
-0.0593559034,
0.0629901662,
-0.4325154722,
0.1961279362,
-0.7751249671,
0.2563077807,
-0.3723276258,
0.2078180462,
-0.2076028436,
-0.8045190573,
0.1216001585,
-0.2392025441,
0.3066572249,
-0.2971836329,
0.0676666871,
1.3079974651,
-0.0869019181,
0.5404478312,
-0.6612141728,
0.3594328463,
0.2923422456,
-0.0307249408,
-0.2327348292,
-0.4494311512,
-0.1232434064,
0.2088976353,
0.3164361715,
-0.0590345412,
-0.3380536735,
0.4524239898,
-0.7520105243,
-0.1166018397,
-0.4449779093,
-0.3997444212,
-0.4458083212,
0.4692009985,
0.0144699225,
0.4441975355,
-0.6205545068,
0.111380741,
0.687640965,
-0.4304547906,
0.4476887584,
0.8942585588,
-0.3800902069,
-0.4984626472,
1.1696363688,
0.1884368509,
-0.3383786976,
0.4914508164,
0.7345062494,
-0.5634506941,
-0.7686898708,
-0.5099166632,
0.1217218041,
-0.5789275765,
-0.1118963882,
-0.5127122402,
-0.5404954553,
-0.4102011919,
0.1293240786,
0.0115903383,
-0.782274127,
-0.4756945074,
-0.0766063258,
0.2004557401,
0.9276685119,
-0.2837106884,
0.7328132987,
-0.8578694463,
0.42984128,
0.5596719384,
0.2991998196,
-0.3987590373,
-0.5669150352,
-0.4140312374,
-0.0525429435,
-0.4495463073,
-0.8689614534,
0.2063270956,
0.5308592319,
1.0069881678,
0.6133073568,
-0.5294448137,
0.3264243007,
-0.7256084085,
0.8971435428,
0.2200661749,
-0.9294466376,
0.9613236189,
-0.0379540026,
0.1424293071,
0.2942523658,
0.3190046847,
-0.2402369231,
0.1800298244,
-0.4901562035,
0.0201225132,
1.0413478613,
0.1884054542,
-0.125332877,
0.1803253144,
0.4951384068,
-0.1510538459,
0.2928332984,
-0.2722403705,
-0.5513353348,
-0.2206121087,
-0.3985282183,
-0.4529195726,
-0.2726521492,
-0.1913181245,
-0.4871493876,
0.667909503,
0.0892571062,
0.4507160783,
-0.2173416317,
-0.1954104155,
0.2619724572,
0.2034453452,
1.0183458328,
0.1873114258,
-0.3841082752,
0.0103758434,
0.4030400813,
-0.9586790204,
0.5202742815,
0.1888893098,
0.2355639189,
0.3347575963,
-0.071060665,
0.765543282,
-0.0149726253,
-0.2629807591,
0.3337221444,
-0.3303350806,
-0.3695912659,
-0.2809551954,
0.3277790546,
-0.0679965243,
-0.1712633222,
0.3136892021,
-0.184902966,
0.3914676905,
-0.4326226711,
0.1443722397,
0.284062922,
-0.5842754245,
0.0315176249,
0.5413765907,
0.0368429571,
-1.1775951385,
0.2943517268,
-0.1127726659,
-0.6580007672,
0.5622006655,
0.4977043271,
0.8913580775,
-0.9205880165,
0.0782101005,
0.5386688709,
0.1795346439,
-0.2571129501,
0.4091466665,
-0.405156374,
-0.7623238564,
0.0393454917,
-1.0063717365,
-0.7881857157,
0.0503931567,
-0.7710727453,
0.5900526643,
-0.5950302482,
-0.3235290349,
0.746853888,
0.2188640088,
-0.5416159034,
0.2438936532,
0.3369446695,
0.9791792035,
-0.6580679417,
1.139313817,
0.7134037018,
-0.1112702042,
-0.7351956964,
-0.5576590896,
0.3288255036,
-0.9736099243,
0.7685881853,
0.1597448736,
-0.5442448854,
0.2487196326,
-0.6317958832,
-0.6935831904,
0.8471740484,
-0.0579345822,
-0.658657372,
0.1457855403,
0.3249515295,
0.575429678,
-0.3103438616,
-0.2076206207,
0.8673006892,
0.2274125963,
0.1783221662,
-1.0598058701,
-0.7340160012,
-0.0502420254,
0.0495821834,
0.0018112198,
-0.183946833,
0.6049279571,
-0.1718007028,
-0.3741271198,
0.2152080387,
0.4593756795,
-0.1071760729,
0.6012520194,
0.6597422361,
0.6609258056,
1.1710605621,
-0.5084716082,
0.7183947563,
-0.4038213789,
-0.0035155844,
1.4727333784,
-0.2162147909,
0.8456420898,
0.1739004254,
-0.8724010587,
0.2013159245,
0.5116255283,
-0.247964859,
0.3780441284,
0.4469672441,
-0.2432980686,
0.4171221852,
0.0449444912,
-0.4566709399,
0.8072826266,
0.9255542755,
-0.36817801,
0.0205441881,
0.5089511871,
-0.4138717949,
-0.1613582075,
-0.6022124887,
1.0448282957,
0.0762259662,
-0.058360327,
0.3028398454,
0.1569800079,
0.282389313,
-0.4673973024,
-0.0950298309,
0.3989666402,
0.2195995301,
-0.1200991422,
-0.8270586729,
0.4566972852,
-0.01342523,
-0.1038579196,
0.0860987008,
0.7688321471,
-0.12051972,
-0.7503733635,
-0.2307465523,
0.1815404594,
0.727196455,
0.3954064846,
-0.7804808021,
0.0933069587,
-0.2351867259,
0.3729178607,
-0.1010041907,
0.1983861178,
0.2803170681,
0.6037489176,
0.5570496321,
0.2830696702,
0.207951501,
0.3163121939,
0.4631422162,
-0.6499218941,
-0.6571542025,
-0.5241215229,
-0.2961271405,
-0.0178183857,
0.2042287737,
0.7452659011,
0.8036041856,
0.6062418818,
0.1540460289,
0.7728018165,
0.187999472,
1.4751265049,
-0.3331773281,
0.5492059588,
-0.2412737012,
0.1453360319,
-0.4336058795,
-0.7632313371,
-0.6519685984,
0.9722331166,
0.0164107531,
-0.215629369,
0.3119723499,
0.7768195271,
0.0694732741,
0.3481517434,
0.5420954823,
0.1423796862,
0.0752047896,
0.2261449993,
1.003625989,
-0.326282084,
0.4608301818,
-0.3330255747,
-0.3021945655,
-0.2618839741,
-0.657120645,
-0.5047092438,
-0.7579984069,
-0.2637255788,
-0.6212041974,
-0.1126011238,
0.7550785542,
0.9319346547,
-0.9629872441,
-0.3043256104,
0.0477134436,
-0.0148346005,
-0.0235178806,
-0.2006968558,
0.3770345151,
0.0072094509,
-0.9162037969,
0.4681243002,
0.2731933594,
0.7061684728,
-0.3516860008,
-0.2303395271,
-0.0630230978,
-0.0160220545,
0.4218645096,
0.7933347821,
-0.4033108652,
-0.0615625344,
-0.352599442,
0.0395784453,
0.1954266876,
0.7968049645,
-0.8681619167,
0.6207479835,
0.458140105,
0.3216833174,
0.6151742935,
-0.1718839258,
0.1247615293,
-0.6364393234,
0.3616425693,
0.301083684,
0.3858669996,
0.5793693066,
-0.0576052107,
0.5483234525,
0.1009076461,
-0.6075556874,
-1.066708684,
0.0510281734,
-1.1277565956,
0.0599626414,
0.7850986719,
0.2280786932,
-0.1448720843,
-0.396312505,
-0.7036363482,
0.5114517808,
0.1029832289,
0.3327147067,
0.801810801,
-0.714056015,
-0.0491940863,
-0.6248313785,
0.7285075784,
-0.337859422,
-0.466909647,
-0.5514310598,
0.4117271304,
0.4617685378,
0.5013370514,
0.5359704494,
-0.3616440594,
0.0123950141,
0.0543018095,
-0.0859312564,
-0.2021820247,
-0.3423367441,
-0.7489005327,
0.2111064941,
0.1939744502,
-0.7237548232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00798v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00798v3
|
Formal-LLM: Integrating Formal Language and Natural Language for Controllable LLM-based Agents
| 2024-02-01T17:30:50 | 2024-06-18T05:44:03 |
Zelong Li, Wenyue Hua, Hao Wang, He Zhu, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL
|
Recent advancements on Large Language Models (LLMs) enable AI Agents to
automatically generate and execute multi-step plans to solve complex tasks.
However, since LLM's content generation process is hardly controllable, current
LLM-based agents frequently generate invalid or non-executable plans, which
jeopardizes the performance of the generated plans and corrupts users' trust in
LLM-based agents. In response, this paper proposes a novel ``Formal-LLM''
framework for LLM-based agents by integrating the expressiveness of natural
language and the precision of formal language. Specifically, the framework
allows human users to express their requirements or constraints for the
planning process as an automaton. A stack-based LLM plan generation process is
then conducted under the supervision of the automaton to ensure that the
generated plan satisfies the constraints, making the planning process
controllable. We conduct experiments on both benchmark tasks and practical
real-life tasks, and our framework achieves over 50% overall performance
increase, which validates the feasibility and effectiveness of employing
Formal-LLM to guide the plan generation of agents, preventing the agents from
generating invalid and unsuccessful plans. Further, more controllable LLM-based
agents can facilitate the broader utilization of LLM in application scenarios
where high validity of planning is essential. The work is open-sourced at
https://github.com/agiresearch/Formal-LLM.
|
[
-0.1960434616,
-0.8514657021,
0.4567003548,
0.3789501488,
0.1219941452,
0.2902268171,
-0.1849295199,
-0.7734475136,
0.3439914286,
0.6358218789,
-0.4571572244,
-0.5147409439,
-0.1808760464,
0.0764018074,
-0.2755584419,
0.5624377131,
-0.5145255327,
-0.185778901,
-0.1922011226,
0.296354413,
-0.0086432723,
-0.418294549,
-0.5853883028,
-0.597892642,
0.2514172196,
0.2673193514,
1.0367088318,
0.8199495077,
0.4914062023,
0.337105453,
0.3932329118,
0.4369214773,
-0.2517789304,
0.1476260126,
-0.2089331299,
-0.4002884328,
-0.8356460929,
-0.1372443736,
0.6474733949,
0.3458844423,
-0.3116270602,
-0.1543336511,
-0.1534048468,
0.4812419415,
-0.5783564448,
0.4892807007,
-0.5979263783,
0.0870311484,
0.0712263212,
-0.4859543741,
-0.2534344494,
-0.4681707323,
-0.2127590477,
-0.7477431297,
-0.1654706299,
0.1199179515,
0.7748044133,
0.4751354754,
-0.1878544837,
-0.5356940031,
-1.1991698742,
0.4806594849,
-0.8947696686,
-0.0056210835,
0.4478660822,
0.4789707661,
-0.4939725399,
-0.6337649226,
-0.6950782537,
-0.6820560098,
-0.1342444271,
0.0435892045,
0.11681135,
0.3605479002,
0.2466896921,
0.2333841175,
-0.5570693016,
0.279468298,
0.0242172647,
-0.3007237017,
0.9074165225,
0.3047687411,
0.488188386,
0.0610876419,
-0.5133932829,
0.4186382592,
-0.520745337,
-0.0465415977,
0.4515142441,
0.350150317,
-0.2143410146,
0.7829102874,
-0.6997168064,
0.4160481095,
-0.0853472427,
-0.1357367933,
-0.1811755449,
-0.3576282561,
-0.3825978935,
0.0196930785,
0.7917816043,
0.1363605559,
0.6119564772,
-0.2784157991,
-0.5236329436,
0.2598888874,
0.1409553885,
-0.5385539532,
-0.0002181633,
0.2967661619,
0.1223688722,
-0.5467660427,
-0.0919232219,
-0.2147844136,
-0.219947055,
-0.3924823701,
0.1338374019,
-0.4933721721,
-0.068707794,
0.2921328545,
0.3565994203,
0.7078709602,
0.4576502144,
-0.7376304865,
0.8110950589,
0.6778147221,
0.4601397216,
-0.0324871764,
-0.3005181253,
-0.6054888964,
0.5752555132,
-0.5549952388,
0.6630551219,
-0.4731756151,
-0.2215202898,
0.3001187742,
-0.287002176,
0.1356114298,
-0.2721779943,
0.4237394035,
-0.6033917665,
0.2042891234,
0.0119364075,
-0.503369391,
0.0716529861,
0.5737567544,
-0.5747661591,
0.901302278,
-0.0989447907,
-0.2658081055,
0.3530691266,
-0.5923238397,
-0.6063586473,
0.367733568,
-0.5170788765,
-0.1054272354,
-0.4653608203,
-0.0645361915,
0.3935092688,
-0.2828670442,
0.5988513827,
-0.074383229,
-0.1341942698,
0.1994876117,
-0.205205515,
0.3506905735,
0.1520879418,
-0.6150131226,
0.3865645826,
-0.6493546963,
0.1994819343,
0.0853372142,
-0.4810432494,
0.1010994837,
0.1642466486,
-0.0945992917,
0.39694345,
0.6284236908,
-0.2041658759,
0.306196779,
-0.5820788741,
0.2418307066,
0.6637548208,
-0.0349757336,
0.8575194478,
-0.709587872,
0.5686019063,
-0.5761093497,
0.1024567038,
-0.1109571308,
-0.0581508614,
-0.4968878329,
-0.252840817,
-0.0137920119,
0.7874500751,
-0.6608433127,
0.6644608974,
-0.1680887192,
-0.38229388,
0.0313764624,
0.138110891,
0.4172125459,
0.4644547403,
0.100967139,
-0.1456672996,
-0.2868711352,
-0.7537225485,
-0.1180975884,
-0.2630234361,
0.0201607496,
0.4051227272,
0.4135297239,
-0.4125878513,
1.1061683893,
-0.2497313917,
-0.2744914591,
-0.343909651,
0.1314473748,
-0.2215203643,
0.4775341749,
0.0505114533,
-0.6993792653,
-0.3305409849,
0.0108513553,
-0.8834708929,
-0.378708601,
-0.5045188665,
-0.350762248,
0.4481752217,
0.4944188595,
-0.6979978681,
0.3537297547,
0.1468050927,
-0.2365968525,
0.8746143579,
-0.3655948639,
-0.1908926219,
-1.0480568409,
0.2314435393,
-0.1991448551,
-0.4587125778,
-0.5312095881,
0.3423112035,
-0.0729347169,
-0.1230136752,
-0.5243836641,
0.7476881146,
-0.3925662637,
-0.0416230261,
-0.1743673682,
0.2013853639,
0.0208020601,
0.5811861753,
0.1507692039,
0.5545486808,
0.4323802888,
-0.714086771,
0.4882836938,
0.1881121695,
0.0510746799,
0.4174972773,
-0.6158232689,
-0.0640031099,
0.0232015755,
0.426387459,
-0.5756409168,
-0.6097967625,
0.4962489605,
-0.1388747543,
0.4265600741,
0.1114137992,
-0.7475371957,
0.015449252,
-0.2742671967,
0.085307017,
0.3554689884,
-0.0480982736,
0.9600470066,
0.2393871397,
-0.2402063608,
-0.3601128757,
-0.8751471043,
0.325735271,
0.134654507,
-0.7309764028,
0.4473148882,
-0.1588782519,
-0.5599126816,
0.0658544526,
-0.078651078,
-0.1248228773,
-0.088963531,
0.3575171828,
0.2103191018,
0.0963702276,
-0.0471569151,
0.1022806168,
-0.2922709882,
0.2191469669,
-0.3127217889,
0.5086632967,
-0.2351248413,
-0.4932517111,
-0.6250718236,
0.2149616033,
0.6380753517,
-0.4243429601,
0.4333227277,
0.2275485247,
-0.4792280197,
-0.3602803946,
-0.4170906246,
-0.0747415051,
-0.4851270616,
-0.0132363606,
-0.2630457878,
-0.588409543,
0.458045125,
-0.3746236265,
0.3859554529,
0.1807472259,
0.4352510273,
-0.0256599728,
0.7200139761,
0.5812015533,
-0.157619223,
0.1846577227,
-0.1641774476,
-0.0872537717,
-0.2950875461,
-0.3180453777,
-0.394898206,
-0.346363157,
-0.623478651,
-0.4921227992,
-0.191213727,
0.0087171989,
-0.0782957375,
0.1090497151,
-0.3297317028,
0.297341764,
0.2361129224,
-0.3006343246,
0.5425435901,
-0.2293906063,
-0.2938224077,
0.2557244003,
-0.5281424522,
-1.0045460463,
0.5855382681,
0.2998841405,
1.0981657505,
-0.0268321857,
0.8872938752,
0.5291962028,
0.0980046466,
-0.7617034316,
0.8305222988,
0.4337040484,
-0.4125549793,
-0.6177784204,
-0.3407138884,
-0.7525310516,
-0.1367076635,
-0.3251176476,
-0.4568277001,
-0.0889786705,
0.251743257,
-0.1748940796,
0.2475811094,
-0.3405123353,
0.4018548131,
-0.6526523829,
-0.4943038225,
-0.1505191773,
-0.5955583453,
0.3874553144,
-0.1413054764,
0.2963417768,
-0.385135293,
-0.3499739766,
0.3178530931,
-0.5726399422,
0.8821085095,
0.0169925876,
-0.3610335588,
0.3025672436,
0.5037817955,
1.2104774714,
0.1490166336,
-0.207368657,
-0.025552066,
-0.3004407883,
-0.4021004438,
-0.5897007585,
0.663003087,
-0.5253868699,
-0.3018409312,
-0.3286597133,
-0.7976340652,
-0.1032386348,
0.4882075489,
0.0206092168,
0.4584271908,
-0.3702774942,
-0.3488128185,
0.3532119989,
-0.2685397565,
0.3531840146,
0.5988272429,
-0.4591043293,
-0.1244002953,
0.7171484828,
-0.0647502393,
0.5307370424,
0.6926540732,
0.1479295492,
-0.2728895843,
-0.6070790887,
-0.0507910401,
0.1690753847,
-0.2976440489,
0.1116387397,
-0.4464085996,
-0.447961539,
-0.2912251949,
-0.6339908838,
-0.2543676496,
-0.5112960935,
0.0214430541,
-0.0292806942,
0.1065900028,
0.693084538,
-0.0608095117,
0.1020103842,
-0.3893095553,
0.5132880211,
0.2075176984,
0.3602778316,
-0.5476332903,
0.0309358649,
-0.0027064476,
0.0729883015,
-0.0639222562,
-0.531734705,
0.4266519547,
0.1573452801,
0.5744443536,
0.3036201298,
0.3013406992,
0.3387173414,
-0.4230744243,
0.4103652537,
-0.1744422466,
-0.5956602097,
0.6466418505,
-0.5819519162,
0.3610150218,
0.5154600143,
0.2658852339,
-0.2700015306,
-0.8261165023,
-0.7078867555,
-0.8825031519,
0.4489547908,
0.4010314047,
-0.0012274374,
0.1767774075,
0.3601686358,
-0.0724012405,
0.4030912519,
-0.6054867506,
-0.0707219765,
0.1415647566,
-0.0439849123,
0.1811161786,
-0.2965425551,
-0.2998796105,
0.177994132,
0.5496538281,
-0.1139400974,
0.1144884378,
0.2057095766,
-0.3292635679,
-0.2726917863,
0.3865553439,
0.8495956063,
0.5343111753,
-0.1786379069,
0.3176889718,
0.0380252749,
-0.331451416,
-0.0292295646,
0.27451092,
-0.4345082343,
-0.2820702195,
0.4617237449,
0.3182388842,
0.3753402233,
-0.6927685142,
0.059794914,
-0.033927273,
-0.4876391888,
-0.6291800737,
0.2691421807,
-0.1417946815,
0.2505025864,
0.1731431782,
0.1133530438,
-0.0992606953,
-0.3574546576,
0.3958512247,
0.4990350604,
-0.2756546736,
-0.2094640583,
0.6214305758,
0.489901036,
-0.5846722722,
0.2250140607,
-0.5671952963,
-0.2854196429,
0.4737405777,
0.5540750027,
0.906034112,
-0.0233914349,
0.269903332,
0.102239877,
0.5812186599,
0.0801587999,
0.6370120645,
-0.1113352627,
-0.7497084141,
-0.5506910086,
-0.6894395947,
-0.4966730177,
-0.0054023266,
-0.1899795085,
0.2126382887,
-0.7816967368,
0.1057941094,
-0.5862418413,
0.1207853705,
-0.366984427,
0.0258535333,
0.1682757586,
1.0126113892,
-0.4285103083,
0.6121788621,
0.6863167286,
-0.3231928349,
-0.9783149958,
0.1016327217,
0.0520795062,
-0.7328668237,
0.449583739,
-0.1330692172,
-0.5179736018,
0.045468308,
-0.535738349,
-0.7683259845,
1.2508127689,
0.3453511298,
-0.5164263844,
-0.2966212034,
0.5060053468,
0.4514497221,
-0.334217459,
-0.058888942,
0.3314147294,
0.7784066796,
0.3464162946,
-0.8312699199,
0.3177541494,
-0.1898771524,
-0.269851774,
0.3531402647,
-0.3854602873,
0.3743252158,
-0.1932063699,
-0.39145419,
-0.0071935756,
0.6098018885,
0.5221574903,
0.2623935342,
0.1819539219,
0.2878079712,
0.9246396422,
0.0687542409,
1.0701934099,
-0.6678004861,
-0.1229512841,
1.2282756567,
-0.6358253956,
0.6013357639,
0.186568588,
0.100976944,
0.5279458165,
0.2110363692,
0.1912833154,
0.1932162046,
0.3055812418,
-0.4415953457,
-0.045618359,
-0.2117862254,
-0.1481400281,
0.3508251011,
0.2585198581,
0.0396471135,
-0.3390702903,
-0.4350041151,
0.0777022466,
0.3974401653,
-0.1898992509,
0.6397032738,
0.1116875038,
-0.4186476171,
0.4579585493,
0.0299948119,
0.6293948889,
-0.8506569862,
-0.024137374,
-0.0416494049,
-0.0749070644,
-0.4543088675,
-0.5933064222,
0.4517236352,
-0.1502839625,
0.0900309384,
-0.4602261186,
1.0365055799,
-0.5122997165,
-0.3596655428,
0.1911028475,
0.4928292036,
0.0225108191,
0.0491705388,
-0.694195807,
-0.1756263971,
-0.4603392482,
-0.1103391051,
0.0814103037,
0.4341023862,
-0.3384736776,
0.9708080292,
0.7963811755,
0.4986215234,
0.081956543,
-0.0138573619,
0.6926280856,
-0.6008204222,
-0.6446234584,
-0.7678691745,
0.5329912305,
-0.0274182893,
0.1477604359,
0.5242375731,
0.6113558412,
0.5540841818,
0.2119249105,
0.768561244,
-0.0443697385,
-0.074557364,
-0.6577866673,
0.7398434877,
-0.2869683206,
0.3759478331,
-0.052869115,
-0.648488462,
-0.3574256301,
0.2950943708,
-0.3386175931,
0.0084129255,
0.5076369047,
0.9106243849,
0.1632364094,
-0.4295772016,
0.3878839612,
-0.0299903173,
0.6334801912,
0.4848217368,
0.923766315,
0.135064587,
0.4429691434,
-0.1020455062,
-0.3863152564,
-0.2044032961,
-1.0060975552,
-0.6375194788,
-0.2467855215,
-0.1945374161,
-0.0005206988,
-0.1094419211,
0.9422334433,
0.64031744,
-0.4359366298,
-0.4806638062,
-0.5214871764,
0.2929014862,
0.0511971004,
-0.2630220652,
-0.1304497719,
-0.5978049636,
-0.5150265694,
0.5153971314,
0.5868639946,
0.1474771798,
-0.5175343156,
-0.5944971442,
-0.2194297165,
0.3629867733,
0.4638612866,
0.7024076581,
-0.7405551672,
0.0693561211,
-0.0672175735,
-0.6461415887,
-0.208658576,
0.7907081842,
-0.5958788395,
0.2996617556,
0.4283476472,
0.6153166294,
0.3773493469,
0.0244731251,
0.9487653375,
-0.7658894658,
0.0425283015,
0.4452948272,
0.1302220076,
-0.0070874258,
-0.5909726024,
0.5076130033,
-0.0939197093,
-0.5959761143,
-0.4857336879,
0.5954364538,
-1.0320155621,
-0.0179699324,
1.2804865837,
0.3822129369,
-0.1689725369,
-0.1706579924,
-0.3289310932,
0.2883155346,
-0.5899332166,
0.7187048793,
0.3427653909,
-0.3468983471,
0.1655422747,
-0.4671653509,
0.7420145869,
0.0238938499,
-1.1700109243,
0.0509313196,
0.599606514,
-0.0948051065,
0.1828729063,
1.030846715,
-0.0885724351,
0.1026247367,
-0.320402652,
0.4159635305,
-0.530225873,
-0.3748501837,
-0.0902655497,
0.070960857,
0.3242563009,
0.1200325787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00794v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00794v2
|
ReAGent: A Model-agnostic Feature Attribution Method for Generative Language Models
| 2024-02-01T17:25:51 | 2024-02-07T21:01:16 |
Zhixue Zhao, Boxuan Shan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Feature attribution methods (FAs), such as gradients and attention, are
widely employed approaches to derive the importance of all input features to
the model predictions. Existing work in natural language processing has mostly
focused on developing and testing FAs for encoder-only language models (LMs) in
classification tasks. However, it is unknown if it is faithful to use these FAs
for decoder-only models on text generation, due to the inherent differences
between model architectures and task settings respectively. Moreover, previous
work has demonstrated that there is no `one-wins-all' FA across models and
tasks. This makes the selection of a FA computationally expensive for large LMs
since input importance derivation often requires multiple forward and backward
passes including gradient computations that might be prohibitive even with
access to large compute. To address these issues, we present a model-agnostic
FA for generative LMs called Recursive Attribution Generator (ReAGent). Our
method updates the token importance distribution in a recursive manner. For
each update, we compute the difference in the probability distribution over the
vocabulary for predicting the next token between using the original input and
using a modified version where a part of the input is replaced with RoBERTa
predictions. Our intuition is that replacing an important token in the context
should have resulted in a larger change in the model's confidence in predicting
the token than replacing an unimportant token. Our method can be universally
applied to any generative LM without accessing internal model weights or
additional training and fine-tuning, as most other FAs require. We extensively
compare the faithfulness of ReAGent with seven popular FAs across six
decoder-only LMs of various sizes. The results show that our method
consistently provides more faithful token importance distributions.
|
[
-0.0621965528,
-0.5894798636,
0.5072225332,
0.2008245736,
-0.2498863488,
-0.096812807,
-0.0850936472,
-0.2177207023,
0.4247829914,
0.3092299104,
-0.6169718504,
-0.3787015676,
-0.6217426658,
0.100614354,
-0.6474725604,
0.9281116724,
-0.1610264629,
-0.211697042,
-0.2932559252,
-0.0707351416,
-0.0951508284,
-0.5337965488,
-0.8081142902,
-0.4580587745,
0.7257739305,
0.1045953482,
0.5383167267,
0.7838273048,
0.3080986142,
0.2754252255,
-0.0122103887,
-0.0795346051,
-0.1699154377,
0.3294034302,
-0.3166107535,
-0.5880045891,
-0.4496658146,
0.1891847551,
0.6020861864,
0.3630979955,
-0.2296306938,
0.3678727746,
-0.0026772607,
0.468549788,
-0.9854721427,
0.106060423,
-0.9199590683,
0.1791434884,
-0.2988070548,
-0.3265208602,
-0.5186141133,
-0.5063764453,
-0.0278853886,
-0.4500365257,
0.8068759441,
-0.1659315825,
0.743674159,
0.5201666951,
-0.1211555153,
-0.1053606123,
-0.5413476825,
1.0455282927,
-0.439914465,
0.5013304949,
0.3052115738,
0.1443730146,
-0.2049528509,
-0.6825076938,
-0.4271406531,
-0.2651626468,
0.1111719981,
-0.0539820082,
-0.298743844,
-0.07893686,
-0.0378487594,
0.6117551327,
-0.1261857152,
-0.1486082375,
0.1499432474,
-0.3130574226,
0.4455700219,
0.0194628891,
0.1070625857,
-0.1426409632,
-0.430218339,
0.0428567901,
-0.8546619415,
-0.0653611124,
0.0817272812,
0.144725576,
-0.0451349467,
0.4952163994,
0.2188120931,
0.6865510941,
0.231195122,
-0.0246534981,
0.4389766753,
-0.2857445478,
-0.1961916089,
-0.0533457771,
0.7879151702,
-0.0588477515,
0.3591775,
-0.1891621053,
-0.5660185814,
0.0880491287,
0.4183530509,
-0.629740119,
-0.299175024,
0.0805848911,
-0.4555045366,
-0.804336071,
-0.1900646687,
-0.7354281545,
-0.2410736829,
-0.004167567,
0.2070319951,
-0.3112296164,
-0.2463378161,
-0.2104771435,
-0.0381802768,
0.0751711428,
0.3307828307,
-1.0342534781,
-0.0408191867,
0.5051257014,
0.969502151,
-0.2827738523,
-0.2698239982,
-0.8047681451,
0.0072020865,
-0.3259533048,
0.7889496088,
-0.5308061838,
-0.2292108238,
-0.0012687936,
-0.0057425783,
-0.0584948547,
-0.3981624842,
0.6153525114,
-0.4243269563,
-0.1398111731,
-0.0310693998,
-0.5472845435,
0.0908047557,
0.0886907876,
-0.8745946288,
0.8720723391,
0.3276222348,
-0.7024408579,
0.4119604826,
-0.7205736637,
-0.5765618086,
-0.1524385959,
-0.3365845084,
-0.6556121707,
0.3358508945,
0.0453323685,
0.3409226537,
-0.4901691675,
0.2642202973,
-0.0709936768,
-0.2035951912,
0.645180583,
-0.9792539477,
0.656211555,
0.2117237598,
-0.3613045216,
0.2762033045,
-0.8125376701,
0.1288448274,
0.2204982787,
-0.6306211352,
0.1107857823,
0.0358628258,
0.1352358758,
-0.1474785954,
0.1827755123,
-0.7313035727,
-0.0784137994,
-0.3905433714,
0.5912234187,
0.8168196678,
-0.1138303131,
0.4063214064,
-0.0776353404,
0.7413138151,
-0.1743109524,
0.0164231472,
-0.2233858854,
-0.6015380621,
-0.7396508455,
-0.4814886451,
0.498155117,
0.4407747388,
-0.6325947046,
0.5882517099,
-0.3225684762,
-0.3057954907,
-0.767659843,
0.0638712868,
0.6239266396,
0.3612983823,
0.2030731738,
-0.2958644331,
-0.3898104727,
-0.999104321,
-0.3336107731,
-0.3073802888,
-0.2060792595,
-0.1075408608,
0.2856613994,
-0.2275708765,
1.1117810011,
-0.6615507603,
-0.2123383135,
-0.2893131375,
0.2425891906,
-0.1031622514,
0.3881407976,
0.5455884933,
-0.5927301645,
-0.4022473693,
-0.0107252356,
-0.4634431005,
-0.3693858683,
0.0790567994,
0.1295100302,
0.5024241209,
0.412879169,
-0.6226001978,
0.626275301,
0.5680352449,
-0.1080532968,
0.4523665309,
-0.146716699,
0.1666885018,
-1.0040514469,
0.1818094105,
0.0583547801,
-0.4273281395,
-0.7539530993,
0.1588065624,
0.0937249064,
-0.0858933553,
-0.4662140012,
0.7132048607,
-0.2341540158,
-0.0334258378,
-0.3625732958,
-0.2118233144,
0.1651409566,
0.480573833,
0.0326485485,
1.0031818151,
0.5157680511,
-0.4539783001,
0.4511739314,
0.0073745851,
-0.240906179,
0.1428277194,
-0.6197253466,
0.0940743312,
-0.0092405584,
0.0465614125,
-1.0689806938,
-0.0145562273,
0.4352974594,
-0.7806147933,
0.3940672874,
-0.1778667718,
-0.3349178731,
-0.0370549858,
-0.2246877998,
0.4233798683,
0.3758915663,
-0.5099758506,
1.0356849432,
0.1021423116,
-0.0469836593,
-0.5737336874,
-0.9844811559,
0.0062772194,
-0.2685259581,
-0.5643617511,
0.4538572133,
0.2840572596,
-0.1023390591,
0.0908093229,
-0.1973975301,
-0.130259797,
0.2534186244,
0.1459536552,
-0.0877604261,
-0.1481592506,
0.255407393,
-0.1401004195,
-0.5853011608,
0.1304427832,
-0.0606163554,
0.3509365022,
0.0669686347,
-0.4740023315,
-0.330016613,
0.4623233378,
0.6442779303,
-0.4712882936,
0.8138798475,
0.72716254,
-0.3471588492,
-0.1614092141,
-0.5519099832,
-0.2028868347,
-0.45025298,
0.5770732164,
-0.4789232016,
-0.7372374535,
0.8278374672,
0.2365538776,
0.2707907557,
0.4477317929,
0.4779704809,
0.3080403209,
0.6988638639,
0.6808261871,
-0.3101777732,
0.6648190022,
-0.0297738984,
0.2925417125,
-0.7241374254,
0.1460202783,
-0.4960771501,
-0.0403412655,
-0.1711282879,
-0.4832419157,
0.0973791108,
-0.1368066818,
-0.1877773106,
0.0345442332,
-0.4126710296,
0.3252123296,
0.5246821642,
-0.0629687756,
0.2677813768,
0.4740348756,
0.3514815271,
-0.143261686,
-0.6120991111,
-0.2285807878,
1.2268824577,
0.4095675349,
0.884775877,
0.410630703,
0.6858817935,
0.433041364,
0.7941852212,
-0.8634382486,
0.3508667648,
-0.3168533742,
-0.491404593,
-0.3739628792,
-0.3585993946,
-0.8419393897,
0.1891941577,
-0.1245473847,
-0.6494639516,
0.1835168302,
0.5075479746,
-0.328866303,
0.2465944737,
-0.5896711349,
0.8180350065,
0.1113497913,
-0.2968008518,
0.0344869085,
-0.3648866415,
0.1705166698,
-0.3466584086,
-0.1693545878,
0.2419199347,
-0.1336661726,
0.6598757505,
-0.4722923934,
0.9263694286,
-0.0688119084,
-0.4571758211,
0.4885286689,
0.2113065273,
0.7893670201,
-0.0719050243,
-0.2160718888,
0.0320501365,
-0.5905395746,
-0.0555939227,
-0.8192036152,
0.7359351516,
-0.7474735975,
-0.9780548811,
-0.2702721357,
-0.2934966683,
0.2426021546,
0.0613058731,
0.6066808701,
0.376916796,
0.04403124,
0.1594971865,
0.6653398871,
0.1233781278,
0.1101793498,
0.1557604074,
-0.1062748209,
-0.383317858,
1.0502665043,
-0.1169554889,
0.6867311001,
0.2656692863,
0.2252554744,
-0.3632116318,
-0.5020942092,
-0.5862181187,
0.0104944315,
-1.0050296783,
-0.3730019927,
-0.7049152255,
-0.3566397429,
-0.2507817447,
-0.4608184993,
-0.7214672565,
-0.276943475,
-0.4806276262,
-0.1999930143,
0.7196679115,
0.2836907506,
0.078827925,
0.2648970187,
-0.630199492,
0.2150946558,
0.3033561409,
0.2913894951,
0.2778824568,
-0.6679345965,
-0.1652110815,
0.0328602642,
-0.392236501,
-0.9698092341,
0.3304527402,
0.3585102856,
0.7072125673,
0.2821411788,
-0.2615155578,
0.4484939277,
-0.4762675464,
0.7470533252,
0.2800015211,
-1.1007490158,
0.4797764719,
-0.2507244051,
-0.0264020171,
0.4683758318,
-0.0746329799,
-0.3726410866,
-0.4482266009,
-0.6445012689,
-0.8964235783,
0.6237342358,
0.4710642993,
0.0509241931,
-0.2135199308,
0.6850851774,
-0.0446796529,
0.265162617,
-0.7483693361,
-0.4865801036,
-0.5504184961,
-0.4304629564,
-0.1725922078,
-0.2253968865,
0.0947008058,
0.0021775444,
0.5010800958,
-0.1081719771,
0.4991430044,
0.2712604105,
0.0776505694,
-0.4131487906,
0.3078592122,
0.3908692896,
0.4830899239,
-0.2049900293,
0.1785007119,
0.078095369,
-0.4930306375,
0.4602881372,
-0.0177049916,
-0.3089483678,
0.2543172836,
0.3615593016,
0.6646819711,
0.240623638,
-0.2898843884,
0.5384480953,
0.2535047531,
-0.2031033933,
-0.469153136,
0.1275344491,
0.1518103927,
0.0487228073,
0.3852396309,
0.1866933256,
0.1242322549,
-0.4341374338,
0.3915388882,
0.3683758676,
-0.5575171709,
-0.3017618656,
0.6615704298,
0.3751226962,
-0.3865894377,
0.4602357149,
-0.2933931649,
-0.5780671835,
0.6771863699,
0.6749937534,
1.4368827343,
-0.6231800318,
0.1707997024,
0.1863453239,
0.0806874633,
-0.052971065,
0.0782651901,
0.2187719196,
-1.0691081285,
-0.463396132,
-0.6792142391,
0.0908339173,
0.1968000382,
-0.4913850427,
0.0543371961,
-0.4320787191,
-0.4141809642,
0.0782391876,
-0.4572156966,
-0.395857811,
0.0648142919,
-0.149795711,
0.6255545616,
-0.941177845,
0.8002232313,
0.7123038173,
-0.3579319417,
-0.5552276373,
0.216996491,
0.1676767915,
-0.673661828,
0.8135300279,
-0.0876540169,
-0.4666737914,
0.2568799853,
-0.2418421358,
-1.0405730009,
1.0454158783,
0.389847815,
-0.2099202871,
0.2374081612,
-0.0504584163,
0.39793998,
-0.7078519464,
-0.1164795384,
0.351573199,
0.2200293243,
0.2822271585,
-0.5417430997,
0.2453706115,
-0.1337975115,
0.1801173687,
0.5141896009,
-0.3468336165,
1.039655447,
-0.2252704948,
-0.4368901849,
0.2299362868,
0.8275104165,
0.5472221971,
-0.0777830407,
0.6274601817,
0.4225721061,
0.5727275014,
0.0958037451,
1.048935771,
-0.1484017819,
0.5297782421,
0.9498327971,
-0.0533783212,
0.7019392252,
0.619374156,
-0.3264488876,
0.3299932182,
0.4021129012,
0.0122816265,
0.6381239295,
0.4496525526,
-0.4327306151,
-0.3712812662,
-0.0700330809,
-0.1868970245,
0.1491908878,
0.2936915159,
-0.8107509613,
-0.3234971762,
-0.2361000925,
0.0844345689,
-0.0313092694,
-0.2326878458,
0.3549358845,
0.083614327,
-0.4572022557,
0.7028397918,
0.1899883747,
0.807531774,
-0.5542211533,
-0.1303307861,
-0.1504349113,
0.3651228845,
-0.1433331966,
-0.7369071841,
0.3962970078,
0.1697452515,
-0.5628737807,
0.0337259211,
0.8082539439,
-0.3957953751,
-0.7087164521,
0.0796146244,
0.3076841235,
0.0376937501,
-0.1530853361,
-0.6546843052,
0.0182729457,
0.4666947722,
-0.480753243,
0.1980133206,
0.4902025163,
-0.1633213609,
1.0438878536,
0.6548676491,
0.0632119328,
0.0015623361,
0.2779230475,
0.7286394238,
-0.585608542,
-0.3944843411,
-0.9098953009,
0.6204198599,
0.2368520945,
-0.2438612282,
0.5924916863,
0.1517710686,
0.365744561,
-0.1798758507,
0.9537697434,
0.0704430565,
0.2181404382,
-0.5188803673,
0.6004545689,
-0.6574920416,
0.1718248576,
-0.1396476477,
-1.043748498,
-0.2931587398,
0.8254894614,
-0.0235101394,
0.0611957684,
0.5996095538,
0.6815011501,
-0.0227443967,
-0.0571028702,
0.1531351358,
-0.0886840522,
0.6217569709,
0.4495027959,
0.4779943228,
-0.3973729312,
0.3490440249,
0.2082678378,
-0.2942503989,
-0.2498439848,
-0.8813923597,
-0.6149654388,
-0.5374740362,
-0.5245215893,
-0.2041537166,
0.0608678684,
0.9060624242,
0.2252615094,
-0.6270810366,
0.2195843309,
-0.3143112063,
-0.0122340834,
-0.1469685435,
-0.2432653904,
0.489708662,
-0.3525197804,
-0.5685735345,
0.0601177178,
0.0485728681,
0.1511900723,
-0.5884281397,
0.077619426,
-0.0844200179,
-0.0596989058,
0.4604690373,
0.099223502,
-1.0923153162,
-0.6117480993,
-0.1733402759,
-0.0344469957,
0.0144863781,
0.975714922,
-0.6849583983,
0.1929416507,
0.4864316285,
0.7133671641,
0.1156832278,
0.0414246544,
0.8973339796,
-0.9762016535,
0.1299078465,
-0.0589053445,
0.4453928471,
0.4250649214,
-0.5235844254,
0.4007344246,
0.2812167406,
-0.4570604265,
-0.6151975393,
0.5396110415,
-0.5782213211,
-0.0683361888,
1.1983085871,
-0.5167482495,
-0.5098785162,
-0.2216212153,
0.2226152718,
0.2976485789,
-0.6337763071,
0.5963435769,
0.6444381475,
0.1615569293,
-0.3181924224,
-0.1914531738,
0.651342392,
0.547227025,
-0.2609864473,
0.6477783918,
0.3161371648,
0.4398989081,
0.561064899,
0.6771377921,
-0.1802538633,
0.1293332875,
-0.0699163675,
0.5460399985,
-0.2301270813,
-0.3595797718,
-0.323982358,
-0.0149466759,
0.2231076658,
-0.2783521414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00786v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00786v4
|
CroissantLLM: A Truly Bilingual French-English Language Model
| 2024-02-01T17:17:55 | 2024-03-29T14:56:42 |
Manuel Faysse, Patrick Fernandes, Nuno M. Guerreiro, António Loison, Duarte M. Alves, Caio Corro, Nicolas Boizard, João Alves, Ricardo Rei, Pedro H. Martins, Antoni Bigata Casademunt, François Yvon, André F. T. Martins, Gautier Viaud, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce CroissantLLM, a 1.3B language model pretrained on a set of 3T
English and French tokens, to bring to the research and industrial community a
high-performance, fully open-sourced bilingual model that runs swiftly on
consumer-grade local hardware. To that end, we pioneer the approach of training
an intrinsically bilingual model with a 1:1 English-to-French pretraining data
ratio, a custom tokenizer, and bilingual finetuning datasets. We release the
training dataset, notably containing a French split with manually curated,
high-quality, and varied data sources. To assess performance outside of
English, we craft a novel benchmark, FrenchBench, consisting of an array of
classification and generation tasks, covering various orthogonal aspects of
model performance in the French Language. Additionally, rooted in transparency
and to foster further Large Language Model research, we release codebases, and
dozens of checkpoints across various model sizes, training data distributions,
and training steps, as well as fine-tuned Chat models, and strong translation
models. We evaluate our model through the FMTI framework, and validate 81 % of
the transparency criteria, far beyond the scores of even most open initiatives.
This work enriches the NLP landscape, breaking away from previous
English-centric work in order to strengthen our understanding of
multilinguality in language models.
|
[
-0.0570833385,
-0.5272678733,
0.1558023989,
0.8545073271,
0.018944703,
0.1284582913,
-0.6528295279,
-0.7047953606,
-0.139702037,
0.7971557975,
-0.2703106105,
-0.449603349,
-0.8189218044,
0.1673457623,
-0.5587504506,
0.756046474,
-0.1176513806,
0.5017552376,
-0.0634896532,
-0.2392234057,
-0.3332798481,
-0.8319323063,
-0.6776211858,
-0.4791683257,
0.5016842484,
0.1520228833,
0.5035644174,
0.6635121703,
0.1083548591,
0.1866572946,
0.1228239015,
-0.0248334426,
-0.5421485901,
-0.3523251414,
-0.1456825584,
-0.8675794601,
-0.5033205748,
0.0755998567,
0.4695272446,
0.7655730844,
-0.1621969491,
0.1229549199,
0.2491531819,
0.6185868382,
-0.4440070093,
0.285307616,
-0.6601606011,
0.1375253052,
-0.2767553627,
-0.025875574,
-0.5893549919,
-0.2991759479,
-0.0474759713,
-0.3095945716,
0.2383998334,
-0.1814812869,
0.8054312468,
-0.1566135883,
-0.5291036367,
-0.0285989884,
-0.9476029277,
1.0626821518,
-0.5520796776,
1.0855610371,
0.5447661281,
0.2747996747,
0.2385572195,
-0.906218648,
-0.3221014142,
-0.0508192927,
0.1600396782,
0.1213710755,
0.1287281513,
-0.3706407845,
-0.2385670245,
0.4971523583,
-0.9048322439,
-0.1227847114,
-0.3433593214,
-0.1043535918,
0.5239574313,
0.0593626909,
0.4202287197,
0.4608477652,
-0.491851598,
0.0472752973,
-0.5291882157,
0.1441222131,
0.4483957887,
0.417968601,
-0.3876554966,
0.5154294968,
-0.0271979701,
0.4264527857,
-0.4800708592,
0.0650355294,
0.375019908,
-0.4022868574,
-0.1551314741,
0.0227626283,
0.9185222983,
0.1720154881,
0.6243912578,
-0.353430301,
-0.2959215045,
0.0894004554,
0.020270234,
-0.8799320459,
-0.4018114209,
0.2399735302,
-0.0771119744,
-0.0895257145,
-0.1534029394,
-0.4482946396,
0.309005022,
-0.4762203991,
0.1517582536,
-0.5234488249,
-0.6428608894,
0.4474053681,
0.0702407658,
0.1333652288,
0.3166062832,
-0.9416621327,
0.4983165264,
0.8414952755,
0.7450611591,
-0.4921454489,
-0.6012949347,
-0.2486996204,
0.1468205303,
-0.2398688197,
0.5090937018,
-0.613776505,
-0.5660791397,
0.2404007018,
0.3425156474,
-0.4025593996,
-0.563282311,
0.6188696027,
-0.3927088976,
0.3115029037,
0.0000051221,
-0.3634604812,
-0.2466459721,
0.4981250763,
-0.7044047117,
1.1666281223,
0.1292833835,
-0.6333582997,
0.2029264569,
-0.432302773,
-0.5446376801,
0.0895162672,
-0.2079386562,
-0.0026432287,
-0.0684397668,
0.3090311587,
0.1258218586,
-0.5242853761,
0.1091254875,
-0.0148856146,
0.1411655098,
0.0497065745,
-0.4309321642,
1.050521493,
-0.019622799,
-0.3279388547,
-0.1358957589,
-0.5567503572,
0.1949647367,
0.2510112226,
-0.3286584914,
-0.0011470144,
-0.2013220191,
0.6040691137,
0.1655216962,
0.5049202442,
-0.658108592,
-0.3406119049,
-0.5359889865,
0.5822845101,
0.4928762615,
-0.517077446,
0.5081596375,
-0.2694257796,
0.5193987489,
0.0870589837,
0.3646982312,
-0.3474007845,
-0.5865983367,
-0.5961049795,
-0.6967558265,
0.6589457989,
0.8894675374,
-0.0986487567,
0.235041514,
-0.2404192537,
-0.4584917426,
-0.4269892275,
0.4165524244,
0.2792445719,
0.4081313014,
0.411945343,
-0.2235670835,
0.0013531648,
-1.1318621635,
-0.5640782118,
0.0677188635,
0.1825476885,
-0.0129094375,
0.1988093406,
-0.2977164388,
0.7212116122,
-0.1034681723,
-0.2581815422,
-0.6524565816,
0.2193246335,
0.1166028157,
0.6524274349,
0.7231279612,
-0.7030482292,
-0.7092533708,
0.3320174813,
-0.6131016612,
0.0304004401,
0.3977866471,
-0.260677129,
0.3460174501,
0.3134545386,
-0.6820893288,
0.3186181188,
0.6508408785,
0.1007731855,
0.427763164,
-0.0013565974,
0.3071418107,
-1.0949727297,
-0.161278069,
-0.0329232737,
-0.5363301635,
-0.442034781,
0.1319150776,
0.3107724786,
-0.2144643515,
-0.7125583887,
0.8051759601,
-0.4084621072,
0.3034221828,
-0.0547954179,
0.0632004738,
0.3140226305,
0.4876832664,
0.2956463695,
0.4593241513,
0.5764331818,
-0.2682212889,
0.1032464504,
0.0254259687,
-0.2152235955,
0.332061559,
-0.6963031292,
-0.1100057736,
0.1674176157,
0.1507879794,
-0.7374058366,
-0.0850341246,
-0.1235512644,
-0.3785737455,
0.2488813102,
-0.230128482,
-0.6480083466,
-0.143996045,
-0.1477339566,
0.7965322137,
0.3436575234,
-0.7119091153,
0.8988729119,
0.2720217407,
-0.343467772,
-0.4399634302,
-1.0653537512,
-0.0474529788,
0.2157955766,
-0.9155659676,
0.0877636671,
-0.1160193309,
0.0058935974,
-0.0433898009,
-0.0479488373,
-0.4558190405,
-0.0471111983,
0.0990251228,
0.1244336441,
-0.544310689,
-0.2189363092,
-0.0093242852,
-0.1152492538,
0.1264117211,
-0.3564793169,
0.7011845112,
-0.1907755136,
-0.3833136559,
-0.5859165192,
0.3241550326,
0.5134776831,
-0.8103407025,
0.7496273518,
0.5707966089,
-0.8043355346,
-0.527993083,
-0.5789646506,
-0.0189832542,
-0.4052260518,
0.3525412083,
-0.3688658178,
-0.9124270082,
0.5381178856,
0.1042286009,
0.3343662918,
0.1634937525,
0.7782378197,
0.372756362,
1.1629952192,
0.6358687282,
-0.0099861212,
0.1927030683,
-0.2336524278,
0.5775356889,
-0.2844549417,
-0.3157838583,
-0.6767939329,
0.0554169901,
-0.2418063283,
-0.5360092521,
-0.0423693769,
0.4314029515,
0.0778579935,
0.525837481,
-0.3263399601,
0.6183016896,
0.2645367384,
-0.1369431913,
0.5470317602,
0.0713323355,
-0.3138697147,
-0.1881462783,
-0.7047565579,
-0.6791003942,
1.0860654116,
0.3970875442,
0.6094878912,
0.0444575176,
0.5373865366,
-0.0012209526,
0.4284176826,
-0.4570359588,
0.3445341587,
-0.087303631,
-0.6599555612,
0.0246548709,
-0.6186211109,
-0.7602251172,
0.2935388982,
-0.0089447666,
-0.6500582695,
-0.1658623815,
0.2056385428,
0.0107813068,
0.3172120452,
-0.8742966652,
1.2537685633,
-0.6676797271,
-0.4956593812,
-0.3169167936,
-0.1300409436,
0.5788211226,
-0.236874789,
0.4351089597,
-0.3982601166,
-0.0651648343,
0.3392172754,
-0.2861435711,
0.5556640029,
0.1351581067,
-0.0711482093,
-0.0727582052,
0.5686690807,
0.2839253545,
0.4154440165,
-0.0388302095,
0.9002480507,
0.3222014606,
-0.6571866274,
-0.3455046415,
1.07908535,
-0.8095771074,
-0.2220292687,
-0.3558033705,
-0.5632809997,
-0.3401931524,
0.2755054832,
0.3219020367,
0.5497640371,
-0.5266717672,
0.1076585725,
0.3525277972,
-0.1472835988,
0.326338917,
0.598664403,
-0.501394093,
-0.4289982915,
0.9172046185,
-0.0952347964,
0.2487470806,
0.4911773801,
0.0078550577,
-0.4264140725,
-0.3619922996,
-0.5623185635,
0.4376485348,
-0.410970211,
0.1569588333,
-1.1149893999,
-0.4015961885,
-0.5198382735,
-0.221125856,
-0.9598260522,
-0.6419833302,
-0.0606029592,
-0.072171241,
-0.0115836766,
0.5637441278,
0.2311231792,
0.0757187977,
-1.0564392805,
0.0988890007,
0.1631622463,
0.3107955754,
-0.157755062,
-0.3640313447,
-0.4603779912,
0.2553069592,
-0.2627828121,
-0.3774735928,
0.4144473672,
0.1162472665,
0.5967869759,
0.1585145593,
-0.2667535245,
0.1890424937,
-0.756274581,
1.0786584616,
0.2221221477,
-0.7515642047,
0.1897677183,
-0.3039897084,
0.2777331769,
0.5916649699,
0.6180256009,
-0.3652557135,
-0.5487428308,
-0.3264372945,
-0.9433428049,
0.6735118628,
0.3741931319,
0.2780334353,
-0.233179003,
-0.0589455366,
0.292965889,
0.3256218135,
-0.9445093274,
0.0443018302,
-0.4686749578,
-0.3676229417,
-0.1879868656,
0.049790673,
-0.3308161497,
-0.3806832433,
0.9042727351,
0.0840215683,
-0.0320713297,
0.0069898767,
-0.523450017,
-0.0761881918,
0.0016266558,
0.6099593043,
0.9992091656,
-0.0561608188,
0.0698387399,
-0.0718571767,
-0.3491398692,
-0.1087939888,
0.1629215777,
0.2228184938,
0.0075080143,
0.5306580663,
0.4776706696,
0.086197786,
-0.8072432876,
0.7851532102,
-0.3875486255,
-0.324174583,
-0.5163491368,
0.0012698661,
0.4825763404,
0.2094685882,
0.0823705718,
-0.0361807905,
-0.2518123686,
-0.4646427631,
0.1590415984,
0.4167011678,
-0.5321296453,
-0.727314651,
0.9410355687,
0.4028543234,
-0.6171514988,
0.2901996374,
0.0711788684,
-0.6555117965,
0.387466222,
0.4365016222,
1.0720564127,
-0.5198279619,
0.1913079768,
0.4716500938,
0.853502214,
-0.5011751056,
0.1602158099,
0.0137023134,
-0.7576252818,
-0.2019996494,
-0.8155648112,
-0.1779456735,
0.2260875106,
-0.6329938769,
0.3008205593,
-0.4733706415,
0.0125243329,
-0.2021360397,
-0.4000922441,
-0.7633737922,
0.1306836903,
-0.1452616304,
1.2805309296,
-0.858328104,
0.8632382751,
0.5096005797,
-0.1558554918,
-0.4873067141,
-0.1040657908,
-0.1320612133,
-0.6500189304,
0.5187030435,
0.2554992735,
-0.164630264,
-0.0979863331,
-0.1828950793,
-0.3847144544,
0.7844073176,
0.5965989828,
-0.574657917,
0.2546031475,
0.7555693388,
0.4147941768,
-0.5450527668,
0.2859872878,
0.5250432491,
0.3393401206,
-0.3748199642,
-0.9536363482,
-0.4240385592,
-0.40766716,
-0.1395900249,
0.3001199365,
-0.7163217068,
0.9363200068,
0.3301438689,
-0.1481136233,
0.0655067116,
0.4938971996,
-0.1801086813,
0.1088754907,
0.4157359302,
0.8015187979,
0.3624378145,
-0.2858937681,
1.1148548126,
-0.9877110124,
0.1893425137,
1.3130669594,
-0.7061089873,
0.8937322497,
0.3775200844,
0.1594940275,
0.2047151178,
0.5477378964,
0.5548167229,
0.2921600938,
-0.2319021672,
-0.424875319,
-0.5279586911,
-0.0641368553,
-0.4041915834,
0.1379490644,
0.1940600723,
-0.2162492275,
-0.3924939036,
0.1092472672,
0.005494053,
0.4209073186,
0.0925788879,
0.3495943248,
0.2412908971,
-0.4223378301,
0.693307519,
0.2295090705,
0.3824245334,
-0.8507254124,
0.0538894273,
-0.3353334665,
0.3425931633,
-0.0889182612,
-0.4716672599,
0.114807874,
-0.0492196381,
-0.1554813832,
-0.3136317134,
0.1819494516,
-0.8922163844,
-0.8029344678,
0.8785820603,
0.588912487,
-0.2283578813,
-0.071947284,
-0.9051608443,
0.3051173091,
-0.0517449267,
-0.3471540809,
0.1955558062,
0.5291099548,
-0.073834464,
0.5208102465,
0.6168928146,
0.1830254942,
0.3615426719,
0.2831383348,
0.5909836292,
-0.4304107726,
-0.5668014884,
-0.5912260413,
0.4444946945,
0.0497917086,
-0.4605990648,
0.7926924229,
1.2103792429,
1.2740197182,
-0.0399133749,
0.8509745598,
0.4224346578,
0.6375200152,
-0.3638886213,
0.5874094963,
-0.7405567169,
0.1690780073,
0.2154493034,
-1.18385005,
-0.2332153022,
0.3721656501,
-0.1552625597,
0.0746935979,
0.8722711205,
1.2346571684,
-0.6280402541,
0.389703095,
0.3303493857,
0.3780395985,
0.2536498308,
0.4650065303,
0.6984401345,
-0.4011751115,
0.4456438422,
-0.373642236,
-0.3628164828,
0.0172365457,
-0.7309088111,
-1.2935794592,
-0.4195491076,
-0.2958573997,
-0.2932586372,
0.0738944411,
1.0101817846,
0.8176061511,
-0.8532025814,
-0.6864234209,
-0.0370251276,
-0.1617592573,
-0.1456468552,
-0.2530580163,
-0.1179802343,
-0.4144048989,
-0.9328995347,
0.5410087705,
0.5803638697,
-0.191098094,
-0.2785702646,
-0.2469129264,
-0.223600924,
0.4714795649,
0.7470311522,
0.3220590055,
-0.5212686062,
0.1822215468,
-0.0217753127,
-0.3798188269,
0.10749764,
0.8771864772,
-0.1750611365,
0.3511452973,
0.4906731844,
0.7862600088,
0.8464685082,
-0.4116103649,
0.8093099594,
-0.5774156451,
0.5892980695,
0.3086878657,
0.3689925969,
0.4442926943,
-0.0364588536,
0.4534955919,
0.2175533175,
-0.406334728,
-1.0760043859,
0.196341157,
-0.9226302505,
-0.1436961591,
0.9155103564,
-0.1012297496,
-0.5667408705,
0.0252273437,
0.011715482,
-0.1038089916,
-0.2127067298,
0.4256550968,
0.7251132131,
0.1449606866,
-0.2300722301,
-0.9091086388,
0.4339184165,
0.5711242557,
-0.6292060614,
0.2053131908,
0.0700920373,
0.5701076388,
-0.0746585056,
0.6703697443,
-0.5392938852,
0.1767932624,
-0.396920979,
0.385427773,
-0.0036704761,
-0.6362064481,
-0.0904012918,
0.1192986295,
0.1269460022,
0.020625677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00746v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00746v6
|
Health-LLM: Personalized Retrieval-Augmented Disease Prediction System
| 2024-02-01T16:40:32 | 2024-03-19T22:12:19 |
Mingyu Jin, Qinkai Yu, Dong Shu, Chong Zhang, Lizhou Fan, Wenyue Hua, Suiyuan Zhu, Yanda Meng, Zhenting Wang, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), especially large
language models (LLMs), have significantly advanced healthcare applications and
demonstrated potentials in intelligent medical treatment. However, there are
conspicuous challenges such as vast data volumes and inconsistent symptom
characterization standards, preventing full integration of healthcare AI
systems with individual patients' needs. To promote professional and
personalized healthcare, we propose an innovative framework, Heath-LLM, which
combines large-scale feature extraction and medical knowledge trade-off
scoring. Compared to traditional health management applications, our system has
three main advantages: (1) It integrates health reports and medical knowledge
into a large model to ask relevant questions to large language model for
disease prediction; (2) It leverages a retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
mechanism to enhance feature extraction; (3) It incorporates a semi-automated
feature updating framework that can merge and delete features to improve
accuracy of disease prediction. We experiment on a large number of health
reports to assess the effectiveness of Health-LLM system. The results indicate
that the proposed system surpasses the existing ones and has the potential to
significantly advance disease prediction and personalized health management.
The code is available at https://github.com/jmyissb/HealthLLM.
|
[
-0.0654125884,
-0.676776886,
0.7089554667,
-0.1769342273,
-0.2177883834,
0.2546201944,
-0.0968611538,
-0.7101049423,
0.8416985273,
0.7194495201,
-0.1447325945,
-0.6422112584,
-0.5872975588,
-0.0045335954,
-0.185750857,
0.9811138511,
0.2576138973,
0.4038426876,
-0.4126662016,
-0.0907232165,
-0.2785033584,
-0.6278424859,
-0.4780828655,
-0.5948703885,
0.6669070721,
0.3583002388,
0.6492785215,
0.7256349325,
0.9338346124,
0.2124702632,
-0.0441071577,
0.2219543159,
-0.0877758488,
0.4081518948,
-0.1622581035,
-0.3595605791,
-0.800762713,
-0.2662725449,
0.3294359744,
0.621330142,
-0.1619395167,
0.2518234551,
-0.115579702,
0.8539315462,
-0.3779205084,
0.2157371938,
-0.3593018949,
0.2077596039,
-0.4012152553,
-0.466499269,
-0.0176141113,
-0.2659878135,
0.2458901554,
-0.2177647799,
-0.2950755954,
0.1804214269,
0.5163526535,
0.4516569674,
-0.3383718431,
-0.0444148481,
-0.5258216858,
0.5320798755,
-0.5907024741,
0.3521801531,
0.3224875927,
0.5688589215,
-0.1511844248,
-0.7597091794,
-0.0821155161,
-0.2936547399,
0.022788208,
0.3033344746,
0.0094067538,
0.0561463982,
-0.0951564386,
0.4807382226,
-0.6434512138,
0.2788893282,
-0.1948695183,
-0.1228362992,
0.8284873962,
0.3635680079,
0.3855355084,
-0.3789955676,
-0.3920687437,
0.3828499913,
-0.7819219828,
-0.2475986332,
-0.3573724031,
0.2725471854,
-0.0689395815,
0.5813823342,
-0.3273642361,
0.444650799,
-0.0293414965,
-0.5562434793,
0.5110520124,
0.1494665146,
-0.4037365317,
0.1427740306,
0.6450073719,
0.1896596253,
-0.2871604562,
-0.2987114489,
-0.1842250079,
-0.2185476124,
0.2009346783,
-0.7412012219,
-0.2324015051,
0.4871180058,
-0.7271764278,
-0.4526038766,
-0.239974916,
-0.7437189221,
-0.8201518655,
-0.1444455832,
0.3356209099,
-0.3902271986,
-0.0196886305,
0.072944425,
0.1469800919,
-0.1991992295,
0.4149426222,
-0.5775060058,
0.2040286064,
0.5774012208,
0.6329860091,
-0.6070520878,
0.1651786864,
-0.7164882421,
0.3909706473,
-0.0546080098,
0.6500723362,
-0.6095737815,
-0.3911102116,
-0.1266054958,
-0.1868156642,
0.1879843771,
-0.9657461643,
0.3273510933,
-0.5919325948,
0.09291327,
-0.0750074536,
-0.609906733,
-0.1401682645,
0.5516288877,
-0.7346268296,
0.6859149933,
0.3014680147,
-0.7377710342,
0.1560595632,
-0.6754877567,
-0.4799762964,
0.6574085951,
-0.2693218291,
-0.5323051214,
-0.0079441927,
0.0964502692,
0.5791134834,
-0.6975371838,
0.3567197621,
-0.4425220788,
-0.408816129,
0.1265177578,
-0.0105779273,
0.3492656052,
0.3417329788,
-0.1457594186,
0.2596788704,
-0.7743861079,
0.0618897192,
0.1835850179,
-0.573366046,
-0.3853058219,
0.0848423839,
-0.2080905885,
-0.0720041022,
0.5997596383,
-0.2327769101,
0.1800989062,
-0.6006698608,
0.2593573034,
0.4493968487,
0.1040613949,
0.3724796772,
-0.6897398233,
0.6393600106,
0.114222087,
0.2961114049,
-0.10170082,
-0.6437339783,
-0.1580073833,
-0.3956206441,
0.4016177952,
0.9074206352,
-0.4762685597,
0.7144466043,
-0.2563872337,
-0.2021382451,
-0.3651053309,
0.1034009829,
0.1805697232,
0.5911280513,
0.5044662952,
-0.2605292797,
-0.5121560693,
-0.6051667929,
-0.2095746994,
-0.1860260516,
-0.1247794181,
0.5113818049,
0.2757121325,
-0.7495120764,
0.6071093082,
-0.5597707033,
-0.4761339128,
-0.3895732164,
-0.3897546232,
0.2523046732,
0.3524864018,
0.207149595,
-0.9710798264,
-0.357006222,
0.2035693079,
-0.7878866792,
-0.0654876009,
0.4779922664,
-0.0131871318,
-0.2142649442,
0.1051136926,
-0.4046604633,
0.4454594553,
0.5256364346,
-0.144299984,
0.421377033,
-0.3737732768,
0.0800801739,
-1.3659230471,
0.2708616257,
-0.0644976646,
-0.4778966904,
-0.3953691125,
0.1439300776,
-0.1450445652,
-0.0949889794,
-0.2479171455,
0.9234746695,
-0.036851909,
0.0268336423,
-0.2472715229,
-0.1715660989,
-0.0336287618,
0.0156773217,
-0.2588371634,
0.3224171698,
0.3639185131,
-0.4723063111,
0.5533924699,
0.1950650811,
-0.31235677,
0.5072922707,
-0.4708923697,
0.0649914145,
-0.0051441523,
0.0507613346,
-0.3508123755,
-0.6705696583,
0.2357501239,
-0.424182266,
0.3574560285,
0.2340644151,
-0.3922567666,
-0.5526330471,
-0.3163775504,
0.1760637015,
0.7097324133,
-0.4350494742,
0.6065481305,
0.9157496691,
-0.2557841837,
-0.3694718778,
-0.694737494,
0.1607309282,
-0.3057398498,
-0.4025629461,
0.6383995414,
-0.1405722797,
-0.3691857457,
0.2035068423,
0.0513660572,
0.0065342449,
0.1799843758,
0.3710003495,
0.3794956505,
0.0568846129,
0.3672913611,
0.0688123778,
0.0082820104,
-0.0985870808,
-0.2120545805,
0.3433644772,
0.1582551599,
-0.4603303373,
-0.4515911043,
0.3032849133,
0.6667791605,
-0.2631137371,
0.4284108281,
0.3669038117,
-0.6463083029,
0.1472711712,
-0.5573413968,
-0.1614087671,
-0.3842091262,
0.5875694156,
-0.0727797225,
-0.9652204514,
0.4973436296,
-0.4756731391,
-0.1054620892,
0.3331961036,
0.6871257424,
-0.2993297577,
1.2798553705,
0.567525506,
-0.2865278423,
0.1632844061,
-0.012370659,
0.0013972956,
-0.8327370882,
-0.5608345866,
-0.3410863876,
-0.3574048877,
-0.6396014094,
-0.4036806822,
0.8622641563,
0.0320308246,
-0.4104740322,
-0.189166829,
-0.6198091507,
-0.1326627731,
0.3853414059,
0.5283441544,
0.3933780491,
-0.1728425622,
-0.2833966315,
0.0159613192,
-0.4364437163,
-0.3090752065,
1.0987919569,
0.4398570955,
0.7798778415,
0.1119660735,
1.0414899588,
0.7002626061,
0.4934151173,
-0.9395941496,
0.2435473204,
-0.6238663197,
-0.4738693833,
-0.1741759181,
-0.5066301227,
-0.8661564589,
-0.2052010894,
-0.4471225739,
-0.6772700548,
-0.1270325333,
0.2620659173,
-0.6263232231,
0.2580974102,
-0.4915252328,
0.4566637576,
-0.476359129,
-0.2140659392,
-0.2354808152,
-0.6630435586,
0.2228677869,
-0.2021630555,
0.4570521116,
-0.2743703425,
-0.1206303313,
0.6718899012,
-0.4078655243,
0.5963269472,
-0.0707441494,
0.2563855946,
-0.0907597691,
-0.0489024594,
0.3656922281,
0.2502844036,
-0.3375560343,
-0.0936066136,
0.0785513446,
-0.2155528665,
-0.4790344238,
0.7466747165,
-0.5040545464,
-0.6905716658,
-0.4567480683,
-0.5964788795,
-0.4682881236,
0.4537821412,
-0.0307333041,
0.3349340856,
-0.2088056654,
-0.0087908283,
0.5302718878,
-0.4563410878,
-0.0488606505,
0.3691552579,
-0.5215547085,
-0.7173358202,
0.9103537798,
-0.0165260471,
-0.1009456813,
0.6594898105,
0.6882825494,
-0.1522049457,
-0.7043347955,
-0.2850598991,
0.191136077,
-0.4652706087,
-0.5781959295,
-0.5249409676,
-0.3835099638,
-0.3803367913,
0.084461242,
0.015342975,
0.1087889224,
-0.3335658908,
0.1825787127,
0.4881180227,
0.9168099761,
-0.0353144817,
0.045075994,
-1.1269015074,
0.4150658548,
0.2418068945,
0.3319322765,
-0.279699266,
-0.4325113893,
-0.4184322357,
-0.0791940168,
-0.2221093923,
-0.8669208884,
0.7028834224,
0.107153818,
0.5904290676,
0.4659894705,
-0.018499475,
0.3515478671,
-0.5895095468,
0.5426194668,
0.4353719652,
-0.5285100937,
0.6110880971,
0.001751449,
0.3104814887,
0.4360845089,
0.3033488095,
-0.3883478642,
-0.159747526,
-0.4062957168,
-0.4972572029,
0.1807117611,
-0.5379107594,
-0.1896356791,
-0.0669968426,
0.6389172673,
0.1211139932,
0.1494172662,
-0.1918169111,
-0.2947222888,
0.224309966,
-0.5621535778,
0.1477217376,
-0.2974842191,
-0.2468812466,
-0.3974479139,
0.5132388473,
-0.33241117,
0.3026120961,
0.2744302452,
-0.0267417543,
-0.193571493,
0.2530109882,
0.2005281448,
0.6281327605,
-0.319409132,
0.081367448,
0.1949045658,
-0.596239388,
-0.1023072675,
0.2868800163,
-0.1681628823,
-0.120988749,
0.3068359494,
0.5291540623,
0.3188879788,
-0.8513720632,
0.4163815975,
0.2323461175,
-0.0049815527,
-0.2931975722,
0.1078510284,
0.2759216726,
0.4382025301,
0.3920918107,
0.1675358415,
0.4930379391,
-0.4678041637,
0.3856210709,
0.4790099263,
-0.4714458585,
-0.3179722726,
0.7867836356,
0.1908404827,
-0.387862891,
0.288431704,
-0.1357252002,
-0.4028661251,
0.5221809149,
0.3375722468,
0.4317027926,
-0.4378939569,
0.1481856853,
0.0442483313,
-0.2397105694,
-0.1435077488,
0.5246362686,
0.4246166945,
-0.5282188654,
-0.6078537107,
-0.8050971627,
-0.4935764968,
0.2533396482,
-0.4887130558,
0.4866523445,
-0.3040483594,
-0.2681747079,
0.0450452603,
0.2768523693,
-0.5349429846,
0.4492906034,
0.4317430258,
0.8777065277,
-0.2087720633,
1.0687898397,
0.816300869,
-0.2447749823,
-0.5903189778,
0.1053637937,
0.1106088236,
-1.0015797615,
0.5457730293,
0.0864286497,
0.2513855994,
-0.1473600566,
-0.283223331,
-0.9585316181,
1.1423614025,
0.4592088759,
-0.7667444348,
-0.2928076386,
-0.0613183156,
0.419407934,
-0.4743985236,
0.0990563929,
0.5461497307,
0.4672442675,
0.2611063421,
-1.1152443886,
0.0219723452,
0.0484135076,
-0.0466284752,
0.1444783211,
-0.5261728168,
0.5807079673,
-0.619866848,
0.1386472285,
0.2569314539,
0.4439869821,
0.3403154314,
0.5036127567,
0.2716526091,
0.7520187497,
0.9897555709,
0.1683810502,
1.0420823097,
-0.535159409,
0.2855885029,
0.8655549884,
-0.5036753416,
0.7520583868,
0.1226775572,
-0.3471486568,
0.4275122285,
0.6111941934,
0.2165436298,
0.6579273939,
0.2009916157,
-0.5389737487,
-0.1441579908,
-0.213973999,
-0.5110843778,
0.5934348106,
0.5059530139,
-0.5233644247,
0.0348866917,
0.3159894645,
-0.096457392,
0.017029902,
-0.5191001892,
0.9080119729,
0.147700727,
-0.2046455592,
0.3123887777,
-0.1085980907,
0.7643614411,
-0.477224201,
-0.2611883581,
-0.0271996763,
0.1335887164,
-0.3053747118,
-0.6390227675,
0.2976011336,
-0.3475093544,
-0.3992307782,
-0.0272575244,
0.8841629624,
-0.4687131941,
-0.40483585,
0.4256561399,
0.7246787548,
0.2101782113,
0.1068267897,
-0.7998554707,
0.0261994265,
-0.1756534427,
-0.0357547477,
0.5634045005,
0.1921364814,
-0.0098870359,
0.6411120296,
0.5345786214,
0.6417009234,
-0.3734485507,
0.0768083557,
0.7686269283,
-0.6331110597,
-0.3633078635,
-0.7269544601,
0.0767004639,
-0.0943365619,
0.0652239993,
0.2749313116,
0.5261896849,
0.2043704242,
0.179852128,
1.0293160677,
0.0388550796,
1.1279425621,
-0.243042767,
0.854719758,
-0.8135434985,
0.3259223402,
0.1329421699,
-0.4920781255,
-0.6050775647,
0.0483968928,
-0.2230043411,
0.0597428866,
0.5762135386,
0.3852988482,
0.2164926827,
-0.2642566562,
0.6411456466,
0.2997567356,
0.4161677659,
0.444198966,
0.3643964827,
0.0404281057,
0.0279374793,
-0.3297692537,
-0.3975977004,
-0.6326524615,
-0.6502087116,
-0.465287745,
-0.3439897299,
-0.2138559818,
-0.3872857094,
0.2769770324,
1.190988183,
0.8243099451,
-0.8834972382,
0.1359515935,
0.352142334,
0.1324348748,
-0.1347203851,
-0.1579957902,
0.4325867891,
-0.0973011106,
-0.4362992346,
0.5450532436,
0.6164736748,
-0.242286548,
-0.2755866349,
-0.2549762726,
-0.0026807534,
-0.1691331267,
0.6392695308,
0.3393955529,
-0.67123878,
-0.2056844682,
0.158544451,
-0.3204120994,
0.1839481294,
0.5834743381,
-0.9033135176,
0.4369828403,
0.3175680935,
0.9037015438,
0.2039872855,
-0.096723251,
0.2717123628,
-0.1388651431,
-0.075219743,
0.6587656736,
0.4567519724,
0.3504016697,
-0.8480971456,
0.2547892034,
0.3666240275,
-0.5691479445,
-0.6330443621,
0.0066457354,
-0.913895309,
-0.2181457728,
1.0180262327,
-0.0819262937,
-0.3155693412,
-0.1418204755,
0.0119509855,
0.240017131,
-0.169476971,
0.7871268392,
0.0883334577,
-0.6803407073,
0.0731319338,
-0.5912219882,
0.4852668047,
0.2841812372,
-1.1822943687,
-0.3971384466,
0.2023115009,
0.4280946255,
0.0854797736,
0.7648326159,
-0.3840715289,
0.3974086344,
-0.7196798921,
0.1018576622,
-0.0357851014,
-0.2131009698,
-0.208439216,
0.1515130401,
0.0868856832,
-0.0976093933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00745v1
|
Enhancing Ethical Explanations of Large Language Models through Iterative Symbolic Refinement
| 2024-02-01T16:39:51 | 2024-02-01T16:39:51 |
Xin Quan, Marco Valentino, Louise A. Dennis, André Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An increasing amount of research in Natural Language Inference (NLI) focuses
on the application and evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
reasoning capabilities. Despite their success, however, LLMs are still prone to
factual errors and inconsistencies in their explanations, offering limited
control and interpretability for inference in complex domains. In this paper,
we focus on ethical NLI, investigating how hybrid neuro-symbolic techniques can
enhance the logical validity and alignment of ethical explanations produced by
LLMs. Specifically, we present an abductive-deductive framework named
Logic-Explainer, which integrates LLMs with an external backward-chaining
solver to refine step-wise natural language explanations and jointly verify
their correctness, reduce incompleteness and minimise redundancy. An extensive
empirical analysis demonstrates that Logic-Explainer can improve explanations
generated via in-context learning methods and Chain-of-Thought (CoT) on
challenging ethical NLI tasks, while, at the same time, producing formal proofs
describing and supporting models' reasoning. As ethical NLI requires
commonsense reasoning to identify underlying moral violations, our results
suggest the effectiveness of neuro-symbolic methods for multi-step NLI more
broadly, opening new opportunities to enhance the logical consistency,
reliability, and alignment of LLMs.
|
[
-0.0533210561,
-0.7966789007,
0.7146993279,
0.0037853734,
-0.3459655046,
0.1040345356,
-0.349183768,
-0.434425205,
-0.0656007677,
0.4356217086,
-0.775610745,
-0.3097149134,
-0.4498698711,
0.4218351841,
-0.2256911993,
0.925670445,
0.0145114101,
0.3182827532,
-0.1096461862,
-0.2535695136,
-0.4402452707,
-0.2501569986,
-1.0038269758,
-0.6448287964,
0.453220129,
0.0157596655,
0.7859725952,
0.7128818035,
0.0800119862,
0.384644866,
-0.181844905,
0.1958120018,
-0.5305788517,
-0.0708186999,
-0.5862315893,
-0.3066397607,
-0.2515497506,
-0.0438165031,
0.4289637506,
0.6745372415,
-0.3242554069,
0.1301499456,
-0.0728922561,
0.6385300159,
-0.6835665703,
-0.1785465181,
-0.7030887008,
-0.1315325648,
0.3329757452,
-0.4060337543,
-0.6015673876,
-0.6704879999,
0.0457020737,
-0.7542558312,
-0.0224534422,
0.0945854485,
0.7896211743,
0.3284059465,
-0.3349407017,
-0.2432732582,
-0.7766017914,
1.2657419443,
-1.1268917322,
0.3803946674,
0.2282448262,
0.165162459,
-0.2417612821,
-0.4528725445,
-0.860830605,
-0.1287820935,
-0.302428335,
-0.01702426,
-0.1627542228,
0.1897879839,
0.3758908808,
0.2076594234,
-0.3398738205,
0.4031580985,
-0.2742809355,
-0.0884302482,
0.7943273783,
0.0984156579,
0.2860428095,
-0.0171834286,
-0.1180318221,
0.1683040559,
-0.7904675007,
-0.1565269977,
0.5606439114,
0.1092796475,
0.0608702749,
0.3534592986,
0.1239877716,
0.7013664842,
0.0751236007,
-0.1030445471,
0.1436612308,
-0.5531413555,
-0.2890455127,
0.3997285366,
0.6408185363,
0.5936883688,
0.6098170877,
-0.1459840089,
-0.1385332197,
0.275614351,
0.3706423342,
-0.6366096139,
0.0900872499,
0.6466768384,
-0.7326144576,
-0.3733291924,
-0.0890666097,
-0.5550253391,
-0.531989038,
-0.8491404057,
0.3068116903,
-0.6122596264,
-0.3716700673,
0.4794233739,
-0.267054677,
0.3900592327,
0.434876889,
-0.5419187546,
0.3561754227,
0.965844512,
0.5526394844,
0.2589080036,
-0.156236887,
-0.6282638311,
0.3670744896,
-0.378595978,
0.2797881663,
-0.6935631037,
0.0023695701,
-0.17500633,
0.0826725811,
-0.0390920416,
-0.3739022315,
0.5962128043,
-0.4284985662,
0.2733452618,
-0.3567537069,
-0.4444569349,
-0.6177957058,
0.2056314796,
-0.5285775661,
0.7147346139,
-0.3530359566,
-0.7043594122,
0.3022407591,
-0.7686648369,
-0.5207791328,
-0.1408082843,
-0.2715170085,
-0.2694844007,
0.1930120438,
0.254178077,
0.2080042213,
-0.5812548399,
0.7643687725,
-0.3504284024,
-0.5198689103,
0.252681464,
-0.4638189673,
1.3190748692,
-0.0494665243,
-0.5616893172,
0.3640649319,
-0.8488615155,
0.0161841922,
0.3427144587,
0.253870666,
-0.5364474654,
0.0964392126,
-0.2155323625,
0.396951139,
-0.0468837246,
-0.6824233532,
-0.3563224375,
-0.6053857207,
0.6343678832,
0.9981521964,
-0.0729601085,
0.4364022911,
-0.4190068543,
0.2486437112,
-0.1657170504,
0.2854080498,
0.0240143798,
-0.3296171427,
-0.6268882751,
-0.1980793029,
0.0584328659,
0.5288766026,
-0.5719742179,
0.667948246,
-0.3176012635,
-0.01686294,
-0.6649708748,
-0.0620124191,
0.3959596455,
0.6654681563,
0.3423677683,
0.148827821,
-0.4973722398,
-1.1060156822,
-0.5791166425,
-0.1689274162,
-0.1473864913,
0.0140388198,
0.8031109571,
-0.0780569762,
0.7903251052,
0.2973329127,
0.349627167,
-0.2025969476,
0.1633120477,
0.3528895676,
0.5662640929,
0.1428575516,
-0.8506632447,
0.2714630365,
-0.1228252128,
-0.8451195359,
-0.1163211539,
-0.4578756392,
-0.2422720492,
0.125392288,
0.1906255186,
-0.4341171682,
0.4965836108,
0.3053981662,
-0.2481705993,
0.5317873955,
-0.2435123771,
0.1316196322,
-0.9041048884,
0.0250140857,
-0.056131959,
-0.1230003685,
-0.5969567299,
0.1948391944,
-0.1040347517,
0.2827397585,
-0.2626626194,
0.4079203904,
-0.3466322422,
0.0937084705,
-0.2668720186,
0.3665085435,
0.0990620032,
0.3464456499,
0.056652721,
0.361297667,
0.563262701,
-0.5786898732,
0.2012142241,
0.1590104252,
0.1876952946,
0.6839994788,
-0.7973327637,
0.1674562246,
-0.4067872167,
0.63048774,
-0.692748487,
0.0812021643,
0.3232665062,
-0.1491393298,
-0.1759771407,
-0.1422210038,
-0.7608779669,
-0.1831422299,
-0.5348621011,
0.5195866227,
0.4338382781,
-0.8513414264,
1.1900291443,
-0.0324065983,
0.2140158415,
-0.7853391767,
-0.7600021362,
0.1854406595,
-0.3106047809,
-0.6711485982,
0.317055434,
-0.0079888981,
-0.6851959825,
0.0114194164,
-0.4468363225,
0.0693538561,
0.1890939176,
0.144452855,
0.3503092527,
-0.2766243517,
0.141945377,
0.2654609978,
-0.2601921856,
0.4289131165,
-0.3744207025,
0.2786243856,
-0.3805749416,
-0.4373571873,
-0.7049716115,
0.4918433428,
0.4387865961,
-0.3773994744,
0.8787581325,
0.3292824924,
-0.6708641052,
-0.284938097,
-0.7167825103,
-0.5381222367,
-0.4674783051,
-0.0374515355,
-0.1454749852,
-0.7906500101,
0.4093720615,
-0.2687704563,
0.3738039136,
0.3587440252,
0.2807307541,
0.1910512596,
0.9710921645,
0.4172461629,
0.2768402994,
-0.03987322,
-0.0977227539,
0.611497879,
-0.7279450893,
-0.2610273659,
-0.3625326455,
-0.4162096381,
-0.7318951488,
-0.234511137,
-0.0884750783,
0.1810679585,
-0.50699085,
0.0959428102,
-0.5642792583,
0.8815563917,
0.3460926712,
0.1190193146,
0.6499350071,
-0.0795811117,
-0.0160411038,
0.1349630654,
-0.4892396629,
-0.8593549132,
0.5261198282,
0.3239229918,
0.6092059016,
0.2167679667,
0.724431932,
-0.2142682374,
0.3625019789,
-0.5935503244,
0.6431381106,
-0.0840856582,
-0.4318707585,
-0.1032722071,
-0.5154870152,
-0.6211988926,
0.3149572015,
-0.2331063002,
-1.1541343927,
0.2528473437,
0.2429062426,
-0.3778620064,
0.3456248343,
-0.5683642626,
0.8238561749,
-0.4523688555,
-0.4557639658,
-0.6803094745,
-0.8777937293,
0.4205209911,
-0.0677554458,
0.2346195728,
0.0191941112,
-0.0437729061,
0.6649994254,
-0.5777415633,
0.9301530719,
-0.0413765088,
-0.4031946659,
0.029247012,
0.2249597907,
0.595084846,
0.2515366673,
-0.4100338519,
0.3051919937,
-0.094226338,
-0.2479079217,
-0.9111807942,
0.6765571237,
-0.2266564667,
-0.780144155,
-0.2351175547,
-0.671623826,
-0.237041682,
0.1711065173,
0.0072441814,
0.4625270069,
0.2630423903,
0.029469911,
0.7565461397,
-0.5709429979,
0.2809608579,
0.4349775612,
-0.0158571731,
-0.2071604133,
0.7118659616,
-0.4356397986,
0.3223096728,
0.2069425583,
0.6164381504,
-0.4465942383,
-0.5809022784,
-0.3945240676,
0.6217717528,
-0.9194760323,
0.1179144755,
-0.5548809171,
-0.0929582119,
-0.0165805705,
-0.4279244542,
-0.1667613238,
-0.4189173877,
0.0191184245,
-0.2403348386,
0.6541658044,
0.5182961226,
0.0555162206,
0.1139281169,
-0.5325336456,
0.4663678408,
-0.1129827723,
0.4439949989,
0.2601349354,
-0.4338697493,
0.4374194741,
0.3032791317,
0.0202111714,
-0.6814808846,
0.0195077471,
-0.0461636558,
0.335048914,
0.2563515902,
0.081460245,
1.0578161478,
-0.5482594967,
0.5037240386,
0.3168719113,
-1.1192677021,
0.5179214478,
-0.256595701,
0.113112703,
0.5564041138,
0.3613706529,
-0.3655533195,
-0.7107735872,
-0.6440715194,
-0.900791347,
0.5693225861,
0.3658745885,
0.0696889684,
-0.0457108133,
0.4285275638,
0.3371685147,
0.0867426023,
-0.7904928327,
-0.1632829756,
0.0899851546,
-0.4414922595,
0.365460366,
0.1236176938,
-0.4577536881,
-0.3799295425,
0.8952418566,
-0.2451331317,
-0.0155759705,
0.1390233636,
-0.1017898545,
-0.0841129944,
0.4143823981,
0.5113393068,
1.1501309872,
0.0802428126,
0.1457114369,
0.2708285451,
0.0003798992,
0.1261984408,
0.1883091629,
0.0029629313,
-0.0520698316,
0.3724030554,
0.4684469402,
0.0346319899,
-0.8253743052,
0.3928965628,
-0.0287213344,
-0.0433172807,
-0.3361209631,
-0.1804997176,
0.1725322157,
0.23964113,
0.1623372734,
0.0750702322,
0.2198863924,
-0.3830800653,
0.1312510371,
0.5030584931,
0.0759523883,
-0.1357093453,
0.6402460933,
0.0330603644,
-0.2245147973,
0.7016890645,
-0.0495139845,
-0.4370003939,
0.6535518765,
0.7436459064,
0.8724420071,
0.0617437065,
0.2314637154,
0.342301935,
0.5423978567,
-0.267613709,
0.338614136,
-0.0961610302,
-0.8079506159,
-1.0201357603,
-0.3511116803,
-0.2640836537,
0.2206805497,
-0.5485979319,
0.0008489381,
-0.5428724289,
0.27732867,
0.1320445389,
-0.50998348,
-0.2554861307,
0.1576418132,
0.0509013124,
0.7837545872,
-0.6846386194,
0.4415941238,
0.340911597,
-0.3094375432,
-0.77338624,
0.1689565182,
0.2249555737,
-0.7263146639,
0.7060042024,
0.390165776,
-0.81296134,
-0.1646439582,
-0.5859283805,
-0.4830706716,
0.8329931498,
0.5996305346,
-0.7248436809,
-0.0328843184,
0.0610032678,
0.5616688728,
-0.1218709424,
0.2981797457,
0.5542547107,
0.6356434822,
-0.0112199718,
-0.7516000867,
0.7173489332,
-0.2370763421,
0.0502622351,
0.4251146019,
-0.1591225266,
0.3269514441,
-0.452370435,
-0.2534659505,
0.1031811908,
0.4232046008,
0.5989901423,
0.3700962365,
0.8214578032,
0.5297748446,
0.950963378,
-0.0367450863,
1.1456304789,
-0.1339884847,
-0.0023002077,
1.1756595373,
-0.3236107826,
0.5190140009,
0.81401366,
0.3981050849,
0.755028367,
0.3761300147,
-0.023966996,
0.0670175478,
0.4843783677,
-0.2333867699,
-0.3787989616,
-0.3646619022,
0.0395591371,
0.2270884663,
0.2258642614,
-0.5321933627,
-0.3132577538,
-0.1716161817,
0.0415184237,
0.2511286438,
-0.1941267401,
0.538051188,
0.1378572136,
-0.5596177578,
0.70859164,
0.0276038498,
0.5772327185,
-0.378326416,
-0.3368607461,
0.1492796838,
0.2178732008,
-0.3372204006,
-0.6264932156,
0.4380631149,
0.1628644168,
0.0680372715,
-0.5349197388,
0.5258448124,
-0.2654588521,
-0.3789093196,
0.4927154779,
0.3090028167,
-0.0243380871,
0.1607794762,
-0.8835451603,
0.0065992014,
-0.1777936965,
0.0369592756,
-0.189444527,
0.5009250641,
-0.3168504834,
0.7972698212,
0.7335776091,
-0.1199015006,
-0.2722134888,
0.4885601401,
0.6815162301,
-0.8078100681,
-0.4015703797,
-1.2764256001,
0.6016234159,
-0.3562259972,
-0.119105272,
0.4928307533,
0.3877277076,
0.8370702267,
0.0798180103,
0.5300971866,
0.0181542989,
-0.0144757032,
-0.7509604692,
0.4369912446,
-0.4922770858,
0.4088786244,
-0.1642576307,
-0.6592540145,
-0.3920700848,
0.8036081791,
-0.4537889063,
0.2102756351,
0.9334008694,
0.8938503861,
-0.1669889838,
0.6706690788,
-0.0978471413,
0.3290777802,
0.1093975455,
0.4382126629,
1.0665769577,
-0.2549585998,
0.3230071366,
-0.3591812551,
-0.1592273116,
0.3879265189,
-1.304659009,
-0.7991477847,
-0.2037488222,
-0.6386262774,
-0.3372345567,
0.2135800868,
1.0629265308,
0.5596151948,
-0.7843658328,
-0.228916809,
-0.5820633769,
0.3105089068,
-0.5973960161,
-0.2889319658,
0.1875100583,
-0.0759155154,
-0.4797119498,
0.4510356486,
0.3704304993,
-0.4600196779,
0.0056295991,
-0.0831632093,
-0.3284761012,
0.2952639759,
0.6026533842,
0.00966994,
-1.2681707144,
-0.3198225498,
-0.2621960044,
0.3599438071,
0.015744511,
1.0116615295,
-0.733183682,
0.1789744347,
0.3231213391,
0.8615496159,
-0.1385363638,
0.0588648245,
0.917519331,
-0.3663821518,
-0.0759752765,
0.4791263044,
0.463920176,
0.3209745288,
-0.4135122597,
0.4736448526,
-0.0210634004,
-0.2340960205,
-0.8242990971,
0.3735069633,
-1.0156489611,
-0.4586416781,
1.1826308966,
0.1807852089,
-0.4255386889,
-0.2333425134,
-0.1796464771,
0.2315193564,
-0.3302896917,
0.6797064543,
0.4554312229,
-0.0262851138,
-0.1718918383,
-0.4887779951,
0.2671796083,
0.5946344137,
-0.9721938372,
0.4202836752,
0.6113082767,
0.3372783959,
0.1462268084,
0.2146441638,
-0.3759887815,
0.4093289673,
-0.3291809559,
-0.1664406806,
-0.0356825292,
-0.0863787979,
-0.5519975424,
-0.2915145457,
-0.3433823287,
0.0072965459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00744v1
|
BATON: Aligning Text-to-Audio Model with Human Preference Feedback
| 2024-02-01T16:39:47 | 2024-02-01T16:39:47 |
Huan Liao, Haonan Han, Kai Yang, Tianjiao Du, Rui Yang, Zunnan Xu, Qinmei Xu, Jingquan Liu, Jiasheng Lu, Xiu Li
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
With the development of AI-Generated Content (AIGC), text-to-audio models are
gaining widespread attention. However, it is challenging for these models to
generate audio aligned with human preference due to the inherent information
density of natural language and limited model understanding ability. To
alleviate this issue, we formulate the BATON, a framework designed to enhance
the alignment between generated audio and text prompt using human preference
feedback. Our BATON comprises three key stages: Firstly, we curated a dataset
containing both prompts and the corresponding generated audio, which was then
annotated based on human feedback. Secondly, we introduced a reward model using
the constructed dataset, which can mimic human preference by assigning rewards
to input text-audio pairs. Finally, we employed the reward model to fine-tune
an off-the-shelf text-to-audio model. The experiment results demonstrate that
our BATON can significantly improve the generation quality of the original
text-to-audio models, concerning audio integrity, temporal relationship, and
alignment with human preference.
|
[
-0.396428287,
-0.3917793632,
0.4167574942,
0.1649775207,
-0.2552856505,
0.1309873164,
-0.2772824764,
-0.3253874183,
0.2852382958,
0.5761445165,
-0.5211280584,
-0.5840503573,
-0.4812760055,
0.0045766956,
-0.4302080274,
1.2312262058,
0.2041717768,
-0.0214913879,
0.0118987858,
-0.2071234435,
-0.8926741481,
-0.2528992593,
-0.8854685426,
-0.4348274171,
0.5483645797,
0.5499290824,
0.7165948749,
0.8243332505,
0.3908322752,
0.1444355398,
0.1630794555,
0.19644849,
-0.1731897891,
0.0408605002,
-0.1233326942,
-0.0283981301,
-0.7968248129,
0.2562182844,
0.2978161275,
0.1879924685,
-0.2535144985,
0.2360147387,
0.3021073639,
0.7948566675,
-0.2791361511,
-0.2667476535,
-0.509518981,
-0.2557728589,
-0.163533479,
-0.6595522761,
-0.527195096,
-0.3937504888,
0.0932427794,
-0.7221198678,
0.2918701172,
0.4285401702,
0.8047376275,
0.4723672271,
-0.5531560779,
-0.3159148991,
-0.8376640677,
0.5532329679,
-0.5867762566,
0.2278657854,
0.6012802124,
0.5268322229,
0.2095845789,
-0.4576982856,
-0.7085710764,
-0.2192495167,
0.2008889914,
0.3425456583,
0.4617687762,
0.0954270512,
-0.0699469671,
0.0530533865,
-0.4303970635,
0.1804469824,
0.0282159019,
-0.0707218498,
1.0620838404,
0.3348099887,
0.5100121498,
-0.2452260256,
-0.5539008379,
-0.2844640613,
-0.6997138858,
0.5301226974,
0.9653881192,
0.6103949547,
-0.3573463559,
0.6529453397,
0.1398048103,
0.8173359632,
0.5674365759,
-0.1679904759,
0.0556891076,
-0.49027583,
0.0796706676,
0.6904960275,
1.0402419567,
0.8549228311,
0.1511358321,
-0.025116777,
-0.41637972,
-0.0733285099,
0.7143111229,
-0.6555038095,
-0.277341187,
0.4145341516,
-0.4538419843,
-0.5027159452,
0.089198254,
-0.5055500269,
-0.688621223,
-0.6332283616,
0.4213100076,
-0.3794879317,
-0.1432001889,
0.1111677885,
-0.2065432072,
-0.1335119903,
0.536411643,
-1.5914552212,
0.1882107109,
0.6117747426,
0.8716220856,
-0.346816808,
0.0098744547,
-0.7373757958,
0.3629920781,
-0.180869475,
0.8874134421,
-0.3984697759,
-0.4104863703,
-0.1456716061,
-0.3936266005,
0.258427918,
-0.5139685273,
0.8630552292,
-0.2934155464,
0.2167521417,
-0.226455614,
-0.6592968702,
0.3176047504,
-0.0473661795,
-0.6675984263,
1.1348040104,
0.1498569697,
-0.7397572398,
0.5572681427,
-0.7452839613,
-0.4781536162,
0.0290994849,
-0.2084338367,
-0.5241655707,
-0.3213901818,
0.5687482953,
0.2190005779,
-0.6576243043,
0.6169480085,
-0.2094142735,
-0.4683772624,
0.3055839241,
-0.41420573,
0.7371115685,
0.0576589704,
-0.3969266117,
0.5457687974,
-0.7706204057,
-0.1933882236,
-0.1890361309,
-0.1914456338,
-0.0796969086,
0.1456786841,
0.5787861943,
-0.0045369533,
0.0765881389,
-0.614105165,
0.2022592723,
-0.3528312147,
0.5076068044,
0.9138316512,
-0.0448494479,
1.0117813349,
-0.6468308568,
0.4159526825,
-0.2128425688,
0.0252546649,
-0.0920492783,
-0.337177217,
-0.0677958503,
-0.3385010362,
0.6052407026,
0.4945100248,
-0.2532781661,
0.7411261797,
-0.1990558356,
-0.3912868202,
-1.1574840546,
0.1374350041,
-0.0351755545,
0.8590243459,
0.4898997843,
-0.363132447,
-0.463801235,
-0.7165083885,
-0.0002056924,
-0.2850345373,
-0.4848538935,
0.5144808888,
-0.0755317584,
0.0326878838,
1.4584863186,
-0.2222032994,
-0.5112438798,
-0.113349624,
0.4310057163,
0.1224196628,
0.5907323956,
0.6638898253,
-0.8811730742,
-0.4438684285,
-0.1196618527,
-0.3836330473,
-0.4832638204,
-0.3323834836,
-0.1109905094,
-0.2457144409,
0.2499414384,
-0.3473865986,
0.1647894681,
0.3755295873,
-0.1714200228,
0.7717324495,
0.0993984342,
0.6182206273,
-1.2599775791,
0.1167756245,
0.0550014265,
-0.2709314525,
-0.4635277092,
-0.6996150613,
0.1232656687,
-0.1086378545,
-0.1493073851,
1.0062180758,
-0.0453506708,
0.0212832671,
-0.5919124484,
0.5784267187,
0.2413944304,
0.3200823963,
0.2739026546,
0.940607965,
0.2614126503,
-0.693566978,
0.5523854494,
0.5662873983,
-0.2681002319,
0.9425433874,
-0.8698678613,
0.1446508318,
0.1585420519,
0.3036960661,
-1.1114183664,
-0.3722387254,
0.1279080063,
-0.8786135316,
0.3015640378,
-0.1562950611,
-0.2492071092,
-0.1140737608,
-0.3932963014,
0.6542508006,
0.3817073703,
-0.8231330514,
0.4571423531,
0.5491529107,
-0.4673814774,
-0.5335214734,
-0.3504302204,
0.0685869977,
-0.3673906922,
-0.5796338916,
0.6609014869,
-0.2120636851,
-0.1514963806,
-0.2675063312,
0.0307140909,
0.1609164029,
-0.0215511266,
0.4693252742,
0.6459352374,
-0.1227665022,
0.3629920781,
0.2686798871,
-0.2343913764,
0.0279575381,
-0.249128744,
0.4502047896,
0.4055988789,
-0.3227314651,
-0.5911980867,
0.3241141438,
0.1781251729,
-0.413952291,
0.3222780824,
0.5490718484,
0.0191867519,
-0.0813620687,
-0.2574470639,
-0.3041524887,
-0.5464564562,
0.1033598557,
0.0977158546,
-0.692592144,
0.196071595,
0.1182164103,
0.1640723497,
0.116281487,
0.6342879534,
-0.5137887597,
1.3548532724,
0.363985002,
-0.2499411851,
0.7463874817,
0.0971243232,
0.1291875988,
-1.0038850307,
-0.1934991628,
-0.6601945162,
-0.4762889445,
-0.1486798823,
0.2304650694,
0.4090886712,
0.1724203974,
-0.5974757075,
0.4081348777,
-0.7293303609,
0.041303549,
0.7157794237,
0.2888252735,
0.0844743773,
-0.227087155,
0.043686185,
-0.0458139442,
-0.4753815532,
-0.8421507478,
1.1272655725,
0.2612152994,
0.7507003546,
0.197341308,
0.8587935567,
0.5785064101,
0.2020119578,
-0.8719409108,
0.2193039805,
0.1487071514,
-0.3929851353,
-0.507992208,
-0.3170973659,
-0.9223556519,
-0.4320320189,
-0.4929680228,
-0.886549592,
-0.192208156,
0.5180377364,
-0.6410152316,
0.0398313627,
-0.5545013547,
0.7023252845,
-0.2757353783,
-0.5562924743,
0.1296499521,
-0.7717174888,
0.1497184783,
0.274766624,
0.176651448,
-0.2298725396,
0.2207529843,
0.8378377557,
-0.5133328438,
0.5931912661,
-0.1122454405,
-0.4348322451,
0.4141037166,
-0.2165489346,
0.4403700829,
0.4556147754,
-0.1219300106,
-0.3277814686,
-0.4793929458,
-0.1952796727,
-0.9013499022,
0.345656395,
-0.7779074311,
-0.5251953006,
0.0752182454,
-0.8485283256,
-0.3395633996,
0.0289773326,
0.5735782981,
0.9422371984,
-0.1550753862,
-0.2410486042,
0.5118030906,
-0.0823664144,
0.5686083436,
0.1639316082,
-0.3468470573,
-0.6603099108,
0.9462381601,
-0.3569083214,
0.2894878387,
0.4671717286,
0.0371637046,
-0.6646549106,
-0.5728737712,
-0.8548731208,
-0.107875295,
-0.2050332278,
-0.2467177212,
-0.3776502609,
-0.1332533062,
-0.681096971,
-0.5655509233,
-0.4709477425,
-0.4812972546,
-0.5654687881,
-0.1098769754,
0.618088603,
0.5067178011,
0.0850146338,
0.6693891883,
-1.1026017666,
0.647595048,
0.2233174741,
0.3186822534,
-0.0457475595,
-0.853944838,
-0.3555805385,
0.2386574596,
-0.4293291271,
-0.8500140309,
0.3250995576,
-0.1665668339,
0.1114356369,
0.4461152852,
0.3737390339,
0.3547570407,
-0.5605970025,
0.9812079668,
0.5660459399,
-0.9701586962,
0.5211115479,
-0.8010669947,
0.1902034581,
0.5846514106,
-0.0617214143,
-0.4857019782,
-0.3469255269,
-0.4587807059,
-0.9070235491,
0.6243343353,
0.2189578712,
-0.0221959352,
0.1295879036,
0.1543754786,
0.1059724167,
0.2949083745,
-0.622250855,
-0.1862676144,
-0.5429962277,
-0.7132105231,
-0.1775743216,
0.0747390166,
-0.2822692096,
-0.1019225717,
0.6914448142,
-0.1748743504,
0.2436494529,
0.0088665942,
0.0445870161,
-0.118421182,
0.4845971167,
0.6097406745,
-0.0622873828,
-0.2500944436,
-0.0392962098,
-0.3117225468,
-0.4151299298,
0.6469063163,
-0.0782463551,
-0.1702999026,
-0.262962997,
0.3260833621,
1.0184299946,
0.0735923722,
-0.5107072592,
0.4920122027,
-0.0530296974,
-0.1239670366,
-0.1122614592,
0.2610084116,
0.1881846339,
0.1797335595,
0.3440606892,
0.3181458116,
0.2985735238,
-0.2945096195,
0.3335150182,
0.4330118597,
-0.605738461,
-0.037833266,
1.1342674494,
0.5453983545,
-0.8886091113,
0.555365622,
-0.0090352809,
-0.3054217398,
0.6313821077,
0.640899539,
0.8379865289,
-0.190919131,
0.4584249556,
0.497733593,
0.0822574422,
-0.0256744586,
-0.0799271464,
-0.394185245,
-0.7271502614,
-0.007484185,
-0.3919748664,
-0.5090447068,
-0.206710577,
-0.9627687335,
0.5256857872,
-0.1986518204,
-0.4801286161,
-0.0800406784,
-0.1624870151,
-0.1480647177,
0.3733260036,
-0.1089102849,
0.7190648317,
-0.7224045396,
0.899001956,
0.3061843216,
-0.4886294901,
-1.255140543,
0.0649928972,
0.0739623681,
-0.4676548541,
0.4000557065,
0.2257791311,
-0.3860218823,
0.1576306671,
-0.5015528798,
-0.4116607308,
1.0247606039,
0.3934907317,
-0.6148759127,
0.0579937175,
0.1452811807,
0.4938247502,
-0.5111686587,
0.3650484085,
0.4527612627,
0.5893226862,
-0.0387418531,
-0.9593124986,
-0.2389023453,
-0.4759843349,
-0.2470349222,
0.4824956357,
-0.4490268826,
0.5518196821,
-0.3236124814,
-0.0466117784,
0.2166353911,
0.7222170234,
0.4463297725,
0.4632167518,
0.4587849975,
0.2528670728,
0.7134004235,
-0.1033695713,
1.0903158188,
-0.2166296393,
0.0704173073,
1.501432538,
-0.5519133806,
0.7203804851,
0.4603061676,
0.0930582657,
0.3010217845,
0.6339476705,
0.0421931557,
0.6735759377,
-0.093728222,
-0.3217916191,
-0.1655332744,
-0.3452202678,
-0.2996710837,
0.3018418849,
-0.1134197041,
-0.2661389709,
0.2698546052,
0.1370862126,
-0.4204499424,
0.3912899196,
-0.4000471234,
0.783416748,
-0.1302753538,
-0.7902379632,
0.2941108346,
-0.0578347445,
0.6255090833,
-0.5072337389,
-0.105587326,
0.108760573,
-0.1684025079,
-0.2904069424,
-0.959730804,
-0.0291442107,
0.077672042,
-0.5066488385,
-0.3007585704,
0.5009340048,
-0.809386909,
0.0372860804,
0.2588089406,
-0.1353420764,
-0.4191560149,
0.0346366204,
-0.5510198474,
-0.1908733547,
-0.0874221995,
-0.051858943,
0.3645447791,
0.1641145051,
0.152252093,
0.5019786358,
0.4641850889,
0.0085493149,
-0.2448473275,
0.3324368,
0.3497610688,
-0.6095046997,
-0.7597635984,
-0.8138175607,
0.6778513193,
-0.1815588772,
-0.3137510121,
0.6123242974,
0.6415162683,
0.5191224813,
0.0650645271,
0.9861319661,
0.105356209,
0.6289682984,
-0.7001300454,
0.8578378558,
-0.5886620283,
0.4756360948,
-0.6284546852,
-0.7885977626,
0.1002857238,
0.425180912,
-0.0640631169,
0.0758305639,
0.4624167383,
0.8780685067,
-0.0514616109,
0.3412666023,
-0.0282569267,
-0.3941216469,
0.3052083552,
0.3496859074,
0.6820732951,
-0.3040038049,
0.2669566572,
-0.0399737619,
-0.0899469331,
-0.1856565475,
-0.9086919427,
-0.7439422607,
-0.8975003362,
-0.1718170643,
-0.465489924,
-0.2005590349,
1.276720047,
0.6618791819,
-0.6789851785,
-0.5074305534,
-0.062297184,
0.0438391045,
-0.3601492047,
-0.2344348878,
0.458999902,
-0.1484671682,
-0.6843839884,
0.4863123,
0.4032756686,
0.2221693248,
0.2881657779,
-0.5551025271,
-0.0091290837,
0.2478884012,
0.3767333627,
0.1073535755,
-0.4459481239,
-0.5648326874,
-0.0759404898,
-0.3249678612,
0.4886696935,
1.0721871853,
-0.6591886878,
0.3665316403,
0.2303290218,
0.6788888574,
0.3991160393,
0.3719147742,
1.0052052736,
-0.9096385241,
-0.0962905288,
0.231058076,
0.2118351609,
0.4360143244,
-0.4522193372,
0.3110454679,
-0.2046491057,
-0.78087008,
-0.7680861354,
0.3071895242,
-1.4409791231,
0.1922688186,
1.0937241316,
0.1768507957,
0.0750025958,
-0.2157656252,
-0.8373621106,
0.7566940188,
-0.8447407484,
1.010237813,
0.5509862304,
-0.1347899735,
-0.0754133835,
-0.2491723448,
0.7921280861,
0.5614758134,
-0.9586209655,
0.2585267723,
0.4227817953,
-0.0052659274,
-0.0037068741,
0.824885428,
0.0459737703,
0.6302238107,
-0.1413609236,
0.1491563767,
-0.197022289,
-0.5308725834,
-0.3296707571,
0.2004804313,
0.1139562652,
-0.1891250312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00743v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00743v2
|
Theoretical Understanding of In-Context Learning in Shallow Transformers with Unstructured Data
| 2024-02-01T16:39:45 | 2024-06-18T13:11:32 |
Yue Xing, Xiaofeng Lin, Chenheng Xu, Namjoon Suh, Qifan Song, Guang Cheng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful models that can learn concepts at
the inference stage via in-context learning (ICL). While theoretical studies,
e.g., \cite{zhang2023trained}, attempt to explain the mechanism of ICL, they
assume the input $x_i$ and the output $y_i$ of each demonstration example are
in the same token (i.e., structured data). However, in real practice, the
examples are usually text input, and all words, regardless of their logic
relationship, are stored in different tokens (i.e., unstructured data
\cite{wibisono2023role}). To understand how LLMs learn from the unstructured
data in ICL, this paper studies the role of each component in the transformer
architecture and provides a theoretical understanding to explain the success of
the architecture. In particular, we consider a simple transformer with one/two
attention layers and linear regression tasks for the ICL prediction. We observe
that (1) a transformer with two layers of (self-)attentions with a look-ahead
attention mask can learn from the prompt in the unstructured data, and (2)
positional encoding can match the $x_i$ and $y_i$ tokens to achieve a better
ICL performance.
|
[
-0.3927357197,
-0.6930758357,
0.7273091078,
0.0007070739,
-0.2029996067,
0.0811910033,
-0.3466713428,
-0.3746980131,
-0.3292380273,
0.305187732,
-0.494644016,
-0.4003685713,
-0.3529457748,
0.0284788217,
-0.6626615524,
1.1458264589,
-0.0780253708,
0.0042815004,
-0.3415438533,
0.1350737214,
-0.4661519229,
-0.3763175905,
-0.4224634767,
-0.637427032,
0.3867261112,
0.5255951285,
0.4382386804,
0.6520310044,
0.290099293,
0.3153124154,
-0.1205078214,
-0.2580137253,
-0.5841777921,
0.0229193345,
-0.222645089,
-0.5961501002,
0.1853022724,
-0.0176068954,
0.7475571632,
0.9478415847,
0.0215298533,
0.1135922372,
0.5263271928,
0.3670416474,
-0.4325891137,
0.2110235542,
-0.8230971694,
0.3254842162,
-0.2204376906,
-0.1198425144,
-0.6934614778,
0.2475431561,
0.2648750544,
-0.3082583547,
0.2590301037,
0.0717709213,
0.6113780737,
0.3522341549,
-0.6729159355,
-0.256732434,
-1.0200018883,
0.8802893758,
-0.5482985973,
0.390460819,
0.170433864,
0.3275156617,
-0.0784734413,
-0.9224998951,
-0.5993403792,
-0.0852271244,
-0.5757753253,
0.2213559747,
0.0021427274,
0.096652545,
0.3546589613,
0.428082794,
-0.1477948427,
0.3798701167,
-0.4474321306,
0.1141853854,
0.4205786288,
0.0600931495,
-0.0202558637,
-0.1810154617,
-0.8598407507,
0.001948541,
-0.7969583869,
0.386382699,
-0.095870316,
0.357863307,
-0.3623402715,
0.4207859337,
-0.0421821252,
0.3209953904,
0.3607156575,
-0.2571154535,
0.1173580587,
-0.0224844404,
-0.3499291837,
0.1793983281,
0.6887913942,
-0.254905045,
0.3324747682,
-0.5872582793,
-0.5532581806,
-0.1309054494,
0.4884231985,
-0.5659489632,
-0.0706901923,
0.1025370806,
-0.5336465836,
-0.1321913153,
0.1696188748,
-0.6275225878,
-0.0734771639,
-0.6661063433,
0.578440547,
-0.2989608645,
0.2391093522,
-0.0211985037,
0.2086914182,
0.3740153015,
0.0853731558,
-0.7875594497,
0.530423522,
0.5034983754,
0.6845583916,
-0.3468707502,
-0.3470732272,
-0.3347599804,
0.2580612898,
-0.0696191862,
0.8995267153,
-0.4232439995,
-0.2562843561,
0.1737072319,
-0.1200400218,
-0.2688776553,
-0.3378986716,
0.5317090154,
-0.6611843705,
0.4260216653,
0.0244317185,
-0.6474907398,
-0.1724241376,
0.0345850959,
-0.5728045702,
1.1168613434,
0.1396778822,
-0.8604362607,
0.400931865,
-0.6736023426,
-0.5053562522,
0.0898091197,
-0.2682363689,
-0.3245464861,
0.4299545884,
0.0205545705,
0.6778222919,
-0.3987420499,
0.3249709308,
-0.1451482624,
-0.6775339842,
0.7055380344,
-0.6619963646,
0.4844335318,
0.1413473487,
-0.5531758666,
0.0356233008,
-0.5629506707,
-0.2088555247,
0.0373055823,
-0.5712380409,
-0.2806155682,
0.2146696299,
0.0882253721,
0.4574082792,
-0.0968578681,
-0.6917700768,
0.1775966436,
-0.4830524027,
0.5087123513,
0.8259149194,
-0.1958718598,
0.8157413006,
0.1242629066,
0.2955930531,
0.203271091,
0.2708550692,
-0.3300295174,
0.0572046638,
-0.7513014078,
-0.1841255873,
0.4002504051,
0.3565909863,
-0.5676982403,
0.0851497501,
-0.270100385,
-0.1240405291,
-0.410164386,
0.1710747331,
0.4875978827,
0.9531482458,
0.5507549047,
0.1313691884,
-0.4071600735,
-0.9694766998,
0.0447630398,
0.1014131531,
-0.2314573973,
0.4012747407,
0.553232491,
-0.2760691345,
1.1963222027,
-0.372104466,
-0.4406745434,
-0.420429498,
-0.1671903729,
0.2947441041,
0.4509479702,
0.3725457788,
-0.8758798838,
-0.5197489262,
-0.0650783032,
-0.8805111647,
0.0857350007,
-0.1724209487,
0.0621588789,
0.1380306482,
0.816470027,
-0.7859645486,
0.5715342164,
0.2630393207,
-0.1621921211,
0.3204253912,
-0.2359799892,
-0.3828362823,
-1.1510066986,
-0.1360856146,
0.1007766053,
-0.0271119624,
-0.7539767027,
0.0131468819,
0.2573283315,
0.0671636239,
-0.61814785,
0.5845121145,
-0.4260370135,
-0.3541911244,
-0.2237413079,
0.2018287927,
-0.0715116113,
0.7126737237,
-0.1424702853,
0.6849201918,
0.597650528,
-0.6803438067,
-0.0897001028,
0.1682003886,
-0.4634560645,
0.3441192806,
-0.8547315598,
0.1145134494,
-0.366725117,
0.302954942,
-1.1242389679,
-0.1322876513,
-0.0515797324,
-0.1642376631,
0.5928720832,
-0.0609583743,
-0.4446027577,
-0.2723270357,
-0.0609834269,
0.6554945111,
0.5446597934,
-0.7859470248,
0.7802268267,
0.4123518169,
0.2871112823,
-0.676689446,
-0.7736568451,
-0.1047420353,
-0.566211462,
-0.2795797288,
0.5667448044,
-0.0766095817,
-0.3463576436,
0.0048150606,
0.0304385703,
0.0410732925,
0.1844998151,
0.3581074774,
0.2646263838,
-0.2835981548,
0.2821518779,
-0.0580286384,
-0.2313341498,
0.192229405,
-0.5204249024,
0.562030077,
-0.1071700156,
-0.4043029547,
-0.3625857532,
0.2636857927,
0.4444206357,
0.0221284293,
0.7030774355,
0.378084898,
-0.3465898633,
-0.494392544,
-0.2993157506,
-0.3104266524,
-0.5102647543,
0.2787902057,
-0.467703402,
-0.7832934856,
0.6130465269,
-0.0222504064,
-0.1002716869,
0.4000613689,
0.5275754333,
-0.4594899714,
0.9859498143,
0.7778197527,
-0.1653148979,
0.2504687607,
-0.3647941053,
0.3736542165,
-0.9891173244,
-0.6403827071,
-0.3891172409,
-0.6725258231,
-0.4919857979,
-0.2007517219,
0.4284746945,
0.1886302233,
-0.3654284179,
0.0584985763,
-0.2529808581,
0.6590085626,
0.4744946361,
-0.0361424647,
0.1854401976,
0.1314893067,
-0.2322763056,
0.0536734387,
-0.7140917182,
-0.3831285238,
0.7508739233,
0.5500914454,
1.0531939268,
-0.1270904243,
0.4093693793,
0.147263065,
0.177349925,
-1.003539443,
0.3354685605,
-0.1545348912,
-0.2755635381,
-0.2602983117,
-0.0070732464,
-0.9862297177,
0.2435527593,
-0.0293706153,
-0.6874998808,
0.1962874681,
0.1935265213,
-0.068505764,
0.3405508697,
-0.6437667608,
0.6107282639,
-0.30809021,
-0.23190175,
0.0220369305,
-0.8262532949,
0.2273067981,
-0.1457478255,
0.1492050588,
0.3838294744,
0.1164144203,
0.4910243452,
0.088530235,
1.0259360075,
-0.1728310883,
-0.1039672866,
0.2001491785,
0.0775790513,
0.4575717151,
0.2392913997,
0.1477835327,
0.3096215427,
-0.4279324114,
-0.2343490422,
-0.6728917956,
0.4632458389,
-0.8882454634,
-0.442725271,
-0.2589942813,
-0.792878449,
-0.2056208402,
0.1001620963,
0.4355903864,
0.6429316401,
0.0901036263,
0.6066923141,
1.0266176462,
0.0163414888,
0.7064304948,
0.4752412736,
-0.0203416962,
0.2371412963,
0.3624396622,
0.1205279827,
0.185316354,
0.8801838756,
0.2169801295,
-0.5017427802,
-0.5302087665,
-0.1881881952,
0.1746596098,
-1.040276885,
-0.3228609264,
-0.7714504004,
-0.4268696308,
-0.0203839913,
-0.2330851257,
-0.2444974184,
-0.0640683919,
-0.3653044105,
-0.3092013896,
-0.0793504938,
1.0547573566,
0.3328880668,
0.4748196304,
-0.4067031741,
-0.029871678,
0.2410649061,
0.3854552805,
0.2873801589,
-0.7657606602,
-0.5058755279,
0.064915292,
-0.05227549,
-0.4489939511,
0.2059960514,
0.0965072736,
0.6690436006,
0.5130084753,
-0.0602338389,
0.7228549123,
-0.6825410724,
0.5407337546,
-0.2558492422,
-1.0220342875,
0.2061504871,
-0.1675985008,
0.3788093626,
0.5004783273,
0.2764388621,
-0.4888732731,
-0.1332474053,
-0.4532045126,
-0.8186302185,
0.8788089752,
-0.031646166,
0.3330423236,
0.1571875215,
0.6006766558,
0.2707779706,
0.1456716806,
-1.0412560701,
-0.1661652178,
-0.2732768357,
-0.3810950816,
-0.1117169186,
-0.4346047342,
0.0058415206,
-0.102969341,
0.3251798451,
-0.4283957779,
0.5512261987,
-0.0239704531,
-0.4099378884,
0.0673825294,
0.2482931614,
0.4506421089,
0.5122067928,
-0.0144128194,
0.5537364483,
0.2619952559,
-0.2010090947,
-0.0775661692,
-0.2092849612,
-0.3077107072,
-0.2970850468,
0.6000698805,
0.9668241143,
0.720133841,
-0.5698286891,
0.4732239544,
-0.1112382635,
-0.0097731231,
-0.4470361173,
-0.1370183975,
-0.1029720381,
0.4001330435,
0.7297635078,
0.0027223178,
0.1088490933,
-0.5429760814,
0.274284631,
0.5859311223,
-0.6387527585,
-0.5286644101,
0.5998924375,
-0.2321963757,
-0.2442271858,
0.8150331378,
0.1774783581,
-0.4770752192,
0.4578350484,
1.0216436386,
0.7937693,
-0.0508413874,
0.1918657571,
0.0214287285,
0.1245890632,
0.114149116,
-0.2280246764,
-0.4057722688,
-0.7347435951,
-0.5447044373,
-0.8676862121,
-0.0387951806,
0.2925762534,
-0.621592164,
0.1274292916,
-0.2141326368,
0.4835090935,
-0.1877039671,
-0.333605051,
-0.8353902102,
0.285280019,
0.2554781735,
0.9492266178,
-0.8801644444,
0.9093284011,
0.4503871202,
-0.16848737,
-1.029062748,
0.2950713634,
-0.2594916523,
-0.9737805724,
0.9922415614,
0.3007383645,
-0.1099326089,
-0.0637249127,
-0.531701684,
-1.1783627272,
1.2090016603,
0.2783921063,
-0.3676239252,
-0.2570047975,
0.3438812196,
0.6146836281,
-0.6867703795,
0.2091943771,
0.407043308,
0.1661571711,
0.0969257727,
-0.5866808295,
-0.0859474093,
-0.0915846899,
0.1303725541,
0.1694115698,
-0.4980501533,
1.2043627501,
-0.1175583601,
-0.3437215388,
-0.2269444764,
0.7084973454,
-0.0573474057,
0.2560806274,
0.4451606274,
0.262831986,
0.3331480622,
-0.1350698471,
1.2967569828,
-0.2843973935,
0.5296218395,
0.9936822653,
-0.2220386714,
0.6454399824,
0.4650422037,
-0.0165094696,
0.7448912859,
0.6024261713,
0.0165600888,
0.7604290247,
-0.19979693,
0.0451480895,
-0.0740026459,
-0.2195140123,
0.0370095149,
0.8231848478,
0.3124644756,
-0.4530749619,
-0.2019759119,
0.2713341415,
-0.0719091371,
0.0074650659,
-0.4261070192,
0.9695876837,
0.0862840787,
-0.6628970504,
0.243593052,
-0.025872875,
0.5113403201,
-0.5226578712,
0.1242470816,
-0.2640731037,
0.4730414152,
-0.1970512718,
-0.8859254718,
0.1664836109,
-0.3082157671,
-0.4707392752,
-0.3098571599,
0.8602249622,
-0.5458545089,
-0.4205115736,
0.4359771013,
0.3740542233,
-0.0559371896,
0.1512049288,
-0.6167963743,
-0.1651094854,
-0.1877762824,
-0.4259473681,
0.6308249235,
0.5452518463,
-0.2481545508,
0.6547825933,
0.3861379921,
-0.2080942392,
-0.0377175957,
0.1477806866,
0.9299470186,
-0.4089346826,
-0.5114707947,
-1.0007382631,
0.6792176366,
0.1202899739,
-0.0652621239,
0.9057562947,
0.4640761614,
1.1699347496,
-0.1352596283,
0.5814861059,
0.1785609424,
0.2768021524,
-0.7562978268,
0.3458503783,
-0.4104034007,
0.1961227208,
-0.1228956282,
-1.0696719885,
-0.1885082871,
0.5982141495,
-0.1750852913,
0.1037809774,
0.8040449619,
0.425537467,
-0.3227108121,
-0.1607920378,
0.2702871859,
0.3546595871,
0.2887416184,
0.4355373383,
0.8682623506,
-0.3261271715,
0.3426364064,
-0.3943677545,
0.068710722,
-0.0751139671,
-0.6488289833,
-1.060274601,
-0.8150802851,
0.1758578569,
-0.1612710059,
-0.4444500804,
0.8403614163,
0.6647834778,
-0.6906778216,
-0.2918513715,
-0.02895681,
0.1578874588,
-0.026664421,
-0.3013640046,
0.5178902745,
-0.4603500366,
-0.773950398,
0.5330650806,
0.5656036735,
0.0561461858,
-0.4241398573,
-0.0032790615,
-0.0226310343,
0.096006833,
0.7939757109,
0.0497699939,
-0.7345141768,
-0.3557302952,
0.0732244551,
-0.0859011486,
0.1934205145,
1.0874841213,
-1.3123681545,
0.0914721191,
0.1861995012,
0.6849044561,
0.5510240793,
0.0762319788,
0.2582114935,
-1.0312620401,
0.2657206059,
0.0900383592,
0.5162058473,
0.3553202152,
-0.5384801626,
0.377607882,
0.0681731254,
-0.6211751699,
-0.9235057235,
0.2899171412,
-0.7064742446,
-0.4365417659,
1.0524228811,
0.0566988885,
-0.2652316988,
-0.2487965077,
-0.0497787483,
0.1977855116,
-0.206756413,
1.1047207117,
0.301196605,
-0.2108973712,
-0.1380339116,
-0.4033124447,
0.4646587074,
0.2554160655,
-0.5841664076,
-0.029327793,
0.1501483917,
0.1343785673,
0.1762779057,
0.2167245299,
0.0591390654,
-0.0710442662,
-0.3954283297,
-0.3343241513,
0.0107581876,
-0.6228944063,
-0.4325905144,
0.3549149334,
-0.2194198817,
0.037834987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00742v1
|
Transforming and Combining Rewards for Aligning Large Language Models
| 2024-02-01T16:39:28 | 2024-02-01T16:39:28 |
Zihao Wang, Chirag Nagpal, Jonathan Berant, Jacob Eisenstein, Alex D'Amour, Sanmi Koyejo, Victor Veitch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2
|
A common approach for aligning language models to human preferences is to
first learn a reward model from preference data, and then use this reward model
to update the language model. We study two closely related problems that arise
in this approach. First, any monotone transformation of the reward model
preserves preference ranking; is there a choice that is ``better'' than others?
Second, we often wish to align language models to multiple properties: how
should we combine multiple reward models? Using a probabilistic interpretation
of the alignment procedure, we identify a natural choice for transformation for
(the common case of) rewards learned from Bradley-Terry preference models. This
derived transformation has two important properties. First, it emphasizes
improving poorly-performing outputs, rather than outputs that already score
well. This mitigates both underfitting (where some prompts are not improved)
and reward hacking (where the model learns to exploit misspecification of the
reward model). Second, it enables principled aggregation of rewards by linking
summation to logical conjunction: the sum of transformed rewards corresponds to
the probability that the output is ``good'' in all measured properties, in a
sense we make precise. Experiments aligning language models to be both helpful
and harmless using RLHF show substantial improvements over the baseline
(non-transformed) approach.
|
[
-0.2069558203,
-0.360563159,
0.5363590717,
-0.0197749473,
-0.0222512186,
-0.0444666818,
-0.6377803683,
-0.5325499773,
0.3460326493,
0.6978704929,
-0.362270385,
-0.0549965389,
-0.8050274253,
-0.3090051711,
-0.2182700783,
1.2831145525,
-0.051232107,
0.0679316223,
-0.2621881664,
-0.334964782,
-0.5356059074,
-0.7266877294,
-0.5316051841,
-0.6205023527,
0.6997084618,
0.4338588715,
0.878244698,
0.5382881165,
0.6403158307,
0.2986828387,
0.1460440308,
0.1253458112,
-0.7169438601,
0.0807043687,
-0.3464229703,
-0.3539471328,
-0.3668115437,
0.3218980134,
0.3781195879,
0.8186557889,
-0.173216477,
0.0148935216,
0.2225155681,
0.8841442466,
-0.7089439631,
0.1333031207,
-0.3811918497,
-0.0943008289,
-0.1688646823,
-0.3601338267,
-0.48529917,
-0.7032104135,
0.0394227244,
-0.3372017145,
-0.0919690132,
-0.0205033459,
0.7592145801,
0.2250245064,
-0.5841290355,
-0.1657956392,
-0.8206319809,
1.2096520662,
-0.5760609508,
0.2993086576,
0.2864351869,
0.4378411472,
-0.1780770272,
-0.304005295,
-0.3079796135,
-0.3346818388,
-0.3020711243,
0.0511906482,
-0.0048221741,
-0.0103791114,
-0.0375527069,
0.4347044528,
-0.5802112222,
0.2340472639,
-0.1941814423,
-0.2455701679,
0.9513210058,
0.1570221037,
0.284145534,
0.0578080453,
-0.3751434386,
-0.777151227,
-0.7214307785,
0.5124356151,
0.4645414948,
0.6523129344,
0.0151456166,
0.6814517975,
-0.190172419,
0.9152467251,
0.036518611,
-0.4170309007,
0.1486788541,
-0.5173820257,
0.0525835268,
0.1857660115,
0.5387049317,
0.4355899692,
0.401152283,
-0.2502995133,
-0.4698885679,
0.2425828278,
0.2395227849,
-0.3948141038,
-0.2230889052,
0.1259296983,
-0.6145225167,
-0.4386422038,
0.1976593733,
-0.4344316125,
-0.4256196022,
-0.6188701987,
0.4888814688,
-0.1501350254,
-0.3170704544,
0.4805599749,
-0.1896600723,
0.2002850473,
0.3197239637,
-1.4934878349,
0.4100828171,
0.8981168866,
0.3982125819,
-0.3858447373,
-0.3742759526,
-0.6741118431,
-0.1103046462,
-0.170261994,
0.8834577799,
-0.442584306,
-0.3071420193,
0.1280238628,
-0.1180526242,
-0.0553336702,
-0.6385744214,
0.6488828659,
-0.4428548515,
0.3815540969,
-0.4436211586,
-0.6187912226,
0.0395872965,
0.2331269979,
-0.8409897685,
0.8045091629,
0.2547435462,
-0.5842555761,
0.2905817032,
-0.7162458301,
-0.3863258958,
-0.247956112,
0.214400813,
-0.072384268,
0.1443533152,
0.0551479496,
0.1664603204,
-0.2906220853,
0.5006769896,
-0.2127248049,
-0.1297141314,
0.5228604674,
-0.2528786063,
0.74705863,
0.1890734881,
-0.0026752753,
0.3941144943,
-0.3417026699,
-0.0730233043,
0.1403132677,
-0.4286544025,
-0.430033356,
0.0782677084,
0.0599226169,
0.0130844014,
0.6382642984,
-0.3856054544,
0.5887119174,
-0.4647707045,
0.1303304583,
0.9291363358,
-0.1897996664,
0.8546938896,
-0.5060983896,
0.3931251168,
0.0318317637,
0.2322576791,
0.2374050617,
-0.3934488893,
-0.6226360798,
-0.0321548358,
0.6053894758,
0.4853687584,
-0.3878076971,
0.5013645291,
-0.349218756,
-0.380757153,
-0.7127023935,
-0.0333210453,
0.147199288,
0.3856902421,
0.5143123269,
-0.3220047653,
-0.3946163952,
-1.0386217833,
-0.3735489547,
-0.3215308189,
-0.0144588053,
0.029260274,
0.0256760977,
0.1135802269,
0.9178239703,
-0.6800696254,
-0.0945024043,
-0.1850120127,
0.3387697041,
0.3794135749,
0.6705908775,
0.5406649709,
-0.9277878404,
-0.3835299611,
0.1669921577,
-0.3203200102,
-0.1045473367,
-0.1426009536,
-0.0579139367,
0.1307270825,
0.077802375,
-0.2207578272,
0.1554088742,
0.6299572587,
-0.2242607623,
0.6185356975,
-0.0532521531,
0.5369551182,
-0.9419280887,
-0.1180475131,
-0.0904000476,
-0.4212913811,
-0.5874541402,
-0.0221792683,
0.026887862,
0.0747660697,
-0.2434016764,
0.6850872636,
-0.1276707947,
-0.0421069413,
-0.4626885951,
-0.1247573495,
-0.1431033909,
0.5033354163,
0.1403844953,
0.6545897722,
0.4514651597,
-0.6087189913,
0.6078240275,
0.2080007195,
-0.1416904926,
0.4451388419,
-0.3150807619,
0.1377724707,
-0.0817445964,
-0.0418840162,
-0.8832124472,
-0.1452980191,
0.1178877503,
-0.5161488652,
0.2798708677,
0.0024012208,
-0.400621593,
0.0704569146,
-0.3469204605,
0.4762822092,
0.5588648915,
-0.7179855704,
0.2820224166,
0.4098610282,
-0.2352640182,
-0.6728458405,
-0.395840764,
-0.0446385592,
-0.3516609669,
-0.6169615984,
0.735237658,
-0.2329797894,
-0.2411426306,
0.2542000711,
-0.0648683757,
0.2898358405,
0.1834182441,
-0.0866311118,
0.4186377227,
-0.2027600408,
0.1286972314,
-0.0803825557,
-0.5124194622,
-0.1765155494,
-0.3339122534,
0.500523448,
-0.0137718795,
-0.3348457515,
0.098129876,
0.6073578596,
0.4980565608,
-0.360262841,
0.8662294149,
0.2540690005,
-0.2688994706,
0.1644975692,
-0.5164653063,
-0.5077846646,
-0.3888250887,
0.1698620617,
-0.2265790552,
-1.018461585,
0.4012956023,
-0.0247833505,
0.1942088902,
0.3808835447,
0.506991148,
0.0380866937,
1.2818515301,
0.893198669,
-0.3050956726,
0.6385920048,
0.2857405841,
0.4671784043,
-0.5004309416,
-0.2087781578,
-0.7330137491,
-0.4351228476,
-0.7394608855,
0.0145091927,
0.3483360112,
0.1249107718,
-0.0855985433,
0.6190912724,
-0.3804767728,
0.4894904792,
0.6607919931,
0.0500264652,
0.1763609797,
0.0690319017,
0.1671443433,
-0.1538949311,
-0.5005019307,
-0.523403585,
1.1771258116,
0.1632575542,
0.9144095778,
0.3887197971,
0.95870471,
0.1578550637,
0.3362999856,
-0.8469108343,
0.2809068263,
-0.2959131002,
-0.3405290246,
-0.5395113826,
-0.4073443413,
-0.9504247308,
0.0442452542,
-0.4592642188,
-0.8703036308,
0.28018713,
0.2732349038,
-0.2619021833,
0.0435570776,
-0.790595293,
1.0403014421,
-0.5553351045,
-0.4200137556,
-0.379493773,
-0.679587543,
0.495382756,
0.1271196157,
0.017488949,
0.0078044124,
0.4597049356,
0.7715994716,
-0.1863241196,
0.472451061,
0.0267649442,
-0.0725685284,
-0.2851973772,
0.1019838676,
0.3794263601,
-0.2000966519,
-0.1614442617,
-0.1639540195,
0.0835463256,
-0.5876707435,
-0.9573426843,
0.6415231228,
-0.8880830407,
-0.7795430422,
-0.3850361109,
-0.7277019024,
-0.2704011202,
-0.0613372885,
-0.0508028269,
0.3636161983,
-0.2105638534,
0.0314298198,
0.6183750033,
0.0130538279,
0.1134130731,
0.1971171796,
-0.4435404241,
-0.275798589,
0.8823267221,
-0.1529571712,
0.5353056192,
0.6269529462,
0.4427628815,
-0.5582791567,
-0.21361579,
-0.132110253,
0.2053223401,
-0.7882534862,
-0.142638132,
-0.1885822713,
-0.1486391723,
-0.7639034986,
-0.3672839105,
-0.394182682,
-0.6090307832,
-0.0599027984,
-0.0128960162,
0.140632093,
0.6114616394,
-0.2818804681,
0.0957324952,
-0.854957521,
0.1710122079,
0.5837446451,
0.1474244297,
-0.1863907278,
-0.613201797,
-0.3039174378,
0.1500043869,
-0.2656069994,
-0.9625042677,
0.4319964647,
-0.253134042,
0.6629893184,
0.2787142098,
0.0877070352,
0.6001989245,
-0.1880209893,
0.6429118514,
0.4404170513,
-0.8346204758,
0.3197619915,
0.0046480279,
0.0543155968,
0.6787258387,
0.3455640674,
-0.8383703828,
-0.0205485336,
-0.5741095543,
-0.5744660497,
0.7625446916,
-0.0025090533,
0.1046343222,
0.2144324332,
0.1288943142,
0.2061496824,
0.052958712,
-1.0213134289,
-0.2924718559,
-0.3331496418,
-0.3262137771,
-0.3821254075,
-0.1520489603,
-0.4237261415,
-0.2862248719,
0.7351135015,
-0.1205884516,
0.2198021859,
-0.222752884,
-0.2093717754,
-0.2015066147,
0.5241816044,
0.7261431813,
0.5695483088,
-0.3260526955,
0.3756132722,
-0.3046952486,
0.2557474673,
0.3677529991,
0.0219170768,
0.2667500377,
-0.4967837036,
0.258508116,
1.0282281637,
0.2484951168,
-0.4009384811,
0.4158878624,
-0.0040712035,
-0.0557988472,
0.1127300486,
0.2196770757,
0.316854924,
0.0664597675,
0.1738548279,
0.1375116855,
0.1325039417,
-0.7568278909,
-0.0341314822,
0.5442413688,
-0.2439446747,
-0.2429317683,
0.2212346494,
0.0624472909,
-0.4935040772,
0.618632853,
-0.1665018797,
-0.7061052322,
0.4035482407,
0.761916995,
0.7381327748,
-0.4762299359,
0.2987954319,
0.4431572855,
0.1658703685,
-0.393319428,
-0.1559513956,
-0.200215444,
-1.150816083,
-0.2795954943,
-0.5111374259,
-0.4729104638,
-0.1244309098,
-0.7019026279,
0.3845677376,
0.1823595166,
0.0886189789,
0.2987537682,
-0.2288098186,
-0.4157397151,
-0.0754535198,
0.2596679032,
0.5077786446,
-1.3584494591,
0.9023697376,
0.8987701535,
-0.5083232522,
-0.9941009879,
-0.1068117693,
-0.0380586013,
-0.7556696534,
0.6437264681,
-0.0255428832,
-0.0961903036,
-0.0253015272,
-0.6808049083,
-0.8149073124,
0.6863312125,
0.3857717812,
-0.3243791759,
0.1767037362,
0.2884070277,
0.4079920352,
-0.466114074,
0.187954843,
0.6360646486,
0.6604514718,
0.0854666308,
-1.024081111,
-0.1134545803,
-0.0300018359,
-0.2399800569,
0.611758709,
-0.236185059,
0.6604984999,
-0.0449080206,
-0.1590501815,
-0.1763346195,
0.3975127339,
0.3934665918,
0.0146651035,
0.683419168,
0.4477411211,
0.6647101641,
-0.1381447762,
0.9994935393,
-0.1953911185,
0.6506410241,
0.7692580819,
-0.425996691,
0.7160677314,
0.8457533121,
-0.2672356665,
0.4145491123,
0.6250146627,
0.4517389834,
0.7480808496,
0.0613809489,
-0.1086474881,
-0.6214482784,
-0.1382232457,
-0.2725049257,
0.4485022724,
0.0702485144,
-0.0368982181,
-0.4033075273,
0.0056376271,
-0.1445163935,
0.3622323871,
-0.0702642053,
0.9080618024,
-0.0142581956,
-1.286072135,
0.5127924085,
0.2646152079,
0.5345524549,
-0.7125712037,
-0.1242380589,
-0.2536585331,
0.1332970411,
-0.227694273,
-0.8565814495,
0.298050791,
-0.2682059407,
-0.3455872238,
-0.6124104857,
0.7425810695,
-0.7872468233,
-0.2835669518,
0.2733604014,
0.2867970169,
-0.0650903657,
0.2073954344,
-0.6570586562,
-0.0065080151,
0.1783917546,
-0.0462459065,
0.6594134569,
-0.0630495325,
-0.2243651897,
0.3312627375,
0.7437304854,
0.0853310972,
-0.2257150263,
0.0209433548,
0.7279930115,
-0.6210917234,
-0.6670831442,
-0.8752917051,
0.635620296,
-0.0450211838,
-0.0462959372,
0.3277319372,
0.4617857039,
0.7723302841,
-0.1274875551,
0.4807415009,
0.1225867271,
0.28467834,
-0.7850241661,
0.3651333153,
-0.6763625145,
0.0650936589,
-0.0993300378,
-1.0740995407,
-0.2481742501,
0.5614612699,
-0.3285559416,
-0.1609797925,
0.8974734545,
0.8391063213,
-0.1013718769,
-0.0685769394,
0.4091090858,
-0.3368900418,
0.3477466702,
0.7819752097,
0.8078717589,
-0.0860311091,
0.0360894315,
-0.2789398134,
-0.4071174562,
-0.2214789242,
-1.0080417395,
-0.2055203021,
-0.8539724946,
-0.304174602,
-0.3224113882,
-0.0777249187,
1.2535278797,
0.757026732,
-1.0221371651,
-0.6045795679,
0.2584254742,
0.3624646068,
-0.6027867794,
-0.2014805079,
0.2662193775,
-0.4434739351,
-0.7694129944,
0.3604032397,
0.3434734941,
-0.0465398133,
-0.2464401573,
-0.3550108969,
-0.0942543522,
0.080883272,
0.3563101888,
0.4355393946,
-0.6558322906,
-0.6393606663,
0.1953291893,
-0.2436030507,
0.2499267608,
1.0601712465,
-0.6894207597,
0.4727340639,
0.6183685064,
0.8261073828,
0.5602667332,
0.1664910167,
0.648309052,
-0.5787702799,
0.0640453175,
0.0261854678,
0.469597131,
0.3955866098,
-0.372772336,
0.3169152737,
-0.0178689286,
-0.6680800319,
-0.8699640632,
0.6268627644,
-1.1955852509,
-0.1991935074,
1.0118266344,
0.1107395515,
-0.0624982081,
0.1083825156,
-0.1538238823,
0.2826907039,
-0.1778347939,
0.9406087995,
0.9175018072,
-0.2887760997,
-0.135167107,
-0.1019460559,
0.4555778205,
0.7725266218,
-0.7447093725,
0.1869281679,
0.3616421223,
0.1923639029,
0.422803849,
0.4561957419,
-0.3294509947,
0.3454746902,
-0.5619757175,
0.3259731829,
0.197046116,
-0.2549986541,
-0.7417194843,
0.0767398849,
0.5379574895,
-0.1799493432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00723v1
|
Improving Semantic Control in Discrete Latent Spaces with Transformer Quantized Variational Autoencoders
| 2024-02-01T16:14:35 | 2024-02-01T16:14:35 |
Yingji Zhang, Danilo S. Carvalho, Marco Valentino, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Andre Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Achieving precise semantic control over the latent spaces of Variational
AutoEncoders (VAEs) holds significant value for downstream tasks in NLP as the
underlying generative mechanisms could be better localised, explained and
improved upon. Recent research, however, has struggled to achieve consistent
results, primarily due to the inevitable loss of semantic information in the
variational bottleneck and limited control over the decoding mechanism. To
overcome these challenges, we investigate discrete latent spaces in Vector
Quantized Variational AutoEncoders (VQVAEs) to improve semantic control and
generation in Transformer-based VAEs. In particular, We propose T5VQVAE, a
novel model that leverages the controllability of VQVAEs to guide the
self-attention mechanism in T5 at the token-level, exploiting its full
generalization capabilities. Experimental results indicate that T5VQVAE
outperforms existing state-of-the-art VAE models, including Optimus, in terms
of controllability and preservation of semantic information across different
tasks such as auto-encoding of sentences and mathematical expressions, text
transfer, and inference. Moreover, T5VQVAE exhibits improved inference
capabilities, suggesting potential applications for downstream natural language
and symbolic reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.2853204608,
-0.1342068017,
0.3083818555,
0.2666518986,
-0.161079511,
0.0273915846,
0.0700376481,
0.0206907578,
-0.0809232891,
0.5124830008,
-0.547291398,
-0.5915518403,
-0.6196959615,
0.1092009619,
-0.4346779287,
0.5330862403,
-0.3332354426,
-0.408719331,
-0.3207103014,
-0.1505401731,
-0.5043063164,
-0.5113976002,
-0.071827203,
-0.1042843312,
0.5035448074,
-0.161111936,
0.6818106771,
0.5114891529,
0.3440412879,
0.3131985366,
-0.1167210788,
-0.0381693766,
-0.4718818069,
0.044415988,
-0.3971557021,
-0.7488837838,
-0.2836044729,
-0.4391823113,
0.4969537854,
0.4677632749,
-0.5975020528,
-0.3861926198,
-0.2212022096,
0.2405544221,
-0.9774239659,
0.1372155845,
-0.4428530037,
0.2927526832,
0.1452445239,
-0.0238692779,
-0.1819434613,
-0.0515827499,
-0.0183271188,
-0.7443412542,
0.3823538721,
-0.2782514393,
0.9245911837,
0.879119575,
-0.4134344757,
0.2550379932,
-0.9383036494,
0.7609255314,
-0.6692337394,
0.6190713644,
0.2955844402,
0.3637631536,
-0.0907176137,
-1.0895065069,
-0.6637771726,
0.0352431014,
-0.0751606673,
0.3939981461,
-0.6688691378,
0.1739383489,
0.2891493738,
0.4394495189,
-0.393835783,
0.0970588326,
-0.0745291412,
-0.1502974927,
0.1975258291,
0.1931563169,
0.2368677258,
-0.4003612101,
-0.4685945213,
-0.2978680432,
-0.3799359202,
0.1077070609,
-0.1504073292,
-0.3492082059,
-0.039156042,
0.4952017963,
-0.3258109689,
0.501412034,
0.1272108257,
0.3363690972,
0.1463261694,
-0.51961869,
-0.4209653437,
-0.6051604152,
0.8573699594,
0.1536367983,
-0.198322475,
-0.5362993479,
-0.2343027741,
0.3364561498,
0.7483459115,
-0.6379080415,
-0.2004519403,
0.4351642728,
-0.3931948841,
-0.2741221786,
0.0084853265,
-0.3058880568,
0.0317011625,
-0.4123326838,
0.3784903884,
-0.7596589923,
-0.1896101236,
0.2956688404,
-0.289586395,
0.8726757765,
0.3473894596,
-1.1721613407,
0.527346313,
0.4344166517,
0.4993119836,
-0.376791954,
-0.1075155213,
-0.2833687961,
0.3599123955,
-0.4858662486,
0.3947479725,
-0.4645395577,
-0.5590369701,
-0.19729729,
-0.0935219377,
-0.0676430166,
-0.5091045499,
0.3820652664,
-0.6493893266,
0.4001450241,
0.0528236665,
-0.6314801574,
0.0268445686,
0.0226428267,
-0.6705729961,
0.8792530298,
0.3444306254,
-0.5394966006,
0.3685205579,
-0.3995046318,
-0.0258728079,
0.0855312273,
-0.6146455407,
-0.5729616284,
0.4284562171,
0.3725477457,
0.4154958427,
-0.1654881984,
0.219537884,
-0.088355422,
-0.0893156081,
0.1842842251,
-0.5659267902,
0.3731215298,
-0.0860876143,
-0.7422348261,
0.4012844265,
-0.658508718,
-0.0371830277,
-0.0643091053,
0.1512585133,
-0.4249512851,
0.1247275844,
-0.2688463032,
0.4837859273,
0.1224921122,
-0.3454088569,
0.2505084872,
-0.4903817475,
0.4832395613,
0.5397797227,
0.1051220447,
0.665828824,
-0.106831342,
0.6897847652,
0.2425325364,
0.3141761422,
-0.0356698073,
-0.0383647494,
-0.9306208491,
-0.2347349077,
0.5030810833,
0.3840326667,
-1.1861070395,
0.673718214,
-0.2583418787,
-0.0923198909,
-0.6329830885,
-0.2327357382,
0.2102082968,
0.252604723,
0.4802386165,
-0.3547831774,
0.0130515723,
-0.8512203693,
0.0467429161,
0.3723590374,
-0.4610886276,
0.3576823771,
0.4953486621,
-0.3027893603,
1.1182696819,
-0.2126033604,
-0.2636722028,
0.3263247311,
0.2282485962,
-0.1509726793,
0.4628113508,
0.3569036424,
-1.1931408644,
-0.0483280793,
-0.1592858732,
-0.6466739178,
-0.1929601878,
-0.1612323821,
-0.2657114863,
0.070498541,
0.6130741239,
-0.5732929111,
0.6918800473,
0.3086570799,
-0.4939551353,
0.1342256069,
-0.3299662173,
-0.1581996977,
-0.9124165177,
-0.0880921856,
-0.4130085707,
-0.4814644158,
-0.2077146173,
-0.0880180225,
0.3921298087,
0.1771067083,
-0.3613980412,
0.1771808118,
-0.2237709612,
-0.000496267,
-0.3297195435,
-0.0209826697,
0.0338663235,
0.6382870674,
0.1565293074,
0.6843803525,
0.4646003842,
-0.6947664022,
0.3685489595,
0.2385422587,
0.2685153484,
0.5017889142,
-0.7766385674,
-0.1061887369,
-0.2971464992,
0.1682238132,
-0.8081727028,
0.0097735645,
-0.0024538101,
-0.5965864062,
0.298425585,
0.2615284324,
-0.269644618,
-0.27459988,
-0.2153480351,
0.2201994956,
0.6045517325,
-0.4129032195,
1.0830470324,
0.0116493786,
0.25745067,
-0.506552279,
-0.6023373008,
0.0218431782,
-0.1348015219,
-0.3296898007,
0.8065814972,
0.0368342362,
0.0104116537,
0.3755335212,
-0.2843228877,
0.0787740201,
-0.0031187157,
0.1642206609,
-0.0172686521,
-0.0400438868,
0.3958252966,
0.2937313318,
-0.5180562735,
0.1024296209,
-0.9876071215,
0.3510002196,
-0.0408940352,
-0.2618405521,
-0.3998347521,
0.4360607862,
0.6188173294,
-0.5239269137,
0.760541141,
0.7195355296,
-0.3514093757,
-0.5297954082,
-0.2097347975,
-0.1416258961,
-0.4923352599,
0.2592960298,
-0.7633001804,
-1.1899694204,
0.371450901,
-0.2191715091,
-0.166906029,
0.8977050185,
0.7772111893,
-0.0933061764,
0.7939475775,
0.9845437407,
0.1663529277,
0.5096020103,
-0.5481560826,
0.0018940354,
-0.7735516429,
-0.3258865774,
-0.2484522909,
0.0442015082,
-1.0205318928,
-0.9671429992,
0.3108087182,
0.0471500792,
-0.1419191808,
0.1847856194,
-0.5526394844,
0.2962613404,
0.5442315936,
-0.1370930225,
0.0875116736,
-0.2098029256,
-0.2449887842,
-0.3615057468,
-1.1041795015,
-0.3042276204,
0.6761950254,
0.2829111516,
0.8095862865,
0.331427604,
0.5693586469,
0.3438799381,
-0.175738439,
-0.5426035523,
0.1065715775,
-0.4438590109,
0.1001263261,
-0.5158914328,
-0.3486707509,
-1.0094870329,
0.5886237025,
-0.0564645231,
-0.59586519,
0.6395776272,
0.0288803,
-0.4448372126,
0.0413793027,
-0.4688709974,
0.9042915702,
-0.0019492912,
-0.5173069239,
-0.047208447,
-0.8647251725,
0.0024586394,
0.016821973,
-0.0950189605,
0.113377735,
-0.4322737157,
0.2821656764,
-0.7676247358,
1.0411087275,
0.0664482415,
-0.3028349578,
0.0490114465,
-0.1054690629,
0.4640474617,
-0.0026670601,
0.3835283816,
0.0720080733,
-0.1149461567,
-0.7497662902,
-0.9601005912,
0.486420393,
-1.0725263357,
-0.3285020292,
-0.2641664445,
-0.286900878,
-0.1123103201,
0.1542889476,
0.4951399267,
0.2165974379,
-0.1202829331,
0.4134463072,
1.1484541893,
-0.3141660392,
0.691210568,
0.414262116,
0.0726667419,
-0.4246678352,
0.894979775,
-0.0302105863,
0.4023108184,
0.9646655321,
0.0666505769,
-0.4285913706,
-0.2966947854,
-0.2222109586,
0.1059486419,
-0.539198041,
-0.1343421787,
-0.824898243,
-0.2624518573,
-0.4406449497,
-0.1386878192,
-0.633990705,
-0.4263074994,
-0.4481253326,
0.0745130107,
0.1132483557,
0.5466473699,
0.010365814,
0.3822950721,
-0.5528004169,
0.675026536,
0.6728773117,
0.4266274869,
-0.2444272786,
-0.351298362,
0.0536692813,
-0.3922948837,
-0.096468538,
-0.7183226347,
0.6111536622,
-0.0524294004,
0.4174715579,
-0.0378800668,
0.0758620948,
0.1109973937,
-0.4194782972,
0.7583344579,
0.1238824949,
-1.2199891806,
0.4110746682,
-0.5066196322,
0.7502734661,
-0.0126753282,
0.1843034476,
-0.4756503999,
-0.4812802374,
-1.0469585657,
-1.0901801586,
0.4727942348,
0.8790934086,
0.2839387357,
0.2835789919,
0.3498776257,
0.0034262193,
0.5212273598,
-0.661547482,
-0.0834245533,
-0.7015898228,
-0.2669239342,
0.2811827064,
-0.2775715888,
0.0041189147,
0.0368850082,
0.3042994738,
-0.2123376727,
0.5474635363,
0.3973045945,
0.2409556657,
0.1278007478,
0.2754846513,
0.5115494132,
0.381071955,
0.142324701,
0.2593007088,
0.2820869982,
-0.2354544699,
0.1238904223,
0.2775095403,
-0.216242969,
-0.0295812935,
0.2720413208,
1.2677643299,
0.0922689438,
-0.2041011006,
0.6641952395,
-0.53469491,
-0.2455598861,
-0.4900914431,
0.3906269073,
-0.1003243551,
0.2740920484,
0.0493197739,
-0.1937460303,
0.1407527328,
0.2109604627,
0.3568781614,
0.0532765724,
-0.2770619094,
-0.1178114787,
1.0444458723,
0.0870590732,
-0.1254989207,
0.4776697159,
-0.0259760879,
-0.3587729335,
0.6519342065,
0.4026982784,
0.9883261919,
-0.4044293761,
0.0760342851,
-0.0499431267,
0.3447875679,
0.4074604809,
0.3451856375,
-0.4519120157,
-0.6965387464,
-0.7051897645,
-0.6580845118,
-0.4127963185,
0.0414098017,
-0.5583577752,
0.0863685235,
-0.1799299866,
0.0231570322,
0.0475162454,
-0.4915587902,
-0.6423484087,
0.6139284372,
0.1845299155,
0.5661210418,
-0.5414301753,
0.8423746228,
0.3806532025,
-0.4229491949,
-0.8651274443,
0.0325324647,
-0.5665545464,
-0.2984541059,
0.3927514851,
-0.2508345842,
-0.3053440154,
0.2484341264,
-0.6468713284,
-1.1764587164,
1.2215908766,
0.0519007146,
-0.6848333478,
-0.0733492076,
0.1413533986,
0.7750532031,
-0.0851723775,
0.2085271776,
0.4137653112,
0.1537329853,
0.2690831721,
-0.7097177505,
-0.1507830024,
-0.2677642107,
0.703931272,
0.4097578228,
-0.8100815415,
0.5842211246,
0.2575217187,
0.1612491608,
-0.2883280814,
1.2206281424,
-0.1596153826,
-0.2918437123,
0.3634162247,
0.6330654621,
0.7340077758,
-0.0842207,
1.4607332945,
-0.2001039237,
0.409701705,
1.0289165974,
0.160507232,
0.6170400977,
0.439095974,
-0.2035907507,
0.492444247,
0.4026801884,
0.0293880925,
0.6419993043,
0.2306803167,
-0.4121026993,
-0.2775926292,
-0.0385558456,
-0.0883839726,
0.5890917182,
0.6026272774,
-0.3164404035,
-0.0671731979,
0.2745390534,
-0.2462165505,
-0.0597321987,
-0.10211844,
0.8839690089,
0.1855089068,
-0.4094668031,
0.7962807417,
0.1944198012,
0.4361807108,
-0.6040589213,
-0.0448261164,
-0.1435167789,
0.1673511416,
-0.0110489111,
-0.3163862526,
0.5565500259,
-0.2394384742,
-0.348129034,
-0.3737178147,
0.7943817973,
-0.4038565457,
-0.1010607779,
0.2400017977,
0.4131783545,
-0.3603459001,
-0.0093652159,
-0.431964159,
-0.1535818577,
-0.2056228817,
-0.3023933172,
0.0580347963,
0.7291377187,
-0.3498065174,
0.4867057502,
0.2943786085,
-0.1822084785,
0.4345358312,
0.118509315,
1.1015789509,
-0.9743180871,
-0.7263749242,
-0.655389607,
0.5434621572,
-0.0539222099,
-0.3164341748,
0.5560443997,
0.1289106458,
0.9338949919,
-0.0914858654,
1.0251450539,
-0.1230891645,
0.149754107,
-0.5692206025,
0.4365344644,
-0.5681580901,
0.0533456951,
0.1154351309,
-0.4953109324,
-0.3972299397,
0.4970920384,
-0.2874142528,
0.0599620454,
0.7287057042,
0.4402106702,
-0.0152660897,
-0.300797224,
0.7321715951,
0.3576467335,
0.5377616286,
0.6512106061,
0.7372856736,
-0.3633331358,
0.2463682443,
-0.31586954,
-0.1046455652,
0.0704989582,
-0.7730892897,
-0.6393257976,
-0.5184440613,
-0.3960048258,
-0.2498164028,
0.0011716428,
0.5243878365,
0.5862886906,
-0.7405079007,
0.1568787843,
-0.7941730618,
0.10093344,
0.0142369969,
-0.2206595689,
0.5100408196,
-0.6314841509,
-0.8187075853,
0.0607829988,
0.5880519152,
0.3053024709,
-0.3465205431,
0.1384719461,
0.2011087686,
0.1375461668,
0.6433698535,
0.1566611826,
-0.9122380614,
0.0890088454,
0.1868101358,
-0.523116231,
0.1007255837,
0.8470765352,
-1.0837128162,
0.7285131216,
0.5080798864,
0.7656893134,
0.8001525402,
-0.0689462349,
0.9925684929,
-0.7778890729,
0.0240543336,
0.5833768249,
0.039420031,
0.1995743513,
-0.2649073601,
0.4545739889,
0.3611323535,
-0.4024817944,
-0.0063095535,
0.1666828841,
-0.970661521,
-0.4229063094,
1.0204092264,
-0.0690553561,
-0.6112523079,
0.0275480114,
-0.0778562948,
0.4534417987,
-0.2467772216,
0.6876636744,
0.5435931683,
-0.1210637316,
-0.3773256838,
-0.5315150619,
0.7161866426,
0.754711628,
-0.9590671062,
-0.1376559436,
0.4616184533,
-0.0547322817,
-0.0901710689,
0.6028015614,
-0.0983275026,
0.3444657624,
-0.0251571853,
0.3984587193,
0.283000052,
-0.1304607987,
-0.7727490664,
0.3305285275,
-0.1991741806,
-0.409222424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00711v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00711v2
|
Explaining Text Classifiers with Counterfactual Representations
| 2024-02-01T16:06:35 | 2024-04-29T16:04:38 |
Pirmin Lemberger, Antoine Saillenfest
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, 62Fxx
|
One well motivated explanation method for classifiers leverages
counterfactuals which are hypothetical events identical to real observations in
all aspects except for one categorical feature. Constructing such
counterfactual poses specific challenges for texts, however, as some attribute
values may not necessarily align with plausible real-world events. In this
paper we propose a simple method for generating counterfactuals by intervening
in the space of text representations which bypasses this limitation. We argue
that our interventions are minimally disruptive and that they are theoretically
sound as they align with counterfactuals as defined in Pearl's causal inference
framework. To validate our method, we conducted experiments first on a
synthetic dataset and then on a realistic dataset of counterfactuals. This
allows for a direct comparison between classifier predictions based on ground
truth counterfactuals - obtained through explicit text interventions - and our
counterfactuals, derived through interventions in the representation space.
Eventually, we study a real world scenario where our counterfactuals can be
leveraged both for explaining a classifier and for bias mitigation.
|
[
-0.3651779294,
-0.9538974166,
0.8882722259,
-0.0587530658,
-0.2588957846,
-0.3643059134,
0.0420191474,
-0.3030555844,
0.0921486989,
0.2124435455,
-0.8443431854,
-0.0637766719,
-0.4470151663,
-0.0404519923,
-0.4830045402,
1.2321825027,
-0.2306384295,
-0.1360644102,
-0.4328769743,
-0.2233284563,
-0.7279428244,
-0.6344724298,
-0.2614226043,
-0.5364607573,
0.6517193913,
0.3658490181,
0.7761263251,
0.4584809542,
0.1483073682,
0.2946467996,
0.2365071028,
0.0794548169,
-0.5541480184,
0.0181245841,
-0.4084778428,
-0.4988852143,
0.0241198223,
0.4536141753,
0.3630176783,
0.6142230034,
0.2014459074,
-0.0549331307,
0.1718289107,
0.3007528782,
-0.6023029685,
0.0613653623,
-0.5502327085,
0.3440357447,
0.0287038907,
-0.33066383,
-0.65743047,
-0.2248604149,
0.2478529215,
-0.857468009,
0.3888550401,
0.0302457958,
0.8440465331,
0.3600635827,
-0.5515608191,
-0.2647213936,
-0.9152827263,
0.9690735936,
-0.1576165408,
0.204161033,
0.2924511433,
0.1472112834,
-0.0090649854,
-0.4395297468,
-0.9831562042,
0.1075968817,
-0.5198768973,
0.3517613113,
-0.3175332546,
-0.2165234536,
0.4168728292,
0.1075516939,
-0.7165102363,
0.0600688159,
-0.0547754914,
-0.2483533472,
0.5767833591,
0.0947260037,
0.2777054906,
-0.006063337,
-0.4777396917,
-0.1457041949,
-0.7733266354,
-0.033282008,
0.2075822055,
0.2739414871,
-0.2093148679,
0.4773778915,
0.3265876174,
0.3194910586,
0.1763028502,
0.051177498,
-0.0008078173,
-0.1616962552,
-0.391831398,
0.4909295142,
0.7090741992,
0.3553879857,
0.2797288597,
-0.0973277986,
0.0430582464,
0.7119669914,
0.5033999085,
-0.8734192848,
-0.0375859998,
0.2327059209,
-0.6070359945,
-0.7420538664,
-0.2520242929,
-0.8064403534,
-0.5411548615,
-0.1593407542,
0.8579508662,
-0.002475637,
-0.0111531215,
-0.2066598088,
-0.2724927366,
-0.1695457995,
0.2306593657,
-0.867428124,
0.2087591887,
0.3848329484,
0.5628558993,
0.2369705141,
-0.066663146,
-0.4609582424,
0.1542887539,
-0.6054483056,
0.7311180234,
-0.8273550272,
-0.6064357162,
0.0436748937,
0.0281809606,
-0.0060772141,
-0.2915043533,
0.5108885765,
-0.2894147336,
0.6528852582,
-0.6084902287,
-0.6807305217,
-0.2585121989,
0.2564926744,
-0.574385643,
1.0738968849,
-0.3276408315,
-0.8354786634,
0.654980123,
-0.796212256,
-0.4256629348,
-0.2539891899,
-0.297888428,
-0.7550243735,
0.0114976373,
0.1903852671,
0.3053044677,
-0.0515196063,
0.5808960199,
-0.2105775625,
-0.5193313956,
0.5633394718,
-0.9830180407,
0.5559093952,
-0.0733000711,
-0.5339609385,
-0.0389595032,
-0.655005753,
-0.4583823383,
0.1738473922,
0.0743913427,
-0.6841517687,
0.2502089143,
0.0806190893,
0.1471224427,
0.0796027258,
-0.6932806969,
0.2278716415,
-0.2321025282,
0.0135025401,
0.7615126371,
0.1173052639,
0.43014431,
-0.4199513197,
0.2699070871,
0.2305350155,
-0.0112907253,
-0.4267967939,
-0.4103382826,
-0.5254398584,
-0.218803212,
0.1553762406,
0.4550209939,
-0.7438717484,
0.050184723,
-0.1522386372,
-0.2953556776,
-0.0168156419,
-0.0956968889,
0.6434730887,
0.8848600984,
0.5250236392,
0.1773800701,
-0.8891949058,
-0.8832128644,
-0.6192489862,
-0.4633898735,
0.0562068224,
0.172907114,
0.6194478869,
-0.1915514022,
1.2126895189,
-0.6165097952,
-0.0997648016,
-0.1045691445,
0.6402125359,
0.1393210292,
0.7669203281,
0.7009041905,
-1.2603111267,
-0.151267767,
-0.2154125124,
-1.0489220619,
-0.2426580042,
-0.7137030959,
-0.0156475529,
0.2806358933,
0.6211788058,
-0.3389776647,
0.8376699686,
0.1936795861,
-0.4613355398,
0.54087466,
0.0561323725,
0.1809460074,
-0.623034656,
0.0072486065,
0.1217851266,
-0.2478087842,
-0.8997759819,
-0.0810517371,
-0.0049853651,
-0.0332840905,
-0.2595036924,
0.6438193321,
0.2031814307,
0.3131221831,
-0.1503062546,
0.3059721291,
0.0469899736,
0.4706636369,
0.4337628782,
0.6435230374,
0.1099496707,
-0.5640303493,
-0.1495242417,
0.2244039774,
0.0982678756,
0.7506251335,
-0.6128175855,
-0.3567373455,
-0.4418088496,
0.3598381281,
-1.2364572287,
-0.0622756518,
0.2994323075,
-0.3295406103,
-0.0171765722,
-0.2702810764,
-0.3196133673,
-0.1658494174,
-0.4019717276,
0.4635187685,
0.5150285363,
-0.9002875686,
0.5910257101,
0.0310384743,
0.2123947591,
-0.3865135014,
-0.9477581382,
0.0171850547,
-0.5781801343,
-0.0580096766,
0.4211620688,
-0.2231910676,
-0.2764383554,
0.08997605,
-0.327840507,
0.0497912727,
0.1975492537,
0.5691289902,
0.5257790089,
-0.1293792278,
0.5534365177,
0.3916811943,
-0.2866986394,
0.2447652519,
-0.2210115939,
0.0890820771,
0.1995034665,
-0.3556425273,
-0.4406303167,
0.2526369691,
0.0815678239,
0.3129326403,
0.7868593931,
0.494527936,
-0.5323995948,
-0.0047212732,
-0.3039387167,
-0.0697044954,
-0.4861540496,
0.1810626537,
-0.4539908469,
-0.5258648396,
0.4400513768,
-0.0830811411,
0.1911287159,
0.4356570244,
0.3996158838,
-0.1760421693,
1.1550792456,
0.6273265481,
0.246263504,
0.5280310512,
-0.010214719,
0.4311740398,
-0.368812412,
-0.2944386899,
-0.5191371441,
-0.1892721355,
-0.6571560502,
-0.2738723457,
0.2928500175,
-0.0434356518,
-0.3835637867,
0.2775504887,
-0.3443194032,
0.5220286846,
0.3782552183,
0.2026678026,
0.1282345057,
-0.0307511128,
-0.3265788257,
-0.4323891401,
-0.759937048,
-0.77037251,
0.7819162011,
0.1661005914,
0.6560546756,
0.1351193488,
0.7219406366,
0.4111034274,
0.7684648633,
-0.6319726706,
0.3118257225,
-0.2522078156,
-0.7020024061,
-0.2621392906,
-0.2799605727,
-0.7786081433,
0.4767173529,
-0.6382290125,
-0.7187528014,
0.544854939,
0.4147748649,
-0.0969621018,
0.060024064,
-0.7008678317,
1.0976361036,
0.1548084915,
-0.6791701913,
-0.2988954484,
-0.263877511,
0.3145163059,
-0.0842027888,
0.5659985542,
0.4386440217,
0.1059238762,
0.688075006,
-0.6704560518,
1.3029968739,
-0.3390467763,
-0.2301599532,
0.1384359896,
0.3049093485,
0.3454862237,
0.0391579717,
0.0731469318,
-0.145680666,
-0.1524691135,
-0.4252334535,
-0.831186235,
0.5523971915,
-0.6426854134,
-0.573692143,
-0.4105564356,
-0.4098316431,
-0.3107159734,
0.150580883,
0.2116316855,
0.8150888085,
-0.5932029486,
-0.1854927391,
0.9381486177,
-0.2791027129,
0.7068920732,
0.4329005778,
-0.268558532,
0.0518200248,
0.9732052684,
0.1263158321,
-0.0755740181,
0.5551922917,
0.531529367,
-0.4847525656,
-0.0070592347,
-0.5512085557,
-0.2459846735,
-0.7143595219,
-0.0578327551,
-0.5960182548,
0.1186878905,
-0.0985616446,
-0.5196106434,
0.0484783836,
-0.4813021123,
-0.3815392256,
-0.2037931532,
0.2605626881,
0.8094174862,
-0.1925979853,
0.4758196473,
-0.5724419355,
0.544005096,
0.6496793628,
0.1026705429,
0.2484384626,
-0.4570397139,
-0.2164807916,
0.089893356,
-0.313259989,
-0.9641209245,
0.1451223791,
0.1267290413,
0.4962904453,
0.5830261707,
0.2100351155,
0.9810864925,
-0.6934614778,
0.8834806085,
0.2040825337,
-1.3582087755,
0.6388629675,
-0.1961763054,
0.0308980141,
0.270927012,
0.7355556488,
-0.5340492725,
-0.4271396399,
-0.7131382227,
-0.4807500243,
0.5261955857,
0.3207976818,
0.1916452199,
0.0113777556,
0.3308781385,
0.2200748324,
0.1233618259,
-0.9928370714,
-0.2245822996,
-0.737593472,
-0.5410439968,
-0.033913061,
-0.3590480089,
-0.2310366184,
0.0898543894,
0.7828406096,
-0.0952134281,
-0.066598773,
0.5898855925,
-0.4447342157,
-0.0965756476,
0.2565741241,
0.7078829408,
0.420396477,
0.1768931299,
0.482737571,
0.1769692898,
-0.3552864194,
0.1867711246,
0.0220141988,
-0.2812553346,
0.1127789095,
0.8563244939,
0.5527890325,
0.4171428084,
-0.581114471,
0.5443692803,
-0.0774876326,
-0.1170992106,
-0.1193770915,
-0.0203339066,
-0.1725237817,
0.1210741177,
0.4969205558,
0.096575588,
0.2456362545,
-0.7141861916,
0.1909689158,
0.29362306,
-0.5806652904,
-0.2525432408,
0.935202837,
0.0625581518,
0.0149342697,
0.0655678809,
-0.1993876398,
-0.7732218504,
0.5916072726,
0.7154846191,
0.5961192846,
-0.1251195967,
0.3747727573,
0.3131104708,
0.3631340265,
0.0403001793,
0.211592868,
-0.155731678,
-0.8264373541,
-0.3234394193,
-0.2127704769,
-0.4268764853,
-0.0906597972,
-0.5489264727,
0.0164859779,
-0.364754796,
0.1150605232,
0.3070792258,
-0.0821910203,
-0.4375707209,
0.4894088805,
0.0389463045,
0.6416273713,
-1.45809865,
0.4545477927,
0.6614793539,
-0.4375579655,
-0.3304070234,
0.2951717675,
0.2802605331,
-0.6220799088,
0.7609887123,
0.2398244441,
-0.0911703333,
-0.6258512139,
-0.6645718217,
-0.2023158669,
0.5546941161,
0.0480027087,
-0.6923714876,
0.3448000252,
0.2552212477,
0.7727623582,
-0.2177489102,
0.1376252323,
0.2280287594,
0.6344609261,
-0.2052153051,
-0.4847735167,
0.5224706531,
-0.1986411661,
0.0836297497,
-0.0948375463,
-0.2370572686,
0.5539396405,
-0.0106391516,
-0.2635855675,
0.0242886785,
0.633654058,
0.0833693743,
0.6041511893,
0.7688457966,
0.4180978537,
0.6930858493,
-0.2532206476,
1.0459965467,
0.1205410361,
0.3408156037,
0.9837979674,
-0.1202454716,
0.40277493,
0.4940945208,
-0.1287175864,
0.7915024161,
0.4918655157,
0.0957976803,
0.5693230629,
0.0206245035,
-0.2519649267,
-0.5434669852,
-0.2949829996,
-0.0431447811,
0.2831006348,
0.3849915564,
-0.1407143772,
-0.2143234164,
0.282356143,
0.0659424141,
0.5559388399,
-0.282643348,
0.758153975,
-0.1476263255,
-0.3917276859,
0.3572500646,
-0.2018308192,
0.5451817513,
-0.0961847082,
-0.4471298456,
-0.0968431607,
0.1048845202,
-0.2591758668,
-0.6256459355,
0.354532212,
0.1240011677,
-0.4721783102,
-0.5281121731,
0.5936806202,
-0.5564126372,
-0.4771899283,
-0.1111070067,
0.0252943113,
-0.0145968338,
0.1786039174,
-0.3522242904,
0.1312125027,
-0.1094896048,
0.0449523404,
0.0687466785,
0.6105614305,
-0.3631273806,
0.3255848587,
0.5484508276,
-0.3362772167,
-0.354184866,
0.1045283303,
0.7292109728,
-0.6718796492,
-0.6945554018,
-1.084269166,
0.4442780316,
-0.0312866308,
-0.2356550097,
0.6604703069,
0.4601133168,
0.6238432527,
0.0000984129,
0.8372614384,
0.1113457978,
0.471927613,
-0.5296126604,
0.4681498706,
-0.651491642,
0.2628242373,
-0.415389955,
-0.3969224095,
-0.2875782251,
0.8163294792,
-0.3663515449,
-0.1811772585,
0.5397932529,
0.518451333,
-0.215354532,
0.3974660337,
0.283124119,
0.4759154022,
0.4112829864,
0.114379786,
0.8056112528,
-0.5969056487,
0.4339778423,
-0.1223116219,
-0.2031918615,
-0.2831655443,
-1.0370419025,
-1.0908757448,
-0.56963557,
-0.4903726578,
-0.2279431075,
0.0832627639,
0.6954495907,
0.4892289639,
-0.7622190714,
0.2473547906,
-0.2455260158,
0.5908758044,
-0.1491258144,
-0.3377017677,
0.2636401355,
-0.3187080026,
-0.842636466,
0.2602328062,
0.1044080928,
0.2204668671,
-0.116559796,
0.1431249231,
-0.0034267921,
0.4119139016,
0.8317821026,
0.1080749854,
-0.4410728812,
-0.6810779572,
-0.3805120289,
0.143904373,
-0.1680894941,
1.0521649122,
-1.2614457607,
0.2966054082,
0.3139661252,
0.4390406609,
0.4822538495,
-0.1414077729,
0.5401470065,
-0.958329916,
0.2370572686,
-0.0555391312,
0.2486852556,
0.0030408024,
-0.5246939063,
0.298967272,
0.3043011129,
-0.0927885398,
-1.0802789927,
0.2944423556,
-0.6302551031,
-0.6313655376,
0.4615981579,
-0.1703844666,
0.0998934135,
-0.2742960453,
-0.1669194549,
0.4141736329,
-0.046046745,
0.9105320573,
0.5490536094,
-0.0811654851,
0.0862617791,
-0.1919216067,
0.3879627287,
0.5335291624,
-0.7355900407,
0.1120903715,
0.4783854783,
0.0427691489,
0.3692495823,
0.3445036411,
-0.0597645827,
0.3649849594,
0.3095192015,
-0.1426163465,
0.129389599,
-0.2413938791,
-0.343693167,
-0.0766662434,
-0.5450029969,
-0.0285281744
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.