id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00707v1
|
Non-Exchangeable Conformal Language Generation with Nearest Neighbors
| 2024-02-01T16:04:04 | 2024-02-01T16:04:04 |
Dennis Ulmer, Chrysoula Zerva, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Quantifying uncertainty in automatically generated text is important for
letting humans check potential hallucinations and making systems more reliable.
Conformal prediction is an attractive framework to provide predictions imbued
with statistical guarantees, however, its application to text generation is
challenging since any i.i.d. assumptions are not realistic. In this paper, we
bridge this gap by leveraging recent results on non-exchangeable conformal
prediction, which still ensures bounds on coverage. The result,
non-exchangeable conformal nucleus sampling, is a novel extension of the
conformal prediction framework to generation based on nearest neighbors. Our
method can be used post-hoc for an arbitrary model without extra training and
supplies token-level, calibrated prediction sets equipped with statistical
guarantees. Experiments in machine translation and language modeling show
encouraging results in generation quality. By also producing tighter prediction
sets with good coverage, we thus give a more theoretically principled way to
perform sampling with conformal guarantees.
|
[
-0.3336845338,
-0.4088778198,
0.708307147,
-0.056135688,
0.0421476103,
-0.3658739924,
-0.3212219775,
-0.6602933407,
0.280649811,
0.3851231337,
-0.5589366555,
-0.3217279315,
-0.6055973768,
0.3148756921,
-0.3772798181,
0.7064461708,
0.158501789,
-0.0661551356,
-0.3475610912,
0.0485060923,
-0.0374617055,
-0.3133308291,
-0.1612710655,
-0.1398167461,
0.0323434025,
0.5104691982,
0.8213202953,
0.4772251844,
0.1253666431,
0.3019303381,
-0.0725294277,
0.042566061,
-0.3951254487,
0.1151238754,
0.1012642682,
-0.6538019776,
-0.357478112,
-0.1479756981,
0.7794338465,
0.7297379375,
-0.1715006381,
-0.0568043143,
-0.3033845425,
0.9902362227,
-0.4267528653,
0.0253580846,
-1.0368146896,
-0.0113588898,
-0.3561580479,
0.1958584934,
-0.5943787694,
-0.7698146701,
0.1186904386,
-0.6477767825,
0.5481006503,
0.0116418106,
0.672196269,
0.120317854,
-0.1314225793,
-0.1570965648,
-0.6085471511,
0.8916674852,
-0.7707935572,
0.4909224808,
0.9349299073,
0.4841307998,
-0.5259956121,
-0.6330062151,
-0.7453377247,
-0.3466094136,
0.152842477,
0.0260898117,
-0.3756815195,
-0.1058696136,
-0.0118398126,
0.3597836792,
-0.5425953269,
-0.3349253237,
-0.6977944374,
-0.1557879448,
0.5185392499,
-0.1145961955,
0.1972608566,
-0.1432230175,
-0.0586901866,
-0.2183678299,
-0.7495639324,
-0.039688129,
0.6779047251,
0.4661974609,
-0.2269713879,
0.6683093309,
-0.4667353928,
0.8856488466,
0.439999789,
0.4897943735,
0.3929364383,
-0.282148838,
-0.0674845576,
-0.0232784301,
0.8305255771,
0.2693067491,
0.3690123558,
-0.268686831,
-0.2469631881,
-0.0583311431,
0.3288477361,
-0.6829963923,
-0.5608737469,
0.2301156819,
-0.535291791,
-0.6184294224,
0.1708054543,
-1.0609394312,
0.0956239477,
0.0365705341,
-0.0368254855,
-0.6590653062,
-0.4860490859,
-0.1550657153,
-0.0741985738,
-0.2138235867,
-0.0167292412,
-1.0066206455,
0.0712607875,
0.2388287634,
0.8385792375,
-0.1401057839,
-0.1209396347,
-0.2464600503,
0.2568546534,
-0.5895576477,
1.11652565,
-0.806740582,
-0.4439969659,
0.0727085471,
-0.2545281053,
0.2182919085,
-0.6346036196,
0.0144343637,
-0.46324718,
0.0794452205,
-0.0452633686,
-0.6251356602,
0.1810649037,
0.0806092545,
-0.8808805346,
0.8565199971,
0.6708371043,
-0.6625635028,
0.2962334454,
-0.166335538,
-0.3093017638,
-0.0269112419,
-0.1713200808,
-0.7858720422,
0.3012503088,
-0.0288748629,
0.1593271345,
-0.0715030283,
-0.0138348043,
-0.5623825192,
-0.121078752,
0.4796804786,
-0.0351116173,
0.1405884922,
0.3384186327,
-0.4160602093,
0.0654931515,
-0.7725920081,
0.5504927039,
-0.2146090418,
-0.0712272748,
-0.0608619303,
-0.2741500735,
0.1874359399,
0.136198923,
0.2682342827,
-0.6335630417,
-0.0764705464,
-0.7455095053,
0.6073873639,
0.8051511645,
0.0773165971,
0.9249212742,
-0.6851525307,
0.6212570071,
0.0069538462,
-0.0543445051,
0.1271323711,
-0.6814066768,
-0.1506697834,
0.0412518904,
0.3554782867,
0.0647289604,
-0.8781110048,
0.3296867311,
-0.1675879061,
-0.8829491735,
-0.2354705781,
-0.0882469192,
0.4251805544,
0.2346612662,
0.3663057387,
0.3928428292,
-0.4828939438,
-0.8891764283,
-0.108398512,
-0.4625786245,
-0.1606708169,
0.1285145581,
0.0748256072,
-0.3746601045,
1.0458469391,
-0.4304180145,
-0.1713738889,
-0.3418557644,
0.1389581114,
0.0558627062,
0.4746025801,
0.4392284751,
-0.821886301,
-0.6837495565,
0.004905879,
-0.4845680892,
-0.1631804705,
-0.1257904023,
-0.2271677703,
0.5431213379,
0.6799279451,
-0.1748011559,
0.3317864835,
1.0322593451,
-0.0108356168,
0.3550606072,
-0.3111420274,
-0.1325597167,
-1.2271074057,
0.0017512521,
0.0273894966,
-0.2974168956,
-0.7640743256,
-0.3028513491,
0.1760786474,
0.1586600393,
-0.2177293897,
0.5922902226,
-0.3696032166,
-0.0464912951,
-0.6178563833,
0.1321278512,
-0.3656418025,
0.1146981418,
0.5679241419,
0.910959661,
0.3641574979,
-0.660984695,
-0.3004091084,
0.5117734671,
-0.2313347757,
0.5987198949,
-0.4136906266,
-0.0394556895,
-0.1167124584,
0.3767699599,
-0.7470405102,
-0.1774091274,
-0.1094108,
-0.791326046,
0.1792383045,
0.2102531195,
-0.1899811029,
-0.1281129271,
-0.0664901584,
0.5950498581,
0.8447480798,
-0.4716627002,
0.178129077,
0.575976193,
-0.1331075281,
-0.2267351747,
-0.6837288737,
-0.1660316885,
0.0304399915,
-0.5024257302,
0.1206440181,
-0.2384055555,
-0.1366648823,
-0.0844112784,
-0.1110749394,
-0.3590177,
-0.3077475727,
0.3545149565,
0.1666660011,
-0.0838548765,
-0.107217662,
0.228055656,
-0.359231025,
-0.0058800103,
-0.4427163601,
0.2679429948,
-0.2740131319,
-0.0732011348,
-0.2588194609,
0.2536995709,
0.272908777,
0.1426623017,
0.5221739411,
0.0483276248,
-0.5932829976,
-0.317812264,
-0.3599482775,
-0.2416590452,
-0.495850563,
0.1828280091,
-0.4522614479,
-0.6114401817,
0.3266552985,
0.0458963551,
-0.0609720573,
0.4511328042,
0.5387251377,
0.0995024145,
0.5983862281,
0.5859654546,
0.2825429142,
0.4751533568,
0.0416424386,
0.0853740573,
-0.8066251278,
-0.0914162695,
-0.5061445832,
-0.0071639367,
-0.7756035328,
-0.61314255,
0.3063345551,
0.1240539551,
0.2395756692,
0.5828255415,
-0.625970602,
0.4655840695,
0.6390031576,
-0.042791266,
0.2240041494,
-0.070771426,
0.0078841383,
-0.264027983,
-0.4883538187,
-0.5257729292,
1.2180429697,
-0.045287624,
0.5407071114,
0.009526561,
0.8870584369,
0.1263512671,
0.6030715704,
-0.2170693427,
0.4804447889,
0.0299692471,
-0.4499105513,
-0.5342493653,
-0.7586553693,
-1.0134007931,
-0.1682730913,
-0.2805806696,
-0.6566799879,
0.2035658509,
0.262329638,
-0.0295514464,
0.5381084681,
-0.2420441061,
0.2382860482,
0.6296290755,
0.0345517173,
0.0733100697,
-0.6759854555,
0.2905110419,
-0.5308736563,
0.2550182343,
-0.0127966404,
0.2743486762,
0.2901746631,
-0.480905652,
0.6057022214,
-0.1212663949,
-0.0660290942,
0.5725492835,
0.3833347559,
0.5598875284,
0.0426628739,
-0.5716232657,
0.4999901652,
0.2966809869,
-0.4082697332,
-0.235006243,
0.5740306377,
-0.72872895,
-0.1014543697,
-0.3917956054,
-0.6061584949,
-0.3119597435,
0.2969287336,
0.930567801,
0.0029090135,
-0.3646481931,
-0.0079270341,
0.4976705313,
-0.1620456278,
0.1159604564,
0.1484961361,
0.0285106022,
-0.7057483196,
1.0256104469,
-0.0153278913,
0.695856154,
0.4632695019,
0.403737098,
-0.4978447556,
-0.6314352155,
-0.4767817855,
0.0835387558,
-0.3639573157,
-0.3651103079,
-0.6266525388,
-0.2087265402,
-0.753695488,
-0.6320438385,
-0.4847572446,
-0.7162597775,
0.0425302424,
-0.1411476284,
0.3036061823,
1.07837677,
-0.6045337319,
0.2935233712,
-0.9996983409,
0.4110040665,
-0.1311862469,
0.2812458575,
-0.0892279819,
-0.2356021851,
-0.1683425754,
0.2958910167,
-0.2069132924,
-1.0019617081,
0.3489381671,
0.0700090304,
0.5056173205,
0.195043847,
0.4928550124,
0.4990190864,
-0.6825477481,
0.7333369851,
0.2664650977,
-0.9608284235,
0.5991593599,
-0.4530657232,
0.1897096187,
0.8281220794,
-0.0236206818,
-0.457331419,
-1.2346473932,
-1.0387581587,
-0.790261507,
0.6268612742,
0.7018386722,
0.1618587673,
-0.4353273809,
0.6069692969,
0.2126396298,
0.24395895,
-0.8093941808,
-0.1706307977,
-0.3939959407,
-0.2776128352,
0.0759329051,
-0.0554980114,
0.2574439645,
0.1911367476,
0.9156425595,
-0.1859736443,
0.4416573346,
0.3093374968,
0.1789765507,
-0.7060077786,
0.0227647889,
0.9264385104,
0.5273593664,
-0.2862157524,
-0.017876029,
0.1513451636,
-0.505212903,
0.0827381462,
-0.2493930608,
-0.3106140196,
0.2467171103,
-0.040829014,
0.1777974814,
-0.1646158546,
-0.7112815976,
0.5980216861,
-0.1969711781,
-0.4810785055,
-0.7111632824,
-0.0813300908,
0.0011935594,
0.209827736,
-0.0169721153,
0.1625883132,
-0.023852637,
0.0232157875,
0.8257607818,
0.5658490658,
-0.6697359681,
-0.6365222335,
0.8298299909,
-0.1160033345,
-0.2075728327,
0.5507394671,
-0.3932904303,
-0.0786063373,
0.7208328843,
0.8935939074,
0.8321197033,
-0.3564364016,
0.2921731472,
0.8042298555,
0.3141420484,
-0.1927016675,
0.2234891802,
0.0616139397,
-0.5836567283,
0.1373747736,
-0.6094431281,
-0.5879415274,
0.0945016369,
-0.8555060625,
0.1725301743,
-0.4173707068,
-0.1306655258,
-0.3116295934,
-0.3555983305,
0.0507600866,
0.0848629922,
0.0512577295,
0.9223566651,
-0.8552094698,
0.941018939,
0.5404075384,
-0.0490989126,
-0.5374161601,
0.4521217048,
-0.2412094772,
-0.5855827928,
0.5399435163,
0.1301631629,
-0.1364571005,
-0.2423253804,
-0.290241152,
-1.0194268227,
0.8218733072,
0.2578643262,
-0.4694247544,
-0.0545196347,
0.3284849524,
0.4883072674,
-0.1040383503,
0.1308118105,
0.2009806186,
0.670723021,
0.5105272532,
-0.5410445929,
0.2076244652,
-0.2609346211,
0.2136807144,
0.5743954182,
-0.5078017116,
0.8342447281,
-0.3497937322,
-0.197020933,
0.6647868752,
1.2683149576,
0.5929054022,
0.3275905848,
0.5966921449,
0.3432792127,
0.8549803495,
0.2468330711,
1.1086828709,
-0.6146425009,
0.1536700726,
1.2067050934,
-0.2707272172,
0.9022072554,
0.5333105326,
-0.0570538752,
0.3428191543,
0.5972031951,
-0.0049413,
0.662704587,
0.358777523,
-0.2790000141,
-0.2234419286,
0.2060529888,
-0.5802484155,
0.0820176974,
0.2244091332,
-0.1724452078,
-0.3513086736,
-0.2369544059,
-0.1873089373,
0.6261029243,
0.0446404256,
0.7231528163,
0.0429385751,
-0.6919316649,
0.4144876897,
0.0498989597,
0.6152140498,
-0.4361563325,
-0.159949407,
0.0083239889,
0.0944427252,
-0.1665306985,
-0.6183695197,
0.6997767091,
-0.3138994575,
-0.377269417,
-0.2528464496,
0.4080019593,
-0.5351167321,
-0.5737567544,
-0.0288768988,
0.2629031241,
0.3280956149,
-0.0086608808,
-0.2153145224,
-0.5004261732,
0.1303137839,
-0.1465755105,
0.4245000184,
0.7239339352,
-0.1539497077,
0.3331629038,
0.8437187672,
0.5520740151,
0.2392762005,
-0.5151679516,
0.6016069651,
-0.5805013776,
-0.6621312499,
-0.644041419,
-0.0005664831,
0.2625517249,
-0.307988137,
0.5040811896,
0.5891240239,
0.79060781,
-0.0639332011,
0.9449831247,
0.0363074057,
0.3981205225,
-0.4626577497,
0.7661406398,
-0.2417933196,
-0.204730466,
-0.1758161485,
-1.0101634264,
-0.1134619862,
0.8943083882,
-0.1284805685,
0.1058265418,
0.8339150548,
0.6952952743,
0.0746993124,
0.4065279365,
0.6017197371,
0.0734900907,
0.3183422983,
0.6398109198,
0.6717602015,
-0.44547984,
0.5073644519,
-0.3947528303,
-0.2251154333,
0.1224483326,
-0.9088147879,
-0.8234660625,
-0.9705229402,
-0.0632791668,
-0.8413527012,
-0.3115736842,
0.7311451435,
0.6866157055,
-0.7261295319,
-0.1822927147,
-0.626496017,
-0.0655064061,
-0.0612190068,
-0.2256197035,
0.1418030411,
-0.4763166606,
-1.1551754475,
0.3282344043,
0.0203713179,
0.4619370997,
-0.0573093668,
-0.0830316022,
0.1594341844,
0.2904618084,
0.0936729908,
0.446552664,
-0.3849654496,
-0.1313721538,
-0.0103017492,
-0.2752296031,
0.1317021698,
0.6603301167,
-0.7817866206,
0.3073389232,
0.5545472503,
0.5046764612,
0.3702961504,
-0.0549827442,
0.9631290436,
-0.8115000129,
0.3122483492,
0.2022536248,
0.078948386,
0.1247793734,
-0.6453587413,
0.3034745455,
-0.1212200522,
-0.6087273359,
-0.9156639576,
0.7029080391,
-0.8180773258,
-0.2992802262,
1.338678956,
-0.0361643583,
-0.5048834085,
-0.1459032744,
0.2988765538,
0.1438307613,
-0.5978120565,
1.0073183775,
0.60766083,
-0.1622310728,
0.2919064164,
-0.5372002721,
0.741194129,
0.5171505213,
-0.9775499701,
0.2897613943,
0.451518476,
0.2086749375,
0.3170821965,
1.0305684805,
-0.3127212226,
0.2625578642,
-0.0491091982,
0.1356420815,
-0.0700689405,
-0.199636206,
-0.2381992489,
-0.0104372744,
0.0080838017,
0.0358523317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01777v1
|
On the Psychology of GPT-4: Moderately anxious, slightly masculine, honest, and humble
| 2024-02-01T15:58:13 | 2024-02-01T15:58:13 |
Adrita Barua, Gary Brase, Ke Dong, Pascal Hitzler, Eugene Vasserman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
We subject GPT-4 to a number of rigorous psychometric tests and analyze the
results. We find that, compared to the average human, GPT-4 tends to show more
honesty and humility, and less machiavellianism and narcissism. It sometimes
exhibits ambivalent sexism, leans slightly toward masculinity, is moderately
anxious but mostly not depressive (but not always). It shows human-average
numerical literacy and has cognitive reflection abilities that are above human
average for verbal tasks.
|
[
-0.658614397,
-0.7599346042,
0.8062508702,
0.2499167025,
0.0154687911,
0.2481549233,
-0.2093391716,
-0.5482239127,
0.050291907,
-0.5114781857,
-0.5849422216,
-0.3303869367,
-0.7184683084,
0.4480957985,
0.1674284488,
1.2476093769,
0.074618347,
0.1908775568,
0.4799209237,
0.1086172238,
-0.444170922,
-0.9357995987,
-0.6955063343,
-0.5492337942,
0.4449197054,
0.0569529198,
1.0083987713,
0.0508770086,
0.5999824405,
0.369273752,
0.2314408123,
-0.6687102914,
-0.6280350685,
0.018795345,
-0.4212534428,
-0.512250185,
-0.8720249534,
0.7715964913,
0.2660427094,
0.2989943027,
-0.015739629,
0.1063772812,
0.1724925935,
0.5005469918,
0.0993297622,
0.5094221234,
-0.0286326911,
0.104303807,
-0.3417965174,
-0.0555775091,
0.1341606379,
-0.6229729056,
0.3540038466,
-0.9185599685,
0.5772433281,
-0.0059076836,
0.8943040371,
-0.2199656963,
-0.6148844957,
-0.2413847744,
-0.4310269952,
0.8594594598,
-0.1743588448,
0.3601741791,
0.8679713607,
0.0290045142,
0.2160978615,
-0.5806851983,
-0.3045887947,
-0.2929568589,
-0.2793070674,
0.3685927391,
-0.2792101502,
0.181717664,
0.343444258,
0.6405161619,
-0.8610721827,
-0.3243483305,
-0.4030188322,
-0.3475845158,
0.3894671202,
0.121051535,
0.2053960264,
-0.0219544675,
-0.2186112106,
0.2308645248,
-0.1667084098,
0.259862721,
0.7474115491,
-0.0612563565,
0.0405137688,
0.2400721461,
-0.023756627,
0.1575412452,
0.5459654927,
-0.156598568,
0.5249442458,
-0.669402957,
0.0826931745,
-0.2472576648,
0.4900730252,
0.6786852479,
0.3248127699,
-0.0972288251,
-0.3204751909,
0.417147249,
0.6281054616,
-0.9272776842,
-0.4561830461,
-0.1323849857,
-0.5233622789,
-0.3077024221,
-0.0033252628,
-0.6023676395,
0.0869323388,
-0.3534765244,
0.2638717294,
-0.5769147277,
-0.1961247474,
-0.2945140898,
-0.3240044415,
0.6190476418,
0.3246219158,
-1.2018584013,
0.703168273,
0.5954809189,
0.9681466818,
-0.3326935172,
-0.1513221562,
0.0668738633,
-0.2047647238,
-0.5036636591,
0.6946992874,
-0.6242014766,
-0.5447773337,
-0.547391057,
0.1711908877,
-0.1065841019,
-0.0373621508,
1.0097163916,
-0.1554679722,
0.4857509732,
-1.0277152061,
-0.0842828378,
-0.3636018038,
0.8301009536,
-0.3728379905,
1.0750521421,
0.7170314789,
-0.8146588802,
0.5204889774,
-0.6957132816,
0.0420847014,
-0.02538234,
-0.525567472,
-0.070865199,
0.0973802358,
0.0201166403,
0.2309142947,
-0.1809470206,
-0.1283597052,
-0.4069677591,
-0.7342000604,
0.4534780085,
-0.3344941139,
0.3188582361,
0.257193625,
-0.4796046019,
-0.2599536777,
-0.1271708608,
0.3957976699,
-0.074465923,
-0.2513143122,
-0.0956278667,
-0.5429665446,
-0.1798631996,
0.2919622064,
0.527706027,
-0.715780437,
0.4160312414,
-0.2063168734,
0.3296260536,
0.845318377,
0.2741034329,
0.4308386445,
-0.4438737333,
0.8826880455,
-0.1383198798,
0.3758338392,
0.6355560422,
-0.9793303609,
-0.2075360417,
-0.4499595165,
-0.059930563,
0.6095836759,
-0.4765149951,
0.2762374282,
0.075970985,
-0.4794225693,
-0.2295852154,
0.2445757091,
0.6316199303,
0.5264394879,
0.014965876,
-0.5821097493,
-0.1938635111,
-1.2349667549,
-0.6186656952,
-0.1457685977,
-0.192570135,
0.1378477514,
0.6198652983,
-0.2622583508,
0.4523910284,
-0.5679751635,
-0.4172451794,
-0.0687914938,
0.4372624755,
0.5516368151,
0.2097583264,
0.7614601851,
-0.785703063,
-0.1669168472,
-0.1573890895,
-0.7802122235,
0.0346665345,
0.4753762484,
-0.2010863423,
-0.1614340097,
0.0833631977,
-0.7474371195,
0.3702622354,
0.1240096241,
-0.7378804684,
0.3964549601,
-0.3016772866,
0.5563594699,
-0.4026681781,
-0.1805909276,
0.0449019372,
0.0205997936,
-0.7407246828,
-0.1383606941,
-0.1403598487,
-0.0846513286,
-0.0346534774,
0.0772864521,
-0.4842388034,
-0.3800453544,
0.1698697656,
0.1027469039,
0.0144436974,
0.6254473329,
0.0002361379,
0.9084602594,
0.5638964772,
-0.4277301729,
0.3839845061,
0.2688602209,
0.3291905224,
0.9254344106,
-0.7187533379,
0.4956874847,
-0.1618123949,
0.1627360433,
-0.9262635112,
-0.6359623075,
0.0991787463,
-0.5256280899,
0.2639147639,
0.273304075,
-0.0832502693,
-0.480976522,
-0.9451143146,
0.4357662797,
0.6286669374,
0.1403323859,
0.4730553627,
-0.0817393437,
-0.6675800681,
-0.1503331065,
-0.7835265398,
-0.0286394674,
-0.315636903,
-0.3321031034,
0.3899652064,
-0.310759604,
-0.2796971798,
-0.2124548852,
-0.0867463499,
-0.4059271514,
-0.1166266203,
0.0540284514,
0.1289771795,
-0.1346311122,
-0.1400965303,
-0.2221801877,
-0.3133068085,
0.3007995188,
0.3036301434,
0.3180062473,
-1.2501146793,
-0.088855803,
-0.6198467016,
0.3135408163,
0.4004557133,
0.111908555,
0.0480217449,
0.8716105223,
-0.2579605877,
0.607498765,
-0.096288152,
-0.6003478765,
-0.4382235706,
0.3467182517,
-0.8774058819,
-0.4890538752,
0.7128578424,
0.3665404022,
-0.2685540318,
0.4354233742,
0.8546238542,
-0.2560931742,
1.055729866,
0.3672809899,
0.1615145653,
0.2199144065,
-0.0773399174,
0.2747637033,
-0.561070621,
0.0629680678,
-0.3652947843,
-0.734087348,
-1.143283844,
-0.0360374302,
0.3550343513,
-0.4742896855,
-0.8169701099,
-0.3251537979,
-0.7383347154,
0.4248393476,
0.6432198286,
0.2335965186,
0.209806934,
-0.6442456245,
0.4911938906,
-0.6562888026,
0.0644929558,
-0.7959456444,
1.175083518,
0.4879903197,
0.6479532123,
0.8118051887,
0.473443985,
0.1754322797,
0.5877479911,
-0.6077563763,
0.4141019881,
0.167867139,
-1.2911872864,
-0.2983533144,
-0.3126437664,
-0.7556679845,
0.0985563099,
0.0054876381,
-0.820227325,
0.169467628,
0.1799245179,
-0.3649975657,
-0.2865146399,
-0.9384800196,
0.7138384581,
-0.2870436013,
-0.2503936589,
0.4764469862,
-0.9925038218,
0.9053370953,
-0.3475505114,
0.14897798,
-0.1264237911,
-0.4259186983,
0.4792616963,
0.0514339134,
0.6264995933,
-0.3591659963,
0.0780868083,
0.0869326368,
0.2664732933,
0.3490051329,
0.273193568,
-0.0950227305,
-0.0234879479,
-0.0478388555,
-0.6003497243,
-0.7579587102,
0.6687071919,
-1.2643216848,
-0.3276502192,
-1.0342698097,
-0.5476870537,
-0.4789661765,
0.1842456013,
0.6556367874,
0.4520555139,
-0.4885781705,
-0.0406834893,
0.6861165166,
-0.0973364785,
0.4476920962,
0.1933922917,
-0.3936255872,
-0.4693325162,
0.5167455077,
0.1861620545,
0.4102609456,
-0.1271685809,
0.3980617225,
-0.636661768,
-0.3075643182,
-0.28407076,
0.2972767651,
-0.4501391351,
0.0937855393,
-0.4967094362,
0.0767599493,
-0.399451077,
-0.2531574368,
-0.4308146536,
-0.3223910034,
-0.0094721075,
-0.5243973732,
0.4167120159,
0.7575756907,
0.2676198184,
0.2205302864,
-0.2603448629,
0.5406511426,
0.557177484,
0.4322764874,
-0.8027246594,
-0.6796087623,
0.4604058862,
-0.2841754854,
-0.7927584648,
-0.8014991283,
0.1561934352,
0.4049076438,
0.1965303719,
0.8039493561,
-0.0850202143,
0.5530952811,
-0.0862497836,
1.1330157518,
0.1633834094,
-0.9376652241,
0.0118553098,
-0.9120621681,
0.0119544463,
0.8321132064,
0.5016151667,
-0.0274724811,
-0.5331345201,
-0.8628441691,
-0.2706405222,
0.5871132612,
0.9332374334,
0.2440630198,
0.0626505315,
0.6647355556,
0.2348574549,
0.3537860811,
-1.2541596889,
-0.387788713,
-0.984418869,
-0.1087420955,
-0.3266170919,
-0.1012045741,
-0.3827164471,
-0.5836399198,
0.3017892838,
0.0337472036,
1.0067149401,
0.2208568603,
0.3357023299,
0.2121586651,
0.5225027204,
0.8728895187,
0.6523325443,
-0.8743882179,
0.5393402576,
0.2535328269,
-1.0441846848,
0.7472310662,
0.2000371963,
0.2539639175,
-0.056961868,
0.4291072488,
0.2506201565,
-0.0252599698,
0.1259776056,
0.8749610782,
-0.3873564303,
-0.5228777528,
-0.3816242516,
0.0975117385,
0.0899159163,
0.2409595698,
0.2722521424,
-0.0184634179,
0.6279488802,
-1.1930539608,
0.0445389971,
0.128675282,
-0.45894292,
-0.9968340993,
0.6313796043,
0.3744949996,
-0.34966892,
0.525853157,
-1.0477062464,
-0.812977612,
-0.0121517573,
0.582680285,
0.712338984,
-0.2773430943,
0.1454344243,
0.2476156652,
0.5857385397,
-0.1058308333,
0.9184091091,
0.1787330657,
-0.7276158333,
0.022235496,
-0.3801742792,
-0.4274478853,
-0.0109569291,
-0.7921707034,
-0.1207007915,
-0.5606614351,
-0.9655954838,
-0.4346383214,
0.4201690853,
-0.8462437391,
0.5750709772,
-0.1481835991,
0.2858658135,
-0.8670588136,
0.6641259193,
0.9116506577,
-0.4244607687,
-1.0701296329,
-0.0583938658,
0.2842070758,
-0.6548405886,
0.901781559,
0.3515156507,
-0.1887014508,
-0.1117552444,
-0.1793078333,
-0.7451746464,
1.2075760365,
0.554711163,
-0.0771389604,
-0.2984432876,
-0.2822330594,
0.7650433779,
-0.0256442055,
0.5863173008,
1.0126260519,
0.8930469155,
-0.3249474466,
-0.9355963469,
0.0609956719,
-0.4345199168,
-0.0728534609,
0.1739555299,
-0.7906724811,
1.2348473072,
-0.0948586464,
0.0668510646,
-0.2107097059,
0.3684957623,
0.4396262765,
0.582423389,
0.4023014903,
0.3841577172,
0.8991422653,
-0.3172898889,
1.3129495382,
-0.118774958,
0.2619081736,
0.6202081442,
-0.1799686998,
0.0314953588,
0.3641000688,
-0.3793829083,
0.3283860683,
0.853317976,
0.3631436527,
0.6245571971,
-0.0481260344,
-0.294539988,
0.2436331958,
0.4237649143,
-0.3493965268,
0.7784976363,
0.0928037837,
-0.2186027914,
0.055109717,
-0.1064489484,
0.314991802,
-0.2709195018,
-0.3264317214,
0.2211172581,
0.257145077,
-0.3859751225,
0.3940521479,
-0.1389388144,
0.4498984814,
-0.4778490067,
0.1793729365,
-0.2204108685,
0.2330265343,
-0.1613568664,
-0.8845205307,
0.276758939,
0.0808061436,
-0.2605416477,
-0.577121377,
0.7421467304,
0.0906374902,
-0.1100065187,
0.0452564843,
0.5275310874,
0.5924136043,
-0.3167934418,
-0.7687904239,
-0.2277721763,
0.1296465993,
-0.8520952463,
0.3238778412,
0.7071415186,
-0.0814493299,
0.5646001697,
0.4287737906,
-0.0267858803,
-0.1924659163,
-0.1329357475,
0.4646295607,
-1.0348553658,
-0.5886314511,
-0.8183081746,
0.0602134541,
-0.2124804705,
-0.7423402667,
0.884219408,
0.4030292034,
0.1147162244,
-0.1337222308,
0.5417926311,
-0.0688681081,
0.5053877831,
-0.3741217256,
0.4298367798,
0.0475015529,
-0.1114250496,
-0.6563006043,
-1.2678589821,
-0.049777057,
0.9007391334,
-0.4983106554,
0.6574241519,
1.0430235863,
0.5618056655,
-0.0540856421,
0.3962714076,
0.3979280293,
0.3051580489,
0.3962319195,
0.5209437609,
0.8519182801,
0.0125690391,
0.2131601572,
-0.1492379606,
-0.5812319517,
0.2401738763,
-0.7409870028,
-0.8999589086,
-0.2229273617,
-0.0517198294,
-0.1110193431,
-0.0721214637,
0.6749441624,
0.4550859034,
0.0186850596,
0.1915735304,
0.0715432763,
-0.4322065115,
-0.2786037624,
-0.2033843845,
0.195674181,
0.0067190477,
-0.6356610656,
-0.0586536787,
0.2458428442,
0.3529030383,
-0.0975983962,
-0.1444685608,
0.374907285,
0.2115680724,
0.4583728313,
-0.2304896563,
-0.4839461744,
-0.7809733152,
0.1189184338,
-0.1706382334,
0.1221624687,
0.5294562578,
-0.3298107386,
0.1980860829,
0.0452928133,
0.1186678261,
0.5015740395,
0.5670850873,
0.6910921931,
-0.6598101258,
0.2243340611,
0.6561531425,
0.1743897796,
0.2246790975,
-0.5622205138,
0.6570432186,
0.449295342,
-0.9221749902,
-0.6591103673,
0.3170990348,
-1.1544412374,
0.2111113071,
0.9082815051,
-0.2753921747,
0.0276864674,
-0.5724161267,
-0.442227453,
-0.1087744981,
-0.7820970416,
0.4525587261,
1.0908169746,
-0.8555372357,
0.0915575251,
-1.2129596472,
0.7612376809,
0.041951932,
-0.8081309795,
-0.2695420682,
0.24575679,
0.5655323863,
0.0216311552,
0.9457443953,
-0.2353390902,
0.4133803844,
0.1437223852,
0.0587452091,
0.3222447932,
0.257419914,
-0.0354620181,
0.3210514784,
0.2448922098,
-0.1866460741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00667v1
|
Improving Weak-to-Strong Generalization with Scalable Oversight and Ensemble Learning
| 2024-02-01T15:30:19 | 2024-02-01T15:30:19 |
Jitao Sang, Yuhang Wang, Jing Zhang, Yanxu Zhu, Chao Kong, Junhong Ye, Shuyu Wei, Jinlin Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a follow-up study to OpenAI's recent superalignment work
on Weak-to-Strong Generalization (W2SG). Superalignment focuses on ensuring
that high-level AI systems remain consistent with human values and intentions
when dealing with complex, high-risk tasks. The W2SG framework has opened new
possibilities for empirical research in this evolving field. Our study
simulates two phases of superalignment under the W2SG framework: the
development of general superhuman models and the progression towards
superintelligence. In the first phase, based on human supervision, the quality
of weak supervision is enhanced through a combination of scalable oversight and
ensemble learning, reducing the capability gap between weak teachers and strong
students. In the second phase, an automatic alignment evaluator is employed as
the weak supervisor. By recursively updating this auto aligner, the
capabilities of the weak teacher models are synchronously enhanced, achieving
weak-to-strong supervision over stronger student models.We also provide an
initial validation of the proposed approach for the first phase. Using the SciQ
task as example, we explore ensemble learning for weak teacher models through
bagging and boosting. Scalable oversight is explored through two auxiliary
settings: human-AI interaction and AI-AI debate. Additionally, the paper
discusses the impact of improved weak supervision on enhancing weak-to-strong
generalization based on in-context learning. Experiment code and dataset will
be released at https://github.com/ADaM-BJTU/W2SG.
|
[
-0.0596845075,
-0.275234133,
0.1294430643,
-0.0907047018,
0.153102532,
-0.2801938951,
-0.3862615228,
-0.646948576,
-0.0700548589,
0.1246943995,
-0.2610584795,
-0.1158686578,
-0.735839963,
-0.1601962894,
-0.365724057,
1.382224679,
-0.0753304511,
0.3871562481,
-0.3847884834,
-0.2504454851,
-0.4885334969,
-0.2203188241,
-0.4769588113,
-0.5435333848,
0.1954167038,
0.629811883,
0.9373781085,
0.6514825225,
0.6957909465,
0.2666538656,
-0.041946888,
0.1244623438,
-0.7877010703,
0.0953138098,
-0.5208967924,
-0.6351839304,
-0.5083299279,
0.0314230062,
0.7907500863,
0.7310003042,
-0.2136157155,
0.1023367122,
0.3391329646,
0.319594264,
-0.7858030796,
0.2032587975,
-0.3595248759,
-0.0955034867,
-0.1126681492,
0.3985903561,
-0.1164127439,
0.1587772816,
0.2345585078,
-0.7521484494,
0.3691088557,
0.0897765681,
1.0366617441,
0.6194638014,
-0.3489991128,
0.205919072,
-0.793941617,
0.9588808417,
-0.3205906153,
0.238568604,
0.5056275725,
0.2838016748,
-0.1416977346,
-0.7455529571,
-0.376596421,
0.0835232288,
-0.1889343262,
0.4874361753,
-0.101337634,
0.1756130308,
0.2346695513,
0.4631803036,
-0.4086196721,
0.453954339,
-0.4049463868,
-0.0623562224,
0.6828872561,
0.0949268863,
0.0474986024,
0.2199224681,
-0.4162609875,
-0.2924561501,
-0.5201615095,
-0.0323189571,
0.4092051685,
0.0877974033,
-0.1875419766,
0.3038543761,
-0.2374879271,
0.252974689,
0.3527103066,
0.2191261649,
0.0798813254,
-0.5558937192,
-0.1341261119,
-0.1653811634,
0.5726158023,
0.4235789478,
0.0581668764,
-0.3089693785,
-0.2783084214,
0.1254312247,
0.3743242323,
-0.4320174158,
-0.3053674102,
0.1721767038,
-0.4140239656,
-0.3640543818,
0.2048028409,
-0.6344083548,
-0.265745461,
-0.5313327909,
0.4199351966,
-0.2555598319,
-0.2767234147,
-0.3191874921,
-0.1779109538,
0.386313796,
0.2651248276,
-1.2444839478,
0.2827498615,
0.8758772016,
0.6018133759,
-0.0761020631,
-0.6747899652,
-0.3902979493,
0.3805930018,
-0.4631555676,
0.4858832359,
-0.5716042519,
-0.1325289011,
-0.2063406706,
-0.0429130867,
-0.0793721676,
-0.4801884592,
0.5304449201,
-0.3632851541,
0.4377247989,
-0.0263108108,
-0.4125501812,
0.119589664,
0.1094321609,
-0.1743237376,
1.0248900652,
0.3704307079,
-0.5778730512,
0.6426879764,
-0.4392281473,
-0.3935684264,
0.0998592079,
-0.2883942723,
-0.7438998818,
0.0811524093,
0.4116204679,
0.2880772054,
-0.1630369723,
0.4469069839,
-0.2909680903,
-0.7207408547,
-0.5011505485,
-0.0531414896,
0.6312991977,
-0.0955192745,
-0.5299325585,
0.4316371679,
-0.3617333472,
-0.0067319488,
-0.0428215042,
-0.0610599071,
-0.4053165913,
0.1174958125,
-0.1471791714,
-0.1223556697,
0.1398181617,
-0.1671814024,
0.5348052382,
-0.5455133319,
0.4363708496,
0.9065592885,
-0.1158122495,
0.7461243868,
-0.2044465244,
0.1801544726,
-0.1012927368,
0.2127744555,
-0.0534261018,
-0.3812795877,
-0.5831899047,
-0.1492132843,
0.5405157208,
0.6071412563,
-0.5976445675,
0.5502149463,
-0.1504267901,
-0.2889992595,
-0.4719554186,
0.3220005333,
0.8048788905,
0.3865433335,
0.705863297,
-0.3725039363,
-0.6347538829,
-0.6875957847,
-0.2178466916,
-0.4619519114,
-0.2357810438,
0.0334536508,
0.6142126918,
-0.5813217163,
0.6152178645,
-0.2918411195,
-0.4413249493,
-0.0934956297,
0.2466277182,
-0.1030327007,
1.0712301731,
0.3262839615,
-0.7868704796,
-0.02550398,
-0.092372559,
-0.9772028923,
0.2801796794,
-0.0881887823,
-0.4373072088,
0.0177325401,
0.6990678906,
-0.8486346006,
0.3632314801,
0.2054700851,
-0.1377708614,
0.7455952168,
-0.0451149009,
-0.1692140698,
-1.0445463657,
0.0705535933,
0.1153061241,
0.0759153366,
-0.6122217774,
0.6188288927,
0.1958206296,
-0.1128246337,
-0.0979301557,
0.1377021074,
-0.3105337322,
-0.1594646871,
-0.04921785,
-0.2460390627,
-0.3446630538,
0.6027830243,
-0.1769787967,
0.7200177312,
0.8471792936,
-0.4939345717,
0.1055053473,
0.2183272094,
-0.075053975,
0.7734590769,
-0.8799371123,
0.0872002542,
-0.2112178355,
0.5593340993,
-0.9577960968,
-0.7199248075,
0.1793726981,
-0.3228120804,
0.689748764,
-0.4205041826,
-0.3675205708,
-0.3134132624,
-0.2515768409,
0.5755885243,
0.2854131758,
-0.6116401553,
0.3236765862,
0.2948243618,
-0.0020313326,
-0.5866277218,
-0.5846994519,
0.1085876301,
-0.1772762388,
-0.4598034918,
0.5109538436,
0.3760219216,
-0.297514081,
-0.1026478782,
-0.3497115076,
0.1041314453,
0.0869202763,
0.2217802256,
0.4989584088,
-0.1166523397,
0.2627825439,
0.1058291346,
-0.3174728453,
-0.1326417029,
-0.7504121065,
0.0765488744,
-0.2758983076,
-0.3125914037,
-0.6318795085,
0.2637653649,
0.5564605594,
-0.2318283617,
0.7158632278,
0.9194688201,
-0.5721740723,
-0.0025580537,
-0.2439774126,
-0.4463650882,
-0.4088118076,
0.3959660232,
0.0013057454,
-0.8543413281,
0.2178208381,
0.0473005585,
0.3822879791,
0.4884469807,
0.3703695834,
-0.3554067612,
1.4923893213,
0.7618591189,
-0.5676147342,
0.580504775,
-0.5515319705,
0.0565106198,
-0.85072124,
-0.1991851032,
-0.3507965803,
-0.6532010436,
-0.5784185529,
-0.1979168057,
0.4207049012,
0.5225917697,
-0.3852043152,
0.2977232039,
-0.4493103623,
0.5607098937,
0.6189805865,
0.0416416302,
-0.1605032533,
-0.0520569272,
0.1284150779,
0.1760219634,
-0.7957126498,
-0.2116730213,
1.2341843843,
0.3381204605,
0.7937013507,
0.2038458288,
0.7258586287,
0.1424832344,
0.3866520822,
-0.5586126447,
0.3916756511,
-0.0627240241,
-0.3314827681,
-0.5954027176,
-0.4556851983,
-0.8403885365,
0.5033723116,
-0.3036708236,
-0.8466359377,
0.1987556964,
0.4660623968,
-0.3679925799,
0.1941248327,
-0.9706331491,
0.7899605632,
-0.0222499538,
-0.7696612477,
-0.3609371185,
-0.9942381978,
0.5975812078,
0.3050775528,
-0.1569318622,
0.4399670959,
0.0217550658,
0.6320483685,
-0.5264777541,
0.9332236052,
-0.2902096212,
-0.1214092225,
0.2643847764,
-0.3891132474,
0.9355257154,
0.259557724,
0.0869254693,
0.345967263,
-0.4034062922,
-0.7373755574,
-0.5423021317,
0.6320108771,
-0.9375059605,
-0.6632758379,
-0.2146546394,
-0.7366896272,
-0.3259443343,
0.1867146045,
0.3530588746,
0.2899261117,
0.1090657935,
0.1817373037,
0.6894596219,
0.5545259714,
0.2827250361,
0.1744365841,
0.2635015845,
-0.2820732892,
1.0195491314,
0.1585724205,
0.0964489281,
0.2050765902,
0.1877963096,
-0.2446199954,
-0.4552299082,
-0.7555416822,
0.0349636935,
-0.1198820025,
-0.287445873,
-0.250772655,
0.0398389921,
-0.8890646696,
-0.2081658393,
-0.1914680451,
-0.538256228,
-0.3115004897,
-0.1232601404,
-0.2430379838,
0.5946673155,
-0.177106306,
0.1872896105,
-0.2022839189,
0.1988466382,
0.60095644,
0.2747030258,
0.0764451623,
-0.5203896761,
-0.4377335608,
-0.0584221967,
-0.5678324103,
-0.2898139656,
-0.3405899107,
0.3088490665,
0.5277747512,
0.9479845166,
-0.0349713415,
0.8089049459,
-0.109177649,
0.7337856293,
0.3270896673,
-0.7420431972,
0.5722525716,
-0.5071143508,
0.2933858335,
0.5426419973,
0.3304278851,
-0.1327666491,
-0.6401711702,
-0.7580718398,
-1.0333844423,
0.8274254203,
0.2853168249,
-0.0412427299,
0.2852579355,
0.4277117848,
-0.2043283284,
0.0501680188,
-0.4043387771,
0.0344146006,
-0.4044657648,
-0.2524623573,
-0.2912510931,
0.0026777266,
-0.389568001,
-0.2608330548,
0.7371733189,
-0.3216010928,
0.1223390624,
0.110673666,
-0.0517350249,
-0.3050837517,
0.2545070946,
0.5626226068,
0.464695394,
0.1600545794,
0.3122545183,
0.5705240369,
-0.4419755936,
0.0181232784,
0.1574451923,
-0.2683051825,
-0.6725253463,
0.7994228005,
0.628677845,
0.3560247719,
-0.4559434652,
0.5250665545,
0.3243439794,
-0.3844807148,
0.1158287674,
0.5064227581,
-0.3820950091,
0.439680934,
0.4303406477,
0.3924383223,
0.0109727709,
-0.6018661261,
0.266279459,
0.4253881574,
-0.5544544458,
-0.4386208653,
0.7626529336,
0.0491464771,
-0.1033717692,
0.5974305868,
-0.4291445613,
-0.4872893691,
0.7378851175,
0.648246944,
0.5173916221,
-0.3657999337,
-0.0949677974,
0.3232643902,
0.249555245,
-0.5814178586,
0.0433921181,
-0.3488821983,
-0.5083655715,
-0.2608916163,
-0.0886952877,
-0.5898634791,
0.0227460787,
-0.9517790079,
0.018494539,
-0.5378984213,
-0.0651208684,
-0.3941911459,
-0.014646586,
-0.4136845767,
0.1358320117,
-0.1494826078,
0.4080685079,
-0.8518078923,
0.4615884423,
1.062057972,
-0.2929812372,
-0.8747214675,
0.5887416005,
0.1081089675,
-0.7093087435,
0.2400176078,
0.1624297351,
0.0812454,
0.0348833166,
-0.9200806618,
-0.940843761,
1.1600487232,
0.1765325665,
-0.5909789205,
-0.0923297703,
-0.3321700096,
0.8083776832,
-0.040944133,
0.2638043761,
0.6192036867,
0.3008619845,
-0.1451877505,
-0.6931465864,
-0.0736687928,
-0.2723883688,
0.0080688288,
0.3942560554,
-1.1670048237,
0.7295821905,
-0.4885910153,
-0.2159731984,
0.1279474646,
1.1106170416,
0.0506290607,
0.4536039233,
0.5583356023,
1.1233525276,
0.8525556326,
-0.0345895551,
0.6479497552,
-0.1572943479,
0.3066732585,
1.2282385826,
-0.2353990227,
0.6535470486,
0.4194228947,
-0.2504681647,
0.5902434587,
0.4011739194,
-0.1998558193,
0.3271435201,
0.0516013876,
-0.0632122234,
-0.1952781379,
-0.2303159088,
-0.4768085182,
0.4702570736,
0.2609936297,
-0.102463834,
-0.092366457,
-0.0983131081,
-0.1008797958,
-0.1485189199,
-0.7530633807,
0.6783635616,
-0.1533404738,
-1.0036239624,
0.4095497727,
0.0647076666,
0.5107167959,
-0.3983932436,
-0.0455900505,
-0.1587141305,
0.3092786074,
-0.4689197838,
-0.5997515917,
0.0960442647,
-0.024705071,
-0.2431501597,
-0.2164248079,
0.7987239957,
-0.4872470796,
-0.3670311272,
-0.0409525558,
0.1499482542,
0.0727427527,
0.3400585651,
-0.4319999814,
-0.3552584052,
-0.3593144119,
-0.0599304922,
0.5779902935,
0.1376623362,
-0.5010099411,
0.3500342369,
0.6058472395,
-0.2024391443,
-0.3295164704,
0.314234674,
0.9207148552,
-0.2304358929,
-0.7135817409,
-0.6255304813,
0.307449162,
-0.0308759119,
-0.6125282645,
0.7900657058,
0.4136817157,
1.0818029642,
0.3451292813,
0.5901281238,
-0.0758316666,
0.0174882356,
-0.4270150959,
0.5600245595,
-0.5034034848,
0.0855081528,
-0.4301886857,
-0.6937317252,
-0.1821724027,
0.429040432,
-0.3255053461,
0.0892784968,
0.3325086832,
0.9143369794,
-0.3135147393,
-0.0035567526,
0.0741461664,
0.0422078855,
0.0291583166,
0.5876439214,
0.7966489792,
-0.5449012518,
0.5927395225,
0.0331795104,
-0.4516500831,
-0.3194365501,
-0.2833337188,
-0.7755323052,
-0.3204534352,
-0.2735314965,
-0.2180824429,
0.2359697521,
0.7211492658,
1.0514017344,
-0.8517571092,
0.0230317917,
-0.5516513586,
0.2684785426,
-0.7741556168,
-0.2443587482,
0.4344782233,
-0.6480965018,
-0.5787641406,
0.5036633611,
0.0405706279,
0.100978516,
-0.2515485585,
-0.3859571517,
0.0960304439,
-0.2236138135,
0.2202832997,
0.4793340266,
-0.339833051,
-0.3761452436,
-0.5027625561,
-0.0527153686,
-0.2732257545,
0.8152467012,
-0.4855602384,
0.2164885998,
0.2732234299,
0.5721307397,
0.2656061053,
0.3914487958,
0.4580044448,
-0.9335855842,
0.0450564884,
0.0736801922,
0.3396208882,
-0.0652043,
-0.547712028,
0.669428885,
0.5242235065,
-0.6690188646,
-0.9789767265,
0.3085494936,
-0.4303781092,
-0.0101685422,
0.8988704085,
-0.2461862266,
0.1522346884,
-0.0997312441,
-0.0033370713,
0.3960905373,
-0.3131878078,
1.0069689751,
0.532143116,
-0.2903545499,
0.026714772,
-0.1587357968,
0.337079674,
1.0027272701,
-0.6384571791,
0.0402218066,
0.3266572356,
-0.081710577,
0.1706606001,
0.2026926875,
0.1507377326,
0.6008011103,
0.1319837719,
-0.1661702842,
-0.0216200761,
-0.6901949048,
-0.5239889026,
0.2775901854,
-0.3316742182,
-0.2070658356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00658v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00658v2
|
Learning Planning-based Reasoning by Trajectories Collection and Process Reward Synthesizing
| 2024-02-01T15:18:33 | 2024-04-15T06:36:24 |
Fangkai Jiao, Chengwei Qin, Zhengyuan Liu, Nancy F. Chen, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks through step-by-step rationale generation.
However, recent studies have raised concerns regarding the hallucination and
flaws in their reasoning process. Substantial efforts are being made to improve
the reliability and faithfulness of the generated rationales. Some approaches
model reasoning as planning, while others focus on annotating for process
supervision. Nevertheless, the planning-based search process often results in
high latency due to the frequent assessment of intermediate reasoning states
and the extensive exploration space. Additionally, supervising the reasoning
process with human annotation is costly and challenging to scale for LLM
training. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose a framework to
learn planning-based reasoning through Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) on
collected trajectories, which are ranked according to synthesized process
rewards. Our results on challenging logical reasoning benchmarks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our learning framework, showing that our 7B model can
surpass the strong counterparts like GPT-3.5-Turbo.
|
[
-0.279738009,
-0.4453523755,
1.1157946587,
0.0197516754,
-0.2667344213,
-0.0049867546,
-0.0748915449,
-0.1528963149,
0.2922205031,
0.7694448829,
-0.9062939882,
-0.3858350515,
-0.4582175314,
-0.0273193214,
0.2012650371,
0.5454378724,
-0.2128886133,
-0.182748571,
0.1840040982,
0.3215724826,
-0.5806182623,
-0.5969027281,
-0.7713300586,
-0.4048357606,
0.6363757253,
0.5233072042,
0.5445558429,
0.7738748789,
0.1273206025,
0.2167496234,
-0.2464045435,
0.4933263659,
-0.4558335841,
0.4516561627,
-0.4046825767,
-0.2911275625,
-0.3864941895,
0.0428485014,
0.2190697193,
0.8216176629,
-0.1793441921,
-0.0830050483,
-0.3409783244,
0.6313124299,
-0.6447947025,
0.4314983785,
-0.7928472757,
0.2706902921,
0.2030040324,
-0.4021784067,
-0.5199158788,
-0.4551875591,
0.2561997473,
-0.7879202962,
0.0058193165,
-0.1086093262,
0.3555419147,
0.4539898932,
-0.2949458659,
-0.478195399,
-0.8010285497,
0.7277011275,
-0.4571568966,
0.114247866,
0.3779897392,
0.5397160053,
-0.526455164,
-0.4638687968,
-0.3825782537,
-0.1153080687,
0.2966612279,
-0.1109324619,
0.4313645959,
0.101875931,
0.5770584345,
0.0217249691,
-0.5460464954,
0.038329456,
-0.1938343942,
-0.0793610737,
0.8423473835,
0.1744026542,
-0.1550785154,
-0.1445837319,
-0.2909384668,
-0.4594347477,
-0.6047816277,
0.1201928109,
0.298774153,
0.3788366914,
0.3908761144,
0.4780727327,
-0.4968610108,
0.7260032296,
-0.0103034656,
-0.2311161608,
0.0799215585,
0.0556238294,
-0.2473867536,
0.1334970593,
0.5127432942,
0.2901664674,
0.2758723199,
-0.1565104127,
-0.284897238,
0.1623905301,
0.3118568659,
-0.5310710073,
-0.2144191265,
0.2603007853,
0.100911513,
-0.3859724104,
-0.1882564574,
-0.6451480985,
-0.3247575462,
-0.5248324275,
0.1695046872,
-0.4344478548,
-0.186668396,
0.4325048029,
0.0715280101,
0.1015014797,
0.5625767708,
-0.9791494608,
-0.2668176293,
0.7059120536,
0.5197970867,
-0.1484753489,
-0.3499696851,
-0.6285899282,
0.3105603755,
-0.487432003,
0.933139801,
-0.4457903802,
-0.6162805557,
0.0243426524,
-0.3464581668,
-0.0744164139,
-0.5153628588,
0.916353941,
-0.3315780759,
-0.0088518495,
-0.349068135,
-0.4140708745,
-0.2825427651,
0.3749420345,
-0.440372318,
0.9169802666,
0.0526869372,
-0.2665786743,
0.6718528271,
-0.5985970497,
-0.4601650238,
0.0590339378,
-0.223307237,
-0.2032855153,
0.0216424782,
0.3474548161,
0.6370525956,
0.0374322385,
0.7893729806,
-0.2098352313,
-0.4708269536,
-0.0199517831,
-0.0331962779,
0.4379819036,
0.289488554,
-0.5798270702,
0.4053562284,
-0.9610247016,
0.0520517752,
0.1966038942,
-0.4062383175,
-0.1062005013,
0.3643475175,
-0.689026475,
0.4758091867,
0.0151741644,
-0.1982735842,
0.5278832316,
-0.5756272674,
0.3385762572,
0.9544360638,
0.1143483147,
0.5317003727,
-0.1328465343,
0.4442920089,
0.0815994367,
0.2455040812,
0.1320021152,
-0.2311517894,
-0.6631500721,
0.1456074268,
-0.4222609103,
0.3050822914,
-0.8959083557,
0.5932876468,
-0.2608941793,
-0.4676793218,
0.1651894897,
-0.1625503302,
0.0478698872,
0.604731679,
0.3869928122,
0.219162479,
-0.5069189668,
-0.6849942803,
0.0779539123,
-0.4040446877,
0.066585809,
0.2072529048,
0.2515166402,
-0.139160946,
0.6130571365,
-0.651469171,
-0.0093570165,
-0.6333121657,
0.0673963577,
0.2392892092,
0.2425683141,
0.1490421891,
-0.6303586364,
-0.0845353752,
-0.237274304,
-0.6227805614,
-0.1476649046,
-0.2424740791,
-0.6085471511,
0.2652305663,
0.1000759974,
-0.6688462496,
0.325642854,
0.1287274212,
-0.3172922134,
0.4667847455,
-0.1272422522,
-0.0728558302,
-0.8091534972,
-0.0978240296,
-0.0443441384,
-0.0634452924,
-0.3414584994,
-0.1485243738,
-0.2565947771,
-0.1917029619,
-0.511169374,
0.5356507301,
-0.3012294471,
-0.1382376701,
-0.3920020461,
0.1043646187,
-0.020901598,
0.8832889795,
0.6825655103,
0.5444756746,
0.230256021,
-0.8044268489,
0.2818041742,
0.2934564054,
-0.1542128921,
0.0851628855,
-0.1628965288,
0.0525692701,
-0.0277056303,
0.2940280437,
-0.4147043526,
-0.1495808214,
0.3066696823,
-0.0907353908,
0.1615064144,
-0.205089584,
-0.317818284,
-0.3765643239,
-0.2144249529,
-0.1082067043,
0.3612522781,
-0.6803187132,
0.516428709,
0.4410530031,
0.0673338771,
-0.6749389768,
-0.1782055199,
-0.2113696188,
-0.1768190116,
-0.5538234711,
0.0644256026,
0.0148216095,
-0.1107214838,
-0.4913000464,
-0.4235078394,
0.224866882,
0.1520964056,
0.3118531108,
0.1831328124,
0.4058960676,
0.0175353605,
0.0719076321,
-0.2807716727,
0.3201830089,
-0.4767073691,
0.579053998,
0.2871874273,
-0.2559465766,
-0.014423294,
0.2303556353,
0.4448665977,
-0.053966783,
0.3076154292,
0.0711817667,
-0.2781771421,
-0.5958632827,
-0.4114079177,
-0.2100283206,
-0.3982211351,
0.2403153777,
-0.5845196843,
-0.6313485503,
0.1631015539,
-0.2763456106,
0.2132090926,
0.3665926158,
0.4777056873,
0.2442077696,
1.0967899561,
0.2735838592,
0.2513998747,
0.2921430767,
-0.4539809227,
0.0689617544,
-0.526639998,
-0.5070650578,
-0.3086017668,
-0.2728027403,
-0.4422412217,
-0.5434782505,
0.2734278738,
0.0223660376,
-0.4162986875,
0.1851982027,
-0.7974870801,
0.3827918172,
0.7138435841,
0.049360577,
0.2608989775,
0.0691836551,
-0.4420441985,
0.070173502,
-0.5866214633,
-0.7415901423,
0.9342963099,
0.0726162642,
0.6323151588,
-0.1179587543,
0.8906025887,
-0.0941593572,
-0.1091645882,
-0.8176881075,
0.9813920259,
0.2454112023,
-0.3676615059,
-0.4372206926,
-0.6059572101,
-0.7825019956,
0.379259944,
-0.1845054477,
-0.8914292455,
0.1451811492,
0.2582017183,
-0.2044197768,
0.3680121005,
-0.5304551125,
0.7321406603,
-0.5943693519,
-0.6817755103,
-0.2499241978,
-0.6914474964,
0.2439253628,
0.2245166451,
-0.010584496,
-0.3362626135,
0.2783895731,
0.5389190316,
-0.4013226032,
0.4565208852,
-0.4773976803,
0.0768736973,
0.2123254091,
0.3940580785,
0.7421853542,
0.2058017403,
-0.2065308541,
-0.2299633175,
-0.1989291608,
-0.2275524586,
-0.6096019149,
0.6287779212,
-0.5973982215,
-0.7749449015,
-0.6627907753,
-0.619060874,
-0.525793612,
0.007590557,
0.0268158857,
0.065708898,
0.0712027326,
-0.4275575578,
0.7483115792,
-0.2654593885,
0.4245296419,
0.1271698624,
-0.4152308702,
-0.207183823,
0.6528898478,
0.0166581254,
0.1121989563,
0.6206619143,
0.3768439591,
-0.492036283,
-0.8129823804,
-0.498657316,
0.1821363121,
-0.6974565387,
0.0267331526,
-0.5919197202,
-0.1014039516,
-0.2160644382,
-0.3603945374,
-0.3738787472,
-0.5880545974,
-0.0321428515,
-0.3793033063,
0.1510898173,
0.6455895901,
-0.0594170988,
0.0900054127,
-0.5250375271,
0.0045449496,
0.2523475289,
0.1782479286,
-0.0238450151,
-0.0982045233,
-0.115053758,
0.0634126365,
-0.5159377456,
-0.6758046746,
0.5696661472,
-0.5161938071,
0.6863999367,
0.2558070123,
0.0796153024,
0.6357702017,
-0.320762068,
0.6037741899,
-0.0963983014,
-0.6147136092,
1.1053357124,
-0.5046772957,
0.1964905113,
0.5081210732,
0.4853552282,
-0.1192074865,
-0.0946549699,
-0.7718419433,
-0.9053903818,
0.7696934938,
0.0873255581,
-0.4031932652,
-0.1171635911,
0.6143087745,
0.0960061103,
0.2968061268,
-0.8313251734,
0.1088391691,
-0.1061460003,
0.0247225203,
0.0293796845,
-0.4198181033,
0.076288037,
-0.1275009215,
0.9458138943,
-0.2191350758,
0.0712482557,
0.1580937803,
-0.0522360541,
-0.0506115444,
0.2193812728,
0.6756378412,
0.8057454228,
-0.4492738247,
0.0675968528,
-0.2089645863,
-0.139419958,
0.3363476396,
0.0581918247,
-0.2355600446,
-0.2519284487,
0.0719235837,
0.977704525,
-0.028918229,
-0.8629335165,
0.2058570385,
0.0686931536,
-0.3557559848,
-0.4448019564,
0.3444302976,
0.0260046925,
0.3020617366,
0.2515827119,
-0.1332216114,
0.1546712071,
-0.2620512247,
-0.1367462426,
0.2162442356,
-0.1866273731,
-0.1123413295,
0.579341352,
0.2476160973,
-0.1804045588,
0.5825776458,
-0.5128499866,
-0.5704966784,
0.2878676653,
0.2153368145,
0.7173729539,
-0.0279249437,
0.303188771,
0.5655862093,
0.0765510276,
-0.508590281,
0.4106398225,
-0.2371708304,
-0.6523489952,
-0.6377286911,
-0.7416234612,
-0.5859273076,
0.2026571482,
-0.2405019552,
0.457652986,
-0.4873232841,
-0.059131816,
-0.3772699833,
0.103320241,
-0.3786099255,
0.2781419456,
0.0696072429,
0.5532848835,
-0.5940445065,
0.6452231407,
0.7539163828,
-0.4755985737,
-1.2294695377,
-0.1238673851,
-0.155192554,
-0.6450967789,
0.8348262906,
0.1995377392,
-0.1194710732,
-0.2109321654,
-0.1441398859,
-0.7137774825,
1.0093712807,
0.5108228326,
-0.6681628823,
-0.49950701,
0.0775198862,
0.3626941442,
-0.3882841766,
0.0742505789,
0.3326484263,
0.3402898014,
0.7114112377,
-0.594558239,
0.0166952088,
0.2051328719,
-0.0787699074,
0.3269996345,
-0.3556277454,
0.6329659224,
-0.308396399,
-0.0162358824,
-0.3185373843,
0.2316444963,
0.8138036132,
0.2954114079,
0.5695123672,
0.6677824259,
0.5405002236,
-0.1064440012,
0.9483305812,
0.1119613871,
0.0542854108,
1.2095341682,
-0.6194102764,
0.7963377833,
0.5648267865,
-0.0081268316,
0.4130806029,
0.891467452,
0.430377543,
0.5921378732,
0.3880079091,
-0.0936209038,
-0.5957501531,
0.1360849589,
0.0293883011,
0.4221297503,
0.3202612996,
-0.2391590327,
-0.1514131278,
-0.2913647294,
-0.0848691389,
0.2376770228,
-0.3479515314,
0.743632257,
-0.0553131104,
-1.035785079,
0.4072757959,
-0.3804184198,
0.3045097589,
-0.4959189594,
-0.1535480469,
-0.2328438461,
0.2570330203,
0.05191008,
-0.6828332543,
0.3127706945,
-0.2770723104,
-0.034466859,
-0.5219729543,
0.5662999749,
-0.0527780652,
-0.4828423858,
0.4968818426,
0.630292356,
0.1149976477,
-0.0931230113,
-0.361117065,
-0.0864636078,
0.1937173605,
-0.5323690176,
0.3254673183,
0.438863039,
-0.2442447841,
0.9466451406,
0.6443648934,
0.4139616489,
-0.0424370579,
0.0885393173,
0.7019093037,
-0.7687132359,
-0.6673485637,
-0.7822082043,
0.3885154128,
-0.1910362244,
0.0301333256,
0.1891150475,
0.6160164475,
1.0319544077,
-0.0171776842,
0.605976522,
0.2679373324,
0.7352746725,
-0.7728793025,
0.0801575854,
-0.2670081258,
0.5318001509,
-0.1174721271,
-1.0740690231,
-0.2206836492,
0.960304141,
-0.5460615754,
-0.0561920069,
0.6243071556,
0.5784239173,
0.0829633474,
-0.0954743922,
0.3463850617,
-0.3025650084,
0.4870636165,
1.0647357702,
0.9288387299,
0.1257739812,
0.5558927655,
-0.3712086678,
-0.1445533186,
-0.1299600899,
-1.0498905182,
-0.8302024007,
-0.4479114115,
-0.2011256367,
-0.1415871829,
0.2062823921,
1.1895619631,
0.6866309643,
-0.3278537691,
-0.4198327661,
-0.386344552,
0.2621164918,
-0.1948050261,
-0.1753541976,
0.1887075752,
-0.2813989222,
-0.6674107313,
0.5315569639,
0.4182980955,
0.0822229534,
-0.2195314169,
-0.2793294787,
-0.345348835,
-0.1744011045,
0.5529173613,
0.161576882,
-0.7414014339,
-0.3649401963,
0.0195718575,
0.1053080261,
0.1044674963,
0.8824244142,
-0.8235549331,
0.3300983608,
0.5597631335,
0.5521386266,
0.9652028084,
-0.1424693465,
0.7320063114,
-0.5046294928,
0.234234035,
0.4673019946,
0.4780321121,
0.2500201166,
-0.3494112194,
0.9118402004,
0.2020350248,
-0.6989780068,
-0.7170667052,
0.3847033978,
-1.1668117046,
-0.1755825281,
1.2494661808,
0.0250872914,
-0.1061220765,
0.2059287876,
-0.2673390806,
0.363615483,
-0.5818142891,
0.8829653859,
0.5486214161,
-0.5754426718,
-0.0908051282,
-0.4008415639,
0.4873667061,
0.2817443609,
-0.7303558588,
0.1771796793,
0.89752388,
-0.0159365293,
0.1428546458,
0.6651456356,
0.0722930059,
0.0577414967,
-0.2143337429,
0.1014516354,
-0.3092298508,
-0.3271863163,
0.0723777488,
0.2066523284,
0.4554920793,
0.0040103807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00632v1
|
Prosody in Cascade and Direct Speech-to-Text Translation: a case study on Korean Wh-Phrases
| 2024-02-01T14:46:35 | 2024-02-01T14:46:35 |
Giulio Zhou, Tsz Kin Lam, Alexandra Birch, Barry Haddow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speech-to-Text Translation (S2TT) has typically been addressed with cascade
systems, where speech recognition systems generate a transcription that is
subsequently passed to a translation model. While there has been a growing
interest in developing direct speech translation systems to avoid propagating
errors and losing non-verbal content, prior work in direct S2TT has struggled
to conclusively establish the advantages of integrating the acoustic signal
directly into the translation process. This work proposes using contrastive
evaluation to quantitatively measure the ability of direct S2TT systems to
disambiguate utterances where prosody plays a crucial role. Specifically, we
evaluated Korean-English translation systems on a test set containing
wh-phrases, for which prosodic features are necessary to produce translations
with the correct intent, whether it's a statement, a yes/no question, a
wh-question, and more. Our results clearly demonstrate the value of direct
translation systems over cascade translation models, with a notable 12.9%
improvement in overall accuracy in ambiguous cases, along with up to a 15.6%
increase in F1 scores for one of the major intent categories. To the best of
our knowledge, this work stands as the first to provide quantitative evidence
that direct S2TT models can effectively leverage prosody. The code for our
evaluation is openly accessible and freely available for review and
utilisation.
|
[
-0.0040948805,
-0.3559851646,
0.6709225774,
0.7743663788,
-0.711561799,
-0.0694340691,
-0.1501177549,
-0.2251086831,
0.013589873,
0.199014321,
-0.3166998327,
-0.5257722139,
-0.7195379138,
0.4362160563,
-0.3814170063,
1.0204342604,
-0.1549503654,
0.4094441831,
0.0823218152,
-0.1700650901,
-0.4398397207,
-0.1610215902,
-0.4984929264,
-0.214798227,
0.2643257976,
0.203920126,
0.8997559547,
0.2817727327,
0.8964153528,
0.2943490148,
-0.3729960918,
-0.1724016815,
-0.1085675806,
0.3897994757,
-0.1966955662,
-0.2048267275,
-0.638366878,
0.0645219088,
0.7461280227,
0.7003537416,
0.1121089682,
0.1123544872,
0.4242758155,
0.5755295157,
-0.3672118485,
0.2286597788,
-0.1792351454,
0.046514038,
-0.1910400093,
-0.2076898515,
-0.3179735839,
-0.5981962681,
0.3374086618,
-0.4236109257,
-0.1549101174,
-0.2184440792,
0.4816327989,
0.4702144563,
-0.7720219493,
-0.608104527,
-0.7193909883,
0.7033077478,
-0.5439193845,
0.6280651093,
0.2283789515,
0.1628415436,
-0.1438546479,
-0.7430858016,
-0.5283331275,
-0.5143037438,
-0.2885644138,
0.7126984596,
-0.2920340002,
0.1652531028,
-0.1300457567,
0.4524442255,
-0.7088550329,
-0.1222491041,
-0.0809591115,
-0.0325346887,
0.5289157033,
-0.0185601506,
0.175548777,
-0.5477835536,
-0.3467198312,
-0.0182994865,
-0.3605700135,
0.0373542234,
0.3361177742,
0.522785306,
-0.1874817461,
0.6523189545,
-0.2122317553,
0.2733561099,
0.2485811859,
-0.2447242737,
0.3740680218,
-0.7601832747,
0.012166664,
0.2117679566,
0.8189550042,
0.3162291348,
0.2860023975,
-0.2935837507,
-0.252886802,
-0.0233937185,
-0.0919700414,
-0.934461832,
-0.0546866022,
0.3744080365,
-0.441336751,
-0.3458656669,
-0.1324792206,
-0.3067835867,
-0.2528559566,
-0.3740773797,
0.2896927595,
-0.2565811276,
-0.607811451,
-0.0583307855,
-0.1860713512,
0.0127041079,
0.0631513,
-0.2785725892,
0.3766528368,
0.4793309867,
0.9978749156,
-0.2481611222,
-0.179286018,
-0.5344263315,
-0.0755311325,
-0.6645393372,
0.5937725306,
-0.3391567469,
-0.7386763692,
-0.0216842759,
-0.1161602959,
0.0261242911,
-0.9044718146,
0.7461583018,
-0.3758679926,
-0.2385683209,
-0.2471940964,
-0.3049225807,
0.3497745395,
-0.2927030921,
-0.4624026418,
0.855237782,
0.1205327809,
-0.7165735364,
-0.1376940608,
-0.1522604823,
-0.7097792625,
-0.0060984455,
-0.1266337633,
-0.2157032788,
0.3198488951,
-0.3286968172,
0.1767568588,
-0.2379213423,
0.597843945,
0.1585392356,
-0.5338258147,
0.3587693274,
-0.3473311365,
0.6644858122,
0.2479790598,
-0.4239735305,
-0.0083763208,
-0.4771307707,
-0.1760091186,
-0.0869036391,
-0.2921870649,
-0.4266313612,
-0.2327128202,
-0.0790934116,
0.2837510109,
0.1340194643,
-0.2762051225,
-0.130785659,
-0.2994822562,
0.2242371291,
0.4547865093,
0.0085739382,
0.6973176003,
0.314824909,
0.4302919209,
0.2651087046,
0.1506625265,
0.0517497547,
-0.7054483891,
-0.5072441101,
-0.1792331487,
0.5090708733,
0.8532914519,
-0.8691327572,
0.3841250241,
-0.2155587673,
-0.3490126431,
-0.7268208265,
-0.2504113317,
0.7406955361,
0.7922772765,
0.4921676517,
-0.0672789663,
-0.3543644249,
-0.9196356535,
-0.3443007171,
-0.2432529777,
-0.3845694363,
0.1896609068,
0.428373009,
-0.0236986633,
0.6216984391,
-0.4308915436,
-0.2357441038,
-0.0636001006,
0.2544881701,
0.1424100101,
0.3441767693,
0.1429220736,
-0.7277885079,
-0.6749067307,
0.0579841845,
-0.694696784,
-0.4594711065,
0.1066459864,
-0.1706987023,
-0.2319621593,
0.5387432575,
-0.8079801202,
0.4011371732,
0.5778838992,
-0.2725763619,
0.7898274064,
-0.0740087107,
0.3498059809,
-1.0342931747,
0.2666709721,
0.02193252,
-0.1802262515,
-0.8112165928,
0.004520236,
0.1524725705,
-0.1454119086,
-0.4290172458,
0.3656793237,
-0.1635959595,
-0.3055624366,
-0.373268038,
0.6067817211,
-0.1657899618,
0.1738885641,
0.1992431879,
1.0844107866,
0.1518481523,
-0.8818497062,
0.2427110076,
0.4064939916,
-0.2726137638,
0.902861774,
-0.7660369277,
0.0613039806,
-0.0264358148,
0.4348810613,
-1.2215270996,
-0.0035898951,
0.2804115117,
-0.6790617704,
0.2236955166,
-0.0227241367,
-0.2639163136,
0.0194394421,
-0.1266531795,
0.3442424536,
0.6767734885,
-0.1142358854,
0.1025003642,
0.1329613924,
-0.6910194755,
-0.4821039438,
-0.6355304718,
0.0657139868,
-0.1049202159,
-0.4179657996,
0.7250013351,
0.2281005681,
-0.406083256,
0.0047077574,
-0.3772649467,
0.061121311,
-0.1622892469,
-0.0695915893,
0.0248274226,
-0.0976878852,
0.1605071872,
0.2879790664,
-0.4421365261,
-0.0813177675,
-0.2278989404,
0.3993538916,
0.0606804453,
0.0307528954,
-0.8791969419,
0.322486937,
0.2791152596,
-0.018032508,
0.3904193938,
0.6781093478,
-0.112157844,
0.1974227577,
-0.0706166849,
-0.3015167713,
-0.434006691,
0.665971458,
-0.685112834,
-0.4684333503,
0.4980568588,
-0.534137547,
-0.4378661513,
0.4116933942,
0.1186286584,
-0.421289444,
1.1476075649,
0.0402068421,
0.2775512338,
0.456910491,
0.0434792414,
0.3249007463,
-1.1409281492,
-0.1305336356,
-0.6892451644,
-0.378326565,
-0.9880945683,
-0.5297432542,
0.4701352715,
0.4043300748,
-0.2709091902,
0.3752351999,
-0.0885711461,
0.1233020574,
0.2586577833,
0.1342439055,
0.3894583285,
-0.1521492451,
-0.0667287037,
-0.4982682765,
-0.1645786613,
-0.5662230849,
0.7064728141,
0.1936354935,
0.2927429974,
0.3006393313,
0.6120834947,
0.2451304048,
0.2315616161,
-0.9280920029,
0.6960722804,
-0.718308568,
0.1190635562,
-0.3238602579,
-0.5538542867,
-0.8031433821,
0.2390599698,
0.2715089917,
-0.2150993049,
0.1797997952,
0.1212364361,
-0.1735677719,
-0.2969466448,
-0.4536916614,
0.6833981872,
-0.1854453981,
-0.3060522676,
-0.025719814,
-0.6404494047,
0.2162792981,
0.0247791689,
0.082920067,
0.0870713294,
-0.2965033054,
0.5894099474,
-0.2792210281,
0.6212825179,
-0.3735152185,
-0.4485357404,
0.3237105608,
0.4576433003,
0.8287250996,
-0.2076465636,
-0.0607415475,
0.1854149103,
-0.2615048885,
-0.047398258,
-0.7345689535,
0.5821431279,
-0.5823412538,
-0.4586069584,
-0.2401740402,
-0.3888002634,
-0.278785795,
0.0261061434,
0.2376170903,
0.209562242,
-0.1320720464,
0.2031279206,
0.5785658956,
-0.1883319169,
0.2279063165,
0.4889785051,
-0.1848601252,
-0.5639062524,
1.0123503208,
0.2496834993,
0.4833105803,
0.3511963785,
0.4790052176,
-0.7133732438,
-0.6591541767,
-0.3733339608,
0.3335313499,
-0.7288612127,
-0.1610465199,
-0.3308476508,
-0.1067735404,
-0.6003187299,
0.1052024066,
-0.4256542027,
-0.624001205,
-0.0567330196,
-0.1366507113,
0.0340525135,
0.6441847682,
0.0133802192,
0.4167776406,
-0.5777023435,
0.4477404952,
0.2865430117,
0.1131401584,
-0.3230259717,
-1.0570824146,
0.05514507,
-0.1445883512,
-0.2727021575,
-1.364352107,
0.2293011993,
0.1559768021,
0.3180452287,
0.052966591,
0.2205881625,
0.8484409451,
-0.66802001,
0.8471711874,
0.1670095921,
-1.2033025026,
0.7839018106,
-0.3900734782,
0.4021937549,
0.5991427898,
0.5777443051,
-0.6713987589,
-0.5431612134,
-0.3395312726,
-0.8600228429,
0.4787404537,
0.5562393069,
-0.0117860055,
-0.1082740948,
0.4566320181,
-0.0969873443,
0.448800087,
-0.3729960322,
-0.1796294004,
-0.0508990102,
-0.4787380099,
-0.094646655,
-0.1505378038,
0.1527916938,
-0.0595673844,
0.4714384377,
0.1194331869,
0.2470854223,
0.3523187041,
-0.2067437768,
0.237149179,
0.305514425,
0.6235973239,
0.3375031352,
-0.3231069148,
0.374658823,
0.056003429,
-0.891350925,
0.376332432,
-0.0321189389,
-0.4635941684,
0.3352318704,
0.2449860871,
0.6144757867,
0.3379866183,
-0.261610955,
0.6903760433,
0.2311607301,
-0.1511512399,
0.0999788791,
-0.4671459794,
0.2003962547,
0.3155014515,
0.1616669744,
0.2223959565,
0.4986014664,
-0.4114505947,
0.0361995623,
0.0809101015,
-0.646468699,
-0.6314308643,
0.3998117149,
0.6140137315,
-0.444571048,
0.5369893312,
-0.422940731,
-0.4495230317,
0.49815768,
0.7334788442,
1.1756716967,
-0.8395448327,
0.4031414688,
0.5123829842,
0.2290614992,
-0.1765058786,
0.3740127683,
-0.163530305,
-0.3664941192,
-0.2752608955,
-0.5294567347,
-0.3831401169,
0.0788009316,
-0.8271440268,
0.2412553877,
0.0799853131,
-0.4731149077,
-0.1945437938,
-0.2219890952,
-0.4810747504,
0.2658658624,
-0.1394403428,
0.5910229683,
-0.8804730177,
0.659430325,
0.5850566626,
-0.4125424922,
-0.3404609561,
0.4825668335,
-0.2628378868,
-0.4110996425,
1.0891708136,
-0.0558528155,
-0.6035760641,
0.1193973199,
0.0878005177,
-0.7401968241,
1.0901831388,
0.4969969988,
-0.8159796,
0.2620931268,
0.5373727083,
0.6747575402,
-0.097053051,
0.2480746061,
0.8499268889,
0.3734285831,
0.0976828188,
-1.2719728947,
0.2040533125,
-0.0442258641,
0.1237118021,
-0.0342855789,
-0.5978705287,
0.7645920515,
-0.1030305102,
-0.3974906504,
0.0536726341,
0.5349799395,
0.2618126571,
0.4342066944,
0.4015707374,
0.1172344387,
0.7374147773,
-0.1038462669,
0.8842431307,
-0.2256922573,
0.0687112212,
1.1579568386,
-0.5346143842,
1.2561719418,
0.6810853481,
-0.432936728,
0.1496796012,
0.3812517524,
0.8242212534,
0.992880404,
0.3148878217,
-0.455896914,
-0.0580455363,
-0.3615628481,
-0.4685185254,
0.475577563,
0.1303701848,
-0.3155605197,
0.0855441019,
0.0692171082,
0.1561382562,
0.1144404188,
-0.1649909168,
0.8296303153,
0.3272280693,
-0.7508749962,
0.4539191425,
-0.0079034464,
0.4876465499,
-0.5495713949,
0.0514324233,
-0.759924829,
0.2108563483,
-0.2651250362,
-0.8633309007,
0.5457498431,
0.2333011478,
0.0890788436,
-0.2566253543,
0.5026896596,
-0.5738453865,
-0.1965512484,
0.3402248919,
0.4932971001,
0.3624337912,
-0.243644014,
-0.3656100631,
0.0091850646,
-0.1014856175,
-0.1588922888,
0.2663458288,
0.4261052608,
-0.1255592853,
0.2521491349,
0.2140674442,
0.3506257236,
-0.2120402753,
0.4775079489,
0.5956405997,
-0.5841221809,
-0.4846058786,
-0.8282610178,
0.6196161509,
-0.0589694493,
-0.366753757,
0.873942852,
0.5478495955,
0.7326139808,
-0.0967553109,
0.7996255755,
0.3551319242,
0.2125776708,
-0.4119153619,
0.3744441867,
-0.2392034084,
0.0999002233,
-0.3728327453,
-0.974898994,
-0.119489558,
0.6669051051,
-0.3630264997,
-0.2328982353,
0.9213587046,
0.6184390187,
0.044963818,
0.0844123587,
0.2037923634,
0.1886571497,
0.0222819578,
0.1755361855,
0.9030360579,
-0.9225286245,
0.8868746161,
-0.1073020101,
-0.3870610297,
-0.0871675536,
-0.6385256648,
-0.2764564455,
-0.5142742991,
-0.6618208885,
-0.4782928228,
0.2207143009,
0.4558582306,
0.3045311868,
-0.7719973326,
-0.4050037265,
-0.1776176989,
-0.0574379899,
-0.4973814189,
-0.1199810207,
0.5668756962,
-0.3829559684,
-0.898352921,
0.5956090689,
0.2932155728,
0.1744517833,
-0.0399846956,
-0.4379600585,
0.1862861961,
0.1188388243,
0.7553801537,
-0.2290301621,
-0.5982751846,
-0.0622154437,
0.2494682074,
-0.2134179473,
-0.2784327269,
0.8790881634,
-0.4586275518,
0.23805058,
0.7342905998,
0.2953563631,
0.33225739,
0.1394236982,
0.4214424789,
-1.0328121185,
0.3838206828,
0.2388795912,
-0.0704339445,
0.398527056,
-0.1252691448,
0.4407661855,
0.3641484082,
-0.5187373757,
-1.0013729334,
0.384426415,
-0.6861225963,
-0.0529061109,
1.3249694109,
-0.2050500959,
0.0770710185,
-0.1740548164,
-0.3584246337,
0.5461861491,
-0.2379352152,
0.4246281683,
0.4735708237,
-0.2455232441,
0.0893718079,
-0.7690004706,
0.7913433313,
0.4048883617,
-0.4852432609,
0.1097928435,
0.2209649235,
0.0063011935,
0.210068047,
0.8881108165,
-0.1699654758,
0.1579783708,
0.3727405965,
-0.284029305,
0.2446805686,
-0.3051683605,
-0.406090647,
-0.1281020045,
-0.0410341881,
-0.6108675599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00620v1
|
Actor Identification in Discourse: A Challenge for LLMs?
| 2024-02-01T14:30:39 | 2024-02-01T14:30:39 |
Ana Barić, Sean Papay, Sebastian Padó
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The identification of political actors who put forward claims in public
debate is a crucial step in the construction of discourse networks, which are
helpful to analyze societal debates. Actor identification is, however, rather
challenging: Often, the locally mentioned speaker of a claim is only a pronoun
("He proposed that [claim]"), so recovering the canonical actor name requires
discourse understanding. We compare a traditional pipeline of dedicated NLP
components (similar to those applied to the related task of coreference) with a
LLM, which appears a good match for this generation task. Evaluating on a
corpus of German actors in newspaper reports, we find surprisingly that the LLM
performs worse. Further analysis reveals that the LLM is very good at
identifying the right reference, but struggles to generate the correct
canonical form. This points to an underlying issue in LLMs with controlling
generated output. Indeed, a hybrid model combining the LLM with a classifier to
normalize its output substantially outperforms both initial models.
|
[
-0.2545921206,
-0.4205252528,
0.666695118,
-0.2994558811,
-0.1590888053,
0.4286313057,
-0.310275346,
-0.4782238603,
0.3438183069,
0.7613527775,
-0.2988086045,
-0.0578802228,
-0.7653680444,
0.1670276374,
-0.4591059387,
0.7979544401,
0.0868403167,
0.1076942086,
-0.3658006489,
-0.112603873,
-0.0493486524,
-0.6251938939,
-0.8080676794,
-0.7279233932,
0.7530267835,
0.2446072847,
0.643207252,
0.410505861,
0.4337463677,
0.4445212483,
-0.2922027707,
0.3040415347,
-0.330583185,
0.1126967296,
-0.4909049869,
-0.4815796018,
-0.1772655994,
0.0836628601,
0.8893094659,
0.8319538236,
0.1820283532,
0.2490162402,
0.0207051691,
0.6994454861,
-0.6922139525,
0.0186190587,
-0.9339505434,
0.0105475429,
-0.4721526802,
-0.2046664953,
-0.3567180336,
-0.4495849907,
0.1188281029,
-0.3340178132,
0.418386519,
-0.0146619985,
1.0869410038,
-0.1695239097,
-0.6539772749,
-0.4220056236,
-1.164639473,
0.5759834051,
-0.6136238575,
-0.3377726972,
0.0830583423,
0.1796400845,
-0.254953444,
-0.5733362436,
-0.4822578728,
-0.2150595188,
-0.1728120446,
0.0508269854,
-0.3032182455,
0.2369895577,
0.05917551,
0.3835181892,
-0.2177551836,
0.3783893883,
-0.4500545263,
-0.4514184296,
0.6122684479,
0.003221913,
-0.0200982187,
-0.6134058833,
-0.4523109794,
0.3029868603,
-0.7771766186,
-0.0378843285,
0.7135648727,
0.4274438918,
0.2457325459,
0.6083564162,
0.0328754,
0.2960434258,
0.4500004351,
-0.1842368245,
-0.1024546251,
0.0649623722,
-0.2967853844,
0.2422530651,
0.6372575164,
0.1104744226,
0.2382728308,
-0.0382435918,
-0.0415695645,
0.0993354917,
0.253005296,
-0.360478133,
0.0849047974,
0.0314149819,
-0.3107900918,
-0.4334945679,
0.3493728042,
-0.3961628377,
-0.6967864633,
-0.327876687,
0.1257561445,
0.0410577171,
-0.464318186,
-0.4623000026,
0.0068773776,
0.4228077829,
0.4102910757,
-0.6205955744,
0.3863767087,
0.8299841285,
0.4644813538,
-0.3932745457,
0.1215846539,
-0.5256679058,
0.2777168453,
-0.7203309536,
0.9931383133,
-0.5934593081,
-0.3221098781,
0.2203291953,
0.1417123079,
-0.1962766051,
-0.9971920252,
0.5578041077,
-0.4957184494,
0.1603858918,
-0.5123042464,
-0.7999820709,
0.1490076929,
0.1059922874,
-0.651458323,
0.7966462374,
-0.111164771,
-0.7521803379,
0.2920131087,
-0.3118457198,
-0.2780201435,
0.3687130809,
-0.6231210232,
-0.1847324073,
0.4735078216,
-0.3000060022,
0.5698363781,
-0.3893033266,
0.6303430796,
-0.0257319678,
-0.0922321156,
0.4179645479,
-0.1192409396,
0.4981326461,
0.0159915984,
-0.0231348667,
0.1316824704,
-0.8746036291,
-0.5296958685,
0.1980917752,
-0.3659840524,
-0.1385206282,
0.2287145257,
-0.1872508824,
-0.1361664385,
-0.0024195653,
-0.5504556894,
-0.0755889937,
-0.2045242488,
0.3458447456,
1.0647716522,
0.0119217858,
0.6483460665,
-0.5340263247,
0.4696089923,
-0.0862659737,
-0.4862164557,
-0.0929062888,
-0.5088098645,
-0.838499248,
-0.1742546558,
0.6499856114,
0.6887968779,
-0.7276371717,
0.1365593672,
-0.0759584159,
-0.3577307463,
-0.2644319832,
-0.1200250909,
0.3287413716,
0.6105099916,
-0.1733038425,
-0.2477189004,
-0.7600314617,
-1.3213951588,
-0.6553302407,
-0.6592757106,
-0.3094207048,
0.518666923,
0.3958596289,
0.2566771805,
0.8651276827,
-0.1332947165,
-0.2250871211,
-0.3289493322,
0.3155542612,
0.2148980498,
0.2641475797,
0.2533846796,
-0.6665229201,
-0.2307332903,
-0.0154275848,
-0.579790771,
-0.1489249021,
-0.3477192819,
0.0663531274,
0.1025692523,
0.4883845747,
-0.583365798,
0.0034287723,
0.3289384246,
-0.1678092033,
0.7865327001,
0.0127954548,
-0.1607080996,
-1.1684480906,
0.2532709837,
0.0196103286,
-0.4141799212,
-0.6603866816,
-0.0202380028,
-0.3947434425,
-0.1425774843,
-0.702108562,
0.3286991715,
-0.3570937514,
-0.0261219107,
-0.249852702,
0.222690016,
-0.3905667365,
0.2401590943,
0.0178641956,
0.4985426068,
0.3251827657,
-0.6067054868,
0.4514138103,
-0.0504717976,
-0.4322584569,
0.8193333745,
-0.3522112072,
0.400046736,
-0.459006846,
0.4238623381,
-1.0687363148,
-0.5416387916,
0.3236958385,
-0.1445108503,
0.3905196786,
-0.3433509767,
-0.4852330685,
-0.1658586115,
0.0797887966,
0.1349340677,
0.3079069555,
-0.3005966246,
0.8513193727,
0.5408446193,
-0.2260355204,
-0.4505456984,
-0.5334079266,
0.3975621164,
-0.5089330673,
-0.4569119215,
0.7554000616,
0.3684581816,
-0.3486987054,
-0.068149969,
-0.1926875263,
-0.1508400887,
0.0453600697,
0.1419886053,
-0.0293029156,
-0.2271100134,
0.1470257342,
-0.0662236437,
-0.3287336528,
0.2480193377,
0.269302845,
0.0444989689,
0.0128580322,
-0.2386167347,
-0.4658717811,
0.7083119154,
0.2668500245,
0.2066525072,
0.239821896,
0.2667150199,
-0.3977470696,
-0.0708714798,
-0.6232565045,
-0.003565365,
-0.438967526,
0.1788603216,
-0.1647255868,
-0.8427531719,
0.4980508089,
-0.7429352999,
0.0849132463,
0.668674767,
0.5572572947,
-0.2222363949,
0.5920103788,
0.3155966103,
0.0355399512,
0.1087428406,
-0.0396340825,
0.0715943351,
-0.5971297026,
-0.1045081913,
-0.7547556758,
-0.4686589241,
-0.6857306957,
-0.3587737083,
0.1745108068,
-0.0833796188,
0.0853772461,
0.3012733459,
-0.3283570409,
0.5992046595,
0.4140843451,
-0.1840427369,
0.3935134113,
-0.1165593415,
-0.1621351987,
-0.2335966825,
-0.5571284294,
-1.0012637377,
0.5154919624,
0.343183279,
0.5118714571,
0.3118208349,
0.794364512,
0.3013285995,
0.3368926346,
-0.6096390486,
0.9341725707,
-0.1046643332,
-0.7749280334,
0.2689496577,
-0.2185943276,
-0.977250874,
0.469646275,
-0.3343576491,
-0.9144147635,
0.3619827628,
0.2453523576,
-0.459312439,
0.4489753246,
-0.2851975262,
0.5827214718,
-0.0060872724,
-0.0990183726,
-0.1367588937,
-0.570938468,
0.3518737257,
0.0590717085,
0.2140426338,
-0.4524165988,
0.003390783,
0.8493965864,
-0.3158881664,
1.1212893724,
-0.1404856592,
0.0339201801,
0.4777028561,
0.0111100785,
0.5438921452,
0.0435115658,
-0.0330834836,
-0.2160515189,
-0.1098865941,
-0.3714215755,
-0.3503189087,
0.5147180557,
-0.6362933517,
-1.016225338,
-0.4876646996,
-0.0772680417,
-0.1070591062,
-0.1002622619,
0.4450893104,
0.2635349333,
-0.6741575599,
0.3453223407,
0.6444810033,
-0.0553940535,
0.5238177776,
0.3120405972,
0.0002527315,
-0.3231051564,
0.876558125,
0.2535617948,
0.1857324541,
0.3097929955,
0.3417899013,
-0.0410347916,
-0.3915266991,
-0.2965625525,
0.238954246,
-0.6941560507,
-0.20233275,
-0.3861503899,
-0.3305365741,
-0.0020251274,
-0.0754702911,
-0.5141480565,
-0.5031084418,
-0.5941341519,
-0.1545423716,
-0.224172473,
0.7348441482,
-0.0392190553,
0.2462705523,
-0.2559208274,
0.2058101594,
0.4997749925,
-0.0508180596,
-0.2186859995,
-0.4400061369,
-0.0560420305,
-0.435454607,
-0.7214312553,
-1.1877400875,
-0.1191090047,
0.2638458908,
0.5291891694,
0.6600272059,
0.2805851102,
0.4455434978,
-0.5230000019,
1.2247816324,
0.1315813214,
-0.7023971677,
0.468922317,
-0.1850544512,
0.1153751165,
0.3267155886,
0.3695293665,
-0.3255317807,
-0.6251621246,
-0.8504326344,
-0.8846402168,
0.4161859751,
0.2847313285,
0.4916250706,
-0.2201424688,
0.2779308558,
0.158213675,
0.2273069322,
-0.6597284079,
-0.158796072,
0.2522569895,
0.4067352414,
-0.0014007716,
-0.5652261972,
-0.3963170052,
-0.0920199603,
0.5395695567,
-0.1946965456,
0.3419073522,
0.5534958839,
-0.0929350108,
-0.25261724,
0.4703125358,
0.7473023534,
0.6432554126,
0.1235197634,
0.4203833342,
0.0820894986,
0.1288113445,
0.1699030399,
-0.1825036407,
-0.1968286484,
0.4986828268,
0.5962941647,
0.7612905502,
0.3871175349,
-0.3345972598,
0.4152724445,
0.2113313377,
-0.6795066595,
-0.6382882595,
-0.0301078632,
0.1674654931,
0.4415352046,
0.8728685975,
0.2224394232,
-0.0818892121,
-0.6956724524,
-0.0515660532,
0.4481911361,
-0.1508264989,
-0.5220711231,
0.5152328014,
0.4548762739,
-0.7247731686,
0.1720384657,
-0.12233527,
-0.5074616671,
0.62554425,
0.4969639778,
0.9873093963,
-0.2222104669,
0.4733952582,
0.176444158,
0.1449518949,
0.108356528,
-0.0737300366,
0.0631637499,
-0.9641724825,
-0.6349285245,
-0.1958209723,
-0.6251966953,
0.3544175923,
-0.6161707044,
0.1063499749,
-0.5920754075,
-0.5395456553,
0.2264623493,
0.1666014791,
-0.462515384,
-0.315837115,
0.5733471513,
0.5837618113,
-1.0518554449,
0.7029418945,
0.6846361756,
0.1313986331,
-0.5002419949,
0.0189183541,
0.2203640044,
-0.3012533486,
0.5352566242,
-0.0198974311,
-0.0188380517,
-0.1566133648,
-0.4346874654,
-0.616791904,
0.8688808084,
0.847753346,
-0.5460551977,
-0.3183443248,
0.2649387419,
0.4566945732,
-0.7656394243,
0.0246019717,
0.3045330644,
0.5707483292,
0.3346527815,
-0.8667666912,
0.0475113094,
0.1186426282,
0.2504243553,
0.0356374942,
-0.6963244081,
0.6675254107,
-0.0582833141,
-0.4410024583,
0.0399980135,
0.9545179605,
0.2189732641,
0.3076610863,
0.6478354335,
0.1398801953,
0.9602519274,
0.1148829833,
0.9146256447,
0.1482090056,
0.1247392073,
1.185901165,
-0.3344140053,
0.7401984334,
0.6330051422,
-0.1270501465,
0.508249104,
0.7218023539,
-0.018164007,
0.2971447706,
0.4355992079,
-0.323800236,
-0.4525036812,
-0.1346313655,
-0.031917844,
0.532147646,
0.2166237533,
-0.5092878342,
-0.4249974191,
-0.3014539778,
0.0357001647,
0.5460919142,
-0.2630130053,
0.8524747491,
0.2685495317,
-0.7660197616,
0.3196010292,
0.0461012051,
0.3215781152,
-0.263010174,
0.1188820451,
-0.0307186861,
0.0163070783,
-0.3555483818,
-0.3464001715,
0.6145555973,
-0.0720560625,
-0.2149801701,
-0.1998509616,
0.896193862,
-0.2883532643,
-0.3686689436,
0.1929949075,
0.5412929654,
0.3007812202,
0.1780632883,
-0.7111859322,
-0.058525458,
-0.2522083819,
-0.3199263215,
0.2788619697,
0.1507039964,
-0.0771395043,
0.3312691748,
0.3650109172,
0.1540975124,
-0.0071179778,
-0.0797996894,
0.7032074332,
-0.4149973392,
-0.0153182046,
-0.8845570087,
0.3990939856,
-0.195095405,
-0.3650853634,
0.5716713071,
0.5611516833,
0.717276752,
-0.0884743184,
0.5527607799,
-0.0125263156,
0.7037225962,
-0.4647942185,
0.3727764189,
-0.1479625404,
0.1675180495,
-0.3035514355,
-0.7783392668,
-0.1123028398,
0.3587377071,
-0.1103658825,
-0.2259518206,
0.6949439645,
0.6323584318,
-0.0186330676,
-0.1794369817,
0.3757841587,
0.0997630656,
0.2206085771,
0.4237945676,
0.958783865,
-0.2490541488,
0.472038269,
-0.0616793148,
0.0229240898,
-0.2514719963,
-1.09983325,
-0.8340849876,
-0.6322501898,
-0.6608228087,
-0.281442374,
0.019980453,
0.8785179257,
0.7587363124,
-0.7189403176,
-0.4860873222,
0.0009784701,
0.3103621602,
-0.2554063499,
-0.1697092503,
0.1124640107,
-0.185354799,
-0.8888306022,
0.4823080897,
-0.0158036146,
-0.3748757243,
-0.3141785264,
0.0722123384,
-0.2673930526,
0.4895716608,
0.4439874887,
0.455471158,
-1.1830589771,
-0.5055744052,
-0.3966127336,
-0.0067213085,
0.1917494684,
1.2552317381,
-0.6628242731,
0.2970303893,
0.2973184586,
0.7500391603,
0.5305545926,
0.0658779591,
0.7750716805,
-0.940569222,
0.0126798507,
0.4509570301,
0.2608020008,
0.434443593,
-0.3769298494,
0.3045402169,
0.5165097713,
-0.5511095524,
-0.9427723885,
0.6273238063,
-0.982534945,
-0.2244194597,
1.1196081638,
0.0228503458,
-0.3422032595,
-0.1182090566,
-0.2073936164,
0.0312454998,
-0.3344902098,
0.4163383543,
0.8453447819,
-0.1713816077,
-0.3217687905,
-0.3933740854,
0.5107163787,
0.2519692779,
-0.2028625757,
-0.0850575641,
0.1656355113,
0.2237413526,
0.4381926358,
0.7964808345,
-0.0220597275,
-0.0447311178,
-0.3328280449,
-0.1753724664,
0.4063032568,
-0.2115511298,
-0.1942657828,
0.5726479292,
0.2220789641,
-0.0719861165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01775v1
|
Design and consensus content validity of the questionnaire for b-learning education: A 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic Delphi based Decision Support Tool
| 2024-02-01T13:32:18 | 2024-02-01T13:32:18 |
Rosana Montes, Cristina Zuheros, Jeovani M. Morales, Noe Zermeño, Jerónimo Duran, Francsico Herrera
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Classic Delphi and Fuzzy Delphi methods are used to test content validity of
data collection tools such as questionnaires. Fuzzy Delphi takes the opinion
issued by judges from a linguistic perspective reducing ambiguity in opinions
by using fuzzy numbers. We propose an extension named 2-Tuple Fuzzy Linguistic
Delphi method to deal with scenarios in which judges show different expertise
degrees by using fuzzy multigranular semantics of the linguistic terms and to
obtain intermediate and final results expressed by 2-tuple linguistic values.
The key idea of our proposal is to validate the full questionnaire by means of
the evaluation of its parts, defining the validity of each item as a Decision
Making problem. Taking the opinion of experts, we measure the degree of
consensus, the degree of consistency, and the linguistic score of each item, in
order to detect those items that affect, positively or negatively, the quality
of the instrument. Considering the real need to evaluate a b-learning
educational experience with a consensual questionnaire, we present a Decision
Making model for questionnaire validation that solves it. Additionally, we
contribute to this consensus reaching problem by developing an online tool
under GPL v3 license. The software visualizes the collective valuations for
each iteration and assists to determine which parts of the questionnaire should
be modified to reach a consensual solution.
|
[
-0.7165068388,
-0.8827970624,
0.1772374362,
0.1652107686,
-0.528367579,
0.3084885776,
-0.4326248169,
-0.3671410084,
-0.077884607,
0.1134918481,
-0.364382416,
-0.3737043738,
-0.731957078,
-0.0857343376,
-0.2249254286,
0.7135770917,
0.3146575391,
0.273058176,
-0.1208420694,
0.0759174675,
-0.6272580028,
-0.2612982094,
-0.8015553355,
-0.3987183571,
0.2201758027,
1.0720745325,
0.5903621316,
-0.315903306,
0.4663575292,
0.2360967696,
-0.1981303543,
0.3727733195,
-0.4035012722,
0.1636861116,
-0.5590962768,
-0.4129922092,
-0.494328618,
0.2787568569,
0.4545555115,
0.6225601435,
-0.5322639942,
0.2274269164,
0.3265421689,
0.7350547314,
-0.4703313112,
0.0630948171,
-0.546208322,
0.0177742448,
0.0902202353,
0.34002316,
-0.3976968229,
-0.8225205541,
0.4809921384,
-0.3636511564,
0.1286630183,
-0.1028253958,
0.7415648103,
0.1872302294,
-0.2706207931,
-0.119861275,
-0.480363071,
0.6635668278,
-0.7684708834,
0.771078825,
0.6467237473,
0.548943758,
-0.0568457022,
-0.3926850259,
-0.8369222879,
-0.1767229289,
-0.0523237698,
0.3142598569,
0.4049980938,
0.1454754025,
0.0693465695,
0.3871120512,
-0.5342401862,
0.0936085656,
-0.8271628022,
-0.0545880757,
0.7336989045,
-0.1859636903,
-0.1544763446,
-0.1155015975,
-0.3239507079,
0.1307688802,
-0.4957398474,
-0.0115317348,
0.277783215,
0.2217012793,
-0.2533878684,
0.6537023187,
-0.19520244,
0.7737721205,
0.4284434915,
-0.0277199429,
0.4471817017,
-0.2670543492,
-0.2283686846,
-0.0019850247,
0.6532336473,
0.7388753891,
0.4710538685,
0.0300365835,
-0.0165760797,
0.0210597031,
0.311234206,
-0.5559876561,
-0.1641328633,
0.5338176489,
-0.3971242905,
-0.0648344159,
-0.0034949747,
-1.0349817276,
-0.4549328685,
-0.5802391768,
0.4713109434,
-0.725976944,
-0.7034993768,
0.3055073023,
-0.2541714609,
0.3374683261,
0.4225195944,
-1.0018758774,
0.3345319033,
0.783904314,
0.7627527714,
-0.302187413,
-0.3146092296,
0.0161929671,
-0.1287210584,
-0.3073665798,
0.8030709028,
-0.5969520807,
-0.7291855812,
-0.0241395943,
-0.3528762162,
-0.0251318328,
-0.4202173352,
0.3301967382,
-0.2841205895,
0.6290555,
-0.2372505963,
-0.8477458954,
-0.5596894622,
0.7419518232,
-0.5181986094,
0.8659794331,
0.3601787686,
-0.4741408229,
0.8029070497,
-0.5540575385,
-0.2371588349,
0.2334442139,
-0.2095132917,
-0.2557516992,
-0.0583290495,
-0.3371071815,
0.2731884718,
-0.2250151634,
0.5345187783,
-0.3443197012,
-0.3298784494,
0.2982309461,
-0.302216053,
0.6629464626,
0.1367729753,
-0.3225348294,
-0.1434515566,
-0.7830776572,
0.2435029149,
-0.3965399563,
-0.4677913785,
-0.20386298,
0.1401545256,
-0.2018104941,
0.3880987763,
0.352679491,
-0.5924296975,
0.2182025164,
-0.4064541757,
-0.1301940978,
0.5582231879,
0.2942379713,
0.3513115346,
-0.5029584765,
0.2689999342,
0.164450869,
0.4972566664,
0.5787366629,
-0.6836495399,
-0.8592600226,
-0.029308917,
0.4261316359,
0.5214264393,
-0.6167706251,
0.501963973,
0.1997207403,
-0.9352071285,
-0.4835977256,
0.0388479158,
0.3971492946,
0.5170947313,
0.3427239358,
-0.1983814836,
-0.4009231627,
-0.7406764627,
0.224655807,
-0.4480777085,
0.1775806099,
0.0583374016,
0.4349041879,
0.1265700758,
0.7195881009,
-0.3824728131,
-0.2553010583,
-0.4011871815,
-0.0682441369,
0.2878296375,
0.7020714879,
0.7121611834,
-0.8448922634,
-0.3563403189,
-0.1649160236,
-0.2967520654,
0.0481103621,
0.2643576264,
-0.3298840523,
0.4843680263,
-0.2302987725,
-0.2705212235,
0.2329297662,
0.4029965699,
-0.4945208728,
0.6283749938,
-0.0168935973,
0.4769765139,
-0.921939671,
0.0629573613,
0.0848754123,
0.1043704376,
-0.3449008167,
0.1376439929,
-0.025615206,
0.0884216949,
-0.4618718326,
0.4031086266,
0.2578260303,
0.3523813486,
-0.1050717831,
0.6129361987,
0.132453084,
0.431333065,
0.3174071014,
0.4885162413,
0.6008312702,
-0.7209026814,
0.6457101703,
0.6011558175,
-0.4050759375,
1.3110762835,
-0.6334363818,
-0.0461549349,
-0.0499445759,
-0.0986753106,
-1.1730573177,
-0.0405018069,
0.6434912682,
-0.7508934736,
0.2345838398,
-0.1973373294,
-0.2194282562,
-0.0802177191,
-0.2755119205,
0.091905199,
0.2963757813,
-0.1346463561,
0.1685248911,
0.3818310201,
-0.1764740795,
-0.488897413,
-0.7729974389,
-0.1681248248,
-0.0110955955,
-0.6241998076,
-0.0047330246,
-0.3361400366,
-0.3721253872,
-0.0256240238,
-0.1827279478,
-0.4115285873,
0.1946976781,
0.0719649643,
0.4160417616,
-0.0381519049,
0.2556270659,
0.2193969786,
0.0008732784,
0.1181124002,
-0.1745502204,
0.5050809979,
-0.0366949402,
-0.4095151126,
-0.0221945159,
0.5161064863,
0.4577173293,
-0.5282303095,
0.4452026486,
0.2140017003,
-0.7492718697,
-0.2307606041,
-0.6674162745,
0.1096113324,
-0.4363283217,
0.0334046073,
-0.0314251371,
-0.6833570004,
0.2407221198,
0.174718067,
0.3853046596,
0.2151915729,
0.753632009,
0.0388993584,
0.6580831409,
0.2412980646,
0.2625645697,
0.3146237731,
-0.5744726062,
0.0918128192,
-0.5843272805,
-1.11211133,
-0.667085588,
-0.6378296614,
-0.360042423,
0.0169139169,
0.2207666039,
-0.2535837293,
-0.5093435645,
-0.0445675217,
-0.5356194973,
0.0680126324,
0.9334135652,
0.5138754845,
0.0545087755,
-0.1187972873,
-0.2605392337,
0.0418192409,
-0.1713048816,
-0.3272414804,
0.6746823192,
-0.0754696801,
0.637073338,
0.5734796524,
0.7336624265,
0.520666182,
-0.0377955325,
-1.1215797663,
0.6027410626,
-0.0501323938,
-0.9138234258,
-0.3469103873,
-0.1118480563,
-0.6086013913,
0.3029046655,
-0.474294126,
-0.6077076197,
0.2388272136,
-0.1373734474,
-0.3539732993,
0.1256220043,
-0.7412078977,
0.9205025434,
-0.3294482231,
-0.410425961,
-0.51860708,
-0.5745446086,
0.126600489,
-0.2120333612,
0.0415152796,
-0.1433860213,
-0.0512389317,
0.719170928,
-0.22215195,
0.6738232374,
-0.5411477685,
-0.0469008535,
0.5952141285,
0.3339919448,
-0.2609007061,
0.1731215119,
-0.4752531052,
0.0254707858,
0.2074912637,
-0.2112471461,
-0.6047660112,
0.4739236832,
-0.7384450436,
-0.7533422112,
-0.4904019237,
-0.0319915637,
-0.5836386681,
0.4007895589,
0.0747102499,
0.5031327605,
-0.0725853592,
0.1658760607,
0.5525522232,
0.1426542401,
0.1044710949,
0.7482869625,
-0.2414756268,
-0.4925798476,
0.7803595662,
0.2764026523,
0.2577199936,
0.1855199635,
0.33639431,
-0.5505636334,
-0.7830592394,
-0.440653801,
0.0135901654,
-0.6527916193,
-0.3303459585,
-0.0133835059,
-0.2403009981,
-0.4570943713,
-0.1396182477,
0.1432912648,
-0.6668022871,
-0.0556492619,
-0.4650940001,
0.2428894043,
0.5063852072,
-0.3777053952,
0.3016686738,
-0.8154871464,
0.2265828699,
0.2269266248,
0.7358747721,
-0.2487597167,
-0.7077864408,
-0.120379813,
0.2814416587,
-0.4962952733,
-1.0428268909,
-0.197784543,
0.3651773036,
0.7067421675,
0.4447304904,
0.0175048821,
0.3113719523,
-0.1297658831,
1.094620347,
0.0021832415,
-0.8960087299,
0.7267218828,
-0.0782954469,
-0.1464044601,
0.9345007539,
0.4875737429,
-0.7246302366,
-0.512432456,
-0.817160666,
-0.4954796433,
0.4497450292,
-0.2019453198,
-0.1456188858,
-0.1937066466,
0.3902743161,
0.2207265794,
0.4415522218,
-0.1458687335,
-0.2579334378,
-0.3684764504,
-0.1729188561,
0.1829813421,
-0.394220829,
0.0342202,
-0.1262695342,
0.8879669309,
0.1307781488,
-0.3299193978,
0.040261209,
0.2271638215,
0.0894198865,
0.5283708572,
0.2664875686,
1.0384464264,
-0.1714803874,
-0.0442621075,
0.2196312994,
-0.5385116339,
0.218514204,
0.0306795891,
-0.2281990051,
-0.0150683718,
-0.1097120643,
0.0632217228,
0.2611592114,
-0.5300523639,
0.7763755322,
-0.0900365561,
-0.3232627809,
-0.3355639577,
0.298926115,
-0.2871472836,
0.2491728663,
0.088027671,
0.120386228,
0.3967136145,
-0.2354620397,
0.4372904599,
0.1576935351,
-0.4200582802,
-0.0420665145,
0.4335534275,
0.4726528823,
-0.2360308766,
0.9041458368,
-0.3184745312,
-0.4829456508,
0.4032889605,
0.3457011282,
0.5239011049,
-0.4810791016,
0.6670992374,
0.5634559989,
0.2860347033,
-0.1696769744,
0.9600358009,
-0.0664228424,
-0.6479927301,
-0.3114478588,
-0.450760603,
-0.9709684253,
-0.1314525157,
-0.6477207541,
0.645924449,
-0.6526036859,
-0.1705976576,
-0.2360162884,
0.2192001045,
-0.4034433961,
0.8069698811,
0.256537497,
1.2346111536,
-0.6796349287,
0.4486809671,
1.0345301628,
-0.4672937393,
-0.8941182494,
-0.5159487128,
0.1080086008,
-0.5105657578,
0.0075790389,
-0.0278696511,
-0.0465733074,
-0.2815499008,
-0.547616899,
-0.5136725307,
0.6522640586,
0.1044578776,
-0.6420572996,
-0.0425437689,
0.1184649765,
0.4775952101,
0.3378559351,
0.1400702894,
0.5273768902,
0.7160061598,
0.5087365508,
-0.9765732884,
-0.124658905,
-0.1104706824,
-0.748904109,
0.2167633325,
-0.7864980698,
0.4597711265,
-0.2156486511,
0.0574819706,
-0.0443121344,
0.5709865093,
0.5553885102,
0.5119280219,
0.5608890057,
0.5081775188,
0.9970591068,
-0.2723467052,
0.352793932,
-0.4357841611,
0.6121591926,
0.9561332464,
-0.0526471883,
0.7979713082,
0.2837207019,
-0.3114079237,
0.4772872925,
0.9160190821,
-0.2085410208,
0.4367637038,
0.3301168978,
-0.3713092506,
-0.4729258716,
-0.1942543089,
-0.4422474205,
0.7190291286,
0.6839668751,
0.1773542762,
-0.2013848424,
-0.2573565245,
0.0583016723,
0.1173510104,
-0.496283263,
0.4961816967,
0.1050660685,
-0.9750583768,
0.2414072901,
-0.1530686915,
0.4126398563,
-0.6570168734,
-0.1617933661,
-0.2845803499,
0.1466483623,
-0.578243494,
-1.2712059021,
0.4376867712,
-0.1043853089,
0.071888946,
0.2069474906,
0.5472593307,
-0.6873838902,
-0.5879818201,
-0.1276548505,
0.8154505491,
0.1655196548,
0.1443601698,
-0.5594007373,
-0.1256136447,
-0.2551427186,
0.1403350532,
-0.1406127363,
0.621229291,
0.296841532,
0.5785065293,
0.1772125214,
0.3182958364,
-0.1421121508,
0.2248011231,
0.7159702182,
-0.2140716761,
-0.4606301486,
-0.6262850165,
0.4196498096,
-0.1079489514,
-0.4225738943,
0.5060005784,
0.7962040305,
1.1784549952,
0.288738966,
0.9936232567,
-0.5795726776,
0.4789032638,
-0.452331543,
0.8097297549,
-0.58752352,
-0.1783933043,
-0.1440189034,
-0.667131424,
-0.3110530674,
0.6752293706,
-0.1076057851,
0.0898183659,
0.6033933759,
0.4400826097,
0.069125466,
0.3718011677,
0.2845147252,
-0.0474476255,
0.135189876,
0.5773730278,
0.9763388038,
-0.006618591,
0.5425444245,
-0.3502422571,
-0.4298365414,
0.1132131442,
-0.5807267427,
-1.0276062489,
-0.7940326929,
-0.4515180588,
-0.5267386436,
0.0429944098,
1.2874910831,
0.3621857762,
-0.7343780994,
-0.1590387672,
0.4738284945,
0.3813985586,
-0.2815667093,
-0.1910166442,
0.3156369925,
-0.2289677709,
-0.7095395923,
-0.0360319205,
-0.0687537491,
-0.0770239085,
-0.4068227112,
0.1058329418,
-0.2294822186,
-0.135318175,
0.5516762733,
-0.0961590111,
-0.3801823556,
-0.7112138867,
0.0241805688,
0.0903307423,
-0.1117356122,
0.5854417086,
-0.5200837255,
0.5462026,
0.7207271457,
0.4050724208,
-0.0251320973,
0.0497003756,
0.2750943601,
-0.3786768019,
-0.0632637814,
0.2563913763,
0.5305690765,
0.2165745795,
-0.1020908728,
0.58378613,
0.2476704419,
-0.6018155813,
-0.2193686217,
0.3060397208,
-1.172922492,
-0.0297158789,
1.3245745897,
-0.3378383517,
0.1878808886,
-0.3492737114,
-0.6768499613,
0.2219060957,
-0.5270591974,
1.1019672155,
0.8160797358,
-0.0373200364,
0.030316649,
-0.0628837124,
0.2680568993,
0.0227392465,
-0.5131295323,
-0.2589808702,
0.6984149218,
0.3855232894,
-0.0586920977,
0.4556752145,
-0.2535772622,
0.6027092338,
-0.2353320867,
-0.2212182581,
-0.2064851224,
-0.302115947,
-0.0332680158,
0.0926146805,
0.2738638818,
-0.4594735801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03471v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03471v1
|
The Information of Large Language Model Geometry
| 2024-02-01T12:50:43 | 2024-02-01T12:50:43 |
Zhiquan Tan, Chenghai Li, Weiran Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
This paper investigates the information encoded in the embeddings of large
language models (LLMs). We conduct simulations to analyze the representation
entropy and discover a power law relationship with model sizes. Building upon
this observation, we propose a theory based on (conditional) entropy to
elucidate the scaling law phenomenon. Furthermore, we delve into the
auto-regressive structure of LLMs and examine the relationship between the last
token and previous context tokens using information theory and regression
techniques. Specifically, we establish a theoretical connection between the
information gain of new tokens and ridge regression. Additionally, we explore
the effectiveness of Lasso regression in selecting meaningful tokens, which
sometimes outperforms the closely related attention weights. Finally, we
conduct controlled experiments, and find that information is distributed across
tokens, rather than being concentrated in specific "meaningful" tokens alone.
|
[
0.0067906054,
-0.7522587776,
0.7958400846,
0.0739070028,
-0.028964838,
-0.4149129689,
-0.4553903639,
-0.2750615478,
0.4568433166,
0.5630795956,
-0.2844131589,
-0.3934009969,
-0.8874585629,
-0.2754748464,
-0.500915885,
0.6567502022,
0.0677107573,
0.2195586264,
-0.1580729485,
0.1275051683,
-0.2727843821,
-0.8192028999,
-0.6760709286,
-0.0329759717,
0.5767771006,
-0.1299545169,
0.7263397574,
1.1473045349,
0.6289576292,
0.3232249618,
-0.2370520085,
-0.3220834136,
-0.5737922192,
0.258782655,
-0.0062566213,
-0.9251111746,
-0.3270824254,
-0.0394003429,
1.281201005,
0.7217625976,
-0.1773401648,
0.1919119656,
0.1333155036,
0.4892989993,
-0.5419263244,
0.514213562,
-0.5697836876,
-0.007425826,
-0.1856854707,
-0.2756229639,
-0.5710480213,
-0.2565521598,
-0.0598498732,
-0.621003449,
-0.0891018212,
0.5600560308,
0.7054700851,
0.4491306841,
-0.5635413527,
-0.3903140426,
-0.6435526609,
0.9245381355,
-0.7610942721,
0.6215491295,
0.4196804464,
0.0826938003,
-0.3139863908,
-0.5334333777,
-0.2015752494,
-0.3249621391,
-0.1782770455,
-0.4287866652,
-0.3237850368,
0.1863273233,
0.3933922052,
0.3826018274,
-0.4482271075,
0.2327567488,
-0.4054998457,
-0.2636662126,
0.553874135,
0.1337400675,
0.4289547801,
-0.1446477473,
-0.1935916394,
-0.1044740379,
-0.8413607478,
-0.0789952874,
0.3476858735,
0.4825273752,
-0.1701851785,
0.7600387931,
0.2055735439,
0.7864046693,
-0.0025322065,
-0.3599787056,
0.2374660075,
-0.2176068425,
-0.3846483827,
0.1622639894,
0.6915211082,
0.0289845578,
0.2259876728,
-0.2874893546,
-0.0880763531,
-0.5717011094,
0.0360117443,
-0.7307789326,
0.1476175487,
-0.0455889255,
-0.7528643608,
-0.0351179503,
0.2418282181,
-0.3244380951,
-0.541700542,
-0.6154564619,
0.3234404325,
-0.2122760415,
-0.52310884,
0.1036480516,
-0.2246832252,
0.3686743677,
0.2346213311,
-1.0262498856,
0.1611973047,
0.8932749629,
0.919993341,
0.0910309181,
-0.174264729,
-0.444860816,
0.3195933998,
-0.1699203551,
0.2320733219,
-0.713085711,
0.0197199062,
0.1313975155,
0.1369844079,
-0.0976953581,
-0.3128083646,
0.2539736927,
-0.6252442002,
0.0341582596,
-0.4025687873,
-0.8881328106,
-0.0735916123,
0.0227422249,
-0.9199435115,
0.7455564141,
0.0280333254,
-0.8882831931,
0.3200933933,
-0.3851804733,
-0.1000320241,
-0.0381123945,
-0.4073227644,
-0.0722012073,
0.4311219156,
-0.2280161232,
0.5947215557,
-0.5168378949,
0.3326426744,
-0.4903007746,
-0.0935631841,
0.200965181,
-0.2634777129,
0.7909443974,
0.2609036863,
-0.0573776551,
-0.058180742,
-0.5045471191,
-0.1351734251,
0.2382854372,
-0.4187803268,
-0.6421554685,
-0.0405032448,
-0.153250739,
-0.1016311347,
0.4463936985,
-0.5714562535,
0.5319972038,
-0.0961232334,
0.416882515,
0.6692655683,
-0.2118199468,
0.6792131066,
0.0168500356,
0.4477881491,
-0.1037611216,
0.0689065382,
-0.0229966864,
-0.3560796082,
-0.5329564214,
-0.3333842754,
0.4165381193,
0.3169536293,
-0.2119082212,
0.3190796673,
-0.3639962077,
-0.0238596257,
-0.2883379161,
0.1874348968,
0.1293950677,
0.0090414546,
-0.1185068116,
0.0589219071,
-0.7345533371,
-0.9522074461,
-0.334666431,
-0.3320682049,
-0.219682917,
0.3714604676,
0.2622156441,
-0.0466773137,
0.8794126511,
-0.485124886,
-0.1218869016,
-0.2153307348,
0.0031573593,
0.3571427166,
0.4238845706,
0.8097080588,
-0.6485196948,
-0.0779451653,
-0.0818663239,
-0.6660357714,
0.0772546828,
0.1288899928,
0.060194917,
0.0370285101,
0.957880795,
-0.5543617606,
0.4053531885,
0.6245007515,
-0.4860218763,
0.2333185822,
-0.3939507604,
-0.1755406708,
-1.0812600851,
-0.0207952149,
0.0053469627,
-0.153677538,
-0.556038022,
-0.1026710793,
0.0814161375,
0.1350365579,
-0.1778724641,
0.828050375,
-0.5883733034,
-0.2770654559,
-0.2553214133,
0.0051922067,
-0.2464219779,
0.3472279906,
-0.1483157724,
0.4889765084,
0.634645462,
-0.5266650915,
0.5074130297,
-0.2457176894,
-0.3458289802,
0.223459065,
-0.5780501962,
-0.1677801013,
-0.4799693227,
0.2771653235,
-1.0630007982,
-0.3954362869,
-0.265426755,
-0.3037779629,
0.507133007,
-0.2784360349,
-0.8655848503,
-0.2642368376,
-0.1219667196,
0.7273692489,
0.4330595136,
-0.466781199,
0.6167808175,
0.8832122087,
-0.1768590063,
-0.4378292263,
-0.6565594673,
0.0065396815,
-0.4836253226,
-0.677662015,
0.0769323409,
0.1296471208,
-0.7052820921,
0.0454565734,
0.3490867317,
0.0118926316,
-0.0407409407,
0.2932578921,
0.0117562544,
-0.5025451183,
0.6479169726,
-0.2896808386,
0.219742626,
0.3270998299,
-0.5638743043,
0.7192307115,
-0.3388413489,
-0.1818758845,
-0.5236259103,
0.2042992264,
0.643309772,
0.1873977035,
1.0136328936,
0.4178771079,
-0.4733402729,
0.0581271127,
-0.6133266091,
-0.1465092897,
-0.4678331614,
0.4878363311,
-0.2573563755,
-1.0176626444,
0.7525994182,
0.0345986523,
-0.1042993814,
0.7294889092,
0.6424499154,
0.1663350165,
1.2366778851,
1.1393107176,
-0.317761004,
0.874014914,
-0.2421428859,
0.3000861704,
-0.8997970223,
-0.392468363,
-0.5332308412,
-0.3676563501,
-0.6985704303,
-0.4806628525,
0.2180401534,
0.2779585719,
-0.7242492437,
0.1947561949,
-0.1408960521,
0.3911882639,
0.6168951988,
-0.189057216,
0.0739689395,
0.0598335639,
-0.06638363,
0.124184601,
-0.7981920838,
-0.2355711609,
1.0049710274,
0.6826831698,
1.1344473362,
0.3035533428,
0.4133417606,
0.228450343,
0.1164784357,
-0.9313093424,
0.2316170186,
-0.102723904,
-0.4944261611,
-0.5101225376,
-0.6280633211,
-1.0847738981,
-0.0221846309,
0.0145724714,
-1.0740225315,
0.370123744,
-0.0651104301,
-0.2317612767,
0.6162065268,
-0.7168866992,
0.3961550891,
-0.2447241247,
-0.1244045198,
-0.2051396072,
-0.5350834727,
0.201170966,
-0.0273137968,
0.3253445029,
0.0252381135,
-0.0944685265,
1.0779570341,
-0.5730366707,
0.8685204387,
-0.1373145729,
-0.3003991544,
0.283922255,
0.1356077343,
0.5759427547,
0.0622628033,
-0.1706029028,
0.1228175014,
0.2118220925,
-0.5004359484,
-0.8201459646,
0.6817121506,
-0.8586801291,
-0.8032628298,
-0.0629873052,
-0.8590367436,
-0.0119090285,
0.1961419284,
0.1157393232,
0.3940499723,
0.180070892,
0.5890415907,
0.5909417272,
-0.2447675616,
0.3816753924,
0.2500411868,
-0.5074031949,
-0.0613445938,
0.478749007,
0.3105550408,
0.1876598895,
0.4163634479,
0.3020182848,
-0.2763654292,
-0.3061403334,
-0.1587256342,
0.7433469892,
-0.7259573936,
-0.2188863903,
-0.4142626822,
-0.4808376729,
-0.5237102509,
0.1174243316,
-0.333843857,
-0.476926744,
-0.2675914466,
-0.1410766691,
0.4861911237,
1.3228398561,
-0.1859469712,
0.41498667,
-0.3730272353,
-0.4484245479,
0.0397568271,
0.311306864,
0.2684904635,
-0.741351068,
-0.4603545368,
0.1806047559,
0.1679249257,
-0.5941593051,
0.4091298878,
-0.0861654207,
0.6394054294,
0.6490150094,
-0.2147761583,
0.4009432197,
-0.4105019569,
0.6623601317,
0.3527473509,
-0.8296042681,
0.2124172598,
-0.3533063531,
0.1830857992,
0.0050334646,
0.2332437932,
-0.517108202,
-0.5321677327,
-0.7142022252,
-0.7594485283,
0.5244048238,
-0.1441031694,
0.4531223774,
0.0958753824,
0.8606982231,
-0.1413618624,
0.1491877884,
-0.7532448173,
-0.1300813854,
0.1096211746,
-0.3000507057,
0.1751647443,
-0.5229315758,
-0.0111609092,
-0.2282909006,
0.3067134619,
0.0642779022,
0.4320110977,
0.0287018232,
-0.0207116921,
-0.0390022695,
-0.0408253148,
0.6613322496,
0.6794614792,
-0.1640085131,
0.3965953588,
0.0673024058,
-0.5156853795,
-0.0545272604,
-0.3683592677,
0.3098248243,
-0.1073579714,
0.6933040619,
1.0819724798,
0.0150357829,
-0.3919097781,
0.6014234424,
-0.1900156736,
-0.077804625,
-0.3754746318,
0.026465388,
-0.0147512341,
0.4545376301,
0.5925602913,
-0.4768650532,
0.0329289213,
-0.8259837031,
0.1827137172,
0.6503195763,
-0.4574033618,
-0.5179579258,
0.4550991654,
-0.2125242054,
-0.2583348751,
0.5762203336,
0.0808789581,
-0.4577203691,
0.8298723698,
0.6543178558,
0.5022647381,
-0.395835042,
0.0234415308,
0.5163519382,
0.3022578359,
-0.1323527992,
0.0463156439,
0.0814487636,
-0.5275111198,
-0.4760826826,
-0.7925994396,
0.0844875574,
0.2233418673,
-0.6735927463,
0.2449226528,
-0.4717644453,
-0.3208517134,
-0.1821613461,
-0.0629444122,
-0.7763192654,
0.0395769291,
0.4249721766,
0.7827604413,
-0.9017238021,
0.8563529253,
0.3286194205,
-0.3324461877,
-1.0606579781,
0.0266524442,
-0.0224435534,
-1.1565382481,
1.2226024866,
-0.0139316628,
-0.0239277631,
-0.0366182365,
-0.6443849206,
-1.8349905014,
1.0848644972,
0.68116045,
-0.5704830289,
-0.350700289,
0.0153081473,
0.5690158606,
-0.7071231604,
0.2410633266,
0.3405559063,
0.4562461972,
0.3333859146,
-1.0282278061,
0.1997635961,
-0.0137863597,
0.0585000329,
0.4055708945,
-0.7629625797,
1.1689722538,
-0.2323539704,
-0.2310205251,
-0.0606229082,
0.5673210621,
-0.0744943619,
-0.2821125984,
0.4229989946,
0.4341936111,
1.0829310417,
0.1022690833,
1.3463221788,
-0.6159844398,
0.6520928144,
0.8172764778,
0.1153714359,
0.8319930434,
0.5268022418,
-0.1280916631,
0.5171075463,
0.6404274702,
0.1048071906,
0.4944565594,
0.5948334336,
0.1345660537,
-0.0710554048,
-0.3021684885,
-0.4026893675,
0.3579703271,
0.4782160223,
-0.8598642945,
-0.1358813494,
0.1197405607,
0.350028336,
-0.6117550135,
-0.5903790593,
0.8593091965,
0.2957268357,
-0.2866670489,
0.6730326414,
0.0485564619,
0.2937157154,
-0.4654955268,
0.2327409387,
-0.1031378657,
0.1540113986,
-0.2007488906,
-0.6850589514,
0.2877911925,
-0.1796730161,
-0.3350197971,
-0.2451997995,
0.3499341607,
-0.465687871,
-0.5831577182,
0.3739809394,
0.2364502102,
0.2863461375,
0.0710155517,
-0.3934317529,
0.3418712914,
-0.0936330557,
-0.4570101798,
0.2692147195,
0.7721300125,
-0.1491104215,
0.5743095875,
0.3490693271,
0.4155600071,
0.3447456062,
0.0151114287,
0.8204025626,
-0.7357794642,
-0.4045596421,
-1.1301320791,
-0.0180519465,
-0.1960406601,
-0.019953467,
0.8467504978,
0.5928819776,
0.4632306993,
0.3157122731,
0.6977379322,
0.1181488484,
0.1744329333,
-0.7551973462,
0.6599478126,
-0.6821017265,
0.3414861262,
0.0433488153,
-1.0135405064,
-0.5185703039,
0.4869629145,
-0.6820683479,
-0.0502919517,
0.7464367151,
0.5677168369,
-0.1677060425,
-0.1489019692,
0.4183797538,
0.6087229848,
0.215611279,
0.3895600736,
0.6060520411,
-0.2116277367,
0.2557160556,
0.4091483355,
-0.271086961,
-0.4733928442,
-0.736474812,
-0.8098484278,
-0.9980462193,
-0.0777134672,
-0.5038193464,
-0.3318658471,
0.8872831464,
0.7833499908,
-0.5410889387,
-0.4220821857,
-0.0287725031,
0.1745529175,
0.454190582,
-0.2106678039,
0.7300022244,
-0.5191147327,
-0.558326304,
-0.0064169285,
0.436262399,
0.1745182723,
-0.5840033889,
-0.0225191247,
0.1521563828,
0.4714423418,
0.5838293433,
0.0697336346,
-0.7913361192,
-0.3560845554,
-0.0801816434,
-0.316211313,
0.1177654192,
1.2006516457,
-0.4520146251,
0.2555680573,
0.7216728926,
0.6266126037,
0.4771912396,
-0.2004421204,
0.8824334741,
-0.6213508248,
0.4507323205,
-0.0252577662,
0.7217622399,
0.311070323,
-0.5959808826,
0.1934945285,
-0.0148537699,
-0.4781641364,
-0.9488635063,
0.3457140625,
-0.6365820169,
-0.3565005362,
1.6332219839,
-0.1012795791,
-0.8058379889,
0.2797942758,
-0.0006673259,
0.0879162997,
-0.2782221138,
0.6393888593,
1.0979328156,
-0.0900419727,
-0.2372812182,
-0.5650251508,
0.6056814194,
0.2486771196,
-0.4382143021,
0.2258260548,
0.2977257073,
0.2970345914,
0.3145143986,
0.3358471394,
-0.0770481452,
-0.3614679873,
-0.0269922111,
-0.1124207303,
0.2171736062,
-0.2849515975,
-0.3694287837,
0.1227339581,
0.1409504414,
0.2405481189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00559v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00559v4
|
A Chain-of-Thought Is as Strong as Its Weakest Link: A Benchmark for Verifiers of Reasoning Chains
| 2024-02-01T12:46:45 | 2024-05-21T09:55:07 |
Alon Jacovi, Yonatan Bitton, Bernd Bohnet, Jonathan Herzig, Or Honovich, Michael Tseng, Michael Collins, Roee Aharoni, Mor Geva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompting language models to provide step-by-step answers (e.g.,
"Chain-of-Thought") is the prominent approach for complex reasoning tasks,
where more accurate reasoning chains typically improve downstream task
performance. Recent literature discusses automatic methods to verify reasoning
to evaluate and improve their correctness. However, no fine-grained step-level
datasets are available to enable thorough evaluation of such verification
methods, hindering progress in this direction. We introduce REVEAL: Reasoning
Verification Evaluation, a dataset to benchmark automatic verifiers of complex
Chain-of-Thought reasoning in open-domain question-answering settings. REVEAL
includes comprehensive labels for the relevance, attribution to evidence
passages, and logical correctness of each reasoning step in a language model's
answer, across a variety of datasets and state-of-the-art language models.
Evaluation on REVEAL shows that verifiers struggle at verifying reasoning
chains - in particular, verifying logical correctness and detecting
contradictions. Available at https://reveal-dataset.github.io/ .
|
[
-0.340503186,
-0.7584857345,
0.6551816463,
-0.2349001914,
0.0029171526,
0.3546530306,
-0.1587020755,
-0.4548440576,
-0.188078329,
0.3820023239,
-0.6654640436,
-0.2938144505,
-0.5811725259,
0.1198026463,
-0.5640006065,
0.8778814673,
-0.4128987193,
-0.1793350428,
-0.2647923827,
-0.1148695499,
-0.3389760852,
-0.2120047659,
-0.2963821888,
-0.600820303,
0.4438390434,
0.1389050335,
0.7696561217,
0.6948430538,
0.585493207,
0.1910923123,
0.0568170063,
0.5230252743,
-0.614223361,
0.2563191354,
-0.6544998884,
-0.4725230336,
-0.4260536134,
-0.0611561872,
0.4182614088,
0.8937712312,
-0.0746748224,
0.5500192642,
-0.3057953715,
0.8271608949,
-1.0727891922,
-0.0113061043,
-0.8066558242,
-0.2071515769,
-0.0511687063,
0.0393640734,
-0.5079975128,
-0.7081938982,
0.2345196307,
-0.3245526254,
-0.0475936793,
0.4255605936,
0.998955667,
0.303594768,
-0.4552856684,
-0.3573178947,
-0.9231863022,
0.5503555536,
-0.4213954806,
0.3234332204,
0.3351967633,
0.7703180909,
-0.1597976089,
-0.795107305,
-0.6410658956,
-0.0450201146,
-0.051398851,
0.0559609868,
-0.4546450973,
-0.0935618952,
0.587613821,
0.7461182475,
-0.5985808372,
-0.3222495019,
-0.1607845426,
-0.1454238594,
0.6479533315,
0.1609689295,
0.3005166948,
0.2616630197,
-0.3994313776,
-0.2418773025,
-0.8109986186,
0.0322854035,
0.2849360704,
0.0948015973,
0.1758751273,
0.6553958654,
-0.6255686283,
0.7165543437,
0.0996155813,
0.2965453267,
0.2457203269,
-0.6072279215,
-0.3040594161,
-0.0425295606,
0.7669856548,
0.2302506268,
0.2068280429,
-0.1153760701,
-0.3468705714,
0.1685875505,
0.3598529696,
-0.6689337492,
-0.4671860039,
0.3278087974,
-0.1800742745,
-0.1169760153,
0.1295911819,
-0.4095750153,
-0.4091293514,
-0.0781735107,
0.761839509,
-0.1109102145,
-0.189831987,
0.4408315122,
-0.2086157799,
0.0663881823,
0.3824004233,
-0.3201929629,
0.5979101062,
0.7626392245,
0.4041664898,
0.0416217893,
-0.2841086388,
-0.5099346638,
-0.0961694643,
-0.6048185229,
0.8070147038,
-0.5105773211,
0.3729960024,
0.0841657445,
0.0604470894,
-0.0242577512,
-0.47562325,
0.7822147012,
-0.4306651056,
-0.0116567258,
-0.5928353071,
-0.6600562334,
-0.0487197302,
0.6583981514,
-0.8091800809,
1.0627000332,
-0.1081112474,
-0.9326053262,
0.2455716878,
-0.2190125138,
-0.2691720426,
-0.0540463217,
-0.1983415335,
-0.2499489188,
0.0237752348,
0.3131725788,
0.2278366387,
-0.6065633297,
0.1766371876,
-0.4290577769,
-0.4466406703,
0.3996638954,
-0.5289638638,
0.8478139043,
0.0384940729,
-0.5485134721,
-0.0107550537,
-0.8672043681,
0.2369427979,
0.1722245663,
0.0111543993,
-0.4394877851,
-0.0027744186,
-0.8722020388,
0.2750665247,
0.1015095487,
-0.5912095904,
0.26702106,
-0.3145669997,
0.2276833653,
0.6675450206,
0.0741223171,
-0.0054759453,
-0.4073184431,
0.3642553687,
0.0724025741,
0.206151545,
-0.2897824347,
-0.4248984158,
-0.9345193505,
0.1235536411,
0.401547581,
0.5146422386,
-0.9269720912,
0.3982340097,
-0.3242288232,
-0.6882717609,
-0.7102483511,
-0.0402625203,
0.8033761978,
0.5259237289,
0.38025406,
-0.242421329,
-0.4131385684,
-0.9604579806,
-0.6610597968,
-0.4444628656,
-0.1448034644,
0.0732923821,
0.9243962765,
-0.0108252196,
0.5826166868,
-0.5232530236,
0.5074697733,
-0.0203907564,
0.1529084742,
0.3061333597,
0.2911721766,
-0.1673394144,
-0.4464764297,
-0.1324504912,
0.0852792487,
-0.8163313866,
0.126395762,
0.0961448774,
-0.3716618419,
-0.4614188969,
0.1211204678,
-0.3917909861,
0.4789337516,
0.2933153212,
-0.4253692031,
0.8360717297,
-0.1921178997,
0.3250254095,
-0.4429611862,
0.2039304972,
-0.1046874896,
-0.3277520835,
-0.5613307953,
0.151161164,
0.1065489277,
0.1588922292,
-0.0320515931,
0.3279311359,
-0.4262546301,
0.0631026626,
0.0418902896,
0.2044898719,
0.1043047383,
0.4694990814,
-0.0368139856,
0.5786474347,
0.6838226914,
-0.5501238108,
0.3049482405,
0.2346222401,
-0.571423173,
0.5056541562,
-0.5640975237,
0.4149372578,
0.0149946166,
0.3994200528,
-1.0581070185,
-0.2073252648,
0.2800018191,
-0.0753014758,
-0.0649222285,
-0.1208080128,
-0.7015869617,
-0.8408244848,
-0.2634938061,
0.4394385219,
0.3951480389,
-0.7761335373,
0.4217858016,
0.265265733,
0.2298351526,
-0.9047479033,
-0.5303124785,
-0.03696841,
0.183843255,
-0.4834555984,
0.0341332145,
-0.169222787,
-0.3940779269,
-0.275234282,
-0.6302304268,
-0.1935928166,
0.0330924168,
0.1665444374,
0.0602885373,
-0.0522179306,
0.2488012314,
0.0461845957,
-0.0866504833,
0.5480877161,
-0.4738484323,
0.0902084857,
-0.5905996561,
-0.6145107746,
-0.1660575867,
0.0064132628,
0.5172875524,
-0.2955944836,
0.2672880888,
0.2231818885,
-0.5328264236,
-0.5234516859,
-0.5960665345,
-0.180862993,
-0.408754319,
-0.1079015583,
-0.5091551542,
-0.6712710261,
0.5185208321,
-0.4765035212,
0.0328569487,
0.446074307,
0.3023927808,
-0.0107869366,
1.072876215,
0.169267714,
0.1849785447,
-0.3090110421,
-0.1535238773,
0.4136949182,
-0.5967006087,
-0.2138511389,
-0.6098245382,
-0.0989588425,
-0.5560442209,
-0.4038142264,
0.119894892,
0.2354789078,
-0.4392310679,
0.4830718338,
-0.5208252668,
0.6797320247,
0.3132695854,
0.383666724,
0.5187343955,
-0.2390174717,
-0.3095437288,
0.2977359891,
-0.6498685479,
-0.7431361675,
0.9702698588,
0.3868581951,
0.7843546867,
-0.0917200297,
0.4554410875,
0.3212391734,
0.0678464249,
-0.4622187018,
0.6434336305,
0.1118309274,
-0.6494332552,
-0.2473774999,
-0.4310855269,
-0.5915193558,
0.0794647932,
-0.1502225697,
-0.686344564,
0.134331584,
0.2494917959,
-0.1015924439,
0.4504916966,
-0.2731315792,
0.8198214173,
-0.1367753893,
-0.4032081366,
-0.0835149735,
-0.7214403749,
0.5532109737,
0.099180609,
0.0549936965,
0.0393595584,
0.2865978181,
0.6390463114,
-0.8674761653,
0.6453751326,
0.0179857481,
-0.3696983755,
0.5345490575,
0.2859741449,
0.9358196259,
-0.119848609,
-0.066412881,
0.0598318093,
-0.1689397097,
-0.2971613109,
-0.8042126298,
0.4627177715,
-0.316903621,
-0.4819339514,
-0.2003962398,
-0.0765443593,
-0.4532105923,
0.2271774411,
0.1532689333,
0.4693488479,
-0.1520423442,
-0.1090548486,
1.0597052574,
0.1495729834,
-0.0523467101,
0.1838772446,
-0.1393674463,
-0.3427686989,
0.7833744884,
-0.0476999767,
0.4363514781,
0.4496895373,
0.3652756214,
-0.20023413,
-0.4833652377,
-0.6220027804,
0.0334646665,
-1.067065835,
-0.1773742586,
-0.4502350986,
-0.1330238879,
0.2211474329,
0.2234193236,
-0.580142796,
-0.6234949827,
0.5268518329,
-0.3430294096,
0.1375576556,
0.9132378101,
0.1975160688,
-0.342235893,
-0.2501933575,
0.3541919887,
0.6481130719,
0.4735369086,
0.0392078757,
-0.1312765777,
-0.1685072184,
0.1948913783,
-0.1148328409,
-0.6586790681,
-0.2978861332,
-0.0905273035,
0.4436400831,
0.2443848103,
0.3646085262,
0.75478971,
-0.4781426787,
0.7556286454,
0.2202837765,
-1.1476539373,
0.9214446545,
-0.1271775365,
0.3807843924,
0.7817916274,
0.4536673129,
-0.0569381826,
-0.6896390319,
-0.6993992329,
-0.682382226,
0.2996667624,
0.5521115661,
-0.4576010704,
-0.0328781269,
0.2350722849,
0.3844743967,
0.2998473644,
-0.5167652965,
-0.5196909308,
-0.2337466776,
-0.0483719595,
0.4258353412,
0.0172541756,
-0.2298022062,
-0.1477981359,
0.7042692304,
-0.237285018,
0.2941539884,
0.3755100369,
-0.1326962262,
-0.3103512824,
0.3289734721,
0.2592907846,
1.0972652435,
-0.2115983963,
0.6497083902,
0.171842128,
-0.2889865637,
0.3007808924,
-0.1016344056,
-0.3007547259,
0.094627589,
0.5905638933,
0.7585757971,
0.0509375818,
-0.7155589461,
0.6781770587,
-0.1961808503,
-0.2534457445,
-0.0581373163,
0.2663854063,
-0.1763504148,
0.1801671237,
0.2506147623,
0.2850525081,
0.3523863554,
-0.636777997,
0.1593674719,
0.0635983273,
-0.7061963677,
-0.4677032828,
0.5631671548,
-0.0362206623,
-0.1144727096,
0.5816169381,
-0.2255615443,
-0.6476120949,
0.4699296355,
0.2696930468,
0.9458104372,
0.0474918336,
0.1639116555,
0.5857266188,
0.500608623,
-0.2820841074,
0.5503477454,
-0.2787129879,
-0.4970077574,
-0.5017297268,
-0.150184989,
-0.6662645936,
-0.0344294533,
-0.7801421881,
-0.0605341941,
-0.3698551953,
-0.0919535384,
0.0309236832,
0.1184092686,
-0.7906022668,
0.4176924527,
0.1592077166,
1.0737137794,
-0.8271709681,
0.7518430352,
0.4777624905,
-0.3559123278,
-0.8337901235,
0.1234416813,
-0.0974609628,
-0.5551408529,
0.639946878,
0.3010078073,
-0.5988028049,
-0.3656410873,
-0.7742280364,
-0.6136391759,
1.0208764076,
0.3057659864,
-0.7979578376,
0.1365400702,
0.0521564819,
0.509447217,
-0.408280462,
0.6407347918,
0.4195449054,
0.544210434,
0.1292330325,
-1.0113643408,
0.5632047057,
-0.3799229264,
-0.2247192562,
0.2140659392,
-0.2596582472,
0.6466721892,
-0.4072838724,
-0.392129153,
-0.1004366353,
0.5747626424,
0.3075949252,
0.3566626012,
0.6845951676,
0.5629315972,
1.2782006264,
-0.3059354722,
0.9958185554,
-0.0476449393,
0.1740812808,
1.3792418242,
-0.494569391,
1.028087616,
0.247236833,
-0.2155954391,
0.9289901257,
0.3614537418,
0.0473628379,
0.3974227011,
0.6625882387,
0.0150662307,
-0.5698772669,
-0.0095791593,
-0.1982958168,
0.0662452951,
0.3451224864,
-0.219503805,
-0.2163668871,
-0.2713920474,
-0.1642539799,
0.1462943107,
-0.3769731522,
0.6732591391,
-0.1311443299,
-0.9186403751,
0.8958923817,
-0.5252386332,
-0.0171257965,
-0.4847462177,
-0.2052428424,
0.0646076947,
0.3639858663,
-0.1510756165,
-1.0807000399,
0.0367134139,
0.1541111469,
-0.0543618128,
-0.1681266874,
0.9159976244,
-0.2171317339,
-0.2125279605,
0.3935234547,
0.6595238447,
0.09714742,
-0.0683504641,
-0.7211984992,
-0.0594162755,
-0.1674753129,
-0.2090391368,
-0.185023427,
0.6189459562,
-0.1977453828,
1.0302428007,
0.4145582616,
-0.048563391,
0.014999683,
0.3030862212,
1.0069108009,
-0.6341230869,
-0.1774819046,
-0.8186964989,
0.4917620718,
-0.3265331984,
-0.3254753351,
0.8594297171,
0.5526726246,
1.0587500334,
0.0517192669,
0.8323246241,
0.0407775082,
0.441775769,
-0.4419063032,
0.4313683808,
-0.2835450172,
0.348674804,
-0.3123637438,
-0.5322390199,
-0.1458881646,
0.3368851244,
-0.3075900972,
-0.251221329,
1.0367845297,
0.5195029974,
-0.1080046594,
0.3946510255,
0.0607784875,
0.3990067244,
0.0637593642,
0.6617978215,
1.1915071011,
-0.9496574402,
0.5640899539,
-0.3961254656,
-0.2816315293,
0.1334011853,
-0.9977880716,
-1.1190145016,
-0.4605917335,
-0.7313348055,
-0.5417324901,
0.4628868997,
0.6411096454,
0.671392858,
-0.8709933758,
-0.2825407982,
-0.5071994662,
0.296359688,
-0.9325656891,
-0.0896808654,
0.4053413272,
-0.1890181005,
-0.1349976659,
0.5193735361,
0.2938925028,
-0.3338377774,
-0.3979582787,
-0.0168980192,
-0.295388341,
0.2678446472,
0.3961883187,
0.1884997487,
-0.8215454817,
-0.2629002631,
-0.1641297787,
-0.057648059,
0.084326081,
0.8538862467,
-0.8869484663,
0.6954805255,
0.7219917178,
0.5375359654,
0.419357419,
0.032796327,
0.7546511889,
-0.4469523132,
-0.6787651777,
0.2218877673,
0.4311548173,
0.0353606492,
-0.1457227468,
0.7140985727,
-0.0854665115,
-0.5400303602,
-0.9777413011,
0.3792215586,
-0.8504087329,
-0.1163457632,
0.6330100298,
-0.4917242527,
-0.5778619647,
-0.2292098701,
0.160151571,
0.1029925346,
-0.1499417871,
0.6147577167,
0.6971765757,
0.0892837271,
0.1530069411,
-0.3518033326,
0.5064308643,
0.0853728652,
-0.9479236007,
0.700025022,
0.2912385762,
0.1288534403,
0.334279716,
0.45232144,
-0.0114853447,
0.2654445469,
0.1443083584,
-0.3654583991,
0.0060447101,
-0.5606062412,
-0.0567840002,
0.2641017437,
-0.0076203216,
-0.0500071384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00530v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00530v2
|
Superfiltering: Weak-to-Strong Data Filtering for Fast Instruction-Tuning
| 2024-02-01T11:57:53 | 2024-06-07T20:28:36 |
Ming Li, Yong Zhang, Shwai He, Zhitao Li, Hongyu Zhao, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Tianyi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning is critical to improve LLMs but usually suffers from
low-quality and redundant data. Data filtering for instruction tuning has
proved important in improving both the efficiency and performance of the tuning
process. But it also leads to extra cost and computation due to the involvement
of LLMs in this process. To reduce the filtering cost, we study Superfiltering:
Can we use a smaller and weaker model to select data for finetuning a larger
and stronger model? Despite the performance gap between weak and strong
language models, we find their highly consistent capability to perceive
instruction difficulty and data selection results. This enables us to use a
much smaller and more efficient model to filter the instruction data used to
train a larger language model. Not only does it largely speed up the data
filtering, but the filtered-data-finetuned LLM achieves even better performance
on standard benchmarks. Extensive experiments validate the efficacy and
efficiency of our approach.
|
[
-0.6163806915,
-0.7448093891,
0.4691032171,
-0.2631897628,
-0.465749383,
-0.0734153464,
-0.2133678645,
-0.4532344639,
-0.2200034261,
0.7029440403,
-0.6855745912,
-0.269043088,
-0.647895515,
-0.0826212838,
-0.5066694617,
0.9972386956,
0.1897140592,
0.4915937185,
-0.2550937831,
0.1449171007,
-0.5020067692,
-0.2648089826,
-0.7387734652,
-0.7646292448,
0.2107334435,
0.7132352591,
0.957704246,
0.9447758794,
0.6447883248,
0.2891099155,
-0.3131055236,
0.2698458433,
-0.7864952087,
0.2934963405,
-0.1392162144,
-0.8634489775,
-0.3620986938,
-0.0501395427,
0.5968161225,
0.625366807,
-0.0153559558,
-0.0033298181,
0.0482137166,
1.0317952633,
-0.5237578154,
-0.0513056181,
-0.6648165584,
0.046808444,
-0.4111047089,
-0.0995869786,
-0.1570513397,
-0.4518929124,
-0.3776998818,
-0.2944275141,
0.5279851556,
0.3008956015,
0.9536963105,
0.4807401001,
0.0283914171,
-0.1318498999,
-0.8251425028,
0.9442600608,
-0.7012404799,
0.9311723113,
0.6655226946,
0.0106324349,
-0.3081177473,
-0.4678341448,
-0.3875318766,
-0.1816855818,
0.0356658548,
0.0379074067,
0.080827266,
0.2776110768,
0.2748841047,
0.6637532711,
-0.4710582197,
0.293402642,
-0.5147969127,
-0.1242225915,
0.6484395266,
0.2725808918,
0.020949496,
0.1005322039,
-0.129692331,
0.0386635885,
-0.9787258506,
-0.3386469483,
0.5113878846,
0.394874692,
0.383728981,
0.1773089319,
-0.4197618067,
0.7884411216,
0.1266564131,
-0.143767193,
-0.34730196,
-0.3660223186,
-0.3747584522,
-0.2243988365,
0.2292383313,
0.1488630921,
0.3338026702,
-0.0996563882,
-0.5216809511,
0.0499065928,
0.0505193621,
-0.9415194988,
-0.3744710684,
-0.1353857219,
-0.5587723255,
-0.1006195098,
0.0803176463,
-0.6851406097,
-0.3811207414,
-0.5509219766,
0.2171380669,
-0.1624864042,
0.0112195974,
0.1667765975,
0.0850076675,
0.1828329414,
0.0823017657,
-1.2381396294,
0.554859817,
0.785695374,
0.5824363232,
-0.1013310105,
0.0060156835,
-0.759315908,
-0.0743279755,
-0.5752262473,
0.9791945815,
-0.848875463,
-0.4632149339,
-0.328974545,
-0.0218567569,
-0.0603636876,
-1.0992729664,
0.6212602854,
-0.9459383488,
-0.228170976,
0.0103682326,
-0.8374583721,
-0.0435312204,
-0.3009138405,
-0.806301713,
1.1787883043,
0.1923517287,
-0.0351644903,
0.3169700801,
-0.0700585544,
-0.5806602836,
0.1952235848,
0.0082943784,
-0.6400051713,
0.4839289784,
0.2146146595,
0.5488303304,
-0.5633378625,
0.1144652218,
-0.3840448558,
-0.9054314494,
-0.1439320743,
-0.5796912313,
0.4680820107,
0.4097947478,
-0.1909972131,
-0.1749958992,
-0.6887866259,
0.161219731,
-0.1063003689,
-0.5755451322,
-0.3215103149,
0.3492203355,
-0.2638115585,
-0.1458009183,
-0.0529646799,
-0.3611332774,
0.0854532719,
-0.3966473937,
0.3436765671,
0.8148649931,
-0.0383882821,
0.3381100297,
-0.3692337871,
0.4410070181,
-0.2547912002,
0.3144825101,
0.0713697523,
-0.4310714006,
-0.9679584503,
-0.0428111628,
0.6012097001,
0.5367698073,
-0.7455995083,
0.2229827791,
0.1159021333,
-0.4276107252,
-0.6697073579,
0.8272526264,
0.5702971816,
0.2739185393,
0.4589321315,
-0.250118643,
-0.4601736069,
-0.8159781098,
-0.1526866704,
-0.0969881117,
0.0669814274,
0.3484243155,
0.1571903527,
-0.0879659578,
0.4502961934,
-0.6823652983,
-0.2572839856,
-0.415201664,
-0.226497829,
0.3692549467,
0.5653617382,
0.1751639098,
-0.8639835715,
-0.4060803056,
-0.1337622702,
-0.3408026099,
-0.3100649714,
0.0909281522,
-0.2388126999,
0.192273438,
0.8401865363,
-0.3597772419,
0.4138504863,
0.5296652317,
-0.2155138105,
0.460073173,
-0.2484503835,
0.1166733503,
-0.4711515009,
-0.4549260139,
0.0339467861,
-0.3857740164,
-0.6129627824,
0.2456459403,
0.1842285842,
0.0769070312,
-0.4747349322,
0.1995970905,
-0.3952298462,
0.1973336339,
-0.5455929637,
-0.1622743607,
0.1524549723,
0.2405816615,
-0.1168534905,
0.7546363473,
0.488242358,
-0.8133029342,
0.4451279938,
-0.0559827872,
-0.5176637173,
0.5269880295,
-0.512668252,
0.159471333,
-0.0357425287,
0.0810022056,
-0.9488132,
-0.0633706376,
-0.0996916667,
0.0265206769,
0.5882582068,
-0.4573025703,
-0.5363299847,
-0.2719113529,
-0.225235045,
0.0655397847,
0.4916562736,
-0.763042748,
0.2421200424,
0.3824206889,
-0.2391274869,
-0.1656239629,
-0.7350079417,
-0.2360075861,
-0.1741885245,
-0.3592528701,
0.4132849276,
-0.1782936752,
0.1228768453,
-0.000589212,
-0.509907186,
-0.2773736119,
0.2567138374,
0.0428046212,
0.522023797,
-0.409889251,
0.23344405,
0.162799269,
-0.373914361,
-0.1293043792,
-0.1299702078,
0.3436967731,
0.1253067702,
-0.2597422898,
-0.5789338946,
0.4746985734,
0.4242089987,
0.1210616529,
0.7427270412,
0.5131690502,
-0.4280898273,
-0.4225004315,
-0.6046333313,
-0.5612621903,
-0.5564175248,
0.3533136547,
-0.233322084,
-0.9272261262,
0.1351471543,
-0.0874115154,
0.0254793428,
0.1624114811,
0.3382379711,
-0.261515826,
1.451335907,
0.5515700579,
-0.248829037,
0.8210537434,
-0.2511761487,
0.2025502324,
-0.6708990932,
0.0147770084,
-0.7053437829,
-0.4594898224,
-0.5858055353,
-0.1453677565,
0.1385047287,
0.3661085367,
-0.0563129,
0.0747819468,
-0.4014439285,
1.0366293192,
0.7150402069,
0.3405894637,
0.2446012199,
0.049081251,
0.0783250853,
-0.0505792722,
-0.7722945809,
-0.4750242233,
1.0192471743,
0.0775984228,
1.1563265324,
-0.1960440725,
0.4691146016,
0.192886427,
0.2500204146,
-0.6867752075,
0.7279620767,
-0.939225316,
-0.8218784928,
-0.2238985598,
-0.5575987697,
-0.7438091636,
0.2729511261,
-0.3381500542,
-0.4521994293,
0.1362428665,
0.3425114751,
-0.4585662484,
0.5388067365,
-1.1611622572,
0.6003111005,
-0.1577708125,
-0.5380116105,
-0.3920580745,
-0.3019460142,
0.2413218766,
-0.0270834994,
0.0387785994,
-0.2242793739,
0.176774472,
0.784209609,
-0.5396890044,
0.7025056481,
-0.1980531365,
0.1103469059,
0.1942846626,
0.0685196742,
0.5113025904,
0.0142566245,
-0.2513269186,
0.0963380337,
-0.1606750488,
-0.3830168843,
-0.6135789752,
0.9825149775,
-0.7346426249,
-0.9499453902,
0.0698150247,
-0.4610462189,
-0.1771805435,
0.0987216905,
0.0229555275,
0.5488952994,
0.3219829798,
0.4678735137,
1.0247166157,
0.2723474801,
0.2682272196,
0.6361662149,
0.1226551905,
-0.0886957198,
1.3397203684,
0.5700539351,
0.2703028917,
0.3019776046,
0.3457972407,
-0.2195010185,
-0.9668261409,
-0.3446404338,
0.1367935538,
-0.5695655346,
-0.4747991562,
-0.0097633796,
-0.4088608027,
-0.212952286,
0.0172139239,
-0.5239428878,
-0.4429338872,
-0.4210959077,
-0.0639561117,
0.2996879816,
0.7344919443,
-0.0393713266,
0.466803968,
-0.680198729,
0.6300221682,
0.539809823,
0.7896487117,
-0.200984031,
-0.5928834081,
-0.5777834654,
-0.2263923436,
-0.3958754539,
-0.6089481115,
0.0217601396,
0.6200233698,
0.6469069123,
0.3360430598,
0.0906113684,
0.9875198007,
-0.5182785392,
0.6207754612,
-0.4005391002,
-0.8708657622,
0.6097128391,
0.2714840174,
0.2907914519,
0.6828248501,
0.2845163643,
-0.1372520328,
-0.4751928449,
-0.3683684468,
-0.9444150925,
0.974750936,
-0.0169670433,
0.2628757954,
0.2291437984,
0.7032122016,
0.1521684527,
-0.0716337636,
-0.1798231453,
-0.490516156,
0.0941788256,
-0.202717334,
-0.1401282847,
-0.3244484663,
0.1360757649,
-0.4016747177,
1.0308742523,
0.1019429713,
0.2037045956,
-0.1340646744,
-0.1984261721,
-0.3688599467,
0.1166831553,
0.3921694458,
0.239255026,
-0.1043969095,
0.2120083869,
0.3694381714,
-0.6658362746,
0.1318096817,
0.0040311664,
-0.2726143897,
-0.2538402975,
0.2957145572,
0.9513902068,
0.3478008509,
-0.3807361424,
0.0594535805,
-0.0651300997,
-0.0602198169,
0.4678570926,
0.962526679,
0.0282258354,
0.218354404,
0.2754811645,
-0.0331168696,
0.1961231381,
-0.3144929707,
0.293217659,
0.314073354,
-0.3592877686,
-0.1074094251,
0.6016392112,
0.1406680793,
-0.4330438375,
0.7085013986,
0.0473725162,
-0.3704252839,
0.6425412893,
0.6674617529,
0.5078026652,
-0.4484073818,
0.0090812687,
0.0180658475,
0.3184556961,
-0.1483456343,
0.3263921142,
-0.22397995,
-0.5533825159,
-0.4124960601,
-0.6675176024,
-0.5768226981,
0.3906810582,
-0.7114201784,
0.1834260523,
-0.4400090873,
-0.1615498662,
0.0722910836,
0.4231620431,
-0.5883928537,
0.5184304714,
0.2571625113,
0.9533409476,
-0.9854441881,
0.8617830873,
0.6314241886,
0.1444237083,
-0.8441168666,
-0.1004573554,
-0.0458956957,
-0.8251746297,
0.3995578587,
-0.0381836072,
-0.2634204328,
0.1712733209,
-0.5256670117,
-0.808118403,
0.8158406615,
0.6390093565,
-0.7644798756,
0.2304256707,
-0.0462959632,
0.4798766673,
-0.2946686149,
0.2580698431,
1.1496562958,
0.4372759461,
0.0912206173,
-0.4077263176,
-0.1079599485,
-0.2049417347,
0.100119628,
0.4056961238,
-0.9536665678,
0.6677487493,
0.1383756548,
-0.2094349265,
-0.0552041382,
0.5682207942,
0.1958292574,
0.324116379,
0.5439969897,
0.4363614917,
0.7531106472,
-0.2998374104,
0.8502078652,
-0.3551075161,
0.2386107594,
0.9589270353,
-0.3330510259,
0.92171067,
0.4164291918,
-0.236295864,
0.3792117536,
0.7228130102,
0.0735091493,
0.5685266256,
0.1153928488,
-0.1931315064,
-0.5330784321,
-0.0837910548,
-0.284827739,
0.2246308029,
0.4700263143,
-0.1579993069,
-0.1500979215,
-0.1130963713,
-0.1070776507,
-0.1517691612,
-0.5955118537,
0.7518684864,
0.107269749,
-0.6233094931,
0.7418029308,
0.0448158383,
0.4272155464,
-0.5182561278,
0.0037123149,
-0.4798474908,
0.3076369464,
-0.3436865807,
-0.7096576691,
0.3524745107,
0.0621800981,
-0.3915484846,
-0.3637431264,
1.0799516439,
-0.394574374,
-0.3574073911,
0.2656363845,
0.3904985189,
0.3031235933,
0.1767234653,
-0.7213286161,
0.3525155187,
-0.0245412905,
-0.6408481598,
0.3583976924,
0.0455572344,
-0.0737204403,
0.6726176739,
0.8686544895,
0.4500119984,
0.0572100878,
0.3621225953,
1.0480151176,
-0.6781044006,
-0.4724174738,
-0.9402776957,
0.0878425762,
0.1782820821,
-0.0756401941,
0.4871146083,
0.4889836907,
0.9353841543,
0.1512947381,
0.4346610606,
0.324716717,
0.3980000317,
-0.8493080735,
0.7318049073,
-0.5468414426,
0.543941915,
0.1233050078,
-1.018258214,
-0.4832037687,
0.5283998251,
-0.2746192217,
0.1635673642,
0.4568122029,
1.2351288795,
-0.2075626552,
0.2416882217,
0.6525089741,
0.2122797072,
0.1005938053,
0.6859616041,
0.6955333352,
-0.5713120699,
0.680121839,
-0.2579859495,
-0.1743962616,
-0.3981419206,
-0.6562787294,
-0.8530108929,
-0.1896395087,
-0.3039889932,
-0.0239655487,
0.1838366985,
0.5959789753,
1.326261282,
-1.0467193127,
-0.2406864762,
-0.2439044863,
0.7040753961,
-0.3696635962,
-0.1905829757,
0.1232254654,
-0.481977582,
-0.8425785899,
0.7516254187,
0.1560225487,
0.0584389046,
-0.320337981,
-0.1977801025,
0.0376676247,
0.5036768317,
0.2865206301,
0.1199657246,
-0.196718663,
-0.3362121582,
-0.2346493304,
-0.1017847583,
-0.0525135212,
0.8056519032,
-0.7462918162,
0.3691996038,
0.4200634658,
0.6248068213,
0.5932625532,
-0.2039229125,
0.2961188555,
-0.7188019156,
-0.1455208659,
-0.0125841238,
0.2512100935,
0.2237753123,
-0.5211138129,
0.4084890783,
0.3483808339,
-0.7676163316,
-1.034735918,
0.1982983649,
-0.2030313313,
-0.2514565587,
0.8766521811,
-0.0312492345,
-0.2582846284,
-0.270750165,
-0.1525405496,
0.301353246,
-0.2745710015,
0.7694235444,
0.8599134684,
-0.3143948317,
-0.1495708823,
-0.8614190221,
0.4774312377,
0.7249119282,
-0.5632095337,
0.0358773395,
0.3365696371,
0.189506501,
-0.2824195027,
0.2779995799,
0.1394618005,
0.3785016835,
-0.0720406845,
-0.5787448287,
-0.1406167597,
-0.6332963705,
-0.4122035801,
0.2833878398,
-0.0632043108,
-0.0552353896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00518v1
|
EE-Tuning: An Economical yet Scalable Solution for Tuning Early-Exit Large Language Models
| 2024-02-01T11:39:04 | 2024-02-01T11:39:04 |
Xuchen Pan, Yanxi Chen, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jingren Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work introduces EE-Tuning, a lightweight and economical solution to
training/tuning early-exit large language models (LLMs). In contrast to the
common approach of full-parameter pre-training, EE-Tuning augments any
pre-trained (and possibly fine-tuned) standard LLM with additional early-exit
layers that are tuned in a parameter-efficient manner, which requires
significantly less computational resources and training data. Our
implementation of EE-Tuning achieves outstanding training efficiency via
extensive performance optimizations, as well as scalability due to its full
compatibility with 3D parallelism. Results of systematic experiments validate
the efficacy of EE-Tuning, confirming that effective early-exit LLM inference
can be achieved with a limited training budget. In hope of making early-exit
LLMs accessible to the community, we release the source code of our
implementation of EE-Tuning at https://github.com/pan-x-c/EE-LLM.
|
[
-0.618362546,
-0.8221259117,
0.7118957043,
0.2738896906,
-0.2310459912,
-0.1024976,
-0.6591446996,
-0.2816586792,
0.0286149494,
0.3714315891,
-0.5865971446,
-0.4867099524,
-0.4650736153,
-0.0237182286,
-0.3405507505,
0.493003428,
0.1018843204,
0.0581414849,
0.065992482,
0.1778104305,
0.1751056165,
-0.1107264385,
-1.2543990612,
-0.2042818367,
0.9666590095,
0.7434415221,
0.2672580779,
1.1739103794,
0.1220314801,
0.2416480482,
-0.0757649019,
0.0394322015,
-0.7809102535,
-0.3025278151,
0.1307515949,
-0.4932509959,
-0.6344670057,
-0.0258543268,
0.4163702726,
0.8099810481,
-0.4531524479,
0.1887803376,
0.1520876735,
0.6807765365,
-0.7923901081,
0.0744898245,
-0.8379859328,
-0.1380901933,
-0.6714245081,
-0.2729848921,
-0.5139885545,
-0.2127667665,
-0.2745219469,
-0.8259317279,
0.0359075554,
0.355876863,
0.8198370934,
0.240105018,
-0.1801402271,
0.1185728237,
-0.4367071986,
0.787193656,
-0.6728510261,
0.618529439,
0.1696993411,
0.2288987786,
0.0067905309,
-0.4557665884,
-0.5739114881,
0.0180851612,
0.331662029,
0.0913475081,
-0.0006107891,
0.280793488,
0.1498584896,
0.4357311726,
-0.5501134396,
0.7489520907,
0.0366107449,
0.0001123695,
0.2921361923,
0.0769782439,
0.0997570902,
0.3368346989,
-0.1316282302,
-0.0456224307,
-1.0240559578,
-0.198826462,
0.6195076704,
0.5098395944,
-0.2303419411,
0.3507862985,
-0.2968370914,
0.8197110891,
0.1155675948,
0.0926836878,
0.1176061705,
0.0059881387,
-0.2388291955,
0.0413016528,
0.4491609335,
0.322247982,
0.3766529858,
-0.2339397371,
-0.2962190807,
-0.1742267758,
-0.1933927238,
-0.8480573893,
-0.3045602739,
0.0901631713,
-0.4903871715,
-0.2547234893,
-0.2870507836,
-0.7410792708,
-0.0444287509,
-0.6210772991,
0.3182678819,
-0.3343085945,
-0.404681623,
0.3215419054,
0.2603967786,
0.5036323071,
0.419139415,
-0.9405497909,
0.2330377847,
0.53671211,
0.8079061508,
-0.0818083733,
-0.4735255241,
-0.9552512765,
0.2301764935,
-0.2182944119,
0.5896241069,
-0.5812799335,
-0.1840436459,
-0.0968307704,
0.0519710369,
0.1486551464,
-0.506223619,
0.4951950908,
-0.6882510185,
-0.1364891529,
-0.0286101196,
-0.5022342205,
0.0129199577,
-0.0605693534,
-0.6415398717,
0.8451996446,
-0.1588566005,
-0.3455273807,
0.5192636847,
-0.6489138603,
-0.334643662,
0.1445726752,
0.0939210206,
-0.3597767055,
0.4890649021,
0.4004984796,
0.4738213718,
-0.642496109,
-0.3407219052,
-0.6253207326,
-0.5009012222,
-0.5923438072,
-0.0726701468,
0.5813786387,
0.4381955266,
-0.235103175,
-0.1958152652,
-1.2447462082,
0.3150050938,
0.215705663,
-0.3762372136,
-0.3840661049,
0.0846435055,
0.1458765268,
-0.195149973,
0.5888733268,
-0.4474335909,
0.0040438995,
-0.4356071353,
0.0965845883,
0.8761162162,
-0.487616241,
0.429338634,
0.0666794851,
0.5161834955,
0.0158137549,
0.0463862643,
-0.3498802483,
-0.307792604,
-0.8951710463,
-0.5626128912,
0.3431911767,
0.486433804,
-0.4981101453,
0.9002367854,
-0.1280847043,
-0.5044932961,
-0.3803310692,
0.3275322616,
0.3256147206,
0.4843093455,
0.2467796206,
0.1499928683,
-0.64267838,
-0.9929248095,
-0.4902985692,
-0.0404374525,
-0.2329775244,
0.2879896462,
0.2022305727,
-0.0703087747,
0.7047385573,
-0.4108237028,
-0.0066019874,
-0.2974342704,
0.2182943374,
0.4896424115,
0.3221476078,
0.4123735726,
-0.3251648545,
-0.7080466747,
0.3080241978,
-0.3680226803,
-0.5435981154,
0.1376918405,
-0.0913683325,
-0.0199037064,
0.8386660814,
-0.2560960352,
-0.075894326,
0.7644110322,
-0.2619157434,
0.3144583404,
-0.1895685345,
0.0960795805,
-0.8770106435,
0.060211435,
0.113514483,
-0.4749348462,
-0.2502307296,
-0.0833631754,
0.2557649612,
-0.135714978,
-0.602517426,
0.4273909926,
-0.5946551561,
0.2036965787,
-0.2286452204,
0.1749780923,
-0.0368242115,
0.2649491727,
0.0246906765,
0.946888566,
0.8285637498,
-0.8092730641,
0.0099620782,
-0.0635725632,
-0.4501726925,
0.3840223551,
-0.6601615548,
0.178753987,
-0.217902109,
-0.190162167,
-0.3266498744,
-0.1059580743,
-0.2023423463,
-0.037189953,
0.474843353,
-0.2029809803,
-0.3929916024,
-0.1824153513,
-0.3063950241,
0.2792468071,
0.5320085287,
-0.9588115811,
0.3814020157,
0.2530997694,
-0.2380876392,
-0.14827618,
-0.5185314417,
0.018039139,
-0.3681567907,
-0.4588360488,
0.2509067655,
-0.0752182379,
-0.0236413404,
-0.0154491784,
0.1696688682,
0.0228239186,
0.0948258862,
-0.525973022,
-0.1213746518,
-0.4406272173,
-0.1960498542,
0.1917863786,
-0.2613022327,
-0.0215763077,
-0.4563469589,
0.509096086,
-0.3040029407,
-0.2761531174,
-0.0447564796,
0.3524521887,
0.5760201812,
-0.138367027,
1.0919706821,
0.4540575743,
-0.3209649324,
-0.5455106497,
-0.7606847882,
-0.1140222251,
-0.5153122544,
0.7324749231,
-0.4669755995,
-0.8609602451,
0.6076840162,
-0.5849798918,
-0.0286301654,
0.2016807646,
0.7070530057,
-0.3323949873,
1.1955276728,
0.8956663013,
0.0400351658,
0.6345581412,
0.0520180911,
0.2144827843,
-0.866333425,
0.0484102853,
-0.60227561,
-0.2932056189,
-0.5245687366,
-0.0479183421,
0.6169350743,
0.4645279646,
-0.4076745212,
0.1767797172,
-0.1821465492,
1.0963162184,
0.3571781814,
0.1449730843,
0.2302643508,
-0.1495406777,
-0.0682465807,
-0.0443251915,
-0.8551169634,
-0.503713429,
1.2805808783,
0.2658004165,
0.8680919409,
0.0444810838,
0.8559151888,
-0.1641756594,
0.1786993593,
-0.4352378547,
0.5309710503,
-0.3629004061,
-0.2758043408,
-0.5303583145,
-0.5659082532,
-0.931137085,
0.1652328968,
-0.0165689252,
-0.883913815,
0.2192901075,
0.4805217385,
-0.2929290533,
0.5696562529,
-1.0052448511,
0.9651893973,
-0.3558214605,
-0.611394763,
-0.2944492698,
-0.2851985693,
0.5124357343,
-0.4378851652,
0.1010098159,
-0.1486774832,
-0.3709998727,
0.5309460163,
-0.4543508887,
0.6572449207,
-0.3239829838,
-0.1848473847,
-0.1571693122,
-0.0600950383,
0.7755030394,
0.3075715899,
-0.1588581651,
0.2940535247,
-0.2996274829,
-0.490891546,
-0.2754977643,
0.9268108606,
-0.8718547821,
-0.3261895776,
-0.0559908003,
-0.131741941,
-0.4279382825,
0.4512467086,
0.4131046236,
0.2024885863,
-0.108228296,
0.4240126312,
1.0866348743,
-0.4493642449,
0.4847388864,
0.7039400339,
-0.2686524093,
-0.2160161287,
0.8360571861,
-0.2268759906,
0.1413573921,
0.3866530359,
0.2610114515,
-0.5180656314,
-0.7912723422,
-0.4110243917,
0.3077619672,
-0.4035859406,
-0.177646324,
-0.3170064092,
-0.0538746156,
-0.003060756,
-0.2420414537,
-0.8732041121,
-0.1148262545,
-0.2931236625,
0.0457755439,
0.2556072474,
0.4878970385,
-0.1705403179,
0.4673728645,
-0.7475304604,
0.2605967522,
0.2477704287,
0.8869175911,
-0.1082676873,
-0.4513458014,
-0.7832275629,
-0.3304309547,
-0.1679157466,
-0.516664505,
0.1224788353,
0.6428632736,
0.5822297335,
0.6399772763,
-0.2915640473,
0.6272969246,
-0.7981678247,
0.6138398051,
0.401792556,
-0.9812479019,
0.6453723907,
-0.5510818958,
0.507797122,
0.8386647701,
0.1515218019,
-0.0072064358,
-0.1271543056,
-0.015851628,
-1.0124806166,
0.7446980476,
-0.0598897934,
-0.1277347654,
-0.0488549247,
0.3447367847,
0.2991899252,
0.2748869061,
-0.7134514451,
-0.4895727932,
0.0854130834,
0.009196748,
-0.3758562505,
-0.31013152,
0.0567931086,
-0.4048835933,
0.7603156567,
-0.2918204069,
-0.1019841656,
-0.3606711626,
-0.253226012,
-0.4538529515,
0.0895182267,
0.2766810656,
0.6536461115,
-0.3513492942,
-0.0905425623,
0.2218237668,
-0.2488598228,
0.2262053639,
-0.0039631859,
-0.1408168226,
-0.2862553596,
0.0310198236,
0.8414905667,
0.5368443131,
-0.4464100003,
0.3315724134,
-0.1384062618,
-0.2765324116,
-0.2509315908,
0.0353916734,
0.2545090318,
0.0693450049,
0.1943036318,
-0.2696486712,
-0.0009861769,
-0.2678851187,
0.1886845976,
0.403457433,
0.2969672978,
-0.1993553489,
1.0420536995,
0.5392366648,
-0.1738425195,
0.5953349471,
-0.2667956948,
0.016832469,
0.4198739231,
0.4656983912,
1.3216150999,
-0.1136164516,
-0.2400183827,
0.287522167,
0.6479643583,
-0.0332361981,
0.4097911716,
-0.0016206371,
-0.6431159377,
-0.9662464857,
-0.8981053829,
-0.4116888344,
0.3689595163,
-0.8025794029,
0.7736097574,
-0.2559155524,
0.2245799303,
-0.523511529,
-0.2960940003,
-0.9980942011,
0.1410688013,
0.509115994,
1.334839344,
-0.698428452,
0.9227013588,
0.7099223137,
0.1686083972,
-0.5548706651,
-0.0547849759,
-0.0224121977,
-0.7628462911,
0.3423111141,
-0.0417772122,
-0.3611060381,
0.5265643001,
-0.5223157406,
-0.8482585549,
0.9609444737,
0.8011575341,
-1.244369626,
-0.0620797835,
0.0725817308,
0.2843609452,
-0.2714531124,
0.4586713016,
0.8277621269,
0.7366753221,
-0.1802975684,
-0.8819896579,
-0.3616557717,
-0.2687588334,
0.1113094836,
0.3391937613,
-0.8865073919,
0.7256799936,
0.0310228001,
-0.0355109312,
-0.1307989508,
0.5996074677,
0.1583378166,
0.0857065767,
0.948392868,
0.9555700421,
0.6672335267,
-0.2469542623,
0.8589736223,
-0.9678514004,
0.239716664,
0.871526897,
-0.3021278381,
0.7154054046,
0.548042357,
-0.1291743517,
0.0870256051,
0.7119283676,
0.3914547563,
0.7399016619,
0.1677511036,
-0.2177770585,
-0.6366063952,
0.4186730385,
-0.5322178602,
0.5668877959,
0.3495125771,
0.1829144508,
-0.2535885274,
-0.1588202864,
-0.168108359,
-0.0563526601,
-0.6438458562,
0.6667943597,
0.2341206819,
-0.2084631026,
0.5619128942,
0.0340375714,
0.7656085491,
-0.9646108747,
0.1931215674,
-0.3033874929,
0.0181727502,
-0.1708604991,
-0.1253305376,
0.0855160281,
0.0173297953,
-0.1411313713,
-0.4324574471,
0.1724389642,
-0.4245892465,
-0.5548192859,
0.4846332371,
0.7773928046,
-0.047850959,
0.0354153849,
-0.6437326074,
0.2702992857,
-0.1936671436,
-0.7826946974,
0.4224702418,
0.6862661242,
0.5042490363,
0.5070884228,
0.5168386102,
0.699947834,
0.2999547124,
0.1571454108,
0.8041654229,
-0.7023522854,
-0.8390932679,
-0.7663984299,
0.5980644822,
-0.0460531786,
-0.3450205326,
0.6734341979,
0.8460172415,
0.9313535094,
-0.0675791353,
0.7972435951,
0.1279405355,
0.5990815759,
-0.9577001929,
0.6630151272,
-0.8982846141,
0.6158198118,
-0.1555170566,
-1.3927992582,
-0.1126020923,
0.3558079302,
-0.0312469117,
0.2573234737,
0.6777304411,
0.8554498553,
-0.4123239219,
-0.1873384118,
0.5783314705,
0.3390011787,
0.2648911476,
0.6854770184,
0.5843940377,
-0.0636816919,
0.3830443919,
-0.1375972927,
-0.5613207817,
-0.1911207139,
-1.1784251928,
-0.7371340394,
-0.1993595064,
-0.3204311132,
0.0867784843,
0.0538120195,
0.7758954167,
0.9143119454,
-0.921061635,
-0.2214954793,
-0.3824071288,
-0.149417758,
-0.147156477,
-0.1770638674,
0.1025475413,
-0.6727536917,
-1.0621700287,
0.8326350451,
0.3627936542,
-0.3851806223,
-0.3237871528,
-0.2101352215,
0.1398690641,
0.2202778757,
0.5477645397,
0.3531864285,
-0.3956801593,
-0.1057685912,
-0.1622955501,
0.1320756376,
0.0392533801,
0.8710587621,
-0.5588229299,
0.3298660517,
0.1558409482,
0.7480328083,
0.6916387677,
-0.3518845439,
0.8367179632,
-0.7664568424,
0.4148693681,
0.0358516611,
0.4736182094,
-0.1007201374,
-0.1660524011,
0.4122092426,
0.0110267065,
-0.5179377794,
-0.9330103397,
0.1103400514,
-0.6925051808,
0.1649878323,
0.7473292351,
0.1701966375,
-0.2981271744,
0.1045688167,
0.1600124687,
-0.0621555224,
-0.3571542799,
0.6732782722,
0.7098864913,
-0.0500817113,
-0.4546021521,
-0.4362644255,
0.3555926979,
0.4560554326,
-0.9345037937,
0.1514617801,
0.1756640375,
0.0189881194,
-0.4477918148,
0.4028181732,
0.0149652185,
0.2173910588,
0.0381907374,
0.235337913,
-0.2696332037,
-0.3900080621,
-0.4211620688,
0.1096860841,
0.3998889625,
-0.1743417233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00913v1
|
Institutional Platform for Secure Self-Service Large Language Model Exploration
| 2024-02-01T10:58:10 | 2024-02-01T10:58:10 |
V. K. Cody Bumgardner, Mitchell A. Klusty, W. Vaiden Logan, Samuel E. Armstrong, Caylin Hickey, Jeff Talbert
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a user-friendly platform developed by the University of
Kentucky Center for Applied AI, designed to make large, customized language
models (LLMs) more accessible. By capitalizing on recent advancements in
multi-LoRA inference, the system efficiently accommodates custom adapters for a
diverse range of users and projects. The paper outlines the system's
architecture and key features, encompassing dataset curation, model training,
secure inference, and text-based feature extraction.
We illustrate the establishment of a tenant-aware computational network using
agent-based methods, securely utilizing islands of isolated resources as a
unified system. The platform strives to deliver secure LLM services,
emphasizing process and data isolation, end-to-end encryption, and role-based
resource authentication. This contribution aligns with the overarching goal of
enabling simplified access to cutting-edge AI models and technology in support
of scientific discovery.
|
[
-0.3129464686,
-0.7552890182,
0.7006583214,
0.1652235985,
0.2739015818,
0.3468206227,
-0.2725470364,
-0.4156922996,
0.3044928014,
0.9290164709,
-0.1573081464,
-0.6950181723,
-0.4061727822,
0.2139749676,
-0.3427435458,
0.5789782405,
0.1049877331,
0.0923365876,
-0.126582846,
-0.033607319,
-0.0186248496,
-0.6674435735,
-0.5783923268,
-0.4266544878,
0.4510981441,
0.4093564153,
0.6613673568,
0.8248189688,
0.7090762854,
0.5001878142,
0.2182740718,
-0.0554962195,
-0.2156998068,
0.3604432046,
-0.2711926699,
-0.4039554,
-0.6025447845,
-0.1340216994,
0.6376479864,
0.5592868328,
-0.3757286668,
0.1921742558,
-0.2222305536,
0.4396115541,
-0.7493440509,
0.3524148166,
-0.6033076048,
-0.0515927188,
-0.3563530743,
0.2804621458,
-0.5021799207,
0.184167698,
0.0170621704,
-0.7740519643,
-0.2487462163,
-0.0335530825,
0.2300047874,
0.1768442988,
-0.4915850461,
-0.071215719,
-0.6920614243,
0.6406030059,
-0.4305800498,
0.4244306684,
0.3899748027,
0.6129845381,
-0.4547433257,
-0.975897491,
-0.4354232848,
-0.4475165009,
-0.0142158503,
-0.1930573434,
-0.153878212,
0.1774456799,
-0.0218593068,
0.0515033156,
-0.4720203876,
0.5601792932,
-0.2768250704,
-0.1994034648,
0.7440496087,
0.18053855,
0.283231318,
-0.1238280535,
-0.1438387483,
-0.0331435725,
-0.7176877856,
0.1910393387,
0.3256930113,
0.6850355268,
-0.1666920781,
0.6674090624,
-0.2376598269,
0.1087059304,
-0.3299658597,
0.2803558707,
0.1351413876,
-0.0650917515,
-0.4016285241,
0.1181557178,
0.9312516451,
-0.3824759424,
-0.1186741963,
-0.2856716216,
-0.2598220408,
0.1035807282,
0.3103406727,
-0.6203356385,
-0.2201005965,
0.2885249853,
-0.4611543715,
-0.3736181557,
0.0144367004,
-0.691287756,
-0.6166312695,
-0.2486681044,
0.1955501586,
-0.015376864,
-0.3744166493,
-0.1226680204,
0.058237996,
0.048474025,
0.3049263656,
-1.0410354137,
0.7294037342,
0.8486193419,
0.8516336083,
-0.4363214374,
-0.2862766385,
-0.5721841455,
0.2147385627,
-0.1797358543,
0.4015274346,
-0.6990886331,
-0.5265507698,
0.0435542576,
0.1961517781,
0.1282212138,
-0.2770219743,
0.3557798862,
-0.8608993292,
-0.1501976699,
-0.0219881646,
-0.501345396,
0.0084124943,
0.1809318066,
-0.8552584052,
0.8581746817,
0.1373719573,
-0.5321598053,
-0.1438108981,
-1.2403818369,
0.07385692,
0.3329428732,
-0.5063325763,
-0.2644771338,
-0.0607150942,
0.2187300622,
0.2504848242,
-0.010596388,
0.4521806538,
-0.7615984082,
-0.1158070639,
0.3491704762,
-0.1998876929,
0.9039456844,
0.5602809787,
-0.3494960666,
0.2689676881,
-0.9195381403,
0.0143345241,
0.2620350718,
-0.2629540861,
-0.4784095585,
-0.1830990613,
0.195465073,
-0.2134167403,
0.7763629556,
-0.6033543348,
0.5031023622,
-0.1156341806,
0.7371295691,
0.892606318,
-0.4050539136,
0.5334611535,
0.3735239208,
0.681229651,
0.0195256192,
0.2015765756,
-0.2889062166,
-0.0928213596,
-0.4723886847,
-0.6244078279,
0.1972368509,
0.507301271,
-0.5422013998,
0.392827332,
-0.072012797,
-0.4833941758,
-0.6734806299,
0.2690613568,
0.1691946685,
0.2774667144,
0.2157004923,
-0.2483347803,
-0.4160071015,
-1.0798904896,
0.1301499605,
-0.1194332168,
0.03397559,
0.3430994451,
0.6718292832,
-0.6648584604,
1.0336557627,
-0.2507128119,
-0.1341196299,
-0.1779301018,
-0.2438877374,
0.3169899285,
0.5050104856,
0.3562371433,
-0.8087106943,
-0.2578671575,
0.2508280873,
-1.2516212463,
-0.017404085,
0.27594468,
-0.2118713856,
-0.1098434925,
0.587698698,
-0.6609434485,
0.2128985077,
0.6693692207,
-0.2843736708,
0.3945041299,
-0.3675899506,
-0.1364316046,
-1.1339006424,
0.2305593789,
-0.2160295546,
-0.3768331409,
-0.6425477266,
0.5644968748,
-0.1753152907,
-0.3208521008,
-0.1345998645,
0.6836659312,
-0.3834311366,
-0.410599798,
-0.4445825815,
0.3504106402,
0.1344124973,
0.1605902016,
-0.0293445643,
0.8739153147,
0.7997459769,
-0.2829142809,
0.4278680384,
0.5386248827,
-0.0794892535,
0.2518299222,
-0.6561530232,
0.4026405513,
0.2519346476,
0.263802439,
-0.5714999437,
-0.3646460176,
0.1353117079,
-0.1501985788,
0.0290086158,
-0.1031733453,
-0.2160053402,
-0.2737901807,
-0.165551126,
0.3319830596,
-0.0197613761,
-0.7651746869,
0.8192473054,
0.7689036131,
-0.3222417831,
-0.8063178062,
-0.6383518577,
0.5557830334,
-0.2631901205,
-0.6239122748,
0.0316451453,
-0.0807629973,
-0.6258534789,
-0.0431528129,
0.4161360562,
-0.3045929968,
0.5504117608,
0.5352692604,
0.2466192096,
-0.4739682674,
0.121785447,
-0.0502111651,
-0.0519402288,
0.3334785104,
-0.3751707375,
0.3894127309,
-0.5107995272,
-0.5581218004,
-0.4617476165,
0.5207641721,
0.7495752573,
-0.2915944457,
0.6582530737,
0.4661337733,
-0.4345192611,
-0.2157804817,
-0.3702572584,
-0.3038962483,
-0.6210127473,
0.2888686359,
-0.4927847683,
-1.2512139082,
0.7862225175,
-0.1099623069,
0.1299037337,
0.3980446458,
0.5176647305,
-0.0082637547,
0.770209074,
0.8387345672,
-0.3558761775,
0.4051246345,
-0.246750474,
0.3635644317,
-0.8847817183,
-0.0714502782,
-0.8821154237,
-0.0423277132,
-0.9127749801,
-0.0627479553,
0.293854326,
-0.189938426,
-0.5949653983,
0.2959818244,
-0.5194530487,
0.2894226611,
0.801586628,
-0.0867492184,
0.5209802985,
-0.0131228426,
-0.0722850263,
0.0522261001,
-0.4691657126,
-0.797393322,
1.2122831345,
0.6162829399,
1.0533343554,
0.2985463142,
0.8991567492,
0.7717333436,
0.3285806775,
-0.3658020496,
0.4814554453,
-0.12239106,
-0.7058814764,
-0.7142011523,
-0.5116804242,
-0.9799623489,
0.2776414156,
-0.1049868017,
-1.1562173367,
0.2586212158,
0.030538898,
-0.2665014863,
0.213109538,
-0.7276521325,
0.7635769248,
-0.4256764054,
-0.2272900641,
-0.2772788107,
-0.4406510592,
0.4570765495,
-0.188347131,
0.3685911596,
0.0448997766,
0.0827930495,
0.4517524838,
-0.3328038454,
0.9296486378,
-0.1964444071,
0.0077911308,
0.2992503345,
0.2205657214,
0.6065596938,
0.2863642871,
-0.2925224006,
0.3347105086,
-0.0081668114,
-0.2283443511,
-0.5320364237,
0.9532162547,
-1.1655470133,
-0.7284908891,
-0.2138332874,
-0.4807478487,
0.0061682221,
0.2890449464,
-0.3586677909,
0.1733391434,
-0.4073355496,
0.4729250073,
0.4660613239,
-0.0780049786,
0.3813974857,
0.6391382813,
-0.4656628072,
-0.3604922593,
0.594183445,
-0.0860652551,
-0.00201228,
0.3659587801,
0.3365989327,
-0.53014189,
-0.5296826959,
-0.3829757869,
0.0185373276,
-0.7674850821,
-0.0527148284,
-0.7387222648,
-0.3844095469,
-0.7341026664,
-0.1724792868,
-0.5182361007,
-0.5051383972,
-0.2281697839,
-0.2497627735,
0.3829651773,
0.8670090437,
-0.0545225963,
0.700615406,
-0.5859484673,
0.1431818306,
0.1439107805,
0.2782775164,
-0.2456989586,
-0.379573524,
-0.3147217035,
-0.1725039035,
-0.1427272856,
-0.5719136596,
0.3124399185,
0.1061920896,
0.7151215076,
0.6050687432,
0.0323950574,
0.0635212585,
-0.2943508029,
0.814563036,
0.0063796793,
-0.9864311218,
0.3763659596,
-0.4922008514,
0.1247493997,
0.6499440074,
0.1677575707,
-0.3760213256,
-0.339579165,
-0.5796847343,
-0.5813789368,
0.39112854,
0.0267397296,
0.0520008579,
0.267822355,
0.5488081574,
0.0088177277,
0.3709484339,
-1.0645291805,
-0.2038012892,
-0.3240487278,
-0.2330008149,
0.015646657,
0.0589999482,
-0.4596901536,
0.240819633,
0.7928259969,
-0.5370912552,
0.0460412093,
0.0938111693,
-0.0155366128,
0.0943340808,
0.4275537133,
0.335185647,
0.6544915438,
0.0681828409,
0.3233844638,
0.1725222468,
-0.558169663,
0.0974726975,
0.3367557824,
-0.2611712217,
-0.2528600395,
0.3094180226,
0.6367786527,
-0.0197285768,
-0.6473075151,
0.1946342736,
-0.2495670617,
0.0507371835,
-0.6058743,
0.2730812132,
0.1185857728,
0.6416043639,
0.3398317099,
-0.3771901429,
0.3146573007,
-0.3576688468,
0.1441086084,
0.5788514018,
-0.3341788948,
-0.2352152169,
0.5983535647,
0.2425873429,
-0.5082474351,
0.707318604,
0.0440334082,
-0.2455701828,
0.6364426017,
0.4669425786,
0.9588059187,
-0.4467726052,
0.248578921,
0.0054560024,
0.4373994768,
0.084741503,
0.1267797947,
-0.0488893427,
-0.7285049558,
-0.1167238504,
-0.5787709951,
-0.6339724064,
0.3932800293,
-0.4441773891,
0.1448054016,
-0.5648082495,
-0.3440477252,
-0.1202326342,
0.0816643983,
-0.4836547077,
-0.1747412831,
0.1736466438,
1.1049417257,
-0.6597711444,
0.8782902956,
0.5339591503,
-0.1039391235,
-0.698926568,
-0.907381773,
-0.0153480154,
-0.957539022,
0.4603931904,
0.0279513523,
-0.2379021496,
-0.2197040617,
-0.6849188805,
-0.9281564951,
1.2237930298,
0.4618808627,
-0.8331741691,
-0.0860472918,
0.4060447812,
0.637932241,
-0.7324767113,
0.2747946084,
0.4981579781,
0.5813863277,
-0.3859643936,
-0.6816091537,
-0.1243176907,
-0.1928038299,
-0.3012218475,
-0.1761624664,
-0.6059732437,
0.6162166595,
-0.0919960886,
0.2636429071,
0.0615806058,
0.8195376396,
0.3439763188,
0.4814182818,
0.5330545902,
0.318125844,
0.9844002724,
0.2399053425,
0.762473464,
-0.4661914706,
0.2405728996,
1.362182498,
-0.5035685301,
0.8499811888,
0.5382886529,
0.0287256334,
0.5087578893,
0.5137609839,
-0.0625278726,
0.2959518731,
0.3196404576,
-0.4000992477,
-0.2884410024,
-0.4217192829,
-0.2363442034,
0.749954164,
0.5549562573,
-0.4596108496,
-0.1534140855,
-0.1510334313,
-0.2247033715,
0.1662632078,
-0.2006100565,
0.6539551616,
0.4390203357,
-0.3281634152,
-0.1974967271,
0.14016518,
0.0809498429,
-0.7855912447,
0.0563944206,
-0.1096834466,
0.057322152,
-0.153444171,
-0.563806057,
-0.0342827067,
0.0218135547,
-0.0002211702,
-0.1453491002,
0.6749691963,
-0.2240882069,
-0.4466001391,
0.5449056029,
0.7296060324,
0.1004880518,
0.2608857453,
-0.7049129009,
0.2010795623,
-0.4309546649,
-0.5320779085,
0.3246720135,
0.5327197313,
-0.3811210096,
1.0029741526,
0.7222240567,
0.1299852431,
-0.0350435264,
0.3088784516,
0.7942497134,
-0.4367094934,
-0.7928711772,
-0.7848591208,
0.0647085235,
-0.1627277881,
-0.1536732018,
0.5275129676,
0.5191753507,
0.4780092835,
0.2165049464,
1.0144944191,
0.1914099306,
0.1893629283,
-0.3557528853,
0.8358485103,
-0.2390470952,
0.315975666,
0.0112258624,
-0.7586589456,
-0.101995185,
0.5351765156,
-0.2257016152,
-0.0674242079,
0.2420092523,
0.9428188801,
-0.1558524519,
0.0061397748,
0.4006014466,
0.4942500591,
0.8489776254,
0.0024355988,
0.764744997,
-0.0514625646,
0.2174173743,
0.0227765255,
-0.2100842893,
-0.1881674975,
-0.9219976664,
-0.8696135879,
-0.5396948457,
-0.0481534712,
-0.1766533405,
0.1268882602,
1.1644960642,
0.854180038,
-0.8175356984,
-0.4364594519,
0.0068798382,
0.0874383301,
0.1649012715,
-0.1946936697,
0.4020145535,
-0.1604917645,
-0.5330320001,
0.8763332367,
0.3946103454,
-0.1884291768,
-1.0930621624,
-0.1026607379,
0.0627554208,
-0.0185003281,
0.2294469923,
0.4915295839,
-0.6149553657,
-0.2283727527,
0.2104063332,
-0.4247095287,
-0.0357070491,
0.7925203443,
-0.4866279662,
0.5090619326,
0.0905545652,
1.1553961039,
0.3282662928,
-0.2187153399,
0.6382728815,
-0.3328224123,
0.1025501192,
0.0330392271,
0.6316680312,
0.4454693496,
-0.7737993598,
0.4705390632,
-0.0138279572,
-0.7971011996,
-0.800588131,
0.2329849005,
-1.0102514029,
-0.0658787042,
0.6229504347,
-0.4134910703,
-0.5185531378,
-0.1757248193,
0.117348589,
0.0399074964,
-0.6516307592,
1.212097764,
0.6473271847,
-0.0339969099,
-0.1727909744,
-0.5437150598,
0.237811476,
0.0440081134,
-1.1183344126,
0.2183194607,
0.2955150008,
0.1421227753,
0.4371715784,
0.671723485,
0.0719885305,
-0.0108420169,
-0.2124318033,
0.2174090147,
-0.2347115278,
-0.5884207487,
-0.4910552502,
0.1401789039,
0.1672145873,
0.0262874924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01772v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01772v1
|
Disentangling the Roles of Target-Side Transfer and Regularization in Multilingual Machine Translation
| 2024-02-01T10:55:03 | 2024-02-01T10:55:03 |
Yan Meng, Christof Monz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Multilingual Machine Translation (MMT) benefits from knowledge transfer
across different language pairs. However, improvements in one-to-many
translation compared to many-to-one translation are only marginal and sometimes
even negligible. This performance discrepancy raises the question of to what
extent positive transfer plays a role on the target-side for one-to-many MT. In
this paper, we conduct a large-scale study that varies the auxiliary target
side languages along two dimensions, i.e., linguistic similarity and corpus
size, to show the dynamic impact of knowledge transfer on the main language
pairs. We show that linguistically similar auxiliary target languages exhibit
strong ability to transfer positive knowledge. With an increasing size of
similar target languages, the positive transfer is further enhanced to benefit
the main language pairs. Meanwhile, we find distant auxiliary target languages
can also unexpectedly benefit main language pairs, even with minimal positive
transfer ability. Apart from transfer, we show distant auxiliary target
languages can act as a regularizer to benefit translation performance by
enhancing the generalization and model inference calibration.
|
[
-0.529564321,
-0.4157165289,
0.4259587526,
0.2625536919,
-0.2984273434,
-0.0154135926,
-0.501136601,
-0.558001399,
0.2139719725,
0.467084825,
-0.370755583,
-0.1176656336,
-1.0406057835,
0.3471903801,
-0.2628425956,
1.1492261887,
-0.1099932343,
-0.0917527303,
0.0057049333,
-0.3374329209,
-0.5016152263,
-0.6477287412,
-0.8194758892,
-0.034647461,
0.9652790427,
0.3003945947,
0.8646728992,
0.6245535016,
0.7294344902,
0.2583644986,
0.4204018116,
-0.1477568746,
-0.5045252442,
0.1460671872,
-0.3292489648,
-0.7018167377,
-0.2082368582,
-0.0242651198,
0.9984737039,
0.6461881995,
0.4028280675,
0.1869333386,
0.097738117,
0.8086124063,
-0.1754228622,
0.2009605765,
-0.4649091959,
-0.0526594333,
-0.2032733709,
-0.0097108046,
-0.3532343507,
-0.1532529891,
-0.0248586014,
-0.5768523812,
0.0571580417,
-0.1170169488,
0.804895997,
0.5716737509,
-0.9777809381,
-0.0860849246,
-0.7572801709,
0.8979749084,
-0.555483222,
0.76687181,
0.4730812907,
0.4607108235,
0.0983155817,
-0.1356564909,
-0.3323295116,
-0.1179644614,
-0.4123010039,
0.1475569606,
-0.1516588777,
0.0646857098,
0.2729339302,
0.1939871013,
-0.3926686049,
0.2498218715,
-0.6931780577,
-0.2649344802,
0.4564029276,
-0.3775266409,
0.3904601336,
0.1636450738,
-0.468361944,
-0.1258697212,
-0.48867172,
-0.0001455971,
0.1896441728,
0.5055724382,
-0.4026649892,
0.4941159189,
-0.01922925,
0.6882258654,
-0.0297747795,
-0.2864464819,
0.0657455325,
-0.7613102198,
0.0227511823,
0.0121824928,
0.7732886672,
0.435349524,
0.3899913132,
-0.4371383488,
-0.0184930619,
-0.1496340334,
-0.1305579245,
-0.8387057185,
0.1147453785,
-0.2200023979,
-0.5094064474,
0.1471128166,
-0.0711332113,
-0.5391474962,
-0.0830647796,
-0.6166998744,
0.4881207347,
-0.3696300983,
-0.2877031267,
0.0323903188,
-0.1375175864,
0.1736157835,
0.202632159,
-0.8576133251,
0.3783834577,
0.4868940115,
0.7816584706,
-0.3364726901,
-0.5196443796,
-0.74928087,
0.3620271981,
-0.3305944502,
0.5111418366,
-0.3103767633,
-0.0237813909,
-0.1469101906,
-0.0392246246,
-0.4514552951,
-0.2158177793,
0.290817827,
-0.447738111,
0.3146981001,
-0.669123888,
-0.1393279433,
-0.4934096336,
0.2282491475,
-0.6163544059,
0.5395495296,
0.0081996731,
-0.4935706556,
0.3515039384,
-0.3677473366,
-0.8933349252,
-0.3969451487,
-0.1277844161,
-0.1726596951,
0.2660968602,
0.0646270514,
0.5393428802,
-0.3219619095,
-0.098511681,
0.06055988,
-0.2277541757,
0.3590047359,
-0.6414637566,
0.5868614912,
0.4040870368,
-0.1768188328,
-0.0451666042,
-0.6278296709,
-0.4691536725,
-0.2390362322,
-0.5542029738,
-0.590095222,
-0.3914563954,
-0.1822052896,
0.7156594992,
0.3420316875,
-0.4541385174,
0.5067995191,
-0.0359734818,
0.2335304469,
0.5035231709,
0.1227673963,
0.7312575579,
-0.3194769621,
0.5809562802,
0.0927523226,
0.1139254645,
0.1271069199,
-0.5810047984,
-0.8777515292,
-0.5844635367,
0.5492244959,
0.4762515128,
-0.9442598224,
-0.0897797197,
-0.3534405529,
0.0141658206,
-0.8844803572,
0.285038352,
0.3671377301,
0.4429458976,
0.5681996346,
-0.2447002232,
-0.3126568496,
-1.2816008329,
-0.2191971391,
0.0678669438,
0.0875421762,
-0.1826075315,
-0.0517779477,
-0.347294569,
0.4071513712,
0.0107270358,
-0.6173315048,
-0.2204816043,
-0.1561832726,
0.3028630912,
0.5477097631,
0.7637634277,
-0.8376725912,
-1.0655434132,
0.5600938201,
-0.529961586,
-0.0704666525,
-0.5695666671,
-0.4266653061,
0.0886500031,
0.4462148547,
-0.5404768586,
0.0987527296,
0.937212348,
-0.1940469444,
0.2610233128,
-0.3729678094,
0.5629974008,
-1.1660259962,
0.1368787736,
-0.2362906039,
-0.2289243191,
-0.7860751748,
0.0239801835,
0.0774287954,
0.139081493,
-0.3702455163,
0.3979613185,
-0.6214011908,
-0.1760023385,
-0.2041341662,
0.1702403426,
-0.0049424469,
0.4439328313,
-0.2756083906,
0.7054290175,
0.4921750128,
-0.6320140362,
0.0713285953,
-0.0007710714,
0.3823704123,
0.6212410331,
-0.3239805698,
0.040853072,
0.0626135021,
0.0281214342,
-0.8880504966,
0.085319303,
0.1865107119,
-0.596067071,
0.8048523664,
-0.3704130352,
-0.6252580881,
0.0043898663,
-0.1194589883,
0.4269105196,
0.5369433761,
-0.1484561414,
0.3694432676,
0.0569619685,
-0.0954129249,
-0.3202136159,
-1.0377938747,
0.1731882393,
-0.3819979727,
-0.5863557458,
0.1385327131,
-0.0058014286,
-0.2172202915,
-0.1264686733,
-0.0445774496,
-0.1594022959,
0.1814466417,
0.1217930093,
0.0815388709,
-0.2560056746,
0.3184300065,
0.3496446311,
-0.3673706055,
-0.1429355741,
-0.4208916426,
0.2427998334,
0.1493523121,
-0.4229336083,
-0.4790320694,
0.4939936399,
0.6669424772,
-0.6916009188,
1.1324850321,
1.0044004917,
-0.1808487177,
0.3832409978,
-0.7253202796,
-0.2664409876,
-0.3709212244,
0.3740455806,
-1.0201998949,
-0.7504563332,
0.4847335517,
0.2934921682,
0.1395205259,
0.7875878811,
0.4247631431,
0.2872938514,
1.1775546074,
0.8625374436,
-0.3977412283,
0.5512593985,
-0.1198560297,
0.1282431483,
-0.7675414085,
0.0953032002,
-0.4890840054,
-0.4568601847,
-0.658357203,
-0.5544794202,
0.1886429489,
0.3690135181,
0.0479761362,
0.7143572569,
-0.2280742377,
0.1391196549,
0.7279856801,
-0.2607604861,
0.6450686455,
0.1934265494,
-0.1557389051,
-0.2893245518,
-0.7411875725,
-0.3038891554,
0.959789753,
0.467009306,
0.4689387977,
0.4264397323,
0.9077163339,
-0.0295671076,
0.3214356005,
-0.6136786938,
0.1401899755,
-0.4032706022,
-0.3516143858,
-0.2183437049,
-0.7026786208,
-1.0269322395,
0.4280624688,
-0.0914631262,
-0.3367940485,
0.0590129644,
-0.1659079343,
-0.0133808618,
0.2185567319,
-1.0661889315,
0.8115485311,
-0.2623008192,
-0.4694725275,
-0.377756089,
-0.8244972229,
0.0438083299,
-0.2840043902,
0.4821386039,
0.1097158492,
-0.1263117939,
0.7238221169,
0.2743402421,
0.4525094926,
-0.0255791284,
-0.246725291,
-0.0344908871,
0.5126808286,
0.4693630636,
-0.1089940965,
-0.218668282,
0.3163528442,
-0.0961343572,
-0.6294288635,
-0.6191697121,
0.9025617838,
-0.7618377805,
-0.7637900114,
-0.0686535388,
-0.8469580412,
-0.1294013411,
0.6102747917,
0.2536529303,
0.0301379543,
0.2698049843,
0.1808748692,
0.4832981527,
-0.0585659817,
0.151694566,
0.7188609242,
-0.3073252141,
-0.0330872647,
1.2134016752,
0.2967434525,
0.8169463873,
0.8038496971,
0.1269944757,
-0.1411748677,
-0.5300633907,
-0.7376853228,
0.5331286788,
-0.5121902823,
0.0349564068,
-0.7325318456,
0.0978290662,
-0.597964704,
-0.2382412553,
-0.4787169099,
-0.6663216949,
-0.1142146811,
-0.1287326664,
0.1644710749,
0.715654254,
-0.4839092493,
-0.0433446653,
-1.014598012,
0.1219986081,
0.1839447618,
0.0115736546,
-0.2825433612,
-0.7020131946,
-0.5555232763,
0.213116467,
-0.1838259399,
-0.8990762234,
0.2246237695,
0.1488292813,
0.7991654873,
0.4654046297,
-0.0683026761,
0.5244005322,
-0.4724208415,
0.3847316802,
0.3401712477,
-0.5768865347,
0.0623044111,
-0.3555651903,
0.3286483288,
0.5125359297,
0.5356518626,
-0.7632977962,
-0.5836927891,
-0.2386789918,
-0.3546285033,
0.5336510539,
0.3925410509,
-0.1212947667,
0.1835187227,
0.0238808673,
0.2311012447,
0.1134267598,
-0.6906449795,
-0.260886997,
0.0598891005,
-0.1031663418,
-0.5123746395,
0.0605197325,
0.0135321599,
-0.0340210497,
0.4207101464,
-0.0182367023,
0.3270511329,
0.1460172385,
-0.1968307793,
-0.3214606345,
0.4010317326,
0.7801138163,
0.2597339153,
-0.0430141613,
0.4154510498,
0.2967053056,
-0.137441352,
0.104233399,
0.4065158665,
0.0481539369,
-0.2190828323,
0.5696924329,
0.5563111305,
0.1355149746,
-0.008886613,
0.2381258756,
0.1550032943,
-0.0648287609,
0.4972622097,
-0.3912521303,
0.098835431,
0.2184517831,
0.2849000394,
0.458463043,
0.2305562943,
-0.6729676723,
0.1740921289,
0.2860592604,
-0.6965624094,
-0.7492385507,
0.5472877622,
0.1359993964,
-0.1294987202,
0.4140865803,
-0.2264568657,
-0.935200572,
0.5988030434,
0.5414187908,
0.4936105013,
-0.3993341029,
-0.0307842437,
0.4422831535,
0.7147396803,
0.1959635466,
-0.3090647459,
-0.1046083495,
-0.335381031,
-0.6461565495,
-0.4238451421,
0.0784126446,
-0.3112326264,
-0.6136128902,
0.2067692876,
0.2463134825,
0.0454292297,
-0.2581889927,
-0.0416146182,
-0.8992289305,
-0.2184863091,
0.1762267053,
0.3880133927,
-0.7147371173,
1.0750831366,
0.5826218724,
-0.6643261313,
-0.5909680724,
-0.1641572863,
-0.1073572859,
-0.5494631529,
0.7874271274,
0.1796477586,
0.0642282665,
0.1086274609,
0.1881375313,
-0.9866847396,
0.7710884213,
0.4796782136,
-0.7028431296,
-0.1224154085,
0.4558683634,
0.7033268213,
-0.1985899061,
-0.0594165623,
0.3812183738,
0.6377028227,
-0.1960873455,
-1.3856996298,
0.3690646291,
0.2829729319,
-0.212919876,
0.5989719033,
-0.9415265322,
0.8874377608,
-0.2489224225,
-0.3583192825,
-0.1912295073,
0.2563991845,
-0.3788009882,
0.0085693831,
0.171296373,
0.2606775165,
0.0924736932,
0.3192763627,
1.1771873236,
-0.4292506278,
0.2079347521,
0.8658161163,
0.0995371714,
0.7705528736,
0.9144265652,
-0.2260453105,
0.0702510923,
0.3243717551,
0.1883182824,
0.5640633702,
0.1181942448,
-0.0197384786,
-0.1518518031,
-0.0228346121,
-0.6680600643,
0.120937936,
0.2951031327,
-0.5249772072,
-0.3148536086,
0.3382805884,
0.1294451058,
0.0910862833,
-0.0463938974,
0.737249732,
0.2956124544,
-0.8525797725,
0.6681306362,
0.0312571339,
0.6425436139,
-0.5728790164,
-0.1838251352,
-0.292253226,
0.3539499044,
-0.1344719827,
-0.4594030082,
0.5067896843,
-0.4164114296,
-0.3263884485,
-0.4166233838,
0.6893736124,
-0.773165226,
-0.4152925611,
0.592869699,
0.7256164551,
0.2569569349,
-0.3279597759,
-0.6363912225,
-0.0556487329,
0.4793040156,
0.0578270257,
0.7328154445,
0.5945114493,
-0.1993370503,
0.4329100251,
0.7910885811,
0.2830139101,
0.4742326438,
-0.0490460545,
0.6750606298,
-0.3039179742,
-0.2043518722,
-0.6889743805,
0.391744405,
0.2252218723,
-0.2060341239,
1.3816348314,
0.5975185037,
0.8237435222,
-0.155213207,
0.4530483484,
0.0634943396,
0.2992653251,
-0.4249648452,
0.7253692746,
-0.4493250549,
0.1325841546,
-0.037744049,
-1.1866986752,
-0.3978500068,
0.3435969651,
-0.3910700977,
-0.2494677603,
0.6652164459,
0.5010893345,
-0.1684008539,
-0.6447249651,
0.7387704253,
0.2402137965,
0.4423035383,
0.7063653469,
0.5170121193,
-0.607265234,
0.85539186,
-0.3935370743,
-0.4435863793,
-0.153002888,
-0.5031113625,
-1.0005886555,
-0.6451603174,
-0.2928608656,
-0.0915775523,
0.0991495252,
0.6553385258,
0.6799426675,
-0.7101436257,
-0.2998392582,
0.1370041072,
0.2143314034,
-0.3654923439,
-0.2168556899,
0.2925874293,
-0.5179188251,
-0.6934024692,
0.3992907405,
0.2490579337,
0.15259929,
-0.1703929454,
-0.1591467261,
-0.4682394266,
-0.1418436915,
0.7835732102,
0.2123088539,
-0.5273580551,
-0.1973144263,
0.0744517818,
-0.3069113493,
-0.0376846567,
0.7340338826,
-0.3426439464,
0.4685871005,
0.3508030176,
0.7710255384,
0.4818913341,
-0.1159853339,
0.7808263898,
-0.7375556827,
0.3583144844,
-0.2083594352,
0.1568577737,
0.4442054033,
-0.4037116766,
0.4864541292,
0.1637464911,
-0.4457979202,
-0.5608977675,
0.2793062329,
-0.7131943107,
-0.067242451,
1.4350743294,
-0.1708313227,
0.0530807115,
-0.1291427314,
-0.4040620327,
0.6075173616,
-0.3606618941,
0.3679078221,
0.795044601,
0.0479772277,
-0.0247818343,
-0.7755309343,
0.4737305045,
0.4881500602,
-0.5949152112,
-0.4016940296,
0.240032196,
0.2396721244,
0.4156632125,
0.2607213259,
0.0066819172,
0.0982614607,
0.0395113826,
-0.2058806419,
0.0275233444,
-0.2623690963,
-0.3517834544,
-0.2992078364,
0.2412553281,
-0.4269962907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00474v1
|
SA-MDKIF: A Scalable and Adaptable Medical Domain Knowledge Injection Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-01T10:26:27 | 2024-02-01T10:26:27 |
Tianhan Xu, Zhe Hu, Ling Chen, Bin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional
performance in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their
effective application in the medical domain is hampered by a lack of medical
domain knowledge. In this study, we present SA-MDKIF, a scalable and adaptable
framework that aims to inject medical knowledge into general-purpose LLMs
through instruction tuning, thereby enabling adaptability for various
downstream tasks. SA-MDKIF consists of two stages: skill training and skill
adaptation. In the first stage, we define 12 basic medical skills and use
AdaLoRA to train these skills based on uniformly formatted instructional
datasets that we have constructed. In the next stage, we train the skill router
using task-specific downstream data and use this router to integrate the
acquired skills with LLMs during inference. Experimental results on 9 different
medical tasks show that SA-MDKIF improves performance by 10-20% compared to the
original LLMs. Notably, this improvement is particularly pronounced for unseen
medical tasks, showing an improvement of up to 30%.
|
[
-0.2076912969,
-0.8324311376,
0.7628822327,
0.0753646791,
-0.2918956578,
-0.1166052371,
-0.1970842332,
-0.3456213474,
0.1813112497,
0.6071122289,
-0.4268830717,
-0.5813742876,
-0.84891361,
0.0006731827,
-0.1699505448,
0.8555471897,
0.0632528141,
0.5160114169,
-0.3698667586,
-0.2469384819,
-0.3395496607,
-0.584459722,
-0.8908001184,
-0.4813226163,
0.5813208222,
0.4777980149,
0.5169098973,
0.9996730089,
0.4286679327,
0.1955064088,
0.1417898983,
0.3714584112,
-0.0307422448,
0.1774424016,
-0.4421765506,
-0.5393027663,
-0.5036049485,
-0.4028944075,
0.6220590472,
0.9239589572,
-0.4442818463,
-0.078835018,
-0.1478878707,
1.0609414577,
-0.5230823755,
0.1524435282,
-0.6767854691,
-0.0978977904,
-0.0581695177,
-0.2036724985,
-0.1569493264,
0.0009070747,
0.0922137573,
-0.5664179325,
0.1101486981,
-0.2323144972,
0.6424918175,
0.4840263426,
-0.742123127,
-0.5890257359,
-0.4264099598,
0.339567095,
-0.9517752528,
0.3758012354,
0.5487588644,
0.4605227113,
-0.3137486577,
-0.7666208744,
-0.5576678514,
-0.0439293385,
0.0998484269,
-0.2100910991,
0.4626297951,
0.465229094,
-0.0421679281,
0.3709444106,
-0.5175430775,
0.396676451,
-0.1464655995,
0.2746841609,
0.4835968018,
0.3107562363,
0.4796324968,
-0.0457066,
-0.0550490394,
0.1848391742,
-0.8520128131,
-0.3307512701,
-0.148099497,
0.3881196678,
-0.2885819972,
0.5453243256,
-0.1437492967,
1.1511831284,
0.0730706453,
-0.7454153895,
0.2149562389,
-0.0162937976,
-0.6036195159,
-0.0025881932,
0.5253576636,
0.0838746279,
0.1312823296,
-0.0092966054,
0.1918938607,
-0.1667335778,
0.459741354,
-0.837742269,
-0.2132172883,
0.3292119503,
-0.3277819157,
-0.6263793707,
-0.3100988269,
-0.6807233691,
-0.7900332212,
-0.2056494802,
0.3367153704,
-0.4899437726,
-0.1365918517,
0.1676454544,
0.105327338,
0.1483486593,
0.1459028572,
-1.162795186,
0.3133648336,
0.525636375,
0.8591661453,
-0.5066075325,
-0.2029062808,
-0.5543254018,
0.4477367997,
-0.353143692,
0.7310550809,
-0.596924305,
-0.3566876352,
0.1143434495,
-0.0142061077,
-0.3999603391,
-0.7756897211,
0.4402883053,
-0.5706127882,
-0.1888086647,
-0.1135887727,
-0.6643066406,
-0.0616276152,
0.1185752451,
-0.4382476807,
0.7959489822,
0.4041111767,
-0.5062173009,
0.4270790517,
-0.985863626,
-1.0466346741,
0.1159272939,
-0.3105016947,
-0.1602495313,
-0.0483849421,
0.4067910314,
0.6537134647,
-0.4423841238,
0.3070614636,
-0.2405772656,
-0.2757166326,
0.2251044512,
-0.2982648015,
0.5550122261,
0.0636827499,
-0.2418720424,
0.0719747394,
-1.1599138975,
-0.0206511691,
0.0105269002,
-0.6726028323,
-0.3325153291,
-0.160766378,
0.0126536703,
0.3068797886,
-0.1961672604,
-0.1674167514,
0.2947334945,
-0.7469883561,
0.4785951078,
0.6382496357,
0.4467824399,
0.4517259002,
-0.2264527231,
0.6492349505,
0.2897749245,
0.0175195504,
0.0367817469,
-0.5822017789,
-0.7488324642,
-0.6939176321,
0.2465674877,
0.5094630718,
-1.1593716145,
0.426651895,
-0.1728011519,
-0.4681530297,
-0.712371707,
0.3574232459,
0.2442946732,
0.8169686794,
0.4041004777,
0.1015287116,
-0.539827466,
-0.7668535113,
-0.1336095035,
0.0303263869,
-0.1802832335,
0.5406336188,
0.2902905941,
-0.4871188104,
0.396890372,
-0.6870344281,
-0.5008231997,
-0.0913616568,
-0.1971337646,
0.2873805463,
0.5321666598,
0.4629377723,
-0.7651578784,
-0.5546440482,
0.2017565519,
-0.722443223,
-0.0872207507,
-0.1842877567,
-0.1590483636,
0.2683888376,
0.3195084333,
-0.6343295574,
0.1826876253,
0.8188432455,
-0.5098481178,
0.5258126259,
-0.4951137006,
0.3673654795,
-1.2905788422,
0.2229304314,
-0.2509444654,
-0.3331787586,
-0.7813962102,
0.1549334228,
0.2035877407,
-0.0654210448,
-0.3214507401,
0.5998131633,
-0.2972311378,
0.0300101209,
-0.4707399905,
-0.006928246,
-0.0241920669,
0.4195549786,
-0.0403100848,
0.9340815544,
0.716057837,
-0.9158397317,
0.2325440645,
0.2323245853,
-0.4152326286,
0.9375482202,
-0.4832957387,
0.1819242388,
0.0900901482,
-0.1035623178,
-0.6803504229,
-0.4606602788,
0.2229578048,
-0.2493747622,
0.493154496,
-0.505512774,
-0.3415749967,
-0.2078569829,
0.3042236269,
0.0309751127,
0.4906124473,
-0.7180068493,
0.8854653239,
0.4876148701,
-0.321447134,
-0.5385271907,
-0.7010008693,
0.1983503699,
-0.012138268,
-0.3661171496,
0.3083303571,
-0.0210101511,
0.0998223051,
-0.1346640438,
-0.0741176978,
-0.4795027077,
0.0220420808,
0.4469897747,
0.2771672606,
-0.3061248064,
0.3824031949,
0.7256452441,
0.0106707253,
-0.0790347308,
-0.3526867926,
0.4018436372,
0.2973923981,
-0.6612519026,
-0.2207539082,
0.3327833116,
0.944763422,
-0.1440616548,
1.2808814049,
0.311329186,
-0.5080963373,
-0.2403798997,
-0.6064094901,
0.068880491,
-0.4773518145,
0.5987178683,
-0.4086406827,
-0.7711325288,
0.0691368878,
-0.2934212685,
-0.0560358465,
0.4671171308,
0.7010647655,
-0.2644203901,
1.0070873499,
0.5788764358,
0.1076036245,
0.1982218176,
-0.1620765328,
-0.1718038172,
-0.835457325,
-0.3031477332,
-0.3043323755,
-0.1036979184,
0.0839179084,
-0.7527316213,
0.4564083219,
0.0992426351,
-0.225464493,
-0.124761939,
-0.2113251388,
0.3146853149,
0.1339309663,
0.360758245,
0.3480955064,
-0.0560113937,
-0.2850022912,
0.0292671639,
-0.8937835097,
-0.2509092391,
1.3108184338,
0.1321553439,
0.6038911939,
-0.0593272075,
0.4069385231,
0.2239455879,
0.5612738132,
-0.8598777652,
0.2803995013,
-0.4703474343,
-0.4051793218,
-0.1553803533,
-0.4461535513,
-0.5949358344,
0.1401964128,
-0.428201884,
-0.2875483632,
0.1650614887,
0.3138466179,
-0.1471726745,
0.4534215331,
-0.8446704745,
0.6604751945,
-0.1233091801,
0.1032155976,
-0.3959030807,
-0.4370045364,
0.3338767886,
-0.45494017,
0.2849216163,
-0.0002354709,
-0.3952295482,
0.5640741587,
-0.4512336552,
0.7480764985,
-0.416315943,
-0.1037476137,
-0.2049382478,
-0.1930678338,
0.3872529268,
0.1184242368,
-0.1636166424,
0.1076154187,
0.2548770607,
-0.4138860703,
-0.8750399947,
1.0525900126,
-0.6156046987,
-0.5768914819,
-0.2958928347,
-0.7663335204,
-0.7508567572,
0.2585164607,
-0.0031032804,
0.3863816857,
-0.2413994074,
0.1588910818,
0.8580484986,
-0.2422785461,
-0.0277354755,
0.6075265408,
-0.1007020101,
-0.5343000889,
0.6541378498,
-0.0104544358,
0.5193667412,
0.3234436214,
0.0372517332,
-0.1322969049,
-0.7114079595,
-0.9237883687,
0.3986051679,
-0.8423629403,
-0.3293969631,
-0.7989498377,
-0.2803465724,
-0.4117769897,
-0.2163871676,
-0.3001197278,
-0.3913244605,
-0.4321510196,
0.0211068466,
0.5097054243,
0.8665158153,
0.1663174629,
0.1984092891,
-0.7555614114,
0.7154359221,
0.175200358,
0.805342555,
0.0114967255,
-0.6821092367,
-0.5050547719,
0.1418497562,
0.2428770065,
-0.8567277193,
0.1055723727,
0.5273748636,
0.5808929801,
0.5290745497,
-0.1315308362,
0.8143087626,
-0.7610600591,
0.5734968185,
0.2174456865,
-0.51137501,
0.4461430013,
-0.0316333026,
0.5276922584,
0.514164269,
0.5435913205,
-0.5258752704,
-0.1921033561,
-0.1645273864,
-0.514686048,
0.346721679,
-0.2477841377,
-0.0124375131,
-0.0068100258,
0.8278152347,
0.1185053438,
0.0920685753,
0.0221938267,
-0.5004497766,
0.120431833,
-0.6301330924,
-0.1782300025,
-0.3487450182,
-0.3526587784,
-0.4097332656,
0.7995811701,
-0.4000576138,
0.0970095545,
0.2371036112,
-0.3168995082,
0.0313271843,
0.0988881961,
0.4951942861,
0.7363672256,
0.2267065346,
0.0052140947,
0.3712310791,
-0.999391377,
0.3659618497,
0.0778183267,
-0.0846140161,
-0.1628779024,
0.3203569949,
0.5652677417,
0.3563966155,
-0.9519887567,
0.3120199442,
0.0492104739,
-0.2360165417,
0.0215998422,
0.3744167387,
0.6272646189,
0.1735491753,
0.3095008135,
0.1130951419,
0.142956093,
-0.2618961334,
0.1878869385,
0.1693626344,
-0.3560176194,
0.1399341822,
0.5340866446,
0.0716380253,
-0.3651882708,
0.3040704131,
0.2276321054,
-0.1233408079,
0.3735666573,
0.7774516344,
0.4826096594,
-0.370780021,
0.0983428955,
0.2165377885,
-0.0207785796,
0.1093926728,
0.3441701531,
0.1197167486,
-0.5086954832,
-0.5144765973,
-0.7662717104,
-0.1903470457,
0.0520500876,
-0.6846800447,
0.0084197624,
-0.611343801,
-0.1043747216,
0.180596143,
-0.2240270972,
-0.7460018992,
0.4749958217,
-0.3080953658,
1.0939418077,
-0.7827920914,
1.3046774864,
0.8827173114,
-0.2993051112,
-0.5609824657,
-0.0041694078,
0.018359635,
-0.8905280828,
0.4756810069,
-0.2767444253,
-0.0591472536,
0.0907004774,
-0.2716301084,
-0.7086823583,
1.1519266367,
0.4884682596,
-0.371589154,
-0.1668141633,
0.1686987728,
0.6653388739,
-0.6396124363,
-0.4443221688,
0.6558793187,
0.1627996266,
0.1962020546,
-0.6764420271,
0.1490584761,
-0.1741925627,
0.1447848976,
-0.0218241923,
-0.0692070648,
0.1562049985,
-0.4721777439,
0.0573783405,
0.1688971668,
0.4233777821,
0.3454353809,
-0.0318553336,
0.5719422102,
0.4169253707,
0.8956903219,
0.2110880464,
0.9849433899,
-0.3877631426,
-0.2255472839,
1.1496424675,
-0.2196321338,
0.969239831,
0.7154647112,
-0.2754453123,
0.6475862265,
0.2316862941,
0.2529576123,
0.5872915983,
0.0884004086,
-0.523014009,
-0.057054244,
0.054904148,
-0.4956428409,
0.3345386088,
0.7415699959,
-0.6177949309,
0.21284087,
0.4670953155,
0.0715880767,
0.0462766066,
-0.3272151947,
0.9322112203,
0.16720514,
-0.6226789355,
0.6416470408,
0.1599917561,
0.5847124457,
-0.9589067698,
-0.3179958463,
-0.1067259833,
0.2674921155,
-0.2530081868,
-0.617767632,
0.2969785035,
-0.0615479462,
-0.3907822967,
0.201152727,
0.9548267126,
-0.4983643889,
-0.4793183208,
0.1425992996,
0.3282732666,
-0.0125073427,
-0.0187782478,
-0.6500551701,
-0.0896455571,
-0.1438433528,
-0.0485820137,
0.6882534623,
0.2177865505,
0.4031385779,
0.9854641557,
0.8999206424,
0.566008389,
-0.0085565345,
0.2421283275,
0.9697697163,
-0.4127386212,
-0.417483896,
-0.5462473631,
0.3173394799,
-0.0764382035,
-0.1924996227,
0.3793869019,
0.3114461303,
0.2786954939,
-0.2338746339,
0.7456239462,
-0.0669306144,
0.5596099496,
-0.6380948424,
1.2808401585,
-0.5265698433,
0.1411107928,
-0.0374971665,
-0.3671103716,
-0.39502877,
0.4993395209,
0.0270675626,
0.1537294388,
0.6814820766,
0.7588886023,
0.0476985611,
-0.1280751526,
0.6137596369,
0.3302526176,
0.2957025468,
0.5021381974,
0.0317422673,
-0.2797748446,
0.4125430882,
-0.2724627852,
-0.3839189112,
-0.121477589,
-0.6796116829,
-1.0727866888,
-0.7008733153,
-0.1325157732,
-0.3527070284,
0.3737795651,
0.844899416,
0.9819537401,
-1.0314987898,
0.0367987119,
0.0605906621,
-0.0043226057,
-0.5531163812,
-0.1849493831,
0.5374956131,
-0.3439930379,
-0.4001731277,
0.6959071755,
0.4415199161,
-0.0173749216,
-0.3149466515,
-0.2398097664,
-0.653883636,
0.1196330935,
0.6835354567,
0.2432724237,
-0.5571262836,
-0.183883816,
-0.0868533924,
-0.2798161209,
0.0303424932,
0.8286501765,
-0.6361625791,
0.5718740225,
0.0314280614,
1.1219270229,
0.502258122,
-0.2822604477,
0.7732679248,
-0.6141906977,
0.0639021471,
0.0468161702,
0.3975078166,
0.3700576127,
-0.6601717472,
0.3899578154,
0.2598589659,
-0.3846915066,
-0.7861877084,
0.1237468794,
-0.7809628844,
-0.3627850115,
1.1718366146,
-0.223330155,
0.0366011038,
-0.3697350323,
-0.2910820246,
0.3493118882,
0.1443014592,
0.6738678813,
0.5862543583,
-0.1147160456,
-0.1296067089,
-0.678144753,
0.6504253149,
0.2465109676,
-1.0966193676,
-0.0998601988,
0.1697564274,
0.7211655974,
-0.3663477004,
0.8930307031,
-0.3509787619,
0.4009900093,
-0.0178329553,
-0.2202967405,
-0.3388864994,
-0.3240074515,
-0.5107622743,
0.0703424662,
0.3283003271,
0.0336925052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00453v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00453v2
|
Instruction Makes a Difference
| 2024-02-01T09:43:30 | 2024-06-13T13:28:37 |
Tosin Adewumi, Nudrat Habib, Lama Alkhaled, Elisa Barney
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We introduce Instruction Document Visual Question Answering (iDocVQA) dataset
and Large Language Document (LLaDoc) model, for training Language-Vision (LV)
models for document analysis and predictions on document images, respectively.
Usually, deep neural networks for the DocVQA task are trained on datasets
lacking instructions. We show that using instruction-following datasets
improves performance. We compare performance across document-related datasets
using the recent state-of-the-art (SotA) Large Language and Vision Assistant
(LLaVA)1.5 as the base model. We also evaluate the performance of the derived
models for object hallucination using the Polling-based Object Probing
Evaluation (POPE) dataset. The results show that instruction-tuning performance
ranges from 11X to 32X of zero-shot performance and from 0.1% to 4.2% over
non-instruction (traditional task) finetuning. Despite the gains, these still
fall short of human performance (94.36%), implying there's much room for
improvement.
|
[
-0.0783732086,
-0.746543467,
0.5874451399,
-0.2460951954,
-0.1714276373,
-0.0772282779,
-0.2404290587,
-0.4139088988,
-0.3222476542,
0.6819291711,
-0.5781166553,
-0.8307092786,
-0.7261943221,
-0.0237188544,
-0.4739988148,
0.5027505159,
0.0600828119,
0.4223224223,
-0.5724546313,
0.1576282829,
-0.6896885633,
-0.0342053995,
-0.7874310017,
-0.1860095263,
0.3457647562,
0.6011813879,
0.3941352665,
1.0326544046,
0.7007752061,
0.3419919014,
0.2633048594,
0.4004376531,
-0.5161843896,
0.0116967708,
0.04447148,
-0.6115934253,
-0.1349931806,
-0.0330006741,
0.5778626204,
0.6507451534,
0.0077020661,
-0.1611190885,
0.0757671371,
0.8488577604,
-0.5158797503,
0.5144131184,
-0.486428529,
0.1061077714,
0.0717739984,
-0.3182909787,
-0.482267797,
-0.2220962644,
0.2065214813,
-0.7908457518,
0.5697197318,
-0.025203757,
0.7290948033,
0.5168397427,
0.0449953116,
-0.5691537857,
-0.5098658204,
0.6575729251,
-0.6668459177,
0.6223824024,
0.4503331184,
0.0579486266,
-0.1475091726,
-0.7238613367,
-0.450537473,
-0.3332971334,
0.1400882602,
0.2349749506,
0.0657286048,
0.263569206,
0.4167123437,
0.3553701639,
-0.4101425409,
0.4317685962,
-0.7242661119,
0.0922112614,
0.5404522419,
0.3187596798,
0.181597352,
-0.0498243421,
-0.132096082,
-0.5316439867,
-0.5091354251,
0.2308547795,
0.3243481815,
0.0137550514,
0.1368662417,
0.4708763957,
-0.355291456,
0.881383419,
0.1515430212,
-0.1989562809,
0.0784524083,
-0.0395167097,
-0.4319714904,
0.0531599931,
0.5575521588,
0.5635653138,
0.2618082762,
-0.3766842186,
-0.206077978,
0.0238204673,
0.4893910885,
-0.884087503,
-0.2793569267,
-0.0294468571,
-0.4426262975,
-0.2184674144,
0.1317928135,
-0.6735783219,
-0.7278157473,
-0.8039363027,
0.354827702,
-0.6070392132,
0.3919722438,
0.1943473518,
-0.1614262015,
0.6951780915,
0.7266229391,
-1.0372982025,
0.5020400882,
0.9576638937,
0.6660907865,
-0.2767080963,
-0.3608982861,
-0.7854862213,
-0.3393456936,
-0.7849028111,
0.8998004198,
-0.7541947961,
-0.4006642103,
-0.0192077048,
0.2584228218,
-0.2544451952,
-0.7054221034,
0.3873125315,
-0.3814246356,
0.1799069345,
-0.2518571615,
-0.7747918367,
-0.3141786754,
0.0708933994,
-0.6368701458,
0.9930479527,
0.0711573139,
-0.343277812,
0.317366749,
-0.4562390149,
-0.4636894166,
-0.046727173,
-0.517362833,
-0.1470515877,
0.1393430829,
0.4315350354,
0.7211797237,
-0.2878926694,
-0.1373494267,
0.1238437593,
-0.9743000865,
0.0866565853,
-0.4920982718,
0.4513713121,
-0.1116141826,
-0.5573819876,
-0.0674447939,
-0.9174131155,
-0.0113590024,
-0.0966094509,
-0.4579035044,
-0.0975904241,
0.1227999255,
-0.4005130231,
-0.0946386904,
-0.0344156474,
-0.4842387736,
0.4019754827,
-0.4744853079,
0.0933429226,
0.8939324021,
-0.0888630673,
0.5522758365,
-0.0507121533,
0.5471786857,
-0.1036637053,
0.1218968853,
-0.3145176768,
-0.4458478987,
-1.1142009497,
0.0810247287,
0.2326127738,
0.7288773656,
-0.9038518071,
-0.0020793697,
-0.1968142539,
-0.3058028221,
-0.7371997833,
0.2486144304,
0.7290853262,
0.823502183,
0.2017732859,
-0.3910157979,
-0.3230641186,
-0.8714811802,
0.1494493335,
-0.065594092,
-0.0058872807,
0.4408996701,
0.3090687394,
0.0608694367,
0.0745544955,
-0.4939641356,
-0.2998038828,
0.0832033753,
0.1803664416,
0.17098324,
0.2850736082,
0.2193788439,
-0.7099427581,
-0.3717287481,
0.0955461636,
-0.9536803961,
0.0681664199,
-0.2428000271,
-0.0276669282,
0.4571436942,
0.7963805199,
-0.3076010644,
0.7450978756,
0.2181087136,
-0.0061474298,
0.3014506102,
-0.435911566,
0.5151039958,
-0.7148635983,
-0.4249767661,
-0.0958669856,
0.0697393194,
-0.679906249,
0.0777485967,
0.2078785151,
-0.1780685186,
-0.6350340247,
0.2575656772,
-0.5511146784,
-0.3930079341,
-0.3249410987,
0.1469441503,
0.3109811544,
0.6669099927,
0.2193862498,
1.0874444246,
0.851622045,
-0.5754579306,
0.4379828572,
0.2464320362,
-0.6642791629,
0.2809366882,
-0.6760965586,
0.4653056562,
-0.3641576469,
-0.2175569385,
-0.905095458,
-0.2626209557,
0.3348969519,
-0.2819210887,
0.7517686486,
0.0038709845,
-0.4030027092,
-0.2274444401,
-0.4472502768,
-0.1746927947,
0.446706593,
-0.5819956064,
0.4969640076,
-0.084921658,
0.1025051028,
-0.8016589284,
-0.7277271748,
0.0987542272,
0.2116697431,
-0.5378565788,
0.3150213361,
-0.0175031293,
-0.2148425132,
-0.0248898547,
-0.0142286289,
-0.1325163692,
0.0062616104,
0.5348427296,
0.3743953407,
-0.3669370115,
0.5884861946,
-0.2325180918,
0.116813913,
0.0504232012,
-0.2160118967,
0.3879258931,
-0.1835362315,
-0.3565881252,
-0.7138142586,
0.3747855723,
0.3267707527,
-0.3282159865,
0.6797724366,
0.3097527325,
-0.16560404,
-0.1776884943,
-0.4763560593,
-0.2041332424,
-0.490208745,
0.4745283127,
-0.3990917802,
-0.3681012094,
0.0331272483,
0.2733134925,
0.1184730381,
0.1738368571,
0.3243548572,
-0.556353271,
0.5808100104,
0.5854866505,
0.2794896662,
0.6254144907,
-0.6729893088,
0.0130575839,
-0.8988326192,
-0.3710530698,
-0.2316716462,
-0.3653638959,
-0.5213306546,
-0.7263926864,
0.1317777485,
-0.0291348603,
0.1559770107,
0.2016064823,
-0.8159849644,
0.6642460227,
0.8074667454,
0.3878718913,
0.050465446,
0.19974491,
0.2340803891,
-0.0121816052,
-0.7338282466,
-0.569583118,
1.2731975317,
0.0643586591,
1.0843793154,
-0.4438926578,
0.7779434323,
0.3443314433,
-0.0901109278,
-1.0087324381,
0.6702641845,
-0.7397515178,
-0.0557499453,
-0.4761596024,
-0.1370848119,
-1.0254253149,
0.1104325652,
-0.1596803218,
-0.7464516163,
0.4628232419,
-0.0430946276,
-0.1870609671,
0.1966229677,
-0.9647658467,
0.8255432248,
-0.4898112416,
-0.4402228296,
-0.1050385311,
-0.2828621566,
0.0002599,
0.23662211,
-0.3114182949,
0.1325712502,
-0.0328131057,
0.759737134,
-0.1476408392,
0.8098936081,
-0.1526542157,
-0.1359820813,
0.3714290261,
-0.2984901965,
0.4966242909,
-0.2706520259,
-0.297100544,
0.0497349687,
-0.1741507947,
-0.2192787975,
-1.0013958216,
0.6849378943,
-0.7280792594,
-0.9586673975,
-0.0919807628,
-0.6530045867,
-0.0038203897,
0.0185304638,
0.421135962,
0.9162508249,
-0.1495473236,
0.5537121296,
1.277072072,
-0.2332993895,
0.3856709003,
0.4217299819,
0.1993921846,
0.0976620093,
0.8633488417,
0.5007457733,
0.1237918735,
0.6821709871,
-0.0412898585,
-0.204671815,
-0.6217205524,
-0.6449139118,
0.0189035349,
-1.1234291792,
0.0301005952,
-0.6644262075,
-0.2883866429,
-0.6060221195,
-0.0835559964,
-0.2561236322,
-0.1948208362,
-0.6147350073,
-0.1081423238,
0.2506020367,
0.7490435839,
0.3396459818,
0.1920299381,
-0.4915517569,
0.4895755947,
0.5552685261,
0.1973268688,
-0.0138605274,
-0.5878843069,
-0.2715391219,
-0.0189542957,
-0.2356308401,
-0.7274791002,
0.0324647315,
0.3360229731,
0.5618816018,
0.3649912477,
-0.1993170977,
0.6597844958,
-0.7217689157,
0.5426266193,
-0.0708283111,
-0.5923773646,
0.6390336156,
0.0012643606,
0.3695460558,
0.4552579522,
0.1438955516,
-0.3604454696,
-0.2644228339,
-0.360099107,
-0.4487298727,
0.9243150949,
0.0648605824,
0.132189393,
0.1816388965,
0.4670371413,
0.1769537479,
0.122732304,
-0.1402626783,
0.0108093051,
-0.1850804389,
-0.2263394743,
-0.0573577695,
-0.0089075612,
0.0435083956,
-0.3043019176,
0.4525993168,
-0.2272051573,
0.4449099004,
0.2136078179,
-0.0775843263,
0.0812266096,
0.1344930381,
0.6347491741,
0.7720732093,
-0.222027868,
-0.0612576492,
0.1649347395,
-0.563942492,
-0.0076920534,
0.1112830341,
-0.1899103373,
-0.1353446245,
0.7608585954,
1.2593473196,
0.1466943026,
-0.6821506619,
0.4742351174,
-0.3112273514,
-0.4612719119,
-0.1716154516,
0.7768118978,
0.0303660743,
0.3492429554,
0.1453533322,
-0.1117759645,
0.2992591858,
-0.6756190658,
0.0596477203,
0.1500970274,
-0.3806731105,
0.1725073308,
0.4478986561,
0.0134404823,
-0.503389895,
0.8883494139,
0.0391169265,
-0.1735036969,
1.1460399628,
0.2719221115,
0.6019820571,
0.0476291329,
0.3990367353,
0.173006013,
0.3900235593,
0.045757059,
0.2977128923,
-0.2857997417,
-0.4492796957,
-0.1641975492,
-0.4265556633,
-0.3214563727,
0.1976408213,
-0.6910639405,
0.0844738856,
-0.5326167345,
0.3589418828,
0.1757306457,
0.2263334394,
-0.9858719707,
0.5381356478,
0.1273771673,
0.8342635036,
-0.4558818042,
0.9722818136,
0.5549357533,
-0.4085759223,
-0.7770068645,
0.0626488924,
-0.2450702935,
-0.9225551486,
0.8009531498,
0.4595158696,
-0.196800828,
-0.1764508486,
-0.5682239532,
-0.5272189379,
1.2313594818,
0.2685836852,
-0.8885064721,
-0.178817451,
0.0728354305,
0.7120790482,
-0.5902293921,
0.0271700993,
0.579810977,
0.2074100524,
0.1093071476,
-0.2680044472,
-0.2917537987,
-0.1824179441,
0.1057706177,
-0.0142125813,
-0.5445541143,
0.7591111064,
-0.2115507424,
-0.3421885073,
0.0511669032,
0.5458840132,
-0.194751963,
0.5288165808,
0.325830102,
0.5626091957,
0.9258805513,
-0.1318882108,
1.4511249065,
0.0526004992,
-0.340141207,
1.4491555691,
-0.0545821562,
0.8403812051,
0.3668057919,
0.0359315164,
0.3211074173,
0.5978602767,
-0.3485535383,
0.5325707793,
0.0552407168,
0.0542750098,
-0.1567724794,
-0.0846964046,
-0.2500441074,
0.7006887197,
0.356346935,
-0.5981497765,
0.0923813879,
0.1570442319,
-0.3058319092,
0.1895933896,
-0.3855387568,
0.9122771025,
-0.0535848364,
-0.7925342321,
0.8306100368,
-0.2178618014,
0.2327540219,
-0.3472702503,
-0.5470915437,
-0.4036350548,
0.1177080795,
-0.0685256198,
-0.9602015018,
-0.0652186796,
0.059692584,
-0.3234003782,
-0.1332591623,
0.791692555,
-0.2950100899,
-0.6538982391,
0.1349457055,
0.185626179,
0.4690653384,
0.1319440454,
-0.6812343001,
0.0036101416,
0.0137186386,
-0.113708429,
0.1851775199,
0.4449772239,
-0.1073334366,
0.5491679311,
0.4529337585,
-0.0302283093,
0.2845195532,
0.3061556518,
0.9412922263,
-0.3439525962,
0.0013009151,
-0.5157125592,
0.2860265374,
-0.2689532042,
-0.3433947265,
0.4813448787,
0.3958143592,
0.9478059411,
-0.3455902338,
0.4088063538,
0.1903095692,
0.1999488771,
-1.0470457077,
0.4676349461,
-0.6442149878,
0.2692298591,
0.0260737389,
-0.8009890914,
-0.0484586395,
0.5202692747,
-0.5355421901,
-0.2196884453,
0.6707602739,
1.1535072327,
-0.092127867,
-0.1694440991,
0.6390223503,
0.0676631704,
0.1264825463,
0.6246605515,
0.8652952313,
-0.6684734225,
0.4788735211,
-0.484957546,
-0.0953990519,
-0.2190441489,
-0.5277302861,
-1.1656756401,
-0.4764301777,
-0.3427512944,
0.02220615,
0.4537135661,
0.391217351,
0.7155624032,
-0.6329106092,
-0.0858663395,
-0.1792806387,
0.0385799855,
-0.2863950729,
-0.1742749065,
0.6974745393,
-0.4857910573,
-0.9718517661,
0.6523714066,
0.395611614,
-0.0430885889,
-0.1798624992,
-0.1954848319,
-0.1900669336,
0.1339319795,
0.4210905135,
0.1734933555,
-0.8368468285,
-0.0906794146,
0.3771861196,
-0.2608999014,
0.4658968151,
0.5986099243,
-0.6195190549,
0.9360406399,
0.4794913828,
0.855127573,
0.5563934445,
-0.0547586642,
0.3768851459,
-0.6750734448,
0.2353685796,
0.1059424728,
0.2110714912,
0.5065402985,
-0.7631322742,
0.642159164,
-0.0609050095,
-0.5293865204,
-0.391377598,
-0.0712609813,
-0.7492461801,
-0.4071576893,
0.8327901363,
-0.3191774487,
-0.6557117701,
0.2331758589,
-0.471416235,
0.3218052983,
-0.3794438541,
0.8166435957,
0.7587505579,
-0.2703459859,
-0.5890387893,
-0.8226493001,
0.3776856065,
0.2445558906,
-0.9729635715,
-0.0702129379,
0.5988919139,
-0.0186163895,
0.0237924121,
0.5537794232,
0.004667934,
0.747210741,
0.2809763253,
-0.0456604436,
-0.3381589651,
-0.6425238848,
-0.3156120479,
-0.0161428023,
-0.0747666135,
-0.665756762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00446v1
|
Improving Dialog Safety using Socially Aware Contrastive Learning
| 2024-02-01T09:24:33 | 2024-02-01T09:24:33 |
Souvik Das, Rohini K. Srihari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
State-of-the-art conversational AI systems raise concerns due to their
potential risks of generating unsafe, toxic, unethical, or dangerous content.
Previous works have developed datasets to teach conversational agents the
appropriate social paradigms to respond effectively to specifically designed
hazardous content. However, models trained on these adversarial datasets still
struggle to recognize subtle unsafe situations that appear naturally in
conversations or introduce an inappropriate response in a casual context. To
understand the extent of this problem, we study prosociality in both
adversarial and casual dialog contexts and audit the response quality of
general-purpose language models in terms of propensity to produce unsafe
content. We propose a dual-step fine-tuning process to address these issues
using a socially aware n-pair contrastive loss. Subsequently, we train a base
model that integrates prosocial behavior by leveraging datasets like Moral
Integrity Corpus (MIC) and ProsocialDialog. Experimental results on several
dialog datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in generating
socially appropriate responses.
|
[
-0.0028750389,
-0.9571136832,
0.2430310994,
-0.1010180488,
-0.3000588417,
0.0835300386,
-0.040753819,
-0.375179112,
-0.1455392241,
0.3835875094,
-0.3332634866,
-0.297428906,
-0.5328025818,
-0.1315918118,
-0.1085048169,
1.3843852282,
0.5730463862,
0.1682065874,
-0.1755809486,
-0.4208731055,
-0.351575166,
-0.5332880616,
-1.3178632259,
-0.1156716868,
0.5199227333,
0.3969552219,
1.053786993,
0.2893702686,
0.3737163246,
0.3650509417,
-0.1975104213,
0.3199478984,
-0.9275460243,
0.099919267,
-0.2089176327,
-0.2746056616,
-0.4269112051,
0.0415723473,
0.2690556347,
0.5242941976,
-0.057275787,
-0.0964358449,
0.5013585687,
0.5729339719,
-0.453602463,
0.2347627431,
-0.5377050638,
-0.0487649813,
0.2838794291,
-0.4071050286,
-0.3930654824,
-0.7333387136,
0.4309805334,
-0.6003369689,
0.137003541,
-0.1547828019,
0.5079573989,
0.2254238576,
-0.5457635522,
-0.4120556712,
-0.5427336097,
0.5282259583,
-0.5300351977,
0.0335969403,
0.6193748116,
0.1357104182,
-0.0515258275,
-0.2795026302,
-0.3753254116,
-0.2299076915,
-0.1428012252,
0.0369955078,
-0.0634490028,
0.2881377935,
-0.2270681262,
-0.0974376053,
-0.3307608664,
0.0249009375,
-0.3187393248,
-0.3048166037,
0.7787070274,
0.4633892477,
0.1933923513,
0.0379814468,
-0.0688545853,
-0.3682594001,
-0.5630161762,
0.1811928153,
0.5294035673,
0.3931858838,
-0.4267396033,
-0.009653789,
0.1216581836,
0.2350705862,
0.1853692979,
0.1174955592,
0.1561175436,
-0.6204803586,
-0.0429312997,
0.1239688843,
0.7780401707,
0.9540064931,
0.6425765157,
0.0063185953,
0.1273654103,
0.2312700599,
0.4425852895,
-0.7874817252,
-0.3658294082,
0.0639224946,
-0.2119965851,
-1.0235683918,
-0.1672728062,
-0.5897155404,
-0.8550163507,
-0.3920512199,
0.3465797007,
-0.5657081008,
-0.3077950478,
0.0273341723,
0.1568739414,
0.0813084021,
0.4476251006,
-0.7206385732,
0.311250031,
0.4553816319,
0.5822249651,
0.3879618943,
0.1379394531,
-0.8876273632,
0.2435153425,
-0.4219848812,
0.3414454758,
-0.5882053375,
-0.5836932659,
0.2004945278,
0.113149412,
0.1208649799,
-0.5440917611,
0.4494530261,
-0.3622580469,
0.0095296111,
-0.1107172146,
-0.134349227,
-0.0467973091,
0.3763930798,
-0.0609155819,
0.4762907326,
-0.2571450174,
-0.9473596811,
0.0245509651,
-0.2964885235,
-0.7141456008,
-0.1353948414,
-0.1597736031,
-0.498550415,
-0.0511110164,
-0.1023486704,
0.6405453086,
0.0711802021,
0.4448212087,
-0.4872564077,
-0.520958066,
0.3368995786,
-0.6179973483,
0.7493499517,
-0.0587138683,
-0.3207802176,
0.3659173548,
-0.6406548619,
-0.1217511445,
0.1477282941,
-0.1660172939,
-0.6661980152,
-0.0398765765,
-0.1006282493,
0.1528706551,
-0.0455857404,
-0.3028785586,
-0.5584361553,
-0.326466769,
0.5002326369,
1.2340511084,
-0.013572922,
0.4322026372,
-0.36735183,
0.1228846163,
0.1856052727,
0.4518440366,
0.2011362463,
-0.2223583758,
-0.8590491414,
0.2365206927,
-0.1715399623,
0.738465786,
-0.9890769124,
0.4559255838,
0.1061217412,
-0.4596458077,
-0.363591671,
-0.0785982087,
0.8782362938,
0.6823911071,
0.0730469078,
-0.3320212364,
-0.1824909747,
-0.7230870128,
-0.0928714052,
-0.4324508905,
-0.011307111,
0.8289058805,
0.111584954,
-0.2179180086,
0.3977935314,
-0.3926203251,
-0.2117661238,
0.0399787799,
0.3384191096,
-0.2884659767,
0.7798692584,
0.2885150611,
-0.85952878,
-0.3604199886,
-0.1680144221,
-0.8695636392,
0.1354039758,
-0.1039261371,
-0.2515845895,
0.1287399679,
0.6865804195,
-0.1492775381,
0.3244773746,
0.3682361245,
-0.4223168492,
0.3915356398,
-0.3497055173,
0.1082463413,
-1.133818388,
-0.1666646749,
0.078272514,
-0.2302592546,
-0.8513201475,
-0.2893312871,
-0.2728905976,
-0.1928548664,
-0.6656453609,
0.2141888291,
-0.0670513958,
0.2411230505,
0.0185423288,
0.2112769336,
-0.206014812,
0.4318982661,
0.0949337631,
0.8929411769,
0.5904883146,
-0.880988121,
0.0689172521,
0.3788258731,
0.0117406575,
0.8287904859,
-0.9855288863,
0.5131469369,
-0.499055028,
0.3007203341,
-0.8127176762,
-0.3594255447,
0.3384109437,
-0.5390025377,
0.2520074546,
-0.1256998628,
-0.1234997213,
0.3616655171,
-0.57783252,
0.4248528481,
0.4363669753,
-0.2248629481,
0.1511343718,
0.5930805802,
-0.6080661416,
-0.4969356656,
-0.298922807,
-0.0447296351,
-0.3537953794,
-0.757286787,
-0.0461538881,
-0.2114512622,
-0.3563581407,
-0.2983237803,
-0.0311096609,
0.0407733805,
0.3930016458,
0.2989275157,
0.3449873328,
0.2625648379,
0.1574388295,
0.0192798339,
-0.318141222,
0.2856300771,
0.3218311071,
0.5016764402,
-0.5023177862,
0.1053913906,
-0.503226459,
0.282820195,
0.2986712158,
-0.0265898332,
0.8337615728,
0.6172221899,
-0.2719752491,
0.1482479423,
-0.1806574613,
-0.563026309,
-0.5683075786,
0.2611208856,
0.1876658797,
-1.0565639734,
0.3575103581,
0.1222161055,
0.0096186735,
-0.1507417411,
0.2225748152,
-0.2661615014,
1.0495120287,
0.4666073322,
0.0051250476,
0.6553336382,
-0.131467551,
0.3795036376,
-0.5391181111,
-0.2780324221,
-0.3650863767,
-0.0035403809,
-0.7762674093,
-0.4553000927,
0.8634677529,
-0.2903845608,
-0.5292199254,
0.0592196994,
-0.3012642562,
0.5962154269,
0.6678028703,
0.5405025482,
0.114423357,
-0.1998082399,
0.1555396169,
0.0042388756,
-0.3870467246,
-0.8265753984,
0.8225986362,
0.2608188391,
0.8341636658,
0.2896433473,
0.7648258209,
0.2736842334,
0.2002558857,
-0.494237572,
0.7215721607,
-0.2680693269,
-0.4334925711,
-0.3999264538,
-0.5720781684,
-0.9265036583,
-0.031291388,
-0.3566794395,
-0.6654078364,
0.2289293408,
0.4296309054,
-0.7242735624,
-0.1176714599,
-0.6757635474,
0.6829921603,
0.0322393924,
-0.7391127944,
-0.4597553313,
-1.1657963991,
0.2473606914,
0.2165384293,
0.4052528739,
-0.2371324301,
0.3660573661,
0.4776118398,
-0.1214707196,
1.4246357679,
-0.2158828825,
-0.085531868,
0.3229524791,
0.4013850689,
0.6420248747,
0.4816605449,
0.0515902266,
0.0505802035,
-0.2271127403,
-0.371720612,
-0.3346227109,
0.5021808743,
-0.8773206472,
-0.5325850248,
-0.1817802787,
-0.3984081745,
-0.4606681466,
-0.0526532196,
0.1323182881,
0.6889967322,
-0.5157731771,
0.3743477464,
1.0607476234,
-0.6516578197,
0.1864539087,
0.5681520104,
0.6817317605,
-0.3801811635,
1.1808388233,
-0.2110079378,
0.4871143699,
-0.0102655208,
0.29865399,
-0.2630186379,
-0.4822677672,
-0.0937574133,
-0.0351078287,
-0.6563066244,
-0.3010333776,
-0.6405258775,
-0.1404902339,
-0.5596109629,
-0.5026402473,
-0.1556800902,
-0.1152366027,
-0.3804775178,
-0.2028148472,
0.2294722199,
0.5216936469,
-0.2686992884,
0.1275633276,
-0.9807008505,
0.1791116893,
0.6909394264,
0.2700366676,
-0.205152154,
-0.4076346159,
0.0862154141,
0.1496526301,
-0.2647288144,
-0.6188750267,
0.1972203702,
0.3422097564,
0.2909577191,
0.6146856546,
0.726456821,
0.2430348247,
-0.4819798172,
0.5459353924,
0.207468763,
-0.6241486669,
0.7443435192,
-0.7745780349,
-0.1719846725,
0.9202576876,
0.3045456409,
-0.6506765485,
-0.4956148267,
-0.6820083261,
-0.9363601804,
0.6189836264,
0.388500303,
0.5672771335,
-0.3258148432,
0.0259095188,
0.0790781528,
0.2526895106,
-0.6153995395,
-0.0925053433,
-0.2401892394,
-0.3188316524,
-0.3161642253,
-0.2489013672,
-0.6032093763,
0.0612440556,
0.6457877755,
-0.4018284082,
0.0470742472,
0.0729823038,
0.0265426505,
0.0522998013,
0.3835756481,
0.3760616779,
0.121907115,
-0.333243072,
0.3098605871,
0.0318347514,
-0.3909425437,
0.2867744267,
0.119628869,
0.0236471966,
-0.5220508575,
0.1526145339,
0.5315830112,
0.3578539789,
-0.7211596966,
0.5602414012,
-0.2964780629,
0.0598234795,
-0.2152563334,
0.4318560362,
0.0458600856,
0.2787985206,
-0.2651159167,
0.0833440796,
0.4672271609,
-0.7317373753,
0.1773346663,
0.4304514229,
-0.4135503769,
-0.2529560924,
0.5155736208,
0.9036145806,
-0.4129782319,
0.6323110461,
-0.2903845906,
-0.247630313,
0.6820573807,
0.288942337,
0.8340100646,
-0.2529354393,
0.6124796867,
0.3517267108,
0.2254631668,
0.347520113,
0.2152966708,
-0.1538382173,
-1.1051956415,
0.1883486509,
-0.1919625103,
-0.6270334125,
0.0591873117,
-0.7335249186,
-0.2246622592,
-0.8279095292,
-0.1919165403,
0.0590988472,
-0.3078919053,
-0.4423685074,
0.2111566961,
0.0427160934,
0.241264537,
-1.0157727003,
0.4341233969,
0.7462293506,
-0.2390157729,
-0.5141066909,
0.0846958309,
0.2966255546,
-0.9584303498,
0.3612711132,
0.3847764432,
-0.5159947872,
-0.234067902,
-0.6494318843,
-0.3814091086,
0.8166549802,
0.4032971263,
-0.4954454899,
0.1653871685,
0.166603744,
0.6691464782,
-0.0325448476,
-0.0998170897,
0.5024834871,
-0.0433415174,
0.0053196098,
-0.71558851,
0.2750683129,
-0.4317979217,
0.0634423569,
0.0647464693,
-0.9586942792,
0.3502280116,
-0.3722707927,
-0.205284059,
-0.1298223734,
0.2848118544,
0.2849633098,
0.7266797423,
0.7651550174,
0.1416492015,
0.7473891973,
-0.0353067145,
0.7639735937,
-0.2161514163,
-0.150351271,
1.2423992157,
-0.3334980607,
0.5444144607,
0.2218855172,
0.1999137849,
0.0948129371,
0.5540470481,
0.5288227797,
0.6033855677,
0.1496355981,
-0.6107069254,
-0.5374087095,
-0.6070534587,
-0.2507700324,
0.4945213199,
0.570794642,
-0.3117334843,
0.1344608217,
-0.2967358828,
0.2624930739,
0.1584583372,
-0.1459114552,
1.0860840082,
0.021041302,
-0.3985240757,
0.3987236619,
-0.3492615521,
0.6767280102,
-0.2248960733,
-0.0297873206,
-0.4633311927,
0.2667778134,
-0.0068466202,
-0.6597654223,
0.4597877562,
-0.0151048386,
0.2686199844,
-0.0781905502,
0.8058114052,
-0.4163440168,
-0.1773903519,
0.2103334665,
0.1602133065,
0.1580893993,
0.141105786,
-0.6480433345,
-0.1645630747,
-0.1847324967,
0.1849192679,
0.6303719282,
0.4319414198,
0.0039965739,
0.6677573323,
0.5351092815,
-0.5312688351,
-0.4259159863,
0.2733359933,
1.0680394173,
-0.4120696783,
-0.6756182313,
-0.4880604148,
0.6859811544,
-0.3394005895,
-0.2920526266,
0.3783976734,
-0.0670513213,
0.6685349345,
0.2861384451,
0.6150832176,
0.2446165085,
0.1131824926,
-0.3728494346,
0.666559577,
-0.1998153776,
0.2037222385,
-0.524335742,
-0.3832350671,
-0.0173532609,
0.8138512969,
-0.1086670235,
-0.02411188,
0.1627860516,
1.0560159683,
0.2985213697,
0.2508293986,
0.3719287813,
0.2358942032,
0.3397985697,
0.567926228,
0.847782433,
-0.2148336768,
0.8117312789,
-0.2414685786,
-0.38097772,
-0.1614968926,
-0.8621442318,
-1.057608366,
-0.2601446211,
-0.4809219241,
-0.5573040247,
0.5990706086,
0.7638192177,
0.6714199781,
-0.598252058,
0.0376812033,
-0.2731649876,
-0.0787452161,
0.042098172,
-0.2764821947,
0.2192717642,
-0.3356612623,
-0.5114156604,
0.4076189697,
0.2315253764,
0.3914162815,
0.0735542923,
-0.2751455307,
0.0986885354,
0.3105394542,
0.6600728035,
0.010067353,
-0.1203543618,
-0.583163023,
-0.2899225056,
-0.0846777335,
-0.1674919277,
0.5731703043,
-0.2645191252,
0.377928108,
0.2340009809,
0.5530989766,
-0.172907576,
0.0016093397,
0.7986525893,
-0.979362011,
0.1576271504,
0.4642442167,
0.0561057813,
0.5432116389,
-0.8089901805,
0.6199328899,
0.0991539285,
-0.6125972867,
-0.675834775,
0.373064816,
-0.748149097,
-0.2322298586,
1.1321735382,
-0.3313375711,
0.1645984948,
-0.4535515904,
-0.5005213618,
0.3907510042,
-0.7315043807,
1.0123281479,
0.2981934845,
-0.1569033563,
-0.0282914266,
-0.2888631523,
0.6995307803,
0.5169701576,
-0.9621192813,
0.4575100243,
0.7342097759,
0.2335993052,
0.1124441475,
0.7899354696,
-0.0463842154,
0.4602787495,
0.126043424,
-0.4087248445,
0.0301105231,
-0.3750015199,
-0.3384661376,
0.0625478178,
-0.1513405293,
-0.2682425082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00421v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00421v2
|
From PARIS to LE-PARIS: Toward Patent Response Automation with Recommender Systems and Collaborative Large Language Models
| 2024-02-01T08:37:13 | 2024-03-05T03:45:22 |
Jung-Mei Chu, Hao-Cheng Lo, Jieh Hsiang, Chun-Chieh Cho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In patent prosecution, timely and effective responses to Office Actions (OAs)
are crucial for securing patents. However, past automation and artificial
intelligence research have largely overlooked this aspect. To bridge this gap,
our study introduces the Patent Office Action Response Intelligence System
(PARIS) and its advanced version, the Large Language Model (LLM) Enhanced PARIS
(LE-PARIS). These systems are designed to enhance the efficiency of patent
attorneys in handling OA responses through collaboration with AI. The systems'
key features include the construction of an OA Topics Database, development of
Response Templates, and implementation of Recommender Systems and LLM-based
Response Generation. To validate the effectiveness of the systems, we have
employed a multi-paradigm analysis using the USPTO Office Action database and
longitudinal data based on attorney interactions with our systems over six
years. Through five studies, we have examined the constructiveness of OA topics
(studies 1 and 2) using topic modeling and our proposed Delphi process, the
efficacy of our proposed hybrid LLM-based recommender system tailored for OA
responses (study 3), the quality of generated responses (study 4), and the
systems' practical value in real-world scenarios through user studies (study
5). The results indicate that both PARIS and LE-PARIS significantly achieve key
metrics and have a positive impact on attorney performance.
|
[
-0.3125277162,
-0.6800796986,
0.8688932061,
0.042977985,
0.0549447052,
0.1969998032,
0.1693992913,
-0.6418328881,
0.5060790181,
0.540030539,
-0.0443060696,
-0.211998865,
-0.5000811219,
0.1647975296,
-0.323145628,
0.4577160478,
-0.05475742,
0.2178696692,
0.1605327576,
0.019216653,
-0.4257869124,
-0.7292199135,
-0.6265551448,
-0.3639183342,
0.6217892766,
0.3096051216,
0.2100444734,
0.1765429378,
0.7955577374,
0.345582962,
0.0436165929,
0.0291876514,
-0.1981921345,
-0.1724135429,
-0.1314658076,
-0.3209922016,
-0.9211504459,
0.0626238957,
0.0274717472,
0.6300275922,
-0.0545831732,
-0.1831613779,
-0.2759661674,
0.8715949059,
-0.5751315355,
-0.10420423,
-0.5963565111,
0.1282755286,
0.393682301,
-0.1569264829,
-0.3439905047,
-0.0601914153,
0.5314017534,
-0.5178280473,
0.0321519971,
0.4692468345,
0.4713508189,
-0.0444178283,
-0.1804462671,
-0.2997966111,
-0.9788300395,
0.5449743867,
-0.5960498452,
0.0341247134,
-0.0159947556,
0.2327450812,
-0.4837750793,
-0.7807351947,
-0.720313251,
-0.4557724893,
0.1352294087,
0.2451834679,
-0.13626948,
-0.1702099741,
0.1241928041,
0.2036700994,
-0.5523640513,
0.1955266148,
-0.5674443841,
-0.086585924,
0.7653162479,
-0.1056994274,
0.1280764639,
0.2166346163,
-0.2367404997,
-0.0651786178,
-0.6117303967,
-0.0293529723,
0.4033665955,
0.4399732053,
0.270902276,
0.8115918636,
-0.1350693703,
0.5053220391,
0.0088142231,
0.233898133,
0.1237725094,
-0.4096315503,
-0.2996703684,
0.1419641674,
0.8703557849,
0.2724077106,
0.2765939236,
-0.1668033451,
-0.2961725891,
-0.3441686332,
0.4313879907,
-0.6859115362,
-0.0526084341,
0.6435977817,
-0.5599598885,
0.011267269,
0.2788057923,
-0.6837592125,
-0.6866140962,
-0.6218373179,
0.3356987238,
-0.1683945954,
-0.1465100497,
0.2139235139,
-0.2324214727,
0.1628777236,
0.5210677981,
-0.6428040862,
0.4570020735,
0.9228910804,
0.7765017748,
-0.313473165,
-0.2037226111,
-0.7995454073,
-0.0034949908,
-0.2293574661,
0.9879994392,
-0.4499641657,
-0.6631199718,
0.1378188878,
-0.0605561286,
-0.2184286714,
-0.7362237573,
0.4435289204,
-0.7752786279,
0.1599599868,
-0.1354585439,
-0.3498311043,
0.0864730179,
0.3157697022,
-0.4427015185,
0.4133045375,
-0.2099882364,
-0.5721955895,
0.4888181686,
-1.0571157932,
-0.3767323494,
-0.1756715178,
-0.2723877132,
-0.2288312912,
0.1927485168,
0.2720385194,
0.4417238832,
-0.3054738343,
0.1104730666,
-0.3875277936,
-0.1265096068,
-0.037529815,
0.1890529841,
0.5440002084,
0.3170657456,
-0.2884800136,
0.3535417914,
-0.8881911635,
-0.4089521766,
0.342300117,
-0.1207642034,
-0.1837577671,
-0.0772583485,
-0.0764281154,
0.2797189951,
0.3973903656,
-0.8677912951,
0.1725626886,
-0.6013988256,
0.4979813397,
0.7487456799,
-0.0342686772,
0.2454030812,
-0.2901281714,
0.3255957067,
-0.1477551311,
-0.0426162407,
-0.2036028802,
-0.5038477778,
-0.6307590008,
-0.1881530285,
-0.016919557,
0.7870771289,
-0.2215108871,
0.6802130342,
-0.4805401266,
-0.3114989996,
-0.0788300186,
-0.0688154325,
-0.0939898044,
0.5418158174,
0.103830725,
-0.6272550821,
-0.2598564327,
-0.8806236386,
-0.1673460901,
-0.2808361053,
-0.045863837,
0.5793771148,
0.6811330318,
0.0363812335,
1.0342817307,
-0.526833117,
-0.1658905298,
-0.3324347138,
0.265440315,
0.4349201918,
-0.018562492,
0.7572637796,
-0.8013586402,
-0.4423365295,
0.2920765281,
-0.4426101446,
0.0008620608,
0.3053482771,
0.0042618583,
0.214723289,
0.5008851886,
-0.2817414999,
0.6205872893,
-0.1129865944,
-0.2910955548,
0.329020083,
-0.3717651367,
0.2565927207,
-1.1739060879,
0.4263092577,
-0.1136852875,
-0.044336345,
-0.5717664957,
-0.2649703026,
-0.2951943278,
-0.529191494,
-0.6707693934,
0.7058053017,
0.0382407717,
-0.2731107175,
-0.4692914188,
0.2152772397,
-0.075535208,
0.3234242797,
-0.0031343123,
0.885624826,
0.320422411,
-0.6139845252,
0.5930515528,
0.2402553409,
0.0039606872,
0.6883060336,
-0.8852510452,
0.3059273064,
-0.0120918658,
0.2335422188,
-1.0359646082,
-0.3146713376,
0.0400009938,
0.0422130749,
0.1473653615,
0.146612823,
-0.7013781071,
-0.804191947,
-0.4729693532,
-0.0488082804,
0.2036106288,
-0.467892319,
1.0352960825,
0.4319511354,
-0.5592036843,
-0.473756671,
-0.4352293611,
0.3423392773,
-0.2140703201,
-0.5541625619,
0.1327081919,
-0.1838704497,
-0.4826619327,
-0.0670366064,
0.2095317543,
-0.1174325496,
-0.0238391552,
0.2279905826,
0.0747404173,
0.0532525852,
-0.0691533983,
-0.3755938709,
-0.1147066951,
0.056363523,
-0.309812367,
0.7416269183,
0.048380509,
-0.5174415112,
-0.6820203662,
0.3263373077,
0.956928432,
-0.2227638513,
0.4532039464,
0.2050132751,
-0.1775756925,
0.0233612657,
-0.3705439866,
-0.2583421171,
-0.4615534246,
0.122521013,
-0.3273060322,
-0.6066393256,
0.5197196007,
-0.2782593668,
0.3315628469,
0.4113095999,
0.7287204862,
0.2831897736,
0.6959296465,
0.9672712088,
-0.4224723577,
0.5913081765,
-0.2898368537,
0.971216917,
-0.6504656672,
-0.1922180057,
-0.625448525,
-0.306157887,
-0.2177402526,
0.0922978669,
0.5390763283,
-0.2457370162,
-0.1524684578,
0.453899622,
-0.3828566372,
0.1561857313,
0.7521024346,
-0.2434069812,
0.3178750873,
0.2388375849,
-0.22802791,
0.3276474178,
-0.586030364,
-0.7515684962,
1.3734515905,
0.3901427686,
0.5556311011,
0.0480550267,
0.7254032493,
0.257848084,
0.1078491211,
-0.931227088,
0.750502944,
-0.213007018,
-0.1118935943,
-0.2290134579,
0.141068235,
-0.8180684447,
-0.063490279,
-0.0073486711,
-0.9269649982,
0.4292633235,
-0.0881130099,
-0.978808701,
0.0814998448,
-0.7811819911,
0.3976345062,
-0.3457863629,
-0.5303713679,
-0.4695946574,
-0.3840311468,
-0.0834143311,
-0.4064999521,
0.1131149158,
-0.0960214287,
0.0858275145,
0.471039176,
-0.6093049645,
0.7095553279,
0.1229815483,
-0.5213587284,
0.1939629018,
-0.0996774584,
0.625379324,
-0.1787907183,
-0.43626526,
-0.3063169122,
-0.2265531272,
-0.0318063535,
-0.5234267712,
0.9644326568,
-0.5345344543,
-0.6753156781,
-0.4574367404,
-0.6542589068,
-0.2329330891,
0.4476485252,
-0.0313734859,
0.2668415606,
-0.3344689012,
-0.0250192005,
0.3087207973,
-0.2832449079,
0.6151542664,
0.8023514748,
-0.1661147475,
-0.6728942394,
0.829223752,
0.1809381843,
-0.1083099544,
0.3635318577,
0.1277903318,
-0.3133134842,
-0.659330368,
-0.1494327188,
0.2750702798,
-0.4600879252,
0.2365914732,
-0.8055350184,
-0.0690910444,
-0.7644813061,
-0.0535352305,
-0.2229667753,
-0.5020911694,
-0.0576446317,
0.1504914016,
0.1883623302,
0.7828030586,
0.1101666242,
-0.1869281381,
-0.6478150487,
0.3651546538,
0.58456707,
0.1848213226,
-0.0666076243,
-0.3388761878,
0.0255391765,
-0.1960457861,
-0.5502873659,
-0.2108626366,
0.1999646872,
0.2226244509,
0.3498930931,
0.4084653854,
0.1520319134,
0.3059500456,
-0.9352217317,
0.8855729103,
-0.2090092152,
-0.4839384854,
0.8970272541,
-0.4436493516,
-0.1513999104,
0.2475778162,
0.2252239287,
0.0424595959,
-0.2318546325,
-0.5341538787,
-1.0929789543,
0.7377424836,
0.0849047452,
0.3142309487,
0.2674668729,
0.5472003222,
-0.2213423848,
0.4520491958,
-0.1992621124,
0.0278999284,
0.2741827369,
0.1413484961,
0.182757467,
0.0779000595,
-0.61798352,
0.181062147,
0.6798847318,
-0.0392207652,
0.2659062147,
0.4307015538,
0.4155731797,
-0.0383104421,
0.2608921528,
0.765825808,
0.865701139,
-0.243734166,
-0.2118839025,
-0.117833823,
-0.3139734864,
-0.013789054,
0.3428421021,
0.1343167424,
-0.3723869026,
0.4155883789,
0.3590482473,
-0.5545965433,
-0.8477941155,
0.4448232353,
-0.1319032311,
-0.2090644389,
-0.2425368428,
0.0994295627,
-0.4007607698,
0.3199869394,
0.4171712995,
-0.0272636004,
0.3288989961,
-0.7426306009,
0.2614969313,
0.4261346161,
-0.3745909929,
-0.1429305971,
0.5842045546,
0.4621352553,
-0.3533043265,
-0.0021754398,
0.0465504713,
-0.5149511695,
0.8440089226,
0.3340619504,
1.000428319,
0.183364436,
-0.1268445998,
0.0865990072,
0.1201232821,
-0.1695911288,
0.3066547215,
0.1329642087,
-0.5487098694,
-0.1095638424,
-0.1967893988,
-0.5392460823,
0.3174904287,
-0.2373267263,
0.2175165415,
-0.8347409368,
-0.2570228875,
-0.0361247286,
0.0948678702,
-0.448553443,
-0.0906018615,
-0.1396901459,
1.0168813467,
-0.7102086544,
0.3835172057,
0.9424538016,
-0.3528304398,
-0.4561901093,
0.2972420156,
0.0447549932,
-0.6437914371,
0.9795103073,
0.0530357696,
-0.5773569942,
-0.2511341274,
-0.2962724268,
-0.4674590528,
1.0654240847,
0.2278383523,
-0.6717367768,
0.5995883942,
0.2342820168,
0.8550772667,
-0.5371858478,
-0.0413543917,
0.6527103186,
0.1158798411,
0.2624142468,
-1.2043793201,
-0.308221668,
-0.4202032983,
0.033162009,
-0.1365477592,
-0.7764977813,
0.5001415014,
-0.3320428133,
0.0498556979,
0.4636782408,
0.5758579373,
0.2040156424,
0.5489871502,
0.2230986059,
0.7171922922,
0.530590415,
-0.0526617467,
1.271009326,
-0.7100350857,
-0.0405760184,
0.9901522398,
-0.9397367835,
1.2367489338,
0.5415818095,
-0.2008371502,
0.2684099078,
0.3940799236,
0.0674664304,
0.5023860931,
0.2807095051,
-0.3369652927,
0.0506711714,
-0.7963020205,
-0.2343625128,
0.0310684238,
0.2596658766,
-0.3703412116,
-0.0297410376,
0.1959112734,
-0.2755252421,
0.207400769,
-0.1405960172,
0.826151371,
0.0614476055,
-0.5327093005,
0.1334225684,
-0.1025075316,
0.1890973896,
-0.3444772363,
-0.0901356414,
-0.1317203939,
0.4314984679,
0.0142633542,
-0.6770410538,
0.1068470702,
0.1303234398,
-0.1988852322,
-0.166042462,
0.3834165931,
0.0062818327,
-0.454964757,
0.4917761385,
0.3660736084,
-0.0150086926,
0.1420801729,
-0.6688823104,
-0.1049561203,
-0.5210002065,
-0.1924374104,
0.0860647708,
0.5210089087,
-0.1119171754,
0.7270166874,
0.6071072817,
0.2868201733,
-0.1375831515,
0.3335800767,
1.016446352,
-0.1280278713,
-0.4685150683,
-0.4819495678,
0.3019662499,
-0.2586595714,
-0.0059674936,
0.4708285332,
0.5897365212,
0.2611118257,
-0.0693361536,
0.8800333738,
-0.1010514721,
0.7767361999,
-0.4554784298,
0.3147036135,
-0.4131046832,
0.6894171834,
-0.3719677031,
-1.1211577654,
-0.6287796497,
0.4425362051,
-0.6195126772,
0.0403721631,
0.4622115493,
0.9044210911,
-0.1613032967,
-0.3038288057,
0.1193312928,
0.166623652,
0.9358529449,
0.334939152,
0.5717670918,
-0.5613529682,
0.1582132876,
0.0225870963,
-0.2054477483,
-0.3927842081,
-0.9256882668,
-1.0157489777,
-0.2654254735,
-0.1692050993,
-0.1359386593,
-0.0289751161,
1.1177736521,
0.5242385864,
-1.169554472,
-0.2286364436,
-0.4044909477,
-0.1962355226,
0.2424854338,
-0.172948882,
0.6990014911,
-0.3428405225,
-0.9230728745,
0.6492284536,
0.912622869,
0.251736939,
-0.2208072245,
0.0345852822,
-0.0661723837,
0.2458214164,
0.5862715244,
0.5712271333,
-0.7010886669,
-0.2323352844,
0.1803675145,
-0.0068715401,
-0.0669492036,
1.0195189714,
-0.5898137093,
0.726375103,
0.7397677302,
0.7469135523,
-0.2144044042,
-0.0062591149,
1.1842620373,
-0.3297995031,
0.3570453823,
0.1559187621,
0.6423977613,
0.0314927883,
-0.1925436854,
0.6605777144,
0.1112988144,
-0.4645629525,
-0.4548242688,
0.1780640334,
-0.6729525328,
-0.1409124732,
0.8516166806,
-0.2578958869,
-0.1175295934,
-0.2877777517,
-0.6113719344,
-0.2863794863,
-0.5701538324,
1.1509362459,
0.8616124988,
-0.5788670778,
0.2335154861,
-0.422223866,
0.131915912,
0.2676146328,
-0.9728983641,
-0.1047760621,
0.4135174453,
-0.1658754498,
0.852458179,
0.6635373235,
-0.0725931227,
0.2260477692,
-0.455735594,
-0.220543012,
-0.0429519825,
-0.7409034967,
-0.3729096949,
0.130829379,
0.1894175857,
-0.0547830984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00414v1
|
Prompt-Time Symbolic Knowledge Capture with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-01T08:15:28 | 2024-02-01T08:15:28 |
Tolga Çöplü, Arto Bendiken, Andrii Skomorokhov, Eduard Bateiko, Stephen Cobb, Joshua J. Bouw
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Augmenting large language models (LLMs) with user-specific knowledge is
crucial for real-world applications, such as personal AI assistants. However,
LLMs inherently lack mechanisms for prompt-driven knowledge capture. This paper
investigates utilizing the existing LLM capabilities to enable prompt-driven
knowledge capture, with a particular emphasis on knowledge graphs. We address
this challenge by focusing on prompt-to-triple (P2T) generation. We explore
three methods: zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting, and fine-tuning, and
then assess their performance via a specialized synthetic dataset. Our code and
datasets are publicly available at https://github.com/HaltiaAI/paper-PTSKC.
|
[
-0.1933601499,
-0.8582792878,
1.057992816,
0.2423611432,
-0.0776612535,
0.0898506641,
-0.0607413836,
-0.2147482485,
-0.1610085368,
0.324511528,
-0.5504711866,
-0.462547034,
-0.5577396154,
0.4505666196,
-0.1000408381,
0.707223773,
-0.2889936566,
-0.5001008511,
-0.0147676263,
0.1960389167,
-0.6830750704,
-0.5025310516,
-0.8658435941,
-0.2491002977,
0.7987003326,
0.6809111834,
0.5203573704,
0.4170435071,
-0.1019860879,
0.0982655883,
0.1487667114,
0.5183520913,
-0.2985578477,
0.4316625595,
0.1783208102,
-0.3492454886,
-0.3218086958,
-0.0276492406,
0.8977212906,
0.5558753014,
0.4119847119,
0.2088459432,
0.0560200438,
0.3702661991,
-0.4754724503,
0.6179288626,
-0.386705637,
0.0883026943,
-0.2392966002,
-0.26710549,
-0.5827766657,
-0.4645358324,
-0.0476979166,
-0.7861139774,
-0.1349247098,
0.0847497284,
0.4700074494,
0.2476496994,
-0.7902703285,
-0.0976162478,
-0.7436598539,
0.492660135,
-0.7007882595,
0.2078110278,
0.5304048061,
0.6583688259,
-0.1850342155,
-0.9368711114,
-0.8214918375,
-0.4096718431,
-0.0840434283,
-0.021291649,
-0.3033859134,
-0.1027164459,
0.6242694855,
-0.1516972333,
-0.4315885305,
0.1662880629,
-0.3326745331,
-0.1715219021,
0.4566049576,
0.4737356603,
0.1915733814,
-0.2917484045,
-0.2115988135,
-0.101995267,
-0.9135399461,
0.1277708858,
0.4300280511,
0.5351406336,
-0.0928435624,
0.9562979937,
-0.3137444258,
1.0020583868,
0.1268389374,
-0.1273196191,
-0.045955658,
-0.595506072,
0.0999027863,
-0.100371629,
0.8934783936,
0.3081715405,
0.2714235187,
-0.1268663555,
-0.1365852356,
-0.197854951,
-0.0847833082,
-0.7093655467,
-0.2672616839,
0.1902730018,
0.0105066625,
-0.3046789765,
-0.1021416262,
-0.5193836093,
-0.4994641542,
-0.4195083678,
0.2133129239,
-0.5207791924,
-0.1591410041,
-0.0567512736,
-0.2728663683,
0.391235292,
0.4325706065,
-0.5736064911,
-0.0094838822,
0.5450981855,
1.0477725267,
-0.1642550677,
-0.3917650282,
-0.8513441682,
0.497508049,
-0.4132894874,
0.7569177747,
-0.3239194751,
-0.2728523016,
0.0952739939,
-0.3133708537,
0.0663987994,
-0.1813301742,
0.1535538584,
-0.6154156923,
0.4024080932,
-0.6378927827,
-0.5358504057,
-0.0026010112,
0.4067626894,
-0.5113934875,
1.2206004858,
0.3912783861,
-0.7150467038,
0.3498025537,
-0.6288917661,
-0.6385503411,
0.2232750356,
-0.202204898,
-0.0786779672,
-0.2553693354,
0.4902081788,
0.7580428123,
-0.2428429276,
0.2566831112,
-0.305532515,
-0.1554861218,
0.0390076675,
-0.2489324063,
0.7573478818,
0.2170804292,
-0.221809864,
0.0814709514,
-0.6318278313,
-0.106971778,
0.3496020138,
-0.3762227297,
-0.0560124405,
-0.2155164033,
-0.4447398782,
0.5237150788,
0.3094159961,
-0.374610275,
0.5973377228,
-0.1454019994,
0.5369064212,
0.6891171336,
0.3574106693,
0.2807802558,
-0.3116251528,
0.7104318142,
-0.0937427878,
-0.1167863905,
-0.3812906146,
-0.5876692533,
-0.4689379036,
-0.1385457665,
0.0309207756,
0.5744175315,
-1.2631120682,
0.400873363,
-0.2317197323,
-0.33923316,
-0.1376484931,
0.09728764,
0.316416353,
0.7489216328,
0.2683513761,
0.1650936902,
-0.3677612543,
-0.6688435078,
-0.2103048563,
-0.5253537893,
-0.3938570917,
0.5202276707,
0.2450034469,
0.0870966315,
1.1950515509,
-0.6265312433,
-0.1253239065,
-0.4747163653,
0.3084623218,
0.1189875752,
0.2026350051,
0.519248426,
-0.2366591096,
-0.5132623911,
-0.3114144206,
-0.9236026406,
-0.4115623236,
-0.1634807289,
-0.0189921763,
0.219876796,
0.6251040101,
-0.8851155639,
0.1865395606,
0.3113044798,
-0.5476816297,
0.6627659798,
-0.0586077534,
0.2595895231,
-1.3286833763,
0.2296606749,
-0.0820892081,
-0.3452498317,
-0.6683214903,
-0.1700758338,
0.1196376458,
-0.3694369495,
-0.6031084657,
0.9680482149,
-0.6090468168,
-0.2465423346,
-0.1825651079,
0.2931331396,
-0.1302554607,
0.6158859134,
0.0484541692,
0.7951982021,
0.3693353832,
-0.6548953652,
0.5611590147,
0.2827082872,
-0.0432348847,
0.5956434011,
-0.7046813965,
0.5473008156,
0.0735461712,
0.5260891318,
-1.0204119682,
-0.6013421416,
0.491565764,
-0.4712992907,
0.2750795186,
-0.2323267609,
-1.0357447863,
-0.5772565603,
-0.354116261,
0.4731413722,
0.5985568762,
-0.6587418318,
0.5601686835,
0.1505196393,
-0.3059796989,
-0.2089413702,
-0.4252955019,
0.3249640167,
-0.102293767,
-0.757730484,
0.0428522788,
0.1855705827,
-0.0936347321,
-0.1919200569,
0.1779415458,
0.3985917866,
-0.1166544557,
0.1839402765,
0.1208339185,
-0.0824997425,
0.0747804418,
0.23636204,
-0.2116541713,
-0.0234277267,
-0.6726431251,
0.6007130742,
0.1010256857,
-0.3529115319,
-0.8867106438,
0.4474977553,
0.5462044477,
-0.1291477084,
0.5499894619,
0.5490048528,
-0.3455712497,
0.0314817913,
-0.5037125349,
-0.3094906807,
-0.4153473973,
0.0662861541,
-0.4350461662,
-1.0820436478,
0.3756148815,
-0.0814426318,
0.1937748641,
0.3273641467,
0.7173206806,
-0.1377268732,
1.2225302458,
0.3299998641,
0.0117602581,
0.4410382509,
-0.0857212171,
0.1799345165,
-0.6124514341,
-0.2621462047,
-0.5432422161,
-0.2711541951,
-0.1497330815,
-0.4050847888,
0.674247086,
0.0963712409,
-0.4978331625,
0.2329674512,
-0.0893490762,
0.3852202892,
0.8600298166,
0.0045215194,
0.3469856977,
0.0717790425,
-0.0051476457,
0.1373578459,
-0.91480726,
-0.4662940502,
1.0369132757,
0.2264687568,
0.4885260165,
0.0672128201,
0.5190911293,
0.2782858014,
-0.2461441904,
-0.8025733232,
0.6996526718,
0.1279371828,
-0.1912437677,
-0.4249321222,
-0.5745639205,
-0.8354821801,
-0.3136841953,
0.0238728076,
-0.610670507,
-0.191120863,
0.5230908394,
-0.7952558994,
0.2407209128,
-0.839707911,
0.657225132,
-0.144051075,
-0.2220191956,
0.0513052717,
-0.8041580319,
0.5675779581,
-0.0668690428,
-0.3295550048,
-0.1349726021,
-0.0542328097,
0.6799013615,
-0.3070514202,
1.1633882523,
-0.5521911979,
-0.0583562069,
0.4097957909,
0.4223410487,
0.8765208125,
0.0687249601,
0.204984501,
0.0010923221,
-0.133608833,
-0.4387096465,
-0.6848727465,
0.4852017462,
-0.7328221202,
-0.4388226271,
-0.2758823037,
-0.7356712222,
-0.6399128437,
0.135214299,
0.1384450942,
0.3759900928,
0.1196248904,
-0.1757209003,
0.3243423998,
-0.3202156126,
0.3401516676,
0.5202679038,
-0.2003898621,
-0.2784369588,
0.7208298445,
0.1406440735,
0.2773966789,
0.3304328024,
0.2541558444,
-0.5615022182,
-0.3033519685,
-0.5065225959,
0.3315625489,
-0.4600747228,
-0.4822784364,
-0.7829344869,
-0.0589588135,
-0.8742500544,
-0.208061263,
-0.0615614094,
-0.7102387547,
-0.3664469421,
-0.2450770587,
0.7039433122,
0.7333235741,
-0.1722400188,
0.5789151788,
-0.9291975498,
0.4893575013,
0.6580143571,
-0.0556825809,
-0.1925359368,
-0.3783864975,
0.1088314503,
-0.1969241202,
-0.009774697,
-1.0864510536,
0.2325083464,
-0.0401273146,
0.4058519006,
0.2131328583,
0.1225983873,
0.4956479371,
-0.3201647103,
1.2052044868,
0.2858196199,
-0.7108050585,
0.9143233299,
-0.5673930645,
0.6132694483,
0.2793348432,
0.308665961,
-0.7879015803,
-0.4232059419,
-0.3892175555,
-0.750446856,
1.0254081488,
0.1980308443,
-0.1074693725,
-0.0474668331,
0.4329934716,
0.0404569209,
-0.0000378453,
-0.2957774401,
0.0831805468,
-0.1487517357,
-0.3158442974,
0.029442111,
-0.4444444478,
-0.1584313214,
-0.0922635198,
0.5056226254,
-0.3956111372,
0.2077819407,
0.0176789593,
0.0053114272,
0.0488636717,
-0.0043815626,
0.4641132057,
0.3865562081,
0.1357929856,
0.3781147599,
0.0778989941,
-0.1441701055,
0.1476059258,
0.1985616833,
-0.468123734,
-0.2547546327,
0.4091428518,
0.8870891929,
0.0423473194,
-0.4419899881,
0.33090657,
-0.079955034,
-0.0554047227,
-0.2186953872,
0.0492603295,
-0.1260485053,
0.41697523,
0.18461743,
-0.2787687182,
-0.2689372599,
-0.2140072882,
0.0538836829,
0.2213854194,
-0.0215590354,
-0.5748310089,
0.5906709433,
0.2469355315,
-0.3448582292,
0.9500446916,
-0.391476512,
-0.438798964,
0.29728055,
0.6263597012,
0.790573895,
-0.181432277,
0.3044521213,
0.5788221955,
0.1538762003,
0.0410834998,
0.2523318529,
-0.4597196281,
-0.6436186433,
-0.4962658882,
-0.2372192591,
-0.252169162,
0.0338367298,
-0.2508178651,
0.479916662,
-0.4401352108,
-0.1019517258,
-0.3642172515,
0.0673049763,
-0.7409052253,
-0.4164069891,
0.1039311066,
0.9484823942,
-0.8370158076,
0.8377413154,
0.4379709065,
-0.449018985,
-1.2551665306,
-0.0601758473,
0.3535200655,
-1.0668091774,
0.6501336694,
-0.1178674325,
0.0240310188,
0.2997481227,
-0.5583828688,
-0.4925086796,
1.3062212467,
0.6010298729,
-0.3428183198,
-0.4600497484,
0.3639016449,
0.2709769309,
-0.2126639634,
0.0141611705,
0.9529698491,
0.6684524417,
0.3042984605,
-0.9188494086,
0.1057970524,
0.0156611782,
0.0359366089,
0.0397042409,
-0.3620298207,
0.6858217716,
-0.3905521333,
-0.282725662,
-0.1526419371,
0.5673677325,
0.7577052116,
0.234186098,
0.4861336648,
0.4544860125,
0.7367633581,
0.0768319964,
1.1950926781,
-0.334607631,
-0.0315606371,
1.1923130751,
-0.4440763593,
0.5581038594,
0.5264456272,
-0.0564743839,
-0.0366976522,
0.651759088,
0.121675007,
0.2544368804,
-0.2470860481,
-0.4125702977,
-0.3495358527,
-0.2388605624,
-0.3270069063,
0.2743569016,
0.2671250105,
-0.1266450733,
-0.3227729499,
0.0142641654,
0.272759676,
-0.3313945234,
-0.1509688646,
1.0139322281,
0.1460926086,
-0.9697003961,
0.4073904455,
-0.0832133591,
0.2509423196,
-0.6637260318,
-0.187543273,
-0.4451523721,
-0.2277471274,
0.0854265988,
-1.1230336428,
0.0772551,
0.3074896932,
-0.0104109244,
-0.6255723834,
0.824074626,
-0.4452627301,
-0.2804165781,
0.0230276398,
0.8096058965,
0.1739266366,
-0.1952145845,
-0.235388115,
-0.1663184911,
-0.0408643559,
-0.1864097714,
0.151284799,
0.5086432099,
-0.0814695209,
0.48295632,
0.6825054884,
0.0983878449,
0.1994052976,
0.1421563476,
0.7554798126,
-0.5286118388,
-0.529676199,
-0.8074680567,
0.4035351276,
0.0155136101,
-0.2564135492,
0.7536187172,
0.415455848,
0.6012906432,
-0.1384911537,
0.8889796734,
-0.1683430821,
0.5533986688,
-0.7284713984,
0.5576666594,
-0.2209108174,
0.0376664065,
-0.0199248474,
-0.6867664456,
-0.4458510876,
0.1656715721,
-0.3164782226,
-0.0701031238,
0.4128655195,
0.8657175899,
0.0208113994,
-0.180490464,
0.2916203439,
0.2746372819,
0.6516379714,
0.8584079742,
1.1295571327,
0.0286574364,
0.5951460004,
-0.1591725498,
-0.2765339315,
-0.1408263594,
-0.987875104,
-0.8970380425,
-0.8315317631,
-0.2262373269,
-0.4727752209,
-0.0019891453,
0.9387640357,
0.6353906989,
-0.5299316049,
0.0567666106,
-0.1260317415,
-0.0097541697,
-0.0962662175,
-0.1727153957,
0.4696281254,
-0.452937752,
-0.5434889793,
0.5874956846,
0.1516754776,
0.2591521144,
-0.2334896624,
-0.1892464012,
0.1767925918,
-0.1819835901,
0.8936077952,
0.5047748685,
-0.5716372728,
-0.3582852781,
0.1766117066,
0.0373354852,
-0.1853329092,
1.3403358459,
-1.0617698431,
0.3578595817,
0.6388089061,
0.5904517174,
0.5884833336,
-0.0693666637,
0.8030785322,
-1.2601783276,
0.0071372502,
0.3775243461,
0.3406457603,
0.306883812,
-0.3533680439,
0.3471230567,
0.3804841638,
-0.3475319743,
-0.7948670387,
0.3541592658,
-0.9820268154,
-0.0400439762,
1.5270451307,
-0.0981840342,
0.0613742396,
-0.185615629,
-0.4058451355,
0.5831110477,
-0.5339754224,
0.5785689354,
0.5543138385,
-0.3315552175,
-0.1862563193,
-0.3811456859,
0.4167529941,
0.0143812913,
-0.9619549513,
0.3413715959,
0.9133427739,
0.1367145181,
-0.1408627182,
0.9662795663,
-0.0656566471,
0.3049834371,
-0.1076894104,
-0.1605154276,
-0.6320137978,
-0.5521582961,
-0.3833315074,
0.3484069705,
0.2083916366,
0.0445220843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00412v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00412v1
|
Hidding the Ghostwriters: An Adversarial Evaluation of AI-Generated Student Essay Detection
| 2024-02-01T08:11:56 | 2024-02-01T08:11:56 |
Xinlin Peng, Ying Zhou, Ben He, Le Sun, Yingfei Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable capabilities in text
generation tasks. However, the utilization of these models carries inherent
risks, including but not limited to plagiarism, the dissemination of fake news,
and issues in educational exercises. Although several detectors have been
proposed to address these concerns, their effectiveness against adversarial
perturbations, specifically in the context of student essay writing, remains
largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by constructing
AIG-ASAP, an AI-generated student essay dataset, employing a range of text
perturbation methods that are expected to generate high-quality essays while
evading detection. Through empirical experiments, we assess the performance of
current AIGC detectors on the AIG-ASAP dataset. The results reveal that the
existing detectors can be easily circumvented using straightforward automatic
adversarial attacks. Specifically, we explore word substitution and sentence
substitution perturbation methods that effectively evade detection while
maintaining the quality of the generated essays. This highlights the urgent
need for more accurate and robust methods to detect AI-generated student essays
in the education domain.
|
[
-0.4407372177,
-1.0317507982,
0.6556741595,
-0.2380251586,
0.0257976744,
0.3050885201,
-0.0208196081,
-0.204717353,
0.0733816996,
0.4862279296,
-0.3648487329,
-0.5944184065,
-0.7542205453,
0.2370889336,
-0.8285831213,
0.9898707867,
-0.0584739745,
-0.0370211489,
-0.2738482952,
0.2227616757,
0.0931640267,
-0.4899967909,
-0.9216956496,
-0.0772012249,
0.4773209393,
0.22107099,
0.4426326454,
0.6298008561,
0.3210860789,
0.2292179614,
0.1384672672,
0.0463403948,
-0.0701712519,
0.1182168052,
0.2832711935,
-0.2438589334,
-0.1403894871,
0.3007305861,
0.9234981537,
0.2778192461,
0.0886095166,
0.0307760574,
0.1027127653,
0.157528013,
-0.6536055207,
-0.2912344337,
-0.8314259052,
0.0624822788,
-0.3866160512,
-0.0671725199,
-0.6164304614,
-0.1775179952,
-0.2895188928,
-0.2741789818,
0.2894542515,
-0.1534321904,
0.8530077338,
0.3856996,
-0.2470186353,
-0.4168501198,
-0.4310586154,
0.5473906994,
-0.6793371439,
-0.2466237992,
0.383641392,
0.2327418327,
-0.4455618262,
-0.6315885782,
-0.8441946507,
-0.3320236802,
-0.1085020751,
0.3150906563,
-0.2270371467,
0.3287844956,
0.0829092041,
0.3648675978,
-0.7768163085,
0.1512221843,
0.0297329165,
-0.2810249627,
0.5963342786,
0.0848506019,
0.6174792051,
-0.2893730998,
-0.3643645644,
-0.1158535108,
-0.5582901239,
-0.0808210373,
1.1909350157,
-0.0299832877,
0.4881806374,
0.5006889701,
0.2135367692,
0.3072158098,
-0.0261095297,
0.0670713559,
-0.4870294631,
-0.0951995552,
0.0082429945,
0.0523086004,
0.8345348835,
-0.0409184359,
0.0982882157,
-0.1905587614,
-0.3066999316,
0.4560224414,
0.3662942648,
-0.4900980294,
-0.4058569372,
-0.038279105,
-0.3368367553,
-0.6734848619,
0.1705256701,
-0.7655810118,
-0.3940565586,
0.078420952,
0.5955215096,
-0.2842797637,
0.2248035669,
-0.2418823987,
-0.0556687787,
0.1571565717,
0.1196101308,
-0.4320168197,
0.2944487333,
0.517280817,
0.4963059425,
-0.3810352683,
-0.4815513194,
-0.5574567318,
0.0053999182,
-0.3631274104,
0.9149585962,
-0.523930788,
-0.5301015377,
-0.0256750993,
-0.1477752328,
-0.157509625,
-0.271764189,
0.7413432002,
-0.1577487588,
0.5374373794,
0.0929047167,
-0.6814411879,
-0.0683891699,
0.2880887687,
-0.3892149925,
0.9488811493,
-0.0861599967,
-0.6925274134,
0.0292368699,
-0.3270003498,
-0.6272985339,
0.01511689,
-0.3805633187,
-0.817825377,
0.1467585862,
0.5000434518,
0.5408558249,
0.1045441851,
0.0874921978,
-0.1136574149,
-0.7463544607,
0.2114627808,
-0.9816014171,
0.6842560172,
0.0457277149,
-0.4196635783,
-0.04943984,
-0.8077033162,
-0.1922608912,
0.2880642414,
-0.4608887434,
-0.3278764784,
-0.1378254294,
0.0488796569,
-0.0923201814,
0.1058410704,
-0.3369106948,
0.1341532618,
-0.2111004293,
0.1102643758,
1.0619444847,
0.2326242924,
0.0900136903,
-0.2714540362,
0.834402144,
-0.3443920612,
-0.0402181223,
-0.680280447,
-0.3604994714,
-0.7759114504,
-0.3756923974,
0.1366546899,
0.4906014502,
-1.0064104795,
0.5127554536,
0.2445362508,
-0.2590751946,
-0.6646429896,
-0.0277856383,
0.5779950023,
0.5184460878,
0.3942319155,
0.1849792004,
-0.3827072978,
-0.6992855668,
-0.7832368016,
-0.3032996953,
-0.1625145972,
0.1597156823,
0.5258554816,
-0.1366356611,
0.4396741092,
-0.5011912584,
-0.2389372736,
-0.1918332875,
0.3619151115,
-0.4427539408,
0.5685937405,
0.6699009538,
-0.4316887558,
-0.7371186018,
-0.5285670757,
-0.6971896291,
-0.3376922011,
-0.5571724772,
0.091713734,
0.3832887709,
0.6775863767,
-0.5846523046,
0.7787200809,
0.3991912007,
-0.4516260326,
0.8051788807,
0.0249670856,
0.3744242489,
-1.0638170242,
-0.0203326177,
0.0007236229,
-0.2666859031,
-0.4536430538,
0.3945341408,
-0.185326159,
-0.2194911391,
-0.0542075373,
0.5281934142,
-0.3687701821,
0.2338581383,
-0.608635664,
-0.066504471,
-0.0124264844,
0.2754566967,
-0.3864360154,
0.9867189527,
0.4260576367,
-0.1605874002,
0.1072086245,
0.0972855911,
-0.0790931359,
0.5322213769,
-0.5229190588,
0.3474782407,
-0.2103927732,
0.6073041558,
-1.3546670675,
-0.3465471864,
0.2371962965,
-0.8361282945,
0.3708393276,
-0.1521961242,
-0.4669113755,
-0.3570865393,
-0.5362204909,
-0.1060844585,
0.4363219142,
-0.857019186,
0.7088928223,
0.0631941706,
-0.0170149934,
-0.6959141493,
-0.607275784,
0.652402401,
-0.3787702322,
-0.3678821027,
0.1329511404,
-0.0724113807,
-0.3566941619,
0.0840702355,
-0.0462864339,
0.2262605429,
0.4175730348,
0.2667700946,
0.3989224136,
-0.208473146,
-0.0679673254,
0.1296108216,
-0.1154490188,
0.2739314139,
-0.4306133687,
0.3710605502,
0.2513067126,
-0.4486416876,
-0.6533782482,
0.5359649062,
0.4969491661,
0.1443683505,
0.8223210573,
0.6925439835,
-0.5260345936,
-0.5759981275,
-0.653021872,
-0.3061282337,
-0.511828959,
0.213313818,
-0.0233905129,
-0.5085960031,
0.3249168694,
0.2183027118,
0.0699009448,
0.3795726597,
0.1391266584,
-0.1269474626,
1.1310172081,
0.3619228601,
-0.2433582246,
0.4204064906,
0.0010394463,
0.352904737,
-0.6681644917,
0.1059714034,
-0.7163072824,
-0.1205284894,
-0.3827179968,
-0.1347933263,
0.3667318225,
-0.1317278743,
0.129008159,
0.2220025212,
-0.5663778186,
0.7391896844,
0.492218256,
-0.0184755456,
0.1758327931,
0.1028385907,
0.0300792959,
-0.0301402956,
-0.3519709408,
-0.9196745157,
1.4403195381,
0.1584463865,
0.543694675,
-0.28925246,
0.6784945726,
0.5905004144,
0.3374842703,
-0.4922776222,
0.9357268214,
-0.6173261404,
-0.2808090746,
-0.0373769552,
-0.2674883604,
-0.5980277658,
0.2741690278,
-0.283075422,
-0.6146216393,
-0.3371689022,
0.1510687619,
-0.3458390832,
0.499058038,
-0.6077736616,
0.5542087555,
-0.0268944539,
-0.5248042941,
-0.0355914608,
-0.1910510361,
0.2885451615,
-0.0113813141,
-0.1380753815,
0.159161821,
0.2418453544,
0.5913684964,
-0.1843364388,
0.4857480526,
-0.1131236479,
0.0824876055,
0.5518119931,
0.2112425566,
0.773357451,
0.1752984971,
-0.0524112731,
0.0497407392,
-0.580560267,
-0.4051891565,
-0.2824464142,
1.0202976465,
-0.5853335857,
-1.0305224657,
-0.4663146436,
-0.4033615887,
-0.0748302042,
0.0535607785,
0.5817387104,
0.1170521006,
-0.1970975995,
0.1355942488,
0.6192205548,
-0.3649889231,
0.5816626549,
0.2767542005,
0.0514739975,
-0.2409485281,
0.9660057425,
0.0884649307,
0.0943708122,
-0.1403373778,
0.1291335821,
-0.1984319389,
-0.7101836205,
-0.4986738265,
0.0120321484,
-0.7449306846,
0.0741646215,
-0.9169977307,
-0.3071588576,
-0.7745195627,
-0.6117507815,
-0.0970506072,
-0.354550302,
-0.6102936864,
-0.2180951983,
-0.1095826775,
0.4951502383,
0.2245290428,
0.4106892347,
-0.2533278763,
0.1941156834,
0.2977419198,
-0.1160469651,
0.0189521667,
-0.6321624517,
0.0313591585,
-0.218356356,
-0.3450061679,
-0.6481609344,
0.3394105434,
-0.0408319794,
0.4933122098,
0.5051540732,
0.1076968908,
0.5086101294,
-0.2308345735,
1.1320896149,
-0.2708235085,
-0.8385163546,
0.4560501277,
-0.4500624835,
0.1700425297,
0.4760604799,
0.3075960875,
-0.100570485,
-0.8465869427,
-0.7001289129,
-0.9184728861,
0.4638534784,
0.2112180442,
0.2142218649,
0.1254823357,
0.6791065335,
0.060964305,
0.2814653516,
-0.7522548437,
-0.1584971547,
-0.1281822324,
-0.4126898944,
-0.1015331969,
-0.1581101865,
-0.0578525737,
0.0618570223,
0.8290950656,
-0.0831130445,
0.0637404248,
0.1995073855,
0.1874713451,
-0.0394624397,
-0.0023718209,
0.4782721996,
-0.1064129472,
0.2404502481,
0.3367316127,
0.0034977358,
-0.6207597256,
0.0578629784,
0.2797648013,
-0.4878872931,
0.0462622307,
0.509346962,
0.4742485881,
-0.4559978843,
-0.7198385,
0.5355175138,
-0.1993563771,
-0.0944883302,
-0.7433339953,
0.3699715734,
-0.3487393558,
-0.0621984787,
0.5751027465,
0.2016482353,
0.2442944497,
-0.5200668573,
0.2545368969,
0.7730163932,
-0.1595884562,
-0.3346097469,
1.0194519758,
-0.0485566147,
-0.3113507926,
0.5222934484,
-0.0533097647,
-0.7697632909,
0.90265131,
0.5103981495,
1.1738427877,
-0.4572016001,
0.1607274264,
0.2073417604,
0.5025203228,
-0.082412973,
-0.1623261273,
0.1401701868,
-0.387498498,
0.0469372496,
-0.507956326,
-0.3728867173,
0.7699505091,
-0.3170892894,
0.269317627,
-0.6423290372,
0.1178955138,
0.0167486276,
-0.086284861,
-0.2092578858,
0.2328951508,
0.2376294285,
0.3505035043,
-0.8212686181,
0.586561501,
0.8414491415,
-0.1529558748,
-0.5513169169,
0.8933560848,
0.4058333337,
-0.4723965824,
0.0329154097,
0.3470762968,
-0.2845435441,
0.0811799988,
-0.7266936898,
-0.2999176979,
0.6515149474,
0.0826409981,
0.0033140876,
-0.057741601,
0.1682953387,
0.7249174118,
-0.2102776915,
0.0297507942,
0.5017068982,
0.4907493591,
-0.0567403771,
-0.0928751007,
-0.0082092388,
-0.2067506015,
-0.2070398629,
-0.1410480887,
-0.6705100536,
1.0302972794,
-0.0089935912,
-0.3737303913,
0.1700221151,
0.4158939123,
-0.0470202453,
0.4628792405,
0.2606332004,
0.5487200022,
0.4598337412,
-0.2018108964,
0.9322673082,
-0.177653864,
-0.0886338204,
0.8764990568,
-0.1851602048,
0.5093848109,
0.4061045945,
0.0667465851,
0.2134580463,
0.3706652522,
-0.3176653385,
0.0544295609,
0.238674894,
-0.6088897586,
-0.220264852,
0.03801677,
-0.0267920233,
0.6088875532,
0.3915656507,
-0.4258394241,
0.051989913,
0.2623536289,
0.4003566802,
0.7274632454,
-0.2497460395,
0.6556417942,
-0.1718978733,
-1.0398623943,
0.377907455,
0.2017225772,
0.7552812099,
-0.5259094834,
-0.1929813027,
-0.4395938218,
0.4038340449,
-0.1291638911,
-0.5351451039,
0.2443223745,
0.3474802971,
0.2098361254,
-0.1971595734,
0.9777168632,
-0.4271082878,
-0.4528658092,
0.1073464081,
-0.035669148,
0.0437375382,
0.0167120118,
-0.4112402797,
-0.0815714002,
-0.0576859042,
-0.5205363035,
0.4868989885,
0.0614231974,
0.188727513,
0.4696626365,
0.7217798829,
0.1108943075,
0.0301051103,
-0.3954059184,
0.7175272703,
-0.2353000045,
-0.5003933907,
-0.9237158895,
0.2507821918,
0.0190509968,
-0.222273916,
1.2815343142,
0.5449233055,
0.7589139938,
0.0525450222,
1.1963683367,
0.3349936306,
0.4443553388,
-0.5185968876,
0.9729748964,
-0.5679212809,
0.5283229351,
-0.4976617396,
-0.6402711868,
-0.3683432639,
0.6349955797,
-0.0992356241,
-0.087258473,
0.5602951646,
0.5804254413,
0.1290932,
0.0159547515,
0.385655731,
0.1596234292,
0.6434541941,
0.3326812387,
0.8195895553,
-0.6964281201,
0.6620133519,
-0.0417699777,
-0.0625191033,
-0.1421448141,
-0.6884128451,
-1.2779966593,
-0.4243872762,
-0.474242866,
-0.6184907556,
0.4503393173,
0.551541388,
0.0569047183,
-0.7418979406,
0.1806860864,
-0.2903596163,
0.1275467724,
-0.0375447944,
-0.2920974493,
0.5672565103,
-0.0414921045,
-0.9937521815,
0.773609817,
0.1545982957,
0.3858388662,
-0.6756131649,
0.3154014349,
-0.186367631,
0.7197592854,
0.048946742,
0.2125981897,
-0.5513141155,
-0.4588263631,
-0.1903817803,
-0.2906831503,
-0.2848640978,
0.6678115726,
-0.7375919819,
0.2648551464,
0.3944786489,
0.7925970554,
-0.0788566247,
0.1921294928,
0.2517201602,
-0.7925604582,
0.1442250609,
0.2955367267,
0.2266773283,
0.3629998565,
-0.8605006337,
0.3743450046,
0.5004112124,
-0.6662763953,
-1.1290024519,
-0.0087444335,
-0.2136036307,
-0.6818945408,
0.9704931378,
-0.5192391872,
-0.0765461773,
-0.0139551945,
-0.1948817074,
0.1695340574,
-0.3108740747,
1.3473215103,
0.9883131981,
0.0532292873,
0.0638329387,
-0.4927789569,
0.6804283857,
0.4299081564,
-0.9959396124,
-0.0932883322,
0.5188341141,
0.0845930874,
0.0569877326,
0.3490428627,
0.027078744,
0.2383574694,
0.3106451035,
-0.1251240373,
-0.2485606819,
-0.6231017709,
-0.3664298356,
0.4009560049,
-0.3950229585,
-0.207211569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00402v1
|
Investigating Bias Representations in Llama 2 Chat via Activation Steering
| 2024-02-01T07:48:50 | 2024-02-01T07:48:50 |
Dawn Lu, Nina Rimsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We address the challenge of societal bias in Large Language Models (LLMs),
focusing on the Llama 2 7B Chat model. As LLMs are increasingly integrated into
decision-making processes with substantial societal impact, it becomes
imperative to ensure these models do not reinforce existing biases. Our
approach employs activation steering to probe for and mitigate biases related
to gender, race, and religion. This method manipulates model activations to
direct responses towards or away from biased outputs, utilizing steering
vectors derived from the StereoSet dataset and custom GPT4 generated gender
bias prompts. Our findings reveal inherent gender bias in Llama 2 7B Chat,
persisting even after Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). We
also observe a predictable negative correlation between bias and the model's
tendency to refuse responses. Significantly, our study uncovers that RLHF tends
to increase the similarity in the model's representation of different forms of
societal biases, which raises questions about the model's nuanced understanding
of different forms of bias. This work also provides valuable insights into
effective red-teaming strategies for LLMs using activation steering,
particularly emphasizing the importance of integrating a refusal vector.
|
[
-0.4033229351,
-0.6775282025,
0.3694028854,
0.4915160835,
-0.1504353434,
0.3614753187,
-0.2643805444,
-0.6833462715,
0.2365836352,
0.3967011571,
-0.8605784774,
-0.1960066706,
-0.8402231336,
0.0766832829,
-0.3237194419,
0.9317541122,
0.0935686454,
0.3311429918,
-0.0184955597,
-0.0687658563,
-0.8067708611,
-0.5393281579,
-0.6376271248,
-0.8376035094,
0.5097658634,
0.3704517484,
0.6035841703,
0.4160137177,
0.1492178887,
0.2100257874,
-0.3849027157,
0.0249162782,
-0.9948425293,
0.340525955,
-0.1081164628,
-0.6460251808,
-0.3342140019,
0.2175689936,
0.5033174753,
0.5870248079,
-0.1253745705,
0.2953726351,
0.2542528808,
0.4419516027,
-0.5192242861,
0.3702685535,
-0.9404842257,
-0.0521306209,
-0.1128243506,
-0.1424047947,
-0.4299712479,
-0.1870440841,
0.2179641724,
-0.4955529273,
0.0947331563,
0.0444111191,
0.4958446622,
0.3902250528,
-0.6137131453,
-0.4740401208,
-0.6508997083,
0.9402928352,
-0.3284014463,
0.1601511538,
0.5327391624,
0.1990227848,
-0.4230043292,
-0.0851676092,
-0.4818259478,
-0.1508527845,
0.1424578428,
-0.0122305276,
-0.1458197534,
-0.0402337536,
0.2229325771,
-0.3077335656,
0.0077381274,
0.4431992471,
-0.5571420193,
-0.231610477,
0.6053170562,
-0.0146435816,
0.2228403389,
-0.085779421,
-0.4240297675,
-0.1181204841,
-0.9897646308,
-0.1691845208,
0.6291618943,
0.1755934358,
-0.2536477745,
0.6840063334,
-0.1184042916,
0.2281167656,
0.424144417,
-0.0322516039,
0.447539866,
0.0608187132,
-0.0385124721,
0.4707050323,
0.5282641053,
0.6219022274,
0.316630125,
0.142288506,
0.0043395697,
0.3750375211,
0.3404888809,
-0.4777472913,
0.2913843989,
0.1263690889,
-0.5247485638,
-0.5799722672,
-0.2605353892,
-0.7972370386,
-0.7982082963,
-0.1993374676,
0.0220076311,
-0.0193533283,
-0.6130273342,
-0.2056859285,
-0.2532936633,
0.573941648,
0.366792798,
-1.0550211668,
0.0106065553,
0.7916314602,
0.5301609635,
-0.3150101602,
-0.1714710593,
-0.2552317381,
0.27153337,
-0.3690062165,
0.6058328152,
-0.736320734,
-0.5596802235,
0.1266088337,
-0.2018975765,
0.234906435,
-0.7241440415,
0.4260809422,
-0.6949824095,
-0.0034487804,
-0.6642534733,
-0.161901325,
-0.2826013565,
0.2684573829,
-0.5125697851,
1.1242948771,
-0.2806957364,
-0.8128414154,
0.6064966321,
-0.7739720345,
-0.147670269,
-0.1503672898,
-0.4952993095,
-0.310023874,
0.1075585261,
0.336904794,
0.233986944,
-0.2911091447,
0.3906113505,
-0.4777432084,
-0.3299235106,
0.2374803126,
-0.4600998163,
0.6794016957,
-0.1767044216,
-0.7860213518,
0.3598905206,
-0.307823658,
-0.5214089751,
0.2279940695,
-0.257586211,
-0.3961373866,
0.2201986611,
-0.1902641058,
0.2014837563,
0.0257577673,
-0.4001962245,
0.1195882261,
-0.3258007467,
0.3805849552,
1.1048415899,
-0.0524298064,
0.8363278508,
-0.1861940324,
0.5430787802,
0.1392255723,
0.0660269186,
0.2487479597,
-0.7732004523,
-0.7531983256,
-0.100131385,
-0.0512920693,
0.381515801,
-0.7247288227,
0.0635551587,
-0.2120928317,
-0.256765753,
-0.5571032166,
0.2209140509,
0.3975911438,
0.3675262332,
0.2171617746,
-0.4039753079,
-0.5509740114,
-1.114926219,
-0.14152354,
-0.5276845098,
-0.0145282364,
0.2859628201,
0.5339864492,
-0.4088483155,
0.9719570875,
-0.0836103857,
-0.2566888034,
-0.5776661634,
0.3736723661,
0.015074526,
0.2567902207,
0.5312845707,
-0.8084581494,
-0.0152270161,
-0.1872955263,
-0.7182683945,
-0.5252361298,
-0.035806179,
-0.3993352056,
0.2536022961,
0.4379433095,
-0.4400884807,
0.6353292465,
0.7999882102,
-0.4336206913,
0.4345935285,
0.3382067382,
0.0834567323,
-0.5830870271,
-0.2982509434,
0.0336683504,
-0.0354390554,
-0.5794460773,
-0.3707703948,
-0.0536343008,
0.37283355,
-0.545655489,
0.4853702784,
-0.5533806086,
-0.3956801295,
-0.4173294306,
0.0080968086,
-0.4058082402,
0.448410362,
0.2780313194,
0.838260293,
0.1838126183,
-0.614171505,
0.0298384223,
0.4559096992,
-0.2612159848,
0.4108741283,
-0.6838057637,
0.2833633125,
-0.4482750893,
0.6172177792,
-0.9895703793,
-0.212781921,
0.6177707911,
-0.4708389044,
0.0720876083,
-0.3195398748,
-0.1762906015,
-0.2552479208,
-0.3233819008,
0.5673567057,
0.5252348185,
-0.5560578704,
0.6147115231,
0.7932258248,
-0.1980410814,
-0.7637176514,
-0.6262311339,
-0.1283683777,
-0.3862245381,
-0.418764174,
0.2255596071,
0.2202023715,
-0.3918381333,
-0.4417921603,
-0.0865743309,
0.3018615842,
0.0309714116,
0.6639570594,
0.3028658926,
0.2331027389,
0.0005919827,
0.3752270043,
-0.0168993026,
0.3826218545,
-0.0140828043,
0.9456651807,
0.1968889683,
-0.5974242687,
-0.3004225791,
0.2053514123,
0.5322499275,
0.0666980743,
0.7187922597,
0.5156453252,
-0.0521894842,
-0.0160252545,
-0.7707670331,
-0.5292883515,
-0.4860072732,
0.6043437719,
-0.0271971934,
-1.0922393799,
0.609107852,
-0.0826619193,
0.1996425837,
0.1926997155,
1.1031345129,
-0.1457274258,
1.0246458054,
0.4505490065,
-0.3550994396,
0.6386150718,
-0.1959433109,
-0.1431754678,
-1.0093636513,
-0.5085901618,
-0.3469199836,
-0.6840091348,
-0.4799081981,
-0.7390344739,
0.4290051162,
-0.098650381,
-0.4735623002,
-0.163241446,
-0.2980540395,
0.3505215943,
0.4804798663,
0.179162994,
0.1064257622,
0.2008809745,
-0.0350331739,
-0.1354173422,
-0.6510109305,
-0.4732531309,
1.1411665678,
0.6957579255,
0.8158607483,
0.0558884554,
0.5468429327,
0.464020431,
0.7485838532,
-0.5515552163,
0.6112722158,
0.5998238325,
-0.8010804057,
-0.1975130886,
-0.2576016188,
-0.9744267464,
0.3816863596,
-0.2612632513,
-0.7519804239,
0.3525089025,
0.2035752684,
0.1828837395,
0.1312895864,
-0.5858319402,
0.3133882582,
-0.1278316975,
-0.4749399722,
-0.4436704218,
-0.5609859824,
0.6142898798,
0.1853185594,
0.4457275569,
-0.3788369894,
-0.0322406478,
0.9353193641,
0.0745988116,
1.4814852476,
-0.2618736625,
-0.3999299705,
0.2239465714,
0.2120984942,
0.5560408235,
0.1244930401,
-0.1614958793,
0.5188391805,
-0.6286128163,
-0.3383116424,
-0.2931053638,
0.5506981611,
-1.0688704252,
-0.8041667342,
-0.434412539,
-0.5768157244,
-0.1742733866,
-0.1807911098,
-0.0450762436,
0.012688891,
-0.2038026154,
-0.1621014178,
0.5975086093,
-0.3944408894,
0.2747828364,
0.2927183509,
-0.399063617,
-0.1893788129,
0.3873229325,
-0.2498355955,
0.6056792736,
-0.1044480503,
-0.0404614285,
-0.4004335999,
-0.3271743357,
-0.5095458031,
0.2984366417,
-0.728518188,
-0.0575496629,
-0.4637432098,
-0.0228636228,
-0.2819096148,
0.0294701923,
-0.359292835,
-0.240125224,
-0.3632618189,
-0.4255870283,
0.3234691918,
1.1084835529,
-0.0239352975,
0.4994331598,
-0.2623132467,
0.2464997768,
0.3126010001,
-0.0125848884,
0.2952824235,
-0.6026248336,
0.2522168458,
0.2905274332,
-0.4919737875,
-1.3286569118,
0.3932785988,
-0.2305719703,
0.6745576262,
0.3594554663,
-0.1249406561,
0.4506039321,
-0.4133443534,
0.8708619475,
0.250490129,
-0.8283527493,
0.5043117404,
-0.4770024717,
0.1636880636,
0.2445397973,
0.4719041288,
-0.3926913142,
-0.5610647202,
-0.4054245353,
-0.8307625651,
0.7058292031,
0.199249655,
0.3298146427,
-0.0896022394,
0.3346768916,
0.0606332868,
0.3380605578,
-0.8972637057,
-0.4553182423,
-0.053175047,
0.0835517868,
0.2288792729,
-0.7068386674,
-0.2522587478,
-0.1450518072,
0.6932846308,
-0.1362119913,
0.4085406065,
0.0258725397,
-0.2449376136,
-0.1946360469,
0.2827588022,
0.5857084394,
0.5594034195,
0.0346698873,
-0.0603120923,
0.4806382954,
-0.5642507672,
0.2648122013,
-0.4153293967,
-0.3455733061,
-0.1766135395,
0.2844365537,
0.8219177127,
0.3723010123,
-0.4321858883,
0.2967602313,
0.1086822674,
-0.2003958374,
-0.1058529466,
-0.0474537648,
0.0851649046,
0.4137194157,
0.5623466969,
-0.0433126427,
0.0145745948,
-0.5301292539,
-0.2078614831,
0.5546306372,
-0.6166555882,
-0.2386321425,
0.716755867,
0.539081037,
-0.0820624754,
0.5910461545,
-0.1492246985,
-0.9915664196,
0.5538591743,
0.5359496474,
0.6394503713,
-0.1255207807,
0.4127013087,
0.3222628534,
0.4214957654,
-0.0329295024,
0.1189386621,
-0.0786595345,
-1.0375138521,
-0.6127412319,
-0.4584241211,
-0.4465626478,
-0.1517228037,
-0.6238660812,
0.2169286311,
-0.326651603,
-0.4723930955,
-0.3626160026,
-0.3018579483,
-0.6184034348,
-0.4049319625,
0.4907440245,
0.7289192677,
-0.9912551045,
0.6127085686,
0.5075072646,
-0.1946519166,
-0.6542207599,
-0.0792773664,
0.514102757,
-1.2195271254,
1.2771331072,
0.2366547436,
-0.1743205339,
-0.2774268687,
-0.7561186552,
-0.8073360324,
1.1088086367,
0.3293665648,
-0.5834235549,
0.085149996,
0.2802436054,
0.2199285179,
-0.4010423124,
0.5930140615,
0.8420751095,
0.5207868814,
0.188934654,
-1.2035095692,
0.0514096953,
0.0549861155,
0.2138634473,
-0.1366063654,
-0.6471837163,
0.461396277,
-0.1751319766,
-0.0580432676,
-0.3026471436,
0.9064397812,
0.7187939286,
0.1159554869,
0.7865092158,
0.2044623941,
0.6498453021,
-0.1153105497,
0.9386608601,
0.0769502297,
0.0240813456,
0.9835019708,
-0.5474963188,
0.6934326887,
0.8650316596,
-0.103037551,
0.6641503572,
0.4526797533,
0.4333087206,
0.3916702569,
0.4604833126,
-0.3081613481,
-0.1834516376,
-0.3064804971,
-0.3915846944,
0.5293486714,
0.6235182285,
-0.3350447118,
-0.148518756,
-0.0703900754,
0.1280868798,
-0.089806512,
-0.3901333511,
0.8310512304,
0.0891078115,
-0.771803081,
0.3561224937,
-0.1181364134,
1.0399446487,
-0.6033003926,
-0.1585833728,
-0.1579952836,
-0.0630462542,
-0.0828818455,
-0.7158862948,
0.0894120783,
0.0442412756,
-0.3098286986,
-0.3746420443,
0.6885974407,
-0.4137727022,
-0.2551585436,
0.6228518486,
0.3752467632,
-0.0953188092,
0.076119706,
-0.6841068268,
0.651119709,
0.2742750645,
-0.3364404738,
0.4675242603,
0.0598138683,
-0.3775674105,
0.9768502116,
0.7696875334,
0.156453684,
0.3163967431,
0.2390735298,
0.9415957928,
-0.4211091995,
-0.4580968022,
-0.8991641998,
0.3109309375,
-0.1950278133,
-0.0763172358,
0.5967011452,
0.1344970018,
0.7619438171,
0.0582745075,
0.86563164,
0.0948423818,
0.3345011473,
-0.3832736313,
0.7569392323,
-0.0985730067,
0.5119026899,
-0.2120722383,
-0.9172163606,
0.1124177948,
0.7465204,
-0.6530947089,
0.0366176069,
0.1938432604,
0.9147216678,
0.217176944,
0.1816321611,
-0.0625787303,
0.4090851545,
0.5891850591,
0.4492490292,
1.3106933832,
-0.0440001562,
0.5063962936,
0.1471185982,
-0.3719911873,
-0.2340282351,
-0.870603919,
-1.0696328878,
-0.2832149565,
-0.1838779896,
-0.4747437239,
0.1425385475,
1.225407958,
0.6940574646,
-0.6032981873,
-0.4347570539,
0.208665669,
0.4166887701,
-0.0041097128,
-0.2241055667,
0.0060046092,
-0.2179685086,
-0.6855692267,
0.1838605404,
0.1949178576,
-0.0814023316,
-0.5434692502,
-0.2955597341,
-0.2009675652,
-0.2252956927,
0.5927756429,
0.2042855024,
-0.8914410472,
-0.3464345634,
-0.2791916728,
0.1026671901,
-0.0338297114,
0.7525498271,
-1.012467742,
0.1242355257,
0.2820684612,
0.5114968419,
0.5083343983,
-0.0328367315,
0.9756013751,
-0.6116315126,
0.4112257361,
0.1667686552,
0.1422048807,
0.324929446,
-0.1251838803,
0.3886475265,
0.0985915884,
-0.5056977868,
-0.7982724905,
0.2193288058,
-0.8964253664,
0.0440003797,
1.6544783115,
0.3770444691,
-0.2870891392,
-0.2826168835,
-0.626897037,
0.2450259477,
-0.7539541721,
0.7986184359,
0.5880005956,
0.0144520905,
-0.0995345488,
-0.6776427031,
0.5158666372,
0.6447591782,
-0.5159186721,
0.138007313,
0.5293405056,
0.3546128571,
0.041677542,
0.7001529336,
-0.0824195892,
0.2271780223,
-0.3467202485,
0.1229789406,
0.126937896,
-0.115741767,
-0.2733486891,
-0.0398541465,
0.0355557129,
0.0202075932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00396v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00396v2
|
Efficient Exploration for LLMs
| 2024-02-01T07:32:24 | 2024-06-04T18:35:09 |
Vikranth Dwaracherla, Seyed Mohammad Asghari, Botao Hao, Benjamin Van Roy
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME, stat.ML
|
We present evidence of substantial benefit from efficient exploration in
gathering human feedback to improve large language models. In our experiments,
an agent sequentially generates queries while fitting a reward model to the
feedback received. Our best-performing agent generates queries using double
Thompson sampling, with uncertainty represented by an epistemic neural network.
Our results demonstrate that efficient exploration enables high levels of
performance with far fewer queries. Further, both uncertainty estimation and
the choice of exploration scheme play critical roles.
|
[
-0.0562283993,
-0.6339071989,
0.9549869299,
0.1563630104,
0.1353364885,
0.2611161172,
-0.5303314924,
-0.5120537281,
0.2254992276,
0.2509141862,
-0.6045407057,
-0.467238158,
-0.6993725896,
-0.095757708,
-0.1510353386,
0.4092316926,
-0.0059007774,
-0.0660292655,
0.0685486943,
0.1335504502,
0.0580547601,
-0.5377523899,
-1.1683040857,
-0.4147899449,
0.8347555399,
0.3462899327,
0.7180564404,
0.5483595133,
0.5199460387,
0.3772391081,
-0.3370968401,
0.5218711495,
-0.7663546205,
0.5877079368,
-0.1682949811,
-1.0137969255,
-0.0662515089,
-0.0692038983,
0.5708999038,
0.6943721771,
-0.63310498,
-0.0506840944,
-0.0655358136,
0.5682019591,
-0.6989012361,
0.2280244976,
-0.4134791493,
0.2870926559,
-0.1589889675,
-0.5575671792,
-0.3313582838,
-0.4234412909,
0.6296459436,
-0.9090608358,
-0.118969284,
0.0235619862,
0.5458541512,
0.2277345806,
-0.4707475901,
-0.4914506674,
-0.8716310263,
1.0832716227,
-0.2636692822,
0.3521945775,
0.4246484339,
0.4988260865,
-0.3440448344,
-0.9041052461,
-0.2148642242,
-0.4362792969,
0.0800212994,
0.1082807779,
-0.2967807651,
0.3176097572,
0.1673165411,
0.1757066846,
-0.140957728,
0.422911942,
-0.217544049,
-0.3633018732,
0.9455102682,
0.3502493501,
0.1893059313,
0.1084923595,
-0.3200494051,
-0.3202403784,
-0.831273973,
0.4640548825,
0.4990568757,
0.21263735,
0.3706766963,
0.808711946,
-0.3499202132,
0.8080313802,
-0.3616051972,
-0.0094391368,
-0.2104012817,
-0.2867762446,
-0.044507686,
-0.3137454987,
0.6337485909,
0.3132640123,
0.158185333,
-0.4202815592,
-0.71676296,
-0.1453789324,
0.2849392593,
-0.5980989933,
-0.1784342229,
0.3946264684,
-0.2313688695,
-0.2897818089,
0.0606187135,
-0.6943610311,
-0.5479544997,
-0.2353476584,
0.3945371807,
-0.3045892119,
-0.344317466,
0.248814255,
-0.5105406642,
0.0446267352,
0.68287462,
-0.8153808117,
0.3375315368,
0.5789289474,
0.6913034916,
-0.2762185931,
-0.2381723225,
-0.6213544607,
0.0734145567,
-0.5063758492,
0.9201658964,
-0.5068856478,
-0.4548604786,
0.1906870753,
-0.2548339963,
0.0614355281,
-0.7390758991,
0.5294071436,
-0.9696035385,
0.2042618841,
-0.4702842832,
-0.7302950621,
-0.3384219706,
0.3676974177,
-0.7474156618,
1.3084400892,
0.2945373356,
-0.3280883133,
0.2939509153,
-1.0769660473,
0.0888752267,
0.0923941061,
0.0480438285,
0.1308780611,
0.3106793761,
0.3785556555,
0.2760744393,
-0.3108281791,
0.1370055079,
0.0401141122,
-0.5700083971,
0.6138395667,
-0.238416642,
0.5300505161,
0.4414438903,
-0.4542236328,
0.131075114,
-0.4237292707,
0.3052790463,
0.2367838472,
-0.6942538023,
-0.3469881713,
0.3429747224,
-0.102286607,
-0.2103981227,
0.267444551,
-0.426618278,
0.3262170553,
-0.4952054024,
0.2796086967,
0.9217954874,
0.1626042277,
0.5802606344,
-0.4654588699,
0.9631993175,
-0.1736357063,
-0.1225441173,
-0.2128108144,
-0.338019073,
-0.8280795217,
-0.2246753275,
0.4813578725,
0.5411920547,
-0.7248319387,
0.2792417705,
-0.163068071,
-0.3642572761,
-0.7193878889,
0.1469221264,
0.0936361179,
-0.2071095556,
0.1083381325,
-0.1070113182,
-0.4533990026,
-0.7454236746,
-0.3945619166,
-0.2535780966,
-0.3158669174,
0.6667253971,
0.0369484648,
-0.4318361878,
0.902182281,
-0.4862642586,
0.1167757511,
-0.3102367818,
0.0010343206,
0.1552700698,
0.0993048772,
0.1402048767,
-0.6567395926,
-0.4109117687,
-0.1951832771,
-0.7725784779,
-0.0507069416,
-0.2098463476,
-0.4277088344,
0.0870485976,
0.3086625338,
-0.8474346995,
0.2787150145,
0.2637387514,
-0.1790656298,
-0.0293424204,
-0.1635862738,
0.003706607,
-0.638305366,
-0.1640263349,
-0.0482176095,
-0.5065748692,
-0.447050631,
0.4023939669,
-0.0322777666,
0.3123238683,
-0.3136267066,
0.4403660893,
-0.8652377725,
-0.1180341393,
-0.3250827193,
0.5567259192,
-0.1996401697,
0.4568361044,
-0.0418160707,
0.7751694322,
0.6628074646,
-0.8270207644,
0.6899099946,
-0.2254322469,
-0.3532703221,
0.0929696634,
-0.6489009261,
0.4137488902,
-0.1264439821,
0.0075033056,
-1.1449424028,
-0.1086728573,
0.1127364188,
-0.4589380622,
0.4137701392,
0.1294573247,
-0.5054343343,
-0.3857225776,
-0.685836494,
-0.0562695339,
0.4932196736,
-0.7892885208,
0.4237669408,
0.6169236898,
-0.196023643,
-0.7375770211,
-0.5581884384,
0.17544204,
-0.1411125064,
-0.7080418468,
0.1233365387,
0.0069573624,
-0.4691978991,
0.0164045691,
-0.0352897421,
0.2722343802,
0.3890381455,
-0.0598650835,
0.0313238651,
-0.0657474697,
0.2849875391,
0.0391041636,
0.1032509729,
0.3311673403,
-0.4169446528,
0.6829337478,
0.0099483822,
-0.3099768758,
-0.5239821076,
0.3781590164,
0.1643651426,
0.1485022604,
0.3687757254,
0.3099478483,
-0.3040502667,
-0.3144373894,
-0.4984737039,
-0.4099566638,
-0.5069136024,
0.5307519436,
-0.3116934896,
-1.0833683014,
0.5399602652,
-0.2140349597,
0.1800462902,
0.5300643444,
0.6420603395,
-0.2841744423,
1.0281531811,
0.7181966305,
0.0585379824,
0.4029147029,
-0.5522068739,
-0.1381280571,
-0.682582736,
-0.3819127679,
-0.3552913666,
-0.6289131641,
-0.5967472792,
-0.5651956201,
0.4388168752,
0.0268061254,
0.1346858293,
-0.0105669731,
-0.5239675045,
0.4696497619,
1.0897088051,
0.2636722922,
0.2506179214,
0.1277290881,
-0.2563492954,
-0.1582837701,
-0.8201415539,
-0.5776210427,
1.5613369942,
0.372446388,
0.9853743315,
0.5347352624,
0.9196797013,
0.1731272042,
0.2479263991,
-0.9675558805,
0.4953123927,
0.7370869517,
-0.6988535523,
-0.7629672289,
-0.5246773362,
-1.3188385963,
0.3691771924,
-0.1528578103,
-0.8508847952,
0.0837844536,
0.0797200128,
-0.7590645552,
0.2788397968,
-0.7108021975,
0.173699826,
-0.2586018443,
-0.5352743864,
-0.3441017866,
-0.6841583252,
0.2071763873,
0.0542045683,
-0.2948278189,
0.2207283974,
-0.4844416976,
0.8086465001,
-0.2893187702,
0.6356626153,
-0.5634136796,
-0.0940191597,
0.6241912842,
0.1882584691,
0.9077013731,
0.2157110423,
-0.0598696321,
-0.4081692398,
-0.2722828984,
-0.2949183285,
-0.8330093622,
0.422211647,
-0.9011176229,
-0.8742733002,
-0.5208297968,
-0.7366354465,
-0.2735677958,
-0.1544453949,
0.165913105,
-0.0849231929,
-0.0997258499,
0.1167943999,
0.7833967209,
-0.2601257563,
0.5773531199,
0.5752780437,
-0.3184480369,
-0.0587970391,
0.3978101313,
0.2817781568,
0.0891819894,
0.5992779136,
0.1376803219,
-0.6716679931,
-0.6652674079,
-0.4653896093,
0.0923870802,
-0.4665823281,
-0.2137444317,
-0.9166437387,
-0.1065121144,
-0.1660097986,
0.1382356435,
-0.3767183125,
-0.6872166991,
-0.145050928,
-0.4099877477,
0.3578556478,
1.0317230225,
-0.3768234253,
0.6946089864,
-0.7934054732,
-0.0552629419,
0.6563510299,
0.1312662065,
0.0027307342,
-0.4316267669,
-0.3132379651,
0.2625228465,
-0.4327187538,
-0.9163758159,
0.4031187594,
-0.0023249686,
1.1201179028,
0.4715017974,
-0.1501935273,
0.424590528,
-0.1204938367,
0.9339640737,
-0.1887476593,
-0.6143016219,
0.5999125838,
-0.3239636123,
0.0684912056,
0.4528281987,
0.6410760283,
-0.4917421937,
-0.2826402783,
-0.6374428272,
-0.9388018847,
0.9138368368,
0.1906713396,
0.0101152044,
0.2002216876,
0.5283545852,
-0.1433849931,
0.2203017771,
-0.5779184103,
-0.0590043329,
0.3438745141,
0.1620068252,
-0.0995724946,
-0.5784105659,
-0.5529530644,
-0.1361504048,
0.6601893306,
-0.0155792199,
0.7516266108,
0.2479111403,
-0.2743031383,
-0.3563427627,
0.1518748105,
0.6246373057,
0.701177001,
-0.3993891478,
0.2489706874,
0.1937159598,
-0.2451669574,
0.1978990883,
0.2351993471,
-0.02642533,
-0.0509850308,
0.1957850158,
0.6919918656,
-0.1456347257,
-0.9814348221,
0.4321112335,
-0.2956677973,
-0.1250833422,
-0.4740225971,
0.3305043578,
0.3163325191,
0.5529965162,
0.5528150201,
-0.084236607,
0.3871405423,
-0.5300835967,
0.0006032953,
0.3978451192,
-0.3081347048,
-0.14626652,
0.4914317131,
-0.030273376,
-0.5703904629,
0.8125736713,
-0.4138352275,
-0.5475747585,
0.5868880153,
0.3676640689,
0.6152057648,
-0.2985325456,
0.1294983178,
0.2053767741,
0.5062507391,
-0.2326318324,
0.6561899185,
-0.267152369,
-0.7393718958,
-0.5925842524,
-0.3385873139,
-0.7176430821,
-0.3082488477,
-0.6334012747,
0.1184411943,
-0.0627920404,
-0.3123678565,
-0.296364367,
0.17015329,
-0.7676174641,
-0.0303296335,
0.0130848633,
0.9847488403,
-0.3115648031,
0.6825500131,
0.7754013538,
-0.0381481647,
-1.0351821184,
-0.3742515445,
0.0955254659,
-1.1176774502,
0.6465759277,
0.0445998125,
-0.2361134142,
-0.0534354076,
-0.7380771041,
-1.183822155,
1.4055602551,
0.2587756813,
-0.6007255316,
-0.0714810938,
-0.110326618,
0.6249072552,
-0.2405328453,
0.6096104383,
0.5874475837,
0.4648804367,
0.1009946242,
-0.4793605804,
-0.0995274112,
-0.2924950123,
0.1635538191,
0.2326624542,
-0.5647010207,
0.6576218009,
-0.4056426883,
-0.3669270873,
0.1955924779,
0.8205677867,
0.5553736091,
0.379106313,
0.6918863058,
0.5217521787,
1.2390218973,
-0.2429667562,
1.491297245,
-0.3228776157,
0.3755957484,
0.8314781189,
-0.095184058,
0.7129882574,
0.5266712904,
-0.4182397723,
0.2306037247,
1.1305725574,
0.4174839854,
0.6147207022,
0.7063877583,
-0.4253010154,
-0.2262803018,
-0.1255308539,
-0.2804201543,
0.5121411085,
0.5455770493,
-0.2635039091,
-0.0180547759,
-0.3869188726,
0.0459641479,
0.0045916396,
-0.1384068877,
0.7853107452,
0.0244440138,
-1.0674506426,
0.2610710263,
0.2455057949,
0.8846498728,
-0.5948799849,
0.076888606,
-0.387463212,
-0.0602468885,
0.0251423735,
-0.5788581371,
-0.0219275579,
-0.2363035977,
0.2258186191,
-0.1733651161,
0.6469132304,
-0.4912120402,
-0.2318882346,
0.4361825287,
0.9300151467,
0.3056510985,
-0.1610867679,
-0.3512043953,
-0.268858254,
-0.0332778394,
-0.9843789339,
0.1381227374,
0.6981707215,
0.2254334837,
0.7955257893,
0.6795830131,
0.3166890144,
0.3642680943,
-0.1234836876,
0.919862628,
-0.9590167999,
-0.4470514059,
-0.8814458251,
0.3838892281,
-0.2300845683,
-0.0742505714,
0.6811775565,
0.6440298557,
0.5931271315,
0.215408355,
0.842939496,
0.2893942595,
0.6794214845,
-0.6383495331,
0.4895555675,
-0.5049011111,
0.5552686453,
0.1314922273,
-0.9337925315,
-0.2293479294,
0.6334329844,
-0.0270376429,
0.0270661246,
0.5711318851,
1.0296708345,
0.2037159801,
0.1478282064,
0.2275444418,
0.0100899274,
0.4250008464,
0.7674173117,
1.5745563507,
-0.1693304181,
0.2546148896,
-0.2749405205,
-0.3132848144,
-0.2069394886,
-0.5884600282,
-0.5343108773,
-0.1628851146,
0.1024175882,
-0.2570735812,
0.0465338975,
1.331504941,
0.81705755,
-0.493742466,
-0.5793833137,
0.1131310463,
0.2240633667,
-0.2112703621,
-0.2140000761,
0.2890276015,
-0.6582543254,
-1.1091253757,
0.7281266451,
0.1944507062,
-0.0055238204,
-0.4503328204,
-0.2623288631,
-0.2682055831,
0.1172918975,
0.5701945424,
0.1364822388,
-0.4823408127,
-0.1183324307,
0.5371495485,
-0.2548215687,
-0.0580838881,
0.9260575175,
-0.7065150738,
0.6022814512,
0.3489131331,
1.0736711025,
0.9213007689,
-0.2817189395,
0.7517284751,
-0.598267436,
0.1098930016,
0.4293596447,
0.3400513828,
0.2340988368,
-0.6778557301,
1.0135077238,
-0.0435864329,
-0.6455945373,
-0.8618884683,
0.0158460569,
-1.0278842449,
0.037551675,
1.3611699343,
-0.1429236233,
-0.163951844,
0.1275998056,
-0.1771327406,
-0.0110097295,
-0.660420537,
0.8110105991,
0.8371981978,
-0.5350320339,
-0.0593955293,
-0.6641381979,
0.358807236,
0.5640751719,
-0.6181558967,
-0.4088091254,
0.2931523323,
-0.0532753654,
0.207840845,
0.9837608337,
0.0149231004,
0.2245004773,
-0.1808242053,
0.0098625673,
0.100102745,
-0.3354480565,
-0.3885409236,
0.3497047424,
0.5559942722,
-0.2157101631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01771v1
|
BlackMamba: Mixture of Experts for State-Space Models
| 2024-02-01T07:15:58 | 2024-02-01T07:15:58 |
Quentin Anthony, Yury Tokpanov, Paolo Glorioso, Beren Millidge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG
|
State-space models (SSMs) have recently demonstrated competitive performance
to transformers at large-scale language modeling benchmarks while achieving
linear time and memory complexity as a function of sequence length. Mamba, a
recently released SSM model, shows impressive performance in both language
modeling and long sequence processing tasks. Simultaneously, mixture-of-expert
(MoE) models have shown remarkable performance while significantly reducing the
compute and latency costs of inference at the expense of a larger memory
footprint. In this paper, we present BlackMamba, a novel architecture that
combines the Mamba SSM with MoE to obtain the benefits of both. We demonstrate
that BlackMamba performs competitively against both Mamba and transformer
baselines, and outperforms in inference and training FLOPs. We fully train and
open-source 340M/1.5B and 630M/2.8B BlackMamba models on 300B tokens of a
custom dataset. We show that BlackMamba inherits and combines both of the
benefits of SSM and MoE architectures, combining linear-complexity generation
from SSM with cheap and fast inference from MoE. We release all weights,
checkpoints, and inference code open-source. Inference code at:
https://github.com/Zyphra/BlackMamba
|
[
-0.5183235407,
-0.676726222,
0.5470067859,
0.1712998599,
-0.2418064326,
0.4528066218,
-0.2763474882,
-0.411558032,
0.5013803244,
0.4461302757,
-0.1285738498,
-0.1756387204,
-0.6723673344,
-0.4113340676,
-0.3034427166,
0.453368336,
0.0421370491,
-0.0139455246,
-0.2927669585,
-0.2458660901,
-0.5773378611,
-0.4907531738,
-0.1882551461,
-0.3831661642,
0.2560646832,
0.1965801269,
0.8130102158,
0.5391251445,
0.0090682693,
0.3285886645,
-0.2555837333,
0.5951832533,
-0.3996184766,
0.1886570305,
-0.2992737293,
-0.5675466061,
-0.4814630747,
-0.2221853435,
0.4157986343,
0.6600865126,
-0.5364837646,
0.0381192826,
-0.2305132449,
0.4327077866,
-1.0603884459,
0.1850370318,
-0.7689920664,
-0.0136774248,
-0.1915421337,
-0.0141110439,
-0.6273025274,
-0.130097717,
-0.1469584256,
-0.5002862811,
-0.0398969464,
0.1897174567,
0.8434351683,
0.6434993148,
-0.4274366796,
-0.0268086493,
-1.1252733469,
0.9164400101,
-0.7529999614,
0.2365670949,
0.0887508541,
0.7810810804,
-0.299883604,
-0.3022930026,
-0.6235368848,
0.2871331871,
0.2035650462,
0.2803919017,
-0.1500005126,
-0.1105919406,
-0.2802859843,
0.5498941541,
-0.2755379379,
0.2009855509,
-0.7497476935,
-0.1002324522,
0.6968623996,
0.2508314848,
-0.0331095755,
-0.1893453449,
-0.4423311055,
0.0561558902,
-0.4551739693,
-0.1923417002,
0.2505186796,
0.2037698179,
-0.132723093,
0.5808871388,
-0.059313938,
0.7773228884,
0.0196598526,
-0.1245909259,
0.1380466968,
0.046947591,
-0.3106870949,
-0.0627868697,
0.8469267488,
0.0643481016,
0.0003626202,
-0.3928565979,
-0.2060734332,
0.1378988773,
0.6880756617,
-0.5782421827,
-0.3439534605,
0.2018773705,
-0.3688555062,
0.0239264667,
0.08881253,
-0.9499377608,
-0.4255127907,
-0.3890431523,
0.6629900336,
-0.4567510188,
-0.6922562718,
0.2134958208,
-0.1050515175,
0.0245541167,
0.3021609485,
-0.6686151624,
0.4191076756,
0.8373082876,
0.9194793701,
-0.2757970393,
-0.0001431968,
-0.179460451,
0.3199248314,
-0.5003468394,
0.5702466965,
-0.7323856354,
-0.6801673174,
-0.4279460907,
-0.5416120291,
-0.1868739128,
-0.6240535378,
0.1394744962,
-0.5531706214,
-0.012295207,
0.1926028579,
-0.7551583648,
-0.3692596853,
-0.232252121,
-0.5341020823,
1.4222084284,
0.2750914395,
-0.2616308033,
0.4471104741,
-0.5855519772,
-0.4706630111,
0.2414509058,
-0.2097948045,
-0.3656553626,
0.3052492738,
0.107948184,
0.7186119556,
-0.204896763,
0.4177094996,
-0.5825592279,
-0.4324866235,
0.1550218612,
0.1220591143,
0.5330423713,
0.6172850728,
-0.3380376101,
0.0385506265,
-1.0706505775,
-0.3144145012,
0.2978643179,
-0.2629623115,
-0.5639138222,
0.3816549182,
-0.4229542613,
0.3690166473,
0.210249275,
-0.4351281226,
0.0372244157,
-0.13986516,
0.468531251,
0.6732077003,
-0.0185369216,
0.7017624378,
-0.0650964081,
0.6768018603,
0.3412278891,
-0.1020800024,
-0.3135927618,
-0.7206513286,
-0.9321903586,
-0.7375744581,
0.3150831759,
0.4007512629,
-0.821054399,
0.8006159067,
-0.2177204937,
-0.8953475952,
-1.0988936424,
0.1061931774,
0.1645658761,
0.5066598058,
0.6717582941,
-0.3312235475,
-0.4677093923,
-1.0844848156,
0.1417334676,
0.0534938797,
0.0318829268,
0.4837575555,
0.3181477487,
-0.1114352271,
1.0639079809,
-0.5687530637,
0.2305327803,
-0.2371315062,
-0.1113275886,
0.1717493832,
0.439132154,
0.6694004536,
-0.3793403208,
-0.0527234226,
-0.0204708427,
-0.6772267222,
0.0261000991,
0.0348088816,
-0.3446343839,
0.0094262054,
0.2127531767,
-0.6948110461,
0.1354178041,
0.6286736727,
-0.0173390731,
0.3133541048,
-0.2976998687,
-0.1552974135,
-1.3938914537,
0.005611633,
0.0393085517,
-0.1561917663,
-0.4840964079,
0.4704272747,
0.1344700605,
-0.2150222212,
-0.3514873981,
0.6839458942,
-0.4146510661,
-0.3106104136,
-0.4042727351,
0.0508535951,
-0.1208902895,
0.6816607118,
-0.2185979486,
0.8510224223,
0.4954390526,
-0.7203416228,
0.0548782386,
0.0423380248,
-0.6630139947,
0.3627922535,
-0.4695332646,
0.1951258332,
0.0361471437,
0.2724291682,
-1.102216959,
-0.1256329119,
0.1680439115,
-0.3406583071,
0.3125225902,
-0.3027462065,
-0.5679380894,
-0.5087224245,
0.2670099139,
0.1825398654,
0.8063138127,
-0.3446650207,
0.9790928364,
0.7135224938,
-0.2311931551,
-0.6425403953,
-0.9104613066,
0.1706959754,
0.0465850569,
-0.4814285338,
0.0144637162,
0.2173333913,
-0.1245196462,
-0.0629518405,
-0.2367263287,
-0.0629648194,
0.4535835087,
0.4622258246,
0.3862324655,
-0.4723008275,
-0.2794716954,
0.5730355978,
-0.1580056548,
-0.0728312209,
-0.4104135931,
0.6668102741,
0.0436070748,
-0.3313255906,
-0.1320663393,
0.2273791432,
0.4206635654,
-0.4791235328,
1.1609779596,
0.2723143995,
-0.2216317803,
-0.493008852,
-0.5680388808,
0.2101743817,
-0.4454504848,
0.1590667665,
-0.4130804241,
-0.8020161986,
0.4091596007,
-0.0613766797,
0.3183923662,
0.3632236421,
0.9114682674,
0.0382985957,
0.7808068395,
0.2304644138,
-0.1976184398,
0.2046299577,
-0.2062133998,
0.3403864801,
-0.4817072153,
-0.4042822123,
-0.5354109406,
-0.6817288995,
-0.1790014058,
-0.8414822817,
0.0282608792,
-0.0278520249,
-0.0926557258,
0.3946644664,
-0.3197210133,
0.492667377,
0.5436003804,
0.2857324183,
0.1205934361,
-0.0787760764,
-0.4239068627,
0.1258204281,
-0.9525245428,
-0.5057553649,
1.1015361547,
0.2828187943,
0.8716806769,
0.0805736259,
0.6339950562,
0.1380568296,
0.1890425086,
-0.6612259746,
0.8255265355,
-0.1253284961,
-0.7949706912,
0.1045103222,
-0.612704277,
-0.73864609,
0.6114908457,
-0.2334754616,
-0.454777211,
0.2669444978,
0.1640616655,
-0.401019901,
0.5721330643,
-0.8189486861,
0.332850039,
-0.0017503245,
-0.1408079416,
-0.7029522657,
-0.6551058292,
0.5731120706,
-0.189012602,
0.1238161325,
-0.3011740148,
-0.2383525372,
0.51115942,
-0.3555296361,
0.673879683,
-0.4342688024,
0.0739097521,
0.23070243,
0.3106992543,
0.0468384437,
-0.2686810195,
-0.3362247646,
0.418672353,
-0.6637547612,
-0.7429579496,
-0.437151134,
0.6732292175,
-1.0383576155,
-0.4867564738,
-0.0800367892,
-0.754203558,
-0.3493581414,
0.1797413081,
-0.2120872885,
0.3110859394,
0.0826986805,
0.4260151684,
0.5740104914,
-0.211129263,
0.2576814294,
0.4760302007,
-0.1609074324,
-0.4587795138,
0.8475571871,
0.0864443406,
0.2594954967,
0.3733852804,
-0.0609403476,
-0.0159981251,
-0.7233171463,
-0.6452924609,
0.0673032477,
-0.5613476634,
-0.1314869672,
-0.7647890449,
-0.2253790796,
0.0291359294,
-0.2384673208,
-0.7430248857,
-0.7717204094,
-0.0702645257,
-0.2393586785,
0.052704975,
0.727024734,
0.1901147515,
0.4640819132,
-0.6769831777,
0.3782974184,
0.0877376571,
0.1948590726,
0.4367469251,
-0.3762518167,
-0.5806385279,
-0.0859241858,
-0.4485465884,
-0.605979979,
0.1346129626,
-0.0482467301,
0.8434483409,
0.6114327312,
-0.0562080629,
0.8677473068,
-0.4931772649,
0.8496465683,
0.0621564388,
-0.8556753993,
0.3022912741,
-0.1445647329,
0.1231062189,
0.3321031332,
0.4189549685,
-0.0593091436,
-0.9706695676,
-0.4737153053,
-0.7029641271,
0.7482114434,
0.1745378971,
-0.0786662698,
0.1140377745,
0.3316486478,
0.4484730959,
0.290825814,
-0.1468779892,
-0.4362225533,
-0.4199864566,
-0.3686236143,
-0.30962044,
-0.0457189754,
-0.1806709617,
-0.1397387981,
0.5276567936,
0.0101594375,
0.2370482236,
-0.2965657413,
-0.5721064806,
-0.1228830069,
0.2746852338,
0.6109477282,
0.8913250566,
-0.0331679471,
-0.0491003878,
0.1875676811,
-0.0445547663,
0.3542571664,
0.3017269671,
-0.2782022655,
0.0755778775,
0.0304784365,
1.0696570873,
0.7700408101,
-0.3776609004,
0.1372310817,
0.2536689639,
-0.2854460478,
0.220442012,
0.7492796183,
0.4112533033,
0.4015296996,
0.7209342718,
0.4341944158,
-0.1316655874,
-0.1706130505,
-0.0198101215,
0.1478491127,
0.0677721575,
-0.323237896,
1.106768012,
0.3790362775,
-0.179050222,
0.2815140188,
0.0228684805,
-0.2594843805,
0.551074326,
0.2234063596,
0.5314712524,
-0.5046237111,
-0.0382806286,
0.1265818775,
0.1670141816,
0.0535012595,
0.2100286931,
-0.3681037724,
-0.6107470393,
-0.5250183344,
-0.7495743036,
-0.7930899858,
-0.1949646026,
-0.7664523721,
0.1317910999,
-0.6308376789,
-0.1555976868,
0.0497004725,
-0.0209463965,
-0.2379542142,
0.0376666337,
0.3996041417,
1.1958830357,
-0.5282406211,
0.8437402844,
0.7311880589,
-0.0262408871,
-0.5297397971,
-0.3668432236,
0.1001209468,
-0.8481560946,
0.2358630002,
0.106636636,
-0.0928815603,
-0.2553887367,
-0.2496449351,
-0.5145934224,
1.1219806671,
0.583899796,
-0.7023903131,
-0.092158623,
-0.0666669607,
0.4995048046,
-0.204247117,
0.115978159,
0.4956201911,
0.3430575728,
0.0937034637,
-0.620203197,
-0.1866126209,
-0.1628102213,
-0.0509500168,
0.6263756752,
-0.9468305111,
0.7104555368,
-0.1217751205,
-0.0580447614,
0.172425285,
1.3258165121,
0.5927860737,
0.1718302071,
0.6072558165,
0.7753348351,
0.8833882213,
-0.1508969665,
0.9605464339,
-0.4912033677,
0.2372215837,
1.0185062885,
-0.4885188043,
0.919854641,
0.0898491591,
-0.3467555046,
0.7668684125,
0.6374204159,
-0.1058215573,
0.398135066,
-0.1642170995,
-0.1167363822,
-0.4356224537,
0.5720934868,
-0.3722910881,
0.2547898293,
0.414434284,
-0.0435271412,
-0.1458494067,
-0.2619215846,
0.0475132614,
0.0338364691,
-0.2894140482,
0.6754414439,
0.2846952677,
-0.7584331632,
0.3454191387,
0.1115604639,
0.7070780396,
-0.7028779984,
0.3356622458,
-0.2780231535,
0.3167414963,
-0.0148694022,
-0.8218547106,
0.2827325761,
-0.1904381663,
-0.185076192,
0.0151042799,
0.656799078,
-0.5730960369,
-0.4444849193,
0.4832115173,
0.4118698239,
-0.0187885147,
0.1441616118,
-0.5737950802,
-0.3123180866,
-0.5311837196,
-0.102625668,
0.3352677524,
0.2509203851,
0.1400307864,
0.8305398226,
0.537683785,
0.2124101073,
0.5657024384,
-0.1215520576,
0.7355539799,
-0.5941530466,
-0.8644957542,
-0.6082507372,
0.4240210354,
-0.0139258038,
-0.1170587689,
0.6856532693,
0.7707701921,
0.558602035,
-0.12501131,
0.6059967875,
0.0605213232,
0.4853826761,
-0.4807806909,
0.825263381,
-0.8000223637,
-0.1032556519,
-0.0302597042,
-0.8396942019,
0.0647787675,
0.1195268482,
-0.1610978991,
0.1112207025,
0.2482466549,
0.7390320897,
-0.3885559738,
-0.0114455456,
0.3354440928,
0.3132764995,
0.2416333109,
0.6780811548,
0.7692314386,
-0.1191982105,
0.6952932477,
-0.1251278669,
-0.0504698493,
-0.6266929507,
-0.4951250255,
-0.8093965054,
-0.4436564445,
0.0279363301,
-0.2008430511,
-0.1557878554,
0.8668206334,
1.187043786,
-0.8019890189,
-0.1697760373,
0.4812530577,
0.1348172724,
-0.2335396856,
-0.2050489634,
-0.1103426814,
-0.2036188692,
-0.8730179667,
0.8102779984,
0.6744940877,
-0.1787870377,
-0.4904507101,
-0.3839165568,
-0.1868297607,
0.4330142438,
0.5942428112,
0.1363148689,
-0.7241258025,
0.2584702671,
-0.2474824637,
-0.1886022091,
0.3370150328,
0.8553799987,
-0.6926673651,
0.5451953411,
0.4732875228,
1.136417985,
0.6453045607,
-0.0479266457,
0.8483244777,
-0.7794677615,
0.4210717082,
0.0668008029,
0.7884813547,
0.2280838192,
-0.0915155336,
0.5310377479,
0.2261037081,
-0.2987008095,
-0.7779842615,
-0.1324107349,
-1.0749806166,
-0.6084911823,
0.8363570571,
-0.0913677141,
-0.1936461031,
-0.0276282579,
-0.0210427195,
0.2670542598,
-0.6772946119,
0.7815817595,
0.9900966287,
0.286393851,
-0.2746724188,
-0.3955086172,
-0.3244520426,
0.5040346384,
-0.7421343327,
-0.3806108832,
0.254388988,
0.1023019478,
0.2521977425,
0.1071501821,
-0.0330926552,
0.394946903,
0.0425446443,
0.2193404883,
-0.5105063915,
-0.4115602374,
-0.2694935799,
0.3460573554,
-0.2560512424,
-0.171671018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00385v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00385v1
|
Computational Morphology and Lexicography Modeling of Modern Standard Arabic Nominals
| 2024-02-01T07:05:45 | 2024-02-01T07:05:45 |
Christian Khairallah, Reham Marzouk, Salam Khalifa, Mayar Nassar, Nizar Habash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) nominals present many morphological and lexical
modeling challenges that have not been consistently addressed previously. This
paper attempts to define the space of such challenges, and leverage a recently
proposed morphological framework to build a comprehensive and extensible model
for MSA nominals. Our model design addresses the nominals' intricate
morphotactics, as well as their paradigmatic irregularities. Our implementation
showcases enhanced accuracy and consistency compared to a commonly used MSA
morphological analyzer and generator. We make our models publicly available.
|
[
-0.4489788115,
-0.944278717,
0.5088423491,
0.0905350596,
-0.3287399411,
0.0729821697,
0.2626314163,
-0.7306488156,
0.5273789763,
0.4589146078,
-0.4379760325,
-0.6543918848,
-0.4283037186,
0.3497603536,
-0.2765567005,
0.5851672888,
-0.2381576747,
-0.2210660428,
0.0410272218,
-0.2649159133,
-0.4900744557,
-0.9361094832,
-0.3172442317,
0.3050188124,
0.3711113036,
0.3359611332,
1.4089750051,
0.793023169,
0.4111437201,
0.351454109,
-0.5425090194,
0.5280900598,
0.2149803042,
0.1540844589,
-0.163500309,
0.0778754354,
-0.5699753165,
-0.2666590214,
0.9450746179,
0.8753401041,
-0.3040217757,
0.2004440725,
-0.4218631983,
0.534448266,
-0.7429776788,
0.114520371,
-0.5233486891,
-0.0539850481,
-0.6862285733,
0.0424567387,
-0.1115888804,
-0.3030028045,
0.0438410863,
-0.2573184371,
0.1001039147,
-0.3785731494,
1.1326828003,
-0.1077999175,
-0.6242920756,
-0.542760551,
-0.8666747212,
0.4345591664,
-0.5040104985,
0.4332980812,
0.0521990731,
0.6085634828,
-0.1174431294,
-0.8742354512,
-0.364738971,
-0.5990347266,
0.1246741116,
-0.2040297687,
-0.169990167,
0.022490317,
-0.0656627342,
0.7030541301,
-0.3966228366,
0.0386326388,
-0.4199003875,
-0.2724889219,
0.284196049,
0.3415243626,
0.5579691529,
-0.2759872079,
-0.1729179174,
0.5304228663,
-0.972051084,
-0.0069515668,
0.4871178269,
0.5102033615,
-0.2710586786,
0.7848818898,
-0.0414622836,
0.5939303041,
-0.4341379702,
-0.0090492545,
0.280924499,
-0.3848314583,
-0.0886173919,
-0.0679558069,
0.2559610009,
-0.0522649661,
0.0496685207,
0.1140315607,
-0.4462274015,
0.0454093888,
0.4569621682,
-0.7346174121,
-0.1028460711,
0.1619642675,
-0.3282416165,
-0.1092437431,
-0.148804009,
-0.615447104,
-0.3180498779,
-0.6537829041,
0.283585906,
-0.6165776849,
-0.1848837882,
0.1120139733,
0.1395640522,
-0.2157285362,
0.3177585602,
-0.7694252133,
0.3352566659,
0.5036936402,
1.0631834269,
-0.0412380062,
0.2090472877,
0.1808418483,
0.1884231865,
-0.5832153559,
0.8684543371,
-0.8946990967,
-0.5576441884,
0.3813051283,
-0.3069290519,
0.0345163643,
-0.6579589844,
0.7508814335,
-0.4852317572,
-0.2610901892,
0.2732478678,
-0.3865586519,
-0.2186189443,
0.307774812,
-0.7994289398,
0.8246366382,
0.4625430703,
-0.5908750892,
-0.1217164695,
-0.6647621989,
0.0496669225,
0.0895176083,
-0.3771164715,
-0.1641204804,
0.2733049095,
-0.0112812519,
0.0422881283,
-0.2266195267,
0.5020347238,
0.0711713657,
-0.0755039304,
0.2502445877,
-0.295511663,
0.6607584357,
0.6009491682,
0.2225502878,
0.4768086076,
-1.0877826214,
-0.3070041835,
0.0388648845,
0.0523326695,
-0.2271302789,
0.2172891051,
0.3621447682,
0.237248823,
0.4575373232,
-0.2579364181,
0.5441552401,
-0.4044326842,
0.323853761,
0.6202120185,
0.1364989579,
0.2614172101,
-0.3270147443,
0.4897976816,
0.2883490324,
0.1585032493,
-0.1361442357,
-0.5113201737,
-0.5562838912,
-0.9219125509,
0.3960712552,
0.2531478405,
-0.565970242,
0.3550978601,
-0.2708443105,
-0.9655174017,
-0.2843554318,
-0.3540939689,
0.1151167229,
0.300465256,
0.2745001912,
-0.485185653,
-0.6434885859,
-1.3075802326,
-0.06297452,
-0.0435651056,
0.0540380627,
0.008166221,
0.5598165393,
-0.4597385228,
1.0357798338,
-0.3147955835,
-0.2574632466,
-0.0750194564,
0.4349161386,
0.2591231167,
0.6186290383,
0.9593289495,
-0.7314622998,
-0.3590075076,
-0.0128040006,
-0.3583394289,
-0.2224322259,
-0.0259331632,
0.058535289,
0.3187957406,
0.4027128518,
-0.767044723,
0.4785942137,
0.4310877919,
-0.4807013869,
1.1826497316,
0.0039613168,
-0.0709744543,
-1.0756479502,
0.0414426699,
-0.2181421965,
-0.1873395294,
-0.8434938788,
0.7275240421,
0.0949951783,
-0.2623739839,
-0.6241740584,
0.5630319715,
-0.2913712561,
0.1672671735,
-0.1422446966,
-0.228157118,
-0.2650020123,
0.2402396798,
0.048112493,
1.0944821835,
0.4715857208,
-0.8041870594,
-0.0512608998,
0.1444711238,
-0.3650736511,
0.2880859077,
-0.6338095665,
0.1483791471,
-0.1090120822,
-0.0657306314,
-0.7448303103,
-0.2398701608,
0.2816676795,
-0.2349567413,
0.3965916336,
-0.2185174227,
-0.7536171675,
0.2125143558,
-0.2290017307,
0.6768692136,
0.3738432825,
-0.2066220343,
0.9403454065,
0.4528297782,
-0.5543572903,
-0.2206309885,
-0.0487153903,
0.3374482691,
-0.0247479063,
-0.6972923875,
0.8426856995,
0.0686299354,
-0.4420469701,
-0.2127966434,
-0.0057197292,
-0.4547015727,
0.0110235596,
0.2832223177,
0.3912397921,
-0.3247960508,
0.0005425782,
0.1381331086,
0.0238832776,
-0.22629264,
0.1504989117,
0.8650298715,
-0.1166999787,
-0.3640226722,
-0.6292510033,
0.6682780981,
0.6989016533,
-0.3583306968,
0.9396045804,
0.2341618091,
-0.7564905882,
0.3630446196,
-0.2334518135,
0.283361733,
-0.5107884407,
0.4568809867,
-0.8574669361,
-0.6294668913,
0.7355350852,
-0.0423450135,
0.249835223,
0.570006609,
0.6815516353,
0.1568438262,
1.2283500433,
0.767257154,
0.285476923,
0.277970016,
0.1198504344,
0.1415544003,
-0.4705803692,
-0.3251027465,
-0.9554223418,
0.0912077054,
-0.6598725915,
-0.4812304974,
0.3640200198,
0.126798436,
-0.4557876289,
0.2538557947,
-0.1951322556,
0.2361448407,
0.3717620075,
-0.4239113331,
0.0149001731,
0.2512558699,
-0.3738853037,
-0.3215128481,
-0.1860751212,
-1.2397527695,
0.4910339713,
0.534934938,
0.3583542109,
0.6020681858,
0.3220981359,
0.4024008811,
0.2179666162,
-0.798271656,
0.2900936902,
-0.0381674394,
-0.7307697535,
0.1498355567,
-0.171270743,
-0.7383320928,
0.2094785273,
-0.0406896584,
-0.881469965,
0.3273293972,
0.0360557102,
-0.2523186803,
0.2935602367,
-0.352675885,
0.7834846973,
0.4432806075,
0.1550216377,
-0.020064773,
-0.5335367322,
0.277794838,
-0.1853493601,
0.4280816615,
-0.2149676979,
-0.2817817628,
0.5716221929,
-0.6034238338,
0.808806181,
0.0535599254,
-0.3955434263,
0.5147078037,
0.6510016918,
0.2678364217,
-0.165109545,
-0.1220517457,
0.3002807498,
0.4102281034,
-0.6944003105,
-0.3497871757,
0.2621185482,
-0.8039669991,
-0.4559231997,
-0.6990130544,
-0.5364919901,
-0.4039767385,
-0.0058660409,
-0.0624684989,
0.7968912721,
-0.6145851016,
-0.2029536217,
0.0056525236,
-0.1046461761,
0.198857978,
0.3997485936,
-0.3381900787,
-0.4160909057,
0.7112761736,
0.4123786092,
0.0551927462,
0.0597051531,
-0.211449191,
-0.2370032817,
-1.0142446756,
-0.6608338952,
0.1184513122,
-0.6753475666,
-0.2601342499,
-0.4200460315,
-0.5555729866,
-0.665261507,
-0.0223303568,
-0.47867769,
-0.6943360567,
-0.3736308515,
-0.0204151645,
0.1694446057,
1.0042418242,
0.0123612192,
0.4657321572,
-1.1837055683,
0.3515691459,
-0.008639791,
0.0434428044,
-0.2284086496,
-0.8075360656,
-0.029030757,
-0.0195664875,
-0.5909192562,
-1.2329462767,
0.5881946087,
0.3499600887,
0.1789359152,
0.7507391572,
-0.2606737614,
0.7163183689,
-1.0027074814,
1.1045889854,
-0.1012969166,
-1.1018861532,
0.3291823268,
-0.4141062498,
0.1392137408,
0.3330887854,
0.5822796822,
-0.7586492896,
-0.2228179723,
-0.4352397323,
-0.9542978406,
0.2883593738,
0.5126312971,
0.4924582243,
-0.3624498248,
0.5272813439,
0.3693229854,
0.0872336477,
-0.203751862,
-0.4518614113,
0.0255239736,
-0.4453285933,
0.1248177066,
-0.9075109959,
-0.0625907928,
-0.1468978524,
0.5805356503,
0.032269869,
0.2529150546,
0.0070972624,
-0.1847011,
0.2547228038,
0.3829238117,
1.001742959,
0.8849890828,
-0.1537896097,
0.4138962626,
-0.0211438406,
-0.6562253833,
0.3146176636,
0.002000913,
-0.4855967462,
0.4602923989,
0.2718780935,
0.4815510213,
0.021965025,
-0.7255697846,
0.1019908264,
0.2794990838,
-0.1543224603,
-0.6433654428,
-0.3436571062,
0.0785785764,
-0.1272185296,
0.2933062911,
0.3138261437,
0.2968038917,
-0.7888500094,
0.1408353597,
0.3019908965,
-0.4100928605,
-0.6198056936,
0.0661944002,
-0.1673947573,
-0.4744763672,
0.3792175651,
-0.2385894656,
-0.6216023564,
0.6736629605,
0.7555770874,
0.3943172991,
-0.5241934657,
0.3196188509,
0.2682814002,
0.1705051214,
0.3891380131,
0.5514402986,
0.3289959729,
-0.5825012922,
0.0353019014,
-0.8715414405,
-0.4772950113,
-0.0425974168,
-0.3662008941,
0.2604402304,
-0.5793356299,
-0.1483516693,
0.1856438965,
-0.2492007911,
-0.2412046939,
0.1725359559,
0.2684876025,
1.3163831234,
-0.5160831213,
0.6392201781,
0.8857619762,
-0.643571198,
-0.4219999015,
-0.4804593325,
0.2421366572,
-0.5219124556,
0.5035680532,
0.3217088282,
-0.4054861069,
-0.301541388,
-0.3797797561,
-1.1603137255,
0.5964774489,
0.4175348282,
-0.2204392105,
-0.1815992743,
0.4945827723,
0.5395233631,
-0.430491358,
0.1972748786,
0.527831912,
0.36073789,
0.1669739485,
-0.8556999564,
-0.0655586272,
-0.3635008633,
0.1772186458,
0.2420652211,
-0.2309901565,
1.1439567804,
0.2751547396,
-0.7870761752,
0.7211173177,
0.9579570293,
0.290047437,
0.0318844207,
0.2127278,
0.453481853,
0.7535415292,
0.0431750454,
0.8335495591,
-0.3362701237,
0.0377352163,
0.9965940118,
-0.3074091673,
0.8517677784,
0.4783007801,
-0.3952567279,
0.7489359379,
1.0605145693,
0.2835129499,
0.1840071529,
0.280436486,
-0.6219214201,
-0.0989359915,
-0.5889368653,
-0.6737287641,
0.5590555072,
0.6321925521,
-0.1673708558,
-0.3554241359,
-0.312728256,
0.0039866278,
0.3005913198,
-0.5837589502,
0.4690339863,
-0.1158213913,
-0.2838060856,
0.6162359715,
0.6187724471,
0.4262173474,
-0.6398662329,
-0.2209624648,
-0.0724339858,
-0.0904788971,
-0.0271522216,
-0.3026613593,
0.7738215327,
0.091241926,
0.0890415311,
0.1792164743,
0.4948203862,
-0.207099244,
-0.6165418029,
-0.2350796163,
0.5702587962,
0.3287346959,
-0.3713044822,
-0.4981941581,
-0.0345320813,
-0.4599656463,
0.2241786122,
0.17853567,
0.2733207345,
-0.4971465766,
0.534899652,
0.4911778867,
0.1129850894,
0.2359456718,
0.1690291166,
0.6879895329,
-0.9967375398,
-0.4714719653,
-0.8679163456,
0.3657693565,
0.1387969404,
-0.1416107565,
0.347846806,
0.6514585614,
0.3542793095,
-0.2890689373,
0.2218904197,
0.0208633058,
0.3241355121,
-0.6296420097,
0.7393612862,
-0.5458167791,
-0.114570491,
0.1154341549,
-0.8811935782,
-0.4551088214,
0.3189782798,
0.3572494686,
0.0559140258,
0.7189516425,
0.786927104,
-0.195725441,
0.1049294546,
0.2949371338,
0.042889677,
0.409188807,
0.0701424628,
1.0032658577,
0.0031788023,
0.0210576188,
-0.2635691166,
-0.0349238031,
-0.2443292737,
-0.7791867852,
-0.6422065496,
-0.7832030654,
-0.2202134579,
-0.1689015776,
-0.0489022955,
1.3745396137,
0.6321374774,
-0.9904296398,
-0.2622396648,
-0.0120510217,
0.0409104452,
-0.0819586664,
-0.2044914514,
0.6092388034,
-0.5885626674,
-0.8657611609,
0.2939843833,
0.2629078329,
0.6517688632,
-0.1733487397,
0.382226944,
-0.3024072349,
0.6643027663,
0.6799476147,
0.1995081902,
-0.7593359351,
-0.3683441281,
-0.2672722042,
-0.3894461393,
0.3443804085,
0.844060719,
-0.4854992926,
0.1589399129,
0.2366593331,
0.4924106598,
-0.1007334962,
-0.1475127488,
0.5249972343,
-0.8534564376,
0.22571747,
0.2017786652,
0.5971800089,
0.2432628423,
-0.077924788,
0.4272183478,
0.1996890157,
0.0332179405,
-0.8710108399,
0.8256193399,
-0.977874279,
-0.4092243314,
0.710991919,
-0.1012096405,
-0.2287358046,
-0.4535932243,
-0.7478403449,
0.3929416239,
-0.173158437,
0.8339809179,
0.82032758,
0.1074170023,
-0.0035096984,
-0.2967239618,
0.5878189802,
0.3214176893,
-0.7409818172,
-0.0616671257,
0.6988082528,
0.0075052101,
0.5417679548,
0.5040987134,
-0.474640727,
0.3419376314,
0.0589688867,
0.1371947825,
-0.2636007369,
-0.6667512059,
-0.4482249618,
0.5347216725,
0.3548446596,
0.1160232946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00371v1
|
What Does the Bot Say? Opportunities and Risks of Large Language Models in Social Media Bot Detection
| 2024-02-01T06:21:19 | 2024-02-01T06:21:19 |
Shangbin Feng, Herun Wan, Ningnan Wang, Zhaoxuan Tan, Minnan Luo, Yulia Tsvetkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media bot detection has always been an arms race between advancements
in machine learning bot detectors and adversarial bot strategies to evade
detection. In this work, we bring the arms race to the next level by
investigating the opportunities and risks of state-of-the-art large language
models (LLMs) in social bot detection. To investigate the opportunities, we
design novel LLM-based bot detectors by proposing a
mixture-of-heterogeneous-experts framework to divide and conquer diverse user
information modalities. To illuminate the risks, we explore the possibility of
LLM-guided manipulation of user textual and structured information to evade
detection. Extensive experiments with three LLMs on two datasets demonstrate
that instruction tuning on merely 1,000 annotated examples produces specialized
LLMs that outperform state-of-the-art baselines by up to 9.1% on both datasets,
while LLM-guided manipulation strategies could significantly bring down the
performance of existing bot detectors by up to 29.6% and harm the calibration
and reliability of bot detection systems.
|
[
-0.3863509893,
-1.234665513,
0.5747227073,
-0.2726172209,
-0.3561740518,
0.5321210027,
-0.3832778335,
-0.4621126652,
0.1720605493,
0.6791232228,
-0.4934400022,
-0.4689616263,
-0.9177067876,
-0.1531333327,
-0.4668268859,
0.8304858208,
0.2597403526,
-0.0320421159,
0.1365050077,
0.1391574889,
-0.7050389051,
-0.5156546831,
-0.5516688824,
0.1636690646,
0.8002222776,
0.5024808049,
0.7925902605,
0.3923555613,
0.5364194512,
0.3691170216,
-0.1512354463,
0.3104498684,
-0.6105492115,
0.21992217,
-0.0732796341,
-0.734253943,
-0.3416137099,
-0.0071405927,
0.476939559,
0.5451815128,
0.0557352453,
0.1324321628,
-0.1023447141,
0.5214127898,
-0.6502822042,
-0.0363902003,
-1.0219430923,
-0.2871825397,
-0.4558952153,
-0.4651221633,
-0.4636681974,
-0.0498156883,
-0.1219479665,
-0.222148031,
0.0279425345,
0.0958276615,
0.4605475962,
0.2060725838,
-0.1608133465,
-0.0978563875,
-0.7707371712,
0.6054598093,
-0.6332637072,
0.0421100371,
0.447358489,
0.6929497719,
-0.3078638613,
-0.4024633765,
-0.8007733822,
-0.0626813248,
0.2815501988,
-0.1218548045,
-0.415635258,
-0.0875588581,
0.1021237448,
0.0731507093,
-0.5081351399,
0.4659690559,
-0.4787004292,
-0.2128856033,
0.8571498394,
-0.0529459044,
0.4024112225,
-0.1551079303,
-0.2818406224,
0.0215224847,
-0.6246734858,
-0.3085330725,
0.8688678145,
0.3712857068,
-0.0055528684,
0.7610874176,
-0.0506083034,
0.5665225983,
-0.0475083999,
0.1481979489,
0.046617493,
0.0633872524,
0.0434365869,
-0.135380134,
0.9018424153,
0.5388156772,
0.5050393343,
-0.1589468122,
-0.2510804236,
0.0007927321,
0.1743016541,
-0.3112007678,
-0.2088446915,
0.1276033521,
-0.3223603368,
-0.5358822942,
0.1610902697,
-0.7202224135,
-0.87476331,
-0.0356391147,
0.4733700752,
-0.2584210932,
-0.3752163947,
0.1827335507,
-0.2773211896,
0.1464003474,
0.4523810744,
-0.4080220163,
0.0978479013,
0.9150324464,
0.6622279882,
-0.1353342235,
-0.1281298846,
-0.8858591914,
0.0531149581,
-0.3988690972,
0.7791261077,
-0.5771788359,
-0.4013029933,
0.2592024505,
0.0238305982,
0.1691394001,
-0.4619649947,
0.2179496288,
-0.670334816,
0.0895741135,
-0.2148175091,
-0.5671905279,
-0.2565895021,
0.1669033766,
-0.6030603051,
0.7473089695,
0.0132108852,
-0.588135004,
0.1678656936,
-0.5390537381,
-0.7464005351,
0.5144280791,
-0.0088330014,
-0.078297548,
0.1570598036,
0.1398410946,
0.7118814588,
-0.2729055583,
0.1240985021,
-0.7002230883,
-0.2185340226,
0.6296295524,
-0.7140631676,
0.6786087155,
0.2013795078,
-0.2674463689,
0.2196145654,
-0.341180712,
-0.4070732296,
0.3730079234,
-0.1310825497,
-0.2454554588,
0.1377130598,
0.1731099784,
0.1819530576,
0.2920691967,
-0.5357877612,
-0.0293565542,
-0.0427279733,
0.5387980342,
1.1667053699,
-0.039786879,
0.4502037466,
-0.3412699997,
0.6412805319,
-0.1873477399,
0.1691885591,
-0.185074687,
-0.6498585939,
-0.5163925886,
-0.3807314336,
0.241058439,
0.4750619829,
-0.768584609,
0.6759375334,
-0.1469460726,
-0.4524392188,
-0.5792833567,
0.3619306982,
-0.0706539825,
0.3236376345,
0.0680325702,
0.0334622636,
-0.285223484,
-0.7754048109,
-0.6338288784,
-0.2787549496,
-0.1748643368,
0.1972888708,
0.2745105922,
-0.2649386227,
0.74897331,
-0.4912537336,
-0.206716612,
-0.5604795218,
-0.1175362021,
-0.0651770383,
0.1293070763,
0.3917666972,
-1.0468201637,
-0.634209156,
-0.0289046373,
-0.5338714123,
-0.2271671295,
-0.0389418192,
-0.0032926982,
0.3707106113,
0.7403203249,
-0.726757884,
0.6092339754,
0.3455980718,
0.0803253353,
0.3285871744,
0.0564161837,
-0.0308739059,
-1.2024396658,
-0.3181954324,
0.1680526584,
-0.6133550406,
-0.6178910136,
-0.0095950626,
-0.1931241751,
-0.1319431663,
-0.542144835,
0.5531126857,
-0.2150576562,
0.2698142827,
-0.5794469118,
0.2360777259,
-0.3655457199,
0.2400980592,
-0.24028337,
0.3935904205,
0.578558147,
-0.4083706141,
0.5546652675,
-0.2529997528,
-0.371216923,
0.4858064651,
-0.6411414146,
0.208695814,
-0.1044935808,
0.5074763894,
-1.3229893446,
-0.466773808,
0.5235695243,
-0.7252463698,
0.3217006922,
-0.0663028359,
-1.1475907564,
-0.457110405,
-0.5239595175,
0.0634122044,
0.5722231865,
-0.3166409135,
0.7902400494,
0.8137614727,
-0.1544481814,
-0.4103989899,
-0.5964862704,
0.3363983929,
-0.3124260902,
-0.6707767248,
-0.0235813931,
0.0887184218,
-0.3199584484,
0.0562537648,
-0.003136443,
0.2098455876,
0.4433473647,
0.3534022868,
0.2714214027,
-0.0354472809,
0.2064877003,
-0.1568437964,
0.0201629084,
0.0700801238,
0.1857703775,
1.1175072193,
-0.026124388,
-0.6766024828,
-0.7683028579,
0.3988112807,
0.5133809447,
-0.0570624284,
0.7780792713,
0.7677599788,
-0.5717828274,
-0.2453495115,
-0.7199476361,
-0.1822398156,
-0.5619253516,
0.543058157,
0.1527798623,
-0.8706855178,
0.4269536138,
-0.0845193416,
0.0584541596,
0.3196884096,
0.7119871378,
-0.3463173211,
1.0032520294,
0.6317988038,
-0.3858370185,
0.6529492736,
-0.0757915974,
0.5105499625,
-0.4062036574,
0.0168194361,
-0.1981934309,
-0.437812984,
-0.7553973794,
-0.6282986999,
0.3508756757,
-0.2188101709,
-0.184897095,
0.3013049364,
-0.0844427422,
0.5216670036,
0.5210132003,
0.2443802953,
0.1552021354,
0.0877975374,
0.681103766,
0.4380734265,
-0.547328651,
-0.5667659044,
1.297693491,
0.4798561633,
0.9920560122,
0.1170471534,
0.3784699142,
0.8083150983,
0.2319966704,
-0.8075934052,
0.6899908185,
-0.0762073174,
-0.7675230503,
-0.3881082833,
-0.219945237,
-0.8308097124,
0.1701895595,
-0.1806382835,
-0.7451919913,
-0.2719877362,
0.0592046641,
-0.0449858457,
0.7336123586,
-0.578810513,
0.5323806405,
-0.3809106648,
-0.1860695034,
-0.3868685365,
-0.6972357035,
0.2729279995,
-0.2125941813,
0.3640260696,
-0.1929920465,
-0.0312002599,
0.3687876463,
-0.2053618431,
1.2323487997,
-0.0849825665,
-0.0969835743,
0.3525396883,
0.0150326071,
0.5882841349,
0.0197698511,
0.0466731489,
0.3132431209,
-0.5208855271,
-0.4188384414,
-0.2854080498,
0.4883553088,
-0.4365546405,
-0.887555778,
-0.2609192133,
-0.6887276769,
-0.0525036231,
0.1376788765,
0.2742656171,
0.0052911923,
-0.2159835249,
0.3451048732,
0.5225334764,
-0.4271181822,
0.1603812575,
0.3991645873,
-0.124125272,
-0.1370122135,
1.000685811,
0.0839432031,
0.4244123697,
0.3043708503,
0.2093694508,
-0.3280487955,
-0.4585166872,
-0.2389187962,
0.1703246832,
-0.6965277195,
-0.2233839333,
-0.773658216,
-0.2392959893,
-0.5656077266,
-0.2582207322,
-0.2761271894,
-0.0959964842,
-0.3374194503,
-0.0032928756,
0.5459296703,
0.6450408697,
-0.0867161453,
0.7429167032,
-0.5553378463,
0.3625114858,
0.1369268149,
0.1398006678,
-0.0074943234,
-0.5042413473,
-0.1047926396,
0.2608627975,
-0.2201523483,
-0.9170393348,
0.3345988691,
-0.202184096,
0.5691990256,
0.4630058706,
0.1992285252,
0.3572128713,
-0.4642769694,
0.5374100804,
0.1465277374,
-0.6305468082,
0.4026505351,
-0.4864183664,
-0.1381713152,
0.2795037329,
0.3094123304,
-0.7367251515,
-0.6148821712,
-0.3627034724,
-0.896281302,
0.5931696296,
-0.0959621668,
0.4724101424,
0.0118472893,
-0.0023946811,
0.0473735183,
0.3165525794,
-0.727057457,
-0.2102096528,
0.3171425164,
-0.1498630196,
-0.1656239182,
-0.0654601827,
-0.3030841351,
-0.01260499,
0.3753976822,
0.0411208794,
0.1274425834,
-0.3830298483,
-0.3779508173,
-0.1911126822,
0.046602957,
0.1889185458,
0.3434734941,
0.0574362949,
-0.0405817181,
-0.0092329001,
-0.0882427245,
-0.2789164782,
0.0840000734,
-0.0413876362,
-0.0282071289,
0.4743901789,
0.5967971683,
-0.0571385659,
-0.8405508995,
0.6402872205,
0.0923535749,
-0.1644137204,
-0.3845421076,
0.1829268634,
0.2262661755,
0.2411037534,
0.6214541197,
0.0321923606,
-0.0101236673,
-0.6916883588,
0.0467431247,
0.6428027749,
-0.2861735225,
-0.4315291941,
0.4234400392,
0.0876549408,
-0.7033627033,
0.0851125643,
-0.0043797162,
-0.8482601643,
0.5943470597,
0.250705868,
0.8662291765,
-0.1762267053,
0.321356535,
-0.3523291945,
0.5169565082,
0.0396322235,
0.1843967289,
0.1383420229,
-0.7805056572,
-0.2214213163,
-0.2108727545,
-0.4310879111,
0.2950864434,
-0.3302488923,
0.5075895786,
-0.6056073308,
-0.0919671953,
0.3484198153,
-0.323605001,
-0.6889865994,
-0.4155177474,
0.4483839571,
0.7485814095,
-0.7858650684,
0.4180279374,
0.4855600893,
-0.1246116906,
-0.315286845,
0.2651886046,
0.3538481891,
-0.8991586566,
0.4030518532,
0.345531255,
-0.1844349653,
-0.2497385591,
-1.0830202103,
-0.4134303033,
0.5245364904,
0.3609642684,
-0.5342516899,
0.1661594361,
0.2425379008,
0.5264828801,
-0.1785374731,
-0.1929523051,
0.2532646656,
0.4754032791,
-0.0817577168,
-0.6273453832,
-0.0543942377,
0.0010613929,
-0.1032481939,
-0.0185178798,
-0.7812786698,
0.8307006359,
-0.069571577,
-0.3502851129,
-0.0091575086,
0.3891831338,
0.0238231607,
0.2947065234,
0.7085386515,
0.2460262626,
0.6350799203,
0.1021050513,
1.056888938,
-0.2082119286,
0.0531101078,
0.8901728988,
-0.5684074759,
0.7670833468,
0.1947973371,
0.0250153691,
0.3220759332,
0.8369978666,
-0.1450439692,
0.1410752237,
0.365804255,
-0.3636590242,
-0.4652378857,
-0.1179012731,
-0.3300864995,
0.5538598299,
0.6292465925,
-0.2624936998,
-0.1582702994,
0.0728857294,
0.1025583073,
0.302679956,
-0.171996668,
0.5639253259,
-0.0652776882,
-0.3279684782,
0.2974228859,
0.019950211,
0.9265384078,
-0.4486739337,
0.0678337589,
0.1165385842,
0.1952690333,
-0.049760554,
-0.9038654566,
0.0390188806,
0.1255613863,
0.1489088535,
-0.1100190505,
0.955489099,
-0.3472226858,
-0.5634949207,
0.5068397522,
0.5723708868,
0.0909436122,
-0.3807992637,
-0.6602423191,
0.0032519475,
-0.2696701288,
-0.2124915421,
0.3536007404,
0.5337126255,
-0.0831393823,
0.9594164491,
0.9765244126,
0.1099861339,
0.1441171467,
0.044070214,
1.161694169,
-0.4507381916,
-0.1985286027,
-1.0859999657,
0.2428822815,
-0.3528757393,
-0.0418113135,
0.8411653638,
0.3813867569,
1.0410654545,
0.0602468997,
1.0118596554,
-0.0652732924,
0.6139881015,
-0.2130059302,
0.8771956563,
-0.7054006457,
0.4509199858,
-0.3071746826,
-0.6160660982,
-0.2833756804,
0.3040066957,
-0.3960814476,
-0.0041174204,
0.2346500903,
0.7807043791,
0.1657812297,
-0.1181622967,
0.3508814275,
0.1631185412,
0.6102741361,
0.2361213863,
1.0551909208,
-0.0354684182,
0.5044951439,
-0.0036850984,
-0.2155935466,
-0.6361445189,
-0.4862243533,
-1.1143766642,
-0.3384443521,
-0.2032206059,
-0.4928046763,
0.0048394697,
0.8295938373,
0.504483223,
-0.5834499598,
-0.0880738646,
0.1598834097,
0.5181055069,
0.0958831161,
-0.2482302189,
0.1137124673,
-0.1827769578,
-0.8342721462,
0.2238523662,
0.2631830275,
-0.0344268903,
-0.4195723534,
0.0994950756,
-0.4104916751,
0.0700858906,
0.6103253365,
0.3088737428,
-0.8756164312,
-0.2568693757,
0.1313042045,
-0.1459420025,
-0.103801325,
0.432618618,
-0.286567688,
0.5410234332,
0.5717469454,
0.9317476153,
0.1113482341,
-0.0631599277,
0.668059051,
-0.5316929817,
0.2354307026,
0.3367991447,
0.3960479498,
0.3301739693,
-0.4961176217,
0.322724998,
0.3154850304,
-0.3031560481,
-1.1237457991,
0.3126298785,
-1.0091348886,
-0.6347260475,
1.4559079409,
0.1278791726,
-0.2858934999,
-0.1608173102,
-0.207233116,
0.2801070511,
-0.5135239959,
0.8560505509,
0.843859911,
0.327806145,
0.0593544729,
-0.7144963145,
0.1541012526,
0.0676934198,
-0.470066756,
0.1332710087,
0.404964298,
0.2884809375,
0.0454599559,
0.5167833567,
-0.0635654107,
0.2727931142,
-0.309157759,
-0.0094730332,
0.0880386755,
-0.199788779,
-0.3015628457,
-0.1438951194,
-0.2710102499,
-0.4407505393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00367v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00367v2
|
Don't Hallucinate, Abstain: Identifying LLM Knowledge Gaps via Multi-LLM Collaboration
| 2024-02-01T06:11:49 | 2024-07-01T01:34:09 |
Shangbin Feng, Weijia Shi, Yike Wang, Wenxuan Ding, Vidhisha Balachandran, Yulia Tsvetkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite efforts to expand the knowledge of large language models (LLMs),
knowledge gaps -- missing or outdated information in LLMs -- might always
persist given the evolving nature of knowledge. In this work, we study
approaches to identify LLM knowledge gaps and abstain from answering questions
when knowledge gaps are present. We first adapt existing approaches to model
calibration or adaptation through fine-tuning/prompting and analyze their
ability to abstain from generating low-confidence outputs. Motivated by their
failures in self-reflection and over-reliance on held-out sets, we propose two
novel approaches that are based on model collaboration, i.e., LLMs probing
other LLMs for knowledge gaps, either cooperatively or competitively. Extensive
experiments with three LLMs on four QA tasks featuring diverse knowledge
domains demonstrate that both cooperative and competitive approaches to
unveiling LLM knowledge gaps achieve up to 19.3% improvements on abstain
accuracy against the strongest baseline. Further analysis reveals that our
proposed mechanisms could help identify failure cases in retrieval augmentation
and pinpoint knowledge gaps in multi-hop reasoning.
|
[
-0.6321359277,
-0.8722571135,
0.9644632936,
-0.0494638085,
0.1420268267,
0.4194832742,
-0.1583143771,
-0.4421690702,
0.1019472703,
0.6122869849,
-0.6957421303,
-0.3903826475,
-0.4855595827,
-0.0101517998,
0.0005841962,
0.4487643838,
-0.1919544488,
0.0017297181,
-0.7291162014,
-0.1917588115,
-0.8916072845,
-0.4520472884,
-0.1351771653,
-0.4701507688,
0.538706243,
0.6442952752,
0.3822940588,
0.3647420704,
0.4340188801,
0.2373580039,
0.0391211659,
0.6921604276,
-0.5031607747,
0.2211085707,
-0.1316126287,
-0.4399329722,
-0.4079220295,
-0.064998664,
0.3860592842,
0.9179592133,
0.0203450099,
0.0525664724,
0.3426698148,
0.7875347733,
-0.9071634412,
0.1702754945,
-0.9207617044,
-0.0819148868,
-0.1146623418,
-0.2304489017,
-0.5113677382,
-0.1487888545,
-0.0040974887,
-0.5952883959,
0.2059655041,
-0.1539607197,
0.5970029831,
0.5865471363,
-0.2425352782,
-0.2667551935,
-0.6343789101,
0.8368082643,
-0.619412601,
0.584137857,
0.5981797576,
0.1051334739,
-0.3347340524,
-0.2356252819,
-0.4835004807,
-0.1476620585,
-0.0036494597,
0.2268023193,
-0.0043622758,
-0.0306397807,
-0.0216637738,
0.1138578132,
-0.3327580094,
0.0776908249,
-0.2676030099,
-0.0828683004,
0.3874114156,
0.0080961818,
0.2060428411,
0.2572106123,
-0.3624935746,
0.1384949535,
-1.1096000671,
-0.1880832165,
-0.0179445483,
0.2000454962,
0.1169836372,
0.7579861879,
-0.0808427408,
0.5684384108,
-0.0121363392,
0.16971533,
0.1248092949,
-0.3614574671,
-0.1799731553,
-0.2567927241,
0.6150966883,
0.1360666901,
0.1655418277,
-0.3638817966,
-0.1227218136,
-0.150359109,
0.1178159267,
-0.2272159606,
-0.2351510376,
0.2513991296,
-0.1469478309,
0.0603080206,
0.0201374236,
-0.7310423851,
-0.6171348095,
-0.227490738,
0.785176158,
-0.1893080175,
-0.3372538686,
-0.0596626326,
-0.0975037664,
0.1238392293,
0.2893359661,
-0.7308945656,
0.3570474982,
0.629283309,
0.792181015,
-0.1787585169,
-0.5286948085,
-0.5270022154,
0.4689695239,
-0.4219418168,
0.5447323322,
-0.3307906985,
-0.2944410443,
-0.2186371833,
0.0112110833,
-0.2388791293,
-0.8530600071,
0.1269755214,
-0.5930453539,
0.0269100294,
-0.6365429163,
-0.7637040615,
-0.3097755909,
0.3817133009,
-0.6842038035,
0.5361708403,
0.0167581197,
-0.594168663,
0.0994440094,
-0.4693334401,
-0.1228861958,
-0.0021185274,
-0.4100754261,
-0.107311219,
0.1290320456,
0.392477721,
0.2323791534,
-0.1858322322,
0.2293395549,
-0.4391525984,
-0.2364622951,
0.2978149951,
-0.3077763319,
0.6371246576,
-0.0309224967,
-0.1342507154,
0.1778383106,
-0.5012146235,
0.0257802345,
0.0016720156,
-0.0684655979,
-0.5019022226,
0.1257016957,
-0.6452754736,
0.2838521004,
0.2904547751,
-0.2405750751,
0.1360132843,
-0.3204036355,
0.0849008933,
0.7364708781,
0.1687614918,
0.2634499371,
-0.7844880819,
0.562918365,
0.1014525592,
0.0962325707,
-0.0726025105,
-0.4266224205,
-1.0123366117,
-0.129921481,
0.0493539907,
0.4926079214,
-0.978910625,
0.6318953633,
-0.0589305162,
-0.4222625792,
-0.6898738146,
0.4219625294,
0.3496138453,
0.5875205398,
0.5593883395,
-0.2639950216,
-0.5025510788,
-0.5205306411,
-0.2181375325,
-0.3259277344,
-0.0352494381,
0.2068085074,
0.4238121808,
-0.0448848829,
0.8484018445,
-0.3692971766,
-0.2898998857,
-0.1537386924,
-0.1475014687,
0.134967193,
0.495377779,
0.111360319,
-0.53194803,
-0.3896407485,
-0.1368795782,
-0.932975769,
-0.0905901566,
-0.0722599775,
-0.1464100331,
0.0543485507,
0.5733724833,
-0.5166285634,
0.2481704652,
0.6708569527,
-0.1772317588,
0.4413342774,
0.0141232926,
0.0753368288,
-0.9510454535,
-0.0917498991,
-0.2230295986,
-0.0728241354,
-0.6964089274,
0.1647767425,
0.0190654658,
0.4531083107,
-0.1787655205,
0.699837625,
-0.6613978148,
0.0231041629,
-0.1445453167,
0.4655311406,
0.2579118609,
0.4177926183,
0.2587146461,
0.6093719602,
0.4525440037,
-0.6945886612,
0.0746761262,
0.5742201209,
-0.1517930329,
0.1096594557,
-0.4187874198,
0.3574104011,
0.1399970353,
-0.1409383565,
-0.8808799386,
-0.1493505687,
0.4571229517,
-0.4856040776,
0.0425958633,
-0.2301175743,
-0.2877346575,
-0.107569702,
-0.2690484822,
0.4062033594,
0.2062540352,
-0.6479047537,
0.5064898133,
0.432549715,
-0.1905703098,
-0.7483806014,
-0.665353179,
-0.1498340666,
-0.1059715748,
-0.7299972177,
0.1631075889,
-0.2398780435,
-0.6091077924,
-0.038118992,
-0.3250416219,
-0.2174513489,
0.2966923118,
0.3085688353,
0.3997451663,
-0.1310794801,
0.3120003641,
-0.0347156487,
0.1450695992,
0.0854479596,
-0.1692643762,
0.5406907201,
0.0691350475,
-0.8964291811,
-0.2866084874,
0.3208279014,
0.4668376744,
-0.2300051302,
0.8026277423,
0.2955873907,
-0.4255816936,
-0.1570111811,
-0.9710976481,
-0.511610508,
-0.4772929251,
0.0964324474,
-0.389788121,
-1.0260870457,
0.5947611332,
-0.1193358675,
0.0005445601,
0.2157845646,
0.467466265,
0.1539976299,
0.5745244026,
0.8721264005,
0.0154715609,
0.1647966206,
0.0357555524,
0.2181716263,
-0.8763669133,
-0.3807067871,
-0.4583327174,
0.1101532727,
-0.3580330312,
-0.612780869,
0.4954127371,
0.4816829264,
0.1070123538,
0.1403841823,
-0.1427592486,
0.5473879576,
0.3611412346,
0.039747525,
0.6560908556,
-0.2307970226,
-0.1010048464,
-0.0809827819,
-0.7196012735,
-0.2207679152,
0.9871523976,
0.2524018586,
0.6182886362,
0.1957354993,
0.813113749,
0.041497007,
0.0513209961,
-0.8339340687,
0.3372952342,
0.2351952195,
-0.4785098433,
-0.5734212995,
-0.6588888764,
-0.6482958198,
0.3931128681,
-0.0967673734,
-0.7124969959,
0.3209324777,
-0.1002108753,
-0.4170213342,
0.2440457195,
-0.6237858534,
0.7276189923,
-0.1151061803,
-0.453861773,
-0.1181348935,
-0.5050649643,
0.5784234405,
-0.5853599906,
0.4356491864,
-0.1924832463,
-0.0115586743,
0.5396130085,
-0.278341651,
0.8815347552,
0.0261919461,
-0.3773372471,
0.3038948476,
0.3051878512,
0.5929363966,
0.0445104837,
-0.1856340617,
0.1621457636,
-0.0775604621,
-0.3286125958,
-0.4996678233,
0.5185701847,
-0.6596168876,
-0.6933351755,
-0.1618027091,
-0.7422093153,
-0.7697572112,
0.2213519663,
0.0567541011,
-0.110276185,
-0.3089394271,
-0.0762455389,
0.700296104,
-0.28283301,
0.453525424,
0.5763312578,
-0.1192211583,
-0.4326199889,
0.7489392161,
0.0486151837,
0.5874022245,
0.2643640041,
0.0145418793,
-0.4668950438,
-0.7342708111,
-0.0971084088,
0.3491071463,
-0.7349241972,
-0.0572739504,
-0.6285353899,
-0.3308433592,
-0.6757283807,
-0.0420177318,
-0.3883332014,
-0.268458724,
-0.2536993027,
0.0389757156,
0.1146801412,
0.8216626048,
-0.2811792493,
0.0411182046,
-1.0542496443,
0.1915614158,
0.3397810161,
0.110699892,
0.0980756655,
-0.5033253431,
-0.1335946023,
-0.0082274694,
-0.3176985085,
-0.9227095246,
0.4918218851,
-0.0644456819,
0.8605242372,
0.2116584778,
0.2942108512,
0.9043427706,
-0.2062888443,
0.5565211773,
0.2394660711,
-1.1497713327,
0.3812674582,
-0.2563334107,
0.1091829911,
0.5539140105,
0.3600353599,
-0.6779010892,
-0.6088431478,
-0.3268701434,
-0.9447484016,
0.4670008123,
0.1415762156,
-0.161103949,
0.1786391437,
0.3180229068,
0.2529848516,
0.3353623152,
-0.7822973728,
-0.1069395319,
0.1864566058,
-0.0481575057,
0.0734337196,
-0.0670802519,
-0.4481112957,
-0.2459436059,
0.6922528148,
-0.2096497715,
-0.0802358761,
0.2538805902,
-0.4322591722,
-0.2410757691,
0.3506264389,
0.4051076472,
1.1679310799,
0.0558310635,
0.3930802345,
0.3347089291,
-0.1880474687,
-0.030643357,
-0.0763541535,
-0.1288940012,
-0.0800612047,
0.4490400553,
0.3736394942,
-0.2668345273,
-0.5691204071,
0.4168044627,
0.1391143799,
-0.2136133462,
-0.2284157723,
0.0156720132,
0.2719878852,
0.3755303919,
0.2131567299,
-0.0804531202,
-0.230011344,
-0.5022813678,
0.4497662187,
0.5662508011,
-0.5595332384,
-0.0788982809,
0.4901027083,
0.0926119611,
0.0510490015,
0.5026747584,
-0.1646258384,
-0.2518064678,
0.5555711985,
0.4004223943,
0.7206823826,
-0.2720678151,
0.3112624288,
0.0513686128,
0.4357159734,
-0.2820925713,
0.2730270922,
0.1009121537,
-1.0596293211,
-0.6255864501,
-0.2275212258,
-0.5354516506,
0.3701153398,
-0.6890964508,
0.1504908651,
-0.3643632829,
0.1949217767,
-0.1544181108,
0.0839443132,
-0.305167824,
-0.2944009006,
-0.0330619439,
0.658301115,
-0.8194271922,
0.8155135512,
0.3166179359,
-0.5138420463,
-0.6962472796,
0.3451849222,
0.3144163191,
-0.7644632459,
0.1949301362,
0.1199789196,
-0.1889027357,
0.099722594,
-0.5453133583,
-0.7055640221,
1.0661023855,
0.325853914,
-0.8667023182,
0.1438587755,
0.0429100394,
0.1644123793,
-0.2201813161,
0.1024149433,
0.4144227505,
0.6309931278,
0.2715542316,
-1.0277401209,
0.2045656294,
0.0841362327,
-0.4338173866,
0.0714842752,
-0.6901567578,
0.7561767697,
-0.4436055422,
-0.0350077897,
0.2278118581,
0.4203704298,
0.6220507026,
0.4806436598,
0.6740344167,
0.303429991,
1.1054953337,
0.0173208639,
0.2848588824,
-0.1595808715,
0.2275862098,
1.3324097395,
-0.6416887641,
0.7418559194,
0.7239342928,
0.1047382951,
0.1943740547,
0.4824538529,
-0.2073912323,
0.409576118,
0.1367158592,
-0.5057054162,
-0.6918197274,
-0.2247104198,
-0.4197352231,
0.3588425815,
0.512382865,
-0.0376014784,
-0.1761308759,
-0.1644970924,
-0.0026314608,
0.0407995805,
-0.0973298028,
0.8157970309,
0.2449777871,
-0.9165537357,
0.6086749434,
-0.3028931618,
0.4254519343,
-0.28618747,
-0.198234573,
-0.3219915926,
0.163122654,
-0.1740087867,
-0.5273182988,
0.2188661695,
-0.2873860896,
-0.1501314789,
0.0231635515,
0.760522306,
-0.613417685,
-0.2667879462,
0.5961714387,
1.3695465326,
0.2247539312,
-0.2300831378,
-0.4715949595,
0.0521731675,
-0.007411819,
0.1426438093,
0.2172119021,
0.3930813372,
-0.012056238,
0.7666662335,
0.5105246305,
0.1372838765,
0.0598413497,
0.2327962071,
1.0004428625,
-0.6542606354,
0.0197473057,
-1.0611400604,
0.2559500039,
0.0449251831,
0.0923243091,
0.8627638817,
0.4138558507,
0.9426212311,
0.157880187,
1.0181032419,
0.1160656586,
0.4997545183,
-0.7300693393,
0.7357262373,
-0.6777886748,
0.7792602777,
-0.2920570076,
-0.6882660389,
-0.3199029267,
0.3725571632,
-0.121041134,
0.0743235648,
0.7621057034,
0.9084123373,
0.2063456178,
-0.1479716897,
0.5143374801,
0.1893768311,
0.2705369592,
0.683863759,
1.1774991751,
-0.110795632,
0.5817965269,
-0.1893862337,
-0.1917720884,
-0.0624853484,
-0.6414990425,
-1.0429791212,
-0.4710381627,
-0.3263242245,
-0.3525381386,
0.197055012,
0.7334392667,
0.6980025172,
-0.8592905998,
-0.2746825218,
-0.2119166106,
0.7174704671,
-0.3479308486,
-0.146576643,
0.230244115,
-0.5255099535,
-0.5368802547,
0.9474037886,
0.1578907371,
0.1394682825,
-0.4371706247,
-0.1673720181,
-0.2192277014,
0.0331731029,
0.29477036,
0.2953697741,
-0.7684406042,
-0.2611948848,
0.3708839417,
0.2860130966,
0.0754794404,
0.6427962184,
-0.6490795612,
0.3189822435,
0.6289829016,
0.6788671613,
0.2554697096,
0.0899680629,
0.6652815938,
-0.9464097619,
-0.0007219606,
0.2368083149,
0.1309120059,
0.2550223172,
-0.2422091365,
0.5758635998,
0.4139146209,
-0.6564882994,
-0.8410004973,
0.3662664294,
-0.7029740214,
-0.5598034263,
1.1478177309,
-0.2973341942,
-0.0181878339,
-0.6527265906,
0.2211750448,
0.3076300919,
-0.0435907394,
1.0586956739,
1.0026142597,
-0.2379235625,
-0.2828397155,
-0.684006393,
0.3970599473,
0.4927792549,
-0.8987458348,
0.3419218063,
0.6249051094,
0.3145383596,
0.3635076582,
0.74949646,
-0.1503937542,
-0.0171044059,
-0.0348972157,
0.1333720833,
-0.0761669129,
-0.5916742682,
-0.3482844234,
0.1460280716,
0.3114897907,
-0.2624749839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00345v1
|
IndiVec: An Exploration of Leveraging Large Language Models for Media Bias Detection with Fine-Grained Bias Indicators
| 2024-02-01T05:20:07 | 2024-02-01T05:20:07 |
Luyang Lin, Lingzhi Wang, Xiaoyan Zhao, Jing Li, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study focuses on media bias detection, crucial in today's era of
influential social media platforms shaping individual attitudes and opinions.
In contrast to prior work that primarily relies on training specific models
tailored to particular datasets, resulting in limited adaptability and subpar
performance on out-of-domain data, we introduce a general bias detection
framework, IndiVec, built upon large language models. IndiVec begins by
constructing a fine-grained media bias database, leveraging the robust
instruction-following capabilities of large language models and vector database
techniques. When confronted with new input for bias detection, our framework
automatically selects the most relevant indicator from the vector database and
employs majority voting to determine the input's bias label. IndiVec excels
compared to previous methods due to its adaptability (demonstrating consistent
performance across diverse datasets from various sources) and explainability
(providing explicit top-k indicators to interpret bias predictions).
Experimental results on four political bias datasets highlight IndiVec's
significant superiority over baselines. Furthermore, additional experiments and
analysis provide profound insights into the framework's effectiveness.
|
[
-0.7819927335,
-0.7239771485,
0.4066305757,
0.2656190991,
-0.0291942786,
-0.0463938937,
-0.6519414186,
-0.0426799133,
0.1037345529,
0.2194458097,
-0.6209803224,
-0.696626842,
-0.7524472475,
-0.3522296846,
-0.6343595386,
1.0641046762,
0.2206784487,
0.2998270094,
0.0093648387,
-0.4663951993,
-0.3063881695,
-0.1419959515,
-0.3250889182,
-0.4339974225,
0.182194382,
0.626209259,
0.5431360602,
0.4632265866,
0.2433248907,
0.1131524816,
-0.0744930431,
0.1702915579,
-0.6707084179,
-0.1174995005,
-0.5182233453,
-0.3058822453,
-0.0034550556,
0.1135719866,
0.5521425605,
0.43124488,
0.2850837111,
0.3681860566,
0.2549525499,
0.9249773622,
-1.0237336159,
-0.0156235192,
-0.9504327774,
0.0478047468,
-0.3938402832,
-0.4299202561,
-0.5687801838,
-0.5001718998,
-0.230156824,
-0.1395063698,
0.2410614043,
-0.3809206486,
0.4872407317,
0.111467585,
-0.5207788944,
-0.5414441824,
-0.909979403,
0.7466115952,
-0.4615338743,
0.4542860091,
0.4474081993,
0.1642297357,
-0.1800549328,
-0.4178029597,
-0.5792507529,
0.1418400556,
0.3869274855,
0.186597243,
-0.1036519036,
-0.1199980229,
0.0800522864,
0.3729308546,
-0.2745380104,
0.2943174243,
-0.1693846434,
0.0482962318,
0.3710810542,
-0.0926317796,
0.199683249,
-0.1253148466,
-0.0957592055,
0.1828952432,
-0.8641222715,
0.017043218,
0.6719028354,
0.3735660613,
-0.1462313682,
0.5668776035,
-0.3078534305,
0.4273633659,
0.3950558305,
0.2155542672,
-0.0800053254,
0.0086241812,
-0.1685237139,
0.1118897647,
0.7567124367,
0.5117262006,
0.3686814308,
0.2503992617,
-0.1345647573,
0.4616509676,
0.0030538538,
-0.8503642678,
-0.249757275,
0.1557019055,
-0.8978613019,
-0.3079956174,
0.1560461968,
-1.0289571285,
-0.953836143,
-0.4467429817,
0.140652284,
-0.1325243711,
-0.4613893628,
-0.1784528643,
0.1978016198,
0.3479899466,
0.1590930223,
-0.825848937,
0.1363857538,
0.7494801879,
0.8020070195,
-0.3701568246,
0.080755122,
-0.7229269147,
-0.3528528512,
-0.4784572423,
0.9627907872,
-0.9780271053,
-0.0951956287,
0.5983695984,
0.0864307955,
0.4085756242,
-0.5992190838,
0.7222617865,
-0.4568083286,
0.1146132126,
-0.4361157119,
-0.6212991476,
0.0898346826,
0.2075457573,
-0.6940909028,
0.9415483475,
0.1458212882,
-1.0592784882,
0.8113769293,
-0.618566215,
-0.4057076871,
-0.2427827716,
-0.3063817322,
-0.1985449642,
0.0994027108,
0.4897114933,
0.5992637277,
-0.333399564,
0.2246706784,
-0.5585756302,
-0.2980859578,
0.3354039788,
-0.5112991929,
0.8789386153,
0.3100961745,
-0.3933219612,
0.2041429877,
-0.7198383212,
-0.3427826166,
-0.1892264336,
-0.4811033607,
-0.581808269,
0.1894244999,
0.1926907599,
0.2618282437,
-0.1883684397,
-0.5955649614,
0.1021319553,
0.1852828562,
0.4081788659,
0.8371168375,
0.1082884744,
0.8606007099,
0.1643274724,
0.303183198,
-0.0254638437,
0.1016098857,
-0.0901441202,
-0.1959543377,
-0.700021565,
-0.1225371733,
0.3389397562,
0.2753320336,
-0.5427108407,
0.3526311815,
-0.0536105484,
-0.210835427,
-0.4517875314,
0.2336801738,
-0.0713232458,
0.132980898,
0.2522956431,
-0.187927261,
-0.5438960195,
-0.7603788972,
-0.6632005572,
-0.0308116451,
-0.0666048676,
0.0770029426,
0.3726694286,
-0.3180877566,
0.7540130019,
-0.0250770319,
-0.4871736765,
-0.2409728318,
0.1834169924,
0.2628090978,
0.2031489909,
0.2417214513,
-0.5857733488,
-0.5664334893,
0.1819626987,
-0.7063977122,
-0.3287650645,
-0.3161449134,
-0.069918029,
0.0190817602,
0.7237818837,
-0.204958424,
0.4747029543,
0.69198668,
-0.4019201696,
0.2971004844,
0.2681083977,
0.2158858329,
-0.7704643011,
-0.1721481979,
0.554230988,
-0.1824329793,
-0.520219624,
-0.4782140255,
0.1795348078,
0.3750184178,
-0.3342027366,
0.3963867426,
-0.3171627522,
-0.0147334486,
-0.3935745656,
-0.0117943343,
-0.0950388834,
0.1459027231,
-0.1093505919,
0.6065393686,
0.1807974577,
-0.5107677579,
-0.0673017576,
-0.1313925833,
-0.8563620448,
0.7745932937,
-0.2204351425,
0.126327455,
-0.3741794229,
0.2021603584,
-1.0135411024,
-0.2808845043,
0.0108348019,
-0.5348555446,
0.243760556,
-0.438331753,
-0.267718792,
-0.1074679568,
-0.3041167855,
0.1649264991,
0.1241158396,
-0.8926540017,
0.7638382912,
0.8453257084,
0.0627492964,
-0.6776537299,
-0.5664857626,
-0.2614524066,
-0.2827732265,
-0.3265742064,
0.0779301897,
0.2694616318,
-0.3518281579,
-0.0786104277,
0.0036574095,
-0.0016067992,
-0.2955248058,
0.3017347157,
0.042439267,
-0.0693944991,
0.2955612242,
0.1758895963,
0.2023963481,
0.1466535777,
-0.2461814284,
0.6869008541,
-0.1287506521,
-0.2896866798,
-0.4971873462,
0.246196121,
0.6828933358,
-0.2542205751,
0.4322250485,
0.8876488805,
-0.4290964305,
-0.5476438999,
-0.8045712709,
-0.312844336,
-0.4106246531,
0.450387001,
0.0407573953,
-0.68122226,
0.7119612694,
-0.1373635232,
0.035436634,
0.3862006068,
1.0158867836,
0.3002119362,
1.1422537565,
0.6095424294,
-0.5025157928,
0.7925391793,
-0.2173689753,
0.2312943339,
-0.7021695971,
0.0024809791,
-0.4624409974,
-0.2818528414,
-0.6497456431,
-0.3033265173,
-0.0030157957,
-0.2658196986,
-0.5169408917,
-0.0384760611,
-0.8044016361,
0.7033913732,
0.3612630963,
-0.1010012776,
0.3140426278,
0.1010825336,
0.189290002,
-0.1567305028,
-0.4647703171,
-0.4424889088,
1.1422532797,
0.6733734608,
1.1686805487,
-0.2123470008,
0.1413183063,
0.7498316765,
0.9291030169,
-0.7893697619,
0.1513348222,
-0.2491424978,
-0.884260416,
0.0424296632,
-0.2160505205,
-0.4036512077,
0.241014272,
-0.4020010829,
-0.6582037807,
0.6498464942,
0.0499535613,
-0.232919544,
0.628703475,
-0.7069352269,
0.7380244732,
-0.0557499006,
-0.6924117208,
-0.2094052881,
-0.2222225368,
0.4830021858,
0.3762335181,
0.2647172213,
-0.2967656255,
0.247723341,
0.6976208091,
0.1032816172,
0.7589371204,
-0.3938993514,
0.0041959109,
0.4003459215,
0.1434499472,
0.5746281147,
0.2076238245,
-0.0308802519,
0.0692900121,
-0.2287928909,
0.0800945386,
-0.2264445424,
0.9949060082,
-0.6719300747,
0.0276715234,
-0.1911994517,
-0.4333576262,
-0.1782483459,
0.0083649335,
0.3318297267,
0.3852825463,
-0.618781209,
0.515350461,
0.7757151127,
-0.2606150806,
0.2327699959,
0.3741180003,
-0.2447584271,
-0.2877370119,
0.7258856297,
0.1741904318,
0.0234973338,
0.25973019,
0.2249935269,
-0.1757901013,
-0.3134837151,
-0.3981366456,
-0.0312164929,
-0.8667274117,
-0.388696909,
-0.7375718951,
-0.0295610018,
-0.1031946242,
-0.1673962474,
-0.7659396529,
-0.0952629521,
-0.1716991663,
-0.0776328966,
0.1608079523,
0.8365436196,
-0.14642407,
0.4456017613,
-0.0363685898,
0.248822853,
0.3077145219,
0.6069282889,
-0.0346209444,
-0.5599083304,
-0.1761458814,
-0.1365495473,
-0.3114404082,
-0.8831615448,
0.3207407296,
0.0581244752,
0.0256263576,
0.9795542359,
0.0561906882,
0.1487508714,
-0.3092139959,
0.4084762633,
-0.0110211521,
-0.8817349672,
0.287638694,
-0.5073074698,
0.2957190871,
0.805447638,
0.4296344817,
-0.4845899343,
-0.236527577,
-0.2839513421,
-0.6259334683,
0.4214624763,
-0.0724769831,
0.1454829276,
-0.080179356,
0.022534091,
0.1413986385,
0.0103466241,
-0.8101926446,
-0.1404941976,
-0.2768152654,
-0.3513967395,
0.3732983172,
-0.3964570165,
-0.2063166946,
-0.3074685037,
0.7507929206,
-0.3124594986,
0.0745602027,
0.0315500312,
-0.096505776,
-0.2818457484,
0.3740588725,
0.3236771524,
0.7164647579,
-0.2622758448,
0.0046826932,
-0.0282311216,
-0.4159528315,
-0.1721392423,
0.0347344428,
-0.3459127545,
0.1207257137,
0.1024327874,
0.4795460403,
-0.2707581222,
-0.4910102487,
0.6881821156,
-0.1492150426,
0.0733455718,
-0.5392574072,
-0.3585927784,
0.1066009998,
0.1478540897,
0.493399471,
-0.0290033631,
0.3480062783,
-0.721250236,
0.1313173771,
0.8007728457,
-1.0117372274,
-0.2780398726,
0.577665627,
0.3382676542,
0.1030507013,
0.1771398187,
-0.1430809498,
-0.4008396268,
0.6287595034,
0.3380781412,
0.8530723453,
-0.2875367105,
0.244660005,
0.3062456548,
0.5894501805,
-0.136682272,
-0.0766327158,
0.136658594,
-0.9724519253,
-0.4723752737,
-0.3025591671,
-0.1512459666,
0.5807150602,
-0.6920313239,
0.4256305695,
-0.7705861926,
-0.3635556996,
0.4056550264,
-0.1310295314,
-0.9081283212,
-0.0463428572,
0.3037470579,
0.905644536,
-1.2021173239,
0.6435809731,
0.5404912233,
0.0298290011,
-0.5295677781,
0.1417046636,
0.4702695012,
-0.5968755484,
0.269462347,
0.3192959726,
0.0100931479,
-0.3941468596,
-0.8718546033,
-0.380858779,
0.6833032966,
0.1905425489,
-0.4045492113,
0.3711556494,
-0.091967307,
0.3285388947,
-0.8736727238,
0.459079355,
1.0205606222,
0.3785905242,
-0.3411563039,
-0.3618966341,
-0.1956949383,
-0.1613565236,
-0.0975747034,
0.254039824,
-0.5773911476,
0.7785925269,
0.1332394779,
-0.204810977,
-0.4555125535,
0.7840019464,
-0.1894398034,
0.3867502809,
0.5289960504,
0.2599133253,
0.5758122802,
-0.1795710027,
0.8572103381,
-0.3807201684,
0.2990393043,
1.2287991047,
-0.3049604595,
0.5701779127,
0.4328412712,
0.0050987429,
0.6596704125,
0.4977284968,
0.1381011903,
0.4659688175,
0.0488729216,
-0.5306286216,
-0.2105796039,
-0.5848177075,
-0.1929618567,
0.5168101788,
0.7828991413,
-0.6062669158,
-0.1777240038,
0.1153087318,
0.3046068251,
0.5216621757,
-0.7099217176,
0.5449137092,
-0.0311269369,
-0.6809072495,
0.2544169426,
-0.050191924,
0.9715403318,
-0.4574419856,
0.0141158681,
-0.3742534518,
0.6245029569,
-0.4770819843,
-0.8907570243,
0.0177271124,
0.1380118132,
-0.2565052807,
0.1963674873,
1.0091450214,
-0.4841460884,
-0.3944222033,
0.3397248387,
0.3857967854,
-0.358264327,
-0.2243065536,
-0.3548489213,
0.6384527087,
0.1234418452,
-0.1672023535,
0.2606640458,
0.6094909906,
-0.1000874713,
0.5699658394,
0.5248741508,
0.0205766186,
-0.1401091814,
0.3017875254,
0.9865596294,
-0.201739192,
-0.2558722794,
-0.7718483806,
0.3028341234,
-0.3062361181,
-0.3868237734,
0.7666156888,
0.4894510806,
1.0580060482,
-0.149783954,
1.1624199152,
-0.1793989539,
0.5663455725,
-0.3496060967,
0.7204908133,
-0.1185159534,
0.0793485194,
-0.3476575911,
-0.9704204202,
-0.2619974911,
0.737627089,
-0.3832373023,
-0.0036069758,
0.4161971807,
0.976565063,
-0.2643048167,
0.1759859622,
-0.1632717997,
0.2954389751,
0.436389029,
0.1762890518,
0.897015214,
-0.1062689349,
0.3270748854,
-0.3029679954,
-0.4582469761,
-0.2358822376,
-0.7541096807,
-1.283085227,
-0.4962668717,
-0.1985327899,
-0.8413187861,
0.019966241,
1.3722789288,
0.7198007703,
-1.1575877666,
-0.240449518,
0.083391495,
0.3747159243,
-0.0502684787,
-0.3305803239,
0.4028014243,
-0.2444516718,
-0.8050863743,
0.0157351382,
0.3060183823,
-0.4108765125,
-0.6008396745,
0.122321479,
-0.4263965189,
0.1762312353,
0.7703249454,
0.5205997229,
-0.3843508363,
-0.3105820119,
-0.2265425324,
0.0309689008,
0.0445476361,
1.2775291204,
-0.6158077717,
0.6006079912,
0.5315534472,
0.710539341,
0.4413674772,
0.2061157525,
0.3160620332,
-0.6221240759,
0.3450596631,
0.2143957466,
0.3497937918,
0.7258598208,
-0.1863385737,
0.4681952298,
-0.1260391921,
-0.74887532,
-0.7242000103,
0.0940324366,
-0.7292799354,
-0.2057673484,
1.5008028746,
0.4641266465,
-0.1314250529,
-0.2137363255,
-0.1115001515,
0.0210451856,
-0.6954152584,
0.8831278682,
0.6816705465,
0.2581448257,
-0.0992348269,
-0.8631388545,
0.5602520108,
0.0965119302,
-0.5545629859,
0.2767316699,
0.5413279533,
0.3117589056,
-0.0568289049,
0.7456058264,
-0.2472740114,
-0.0308392961,
-0.328959316,
0.1854980737,
0.3694136441,
-0.4027055502,
-0.3674342632,
0.0128823677,
0.0804438144,
-0.0162013918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00322v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00322v1
|
Bias in Opinion Summarisation from Pre-training to Adaptation: A Case Study in Political Bias
| 2024-02-01T04:15:59 | 2024-02-01T04:15:59 |
Nannan Huang, Haytham Fayek, Xiuzhen Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Opinion summarisation aims to summarise the salient information and opinions
presented in documents such as product reviews, discussion forums, and social
media texts into short summaries that enable users to effectively understand
the opinions therein. Generating biased summaries has the risk of potentially
swaying public opinion. Previous studies focused on studying bias in opinion
summarisation using extractive models, but limited research has paid attention
to abstractive summarisation models. In this study, using political bias as a
case study, we first establish a methodology to quantify bias in abstractive
models, then trace it from the pre-trained models to the task of summarising
social media opinions using different models and adaptation methods. We find
that most models exhibit intrinsic bias. Using a social media text
summarisation dataset and contrasting various adaptation methods, we find that
tuning a smaller number of parameters is less biased compared to standard
fine-tuning; however, the diversity of topics in training data used for
fine-tuning is critical.
|
[
-0.5751180053,
-0.3500218689,
0.348369509,
-0.0372657254,
-0.5580179095,
0.0515662208,
-0.1266487092,
-0.2239423692,
0.4797748029,
0.3503701985,
-0.5705872774,
-0.2823508978,
-0.8364803791,
-0.0722373053,
-0.3154424727,
1.5584828854,
0.2144895047,
0.2085305452,
-0.0321162082,
-0.4606668353,
-0.2067794502,
-0.8403098583,
-0.1806341112,
-0.3935443759,
0.1859738529,
0.3585007489,
0.5253937244,
0.1079092324,
0.2396272123,
0.1579838693,
-0.2245156169,
0.1034169868,
-0.8548413515,
-0.4147503972,
-0.4491036534,
-0.6952810884,
-0.4171529114,
0.2571618855,
0.3649997711,
0.5457432866,
0.2333733588,
0.3932369649,
0.2790480852,
1.2820672989,
-0.859154582,
-0.1182557493,
-0.901951015,
0.0371438265,
0.1320797503,
-0.3198059499,
-0.1629224271,
-0.621188581,
0.3057455122,
-0.5526424646,
0.568263948,
-0.2787048817,
0.6931867003,
0.0888882726,
-0.488353461,
-0.5673539639,
-0.9060478806,
0.7585737705,
-0.7601466179,
-0.1138306707,
0.1315056384,
0.1674885452,
0.4163937569,
-0.3700715601,
-0.3700126112,
0.4350704253,
-0.0042615822,
0.4301935732,
0.0813620836,
-0.068177782,
0.1985546201,
0.2395953685,
-0.0267143548,
-0.2284245193,
-0.7004582286,
0.0353555679,
0.7830150127,
-0.108072184,
-0.1546142101,
-0.4512243569,
-0.0786118582,
-0.0531618595,
-0.7381576896,
-0.0334786102,
0.8651772738,
0.4161764383,
-0.3407870233,
0.4521534443,
-0.467413336,
0.4416042864,
0.4901928604,
0.1382493377,
0.2185736746,
-0.5186402202,
0.0047463328,
0.3596782684,
0.64249897,
0.8062891364,
0.7591915131,
0.4480459392,
-0.0444293469,
0.2381362468,
0.3652727604,
-0.7543087006,
-0.1391766667,
0.2219997942,
-0.9394226074,
-0.6442776918,
0.2425016761,
-0.9046798944,
-0.5876070261,
-0.3264561594,
0.2729311883,
-0.0476215966,
-0.3882595599,
0.0433985591,
-0.3768334389,
0.2625233233,
0.4998137653,
-0.8864734769,
0.2155637592,
0.6424473524,
0.8981929421,
-0.2572754323,
-0.0249115545,
-0.0812115073,
-0.0514566712,
-0.2595589757,
1.0811247826,
-0.3432655036,
-0.436314106,
0.0140934484,
-0.0351151675,
0.1243381426,
-0.5599868894,
0.262780726,
-0.3247852325,
0.3799287677,
-0.6070389748,
-0.3239802718,
-0.0971096307,
0.0304501336,
-0.4820610881,
0.6129273772,
-0.0021563191,
-1.1897195578,
0.7948302031,
-0.7103965282,
-0.7154606581,
-0.6921045184,
-0.1484452784,
-0.3711596131,
0.4637025893,
0.6043611765,
0.3539851904,
0.0499434359,
0.1127178073,
-0.455766052,
-0.2044612467,
0.1487253457,
-0.0438826531,
0.7875739932,
0.044821348,
-0.1941512376,
0.2072304636,
-0.5211077332,
-0.4977288246,
-0.167424351,
-0.0427971482,
-0.6711239815,
0.183089599,
0.0232986156,
0.4886573255,
-0.1002071351,
-0.2156626582,
0.0042976951,
-0.3747031093,
0.4927716255,
1.0603872538,
0.3715505302,
0.8392743468,
-0.3951430321,
0.2788721025,
0.2313777208,
0.0456253439,
-0.0516514182,
-0.0485323817,
-0.5404450893,
0.2150961459,
0.5365136862,
0.3638709486,
-0.5378445983,
0.143180877,
-0.4067717195,
-0.3249832094,
-0.6243289113,
0.0969477072,
0.0887893811,
0.3220096827,
-0.0307405349,
-0.3879109919,
-0.4296269715,
-0.9986331463,
-0.8201341629,
-0.4546623528,
-0.1494823247,
0.2577508092,
0.8472977877,
0.079949446,
0.8812941313,
-0.4140152931,
-0.2642301023,
-0.3479701877,
0.4234291017,
0.1065971702,
0.1741872877,
0.6711496711,
-0.7006920576,
-0.2881691456,
-0.1971686184,
-0.5266703367,
-0.2281194627,
-0.4225234985,
-0.2654673457,
0.1507796347,
0.2086790949,
-0.3963822424,
0.4030916393,
0.3827937841,
-0.1303972155,
0.5072427392,
0.2046389133,
0.2086878568,
-1.3308737278,
-0.0873341635,
0.2101588398,
-0.5019903183,
-0.4242056608,
-0.2889327705,
-0.1424339563,
0.2605391145,
-0.5344023108,
0.2077800483,
-0.5267019868,
-0.161361292,
-0.6175198555,
0.0122740641,
0.0296170972,
0.2542056143,
0.2108208388,
0.4626978338,
0.1751351655,
-0.5485917926,
-0.1928954124,
0.167866081,
-0.5046120286,
0.6304686666,
-0.6314136982,
0.1937465072,
-0.3419578969,
0.1243117973,
-0.9092981219,
-0.2005589157,
0.0686031878,
-0.4646998048,
-0.0558803119,
-0.2967494428,
-0.1139821336,
-0.0351862721,
-0.6411528587,
0.1629585326,
0.4684826732,
-0.3050533235,
0.6643280983,
0.7249842882,
-0.3426894248,
-0.4307533205,
-0.5130935311,
-0.3840299249,
-0.3881582022,
-0.0781550407,
0.3309761584,
0.1759655923,
-0.4648427963,
0.0488350168,
-0.4000942707,
0.1868482083,
-0.1625677347,
0.1817761511,
-0.091318436,
-0.0923776105,
-0.1807731837,
0.2729292512,
0.1457624137,
0.2986113131,
0.1376903653,
0.3357817233,
0.0562573485,
-0.2237178683,
-0.1641341895,
0.3699231148,
0.6854982972,
0.1039312929,
0.5684796572,
0.1700937301,
-0.2614712417,
-0.2687879205,
-0.4744790196,
-0.4292277992,
-0.3688536286,
0.520077467,
0.1808890849,
-0.5541800261,
0.577036202,
-0.2166918218,
0.2730552554,
0.4988826513,
0.748100698,
-0.126280427,
0.9324091077,
0.6992883086,
-0.4736272097,
0.6430204511,
-0.1338563859,
0.0486213602,
-0.4626690745,
0.2338555455,
-0.4225476682,
-0.4041633308,
-0.4906248748,
0.0108105876,
0.1596629024,
-0.159466207,
0.1962970942,
-0.2414966524,
-0.4282952845,
0.6334187984,
0.4113427699,
0.3376238644,
0.0200524274,
0.1756482273,
0.4788461328,
0.0769499019,
-0.6483792663,
-0.5503100753,
1.2294018269,
0.1218481734,
0.5512160659,
-0.1845065504,
0.4499204755,
0.6025928855,
0.6193646193,
-0.5944800377,
0.2367079854,
-0.0930253938,
-0.700889349,
-0.1706419736,
-0.2935952842,
-0.3176869154,
0.2984347939,
-0.535407722,
-0.2552409768,
0.4411732256,
0.2651098073,
-0.4076405168,
0.1882369965,
-0.6836385131,
0.5953343511,
-0.134684518,
-0.2545291781,
-0.286655575,
-0.6588975787,
0.5319371819,
-0.2169657201,
0.383230716,
-0.0895846188,
0.3492767215,
1.1623740196,
-0.2668979764,
0.9777856469,
-0.3662453294,
0.3298358619,
0.1450920254,
-0.4275326729,
0.3241453767,
-0.0676874518,
-0.056292288,
0.134464696,
0.0132373543,
-0.5319932699,
-0.4719337225,
0.3631977439,
-1.1124079227,
-0.6688340902,
-0.4548227191,
-0.4972103536,
-0.1072202623,
0.1429479271,
0.4038775861,
0.2368128747,
-0.4818450212,
0.2404898703,
0.5688586831,
-0.0987072736,
0.3353244662,
0.3295543194,
-0.1333209276,
-0.2760845125,
0.4870479703,
0.5511303544,
0.3345088661,
0.1467573345,
0.3668415248,
0.0474447832,
-0.5285924673,
-0.1485150009,
-0.0277889892,
-0.7745212913,
0.0052840128,
-0.6012665629,
-0.1627580822,
-0.4882166088,
-0.282238692,
-0.409770757,
-0.7065297961,
-0.2835745215,
-0.4271304905,
0.355753988,
0.8421993256,
0.0302724037,
0.6554683447,
-0.2240204215,
0.6428529024,
0.3295214176,
0.1125115156,
-0.12345016,
-0.6922451258,
-0.3405147195,
0.1002796963,
-0.4192400575,
-1.2958791256,
0.3166800737,
0.2894791067,
0.2070959061,
0.6171423197,
0.2866070569,
0.5883823037,
-0.3408399224,
0.7923792601,
0.0407106951,
-0.728286624,
0.7756913304,
-0.4446079731,
0.5247960091,
0.9199476242,
0.5877454877,
0.0033744643,
-0.3976937532,
-0.5284656286,
-0.9701185822,
0.6354744434,
0.0433896407,
0.2387016565,
0.2464815229,
0.369766444,
0.4570593536,
0.4184699357,
-0.7268553376,
-0.1619818211,
-0.5578576922,
-0.0327823535,
-0.1214028522,
-0.4315466583,
-0.2399034351,
-0.4066170454,
0.7431290746,
-0.122323826,
-0.0218993276,
0.1067888364,
-0.4681718647,
0.106246233,
0.2041383088,
0.6500316858,
1.0305384398,
-0.3229092062,
-0.0128507214,
0.1834186465,
-0.4115455449,
-0.01711745,
-0.0394042134,
-0.4322181642,
0.3678763807,
0.2629077137,
0.6727054715,
-0.0769070908,
-0.1833917797,
0.669836998,
-0.1714583039,
-0.3590130508,
-0.1887623668,
-0.1993978471,
0.0509650148,
-0.0976927951,
0.4022030234,
0.3496062756,
0.2855587304,
-0.7838270664,
-0.0246724319,
0.4368273914,
-0.3910730183,
-0.5668696165,
0.6193672419,
0.2920157611,
-0.0719568357,
-0.1168124378,
0.1624205112,
-0.3853312135,
0.4377161264,
0.2386756241,
1.009670496,
-0.1262087226,
0.2460427135,
0.1399388164,
0.5683145523,
-0.0998665392,
0.2488045543,
-0.0010121762,
-0.6295489669,
-0.2525346577,
-0.4170128703,
-0.4637718499,
0.0083215665,
-0.9056658745,
0.2840852737,
-0.5550208092,
-0.3584774435,
0.2221574336,
-0.1867326349,
-0.4663982391,
0.1684903651,
-0.1034385115,
0.7225007415,
-1.4842939377,
0.4601463377,
0.7007032633,
-0.1463133395,
-0.2714356184,
0.2112555206,
0.0975560993,
-0.4359973073,
0.2915890217,
0.1353445202,
-0.0396889821,
-0.5303352475,
-0.5829713345,
-0.3603835106,
0.5399882793,
0.378788799,
-0.5069624186,
0.0131888324,
0.1594522893,
0.4797129631,
-0.6314319968,
0.2748720944,
0.4970390499,
0.0242751502,
-0.3559673727,
-0.4645361304,
0.0062381835,
-0.3438217938,
-0.0962294713,
-0.1473870128,
-0.6577473879,
0.7030037045,
0.0261444002,
0.0247443374,
-0.7092180848,
0.6699945927,
0.0380713865,
0.3831436038,
0.4766657054,
-0.0472503491,
0.5780267715,
-0.0799613073,
0.9320840836,
-0.5609457493,
0.0588040501,
1.3595393896,
-0.4207195342,
0.6813441515,
0.7436543703,
0.1650071442,
0.4521124363,
0.6484521627,
0.2674963176,
0.8686096072,
0.1211626381,
-0.0096740639,
0.1083795652,
0.1262430102,
-0.4858396351,
0.1252261996,
0.4243046343,
-0.6345895529,
-0.0470155254,
-0.125685811,
-0.0660151765,
0.1415508538,
-0.6949196458,
1.0926396847,
0.1450903714,
-0.700006485,
0.128070727,
-0.2719974518,
0.7689184546,
-0.3913019598,
0.1591756046,
-0.3672631085,
0.055293791,
-0.4186346829,
-0.5414572358,
0.4956457615,
0.1456790119,
-0.52650702,
-0.1792910993,
0.8466350436,
-0.0134006366,
-0.6191468835,
-0.0368194096,
0.6789178848,
-0.057985194,
-0.2160594016,
-0.5269076824,
0.0097171888,
0.0250348412,
-0.5048753619,
0.474314183,
0.4422215521,
-0.0140339332,
0.1958935559,
0.5161023736,
0.3727906048,
-0.0957908109,
0.085242942,
1.0378997326,
-0.4850253761,
-0.8078683615,
-1.1433551311,
0.4646310508,
-0.4064842165,
-0.3583874106,
0.8302739859,
0.5353752971,
0.878962934,
-0.2548339069,
1.238008976,
0.2392154336,
0.4388143718,
-0.5562547445,
1.0814478397,
-0.2976893783,
0.0786692649,
-0.531783402,
-0.8892027736,
0.0482584387,
0.6638752818,
-0.6971186399,
0.0438825861,
0.4200370908,
0.7245196104,
-0.1554300934,
0.1756411791,
-0.1560075581,
0.2865663767,
-0.147827521,
0.1512376219,
0.7511296868,
-0.2092574537,
0.220910579,
-0.1986198276,
-0.2928030789,
-0.2731141448,
-0.9969380498,
-1.2976894379,
-0.3192941844,
-0.4004327953,
-0.5728305578,
0.3919876516,
0.9139388204,
0.8315662742,
-0.9850740433,
-0.2294873744,
0.1191288382,
0.2735024393,
-0.1186017692,
-0.2068138272,
0.4198723435,
0.1515950412,
-0.4149823189,
-0.450091362,
0.0464420244,
-0.1869993806,
-0.1237130463,
0.2248972505,
-0.1360004693,
0.3241583109,
0.7510841489,
0.218225807,
-0.3655688763,
-0.2674981058,
-0.3948021233,
0.2684328556,
0.2480285168,
0.9761057496,
-0.5365703702,
0.3174412847,
0.4749608934,
0.4175815284,
0.6379053593,
0.3783554435,
0.8721538782,
-0.722260654,
0.1747603118,
-0.0232465919,
0.2532014549,
0.4503565729,
-0.2109683752,
0.1879043281,
0.0658695549,
-0.377071023,
-0.8423492908,
0.1797626466,
-0.8249595761,
-0.4244221747,
1.2013853788,
0.1997590959,
-0.2958770096,
-0.0725481138,
-0.3547501862,
0.2881696224,
-0.4065829515,
1.3137276173,
0.7351977825,
0.00779441,
-0.1284183562,
-0.5582912564,
0.5651043057,
0.1229537949,
-0.8184665442,
0.2221891582,
0.3794430792,
0.437195003,
-0.0408122391,
0.8781576753,
-0.0434006304,
0.3066156805,
-0.1818440408,
-0.0312062073,
0.2156546116,
-0.1318556219,
-0.583671391,
0.3593159914,
-0.066300109,
0.011472079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01769v1
|
Redefining "Hallucination" in LLMs: Towards a psychology-informed framework for mitigating misinformation
| 2024-02-01T03:01:11 | 2024-02-01T03:01:11 |
Elijah Berberette, Jack Hutchins, Amir Sadovnik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have become incredibly popular,
with ChatGPT for example being used by over a billion users. While these models
exhibit remarkable language understanding and logical prowess, a notable
challenge surfaces in the form of "hallucinations." This phenomenon results in
LLMs outputting misinformation in a confident manner, which can lead to
devastating consequences with such a large user base. However, we question the
appropriateness of the term "hallucination" in LLMs, proposing a psychological
taxonomy based on cognitive biases and other psychological phenomena. Our
approach offers a more fine-grained understanding of this phenomenon, allowing
for targeted solutions. By leveraging insights from how humans internally
resolve similar challenges, we aim to develop strategies to mitigate LLM
hallucinations. This interdisciplinary approach seeks to move beyond
conventional terminology, providing a nuanced understanding and actionable
pathways for improvement in LLM reliability.
|
[
-0.510437727,
-0.8958995342,
0.680162251,
0.446836561,
-0.1438868493,
0.0886218995,
-0.4729422927,
-0.6262318492,
0.4905983508,
0.497355938,
-0.7990375161,
-0.3137871623,
-0.7285336256,
0.1296694726,
-0.3916862905,
0.764124155,
0.1343532652,
0.1636462212,
-0.4335589111,
0.1927680373,
-0.7711673379,
-0.796525538,
-0.5204901099,
-0.5599732995,
0.6441933513,
0.2240596414,
0.8135607839,
0.2826200128,
0.6316343546,
0.1465362161,
-0.034618903,
0.1940775365,
-0.8156360388,
0.2826826274,
-0.0036804138,
-0.5496123433,
-0.1521850675,
-0.1394731551,
0.2817487717,
1.0749638081,
-0.5002924204,
-0.212927267,
0.2937064469,
0.7507629395,
-0.6817339659,
-0.0275984686,
-0.8485617042,
0.4119026363,
0.0237424541,
-0.5212399364,
-0.5040944219,
-0.4362928271,
0.070083797,
-0.4027722478,
0.1610984206,
-0.000115658,
0.5146170259,
0.4401361048,
-0.2123346925,
-0.5641995668,
-1.0137296915,
0.573076725,
-0.4591832161,
0.6698431969,
0.6328536272,
0.2638149559,
-0.2323592901,
-0.4437178373,
-0.3845843971,
-0.3294234574,
-0.1029576063,
-0.1170126498,
-0.1240304783,
-0.0870732516,
0.3249954581,
0.0774977282,
-0.6185542941,
0.0735160038,
-0.4974614978,
-0.4921471477,
0.5854988098,
0.2899238765,
0.3010675907,
0.0647240728,
-0.2260002047,
0.4296013415,
-0.7830904722,
-0.6771960855,
0.2741799057,
0.252376467,
0.3136823475,
0.551328063,
-0.0838145912,
0.1212916821,
0.0459764265,
-0.0765568316,
0.235257566,
0.2106255591,
-0.2438631654,
0.4616214335,
0.5078963041,
0.5613987446,
0.40747118,
-0.6917996407,
-0.1738534868,
0.4625174403,
0.7324855328,
-0.7116916776,
-0.2047476619,
0.3939296007,
-0.4911319315,
-0.2265411764,
-0.0231718719,
-0.8482522964,
-1.0453248024,
-0.4874292016,
0.4284368753,
-0.5359898806,
-0.4443913996,
0.3290458322,
0.0803885013,
-0.0103940489,
0.3000628352,
-0.8880474567,
0.3476451337,
0.7761258483,
0.8747297525,
-0.3262385428,
-0.5410132408,
-0.0857535899,
0.2135533243,
-0.3312598169,
0.8381566405,
-0.3192799985,
-0.6066994667,
0.1759843528,
-0.0663981661,
0.0273605511,
-0.7778963447,
0.4159291685,
-0.2710128129,
0.2461381108,
-0.4334878922,
-0.505081594,
-0.2194203138,
0.3197965324,
-0.4130485654,
0.8033802509,
-0.1944677681,
-0.6476453543,
0.3057869673,
-0.345276624,
-0.3640196919,
0.1044937894,
-0.3152835071,
-0.1179246083,
0.4167200029,
-0.0532684028,
0.3115003407,
-0.2739046812,
0.4745715857,
-0.1733685434,
-0.5888997912,
0.5116220117,
-0.4877294302,
0.3207751513,
0.2431794852,
-0.4126397967,
0.1202092022,
-0.6407449841,
-0.2484281361,
-0.0278048757,
0.0114677977,
-0.3593209684,
0.1518810391,
-0.1157628968,
0.006159205,
0.2218724191,
-0.12118119,
-0.0013688242,
-0.3572666943,
0.192931205,
0.8567211628,
-0.001282385,
0.3568663001,
-0.5328840017,
0.3405106068,
0.0937501043,
0.4000811279,
0.1165210232,
-0.3101997674,
-0.568220377,
-0.2163363993,
-0.3551427126,
0.5678610802,
-0.4534666836,
0.5198357105,
-0.1427706182,
-0.5733181834,
-0.3478887677,
0.1048567519,
0.0554935336,
0.4942221344,
0.2803770006,
-0.3047712147,
-0.8234149814,
-0.9228438735,
-0.359775275,
-0.2866159081,
0.0180628877,
0.0821294188,
0.5172903538,
-0.8198192716,
0.6690198183,
-0.3767392337,
-0.6370127797,
-0.2247762531,
0.2866224945,
-0.0234194547,
0.1826969683,
0.0551958643,
-0.635422945,
0.0034656057,
-0.0979119465,
-1.058226943,
-0.1598862261,
-0.4706304669,
-0.037605498,
0.3986939788,
0.5916438103,
-0.8311135173,
0.4525833726,
0.1451927722,
-0.2959973812,
0.9222103953,
-0.0314729363,
0.0793598816,
-0.8518895507,
-0.2382017821,
-0.0355771519,
0.2894311547,
-0.6161261201,
-0.2024597973,
-0.2984241545,
0.2676871717,
-0.3109678626,
0.2666190565,
-0.3759062588,
-0.0297427159,
-0.457110256,
0.3553967178,
-0.4003638625,
0.2270212322,
0.0746559054,
0.5848558545,
0.646330595,
-0.6705225706,
0.4636611938,
0.1657332033,
-0.2758429348,
0.6008542776,
-0.29600963,
-0.0308183748,
-0.4241866469,
0.2948459983,
-0.7863484025,
-0.3928614855,
0.4676060081,
-0.4763770998,
-0.1494006515,
0.3092631996,
-0.6968426704,
-0.226220578,
-0.2899044752,
0.3121941984,
0.3718374968,
-0.5333195925,
0.573805511,
0.3402138054,
0.1102083921,
-0.4278094471,
-0.9450012445,
0.4239518642,
-0.5115843415,
-0.5767025352,
0.2003972828,
-0.168801114,
-0.5714240074,
-0.2556006312,
-0.2486301959,
0.1978372037,
0.1554933935,
0.4680329859,
0.2449062169,
-0.0856849924,
0.5946111083,
-0.4752631783,
-0.0543548428,
0.5434426665,
-0.0646613017,
0.9010720253,
-0.0585912801,
-0.5589337349,
-0.4827004671,
0.3813823462,
0.4297122955,
0.3013570309,
0.9155039787,
0.5847811699,
-0.802057147,
-0.3330304325,
-0.7899803519,
-0.7575155497,
-0.4083233774,
0.4087596238,
-0.3581456542,
-0.792135179,
0.6580657363,
-0.1100755632,
-0.2829325497,
0.1294612139,
0.718018055,
-0.1800671816,
0.9464100599,
0.7291858792,
0.0046606194,
0.1663064808,
0.0973241329,
0.5649690628,
-0.6011182666,
-0.6366658807,
-0.2715344727,
-0.22901766,
-0.5890873671,
-0.2930800319,
0.1089051366,
0.0656708255,
-0.1841518432,
-0.1488684267,
-0.6286674738,
0.408072412,
0.1802653521,
0.1539363414,
0.4218376875,
0.2283302844,
0.1932724863,
-0.3947029412,
-0.4508233666,
-0.794839263,
0.9593235254,
0.4660984874,
1.0985702276,
0.1745610982,
0.7375192642,
0.4335191548,
0.3131171763,
-0.8873877525,
0.6826648712,
0.4752214551,
-0.6039103866,
-0.2148538828,
-0.3492423594,
-0.8874238729,
0.3772983551,
-0.2487680465,
-1.4067920446,
0.1343093812,
-0.0577701814,
-0.1442196667,
0.3395074904,
-0.4657547176,
0.528362155,
-0.3958532512,
-0.3326816857,
-0.4758096635,
-0.4275245965,
0.5964810848,
-0.2558468282,
0.2980861962,
-0.0623498857,
-0.0153763192,
0.6639947891,
-0.137631759,
1.2142806053,
0.1151443049,
-0.4614981711,
0.0394796096,
0.3649148047,
0.4631507993,
-0.0430628285,
0.0732133687,
0.1823135465,
-0.0806939304,
-0.0980848446,
-0.7165629268,
0.6982328296,
-0.7829421163,
-0.7209426761,
-0.4773370624,
-0.664568007,
-0.4517895281,
-0.1246940047,
0.3456667066,
-0.0593742467,
-0.3700376153,
0.1359220594,
0.9375060201,
-0.2248446345,
0.02515864,
0.2554007471,
-0.7051730156,
-0.1784018576,
0.9857860804,
0.1319918483,
0.0696249083,
0.0086175641,
-0.0502664484,
-0.2978419065,
-0.547138989,
0.3295873404,
0.4976913333,
-1.0626671314,
0.1730178744,
-0.7610077858,
-0.5124834776,
-0.4036138654,
-0.2508606315,
-0.273402065,
-0.0957833454,
-0.521723032,
-0.2452434003,
0.2301663905,
0.7823728919,
-0.1295659691,
0.438860029,
-0.4578396082,
0.3382618725,
0.0217459481,
0.507245779,
0.1680756807,
-0.499276191,
-0.2208627164,
-0.059928257,
-0.3822191954,
-0.9677598476,
0.4326874316,
-0.2571530044,
0.7566455603,
0.5395618677,
-0.1112819538,
0.7590697408,
-0.2112038136,
0.8218693137,
0.3952786624,
-0.7808319926,
0.5425649285,
-0.0860009566,
-0.0803602189,
0.4316532612,
0.5777568221,
-1.0059740543,
-0.4898275137,
-0.5798417926,
-0.9991796613,
0.2454981059,
0.0968684703,
0.1332152486,
-0.2280169576,
0.2341982275,
0.4320371449,
0.1974825859,
-0.949367702,
-0.0347295552,
-0.0773658231,
-0.1210478395,
-0.0617414936,
-0.4961033762,
-0.3718278408,
-0.1322474331,
0.9002487063,
-0.0322255343,
0.2790468037,
0.1489885598,
-0.5009666681,
-0.2562957406,
0.11338,
0.6192877889,
1.0161247253,
-0.2549625337,
0.3028568923,
0.1378642321,
-0.5974431634,
-0.0091809556,
-0.206884563,
0.0170864705,
-0.0714934394,
0.400470823,
0.670414567,
0.1264865845,
-0.7629460692,
0.1954517812,
0.0636136979,
-0.3554740548,
-0.5047095418,
-0.0636644885,
0.162730366,
0.3439632058,
0.5894367099,
-0.1022543907,
0.1085278168,
-0.7202445269,
0.2497268021,
0.423517853,
-0.4206045568,
-0.1349978298,
0.5830481648,
0.0030054245,
-0.4122640193,
0.5824943185,
-0.0122333393,
-0.2944630086,
0.4737673104,
0.6050445437,
1.0746567249,
-0.112864539,
0.2345537096,
0.216056332,
0.6997923255,
-0.409372896,
0.233317703,
0.2403626442,
-0.9292564988,
-0.2020200342,
-0.5050427914,
-0.3023125529,
0.3085558712,
-0.523434639,
0.2541743815,
-0.4353180528,
-0.2898838222,
-0.271867305,
-0.2809572816,
-0.3557535708,
0.0646135882,
0.5313991904,
0.8636502028,
-0.8749863505,
0.5401829481,
0.4162587225,
-0.4297283888,
-0.2078884393,
0.4125929475,
0.2427203059,
-0.6631401181,
0.6138139367,
0.36157763,
-0.2735866606,
-0.2927887738,
-0.5264396667,
-0.6482473016,
1.1168539524,
0.1811545491,
-0.6439164281,
0.0469222404,
0.4703489542,
0.5610880852,
-0.5570361614,
0.0827201456,
0.7929147482,
0.6218138337,
0.1458899826,
-0.7040593624,
0.1283738762,
0.1495419741,
0.081576921,
-0.1067467108,
-0.4283950329,
0.4282019734,
-0.2857281864,
-0.2958653271,
-0.0519662052,
0.5955129266,
0.4778201282,
0.4040232003,
0.4324499071,
0.3030590713,
1.1750411987,
-0.1298320442,
0.685634017,
-0.0935266167,
0.0823747814,
1.2245804071,
-0.4167002738,
0.6724054813,
0.9443987608,
-0.0237477925,
0.2084518224,
0.830033958,
0.0209785439,
0.4645708203,
0.580524683,
-0.2305795699,
-0.2830663323,
-0.2012768388,
-0.438544333,
0.3038926125,
0.7579040527,
-0.3080667853,
-0.1811848134,
0.2530495524,
-0.1147925854,
0.2654303014,
-0.1638290137,
0.7029865384,
0.2279429436,
-0.4736689329,
0.6799695492,
-0.4020061195,
0.7967383265,
-0.3477419019,
0.2177775502,
-0.386774838,
0.1179756075,
-0.4695595205,
-0.6176012158,
0.5469445586,
-0.1954985857,
-0.2413750887,
-0.1881681085,
0.7972402573,
-0.3480187356,
-0.5156989098,
0.5198108554,
0.7717145681,
0.4713209569,
-0.2911269069,
-0.389221549,
0.5430175662,
-0.0154985739,
-0.0034836649,
0.2592152059,
0.6076367497,
-0.0903799385,
1.0628011227,
0.3001695871,
0.3550112545,
0.0694476217,
0.4095116258,
0.6879593134,
-0.8381232023,
-0.2663694322,
-1.1086014509,
0.3037181497,
-0.0164140835,
-0.0995584875,
0.6745857596,
0.514893353,
0.7398985624,
-0.0562130101,
0.9438316226,
0.2307949811,
0.2061647773,
-0.4166637957,
0.9176853299,
-0.5728322268,
0.7551866174,
-0.2086458653,
-1.1523852348,
-0.5139956474,
0.6630972028,
-0.4091598392,
0.0206854511,
0.8188196421,
1.0715712309,
0.0794250295,
0.4208391309,
0.4740492702,
0.5031933188,
0.1765497923,
0.4695252776,
1.3657262325,
-0.0596160628,
0.5432503819,
-0.1826312691,
-0.104706943,
-0.4734416604,
-0.7323943377,
-0.9894025922,
-0.6345941424,
-0.446568042,
-0.3549973667,
0.1745561957,
1.014668107,
0.4146511853,
-0.5430949926,
-0.3964215219,
-0.1588891447,
0.2707586586,
-0.0154522117,
-0.2636331022,
0.0499345697,
-0.6807367206,
-0.3202298582,
0.0646018684,
0.3671806157,
0.0922662914,
-0.7317691445,
-0.2233545184,
0.1189054027,
0.2159395814,
0.7183499336,
-0.0224378724,
-1.0987068415,
-0.2348344028,
-0.1130090132,
-0.2296163291,
0.0857701376,
0.8235221505,
-0.7710331678,
0.2248952836,
0.1152948067,
0.610278666,
0.0548838861,
-0.294205755,
0.5128744245,
-0.3676010966,
0.0386287309,
0.2643012404,
0.2845253646,
0.4609181285,
-0.6422613859,
0.6192996502,
0.3690462112,
-0.3151109219,
-1.1621787548,
0.2447871417,
-0.7458256483,
-0.6605671048,
1.2166082859,
0.5548410416,
-0.1684272438,
-0.1431446373,
-0.4666498005,
0.1118661016,
-0.1981956065,
1.6643707752,
1.0201262236,
-0.1581484675,
-0.302642405,
-0.6909139156,
0.6182514429,
0.44330585,
-0.9228243828,
0.4665098786,
0.5469574332,
0.0325145274,
0.3316992521,
0.545602262,
-0.1331691593,
0.1662053466,
-0.0620967522,
0.3163903356,
0.3346095681,
-0.4536252916,
-0.2250818461,
0.1792095006,
0.026833022,
0.1663783491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01767v1
|
HiQA: A Hierarchical Contextual Augmentation RAG for Massive Documents QA
| 2024-02-01T02:24:15 | 2024-02-01T02:24:15 |
Xinyue Chen, Pengyu Gao, Jiangjiang Song, Xiaoyang Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As language model agents leveraging external tools rapidly evolve,
significant progress has been made in question-answering(QA) methodologies
utilizing supplementary documents and the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
approach. This advancement has improved the response quality of language models
and alleviates the appearance of hallucination. However, these methods exhibit
limited retrieval accuracy when faced with massive indistinguishable documents,
presenting notable challenges in their practical application. In response to
these emerging challenges, we present HiQA, an advanced framework for
multi-document question-answering (MDQA) that integrates cascading metadata
into content as well as a multi-route retrieval mechanism. We also release a
benchmark called MasQA to evaluate and research in MDQA. Finally, HiQA
demonstrates the state-of-the-art performance in multi-document environments.
|
[
-0.6441640854,
-1.0499148369,
0.5471123457,
-0.110527873,
0.1519192457,
0.4487164319,
0.3376713991,
-0.5736590028,
0.3050338626,
0.6448976994,
-0.5581146479,
-0.242523998,
-0.4492295384,
0.0503237545,
-0.3572362959,
0.8127202392,
0.1608010083,
-0.0193452034,
-0.5100955963,
-0.4417751133,
-0.5962875485,
-0.6280355453,
-0.5234156847,
-0.174863115,
0.4984645247,
0.2118065506,
0.9619117975,
0.5044115782,
0.5154199004,
0.3219217956,
-0.1612389833,
0.5263797045,
-0.1208974421,
0.5624310374,
-0.2700945437,
-0.1122790128,
-0.7730175257,
-0.1540590823,
0.8392918706,
0.6547973752,
0.0328379981,
0.184453696,
-0.0789244696,
0.370901078,
-0.8970350623,
-0.1602125466,
-0.4859022498,
-0.1767197102,
0.0345418341,
-0.5702508092,
-0.1611165702,
-0.1123749167,
0.1896926016,
-0.8744960427,
0.0530663282,
0.0247709621,
0.9120507836,
0.4042487144,
-0.7156774998,
-0.6121271849,
-0.5938929915,
0.4525716007,
-0.6544658542,
0.3870283663,
0.3345301449,
0.3666138947,
-0.1300151199,
-0.9544407129,
-0.770228982,
-0.1707879454,
0.0282370988,
0.2551367283,
0.2076286376,
-0.0024152116,
0.2436412424,
0.3483630419,
-0.6048374176,
-0.0965491086,
-0.1367616206,
-0.1572740227,
0.2280739844,
0.1330488771,
0.4439133704,
-0.4253756404,
-0.3671042919,
-0.1642010659,
-0.3584227264,
-0.0882366151,
0.2354969084,
0.1095352992,
0.2239799947,
0.495821178,
-0.3776844144,
0.5180312395,
0.0210209321,
-0.3115006983,
0.3231416047,
-0.3578861356,
-0.2384479195,
-0.3210657239,
0.3141897023,
-0.0065343054,
-0.538918972,
-0.1312512308,
-0.1626015753,
-0.4552341104,
0.4966619611,
-0.6449309587,
0.1072930843,
0.3993156552,
-0.1958164275,
-0.1171092689,
0.025242798,
-0.8759152293,
-0.6902326941,
-0.3390237689,
0.9241660237,
-0.1396692097,
-0.1212090105,
-0.1498728544,
-0.3326066434,
0.413875103,
0.5509851575,
-0.5554730892,
0.139008835,
0.73026371,
0.4557923377,
0.0158766154,
-0.4679946005,
-0.8429314494,
0.2754956186,
-0.4739928842,
0.8620095849,
-0.5591105819,
-0.2756313682,
-0.0087556271,
-0.0437279977,
0.0389720388,
-0.6394655704,
0.9344485402,
-1.0019809008,
0.5957782269,
-0.4296802282,
-0.2384447306,
-0.1660826504,
0.6108922958,
-0.8122653961,
1.4330631495,
0.4696180224,
-0.8057577014,
0.193191573,
-0.6316177249,
-0.2482917458,
0.3839172721,
-0.0368392132,
-0.1463163048,
-0.2477312684,
0.3542328775,
0.199023366,
-0.4207645655,
0.228679046,
-0.065742977,
-0.4345366359,
0.0938630253,
-0.4267916381,
0.5796335936,
0.1997112334,
-0.1768873483,
0.2617459297,
-0.7440747619,
-0.0232639574,
-0.1254589558,
-0.7237396836,
-0.5556742549,
-0.258697629,
0.1444752365,
0.611552,
0.4182104766,
-0.3196976781,
0.2385666072,
-0.3986589909,
0.0775802657,
0.4745438695,
0.2455090582,
0.5297936201,
-0.5129317045,
0.6003777385,
0.0178435817,
0.1169327199,
-0.4365458786,
-0.3887373507,
-0.6245664358,
-0.2299962193,
0.3748120964,
0.356264174,
-1.1357377768,
0.2472103834,
-0.2748574615,
-0.2927062809,
-0.7444309592,
-0.0370061025,
0.3480482996,
0.6436578631,
0.5979380608,
-0.3311349452,
-0.5903913975,
-0.7832514048,
0.0518252552,
-0.2654561698,
-0.1968038231,
0.4227195978,
0.5587468743,
-0.4390591681,
0.8506103754,
-0.3305241168,
-0.2135564387,
0.0365982242,
0.4305067956,
-0.0949558467,
0.4507682025,
0.215715155,
-1.1657099724,
-0.269310534,
0.0222199354,
-0.8086982369,
-0.0589684732,
-0.2589629591,
-0.3903336227,
0.3145923913,
0.5664963722,
-0.7092335224,
0.0020646923,
0.5245869756,
-0.1859483272,
0.7371234298,
-0.3489949405,
0.5597715974,
-1.532053113,
0.2361635864,
-0.3146498799,
-0.0209708568,
-0.6839446425,
0.794410646,
0.3473882377,
-0.1233202219,
-0.2835407853,
0.783382833,
-0.5188338161,
-0.2430894226,
-0.4625616372,
0.3232652247,
0.398947686,
0.4907488525,
-0.283007741,
1.0558609962,
0.4709631801,
-0.4937241673,
0.2818324566,
0.4362554252,
-0.0063456604,
0.8589306474,
-0.5024495721,
0.2052630037,
-0.5066516995,
0.4482878149,
-0.954025209,
-0.4918725491,
0.0369055308,
-0.6044445634,
0.2790303826,
-0.0558428504,
-0.7317548394,
-0.329265058,
-0.3294621706,
0.3984296322,
0.2993140519,
-0.679417789,
1.0041031837,
0.594647944,
-0.3256520927,
-0.9574024677,
-0.2359542698,
0.49586308,
-0.0867291167,
-0.5594696403,
0.3118183315,
-0.2963680923,
-0.0279237814,
-0.1329869628,
-0.2657038271,
-0.436663121,
0.1745560616,
0.1360851824,
0.2943448126,
-0.3375661075,
0.3086916804,
0.3477714658,
0.1667144746,
0.013680907,
-0.2332217544,
0.386172086,
0.0629291758,
-0.244668141,
-0.0068444847,
0.7074323297,
0.9500330091,
-0.6576656699,
0.7540089488,
0.7052660584,
-0.5440952182,
0.0025742725,
-0.7381979227,
0.0202996749,
-0.4765416682,
0.320320785,
-0.8147357106,
-0.887824893,
0.4819251895,
-0.0421188734,
0.0910268798,
0.5648398399,
0.5527763367,
-0.1869275719,
0.9569573998,
0.5030038953,
0.125700891,
0.0402685888,
-0.0240405649,
-0.0435117744,
-1.1752222776,
-0.2471286058,
-0.9515329003,
0.1554348916,
-0.5684161186,
-0.6322584748,
0.778826654,
0.1575653106,
-0.0709293783,
0.2084355801,
-0.1770844162,
0.3607903421,
0.5611944199,
-0.0965977088,
0.57317698,
-0.3259252012,
-0.1881847084,
0.3035180271,
-0.5717315674,
-0.4685610831,
0.6505698562,
0.4537846744,
0.7076455355,
0.3422031999,
0.3835121393,
0.2187476158,
0.2775526643,
-0.7372126579,
0.3725019991,
0.3784516454,
-0.9101501107,
-0.6852936745,
-0.3467517495,
-0.9196863174,
0.8847216368,
-0.4779438674,
-0.4808332622,
0.2964682877,
-0.2766764164,
-0.3340436816,
0.0056571998,
-0.3582275212,
0.7536264062,
0.2789495587,
-0.3733433783,
0.0535766855,
-0.8267159462,
0.277957499,
-0.4197442532,
0.2473982126,
0.0936160386,
-0.2812261283,
0.5320725441,
-0.077662833,
0.2382092625,
0.0468075983,
-0.4136832058,
0.171894595,
0.021333864,
0.4127642214,
0.0122424737,
-0.1738288105,
-0.3072598577,
0.5693610311,
-0.5169748068,
-0.7838544846,
0.6868026257,
-0.4690520763,
-0.5884823203,
-0.3938905299,
-1.0313441753,
-0.621198833,
0.3733147383,
-0.0851622522,
0.8363253474,
-0.1029524058,
0.4221486151,
0.7163671851,
-0.3242925704,
0.3471334279,
0.5053910017,
0.0823461935,
-0.2531468272,
0.6238890886,
0.055588983,
0.1549332589,
0.5944029093,
0.1346643865,
-0.6261867285,
-0.5011874437,
-0.7096812725,
0.1154767722,
-0.9374412894,
-0.077721417,
-1.0859576464,
-0.2604278922,
-0.7168574929,
-0.0713225082,
0.0495680161,
-0.4176912606,
-0.01500767,
0.1883966327,
-0.3138882816,
0.5789028406,
0.2678763866,
-0.0388671868,
-1.1692086458,
0.6971627474,
0.4740000665,
0.069550924,
0.1129576042,
-0.6799764633,
-0.4325322509,
-0.0927986577,
-0.3445596099,
-0.9141404033,
0.3157604039,
0.0358468927,
0.6943678856,
-0.0771128014,
0.2716600597,
0.5969675183,
-0.3933474422,
0.6973310113,
-0.2817972302,
-0.7534938455,
0.2582256496,
-0.5744424462,
0.6657881737,
0.6402001381,
0.5389296412,
-0.6163835526,
-0.5403055549,
-0.5212991834,
-0.8204190731,
0.3514458537,
0.0282234438,
0.3018826544,
0.1722562313,
0.2302893996,
0.0220979061,
0.3497790396,
-0.2966170311,
0.0053213942,
0.0255257487,
-0.0391139016,
0.1643799245,
-0.2163668275,
-0.1957645863,
-0.0459786989,
0.6571963429,
-0.5941412449,
-0.0924877599,
0.3377959132,
-0.2420089692,
-0.1125815287,
0.6795781255,
0.2928349376,
1.0118941069,
-0.26764974,
0.1181782931,
0.2033324689,
-0.5072233677,
0.1324133426,
0.18491669,
-0.3386688232,
-0.0230805315,
0.3108495772,
0.2663727403,
0.0431566387,
-0.7902991772,
0.4766939282,
-0.0820230171,
-0.2854246497,
0.0022820721,
-0.2694907188,
-0.0600711741,
0.1845624447,
0.7669177055,
-0.1910509765,
0.7230898142,
-0.9525117278,
0.2961305976,
0.4760375321,
-0.3431411386,
0.2308895737,
0.5942792296,
0.158156544,
-0.0611584373,
0.1713777184,
-0.1701641381,
-0.4469840527,
0.5269836783,
0.351629436,
0.6824149489,
-0.0464697219,
0.4312212765,
0.2986139655,
0.3118140697,
0.1388902068,
0.2422979474,
-0.2068552226,
-0.4922659397,
-0.5013723969,
-0.7750433087,
-0.7453130484,
0.050122086,
-0.7784514427,
-0.3066814244,
-0.0653482378,
0.0454186425,
0.1357656568,
0.2835614979,
-0.2748934627,
0.4719224274,
-0.1902230829,
0.845156014,
-0.305775404,
0.9033201337,
0.8768184781,
-0.5655339956,
-0.7440706491,
0.4443132579,
-0.1394246966,
-0.2078155428,
0.3383536339,
-0.0478956327,
-0.1708420515,
0.0516414493,
-0.2078253776,
-0.874404192,
1.0953691006,
0.0614606068,
0.1614211202,
-0.3503841162,
-0.059563376,
0.7432152629,
-0.1343037933,
0.3441053927,
0.6443154216,
0.4203920662,
0.5175061822,
-0.9336978793,
0.158053413,
-0.265809834,
0.0146375597,
0.1470654756,
-0.3288158178,
0.7583256364,
0.0486736894,
-0.2619760036,
0.4056824446,
0.6413298249,
0.2109863311,
0.4269361496,
0.3117359579,
0.4876324832,
0.8755736947,
0.0038174505,
1.0954176188,
-0.1235427484,
0.1234614477,
1.3267357349,
-0.2913294137,
0.9459714293,
0.3644345403,
0.1849074215,
0.5048457384,
0.522718668,
0.4306069911,
0.1011232436,
-0.1417873651,
-0.4443592727,
0.0088803191,
-0.4805862904,
-0.4369427264,
0.4056307673,
0.2660443783,
0.1465963572,
-0.2944264412,
0.0276180599,
-0.1887596995,
0.1930943578,
-0.2786833644,
0.9343065023,
-0.2758411169,
-0.8334760666,
0.5228580832,
0.2800122201,
0.540106535,
-0.3578126431,
-0.1460811645,
-0.3668139875,
-0.3397170901,
-0.1434970051,
-0.744137466,
0.3316211104,
-0.2930520773,
-0.1897538453,
0.0286607966,
0.8039557338,
-0.4758537412,
0.0996092036,
0.0432775579,
0.9859778285,
-0.1331557184,
-0.2636115551,
-0.7430066466,
-0.2562490702,
-0.7431792617,
-0.0500129834,
0.4121202826,
0.5214565396,
-0.1473642439,
0.5933021307,
0.7007646561,
-0.2587995231,
0.1142314747,
0.2618050873,
0.9725663066,
-0.3432829082,
-0.7028843164,
-0.1973332614,
0.5275120735,
-0.1598855406,
-0.2571088076,
0.8995489478,
0.5408414602,
0.6597374082,
-0.0393210351,
0.4842209518,
0.0342146792,
0.6888277531,
-0.5820635557,
0.6780133247,
-0.9174103737,
0.1518155485,
-0.46613428,
-1.0178034306,
-0.0838194117,
-0.0045647784,
0.0936565176,
-0.010801658,
0.947461307,
1.0638461113,
0.0184268653,
-0.2905802131,
0.5826465487,
-0.0268174727,
0.235239014,
0.2767218351,
1.0432702303,
-0.6711915731,
0.4268758595,
0.1872346699,
-0.2104434669,
-0.0169189945,
-0.5073751807,
-0.6552288532,
-1.0270835161,
-0.0237796046,
-0.5142182708,
0.1402544826,
0.7368360758,
0.8954196572,
-0.4677135348,
0.0274865087,
0.4722486734,
0.1771096736,
-0.1828942299,
-0.2642586827,
0.3078581691,
-0.3348280489,
-0.9030457139,
0.5393635631,
0.5009733438,
0.0390666239,
-0.4990185797,
-0.0637515411,
-0.5768609643,
0.5290954709,
0.8313445449,
0.3720689416,
-0.4907472134,
-0.0716305003,
0.0509830564,
-0.5594285727,
0.1565943956,
0.6656920314,
-0.6936551929,
0.5100541115,
0.7827194333,
1.2863028049,
0.3178052604,
0.4588100314,
0.3001026809,
-0.8240972161,
-0.1966417879,
0.3067687154,
0.0213933717,
0.2786275446,
-0.4234117866,
0.3594853282,
-0.0196526479,
-0.5784965158,
-0.7767181993,
0.1180949137,
-1.0390403271,
-0.4864896834,
1.0190069675,
0.1027117297,
-0.1326393783,
-0.4750297964,
-0.5293036103,
0.0352330282,
-0.1591251791,
0.6781830788,
0.6160809398,
0.2348944098,
-0.3404364586,
-0.8420997858,
0.3976278901,
0.371860981,
-1.4555231333,
-0.273909241,
0.9225686789,
-0.0968371406,
0.4225647151,
0.8858665228,
-0.2422660142,
0.5547930002,
0.0116582597,
-0.166620791,
0.0698995739,
-0.7185678482,
-0.4601533413,
0.772898674,
0.1792642474,
0.0484782942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00271v1
|
A Crucial Parameter for Rank-Frequency Relation in Natural Languages
| 2024-02-01T01:45:46 | 2024-02-01T01:45:46 |
Chenchen Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
$f \propto r^{-\alpha} \cdot (r+\gamma)^{-\beta}$ has been empirically shown
more precise than a na\"ive power law $f\propto r^{-\alpha}$ to model the
rank-frequency ($r$-$f$) relation of words in natural languages. This work
shows that the only crucial parameter in the formulation is $\gamma$, which
depicts the resistance to vocabulary growth on a corpus. A method of parameter
estimation by searching an optimal $\gamma$ is proposed, where a ``zeroth
word'' is introduced technically for the calculation. The formulation and
parameters are further discussed with several case studies.
|
[
-0.8260985613,
-0.9912335873,
0.7159717083,
0.0567754619,
-0.4504489005,
-0.5521712899,
-0.351659596,
-0.2996889949,
0.3906971216,
0.275609076,
-0.3825508952,
-0.1919212639,
-0.604937911,
0.0828630775,
-0.5474641919,
0.5969510078,
0.5556724072,
0.0693567768,
0.0762168616,
-0.3206928968,
-0.4512704611,
-0.6397075057,
-0.4123011827,
-0.4023886621,
0.9036845565,
0.4009048045,
0.93513906,
0.4283870459,
0.5775052309,
0.2400631458,
-0.2082687616,
-0.2627754509,
-0.2978574038,
0.5252799392,
0.0765232444,
-0.4897584021,
-0.3687894344,
0.0859678537,
0.8785772324,
0.8193551898,
-0.0855422765,
-0.0160595179,
-0.4260256588,
0.8881174922,
-0.3589395285,
0.2772011161,
-0.447983861,
-0.2485086173,
-0.5763812661,
-0.6146336794,
-0.2568632662,
-0.5146013498,
-0.0700591132,
-0.7749658823,
0.2342906892,
0.2432412654,
1.4459842443,
0.1658309251,
-0.2340383381,
-0.2995821536,
-0.7278940678,
0.7901646495,
-0.4704176784,
0.6914074421,
0.7173885703,
0.3196906745,
-0.339222312,
-0.5337154269,
-0.3702948689,
-0.6882584095,
0.0904717669,
-0.1417636126,
0.3000791669,
0.2294315249,
0.1729519516,
0.4709687233,
-0.1821185201,
-0.3498121202,
-0.5721029043,
0.1133847758,
0.7272164226,
-0.2101720572,
0.5061945319,
-0.2736977339,
-0.1844994277,
-0.0612107404,
-0.716716826,
-0.2393298596,
0.2662968636,
0.5514514446,
0.1491153836,
0.2560778856,
0.2282588184,
0.986569941,
0.108303152,
-0.0117238574,
-0.0968299657,
-0.3617064059,
0.130092904,
-0.0226974357,
0.2559536397,
0.1265615821,
0.7220511436,
-0.4070479274,
-0.0064692814,
-0.0387436599,
0.4725186527,
-0.7295656204,
-0.0208865404,
-0.2418403625,
0.0548680723,
-0.1577941477,
0.3267520666,
-0.7548490167,
0.0274016988,
-0.2217443734,
0.717261672,
-0.5625100732,
-0.3213106394,
-0.1264289618,
-0.0578344911,
0.3540898561,
-0.147353977,
-1.1031987667,
0.6503199935,
0.7765954137,
0.8670040965,
0.1515258849,
0.0250967089,
-0.4850030541,
-0.2461502552,
-0.460621506,
0.5583300591,
-0.6623979807,
-0.5068510771,
-0.2142913789,
-0.2505483329,
-0.1565854549,
-0.1348326504,
0.8803511262,
-0.9090532064,
-0.0269678235,
-0.2371847928,
-0.7826530933,
-0.4066183269,
-0.0505152047,
-0.6500921249,
1.2936702967,
0.2600498199,
-0.5404229164,
0.6358457804,
-0.5887559652,
-0.3643010557,
0.2197477371,
-0.1738575846,
-0.3115116358,
0.3232809901,
-0.186661303,
0.1898238212,
-0.4131464958,
0.3533788621,
-0.498572737,
-0.4466727972,
0.4696701467,
-0.2463518083,
0.6263797879,
0.1846601814,
-0.0346541964,
-0.1332315654,
-0.6932666302,
0.166766122,
0.0957478732,
-0.1494559944,
-0.7800512314,
0.1406989396,
-0.1464994997,
-0.0655264631,
0.1802203059,
-0.5956916213,
0.068714343,
-0.6699320674,
0.3707655072,
0.437931031,
0.1759060919,
0.3946336806,
-0.4239605963,
0.6478265524,
-0.5931478143,
0.2504058778,
0.3608168066,
-0.5745959282,
-0.4977840483,
-0.2555450201,
0.8103634715,
0.0520185754,
0.0602869838,
0.3945189416,
-0.4580031931,
-0.6524490714,
-0.3414692879,
-0.1232640818,
0.2041189224,
0.3959852755,
0.2993295789,
-0.0721228942,
-0.2811239064,
-0.592877388,
-0.2206826806,
-0.3509345949,
0.2351770997,
0.2683290541,
0.2924517393,
0.2000654787,
1.1395816803,
-0.5255643129,
-0.2309820503,
-0.1741192341,
0.2094625533,
0.4765244126,
0.2166114599,
1.0234831572,
-0.9554198384,
-0.5033934116,
-0.2984225452,
-0.2636600733,
-0.3586098552,
0.6510187984,
-0.0929039121,
0.1042777076,
0.7378228307,
-0.0376521647,
0.1249020994,
0.760398984,
-0.3248191476,
0.1453634501,
-0.443594873,
-0.1347401887,
-0.9195702672,
0.5021134019,
0.3039589524,
-0.0837779194,
-0.9102708101,
0.662338078,
-0.0036654798,
-0.0109685017,
-0.1062779948,
0.8730938435,
-0.3251293898,
-0.0686755404,
-0.0413184501,
0.3561993241,
-0.2018167675,
0.3837201297,
-0.0610746518,
0.9834111929,
0.5125219226,
-0.9767707586,
0.1815385371,
0.0602613837,
0.0327216536,
0.3568513393,
-0.5958616138,
-0.2146127224,
-0.2428012788,
-0.2641762495,
-1.0073801279,
0.0242401678,
-0.1776218712,
-0.5446394086,
0.2911646366,
-0.3666613698,
-0.3614679873,
-0.0809697211,
-0.362994343,
0.5283488035,
0.4982507825,
-0.1515258104,
0.4427117407,
0.6048098207,
-0.3016146421,
-0.3986507058,
-0.4494025111,
-0.1770908535,
-0.3384059966,
-0.7285470366,
0.5995311737,
-0.146459505,
-0.4212183654,
-0.0877869204,
-0.1577240527,
-0.3232495785,
0.1928335279,
0.3639337122,
0.1240829453,
-0.2918249965,
0.253801465,
-0.175863713,
-0.4860741794,
0.1532623023,
0.1833121777,
0.6705482006,
-0.2983117998,
0.0865826681,
0.2526129484,
0.1756609976,
0.7728670239,
-0.188887462,
0.488997221,
0.2066686004,
-0.2545373738,
-0.097646527,
-0.4248641133,
-0.3139241934,
-0.5098953843,
0.0980071649,
-0.3970455229,
-0.3549857438,
0.5100593567,
0.2799286842,
-0.2639194429,
0.6337297559,
0.3532984555,
0.2318148762,
0.9355477095,
0.6471738219,
0.114052631,
0.7108350396,
0.0759805143,
0.2734228969,
-0.7758234143,
-0.2254758477,
-0.7952703238,
-0.0749883279,
-0.7313870788,
-0.0576051325,
0.6872522235,
0.1024939567,
-0.1634926051,
0.3297399879,
-0.2719360292,
0.1342340708,
0.6782491207,
-0.2525310516,
0.2280043811,
-0.039293699,
-0.3521097004,
-0.3157947958,
-0.4641962647,
-0.0296429917,
0.8760131598,
0.1796208769,
0.4829564095,
0.3998028338,
0.7531605363,
0.2674227059,
0.5202509761,
-1.1695287228,
0.5314685106,
-0.2997406423,
-0.9791631699,
-0.726133883,
-0.128628701,
-1.1710470915,
0.4220494926,
-0.0191431195,
-0.4790399671,
0.2003057301,
-0.2151525021,
-0.1239505187,
-0.2669847012,
-0.3309284151,
0.5760920644,
-0.1642980874,
0.0099657336,
-0.3029768467,
-0.5441204309,
0.0331636481,
-0.0759035721,
0.3910281062,
-0.6376999617,
-0.1950706244,
0.7842449546,
-0.8264944553,
0.0254918151,
-0.181697771,
0.0654659644,
0.0779872984,
0.1837275922,
0.1390288621,
0.1664132178,
-0.6373054385,
0.0413551629,
0.1750685275,
-0.4386157393,
-0.3760468066,
0.6564572453,
-0.6397051215,
-0.4426386058,
-0.6817118526,
-0.401633054,
-0.3330205381,
0.3645088375,
0.4608996809,
0.5870091915,
-0.3326561749,
0.4488396943,
0.5888147354,
0.113352783,
0.5987693071,
0.7093107104,
-0.4486905038,
-0.3371255994,
0.8283452988,
0.7766738534,
0.2003351599,
0.4179876149,
0.485050559,
-0.3338984251,
-0.4445576072,
-0.2494813204,
0.5427162051,
-0.3531229794,
-0.0561891086,
-0.2592164576,
-0.4667868018,
0.2715623677,
-0.2993161678,
-0.0988987088,
-0.3926729262,
-0.084340632,
0.0763192251,
1.0163758993,
0.3845956922,
-0.0789556578,
0.1300874949,
-0.4508908391,
0.6324137449,
0.4205707312,
0.4916838109,
-0.2174286395,
-0.8601236939,
0.0405225642,
-0.1077562943,
0.1790362448,
-1.2213556767,
0.7274436355,
0.8257954717,
0.7186650038,
0.1464910954,
0.3237911165,
0.5043690205,
-0.2035123408,
0.5948479176,
-0.2336951047,
-1.0466639996,
0.4350183308,
-0.5309610367,
0.03661054,
0.7805415392,
0.2248819023,
-0.6240895391,
-0.8921678066,
-0.8123903871,
-1.2059882879,
0.7681017518,
0.3026671112,
0.437400043,
-0.0224871784,
0.6340723038,
-0.2275066078,
0.0499584302,
-0.4248992503,
-0.6719099283,
-0.1093856543,
0.0295040123,
0.0289027561,
-0.3424286544,
0.1410406679,
-0.492151618,
0.8266522288,
-0.0217337441,
0.2152710259,
0.0319293179,
-0.1663699746,
-0.2174781859,
0.1911180019,
0.8673560023,
0.8097275496,
-0.6867104173,
0.0417548157,
0.1092384905,
-0.7124214172,
0.096155487,
0.1708872765,
-0.3338095844,
0.3622376919,
0.0260565989,
0.3673762977,
0.6250290275,
-0.2906511724,
0.6063935161,
-0.052515626,
-0.3055368066,
-0.5781633854,
0.2975991964,
0.0097781206,
-0.4739891291,
0.8237389922,
-0.3553442061,
-0.0234232899,
-0.4179932475,
0.6148355603,
0.3866644204,
-0.7411525846,
-0.2967330813,
0.7804486752,
0.1400686353,
-0.2862912118,
0.4131310582,
-0.2221569568,
-0.3133798838,
0.7753680348,
0.3779448867,
0.6996914148,
-0.3550611138,
0.3316660821,
0.4664378762,
0.1005879641,
-0.0546764508,
0.5901550055,
0.139875263,
-0.5256017447,
-0.2763907611,
-0.9645885229,
-0.3737837374,
-0.0685317144,
-0.9781214595,
0.2951436341,
-0.6186810732,
-0.4545091093,
0.4540815949,
0.444004178,
-0.2018028945,
0.1827656925,
-0.0421373434,
0.7623958588,
-0.689119935,
0.994063139,
0.3622652888,
-0.6515676975,
-0.9161943197,
0.0462964065,
-0.3654518723,
-0.8140081167,
0.9024258852,
-0.1786765009,
-0.3522716165,
0.0805595368,
-0.1385866553,
-1.3365184069,
0.8464277983,
0.5687263012,
-0.1758702695,
0.2252817303,
-0.322804153,
0.8139024973,
-0.1295283288,
0.1283041984,
0.41132617,
1.0441429615,
-0.0047149556,
-0.8226200938,
0.1569347978,
-0.2835754454,
0.0777281225,
0.8991224766,
-0.6323176622,
1.0608379841,
0.0446931794,
-0.1554612666,
0.1000475213,
0.6652181745,
-0.1542785615,
-0.1770310998,
0.3119106293,
0.0923305452,
0.5477648973,
-0.1429514289,
0.9706608653,
-1.1080213785,
0.6796420813,
0.3091419935,
0.0715197176,
0.8885042071,
0.3499390483,
-0.2627631724,
0.4543778896,
0.3091748655,
0.0070922505,
0.4848048687,
0.2177587301,
-0.2793838084,
-0.1220993623,
-0.0611896701,
-0.5146526098,
0.4083563089,
0.6274961233,
-0.3681737781,
-0.3770691752,
-0.4542348087,
0.5017857552,
0.2292784303,
-0.3623212576,
0.6767449379,
0.254881382,
-0.7851065993,
1.0486239195,
0.3366505206,
0.4255683124,
-0.95125103,
0.1663601696,
-0.1913803369,
-0.0793395787,
-0.2006360441,
-0.4566945732,
0.3546197712,
-0.3364421129,
-0.0590537675,
0.1603956223,
0.3179865181,
-0.4503594637,
-0.5002472997,
0.4078187346,
0.1753728986,
0.035517849,
0.0847395435,
-0.5419194698,
-0.2480378598,
-0.5848330259,
-0.4310805202,
0.1104332879,
-0.0167502146,
-0.0615152866,
0.5238233209,
0.422673732,
0.4057255685,
0.2445095181,
-0.0670518801,
0.388956517,
-0.5823139548,
-0.7260535955,
-0.6329416037,
-0.2403358668,
0.0750256553,
-0.4848604202,
0.4806250334,
0.2407488227,
0.1646202356,
0.1572658718,
0.5319473743,
-0.3455054164,
0.3130508959,
-0.4845456183,
0.7935447097,
-0.6718819737,
-0.0844047889,
-0.2474635094,
-1.2026853561,
-0.6610546708,
0.6172863245,
-0.3755693436,
0.3062899411,
0.9377703071,
0.99065274,
-0.013182058,
-0.0881655142,
0.6089300513,
0.1590645462,
0.0693718418,
-0.0435885638,
0.0011801864,
-0.3938892782,
0.3886354268,
-0.027400123,
0.0525879264,
-0.6923412085,
-0.9227032065,
-0.2305210978,
-0.8248646259,
-0.1530070901,
-0.2996083796,
0.3250409663,
0.8818273544,
0.8110283017,
-0.6635990739,
-0.2560171783,
-0.3431928158,
0.1550382376,
-0.5896834731,
-0.2195809633,
0.3502717912,
-0.3802760243,
-0.5851872563,
0.3025161922,
0.1792530119,
-0.1025415808,
-0.5166488886,
-0.2057789266,
-0.2647342682,
0.8700813055,
0.2372826785,
0.7526888251,
-0.7731644511,
-0.5058246255,
-0.2241458297,
-0.2231522352,
0.1507546008,
0.718049109,
-0.6160889864,
0.4375773072,
0.5715514421,
0.1132139489,
0.4855238497,
0.2696309984,
0.8383103013,
-1.1078648567,
0.2117569447,
0.3032081127,
0.1615398526,
0.0195332877,
-0.1649400592,
0.509321928,
0.1864888221,
-0.3820638359,
-0.6578574181,
0.4420917034,
-1.1325566769,
-0.1318944246,
1.1562407017,
0.2771949768,
-0.3517805934,
-0.2045327872,
-0.0866283774,
0.0146634737,
-0.5743624568,
0.6008121967,
0.8441867828,
0.0044140108,
-0.1691194773,
-0.7044515014,
0.7449389696,
0.5669508576,
-0.2351244092,
-0.168615669,
0.2698177099,
0.2838320732,
0.157175675,
0.5436909199,
-0.3257394433,
0.1151425242,
0.0099517675,
-0.254119575,
-0.2224526107,
-0.403003633,
-0.242220521,
0.5875834227,
0.6944946647,
-0.0493007377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00263v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00263v3
|
Does DetectGPT Fully Utilize Perturbation? Bridge Selective Perturbation to Fine-tuned Contrastive Learning Detector would be Better
| 2024-02-01T01:23:07 | 2024-02-24T13:46:21 |
Shengchao Liu, Xiaoming Liu, Yichen Wang, Zehua Cheng, Chengzhengxu Li, Zhaohan Zhang, Yu Lan, Chao Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The burgeoning generative capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
raised growing concerns about abuse, demanding automatic machine-generated text
detectors. DetectGPT, a zero-shot metric-based detector, first introduces
perturbation and shows great performance improvement. However, in DetectGPT,
random perturbation strategy could introduce noise, and logit regression
depends on threshold, harming the generalizability and applicability of
individual or small-batch inputs. Hence, we propose a novel fine-tuned
detector, Pecola, bridging metric-based and fine-tuned detectors by contrastive
learning on selective perturbation. Selective strategy retains important tokens
during perturbation and weights for multi-pair contrastive learning. The
experiments show that Pecola outperforms the state-of-the-art by 1.20% in
accuracy on average on four public datasets. And we further analyze the
effectiveness, robustness, and generalization of the method.
|
[
-0.3163416982,
-0.9275110364,
0.5511884093,
0.1319216043,
-0.4451208711,
0.0499955788,
-0.2170226276,
-0.1967912167,
-0.0839893147,
0.3262999058,
-0.2305040061,
-0.7242156267,
-0.8070366383,
0.0090817856,
-0.2609692514,
1.1286039352,
0.0717146173,
0.0322379023,
0.3663887382,
0.105699122,
-0.1113786623,
-0.4809280932,
-0.8947042227,
-0.3437441289,
0.6498056054,
0.4475694597,
0.2528712749,
0.2817728221,
0.4351362288,
0.2183842361,
-0.2115000784,
0.0775232017,
-0.5494740605,
0.2072439045,
0.0692081451,
-0.5110304952,
-0.2855034769,
0.007175033,
0.7588230371,
0.3493104279,
-0.0246159341,
-0.0235059783,
0.3250349164,
0.4113564491,
-0.7646859288,
0.00516759,
-0.9980435967,
-0.0178062432,
-0.4478542507,
-0.2446311414,
-0.456039995,
0.243343845,
-0.1649855971,
-0.3389777839,
0.3941394091,
-0.2530573905,
0.7737559676,
0.4760201871,
-0.2789590061,
0.0265694819,
-0.7079114914,
0.9647767544,
-0.4445852339,
0.329790324,
0.427406311,
0.2552048266,
-0.1432487518,
-0.8175012469,
-0.4082021713,
-0.3246805072,
-0.0223661028,
0.2896074355,
-0.1774569452,
-0.0123442337,
0.2858013511,
0.5835459828,
-0.6173138022,
0.4121445417,
0.1210436597,
-0.3851186633,
0.3294379711,
0.0885735974,
0.0595845878,
0.1621470302,
-0.4250923693,
-0.0450290665,
-0.8340865374,
-0.1746791303,
0.7729392648,
0.368979156,
-0.2249208838,
0.1666732728,
-0.2680589259,
0.7888700962,
0.086111702,
0.3058343828,
0.280140996,
-0.3837081194,
-0.2909709811,
-0.0917635188,
1.0684734583,
-0.1497677714,
0.2699616849,
-0.0818388313,
-0.23246786,
0.2979857028,
-0.3033839762,
-0.9454660416,
-0.8811340332,
-0.0732489675,
-0.1615026742,
-0.6344143152,
-0.0218553785,
-0.75528723,
-0.2697060704,
0.0861207396,
0.2026134431,
-0.3650749624,
-0.2043228447,
0.4814706743,
0.1292856783,
0.2022630423,
0.2861456871,
-1.0320410728,
0.2076682001,
0.3908562362,
0.6669581532,
-0.1885124594,
-0.275950253,
-0.8922611475,
-0.2138624042,
-0.0999905691,
1.1931860447,
-0.7715168595,
-0.3171155155,
-0.3207823932,
-0.0415887758,
0.0134233674,
-0.5838890672,
0.7974558473,
-0.3282470703,
0.2215009928,
-0.1245657578,
-0.2796731591,
0.3059651852,
0.3451545238,
-0.530811727,
0.7709391713,
-0.0662915409,
-0.9571868777,
0.6240538359,
-0.3433787823,
-0.4632099569,
0.1188450828,
-0.2808738649,
-0.9115791917,
-0.106403254,
0.574773252,
0.4131026268,
0.0869503915,
0.0381732583,
-0.3410291672,
-0.7002078295,
0.076748468,
-0.8438341022,
0.6202600002,
0.0411624424,
-0.3865308762,
0.3218931258,
-0.8566471338,
-0.4233067036,
0.2517984509,
-0.74015522,
-0.2423404157,
0.1290539503,
0.0617302023,
-0.1555032879,
0.081995666,
-0.7424784303,
-0.0532961264,
-0.3019191027,
0.4815016687,
0.79602772,
0.0885218233,
0.2011192143,
-0.2997916639,
0.3511552215,
0.0226844773,
0.0261604283,
-0.4446118772,
-0.413831085,
-0.6056748033,
-0.6050355434,
0.5050111413,
0.4088986218,
-0.4743972719,
0.4472353756,
0.1583436877,
-0.3572530448,
-0.3013644218,
0.0638204291,
0.4212557375,
0.5052067041,
0.5476990938,
-0.1537653655,
-0.3675118387,
-0.7024802566,
-0.3658441305,
0.039354153,
-0.200200513,
0.2774710655,
0.36268875,
0.0078496393,
0.2818821669,
-0.5056365728,
-0.327683419,
0.0321234427,
0.0638062358,
0.1711914837,
0.5053893328,
0.5921378732,
-0.8631789684,
-0.9478006363,
0.0402697772,
-0.4373145103,
-0.2326893955,
0.0699974373,
0.1517797709,
-0.0845175385,
0.5707389116,
-0.0950162783,
0.1574563533,
0.6775512099,
-0.3089314103,
0.7366821766,
0.07717935,
-0.0244504716,
-0.8408898115,
0.1058590785,
0.1731031388,
-0.4363856316,
-0.4402323961,
0.009027563,
-0.0119365295,
0.0092327856,
-0.3785095811,
0.3889653087,
-0.2740021646,
0.1494983882,
-0.2856504023,
0.1551353782,
-0.2517033815,
0.3135752678,
0.0072701178,
0.8069351315,
0.7003161907,
-0.5628979206,
0.2732504904,
0.0244090147,
-0.1967329979,
0.6986501813,
-0.5906858444,
0.3453594744,
-0.0993632078,
0.2982443869,
-1.1909011602,
-0.0641496181,
0.2799043059,
-0.7734175324,
0.4349728227,
-0.2378727794,
-0.4540472627,
0.0520050563,
-0.3672552407,
0.2378565371,
0.2550360858,
-0.6707075834,
0.2490927726,
0.2283691019,
0.1577070802,
-0.6096865535,
-0.6215637326,
-0.0321964435,
-0.1303965747,
-0.2211666554,
0.3788058162,
-0.1922117919,
0.038638927,
0.0340785459,
-0.3963049948,
0.2453853637,
0.3058157861,
-0.0630286038,
0.0831779391,
-0.1347587109,
0.182071358,
-0.0926826,
-0.3819124401,
-0.3262597024,
-0.4483247101,
1.0380672216,
-0.1832216084,
-0.3070118129,
-0.5117346048,
0.0077158627,
0.3385996819,
-0.4556215405,
0.2973102629,
1.0554525852,
-0.24507761,
-0.2620178759,
-0.478047967,
-0.3638395369,
-0.5202692747,
0.5263585448,
-0.6492070556,
-1.1002042294,
0.3773137927,
-0.0316573568,
-0.0425261445,
0.2367268801,
0.6126195788,
-0.0830228105,
0.9982660413,
0.4181700945,
-0.2639572024,
0.7794541121,
-0.0799997449,
0.1198335066,
-0.9022593498,
-0.0317946188,
-0.6540958285,
-0.4514657855,
-0.7643823624,
0.0096679814,
0.1320796013,
0.0417697318,
-0.45991835,
0.2295673937,
-0.6959453225,
0.5317906737,
0.4628638327,
0.4290885627,
0.485974431,
0.3727247715,
-0.4068044126,
-0.153389737,
-0.4966051877,
-0.3305621743,
1.3200359344,
0.1290038377,
0.8845344782,
-0.0951029733,
0.8034926057,
-0.0365054496,
0.1952350438,
-0.7145590186,
0.4582853317,
-0.7064483762,
-0.4044253528,
-0.0855448321,
-0.504335463,
-1.0857235193,
0.294834733,
-0.4274816215,
-0.7806740999,
0.0996192098,
0.2898430824,
-0.1876240671,
0.5993626714,
-0.514973402,
0.6863116622,
-0.104633756,
-0.6043129563,
-0.1394651979,
-0.1674681008,
0.1148506999,
-0.0804131627,
-0.3472172916,
-0.0974211842,
-0.0014440661,
0.3235455751,
0.2489385158,
0.8898153305,
-0.0897002816,
0.040894229,
0.0490013771,
0.32852,
0.5759319067,
0.1047203317,
-0.0803077519,
0.0882480145,
-0.3254662454,
-0.7710001469,
-0.4210857451,
0.9124739766,
-0.4570808113,
-0.6931813955,
-0.2570374906,
-0.3952788115,
-0.2901418805,
0.3251230121,
0.5754675865,
0.0906121284,
-0.0518720932,
0.4018140733,
0.7819333076,
-0.1930086315,
0.2553041875,
0.6724137068,
-0.0618334673,
-0.3407698274,
0.9122312069,
-0.1654557586,
0.2337126732,
0.6337003708,
0.3588782251,
0.0335812941,
-0.8487173319,
-0.0622828528,
0.3438324034,
-0.2904033363,
-0.0057627885,
-0.4077098966,
-0.0906410515,
-0.0987513661,
-0.0464362837,
-0.3066125214,
0.0350027904,
-0.292604357,
-0.2102454454,
-0.0415785201,
0.3027112186,
0.0900214985,
0.4530025423,
-0.3979935348,
0.1434570998,
0.4661485851,
0.5564094782,
-0.4121703506,
-0.460858345,
0.1288131475,
-0.2563182712,
-0.285584569,
-0.705260396,
0.1770032346,
-0.0059195296,
0.5648647547,
0.5276940465,
0.0211900268,
0.3418962359,
-0.2184927613,
0.5372090936,
0.1163903102,
-0.6877526045,
0.6073217392,
-0.520412147,
0.3786354661,
0.3976539969,
0.3652409315,
-0.2639071345,
-0.3051554859,
-0.501485467,
-0.5673151612,
0.4792900383,
0.0339292139,
0.1466513276,
0.1557873487,
0.3481927514,
-0.0016866633,
0.104017213,
-0.8390319943,
0.0137759838,
0.1017427891,
-0.1377313584,
-0.1637758017,
-0.2719364464,
-0.0057917959,
0.0010487224,
0.4688479304,
-0.1385205388,
0.2194941193,
0.2870439887,
0.0070837694,
-0.110090673,
0.1214104667,
0.1673570126,
0.24815768,
-0.2751370668,
0.3091746569,
-0.0067952969,
-0.6190461516,
-0.0603685305,
0.241721198,
-0.5789403319,
-0.1738255322,
0.201242581,
0.9100344181,
0.0899839476,
-0.2742211223,
0.3706223071,
-0.0996770859,
-0.3263176978,
-0.044772625,
0.1541053206,
-0.2064188868,
0.2821565568,
0.0872512087,
0.1945093274,
0.0490487032,
-0.3033362329,
0.3866892159,
0.6928286552,
-0.6026991606,
-0.4700211883,
0.8405659795,
0.2232856601,
-0.2939710617,
0.4178889096,
-0.2836782038,
-0.6216039062,
0.4015825391,
0.689661324,
0.7496904731,
-0.3944182098,
0.0891891122,
0.4338610172,
0.4074218273,
0.1958389282,
0.1952859908,
-0.3714912832,
-1.2055504322,
-0.4256913662,
-0.558934629,
-0.2555497289,
0.6735210419,
-0.276766628,
0.4712936282,
-0.7231017947,
-0.1654774249,
0.0930293351,
0.2464937419,
-0.4737477601,
0.0446004048,
0.1708185673,
0.6094763875,
-1.0071080923,
0.9278094769,
0.8451921344,
-0.462813139,
-0.5575094223,
0.4474191964,
0.011894702,
-0.7354056835,
0.4097981751,
0.139525637,
-0.2213459909,
0.2410984486,
-0.6806601286,
-0.3686361313,
0.7979104519,
0.563247323,
-0.7128189206,
0.1851707846,
-0.3390795588,
0.4163067341,
0.0083980393,
0.0334795155,
0.7423291802,
0.4033711851,
-0.0085510956,
-0.701561451,
-0.0146974754,
-0.0770571008,
-0.3012213111,
0.3898321688,
-0.8539758921,
0.8479934931,
0.0233216025,
-0.3680776656,
-0.0935899988,
0.1316320747,
0.3509591818,
0.2072874457,
0.4598469734,
0.7876596451,
0.6336098909,
-0.2452368289,
0.8600298762,
-0.2273931354,
0.4752679169,
1.1870430708,
-0.1606779546,
0.745390296,
0.3899497092,
-0.5165798664,
0.2678965032,
0.6879794002,
-0.3395531774,
0.4333409071,
0.1804953218,
-0.5873996615,
-0.487919271,
0.1399533451,
-0.0581419319,
0.4203624129,
0.4880822003,
-0.3551254869,
-0.324814558,
-0.2498200089,
0.1112111807,
0.3134341836,
-0.276645869,
0.4069223702,
0.066658929,
-0.4523542225,
0.5550427437,
-0.0499743931,
1.1422036886,
-0.5142615438,
0.0049389321,
-0.3908729255,
0.4717323184,
-0.4740534127,
-0.6367361546,
-0.0796877518,
-0.1478499174,
0.114479363,
0.1476910412,
1.016474247,
-0.4255887568,
-0.2067786455,
0.4704335332,
0.2171021849,
-0.114058435,
-0.3176491261,
-0.5246161819,
-0.1137269735,
0.184195742,
-0.2175196409,
0.5180754066,
0.1216105074,
0.1685665995,
0.4353999197,
0.8795319796,
0.4182544351,
0.0396030843,
0.2407000065,
0.8413537145,
-0.1871307045,
-0.3014469445,
-1.0136421919,
0.3156405985,
-0.0307402406,
-0.2030698359,
0.6279696822,
0.4552888274,
1.1460425854,
0.1125455424,
0.7409710884,
0.3907218874,
0.3020059466,
-0.5195392966,
0.5371333957,
-0.4429006577,
0.3746995926,
-0.1948981285,
-1.0432702303,
-0.9210486412,
0.6617142558,
-0.5383653045,
-0.0377215333,
0.674308598,
0.8301141262,
-0.237537235,
-0.3038128912,
0.6270665526,
0.3059509397,
0.5736608505,
0.6951826215,
0.6098429561,
-0.4221751988,
0.7878662348,
-0.1789444685,
-0.3706785142,
-0.0393859111,
-0.7186263204,
-0.9190789461,
-0.4683080316,
-0.3363391459,
-0.2361830622,
0.2716031373,
0.2590812445,
0.6628632545,
-1.0096421242,
0.0916407555,
-0.495046258,
0.051057253,
-0.0600671843,
-0.2366923839,
0.4292385578,
-0.6138568521,
-1.1428233385,
0.4375252128,
0.4451788068,
-0.0580902398,
-0.2384412885,
0.0325694792,
-0.1669588387,
-0.1810349077,
0.4976681173,
0.2642554641,
-0.2399840951,
-0.1395066231,
-0.0925147086,
-0.0021112696,
0.1980526447,
0.8145791888,
-0.8079410195,
0.6235634685,
0.6970480084,
0.6962720156,
0.9862109423,
-0.1091221496,
0.2258931994,
-0.7864128947,
0.3776461482,
0.294261694,
0.5205875635,
0.3265506923,
-0.3704958856,
0.47709921,
0.6012808681,
-0.6926723123,
-0.7181936502,
0.6616814733,
-0.5113680959,
-0.2901582122,
1.0535827875,
-0.2809809148,
0.0310828872,
-0.0610872731,
-0.1793013513,
0.1807155907,
-0.5682029128,
0.6628236175,
0.6426296234,
-0.1173142195,
-0.3406769931,
-0.2434192151,
0.3054075837,
0.6151605844,
-0.4514253736,
-0.2068877816,
0.3545316756,
0.545936048,
-0.0098869419,
0.6328517795,
-0.4370090067,
0.1613006592,
0.158250019,
-0.2979962528,
-0.2485608608,
-0.3294400275,
-0.5054829717,
0.2442554086,
0.2345684916,
-0.50826931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00253v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00253v2
|
A Survey on Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-01T00:33:21 | 2024-05-06T01:10:01 |
Hanchao Liu, Wenyuan Xue, Yifei Chen, Dapeng Chen, Xiutian Zhao, Ke Wang, Liping Hou, Rongjun Li, Wei Peng
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent development of Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) has attracted
growing attention within the AI landscape for its practical implementation
potential. However, ``hallucination'', or more specifically, the misalignment
between factual visual content and corresponding textual generation, poses a
significant challenge of utilizing LVLMs. In this comprehensive survey, we
dissect LVLM-related hallucinations in an attempt to establish an overview and
facilitate future mitigation. Our scrutiny starts with a clarification of the
concept of hallucinations in LVLMs, presenting a variety of hallucination
symptoms and highlighting the unique challenges inherent in LVLM
hallucinations. Subsequently, we outline the benchmarks and methodologies
tailored specifically for evaluating hallucinations unique to LVLMs.
Additionally, we delve into an investigation of the root causes of these
hallucinations, encompassing insights from the training data and model
components. We also critically review existing methods for mitigating
hallucinations. The open questions and future directions pertaining to
hallucinations within LVLMs are discussed to conclude this survey.
|
[
-0.4356105328,
-0.9074495435,
0.7329555154,
-0.0256059226,
-0.0556529239,
-0.2285489142,
-0.2597368956,
-0.7755599022,
0.2845830917,
0.8560498357,
-0.5693978071,
-0.3235836625,
-0.4950392544,
0.0523637161,
-0.5882509947,
0.6176466346,
0.0392002761,
0.1740721464,
-0.3023320436,
-0.1228540242,
-0.8672332168,
-0.828537643,
-0.4802299142,
-0.1924119741,
0.6354342103,
-0.0602174178,
0.5943014622,
0.1090410948,
0.7359555364,
0.2400207967,
0.0689821094,
0.4148058593,
-0.7279344201,
0.4374254644,
0.0903996676,
-0.2109735459,
-0.1746174395,
-0.3317540288,
0.6589013934,
0.9882982969,
-0.2437437326,
-0.0802112669,
0.0334651545,
0.860131979,
-0.8676941395,
-0.0851747021,
-0.690753758,
0.5208554864,
-0.0457500294,
-0.1638457626,
-0.6197548509,
-0.1256430894,
0.2510605454,
-0.2292493284,
0.3284572363,
0.264593184,
0.4652598202,
0.8053810596,
-0.2510835528,
-0.4621788561,
-1.0300738811,
0.8290053606,
-0.4072158337,
0.7362286448,
0.3088972569,
0.339312166,
0.0258119199,
-0.6297792792,
-0.5483952165,
-0.4477601349,
-0.0285688434,
-0.0249062348,
-0.0716929361,
-0.0920157135,
0.4453914165,
0.2216047049,
-0.7861068845,
0.229449138,
-0.5749069452,
-0.3233101666,
0.652577579,
0.4791627824,
0.218723923,
-0.0379498303,
-0.1145956516,
0.0482105091,
-0.7251701355,
-0.3177223504,
0.1903243065,
0.1047736481,
0.3762392402,
0.8327741623,
0.0006384183,
0.8121597171,
-0.3953409493,
0.0813091174,
0.2328421772,
-0.2520430386,
-0.3080963194,
0.1581779569,
0.5062927008,
0.6585280895,
0.3954424262,
-0.2686037719,
-0.4317919016,
0.1104789674,
0.7128857374,
-0.5878176093,
-0.2796497345,
0.4805422425,
-0.6557911038,
-0.2781437039,
-0.0466211215,
-0.7630666494,
-1.1046447754,
-0.4451112747,
0.350484848,
-0.3338645101,
-0.2858946919,
0.125496462,
-0.1883503795,
0.4424504936,
0.4223113358,
-0.7330115438,
0.0948382542,
0.5624123812,
0.6676940918,
-0.3966104984,
-0.5778514743,
-0.5728034973,
-0.1233041137,
-0.4616357684,
0.6228784919,
-0.3350208998,
-0.2405037284,
0.4470347464,
-0.0695733726,
0.0030774807,
-0.8226414323,
0.2946273983,
-0.0973693505,
0.0717216879,
-0.4498900771,
-0.36773929,
-0.2260088772,
0.2840167284,
-0.7445374131,
0.7286401987,
-0.1744865775,
-0.7505609989,
0.3576413393,
-0.2076098174,
-0.2277661115,
0.1337156743,
-0.4979503155,
-0.4331856966,
0.4126978517,
0.0790871456,
0.6337532997,
-0.1068200245,
0.3556372225,
0.0106124142,
-0.5434539318,
0.3618929088,
-0.3895017207,
0.5034371018,
0.0041444153,
-0.395955056,
0.4250105619,
-0.7182811499,
-0.2529181838,
0.2793389261,
0.3518793285,
-0.3981741667,
0.3948919177,
0.098175332,
-0.1336397976,
0.0601095222,
0.0369310006,
0.1612005085,
-0.2817054093,
0.1160021275,
0.7612580061,
0.0949966684,
0.218313098,
-0.1705238223,
0.2097685337,
0.0522494279,
0.4399359822,
0.0083969096,
-0.3185492158,
-0.998581171,
0.0450442657,
-0.3508092761,
0.3301245868,
-0.9184035659,
0.2172340602,
0.013031465,
-0.4172469378,
-0.350869745,
-0.1383113265,
0.3674137592,
0.4485424161,
0.3722519875,
-0.1563686281,
-0.5269027352,
-0.9487892389,
-0.0018409081,
-0.0910525396,
0.2854454219,
0.2304858267,
0.7554411888,
-0.4688421786,
0.4976133108,
-0.4527057707,
-0.5078724027,
-0.2610234618,
-0.0281734988,
-0.3651615977,
0.2188314199,
0.5951855779,
-0.9837291241,
-0.0813061595,
-0.0355839022,
-0.900437355,
0.1928388178,
-0.3252695501,
0.262612164,
0.6447451115,
0.6958053708,
-0.6112394929,
0.65863657,
0.4228329062,
-0.2902934551,
0.9228006005,
-0.1031736434,
0.1216956005,
-0.6285575628,
-0.0181581955,
-0.2200386077,
0.1842475682,
-0.728066802,
0.2117447555,
-0.309941411,
0.1029372886,
-0.4331598282,
0.2348880321,
-0.489564985,
-0.3799068332,
-0.0943427309,
0.2443175912,
-0.3436551094,
0.2534830868,
0.230210945,
0.3983663321,
0.7416160107,
-0.5513138175,
0.7987027764,
0.1963261217,
-0.5339680314,
0.1603157073,
-0.3923534751,
0.0378337242,
-0.4591177702,
0.0367255285,
-0.7924993634,
-0.4146491289,
0.5266566277,
-0.2194851935,
0.0531595945,
0.2958702147,
-0.4453427196,
-0.3536501527,
-0.3691310585,
0.5037477016,
0.5097292662,
-0.5086467266,
0.4124399722,
0.254747808,
0.2047301531,
-0.6834958196,
-0.6975027919,
0.3362422884,
-0.2137788981,
-0.4771784544,
0.0236673541,
-0.1462654173,
-0.629110992,
-0.1474643052,
0.1650869101,
0.2533814013,
-0.024896061,
0.2562500238,
0.174461931,
-0.1666124314,
0.1386741549,
-0.5616700649,
0.2357785553,
0.3597529829,
-0.0763505697,
0.856926918,
-0.0956287459,
-0.7261625528,
-0.2096748948,
0.4613953233,
0.5477243662,
-0.3200371265,
0.7191406488,
0.6172152758,
-0.5991293192,
-0.4026128054,
-0.7269393206,
-0.3765845895,
-0.3316733241,
0.7005884051,
-0.3164088726,
-0.6078752875,
0.5311636925,
0.2541501522,
-0.1154259667,
0.3635749221,
0.7810326219,
-0.0625369921,
0.9872535467,
0.6267889738,
0.1666522324,
0.2359822541,
-0.2706602812,
0.4060818553,
-0.5791298151,
-0.6501452923,
-0.3316388726,
-0.1443544626,
-0.5054709315,
-0.4848375916,
0.1669755876,
-0.3913559318,
0.0690764263,
-0.1817259192,
-0.6669539213,
0.4146464765,
0.3379093111,
-0.0849452093,
0.0629881695,
0.0946379229,
0.2281499505,
-0.1581898481,
-0.6115500927,
-0.3244163692,
0.7483797073,
0.2969983816,
0.7852280736,
0.0492907129,
0.6639950871,
0.2547390163,
-0.2117741406,
-0.8548160195,
0.6547236443,
0.0310377963,
-0.3451111317,
-0.6071377397,
-0.2881076038,
-0.7658266425,
0.2500070333,
-0.3425239325,
-1.0936187506,
0.1625510752,
0.1561537087,
-0.1937697679,
0.297724843,
-0.3902239799,
0.9230965376,
-0.3888799548,
-0.3474324942,
-0.2974693477,
-0.6494984627,
0.710224092,
-0.0813872963,
0.0472961254,
0.2879399061,
0.4018934667,
0.4265879393,
-0.2010053843,
0.9661484361,
-0.1501069069,
-0.4647288322,
0.2574363351,
0.0356723331,
0.4166644216,
-0.3411174715,
0.3700892925,
0.2047769278,
-0.054895293,
-0.1051929295,
-0.5184644461,
0.6174667478,
-0.565630734,
-0.6411985159,
-0.6233661175,
-0.5956625342,
-0.2168804854,
-0.024509808,
0.4189560115,
0.3994252682,
-0.3466073573,
0.299487263,
0.8969350457,
-0.5191620588,
0.4153726995,
-0.0882083029,
-0.8474237323,
-0.1172896624,
1.2332808971,
0.2087731957,
0.2570359707,
0.1248722374,
-0.1358288527,
-0.2095500231,
-0.8639550209,
-0.2715449929,
0.2254816145,
-0.8662536144,
0.2566098273,
-0.5062735677,
-0.6015478969,
-0.5279394984,
-0.0315093212,
-0.3573825657,
-0.1215807199,
-0.369153589,
0.1147129089,
-0.0253357422,
0.9641677737,
0.3792045712,
-0.0814285278,
-0.5699740052,
0.5558125973,
0.1706408411,
0.1537865102,
0.31779024,
-0.2387890965,
-0.2326829582,
-0.1285773814,
0.082960777,
-0.6927796006,
0.4816289842,
-0.2117595077,
0.5573610663,
0.5984445214,
0.0936173722,
0.7796962261,
-0.5902714729,
1.1539388895,
0.3601446748,
-0.5446557999,
0.4698521793,
0.0904190093,
0.0371721834,
0.1954202801,
0.2858177125,
-0.6484593153,
-0.5856561065,
-0.2251601219,
-0.7144855857,
0.1979364604,
0.3355596066,
0.0287680104,
0.1365252137,
0.2055870593,
0.2605548799,
0.0876385123,
-0.7867745757,
-0.0775584579,
-0.1743700802,
-0.0174584966,
-0.0894929245,
-0.4309014082,
-0.2511523366,
-0.3211078048,
0.4416933358,
0.002269848,
0.0256124567,
0.2098979652,
-0.3732994795,
-0.0958327949,
-0.1856232882,
0.9394749403,
0.9855149984,
-0.2296142578,
0.1501447707,
0.1091479585,
-0.5675536394,
-0.2842039168,
-0.3382901251,
-0.2919774354,
0.0920926929,
0.6626989245,
1.1348817348,
-0.2493142337,
-1.0400165319,
0.518024385,
-0.1483907551,
-0.2935609221,
-0.8016747832,
0.1171688735,
-0.247542873,
0.4245743155,
0.3758124709,
-0.0124449031,
0.1726140231,
-0.7313861251,
-0.061834272,
0.6645222306,
-0.4460369945,
-0.1139016971,
0.5799450874,
-0.0674262941,
-0.3841924667,
0.8388827443,
0.1065228507,
-0.5741838813,
0.6549733877,
0.3602734208,
1.0121508837,
-0.0271985438,
0.0486827642,
0.1548743695,
0.5991104841,
-0.1367000937,
0.3233859241,
0.0902763531,
-0.7475097775,
-0.1813986599,
-0.6818948984,
-0.372597903,
0.3086631894,
-0.6058408618,
0.4046348035,
-0.1818605065,
0.019785149,
-0.1062138602,
-0.3735055029,
-0.5197908878,
0.2498668283,
0.6542033553,
0.5334111452,
-0.7708386183,
0.6402908564,
0.4153172672,
-0.5291510224,
-0.2262479961,
0.340308398,
-0.0862374529,
-0.6084893346,
0.5609030724,
0.28136608,
-0.2971279323,
-0.2256473154,
-0.6461573839,
-0.3611584604,
0.8986337185,
-0.1663083434,
-0.6661611795,
-0.2927245796,
0.5082665682,
0.5787159801,
-0.3578453958,
-0.2868021131,
0.7567320466,
0.4785829782,
0.0968515426,
-0.6822490692,
0.0286929384,
0.0620893016,
0.0203750525,
0.0611428022,
-0.6929288507,
0.6373178959,
-0.2934959233,
-0.0524439141,
0.2128749788,
0.3962640762,
0.3172755539,
0.5384833217,
0.49817729,
0.3977195919,
0.8069509268,
-0.0308024082,
0.9090015888,
-0.0663640052,
0.0107270507,
1.0156021118,
-0.4828812182,
0.7346887589,
0.9238089323,
0.1429087222,
0.0041843737,
0.462569654,
-0.2726736367,
0.4596772194,
0.3680340648,
-0.0637103096,
-0.244282037,
-0.0453533642,
-0.5954198241,
0.5319777727,
0.3689316809,
-0.2476194799,
0.1721943766,
0.3589685559,
-0.6417797804,
-0.0793474019,
-0.3742379844,
0.765645802,
0.0202883873,
-0.7792702913,
0.6805428267,
-0.4300694168,
0.2932491004,
-0.3742532432,
-0.282146275,
-0.2585827708,
0.1059120074,
-0.1951186508,
-0.6019949913,
0.4439691901,
-0.0481341109,
-0.2002428472,
-0.2448860854,
0.7810088992,
-0.3619087636,
-0.4194933176,
0.3467788696,
0.5255179405,
0.4966086745,
-0.3040070534,
-0.1733674705,
0.6537419558,
0.1340846121,
-0.1371821314,
0.12694484,
0.5506052375,
-0.1895977408,
0.673645556,
0.3083426356,
0.1891331524,
0.2729912698,
0.5195813179,
0.7148048878,
-1.0047389269,
-0.0972278565,
-0.9693992734,
0.5589873791,
-0.0824570656,
-0.2978048623,
0.5366006494,
0.5833135843,
0.7982746959,
-0.4754947126,
0.7687448859,
0.0801646337,
0.1385002285,
-0.8294090033,
1.0167771578,
-0.9409897923,
0.2279486209,
-0.2736688256,
-1.2318419218,
-0.4791558683,
0.6364882588,
-0.1013104841,
-0.2732169628,
0.8599407077,
0.8084782362,
0.1120308042,
-0.0674633235,
0.713375926,
0.469956845,
0.1103382781,
0.4679384232,
1.4546785355,
-0.1210848689,
0.415248245,
-0.1309202462,
0.1454403698,
-0.6280715466,
-0.6742577553,
-0.9584902525,
-0.9448990822,
-0.3637831509,
-0.2133504152,
0.1220723018,
0.5477910042,
0.2874075174,
-0.7532302737,
-0.1370761544,
-0.1389370114,
0.1307540238,
0.0002686228,
-0.1911752224,
0.3309550881,
-0.3961391151,
-0.6778382063,
0.1405663192,
0.303297013,
0.1924511343,
-0.9269633889,
-0.1502228975,
0.1889526993,
-0.1596402973,
0.8703663349,
0.0625845566,
-1.2688890696,
-0.5527659655,
0.1722680479,
-0.1512398273,
-0.0852792859,
0.7842116952,
-0.6372480989,
0.4585387707,
0.3908861876,
0.5417720079,
0.4090345502,
-0.314884901,
0.2702569962,
-0.5728021264,
0.3290978372,
0.4897475541,
0.3758185506,
0.3612429798,
-0.2876365781,
0.4314518273,
0.2957430482,
-0.4136204422,
-1.2572925091,
0.3790266812,
-1.1164159775,
-0.5403469801,
1.175937891,
0.5188409686,
-0.1580379456,
0.0829282925,
-0.5741269588,
0.018046001,
0.3683443069,
1.1343771219,
0.9666948318,
-0.1784286946,
-0.2767814398,
-0.747412622,
0.5906050801,
0.3497133553,
-0.7016772032,
0.41310063,
0.9995098114,
-0.3469980657,
0.2497114539,
0.3908850253,
0.2139610797,
0.1917029768,
0.2163776606,
0.2902207971,
0.2175760269,
-0.7112688422,
-0.3289656639,
0.2330146283,
-0.0138496058,
0.0313155949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00251v1
|
Efficient Non-Parametric Uncertainty Quantification for Black-Box Large Language Models and Decision Planning
| 2024-02-01T00:23:31 | 2024-02-01T00:23:31 |
Yao-Hung Hubert Tsai, Walter Talbott, Jian Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Step-by-step decision planning with large language models (LLMs) is gaining
attention in AI agent development. This paper focuses on decision planning with
uncertainty estimation to address the hallucination problem in language models.
Existing approaches are either white-box or computationally demanding, limiting
use of black-box proprietary LLMs within budgets. The paper's first
contribution is a non-parametric uncertainty quantification method for LLMs,
efficiently estimating point-wise dependencies between input-decision on the
fly with a single inference, without access to token logits. This estimator
informs the statistical interpretation of decision trustworthiness. The second
contribution outlines a systematic design for a decision-making agent,
generating actions like ``turn on the bathroom light'' based on user prompts
such as ``take a bath''. Users will be asked to provide preferences when more
than one action has high estimated point-wise dependencies. In conclusion, our
uncertainty estimation and decision-making agent design offer a cost-efficient
approach for AI agent development.
|
[
-0.1901943982,
-0.6056764126,
1.0932506323,
0.2024631649,
0.1100020185,
-0.1653027385,
-0.0902500302,
-0.3746436238,
0.2579987049,
0.4907789528,
-0.3275378048,
-0.4008304477,
-0.448770225,
-0.0269400179,
-0.0521831401,
0.255423069,
-0.1281728894,
0.0566424988,
-0.1262241751,
0.0131487828,
-0.3162123561,
-0.061305441,
-0.8070448637,
-0.2977851033,
0.3986819685,
0.2343999892,
1.0876346827,
0.2329249978,
0.0827305019,
0.260556221,
0.1179310456,
0.3326449692,
0.0191447027,
0.2637214363,
-0.2098022103,
-0.3693857789,
-0.6228840947,
-0.223484382,
0.1023944467,
0.5152459145,
-0.0878518,
0.137865141,
-0.1961112171,
0.5380156636,
-0.8839896917,
0.5215005279,
-0.5238392949,
0.2037156671,
0.5542564988,
-0.2221234143,
-0.5775815845,
-0.1558274776,
0.0415949039,
-0.46792835,
-0.0719605759,
0.0371330418,
0.3770233393,
0.7464154959,
-0.1533470452,
-0.3632547557,
-1.0139876604,
0.9780846834,
-0.6909836531,
0.7732024193,
0.8558708429,
0.1317786425,
-0.3832433224,
-0.595556736,
-0.5052927732,
-0.5027977228,
-0.0556596108,
-0.2762806714,
0.0431038029,
0.2910173237,
0.1391953379,
-0.2453120351,
-0.5050429106,
-0.1095552593,
-0.0473438203,
-0.2949825227,
0.784663558,
-0.0191200599,
0.0602323562,
-0.1523222029,
-0.1714911312,
-0.0071707861,
-0.2601646185,
-0.151711449,
0.2205721289,
0.3355606198,
0.0094670039,
0.5888819098,
-0.1981909871,
0.4608106315,
0.0427271575,
-0.4609267712,
-0.0774996653,
-0.26681301,
-0.3648543358,
0.0973732769,
0.7402173281,
0.1636399925,
0.3573567569,
-0.3478083313,
-0.4397130013,
0.0385809019,
0.4229225516,
-0.7201237082,
-0.1061784923,
0.6900980473,
-0.2733242214,
-0.2830856442,
-0.2765174508,
-1.034920454,
-0.6010894775,
-0.2827722728,
0.4540615976,
-0.4384497106,
-0.2185019255,
0.0636984184,
0.0998875573,
0.4088579416,
0.428042531,
-0.7510452867,
0.2243116647,
0.3588577509,
0.6903429031,
-0.0135246394,
-0.3688533008,
-0.4023807645,
0.3488779962,
-0.8014350533,
0.5327882171,
-0.5353392363,
-0.4238922,
-0.0443431772,
-0.4799391031,
0.097440362,
-0.3644105196,
0.2722184658,
-0.3801799715,
-0.2948993146,
-0.021946894,
-0.3289478123,
-0.1943077594,
0.3073579967,
-0.6943866014,
0.7714502215,
0.2829224467,
-0.4323500991,
0.5259535313,
-0.5507653356,
-0.5034440756,
0.1551122665,
-0.3431202471,
-0.4135459661,
0.2263230085,
0.4064526856,
0.414518714,
-0.2057875246,
0.3843261898,
-0.2456376255,
-0.2941662371,
0.1798013449,
-0.3900511265,
0.6539002061,
0.2336062342,
-0.5936066508,
0.4568598568,
-0.7543424964,
0.1211542934,
0.0201266129,
-0.0568448007,
-0.0572106466,
0.3220826387,
-0.1961259991,
0.1745012254,
0.4879694581,
0.0794273913,
-0.0778353289,
-0.0604786463,
0.3799948692,
0.8018590808,
0.0926920697,
0.5599137545,
-0.3143088222,
0.6848846674,
-0.3251678944,
0.4979017973,
0.3733276129,
-0.4349864423,
-0.720431447,
-0.1902062297,
0.0496461429,
0.4610348642,
-0.7578805685,
0.5071830153,
0.2034490258,
-0.3892197609,
-0.2562092543,
-0.0838871151,
0.1041459441,
0.0713474676,
0.3292860389,
0.3041511476,
-0.27655527,
-0.4901835322,
0.1414562315,
-0.7159230113,
0.0552290007,
0.2138088495,
0.6085662842,
-0.3335753977,
0.6809671521,
-0.3298317194,
-0.0989146605,
-0.2947691679,
0.1093087494,
-0.3372211754,
0.1677306592,
0.3191352487,
-0.7778853178,
-0.2299400568,
-0.143451646,
-0.6896448731,
0.190748632,
-0.418301791,
-0.1945322156,
0.4948890209,
0.4647430778,
-0.9683115482,
0.7058998942,
0.3927641809,
-0.2095540911,
0.6296102405,
-0.3665358424,
0.0744435713,
-0.9836014509,
-0.1201189831,
0.0870847628,
-0.0364889279,
-0.7324903011,
0.2547907829,
-0.0380486958,
0.0259827431,
-0.389156729,
0.7221354842,
-0.5403125286,
-0.3224502802,
-0.2520700693,
-0.0553448983,
-0.1381069422,
0.7456235886,
0.2668136954,
0.8669122458,
0.5827285051,
-0.665961206,
0.1105881259,
0.0858932585,
-0.2316657603,
0.4248532057,
-0.4771881402,
0.2346158475,
0.025288647,
0.0633058622,
-0.6875482202,
-0.0979347229,
0.6377446055,
-0.5238803029,
0.1423790306,
0.0648863539,
-0.4045131207,
0.008214104,
-0.2867463231,
0.3694346845,
0.3061718345,
-0.2680815756,
0.7759516835,
0.4091820121,
-0.0604614392,
-0.5670463443,
-0.5236014724,
0.1682884693,
-0.2172326297,
-0.4431002438,
-0.007538157,
-0.0765621886,
-0.6873793602,
-0.1328962743,
-0.3509473503,
-0.2786312401,
0.0354302824,
0.3253996372,
0.1320398748,
0.0388139337,
-0.0010152863,
0.0140692871,
-0.1418850273,
0.2642552853,
-0.2988556623,
0.60330832,
0.0810627043,
-0.5193566084,
-0.3891646862,
0.2716949284,
0.6852772236,
-0.229253009,
0.5338502526,
0.2336749732,
-0.6579504609,
-0.7528421879,
-0.4030148685,
-0.2574983835,
-0.4542010725,
0.2548021972,
-0.4548435211,
-0.3256932199,
0.5386599302,
0.1291660815,
-0.0100637665,
0.0907697007,
0.5304036736,
0.1525855213,
0.9237272739,
0.5776741505,
0.1341888756,
0.1924890131,
-0.1058012098,
0.4813941717,
-0.2663279474,
-0.1577774733,
-0.5067611337,
-0.2094061524,
-0.5949602127,
-0.8679306507,
0.2991706729,
-0.2988937497,
-0.091264151,
0.0043491847,
-0.3193128407,
0.113366127,
0.5657902956,
0.0465545841,
0.221166119,
-0.1677115262,
0.1761566252,
0.3390507996,
-0.2898941636,
-0.5713734627,
1.0493407249,
0.2424377799,
0.9558107853,
0.007702861,
0.8468052745,
0.1861887574,
-0.2946976721,
-1.0346744061,
0.6352545619,
0.5675622821,
-0.4702716768,
-1.0295494795,
-0.3945391178,
-0.8555802107,
0.1782360822,
-0.0064399475,
-0.804402411,
0.4744260013,
-0.1240393594,
-0.466740191,
0.3712597787,
-0.4883803427,
0.4398401082,
-0.2873367071,
-0.2300111204,
-0.16140531,
-0.454171598,
0.0680110902,
-0.2799914777,
0.0766617134,
-0.0198859964,
-0.2852962315,
0.5396637917,
-0.4207711816,
0.5813502669,
-0.3385218084,
-0.116319865,
0.4115423858,
0.3815498352,
0.8907983899,
0.2792767584,
-0.4189770818,
0.082102105,
-0.0148835983,
-0.421676755,
-0.6980499029,
0.4098311067,
-0.6480333805,
-0.6386117339,
-0.5859324336,
-0.9752725959,
-0.5534594655,
0.1983290464,
0.0486128703,
0.0019436358,
-0.0555620342,
-0.3289497495,
0.5746392608,
-0.3642368317,
0.6795001626,
0.2713854015,
-0.0917866901,
-0.2691158354,
0.7737179399,
0.1938464344,
0.1649328321,
0.4242792428,
0.1094598025,
-0.3751836121,
-1.049793601,
-0.3227752447,
0.2486718446,
-0.4423904717,
-0.0041618468,
-0.2815264463,
-0.3921375573,
-0.7199164033,
-0.4613154531,
-0.3448435664,
-0.2266142666,
-0.2435441464,
-0.2999478877,
0.2329640538,
0.7757502794,
-0.0868037269,
0.0898289755,
-0.2025707364,
0.4735610783,
0.1682239771,
0.3777773678,
0.0934060812,
-0.1130085737,
-0.1958137751,
-0.040420346,
-0.1170261055,
-0.9673591256,
0.6899805665,
-0.2888092101,
0.54992342,
0.5066905618,
0.6517015696,
0.4962304533,
-0.1286326796,
0.6250231862,
-0.1656060815,
-0.774851501,
0.4471477568,
-0.0791702867,
0.0340481848,
0.707070291,
0.2482288778,
-0.1140090674,
-0.4869333804,
-0.6444458365,
-0.7388516665,
0.5791923404,
0.2735126615,
-0.1555019617,
0.2143202275,
0.2085678577,
0.0977489799,
0.3291861415,
-0.6339344978,
-0.2693941891,
0.0251708347,
-0.052261591,
-0.2040487677,
-0.3111705482,
-0.0176197346,
-0.2258937061,
0.6928593516,
-0.2055623978,
0.3891968131,
0.0258067418,
-0.2001390904,
-0.2221871912,
0.1951596737,
0.6649708152,
1.0640889406,
-0.4149947166,
0.2878826559,
0.2821448445,
-0.2825061977,
0.3818505406,
0.0415755585,
-0.3453630209,
0.0276985448,
0.2950282991,
0.6709466577,
-0.0851133615,
-0.5677872896,
0.2496036887,
-0.0168945063,
-0.3189602196,
-0.6572167277,
-0.004958292,
-0.1199560836,
0.6195607781,
0.0673952848,
-0.0852384493,
0.19114016,
-0.2482110262,
0.3369731009,
0.4610307217,
-0.4846353233,
0.0075210701,
0.5335724354,
-0.030470904,
-0.5028497577,
0.4720122814,
-0.6628622413,
-0.0076274835,
0.5991029739,
0.3986822665,
1.2422025204,
-0.2839590907,
0.7776385546,
0.1275462657,
0.5050705075,
-0.0173688941,
0.5438713431,
0.0007163401,
-0.7458220124,
-0.295650214,
-0.6918786168,
-0.5551566482,
0.2087467462,
-0.3453633487,
0.3568194807,
-0.711890161,
-0.0893058479,
-0.2871312201,
0.1186294481,
-0.3988600075,
0.1681104749,
-0.0222950857,
0.6234922409,
-0.6064642072,
0.7514953613,
0.5298628807,
-0.4317699075,
-0.9071320295,
0.4587699771,
-0.2069527507,
-0.995616436,
0.1216868535,
-0.2033728361,
-0.3512184918,
-0.2584503889,
-0.4176329374,
-0.8125901222,
1.0696794987,
0.4924633801,
-0.2835812867,
-0.4215572178,
0.4312780201,
0.3002239168,
-0.0156080527,
0.1680137813,
0.6763246059,
0.7785246968,
0.4007793963,
-0.5177018642,
0.3535131812,
0.1857997775,
-0.0113763222,
0.487657249,
-0.4920837581,
0.7566702962,
-0.5013998151,
-0.053800147,
0.0472580492,
0.6425020695,
0.3640530705,
0.5452648997,
0.4776821733,
0.4046978056,
0.8624958396,
0.3013814688,
0.7607969046,
-0.5250779986,
0.1691980213,
0.9947738051,
-0.1975654662,
0.748270452,
0.6659359336,
-0.2688741684,
0.0606395528,
0.8399390578,
0.058375936,
0.4087035656,
0.2455052286,
-0.2466926873,
-0.1593934149,
0.0410310477,
-0.0448052995,
0.3213424683,
0.3390855193,
-0.2574429214,
-0.0831645578,
-0.272394985,
0.2593863606,
-0.3400485814,
-0.0792816356,
0.6898419857,
0.2013216317,
-0.7780563831,
0.4609082937,
-0.0611494035,
0.1549041271,
-0.3636293113,
0.1105573252,
-0.2571046352,
-0.0737885758,
-0.1400825083,
-0.5040060282,
0.1544032395,
-0.3099431098,
0.093682088,
-0.1186672971,
0.4739430845,
-0.1531186849,
-0.8082066774,
0.4134784639,
0.6186861992,
0.2739010751,
-0.389583528,
-0.5392676592,
-0.091656372,
-0.0618650466,
-0.2505199611,
0.2191575319,
0.562654376,
-0.2387632579,
0.7097806334,
0.2026098371,
0.3703628778,
0.05649684,
-0.0761590973,
0.2429614812,
-0.633548975,
-0.3243594468,
-0.8620000482,
0.3267126679,
0.4187164903,
-0.1480004489,
0.3283167779,
0.3266094327,
0.5863165259,
0.1210917458,
0.8917562366,
0.1054925397,
-0.2663909197,
-0.4813451469,
0.6216467023,
-0.4175184071,
0.223079294,
-0.330021143,
-1.0351974964,
-0.3138251007,
0.8867533207,
-0.2201650292,
0.1909449697,
0.8097137213,
1.1225670576,
0.2345717251,
-0.0900781825,
0.5923031569,
0.0558045767,
0.3177665472,
0.5190842748,
0.7534472942,
-0.0739210248,
0.4497520924,
-0.5157916546,
-0.2300170958,
-0.1220094115,
-0.6356915236,
-0.7493964434,
-0.7921885848,
-0.3875634074,
-0.2300361991,
-0.208059147,
0.9458902478,
0.7171245217,
-0.8581017852,
-0.5832303762,
-0.1145399734,
0.5899681449,
-0.3970528543,
-0.1525102556,
0.4804962277,
-0.528010726,
-0.7935785055,
0.3396770656,
0.1888727695,
0.0889008418,
-0.6320284605,
-0.5015091896,
-0.2117740512,
0.5308594704,
0.5446055532,
0.1011589468,
-0.9153450131,
-0.4773475528,
-0.002861025,
-0.0186174139,
0.1167987213,
0.5035461783,
-0.3536091745,
0.2798388898,
0.3379821181,
0.4349570274,
0.515309453,
-0.2865614295,
0.5558356047,
-0.3920139372,
0.161499247,
0.3925327361,
0.2581259906,
-0.0137208849,
-0.5083265901,
0.5520269871,
-0.141220063,
-0.6558452249,
-0.7912930846,
0.2348428071,
-0.9196887612,
-0.4880388975,
1.4064595699,
0.2225879729,
-0.2699271441,
-0.1909636855,
-0.18371135,
0.3011034727,
-0.6588671207,
0.8983686566,
0.6527550817,
-0.5393353105,
-0.3231608272,
-0.620637536,
0.6450381279,
0.1542585492,
-0.8342314959,
0.0638936311,
0.681157887,
-0.2046649307,
0.2113931179,
0.5937258005,
0.2462358624,
-0.0453830101,
0.3237569332,
0.1806873232,
0.1378694773,
-0.7751085758,
-0.0726885125,
0.3730895519,
0.5090308189,
-0.4350803196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00235v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00235v1
|
Exploring the limits of decoder-only models trained on public speech recognition corpora
| 2024-01-31T23:29:42 | 2024-01-31T23:29:42 |
Ankit Gupta, George Saon, Brian Kingsbury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The emergence of industrial-scale speech recognition (ASR) models such as
Whisper and USM, trained on 1M hours of weakly labelled and 12M hours of audio
only proprietary data respectively, has led to a stronger need for large scale
public ASR corpora and competitive open source pipelines. Unlike the said
models, large language models are typically based on Transformer decoders, and
it remains unclear if decoder-only models trained on public data alone can
deliver competitive performance. In this work, we investigate factors such as
choice of training datasets and modeling components necessary for obtaining the
best performance using public English ASR corpora alone. Our Decoder-Only
Transformer for ASR (DOTA) model comprehensively outperforms the
encoder-decoder open source replication of Whisper (OWSM) on nearly all English
ASR benchmarks and outperforms Whisper large-v3 on 7 out of 15 test sets. We
release our codebase and model checkpoints under permissive license.
|
[
-0.2269196063,
-0.0647469237,
0.3499221206,
0.3254992962,
-0.107669048,
-0.0816126689,
-0.4128776193,
-0.6920855641,
-0.3069489002,
0.6144080162,
-0.2779579461,
-0.5378819704,
-0.7381316423,
0.5280576944,
-0.6289710999,
0.6900277138,
0.2287922055,
0.1750880331,
-0.146159336,
-0.1714195758,
-0.1239470243,
-0.7993947864,
-0.3672237396,
-0.191083163,
0.1959499568,
0.3884218037,
0.4821211398,
0.6663227081,
0.3456951082,
0.2569953501,
-0.4357523322,
-0.1160630509,
-0.5783163905,
-0.1475592852,
-0.0897839591,
-0.3574251235,
-0.2189411372,
-0.0584921055,
0.7724567652,
0.632289052,
-0.2002542764,
0.4271711707,
0.0093202824,
0.2955267131,
-0.7277126312,
0.3874396682,
-0.9314258695,
-0.1365219653,
-0.3009293079,
0.2105527967,
-0.6308249831,
-0.3298265934,
0.3106351495,
-0.5408679247,
0.3484447598,
-0.1268238723,
0.9451653361,
0.2509660721,
-0.2287944108,
-0.3839425445,
-1.0753064156,
0.6827047467,
-0.4638830125,
0.7537374496,
0.1527759731,
0.5195420384,
0.3724576831,
-0.7213676572,
-0.337154597,
0.0461271964,
0.1395267397,
0.0218749736,
-0.7953919172,
-0.0197619889,
0.1487161964,
0.2872633934,
-0.4158701301,
0.3113585114,
-0.9052339196,
0.0281299483,
0.4772256911,
0.0537599027,
-0.0325534754,
-0.0363211818,
-0.4599387944,
-0.2471602112,
-0.8095258474,
0.2303025573,
0.1549703032,
0.6062191129,
-0.0201464724,
0.5258716345,
-0.0573819205,
0.2199331373,
-0.0619431138,
0.0635629296,
0.2972504795,
0.1765832603,
-0.2459768504,
0.3234489858,
0.9396092296,
-0.0951071158,
0.0867626145,
-0.4079030454,
-0.3518011868,
0.4439788461,
0.1270866841,
-0.8135849833,
0.0221977625,
0.1533747911,
-0.3511793911,
-0.1971371919,
-0.0602528043,
-0.6448549628,
-0.2007659972,
-0.406393528,
0.5242605805,
-0.1647684425,
-0.5752409697,
0.4568724036,
-0.2365363091,
0.2383631021,
-0.1109030023,
-0.6951969862,
0.6049448252,
0.8566981554,
0.7465128303,
-0.139793992,
-0.3814645708,
-0.5264451504,
0.010408652,
-0.4551844597,
0.7575420737,
-0.5743590593,
-0.6535158157,
0.1524433792,
-0.0247992314,
-0.3323815763,
-0.8100069165,
0.8820901513,
-0.7305836678,
-0.1458469778,
-0.1068707332,
-0.5362369418,
0.0216383953,
-0.2461023331,
-0.7044146657,
0.4882020652,
-0.2583860755,
-0.6714791656,
0.245241642,
-0.8555284142,
-0.3016589582,
-0.0268431343,
-0.2204782665,
-0.4666416943,
0.3081320226,
0.1974597126,
0.3925591111,
-0.3818413317,
0.1242261156,
0.0830945149,
-0.5250225067,
0.2602068782,
-0.5894765258,
0.7704350352,
0.3105565608,
-0.3133959472,
0.2018076032,
-1.0375311375,
-0.2487605065,
0.0824993476,
-0.5239298344,
0.0092054009,
0.0959880203,
0.295766592,
0.0470397882,
-0.0407877751,
-0.9402008057,
-0.3576867878,
-0.4974054694,
0.5653674603,
0.6926836371,
-0.4577703476,
0.2720369399,
-0.1401777416,
0.5023445487,
-0.1058186144,
0.1200551987,
0.0702991635,
-0.4780519903,
-0.594209671,
-0.6707081199,
0.529581368,
0.3192602694,
-0.1823789626,
0.2627547085,
-0.7100887299,
-0.4986245334,
-1.2239847183,
-0.2852435708,
0.5089988708,
0.35616678,
0.4026815593,
0.1410198659,
-0.8037192225,
-0.9224894643,
-0.0387718305,
-0.0116371643,
-0.5531719923,
0.2511913478,
0.2648004591,
-0.3591064513,
1.0441108942,
-0.4750602543,
-0.3821947277,
-0.4279070795,
0.0126317963,
0.1773562729,
-0.0823946521,
0.1235056072,
-0.7627655864,
-0.4224316776,
-0.0132955862,
-0.4764885306,
-0.1171214655,
0.3666982651,
0.358127147,
0.2446334362,
0.3644191325,
-0.429561764,
0.3126264215,
1.0675075054,
-0.1849856079,
0.6358190179,
-0.2018000782,
-0.1307929456,
-0.7332608104,
0.3460653126,
-0.1608054787,
-0.2396437377,
-0.7024604082,
0.0740895122,
0.1566965282,
-0.8361490369,
-0.5431237817,
0.2450066656,
-0.5294867158,
-0.2219686806,
-0.2854795456,
-0.0163805839,
-0.1358448565,
0.3450380862,
0.5656734109,
0.8982852101,
0.8120490909,
-0.7230411172,
-0.0682242066,
0.5288217664,
-0.5275119543,
0.0545052178,
-0.9122234583,
0.2815323174,
-0.0211109519,
-0.0216351114,
-0.5152168274,
0.0051440606,
-0.3351102471,
-0.4398852289,
0.2699136138,
-0.1601795703,
-0.3176971078,
-0.405660212,
0.0809236243,
-0.0570561364,
0.8123627901,
-1.0157104731,
0.7501947284,
0.5636270642,
0.05913442,
-0.2990369797,
-0.6363831758,
-0.0768719167,
-0.0589002743,
-0.8070288301,
0.1863065064,
-0.0294998866,
-0.0940866917,
-0.2786746919,
-0.2230523378,
-0.190648824,
-0.1340663284,
0.4669843316,
0.1568980664,
-0.4924635291,
-0.2364800721,
-0.3488198817,
-0.3905262351,
0.1435707361,
0.0133292703,
0.2833078504,
-0.1989897788,
-0.3563866019,
-0.6013874412,
0.3982428908,
0.6541160345,
-0.4973510206,
0.7254949808,
0.167290315,
-0.0395659283,
-0.4434863925,
-0.507583499,
0.0012286258,
-0.4972873628,
0.2295912951,
-0.6115760803,
-0.8602219224,
0.3713397384,
0.0387263633,
-0.0121368719,
0.3161248863,
0.3322601318,
0.3492402434,
0.9468717575,
0.6996374726,
-0.3623201251,
0.0696502477,
-0.1996393949,
0.1049029455,
-0.6959396601,
-0.1942397803,
-0.7532957792,
0.1813764125,
-0.5399441123,
-0.5191043019,
0.5518759489,
-0.2280969173,
-0.0613234043,
0.4760716856,
-0.6720951796,
0.4843614697,
0.4890052974,
0.0191864409,
0.5277604461,
0.0729634985,
0.2029550076,
0.1743041128,
-0.5660763383,
-0.5473067164,
1.2439632416,
0.7193689942,
0.7041581869,
0.054022532,
0.4199104905,
-0.1587729007,
-0.0609126501,
-0.6091942191,
0.4166314304,
-0.4589567184,
-0.724121213,
-0.4100836217,
-0.431447506,
-1.0888367891,
0.2995743155,
-0.0370851196,
-0.2549735606,
0.4193769097,
-0.1080161482,
-0.1868543327,
0.3477339149,
-0.6580745578,
0.7253665924,
0.3294222653,
0.2273031622,
0.0321755819,
-0.4074192643,
-0.0014127003,
-0.0647893399,
0.1872295141,
0.0218262356,
0.0101900017,
0.5719514489,
-0.2350381464,
0.6351104975,
-0.1701621711,
0.0028908397,
0.2836646736,
-0.2161169797,
0.5109424591,
-0.300856024,
-0.1487496942,
0.7231411338,
-0.0214496441,
-0.219088763,
-0.1132757142,
0.3738775253,
-1.1844896078,
-0.4678519368,
-0.274132818,
0.0140834581,
-0.3568716645,
-0.0444551185,
0.6528317332,
0.6914357543,
-0.3716955781,
0.546397984,
0.943488121,
0.0575774983,
0.2858906388,
0.960469842,
-0.0149408998,
-0.3289576173,
0.9702087641,
0.0704174489,
0.2065256089,
0.546166122,
0.4154634774,
-0.4405486286,
-0.7265196443,
-0.2863357365,
0.096248664,
-0.4406855404,
-0.1795257032,
-0.8596327901,
-0.4707517028,
-0.4502525032,
0.0940325037,
-0.7714301944,
-0.0737016127,
-0.4154844582,
-0.1417958587,
0.2420728952,
0.9646857381,
-0.23656106,
-0.120295234,
-0.6860437393,
0.328086704,
0.4729481339,
0.4957891405,
-0.0314266086,
-0.5874195099,
-0.1111651883,
-0.0739243403,
-0.0452891774,
-0.6645073891,
0.2582902312,
0.1567483246,
0.4474957883,
0.3872211576,
0.1747796834,
0.4435527027,
-0.918422401,
0.6745031476,
0.1088323966,
-0.9622436166,
0.2419930398,
-0.4886841178,
0.3209241331,
0.3690809906,
0.4155495465,
-0.2883659005,
-0.4673477113,
-0.4418547153,
-0.6294595003,
0.7866384387,
0.4218281209,
0.0597858243,
0.1087567136,
-0.2206323296,
0.1573086828,
0.0723467544,
-0.4271152318,
-0.1834404916,
-0.415671736,
-0.1231589764,
-0.2297676951,
-0.2586779594,
-0.0646640211,
0.0338654779,
0.6190345883,
0.1873156577,
0.2117719203,
0.1358437687,
-0.0642145127,
-0.02297749,
0.5257291198,
0.3647910655,
0.5796896815,
-0.229636386,
-0.1048272997,
0.0664634481,
-0.6037592292,
0.0388328657,
0.3491573334,
-0.1489566714,
0.3403057456,
0.0596377254,
0.9224425554,
0.4417962432,
-0.8320808411,
0.7653709054,
-0.1115773246,
-0.2444411665,
-0.3737706542,
-0.146228835,
0.2825286984,
0.2928160131,
0.5263667703,
0.0240794308,
0.2386828214,
-0.3607026637,
0.0518320613,
0.1741343588,
-0.2917883098,
-0.5795282125,
0.8492002487,
0.2473305911,
-0.2644050717,
0.4511442482,
-0.0256083012,
-0.5167440772,
0.2562375069,
0.6305368543,
0.8315610886,
-0.3797291815,
-0.0317955092,
0.3023660779,
0.1214422137,
-0.4095914364,
0.044063352,
0.0565732419,
-0.428596288,
-0.2960819602,
-0.8182010651,
-0.5377469659,
0.3150368333,
-0.9661740661,
0.5613465905,
-0.2198091745,
0.0101349894,
0.0117155099,
-0.1999776065,
-0.7488299608,
0.1606924236,
0.4459857643,
1.1528170109,
-0.8102596402,
0.6677950621,
0.2573363185,
-0.3202376366,
-0.9842454195,
-0.17684412,
-0.1141227633,
-0.6887683868,
0.5928069353,
0.0692744702,
-0.3752957284,
-0.0282022562,
-0.3495625556,
-0.9619105458,
0.8856008649,
0.5047416091,
-0.8290362954,
-0.3389063478,
0.1867636889,
0.5655177832,
-0.1789016277,
0.039327804,
0.506878078,
-0.0155849773,
0.2342818826,
-1.3126465082,
-0.2774621844,
-0.0217598286,
0.1196491048,
0.02037015,
-0.6562392116,
0.6607785821,
0.0962936208,
-0.5556724668,
0.0201898627,
0.6486201286,
0.3375957608,
0.1788997203,
0.3475107253,
0.3827659786,
0.4907056391,
0.1101196334,
0.9548364282,
-0.1140845045,
0.0694684759,
1.1171830893,
-0.2845941484,
1.4504826069,
-0.0789689943,
-0.2859806418,
0.4053690434,
0.0829592422,
-0.1804009676,
0.6265606284,
0.0793630406,
-0.2488970608,
-0.1335776001,
-0.0373183303,
-0.3531945348,
0.8167242408,
-0.0013776741,
-0.2427626699,
-0.0326997712,
0.2101076394,
-0.0245085247,
0.3606786728,
-0.4783793986,
0.9812599421,
0.004464624,
-0.198797062,
0.6765581965,
-0.1082473472,
0.9459046125,
-0.784543097,
0.4379651845,
0.1310749948,
0.2123106271,
-0.0769943446,
-0.3266804516,
0.3310818076,
0.4934732616,
-0.4617693722,
-0.2337637395,
0.4860026836,
-0.2898173332,
-0.551145196,
0.5861083269,
0.0225636624,
0.3249821067,
-0.3911212385,
-0.183364138,
0.5166345835,
-0.2377465516,
-0.0394839086,
0.2878352106,
0.402923584,
0.5193533897,
0.5478077531,
0.5275074244,
0.3188156188,
0.2848494649,
0.155599013,
0.9151815772,
-0.3775121868,
-0.623404026,
-0.3994867206,
0.5361448526,
0.0741381273,
-0.1438831538,
0.7710097432,
0.9002862573,
0.7713373899,
-0.1983486265,
0.7565280199,
0.4488430023,
1.0994743109,
-0.3457711041,
0.8663924932,
-0.2068712413,
0.0615107007,
-0.0354602747,
-0.5386835933,
0.19224751,
0.3034934103,
-0.335208118,
-0.5164331794,
0.3861681819,
0.7755352259,
-0.1192678586,
0.3673937619,
0.71350348,
0.3019841313,
0.252948612,
0.6499453783,
0.8340983987,
-0.5238713026,
1.1483399868,
0.1065016389,
-0.123137854,
0.0130812386,
-0.5227556825,
-0.9754974246,
-0.7007323503,
-0.1950509548,
-0.2690147758,
0.0525723025,
0.8304729462,
0.8519080281,
-0.8910531402,
-0.4617385268,
0.0627857372,
-0.3585236371,
-0.0912854299,
-0.1359976232,
0.4283709228,
-0.103464976,
-0.7387212515,
0.8917752504,
-0.0405014157,
-0.1964239329,
-0.2575374544,
-0.0108466446,
0.3368181586,
0.2704623342,
0.4951346815,
0.3293911517,
-0.6122450233,
0.0152802439,
0.1385178715,
-0.0625277087,
0.3235163093,
0.8242944479,
-0.6357714534,
0.4710939229,
0.1920638084,
0.5391632318,
0.6012969017,
-0.0712510422,
0.7395346761,
-0.6173356175,
0.1291591227,
0.4389848113,
0.0979127213,
0.465955019,
-0.0391694233,
0.2752313316,
-0.085974656,
-0.6308283806,
-1.0017688274,
0.0552341379,
-0.5456523895,
-0.3192641139,
1.4051352739,
-0.1195256114,
-0.2620687783,
-0.0903626308,
0.0547538511,
0.247180596,
-0.5471994877,
0.5428158641,
0.3103727698,
0.1815133095,
0.0944256037,
-0.348849684,
0.6737255454,
-0.2843662202,
-0.4330172837,
0.2776330113,
0.2632961869,
0.5852994919,
0.3268683851,
0.6646665931,
-0.2239410579,
0.1987751424,
0.4016580582,
0.0011902659,
-0.3205876052,
-0.5168280602,
-0.8721168637,
0.4913448989,
0.1834579259,
-0.4765260816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00234v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00234v1
|
Are Generative AI systems Capable of Supporting Information Needs of Patients?
| 2024-01-31T23:24:37 | 2024-01-31T23:24:37 |
Shreya Rajagopal, Subhashis Hazarika, Sookyung Kim, Yan-ming Chiou, Jae Ho Sohn, Hari Subramonyam, Shiwali Mohan
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Patients managing a complex illness such as cancer face a complex information
challenge where they not only must learn about their illness but also how to
manage it. Close interaction with healthcare experts (radiologists,
oncologists) can improve patient learning and thereby, their disease outcome.
However, this approach is resource intensive and takes expert time away from
other critical tasks. Given the recent advancements in Generative AI models
aimed at improving the healthcare system, our work investigates whether and how
generative visual question answering systems can responsibly support patient
information needs in the context of radiology imaging data. We conducted a
formative need-finding study in which participants discussed chest computed
tomography (CT) scans and associated radiology reports of a fictitious close
relative with a cardiothoracic radiologist. Using thematic analysis of the
conversation between participants and medical experts, we identified commonly
occurring themes across interactions, including clarifying medical terminology,
locating the problems mentioned in the report in the scanned image,
understanding disease prognosis, discussing the next diagnostic steps, and
comparing treatment options. Based on these themes, we evaluated two
state-of-the-art generative visual language models against the radiologist's
responses. Our results reveal variability in the quality of responses generated
by the models across various themes. We highlight the importance of
patient-facing generative AI systems to accommodate a diverse range of
conversational themes, catering to the real-world informational needs of
patients.
|
[
-0.3419830501,
-0.7393411398,
0.8800337315,
-0.0631252974,
-0.3722663522,
-0.1232311428,
0.1189218611,
-0.4955277741,
0.1610447466,
0.6515449286,
-0.5056558847,
-0.3389466107,
-0.6877391934,
0.1411513984,
-0.2794725895,
0.7472605705,
-0.0447221808,
0.4107193351,
-0.7278542519,
-0.0266145673,
-0.6710532308,
-0.0859672502,
-0.9575312138,
-0.2340899408,
0.5368931293,
0.2742232382,
1.1110717058,
0.4911375046,
0.9459620714,
0.2876749933,
0.1792951077,
0.1415611356,
-0.25734514,
0.7769652605,
0.18436113,
-0.4133427441,
-0.1710680127,
-0.4621920288,
-0.08901418,
0.5729482174,
-0.2340058237,
-0.200317204,
-0.0734582096,
0.5626530051,
-0.3158863485,
0.2782138586,
-0.0774472505,
0.5567660928,
0.1288351417,
-0.5880842209,
-0.2256855965,
-0.2815721333,
0.444598794,
-0.9523531199,
0.2647308707,
-0.2574296892,
0.9584913254,
0.52003479,
-0.1850488335,
-0.4631257951,
-0.8759391308,
0.0749829262,
-0.3301126957,
0.0283712316,
0.5876854062,
0.600361824,
-0.0717054456,
-0.6706603169,
-0.2844126821,
0.0945346504,
-0.2983104587,
0.6219406128,
-0.4074522555,
0.3306325078,
0.1983078867,
0.4010881782,
-0.7306280732,
-0.0481076874,
-0.41774562,
-0.0950107574,
0.4379245341,
0.5240604281,
0.7871656418,
-0.27741009,
-0.2406387627,
0.0421079472,
-0.3706355989,
-0.3147818744,
-0.3448207974,
-0.1717974395,
-0.2772271931,
0.5776526332,
-0.0913942009,
0.7569000125,
-0.0601344928,
0.0422702841,
-0.0130801043,
-0.2775037587,
-0.3443091512,
-0.2046242058,
0.676045835,
0.3102601767,
0.0536793657,
-0.0458384119,
0.0413668565,
-0.00802135,
0.460223943,
-0.5050388575,
-0.4225879908,
0.5285661221,
-0.6427605152,
-0.0402946025,
0.0327565745,
-0.6645134091,
-0.6950061321,
-0.3022667766,
0.2072959244,
-0.7275166512,
-0.4309267402,
0.0499807224,
-0.376045078,
0.1861893684,
0.7670958638,
-0.5291318297,
-0.215829432,
0.2685730159,
0.569111526,
0.4136028886,
0.2181109637,
-0.4805128872,
0.2922264338,
-0.2108830512,
0.9583583474,
-0.5817825794,
-0.6156371236,
-0.0275004469,
-0.2761372328,
-0.2493962348,
-0.6071640253,
0.119825013,
-0.6460924745,
0.302479893,
-0.4079874158,
-0.2414818108,
0.1340019703,
0.3800662756,
-0.658379674,
0.3214220405,
0.2836053669,
-0.7361903787,
0.236104995,
-0.5255609751,
-0.2582609057,
0.7536699176,
-0.8491716981,
-0.3715255558,
0.2319624722,
0.3158317208,
0.5882801414,
-0.5364258885,
0.2591170967,
-0.094883211,
-0.1457404643,
0.4021080434,
-0.2286957651,
0.3953236639,
0.5784572959,
0.0747905448,
0.1282401979,
-0.441930145,
0.0466610044,
0.2131430358,
-0.2824482024,
-0.222328037,
0.0347474553,
-0.0390375108,
0.0403791144,
-0.0839787498,
-0.3038009405,
0.1720739156,
-0.049081061,
0.2079652548,
0.5972477198,
0.2928043902,
-0.1609922647,
-0.5185192823,
1.0021693707,
0.2691730261,
0.2650016248,
-0.3970895112,
-0.7560362816,
-0.7093352079,
-0.3602835834,
-0.0464951955,
0.4693242908,
-1.2371298075,
-0.1548520476,
-0.3551768959,
-0.1304763854,
-0.6425529122,
-0.3099353313,
0.5468783975,
0.7266945839,
0.2796773612,
-0.4321300089,
-0.4179970026,
-0.7740345597,
0.3543950319,
-0.4604789317,
-0.2494086027,
0.7182867527,
-0.0484887809,
-0.1229146644,
0.6156605482,
-0.5678465366,
-0.3174369037,
-0.3194859624,
0.3184213638,
-0.1723664552,
0.0657887608,
0.4101086259,
-1.0810786486,
-0.2675042152,
0.3617375493,
-1.4136348963,
0.0887900293,
-0.2908900976,
0.0843293592,
-0.2256752849,
0.3936861753,
-0.3943373263,
0.6669459939,
0.2598083913,
-0.2950653136,
0.0562676899,
-0.5289040804,
0.3060966432,
-1.1610966921,
0.0956056118,
-0.0337649398,
-0.2307935655,
-0.6774821281,
-0.0246151239,
-0.3224366605,
-0.4759534001,
-0.0426104479,
0.0759493336,
-0.3902851343,
-0.063444145,
-0.0493298545,
-0.154408887,
0.0256361868,
0.0375763737,
0.3034982681,
0.5876128078,
0.7922748327,
-0.4823226333,
0.3585037589,
0.4980355799,
-0.302211374,
0.8859298229,
-0.7090811729,
0.1274293065,
-0.6606807113,
-0.0622780174,
-0.8724125624,
-0.5707349777,
0.4210010767,
-0.5791321993,
0.2587524652,
-0.1859977841,
-0.3289911449,
-0.4200784266,
0.4110644162,
0.4192661047,
0.3575917184,
0.0201208163,
0.7882433534,
0.2500357032,
-0.4132914245,
-0.2745433748,
-0.8039106727,
0.4228844941,
-0.0580670126,
-0.658700943,
0.0110728489,
0.0316921845,
-0.2566692829,
0.2299739718,
0.4593390822,
-0.2797729075,
0.1270261556,
0.4168686867,
0.2349653393,
-0.3404499888,
0.486366868,
-0.3250356615,
-0.1756687462,
0.0297414642,
-0.1972547472,
0.5370082855,
-0.0509981029,
-0.6290999651,
-0.6290255189,
0.7313123345,
0.6697752476,
-0.3010171056,
0.4887954891,
0.5021086335,
-0.3842830062,
0.393363595,
-0.5511157513,
-0.0938428193,
-0.356062144,
0.2323576957,
-0.3937427402,
-0.724103272,
0.5352740884,
0.3525367975,
-0.3799830973,
0.4167627096,
0.5851938725,
-0.5316283703,
0.9725850821,
0.4290155172,
0.1611328423,
0.0873104557,
-0.2432005703,
0.1207258552,
-0.5679758787,
-0.6681956053,
-0.2248957753,
-0.0665874481,
-0.5231803656,
-0.2479248494,
1.0508202314,
-0.3117115498,
0.175393641,
-0.1507705599,
-0.6814854145,
-0.0702129677,
0.3767044246,
0.7001725435,
0.1429514587,
0.1734057516,
0.1727654189,
0.0426663235,
-0.9437559247,
-0.2181263417,
0.8209227324,
0.1368811429,
1.0046730042,
0.148431778,
0.3476860225,
0.3375599086,
0.1773533821,
-0.6256183982,
0.2873113155,
-0.1367550939,
-0.3172240257,
-0.2468351424,
-0.2891014516,
-1.1259642839,
-0.1417165548,
-0.2510842085,
-0.2467028946,
0.3902870715,
0.2934266627,
-0.6077445149,
0.0891855955,
-0.4441619515,
0.7938383222,
-0.3102074862,
-0.1169373244,
-0.1959787905,
-0.944852531,
-0.0949035361,
0.2708208263,
0.0217915755,
0.1741073132,
0.2339314818,
0.4883077145,
-0.5204575062,
0.8661315441,
-0.0691037476,
0.2126058042,
0.4042809606,
0.0243585799,
-0.0809090063,
0.1082309112,
0.1226007268,
-0.1601397097,
0.1889562309,
-0.5466094017,
-0.744758606,
0.4075725079,
-0.9620444775,
-0.881963253,
-0.4470009804,
-0.4272518456,
-0.2254244834,
0.0748464391,
0.4166407287,
0.4688635468,
-0.0361956246,
0.1777908504,
0.8240246177,
-0.2735486329,
0.0059511722,
0.1661865115,
0.2856528163,
0.0186920017,
0.7046682239,
-0.1069028378,
0.16119802,
0.6069115996,
0.2700526118,
0.32691136,
-0.6111325622,
-0.6470378637,
0.0992587805,
-0.7959229946,
-0.3215305209,
-0.7875759602,
-0.4329380691,
-0.1843411624,
-0.1512601078,
0.1102290303,
0.0468576774,
-0.7520197034,
0.0090263058,
0.435207516,
0.7660084367,
0.2843323052,
-0.0246013086,
-0.8956938982,
0.2577571273,
0.5089491606,
0.126659289,
-0.0711951405,
-0.2105371803,
-0.0905358717,
-0.0136267645,
-0.2022471875,
-0.9647444487,
0.2233734429,
0.1459007859,
0.5345808864,
0.4235859513,
-0.0627031922,
0.6149812937,
0.0974021107,
0.6544589996,
0.3194694519,
-0.3746290207,
0.8753871322,
-0.4400229454,
0.4932083488,
0.502112031,
0.4625771344,
-0.7774480581,
-0.3398583531,
-0.4911946356,
-0.4505139589,
0.527956605,
0.2307940871,
0.2051519006,
-0.147172749,
0.5303285122,
-0.1228598803,
0.0702671483,
-0.3419582248,
0.0185105335,
-0.5192055702,
-0.3669271469,
0.2795450687,
-0.3096603155,
-0.4071753919,
0.2924096286,
0.0688693523,
-0.3238585889,
0.6588526964,
0.5490992665,
0.1926654279,
-0.1924470514,
0.297583282,
0.3050732315,
0.6105448008,
0.1171192825,
0.1133046076,
-0.2646202743,
-0.3413345814,
-0.1440908909,
-0.0563903861,
-0.215514943,
-0.165127188,
0.4685107768,
0.9051809907,
-0.2561844587,
-0.7100608945,
0.6725897789,
-0.2582911849,
-0.0258609131,
-0.2952009439,
0.2290240973,
-0.0164218135,
0.1878205836,
0.2230600417,
0.2456560433,
0.2224348933,
-0.5013454556,
0.1589785218,
0.4791185558,
-0.8758045435,
-0.2466590255,
0.6186252236,
0.1134642586,
-0.2266774327,
1.0856007338,
0.3160835803,
-0.2043744922,
0.9792141318,
0.3072234094,
0.5398720503,
-0.2716777325,
0.6046126485,
0.1366609782,
0.0648345649,
0.2352706343,
0.5948986411,
-0.0762921274,
-0.6238102913,
0.063004531,
0.0341466516,
-0.2744122744,
0.1010564044,
-0.9553367496,
0.0712119788,
-0.4633679092,
-0.2420856357,
0.106269218,
-0.6061166525,
-0.8733439445,
0.7221796513,
0.2396591455,
0.4531077743,
-0.7237737179,
0.4860403836,
0.8215582967,
-0.8509858251,
-0.779589653,
-0.0179805066,
-0.108386524,
-1.047350049,
0.6357802153,
-0.127816245,
0.148936376,
-0.2878296375,
-0.3026066422,
-0.7925437689,
1.1103870869,
0.174095124,
0.0203105472,
-0.1119564101,
0.1887889206,
1.1118713617,
-0.536049366,
0.532964468,
-0.1042942479,
0.2561278045,
0.6097824574,
-0.5945557356,
0.0792088062,
-0.542055428,
0.1355718672,
-0.0905381516,
-0.5914161801,
0.544637084,
-0.471796602,
-0.4145708382,
0.1586705446,
0.5459229946,
-0.181000948,
0.4225614071,
0.3607895076,
0.46358639,
0.6965271831,
-0.1950712949,
1.5578918457,
-0.1399654001,
-0.2323329002,
0.532875061,
0.1693244278,
0.4696620703,
0.3793582618,
-0.0816104561,
0.4990056157,
0.6266544461,
-0.0520076305,
0.2739052474,
-0.0313187875,
-0.3317898214,
-0.5548502803,
-0.5614851117,
-0.6316330433,
0.3550139368,
0.6507874727,
-0.5327314138,
0.0094799921,
0.2906112671,
-0.2928317785,
-0.0764034912,
-0.0785230026,
1.0765304565,
-0.0173354466,
-0.8094983101,
0.4548974931,
-0.3018369675,
-0.0915024728,
-0.5606473088,
-0.0510154478,
-0.3187404871,
-0.2183650583,
-0.3967437744,
-0.8740836978,
0.3298951089,
-0.1112909466,
-0.3058365285,
-0.0558192693,
0.4338424504,
-0.3369850516,
-0.6510051489,
-0.0309335217,
0.5054744482,
0.211216867,
0.183318302,
-0.5340234041,
0.0599498376,
0.0228731949,
0.1553021669,
0.2624031603,
0.0334082469,
-0.231357947,
0.9105956554,
0.2040288895,
0.0639218688,
-0.3334009349,
0.1700413674,
0.9131560922,
-0.2237190157,
-0.3287432194,
-0.2620566785,
0.3233197331,
0.0423579663,
-0.3937668502,
0.2371133566,
0.1970228404,
0.5147440434,
-0.1039885134,
1.0463224649,
-0.0097221304,
0.1599647701,
-0.657538116,
0.6254663467,
-0.8048509955,
0.4074999392,
0.0318880528,
-0.1541542858,
-0.471203953,
0.461469233,
-0.3755470514,
0.1916924268,
0.4661542177,
0.5528963208,
0.1386314481,
0.2696971297,
0.3939765394,
0.1943897754,
0.4879935682,
0.8229058981,
0.853047967,
-0.2093321085,
0.5707994103,
-0.0708909184,
-0.2461874783,
-0.2723418772,
-0.2538409829,
-0.5810875893,
-0.7447535396,
-0.611576736,
-0.2204603702,
0.3576803803,
0.588318944,
0.6490037441,
-0.481485039,
0.0972395092,
-0.0054591121,
-0.1599699557,
0.0137073994,
-0.1924537122,
0.5626522899,
-0.0993959233,
-0.2828435898,
0.0041174283,
0.6338660717,
0.3023231328,
-0.1221089512,
0.1495260298,
0.2873761058,
-0.2590317428,
0.196149826,
0.436929673,
-0.7029473782,
-0.0534994453,
0.0602835752,
-0.4815955758,
0.453900516,
0.9192228317,
-0.7442582846,
1.1089401245,
0.3709360957,
0.8047909141,
0.4906463623,
0.11324092,
0.4913787842,
-0.2154193223,
-0.1595502347,
0.4700025022,
0.1650463641,
0.5021444559,
-0.8710202575,
0.0695805848,
0.2797593474,
-0.246687606,
-0.1619817019,
0.2535998821,
-0.8732576966,
-0.2067938894,
0.766299963,
-0.4748631716,
0.0167279113,
-0.343834281,
-0.1780161113,
-0.0624037087,
-0.1091993377,
0.8180410266,
0.4089676142,
-0.6200059056,
-0.6503244638,
-0.2085104585,
0.3633703887,
0.5377905965,
-1.0481024981,
-0.4349123538,
0.5415877104,
0.0559454411,
-0.0040446124,
0.9800859094,
-0.1519379467,
0.7000566125,
-0.227068767,
-0.1835733652,
-0.2272533774,
-0.2166786939,
-0.0806111172,
0.4327973127,
0.175032109,
-0.1884279102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15514v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15514v2
|
Large Scale Generative AI Text Applied to Sports and Music
| 2024-01-31T22:47:01 | 2024-02-28T00:03:57 |
Aaron Baughman, Stephen Hammer, Rahul Agarwal, Gozde Akay, Eduardo Morales, Tony Johnson, Leonid Karlinsky, Rogerio Feris
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We address the problem of scaling up the production of media content,
including commentary and personalized news stories, for large-scale sports and
music events worldwide. Our approach relies on generative AI models to
transform a large volume of multimodal data (e.g., videos, articles, real-time
scoring feeds, statistics, and fact sheets) into coherent and fluent text.
Based on this approach, we introduce, for the first time, an AI commentary
system, which was deployed to produce automated narrations for highlight
packages at the 2023 US Open, Wimbledon, and Masters tournaments. In the same
vein, our solution was extended to create personalized content for ESPN Fantasy
Football and stories about music artists for the Grammy awards. These
applications were built using a common software architecture achieved a 15x
speed improvement with an average Rouge-L of 82.00 and perplexity of 6.6. Our
work was successfully deployed at the aforementioned events, supporting 90
million fans around the world with 8 billion page views, continuously pushing
the bounds on what is possible at the intersection of sports, entertainment,
and AI.
|
[
-0.5318280458,
-0.6347830296,
0.3067372143,
0.6998708248,
-0.3301471174,
0.1491199285,
-0.517593503,
-0.6410603523,
0.5085578561,
0.0462366007,
-0.8046544194,
-0.501984179,
-0.4639132321,
0.217473805,
-0.4947281182,
1.3239350319,
0.0757529885,
0.0439736359,
-0.223129347,
-0.3739410937,
-0.368427366,
-0.1972929239,
-0.6691124439,
-0.0289723892,
0.336432606,
0.2514140904,
0.6492362618,
0.5797370672,
0.7533508539,
0.2882179916,
-0.0249353964,
0.441173315,
-0.4547552168,
0.383053869,
-0.1718078107,
-0.1134691611,
-0.6144968271,
0.0120533248,
0.6920537949,
0.457070291,
0.1096002236,
0.3260537982,
-0.1619360447,
0.6128991842,
-0.307734549,
0.3646522164,
-0.2837573588,
0.3543380499,
-0.1780691743,
-0.6920257211,
-0.2881347537,
-0.1300321072,
-0.0426181853,
-1.070941329,
0.1505824924,
0.0900320932,
0.7160891891,
0.428480953,
-0.2024552226,
-0.226124987,
-1.3344548941,
0.6757432818,
-0.2479701787,
0.2207590491,
0.1246418506,
0.4328607023,
0.0487719662,
-0.4096877873,
-0.6183902025,
-0.2852161229,
0.324728936,
0.4611178935,
-0.2646625638,
0.0491637327,
0.236075893,
0.3825867176,
-0.6935122609,
0.0242840871,
-0.3128311038,
0.1938644946,
1.3380134106,
0.2889335454,
0.4911171198,
0.305285573,
0.078593336,
-0.0039697168,
-0.4703203738,
-0.1392077953,
0.3621560931,
0.0004363463,
-0.1410396248,
0.5709276199,
-0.5998771191,
0.4184219837,
0.0673020706,
-0.3934827745,
0.2387277186,
-0.5093182325,
0.0325018391,
0.2036624998,
0.9397408962,
0.6079528332,
0.2080315948,
-0.4830594659,
0.0584372096,
-0.1311852634,
0.2834203541,
-0.641048193,
-0.2478599697,
0.3761052787,
-0.5415863395,
-0.1412305981,
0.2073064446,
-0.8700546026,
-0.5287539363,
-0.6698942184,
0.3413998187,
-0.1945833564,
-0.0085810991,
0.0654527768,
-0.3794478476,
0.1823541522,
0.6124076247,
-0.6933714747,
-0.2450410277,
0.5404275656,
0.6973914504,
-0.0990098864,
-0.2832214832,
-0.8391897082,
0.5327200294,
-0.2653742135,
0.8376726508,
-0.3745856881,
-0.3420163691,
0.2098878622,
-0.3612360358,
0.4197549522,
-0.5327813625,
0.5997489691,
-0.5842915177,
-0.2225464731,
-0.0171214603,
-0.4551243186,
0.1298505068,
0.2645536661,
-0.736728847,
0.4970625937,
-0.0723655671,
-0.7113655806,
0.5429392457,
-0.9753537774,
-0.8682954311,
0.2006415576,
-0.1545837373,
-0.5472723246,
0.141932562,
0.4741057754,
0.1908793747,
-0.2227718532,
0.2123011649,
-0.2308488786,
-0.5800285339,
0.0996825472,
-0.5124348998,
0.3941505551,
0.2017299384,
-0.5861569047,
0.4040773213,
-1.0130399466,
-0.2937674224,
-0.0683661774,
-0.5820393562,
0.2220290303,
0.176339522,
0.3801269233,
0.1295509487,
-0.0014781147,
-0.4252659976,
0.4808133245,
-0.157394886,
0.5378745198,
0.6874376535,
-0.1611542553,
0.5829572678,
-0.1105283871,
0.7634677887,
-0.0063827401,
0.3473592401,
-0.4202088118,
-0.4115254581,
-0.4038030505,
-0.1764360964,
0.1323023438,
0.4398936331,
-0.6634050012,
0.4532161355,
-0.7203738689,
-0.2796465456,
-0.4713253975,
0.3961679339,
0.031227367,
0.1995851994,
0.2444434464,
-0.0539215766,
-0.5795192719,
-0.7939265966,
-0.0693117753,
-0.0235431325,
-0.1096578687,
0.4158321917,
0.2730322182,
0.0368924886,
0.6833097935,
-0.4544925988,
-0.6264741421,
-0.1444918066,
0.472122252,
-0.0193768144,
0.548681736,
0.5691362023,
-1.0687348843,
-0.8060424328,
0.143789947,
-0.993753612,
-0.0034837108,
-0.437987566,
-0.2082855999,
-0.0601647533,
0.644929111,
-0.6312289238,
0.3203363419,
0.6514490843,
-0.4545284212,
0.5957627296,
-0.1248306111,
0.491124779,
-0.8351690769,
-0.0243188106,
0.1772467047,
-0.072664462,
-0.4149994552,
-0.0994069204,
-0.5827991366,
-0.0688944533,
-0.1374953389,
0.3347345591,
-0.3195986748,
-0.2211686671,
-0.3900482953,
0.0555716269,
0.0935440883,
0.3194542825,
0.1136596352,
1.0368806124,
0.3874758184,
-0.5017328262,
0.6865905523,
0.351234138,
-0.5824850798,
0.8678315282,
-0.4988185763,
-0.1187884435,
-0.3625741005,
0.7040978074,
-0.781668365,
-0.40836218,
0.1121178493,
-0.6086850166,
0.2619299591,
0.180647254,
-0.6332695484,
-0.4900701344,
-0.1367428303,
0.5341143608,
0.4713905156,
-0.4744060636,
0.6519021988,
0.5080941916,
-0.3770227134,
-0.0683069006,
-0.4198227227,
0.5104320645,
-0.1988510191,
-0.6427201629,
0.4069786966,
-0.3585548997,
-0.2839179933,
-0.0246271007,
0.1321693957,
-0.0533371456,
0.1504014432,
0.3125099838,
0.0409800373,
-0.5377612114,
0.2308420688,
0.0296528023,
0.1619252414,
-0.1010145545,
-0.761365056,
0.4119512737,
0.0567471869,
-0.0921637639,
-1.1445028782,
0.7140117884,
0.704608202,
-0.2938967943,
0.7497481108,
0.835174799,
0.1605973095,
-0.1675596982,
-0.2803583443,
0.0345431045,
-0.4102033079,
0.507671833,
-0.2603802085,
-0.8379103541,
0.2675908804,
0.1018864736,
0.1713877171,
0.7850188017,
0.5210656524,
-0.5173409581,
1.7317552567,
0.4655541182,
-0.535494864,
0.5482750535,
-0.3242495656,
-0.0118863173,
-0.6833793521,
-0.3586731851,
-0.6634101272,
-0.763068676,
-0.4580444694,
-0.2310236692,
0.5059298277,
-0.0582000278,
-0.4465849698,
0.0424949117,
-0.5350580812,
0.5886638761,
0.9086866379,
0.0162211508,
0.467107594,
-0.2162902802,
0.6299758554,
-0.0229575038,
-0.6335508823,
0.0294304602,
1.0220888853,
0.2072671503,
0.7084784508,
0.3242050409,
0.4247161746,
0.761634469,
0.778226316,
-0.7718963027,
0.1782815307,
-0.2386266887,
-0.6711280346,
-0.675460577,
-0.2667555511,
-0.5315120816,
-0.2521690726,
-0.3669324219,
-0.4395365119,
-0.2053179145,
0.1859554946,
-0.4735563993,
0.3484764993,
-0.2949391007,
0.3800323009,
-0.2221961468,
-0.3123428226,
-0.0030284631,
-0.4337628484,
0.3698424399,
-0.0116028339,
0.3881475925,
-0.0091442615,
0.1113236025,
0.7318780422,
-0.381265372,
0.6184591651,
-0.0398222432,
-0.1902812421,
0.3814190626,
-0.1284694225,
0.4504165947,
0.2972196341,
0.1749235392,
-0.0154866911,
-0.4946574569,
-0.4183209836,
-0.5859767795,
0.5033360124,
-0.9897880554,
-0.7185721993,
0.0002574699,
-0.6727856398,
-0.3553824127,
0.0270345919,
0.2332030833,
0.4164094031,
-0.186764583,
0.5481114388,
0.6453366876,
-0.0938920453,
0.4966748059,
0.1424886584,
0.1074966565,
-0.7074817419,
0.8452894092,
-0.1767800301,
-0.224115327,
0.5537142754,
-0.0095590781,
-0.3008289337,
-0.997061193,
-0.844163835,
0.0777976289,
-0.406889379,
-0.345620811,
-0.5361905098,
-0.0116134435,
-0.5441407561,
-0.236078307,
-0.2389367372,
-0.3036899269,
-0.3690953553,
-0.2291594893,
0.2662761807,
0.8541353941,
0.0314709321,
0.6184053421,
-1.0829210281,
0.173037529,
0.1519850492,
0.4493533075,
-0.1163500547,
-0.6118351817,
-0.5847567916,
-0.2265151441,
-0.4266236424,
-0.5434426069,
0.4103258848,
0.4842501581,
0.4231470227,
0.8385103941,
-0.2198087424,
0.6580895185,
-0.7137008905,
1.0078542233,
0.3140923679,
-0.843401432,
0.7312771678,
-0.830973804,
0.3067079782,
0.6733218431,
0.3346505463,
-0.3678914607,
-0.3961672187,
-0.6298716068,
-0.6240535975,
0.7834921479,
0.1907316446,
0.3920998275,
0.007032468,
0.3505441248,
0.0859699845,
0.459938854,
-0.4901826382,
-0.3002235889,
-0.3335072398,
-0.3119142652,
-0.703302145,
-0.0527507216,
-0.3188745677,
-0.261778146,
0.5798832774,
-0.3203172684,
-0.0153216356,
0.1078413948,
0.1743503511,
-0.1114064977,
0.0149432626,
0.9571345448,
0.614896059,
-0.1087099314,
-0.29319188,
-0.2241595089,
-0.3844709098,
0.0644223019,
0.2280158848,
-0.5048228502,
0.0622198284,
0.6455926895,
0.8516067863,
0.1627679169,
-0.9776386023,
0.3583548367,
0.0806356817,
-0.5406206846,
-0.3344759047,
-0.1672276109,
0.1200324148,
0.2465757579,
0.444221735,
0.1050077379,
0.3679178059,
-0.779202044,
0.3244407475,
0.3971828818,
-0.6190276146,
-0.4628682137,
1.3922858238,
0.5725685954,
-0.2217043191,
0.5627715588,
-0.0849140957,
-0.557579875,
0.7119792104,
0.4032811821,
0.8213248849,
0.0891704783,
0.5212097764,
0.3290207684,
-0.1935689002,
-0.0192702804,
-0.0194769595,
-0.2443471551,
-0.4704554677,
-0.6005525589,
-0.8357117772,
-0.1627088338,
0.059651114,
-0.4714206159,
-0.1638843566,
-0.399671793,
-0.1166313142,
0.4642727077,
0.0194841865,
-0.548560679,
0.3665855229,
0.4550070465,
0.9121024013,
-0.9847688079,
0.4434742332,
0.9744588733,
-1.0110566616,
-0.8203465343,
0.1161431894,
0.0505039357,
-0.3474583924,
1.0549708605,
-0.2224205732,
0.2967789471,
-0.0080949962,
-0.6632006168,
-0.5461316109,
1.0189628601,
-0.0965278372,
-0.488984704,
-0.056250535,
0.2543371618,
0.627861321,
-0.5124715567,
0.1281848997,
0.4190678895,
0.570953548,
0.6127747893,
-0.9137596488,
-0.6777633429,
-0.1599986404,
-0.1043422073,
0.1329406798,
-1.1133164167,
0.7138833404,
0.0185930785,
0.2298550755,
0.1683409661,
1.0692044497,
0.1090072915,
0.3386774063,
0.2619702816,
0.4329094291,
0.6596214771,
-0.165350616,
1.2420232296,
-0.1404995322,
0.1517625451,
1.0369135141,
-0.2243668884,
0.5924034715,
0.1611616462,
-0.3788579106,
0.1864913106,
0.3543481529,
-0.3076396883,
0.4188922644,
0.3529717922,
-0.5655928254,
-0.3007135093,
-0.3629766405,
-0.2236693203,
0.8384894133,
0.0211707056,
-0.509355545,
-0.0479341,
0.377435714,
-0.0757185668,
0.2986934483,
-0.5905554295,
1.0518959761,
-0.3117022216,
-0.9058070183,
-0.132466644,
0.0205849074,
0.6773777604,
-0.3331555724,
-0.0996075869,
-0.4071892798,
0.2991389036,
-0.0534747988,
-0.7090740204,
0.1785996705,
0.0367883593,
-0.4841061831,
-0.2233840376,
0.2150992155,
-0.3709985912,
-0.5891184211,
0.0271034706,
0.157260403,
0.0717510805,
-0.337787509,
-0.3828475773,
0.4388027787,
-0.030322101,
-0.1459500045,
0.3083810806,
0.4329107702,
-0.0864225999,
0.5961753726,
0.6085202694,
0.3801340163,
0.2057065219,
0.3995035589,
0.7576131821,
-0.5104807019,
-0.740883112,
-0.6180074811,
0.3955547512,
-0.3023680449,
-0.3457686603,
0.7480869293,
0.9792177677,
0.7368847728,
-0.3232570589,
0.9966114163,
0.0794480592,
0.1679221392,
-0.3885997236,
0.8555098772,
-0.6275035739,
-0.046459917,
-0.122706078,
-0.9105531573,
-0.587569356,
0.0960181206,
0.0865030885,
0.0138934441,
0.152959004,
0.1620622128,
0.1603108346,
0.2398126274,
0.2601483166,
0.1472638249,
0.591098845,
0.3635993004,
0.7125265002,
-0.3944294155,
0.8765275478,
-0.0992870554,
-0.3893855512,
-0.5306662321,
-0.6302000284,
-0.8140087724,
-0.5993711352,
-0.5491904616,
-0.4838320017,
0.1508469135,
0.749586463,
0.8239437342,
-0.9217354059,
0.042957291,
-0.0096510109,
-0.2074199021,
-0.2264365405,
-0.2683550119,
0.5653063655,
-0.2968202829,
-1.2003256083,
0.2928789854,
0.5258846283,
-0.2668921649,
-0.357221961,
0.0243855175,
0.0538427942,
0.0127494363,
0.8302160501,
0.6426672339,
-0.5026560426,
-0.5253615379,
-0.1172159165,
0.0498422869,
0.2805534899,
0.8413150907,
-0.5178226233,
0.3045591712,
0.4949973524,
0.815295279,
0.4349723756,
0.4272266626,
0.6683241725,
-0.5096226931,
0.1018522233,
0.4393028915,
-0.09207353,
0.0263826512,
-0.4419427514,
0.3356231749,
0.4061469138,
-0.5901207924,
-0.5404419303,
-0.0722451806,
-1.1585488319,
-0.0890747458,
1.1651188135,
0.0844147131,
-0.0622819513,
-0.0704997554,
-0.2167980522,
0.0441619456,
-0.2380135804,
1.0247608423,
0.7984135151,
-0.4759013951,
-0.0444495529,
-0.6056706905,
0.8161050677,
0.0367482677,
-0.792231679,
-0.1764822155,
0.7981203794,
0.0767216533,
0.3301219642,
0.6351512671,
-0.0473498739,
0.5240802169,
0.3265627027,
-0.08024849,
-0.1577104628,
-0.6159843206,
-0.1079747751,
0.3843748271,
-0.1773315072,
-0.2364508212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00179v1
|
De-identification is not always enough
| 2024-01-31T21:14:01 | 2024-01-31T21:14:01 |
Atiquer Rahman Sarkar, Yao-Shun Chuang, Noman Mohammed, Xiaoqian Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For sharing privacy-sensitive data, de-identification is commonly regarded as
adequate for safeguarding privacy. Synthetic data is also being considered as a
privacy-preserving alternative. Recent successes with numerical and tabular
data generative models and the breakthroughs in large generative language
models raise the question of whether synthetically generated clinical notes
could be a viable alternative to real notes for research purposes. In this
work, we demonstrated that (i) de-identification of real clinical notes does
not protect records against a membership inference attack, (ii) proposed a
novel approach to generate synthetic clinical notes using the current
state-of-the-art large language models, (iii) evaluated the performance of the
synthetically generated notes in a clinical domain task, and (iv) proposed a
way to mount a membership inference attack where the target model is trained
with synthetic data. We observed that when synthetically generated notes
closely match the performance of real data, they also exhibit similar privacy
concerns to the real data. Whether other approaches to synthetically generated
clinical notes could offer better trade-offs and become a better alternative to
sensitive real notes warrants further investigation.
|
[
-0.0334000178,
-0.9878219366,
0.7029374838,
-0.0329728015,
-0.1485310942,
0.1685701907,
0.0305178165,
-0.7788100243,
0.4325019717,
0.4688574672,
-0.4955233932,
-0.7098149657,
-0.320789963,
0.1174845919,
-0.6426119804,
1.0101516247,
0.2980347574,
0.1418870389,
-0.2278746367,
-0.1037637964,
0.0261556376,
-0.9172302485,
-0.5682865977,
0.1454167217,
0.874252975,
-0.2009214759,
0.4971502721,
0.8515641689,
0.7084464431,
0.3109944761,
-0.0742200613,
0.2319114208,
-0.3796616197,
0.1507377028,
-0.1382617354,
-0.603259325,
-0.9475483298,
0.3332984149,
0.5672647357,
0.5088350177,
-0.0331533365,
0.0532341562,
-0.4580474496,
0.6242197156,
-0.4729892612,
-0.0382842533,
-0.6415931582,
0.1732964665,
-0.3051165342,
-0.1123434007,
-0.5137581825,
-0.4753690064,
0.2212206572,
-0.6649187803,
0.8411794305,
-0.1297149956,
0.8451110125,
-0.3860204518,
-0.1478016526,
-0.3987555206,
-1.0387632847,
0.3498362005,
-0.7906864882,
0.2275861055,
0.6634654403,
0.5789946318,
-0.2235228717,
-0.8305240273,
-0.6108358502,
-0.5110867023,
-0.1497959793,
0.2480729669,
0.294562012,
0.2160931975,
0.4772504568,
0.5479738712,
-0.4981731772,
0.1199431121,
-0.6384599209,
-0.2048510313,
0.9858205914,
0.3123998344,
0.3081365824,
-0.1302313656,
-0.4391165376,
-0.1640194803,
-0.8689893484,
-0.391839534,
0.3211502731,
0.4663162231,
-0.2409462333,
0.5873395205,
0.0187764037,
0.3975697458,
-0.1232481971,
-0.4205566347,
0.066733107,
-0.0838289559,
-0.2796270847,
0.3953193426,
0.9547928572,
0.3946921825,
0.0567599423,
-0.4111764431,
0.1635355204,
0.3568367958,
0.4741688073,
-0.759367466,
-0.6176332235,
0.4322502017,
-0.5018048882,
-0.56174016,
0.2877546549,
-0.810120523,
-0.4657242,
-0.3538981974,
0.2821127772,
-0.3702448308,
-0.1799124926,
-0.145801872,
-0.2937824428,
-0.218283698,
0.4356970489,
-0.8658720255,
0.359995991,
0.8032889962,
0.6909332275,
-0.1493045092,
-0.0234830417,
-0.1625148058,
0.5408917665,
-0.5083781481,
0.4109120667,
-0.4442019761,
-0.8686910272,
-0.1060761586,
0.1231592745,
-0.2743771374,
-0.6682774425,
0.3364672661,
-0.4464173317,
0.2668160796,
-0.4098763466,
-0.514518559,
0.0683900863,
0.2253833711,
-0.7398822308,
0.37934798,
0.3992074132,
-0.6746878028,
0.4325525463,
-0.2257350087,
-0.4428253174,
0.0544309877,
-0.3635200858,
-0.6833001375,
0.0968945101,
-0.2406033725,
0.1782199144,
-0.0848734528,
0.1072976738,
-0.4935640097,
-0.2037446797,
0.7799972892,
-0.3796019554,
0.6411523223,
0.3427265882,
-0.0188755095,
-0.3963017762,
-0.9848082662,
-0.0731106848,
0.0987151936,
-0.1909507662,
-0.4362535179,
-0.2447245121,
-0.0352088436,
0.0118713034,
-0.0559455305,
-0.7543267012,
0.1964460015,
-0.5572961569,
0.4153790176,
0.5961743593,
0.3663668334,
0.2685299814,
-0.6998372078,
0.7015790939,
0.1420604885,
0.1518381834,
0.0816847906,
-0.3532157242,
-0.2573638856,
-0.8819266558,
0.8713883162,
0.4605278969,
0.0706519186,
0.177420184,
-0.2152370065,
-0.6425758004,
-0.4385849237,
-0.2482067794,
0.7586883307,
0.4728716314,
0.4275462329,
-0.2864468396,
-0.6203411818,
-0.9859849215,
-0.4780349731,
-0.1335373521,
-0.142787993,
0.5069568157,
0.3415863514,
-0.1789414734,
0.6964123249,
-0.524960041,
-0.342161268,
-0.1431772709,
-0.1139188707,
-0.2655594647,
0.8419399858,
0.5893626809,
-0.6232895255,
-0.4848923087,
-0.1345492303,
-0.7366501093,
0.1745326519,
-0.4550325871,
-0.1411247253,
-0.0684562102,
0.2445415258,
-1.0857104063,
0.7465285063,
0.1041742936,
0.1826232225,
0.1858229488,
-0.5947470069,
0.1242741644,
-1.0679478645,
0.1670697778,
-0.1944640875,
-0.3104265034,
-0.804268837,
0.123939462,
0.0218322501,
-0.4117004275,
-0.2553027272,
0.4355427921,
-0.310557425,
0.3558486104,
-0.0390849747,
-0.0113885486,
0.18384552,
0.1555122435,
0.0903188735,
0.3269228637,
0.3525845408,
-0.5597037673,
-0.1360912919,
0.632702589,
0.0374674015,
0.536768198,
-0.5414616466,
0.4658333063,
-0.178647086,
0.3305852413,
-0.7636444569,
-0.5753489733,
0.397433877,
-0.7190164924,
0.596981883,
-0.2657143176,
-0.1972038448,
-0.2272294909,
-0.3825146556,
0.2335455567,
0.672529161,
-0.2452006489,
0.3991475403,
0.5298009515,
-0.088195771,
-0.35872069,
-0.9091048241,
0.1361595094,
-0.5101991892,
-0.1330920756,
0.7200485468,
0.2440036386,
-0.3971171081,
-0.0563671999,
-0.2895556986,
-0.2561864555,
0.0835651681,
0.5714161992,
0.3452481031,
0.0141113773,
0.0807429999,
0.1640631855,
-0.1734890044,
0.2377803475,
0.1601752937,
-0.0242876559,
0.6218920946,
-0.2799002528,
-0.8721717596,
0.7480024099,
0.6441671252,
-0.0816057995,
0.8257417083,
-0.0077041364,
-0.5136467814,
-0.5704067945,
-0.4057342708,
-0.2417216748,
-0.4598392546,
-0.0336210802,
-0.1652993411,
-0.4626027644,
0.5798334479,
-0.0447351448,
0.1166298464,
0.1856792718,
0.3730244637,
-0.4244687855,
0.9702771902,
0.0700739548,
0.1995727122,
0.0760941431,
-0.3167186677,
0.613684833,
-0.6997191906,
-0.3866935372,
-0.6954894066,
-0.2137469053,
-0.7279980183,
-0.1908643991,
0.4801976383,
-0.1774505675,
0.0406401195,
0.4417762458,
-0.5515331626,
0.2365850061,
0.365994215,
0.4451310039,
0.1880299151,
0.0170871187,
0.3481835425,
-0.1412345767,
-0.4014599621,
-0.6526407599,
1.3323284388,
0.13088952,
0.8277115822,
0.0455860049,
0.9356744885,
0.4508586228,
0.5156329274,
-0.1685781181,
0.6293348074,
-0.0149988765,
-0.8081300259,
-0.090328604,
-0.5011383295,
-0.9637572765,
0.2770553529,
-0.2741775811,
-0.7644300461,
0.3316063881,
0.5181267262,
-0.537027061,
0.041242484,
-0.7467522025,
0.7825998664,
-0.0074434206,
-0.4546141326,
-0.0902957395,
-0.6027463675,
0.4124785066,
-0.2590352297,
0.1642949283,
0.0371064581,
0.2527665496,
0.7050765753,
-0.8365629911,
1.0030657053,
-0.3184456825,
-0.0788352117,
0.4325217307,
0.4206189215,
0.5215713978,
0.3425617516,
0.0215438996,
-0.105118379,
0.3516686559,
-0.1050306112,
-0.7685663104,
0.8855340481,
-0.4347913265,
-0.8097772002,
-0.4645401835,
-0.366086036,
-0.294123441,
0.0058299527,
0.2064959854,
0.7869053483,
-0.3463063538,
0.030616194,
0.294894129,
-0.1949561685,
0.189086929,
0.54947716,
0.3518672884,
-0.6962596178,
1.0278973579,
0.3331087828,
0.3182201982,
0.2484886795,
0.2787192464,
-0.4600263238,
-0.5467833281,
-0.2403218597,
0.5196408629,
-0.3850779235,
0.1213340536,
-0.8879190087,
-0.1805470735,
-0.5312252641,
-0.1752469689,
-0.2769437134,
-0.8520923257,
-0.2032666951,
-0.4345114827,
0.4046599865,
0.2781715989,
-0.1755629182,
0.0772114545,
-1.0449197292,
0.6776341796,
0.1467866153,
-0.0156176714,
0.002390011,
-0.2610295117,
0.0713287368,
0.2790673375,
-0.1812139153,
-0.8566475511,
0.5313515067,
0.1505079269,
0.424365133,
0.2853277922,
0.4043304026,
0.7450923324,
-0.4108797908,
0.5824679136,
-0.0629772916,
-0.5636296868,
0.4730527699,
-0.5590566397,
-0.3383730352,
0.8634091616,
0.3752679229,
-0.0683879852,
-0.5945954919,
-1.1604914665,
-0.648473382,
0.5440400839,
0.297737956,
0.2997496128,
-0.2406897843,
0.4680246711,
0.121125333,
0.4263782501,
-0.6463853121,
-0.0551920347,
0.033504039,
-0.2404927015,
0.3011949062,
-0.1451666057,
-0.4734877944,
-0.1935685724,
0.2532044053,
0.24600178,
0.2464031279,
0.674456954,
0.1727283001,
0.1207160652,
-0.0749238953,
0.5656880736,
0.5974218249,
-0.3012500107,
0.2736041248,
-0.078233473,
-0.7238826156,
0.084670797,
-0.0194432531,
-0.5847808719,
0.0248544049,
0.3610044718,
0.4471841455,
-0.194323346,
-0.714083612,
0.4546123147,
0.0480865948,
-0.4842366278,
-0.6318797469,
0.3559037745,
0.1296999604,
-0.3096263707,
-0.2996763885,
-0.0615817085,
0.0448589362,
-0.7898694277,
0.2221097201,
0.579262197,
-0.4286926687,
-0.661070466,
1.0047028065,
-0.0258508958,
-0.6216750145,
0.6599462628,
0.1943842769,
-0.2014682144,
0.7841141224,
0.7466856241,
0.8954868913,
-0.4361165464,
0.2657807767,
0.443362087,
0.0000041791,
0.1703211367,
0.2788094282,
-0.3270637393,
-0.2352643907,
0.160366863,
-0.2960104942,
-0.3922331929,
0.2976380885,
-0.6412066221,
-0.0219304338,
-0.8502534628,
-0.422490567,
0.2123398483,
-0.4086066484,
-0.1226044521,
0.5205209255,
-0.1598755121,
0.5395201445,
-0.704077363,
0.8265041709,
0.1575535685,
-0.3352042437,
-0.6376899481,
-0.1182295457,
0.09192992,
-0.0912796408,
0.3004534841,
0.1770853102,
0.2835035026,
-0.4124142528,
0.0116575835,
-0.4131792486,
0.7974675894,
0.1529112607,
-0.5949229598,
-0.1864974201,
0.6229378581,
0.9876666069,
-0.1447144598,
-0.077358909,
0.3232156038,
0.2141185403,
0.0477274023,
-0.5312367082,
0.2482961267,
-0.1561929435,
-0.2160061151,
0.1557438672,
-0.6164821982,
0.9831261635,
-0.1700726002,
-0.474520117,
0.1169894338,
0.3630833924,
0.3683316112,
0.5804594755,
0.2653452158,
0.6039123535,
0.9044045806,
0.1108226031,
1.1871398687,
-0.1555965841,
0.071798794,
1.0910289288,
-0.8950203061,
0.3574023843,
0.1621433198,
-0.2260580659,
0.3114421666,
0.1895217597,
-0.1609092653,
0.5796276927,
0.4634915292,
-0.6187903285,
-0.0970060229,
0.1461942941,
-0.5050425529,
0.1785697937,
0.4266853333,
-0.8253806829,
0.1406648457,
-0.319938302,
0.1788986325,
0.1774983257,
0.3365801871,
0.9732496738,
0.3798901737,
-0.5706101656,
0.6503615379,
-0.0153922932,
-0.2505599558,
-0.707508266,
-0.2618916035,
-0.0777304694,
0.3472732902,
-0.2272266895,
0.09618029,
0.4459602833,
0.1472377777,
-0.0176153276,
-0.0709836781,
0.373041302,
-0.4150467515,
-0.5171223879,
-0.2325216532,
0.216453582,
-0.0713354796,
0.1586189419,
-0.3502232432,
-0.3037222624,
-0.2108324021,
-0.2261742204,
0.7120614052,
0.32606408,
-0.3476086855,
0.5031386018,
0.9009449482,
0.4797732532,
-0.2288953215,
0.1216112524,
0.6425219774,
-0.6248126626,
-0.6648499966,
-0.902042985,
0.1889246404,
-0.4009994268,
-0.424980551,
0.9821000695,
0.851673305,
0.5080350637,
-0.3376188576,
0.8662611246,
0.0808618814,
1.0482304096,
-0.5196375251,
0.7760320306,
-0.2387806475,
0.1423824728,
-0.474170953,
-0.6039938331,
-0.4373676777,
0.3788496852,
0.0500466041,
-0.2576294243,
0.7837462425,
1.155673027,
-0.0921005085,
0.2045539021,
-0.012183683,
0.0902637243,
0.6333175898,
0.4314918816,
0.8023520112,
-0.4832438529,
-0.0027419894,
-0.4782559872,
-0.0033617879,
0.1807977855,
-0.6674184203,
-1.1000937223,
-0.3424361348,
-0.4526121914,
-0.5101225376,
-0.0087849041,
0.6597399712,
0.6310075521,
-0.8476469517,
0.1679880768,
-0.2449695468,
-0.3601956964,
-0.3141882122,
-0.1061647758,
0.8133237362,
0.3163169622,
-0.6431932449,
0.6384942532,
0.1804376692,
0.57175982,
-0.047827024,
0.3175213635,
0.2247086912,
0.333029598,
0.1616276205,
0.4799059927,
-0.569034636,
-0.1683909893,
-0.2218757421,
-0.184366405,
0.0827689767,
1.1043816805,
-0.6774631143,
0.4516638517,
0.5435658097,
0.4902897179,
0.6162914634,
0.6092262268,
0.5840944648,
-0.4024026394,
0.3242297471,
0.4918991327,
0.0572368279,
0.1602235585,
-0.6578637958,
0.4665115476,
0.3317444623,
-0.2760170698,
-1.2794238329,
-0.0007631764,
-1.2009176016,
-0.0550268479,
0.7182658315,
-0.3912873864,
-0.4665988684,
-0.2125164866,
-0.3188340068,
-0.0302488096,
-0.0918221697,
1.1680321693,
0.0203145817,
0.047778856,
0.2601919472,
-0.437564522,
0.8444643021,
0.070153676,
-0.8557354808,
0.5551790595,
0.6247000694,
0.0059298747,
0.2212701887,
0.8334540725,
-0.6590468287,
0.2739365995,
0.1524137855,
-0.5026681423,
-0.1864841878,
-0.5148204565,
-0.0306692049,
0.3361299038,
-0.2135000974,
-0.2329202443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00160v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00160v2
|
Emergency Department Decision Support using Clinical Pseudo-notes
| 2024-01-31T20:31:56 | 2024-04-29T21:37:34 |
Simon A. Lee, Sujay Jain, Alex Chen, Kyoka Ono, Jennifer Fang, Akos Rudas, Jeffrey N. Chiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we introduce the Multiple Embedding Model for EHR (MEME), an
approach that serializes multimodal EHR tabular data into text using
pseudo-notes, mimicking clinical text generation. This conversion not only
preserves better representations of categorical data and learns contexts but
also enables the effective employment of pretrained foundation models for rich
feature representation. To address potential issues with context length, our
framework encodes embeddings for each EHR modality separately. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of MEME by applying it to several decision support tasks
within the Emergency Department across multiple hospital systems. Our findings
indicate that MEME outperforms traditional machine learning, EHR-specific
foundation models, and general LLMs, highlighting its potential as a general
and extendible EHR representation strategy.
|
[
-0.1278808117,
-0.7882875204,
1.2271527052,
-0.0216837823,
-0.2698926926,
-0.1639866382,
0.0849577188,
-0.3404436409,
0.7387168407,
0.3243436515,
-0.1851513386,
-0.5137363076,
-0.3798607886,
0.1933097243,
-0.1263509691,
1.1746411324,
-0.2801854014,
0.3243589699,
-0.2399597764,
-0.235859856,
-0.4208160639,
-0.8845867515,
-0.3678197563,
-0.3230132759,
0.4476498663,
0.7217770219,
0.3949128985,
0.3375218213,
0.6903293133,
0.2282598019,
0.5235778689,
-0.016678514,
-0.0195420329,
0.0184146669,
0.185623467,
-0.3763923347,
-0.9647729993,
-0.461271286,
0.6297961473,
0.3033605516,
-0.6904213428,
-0.0465467311,
-0.1070473641,
0.4437311292,
-0.4986192882,
-0.1113920882,
-0.3048063517,
0.2360527366,
-0.0591638461,
-0.4547324479,
-0.5166876316,
-0.1199439019,
0.7523302436,
-0.4388213456,
0.1296506971,
0.3046095669,
0.4299288988,
-0.0176240318,
-0.5551725626,
-0.339048028,
-0.8569532037,
0.6978422403,
-0.3946911097,
0.6092599034,
0.3168722987,
0.4854107797,
0.2123019248,
-0.9169664979,
-0.5571750998,
0.1271171421,
-0.1479933113,
0.1294814646,
0.0114527429,
0.4296617508,
0.0123201916,
0.1209985539,
-0.4866358936,
-0.1754202098,
-0.2648687661,
-0.0292924624,
0.274346292,
0.4111119211,
0.3017918468,
-0.4424794018,
-0.4450485408,
-0.2792514563,
-0.5373207927,
-0.1937584728,
-0.341031462,
-0.1280299276,
-0.0516786017,
0.5176374912,
0.2993416488,
0.3482273817,
0.033269871,
-0.39864856,
0.4798580408,
-0.0457011349,
-0.507563591,
0.6743938327,
0.5706226826,
0.6010946631,
-0.2329103798,
-0.1365188509,
-0.277489543,
0.0790245757,
0.7244833708,
-0.5714403391,
-0.4923019409,
0.2523246109,
-0.8577829599,
-0.0180782657,
-0.0225137174,
-1.0948859453,
-0.1790992022,
-0.3200319111,
0.3492213488,
-0.4956449568,
-0.1423447132,
0.0745329335,
0.0074752215,
-0.0125774257,
0.600725174,
-0.58205688,
0.5042760372,
0.0378878675,
0.8252286315,
0.4064851105,
0.0377162546,
-0.2128137201,
0.280641526,
-0.2729458511,
0.9030250311,
-0.6977739334,
-0.6624448299,
-0.0504881702,
0.0681362152,
-0.2291464955,
-0.4828718305,
0.8117771149,
-0.3632410169,
-0.0323268995,
-0.2500815094,
-0.5548714995,
-0.3033575714,
0.2857194245,
-0.6798400879,
0.5572464466,
0.3229749501,
-0.5482999682,
0.5615686178,
-0.691880703,
-0.4540103674,
-0.0326246843,
-0.5653207302,
-1.0768020153,
0.2489925921,
0.1713311821,
0.746460557,
-0.1720485538,
0.2030788362,
-0.3457051814,
-0.0125622144,
-0.1538715959,
0.0198171027,
-0.1819096506,
0.3469371498,
-0.0250251945,
-0.0262000244,
-0.7106131911,
0.0364619493,
0.1379551888,
-0.5205414891,
-0.5726810694,
0.265960902,
0.6138696074,
0.5203201175,
-0.1588356644,
-0.3798296154,
-0.0613363758,
0.2109187245,
0.4080384374,
0.3524166048,
0.1772983819,
0.3779268563,
-0.7988080978,
0.4448606372,
0.2799341083,
-0.0472969674,
-0.4911489785,
-0.4416127503,
-0.4007205069,
-0.4130922556,
0.0773669481,
0.7735778689,
-0.5828277469,
0.4701364636,
-0.2741297781,
-0.0785422698,
-0.6459317207,
-0.2101310194,
0.241405353,
0.6473678946,
0.9368875623,
-0.1675597578,
-0.8744313717,
-1.0795235634,
0.1659390926,
-0.2030373067,
0.0546806194,
0.4965033829,
0.432693392,
-0.6397346854,
0.7437400818,
-0.0980706662,
-0.6643928289,
-0.5307437778,
0.1457860768,
0.0155777792,
0.5992774963,
0.6450862885,
-0.6177422404,
-0.2646846473,
-0.0893770754,
-0.9289577007,
0.1951055974,
-0.3897584677,
0.2905776799,
-0.2963712513,
0.3051283062,
-0.1864094734,
0.5628908277,
0.2194688171,
-0.2401719987,
0.2628924251,
-0.6893220544,
0.5734239817,
-1.2097594738,
-0.0926701128,
0.0973077044,
-0.6306409836,
-0.8368721008,
-0.4764571488,
0.4932356775,
-0.1939592212,
-0.1533622295,
0.1716802716,
-0.5969940424,
0.2096905112,
0.1521960348,
-0.1324275881,
0.0905112103,
0.1210867912,
0.3065042794,
0.2550087273,
0.4307088852,
-0.585665524,
-0.0292727891,
0.5502502322,
-0.265558213,
0.9148353338,
-0.7135930657,
0.1879027933,
-0.3450042903,
0.5478826761,
-0.6697755456,
-0.3512145877,
-0.1412083209,
0.1500694603,
0.6985988021,
-0.242754072,
-0.5413141847,
-0.5784709454,
-0.4644472003,
0.2990934551,
0.4695265591,
-0.1514346302,
0.7961025834,
0.6234214902,
-0.3413353562,
-0.2837121189,
-0.9197092056,
0.1998686343,
-0.3307134807,
-0.4226570129,
0.617053926,
0.1477522701,
-0.1639336646,
0.1336724907,
0.1016560718,
-0.0847486705,
-0.0928961262,
0.2529426515,
0.2857370675,
-0.6065006852,
0.3628211021,
0.4301276207,
0.1052820683,
-0.0492053591,
-0.1344844848,
0.3180247545,
-0.0665677264,
-0.6315241456,
-0.609654963,
0.8844006062,
0.8094577789,
0.1412972659,
0.7300948501,
0.0164247081,
-0.9770377874,
-0.2071113586,
-0.6792733669,
-0.3427660763,
-0.3565943539,
0.4084636569,
-0.3040095568,
-0.6563245058,
0.4514897466,
-0.2943176031,
0.1353435665,
0.2995585203,
0.4971775115,
-0.3355383575,
1.0378924608,
0.5144476295,
0.0486466251,
0.3287704289,
-0.2169574648,
0.4935979843,
-0.958453536,
-0.5436713696,
-0.2745805681,
-0.4011006057,
-0.2596407533,
-0.5118225813,
0.8932195306,
0.1804593056,
0.2099597603,
0.0317623131,
-0.4430088103,
0.0818280652,
-0.128396824,
0.5706558824,
-0.1497323364,
0.0112018147,
-0.3422128856,
-0.1988564879,
-0.769061327,
-0.884555459,
1.2233909369,
0.5561307669,
0.7319705486,
0.1832334101,
0.8939666748,
0.4732558429,
0.4767102897,
-0.3309390247,
0.0411540307,
-0.021135807,
-0.645888865,
-0.1535722762,
-0.0405737795,
-0.583712399,
0.1721338779,
-0.6273208261,
-0.6299574375,
0.3888345063,
0.4120183289,
-0.693390727,
0.4596161842,
-0.8946120739,
0.7756640911,
-0.2109480053,
-0.0771425441,
-0.4656900167,
-0.660330236,
-0.149546057,
-0.2309712023,
0.3522975743,
0.2847959399,
0.0572611652,
0.9100213647,
-0.6595865488,
0.5772268772,
-0.0634240955,
0.3506791592,
0.5862465501,
-0.0199790131,
0.6230849028,
0.2159541249,
-0.0419542715,
-0.119131349,
0.0290723499,
-0.3380643129,
-0.3748901486,
0.7341057062,
-0.5697465539,
-0.3023713827,
-0.3072007895,
0.0097071305,
-0.3176955879,
0.0989253968,
0.1910078377,
1.0244226456,
-0.3378461003,
0.2335979939,
0.7354064584,
-0.1685997844,
0.4206465483,
0.2705753744,
0.1914972812,
-0.3618749678,
0.5640099049,
0.4040449262,
-0.3248224556,
0.7341409326,
0.0505916215,
-0.7087115645,
-0.4052192867,
-0.6193548441,
0.1863144785,
-0.9649479389,
-0.0775810033,
-1.3313589096,
0.0716005415,
-0.2503461838,
-0.5874044895,
-0.1409391463,
-0.3199362755,
-0.4480826557,
-0.6259229779,
0.501932323,
0.9985786676,
0.0124696707,
0.3832076788,
-1.0948268175,
0.1123720482,
0.1573994309,
0.2575262189,
0.1302290708,
-0.1997769028,
-0.1881840378,
-0.38242957,
-0.4722540677,
-1.3015233278,
0.1013678387,
0.266223073,
0.6960123181,
0.717823565,
0.0091767702,
0.8034673333,
-1.1312359571,
0.6077415943,
0.6657065749,
-0.6333181858,
0.6291357875,
-0.2182033062,
-0.2685320377,
0.7113717794,
0.3411171734,
-0.2573324442,
0.1789160669,
-0.9223506451,
-0.8311231732,
0.4986492991,
-0.0624547377,
0.0739756748,
-0.3009376228,
0.3069577515,
-0.0905698463,
0.284214139,
-0.4616687596,
-0.5768373609,
-0.3925624788,
-0.4890552759,
-0.0960475504,
-0.7315474153,
0.1040688455,
-0.0643831715,
0.0765946358,
0.133141011,
0.6484304667,
0.7867359519,
-0.2610136271,
-0.3268193901,
0.7304651141,
0.6046923995,
0.6887976527,
-0.2571084499,
0.5518370867,
0.4584802687,
-0.4309101105,
0.1591458321,
0.0119936196,
0.2945706248,
0.3309010863,
0.2908688486,
0.7700141668,
0.4977767169,
-0.5111365914,
0.4830005467,
0.066190131,
0.0247154776,
-0.2506515682,
-0.3722881377,
-0.1391161531,
-0.0756525472,
0.1974677593,
0.0499425083,
0.5184468627,
-0.5059047341,
0.9392664433,
-0.0533444732,
-0.6290220618,
-0.646404624,
0.7763780951,
0.1758018583,
-0.0797064081,
0.2041159272,
0.1187300012,
-0.5829010606,
0.545797348,
0.914280951,
0.7175552845,
-0.5930655003,
0.1999872327,
0.3877791464,
0.2966884673,
-0.2903393805,
0.6280916333,
0.0345942229,
-0.2521991432,
0.110849686,
-0.3378269374,
-0.3476169407,
0.1213406995,
-0.686466217,
0.6223593354,
-0.9385684729,
-0.415241152,
-0.2667099833,
-0.628899157,
-0.92214185,
0.618245542,
0.3017940819,
0.5609222651,
-0.7815114856,
0.615655303,
1.4175149202,
-0.2306994051,
-0.875007987,
-0.1800037324,
0.1460535377,
-0.4439421594,
0.086196579,
0.2644510269,
0.22033301,
-0.3399069011,
0.0871427953,
-0.5185201764,
1.0214344263,
-0.1145272776,
-1.0828063488,
-0.1636530012,
-0.0380141549,
0.6177812815,
-0.6133724451,
0.6856669784,
0.344083488,
0.2065900862,
-0.4935291409,
-0.8383544683,
0.1628163755,
-0.1497178674,
-0.3557920158,
0.4216365814,
-0.4510338902,
0.812676847,
-0.4892573059,
-0.0734488294,
-0.5936850905,
0.3545945287,
0.2077615112,
0.6381135583,
0.4906544387,
0.7779306173,
0.8486754894,
0.080497779,
1.3437728882,
-0.0965208039,
0.2940511405,
0.9229217768,
-0.441480726,
0.7750005126,
0.5007982254,
-0.0284444913,
0.9040677547,
0.5702620745,
0.3125114739,
0.8656228781,
-0.1196138188,
-0.2809145749,
-0.236247316,
-0.0095807463,
-0.5535425544,
-0.0678129122,
0.6722140908,
-0.7764438391,
-0.312191695,
0.0185104124,
0.0849204063,
-0.2690680027,
-0.2585771382,
0.7764599323,
0.5257683992,
-0.2251098305,
0.242974624,
0.138435021,
0.1131667644,
-0.4952436686,
-0.4331001937,
0.3842134476,
0.2827307284,
-0.4203903973,
-0.4217032492,
0.1957019418,
-0.0891868398,
-0.453715831,
-0.1745734364,
0.6236045957,
-0.2808122933,
-0.3804137409,
0.3264656961,
0.5156888366,
-0.1248939484,
0.3524327278,
-0.7106578946,
-0.3733575046,
-0.2158681303,
-0.2035913914,
0.3279658556,
0.6995713711,
-0.3066995442,
0.3766237199,
0.4642636478,
0.1063633412,
0.1360385269,
0.2043500394,
0.8250326514,
-0.5330075026,
-1.0654276609,
-0.8751111627,
0.5969825387,
0.0192819927,
-0.346445471,
0.229635179,
0.2573438883,
0.3679108322,
-0.1431125551,
1.0200307369,
-0.0937998071,
0.5877084136,
-0.6317883134,
0.5829854608,
-0.6586406231,
0.2108092308,
-0.6368255019,
-0.6598787904,
-0.3576437831,
0.8178427219,
-0.2679333389,
-0.1277247965,
0.9908509851,
0.1853390783,
-0.2815767527,
0.14296709,
0.3758408427,
-0.0146037154,
0.390004456,
0.6501869559,
0.8577625155,
-0.3895955384,
0.0472013839,
-0.2771702111,
-0.3954170942,
-0.5019297004,
-0.7868881226,
-0.9652171731,
-0.3889214694,
-0.3369925618,
-0.0912271962,
-0.267950058,
1.2704128027,
0.9061146379,
-1.1265565157,
0.2338176221,
0.2505544424,
-0.0570601113,
0.2033506036,
-0.1141733453,
0.5559909344,
0.0506618656,
0.0044379672,
0.3498918414,
0.5663769245,
0.3119968176,
0.2009426951,
0.0123524675,
-0.1807273775,
0.061402116,
0.520891726,
-0.1336356699,
-0.5735387206,
-0.2390728444,
-0.0399642922,
-0.0765202343,
0.2855250239,
1.2166283131,
-0.6183472276,
0.6350412369,
0.3108121753,
0.758500278,
0.1143165529,
-0.095771499,
0.3797720075,
-0.4845308959,
0.0230977759,
0.3831317127,
0.9967517257,
0.4232068956,
-0.6029711366,
0.0458072089,
0.0982611179,
-0.4579427838,
-0.7601861358,
-0.2516313195,
-0.6224372387,
-0.0259389989,
0.7034292221,
-0.2278985828,
0.0934550464,
-0.6312558651,
-0.12417119,
-0.0710178167,
-0.7387650013,
0.7425628304,
0.4864287078,
-0.3598703146,
-0.2372120917,
-0.6672003269,
0.4909336865,
0.4308023453,
-0.8741391897,
-0.5183234811,
0.4359762967,
0.2645220757,
0.5082369447,
0.9325113893,
-0.2784046233,
0.4108964801,
-0.3548576832,
-0.0332362615,
0.4362686276,
-0.8027107716,
-0.3134650886,
0.1632402837,
-0.0906580389,
-0.2256656587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00159v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00159v2
|
Dolma: an Open Corpus of Three Trillion Tokens for Language Model Pretraining Research
| 2024-01-31T20:29:50 | 2024-06-06T18:46:40 |
Luca Soldaini, Rodney Kinney, Akshita Bhagia, Dustin Schwenk, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Ben Bogin, Khyathi Chandu, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Valentin Hofmann, Ananya Harsh Jha, Sachin Kumar, Li Lucy, Xinxi Lyu, Nathan Lambert, Ian Magnusson, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Abhilasha Ravichander, Kyle Richardson, Zejiang Shen, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Oyvind Tafjord, Pete Walsh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Iz Beltagy, Dirk Groeneveld, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Information about pretraining corpora used to train the current
best-performing language models is seldom discussed: commercial models rarely
detail their data, and even open models are often released without accompanying
training data or recipes to reproduce them. As a result, it is challenging to
conduct and advance scientific research on language modeling, such as
understanding how training data impacts model capabilities and limitations. To
facilitate scientific research on language model pretraining, we curate and
release Dolma, a three-trillion-token English corpus, built from a diverse
mixture of web content, scientific papers, code, public-domain books, social
media, and encyclopedic materials. We extensively document Dolma, including its
design principles, details about its construction, and a summary of its
contents. We present analyses and experimental results on intermediate states
of Dolma to share what we have learned about important data curation practices.
Finally, we open-source our data curation toolkit to enable reproduction of our
work as well as support further research in large-scale data curation.
|
[
-0.1009856388,
-0.797616601,
0.3231547475,
0.0650027096,
-0.0699771717,
0.0540200174,
-0.3926306665,
-0.3496794403,
0.1839610189,
0.5040704012,
0.001260998,
-0.2769301236,
-0.4976313114,
0.0411177613,
-0.6026295424,
1.3390879631,
-0.1625588536,
0.4733043611,
-0.3301816881,
0.2265201807,
0.1073551476,
-0.8417770267,
-0.36353302,
0.0536607727,
0.7913801074,
0.4397583604,
0.4901893735,
0.4730485082,
0.5132318735,
0.1313092858,
-0.0137531841,
-0.1717546433,
-0.8805380464,
-0.0063802982,
0.1245171875,
-0.7685523033,
-0.8091619015,
0.4569862485,
0.9571605325,
0.9330678582,
-0.1028891206,
0.4834758639,
-0.1261352748,
0.4709020853,
-0.7220173478,
0.2683932483,
-0.6426619887,
-0.0938896984,
-0.993834734,
0.1012590379,
-0.4734656811,
-0.4109180272,
-0.1517270207,
-0.7042175531,
0.4896503687,
0.3435434699,
0.6033604741,
0.1723791063,
-0.2270786464,
-0.167857334,
-0.7696869969,
0.7138234377,
-0.6022120714,
0.5351127982,
0.7675839067,
0.1546051353,
-0.0851210207,
-1.0234889984,
-1.0193026066,
-0.3692165315,
-0.1213557199,
-0.3487930894,
-0.3339495957,
-0.1983390898,
0.0563660488,
0.5636421442,
-0.6955670118,
0.1449061036,
-0.8269492984,
0.0304615702,
0.4233286679,
-0.0345409624,
0.2804911435,
0.1872684062,
-0.1389378458,
-0.2782202363,
-1.1248589754,
-0.2548959851,
0.681504786,
0.1950007379,
-0.0737378001,
0.6579912901,
0.0808872506,
0.6503107548,
-0.1641058773,
0.3840029538,
0.6031849384,
-0.2995731831,
-0.2167093307,
0.0960513651,
0.8455447555,
-0.0888033509,
-0.0137462802,
-0.3859835267,
-0.1647693664,
0.0661425814,
0.6443496943,
-0.667915225,
-0.2965997458,
0.1048733443,
-0.3449662924,
-0.419212997,
0.0261486042,
-0.6619961262,
0.043545682,
-0.3777656257,
0.10544689,
-0.1584125906,
-0.5913640857,
0.075156495,
0.1081836522,
-0.0936342627,
-0.0053594024,
-1.0745459795,
0.3270475566,
0.724930048,
0.7993032336,
-0.1945321262,
-0.5554639101,
-0.5595646501,
0.0948977768,
-0.6508542895,
0.4778413177,
-0.5663835406,
-0.3550306559,
-0.0953879207,
0.1960986555,
-0.1014556587,
-0.4856854081,
0.468338728,
-0.8532603979,
0.1758652329,
0.0663373172,
-0.3293695152,
0.0462377332,
0.0884848759,
-1.0020593405,
1.1410915852,
0.2418307066,
-0.8604778647,
0.3111253381,
-0.8885630965,
-0.1435441673,
0.3551044464,
-0.0726904273,
-0.1419049352,
0.2915327549,
-0.1207116991,
0.4666865766,
-0.3610885143,
0.7746930718,
-0.4891958535,
-0.1424431354,
0.3370770514,
-0.1779839098,
0.7613289952,
0.6374155283,
0.0002742502,
0.1972003132,
-0.7315645814,
-0.3330353796,
0.3939074278,
-0.1249689013,
-0.4187855422,
-0.301579386,
0.1793033034,
-0.1110050082,
0.4196903706,
-0.8224571943,
0.2173121721,
-0.2066306621,
0.4200317264,
0.4030285776,
-0.720903039,
0.5539028645,
-0.3646228909,
0.6681121588,
0.3470118046,
0.0677289218,
-0.2728736103,
-0.1707166433,
-0.7556393147,
-0.1969338059,
0.6211079359,
0.0953206345,
-0.3931310475,
0.2328110933,
-0.2755700052,
-0.9125268459,
-1.0715489388,
0.0562561639,
0.4136207104,
0.6020789146,
0.320160538,
-0.252004683,
-0.718295455,
-0.7126556635,
0.1815437376,
-0.2361885756,
-0.057039991,
-0.0379209742,
0.707077682,
-0.108576864,
0.9723563194,
-0.6638141274,
-0.0614805669,
-0.0564786606,
0.1001444459,
0.0891162679,
0.5403190851,
0.6240876317,
-0.6230221391,
-0.2219942063,
-0.0813027471,
-0.702272892,
0.2839639783,
0.4493920207,
-0.3121724725,
0.1879962087,
0.4295504987,
-0.6461594701,
0.2262076437,
0.7909650207,
-0.204929769,
0.5263996124,
-0.1839605272,
-0.0356708206,
-0.8882690668,
0.7488780022,
-0.4437323511,
-0.1311201751,
-0.863591969,
0.0464384146,
0.2070617974,
-0.3169110715,
-0.4611485004,
0.7975512743,
-0.1793367267,
0.1646874249,
0.0132472022,
0.0165366363,
-0.0320686959,
0.2519786358,
0.2064704895,
0.7390310168,
0.6741238236,
-0.5315308571,
0.0381422192,
0.4439096749,
-0.5379558802,
0.1813857853,
-0.7807205915,
0.4153751433,
-0.2773092091,
0.4704893827,
-0.7195321321,
-0.4181160629,
0.3544391692,
-0.3165498674,
0.3515059948,
0.1166059077,
-0.5410552621,
-0.30295524,
-0.136687085,
0.4884983897,
0.4875325263,
-0.5636814237,
-0.0835102126,
0.9040629864,
-0.4864159822,
-0.4818193614,
-0.4799250364,
-0.0503714606,
-0.0573305376,
-0.538857162,
0.4290959239,
-0.2963712215,
-0.4170756638,
0.0932787731,
0.0780884102,
-0.1951902062,
0.1052003875,
0.1052914485,
0.505674243,
-0.2911648452,
0.1792990118,
-0.2481489331,
0.0320835151,
0.0625839978,
-0.2030447274,
0.6412167549,
-0.2553812861,
-0.2798423469,
0.1130874678,
0.2009431571,
0.3358891606,
-0.2247016877,
0.9308136106,
0.5012203455,
-0.2216723859,
-0.1490282565,
-0.4773017764,
0.0125408396,
-0.3597179949,
0.1113687381,
-0.140868023,
-1.0559301376,
0.0847067237,
0.2225049138,
0.2637638152,
0.323492825,
0.5998725295,
-0.028524382,
0.6240620613,
0.6075460315,
0.0855041221,
0.3274087012,
-0.2886794508,
0.4939795434,
-0.6834571362,
-0.5264587402,
-0.8811278343,
-0.0338840149,
-0.1237048879,
-0.6793187857,
0.1306620091,
0.2761627734,
-0.239181459,
0.1946033984,
-0.2112515867,
0.3204865158,
0.7095039487,
-0.1723998487,
0.2719582319,
-0.1105599552,
0.0517231636,
0.1988213956,
-0.5536163449,
-0.8237762451,
1.450171113,
0.2885121107,
0.6663419008,
-0.0424826629,
0.6034495234,
0.0742490366,
0.4743021131,
-0.397729218,
0.315978229,
-0.0105758477,
-0.9671304822,
-0.2983812392,
-0.3247057796,
-1.2959997654,
-0.1638775319,
0.1126030535,
-0.217021361,
-0.1789702773,
0.3841087222,
-0.0741404518,
0.1182751134,
-0.60367167,
0.8463651538,
-0.3140437007,
-0.1187585667,
-0.2300839871,
-0.6724419594,
0.4234909117,
-0.6357690096,
0.4240168631,
-0.1264372021,
0.0678016469,
0.9051977396,
-0.4145462513,
0.8106274009,
-0.0133292377,
-0.1560972631,
0.279310286,
0.0499527119,
0.2152437866,
-0.1522638947,
-0.1668634862,
0.724930346,
0.1983889639,
-0.4255222976,
-0.2928490043,
0.6053472161,
-0.9386776686,
-0.4410670996,
-0.3731867671,
-0.3586607873,
-0.1737069041,
0.2955907583,
-0.0222854223,
0.1041625366,
-0.6511461139,
0.4753704667,
0.3506289423,
-0.0232275836,
0.4366378784,
0.557914257,
-0.4372338653,
-0.1832525283,
1.0590434074,
0.1162196323,
-0.0755230859,
0.2304556966,
0.1730265766,
-0.3048272729,
-0.612056613,
-0.3599190414,
0.2981295884,
-0.4685723484,
0.0109501062,
-0.7232775092,
-0.3180124462,
-0.777543664,
-0.0019374469,
-0.371963203,
-0.5183237791,
-0.4760369956,
-0.2866877615,
0.3956760466,
1.0821826458,
-0.1088445783,
0.4474480152,
-0.8665686846,
0.3377376795,
0.0296399165,
0.5534368157,
0.0353430435,
-0.3130980432,
-0.4824741185,
0.1590174437,
-0.2108372152,
-0.4538193047,
0.5650457144,
-0.0224225521,
0.8151378036,
0.137078166,
-0.0346505232,
0.5111806393,
-0.5452628732,
0.9746415615,
0.2981619239,
-0.7138437033,
0.4586161375,
-0.4391122758,
-0.0081388494,
0.5312713385,
0.8949002028,
-0.3294765353,
-0.1449016035,
-0.8820050359,
-0.7374672294,
1.072555542,
0.1329174638,
0.2117079198,
-0.3404549658,
-0.131351769,
0.460716933,
0.6087514758,
-0.6766649485,
-0.0916200802,
-0.3595982194,
-0.2501819432,
-0.4417235255,
-0.2914555371,
-0.3463151753,
-0.1119137481,
0.7307904959,
0.0098565593,
-0.1125703156,
-0.1392252147,
-0.2952081561,
-0.0189201087,
0.1506240219,
0.3014426529,
0.6095238924,
-0.0794211924,
0.315944463,
-0.1468814164,
-0.8895603418,
-0.0273805317,
0.101298444,
-0.1901497245,
-0.065117307,
0.1305252165,
1.0440145731,
0.1935376078,
-0.9392921925,
0.4488593936,
-0.0940188617,
-0.1883257478,
-0.4819220603,
-0.038274873,
0.0919664204,
-0.2150123566,
0.1253989786,
-0.0202635285,
-0.1898121387,
-0.3689755797,
0.0896868706,
0.0886358917,
-0.1806832403,
-0.6522566676,
0.7340804935,
0.2397663444,
-0.2604423761,
0.8335003257,
-0.005493267,
0.0830821097,
0.2618895173,
0.6703858376,
0.5959287286,
-0.1312858611,
0.2779124677,
0.3419662714,
-0.0276465863,
-0.3180647194,
0.3781309426,
-0.1247477978,
-0.5920003653,
-0.3288202286,
-1.1490063667,
-0.295419246,
0.3245228529,
-0.4864014685,
0.4385006726,
-0.3088457286,
-0.093859762,
-0.004013754,
-0.1888361424,
-0.9355293512,
-0.0209313594,
0.3889398873,
0.7103943229,
-0.7578588128,
1.0407645702,
0.6334989071,
-0.5830225945,
-0.6176924706,
-0.3501611054,
-0.0761028975,
-0.9681754112,
1.1746566296,
0.0861416981,
0.0755311698,
0.1659542322,
-0.684382081,
-1.1445162296,
0.7929061651,
0.6544395685,
-0.7385893464,
-0.304459542,
0.0765669495,
0.5462137461,
-0.4152223766,
0.2721191347,
0.6294813752,
0.4099089503,
0.1702984422,
-1.0486489534,
-0.2374489754,
-0.6100604534,
-0.2994722128,
0.1094682664,
-0.5748509169,
0.9487633109,
-0.0706360415,
-0.0217921976,
-0.0708717182,
0.4219782948,
0.4125384092,
0.1891277432,
0.4422893226,
0.6906493902,
1.0440881252,
0.1420249939,
0.9202662706,
-0.3766431212,
-0.1018896922,
1.1595041752,
-0.4499195814,
1.0584185123,
0.6249954104,
-0.2454131097,
0.3787820637,
0.631342113,
0.0611641966,
0.3138692379,
0.486027509,
-0.359957248,
0.1590642035,
-0.4176409841,
-0.341647774,
0.6737357378,
0.3948711753,
-0.3340289593,
-0.053301584,
-0.0369150974,
0.4131217301,
-0.1787717044,
-0.0839520842,
0.4998990297,
0.0320319794,
-0.9208520651,
0.469968915,
-0.3249870837,
0.3298557997,
-0.6905217171,
0.0125667676,
-0.0875570998,
-0.0581951365,
-0.2104339451,
-0.5578459501,
0.4390210509,
0.4057876468,
-0.0610525757,
-0.5631479621,
0.3465871811,
-0.5410477519,
-0.4226132035,
0.1271349937,
0.5415498018,
0.7027809024,
0.2881447971,
-0.2149718553,
0.3788070977,
-0.3232625723,
-0.561185658,
0.5916379094,
0.2931189835,
-0.0521059297,
0.2895593047,
1.0657058954,
0.4342330992,
0.2483833283,
0.0922338068,
0.9980855584,
-0.5502297282,
-0.2765807509,
-0.7121247649,
0.5175032616,
-0.0254965201,
-0.4974561334,
0.6868802905,
0.716540277,
1.3351432085,
-0.1591057777,
0.8728365302,
-0.2939664125,
0.5368288755,
-0.4327331483,
0.9155160189,
-0.4360915422,
-0.0863184184,
0.0533758402,
-0.7613931298,
-0.4479656219,
0.3906235993,
-0.2504635155,
-0.3034696281,
0.62045151,
0.8578971624,
-0.110633716,
0.1896788776,
0.2708031237,
0.3432196975,
0.2268909514,
-0.0357984081,
0.8104821444,
0.0238668285,
0.4470411539,
-0.1137835905,
-0.2078577429,
-0.2092191726,
-0.9039129615,
-0.9238754511,
-1.0086007118,
0.0265490357,
-0.0284333397,
-0.2440651506,
0.8110167384,
0.9504539371,
-0.7028992772,
-0.3177279532,
-0.0392486639,
-0.2648410201,
0.2133351415,
-0.086827904,
0.3278697431,
-0.6804674268,
-0.7551547885,
0.6298476458,
-0.0926226005,
0.0595324598,
-0.4738964438,
-0.0975514278,
-0.1183050945,
-0.1915370524,
0.4248461127,
0.1978490502,
-0.4533806145,
0.1988526583,
0.1360333115,
-0.028954206,
-0.02587712,
1.0186207294,
-0.7181236744,
0.6162861586,
0.4272225499,
0.5387358665,
0.6031771898,
-0.4545535147,
0.9424923658,
-0.7908117771,
0.41805619,
0.4395513535,
0.3803763688,
0.3007671833,
-0.2005381882,
0.6814408302,
-0.0273621529,
-0.6694108248,
-1.2938164473,
-0.0816410035,
-0.7729517221,
-0.1876788139,
0.9348873496,
-0.4023402035,
-0.4125773907,
-0.1179956794,
-0.1387590319,
0.5228382349,
-0.2397811562,
0.6518746614,
0.708388865,
0.1499055922,
0.1918581277,
-0.7627004385,
0.5857583284,
0.159066692,
-0.8370687962,
0.2898570895,
0.4903108776,
0.1243395358,
0.1941054165,
0.9719252586,
-0.3864168525,
-0.1175836995,
0.2544638813,
0.2286360115,
-0.2220869064,
-0.6171529293,
-0.3854226768,
0.2339433432,
0.3374845386,
-0.041598253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00157v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00157v3
|
Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning: Progresses and Challenges
| 2024-01-31T20:26:32 | 2024-04-05T04:06:51 |
Janice Ahn, Rishu Verma, Renze Lou, Di Liu, Rui Zhang, Wenpeng Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mathematical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for assessing the fundamental
cognitive capabilities of human intelligence. In recent times, there has been a
notable surge in the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) geared towards
the automated resolution of mathematical problems. However, the landscape of
mathematical problem types is vast and varied, with LLM-oriented techniques
undergoing evaluation across diverse datasets and settings. This diversity
makes it challenging to discern the true advancements and obstacles within this
burgeoning field. This survey endeavors to address four pivotal dimensions: i)
a comprehensive exploration of the various mathematical problems and their
corresponding datasets that have been investigated; ii) an examination of the
spectrum of LLM-oriented techniques that have been proposed for mathematical
problem-solving; iii) an overview of factors and concerns affecting LLMs in
solving math; and iv) an elucidation of the persisting challenges within this
domain. To the best of our knowledge, this survey stands as one of the first
extensive examinations of the landscape of LLMs in the realm of mathematics,
providing a holistic perspective on the current state, accomplishments, and
future challenges in this rapidly evolving field.
|
[
-0.5133901834,
-1.0523401499,
0.9263854027,
0.4095727205,
0.1367830783,
0.2899754941,
-0.4461828172,
-0.3673360646,
-0.1466478407,
0.6521805525,
-0.5406683087,
-0.3815191984,
-0.7582116127,
0.0856541172,
-0.2560895681,
0.5118424892,
-0.1456372887,
0.1418234706,
-0.575638175,
-0.0786552727,
-0.4157696664,
-0.908698976,
-0.6375157237,
-0.3121020794,
0.3492192626,
0.2137662321,
0.7307652235,
0.1817940772,
0.8452053666,
0.4331580698,
-0.2152818292,
0.08920376,
-0.2741636932,
0.459612757,
-0.1332932562,
-0.5335727334,
-0.2552722394,
-0.1037827879,
0.78808254,
1.3679900169,
0.0065582274,
0.1655994952,
-0.1776789427,
0.7523724437,
-0.3522071838,
0.4036521316,
-0.5504136682,
-0.0628966987,
-0.5197899342,
0.2035698742,
-0.2312119454,
-0.3306597471,
0.3453923762,
-0.4471504986,
-0.144475624,
-0.0943709314,
0.4009127915,
0.1841235012,
-0.7409358621,
-0.5258908868,
-1.0377113819,
1.0602961779,
-0.5757132173,
0.3801503181,
0.3498882353,
0.374568373,
-0.3061104715,
-0.5260456204,
-0.3803693354,
-0.0930320248,
0.4362692535,
-0.114231132,
-0.2295488864,
-0.3211508095,
0.4941598773,
0.3933891654,
-0.4791859388,
0.3229792118,
-0.2370148301,
-0.2225707024,
0.9136378169,
0.5926163197,
0.2497376949,
0.0080377571,
0.2153917551,
0.1905997545,
-0.7987650037,
0.0157038122,
0.2736460865,
-0.0118837086,
0.0750994012,
0.6927093863,
-0.0080109332,
0.7505794168,
-0.4515712261,
-0.2188612223,
0.0138943177,
-0.2960872948,
0.0461402722,
-0.4661028981,
0.5890333056,
-0.0998913348,
0.5127335787,
0.3894254863,
-0.2345826775,
0.140308097,
-0.2228595018,
-0.4131796658,
0.0057454365,
0.2244348079,
-0.1827505976,
-0.0703584552,
-0.2950742245,
-0.6120918393,
-0.4147560894,
-0.7838172913,
0.0196873471,
-0.2898890674,
-0.3128703237,
0.3131110072,
0.4057482183,
0.2654489875,
0.597641468,
-0.7625504732,
0.1775009036,
1.0520809889,
0.5091735125,
-0.0870560408,
0.0196770951,
-0.0779071152,
-0.077019304,
-0.4183889627,
0.9194175601,
-0.7491413951,
-0.4983997643,
0.3274255991,
-0.2745404541,
0.0239778068,
-0.6648650765,
0.6592512727,
-0.5033587813,
0.1657035649,
-0.4455737174,
-0.6091936231,
-0.2200136185,
0.6123221517,
-0.5588710904,
0.8501698375,
0.1307276487,
-0.3995217383,
-0.2391086966,
-0.6768900752,
-0.3326255977,
0.1398857087,
-0.3638533354,
-0.2565543056,
0.324798286,
0.2059182674,
0.3294206858,
-0.8067998886,
0.404735297,
-0.4064431787,
0.0653728768,
0.6093962789,
-0.5801327825,
0.9787950516,
0.264138341,
0.0519094318,
0.0059450446,
-0.7699652314,
0.0434435941,
0.4696444869,
-0.0172386989,
-0.252949059,
0.2105437219,
-0.1796044856,
0.256137073,
0.4633390605,
-0.2904243469,
0.349466145,
-0.2409762144,
0.6343890429,
0.7077514529,
-0.0239983257,
0.2594329119,
-0.1754503399,
0.6082174778,
-0.0238651801,
0.2045466006,
-0.2731889486,
-0.6745963097,
-0.5384257436,
-0.1788668334,
0.2929560244,
0.612529695,
-0.5521690249,
0.1800378859,
-0.2602595985,
-0.5139731765,
-0.069328934,
0.2235682458,
0.1852590591,
0.1985153109,
0.0024943538,
0.2963419259,
-0.2834882438,
-0.842191875,
-0.1353281736,
-0.0005761111,
0.0268414803,
0.4866352677,
0.618183434,
-0.2095045149,
0.8148214817,
-0.6603098512,
-0.251763314,
-0.2338434309,
-0.0130868405,
0.2464625984,
0.2592351139,
0.4304738343,
-0.7521110177,
-0.4443664551,
-0.0387210064,
-0.9387400746,
-0.3314293623,
0.1846077591,
-0.034108419,
0.0743007958,
0.441736728,
-0.7151393294,
0.2609919906,
0.5259391069,
-0.2111717016,
0.669024229,
-0.0531095453,
-0.1032129228,
-0.7433236837,
-0.0785176009,
0.236346826,
0.2612440586,
-0.4468782246,
0.0388040245,
-0.2773971558,
-0.2592731416,
-0.0665654689,
0.594931066,
-0.5312196016,
-0.2441738695,
0.0228408426,
0.4031617939,
-0.1822300553,
0.186842978,
-0.0566468835,
0.3643822968,
0.7489605546,
-0.5482556224,
0.696847856,
0.1538797021,
-0.349511832,
0.6221755743,
-0.6313467026,
0.1058609113,
-0.2485777438,
0.2166140825,
-0.9389663339,
-0.1775632501,
0.1118905246,
-0.4635541439,
0.1231926903,
0.1099268124,
-0.6423797607,
-0.4905014634,
0.1077132151,
0.7999078631,
0.4997005165,
-0.2190551013,
0.6473193765,
0.4607459009,
-0.5193604231,
-0.3485990763,
-0.4141619802,
0.1925054193,
-0.1910117418,
-0.8867020011,
0.0319875926,
-0.1370494068,
-1.0222642422,
-0.1412961036,
-0.0451113507,
-0.0883776844,
0.0966957137,
-0.1276909262,
0.4757175744,
-0.3039562106,
0.0712951049,
-0.1547293514,
-0.2994224131,
0.5366763473,
-0.3884919286,
0.5052787066,
-0.2260684073,
-0.6682924032,
-0.2029991448,
0.5759094357,
0.5896736979,
-0.6042144299,
0.5130270123,
0.1056850478,
-0.6279727817,
-0.2535229325,
-0.6069844365,
0.0828563645,
-0.407963872,
0.3649661243,
-0.5124332905,
-0.9984002709,
0.6508995295,
-0.2845098078,
0.1134145632,
0.5303225517,
0.8202200532,
0.030062411,
1.2147078514,
0.24857831,
0.0864596069,
0.1809123755,
-0.2917999029,
0.3990940154,
-0.8595305085,
-0.4200360477,
-0.8334215283,
-0.1231657937,
-0.3036950529,
-0.5205133557,
0.5424449444,
-0.0514156558,
-0.2862155139,
-0.1696123779,
-0.2779954374,
0.4273839891,
0.1179773957,
-0.3202593923,
0.3708542883,
-0.0885399655,
-0.1689801067,
-0.3007737994,
-0.4427866042,
-0.6134263873,
1.0804817677,
0.4899117351,
0.6906810999,
0.4215183556,
0.306938976,
-0.1434368789,
0.3118082285,
-0.8911218047,
0.7263506055,
-0.0915112272,
-0.7634902,
-0.5728198886,
-0.6651679873,
-1.0217715502,
0.3703707159,
-0.0764086843,
-0.856867373,
-0.1329188049,
-0.0226709172,
-0.2002442181,
0.4047787786,
-0.3424012661,
0.5758436918,
-0.6031057835,
-0.2996781468,
-0.2539442182,
-0.4543530941,
0.6551237702,
-0.3397069871,
0.588639915,
-0.3407471776,
0.0445518345,
0.5196425915,
-0.2400178462,
0.5642505884,
0.0342024416,
-0.5687016845,
0.4234300852,
0.2967326641,
0.2714666724,
0.1937344372,
-0.0190870985,
0.144734025,
0.1994017065,
-0.4057253301,
-0.720046103,
0.6751249433,
-0.6779716611,
-0.930929482,
-0.6339494586,
-0.7732964158,
-0.5526189208,
0.0086769275,
-0.1125429198,
0.6426746845,
-0.0812068358,
0.2337367237,
0.9172391891,
-0.4263940752,
0.3092570901,
0.3195270598,
-0.6712800264,
-0.2928087711,
0.8000395894,
0.3297142088,
0.2621689439,
0.3150803745,
0.1975732744,
-0.5176072121,
-0.769107759,
-0.1129230261,
0.5473513007,
-0.8599242568,
-0.0177755654,
-0.3491399288,
-0.3858295381,
-0.3734400272,
0.0620641485,
-0.2853671312,
-0.3183765113,
-0.2451752573,
0.4120826721,
0.2222274393,
0.8544337153,
0.1420294344,
0.0558316968,
-0.7335031033,
0.2839713097,
0.4078917801,
0.2526872456,
0.1152855232,
-0.3696008325,
0.0172860753,
0.0958653688,
-0.2330163717,
-0.5304577351,
0.163904205,
-0.2022161633,
0.7319743633,
0.4503566027,
-0.0953247175,
0.4929374456,
-0.4830701351,
0.8224992156,
0.190141663,
-0.975713253,
0.2735995352,
-0.4987894893,
0.1870335639,
0.0664450228,
0.5123586655,
-0.4445195198,
-0.0557933636,
-0.4270510972,
-0.5877287388,
0.1443843395,
0.1340849698,
0.0802403465,
-0.0707850829,
0.4845038652,
-0.1763801128,
-0.0254105348,
-0.3682421744,
-0.0995296761,
0.1946087778,
-0.1982691139,
-0.284201324,
-0.1974361241,
-0.0747917145,
-0.4341355562,
0.4184952974,
0.01589646,
0.0985825211,
-0.1464099586,
-0.1128572226,
-0.0190309342,
0.3296592832,
0.8556131124,
1.0378571749,
0.2280569524,
0.0356570706,
0.1898775101,
-0.2359838486,
0.1647340357,
0.0790712088,
0.1108381376,
-0.2224422842,
0.4425515234,
0.5272936225,
0.2005941421,
-0.7805595994,
0.3317896128,
0.0826752484,
-0.5076306462,
-0.7285075784,
-0.2116194516,
0.3010205328,
0.2483773082,
0.5182912946,
-0.1590150297,
-0.1129925698,
-0.6438450813,
-0.270499289,
0.646802783,
-0.0033833517,
-0.3629895747,
0.4470092952,
-0.0089238016,
-0.4365469217,
0.841072619,
-0.0534674749,
-0.7167013288,
0.6797642708,
0.5715270638,
0.5351804495,
-0.1679029912,
-0.0548480079,
0.1889570951,
0.224566415,
0.0063149617,
0.2367656529,
0.2486458421,
-0.7894082069,
-0.6172360182,
-0.5744249225,
-0.5016387701,
0.1519606262,
-0.4275968671,
0.1167280823,
-0.4662903845,
-0.1719812155,
0.1909548491,
0.1244919226,
-0.5870637894,
0.0031170889,
0.360850215,
0.7345199585,
-0.610953927,
0.5798347592,
0.8037739992,
-0.146884203,
-0.4916047752,
-0.311190784,
0.1778387129,
-0.8231593966,
0.7390796542,
-0.1872355789,
-0.0471693464,
-0.0147002004,
-0.6167374849,
-0.9791017771,
0.7223719358,
0.32755211,
-0.5291585922,
-0.1010036096,
0.4249122143,
0.5375736356,
-0.410002172,
0.0952943116,
0.6448874474,
0.6774382591,
0.2778815925,
-0.9125595093,
-0.3299686909,
-0.2095272988,
0.2768975496,
0.3986784518,
-0.5902450085,
1.1771034002,
-0.0567949377,
0.0406037159,
0.2093702555,
0.5546230078,
0.6090692282,
0.3596118093,
0.3835265934,
0.6146582365,
0.6396307349,
-0.3571776748,
0.8275104165,
-0.1191715151,
0.4260132313,
0.7033806443,
-0.7196555734,
0.6073126793,
0.2974928916,
-0.5434430838,
0.4395113885,
0.5591078401,
0.0557940267,
-0.2307236493,
0.7654274106,
-0.5593731999,
-0.6101104021,
-0.0208044332,
-0.4992524087,
0.578237772,
0.9610284567,
0.0211164858,
-0.3827013075,
-0.0235130526,
-0.0848134756,
0.4448589385,
-0.6203215718,
0.5213590264,
0.2801858783,
-0.6194476485,
0.206790477,
0.0630206019,
0.3146347404,
-0.6023139358,
-0.16858989,
-0.0940360948,
0.2451945096,
-0.1145971492,
-1.0053646564,
0.3935228586,
0.0110845957,
0.0047147726,
-0.1613059789,
0.4864423871,
-0.1846190542,
-0.7791358829,
0.0351711996,
0.8160200119,
0.1946848929,
-0.024118619,
-0.6534682512,
0.5017741919,
-0.181979388,
-0.1229545698,
0.3626187444,
0.8139526844,
-0.430740118,
0.9573305249,
0.7693047523,
0.0045577739,
0.1603517681,
0.2180065066,
0.7298806906,
-0.9180919528,
-0.2324246019,
-0.8410996795,
0.2443563938,
0.0961854309,
-0.3119935095,
0.7038843036,
0.4366427064,
0.5119318366,
0.0203936473,
0.8275027871,
0.1529825181,
0.5364570022,
-0.5410749316,
0.243535161,
-0.2512149811,
0.5001584888,
-0.3528428972,
-0.9873381853,
-0.6402420402,
0.6440380216,
-0.6803539395,
0.1745738238,
0.6884289384,
0.317153722,
0.1159477681,
0.0864074528,
0.3497154415,
0.1295137703,
0.3634931147,
0.742410183,
1.3133734465,
0.0320784897,
0.4445683658,
-0.0667824224,
-0.142755881,
-0.0702678263,
-0.7363112569,
-0.9205653071,
-0.5315395594,
-0.458147794,
-0.2265450954,
-0.5615016818,
0.8676111698,
0.3076064587,
-0.7350096703,
-0.4843834937,
0.1133253202,
0.2965525091,
0.0092569375,
-0.2099953741,
0.2089774311,
-0.2974102497,
-0.7118534446,
0.0308481399,
0.4281259179,
-0.0208590366,
-0.6519755125,
0.0971335396,
-0.055721309,
0.2299114466,
0.9910354018,
0.3608883321,
-0.8894386888,
-0.2320561707,
0.2075116187,
-0.0415562131,
-0.1144795492,
1.0021294355,
-0.3895102739,
0.0968691781,
0.3337948322,
1.0045907497,
0.391505897,
-0.3414332867,
0.3345728517,
-0.1303626597,
-0.0404507481,
0.4298700988,
0.5514504313,
0.2046193779,
-0.0985486805,
0.34756428,
0.3332337737,
-0.5935502648,
-0.9535479546,
0.554196775,
-0.9716143012,
-0.2747433782,
1.0034171343,
0.0664904714,
-0.1178868487,
-0.1847034246,
-0.1287821829,
-0.1461909562,
0.130758211,
0.4725161791,
1.1115010977,
-0.3540932536,
-0.3586060703,
-0.6867515445,
0.074083142,
0.3975908756,
-0.9247784019,
0.0403514579,
0.763771534,
0.2296274155,
0.1947183162,
0.3443649709,
-0.4541427195,
-0.0058872825,
-0.2164211273,
-0.3108772039,
0.1345580965,
-0.2547457218,
-0.4894768894,
0.3463756442,
0.2235073596,
0.3962539434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00149v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00149v1
|
The Impact of Language Adapters in Cross-Lingual Transfer for NLU
| 2024-01-31T20:07:43 | 2024-01-31T20:07:43 |
Jenny Kunz, Oskar Holmström
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modular deep learning has been proposed for the efficient adaption of
pre-trained models to new tasks, domains and languages. In particular,
combining language adapters with task adapters has shown potential where no
supervised data exists for a language. In this paper, we explore the role of
language adapters in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer for natural language
understanding (NLU) benchmarks. We study the effect of including a
target-language adapter in detailed ablation studies with two multilingual
models and three multilingual datasets. Our results show that the effect of
target-language adapters is highly inconsistent across tasks, languages and
models. Retaining the source-language adapter instead often leads to an
equivalent, and sometimes to a better, performance. Removing the language
adapter after training has only a weak negative effect, indicating that the
language adapters do not have a strong impact on the predictions.
|
[
-0.359608233,
-0.4828068912,
0.2755374312,
0.1531051248,
-0.1815249026,
-0.120698072,
-0.4563563168,
-0.659196496,
-0.1082095653,
0.3393490016,
-0.1748486608,
0.0260372367,
-0.6709465981,
0.295789063,
-0.0648964345,
0.8653553128,
-0.1727134436,
-0.0502948388,
-0.0809310675,
-0.3640011549,
-0.7935128212,
-0.2546305656,
-0.655203402,
-0.5222999454,
0.4962373078,
0.4179997444,
0.5702540278,
0.3463109732,
0.2471836507,
0.320389688,
0.1274190098,
-0.3766622245,
-0.4128504097,
-0.1136635095,
-0.5898990035,
-0.6967079043,
-0.3603668213,
-0.4537575245,
0.8565722108,
0.8454189301,
-0.0245923102,
-0.0945314243,
-0.0992132574,
0.764018476,
-0.7311897278,
0.1764439195,
-0.8223810792,
0.1872856617,
0.1001686677,
0.0132103832,
-0.5796514153,
0.0592086762,
0.1914211661,
-0.5976023674,
0.1733845919,
-0.2138113081,
0.6707566977,
0.3236265182,
-0.4317030013,
-0.1315857619,
-0.7440761328,
0.869572103,
-0.8547692299,
0.5392826796,
-0.0754835457,
0.3629262447,
0.0881548822,
-0.0351467989,
-0.614146769,
0.2799493372,
-0.5768123865,
0.1605645865,
-0.4839882553,
0.08826904,
-0.0062987111,
0.353736192,
-0.5732274055,
0.41554299,
-0.4616640508,
-0.070049569,
0.5553281903,
-0.0560375825,
0.4948822856,
-0.0715220571,
-0.1085471138,
0.1645066142,
-0.5582963228,
0.1588521153,
0.1466350108,
0.5889351368,
-0.2644974291,
0.3813320994,
-0.2112808973,
1.0795547962,
0.2565552592,
0.1304278225,
0.2903053164,
-0.5118517876,
-0.3953510523,
0.3384308219,
0.7461791635,
0.0600663461,
0.409188658,
-0.4903444946,
0.1310432106,
-0.1144768745,
0.2814404964,
-0.9385243654,
-0.1014715657,
-0.0592094287,
-0.1242233962,
0.1474930197,
-0.1556658,
-0.5632663965,
0.0348319821,
-0.2546922863,
0.4501342773,
-0.4034146369,
-0.4265848398,
0.2893712521,
-0.1709132791,
0.4381707907,
0.117677696,
-1.1896685362,
0.2528712153,
0.4369189739,
0.5570371151,
-0.254001379,
-0.565397203,
-0.5273489356,
0.1679004282,
-0.430975467,
0.7694340348,
-0.562299788,
-0.1911070943,
0.0346919633,
0.3938643038,
-0.6341644526,
-0.6529036164,
0.2398903072,
-0.345062077,
0.2532323301,
-0.2767344415,
-0.3505583405,
-0.4853724539,
0.1809178591,
-0.548478663,
0.6232315302,
0.0987555757,
-0.1327654868,
0.5057304502,
-0.6181522012,
-0.7624825239,
0.0234425366,
0.0703347474,
-0.0624487512,
0.3942071795,
0.2668274343,
0.4750286639,
0.0422625281,
0.2714260519,
-0.1190975457,
-0.483623445,
0.1112953648,
-0.3936485648,
0.6556323767,
-0.0894543678,
-0.4188044071,
0.0025115095,
-0.81286937,
-0.385581851,
-0.0077988221,
-0.5325598121,
-0.4392013252,
-0.2296491712,
0.1312174052,
0.4701184928,
-0.1301321089,
-0.6239070892,
0.0663649291,
-0.2781480551,
-0.0028000055,
0.5298506021,
-0.401594013,
0.9708904624,
-0.210972935,
0.5621882081,
0.1755637527,
-0.2891165614,
-0.3738184571,
-0.2603271604,
-0.9100382328,
-0.1273954213,
0.2264746875,
0.4761679769,
-0.9760411978,
0.1877141893,
-0.4663298428,
-0.5407113433,
-0.7317412496,
0.3999429345,
0.4424992502,
0.5828161836,
0.3807859123,
-0.2369879186,
-0.4995518327,
-0.9228902459,
-0.602519989,
-0.0821167678,
-0.0230730791,
0.3221170306,
0.1071214154,
-0.1398077458,
0.7037914395,
-0.0892148539,
-0.4027843773,
-0.6346970201,
-0.0656774715,
0.3447179496,
0.4929933846,
0.8902875185,
-0.4621760547,
-0.8353720903,
0.504964292,
-0.7671797276,
-0.0046950467,
-0.3932355046,
-0.020468561,
0.4391156137,
0.3106563687,
-0.367957592,
0.1655345559,
0.9027101994,
-0.2968422174,
0.3865929544,
-0.196916908,
0.0846465975,
-0.8741134405,
0.238397941,
0.0100461179,
-0.0354329199,
-1.312251687,
-0.1772874743,
0.2008186132,
0.0432142988,
-0.8637529016,
0.9670760632,
-0.2856251001,
-0.0631361827,
-0.3551032245,
-0.0173695236,
0.163755253,
0.4694016874,
0.2431718409,
0.6425555944,
0.6637193561,
-0.5354012847,
-0.1311528385,
0.2468073815,
-0.1281128079,
0.7314119935,
-0.524407804,
0.0220993981,
-0.1855928153,
0.0820835382,
-0.9504782557,
0.1533336043,
0.2267984599,
-0.2519195378,
0.5276678801,
-0.3372319937,
-0.0871167108,
0.1107668504,
-0.098802954,
0.7498217225,
0.3236429095,
-0.5162400603,
0.8730589747,
0.0268897638,
0.0186922178,
-0.6632521152,
-1.085164547,
0.0332547128,
-0.1447491795,
-0.322389245,
0.1533994675,
-0.1352977306,
-0.0379571877,
0.1904259473,
-0.2693351209,
-0.2042672336,
0.062295422,
0.1524452716,
0.3611357808,
-0.5001158118,
-0.1281376332,
0.0581923723,
-0.1873149723,
0.0264576171,
-0.176849246,
0.3369258642,
-0.0841446668,
-0.2824822664,
-0.3671569824,
0.1255035996,
0.5594806671,
0.0512547344,
0.8631064296,
0.7885589004,
-0.1169889495,
0.0694654509,
-0.4972597659,
0.1239091456,
-0.4867971539,
0.4445270002,
-0.4861931205,
-0.859264791,
0.4643480182,
0.256252259,
0.1951287687,
0.4081615508,
0.4969739616,
0.2805587351,
0.478861779,
0.7023880482,
-0.2816630304,
0.6532229185,
-0.0026650287,
0.3698759675,
-1.0494550467,
-0.0577778481,
-0.4137392044,
-0.4545590281,
-0.4036888778,
-0.3725746274,
-0.3770391047,
0.0727954954,
0.0937529877,
0.7439564466,
-0.041447714,
0.4239304364,
0.1644013375,
-0.3433865309,
0.2878897786,
-0.0287744123,
0.0494664907,
0.0099348528,
-0.9956828952,
0.129788518,
0.9910342693,
-0.0127859442,
0.5498251915,
0.2365690023,
0.4769227207,
-0.2509548366,
0.2294689268,
-0.8843579292,
0.3026639521,
-0.4684426785,
-0.6445222497,
-0.2089657784,
-0.439227432,
-1.0514179468,
0.5352325439,
-0.0925691724,
-0.6849076748,
0.6427900791,
-0.0213185549,
-0.1643591374,
0.4455227852,
-0.7361148,
1.0375851393,
-0.1475794762,
-0.385424614,
-0.1633434743,
-0.2114869356,
0.1930828393,
-0.3392185867,
0.507106185,
-0.1508651674,
0.1367949843,
0.6193560362,
0.1532199681,
0.7113134861,
-0.1804702282,
-0.0274318308,
-0.0491357446,
0.2874861062,
0.2481398582,
-0.1200224385,
-0.4105210304,
0.5032013655,
-0.3671147525,
-0.7908915877,
-0.5664185286,
0.708247602,
-0.8091154099,
-0.6783075333,
-0.2281657308,
-1.0151914358,
-0.0959195122,
0.4507177174,
-0.157528013,
0.3849153817,
-0.2202278078,
0.1906439513,
0.276729852,
-0.2418315709,
0.7516012788,
0.9544659853,
-0.1681104004,
-0.067401737,
1.1384818554,
0.0668976903,
0.7253026366,
0.5479991436,
0.1522288918,
0.0831461772,
-0.8219554424,
-0.819001615,
0.3380163014,
-0.6620208025,
0.192100659,
-0.587261498,
-0.2147987932,
-0.4054074287,
-0.5813170075,
-0.3851724565,
-0.3021633327,
-0.2836126983,
-0.1608488858,
0.1379098594,
0.6068950891,
-0.1556043178,
0.296520263,
-0.8721157312,
0.3410544991,
0.4152147174,
0.300459981,
-0.0247492399,
-0.6400306821,
-0.5503227115,
-0.0973528996,
0.2008325756,
-0.3798882961,
0.268063426,
0.5488188863,
0.8722743392,
0.4128288031,
-0.1180759296,
0.9203620553,
-0.6222814322,
0.5596019626,
0.1382330805,
-0.8823177814,
0.1524817795,
-0.2607383728,
0.9647245407,
0.8313532472,
0.3291323185,
-0.6891729236,
-0.3068170547,
-0.0968389064,
-0.7662135363,
0.9995891452,
-0.0556345582,
0.3397424221,
0.0658544973,
0.1647822261,
0.3747675121,
-0.0360778458,
-0.7501745224,
-0.349817276,
-0.1790023595,
0.1317585707,
-0.4557829201,
0.0135144861,
0.2272010595,
-0.3336322308,
0.5535008907,
-0.3797896504,
-0.0491318591,
0.0538499579,
-0.5836844444,
-0.4254485369,
0.5344231725,
0.5089254975,
0.6396936178,
-0.1887542605,
0.0028377285,
0.4990725517,
-0.3330209553,
0.0286788289,
0.1560248137,
-0.2351174951,
0.2632699609,
0.4908266068,
0.9901496768,
0.6158199906,
-0.5847052336,
0.1589433849,
-0.2207355946,
-0.2902883589,
0.1402527392,
0.0346151963,
0.1398688853,
-0.0788517743,
0.2557530403,
0.4633114934,
0.0017727432,
-0.7364673615,
0.1705524474,
0.537899673,
-0.8717524409,
-0.6242795587,
0.3319306076,
0.1130542159,
-0.2983025312,
0.3751261234,
0.1141802967,
-0.4672736228,
0.4479039311,
0.7615905404,
0.7650396228,
-0.582676053,
0.0180874597,
0.4136713743,
0.3923199177,
0.2775424123,
-0.1639885306,
-0.0569417588,
-0.8586475253,
-0.751311183,
-0.5693867803,
-0.2773606479,
-0.2177235335,
-0.7583335638,
0.247149989,
-0.011975199,
0.4204718173,
0.0092368862,
-0.2857835591,
-0.9928501844,
0.0243015718,
0.3285838068,
0.7780176997,
-1.0791578293,
1.1893326044,
0.6464386582,
0.052481994,
-0.5760993361,
-0.1818953305,
0.0033422357,
-0.8732719421,
0.377027452,
0.1925136745,
0.1453561932,
-0.1160024628,
0.619395256,
-0.7835568786,
0.9053840637,
0.4394777715,
-0.6901111603,
-0.0710565746,
0.6120619774,
0.5051919222,
-0.3287364841,
0.4627143741,
0.6743981838,
0.5299080014,
0.1195148379,
-1.1341228485,
0.3244834244,
-0.2207432687,
-0.182274282,
0.2402561307,
-0.3187917471,
0.8413307071,
0.0590716153,
-0.1366192698,
-0.3239625692,
0.3606185615,
-0.0881746039,
0.1326311082,
0.5265917778,
0.559179306,
0.1539039463,
0.1941503137,
0.9327924252,
-0.2270962149,
0.0924838036,
1.0942733288,
-0.2863458991,
0.9220869541,
0.6462435126,
-0.0809595734,
0.5592076182,
0.0758495927,
0.0578827113,
0.4718687236,
-0.1283593029,
-0.150960207,
-0.0894854218,
-0.2053123862,
-0.3698410392,
0.3331835568,
0.2949648201,
-0.1351447403,
-0.4849063456,
0.0718795508,
0.0315363929,
-0.1712264568,
-0.2002930492,
0.9905793667,
0.0552351139,
-0.8009387255,
0.7013391852,
-0.4411887825,
0.9597972035,
-0.5309301615,
0.152481094,
-0.2810040116,
0.3404355347,
-0.4455233514,
-0.6516133547,
0.8343821764,
-0.2915814221,
-0.1633835584,
-0.234035939,
0.7613658905,
-0.5794532895,
-0.6667516828,
0.8427919149,
0.7064329386,
-0.0186752081,
0.0302871019,
-0.5665744543,
-0.0891283378,
0.1015254259,
-0.1743394434,
0.8567211628,
0.3616358042,
0.2681513131,
0.2534680068,
0.8453366756,
0.0148699041,
0.1619225293,
-0.024890516,
0.7839069963,
-0.5020121932,
0.0210302006,
-0.9620459676,
0.6816136241,
0.269323647,
-0.1023128852,
0.9549382925,
0.6057255268,
1.050797224,
0.008704422,
0.8232059479,
-0.0666887313,
-0.1616109312,
-0.243797645,
0.8012303114,
-0.7226179242,
0.1763059646,
-0.151529178,
-0.9972938299,
-0.4574955404,
0.1772223413,
-0.4017218351,
-0.3714274764,
0.6025437713,
0.5007506609,
-0.2625511885,
-0.3043448031,
0.7292999029,
0.1310116947,
0.4748769701,
0.6283518672,
0.3160017729,
-0.5856046081,
0.7722977996,
-0.5810839534,
0.0320309848,
-0.2714774907,
-0.7967912555,
-1.1507754326,
-0.2841125727,
-0.300287962,
0.0653342828,
0.1630293876,
0.4570972025,
0.6220595241,
-1.0797666311,
-0.5774101019,
-0.0556413792,
0.3676837981,
-0.2881354988,
-0.2843634784,
0.1227285266,
-0.4851219952,
-0.870190084,
0.6720926762,
0.485165596,
-0.2749560177,
0.0404066034,
-0.0953943059,
-0.3987354636,
0.0559735708,
0.6181249619,
0.5527016521,
-0.8094837666,
-0.2933185995,
0.2053982168,
0.2297056019,
0.3451562226,
0.7335921526,
-1.0487985611,
0.7209694386,
0.4940358102,
0.875880003,
0.3928975761,
-0.3303923607,
0.9514892101,
-0.4871199429,
0.3822705448,
-0.1974999607,
0.5284311175,
0.3654156625,
-0.2015928775,
0.384608835,
-0.03452399,
-0.3714282513,
-0.6431863904,
-0.0183549095,
-0.8705379963,
-0.4701863527,
1.0650957823,
-0.2967496216,
-0.3303804398,
-0.4152401388,
0.0360664986,
0.198108092,
-0.2801751196,
0.4436465502,
0.6144533157,
-0.0939467922,
-0.3398015201,
-0.6118774414,
0.1525401473,
0.7401047945,
-0.6375945807,
-0.0000126773,
0.0416867957,
0.4749426544,
0.2653216422,
0.414680928,
0.2243652344,
0.3673764765,
-0.0937897637,
0.1264431924,
-0.0385802463,
-0.0705266371,
-0.9270170331,
-0.0838445351,
0.0581635721,
0.0193744674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00898v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00898v1
|
An Early Categorization of Prompt Injection Attacks on Large Language Models
| 2024-01-31T19:52:00 | 2024-01-31T19:52:00 |
Sippo Rossi, Alisia Marianne Michel, Raghava Rao Mukkamala, Jason Bennett Thatcher
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models and AI chatbots have been at the forefront of
democratizing artificial intelligence. However, the releases of ChatGPT and
other similar tools have been followed by growing concerns regarding the
difficulty of controlling large language models and their outputs. Currently,
we are witnessing a cat-and-mouse game where users attempt to misuse the models
with a novel attack called prompt injections. In contrast, the developers
attempt to discover the vulnerabilities and block the attacks simultaneously.
In this paper, we provide an overview of these emergent threats and present a
categorization of prompt injections, which can guide future research on prompt
injections and act as a checklist of vulnerabilities in the development of LLM
interfaces. Moreover, based on previous literature and our own empirical
research, we discuss the implications of prompt injections to LLM end users,
developers, and researchers.
|
[
-0.340690583,
-1.2884497643,
0.5966635346,
0.1006941274,
0.1444608122,
0.1717621982,
0.0961208045,
-0.5229251385,
-0.2942949235,
0.7811912298,
-0.4598921239,
-0.28093642,
-0.7198320627,
0.0691589043,
-0.5201805234,
0.7891469598,
0.1006298363,
-0.1121257469,
-0.1640698314,
0.357747972,
-0.7056794167,
-0.8132584095,
-0.8900432587,
-0.0837157592,
0.7654767036,
0.0285638757,
0.8978033662,
0.2794809341,
0.6566384435,
0.4100200832,
-0.1074118614,
-0.2669354677,
-0.0909167454,
0.175634563,
0.0165845118,
-0.6792865396,
-0.1929277033,
0.0262402836,
0.1411777437,
0.5560190678,
0.0177492257,
-0.0814370736,
-0.093014285,
0.1810867637,
-0.3926721811,
-0.1067495123,
-0.5973024964,
0.211008355,
-0.4596058428,
-0.3083334863,
-0.7611969709,
-0.2239586115,
0.0382238105,
-0.2752235234,
-0.2320620865,
0.3405686617,
0.5503035188,
0.1980665028,
-0.4703607559,
-0.4973538518,
-0.4431539774,
0.4171143472,
-0.5145225525,
0.0043638325,
0.0605108365,
0.7562310696,
-0.9614747763,
-0.5304533243,
-0.5253807902,
-0.3837595284,
-0.1502821743,
-0.3250520527,
-0.6776425838,
0.3998675644,
0.3621582687,
0.0360073484,
-0.6845908165,
0.6166135073,
-0.1716736555,
-0.2601550817,
0.4870396256,
0.3796082735,
1.0326292515,
-0.2101746053,
-0.566598177,
0.3851742744,
-0.9606475234,
0.1291833371,
0.6414546371,
0.3629565835,
-0.191381067,
0.698376596,
-0.0245140102,
0.8097881079,
-0.0569374375,
0.016745856,
-0.288734436,
-0.2380992174,
-0.0663544685,
-0.1607499421,
1.0360707045,
0.2280716747,
0.3118085265,
0.0856877267,
-0.306712836,
-0.3451842368,
0.0590882115,
-0.5391103625,
-0.1785103828,
0.4252829254,
-0.2440606803,
-0.4282025397,
-0.2108705193,
-0.6748583913,
-0.867316246,
0.149988085,
0.2889210582,
-0.0629248619,
-0.1951050609,
-0.0040144408,
0.0069754566,
0.253906846,
0.4611655176,
-0.6021214128,
0.0817060694,
0.9421622753,
0.696326077,
-0.3158504665,
-0.1385346502,
-0.5518946052,
-0.0974201337,
-0.081163995,
0.9277223945,
-0.5151139498,
-0.6962752938,
0.2843439281,
-0.0396489911,
0.33399266,
-0.4305976331,
0.163099736,
-0.5982615352,
0.4074486494,
0.1222079322,
-0.3602434099,
0.0286832321,
0.2725622058,
-0.3522439897,
0.6574337482,
-0.0246677306,
-0.6524646282,
0.0639315099,
-0.4889898002,
-0.2134279758,
0.3980317712,
-0.197644338,
0.0735048577,
-0.1167583764,
-0.0271629486,
0.6397694349,
-0.316509515,
0.433742255,
-0.1844878197,
-0.045146849,
0.5915848017,
-0.4587243497,
1.0744988918,
0.2574370205,
0.0118625173,
0.3421429694,
-0.5573153496,
-0.1743105352,
-0.1223864406,
-0.1209408492,
-0.1937895566,
-0.0078831725,
-0.2198141962,
0.2849215865,
0.3089141548,
-0.1746606231,
0.3044942319,
-0.3494414985,
0.7184343338,
0.8955836892,
0.4381036162,
0.3571249247,
-0.1390791535,
0.7839211226,
0.1895170361,
0.6110383272,
-0.6289954185,
-0.8315271735,
-0.4104188979,
-0.4323575199,
0.1097321808,
0.9413802624,
-0.9074524045,
0.4979914725,
0.2787680328,
-0.8034018278,
-0.1913323104,
-0.0362521261,
0.2979109287,
0.2224278897,
0.1541791111,
0.1694672257,
-0.2055985928,
-0.9264121056,
-0.2775683403,
-0.4586523473,
-0.3108410239,
0.3192230761,
0.3119678199,
-0.3254498541,
0.8411819935,
-0.3656347096,
0.1490531266,
-0.2200576067,
0.0956775993,
0.4048243165,
0.6192839146,
0.381164223,
-0.4290918708,
-0.3832566142,
0.1322151423,
-0.5867441893,
-0.3539068699,
-0.3741648793,
-0.1430115998,
-0.1978252679,
0.7890330553,
-0.8926083446,
0.3367158473,
0.2252547592,
-0.2410824746,
0.5783957243,
0.0267878417,
-0.032104101,
-0.8931604028,
-0.1089326143,
-0.0709961951,
0.0023917283,
-1.0471651554,
0.2999902368,
-0.080211401,
-0.2868769765,
-1.0316333771,
0.9222232103,
-0.271861732,
0.0986137986,
-0.0858952627,
-0.0394476354,
-0.0929445326,
0.0897987932,
-0.3513899446,
1.0933492184,
0.6964304447,
-0.6372199059,
0.4811302722,
0.1398486346,
-0.2171586305,
0.28264606,
-0.9266574383,
0.158399418,
0.1154250279,
0.3434995115,
-1.0946625471,
-0.3028840721,
0.6241391301,
-0.605902791,
0.4404937625,
0.0274934974,
-0.4878723025,
-0.3517128229,
-0.2234487236,
0.220323801,
0.5916727781,
-0.4747993648,
0.4091370404,
0.2835884988,
-0.2692975104,
-0.7031832933,
-0.4576922953,
0.3082022965,
-0.3969325125,
-0.6851561069,
-0.1318583935,
-0.0374535099,
-0.4732552469,
-0.4275620282,
0.469889015,
-0.090876475,
0.5670261383,
0.2948179841,
0.2965514958,
-0.047625538,
-0.0970107317,
-0.1802330762,
-0.2524363995,
0.170443967,
0.305481106,
0.6226768494,
0.3082200289,
-0.6906802654,
-0.5581106544,
0.4583258927,
0.3402470052,
-0.011853449,
0.5121027827,
0.1476530582,
-0.1556752324,
0.0657964945,
-0.625108242,
-0.2127721161,
-0.5470504165,
0.4295242727,
-0.2867210507,
-0.9369676113,
0.6823157072,
-0.1206231639,
0.1877338439,
0.2534688413,
0.4255050123,
0.010642264,
1.1971678734,
0.5021674633,
0.0944538638,
0.5308439136,
0.369825542,
0.3571172357,
-0.4539987445,
-0.3392497599,
-0.8067910075,
0.110482648,
-0.7470549941,
-0.4368419945,
0.1952741146,
0.0872402489,
-0.3162529469,
0.2477663457,
-0.4148938954,
0.5862928629,
0.4945634902,
-0.2774373889,
0.1015392616,
-0.3759696484,
0.1074727848,
0.2460865378,
-0.6211602092,
-0.6165195107,
0.8526036739,
0.4654481411,
0.9088721871,
0.0868370235,
0.4683946669,
0.5175477266,
0.1450977176,
-0.8389914632,
0.8118068576,
0.1657231599,
-0.5342183113,
-0.1090141609,
-0.1795101911,
-1.208147049,
-0.0167370718,
-0.0801512599,
-0.7767532468,
0.1420314163,
-0.0416241623,
-0.5525863767,
0.1095152795,
-1.0234761238,
0.7960175276,
-0.3100168407,
-0.1382357031,
0.2568211854,
-0.7122529745,
0.6537975073,
-0.0977973714,
0.28317222,
-0.248970896,
-0.1794186682,
0.231645003,
-0.3305174708,
1.0818200111,
0.0138273798,
-0.3151803613,
0.4674313366,
0.2651208341,
0.4437583685,
0.0746172071,
0.2392418832,
0.383000344,
-0.122325547,
-0.4216897786,
-0.4325143397,
0.4630934894,
-0.6095722914,
-1.1930010319,
-0.5283930898,
-0.2656186521,
0.0167123247,
0.1104292125,
0.1533326805,
0.2629028857,
-0.2358088344,
-0.322568953,
0.7662276626,
-0.9524276257,
0.5496678352,
0.4129408598,
-0.4334824681,
-0.1467157602,
0.8558560014,
-0.1315887421,
0.5646303892,
0.3205913007,
-0.0563065931,
-0.0496112518,
-0.8057056665,
-0.4167552888,
0.036798615,
-0.5348289013,
-0.4572044909,
-0.598939538,
-0.339101553,
-0.3426822126,
-0.2238842696,
0.0661245584,
-0.1237854362,
-0.384286195,
0.1407138109,
0.4112875164,
0.7419172525,
0.2030121684,
0.7804281116,
-0.8851007819,
-0.0343457349,
0.3476299644,
0.0537955947,
-0.1416257173,
-0.1295595765,
0.1624978185,
-0.2766644955,
-0.1857416779,
-1.0202003717,
0.1980531812,
-0.1939856559,
0.6195600033,
0.6256282926,
-0.0692590475,
0.2533111274,
-0.8155542612,
1.1995443106,
0.4168956578,
-0.6366360188,
0.5830414891,
-0.2838710546,
0.2818851173,
0.1266543269,
0.3988038599,
-0.8205599189,
-0.5158991218,
-0.3973929286,
-0.7601532936,
0.4543887377,
-0.0516657904,
0.447178334,
-0.4690418839,
0.1173125654,
0.31588009,
0.2564052045,
-0.4004034102,
-0.1799021065,
0.2347521782,
0.1103910953,
0.183606565,
-0.4188502133,
-0.0292136483,
0.1259640008,
0.3380283713,
0.1981755942,
0.1482180506,
-0.1885233372,
-0.0808270276,
0.1584746987,
0.4397067726,
0.5399308205,
0.2843967974,
0.2420876175,
0.3550313413,
-0.1767621934,
-0.2589614987,
0.268658787,
-0.0466237105,
-0.3233480453,
-0.1645122021,
0.5173717141,
0.6859393716,
0.021471994,
-0.942838788,
0.5866422057,
0.0164252985,
0.3579193056,
-0.42896384,
0.3114456236,
-0.3582524955,
0.3200877011,
0.2354012579,
0.044692874,
0.1786476523,
-0.4949803352,
0.0622349307,
0.7277972698,
-0.3460709155,
-0.3477805853,
0.3176938891,
0.2884691358,
-0.6629830599,
0.3087290823,
0.0539160296,
-0.5015678406,
0.6745696068,
0.2272345126,
0.8832504749,
-0.6065962315,
0.1235764325,
0.3186915517,
0.4241152704,
0.2098108083,
0.0508186445,
0.2889945507,
-0.5614533424,
-0.3471276164,
-0.2738195062,
-0.4376983643,
0.0839361027,
-0.1447474211,
0.5562052727,
-0.5613466501,
-0.2798387706,
0.1126232967,
-0.3851301074,
-0.5500987172,
-0.463866055,
0.0489443019,
1.0123989582,
-0.5910797715,
0.3976631463,
0.4523738325,
-0.3052800298,
-0.2663377225,
-0.3093309402,
0.1728771925,
-1.0081803799,
0.7422970533,
0.1410589814,
0.3947612643,
-0.0568539463,
-0.6897652745,
-0.5553432107,
0.5428789854,
0.0872134566,
-0.3925602734,
-0.1327738315,
0.2732297778,
0.3159255087,
-0.3003278971,
0.5392127633,
0.5158225894,
0.500507772,
-0.1050228626,
-0.7921600938,
0.0706444681,
-0.0208372902,
0.0835481286,
0.2140003443,
-0.4083380699,
0.8380126357,
-0.1519776732,
-0.4831339419,
0.1634688824,
0.4874606431,
0.0629692674,
0.1246344745,
0.3258243203,
0.0126677109,
0.535405457,
-0.093865782,
1.1060590744,
-0.0321740136,
-0.3723548353,
0.8948861957,
-0.286801815,
0.6549381614,
0.6468957067,
-0.4443415999,
0.0897941068,
0.9286804199,
-0.0111933611,
0.1630779952,
0.5795122385,
-0.4061016738,
-0.0193563737,
-0.3325754106,
-0.5523748398,
0.1635169089,
0.670707643,
0.0693744048,
-0.2423614562,
0.3392708302,
0.3332145214,
-0.1812843978,
-0.2252117693,
0.9581915736,
0.0145134041,
-0.3384836018,
0.3068365753,
-0.156088233,
0.7819778323,
-0.5526203513,
-0.0335161276,
-0.3372225165,
-0.3826990128,
-0.0318038203,
-0.9611910582,
-0.095550105,
0.0166081376,
0.1543062627,
-0.0702412724,
0.6101367474,
-0.2213546783,
-0.0822474137,
0.047178071,
0.6952303648,
0.2600831985,
-0.0588538535,
-0.7283173203,
0.1928552836,
-0.1371057928,
-0.3597792387,
0.454960525,
0.538136065,
-0.2548812628,
0.9720139503,
0.7365069985,
-0.0664039776,
0.3544399142,
-0.2533391714,
0.7987143397,
-0.47031039,
-0.097772412,
-1.1975033283,
0.4683642387,
-0.0038262759,
-0.1754752845,
0.812430799,
0.2308304459,
0.3166824281,
0.097638987,
0.6396571398,
-0.0528315119,
0.3175748885,
-0.4280793071,
0.6227138042,
-0.2506676614,
0.4650705159,
-0.1913696676,
-0.6364825964,
-0.3673061728,
-0.1178121492,
-0.1887747943,
-0.089180097,
0.4947710037,
0.9119400978,
0.2879941463,
-0.2735885978,
0.4596074522,
0.3778057396,
0.5966442227,
0.5768494606,
1.3159325123,
0.0221694075,
0.3364690244,
-0.0471572466,
-0.3525185287,
-0.3751643002,
-0.9047753811,
-1.1960017681,
-0.4630829692,
-0.1948894858,
-0.4293361604,
0.0627058744,
0.7844797969,
0.2153600454,
-0.8138380051,
-0.060332574,
-0.0116118258,
0.510448277,
0.287986815,
-0.2535259128,
0.1384094656,
-0.3947239816,
-0.6518144608,
0.35756284,
0.3123793602,
0.4480848908,
-0.7311227918,
0.2522287369,
-0.1653119624,
0.1755664796,
0.5090193152,
0.5596981049,
-0.9764937162,
-0.4317437112,
-0.0039982479,
-0.2543372214,
-0.1313882321,
0.7586867213,
-0.653891325,
0.2807178795,
0.569157958,
0.9440800548,
-0.4636818171,
-0.3326558769,
0.7197163701,
-0.5256502628,
0.3950408995,
0.089244999,
0.2105752826,
0.1648173332,
-0.7158296108,
0.3691543043,
-0.048301667,
-0.4096000493,
-1.1491234303,
0.7343488932,
-0.9394349456,
-0.2247938365,
1.0711145401,
-0.1543497443,
-0.3893769979,
-0.3151162565,
-0.5337460041,
-0.0828418657,
-0.4706134796,
0.6785292625,
0.8334493041,
0.0060807425,
-0.2443024218,
-1.0170384645,
0.6135465503,
0.0277304593,
-1.0538306236,
0.0611382201,
0.5025860071,
-0.2443315536,
0.0839048177,
0.4049110711,
-0.0877638385,
0.2382140309,
-0.1691419929,
0.1909743845,
0.0323112682,
-0.2176340371,
-0.2927868962,
0.2264542431,
0.1783100218,
0.1361723989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00143v1
|
Making a Long Story Short in Conversation Modeling
| 2024-01-31T19:48:58 | 2024-01-31T19:48:58 |
Yufei Tao, Tiernan Mines, Ameeta Agrawal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Conversation systems accommodate diverse users with unique personalities and
distinct writing styles. Within the domain of multi-turn dialogue modeling,
this work studies the impact of varied utterance lengths on the quality of
subsequent responses generated by conversation models. Using GPT-3 as the base
model, multiple dialogue datasets, and several metrics, we conduct a thorough
exploration of this aspect of conversational models. Our analysis sheds light
on the complex relationship between utterance lengths and the quality of
follow-up responses generated by dialogue systems. Empirical findings suggests
that, for certain types of conversations, utterance lengths can be reduced by
up to 72% without any noticeable difference in the quality of follow-up
responses.
|
[
-0.4843743742,
-0.6835786104,
1.0731155872,
0.1283435374,
-0.3143888712,
0.0841303542,
-0.1046386212,
-0.8476762176,
0.1967654079,
0.7410442233,
-0.514498055,
-0.2030333728,
-0.4528707266,
0.0230095312,
-0.4185446203,
1.2384734154,
0.281314671,
-0.2336339206,
0.084404029,
-0.2774894238,
-0.7715081573,
-0.7021638751,
-0.6273291707,
-0.2182266712,
0.6005333662,
0.3782757521,
1.2443979979,
0.1998411119,
0.4111883342,
0.1586049497,
-0.1250711679,
-0.1094664484,
-0.783131361,
0.3070050478,
0.2716871798,
-0.4506473839,
-0.3943639994,
-0.112831682,
0.6623964906,
0.8058277965,
-0.1398108453,
-0.0547445677,
0.219485268,
0.5720527172,
-0.0778022185,
-0.0546686836,
-0.1643167734,
-0.2193262428,
-0.157706514,
-0.0450898856,
-0.3734716773,
-0.3298709989,
0.7725133896,
-0.3303920031,
0.2659418583,
-0.0432282314,
0.7218173146,
-0.3152870238,
-0.4090867937,
-0.4578014612,
-1.1073248386,
0.7288414836,
-1.1126190424,
0.1109306961,
0.0680863485,
0.2970073819,
0.0716975257,
-0.3794001937,
-0.6809127331,
-0.5346113443,
-0.4791904986,
0.0636798367,
0.0349284559,
0.2807955742,
0.3152317405,
0.2780250907,
-0.5175700784,
0.0071259872,
-0.7292040586,
0.1534992009,
0.537737906,
0.7312748432,
0.1060087308,
-0.2716056705,
0.0036528239,
0.0760812312,
-0.7287517786,
0.1101708263,
0.7941431403,
0.3514143527,
-0.1221062839,
0.6931286454,
-0.3119733632,
0.7206784487,
-0.0726210326,
-0.3251439035,
-0.1194603294,
-0.6738305092,
-0.062904194,
-0.317399472,
0.855061233,
0.5817810893,
0.2629352212,
-0.0228227228,
-0.0512345657,
-0.0239439793,
0.0530138314,
-1.017313242,
-0.0351666696,
0.2305371016,
-0.5276803374,
-0.1157818958,
0.0630081296,
-0.6599332094,
-0.1195637509,
-0.4092231393,
0.1148399413,
-0.5513195992,
-0.0264120996,
0.3175985813,
0.0093741901,
0.2369700223,
0.3902519643,
-0.757483542,
0.5674271584,
0.5922944546,
1.1732798815,
-0.2760677338,
-0.213772431,
-0.2907701135,
0.0246948171,
-0.3258940876,
0.5706596375,
-0.739677906,
-1.1126508713,
-0.2540682852,
-0.1016227901,
0.1523635834,
-0.2293945998,
0.4764714539,
-0.3815133274,
0.5587098002,
-0.1615531445,
-0.4680346847,
-0.148350358,
-0.0766449422,
-0.5360693932,
0.298704356,
0.1461317092,
-0.5750883222,
0.1967372894,
-0.639736414,
-0.6725836396,
0.0201964341,
0.0001872098,
-0.4167185128,
0.3269336522,
0.0482836291,
0.3536030352,
-0.297978133,
0.1351551563,
-0.4581541419,
-0.4293419719,
0.3852763474,
-0.5295176506,
0.3941037953,
0.1591286361,
-0.0538182743,
0.086303778,
-0.8049651384,
-0.0186586529,
-0.1674666256,
-0.4178533256,
-0.0737752616,
0.0910709724,
-0.050607089,
0.2933628261,
-0.266902566,
-0.7629165053,
0.1422230154,
-0.32793504,
0.4109829068,
0.5549460649,
0.2474271208,
0.3094783425,
-0.6712223291,
0.551299274,
-0.1128482297,
0.2050231248,
-0.5650707483,
-0.6702571511,
-0.8351132274,
-0.0755289644,
0.0057273437,
0.4574958682,
-0.5512676835,
-0.0282742102,
-0.4506872892,
-0.3876379132,
-0.340172261,
-0.1808422059,
0.3801958859,
0.2754975855,
0.303548038,
-0.4461366832,
-0.1480287164,
-0.9567270875,
-0.404611975,
-0.4653030634,
-0.4312757552,
0.3581404686,
0.4090562761,
0.0776253864,
1.2243531942,
-0.6462704539,
-0.0205323622,
-0.295530647,
0.234598279,
0.2580996454,
0.2944147885,
0.5736759305,
-0.3390633166,
-0.6415354013,
-0.2326960266,
-0.2990319133,
0.1620034873,
-0.3672613502,
0.1979677528,
-0.0692944601,
-0.0298695564,
-1.009139657,
0.651868701,
0.4955037832,
-0.1848072857,
1.014236331,
0.0410655141,
0.4574160576,
-1.0014783144,
-0.2425611913,
-0.1657193005,
-0.0433230698,
-0.9532359242,
-0.4757699668,
-0.3567394912,
-0.4171953797,
-0.4806935787,
0.4137571156,
-0.4606920183,
-0.2401511669,
-0.2039504051,
-0.0369897895,
0.2752348185,
0.3980400264,
0.1425997019,
0.8807024956,
0.1573418677,
-0.719396472,
0.3974098861,
0.4629932344,
-0.4767239094,
0.8487916589,
-1.1051552296,
0.4873434901,
0.0811524391,
0.469091624,
-1.1061704159,
-0.3842712939,
-0.0085971784,
-0.6416815519,
-0.0677166432,
-0.2530573308,
-0.4446733594,
-0.6374986768,
0.0279253442,
0.1547602415,
0.4636815786,
-0.2114927918,
0.4640006125,
-0.2726593912,
-0.8826435208,
-0.0147802942,
-0.7735643983,
0.2504917383,
-0.3657472134,
-1.0433079004,
0.1940047294,
-0.2857473493,
-0.1561909169,
-0.4264973998,
0.2584385574,
-0.0082106702,
-0.1599706411,
0.1605056673,
0.080485791,
-0.1950629801,
0.2821126282,
-0.2043856382,
0.2025683671,
0.0381653868,
0.1129757538,
0.6181596518,
-0.3226907551,
-0.5692805052,
-0.7594809532,
0.9457279444,
0.8199243546,
0.0402494855,
0.853567183,
0.2373917401,
0.1087849736,
0.5480334163,
-0.4590126276,
-0.3461410999,
-0.4665808082,
0.4150480926,
-0.721709311,
-0.8426958919,
0.7975026369,
0.4727610648,
-0.0092046019,
0.2597640455,
0.4144008458,
0.0129012773,
1.3556251526,
0.7122808099,
0.0402698368,
0.5231626034,
0.2460805923,
0.612691462,
-0.7461972833,
-0.1561486423,
-0.4921524823,
0.0347942784,
-0.4967197776,
-0.0367107317,
0.1740065664,
-0.0728155971,
-0.1323545575,
0.2701253593,
-0.2758504748,
0.3994627297,
0.3750574589,
0.1371496022,
0.340383023,
-0.4945400059,
0.5135176778,
-0.0462534614,
-0.3662003577,
-0.578128159,
0.848428607,
0.464886874,
0.8823618889,
0.4614716172,
0.6277149916,
0.1858271658,
0.0730696097,
-0.805644989,
0.2927708328,
0.3414767981,
-0.4822395742,
-0.6916677952,
-0.4875253141,
-0.8762856126,
0.181143865,
0.1952829063,
-0.8318392634,
-0.0121423043,
-0.0574642681,
-0.9008384347,
0.1510547101,
-0.7088036537,
0.3726094663,
-0.2991186976,
-0.0335021131,
-0.1064250618,
-0.8297231793,
0.4242950678,
-0.0389197692,
0.0238523856,
-0.2904143333,
0.4200775325,
0.8717473149,
-0.6319146156,
0.6701316237,
0.0401072428,
-0.0645743981,
0.5823349953,
0.202395767,
0.5827586055,
0.2464200705,
0.2825617492,
-0.124180764,
0.0945483223,
-0.4822528958,
-0.5579759479,
0.5238312483,
-0.7054649591,
-0.7118166685,
-0.0846350119,
-0.4192424119,
-0.4836721718,
-0.0116984192,
0.2928523123,
0.5161408186,
-0.4065030217,
0.1361667663,
0.3838844895,
-0.2897885144,
0.5628390312,
0.4602154195,
-0.1312384903,
-0.2867451608,
0.4555643201,
0.167422682,
0.8998208046,
-0.0952135623,
0.0866846442,
-0.3203845322,
-0.5486986041,
-0.3323577642,
0.2899990082,
-0.6873119473,
0.0518090948,
-0.8189453483,
-0.0614990592,
-0.6053735614,
-0.1833271384,
-0.3798052371,
-0.3858683109,
-0.4813224673,
-0.2098961323,
0.3985480964,
1.1678874493,
0.183760196,
0.9946674109,
-1.0561994314,
0.2781791389,
0.5658331513,
0.4176900387,
0.0327450372,
-0.7217769623,
-0.142060414,
0.2599269152,
-0.3250516951,
-1.004275918,
0.4310048819,
0.3084401786,
0.3115203679,
0.2472796887,
-0.3261952102,
0.5754639506,
-0.52068609,
1.307464242,
0.8125707507,
-0.8077996969,
0.5054475665,
-0.7144697309,
0.8155671954,
0.3858219683,
0.2645286024,
-0.9872082472,
-0.2836131155,
-0.6535386443,
-0.744610548,
0.3869504333,
0.4280712008,
0.5298919082,
-0.0179220736,
0.057299301,
0.3694421947,
0.1410280466,
-0.4218524694,
-0.0736895055,
-0.235386759,
0.2502577603,
-0.127880156,
-0.6013792753,
-0.1263164729,
0.128304407,
0.3876779079,
-0.1051145345,
0.4758133292,
-0.0646234155,
-0.0620276891,
0.4112187326,
0.7009654045,
0.9286488891,
0.9038378596,
-0.3033976555,
-0.3740524352,
0.1755712628,
-0.2311870903,
0.0253683608,
-0.0517383032,
0.1932814717,
0.3636574447,
0.2538708746,
1.0503261089,
-0.1380132437,
-0.1476864368,
0.4261776209,
-0.1658162624,
-0.100727886,
0.0098235114,
-0.3381143808,
0.1381191611,
-0.0023747762,
0.430113107,
0.0503319614,
0.3786026835,
-0.6525884867,
0.2778032422,
0.034252841,
-0.5591439605,
-0.4657564759,
0.2675587535,
0.5617061853,
-0.3714802265,
0.7177176476,
0.2576732635,
-0.441826731,
0.5395717621,
0.3263656795,
0.6889059544,
-0.2715186775,
0.3539118469,
0.1437853426,
-0.1259396225,
-0.0317924805,
-0.2122134268,
0.0341522396,
-0.4167909622,
-0.5609419942,
-0.4478204846,
-0.6891806126,
0.2399385124,
-0.852286756,
0.1023393199,
-0.231785357,
-0.439380914,
0.0397227928,
-0.1712157726,
-0.7878339887,
0.1936971396,
0.0545076542,
0.286398232,
-0.6438581347,
0.3050801754,
-0.1687790602,
-0.4565224946,
-0.6454356313,
-0.1020326316,
-0.0750446543,
-0.3404847383,
0.4662808478,
0.4226617217,
-0.4218665063,
-0.3036178946,
-0.3970840871,
-0.9404422045,
0.6683142781,
-0.0026294384,
-0.7660195827,
-0.2078204751,
0.4636254013,
0.7764403224,
-0.5481646657,
0.6050264239,
0.9746719599,
0.1871933043,
0.0552027263,
-1.4174747467,
-0.207372725,
0.1732048988,
0.2398614585,
0.0800567344,
-0.8266537189,
0.8964990377,
-0.5018349886,
-0.3038043976,
0.6239594221,
0.6650426984,
0.1396031231,
-0.0737608746,
0.2481153309,
0.3148620427,
0.4191533625,
-0.1530000865,
1.1272011995,
-0.1227505356,
0.3472503424,
1.4145286083,
-0.3004468083,
0.575550139,
0.351364851,
-0.282986939,
0.6062884331,
0.7170838118,
0.2135333866,
0.5082588196,
0.4008209705,
-0.3045828342,
-0.1137871593,
0.1373546422,
-0.6365173459,
0.3520014584,
0.4252894223,
-0.2343644053,
0.0811974406,
0.1640542895,
0.2606541812,
-0.2418478131,
0.0289583839,
0.7441113591,
0.2452153414,
-0.8295494914,
0.4306963682,
-0.3362017572,
0.6384627819,
-0.3406921029,
0.0485419855,
-0.4474596977,
-0.0308422819,
-0.0332580395,
-1.0940489769,
0.2661091387,
-0.2421991229,
-0.414331615,
0.0251242109,
0.4219244123,
-0.3982160985,
-0.1431781352,
0.1698704958,
0.6025885344,
0.2142422944,
-0.06376791,
-0.4917330146,
0.0461493768,
0.0030007418,
-0.4736510813,
0.1333708018,
0.1977432072,
0.1390173584,
0.7546854615,
0.6609156132,
-0.2163728327,
0.0227343533,
0.3093675971,
0.7797110081,
-0.7187287211,
-0.6581667662,
-0.767080009,
0.5023536086,
-0.2738552094,
-0.376706183,
0.4955454469,
0.41901353,
0.5404894948,
-0.0584982112,
1.11952281,
0.2211737931,
1.0090938807,
-0.4568537772,
0.4476811886,
0.0086841956,
0.2973687649,
-0.2793598175,
-0.9646875858,
-0.0709571913,
0.1373412162,
-0.4766174853,
0.2230996192,
0.7106301785,
0.5107052922,
0.0755008459,
0.2409678698,
0.5353055,
-0.0192348212,
0.7982666492,
0.4457728267,
1.1573227644,
-0.2151981294,
0.8504327536,
0.0640170202,
0.0681914613,
-0.3545266092,
-0.4562446177,
-0.9297455549,
-0.415507853,
-0.0066486159,
-0.4784018397,
0.1847593635,
0.0185614377,
0.7795469761,
-0.672416091,
-0.2051517814,
0.1424488276,
-0.1295662224,
0.2147232592,
-0.3236860037,
0.0759717152,
-0.1155053824,
-0.4981044233,
0.1834476143,
0.2938044369,
0.5508564711,
-0.059928216,
-0.2315726578,
0.0634085536,
0.4884828031,
0.6918885112,
0.3053740859,
-0.9641115069,
-0.7960036993,
0.1085155383,
-0.0873939171,
0.3434321284,
1.0148924589,
-0.5511608124,
0.337228775,
0.3686601222,
0.2494819164,
0.7829703689,
0.1656422019,
0.9529098272,
-0.6626278162,
-0.1996890008,
0.423124522,
0.1787896901,
0.5642108321,
-0.5027304888,
0.2636734247,
0.1137252152,
-0.7310079336,
-0.5810588002,
0.5575565696,
-0.880584836,
-0.1171625927,
1.2684326172,
-0.3212201893,
0.2858421803,
-0.260032624,
-0.4333428442,
-0.0117528737,
-0.6195173264,
0.4378361404,
1.0918716192,
-0.7244887352,
-0.3043045998,
-0.440314889,
0.5260651112,
0.4391082227,
-0.7837284803,
0.0878150314,
0.706340313,
0.4506698847,
0.4720857441,
0.7068473101,
0.0803250447,
0.1386014372,
0.1177566573,
-0.3029055595,
0.3186428845,
-0.443495363,
0.0030601248,
0.2141518295,
0.0086629223,
-0.0249422081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00126v1
|
Common Sense Reasoning for Deep Fake Detection
| 2024-01-31T19:11:58 | 2024-01-31T19:11:58 |
Yue Zhang, Ben Colman, Ali Shahriyari, Gaurav Bharaj
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
State-of-the-art approaches rely on image-based features extracted via neural
networks for the deepfake detection binary classification. While these
approaches trained in the supervised sense extract likely fake features, they
may fall short in representing unnatural `non-physical' semantic facial
attributes -- blurry hairlines, double eyebrows, rigid eye pupils, or unnatural
skin shading. However, such facial attributes are generally easily perceived by
humans via common sense reasoning. Furthermore, image-based feature extraction
methods that provide visual explanation via saliency maps can be hard to be
interpreted by humans. To address these challenges, we propose the use of
common sense reasoning to model deepfake detection, and extend it to the
Deepfake Detection VQA (DD-VQA) task with the aim to model human intuition in
explaining the reason behind labeling an image as either real or fake. To this
end, we introduce a new dataset that provides answers to the questions related
to the authenticity of an image, along with its corresponding explanations. We
also propose a Vision and Language Transformer-based framework for the DD-VQA
task, incorporating text and image aware feature alignment formulations.
Finally, we evaluate our method on both the performance of deepfake detection
and the quality of the generated explanations. We hope that this task inspires
researchers to explore new avenues for enhancing language-based
interpretability and cross-modality applications in the realm of deepfake
detection.
|
[
-0.6446869373,
-0.911301434,
0.7891927958,
-0.0966365561,
-0.34862414,
-0.0222833473,
0.1937961578,
-0.72448349,
0.0627533421,
0.5935497284,
-0.6633704901,
-0.3480257988,
-0.4439095855,
-0.0037367281,
-0.4054916799,
0.506688118,
-0.0262700636,
-0.0515908599,
-0.1071560532,
-0.0712823644,
-0.3948592842,
-0.619463861,
-0.5200692415,
-0.1953870356,
0.2955201864,
0.3062569499,
0.8448079824,
0.3356707394,
0.1625496447,
0.3074299395,
0.1014824137,
0.3076797426,
-0.2389459163,
-0.2866390646,
-0.3334501088,
-0.0701346844,
-0.3811549842,
0.0952534452,
0.1648436487,
0.4922903776,
0.22629942,
-0.2731025815,
-0.4186371267,
0.4523513913,
-0.5703713298,
-0.1751505733,
-0.5653363466,
-0.0523875542,
-0.053121984,
0.2029372901,
-0.116134353,
-0.1368624568,
0.1007851437,
-0.8159130812,
0.5573634505,
-0.1962911636,
1.1036946774,
0.306232661,
-0.4043183625,
-0.011172438,
-0.5543992519,
0.736051023,
-0.460858345,
0.5363288522,
0.192063421,
0.5450509191,
-0.1707478464,
-0.7802760601,
-1.3815617561,
-0.0746643171,
-0.2078792751,
0.0626650676,
-0.3222975433,
-0.0118642161,
0.117831558,
0.5279737711,
-0.5282065272,
0.0160606466,
0.0064785136,
-0.4713021815,
0.7802034616,
-0.0027869353,
0.4420554936,
-0.0017098641,
-0.6247617006,
-0.0402431265,
-0.4259286523,
0.0916020423,
0.228475064,
-0.0633454323,
-0.0669817403,
0.261216253,
-0.6493090391,
0.5216058493,
0.2157182842,
0.2218108475,
0.2554565072,
-0.3533273041,
-0.4075125754,
-0.1306857914,
0.502555728,
0.6369236708,
0.7594975233,
-0.0520559587,
-0.2452020943,
0.3523248732,
0.2475837916,
-0.6237972379,
-0.1921798587,
0.1508181691,
-0.3508167863,
-0.6014010906,
0.1641015857,
-0.653879106,
-0.3768659532,
-0.691729188,
0.6316527128,
-0.4743807912,
-0.6943508983,
0.3645262122,
-0.2109690011,
0.2867411375,
0.7847206593,
-0.431322068,
0.3855633736,
0.8254639506,
0.5763337016,
-0.1193288416,
-0.2254119962,
-0.4599356949,
-0.2099363059,
-0.1883999258,
0.8801074028,
-0.2966223955,
0.0695335492,
-0.155679509,
0.3816948831,
0.2039210945,
-0.4629218578,
0.5043335557,
-0.5725461841,
0.0950674415,
-0.4144758582,
-0.359187156,
-0.4948334694,
0.2560835183,
-0.7526894808,
0.8196325302,
0.0176817253,
-0.2446581721,
0.8218739033,
-0.5283287764,
-0.6626868844,
0.2217328697,
-0.149482578,
-0.2637712359,
0.2409168333,
0.3942308724,
0.6918094754,
0.0210214499,
0.3845496178,
-0.3905421793,
-0.5830013752,
0.5022367239,
-0.9227611423,
0.9394135475,
0.2691586912,
-0.7055050731,
-0.2736672759,
-0.6974209547,
-0.1241971031,
0.1372688413,
-0.0155847128,
-0.2674076557,
-0.3037482798,
0.1910292059,
0.096319139,
0.0546823628,
-0.5114517212,
-0.0315005556,
-0.4011158347,
0.1305374354,
0.6119568944,
0.076590918,
0.387365371,
-0.036099229,
0.0649130866,
0.4458419383,
0.3054294586,
-0.1163072139,
-0.5578954816,
-0.5130406022,
-0.6185039878,
0.1106743142,
0.4603386223,
-0.8127727509,
0.3688628078,
-0.1715169996,
-0.1065386683,
-0.4430763423,
0.0684958473,
0.439242065,
0.6694704294,
0.6099793315,
-0.4784522355,
-0.2468565404,
-1.0757659674,
-0.5692269802,
0.1861825138,
0.0304897893,
0.1266548187,
0.7103270888,
-0.2329826802,
0.9131342769,
-0.2658634186,
-0.1040734798,
0.1289326102,
0.3266257048,
-0.0456585474,
0.4681616127,
0.5661879182,
-1.3507982492,
-0.1482505351,
-0.1039242223,
-0.5804717541,
-0.1370857358,
-0.2639750838,
0.046887245,
0.572722733,
0.4395367205,
-0.7365260124,
0.8860783577,
0.2159366459,
-0.5069254637,
0.722646296,
0.4048126638,
0.535649538,
-0.6115328074,
0.0921632871,
0.2117110342,
-0.3840156198,
-0.6743980646,
0.099217318,
-0.318525672,
0.0347043686,
-0.6624847651,
0.8660030365,
-0.1828717589,
-0.1229397357,
-0.2801370621,
-0.2398755103,
0.4144001603,
0.3258527219,
0.3102892935,
0.6116234064,
0.3627156317,
-0.4362272322,
0.4657387435,
-0.0680970028,
-0.2952334583,
0.8668273091,
-0.6055075526,
0.2294387817,
-0.0171516947,
0.2311982512,
-1.1694434881,
-0.6415507793,
0.5449393988,
-0.7694399953,
0.1800453067,
-0.377353996,
-0.6116064191,
-0.2099820524,
0.1659475863,
0.28616032,
0.3217173517,
-0.8732124567,
0.6410605907,
-0.0550500229,
0.4863759577,
-0.7262750864,
-0.7383267879,
0.128935352,
0.0192444045,
-0.9370105863,
0.4265532494,
0.0805421174,
-0.4332738221,
0.142576009,
-0.393371582,
-0.5167556405,
0.5063577294,
0.4366534054,
0.1442361623,
-0.2142994404,
-0.0263425857,
0.1231116652,
-0.2549643219,
0.0781007558,
0.1252871156,
0.1919994354,
-0.4267661273,
-0.4542916119,
-0.653660953,
0.5006341338,
0.8585227132,
0.0475796424,
0.5353389382,
0.7476997375,
-0.572465539,
-0.1823663712,
-0.6324130893,
-0.4013230205,
-0.4874314964,
0.0256400667,
-0.4997324347,
-0.9251829982,
0.373712182,
-0.3961230516,
-0.3621192276,
0.28652668,
0.5333646536,
-0.336658746,
1.0597625971,
0.2596580982,
0.1851396412,
0.0408299714,
-0.0323955119,
0.1746262908,
-0.0868914351,
-0.2432088256,
-0.0515364818,
-0.3017557561,
-0.0712943897,
-0.5947855115,
-0.050520774,
0.1777956933,
-0.3760636449,
0.0713241026,
-0.696552217,
0.6872709394,
0.6547673345,
0.3614290357,
0.2698819637,
0.2576901615,
-0.0581061728,
-0.0850472003,
-0.1603661031,
-0.4775952995,
0.4364357591,
0.3509755731,
0.3093996048,
0.1340766847,
0.507311523,
0.3743838072,
0.1407340765,
-0.9168461561,
0.5901248455,
-0.2320154756,
-1.061250329,
-0.3190398812,
-0.0999765992,
-0.4538607597,
-0.0253637657,
-0.404096514,
-0.4937401116,
0.4444906414,
0.3217974901,
-0.3176254034,
0.0538069829,
-0.8410977721,
0.9486591816,
-0.3844840825,
-0.3348752856,
-0.2474536449,
-0.5755824447,
0.6126808524,
0.015106393,
0.2135932893,
0.0176585615,
0.1542980224,
0.3508360088,
-0.4351581931,
1.2682361603,
-0.4317694306,
0.1389995664,
0.2884791493,
0.3535336852,
0.1425802112,
0.1349647939,
0.1550049186,
0.6157363653,
-0.1846120954,
-0.4884547889,
-0.839191854,
0.519718945,
-0.4821570814,
-0.6110240221,
-0.3801551163,
-0.1923438907,
-0.0897895098,
0.2255895883,
0.2903097272,
0.0966907069,
-0.2222338319,
0.0377090573,
0.7368159294,
-0.2463168353,
0.2912850082,
0.3055452108,
-0.0122669367,
-0.358964026,
0.7622685432,
-0.0910424292,
0.1031538323,
0.0252970587,
0.1094758958,
-0.1929709911,
-0.3947999477,
-0.4493371844,
-0.0045152837,
-0.7571821213,
0.0244990345,
-0.3018086553,
-0.1802607626,
-0.3430368006,
-0.4754009545,
-0.3686619997,
-0.4223597944,
-0.3157872856,
0.084694311,
0.6418421268,
0.3195761442,
-0.4007461965,
0.3651328683,
-0.4518887401,
0.9544883966,
0.6839650869,
0.4599842131,
-0.1153055057,
-0.5212327838,
-0.005188188,
0.0948237181,
-0.0307536144,
-0.8656207323,
0.2664897442,
-0.071837306,
0.6111993194,
0.4750589728,
-0.0524240993,
0.5960737467,
-0.1612841934,
0.728112936,
0.2635693252,
-1.230106473,
0.5401285887,
-0.1607350409,
-0.0213667434,
0.5582811236,
0.6264904141,
-0.2833975554,
0.0373761505,
-0.6988242865,
-0.5163904428,
0.215638712,
0.2353190631,
0.1952887774,
0.0482764803,
0.4114009738,
0.1870177686,
0.1346689016,
-0.7937493324,
-0.1502519399,
-0.6816315651,
-0.1222022027,
0.3143522739,
0.0027559379,
-0.3310753405,
-0.5257232785,
0.315712899,
-0.4095881283,
0.2756338716,
0.425496459,
-0.2147648335,
-0.028419612,
0.0769909993,
0.6264464855,
0.3797351718,
0.0080912346,
0.3027653098,
0.007652706,
-0.4551590979,
0.0541222058,
0.0755180344,
-0.1150235981,
0.1217963845,
0.4170706868,
0.5145560503,
0.1253641993,
-0.439213872,
0.8623520136,
-0.0150144733,
-0.5226719975,
-0.3807879388,
0.1597785056,
0.0597934201,
0.3516876996,
0.5702910423,
0.4069876969,
0.3353101611,
-0.5775343776,
0.6692593098,
0.3787662387,
-0.3079346418,
-0.3947587609,
0.2869060934,
0.1872621328,
-0.1501131505,
0.4482422769,
-0.1457231045,
-0.9191904664,
0.6640921831,
0.1066365987,
0.6972141862,
-0.1039389893,
0.3438013792,
0.1634185463,
0.4308271706,
-0.043738436,
0.3936068118,
-0.0110392375,
-1.1644796133,
-0.5903688669,
-0.4056885839,
-0.1744989753,
0.4909084439,
-0.2934297621,
0.2681431174,
-0.6985524893,
0.1202690452,
0.3308101296,
-0.1908091903,
-0.9045578241,
0.781398952,
0.5289158225,
0.8357737064,
-1.0941554308,
0.5535646677,
0.5276773572,
-0.5744843483,
-0.7736186981,
0.0002994364,
0.3981878459,
-1.0129565001,
0.9125982523,
0.2601139843,
-0.1858071536,
-0.1420355141,
-1.1351798773,
-0.5157194734,
0.7708303332,
0.3006711602,
-0.5857113004,
0.211592868,
0.1443517804,
0.4138111174,
-0.3419100344,
-0.0656523779,
0.5771366358,
0.7693448067,
0.383420974,
-0.5878027081,
0.4796067178,
-0.0353055,
-0.3887604177,
-0.1251983941,
-0.3556697369,
0.68903476,
-0.1452647299,
-0.2411344945,
-0.1752205044,
0.4827677906,
0.3858941197,
0.9388526678,
0.6929243803,
0.9072446823,
0.5185991526,
-0.0769527107,
0.9011999965,
0.2663840652,
0.0545154624,
1.071649313,
-0.1391124874,
0.500304997,
0.4477642179,
0.0838434771,
0.6988864541,
0.4512066245,
-0.3517320454,
0.5120120645,
-0.0931915939,
-0.3886321783,
-0.7881217599,
0.1367053986,
-0.0142601375,
0.769508183,
0.385879159,
-0.3702334166,
-0.2072917074,
-0.1243456081,
0.0261497814,
0.164315775,
-0.2353998125,
0.5800182223,
0.1297264546,
-0.3800847828,
0.6663533449,
-0.2696428001,
0.6763209701,
0.2384289056,
-0.4795367122,
-0.2149722129,
-0.0854258016,
-0.4030452073,
-1.0533664227,
0.4754105508,
-0.0379962958,
-0.2738669515,
-0.0504979119,
1.0712589025,
0.0912098363,
-0.2902609408,
0.0550961681,
0.5218003988,
0.2040375918,
-0.488209188,
-0.9638861418,
-0.028649088,
-0.189792648,
-0.3135459125,
0.1663833857,
0.8284157515,
-0.124686487,
0.409294039,
0.9800080657,
-0.1378953606,
-0.0810289755,
0.0207765996,
0.6779034734,
-0.6086264849,
-0.1907955259,
-0.7140929699,
0.9118176699,
-0.3958750665,
-0.3666214347,
0.4160022736,
0.153315559,
0.7250167727,
-0.2021644861,
0.7969366312,
0.1155495867,
0.4595625997,
-0.4967410564,
0.8146947026,
-0.8154494166,
0.0297257639,
-0.2724614441,
-0.5561534166,
-0.3348659575,
0.7210008502,
-0.1904498637,
0.0174548421,
0.4514229596,
0.9076340795,
-0.455172956,
-0.0761300176,
0.5754064918,
0.0650347546,
0.0925396308,
0.3478852808,
0.8024917841,
-0.474073261,
0.3811220825,
-0.2291912884,
-0.1495418549,
-0.3934164345,
-1.067609787,
-0.7498812079,
-0.6417064071,
-0.5291669965,
-0.4653926194,
-0.1051564068,
0.365352571,
0.8719192147,
-0.726690352,
0.5743632913,
-0.3869087994,
0.238068074,
-0.2502326667,
-0.3944317698,
0.0305497479,
0.166460827,
-0.4747499824,
0.3306067288,
0.0788093954,
0.3519053459,
-0.1564448625,
-0.1546329409,
-0.1176296547,
0.2212440372,
0.5254052281,
0.4892217517,
-1.0771611929,
-0.5904386044,
0.0107497945,
0.0032540148,
-0.158009395,
0.6470462084,
-1.1972343922,
0.3471539617,
0.297768116,
0.5980517864,
0.3996446431,
0.0013950198,
0.5612011552,
-0.697371304,
0.0843802914,
0.2579651773,
0.0757516325,
0.3553616405,
-0.6297742128,
0.4510065317,
0.7765871286,
-0.250077039,
-0.9751554728,
0.4788302779,
-1.3233622313,
-0.6905781031,
0.8547731638,
-0.1100289598,
-0.3369164169,
-0.545324564,
-0.0667080358,
0.3433801532,
-0.3312276304,
0.6975572109,
0.5367636681,
0.0404957198,
-0.651830852,
-0.4143203497,
0.7149608731,
0.3337022066,
-0.5803803205,
0.0221715104,
0.7609657049,
0.4749041796,
0.3327366114,
0.3721000552,
0.0303281564,
0.8778350353,
0.0222797189,
0.1573131382,
-0.2585929632,
-0.4175324142,
-0.4189105034,
0.0404375233,
-0.4350591004,
-0.025330415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00123v1
|
Comparing Template-based and Template-free Language Model Probing
| 2024-01-31T19:07:37 | 2024-01-31T19:07:37 |
Sagi Shaier, Kevin Bennett, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The differences between cloze-task language model (LM) probing with 1)
expert-made templates and 2) naturally-occurring text have often been
overlooked. Here, we evaluate 16 different LMs on 10 probing English datasets
-- 4 template-based and 6 template-free -- in general and biomedical domains to
answer the following research questions: (RQ1) Do model rankings differ between
the two approaches? (RQ2) Do models' absolute scores differ between the two
approaches? (RQ3) Do the answers to RQ1 and RQ2 differ between general and
domain-specific models? Our findings are: 1) Template-free and template-based
approaches often rank models differently, except for the top domain-specific
models. 2) Scores decrease by up to 42% Acc@1 when comparing parallel
template-free and template-based prompts. 3) Perplexity is negatively
correlated with accuracy in the template-free approach, but,
counter-intuitively, they are positively correlated for template-based probing.
4) Models tend to predict the same answers frequently across prompts for
template-based probing, which is less common when employing template-free
techniques.
|
[
-0.3907595575,
-0.8801897764,
0.6985442042,
0.155292064,
-0.2093121707,
-0.2238012552,
-0.1989949495,
-0.6447902918,
0.1522595137,
0.3692853749,
-0.2357172668,
-0.5070853233,
-0.6619203687,
0.4209835529,
-0.3993964791,
0.598836422,
0.0219065957,
0.3929241896,
-0.6748399734,
-0.3800742626,
-0.4684299827,
-0.4279372692,
-0.6977782249,
-0.2446869612,
0.6265524626,
-0.0028009363,
0.3729842901,
0.6976953745,
0.5143064857,
0.2273449898,
-0.3243989944,
-0.0514678173,
-0.2503148317,
0.1624802947,
-0.4696953893,
-0.5219840407,
-0.5565273762,
0.2393801361,
0.1455993205,
0.7936910391,
0.2032035589,
0.3068474531,
0.2010460794,
0.5486477613,
-0.634889245,
0.0380891412,
-0.4358744025,
-0.3385456204,
-0.2205430269,
-0.0534050539,
-0.500259459,
-0.2309123427,
0.5460405946,
-0.4269028902,
0.538931489,
0.1279790401,
0.6043925881,
-0.1210091114,
-0.8027656674,
-0.5320109129,
-0.5154463649,
0.8887135983,
-0.7101109028,
0.4128456116,
0.1895066202,
-0.0612950549,
0.1238396019,
-0.7074725628,
-0.3764770627,
-0.5204473734,
-0.1360264719,
0.1327820569,
-0.2608886063,
0.0450892821,
0.2062188685,
0.2675178051,
-0.957952261,
0.2455722094,
-0.5456588268,
-0.3010914326,
0.5029696822,
0.2776761055,
0.0811599791,
-0.2457255572,
-0.4645884037,
-0.1798725426,
-0.9233290553,
0.3342066407,
0.069224149,
0.3593818247,
-0.101770699,
0.4834222794,
0.0066361194,
1.0171632767,
0.0882050842,
-0.0566436499,
-0.0209798291,
-0.2422561347,
-0.3762717247,
-0.1581596583,
0.8189390898,
0.5010665655,
0.2655237615,
-0.1554936022,
-0.0988999754,
-0.0529257953,
0.1458148956,
-0.529587388,
-0.0617154874,
0.5820449591,
-0.5199266076,
-0.1942590773,
0.0460573509,
-0.6054261327,
-0.4321255982,
-0.1814110875,
0.4148211479,
-0.301903367,
-0.0828031972,
0.2117198259,
-0.1674347818,
0.3989171982,
0.4663800299,
-0.52522403,
0.4105938971,
0.5975253582,
0.7742277384,
-0.683652699,
-0.1255308986,
-0.3238115907,
-0.2037824541,
-0.4257686734,
1.1011481285,
-0.4386033416,
-0.666778326,
-0.1233704463,
-0.0492449515,
-0.4506966472,
-0.8867632151,
0.2544070482,
-0.2764891088,
0.7619040012,
-0.5743093491,
-0.9594243169,
-0.3744805157,
0.2040293664,
-0.6703460813,
0.9439370036,
0.1426016539,
-0.9222226143,
0.1856200993,
-0.5332456231,
-0.0637191236,
0.0264830552,
-0.3744261265,
0.1172962934,
0.0635729209,
0.2052514553,
0.4651309848,
-0.75157547,
0.186001122,
-0.2697097063,
-0.4390789568,
0.3240542412,
-0.0865639597,
0.8328521848,
0.1827949882,
-0.4924044609,
0.0735628307,
-0.5345696211,
0.3316200972,
0.2996072769,
-0.1163240075,
-0.4766669869,
0.0204090532,
-0.0984850153,
0.1062473059,
0.0703509152,
-0.7378809452,
0.2646067142,
-0.4590136409,
0.1198883951,
0.4064900279,
0.1229268536,
0.2622058988,
-0.8099339008,
0.5494184494,
0.1501754671,
-0.1837600321,
-0.0452761576,
-0.7445852757,
-0.6400777102,
-0.3012288809,
0.2801437974,
0.8041793108,
-0.241431728,
0.02416436,
-0.1928910017,
-0.7215762138,
-0.7278956771,
-0.2035843581,
0.5976759791,
0.8237443566,
0.6143730283,
-0.5222199559,
-0.1782796085,
-0.9585042,
-0.6196792126,
-0.024144657,
-0.2237017453,
0.5600152016,
0.5752891302,
0.2310680002,
0.9020557404,
-0.4759234786,
-0.0657944232,
-0.5062372684,
0.06463819,
0.3069726825,
0.3403949738,
0.8703392148,
-0.5586101413,
-0.8594767451,
-0.2605115771,
-0.5930601358,
-0.2026289701,
0.1335662007,
0.6030035019,
0.1886059046,
0.4238031507,
-0.7468118668,
0.4329806268,
0.3918558955,
-0.1253813803,
0.6929966211,
0.0193003006,
0.4310781956,
-1.0456669331,
0.3561914861,
0.0655172989,
-0.1108240932,
-1.1311845779,
0.2700371444,
0.3532663584,
0.0123666152,
-0.7225461006,
1.0841193199,
-0.4737795889,
0.0565999076,
-0.2577386498,
0.1452150643,
0.2167013735,
0.2347812206,
0.0039245794,
1.0184167624,
0.7029412389,
-0.6987210512,
0.0243992731,
0.0255108923,
-0.5993780494,
0.1435797811,
-1.0756965876,
0.5112417936,
-0.1099637598,
0.0826751068,
-0.9931186438,
0.1960054189,
0.1384533048,
-0.5714958906,
0.243208915,
-0.0964998007,
-0.2940506637,
-0.1221743077,
-0.5238513947,
0.5214816332,
0.5617597699,
-0.0162632782,
0.0859535784,
-0.004662944,
-0.3405974805,
-0.6566623449,
-0.3493057489,
-0.1783679426,
-0.2480499297,
-0.455253005,
0.2198745757,
-0.1738046706,
-0.5352684259,
-0.2040216923,
-0.3929959536,
0.0234536976,
0.0685043931,
-0.0369202122,
0.0339533947,
-0.5749441385,
-0.1132831424,
-0.1929598451,
0.2161265314,
0.0339535065,
-0.2377844751,
0.6097176075,
0.0094466275,
-0.4337013066,
-0.3486009836,
0.6700488329,
0.6857928634,
-0.5743209124,
0.611898303,
0.126725167,
-0.2594225407,
0.1394658685,
-0.7626120448,
-0.1516520381,
-0.4936701953,
0.1621175408,
-0.2736655474,
-0.9487409592,
0.6348484755,
0.336825043,
-0.0263209473,
0.4854608476,
0.6307967305,
-0.2488260865,
0.905703783,
0.489197433,
0.057352908,
0.0588810928,
-0.0722982436,
0.1428484023,
-0.7865353823,
0.0019588624,
-0.8345352411,
-0.0187467672,
-0.5925418139,
-0.4636615813,
0.5384515524,
-0.0108989552,
-0.0161824729,
0.2372225523,
-0.4155785143,
0.2148025036,
0.5173364282,
-0.0900974274,
0.1248978823,
-0.0907347947,
-0.5428212881,
-0.0810805857,
-0.7338224053,
-0.6113948822,
1.3193603754,
0.131863609,
0.3762230277,
-0.0173687376,
0.5498970151,
0.0758841783,
0.3354019523,
-0.6440169811,
0.6298077106,
-0.1637226939,
-0.844350934,
-0.1888121665,
-0.2506918013,
-1.2061691284,
0.3665448427,
-0.0330670625,
-1.1440682411,
0.2316319048,
0.2712433338,
-0.1684360951,
0.3482834697,
-0.4695012271,
0.6270396709,
-0.150017634,
-0.3763504624,
0.0453004651,
-0.5067104697,
0.1501857042,
0.1303276122,
0.3104756474,
0.0090064034,
0.1130817458,
0.7953736782,
0.0238724183,
0.7765079737,
-0.0903834924,
-0.1532748342,
0.5191550851,
0.4657116532,
0.2419014871,
-0.0069509558,
-0.1442494988,
0.0100821741,
0.2577023804,
-0.6123715043,
-0.508723855,
0.5645389557,
-0.5943244696,
-1.0732505322,
-0.5088502765,
-0.5962678194,
-0.2985963225,
0.2625501454,
0.6152249575,
0.7916337252,
-0.1673727781,
0.2526519299,
0.8271037936,
-0.3709760308,
0.0447234549,
0.8029772043,
-0.0195027869,
-0.1293220222,
0.5014830828,
0.035180293,
0.4495669007,
0.7287838459,
0.3067865968,
-0.2256837487,
-0.6544444561,
-0.2198613882,
0.5165838599,
-0.5998991728,
-0.0381350629,
-0.6833403111,
-0.0199955869,
-0.8847587109,
-0.114899233,
-0.4210681617,
-0.404571265,
-0.1334067583,
-0.1383999437,
0.2376507521,
0.671433568,
0.2357224375,
-0.162175253,
-0.8476014137,
-0.0766935572,
0.051926028,
0.0011924896,
-0.0330287181,
-0.2983844578,
0.0344087891,
0.1322472543,
-0.2327234745,
-1.4067735672,
0.3310466409,
-0.0000380075,
0.6170096993,
0.2930056453,
-0.1714833677,
0.5074263811,
-0.4355101287,
1.0489404202,
-0.0676164702,
-0.8354606628,
0.3873014152,
-0.6080848575,
0.3349269629,
0.337180078,
0.7209396958,
-0.6764290333,
-0.6909374595,
-0.4426011443,
-0.882193923,
0.2905228734,
0.0806119964,
-0.1485302746,
-0.3259690106,
0.6098783612,
0.4135846496,
0.2384362221,
-0.5563185811,
-0.4559835196,
-0.0181642026,
-0.080248028,
-0.2495148033,
-0.1599122137,
-0.2183776945,
-0.208580792,
0.0173019357,
-0.0330609269,
0.7128817439,
0.640358448,
-0.1909267157,
0.130889833,
0.41118294,
0.9410307407,
0.5867720842,
-0.5019358397,
0.1104547232,
0.2106161714,
-0.4745237827,
0.1916312575,
-0.244919911,
-0.2301207185,
0.1292329133,
0.7687388659,
0.6787657738,
0.114099212,
-0.6002451777,
0.454549849,
0.0939928889,
-0.5305669308,
0.0165251698,
0.2388858646,
0.3511097133,
-0.0482714884,
0.2532883883,
-0.2183277905,
0.1654132903,
-0.2989575863,
0.0781406313,
0.3575873375,
-0.3852430582,
-0.4001141191,
0.6808162928,
0.0588153824,
-0.3890209198,
0.5487126112,
-0.0575816929,
-0.2973635793,
0.8744103909,
0.668343842,
0.5253482461,
-0.4001799822,
0.0192776117,
0.3766584992,
0.1807111204,
0.0502204299,
0.5558072925,
0.1468856484,
-0.5798245668,
-0.0450254045,
-0.1103870794,
-0.5498894453,
0.6425958872,
-1.2522044182,
-0.0365847759,
-0.1529754698,
-0.1509943306,
-0.1345855594,
0.1658789217,
-1.0298732519,
0.4124698639,
-0.2867853045,
1.3814212084,
-0.6121867299,
0.7954393029,
1.1724104881,
-0.1765512228,
-0.684504509,
-0.0176160503,
0.1945237219,
-0.4420399666,
0.3955594301,
0.3425818384,
-0.0914057642,
0.0932555944,
-0.3635809124,
-1.0861663818,
1.3062301874,
0.1156087965,
-0.3637782037,
-0.1479760706,
0.1249684393,
0.6959050894,
-0.3465471268,
0.4201267362,
0.1718174666,
0.194293052,
-0.5568288565,
-1.3183176517,
0.0455278978,
-0.2514341176,
-0.3533527851,
0.0904176012,
-0.6115496755,
1.0497159958,
-0.0954280645,
-0.3778164387,
0.4142620564,
0.3904793859,
0.3221561909,
0.5502126217,
0.4262892902,
0.2430312335,
0.625017643,
0.0624227934,
1.2516133785,
-0.4828529954,
0.4830711782,
0.7764140368,
-0.6572851539,
0.743486762,
0.4618397355,
-0.0903741866,
0.3126720786,
0.581597805,
0.0635455325,
0.5504130125,
0.3152348101,
0.0045304783,
-0.0631988049,
0.2339179814,
-0.483661145,
0.3809502125,
0.5692991018,
-0.1049302667,
-0.3400983214,
-0.0628363043,
0.1524131,
0.0080177877,
-0.0674678385,
0.5740661621,
0.1707039773,
-0.8320118785,
0.7041413784,
0.2833519578,
0.448549062,
-0.7000417709,
0.4578865469,
-0.6351231337,
-0.0332257524,
0.2594589591,
-0.5422786474,
0.0609130263,
0.2007127106,
-0.063082993,
-0.1423493028,
0.7184557915,
-0.131005764,
-0.1101054996,
0.4501159489,
1.2067197561,
0.2583225965,
0.1569387019,
-0.6316686273,
-0.2675090432,
-0.1334151924,
-0.532405138,
0.6555279493,
-0.0271920078,
-0.2371399105,
0.8363752961,
0.3338466585,
0.0893003941,
0.0163953006,
-0.354572922,
0.6543392539,
-0.6878193021,
-0.145173192,
-0.5755167007,
0.400580436,
0.0719881356,
-0.5069023371,
0.6315540075,
0.538697958,
0.8139328957,
-0.3141106963,
0.6960299015,
0.1088757217,
0.9327321053,
-0.685670197,
0.5875231028,
-0.750597775,
0.066490069,
-0.2036322504,
-0.7312154174,
-0.2798215747,
0.5535488725,
-0.285607934,
0.053238295,
1.1884121895,
0.9325371981,
-0.2840593457,
-0.1765868664,
0.2603408694,
0.2285826504,
0.3972766995,
0.4975177646,
0.6310347319,
-0.1562909335,
-0.0084506292,
-0.1410990357,
-0.1026573926,
-0.0758217424,
-0.9353802204,
-0.974837184,
-0.6957708597,
-0.1946769953,
-0.1329165995,
0.2416419387,
0.9665988684,
0.2946479023,
-1.0143699646,
-0.4297536314,
0.3380478919,
-0.1269444525,
-0.370844394,
-0.1914385855,
0.5709471703,
-0.1025651991,
-0.7436794639,
0.8364622593,
0.2152672261,
0.1020603478,
0.1088247746,
0.3973823786,
-0.0346638486,
0.5060815215,
0.328262955,
0.2622058988,
-0.9122681618,
-0.4147660136,
0.7082186341,
-0.4694499969,
0.139344722,
1.169819355,
-0.6810295582,
0.2365526855,
0.6402614713,
0.3070428967,
0.106122829,
-0.0185205191,
0.7705301642,
-0.5653666258,
0.0455186181,
0.3226008415,
0.3498920202,
0.2954495251,
-0.2091501951,
0.1925744712,
0.3211987019,
-0.5565149784,
-0.8961085081,
0.5442679524,
-1.1923516989,
-0.4541128874,
1.2548232079,
-0.3419920504,
0.0255778469,
-0.3018658757,
-0.0051783295,
0.0694675297,
0.0568538606,
0.7245369554,
0.7848771811,
-0.2803325057,
0.1607823074,
-0.744725585,
0.4470752478,
0.7235988379,
-0.3677038252,
-0.2811175585,
0.1413397193,
0.7695989013,
0.0327573791,
0.9281862974,
-0.1830899715,
0.489276588,
-0.3139253557,
-0.1208348125,
-0.2354653031,
-0.1769601554,
-0.3278422356,
0.3245131075,
0.080317542,
0.024285607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18070v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18070v2
|
Do Language Models Exhibit the Same Cognitive Biases in Problem Solving as Human Learners?
| 2024-01-31T18:48:20 | 2024-06-17T15:08:05 |
Andreas Opedal, Alessandro Stolfo, Haruki Shirakami, Ying Jiao, Ryan Cotterell, Bernhard Schölkopf, Abulhair Saparov, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
There is increasing interest in employing large language models (LLMs) as
cognitive models. For such purposes, it is central to understand which
properties of human cognition are well-modeled by LLMs, and which are not. In
this work, we study the biases of LLMs in relation to those known in children
when solving arithmetic word problems. Surveying the learning science
literature, we posit that the problem-solving process can be split into three
distinct steps: text comprehension, solution planning and solution execution.
We construct tests for each one in order to understand whether current LLMs
display the same cognitive biases as children in these steps. We generate a
novel set of word problems for each of these tests, using a neuro-symbolic
approach that enables fine-grained control over the problem features. We find
evidence that LLMs, with and without instruction-tuning, exhibit human-like
biases in both the text-comprehension and the solution-planning steps of the
solving process, but not in the final step, in which the arithmetic expressions
are executed to obtain the answer.
|
[
-0.338214606,
-0.9047995806,
0.9263198972,
0.2548832893,
0.0765850842,
0.0930938795,
-0.3372766376,
-0.4315371811,
-0.0289701633,
0.6310474277,
-1.0154312849,
0.047762353,
-0.7752728462,
0.1696779728,
-0.1129372418,
0.6310588717,
-0.1884673536,
0.5535482168,
-0.5530807376,
0.1288182735,
-0.4362929463,
-0.5869264007,
-0.6780391335,
-0.7976050973,
0.3388734758,
0.473493576,
0.7565801144,
0.6982761025,
0.3970192969,
0.2768611908,
-0.2211601138,
-0.148763001,
-0.212605238,
0.0605359413,
-0.3149952888,
-0.7812224627,
-0.0558482558,
0.2983779311,
0.2041080296,
1.2275686264,
-0.1686483622,
0.1456805915,
0.1088225245,
0.9446645975,
-0.542386651,
0.3206019104,
-0.6209424138,
0.0730371848,
-0.0024716703,
0.1746857315,
-0.4633411169,
-0.1491592079,
0.1648834497,
-0.7586393356,
0.4994892776,
0.0661544651,
0.5615655184,
0.4230721295,
-0.4395592809,
-0.7222191095,
-0.5267178416,
1.0786529779,
-0.6661898494,
0.0342492275,
0.6334222555,
-0.1995044202,
-0.3263963163,
0.10995166,
-0.8419012427,
-0.2276496738,
-0.1295086592,
-0.2241932899,
0.0552700162,
0.056729842,
0.5763744712,
-0.1485243738,
-0.5308415294,
0.1424065828,
-0.5872446299,
-0.2748073041,
0.6488812566,
0.3541004062,
0.2975530624,
-0.2334977835,
-0.0885819569,
-0.1338045597,
-0.6797897816,
-0.0327110738,
0.3142257333,
0.1904541701,
0.0503301322,
0.7034546137,
-0.0979734808,
0.6363781095,
-0.0611032322,
-0.0522401407,
0.2198754102,
0.0907525271,
-0.0246577002,
0.1562534571,
0.5908152461,
0.1087567732,
1.068235755,
0.0661270618,
-0.3853290975,
0.6043648124,
0.1966067702,
-0.4658329189,
-0.0600028746,
-0.0800775439,
-0.149612844,
-0.3510945439,
-0.3695344329,
-0.4719088972,
-0.3828343153,
-0.4572431147,
0.5779451132,
-0.3750266135,
0.0660621822,
0.3903836608,
-0.0429472513,
0.0303719807,
0.0219259057,
-1.174933672,
0.4705480635,
0.8163765073,
0.4055042565,
-0.1603565365,
-0.2695932984,
-0.3196588457,
-0.0795832649,
-0.5658326745,
0.7071062326,
-0.8074637651,
-0.469951123,
0.0098499795,
-0.1668194383,
-0.1149907038,
-0.8248929381,
0.4504258037,
-0.5524417758,
0.2123452425,
-0.6320251226,
-0.5211256146,
-0.0184123013,
0.1081454977,
-0.6397668719,
0.7899543643,
-0.0904112309,
-0.7492290735,
0.2459918112,
-0.5446151495,
-0.3770657778,
-0.3034616113,
-0.3868710101,
-0.1130743995,
0.5078738332,
0.4148772955,
0.1590761244,
-0.4560935199,
0.0231273454,
-0.2336734831,
-0.3358416557,
0.447814703,
-0.498097688,
0.8196815252,
-0.1189825982,
-0.5279688239,
-0.0928427875,
-0.6010360122,
0.0876850486,
0.4720183909,
-0.2328604162,
-0.4227374792,
0.2870033383,
-0.4028244913,
0.447098881,
0.4325830936,
-0.6564727426,
0.1814866662,
-0.2374334484,
0.4358997941,
0.8874518871,
-0.058604829,
0.3305982351,
-0.4938675165,
0.4596863389,
0.0925503522,
0.0523960181,
-0.0940713957,
-0.5704634786,
-1.0795354843,
0.3458776772,
-0.1045617089,
0.4816994071,
-0.7435432076,
-0.0245452374,
-0.1514463425,
-0.1403795332,
-0.2141403556,
0.0967210904,
0.673666656,
0.4526887834,
0.2276193649,
-0.2085858285,
-0.1010427549,
-1.1037158966,
-0.4720637798,
-0.1508851349,
-0.2480050921,
0.494607985,
0.5247343183,
0.1273588091,
0.7516798377,
-0.7501221895,
-0.1956074983,
0.1799397767,
0.268950969,
0.0545944981,
0.2004272938,
0.2277751565,
-0.6227855682,
-0.1949208081,
-0.3386417031,
-0.7065269351,
-0.4788752496,
0.0880869105,
0.1103050485,
0.4671992958,
0.5578983426,
-0.7691060901,
0.3061003387,
0.4659393132,
-0.5687509179,
0.7668057084,
-0.1788748056,
-0.3303815126,
-0.4813268185,
-0.420547843,
0.2673597336,
0.2019875348,
-0.4130179882,
0.0913362876,
0.1214652061,
0.2795420587,
-0.268545121,
0.2379189879,
-0.5410155654,
-0.1886106879,
-0.2799882293,
0.31012398,
0.1059080437,
0.519820869,
0.1691315174,
0.7519809008,
0.3456678689,
-0.5273892879,
0.158654213,
-0.3363151252,
-0.2709629834,
0.4065379798,
-0.8622114062,
0.3921179473,
-0.3244907558,
0.012224813,
-0.7148733735,
0.0227460042,
0.005489314,
-0.3610904217,
0.1412830949,
0.1250872016,
-0.6417630315,
-0.4102250636,
-0.0807986483,
0.5131216049,
0.5986861587,
-0.21968925,
0.3663796186,
0.2808356881,
-0.2779227495,
-0.412281841,
-0.6632233262,
-0.2162365019,
-0.0064670858,
-0.535835743,
0.2643783391,
-0.2181687355,
-0.5483036637,
0.0884344801,
-0.3750897348,
-0.1414143443,
-0.2207552642,
0.1443458349,
0.4488267601,
-0.0608592704,
0.2357462645,
-0.1382403523,
-0.1179540232,
0.5752949119,
-0.223354578,
0.6768194437,
0.0573093519,
-0.4419764876,
0.0193608552,
0.2851917446,
0.6026949883,
-0.2545165122,
0.5992244482,
0.0005107017,
-0.497934401,
-0.2565560341,
-0.5496439338,
-0.5365108252,
-0.474730134,
0.459915936,
-0.3537160456,
-0.7626771927,
0.397287339,
0.2762237191,
0.0458806232,
0.2502428293,
0.6803739667,
-0.3237760365,
1.2604863644,
0.4798504114,
0.0326309986,
0.1652848125,
-0.1796457469,
-0.0187614355,
-0.9476479292,
-0.2632690668,
-0.5785196424,
-0.4052366316,
-0.4877331257,
-0.549869895,
0.3211877644,
-0.0207343511,
-0.5939564705,
-0.0676704645,
-0.6157016158,
0.8197649121,
0.3130014539,
-0.0467680022,
0.323735863,
0.1065939814,
-0.4350875914,
-0.3024836779,
-0.7118887305,
-0.5620751977,
1.2169978619,
-0.0055492567,
0.7262430191,
-0.1378930211,
0.5319541693,
-0.0285585709,
0.507661581,
-0.7592456937,
0.6909162998,
-0.0804585814,
-1.0424103737,
-0.4700564146,
-0.5426527858,
-1.1029165983,
0.4879767597,
-0.2154954374,
-1.0861102343,
0.0155268535,
-0.1124396697,
-0.0027392104,
0.2066460401,
-0.6887289286,
0.4715863466,
-0.2915121615,
-0.3092799187,
-0.5858464837,
-0.3187138736,
0.3591363132,
-0.1941546202,
0.6008826494,
-0.2063117772,
-0.0871209577,
0.8804094195,
-0.3749059141,
0.8082214594,
0.0177960768,
-0.2507722676,
0.3381705284,
0.328748405,
0.4331799448,
-0.1314664781,
-0.0224629827,
-0.0906862915,
-0.0479297712,
-0.6930136085,
-0.6992660165,
0.8282817602,
-0.8683824539,
-0.9941481352,
-0.805038929,
-0.7893535495,
-0.3596204817,
0.2931144238,
-0.0365602262,
0.3755970299,
0.0829172209,
-0.2174217701,
0.9496097565,
-0.1243521646,
0.6232990623,
0.7599529624,
-0.42465958,
0.0353718363,
0.7776302695,
0.2945308089,
0.6101588607,
0.0257181916,
0.3459623754,
-0.0360316969,
-0.4342876077,
-0.2702067792,
0.4843147397,
-0.6056657434,
0.2830657363,
-0.2064909786,
-0.1456941962,
0.096784696,
-0.141821906,
-0.2740225494,
-0.383154422,
-0.2157204747,
0.081631884,
0.1096752137,
1.0373153687,
0.314088732,
0.0611425266,
-0.4919132888,
0.5021883249,
0.5567353964,
0.2268257737,
0.261626929,
-0.404815942,
-0.1700877398,
0.35088557,
-0.4807602167,
-0.9185878634,
0.1730365157,
0.009577699,
0.2280193865,
0.265378058,
-0.0719677359,
0.3087663352,
-0.587536037,
0.849409759,
0.0259928647,
-0.8678659797,
0.1792411506,
-0.2232702821,
0.45240888,
0.2135722637,
0.4506910145,
-0.4567996264,
-0.1411733031,
-0.4972620904,
-0.4805130959,
0.778363049,
0.0479516685,
0.3316479921,
-0.2331690937,
0.4303539395,
-0.1737733483,
-0.0615452267,
-0.5849327445,
-0.3509218991,
0.1106917337,
0.0465351827,
-0.1152706221,
-0.1643774211,
-0.0681339949,
-0.1943677664,
0.616915822,
-0.1139570847,
-0.1279746741,
0.179552868,
-0.2209602147,
-0.432795465,
0.297024101,
0.5265331864,
0.6322833896,
0.0910255462,
0.0453356616,
0.1387281865,
-0.5693003535,
0.2904528081,
-0.1959215254,
-0.245939225,
-0.2537205517,
0.5717181563,
0.5402465463,
0.302942276,
-0.8166386485,
0.322348088,
-0.0439351723,
-0.3821420372,
-0.3586964905,
0.2827882171,
0.472814858,
0.1042390913,
0.6047410965,
-0.063715823,
-0.0923137292,
-0.6495867968,
-0.2501890063,
0.4956370294,
-0.4165219963,
-0.2766746879,
0.3937397301,
-0.0660174489,
-0.7336586118,
0.9782874584,
-0.32191962,
-0.6762248874,
0.8594179153,
0.784776926,
0.6361013055,
-0.0199923459,
0.2429101616,
0.0365866162,
0.5238800049,
0.0983178467,
0.4990580976,
0.1826914102,
-1.0606669188,
-0.7736889124,
-0.5701911449,
-0.2241471112,
0.1184129789,
-0.6948924661,
-0.0028167812,
-0.4135776162,
-0.1743081659,
0.2818880379,
0.0058766515,
-0.6525985599,
0.3552342951,
0.3759452105,
0.694824636,
-0.7381904125,
0.6223084927,
0.869105041,
-0.1614289433,
-0.9029601812,
0.0654239431,
0.0564826317,
-0.8555203676,
0.7910797596,
0.0875983685,
-0.0838839933,
-0.1783564091,
-0.5223388672,
-0.963181138,
0.6862156391,
0.3489528894,
-0.6223905683,
-0.3131691813,
0.4264705181,
0.5424355268,
-0.3121428788,
0.1785048693,
0.8071617484,
0.50605762,
-0.0048173456,
-1.0381166935,
0.004955451,
-0.0975241959,
-0.0313122943,
0.319383204,
-0.6184555292,
0.9778793454,
-0.4207182527,
0.0336195417,
-0.4770024717,
0.3438205719,
0.6006562114,
0.3689299524,
0.5274074674,
0.7010829449,
0.4703147113,
-0.045957461,
1.0044116974,
-0.2608282268,
0.2316971868,
0.8264020085,
-0.2003938109,
0.6284665465,
0.7005395293,
-0.470397383,
0.526514411,
0.3712722361,
0.4669766128,
0.2382330596,
0.564950645,
-0.1391620189,
-0.2979809046,
-0.0152308792,
0.0426350385,
0.3220025301,
0.8060308695,
-0.1838783771,
-0.0976212248,
-0.290214628,
0.2936246693,
0.3132466376,
-0.5417028069,
0.4644051492,
0.4468967617,
-0.8939367533,
0.6515882611,
0.1084380671,
0.7340826392,
-0.3638921082,
0.1682603508,
-0.0099511193,
-0.029148126,
-0.1738049984,
-0.8645946383,
0.2009744644,
0.0157632977,
-0.5294911861,
0.0230800305,
0.4363270104,
-0.2035233229,
-0.8320165277,
0.1254980862,
0.517506063,
0.0178894214,
-0.109442614,
-0.5456022024,
0.0894415155,
0.0781160221,
-0.4688754082,
0.3757495582,
0.3989089727,
-0.5861058235,
0.9770370126,
0.6595990062,
0.204073742,
0.403314054,
0.1228308305,
0.6550980806,
-0.7714977264,
-0.1699372977,
-0.9727160931,
0.0678762496,
0.0351582319,
-0.2909908891,
0.4053447247,
0.2851722538,
0.8316149116,
-0.057500001,
0.7341667414,
0.4171410203,
0.1132065132,
-0.4584838152,
0.3874315917,
-0.2233121842,
0.3574675322,
-0.2430605292,
-1.2662291527,
-0.1302499473,
0.7357180119,
-0.6870937943,
0.3231010139,
0.9799753428,
0.716019392,
0.1541615576,
0.2373964041,
0.1249819994,
0.228023842,
0.2013054043,
0.9582874179,
0.7116553783,
-0.0942110196,
0.190155223,
-0.3154997826,
-0.3553858399,
-0.0492040589,
-0.6661958694,
-0.8730736971,
-0.3621133864,
-0.1746330708,
-0.0208341274,
0.0834186971,
0.9383556843,
0.3604935706,
-0.5527216196,
-0.1859553456,
-0.1812996715,
0.2887462974,
-0.0145163247,
-0.2295708507,
0.2612097561,
-0.4057698548,
-0.6940760612,
0.0577104054,
0.1237781048,
-0.1560729146,
-0.6028015614,
0.0550960489,
0.1719934344,
0.6658363938,
0.399813205,
-0.0127537614,
-0.8089703918,
-0.36787498,
0.1881437004,
-0.2400642484,
-0.0690945089,
0.9789363146,
-0.9565131068,
0.4162034988,
0.2373240143,
0.1992503405,
0.7073388696,
-0.2753838003,
0.3665942848,
-0.383216083,
0.1205967441,
0.319765687,
0.3538465798,
0.3201613128,
-0.099777095,
0.1793715507,
0.1377286017,
-0.553581655,
-0.5816103816,
0.5064788461,
-0.4398609698,
-0.3957003355,
0.948623836,
0.3066362441,
-0.3252751231,
0.0791786909,
-0.1460877061,
0.0668249875,
-0.1743555218,
1.0268259048,
1.1534156799,
-0.2368455231,
-0.0222765449,
-0.7267683148,
0.1727003753,
0.8787686825,
-0.2137729228,
0.0420750231,
0.4607875347,
0.32281968,
0.2981837392,
0.3323430419,
-0.2684439719,
0.1139044464,
-0.0154319461,
0.0972528756,
0.1118958294,
-0.1498564631,
-0.2147559822,
-0.1555802971,
0.2690930068,
0.2675313652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18059v1
|
RAPTOR: Recursive Abstractive Processing for Tree-Organized Retrieval
| 2024-01-31T18:30:21 | 2024-01-31T18:30:21 |
Parth Sarthi, Salman Abdullah, Aditi Tuli, Shubh Khanna, Anna Goldie, Christopher D. Manning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Retrieval-augmented language models can better adapt to changes in world
state and incorporate long-tail knowledge. However, most existing methods
retrieve only short contiguous chunks from a retrieval corpus, limiting
holistic understanding of the overall document context. We introduce the novel
approach of recursively embedding, clustering, and summarizing chunks of text,
constructing a tree with differing levels of summarization from the bottom up.
At inference time, our RAPTOR model retrieves from this tree, integrating
information across lengthy documents at different levels of abstraction.
Controlled experiments show that retrieval with recursive summaries offers
significant improvements over traditional retrieval-augmented LMs on several
tasks. On question-answering tasks that involve complex, multi-step reasoning,
we show state-of-the-art results; for example, by coupling RAPTOR retrieval
with the use of GPT-4, we can improve the best performance on the QuALITY
benchmark by 20% in absolute accuracy.
|
[
-0.3904760182,
-0.8263789415,
0.6254738569,
-0.1061005965,
-0.2128068805,
0.7964012027,
0.2805577815,
-0.8041790128,
0.3987553418,
0.1151876077,
-0.0992131308,
-0.5047327876,
-0.7848047018,
0.239447102,
-0.7667906284,
0.9734523892,
-0.0463852659,
-0.5845317245,
-0.0017641546,
0.0211608093,
-0.2127231807,
-0.6078574657,
-0.6013583541,
-0.4614562392,
0.5113838315,
0.1168850064,
0.7128916383,
0.7389466166,
0.4992662966,
0.2861326039,
-0.3985304236,
0.1454340667,
-0.2862833738,
0.4930306971,
-0.3465732038,
-0.3639904857,
-0.3604679704,
-0.2460328937,
0.6810268164,
0.5389799476,
-0.2284646332,
-0.0673750788,
-0.2263181955,
0.4975378215,
-0.8388591409,
0.1381184906,
-0.5205934048,
0.26332286,
0.0566022173,
-0.5149977803,
-0.5574718118,
-0.2591381371,
0.0922560617,
-0.538254559,
0.3186387718,
-0.0546544977,
0.4899703562,
0.209577769,
-0.3236888051,
-0.4245706201,
-0.7522221208,
0.6764567494,
-0.3935891688,
0.3913016915,
0.298471868,
0.3254796267,
0.0266529862,
-1.0946884155,
-0.2115359157,
0.0561370328,
-0.2440457791,
0.2855580151,
-0.5699071884,
0.0837192237,
0.216103673,
0.6085487008,
-0.2135136873,
-0.3455786109,
-0.3452939689,
-0.0142641775,
0.3146785796,
-0.0562165454,
0.4103300571,
-0.2216732949,
-0.0528474115,
-0.1184921265,
-0.4214870036,
0.152016148,
-0.0275333151,
0.2741220593,
0.3671285808,
0.5121762753,
0.0195506569,
0.7953360081,
0.3124419749,
-0.1822325438,
0.1613839418,
-0.5293740034,
-0.0168384574,
0.0523825474,
0.3464019299,
0.1395130008,
-0.0461119935,
-0.399358511,
-0.4756285846,
-0.0346716344,
0.3440128267,
-0.9054259062,
-0.0237306822,
0.3489626646,
-0.3080263436,
-0.2930932641,
-0.0472253636,
-0.4721395969,
0.0532716848,
-0.0509286635,
0.2460532337,
-0.5996394157,
-0.2636418045,
0.0405832455,
-0.3081087768,
0.1720353663,
0.3302765489,
-0.9950596094,
0.8173599243,
0.7816973329,
1.3989900351,
-0.1830485314,
0.019767575,
-0.9875134826,
0.1815475225,
-0.402526319,
1.0062644482,
-0.9879983664,
-0.6005565524,
-0.2313778698,
-0.0917939842,
-0.0533761755,
-0.412430793,
0.464535445,
-0.8637555838,
0.0734497756,
-0.018594496,
-0.4750650227,
-0.2199216336,
0.4696684778,
-0.610104382,
1.2221722603,
0.2990101576,
-1.0258569717,
-0.1237762719,
-0.786405623,
-0.5381148458,
-0.0066962079,
-0.1648352295,
-0.0514014997,
0.0868503749,
0.437790215,
0.1618300974,
0.1169289127,
-0.0654149428,
0.350320518,
-0.6079289913,
-0.1510596722,
0.206117779,
0.3996245265,
0.2847463489,
0.0784547552,
0.1408586949,
-0.4331478179,
-0.0903332382,
-0.0614694543,
-0.3506734371,
-0.5976635814,
0.1765809357,
-0.2410997301,
0.1255855113,
0.1592417955,
-0.7808092237,
0.3546203375,
-0.6412402391,
0.6261001229,
0.2869093418,
0.1813858747,
0.517791748,
-0.3745028079,
0.7226162553,
0.1668945402,
-0.247755155,
-0.7182642817,
-0.2314448059,
-0.2390847057,
-0.0317724049,
0.2908543348,
0.4545741677,
-0.6665096879,
0.0846858844,
-0.2827050984,
-0.2265306264,
-0.4274477065,
-0.316703409,
0.3741555512,
0.4998925328,
0.4960146844,
-0.3600966036,
-0.6209021807,
-0.7070679665,
-0.1249901205,
-0.0076449141,
-0.0143496878,
0.097663179,
0.6433724165,
-0.0899802148,
0.9334064722,
-0.5950039625,
-0.0363058001,
-0.324483335,
0.4242740273,
0.3186275661,
0.3430034816,
0.4619305432,
-0.9572969675,
-0.3388125896,
0.2766513526,
-0.3773701489,
0.1174567044,
0.1982329339,
0.1407001615,
-0.0590771176,
0.6790175438,
-0.7470328808,
0.252613008,
0.3246193528,
-0.1369559616,
0.3230673969,
-0.2831689119,
0.1314179599,
-1.2639495134,
0.0965320989,
-0.2576606274,
-0.5913745165,
-0.5286689401,
0.3706410229,
-0.0734062195,
0.0794500485,
-0.1136191562,
0.2179757804,
-0.5351634622,
-0.6951740384,
-0.5361828804,
0.4818449318,
0.1205662042,
0.12196026,
0.053468924,
1.0491302013,
0.2861715257,
-0.5101533532,
0.1026370376,
0.3854272962,
-0.1182134002,
0.2587056756,
-0.8454586864,
0.3054388463,
-0.5051966906,
0.4267496467,
-0.9501727223,
-0.1215295419,
0.0037423775,
-0.6869617105,
0.2705857158,
-0.4999365807,
-0.5193106532,
-0.0672296435,
-0.4048810899,
0.5121347308,
0.3587455153,
-0.3789740503,
0.9966198802,
0.4115363061,
-0.3637367189,
-0.854232192,
-0.4732064307,
0.1124030352,
0.2042335123,
-0.3560585082,
0.9411489964,
0.0534859188,
-0.3707993329,
0.1519688666,
-0.1855094135,
0.0184288211,
-0.0176577549,
0.1196850911,
-0.0617378354,
-0.074691236,
0.2753941417,
0.2164676636,
-0.2451809198,
-0.0574331805,
-0.2289873213,
0.4462053478,
-0.2990384996,
-0.0824608505,
0.0768614113,
0.5934431553,
0.6285214424,
-0.5203058124,
0.4280263782,
0.2367687225,
-0.4519894719,
0.1375908554,
-0.2254681885,
-0.1849400103,
-0.3663282692,
0.3006906509,
-0.6757767797,
-1.0017614365,
0.473934114,
-0.1092232615,
0.4676230848,
0.3770200908,
0.1730312556,
-0.0748941824,
1.3097856045,
0.6358693242,
-0.058811985,
0.4383976161,
-0.4409045875,
0.1859281063,
-1.0053851604,
-0.1842141598,
-0.5428712964,
-0.2521847188,
-0.5366575718,
-0.3617600501,
0.1975473762,
0.1675167084,
-0.1434049457,
0.2213654816,
-0.7674875259,
0.7042114139,
0.4053692222,
-0.1176054403,
0.8407037258,
0.0090897735,
-0.3249676526,
0.2012107372,
-0.4716888368,
-0.4075755775,
0.6633446217,
0.202439934,
0.5086555481,
0.2443700135,
0.8234739304,
0.4184556603,
0.4865581691,
-0.9873851538,
0.204963699,
-0.0530013964,
-0.4243993461,
-0.1098096073,
-0.1823488325,
-1.0077644587,
0.6691330075,
0.0583475046,
-0.8570427299,
-0.0260831583,
-0.0252514295,
-0.48494187,
0.3271662295,
-0.4965411425,
0.2865864336,
0.0882246122,
-0.0668879375,
-0.1898238361,
-0.6521300077,
0.3689107299,
-0.0618276075,
0.2848800421,
0.1805868149,
-0.2517932653,
0.7420349717,
-0.3304221034,
0.4995141029,
-0.0669209585,
0.1008004248,
0.2180842608,
0.2800770104,
0.6751503348,
-0.2519950271,
-0.0918028876,
-0.3769626021,
0.6244659424,
-0.3259579539,
-0.9101464748,
0.7302772403,
-0.855006218,
-0.6428185701,
-0.9155934453,
-0.6832057238,
-0.1331477612,
0.3178702891,
0.0819332451,
0.3803911507,
0.0355341658,
0.3004116118,
0.4012546241,
0.1119123027,
0.5012000203,
0.5266373754,
-0.7014552951,
-0.2209853828,
0.4409391284,
0.1638229787,
0.0951160863,
0.7844304442,
0.1263684928,
-0.3982616067,
-0.8008806705,
-0.1007467508,
0.0956968665,
-0.7156150341,
-0.2245728076,
-0.9925627708,
-0.4817976356,
-0.0102014048,
-0.0769627467,
-0.2636654675,
-0.4217449427,
0.0275649931,
-0.5674599409,
0.4320058227,
1.0511705875,
-0.0699165091,
0.2894669771,
-0.8635197282,
0.3709033132,
0.0643229336,
0.3016722798,
0.2009069473,
-0.6341516972,
-0.1383448094,
-0.1173276082,
-0.4062721431,
-0.7684987783,
0.4229320586,
0.1293075085,
0.2128797919,
0.0402492844,
0.0425218903,
0.7011908889,
-0.5228162408,
0.4636761546,
0.0414474942,
-0.8025012016,
0.6728938818,
-0.2044132501,
0.4602634013,
0.4003033638,
0.4295493662,
-0.6655340195,
-0.274269402,
-0.5172094107,
-0.8299382925,
0.592828989,
0.4330168068,
0.0246598814,
-0.1873915344,
0.5475717187,
-0.0484734066,
-0.0492471941,
-0.407330215,
-0.0840919837,
-0.3043019176,
0.0065288306,
0.0438769124,
-0.357589215,
0.0126384292,
-0.2879357338,
0.3756049573,
-0.1290413439,
0.2026857287,
0.4225867689,
-0.2190547436,
-0.1303729713,
0.4800075591,
0.4623503685,
0.974698782,
-0.6235485673,
0.570762217,
0.0626897886,
-0.5854277611,
0.2426260412,
0.2672156394,
-0.3063367307,
0.2045568973,
0.3532507122,
0.2135197073,
0.4871739149,
-0.484564513,
0.2147294879,
-0.1965680718,
-0.1397317648,
-0.3556576073,
-0.0932584107,
0.2877162099,
0.2479698956,
0.8412867188,
-0.0703611374,
0.3501936793,
-0.5773208141,
0.4427485168,
0.2643233836,
-0.2185538709,
-0.4049793184,
0.3142435551,
0.061417941,
-0.4021983743,
0.5041153431,
0.0330458172,
-0.3390866518,
0.4185754955,
0.8176447749,
0.572530508,
-0.2698377073,
0.2227464318,
0.5675824285,
0.1017857119,
-0.1061344892,
0.3672800958,
-0.4204940796,
-0.8095967174,
-0.9363399148,
-0.6793899536,
-0.5356022716,
-0.0224677119,
-0.6995706558,
-0.4776608944,
-0.5491786003,
-0.1578528583,
0.2759413123,
0.0064485921,
-0.0763467029,
0.0431777388,
-0.3500147164,
1.0639792681,
-0.3882959187,
0.6544274092,
0.5312743187,
-0.6507626176,
-0.5597928762,
-0.232606709,
-0.2592522502,
-0.5914612412,
0.7755044699,
0.1774039119,
-0.6524290442,
0.4564379454,
-0.4237414598,
-1.0921674967,
1.12507236,
0.0832858086,
-0.587654233,
-0.3110400736,
-0.3343813121,
0.6256945729,
-0.4751370549,
0.514846921,
0.7584873438,
0.2517080605,
0.5195944309,
-0.5513088107,
-0.0671757981,
-0.4526057839,
0.0035358453,
0.5693318248,
-0.2104495764,
0.7974250317,
-0.3146792054,
-0.5555684566,
0.002543292,
0.6088269949,
0.2862997651,
0.1386611015,
0.3694964945,
0.5311073661,
0.7690160275,
-0.0772516504,
1.3525128365,
-0.5790603161,
0.2278012186,
1.2965539694,
0.0761575997,
1.0937033892,
0.4301423728,
-0.1854350567,
0.834141016,
0.5850278139,
0.4369941652,
0.3663921356,
-0.037447311,
-0.481565237,
-0.0494103953,
-0.3397529125,
-0.3050764501,
0.2767498791,
0.4135408103,
-0.4987194538,
-0.5652596951,
-0.2396078706,
-0.1461094767,
0.1481018811,
-0.3760426342,
0.7873194814,
0.1097563952,
-0.8418044448,
0.4412522316,
0.1540028304,
0.5001932383,
-0.3761619031,
-0.310957998,
-0.2875697315,
0.0332333446,
-0.5094052553,
-0.9671266675,
0.6206374168,
0.1217104867,
-0.3524342179,
-0.2525593638,
0.7291302681,
-0.2389708459,
-0.4312480986,
0.4010005891,
0.6644281149,
0.2488899529,
-0.1731365323,
-0.4826953709,
0.0049328571,
-0.438518405,
-0.1109114513,
0.1964900494,
0.1916899979,
-0.057675451,
0.7314954996,
0.7387030721,
-0.0185521282,
-0.1861970127,
0.2699825764,
0.8820151687,
-0.9136193395,
-0.5573019385,
-0.7342965007,
0.1733437628,
-0.0116117988,
0.2371834964,
0.5532671809,
0.6420391798,
0.7378240824,
0.309905082,
0.9170903563,
-0.0846067294,
0.7631807923,
-0.2939462364,
0.2956857979,
-0.2880960107,
0.1875251085,
-0.1639651656,
-0.8646166921,
-0.3338802159,
0.6361494064,
-0.4207363427,
0.1062668115,
0.7257363796,
0.4741384983,
-0.269415617,
-0.0312161837,
0.3153065145,
0.2758452594,
0.5184172392,
0.5311825871,
0.8962004781,
-0.467435956,
0.6194450855,
0.0021946463,
-0.0674284548,
-0.1003133431,
-0.5809834599,
-0.541652441,
-0.6437878609,
0.0765261501,
-0.1970547736,
0.2247435004,
0.7433784008,
0.5266493559,
-0.7193548679,
-0.023060862,
-0.2946544588,
0.2927091718,
-0.1922219694,
-0.2448652238,
0.4562030435,
-0.3948887587,
-0.6531899571,
0.4545111656,
0.6023321748,
0.1620508283,
-0.1547476351,
0.0361491106,
-0.4921121895,
-0.1040692404,
0.9871579409,
0.4438531697,
-0.7491756082,
-0.5032227635,
0.1211859584,
0.1516369134,
0.4688135684,
0.9366394877,
-1.0257021189,
0.5699611306,
0.4487006366,
0.6940038204,
0.9704677463,
0.5268593431,
0.5571013689,
-0.7522482276,
-0.1477404833,
0.5148746371,
0.3862074316,
0.4268990159,
-0.1911982745,
0.5900990367,
-0.1411455721,
-0.278859973,
-0.5606318116,
0.2433223128,
-0.7358243465,
-0.3203020692,
0.7084046602,
-0.109796308,
-0.2271589637,
-0.3750243783,
-0.3297894895,
0.2091136426,
-0.4902507961,
0.6706937551,
0.6901357174,
-0.4215919673,
-0.7433392406,
-0.2283414304,
0.3605605662,
-0.0543909669,
-0.854823947,
-0.0642539561,
0.4050408006,
0.3934452236,
0.7177008986,
0.7757120132,
-0.3059975207,
0.3026492,
-0.0411438122,
-0.2089383453,
-0.2684696913,
-0.2722741365,
-0.1150922477,
0.5190501213,
0.1920055151,
-0.0502277277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18058v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18058v1
|
LongAlign: A Recipe for Long Context Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-01-31T18:29:39 | 2024-01-31T18:29:39 |
Yushi Bai, Xin Lv, Jiajie Zhang, Yuze He, Ji Qi, Lei Hou, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Extending large language models to effectively handle long contexts requires
instruction fine-tuning on input sequences of similar length. To address this,
we present LongAlign -- a recipe of the instruction data, training, and
evaluation for long context alignment. First, we construct a long
instruction-following dataset using Self-Instruct. To ensure the data
diversity, it covers a broad range of tasks from various long context sources.
Second, we adopt the packing and sorted batching strategies to speed up
supervised fine-tuning on data with varied length distributions. Additionally,
we develop a loss weighting method to balance the contribution to the loss
across different sequences during packing training. Third, we introduce the
LongBench-Chat benchmark for evaluating instruction-following capabilities on
queries of 10k-100k in length. Experiments show that LongAlign outperforms
existing recipes for LLMs in long context tasks by up to 30\%, while also
maintaining their proficiency in handling short, generic tasks. The code, data,
and long-aligned models are open-sourced at https://github.com/THUDM/LongAlign.
|
[
-0.0968171582,
-0.6254038215,
0.5451385975,
0.315199405,
-0.0446448736,
-0.2585000694,
-0.6667335033,
-0.2836812139,
0.136566028,
0.6980870962,
-0.6975226998,
-0.7655031681,
-0.4042979181,
-0.0886534601,
-0.5479207635,
0.9285203815,
-0.2762684226,
-0.0244180355,
-0.3323335946,
-0.2707464695,
-0.8142151237,
-0.3091539741,
-0.5536848903,
-0.1407258809,
0.7343801856,
0.6063104272,
0.5974889398,
1.1108170748,
0.3004075289,
0.2574605644,
0.2062083185,
0.0250742827,
-0.7375546098,
0.3966563344,
-0.3406140506,
-0.235299632,
-0.4994260967,
-0.2432243973,
0.7848762274,
0.751367569,
-0.2685748041,
0.1638163626,
0.3789018691,
0.9262398481,
-0.6044667363,
0.0886395797,
-0.1421433538,
-0.1692610383,
-0.5869452953,
-0.015409572,
-0.4873292446,
-0.1411016285,
-0.0836846307,
-0.5907794833,
-0.1098572761,
0.2217229158,
0.2956928015,
0.5216615796,
-0.6161924601,
-0.473353982,
-0.6037813425,
0.8534282446,
-0.6314703822,
0.5954230428,
0.4199534953,
0.4148646295,
-0.5189816952,
-0.6639176607,
-0.221810773,
0.0949345455,
0.0678739101,
0.0462301038,
0.305211395,
0.0978052691,
0.1797569394,
0.2570349872,
-0.8478443623,
0.6947360039,
-0.3847953677,
0.1616042107,
0.5887488127,
0.0662135929,
0.1031590253,
0.2066383213,
-0.5099534392,
-0.0532972179,
-0.9472783208,
0.0842471197,
0.30788517,
0.4663615525,
-0.271451205,
0.5704724789,
-0.404846549,
1.022767067,
0.1990700364,
-0.0905603245,
0.0437644161,
-0.1196055561,
-0.2700859308,
0.6155813932,
0.6655741334,
0.6085617542,
0.1499664932,
-0.0539772436,
-0.22440584,
-0.3676323593,
0.1032308266,
-0.8624228239,
-0.079456374,
0.0651974231,
-0.188908428,
0.0675937533,
-0.1766910404,
-0.6752409339,
-0.261688292,
-0.6345655918,
0.2617557049,
-0.2516419291,
0.1943273246,
0.3814758062,
0.2310233563,
0.4910185337,
0.2157306224,
-1.0846778154,
0.3693208098,
1.2618472576,
0.6781083941,
-0.4851828516,
-0.3985361159,
-0.7628521919,
0.3491324782,
-0.2698249221,
0.3996535242,
-0.6119396687,
-0.1678763479,
0.2149285078,
0.4126724005,
0.0287564211,
-0.3816838562,
0.5466623902,
-0.3450419605,
0.4659888148,
-0.1624016613,
-1.0971633196,
0.1178431213,
0.2451499999,
-0.6833662391,
0.9816079736,
0.0512787104,
-0.3090793192,
0.3406551182,
-0.5321671367,
-0.8253675103,
-0.0687022656,
-0.1529762447,
-0.3173967898,
-0.1438961029,
0.2482033968,
0.5910248756,
-0.2320127785,
0.2899626493,
-0.4268962443,
-0.6017650962,
0.0323823579,
-0.3974795938,
0.6491500139,
0.0269691776,
-0.3845227063,
0.2568031251,
-0.5536301136,
0.0172101967,
0.0425776467,
-0.3743693233,
-0.4797325134,
0.142507568,
-0.2364322245,
-0.0303110387,
0.2312659919,
-0.1878466606,
0.5919690132,
-0.3126448393,
0.4907878637,
0.7958043218,
-0.3122158051,
0.6387757063,
-0.1148977429,
0.4228706956,
-0.1517889947,
0.1563979387,
-0.2822065055,
-0.13348943,
-0.6646649837,
-0.1142929569,
0.2898187339,
0.4521197677,
-0.4040811062,
0.6542032361,
-0.6991748214,
-0.0709015951,
-0.5104520917,
0.487554431,
0.4757869542,
0.5609427094,
0.5266526341,
-0.3505121171,
-0.3408175409,
-0.8325416446,
-0.0196998846,
0.4578037262,
0.0262206979,
0.0246363245,
0.3431710303,
-0.1627249867,
0.7247177362,
-0.5384323001,
-0.2420764714,
0.0131074358,
0.0157851912,
0.2088038176,
0.7364962101,
0.2626768351,
-0.3695052862,
-0.4838934839,
-0.0917716995,
-0.6153630614,
0.110298872,
-0.0715832859,
-0.5140717626,
0.4551391602,
0.9560013413,
-0.6951771379,
0.2835780084,
0.6928277612,
-0.128397584,
0.4094971716,
0.093599461,
0.0631297752,
-1.3695031404,
-0.175467521,
-0.0029429495,
-0.4251096845,
-0.3215459287,
0.0114923092,
0.3921257854,
-0.1592087597,
-0.3939742446,
0.6649965644,
-0.6240861416,
0.0246591792,
-0.1647535563,
-0.0068556983,
0.0566916503,
0.4250901341,
-0.0659325942,
0.8461726308,
0.5625190735,
-0.522451818,
0.5331766605,
-0.1022895202,
-0.6993160844,
0.6091023088,
-0.5063540936,
0.2612516284,
0.021568941,
0.5030930042,
-0.783272624,
-0.4636649489,
0.3325567544,
-0.0145225851,
0.7713207006,
-0.5891271234,
-0.4916576445,
-0.4081302881,
-0.159247607,
0.707603097,
0.3926637173,
-0.7440675497,
0.1272266656,
0.0264621209,
-0.1838022321,
-0.7555838823,
-0.5714860559,
0.0491634756,
-0.4563629925,
-0.4886977077,
0.5698925257,
-0.1215414628,
0.091331251,
-0.156087786,
-0.2433764786,
-0.0472148359,
-0.0750418007,
0.2720135748,
-0.1852787435,
-0.5357223749,
0.4646133184,
0.1603304893,
-0.0585138761,
0.1132120937,
-0.5467848182,
0.6114490032,
0.0022511194,
-0.6838002801,
-0.4486027658,
0.4225651026,
0.4389185011,
-0.2153550982,
0.7164211869,
0.507562995,
-0.3195800185,
-0.3292860687,
-0.5074685216,
-0.087847434,
-0.5064587593,
0.4156093597,
-0.0805948302,
-0.8494161963,
0.2689599097,
-0.0505528636,
0.1392156482,
0.1972418427,
0.2669124901,
-0.3571905196,
0.9613037109,
0.6905500889,
-0.4080631733,
0.4238518178,
0.0118763326,
0.2221053094,
-0.6263535619,
0.0264493879,
-0.2218891978,
-0.6472001672,
-0.4307681918,
-0.5568193197,
0.0563047715,
0.1367693841,
-0.3908053935,
0.3208552599,
-0.4671353996,
0.8653677702,
0.5748095512,
-0.0148095815,
-0.0915728584,
-0.2070696205,
0.350858748,
0.1081774607,
-0.4869942367,
-0.2651165426,
0.8799845576,
0.3325761557,
1.1895222664,
0.1388485134,
1.0869436264,
0.006623101,
0.12482097,
-1.0981211662,
0.5463664532,
-0.2839963138,
-0.4865121245,
-0.5391860604,
-0.3601472378,
-1.1470302343,
-0.4976584911,
0.1267964244,
-0.4871304929,
-0.2934800088,
0.1900694817,
-0.3555760682,
-0.0115485685,
-0.6754543185,
1.2398455143,
-0.8108856678,
-0.4113233089,
-0.1086027995,
-0.7971006036,
0.2470075488,
0.1120439172,
-0.0186872818,
-0.0544936694,
0.1523399651,
0.8172557354,
-0.2130434215,
1.037304163,
-0.0475620031,
-0.3334797323,
0.0816337839,
0.0062821759,
0.4374205172,
-0.1294230819,
-0.0100580035,
-0.2630273104,
-0.0020555297,
-0.4742235541,
-0.7730828524,
1.0559618473,
-0.3757933974,
-0.7086298466,
-0.2369738519,
-0.5879765153,
-0.0455339812,
0.5171192884,
0.1165997237,
0.5440468788,
-0.2254730016,
0.4564997852,
0.6899323463,
-0.1068494841,
0.3687745929,
0.1646069288,
-0.2418707311,
-0.1997375041,
0.7260429859,
0.0986200422,
0.2733545601,
0.5807158947,
0.0827179924,
-0.2025094777,
-0.2862308919,
-0.6241047382,
0.0366308764,
-0.7537938952,
-0.4312652051,
0.0342045538,
-0.2357553095,
-0.5010334253,
-0.2894251645,
-0.5956065059,
-0.303422004,
-0.2827654779,
0.1369967461,
0.274417609,
0.6372756958,
0.4630983174,
0.4575685561,
-0.7111266851,
-0.128555268,
0.3153108656,
0.6830258369,
-0.1409261078,
-0.4276838601,
-0.4832066596,
0.1976295859,
-0.2833552063,
-0.5672471523,
0.0988841429,
0.2945925891,
0.2819758654,
0.4736203551,
0.1511455923,
1.0810326338,
-0.6364641786,
0.6259334683,
0.2683945,
-0.6886685491,
0.4372560382,
-0.2925219238,
0.6720420122,
0.6878831983,
0.5001940131,
-0.5932241678,
-0.0036179731,
0.0133267175,
-1.0224955082,
0.3984153569,
-0.2054890394,
0.1245352849,
-0.1765503734,
0.4357261062,
0.2332448661,
-0.1062834933,
-0.6090307832,
-0.0356178209,
-0.0140020773,
-0.7606871724,
-0.191137284,
-0.1525714546,
-0.4889607131,
-0.2009746879,
0.5124866962,
-0.1971998215,
0.0775020793,
-0.2348607332,
-0.3467365503,
0.0254141688,
0.3404892981,
0.852496624,
0.8520104289,
-0.1054778248,
0.0910482481,
0.0822281688,
0.03009413,
-0.1085548699,
0.2599988282,
0.3116671741,
-0.3820784986,
0.3898662329,
0.6894379854,
0.5953144431,
-0.4898688495,
0.5364285111,
-0.0475192294,
-0.005257267,
-0.4217282534,
0.0904039964,
0.3861053586,
0.1870286912,
-0.0317358859,
-0.5697435141,
0.0526819676,
-0.499796778,
0.1883655936,
0.3754388094,
-0.4100215733,
-0.1096290946,
0.2957814038,
0.2260392755,
-0.3019007444,
1.0913100243,
-0.1267611533,
-0.2757604718,
0.5130674243,
0.7763841748,
0.5578664541,
-0.209535569,
-0.2781695127,
0.2518541217,
-0.1118946448,
-0.4478542507,
-0.1631818861,
-0.1587017328,
-0.2008268237,
-0.6667913795,
-0.4797098041,
-0.1081772447,
0.2052660882,
-0.8655075431,
0.5516493917,
-0.2192821205,
0.0223792046,
-0.0913659036,
-0.1968779713,
-0.7153821588,
-0.0304072239,
0.354051441,
0.8656479716,
-0.6257786751,
1.0009964705,
0.4365810156,
0.0236342531,
-0.5636422038,
-0.0000347841,
0.1793996692,
-0.9266549349,
0.6049202681,
0.6805323958,
-0.1000496,
-0.2478713989,
-0.7085191011,
-0.9676451087,
1.0398068428,
0.227726236,
-1.0826883316,
-0.2404467463,
0.1939313859,
0.2809525728,
-0.4277718365,
-0.3961363137,
0.4873341024,
0.2826337516,
0.0758785754,
-0.8842471838,
0.0414225757,
-0.0101124765,
-0.396269381,
0.6799305081,
-0.3806806505,
0.3184039891,
-0.0105869807,
-0.1909882277,
0.2222557664,
0.8259960413,
-0.0367802866,
0.4340840578,
0.3952144682,
0.8038529754,
0.5286781788,
0.0054547596,
0.6392000318,
-0.5320461988,
0.1650062501,
1.7616380453,
-0.317825526,
0.8771879077,
0.4280212522,
0.2149066925,
0.3894181848,
0.7048480511,
0.1300925165,
0.4329674542,
0.341863364,
-0.0166730098,
-0.1095488891,
0.1267794222,
-0.3772813082,
0.4453036785,
0.4441764653,
-0.3789668977,
-0.1576556116,
-0.1514676064,
0.2464928478,
-0.0545410961,
-0.2525431514,
0.7509081364,
0.3165032268,
-1.0378119946,
0.9001128674,
-0.1761590838,
0.586796999,
-0.4375818372,
-0.0815025792,
-0.2458111942,
0.245807901,
-0.1186594591,
-1.1665945053,
0.0713014901,
-0.2103098631,
-0.1379127055,
-0.4305731952,
0.2941294909,
-0.767696619,
-0.3853993714,
0.1405465305,
0.0824387223,
0.1195044592,
0.2285090536,
-0.595058322,
0.055191908,
-0.2639499009,
-0.2024178058,
0.5501974821,
0.3880765438,
-0.287956804,
0.6261860132,
0.2642895281,
-0.239097476,
0.0475758575,
0.2884293795,
0.6257739067,
-0.7541072369,
-0.253483057,
-0.910790801,
0.4335919023,
-0.0833110139,
-0.3646419346,
0.5565725565,
0.7766558528,
0.9530703425,
-0.0145221809,
0.1556569934,
0.2061477751,
0.1751031578,
-0.8774889112,
0.4446243346,
-0.5941542387,
0.0901527926,
0.2588118017,
-1.0696702003,
-0.3492642641,
0.3160713613,
-0.3956452012,
0.0174332205,
0.4724538326,
0.884357214,
-0.5979442,
-0.2517911494,
0.0039602835,
-0.0162511691,
0.3283845484,
0.612947166,
0.6364827156,
-0.0916536748,
0.2899292111,
-0.3535241187,
-0.0435409695,
-0.3696966469,
-1.1082264185,
-0.7829996347,
-0.6223524809,
-0.2074184716,
-0.1923204809,
0.3444644511,
1.1493698359,
0.9913906455,
-0.5543162227,
-0.4548034072,
0.2067937851,
0.0001866933,
-0.3253028691,
-0.1966117471,
0.5047482848,
-0.4735472798,
-0.6349174976,
0.6570040584,
0.1404807419,
0.2152512521,
0.0815521851,
-0.1652191281,
-0.0131058712,
-0.2753837407,
0.6920993924,
0.5891334414,
-0.7217252851,
-0.47461465,
0.0846093595,
-0.1956858784,
0.1260394156,
0.6185545325,
-0.3978363276,
0.44889009,
0.2599388361,
0.6765785217,
0.4519139826,
0.1840571612,
0.7159715295,
-1.0342265368,
-0.0294110347,
0.1652816683,
0.3373249471,
0.4253919125,
-0.3336816132,
0.4357367754,
-0.5754694343,
-0.9532191157,
-0.8718554974,
0.2346381545,
-1.2201453447,
-0.1879768968,
1.1344462633,
-0.0672948584,
-0.42742607,
0.3737566471,
0.0169371292,
0.4410538077,
-0.3406493962,
0.7460361719,
0.701120913,
-0.0981301889,
-0.0394928232,
-0.5970416069,
0.4706920087,
0.460957408,
-0.7548232675,
0.4059625566,
0.5690954924,
0.4293889105,
-0.1176372617,
0.2524951696,
0.134195894,
0.1690246463,
-0.6616092324,
0.0083178012,
0.057193242,
-0.5374916792,
-0.3174562156,
-0.3252607882,
0.1536921561,
-0.1518265158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18046v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18046v2
|
Multipath parsing in the brain
| 2024-01-31T18:07:12 | 2024-06-06T13:40:47 |
Berta Franzluebbers, Donald Dunagan, Miloš Stanojević, Jan Buys, John T. Hale
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans understand sentences word-by-word, in the order that they hear them.
This incrementality entails resolving temporary ambiguities about syntactic
relationships. We investigate how humans process these syntactic ambiguities by
correlating predictions from incremental generative dependency parsers with
timecourse data from people undergoing functional neuroimaging while listening
to an audiobook. In particular, we compare competing hypotheses regarding the
number of developing syntactic analyses in play during word-by-word
comprehension: one vs more than one. This comparison involves evaluating
syntactic surprisal from a state-of-the-art dependency parser with LLM-adapted
encodings against an existing fMRI dataset. In both English and Chinese data,
we find evidence for multipath parsing. Brain regions associated with this
multipath effect include bilateral superior temporal gyrus.
|
[
-0.3285855949,
-0.7327281237,
1.0033444166,
0.6627078652,
-0.007358388,
-0.1287674606,
-0.0414127,
-0.8050938845,
0.2931660116,
0.1546880007,
-0.8608524203,
-0.2495271713,
-0.5462066531,
0.1180452108,
0.0050061587,
0.4341299236,
0.1490142792,
0.3057940602,
-0.2413616031,
-0.5552501082,
-0.6276145577,
-0.795932889,
-0.6080808043,
-0.638487339,
0.7690614462,
0.0027741715,
0.8949622512,
0.4244640768,
0.2342452407,
0.296613723,
-0.242028743,
-0.3667548001,
0.4850627184,
0.261287868,
-0.0243858434,
-0.4193252623,
-0.3013971746,
-0.1566862315,
0.512326777,
0.8933469057,
-0.3364929557,
-0.1712570339,
-0.112082839,
0.6279872656,
-0.4783975184,
-0.2024234235,
-0.073639378,
0.2027717084,
-0.4358203113,
-0.4406879842,
-0.5264557004,
0.0719494671,
0.3641477525,
-0.3557627797,
0.2124031484,
-0.0922542289,
0.7595955729,
0.2613674998,
-0.5677326322,
-0.3018164933,
-0.3825334013,
0.3881599307,
-0.5080750585,
0.7113584876,
0.3618380427,
0.1511099786,
-0.2632645667,
-0.5398474932,
-0.5723721385,
-0.3082435131,
-0.5111563802,
0.1878075302,
-0.0343282819,
0.1097136661,
0.410869807,
0.1783750355,
-0.6441178918,
-0.1653610617,
-0.391155839,
-0.3001836538,
0.1257476658,
0.2746576965,
0.5803956985,
-0.4984814823,
-0.4163274765,
-0.0228115302,
-0.2755264938,
0.2011312693,
0.5451376438,
0.0631214976,
-0.1519318819,
0.4779824018,
0.0917543024,
0.8883963823,
-0.3779154122,
-0.0427737497,
0.4820732176,
-0.5478981137,
0.0032615417,
0.1689436883,
0.7004534602,
0.0944015309,
0.1698976457,
-0.3125532269,
0.1459652632,
0.4192527235,
0.2081829011,
-0.2843276262,
-0.0702997223,
0.3765375316,
-0.4977703094,
0.2723109424,
-0.226505965,
-0.7037013173,
-0.5542648435,
-0.45114097,
0.2963812649,
-0.8600833416,
-0.0486165434,
0.4978538156,
-0.3868975639,
0.123175472,
0.1477593333,
-0.8745926619,
0.269908458,
0.193840608,
1.1348775625,
0.2314293683,
-0.8775479198,
-0.478941083,
0.3470592499,
0.0243590903,
1.1954283714,
-0.3807034791,
-0.1144279987,
-0.4685470462,
-0.0224620327,
-0.3089934289,
-0.3454078138,
0.5785115957,
-0.2144925892,
0.1800639927,
-0.3394637704,
-0.0753587112,
-0.3711925447,
0.0260241069,
-0.6813173294,
0.3169905245,
0.0326132663,
-0.9042259455,
0.419773519,
-0.6574565768,
-0.7317698598,
-0.2663444877,
-0.3206652403,
0.1367083639,
0.1876488626,
0.3537827432,
0.3008453846,
-0.0761097297,
0.3759101629,
-0.1387256831,
-0.2154429853,
0.285556823,
-0.60268718,
1.0876812935,
0.0205163285,
-0.0123149734,
0.1820813268,
-0.6416365504,
-0.2273684144,
-0.0207248237,
-0.4451500475,
-0.5945750475,
0.2761933506,
0.0491238981,
0.5492103696,
0.010109839,
-0.5923680663,
-0.014760904,
-0.3963850439,
0.5887896419,
0.6448270679,
0.15405114,
0.0727221444,
-0.5150130987,
0.3143878281,
0.5115173459,
0.0865138099,
-0.5261287689,
-0.4509326518,
-0.63643682,
-0.0112745557,
-0.0076180166,
0.5046925545,
-0.3637254536,
0.0468470603,
-0.2282123864,
-0.1266058832,
-0.6292081475,
-0.2324708402,
0.1956356168,
0.2489884943,
0.6969952583,
-0.3209370673,
-0.2878103256,
-0.9171577096,
-0.4698836505,
0.0123687489,
-0.1500348896,
0.2362859696,
-0.0066058422,
-0.3001293838,
0.5863534212,
-0.4144584239,
-0.5649636984,
-0.1127813905,
0.3425145745,
0.1697799861,
0.2948824763,
0.4417939186,
-0.4878336787,
-0.1443977505,
-0.2150419652,
-0.7672383189,
0.0147159463,
-0.6288383007,
-0.2195422053,
0.1390318424,
0.7168411016,
-0.7444921136,
0.1581329107,
0.5751039386,
-0.8650215864,
0.3057217896,
-0.3765692115,
0.1263495833,
-0.8601077199,
-0.1255664527,
0.0837280229,
0.0800755173,
-0.424524188,
-0.27352193,
-0.1142298728,
0.3572687805,
-0.1868488491,
0.3320600688,
-0.6351376772,
-0.3661982715,
0.2705185115,
0.1724081188,
0.2557671368,
0.5600888133,
0.0648710728,
0.5362570882,
0.4062173367,
-0.2907836735,
0.0827678666,
0.3279145956,
-0.3550178111,
0.2957367301,
-0.5966143012,
0.1266452968,
-0.4289374053,
0.196580857,
-1.0294958353,
-0.1926158369,
0.2822191715,
-0.373216778,
0.1836760491,
0.0096449489,
-0.5905621052,
0.0911358967,
-0.0285206623,
0.5623241663,
0.0706672445,
-0.4411239624,
0.7594272494,
0.2608181238,
0.0575453043,
-0.407168448,
-1.0502607822,
0.0263791308,
-0.1097136661,
-0.8476883769,
0.3622939587,
0.0077219466,
-0.383644402,
-0.0821951032,
-0.0292038824,
-0.0081175203,
0.0315070935,
0.3670311868,
0.0483517274,
-0.1579200476,
0.1180821359,
0.0903023556,
-0.0975603238,
0.3477040529,
0.1099608541,
0.7114423513,
0.1353643835,
-0.3329019248,
-0.331028223,
0.5377204418,
0.665027082,
-0.1191178933,
0.6696516871,
0.3641750813,
-0.1603351235,
0.2829903364,
-0.2961783111,
0.1323398203,
-0.4383452237,
0.0798362568,
-0.672226429,
-0.5703955889,
0.5461648107,
0.2758010924,
-0.2032903135,
0.1982000321,
0.3224267364,
-0.0157291703,
0.8201711774,
0.4061513245,
0.2761251032,
0.3239414096,
0.1386680454,
-0.0390048102,
-1.0357341766,
-0.2753928304,
-0.2616168857,
-0.2890767157,
-0.5278629065,
-0.1408859193,
0.2999906242,
-0.1412130147,
0.0343008414,
0.3052508533,
-0.3266991973,
0.5820208192,
0.3340471685,
0.3063797653,
0.3444183171,
-0.1820932925,
-0.4234039783,
-0.09844587,
-0.4320582747,
-0.1475642323,
0.8186300993,
0.3342873156,
0.4514639676,
0.3196614087,
0.3054572344,
0.1140669659,
0.1745485812,
-1.0133668184,
0.3499355614,
-0.4397999346,
-0.5001860261,
-0.1578020751,
-0.1219656542,
-0.8937525749,
0.6406735182,
-0.0495890602,
-0.795119524,
0.3713403046,
-0.0738572478,
-0.6701541543,
-0.0355631039,
-0.9601924419,
1.0501949787,
-0.3106305599,
-0.2682800591,
-0.3314054906,
-1.0134065151,
0.4590653777,
0.2401560098,
0.3263728321,
-0.0654160902,
0.2162183374,
0.6531215906,
0.1889434159,
0.4497771263,
-0.1932954639,
0.0934696123,
-0.0370062776,
0.175045222,
-0.3026806116,
0.0583150648,
-0.1174258143,
0.4688582718,
0.1631757319,
-0.2511866987,
-0.3594330549,
0.6684744954,
-0.6893446445,
-0.6134624481,
-0.8396526575,
-0.74286443,
-0.3266853094,
0.097316578,
0.4576867521,
0.5183692575,
0.0379238911,
-0.2245573103,
0.1271284074,
-0.37712273,
0.6265082955,
0.3237872124,
-0.0617931262,
-0.3618064523,
0.3499459028,
0.2602060437,
0.2135243863,
0.4530887306,
0.2345724404,
-0.3740570545,
-0.4289166331,
-0.2391573042,
0.5361751318,
-0.7729128599,
0.2059598714,
-0.9453274012,
-0.0733369142,
-0.207789436,
-0.0799263492,
0.0720918849,
-0.1605582237,
0.0293692257,
0.0539689437,
0.1671637744,
0.7676408291,
-0.0756822675,
0.2980363667,
-1.0167125463,
0.4584349692,
0.0504274741,
0.2923565209,
0.0944905505,
-0.1895083338,
-0.1352831721,
-0.0737159476,
-0.3347505033,
-1.0345157385,
0.1324891299,
0.064937152,
0.3262755573,
0.1096230894,
-0.3896105587,
0.9667475224,
-0.7589678168,
0.5842561126,
0.2345768958,
-1.0569601059,
0.4997692704,
-0.3271379471,
0.7208947539,
0.4267163277,
0.2900189459,
-1.0159167051,
-0.3916448951,
-0.3664805293,
-0.8899579048,
0.8182931542,
-0.1395739317,
-0.0569311753,
-0.1653118432,
0.2597054839,
0.2305590063,
-0.2434201241,
-0.7333176732,
-0.2288600057,
-0.1797913015,
0.1096024439,
-0.3367336392,
-0.2484353632,
0.015327543,
-0.3298034668,
-0.0827337652,
0.1543882787,
0.4607378244,
0.4530532956,
-0.0869117454,
-0.2318726033,
0.3801431358,
0.6825137734,
0.6267490983,
-0.2978702784,
0.3822723925,
-0.0742420778,
-0.5853334069,
0.3702188134,
-0.017147338,
0.2174252421,
0.2706563473,
0.7145042419,
0.6786459088,
-0.0582307987,
-0.402113229,
0.4120713174,
-0.3963762522,
-0.0919645503,
-0.4820288718,
0.0104632098,
0.4323522747,
0.4093901217,
-0.1161713898,
0.5818596482,
0.2949682176,
-0.4965807199,
0.2972747684,
0.1843435168,
0.0086782956,
-0.4955108464,
0.5868484378,
-0.2487449795,
-0.228380084,
0.7362888455,
0.0652128533,
-0.1659874469,
0.348993808,
0.4985073209,
0.9500521421,
-0.065331772,
0.0296212677,
0.3503549099,
0.1924088597,
-0.0952023864,
0.3758324981,
-0.049316287,
-0.8648731709,
-0.6302671432,
-0.7924623489,
-0.176185742,
0.1442860365,
-0.592081666,
0.304390341,
-0.4209380746,
-0.3192776144,
0.5446849465,
-0.5989030004,
-0.557305336,
-0.0456460826,
0.1392104626,
0.8143827319,
-0.857806921,
1.064299345,
0.9044139385,
-0.540686965,
-0.7275668979,
0.7545401454,
-0.140401721,
-0.4413310587,
0.5676291585,
0.4785347283,
-0.353007704,
-0.0156650227,
-0.0118113114,
-0.7396275997,
1.0125005245,
0.4943121076,
-0.4209745824,
-0.3146162033,
-0.0388758406,
0.6279847026,
-0.0778486952,
0.2151094526,
0.604940176,
0.4322115183,
-0.0476730689,
-0.5500859618,
0.2365522981,
-0.0847219452,
0.0349660479,
0.5922911167,
-0.5811225176,
0.9819383621,
-0.2803135514,
-0.4478019178,
-0.2270420641,
0.2318071872,
0.2144401968,
0.2991912067,
0.5091397166,
0.6133626699,
0.3073081374,
0.0699485689,
0.9813218713,
-0.203850016,
-0.0778891891,
1.1966154575,
-0.0585235581,
0.6220655441,
0.8902392387,
-0.3391233385,
0.7272857428,
0.5709576011,
0.2481339425,
0.487873584,
0.0734800771,
-0.2702231407,
-0.1728363782,
-0.0810748711,
-0.0553883687,
0.6681667566,
0.3682704866,
-0.0932131335,
-0.4108185768,
0.0703621507,
-0.0179560222,
-0.0782192573,
0.1664084494,
0.5867041349,
0.2830018401,
-0.8757771254,
0.3686369956,
-0.1011871547,
0.6373689175,
-0.6551500559,
-0.0399617516,
-0.1764649749,
0.1574887484,
-0.2767847478,
-0.9552175403,
0.6784626842,
-0.4275856912,
-0.2600095272,
-0.253252387,
0.22992073,
-0.27621755,
-0.0156500041,
1.0596265793,
0.5829663873,
0.0534295738,
0.0951771736,
-0.6376523972,
-0.1225692332,
-0.1609470248,
-0.4411913157,
0.4428480566,
0.6124685407,
0.0209226087,
0.5705815554,
0.6272302866,
0.2029608339,
0.1737976074,
0.3202145994,
0.6536642313,
-0.9662983418,
-0.5199304223,
-1.220870018,
0.5550771952,
0.3704668283,
-0.3827946782,
0.373996675,
0.0722758919,
0.9027361274,
0.0572883561,
0.5550909638,
-0.2087946981,
0.1567552388,
-0.7469394803,
0.4342727363,
-0.6708845496,
0.3218964338,
-0.0891746134,
-0.7281299233,
-0.4395319521,
0.6032117605,
-0.2385511696,
-0.1872294396,
1.2283300161,
0.556494236,
-0.2065840662,
0.080802843,
0.2767702937,
0.161518842,
0.0862602741,
0.8248513937,
0.8784214854,
-0.2659596503,
0.1627825201,
-0.3430163264,
-0.0597715229,
0.4672926664,
-0.6901876926,
-0.5836377144,
-0.6197342873,
0.0239330009,
-0.3415622711,
-0.0251507983,
0.8511099219,
0.2246191204,
-0.5672145486,
-0.4755144119,
-0.2860633731,
0.2076887786,
-0.230524227,
-0.2502762675,
0.2612461448,
-0.495484978,
-0.3446701169,
0.4201495945,
0.4905364215,
0.0941173732,
-0.1662038714,
0.0999648497,
-0.6970291734,
-0.1082853079,
0.5374366045,
-0.1326594949,
-0.8004801869,
-0.4580091238,
0.0481711738,
-0.087215513,
0.4452851713,
1.0343739986,
-0.7455255985,
0.3692051768,
0.5932266116,
0.1863776296,
0.1272277236,
-0.0852286741,
0.5087730885,
-0.5375653505,
0.2696415186,
-0.0045767967,
0.4729911387,
0.3057714105,
-0.5986370444,
0.4035196304,
0.335308522,
-0.5677317977,
-0.4310276806,
0.356855154,
-0.9573768973,
-0.527639091,
1.0165016651,
-0.0459403209,
-0.0602592789,
-0.3711764812,
-0.1426422596,
0.3011732101,
-0.1778955907,
0.5684700012,
1.0744456053,
-0.7716985941,
-0.1342000663,
-0.746435523,
0.3579291701,
0.3930024505,
-0.5604807138,
0.2781527042,
0.6866452098,
0.2230610102,
0.4848671854,
1.0417377949,
-0.0685837269,
0.2358589023,
0.1543551236,
-0.1306617558,
0.2860345542,
-0.5221262574,
-0.446216017,
0.1687713712,
-0.0346246362,
-0.267590493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18045v1
|
SpeechComposer: Unifying Multiple Speech Tasks with Prompt Composition
| 2024-01-31T18:06:29 | 2024-01-31T18:06:29 |
Yihan Wu, Soumi Maiti, Yifan Peng, Wangyou Zhang, Chenda Li, Yuyue Wang, Xihua Wang, Shinji Watanabe, Ruihua Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent advancements in language models have significantly enhanced
performance in multiple speech-related tasks. Existing speech language models
typically utilize task-dependent prompt tokens to unify various speech tasks in
a single model. However, this design omits the intrinsic connections between
different speech tasks, which can potentially boost the performance of each
task. In this work, we propose a novel decoder-only speech language model,
SpeechComposer, that can unify common speech tasks by composing a fixed set of
prompt tokens. Built upon four primary tasks -- speech synthesis, speech
recognition, speech language modeling, and text language modeling --
SpeechComposer can easily extend to more speech tasks via compositions of
well-designed prompt tokens, like voice conversion and speech enhancement. The
unification of prompt tokens also makes it possible for knowledge sharing among
different speech tasks in a more structured manner. Experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed SpeechComposer can improve the performance of
both primary tasks and composite tasks, showing the effectiveness of the shared
prompt tokens. Remarkably, the unified decoder-only model achieves a comparable
and even better performance than the baselines which are expert models designed
for single tasks.
|
[
-0.0660395026,
-0.4572554231,
0.3172083497,
0.373270303,
-0.3839778006,
0.08363235,
-0.1815117747,
-0.1626172364,
0.2949048579,
0.6207094193,
-0.5911024809,
-0.3789687157,
-0.4946150482,
0.2200331986,
-0.2681989968,
0.8231980801,
0.3958981037,
0.0627712682,
-0.3642477989,
-0.128828451,
-1.2357435226,
-0.6079676151,
-0.6550174952,
-0.3891120255,
0.5345266461,
0.5094729662,
0.1832369715,
0.5151157975,
0.2198536843,
0.3986153901,
-0.1053582728,
0.0424585603,
-0.2151046246,
0.4520157576,
-0.1590296924,
-0.3301489353,
-0.3618255258,
-0.3351254165,
0.6683478355,
0.8420712352,
-0.1061822399,
0.125306204,
0.3677018285,
0.1323218793,
-0.5780527592,
0.274551928,
-0.47181198,
-0.2175194919,
-0.0837342367,
-0.08451318,
-0.5338711143,
0.0447829105,
0.0124850273,
-0.5079349875,
0.1898165494,
-0.2298981696,
0.052877441,
0.437364608,
-0.4091279507,
0.0340733677,
-0.7838955522,
0.7727699876,
-0.4919776618,
0.3841918707,
-0.147197023,
0.4000133574,
0.1320526302,
-0.9167982936,
-0.478351742,
-0.1493222415,
-0.0719785169,
0.1327586025,
-0.5260797143,
0.1968186647,
0.0569699816,
0.0241000149,
-0.4615201652,
0.0428783819,
-0.3130642176,
-0.4554371834,
0.1446931213,
0.3034119606,
0.6144177914,
-0.2960435152,
-0.5102328658,
-0.0173152182,
-0.4336509705,
0.4160523713,
-0.0098922523,
0.8410112262,
-0.022396775,
0.542350471,
-0.1924351603,
0.7002396584,
0.014151305,
-0.2278427929,
0.0932722464,
-0.5137203336,
-0.0442237146,
0.4029019475,
0.6504821777,
0.0871280357,
-0.3064505458,
-0.3907684386,
-0.1240188405,
0.3174653649,
0.1437356323,
-0.6549265385,
-0.2172325999,
0.1358165592,
-0.4014796317,
0.0148057677,
-0.0087933447,
-0.3175035119,
-0.3918953836,
-0.4639841616,
0.510710299,
-0.3212551177,
-0.3814864755,
0.1001057029,
-0.4353423119,
-0.0974308923,
0.0483952761,
-0.7523640394,
0.4932759106,
0.9161888957,
0.7920464873,
-0.5195048451,
-0.5523061156,
-1.0717037916,
0.2713736594,
0.048521135,
0.8759997487,
-0.6360544562,
-0.6359613538,
-0.2390893996,
-0.056214802,
-0.3000302613,
-0.422644794,
0.8588065505,
-0.1941301823,
0.0460306555,
-0.4303535521,
-0.6900386214,
-0.1260971278,
-0.0425666161,
-0.9854398966,
0.7278629541,
-0.3271113634,
-0.7128580809,
0.0879554972,
-0.9609490633,
-0.5688009262,
0.5462905765,
-0.161802426,
0.1714291722,
0.1630551815,
0.3536941707,
0.3187116981,
-0.2658931613,
0.4725986719,
0.3448260427,
-0.4873797894,
0.3369604349,
-0.5336933732,
0.7532365322,
0.1119580343,
-0.1368833184,
0.5527253747,
-0.8160161376,
-0.0524298772,
-0.3424887359,
-0.424240768,
-0.1796107143,
-0.1168877408,
0.2832951546,
0.0796868056,
0.4522507191,
-0.7275931239,
0.004631937,
-0.2341128141,
0.5053753257,
0.4712525904,
-0.1141810492,
0.5957010984,
-0.5541300774,
0.7119062543,
0.1357675344,
-0.169067353,
-0.5971110463,
-0.661444366,
-0.5413689613,
-0.7399381399,
0.1598374844,
0.6793391705,
-0.5927310586,
0.4216160178,
-0.356331408,
-0.4149481952,
-0.6448459029,
-0.1265451908,
0.4479122758,
0.7512466908,
0.3033780456,
-0.0720973834,
-0.701864481,
-0.7620077133,
-0.5145195127,
-0.0075196638,
-0.1638416648,
-0.1504145712,
-0.0220826101,
0.028267201,
1.1508858204,
-0.3305112123,
-0.4476614892,
-0.6242174506,
0.1029940546,
0.400497973,
0.7012168765,
0.1266584843,
-0.7445325851,
-0.3255442679,
-0.1972172409,
-0.1184894219,
-0.3145787716,
0.0322754756,
0.3019840121,
-0.0028074528,
0.5078860521,
-0.6807370186,
0.100456886,
0.5373607278,
-0.3213077486,
0.5480589271,
-0.2302608043,
0.0785451457,
-1.2548279762,
0.3370015323,
-0.4050732255,
-0.0626393408,
-1.0864801407,
-0.1235165149,
-0.1660429835,
-0.6456013918,
-0.5694463253,
0.6232455969,
-0.1918462962,
-0.0122960173,
-0.5436829329,
-0.0902629048,
0.0781223997,
0.4827906191,
-0.033605665,
0.8853500485,
0.9096437097,
-0.601804018,
0.5318404436,
0.3470669985,
-0.1631154865,
0.4952874482,
-1.063939929,
0.2931522727,
-0.2487722188,
0.1460195482,
-1.3586800098,
-0.2533552647,
0.1355495602,
-0.470153749,
-0.0778024942,
-0.070252873,
-0.3520773947,
-0.1395844668,
0.167994827,
0.432783097,
0.3245568871,
-0.5186748505,
0.9485901594,
0.3802910745,
-0.6936569214,
-0.3478242159,
-0.7294196486,
0.2088766694,
-0.1033379138,
-0.6260709763,
0.6113301516,
-0.1713875383,
0.0910917595,
0.030532321,
-0.2202158123,
-0.1982894987,
-0.2166389078,
0.4521600008,
0.2088540941,
-0.0099555394,
0.3334987462,
0.088348344,
-0.4035829902,
-0.2013327479,
-0.4112016261,
0.5801896453,
0.0990068316,
-0.3312647641,
-0.7339590788,
1.0409365892,
0.6829618812,
-0.6569101214,
0.4703201056,
0.4320443869,
-0.2520330548,
-0.0717461482,
-0.5864249468,
-0.2185536176,
-0.4646745324,
0.3064329922,
-0.7688921094,
-1.2256388664,
0.6016808748,
-0.0168308504,
0.2200762033,
0.0853477493,
0.3447817564,
0.2883731425,
1.0664247274,
0.6788624525,
-0.1780320704,
0.472684443,
0.2216657251,
0.1902596056,
-0.5661835074,
-0.3924294412,
-0.7894489169,
-0.1921345741,
-0.2432729453,
-0.4222270846,
0.4837738276,
-0.3180486262,
-0.1155335084,
0.4292497933,
-0.6872264147,
0.5755871534,
0.9607591033,
0.0547930337,
0.3609927297,
0.0802450404,
-0.0941674262,
0.0288388841,
-0.7942097783,
-0.4585932791,
0.6679536104,
-0.0661594495,
0.3525644243,
-0.1599184424,
0.7713175416,
0.0346450582,
-0.4439896047,
-0.6772962213,
0.6815854907,
-0.5512496829,
-0.407856226,
-0.3320052624,
-0.4686440825,
-0.9407227039,
0.4402238727,
0.085278146,
-0.6263664365,
0.0920066237,
0.0703748688,
-0.4039035738,
0.0048849629,
-0.6447651982,
0.9382288456,
0.1181443706,
0.1716405898,
-0.2415443063,
-0.5094753504,
0.0478494689,
0.1191774085,
0.131369859,
-0.0717488527,
-0.0764363334,
0.8967312574,
-0.2083516717,
0.9711458087,
-0.2964844108,
0.1284092218,
0.3588462174,
-0.0688415319,
0.3820341229,
-0.1697445661,
-0.2547245622,
-0.1206212863,
0.0394326113,
-0.2397773713,
-0.5315617323,
0.6361772418,
-0.6051160097,
-0.6501594186,
0.0293493904,
-0.7721535563,
-0.2101465911,
0.5623086691,
0.187001422,
0.9043061137,
-0.3204842508,
0.1457227021,
0.2934153378,
0.0729758516,
0.6414313316,
0.4001098275,
0.1899055988,
-0.7329528332,
0.901109457,
-0.1536033452,
0.0688187331,
0.5662494302,
0.2576174438,
-0.4841971993,
-0.3095770478,
-0.0936603099,
-0.0510740653,
-0.7444142699,
-0.0024231651,
-0.785870254,
0.0611818843,
-0.7251229882,
0.0557358526,
-0.3278771341,
-0.5007187128,
-0.5264686942,
0.0263214558,
0.1387463361,
0.4587077796,
-0.2164895087,
0.4428662956,
-0.9598252773,
0.6718363166,
0.7313519716,
0.0525367372,
-0.1201352552,
-0.4097387493,
0.0155323287,
0.0809176415,
-0.0720985755,
-0.7545847297,
0.2446977198,
0.1554424018,
0.7284619212,
0.2125486434,
0.1821353287,
0.6153396368,
-0.626609087,
0.8705011606,
0.6326236129,
-1.1987371445,
0.2850230634,
-0.2709693015,
0.7328158617,
0.6345534921,
-0.1217257455,
-0.7225320935,
-0.2784258723,
-0.1679645777,
-0.6778314114,
0.8132450581,
0.1202085018,
0.3380436897,
-0.0049862685,
-0.0867663845,
0.2512926459,
0.1880118251,
-0.465549916,
-0.2972614169,
-0.365442574,
-0.1617410034,
-0.1424243599,
-0.1852669865,
-0.1192647591,
-0.3491797745,
0.3753964305,
-0.0748835728,
0.2954236269,
0.1221061349,
0.0051942668,
0.1663783491,
0.7038004398,
0.4925425351,
0.4943673313,
0.2243719995,
0.3674794734,
-0.1578415781,
-0.3394314647,
0.3300947547,
0.3818812966,
-0.1402011812,
0.3211845756,
0.2926160097,
1.0594332218,
0.6448938251,
-0.5977482796,
0.4365717471,
-0.0985882282,
0.0691734925,
0.10196767,
0.1347615719,
0.4440857768,
0.2139581442,
0.582710743,
0.3790735602,
0.2919097841,
-0.338483423,
0.3660492003,
0.2599389851,
-0.3038710654,
-0.3603360057,
0.8511012197,
0.4865995944,
-0.5136627555,
0.2996799648,
-0.0409080908,
-0.4711294472,
0.5095597506,
0.8361896873,
0.9675340056,
-0.6235319376,
0.2843007445,
0.150063619,
-0.056234166,
-0.082245864,
0.476139307,
-0.3213571906,
-0.4376349151,
-0.6902629733,
-0.3847945631,
-0.3713021576,
-0.2289585024,
-0.638861239,
0.2115665674,
0.1217194721,
-0.2175356895,
0.1204615757,
-0.237872839,
-0.4576876462,
0.0114506977,
0.0432136096,
0.6664544344,
-0.6408667564,
0.702224493,
1.0025126934,
-0.1656662673,
-1.112052083,
-0.3108374476,
-0.1836099029,
-0.3711416721,
0.5585337281,
0.3678872287,
-0.2457163632,
0.3008323312,
-0.0262260269,
-0.7263771296,
0.8844260573,
0.5987617373,
-0.6824500561,
-0.1325427443,
0.4826104343,
0.1639662534,
-0.4863679409,
-0.0702841133,
0.4125085175,
0.353277415,
0.4335839152,
-1.1623126268,
0.1401848644,
-0.2114097476,
0.0636327863,
-0.0538034029,
-0.1763689071,
1.0665766001,
-0.0722058117,
-0.4989749789,
0.2585598826,
0.6519410014,
0.4829952121,
0.2101460844,
0.6485188603,
0.2597917318,
0.8497212529,
0.2079350203,
0.6699675322,
-0.3794586957,
-0.0831742659,
1.291490078,
-0.2696903348,
0.6567380428,
0.3977722526,
0.157300666,
0.2027219236,
-0.2028913349,
0.1433570385,
0.7746158838,
0.0073358021,
-0.7127756476,
-0.5327958465,
-0.5261315703,
-0.1198283657,
0.720318675,
-0.1486590952,
0.0784204528,
-0.330147028,
0.4411430061,
-0.1565346569,
0.0876622275,
-0.3977322578,
0.9526076317,
-0.0406901501,
-0.915602088,
0.3163786232,
-0.0615820326,
0.7028330564,
-0.5247120261,
0.0338746756,
0.057899531,
0.136139974,
-0.0229545906,
-0.4280667007,
0.2128170878,
0.0093201334,
-0.3653838336,
-0.2450674772,
0.981379807,
-0.691824019,
-0.513749361,
0.1001581922,
0.5320488811,
-0.0667145029,
-0.4480560124,
-0.3920973837,
0.4003234208,
-0.0588668622,
0.2592241764,
-0.0444256961,
0.2993711829,
0.2918080688,
0.5767015815,
0.7253242135,
0.0966236517,
0.24370341,
0.3018272221,
0.8538418412,
-0.6385797262,
-1.0159413815,
-0.6929643154,
0.7357419133,
0.0340198129,
-0.1622816324,
0.771211803,
0.5707930923,
0.3011311889,
-0.3031242788,
0.9604703188,
0.1319339126,
0.8577271104,
-0.1465208083,
0.6469317079,
-0.2567944527,
-0.038063243,
-0.272164762,
-0.7873873711,
-0.3518146873,
0.1724625826,
0.2122476548,
-0.2541947961,
0.5041396022,
0.7661367059,
0.090063937,
0.2746095359,
0.4504524469,
-0.230626747,
0.3895697296,
0.4747884572,
0.8144188523,
-0.1667292118,
0.8009844422,
-0.1626364887,
-0.1358842999,
0.0021900984,
-0.7357116342,
-0.8284772635,
-0.8773863316,
-0.3254481554,
0.2553183436,
-0.0262815896,
0.7447466254,
0.7817831039,
-0.7602856159,
-0.2788854837,
-0.1915243715,
-0.0781701282,
-0.4323867857,
-0.2185904682,
0.2358500212,
-0.4759038687,
-0.7481700182,
0.9271034002,
0.2485666424,
-0.2029292285,
0.1261783838,
0.0662567988,
0.3207370937,
0.1116643474,
0.513530314,
0.17798464,
-0.8206641674,
-0.1002446041,
0.1495588422,
0.0829683766,
-0.0917096883,
1.2346309423,
-0.9025536776,
0.5071615577,
0.6208488345,
0.6270095706,
0.1794666052,
0.0251293704,
0.6025631428,
-0.8839667439,
0.1741948724,
0.3316246569,
0.3526787162,
0.3222306073,
-0.1183440238,
-0.1771460474,
-0.023002658,
-0.5004022121,
-0.7171325684,
0.3063827753,
-1.3507455587,
-0.3510399759,
0.8737316132,
-0.0972947106,
0.0092042936,
-0.2622698247,
-0.4706537426,
0.5398311019,
-0.6476992965,
0.4102137685,
0.4895296097,
-0.0786126629,
-0.3236316741,
-0.0579404309,
0.263150543,
0.4152654111,
-0.6249193549,
0.31500718,
0.572044313,
0.375202626,
0.2009684294,
0.6740021706,
0.0380572155,
0.4381088018,
0.0374211781,
0.1890380979,
-0.5696584582,
-0.387932539,
-0.5169312358,
0.5779152513,
-0.2694614828,
-0.5988054872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18040v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18040v2
|
Enhancing End-to-End Multi-Task Dialogue Systems: A Study on Intrinsic Motivation Reinforcement Learning Algorithms for Improved Training and Adaptability
| 2024-01-31T18:03:39 | 2024-03-25T23:03:58 |
Navin Kamuni, Hardik Shah, Sathishkumar Chintala, Naveen Kunchakuri, Sujatha Alla Old Dominion
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
End-to-end multi-task dialogue systems are usually designed with separate
modules for the dialogue pipeline. Among these, the policy module is essential
for deciding what to do in response to user input. This policy is trained by
reinforcement learning algorithms by taking advantage of an environment in
which an agent receives feedback in the form of a reward signal. The current
dialogue systems, however, only provide meagre and simplistic rewards.
Investigating intrinsic motivation reinforcement learning algorithms is the
goal of this study. Through this, the agent can quickly accelerate training and
improve its capacity to judge the quality of its actions by teaching it an
internal incentive system. In particular, we adapt techniques for random
network distillation and curiosity-driven reinforcement learning to measure the
frequency of state visits and encourage exploration by using semantic
similarity between utterances. Experimental results on MultiWOZ, a
heterogeneous dataset, show that intrinsic motivation-based debate systems
outperform policies that depend on extrinsic incentives. By adopting random
network distillation, for example, which is trained using semantic similarity
between user-system dialogues, an astounding average success rate of 73% is
achieved. This is a significant improvement over the baseline Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO), which has an average success rate of 60%. In addition,
performance indicators such as booking rates and completion rates show a 10%
rise over the baseline. Furthermore, these intrinsic incentive models help
improve the system's policy's resilience in an increasing amount of domains.
This implies that they could be useful in scaling up to settings that cover a
wider range of domains.
|
[
-0.3981533051,
-0.4075962603,
0.520142138,
0.1406874061,
-0.0708180144,
0.177766636,
-0.4294198453,
-0.0686422884,
0.2005663663,
0.2027065605,
-0.8208978176,
-0.0255691148,
-0.4964282513,
0.163221091,
0.0863959715,
1.0181815624,
-0.0152792921,
-0.0225458909,
-0.1333769709,
-0.1593988985,
-0.4752862155,
-0.7024492025,
-0.8220236897,
-0.5408428907,
0.4295739532,
0.3382707834,
0.0492599122,
-0.1275213957,
0.0823659822,
0.3568133116,
-0.2460085303,
0.2041958869,
-0.7458965182,
0.3146495521,
-0.3151376247,
-0.5670263767,
0.187412113,
-0.1567245126,
0.4933325052,
0.2999143302,
-0.5274813771,
-0.2092581391,
0.2847982943,
0.6297234297,
-0.5650836825,
0.3135395646,
-0.6758716702,
0.1016347334,
0.2677439749,
-0.6306298375,
-0.4151731431,
-0.3655052781,
0.4515405595,
-0.5339323878,
-0.3126087785,
0.130523324,
0.6250580549,
0.2400285155,
-0.436632812,
-0.4845511019,
-0.638820827,
0.9093572497,
-0.5514187217,
-0.0759007111,
0.0851351768,
0.2903541028,
-0.4745211005,
-0.3636889756,
-0.4943685234,
-0.6089985967,
0.2486692667,
0.3039518893,
-0.2902633846,
0.2732855082,
0.2250205278,
0.2553793192,
-0.2442538291,
0.1437399387,
-0.0281833131,
-0.1802027375,
0.1131433249,
0.2290057391,
-0.005843,
0.1928882748,
-0.417994827,
-0.300314784,
-0.5878417492,
0.8143847585,
0.4787871838,
0.1522231251,
0.3184309006,
0.3676935136,
-0.8353556395,
0.4317550361,
0.133022368,
-0.13325876,
0.116132088,
-0.3414377868,
0.0904664174,
0.2509230971,
0.49807024,
0.2723643184,
0.1382263899,
-0.127450332,
-0.3310978413,
0.065873675,
0.2796827853,
-0.7383278608,
0.0189096332,
0.0715108067,
-0.4153911769,
-0.2562836409,
-0.1914253235,
-0.2062729597,
-0.1272749603,
-0.6709749103,
0.5191522241,
-0.4788269699,
-0.3207058907,
0.112082839,
-0.5282363296,
0.1338400692,
0.6139104962,
-0.8645091057,
0.3275183737,
0.552667141,
0.9064390659,
-0.0724606067,
-0.2798599899,
-0.5454811454,
0.0234432034,
-0.2054003924,
0.8268949986,
-0.6166802645,
-0.2444579452,
-0.0635221303,
-0.0816283002,
-0.1026717275,
-0.5207911134,
0.4873834252,
-0.4119556248,
0.2092668712,
-0.2988681793,
-0.3905941546,
-0.3618872166,
0.6452928185,
-0.251949966,
0.6281599402,
0.2918571234,
-0.1686966121,
0.3387945294,
-0.930315733,
-0.2145856917,
-0.2562613785,
0.0419589728,
-0.0727889016,
0.3186520934,
0.0905107856,
0.1381539553,
-0.4152162075,
0.4174823761,
-0.3212297857,
-0.3330322206,
0.3298999667,
-0.6759933233,
0.5946173072,
0.1641001999,
-0.4692511559,
0.377779752,
-0.3455080092,
0.0784128457,
-0.0689496696,
-0.3365805149,
-0.3082223535,
0.1365840137,
-0.3385957479,
0.4571090341,
0.0397865362,
-0.6976805329,
0.2049120665,
-0.3561885953,
0.6027901769,
1.0726993084,
0.1957674026,
0.141565308,
-0.4621008039,
0.3975164294,
0.1813291162,
0.2670199871,
-0.369140923,
-0.4134944379,
-0.563811481,
-0.1758245826,
0.0686661676,
0.5504438281,
-0.8282468915,
0.3286047578,
-0.2431347221,
-0.2207920551,
-0.1861121804,
-0.1353857219,
0.4874474704,
0.4575307071,
0.1255787909,
-0.694591701,
-0.0363135263,
-0.6083993912,
-0.0301250536,
-0.2753031254,
0.102197051,
0.5803536177,
0.4943661094,
0.1442396045,
0.957829237,
-0.3370850384,
-0.3416696787,
-0.1766462773,
0.3223386109,
0.32910344,
0.375225395,
0.5340557694,
-0.6543291211,
-0.6646556854,
0.1504318863,
-0.5849042535,
0.137374267,
-0.1982749701,
-0.0558574498,
-0.0868465155,
-0.0115696089,
-0.395021975,
0.3301607668,
0.1197398305,
-0.1817793548,
0.8060340285,
-0.2491457462,
0.3606996238,
-0.543731153,
-0.2554414272,
0.0918857232,
-0.2203248292,
-0.6617090106,
-0.224895671,
-0.4499551058,
-0.0138771711,
-0.4844073951,
0.1078933626,
-0.2572988272,
0.047270555,
-0.582562387,
-0.0899757743,
-0.1643297821,
1.1838858128,
0.1091340333,
0.8181289434,
0.7323787212,
-0.8474154472,
0.7251945138,
0.1923344433,
-0.3363679945,
0.9334599972,
-0.6768336892,
0.1322623044,
-0.0733288154,
0.4942122698,
-0.867647469,
0.1115706488,
0.3182320595,
-0.4063716531,
0.0944921002,
-0.0448820181,
-0.120048143,
-0.0079501458,
-0.426127255,
-0.009725742,
0.3400260508,
-0.683639884,
0.5261740088,
0.3173894286,
-0.3200320899,
-0.7329468131,
-0.0004337633,
0.2138881832,
-0.3382172883,
-0.3182487786,
0.3175212443,
-0.1238202602,
-0.0683459416,
0.1082765386,
-0.2251379341,
0.057130333,
0.3065737188,
0.1621820629,
0.0745432526,
-0.047702495,
-0.0045474796,
0.2554665804,
-0.179404363,
0.2571103275,
-0.8427627087,
0.6081355214,
-0.3336592913,
-0.3259143829,
-0.7206057906,
0.3739526272,
0.3458431959,
0.0016875507,
0.7195456624,
0.4150735736,
-0.0928042829,
-0.1011165231,
-0.2845919728,
-0.4422137439,
-0.4818888903,
0.3697372973,
-0.5764766932,
-1.0746052265,
0.2637218833,
-0.6881833673,
0.319506675,
0.2928081751,
0.7163664699,
-0.1002852172,
0.8986791968,
0.436840117,
-0.1119618341,
0.7720261812,
-0.0325132161,
0.0485945493,
-0.9005041718,
-0.3822238147,
-0.5400648117,
-0.3968507946,
-0.2228164673,
-0.1145779267,
0.4667877853,
0.054292433,
-0.1319095492,
0.336918354,
-0.5906994939,
0.3531768322,
0.8744122386,
0.1298132092,
0.104399249,
0.1919100881,
-0.1867390275,
0.1480148435,
-0.5622754097,
-0.2448146343,
1.0727317333,
0.2060191184,
0.6098034978,
0.4618857205,
0.6558105946,
0.5871308446,
0.3052462041,
-0.7301692963,
0.275451988,
0.2038131356,
-0.1906636655,
-0.6693047881,
-0.6657676101,
-0.6550416946,
0.4740037024,
-0.0210099816,
-0.9950387478,
0.4849460125,
0.0960351005,
-0.2997764945,
0.1478290707,
-0.73525244,
0.5456382632,
-0.3261928558,
-0.3257594109,
-0.6011027098,
-0.5288709998,
0.1627398729,
0.0459148027,
-0.2807926536,
-0.3095310032,
0.2823509872,
0.6954374909,
-0.3652308881,
0.6742457151,
-0.5352888703,
0.0263439473,
0.445561409,
-0.203106612,
0.6794507504,
0.0639640763,
0.0948201418,
-0.0315960459,
-0.0601625703,
-0.1804757416,
-0.8650280833,
0.5800408125,
-0.7535687685,
-0.6100241542,
-0.3232237399,
-0.3705162108,
-0.3876709044,
-0.1327141225,
-0.0529236868,
0.6842906475,
-0.2424327135,
0.4536893964,
0.8626334071,
-0.1406038851,
0.4093501866,
0.5443387032,
0.2062881142,
-0.244008407,
1.3489040136,
-0.2118193358,
0.435205698,
0.5929219127,
0.2515301406,
-0.5594294667,
-0.4488826692,
-0.4626850188,
-0.2869124115,
-0.5933688283,
-0.1495848149,
-0.617177546,
0.0694824234,
-0.2721304893,
0.1167541146,
-0.0636501387,
-0.6504498124,
-0.2222549468,
0.1032185331,
0.2864980102,
0.4482154548,
-0.1399997473,
0.518019259,
-0.3701211512,
0.0853129849,
0.432320118,
0.1958695948,
0.0921366364,
-0.7052553296,
-0.3055934906,
0.103243567,
-0.667162776,
-0.8184283376,
0.2029311508,
0.4384859502,
0.8468185663,
0.6194429994,
0.1728312373,
0.4169576764,
-0.3225857615,
0.5713459849,
0.6127752066,
-0.8178082705,
0.4504432082,
-0.10878212,
0.0571538545,
0.7154039741,
0.3518450558,
-0.6170065999,
-0.1698010564,
-0.2896287441,
-0.6901280284,
1.0814509392,
0.0228845906,
0.1321649104,
0.1922223121,
0.1842814237,
0.0707258955,
0.4363196492,
-0.6550371051,
-0.1704312265,
-0.3230173588,
-0.1574740708,
0.0662079453,
-0.0867980123,
-0.4095073342,
0.0054417322,
0.8581639528,
-0.5419663191,
0.4635556936,
0.1587602049,
-0.0844944715,
0.2026221007,
0.628585279,
0.7403569818,
0.400226146,
-0.2052552998,
-0.2476740181,
0.1149070337,
-0.0891114101,
0.5312822461,
-0.0656829476,
0.1092159748,
-0.1409823895,
-0.4389698207,
1.293592453,
-0.0125599625,
-0.8871064186,
0.4629325271,
-0.3404545784,
-0.3752822578,
-0.2534244657,
0.3266727626,
-0.3014395237,
0.3333357573,
0.4522020519,
0.0924608558,
0.4040371478,
-0.7300879359,
0.1040431634,
0.5825135112,
-0.7244384885,
-0.1048821509,
0.1941646188,
0.2604919076,
-0.3377869129,
0.5755987763,
-0.3936821222,
-0.6337339282,
0.5174214244,
0.4983448386,
0.9085727334,
-0.1511076838,
0.3544424772,
0.1925903261,
0.3399282992,
-0.1347580701,
0.0009483439,
-0.5467216969,
-0.6298882365,
-0.4944683909,
-0.3454622328,
-0.7766909599,
-0.1325891763,
-0.5751398802,
-0.052626837,
-0.2627595663,
-0.2243780196,
-0.3315466046,
-0.0821501985,
-0.4330327213,
-0.0713149309,
0.0358048491,
0.5618843436,
-0.6044214368,
0.4643686414,
0.5415769815,
-0.1494423151,
-0.5744786859,
-0.2920719981,
0.0900275409,
-0.5518577099,
0.5087054968,
0.2606840134,
-0.1834425926,
0.0090447115,
-0.3461072743,
-0.743421495,
0.9876983762,
0.1246247664,
-0.5814089775,
-0.0908222124,
-0.045772478,
0.4099714756,
-0.566763103,
0.8017184138,
0.3914783895,
0.2258550376,
0.06045416,
-0.9489324689,
-0.1103041247,
-0.2830844223,
-0.153853938,
0.2423564494,
-0.6744154096,
0.5664935708,
-0.1093754694,
0.0542850718,
-0.1381797343,
0.6566982865,
0.3847314417,
0.416639179,
0.881930232,
0.449490726,
0.6211928725,
-0.3738285601,
0.8567576408,
-0.3000271618,
0.3804383874,
0.9149993658,
-0.4670675993,
0.5321857929,
0.4322064221,
-0.1507986933,
0.7080181241,
0.5698119998,
0.2586921751,
0.8360183835,
0.4450727403,
-0.47485888,
-0.1571417004,
-0.5780938268,
-0.1601705998,
0.1510886997,
0.5989893675,
0.0710359365,
-0.2421384603,
0.3679817617,
-0.3874524534,
-0.2302192003,
-0.2461054772,
1.0606400967,
0.1132438481,
-0.8820410371,
0.357542038,
-0.0179102682,
0.7122436762,
-0.8843984008,
-0.113199167,
0.1047589853,
0.1121901199,
0.081834875,
-0.5278589129,
-0.1288409531,
-0.194959119,
-0.0930302665,
-0.4763362706,
0.5392323732,
-0.3491354287,
0.2736811638,
0.1423906982,
0.3966121674,
0.1616418064,
-0.2581267953,
-0.8909134865,
-0.2962801754,
0.2099741697,
-0.4056423306,
0.5611408353,
0.5032353997,
-0.0126553541,
0.7509256005,
0.9644755125,
-0.0208851919,
-0.0352285616,
0.0806876644,
1.0710594654,
-0.4853197634,
-0.8686557412,
-0.5340289474,
0.2532558143,
-0.2909184992,
-0.4122624695,
0.450296402,
0.2740040421,
0.8304803967,
0.2021491677,
0.6734374762,
-0.1298859715,
0.2378367782,
-0.4811022878,
0.1150118411,
-0.4673787653,
0.1440795809,
0.0048149894,
-0.9376740456,
0.5139011741,
0.4100704193,
-0.0976108909,
-0.1093359888,
0.6764959693,
0.5384975672,
0.3213609159,
0.2033585012,
0.2117812485,
-0.2274214476,
0.5743097067,
0.9069119096,
1.3332331181,
0.2212122977,
0.5436294675,
-0.2363757938,
-0.5689684749,
-0.2592080534,
-0.3962035775,
-0.6305554509,
-0.5502974391,
-0.169805944,
-0.2365658283,
0.2965455353,
1.0419623852,
0.6144505739,
-0.6813744903,
-0.2644743323,
-0.1191126332,
0.0113248741,
-0.7519834638,
-0.2594820261,
0.057002116,
-0.6474867463,
-0.6857950091,
0.567637682,
0.6457218528,
-0.3615539372,
-0.2733638585,
-0.3651995063,
-0.0639009625,
0.0252308026,
0.6251156926,
0.5163549781,
-0.6778950095,
-0.1008318886,
0.0422056913,
0.0623770915,
0.1022898927,
1.1454133987,
-0.814686358,
0.403709203,
0.3459543884,
0.7955809832,
0.3133376241,
0.0795999914,
0.4504606724,
-0.3910186887,
0.0559714213,
0.3635893166,
0.3846510947,
-0.0452718586,
-0.299085319,
0.3204660118,
0.285808444,
-0.7272436619,
-0.8153805733,
0.2742799819,
-0.9120422602,
-0.2436029464,
0.8896386623,
-0.4660459459,
-0.2136922181,
-0.4584152699,
-0.3507768512,
0.0470050834,
-0.8057251573,
0.7866367698,
0.6678890586,
-0.3732669652,
-0.036703594,
-0.2772146165,
0.350366354,
0.8157550097,
-0.8180472851,
-0.1633688658,
0.3958621323,
0.1062595621,
0.2544901371,
0.7940493226,
0.2130975276,
0.3204056323,
-0.228256017,
-0.1166320071,
-0.1349057704,
-0.5397889614,
-0.4916882217,
0.1479765177,
-0.0175048988,
-0.1655006856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18034v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18034v1
|
Paramanu: A Family of Novel Efficient Indic Generative Foundation Language Models
| 2024-01-31T17:58:10 | 2024-01-31T17:58:10 |
Mitodru Niyogi, Arnab Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Gyan AI Paramanu ("atom"), a family of novel language models for
Indian languages. It is a collection of auto-regressive monolingual, bilingual,
and multilingual Indic language models pretrained from scratch on a single GPU
for 10 Indian languages (Assamese, Bangla, Hindi, Konkani, Maithili, Marathi,
Odia, Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu) across 5 scripts (Bangla, Devanagari, Odia,
Tamil, Telugu) of varying sizes ranging from 13.29M to 367.5M.The models are
pretrained with a context size of 1024 on a single GPU. The models are very
efficient, small, fast, and powerful. We have also developed an efficient most
advanced Indic tokenizer that can even tokenize unseen languages. In order to
avoid the "curse of multi-linguality" in our multilingual mParamanu model, we
pretrained on comparable corpora by typological grouping using the same script.
We performed human evaluation of our pretrained models for open end text
generation on grammar, coherence, creativity, and factuality metrics for
Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit. Our Bangla, Hindi, and Sanskrit models
outperformed GPT-3.5-Turbo (ChatGPT), Bloom 7B, LLaMa-2 7B, OPT 6.7B, GPT-J 6B,
GPTNeo 1.3B, GPT2-XL large language models (LLMs) by a large margin despite
being smaller in size by 66 to 20 times compared to standard 7B LLMs. To run
inference on our pretrained models, CPU is enough, and GPU is not needed. We
also instruction-tuned our pretrained Bangla, Hindi, Marathi, Tamil, and Telugu
models on 23k instructions in respective languages. Our pretrained and
instruction-tuned models which are first of its kind, most powerful efficient
small generative language models ever developed for Indic languages, and the
various results lead to the conclusion that high quality generative language
models are possible without high amount of compute power and humongous number
of parameters. We plan to release our models at https://www.bharatgpts.com.
|
[
-0.3894352317,
-0.6992400289,
0.0150064845,
0.2433766127,
-0.4806692302,
0.0497216322,
-0.6135249138,
-0.283513695,
-0.047954388,
0.2516403496,
-0.1952286214,
-0.3384083807,
-0.4293623567,
0.414378792,
-0.3285494745,
0.7833522558,
0.1275598705,
-0.0594955124,
-0.2581574321,
-0.3461384177,
-0.3340660036,
-0.331194669,
-0.5805274248,
-0.3059104681,
0.1817654371,
0.2565870583,
0.7163703442,
0.6406699419,
0.3625395596,
0.3624913692,
0.0976569504,
0.1036308706,
-0.1078836173,
-0.2168090791,
-0.0317333601,
-0.4619006515,
-0.2028994709,
-0.1874055713,
0.7580153346,
0.6438823938,
-0.2896780372,
0.1077059135,
0.0870996788,
0.4965873957,
-0.6794900298,
0.3468623459,
-0.4318549931,
-0.2177489847,
-0.4350696802,
0.0044064503,
-0.560574472,
-0.4174308777,
-0.2866943777,
-0.6432796121,
0.027428994,
-0.0539859384,
0.8501065373,
0.332043916,
-0.3034177721,
-0.2350497097,
-0.9308646321,
0.6831723452,
-0.927470088,
0.364677757,
0.3546726704,
0.4014773965,
0.0282129347,
-0.572873652,
-0.5944165587,
-0.4113634229,
-0.0539100729,
0.1225038841,
-0.0030687579,
0.1464649141,
0.0015465702,
0.5973638296,
-0.7343717217,
0.1024714932,
-0.3415373564,
0.195999518,
0.5243808031,
0.2201604992,
0.562954247,
-0.2451818734,
-0.3792945147,
0.0357835144,
-0.8188950419,
0.069488205,
0.5937231779,
0.439468354,
-0.322342217,
0.3842127621,
-0.2777986228,
1.1625803709,
-0.0839779973,
-0.2824135423,
-0.0224343073,
-0.5515238047,
-0.322624892,
-0.0915035307,
1.2084687948,
-0.1339118928,
0.242740199,
-0.1903461367,
0.0026173345,
0.292085886,
0.0424808599,
-0.7289622426,
-0.1211949587,
-0.109013617,
-0.4328919053,
-0.2005634904,
-0.3237669468,
-0.790910542,
-0.1323498189,
-0.3855670393,
0.2245926261,
-0.7898786068,
-0.7621626854,
-0.0991102234,
0.2396374792,
0.3396986425,
0.1851136833,
-1.3055592775,
0.1945539415,
0.4098072648,
0.6175679564,
-0.0510198101,
-0.5439015031,
0.1024616137,
0.0923826396,
-0.5984359384,
0.7919640541,
-0.9255965352,
-0.4157558382,
-0.0227583889,
-0.4497108459,
-0.4705277085,
-0.5976410508,
0.425491035,
-0.3542085588,
-0.0184077844,
-0.1154978722,
-0.4729057252,
-0.2760978341,
0.109050177,
-0.5802278519,
0.8219492435,
0.3278877437,
-0.7469139099,
0.3064649701,
-0.5500600338,
-0.4691367745,
0.5128337145,
-0.4734197259,
-0.1219656393,
0.2138847411,
0.2131144553,
0.2987888455,
-0.8292215466,
0.4837391973,
-0.0288341884,
-0.4801037312,
-0.0483451225,
-0.3163821101,
0.831433773,
0.419184655,
-0.2106380612,
0.359744221,
-0.9309656024,
-0.1381191164,
0.1091109589,
-0.4591188729,
-0.3867435455,
-0.2253747135,
0.0641776696,
0.237519443,
0.1947416812,
-0.4817940295,
-0.0047546779,
-0.3706808686,
0.618047893,
0.6251580119,
-0.3137476146,
0.4099993408,
0.0042672674,
0.9286342859,
0.0437651239,
0.2003434449,
-0.2663972676,
-0.5619117022,
-0.8223060966,
-0.3558716774,
0.3364425898,
0.5109851956,
-0.8299789429,
0.2080269605,
-0.261251986,
-0.597140193,
-0.6181318164,
0.2950485349,
0.6951789856,
0.4982127547,
0.1233062148,
0.065213047,
-0.3814825714,
-1.1903090477,
-0.4190118909,
-0.2550365329,
0.3168153465,
-0.0172229558,
0.3334459066,
-0.3291383684,
0.8487604856,
0.0276208855,
0.1322824955,
-0.6091215014,
0.1583914161,
0.0277984776,
0.4014979303,
0.4438246787,
-0.843765378,
-0.7169058323,
0.2675349712,
-1.0705212355,
0.2293435037,
0.052334182,
-0.0532443039,
0.4154432118,
0.5764366388,
-0.8690305352,
0.2609937787,
0.5785283446,
-0.2178829461,
0.5375186205,
-0.2641842961,
0.0356701687,
-1.4202910662,
0.1421518177,
0.0636746511,
-0.1929493695,
-0.6041899323,
0.5108790398,
0.1493408084,
-0.4625403285,
-0.4454542398,
0.5658758283,
-0.4950771928,
0.2576442957,
-0.2230279148,
-0.1380778104,
-0.4114105701,
0.7343588471,
-0.1395293325,
1.1066306829,
0.5768874288,
-0.7879041433,
0.2977496684,
0.2854968905,
-0.5012155175,
0.3469608128,
-0.5911020041,
0.0142239211,
-0.2344145179,
0.0828881264,
-0.9128919244,
-0.3299017549,
0.3663749397,
-0.3174569309,
0.4647664428,
-0.0194043946,
-0.5050638318,
-0.306299448,
0.0198461898,
0.5538828373,
0.5347729921,
-0.512152195,
0.7875860929,
0.2992991209,
-0.2368567586,
-0.5541509986,
-0.6139726043,
0.0742689595,
-0.3337298036,
-0.4114126861,
-0.0957432315,
-0.2324839234,
-0.1928558052,
0.1345509291,
0.1987808496,
-0.0259654447,
-0.1431030184,
0.2958969772,
0.2797541618,
-0.3161611259,
-0.0358457901,
0.1840588897,
-0.2056730241,
-0.1279043555,
-0.1671058536,
0.7614251971,
-0.5325390697,
-0.0592550747,
-0.6268622279,
0.3199439645,
0.5734696388,
-0.5646058917,
0.7925200462,
0.6689186692,
-0.4778036475,
0.0798472315,
-0.4433259964,
0.3287808001,
-0.4359553456,
0.2906991243,
-0.7698018551,
-0.8489545584,
0.427118361,
-0.1084660664,
-0.0667761341,
0.7480663061,
0.7368994355,
0.5233381987,
0.8982387781,
0.7681193948,
-0.208399713,
0.3835569918,
-0.3523001671,
0.3408983946,
-0.7508987784,
-0.176194638,
-0.3508838415,
0.1928346008,
-0.6769494414,
-0.2376160771,
0.0698315203,
0.295293659,
0.0377863795,
0.5207250714,
-0.4685933292,
0.4922314882,
0.5792393088,
-0.1947745532,
0.2400687337,
0.0503055975,
-0.2199879736,
0.1299968958,
-0.8319377899,
-0.526661396,
1.4289721251,
-0.0324339084,
0.7341551185,
-0.0328963362,
0.6942494512,
-0.1121994257,
0.4715954363,
-0.3759740591,
0.6287451982,
-0.0955120251,
-0.7240208983,
-0.1767205,
-0.463922888,
-0.6920276284,
0.3234933317,
0.0924146995,
-0.4816374183,
0.2286773324,
0.1073550582,
-0.5270302892,
0.4013981521,
-0.9455823302,
1.0811767578,
-0.0060506305,
-0.2847663462,
-0.3141436279,
-0.5951267481,
0.8476768732,
-0.1048963368,
0.1857087761,
-0.1687314659,
-0.0019332697,
0.6078189015,
-0.4400019944,
0.5898128152,
-0.0665866882,
0.0874566361,
0.600376308,
-0.0818272382,
0.2782027423,
0.2038196921,
-0.0172591899,
0.2694250643,
-0.1685243398,
-0.5502279401,
-0.4977006614,
0.89005059,
-0.9572789669,
-0.490013063,
-0.5067008734,
-0.5842412114,
-0.0426039286,
0.3195036352,
0.5652630329,
0.5741605163,
-0.2522068918,
0.0400111526,
0.473294735,
-0.2835523784,
0.7951770425,
0.3051253855,
-0.1993049681,
-0.5254136324,
1.2436847687,
-0.0349637195,
0.2115769535,
0.4985188842,
0.2254893333,
-0.357460171,
-0.6760674119,
-0.9359448552,
0.3512777388,
-0.5713031888,
-0.2038781941,
-0.6619125605,
-0.2400435209,
-0.5490586162,
0.1477507651,
-0.4558064044,
-0.3292135298,
-0.0949346125,
0.0121072037,
0.0991639644,
0.9528422356,
0.1415412277,
0.3535273671,
-0.5236883163,
0.3787826002,
0.344658345,
0.2953086197,
-0.0913220793,
-0.3370916247,
-0.3136141896,
-0.117343612,
-0.0848018751,
-0.5487763882,
0.3742035627,
0.4302462935,
0.4487428367,
0.4930514097,
-0.1989408284,
0.5599567294,
-0.4909920692,
0.5712200403,
0.159727335,
-0.7529643178,
0.4814955592,
-0.4871979654,
0.3795050383,
0.763335824,
0.5790279508,
-0.3979054689,
-0.3616707027,
-0.4518967569,
-0.7235323191,
0.7202964425,
0.1981681883,
0.1106281504,
-0.2470326424,
0.4951778948,
0.3191549778,
0.344512701,
-0.6327981949,
-0.3290335536,
-0.2781595588,
-0.366548419,
-0.427662611,
-0.3955904245,
0.0983800665,
-0.5197479725,
0.6668078303,
-0.0474377237,
0.2401231229,
-0.0381239317,
-0.3436955512,
-0.0899008438,
0.2688427269,
0.7573089004,
1.0030457973,
-0.0864642486,
-0.0669393092,
-0.0372473672,
-0.4214963615,
0.2874586582,
0.3401892483,
-0.2817235589,
0.0284570381,
0.2809556127,
1.1733291149,
0.1239878982,
-0.7428811789,
0.2259998769,
-0.3384402394,
0.2200453281,
-0.5008129478,
-0.0645355433,
0.2688162029,
-0.0771450475,
0.0832390115,
0.1744190753,
0.0380608775,
-0.3556638062,
-0.1449465305,
0.246426627,
-0.069361195,
-0.4251427054,
1.0270347595,
0.3323004842,
-0.3287117183,
0.7559646368,
-0.4532178342,
-0.2114628106,
0.3924421072,
0.7841724753,
0.9793969393,
-0.7282360196,
0.1723010838,
0.529135704,
0.4166101515,
-0.0742210224,
0.1223506555,
-0.1106194705,
-0.5031331778,
-0.3319898248,
-1.0608565807,
-0.3192666173,
0.245107159,
-0.423874855,
0.130783841,
-0.6246218085,
0.024577627,
-0.0902212262,
-0.0046635428,
-0.5482753515,
0.2249048203,
0.0688765496,
0.8194785714,
-1.0313233137,
1.1382359266,
0.8021050096,
-0.6839649081,
-0.8628203273,
-0.2664674222,
-0.2890794873,
-0.5659450293,
0.4287824035,
0.2549606264,
-0.0711525604,
0.3046774566,
-0.0617326051,
-0.8108915091,
0.9247184396,
0.7525266409,
-0.6367976665,
-0.1224947423,
0.3256496787,
0.4863879979,
-0.2748785615,
0.3298664689,
0.7195894122,
0.2619268298,
-0.2245113999,
-0.6630687714,
0.0169085525,
-0.7850682735,
0.5199807882,
0.3833849132,
-0.8330835104,
1.1949976683,
-0.0278498791,
-0.1490357667,
0.3040864468,
0.9033618569,
0.1963862777,
-0.0668398961,
0.3423835337,
1.0227431059,
0.486453861,
0.0757461563,
1.5063683987,
-0.680811584,
0.0878238901,
0.8247181773,
0.0249420982,
0.7581844926,
0.1751034409,
-0.1898453981,
0.4892034829,
0.6539505124,
0.3676403761,
0.2805965543,
0.0090134535,
-0.5390597582,
-0.3799413741,
-0.1524215341,
-0.5394009352,
0.4653562307,
0.2126910388,
0.0189053193,
-0.1799818426,
0.2656868696,
0.0379382186,
0.2418406457,
-0.1643813998,
0.4259017408,
0.0972227901,
-0.8087552786,
0.9313129187,
0.3360849917,
0.8050160408,
-0.8705088496,
0.1294404268,
-0.5159968138,
0.3496851623,
0.0248774681,
-0.0050707236,
0.2573730946,
-0.075811103,
0.0814406201,
0.0694975778,
0.6763657928,
-0.6388387084,
-0.7660499215,
0.2709475756,
0.1995493323,
0.0572372712,
-0.2299092263,
-0.5664690137,
0.2394951582,
-0.2260570973,
-0.1695243269,
0.3690906167,
0.1145408526,
-0.1638446152,
0.6583048701,
0.4549114406,
-0.0667260587,
0.455586642,
0.0515025482,
0.6676142812,
-0.596349299,
-0.5115264654,
-0.8915484548,
0.2363336682,
0.1833368838,
-0.5935105085,
0.9720605612,
0.8887335062,
1.0503807068,
-0.2890681922,
0.9023839235,
-0.0272753593,
0.2038644552,
-0.3083838224,
0.7989796996,
-0.4777699709,
-0.2415516078,
-0.0397090279,
-0.9633313417,
-0.2246975005,
0.3189794421,
-0.0654702112,
0.1639169455,
0.6473715305,
0.6224662066,
-0.0573513322,
0.0433564782,
0.2896304131,
-0.0153443096,
0.2086428702,
0.8790261745,
0.8579657674,
-0.6090834141,
0.6555745006,
-0.4959312677,
-0.3222783208,
-0.103708446,
-0.3718051612,
-1.0393438339,
-0.6709927917,
-0.3226020634,
0.131918177,
0.0789500847,
0.9441789389,
0.6718103886,
-0.743691802,
-0.576903224,
-0.5292808414,
-0.1307592988,
-0.060717117,
-0.1724215448,
0.3504057527,
-0.5154838562,
-1.0122723579,
0.6939151287,
0.4233510792,
-0.0955152065,
-0.3462810218,
-0.2582513094,
-0.6028337479,
0.08107014,
0.5935887694,
0.5895829201,
-0.7835623622,
0.2698133886,
-0.4296917617,
-0.2322054207,
0.1152534634,
0.876173377,
-0.7046227455,
0.4793159664,
0.5178251863,
0.7203931808,
0.2875244915,
-0.1130353212,
0.4714515209,
-0.5078428388,
0.5871188045,
0.1001083925,
0.2609181702,
0.5333727002,
-0.2165978998,
0.4400417805,
0.410205543,
-0.3223451674,
-0.8192852736,
0.1832948476,
-0.6635732651,
-0.2764617801,
1.0481520891,
-0.0710705668,
-0.5084824562,
0.2354501188,
0.0795359984,
0.5510713458,
-0.1036494374,
0.499520123,
0.6179215908,
0.0150275091,
-0.2249387056,
-0.5849855542,
0.538785696,
0.4057658315,
-0.9713906646,
0.0226905197,
0.1194408834,
0.2764134705,
0.1220506653,
0.8446356654,
-0.2162937969,
0.209428072,
0.2012733966,
0.2502635419,
-0.3269482255,
-0.720703125,
-0.6501744986,
0.0093389479,
0.2248035967,
-0.3086842597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18028v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18028v2
|
Evaluating the Capabilities of LLMs for Supporting Anticipatory Impact Assessment
| 2024-01-31T17:43:04 | 2024-05-20T23:34:39 |
Mowafak Allaham, Nicholas Diakopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Gaining insight into the potential negative impacts of emerging Artificial
Intelligence (AI) technologies in society is a challenge for implementing
anticipatory governance approaches. One approach to produce such insight is to
use Large Language Models (LLMs) to support and guide experts in the process of
ideating and exploring the range of undesirable consequences of emerging
technologies. However, performance evaluations of LLMs for such tasks are still
needed, including examining the general quality of generated impacts but also
the range of types of impacts produced and resulting biases. In this paper, we
demonstrate the potential for generating high-quality and diverse impacts of AI
in society by fine-tuning completion models (GPT-3 and Mistral-7B) on a diverse
sample of articles from news media and comparing those outputs to the impacts
generated by instruction-based (GPT-4 and Mistral-7B-Instruct) models. We
examine the generated impacts for coherence, structure, relevance, and
plausibility and find that the generated impacts using Mistral-7B, a small
open-source model fine-tuned on impacts from the news media, tend to be
qualitatively on par with impacts generated using a more capable and larger
scale model such as GPT-4. Moreover, we find that impacts produced by
instruction-based models had gaps in the production of certain categories of
impacts in comparison to fine-tuned models. This research highlights a
potential bias in the range of impacts generated by state-of-the-art LLMs and
the potential of aligning smaller LLMs on news media as a scalable alternative
to generate high quality and more diverse impacts in support of anticipatory
governance approaches.
|
[
-0.5356393456,
-0.7834957838,
0.6722276807,
-0.2398867011,
-0.1232427061,
-0.0494207144,
-0.2399227172,
-0.5686526895,
0.1090570837,
0.534150064,
-0.2974059582,
-0.1866060346,
-0.9280896783,
-0.1176715568,
-0.6939746141,
1.141297698,
0.007329904,
-0.005375287,
0.0472305156,
0.2577698827,
-0.5376215577,
-0.2029872835,
-0.3287316859,
-0.2876136899,
0.2454050928,
0.2106043249,
0.8789177537,
0.4120162129,
0.5478345156,
0.272159934,
-0.2627028525,
0.1904845536,
-0.582475543,
-0.5454425812,
-0.3574883342,
-0.2592850029,
-0.2292388678,
0.5079036355,
0.6558562517,
0.3526006937,
-0.1307687163,
0.4557441771,
0.4729290903,
0.3647414148,
-0.7003561854,
0.2207226455,
-0.7571805716,
-0.2474589199,
0.0338722169,
-0.1311915219,
-0.0880121365,
-0.5051614046,
0.311109066,
-0.3295408487,
-0.2269125432,
-0.2869468629,
0.7875070572,
0.5923517942,
-0.384524107,
-0.5507044196,
-0.8538829088,
0.7160168886,
-0.9456629753,
0.2339393497,
0.2356970608,
0.2332280725,
-0.2237533629,
-0.5941632986,
-0.6809991002,
-0.1236098409,
0.1082995012,
0.1429252774,
-0.2397292107,
0.298188746,
0.072075434,
0.2334995419,
-0.1131697372,
0.2313944697,
-0.6287666559,
0.0192642212,
0.5161899328,
0.2670017481,
0.1543938816,
-0.327542007,
-0.1333921403,
0.234354645,
-0.7691656351,
0.2032990456,
0.5574563742,
0.3764362633,
-0.1906697303,
0.5662974119,
-0.144325316,
0.5606667399,
-0.0137223247,
-0.0614443235,
-0.0563560762,
-0.5253916979,
-0.1617956758,
-0.1300213486,
0.7191374302,
0.2413336784,
0.2751949728,
0.0190033838,
-0.1638329327,
0.1272742748,
0.4358418286,
-0.7931013107,
-0.0071608275,
0.1277788132,
-0.4464752674,
-0.3147116303,
0.2727343738,
-0.5337754488,
-0.5373950005,
-0.6765574217,
0.7490522861,
-0.1236422509,
-0.2299557775,
0.095924601,
0.025126243,
0.1748765707,
0.6321906447,
-0.5667057037,
0.0642496869,
0.7065760493,
0.8495649099,
-0.0548327006,
-0.0615475848,
-0.4611265957,
0.123456344,
-0.3794382811,
0.7698699236,
-0.6204352379,
-0.4597496688,
0.0193413198,
-0.256123513,
0.0627650246,
-0.6701805592,
0.3653685451,
-0.3841024339,
-0.0560146756,
-0.2536478341,
-0.4396110475,
-0.3685022891,
0.2686497569,
-0.7419538498,
0.7363267541,
0.1578690261,
-0.5664176345,
0.4447608292,
-0.6341224909,
-0.4473114312,
0.018027205,
-0.4616937935,
-0.2180065066,
0.0968748257,
0.1333789676,
0.2878403664,
-0.4928257465,
0.7085744739,
-0.045695249,
-0.582480371,
-0.0917010084,
-0.7757689357,
0.580919683,
0.0162787009,
-0.7779315114,
0.3341744542,
-0.7736995816,
0.0527401008,
-0.4805192649,
-0.6023647785,
-0.0630157813,
0.1894226968,
-0.0512286052,
0.2572980523,
0.3270559609,
-0.3358792961,
0.0342488289,
-0.1761265099,
0.620930016,
0.9777593017,
0.0393398963,
0.2198335826,
-0.3911608756,
0.5012334585,
-0.098863259,
0.4140099287,
-0.1883559227,
-0.4699530005,
-0.5718792677,
-0.2718391418,
0.379013598,
0.4678002,
-0.796284616,
0.2804826796,
-0.292206943,
-0.6385176182,
-0.7094964981,
0.0626747832,
0.2090072185,
0.4129999578,
0.2471300364,
-0.2551477551,
-0.5493929982,
-0.8858464956,
-0.3365473747,
-0.3783224523,
0.1298019588,
0.4180622101,
0.5749940872,
-0.2705542445,
1.1170774698,
0.0726109743,
-0.2682376206,
-0.104282245,
0.1878318638,
0.2976740003,
0.2838896513,
0.2934355736,
-0.7786828876,
-0.2048586309,
-0.1279390454,
-0.6425093412,
-0.1699108481,
-0.1666347533,
0.0653280988,
-0.035671223,
0.1097874492,
-0.7415052056,
0.6589945555,
0.5535836816,
-0.2189661562,
0.6009588242,
0.077162236,
0.4984357357,
-0.754227221,
0.1282323003,
-0.0093752695,
0.0134590603,
-0.6464771628,
-0.0980248526,
-0.0914705992,
0.0900356993,
-0.7903856635,
0.6568161249,
-0.2816803753,
-0.091019921,
-0.3597208261,
-0.0449301079,
-0.1381348521,
-0.0622250028,
-0.124896951,
0.8989730477,
0.1125198826,
-0.5023313165,
-0.1130800545,
-0.0072485656,
-0.6691625118,
0.0702003017,
-0.7170962095,
-0.2448921502,
-0.0007425596,
0.2566649914,
-0.5798994303,
-0.1964016259,
0.0303266719,
-0.3298638761,
0.0367596559,
-0.0312867798,
-0.5828834176,
-0.2986364067,
-0.4294488132,
0.3112373948,
0.4675715566,
-0.384241581,
0.6985427737,
0.5680142641,
-0.1172248721,
-0.4349874258,
-0.5678672194,
0.2707286179,
-0.2359846085,
-0.5520147681,
0.0416825004,
0.0886076689,
-0.3738329709,
0.1295874417,
0.1340288222,
0.3125790954,
0.1669867337,
0.3422612846,
0.1901081949,
-0.091934666,
-0.2373264134,
0.1132438406,
0.1436596215,
-0.0470708273,
-0.0100580035,
0.4209936261,
-0.0193953775,
-0.4169167876,
-0.5810040832,
0.1423045248,
0.6621752381,
-0.2871358395,
0.6578876972,
0.6079388261,
-0.4850788414,
-0.0109578343,
-0.7132692337,
-0.2544586658,
-0.473269403,
0.5402806997,
0.0719082877,
-1.0006933212,
0.6142058372,
-0.0739294887,
0.1776468754,
0.5907168984,
0.7026746869,
0.3491491079,
1.0132642984,
0.5746518373,
-0.217964232,
0.7125967741,
-0.4337610006,
0.1536000222,
-0.7220864892,
-0.1504372656,
-0.2799481452,
-0.0850271955,
-0.5446733236,
-0.4497390687,
0.5712863803,
0.121102646,
-0.4088527858,
-0.0780452788,
-0.3824413121,
0.3874106705,
0.8136493564,
-0.0077844691,
0.3361853957,
-0.1039130539,
0.4495580792,
0.2050574571,
-0.5505274534,
-0.9957588315,
1.1742857695,
0.437433511,
0.8969609737,
0.1542097032,
0.5220934749,
0.6482728124,
0.6489978433,
-0.6906622648,
0.3051279485,
-0.3291606009,
-0.4964769185,
-0.2723595798,
-0.4368526936,
-0.6906867027,
0.0002037917,
-0.4331543446,
-0.7789913416,
0.0919899568,
-0.0687670484,
-0.632778883,
0.3597030342,
-0.6535723805,
0.5356560946,
-0.1975762099,
-0.2938508093,
-0.4405470192,
-0.2855000496,
0.3393818736,
-0.1811156273,
0.5138009787,
-0.0955018625,
0.1061017811,
0.8436301351,
-0.2784136236,
1.2211061716,
-0.3234921992,
-0.3586692214,
0.8419446349,
-0.208363831,
0.4725406766,
0.0101829143,
-0.2211196423,
0.4803632498,
-0.093323417,
-0.0305378214,
-0.4918839633,
0.6773952246,
-1.2146470547,
-1.042448163,
-0.0729304478,
-0.6994493604,
-0.0528701767,
0.3527876139,
0.0518795252,
0.3436139524,
-0.1929384321,
-0.0251669288,
0.267490238,
-0.165921554,
0.4217174947,
0.7030728459,
0.0347437225,
-0.4179100394,
0.9486017823,
0.6800013781,
0.060152702,
-0.0938319266,
0.1235004514,
-0.0928562731,
-0.7699958682,
-0.6409436464,
-0.071588248,
-0.5043407679,
-0.2946201563,
-0.5044495463,
-0.4344797432,
-0.4336832464,
0.0197257344,
-0.1637397557,
-0.2862817645,
-0.4897507429,
0.0583110191,
-0.0281265508,
1.3396447897,
-0.1309769452,
0.4424140453,
-0.921176672,
0.1416275501,
0.1947039515,
0.3112018406,
0.2368905395,
-0.5621798635,
-0.6538225412,
0.23519741,
-0.697807312,
-0.6378884912,
0.1252403408,
0.0865268558,
0.6813126802,
0.3295271695,
-0.0406037159,
0.564337492,
-0.7136234641,
1.020375371,
-0.0314927809,
-0.8733371496,
0.5681302547,
-0.5699337721,
0.2559401095,
0.4344367981,
0.2569954693,
-0.0506150723,
-0.5330371857,
-0.4628968239,
-0.9206647873,
0.5432191491,
0.1345422864,
0.2607542276,
-0.2413555831,
0.4355760515,
0.2063682675,
0.322825104,
-0.4151819348,
0.2058168799,
-0.1057265028,
-0.276381284,
0.0807839781,
-0.3715324402,
0.0257979464,
-0.000765209,
0.773999393,
0.1544125229,
-0.1437381208,
0.0550241247,
0.1068928018,
-0.2290076315,
0.2978450358,
0.4843620658,
0.5750063062,
-0.0421973504,
-0.1136097014,
-0.0647365749,
-0.5316812396,
0.0766043514,
0.2214319557,
-0.5566844344,
-0.2742941976,
0.4921010137,
0.5976544023,
-0.0947555974,
-0.7892056108,
0.410020709,
0.137465924,
-0.1190803945,
-0.202291593,
0.2262626141,
-0.1057161689,
0.6401414871,
0.5640663505,
0.0871574804,
0.4660773873,
-0.6294993758,
0.2907606661,
0.6001664996,
-0.3898208439,
-0.3051858246,
0.7464733124,
0.3034262657,
-0.1013812125,
0.3576168716,
-0.006918055,
-0.4121480584,
0.8727139831,
0.3137180805,
0.6627193093,
-0.1465505511,
0.0257712808,
0.2780576944,
0.5632041097,
-0.32676512,
0.3641556501,
0.3168751001,
-0.6070381999,
-0.6197013259,
-0.6277782917,
-0.3404491842,
0.1995230317,
-0.5480943322,
0.4011256397,
-0.4520515501,
-0.5285989642,
-0.0966252163,
0.0677266642,
-0.6436830163,
0.1921517104,
0.1435212046,
0.7240406275,
-0.8197906613,
0.5130900741,
0.6634703279,
-0.4776150882,
-0.777100265,
0.1922934204,
0.1830180138,
-0.7206929922,
0.5245684385,
0.2740932107,
-0.1322568357,
-0.058103323,
-0.3806404173,
-0.9689545035,
0.9724268913,
0.5372983813,
-0.6890079379,
-0.251532644,
0.3850390017,
0.5739088655,
-0.3382686377,
0.4901332259,
0.6090344191,
0.5584093928,
-0.215170905,
-1.3682310581,
-0.0084854811,
-0.1106138229,
-0.0118893748,
0.228813991,
-0.732059896,
0.8467364907,
-0.2912614346,
-0.2300917655,
0.0664221272,
0.5920314789,
0.0502726696,
0.2489729077,
0.3762001693,
0.5240624547,
0.4715544879,
0.2186350673,
1.0509035587,
-0.573302567,
0.3239434659,
1.0469751358,
0.2006164342,
0.926492393,
0.3818776906,
-0.2390497625,
0.3414472044,
0.6633169055,
0.0930929407,
0.4845876992,
0.3773193657,
-0.1701202095,
0.0420654677,
-0.6093294621,
-0.1967122555,
0.4987280965,
0.5397458673,
-0.4350744784,
-0.1460447311,
0.0563440174,
0.0084942635,
0.1056222543,
-0.7779345512,
0.7125648856,
0.0619206987,
-0.7053055167,
0.3628040552,
-0.0586959869,
0.9237763882,
-0.1668234766,
-0.2908144295,
0.1600347757,
0.0171708521,
-0.3589315116,
-0.9424746037,
0.3612661064,
0.1574830413,
-0.3443073332,
0.3989829421,
0.4310717881,
-0.4077067673,
-0.6126773953,
0.3656647503,
0.7225015759,
-0.0910273194,
-0.030983068,
-0.419696331,
0.2462258786,
-0.0189106856,
-0.341848433,
0.2059605122,
0.3149170876,
-0.3311441243,
0.3943112493,
0.3610923588,
0.2457265109,
-0.014454484,
0.2011020482,
0.9079462886,
-0.371286571,
-0.3402578831,
-1.0277469158,
0.4355718195,
0.3508494794,
-0.2112108916,
0.5717721581,
0.5197116733,
0.7650393248,
0.3486807644,
1.2077682018,
-0.0896598026,
0.3023423254,
-0.4228696227,
0.7238444686,
-0.4892487228,
0.5006598234,
-0.3176296055,
-0.7754464149,
-0.0061062961,
0.2402949035,
-0.63521415,
0.2583688498,
-0.063079834,
0.6024012566,
-0.0369223692,
0.0954650939,
0.251789242,
0.3038578928,
0.6069958806,
0.3369781077,
0.8831825256,
-0.2428628653,
0.5543274879,
0.1484038085,
-0.484698683,
0.1296699494,
-0.6723678708,
-0.9031598568,
-0.442338258,
0.0512182899,
-0.2008105218,
0.3467814624,
0.8041169643,
0.5414707065,
-0.5708840489,
-0.0548091903,
0.090718098,
-0.0606939271,
0.3367438614,
-0.3042463958,
0.55330199,
-0.1791567653,
-0.7215462923,
0.0785611346,
0.162949577,
0.0353019312,
-0.5496231914,
-0.0779600888,
-0.0564115122,
0.3883751631,
0.7661995292,
-0.044881504,
-0.9672476053,
-0.557484746,
-0.2595297992,
0.0690714121,
-0.1947782338,
0.5997926593,
-0.9463937879,
0.1493369192,
0.3104415536,
0.7680116296,
0.0219190624,
0.0270461347,
0.4768052101,
-0.2494519055,
-0.1017981842,
0.0611978732,
0.174706921,
0.2683034241,
-0.531140089,
0.5920823812,
-0.167332083,
-0.7132005095,
-0.7148653865,
0.1509702653,
-0.4067825377,
-0.2803781033,
1.334954381,
-0.1114125997,
-0.0512972958,
-0.0470914766,
-0.2680951059,
0.3770737648,
-0.5422484875,
1.1625183821,
0.6256877184,
-0.2930352092,
-0.1538338363,
-0.6742447615,
0.3271781802,
0.1373299956,
-0.7692618966,
-0.0162875,
0.5105338097,
0.0935323387,
0.1087369099,
0.6860645413,
-0.1936685592,
0.2915255725,
-0.2069344074,
0.0330620557,
-0.1169729382,
-0.2828852236,
-0.2661679983,
-0.0282593891,
0.09730836,
0.2728508711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18018v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18018v4
|
On Prompt-Driven Safeguarding for Large Language Models
| 2024-01-31T17:28:24 | 2024-06-03T06:52:58 |
Chujie Zheng, Fan Yin, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Kai-Wei Chang, Minlie Huang, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Prepending model inputs with safety prompts is a common practice for
safeguarding large language models (LLMs) against queries with harmful intents.
However, the underlying working mechanisms of safety prompts have not been
unraveled yet, restricting the possibility of automatically optimizing them to
improve LLM safety. In this work, we investigate how LLMs' behavior (i.e.,
complying with or refusing user queries) is affected by safety prompts from the
perspective of model representation. We find that in the representation space,
the input queries are typically moved by safety prompts in a "higher-refusal"
direction, in which models become more prone to refusing to provide assistance,
even when the queries are harmless. On the other hand, LLMs are naturally
capable of distinguishing harmful and harmless queries without safety prompts.
Inspired by these findings, we propose a method for safety prompt optimization,
namely DRO (Directed Representation Optimization). Treating a safety prompt as
continuous, trainable embeddings, DRO learns to move the queries'
representations along or opposite the refusal direction, depending on their
harmfulness. Experiments with eight LLMs on out-of-domain and jailbreak
benchmarks demonstrate that DRO remarkably improves the safeguarding
performance of human-crafted safety prompts, without compromising the models'
general performance.
|
[
-0.0911314785,
-0.7402408123,
0.8821827173,
0.1000711992,
-0.272498101,
0.0930841267,
0.0112967165,
-0.2168493271,
-0.1774818301,
0.6921035647,
-0.7060334682,
-0.5691535473,
-0.3661516905,
0.2332386971,
-0.0104356417,
0.6276294589,
0.062079329,
-0.2053471357,
-0.292758435,
0.2087981403,
-0.8743996024,
-0.7238107324,
-0.9843030572,
0.0296266079,
0.8325853348,
0.1922988594,
0.7420195937,
0.9386420846,
0.165248841,
0.3123533428,
-0.2807018757,
0.0947791412,
-0.3684185743,
0.7055118084,
-0.2645141184,
-0.5114386082,
-0.2335903347,
-0.1027309299,
0.5008205175,
0.3763057888,
-0.223492384,
-0.4828002751,
0.0988685191,
0.5165907741,
-0.7824831009,
0.1078483239,
-0.4636221528,
0.0642210245,
0.083067663,
-0.2654293776,
-0.9710700512,
-0.3701251447,
-0.1084234193,
-0.5219828486,
-0.1931071877,
0.201325357,
0.5889881253,
0.2176184058,
-0.4530241787,
-0.1522590518,
-0.2545853853,
0.8347289562,
-0.528490901,
0.1896112114,
0.5015732646,
0.2727776766,
-0.827187717,
-0.2849913836,
-0.3802460432,
-0.4515930712,
-0.2021609396,
-0.269161433,
-0.1655428559,
0.459431231,
0.5787090659,
-0.4775106609,
-0.4483533502,
0.605969131,
0.0399595425,
-0.4617009759,
0.8324500322,
0.2944419086,
0.4971356988,
-0.2382972986,
-0.5839195848,
-0.6752195954,
-1.1442642212,
0.2903390825,
0.2824863195,
0.3668049872,
0.0813415945,
0.1714010239,
-0.029593382,
0.5872074962,
0.0023299174,
-0.2192671895,
-0.1609216034,
-0.0092179952,
-0.0261642169,
0.004210467,
1.0281847715,
0.5407612324,
0.4529796243,
0.0200942121,
-0.6446687579,
-0.217593208,
0.2325544059,
-0.7960511446,
0.0170964859,
0.1713214517,
-0.317633301,
-0.583480835,
-0.0685100853,
-0.8753883839,
-0.7106944323,
-0.1109197661,
0.196737349,
-0.2994658947,
-0.1303208768,
0.002575458,
0.0947008133,
-0.1318288147,
0.1834644228,
-0.8789687753,
-0.0609230325,
0.5999312997,
0.6322043538,
-0.0296235941,
0.0031824252,
-0.9164574742,
0.3271126747,
-0.635561645,
0.4340704978,
-0.7136252522,
-0.7384067178,
0.2202182263,
0.0938761532,
-0.2563610673,
-0.428435117,
0.7003168464,
-0.9528855085,
0.0791989192,
-0.5993288159,
-0.1949988902,
-0.2242897302,
0.1150241941,
-0.4657710791,
0.461455673,
-0.2761483788,
-0.6042432189,
0.3456595242,
-0.4416970611,
-0.489177078,
-0.1506530941,
-0.4193027914,
-0.3394068778,
-0.0186483674,
0.3125510812,
0.5349726081,
-0.0205994472,
0.3402026892,
-0.3659699559,
-0.2260653377,
0.4144743681,
-0.4251126051,
0.8419032097,
0.3099104166,
-0.0865083933,
0.5426290035,
-0.4537826777,
-0.1492139548,
0.3598092198,
-0.2648039758,
-0.7288368344,
0.1566040814,
-0.4612860084,
0.3967060745,
0.0595160723,
-0.5093860626,
0.1257549673,
-0.3970902562,
0.4905313849,
1.249557972,
0.1079362035,
0.4381495416,
-0.2258962244,
0.7823645473,
0.1242381632,
0.3155027926,
-0.3515290022,
-0.2196144313,
-0.274864465,
-0.3628607392,
-0.0220805407,
0.5946250558,
-0.6908097863,
0.5117085576,
0.1286298484,
0.0411228016,
-0.0312751122,
-0.1284946352,
0.5698131919,
0.695523262,
0.0857663453,
0.0848774537,
-0.2645713985,
-0.8368332982,
-0.0797844976,
-0.4919065833,
0.0860863104,
0.2086591125,
0.1467238963,
-0.1509177834,
0.8009793758,
-0.436802417,
0.0621631145,
-0.0541739874,
-0.1599199623,
0.056790974,
0.619261086,
0.8789930344,
-0.8201468587,
-0.396766156,
-0.3208635449,
-0.9345834255,
-0.1623526961,
-0.2698662579,
-0.2224694341,
0.4259003401,
0.8278372884,
-0.8334591389,
0.26047194,
0.0999241993,
-0.3670906425,
0.538196981,
-0.2368173003,
0.1067833081,
-0.9124794006,
-0.1614277512,
-0.2484820634,
-0.317121923,
-0.5493103862,
0.3479077518,
0.3078655005,
-0.3970967829,
-0.4752818346,
0.4776153564,
-0.4739106596,
0.4141120911,
-0.2847662568,
0.0458448231,
0.0203207508,
0.1821103394,
0.1503797919,
0.9708868861,
1.0094723701,
-0.8497473598,
0.0030152898,
0.2130164653,
0.1152890772,
0.3600182831,
-0.8824071884,
0.4835631549,
-0.3045788109,
0.169515416,
-0.8538892269,
-0.2554880381,
0.3482964337,
-0.0855910704,
0.6363304257,
-0.5395319462,
-0.5519497395,
-0.3201235533,
-0.5272662044,
0.2867432535,
0.6592245102,
-0.5610560179,
0.4209032655,
0.4070078433,
-0.3661308587,
-0.8309679031,
-0.4209606349,
0.0740172341,
-0.6101189256,
-0.7060568929,
0.1854900718,
-0.0506121479,
-0.292647779,
-0.3844971657,
-0.1065442711,
0.1665323675,
0.3662148118,
0.3518459499,
0.4595480561,
0.1795975119,
0.190296784,
0.3165155649,
-0.2103713602,
0.4155060947,
0.0696440116,
0.501775682,
0.3342786729,
-0.3878624737,
-0.513579607,
0.5822184682,
0.4645987749,
-0.2006918788,
0.8936898708,
-0.1457303762,
-0.2170951664,
-0.3548342884,
-0.2449067384,
-0.632656455,
-0.6529108882,
0.210793227,
-0.360675931,
-0.9145454764,
0.5452460051,
0.111820884,
0.2504912615,
0.1365026981,
0.1588930935,
-0.0474354587,
1.3782171011,
0.6107289791,
-0.0987989008,
0.543125391,
0.3271614313,
0.1602703482,
-0.3711086512,
-0.3026731908,
-0.5877252221,
-0.0015293948,
-0.679350853,
-0.2410349101,
0.3832851648,
0.2715105116,
-0.3014755845,
0.4231372476,
-0.5099570751,
0.517250061,
0.2920744121,
0.1077069193,
0.0849887505,
0.1079824045,
-0.355751574,
-0.050764177,
-0.7156775594,
-0.6784902215,
0.5874546766,
0.5424448848,
1.0979648829,
0.1284188777,
1.0008660555,
0.249335289,
-0.0888327435,
-0.5764046907,
1.0203272104,
0.2588832378,
-0.4968489408,
-0.1286678314,
-0.6890621185,
-1.0143810511,
0.2899886966,
-0.0687628686,
-0.8096997142,
0.4086233675,
0.1670320928,
-0.5595332384,
0.0919676349,
-0.7625398636,
0.558437109,
-0.2445058823,
-0.4603691101,
-0.3338675499,
-0.6694127321,
0.2063476294,
-0.0369380563,
0.2346553802,
-0.1091566384,
-0.0538412333,
0.803918004,
-0.2883316875,
1.0265822411,
-0.5274217129,
-0.2732479274,
0.3071833849,
0.5275738239,
0.9058885574,
0.2544950545,
-0.2055789679,
-0.1976514906,
0.060849946,
-0.1777502745,
-0.4406504035,
0.8746529222,
-0.2750513256,
-1.1843013763,
-0.5971500278,
-0.5743069053,
-0.2491100132,
0.4078976214,
0.1411755979,
0.2393290997,
0.0691295713,
-0.0521718077,
1.0197268724,
-0.602611959,
0.8194329739,
0.5423050523,
-0.1931887269,
0.0315891244,
0.4580788612,
0.0171181932,
0.2947217524,
0.1960307211,
0.2416858077,
-0.5924240947,
-0.7303734422,
-0.5086020231,
0.2266433984,
-0.923204422,
-0.3677463233,
-0.5717709064,
0.0406517237,
-0.3273054063,
-0.0821393505,
-0.0491237231,
-0.2709641457,
-0.41200912,
-0.4320282638,
0.4998218119,
0.5133045912,
-0.087417759,
0.0873832852,
-0.860599637,
-0.1128747463,
0.2338431925,
0.1787823141,
0.0617329329,
-0.4526443481,
0.2779780626,
-0.1727955341,
-0.1213545948,
-0.7271419764,
0.2818285227,
-0.1822128296,
0.7095509768,
0.6634960175,
0.797334969,
0.2619213462,
-0.5723100305,
0.4475765228,
0.2560065985,
-0.4192665517,
0.6778509021,
-0.5920282602,
-0.1926875859,
0.5454811454,
0.4654234648,
-0.3306335211,
-0.1014568508,
-0.0550827906,
-0.8043943048,
0.6925013661,
-0.0875278339,
0.6654129624,
-0.3447461724,
0.3663479984,
-0.0121701173,
0.0253373887,
-0.6286170483,
-0.003987689,
0.1989144981,
-0.000958787,
0.4090622663,
-0.6585111618,
-0.4647375643,
0.2596747577,
0.3961387277,
-0.0330890529,
0.1508726478,
0.0471870266,
0.0381334908,
-0.1218951792,
0.4741772115,
0.5392712951,
0.4106516242,
-0.0521703996,
0.1049362272,
-0.1533727944,
-0.1960795373,
0.3678382635,
0.2802926302,
-0.5195094943,
-0.3363914192,
0.3433305323,
0.6448715925,
-0.1323620975,
-0.7628249526,
0.3764672279,
-0.1802240461,
0.2078280002,
-0.0084059425,
0.556297183,
-0.2841641605,
0.0084683709,
0.2976777256,
-0.0664088503,
0.0224019773,
-0.4800356328,
0.2073515058,
0.5625917912,
-0.2977422178,
-0.2245731652,
0.8044958115,
0.257976383,
-0.2924556732,
0.5457521081,
-0.1092862859,
-0.5299241543,
0.4503902793,
0.5401949883,
0.8790006638,
-0.3524116874,
0.1862350553,
0.5304461718,
0.2810953856,
-0.1227864847,
0.249909237,
0.0331741795,
-0.5465154648,
-0.2405498028,
-0.4452235997,
-0.1635613441,
-0.1258385032,
-0.5499379635,
0.0764138699,
-0.854816556,
-0.283206135,
-0.4175654948,
-0.4766587615,
-0.2034420818,
0.0301284119,
-0.0217475593,
0.9065462947,
-0.6208758354,
0.5547894835,
0.4979335368,
-0.3758659959,
-0.8700388074,
0.1038606167,
0.0446659066,
-0.6371923089,
0.4177466929,
0.3711630106,
-0.1718615741,
-0.1574060917,
-0.5711455941,
-0.6171797514,
0.7731178999,
0.6838452816,
-1.0316947699,
-0.0960443914,
-0.0239196904,
0.2441183776,
-0.1468491554,
-0.2130866647,
0.3884359896,
0.2797214687,
-0.119424738,
-0.6735463142,
0.6630480886,
0.1055649966,
0.0461811945,
0.1012396514,
-0.4404514134,
0.5522837043,
-0.4875165224,
-0.6340335011,
0.0849065557,
0.3855592906,
0.6775566936,
0.283824116,
0.763548553,
0.244093895,
0.766332984,
-0.1777785569,
1.4257119894,
0.1063784882,
-0.0657779276,
0.7686030865,
-0.416787982,
0.5873913169,
0.5702207088,
0.0167387053,
0.453869611,
0.7334026694,
0.3874247372,
0.9439284801,
0.0889083445,
-0.4686045051,
-0.3993244171,
-0.2830022275,
-0.3181705475,
0.0231201816,
0.2588554323,
-0.512285769,
-0.0831548199,
0.1138281003,
0.2738417983,
0.3180387318,
-0.2218283862,
0.9011830091,
0.3186079562,
-0.7498084307,
0.8696396351,
0.0377998352,
0.4142593145,
-0.6059311628,
0.0342867821,
-0.3085311055,
-0.0647233427,
0.0427242368,
-0.8392673135,
0.1625226587,
-0.0545593053,
-0.1027537212,
-0.3522254229,
0.8204550147,
-0.1417172551,
-0.0491535105,
0.6317666173,
0.0089992397,
-0.0669141561,
0.0143951578,
-0.6208429337,
0.0881450474,
-0.0592615791,
-0.3596764207,
0.621906817,
0.3453816473,
-0.5649878979,
0.8412927985,
0.740313828,
-0.270262301,
-0.1269757897,
0.296456784,
1.0823947191,
-0.5705952048,
-0.7423962355,
-1.0672121048,
0.3997206688,
0.008476017,
0.2442038804,
0.6524097919,
0.0069317129,
0.4854878187,
-0.1305804849,
0.7155533433,
-0.0187450312,
0.181864053,
-0.8148301244,
0.9311902523,
-0.2287250906,
0.4233037233,
-0.2158959061,
-0.6818888783,
-0.2856618166,
0.5906516314,
-0.4342251122,
0.1821529567,
0.3056670725,
1.1257880926,
0.2287990302,
-0.2528721392,
0.4599971771,
-0.0982108936,
0.5741450787,
0.4413133264,
1.0321838856,
0.0267203953,
0.405880034,
-0.2197089791,
-0.24469015,
-0.1402363181,
-1.0933325291,
-1.1069774628,
-0.318149507,
-0.212983638,
-0.4080990553,
0.3057392836,
0.9368771315,
0.9442358017,
-0.9037957788,
0.1107773632,
-0.1839582175,
0.3351108134,
-0.018119432,
-0.2148651779,
0.4127709866,
-0.3380547762,
-0.5312316418,
0.966082871,
0.1200336218,
0.2384020984,
-0.1620653272,
-0.1859966367,
0.0548296161,
0.1798602939,
0.5390854478,
0.2997401953,
-0.4622014463,
-0.5157897472,
0.072345525,
-0.2239989638,
-0.1164268404,
0.629712522,
-0.5247775912,
0.5430182219,
0.6369324923,
0.5916337371,
-0.0528049394,
0.1258218288,
0.8088128567,
-0.9947410226,
0.2958427072,
0.3717205524,
0.4547533393,
0.4223798811,
-0.8598927855,
0.2518919706,
-0.0018818056,
-0.5281334519,
-0.9520800114,
0.5645253062,
-0.7003981471,
-0.2953417897,
0.9964494705,
-0.3850320578,
-0.1463527381,
-0.1286379397,
-0.306788981,
-0.0197416265,
-0.8364936113,
0.8326832652,
0.4467319846,
-0.0118783908,
-0.4345892966,
-0.4542081058,
0.6577870846,
0.4821597636,
-0.5204107761,
0.5121117234,
0.6453823447,
0.2852931917,
0.1319303215,
0.2468813807,
-0.2829128206,
0.2858967781,
-0.2779445052,
-0.3045038879,
-0.3632836938,
-0.4960803986,
-0.5894493461,
0.0787292123,
0.3385650814,
-0.3001815081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.18001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.18001v1
|
Desiderata for the Context Use of Question Answering Systems
| 2024-01-31T17:02:31 | 2024-01-31T17:02:31 |
Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prior work has uncovered a set of common problems in state-of-the-art
context-based question answering (QA) systems: a lack of attention to the
context when the latter conflicts with a model's parametric knowledge, little
robustness to noise, and a lack of consistency with their answers. However,
most prior work focus on one or two of those problems in isolation, which makes
it difficult to see trends across them. We aim to close this gap, by first
outlining a set of -- previously discussed as well as novel -- desiderata for
QA models. We then survey relevant analysis and methods papers to provide an
overview of the state of the field. The second part of our work presents
experiments where we evaluate 15 QA systems on 5 datasets according to all
desiderata at once. We find many novel trends, including (1) systems that are
less susceptible to noise are not necessarily more consistent with their
answers when given irrelevant context; (2) most systems that are more
susceptible to noise are more likely to correctly answer according to a context
that conflicts with their parametric knowledge; and (3) the combination of
conflicting knowledge and noise can reduce system performance by up to 96%. As
such, our desiderata help increase our understanding of how these models work
and reveal potential avenues for improvements.
|
[
-0.6350158453,
-0.818553865,
0.9914053679,
0.0305725578,
-0.2723511755,
-0.2353478223,
0.365308702,
-0.6233893037,
0.0622642823,
0.3432198465,
-0.544506669,
-0.1332692653,
-0.3534001112,
0.2264799327,
-0.5214070082,
0.644080162,
-0.0388176925,
0.0188671015,
-0.4358977377,
-0.416893214,
-0.9870409369,
-0.6035469174,
-0.5298053026,
0.1477776617,
0.4522124529,
0.2332877815,
0.4855261743,
-0.0230872706,
0.4105660021,
0.1882609427,
-0.4439569414,
-0.0121646775,
-0.2167867422,
0.3858207166,
-0.233257398,
-0.3113359511,
-0.1773234755,
-0.2263445556,
0.6321906447,
0.6843804717,
-0.0879305825,
0.5093343258,
-0.0201444682,
0.6187716126,
-0.8592525125,
-0.0109881889,
-0.4228799045,
-0.2409977466,
0.1155674309,
-0.2497237921,
-0.2114070207,
-0.4827017486,
0.2560010254,
-0.5117052197,
-0.2729257345,
-0.372263819,
0.5532251596,
0.5007604361,
-0.7292893529,
-0.1357380301,
-0.9627919197,
0.6743202209,
-0.7056819797,
0.2916798592,
0.2756300569,
0.5887557864,
-0.1519935131,
-0.695097506,
-0.3691188693,
0.4697905779,
-0.0847961903,
-0.0721936077,
-0.3224891722,
-0.2607284784,
0.4631039202,
0.1712898612,
-0.2502242029,
-0.2723581791,
-0.4488852024,
0.0133466683,
0.4250858426,
0.3201304078,
0.2740546465,
0.1039230749,
-0.4307171106,
0.1811691374,
-0.7665852308,
0.497264415,
-0.2159899771,
-0.1196762323,
0.3270015717,
0.0382040665,
-0.4269590974,
0.9015737772,
0.1505894512,
0.1078541949,
-0.0369105786,
-0.3637115657,
-0.3497973382,
-0.5734962225,
0.2261446714,
0.3589700162,
-0.1175936982,
-0.1781272888,
-0.3069187999,
-0.2343956232,
0.3170467019,
-0.7207376957,
0.0057750484,
0.384403199,
-0.4745250344,
-0.1434658021,
-0.1715027392,
-0.7388063669,
-0.2646244168,
-0.4580241442,
0.6759676933,
-0.1279640794,
-0.428468287,
0.0052553923,
-0.3482969999,
0.2777815163,
0.5773060322,
-0.6829832792,
0.3924325407,
0.4517463744,
0.4959111214,
0.1333664805,
0.0942304581,
-0.3736056089,
-0.1091960594,
-0.4613746107,
0.9610399604,
-0.6165341735,
-0.2458377182,
0.0595956407,
0.1438940316,
-0.2684507668,
-0.5582786798,
0.3806889057,
-1.0891735554,
0.3930644393,
-0.8833494186,
-0.5715580583,
-0.5109391809,
0.2373168319,
-0.6442171335,
0.8191145062,
0.4350297153,
-0.9087373018,
0.4180915654,
-0.6966987848,
-0.1415891796,
-0.2244520336,
-0.0901224241,
0.0041312873,
0.3126116097,
0.1097006649,
0.0488273948,
-0.4380357862,
0.2175616771,
-0.1023876294,
-0.6845080853,
0.3983214796,
-0.2546327114,
0.9830025434,
0.4564770758,
-0.2440605462,
-0.1540745497,
-0.5122588873,
0.1865621209,
-0.2324354202,
-0.180972293,
-0.7621843815,
0.0017235404,
0.0087672826,
0.4218502939,
0.2454073131,
-0.5672382116,
-0.0189909637,
-0.2248060852,
0.761636138,
0.4109884799,
0.416110754,
0.2520774305,
-0.5373994112,
0.6752510071,
0.3558263779,
0.3437331915,
-0.1200646386,
-0.4696448147,
-0.4098957181,
0.0221136566,
0.3233891129,
0.398684144,
-0.6006695032,
-0.2491403371,
0.0542238653,
-0.2848191559,
-0.1138037592,
-0.1636315882,
0.317802757,
0.7395139337,
0.445184648,
-0.2055524886,
-0.4670437872,
-0.9887759089,
-0.1970853955,
-0.2348261774,
-0.0161135625,
0.3366514146,
0.3982791305,
-0.1842659563,
1.2223137617,
-0.4489844739,
0.1577512771,
0.1181044132,
-0.1970335245,
0.081915237,
0.3209448457,
0.7742328048,
-1.1332179308,
-0.3115273714,
-0.5714155436,
-0.6013538241,
-0.1043520123,
0.3236129284,
-0.1335426271,
0.1155287176,
0.4096936285,
-0.3871568143,
0.4675087035,
0.2842178345,
-0.4013680816,
0.3020699322,
0.1931900829,
0.4633146822,
-1.3004963398,
0.4597150981,
-0.1367320269,
0.0192962717,
-0.9401379824,
0.0725958496,
0.115576297,
-0.0913159251,
-0.5764106512,
0.5479143858,
-0.1524771899,
0.0076316404,
-0.2247958481,
0.0985418186,
0.2330461293,
0.5516200066,
-0.0361273997,
0.9315258265,
0.3331013322,
-0.8811882138,
-0.0871882141,
0.4351802468,
-0.1798840165,
0.6004049778,
-0.8412824273,
0.1213767081,
-0.1846382618,
0.2020513862,
-1.0430190563,
-0.1015817225,
0.3147066832,
-0.2666853666,
-0.0288409926,
0.0104430839,
-0.1843856871,
-0.3548334241,
-0.0271897912,
0.8158022165,
0.5199202299,
-0.2558183074,
0.3148328364,
0.7367302179,
-0.0511316098,
-0.6568220258,
-0.3905209005,
-0.128861472,
-0.4689088762,
-0.4600672126,
0.1772638261,
-0.1224053502,
-0.4722279906,
-0.1104572639,
-0.4209260345,
-0.8268424273,
0.5037949681,
0.1689791381,
-0.2068151683,
-0.2892839015,
0.5196601748,
0.1839062124,
0.0077753458,
0.2088530511,
-0.2903253436,
0.1927944571,
-0.0483065173,
-0.2336808294,
-0.6875626445,
0.6484485865,
0.7528275847,
-0.2319266051,
0.4907239377,
0.0673005432,
-0.5545996428,
0.2130301148,
-0.4736185074,
-0.4081048965,
-0.3927038908,
0.1473677903,
-0.4303684235,
-0.9115206003,
0.7789174914,
-0.0181225743,
0.2056703269,
0.4046090841,
0.1044177711,
-0.2526350915,
1.0103430748,
0.8099299073,
0.1863556802,
0.568854928,
0.1207181886,
0.079535611,
-0.9032221437,
0.0214366037,
-0.7328068018,
-0.2641355693,
-0.4734958708,
-0.0509035736,
0.3831882477,
0.2624263763,
-0.3662134111,
0.3867065609,
-0.5689616799,
0.205467239,
0.6361185312,
0.0775540918,
0.4410373569,
-0.2505751252,
0.2414277047,
0.1530967653,
-0.8297448754,
-0.6774433851,
1.0506122112,
0.3716848791,
0.6159536242,
0.2353145331,
0.5784732699,
0.1762760133,
0.3447777927,
-0.378713876,
0.3543965816,
0.1607338637,
-0.982578218,
-0.6039887071,
-0.2089382559,
-0.9056848884,
0.2745178044,
0.1588751823,
-0.7875136733,
0.7537103891,
0.230584234,
-0.6894273162,
0.1976912618,
-0.5839161873,
0.8587509394,
0.3501967788,
-0.3069671988,
0.0735188574,
-0.6582403183,
0.3196726143,
-0.1036166027,
0.0757450834,
-0.0716422275,
0.0525272526,
0.8362760544,
-0.2437505722,
0.9504631162,
-0.4733187258,
-0.5823715925,
0.7562283874,
-0.0520394817,
0.276678592,
0.240275532,
0.0094598411,
-0.0540610291,
1.2359708548,
-0.4980673194,
-0.7258838415,
0.3545203805,
-0.4189307988,
-0.8684425354,
-0.2800330818,
-0.4814065695,
-0.4681436419,
0.2381299138,
0.0098063787,
0.7106758356,
-0.3299963176,
0.3031828701,
0.9152687788,
-0.0326865502,
0.3461557925,
0.6704602838,
-0.0002546877,
-0.1961431503,
0.3646886945,
0.2103604972,
0.0543796085,
0.4525812864,
-0.1216259375,
-0.5128272176,
-0.3749329448,
-0.5623007417,
-0.148659274,
-0.6614096165,
-0.3025071323,
-0.6776131392,
0.0032615871,
-0.3454979658,
0.2952069342,
0.0883254632,
-0.6422060132,
-0.0870632455,
0.355435729,
0.0484967194,
0.7969420552,
0.2565615475,
0.0299852807,
-0.8668062091,
0.1945330948,
0.8146288395,
0.3121460676,
0.0096314177,
-0.4518510401,
-0.2079570442,
0.3219108284,
-0.4121595621,
-1.3932971954,
0.0287167747,
-0.0724593624,
0.649916172,
0.1819348484,
0.4424556792,
0.442807436,
-0.1918309033,
0.7432464361,
-0.3189334869,
-0.8562718034,
0.6454735994,
-0.4871128201,
0.3551141322,
0.7844372392,
0.2694966197,
-0.7604570985,
-0.388461858,
-0.6273305416,
-0.5448355675,
0.527084291,
0.0727871209,
0.1732582152,
-0.0882554501,
0.6883170605,
0.012499094,
0.5595199466,
-0.3790604472,
-0.1342419982,
0.0104329577,
-0.1226430759,
0.1863708198,
-0.5402595997,
-0.4597609341,
-0.0197761878,
0.402284354,
-0.1773971468,
0.3420939744,
0.4192687273,
-0.0958445966,
-0.1964419484,
0.5389438272,
0.8683412075,
1.2796114683,
-0.2228508592,
0.0460789837,
0.3670878112,
-0.2794819772,
0.5394742489,
-0.2007137984,
-0.7385100126,
-0.0421155468,
-0.0453228429,
0.3283084333,
0.3052496314,
-0.7001645565,
0.3910329044,
-0.2469727844,
-0.1594374329,
-0.4038816988,
0.0518655814,
0.0365321003,
0.4191115201,
0.5259462595,
0.0971661061,
0.5467276573,
-0.530207932,
0.2353117615,
0.5519029498,
-0.6977653503,
-0.3523032963,
0.6086470485,
0.4243565202,
-0.1841335893,
0.1564662158,
0.1691797972,
-0.3636469841,
0.9270790219,
0.4464815259,
0.7563539743,
-0.0614818372,
0.387979269,
0.2620314956,
0.0401724093,
0.099642083,
0.5370730758,
-0.2863400877,
-0.43038854,
-0.2648074627,
-0.4610323012,
-0.5380951166,
0.342569232,
-0.9286676049,
-0.1643302441,
-0.1797941476,
-0.4057281017,
-0.2534632087,
0.1481204331,
-0.463485986,
0.3335572481,
-0.3200106025,
1.0504276752,
-0.9365907907,
0.453936398,
1.0407140255,
-0.506603241,
-0.5730971694,
0.27859357,
-0.3674165905,
-0.1746536195,
0.7097124457,
0.0706204399,
-0.0174078941,
0.0200989097,
-0.4024464488,
-1.2466554642,
1.2065097094,
0.224368602,
-0.2921835184,
-0.0131761068,
-0.2146955281,
0.6659887433,
-0.4345239103,
0.1260004044,
0.5218149424,
0.4901444316,
-0.0079919044,
-0.8438112736,
0.3308350742,
-0.1769381016,
0.0945674703,
0.1680028141,
-0.8270198703,
0.7273429036,
-0.1345113814,
-0.5786909461,
0.2790879607,
0.3908881545,
0.0693646148,
0.6753273606,
0.5113635659,
0.2598570287,
0.7058150768,
-0.08507967,
0.5201209188,
-0.3791080117,
0.150498122,
1.0218031406,
-0.2191632092,
0.8908711672,
0.675712347,
-0.2268281132,
0.6732564569,
0.9042266607,
0.4565483034,
0.5196877718,
0.0478240475,
-0.2152545303,
-0.3940730095,
0.0345256925,
-0.6277551055,
0.2606594563,
0.0414893739,
-0.2894643545,
-0.3751963675,
0.0833477154,
-0.3419503272,
-0.012082886,
-0.1032807305,
0.9428460002,
-0.0982047841,
-0.8155328631,
0.6775628328,
-0.3383302391,
0.19328399,
-0.1253904551,
-0.1355826706,
-0.6052829623,
-0.1666876078,
0.0561766773,
-0.5614088774,
0.4358378351,
-0.1382638365,
-0.559332788,
-0.0284021813,
0.611892283,
-0.1667255312,
-0.0963490605,
-0.0039171572,
0.8550266027,
0.0406347178,
-0.176152125,
-0.4676133692,
-0.2555785179,
-0.111056827,
-0.1047625095,
0.3587264717,
0.6029697061,
-0.2473595887,
0.7387575507,
0.2741543949,
-0.3657057881,
-0.2641105354,
-0.1989877671,
1.0544669628,
-0.7070916295,
-0.4832556546,
-0.2789527178,
0.3704375029,
-0.0386837795,
-0.4337470233,
0.5324133039,
0.2195211351,
0.5375590324,
0.022136135,
0.6364454031,
-0.091692701,
0.7276562452,
-0.3532510102,
0.5959367156,
-0.7328742146,
0.3535068333,
-0.1599730849,
-0.8266003728,
0.0278187897,
0.1817681938,
-0.3092951775,
0.138325721,
0.6623842716,
0.596254468,
0.049111709,
0.0798749998,
0.4223523736,
-0.0440708697,
0.1561544389,
0.616908133,
1.0708065033,
-0.7943015695,
0.5361410379,
-0.0884928778,
-0.2317744493,
-0.4046892822,
-0.5244078636,
-0.5776312351,
-0.9213513136,
-0.3520996571,
-0.1589712948,
0.2895643413,
0.1965915561,
0.7014605999,
-1.0280839205,
0.1459002644,
-0.0614244752,
0.3894138038,
-0.5435186625,
-0.2100248039,
0.2823336422,
-0.5169636011,
-0.7024079561,
0.148260504,
0.0182399433,
0.1640216261,
-0.1389355361,
0.3010144532,
-0.1802774966,
0.4097751081,
0.5188686252,
0.608461082,
-0.5555838943,
-0.4077672958,
0.2851209939,
-0.1733540297,
-0.0333486013,
0.7763323188,
-0.9361066222,
0.1246672645,
0.7886959314,
0.5058133602,
0.1137409061,
0.4510392547,
0.6377202868,
-0.2056348622,
-0.187385872,
0.2844561636,
0.1724225432,
-0.0226425827,
-0.2826645374,
0.391646713,
0.0301566087,
-0.7647737861,
-0.9450309873,
0.4327411354,
-0.5484502316,
-0.5598835945,
0.9866173863,
-0.1278636903,
-0.1448931694,
-0.5296286345,
-0.1881207377,
-0.0701487586,
-0.2071604431,
0.9975901842,
0.5980546474,
-0.2590242028,
-0.0801569968,
-0.5791522861,
0.8805644512,
0.5815521479,
-0.7326953411,
0.0820476264,
0.715816915,
0.6040413976,
0.2885644138,
0.852899611,
-0.213781476,
0.6044948697,
-0.1694571078,
-0.403966248,
0.2382116318,
-0.411318332,
-0.3867245913,
0.5002532005,
0.1991367936,
-0.3366515338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17979v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17979v1
|
Entity Linking in the Job Market Domain
| 2024-01-31T16:34:10 | 2024-01-31T16:34:10 |
Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In Natural Language Processing, entity linking (EL) has centered around
Wikipedia, but yet remains underexplored for the job market domain.
Disambiguating skill mentions can help us get insight into the current labor
market demands. In this work, we are the first to explore EL in this domain,
specifically targeting the linkage of occupational skills to the ESCO taxonomy
(le Vrang et al., 2014). Previous efforts linked coarse-grained (full)
sentences to a corresponding ESCO skill. In this work, we link more
fine-grained span-level mentions of skills. We tune two high-performing neural
EL models, a bi-encoder (Wu et al., 2020) and an autoregressive model (Cao et
al., 2021), on a synthetically generated mention--skill pair dataset and
evaluate them on a human-annotated skill-linking benchmark. Our findings reveal
that both models are capable of linking implicit mentions of skills to their
correct taxonomy counterparts. Empirically, BLINK outperforms GENRE in strict
evaluation, but GENRE performs better in loose evaluation (accuracy@$k$).
|
[
-0.2701669037,
-0.5123231411,
0.4812666476,
0.1740695685,
-0.0092042815,
-0.1472719312,
-0.3690723181,
-1.2461106777,
0.3745366335,
0.3182125688,
-0.3902755976,
-0.521250844,
-0.4353682101,
0.3562216461,
-0.6249566674,
1.2859661579,
0.3938497007,
-0.5042626858,
-0.657766819,
0.0089874929,
-0.1248185858,
-0.1845685244,
-1.063167572,
-0.132353425,
0.9413636923,
0.064212501,
0.7105270624,
0.802202642,
0.3600937724,
0.301109612,
0.1302220076,
0.1725277454,
-0.2792399526,
0.3259605765,
-0.3286335766,
-0.3679650426,
-0.7233157158,
-0.0340085514,
0.3447949886,
1.028050065,
-0.0311017055,
0.4478161335,
0.0243347697,
0.6038553715,
-0.5657948256,
0.4074606597,
-1.1784071922,
-0.543571353,
-0.5354075432,
-0.0135260839,
-0.4106883705,
-0.1099024713,
0.1820183396,
-0.7903661132,
0.5415711403,
0.2953326702,
1.1617974043,
0.4406548738,
-0.52301687,
-0.3639282584,
-0.5659137368,
0.3182850182,
-0.2723525763,
0.4836984575,
0.6108763814,
0.0515561253,
0.4099003971,
-0.5108693242,
-0.4740593433,
-0.2228087187,
-0.0607844405,
-0.0193394683,
-0.1084104255,
0.2517462671,
0.214024514,
0.3655514121,
-0.2452479452,
0.2530699968,
-0.7526405454,
0.06127242,
0.7396540642,
0.1594628692,
0.2146278471,
-0.0941800773,
-0.330684036,
0.1415396631,
-0.8375197053,
-0.1266033798,
0.77676934,
0.1787972301,
0.1493810266,
0.7686654925,
-0.3200474679,
0.757770896,
0.1029325798,
0.093852371,
0.1556656659,
-0.3338634372,
0.0476259664,
0.083093442,
0.6476625204,
0.4359107316,
0.3421057761,
-0.5955892801,
-0.2109301686,
-0.0087283514,
0.7015314698,
-0.1434343755,
-0.1841039658,
-0.119180657,
-0.1189707667,
-0.1235277504,
-0.0246956032,
-0.4224384725,
-0.2590481639,
-0.16736269,
0.5271511078,
-0.2284692973,
0.0479054451,
-0.0932765976,
-0.0188673511,
-0.0785738379,
-0.071878694,
-1.0903184414,
0.3976344168,
0.8486561775,
0.7597180009,
0.0664570555,
-0.351800561,
-0.2056368291,
0.4410656393,
-0.0815337002,
0.9822673798,
-0.5550864339,
0.0078967242,
0.2818270028,
0.1346399635,
-0.2369145453,
-0.5610081553,
0.3754765391,
-0.8065299988,
-0.2698277533,
-0.1866837144,
-0.3506613672,
-0.0800812617,
0.0434038006,
-0.9189522266,
1.4200180769,
0.1859763414,
-0.7157198191,
0.7843328714,
-0.6289458871,
-0.5260184407,
-0.0688866824,
-0.0089218402,
-0.2329129577,
-0.0837915316,
-0.3014179468,
0.4617163837,
-0.3626672029,
0.1692093015,
-0.3602656722,
-0.4792546034,
0.2143218815,
-0.2165466845,
0.4308504462,
-0.0448934101,
-0.2941656411,
-0.2484067529,
-0.5735632777,
-0.5480703712,
-0.1196797714,
-0.2916617692,
-0.6806721091,
-0.0988005847,
-0.144166857,
0.3714301884,
0.2304041535,
-0.3812132776,
0.0526806377,
-0.6102944016,
0.0588565394,
0.5286044478,
-0.0211359803,
0.4665404856,
-0.1616642922,
0.1935243011,
-0.0578104965,
-0.0468927994,
0.0669407696,
-0.5242930055,
-0.9450338483,
0.0477680638,
0.3333969712,
0.2845655978,
-0.7575541735,
0.4323096871,
-0.3310163021,
-0.6093046069,
-1.049017787,
0.0276814867,
0.4610205889,
0.6870462894,
0.6935719252,
-0.2237249762,
-0.4813793898,
-1.1950960159,
-0.6054569483,
-0.1387386322,
-0.2758192122,
0.3067917228,
0.504416585,
0.0008503285,
0.6934851408,
-0.4868660271,
-0.5215530396,
0.1342895925,
0.2142261863,
0.0983583257,
0.1339178383,
0.5126892924,
-0.6016589403,
-0.7473477721,
-0.0854103938,
-0.4798811674,
-0.1401114017,
-0.0918478444,
-0.1685195565,
0.1970537752,
0.4631861448,
-0.6682695746,
0.361659646,
0.2775492072,
-0.5041083694,
0.4998408854,
-0.1260333806,
0.0797403157,
-0.8694301844,
0.2897110581,
0.5383357406,
0.0092737908,
-0.4253985584,
-0.3826780617,
-0.3101499081,
0.0532909073,
-0.2609840631,
0.6552360058,
-0.6578105688,
-0.5320631266,
-0.1296085864,
0.2528250217,
-0.0194422379,
0.4555876851,
0.128009066,
0.8649582267,
0.6628297567,
-0.6911092997,
0.2957855463,
0.2816925049,
-0.2725137174,
0.630720973,
-0.7541150451,
0.1298355311,
-0.1731846035,
0.038425412,
-0.6099008918,
-0.1211170331,
-0.0900027156,
-0.1873034686,
0.2025939226,
-0.114762865,
-0.6645742655,
-0.3729700148,
-0.2913449705,
0.2794098258,
0.3030945957,
-0.1417360306,
0.2221819013,
0.4546179175,
-0.2674745619,
-0.6120106578,
-0.6484479308,
-0.0207208116,
-0.0875785425,
-0.4940182269,
0.85704422,
0.2339201272,
-0.0396210402,
0.2832767069,
-0.2716855109,
-0.3328725696,
0.193676576,
0.2865850329,
0.5851607323,
-0.2423167676,
0.3298221827,
0.0870605558,
-0.2473996133,
0.2571085095,
-0.1171389893,
0.0467468686,
0.0768517107,
-0.3608654439,
-0.0579869002,
0.064626351,
0.3758845925,
-0.1601934284,
1.2485781908,
0.7500630617,
-0.4175965786,
-0.1465732008,
-0.7345896959,
-0.1223810539,
-0.4520909786,
0.4051058292,
-0.185679242,
-0.7627852559,
0.2825066149,
-0.0683877543,
-0.1470874995,
0.7932143807,
0.1911799461,
-0.321201086,
0.4264605939,
0.8215801716,
-0.0111119263,
0.2295497954,
-0.1318940967,
0.3343964219,
-1.2313234806,
-0.5220077038,
-0.5806299448,
-0.4105382264,
-0.3188174665,
-0.4281201065,
0.3263360858,
0.0278417282,
-0.1935421675,
0.8429206014,
-0.4332535565,
0.3593651056,
0.591283381,
0.0909688994,
0.3675120473,
-0.1952388138,
0.0160731487,
0.1075362563,
-0.5395721197,
-0.5614519715,
1.0701479912,
0.3409723938,
0.448630631,
-0.0997036397,
0.4868473709,
0.2780434489,
0.2565505505,
-0.6061640382,
0.520410955,
-0.2874792814,
-0.6807227731,
-0.5503874421,
0.0184417702,
-0.7494919896,
-0.0476718508,
-0.6275981665,
-0.6858350039,
0.0992194936,
0.203310594,
-0.3076978922,
0.313981235,
-0.5049048662,
0.9483526945,
0.044055853,
-0.5902665854,
-0.2189317495,
-0.5276330709,
-0.0024545135,
-0.1642733812,
0.1620172709,
-0.385997355,
-0.3271015286,
0.6173598766,
-0.1803967208,
0.9449022412,
0.1666417271,
-0.1574566513,
0.2673262954,
-0.0530053936,
0.4102086425,
-0.0106077287,
-0.481186986,
0.4156217277,
-0.285702318,
-0.1974138618,
-0.3211456537,
0.7804343104,
-0.4150621891,
-0.3224116564,
-0.1858370751,
-0.3097105622,
-0.5405971408,
0.0828203186,
0.2942064404,
0.2999114394,
-0.2079860419,
0.2667284906,
0.7140946388,
0.1749207228,
0.1651448756,
0.4592830837,
0.450314343,
0.0932397842,
0.6644352078,
0.2039124668,
0.1060853451,
0.3326667547,
-0.698477447,
-0.4787665904,
-0.1199144199,
-0.0555281304,
0.4155147076,
-0.5635380745,
-0.3943886459,
-0.7211628556,
-0.2454628497,
-0.2854503989,
-0.4357658327,
-0.3221576512,
0.0190367382,
-0.0043720622,
-0.2706272006,
0.4843791127,
0.586582303,
0.1879908741,
-0.15802297,
-0.5591036677,
0.2726829648,
0.3849210739,
0.787889421,
0.2208887488,
-0.019550262,
-0.7885836959,
0.0469597541,
0.0150597822,
-0.9287781119,
-0.0101475716,
0.4528232813,
0.5701280236,
0.2549403608,
0.0188750271,
0.5849701762,
-0.6555739641,
0.7356534004,
0.1938876808,
-0.7599144578,
0.4602280259,
-0.337703526,
-0.1576550156,
0.7234038115,
0.8463152051,
-0.6897423267,
-0.5469499826,
-0.6180439591,
-1.2014832497,
0.6056700945,
0.2923048735,
0.1790226698,
-0.6426007748,
0.194699958,
0.1617723852,
0.4500469565,
-0.6463070512,
-0.4026940167,
0.3079759479,
-0.3551814854,
0.2535530925,
-0.3603478074,
0.0545610562,
-0.2211891264,
0.6582683325,
0.0344532207,
0.3659207821,
0.0967756584,
-0.3622910976,
-0.1482114792,
0.2071643174,
0.1344121546,
0.4973157942,
0.0163603071,
0.2094948441,
0.3165008724,
-0.3358132839,
-0.2551080883,
-0.0404767282,
-0.0268899631,
0.2174769044,
0.31849581,
0.8335630894,
0.8599920869,
-0.5398247838,
0.5798355937,
0.7560856938,
-0.2003386468,
-0.3226029575,
0.2969623208,
0.3150987625,
0.2873685956,
0.5324521065,
0.0750527158,
0.3169143796,
-0.6675789952,
0.2036451995,
0.2162483633,
-0.5594285131,
-0.5478143096,
1.0749782324,
0.5642350912,
-0.0720076263,
0.6869820356,
-0.1706444919,
-0.2339891195,
0.6228376031,
0.5808912516,
0.9269931912,
0.1494838893,
0.0935126096,
0.5851477981,
0.1877314895,
-0.1323254257,
-0.1769719869,
-0.1437749565,
-0.5136360526,
-0.346721828,
-0.6336998343,
-0.1900623292,
-0.2185049057,
-0.7409084439,
0.3253323436,
0.0460506268,
-0.2292264104,
0.2078976929,
-0.2630988359,
-1.1521505117,
0.4068641067,
0.3467698395,
0.7739635706,
-0.9954108,
0.844776392,
0.8293545246,
-0.9964336753,
-0.5660640001,
0.0769410729,
-0.2184085697,
-0.5012862086,
0.9345341325,
0.111701861,
-0.2301587164,
0.3285413682,
-0.102413699,
-0.6989508867,
1.4570301771,
0.2260531783,
-0.411085546,
-0.6565762162,
0.0382374078,
0.5921692252,
-0.4171373844,
0.4203421772,
0.3538082242,
0.2764939368,
-0.2246709764,
-1.4017255306,
-0.0185135026,
-0.1796200424,
0.1217862219,
0.2842150331,
-0.5934739113,
0.5595070124,
-0.1500776559,
-0.3261374831,
-0.2569262087,
0.7160416842,
-0.0417898186,
0.5159945488,
0.6073481441,
0.4623123407,
0.7364230156,
-0.0869240612,
0.6136655211,
-0.6352868676,
0.4520589113,
1.0915620327,
-0.3670505881,
1.1176373959,
0.3144544959,
-0.3397047222,
1.0986560583,
0.4205697477,
-0.2895434499,
0.2816832066,
-0.0122387996,
-0.3306201696,
-0.1623152792,
-0.3197022378,
-0.2005332559,
0.304161191,
0.1891027987,
-0.4981146753,
-0.1930020005,
-0.186281845,
-0.1125817001,
0.2265075296,
-0.5126885772,
0.8412674665,
0.1483145654,
-0.5584400296,
0.1158746406,
-0.1466416419,
0.9100148082,
-0.5158956051,
-0.3138459921,
0.083588548,
-0.5496798158,
-0.4393691421,
-1.022632122,
0.696352005,
0.1769226789,
-0.379585892,
-0.1833786666,
0.8741755486,
-0.8176780343,
0.0216969475,
0.2545149028,
0.2143021524,
0.1432829052,
-0.1334358901,
-0.5660300851,
-0.2615201771,
-0.4788896441,
-0.0214273855,
0.303078264,
0.5408657789,
0.1313228011,
0.6439522505,
0.5327651501,
0.1173717454,
0.0918556005,
-0.0285245646,
0.6537489295,
-0.8051603436,
-0.453691721,
-0.4354162514,
0.8057061434,
-0.3809338808,
-0.5148327947,
0.5468716621,
0.7467057109,
1.2628530264,
-0.3746217787,
0.4477969706,
-0.1567959338,
0.3308337331,
-0.4633433521,
0.7501326799,
-0.5856901407,
0.2216314673,
-0.2430871874,
-1.1789418459,
0.2734591663,
0.3263035119,
-0.3826493025,
0.1067566276,
0.9520219564,
0.7751327157,
-0.1705618799,
-0.543956697,
0.2866733968,
0.0622309409,
-0.6069541574,
0.4945723414,
0.258700043,
-0.4812450409,
0.5798203349,
-0.3496651351,
0.3376173675,
-0.4849003255,
-0.7634090185,
-0.6901647449,
-0.9531407356,
-0.7756750584,
-0.2325799018,
0.0858031213,
0.8164541125,
0.5148723125,
-0.3513557613,
-0.0947920159,
0.2712580264,
0.0209373292,
-0.4716165066,
-0.2473745793,
0.1968618184,
-0.3397054672,
-0.7646238208,
0.4104683995,
0.5859647393,
-0.3764436841,
-0.2179244459,
0.2190428078,
-0.3301448524,
0.07256262,
0.5576901436,
0.1965826154,
-0.7039529085,
-0.3369286954,
-0.0477557555,
-0.4097898901,
-0.3440096676,
0.4912026227,
-0.6477655768,
0.3475442827,
0.190030992,
0.6755985022,
0.3594691157,
0.0041686487,
0.3945921361,
-0.8963503838,
-0.001745833,
0.1802586615,
0.2355905026,
0.1899938583,
-0.6719256639,
0.8019218445,
0.2330307961,
-0.3546731174,
-0.6212213635,
0.1158658117,
-0.8161186576,
0.0259825755,
1.057240963,
0.1465544701,
-0.3368171453,
-0.3280659914,
0.1934365481,
0.4834097624,
-0.2062859237,
0.9827491045,
0.504170537,
-0.016044246,
0.093146123,
-0.6907711625,
0.5928339362,
-0.0847231671,
-0.5751650333,
-0.172081992,
0.3810575604,
0.3582371175,
0.099802725,
0.84201473,
0.1077682227,
0.5021111369,
0.3955116272,
0.2839550376,
-0.2634980679,
-0.5425658822,
0.1238060147,
0.0155374948,
0.4374729097,
-0.0483411066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17974v1
|
GUMsley: Evaluating Entity Salience in Summarization for 12 English Genres
| 2024-01-31T16:30:50 | 2024-01-31T16:30:50 |
Jessica Lin, Amir Zeldes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As NLP models become increasingly capable of understanding documents in terms
of coherent entities rather than strings, obtaining the most salient entities
for each document is not only an important end task in itself but also vital
for Information Retrieval (IR) and other downstream applications such as
controllable summarization. In this paper, we present and evaluate GUMsley, the
first entity salience dataset covering all named and non-named salient entities
for 12 genres of English text, aligned with entity types, Wikification links
and full coreference resolution annotations. We promote a strict definition of
salience using human summaries and demonstrate high inter-annotator agreement
for salience based on whether a source entity is mentioned in the summary. Our
evaluation shows poor performance by pre-trained SOTA summarization models and
zero-shot LLM prompting in capturing salient entities in generated summaries.
We also show that predicting or providing salient entities to several model
architectures enhances performance and helps derive higher-quality summaries by
alleviating the entity hallucination problem in existing abstractive
summarization.
|
[
-0.3707537949,
-0.2852846086,
0.4515225291,
0.320985198,
-0.3081439435,
-0.1495871991,
-0.3317599595,
-0.8803779483,
0.7030782104,
0.1592915952,
-0.3661348522,
-0.6566505432,
-0.6758272052,
0.5351881981,
-0.6552923918,
1.2476398945,
0.236670956,
-0.0245187692,
-0.2493611723,
-0.1626894623,
-0.2977907062,
-0.2345950007,
-0.2419346422,
0.0175964907,
0.8227528334,
0.3736492991,
0.4287512004,
0.4587417841,
0.8384116888,
0.2517216802,
-0.189676404,
-0.1298670471,
-0.5258378983,
0.4233204722,
-0.5495637059,
-0.2482243478,
-0.6486514211,
-0.1680291742,
0.3935958445,
0.908095181,
0.1443779767,
0.438220799,
-0.0503618903,
0.5405021906,
-0.6589569449,
0.2591829002,
-0.5959262848,
-0.0260079149,
-0.5629894137,
-0.3087537587,
-0.2853744924,
-0.3429970145,
0.3981246054,
-0.5958949924,
0.3187536597,
0.4034714401,
1.2617827654,
0.3903977871,
-0.2341371328,
-0.4348524213,
-0.4528177381,
0.6048931479,
-0.4482593834,
0.2850057781,
0.0920210257,
0.098471798,
0.2539741397,
-0.6300963163,
-0.1610743999,
-0.2394660413,
-0.1736325473,
0.371119529,
-0.3624728322,
0.0480307117,
0.1005016789,
0.5878508687,
-0.5842556953,
0.158632338,
-0.4454879761,
0.0612636954,
0.5239698887,
-0.0533739664,
0.1187424809,
-0.4292525351,
-0.4538981616,
0.3026261926,
-0.4464634359,
0.059467759,
0.3380313218,
0.0281897485,
0.3534932435,
0.6622359157,
-0.1129016206,
0.4137309492,
0.1295956373,
-0.2719002068,
-0.0960421339,
-0.2935592234,
-0.1900495738,
0.4723784924,
0.4226496518,
0.3694484234,
0.2050752938,
-0.4342889786,
-0.2722513676,
0.1170414835,
0.132972762,
-0.7593613863,
-0.3007597327,
0.3515684307,
-0.444560647,
-0.1387709677,
0.1471528411,
-0.6583913565,
-0.2314020693,
-0.1457263678,
-0.1914642751,
-0.9402022362,
-0.286411494,
0.0324870124,
-0.3421062827,
0.0028361077,
0.2629180849,
-1.07584548,
0.3764533103,
0.6373764277,
0.7672073245,
-0.4005174935,
-0.4218527675,
-0.1394737661,
0.3709698021,
-0.1751279235,
1.4220026731,
-0.4415209591,
-0.4534667134,
-0.6027013063,
-0.2160335034,
0.2182958275,
-0.597268343,
0.5469290614,
-0.2741003633,
-0.0123099098,
-0.2694099545,
-0.5395109057,
-0.34729141,
-0.1321218759,
-0.7736484408,
0.8485884666,
0.3101248741,
-0.8414572477,
0.6104944348,
-0.6545810699,
-0.6187794805,
0.293022722,
-0.0152249923,
-0.2896687388,
0.4193270206,
-0.1064919382,
0.5714850426,
-0.1711818576,
0.4354797304,
-0.0380277224,
-0.3861882985,
0.224342972,
-0.0584985241,
0.4299588501,
-0.0694517493,
-0.2809448242,
0.2588109374,
-0.7076938152,
-0.2702792585,
-0.0156138595,
-0.0315136388,
-0.8323321342,
-0.3525069058,
0.1194419041,
-0.1141371578,
0.0790323466,
-0.0352208912,
0.0007653022,
-0.3282597959,
-0.1694732606,
0.5973336101,
0.3018506169,
0.3118779957,
-0.242923528,
0.6157187223,
0.1045862958,
-0.2901633978,
-0.3418286443,
-0.4061751962,
-0.4814164042,
-0.5889073014,
0.663061142,
0.2587576509,
-0.3556767702,
0.4913107753,
-0.5085647106,
-0.547287643,
-0.5140070319,
-0.2084982097,
0.591257751,
0.6379747391,
0.4680474102,
-0.5472140312,
-0.6047438383,
-0.9665947556,
-0.4253821671,
-0.1905281991,
-0.1666122526,
0.1301218718,
0.504062593,
0.1485310793,
0.7991169691,
-0.3157819211,
-0.2802007794,
-0.2321060598,
0.2982187271,
-0.0342381969,
0.1723032594,
0.7837831974,
-0.5874093175,
-0.1659122556,
-0.3680057526,
-0.7861460447,
-0.37166816,
0.012082044,
-0.1841940135,
0.1869722009,
-0.1338614076,
-0.7689570189,
0.2554510534,
0.2575182915,
-0.449336797,
0.7199755907,
0.3742009997,
0.2660918534,
-0.7785772085,
0.4993628561,
0.1377332658,
-0.232289046,
-0.3173260391,
-0.0047808951,
0.0837753639,
0.0055608233,
-0.2558072209,
0.3622101247,
-0.909794271,
-0.4774450064,
0.0459648818,
0.4795690477,
0.2587661743,
0.24742724,
0.2219610512,
0.7675131559,
0.3878775537,
-0.9020840526,
0.3606757224,
0.0934522226,
-0.2105424553,
0.9126951694,
-0.5087379217,
-0.3602095544,
-0.564016223,
-0.00446303,
-0.6414040327,
-0.4554412663,
-0.0225794557,
-0.4327487051,
0.3063026369,
0.0101292804,
-0.1610030681,
0.1342225075,
-0.4617855251,
0.0575896539,
0.1091288254,
-0.0877538696,
0.5469037294,
0.48346892,
-0.3957173228,
-0.7162895203,
-0.6003453135,
0.1495731026,
-0.3852801025,
-0.4167189002,
0.5051825643,
0.1721975654,
-0.4676756263,
0.3881560564,
-0.4203236103,
0.1464591473,
0.5188845396,
0.340575546,
0.3353008628,
-0.2817333043,
0.2041721642,
0.073711738,
-0.3825269938,
-0.0221985523,
-0.3761865199,
0.2444497645,
-0.2160703689,
-0.0852922723,
0.0389567278,
0.3891845047,
0.1953358799,
-0.4874660075,
0.513042748,
0.3322786391,
-0.4052474797,
0.1183981672,
-0.3731795847,
-0.178385213,
-0.2389641255,
0.5141914487,
-0.445387423,
-0.4415823221,
0.3828077018,
0.0433840677,
0.2048945278,
0.6330313087,
0.2469079494,
-0.1398817152,
0.3523083329,
0.479216665,
0.0814680457,
0.4374457002,
-0.2608341575,
0.1357252747,
-0.5919036269,
-0.3359696269,
-0.530364573,
-0.3452149928,
-0.3514572382,
0.0751795992,
0.4822960496,
0.2453323305,
0.4774140716,
0.5053952336,
-0.4424551725,
0.5914727449,
0.389652729,
-0.2034586072,
0.6862364411,
-0.0652387664,
0.1763353348,
-0.2347395569,
-0.3957121074,
-0.7358606458,
0.6676741242,
0.1996402442,
0.6912632585,
0.6694182158,
0.7566446066,
0.1027440131,
0.3862668574,
-1.0691363811,
0.6843531728,
0.0002067284,
-0.3555198312,
-0.4107754529,
-0.2507693172,
-1.0040085316,
0.0907183439,
-0.2486498356,
-0.5529752374,
0.2247455567,
0.1630429626,
-0.5656738281,
-0.0667541325,
-0.6415246725,
0.6728935838,
-0.2184378207,
-0.3147523701,
-0.1642017961,
-0.5618472695,
0.6865106821,
0.2518987656,
-0.1340081841,
-0.5232468843,
-0.2716661096,
0.5696783662,
0.023630118,
0.2092163265,
0.0072825607,
-0.0253807828,
-0.0282693673,
0.2729288638,
0.0204424188,
0.2701233625,
-0.0887134448,
0.3263191581,
-0.0427469388,
-0.4298225641,
-0.5388813615,
0.6200154424,
-0.333822459,
-0.6301788092,
-0.6440470219,
-0.3956473172,
0.0261143167,
0.4192408025,
0.4830338657,
0.4542858601,
-0.2663958669,
0.1696493775,
0.9449357986,
0.3398268819,
0.5800024867,
0.4834721088,
-0.2159031183,
0.0100980448,
0.7426287532,
0.4111929834,
-0.0046110419,
0.5193991661,
-0.2842786014,
-0.2826631367,
-0.6007883549,
-0.3630563617,
0.1577385664,
-0.7105936408,
-0.4959171712,
-0.9025697112,
-0.0098556885,
-0.5703574419,
-0.1854062825,
-0.2538288236,
-0.7932863832,
-0.3372923434,
-0.3823785782,
0.4141900539,
0.5124949217,
0.2655569315,
-0.2335408479,
-0.6372308135,
0.1932150126,
-0.062103536,
0.3940062821,
-0.1696739048,
-0.4193063676,
-0.3143024445,
-0.7568753958,
-0.2125789374,
-1.3220187426,
0.4395391345,
0.2401686758,
0.4891847074,
0.5199123621,
0.0962765813,
0.6298508644,
-0.1988906264,
0.7997192144,
0.0688678995,
-0.922555089,
0.623699069,
-0.0748300105,
0.152294904,
0.5684403181,
0.7740758657,
-0.4772141874,
-0.485709399,
-0.7760014534,
-1.2367553711,
0.3770959377,
0.1534575224,
-0.35831967,
-0.0788540244,
0.0890266448,
0.27441594,
0.3486877084,
-0.4761365652,
-0.3711462021,
-0.3422894478,
-0.3905438185,
0.2292252183,
-0.5250030756,
0.0333782248,
0.238833636,
0.9628534317,
0.0251113232,
0.0498678274,
0.3229773045,
-0.5621823668,
0.1306724548,
0.5294026732,
0.5626874566,
0.8699130416,
-0.3216583729,
0.4164056778,
0.0709043071,
-0.5304019451,
0.0422549732,
0.3727324605,
-0.3198744059,
0.5662015676,
0.5004284978,
0.6598511934,
0.8493344784,
-0.6867063642,
0.3402596116,
-0.0784099624,
0.3394404948,
-0.4219136536,
0.2312217951,
-0.1004470214,
0.104708001,
0.4462546706,
0.2450438887,
0.7564195395,
-0.5117456317,
0.0472758934,
0.198944211,
-0.1563351899,
-0.4705444276,
0.641635716,
0.1358872652,
0.0780835524,
0.0592104532,
-0.3574672043,
-0.0424350277,
0.1977893412,
0.3212707937,
0.8047213554,
-0.3016052246,
-0.042211704,
0.2083983421,
0.1787984073,
0.1465615481,
0.0490403734,
0.0060348832,
-0.3702311516,
-0.0803760961,
-0.4760428667,
-0.5161083937,
-0.2821123004,
-0.8873571157,
0.4684060514,
-0.383944571,
-0.3596845269,
0.484088093,
-0.0367884561,
-0.3451957107,
0.074344635,
-0.1978907585,
0.8832768798,
-0.4695631266,
0.3240434229,
0.9592955112,
-0.8940236568,
-0.6361641288,
0.1731826067,
0.0381536409,
-0.2532211542,
0.4502377808,
0.156920895,
-0.2271205634,
0.3161179721,
-0.3369098008,
-0.9266163111,
1.4715530872,
0.515864253,
-0.3785798848,
-0.3543983102,
-0.5002997518,
0.3975960314,
-0.1511176825,
0.7617739439,
0.6286299229,
0.3610742688,
0.0337223783,
-0.7228078842,
-0.0139430612,
-0.3745087087,
0.3110017776,
-0.1436614692,
-0.6794427633,
0.6958943009,
-0.2467742264,
-0.6393525004,
-0.3084433973,
1.1885221004,
0.6081718802,
0.2741963565,
0.2700884044,
0.1795930266,
1.1835064888,
-0.3097340465,
1.1083476543,
-0.5662534237,
0.1898869425,
1.0642367601,
-0.2711291313,
0.3767392635,
0.4301095903,
-0.0605136603,
0.4771521091,
0.6862470508,
0.0059185997,
0.478091985,
0.0195953995,
-0.3148505986,
0.3128938079,
-0.6089172959,
-0.3372609913,
0.4171679318,
0.2330952436,
-0.2732305527,
-0.191544354,
-0.0937825888,
0.3736408949,
0.1940675378,
-0.402243644,
0.7601320148,
0.1047347263,
-0.807574451,
0.266405493,
0.2921053469,
0.7352420092,
-0.5482893586,
0.0050673038,
-0.4735445082,
-0.2302580476,
-0.4519689977,
-0.6970397234,
0.428879261,
0.2524155676,
-0.5982091427,
-0.1687242985,
0.7601863742,
-0.3505479991,
-0.2153591216,
0.1633170247,
0.1810678542,
0.6403675079,
-0.0364727639,
-0.2320614755,
-0.3484066129,
-0.4027592242,
-0.3707513511,
0.1509904861,
0.7794731259,
-0.098596856,
0.4682025611,
0.3359573781,
0.4161393046,
-0.0385730267,
0.0774183497,
0.7901967764,
-0.8256462812,
-0.4740749002,
-0.8474115729,
0.5575515628,
-0.2507537007,
-0.3547679186,
0.9792040586,
0.7150827646,
0.7644295096,
-0.2063204199,
0.679597795,
-0.1673417091,
0.5881706476,
-0.7460407019,
0.5147948265,
-0.1127630621,
0.4559890926,
-0.3612805009,
-0.7901985049,
-0.1755575687,
0.4447767437,
-0.2244372964,
0.0332607068,
0.9373207092,
0.5023539662,
-0.1116886213,
0.0800976008,
0.4476142824,
0.1755715162,
-0.0769975185,
0.4010977745,
0.5144845247,
-0.1482573152,
0.28955549,
-0.1664630473,
-0.1737070829,
-0.4093700945,
-0.7729702592,
-0.72787714,
-0.4766005576,
-0.2005566061,
-0.4112935662,
0.1342288852,
1.1235585213,
0.4009229839,
-1.0520679951,
0.0891486481,
0.4126182199,
0.3010135293,
-0.3667676151,
-0.2782278955,
0.2760391533,
-0.2651423216,
-0.9078384042,
0.1407492757,
0.7376365662,
0.202414915,
-0.4554304481,
0.288670212,
-0.1269227564,
-0.1540692598,
0.4704331756,
0.1946071088,
-0.7355669141,
-0.0462400876,
0.2848909199,
-0.3068103492,
0.0051837014,
0.8813983798,
-0.4607971311,
-0.065564692,
0.1489271671,
0.458131969,
0.3049496412,
0.3025969565,
0.1711864322,
-0.9288284183,
0.2444991916,
0.3919594884,
0.5313795209,
0.4023352861,
-0.6875864267,
0.6512932181,
0.4604253173,
-0.2149003595,
-0.6692124009,
0.0552833416,
-0.7051472068,
-0.14193286,
0.8402773142,
-0.5321776867,
-0.3651757836,
-0.2647842169,
-0.0726734251,
0.3198112547,
-0.6299489141,
0.8820855021,
0.6250453591,
-0.2609835267,
-0.4261790812,
-0.3817845881,
0.5665638447,
0.4615927637,
-1.000146389,
-0.0499154329,
0.7385798097,
0.1201862544,
0.3286097348,
0.6267888546,
0.0152478162,
0.1762416363,
-0.084919259,
0.4705325961,
-0.2478157133,
-0.6081446409,
-0.2316308916,
0.169573009,
0.0865775719,
0.2574718893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08795v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08795v1
|
Ontologia para monitorar a deficiência mental em seus déficts no processamento da informação por declínio cognitivo e evitar agressões psicológicas e físicas em ambientes educacionais com ajuda da I.A*
| 2024-01-31T16:15:41 | 2024-01-31T16:15:41 |
Bruna Araújo de Castro Oliveira
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
The intention of this article is to propose the use of artificial
intelligence to detect through analysis by UFO ontology the emergence of verbal
and physical aggression related to psychosocial deficiencies and their
provoking agents, in an attempt to prevent catastrophic consequences within
school environments.
|
[
-0.5470452309,
-1.1149814129,
0.6788426042,
0.1283058822,
0.3372214735,
0.191967696,
0.2881362438,
-0.5687824488,
0.3543041348,
0.3444871604,
-0.9412863851,
-0.2778572142,
-0.6465520859,
0.1629925519,
-0.390036881,
0.6257380843,
0.2645172775,
0.1436936259,
-0.2192040086,
0.1756685674,
-0.3300434947,
-0.5528641939,
-1.1404907703,
0.0041447878,
0.2273531854,
0.3363814354,
0.5665265322,
0.1684312969,
0.8211635351,
0.6295261979,
0.119731918,
-0.0718084574,
-0.3581959307,
-0.0526259206,
-0.7427188754,
-0.4267138541,
-0.4464115798,
0.1033281609,
0.5946308374,
0.3645173013,
-0.0701199695,
0.2363945246,
-0.2831628919,
0.5224632621,
-0.2083805352,
0.2607012391,
-0.1155219898,
0.3066450953,
-0.0440852977,
-0.059110269,
0.0296526197,
-0.1610933244,
-0.0415115766,
-0.7593932152,
-0.1045798063,
0.0726095885,
0.8527678847,
0.6986984015,
-0.1739402562,
-0.4091537297,
-0.8249636292,
0.6981820464,
-0.4085683227,
0.4938891232,
0.7623185515,
0.1377724111,
-0.4040667117,
-0.6836619377,
-0.9019700885,
-0.2607572675,
0.1134781912,
0.1176754609,
-0.436313808,
-0.0431417413,
0.3437226117,
-0.3690226078,
-0.2435521036,
0.1680320352,
-0.5258074999,
-0.4551131129,
0.7950997353,
0.5599480867,
0.82158494,
0.0196645595,
-0.1369741261,
0.0799167827,
-0.2634167671,
0.3000762463,
0.6538716555,
0.1993108988,
-0.3478963077,
0.5351713896,
-0.0959011987,
0.5536261797,
0.1390529871,
-0.1377296597,
-0.1433302909,
-0.3458409607,
-0.1218449995,
0.0057414081,
0.906368494,
0.4436341524,
-0.0111868903,
0.0367807187,
-0.1545137316,
0.7459587455,
0.6901009083,
-0.5030514002,
0.1372532845,
0.3232255578,
-0.2254087031,
-0.726295948,
0.1828948706,
-1.0840339661,
-0.2921413779,
-0.2885304391,
0.2746915817,
-0.5313907862,
-0.2379268408,
-0.019641459,
-0.0154793784,
0.0117070125,
0.2469539791,
-0.5541248918,
0.4763686359,
0.4244278967,
0.5124971867,
0.3960652053,
-0.3671260774,
-0.1568438113,
-0.0104588438,
-0.3803514838,
0.9862495065,
-0.5984486938,
-0.2465839982,
-0.2015365511,
-0.0274057053,
0.1558474898,
-0.3276294172,
0.7402600646,
-0.2041213661,
0.272620976,
-0.0911623761,
-0.231792897,
-0.5578805804,
0.2395173311,
-0.3724366724,
1.2842617035,
0.4322021008,
-0.3076176345,
0.1835138649,
-0.8077315688,
-0.2325913608,
0.3940058053,
-0.4298072159,
-0.4200902581,
-0.2917176485,
-0.4523046911,
0.467792362,
-0.1715314239,
0.3668546975,
-0.1637866199,
-0.111812979,
0.3632275164,
-0.0137681002,
1.0064015388,
0.2159089893,
-0.6142969131,
0.3206908405,
-0.7960010767,
-0.0971814469,
0.4859423041,
-0.0575377308,
-0.6247396469,
0.5183449984,
-0.2535150647,
0.4692523777,
0.3911686838,
-0.771130681,
0.062719427,
-0.3173855245,
0.0724156499,
0.8019869328,
0.1493563652,
-0.025400158,
-0.464100033,
0.4260814488,
-0.0902789533,
0.503860414,
0.2497736514,
-0.3547733724,
-0.3616187572,
-0.0614880137,
-0.5833266973,
0.8159419298,
-0.587090075,
0.7030971646,
-0.0671705306,
-0.5030189753,
-0.1277291924,
0.2500119805,
0.7969629765,
0.5236406922,
0.2162421346,
-0.3165842593,
-0.9400035739,
-0.1906843632,
-0.059933614,
-0.3012503684,
0.0249310862,
0.4719427526,
0.8188000917,
-0.3218164444,
0.6536442041,
-0.2673295736,
-0.782413125,
0.0230659675,
-0.1246792451,
-0.3501673639,
0.3070864081,
0.9411791563,
-1.1558519602,
-0.5309048891,
0.0844272152,
-1.549438715,
-0.2170617282,
0.1702267677,
-0.1755101383,
0.0239949673,
0.9713485837,
-0.2936884761,
0.6700286865,
0.3269622624,
-1.1944941282,
0.4886727631,
-0.060478244,
0.2262821943,
-0.7187755108,
-0.1063145101,
0.4373157322,
-0.0448973998,
-0.9022922516,
0.1282399893,
-0.4616908729,
0.0251545329,
-0.7383054495,
0.3428351879,
-0.0076310392,
0.4113314152,
-0.2468397766,
0.3393282294,
-0.1915893108,
0.5166050196,
-0.1184614003,
0.4886525869,
0.6638016701,
-0.655343473,
0.794400394,
0.5553969741,
-0.0325408913,
0.8635483384,
-0.6282503009,
-0.050224591,
-0.2974615693,
-0.1903928816,
-0.73821944,
-0.2543089092,
0.7890731692,
-0.7242378592,
-0.0324291959,
0.6095065475,
-0.1383904964,
-0.5377975702,
-0.3469213843,
-0.1178241223,
0.2712156177,
-0.2513087392,
0.8929765224,
0.7270875573,
-0.0260267965,
-0.3560372591,
-0.5541065335,
0.2019952089,
-0.299972564,
-0.4034689665,
0.0993261561,
-0.0678920522,
-1.0594934225,
0.2600516081,
0.1059125662,
-0.1602673233,
0.3625384271,
0.6757612228,
0.5075966716,
-0.2929166853,
-0.1778159589,
0.0209878236,
0.2410440147,
0.805311799,
0.1068174392,
0.5682273507,
-0.1412847489,
-0.0029657099,
-1.0772156715,
0.406971246,
0.564060986,
0.0732543468,
0.9683132172,
-0.0639081225,
-0.4036611319,
0.0466247648,
-0.1282223463,
-0.1302907914,
-0.6024193168,
0.3026049435,
-0.3258672059,
-0.1985503137,
0.442943722,
-0.2306113392,
-0.4281827211,
0.5579530597,
0.4019776583,
-0.3077284098,
0.9242576361,
0.4923338592,
-0.1826797873,
0.777169466,
-0.6229360104,
-0.0485731289,
-0.4723268449,
-0.975521028,
-0.6192145944,
-0.1295072436,
-0.3904803693,
-0.1062904298,
0.141983673,
-0.5208249092,
-0.6172478199,
0.1826958209,
-0.7762035728,
0.3642677367,
0.3371697068,
0.1669007838,
-0.0444259159,
-0.169627279,
0.0255519245,
0.1410355717,
-0.5273268819,
-0.704936564,
0.9351093769,
0.0822031051,
0.462233752,
0.4616147876,
0.1295496076,
0.621733129,
0.3451340497,
-0.7834278345,
0.9564413428,
0.0369339585,
-0.7248103023,
-0.5930370688,
-0.0514752232,
-1.0717691183,
0.0829215497,
-0.4834925532,
-0.9517276287,
0.4945982993,
-0.1811266989,
-0.381949544,
0.1838475615,
-0.576667726,
0.7816990614,
-0.2747082412,
-0.6230630279,
-0.2733145654,
-0.5828314424,
0.0974023193,
-0.4163871706,
0.3743201196,
-0.4535962343,
-0.2279842943,
0.8949941397,
-0.492323488,
1.2211359739,
-0.2499809563,
-0.2102729082,
0.744064033,
-0.189110443,
0.1163468212,
-0.3517716229,
0.1042634696,
0.2679362893,
-0.0005611322,
-0.2995230854,
-0.4621985853,
0.6514188647,
-1.3641257286,
-0.5427646041,
-0.7396985888,
-0.3408566117,
0.0892893896,
0.5768649578,
0.2866184413,
0.2151495069,
-0.4892973602,
-0.2517706752,
0.397626996,
0.1734054238,
0.3412574232,
1.0993487835,
-0.2589458227,
-0.1381890178,
0.9447527528,
0.3070401847,
-0.0530045964,
0.0632788166,
0.3758199215,
-0.2140392959,
-0.279083699,
0.2215826958,
0.2463932484,
-0.4039567709,
-0.3368680477,
-0.5552951097,
-0.0824095607,
-0.8335443735,
-0.2075026631,
-0.3546981812,
0.1683652252,
-0.1963297427,
-0.0881012604,
0.3288993239,
1.0473093987,
-0.1166307405,
0.6539849043,
-0.3952817023,
0.5184260607,
0.1425539404,
0.2023047507,
-0.2479840815,
-0.395211041,
-0.2169250697,
0.1317379475,
-0.6677452326,
-0.8837643266,
0.5626327991,
0.217902109,
0.6134706736,
0.9957360029,
0.1517068595,
0.1822158843,
-0.1007510945,
0.5546803474,
-0.0056487531,
-0.8476440907,
1.0201292038,
-0.5184658766,
-0.0592961311,
0.339610517,
1.2824745178,
-0.1282566488,
-0.6360086799,
-0.9741101861,
-0.5333306789,
0.9947353601,
-0.0152501306,
-0.009175729,
-0.0732680857,
0.2869024873,
-0.3313019574,
-0.062688902,
-0.4512366951,
-0.4596033692,
-0.2682645917,
-0.067810826,
0.0474631675,
-0.0827937946,
-0.4470261037,
-0.5086607933,
0.6983811855,
0.1815142781,
0.1653971672,
0.3409618735,
0.2428716719,
-0.5032745004,
-0.2366914153,
0.5486200452,
0.4771807194,
0.1092310995,
0.286142379,
0.0805895701,
-0.9967158437,
0.3973230422,
-0.2331193686,
-0.2065438926,
-0.2587060034,
0.3369650841,
0.7181911469,
0.1580286473,
-1.0790842772,
0.6316629648,
-0.0794519708,
-0.4032417238,
-0.891769886,
0.251901716,
-0.6300945282,
0.4348584414,
0.4051802754,
0.1863668412,
0.2252387404,
-0.7213489413,
0.1986625642,
0.3486782014,
-0.3387492001,
-0.6595526934,
0.7842125297,
-0.0457865223,
-0.8549610972,
0.5494701266,
-0.5795763731,
-0.6916739345,
0.8457384706,
0.7171751261,
0.5401293039,
-0.9776171446,
0.4650985897,
0.3472312987,
0.4463064969,
0.0866886824,
0.7387196422,
0.2606230676,
-1.1736580133,
-0.1630310565,
-0.3220212162,
-0.4892587364,
0.2894305885,
-0.6754828691,
0.2724710703,
-1.0290845633,
-0.2813600302,
0.2700970769,
-0.1270781904,
-0.4104411602,
0.6465657949,
0.1405220926,
0.3685756624,
-1.3840868473,
0.54778862,
1.0040290356,
-0.4656838179,
-0.761131227,
-0.1406343877,
0.2762713134,
-0.6979455948,
0.8301873803,
-0.1873253435,
-0.5118718743,
0.1439809352,
-0.6123360991,
-1.1127669811,
0.5113370419,
0.0441465825,
-0.2114862055,
0.0995887965,
0.1852082908,
1.0187586546,
-0.137685284,
0.0568164699,
0.8347999454,
0.7960618734,
-0.1172614694,
-0.4056291878,
0.1907805502,
-0.4440355003,
-0.3300673366,
0.3155407012,
-0.9985454082,
0.420984745,
-0.2921255231,
-0.3912056088,
-0.3007970452,
0.7637010813,
-0.2818828523,
0.7996014953,
0.0781569034,
0.5174245834,
0.5364567637,
-0.0440244526,
0.9274169803,
-0.2905162275,
-0.1785861701,
0.7715459466,
-0.088793993,
0.6553021073,
0.4768643677,
-0.6312812567,
0.8473527431,
0.3772320449,
-0.3808153868,
0.408570677,
-0.1423605531,
-0.6657831669,
0.1735231131,
-0.7481834292,
0.260401696,
1.024212122,
0.8210541606,
0.0172873065,
0.2518746853,
0.5663847923,
0.02153253,
0.7784727216,
-0.8019121885,
0.8492545485,
-0.282851398,
-0.7616853714,
0.2949741781,
-0.2152594924,
0.5773591995,
-0.6004008055,
0.1193780154,
0.0101775583,
0.1316305101,
-0.4483862221,
-0.6819239855,
0.8450703621,
0.0192071293,
0.1292708367,
-0.1441392154,
0.836042285,
0.2262242585,
-0.6638125777,
0.7061154842,
0.3660719991,
0.3907564878,
0.2266866267,
-0.7820065022,
-0.0704511404,
-0.0978796706,
-0.3772675693,
0.4269381464,
0.3369752765,
-0.3697621822,
0.7748964429,
0.5537025332,
0.4359109998,
0.1297109872,
-0.4032529294,
0.9619266391,
-0.5646902919,
-0.4207986593,
-0.9533632398,
0.0930997133,
-0.0101363631,
-0.1559096873,
0.8583071232,
0.6043697596,
0.8850638866,
0.0491464213,
0.6878685951,
-0.464545697,
0.2733218968,
0.1787660122,
0.4222789705,
-0.425332725,
-0.1588420272,
-0.2893548608,
-0.5350453854,
-0.0775187612,
0.7432817817,
-0.5970184207,
-0.0781199038,
0.6763212085,
0.6244021654,
0.3335424364,
-0.1055247039,
0.4928034246,
0.3663464785,
-0.035923209,
0.1252501607,
0.7583368421,
-0.3262873292,
0.287271291,
-0.5217421055,
-0.3851715624,
-0.1210766286,
-0.4167988896,
-0.9472702146,
-0.5754464269,
-0.4534855187,
-0.3505106568,
0.0913007259,
0.6766489744,
-0.0473506264,
-0.7822887301,
-0.1817376316,
-0.2313019633,
0.1032255143,
-0.3258637488,
-0.3407890201,
0.16118595,
-0.0424626842,
-1.0770679712,
0.434234947,
0.1194291189,
0.4882347882,
-0.4901096821,
0.0532928668,
-0.5390227437,
0.4561668336,
0.447683841,
0.63944453,
-0.3889282048,
-0.2826125324,
-0.136868,
-0.2484661937,
-0.1519056112,
0.3015146554,
-0.7679949403,
0.0866596475,
0.4074599445,
0.1826718003,
-0.1881300956,
-0.1262164414,
0.091226913,
-0.6400491595,
0.5987169147,
0.3373120427,
0.0406832062,
-0.0934273228,
-0.9010682702,
0.7228412032,
0.4589823782,
-0.5467082858,
-0.8971785903,
-0.0056889178,
-0.6534383893,
-0.3542785048,
0.6834753156,
-0.223986119,
-0.4810058773,
-0.317252934,
-0.5092060566,
0.3917553127,
-0.2836463153,
1.091899991,
0.4043676555,
-0.4483869672,
0.2167354226,
-0.4131243527,
0.5195004344,
0.3091790378,
-0.8743064404,
-0.5670995712,
0.3076402545,
0.0464929678,
0.525816679,
0.5760269165,
0.2255693376,
0.3218563199,
0.5028204322,
0.3011039495,
-0.0082917958,
-0.4626788795,
0.0512264483,
0.146023035,
-0.4780201614,
-0.1406213343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17922v1
|
[Lions: 1] and [Tigers: 2] and [Bears: 3], Oh My! Literary Coreference Annotation with LLMs
| 2024-01-31T15:35:21 | 2024-01-31T15:35:21 |
Rebecca M. M. Hicke, David Mimno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Coreference annotation and resolution is a vital component of computational
literary studies. However, it has previously been difficult to build high
quality systems for fiction. Coreference requires complicated structured
outputs, and literary text involves subtle inferences and highly varied
language. New language-model-based seq2seq systems present the opportunity to
solve both these problems by learning to directly generate a copy of an input
sentence with markdown-like annotations. We create, evaluate, and release
several trained models for coreference, as well as a workflow for training new
models.
|
[
-0.1975560933,
-0.5696365237,
0.6806030273,
0.0536723621,
-0.3814960718,
-0.0302896723,
-0.21508874,
-0.6814783216,
0.3298674524,
1.0058193207,
-0.5076653957,
-0.3948323727,
-0.4210207164,
0.3066717684,
-0.2810091972,
0.9977066517,
0.1140365228,
0.1224984899,
-0.2145278454,
-0.1868546158,
-0.0731258392,
-0.9192945957,
-0.4090971649,
-0.6531412005,
0.4810983837,
0.3199359179,
0.8996080756,
0.5710374117,
0.7065637708,
0.1241459474,
-0.1730585396,
0.1856029481,
-0.2203404754,
0.5912026167,
-0.4309363067,
-0.4214306474,
-0.1771082729,
0.2214890569,
0.3305955231,
0.6555380821,
0.4471624792,
0.2357375622,
-0.1825713962,
0.6360905766,
-0.7495979667,
-0.0342934653,
-0.6493601799,
0.0849313959,
-0.2122669071,
-0.0695469603,
-0.637812674,
-0.6067636609,
-0.2253061235,
-0.5861549377,
0.1891477108,
0.1765346974,
0.8663414717,
0.2943882942,
-0.5774721503,
-0.5507175922,
-0.4534598589,
0.6589582562,
-0.6291320324,
-0.1195039973,
0.6208245754,
0.1502956748,
0.0848337859,
-0.6895815134,
-0.6455857754,
-0.291164875,
-0.1376331747,
0.0023750018,
0.1595375985,
0.0402486436,
0.2998153567,
0.451939106,
-0.2753027678,
0.1449598819,
-0.1861788034,
-0.1711273789,
0.8189088106,
0.0808547288,
0.3496989906,
-0.4631016254,
-0.0809339881,
0.382615,
-0.8353130221,
-0.0759246945,
0.1292778552,
0.3458834291,
0.2936392725,
0.7701948285,
0.0287693702,
0.477302134,
0.203639701,
-0.1494309008,
0.1784646362,
-0.1544100493,
-0.047784023,
-0.0334802046,
0.5409350991,
0.5454062223,
0.3080566525,
-0.182985276,
-0.3339697421,
0.1690382361,
-0.0050213202,
-0.5666189194,
-0.2443812788,
0.0273844898,
-0.4292901456,
-0.436037153,
-0.3050179482,
-0.020622937,
-0.8094791174,
-0.5731416941,
0.4580701292,
-0.4618443251,
-0.150161311,
-0.1064871028,
-0.2152021527,
0.2843717635,
0.4425885081,
-0.9446699619,
0.1362705678,
0.5063875318,
0.6775733232,
-0.1278714836,
-0.2577399313,
-0.400770843,
0.1888685673,
-0.4477344155,
0.9250050187,
-0.5260683298,
-0.4229477644,
-0.0838605911,
0.0363404863,
0.1762857586,
-0.56704247,
0.8524212241,
-0.3993270099,
-0.0849799067,
-0.3147166967,
-0.7512090802,
-0.2572018802,
0.2109289467,
-0.7503837347,
1.4333931208,
0.0303673092,
-0.6643435359,
-0.3049755692,
-0.3627613187,
-0.4562509954,
0.2261223644,
-0.2195845097,
0.015566254,
0.2609089017,
0.0524521023,
0.7785319686,
-0.5249618888,
0.1310072839,
-0.229979381,
-0.3876927793,
0.457482636,
0.4608811438,
0.7192397118,
0.3916587234,
-0.0775846913,
0.0513041131,
-0.5545348525,
-0.0729468986,
0.1865868121,
-0.0735657066,
-0.3765039444,
-0.1865430772,
0.2681010365,
0.0186976604,
0.397927314,
-0.468408525,
0.2603398263,
-0.0167837981,
0.7565662265,
0.2314956188,
0.1841694564,
0.4784186184,
-0.6059976816,
0.4426918924,
-0.2642262578,
-0.2396262884,
-0.481685698,
-0.2338726521,
-0.7153443098,
-0.3222216666,
0.2230083346,
0.6905463934,
-0.7350557446,
0.4555352628,
0.2132615,
-0.8229695559,
-0.0568109453,
-0.051585339,
0.2678900063,
0.2996433079,
0.1632671058,
0.0594221316,
-0.7089422345,
-0.9498584867,
-0.2067242861,
-0.3190648258,
0.0288885999,
0.2363160104,
0.6581526995,
-0.1072691604,
0.7520451546,
-0.4085593224,
-0.3380595148,
-0.4282881021,
0.2369976044,
0.2269845158,
0.5396406651,
0.6390978694,
-0.4794676006,
-0.1025775149,
-0.2967962921,
-0.7813929915,
-0.5172609091,
-0.1667808592,
-0.3304286003,
-0.0500010699,
0.749979198,
-0.2954247594,
-0.0291567948,
0.4524858296,
-0.4146571159,
1.0974209309,
0.2741756439,
0.2384114712,
-1.2034860849,
0.021602748,
-0.2310132235,
-0.3269095123,
-0.3588986397,
0.1067278236,
0.249365136,
-0.1189352348,
-0.2627522349,
0.4897494018,
-0.5384472609,
0.1297180355,
-0.3325274587,
0.3054161966,
0.235644266,
0.3387501836,
0.2174749374,
0.6423780322,
0.3045330942,
-0.6363384128,
0.3853010833,
0.5129677653,
-0.2018656284,
0.7147250772,
-0.4157511592,
0.2553711832,
-0.0724695325,
0.2261597961,
-0.8919659257,
-0.2931549251,
-0.1277505159,
-0.6465672255,
0.0565590337,
-0.0958828777,
-0.5348370671,
-0.011808821,
-0.2067392766,
0.412520647,
0.4241793752,
-0.5109642744,
0.609623611,
0.4962329268,
-0.3555646837,
-0.5580160022,
-1.0227745771,
0.2475055158,
0.1156875119,
-0.3936232626,
0.4370705783,
0.0392536633,
-0.3480234444,
0.12456882,
0.3312521875,
-0.2557497621,
0.144655928,
0.5873993635,
0.2760199904,
-0.1532980651,
0.444914639,
0.2528628409,
-0.0791281462,
-0.0951628014,
-0.0160813462,
0.1631622612,
-0.1898042709,
-0.3330956399,
-0.2393574864,
0.5629768372,
0.5196018815,
-0.3460604548,
0.2391893566,
0.2638002932,
-0.6862967014,
-0.1876014024,
-0.9063367844,
-0.1859571636,
-0.3699685633,
0.3352198303,
-0.5926633477,
-1.3859877586,
0.3533420861,
-0.1986148208,
0.0987957045,
0.6395157576,
0.7449098825,
-0.3063790798,
0.4128347337,
0.4558596313,
0.2674807608,
0.4372544289,
0.0495179296,
-0.0286074392,
-1.0027432442,
0.0260626897,
-0.7628974915,
-0.3013331592,
0.002576676,
-0.6439765692,
0.0604461282,
0.616022408,
-0.4649947286,
0.5178685784,
-0.4795849919,
0.777690053,
0.6226070523,
-0.0089356462,
0.5800449252,
-0.1187816337,
-0.447427392,
-0.4692202508,
-0.0589522794,
-0.9800287485,
0.7666068077,
0.1948110163,
0.7978073359,
0.2918814719,
0.7580168247,
0.6530708075,
0.3320557773,
-0.8104135394,
0.6184306741,
-0.204679355,
-0.8037185669,
-0.1902877837,
0.1178505644,
-0.5063995123,
0.1242909431,
-0.4251268506,
-0.851400733,
0.0165489912,
-0.0585160181,
-0.5879823565,
0.276861757,
-0.4195890129,
0.5230857134,
-0.1319438517,
-0.3116435409,
0.0317930579,
-0.5555604696,
0.4095542133,
0.0442526005,
0.0487212166,
-0.6870852113,
-0.1263339818,
0.7730256319,
-0.1288616955,
0.9936297536,
0.2840359211,
0.2584023476,
0.6011980176,
0.7257188559,
0.3810347319,
0.0325077213,
-0.3818497062,
-0.1533160657,
0.4385129511,
-0.205107376,
-0.506370306,
0.5045471191,
-0.7346880436,
-0.2848576307,
-0.5562325716,
-0.5131943822,
-0.1547669768,
0.1173323542,
0.2504200637,
0.3194376528,
-0.2442287952,
0.1667701602,
0.3865082562,
0.0103034526,
0.4909899533,
0.5730849504,
-0.4645568132,
-0.8582670093,
0.403665632,
0.0677085668,
0.0974511951,
0.3688782752,
-0.1931262761,
-0.4204569757,
-0.5836872458,
-0.3266859651,
0.6513385177,
-1.0655254126,
-0.3223479092,
-0.6454975605,
-0.4231329858,
-0.5135776401,
-0.5568605065,
-0.2198458016,
-0.8777359724,
-0.4600924551,
-0.3031145036,
0.3718031347,
0.9947015047,
-0.1522523314,
0.3351689279,
-0.9094411731,
-0.1020699739,
0.0710431114,
-0.0007946668,
-0.3905909061,
-0.6810051203,
-0.3847023845,
-0.5066066384,
-0.3625687659,
-1.2254830599,
0.2817699313,
0.3036174774,
0.3498004079,
0.1820379794,
0.403745234,
0.209609136,
-0.3143820763,
1.2198580503,
0.2631393671,
-1.1436862946,
0.581106782,
-0.3146755397,
0.2144686282,
0.7635606527,
0.3132545054,
-0.879373312,
-0.3252263367,
-0.4200431705,
-0.4852689207,
0.3382278085,
0.2057228386,
0.1195456535,
-0.2009188682,
0.7846362591,
0.1623580903,
0.1421608031,
-0.75669837,
-0.0817020163,
0.0863331929,
-0.3357359767,
-0.1636524647,
-0.801225543,
-0.0176693741,
-0.1209133789,
0.8505077362,
-0.4059974551,
0.0878278464,
0.3852159977,
-0.5279881358,
0.0205785558,
0.3210196197,
0.3239060342,
0.4283638,
-0.102076903,
0.5179494619,
0.1099050343,
-0.4609069824,
0.2032529265,
-0.1498651952,
-0.5032221079,
0.0926151127,
0.4829909801,
0.5148476362,
0.1717962176,
-0.8089630604,
0.3057155013,
0.1960011572,
-0.3432106376,
-0.6590334773,
-0.036697112,
0.3552986979,
0.5749370456,
0.4542994201,
-0.0341589637,
0.2566697001,
-0.1449313611,
0.2555919588,
0.2327449918,
-0.4901662767,
-0.2227514386,
0.5578477383,
0.4901710153,
-0.2333882749,
0.3881367743,
-0.321994096,
-0.7876736522,
0.4517602026,
0.6600306034,
0.9825743437,
0.1111382246,
0.2280255407,
0.7114616632,
0.483738035,
-0.0678344816,
0.4160667062,
-0.0545122623,
-0.9507646561,
-0.5075646043,
-0.700709641,
-0.908202529,
0.0225505475,
-0.6381528378,
0.3482429087,
-0.6121040583,
-0.3339600861,
0.0040909993,
0.0667665228,
-0.2370531708,
0.2100770921,
0.546150744,
0.7545362115,
-0.8819173574,
0.8279008865,
1.1494463682,
-0.6420227289,
-0.6024421453,
-0.483268261,
0.1484007537,
-0.5115470886,
0.6951757073,
0.2436729074,
-0.0513868444,
0.2618849874,
-0.6840890646,
-0.8440951705,
1.1920733452,
0.4351523221,
-0.3016240001,
-0.0325933918,
-0.0646682382,
0.3382602334,
-0.6753600836,
0.5619555116,
0.5876225829,
0.1773747653,
0.2634219229,
-0.882255137,
0.1618271023,
-0.4140634239,
0.1320883185,
0.0177399013,
-0.4680830538,
0.8768068552,
-0.3156664968,
-0.1605314761,
0.2867017686,
0.8596609235,
0.3600602448,
0.1132391691,
0.3645039201,
0.698805511,
0.943195343,
-0.2485503405,
0.6190148592,
-0.3063233495,
0.4407496452,
1.5974333286,
-0.4400986433,
1.0383605957,
0.4722846746,
-0.131832853,
0.3906523585,
1.0141483545,
0.0269046351,
0.0217469465,
0.1930026561,
-0.3959986269,
-0.6447578073,
-0.5271632075,
-0.3425680697,
0.0263017993,
0.4589710832,
-0.5748333335,
-0.0291533731,
0.0391648188,
0.1561714113,
0.5132398605,
-0.1271455586,
0.6931582689,
0.2384826094,
-0.6229317784,
0.2667881548,
0.1090148315,
0.6704462171,
-0.3512973785,
0.1548173726,
-0.2240392864,
0.0597817264,
-0.3296273351,
-0.7341581583,
0.4007590711,
-0.0133333793,
-0.5786640048,
0.0083909137,
0.809551239,
-0.3823079169,
-0.4843114018,
0.0914884359,
0.5042021275,
0.366749078,
-0.3942678869,
-0.5385713577,
0.074512057,
-0.0873989835,
-0.1895473599,
-0.1114336997,
0.4618101418,
0.0060285265,
0.5488513112,
0.3918478489,
0.0366802812,
0.0165153928,
0.0304257385,
0.5512635708,
-1.1234424114,
-0.4226180315,
-0.5937697887,
0.2750946581,
0.0021882944,
-0.4353607893,
0.6124401689,
0.4340144992,
0.404538691,
-0.1427272856,
1.0567758083,
-0.1401648521,
0.8022357225,
-0.4248239696,
0.4691911638,
-0.4179159999,
0.1079253778,
-0.0587233864,
-0.779830277,
-0.5963081121,
0.6133945584,
-0.3032080531,
-0.2904489934,
1.0135415792,
0.8737142682,
0.4422465265,
0.3439195454,
0.5021691322,
0.0872983932,
0.1075551435,
0.5659055114,
1.089081645,
-0.3566894531,
0.2243629396,
-0.3926358521,
-0.1682445258,
-0.487952143,
-0.9889797568,
-1.0161042213,
-0.8623104095,
-0.6631190181,
-0.743547678,
-0.0355170406,
1.3118370771,
0.4438964128,
-0.8391540051,
-0.2412029505,
0.4236908555,
-0.0185011216,
-0.1801139712,
-0.1704968065,
0.2797961831,
-0.5517522693,
-0.6149318218,
0.0392635055,
0.2767241001,
0.1706887782,
-0.2666577399,
-0.0513626263,
-0.3546498418,
0.278729856,
0.6381136179,
0.0324812569,
-0.894980371,
-0.2129302621,
-0.0793536156,
-0.6009191275,
-0.2259172797,
1.1163905859,
-0.5528978109,
0.3079388738,
0.5507993698,
0.793710351,
0.4934655726,
-0.0676890314,
0.3553557098,
-0.447509706,
0.1597946733,
0.6053107977,
0.5025014877,
0.5383512974,
-0.4331963658,
0.7766492963,
0.4739806056,
-0.7147307396,
-0.7317031622,
0.3977914453,
-1.0916850567,
-0.2568166852,
1.3008637428,
-0.2220217735,
-0.3263531923,
-0.0950205252,
-0.6817291975,
0.1711976528,
-0.1575385481,
0.1834693402,
0.9033111334,
-0.3073159158,
-0.4242074192,
-0.3254870474,
0.4459040463,
0.5196843743,
-0.4838114679,
-0.0978906751,
0.7794066072,
0.2083897889,
0.3082336485,
0.6210882068,
-0.1501967758,
0.1393244267,
0.0033647441,
0.699182272,
-0.1645821333,
-0.0026788325,
-0.2188452184,
0.3127060831,
0.469612211,
0.0410692245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17919v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17919v3
|
LOCOST: State-Space Models for Long Document Abstractive Summarization
| 2024-01-31T15:33:37 | 2024-03-25T12:52:42 |
Florian Le Bronnec, Song Duong, Mathieu Ravaut, Alexandre Allauzen, Nancy F. Chen, Vincent Guigue, Alberto Lumbreras, Laure Soulier, Patrick Gallinari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
State-space models are a low-complexity alternative to transformers for
encoding long sequences and capturing long-term dependencies. We propose
LOCOST: an encoder-decoder architecture based on state-space models for
conditional text generation with long context inputs. With a computational
complexity of $O(L \log L)$, this architecture can handle significantly longer
sequences than state-of-the-art models that are based on sparse attention
patterns. We evaluate our model on a series of long document abstractive
summarization tasks. The model reaches a performance level that is 93-96%
comparable to the top-performing sparse transformers of the same size while
saving up to 50% memory during training and up to 87% during inference.
Additionally, LOCOST effectively handles input texts exceeding 600K tokens at
inference time, setting new state-of-the-art results on full-book summarization
and opening new perspectives for long input processing.
|
[
-0.1063912511,
-0.4026343226,
0.7631719708,
0.3107147217,
-0.494086355,
-0.4380573034,
-0.1889333874,
-0.294475317,
0.4223653972,
0.2984809875,
-0.4740618169,
-0.4252153039,
-0.6114947796,
0.2803220451,
-0.8728309274,
1.2452514172,
0.0215538405,
-0.3483901322,
-0.4664112628,
0.0388424285,
-0.419805795,
-0.5105160475,
-0.5129981637,
-0.0074704904,
0.5014164448,
-0.2024007142,
0.4664051533,
0.5754223466,
0.3645933568,
0.3359320164,
-0.2656221986,
0.1515969634,
-0.4887771904,
0.3375114799,
-0.2092810422,
-0.2903858423,
-0.9378439784,
-0.4803209603,
0.6773744822,
0.4775387645,
-0.0475258417,
-0.0501015149,
0.1486927271,
0.7320318222,
-0.8114430904,
0.3189398944,
-0.0481225699,
-0.0943537503,
0.291040957,
0.0260470882,
-0.5701006651,
-0.262281388,
-0.101345025,
-0.6005025506,
0.2390268743,
-0.166178897,
0.7541879416,
0.5455117822,
-0.7383068204,
-0.3447619081,
-0.875715971,
0.4196693003,
-0.676817894,
0.6061744094,
0.4075903893,
0.1557986885,
-0.1745317429,
-1.0719330311,
-0.4721515477,
-0.0316806734,
-0.3892457485,
0.5214773417,
-0.1276723891,
0.2514787912,
0.2145510465,
0.3503526449,
-0.6940885782,
-0.3272288144,
-0.5750351548,
-0.080357857,
0.491165638,
0.5168340206,
-0.0653000027,
-0.443742156,
-0.393971771,
0.1083523557,
-0.515352726,
0.0651282966,
0.2191450596,
0.0037705472,
-0.2305022478,
0.6118637919,
-0.3256780803,
0.7869608998,
0.2800982296,
0.0681439936,
-0.2709645331,
-0.4633614719,
-0.3172849119,
0.0386636108,
0.8899306655,
0.269680202,
-0.320822835,
-0.223286435,
-0.5486769676,
0.1412753612,
0.3066062629,
-1.1778622866,
-0.0733307078,
0.3708918393,
-0.3823286891,
0.0106746219,
-0.0134767573,
-0.8718519211,
-0.5060483217,
-0.2200289071,
0.3639463186,
-0.6566103101,
0.1785272211,
0.5403875709,
-0.3327866197,
0.2357993573,
0.4142809212,
-0.9092934728,
0.538932085,
0.8827270269,
1.1300911903,
-0.4415646195,
0.002975825,
-0.4969281852,
0.1475081742,
-0.2200272679,
0.7026037574,
-0.217416957,
-0.5756357908,
0.0003966882,
0.1061559916,
0.0508957282,
0.0095846774,
0.5683090091,
-0.7310807109,
0.1286085993,
-0.0317325406,
-0.6752682924,
0.0264226776,
0.3698588014,
-0.93309021,
0.9837142825,
0.1715613455,
-0.7075891495,
0.3222312331,
-0.6933426857,
-0.8707708716,
-0.1713040322,
0.0180040672,
-0.4530694783,
-0.0526885167,
0.1918209791,
0.4714172482,
-0.0890530273,
0.3967786133,
0.0456367955,
-0.3595298529,
-0.0302550606,
-0.331027478,
0.3247952461,
0.2558809221,
-0.1171872094,
0.2192219496,
-1.0118113756,
-0.5113828778,
-0.19398956,
-0.7207432389,
-0.5935658216,
0.3564969003,
-0.0716129839,
0.1807419509,
0.6233668923,
-0.5835183263,
0.3100171685,
-0.6398466825,
0.6518814564,
0.4963035285,
0.0287525225,
0.8398787975,
-0.1071379185,
0.6334463954,
0.1529856771,
-0.0037285408,
-0.8254567385,
-0.0848597214,
-0.9524921179,
-0.4969414473,
0.2697699368,
0.3699080348,
-0.7925505042,
0.6943078637,
-0.8357408643,
-0.1535024047,
-0.0557267852,
-0.3729274273,
0.2108738422,
0.4568580985,
0.3063457012,
-0.0821190998,
-0.694462359,
-0.9500414133,
0.0000179007,
0.0876397267,
-0.1573472917,
-0.2279682755,
0.8963848948,
-0.1949454844,
1.1595739126,
-0.4910890162,
0.0094704926,
-0.3839426935,
0.0008015258,
0.4895117581,
0.309923619,
0.2854335904,
-0.7471679449,
-0.2780331671,
-0.0266532395,
-0.6501498222,
0.4049547613,
-0.1611856669,
-0.1257081479,
0.3015304208,
0.7217502594,
-1.1312096119,
0.7596668601,
0.6404597759,
-0.6164507866,
0.1503201574,
-0.432581991,
0.0895482749,
-1.489939332,
0.1824460328,
-0.2646067441,
-0.5668029785,
-0.4779483676,
0.0276407395,
0.4399838746,
-0.5461627245,
-0.3559565842,
0.6925207376,
-0.6601422429,
-0.098016046,
-0.2808433175,
-0.0401617065,
0.1945676953,
0.714012146,
0.2976552844,
0.7084837556,
0.0875683352,
-0.8717312813,
0.1266831309,
0.1724449545,
-0.4214363396,
0.1878596097,
-0.771039784,
0.1111859158,
-0.4257903993,
0.7571117878,
-1.0127285719,
-0.3709774911,
0.034843497,
-0.2950938642,
0.2616417408,
-0.2400408387,
-0.3999664187,
-0.3452865183,
-0.2472751588,
0.5615624785,
0.6845559478,
-0.4235642254,
1.0290198326,
0.0941491649,
-0.2122416496,
-0.6041839719,
-0.5317787528,
-0.0175580904,
0.0011058098,
-0.5975599885,
0.2272763997,
0.2803659439,
0.1778147072,
0.1016360521,
-0.1414238662,
0.0110100359,
-0.283421576,
0.5629125834,
0.209114179,
-0.2943938971,
0.1206556559,
0.3672219515,
-0.136855185,
0.0440493822,
-0.596470654,
0.5591729879,
-0.1742866188,
-0.1487540901,
-0.0388024226,
0.5492460132,
0.775877893,
-0.3650350273,
0.5511661768,
0.0741928667,
-0.4007206857,
-0.3353987932,
0.0789008215,
0.0365186892,
-0.5150560141,
0.7994033098,
-0.2645797729,
-0.7990707159,
0.5406859517,
0.1031997874,
0.3428872526,
0.5902125835,
0.661362946,
-0.0886844993,
0.7640225291,
0.7877237797,
-0.1598166674,
0.3525565863,
-0.3353790939,
0.3665020168,
-0.6040031314,
-0.1976387054,
-0.2209231406,
-0.302084595,
-0.2662089169,
-0.7029341459,
0.4495227635,
-0.2709206045,
-0.132264331,
0.4030531645,
-0.4475924671,
0.5387662649,
0.1789894849,
0.0478829481,
0.1474352032,
-0.3506315947,
0.2363172621,
0.3095134199,
-0.8157179356,
-0.2301176488,
0.8623408675,
0.2348757088,
1.1343259811,
0.0991931185,
0.7653154135,
0.3524546325,
0.1567407101,
-1.233063817,
0.6944988966,
-0.2004716098,
-0.5352581739,
-0.6584638357,
0.0337331034,
-1.2148141861,
0.2339331657,
-0.0802543983,
-0.3188021779,
0.43751809,
0.2988054454,
-0.5906519294,
0.2001136392,
-0.3033013344,
0.5934663415,
-0.0087310681,
-0.319749862,
-0.0714994669,
-0.6375347376,
0.5557226539,
0.0388877839,
0.0574227348,
0.4486490488,
-0.3154888451,
0.6902532578,
-0.6302719712,
0.866684258,
0.170546174,
-0.2575939298,
0.4014134705,
0.210752815,
0.8022507429,
0.0479371734,
-0.0958224982,
-0.1313724518,
-0.0598481558,
-0.1137072891,
-0.7861570716,
0.4853488803,
-0.4871425033,
-0.32587412,
-0.5417954326,
-0.5866066813,
0.0215795897,
0.313733995,
0.5566369295,
0.658005774,
-0.3871252835,
0.2433791906,
0.846381247,
-0.0870540738,
0.571454823,
0.2586987913,
-0.1489804983,
-0.4513083398,
0.7214491963,
-0.2125132382,
-0.033991456,
0.7593877316,
-0.1493952572,
-0.4167611301,
-0.1549557149,
-0.4226971567,
0.1612751186,
-0.9058293104,
-0.2534449399,
-0.8677285314,
-0.3862830997,
-0.4454669356,
-0.2653315365,
-0.603133142,
-0.5831500292,
-0.3137647808,
-0.1428568959,
0.1888655126,
0.8299773932,
0.1526714861,
0.3171227872,
-0.8540705442,
0.6148001552,
0.2941261828,
0.290025413,
-0.0496349297,
-0.6369556189,
-0.7317436337,
-0.3025230169,
-0.1219788864,
-0.8417067528,
0.5899302959,
0.0359026082,
0.0202463157,
0.3156390488,
0.036796771,
0.6011258364,
-0.8562112451,
0.8779944181,
0.3103720546,
-0.8059387207,
0.3360668421,
-0.5739403963,
0.6126220822,
0.3690232635,
0.3190634549,
-0.5421520472,
-0.440362066,
-0.3185053468,
-1.0403008461,
0.6192589402,
0.0949681625,
0.1143960208,
-0.1929930598,
0.3265649676,
0.1413371712,
-0.0259876437,
-0.6494633555,
0.0787822455,
-0.4498207867,
-0.3289020061,
-0.2718954384,
-0.4445664883,
0.0862811431,
-0.1936219782,
0.411120683,
0.112457864,
0.5239058733,
0.36977911,
-0.2292452902,
0.208153218,
0.5179023147,
0.9305183291,
0.5156750083,
-0.1359066814,
0.182934612,
0.1386493295,
-0.5444954038,
0.2606225014,
0.000085632,
-0.2932141721,
0.2976409793,
0.3774116039,
0.9349110126,
0.4658508897,
-0.4405145049,
0.7859212756,
-0.1714675725,
-0.4436356723,
-0.522891283,
-0.0256758984,
0.237263158,
-0.0227356963,
0.0913497806,
-0.0579225048,
0.5198938847,
-0.2438025326,
0.1958722025,
0.0466071181,
-0.334515065,
-0.5812554955,
1.0216065645,
0.483227402,
-0.1359245479,
0.5397635102,
-0.120625332,
-0.3713461161,
0.8186705112,
0.6103757024,
1.0170084238,
0.0415729731,
-0.1840353459,
0.6177931428,
0.2363814563,
-0.257671237,
0.1115246192,
-0.3062886894,
-0.2457951456,
-0.7490339279,
-0.8827231526,
-0.157913968,
0.22558254,
-0.7784808874,
0.4652283192,
-0.3059515953,
-0.213998884,
-0.3708848953,
-0.6645448208,
-0.4232388139,
0.1849088818,
0.1655305028,
1.027993679,
-0.7538332939,
0.836515069,
0.6313364506,
-0.0653061494,
-0.4439453781,
-0.2621411383,
-0.4052136242,
-0.2225577235,
0.8157073855,
-0.0552357435,
-0.3978909552,
-0.1954162717,
-0.3535907865,
-0.9409292936,
1.0491759777,
0.1745495349,
-0.8067321777,
-0.4523335099,
-0.0541942604,
0.6205255389,
-0.0505177006,
-0.0769715384,
0.4938001633,
0.2437876016,
-0.083064869,
-0.6164146662,
-0.0028340749,
-0.3649078608,
-0.0617560893,
0.7259720564,
-0.6743370295,
1.1050028801,
-0.1619364917,
-0.3685334921,
0.3855592608,
1.1737983227,
0.0930620804,
0.3372678161,
0.400621891,
0.4886405468,
0.3454580903,
0.1651354134,
1.3024749756,
-0.4669000506,
0.3509719074,
1.175973773,
-0.0294377003,
0.8019172549,
0.3414177001,
-0.0364983939,
0.5831413269,
0.4445851743,
0.2285579145,
0.6857084632,
-0.0118189007,
-0.2303623408,
-0.2897551656,
0.6370060444,
-0.1613649577,
0.3096795082,
0.4486935437,
-0.4017067552,
-0.3188317418,
0.0133272652,
-0.0035356169,
-0.0989216045,
-0.4627140164,
0.7031046748,
0.1778386086,
-0.9569402337,
0.42832461,
0.3055435419,
0.7481958866,
-0.7288333178,
-0.1862707585,
-0.4672765136,
0.1789805144,
-0.1548704952,
-0.6134212017,
0.1091645584,
0.1794568747,
-0.5326812267,
-0.2258967757,
0.7570305467,
-0.5214344859,
-0.5366795659,
-0.0051564737,
-0.0023221106,
0.1239725053,
0.2131608278,
-0.0027276615,
-0.3670811951,
-0.2806922793,
-0.4994334579,
0.293808341,
0.4975468516,
-0.3367914557,
0.609224081,
0.3717488348,
0.0173015725,
0.285443157,
-0.1618180275,
0.8960226774,
-0.8667610288,
-1.1864045858,
-0.9105613828,
0.6687332988,
0.0926862508,
-0.2039716393,
0.5664168,
0.9900039434,
0.2841899693,
-0.3982099891,
0.8908663988,
-0.2359164655,
0.1825238168,
-0.6811511517,
0.7543724179,
-0.5574869514,
-0.0366246626,
0.1278969198,
-0.6461344361,
0.0123717571,
0.2989688814,
-0.3091047704,
-0.0381735861,
0.8533867002,
0.5485101342,
-0.282525301,
-0.1562216282,
0.4097414315,
0.0552056283,
0.3508746326,
0.869063437,
1.0582900047,
-0.5251008272,
0.6284809113,
0.0067278165,
0.0987806618,
-0.2598440945,
-0.8889052868,
-0.9865862727,
-0.7413249612,
0.1664759517,
-0.3373614252,
0.1166521534,
0.531612277,
0.5756244659,
-0.5522540808,
-0.118182376,
-0.0066644386,
-0.0203963649,
0.2046388835,
-0.1768669784,
0.6753525734,
-0.2218440324,
-0.8803275824,
0.4230827689,
0.4706616104,
-0.0685461164,
-0.0736548528,
-0.2579368353,
0.2689986229,
0.2517960072,
1.1175818443,
0.4607287347,
-0.4883515239,
-0.15859586,
0.0538561307,
-0.420496583,
-0.0120407091,
1.0515555143,
-0.8555167913,
0.2962619662,
0.6796776056,
0.5654213428,
0.8581008315,
0.2447233647,
0.6206336617,
-0.6451376081,
0.5772914886,
0.3999684751,
0.5168542266,
-0.121200256,
-0.499738723,
0.3437654674,
-0.2129141986,
-0.5495788455,
-0.5909082294,
0.0418731607,
-1.2282691002,
-0.3321809173,
1.3281029463,
0.0253181439,
-0.5884401798,
0.115232192,
-0.0631514937,
0.3388137221,
-0.4830870926,
0.6124985218,
0.5604984164,
-0.1824959219,
0.0251233596,
-0.3239080608,
0.5395430923,
0.1086740494,
-0.872498095,
0.1343835145,
0.8237179518,
0.2315114737,
0.1186466962,
0.8491396904,
-0.1399661601,
0.6670249104,
0.1939345151,
0.2332692146,
-0.274253875,
-0.4610919356,
-0.5166659951,
0.1444663107,
-0.3347838521,
-0.2026646137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17911v1
|
SNNLP: Energy-Efficient Natural Language Processing Using Spiking Neural Networks
| 2024-01-31T15:16:25 | 2024-01-31T15:16:25 |
R. Alexander Knipper, Kaniz Mishty, Mehdi Sadi, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As spiking neural networks receive more attention, we look toward
applications of this computing paradigm in fields other than computer vision
and signal processing. One major field, underexplored in the neuromorphic
setting, is Natural Language Processing (NLP), where most state-of-the-art
solutions still heavily rely on resource-consuming and power-hungry traditional
deep learning architectures. Therefore, it is compelling to design NLP models
for neuromorphic architectures due to their low energy requirements, with the
additional benefit of a more human-brain-like operating model for processing
information. However, one of the biggest issues with bringing NLP to the
neuromorphic setting is in properly encoding text into a spike train so that it
can be seamlessly handled by both current and future SNN architectures. In this
paper, we compare various methods of encoding text as spikes and assess each
method's performance in an associated SNN on a downstream NLP task, namely,
sentiment analysis. Furthermore, we go on to propose a new method of encoding
text as spikes that outperforms a widely-used rate-coding technique, Poisson
rate-coding, by around 13\% on our benchmark NLP tasks. Subsequently, we
demonstrate the energy efficiency of SNNs implemented in hardware for the
sentiment analysis task compared to traditional deep neural networks, observing
an energy efficiency increase of more than 32x during inference and 60x during
training while incurring the expected energy-performance tradeoff.
|
[
-0.0854860395,
-0.5715383887,
0.2557472587,
0.5141797066,
-0.2617063522,
0.0513699464,
-0.4646412134,
-0.3414236903,
0.6597412229,
0.0741618052,
-0.2530401349,
-0.2039746642,
-0.6430643201,
0.0770240724,
-0.3102229238,
1.0936051607,
0.3418901861,
0.1025618538,
-0.2443982959,
0.1560464501,
0.1812990308,
-0.583963275,
-0.9388112426,
-0.4938197136,
0.6047625542,
-0.1694329232,
0.5534955263,
0.614117384,
0.5785154104,
0.1423900127,
-0.4468743503,
0.092980139,
-0.2281255126,
0.2280735523,
0.0804338679,
-0.0788497478,
-0.411270231,
-0.3095877171,
0.5033516288,
0.4830757678,
-0.4078840315,
0.0503933765,
-0.0690978765,
0.7232672572,
-0.7178843021,
-0.0893516168,
-0.7963412404,
0.6346012354,
-0.2002155483,
-0.459915638,
-0.4742227495,
-0.3020702004,
0.0466538556,
-0.1990383863,
0.2660978436,
-0.0416280963,
0.732136488,
0.2878986895,
-0.021343559,
-0.3232996762,
-0.3139696419,
0.5245275497,
-0.9687858224,
0.2423646152,
0.2499654293,
-0.0950273573,
-0.0803781375,
-0.6812643409,
-0.5759398937,
-0.1500439495,
0.1840963364,
0.2895982563,
-0.3892451823,
0.1889242977,
0.3167574406,
0.6458512545,
-0.4260713458,
0.1662563086,
0.0329656377,
-0.0182201881,
0.6681861281,
0.0319429673,
0.1307183504,
-0.5344426632,
-0.4754188061,
0.2189262807,
-0.2679208219,
-0.0174931232,
0.5340386629,
0.5684629083,
0.2568451762,
0.4508350492,
-0.0642571673,
0.559810698,
0.085039705,
0.2488034666,
0.3834751546,
-0.1012598574,
-0.3403953016,
0.4460376203,
0.9580705762,
0.6814213991,
0.0562366508,
-0.4159169495,
-0.1443573534,
0.1030012593,
0.6092723608,
-1.001485467,
-0.276704073,
0.1974524707,
-0.6090806723,
-0.4162607193,
-0.7213103175,
-0.9417591095,
-0.7140830755,
0.0761166811,
0.3652206659,
-0.6413840055,
-0.6785476208,
0.6805978417,
-0.3760406375,
-0.2732312679,
0.0315995291,
-1.3642843962,
0.4201011956,
0.683578074,
1.2499834299,
-0.2524301708,
-0.2196075767,
-0.300576359,
-0.4183699191,
-0.1009206101,
0.6668693423,
-0.3342003524,
-0.046283029,
0.1138483807,
-0.5916211009,
-0.1346684694,
-0.2206634432,
0.4928018451,
-0.3213647306,
-0.271092087,
0.0110377939,
-0.6384364367,
0.019794926,
0.2069347501,
-0.669318974,
1.3398896456,
-0.3847290277,
-1.0062096119,
0.2533775866,
-0.6884508729,
-0.7656465173,
0.0263394006,
-0.0906604379,
-0.3089647889,
0.5867099166,
0.0087542664,
0.7736745477,
-0.343714565,
0.2564187944,
0.2785155773,
-0.1953221411,
0.1211971864,
-0.6993410587,
0.7312191725,
0.1872102022,
-0.6670821905,
0.0127035016,
-0.7998554111,
-0.2458178997,
0.2043406069,
-0.4874580204,
-0.1263537854,
0.2803359032,
-0.0147586465,
0.0540882722,
0.283144474,
-0.8368947506,
0.1273657829,
-0.6169673204,
0.5227057934,
0.6920182109,
-0.1682913303,
0.6122217774,
0.029930722,
0.1664766967,
-0.0279675797,
-0.0480212979,
0.0209918618,
-0.6207944751,
-0.9435747862,
0.1820833087,
0.000478719,
0.2979816496,
-0.9130904078,
0.5545803905,
-0.2458153963,
-0.7573641539,
-0.5604531765,
-0.1700439304,
0.0979649723,
0.6338865161,
0.5338183045,
-0.2593316734,
-0.3727920055,
-0.7369562387,
-0.7163578868,
0.2463233024,
0.0276973639,
0.2151843756,
0.1946615726,
0.1714686453,
0.6726417542,
-0.1981651783,
0.2911652327,
-0.538639307,
0.2871052325,
0.4831485748,
0.5539629459,
0.40257442,
-0.5666234493,
-0.3083185852,
0.0326013379,
-0.5865799785,
0.1516654491,
-0.2927652597,
0.0204557087,
0.1443427652,
0.2616627514,
-0.8687901497,
0.7425598502,
0.3460814357,
-0.0894167498,
0.6659761071,
-0.2391303927,
0.0121612214,
-0.7763825059,
-0.13291201,
0.2700951695,
0.132333979,
-1.1447575092,
-0.1922033727,
0.1015008613,
-0.2052165866,
-0.4306952357,
0.0221331902,
-0.3740605414,
0.0201591179,
-0.354504317,
-0.0556548089,
-0.0083304616,
0.6012668014,
0.2776140869,
0.6086790562,
0.8351978064,
-0.696202457,
0.3394888639,
-0.2617133558,
-0.301422596,
0.2888756096,
-0.3938691318,
0.3346913755,
-0.2915682495,
0.0608570278,
-0.4428915679,
0.1701411605,
0.1293525398,
-0.5351617336,
0.276398927,
0.0844554156,
-0.7564938068,
-0.0575730354,
-0.2612735331,
0.2509921193,
0.3482678235,
-0.684758842,
0.8134168386,
0.3251272142,
0.2763024569,
-0.5597328544,
-1.0263308287,
0.2944490016,
-0.1604518592,
-0.4761117399,
0.4482167959,
0.015483086,
0.3076472282,
-0.0773591697,
-0.3904262483,
0.1356756091,
0.0725359321,
0.1020258069,
-0.0205515902,
-0.2947346866,
0.4797887802,
-0.1396029145,
-0.1959549338,
0.2689344883,
-0.2587287128,
0.9279332161,
-0.1715951264,
-0.0596752986,
-0.7034388781,
0.3980523944,
0.3105754256,
-0.1482955515,
0.8931820989,
0.5373996496,
-0.7234089375,
-0.3448048532,
-0.3297177553,
-0.1596324742,
-0.4482094944,
0.3911157846,
-0.2340784073,
-0.7326134443,
-0.0675299764,
-0.2016715705,
0.1602683663,
0.3026055396,
0.4853624105,
-0.1795417964,
1.0162439346,
0.4655927122,
-0.1087079719,
0.6998624802,
-0.0704967156,
0.7393739223,
-0.8815923929,
-0.0014552728,
-0.4492693245,
-0.5517340899,
-0.3410055935,
-0.458240211,
-0.0475501642,
-0.1521272808,
-0.1932486296,
0.4638110697,
-1.0071464777,
0.3181384802,
0.4109352529,
-0.0257707033,
-0.1738150865,
0.4368724823,
0.0732063949,
-0.3504635096,
-1.1939697266,
-0.1592609137,
0.8361324668,
0.4106805325,
0.4359348714,
-0.3449756801,
0.6281174421,
0.0902808607,
0.114381969,
-1.0547631979,
0.6621875763,
-0.5676175952,
-0.3886352479,
0.2210737914,
-0.6625394821,
-0.6417561173,
0.0662170053,
-0.5262982249,
-1.0031677485,
-0.0161219612,
0.0938735381,
-0.4792306125,
1.0175915956,
-0.5775313973,
0.763428092,
-0.3927127421,
-0.4097129405,
-0.2583574057,
-0.3864308,
-0.0967252105,
0.5929016471,
-0.2346560806,
-0.1358514726,
0.2887425423,
0.9509109855,
-0.2560194135,
0.6611407995,
-0.3448105752,
0.1262895763,
0.0184990596,
-0.0890303925,
0.3792296648,
-0.00454209,
-0.6718077064,
0.4902681708,
-0.4851560295,
-0.2420390844,
-0.8019859195,
0.6208977699,
-0.5140967369,
-0.3021264672,
-0.8112848997,
-0.474404335,
-0.0000718764,
0.1381402612,
0.5097483397,
0.5520259142,
0.1305728555,
0.1572183669,
0.6594944596,
-0.1666464657,
0.6317576766,
-0.2138556242,
-0.1932312101,
-0.2412819415,
1.1570621729,
0.2417845428,
0.1922980845,
0.2509416938,
0.2988246083,
-0.0861906111,
-0.8407253623,
-0.5347964168,
-0.0481554829,
-0.4902502,
-0.3885904253,
-0.7649775743,
-0.5794317126,
-0.3527736664,
-0.27344805,
-0.6901272535,
-0.267262727,
-0.446049273,
-0.2138174325,
0.6920273304,
0.4443383515,
-0.1310658455,
0.5704807043,
-0.4183000922,
0.4529101551,
0.1042329744,
0.3998117447,
0.2358304113,
-0.1803409457,
-0.2983123958,
-0.1392452419,
0.1653992981,
-0.8977475166,
0.4505876303,
0.2810868323,
0.240571484,
0.2672726512,
-0.1650825441,
0.706976831,
-0.7019534707,
0.9299173951,
0.773086071,
-0.9626705647,
0.5299443007,
0.1569975764,
0.3006860614,
0.6481109858,
0.4975381792,
-0.7890015841,
0.134968698,
-0.6485773921,
-1.1036314964,
0.5795375109,
0.3283674717,
0.354129374,
-0.3269270957,
0.5329697728,
0.0783236474,
0.5229076743,
-0.641690135,
-0.478867054,
-0.563818872,
-0.1894881874,
0.0349544846,
-0.2440504283,
0.1723506451,
-0.3334088326,
0.6137043238,
-0.0241681915,
0.5030127764,
0.2555002868,
-0.0417862646,
0.3403334022,
0.0459354855,
0.2447061986,
-0.0427757837,
-0.3948241472,
0.5934602022,
0.2583504021,
-0.7934023738,
-0.0620527901,
-0.1201460361,
-0.1989204288,
0.3244348764,
-0.0907419547,
1.2020534277,
0.1388094127,
-0.2767302096,
0.3751156628,
-0.42852211,
-0.026490584,
0.0079838997,
0.0780680552,
0.2894186974,
0.0244039372,
0.2566284835,
0.7462348938,
0.2009516209,
-0.3408283591,
-0.0704448745,
0.0822277516,
-0.5149739385,
-0.2762593925,
0.263330549,
0.1920345426,
-0.9259688854,
0.6195777059,
-0.5891344547,
-0.554187417,
0.3998421133,
0.8343925476,
1.0502347946,
0.1661797762,
0.1078123376,
0.5105233788,
0.3622098565,
0.0310455523,
0.3151152134,
-0.3867480159,
-0.8500309587,
-0.4824972153,
-1.0089712143,
-0.0983441919,
-0.0185793731,
-0.6975544095,
-0.2232416719,
-0.9970541,
-0.4951077104,
0.0838951096,
-0.2071112692,
-0.4518820345,
0.3967500329,
0.3630076349,
1.2677358389,
-0.6848462224,
0.5793124437,
0.5947138667,
-0.0823660642,
-0.4424062073,
-0.0244666766,
-0.2300626934,
-0.3973144293,
0.4675627649,
0.4302261174,
-0.5154070258,
0.0675303936,
-0.433827281,
-0.6018283963,
0.7065694332,
0.2907531559,
-0.4955703616,
0.0891653746,
0.0892457515,
0.5999658704,
-0.3438784778,
0.2451599091,
0.8833292127,
0.1145836487,
-0.240997225,
-0.4123665392,
-0.059875913,
-0.8601303697,
0.0104967942,
0.1193153188,
-0.499987781,
0.6982730627,
0.4939017296,
-0.3776114285,
-0.2436095476,
0.8831208944,
0.2685313821,
0.3780270815,
0.5100190639,
0.8212957978,
0.8339784145,
-0.1513332874,
0.9315034747,
-0.3456953168,
0.1907684207,
0.7514642477,
-0.1973396689,
1.057285428,
0.822088778,
-0.1160295829,
0.3749903142,
0.4202389121,
0.2342033386,
0.3890158236,
0.470038265,
-0.6062735319,
-0.2155663222,
-0.2702167928,
-0.2765002549,
0.2112892866,
0.4469259381,
-0.1135917306,
-0.0262533501,
-0.0055762515,
0.2368614525,
0.0897171795,
-0.5581973195,
0.5488913655,
0.1106171012,
-0.2849777937,
0.2062957734,
-0.1808638275,
1.4173108339,
-0.64556849,
0.2868824899,
-0.0861987546,
-0.0945237353,
-0.5297177434,
-0.6517720819,
0.423931241,
0.4055293202,
-0.3406777382,
-0.6024346948,
0.9590245485,
0.1077400967,
-0.5527825356,
0.2913659513,
-0.1115968153,
0.4191042483,
-0.0867125317,
-0.7066088915,
0.0269533042,
-0.1258363575,
-0.3100281656,
0.2327433228,
0.2924786806,
0.6432442069,
0.4465352893,
0.8204078674,
0.8138718009,
0.4416807294,
0.3054723442,
0.7708096504,
-0.8166643977,
-0.6579399109,
-0.8492277861,
0.5962253213,
-0.5430691838,
-0.7143012285,
0.8946716785,
0.5524510145,
0.331340611,
0.1685787886,
0.6748632789,
-0.2394568175,
0.1604962498,
-0.53212744,
1.0634577274,
-0.5183048844,
-0.1058875397,
-0.0570424013,
-0.6116495132,
-0.5756466985,
0.9517534375,
-0.3466340303,
-0.1769908965,
0.7694912553,
0.6141197085,
0.0373554304,
0.4334347248,
0.0023133084,
0.1293545961,
0.1780643165,
0.5037836432,
0.7638056278,
-0.5248938203,
0.1521699727,
-0.5855184793,
0.0090287868,
-0.2642916441,
-1.167191267,
-0.7575060725,
-0.32155931,
-0.3445355296,
-0.3231660724,
-0.0375724919,
0.875821054,
0.6113108993,
-0.6326570511,
-0.2140909582,
-0.5936251283,
-0.0496213697,
-0.4051109552,
-0.1840175837,
0.5161466002,
-0.4743703902,
-0.5954196453,
0.705619514,
0.8148267269,
-0.4110916853,
-0.207755968,
0.0899350345,
-0.5593664646,
0.0429514982,
0.5427076221,
0.0823064446,
-0.1277012825,
-0.1675651073,
0.1530434191,
-0.0816717744,
0.5171311498,
0.9044291973,
-0.5779885054,
0.6235671043,
0.8089296222,
1.0609811544,
0.7717716694,
-0.3596281409,
0.2834824324,
-0.7293744683,
0.1460725516,
0.6590816379,
0.3213068843,
0.520511806,
-0.374579221,
0.0194321461,
0.1223552078,
-0.6203640103,
-0.8041279316,
0.1991140991,
-0.9432454705,
-0.0296686031,
0.9400467277,
0.0152288657,
-0.7902507186,
0.1260584742,
-0.1634223014,
0.4297838509,
-0.426438719,
0.7914122343,
0.347838372,
-0.4220847487,
-0.2214581966,
-0.6951360106,
0.7954457998,
0.8772658706,
-0.6500650048,
0.0242912583,
0.003458611,
-0.1656745076,
0.5019829869,
0.5710573196,
0.4059736431,
0.2610920966,
0.4983956814,
0.2944719195,
0.1564586014,
-0.3215931952,
-0.6742374897,
0.4210898876,
-0.3493757546,
-0.2437704355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17902v1
|
Revisiting speech segmentation and lexicon learning with better features
| 2024-01-31T15:06:34 | 2024-01-31T15:06:34 |
Herman Kamper, Benjamin van Niekerk
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
We revisit a self-supervised method that segments unlabelled speech into
word-like segments. We start from the two-stage duration-penalised dynamic
programming method that performs zero-resource segmentation without learning an
explicit lexicon. In the first acoustic unit discovery stage, we replace
contrastive predictive coding features with HuBERT. After word segmentation in
the second stage, we get an acoustic word embedding for each segment by
averaging HuBERT features. These embeddings are clustered using K-means to get
a lexicon. The result is good full-coverage segmentation with a lexicon that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ZeroSpeech benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6056668162,
-0.5094061494,
0.4709192514,
-0.0266915895,
-0.4069102407,
0.4297583103,
-0.1645534933,
-0.5707922578,
0.7331376672,
0.5050655603,
-0.6729248762,
-0.3874539435,
-0.3718746305,
0.0339885466,
-0.5129918456,
0.6916382313,
0.2464056909,
0.0543193333,
-0.2364894748,
-0.4198638201,
-0.3348762989,
-0.4864378273,
-0.4309495687,
-0.4122021794,
0.4775725603,
0.6278003454,
0.4747574031,
0.9077417254,
-0.0652434975,
0.2715182602,
-0.3862600327,
0.0856708884,
-0.219254449,
0.1639074832,
0.0362949483,
-0.0176964924,
-0.0052890852,
0.1968423873,
0.6098991632,
0.9125493169,
-0.4077881575,
-0.1516814083,
0.0064315847,
0.2639791965,
-0.6323472261,
0.046685271,
-0.6620602608,
0.0267901029,
-0.1612686515,
-0.0976317003,
-0.1238733828,
-0.0738171488,
0.1795947403,
-0.4556622207,
0.3080099821,
-0.2278855592,
0.8488487601,
0.2044056058,
-0.1253277808,
-0.3581045568,
-0.7044112682,
1.0498408079,
-0.4008608758,
0.6936252117,
0.3120196462,
0.1175999939,
0.138069734,
-0.8202309012,
-0.4128979743,
-0.416821897,
0.1369691342,
-0.040523883,
0.0288412701,
0.0919411406,
-0.0265332349,
0.4099874794,
-0.1212962419,
0.3329073787,
-0.5537781119,
-0.4699662924,
0.7614414096,
-0.2523737848,
-0.076532498,
-0.2428772151,
-0.4343359172,
-0.2894876897,
-0.3452081382,
-0.0954967737,
0.2978504896,
0.357137233,
-0.1183236465,
0.2515756488,
-0.2729969323,
0.3964267969,
-0.2279234529,
-0.3987920284,
0.664652586,
-0.1054077148,
0.0468349345,
0.6003491879,
0.4388005137,
-0.1329960972,
0.4655177891,
-0.1093353406,
-0.1484220177,
0.1094451547,
0.1453326195,
-0.4202670157,
-0.4918104112,
0.1628917903,
-0.1428582966,
-0.2738712132,
-0.1852700263,
-0.59325248,
-0.0390668362,
-0.5670824647,
0.2748173177,
-0.552677393,
-0.2782936692,
0.0104902275,
-0.1138504818,
0.3479224145,
0.2154420614,
-0.9422335625,
0.480365634,
0.6784444451,
1.0451945066,
-0.1494636089,
-0.1416109949,
-0.3796276748,
0.0120820655,
-0.5383704901,
0.9610406756,
-0.5704094768,
-0.7089107633,
-0.0953273252,
-0.0742884725,
0.1530762017,
-0.6117348075,
0.2000737935,
-0.1743295193,
0.2421030998,
-0.0958838537,
-0.6626118422,
-0.2240664363,
0.1194277108,
-0.254658699,
0.9864240885,
0.2839182615,
-0.4483981431,
0.4506905079,
-0.5157445669,
-0.4725440145,
0.0154221579,
-0.3028598428,
-0.4445876479,
0.119955726,
0.248982802,
0.2008496821,
0.2978181541,
-0.024903819,
-0.4915530682,
-0.1882736534,
0.1758876294,
-0.251724571,
0.4316224754,
0.3406325281,
-0.1812171638,
0.1947262585,
-1.0866558552,
0.0822642967,
0.0136860795,
-0.1203386709,
-0.1772473902,
0.2135221362,
-0.113615118,
0.0251638386,
0.1216293052,
-0.9391037822,
-0.0062938938,
-0.55822891,
0.4436929524,
0.5592330098,
0.1194747016,
0.4479967058,
0.1124893799,
0.3210071921,
-0.2754285932,
0.1890191436,
-0.1207459196,
-0.2845080495,
-0.7797659039,
-0.3879105151,
0.5630930066,
0.4837933481,
-0.5334123373,
0.3922519684,
0.1779794246,
-0.3694949448,
-0.4564785659,
0.0607448928,
0.3546864688,
0.5456976891,
0.6096428037,
-0.379406631,
-0.5066191554,
-1.0065141916,
0.2143812329,
-0.2703508139,
-0.2524743974,
0.3985934854,
0.1770740747,
-0.1256312132,
0.7005867362,
-0.8129094839,
-0.3668920994,
-0.4424367845,
0.1970292181,
0.0903641656,
0.4116641283,
0.2645437717,
-0.4816893637,
-0.2789984643,
-0.2088235617,
-0.3241608441,
-0.375017941,
0.0063840668,
0.1736198962,
0.2874843478,
0.8994096518,
0.0215468053,
0.2715499997,
0.4172292352,
-0.0375860818,
0.3910453022,
-0.1659249067,
-0.2260761112,
-0.9199552536,
-0.3100135922,
-0.2969340086,
-0.1738558114,
-0.5325413942,
-0.2260343879,
-0.0964222774,
-0.2383520007,
-0.5493184924,
0.3708213568,
-0.5886865854,
-0.2544993162,
-0.5776172876,
0.3503845334,
-0.089475438,
0.451859951,
0.1482060999,
0.6376169324,
0.6238886714,
-0.5683661699,
0.3673498631,
0.2105710953,
-0.4913303554,
0.2703518569,
-0.4686742723,
0.1962271929,
-0.1100056022,
-0.0927807167,
-1.0264635086,
-0.0598842315,
0.0366784893,
-0.5396199822,
0.582505703,
0.0993080139,
-0.1178458855,
-0.335583955,
-0.3234648407,
0.3012102842,
0.4635351896,
-0.420037359,
0.0710868612,
0.7840887308,
-0.0769492611,
-0.2727778256,
-0.659286499,
0.1039008051,
-0.035706114,
-0.3612092137,
0.6620130539,
0.3367328644,
-0.1497548074,
0.0378427133,
-0.1892078221,
-0.0772058293,
0.0773207918,
0.1608288288,
-0.1349107474,
0.0325996466,
0.2370863408,
-0.097876586,
-0.2207798511,
-0.17681472,
-0.2236869931,
0.7517095804,
0.1908590645,
-0.1543480307,
-0.3639940321,
0.330816716,
0.096405074,
-0.3386524916,
0.3295252919,
0.6794291735,
-0.2683805823,
-0.3325782716,
-0.4901617169,
-0.2906027734,
-0.4564192593,
0.4928951263,
-0.2350637019,
-1.2194590569,
0.2343103439,
-0.0583777986,
-0.0082094911,
0.4663177133,
0.202886492,
-0.2153928578,
0.7608472705,
0.7886576056,
-0.1287010908,
0.4330074787,
-0.3632923961,
0.1724143177,
-0.951534152,
-0.5371847749,
-0.5511135459,
-0.3778117895,
-0.7360242009,
-0.4953186214,
0.2612555921,
0.2649773955,
0.1542665511,
0.4058583975,
-0.6271321177,
0.2384409606,
0.7163814902,
-0.1343515217,
-0.2783112824,
0.1780689955,
-0.4015953839,
-0.0039284299,
-0.5882958174,
0.008395046,
0.7329378724,
0.3636141419,
0.65296942,
-0.2658963501,
1.0756297112,
0.3847226202,
-0.0379011296,
-0.9765450358,
0.5409576893,
-0.1321382374,
-0.4352199137,
-0.704020381,
-0.3549994826,
-1.0225032568,
0.3078854084,
-0.1845305562,
-0.8315446973,
0.3171353638,
0.1133270413,
-0.6244596243,
0.3257022202,
-0.4142530859,
0.4813975692,
-0.2139039934,
-0.0515998267,
-0.5504826307,
-0.301954776,
0.0173507873,
-0.0324564278,
0.3158906698,
-0.5634894967,
-0.1185426041,
1.0114872456,
-0.4435704947,
0.5120044947,
-0.3973390162,
0.0231185071,
0.5985079408,
0.0134998504,
-0.167357564,
0.0885697454,
0.1641697884,
0.3739238381,
0.0938165039,
-0.325619638,
-0.3596710265,
0.7177430391,
-0.5264401436,
-0.4509767592,
-0.5291209817,
-0.1102130488,
-0.5258362889,
-0.0297215302,
0.08957389,
0.6330235004,
-0.2851085663,
0.3317133188,
0.464443773,
-0.3726872802,
0.8145190477,
0.5017169714,
-0.1503745764,
-0.8285194039,
0.8434397578,
0.2928903699,
0.061511647,
0.3343522549,
0.4671176076,
-0.5068531036,
-0.6566063166,
-0.2196858227,
0.3368848264,
-0.2239146233,
-0.1272145212,
-0.549041748,
-0.5959065557,
-0.5774728656,
-0.069395259,
-0.6943560243,
-0.4939409196,
-0.440033257,
-0.1699947566,
0.1411123276,
0.699670136,
-0.6235828996,
0.5480196476,
-0.6285575032,
0.3263538182,
0.5051272511,
0.1747096628,
-0.0782783628,
-0.7234746218,
-0.4010079801,
-0.2881175876,
-0.5131797791,
-0.7681980729,
0.514111042,
0.5002176762,
0.5353467464,
0.6366870999,
-0.2577960789,
0.4961488247,
-0.7070482373,
0.7650727034,
0.3648727238,
-0.8619756103,
0.6691983342,
0.0552810393,
0.5179924369,
0.5093111992,
0.3160400391,
-0.7527654171,
-0.0173683353,
-0.7482762337,
-0.9962016344,
0.7933604717,
0.1685377806,
0.1249065027,
-0.2556904852,
0.3299020231,
-0.0917159691,
0.2452256978,
-0.2003157586,
-0.2464475632,
-0.211045891,
0.2709314227,
-0.1375426352,
-0.9156417251,
0.0587874465,
-0.3490068316,
0.7753722072,
-0.0547906943,
0.1918001771,
0.2936663926,
0.252523303,
0.0840281397,
0.3819518089,
0.5624203086,
0.5523266792,
-0.2934672534,
-0.0157841947,
0.4008188248,
-0.3388561904,
0.2250075638,
0.1449846476,
-0.0580781177,
0.2191446424,
0.6466124654,
0.8888843656,
0.5746688843,
-0.2359047681,
0.4218762815,
0.2442104965,
-0.6582457423,
-0.5182034969,
0.17214939,
0.0592273138,
0.1016640663,
0.2038429826,
-0.3812611997,
0.2185304761,
-0.5098132491,
0.6504592299,
0.2835886776,
-0.6362100244,
-0.1668659598,
0.394739151,
0.213346824,
-0.2501396239,
0.5824005008,
-0.2925449312,
-0.5165627599,
0.5208778381,
0.4265657961,
0.9369947314,
-0.6648430824,
0.4144625962,
0.401407212,
0.0838500783,
0.1566416472,
0.6520373821,
-0.5327566266,
-0.763841629,
-0.6150979996,
-1.0591673851,
-0.4367545247,
0.2536498904,
-0.7377095819,
0.1781365871,
-0.6027922034,
-0.0231000334,
0.1797179282,
-0.0062554469,
-0.2498308271,
0.3184829354,
0.6066179872,
0.7955040932,
-0.4790010154,
1.0521936417,
0.4002489448,
0.1852455735,
-0.9765191078,
-0.2259223312,
-0.0079092467,
-0.9155342579,
0.1871224344,
0.3654966354,
-0.0794932842,
-0.1489533037,
-0.3846746385,
-1.3891299963,
0.8693904281,
0.0924890041,
-0.946855247,
0.0111476565,
0.0827397257,
0.269543618,
-0.1638569832,
-0.1343871504,
0.6295489669,
0.2552096248,
0.3950443864,
-0.8452530503,
-0.6470488906,
0.4302811921,
0.0300030652,
0.4058759809,
-0.556437552,
0.6612407565,
-0.2227079719,
-0.3477807343,
-0.052541431,
1.029732585,
-0.1041641384,
0.3629874587,
0.8378638625,
0.937767148,
0.7502538562,
-0.1056043506,
0.6010646224,
-0.3096092343,
0.4340507984,
1.2486680746,
-0.1587766558,
0.812966764,
0.2235080004,
-0.445294708,
0.7233248949,
0.6526964307,
-0.1178814843,
0.8134910464,
0.4292091429,
-0.3737455308,
-0.4037016928,
-0.3434028924,
-0.2799442708,
1.2230242491,
0.3704125881,
-0.1912004501,
-0.4695962369,
0.1591990888,
0.0720505416,
0.0679248795,
-0.569462955,
0.945294261,
0.3621986806,
-0.2500531077,
0.6915652752,
0.1546172798,
0.6326029301,
-0.7347204089,
-0.0087747062,
-0.1451787949,
-0.0868335217,
-0.1555448025,
-0.7172377706,
0.4682782292,
-0.249540031,
0.1647216678,
-0.0889990851,
0.6317716241,
-0.5124390125,
-0.4480405748,
0.422840327,
0.3010973036,
0.350281924,
-0.1054735035,
-0.5984745026,
-0.0301092137,
0.2453970313,
0.0313453749,
0.1814005822,
0.2566053867,
0.1702170968,
0.4053715169,
0.4391130209,
0.3250284791,
-0.1086217389,
0.4971803725,
0.7538327575,
-0.7195936441,
-0.793828249,
-0.7784511447,
-0.0159892533,
-0.1942749619,
-0.2770129144,
0.5169464946,
0.5711902976,
1.1569191217,
0.257460624,
0.3603396714,
0.1430635303,
0.8077765107,
-0.5483525395,
0.4859382212,
-0.7057298422,
-0.0751399621,
-0.1751121134,
-0.8179991841,
-0.1527040303,
0.5743598938,
-0.0669261068,
-0.049176611,
0.5660679936,
0.6623429656,
0.0804808065,
-0.1130809784,
0.7257268429,
-0.0779377893,
0.230630815,
0.1081971005,
0.6810956001,
0.1285375953,
0.4323242605,
-0.8491063118,
-0.3681329489,
0.0330333114,
-0.6566931605,
-0.5388721824,
-0.5903869271,
-0.47886917,
-0.255874455,
-0.0040346296,
0.7811434269,
0.960275352,
-0.9631868005,
-0.3102003038,
0.1687919497,
-0.01306176,
-0.0795981064,
-0.2621144354,
0.4044601619,
-0.5636019707,
-0.5709503889,
0.8741146922,
0.546117425,
-0.1448325813,
-0.4150227606,
0.1093237326,
-0.2280425131,
0.1559600681,
0.5541875362,
0.4587013721,
-0.4252232611,
-0.4226924479,
-0.3477404118,
0.3454628289,
0.2023081779,
0.9035314322,
-0.9645141959,
0.3811699152,
0.1240261719,
0.4856673777,
0.67442137,
-0.1194696724,
0.08071547,
-0.8215969205,
0.2810910642,
0.436596483,
0.4498056471,
0.453949362,
-0.1234995052,
0.4588876367,
0.5503067374,
-0.5149123669,
-0.6126773953,
0.344953388,
-0.8996065855,
-0.5304844975,
1.0375819206,
0.1544385105,
-0.4051104486,
-0.052982863,
0.0226043593,
0.3765776753,
-0.3538487256,
0.783757031,
0.3480644524,
-0.5714884996,
-0.1336915791,
-0.0580708049,
0.6547444463,
0.305213809,
-0.3886939883,
-0.2659469843,
0.5229272246,
0.4650890827,
0.4469053745,
0.5930576921,
-0.281131953,
-0.0003099921,
0.1190139726,
0.2799633741,
-0.2830195427,
-0.796790719,
-0.3141521513,
0.3177631199,
0.1977099478,
-0.7680000663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17897v1
|
Employing Label Models on ChatGPT Answers Improves Legal Text Entailment Performance
| 2024-01-31T15:04:01 | 2024-01-31T15:04:01 |
Chau Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The objective of legal text entailment is to ascertain whether the assertions
in a legal query logically follow from the information provided in one or
multiple legal articles. ChatGPT, a large language model, is robust in many
natural language processing tasks, including legal text entailment: when we set
the temperature = 0 (the ChatGPT answers are deterministic) and prompt the
model, it achieves 70.64% accuracy on COLIEE 2022 dataset, which outperforms
the previous SOTA of 67.89%. On the other hand, if the temperature is larger
than zero, ChatGPT answers are not deterministic, leading to inconsistent
answers and fluctuating results. We propose to leverage label models (a
fundamental component of weak supervision techniques) to integrate the
provisional answers by ChatGPT into consolidated labels. By that way, we treat
ChatGPT provisional answers as noisy predictions which can be consolidated by
label models. The experimental results demonstrate that this approach can
attain an accuracy of 76.15%, marking a significant improvement of 8.26% over
the prior state-of-the-art benchmark. Additionally, we perform an analysis of
the instances where ChatGPT produces incorrect answers, then we classify the
errors, offering insights that could guide potential enhancements for future
research endeavors.
|
[
-0.11666812,
-0.9784759283,
0.5714125037,
0.159747988,
-0.3658748269,
-0.1339769959,
-0.0972345099,
-0.6917600632,
-0.0825482979,
0.7466674447,
-0.0347913727,
-0.5804133415,
-0.8679744005,
-0.2300493717,
-0.4274807274,
1.3902763128,
-0.0557084531,
-0.1207164377,
-0.3639891148,
-0.0689766854,
-0.3340330124,
-0.5899184346,
-0.7292246222,
-0.369361788,
0.3881770074,
0.1927031875,
0.8405930996,
0.6514382362,
0.7851956487,
0.1747911721,
-0.3071101308,
0.0860511884,
-0.4749037921,
0.1785268337,
0.0156035274,
-0.498699367,
-0.6423743367,
0.1395517439,
0.2084250748,
0.4297070503,
-0.4790928662,
0.0407969281,
0.1121915802,
0.499035418,
-0.6366515756,
0.4770777524,
-0.6408175826,
-0.0891524702,
-0.0897540748,
-0.2759543061,
-0.6882525086,
-0.6622689366,
0.333351016,
-0.5998590589,
0.3756927252,
0.0773205757,
1.1254860163,
0.6060340405,
-0.700163126,
-0.5808164477,
-0.6679153442,
0.182327792,
-1.0988460779,
0.5016644001,
0.5076603293,
0.1286147833,
-0.2505183816,
-0.9757732749,
-0.3792471588,
-0.4429212511,
-0.2251435667,
0.6098136306,
-0.2091384232,
0.3714479506,
0.4593060911,
0.029314328,
-0.5590665936,
0.1114088669,
-0.1824196875,
-0.2608577013,
0.5533598661,
-0.0253817663,
0.2411861271,
0.1347114891,
-0.1544720083,
-0.0575286038,
-0.6532132626,
0.2981936038,
0.3484591544,
0.2099522799,
0.0855406672,
0.8319826722,
-0.1646043658,
0.8237042427,
0.0832933113,
-0.0315786973,
-0.0387760177,
-0.2924621999,
-0.1751123518,
0.4313509166,
0.8974474072,
0.3455993533,
0.2100798935,
-0.3239246905,
-0.0978304222,
-0.0886134952,
0.0643986911,
-1.1798100471,
-0.5689202547,
0.2835296988,
-0.1059808731,
-0.154135555,
0.1579362601,
-0.6940312982,
-0.6641094089,
-0.5506544113,
0.2815774381,
-0.4975922406,
-0.0254125521,
0.3875976205,
-0.3260852396,
0.3544220328,
0.352535516,
-0.6964809299,
0.4251286983,
0.8820058107,
0.5393463969,
0.2380762398,
0.3064567745,
-0.6176819205,
0.2452059686,
-0.2357171178,
0.9371871948,
-0.9009139538,
-0.1705386639,
-0.1384003609,
-0.120370701,
-0.3074395657,
-0.5212607384,
0.9128937721,
-0.7270588279,
0.1526405066,
-0.0974260271,
-0.9228173494,
-0.2503391206,
0.3770909011,
-0.5011402369,
1.0194786787,
-0.4719171822,
-0.99627316,
0.5777469873,
-0.6550253034,
-0.3510149121,
0.0268905889,
0.050026387,
-0.8219221234,
-0.2761034667,
0.3246210814,
0.270545572,
-0.2991812527,
0.6306062937,
-0.2043497115,
-0.1629107744,
0.5121712089,
-0.5671727061,
0.7404865026,
0.1152196452,
-0.364222914,
0.0024625314,
-0.4711752534,
0.0662638023,
-0.1621800512,
-0.6024287939,
-0.2965484262,
0.1957167089,
-0.3113224208,
-0.0479258671,
0.2059948146,
-0.5934233665,
0.094175756,
-0.3346053064,
0.1701012254,
0.4371854663,
0.2653084695,
0.3365967274,
-0.2461812943,
0.5562762022,
0.0162153915,
-0.109334901,
0.061256323,
-1.0951529741,
-0.7868478894,
-0.210285157,
0.7016470432,
0.8370625377,
-0.6013120413,
0.086253725,
-0.3788158,
-0.7962803245,
-0.6234864593,
-0.0017041075,
0.5186082125,
0.5317927599,
0.3356927931,
-0.061099682,
-0.3950605094,
-0.8683178425,
-0.6182638407,
-0.4924856424,
-0.1472891867,
0.2572761774,
0.5433706045,
-0.0878494456,
1.0939522982,
-0.6278538704,
0.0443831198,
0.0988109857,
0.5898051858,
0.4362206757,
0.2278677821,
0.2547856271,
-1.0782459974,
-0.7102811337,
0.3539432287,
-0.783773005,
-0.3258491158,
-0.0249752272,
-0.1246011034,
-0.0408003964,
0.4299974144,
-0.5689250827,
0.4480607212,
0.1693021506,
-0.5498645306,
0.6874935627,
-0.2284056693,
0.2591325045,
-0.7573919296,
-0.251401633,
0.2331242561,
-0.263225019,
-0.788004756,
0.0860268623,
0.2149600834,
0.0384238139,
-0.5848760605,
0.1765466779,
-0.2311973125,
0.481311202,
-0.2674597204,
0.0441905037,
-0.0444439352,
0.2590178549,
0.0151818749,
0.7583252788,
0.5826228857,
-0.7311288118,
0.4261550009,
0.1339856535,
-0.0265930779,
0.4737786353,
-0.8329956532,
0.1369042248,
-0.3707090914,
0.2571349442,
-0.9148861766,
-0.4611918926,
0.4452596903,
-0.3748256564,
0.4498372376,
-0.5216259956,
-0.7202177644,
-0.2358343601,
0.1668172032,
0.0301970784,
0.657735467,
-0.2099716067,
0.6135965586,
0.5480581522,
-0.1478590369,
-0.3953998983,
-0.5521097183,
0.0791977495,
-0.4118470252,
-0.5569916368,
0.1669230461,
0.0385812856,
-0.3285036087,
0.1198631227,
-0.1449483335,
-0.4998842776,
-0.1169980168,
0.1406586915,
0.0309673958,
-0.3508837521,
0.4349404275,
-0.1773155183,
0.1541885734,
0.2323606312,
-0.1699539572,
0.3091906905,
-0.3997686207,
-0.3372024894,
-0.2542101741,
-0.0154186469,
0.4103688598,
-0.3736330867,
0.8146235347,
0.4542736411,
-0.2955359817,
0.0776089206,
-0.5911081433,
-0.2112777382,
-0.4454178214,
0.1434184611,
-0.2668384314,
-0.7706125379,
0.5575614572,
0.1463554204,
0.1927851737,
0.2596662939,
0.3906880021,
-0.2636294067,
0.6935001612,
0.4691126347,
0.2701624632,
0.307046026,
0.2430042922,
0.4233866334,
-0.3972127438,
-0.4211262763,
-0.6318573356,
0.1553446651,
-1.0006723404,
-0.5252011418,
0.4140323102,
-0.0486863591,
-0.1221234426,
0.5397618413,
-0.5330341458,
0.6430915594,
0.6585627198,
0.464930445,
0.3393549025,
-0.2415446788,
0.1001945958,
-0.0561419502,
-0.8290694952,
-0.6683756709,
0.9297737479,
0.3839808404,
0.7876547575,
0.2970555723,
0.6233286262,
0.1604626626,
0.5725719333,
-0.8914936185,
0.5938435793,
-0.1307578236,
-0.7159651518,
-0.4151090384,
-0.4334909022,
-0.9908472896,
0.460203439,
-0.1164965928,
-0.8239507675,
0.098241061,
0.1772075295,
-0.0547469743,
0.2372213751,
-0.8403176069,
0.7973586321,
0.0003945465,
-0.6719884872,
0.3855270743,
-0.4682429135,
0.4800397754,
-0.378501296,
0.1690566838,
-0.3158120513,
0.0999018624,
1.127710104,
-0.4849388301,
1.1007169485,
0.0362569802,
-0.4296777844,
0.9141577482,
-0.1539449841,
0.7735609412,
-0.040585205,
-0.1601669192,
-0.2886913121,
0.2291348428,
-0.2166306674,
-0.7477454543,
0.1877496988,
-0.2664322853,
-0.6558685899,
-0.3930815458,
-0.5968132615,
-0.1569742709,
0.1227106899,
0.3625208139,
0.412137121,
0.0380643122,
0.4011821151,
0.9924153686,
-0.1445214748,
0.1856197566,
0.9195589423,
0.0895491764,
0.1004804298,
0.7871089578,
0.382487148,
0.0957255363,
0.3736971021,
0.3847775459,
-0.6538605094,
-0.3332673311,
-0.0426204912,
0.184010908,
-0.928960979,
-0.324225992,
-0.8926981091,
-0.2826559544,
-0.5879608393,
0.1743732989,
-0.3333731294,
-0.2627654672,
0.0707708001,
-0.1394787133,
0.5098028183,
0.5413886905,
0.1966427267,
0.4366354942,
-0.8571950793,
0.3303078115,
0.3881506324,
0.43193537,
-0.5588582158,
-0.7891154289,
0.022441769,
0.4277918339,
-0.4948355556,
-1.2050870657,
0.2396632582,
0.2691233158,
0.5952320695,
0.1868219078,
0.4168765545,
0.7438530922,
-0.6214783788,
0.4386395514,
0.0077547911,
-0.7816835046,
0.7791089416,
-0.6692031622,
0.2696321011,
0.4209451973,
0.3877394199,
-0.4858303368,
-1.1010183096,
-0.6439673901,
-0.9112451673,
0.3307856321,
0.5538496971,
-0.0462799333,
0.1254256517,
0.2466211021,
-0.0945403799,
-0.0232540835,
-0.876755476,
0.0550449677,
0.1898429841,
-0.0517292395,
0.2037632465,
-0.260453999,
-0.0704781711,
-0.2144818604,
0.903788507,
-0.0218096524,
0.298432976,
0.0782083943,
0.1395071447,
0.3176024556,
0.7253392935,
0.370749712,
0.6127881408,
-0.4444517195,
0.2508244514,
0.2188563049,
-0.5866031051,
0.2231220901,
0.2725667059,
-0.3143134713,
0.2320406735,
0.3366537392,
0.709843874,
0.0420294777,
-0.5106108785,
0.3888890743,
0.0089886012,
-0.3975767493,
-0.0753177032,
0.0783548504,
0.1151602045,
-0.0101116253,
0.0765810907,
0.0164278951,
0.5030554533,
-0.3586809635,
0.4670991898,
0.158352077,
-0.6566433311,
0.1188197136,
0.9965883493,
-0.1561546028,
-0.0619985312,
0.5280427933,
-0.0687938184,
-0.5083456635,
1.0516490936,
0.5899561644,
0.5746246576,
0.0413892195,
0.3786823452,
0.3772065639,
0.4877300262,
-0.4012210369,
-0.0443013348,
0.1968111843,
-0.6765937805,
-0.5230284929,
-0.5646418333,
-0.7710509896,
-0.292057544,
-0.7321768999,
0.0665417463,
0.0349559002,
-0.3522753716,
0.1825478822,
-0.4778911173,
-0.702608645,
0.3101446629,
-0.1437171251,
0.6227886677,
-0.8909056783,
0.7612106204,
0.7533485889,
-0.4714326859,
-0.9162738919,
0.0950122252,
-0.1207080036,
-0.3234992027,
0.5490887761,
0.1548394561,
-0.0973890796,
-0.078167446,
-0.7713371515,
-0.5339112878,
0.6827768683,
0.3784094155,
-0.6012076139,
0.3510192335,
0.5025663972,
0.7951111794,
0.1687522829,
0.326390475,
0.8415100574,
0.5360604525,
0.4555914402,
-1.0475974083,
0.1166692972,
-0.2166744024,
-0.4305541813,
0.2492208779,
-0.3383697271,
0.3503223956,
-0.1759766787,
-0.372684747,
-0.4094464183,
0.6308998466,
0.2481979877,
0.542309165,
0.1486304998,
0.5655644536,
1.2325308323,
-0.5409470797,
1.2220212221,
-0.1774410456,
0.3646721244,
1.4406702518,
-0.1886328608,
0.8586075306,
0.3919355273,
-0.1986441463,
0.1301756054,
0.7741408944,
-0.0287181493,
0.4468632042,
0.2136575729,
-0.4186620712,
-0.362316668,
-0.4144970179,
-0.3847950995,
0.4971026182,
0.3684991896,
-0.1982495338,
-0.1300140172,
-0.0881628841,
0.2102086246,
0.0640783906,
-0.1505441964,
1.0025525093,
0.0390386321,
-0.9114928842,
0.3638260067,
-0.0710258111,
0.4301553071,
-0.3863233328,
-0.0264379699,
-0.2490381151,
0.1823181957,
-0.1285683662,
-1.1392221451,
0.3140529096,
0.2237345576,
0.1195140406,
-0.3614121974,
0.8393967748,
-0.4973123372,
-0.6710538864,
-0.1086723506,
0.3325290382,
0.3562192917,
-0.1346770525,
-0.4830788076,
-0.4752105474,
-0.1045456603,
-0.1137233078,
-0.0915761143,
0.769246757,
0.0540280975,
0.7793649435,
0.5440465808,
-0.1162765399,
0.4576997757,
-0.0722894743,
0.9371553063,
-0.2825237215,
-0.5320860147,
-0.992243886,
0.5596553683,
-0.2134000212,
-0.0453066975,
0.7903714776,
0.7943490744,
0.6145954728,
-0.0179522634,
0.7043714523,
-0.0903244466,
0.2653088868,
-0.8404568434,
0.7037466168,
-0.2213442475,
0.3378191888,
-0.23646456,
-0.9223742485,
-0.4460133016,
0.2777610123,
-0.7821764946,
-0.2545791566,
0.6015794277,
0.9295911789,
-0.1788503677,
0.1402209252,
0.3796123564,
0.0130577991,
0.701428175,
0.387015909,
0.747194469,
-0.5648416281,
0.8335615396,
-0.2200460881,
0.0194298364,
0.005073369,
-0.8561089039,
-0.847140789,
-0.1711544096,
-0.8536080122,
-0.4892338812,
0.2960838675,
0.4406300187,
0.6207157373,
-0.9716125131,
-0.0149641233,
-0.1562541425,
-0.1629362255,
-0.1257353276,
-0.2722280025,
0.3565376103,
-0.563159585,
-0.6716834307,
0.0983292609,
-0.0040618959,
0.3183796108,
0.6686682105,
-0.1418331414,
-0.1641024947,
0.2799001932,
0.4196081161,
0.1464059502,
-0.6345536113,
-0.1180557981,
-0.2454278767,
-0.3458603919,
0.1880499572,
0.6749560833,
-0.2922767103,
0.6704838872,
0.5698506236,
0.6897086501,
0.7037560344,
0.3217820823,
0.546784699,
-0.65907377,
0.1677412689,
0.3662729859,
0.3116597235,
0.0822369456,
-0.3562044203,
0.7483940721,
-0.0110248458,
-0.6380751729,
-0.4521917403,
0.1164271235,
-0.9468237162,
-0.2408440709,
1.2977273464,
-0.4059432447,
-0.2304290235,
-0.3279028237,
-0.3417422771,
0.4893114567,
-0.4424546957,
0.6647697687,
0.8996235728,
-0.032349214,
-0.3480769992,
-1.1248173714,
0.3815446794,
0.3066908121,
-0.9449728727,
0.117042914,
0.4291759133,
0.2222931087,
0.0084123192,
0.6025658846,
0.001817954,
0.194709152,
0.2392674237,
-0.1185276881,
0.1570921838,
0.0070290607,
0.2039500624,
0.2754429877,
-0.0300038215,
-0.203130886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01766v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01766v2
|
LLM Voting: Human Choices and AI Collective Decision Making
| 2024-01-31T14:52:02 | 2024-05-15T14:50:37 |
Joshua C. Yang, Damian Dailisan, Marcin Korecki, Carina I. Hausladen, Dirk Helbing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC, 68T05, 91B14, 91C20, I.2.7; J.4; K.4.1
|
This paper investigates the voting behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, their biases, and how they align with human
voting patterns. Our methodology involved using a dataset from a human voting
experiment to establish a baseline for human preferences and a corresponding
experiment with LLM agents. We observed that the methods used for voting input
and the presentation of choices influence LLM voting behavior. We discovered
that varying the persona can reduce some of these biases and enhance alignment
with human choices. While the Chain-of-Thought approach did not improve
prediction accuracy, it has potential for AI explainability in the voting
process. We also identified a trade-off between preference diversity and
alignment accuracy in LLMs, influenced by different temperature settings. Our
findings indicate that LLMs may lead to less diverse collective outcomes and
biased assumptions when used in voting scenarios, emphasizing the importance of
cautious integration of LLMs into democratic processes.
|
[
-0.5306342244,
-0.4627218843,
0.8623915315,
0.0056632268,
-0.3353722692,
0.5180238485,
-0.1873601228,
-0.3681430817,
0.1930344403,
0.5717072487,
-0.5097267628,
-0.4695592225,
-0.4708811939,
0.1402755231,
-0.0315942056,
0.8804187775,
-0.0025157998,
0.3257252276,
-0.4419340491,
-0.1432574391,
-0.2261266559,
-0.8562054634,
-0.5958049297,
-1.0512350798,
0.7266866565,
0.5744861364,
1.0329060555,
0.786570549,
0.2694939673,
0.3443671167,
0.2328444272,
0.0868740603,
-0.596480608,
0.0242571905,
-0.2538396418,
-0.821804285,
-0.3300655186,
0.4882806838,
0.4769824147,
0.2487174869,
-0.2508342564,
0.0702339932,
0.0069765653,
0.7645482421,
-0.3709836304,
0.1058605686,
-0.8028308153,
-0.144771859,
-0.4440380633,
-0.1016767174,
-0.1379303932,
-0.485019803,
0.0591404252,
-0.0164896287,
0.1071967706,
0.1718300432,
0.5592496395,
0.426314503,
-0.4817232192,
-0.3212697804,
-0.5916407108,
0.8552652001,
-0.8120484948,
0.1704641432,
0.5074939728,
-0.0918329358,
-0.193004176,
-0.3432473242,
-0.7944278717,
-0.1060136557,
0.2336675525,
0.1483491212,
0.110414274,
0.2058325112,
-0.1616862267,
0.0165357515,
-0.4567824304,
0.560229063,
-0.2001944333,
-0.0559248328,
0.8182130456,
0.4296246469,
0.1792351305,
-0.102810882,
-0.2034455985,
-0.0207743812,
-0.7610172629,
-0.0428133197,
0.7435564995,
0.3105776906,
-0.0688685477,
0.6660687923,
-0.0277230982,
0.7626636028,
0.1883180588,
0.0785201117,
0.0501462668,
-0.3106778264,
-0.2615800798,
-0.1163507253,
0.8458263874,
0.5786462426,
0.2920017242,
0.0487915464,
-0.1261386573,
0.2931898236,
0.0536190793,
-0.4862897098,
-0.1834272742,
0.2859261632,
-0.4421311617,
-0.4730263352,
0.3765944242,
-0.5546773076,
-0.5917463899,
-0.8242124319,
0.2218911499,
0.1760193855,
-0.0496539697,
-0.0834614858,
-0.2526424527,
0.4441120327,
0.6257258058,
-0.9409508705,
0.2466295511,
1.024528861,
0.7116903067,
-0.5700027347,
-0.3802725673,
-0.0963197276,
-0.0060887435,
-0.5793262124,
0.8085565567,
-0.8613727093,
-0.234096393,
-0.2498973012,
-0.3945919871,
0.0533239283,
-0.684448123,
0.0307051037,
-0.8522215486,
0.3936799169,
-0.5795155764,
-0.6446827054,
-0.2107557356,
0.3001502752,
-0.6859603524,
0.7063257098,
-0.2876031399,
-0.3875990808,
0.6199315786,
-0.6187909842,
-0.1853699833,
-0.08619719,
-0.5117474794,
-0.2403060347,
-0.1193859577,
0.1004089937,
0.6402118802,
-0.3257062137,
0.2090956867,
-0.5008406639,
-0.4234421253,
0.5773058534,
-0.3457490802,
0.8190047145,
0.0845422223,
-0.3616486192,
0.470374018,
-0.1092846021,
-0.2276739329,
0.0905737728,
-0.5496612787,
-0.1093049273,
0.4047101736,
-0.128381595,
0.1850889474,
0.2536625564,
-0.2544266582,
0.6057290435,
-0.1424954683,
0.5270568728,
1.3449244499,
-0.1403164268,
0.7740989923,
-0.4905102849,
0.4454777539,
0.0485386252,
0.0706932545,
0.6057825089,
-0.9723449945,
-0.5971358418,
0.0381893478,
0.1949021369,
0.7193714976,
-0.5109975934,
0.1992621422,
0.0097810552,
-0.5237324238,
-0.2745168805,
0.3223138452,
-0.0596713945,
0.0737808719,
-0.2202313989,
-0.1774312407,
-0.5582001209,
-0.7379344106,
-0.051925309,
-0.7666983008,
0.1196720153,
0.256310761,
0.5602557063,
-0.4565497339,
1.0975061655,
-0.3289033473,
0.0077588982,
-0.2439794391,
0.0335729681,
0.3804886341,
0.143740803,
0.2611050606,
-0.6235840321,
-0.0737658963,
0.043619737,
-0.4786429703,
0.0450727977,
0.0506996028,
-0.0472985283,
0.5171202421,
0.2419523895,
-0.4923970699,
0.312697053,
0.7483014464,
-0.1961221695,
0.4024110436,
0.0581773333,
0.1999583542,
-0.906431973,
-0.4823123217,
0.0244695134,
-0.2382567823,
-0.4814194143,
-0.0884462297,
-0.2629785538,
0.2867167294,
-0.4232351184,
0.550037384,
-0.3665446937,
-0.3656647503,
-0.2858763933,
-0.0216862205,
-0.2590418458,
0.3994493484,
0.0815345421,
0.9622001648,
0.2160343826,
-0.5910930634,
0.6025670171,
0.1130309328,
-0.3901794553,
0.3429682255,
-0.5010241866,
0.7449079752,
-0.1483488083,
0.3270268142,
-1.0988333225,
-0.3207434416,
0.3225340545,
-0.4467460513,
-0.0507204272,
0.0633933395,
-0.5586651564,
-0.1353542358,
-0.2661845982,
0.3207044005,
0.3350594044,
-0.375857234,
0.5207555294,
0.7699255347,
-0.0306161586,
-0.4690570235,
-0.5514172912,
0.2568415403,
-0.4675100148,
-0.5549354553,
0.319344461,
-0.0424197689,
-0.7036063075,
-0.2042598873,
0.3103140891,
0.1048002094,
-0.1740237325,
0.2750205696,
0.5701169372,
-0.0357875191,
0.0473661236,
-0.359446913,
0.0729655102,
-0.1086462289,
-0.1636388302,
0.7229803205,
-0.2469170392,
-0.4454610646,
-0.284055233,
0.2905340195,
0.6228252649,
0.0338083841,
0.5310499072,
0.3929564059,
-0.3204461038,
0.1103910878,
-0.8055622578,
-0.2942891717,
-0.4772569239,
0.4316874444,
-0.0489886589,
-1.152395606,
0.7257561684,
0.0963549986,
0.1906012893,
0.1470107436,
1.2741267681,
-0.4320765734,
1.2306681871,
0.206594184,
-0.6541344523,
0.4207618237,
0.1785964668,
-0.0991025418,
-0.6225838065,
-0.1926517189,
-0.6031194329,
-0.7529894114,
-0.8213244677,
-0.8092922568,
0.3421062529,
-0.1859315485,
-0.6800076962,
-0.1376530677,
-0.3972347975,
0.6345406771,
0.7190012932,
0.1690550297,
0.1129619032,
-0.1167673841,
0.0870015621,
0.0439061522,
-0.5617398024,
-0.7579914331,
1.0060151815,
0.1253924072,
0.7882969379,
0.2517185211,
0.8909059167,
0.4140698612,
0.4357371628,
-0.7356616259,
0.5794250369,
-0.0821803138,
-0.6998932362,
-0.6501049995,
-0.1720636636,
-0.9950692654,
0.2848684192,
-0.0492387824,
-0.724158287,
0.1513009369,
0.0358242281,
-0.2025835365,
0.4958136082,
-0.331020236,
0.4993845522,
-0.4010820389,
-0.2030342221,
-0.44522205,
-0.702457428,
0.3143837452,
0.0958158076,
0.1248842031,
-0.2326088846,
-0.3870257139,
0.9640811086,
-0.2336743474,
1.2273082733,
0.069787465,
-0.0763354227,
0.2233777642,
-0.1677378565,
0.7148305774,
-0.0140742548,
-0.5545423031,
0.5193514228,
-0.3538772166,
-0.2537915111,
-0.4944406152,
0.6469677687,
-1.3626410961,
-1.0102888346,
-0.6037861705,
-0.4408910573,
-0.1484605521,
-0.2330377847,
0.2781727612,
0.0469783135,
-0.2209432125,
-0.0332428329,
0.1911531389,
0.2021035105,
0.4491986632,
0.2820791602,
-0.436073035,
-0.511469841,
0.6899817586,
0.1625599563,
0.3499789238,
0.1905401647,
0.3066862822,
-0.4522289336,
-0.5487273932,
-0.5417869091,
0.2556803524,
-0.7058925629,
-0.0187822562,
-0.0761716887,
0.0894375145,
-0.3162713349,
-0.1648503691,
-0.148265034,
-0.2506833673,
-0.7837787271,
-0.242223978,
0.1736064702,
1.1943229437,
-0.008137852,
0.1765132695,
-0.383813858,
0.1371554434,
0.592526257,
0.2280788869,
-0.1368458271,
-0.2847592533,
0.1027007475,
-0.0663908049,
-0.3358092606,
-1.2061706781,
0.0598364472,
-0.0755516812,
0.5792353153,
0.531201303,
-0.1198000088,
0.654388845,
-0.2831232548,
1.0890899897,
0.0493485071,
-0.9444547296,
0.361412257,
-0.3822146654,
0.2796502113,
0.5499583483,
0.053164795,
-0.4794135988,
-0.3979628086,
-0.2884690166,
-0.4461317062,
0.6391792297,
-0.0431128331,
0.2275035083,
0.092202872,
0.3109143972,
0.0933474228,
0.1933121532,
-0.6420339346,
-0.3330607414,
-0.0204815827,
0.0857595205,
-0.2346731722,
-0.1084059402,
-0.2565594614,
-0.3549933434,
0.4841322303,
-0.1993360221,
0.188140735,
0.015814919,
0.3528933227,
-0.3801326156,
0.1919934303,
0.9280485511,
0.9241331816,
-0.0409972258,
-0.0841489434,
0.3186412454,
-0.1181022823,
0.4362221658,
-0.4973356724,
-0.1197820455,
-0.2883157134,
0.2979559004,
0.8557946086,
-0.1971772909,
-0.1711600572,
0.1050100103,
-0.0785567462,
-0.2577480376,
-0.2678748667,
0.2222444266,
0.4245469272,
0.3518970907,
0.2409133017,
0.3537323773,
-0.0622486249,
-0.8155062199,
-0.0496060364,
0.8465038538,
-0.2599679232,
-0.3347933888,
0.451874882,
0.4025705457,
-0.5656014681,
0.7507535815,
-0.0980329737,
-0.8731306195,
0.7276933789,
0.3391693532,
0.6415694356,
-0.4547087848,
0.1967753023,
-0.0190171618,
0.4611288309,
-0.1186480671,
0.1741037518,
0.1245254725,
-1.3473412991,
-0.4836705625,
-0.2614142895,
-0.8462049365,
-0.0533260331,
-0.4366442561,
0.30337888,
-0.5192629695,
-0.4808526337,
-0.2320498377,
0.1936828643,
-0.7400434017,
0.0777575225,
0.4594462216,
0.3916723728,
-0.8694646955,
0.7710032463,
0.834035635,
-0.0540536381,
-0.884115696,
0.0311644748,
0.4943588674,
-1.1252293587,
0.4730495512,
-0.0679312274,
-0.0709892586,
-0.1915908009,
-0.7839341164,
-0.9403837919,
1.0419192314,
0.4490094185,
-0.6779866815,
0.0350919217,
0.2576277554,
0.267604351,
-0.4575510919,
0.188685894,
0.7832599878,
0.7992473245,
0.1690888554,
-0.84798944,
-0.1208730191,
0.0823629797,
-0.2137340307,
0.135857597,
-0.9594311118,
0.8718941808,
-0.4227375388,
0.0463643521,
-0.1152925566,
0.766528964,
0.742045939,
0.4584208727,
0.6815280914,
0.4000807106,
1.0902522802,
-0.0678204596,
1.1035490036,
0.1484221369,
0.0449628793,
0.8230166435,
-0.8863534331,
0.7990788817,
0.7521827221,
-0.5954746604,
0.6171275973,
0.9581255913,
0.0968701169,
0.2370726466,
0.3366626203,
-0.2592973411,
-0.6246712804,
0.117425628,
-0.0502417572,
0.7573182583,
0.2310653627,
0.0075413845,
0.3053690195,
-0.298032552,
0.051261235,
-0.1615635604,
-0.3450033665,
0.9727729559,
0.2040195018,
-0.9587970972,
-0.0335731469,
-0.0304679777,
0.7268593311,
-0.2421964854,
-0.0030683936,
0.0517266244,
-0.0200810041,
-0.3539632559,
-1.1833693981,
0.0291985031,
-0.0702569187,
-0.4803926349,
-0.1616722345,
0.5055834055,
-0.168900758,
-0.4925470054,
0.151394099,
0.6761481762,
0.1802722961,
0.0508613437,
-0.810320735,
0.3033683598,
0.2361303568,
-0.4814976454,
0.4482129216,
-0.0291311014,
-0.3400561512,
0.5596615076,
0.8835664988,
0.305322051,
-0.2420500368,
0.3211568296,
0.7303622961,
-0.5892553329,
-0.3846000731,
-1.3310374022,
0.3270309567,
-0.0419154763,
-0.2161316127,
0.3611094356,
0.3796700835,
0.5980128646,
0.1509846598,
0.978556931,
0.2983478904,
0.1524607986,
-0.6118280292,
0.7184573412,
-0.174013108,
0.3133255839,
-0.17672804,
-0.9751377106,
-0.2327957898,
0.5367872119,
-0.4731511176,
0.2590677738,
0.3263651133,
0.8676120639,
0.3709421158,
0.0607080795,
0.2811135352,
0.0368123315,
0.3972115517,
0.3596858978,
1.1559052467,
0.0849221945,
0.2491465062,
0.095314227,
-0.1754748821,
-0.156569764,
-0.9104123116,
-0.8219826221,
-0.6339523196,
-0.3913730383,
-0.0348608308,
-0.1279898137,
1.3409682512,
0.8415853977,
-0.7218596935,
-0.6718254089,
0.2009638697,
0.5029959679,
0.0581888445,
-0.2271597087,
0.1111563742,
-0.0025421642,
-0.7989481091,
0.1322158128,
0.3025493622,
-0.0721904859,
-0.3631078899,
-0.5603268147,
-0.1433300525,
0.3455306292,
0.4027449489,
-0.0348772071,
-1.272228837,
-0.3927581012,
-0.0908631608,
-0.1603892595,
0.3206870556,
0.8653883934,
-0.7305665612,
0.1970200688,
0.6687161922,
0.2503626049,
0.275437206,
0.3360399306,
0.8254363537,
-0.4305900633,
-0.1333072484,
0.2993671,
0.3243226707,
0.3043718338,
-0.3082130551,
0.3877266347,
0.0764391795,
-1.1110130548,
-0.4382658303,
0.1440093368,
-0.9285507798,
-0.0913798138,
1.2219244242,
0.3888629079,
-0.0721783489,
-0.1808322072,
-0.4131764472,
0.1825595349,
-0.6324412227,
0.6634524465,
0.9661437273,
-0.6312679648,
-0.2178372145,
-0.4344995022,
0.3401818573,
0.2702945173,
-0.7724017501,
-0.1140162647,
0.5717555881,
0.1414548755,
-0.053117983,
0.8833643198,
0.1375698298,
0.2294573486,
-0.6063294411,
-0.1096550375,
0.2251068503,
0.0243027192,
-0.4159504175,
0.1202393472,
0.3360061347,
0.0214870498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17882v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17882v2
|
I Think, Therefore I am: Benchmarking Awareness of Large Language Models Using AwareBench
| 2024-01-31T14:41:23 | 2024-02-16T09:47:38 |
Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Yuli Lin, Siyuan Wu, Yao Wan, Lichao Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Do large language models (LLMs) exhibit any forms of awareness similar to
humans? In this paper, we introduce AwareBench, a benchmark designed to
evaluate awareness in LLMs. Drawing from theories in psychology and philosophy,
we define awareness in LLMs as the ability to understand themselves as AI
models and to exhibit social intelligence. Subsequently, we categorize
awareness in LLMs into five dimensions, including capability, mission, emotion,
culture, and perspective. Based on this taxonomy, we create a dataset called
AwareEval, which contains binary, multiple-choice, and open-ended questions to
assess LLMs' understandings of specific awareness dimensions. Our experiments,
conducted on 13 LLMs, reveal that the majority of them struggle to fully
recognize their capabilities and missions while demonstrating decent social
intelligence. We conclude by connecting awareness of LLMs with AI alignment and
safety, emphasizing its significance to the trustworthy and ethical development
of LLMs. Our dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/HowieHwong/Awareness-in-LLM.
|
[
-0.3683063388,
-0.661344409,
0.6143636703,
0.236332193,
0.1275545806,
0.1867439151,
-0.4937560856,
-0.7945472598,
0.1687384546,
0.1953158081,
-0.2305387706,
-0.461525023,
-0.503557682,
-0.0043862551,
-0.5082917809,
0.5200812221,
0.1199445203,
0.0754846931,
-0.3342868686,
-0.3961384892,
-0.2226486653,
-0.5593336225,
-0.5412487388,
-0.4714890122,
0.5249156952,
0.3076738715,
0.4555057287,
0.6763960123,
0.618473649,
0.2909327149,
0.0479669645,
-0.1842228323,
-0.6203665733,
0.1420558989,
-0.2681842148,
-0.4430168271,
-0.5989688635,
0.1730260402,
0.8369185925,
0.8081280589,
0.0380764008,
0.5280085802,
0.0737567097,
0.5714100003,
-0.7312582731,
0.1161015034,
-0.7633230686,
-0.1388257593,
-0.1339516938,
0.4995741844,
-0.2634284198,
-0.3782190084,
0.1969947964,
-0.3505557775,
-0.1431814134,
0.4107871056,
0.5222325325,
0.5173166394,
-0.4178654253,
-0.0615085326,
-0.5851858854,
0.687422514,
-0.5942756534,
0.5617488027,
0.346504271,
0.4143203795,
0.0054146363,
-0.558529079,
-0.7604991794,
-0.0652735531,
0.0594885983,
0.1374767423,
-0.2453357577,
-0.0675398409,
0.5039858818,
0.22282359,
-0.6356112957,
0.160172075,
-0.0780546367,
-0.3501925766,
0.7982602715,
0.1059063822,
0.1467624158,
0.0358281732,
-0.4024568796,
0.0088682435,
-0.5329548717,
0.114031516,
0.1512142569,
-0.0233468581,
-0.2694565952,
0.467748791,
-0.2450001687,
0.615001142,
-0.3446971476,
-0.0732203424,
0.4588856101,
-0.0989277959,
-0.2062655985,
0.0731988922,
0.5773202777,
0.4340749085,
0.8261142373,
0.0348198153,
-0.1031409055,
0.1796312928,
0.5142765045,
-0.6591775417,
-0.0032399539,
0.17937994,
-0.4374599755,
-0.0700578094,
-0.2069648802,
-0.4494879544,
-0.9516423941,
-0.1774859428,
0.4206107855,
-0.3535889387,
-0.4023947716,
-0.0195586793,
-0.0410191081,
0.5204238892,
0.2874680459,
-0.7681346536,
0.4487537146,
0.8674531579,
0.5130577683,
0.0641094595,
-0.4173606038,
-0.2844093144,
0.1257862151,
-0.5034928918,
0.758490324,
-0.4715688527,
-0.4697509408,
-0.1213099733,
-0.2771735787,
-0.1257942021,
-0.5493661761,
0.5407217741,
-0.3832599223,
-0.3472941816,
-0.55279845,
-0.7672522664,
-0.2124673575,
0.6783878803,
-0.4251618683,
1.085100174,
0.0234852117,
-0.6727536917,
0.360326618,
-0.3888170421,
-0.3309990466,
0.1191940606,
-0.4430484176,
-0.0734551847,
0.0381522998,
-0.1852415502,
0.5150932074,
-0.4062503874,
0.0718552321,
-0.6713942885,
-0.2032916546,
0.4523179829,
-0.180329904,
0.6262849569,
0.0942856744,
-0.3395460248,
0.2947474718,
-0.696093142,
0.2455300838,
0.0449581891,
-0.3798683882,
-0.5159900188,
0.1187109426,
-0.2771512866,
0.2463799715,
0.603145659,
-0.4440059066,
-0.1721470803,
-0.307823956,
0.177527234,
1.0436242819,
-0.0814597011,
0.1895269603,
-0.2879296243,
0.2419076115,
-0.2193568498,
0.1784478873,
0.3377155066,
-0.2009974718,
-0.9904806614,
-0.2613839805,
0.0466946959,
0.4621968567,
-0.0297050923,
0.617833674,
-0.4676285684,
-0.6606304049,
-0.4666885734,
0.3523942232,
0.5095459223,
0.5401896834,
-0.0158311445,
-0.4185941219,
-0.4537932277,
-1.199328661,
-0.5651673079,
-0.6183273792,
0.0347119346,
0.4989984035,
0.5229626894,
-0.1907034814,
0.6938780546,
-0.1912244707,
-0.0204831958,
-0.3381516635,
-0.041150298,
-0.0472097434,
0.3794004619,
0.5329962969,
-0.5390219092,
-0.6672954559,
0.0238931198,
-1.0119063854,
0.0001074327,
0.273165226,
-0.147480011,
0.0503541082,
0.8770415187,
-0.4187209308,
0.212567836,
0.40211007,
-0.2214723378,
0.287389636,
-0.102261968,
-0.0978530049,
-1.1450132132,
0.2965092361,
0.0054488694,
-0.2955136299,
-0.5665262341,
-0.1507582217,
0.3757553995,
0.1663972586,
-0.2584519982,
0.7641012073,
-0.6036056876,
-0.5531588197,
-0.0984572545,
0.4015944302,
-0.2874496281,
0.2796655893,
-0.1258994788,
0.6550005674,
0.7597813606,
-0.3965486288,
0.322714895,
0.0236394852,
-0.8854754567,
0.8536502719,
-0.5736656785,
0.1547027826,
-0.1172953397,
0.1278852373,
-0.8455747962,
-0.4501125813,
-0.065139249,
-0.4360261261,
0.0793383643,
0.3198272586,
-0.6443164945,
-0.4791760147,
-0.1859917492,
0.181852892,
0.5538917184,
-0.2294631898,
0.875469625,
0.6128778458,
-0.0922387615,
-0.5420809388,
-0.5439556241,
-0.0050836103,
-0.2822803557,
-0.4612001777,
-0.1028715223,
-0.2903485298,
-0.8292697668,
-0.1523088962,
-0.2402108908,
0.1902047098,
0.5430012941,
0.5152294636,
0.0297983121,
-0.0280726664,
0.2904979587,
-0.5589962602,
-0.0045677591,
0.3271178305,
-0.059386,
0.5314706564,
-0.6294545531,
-0.6684633493,
-0.2453534454,
0.1040932164,
0.5710624456,
-0.4705917239,
0.6749724746,
0.5663973093,
-0.5760155916,
-0.1866983175,
-0.847571373,
-0.1355326623,
-0.4426324069,
0.4710738063,
-0.3227396011,
-0.968528986,
0.7494767904,
-0.1793196499,
0.1093443409,
0.3256510496,
0.7425674796,
-0.1222990826,
1.0942158699,
0.9210082889,
-0.6699252725,
0.4820470214,
0.0172735807,
0.3274158239,
-0.9479651451,
-0.0426753201,
-0.6294061542,
-0.6422291398,
-0.4094926715,
-0.4494641423,
0.5948266387,
-0.0708486512,
-0.7243904471,
0.0189163685,
-0.0528420843,
0.5712298155,
0.4420512617,
-0.1197448224,
0.1566450596,
-0.4288431704,
-0.0723406821,
0.1091361865,
-0.5019392371,
-0.6966901422,
1.0271431208,
0.4896274209,
0.8008656502,
0.2944051921,
0.5316283703,
0.1988737583,
0.6374647617,
-0.6710926294,
0.806415081,
0.1733114719,
-0.9247154593,
-0.2712415755,
-0.2432562113,
-0.5979090929,
0.1483873278,
-0.2591663301,
-1.1084442139,
0.0671730191,
-0.0018133949,
-0.2856616676,
0.1389005333,
-0.7713305354,
1.0332773924,
-0.4770724773,
-0.2917918563,
-0.6025471091,
-0.9674988985,
0.2989038229,
-0.1556518823,
0.3510428071,
-0.6278274059,
-0.0761766359,
0.671756804,
0.1022805795,
1.0828502178,
0.1091079414,
0.0992332473,
0.1979225725,
0.0682233945,
0.3933437765,
-0.1270837486,
-0.3049286604,
-0.035515096,
-0.3137851954,
-0.3809543848,
-0.3322531879,
0.837677002,
-0.9895647168,
-0.7451306581,
-0.3119316399,
-0.6065567732,
-0.5112957954,
0.5493313074,
-0.2727870643,
0.1053728759,
-0.6214879751,
0.2800051868,
0.8295736909,
0.0312181357,
0.2223893106,
0.8806945682,
-0.2723945975,
0.0663963035,
0.6731908321,
0.1703690439,
0.4382823706,
0.312394768,
0.1291068047,
-0.195672065,
-0.4362782538,
-0.1836432517,
0.2352377623,
-1.0949645042,
-0.0053981799,
-0.8336016536,
-0.2729044259,
-0.4428175688,
-0.1188094914,
-0.428445369,
-0.2308588624,
0.0973727629,
-0.2954086065,
0.3756432533,
0.7783061862,
-0.0317394882,
0.0750208423,
-0.4845424592,
0.1528441757,
0.4231642485,
0.6649137735,
0.1671048999,
-0.3136365414,
-0.3457827568,
-0.1089532524,
0.0110026998,
-0.4862109721,
0.0613217875,
0.1897256225,
1.0436733961,
0.6471416354,
0.1976954192,
0.4328526556,
-0.2175270766,
0.5000184178,
-0.2893784642,
-1.0555859804,
0.2984770536,
-0.23940745,
0.2306439281,
0.8081780076,
0.4241374731,
-0.6026864648,
-0.545558989,
-0.6603387594,
-0.5276659727,
0.3925215602,
-0.1617502272,
0.0294346474,
-0.0829393566,
0.1598872393,
-0.300489068,
0.2719474435,
-0.6362993121,
-0.1406790018,
0.0163448621,
-0.3396699131,
-0.433616668,
-0.2838276327,
-0.254127562,
-0.0566259585,
0.7023227215,
-0.2140600532,
-0.1106077954,
0.0401830189,
-0.1476152241,
-0.0321477801,
0.2957310677,
0.3418002725,
0.6487950087,
-0.2118896246,
0.5958360434,
0.4381051064,
-0.3423255384,
-0.1473446786,
-0.093315132,
0.2687060535,
-0.68836236,
0.5045784116,
0.4414076805,
0.1822727174,
-1.0643982887,
0.4301557243,
-0.2625872791,
-0.0343725458,
-0.4865971804,
0.2090040296,
0.6319440007,
0.4497119486,
-0.0104147438,
-0.0210511982,
-0.0347967222,
-0.6855435967,
-0.1255770326,
0.70965451,
-0.5596958399,
-0.1627313197,
0.5063622594,
0.3017965257,
-0.2002838105,
0.5931876898,
-0.0597824939,
-0.6627200842,
0.5970441103,
0.3362844586,
0.87632972,
-0.1100427434,
-0.3515059352,
0.332729727,
0.7191249728,
0.0044669015,
0.3963943422,
-0.0425766036,
-1.2246432304,
0.0555108115,
-0.6117116213,
-0.6062149405,
-0.1386203915,
-0.5006726384,
-0.0832202733,
-0.6864057779,
-0.2027672976,
0.2752667069,
0.1672604084,
-0.6634027362,
0.0019207754,
0.1255221814,
1.1219910383,
-0.8041201234,
0.8900123239,
0.8832011223,
-0.0142319873,
-0.968205452,
0.0539163984,
0.3605307639,
-1.1333395243,
0.4216954112,
0.4133467972,
-0.3696468174,
0.1124457568,
-0.4929938316,
-0.9186830521,
1.0260047913,
0.1638294458,
-0.3500093818,
0.5714623332,
0.0079372069,
0.7474746108,
-0.4492442906,
0.0101764146,
0.7729213238,
0.7051126361,
-0.4347142577,
-0.871512711,
-0.1210801229,
-0.5988841057,
-0.0590609461,
0.0727823898,
-0.9835814238,
0.6323137283,
-0.2425059229,
-0.293967694,
-0.1045962647,
0.4897339344,
0.0569222495,
0.2283151448,
0.6800136566,
0.5562035441,
0.945772171,
0.0439122729,
1.0618292093,
-0.5863711834,
-0.0223900378,
0.9796602726,
-0.9042234421,
0.9316546321,
0.3235199153,
-0.0705960467,
0.2976989746,
0.5219966769,
0.2935580611,
-0.0128771635,
0.3179348409,
-0.356897831,
-0.6149401069,
-0.4179689586,
-0.2006918192,
0.5002008677,
0.5490809679,
-0.2263212651,
-0.0177177452,
-0.2351417542,
-0.0678108707,
0.3422649205,
-0.3131864667,
1.0539107323,
0.0238841698,
-0.487002939,
0.5529620051,
-0.1317426711,
0.4245507419,
-0.6616048217,
0.4909966886,
-0.0637731627,
0.4787017703,
-0.024771018,
-0.8742992878,
0.2229566425,
0.1191319823,
-0.3028935194,
-0.167977199,
0.7483019233,
-0.2300005406,
-0.4439091384,
0.4696285129,
0.804207027,
0.321703434,
0.0461219512,
-0.5870511532,
0.2950953543,
-0.0002923879,
-0.2376829535,
0.5101001859,
0.4646698833,
-0.3788208663,
1.0147060156,
0.365447998,
-0.1221709549,
0.0057769539,
0.3380284309,
0.669139266,
-0.6427768469,
-0.2278956771,
-0.8863054514,
0.0997325704,
-0.2784677744,
-0.2835732996,
0.9828133583,
0.7447237968,
0.8443043828,
0.1216191128,
0.982216835,
-0.089445211,
0.8184017539,
0.0222732536,
0.9067935348,
-0.5140790343,
0.2328335941,
-0.2015752941,
-0.7929626703,
-0.1449905634,
0.7598276734,
-0.5618338585,
0.1812720448,
0.3201375306,
0.9122332335,
0.1168694124,
0.153459236,
0.4301511347,
0.5053426623,
0.2022991329,
0.390070349,
0.8919522166,
0.1520153433,
0.1596668214,
-0.2829531729,
-0.3666554987,
-0.2165717781,
-0.9221776724,
-1.0490778685,
-0.4988494813,
-0.0705780908,
-0.0312879942,
-0.0018368043,
1.0599968433,
0.6896931529,
-0.4781635702,
-0.5183031559,
0.1003712341,
0.2841786444,
-0.2759609818,
-0.1767812669,
0.1098602712,
-0.194210723,
-0.4411411881,
0.3029734492,
0.3628545702,
0.1724567562,
-0.4918321967,
0.0257427767,
-0.2727051377,
0.2140819877,
0.5672299862,
0.2461170554,
-0.5270678997,
-0.7043741345,
0.0803262591,
-0.3457618356,
-0.2085503042,
0.6793649197,
-0.5786764622,
0.4562531412,
0.4757827818,
0.5768159032,
0.3023368716,
-0.0120106749,
0.4768192172,
-0.6107628345,
0.0361103639,
0.1777784675,
0.5023229718,
0.4403321147,
-0.1052181721,
0.5275480151,
-0.1715418696,
-0.7121781707,
-0.7474321723,
0.2672846019,
-0.9990290403,
-0.1027868316,
0.9067785144,
-0.0654275641,
-0.262545526,
-0.1645363569,
0.0115753524,
0.1314615309,
-0.2913999557,
0.8252921104,
0.7631185055,
-0.0951657593,
-0.0451617613,
-0.7883028388,
0.3543271124,
0.4306567609,
-0.9305731654,
0.5179532766,
0.4837275147,
0.3994951248,
0.269787997,
0.7556800246,
0.0278051533,
0.1089323387,
0.0178476721,
0.3159194887,
0.3527465165,
-0.1283821613,
-0.0868480951,
-0.1296727061,
0.47199893,
0.3221957088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17858v1
|
Probing Language Models' Gesture Understanding for Enhanced Human-AI Interaction
| 2024-01-31T14:19:03 | 2024-01-31T14:19:03 |
Philipp Wicke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has affected various disciplines
that got beyond mere text generation. Going beyond their textual nature, this
project proposal aims to investigate the interaction between LLMs and
non-verbal communication, specifically focusing on gestures. The proposal sets
out a plan to examine the proficiency of LLMs in deciphering both explicit and
implicit non-verbal cues within textual prompts and their ability to associate
these gestures with various contextual factors. The research proposes to test
established psycholinguistic study designs to construct a comprehensive dataset
that pairs textual prompts with detailed gesture descriptions, encompassing
diverse regional variations, and semantic labels. To assess LLMs' comprehension
of gestures, experiments are planned, evaluating their ability to simulate
human behaviour in order to replicate psycholinguistic experiments. These
experiments consider cultural dimensions and measure the agreement between
LLM-identified gestures and the dataset, shedding light on the models'
contextual interpretation of non-verbal cues (e.g. gestures).
|
[
-0.2609639466,
-1.0599001646,
0.5890210271,
0.2481344789,
-0.197708264,
-0.005778783,
-0.2182670832,
-0.8228191733,
0.4295351207,
0.4196392,
-0.763512373,
-0.4664585292,
-0.6794726253,
0.2172858268,
-0.5575409532,
0.5816863775,
-0.0351256467,
0.3133171201,
-0.2602545619,
-0.0108118346,
-0.1433701664,
-0.5334474444,
-0.7966601253,
-0.6391913891,
0.5179054141,
0.4004301131,
0.6334547997,
0.2082085013,
0.3183383346,
0.2932480574,
-0.1705216318,
0.1000495628,
-0.2731924355,
-0.0831822827,
0.1137675568,
-0.4747511446,
-0.5803537369,
0.3709247112,
0.5499953032,
0.8723752499,
0.2723647356,
0.1179809421,
0.1672532409,
0.1433146,
-0.2198502868,
0.1120895892,
0.0016640568,
0.0625590608,
-0.2103387713,
-0.2426448017,
-0.4080893993,
-0.0989874229,
-0.0424732827,
-0.3035949469,
-0.0032684782,
0.1087035239,
0.5520892143,
0.1680343002,
-0.7142605186,
-0.1827497333,
-0.6217539907,
0.561480999,
-0.75726825,
0.458111316,
0.7433773875,
-0.0937065184,
-0.2498214543,
-0.5766831636,
-0.7944236398,
-0.6987347603,
-0.1150927469,
-0.0536988564,
0.0970705375,
0.1167220026,
0.2521040142,
-0.0187724829,
-0.6922914982,
0.37290892,
-0.0349967778,
-0.0824683011,
0.9491139054,
0.3436309695,
0.6243901253,
-0.3734922111,
-0.3144182265,
-0.0566723533,
-0.6876205802,
0.1755856872,
0.2917272747,
0.4556779563,
-0.6639854312,
0.6773014665,
-0.0836816356,
0.8611109257,
0.0310168732,
-0.0844438672,
0.1740365773,
-0.6122699976,
-0.3585546911,
-0.0942704156,
0.6865163445,
0.5339617133,
0.554199338,
-0.024558248,
0.0316829942,
-0.1832509339,
-0.0885932744,
-0.5185564756,
-0.0866996273,
0.3100162745,
-0.6756592989,
-0.24646236,
-0.0910974666,
-0.5794966817,
-0.6854359508,
-0.5190352798,
0.1798239797,
-0.2938491702,
-0.6981906891,
-0.0348533131,
-0.1994017959,
0.7202758789,
0.3526845276,
-1.0151722431,
0.0017848527,
0.7757990956,
0.7779009342,
-0.011329025,
-0.5647784472,
-0.2114235014,
0.2066753209,
-0.4136970639,
0.6452848911,
-0.8324791193,
-0.830403924,
-0.0941991955,
-0.1331203431,
-0.1602247357,
-0.3483833969,
0.5507280827,
-0.2058382034,
0.328920573,
-0.2651216686,
-0.53776896,
-0.12969248,
0.402279526,
-0.506146729,
1.0167819262,
-0.1838023216,
-0.5511165261,
0.3857389987,
-1.0626988411,
-0.6014878154,
0.2991210818,
-0.4174489677,
-0.0043682544,
0.1951897889,
0.092570819,
0.6284162998,
-0.2234856784,
0.312498033,
-0.263874352,
-0.3494673073,
0.5136454701,
-0.6284102798,
0.7636638284,
-0.09563227,
-0.3169877529,
0.4434115887,
-0.4012353718,
-0.124841623,
0.2447025925,
-0.1989755929,
-0.4045400918,
0.0769717097,
0.2425139695,
0.0866128281,
0.4136493206,
-0.4169156253,
0.3925337493,
-0.3996533155,
0.5252036452,
0.5138582587,
-0.0288847778,
0.6437481046,
-0.2516424358,
0.5982421637,
-0.3558934033,
0.1924594492,
-0.1080187485,
-0.5259367228,
-0.5390660167,
-0.2537780106,
-0.0487281345,
0.3583105803,
-0.6403335333,
0.2716943026,
-0.209425509,
-0.3433690667,
-0.324247092,
-0.0048838104,
0.3986882865,
0.4218070209,
-0.1248724014,
-0.0566763543,
-0.4099689722,
-0.7161144614,
-0.3114381433,
-0.5103996396,
-0.2371090502,
0.4120392203,
0.4235264063,
-0.0654564053,
0.8855107427,
-0.0120955128,
-0.0019206079,
-0.4673841894,
0.5520235896,
-0.0972128808,
0.0667151585,
0.6399106383,
-1.0195081234,
-0.2067199796,
-0.2719288468,
-0.7060806155,
-0.1280639768,
-0.0361607112,
0.1142831221,
0.3577388823,
0.7947417498,
-0.6267441511,
0.3963957131,
0.6831653714,
-0.7413093448,
0.4394313991,
-0.0436533839,
0.3954204321,
-1.1056642532,
-0.0236565266,
-0.0692970753,
-0.0232980289,
-0.9332633018,
0.004211029,
0.0627296045,
-0.0845728815,
-0.7527251244,
1.0208982229,
-0.5626578331,
-0.2287854105,
-0.504460454,
0.3571552634,
-0.2571355104,
0.1663430482,
0.5638065338,
0.8334835768,
0.5364807248,
-0.5909434557,
-0.0070837517,
0.234749794,
-0.2758540511,
0.8104413152,
-0.5378903747,
0.2633862793,
-0.0496169887,
0.1366559416,
-1.2642776966,
-0.4444206953,
0.2462550998,
-1.0101963282,
0.1127109006,
0.0696608573,
-0.4854901731,
-0.1788044274,
-0.3225290179,
0.2889514863,
0.2512851357,
-0.511520505,
0.9346184731,
0.3185906112,
-0.2703735828,
-0.4262128472,
-0.714630425,
0.5411422253,
-0.5354528427,
-0.7666861415,
-0.0563644134,
-0.0102808308,
-0.533921659,
-0.5819976926,
0.4167227447,
0.2194658518,
0.3877503872,
0.3322225213,
0.3913964927,
-0.0898534283,
-0.0710683987,
0.0322081521,
-0.0092870807,
0.3486166298,
0.1083088815,
0.7272220254,
0.1644216329,
-0.572075665,
-0.8105258942,
0.2500447035,
0.7163621187,
-0.1975465417,
0.5886847377,
0.5150893331,
-0.3316533267,
0.3313266635,
-0.1195753962,
-0.4596574008,
-0.508174777,
0.406362921,
-0.5272430778,
-0.8269318938,
0.3695920408,
-0.2221755981,
0.0970185921,
-0.1574710608,
0.7043091655,
-0.3463585377,
1.093012929,
0.6032565236,
-0.3615840673,
0.5688778162,
-0.116481334,
0.3312666118,
-0.8680979609,
-0.376865238,
-0.5345444083,
-0.6322077513,
-0.3982713521,
-0.6658818722,
0.1707857698,
-0.1194522306,
-0.067879647,
0.0230980851,
0.1319230795,
0.2970433533,
0.41796422,
-0.1602397263,
0.2667191923,
-0.1664987952,
-0.0733581632,
0.1593010575,
-0.2595830858,
-0.7707042098,
0.7864962816,
0.3461816013,
0.6443312168,
0.3212866485,
0.5339093804,
0.2876951396,
0.2077435404,
-0.8874856234,
0.8501594067,
0.1577783227,
-0.4538596869,
-0.5477556586,
-0.022202218,
-1.1105245352,
0.1238451153,
-0.2822834253,
-0.9428315163,
0.0003029704,
0.1044659466,
-0.0296463128,
0.1386416107,
-0.5076217055,
0.5045357943,
-0.4657813907,
-0.1986743808,
-0.2433443069,
-0.6327257752,
0.2749216259,
0.1729868799,
0.3312133849,
-0.1349413246,
-0.1422597617,
0.6439499855,
0.0772550181,
1.4157515764,
-0.3300149739,
-0.524620533,
-0.03595566,
0.3719132841,
0.2931194901,
-0.1245455146,
-0.1692557633,
0.3466274142,
-0.2475042492,
-0.3061250448,
-0.5459709764,
0.4955681562,
-0.688945353,
-0.4068606198,
-0.2707505524,
-0.8190250993,
-0.3473258913,
-0.1329104155,
-0.0337405875,
0.3456613123,
-0.5016377568,
-0.2140676677,
0.3943158984,
-0.1474482864,
0.5607697368,
0.9094380736,
-0.2918942869,
0.195796147,
0.5550515056,
-0.4755502343,
0.2946427464,
0.4730661213,
0.1805845946,
-0.6989334822,
-0.636287272,
-0.5315904021,
0.3324669003,
-0.3537606001,
0.2709010839,
-0.0976625979,
-0.0447517224,
-0.6967528462,
-0.1739864647,
0.2203219235,
-0.2889180779,
-0.3211805522,
-0.4834755063,
0.5838421583,
0.914618969,
-0.1304697692,
0.407127738,
-0.5780613422,
0.2760041058,
-0.1983901709,
-0.117368944,
0.0628871992,
-0.6174814701,
0.1873037964,
0.0172633901,
0.0474922806,
-0.8234661818,
0.3799293935,
0.1233524904,
0.451310128,
0.6824839115,
-0.1067827344,
0.5374767184,
-0.3555151224,
1.1645100117,
0.0492389612,
-0.8604632616,
0.5153218508,
-0.6993255615,
0.314204067,
0.1607021391,
0.4255599976,
-0.8378635049,
-0.604996264,
-0.4429113865,
-0.6853203177,
0.6489133239,
0.0514969379,
0.3946193755,
0.0332073234,
0.6525359154,
-0.1328800321,
-0.03707432,
-0.5501291752,
-0.2126639038,
0.4402561486,
-0.3768727481,
-0.4763757885,
-0.0991047397,
-0.0209946539,
-0.1179519072,
0.1601714045,
-0.1012146994,
0.0957413763,
-0.123183623,
-0.1288326383,
0.0842978358,
0.1085764915,
0.7706691027,
0.524466157,
0.2733453214,
0.2089978606,
0.1455620825,
-0.513643682,
0.0909797028,
-0.2054711431,
-0.0988170579,
-0.3252567649,
0.7217690945,
0.7909340858,
0.092117466,
-0.7516461015,
0.1957916021,
-0.2799417675,
-0.2281691432,
-0.3553172946,
-0.0246135835,
0.3828759491,
0.3448999822,
0.2058185637,
-0.4447871447,
0.1721530557,
-0.5876733065,
0.166246891,
0.6622024775,
-0.2562725842,
-0.4102853239,
0.4499595165,
0.4255453348,
-0.78124547,
0.8687146306,
-0.0081711495,
-0.3457635641,
0.6623172164,
0.4425148368,
0.667440176,
-0.3806173801,
0.4125450253,
0.1840116382,
0.1944146007,
0.2955934107,
0.5558563471,
-0.3752939403,
-0.7657966614,
-0.3472519517,
-0.3149549365,
-0.5549881458,
0.0077356696,
-0.6351979375,
0.4028210342,
-0.0356210507,
-0.1418459117,
-0.2062829882,
-0.1195861995,
-0.3632537723,
0.1435204744,
0.4487925768,
0.798899889,
-1.2713593245,
0.9326865673,
0.8528510332,
-0.2380134761,
-0.7397431135,
0.269148618,
0.302916944,
-1.191362977,
0.7497469783,
0.0335144922,
-0.406896323,
-0.0354784913,
-0.452783227,
-0.6456131935,
1.019182086,
0.3823419809,
-0.3518718481,
-0.0342248715,
0.5028244853,
0.5424559116,
-0.0329418369,
0.4590975344,
0.900154829,
0.7194551826,
0.1802555025,
-1.2166745663,
-0.0326168947,
-0.2138883621,
-0.2067021281,
0.3930559456,
-0.6258517504,
0.5740989447,
-0.3397207856,
-0.0505799465,
0.412407428,
0.8362205625,
0.4294002652,
0.5847902894,
0.3932975829,
0.2054135054,
0.8352389932,
-0.0047669699,
1.1178039312,
-0.2461222708,
-0.1053163409,
1.0276055336,
-0.4918672442,
1.1138589382,
0.7411654592,
-0.0849606171,
0.403714627,
0.9037749767,
0.3193634152,
0.1257282346,
0.3344318867,
-0.3951177001,
-0.0355163887,
-0.3358970582,
0.0598772615,
0.8296509385,
0.5285019875,
-0.2320653051,
-0.0802526101,
0.4062612355,
0.1690688431,
0.1557286978,
-0.3398329318,
0.828582108,
0.1485064477,
-0.504127264,
0.3109553158,
0.1448704451,
0.8334846497,
-0.6070350409,
0.1188781187,
-0.2416388541,
-0.1092172489,
-0.1100227386,
-1.0266968012,
0.2128599137,
-0.0463799052,
0.0965643078,
-0.3879764378,
0.6608614326,
-0.2881420255,
-0.465765059,
0.5766430497,
0.681147337,
0.7327439189,
0.1870741993,
-0.6566975713,
0.193069905,
-0.1765586287,
-0.1721767187,
0.4807826281,
0.184142977,
-0.3079686761,
0.5352318287,
0.265973717,
0.0580027178,
-0.0697842166,
0.5304583311,
0.2602029741,
-0.7357094884,
-0.2503725588,
-0.9355838299,
0.2562998533,
0.1359161288,
-0.2564150691,
0.7836444974,
0.2199192345,
0.6806686521,
0.082242839,
0.6194984913,
-0.0455080979,
0.1763059646,
-0.6773449779,
0.7153314948,
-0.5154417753,
-0.1735872924,
-0.135307759,
-0.5016698241,
-0.1304642111,
0.7996607423,
-0.4721152782,
0.361630559,
0.2597382069,
0.7711139917,
0.07923273,
0.3728326857,
0.5087749958,
0.1485668868,
0.2881492674,
0.4698223472,
1.0998408794,
0.1730404645,
-0.0382258669,
0.1828615814,
-0.323405385,
-0.0223130304,
-0.9987065196,
-1.1282898188,
-0.7737926841,
-0.2443769127,
0.1908302009,
-0.2155861855,
0.8282822967,
0.6951100826,
-0.4170115292,
-0.7326185703,
0.1724901795,
-0.2225880921,
-0.0586654656,
-0.2619623542,
0.2983927429,
0.0237454847,
-1.2077003717,
0.7178604603,
0.1255540252,
0.3936597705,
-0.4166633487,
-0.3225645721,
-0.153476879,
0.2855979204,
0.8555924892,
0.163477391,
-0.7848640084,
-0.30099684,
0.2163139582,
0.375898093,
-0.2817439437,
1.0124298334,
-0.6066544056,
-0.049976524,
0.5078892708,
0.3403943479,
0.1664497703,
0.165718928,
0.6484150887,
-0.8012772799,
0.3537498116,
0.0357363448,
0.273403883,
0.4112340808,
-0.4023947418,
0.211884141,
-0.2260889262,
-0.3024556637,
-0.7533529997,
0.4328681231,
-0.8820130825,
-0.3437974155,
1.2256029844,
0.175410822,
-0.0337124728,
-0.2284596264,
-0.4206852317,
0.1132081673,
-0.261621356,
0.6750681996,
0.7755861878,
-0.8146771789,
-0.2930010557,
-0.3069596887,
0.3409358263,
0.4626300037,
-0.8332232833,
0.2414808422,
0.5806157589,
0.1905401945,
-0.039403718,
0.894221127,
-0.0669233128,
0.0916349515,
-0.4710456729,
0.0234628301,
0.0720139369,
-0.3223987222,
-0.7076088786,
-0.158227846,
0.4976921678,
-0.1114751324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03366v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03366v1
|
Uncertainty-Aware Explainable Recommendation with Large Language Models
| 2024-01-31T14:06:26 | 2024-01-31T14:06:26 |
Yicui Peng, Hao Chen, Chingsheng Lin, Guo Huang, Jinrong Hu, Hui Guo, Bin Kong, Shu Hu, Xi Wu, Xin Wang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Providing explanations within the recommendation system would boost user
satisfaction and foster trust, especially by elaborating on the reasons for
selecting recommended items tailored to the user. The predominant approach in
this domain revolves around generating text-based explanations, with a notable
emphasis on applying large language models (LLMs). However, refining LLMs for
explainable recommendations proves impractical due to time constraints and
computing resource limitations. As an alternative, the current approach
involves training the prompt rather than the LLM. In this study, we developed a
model that utilizes the ID vectors of user and item inputs as prompts for
GPT-2. We employed a joint training mechanism within a multi-task learning
framework to optimize both the recommendation task and explanation task. This
strategy enables a more effective exploration of users' interests, improving
recommendation effectiveness and user satisfaction. Through the experiments,
our method achieving 1.59 DIV, 0.57 USR and 0.41 FCR on the Yelp, TripAdvisor
and Amazon dataset respectively, demonstrates superior performance over four
SOTA methods in terms of explainability evaluation metric. In addition, we
identified that the proposed model is able to ensure stable textual quality on
the three public datasets.
|
[
-0.2395794839,
-0.6721204519,
1.08675313,
0.0786490142,
-0.3283499479,
-0.279642731,
-0.3699520528,
-0.4015740156,
-0.2274326533,
0.1248288602,
-0.8998454213,
-0.3535451591,
-0.5632352233,
-0.0905456468,
0.0081200432,
1.4053257704,
-0.2971551418,
0.0177105665,
-0.1755842566,
-0.0032215582,
-0.6778796315,
-0.2690213025,
-0.9767288566,
-0.4485220313,
0.6157607436,
0.5560135245,
0.7775049806,
0.4189763069,
0.222925514,
0.1288874596,
0.0503024347,
0.3010899723,
-0.4512110651,
0.2077770233,
-0.5298643112,
-0.3972339928,
-0.2393175364,
-0.2941689193,
0.1856686324,
0.5071274042,
-0.2625178099,
0.0415345319,
0.2288978249,
0.6259480119,
-0.3171342909,
0.2668161988,
-0.3759188354,
-0.1863958985,
0.0572585277,
-0.0680202395,
-0.1705252975,
-0.2679036856,
0.6582767367,
-1.0875296593,
0.1695099771,
0.3531274199,
0.7095200419,
0.1704762429,
-0.2765841782,
-0.5066487193,
-0.8509808183,
0.6747608185,
-0.4190299213,
0.4798796773,
0.6546424031,
0.473264575,
-0.1725009233,
-0.4829728603,
-0.4864517748,
-0.0682742447,
-0.0874266773,
0.0885003433,
-0.1888665557,
-0.1145559996,
0.035084676,
0.1000270993,
-0.8925625086,
0.1583081037,
0.1441318989,
-0.254049927,
0.3352339864,
-0.0570578091,
-0.0038117634,
0.0115656126,
-0.549343884,
0.0853930041,
-0.6332284212,
0.2896613777,
0.3830848932,
0.276607722,
-0.0172429923,
0.4995140433,
-0.2151185572,
0.4705576003,
0.1780971289,
-0.1666561216,
-0.0291185305,
-0.4005594552,
-0.0696653053,
-0.2447106093,
0.83158952,
0.5410996079,
0.1783488691,
-0.2970579863,
-0.2052398026,
-0.1871189028,
0.0727480948,
-0.7507171631,
-0.0124077825,
0.517174542,
-0.4833672941,
0.0435037725,
0.0773485079,
-0.7626048326,
-0.6298376322,
-0.3621836007,
0.6603022218,
-0.5957597494,
-0.2882684171,
0.2102963179,
-0.0060344688,
-0.3323118985,
0.4815753698,
-0.9821395278,
0.048557654,
0.4680898786,
0.6476424932,
-0.1980106831,
-0.3160862923,
-0.4081196487,
0.1902014464,
-0.0616831295,
0.7648546696,
-0.4577735066,
-0.2584835887,
0.143766582,
-0.0224548839,
0.1920161843,
-0.1937947422,
0.5729612708,
-0.5767287612,
0.4258502126,
-0.6720421314,
-0.5153775811,
-0.6103597879,
0.1489111632,
-0.2827338278,
0.9557760954,
0.2362257689,
-0.4966420233,
0.6780673862,
-0.7970943451,
-0.2623735964,
0.0518519133,
0.0028927927,
-0.2990172207,
-0.0957306847,
0.7183912396,
0.6544360518,
-0.5322499871,
0.6155469418,
-0.3175752163,
-0.476375252,
0.2272200286,
-0.529497087,
0.3354901671,
0.2971271873,
-0.2956359982,
0.4254957736,
-0.4305004179,
-0.2215329409,
0.1964771152,
-0.1525578499,
-0.2369659692,
-0.0273544732,
0.0768889636,
0.0529709868,
0.3597983718,
-0.0428617261,
0.052430328,
-0.3891459107,
0.5414943695,
0.7809791565,
0.158870101,
0.4062134922,
-0.3639144301,
0.642246604,
0.0157218538,
0.0724021047,
-0.2861155272,
-0.3870295286,
-0.4444992542,
-0.0462840833,
0.0254503544,
0.3276304603,
-0.8763062358,
0.3397475183,
-0.2544202805,
-0.3701440096,
-0.260068506,
0.112298511,
0.3310466409,
0.3405367434,
0.4074263573,
0.0522021279,
-0.3549343348,
-0.5636746883,
-0.3557841182,
-0.2964447141,
-0.3266522884,
0.4478169084,
0.3435052037,
-0.263464272,
0.9158115387,
-0.4073327482,
-0.1093691811,
-0.3458961248,
0.2126575559,
0.3315115571,
0.0771613047,
0.3570607007,
-0.6752147675,
-0.4156406224,
-0.1180850863,
-0.4838469923,
0.1389979422,
-0.3518300951,
-0.0387500077,
-0.0569252856,
0.0812748894,
-0.5103141069,
0.1172526181,
0.3608168364,
-0.4506651759,
0.5572085977,
-0.5385647416,
0.2258450687,
-1.2452443838,
-0.263935715,
0.4171902537,
-0.2967420816,
-0.3624865711,
-0.1595537215,
-0.0970714614,
-0.0722520128,
-0.0780538917,
0.511828959,
-0.3118766546,
0.0502243713,
-0.2499216646,
0.1999510676,
0.082418479,
0.6585428119,
-0.0508466288,
0.8424689174,
0.7668249607,
-0.602406621,
0.2158203423,
0.1381050646,
-0.4220953882,
0.7520067692,
-0.850630939,
0.0927488729,
-0.1853344291,
0.4603543878,
-1.2588249445,
-0.3263707161,
0.3577775955,
-0.1611881852,
0.0599283278,
-0.2220745236,
-0.3074521124,
-0.3374972939,
-0.2352689505,
0.2765923142,
0.2737399638,
-0.7745650411,
0.5042241216,
0.0107226279,
-0.3655705452,
-0.6157556772,
-0.2382096499,
-0.1218411028,
-0.5199310184,
-0.4811494648,
0.4113661349,
-0.3144264817,
-0.0505864024,
-0.0501648709,
-0.2697730064,
-0.0255654231,
0.1232216805,
0.5675637126,
0.3471227586,
0.0282665603,
0.5822415948,
0.0138604203,
-0.2487284541,
0.0463344269,
-0.6786319613,
0.4301300347,
-0.2094219774,
-0.3255881965,
-0.6717696786,
0.3130421638,
0.4407568276,
-0.1085926741,
0.700894773,
1.0897678137,
-0.2710256875,
-0.1441440433,
-0.4281761348,
-0.3593328893,
-0.4434294403,
0.4562507868,
-0.5390365124,
-1.1633872986,
0.4298336208,
-0.1027250588,
-0.1337880045,
0.4278990328,
0.693441391,
-0.1831941158,
0.882589519,
0.5524300933,
-0.0486395806,
0.4559115469,
-0.0022052664,
0.3731980622,
-0.4848488867,
-0.2612680197,
-0.3841932416,
-0.1211028099,
-0.2630434334,
-0.3691736162,
0.3618761003,
0.2400497198,
-0.2142778635,
0.2188670486,
-0.4629858434,
0.3634728491,
0.7865606546,
0.3787129819,
0.1869740635,
0.1161811501,
-0.0461705029,
0.046370659,
-0.5538779497,
-0.4069259763,
1.0734629631,
0.5631996393,
0.7878393531,
0.1495686024,
0.2359181494,
0.3486244977,
-0.2342851311,
-0.8617508411,
0.1842104793,
0.0500729904,
-0.5060248971,
-0.5988140702,
-0.3318482041,
-0.7588689923,
-0.0719661787,
-0.3471283913,
-0.9184674025,
0.0960296318,
0.2285298705,
-0.7184257507,
-0.0558790527,
-0.7205654383,
0.7537487745,
-0.2874359787,
-0.3427009881,
-0.2959488034,
-0.5794723034,
-0.0194920022,
-0.2081882209,
0.2892513573,
-0.0917237923,
0.1635758728,
0.8339898586,
-0.3975997567,
0.5017220378,
-0.4096201956,
-0.0768482462,
0.1818510443,
0.0518463552,
0.9640728235,
0.3733573556,
-0.1870829463,
0.1351997107,
-0.2152680904,
-0.0551386587,
-0.788046062,
0.703941524,
-0.7701964378,
-0.5940172076,
-0.0841565877,
-0.8044252396,
-0.4753298163,
0.0514855497,
0.3425002396,
0.3671156764,
0.1456400454,
0.0119292568,
0.7015848756,
-0.2530604303,
0.3166124821,
0.4941570461,
-0.1951539665,
-0.2782510519,
0.9813092351,
0.0462227799,
-0.0927070305,
0.4281262457,
0.4371372163,
-0.7096711993,
-0.7851213217,
-0.4599009454,
0.0418753885,
-0.4883231223,
0.1202054098,
-0.5793393254,
0.3390298784,
-0.2602887154,
-0.1762928069,
-0.0242968854,
-0.3835391402,
-0.2651837766,
-0.2999564707,
0.6504846215,
0.7989173532,
0.1281585842,
0.716150105,
-0.3756032884,
0.4066986144,
0.4917327762,
0.6274823546,
-0.0628891513,
-0.6490515471,
-0.4636101127,
0.1418370903,
-0.004559515,
-0.853602767,
0.0738820806,
0.0608015135,
0.5616621375,
0.717653513,
0.1660900414,
0.6023094654,
-0.1609181613,
0.9010546803,
0.2256771922,
-0.8177734017,
0.6357922554,
-0.6103315353,
0.3125885129,
0.5147479773,
0.6334150434,
-0.3891002834,
-0.1440356821,
-0.305046916,
-1.0264216661,
0.8287049532,
0.0508961566,
-0.1525663733,
0.3406565785,
0.421346277,
0.6276512742,
0.1991015971,
-0.7045798898,
-0.2732289433,
-0.0785266235,
-0.3131177425,
-0.3717254996,
-0.7344017625,
-0.1424381733,
0.1586142927,
0.944085598,
-0.0763825104,
0.2872759104,
0.0310619585,
0.0273077879,
-0.2163352072,
0.5127897263,
0.6163973212,
0.9981514812,
-0.3127680123,
0.0139309019,
-0.0346765108,
-0.2223514616,
0.1306650937,
0.3653612137,
0.0456914641,
-0.1514713466,
0.0663986206,
1.0520117283,
-0.1575824618,
-0.4618242383,
0.4807241261,
-0.204672724,
-0.1885140091,
-0.161979273,
-0.056030333,
0.1704548001,
0.3864653707,
0.3908046186,
0.1992162317,
0.2807712257,
-0.3362689912,
-0.0552037694,
0.2711860836,
-0.7280119061,
-0.1663296819,
0.6388123035,
0.1241616234,
-0.1324250251,
0.339835614,
-0.2323666513,
-0.2906971276,
0.1013514474,
0.489991039,
0.744094789,
-0.0327837467,
0.4686431289,
0.2004312277,
0.2502058148,
-0.2909155786,
0.2185783982,
-0.1059561446,
-0.6786071658,
-0.3481635451,
-0.4174575806,
-0.511357069,
0.1459297538,
-0.6995985508,
0.0817045867,
-0.2579070032,
-0.1293894351,
0.0857421085,
-0.2263690531,
-0.7625144124,
0.2484943569,
-0.2482817322,
0.4206787646,
-0.8696804047,
0.5860105157,
0.7555785179,
-0.4330971241,
-1.1646075249,
0.1759720445,
0.1677633971,
-0.8743771315,
0.1263194233,
0.1403268725,
-0.0629897863,
-0.2292710245,
-0.2121375501,
-0.5743044019,
1.0874211788,
0.4790269136,
-0.6383023858,
0.0612410046,
-0.1198333129,
0.5425901413,
-0.2762790024,
0.5195856094,
0.3011828959,
0.5715526342,
0.1183621287,
-0.7609482408,
0.2102397233,
0.0718450323,
0.0886722729,
-0.0404749513,
-0.3336763382,
0.5515450239,
-0.4469390512,
0.0362262055,
-0.0958791226,
0.5695974231,
0.2837284505,
0.5001888275,
0.7556940913,
0.3659247756,
0.987955451,
-0.1737377495,
1.0970686674,
-0.0824500695,
0.3272584975,
1.4373258352,
-0.0839723945,
0.6460106373,
0.567720592,
-0.3037834466,
0.6319941282,
1.0981264114,
0.0490135662,
0.6123276949,
-0.0565551259,
-0.047062356,
-0.306684494,
-0.3761226833,
-0.3385087848,
0.1485602111,
0.3023136556,
-0.4527460337,
-0.0869518965,
0.3386143148,
-0.0273671132,
-0.1279388964,
-0.2544855475,
0.8201242685,
-0.1322896481,
-0.7969032526,
0.3409382999,
0.0619602948,
0.5418220162,
-0.7115556002,
-0.0256926697,
0.0255447514,
0.0254589431,
-0.1089653894,
-0.7769083977,
-0.1875222474,
-0.0229117423,
-0.6545578837,
-0.4368409216,
0.584546864,
-0.539003551,
-0.3749570847,
0.1324905455,
0.4704796076,
0.2474489808,
-0.3811832666,
-0.6846609116,
-0.2844105959,
0.1432599127,
-0.2878488004,
0.1944167167,
0.5851736069,
-0.1019678935,
0.9225386977,
0.6576883793,
-0.0946688652,
-0.5265417695,
0.1491936445,
0.5141295195,
-0.2131444663,
-0.6644507051,
-0.7511530519,
0.5117010474,
0.2430000901,
-0.2671689987,
0.6690319777,
0.1914672554,
0.5999848247,
-0.2085819095,
0.9283027649,
0.1387613863,
0.589061141,
-0.4850341678,
0.4369694293,
-0.5310640931,
0.6818681359,
-0.1998731345,
-0.9796202183,
0.0412136652,
0.4603026211,
-0.3550702333,
0.3401079178,
0.9105747342,
0.6629040837,
0.0836651623,
0.1239320412,
0.0841744021,
0.1423764676,
0.2087767571,
0.5887477994,
0.6266260743,
-0.216079548,
0.7655476332,
-0.0432757661,
-0.1976926327,
-0.3790789843,
-0.8072046041,
-0.7746965289,
-0.5973702669,
-0.3579130769,
-0.3819090724,
0.3436642885,
1.0880943537,
0.8355588317,
-0.8354547024,
-0.0515077375,
-0.1718433946,
0.2892757356,
-0.6514754295,
-0.2117071748,
0.553689599,
-0.0936844051,
-0.4893304408,
0.4712267518,
0.194032982,
0.0887881145,
-0.2157960087,
-0.30430004,
0.1189725175,
-0.1866586655,
0.2852984369,
-0.1016122103,
-0.9014701843,
-0.4182912707,
-0.0919283181,
0.1337538064,
-0.2409506142,
0.6434417963,
-0.4905835688,
0.7217124701,
0.2606920302,
0.5430876017,
0.4887982905,
0.0860757232,
0.9204714298,
-0.6360480785,
-0.155968681,
-0.1372958124,
0.4309628606,
0.1354705095,
-0.758680284,
0.4429893792,
-0.0729631931,
-0.7904891372,
-0.338383466,
0.1390670091,
-1.2441357374,
-0.294613868,
1.345212698,
-0.5742637515,
0.2952349186,
-0.3964449465,
-0.3998222649,
0.2272078246,
-0.8626922369,
0.8013390899,
0.964479208,
-0.0434931926,
-0.1085886136,
-0.3765811622,
0.4866491854,
0.364092648,
-0.6796140075,
0.2478940785,
0.475499779,
0.3234846294,
-0.1711146086,
0.4945454001,
0.3437229097,
0.3412171304,
-0.2750068307,
-0.1405581981,
-0.3312596381,
-0.4945971072,
-0.4212956727,
0.2645374238,
0.4113262892,
-0.0592739731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17839v1
|
Global-Liar: Factuality of LLMs over Time and Geographic Regions
| 2024-01-31T13:57:24 | 2024-01-31T13:57:24 |
Shujaat Mirza, Bruno Coelho, Yuyuan Cui, Christina Pöpper, Damon McCoy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
The increasing reliance on AI-driven solutions, particularly Large Language
Models (LLMs) like the GPT series, for information retrieval highlights the
critical need for their factuality and fairness, especially amidst the rampant
spread of misinformation and disinformation online. Our study evaluates the
factual accuracy, stability, and biases in widely adopted GPT models, including
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, contributing to reliability and integrity of AI-mediated
information dissemination.
We introduce 'Global-Liar,' a dataset uniquely balanced in terms of
geographic and temporal representation, facilitating a more nuanced evaluation
of LLM biases. Our analysis reveals that newer iterations of GPT models do not
always equate to improved performance. Notably, the GPT-4 version from March
demonstrates higher factual accuracy than its subsequent June release.
Furthermore, a concerning bias is observed, privileging statements from the
Global North over the Global South, thus potentially exacerbating existing
informational inequities. Regions such as Africa and the Middle East are at a
disadvantage, with much lower factual accuracy. The performance fluctuations
over time suggest that model updates may not consistently benefit all regions
equally.
Our study also offers insights into the impact of various LLM configuration
settings, such as binary decision forcing, model re-runs and temperature, on
model's factuality. Models constrained to binary (true/false) choices exhibit
reduced factuality compared to those allowing an 'unclear' option. Single
inference at a low temperature setting matches the reliability of majority
voting across various configurations. The insights gained highlight the need
for culturally diverse and geographically inclusive model training and
evaluation. This approach is key to achieving global equity in technology,
distributing AI benefits fairly worldwide.
|
[
-0.0013455827,
-0.6447061896,
0.8781231046,
0.0911957249,
-0.003577474,
0.2371389717,
-0.049584657,
-0.6099333763,
-0.1393214911,
0.1394149363,
-0.301759541,
-0.4539743364,
-0.7626855969,
-0.0257663596,
-0.3941935897,
1.1403342485,
0.055417303,
0.0292498227,
-0.1681934148,
-0.2660948038,
-0.2506145537,
-0.881911695,
-0.3236586154,
-0.5029335618,
0.3300039172,
0.0684629232,
1.2259362936,
0.6269360781,
0.5901805758,
0.3234096766,
-0.1023278087,
0.0460941419,
-0.5025908351,
-0.0595622547,
-0.2363016605,
-0.6582325101,
-0.3788520098,
0.2432740182,
0.6471453905,
0.4893890321,
-0.2868810594,
0.3012675643,
-0.0509278588,
0.4825451374,
-0.4789972007,
0.1855262518,
-0.7669818401,
-0.0928502008,
-0.0792963281,
0.1365741789,
-0.1973869652,
-0.8218182325,
0.474730432,
-0.3100879788,
0.6602140069,
0.0110567641,
0.9527539611,
0.389387846,
-0.7140818834,
-0.5313242674,
-1.1307975054,
0.7349298,
-0.6193518043,
0.2022084445,
0.1658835262,
0.3884364069,
0.0648786351,
-0.7119261622,
-0.4647418559,
-0.4557659626,
-0.0253476202,
0.1240725666,
-0.1028951481,
-0.1312446892,
0.2840627432,
0.3381495476,
-0.5736755729,
-0.0279696472,
-0.4537970424,
-0.5137480497,
0.5182837844,
0.0739585385,
0.4063329697,
-0.0739674792,
-0.3437290192,
0.4475595951,
-1.0800285339,
-0.2128193974,
0.6234859228,
0.3687420189,
-0.3712487817,
0.5427438617,
-0.0270025693,
0.4246244133,
-0.2907676101,
-0.5079159737,
-0.0407013334,
-0.4918702841,
-0.0788487047,
0.060547296,
0.4071714282,
0.2994093597,
0.01336494,
-0.349152267,
-0.1299815476,
0.3544006348,
0.0175811835,
-0.7017774582,
-0.0528525785,
0.0135768736,
-0.323668927,
-0.0054594167,
0.352607131,
-0.544582963,
-0.3882910907,
-0.5438529253,
0.2068562806,
-0.0670857653,
-0.1315218657,
-0.1318061948,
0.0918343887,
0.1864489913,
0.3645048141,
-0.6409178376,
0.2036313564,
0.7269334793,
1.0867761374,
-0.0782597661,
-0.118830286,
-0.0483871028,
0.1331292093,
-0.2788264751,
0.6050004959,
-0.5826277733,
-0.2297486961,
-0.0737224743,
-0.0435270146,
0.0955447778,
-0.4825874865,
0.5579095483,
-0.6773205996,
0.4405616522,
-0.8164777756,
-0.2160392404,
-0.2684801817,
0.2756263316,
-0.6964502335,
0.8054840565,
-0.1094700694,
-0.7202786803,
0.3506896794,
-0.586591661,
-0.0761117116,
-0.2877066135,
-0.3542987704,
-0.307122618,
-0.0228288565,
0.3709893525,
0.1270204931,
-0.4025619924,
0.6918497086,
-0.2868850231,
-0.6848883033,
0.0754177123,
-0.9987846017,
0.8494248986,
0.084062174,
-0.6995546222,
-0.167416811,
-0.4836174548,
-0.2482308447,
0.2058174163,
-0.2927405238,
0.0090383003,
0.0619768836,
-0.4598069191,
0.1763846278,
0.2821517289,
-0.6026639342,
0.2520634532,
-0.2637416124,
0.3112601638,
0.9700993299,
-0.1357702017,
0.3677253723,
-0.5981677771,
0.583173275,
-0.0608396046,
0.2581281662,
0.1933714002,
-0.5901712179,
-0.6814967394,
-0.1376914233,
0.3254779875,
0.9214165211,
-0.6711520553,
-0.0436354429,
-0.5881491899,
-0.4930537641,
-0.5001708865,
-0.1972073913,
0.2235050946,
0.495531261,
0.0929383561,
0.1126448512,
-0.3154808581,
-0.9952688813,
-0.2101034969,
-0.3807999492,
-0.0228277203,
0.3558263183,
0.6321067214,
-0.1938984245,
1.1657065153,
-0.2229929119,
-0.011526403,
-0.0278932378,
0.160036087,
0.4186686575,
-0.0909173265,
0.6042827964,
-0.9308493137,
-0.2903478444,
-0.1519547254,
-0.891834259,
0.0045420486,
-0.0668072924,
0.2250296324,
0.6368104815,
-0.0860386267,
-0.5740702748,
0.6143867373,
0.747389555,
-0.3958641291,
0.7715038657,
-0.1592916995,
0.3283438087,
-0.6572373509,
0.1414378434,
0.0099773621,
-0.2606003582,
-0.2772987187,
0.0213661753,
-0.2115000039,
0.0518364981,
-0.4145055413,
0.6733207107,
-0.4245746732,
-0.3918824494,
-0.0557278879,
0.3180043995,
-0.1676609367,
0.1055046096,
-0.4501715899,
1.1811300516,
0.2394703776,
-0.4506052136,
0.6074706912,
0.030354498,
-0.4211987853,
0.3183145225,
-0.6739726067,
0.164078787,
-0.2615194023,
0.3856189847,
-0.698661387,
-0.160764873,
0.2498838156,
-0.4312621355,
0.0728740022,
-0.3439882398,
-0.5622125864,
-0.2182333767,
0.036022231,
0.2545021474,
0.4250152111,
-0.6232312918,
0.5205432177,
0.2741447091,
-0.438468039,
-1.0167555809,
-0.6709256768,
0.2696041465,
-0.1901084185,
-0.7560093999,
0.163043499,
-0.0271332096,
-0.5793585181,
0.1947873533,
-0.3167361021,
0.1830072254,
0.0113500189,
0.1202634126,
0.4184542894,
-0.1195533201,
0.0400866456,
-0.5522990823,
-0.1299756467,
0.1734024286,
-0.345364809,
0.3224892318,
-0.5217623711,
-0.6837574244,
-0.2773812115,
0.1994403899,
0.4432875812,
0.0241338816,
0.9085803032,
0.6572961211,
-0.2976467609,
0.2319035083,
-0.6808116436,
-0.119442448,
-0.4366517961,
0.3935039639,
-0.0638061017,
-0.8605105877,
0.7411657572,
0.1033262834,
0.0982024744,
0.4067749381,
0.4814448357,
0.1571784168,
0.8604160547,
0.7356032133,
-0.5056176186,
0.085118793,
-0.1746761054,
0.4928283691,
-0.3281654119,
-0.3467111588,
-0.5364481211,
-0.3020665944,
-0.8797460198,
-0.4265957475,
0.6095930934,
-0.2721078992,
-0.7121017575,
-0.7181769609,
-0.2074298263,
0.7340524793,
0.6419007778,
0.12106888,
0.4629328847,
0.289824754,
-0.2274174243,
-0.4297358096,
-0.66480124,
-0.7833091617,
1.219024539,
0.3336220384,
0.864807725,
0.552493453,
0.125196889,
0.5130654573,
0.6469370723,
-0.448713094,
0.3412359059,
-0.186452806,
-0.8126853108,
-0.1535497904,
-0.4907938242,
-0.5363754034,
0.0895206556,
-0.0042593945,
-0.6322436929,
-0.1378925294,
0.0817224309,
-0.2273295969,
0.7045057416,
-0.4589708745,
0.4373078644,
-0.4641367793,
-0.3167175353,
-0.113703832,
-0.7542830706,
0.5556584001,
0.0097169271,
0.2157492787,
-0.3594249189,
-0.1261047274,
0.316668123,
-0.2412727475,
1.076482892,
-0.2890293896,
-0.055796206,
0.2693893313,
0.0478189215,
0.598256886,
0.2196144313,
-0.3359327018,
0.5273028612,
-0.336261481,
-0.4970575571,
-0.6051751375,
0.6767293215,
-1.1896845102,
-0.8155537844,
-0.9110632539,
-0.5016140938,
-0.027137449,
0.1061767712,
0.2872260511,
0.6466199756,
-0.2323939353,
0.0040409113,
0.7277562022,
-0.2612730265,
0.1206207052,
0.4152840674,
-0.2588563561,
-0.3094639778,
0.820560813,
0.3865034878,
0.4084336758,
0.1220197529,
0.1530047804,
-0.5118379593,
-0.4832401276,
-0.2070810199,
0.5290357471,
-0.9535139799,
-0.0517286249,
-0.2700437009,
-0.4640117586,
-0.228391245,
-0.0225342754,
-0.2211892158,
-0.2733193636,
-0.0585838296,
-0.210169673,
0.2367780358,
1.0585798025,
-0.2338553071,
0.4286192954,
-0.4834910929,
0.3844569623,
0.2147021294,
0.3232813478,
-0.2929340303,
-0.6632357836,
-0.1014842764,
0.277995497,
-0.3213183582,
-0.7809565067,
0.2299130112,
0.0867084563,
0.7085428834,
0.0148387942,
0.0463506989,
0.5868728161,
-0.4462582171,
1.065862298,
-0.2345149666,
-0.8775768876,
0.3963901103,
-0.4923422933,
0.3269706964,
0.1392046809,
0.6916851401,
-0.590780735,
-0.4519816935,
-0.6772087216,
-0.8818085194,
0.5060483217,
-0.0611352399,
0.1418882757,
0.3016685545,
0.589558363,
0.1891702414,
0.29798612,
-1.0253148079,
-0.5772711039,
-0.1045201868,
-0.0894745141,
0.0443530194,
-0.4980697036,
-0.2942684591,
0.0349002369,
0.8888489008,
-0.3251425922,
0.545065999,
0.3514562547,
-0.0942585692,
0.1575397104,
0.3009497523,
0.6079417467,
1.3578346968,
-0.1608891189,
-0.0643596873,
0.0823532268,
-0.475053221,
0.3297308087,
0.0808245093,
-0.730004251,
0.2018706053,
0.4026751518,
0.6937226653,
-0.1314480156,
-0.1827235222,
0.4283815324,
-0.2805474401,
0.0544625148,
-0.5362419486,
-0.1342198253,
-0.0804585367,
0.393568486,
0.4817095101,
0.3753184974,
-0.0057254438,
-0.5714714527,
0.0187936705,
0.5180711746,
-0.0846986696,
-0.3560906351,
0.7989737391,
0.0690360367,
0.1169596836,
1.0111544132,
-0.3168408573,
-0.7636081576,
0.6140160561,
0.5254741907,
0.4857506156,
-0.1679762602,
0.4661834538,
0.2337163091,
0.8090875149,
-0.1545434445,
0.3330849707,
0.4637643397,
-0.7053591013,
-0.5220510364,
-0.3710622489,
-0.5650487542,
0.1778317839,
-0.3307621181,
-0.0275302157,
-0.4591103792,
-0.4664982557,
-0.7267889977,
0.3348922133,
-0.8440830112,
0.1607665569,
0.3732548654,
0.6746828556,
-0.9321420789,
0.4969049692,
0.4480143189,
-0.0952045321,
-0.5199787617,
0.3008785248,
0.5683722496,
-0.8504324555,
0.5034796596,
0.1468739212,
-0.1516927928,
-0.3843871951,
-0.7315416932,
-1.33893466,
1.2526518106,
0.8601915836,
-0.4064002633,
-0.1981832385,
0.4708256423,
0.4074248075,
-0.1593075693,
0.3592799306,
0.6675307155,
0.4684171677,
0.1716235727,
-1.1175489426,
0.0547989346,
0.1572322249,
0.0536307171,
-0.1289686561,
-0.9951834679,
0.7516778708,
-0.5782983899,
-0.4218581319,
0.0484082773,
0.7179416418,
0.4503365159,
0.1689180732,
0.229432568,
0.342154175,
1.2097351551,
-0.5380615592,
1.1426372528,
-0.1838053316,
0.336789012,
1.0966063738,
-0.3552214205,
0.4471279681,
0.0124909682,
-0.3518068492,
0.4991231859,
0.592366755,
0.0141783208,
0.3889641166,
-0.0250166841,
-0.4017383158,
-0.0005810859,
-0.2078760266,
-0.4336127341,
0.3912942111,
0.395231396,
0.0232677367,
-0.3573487401,
-0.3185532093,
0.3369445205,
-0.0271289833,
-0.3061496913,
0.238766849,
0.0264527183,
-0.4589678943,
0.2385176569,
0.073912181,
0.6974223852,
-0.57679528,
0.1288750917,
-0.5059531331,
0.0887857154,
-0.136556074,
-0.6366310716,
0.416223526,
0.1321619302,
-0.3526865244,
0.0772497356,
0.573690474,
-0.2684511542,
-0.7375854254,
0.192191273,
0.6051607132,
0.0223895013,
0.053356126,
-0.9031674862,
0.2555532455,
0.1330266893,
-0.1224212348,
-0.0096348468,
0.4244899452,
-0.1821158975,
1.0115312338,
0.5335116386,
0.4781994522,
0.1858469993,
-0.0231659655,
0.5030947328,
-0.6530128121,
-0.4305968583,
-1.0077219009,
0.3624762595,
-0.0644699335,
0.1114156097,
0.7423107028,
0.3827520013,
0.7797365785,
0.3907188773,
1.2590100765,
0.0803359151,
0.5845541954,
-0.7075063586,
0.6174581647,
-0.2418278009,
0.543019712,
0.1661500484,
-1.0307044983,
-0.2520019412,
0.3363188803,
-0.6236753464,
0.4248279333,
0.5366080999,
0.6272995472,
0.0087876599,
0.1487986445,
0.0752086565,
0.5715540051,
0.6774650216,
0.2756848931,
0.8730722666,
-0.3315950334,
0.4601177871,
-0.0875069797,
-0.1551996768,
-0.1084138602,
-1.0741560459,
-0.4096210897,
-0.1437436491,
-0.2126558125,
-0.4254362285,
0.3032856286,
0.79542768,
0.5425131321,
-0.6033662558,
-0.0512150154,
0.6010894775,
0.33821854,
0.2311686873,
-0.2246248424,
0.5192064643,
-0.0481262617,
-0.583250165,
0.0613207966,
0.1450748444,
0.2358240485,
-0.3808114231,
-0.0175423436,
0.0613083616,
-0.031776391,
0.4706219733,
0.1805962771,
-1.0182188749,
-0.46993348,
-0.1797611117,
-0.1204464585,
0.0930600241,
0.500672996,
-0.7784807682,
0.202655822,
0.071725212,
0.5686789751,
0.096934177,
0.219358936,
0.6937839985,
-0.7561519742,
0.1536387056,
0.2622733414,
0.333085984,
0.6627213955,
-0.414227277,
0.5718291998,
0.5729913116,
-1.0493299961,
-0.5865516663,
0.1328862607,
-0.3450228572,
-0.0825504959,
1.1693140268,
-0.0975440368,
-0.0813825577,
-0.2833790183,
0.0458238684,
0.1389057934,
-0.3304430246,
0.9537094831,
0.9500431418,
-0.1034529656,
0.2430067658,
-1.0943646431,
0.3671304286,
0.1045877188,
-0.5960913301,
-0.0265705865,
0.7430182695,
0.5375084877,
0.1270813048,
0.7278833389,
-0.1165026426,
0.0371376611,
-0.10707248,
-0.2953093946,
0.1500967145,
-0.6160306334,
-0.2927562892,
0.0427079648,
0.0561941117,
0.2840610147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01765v1
|
LLMs Simulate Big Five Personality Traits: Further Evidence
| 2024-01-31T13:45:25 | 2024-01-31T13:45:25 |
Aleksandra Sorokovikova, Natalia Fedorova, Sharwin Rezagholi, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; J.4; I.2.1
|
An empirical investigation into the simulation of the Big Five personality
traits by large language models (LLMs), namely Llama2, GPT4, and Mixtral, is
presented. We analyze the personality traits simulated by these models and
their stability. This contributes to the broader understanding of the
capabilities of LLMs to simulate personality traits and the respective
implications for personalized human-computer interaction.
|
[
-0.6316789389,
-0.7190846801,
0.8842812181,
0.4706115723,
0.1205296144,
0.0924777538,
-0.2692978084,
-0.4686154723,
0.4235712886,
0.709641099,
-0.618067205,
-0.4093701839,
-0.4655858278,
0.2455804497,
-0.3882219493,
0.8027456999,
0.1544166654,
0.2400209457,
-0.2604925632,
-0.1097270027,
-0.4064975083,
-1.1739100218,
-0.6287091374,
-0.5979180932,
0.6960131526,
0.5059782267,
0.6540614367,
0.0372087657,
0.5094431043,
0.3359813988,
-0.1428913176,
-0.0724768937,
-0.6592928171,
0.2133997381,
-0.002259996,
-0.5428565741,
-0.6443140507,
0.2899942398,
0.7317509055,
0.6042956114,
-0.3850058615,
0.1276337802,
-0.1301331371,
0.3332090378,
-0.0550806373,
-0.0472108312,
-0.287492007,
-0.2246086448,
-0.0354744084,
0.015292692,
-0.4287426174,
-0.4174864292,
0.1141752899,
-0.2009875476,
0.0955482498,
0.1291875541,
0.7317785025,
0.0825764984,
-0.6566819549,
-0.1764312983,
-1.0558917522,
0.8724754453,
-0.8408164382,
0.0367898718,
0.5664112568,
0.5377238989,
-0.3877331614,
-0.4943960309,
-0.9305568933,
-0.2933770418,
-0.0618204772,
0.1251512915,
0.2116378993,
0.2717382908,
0.3551438749,
0.3961657882,
-0.2374756783,
0.3778110445,
-0.4340497553,
-0.0221259035,
0.9204103351,
0.4760692716,
0.2578856647,
0.3034570515,
-0.0220013,
-0.2115995437,
-0.9465814829,
-0.1652291715,
0.6671491861,
-0.2969582379,
-0.1400766075,
0.7127268314,
-0.0721535608,
0.2733349502,
0.2131794095,
-0.6852409244,
0.2941074073,
-0.265893966,
-0.2320881039,
0.0817597955,
0.5322583914,
0.5347873569,
0.5107575059,
-0.0052377349,
-0.0110170525,
0.2220748514,
0.1833554208,
-0.9447396398,
-0.2312746942,
0.6755267978,
-0.6820943356,
-0.4116794467,
-0.2300492823,
-0.545016408,
-0.5450108647,
-0.2263332456,
0.0161100272,
-0.5341048241,
-0.3438356221,
-0.1177480221,
-0.2225904316,
0.4946797192,
0.4067306519,
-1.1291205883,
0.6317014694,
0.6095211506,
0.476857245,
-0.2911799848,
-0.558178246,
-0.1907069683,
0.0253980439,
-0.2555282414,
0.52310431,
-0.8138434291,
-0.6861786842,
-0.0392762907,
-0.1336458176,
0.3521517217,
-0.5874818563,
0.4232547879,
-0.4947041869,
0.1837999523,
-0.8045473099,
-0.6936722398,
-0.0922317728,
0.4295460284,
-0.5115044713,
0.8648632765,
0.1067302227,
-0.643619597,
0.405231148,
-0.6230224967,
-0.1959775537,
-0.3149451017,
-0.2973448038,
-0.4942633808,
0.0717126206,
-0.1294498146,
0.7183192372,
-0.2071061879,
0.0505927876,
-0.8778704405,
-0.6233481765,
0.7099730968,
0.1618188322,
0.6213683486,
0.0347122662,
-0.0543699116,
0.2276088595,
-0.7929784656,
-0.2368753105,
0.3192121387,
-0.472935468,
-0.1439869404,
0.3121575117,
-0.0091197435,
0.3257197142,
0.192740351,
-0.7104310393,
0.599927783,
0.0929870605,
0.3154158592,
0.6976519823,
0.124367483,
0.2390537858,
-0.4629696906,
0.5938332677,
0.1692522764,
-0.118900612,
0.081013009,
-0.6354689002,
-0.7873405814,
-0.4677520692,
0.1146289259,
0.4477401674,
-0.1603313237,
0.3888977468,
-0.1416889727,
-0.4628506303,
-0.2769563496,
0.2459379286,
0.2990385294,
-0.2242398113,
0.0646456927,
-0.3049587011,
-0.6810078025,
-0.8339374065,
-0.1582999825,
-0.1815342605,
-0.2404843867,
0.2497175038,
0.5891216993,
-0.544927299,
0.9199402928,
-0.2413164973,
0.1890898049,
-0.5119595528,
0.117884323,
-0.0550761782,
0.1129273623,
1.0464203358,
-0.5204567313,
-0.1975997239,
-0.2636454999,
-0.5776959062,
-0.3026167154,
0.1405494213,
0.246906653,
0.0382495411,
0.340898335,
-0.6080238223,
0.2702566385,
0.8309621215,
-0.4046318233,
1.0223232508,
-0.1555382162,
0.0120834671,
-0.9606134892,
0.0792835951,
0.0325094648,
-0.1213065162,
-0.7015909553,
-0.1416918933,
-0.1009193882,
0.0972073451,
-0.0392576829,
0.6172416806,
-0.3940359354,
-0.5827746391,
-0.2355938852,
-0.0269553233,
-0.14603284,
0.2141416371,
0.0583651997,
1.0040625334,
0.2619806528,
-0.6474743485,
0.4925420582,
0.2585081458,
-0.1384640336,
0.7624002695,
-0.7556857467,
0.2535420656,
-0.2157107145,
0.4057205617,
-1.1721893549,
-0.7425299883,
-0.2560602427,
-0.3628690243,
0.0095213139,
0.0131156389,
-0.7375981212,
-0.3572238386,
-0.5459849238,
-0.0395555533,
0.8128269911,
-0.4616912305,
0.6930373311,
0.3343777955,
-0.3998734951,
-0.0554924309,
-0.580462873,
0.1234472468,
-0.6454181671,
-0.4649662673,
0.2910988033,
-0.4621328115,
-0.7906162143,
-0.4422623217,
0.504530251,
0.1270719618,
0.1451732069,
0.3466448784,
0.2532294095,
-0.1000467017,
-0.2914871275,
0.114693746,
0.3291645348,
0.2460387945,
0.1293019354,
0.6053060889,
-0.2544565201,
-0.3244879842,
-0.4791760147,
0.1518961787,
0.8068976998,
0.0852677375,
0.8441768289,
0.568428576,
0.0023604357,
-0.0186670851,
-0.7409676313,
-0.334177196,
-0.5241626501,
0.2545307279,
-0.4282457232,
-1.0834116936,
0.9694892168,
-0.1728332341,
0.1688635796,
-0.0539698228,
1.063129425,
-0.2627767324,
1.2241050005,
0.697630465,
-0.0539509803,
0.3444012702,
0.1381569356,
0.11844486,
-0.9711760879,
-0.2098615468,
-0.2711920142,
-0.5918837786,
-0.7219768763,
-0.2917993069,
0.3288109601,
-0.3485223651,
-0.5435341597,
-0.2004570216,
-0.0167118814,
0.3896538913,
0.4682950079,
-0.1202156544,
0.1807034314,
-0.0577360392,
-0.3636938334,
-0.0407132171,
-0.1695463359,
-0.7428935766,
1.1669608355,
0.5874463916,
0.9464682937,
0.4866597056,
0.612939775,
0.1324424297,
0.5039699078,
-0.4380936623,
0.7487145066,
0.0419047438,
-0.7979441285,
-0.3860658407,
-0.3008820117,
-0.7029357553,
0.0658125207,
-0.2648446858,
-1.1059901714,
0.1571860015,
0.4201850593,
-0.191697672,
0.0670077503,
-0.7964787483,
0.4455469251,
-0.2506455183,
-0.175102815,
-0.286778897,
-0.6401527524,
0.7540674806,
0.0306387264,
0.018350685,
-0.2298105657,
0.0271447618,
0.4667149186,
-0.3968794346,
1.1286122799,
0.0566087067,
-0.1850158572,
0.053052552,
0.3033832908,
0.5494170785,
-0.0533741228,
-0.3033927679,
0.184449017,
0.2381587178,
-0.5484956503,
-0.6337555051,
0.8776330352,
-1.1864763498,
-0.462547183,
-0.3048669696,
-0.2265585661,
-0.4185626209,
0.0163005963,
-0.0955200642,
-0.0039055799,
-0.6560992599,
0.1026322469,
0.5673390627,
-0.3267348707,
0.4212287664,
0.3878982961,
-0.6956432462,
-0.5070669651,
0.578161478,
-0.0512824319,
0.4233834445,
-0.0451501496,
0.3427385092,
-0.0949780196,
-0.4913330972,
-0.0989346355,
0.3570227027,
-0.5778288841,
0.4128609896,
-0.2733041644,
-0.1131288409,
-0.4338695705,
-0.0842088982,
-0.1643161923,
-0.1797738075,
0.1339226812,
-0.1531727612,
0.4391736984,
1.1499620676,
0.4121483564,
0.6982491612,
-0.5056998134,
-0.0103327343,
0.4677098989,
0.4517672658,
-0.1288955063,
-0.4276580811,
0.1675235778,
-0.1730741411,
-0.4001627862,
-0.8695938587,
0.3619545698,
0.0394407734,
0.468952477,
0.8862305284,
-0.5238080025,
0.3370310664,
-0.3697505593,
0.9105427265,
0.0380390137,
-0.7645713687,
0.1109578162,
-0.630731225,
0.046311304,
0.2806926966,
0.4419699907,
-0.6736482978,
-0.1789468676,
-0.6067316532,
-0.2773501277,
0.4871125817,
0.37535128,
0.1650111377,
0.0275053531,
0.6155135632,
0.0503018349,
0.4244095385,
-0.5197358727,
-0.1565430164,
-0.1348992288,
-0.3856753707,
-0.1240586638,
-0.8224021196,
-0.1448917538,
-0.2909849882,
0.3262889087,
-0.1283017844,
0.343405962,
-0.0928190425,
0.3168173432,
0.2577482164,
0.0441172048,
0.9540293217,
0.5848436356,
-0.2934810817,
0.2136327773,
0.5074521303,
-0.6913541555,
0.2620242238,
-0.4229842722,
0.1559468508,
-0.3178298175,
0.2618571818,
0.6828759909,
0.2404121608,
-0.7932671309,
0.4201650023,
-0.257561475,
-0.2959499657,
-0.7887965441,
0.235898912,
0.4249732792,
0.1467530131,
0.0796185285,
-0.4517070949,
-0.1354902536,
-0.9104767442,
-0.1669123173,
0.3433102071,
0.1393775493,
-0.7278969884,
0.5410382152,
0.3163534403,
-0.2347605973,
0.5109356642,
-0.1985680759,
-0.5330560803,
0.5973439217,
0.6776611209,
0.5392060876,
-0.4961679876,
-0.1154490113,
0.0071220901,
0.0854485482,
-0.0778553635,
0.5878551006,
0.3165352046,
-0.9964104891,
-0.42033571,
-0.6653228998,
-0.8665249944,
0.1469018161,
-0.1558916122,
0.368491739,
-0.8601090908,
-0.3995635509,
-0.0382235497,
0.0851204917,
-0.6137804985,
0.169490248,
0.4783746004,
0.5904473662,
-0.7553339601,
1.0865083933,
0.925182879,
-0.2138242126,
-0.6997765303,
0.0702485442,
0.2021284997,
-0.8706155419,
0.991768539,
-0.0154193649,
-0.114345111,
-0.0630910546,
-0.7103265524,
-0.9200813174,
1.234087944,
0.4158170223,
-0.3276201487,
-0.185012266,
0.1654617637,
0.591722846,
-0.4219517112,
0.4911677241,
0.9359238744,
0.6303904057,
0.2403691113,
-1.0751821995,
-0.071157746,
-0.2707329392,
0.2910285294,
-0.1067085713,
-1.0732660294,
0.7774296999,
-0.3093350232,
0.2357903123,
0.1107208729,
0.7656934857,
0.6651611328,
-0.0745694935,
0.2556221485,
0.6457890272,
0.8626692295,
0.1725287139,
1.188778758,
-0.5765239,
0.2891050875,
0.7015480399,
-0.7672656775,
0.7796214819,
0.4247981012,
-0.4414038062,
0.7841781974,
0.7344042659,
-0.1265582889,
0.1932667494,
0.2007042021,
-0.2815926075,
-0.1000599787,
0.347967267,
-0.042364981,
0.7547712326,
0.5495401621,
-0.3056851029,
0.2932677269,
-0.3258368671,
0.3344377875,
-0.3531325758,
-0.1931640655,
0.4987079501,
0.114222765,
-0.5396561027,
0.3285906911,
0.2198728621,
0.6315168142,
-0.4419760108,
-0.0073902071,
-0.2695539296,
0.2382940352,
-0.1484176517,
-0.8296198845,
0.1345760077,
-0.0412209444,
-0.0450531952,
-0.0762146637,
0.7252383232,
-0.1851042509,
-0.3279141784,
0.1371863335,
0.1374742538,
0.3614273071,
0.043434307,
-0.2160310149,
0.2172996253,
-0.4724078476,
-0.4878008366,
0.6976066232,
0.4315687716,
-0.1818628162,
0.8195914626,
0.7075640559,
0.1521511525,
0.1720236093,
0.0306768101,
0.8316891789,
-0.9385488033,
-0.5030655265,
-1.0712714195,
0.1665385813,
-0.4428627193,
-0.3625023663,
0.9274647236,
0.3515840471,
0.4702411294,
-0.1383256018,
0.878021419,
0.0740151778,
0.4189998806,
-0.4956528246,
0.7684019208,
-0.196589455,
0.1805618405,
-0.3224509954,
-0.9461607933,
-0.0451322012,
0.3493564725,
-0.5217601061,
0.4674098194,
0.5803847313,
0.4972029328,
0.0963732973,
0.0096340459,
0.5088754892,
0.5917127728,
0.3064529896,
0.2292084694,
0.7234592438,
0.2633543611,
-0.0544385165,
-0.0731826052,
-0.1839278936,
-0.6449358463,
-0.8636160493,
-1.3624258041,
-0.2088364661,
0.1348533481,
-0.3697800636,
-0.1104516685,
0.7718596458,
0.6343723536,
-0.5375458598,
-0.3484025896,
0.1886036843,
-0.0135189015,
0.0052942955,
-0.1473944485,
-0.092381008,
0.0424403362,
-0.4911303818,
0.1004055962,
0.2699027956,
0.3145287335,
-0.7663275003,
-0.1818872988,
0.2363319844,
0.4992362559,
0.8642604947,
0.2007821202,
-0.8327861428,
-0.6238102913,
0.0608597957,
-0.1384397149,
0.1020685956,
0.7185963988,
-0.4753913581,
-0.1163157597,
0.3851578534,
0.3379787505,
0.5006177425,
0.2968750596,
0.7279244065,
-0.7059227228,
0.2148377597,
-0.0590622649,
0.5311771631,
0.3289928436,
-0.3193266392,
0.261456728,
0.2596338391,
-0.7921264768,
-0.5507565141,
0.3348762095,
-1.1420583725,
0.0686325282,
1.5087295771,
-0.1419088989,
-0.2382152677,
-0.0093926396,
-0.394246906,
-0.2777003944,
-0.1890700012,
1.0027896166,
1.0514997244,
-0.4579926431,
-0.3025179803,
-0.7462648749,
0.3730206788,
0.2346441895,
-0.8486742377,
-0.0601655096,
0.5454064012,
0.6828427911,
-0.0476751477,
0.6776784658,
0.0307139438,
0.0749322101,
0.0616297498,
0.4811123908,
0.1729196459,
-0.0432924628,
-0.1969797313,
-0.0153138768,
0.512073338,
0.4888533652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17827v1
|
Neural Machine Translation for Malayalam Paraphrase Generation
| 2024-01-31T13:40:00 | 2024-01-31T13:40:00 |
Christeena Varghese, Sergey Koshelev, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.7.0; I.2.7
|
This study explores four methods of generating paraphrases in Malayalam,
utilizing resources available for English paraphrasing and pre-trained Neural
Machine Translation (NMT) models. We evaluate the resulting paraphrases using
both automated metrics, such as BLEU, METEOR, and cosine similarity, as well as
human annotation. Our findings suggest that automated evaluation measures may
not be fully appropriate for Malayalam, as they do not consistently align with
human judgment. This discrepancy underscores the need for more nuanced
paraphrase evaluation approaches especially for highly agglutinative languages.
|
[
-0.1351813972,
-0.6211250424,
0.6226489544,
0.5252681375,
-0.7319095731,
-0.1568124145,
-0.0238878503,
-0.0829497948,
0.2052612901,
0.5236778855,
-0.2934024632,
-0.1957339346,
-0.4928253591,
0.5825750828,
-0.4984357655,
0.69688797,
-0.0917630345,
0.2872932553,
-0.1851200908,
0.1164391637,
-0.6170225143,
-0.4912186265,
-0.7065516114,
-0.4298301935,
0.1577673107,
0.4596655071,
0.6921387911,
0.79573071,
0.9670363069,
0.3544960916,
0.2258192599,
0.1475409567,
0.2485077083,
0.4149848223,
-0.4549254775,
-0.3381813169,
-0.3431068957,
-0.0810947865,
0.530529201,
0.5378261209,
0.2184467167,
0.4137906134,
0.0446741059,
0.4529021978,
-0.5266849399,
0.1438995004,
-0.5818690062,
0.3345890641,
-0.0907878578,
-0.5222790241,
-0.2180982232,
-0.6842030883,
0.0491490327,
-0.1660042703,
0.15066576,
0.1118772626,
0.7348587513,
0.3454194963,
-0.5075402856,
-0.6284658313,
-0.4118575454,
0.917362988,
-0.6530997753,
-0.0075247358,
0.6060064435,
0.7022222281,
0.2168806791,
-1.0254698992,
-0.4688122869,
-0.4273156822,
-0.0266498644,
0.0973428711,
0.1123224646,
0.0608971603,
-0.1300429851,
0.5249553323,
-0.3959077299,
-0.2313415259,
-0.5535164475,
-0.3365952671,
0.5735257864,
0.4233971536,
0.3543467522,
-0.9383178353,
-0.5095727444,
-0.1306087375,
-0.2401838452,
-0.2692737579,
0.4163639843,
0.1724420488,
0.2695167661,
0.9271579385,
-0.2691169083,
0.757774055,
0.1233146042,
0.0483319312,
0.2202490717,
-0.7940260768,
-0.2861527503,
0.0586755797,
0.9517047405,
0.9124056697,
0.4660069942,
-0.1902574152,
-0.4218558669,
0.0841329321,
0.4866177142,
-0.6742020249,
0.0123649808,
0.0153228464,
-0.5339359641,
-0.5594227314,
-0.0422635712,
-1.078440547,
-0.4342498779,
-0.5502870679,
0.6063358784,
-0.6728630066,
-0.0767266676,
-0.0594282411,
-0.5290039182,
0.3853191733,
0.054471124,
-0.7854114175,
0.4225160778,
0.4787742496,
1.1704417467,
-0.2286948413,
-0.664555192,
-0.2790834308,
-0.2625465691,
-0.4479537308,
0.4958170056,
-0.2925474942,
-0.1595789343,
-0.2567400038,
-0.306919992,
-0.4034761488,
-0.646548152,
0.3907581568,
-0.1429045349,
0.1116054654,
-0.0877255946,
-0.3773226738,
-0.3802671134,
-0.0072448486,
-0.3018831909,
0.6323035359,
0.29339692,
-0.5768675208,
0.0737986788,
-0.5612475872,
-0.5083168149,
-0.1329853684,
-0.1114524305,
-0.1989902854,
0.4899157584,
0.2418393493,
0.7303769588,
-0.6629491448,
0.3367516696,
0.1994796097,
-0.0700684115,
0.2964091599,
-0.4786610901,
0.7701050639,
0.81432271,
-0.6193755269,
0.1044050828,
-0.686183095,
0.0613069199,
0.0178106837,
0.088601999,
-0.2191004902,
-0.4745849967,
0.3965550065,
0.7885041833,
0.4208882153,
-0.3448123932,
-0.4127677679,
-0.3311398327,
0.4860017002,
0.6879042387,
0.529175818,
0.4414521158,
-0.4877233803,
0.9874101877,
-0.0551591478,
0.0581436567,
0.1008778736,
-0.4211979508,
-0.5367310643,
-0.04929474,
0.1490553617,
0.579892993,
-0.8067525029,
0.1441576928,
-0.3219976723,
-0.5762855411,
-0.684792161,
0.3845759928,
0.7053274512,
0.6342523098,
0.5838738084,
-0.3255156875,
-0.7412929535,
-1.0521883965,
-0.4454395175,
0.2979238629,
0.1523729712,
-0.0265825335,
0.6292905211,
0.1299564838,
0.697451055,
-0.0847913846,
-0.0966129899,
-0.3084371686,
0.0314093791,
-0.0577394031,
0.3533960879,
0.5558324456,
-0.9113762975,
-0.7774681449,
0.2532276511,
-1.2169588804,
-0.1756378114,
-0.0782501027,
0.0632099956,
0.0203432813,
0.6535118818,
-0.8054183722,
0.3783304393,
0.2173690498,
-0.3474304676,
0.5215880871,
-0.2406668365,
0.546825707,
-1.7499424219,
0.1290185302,
-0.2623153925,
-0.3314119875,
-0.3943226635,
0.3982321024,
0.1548140794,
-0.1338905245,
-0.7109413743,
0.5517722368,
-0.5025777817,
-0.0436659642,
-0.4112190604,
0.1639501303,
-0.094208613,
0.1029966623,
-0.146047011,
0.8080708981,
0.3367905617,
-0.5793228745,
0.6742019057,
0.1985268146,
-0.182121709,
0.7564796209,
-0.4988292456,
0.1118293628,
-0.0592180789,
-0.0916623622,
-0.8795719147,
-0.4418917894,
0.1909947395,
-0.7149873376,
0.0726917163,
0.051312577,
-0.299613148,
-0.1001323164,
-0.3966623247,
0.2690063417,
0.7509719729,
-0.0648951605,
0.2106570303,
0.0328252986,
-0.3595097363,
-0.5639699697,
-0.871974051,
0.5469289422,
-0.6672037244,
-0.3904664218,
-0.1277308315,
0.3715059161,
-0.5087688565,
-0.1754296422,
-0.0489593856,
-0.1439719945,
0.0035946043,
0.1983196884,
-0.3006229401,
-0.3226521313,
-0.127276361,
0.0063401563,
-0.0402742699,
0.2582249343,
-0.6556738019,
0.8864686489,
-0.2277183384,
-0.0288402494,
-0.5852802396,
0.3097131848,
0.7108310461,
-0.3312852979,
0.3188790977,
0.7162697315,
-0.4851451218,
0.4359109998,
-0.3790536821,
-0.1775137782,
-0.4269305468,
0.4473861456,
-0.6823689938,
-0.0056170416,
0.4125999808,
0.16267398,
-0.3035643995,
0.7344331145,
0.8348330259,
-0.0174881369,
0.6327978969,
0.0411945991,
0.4139355421,
0.0930466801,
-0.2239533961,
-0.1324193329,
-0.7013232708,
-0.1719209701,
-0.532592237,
-0.3370357454,
-0.5107875466,
-0.4382011592,
-0.1793929935,
0.0815593228,
0.0947947651,
0.6836872697,
-0.3735779226,
0.3886241913,
0.6031227708,
-0.0142104439,
0.1073458865,
0.1087665558,
-0.3157926202,
-0.2003861368,
-0.3281074762,
-0.728469193,
1.3118582964,
-0.1203380153,
0.2036887854,
0.1442724764,
1.0265474319,
0.2755402029,
-0.0614894815,
-0.4979426563,
0.648780942,
0.0246490948,
-0.7020731568,
-0.3917936385,
-0.4684124291,
-1.1482329369,
0.2682313323,
0.103123188,
-0.587064147,
-0.1358980983,
-0.043062076,
-0.0910496265,
-0.0389888957,
-0.8290242553,
0.9024265409,
-0.0966897905,
-0.1215305477,
-0.2184127718,
-0.7935595512,
0.2160326689,
-0.3628021777,
-0.0348752588,
0.1619227827,
-0.1770334542,
0.6291826367,
-0.5878445506,
0.3406319916,
-0.2632731199,
0.4711042345,
0.3653437495,
0.2055357546,
-0.0577413291,
-0.0369587168,
-0.2545191348,
-0.1699077636,
-0.2368558645,
-0.7185758352,
-0.5553714037,
0.6719359159,
-0.6541312337,
-0.4491407573,
-0.5144242644,
-0.7323057652,
-0.0213242993,
0.4027374685,
0.7972354889,
0.1220695153,
0.1839333028,
0.2599890232,
0.0219442621,
0.0351361856,
0.592535913,
-0.2519902289,
-0.3804112077,
-0.8901346326,
1.0584185123,
0.134453401,
0.4340575933,
0.3912012279,
0.3137165904,
-0.4964878559,
-0.6427865028,
-0.4913458526,
0.1345930994,
-1.014521122,
-0.2201680094,
-0.6499567628,
-0.1080564037,
-0.6647752523,
-0.2205938101,
-0.1597343832,
-0.8606053591,
0.0952206552,
-0.1553491205,
0.4435016215,
0.8535268307,
0.0356676579,
0.4546819329,
-0.5649632215,
0.4414066076,
0.1208666265,
-0.2433149815,
-0.0872106403,
-0.6730933785,
-0.1789127737,
0.0987677947,
-0.5475808978,
-1.0098357201,
0.7061053514,
0.3267039061,
0.3016918898,
-0.0702045113,
-0.2843118012,
0.5789821148,
-0.62565732,
0.7251378298,
0.3030346036,
-0.8705450892,
0.6206945181,
-0.3604460657,
0.262217015,
0.7131969333,
0.6232441068,
-0.2612225115,
-0.3645182252,
-0.6325293183,
-0.9779731035,
0.2950481772,
0.5634336472,
0.2671067417,
-0.2760489583,
0.4027496874,
0.1843045503,
0.4488730431,
-0.3913272917,
-0.1847463697,
-0.3840985298,
-0.6135433316,
-0.6323287487,
0.0638104156,
0.4235576689,
-0.2739174366,
0.2426835746,
0.2527050376,
0.1289374381,
0.2962460816,
-0.6725208759,
0.0149004068,
0.0423830897,
0.8755579591,
0.9123364687,
-0.3873698413,
0.1778205186,
0.2593792677,
-0.8252549171,
0.5497961044,
0.0763111413,
-0.1922396123,
0.3043588996,
0.2995918691,
0.6960716844,
0.0588315837,
-0.246110931,
0.3694545925,
-0.1441674232,
-0.1355004609,
-0.44929263,
-0.2388192117,
0.1775776148,
0.0510761589,
0.2383766472,
0.3489211202,
0.2638531625,
-0.3538971245,
0.4022659063,
0.0137723451,
-0.3841508925,
-0.3027794361,
0.7865206003,
0.0400658324,
-0.8520416021,
0.6837829947,
-0.0472287834,
-0.2267361879,
0.508267343,
0.546190083,
1.2257395983,
-0.5604474545,
0.0649763867,
0.1095882431,
0.4159877896,
-0.0650103465,
0.4307131469,
-0.0089574065,
-0.013570739,
-0.5447439551,
-1.1391566992,
-0.2754334211,
0.1434805244,
-0.6417583227,
0.3669781685,
-0.4100342989,
-0.3601906002,
0.2477606684,
-0.1297041327,
-0.7235469818,
0.39009583,
-0.2553190291,
0.6237494349,
-0.7930903435,
0.5770745873,
1.1288889647,
-0.9401786327,
-0.5235025287,
0.0991228297,
-0.2152740657,
-0.5263430476,
0.7804957032,
0.2868679166,
0.0114605241,
0.3432885706,
0.1168053299,
-0.5357862115,
1.0944386721,
0.5253611803,
0.1409226358,
-0.323899895,
0.456702292,
0.6020511389,
-0.2103513479,
0.3701342344,
0.3859149814,
0.4882882237,
-0.4108145237,
-1.1826101542,
0.1230678409,
-0.3214240968,
0.1125943065,
-0.0458552875,
-0.3060207367,
1.0601993799,
0.1996724755,
0.3161658943,
0.0963711813,
0.5520233512,
-0.0065257419,
0.4719075859,
0.1651378572,
0.4111553729,
0.3311552107,
0.3867915869,
1.4326514006,
-0.2601241469,
0.2548675835,
0.8077398539,
0.1150093526,
0.5477358103,
0.8006190658,
0.0307460204,
-0.0892300606,
0.6983574629,
0.3769782782,
0.4077575505,
0.3211084902,
0.00317484,
-0.1092975661,
0.1355569214,
-0.2603406608,
0.7001667619,
0.2371924371,
-0.6957650781,
-0.4634089172,
0.2384078205,
-0.1159055457,
0.4369857013,
-0.3229239583,
0.639657855,
0.607847929,
-1.029311657,
1.0318398476,
0.1966309249,
0.3848704994,
-0.2701857388,
-0.0500767045,
-0.3491935432,
0.290736109,
-0.1269303858,
-0.5327261686,
0.6471621394,
0.0010038958,
0.0809199587,
-0.2798834741,
0.6506043673,
-0.1175808534,
-0.3495483696,
0.203722477,
0.6681383252,
0.651394248,
-0.4109056294,
-0.6170133948,
-0.5270294547,
-0.0000172776,
-0.299246937,
0.3124398589,
0.4463225007,
-0.4192040563,
0.6591314077,
0.4621825814,
0.2078316361,
0.5395748019,
-0.2984937429,
0.09412954,
-0.8492456079,
-0.401681304,
-1.3282116652,
0.1960067004,
-0.2642682791,
-0.6083182096,
1.2546389103,
0.5894383788,
0.4727286398,
-0.6087139249,
0.8620870709,
0.0043177414,
-0.0022974487,
-0.5455784202,
0.7297884226,
-0.3659434021,
-0.396432519,
-0.4131907523,
-1.4138877392,
-0.1694193482,
0.7721216083,
-0.1746090502,
0.0991614908,
1.1426328421,
0.5795208216,
-0.4069711566,
-0.2350450158,
0.5458433032,
-0.0064436994,
0.0143954977,
0.3639574945,
0.887295723,
-0.7051922083,
0.5842276216,
-0.4213360846,
0.0328477621,
-0.3849153519,
-0.7507577538,
-0.8773452044,
-0.7979406714,
-0.1016732082,
-0.5761598945,
0.2527145743,
1.1114933491,
0.2735894918,
-0.7376198173,
-0.4967685938,
-0.4455864727,
-0.1890480071,
-0.2802773416,
-0.2143523097,
0.5186030269,
-0.775849998,
-0.8402451873,
0.2458819151,
0.2270750701,
0.0572800525,
-0.1994288564,
-0.0981088653,
-0.5244501233,
0.1967107505,
0.399500072,
-0.1581974924,
-0.5593342781,
-0.1225199699,
0.1671665311,
-0.3491555154,
-0.0882558078,
0.5129710436,
-0.3176789582,
0.2735986114,
0.7590889335,
0.8290450573,
0.3601491749,
-0.008857674,
0.8171323538,
-0.8413852453,
0.2465406805,
0.3858081996,
0.2749901116,
0.6218572259,
0.0246461704,
0.4353547096,
0.3305470049,
-0.5470147133,
-0.8652153015,
0.2202260196,
-0.6028274298,
0.1203233078,
1.335899353,
-0.1501884013,
-0.4381822348,
-0.3351374269,
-0.3076057434,
0.4511191547,
0.1054341123,
0.6540364623,
0.8309121132,
0.1515497118,
0.1094505489,
-0.8291418552,
0.5367473364,
0.5778570771,
-0.4345320761,
-0.2845464051,
0.1298895329,
0.3257265687,
0.2070261389,
0.4912786782,
-0.1580224335,
0.6358820796,
0.3471693695,
0.2334812284,
-0.1638401002,
-0.1111268625,
-0.5193372965,
-0.0620826595,
0.3187182248,
-0.4274321496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17824v1
|
A Survey of Pre-trained Language Models for Processing Scientific Text
| 2024-01-31T13:35:07 | 2024-01-31T13:35:07 |
Xanh Ho, Anh Khoa Duong Nguyen, An Tuan Dao, Junfeng Jiang, Yuki Chida, Kaito Sugimoto, Huy Quoc To, Florian Boudin, Akiko Aizawa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The number of Language Models (LMs) dedicated to processing scientific text
is on the rise. Keeping pace with the rapid growth of scientific LMs (SciLMs)
has become a daunting task for researchers. To date, no comprehensive surveys
on SciLMs have been undertaken, leaving this issue unaddressed. Given the
constant stream of new SciLMs, appraising the state-of-the-art and how they
compare to each other remain largely unknown. This work fills that gap and
provides a comprehensive review of SciLMs, including an extensive analysis of
their effectiveness across different domains, tasks and datasets, and a
discussion on the challenges that lie ahead.
|
[
-0.2463071197,
-0.3125688732,
0.6191868186,
0.332559526,
-0.1385224611,
0.4425538778,
-0.2930189967,
-0.6845251322,
0.0485781319,
0.5323520303,
-0.4148887098,
-0.4474733174,
-0.8542631865,
0.5883458257,
-0.6755712032,
1.0869582891,
0.0321461558,
0.3250835836,
-0.5626330972,
0.1261405647,
0.1081129387,
-0.5970373154,
-0.2803875208,
-0.3565433621,
0.6088713408,
-0.0697479993,
0.4848663509,
0.3265089095,
0.8462859392,
0.2918425798,
-0.4307590723,
0.2795552909,
-0.5157826543,
0.5501022339,
-0.0912742093,
-0.2135625631,
-0.5116529465,
0.1418215036,
0.8723230958,
1.0910415649,
0.150624454,
0.2358715981,
-0.0418204442,
0.4036931992,
-0.3801772594,
-0.0180910937,
-0.5752453208,
0.0774713606,
-0.4017328918,
-0.1893403232,
-0.6878602505,
-0.2551560998,
0.4227844775,
-0.4640865624,
0.3597464263,
0.2080768496,
0.4944359958,
0.0633812919,
-0.3513815701,
-0.3374539018,
-0.7388513088,
1.0478959084,
-0.6491944194,
0.566521883,
0.2817021906,
-0.0606876798,
-0.2409467846,
-1.1332142353,
-0.1929613799,
-0.5329582691,
-0.1110902652,
-0.0856968611,
-0.1929989159,
-0.0885689259,
0.1307937652,
0.2257582396,
-0.7992094159,
0.2089708,
-0.7706913948,
0.0059298333,
0.6415848136,
0.2007091343,
0.1462127566,
0.0202727355,
-0.1383468211,
-0.0059732059,
-0.7167153358,
-0.2480438352,
-0.0975321904,
0.0942574069,
0.4076133966,
0.5564523339,
-0.1408542097,
1.0406314135,
-0.5091903806,
0.0435644351,
0.0575449131,
-0.6644374132,
-0.2874031663,
-0.0881834924,
1.1152098179,
0.1307401508,
0.1168337017,
-0.0728002787,
-0.0671344176,
-0.0228802674,
0.2900724411,
-0.8089841008,
-0.2603823543,
0.0697387829,
-0.3968318999,
-0.2315223515,
-0.2740013897,
-0.5696048737,
-0.3636476696,
-0.2083632499,
-0.1872430742,
-0.1154619157,
-0.2384192795,
0.2116232514,
0.0609997846,
-0.3840932846,
0.4637107253,
-0.5861372948,
0.3233018219,
0.660797894,
1.100214839,
-0.2573651671,
-0.3225593567,
0.0548666231,
-0.1123998091,
-0.4211255908,
1.0396220684,
-0.626730442,
-0.5326068401,
-0.2185958773,
-0.1896851957,
-0.1631611437,
-0.3036123514,
0.6050755978,
-0.6535874605,
0.4121982157,
-0.1652344763,
-0.6324188113,
0.0655428246,
0.1883237213,
-0.6011201143,
1.0905444622,
0.0420728922,
-1.0386462212,
0.2664856613,
-0.7267299891,
-0.189375475,
0.3020353019,
-0.0235261116,
-0.1489339769,
0.1388031393,
0.0283779223,
0.6587250829,
-0.4243654609,
0.3838150203,
-0.187786907,
-0.2448592782,
0.4374303818,
-0.0797814503,
0.4923106134,
0.7771833539,
0.2642589509,
0.4518758655,
-0.6968396902,
0.2680072188,
-0.0934212208,
-0.1423750073,
-0.57755059,
0.4034479856,
0.1261509806,
0.1360817999,
0.3702700138,
-0.5864673257,
0.46007061,
-0.4067456722,
0.7093398571,
0.2651185691,
-0.3893757164,
0.3562946618,
0.008476736,
0.5620139241,
-0.2986954749,
0.191448167,
-0.4905117154,
-0.4110185802,
-0.4316335022,
-0.2863410711,
0.208767578,
0.1943646222,
-0.4681688845,
0.0782466829,
-0.1852306575,
-0.9955521822,
-0.7454054952,
0.0073064752,
0.3083749712,
0.3179718554,
0.5078044534,
-0.1016308963,
-0.6892070174,
-0.5999435782,
-0.4585621953,
-0.1400545388,
0.0206028186,
0.0462391153,
0.4203036427,
-0.2402034551,
0.9748412371,
-0.4202114046,
0.0977455974,
-0.2261565775,
0.2919312119,
0.2343675494,
0.2200441509,
0.4153898656,
-0.8005056381,
-0.5263867974,
0.0923496634,
-0.8272190094,
-0.183095932,
0.3625459969,
0.3425128758,
0.1685846448,
0.6713249683,
-0.6119806767,
0.1818514168,
0.6304028034,
-0.3698296845,
0.6094189882,
-0.2264928222,
0.2947304547,
-0.6470317245,
0.2730261981,
0.01916302,
-0.2085537612,
-1.0345768929,
0.03460088,
0.1032976136,
0.0001228072,
-0.5785377026,
0.5652022958,
-0.6901256442,
-0.124262847,
-0.4788376391,
0.1400777698,
-0.0952172354,
-0.2732624114,
0.4970213771,
0.5367624164,
0.6270756125,
-0.666428566,
0.2757585645,
0.1648940891,
-0.5564987659,
0.0010181309,
-0.8158060908,
0.0424546115,
-0.3828900456,
0.4044225216,
-0.7412601113,
-0.0597118326,
0.0087434258,
-0.3832399845,
0.1579637229,
0.2373735011,
-0.2144423425,
-0.5961560607,
-0.1539556831,
0.4793994427,
0.4371800721,
-0.1024522781,
0.2535277605,
0.3515765071,
-0.6474622488,
-0.8488960862,
-0.3119311035,
0.2167380452,
0.1045677662,
-0.4206085205,
0.1941445619,
-0.1045667231,
-0.5275022984,
0.0409696363,
-0.1459224671,
-0.0145193506,
0.0571987592,
0.0665436089,
0.3864850104,
-0.2020721436,
0.0263813697,
-0.2377503067,
0.1223187,
0.1295472234,
-0.1627091467,
0.6135541797,
-0.0841618031,
-0.2191659808,
0.0593043603,
0.3458230197,
0.5520937443,
-0.2918173373,
0.5755431056,
0.2957101166,
-0.2703124881,
0.0336569734,
-0.397952497,
-0.1360494196,
-0.4373129308,
0.7205280662,
-0.2052582055,
-1.0177452564,
0.1199600697,
0.0483155176,
0.3420617282,
0.45962286,
0.4592589736,
-0.2518925369,
1.3079683781,
0.6390355229,
0.1220194325,
0.2704692781,
0.0365195908,
0.4206041098,
-0.599535048,
-0.5421435833,
-1.0213297606,
0.1415640116,
-0.3426028788,
-0.3960667253,
0.1507599354,
0.0734372288,
-0.12524499,
0.2454733849,
-0.7242210507,
0.407227695,
0.1912245005,
-0.5845214725,
0.3762153387,
-0.00958905,
0.1120510623,
-0.0937982276,
-0.8947254419,
-0.8755668402,
0.9252892137,
0.4492509961,
0.8578348756,
-0.4382025003,
0.4553059042,
0.1439332962,
0.7733598351,
-0.5350202918,
0.6161060333,
-0.3350553215,
-0.5832020044,
-0.3778797388,
-0.5175230503,
-1.0883069038,
0.5670704246,
-0.1908255219,
-0.4322741032,
-0.1278146058,
0.0755789131,
-0.1671656519,
0.2766552866,
-0.2833657563,
0.6270723939,
-0.46552068,
-0.1884176284,
-0.1808301508,
-0.6121847034,
0.4036931992,
-0.3141714334,
0.5640409589,
-0.2763851583,
0.0381382965,
1.1225236654,
-0.1079988852,
0.4857367873,
-0.0638648346,
-0.1672323793,
0.2060630172,
0.023836391,
0.0477687903,
-0.1775308549,
-0.1272964031,
0.2096822113,
0.601674974,
-0.2723267674,
-0.1853796989,
0.7047766447,
-0.5409210324,
-0.5056841969,
-1.0635794401,
-0.5903993845,
-0.2093164027,
0.249070406,
0.2566402853,
0.0326604024,
-0.4434124827,
0.1401009262,
0.6019541621,
-0.1691002846,
0.4218928218,
0.7783967257,
-0.6095581055,
-0.0718168914,
0.5839327574,
0.0445801541,
0.1898485422,
0.1061307862,
-0.1722586155,
-0.4119665623,
-0.8578754663,
-0.1292409301,
0.3053246737,
-0.5244504213,
-0.1524042338,
-1.0144022703,
-0.3801723421,
-0.7339705229,
0.0713542625,
-0.3475215137,
-0.2853389084,
-0.4582873881,
0.079803288,
0.3752505779,
1.3625564575,
0.3750138879,
0.2938256562,
-0.9070268273,
-0.0121583007,
-0.1368274987,
0.2251630276,
-0.1025097221,
-0.4800826311,
-0.325874567,
0.0470212959,
0.0568561181,
-0.6886146069,
0.8365949988,
0.3079544008,
0.5890894532,
0.28213045,
-0.1443613023,
0.4811770022,
-0.7276684046,
1.0452060699,
0.260890156,
-0.6849544644,
0.4743716121,
-0.0179306697,
0.0670287088,
0.3584731817,
0.9918205738,
-0.7970775962,
-0.4401663244,
-0.3921515644,
-0.8035664558,
0.5583215952,
-0.1099068522,
-0.0736204833,
-0.0203707293,
0.1955060065,
0.19395262,
0.3137360513,
-0.6401638985,
0.0408908725,
-0.1516183615,
-0.2796038687,
-0.4914304912,
-0.3202410936,
-0.0712894499,
-0.2862648666,
0.5846748948,
-0.0479065552,
-0.0173432957,
0.1110762805,
-0.2758160233,
0.0439519957,
0.3503696918,
0.751480639,
0.777923882,
-0.2188357562,
0.3539595902,
0.0068725906,
-0.8212700486,
0.0816538632,
0.0443262756,
-0.2330091894,
0.2121937722,
0.6201035976,
0.8568272591,
0.2403672934,
-0.866081655,
0.1969285011,
-0.1457619071,
-0.2432047427,
-0.0671480745,
-0.0212510414,
0.0342202745,
-0.0709618255,
0.4623333812,
0.1484244764,
0.146340996,
-0.3873655498,
-0.1100070626,
0.4811830521,
-0.2505761683,
-0.4780909419,
0.5893650055,
0.0652178004,
-0.233518675,
0.4452490807,
0.0548378453,
-0.6790646315,
0.3889215589,
0.6638137698,
0.3897203803,
-0.3951066434,
0.1484616697,
0.2594960034,
0.2916878164,
-0.405197084,
0.3969454169,
0.0702041164,
-0.5370189548,
-0.7963010669,
-0.9908559322,
-0.5000194907,
0.1135295182,
-0.5284118652,
0.1558372229,
-0.234534651,
-0.3549161553,
0.0942422897,
0.0470699519,
-0.6014891267,
0.2608661354,
0.0464650244,
1.124032259,
-0.8747153282,
0.883105576,
0.9644954801,
-0.1633248925,
-0.3563420177,
-0.7275232673,
-0.3240804672,
-0.4274047315,
1.0133528709,
-0.1333117485,
-0.1024685502,
0.0089246593,
-0.5876008272,
-1.1467994452,
0.6747326255,
0.0713230073,
-0.8596199155,
-0.2008755356,
0.1392392963,
0.9243110418,
-0.3306886852,
0.5503945351,
0.6389826536,
0.5237598419,
-0.0791794509,
-1.1411973238,
-0.3958276212,
-0.4170508981,
-0.1986750364,
-0.004375679,
-0.31358549,
1.074113369,
0.0156820435,
-0.219088167,
0.2101107538,
0.7098183632,
0.4862516224,
0.5540397167,
0.2937579453,
0.083430104,
0.9133359194,
-0.1874525547,
0.8565990925,
-0.3757392466,
0.2535609007,
0.8687480688,
-0.7635127306,
0.8075281978,
0.4952151775,
-0.5085773468,
0.3161619008,
0.8723984957,
-0.016550947,
0.2940272987,
0.4542134702,
-0.3722726405,
-0.1596791297,
-0.2992261052,
-0.6531726718,
0.2217092663,
0.6071887612,
-0.4874173403,
-0.1216614619,
0.2196946293,
-0.0801983476,
0.1704482585,
-0.5257448554,
0.5486006141,
0.2032981515,
-0.8021577597,
0.4591418207,
0.0577031001,
0.8413906097,
-0.9291369915,
0.1963833719,
-0.065663442,
-0.1458410323,
-0.3530360758,
-0.8180892467,
0.2225336879,
0.4730769694,
-0.2944445312,
-0.6904503703,
0.9973564744,
-0.6051077247,
-0.4238601327,
0.2175583243,
0.530716002,
0.6631671786,
0.2016782016,
-0.2619856894,
0.3509949744,
-0.1250660419,
-0.5049093962,
0.2548584044,
-0.0002265255,
-0.2820222974,
0.8074255586,
0.6340433359,
0.5493501425,
0.4035429955,
0.1736014187,
0.7105388641,
-0.7577475309,
-0.2402187735,
-0.6622547507,
0.225522846,
-0.2187408358,
-0.1945119649,
0.9544773102,
0.5181820393,
0.7715435028,
-0.2499429286,
0.9266265035,
0.0828592852,
0.7686089277,
-0.3135264814,
0.9161173105,
-0.2908339202,
0.193286255,
-0.2064452171,
-0.9613770247,
-0.5266889334,
0.6686280966,
-0.1990775764,
-0.020410724,
0.8010293841,
0.4818611741,
0.1743970513,
0.3684895933,
0.1969147027,
0.269844979,
0.3321640193,
0.2111326009,
1.3094767332,
-0.0510070622,
0.1169243455,
0.1334405839,
-0.0342909135,
-0.0050701299,
-1.0890487432,
-0.7043135762,
-0.5956038833,
-0.3124969304,
0.0541005321,
0.0070890854,
0.792412281,
0.8218942881,
-0.9192732573,
-0.2623637319,
0.1738690287,
-0.1851077825,
0.0099943718,
-0.0939464048,
0.3181677461,
-0.392563045,
-0.7981281877,
0.8493695855,
0.2020671368,
0.0061726947,
-0.514700532,
-0.0276685748,
-0.2050763071,
0.1935195029,
0.7440032363,
0.4592909515,
-0.621453464,
0.1152099669,
0.419565022,
-0.3040963411,
-0.3296456635,
1.055444479,
-0.8514083028,
0.321218133,
0.6795685887,
0.4348373413,
0.4963576496,
-0.3596497476,
0.334082365,
-0.6391400099,
0.0101848748,
0.6719534993,
0.3285335302,
0.4528356194,
0.0210667066,
0.524053514,
0.1355672926,
-0.8038166761,
-1.5673741102,
-0.0213151984,
-0.8101582527,
-0.4837337434,
0.8035477996,
-0.1056404337,
-0.0779005885,
-0.1563442349,
-0.0991016254,
0.0597448163,
0.1457271874,
0.3400629163,
0.867631495,
-0.3013843,
-0.0114560816,
-0.3676638007,
0.6616075039,
0.5897318125,
-0.7648011446,
0.0958203748,
0.4970905185,
0.2550257146,
0.3065523803,
0.8303514123,
-0.0712915137,
-0.0580764376,
-0.4098215699,
0.2016172111,
-0.2462737858,
-0.6191933155,
-0.4602426291,
0.3385145068,
0.237547189,
0.5775717497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17809v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17809v3
|
SWEA: Updating Factual Knowledge in Large Language Models via Subject Word Embedding Altering
| 2024-01-31T13:08:45 | 2024-04-23T01:08:44 |
Xiaopeng Li, Shasha Li, Shezheng Song, Huijun Liu, Bin Ji, Xi Wang, Jun Ma, Jie Yu, Xiaodong Liu, Jing Wang, Weimin Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The general capabilities of large language models (LLMs) make them the
infrastructure for various AI applications, but updating their inner knowledge
requires significant resources. Recent model editing is a promising technique
for efficiently updating a small amount of knowledge of LLMs and has attracted
much attention. In particular, local editing methods, which directly update
model parameters, are more suitable for updating a small amount of knowledge.
Local editing methods update weights by computing least squares closed-form
solutions and identify edited knowledge by vector-level matching in inference,
which achieve promising results. However, these methods still require a lot of
time and resources to complete the computation. Moreover, vector-level matching
lacks reliability, and such updates disrupt the original organization of the
model's parameters. To address these issues, we propose an detachable and
expandable Subject Word Embedding Altering (SWEA) framework, which finds the
editing embeddings through token-level matching and adds them to the subject
word embeddings in Transformer input. To get these editing embeddings, we
propose optimizing then suppressing fusion method, which first optimizes
learnable embedding vectors for the editing target and then suppresses the
Knowledge Embedding Dimensions (KEDs) to obtain final editing embeddings. We
thus propose SWEA$\oplus$OS method for editing factual knowledge in LLMs. We
demonstrate the overall state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of SWEA$\oplus$OS
on the \textsc{CounterFact} and zsRE datasets. To further validate the
reasoning ability of SWEA$\oplus$OS in editing knowledge, we evaluate it on the
more complex \textsc{RippleEdits} benchmark. The results demonstrate that
SWEA$\oplus$OS possesses SOTA reasoning ability.
|
[
-0.1659773141,
-1.0775402784,
0.6793115735,
-0.0955604017,
-0.0938392058,
0.1088947803,
-0.3998825848,
-0.5185486078,
0.0609441809,
0.6891373396,
-0.5330970883,
-0.5929090381,
-0.5158991814,
0.0857265294,
-0.2029188722,
0.6427744031,
-0.2591178417,
0.0644428208,
-0.3975719213,
-0.5238181949,
-0.6297878027,
-0.2496830821,
-0.3985881805,
-0.0110150157,
0.2670259178,
0.38773489,
0.7032198906,
0.6358833313,
0.5119164586,
0.4552313089,
-0.6243118644,
0.338267386,
-0.4896740913,
0.4337829649,
-0.6905384064,
-0.7187871337,
-0.6889101863,
-0.3206739128,
0.76188761,
0.4880948067,
0.080975987,
0.2732844055,
-0.2256000191,
0.4992881119,
-0.6732238531,
-0.0777779445,
-0.9541419148,
-0.0972358286,
-0.1939345002,
0.0029748331,
-0.3735071421,
-0.1699344516,
0.2500643432,
-0.3909478188,
0.2055715919,
0.0889096633,
0.774012208,
0.4278076887,
-0.090386115,
-0.0388350859,
-0.8363916874,
0.8099610806,
-0.9583905935,
0.5698416233,
0.1987450123,
-0.0304001272,
-0.2196422368,
-0.5656899214,
-0.5085731745,
-0.1221761405,
0.0724239349,
-0.0212062281,
-0.4060152769,
0.2127628326,
0.4990872741,
0.230533421,
-0.2788368464,
0.237335816,
-0.400693655,
-0.0936653167,
0.7032174468,
0.1049261317,
0.5431509614,
-0.0415453836,
-0.159752667,
0.1041978151,
-1.0197986364,
-0.2904973328,
0.0660242811,
0.1664397269,
0.1803522557,
0.9017034769,
-0.11547672,
0.6336443424,
0.0072778128,
-0.1844989657,
0.1556437314,
-0.1035407111,
-0.4791747928,
-0.0949816257,
0.264190793,
0.1143628135,
-0.398219943,
-0.0345600136,
-0.3103251457,
-0.1576051116,
0.1347253919,
-0.6631887555,
0.3860867023,
0.3747108877,
-0.3517698646,
-0.1826057583,
-0.0490426645,
-0.6452654004,
-0.5429853201,
-0.4227446318,
0.5757662654,
-0.5957475901,
0.0382740237,
0.0665727258,
-0.155675739,
0.1571126282,
0.3871034682,
-0.4230169356,
-0.11763677,
0.6232138872,
0.6133784056,
0.2291578948,
-0.5120120645,
-0.4105119407,
0.2891032398,
-0.2079705596,
0.6775678396,
-0.7329797745,
-0.4741896987,
-0.0349498391,
-0.1213659719,
0.1560967565,
-0.350468576,
0.3303248882,
-0.7274810672,
0.2343686372,
-0.5436096787,
-0.9144530892,
-0.2414233088,
0.0624298975,
-0.4959048629,
0.9785416722,
-0.0243754257,
-0.6508707404,
0.278190583,
-0.823361516,
-0.4999585748,
-0.1863906682,
0.2761667073,
-0.2734514475,
0.310480535,
0.3801851571,
0.3078045249,
-0.0206492878,
0.3226347864,
-0.3122284412,
-0.3177680075,
0.1586382687,
-0.2176386267,
0.4434359372,
-0.0538708232,
-0.3175246119,
0.5945879817,
-0.8034122586,
-0.3623928428,
-0.0296715032,
-0.0806856304,
-0.6025234461,
0.0994801074,
-0.4845297039,
0.1987785697,
0.3454083204,
-0.7847749591,
0.4675996006,
-0.5758910775,
0.4139230251,
0.9549000859,
0.1857779324,
0.5506491065,
-0.1496673524,
0.3244876266,
-0.0185336098,
0.2333652377,
0.0357910171,
-0.376285702,
-0.8212295175,
-0.3665217161,
0.4495013654,
0.5174543858,
-0.766985476,
0.3508862555,
-0.261811167,
-0.8212133646,
-0.9045188427,
0.2906492651,
0.0817366764,
0.4071550071,
0.6368343234,
0.2737038136,
-0.6981999874,
-0.8360500336,
-0.5467101932,
0.2224541008,
0.0149702756,
0.1241074726,
0.4240102768,
-0.4466446638,
1.1465631723,
-0.6880338788,
-0.3850719333,
-0.3122105896,
0.0854134038,
-0.0339590348,
0.272910744,
0.3736039102,
-0.4608697295,
-0.1201836541,
0.0097998381,
-0.699721396,
-0.1666944325,
-0.2057064623,
-0.1939177066,
0.1303703338,
0.4438622594,
-0.6369495392,
0.5174680352,
0.4629081786,
-0.5335248113,
0.4200365245,
-0.4293530285,
0.1455232352,
-0.8873176575,
-0.1446527094,
0.0000081018,
-0.2560819983,
-0.6350675225,
0.4103354812,
0.0503314175,
-0.2201800346,
-0.6140821576,
0.6250350475,
-0.5882217288,
-0.2083754987,
-0.334033072,
0.6298696995,
-0.003250672,
0.4754811227,
-0.0077636885,
0.5798878074,
0.5526763797,
-0.5169200301,
0.1469544619,
0.4029501379,
-0.3091809154,
0.3699347675,
-0.624622643,
0.2307705581,
-0.3656679392,
0.2331310511,
-0.5520207882,
0.2299911231,
0.0219800584,
0.0743215457,
0.1913780421,
0.0786634982,
-0.2163865566,
-0.0074918773,
-0.4052621126,
0.1033350974,
0.3199866414,
-0.6321612597,
1.1167217493,
0.3661215901,
-0.34486112,
-0.6777067184,
-0.6424618959,
0.1058124527,
0.1418663561,
-0.6550771594,
0.5278360248,
0.0854518488,
-0.5121175051,
0.414816916,
-0.0906312466,
0.2130350918,
-0.0428434908,
0.1143594161,
0.4881814718,
-0.3019845486,
0.1092603505,
0.6056903005,
-0.0327285156,
-0.2424087673,
0.1319210976,
0.2344511747,
-0.0300286245,
-0.4721636474,
-0.3820967674,
0.0672522485,
0.6284647584,
-0.5220144391,
0.7864841819,
0.534153223,
-0.5401694775,
-0.2265547514,
-0.6467120051,
-0.1592556536,
-0.4964153469,
0.6994450092,
-0.4851328135,
-0.9748135209,
0.5104045868,
-0.2223465741,
0.4885754585,
0.5242484212,
0.415432483,
-0.0351950265,
0.901078701,
0.4291576445,
-0.055597201,
0.4190407693,
-0.1982715875,
0.1807687134,
-1.1028194427,
0.048777733,
-0.4575359225,
-0.5403255224,
-0.4438971877,
-0.8494423032,
0.1974829733,
-0.1376725286,
-0.0813294128,
0.264762193,
-0.2469257861,
0.4409855306,
0.3523041606,
0.2170516998,
0.2544967532,
-0.4377009869,
0.1467222273,
-0.3019596338,
-0.429343313,
-0.2508672476,
0.7521396875,
0.4301891029,
0.6124202609,
0.2881447077,
0.4092643261,
0.4034416378,
0.4398302734,
-0.6508318186,
0.7750723958,
-0.2724668086,
-0.4037360847,
-0.5066999197,
-0.2296368182,
-0.5024520755,
0.571400404,
-0.5264986753,
-0.6004830003,
0.3329881132,
0.0268711485,
0.017407408,
0.938570559,
-0.4469407499,
0.4568723142,
-0.0423309281,
-0.302018851,
-0.6456471682,
-0.3662939966,
0.1698681414,
0.1072933078,
0.3002565503,
0.0026570507,
-0.1122392863,
0.6565318704,
-0.5479049683,
0.9692510962,
-0.4295343757,
-0.3501241505,
0.1811980754,
0.2377087176,
0.8559699059,
-0.0381583385,
-0.2845921516,
0.2627967894,
-0.1258503497,
-0.2778170109,
-0.9275356531,
0.6139455438,
-0.6682590842,
-0.8572453856,
-0.2228044719,
-0.5654205084,
-0.5517286062,
0.2481618822,
-0.0091589475,
0.6728446484,
-0.3354514837,
0.2428844273,
0.6164005399,
-0.4290991426,
0.1513886452,
0.5763731003,
-0.3240794837,
-0.3159084916,
0.9758244157,
0.2439627051,
0.1839249432,
0.5548734069,
0.4629327655,
-0.2184455395,
-0.4718608856,
-0.3016096652,
0.3492081761,
-0.7833881974,
-0.1729700714,
-0.5792316794,
-0.0722286552,
-0.3289044201,
-0.4671069086,
-0.3716975749,
-0.2943605483,
-0.1373776644,
-0.2551982403,
0.3792052269,
0.8834875822,
-0.0037548691,
0.1539197713,
-0.8610811234,
0.366568625,
0.1758902222,
0.2084136158,
0.0032866353,
-0.6604773402,
-0.0871050656,
0.2023333609,
0.064697437,
-0.9745374918,
0.0902388021,
0.1130906641,
0.5106186867,
0.2418129146,
-0.0154950777,
0.8663057685,
-0.3061619103,
0.8940294981,
-0.2551400065,
-1.5121929646,
0.7333234549,
-0.0018623781,
0.259768188,
0.355091095,
-0.131539464,
-0.6018434167,
-0.8292609453,
-0.6605801582,
-0.6117516756,
0.5767149925,
-0.1494340897,
0.2982185483,
0.2921955884,
0.4837486744,
0.1718246043,
0.0938356072,
-0.1796709895,
-0.2305248231,
0.0625354201,
-0.1440812796,
0.3691685796,
-0.6659089327,
0.1009343565,
-0.5632402301,
1.2976011038,
0.0792480335,
0.0391290002,
0.2691336274,
-0.5218451023,
0.0076181325,
0.5421977043,
0.8458465338,
0.8373978138,
-0.2142096907,
-0.1290453821,
0.8082152605,
-0.4530259371,
-0.1664952487,
-0.2962303758,
-0.4611295462,
0.1158960462,
0.4986518919,
1.2228589058,
0.6768137813,
-0.6932221651,
0.3427106738,
0.127301082,
-0.271379739,
0.2293536812,
0.0422098413,
-0.0123202372,
0.1404333413,
0.1106389984,
0.4202851951,
-0.1459052265,
-0.4185234308,
0.0459940135,
0.1641560942,
-0.4113451838,
-0.3526098728,
0.476858288,
0.2012189329,
-0.2892898917,
0.3834592104,
-0.0136058526,
-0.5162220001,
0.1203839332,
0.6381894946,
0.7445352077,
-0.4067253172,
0.2190137655,
0.3052146733,
0.4542572796,
0.1546677947,
0.3100668192,
0.2129870802,
-0.9686209559,
-0.6257994175,
-0.3237251043,
-0.5915756226,
0.0905545875,
-0.5963739753,
0.4805402756,
-0.5313416123,
0.048190698,
-0.2268034965,
-0.1342099905,
-0.6957808733,
0.2406962812,
-0.1403920799,
1.0328798294,
-0.6312249303,
0.7008453608,
0.8151916265,
-0.1610067636,
-0.6732326746,
-0.0989479497,
-0.0242991503,
-0.6453689337,
0.2274283469,
-0.3658904731,
-0.2077320814,
-0.084731847,
-0.3919379413,
-0.9469970465,
0.9920985699,
0.4040158689,
-0.6214952469,
0.0157866068,
-0.0590486452,
0.5023363233,
0.0396728814,
0.0549321361,
0.5570036173,
0.6945576668,
0.0496717803,
-0.2844593525,
0.2753456831,
0.0816567764,
-0.0033786693,
0.1100550368,
-0.4753481448,
0.4952107966,
-0.3612091839,
-0.1385381967,
-0.0934168249,
1.1672503948,
0.1414207816,
-0.0148071628,
0.5582697988,
0.6021140814,
1.0505301952,
0.02517155,
0.6478173733,
-0.2410268486,
0.3822395802,
1.3352752924,
-0.6729915142,
1.1226741076,
0.3705140054,
-0.1510494649,
0.7061806917,
0.063794978,
-0.2345555723,
0.2674055398,
-0.0890310034,
-0.1891674846,
-0.0946182162,
0.1467500627,
-0.1954624057,
0.7463294268,
0.3417097032,
-0.1960539669,
-0.1617581695,
0.2945486903,
0.2129872441,
0.0824851692,
-0.1932388991,
0.7689130902,
-0.141380161,
-0.3235613108,
0.0004725728,
0.4710812867,
0.688744545,
-0.6390951872,
0.0066936119,
-0.0807464793,
0.0030294897,
-0.1646431684,
-0.7103819251,
0.3993156552,
0.1436994523,
-0.07316944,
-0.0128955543,
1.1560389996,
-0.4809536338,
-0.5742453933,
0.2068119794,
0.5230828524,
-0.2396129072,
0.1155104637,
-0.6566030383,
0.2521843314,
0.0535864048,
-0.481654495,
0.1734837592,
0.2836487591,
-0.0005470976,
0.6834647059,
0.8266492486,
0.5069743395,
-0.214176327,
0.1962408274,
0.6317944527,
-0.7318962812,
-0.5037307739,
-0.8671646118,
0.5475972891,
-0.229762271,
-0.2794509828,
0.7238385081,
0.2638984919,
0.4360578656,
-0.1210502908,
0.8192126751,
-0.1303502321,
0.3086434305,
-0.6288217306,
0.6474142671,
-0.5095098019,
0.1953464597,
-0.3666708469,
-0.8747259378,
-0.267337501,
0.3685138822,
-0.5586356521,
-0.3274792135,
0.5458188653,
0.8634922504,
0.1790010035,
0.371827811,
0.4584360421,
0.7786405087,
0.3601698875,
-0.0827194303,
0.6482628584,
-0.440642029,
-0.083031401,
-0.414588064,
-0.1697205603,
-0.1204947829,
-0.8072234392,
-0.740994215,
-0.5538525581,
-0.511818409,
-0.1380303949,
0.0339759439,
1.0178252459,
0.3004326522,
-0.6948493719,
0.2812798917,
0.303694576,
0.5643858314,
-0.5910095572,
-0.2185526341,
0.6069130898,
-0.0748840719,
-0.6759396195,
0.7789492011,
0.4006772935,
-0.3029197752,
-0.4088748991,
0.1683636159,
-0.3170666099,
0.4333908856,
0.9008859992,
0.1842084974,
-0.7868588567,
-0.6566392183,
-0.0797138438,
0.0856483802,
-0.2355073243,
0.7252307534,
-0.5559865236,
0.419557035,
0.6767019033,
0.7877975106,
0.2858924866,
0.0971365795,
0.583011508,
-0.918394804,
0.1711647511,
0.036147438,
0.7412489057,
0.3065449297,
-0.4848929048,
0.2200321555,
0.2036860585,
-0.4413722456,
-0.9332181215,
-0.0338190943,
-0.8799812794,
-0.4559702575,
1.2062190771,
-0.0233332161,
-0.5064414144,
0.0671847239,
-0.5202149153,
0.3692936599,
-0.0202768538,
0.5319840312,
0.6091228127,
0.1330465674,
0.0647232682,
-0.1491895318,
0.2343043834,
0.4718065262,
-0.8573664427,
0.2493305802,
0.4434790909,
0.4404995739,
0.0143108629,
0.2561193705,
-0.0529724397,
0.154340595,
-0.0628912374,
0.324139148,
-0.3201342821,
-0.1076045632,
-0.2239969969,
0.0798136145,
0.0548769906,
-0.0362620279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17755v1
|
CauESC: A Causal Aware Model for Emotional Support Conversation
| 2024-01-31T11:30:24 | 2024-01-31T11:30:24 |
Wei Chen, Hengxu Lin, Qun Zhang, Xiaojin Zhang, Xiang Bai, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Emotional Support Conversation aims at reducing the seeker's emotional
distress through supportive response. Existing approaches have two limitations:
(1) They ignore the emotion causes of the distress, which is important for
fine-grained emotion understanding; (2) They focus on the seeker's own mental
state rather than the emotional dynamics during interaction between speakers.
To address these issues, we propose a novel framework CauESC, which firstly
recognizes the emotion causes of the distress, as well as the emotion effects
triggered by the causes, and then understands each strategy of verbal grooming
independently and integrates them skillfully. Experimental results on the
benchmark dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and show the
benefits of emotion understanding from cause to effect and
independent-integrated strategy modeling.
|
[
-0.3465528786,
-0.8207982183,
0.5391890407,
0.6401364207,
0.0116847847,
-0.2149130106,
0.0560687967,
-0.5947330594,
0.7015933394,
0.4244660139,
-0.98291713,
-0.0734181404,
-0.4910543263,
0.1140948981,
-0.4569482803,
0.8764590025,
0.1425019056,
0.2344373614,
-0.0583521351,
-0.2471582592,
-0.7209324837,
-0.365277648,
-1.3043138981,
-0.1002182886,
0.5558002591,
0.608022809,
0.3420733213,
0.2363609672,
0.4420304894,
0.3405457139,
-0.2150681615,
0.2339533716,
-0.603916049,
0.3405321836,
-0.1738830805,
-0.4660581946,
-0.4563212097,
-0.1564527452,
0.3247008324,
0.4832720757,
-0.7877032161,
-0.1075930074,
0.3331464231,
0.5365824103,
-0.8876357675,
-0.0827481672,
-0.5521370769,
0.1577447951,
0.0766048953,
-0.242350027,
-0.6071214676,
-0.1631337106,
0.1331834793,
-0.5694855452,
0.1229628474,
-0.3122121096,
0.3580568433,
0.2151400894,
-0.9038766026,
-0.4164183438,
-0.8757936358,
0.5138664246,
-0.4632094204,
0.2983735204,
0.5566440225,
0.2172703594,
-0.0542240702,
-0.4726157784,
-0.194372341,
0.2262075692,
-0.1400986463,
0.3911903501,
-0.5066452622,
0.374969542,
0.2639369965,
0.0122003816,
-0.300850302,
0.0030565648,
-0.2603271306,
-0.0189002659,
0.5474700332,
0.3541971147,
0.2938371301,
-0.0043028272,
-0.4813518524,
0.3181234002,
-0.475156039,
0.3078086376,
-0.1170092821,
0.3501752615,
-0.128813073,
0.1697891802,
-0.0662301183,
0.3641882241,
0.3976297379,
0.1300659478,
-0.4597504139,
0.1344997138,
-0.4186015725,
0.5232753754,
0.2411148399,
0.3647482693,
0.0256915633,
-0.0579067953,
0.3103028834,
0.2944133878,
0.4034797847,
-0.9667476416,
0.2767182887,
0.2817622721,
-0.5846930742,
-0.0393475443,
-0.0595841222,
-0.7670682669,
-0.7790712118,
-0.5050894618,
-0.0576933883,
-0.1638746709,
-0.3865274191,
0.1010824218,
0.1400010735,
0.2213311493,
0.4573377073,
-0.709189415,
0.8189778328,
0.311525315,
0.7387753129,
0.1603767425,
0.2643440068,
-0.9047906399,
0.1100702211,
-0.013877226,
0.8165732622,
-0.515812397,
-0.6693746448,
0.0881071612,
0.1266776174,
-0.1180305704,
-0.1499690115,
1.0271809101,
-0.1933174431,
-0.1806717366,
-0.7544157505,
-0.359179616,
-0.2921296954,
0.1006402597,
-0.4690282345,
0.7322241664,
-0.2573850155,
-0.7698705196,
0.1474245489,
-0.4603289664,
-0.4593671262,
0.057426367,
-0.1062117219,
0.0346019864,
0.3178505301,
0.2343408763,
0.4012026191,
-0.4777462482,
0.6661088467,
-0.4852151573,
-0.1211271212,
0.0131452437,
-0.2674620748,
0.4242716432,
0.347301811,
-0.4838577211,
0.1603936106,
-0.7122823,
-0.1778688282,
-0.0432918854,
0.1933470368,
-0.7233703136,
0.4967359304,
-0.0971660838,
0.4278130829,
-0.3822123408,
-0.4880911112,
-0.2327509373,
-0.3876791894,
0.2142819166,
0.7650445104,
0.2774349749,
0.4379459918,
0.0118259033,
0.6838581562,
0.003123374,
0.4315360487,
-0.1056374535,
-0.1827794164,
-0.8589744568,
-0.313929677,
-0.4984928668,
0.5846709013,
-0.5166137218,
0.0687179565,
0.5411381721,
-0.5031166077,
-0.3152986169,
-0.2578465939,
0.5258627534,
0.7955402732,
0.4081278443,
-0.1678963453,
-0.7352175713,
-0.8588918447,
-0.335032016,
-0.3048396409,
0.4598300457,
0.382186681,
-0.0217127148,
0.0146833854,
0.874874711,
-0.305177927,
-0.1948783547,
-0.0992309526,
0.3017168641,
-0.3161422312,
0.4265543222,
0.5867862105,
-0.6942358017,
-0.2808768451,
-0.2395807654,
-0.8310123086,
-0.4353168607,
-0.3151772916,
-0.3835236728,
-0.0603787936,
0.6296984553,
-0.3828567564,
0.9459508061,
0.3788737953,
-0.5758425593,
0.2705776095,
-0.0248028338,
0.534444809,
-0.8790813088,
-0.0075790598,
0.5117092729,
0.0273949895,
-0.784268856,
-0.4563591182,
-0.1284161806,
-0.2390724868,
-0.492792815,
0.3736696243,
-0.3207384944,
0.2935891747,
-0.1855508536,
0.2523828745,
0.0424746461,
0.4094318748,
0.2013801932,
0.3267455697,
0.5129175186,
-0.6824855208,
0.0792835131,
0.518999517,
0.152411446,
1.3255267143,
-0.861302197,
-0.05382853,
-0.2721935809,
0.4389797747,
-0.9324448705,
0.0420764089,
0.2217935771,
-0.1618488282,
0.1650487781,
-0.0026454176,
0.1906518936,
-0.3201344907,
0.098856315,
0.4003990889,
-0.0991377905,
-0.5479644537,
0.8955028653,
0.3056774735,
-0.4276362062,
-0.5371006727,
-0.6568020582,
0.1088817641,
-0.4554169178,
-0.7625553012,
0.1881841421,
-0.3845282793,
-0.3473097086,
-0.4456123412,
-0.1524019539,
0.0379259326,
0.2667217553,
0.5748355389,
-0.0672186315,
0.0697511584,
0.491332382,
0.2650194764,
-0.1207252294,
0.3368297815,
0.1231841594,
0.2683229148,
-0.2383152395,
-0.6432489753,
-0.7110163569,
1.0710150003,
0.3619790375,
-0.4377523959,
0.859406054,
0.4585320055,
-0.5578175187,
-0.1059179381,
-0.8057870269,
-0.5046111941,
-0.4263136685,
0.2915125489,
-0.1275887787,
-0.8327627778,
0.7879501581,
-0.3651419282,
-0.3140611351,
0.146554634,
0.3569174111,
0.0733795166,
1.488212347,
0.808462441,
-0.0615074039,
0.469833374,
0.2297661155,
0.4744374156,
-0.6080104113,
-0.381141901,
-0.8485639095,
-0.2618786991,
-0.3100454509,
0.1748657972,
0.1557866335,
0.2999447584,
-0.4698364735,
0.0415277034,
-0.537217021,
-0.0150914593,
0.0908928812,
0.3313640058,
0.0792750642,
-0.1985290498,
-0.0835486278,
-0.3539501131,
-0.6857510805,
-0.2191738486,
0.1259673834,
0.4072989225,
0.7452546954,
0.2362878472,
0.486343205,
0.0948906094,
0.3235767782,
-0.785226047,
0.6146463156,
0.2690787017,
-0.5717526078,
0.2474939227,
-0.3497475684,
-0.9297883511,
0.1561125517,
-0.2264737785,
-1.2678312063,
0.7471156716,
0.090768218,
-0.3400038183,
0.0222547054,
-0.8757190704,
0.5674614906,
-0.2995868027,
-0.6343945265,
-0.4366413653,
-0.7646743655,
0.3282974064,
0.1354297996,
0.4735080004,
0.0069634886,
0.4159962535,
1.069896698,
-0.6884917021,
1.09443295,
-0.3866363466,
0.0766331479,
0.5953035951,
0.3161334395,
0.7207638621,
0.0080524106,
-0.1242330968,
-0.5764526725,
-0.0194820538,
-0.279027462,
-0.7852042913,
0.7060067058,
-0.5336327553,
-0.7316804528,
-0.1986112297,
-0.3264955878,
-0.4823087454,
-0.0531795472,
-0.2208600044,
0.4908709526,
-0.5045235753,
0.0671099499,
0.5830103159,
-0.190350771,
0.4328365624,
0.7606726289,
0.0880973265,
-0.2189921588,
0.1579677761,
-0.1190103441,
-0.0089423126,
-0.1887558401,
0.2804855108,
-0.0782639533,
0.1110303476,
0.303948462,
0.3441993296,
-0.8923687339,
-0.4431629181,
-0.8068648577,
0.0890557095,
-0.370169729,
-0.4087848663,
-0.3797752261,
0.0060327318,
-0.4606645703,
-0.5195580125,
0.6892307401,
0.6389410496,
-0.2460400015,
0.6904478073,
-0.8716125488,
-0.0652528852,
0.3505062759,
0.1218857244,
0.3100841641,
-0.1717341691,
-0.3334094286,
0.0854693726,
-0.458240062,
-1.234926939,
0.4921248257,
0.1855233759,
0.5497035384,
0.8270139694,
0.3323338628,
1.0391584635,
-0.0424370468,
0.8423272967,
0.5661233068,
-1.2923765182,
0.966616869,
-0.3178729117,
-0.0814218447,
0.56270051,
0.3709404469,
-0.8069142103,
-0.030641567,
-0.8035020828,
-0.804695189,
0.9040078521,
0.1121889874,
-0.1943465769,
-0.417108953,
0.4411135316,
-0.4234579802,
-0.0355289802,
-0.5910670161,
-0.1767399907,
0.1040200666,
-0.103109099,
0.2974758148,
-0.5594550371,
-0.3864899278,
-0.0718873665,
0.8072103858,
-0.085507527,
0.4122908413,
0.5365290642,
0.1576082259,
-0.618560791,
0.2348267734,
0.5814716816,
0.1958609521,
0.0327210128,
0.0174221564,
0.3798693419,
-0.1912817359,
-0.0919898599,
0.0365417674,
0.4890550673,
-0.296292603,
0.1178571731,
0.7886836529,
0.4609130025,
-0.3109004796,
0.5409547091,
-0.2435000092,
-0.1259129941,
0.0689576864,
-0.2255090773,
0.1306100488,
0.5860974193,
0.1821856797,
0.1863880754,
0.5497891903,
-0.261256367,
0.215159297,
0.3989092112,
-1.0287666321,
-0.2530226707,
0.5773392916,
0.4910596311,
-0.2010677606,
0.4553608298,
0.1272940785,
-0.6085851192,
0.6326764822,
0.6765704751,
0.7773569226,
-0.8333442211,
0.3638940156,
0.4875679314,
0.1069530696,
-0.1453769654,
0.2897004783,
-0.2537073493,
-0.5995722413,
-0.3218677938,
-0.0938027427,
-0.3522171974,
-0.4941113889,
-1.2415952682,
0.3134667873,
-0.2092118859,
-0.287006706,
-0.3426507711,
-0.2095138431,
-0.6844573617,
0.3102657497,
0.1134359986,
1.0380764008,
-1.2206060886,
0.3298677504,
0.3701657057,
-0.4148731828,
-1.4246968031,
-0.5850356221,
0.3919396698,
-0.7172846198,
0.6484556198,
0.0969570205,
-0.6176133752,
-0.2292428315,
-0.7002432346,
-0.6293253303,
1.0527971983,
0.4678559303,
-0.4353831708,
0.138591662,
-0.2608043253,
0.4593494833,
-0.4036692083,
0.6330741644,
0.5393214226,
0.490901798,
0.4312892258,
-0.7646402121,
0.173305124,
-0.522904098,
-0.0463836454,
0.040540874,
-0.8218111396,
0.3841782212,
0.0375147127,
-0.4282301366,
0.0936192051,
0.5577080846,
0.1760535389,
0.6014738083,
0.5316673517,
0.3568103313,
0.9184815288,
-0.1142756045,
0.8235010505,
-0.1272293478,
0.2281705439,
1.1881293058,
-0.4566196203,
0.5289440155,
0.5711962581,
0.1434955895,
0.5588926077,
0.5780555606,
0.641391933,
0.3448931873,
0.1878648698,
-0.5541225672,
-0.4275979698,
-0.8609495163,
-0.3608367741,
0.6114037633,
0.6594157219,
-0.4024541676,
-0.3180879653,
0.2962356806,
0.337385565,
0.2937269509,
-0.4365211427,
0.7741332054,
0.3513801396,
-0.7123764753,
0.2431342304,
-0.0717186406,
0.3355198205,
-0.7987492681,
-0.0434524268,
-0.4241892993,
0.132352367,
-0.5826354623,
-0.276694268,
0.5010032654,
0.0088617057,
-0.0561608225,
-0.1450619698,
1.1265850067,
-0.297677815,
-0.2201423943,
0.766820848,
0.5646573901,
-0.1679415703,
-0.1196860224,
-0.5890372992,
0.1027163118,
-0.3030003309,
-0.2898104787,
0.2819402218,
0.6973567009,
-0.0273003262,
0.6048699021,
0.3408603668,
-0.1563957483,
-0.4544870555,
0.3211543262,
0.8479889035,
-0.4749272466,
-0.7309421301,
-0.5757887363,
0.7812527418,
-0.185011223,
-0.0346431173,
0.46438995,
-0.1417969763,
-0.0344216749,
0.3211816847,
0.4594167471,
0.1243749261,
0.2893185318,
-0.2392135412,
0.345874548,
-0.4738798738,
0.1476067901,
-0.7007594109,
-0.5047460198,
-0.3882827163,
0.7898700237,
-0.3737021685,
0.1363375485,
0.6440803409,
0.8714301586,
0.3141068518,
0.812068522,
0.1038260534,
0.2936779559,
0.5294887424,
0.6206852198,
1.0430195332,
-0.1615535617,
0.3590908945,
-0.0497902036,
-0.438836664,
-0.0411798283,
-1.0176727772,
-0.5716104507,
-0.5710625052,
-0.3368324339,
-0.4593141377,
0.0014880702,
0.9458662271,
0.8044121861,
-0.5083658099,
-0.1707470417,
-0.3653236032,
-0.0378321894,
-0.3756496012,
-0.2366709858,
0.1367851198,
-0.1213747337,
-0.0716263875,
0.3865483105,
0.2964111269,
-0.2645269036,
0.0897128135,
-0.1403509527,
-0.4086101353,
0.4413830936,
0.6742357016,
0.4546154141,
-0.4629586935,
-0.3945511281,
0.0537386127,
0.1238171905,
-0.0163431894,
1.1537735462,
-0.7594096661,
0.6125004292,
-0.0793763027,
0.5674905181,
0.4438549578,
-0.0346972793,
0.5489680767,
-0.615223527,
0.2088181674,
0.06820824,
0.5788195133,
0.1895166039,
-0.94114393,
0.4038859904,
0.1446958929,
-0.5990166664,
-0.5588383079,
0.3982411027,
-1.3339757919,
-0.0011797722,
0.9529955983,
-0.3490796387,
0.1266057789,
0.0379772075,
-0.7305237055,
0.5767473578,
-0.4921050966,
0.5100132227,
0.4957265258,
-0.3415556252,
-0.3378088176,
-0.0890000239,
0.3157392442,
0.6748040318,
-0.8893467188,
0.2186105251,
0.5822349191,
-0.2593499124,
-0.1079856083,
0.6741349697,
0.0538565367,
0.0908454135,
-0.2232088298,
0.0950264186,
0.3011570573,
-0.3084806204,
-0.2527781725,
0.1102061123,
-0.0315987207,
0.2716982961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17716v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17716v1
|
Enhancing Large Language Model with Decomposed Reasoning for Emotion Cause Pair Extraction
| 2024-01-31T10:20:01 | 2024-01-31T10:20:01 |
Jialiang Wu, Yi Shen, Ziheng Zhang, Longjun Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction (ECPE) involves extracting clause pairs
representing emotions and their causes in a document. Existing methods tend to
overfit spurious correlations, such as positional bias in existing benchmark
datasets, rather than capturing semantic features. Inspired by recent work, we
explore leveraging large language model (LLM) to address ECPE task without
additional training. Despite strong capabilities, LLMs suffer from
uncontrollable outputs, resulting in mediocre performance. To address this, we
introduce chain-of-thought to mimic human cognitive process and propose the
Decomposed Emotion-Cause Chain (DECC) framework. Combining inducing inference
and logical pruning, DECC guides LLMs to tackle ECPE task. We further enhance
the framework by incorporating in-context learning. Experiment results
demonstrate the strength of DECC compared to state-of-the-art supervised
fine-tuning methods. Finally, we analyze the effectiveness of each component
and the robustness of the method in various scenarios, including different LLM
bases, rebalanced datasets, and multi-pair extraction.
|
[
-0.4851224422,
-0.8729999661,
0.6405499578,
-0.1635885984,
-0.3758937716,
-0.0742861032,
-0.5125845671,
-0.5593752265,
0.2096239626,
0.553452909,
-0.7301250696,
-0.5355042219,
-0.5006113052,
0.1365938038,
-0.4401747882,
0.863399446,
0.1083072424,
-0.3242180943,
-0.23164545,
0.0005874243,
-0.158151865,
-0.6935688853,
-0.8751907945,
-0.2525528967,
0.4293502867,
0.6177126765,
0.1427660137,
0.0425172485,
0.2621900141,
0.3199188113,
-0.0234800149,
0.4146853387,
-0.5543570518,
0.22506845,
-0.1433360726,
-0.4636197686,
-0.6551908851,
-0.1219678447,
0.2785678506,
0.4627100825,
-0.3651211858,
-0.0651951507,
-0.0186856687,
0.9217044711,
-0.7367380857,
0.1189280599,
-0.8378949761,
-0.1760178506,
0.0061135977,
-0.1788694263,
-0.5824910402,
-0.1225329936,
0.0557799414,
-0.298871845,
0.0033489661,
0.1158749983,
0.4946525097,
0.3151924908,
-0.7281160355,
-0.2530319989,
-0.4300052524,
0.6997724771,
-0.9215561748,
0.340272367,
0.3683834672,
-0.3551695645,
-0.3320937455,
-0.4952671528,
-0.6256104112,
0.1141334921,
0.1067957878,
0.2762294114,
-0.1363675743,
0.2316601872,
0.4596651196,
0.3687199652,
-0.378031224,
0.2168572694,
-0.0853327587,
0.1207948104,
0.7325981855,
0.1713623852,
0.5575412512,
-0.0347042717,
-0.3574129939,
-0.0738651976,
-0.8456627131,
0.0591240861,
0.4280507267,
0.1013222337,
-0.236894086,
0.3054176271,
-0.0070608463,
0.4540165663,
0.0373704135,
0.1857424527,
0.1930230707,
0.0568345413,
-0.2987139821,
0.2154227048,
0.8128243089,
0.433373183,
0.2223044783,
-0.0556607582,
-0.179580912,
0.3296914995,
0.295515269,
-0.9407476783,
-0.2391859591,
0.5307961106,
-0.4084709585,
-0.3223064244,
-0.0796388686,
-1.2510824203,
-0.4181421995,
-0.4848915339,
0.032151822,
-0.4379864037,
-0.583315134,
0.1933543086,
0.0250746198,
0.151723817,
0.1761749089,
-0.986048162,
0.408497721,
0.9421910644,
0.4710873961,
-0.109021455,
-0.0098503781,
-0.6781160831,
-0.1774626076,
-0.3144541979,
0.6835786104,
-0.5783472657,
-0.0463041589,
0.2465343028,
0.1171035469,
0.0807030275,
-0.4453796148,
0.95880723,
-0.3819586337,
0.2437244654,
-0.2625618875,
-0.7228804231,
-0.1478954852,
0.2895610034,
-0.6254362464,
0.9482956529,
-0.1786094308,
-0.9397688508,
0.1072235852,
-0.5164653659,
-0.5918182731,
-0.084671773,
-0.0866997987,
-0.2773934007,
0.3399931788,
0.3644976318,
0.5718052983,
-0.6016806364,
0.2605378628,
-0.5153570175,
-0.0216820892,
0.1622987986,
-0.1814864427,
0.6781474948,
0.0165945143,
-0.37041682,
0.1029305533,
-0.9835759997,
-0.1205759123,
0.1175831556,
-0.1866990924,
-0.7860447764,
0.235663265,
-0.136180982,
0.7243905067,
0.0251745749,
-0.5196647048,
0.0293682199,
-0.6733720303,
0.6315037608,
0.8143366575,
0.1997752339,
0.3674423993,
0.221945107,
0.4681694508,
0.1052846313,
-0.1431128979,
-0.2020470649,
-0.1136504486,
-0.7224040031,
-0.26057899,
-0.1492973417,
0.2766800523,
-0.6819756031,
0.589843154,
0.0591424629,
-0.1222165599,
-0.4045103788,
0.2207727283,
0.350581646,
0.7403899431,
0.3479005694,
-0.1591149569,
-0.6042593718,
-0.7367956638,
-0.1500727981,
-0.1138001904,
-0.1355522722,
0.1579276174,
0.4068900347,
-0.0991007388,
0.4614513516,
-0.5342460275,
0.0072229663,
-0.2446258068,
0.354341954,
0.0779236332,
0.2573060691,
0.1565715224,
-0.6798175573,
0.046682395,
-0.1641079932,
-0.6528770328,
-0.3424662054,
-0.2268110514,
-0.4352658391,
0.4866041243,
0.5904578567,
-0.5319523811,
0.3087974191,
0.6630982757,
-0.5169135928,
0.5444842577,
-0.2859219313,
0.1707191467,
-1.1430857182,
0.0337341353,
0.3245213628,
-0.0557392538,
-0.5146533847,
0.0278778933,
0.1710641235,
-0.0253624674,
-0.3593799174,
0.1255894452,
-0.4377311766,
0.0187579878,
-0.2519498169,
0.4030393064,
0.1870512366,
0.5974138379,
0.1525651366,
0.0634860024,
0.4551154077,
-0.3578206301,
0.4787662625,
0.2313238382,
-0.3256572783,
0.8333806992,
-0.4456238747,
0.2553842664,
-0.22644113,
0.2881886661,
-0.8126668334,
-0.1492809504,
0.0014264388,
0.0192790888,
0.3503329158,
-0.0233440269,
-0.6734322309,
-0.3431440294,
-0.3196747899,
0.2747269869,
0.6101824045,
-0.8367720246,
0.6092203259,
0.3092848361,
-0.0654800907,
-0.1433441937,
-0.5274078846,
0.1453733593,
-0.6551290154,
-0.612682879,
0.3863894343,
-0.011657726,
-0.3571753502,
-0.33681041,
-0.2042406946,
0.0196683221,
0.1722276211,
0.4081912637,
0.2022863626,
0.0763003677,
0.5280277133,
-0.0102414554,
-0.0202109981,
0.6109662652,
0.1280831397,
0.549148798,
-0.2313203812,
-0.1602250338,
-0.2525559962,
0.5055451989,
0.8499883413,
-0.4820128381,
0.594233036,
0.3467811346,
-0.4492202401,
-0.5622558594,
-0.5158324838,
-0.4573654532,
-0.4001309276,
0.3654805124,
-0.2008302063,
-0.6708037853,
0.5341420174,
-0.6086921692,
-0.2478622943,
0.1701084524,
0.6501964927,
-0.1005143821,
0.845415175,
0.4670089483,
-0.25497365,
0.5424832106,
-0.1824326366,
0.3481239676,
-1.0719482899,
-0.2412152588,
-0.3322063684,
-0.2993142903,
-0.441070348,
-0.0952947587,
0.2145616859,
0.2209931761,
-0.3262289464,
0.15752621,
-0.3251339793,
0.3005740047,
0.3685556948,
0.4830933809,
0.2321822047,
-0.1983590275,
0.0154824723,
0.0639155135,
-0.5594556332,
-0.2393518686,
0.8318802714,
0.2397501767,
0.6224550605,
-0.0686943978,
0.6748454571,
-0.0573892854,
0.0804850683,
-0.7254686952,
0.573084116,
-0.1434135437,
-0.3422288001,
-0.082895495,
-0.3700703681,
-0.8801327348,
0.2096584439,
-0.3840554059,
-1.0780705214,
0.1800812632,
0.0901609808,
-0.0994339287,
0.3628661931,
-0.5401450396,
0.9247731566,
-0.3645755053,
-0.538839519,
-0.6344932318,
-0.6872540116,
0.6679077744,
-0.2064293027,
0.3726699054,
-0.0330236927,
0.1799340546,
0.6671018004,
-0.6786744595,
0.9171043634,
0.1363156438,
-0.4781317711,
0.4010002911,
0.1311718971,
0.8722838163,
-0.1962435246,
-0.2801447511,
0.0021369711,
-0.3200929463,
-0.1334110349,
-0.6846552491,
0.8256630898,
-0.4119513035,
-0.5012125373,
0.0719659179,
-0.3831891418,
-0.256174922,
-0.1049202159,
0.0842676535,
0.5798668265,
-0.0390106104,
0.1976108551,
0.4357357323,
-0.3936457038,
0.6566416025,
0.4023735225,
0.02409954,
-0.446213901,
0.5749681592,
-0.4271850586,
0.3486644626,
0.353798151,
0.348918736,
-0.2333561182,
-0.0791891292,
-0.0009683664,
0.2050337344,
-0.6344026923,
-0.1727778912,
-0.5244262218,
0.244897902,
-0.1305177361,
-0.1408358961,
-0.4825296998,
0.0082154712,
-0.1141726822,
-0.3738310337,
0.4993789792,
0.2985286117,
0.0039887195,
-0.0597082265,
-0.7976540923,
0.4595253766,
0.2690497935,
0.1887284666,
0.1751390696,
-0.3741810322,
-0.1482269615,
-0.0019440309,
-0.2511870861,
-1.0574998856,
0.6556309462,
0.1247066781,
0.2204227597,
0.6149551868,
0.5998226404,
0.6398431659,
-0.2829200327,
0.6753172278,
0.3401098847,
-1.1909953356,
0.775472343,
-0.2273051888,
-0.0331413373,
0.3160379231,
0.3594740033,
-0.5257404447,
-0.4083155692,
-0.9062342644,
-1.1869622469,
0.5114524364,
0.0862040222,
-0.1666575819,
-0.3522432446,
0.3302048147,
-0.181208089,
0.0866699368,
-0.5226026177,
-0.0614872351,
0.2364945263,
-0.3223255873,
0.0723843798,
-0.4019675255,
-0.0526828207,
-0.1995519549,
0.6329847574,
-0.1306922287,
-0.1006144881,
0.3568788171,
-0.0986653119,
-0.4216087461,
0.4255433381,
0.3982583284,
0.2798978686,
-0.2293768227,
0.406082958,
0.2816646695,
0.1187568679,
-0.0186970476,
-0.1868025661,
0.3154479563,
-0.4809524119,
0.5258303881,
0.7182399631,
0.4288513958,
-0.9231158495,
0.5902978182,
0.0933350548,
-0.1017656028,
-0.2413951159,
-0.1977096349,
0.2998071909,
0.403358072,
0.1329627633,
-0.1936647445,
0.2110612839,
-0.7005712986,
0.205627948,
0.4458521605,
-0.2164958417,
-0.6106898189,
0.4892488718,
0.5561614633,
-0.2031205893,
0.8495921493,
-0.1004941612,
-0.8945060968,
0.8354931474,
0.6633210182,
0.9859562516,
-0.1932727098,
0.0548208989,
0.478204757,
0.225433737,
-0.2494213134,
0.2139883935,
-0.1248640344,
-0.8454834819,
-0.6741618514,
-0.2657822073,
-0.3490361571,
0.2638500929,
-0.7968407273,
0.4396860003,
-0.1320734173,
0.2036450505,
-0.4565059841,
-0.1539986134,
-0.7075764537,
0.1983894259,
0.5743525624,
0.6179727316,
-1.1499193907,
0.8791453838,
0.6701722741,
-0.3830221295,
-0.904194653,
-0.0174122732,
0.0254138559,
-0.4931965172,
0.7790888548,
0.2700157166,
0.0306717493,
-0.0532817915,
-0.435174197,
-0.3529828489,
0.862341702,
0.3412469327,
-0.9242163897,
0.2317343056,
-0.1349383742,
0.6898345947,
-0.5287559032,
0.3597097993,
0.6276428699,
0.3336713612,
-0.019392807,
-0.4879563153,
0.5114296675,
-0.1573614478,
-0.3222412467,
0.39970842,
-0.6590593457,
0.5224094987,
-0.2306055427,
-0.1482613683,
-0.4973708391,
0.2084287107,
0.29654181,
0.3221304119,
0.7836429477,
0.852098763,
0.8892755508,
0.2574499547,
1.01222682,
-0.5137203336,
0.3405652344,
1.2664387226,
-0.4913281202,
1.075497508,
0.6376401782,
-0.1283632219,
0.7421619296,
0.515781343,
0.3304490745,
0.4115250111,
0.3289967477,
-0.3701808155,
-0.6236876249,
0.05162232,
-0.0484577157,
0.5040473342,
0.5880971551,
-0.5577173233,
-0.1307917386,
-0.2686066031,
0.052717302,
0.0624321625,
-0.3702927828,
0.7792976499,
0.4100702405,
-0.5997434258,
0.4933620393,
-0.4571721554,
0.6424373984,
-0.1899963319,
-0.1772243977,
-0.3460930288,
0.1186046079,
-0.3785259128,
-0.3918441534,
0.2376994342,
0.1162673458,
-0.0096440427,
-0.1688342541,
0.8717464209,
-0.7303771377,
-0.4305562377,
0.5564181209,
0.3658881187,
0.0585811473,
-0.3801555336,
-0.419862777,
0.1014120951,
-0.0681359917,
-0.5393654108,
0.3333856761,
0.9353842139,
0.1146867946,
0.5563471317,
0.6403419375,
0.0472616851,
-0.4779674411,
0.1973220259,
0.8635969758,
-0.8523762226,
-0.2675773203,
-1.2954906225,
0.8209617734,
-0.277866751,
-0.1624406725,
0.3254987299,
0.283531934,
0.4066245854,
0.0490884259,
0.536876142,
0.0036195735,
0.1081545949,
-0.5382663012,
0.4434270263,
-0.592790246,
0.3292285204,
-0.6229393482,
-0.8467031717,
-0.1906470656,
0.4200809598,
-0.3417929411,
-0.2912665308,
0.9726179838,
0.6815419197,
0.118832849,
0.1058445573,
0.4104450345,
0.4709955454,
0.4021633863,
1.0923316479,
0.7806289792,
-0.2911580205,
0.4078812003,
-0.2654564381,
-0.3416627944,
-0.2261554599,
-1.3586310148,
-0.9602743387,
-0.608718276,
-0.7251921892,
-0.3030729592,
-0.1548477858,
1.1736675501,
0.5384290814,
-0.6022256613,
0.1935411692,
-0.5290805697,
0.1863064915,
-0.1604933441,
-0.2334510237,
0.5041705966,
-0.4014115632,
-0.6679034829,
0.3802513182,
0.2759596705,
-0.3666345477,
0.0202310737,
-0.005917212,
-0.0485036187,
-0.010770971,
0.8736766577,
0.1546893269,
-0.7301477194,
-0.3940836787,
-0.4501887858,
0.1397303939,
0.0455263965,
0.8636969924,
-0.6126629114,
0.4344376624,
0.5959060788,
0.6038910747,
0.4280208647,
0.1726177335,
0.8143523335,
-0.7267419696,
0.0368534848,
-0.0385456644,
0.7885818481,
0.2439171225,
-0.4249763489,
0.5626032948,
0.0808904916,
-0.6934270263,
-0.6522632837,
0.3250050247,
-1.1610369682,
-0.3364885747,
1.3147126436,
-0.3544048965,
-0.1836621463,
0.2829172015,
-0.3189303577,
0.42971012,
-0.5074156523,
0.9848275185,
0.6522939205,
-0.1792862266,
-0.3921495378,
-0.2067697197,
0.1993670166,
0.4543392062,
-1.2648195028,
0.4746950269,
0.6046901941,
0.0947217494,
-0.1252325922,
0.2321769595,
-0.0714731738,
-0.1859585792,
-0.0416350923,
0.6322064996,
0.0817658603,
0.035645932,
-0.4185135663,
0.2358108312,
-0.1414550096,
0.0284569524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17703v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17703v1
|
WSC+: Enhancing The Winograd Schema Challenge Using Tree-of-Experts
| 2024-01-31T09:49:22 | 2024-01-31T09:49:22 |
Pardis Sadat Zahraei, Ali Emami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7; K.4.1
|
The Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC) serves as a prominent benchmark for
evaluating machine understanding. While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at
answering WSC questions, their ability to generate such questions remains less
explored. In this work, we propose Tree-of-Experts (ToE), a novel prompting
method which enhances the generation of WSC instances (50% valid cases vs. 10%
in recent methods). Using this approach, we introduce WSC+, a novel dataset
comprising 3,026 LLM-generated sentences. Notably, we extend the WSC framework
by incorporating new 'ambiguous' and 'offensive' categories, providing a deeper
insight into model overconfidence and bias. Our analysis reveals nuances in
generation-evaluation consistency, suggesting that LLMs may not always
outperform in evaluating their own generated questions when compared to those
crafted by other models. On WSC+, GPT-4, the top-performing LLM, achieves an
accuracy of 68.7%, significantly below the human benchmark of 95.1%.
|
[
-0.4903711975,
-0.5636116862,
0.7744241357,
-0.1540643126,
-0.1071104854,
0.5887432098,
-0.3015170395,
-0.7352213264,
-0.1722486466,
0.2207158357,
-0.6925649047,
-0.5594756007,
-0.6399880648,
0.1647108644,
-0.2191535681,
0.9420979619,
0.1460532844,
-0.2268830538,
-0.4126410484,
-0.1078740507,
-0.5502894521,
-0.3677009046,
-0.2380829453,
-0.0372914784,
0.3784211576,
0.7383359075,
0.8500630856,
0.4093362689,
0.4677175879,
0.2791995704,
-0.3780686557,
0.2807630002,
-0.3726318777,
0.4403122365,
-0.2722642422,
-0.2820665538,
-0.5457561612,
-0.016938528,
0.2073355764,
0.8558137417,
-0.4774104357,
0.2554098964,
-0.0094148181,
0.5838292241,
-0.6272159219,
0.2496049255,
-1.1438935995,
-0.0845420659,
-0.3093446195,
-0.1589642614,
-0.6456310749,
-0.3759498894,
0.3194963634,
-0.7574986815,
0.342567116,
0.2619512379,
0.7180120945,
0.2191529423,
-0.5028599501,
-0.3354848921,
-0.2977146208,
0.6439614296,
-0.6137991548,
0.2248553336,
0.2020102292,
0.4291553199,
-0.402443707,
-0.3367452621,
-0.4480887949,
-0.350613445,
-0.0220800247,
0.2058680654,
-0.4838466644,
0.0366233774,
0.5554661751,
0.2597363889,
-0.5693885684,
0.1512947828,
-0.2120079249,
-0.1882710904,
0.5746565461,
0.3473755121,
-0.1262018383,
-0.2784490883,
-0.0601431616,
-0.1433918625,
-0.767537415,
0.1175108626,
0.4694122076,
0.1242648885,
0.4290955365,
0.5450422168,
-0.4395140111,
0.8441742063,
0.1869119704,
0.0753196031,
0.3164994121,
-0.1887218952,
-0.0637062639,
0.1442411244,
0.4489403963,
0.3395138085,
0.2465056181,
0.030635735,
0.0344150811,
0.3372125328,
0.1254971027,
-0.630818069,
-0.1934386194,
0.2486462742,
-0.3873501122,
-0.7422215343,
0.0407950431,
-0.5785316229,
-0.4413880408,
-0.1635507345,
-0.0176815894,
-0.4545274973,
-0.4414326847,
0.431830138,
-0.3479628563,
0.2082203031,
0.3915916383,
-0.5856283307,
0.3414845467,
0.6703492403,
0.2465644032,
-0.0653389916,
-0.2775557935,
-0.678627789,
0.1570413709,
-0.5644042492,
0.9351596832,
-0.8862230778,
-0.2902329564,
-0.3529036045,
-0.0948846638,
0.1360095143,
-0.2782117128,
0.4785388708,
-0.2762874365,
0.6767629385,
-0.5101659894,
-0.419493109,
-0.0429819971,
0.4146519303,
-0.2689880729,
1.4897009134,
0.3985298574,
-1.1442378759,
0.5491954684,
-0.7591845393,
-0.2395743132,
0.4669536948,
-0.29462412,
-0.0588381141,
0.2734062374,
0.4232499897,
0.3999692202,
-0.430785507,
0.7941023111,
-0.3921895027,
-0.1811695993,
0.0824965462,
-0.4856237769,
0.8109389544,
0.2000726908,
-0.373074621,
0.3046272993,
-0.8249323368,
0.1977941245,
0.3643946946,
-0.0866080299,
-0.5494835377,
0.1112965345,
-0.4695961475,
0.345521003,
0.1000775099,
-0.8984523416,
0.4306845367,
-0.2440118343,
0.4605766535,
0.7724208832,
0.0039400617,
0.0175379645,
-0.1487743855,
0.6033402681,
-0.1895069331,
0.2550680041,
-0.373175025,
-0.6377434731,
-0.5115099549,
0.0066330107,
0.1815624982,
0.5736624002,
-0.7716822624,
0.4725714028,
-0.3037207425,
-0.8204740286,
-0.6985340714,
-0.183518365,
0.4084624946,
0.746856153,
0.4353196919,
-0.2286809087,
-0.4431169331,
-0.8539386988,
-0.0225802418,
-0.4456610084,
-0.1762197614,
0.5686092973,
0.3466054797,
0.1313651651,
1.0788136721,
-0.6384122968,
0.2601788044,
-0.3119092286,
0.0721903145,
0.066941835,
0.4064095318,
0.3439491093,
-0.3410314918,
-0.4501197934,
-0.0500152968,
-0.6288917065,
-0.0399497747,
-0.0468296632,
-0.1385799199,
0.1305277497,
0.5548937321,
-0.8492477536,
0.1374856383,
0.4952925742,
-0.6645343304,
0.8414036632,
-0.2656055987,
0.0874262378,
-1.0232152939,
0.1257176697,
-0.3095170557,
-0.2741583586,
-0.2557130158,
0.2816490531,
0.084136948,
-0.1510591209,
-0.4167129993,
0.0709864721,
-0.5547192693,
-0.0222658273,
0.255641222,
0.2803948522,
0.0626621321,
0.3954498768,
0.0435736217,
0.5251100063,
0.8554410934,
-0.3036428392,
0.2843586802,
0.3345588148,
-0.575820148,
0.7649224401,
-0.6889747381,
0.2784442604,
-0.2911041081,
0.3153175414,
-1.0666505098,
-0.332698375,
0.0679646432,
-0.270536691,
0.4573870301,
-0.1418056339,
-0.4956682622,
-0.8573668599,
-0.4032876492,
0.3085374832,
0.5741822124,
-0.4979658425,
0.3335027397,
0.295694977,
-0.3387273252,
-0.7424793243,
-0.2446475178,
0.3702896833,
-0.1711391509,
-0.6897650957,
0.45773682,
-0.1781233698,
-0.1849867553,
-0.0443459265,
-0.1429001391,
0.4823357165,
0.3001759648,
0.0430082455,
0.3139130473,
-0.4487394392,
0.0920512602,
0.3430847228,
-0.1588202417,
0.1238790601,
-0.2620781362,
0.4105549753,
-0.4447336495,
-0.6091938019,
-0.3272388577,
0.497433275,
0.5532858372,
-0.4525799453,
0.2665879726,
0.1903941184,
-0.0824374259,
0.1598376185,
-0.665848434,
-0.2185887098,
-0.5176461339,
0.5460121036,
-0.5145373344,
-1.0364243984,
0.2039983422,
-0.0835043639,
0.2047404647,
0.5083270073,
0.2310089916,
-0.2286093384,
1.4641507864,
0.4871644676,
-0.1313580573,
0.0887453333,
0.1761631519,
-0.117098324,
-0.6579141021,
-0.3676225245,
-0.7712825537,
-0.0727108642,
-0.5178707838,
-0.2998079658,
0.0527587347,
0.0151983956,
-0.2792808115,
0.5045644641,
-0.7826508284,
0.6065183878,
0.3101676106,
-0.0340300277,
0.3797326088,
-0.091701664,
-0.1293276697,
-0.1257539392,
-1.0035777092,
-0.3523614109,
0.8859663606,
0.4864081144,
0.5907734632,
-0.0656183586,
0.4896651506,
0.1830350459,
0.4644952416,
-0.623006165,
0.6059187055,
0.1486032307,
-0.6283794045,
-0.3740383089,
-0.4058385789,
-0.9874936938,
0.232497409,
-0.3200332522,
-0.697039783,
0.1593411714,
0.1671880186,
-0.3041644394,
0.1915364861,
-0.3903777599,
0.8153134584,
-0.3718626201,
-0.0314895324,
-0.0541759431,
-0.7511660457,
0.2609811723,
0.140843004,
0.2803164423,
-0.2481115162,
-0.0297673699,
0.7143207192,
-0.2526957691,
0.5832104087,
-0.4933297932,
-0.3423270881,
0.4290803373,
0.3710668683,
0.8556997776,
-0.1735076457,
-0.2299478203,
-0.0619350187,
-0.0816229433,
-0.3263864517,
-0.4236694574,
0.3529935479,
-0.2412171215,
-0.823831141,
-0.4040090442,
-0.6102741957,
-0.4586979449,
0.2799400091,
0.1547370851,
0.3954838216,
-0.3579495251,
0.3351356685,
0.6431649327,
-0.2667423189,
0.1469355524,
0.6343735456,
-0.2393059433,
-0.147196874,
0.8856393099,
-0.1850447208,
0.2975860238,
-0.0455392115,
0.4271900952,
-0.2351516783,
-0.741830647,
-0.7458823323,
0.0187261533,
-0.5692045689,
-0.5058014989,
-0.7050246,
0.0857445672,
-0.1789661497,
-0.0020600779,
-0.2999321222,
-0.5442222357,
0.0950918645,
-0.5095641017,
0.5384393334,
0.9354237914,
0.3207291961,
0.260985285,
-0.6342425346,
-0.106699422,
0.2015692741,
0.3398641944,
-0.0284803882,
-0.527012825,
0.1928297132,
-0.1185678542,
-0.333853811,
-0.9942350388,
-0.0611078627,
0.1907640994,
0.7015803456,
0.4593410194,
0.1617683023,
0.7790004015,
-0.4906434715,
0.7619479299,
0.0991565734,
-1.1201299429,
0.4991032779,
-0.6442230344,
0.2334674001,
0.7745864987,
0.2928605378,
-0.5374046564,
-0.9903968573,
-0.9769028425,
-0.8160157204,
0.7410811186,
0.2252345234,
0.1212313771,
-0.2078936845,
0.2273214906,
0.3990986645,
0.191409573,
-0.4093411863,
-0.0098482696,
-0.1635601521,
-0.3065772653,
0.2270374149,
-0.3439393938,
0.0512111112,
-0.1766697317,
0.430421114,
-0.2803488076,
-0.0905352309,
0.0536859445,
-0.0463047251,
-0.1829195619,
0.4834869802,
0.46898821,
0.7443121672,
-0.20346196,
0.0618119352,
0.5381629467,
-0.1916167587,
-0.0966066122,
-0.1822335273,
-0.1248581037,
-0.0049962117,
0.5246753693,
0.7104164362,
0.2168817967,
-0.6885871887,
0.5410076976,
-0.1079849824,
-0.5652080774,
0.1097632051,
0.1434976757,
0.2638201118,
-0.0683013052,
0.6010013819,
0.2647534013,
0.0371051282,
-0.3996612728,
0.2641254365,
0.6146757603,
-0.3896769583,
-0.1260436624,
0.4916893542,
0.1898918599,
-0.0966344327,
0.4668055773,
-0.4122033715,
-0.7482839823,
0.689342618,
0.5500721931,
0.3737409711,
-0.3505049348,
0.3870475888,
0.3732272089,
0.4639674723,
-0.08964248,
0.6278356314,
-0.2006913871,
-0.4593597054,
-0.5276406407,
-0.2032391578,
-0.5160191059,
0.0288005285,
-1.0622116327,
0.2262201905,
-0.0893803835,
0.0398520268,
-0.1124193966,
-0.1314782351,
-0.7527318001,
0.0323349461,
0.0505189709,
1.2776488066,
-0.8708364367,
0.8406517506,
0.3994600773,
-0.0221090913,
-0.8006951213,
-0.191517517,
-0.2515536249,
-0.628423512,
0.1807844192,
0.25846228,
-0.0969404653,
0.0143619822,
-0.6491676569,
-0.910071969,
1.0391099453,
0.4094363153,
-0.8784186244,
-0.0320111141,
-0.1013858914,
0.6336860061,
-0.5915444493,
0.4640245438,
0.7936195135,
0.60526371,
0.0273241624,
-0.8361344337,
0.3605606556,
-0.2409874499,
-0.266937077,
0.1722273529,
-0.2608702183,
0.7132716775,
-0.5499584079,
-0.2021448612,
-0.1037853807,
0.5722024441,
0.5186085701,
0.2387295365,
0.8847540617,
0.2276168615,
1.3063035011,
0.0652455762,
0.9522290826,
-0.1414352059,
0.2129824609,
1.3680939674,
-0.4348181784,
0.8297135234,
0.4003866911,
-0.2881904244,
0.7651646137,
0.8917816281,
-0.1130056679,
0.2942058444,
0.2770531476,
0.0712642148,
-0.5041027069,
-0.0727904513,
-0.7381560802,
0.5721104145,
0.5190464258,
-0.0133008221,
-0.3350931108,
-0.0286451578,
0.1482439488,
0.0729936659,
-0.1357742995,
0.8857239485,
-0.3338030577,
-0.8498884439,
0.483768791,
-0.140451476,
0.6536082625,
-0.5500364304,
-0.0509800315,
-0.1883764565,
-0.2192926258,
-0.2580692768,
-0.969481051,
0.2028440833,
0.3227496445,
0.0024992516,
-0.069747448,
0.5780444741,
-0.5318701267,
-0.6669104695,
0.2680462301,
0.6173496246,
0.3405672312,
-0.2111607641,
-0.6940306425,
-0.158396557,
0.1604654789,
-0.2961870432,
0.2428270131,
0.5863558054,
-0.3661318421,
0.620378077,
0.8021756411,
-0.0167318918,
-0.241988197,
0.0009442075,
1.0916817188,
-0.603717804,
-0.3357276022,
-0.8458577394,
0.5035194755,
-0.3291124403,
-0.275803417,
0.7203427553,
0.5521281958,
0.8162966371,
0.0539351813,
0.9317014813,
-0.3265376985,
0.5279456377,
-0.288579613,
0.7027000189,
-0.4739082754,
0.1404629201,
-0.6815443039,
-0.7850521803,
-0.0490044728,
0.39015764,
-0.1770545393,
-0.1769310981,
0.7263498306,
0.6975613832,
-0.0641275272,
0.2387392372,
0.1365978718,
0.1065011024,
0.4114530385,
0.847235024,
1.1184518337,
-0.1267937869,
0.9146208763,
-0.2058971971,
-0.3917659521,
-0.053170871,
-1.3010158539,
-0.7317233682,
-0.369528681,
-0.2385964096,
-0.3462541103,
-0.0810496882,
0.899104476,
0.5957442522,
-0.9330258965,
0.0920579731,
-0.2080492973,
0.0963296741,
-0.3144914806,
-0.1357445717,
0.539942503,
-0.2557354569,
-0.3165819943,
0.7199237347,
0.09991014,
-0.1085302308,
-0.2327799201,
-0.2089125961,
0.3043322563,
0.036637608,
0.6479944587,
-0.057048846,
-0.6851898432,
-0.5305198431,
0.3647656143,
-0.0274236519,
0.0483736619,
0.928271234,
-0.9040798545,
0.4588005841,
0.3506620824,
0.4618709087,
0.327275455,
0.2560808659,
0.450870961,
-0.6276639104,
0.1025708392,
0.3456456065,
0.3259781003,
0.3615313768,
-0.5645994544,
0.3824109733,
0.1643057019,
-0.2762224972,
-1.0773066282,
0.2838285565,
-0.8010079861,
-0.3622276187,
0.9230342507,
-0.1443244964,
0.0400972366,
-0.4414839745,
-0.6430079937,
-0.1130988449,
-0.5808879733,
0.769413054,
0.8490265608,
-0.1304640025,
0.061797224,
-0.3070767522,
0.5540289283,
0.6451237798,
-0.9244617224,
0.6005934477,
0.5407250524,
0.2577301264,
-0.0086108586,
0.532810092,
-0.0836986676,
0.409327656,
0.0521670543,
0.0217999015,
-0.6328971386,
-0.5362355709,
-0.0431459062,
0.3455668688,
0.2354940474,
0.0591367297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17692v1
|
Mitigating the Problem of Strong Priors in LMs with Context Extrapolation
| 2024-01-31T09:28:06 | 2024-01-31T09:28:06 |
Raymond Douglas, Andis Draguns, Tomáš Gavenčiak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) have become important tools in a variety of
applications, from data processing to the creation of instruction-following
assistants. But despite their advantages, LMs have certain idiosyncratic
limitations such as the problem of `strong priors', where a model learns to
output typical continuations in response to certain, usually local, portions of
the input regardless of any earlier instructions. For example, prompt injection
attacks can induce models to ignore explicit directives. In some cases, larger
models have been shown to be more susceptible to these problems than similar
smaller models, an example of the phenomenon of `inverse scaling'. We develop a
new technique for mitigating the problem of strong priors: we take the original
set of instructions, produce a weakened version of the original prompt that is
even more susceptible to the strong priors problem, and then extrapolate the
continuation away from the weakened prompt. This lets us infer how the model
would continue a hypothetical strengthened set of instructions. Our technique
conceptualises LMs as mixture models which combine a family of data generation
processes, reinforcing the desired elements of the mixture. Our approach works
at inference time, removing any need for retraining. We apply it to eleven
models including GPT-2, GPT-3, Llama 2, and Mistral on four tasks, and find
improvements in 41/44. Across all 44 combinations the median increase in
proportion of tasks completed is 40%.
|
[
-0.2828563154,
-0.835767746,
0.7619594336,
0.0719570443,
-0.1711184531,
-0.3847017884,
-0.3678864539,
-0.0546893589,
-0.053209167,
0.9336996078,
-0.4697907865,
-0.1826259494,
-0.49645257,
-0.1454422176,
-0.3428827226,
1.0422908068,
-0.08067552,
0.0991831198,
-0.2024539858,
0.0434904024,
-0.6555153728,
-0.6574215889,
-0.6829810739,
-0.5466077924,
0.2267571688,
0.352825731,
0.7304047942,
0.4747689068,
0.4660888314,
0.238180235,
-0.167750299,
0.0808044001,
-0.5221943855,
0.486061573,
-0.1634813696,
-0.6016002893,
-0.3077130914,
-0.2886834443,
0.837097764,
0.8860529661,
-0.2017192096,
-0.1404705048,
0.3704704046,
0.6761458516,
-0.6380684972,
-0.1028036028,
-0.6805197001,
-0.0587957948,
0.1383058876,
-0.2975893617,
-0.5537395477,
-0.0288900007,
0.0572487786,
-0.4424926043,
0.1160880849,
-0.3029201925,
0.5034381747,
0.2225242853,
-0.416056186,
0.0795506537,
-1.0631123781,
0.9097232223,
-0.8486761451,
0.1888322532,
0.4948690534,
0.2815113068,
-0.5251169205,
-0.7703522444,
-0.4461255968,
-0.3312353194,
-0.0057525309,
0.0276221689,
-0.1083676293,
0.0154301189,
0.4346933067,
0.2580343187,
-0.3404891491,
0.2289298773,
-0.2173820734,
-0.100781396,
0.3002550304,
0.3061182499,
0.06861642,
0.2601005733,
-0.4653697908,
-0.1770846397,
-1.2108520269,
-0.0932589024,
0.2035810798,
0.4238908887,
0.0463865884,
0.5470406413,
-0.1508849412,
0.8495897651,
0.1577409208,
-0.0543009229,
0.0927047729,
-0.4321574867,
-0.1420082152,
-0.3317663372,
0.3768742383,
0.2897785306,
0.2519223094,
0.1887684464,
-0.4063480198,
-0.186829865,
0.0948970094,
-0.8876953125,
-0.3228065073,
0.1093603894,
-0.2287454307,
-0.0347736403,
-0.0389650688,
-0.4184199572,
-0.580579102,
-0.4082827568,
0.5556949973,
-0.2633166909,
-0.3143607974,
-0.1663480848,
0.1189742759,
0.1118655056,
0.3186938763,
-0.6997661591,
0.4844029248,
0.5430596471,
0.889675498,
-0.0481980927,
-0.1882105768,
-0.7172118425,
0.2879528701,
-0.3393275142,
0.6961262226,
-0.6436780095,
-0.6567106843,
-0.262286365,
-0.0222049188,
0.1367065609,
-0.6465508342,
0.6040627956,
-0.3122057915,
0.2685917318,
-0.1108381301,
-0.7124034762,
-0.0425919816,
0.0916547179,
-0.5788998604,
0.9687283635,
0.1364988685,
-0.5329756737,
0.0497061647,
-0.2739622891,
-0.5282506347,
-0.2683290839,
-0.1085238606,
-0.3416720033,
0.4093458951,
0.4049049914,
0.5240340233,
-0.3271740675,
0.2724007964,
-0.3522734046,
-0.3723036349,
0.0621958375,
-0.4840096533,
0.4874043465,
0.1166303158,
-0.1833198816,
0.2750223875,
-0.5324761271,
0.1246849969,
0.0476045683,
-0.0481980033,
-0.5982509851,
0.0074351905,
-0.3424256444,
0.2998212576,
0.0796531588,
-0.0385892726,
0.3149242997,
-0.5284949541,
0.2072293758,
0.7913579941,
0.2696482837,
0.6193481088,
-0.3611243665,
0.5345332623,
0.1986945122,
-0.0357288457,
-0.5741925836,
-0.5445713401,
-0.6052803993,
-0.3229497969,
0.0324435532,
0.609359622,
-0.7784015536,
0.5298945308,
-0.253087461,
-0.4571959674,
-0.0790894553,
0.3111659586,
0.2475025803,
0.6626371741,
0.450150311,
-0.2559762001,
-0.4920630157,
-0.9329717159,
-0.2467859536,
-0.0709261373,
-0.2593277097,
0.0315156206,
0.3524204791,
-0.0968007222,
1.0356993675,
-0.6736069918,
-0.1684408486,
-0.2274357826,
-0.0474115759,
0.4342406988,
0.7937908173,
0.2240184397,
-0.8910499215,
-0.3983530998,
-0.2412440926,
-0.4710368514,
-0.3361078203,
-0.3155251741,
0.0797605738,
-0.026085902,
0.6439467072,
-0.4513922632,
0.1567961574,
0.374974817,
-0.224121049,
0.6227132082,
-0.413069129,
-0.2331913859,
-1.0667550564,
-0.0608347766,
0.112918444,
-0.3623372912,
-0.8458491564,
0.3788778782,
0.1190260723,
-0.1701142043,
-0.4090470076,
0.6331775784,
-0.5757446289,
0.1884643734,
-0.4781468213,
-0.2518506646,
-0.0119524179,
0.4835860431,
0.2828016579,
0.586777091,
0.6881882548,
-0.653157115,
0.2730305195,
-0.3625135124,
0.0318303593,
0.5459399819,
-0.7694693208,
0.1967459619,
-0.1450912505,
0.5148710012,
-1.050781846,
0.1585936248,
0.1704952419,
-0.0485282131,
0.4695954025,
-0.3667343855,
-0.4000850916,
-0.267855227,
-0.4449064434,
0.1604688317,
0.5543509126,
-0.3558437824,
0.7092297673,
0.0948077217,
-0.3040639758,
-0.4116872549,
-0.4836758375,
0.02071606,
-0.4910315871,
-0.3600355983,
0.2972501516,
-0.1635431945,
-0.3597236276,
-0.0694176704,
-0.1189660057,
-0.2546674609,
0.2107037902,
0.0888302773,
0.2231052071,
-0.3120746315,
-0.042134393,
0.4005198777,
-0.1239172146,
-0.0554468296,
-0.4086752236,
0.5169777274,
0.0599451177,
-0.3977482617,
-0.3179259896,
0.5314729214,
0.5300453305,
0.0223147031,
0.8097575903,
0.4837189317,
-0.5692065954,
-0.1141448319,
-0.4606229067,
-0.552739799,
-0.4959796071,
0.4448577166,
-0.5271772742,
-0.4006724954,
0.6137804389,
-0.1358972937,
0.0402208716,
0.3992166519,
0.5795844793,
0.1493239999,
1.1149226427,
0.5550162196,
-0.0751908198,
0.6922522187,
-0.1078723595,
-0.0792185962,
-0.8787640929,
0.2747550309,
-0.2218155265,
-0.0817362815,
-0.2808499336,
-0.383020848,
0.4823583663,
0.4674047232,
-0.0230266936,
0.3801667988,
-0.1918639541,
0.6221901774,
0.5649423599,
0.2763446271,
0.2868384719,
0.1060620099,
-0.1090072542,
-0.0752855241,
-0.6680262089,
-0.4253132641,
1.3330724239,
0.3525113463,
0.8429727554,
0.2669822574,
0.7405386567,
0.2075774223,
0.5060519576,
-0.5729372501,
0.4950440824,
0.043385867,
-0.3780084848,
-0.2670264542,
-0.6665654182,
-0.8180806637,
0.4732687771,
-0.1668497473,
-0.7407708764,
0.0013740938,
0.3156070113,
-0.4990058541,
0.2203331441,
-1.0018572807,
0.6020537019,
0.1043824032,
-0.7067408562,
-0.1498463601,
-0.6777550578,
0.3022484183,
-0.231200695,
0.1627257764,
0.234643355,
-0.1391584277,
0.426443994,
-0.6415081024,
1.0830310583,
-0.3607951105,
-0.520381391,
0.3438571393,
0.1799594611,
0.9838409424,
-0.036243163,
0.1545264572,
-0.3144279718,
-0.0382378921,
-0.4466025531,
-0.8999843597,
0.8293377757,
-0.3751378655,
-0.8702508211,
0.0246633366,
-0.5846181512,
-0.2693506777,
0.2190491706,
0.3235562146,
0.5675222874,
-0.0666605234,
0.0252167843,
0.6412161589,
-0.0124299992,
0.2107251734,
0.4712272882,
-0.278625071,
-0.1802867949,
0.8733654618,
0.2222031653,
0.5807337761,
0.3246399164,
0.472119391,
-0.3446120024,
-0.6767673492,
-0.3866809309,
0.079941541,
-0.7898988128,
-0.163095057,
-0.4437487721,
0.004845148,
-0.4596667588,
0.0205484349,
-0.2643214166,
-0.6580570936,
-0.272290349,
0.1213301867,
0.0142229972,
0.6129214168,
0.0097451769,
0.497065872,
-0.6330102086,
0.1338167489,
0.2426960319,
0.1043639109,
0.0073105926,
-0.7857090235,
-0.1583516747,
0.1065528691,
-0.3691929579,
-1.0121401548,
0.3871714771,
0.2465250939,
0.5470977426,
0.4289689958,
0.016463371,
0.6218534708,
-0.6011279821,
0.7584428191,
0.1087431386,
-0.7204014063,
0.5113744736,
-0.3969432116,
0.453766644,
0.2405417711,
0.3071370721,
-0.368471086,
-0.6332451701,
-0.6111938953,
-1.1292556524,
0.1487261653,
0.2757386565,
0.2401788384,
0.1173666492,
0.4729059935,
0.0875614956,
0.0182576589,
-0.6035162807,
-0.3235570788,
-0.0195731744,
-0.203550607,
-0.2214066684,
-0.320785284,
-0.0716782436,
-0.215025425,
0.7018989921,
-0.0562770329,
0.0816045105,
0.2154585421,
-0.2962854207,
0.0605780743,
0.2567328811,
0.8199219704,
0.6512078047,
-0.058279492,
0.3684006035,
0.2790706754,
-0.4564218521,
0.1279013604,
0.2049117535,
-0.1874845177,
-0.1606263965,
0.420758605,
0.5682944655,
0.0417175069,
-0.5708059669,
0.3641119897,
0.1190284267,
0.3906705081,
-0.3041316569,
0.1058923155,
-0.0975927413,
0.1220222935,
0.7101345658,
0.1510390341,
0.1353980899,
-0.4654319882,
0.3540985286,
0.3104922175,
-0.3435350358,
-0.3589649498,
0.3608969748,
0.1800632775,
-0.0524402708,
0.162406072,
-0.0306321215,
-0.5646417737,
0.6628995538,
0.9724349976,
0.61793226,
-0.4318154156,
-0.317805618,
0.3507392704,
0.3703522086,
-0.4499832392,
0.125351578,
-0.0550883226,
-0.764543891,
-0.5130898952,
-0.0586758144,
-0.3835707605,
0.2260200232,
-0.6204780936,
0.2821521461,
-0.4533159733,
-0.2544511557,
-0.3714342713,
-0.1202414334,
-0.4416404366,
0.1211872548,
0.1002177596,
0.6810148954,
-0.9878558517,
0.893700242,
0.5681272149,
-0.211473003,
-0.6065254211,
0.0898888335,
-0.0222309344,
-0.511692524,
0.4211304188,
0.0721456558,
-0.0996784046,
0.1118372455,
-0.342735976,
-0.814766705,
0.6520611048,
0.5015417337,
-0.6915997863,
-0.0655495673,
-0.2944399118,
0.4447621107,
-0.2781410515,
0.2955476642,
0.5090308785,
0.3188710213,
-0.2354566902,
-0.8391533494,
0.3040268421,
-0.2021453977,
-0.0612224266,
0.3069818318,
-0.1467408091,
0.7891384363,
-0.3528196812,
-0.1626394987,
0.3302394748,
0.6679543853,
0.2585446835,
-0.0646826848,
0.5863216519,
0.4699232876,
0.8024993539,
0.1322664022,
1.2084497213,
-0.1407804638,
0.3339193165,
1.6013948917,
-0.4044291675,
0.8115956783,
0.67065835,
-0.1568286717,
0.4408468008,
0.4069643617,
0.2147281766,
0.5491723418,
0.2642184496,
-0.2929787338,
-0.1791598946,
-0.0029635136,
-0.7081412673,
0.0690004826,
0.5707182884,
-0.4917109907,
-0.2028619498,
0.0760224164,
0.1193897426,
0.2012434304,
-0.4092723429,
0.6104932427,
0.1060762256,
-0.6638606787,
0.6829583645,
-0.0017192455,
0.6122387052,
-0.7301072478,
-0.1229888946,
-0.3291126192,
0.3013516665,
-0.0072494443,
-0.6925684214,
0.2641844451,
-0.198774457,
-0.2035176754,
-0.0689859539,
0.7680299282,
-0.6392747164,
-0.5641651154,
0.0314470716,
0.5353673697,
0.0104561588,
-0.3285726905,
-0.3904752135,
-0.2116401047,
-0.1516591311,
-0.4853984118,
0.2597731948,
0.3472124934,
-0.3014304042,
0.7268136144,
0.5800667405,
0.3631768525,
-0.0556825921,
0.086313501,
1.0196768045,
-0.48399207,
-0.6036506295,
-1.1744997501,
0.2189951986,
-0.0826790184,
-0.1875363588,
0.8705171943,
0.456428051,
0.595882535,
0.1117993221,
0.5795326233,
0.391120851,
0.30109936,
-0.7642576694,
0.3237365186,
-0.3511803448,
0.5732850432,
-0.4030438662,
-1.0444478989,
-0.4732681811,
0.4031514823,
-0.4339624643,
0.0869205296,
0.5578368306,
0.8270475864,
-0.1395852566,
-0.1882635653,
0.3072713017,
0.2658861578,
0.3016976416,
0.5685044527,
0.9607540369,
-0.0886927471,
0.3021177053,
-0.2570597529,
-0.3603979647,
-0.0063874042,
-0.9205543399,
-0.7502506971,
-0.4796079397,
-0.1442042142,
-0.4011541605,
-0.0367800854,
0.9654905796,
0.7773663402,
-0.7640015483,
-0.0730512813,
-0.1437878013,
0.2421978265,
-0.4904936254,
-0.2262554467,
0.2827032506,
-0.1705604494,
-0.5776218772,
0.5389367342,
-0.1239372566,
0.3950956166,
-0.3803031743,
-0.038706217,
0.0634642094,
0.117591083,
0.5829645395,
0.2203273475,
-0.554137826,
-0.2313014716,
-0.2860177457,
0.0668194294,
-0.0425218455,
1.1488496065,
-0.9386280775,
0.3637678027,
0.4186041653,
0.4521783888,
0.4746849537,
-0.0371316932,
0.9928864837,
-1.026906848,
0.3639954031,
0.2649850845,
0.6018634439,
0.4643524885,
-0.4215838313,
0.4057779908,
0.2339255959,
-0.2067230791,
-0.9991987348,
0.6337807775,
-0.5960228443,
-0.6012428403,
1.221655488,
-0.2292612791,
0.0085974121,
-0.0296647027,
-0.317245543,
0.0501600653,
-0.4265789688,
0.3538973331,
0.5844722986,
0.0844918117,
0.0024945403,
-0.3712943494,
0.2305670679,
0.7871464491,
-0.5282744169,
0.2440723926,
0.5220466256,
0.2660140991,
0.0301107038,
0.577050209,
0.0281143971,
0.025332436,
-0.1735760272,
-0.3111408055,
-0.0629077852,
-0.4827980399,
-0.7787377238,
0.1264315993,
0.1227447316,
0.0993388072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17686v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17686v2
|
Deductive Beam Search: Decoding Deducible Rationale for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-01-31T09:16:35 | 2024-02-04T13:18:34 |
Tinghui Zhu, Kai Zhang, Jian Xie, Yu Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements have significantly augmented the reasoning capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs) through various methodologies, especially
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. However, previous methods fail to address
reasoning errors in intermediate steps, leading to accumulative errors. In this
paper, we propose Deductive Beam Search (DBS), which seamlessly integrates CoT
and deductive reasoning with step-wise beam search for LLMs. Our approach
deploys a verifier, verifying the deducibility of a reasoning step and its
premises, thus alleviating the error accumulation. Furthermore, we introduce a
scalable and labor-free data construction method to amplify our model's
verification capabilities. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach
significantly enhances the base performance of LLMs of various scales (7B, 13B,
70B, and ChatGPT) across 8 reasoning datasets from 3 diverse reasoning genres,
including arithmetic, commonsense, and symbolic. Moreover, our analysis proves
DBS's capability of detecting diverse and subtle reasoning errors and
robustness on different model scales.
|
[
-0.2120333463,
-1.158546567,
1.0731751919,
0.1653865427,
-0.2310021967,
0.2662449777,
0.0914323255,
-0.182028845,
-0.0007953701,
0.5063887835,
-0.4331709146,
-0.5112568736,
-0.6013140082,
0.0949397534,
-0.5949512124,
0.1463378668,
-0.2510418296,
-0.0477461182,
0.012675019,
0.1200671643,
-0.5843502879,
-0.3672082424,
-0.4941217005,
-0.3319406807,
0.2989294529,
0.1213148162,
0.669835031,
0.6646025181,
0.5261525512,
0.2191926539,
-0.4501498342,
0.8086821437,
-0.3119055927,
0.2766326368,
-0.6488773227,
-0.2583574057,
-0.5534582734,
-0.2837719321,
0.4553177357,
0.6787882447,
-0.1879054904,
-0.1034018099,
-0.2444496751,
0.7753812075,
-0.8175714612,
0.2906450331,
-0.9972977638,
-0.1380243897,
-0.058601249,
-0.2331875712,
-0.7781907916,
-0.4123884439,
-0.2829499841,
-0.2011758089,
-0.0835870132,
0.0649476275,
0.5777459145,
0.4675293863,
-0.6102721691,
-0.4486709535,
-0.8741116524,
0.7206500769,
-0.7298991084,
0.6299555302,
0.5435168147,
0.2704764307,
-0.49435848,
-0.5778710842,
-0.5487160087,
-0.1614731252,
-0.1962621659,
-0.1919451952,
-0.200912714,
0.2520296872,
0.393103838,
0.4091101885,
-0.6397736669,
-0.1358554512,
-0.0401625112,
0.1013731286,
0.5764135718,
0.2925188243,
-0.009714338,
-0.110956125,
-0.2234473675,
0.0114980359,
-0.8310961127,
-0.048889216,
-0.180473119,
0.1725805849,
0.1700937003,
0.5278705359,
-0.5888493061,
0.9253955483,
0.2092029452,
0.0814266428,
-0.0274706073,
-0.5359554291,
-0.3058353961,
0.1983542591,
0.4749859571,
0.053118486,
-0.0775107294,
-0.0238391608,
-0.2398783267,
0.1494918019,
0.1190093756,
-0.7417225242,
-0.151707381,
0.4569835663,
-0.3799045384,
-0.2508825064,
-0.3494807482,
-0.3214130402,
-0.5535305142,
-0.288213402,
0.1011049896,
-0.5835584998,
-0.2317798883,
0.5825007558,
0.0198846087,
0.1377238333,
0.3092615902,
-0.7104616165,
-0.0810900331,
0.7479649782,
0.6290336251,
0.4901878536,
-0.1308516264,
-0.6582545042,
0.2129643112,
-0.7595487833,
0.7761052251,
-0.6477405429,
-0.1394636184,
-0.0597124211,
-0.2681140006,
-0.1626542658,
-0.3233368099,
0.5911593437,
-0.8240998387,
-0.3789410293,
-0.4455862343,
-0.7399511337,
-0.1483155489,
0.6173805594,
-0.616972506,
0.8861151338,
-0.0136855356,
-0.7753249407,
0.3664029837,
-0.3316626847,
-0.5019598007,
0.1381839365,
-0.4350359738,
-0.0532466769,
0.3163742721,
0.3885309994,
0.4347430468,
-0.5387552381,
0.5573910475,
-0.7073269486,
-0.5154623389,
0.303686738,
-0.427628845,
0.9979700446,
0.2107869387,
-0.4509456754,
-0.3387949765,
-0.9534678459,
0.0652216896,
0.1904831529,
-0.3548064828,
-0.4802750051,
0.4794812799,
-0.7076739669,
0.1307384223,
0.1195327342,
-0.4609263539,
0.2891754508,
-0.4622787535,
0.5034223795,
0.5122084618,
-0.0940123573,
0.1449986994,
-0.0188151095,
0.3345639408,
0.1859344691,
-0.0035194575,
-0.1633309722,
-0.0938868895,
-0.4716448486,
-0.4082977474,
-0.0293042678,
0.5170006156,
-0.9054407477,
0.6396601796,
-0.1481112391,
-0.5874385834,
-0.2638648748,
0.1025660411,
0.3731895387,
0.5676090121,
0.4328321218,
0.2103445083,
-0.7437548041,
-0.5033057928,
-0.1347154677,
-0.2695855498,
0.1061185822,
0.1001256183,
0.5073545575,
-0.4624499977,
0.9309431314,
-0.4426633418,
0.0043685702,
-0.364287734,
-0.041082155,
0.5525119305,
0.321805954,
0.1187707782,
-0.6114305854,
-0.0627729148,
0.0311495848,
-0.977439642,
0.0598956272,
-0.2326089293,
-0.214044407,
0.1287310123,
0.5106226802,
-0.7104207873,
0.5541612506,
0.3133550584,
-0.5018829107,
0.4363271594,
-0.3347312808,
0.1051970571,
-0.6224064827,
-0.0204359535,
-0.2533157468,
-0.1390579492,
-0.2253102958,
0.0825538561,
0.1271883845,
0.3590530157,
-0.0378592387,
0.2854529023,
-0.3308410347,
0.1039136946,
-0.324549973,
0.5172205567,
0.3258196414,
0.2127047926,
0.1239556745,
0.3338013589,
0.6654598117,
-0.6452757716,
0.6942017078,
0.3794005513,
-0.4101294279,
0.5848655701,
-0.6759853959,
0.1024008095,
-0.2920742929,
0.6632168293,
-1.0730922222,
-0.0069120121,
0.0106487386,
-0.134456262,
-0.0407863446,
-0.1503277719,
-0.6338647604,
-0.5348927379,
-0.280644238,
0.5389731526,
0.1917490214,
-0.8369982839,
0.6465967894,
0.2372305393,
0.2084591985,
-0.7537810206,
-0.5889597535,
-0.098629564,
-0.0335887782,
-0.7533544898,
0.2369504869,
0.112973012,
-0.4090856016,
-0.1378611475,
-0.3388886154,
-0.0777864382,
0.2354853749,
-0.1653162986,
0.4450350106,
-0.0979532525,
0.182567507,
0.2869352102,
-0.0487086661,
0.2872971892,
-0.4033397436,
0.4969794452,
-0.3802778125,
-0.6491256356,
0.1101197228,
0.1420322359,
0.7197032571,
-0.3087753952,
0.6457412839,
0.2364570796,
-0.4634354711,
-0.5646653771,
-0.6940640807,
-0.1436140835,
-0.438477844,
0.278252393,
-0.60790658,
-0.7140643597,
0.5201662779,
-0.1543510407,
-0.1466557384,
0.0952537358,
0.5755256414,
0.1364209652,
1.2252631187,
0.0368857235,
0.2963093221,
-0.050207939,
-0.2815752625,
0.747287631,
-0.734842062,
-0.2269954979,
-0.467824012,
-0.2013259977,
-0.4859941602,
-0.60014081,
0.2136490196,
0.295601964,
-0.3826037049,
0.3636420667,
-0.5150250793,
0.7194240093,
0.297604084,
0.2276413888,
0.622882545,
-0.3589909375,
-0.1176247001,
0.2678592801,
-0.4890984595,
-0.3845613897,
0.7913650274,
0.2149040699,
0.9688955545,
0.0253713261,
0.680818975,
0.1154482886,
-0.179278478,
-0.6127254963,
0.6526091695,
-0.1977542341,
-0.9919432998,
-0.326772362,
-0.6678349376,
-0.5594770908,
0.3506790996,
0.2426807284,
-0.7411527038,
0.3381130099,
0.3502098918,
-0.1866011769,
0.4481450021,
-0.1092744097,
0.7766771913,
-0.3688753545,
-0.3926256299,
-0.6633309126,
-0.4268412888,
0.6224536896,
0.004695972,
0.4534476101,
-0.1966464221,
0.3562389314,
0.3519888818,
-0.4686547816,
0.4972001314,
-0.2177418768,
-0.281090498,
0.4681095481,
0.5967501998,
0.8949546218,
0.2262931913,
-0.0267163273,
-0.0172616933,
0.0274080373,
-0.3025945425,
-0.5899620056,
0.6360300779,
-0.1247847378,
-0.7152067423,
-0.1825898141,
-0.550963521,
-0.2780473232,
0.2052563429,
-0.0395648703,
0.4798446596,
0.0031300385,
0.3869945705,
0.8657451868,
0.067443192,
0.1785325855,
0.4131919444,
-0.4353979528,
-0.2134698778,
0.5395457149,
-0.0947252735,
0.0899292827,
0.5982970595,
0.1262768954,
-0.4762532413,
-0.6077632308,
-0.4374121726,
0.2161814421,
-0.8977355957,
-0.3181886077,
-0.4724020064,
-0.1438652128,
-0.1527694911,
-0.2780466378,
-0.5801490545,
-0.486476481,
0.2956257164,
-0.3787479103,
0.311021328,
0.4431009591,
-0.1623513401,
-0.2154616416,
-0.7573661208,
0.294391036,
0.2175443918,
0.3962130845,
0.0873207301,
-0.4103479385,
-0.3728066087,
0.2196599245,
-0.28311795,
-0.641464889,
0.1891578138,
-0.3359772265,
0.5117961168,
0.2769112289,
0.267127037,
0.6207606196,
-0.2704746127,
0.4408774078,
0.0617258549,
-1.2186092138,
0.8145858645,
-0.2431515306,
0.0867232159,
0.4326568544,
0.2451605499,
-0.1376346797,
-0.4947819114,
-0.4436441362,
-0.89918679,
0.5990478992,
0.1326818615,
-0.2836052477,
-0.3935866654,
0.0652665496,
-0.2367734313,
-0.099974528,
-0.5196800828,
-0.0402354263,
-0.0535641126,
-0.1150942296,
0.514634192,
-0.3107667863,
-0.109697029,
-0.2305239886,
0.8002301455,
-0.1906198412,
-0.1820739955,
0.3709549308,
-0.0873051733,
-0.054159984,
0.3274804056,
0.2035530806,
0.8143191338,
-0.4766421616,
0.4660873711,
0.2280328125,
-0.0660210624,
0.2899939716,
0.0985837355,
-0.0847671628,
0.1815922111,
0.3293516338,
0.613602221,
0.1352582276,
-0.9697231054,
0.3551259041,
-0.0136461686,
-0.1408287883,
-0.2167487144,
-0.1127990782,
0.2394928485,
0.4839261174,
0.1762714982,
-0.1213468984,
0.2248652577,
-0.3297700882,
0.0759565681,
0.56281358,
-0.0148442341,
-0.0698846579,
0.7178798318,
0.2064737827,
0.1522417963,
0.6983842254,
-0.4632455111,
-0.3415128291,
0.4477446675,
0.4894928634,
0.9843150973,
0.0031475623,
0.1888151169,
0.448800385,
0.3242410123,
-0.3595893681,
0.2186580002,
-0.237166509,
-0.8820948601,
-0.7702785134,
-0.4708707333,
-0.4962530434,
-0.0761859268,
-0.3405192494,
0.3575090468,
-0.5396175981,
0.0647328198,
-0.0844394192,
-0.2085319161,
-0.4392580688,
0.1879069656,
0.595032692,
0.9471035004,
-0.5160915852,
0.864444077,
0.439989835,
-0.4363903999,
-0.8934553862,
-0.335172236,
-0.0226719994,
-0.7563672662,
0.9718475342,
0.1563598365,
-0.5784971714,
-0.3036489487,
-0.2329076678,
-1.051117301,
1.2692906857,
0.4034027159,
-0.7784379721,
-0.338488549,
0.0556012392,
0.2853088975,
-0.3660575151,
0.4264476299,
0.8840478659,
0.4040960371,
0.4760723114,
-0.822804153,
0.432475239,
0.1616987735,
0.1311065704,
0.209907487,
-0.2326135635,
0.8322772384,
-0.2331136614,
-0.0995543078,
-0.2643320262,
0.3632421494,
0.7791483402,
0.5242775679,
0.4004219174,
0.6540206075,
1.0012453794,
0.0197165962,
0.8814708591,
-0.381796211,
0.5053857565,
1.0171890259,
-0.6757790446,
0.6662858725,
0.3427805603,
-0.3319524527,
0.74487257,
0.219268322,
0.2001479268,
0.4797360003,
0.3473268151,
-0.1364380568,
-0.6155653,
0.1177527234,
-0.2372863144,
0.4819343686,
0.5362949371,
-0.3858229518,
-0.4218343794,
-0.2241200805,
0.146865353,
0.1948384941,
-0.2258954197,
0.3510620296,
0.0221888665,
-0.6598029137,
1.104691267,
-0.1035104021,
0.2670197189,
-0.4509865046,
-0.0499635637,
-0.3220718503,
0.8093291521,
-0.2431364506,
-0.6164457798,
0.5765830874,
-0.0273809265,
-0.1089266315,
-0.2655498683,
0.7431787848,
-0.1958425194,
-0.4540967345,
0.5267542601,
0.5748804808,
-0.1952039152,
-0.1843653619,
-0.4819754362,
0.3511181474,
0.1290704608,
-0.4383386075,
-0.0664184466,
0.751480639,
0.0402131826,
0.8155670166,
0.38528198,
0.0125739258,
-0.1880020648,
0.0010664789,
0.9462013245,
-0.8136279583,
-0.2576153576,
-1.1799463034,
0.4654740691,
-0.1386150569,
0.1185430735,
0.5748261213,
0.4765851796,
0.8349638581,
0.0081792539,
0.6363019347,
-0.224536851,
0.5813858509,
-0.7326312065,
0.2612607181,
-0.2907041907,
0.7262923121,
-0.1907002032,
-0.696125567,
-0.3314164281,
0.8411101699,
-0.4477395415,
-0.2266885489,
0.9937067628,
0.8735911846,
0.0036865133,
0.2366762012,
0.2590745687,
0.3789273798,
0.6302090883,
0.8287860155,
1.0015411377,
-0.3217156827,
0.6776639223,
-0.0907702148,
-0.3292086124,
-0.2226035148,
-0.9538548589,
-0.8855781555,
-0.3085567355,
-0.4687715173,
-0.5559182763,
-0.1192707047,
0.8042509556,
0.4418924153,
-0.5674850941,
-0.1830214858,
-0.6767354012,
0.4892158806,
-0.455837518,
-0.1915276051,
0.2926548719,
-0.5191031694,
-0.4311015308,
0.779355824,
0.3652544618,
-0.4493112266,
-0.2124730945,
-0.117599763,
-0.3569103181,
0.5122523904,
0.724807322,
-0.0371333286,
-0.7947462201,
-0.1653916985,
0.0598940626,
-0.1236401573,
-0.2259286642,
0.7834866643,
-1.0521429777,
0.4010682702,
0.6502363086,
0.6254346967,
0.5816370845,
-0.2032681257,
0.3569661379,
-0.4345619082,
-0.013927795,
0.2910981178,
0.75267452,
0.1184444651,
-0.2814400494,
0.7595851421,
0.2903828323,
-0.6096886992,
-1.0144944191,
0.5357820392,
-1.0307468176,
-0.4173268378,
0.9380887151,
-0.2844038606,
-0.0571374781,
-0.033599671,
-0.2314425558,
-0.0171849169,
-0.0506100357,
0.9227509499,
0.7774492502,
-0.2292613089,
0.1408101618,
0.0543730445,
0.2473762482,
0.375382483,
-0.6322925687,
0.6952005029,
0.7423142791,
-0.1254217178,
0.282972455,
0.620252192,
-0.1837060452,
0.3206278682,
0.2930791676,
-0.4672857821,
-0.2435529381,
-0.1731622517,
0.0377829969,
0.0944362953,
0.1660475731,
-0.0840909779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17671v1
|
Contextual Feature Extraction Hierarchies Converge in Large Language Models and the Brain
| 2024-01-31T08:48:35 | 2024-01-31T08:48:35 |
Gavin Mischler, Yinghao Aaron Li, Stephan Bickel, Ashesh D. Mehta, Nima Mesgarani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC
|
Recent advancements in artificial intelligence have sparked interest in the
parallels between large language models (LLMs) and human neural processing,
particularly in language comprehension. While prior research has established
similarities in the representation of LLMs and the brain, the underlying
computational principles that cause this convergence, especially in the context
of evolving LLMs, remain elusive. Here, we examined a diverse selection of
high-performance LLMs with similar parameter sizes to investigate the factors
contributing to their alignment with the brain's language processing
mechanisms. We find that as LLMs achieve higher performance on benchmark tasks,
they not only become more brain-like as measured by higher performance when
predicting neural responses from LLM embeddings, but also their hierarchical
feature extraction pathways map more closely onto the brain's while using fewer
layers to do the same encoding. We also compare the feature extraction pathways
of the LLMs to each other and identify new ways in which high-performing models
have converged toward similar hierarchical processing mechanisms. Finally, we
show the importance of contextual information in improving model performance
and brain similarity. Our findings reveal the converging aspects of language
processing in the brain and LLMs and offer new directions for developing models
that align more closely with human cognitive processing.
|
[
-0.5679858923,
-0.7769389749,
0.8356934786,
0.1019780114,
0.014982298,
0.0366564803,
-0.6301983595,
-0.6343571544,
0.0656896383,
0.5294921994,
-0.4835543931,
-0.3311181366,
-0.6915100217,
0.0015270772,
-0.304392308,
0.7459535599,
0.181425631,
-0.093990095,
-0.6611413956,
-0.2926058769,
-0.6089576483,
-0.5866677761,
-0.3570601046,
-0.7763438821,
0.6063486338,
0.1021796539,
0.6570277214,
0.9956424832,
0.3783909082,
0.259257108,
-0.1600025892,
-0.0899477825,
-0.243519336,
0.3485505283,
-0.1799470037,
-0.4809533358,
-0.4514238238,
-0.216182977,
0.6886351705,
1.0210921764,
-0.1166309193,
0.0392050557,
0.4578696489,
0.4531590343,
-0.8056402802,
0.0099594742,
-0.7018790245,
-0.197416082,
-0.1930520236,
-0.3856811225,
-0.3017292917,
-0.0173958503,
0.4274133146,
-0.3362832665,
0.0719442517,
0.0434163027,
0.6928328276,
0.2704979479,
-0.2557009161,
-0.2309470028,
-0.4466802478,
0.7830952406,
-0.6867638826,
0.5539227724,
0.1976017505,
0.0010525059,
-0.1044038832,
-0.6404999495,
-0.4347550273,
-0.082957454,
-0.1600704789,
-0.2586573064,
-0.104693912,
-0.1522760391,
0.3649837971,
-0.0716556236,
-0.5441842079,
0.5656448007,
-0.0424733721,
-0.170965001,
0.3151818812,
0.1719180793,
0.2135599852,
-0.2936717868,
-0.3369805217,
-0.1550381482,
-0.8639594316,
0.1699837893,
-0.1711499542,
0.3182522655,
-0.0761783123,
0.2997410893,
-0.0096884165,
0.7732861638,
-0.2157371044,
-0.2244548202,
0.2230342478,
-0.0499490835,
-0.1762088239,
0.0131869055,
0.6682168841,
0.2145126611,
0.4377226233,
-0.2716711462,
-0.3126287758,
-0.2613992691,
0.1924601644,
-0.6161605716,
0.0119187208,
0.0626339093,
-0.4401364028,
0.0395326242,
-0.1903770864,
-0.6067811847,
-0.4758540988,
-0.5753705502,
0.2254084647,
-0.3327322304,
-0.1660152227,
-0.127872631,
-0.1188655794,
0.5760415792,
0.3037646413,
-1.1689130068,
0.4277163148,
1.003354907,
0.8132728338,
-0.5545380116,
-0.5574205518,
-0.3977979422,
0.1622989774,
-0.2933394015,
0.7709420323,
-0.7247943282,
0.1845191866,
0.0350353383,
-0.0818020999,
-0.0981602669,
-0.8667277098,
0.1909292191,
-0.8842602372,
-0.0009278611,
-0.6145279408,
-0.3670612872,
-0.2165906876,
0.1450462788,
-0.6648712158,
0.7979703546,
-0.1311767846,
-0.7691955566,
0.4411284029,
-0.4563313127,
-0.5026199818,
0.1974314302,
-0.5791150928,
-0.0259913336,
0.3232758939,
0.2270822823,
0.6429061294,
-0.6899975538,
0.131250605,
-0.495462209,
-0.5289503932,
0.397316277,
-0.2455921173,
0.8137421012,
0.0446549766,
-0.3009518087,
0.1031604484,
-0.4341722429,
0.0374809541,
0.077851437,
-0.3771940172,
-0.3962315917,
0.3127188087,
-0.0861809254,
0.3515945971,
0.4713041186,
-0.1932790279,
-0.045716323,
-0.2207527459,
0.8794671893,
0.5883859396,
-0.1699530482,
0.4845545888,
-0.2218330652,
0.2143095136,
0.0736506358,
-0.3659643531,
-0.2466135174,
-0.2249114811,
-0.4232562184,
-0.3779492676,
0.2047740817,
0.5142792463,
-0.1281453073,
0.6519197822,
-0.6899089813,
-0.0103941979,
-0.4352531433,
0.1854179949,
0.2295098603,
0.4992724061,
0.3400250375,
-0.3954738081,
-0.4535520077,
-1.1307553053,
-0.1611466557,
0.0380517989,
-0.2766192853,
0.3581295907,
0.2557707727,
-0.1479404569,
1.1545920372,
-0.4292804599,
-0.0107391058,
-0.1033523306,
-0.0285575725,
0.1347612441,
0.3269583881,
0.4843551815,
-0.5374156833,
-0.0912939236,
0.2744399607,
-0.8960615993,
-0.1879050136,
0.1369285733,
0.0440040193,
0.2118970603,
0.7438064218,
-0.6578351855,
0.0395993628,
0.4424409568,
0.0115805371,
0.1590685546,
-0.1236621365,
-0.0103795612,
-1.0218657255,
0.2854244113,
-0.1388262957,
-0.0768143535,
-0.4552567303,
0.1123454273,
0.14612104,
0.1886630207,
-0.1995131224,
0.4036619365,
-0.6967160702,
-0.6930605769,
-0.4281741679,
0.4781597853,
-0.0481743664,
0.6857961416,
0.0524219051,
0.6555908918,
0.755687356,
-0.5031222105,
0.1040515453,
0.0619757921,
-0.3224908113,
0.3606218994,
-0.6682541966,
0.1468705386,
-0.2434225827,
0.0818106681,
-1.0533750057,
-0.2959681749,
-0.3721621335,
-0.2952927649,
0.4413528442,
0.1784051359,
-0.4543229342,
-0.0459245816,
-0.0715068579,
0.5041081309,
0.8113057017,
-0.4715486467,
0.5818508267,
0.4762312472,
-0.3940355778,
-0.6009081602,
-0.7294037938,
0.1455045044,
-0.4072940052,
-0.5880877376,
0.5481156111,
0.1780265421,
-0.1600030661,
-0.1622353345,
-0.0193047356,
0.0432460569,
0.2196682096,
0.1639582068,
0.1534400582,
-0.4281562567,
-0.0412100442,
-0.0305022225,
0.2524415255,
0.2956431806,
-0.2350129932,
0.8141834736,
0.0442231409,
-0.0893764645,
-0.1696867049,
0.2354233712,
0.8039706945,
-0.2716535926,
0.726795733,
0.3377922475,
-0.5711439848,
-0.1050953045,
-0.6650239825,
-0.4122699499,
-0.4305596352,
0.660438776,
-0.5528586507,
-1.1598783731,
0.7763143778,
-0.0875265896,
-0.0236573853,
0.3128264844,
0.7066144943,
-0.1352473348,
1.0741209984,
0.5725067258,
-0.2220393866,
0.5322984457,
0.0688548535,
-0.0059972159,
-1.2462055683,
-0.2377492785,
-0.4471061528,
-0.4356087744,
-0.6089885831,
-0.1778614521,
0.1585539877,
0.2676519156,
-0.1372229308,
0.3784787357,
-0.2018428296,
0.4744999409,
0.3033283055,
-0.0198084321,
0.0542675816,
0.2852881253,
-0.3782861829,
-0.0422071218,
-0.7058225274,
-0.4590495527,
0.7994798422,
0.4334644377,
0.5838528872,
-0.0865749419,
0.4499612153,
0.0463982783,
0.202826798,
-0.6483709812,
0.6261489987,
-0.2026206553,
-0.3305133879,
-0.2367142588,
-0.1238924265,
-1.0554969311,
0.3908523917,
-0.217561543,
-1.0467830896,
0.3529871702,
-0.2047428638,
-0.4608904421,
-0.0297597665,
-0.5432867408,
0.8266321421,
-0.0521098375,
-0.5225702524,
-0.2500035465,
-0.7565214634,
0.2797642648,
-0.2472378761,
0.0994627103,
-0.1079187542,
-0.3821403682,
0.5374545455,
0.0838436633,
0.7775162458,
0.1600839198,
-0.2540647089,
-0.1188161597,
0.0457350686,
0.0239079278,
-0.2283577919,
-0.0192741342,
0.3663556874,
-0.0524391159,
-0.3498577178,
-0.6024315357,
1.0439140797,
-0.8036258221,
-0.8648388386,
-0.1218333468,
-0.8505048752,
-0.2136344016,
0.2034121454,
0.2726819515,
0.3387234807,
-0.0745240077,
0.4572750032,
0.6358081698,
-0.0418368392,
0.7678752542,
0.0621181615,
-0.0913859159,
-0.3957306445,
0.5823637843,
0.1634247005,
0.2505969703,
0.4117050767,
-0.0941348597,
-0.256947577,
-0.6860542893,
-0.2380332798,
0.2399539948,
-0.7654889226,
-0.0161945783,
-0.5879359841,
-0.3671960533,
-0.4666486681,
-0.0669339597,
-0.0663930178,
-0.1023600623,
-0.1544585377,
0.2229956686,
0.0244859811,
0.7025969625,
0.188444376,
0.2286343277,
-0.6404904723,
0.0607508756,
0.3424852788,
0.1832339615,
0.352596879,
-0.4997247756,
-0.402556926,
-0.0170675311,
-0.2612689137,
-0.8170942664,
0.2533127666,
0.1864316911,
0.6219859123,
0.3007386327,
-0.4499747157,
0.7181571722,
-0.6011348963,
0.6149660349,
0.0213894527,
-0.7337773442,
0.1909537017,
-0.2698166668,
0.5917934775,
0.3473132551,
0.3860789835,
-0.4984247088,
-0.1603381038,
-0.1746243984,
-0.7058063745,
0.7109542489,
0.1148363352,
-0.014612929,
-0.0391255096,
0.6130937934,
0.0290424339,
0.1273579448,
-0.6565775275,
0.1201452538,
0.278110832,
-0.1445301324,
-0.0906058177,
-0.0587862879,
-0.2739849985,
-0.1412495971,
-0.1423669308,
-0.2966118157,
0.307600081,
0.1275174171,
-0.1727338433,
-0.2024850994,
0.1161029562,
0.6717373133,
0.8106173277,
-0.0363972411,
0.2977291942,
0.3553163409,
-0.3107026517,
-0.1467442364,
-0.0037340352,
-0.0559381172,
-0.5054415464,
0.9256336689,
0.9596162438,
0.2593570054,
-0.6751939058,
0.4089371264,
-0.015614762,
-0.0677361712,
-0.1212290004,
0.3164796829,
0.3841885924,
0.522510469,
0.4428623617,
0.205905512,
0.1063079238,
-0.736857295,
0.2276907712,
0.7098741531,
-0.0580645762,
-0.3326728046,
0.4782323837,
-0.1794411093,
-0.4776141047,
0.7554237247,
0.383569181,
-0.4974489212,
0.6103878021,
0.6717993021,
1.0076082945,
0.0563357845,
-0.4458779693,
0.2266079634,
0.0077632507,
-0.0573221147,
0.0297583211,
-0.3305057585,
-0.8166555762,
-0.6195769906,
-0.7775417566,
0.0199380629,
0.03279889,
-0.7309166193,
0.1821463555,
-0.3916979432,
-0.1899734288,
0.0377873667,
-0.1575875133,
-0.7189816236,
0.1730303168,
0.5374389291,
0.7144807577,
-0.6254575253,
1.1299577951,
0.6483225226,
-0.0839485601,
-0.5501631498,
0.4686959982,
-0.2592861056,
-0.7771071196,
0.7192054391,
0.3725775182,
-0.1126577333,
0.0926536024,
-0.4604220986,
-1.1318954229,
1.2651702166,
0.6906039119,
-0.6644766331,
-0.3045874834,
0.1362335384,
0.6696513295,
-0.8596566319,
0.2909653485,
1.0001268387,
0.141620487,
0.1360912621,
-0.8605600595,
0.3270441294,
-0.0679770708,
0.233431071,
0.2639555335,
-0.3952137828,
0.7762182355,
-0.1549033523,
-0.1555760801,
-0.0265539456,
0.539542675,
0.635427773,
-0.0321183205,
0.3704360425,
0.5428289175,
0.5920950174,
-0.1048640609,
0.885869205,
-0.3639068902,
0.0103612859,
0.9502725005,
-0.3944565952,
1.2878735065,
0.5590432286,
0.0633091554,
0.73305583,
0.7482475638,
0.2827823162,
0.5294884443,
0.0317399949,
0.1058112532,
-0.2804031968,
0.0008063138,
-0.1124748141,
0.5700840354,
0.438359648,
-0.3325870037,
-0.0300950967,
-0.0569102392,
-0.3008846641,
-0.1004661843,
-0.1876380146,
0.9167872071,
0.1983552575,
-1.0746126175,
0.7855345607,
-0.1868715435,
0.7037935853,
-0.3462119401,
0.0788286924,
-0.1700679362,
-0.1132272258,
-0.1251704991,
-0.9153898954,
0.2273447067,
-0.1977551877,
-0.3842278123,
-0.1291665733,
0.4990495741,
-0.5283195376,
0.2119281143,
0.7245912552,
0.4943193495,
0.1014631018,
0.0733600035,
-0.6332954764,
0.3920765817,
-0.2484509498,
-0.3033658862,
0.4910696149,
0.4095454514,
-0.3118871748,
0.4913174212,
0.487716496,
0.2161325663,
0.1371947676,
0.0979671478,
0.7960324287,
-0.8365313411,
-0.3768109679,
-1.2080506086,
0.2355648279,
-0.1336217523,
-0.2094670832,
0.3961917758,
0.3055066168,
0.7603248358,
0.0909532011,
0.3858161569,
0.1114713922,
0.1824817955,
-0.5557594895,
0.6656873226,
-0.7213801146,
0.3440465927,
-0.1136524454,
-1.3598505259,
-0.2938229144,
0.4061314166,
-0.3328346312,
0.3062320352,
0.8938031793,
0.670024097,
-0.04781444,
-0.1998966187,
0.4242536128,
0.2987323701,
0.1852138638,
0.6949560046,
0.6385609508,
-0.1549984664,
0.2074462026,
0.1078579649,
-0.2080181539,
-0.1855379939,
-0.9506667852,
-0.7815609574,
-0.6016025543,
-0.0793799087,
-0.0059006251,
-0.1870490164,
0.8574498892,
0.9171438217,
-0.6703348756,
-0.4953999221,
-0.1887778342,
0.0346245691,
-0.1310745329,
-0.2335996777,
0.345561713,
-0.3905128837,
-0.7029153705,
0.2558608055,
0.5886384249,
-0.2314261794,
-0.4057404697,
-0.1854124665,
-0.0995553285,
0.1341945976,
0.61787045,
0.1339396089,
-1.0647250414,
-0.2560022771,
0.181797713,
-0.5133286715,
0.2838872075,
0.8382158279,
-0.9258932471,
0.0408094302,
0.7742250562,
0.9481830001,
0.3159960806,
-0.1639580131,
0.6940972805,
-0.6443719268,
0.0394607671,
0.123315841,
0.441747725,
0.5239386559,
-0.2866825163,
0.164625749,
0.0287337955,
-0.7095861435,
-0.8060622811,
0.2834437191,
-0.9231045842,
-0.4519131184,
0.9016920924,
0.1192084402,
-0.487326771,
0.1375044435,
0.031732697,
0.1726561636,
-0.0045035132,
0.7301358581,
0.9495868683,
-0.3454327881,
-0.4151979089,
-0.5108190775,
0.4418821633,
0.637224555,
-0.6421805024,
0.2403579205,
0.4107269347,
0.3514167368,
0.2960698903,
0.378722012,
-0.0892719701,
0.3045231402,
-0.3177376986,
0.0298872739,
0.4517706037,
-0.539530158,
-0.5527111888,
0.534886241,
0.2680203021,
0.1544138491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17658v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17658v1
|
Document Structure in Long Document Transformers
| 2024-01-31T08:28:06 | 2024-01-31T08:28:06 |
Jan Buchmann, Max Eichler, Jan-Micha Bodensohn, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Long documents often exhibit structure with hierarchically organized elements
of different functions, such as section headers and paragraphs. Despite the
omnipresence of document structure, its role in natural language processing
(NLP) remains opaque. Do long-document Transformer models acquire an internal
representation of document structure during pre-training? How can structural
information be communicated to a model after pre-training, and how does it
influence downstream performance? To answer these questions, we develop a novel
suite of probing tasks to assess structure-awareness of long-document
Transformers, propose general-purpose structure infusion methods, and evaluate
the effects of structure infusion on QASPER and Evidence Inference, two
challenging long-document NLP tasks. Results on LED and LongT5 suggest that
they acquire implicit understanding of document structure during pre-training,
which can be further enhanced by structure infusion, leading to improved
end-task performance. To foster research on the role of document structure in
NLP modeling, we make our data and code publicly available.
|
[
-0.2143525183,
-0.5315539837,
0.5439118743,
0.1720863581,
-0.1813843846,
0.0058307564,
-0.1259831935,
-0.864831984,
0.1346984059,
0.4459054172,
-0.3321472704,
-0.1953202039,
-0.7400558591,
0.1359336078,
-0.6134068966,
1.1575357914,
-0.1597758532,
0.0036332607,
-0.4168069065,
0.1829572767,
-0.1121671274,
-0.6521396041,
-0.5545472503,
-0.6108666658,
0.3861029446,
-0.0081291199,
0.6585413814,
0.5023762584,
0.476526618,
0.3733374178,
-0.2575874031,
-0.2991606295,
-0.2277920544,
0.1982001662,
-0.1166081876,
-0.8080170155,
-0.6044542789,
-0.0498697609,
1.0103439093,
0.8627067804,
0.0976457745,
0.0565453731,
0.4296465516,
0.6937107444,
-0.4080675244,
0.4986495376,
-0.2691999972,
-0.0051880758,
-0.4144131839,
-0.0467735045,
-0.4710550308,
0.0095796529,
0.3396654427,
-0.3350199461,
0.6284083724,
-0.0331385322,
0.801055491,
0.2744481862,
-0.4935408235,
-0.5208753943,
-0.7993458509,
0.3114837706,
-0.414417088,
0.5110393167,
0.5842887759,
0.1567144543,
-0.2280631214,
-0.9759070873,
-0.395998776,
-0.3081338406,
-0.5307491422,
0.262062043,
0.0517304018,
0.4156001806,
0.2204194218,
0.6558673978,
-0.6114804149,
0.2679021358,
-0.4613887072,
-0.1424473971,
0.3172378838,
-0.3135142028,
0.1038466468,
-0.2095740288,
-0.4487767518,
-0.3189977109,
-0.3760243952,
0.1095484123,
0.5589355826,
0.0328253172,
-0.1616640836,
0.6126605868,
-0.091803059,
0.4207185507,
0.0693920925,
0.0665478408,
0.2177370191,
-0.3249996305,
-0.4454309642,
0.3590836823,
0.5209838152,
-0.0804891586,
0.1056202576,
-0.1911608428,
-0.2464529723,
0.0518847927,
0.5888540745,
-0.8220291138,
-0.0732115656,
0.4275161624,
-0.4309512377,
-0.1877156347,
0.0792376325,
-0.3508314788,
-0.2116488516,
-0.3440713584,
0.3799493611,
-0.3868876696,
-0.0885857046,
0.3372966051,
-0.5689896345,
0.5352697968,
0.2512067854,
-1.010979414,
0.5169875622,
0.61794734,
0.638615489,
-0.166702047,
-0.3469575346,
-0.2562148273,
0.2749558687,
-0.1362035871,
1.0571539402,
-0.3666735291,
-0.3965629339,
0.1092865914,
0.1764933318,
-0.1153467298,
-0.4452521801,
0.985837996,
-0.4628961384,
0.5723900795,
0.080904372,
-0.6297085881,
0.0594114512,
0.3584710658,
-0.7363560796,
1.0491375923,
0.3655783236,
-0.7393356562,
0.3373844624,
-0.7443417907,
-0.4926598966,
0.0899935812,
-0.3108314276,
-0.4447464347,
0.2195670456,
0.339545697,
0.5144829154,
-0.060659714,
0.0424376465,
0.0896833614,
-0.4023549259,
0.1279387325,
-0.3401222825,
0.5674855709,
-0.3423247039,
-0.1859388649,
0.2468805611,
-0.7593304515,
-0.2337249368,
0.0043296041,
-0.4106985033,
-0.2323366553,
0.0191359427,
-0.0352374315,
0.0274579618,
0.1213785037,
-0.5330353975,
0.355029285,
-0.649522841,
0.26962924,
0.496429801,
0.053109102,
0.8577889204,
-0.1071072295,
0.4054135084,
0.0727892891,
0.3544322252,
-0.381030798,
-0.4157646,
-0.7818237543,
-0.150058344,
0.0132465279,
0.0614885502,
-0.3235627413,
0.379632026,
-0.2913752198,
-0.4303617477,
-0.3816212416,
-0.0634811372,
0.4638794661,
0.7863276005,
0.5625428557,
-0.3102806807,
-0.2894904912,
-1.1116344929,
-0.1247740835,
-0.1931247413,
-0.3196208179,
-0.266651392,
0.6790999174,
-0.1826773733,
0.7061172128,
-0.5854847431,
-0.3951295316,
-0.4069653153,
0.5321620107,
0.29152596,
0.4247022569,
0.4609723389,
-0.7247001529,
-0.2979850173,
-0.2541556954,
-0.4335372448,
0.1515689194,
-0.3121810555,
-0.1518412679,
0.1343951523,
0.7560554147,
-0.8820777535,
0.4673341215,
0.3034167886,
-0.2515768707,
0.5107579231,
-0.3585170209,
-0.1235582009,
-1.0069667101,
-0.0997689366,
-0.1647085249,
-0.1731399298,
-0.8065304756,
0.0105236545,
0.4738770127,
-0.1459279358,
-0.2765023708,
0.354255259,
-0.6672617793,
-0.2868299186,
-0.3751162887,
-0.0897493064,
0.3650914729,
0.6258510351,
0.2204813361,
0.5001909733,
0.404286921,
-0.4370712042,
-0.1213582009,
0.3075256944,
-0.5605395436,
0.4537745714,
-0.7799388766,
0.2769649923,
-0.5155257583,
0.618971765,
-0.927967906,
-0.2815887034,
0.1005296335,
-0.3855222166,
0.8208819032,
-0.3663603365,
-0.5253525972,
-0.2788853347,
-0.2343022674,
0.0498014987,
0.1741237044,
-0.163806811,
0.650606215,
0.0642200783,
-0.0362929106,
-0.3968952894,
-0.5770716667,
-0.0413833521,
0.0289762765,
-0.7315067053,
0.8755427003,
-0.0119390963,
-0.035494633,
-0.1913215369,
-0.4127188325,
-0.2810770273,
0.1087513864,
0.5928505659,
0.057335943,
-0.2963909507,
0.4163932204,
0.1057793424,
0.007922885,
0.4177880585,
-0.2608154118,
0.4977588654,
-0.1032330468,
-0.3369497061,
-0.3594610989,
0.4419671595,
0.5547026992,
-0.5478275418,
0.8276607394,
0.5296677351,
-0.2744435072,
-0.3386255801,
-0.5141394138,
-0.0998365059,
-0.4784884155,
0.4867880046,
-0.3285202384,
-0.6010562778,
0.4029952586,
0.1258745342,
0.0950901434,
0.6431100368,
0.3244531453,
-0.5520310998,
0.7096927166,
1.0325391293,
-0.0322176553,
0.5935242772,
-0.2819292843,
0.0112450588,
-0.7243195176,
-0.3376810849,
-0.8577263355,
-0.3264617324,
-0.2624163032,
-0.5469292402,
0.2597539127,
0.2350787967,
-0.116227515,
0.1754731983,
-0.4175713956,
0.4602025747,
0.2880373299,
0.0230355468,
0.243898049,
-0.1993797123,
0.2589648068,
0.240701139,
-0.2903764546,
-0.4003598392,
0.796289444,
0.635232687,
0.6287059188,
-0.2497962266,
0.6681628823,
-0.0043785428,
0.2882541716,
-0.9115466475,
0.1973717362,
0.1864076853,
-0.5289638638,
-0.3985472023,
0.1133973897,
-0.915943563,
0.0156625286,
-0.0401395857,
-0.3815436959,
0.3371770084,
-0.0531438179,
-0.0984023064,
-0.0944443271,
-0.8670435548,
0.780566752,
-0.2821600437,
0.0762602165,
-0.0532061309,
-0.8077151179,
0.0788726807,
-0.131619215,
-0.1310205609,
0.3358035684,
0.1103355065,
0.7755240798,
-0.191977337,
0.7643557191,
0.0329159088,
-0.2494792044,
0.1379768401,
-0.2673318684,
0.6036926508,
-0.041919142,
-0.1950164884,
0.159529686,
-0.1658741236,
-0.2758646607,
-1.0030386448,
0.1331089437,
-0.6556181908,
-0.66778332,
-0.3986752033,
-0.4280427396,
-0.1215359345,
0.3926860094,
0.3921654522,
0.4969118237,
-0.1054411903,
0.5723776817,
0.7594219446,
0.1627336442,
0.4264144897,
0.3275665939,
0.1532458961,
0.1701250076,
0.1324493587,
0.052235689,
0.3266281486,
0.8436350226,
0.2238019705,
-0.3290928602,
-0.8575748205,
-0.1465223581,
0.244444102,
-0.8496550322,
0.1089821756,
-0.7359451652,
-0.5292052031,
-0.3941833377,
-0.1945142746,
-0.4545045793,
-0.3227765262,
-0.2570191622,
-0.3608047366,
-0.090081647,
0.8030872345,
0.5352663398,
0.4178196192,
-0.7615961432,
0.444298923,
0.1940312535,
0.4783929884,
-0.2583646476,
-0.4755751193,
-0.5264568925,
-0.0779209211,
-0.1858667433,
-0.7793582082,
0.0838171989,
0.1939436793,
0.6625317931,
0.418561101,
-0.1039687172,
0.6005420089,
-0.5758740902,
0.6426829696,
-0.0920782164,
-0.643915236,
0.5563963652,
-0.1468772888,
0.475372076,
0.4389774501,
0.5838143826,
-0.1280035377,
-0.5971443653,
-0.3749465644,
-0.7194903493,
0.5039934516,
0.4415899813,
0.0210778713,
0.0366232358,
0.4001656771,
-0.0040237284,
0.1455876976,
-0.8065678477,
-0.0171560068,
-0.4492576122,
0.0249367096,
-0.1359496266,
-0.410181284,
-0.1862716526,
-0.1006349474,
0.064287819,
-0.1463228613,
0.3442598581,
0.4905914068,
-0.3698446453,
0.2119860649,
0.5246224403,
0.437397629,
0.4855195582,
-0.5693206191,
0.1980272233,
-0.2087085992,
-0.7173619866,
-0.1169086471,
0.2298344523,
0.1592705101,
-0.1275799125,
0.7239419222,
0.6832628846,
0.466956377,
-0.1594499201,
0.3516620994,
-0.2242073119,
-0.379314065,
-0.4229544103,
-0.0160017665,
0.2005072385,
0.2931751907,
0.4040037096,
-0.2063816637,
0.1167991087,
-0.8146400452,
-0.0040236581,
0.3473398387,
-0.4169560969,
-0.3337157667,
0.3803171217,
0.0706624091,
-0.2031253874,
0.8371773958,
0.1497560889,
-0.4560609758,
0.5438921452,
0.684107244,
1.0022143126,
-0.0542019196,
0.1309813261,
0.0411075614,
0.4925136268,
-0.1465145946,
0.0444003008,
-0.3892871737,
-0.5497296453,
-0.4530875683,
-0.9144631028,
-0.2540380657,
0.0533205457,
-0.6540278792,
0.1651771367,
-0.0684124157,
-0.0117257461,
0.1208853349,
0.0179961771,
-0.6211959124,
0.2721902728,
0.2838933468,
0.9683272839,
-0.5366712213,
1.0444808006,
0.3498100638,
-0.5008035302,
-0.5602275133,
0.1513581127,
-0.3371704519,
-0.3497362435,
0.9050763249,
0.353621304,
-0.2677935362,
-0.1361256242,
-0.3689370453,
-0.923794806,
1.0093346834,
0.2732006311,
-0.1971286088,
-0.7077773809,
0.3907281756,
0.7611761689,
-0.0771165863,
0.364916414,
0.143548131,
0.4723627567,
-0.1627023816,
-0.736605525,
-0.2200774401,
-0.2891683877,
-0.2973362207,
0.3733709157,
-0.2580687106,
0.8537271023,
0.2667928636,
-0.4173299372,
-0.358715415,
0.8368725181,
-0.2263421118,
-0.0022984787,
0.5046429038,
0.3084337413,
0.7219878435,
0.056266211,
1.2734242678,
-0.1916752011,
-0.2068189681,
1.2884207964,
-0.1394186616,
0.7416245341,
0.3965314925,
0.0032968789,
0.6615695357,
0.2876496911,
-0.041860994,
0.2074095756,
0.1894138902,
0.0863534808,
0.1706189066,
-0.0681699738,
-0.403975606,
0.6858821511,
0.4238483608,
-0.4376815557,
-0.2845352888,
-0.2572784722,
-0.0891537145,
-0.1914186776,
-0.2886802256,
0.6086503267,
0.1663687378,
-0.7620620728,
0.3436317742,
-0.017556889,
0.4980320036,
-1.0741535425,
0.0164267607,
-0.2605483532,
0.1275490671,
-0.2555640042,
-0.9082408547,
0.5735941529,
-0.1914125681,
-0.4682749212,
-0.8580249548,
0.8295266628,
-0.3124498427,
-0.2336114943,
0.323926717,
0.2516462803,
-0.078192845,
-0.6116378903,
-0.2489240468,
-0.2125233859,
-0.4190258384,
-0.5783186555,
0.6862437725,
0.2072023749,
-0.315338701,
0.3435304761,
0.6540378332,
-0.0319241025,
0.06969852,
0.3642118871,
0.9326357841,
-0.5282105207,
-0.6188456416,
-0.6898952723,
0.6100812554,
-0.2483189851,
-0.3145053983,
0.7330509424,
0.6947466731,
0.9174229503,
-0.0460852943,
0.2355900109,
0.4009450972,
0.0877945051,
-0.606192708,
1.0579429865,
-0.3601832986,
-0.2013248205,
-0.2008687407,
-0.9170475602,
-0.1871175766,
0.1817069799,
-0.0861199275,
-0.3395765722,
0.9991841912,
0.5692234039,
-0.0243649259,
0.0366797075,
0.0306471102,
0.2192596793,
0.5880056024,
0.2816422284,
0.6410347223,
-0.3450078964,
0.5869076848,
-0.3210153282,
-0.0141291199,
0.0537864752,
-0.7814341187,
-1.0182626247,
-0.7978783846,
-0.0204141736,
-0.0136974175,
-0.1875833124,
0.4410995841,
0.4851667285,
-0.2650609612,
-0.2853066027,
-0.1664577127,
0.1482848972,
-0.0653675795,
-0.1823972464,
0.7183471918,
-0.4160582125,
-0.6911461353,
0.7668602467,
0.4362829626,
0.2467813492,
-0.1320268661,
0.3374307454,
-0.1734129339,
-0.0092322715,
0.7642756104,
0.1363374442,
-0.2211319953,
-0.0963319018,
0.0406300388,
-0.2778680027,
0.2922261059,
0.8985511661,
-0.7058929801,
0.3539164364,
0.6758557558,
0.4942610264,
0.826461792,
-0.0804926381,
0.7412285209,
-0.9808918834,
0.229533866,
0.3856322467,
0.4678207338,
0.1459970623,
-0.5129277706,
0.3372190595,
-0.2636018395,
-0.4880121648,
-0.8037520647,
0.2624683976,
-0.9059410095,
-0.3447498381,
0.8581981659,
0.0265690293,
-0.36147663,
-0.312271297,
-0.1400859505,
0.546151042,
-0.1061979309,
0.5639612675,
0.7903736234,
-0.0965732858,
-0.1094488427,
-0.5668575764,
0.8054375648,
0.2141896039,
-1.0350074768,
-0.107200779,
0.1966286302,
-0.0909788311,
0.447080195,
0.6400500536,
-0.2655057013,
-0.144993186,
-0.1063377559,
-0.1054455638,
-0.1885290146,
-0.5450789928,
-0.3070853949,
0.3473641574,
-0.1479990929,
0.014515928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17633v1
|
Navigating the OverKill in Large Language Models
| 2024-01-31T07:26:47 | 2024-01-31T07:26:47 |
Chenyu Shi, Xiao Wang, Qiming Ge, Songyang Gao, Xianjun Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Xun Zhao, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models are meticulously aligned to be both helpful and
harmless. However, recent research points to a potential overkill which means
models may refuse to answer benign queries. In this paper, we investigate the
factors for overkill by exploring how models handle and determine the safety of
queries. Our findings reveal the presence of shortcuts within models, leading
to an over-attention of harmful words like 'kill' and prompts emphasizing
safety will exacerbate overkill. Based on these insights, we introduce
Self-Contrastive Decoding (Self-CD), a training-free and model-agnostic
strategy, to alleviate this phenomenon. We first extract such over-attention by
amplifying the difference in the model's output distributions when responding
to system prompts that either include or omit an emphasis on safety. Then we
determine the final next-token predictions by downplaying the over-attention
from the model via contrastive decoding. Empirical results indicate that our
method has achieved an average reduction of the refusal rate by 20\% while
having almost no impact on safety.
|
[
-0.3661635518,
-0.8778196573,
0.7837124467,
0.0588567704,
-0.2166968882,
-0.2150789797,
0.0003995289,
-0.3673447371,
-0.1193071529,
0.7593568563,
-0.4732497633,
-0.330450356,
-0.5104469061,
0.0196472462,
-0.7005662322,
1.0993460417,
0.152322188,
-0.327072829,
-0.1769806445,
-0.0713075325,
-0.4048299491,
-0.8454729915,
-1.1193822622,
-0.027832929,
0.8083367944,
0.0902369767,
0.9310257435,
0.7676019073,
0.2983544767,
0.3067804873,
-0.3885580897,
-0.2044099718,
-0.8080490828,
0.0884992331,
-0.4541666806,
-0.4682695568,
-0.3803520203,
-0.0109584602,
0.3721887171,
0.6846749783,
-0.0858044326,
0.104146041,
0.2404389083,
0.6487500668,
-1.1223994493,
-0.0056391531,
-0.6514980793,
-0.2012679875,
-0.2257004827,
-0.1880686432,
-0.6658094525,
-0.1009453908,
-0.0253691711,
-0.4825542867,
-0.0931804106,
-0.0983059481,
0.4064629674,
0.3597787023,
-0.4943151176,
-0.3686835766,
-0.5056604743,
0.9560364485,
-0.5881744027,
0.1559942067,
0.8922267556,
0.2953602374,
-0.1628220677,
-0.307915628,
-0.3532821834,
-0.0727582052,
-0.2104326934,
0.0389004387,
-0.5338999033,
0.3774447739,
0.2993169427,
0.0634028241,
-0.5668329597,
0.212971434,
-0.5528566837,
-0.0301965643,
0.4862522483,
0.424501121,
0.4261813462,
-0.2671442926,
-0.2420837879,
0.1417576671,
-0.732865572,
-0.236343652,
0.194337979,
0.2257642895,
-0.0061449958,
0.4592806995,
-0.3770870864,
0.7264142632,
0.1063393056,
0.2337001562,
0.0313559473,
-0.3642608523,
-0.3746186793,
0.0345248729,
0.808958292,
0.6749717593,
0.5318484902,
-0.1653734595,
-0.1464397013,
0.0427979045,
0.5066078305,
-0.8031336665,
-0.2456611097,
0.6159963608,
-0.5922145247,
-0.4402808547,
-0.8132325411,
-0.6632005572,
-0.0980830118,
-0.0160572995,
0.613481462,
-0.4933593869,
-0.2371885628,
0.392975688,
0.0517258495,
0.0901090354,
0.2132976353,
-0.8373392224,
0.2280818522,
0.5296476483,
0.989593327,
-0.0237273034,
-0.2410570383,
-0.7433362007,
0.3820835948,
-0.4744835496,
0.582960844,
-0.3040812314,
-0.8076183796,
-0.0714169368,
0.0375490859,
-0.2063272148,
-0.4659129381,
0.5591310859,
-0.6274663806,
0.1764522195,
-0.6270874739,
-0.5823771358,
-0.3368909061,
0.455689013,
-0.5365532041,
0.588862896,
-0.2698125541,
-0.9719051719,
0.2421804816,
-0.5613973737,
-0.7790937424,
-0.0991649106,
0.0628742874,
-0.2399869263,
-0.0560151935,
0.0795050338,
0.538820982,
-0.1543472707,
0.0357390679,
-0.356368959,
-0.2299568802,
0.0615509823,
-0.4092377424,
0.977627635,
0.5504056215,
-0.2277408838,
0.0511199385,
-0.8570230603,
0.0775735304,
0.2039555758,
-0.4251396656,
-0.7488037348,
-0.104400456,
0.0232251454,
0.4519586861,
-0.0051770946,
-0.5495544672,
-0.2047391683,
-0.5784416795,
0.5040788651,
0.6402125955,
-0.1050504446,
0.3593650162,
-0.3506493568,
0.6887913346,
-0.0892588571,
0.3582165837,
-0.3765283227,
-0.2196782678,
-0.6562854052,
-0.0884340554,
0.088785015,
0.370695591,
-0.693059206,
0.3966867924,
-0.0339879133,
-0.4384360611,
-0.5542184114,
0.046040494,
0.8825393915,
0.4560776949,
0.5040326118,
-0.1344691962,
-0.322098881,
-0.8375916481,
-0.1747374982,
-0.1788101941,
0.0621314384,
0.0036119041,
0.5203101039,
-0.2162277251,
0.7529267073,
-0.539037168,
-0.5770719051,
-0.3604242504,
0.1161584109,
-0.1660768837,
0.5857995749,
0.7683632374,
-0.69324857,
-0.4732901156,
-0.1866562366,
-0.5924893022,
0.1518830508,
-0.3569612801,
-0.021261815,
0.3432182074,
1.0290989876,
-0.6561613083,
0.3285250962,
0.2903716862,
-0.104548879,
0.3618959785,
-0.3225032985,
-0.0598831922,
-0.8837093711,
0.4824261963,
-0.1673658341,
-0.0127139734,
-0.7284045815,
0.4055317938,
0.1716902405,
-0.1588937193,
-0.5258626342,
0.7202466726,
-0.5585494041,
0.1966805011,
-0.5356434584,
-0.0791758001,
0.1407039165,
0.3432488739,
-0.0219054706,
0.7710109353,
0.5559982061,
-0.6292671561,
0.0941289812,
0.2010281682,
-0.2752180398,
0.4683540463,
-0.9420286417,
-0.0422616117,
-0.4203048348,
0.1881997734,
-1.0281587839,
-0.1249160618,
0.3396478891,
-0.3885589242,
0.3172458112,
-0.4259664118,
-0.4382688105,
-0.3944381773,
-0.2326795608,
0.8388975859,
0.4458339214,
-0.3689795732,
0.5227251053,
0.4060923457,
-0.0832275599,
-0.4517195523,
-0.9396563768,
0.083322525,
-0.3336037993,
-0.3316601515,
-0.0534843393,
-0.1893715411,
-0.1297491342,
-0.2015472054,
0.1297991872,
-0.0935542732,
0.432908088,
0.2463391423,
-0.0905880705,
0.090937905,
0.1804418415,
-0.2067123055,
-0.3977963924,
0.4512546659,
0.0756524652,
0.5184109211,
0.2865677476,
-0.4776371419,
-0.2711004019,
0.6183884144,
0.7815064788,
-0.5291000605,
0.7745122313,
0.2519365549,
-0.1798239499,
0.1551579982,
-0.7226049304,
-0.1321205795,
-0.5272639394,
0.4613593519,
-0.3087696135,
-0.4845041931,
0.6976729035,
0.2458793968,
-0.0699762106,
0.1948999912,
0.3082741499,
0.0462775715,
1.29162848,
0.5989969969,
-0.3027958572,
0.3548152149,
-0.244745031,
0.06980066,
-0.5672188401,
-0.1758351773,
-0.657992363,
0.2014939934,
-0.3492586315,
-0.4190499485,
0.4957038164,
-0.1350454986,
-0.1662532687,
0.2696925402,
-0.3691426218,
0.7752667069,
0.4246191382,
-0.0074082022,
0.1003305465,
-0.2669943273,
0.0563855916,
0.0217269044,
-0.8106719255,
0.0422022827,
0.9676011801,
0.4627479911,
1.147957921,
-0.0552343652,
0.5527042747,
-0.0251171868,
-0.3085952997,
-0.8111863136,
0.5297904015,
-0.1824092865,
-1.0568474531,
-0.4734371006,
-0.4908235371,
-1.0681504011,
0.2501324117,
0.0639363378,
-0.5488023162,
0.1983339041,
0.4057162702,
-0.8631507754,
0.178205952,
-0.6639063954,
1.0686147213,
-0.3759877086,
-0.2355508804,
-0.5034027696,
-0.8191162348,
0.3074219525,
-0.1034892425,
0.4853438735,
0.1075951308,
0.246754691,
0.5617004633,
-0.1045893952,
1.0608296394,
0.1001231074,
-0.2774147987,
0.173994869,
0.5271978378,
0.5454612374,
-0.5781282187,
-0.2991286218,
0.0351108275,
0.0671946257,
-0.573410809,
-0.3431419134,
0.658480227,
-0.3684303463,
-0.5483337641,
-0.4011888206,
-0.2687990665,
0.104591012,
0.4569132328,
0.5342744589,
0.6877891421,
-0.0685913116,
0.1552915871,
0.7621863484,
-0.5226628184,
0.5086873174,
0.5363037586,
-0.157034725,
-0.1065083072,
1.0215972662,
0.3881905079,
0.782700479,
0.1862075627,
-0.0151328752,
-0.5137099028,
-0.6905066371,
-0.5731589198,
0.2352515757,
-1.0032583475,
-0.2159484476,
-1.1368246078,
-0.1987707466,
-0.3289163411,
-0.1800234616,
-0.5705408454,
-0.0776187629,
-0.4039593935,
-0.1584772617,
0.2548615932,
0.6838907599,
-0.1223054975,
0.2284104228,
-0.8402830362,
0.1563818455,
0.3832557797,
0.327858448,
0.3565518558,
-0.4577850401,
-0.4447331727,
-0.2203266025,
-0.1832211763,
-0.7726373076,
0.4813205302,
0.0037085465,
0.7501763701,
0.5048051476,
0.6394877434,
0.4336951375,
-0.4436816573,
0.5581085682,
0.2013493627,
-0.9553794265,
0.5360634923,
-0.6270022988,
0.7423473001,
0.647303462,
0.76277107,
-0.6411732435,
-0.5792844296,
-0.2874490023,
-1.0689754486,
0.6433017254,
0.2246427536,
0.4304406047,
-0.5478605032,
0.1277332604,
-0.0995433778,
0.1109832674,
-0.7287485003,
-0.2260564119,
-0.1854852885,
0.0659250766,
-0.0106340908,
-0.7807649374,
-0.1841176897,
0.0537369177,
0.5492978096,
-0.2768857479,
-0.0786671862,
-0.0617926233,
-0.0865348727,
-0.3273040652,
0.4823191464,
0.4791405201,
0.6347041726,
-0.2611801624,
0.1212199181,
0.2379403859,
-0.0540541373,
-0.0692618638,
-0.1019431129,
-0.3093850911,
-0.1796723902,
0.1963593811,
0.4571198821,
0.3509758413,
-0.649712801,
0.505122602,
0.0457979403,
0.112636216,
-0.0054007526,
0.0526197292,
0.0541881174,
-0.1384269893,
0.1279990524,
-0.2105742246,
0.6512198448,
-0.6803398132,
0.0230054986,
0.7084817886,
-0.3309338391,
-0.0856574401,
0.7183595896,
0.3497139812,
0.0789977461,
0.3135577738,
-0.0840399936,
-0.7222374082,
0.6192499995,
0.4802336097,
0.7851159573,
-0.2566521466,
0.2008728534,
0.4205930531,
0.3104466498,
-0.0924189836,
0.2218643874,
0.0693673491,
-0.3130012453,
-0.3823775053,
-0.4908272624,
-0.1498962194,
0.343963623,
-0.8609955311,
0.0507488512,
-0.5414914489,
-0.0806584358,
0.0771105662,
-0.4256546497,
-0.2546109557,
0.5778237581,
0.0373892523,
0.77029109,
-0.6598209739,
0.8896965981,
0.3235023618,
-0.5609711409,
-0.567540288,
0.1098647043,
0.0065511847,
-0.7587590218,
0.6089954972,
0.2983253896,
-0.3608309329,
-0.0846491158,
-0.3501081169,
-0.9885823131,
0.4429703951,
0.2488676608,
-0.6135729551,
-0.2925211489,
-0.0530896708,
0.5580147505,
0.1626953185,
0.2037755698,
0.5060791373,
0.2871646881,
0.067978926,
-1.1419062614,
0.2973110378,
0.0340159088,
-0.0820920691,
0.2362257093,
-0.7122263312,
0.9495346546,
-0.43211025,
-0.4559907615,
0.192096293,
0.1243663058,
-0.2251384109,
0.168463856,
0.6791390181,
0.3625974357,
0.2179493308,
0.4450836778,
1.2096749544,
-0.2662459314,
0.480209738,
1.1718356609,
-0.0425657183,
0.8905887008,
0.4637202322,
0.0295634959,
-0.101665169,
0.3456344604,
0.1516837478,
0.8068079352,
0.1691103727,
0.049600333,
-0.7493842244,
-0.033069402,
-0.5969967842,
0.4899134338,
0.4598536491,
-0.5126633048,
-0.648568213,
0.19533059,
0.1245384812,
0.1296624541,
-0.346401155,
0.856055975,
0.2196743637,
-0.6453550458,
1.0842891932,
-0.1066682935,
0.6796082258,
-0.4577436149,
0.2195966393,
-0.1261802763,
0.1616358459,
0.0099953422,
-0.9407731295,
0.5192494392,
-0.3044799864,
-0.3930769861,
-0.221014902,
0.5460444093,
-0.4384790957,
-0.3632510006,
0.8650584817,
0.2541681528,
0.2302195728,
-0.3859581947,
-0.793898344,
0.0892671719,
-0.0266006738,
-0.0874888226,
0.5815665126,
0.4326474965,
0.0732596144,
1.2274565697,
0.5162544847,
-0.1091296226,
-0.0671436489,
-0.2636458874,
0.990717411,
-0.5736327171,
-0.9356252551,
-0.9214625955,
0.2688939571,
0.2742405534,
-0.1132473573,
0.7881193757,
0.2469354719,
0.9586967826,
-0.0163846631,
0.690097928,
0.3337573707,
0.734048903,
-0.6739074588,
1.1918627024,
-0.9118772149,
0.2841590643,
-0.2775309682,
-0.3276108503,
-0.1968066394,
0.4521977007,
-0.6354499459,
0.2806533873,
0.3687211275,
0.8292387724,
-0.1376004964,
-0.2761463821,
0.7723756433,
0.4006532431,
0.2161655128,
0.5609405041,
0.746842742,
-0.1489059478,
0.9936950803,
-0.1800849736,
0.0780838281,
-0.5979768038,
-0.7610684037,
-1.1703004837,
-0.354508549,
-0.2386294901,
-0.4514977932,
0.4965937138,
0.6286404133,
0.8975723982,
-0.8420569301,
-0.0603870936,
0.0367215425,
0.0197981372,
0.2029149681,
-0.1298061311,
0.4210269153,
-0.497841984,
-0.4779475927,
0.3489739001,
0.1212426946,
0.3393366933,
-0.3568895757,
0.1758665293,
-0.1677879989,
0.064048551,
0.5048841834,
0.6101982594,
-0.7298822999,
-0.2418212295,
-0.2089331746,
-0.4415195882,
-0.1841109395,
0.6114112139,
-0.6198160052,
0.5688173771,
0.319795996,
0.5995537639,
0.0834327638,
0.0030959593,
0.8912417889,
-0.6646351218,
0.1306339502,
0.1009105518,
0.2175123245,
0.3891743124,
-0.8038645983,
0.2060820162,
-0.1594408453,
-0.6759420037,
-0.7978007793,
0.360477984,
-0.6653038859,
-0.8026869297,
1.3318806887,
-0.3596355915,
-0.2754534483,
-0.550532043,
-0.4548934698,
-0.0222667307,
-0.4273317754,
1.019998312,
0.4703479409,
0.2641445994,
-0.1368378252,
-0.4542177916,
0.8525473475,
0.8961187005,
-0.5870207548,
0.4814688861,
0.6353635788,
0.4864850044,
0.375739336,
0.6899371147,
0.0527546108,
0.5759071708,
-0.0830038339,
-0.1231962517,
0.0220123529,
-0.4921091795,
-0.5581223965,
0.2773810327,
0.1011861488,
-0.4217297435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17632v1
|
What Do Self-Supervised Speech and Speaker Models Learn? New Findings From a Cross Model Layer-Wise Analysis
| 2024-01-31T07:23:22 | 2024-01-31T07:23:22 |
Takanori Ashihara, Marc Delcroix, Takafumi Moriya, Kohei Matsuura, Taichi Asami, Yusuke Ijima
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Self-supervised learning (SSL) has attracted increased attention for learning
meaningful speech representations. Speech SSL models, such as WavLM, employ
masked prediction training to encode general-purpose representations. In
contrast, speaker SSL models, exemplified by DINO-based models, adopt
utterance-level training objectives primarily for speaker representation.
Understanding how these models represent information is essential for refining
model efficiency and effectiveness. Unlike the various analyses of speech SSL,
there has been limited investigation into what information speaker SSL captures
and how its representation differs from speech SSL or other fully-supervised
speaker models. This paper addresses these fundamental questions. We explore
the capacity to capture various speech properties by applying SUPERB evaluation
probing tasks to speech and speaker SSL models. We also examine which layers
are predominantly utilized for each task to identify differences in how speech
is represented. Furthermore, we conduct direct comparisons to measure the
similarities between layers within and across models. Our analysis unveils that
1) the capacity to represent content information is somewhat unrelated to
enhanced speaker representation, 2) specific layers of speech SSL models would
be partly specialized in capturing linguistic information, and 3) speaker SSL
models tend to disregard linguistic information but exhibit more sophisticated
speaker representation.
|
[
-0.3805675805,
-0.5257753134,
0.445407778,
-0.1454247087,
0.1225967407,
0.0255574975,
0.0989517123,
-0.6355705261,
0.0227997303,
0.7040370107,
-0.4254309535,
-0.1302663237,
-0.3555412292,
-0.1627154648,
-0.534794867,
0.8889197111,
0.6506499648,
0.1698167175,
-0.3667275012,
0.2169055045,
-0.2448472083,
-0.8056521416,
-0.4148851335,
-0.6066996455,
0.2660707831,
0.1429992616,
0.3927280009,
0.7671664953,
0.0938836858,
0.3244971335,
-0.039624963,
-0.1657712609,
-0.5286874771,
0.0162286293,
-0.3936243355,
-0.0554584488,
-0.2055907845,
0.4556246996,
0.735293448,
0.8649337888,
-0.0634612367,
0.4374542236,
0.2913540304,
0.3219060302,
-0.5914276242,
0.2798269689,
-0.8280054927,
0.2293294817,
-0.2916439176,
-0.3929888308,
-0.6346077323,
0.3762670457,
0.3031460643,
-0.1243423074,
0.2805036008,
-0.1846445501,
0.4571472406,
0.055481948,
-0.5936555266,
-0.1149003953,
-0.9633721709,
0.8159230351,
-0.6798145175,
0.6541099548,
0.538985908,
0.4515914023,
0.2196739912,
-0.6071017385,
-0.2203827649,
-0.4020854831,
-0.0068336097,
0.22622177,
-0.167619139,
0.0970015228,
0.2099167556,
0.4054349661,
-0.2739449143,
0.3050249517,
-0.5481440425,
-0.4814306796,
0.9042545557,
-0.0145456744,
0.1372327954,
-0.498975575,
-0.5548772812,
-0.2134504914,
-0.3047938049,
0.2326955795,
0.4097414613,
0.4893044233,
-0.0506583713,
0.4436252117,
-0.1229637414,
0.6440845132,
0.1475000829,
-0.1788738221,
0.0847538635,
-0.1294126362,
-0.272790432,
0.3234807551,
0.7592965364,
-0.1856084168,
0.2756819129,
-0.2807986438,
-0.1883378923,
-0.4453512728,
0.3816354573,
-0.3838123083,
-0.4026698768,
0.1796176285,
-0.6080492735,
-0.0779682398,
0.0799708441,
-0.3374762237,
-0.2180596143,
-0.4660025835,
0.5731053948,
-0.3265018165,
-0.5870442986,
-0.2064421624,
-0.2694969177,
0.3066531718,
0.1549292207,
-1.0292005539,
0.6124920845,
0.6109739542,
0.4998427927,
-0.1992336959,
-0.3632315397,
-0.6394491196,
0.2182125151,
-0.461571455,
0.3910570443,
-0.6685805917,
-0.2657854259,
-0.1245234758,
-0.244578287,
-0.3679958582,
-0.3737211227,
0.2939347029,
-0.3650225401,
0.2060837448,
-0.2449290752,
-0.88460356,
-0.1237196401,
-0.2019392699,
-0.6958816648,
0.7526772618,
-0.0624351203,
-0.8066859841,
0.0789029747,
-0.2243792862,
-0.1250130385,
0.1790971756,
-0.3780670762,
-0.2169764787,
0.2836199701,
0.0484496802,
0.8791810274,
0.0814240351,
-0.1505547315,
-0.2958266735,
-0.176894635,
0.381418705,
-0.4031726718,
0.6064265966,
0.2780883312,
-0.2442145199,
0.0229610857,
-1.00691998,
0.0506156273,
0.244532004,
-0.2336957008,
-0.2669261098,
0.0144043304,
-0.0272102933,
0.1523500383,
0.2474533319,
-0.7817801237,
-0.4339772761,
-0.2042463422,
0.6360923648,
0.6773590446,
-0.0411165543,
0.2967180908,
0.1290454417,
0.3530571461,
-0.120737128,
0.0589119121,
-0.1814792603,
-0.3677318096,
-0.3947155774,
-0.0344297998,
0.5372947454,
0.4079685509,
-0.1861962229,
0.1529423445,
0.0762913525,
-0.561616838,
-0.7650360465,
0.2134373784,
0.6658645868,
0.6028730869,
0.4519383609,
-0.320905596,
-0.3129964471,
-1.0424118042,
-0.2340067327,
-0.3430626094,
0.0985445157,
0.3382547498,
0.3217762113,
0.2890136242,
0.8587653041,
0.1461044997,
-0.3151113093,
-0.4631642103,
0.0861300901,
-0.1013401523,
0.5970228314,
0.6057338715,
-0.7852541208,
-0.3261552751,
0.0101957265,
-0.6577051878,
-0.0110593261,
-0.2626030445,
0.2138814628,
-0.1434440315,
0.4783422053,
-0.4818612337,
0.3875629008,
0.5805476904,
-0.1235460266,
0.483425647,
-0.3006877303,
-0.0369559787,
-0.3709868193,
-0.2550697029,
0.0422243811,
-0.3808944523,
-0.9706029296,
0.0137919998,
0.1925750375,
-0.227904126,
-0.4714718163,
0.4598312676,
-0.6772215366,
-0.6881254315,
-0.3490363061,
0.2969141901,
0.0646449327,
0.4801819921,
0.2442666441,
0.5968590975,
0.7418396473,
-0.4483205676,
0.2929669619,
-0.0696411133,
-0.2413923889,
0.3706026971,
-0.7986354828,
0.4889879525,
0.07613419,
0.0208096225,
-1.0914435387,
-0.259319663,
0.002400941,
-0.4452838898,
0.5950061679,
-0.2844232917,
-0.0941348225,
-0.2892247438,
0.0199601706,
0.2805666327,
0.4720493853,
-0.6107270122,
0.7960187793,
0.6919573545,
-0.0841436386,
-0.4962210655,
-0.9654606581,
-0.0144438539,
-0.0424490422,
-0.3868630826,
0.5301365852,
0.2061175704,
-0.0897364169,
0.0109829856,
-0.2566584945,
-0.1121656299,
0.0533036031,
0.3129573464,
-0.1270497292,
-0.2856844664,
0.3022963703,
-0.2876753211,
0.0214044005,
0.3102937341,
-0.2529691458,
0.57140553,
-0.1096841842,
-0.6724819541,
-0.8831394911,
0.5752445459,
0.0841023177,
-0.5690459609,
0.4824103415,
0.6151952147,
-0.0753782392,
-0.2197213024,
-0.8549349904,
-0.1465681046,
-0.3954430223,
0.3541364074,
-0.7461761832,
-0.8169488311,
0.6823433042,
0.535995543,
-0.1346860677,
0.6472215056,
0.3332012296,
-0.3060613871,
1.0545890331,
0.66943115,
-0.0795688853,
0.3514300287,
-0.2374570519,
-0.1023393199,
-0.920262754,
-0.3907630742,
-0.5300966501,
0.168610543,
-0.4846709371,
-0.2565074861,
-0.1007682756,
0.0362926275,
-0.0169390235,
0.2828319371,
-0.4978414774,
0.3034533262,
0.8237017393,
0.0596647523,
0.0289361123,
-0.0005646148,
0.0207810327,
-0.0666815415,
-0.7081504464,
-0.3492790163,
0.9411517382,
0.7274422646,
0.7719346285,
-0.2895971239,
0.9051967859,
0.474178642,
-0.64680022,
-0.4677793384,
0.5577572584,
-0.073368609,
-0.5606713295,
-0.3568641245,
-0.5036100745,
-0.7669916749,
0.4165322483,
-0.0055866111,
-0.7406850457,
0.3579108715,
0.1848304272,
-0.270181179,
0.3239011467,
-0.6353138685,
0.8478425145,
-0.2895923853,
-0.0814540312,
-0.4697515666,
-0.542501092,
0.06479121,
-0.0034296592,
-0.0075435885,
-0.0860495195,
0.3866042793,
0.8900290728,
0.0513707362,
0.9605171084,
-0.2882108092,
-0.1738988906,
0.4403448403,
0.1893938631,
-0.0672616735,
-0.2048615813,
-0.2157241404,
0.3738852441,
0.157645762,
-0.4861576259,
-0.4546507597,
0.605007112,
-0.8919417858,
-0.827565074,
-0.1499069631,
-0.248312071,
-0.2244413644,
-0.062374305,
-0.0094747897,
0.897149086,
-0.1743520498,
0.3240323365,
0.5668109059,
-0.1894858927,
0.3864932656,
0.3857803643,
-0.1009788066,
0.0758115053,
0.9557551146,
0.4771647453,
0.6226292849,
0.3931380212,
0.1764922291,
-0.4280729294,
-0.7058115602,
-0.2474313676,
0.1639298797,
-1.0267733335,
0.2227789611,
-0.8076210022,
-0.8046067953,
-0.8096600771,
0.5040990114,
-0.4439756572,
-0.5951311588,
-0.4091190994,
-0.2909904122,
-0.1447776109,
0.8736575842,
-0.378005147,
0.1851394475,
-0.3972565532,
0.2579301298,
0.934250176,
-0.0283757895,
0.1835354567,
-0.7716196775,
-0.1777352989,
0.0307842065,
-0.1090382114,
-1.0801627636,
0.2157865912,
0.6082597375,
1.1057095528,
0.3335838318,
-0.1265645325,
0.689191103,
-0.38441661,
1.0808862448,
-0.1074889228,
-1.1520451307,
0.8908694386,
-0.1542265117,
0.1773490906,
0.2453941554,
0.3161143064,
-0.3072677553,
-0.5351191163,
-0.7821049094,
-0.2869744003,
0.7799309492,
0.1973385066,
0.5542629361,
0.0555732399,
0.2901721299,
0.2401692271,
-0.0393740796,
-0.8425313234,
-0.0300530363,
-0.718981266,
0.065251857,
-0.0678410381,
-0.4835985601,
-0.0469771251,
-0.0862290338,
0.3711724877,
-0.0466127582,
0.2908026874,
0.4577993751,
-0.0858041421,
0.1549945325,
0.3019279242,
0.0740102306,
0.5270290971,
-0.2900972068,
0.4571605325,
0.1138567328,
-0.0008901547,
-0.2733469009,
-0.067177318,
0.3057994843,
-0.0204687379,
0.8615292311,
0.9987931252,
0.0367096625,
-0.4210201204,
0.5781763792,
0.2000382841,
-0.0759488717,
-0.2298567146,
0.3602895737,
-0.0143129602,
0.4701675475,
0.5129621029,
-0.133819744,
0.464548111,
-0.9052916765,
0.2089310288,
0.5664836168,
-0.6689680815,
-0.4314972162,
0.7157996893,
0.0812701061,
-0.3062438965,
0.5257633924,
-0.0514339246,
-0.4918288291,
0.519544065,
0.6617899537,
0.7085462213,
-0.6615703106,
0.4428436756,
0.0252314564,
-0.0833107084,
0.3476448655,
0.0411126465,
-0.7445902824,
-0.6408845782,
-0.447933197,
-0.504106164,
-0.4241571724,
0.0685197785,
-0.9534819722,
-0.2551249266,
-0.3806723356,
-0.1213429272,
0.2608978152,
-0.0310762729,
-0.7045376897,
0.3425743878,
0.5765333772,
0.695222199,
-0.8812031746,
1.0380424261,
0.2316389531,
-0.2799832821,
-0.9918334484,
-0.205347091,
0.0024184647,
-0.7882922292,
0.909714222,
0.2538609803,
-0.3348577917,
0.038375251,
-0.4585462511,
-0.8130638599,
0.7247563601,
0.4666967094,
-0.4716226161,
-0.0069332691,
0.3565378785,
0.6100257635,
-0.7547217607,
0.4297793508,
0.3639287651,
-0.02434716,
-0.0042504491,
-1.1417064667,
-0.2826508284,
-0.2536035776,
0.1255955696,
-0.5761684775,
-0.4288124144,
0.9415718317,
-0.0004617614,
-0.4439377487,
-0.1921188533,
0.8432571292,
0.034676902,
0.1785240918,
0.5914725661,
0.1415859163,
0.7206522226,
0.0576517656,
1.1465519667,
-0.2162071913,
0.2921959162,
1.367087245,
-0.1475353837,
0.9088567495,
0.1312102228,
-0.0550447777,
0.3784133792,
0.6788342595,
-0.2212309837,
0.6770021915,
-0.0763076395,
0.2272240371,
-0.7829118967,
-0.2581232488,
-0.5609716177,
0.9407706857,
0.1071311012,
-0.3977807462,
0.019222213,
0.325688839,
-0.6102301478,
0.0600843616,
-0.4345942438,
0.8556260467,
0.2690053582,
-0.3473534286,
0.4114814699,
-0.2987234294,
0.0589197278,
-0.4255748689,
0.106663309,
0.1184730083,
-0.0492156744,
-0.2372648865,
-0.923584342,
0.0977160111,
-0.2955617607,
-0.1009178162,
-0.3460250795,
1.0002726316,
-0.4185449779,
-0.2192578614,
0.748942554,
0.6076798439,
0.4524977803,
-0.1062581241,
-0.7232471108,
-0.0198512524,
-0.0689791664,
-0.2746591568,
0.2311077118,
0.3210288286,
0.3218384683,
0.7452868819,
0.3577911556,
0.3954063952,
0.4252678752,
0.4984658957,
0.5038613081,
-0.7313128114,
-0.5218263865,
-0.7411448359,
0.3588277102,
-0.3293831944,
-0.1373376101,
0.9244110584,
0.3650870323,
1.0114850998,
-0.0134722022,
0.5853912234,
0.3462364078,
0.7136837244,
-0.6672146916,
0.3096095026,
-0.5248649716,
0.1448669583,
-0.2254576236,
-0.7879198194,
0.3189614415,
0.5886025429,
-0.3945233822,
0.1608200967,
0.1595696807,
0.3973808587,
-0.3501125872,
0.3115703464,
0.5728683472,
0.1617300659,
0.2475378513,
0.2864268422,
1.2165291309,
-0.2285117805,
0.3906716108,
-0.4994858205,
0.1496146768,
-0.0783104599,
-0.44377321,
-1.1480373144,
-0.8591541052,
-0.4509135485,
0.0769411847,
-0.0482118204,
0.5803282261,
1.3006372452,
-0.7739911079,
-0.3184849024,
0.2959228158,
-0.1870769262,
-0.3251757324,
-0.2066625059,
0.4147211611,
-0.4060920179,
-0.491678834,
0.8807699084,
0.2964603007,
0.0551882535,
-0.7222551703,
0.0818670765,
0.1834415048,
0.2046773136,
0.4218600094,
0.2946469486,
-0.9752675891,
-0.3485955894,
-0.3017015755,
-0.2566881776,
0.1805223525,
0.5238232017,
-0.8605434299,
0.5553694963,
0.4605598152,
0.6439270973,
0.8305784464,
-0.02882904,
0.4063792527,
-0.868663013,
-0.0199199915,
0.1168051139,
0.306478858,
0.4638535082,
-0.2886114419,
0.2686639428,
-0.1070645154,
-0.5442221165,
-0.7557920218,
0.333019644,
-1.0816704035,
-0.369096458,
0.9330749512,
-0.2911210358,
-0.1982150525,
-0.0516767837,
-0.0154033201,
0.2413876206,
-0.1443501711,
0.5783712268,
0.5580306053,
-0.3549029529,
-0.5053859353,
-0.681599021,
0.3466917276,
0.4691006839,
-0.3503473699,
-0.0711682439,
0.200586915,
0.2759524882,
0.4169223607,
0.6127855182,
-0.1104323417,
0.2238310128,
-0.0280438457,
-0.2840502858,
-0.2668749094,
-0.5179513097,
-0.4506704211,
0.6213617921,
-0.1584078819,
-0.2597424388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17623v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17623v2
|
Neighboring Perturbations of Knowledge Editing on Large Language Models
| 2024-01-31T06:49:36 | 2024-05-27T03:52:43 |
Jun-Yu Ma, Zhen-Hua Ling, Ningyu Zhang, Jia-Chen Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite their exceptional capabilities, large language models (LLMs) are
prone to generating unintended text due to false or outdated knowledge. Given
the resource-intensive nature of retraining LLMs, there has been a notable
increase in the development of knowledge editing. However, current approaches
and evaluations rarely explore the perturbation of editing on neighboring
knowledge. This paper studies whether updating new knowledge to LLMs perturbs
the neighboring knowledge encapsulated within them. Specifically, we seek to
figure out whether appending a new answer into an answer list to a factual
question leads to catastrophic forgetting of original correct answers in this
list, as well as unintentional inclusion of incorrect answers. A metric of
additivity is introduced and a benchmark dubbed as Perturbation Evaluation of
Appending Knowledge (PEAK) is constructed to evaluate the degree of
perturbation to neighboring knowledge when appending new knowledge. Besides, a
plug-and-play framework termed Appending via Preservation and Prevention (APP)
is proposed to mitigate the neighboring perturbation by maintaining the
integrity of the answer list. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of APP
coupling with four editing methods on four LLMs. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/mjy1111/PEAK.
|
[
-0.4014228582,
-1.0487759113,
0.5810446143,
-0.1239537895,
0.1688372195,
0.0885991827,
-0.2971422672,
-0.3136920333,
0.0048320214,
0.7513051629,
-0.3219328821,
-0.5212821364,
-0.4393177629,
-0.2298553288,
-0.2625753284,
1.1044967175,
-0.0052351779,
-0.2717410624,
-0.7599163055,
-0.3240394592,
-0.780411005,
-0.9709920883,
-0.4392380416,
-0.3447520435,
0.4298813641,
0.7153529525,
0.8214125633,
0.7234709859,
0.3317470253,
0.3152897954,
-0.413955152,
0.0699841157,
-0.6808735132,
0.2505037189,
-0.3150354624,
-0.7287821174,
-0.598744452,
-0.1677315831,
0.9175716043,
0.7695917487,
0.0513740778,
0.3829668462,
0.0484400392,
0.6173629761,
-0.6534569263,
-0.2724374831,
-1.0484017134,
-0.1764976233,
-0.1197136119,
-0.2064128816,
-0.2570643127,
-0.4279403389,
0.0675786957,
-0.1957972944,
0.1747769564,
-0.2050735652,
0.6492057443,
0.3370989859,
-0.0060204435,
-0.1402862519,
-0.6512835026,
0.5955103636,
-0.7207905054,
0.3127861023,
0.3171158731,
-0.0982793868,
-0.4579287469,
-0.2831389308,
-0.7225062847,
-0.1406952441,
0.1461588144,
-0.0524367467,
-0.1938281059,
-0.0676412135,
0.4250590801,
0.4116912186,
-0.1814758629,
0.28390944,
-0.1641516685,
-0.2064179331,
0.5192171931,
0.3795344532,
0.3679125309,
-0.0330512486,
-0.2733972669,
-0.0286610443,
-1.2069085836,
0.1879807413,
0.5646826029,
0.0998972282,
0.1231855303,
0.7186140418,
0.0203247145,
0.572881043,
0.1585015804,
-0.0592506155,
0.1558161527,
-0.4848312736,
0.074911043,
-0.0291600451,
0.5736730695,
0.6009405851,
0.2688046694,
0.0076958714,
-0.166732803,
-0.216501072,
0.0535120256,
-0.4740937948,
-0.395994693,
0.0981638059,
-0.2276286036,
-0.3334428668,
-0.3749336004,
-0.3262679577,
-0.6013139486,
-0.0610499159,
0.5908610821,
-0.5451758504,
0.0075918278,
-0.0113402372,
0.0626819059,
-0.3034709096,
0.3503516912,
-0.7190945745,
0.3133279681,
0.6097013354,
0.6450828314,
0.1932730377,
-0.7666992545,
-0.6276906729,
0.2887843549,
-0.3683195412,
0.9062452912,
-0.5462902188,
-0.4697816372,
-0.0688354,
-0.1655157208,
-0.0105829006,
-0.7297700047,
0.2589908242,
-0.7631182671,
0.0462442525,
-0.5410682559,
-0.7311487198,
-0.2343772352,
0.4609220326,
-0.4672092497,
0.8694761992,
-0.0327651575,
-0.9465661049,
0.1130512878,
-0.3630479872,
-0.4925873578,
-0.3314576745,
0.1003829017,
-0.4965059459,
0.1909039617,
0.250009954,
0.2737669051,
0.0318719782,
0.0875748321,
-0.4197832942,
-0.4183861315,
0.5273109078,
-0.2844409347,
0.6030002236,
-0.2263584733,
0.2546099722,
0.2969241142,
-0.658988893,
-0.3306672573,
-0.0468649417,
-0.483028084,
-0.709892571,
-0.064345181,
-0.6270405054,
0.1221995875,
0.4093594253,
-0.5734389424,
0.420522958,
-0.1859541833,
0.0430213772,
1.0541819334,
0.6571588516,
0.3008306921,
-0.779664278,
0.5311561227,
0.0194950271,
0.1546473354,
-0.2308743149,
-0.4105249941,
-0.5404825807,
0.2697119117,
0.1273045987,
0.5913016796,
-0.6034133434,
0.0932248384,
-0.3973529041,
-0.5083554983,
-0.1838963479,
0.3350877166,
0.3324791491,
0.7078951597,
0.4119949639,
-0.0901935175,
-0.5864041448,
-0.626406312,
-0.4030275941,
-0.2886454761,
0.130548507,
0.3700841665,
0.3604869545,
-0.2899565399,
0.9345662594,
-0.5551328063,
-0.2918237448,
0.0760820508,
-0.3602856994,
0.3511028886,
0.3808665276,
0.5935825109,
-0.3144793212,
-0.4474039078,
-0.1683813035,
-0.5188633204,
-0.22795856,
-0.0526324101,
-0.0454644524,
-0.0384315215,
0.4634538889,
-0.3588132262,
0.1754760742,
0.678635478,
-0.110178493,
1.126459837,
-0.2850698233,
0.1623277813,
-1.032435298,
-0.1250819266,
-0.3510934114,
-0.0388725661,
-0.6726620793,
0.0947562456,
-0.0387172028,
0.2984842956,
-0.3397710621,
0.4604168534,
-0.2520954907,
-0.0540122055,
-0.1489676386,
0.297370404,
-0.1420489252,
0.1900544912,
-0.0787089914,
0.8222732544,
0.2743012011,
-0.7113851309,
0.4982933104,
0.5576490164,
-0.1338236034,
0.3676045239,
-0.3090364635,
0.3071897626,
-0.1287558675,
0.0533944219,
-0.7633339167,
0.0668877512,
-0.0868291259,
-0.617287457,
0.209564209,
-0.3534595072,
-0.4602873921,
-0.1412047446,
-0.7729625106,
0.3478974998,
0.0809888169,
-0.5183380842,
0.1645662636,
0.4842395782,
-0.2905891538,
-0.6263648868,
-0.6787002683,
0.149908483,
-0.23142308,
-0.6443915963,
0.2472946048,
-0.2237082571,
-0.4506585002,
0.3874997199,
-0.0071074725,
0.1840471476,
0.0332029127,
0.0267348588,
0.3142382503,
-0.1072065532,
0.3403639197,
0.1345435232,
-0.0060904771,
0.0881922916,
-0.1361789703,
0.4175259769,
0.0413383208,
-0.3572586179,
-0.1877046824,
0.0729332939,
0.6950652599,
-0.2745397687,
0.8288699389,
0.2690806389,
-0.429055661,
0.10562139,
-0.893384099,
-0.1305841506,
-0.4953145683,
0.6809263825,
-0.6597532034,
-1.0564476252,
0.8907040954,
0.0883332565,
0.0868590698,
0.3935030103,
0.4321363568,
-0.0016657144,
0.6175740361,
0.5686530471,
-0.274045676,
0.4825281501,
-0.0999244601,
0.0176300593,
-1.3429359198,
-0.000393327,
-0.3977685571,
-0.1138440892,
-0.4081607163,
-0.4736796319,
0.5059447885,
0.1968465447,
-0.2339056432,
0.2601986527,
-0.1782832891,
0.5049052835,
0.3465206325,
0.1119216532,
0.5462911725,
-0.0110551976,
-0.3059236407,
-0.1543108225,
-1.0202783346,
-0.3917831182,
1.3351402283,
0.3230332136,
0.7518262267,
0.283100158,
0.6750149131,
0.2603761554,
0.3105621338,
-0.5608346462,
0.5141642094,
-0.2155617923,
-0.4461064637,
-0.4223652184,
-0.4875852466,
-0.4812844694,
0.0229930766,
-0.3775221109,
-1.0213259459,
0.1744245738,
0.3688348532,
-0.5208676457,
0.7601950765,
-0.5623037219,
0.6343083382,
-0.0286704376,
-0.7126141191,
-0.3117130101,
-0.3048716486,
0.350604862,
-0.1163988933,
0.4660095572,
0.0707772747,
0.0404032506,
0.6524757743,
-0.430121243,
0.6475532651,
-0.2271451503,
-0.3039194345,
0.4670816064,
0.4153153896,
0.7706735134,
0.190756768,
-0.2852304578,
-0.0447555594,
0.0646882504,
-0.2663938105,
-0.6755004525,
1.0506874323,
-0.7015116215,
-0.8076745272,
-0.0960479081,
-0.6239572167,
-0.5132144094,
0.0824091211,
0.246560052,
0.5590534806,
0.1400846839,
0.0884857625,
0.8165391684,
-0.5279137492,
0.2129841149,
0.4938996434,
-0.3949393034,
-0.4916178286,
0.9356081486,
0.4799664617,
0.4837962687,
0.3443825245,
0.3827683628,
-0.1168596148,
-0.8225226998,
-0.285494566,
0.2972940207,
-0.7817659378,
-0.1352420449,
-0.6755626798,
-0.1804853529,
-0.3558521867,
-0.178017363,
-0.4120368958,
-0.3193380833,
-0.0278050005,
-0.0348463468,
0.4530976415,
0.8726041913,
-0.3244776428,
0.0332558528,
-0.9931986332,
-0.102105841,
0.3187323511,
0.5633292794,
0.3587575853,
-0.6540676355,
-0.5180614591,
0.0543729849,
-0.1035248935,
-0.8755463362,
-0.2770829201,
-0.0062428787,
0.5577945113,
0.2345984131,
0.1656876802,
0.9267619848,
-0.5609020591,
0.7410037518,
-0.0431800149,
-0.8538526893,
0.3767917752,
-0.45478338,
0.6839793921,
0.5426440239,
0.1682356745,
-0.8894787431,
-0.5620054603,
-0.4649642408,
-0.6333796978,
0.4460315704,
-0.3374740779,
0.4261683822,
0.1133015454,
0.6791987419,
0.0654767156,
0.1616829336,
-0.4890308976,
-0.2002116442,
0.2008113861,
0.2769073844,
0.0308288392,
-0.8530304432,
0.1514921784,
-0.3603055775,
0.8769524693,
0.2272185981,
0.0090347687,
0.2390433103,
-0.2164511532,
-0.332249403,
0.2169532329,
0.6050743461,
0.599201858,
-0.1159568951,
0.1579347253,
0.7058342695,
-0.4808611572,
0.0417610854,
-0.2670833766,
-0.2934143841,
-0.3046790063,
0.6472745538,
0.476356864,
0.088848263,
-0.4880355895,
0.3078058064,
-0.034142226,
-0.0692424998,
-0.3102728724,
0.0375441685,
0.0557127111,
0.1006482467,
0.2808468044,
0.2576414943,
-0.0885401517,
-0.6346789002,
0.2857366502,
0.4424612522,
-0.4065111578,
-0.460373193,
0.4886833429,
-0.1843645722,
-0.3635218441,
0.3872161508,
-0.0765312612,
-1.0580127239,
0.1366987675,
0.4928213656,
0.4711355269,
-0.5193912387,
-0.2935973704,
0.3881016374,
0.5794537663,
0.5252773166,
0.0423695706,
-0.011364867,
-1.0543932915,
-0.620413363,
-0.4179689586,
-0.4135932028,
0.4693803191,
-0.2488521934,
0.2146595567,
-0.5473543406,
-0.1501772255,
-0.3653679788,
-0.0027813253,
-0.2728494108,
0.0955772623,
-0.2300783098,
0.5619673133,
-0.800221622,
0.6689699292,
0.9556204677,
-0.2367254049,
-0.7164661288,
0.298343569,
0.0353395008,
-0.3206453919,
0.0320777781,
-0.2240979522,
-0.2197882831,
-0.1510127634,
-0.2979041636,
-0.9933066964,
0.518586576,
0.3059097826,
-0.4913094938,
0.1840472817,
0.0346562639,
0.4949386716,
0.0371230245,
-0.0385375693,
0.563976109,
0.2914455533,
0.0325776786,
-1.0107072592,
0.223960951,
-0.1863616258,
-0.1978364289,
0.079875268,
-0.6557776928,
0.8747376204,
-0.5026695132,
0.1158797815,
0.0845337883,
0.1702973843,
-0.0441482887,
-0.1209512278,
0.414359659,
0.6756646633,
0.6348212957,
0.2311092317,
0.8053622246,
-0.2033400387,
0.2466371059,
1.5347633362,
-0.1947437823,
0.7938435078,
0.4844550192,
-0.3607147038,
0.5123426914,
0.4120332003,
0.1193804964,
0.1879680157,
0.2519724965,
-0.3704333901,
-0.0209303796,
-0.0524211377,
-0.4669303298,
0.4499062598,
0.3663247824,
-0.0261308774,
-0.0548243001,
0.0069068908,
0.4315159321,
0.4208022058,
-0.2107281238,
0.8987294436,
-0.2343111187,
-0.6082802415,
0.6258310676,
-0.031932611,
0.4020452499,
-0.1588181853,
-0.0152787548,
-0.2280109674,
0.2895364165,
-0.4376343191,
-0.9361101985,
0.5079601407,
0.0248861723,
-0.4274129272,
0.1900487393,
0.667265296,
-0.4409561455,
-0.1860446185,
0.3774121404,
0.3059402406,
-0.193806231,
-0.1077708676,
-0.2674249411,
0.1164834052,
0.1698633581,
-0.196878776,
0.374756068,
0.3437695801,
-0.0718670338,
0.6183281541,
0.7739379406,
0.3532030582,
0.1800713539,
-0.0290236119,
1.1860579252,
-0.325671941,
-0.32650581,
-1.0004775524,
0.4076724648,
-0.0237892251,
-0.078449674,
1.0310070515,
0.6164563298,
0.8313217163,
0.0865006223,
0.8454892635,
0.1630621254,
0.5697812438,
-0.4771947265,
0.8251182437,
-0.3909436464,
0.7535235882,
-0.6489052773,
-1.1597105265,
-0.4651016593,
0.1838999093,
-0.7560222745,
-0.2231724709,
0.5846553445,
0.6559842825,
0.2375100851,
-0.1825596541,
0.3695040047,
0.6423717141,
0.219509393,
0.575197041,
0.9999406934,
-0.3061763942,
0.4579191506,
-0.5245713592,
-0.3937312961,
-0.0338478535,
-0.7090767026,
-0.8595202565,
-0.4936154783,
-0.3505662978,
-0.3962576687,
0.3549095392,
0.6806186438,
0.2108967304,
-0.7712031603,
-0.26547122,
0.16032888,
0.502225399,
-0.1010500565,
-0.1894809902,
0.4096677899,
-0.1631759405,
-0.2981657684,
0.4118421674,
0.17146492,
-0.1171173602,
-0.1502014101,
0.1018033698,
-0.4653472304,
-0.0738236904,
0.5275321007,
0.1215099767,
-0.2557474971,
-0.6469057798,
-0.090071179,
0.4519506097,
-0.016627131,
0.4841590822,
-0.8374690413,
0.6555727124,
0.3885035515,
0.5900059938,
0.3359661996,
0.1549627334,
0.5721417069,
-0.8308990002,
0.0723861828,
0.0596554875,
0.3342186511,
0.5048488379,
-0.5035176277,
0.0776994899,
0.3047460616,
-0.7012252808,
-0.8477165699,
0.2804281116,
-0.0955858827,
-0.062912114,
0.9771581888,
-0.236779213,
-0.1167356148,
0.0123347137,
-0.1805730909,
0.2147555053,
-0.1420504153,
0.7830376029,
0.9141768217,
-0.1262965053,
0.0018424441,
-0.2619285583,
0.4050021768,
0.3714346886,
-0.43444556,
0.2516045272,
0.7107806802,
0.5505219698,
0.0591559336,
0.4196484983,
-0.0853682905,
0.3713410199,
0.0545253754,
-0.1009037644,
-0.2741045654,
-0.2805628181,
-0.4102931023,
0.1694185138,
0.5858545899,
-0.0268938169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17602v1
|
Assertion Detection Large Language Model In-context Learning LoRA Fine-tuning
| 2024-01-31T05:11:00 | 2024-01-31T05:11:00 |
Yuelyu Ji, Zeshui Yu, Yanshan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we aim to address the task of assertion detection when
extracting medical concepts from clinical notes, a key process in clinical
natural language processing (NLP). Assertion detection in clinical NLP usually
involves identifying assertion types for medical concepts in the clinical text,
namely certainty (whether the medical concept is positive, negated, possible,
or hypothetical), temporality (whether the medical concept is for present or
the past history), and experiencer (whether the medical concept is described
for the patient or a family member). These assertion types are essential for
healthcare professionals to quickly and clearly understand the context of
medical conditions from unstructured clinical texts, directly influencing the
quality and outcomes of patient care. Although widely used, traditional
methods, particularly rule-based NLP systems and machine learning or deep
learning models, demand intensive manual efforts to create patterns and tend to
overlook less common assertion types, leading to an incomplete understanding of
the context. To address this challenge, our research introduces a novel
methodology that utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) pre-trained on a vast
array of medical data for assertion detection. We enhanced the current method
with advanced reasoning techniques, including Tree of Thought (ToT), Chain of
Thought (CoT), and Self-Consistency (SC), and refine it further with Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) fine-tuning. We first evaluated the model on the i2b2 2010
assertion dataset. Our method achieved a micro-averaged F-1 of 0.89, with 0.11
improvements over the previous works. To further assess the generalizability of
our approach, we extended our evaluation to a local dataset that focused on
sleep concept extraction. Our approach achieved an F-1 of 0.74, which is 0.31
higher than the previous method.
|
[
-0.0111116944,
-1.105551362,
0.9264932275,
0.2053308934,
-0.253692925,
-0.1064209566,
-0.3455980718,
-0.7186562419,
0.2149894089,
0.4465500414,
-0.3960557878,
-0.691973865,
-0.7005761266,
0.095108144,
-0.2430686206,
0.8525096774,
-0.2613762915,
-0.0482995808,
-0.1580259204,
-0.0449961014,
-0.6123054624,
-0.2838867009,
-0.707361877,
-0.3340777457,
0.2165659666,
0.4317685366,
0.2548027337,
0.4199821055,
0.6448784471,
0.2523576915,
-0.146002844,
0.3766879141,
-0.0866597518,
0.1909673661,
-0.1213690862,
-0.4609598219,
-0.652890861,
-0.2555932105,
0.6042189002,
0.5556111932,
-0.1855347902,
0.3467697203,
-0.0333022848,
0.5388837457,
-0.7338425517,
0.1144237742,
-0.7317139506,
0.213569507,
-0.1729626209,
-0.2410167456,
-0.4888783395,
-0.3576170504,
0.2395009547,
-0.2552596331,
0.1183357611,
-0.1047622338,
1.1431219578,
0.5834269524,
-0.4006049335,
-0.470377177,
-0.5515204072,
0.6080114841,
-1.0999025106,
0.1865158677,
0.5573959947,
0.2640498579,
-0.1371161491,
-0.6765759587,
-0.7176172137,
-0.3763707578,
-0.180816412,
0.0706852973,
-0.2282956839,
0.0664917231,
0.2603281438,
0.4165701568,
-0.5093134046,
0.553578794,
-0.0450045355,
-0.2110746354,
0.458098799,
0.0830989853,
0.325524658,
-0.3826152384,
-0.3522172868,
0.3349048197,
-0.7035073638,
0.048255574,
-0.4088684022,
0.1351305693,
-0.3182936311,
0.55300951,
-0.4071914256,
0.6298334599,
0.1828536838,
-0.5429779887,
0.3076276779,
-0.2806998789,
-0.4217115939,
0.3312540948,
0.8066251874,
0.2028543949,
-0.2315694541,
-0.0758418664,
-0.1998676509,
0.3290344179,
0.0123653868,
-0.7399506569,
0.1598248482,
0.5916636586,
-0.5992398262,
-0.4102924764,
-0.2218331546,
-0.6226365566,
-0.5722920299,
-0.3681553602,
0.5342295766,
-0.5758650303,
-0.1689081788,
0.3667457402,
0.2190382928,
0.4639456272,
0.4299192429,
-0.6390510201,
0.1499470621,
0.6548862457,
0.7163915038,
-0.4020795822,
0.0954260603,
-0.6210010052,
0.078173846,
-0.3979353011,
0.8390200734,
-0.3050281703,
-0.1681485623,
-0.0590642095,
0.1726835966,
-0.2544639409,
-0.6673510671,
0.9635195732,
-0.1579124779,
0.1860750318,
-0.031092504,
-0.8630724549,
0.0084724687,
0.4891207516,
-0.3112149239,
0.7215092778,
0.1961336583,
-0.5650655627,
0.3886570036,
-0.828758657,
-0.445481807,
0.0386428647,
-0.4778987467,
-0.7115676403,
0.3023057282,
0.3743122518,
0.6133822799,
-0.4213909209,
0.4177455902,
-0.1963359714,
-0.0725249723,
0.4698539674,
-0.2702473104,
0.7185537219,
0.3403056562,
-0.505720377,
0.0963481739,
-0.821993649,
0.2059550732,
0.258389771,
-0.1514405459,
-0.3290601671,
0.0777408183,
-0.4006203711,
0.2327959538,
0.2373048216,
-0.7104747295,
0.3357926309,
-0.4279442728,
0.3595370352,
0.4783302248,
0.3228347003,
-0.1942561418,
-0.322224915,
0.4973960221,
0.0504027605,
0.0815843567,
-0.2121775597,
-0.3019764125,
-0.8231048584,
-0.4550719261,
0.3763299882,
0.5410454273,
-0.5054442286,
0.8640792966,
-0.3849952519,
-0.172531724,
-0.6329417825,
0.0189940613,
0.5588529706,
0.932680428,
0.483184725,
-0.0479978137,
-0.5597893596,
-0.8219928741,
-0.1514084488,
-0.0462304838,
0.1261324137,
0.0304856449,
0.6013820767,
-0.5908042789,
0.840167284,
-0.7131726742,
-0.5311754942,
-0.1724122316,
0.1384025961,
0.2724244297,
0.524836719,
0.4517350197,
-0.5588939786,
-0.3528056145,
0.1410562098,
-1.0111755133,
-0.0772698745,
-0.1926021576,
0.216631636,
0.351645261,
0.7211222649,
-0.4398156106,
0.5744462609,
0.3987625539,
-0.5936045051,
0.5588465333,
-0.2447844595,
-0.0498129539,
-1.1951105595,
-0.0786644742,
-0.0477553308,
-0.1808347255,
-0.417140156,
0.2202725261,
0.0893525556,
0.2304014117,
-0.145715639,
0.4645164311,
-0.2367490977,
0.2695121467,
-0.241373539,
0.0174867865,
0.0452316217,
0.2112489939,
0.0579320192,
0.4201870859,
0.539031148,
-0.605384171,
-0.2309886217,
0.3647284508,
-0.650611937,
0.618760705,
-0.6796271801,
0.1392291039,
0.0530043952,
0.2448434085,
-1.0127116442,
-0.274004668,
-0.0242568497,
-0.5000124574,
0.2717529237,
-0.1559723169,
-0.4367115498,
-0.3523017168,
0.118480511,
0.1124668121,
0.3788374364,
-0.5277888775,
0.5569661856,
0.2857771516,
-0.2184886932,
-0.5825420618,
-0.6315193176,
-0.0149279656,
-0.2235063314,
-0.3907103539,
0.4175588191,
0.0570884235,
-0.3828822076,
-0.2362965196,
-0.3095609844,
-0.218579635,
0.2519380748,
0.235168919,
0.5245961547,
-0.5579544902,
0.2901480198,
0.3996390402,
-0.0671396628,
0.1517740935,
-0.1608252078,
0.4862358868,
-0.2847234011,
-0.5162878633,
-0.8351755142,
0.1778204888,
0.527415514,
-0.2743187249,
0.6706365943,
0.7624959946,
-0.6587818265,
-0.1978547573,
-0.7199730873,
-0.0530284829,
-0.4232098162,
0.3415334523,
-0.2916774452,
-0.8669586182,
0.4858311415,
-0.2411196977,
-0.0465922467,
0.6124672294,
0.5806846023,
-0.2758388519,
0.8982940316,
0.4694373608,
-0.0197643097,
0.2164299041,
-0.2902406454,
0.2477856725,
-0.9685886502,
0.0418875627,
-0.5995307565,
-0.1991768032,
-0.4484505653,
-0.4755247533,
0.4452365339,
0.1904087067,
-0.1686596423,
-0.1367536932,
-0.5410670638,
0.4109140337,
-0.0754901767,
0.4156053066,
0.4634330273,
-0.138315931,
-0.135451287,
0.0442419462,
-0.255972147,
-0.4005190134,
1.1127638817,
0.4468763769,
0.3000814915,
0.2871962488,
0.8636248708,
0.4238829911,
0.5354520082,
-1.0228601694,
0.4848259985,
-0.2366085649,
-0.3527194262,
-0.2212360054,
-0.364490062,
-1.0707784891,
0.1927732676,
-0.3926620185,
-1.0644465685,
0.1303301603,
0.0852661505,
-0.8224668503,
0.1545723528,
-0.6537594199,
0.7970959544,
-0.3130049706,
-0.0634777918,
-0.2225214988,
-0.5833948255,
0.4690761268,
-0.2201490849,
0.0424865298,
-0.1697148234,
0.1232075691,
0.6390892863,
-0.3369494677,
0.8922348022,
-0.176924333,
-0.4506604373,
0.3477832377,
0.0223188419,
0.6165233254,
0.096515812,
-0.0452036373,
0.1046033725,
0.1376608461,
-0.3358955085,
-0.4828137159,
0.4446163476,
-0.5548484921,
-0.4905385971,
-0.3399435282,
-0.3557963371,
-0.5001708865,
0.29670012,
0.3558910787,
0.4180543125,
-0.3688412607,
0.3195840418,
0.8603451848,
-0.4516358376,
0.2467479706,
0.7512839437,
-0.3491532803,
-0.1559244543,
0.7345232964,
-0.1286311895,
0.3454704285,
0.5720009804,
0.6763615012,
-0.2736845315,
-0.957741797,
0.0134630213,
0.2873217762,
-0.5566679835,
-0.2193578035,
-0.6452091336,
-0.1456512213,
-0.5072955489,
-0.0609279573,
-0.2929930389,
-0.4208580554,
-0.0360063426,
-0.1679885834,
0.2165507525,
0.4087623656,
0.2657862306,
0.4163260758,
-0.7183339,
0.642486155,
0.0732405782,
0.129038319,
-0.2313582301,
-0.702567637,
-0.0133228749,
-0.0643112734,
-0.3114672005,
-0.5501389503,
0.392742306,
0.0882270709,
0.4374468327,
0.8206355572,
0.0816430375,
0.6840667129,
-0.2457815409,
0.5719561577,
0.2963499725,
-0.9548213482,
0.8040629029,
-0.3510195315,
0.0479609221,
0.5861568451,
0.1782812625,
-0.4062531888,
-0.1499644369,
-0.7549487948,
-0.6137055755,
0.222379446,
-0.1068355814,
-0.3955794871,
-0.0385526009,
0.6031856537,
0.1126940846,
0.0464623533,
-0.6618468165,
-0.0873464718,
0.2489951402,
-0.4584448636,
-0.1503421515,
-0.1791269332,
-0.3379566371,
-0.5058748126,
0.3473624289,
-0.5229119658,
0.37769714,
0.5348770618,
-0.2468224168,
-0.0697897002,
0.557308495,
0.793248117,
0.8184812069,
-0.3450322151,
0.0440958627,
0.2181271464,
-0.4452316463,
0.047937613,
0.1783432811,
-0.3229186237,
0.080550313,
0.44715783,
0.8012841344,
0.0427800715,
-0.7380358577,
0.5965487957,
0.0486686826,
-0.0878715441,
-0.5553444624,
0.0564463139,
-0.0509268455,
0.1491061449,
0.0787579417,
0.1019490063,
0.0681756437,
-0.5387088656,
0.232168749,
0.5662271976,
-0.5456998944,
-0.2703260481,
0.4278629124,
-0.2094052285,
-0.1972433776,
0.3505772352,
-0.1820343286,
-0.3555384874,
0.7303940654,
0.8354479671,
0.9666201472,
-0.20878613,
0.2115042061,
0.3879716396,
0.1230887771,
-0.0955288708,
0.384734273,
0.2057637721,
-0.9105224013,
-0.5930792689,
-0.54773736,
-0.2938842773,
0.4651209414,
-0.8203147054,
0.1585368514,
-0.4455735683,
-0.1818277091,
0.2096177787,
0.080881834,
-0.5293691754,
0.2634562552,
0.2491579801,
0.7496041656,
-0.6919490695,
1.0347570181,
0.4319877625,
-0.3129620552,
-0.7826806903,
0.2577849329,
0.1705896705,
-0.9147347808,
0.548886776,
0.1997243315,
-0.164888829,
-0.2431221753,
-0.6659545898,
-0.6425366998,
1.0434651375,
0.2614408135,
-0.4961973727,
-0.1054621041,
-0.0741657987,
0.6924214363,
-0.6197690964,
-0.0798590034,
0.7153442502,
0.3647555411,
-0.0987934694,
-0.9981639385,
0.3061157167,
0.1199670956,
-0.4827966392,
0.1916287392,
-0.4495519102,
0.6617108583,
-0.5434367657,
-0.0359427668,
0.2024219036,
0.5893669724,
0.3849965334,
0.5244706273,
0.542331934,
0.5945269465,
1.2779655457,
-0.0209705979,
1.1695057154,
-0.1053741574,
0.2832172513,
1.4776986837,
-0.3765352964,
1.0022541285,
0.4375237525,
-0.0571388006,
0.7354598045,
0.4352427721,
0.2108386755,
0.2420437783,
0.0244099554,
-0.2089457065,
-0.2610530853,
-0.211828351,
-0.4657486379,
0.7319090962,
0.9986882806,
-0.5652475357,
-0.0001425184,
-0.1069465578,
0.1966625452,
-0.139307335,
-0.2895901501,
0.9426286221,
0.1050877944,
-0.9254765511,
0.9765849113,
-0.2215817422,
0.4570757449,
-0.7422761321,
-0.0228653997,
-0.0143963089,
0.5227156878,
-0.2478642017,
-0.4164803326,
0.0593799353,
-0.0781634524,
-0.029906638,
0.0281242821,
0.7507665753,
-0.2680971324,
-0.4519883692,
0.1053905189,
0.6565990448,
-0.0033501356,
-0.0001306559,
-0.6944763064,
-0.1679508239,
0.1659928411,
0.0280334055,
0.3693278134,
0.5786334276,
-0.1013537943,
0.6651115417,
0.6049497724,
0.2993121147,
-0.2796981633,
0.0940860137,
0.5389043689,
-0.6380426884,
-0.5706299543,
-0.9107571244,
0.154746905,
-0.2005577087,
-0.3756316602,
0.5954196453,
0.3425062597,
0.3307834864,
0.1197388396,
0.7460668087,
0.062136475,
0.8131289482,
-0.7997466922,
0.604917109,
-0.5369625092,
0.2602816522,
-0.478695482,
-0.2620814741,
-0.3712240756,
0.7015487552,
-0.3849551678,
-0.4373092949,
1.0174838305,
0.4289276898,
0.0632013455,
0.0561217479,
0.1050692499,
0.6121990681,
0.4271161556,
0.6005730033,
0.7971571088,
-0.3152420223,
0.0048281788,
-0.0339887254,
-0.2650895119,
-0.343432188,
-0.9455085397,
-0.7319056988,
-0.3845630586,
-0.6561834216,
-0.7618883252,
-0.258335948,
1.1208418608,
0.553819418,
-1.024408102,
0.0879320502,
-0.0018319389,
0.1848207265,
-0.6223202348,
-0.2030830979,
0.8142047524,
-0.4801630974,
-0.2291953117,
0.55163306,
0.2742999494,
0.0544314086,
0.0608150363,
0.0274244752,
-0.2583197355,
0.0637167767,
0.746283114,
0.3913202584,
-0.7883966565,
-0.2791370451,
-0.0948574319,
-0.0706216991,
0.3388703763,
0.8232554793,
-0.7313138843,
0.374895215,
0.0770631358,
0.853064537,
0.2793083787,
-0.0102067208,
0.2374080867,
-0.5451675653,
0.0846076608,
0.3671161234,
0.7012148499,
0.1042451486,
-0.4462101758,
0.6157009006,
0.1858848333,
-0.4854141176,
-1.0495095253,
0.2787283063,
-1.1983752251,
-0.3951088488,
1.0425678492,
-0.1465513557,
-0.1621192247,
-0.2392153889,
-0.2011895925,
0.0620044172,
-0.1263317317,
1.0224043131,
0.4091941416,
-0.3836836815,
0.1497718543,
-0.7156385779,
0.6389590502,
0.4573907852,
-0.9775329232,
0.0406885408,
0.2911934555,
0.3558549881,
0.3975656927,
0.7350854874,
-0.2371385545,
0.2069028467,
-0.4270821512,
-0.1205448434,
0.2713794708,
-0.003342815,
-0.3774836063,
0.141628325,
-0.0345063098,
-0.2767795026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17600v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17600v1
|
Good at captioning, bad at counting: Benchmarking GPT-4V on Earth observation data
| 2024-01-31T04:57:12 | 2024-01-31T04:57:12 |
Chenhui Zhang, Sherrie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance
on complex tasks involving visual input with natural language instructions.
However, it remains unclear to what extent capabilities on natural images
transfer to Earth observation (EO) data, which are predominantly satellite and
aerial images less common in VLM training data. In this work, we propose a
comprehensive benchmark to gauge the progress of VLMs toward being useful tools
for EO data by assessing their abilities on scene understanding, localization
and counting, and change detection tasks. Motivated by real-world applications,
our benchmark includes scenarios like urban monitoring, disaster relief, land
use, and conservation. We discover that, although state-of-the-art VLMs like
GPT-4V possess extensive world knowledge that leads to strong performance on
open-ended tasks like location understanding and image captioning, their poor
spatial reasoning limits usefulness on object localization and counting tasks.
Our benchmark will be made publicly available at https://vleo.danielz.ch/ and
on Hugging Face at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mit-ei/vleo-benchmark-datasets-65b789b0466555489cce0d70
for easy model evaluation.
|
[
-0.4854560792,
-0.2394465804,
0.7201427221,
0.002945269,
-0.5935199261,
-0.1928684711,
0.0147581277,
-0.747948885,
-0.5972519517,
0.447444737,
-0.2631129622,
-0.5792324543,
-0.6068496704,
0.3449872136,
-0.3334155977,
0.7605128288,
-0.2311288863,
-0.107863307,
-0.5495688319,
-0.4130915403,
-0.3795673549,
-0.400555402,
-0.1739134341,
-0.0635683089,
0.3387107849,
0.195095256,
0.4757693708,
0.6462000608,
0.5806441903,
0.2994799912,
0.0842747167,
0.3667958081,
-0.4497805536,
-0.3039192855,
0.0476677604,
-0.3905637562,
-0.1091444418,
0.1780696809,
0.8149904609,
0.2582456172,
-0.1857904196,
0.1801348478,
-0.2595853209,
0.5878551602,
-0.4574555457,
0.5642470717,
-0.7294850349,
0.1528117061,
-0.2041646242,
0.1896684319,
-0.0844982415,
-0.2220871896,
0.3582896292,
-0.871527493,
0.4407381713,
0.2694462836,
1.0971393585,
0.4883062541,
-0.2582177818,
0.2002357394,
-0.3788541555,
1.0485757589,
-0.6916179061,
0.4913471639,
0.5007981658,
0.5782951117,
0.1221925914,
-0.654486537,
-0.611154139,
-0.2693931758,
0.0830790326,
0.3429328799,
-0.2805523276,
-0.3874791861,
0.3835514188,
0.3195671737,
-0.5432312489,
-0.0063040867,
-0.4958336651,
-0.2445107102,
0.4512995481,
-0.010627389,
0.0779286474,
-0.1896226704,
-0.475441426,
-0.0619923063,
-0.7733165026,
0.0237204358,
0.3485693634,
0.1089506671,
-0.5636523366,
0.4019638002,
-0.4094500542,
1.1827492714,
-0.5576734543,
0.2087545097,
0.4948352277,
-0.555462718,
-0.4029338062,
-0.4080556333,
0.3670322299,
0.8035334945,
0.3942601979,
-0.245565936,
-0.0792205408,
0.2017724216,
0.3153637052,
-0.8643432856,
-0.3355586529,
-0.1103813723,
-0.1802615672,
-0.1372654289,
0.3301480711,
-0.7065336108,
-0.2927000523,
-0.6499570608,
0.2117665261,
-0.2895697653,
0.0312154256,
0.1190939695,
-0.2037719488,
0.5975052118,
0.6506428123,
-0.4138906598,
0.4039185941,
0.8329588175,
0.9957820773,
-0.0994669572,
-0.5057829022,
-0.8787975907,
-0.1776988208,
-0.3148953617,
0.8644036055,
-0.3363309801,
-0.0862366557,
-0.0924848914,
0.3390060365,
-0.0470356382,
-0.6972916126,
0.6681264043,
-0.2624555826,
-0.0371924788,
-0.4841816127,
-0.2555064857,
-0.321569562,
0.480117321,
-0.8788511157,
1.1270143986,
0.0869831964,
-0.4833679199,
0.7198722363,
-0.2722212374,
-0.3607329428,
0.1707738787,
-0.2529531419,
-0.6604556441,
0.2639819384,
0.4766963124,
0.3103319407,
-0.486038059,
0.1046018675,
-0.1805333942,
-0.2956223786,
0.092095226,
-0.2703070343,
0.2029118687,
0.3198236525,
-0.2915875912,
-0.0672956854,
-0.7342729568,
-0.1088166907,
0.1845149398,
-0.1117079929,
-0.2438529134,
0.2451908141,
0.066364564,
0.1294114441,
-0.0155041851,
-0.5541870594,
0.1763625592,
-0.0345112495,
0.5255596638,
0.5729600191,
-0.2425265014,
0.0965441167,
-0.3639068007,
0.1993597299,
0.0888550356,
0.2455539703,
-0.2948325872,
-0.9194617271,
-0.3035514951,
-0.2632296979,
-0.1549661309,
0.3368067145,
-1.0611531734,
0.0490544885,
-0.6636536717,
-0.5014590025,
-0.273403585,
0.1082124263,
0.3599651456,
0.5938370228,
0.5109421015,
-0.4238998294,
-0.3970234692,
-0.7573039532,
-0.4385272264,
-0.0733670667,
-0.2305672169,
0.4585312903,
0.61191082,
0.0938632861,
0.7283529639,
-0.3371213377,
-0.1341282725,
0.1382749677,
0.2314517051,
0.0706321895,
0.1011566073,
0.8199101686,
-1.1012114286,
-0.4615759552,
0.3318473101,
-0.9064768553,
-0.0933373943,
0.2626006007,
0.2290597707,
0.3059979379,
0.2515065372,
-0.5381540656,
0.5600559711,
0.5836974382,
-0.2529523969,
0.3476416171,
-0.2915427983,
0.4535810947,
-0.4039198756,
0.0063417926,
0.0896586031,
-0.4066360295,
-0.6229515672,
0.0766866207,
0.0980383083,
-0.1130360886,
-0.6154286265,
0.3779583871,
-0.7977247834,
-0.5657660365,
0.0692853704,
0.0743228197,
-0.1373413801,
0.253092438,
0.1380076408,
0.6092162728,
0.7058182955,
-0.3942764699,
0.4047339261,
0.2601274848,
-0.6018886566,
0.8484390378,
-0.5476748347,
0.4330586493,
-0.1348194629,
0.1568168104,
-0.7713055015,
-0.177073583,
0.1016856208,
-0.2560169995,
-0.0274232235,
-0.5608745217,
-0.5576233864,
-0.5734397173,
-0.3904124796,
0.2650727034,
0.5744517446,
-0.6527758241,
0.4863748848,
0.0300757941,
-0.0927996188,
-0.1892164499,
-0.6754184961,
0.371724695,
-0.2187611163,
-0.4176182151,
0.3794094324,
0.0530210026,
-0.1257629991,
0.1320014447,
-0.2997474372,
-0.0476283133,
-0.1161500067,
0.3198176026,
0.2285716236,
-0.0206639562,
-0.1837307662,
-0.5587561131,
-0.0912628174,
0.0316807814,
-0.429344207,
0.2334345728,
-0.491851449,
-0.3090749979,
-0.2101044059,
-0.0430542603,
0.9455646276,
-0.3698480427,
0.55411309,
0.540094316,
-0.5585392714,
-0.033968173,
-0.5012739897,
0.1492655575,
-0.3407844603,
0.3464305401,
-0.4319423139,
-0.4817287326,
0.403721869,
0.0886236355,
0.1214539185,
0.2871609628,
0.1836890131,
0.0873262584,
0.5500274301,
0.2140209973,
-0.4323599935,
0.4574524164,
-0.2394210994,
-0.011535285,
-0.7284348011,
-0.0326387547,
-0.4005204439,
-0.0827407017,
-0.5336393714,
-1.0145745277,
0.148180142,
-0.2207231075,
-0.2842835486,
0.2841178775,
-0.4220752418,
0.4029753506,
0.351826638,
0.0868542045,
0.3930765092,
0.1614085138,
0.4260882735,
-0.1759755015,
-0.4532023966,
-0.4169270396,
1.0875302553,
0.074227877,
0.5737634897,
0.1391694546,
0.4590034485,
0.4763792753,
0.5377420783,
-0.4452422857,
0.4840666652,
-0.2404339164,
-0.0841292366,
-0.3608990014,
-0.4827949405,
-0.7575726509,
0.4617005885,
0.1003744379,
-0.5519080758,
-0.0017804563,
0.2234054506,
0.0421722457,
0.3476940691,
-0.6480858326,
0.9986479878,
-0.3248907924,
-0.4193345308,
-0.0267680287,
-0.6813980341,
-0.0653121546,
0.1157016829,
0.3801425993,
-0.2220752388,
-0.0962838829,
0.2927697301,
-0.3259519637,
0.7126563191,
-0.5068801641,
0.0371538065,
0.5652790666,
-0.3452191949,
0.6833031774,
-0.1671995968,
0.0111834211,
0.6004869938,
-0.1196520329,
-0.4765329659,
-0.290900588,
0.6760548353,
-0.8827270269,
-0.1542347372,
-0.4967342913,
-0.2426832467,
-0.0712639987,
0.068060115,
0.263551861,
0.5409973264,
-0.3194903135,
0.2202152163,
0.2536929548,
-0.1134129688,
0.2492465973,
0.6878511906,
-0.2532588243,
-0.3180734813,
1.13098526,
0.3343107998,
0.3332353234,
0.2717782259,
0.2195911407,
-0.3812448084,
-0.8388268948,
-0.7464122176,
0.1201512739,
-0.6569114923,
-0.2062353194,
-0.374846518,
0.0734130442,
-0.0376755707,
-0.0102753658,
-0.2735569775,
0.2272776216,
0.0392637812,
-0.3072520792,
0.3722161353,
0.7230305076,
0.237463519,
-0.1736011803,
-0.7587734461,
0.6359427571,
0.4132552445,
0.3840670884,
-0.3589921594,
-0.6220992804,
-0.2176352441,
-0.1930764914,
-0.1125935838,
-0.487131238,
0.5034109354,
0.2256658524,
0.5895959735,
0.0374632515,
-0.1168739498,
0.6523500681,
-0.5930745006,
0.8631884456,
0.008474784,
-0.84243083,
0.4544477463,
-0.3838969469,
0.5278839469,
0.4351699054,
-0.0663239062,
-0.2921217978,
-0.2889983952,
-0.4341106117,
-0.6346777678,
0.489210844,
0.278436482,
-0.1055697054,
0.1358993948,
0.1015596837,
0.09801846,
0.5067300797,
-0.5331061482,
0.1320064366,
-0.5701560378,
-0.0334472507,
-0.1903286874,
0.1132865846,
-0.2045896351,
-0.2634268999,
0.1995697767,
-0.4196015298,
0.1156553552,
0.5545680523,
-0.3553057909,
-0.0162283201,
0.1065079495,
0.6596212983,
0.5929905176,
-0.1730110496,
0.207079336,
0.2499510795,
-0.636559546,
-0.2272201478,
0.5711317062,
-0.1880885959,
-0.0831168294,
0.5126457214,
0.8746176362,
0.279293865,
-0.5230590105,
0.5365583301,
-0.0209574979,
-0.3146604896,
-0.2375482768,
-0.2466758937,
-0.0005520742,
-0.0822549388,
0.4440870881,
0.0759961233,
0.1807628572,
-0.5273066163,
0.04603412,
0.0814457014,
-0.2489072382,
-0.7117359638,
0.7546438575,
0.3261798024,
-0.0779833496,
0.6270928383,
-0.2723116875,
-0.5989299417,
1.042606473,
0.2053478509,
0.6747407317,
0.0091883577,
0.0199817866,
0.5354295969,
0.585039854,
-0.1583979726,
0.3985796571,
-0.1105160564,
-0.7822731733,
-0.3928491473,
-0.2278883904,
-0.5476598144,
0.0529094376,
-0.7583416104,
0.0645517558,
-0.2924296856,
0.1710002869,
-0.0403738543,
-0.2696357071,
-1.3746484518,
0.2619588971,
0.3751220703,
0.6276305318,
-1.0663555861,
0.5285272002,
1.0108548403,
-0.1401952952,
-0.3700560331,
-0.1827696562,
0.2773732841,
-0.7451502681,
0.4106117487,
0.7582141161,
-0.1866745502,
-0.0180567112,
-0.8184726834,
-0.6366344094,
1.2147032022,
0.0536279343,
-0.972148478,
0.5828234553,
0.018299425,
0.6495335102,
-0.1253246069,
0.1080765203,
0.5339414477,
0.7610523105,
-0.1010139063,
-0.9549185038,
-0.0027316662,
-0.1463471055,
0.0755621642,
0.2204151452,
-0.787258327,
0.722907722,
-0.379686594,
-0.2799340487,
0.2516973317,
0.4193426073,
0.0172291026,
0.6877888441,
0.8103452921,
0.857047081,
0.5775566101,
-0.4680472612,
1.4601211548,
-0.0014167752,
0.40796718,
1.0759469271,
-0.7028239369,
0.7631936669,
0.4673527479,
-0.5699578524,
0.1561515778,
0.3239786327,
-0.3996470869,
0.8105492592,
0.3136079013,
-0.1845956594,
-0.145712629,
0.0578673184,
-0.1825384349,
0.3535374999,
0.0054140431,
0.1294766366,
-0.1638626456,
0.0626100004,
-0.3254742622,
0.0942489654,
-0.1445436925,
0.5905531049,
-0.0201289579,
-0.8419189453,
0.3671817183,
-0.437041223,
0.3757122457,
-0.4905982912,
-0.5005332828,
-0.1812979728,
-0.0155221717,
-0.1666496247,
-0.8201205134,
0.1810257882,
0.2527545989,
-0.1566102058,
-0.1098535508,
0.3804713488,
-0.1508071423,
-0.4434498847,
0.2805501223,
0.4362710118,
0.4292865992,
-0.3406614661,
-0.3139424622,
0.1965887845,
0.0889315084,
-0.1921498477,
0.1526640207,
0.3846617639,
-0.3418584466,
0.5968952775,
0.8250130415,
0.0516398288,
0.1972304881,
0.4608890414,
0.7495815754,
-0.808222115,
-0.3639476001,
-0.6850906014,
0.52140975,
-0.3891218901,
-0.4032283425,
0.6619330049,
0.712046206,
0.8759406805,
-0.2897726297,
0.9328143597,
-0.16447559,
0.2998962402,
-0.5961229801,
0.1832769662,
-0.4505782127,
0.0587369725,
-0.0997263268,
-0.955781281,
-0.27345559,
0.4911570847,
-0.4397985935,
-0.1355378926,
0.4522522092,
0.4288956225,
0.036644768,
-0.1285388172,
0.5512649417,
0.2144846618,
0.5441994071,
0.4645113647,
1.0183848143,
-0.4480044842,
0.5174418688,
-0.0591196083,
-0.2298114151,
0.0262982156,
-1.3039087057,
-0.6702805758,
-0.3593522012,
-0.3494563401,
0.4069294333,
0.12931934,
0.2148617655,
0.7533593774,
-0.640950799,
0.3024896085,
-0.3204912245,
0.0073591606,
-0.4699234962,
-0.1790920943,
0.2556750476,
0.3095139265,
-0.8709944487,
0.3723117411,
0.3884650767,
0.1231995672,
-0.0313663669,
-0.1101088524,
0.2021000534,
-0.3396353126,
0.6535974145,
0.4719416499,
-1.0565581322,
-0.633528769,
-0.1419583708,
0.1785066128,
0.0926582366,
0.5571790338,
-0.7429252267,
0.8669095635,
0.3251346648,
0.6198855042,
0.8793222904,
0.3523204625,
0.453448534,
-0.5680463314,
0.1349356025,
-0.0349774621,
0.5278458595,
0.8168718219,
-0.0372004397,
0.9253311157,
0.4272662997,
-0.6365938187,
-0.7287487388,
-0.0033429419,
-1.0415633917,
0.2758838236,
0.8932471871,
-0.4625878036,
0.0210312977,
-0.1715805978,
-0.2398963422,
-0.2098326832,
-0.2692002654,
0.4685533643,
0.7724967003,
0.0151905771,
-0.3810051084,
-1.0637351274,
0.1781132817,
0.2146082819,
-1.1809879541,
0.0768831894,
0.8190101981,
0.516194582,
0.0790165588,
0.399862349,
-0.1652111709,
0.3209431767,
0.0116674192,
0.1538345218,
-0.3190574646,
-0.3608576655,
-0.3050106168,
-0.2485634387,
0.0066914507,
-0.525886178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17597v1
|
SPECTRUM: Speaker-Enhanced Pre-Training for Long Dialogue Summarization
| 2024-01-31T04:50:00 | 2024-01-31T04:50:00 |
Sangwoo Cho, Kaiqiang Song, Chao Zhao, Xiaoyang Wang, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-turn dialogues are characterized by their extended length and the
presence of turn-taking conversations. Traditional language models often
overlook the distinct features of these dialogues by treating them as regular
text. In this paper, we propose a speaker-enhanced pre-training method for long
dialogue summarization, which leverages the inherent structure of multiple-turn
dialogues. To support our study, we curate a diverse dataset that includes
transcripts from real-world scenarios, movie or TV show transcripts, and
dialogues generated by a Large Language Model. We then perform a pre-training,
which encompasses the detection of speaker changes, and masked utterance
generation. Experimental results of fine-tuned models demonstrate that our
model achieves state-of-the-art performance on downstream benchmarks with long
context, surpassing baseline models and highlighting the effectiveness of our
approach. Our findings highlight the importance of curating pre-training
datasets that exhibit diversity and variations in length distribution to ensure
effective alignment with downstream datasets.
|
[
-0.7992452979,
-0.4381476343,
0.3497363031,
-0.0456476398,
-0.5464672446,
0.4119120538,
-0.4204464853,
-0.2443384528,
0.7271546125,
0.9554471374,
-0.8756616116,
-0.2031196505,
-0.5895457268,
0.0459949672,
-0.3945793509,
1.2608476877,
0.5578491092,
0.0173693094,
0.1771186888,
-0.0529639125,
-0.238926664,
-0.4607900977,
-0.1136208773,
-0.1599797308,
0.378932029,
0.3433457017,
0.7057010531,
0.1516716331,
0.0362325534,
0.3062787652,
0.0165376067,
0.4389415383,
-0.7314588428,
0.2122362703,
0.1963779777,
-0.0161972474,
-0.718301177,
-0.002690369,
0.8732810616,
0.903408885,
-0.0274374858,
0.0513705686,
0.0976969078,
0.6401762366,
-0.7445201874,
0.0721148774,
-0.3346995413,
-0.0175474435,
-0.3249569833,
-0.3004146814,
-0.5238996744,
-0.2866958082,
0.2894220352,
-0.6619708538,
0.1300984323,
-0.2727249861,
0.5607239604,
0.1220661327,
-0.5225870609,
-0.1147346199,
-1.0411865711,
0.5434968472,
-0.8277133107,
0.3275446296,
0.2757903337,
0.521204114,
-0.001023441,
-0.7795507908,
-0.6812611222,
-0.1363701969,
-0.1323136836,
0.3989210129,
0.2742401361,
0.395713985,
0.2283614278,
0.4336860478,
-0.2882581949,
0.0180966705,
-0.3071886897,
-0.1826887876,
0.5436528325,
0.1386134475,
-0.0958527625,
-0.1420732141,
0.0157113839,
-0.2989084125,
-0.5313281417,
-0.0279896688,
0.725726366,
0.4478098452,
-0.1833118051,
0.3441921473,
-0.46972844,
0.6976342201,
0.0316409506,
-0.1163963899,
0.3655976057,
-0.657882154,
0.0059710937,
0.1639602333,
0.5328694582,
0.3265225589,
0.4976164401,
0.1827010065,
0.0641042143,
-0.2456292361,
0.0707234666,
-0.9554582238,
-0.3422302008,
0.1736994684,
-0.3288919926,
-0.0278519057,
0.0702207312,
-0.9743608832,
-0.2735465467,
-0.5486844182,
0.2044916898,
-0.3530360162,
-0.490044266,
0.2081110328,
-0.0870413929,
0.2797052264,
0.1577497572,
-0.9938622713,
0.4237261713,
0.6076147556,
0.493809104,
0.0828072056,
-0.2493710667,
-0.8498414755,
0.2493891567,
-0.3315010369,
0.628236115,
-0.7693351507,
-0.5304983854,
0.1116325855,
-0.2365372181,
0.0934895128,
-0.1663827449,
0.2889608443,
-0.2791620493,
0.3594947457,
-0.0629637763,
-0.3688232303,
0.2385652214,
-0.1020141095,
-0.3298335671,
0.759906292,
0.0810935944,
-0.6624551415,
0.4031630456,
-0.7184882164,
-0.6245943308,
0.0686400011,
-0.2158391029,
-0.5921624303,
0.0516231507,
0.696066916,
0.3721598685,
0.3170681298,
0.2494387031,
-0.0755014122,
-0.3805780709,
0.2229023278,
-0.2569197118,
0.3259261847,
0.181338042,
-0.1044033095,
0.3235052228,
-0.8749767542,
-0.108492963,
-0.2284653485,
0.1444923133,
-0.1257556975,
0.0054407446,
-0.0678045526,
0.0109220063,
-0.1364707053,
-0.5392012,
0.0480136164,
-0.6439816356,
0.2503041029,
0.6984775066,
0.1274710596,
0.4406682253,
-0.2044795901,
0.509373188,
0.0284443386,
0.1591221392,
-0.9231907725,
-0.1697780192,
-0.7977592945,
-0.6475462317,
0.204111129,
0.4076115191,
-0.8291879892,
0.6492159367,
-0.724828124,
-0.4333704114,
-0.4069339633,
-0.0479463562,
0.4755118787,
0.3231011629,
0.5328401327,
-0.6118022799,
-0.6600373983,
-0.773352921,
-0.3405168056,
0.2450587749,
-0.26781106,
0.2718982995,
0.3442800045,
-0.1772515476,
1.2801107168,
-0.6672629118,
-0.1797250211,
-0.6152339578,
0.2624757886,
0.1992249489,
0.3839924932,
0.3069646358,
-0.5664669275,
-0.3027001023,
-0.3942372799,
-0.335339427,
0.0309120361,
-0.2688345909,
-0.0261977091,
-0.2127915323,
0.5941182971,
-0.467728734,
0.3734417558,
0.4047508836,
-0.0392102748,
0.5265446901,
-0.1902235746,
0.1930557638,
-1.2946686745,
-0.1818028092,
-0.3048087955,
-0.4403252006,
-0.9670810103,
-0.4311915636,
-0.1219181418,
-0.5594713688,
-0.3242343366,
0.225359261,
-0.4554559588,
-0.3972401619,
-0.2543233931,
0.1903052479,
-0.0340703726,
0.6511853337,
0.3730558753,
0.642629385,
0.2365248054,
-0.7620313168,
0.3166764975,
0.3977083564,
-0.6883196235,
0.3711902797,
-0.4826361239,
0.2839419842,
-0.2407833785,
0.8137295246,
-1.083619833,
-0.3705125153,
-0.1793504208,
-0.480302155,
0.5886237621,
-0.1828339547,
-0.1416358948,
-0.2212518454,
-0.2793881595,
0.4750444889,
0.4783829153,
-0.3910132647,
0.7784782052,
0.3610648811,
-0.669842124,
-0.6032038927,
-0.3315578699,
0.3067457676,
-0.143822208,
-0.6538291574,
0.3267562985,
-0.0630227029,
0.1576409936,
-0.7336537838,
0.1085814759,
0.0853219479,
-0.0290841423,
0.1298067868,
-0.0156855099,
-0.130140081,
0.0855630934,
0.1691019535,
-0.2952929139,
-0.1810919344,
-0.0990005136,
0.8317183256,
0.1507025212,
-0.31259951,
-0.4266081154,
0.7143964767,
0.4261402488,
-0.66881001,
0.3767824173,
0.512626946,
0.1754590124,
-0.0278591178,
-0.5869962573,
-0.5155910254,
-0.4891287982,
0.7902245522,
-0.2714626491,
-0.8717768192,
0.5035673976,
-0.2536314726,
0.1321902275,
-0.0097739547,
0.4939627647,
-0.0935541391,
0.949190557,
0.589967072,
0.0244538635,
0.8577381372,
-0.174812004,
0.4913048744,
-0.8331210613,
-0.0499908365,
-0.3720154762,
-0.0445615463,
-0.3883217573,
-0.3133909106,
0.4430021942,
-0.2925899029,
-0.2017014772,
0.1579087675,
-0.1669950932,
0.6241180897,
0.3267105222,
0.0455972105,
0.1679716259,
-0.2653538883,
0.3648604155,
-0.1033277437,
-0.3312468827,
-0.1908807904,
1.1953333616,
0.4336850345,
0.6534797549,
0.0212409124,
0.913389504,
0.1513726413,
0.1390910447,
-0.5066549778,
0.4816270769,
-0.0179369934,
-0.2765984535,
-0.6342813969,
-0.3229161501,
-0.8671002388,
0.2549704909,
-0.2006203383,
-0.3130262792,
0.1499675363,
0.0946322083,
-0.5273863673,
-0.0333176889,
-0.6351554394,
0.584798336,
-0.2719926536,
0.142024368,
-0.2858818471,
-0.9250021577,
0.3137853146,
-0.0340454429,
0.379260987,
0.0743549764,
0.3802638352,
0.7845555544,
-0.5288478136,
0.8065530062,
-0.3603146672,
0.1563070863,
0.1323240846,
-0.1943603605,
0.4369838238,
0.1669829488,
0.4569079876,
-0.1482814848,
-0.2948327065,
-0.5679304004,
-0.4462610185,
0.113056086,
-0.8197463751,
-0.4799458086,
-0.167757228,
-0.3549486101,
-0.6007279158,
0.0805106908,
0.4095078111,
0.7557836175,
-0.3878081441,
0.1867378652,
0.8727134466,
-0.332590282,
0.5375445485,
0.442661494,
-0.2798013091,
-0.4851496518,
0.7456440926,
0.0393804498,
0.6841897368,
0.2135230601,
0.0577508695,
-0.1731696576,
-0.7122486234,
-0.3156470656,
0.0688860416,
-0.62880373,
0.067533344,
-0.8209638596,
-0.2970135212,
-0.8387375474,
-0.0248950422,
-0.5939108729,
-0.4620111585,
0.2244063765,
-0.4252507687,
0.1964908242,
0.4584412277,
0.108461529,
0.7212327719,
-0.8089362979,
0.521409452,
0.7275840044,
0.2659456134,
-0.2484573573,
-0.6942902803,
-0.4916928411,
0.1207328737,
-0.1698731035,
-0.7455527186,
0.4490543902,
0.645391047,
0.5109422803,
0.3984113932,
0.0504632965,
0.6315252781,
-0.383597672,
1.0011615753,
0.4141851366,
-0.9415944219,
0.7687894702,
-0.576222837,
0.7175803781,
0.700617075,
0.1350646913,
-0.4412389696,
-0.5171614885,
-0.3147070706,
-0.8349714279,
0.6263721585,
0.3198139071,
0.4468207955,
0.061156895,
-0.0874998197,
0.1158179119,
0.2960040867,
-0.6459472179,
-0.160431996,
-0.8871906996,
-0.0388016738,
-0.6675454378,
-0.4007357061,
-0.1860577762,
-0.2203148007,
0.5851278305,
-0.252186209,
0.0354854204,
0.2038149238,
-0.4343090951,
0.3597588539,
0.5033831596,
0.9417563081,
0.7407034039,
-0.5001394749,
-0.1432205588,
0.1688214242,
-0.6319935918,
-0.0777774081,
0.1078851223,
0.3921678066,
0.1046096981,
0.5887088776,
0.9218251705,
0.2693465352,
-0.449250102,
0.5915740132,
-0.1747635156,
-0.0800103322,
-0.5488687158,
-0.2224507481,
-0.0351626948,
-0.1801510751,
0.4525496364,
-0.1491453201,
0.2283627987,
-0.6081551909,
0.1716504991,
-0.0377739519,
-0.339869231,
-0.1986048222,
0.0179061051,
0.6914384365,
-0.279833883,
0.7925240993,
0.0343159996,
-0.6260545254,
0.3479180932,
0.2580586374,
0.9079003334,
-0.5267647505,
0.0576356426,
0.1791199148,
0.1049090475,
0.335265696,
-0.0302865095,
-0.4580729902,
-0.6823923588,
-0.735209167,
-0.4976485372,
-0.4386339188,
0.0891626701,
-0.7400300503,
0.2793432772,
-0.2273243964,
-0.1405496895,
0.0415741764,
-0.2248882651,
-0.3441720605,
0.0684102625,
0.3646318913,
0.5213921666,
-1.073469162,
0.9017349482,
-0.0534662008,
-0.2024251074,
-0.4941619635,
-0.1521874219,
-0.2789570391,
-0.4352189898,
0.4827499092,
0.2951490283,
-0.3488717675,
-0.1387945265,
-0.2292291522,
-0.6311771274,
0.730730176,
0.2598139346,
-0.7243400216,
-0.0549941026,
0.384963572,
0.448038429,
-0.7150641084,
0.6152513027,
0.6701591015,
0.2070979476,
0.1847153455,
-1.0992946625,
-0.5040054321,
-0.188857004,
-0.0911629945,
0.4453069568,
-0.4586084485,
0.7517870069,
-0.0009889974,
0.0509146191,
-0.1668068767,
0.8724219203,
0.0287468508,
0.2577389181,
0.6405367255,
0.3027753532,
0.5671670437,
-0.0219710767,
0.9537083507,
-0.2991387546,
-0.0156762712,
1.5881377459,
-0.4017802179,
0.5524546504,
0.2616103292,
-0.030276062,
0.5927037001,
0.4937877953,
0.3050175309,
0.7857304811,
0.2697507441,
-0.3065021336,
-0.5502591133,
0.1392471045,
-0.6416645646,
0.5791552067,
0.5032005906,
-0.2056369185,
-0.0859332904,
0.334286958,
-0.0882996991,
0.2862951159,
-0.2722152174,
1.1308233738,
0.14659293,
-0.8001127839,
0.4061887264,
-0.5102142692,
0.7053893805,
-0.9292717576,
0.0907064304,
-0.3833727241,
0.1056389585,
-0.2076427937,
-0.4291878343,
0.171011135,
-0.1797410995,
-0.0758041069,
-0.3872463405,
0.2869852185,
-0.4632779658,
-0.3066641092,
0.1430602968,
0.2614703476,
0.1478653848,
0.0079747187,
-0.1538823992,
-0.1874230951,
0.0168007258,
-0.202382654,
0.418559432,
0.1325229555,
-0.0154685667,
0.4069158137,
0.6439245939,
-0.0554497764,
0.129861027,
0.6056153178,
0.9691229463,
-0.5120360255,
-0.9743578434,
-0.6233025193,
0.6325136423,
-0.5122647882,
-0.3191840053,
0.5223538876,
0.7820479274,
0.6587132215,
-0.0261837915,
0.6390749216,
0.5695055723,
0.8501623273,
-0.5746154189,
0.4893322289,
0.0914462209,
0.3056149483,
-0.4594893456,
-1.0792919397,
0.2168531269,
0.3503571153,
-0.3242454231,
0.2089732438,
0.4090059698,
0.7930859327,
-0.1254864782,
0.1877379417,
0.2384924591,
0.1179183647,
0.6697712541,
0.4910321832,
0.9876577258,
-0.1261923611,
0.5027076006,
0.0630992278,
-0.3610117435,
-0.2646659315,
-0.9089596272,
-1.1589756012,
-0.5998775363,
-0.2627438605,
-0.1382680088,
-0.006661518,
0.6425525546,
1.1276949644,
-0.6449389458,
-0.299482584,
0.2199143469,
-0.3080456257,
-0.0518919043,
-0.125595361,
0.1925301403,
-0.2744220495,
-0.5476722717,
0.6993150711,
0.3296901882,
0.0927530527,
-0.1315871924,
-0.1434496492,
-0.1245951355,
0.3864735365,
0.5996325612,
0.1888634264,
-0.3830922544,
-0.4337158203,
-0.351077497,
0.3000065088,
0.1289370358,
1.0732547045,
-0.8859421015,
0.7731957436,
0.3174908757,
0.3553092778,
1.1637141705,
0.0357341468,
1.0119897127,
-1.0874984264,
0.4376257062,
0.4664363265,
0.1687387824,
0.3142436445,
-0.1110729054,
0.1065415218,
-0.235359937,
-0.4075134695,
-0.9080200791,
0.5934140682,
-1.0732541084,
-0.2352140397,
0.6655595303,
-0.1960735917,
0.3056604564,
-0.2984669507,
-0.2126455158,
0.4090072811,
-0.386536628,
0.488738656,
0.6318807602,
-0.0054502883,
-0.3323143721,
-0.1117045358,
0.7896899581,
0.5224907994,
-0.9089607596,
0.2104854435,
0.3936531842,
-0.0030566333,
0.3396358788,
0.7757049799,
-0.0593898334,
0.2104438692,
-0.2601791024,
-0.1113535836,
-0.3290512264,
-0.3333808184,
-0.2700514495,
0.047794994,
-0.1887837052,
-0.0361455567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17588v1
|
Local and Global Contexts for Conversation
| 2024-01-31T04:19:22 | 2024-01-31T04:19:22 |
Zuoquan Lin, Xinyi Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The context in conversation is the dialog history crucial for multi-turn
dialogue. Learning from the relevant contexts in dialog history for grounded
conversation is a challenging problem. Local context is the most neighbor and
more sensitive to the subsequent response, and global context is relevant to a
whole conversation far beyond neighboring utterances. Currently, pretrained
transformer models for conversation challenge capturing the correlation and
connection between local and global contexts. We introduce a local and global
conversation model (LGCM) for general-purpose conversation in open domain. It
is a local-global hierarchical transformer model that excels at accurately
discerning and assimilating the relevant contexts necessary for generating
responses. It employs a local encoder to grasp the local context at the level
of individual utterances and a global encoder to understand the broader context
at the dialogue level. The seamless fusion of these locally and globally
contextualized encodings ensures a comprehensive comprehension of the
conversation. Experiments on popular datasets show that LGCM outperforms the
existing conversation models on the performance of automatic metrics with
significant margins.
|
[
-0.4266262054,
-1.128397584,
0.5434647202,
-0.1965407282,
-0.1154059842,
-0.0279004369,
-0.3019836843,
-0.6424977779,
-0.0305444021,
0.6091657281,
-0.5646054745,
-0.4303232729,
-0.2606389821,
-0.171333462,
-0.1615231335,
1.1256597042,
-0.0768548101,
0.195710808,
-0.5821321607,
-0.3392559886,
-0.7429080606,
-0.87737602,
-0.6397716403,
-0.502589643,
0.0288259275,
0.3603800237,
0.6915627718,
-0.0398435965,
0.2331719398,
0.3522655368,
-0.354481101,
0.0436042845,
-0.79459548,
0.1968942583,
-0.1570422053,
-0.4211398363,
-0.4187621772,
-0.1347355843,
0.532435596,
0.5992128253,
-0.0880029351,
-0.0388787463,
0.1103260145,
0.137712881,
-0.3391910195,
0.2103076726,
-0.8482018113,
0.170896098,
0.3916074932,
-0.2462299615,
-0.2810864449,
-0.2933964729,
0.4544215202,
-0.1802022159,
0.4828124642,
-0.2656798959,
0.6429535747,
-0.1162091345,
-0.8393817544,
-0.3357611299,
-1.1939736605,
0.5141458511,
-0.3877229095,
0.2437613457,
0.2163992226,
0.5770685077,
-0.1790060997,
-0.8046095371,
-0.400883764,
-0.0266534593,
-0.387658149,
0.1857376546,
-0.2499882877,
0.0673722029,
-0.1478594095,
0.8323561549,
-0.2552091181,
-0.178769365,
-0.3785113692,
-0.060571,
0.1068373099,
0.5264377594,
0.2023437917,
-0.1341762692,
-0.4687350094,
0.2846839428,
-0.6383481622,
0.3157388866,
-0.0496999845,
0.3854926825,
-0.3699902594,
-0.0387557074,
-0.2806786895,
0.7117259502,
0.2461071312,
-0.3547896743,
-0.2565771937,
-0.7371543646,
-0.3399271071,
-0.09473221,
0.5621250868,
0.4630372822,
0.2447665334,
-0.227760613,
0.4154342115,
-0.1344451904,
0.3456738591,
-0.920958519,
0.2051226348,
0.1315117776,
-0.3335990608,
-0.1078717932,
0.0954585075,
-0.7743416429,
-0.1553617269,
-0.5561979413,
0.1044141427,
0.1279936433,
-0.1254862845,
-0.1028280482,
0.3886112273,
0.5860619545,
0.2700355351,
-0.876116097,
0.3820881844,
0.4882810414,
0.8372380137,
-0.0879894719,
0.1051009372,
-0.3983663023,
0.1398486793,
-0.0725673065,
0.540958941,
-0.5891941786,
-0.7251520753,
0.2673627436,
0.3433436751,
-0.1180603877,
-0.4184765816,
0.6213213801,
-0.3699393272,
0.6651750207,
-0.1187358052,
-0.2291639447,
-0.0950787663,
0.3468113542,
-0.3966420889,
0.7533510923,
0.1371327341,
-0.863514781,
0.2032329291,
-0.5469273329,
-0.4934462607,
0.0237659477,
-0.3284204006,
-0.2065176964,
0.1762750149,
0.5949356556,
0.5204905272,
-0.3708308637,
0.7611221671,
0.0013413935,
-0.509716332,
0.0093443608,
-0.5106644034,
0.4069343805,
0.0659735128,
-0.2958906889,
0.4446690679,
-0.4053959846,
-0.1047977135,
0.1378608048,
-0.1617172062,
-0.0453614071,
0.0492534228,
-0.3019860387,
0.2822565138,
-0.0448987298,
-0.4327684343,
0.1603342742,
-0.3478592038,
0.8769772649,
0.3155889511,
0.2746388912,
0.8791202903,
-0.2045916468,
0.2952533364,
0.2954056263,
0.1547936052,
-0.6424978971,
-0.4721300602,
-0.8168333769,
-0.0473523214,
-0.1066358164,
0.6654236913,
-0.4586531818,
0.4306586981,
-0.6366445422,
-0.3986699581,
-0.3576079309,
-0.3154461384,
0.0435509086,
0.7144159079,
0.2000956684,
-0.1653437167,
-0.3299970031,
-0.770824194,
-0.1020520627,
0.0522655472,
-0.2875014246,
0.7044365406,
0.3505472541,
-0.3975574076,
1.517802,
-0.381996572,
-0.4522155821,
-0.3364980221,
0.0993343964,
0.2493494004,
0.281922549,
0.2981170416,
-0.8033019304,
-0.577188611,
0.2155265361,
-0.7448304892,
0.3022908568,
-0.3239633739,
-0.2458311468,
0.0273597948,
0.5707504749,
-0.74155581,
0.640053153,
0.4986401796,
-0.094683297,
0.1276174486,
-0.1127767712,
0.4733217061,
-1.3127655983,
-0.0304931663,
-0.2337418199,
-0.3040417433,
-1.0756115913,
-0.132132262,
-0.1290499419,
-0.5027622581,
-0.6811293364,
0.6013082266,
-0.3948469162,
0.1380425841,
0.0799783766,
0.285834372,
-0.1189635321,
0.719655633,
0.3396023512,
1.0049413443,
0.5385240912,
-0.5993708968,
0.2206429988,
0.5332175493,
-0.6470484734,
0.7319409847,
-0.6877430677,
0.4560834169,
-0.1838709116,
0.7215650082,
-0.9834911823,
-0.2910697758,
0.1454467475,
-0.2090699226,
0.1970426589,
-0.1614637673,
-0.0064711077,
-0.296266824,
0.1518089473,
0.4517293274,
0.362926662,
-0.710087657,
0.8990767598,
0.3400668204,
-0.3037640154,
-0.1371451765,
-0.3785839677,
0.0129647041,
-0.3916042745,
-0.9821779728,
0.422591418,
-0.1073769927,
-0.108076483,
-0.6017063856,
-0.2157554775,
-0.0737283379,
-0.1954476088,
0.4242720604,
-0.0428384803,
-0.2366947085,
-0.1908726096,
-0.3115985692,
-0.1629408449,
0.2045913488,
-0.1050299034,
0.5548541546,
-0.2951855958,
-0.4555788338,
-0.2686621249,
0.6600538492,
0.6316215992,
-0.0594949089,
0.8311030269,
0.5857747197,
-0.2567937672,
0.2121305615,
-0.4375421107,
-0.3160810471,
-0.4651615322,
0.4257513881,
-0.426063627,
-1.2970352173,
0.8132709265,
-0.2914354801,
-0.1786562204,
-0.0884689614,
0.6368798018,
0.2478722185,
1.0200208426,
0.6277439594,
-0.3886021078,
0.4096707106,
0.0651097819,
0.7818654776,
-0.7269121408,
-0.2727977335,
-0.4432750344,
-0.0957600698,
-0.3024614453,
-0.5573170185,
0.4312563241,
0.24275814,
-0.289531976,
0.0566228032,
-0.328209579,
0.7486347556,
0.4835427701,
-0.0803370699,
0.3761392832,
0.0780319422,
-0.0456391089,
-0.4113715887,
-0.5381956697,
-0.6605664492,
0.3942340612,
0.4483715594,
0.6483992934,
0.0349742994,
0.2922905385,
-0.0967141017,
0.3323462903,
-0.7404791117,
0.3883647919,
0.4889070392,
-0.5472179651,
-0.0362719297,
-0.4696035087,
-1.0428550243,
0.4825628102,
-0.0155595336,
-1.2892264128,
-0.2635318935,
-0.0371606871,
-0.2652911842,
0.5106986165,
-0.5023670197,
1.0847568512,
0.0520107597,
-0.0579206869,
0.1797402501,
-0.8190731406,
0.4142765999,
0.1913677007,
0.3666310906,
0.0896569043,
0.8091493845,
0.1748168766,
-0.0628210902,
1.0503128767,
-0.0082936995,
-0.3851746023,
0.5467289686,
0.097121194,
0.4845607877,
0.1886327714,
0.4263917208,
0.4329707921,
-0.2839213312,
0.0302398186,
-0.4270651639,
0.5897403359,
-0.806948185,
-0.7963243723,
-0.1471398622,
-0.3259658217,
-0.4007924497,
-0.1118684486,
0.4741896689,
0.537453115,
-0.8508062959,
0.3695621192,
0.5785664916,
-0.3014802337,
0.2290341854,
0.3815366924,
-0.1977696866,
-0.4302671254,
0.4933182299,
-0.3919664621,
0.5368100405,
0.5014497042,
0.0952173397,
-0.0637912452,
0.0435235575,
-0.1772661954,
-0.1444226354,
-1.162130475,
-0.2871945202,
-0.6815108657,
-0.4521903098,
-0.4249238968,
-0.3523083925,
0.0360838324,
0.1777959317,
-0.2531554699,
-0.1472593099,
0.0381334759,
0.7356859446,
0.2539422512,
0.5553013086,
-0.8808793426,
0.3180535138,
0.6176271439,
0.0917003006,
0.0193393696,
-0.5918296576,
-0.1826086044,
0.320247829,
-0.504154861,
-0.8439568281,
0.3635936379,
0.192520082,
0.6283393502,
0.3859668374,
0.0021047511,
0.737866044,
-0.7270637751,
1.1879185438,
-0.0213475917,
-1.0750656128,
0.6739819646,
-0.470290333,
0.7598643303,
0.4110229313,
0.4289612472,
-0.900805831,
-0.4013817906,
-0.449657172,
-0.9326775074,
0.7564632297,
0.0952282548,
0.5564332008,
-0.160424307,
0.2289376855,
0.0502992384,
-0.0090599861,
-0.8898792267,
-0.1285438687,
-0.1634160429,
0.2008594722,
-0.172770083,
-0.2473092973,
-0.4312836528,
-0.4483416378,
0.2565393448,
-0.4321959317,
0.7147355676,
0.2045378983,
-0.1132985055,
-0.1908649653,
0.5630672574,
0.7890627384,
0.6857289076,
-0.0834913701,
-0.015553847,
0.6338869333,
-0.2112413198,
-0.0621492416,
-0.5250397325,
0.0151458383,
-0.0116258413,
0.2240718305,
1.1592890024,
0.7285880446,
-0.0842652023,
0.5428428054,
-0.4013311565,
-0.1008905023,
-0.2222712785,
-0.1669401526,
0.2532548308,
0.0817446038,
0.351608932,
-0.0389181934,
-0.0476007946,
-0.6902577877,
0.0133852484,
0.4181147516,
-0.4979147017,
-0.2334251851,
0.6564813256,
0.4912734926,
-0.3430920839,
0.602611661,
0.2070766985,
-0.8290373087,
0.37210536,
0.8761839867,
0.7950556874,
-0.1153362617,
0.1529449373,
0.5314516425,
-0.1211582348,
0.273721993,
-0.1740889847,
-0.5398296118,
-0.7627936006,
-0.3828426301,
-0.456361562,
-0.8062007427,
0.2010345906,
-0.8785651922,
0.0076687057,
0.0290450361,
-0.1088624746,
-0.5161246061,
-0.2290498018,
-0.7967900634,
0.0541186556,
0.122944504,
0.5016614795,
-0.7463569045,
0.6150408387,
0.2632964253,
-0.0403167382,
-0.2983814478,
0.0151993595,
-0.1024527252,
-0.6263820529,
0.477396518,
0.5471320152,
-0.321526438,
-0.2931603789,
-0.5547751784,
-0.8430965543,
1.1650694609,
0.2648209929,
-0.3841763735,
-0.0364271477,
0.3829437792,
0.436720103,
-0.5907793641,
0.5542554855,
0.6201292276,
0.125234887,
0.3675148785,
-1.1265619993,
-0.1017214283,
0.0299413726,
0.152810663,
0.3147291839,
-0.7181130648,
0.761562407,
0.0601006001,
-0.5099854469,
0.1584491879,
0.8891567588,
-0.0600466058,
0.0043830727,
0.1256312281,
0.0966733322,
0.5970848203,
-0.5131450295,
0.830334425,
-0.4663487077,
0.2518301606,
1.2545896769,
-0.3712567687,
0.7707326412,
0.1597322673,
0.0755320787,
0.4813086092,
0.4413062632,
0.5371149778,
0.4560905099,
0.0667958632,
-0.6108071208,
-0.2207709253,
0.0358538739,
-0.5802852511,
0.5598173738,
0.3832940161,
0.0698426291,
-0.3085166216,
0.0194406807,
0.1811487824,
0.0121423248,
-0.2760298848,
1.1374233961,
0.0397599451,
-0.9282029867,
0.4279843867,
-0.071523793,
0.7075129151,
-0.6545850039,
0.1438447833,
-0.5167097449,
0.3876134753,
-0.0230122525,
-0.4438669384,
0.5565080047,
-0.1455492228,
-0.1988478303,
-0.3491882086,
0.8019959927,
-0.7236235142,
0.0148801515,
0.2896217108,
0.3987860084,
0.0916354358,
-0.1401932389,
-0.2626064122,
0.0694626942,
-0.1177187636,
-0.0441356599,
0.4097324908,
0.650762856,
-0.1551063508,
0.4073589444,
0.4574942589,
-0.531047523,
-0.1863720864,
0.2992257774,
0.730050087,
-0.7417001724,
-0.7385113239,
-0.5376583338,
0.7054925561,
-0.0465108193,
-0.373580277,
0.6589782238,
0.143400684,
0.7420549393,
-0.053459391,
0.5275414586,
0.2975550294,
0.201406613,
-0.4813157022,
0.608089447,
-0.0199227016,
-0.1385673136,
-0.1518801451,
-0.9823938608,
-0.1192685887,
1.016381979,
-0.3417804241,
0.1600050479,
0.5789299607,
0.5046745539,
-0.1571861804,
0.6115723252,
0.4733867049,
-0.0502595007,
0.4975060225,
0.720051825,
1.0147861242,
-0.3996270299,
0.5744046569,
0.2014817148,
-0.0921595171,
0.0370138064,
-1.0436478853,
-1.1054199934,
-0.4962660968,
-0.1451893598,
-0.1637435257,
-0.2801275253,
0.6577385068,
0.9391721487,
-0.8655323982,
-0.3164137006,
-0.1363717318,
-0.0952036306,
0.1328516603,
-0.3102947176,
-0.1171729416,
-0.403999716,
-0.7648089528,
0.6830538511,
0.1686090082,
0.1366630495,
-0.1975766122,
-0.2133092731,
0.0167872272,
0.0869122222,
0.7675096393,
0.1728480011,
-0.856241703,
-0.5451079011,
-0.1520114988,
-0.1311727017,
0.5968221426,
1.2186620235,
-0.8931135535,
0.4793814123,
0.0709636882,
0.5176617503,
0.7855556011,
0.1346599311,
0.9219110012,
-1.1411893368,
0.2933914363,
0.0440838225,
0.3365663588,
0.5701210499,
-0.3991875052,
0.4503745139,
0.0189653244,
-0.8459755182,
-0.5296325088,
0.398314625,
-0.6215423346,
-0.1002553403,
0.9558443427,
-0.1462240517,
0.1868768036,
-0.1237128377,
-0.5260006189,
0.190743044,
-0.0909084454,
0.3745930195,
0.7887538671,
0.1204085425,
-0.0558239967,
-0.5911077857,
0.4982676208,
0.2295910716,
-0.9043440223,
0.1044612378,
0.4534423053,
0.0721543431,
0.319662571,
0.8608995676,
0.0907834768,
-0.1307435036,
-0.0835607275,
-0.2797782123,
0.4308361113,
-0.5234465599,
-0.4094383419,
0.324878037,
-0.4313451052,
0.0238513872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17585v1
|
Propagation and Pitfalls: Reasoning-based Assessment of Knowledge Editing through Counterfactual Tasks
| 2024-01-31T04:12:59 | 2024-01-31T04:12:59 |
Wenyue Hua, Jiang Guo, Mingwen Dong, Henghui Zhu, Patrick Ng, Zhiguo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
Current approaches of knowledge editing struggle to effectively propagate
updates to interconnected facts. In this work, we delve into the barriers that
hinder the appropriate propagation of updated knowledge within these models for
accurate reasoning. To support our analysis, we introduce a novel
reasoning-based benchmark -- ReCoE (Reasoning-based Counterfactual Editing
dataset) -- which covers six common reasoning schemes in real world. We conduct
a thorough analysis of existing knowledge editing techniques, including input
augmentation, finetuning, and locate-and-edit. We found that all model editing
methods show notably low performance on this dataset, especially in certain
reasoning schemes. Our analysis over the chain-of-thought generation of edited
models further uncover key reasons behind the inadequacy of existing knowledge
editing methods from a reasoning standpoint, involving aspects on fact-wise
editing, fact recall ability, and coherence in generation. We will make our
benchmark publicly available.
|
[
-0.5139193535,
-1.1021988392,
0.6116841435,
-0.2764036655,
-0.0386023559,
0.085221909,
0.2008509189,
-0.6454866529,
-0.1545519382,
0.4223347902,
-0.7567789555,
-0.3076422513,
-0.5630139112,
0.1446657032,
-0.4525669813,
0.7008538842,
-0.2661147714,
-0.2537344396,
-0.5659134388,
-0.3379729986,
-0.87920928,
-0.3580266535,
-0.2665084004,
-0.3800807595,
0.2476292253,
0.5488364697,
0.8189709783,
0.3879438341,
0.3261602521,
0.2904189825,
-0.3460533023,
0.4484569728,
-0.4380879104,
-0.0021980153,
-0.8407900929,
-0.3898679316,
-0.5242168307,
0.0676659122,
0.4487217963,
0.7868115902,
-0.0413472578,
0.1798278689,
-0.2417495847,
0.6478846669,
-0.849535346,
-0.3115665615,
-0.7644674778,
0.0002139861,
-0.1190406531,
0.2298217267,
-0.4121548235,
-0.4811046422,
0.3159586787,
-0.8300830722,
0.374279201,
0.0548323356,
0.5047243237,
0.3148986101,
-0.2962294817,
-0.1891685575,
-0.494663626,
0.6288596988,
-0.5678426623,
0.5948597789,
0.0565849356,
0.2004106194,
-0.3148111105,
-0.6713405252,
-0.688765347,
0.0823854581,
0.0301509202,
0.0202588271,
-0.5954196453,
0.0441451371,
0.604203105,
0.1049450487,
-0.3371722698,
-0.1932556778,
-0.2949792743,
-0.1046074703,
0.6898375154,
-0.0218916368,
0.1111348867,
-0.0883690268,
-0.2748032808,
-0.1430462599,
-0.9455342889,
-0.2812913954,
0.2833946645,
-0.2084748149,
0.1344232857,
0.5945126414,
-0.4252162576,
0.8547225595,
0.1385358423,
0.2300356179,
0.1371120512,
-0.4370667934,
-0.4758740366,
-0.0040685087,
0.412261337,
0.6365303397,
0.2403513044,
-0.0010656469,
0.0330224596,
0.2383177131,
0.488157928,
-0.3253768086,
-0.1723747402,
0.1919036955,
-0.2333492488,
-0.4602158368,
-0.2219896466,
-0.7424911261,
-0.3532189429,
-0.0722708479,
0.6487526298,
-0.427072674,
-0.0267523117,
0.1074482948,
-0.3163511753,
-0.3883105516,
0.8273897767,
-0.2874322534,
0.1858163476,
0.6007338166,
0.5954493284,
0.0500408448,
-0.3614418805,
-0.1453545541,
-0.0635233074,
-0.5179339647,
1.0059485435,
-0.5347644687,
-0.5271926522,
-0.1710629612,
-0.1042568386,
-0.1925200224,
-0.5822914243,
0.595490396,
-0.5565527678,
0.1200676635,
-0.6014968157,
-0.8615192175,
-0.5208508372,
0.2919727266,
-0.6037160158,
0.7448909879,
0.1319042742,
-0.9569570422,
0.4060589373,
-0.6275666356,
-0.4569771886,
-0.3611552119,
0.0723306537,
-0.3527073562,
0.0040872786,
0.2378590405,
0.0927219465,
-0.2890222967,
0.4519558847,
-0.3191666603,
-0.387491107,
0.4175776839,
-0.5439221263,
0.7338802814,
0.278476119,
-0.4532319605,
-0.0923262462,
-0.8647348285,
-0.1654462367,
-0.2066289932,
0.1777750552,
-0.3421795964,
0.0200322047,
-0.5626558661,
0.2872331738,
-0.0765157491,
-0.6979601383,
0.3919190466,
-0.0655998737,
0.2247314751,
0.5783486962,
0.4992003143,
0.0971083045,
-0.7418221831,
0.3011422455,
0.1569539756,
0.43518731,
0.0491299666,
-0.5963455439,
-0.4222488999,
0.3509533405,
0.3476274014,
0.7912750244,
-0.9857106209,
-0.1039218903,
-0.0423079804,
-0.9362146258,
-0.5766884089,
0.143651247,
0.6513795257,
1.158367157,
0.6358550191,
-0.108035095,
-0.4415320158,
-0.911837697,
-0.7321585417,
-0.1675948203,
0.3539959192,
0.0189921111,
0.649959743,
-0.259331286,
0.6818304062,
-0.5416162014,
0.3609598875,
0.1013193205,
0.488615185,
-0.0753159821,
0.7217358351,
0.4026855826,
-0.6092854142,
-0.0990705863,
-0.1588715166,
-0.7993706465,
-0.3904606402,
-0.2868885994,
-0.220591709,
0.2522115409,
0.5352338552,
-0.7267910838,
0.7476277351,
0.2738418877,
-0.3249587417,
0.836961329,
-0.1453687698,
0.7125317454,
-0.4521371126,
0.1256084591,
-0.048298277,
-0.0562922284,
-0.737185955,
0.2083547115,
0.0133153955,
0.21349594,
-0.494312048,
0.3996763229,
-0.0861846879,
0.0626460463,
0.0808639154,
0.2469567806,
0.2279833406,
0.3548668027,
0.0552746579,
0.6133038402,
0.1584829241,
-0.5058293939,
0.3703115582,
0.4078630805,
-0.5604557395,
0.9778727889,
-0.58425951,
0.2044685632,
-0.0213047918,
0.0669974461,
-0.8843907118,
0.0800010636,
0.3785964549,
-0.2645739317,
-0.0256261602,
-0.0630939156,
-0.3685382903,
-0.0890700817,
-0.2145799398,
0.5221785903,
0.2582272589,
-0.5018755794,
0.236670509,
-0.0364775769,
-0.0128266728,
-0.7499515414,
-0.8861491084,
-0.0130611006,
-0.1361691207,
-0.7024289966,
0.2467720211,
-0.1856751442,
-0.6618491411,
0.2402297258,
-0.2466934323,
0.0522254333,
0.1300252527,
0.0123245846,
0.1837875247,
0.1423532069,
0.2326877266,
0.4916336238,
0.0982067734,
0.114655301,
0.0327363089,
-0.3855101466,
0.3226199746,
-0.6048736572,
-0.3863339126,
0.0998363346,
0.6112070084,
-0.0243060477,
0.4578742981,
0.0036519296,
-0.4310023189,
-0.1716507524,
-0.9464499354,
0.150037095,
-0.3565866351,
0.2821127176,
-0.547878623,
-0.4291795492,
0.4367720783,
-0.4189846516,
0.2880965471,
0.645260036,
-0.078955546,
-0.2020639479,
0.5782276392,
0.031620685,
0.6129527688,
0.1782879829,
-0.2133225203,
-0.1773635596,
-0.7939150929,
-0.1365792453,
-0.4130429924,
-0.0504100434,
-0.6572063565,
-0.6642336845,
0.1602327526,
0.3122277558,
-0.3933209777,
0.3236874938,
-0.3660583496,
0.1982600987,
0.6008104086,
0.2532668114,
0.6345410347,
-0.3279085159,
-0.0510713346,
-0.0558368787,
-0.9527837038,
-0.2974194288,
0.9573684335,
0.1701023877,
0.6052747965,
0.0553476885,
0.3203559518,
0.6880757809,
0.4326321185,
-0.143730253,
0.4119098783,
-0.1132577658,
-0.6432730556,
-0.462836951,
-0.4466635883,
-0.3178423345,
0.3034646213,
-0.4947298169,
-0.5447808504,
0.8014127612,
0.513553679,
-0.143389836,
0.6202902794,
-0.8390267491,
1.0108312368,
0.0681822076,
-0.6612077355,
-0.4125199616,
-0.441827029,
0.5112121105,
-0.1921905577,
0.506372571,
0.3071137965,
0.2567173541,
0.6878855824,
-0.6296883821,
0.5635141134,
-0.3391464651,
-0.048332762,
0.739217639,
0.4932654202,
0.8428442478,
-0.0311574917,
-0.2763445675,
0.2720806301,
0.1408511549,
-0.2554432452,
-0.8981320262,
0.409054786,
-0.4875164926,
-0.7586468458,
-0.2651399076,
-0.3916376233,
-0.5441070795,
0.1144884825,
0.4529640079,
0.6312001944,
-0.4010159671,
-0.0775946453,
0.7131263614,
-0.2538462579,
0.0252543408,
0.3596556783,
0.0735522956,
-0.5477713346,
0.6529584527,
0.5590391755,
0.6238324046,
0.2699281871,
0.1163091138,
-0.1505017579,
-0.5948482156,
-0.6020292044,
-0.0606951304,
-0.8891975284,
-0.0442184396,
-0.503661871,
0.030156035,
-0.3422337472,
-0.3641961515,
-0.4502596855,
-0.5780135393,
0.0607695803,
-0.2362238318,
0.364161104,
0.9689249992,
-0.4227296114,
0.0804993361,
-0.4853580296,
0.4453867078,
0.482270956,
0.4206734896,
0.227323696,
-0.5463502407,
-0.1220109165,
0.2638894618,
-0.2485197634,
-1.0301679373,
-0.1420014799,
-0.335506916,
0.5266224146,
-0.006391733,
0.1535830647,
0.8565983772,
-0.4155923724,
0.5628277659,
0.0143610137,
-1.1336139441,
0.6692433953,
-0.1602450907,
0.4340865314,
0.5979933143,
0.2774645984,
-0.6012735367,
-0.3359234929,
-0.889998138,
-0.2706246376,
0.4802647233,
0.1284151077,
-0.4305387735,
-0.0462008491,
0.4549720585,
0.3096901178,
0.3523375392,
-0.27997154,
-0.1536884457,
-0.4742326438,
0.2515708208,
0.1781445891,
-0.4629358351,
-0.0653523356,
-0.2905452549,
0.8814592361,
0.1778678745,
-0.1074112207,
0.8956118226,
-0.3934955895,
-0.3992776573,
0.4778371453,
0.9680922627,
0.9162518382,
-0.4350443482,
0.0471433774,
0.5724573731,
-0.3916621506,
0.1790311635,
0.0401949845,
-0.4938622713,
0.0078276917,
0.7003155351,
0.7747295499,
0.4873462021,
-0.5129288435,
0.2608527541,
0.1224855185,
-0.525431931,
0.1581512243,
0.1148222759,
0.0721302629,
0.2170374393,
0.0616801977,
0.591450572,
0.2199387848,
-0.4915697873,
0.151548475,
0.0257760938,
-0.2685510218,
-0.2315215319,
0.6144934297,
0.2804080844,
-0.171275422,
0.6535265446,
-0.2301779687,
-0.2590402067,
0.3957648277,
0.1705243587,
0.6898182631,
-0.2482513636,
0.2515770197,
0.4227752984,
0.4919402301,
-0.0106319087,
0.2045823336,
0.0371076465,
-0.8936005831,
-0.588077426,
0.1368167549,
-0.8246394396,
0.1301285177,
-0.4505725503,
0.0559192002,
-0.2570884824,
-0.0854555219,
0.1526577771,
-0.062248379,
-0.6328495145,
0.5072348118,
-0.3933855891,
1.3277573586,
-0.8556560278,
0.4736457467,
0.6263510585,
-0.1675404906,
-0.2718352973,
-0.2538873851,
0.112027511,
-0.2888715863,
0.3862983584,
-0.300417006,
-0.2298590988,
-0.3064470291,
-0.3686519861,
-0.6913603544,
0.8605750799,
0.3933888972,
-0.9305537939,
0.047786057,
-0.0296020787,
0.3938212395,
-0.1120043099,
0.1500945985,
0.5277366638,
0.5985887051,
0.1241703182,
-0.8895896673,
0.2503630221,
-0.1109155566,
-0.2982623577,
-0.0219038688,
-0.538602829,
0.788706243,
-0.2579323649,
-0.0874535739,
-0.0469078235,
0.2258187234,
0.2302979678,
0.6250585914,
0.598923862,
0.8339734077,
0.6521356106,
0.0376811698,
0.8953948617,
0.013171982,
0.0993793085,
1.4069755077,
-0.1205119491,
0.6893054843,
0.2873079479,
-0.1414825618,
0.7695343494,
0.3284302354,
-0.0462188646,
0.3795340955,
0.1191872433,
-0.1232136562,
-0.2116510272,
-0.0576534942,
-0.3796515167,
0.3301641345,
0.2822394967,
-0.0887442976,
-0.0816858485,
-0.1057132483,
0.163000077,
0.3564092517,
-0.3092169166,
0.5162218809,
-0.1822754741,
-1.0462449789,
0.390688628,
-0.1233269051,
0.2683695555,
-0.1830331236,
-0.5395576954,
-0.2013572752,
-0.0950625017,
-0.1836981475,
-0.956017673,
0.5461555123,
0.0382868461,
-0.0745688677,
-0.1171485186,
0.9068160653,
-0.1455882043,
-0.3470764756,
0.1066977829,
0.7320423722,
-0.0959540531,
-0.0016687827,
-0.7442429662,
0.1753905565,
0.0275876243,
-0.31087327,
-0.1816750914,
0.5468230844,
-0.3386554122,
0.5868852139,
0.4691700935,
0.1103111058,
-0.2607643306,
0.0434952937,
0.54237324,
-0.8322582245,
-0.3417466283,
-0.6271088123,
0.4893675148,
-0.1297876835,
-0.3797074854,
0.6484558582,
0.1830805838,
0.9917390943,
-0.0517104492,
0.8375356793,
0.1060262024,
0.7083320022,
-0.4463047385,
0.561068058,
-0.3333496749,
0.059387356,
-0.7538026571,
-0.545152843,
-0.1491447985,
0.2418072373,
-0.5164942145,
-0.0355064198,
0.6452156305,
0.6164044142,
0.1281031817,
0.3416356146,
0.4063354731,
0.5380439758,
0.0433373675,
0.411872834,
0.8698775172,
-0.7313848138,
0.1623569578,
-0.7432951331,
-0.0830728188,
-0.1070138887,
-1.0685068369,
-0.6650909781,
-0.3496397734,
-0.6513439417,
-0.1799954772,
0.6292649508,
0.5003701448,
0.4814631343,
-0.6475880742,
0.1267055422,
-0.5619282722,
0.6658717394,
-0.6199349165,
-0.1805359721,
0.3848172128,
0.2469540983,
-0.3864477277,
0.3097170293,
-0.0253471807,
-0.0462329499,
0.0221094955,
0.2261176109,
-0.6533383727,
0.2528392076,
0.5975022912,
0.4371629059,
-0.6571497321,
-0.6286206841,
-0.246295616,
0.3774481118,
-0.181033209,
0.5129140019,
-0.9676510692,
0.8693938851,
0.5726046562,
0.4880986214,
0.2733435929,
0.2498429716,
0.5711926222,
-0.3954779804,
-0.2197915465,
-0.1881053448,
0.246590361,
0.4104001224,
-0.4471590817,
0.6831948757,
0.7166194916,
-0.5232294798,
-0.8742610216,
0.1214486361,
-0.6304910779,
-0.5605307817,
0.6540467739,
-0.1913560629,
-0.0864092261,
-0.3172734082,
-0.185324952,
0.4249830246,
-0.0030294065,
0.8178312182,
0.7354447842,
-0.5070430636,
-0.0973553285,
-0.5774449706,
0.548979938,
0.4400542676,
-0.800154686,
0.2178982496,
0.7252281308,
0.4136944711,
0.2346571833,
0.3191449344,
-0.0317397974,
0.8561394811,
0.5400512218,
0.0284611322,
-0.4030930996,
-0.2490419894,
-0.1248964965,
0.0608014874,
0.0225470476,
0.0412474275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17574v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17574v1
|
Scavenging Hyena: Distilling Transformers into Long Convolution Models
| 2024-01-31T03:39:07 | 2024-01-31T03:39:07 |
Tokiniaina Raharison Ralambomihanta, Shahrad Mohammadzadeh, Mohammad Sami Nur Islam, Wassim Jabbour, Laurence Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapid evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs), epitomized by
architectures like GPT-4, has reshaped the landscape of natural language
processing. This paper introduces a pioneering approach to address the
efficiency concerns associated with LLM pre-training, proposing the use of
knowledge distillation for cross-architecture transfer. Leveraging insights
from the efficient Hyena mechanism, our method replaces attention heads in
transformer models by Hyena, offering a cost-effective alternative to
traditional pre-training while confronting the challenge of processing long
contextual information, inherent in quadratic attention mechanisms. Unlike
conventional compression-focused methods, our technique not only enhances
inference speed but also surpasses pre-training in terms of both accuracy and
efficiency. In the era of evolving LLMs, our work contributes to the pursuit of
sustainable AI solutions, striking a balance between computational power and
environmental impact.
|
[
-0.4359247983,
-0.5077863932,
0.5282601118,
0.234040767,
-0.3734936714,
0.2191900909,
-0.2955231965,
-0.502116859,
0.1420425773,
0.3819819391,
-0.4165410697,
0.1108650118,
-0.8394990563,
0.0739608034,
-0.4232520163,
0.7966452241,
0.1796135604,
-0.3901461363,
-0.1343506724,
-0.205759123,
-0.094658263,
-0.6039905548,
-0.5801451802,
-0.5966714621,
0.7021031976,
0.0262247566,
0.6718168855,
0.8067293167,
0.3377133608,
0.3466888964,
-0.0842965469,
-0.1495520622,
-0.689428091,
0.0870363042,
-0.4140024483,
-0.3433052599,
-0.098482281,
0.1596632004,
0.3361167908,
0.4464125633,
-0.2556223273,
0.4393902123,
0.4127004743,
0.9028769135,
-0.8630235791,
0.2394936532,
-0.914272666,
-0.0201037489,
-0.253072381,
-0.3787629306,
-0.2404472083,
-0.3684239388,
0.4749960899,
-0.5683047771,
0.1280123144,
-0.124845393,
0.8611335158,
0.9144107699,
0.0993927792,
-0.2433847189,
-0.878608942,
0.9119841456,
-0.5300431848,
0.4438513517,
0.4023515284,
0.4604045749,
-0.1189255789,
-1.2598019838,
-0.7149891853,
-0.0321576856,
-0.0892708376,
-0.1379003674,
-0.703894794,
-0.1901922822,
0.2473386079,
0.4204689562,
-0.2555686831,
0.0843799636,
-0.6710823178,
-0.0028771886,
0.3828255236,
-0.2793806791,
-0.0477090962,
0.1390781254,
-0.5267833471,
-0.0735637695,
-0.8078586459,
0.0233447179,
0.1433297396,
0.0360997953,
0.209255442,
0.5220159888,
-0.0073148445,
0.5317723155,
0.2771376073,
-0.1257558018,
0.1763873547,
-0.2856606543,
-0.5398280025,
0.2177937031,
0.5583384037,
-0.0015099525,
0.2000105679,
-0.1543833613,
0.0476446263,
-0.0158348959,
0.654316783,
-1.0759880543,
-0.4098840356,
0.0385463946,
-0.5201852918,
-0.2158175856,
-0.4816893339,
-1.0153245926,
-0.2584523261,
-0.5795636773,
0.2572138906,
-0.1784361154,
-0.1620537639,
0.3060701489,
-0.3795574307,
0.4333700538,
0.076062791,
-1.1441557407,
0.1498371214,
0.5578759313,
0.8322569728,
-0.1104695573,
-0.2698484063,
-0.5191707611,
0.2723642588,
0.1844496429,
0.6408118606,
-0.4321165681,
-0.1710346043,
-0.1337132454,
-0.0757179856,
0.196162641,
-0.6493242383,
0.5869939923,
-0.5160781145,
-0.1704737693,
-0.275046885,
-0.2074088305,
-0.2759031951,
0.2629684806,
-0.8633279204,
1.1139130592,
0.1947205663,
-0.9090617895,
0.2583807111,
-0.480270803,
-0.5632589459,
0.080336988,
-0.0295760799,
-0.3418613076,
0.0595441572,
0.3391468525,
0.5815182328,
-0.5266407728,
0.1931380033,
-0.3134266734,
-0.1259802878,
-0.3647623956,
-0.3683750629,
0.7644301653,
0.3622839451,
-0.4938773215,
-0.0477583371,
-0.7575623989,
-0.4151076376,
0.1433588415,
-0.6126944423,
-0.7626646161,
0.0638608634,
-0.4646980464,
0.3482494056,
0.3858323991,
-0.3797160983,
0.2941233516,
-0.0278714336,
0.7482346296,
0.8263514638,
-0.3240569532,
0.6130085588,
-0.2091834247,
0.3328414559,
-0.1013940722,
0.1703194976,
0.0074276589,
-0.1682669818,
-0.9280190468,
-0.4122778177,
-0.1596565992,
0.3454551697,
-1.0827928782,
0.379660219,
-0.3558512628,
-0.8098985553,
-0.680575788,
0.2217814624,
0.0518017672,
0.5456739068,
0.5910112262,
0.0671468601,
-0.706846714,
-0.9434556961,
-0.3159450889,
-0.0348201431,
0.064030692,
0.0235948842,
0.3392449617,
-0.2856010497,
1.0516092777,
-0.445910722,
-0.1830560714,
-0.470143795,
0.1776049435,
0.1162620634,
0.3807463944,
0.8058260679,
-0.6603859067,
-0.3458928764,
-0.2244371325,
-0.6958251595,
-0.1030861512,
-0.0332514457,
-0.3116522729,
-0.1474212557,
0.7118800879,
-0.8655653,
0.3817373514,
0.7437904477,
0.1562291831,
0.4914350212,
-0.1381196976,
-0.0297018029,
-1.0853888988,
0.2680982351,
0.191688776,
-0.0669393688,
-0.6147243381,
-0.1995090842,
-0.1253219992,
0.0743362904,
-0.6289840937,
0.50154531,
-0.7428051829,
0.0510038473,
-0.3799856901,
-0.0718401223,
0.0115379915,
0.6819426417,
0.0714704841,
0.652439177,
0.3866568804,
-0.8243563771,
0.4566419721,
0.1629188061,
-0.3045404553,
0.3788406253,
-0.6324745417,
0.3273177445,
-0.1805096269,
0.4102694988,
-0.5419737101,
0.4001198113,
0.2467124909,
0.0124617815,
0.3218801022,
-0.1123465374,
-0.2367456853,
-0.5122874975,
-0.2866014838,
0.5780668855,
0.7123619318,
-0.9598306417,
0.9339876175,
0.4615779221,
-0.2797268629,
-0.6698228717,
-0.6793329716,
0.129668355,
-0.5154334307,
-0.4500096738,
0.3635903597,
0.0468497947,
-0.3026146293,
-0.1162083596,
-0.2112211287,
0.0031074998,
0.1135639697,
-0.0661193505,
-0.0664894059,
-0.1428091824,
0.0150001962,
-0.0536661744,
0.0080941282,
0.0542321317,
-0.5441092253,
0.7031645179,
0.2176455557,
0.1022854075,
-0.6418893933,
0.0842005536,
0.9165873528,
-0.5271530151,
0.5501513481,
0.4862864614,
-0.3615115583,
-0.2399035394,
-0.5966207981,
-0.2236787826,
-0.5396777391,
0.4072419405,
-0.4438541532,
-0.8177090287,
0.1272992194,
-0.4539962411,
0.1646927148,
0.355325222,
0.6068707108,
0.1010259166,
0.4249722958,
0.9519590735,
-0.5221329331,
0.7694137692,
-0.3535163105,
0.4834010601,
-0.7724645138,
-0.1360265911,
-0.9608610272,
-0.3991234601,
-0.3783712089,
-0.5646349788,
0.0455494411,
0.047299318,
-0.1904141605,
0.6211699247,
-0.5583036542,
0.4275891483,
0.6103154421,
-0.1066565439,
0.3456181586,
0.0483509824,
0.2928023934,
0.125112161,
-0.6870515347,
-0.5511111021,
0.9360318184,
0.4581699669,
1.0114622116,
-0.2104381174,
0.6445633173,
0.2626778483,
0.4355656207,
-0.8312116265,
0.396382302,
-0.1554359198,
-0.3199766576,
-0.4856610894,
-0.2178582549,
-0.9454000592,
0.5136688352,
0.0405765884,
-0.6265386343,
0.270686686,
0.0744270161,
-0.4859685004,
0.5622501969,
-0.4401959479,
0.8070550561,
-0.2157884836,
-0.5434436798,
-0.4692876935,
-0.6102062464,
0.4619828761,
-0.2132680863,
0.0441041961,
-0.1139757708,
0.1605803967,
0.6072493792,
-0.2717081308,
0.7155157328,
-0.2267668694,
-0.324536413,
0.3691133261,
-0.0258928798,
0.6789340377,
-0.3229344189,
-0.1419165134,
0.2415664643,
-0.2027100623,
-0.4381552637,
-0.655318737,
0.3288350701,
-0.6581106782,
-0.7983143926,
-0.4593259394,
-0.353543669,
0.0960508585,
0.1509072781,
0.1574201733,
0.0015875008,
-0.3359993994,
0.3222831786,
0.570330143,
-0.0548446774,
0.677693665,
0.3031218648,
0.1078686267,
-0.0209282208,
0.6673713326,
0.1335886568,
0.2856456339,
0.3103339672,
0.2579146624,
-0.3895663321,
-0.7547126412,
-0.3369821906,
0.1140303239,
-0.5642212033,
-0.1510578096,
-0.9695848823,
-0.1864184141,
-0.2692606449,
-0.1149276271,
-0.4970205426,
-0.0590203777,
-0.5649577379,
-0.1733627319,
0.1302726567,
0.6926181316,
-0.1090571284,
0.4497395754,
-1.0685371161,
0.4788953662,
0.6039957404,
-0.025192434,
0.1579778492,
-0.5147662163,
-0.3596154749,
0.1171473861,
-0.3038670421,
-0.5728670359,
0.5976489186,
0.3114711344,
0.7512498498,
0.2125582397,
0.1128029004,
0.6910389066,
-0.4743098021,
0.6778233647,
0.2369743437,
-0.9410297871,
0.2752307951,
0.0638827607,
0.2857737243,
0.5956928134,
0.5609643459,
-0.4309737384,
-0.2607509494,
-0.2837790847,
-0.8736814857,
0.5136855841,
0.1684621722,
0.1433085054,
0.1266318709,
0.243968159,
0.3904684186,
0.1589905918,
-0.4650806487,
0.1180828884,
-0.4531760216,
-0.0416033976,
-0.1690297574,
-0.288095355,
-0.0162966698,
-0.6116545796,
0.8574726582,
-0.2075010985,
-0.2187954187,
0.1350256801,
-0.5014801025,
0.3527959883,
0.2531502247,
0.3070118129,
0.4750367701,
-0.0408057459,
0.4026204348,
0.090156801,
-0.6588163972,
0.4360106587,
0.0655909032,
0.1623869538,
-0.3049127162,
0.1007942855,
0.7434383631,
0.1194905043,
-0.2603206933,
0.2384205312,
-0.3275362551,
-0.0915726274,
-0.1579594761,
-0.0797980428,
0.2995155454,
0.4958747327,
0.5178815126,
0.0831368044,
0.1277657002,
-0.6230330467,
0.3480849862,
0.1212025359,
-0.2234547585,
-0.3561026752,
0.4704971313,
0.5732293129,
-0.1553040892,
0.7893690467,
-0.0891419649,
-0.4376155734,
0.4046824872,
0.4696533382,
1.1992391348,
-0.3154608011,
-0.0594304763,
0.2944905162,
0.3127981126,
-0.324871093,
-0.1444477886,
-0.447332859,
-0.7110900283,
-0.3841516078,
-1.0408849716,
-0.0557329059,
0.2381937355,
-0.5931589007,
0.1460751593,
-0.2753504217,
-0.1698594242,
0.1187182218,
-0.2642372549,
-0.7707977295,
-0.2020085305,
0.2027837336,
0.9132376313,
-0.7585157752,
1.2803311348,
0.2744983137,
-0.4177044928,
-0.6099326015,
0.0923645943,
-0.3194257617,
-0.7637553215,
0.6900984049,
0.1855073124,
-0.4001621902,
0.2352663875,
-0.6470658779,
-0.9443620443,
1.2190191746,
0.6536405087,
-1.0301613808,
-0.309755981,
0.1488317102,
0.4917375445,
-0.0885673612,
-0.1700487882,
1.3245675564,
0.5774310231,
0.1402029246,
-0.9568524957,
0.1512745619,
-0.2734354436,
-0.0358476602,
0.0310189482,
-0.7259507179,
0.7454581261,
-0.1974032223,
-0.3758267462,
-0.0049540284,
0.8079554439,
0.1663750708,
-0.0798361897,
0.5459020734,
0.9002096057,
0.7402886748,
0.0405441634,
0.8808909655,
-0.2800295055,
0.140743345,
1.1290338039,
-0.4618492126,
0.6086684465,
1.0044032335,
-0.2096484751,
0.3877420127,
0.5265730023,
0.1106635109,
0.8440061808,
0.6751172543,
-0.2770061493,
-0.0646051094,
-0.0532531328,
-0.2324751616,
0.732634902,
0.2260529399,
-0.2160951048,
-0.4886182249,
0.0814650878,
0.1126619801,
-0.1696943045,
-0.3402679265,
0.8687955737,
0.3940150738,
-0.8972094059,
0.8140220046,
-0.4287288189,
1.034773469,
-0.523129642,
-0.1039772406,
-0.1279711425,
0.4232133627,
-0.0801871642,
-0.4847545326,
0.5245715976,
-0.0554602854,
-0.2839342356,
-0.470531553,
0.6965252757,
-0.5202547908,
-0.1985828578,
0.6501203179,
0.5566361547,
0.1331080198,
-0.4681712091,
-0.516734004,
0.019688284,
0.0395653956,
-0.4294442236,
0.2427366078,
0.4414841235,
-0.0172341615,
0.6146762967,
0.7930347323,
-0.0535029061,
0.2870628536,
0.0056195413,
1.1310030222,
-0.6624824405,
-0.5550883412,
-1.182862401,
0.3039254844,
-0.0300339535,
-0.084705323,
0.4347696006,
0.5493896604,
0.7677759528,
0.0281534251,
1.1423989534,
0.0610925965,
0.0845259652,
-0.3427950442,
1.0343638659,
-0.3664190173,
0.0357315578,
-0.0150859598,
-1.1352062225,
0.1368063688,
0.3558842838,
-0.0701223612,
-0.1997339427,
0.7682655454,
0.4894026518,
-0.2026085258,
0.0362766758,
0.1255093515,
0.2250804454,
0.734220922,
0.6006115079,
0.9139674902,
-0.0977537706,
0.5776565671,
-0.2857925296,
-0.2712934017,
-0.1374174654,
-1.0610095263,
-0.7901570201,
-0.5451269746,
-0.0435396954,
-0.1518125683,
0.0855201259,
0.7037004828,
0.7215554714,
-0.3751401603,
-0.1853420734,
0.0479740538,
-0.1783633083,
-0.2965920866,
-0.1044189706,
0.5569195747,
-0.3432925344,
-0.7735511661,
0.4392760098,
0.423499316,
0.2159949094,
-0.5554619431,
-0.0478618257,
-0.3317826986,
0.1591559798,
0.8162674904,
0.4618906379,
-0.407238245,
-0.328307122,
-0.11739932,
-0.2714933157,
0.2446945012,
1.0358628035,
-1.0309592485,
0.128037408,
0.7166691422,
0.9857352972,
1.0177022219,
-0.0834511369,
0.7458241582,
-0.3783533573,
0.433026582,
0.3336536288,
0.5654137731,
0.4259651005,
-0.2195840031,
0.4218067825,
0.203196317,
-0.5228709579,
-0.6447098851,
0.0621783361,
-0.9105506539,
-0.2591206729,
1.1519421339,
-0.3231089413,
-0.673458457,
-0.3340125084,
-0.2960717082,
0.6113318801,
-0.3445010185,
1.021250844,
0.5500102043,
0.1032695174,
-0.1121754199,
-0.2226533294,
0.7811422944,
0.1936206371,
-1.0619385242,
0.362588644,
0.2412478477,
0.3125056326,
0.2353161573,
0.6730308533,
-0.0044417204,
-0.104069747,
-0.1122026518,
0.362564832,
-0.0903547779,
-0.4810660481,
-0.2396834195,
0.1663854271,
-0.1827012599,
-0.367251724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17536v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17536v2
|
PipeNet: Question Answering with Semantic Pruning over Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-01-31T01:37:33 | 2024-05-17T01:06:46 |
Ying Su, Jipeng Zhang, Yangqiu Song, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
It is well acknowledged that incorporating explicit knowledge graphs (KGs)
can benefit question answering. Existing approaches typically follow a
grounding-reasoning pipeline in which entity nodes are first grounded for the
query (question and candidate answers), and then a reasoning module reasons
over the matched multi-hop subgraph for answer prediction. Although the
pipeline largely alleviates the issue of extracting essential information from
giant KGs, efficiency is still an open challenge when scaling up hops in
grounding the subgraphs. In this paper, we target at finding semantically
related entity nodes in the subgraph to improve the efficiency of graph
reasoning with KG. We propose a grounding-pruning-reasoning pipeline to prune
noisy nodes, remarkably reducing the computation cost and memory usage while
also obtaining decent subgraph representation. In detail, the pruning module
first scores concept nodes based on the dependency distance between matched
spans and then prunes the nodes according to score ranks. To facilitate the
evaluation of pruned subgraphs, we also propose a graph attention network (GAT)
based module to reason with the subgraph data. Experimental results on
CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.5909441113,
-0.7943667173,
0.6884338856,
-0.2775057554,
-0.4584213495,
-0.1050812081,
0.2361937463,
-0.047601115,
0.3947502971,
0.5842239261,
-0.7025285959,
-0.637218833,
-0.5791669488,
-0.0767348185,
-0.2712604702,
0.7454929352,
0.0733065978,
-0.3730648458,
-0.4333924949,
-0.1194885522,
-0.6572204828,
-0.035106279,
-0.8313835859,
-0.1699211001,
0.9985743165,
0.4612024426,
0.6036024094,
0.7243075371,
0.3830704987,
0.258559823,
-0.3285702765,
0.3590219617,
-0.6338119507,
0.3974853456,
-0.3348766565,
-0.3268205822,
-0.1078600734,
-0.334982127,
0.5388759375,
0.7885690928,
0.2199404538,
0.3527175188,
-0.2628184259,
0.64742136,
-0.6726443172,
0.3675866723,
-0.7630072832,
0.0927041918,
0.0344721451,
-0.3652917743,
-0.2182812989,
-0.1204483956,
0.003625853,
-0.8804359436,
0.1263938248,
0.2438687682,
0.9268015623,
0.6607990265,
-0.3960863948,
0.0015607215,
-0.216235891,
0.3930729032,
-0.4230009019,
0.5889014006,
0.3641415536,
0.3049813509,
-0.1020768434,
-1.0457260609,
-0.3115209639,
0.229899317,
-0.3155755699,
0.450512588,
-0.1149032861,
0.2953791916,
0.2360344827,
0.1509743482,
-0.5260064602,
-0.328491509,
-0.5475175977,
-0.509729147,
0.2257988602,
0.045426067,
0.2505223155,
-0.248428002,
-0.0839677602,
0.0383180231,
-0.5321047306,
-0.1002469361,
0.4794657826,
0.0483174734,
0.809543848,
0.6526878476,
-0.6153752804,
0.8517336249,
-0.2163350433,
-0.0452996455,
-0.0566761643,
-0.1509047449,
-0.2795260847,
0.0079245307,
0.3503835499,
0.4884613752,
0.4482499361,
-0.6434946656,
0.2920154929,
0.0488368981,
0.3864164352,
-0.8773595095,
-0.5504307151,
0.4946905673,
-0.3717113733,
-0.0837849975,
-0.1486037374,
-0.3233968914,
-0.2421135008,
-0.2043020427,
0.2595615089,
-0.5650372505,
-0.498752594,
0.0355041288,
-0.632409811,
0.2273828685,
0.2685107589,
-0.193707332,
0.3037720323,
0.9111886024,
0.7122453451,
0.3356528878,
-0.1183330938,
-0.7085040808,
0.1671921909,
-0.3382793069,
0.6117477417,
-0.4561296105,
0.0631324127,
-0.537725091,
0.1254724264,
-0.2027216405,
-0.3985319734,
0.7121454477,
-0.8676534295,
-0.0010489784,
-0.2738507986,
-0.7430891395,
-0.4860371947,
0.487906158,
-0.478717804,
0.7647544742,
0.0642675608,
-1.4448496103,
0.2080307305,
-0.4834204614,
-0.3635343313,
0.1203694344,
0.2240073532,
-0.3916422725,
-0.2286603749,
0.373492986,
0.4944736063,
-0.215084821,
0.2959776819,
-0.2275494486,
-0.3263399005,
-0.2769518495,
0.0900905728,
0.7431576252,
0.4349790215,
0.1464901716,
0.141869396,
-0.4219406247,
0.4928329587,
-0.0694012642,
0.0742452443,
-0.3531341553,
-0.0583063588,
-0.7348157763,
0.07422968,
-0.2865803838,
-0.6665867567,
-0.1642042696,
-0.5498347282,
0.7194026709,
0.5240877867,
0.3664997518,
0.309568882,
-0.3051822484,
0.5437330604,
0.2717954814,
-0.1359218955,
-0.0751034915,
-0.6486439705,
-0.7170143723,
-0.1514503956,
0.5016332269,
0.5302850604,
-0.9086949825,
0.0154161053,
-0.5641489029,
-0.5402216911,
-0.6424916983,
-0.0662309229,
0.2577828169,
1.0601245165,
0.4435693026,
-0.3437584043,
-0.3772923946,
-0.8965249658,
-0.2794715762,
-0.3354505897,
-0.1233367473,
0.5304194689,
0.3019856215,
0.2659524083,
1.3736331463,
-0.7257175446,
-0.1556548774,
-0.0156975798,
-0.064725399,
0.2458453625,
0.2267882526,
0.1415249109,
-1.0195724964,
-0.3094866872,
-0.0207270663,
-0.528532505,
-0.12228138,
0.365991354,
-0.4107594788,
-0.467186451,
0.4375527799,
-0.877292037,
0.2894185781,
0.1083835363,
-0.2128349394,
0.4972721934,
0.1755592823,
-0.026864361,
-0.8326033354,
0.1509945691,
-0.3332355022,
-0.3490647674,
-0.3940648437,
0.2259646058,
-0.1579326987,
-0.3851373792,
-0.4022675753,
0.4138226509,
-0.3675100207,
-0.2026460767,
0.1362819672,
0.3152917624,
0.3009428382,
0.568662405,
0.1894924939,
0.5299868584,
0.5090494156,
-0.5559357405,
0.6672524214,
0.1443847418,
-0.0749371499,
0.2484197766,
-0.7696006298,
0.3314912915,
-0.6396187544,
0.2740592659,
-1.0500473976,
-0.1294265985,
0.3797775805,
-0.6934937239,
0.0524485372,
-0.8058212996,
-0.2010774314,
-0.4338807464,
-0.0580679327,
0.1594565511,
0.3616973162,
-0.1162200868,
0.515804708,
0.3526413441,
-0.0660021156,
-0.686359942,
-0.511040926,
-0.1343097389,
-0.4220383763,
-1.1077313423,
0.0550194904,
0.3291772008,
-0.0505404845,
0.6273144484,
-0.4210687876,
-0.2906316519,
0.3015300632,
0.026535064,
-0.2987638712,
-0.1491064131,
0.5463944077,
0.0460230857,
-0.4307150245,
0.132887423,
-1.0433751345,
0.3793745637,
0.0919483006,
-0.2848392129,
0.0338665582,
0.3394442201,
0.4849665761,
-0.4045701623,
0.7170494795,
0.6157183647,
-0.2836014628,
-0.0491683483,
-0.2919047475,
-0.3055665493,
-0.3237093687,
0.4772245884,
-0.7140282393,
-0.9768003225,
0.2962308526,
-0.3172926903,
-0.1966780275,
0.3027094305,
0.1947423965,
-0.0738773271,
0.7151562572,
0.0173189975,
0.1509382725,
-0.067727983,
-0.3917591274,
0.5399833918,
-0.8311357498,
-0.0013746112,
-0.5233861804,
-0.2815552354,
-0.3560670316,
-0.4696936309,
0.4923121929,
0.3584419489,
-0.2356666625,
0.4021247327,
-0.7795093656,
0.5148016214,
0.6399871111,
0.0675189421,
0.1190226376,
-0.2019560635,
-0.4014040232,
0.1453111619,
-1.1522231102,
-0.133636564,
0.6848245859,
0.2877162993,
0.3299105465,
0.0826451033,
0.5853421688,
-0.2968240976,
0.0719465911,
-0.9204938412,
0.5387467146,
0.0730629563,
-0.6110089421,
-0.676214695,
-0.8938789368,
-0.8313743472,
0.3034399748,
0.1901720613,
-0.62746948,
-0.2509348392,
0.1003252938,
-0.025832288,
0.438929677,
-1.0353953838,
0.9915525317,
0.3739660978,
-0.3225441575,
0.0190659016,
-0.9319866896,
0.2493886799,
0.5449103713,
0.1234566048,
-0.1635620296,
0.1560410559,
0.7445137501,
-0.740976572,
0.4408127666,
-0.518777132,
0.2765341401,
0.6701830626,
0.0715781525,
0.5587773919,
0.0582021996,
-0.036227461,
-0.2364653051,
-0.0110403169,
-0.4342069626,
-0.969745338,
0.6217630506,
-0.5811885595,
-0.8132033348,
0.0850848109,
-0.4931385517,
-0.4048068523,
0.3617768586,
0.0259446949,
0.5752978325,
0.3426741958,
0.3362417519,
0.7781288028,
0.1552816927,
0.0407255515,
-0.148393169,
-0.0488085672,
-0.3336084187,
0.8579317927,
0.5765098333,
0.2001485676,
0.7322113514,
0.4619942009,
-0.5134689808,
-0.5773857832,
-0.4368802607,
0.0371203646,
-0.8187798858,
-0.4214015603,
-1.0991151333,
-0.2665025592,
-0.6421973705,
0.3048247099,
-0.0770549476,
-0.6092010736,
0.1775204241,
-0.3751491904,
0.5573872328,
0.0726267397,
0.245457679,
-0.0070700925,
-0.645660758,
0.2982616723,
0.7650222182,
0.3949272037,
0.1183530241,
-0.2040025443,
0.1217702478,
-0.1152686328,
-0.0985452533,
-0.9102351665,
0.0639567301,
-0.0374353938,
0.4001216292,
-0.0203458685,
0.5522993803,
0.7961345911,
-0.3072371483,
0.397453934,
0.0849966779,
-0.6166199446,
0.5549404621,
-0.3718010783,
0.2527453303,
0.3983479142,
0.5081387162,
-0.7963831425,
-0.462207526,
-0.8973773718,
-0.9314587116,
0.5540553331,
0.4853268266,
-0.1838591397,
-0.2363815457,
0.3829410076,
-0.3369924426,
0.2317260802,
-0.3103123307,
-0.2012766451,
-0.490529716,
-0.2501398027,
0.4061312675,
-0.1136193871,
-0.1713339984,
-0.1962522715,
0.7873523831,
-0.4512884617,
0.1423435211,
0.5610471964,
-0.102360487,
0.2547883987,
0.2788316905,
-0.1739319265,
0.6973504424,
-0.0200085733,
0.5054600239,
0.2840667665,
-0.4032181203,
-0.010661602,
-0.1606447995,
-0.3649485707,
-0.0357198715,
0.3063180447,
0.8008267879,
-0.1893780828,
-0.3567290306,
0.4330769777,
0.0021834294,
-0.194612354,
-0.0543763489,
0.1979589164,
0.7313557863,
-0.1381587237,
0.0843207613,
0.0225621685,
0.1705443561,
-0.2924440801,
0.2682126164,
0.2583094239,
-0.6763184071,
0.2265433967,
0.4801126719,
0.2018388808,
-0.3331856132,
0.7989574671,
-0.2641712427,
-0.7695868611,
0.8572063446,
0.2250359952,
0.6042824984,
0.3799914122,
0.3043920398,
0.5298470259,
0.276912272,
0.5386181474,
-0.1581718922,
-0.2609206438,
-0.8905199766,
-0.8125474453,
-0.5426102281,
-0.2275927663,
-0.2012531161,
-0.2664017081,
0.2741246819,
-0.3286094666,
0.1570230573,
-0.0637226999,
0.1955403984,
-0.3780534863,
0.6301185489,
-0.2300786227,
0.9593991041,
-0.571455121,
0.7248983979,
0.860317111,
-0.3791373968,
-1.3624782562,
-0.1998941749,
-0.318430692,
-0.6242980361,
0.6634041071,
0.2760428786,
-0.2417235374,
0.5804539919,
-0.2609003186,
-0.6475500464,
1.2917342186,
0.3629447222,
-0.1735455543,
0.0452072173,
-0.122717306,
0.2525620461,
-0.1102697849,
0.6824391484,
0.357093662,
0.5534240007,
0.5550595522,
-0.6093481779,
-0.0074190237,
-0.3528718352,
-0.2422563434,
0.5135740042,
-0.7883749008,
0.54545784,
-0.0244274065,
-0.3339048028,
-0.3492606282,
0.4913824797,
0.1962961555,
0.3987506032,
0.8604433537,
1.1063678265,
0.9340381026,
-0.1896946579,
0.8532119989,
-0.1777055562,
0.4113957584,
0.8205742836,
-0.059586022,
0.1563794613,
0.5391058326,
-0.1331321597,
0.3061958551,
0.6903229356,
0.6426682472,
0.4796175957,
0.5394816995,
-0.0081686154,
-0.5386514068,
-0.355863452,
-0.2489099354,
0.2121363878,
0.0632572174,
0.0123881679,
-0.3583912253,
-0.3109167218,
0.1902362108,
-0.0490716659,
-0.3328653276,
0.8052251339,
-0.0295191724,
-0.9347900748,
0.2406942248,
-0.0951873213,
-0.0078755999,
-0.5765467286,
-0.1323911548,
-0.153131485,
-0.2106068134,
-0.2862092257,
-0.8224341273,
0.6583302617,
-0.2963591814,
-0.2162512541,
-0.2982000113,
1.2110993862,
-0.1570281386,
-0.2107779384,
0.3558373749,
0.5027364492,
0.3848147392,
-0.2514466941,
-0.4493343234,
-0.4371227622,
-0.1205291301,
-0.2077869624,
0.1204429418,
0.8372482061,
-0.0909493417,
0.9238758087,
0.6922745705,
0.0639691502,
0.1654445529,
0.0689576417,
1.0811693668,
-0.3375866115,
-0.6348830462,
-0.2728403211,
0.4586293697,
-0.3777808547,
-0.2997575104,
0.4516034126,
0.4530149102,
0.7963741422,
0.1454156935,
0.5335190296,
-0.3732022047,
0.725492835,
-0.5282322168,
0.5020129085,
-0.3005331159,
0.0717442632,
-0.1538781524,
-0.8542129993,
-0.1762049943,
0.5217081308,
-0.503371954,
-0.1450220495,
0.8726938367,
0.9256045818,
-0.1964216679,
0.067598775,
0.3590615094,
0.2664247751,
0.0974047333,
0.5895347595,
0.6993658543,
-0.2952500582,
0.8762106895,
-0.3692486584,
0.0547013655,
0.3055984974,
-0.8865779638,
-0.5468184352,
-0.3781801462,
-0.4705922008,
-0.2928971648,
0.2543215752,
0.229903087,
0.8161793947,
-0.5042592883,
0.3855473697,
-0.5652916431,
0.6527013779,
-0.2777844071,
-0.3389817178,
0.5438343883,
-0.3800743818,
-0.3579156101,
0.129782021,
0.2184375823,
-0.6114362478,
-0.1201868132,
0.0283741113,
-0.396928221,
-0.3367260695,
0.2787948549,
0.0302115306,
-0.410677433,
-0.8275690079,
0.1916584671,
0.4764585495,
-0.1745872647,
0.8360007405,
-1.0575520992,
0.3374695182,
0.8055850267,
0.9386639595,
0.7728318572,
0.3391326666,
0.3148337603,
-1.0248076916,
0.2520289421,
0.5699186325,
0.1604256034,
0.261828959,
-0.3685734868,
0.7654503584,
0.6004418731,
-0.4356005192,
-0.4012670517,
0.4685288668,
-0.6596500874,
-0.3501001,
1.1041594744,
-0.6028584838,
-0.4521873295,
-0.5414298773,
-0.2460217625,
0.3613648117,
0.0149447629,
0.1195245162,
0.9140399098,
-0.0000940026,
-0.4967685938,
-0.3606194854,
0.1142333597,
0.622317791,
-0.5127868652,
-0.0432694294,
0.3778508604,
0.4508323371,
0.2440021932,
0.8052982092,
0.1199765205,
0.1288999617,
0.2331972718,
-0.4285637736,
-0.4848961234,
-0.4687007368,
0.495177865,
0.6848694086,
-0.0373392142,
-0.2586378455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17514v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17514v2
|
How Useful is Continued Pre-Training for Generative Unsupervised Domain Adaptation?
| 2024-01-31T00:15:34 | 2024-04-01T20:40:40 |
Rheeya Uppaal, Yixuan Li, Junjie Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent breakthroughs in scale have enabled the emergence of powerful
generative language models, and the ability to fine-tune these models on
various tasks by casting them into prompts or instructions. In this landscape,
the problem of Unsupervised Domain Adaptation (UDA), or the problem of
leveraging knowledge from a labeled source domain to an unlabeled target
domain, has been left behind, with recent UDA methods still addressing
discriminative classification. In particular, two popular UDA approaches,
involving Continued Pre-Training (CPT) and learning domain invariant
representations, have been under-explored in the generative setting, signaling
a gap. In this work, we evaluate the utility of CPT for generative UDA. We
first perform an empirical evaluation to measure the trade-offs between CPT and
strong methods promoting domain invariance. We further evaluate how well the
benefits of CPT extend to different architectures, tuning methods and data
regimes. We then motivate the use of CPT by studying to what degree it benefits
classification performance on the target domain. Finally, we attempt to
understand the mechanism behind which CPT improves classification performance
on the unlabeled target domain. Our findings suggest that a implicitly learns
the downstream task while predicting masked words informative to that task. Our
work connects the body of UDA research with that of instruction tuning,
enabling an initial step towards a wider applicability of modern language
models.
|
[
-0.4064960778,
-0.3021320999,
0.5060815811,
0.1734962761,
-0.4954668283,
0.2629129589,
-0.3443505466,
-0.2273961753,
-0.3352575302,
0.4319604337,
-0.4609002769,
-0.242344752,
-0.6805321574,
-0.0788745582,
-0.2368353903,
0.9772911668,
-0.1178393215,
-0.0782837495,
-0.3322933316,
0.093125537,
-0.9716575742,
-0.8929719925,
-0.7467237115,
-0.4633662999,
0.3268932104,
0.1997383982,
0.2039393038,
0.353260994,
0.2291211188,
0.2240466326,
0.3765243292,
-0.0610183142,
-0.6674974561,
-0.0282093938,
-0.1803614199,
-0.5252193809,
-0.2634039223,
0.3255081773,
0.6987181306,
1.1093965769,
-0.1555735171,
-0.0417560376,
0.6563277245,
0.8964993954,
-0.7802777886,
0.3279089332,
-0.6583608985,
0.0504558235,
-0.4540127516,
-0.304677099,
-0.5928342342,
-0.0989696756,
0.3857609332,
-0.8961771727,
0.2723775804,
-0.1979016364,
0.675229311,
0.3506877124,
-0.1671577096,
-0.0129453512,
-0.935513556,
0.8513150811,
-0.1038688496,
0.6848996282,
0.3889167011,
0.0720147491,
-0.2712581456,
-0.898992002,
-0.4973391593,
-0.1390074939,
0.051488094,
0.5606159568,
-0.4114408791,
0.0237132013,
0.1440585107,
0.2086961418,
-0.3904184699,
0.3859576881,
-0.2804621458,
-0.0587702654,
0.2047702521,
-0.2893031538,
0.2030285895,
0.4688334763,
-0.5233106613,
-0.1781151295,
-1.0462193489,
0.0509224832,
0.136508286,
0.0818985701,
-0.0268986877,
0.2300416529,
0.0142800137,
0.8797969222,
0.2233049124,
0.2806511521,
0.0040221917,
0.0537112504,
-0.2310548425,
-0.1507948339,
0.2231634557,
0.1377935559,
0.636603415,
-0.2038394958,
-0.0567884892,
0.1605921388,
0.6543792486,
-0.7199802399,
-0.7219047546,
-0.2927606106,
-0.268332839,
0.104717426,
0.1378957778,
-0.6904489994,
-0.1296566278,
-0.577426672,
0.4066415429,
-0.2141729593,
-0.2777866423,
0.2042433619,
0.0078447862,
0.1500591338,
0.6004787683,
-1.0737458467,
0.0990545005,
0.5576709509,
0.6256465316,
-0.4602491558,
-0.3458820581,
-0.3674800992,
0.0323460437,
-0.570880115,
0.8874382973,
-0.6287693381,
-0.4978341162,
0.043375507,
0.1675120741,
-0.5976612568,
-0.6334414482,
0.245392859,
-0.9617123008,
0.1994161159,
-0.1659146696,
-0.4668975174,
-0.1541370898,
-0.108100675,
-0.5351676345,
0.7188104391,
0.4845426083,
-0.3860616982,
0.8417907953,
-0.5469149351,
-0.385966152,
0.367592454,
0.0603782758,
-0.3811281025,
0.2782848775,
0.2049686164,
0.525975585,
0.0291594081,
-0.1823812723,
-0.1132225618,
-0.2654821575,
0.1928850263,
-0.5521346331,
0.4810686111,
0.0768346116,
-0.2401978821,
-0.2112363875,
-0.4650137722,
-0.14621301,
-0.0231701899,
-0.49445948,
-0.4709064364,
-0.043979302,
-0.2823072374,
-0.066573292,
-0.0702593327,
-0.2234749049,
0.1461417526,
-0.1119107753,
0.0164739657,
1.1347631216,
-0.0725573376,
0.3978863358,
-0.1133029833,
0.716766715,
0.0025960128,
0.0073446776,
0.025960682,
-0.4726988971,
-0.6914481521,
-0.4655404091,
0.6349297762,
0.3046779335,
-0.9137514234,
0.4202336967,
-0.2410179675,
-0.1357996911,
-0.1991893649,
0.2411212921,
0.4414251149,
0.3445463479,
0.4048986733,
-0.8900346756,
-0.5764700174,
-0.1758722514,
-0.0642410517,
-0.0322393589,
-0.2392045707,
-0.0030660643,
0.348616004,
-0.219917655,
0.8738212585,
-0.5432180762,
-0.2823334336,
-0.3301751912,
0.1801876277,
-0.0894495472,
0.4301219583,
0.683799684,
-0.6674792767,
-0.7268874645,
0.0844071433,
-0.6545729041,
-0.0067454865,
-0.3588370383,
-0.1308480799,
-0.005512388,
0.3223299682,
-0.5103243589,
0.3317398429,
0.6727136374,
-0.0129727628,
0.4892272055,
-0.3674610257,
0.0412555411,
-0.7807995677,
-0.1534100771,
-0.2128374428,
-0.2291809171,
-0.726834476,
-0.2283083498,
-0.0780093074,
-0.060853824,
-0.1738876998,
0.2559899986,
-0.693338275,
0.030278841,
-0.5409976244,
-0.0875443816,
-0.1141624823,
0.4059049785,
0.3289599419,
1.1366369724,
0.7175511122,
-1.0103590488,
-0.0062016631,
0.1822289973,
-0.3725280762,
0.5809030533,
-0.3164053559,
0.4509436786,
0.008465128,
0.1818577349,
-0.4900692701,
-0.0019797317,
0.1261985898,
-0.3638953567,
0.849851191,
-0.1544845104,
-0.0968360528,
-0.2719317079,
-0.1185592264,
0.5083373785,
0.7553598285,
-1.053917408,
0.4180938601,
0.2862309515,
0.0561964251,
-0.3642359078,
-0.0998551473,
-0.0546739139,
-0.1507805735,
-0.1127080619,
0.54079175,
-0.0680701137,
0.1446706504,
-0.051340282,
-0.3065386713,
0.0883606523,
0.2462629676,
0.2655458748,
0.0741558298,
-0.3321149945,
0.0607019104,
0.0473527201,
-0.2584225535,
-0.0042673023,
-0.630859971,
0.5280215144,
0.0680776834,
-0.1899308562,
-0.3543775082,
0.1387029588,
0.2599362135,
-0.1030099764,
0.8308008909,
0.4472860396,
-0.2522765398,
-0.4726758897,
-0.1765995175,
-0.1065378785,
-0.4308591485,
0.222958222,
-0.4534087479,
-0.9701359272,
0.090874128,
-0.6484319568,
-0.3570586145,
0.4626068175,
0.2715345919,
-0.2958020568,
0.6436576247,
1.18440938,
0.0394273847,
0.6573376656,
-0.3350747228,
0.1934592873,
-0.9759843946,
-0.2661408782,
-0.3227547705,
0.1734889448,
-0.4096170366,
-0.3201258183,
0.179480046,
0.5613661408,
0.1391213536,
0.4848882556,
-0.2859018147,
0.4300120771,
0.4757787585,
0.1602803469,
0.0603634566,
0.115382269,
0.3634414673,
-0.0158139616,
-0.7979644537,
-0.1417256743,
1.2297544479,
0.1764454097,
0.8214236498,
-0.173780039,
0.3855662942,
0.5549430847,
0.7698730826,
-0.6270397902,
0.2657624185,
-0.4708750248,
-0.1404888183,
-0.2804493606,
-0.1461395174,
-1.1917624474,
0.1629204601,
-0.0598976649,
-0.4994000494,
0.4769053161,
0.350240171,
-0.3940837979,
0.0868178979,
-0.8312831521,
0.939025104,
-0.067973271,
-0.1586561203,
-0.2271190882,
-0.3554812074,
0.0539475493,
-0.6955993176,
-0.2377244681,
0.2597527802,
0.2564926744,
0.9973546863,
-0.1672986448,
1.156247139,
-0.0919790938,
-0.1081225649,
0.1223779917,
-0.3913773298,
0.2598549724,
-0.0965789407,
0.4674551785,
0.3745751679,
-0.1011014506,
-0.430960089,
-0.7054619789,
0.419634521,
-0.8052052855,
-0.8639056683,
-0.5121894479,
-0.2076660544,
-0.4553655386,
0.2607973516,
0.4217053354,
0.3514664769,
-0.3270895183,
0.3131422997,
0.9505586624,
-0.0173351616,
0.1991874576,
0.3261314332,
0.2173285931,
-0.1096674427,
0.8662346005,
-0.1495148987,
0.3777591586,
0.6318394542,
0.1284141243,
-0.30424124,
-0.8379489779,
-0.4428745508,
0.0298294127,
-0.7250653505,
-0.2798799276,
-0.4576818347,
-0.1957008988,
-0.3900668323,
-0.2589150965,
-0.1799104661,
-0.0793474689,
-0.6663487554,
-0.210946843,
0.0994890481,
0.7506937981,
-0.135109216,
0.4748907387,
-0.6272988319,
0.2434103638,
0.7244190574,
0.2100978792,
-0.2280800939,
-0.6950841546,
-0.3516388535,
-0.0802260414,
-0.2272768468,
-0.7117830515,
0.1142254546,
0.5619267821,
0.75589329,
0.2817491889,
-0.005991987,
0.6337314844,
-0.5065571666,
0.6450206041,
0.2446946055,
-0.8687520027,
0.3798680604,
0.0182476584,
0.3876770139,
0.4034090638,
0.6404104233,
-0.2315458655,
0.0264992435,
-0.1551478803,
-0.4574327469,
0.6649978161,
0.0582279228,
0.439565748,
0.1694084257,
0.4275370836,
0.4117514789,
0.1729871482,
-0.4893219769,
0.0358235501,
-0.5868245959,
0.1709902436,
-0.3308556974,
-0.4390729666,
-0.051764451,
-0.3313620389,
0.562964797,
-0.2755742967,
0.320445776,
-0.210793525,
-0.3634375334,
0.0648506582,
0.2579495609,
0.4594290853,
0.7937002182,
-0.1268341094,
0.0246545095,
0.1044186577,
-0.8936610818,
0.0315980352,
0.1835563034,
-0.0284085087,
-0.2879651189,
0.5538191795,
0.9776334167,
0.0318153985,
-0.3291755319,
0.5121394396,
-0.0571305677,
-0.1122845635,
-0.1791606992,
-0.0576195456,
-0.3969170749,
0.0516435467,
0.1991091222,
0.2129530609,
-0.2543317974,
-0.669408679,
0.3521166444,
0.3450413048,
-0.4438559413,
-0.5373893976,
0.5098444819,
0.1853356361,
0.0333879143,
0.725336194,
-0.01685955,
-0.6636615396,
0.2765307426,
0.7581433654,
1.1070306301,
-0.4467775226,
0.3015932739,
-0.0338349566,
0.2872923315,
-0.0803805217,
-0.1721139699,
-0.4446195364,
-0.9975593686,
-0.5087015629,
-0.7803202868,
-0.1222475916,
0.0729289949,
-0.7109133005,
-0.1853112727,
-0.3744384646,
-0.0467165522,
-0.181686312,
-0.387825042,
-0.9051673412,
0.3537173569,
-0.1506141424,
0.5910179615,
-0.8444681764,
0.9898862839,
0.6594730616,
-0.2775388956,
-0.6120074391,
0.3862588704,
-0.4730658829,
-0.776432693,
0.8768894076,
0.1394867301,
-0.4083932042,
0.1921141744,
-0.3026926517,
-0.6171067357,
0.8822824359,
0.3803610206,
-0.5095936656,
0.2454729825,
-0.0606299937,
0.7231650352,
-0.5527822971,
-0.3189910054,
0.7607990503,
0.0906102732,
0.0631294698,
-0.6129098535,
0.1016869992,
0.0273531303,
0.2027001083,
0.0715537295,
-0.1926752031,
0.5181118846,
-0.4241873026,
-0.5565924048,
0.0104090767,
0.7530318499,
-0.0286449827,
0.1972248852,
0.6727977395,
0.4632148743,
0.475848794,
-0.2931886017,
1.0168066025,
0.074465476,
0.1900339723,
0.876119256,
-0.2960125804,
0.6496793032,
0.2229259461,
-0.4173368812,
0.663263917,
0.7814129591,
0.1189319342,
1.0611037016,
0.2625901699,
-0.5084583759,
-0.4510446489,
-0.0381621048,
-0.6374134421,
0.4663420618,
0.4478459358,
-0.1091234237,
-0.0555273965,
0.3980823457,
-0.1628210247,
0.1035999358,
-0.2728471756,
0.882735014,
0.214845866,
-0.6346893311,
0.6180852056,
-0.3933714926,
0.4461931884,
-0.6326480508,
-0.2537375391,
-0.2011444718,
0.3535104692,
0.027327694,
-0.5207990408,
-0.0016443075,
-0.0804733038,
-0.1770635098,
-0.549354732,
0.6247883439,
-0.2602677643,
-0.0852445588,
0.3445626497,
0.2825040519,
0.0869474933,
-0.310021311,
-0.5011629462,
-0.0369048975,
-0.1107337698,
-0.1525453627,
0.6080843806,
0.3632415533,
-0.1086721942,
0.4089580774,
0.8496650457,
0.0374845527,
0.0946484506,
0.3485228717,
1.1189194918,
-0.3640690148,
-0.3081713319,
-0.4191347659,
0.260386616,
0.2590694726,
-0.2786754668,
0.7111334205,
0.3072440326,
1.382948041,
-0.4293024242,
0.7757441998,
0.1683250666,
0.1883224696,
-1.0503102541,
0.5328505635,
-0.484613657,
0.2576724887,
0.069911018,
-0.9843586087,
-0.266551286,
0.2339497507,
-0.2301742584,
0.3489536345,
0.9230995774,
0.4020532966,
0.0056362106,
-0.1692493111,
0.5820786357,
-0.1899298429,
0.1979750693,
0.4530972242,
0.9524035454,
0.0659592673,
0.1780365855,
-0.1545119733,
-0.5853070021,
0.0948715881,
-0.7069898248,
-1.0583796501,
-0.6924530864,
-0.3899823725,
-0.1547560841,
0.3723133802,
0.3527365923,
0.8636197448,
-0.9072733521,
-0.0040553133,
-0.1966642737,
-0.1592347622,
-0.6521695256,
-0.1414639205,
0.6365851164,
-0.4554854929,
-0.6079865098,
0.558103323,
0.3675895333,
0.1686333269,
-0.0009807728,
0.0109684281,
0.1626984477,
-0.2087775916,
0.9592856169,
0.622456789,
-0.3831557631,
-0.3488557637,
-0.0887229964,
0.3316133022,
0.0070116362,
1.2136012316,
-0.8287379742,
0.6394769549,
0.2388524711,
0.9583070278,
0.5161312819,
0.0391602591,
0.8610883951,
-0.7347883582,
-0.1059081852,
0.0503369644,
0.2066290081,
0.3630832434,
-0.4248242378,
0.3222098649,
0.5208436251,
-0.4259419143,
-0.566781342,
0.3404020667,
-0.8929036856,
-0.2778527737,
0.9224324226,
-0.4891390204,
0.1297340542,
-0.5221111774,
0.0455968864,
0.1888467222,
-0.0357138589,
0.7657686472,
0.4418233037,
-0.2555483282,
-0.3168061078,
-0.3377031982,
0.9224214554,
0.4051013887,
-1.0431206226,
0.0753193498,
0.1521544456,
0.209268108,
0.0502583906,
0.8337450624,
0.0103687057,
0.3378767371,
-0.0748534203,
-0.1203738675,
0.1148883328,
-0.7744206786,
-0.4721134305,
-0.0989025608,
0.2964450419,
-0.6186868548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17511v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17511v1
|
Linguistically Communicating Uncertainty in Patient-Facing Risk Prediction Models
| 2024-01-31T00:08:44 | 2024-01-31T00:08:44 |
Adarsa Sivaprasad, Ehud Reiter
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the unique challenges associated with uncertainty
quantification in AI models when applied to patient-facing contexts within
healthcare. Unlike traditional eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)
methods tailored for model developers or domain experts, additional
considerations of communicating in natural language, its presentation and
evaluating understandability are necessary. We identify the challenges in
communication model performance, confidence, reasoning and unknown knowns using
natural language in the context of risk prediction. We propose a design aimed
at addressing these challenges, focusing on the specific application of
in-vitro fertilisation outcome prediction.
|
[
0.0168772489,
-0.6469205618,
0.7342478633,
0.4048053324,
-0.04084187,
0.1627053171,
0.1895575076,
-0.9408794045,
-0.2153650671,
0.1348693967,
-0.7449260354,
-0.1574986428,
-0.6299619079,
0.0581952408,
-0.1638148427,
0.5529708266,
-0.3581313491,
0.3851712346,
-0.5306874514,
0.2265301794,
-0.4809359312,
-0.7315465808,
-0.6656382084,
-0.5069978833,
0.071921058,
0.4220581949,
1.0872017145,
0.4820838273,
0.8509871364,
0.2657980621,
-0.178699404,
-0.431869626,
0.0794245228,
0.1333906204,
0.0538662896,
-0.5544510484,
-0.1543085724,
-0.1968671978,
0.7136368752,
1.2164129019,
-0.2400537878,
-0.0402394794,
-0.2769325972,
0.4026170075,
-0.4202716649,
0.2705571651,
-0.3610903323,
0.4388272166,
-0.0135156205,
0.0217199326,
-0.3839198351,
-0.0962114334,
0.6876603961,
-0.6494477987,
-0.1530255824,
0.1502629369,
0.7606847882,
0.5190618038,
-0.3412343264,
-0.7358736992,
-1.2204698324,
0.5687765479,
-0.6529895067,
0.4680649638,
0.5596525073,
0.5073743463,
-0.1826174855,
-0.7180446386,
-0.4851233065,
-0.0518647991,
-0.262629956,
-0.30150491,
-0.2530820966,
0.4412895143,
-0.031717021,
0.491004467,
-0.2323851734,
0.1844958216,
-0.2498669028,
-0.2056162357,
0.7210050821,
0.1030604914,
0.1772102267,
-0.1134783626,
-0.3881160021,
0.1061181203,
-0.2724063993,
0.2628312111,
0.1588260978,
0.232287243,
-0.4298028052,
0.4357450008,
-0.283457458,
0.4536676705,
-0.0392234884,
0.0481745303,
0.2337950915,
-0.1960163862,
-0.3450998962,
0.0030521257,
0.6746922135,
0.0588247553,
0.0034698446,
-0.0432279669,
0.0290501732,
0.08029522,
0.4645279646,
-0.6717119813,
-0.1635651439,
0.6875396371,
-0.1367057115,
-0.5899648666,
-0.1815522462,
-0.9184111953,
-0.4664971828,
0.1920852363,
0.5967002511,
-0.4643972814,
-0.131596297,
0.2031358778,
0.1148428023,
-0.0142851043,
0.2697309256,
-0.8031345606,
0.3378065526,
0.3989454806,
0.3879126608,
0.1643253565,
0.1142823845,
-0.0520131253,
0.071765177,
-0.5508677363,
0.5000653267,
-0.3210724592,
-0.5320250988,
0.0412290394,
-0.2664249837,
-0.0520419776,
-0.2154195607,
0.7224921584,
0.1126961932,
0.2110749483,
-0.0585633442,
-0.6456673741,
0.0067685288,
0.0498959683,
-0.5718853474,
0.4800018072,
0.4289065897,
-0.8352488875,
0.5646089911,
-0.6644299626,
-0.6352890134,
0.4259812832,
-0.3854340017,
-0.7932928801,
0.1030469537,
0.0715169981,
0.4250080287,
-0.134093821,
0.4456842244,
-0.0350209251,
-0.0082993032,
0.7542849779,
-0.4953222871,
0.3161880076,
0.2893882096,
-0.4941661358,
0.1695769131,
-0.6855220795,
0.2227884233,
-0.0991073698,
0.0745607689,
0.0136635434,
0.070422627,
-0.1202892214,
0.3700416088,
-0.013744398,
-0.2602403164,
-0.2923429012,
-0.674679637,
0.5798467994,
0.3780249059,
0.1439944655,
0.6110761762,
-0.298582375,
0.6093910336,
0.0547020473,
0.5645819306,
0.1920309365,
-0.7807761431,
-0.4731144011,
0.0857733116,
0.1986213923,
0.6497286558,
-0.7757502198,
-0.4627222419,
-0.1718296409,
-0.555883646,
-0.8180149794,
-0.2124401927,
0.5131101012,
0.7233198881,
0.0358060189,
0.1120754853,
-0.5877687931,
-0.8321943879,
-0.0832434371,
-0.8905605078,
0.1222987622,
0.5305225253,
0.5362173319,
-0.2902278602,
0.6130614281,
-0.3888477087,
-0.0409731381,
-0.32722193,
0.602417767,
0.108199656,
0.8095701337,
0.2295860797,
-1.2814617157,
-0.3170905709,
0.3215031326,
-0.8732358813,
0.3195628524,
-0.3318288326,
-0.0935400203,
0.2090227604,
0.1237689331,
-0.748911202,
0.8015713692,
0.5665495992,
-0.1838655174,
0.5705858469,
-0.3344115317,
0.2622739673,
-0.8179504275,
-0.212179929,
0.1175567135,
-0.0965889618,
-1.2482095957,
0.2420679629,
-0.1506505013,
-0.179506138,
-0.7104417086,
0.6472020745,
-0.2684273422,
0.1623042822,
0.0297317952,
-0.4281801581,
-0.0038348427,
0.0233621504,
0.2496804297,
0.9350720644,
0.6633089781,
-0.5316724181,
0.0697717667,
0.6444256306,
-0.1772142947,
0.6827483177,
-0.8030386567,
-0.2510836124,
0.0125506818,
-0.0954711214,
-0.5776975155,
-0.7899691463,
0.4201978445,
-1.0016288757,
0.4857745767,
0.092184484,
0.101879932,
-0.7722074389,
0.2008911967,
0.4250590205,
0.2602116168,
0.1905330271,
0.5996387005,
0.2942254245,
-0.2663196027,
-0.5676514506,
-1.046459198,
0.2726165056,
-0.2744522095,
-0.7264497876,
0.4127464592,
-0.1266054064,
-0.5862825513,
-0.1568534672,
-0.0374565348,
-0.5481288433,
0.4898963273,
0.6573877931,
0.1223687902,
-0.0758420676,
0.5900559425,
-0.0721964762,
-0.2377654612,
0.4072308242,
-0.1472443491,
0.0195899419,
-0.1490225941,
-0.4609827399,
-0.7728583217,
0.8444872499,
0.296807766,
0.0744595006,
1.0211629868,
0.5270754695,
-1.0923554897,
0.0926750749,
-0.2011367381,
-0.1068162695,
-0.3902494907,
0.212813437,
-0.2757688761,
-0.5679994822,
0.5663478971,
0.0006360163,
-0.2347937077,
0.5122125745,
0.4841800034,
-0.5358285904,
1.2038360834,
1.1008594036,
0.1749667823,
-0.1766357422,
-0.1206964776,
0.437330991,
-0.1282795966,
-0.5050407648,
-0.6082338095,
0.1948815286,
-0.5877513885,
-0.5656250715,
0.5264966488,
-0.1378346533,
-0.1412327141,
0.0743798688,
-0.5410901308,
-0.3356967568,
0.4582020342,
0.2323599756,
0.3117967844,
-0.3202202022,
-0.0097331796,
-0.1338485777,
-0.7289940715,
-0.5780413747,
0.5334218144,
0.8746296763,
0.7973983884,
0.1201014966,
0.5086898208,
0.1501266509,
0.2895898819,
-0.5924306512,
-0.0998294875,
0.3707185984,
-0.9399428368,
-0.6046774387,
-0.608399868,
-0.6332265735,
-0.3298715949,
-0.6932522655,
-0.9263805151,
0.350494802,
0.0709387138,
-0.9235239625,
0.2539736629,
-0.6660900116,
0.9290360808,
-0.234141618,
0.04345534,
0.326189816,
-1.0511791706,
-0.0316664465,
-0.243671298,
0.5826433897,
0.0840343982,
-0.0208539423,
0.3680301011,
-0.3771151602,
0.8020043373,
0.4100565612,
0.0440516062,
0.2553250194,
-0.1208461076,
0.4162502587,
0.4050893188,
-0.4352603853,
0.0476959348,
0.2500213981,
-0.5127201676,
-0.3667027354,
0.1521015912,
-0.8211220503,
-0.5868875384,
-0.6150798798,
-0.6052293181,
-0.4877036512,
-0.0406470671,
0.6535637379,
0.2953712344,
-0.2241569906,
-0.3599534035,
0.6997289658,
-0.4715824425,
0.1196960807,
0.0257760175,
-0.0029470925,
-0.1442164779,
0.6403896809,
-0.1627428681,
0.6783655286,
0.4386122823,
0.183419019,
-0.1907917261,
-0.7435529828,
-0.4682032466,
-0.0036406682,
-0.8183720112,
-0.1202826947,
-0.7287365794,
-0.6669586301,
-0.5557310581,
-0.3803673387,
-0.2673200965,
-0.1826858968,
-0.637381196,
-0.4788018167,
0.1996932924,
1.0449593067,
0.0611976162,
0.7174919844,
-0.5809548497,
0.1065866351,
0.0860371962,
0.4692753255,
-0.5606870651,
-0.1542655081,
-0.2161502093,
0.3579378426,
0.080681853,
-1.2028903961,
0.6622701883,
0.2348617315,
0.6788713336,
0.2890553176,
0.3032081723,
0.5406765938,
-0.1729497463,
0.725351274,
0.0122299828,
-1.0843816996,
0.6021638513,
-0.0920479149,
-0.0252688583,
0.5621211529,
0.747235775,
-0.3626925349,
-0.2823981047,
-0.9569535851,
-0.7578650117,
0.2540840805,
0.6101309657,
-0.0097090881,
-0.0162934251,
0.5489938259,
0.1068931818,
0.521541059,
-0.6596286893,
-0.3529792428,
0.1951996982,
-0.1969810873,
-0.0241094418,
-0.4188889265,
-0.2038419992,
-0.2224267274,
0.6420372128,
-0.1192260236,
0.5865727067,
0.4184083641,
0.0446741655,
-0.4591034353,
0.3112322688,
0.7185922265,
0.7937050462,
-0.2885784209,
-0.0308129657,
0.2599876523,
-0.3762103617,
0.1474899799,
0.3868072331,
-0.026926402,
0.1252976954,
0.5624590516,
0.9100279212,
0.3581578434,
-0.5462682247,
0.5019892454,
-0.2422970384,
-0.2502141893,
-0.7138855457,
-0.5675566792,
0.0614244975,
0.0384714156,
0.4826781452,
0.3787356913,
0.3222319782,
-0.5094240308,
0.5432046056,
0.2437544465,
-1.0997797251,
-0.1339849085,
0.9850914478,
0.1769869179,
-0.3494970202,
0.5289807916,
-0.1931482702,
-0.4844280481,
0.8684897423,
0.3278876543,
0.6257417798,
-0.2672754228,
0.6014070511,
0.1215621755,
0.3082295358,
0.2304375619,
0.5009125471,
0.5263291597,
-0.6391850114,
-0.5016000867,
-0.3726138771,
-0.8981764317,
-0.3542167544,
-0.6154971123,
-0.0164220817,
-0.4317599237,
-0.5253728628,
0.3252021074,
0.0097880345,
-0.6132923365,
0.617362082,
0.3974341452,
0.8512094021,
-0.898460865,
0.4729172885,
0.7610972524,
-0.3983538151,
-1.0886294842,
-0.2896463573,
0.0901039019,
-0.5140077472,
0.3779993057,
0.0604231842,
0.3027250171,
-0.4431776404,
-0.2829501033,
-0.723105073,
0.8987353444,
0.2677218914,
0.0380050167,
-0.2119195908,
0.7933831811,
0.6344373226,
-0.46220842,
0.1889178604,
0.330052048,
0.4666362107,
0.258261323,
-1.0786896944,
-0.1593144387,
-0.1608098894,
-0.0512553565,
0.0156501736,
-0.0249252953,
0.9992061853,
-0.5700239539,
-0.4784802496,
0.351156354,
0.7987119555,
-0.3071289659,
0.6663580537,
0.2072256058,
0.288607806,
0.8655801415,
-0.3424811661,
1.3036864996,
-0.0925162137,
0.0718697459,
0.8112249374,
-0.1185625792,
0.7120085955,
0.5054370761,
-0.3431820273,
0.2982384264,
0.690115869,
0.5818809867,
0.08493568,
0.2555035353,
-0.512427032,
-0.1760924906,
-0.5108464956,
-0.4560510218,
0.4219700694,
0.8053103089,
-0.2269894481,
0.1823872775,
0.2563531697,
-0.2600867748,
0.1616061926,
-0.2042773813,
0.6790896654,
0.2051863521,
-0.3590474427,
0.22515212,
-0.1679439247,
0.3235336542,
-0.281260103,
-0.2247281522,
0.2712209821,
0.1914182454,
-0.0812704042,
-0.9803640842,
0.5868185163,
-0.5443590283,
-0.1566663384,
-0.1424236149,
0.6559990048,
-0.3086154461,
-0.9463108182,
0.0736390501,
0.5679327846,
0.049486421,
-0.2113326788,
-0.7384130359,
0.0298258513,
-0.1190501004,
0.2256923169,
0.0834645927,
0.6664777994,
-0.386054635,
1.512152791,
0.293233335,
0.1743709296,
-0.0661471188,
-0.2542437315,
0.6544860005,
-0.4181462824,
-0.4363036752,
-0.5518669486,
0.4915836453,
0.1257633418,
-0.4049644768,
0.1834497154,
-0.0801854804,
0.4227648377,
0.0050798664,
0.7837787271,
0.1361460984,
0.526522696,
-0.0870927274,
0.675205946,
-0.1367133707,
0.1782935411,
-0.4862522483,
0.2069429159,
-0.4140285254,
0.5676681995,
-0.2011855543,
-0.0449785553,
0.5029948354,
0.1834858805,
0.5582930446,
0.243719995,
0.4542317986,
0.1941951662,
0.1480921805,
0.7056338787,
0.6342017651,
-0.5975428224,
0.3523558378,
-1.0996546745,
-0.1559962779,
-0.1779219061,
-0.9733427763,
-0.5583720207,
-0.7253494859,
-0.4198300242,
-0.1671323031,
0.3262104988,
0.6711468101,
0.8919596076,
-0.9145222902,
0.1099910289,
-0.0032649867,
0.3685787618,
-0.2674249411,
-0.1863141954,
-0.0344781578,
-0.0629314929,
-0.4712747335,
-0.1362898201,
0.2621538043,
0.5461949706,
-0.217490688,
-0.0351756848,
-0.2608038187,
0.2241244018,
0.1912686825,
0.3860357106,
-0.512716651,
-0.4237534106,
-0.1052390411,
-0.2889275253,
0.0742386132,
0.1351963282,
-0.6545253396,
0.3626543283,
0.128504768,
0.7939528227,
0.0704712421,
0.1190994158,
1.1873145103,
-0.4725055993,
0.1745191216,
0.6508846879,
0.279936254,
0.5510071516,
-1.244731307,
0.502871573,
-0.0756540969,
-0.4904180467,
-0.6377140284,
0.3521303833,
-0.7158793807,
-0.1363193691,
0.7605628371,
-0.3731383681,
-0.2333410233,
-0.3718230426,
0.0623788536,
0.2453998923,
-0.0671497136,
0.4082344174,
0.6357622743,
-0.0698401034,
-0.3000862598,
-1.2195546627,
0.9037860036,
0.5171270967,
-0.9015415311,
-0.2046827525,
0.0188729186,
-0.1598608345,
0.1995435953,
0.3733514845,
0.0109354435,
0.3105707169,
0.069729194,
0.0618673377,
0.2560299039,
-0.2793256044,
-0.2169763744,
-0.0847512335,
0.2522906363,
-0.0893113315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17505v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17505v3
|
Arrows of Time for Large Language Models
| 2024-01-30T23:46:35 | 2024-06-03T17:35:04 |
Vassilis Papadopoulos, Jérémie Wenger, Clément Hongler
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We study the probabilistic modeling performed by Autoregressive Large
Language Models (LLMs) through the angle of time directionality, addressing a
question first raised in (Shannon, 1951). For large enough models, we
empirically find a time asymmetry in their ability to learn natural language: a
difference in the average log-perplexity when trying to predict the next token
versus when trying to predict the previous one. This difference is at the same
time subtle and very consistent across various modalities (language, model
size, training time, ...). Theoretically, this is surprising: from an
information-theoretic point of view, there should be no such difference. We
provide a theoretical framework to explain how such an asymmetry can appear
from sparsity and computational complexity considerations, and outline a number
of perspectives opened by our results.
|
[
-0.0390486121,
-0.8328681588,
0.6851112247,
0.3060945868,
-0.3571544886,
0.3936007917,
0.1296967268,
-0.6533152461,
0.0678328872,
0.0383734629,
-0.6787800193,
-0.3114903271,
-0.7819247842,
0.0808033645,
-0.7320097089,
0.7114631534,
-0.1201329902,
0.1818230003,
0.2095217556,
-0.1197656095,
0.0120129669,
-0.3464617133,
-1.0190695524,
-0.325628072,
0.6910195351,
0.105766952,
0.9997239113,
1.0111517906,
0.5874009132,
0.2420799285,
0.1533092558,
-0.4606853127,
-0.1766205579,
0.3118817508,
-0.0335127749,
-0.5201717019,
-0.102443926,
0.1970309317,
1.0584822893,
1.0908366442,
-0.1222964302,
0.0529019125,
0.0506709889,
0.9337255955,
-0.3240463138,
0.0482122116,
-0.6021845341,
0.1853983998,
-0.3163899779,
-0.440946877,
-0.0191503409,
-0.2483348101,
0.2856917977,
-0.5064508915,
0.255953908,
0.3562472761,
0.8875514269,
0.0569409616,
-0.4438542426,
-0.4566781223,
-1.053175807,
1.0960382223,
-0.7899103165,
0.5042333603,
0.3363265097,
0.5715348125,
-0.2498863637,
-0.6005422473,
-0.4050548971,
-0.3359021842,
0.3566113412,
-0.3974484205,
-0.2585256398,
-0.0419432074,
0.3721617162,
0.0632223412,
-0.7288288474,
0.3539048433,
-0.201751247,
0.1574829221,
0.8563754559,
0.2366631776,
0.1788115501,
0.0510821082,
-0.3764979541,
0.1943042874,
-1.024289608,
0.1203851625,
0.8963146806,
0.1916700453,
-0.0789362267,
0.6808323264,
-0.0875626132,
0.8039284945,
0.1773017645,
-0.0383622907,
-0.1557136327,
-0.2611051798,
-0.0888704136,
-0.0430717468,
0.7526001334,
-0.0131340483,
0.2383497953,
-0.1745307148,
-0.297791779,
-0.287094295,
-0.1883298308,
-0.609847486,
-0.1428608447,
0.237075761,
-0.4039473832,
-0.2183765173,
-0.0933812037,
-0.4709688127,
-0.5125367045,
-0.4729287624,
0.2250344157,
-0.4874357879,
-0.3542819917,
0.0681618899,
0.1522606313,
0.5064613819,
0.2640860379,
-0.5866373181,
0.15745987,
0.9007050991,
0.8494223952,
-0.1690364182,
-0.4472272098,
-0.4882575274,
0.0091605186,
-0.4835846424,
0.598007679,
-0.9147680998,
-0.2640140653,
0.0889341384,
-0.0929943696,
-0.0433620475,
-0.2737691104,
-0.0038739436,
-0.6579439044,
0.0412067659,
-0.1506287456,
-0.5165382624,
-0.1651359797,
0.0091224369,
-0.4679108858,
0.5235024691,
-0.2290388793,
-0.7325171232,
0.4526235461,
-0.2615793943,
-0.4499120414,
-0.0642316565,
-0.4655024707,
-0.3632400036,
0.1892186254,
-0.2802477181,
0.4354549944,
-0.3285692036,
0.5029169917,
-0.5151295066,
-0.1068382859,
0.8596609831,
-0.6068466306,
1.1715557575,
0.5232846737,
-0.4120719135,
-0.0660566688,
-0.8965517282,
-0.2718423009,
0.1265091896,
-0.4456473589,
-0.3106197417,
0.5828047991,
-0.2749412358,
0.2413110137,
0.1782406271,
-0.5260365009,
0.3230665028,
-0.3001809716,
0.471170038,
0.8465783,
-0.2739427388,
0.4922924638,
-0.2087720782,
0.568207562,
0.187761277,
0.1412615925,
0.2672247291,
-0.393751353,
-0.7544382811,
-0.1353459656,
0.1370695233,
0.328637898,
-0.6581815481,
0.1921932548,
-0.1325765699,
-0.1997750849,
-0.4232457578,
0.3030183613,
0.4959745109,
0.0880256146,
-0.0233400986,
-0.3285471499,
-0.5972984433,
-0.635029614,
-0.5374572873,
-0.4664283097,
-0.104640536,
0.1213369817,
0.4231951535,
-0.0113758212,
0.7828717828,
-0.1931269616,
0.1378967464,
-0.2923108935,
0.6108059883,
0.2455226779,
0.3923357129,
0.3877870142,
-0.6307752132,
-0.5125418901,
-0.106905289,
-0.8402602673,
0.0099840797,
-0.0214452837,
0.1679836363,
0.6782169938,
0.8643144965,
-0.6323890686,
0.4581269026,
0.4290812612,
-0.5830936432,
0.6079949737,
0.0083776591,
-0.2064675242,
-0.8321728706,
-0.0053339684,
0.0185862202,
0.0007828443,
-0.596570313,
-0.1800063998,
-0.3616884351,
0.0248679984,
-0.353772372,
0.7553471327,
-0.7591472268,
-0.3624152243,
-0.1611560285,
0.159088701,
-0.2025036663,
0.2839327157,
0.0663698763,
0.2946620882,
0.6468744278,
-0.7994699478,
0.2617710233,
-0.5447084904,
-0.3286583424,
0.6630363464,
-0.6777387261,
-0.0011634089,
-0.3770864308,
0.015930865,
-1.2104629278,
-0.1172586977,
0.0584283806,
-0.8513855338,
0.6763540506,
-0.2303793132,
-0.2332288921,
-0.2816585898,
-0.3462692201,
0.6287498474,
0.4314698577,
-0.3573491871,
0.6234937906,
0.2087325007,
-0.228318274,
-1.0882979631,
-0.4448431134,
-0.1189411283,
-0.1477939934,
-0.4707027972,
-0.1402757317,
-0.0469378196,
-0.9598335624,
0.1317604929,
0.0381566212,
-0.0107990084,
0.2112052739,
0.1857587248,
0.2220689058,
-0.3943046331,
0.2225275189,
-0.3515931666,
-0.0650591776,
0.2258725464,
-0.4878362417,
0.5607485771,
-0.1054342836,
-0.7568368316,
-0.4534613788,
0.2067401558,
0.4431404173,
0.1059316397,
0.813370049,
0.400574863,
-0.2505310774,
0.1660760939,
-0.7411410213,
0.0060046525,
-0.4210924506,
0.4369388819,
-0.3239246011,
-0.5483262539,
0.7883535028,
0.6388385296,
0.3440308869,
0.4745413065,
0.2626646459,
-0.3844912946,
1.1786625385,
0.5697668791,
-0.181335181,
0.7773319483,
-0.2910724878,
0.3855469823,
-0.6168451309,
-0.325527221,
-0.6548107266,
-0.4474710226,
-0.62749964,
-0.2655829191,
-0.1609389335,
0.1794958115,
-0.4884640276,
-0.0443018489,
0.0125424005,
0.3087044358,
0.498254776,
-0.4088985622,
0.4026259184,
0.1595413238,
0.0166970454,
0.068479076,
-0.6604537368,
-0.2926087379,
1.1640318632,
0.5556214452,
1.1373083591,
0.1343535185,
0.550014019,
-0.0591814853,
-0.0059608617,
-0.8339192867,
0.675073266,
0.0179911368,
-0.6962866187,
-0.6712044477,
-0.4075441658,
-1.4710917473,
-0.1740413308,
-0.0855590701,
-0.6268202662,
0.1501213908,
0.2638007104,
-0.1466983259,
0.5075170398,
-0.3953375816,
0.5273801088,
-0.4231689274,
-0.4638470113,
-0.1948737055,
-0.7708829045,
-0.0704962835,
0.2255447656,
0.2217783034,
-0.3311373889,
-0.1102373675,
0.9127238989,
-0.2795072794,
0.8334198594,
-0.2880702317,
0.0069103241,
0.7859650254,
0.4806363583,
0.6705847383,
-0.0771598518,
0.2012734562,
0.2037154138,
-0.1396996379,
-0.5270804167,
-0.4764881432,
0.657111764,
-0.8986477256,
-0.7200822234,
-0.6565734744,
-0.5821834207,
-0.0073731057,
-0.0571763478,
0.3793358505,
0.6896344423,
-0.1288687736,
0.2120305151,
0.654953599,
-0.2446655333,
0.8439754248,
0.8704606891,
-0.408323288,
0.1225929186,
0.8156537414,
0.6495055556,
0.4854007363,
0.4800162315,
0.1304078549,
-0.4434020817,
-0.7446618676,
-0.0960620269,
0.6193567514,
-0.664883852,
0.1160630137,
-0.4501535594,
-0.4928742945,
-0.4746024013,
-0.2711236477,
-0.4398629367,
-0.6564382911,
-0.3719499409,
-0.0630425215,
0.3487412333,
1.108902216,
0.0707605481,
0.1738512367,
-0.4322374165,
-0.1749801189,
0.4127539098,
0.2716885805,
0.108699657,
-0.8386314511,
-0.1013065949,
0.0056715193,
-0.2376370579,
-0.7078645825,
0.3812196553,
0.075586535,
0.5930811167,
0.6227380037,
-0.2803288102,
0.426071763,
-0.5084600449,
0.7096127272,
0.3284927309,
-0.727655828,
0.1679145396,
-0.5609520674,
0.4347836971,
0.0672590211,
0.7688824534,
-0.434892267,
-0.5040551424,
-0.943279624,
-0.8194236755,
0.2865413725,
-0.0090453913,
-0.2092693001,
0.1611138433,
0.2656614184,
0.2232711762,
0.3158441782,
-0.7731559277,
-0.156082958,
-0.0497771055,
-0.294291079,
-0.2930109799,
-0.5570468903,
-0.0132967457,
-0.1100203022,
0.5451654792,
0.0183832683,
0.5613948703,
-0.0604943261,
-0.1319009662,
-0.2729125917,
0.3658213913,
0.5803561807,
1.1837075949,
-0.1705715209,
0.5134043097,
-0.0649334416,
-0.3813042343,
0.1951660514,
0.0473541431,
-0.0067111063,
0.1279534101,
0.7038811445,
0.8499518633,
0.0858297721,
-0.3384176493,
0.4081560671,
0.1987845451,
-0.0906769261,
-0.6229408979,
-0.2379043996,
0.023036059,
0.4293253124,
0.6589558721,
-0.3209261894,
0.0140662147,
-0.7631543875,
-0.2336869985,
0.9194181561,
-0.2795699239,
-0.7197520733,
0.4097937644,
0.1332960427,
-0.6920220852,
0.5669237375,
-0.3173573911,
-0.1928107291,
0.7847909331,
0.3981435597,
1.1618846655,
-0.4166614115,
0.0562617294,
0.2506369948,
0.1861768812,
-0.129645884,
0.2721659243,
0.1517293751,
-0.5796881914,
-0.3586427271,
-0.7486715913,
-0.1036181748,
0.1652939171,
-0.441670984,
0.2307373285,
-0.5914991498,
-0.2123708129,
-0.0075973254,
0.0463586226,
-0.6065607071,
-0.0819134116,
0.0250755437,
0.6497549415,
-0.8606988788,
0.7609112263,
0.528854847,
-0.1963279098,
-0.7414778471,
-0.0866987258,
0.0911977068,
-0.9472123384,
0.9670842886,
0.0705055743,
-0.5537506342,
-0.2189265043,
-0.8585318923,
-1.0754084587,
1.0333869457,
0.1687437296,
-0.8342952728,
-0.3548290133,
0.0903228447,
0.6479606628,
-0.4802981317,
-0.0340228565,
0.5205310583,
0.024509808,
0.3165601194,
-0.7387576103,
-0.175298214,
0.1244271174,
0.0874271616,
0.2395694852,
-0.3976838589,
1.1258972883,
-0.4836498499,
-0.4925808311,
-0.0683657899,
0.7258710861,
0.0910344422,
0.4421123564,
0.2615951002,
0.1058475152,
0.520829618,
0.0297772493,
1.136590004,
-0.5191841125,
0.2502849698,
0.9546718597,
-0.1654070765,
0.8748028278,
0.831720233,
-0.4942832887,
0.4666912854,
0.4843074381,
0.4318386316,
0.2068680823,
0.1857412606,
-0.2821750641,
-0.2734676898,
0.1440297067,
-0.3127835989,
0.1085607931,
0.3428318202,
-0.3926355243,
-0.0312967151,
-0.2582770586,
0.371987164,
-0.1269095093,
-0.4293241203,
0.5164026618,
0.3633618653,
-0.6925399303,
0.5727869868,
-0.1347425282,
0.454938978,
-0.676063776,
0.1400455534,
-0.1123386398,
0.3522706926,
-0.1231893897,
-1.0577741861,
0.3419239819,
-0.1429021955,
0.0434619673,
-0.0338544399,
0.5330334902,
-0.3996104896,
-0.737945497,
0.3926359415,
0.3686933517,
0.1624102443,
0.3622587621,
-0.7999911904,
0.0961449444,
-0.1218347922,
-0.4399587214,
0.303273499,
0.5955963135,
0.0068016103,
1.27569592,
0.2243668139,
0.1977319717,
0.5268884897,
-0.2390054613,
0.3869452775,
-0.6574787498,
-0.2348421663,
-1.3007278442,
0.2294998616,
0.1725512296,
-0.1920218021,
0.9261754155,
0.3127260506,
0.7353884578,
0.0606654771,
0.5505170226,
0.0021972756,
0.5780119896,
-0.8616034985,
0.3860827684,
-0.5092670321,
0.4964846671,
0.0026056431,
-0.8638966084,
-0.2102547735,
0.7638270259,
-0.6451265812,
0.1125278175,
0.9152570367,
0.6358719468,
0.2695438266,
-0.2339902669,
0.116556786,
0.4607269466,
0.3349409103,
0.5906001925,
0.9701225758,
-0.0565219186,
0.4703897834,
0.1028699428,
-0.1037664339,
-0.4350146353,
-0.9394786954,
-1.0194201469,
-0.7410791516,
-0.460506916,
-0.4640891254,
0.2923324704,
1.0579545498,
0.3099574447,
-0.6650195718,
-0.7893298268,
-0.2445594817,
0.2526776791,
-0.0285588726,
-0.1755924523,
0.2109108567,
-0.3711989522,
-0.4318322837,
-0.0527293496,
0.3008674979,
0.5281486511,
-0.6288127899,
-0.183013469,
-0.5531591177,
0.317666918,
0.5226439238,
0.7312665582,
-0.6554638743,
-0.3676513135,
0.0488855131,
-0.1491346061,
0.0850074813,
0.8812326789,
-0.3923935592,
0.4625437856,
0.5023710132,
0.3185753524,
0.3365785778,
-0.2702244222,
0.7069042325,
-0.612752378,
0.3365375996,
0.1492334753,
0.2970559001,
0.4500673413,
-0.2034951001,
0.4325895011,
0.3921654224,
-0.5389376283,
-0.9075930715,
0.673073411,
-0.594009459,
-0.2585583031,
1.5230190754,
-0.1745055318,
-0.3457291126,
-0.2965164483,
0.1856631339,
0.241976589,
-0.1428853124,
0.738627255,
1.0007992983,
-0.3866761327,
0.1468652636,
-0.5835604668,
0.6447035074,
0.2716547549,
-0.3723524809,
0.0798338354,
0.3736518025,
0.6022570729,
0.0981043875,
0.6486839056,
-0.1263046265,
0.0163804684,
0.0367765129,
-0.3162856996,
0.0720069334,
-0.7458429933,
-0.6694027781,
-0.1605846733,
0.7432079911,
-0.1547682285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01763v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01763v2
|
When Large Language Models Meet Vector Databases: A Survey
| 2024-01-30T23:35:28 | 2024-02-06T01:25:18 |
Zhi Jing, Yongye Su, Yikun Han, Bo Yuan, Haiyun Xu, Chunjiang Liu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This survey explores the synergistic potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) and Vector Databases (VecDBs), a burgeoning but rapidly evolving
research area. With the proliferation of LLMs comes a host of challenges,
including hallucinations, outdated knowledge, prohibitive commercial
application costs, and memory issues. VecDBs emerge as a compelling solution to
these issues by offering an efficient means to store, retrieve, and manage the
high-dimensional vector representations intrinsic to LLM operations. Through
this nuanced review, we delineate the foundational principles of LLMs and
VecDBs and critically analyze their integration's impact on enhancing LLM
functionalities. This discourse extends into a discussion on the speculative
future developments in this domain, aiming to catalyze further research into
optimizing the confluence of LLMs and VecDBs for advanced data handling and
knowledge extraction capabilities.
|
[
-0.6805160642,
-0.6840090752,
0.7867148519,
0.1234171912,
0.0551884547,
0.5089641213,
-0.3647697568,
-0.6284074187,
0.3206346929,
0.7088985443,
-0.3104172051,
-0.4894928038,
-0.6213813424,
-0.0659563094,
-0.7387580872,
0.4619745612,
0.0241952892,
0.0835627466,
-0.6438435316,
-0.1627634317,
-0.604644835,
-1.1283332109,
-0.1671202779,
-0.0649782121,
0.5931164622,
0.2871135175,
0.8123835921,
0.6863371134,
0.6206685901,
0.3069770932,
-0.146495983,
0.1444892883,
-0.7724170685,
0.5434746146,
-0.1783479005,
-0.4545463324,
-0.4393374622,
-0.1776086092,
0.6216454506,
0.8813274503,
-0.1849821806,
-0.0824723691,
-0.1548512131,
0.4542930722,
-0.6782316566,
-0.0628495067,
-0.3881583512,
-0.068457216,
-0.5159951448,
-0.0956844613,
-0.1074772701,
-0.2531565428,
0.2319660485,
-0.1198530421,
-0.1637109369,
0.1242700145,
0.5962506533,
0.0890015364,
-0.4779457152,
-0.2741030455,
-1.06001544,
0.9020618796,
-0.2581526637,
0.7314519882,
0.0798789859,
0.3484216928,
-0.5493811369,
-0.7176775932,
-0.706735611,
0.085646905,
0.2081621587,
-0.0355878919,
-0.3784966171,
-0.1247786656,
0.196901679,
0.6467227936,
-0.3729942143,
0.5266715288,
-0.3906337619,
-0.0230245348,
0.5359781981,
0.4841591418,
0.274377346,
-0.285874337,
-0.5446004272,
0.1220150888,
-0.9330161214,
-0.1103456318,
0.1950770617,
-0.0119099552,
0.0626294538,
0.8252260685,
-0.0217936989,
0.8488115072,
-0.4794119,
0.2100323737,
0.1078559086,
-0.5352493525,
-0.1264592707,
-0.3645298183,
0.7583112717,
0.0990428925,
0.190732792,
-0.3423870802,
-0.3027409613,
-0.0307652075,
0.2685894966,
-0.5547484159,
-0.0828782693,
0.3280607164,
-0.5117843151,
-0.1451848,
0.0091113504,
-0.7725743055,
-0.5219935775,
-0.7539304495,
0.0587085336,
-0.4123472869,
-0.449021101,
0.2851622701,
-0.0776796415,
0.5378990173,
0.2956623137,
-0.8456694484,
0.4272204936,
1.206990242,
0.700696528,
-0.5983216166,
0.055141028,
-0.2530430853,
0.2691025436,
-0.2572640181,
0.8590164781,
-0.7303799987,
-0.794547081,
0.2693223357,
-0.084541142,
0.3936008215,
-0.6745640635,
0.4776415229,
-0.6302580833,
-0.2365958542,
-0.7021877766,
-0.6748691797,
0.0100609642,
0.2091578096,
-0.774335742,
0.9263410568,
0.0893394947,
-0.7045490146,
0.2168444097,
0.102961801,
-0.4676936567,
0.2050761878,
-0.5810748935,
-0.160834223,
0.3405949473,
-0.014838622,
0.7424790859,
-0.8985313773,
0.146647051,
-0.55386132,
-0.0930120945,
0.5100730658,
-0.2731024623,
0.7003753781,
0.2705466151,
0.5048288107,
-0.1056685224,
-0.8230378032,
-0.1254971772,
0.0523222201,
-0.4238573015,
-0.663642168,
0.233216688,
-0.1352465153,
0.1482673883,
0.5158368349,
-0.3807944953,
0.304926306,
-0.1614942253,
0.4706286192,
0.629748702,
-0.2250927985,
0.4396007061,
-0.1829810441,
0.6377545595,
0.0555049963,
0.0200800765,
-0.0046989904,
-0.1089438051,
-0.609064579,
-0.4168270528,
0.2099339217,
0.3690362275,
-0.8531169891,
0.4774898291,
-0.3375717103,
-0.6210762858,
-0.2441593856,
0.2540397346,
-0.1796177775,
0.0637744889,
0.1604367197,
-0.3359387517,
-0.6624108553,
-0.7827425599,
-0.0568130687,
-0.1545221955,
0.1157643646,
0.4101504087,
0.2592350543,
-0.311960727,
1.0398608446,
-0.5410302281,
-0.1889786422,
-0.528434813,
-0.3282706141,
0.2397492677,
0.2582792044,
0.6663951278,
-0.660405159,
-0.1883837134,
0.1431483924,
-0.8958981037,
0.0201402809,
0.2742218077,
-0.1404598951,
0.0540338121,
0.8094673157,
-0.934278965,
0.0189731717,
0.7311276793,
-0.0534594208,
0.6191917658,
-0.2915268242,
-0.1196919009,
-0.9532828927,
-0.2501311302,
-0.2278603166,
-0.1327351928,
-0.6131429076,
-0.2618986368,
0.0758914798,
0.1593068689,
-0.1733536422,
0.397351861,
-0.7271150947,
-0.3752469718,
-0.1404827088,
0.1735453308,
-0.1378010213,
-0.0146971848,
-0.1525669545,
0.6471741796,
0.9736413956,
-0.6689018011,
0.7379946113,
0.3282412887,
-0.4055098295,
0.650942266,
-0.5089013577,
-0.0267715454,
-0.2437389791,
0.0920124352,
-0.9666255713,
-0.1107556745,
0.024814263,
-0.3195330799,
0.4845424592,
0.0980070755,
-0.6499868035,
-0.5291059613,
-0.2700628936,
0.3734324276,
0.5422387719,
-0.6230349541,
0.8671582937,
1.0056426525,
-0.3373313248,
-0.7265121341,
-0.428712517,
0.2782124579,
-0.1388317347,
-0.6693168283,
0.0362115353,
0.2991909385,
-0.4473417699,
0.0962572545,
-0.0314062424,
0.0640837401,
-0.0450437479,
0.0540420711,
0.5255510211,
-0.2105190605,
0.3138609529,
-0.1855467111,
-0.0549986288,
0.3068555892,
-0.5230708718,
0.598223865,
0.1183073893,
-0.1865663379,
0.2497977614,
0.3481919169,
0.5363058448,
-0.5169852972,
0.8324551582,
0.4578438103,
-0.2363687158,
-0.4169846475,
-0.7074732184,
0.0597764365,
-0.4875937402,
0.5806897879,
-0.4137997627,
-1.0720851421,
0.5409226418,
-0.3643813729,
-0.0073570996,
0.2032878846,
0.9128978252,
-0.3503050208,
0.5447600484,
0.8101052046,
-0.2548249066,
0.4541735649,
-0.2818674743,
0.3772337437,
-0.7575008273,
-0.3263379037,
-0.6774747372,
-0.2118704915,
-0.5468367934,
-0.6818848252,
0.152229622,
-0.0384049453,
0.1703000069,
0.2551577687,
-0.147698462,
0.3448612988,
0.3717333376,
-0.4061155021,
0.2577473819,
0.0965185538,
0.0384730734,
-0.0726835206,
-0.7754957676,
-0.4177755117,
1.2488973141,
0.4568561912,
1.0933662653,
0.2706168592,
0.578738451,
-0.0231273901,
0.098452203,
-0.6913524866,
0.7348175049,
-0.439981848,
-0.4343661666,
-0.2348420322,
-0.2937480807,
-0.9218161702,
0.3552039862,
-0.3430944085,
-0.5885779858,
0.4502738714,
-0.0881760791,
-0.107311897,
0.3766144514,
-0.4576617777,
0.662274003,
-0.3645858765,
-0.5491840839,
-0.4539158642,
-0.4375272989,
0.5314488411,
-0.217221573,
0.2814028263,
-0.0231890287,
-0.1073322818,
0.6266659498,
-0.331890583,
0.4884568155,
0.1669605225,
-0.4988386929,
0.3351818621,
0.2117715031,
0.3859267533,
-0.1307964176,
0.1491558552,
0.4740110338,
0.1303283274,
-0.0325753056,
-0.4125653803,
0.9078193307,
-0.7942218781,
-0.628897965,
-0.434335798,
-0.6451000571,
-0.275911957,
0.0526052043,
-0.2587816417,
0.4059243202,
-0.3684854507,
0.4383087456,
0.9036635756,
-0.5474050045,
0.1463998109,
0.4033896029,
-0.4752962589,
-0.109846063,
1.0934348106,
0.1614213139,
0.3934218585,
0.3810389638,
-0.1575075388,
-0.3795730174,
-0.7020742297,
0.241211921,
0.5604115725,
-0.8862479925,
-0.2394794822,
-0.8709260821,
-0.1955343038,
-0.3580046892,
-0.0029865725,
-0.3662197292,
-0.4232975245,
-0.3839037716,
-0.0762281418,
0.5088062882,
0.9263910651,
-0.2853555083,
0.0837985799,
-0.7565893531,
0.4738246799,
0.1234722063,
0.3623832166,
-0.0574129559,
-0.1153067872,
-0.2341775745,
-0.4272932112,
-0.0316030644,
-0.5519029498,
0.3010866046,
-0.2905786932,
0.6048055887,
0.2513838112,
-0.0868069306,
0.392708987,
-0.5984714031,
0.5522025228,
0.0999929011,
-0.6058421135,
-0.0843298212,
-0.2124190181,
-0.1481859833,
0.0191715714,
0.5517299771,
-0.7197853327,
-0.4474833608,
-0.2833762467,
-0.8531151414,
0.4988093376,
-0.0350553617,
0.2911809385,
0.0212782323,
0.0984131023,
0.0908663273,
0.2500981987,
-0.1309768707,
-0.3636951149,
0.3328821361,
-0.1903789788,
-0.0923307464,
-0.5943335295,
0.0055138329,
-0.2106243372,
0.2269849926,
0.3051894903,
0.2023987919,
-0.3277122676,
0.0570412986,
0.1717998534,
0.1715393066,
0.1720833927,
0.6743991971,
0.0317766294,
0.1871587932,
0.0255839098,
-0.5147922039,
0.116582863,
-0.062429253,
0.0527894087,
-0.0751494467,
0.1915764213,
0.5031412244,
0.1016748697,
-0.7952384949,
0.39496696,
-0.1048809141,
-0.0342965387,
-0.5084536672,
0.035782624,
0.4742843509,
0.4529599249,
0.1089475006,
-0.1281434596,
-0.0762904882,
-0.4981569648,
0.1376878768,
0.7541671395,
-0.0517764501,
-0.2581577301,
0.6481539011,
0.1360879093,
-0.0542868674,
0.4028910398,
0.2540035844,
-0.4237166047,
0.4376564324,
0.1405706555,
0.7076886892,
-0.1288591474,
-0.1525345296,
-0.0308959857,
0.2734840512,
-0.0308989212,
0.3736306727,
0.1429465711,
-0.9178957343,
-0.3727874458,
-0.687985599,
-0.391277045,
-0.1006790176,
-0.3478242457,
0.5787987113,
-0.3555399477,
-0.1996349692,
0.054887861,
-0.1197862253,
-0.7565008998,
-0.2041494548,
0.2928512096,
0.8080945015,
-0.4017481506,
1.0565116405,
0.3906772435,
-0.3396850526,
-0.5093715787,
-0.4230851531,
-0.0246548038,
-0.8501304984,
0.9356293678,
-0.4008543491,
-0.0479454771,
0.0355308242,
-0.5164355636,
-1.0539351702,
0.8661020398,
0.3255915642,
-0.6823753715,
-0.0222035237,
0.2990859747,
0.5206130147,
-0.1577208042,
-0.1444570869,
0.9455642104,
0.3361898065,
0.2057318985,
-0.5223562717,
-0.1180401519,
0.1879344434,
0.1419851482,
0.2380750626,
-0.5267569423,
1.099332571,
-0.1154151559,
-0.3535514772,
-0.0141865415,
1.0597425699,
0.0061315768,
-0.3411968648,
0.2007159144,
0.467015475,
0.6813674569,
-0.2040176839,
1.2619931698,
-0.340610534,
0.1444677114,
0.803550005,
-0.6399540305,
0.807974875,
0.6815456152,
-0.3902784288,
0.1829715073,
0.2183648497,
-0.0648337826,
0.1844269335,
0.3708562851,
-0.2682018578,
-0.3980464339,
-0.1067188084,
-0.2789503932,
0.4076316357,
0.7514712811,
0.0892002508,
-0.1709876359,
-0.0314625576,
-0.1285514385,
0.1769726127,
-0.0944245234,
0.6400492787,
0.364359647,
-0.3001206219,
0.4916161895,
-0.1006055996,
0.5415335298,
-0.5722786784,
0.0479404144,
-0.0601672344,
0.2834457755,
-0.0084148785,
-0.9940267205,
0.1214461327,
-0.1353777647,
-0.0563055128,
-0.2871825993,
0.7547142506,
-0.6131635904,
-0.3266672492,
0.4794418216,
0.8519377708,
-0.030246079,
0.4450847208,
-0.2944177091,
0.7358108759,
-0.3404900134,
-0.1025870293,
0.2872094214,
0.9779410958,
0.1075370982,
0.9062844515,
0.5688619018,
0.4658616781,
0.1954964399,
0.0340611748,
1.04807055,
-0.811042726,
-0.2670704424,
-0.6916468143,
0.1359117627,
-0.0791220069,
0.1246272177,
0.83589679,
0.5275063515,
0.8694049716,
0.0653268546,
1.0300904512,
-0.1487610489,
0.7222400904,
-0.5366688967,
0.6040441394,
-0.4189801216,
0.5391666293,
-0.2046872228,
-1.007216692,
-0.2518015504,
0.2980671823,
-0.4032776952,
-0.0888703763,
0.6048388481,
0.707614243,
0.0093209594,
0.0106278472,
0.4149990678,
0.3859332502,
0.6454538703,
0.5558494329,
1.2854295969,
-0.1064095199,
0.2541903257,
0.1584811658,
0.0520292483,
-0.2267435491,
-0.6338778138,
-0.9947229028,
-0.5429017544,
-0.2152457535,
-0.1632047445,
-0.1804881692,
0.70442909,
0.1033760235,
-0.6096758842,
-0.6355935931,
0.2813084126,
0.3393179774,
0.230689019,
-0.1398723871,
0.2845214307,
-0.3772763908,
-0.7812556624,
0.1805369407,
0.4247477949,
0.1980931014,
-0.7804753184,
-0.1162505895,
-0.1097113788,
0.0359703489,
0.7557504773,
0.39036569,
-0.4494232833,
-0.1839071363,
0.1482543945,
-0.3783018589,
-0.1716761291,
1.0618669987,
-0.9623183608,
0.3215481043,
0.741640389,
1.0855736732,
0.3049100935,
-0.2786284685,
0.9579372406,
-0.441521287,
0.1463665813,
0.0267979112,
0.4371705651,
0.2421316653,
-0.0800214782,
0.2619736493,
0.2175546885,
-0.4634604454,
-1.1134728193,
0.2617383897,
-1.0161728859,
-0.3352641463,
1.0489641428,
0.2779045105,
-0.1337436438,
-0.2904290855,
-0.0414558314,
-0.1168868542,
0.0749086887,
0.43961972,
0.8914057016,
0.2102975696,
-0.0866614729,
-0.7735168338,
0.4827780724,
0.1540196836,
-0.6780293584,
0.4987139702,
0.6608016491,
-0.0995410904,
-0.1611434668,
0.4237522185,
-0.218845427,
-0.0196536817,
-0.2608868778,
0.0924643651,
-0.0179768149,
-0.3832799792,
-0.3051347733,
0.2285277098,
0.0495367795,
0.1564806551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17498v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17498v2
|
Improving QA Model Performance with Cartographic Inoculation
| 2024-01-30T23:08:26 | 2024-02-01T20:43:02 |
Allen Chen, Okan Tanrikulu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
QA models are faced with complex and open-ended contextual reasoning
problems, but can often learn well-performing solution heuristics by exploiting
dataset-specific patterns in their training data. These patterns, or "dataset
artifacts", reduce the model's ability to generalize to real-world QA problems.
Utilizing an ElectraSmallDiscriminator model trained for QA, we analyze the
impacts and incidence of dataset artifacts using an adversarial challenge set
designed to confuse models reliant on artifacts for prediction. Extending
existing work on methods for mitigating artifact impacts, we propose
cartographic inoculation, a novel method that fine-tunes models on an optimized
subset of the challenge data to reduce model reliance on dataset artifacts. We
show that by selectively fine-tuning a model on ambiguous adversarial examples
from a challenge set, significant performance improvements can be made on the
full challenge dataset with minimal loss of model generalizability to other
challenging environments and QA datasets.
|
[
-0.3195962608,
-0.5762175322,
0.4666282833,
-0.3294589221,
-0.3730572462,
0.106407024,
0.0239696149,
-0.5000032783,
-0.1974755377,
0.8566989303,
-0.6097362638,
-0.5198319554,
-0.4606084228,
-0.1974018812,
-0.2812165618,
1.0012952089,
0.0220322628,
0.2623601854,
-0.5984080434,
-0.3139487207,
-0.8041484952,
-0.7437337637,
-0.4385361373,
-0.5459108949,
-0.0889103785,
0.5943602324,
0.9891911745,
0.5854403377,
0.7463932633,
0.1764445007,
-0.1866456121,
0.6800094843,
-0.6383094192,
0.1596149653,
0.058833383,
-0.7060472369,
-0.0490309857,
0.0507010296,
0.3106847107,
0.6965072155,
-0.0979480669,
0.4750995338,
0.0562942922,
0.3731861413,
-0.7857953906,
0.1140592471,
-0.5002399683,
-0.0055044098,
-0.1696958542,
-0.2729291916,
-0.5405446291,
-0.4696843922,
0.3853058517,
-1.2258396149,
0.3590180278,
-0.0033859322,
0.9566363096,
0.5237368941,
-0.2347193658,
-0.2199059576,
-0.9112248421,
0.6529218554,
-0.7163449526,
-0.066975221,
0.5001766682,
0.3711749613,
-0.4101028144,
-0.7390390635,
-0.2864959538,
-0.0935257301,
0.0444850512,
-0.1179332435,
-0.2106129676,
0.0408576727,
0.5569266677,
0.1371317059,
-0.4173968434,
0.0512147918,
-0.4430561662,
0.0843973607,
0.576274097,
0.4251137078,
0.370002389,
0.1711864173,
-0.2434576452,
-0.2372992784,
-0.8631358743,
0.1661829352,
0.2845647335,
0.3147985339,
0.2855685055,
0.4370397329,
-0.1799823195,
0.6462641358,
0.2821666598,
0.1611914784,
0.1019544676,
-0.0728508532,
-0.1941766292,
-0.2275635898,
-0.0166043825,
0.306307584,
0.1941678524,
-0.3406074941,
-0.284686327,
0.2600592077,
0.6019418836,
-0.6892003417,
-0.694476068,
0.2479802072,
-0.2306556255,
-0.3532107472,
0.0384029895,
-0.4775563478,
-0.5944027901,
-0.5346076488,
0.6857679486,
-0.5773692131,
0.214728117,
0.2347001433,
-0.1633576304,
-0.011615918,
0.5947762132,
-0.4832947552,
0.2228887975,
0.675393939,
0.7462800145,
0.0213120393,
-0.0892740637,
-0.5256980658,
0.279169172,
-0.4564600885,
0.8860291839,
-0.7637290955,
-0.3694041967,
0.0014682509,
-0.159909144,
0.0627702177,
-0.9445331097,
0.5655404329,
-0.6423237324,
0.100804463,
-0.3769545257,
-0.6155425906,
-0.58037889,
0.3273423314,
-0.9034679532,
1.1389859915,
0.3117968738,
-0.2854741514,
0.7238233089,
-0.5711881518,
-0.2912436128,
0.2910584807,
0.060238272,
-0.8034915924,
0.0818255693,
0.5481188297,
-0.0109949019,
-0.3245631754,
-0.0077986456,
-0.3369839489,
-0.5986006856,
-0.0067524817,
0.0987739861,
0.75697577,
0.044392515,
-0.4188704789,
0.1941304505,
-0.8150458932,
0.1434775889,
0.0379106291,
-0.0694334507,
-0.6336512566,
0.1156477481,
-0.011802691,
0.1825862527,
-0.0972198769,
-0.2674684525,
0.4440393448,
-0.2676912546,
0.2657606304,
0.6900163293,
0.1884102076,
0.5487248898,
-0.6522696018,
0.6659903526,
0.0886969268,
0.6545343399,
0.0757687017,
-0.7556560636,
-0.7270848155,
-0.4461669922,
0.0749661177,
0.4008493125,
-1.0284596682,
-0.086908564,
-0.2270442247,
-0.7026984692,
-0.5380498767,
-0.048309736,
0.3691717386,
0.5242087245,
0.4607646465,
-0.5517792702,
-0.4416627288,
-0.5808756351,
0.0224705096,
-0.0930375233,
-0.1278844923,
0.21795398,
0.6304281354,
0.1005854383,
0.7589129806,
-0.5252859592,
-0.4335658848,
0.1193776056,
0.3305178583,
0.1347145587,
0.6761041284,
0.6508973837,
-0.7893477678,
-0.0593299307,
-0.1896868348,
-0.6734049916,
-0.0202602651,
-0.1165012643,
-0.2500507534,
-0.2015894949,
0.2965594232,
-0.6479275227,
0.6279540658,
0.161875993,
-0.5790631771,
0.531273067,
-0.2336553186,
0.4275095165,
-0.5598611832,
-0.1454129666,
-0.2082172036,
0.0573586412,
-1.0369679928,
0.6077767015,
0.1286861151,
-0.3927039802,
-0.3927974105,
0.1604757905,
-0.3283095062,
0.0354723632,
-0.0619817153,
0.0654312521,
0.452154547,
0.4559223652,
-0.246218279,
0.6096251607,
0.2715523839,
-0.6554442048,
0.3308191299,
0.6515934467,
-0.4057030082,
0.7540071607,
-0.5451545119,
0.4670532644,
-0.1741436273,
0.3019452393,
-0.8478325605,
0.0955656469,
0.3172042966,
-0.036838945,
0.2232060283,
-0.1641740352,
-0.5771428347,
-0.2621808052,
-0.3918100595,
0.84624964,
0.2342071682,
-0.9202646017,
0.5746707916,
0.127123788,
0.5768070817,
-0.2645143867,
-0.6557290554,
-0.0697363988,
-0.5493988991,
-0.7049355507,
0.3917605579,
-0.0907607004,
-0.1326134205,
-0.1950255483,
0.1797118336,
-0.1835630685,
0.2892735302,
0.3084167838,
0.3832383156,
-0.2009859532,
0.2988973558,
-0.3227304518,
0.086186558,
0.0023466134,
-0.5109471083,
0.3378656507,
0.1998896599,
-0.656042099,
-0.4975962937,
0.2818557322,
0.7225049138,
-0.3832057118,
0.4919145107,
0.296218127,
-0.6091411114,
-0.2486307472,
-0.5540441275,
-0.3944860399,
-0.4162498415,
0.4377713203,
-0.3347124755,
-0.2813751698,
0.843452394,
-0.0814185813,
0.1289841235,
0.1335884333,
0.1999201924,
0.0124889202,
1.1996179819,
0.4187738001,
-0.1001555771,
0.4960894585,
-0.6108081937,
0.1404281706,
-0.8416600227,
-0.2673699856,
-0.5022700429,
-0.4198125303,
-0.2887921035,
-0.6960226893,
0.4923935235,
-0.0010373873,
-0.3033930957,
-0.0410407186,
-0.8366045356,
0.3567109704,
0.7602098584,
0.7995554805,
0.366599232,
-0.1202063262,
0.4675456285,
-0.1355517507,
-0.9710692167,
-0.545551002,
1.3986949921,
0.0373115204,
0.5810998678,
0.1147194207,
0.22869578,
0.2703411877,
0.3028764725,
-0.4273418486,
0.1830103844,
-0.266643703,
-0.4525412619,
-0.30969432,
-0.0719380677,
-0.8845734596,
0.079042241,
-0.4220009446,
-0.5989079475,
0.605060339,
0.2213969678,
-0.6162870526,
0.3305051029,
-0.555131793,
0.7584840059,
0.0701519996,
-0.0663905591,
-0.2284521312,
-0.2999717295,
0.1923621744,
0.0282751899,
0.0726027191,
0.0738151595,
0.2131349444,
0.5011529922,
-0.5272495151,
0.776558876,
-0.1628179252,
0.0861258954,
0.3831774592,
0.1524814963,
1.0336469412,
-0.0823869854,
-0.0346233658,
0.1401742399,
-0.0077938149,
-0.703119278,
-0.8698009253,
0.2301918268,
-0.8065541387,
-0.6461416483,
0.0107988138,
-0.8303309083,
-0.1783133298,
-0.3336083591,
0.4933476448,
0.6971767545,
-0.1428882778,
-0.0519728027,
0.9576783776,
0.1051160842,
0.0411311463,
0.3626476526,
0.1317550689,
-0.1605924964,
0.7551788688,
0.3023801446,
0.4799123704,
-0.0095857652,
-0.2005021423,
0.0393143706,
-0.8845339417,
-0.6021546125,
-0.2322917581,
-0.9257733822,
-0.4052122831,
-0.1050290093,
0.0943857729,
-0.1635934114,
-0.239842549,
-0.1148495376,
-0.4081832767,
-0.7274011374,
0.1288017929,
0.4563566744,
0.7922267318,
0.2986860871,
0.3876428008,
-0.3743335903,
0.1789640635,
0.2437289655,
0.0975573435,
-0.1014572233,
-0.8043569922,
-0.4957187474,
0.1082557589,
-0.4689507186,
-0.9214991331,
0.2828764915,
0.2453009188,
0.5288494229,
0.3389038146,
0.1274871677,
0.9745385051,
-0.1596581042,
0.709531188,
-0.3576925993,
-0.840910852,
0.6723818779,
-0.2321530879,
0.4884622097,
0.4255839288,
-0.0636572838,
-0.1622608304,
-0.8169927597,
-0.5993306041,
-0.8623853326,
0.5320162177,
0.2617360353,
-0.2121152729,
0.1753447801,
0.7723163366,
-0.0390474312,
0.0035738612,
-0.291479528,
-0.0463126749,
-0.1409083754,
-0.081489332,
0.0204766821,
-0.1673079282,
-0.5324172378,
-0.3113667965,
0.7738346457,
-0.2536884248,
-0.2305297852,
0.2777342498,
-0.435877651,
-0.2982971668,
-0.2232560962,
0.673545599,
0.7772001028,
-0.0738390312,
-0.1456386149,
0.4501200914,
-0.6250368357,
0.205232814,
0.022928739,
-0.6381361485,
-0.0254498404,
0.3314383924,
0.6070566177,
0.1628774852,
-0.557205379,
0.3409865201,
-0.0381787196,
0.008371341,
-0.1523557305,
-0.1699250638,
-0.5042839646,
0.7322381139,
0.4769940674,
0.0781481266,
0.4409703612,
-0.2341965586,
0.2899003327,
0.6524347663,
-0.4458730817,
-0.0736241117,
0.7581217885,
-0.0725420713,
-0.1834489852,
0.8752189279,
-0.0108940927,
-0.523783803,
1.1609523296,
0.4465424716,
0.7001349926,
-0.3151855469,
0.2602519095,
0.3955849707,
0.5705830455,
-0.1453038454,
0.2413835377,
0.3187331855,
-0.5837039948,
-0.1958290935,
0.0092415912,
-0.4634132981,
0.1319635212,
-0.871188879,
0.3475088477,
-0.3808211982,
-0.2544077337,
-0.3866957426,
0.016178403,
-0.7615615129,
0.3891385794,
0.0101031354,
0.5751367211,
-0.9677744508,
0.5527778268,
0.7752312422,
-0.510964334,
-0.6993471384,
-0.1056530401,
-0.1448536068,
-0.4455486238,
0.5062628984,
-0.0757778436,
0.1540577859,
-0.224578619,
-0.5161623359,
-0.9988969564,
1.2027168274,
0.5935261846,
-0.2855097353,
0.1450294256,
0.091006726,
0.5584881902,
-0.5578733087,
0.2524901032,
0.6266855001,
0.3731118739,
-0.2071857005,
-0.6512755156,
0.2721318603,
-0.198552072,
0.2314181477,
0.2313931733,
-0.4041167796,
0.9110072851,
-0.3146903813,
-0.2546773553,
0.142343685,
0.5383089185,
0.3550419807,
0.3592724502,
0.5639084578,
0.840110302,
1.0780303478,
-0.3173740208,
0.8802807927,
-0.2655603588,
0.3705317676,
1.217258811,
0.0080740266,
0.494598031,
0.555942595,
0.1163022742,
0.4363104999,
0.9560037255,
-0.3896707594,
0.6273413301,
0.3277703226,
-0.3135392368,
-0.2448120713,
-0.3430466354,
-0.4940885603,
0.5528678894,
0.3197531104,
-0.0954473466,
-0.1207556129,
0.3086354136,
-0.207036227,
0.2867124379,
-0.4026291966,
0.622082293,
-0.411360532,
-0.4994339049,
0.6872293353,
-0.5022563934,
0.2744634151,
-0.1979190409,
-0.3746167719,
-0.2047926784,
0.0986593291,
-0.2126633376,
-0.2856382132,
0.0951865241,
-0.5768281817,
-0.3542374969,
0.1532887965,
0.2703357339,
-0.4099946022,
-0.4266905189,
0.0814303085,
0.2680943906,
-0.0933075249,
-0.2119020671,
-0.3456766307,
-0.2697920501,
-0.2329659611,
-0.208239764,
0.1156714633,
0.5298606753,
-0.3457666934,
0.8278164864,
0.5643285513,
0.0844049156,
-0.0357969031,
0.1339290589,
1.0418217182,
-0.2710428238,
-0.5106264949,
-0.5603784323,
0.4709647596,
-0.0249304995,
-0.573420167,
0.4114620686,
0.5200257897,
0.9310022593,
-0.0030430988,
0.5442652702,
0.5225689411,
0.1239022091,
-0.491997987,
0.7069227099,
-0.5271311402,
0.4334190488,
-0.2318881899,
-0.4109161198,
-0.4506409168,
0.2429774702,
-0.3211691976,
-0.1648795754,
0.5401788354,
0.7750029564,
0.0461098738,
0.1018882841,
0.3116732836,
-0.0443379581,
0.3722506166,
0.8351526856,
0.8537777662,
-0.5707532167,
0.6382055879,
-0.7351318002,
-0.3115277588,
-0.2714307606,
-0.5491377115,
-0.8183576465,
-0.7004849911,
-0.4334710836,
-0.5701136589,
0.4398832917,
0.5597655177,
0.8443078399,
-0.921485126,
-0.0739263147,
0.0778947175,
0.1285893321,
-0.561942935,
-0.2002753019,
0.4416483343,
-0.3207058907,
-0.6742410064,
0.1048495173,
0.1553152204,
0.069456324,
-0.1139893681,
0.1873643696,
-0.1620024294,
0.112310566,
0.3692666888,
0.0709379464,
-0.6774815917,
-0.6171811223,
-0.2020480186,
-0.0665000528,
0.3082471192,
0.9347602725,
-0.8034802675,
0.7894738913,
0.1173318401,
0.4374641776,
0.504371345,
-0.0272281021,
0.7878673673,
-0.6049069166,
0.388359189,
0.4834716618,
0.2541360557,
0.2827095091,
-0.9396395683,
0.6591958404,
0.0698595867,
-0.6023203731,
-0.9567601681,
0.3594857752,
-0.4136716425,
-0.3591865003,
0.7000219822,
-0.4007844329,
-0.0358061604,
-0.4113945365,
-0.1552074105,
0.4543151855,
-0.1481023878,
1.3362165689,
0.7079926133,
-0.1146217659,
-0.0314356573,
-0.5742673874,
0.6602327228,
0.7020699382,
-0.9051015377,
-0.1089697182,
0.5875547528,
0.0014451352,
0.1641997695,
0.1096643656,
0.0404083841,
0.8009127378,
-0.1052745357,
0.1894359887,
-0.0797242895,
-0.1360442042,
-0.5007182956,
0.4668062031,
0.1059164703,
-0.4026505649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17477v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17477v1
|
Detecting mental disorder on social media: a ChatGPT-augmented explainable approach
| 2024-01-30T22:22:55 | 2024-01-30T22:22:55 |
Loris Belcastro, Riccardo Cantini, Fabrizio Marozzo, Domenico Talia, Paolo Trunfio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
In the digital era, the prevalence of depressive symptoms expressed on social
media has raised serious concerns, necessitating advanced methodologies for
timely detection. This paper addresses the challenge of interpretable
depression detection by proposing a novel methodology that effectively combines
Large Language Models (LLMs) with eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) and
conversational agents like ChatGPT. In our methodology, explanations are
achieved by integrating BERTweet, a Twitter-specific variant of BERT, into a
novel self-explanatory model, namely BERT-XDD, capable of providing both
classification and explanations via masked attention. The interpretability is
further enhanced using ChatGPT to transform technical explanations into
human-readable commentaries. By introducing an effective and modular approach
for interpretable depression detection, our methodology can contribute to the
development of socially responsible digital platforms, fostering early
intervention and support for mental health challenges under the guidance of
qualified healthcare professionals.
|
[
-0.437010318,
-1.1009209156,
0.8644496799,
0.6010315418,
-0.3837994933,
0.1973956227,
-0.2395755947,
-0.4060391188,
0.6019970179,
-0.14022021,
-1.3436583281,
-0.4797609448,
-0.8580715656,
-0.1584831923,
-0.634519875,
1.1131157875,
0.0028436601,
-0.0107970098,
0.2629909813,
0.370537281,
-0.3060927391,
-0.4030566216,
-1.2977653742,
-0.1764607877,
0.4699311554,
0.2105183601,
0.85994941,
-0.1063095033,
0.6837658882,
0.1517249942,
-0.1349598765,
0.1878214329,
-0.6418076158,
-0.172587052,
-0.1886456907,
-0.1819794625,
-0.6872900724,
-0.3454901576,
0.0609804504,
0.3783087432,
-0.0635489002,
-0.0369502045,
0.2927282155,
0.3379475474,
-0.0725924745,
0.3995820582,
-0.2930856049,
0.2377237678,
0.0346688405,
-0.2123284936,
-0.0277268775,
-0.2886287272,
-0.1321304888,
-0.4183583558,
0.4442530572,
-0.6926220655,
0.6425927877,
0.4637220204,
-0.1928208321,
-0.4425638318,
-0.7989907265,
0.4132086635,
-0.6863099337,
0.0776414573,
0.5100146532,
0.5739247799,
-0.0960070863,
-0.4557298124,
-0.6794210076,
0.4190376699,
0.0435443558,
0.1645088941,
-0.2985825539,
-0.0649714172,
0.1014320776,
0.4473166466,
-0.7475013137,
-0.0695748329,
-0.015206933,
-0.0178151894,
0.7565434575,
-0.0098638143,
0.6172383428,
-0.4354295731,
-0.0757035464,
0.502969265,
-0.0285856239,
-0.0656455904,
-0.0707709789,
0.1569527686,
-0.5053880215,
0.4146099985,
0.1182960048,
0.1711083204,
0.1932367533,
0.0754567161,
-0.1802628338,
0.112615101,
-0.2090975493,
0.2167762667,
0.6158645153,
0.5506243706,
0.2714878619,
0.0517902151,
-0.1986869127,
0.290515691,
0.2151138932,
-0.5620289445,
-0.7205787301,
0.520314455,
-0.7879253626,
-0.2737535536,
-0.390237242,
-0.8468530178,
-0.9832541943,
-0.164667964,
0.4692628086,
-0.6923160553,
-0.7806587815,
0.0662743002,
-0.1706837565,
0.0945617929,
0.4572062194,
-0.8621572852,
0.1136453673,
0.7509061098,
1.2182979584,
-0.0584953539,
0.4188475311,
-0.0617584474,
0.1762603521,
-0.1678714156,
1.0419813395,
-0.1667186171,
-0.1838017106,
0.0922615007,
0.1120058075,
0.1209140122,
0.0009762106,
0.6594455838,
-0.1530453265,
-0.0070887492,
-0.2601039708,
-0.4155829251,
-0.0212795548,
0.3029479384,
-0.486443907,
0.7551570535,
0.3723151088,
-1.03703475,
0.2175223678,
-1.0134288073,
-0.2987826169,
0.3590269387,
0.0666356906,
-0.1980634183,
0.052963689,
0.6175295115,
0.9079141021,
0.0249095373,
0.3660521209,
-0.7513524294,
-0.3730101287,
0.3254096806,
-0.5290045738,
1.0080200434,
0.2421742082,
-0.4154516757,
-0.0202700198,
-0.7571998239,
-0.168843165,
0.327537328,
-0.0072591989,
-0.2191269547,
0.3222346008,
0.1803143024,
0.0409419686,
0.1915029883,
-0.3923284411,
-0.3073877394,
-0.1514692903,
0.7949741483,
0.9358706474,
0.104769133,
-0.1050560996,
-0.1490309834,
0.5651297569,
-0.078419432,
0.4446331263,
-0.0887378007,
-0.6636373401,
-0.2248090357,
-1.0102733374,
-0.1292100698,
0.604567349,
-0.6350185275,
0.5745429397,
-0.2559940815,
-0.3185665607,
-0.6775304079,
-0.0581694245,
-0.0616230182,
0.3257748485,
0.2174011171,
-0.0430234261,
-0.5625954866,
-0.7468740344,
-0.1879310012,
-0.1035661325,
-0.0761490017,
0.1515528709,
0.1093926877,
-0.6577411294,
0.7575431466,
-0.3407123089,
-0.2472627759,
-0.4892860949,
0.3074727058,
0.2384803593,
0.0609810278,
0.3067121208,
-0.7836392522,
-0.6116489768,
0.0118626673,
-0.9072459936,
-0.3427944779,
-0.3843492568,
0.0416445881,
-0.1720566601,
0.2127422243,
-0.7257231474,
0.5593281984,
0.4413237274,
-0.396194905,
0.3766810596,
0.0389385782,
0.0534199141,
-0.9179258347,
-0.286722213,
0.2543133199,
-0.6976541877,
-0.4156182706,
-0.2888858616,
-0.208391428,
-0.4616011083,
-0.030110117,
0.24347803,
-0.205116272,
0.0971730575,
-0.2759468257,
0.4836137593,
-0.1280019581,
0.0998531654,
-0.2723912299,
0.3945804238,
0.7119284272,
-0.1208944321,
0.3326963484,
0.2894276381,
-0.3524163663,
0.8103317022,
-0.5466312766,
-0.2454630435,
-0.3506603837,
0.3265949786,
-1.4469219446,
-0.3327409327,
0.6979361773,
-0.6688955426,
0.0857198387,
0.0557010807,
-0.5498806238,
-0.3984936476,
-0.2240285426,
0.2812653184,
0.361836493,
-0.61202389,
0.3861853182,
0.2160418481,
-0.4608755708,
-0.0201775655,
-0.7353773117,
0.3321400583,
-0.5054734349,
-0.8481063247,
0.5144168139,
-0.0659685656,
-0.3550432324,
0.2145633548,
-0.0226978865,
-0.3066097796,
0.2343216091,
0.1939207762,
0.1118362769,
-0.1619616449,
0.3576836884,
0.1633585244,
-0.1333632469,
0.3385781348,
0.2702006102,
0.5806750655,
0.1665172875,
-0.2419428974,
-0.8962942362,
0.7237049341,
0.3735575378,
0.3737221956,
0.6886674166,
0.899713397,
-0.5241815448,
-0.367312938,
-0.1671946943,
-0.2752040327,
-0.4440819323,
-0.0180558469,
-0.2713292837,
-0.5974524617,
0.7182215452,
-0.0065518394,
-0.346947372,
0.1262663305,
0.6910718679,
-0.3060969412,
1.5904279947,
0.6582758427,
-0.119934015,
0.6717209816,
-0.0592507906,
0.8563818932,
-0.3610098362,
0.1729597449,
0.0424495898,
-0.1064534783,
-0.675660193,
-0.2391878217,
0.2602419853,
-0.0466013551,
-0.1308627874,
0.055946786,
-0.6313054562,
0.2515693605,
0.1813660413,
0.7390598655,
0.2751792371,
-0.1049742252,
0.4762391746,
-0.2534878254,
-0.4801103175,
-0.5582841039,
0.6639694571,
0.4254213274,
0.8371546268,
0.1699060947,
0.7668224573,
1.0412659645,
0.4342570007,
-0.8159826994,
0.3205816746,
-0.146635294,
-0.8151186705,
-0.1878428757,
-0.2655538619,
-0.7298303246,
-0.113649644,
0.0262941141,
-1.0966876745,
0.1501742452,
0.130080983,
-0.4655911028,
0.1685480326,
-0.9807257652,
0.8729563355,
-0.4082011878,
0.0664731637,
-0.4985292256,
-0.5261412859,
0.6685400009,
-0.2963219285,
0.5910087228,
-0.4267649949,
0.2269782722,
0.5489606857,
-0.306576848,
1.2236101627,
-0.2710444629,
-0.3571690917,
0.0909913629,
-0.1650562435,
0.1996631473,
0.2993685305,
0.0672506988,
-0.0505941436,
0.3729496896,
-0.6863610744,
-0.8501684666,
0.6749140024,
-0.910207212,
-0.5499033332,
-0.1141601652,
-0.6363552809,
-0.1566018015,
0.0639820918,
-0.025818307,
0.2713663876,
-0.2631721795,
-0.3279943466,
0.6735590696,
-0.3422856629,
0.2754915357,
0.2214532495,
-0.3974811733,
-0.1901403517,
0.9768410325,
0.0575310886,
-0.0846455395,
0.1706961542,
0.1321299225,
-0.1319834739,
-0.2454712093,
0.1704085618,
0.4450834692,
-0.9055067897,
0.1180299819,
-0.6336458325,
-0.1511951983,
-0.5851506591,
-0.3146794736,
-0.2583752275,
-0.6145508885,
-0.4178863764,
-0.1736454815,
0.4543325603,
0.6537108421,
-0.5747980475,
0.7348644733,
-0.6391772628,
0.919084847,
0.1794891953,
0.5501608849,
0.058474157,
-0.1831218749,
-0.1319425851,
0.3718689978,
-0.2698850632,
-1.1713920832,
0.4121617675,
0.1865685135,
0.3269288242,
1.0807379484,
0.3443349302,
0.8007708788,
0.0566808283,
0.5429412723,
0.2053417116,
-0.9501614571,
0.8110708594,
-0.5587305427,
-0.1375581622,
0.1685101837,
0.8906972408,
-0.7920763493,
-0.3310821652,
-0.6315527558,
-0.7954233289,
0.6074195504,
0.1955961883,
0.275847435,
-0.417707324,
0.3173977137,
0.2488714308,
-0.2688235641,
-0.7840390205,
-0.0631625429,
-0.3066276312,
-0.3759087026,
-0.2040245682,
-0.4027711153,
-0.24391976,
-0.1928745508,
0.733145237,
0.1319579929,
0.8961893916,
0.4046794474,
-0.0983382389,
-0.0882278383,
-0.0283318255,
0.1352778822,
0.8120872974,
-0.6084060073,
0.193833977,
-0.486731559,
-0.0504716374,
-0.0702777952,
0.4979193211,
0.0778241679,
0.3171981573,
0.3774522841,
0.5725333095,
0.0406173095,
-0.7271612883,
0.5404285789,
-0.2634573877,
-0.1731067151,
-0.5738093853,
-0.0602263473,
0.2545248568,
0.7344033718,
0.3304022551,
-0.5219436884,
0.195695892,
-0.706517756,
0.1507599801,
0.5285282135,
-0.7008035779,
-0.6330672503,
0.5674060583,
0.0786814615,
-0.7198358774,
0.3067260385,
-0.3155442476,
-0.4461314976,
0.4287936687,
0.4205766618,
0.9302213192,
-0.1695865691,
0.9133669734,
-0.1801730543,
0.2510074377,
0.072259225,
0.658731401,
-0.2416618168,
-0.8000076413,
-0.3786413074,
-0.1411316395,
-0.3434053361,
0.3208072186,
-0.6669384837,
0.2824794948,
-0.5764154792,
-0.3543247879,
0.621555686,
-0.305757314,
-0.3479386568,
0.2023336142,
0.5073212385,
0.7262008786,
-0.9992554188,
0.4634620547,
0.5634961128,
-0.2122912407,
-0.294226855,
0.4234542251,
0.1994939297,
-1.036306262,
0.2306785583,
0.3392958641,
0.1658842713,
0.1544672996,
-0.5996721387,
-0.5107769966,
0.7319372892,
0.2562791109,
-0.1154190525,
0.0231892988,
0.1338768005,
0.7245669961,
-0.1272805631,
0.3187149167,
0.6141815186,
0.5799953938,
-0.1282838732,
-0.6190025806,
0.0422515944,
-0.3419169784,
-0.2039242834,
0.1522810161,
-0.2852746844,
0.3312340975,
-0.0571089871,
-0.6641737819,
-0.271979183,
0.2166905105,
-0.1045052707,
0.5027084351,
0.4009802639,
0.4865321219,
0.9447283745,
0.2117465883,
1.0873683691,
-0.220562607,
0.5647142529,
0.8378520608,
-0.0471875705,
0.4869244993,
0.3252551854,
-0.2550297081,
0.4901708961,
1.0935288668,
0.0983682647,
0.6545124054,
-0.0255469736,
-0.6876116395,
-0.4745977521,
-0.2027420849,
-0.1760542095,
0.0280895419,
0.6167396307,
-0.4706957638,
-0.7005084753,
0.3476585448,
0.1242095456,
-0.0853375196,
-0.3569179177,
0.5552675724,
0.2486692816,
-0.1679166704,
0.7028269172,
-0.1039443091,
0.4304622114,
-0.2123802304,
0.0881619751,
-0.1393063813,
0.5617589951,
-0.2999681234,
-0.8755162954,
0.6946710348,
0.1116036475,
-0.3846896887,
-0.3839879334,
0.957674861,
-0.0738276988,
-0.791290164,
0.5583068728,
0.7609730959,
0.4311170876,
-0.541642487,
-1.0183186531,
-0.1947154403,
-0.0885678902,
-0.1057574823,
0.2757515907,
0.9526098371,
-0.2349842638,
0.9758634567,
0.4019931555,
0.0003417198,
-0.1781286001,
0.045166485,
0.8509918451,
-0.539103806,
-0.5561931133,
-0.9918165207,
0.4698882699,
-0.1051374748,
0.2183213532,
0.5072188377,
-0.0308450442,
0.1838577986,
0.0301646534,
1.0977414846,
-0.5764318109,
0.8892945051,
0.0105920369,
0.654973805,
-0.463255167,
0.1169512123,
-0.2996785045,
-0.6016603112,
-0.3722380996,
0.7317587137,
-0.513009727,
-0.2166859657,
0.5821800232,
0.7672605515,
-0.1689542383,
0.127017349,
0.200908497,
0.5103562474,
0.526638329,
0.3787264526,
1.0131225586,
0.0545540787,
0.6772940159,
-0.3350645006,
-0.5011827946,
-0.2710216343,
-0.7806850672,
-1.1263598204,
-0.4449691474,
-0.5573073626,
-0.2133492082,
0.317083478,
0.6813778877,
0.4513372481,
-0.6031134725,
0.2795241177,
-0.0965100825,
0.4910674989,
-0.4032039344,
-0.3923569024,
0.4635274708,
-0.2688716948,
-0.3833172917,
-0.0365144797,
0.1293212622,
-0.2168634087,
-0.289427489,
0.2900513411,
-0.1726529747,
0.1022932008,
0.8467103243,
0.0142497225,
-0.6564569473,
-0.2686610818,
-0.240264371,
0.164754644,
0.2710898221,
0.6459230781,
-0.4618967175,
0.2967190742,
0.438923806,
0.5629132986,
0.4730877876,
0.2254102528,
0.4944596887,
-0.214648515,
-0.2983442545,
0.0361955054,
0.1400515139,
0.5239195824,
-0.7946994305,
0.4576703906,
0.2131064683,
-0.5052180886,
-0.7739086747,
-0.0583292656,
-1.1240980625,
-0.4604377747,
0.8321608305,
-0.557392776,
-0.1819862574,
-0.5282537341,
-0.4543713927,
0.4096266031,
-0.4969323575,
1.6014820337,
0.7022351623,
-0.371622026,
-0.5664611459,
-0.7019254565,
0.307903856,
0.0648004189,
-0.6494032741,
0.2388191223,
0.2035443932,
0.0627144575,
-0.21431458,
0.8463625312,
0.0446316265,
0.246243,
-0.3141440153,
0.0548964553,
0.4012016654,
0.3584502041,
-0.2907776237,
-0.1325633079,
-0.3276414275,
-0.0797562376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00075v1
|
D-Nikud: Enhancing Hebrew Diacritization with LSTM and Pretrained Models
| 2024-01-30T22:07:12 | 2024-01-30T22:07:12 |
Adi Rosenthal, Nadav Shaked
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
D-Nikud, a novel approach to Hebrew diacritization that integrates the
strengths of LSTM networks and BERT-based (transformer) pre-trained model.
Inspired by the methodologies employed in Nakdimon, we integrate it with the
TavBERT pre-trained model, our system incorporates advanced architectural
choices and diverse training data. Our experiments showcase state-of-the-art
results on several benchmark datasets, with a particular emphasis on modern
texts and more specified diacritization like gender.
|
[
-0.6251567602,
-0.9277865291,
0.1130696386,
-0.1752554625,
-0.5439960361,
0.4981270134,
-0.152139008,
-0.1811910123,
0.1780900508,
0.4192771912,
-0.5128503442,
-0.9118160605,
-0.8103696108,
0.261374563,
-0.6894740462,
1.163071394,
-0.0781382173,
0.481033802,
0.3865338862,
0.2063906491,
-0.3516334295,
-0.3323024213,
-0.3025098443,
-0.2188620269,
0.7770856023,
0.3976651132,
0.8414548039,
0.4950421154,
0.7910242081,
0.291888237,
-0.1082923859,
-0.0848264694,
-0.485267967,
0.3405355811,
-0.0076625072,
-0.3525935113,
-0.9580639005,
0.0067645186,
0.6640151143,
0.8098496795,
0.0605097562,
0.262362808,
-0.2254731357,
0.9210256338,
-0.6115908027,
-0.2549518943,
-0.2354519367,
0.4025859237,
-0.5079924464,
-0.0791584477,
-0.2828710973,
-0.9580106139,
0.3710301518,
-0.4664729536,
0.530913949,
-0.0187767148,
0.5681506395,
0.3943543434,
-0.4296952486,
-0.0901935399,
-1.1752319336,
0.7688271403,
-0.6656509042,
0.6082618237,
0.7989327312,
0.2052046508,
0.0655134916,
-0.9312983155,
-0.5352148414,
-0.2143681049,
0.0940262303,
0.2560476363,
0.0574047156,
0.2348337471,
0.1859765649,
0.6094727516,
-0.5529959798,
0.5550189018,
-0.5591804385,
0.1715474725,
0.5193890929,
0.1794363856,
0.4067944884,
0.1775904894,
-0.5301632285,
-0.1043729708,
-0.5310999751,
-0.1432887912,
0.5373325348,
0.1658241302,
-0.2146443576,
0.5990377665,
0.022710247,
1.0368119478,
0.1697577685,
-0.0711793974,
0.1609293669,
-0.3355742097,
-0.4237300754,
0.1923148483,
0.4910073876,
0.1690650135,
0.4984070361,
-0.1644877642,
-0.1528111547,
-0.0143431909,
0.8546221256,
-1.0304708481,
-0.5352191925,
0.0866101757,
-0.5216305852,
-0.5990706682,
0.0554227084,
-1.0264137983,
-0.2421773374,
-0.3489812016,
0.450394839,
-0.5945234299,
-0.3690584302,
0.1854728609,
-0.1268113256,
0.2205666602,
0.6330627799,
-1.101370573,
0.5910799503,
0.6185621619,
0.8139553666,
-0.366335094,
-0.2643314302,
0.0125483135,
-0.048667416,
-0.7167165279,
0.5089116693,
-0.427371949,
-0.364061594,
-0.0900606811,
-0.4431711435,
-0.0381276459,
-0.3495429754,
0.4968247712,
-1.0617524385,
-0.0285930894,
-0.056112133,
-0.7416846156,
-0.3821028471,
0.1668837965,
-0.8637225032,
1.1406769753,
0.5360499024,
-1.0946823359,
0.7632858753,
-0.4581343234,
-0.377061218,
0.5015531778,
-0.1542952806,
-0.6839941144,
0.2901014984,
0.1897135973,
0.5044731498,
-0.3003885448,
0.5642895103,
-0.0084461235,
-0.5223276019,
0.1853464097,
-0.4560604393,
0.6400396824,
0.1460140198,
-0.3141693771,
0.1472098827,
-0.7832061052,
-0.0526008308,
0.2374881208,
-0.4371531904,
-0.5392610431,
-0.1206161976,
0.003485909,
-0.2575803399,
0.0952498764,
-0.7038383484,
0.2978714108,
-0.5996248722,
-0.0358947851,
0.720500946,
-0.2498746067,
0.6232354045,
-0.4525769651,
0.8049080968,
-0.0329116099,
0.3445407748,
0.2587803304,
-0.3544382155,
-0.7087520957,
-0.5566430688,
0.5821883678,
0.2710410357,
-0.7689158916,
0.6091321707,
-0.5489798784,
-0.663823247,
-0.6490097642,
-0.0951104239,
0.4044398665,
0.4367799163,
0.4332752824,
-0.6580410004,
-0.3047637939,
-0.8543756604,
0.2689602077,
0.1887156665,
0.5183777809,
-0.307025522,
0.5374938846,
0.1188077107,
1.0670927763,
-0.3584112525,
-0.3133509159,
-0.7229543924,
0.0527876727,
0.3686214089,
0.4666405022,
0.8220689893,
-1.0843257904,
-1.0533668995,
0.0099833971,
-0.3039711416,
-0.0302071534,
0.33840397,
0.0674656779,
-0.3264978528,
0.4202115238,
-0.2655393779,
1.2009906769,
0.4276275635,
-0.1353159845,
0.9236142635,
-0.2010928392,
0.5060291886,
-1.0251034498,
0.002177374,
-0.418295294,
-0.3700838089,
-1.3490285873,
-0.2291184366,
0.0769823492,
0.1140000895,
-0.6461225748,
0.504129827,
-0.2014302611,
-0.1431686133,
-0.4603223801,
0.0492047817,
-0.087934345,
0.1992551088,
-0.1331117153,
1.0694109201,
0.6331311464,
-0.9105262756,
0.7827453017,
0.9331493378,
-0.6452094913,
0.5511297584,
-0.6916773319,
-0.0166418683,
-0.3975159526,
0.1301466376,
-0.9397164583,
-0.1238677353,
0.3192917705,
-0.4090709686,
0.7082790732,
-0.5146217346,
-0.48923406,
-0.594040513,
-0.5665632486,
1.1159828901,
0.4482084215,
-0.455360204,
0.3223303258,
0.0268396419,
-0.2537873089,
-0.8419585228,
-0.7441192269,
0.1313712746,
-0.3966979086,
-0.1270752251,
0.7546397448,
-0.1367716193,
-0.2598449886,
-0.079370454,
0.1184973791,
-0.4978338778,
0.2336814553,
0.0123003712,
0.2563610375,
-0.1575772464,
-0.0161351673,
0.0257475823,
-0.1846187264,
-0.4454502761,
0.0839178339,
1.1505727768,
0.3983840942,
-0.5316678286,
-0.968616426,
0.3098556995,
0.5043073297,
-0.4285669029,
0.6372574568,
1.0624819994,
-0.2327084094,
-0.3222367465,
-0.4617552161,
-0.317669332,
-0.4848369062,
0.6353375316,
-0.2804252803,
-0.6629437208,
0.3385264874,
-0.135220319,
-0.0324513018,
0.1393058747,
0.8333098292,
-0.1930413842,
0.6515348554,
0.5660889745,
-0.1572250873,
0.7788808346,
-0.1717248261,
0.1272465289,
-1.0081175566,
-0.1500761658,
-0.4530341029,
-0.7073346376,
-0.5226151943,
-0.4247252345,
0.3243061006,
0.1255152822,
-0.4398430288,
0.38528651,
-0.458314687,
0.2972770929,
0.9193066359,
0.0734515712,
0.1218636557,
-0.0779253468,
-0.2220776677,
-0.3762685061,
-0.7379899025,
-0.3108328283,
1.3660269976,
0.2278942913,
0.8700026274,
0.2569489777,
0.9186242819,
0.8121194839,
0.4274175465,
-0.8174227476,
0.360748291,
-0.2122243941,
-0.8769004941,
-0.2256237119,
-0.1674616039,
-1.3116254807,
0.0188156012,
-0.1229083389,
-0.7614094019,
0.1008195207,
-0.1254613847,
-0.6239742637,
0.5939288139,
-0.1739934981,
0.5272499919,
-0.2741405666,
0.0389113799,
-0.2240019143,
-0.7111238837,
0.3237664402,
-0.3652157784,
0.1900519729,
-0.3719297945,
0.236252889,
0.9296184778,
-0.4511965811,
1.1093528271,
-0.210859403,
-0.2009562105,
-0.0753234774,
0.3650075197,
0.0778069273,
-0.0211158246,
0.0697234944,
-0.0397758558,
-0.1560488939,
-0.1088085249,
-0.4260227382,
0.4661450684,
-0.9697391391,
-0.5452933311,
-0.5339881778,
-0.6153755188,
0.0036590381,
0.32529971,
0.1471822262,
0.802025497,
-0.5833416581,
-0.0777626857,
0.7439572811,
-0.3589619696,
0.523039937,
0.2940061986,
-0.5943126678,
-0.9720287919,
0.2381510288,
-0.0429552421,
0.3886057436,
0.390273124,
0.1619522721,
-0.2067734301,
-1.0244868994,
-0.6274396777,
0.1782667339,
-0.7924747467,
-0.466906935,
-0.4606103599,
-0.5760238171,
-0.3112321198,
-0.260856688,
-0.6154171228,
-0.3904528916,
-0.4639750421,
-0.2166668028,
0.689874649,
1.1542851925,
0.1214165688,
0.8015096188,
-0.9079647064,
0.5984017849,
0.0193817653,
0.323736757,
0.0809899494,
-0.7410228252,
-0.4116519094,
-0.0860468969,
-0.239130348,
-1.0105475187,
0.4461285472,
0.2989011705,
0.493771255,
0.5034884214,
0.2296082228,
0.5749053955,
-0.9384792447,
0.6880352497,
0.3549523652,
-0.804426074,
0.6217173934,
-0.2772498131,
-0.0122170234,
0.7024846077,
0.5612708926,
-0.4067766666,
-0.2059267461,
-0.215231061,
-0.7198534012,
0.8168040514,
0.1971434951,
0.317817688,
-0.1420034766,
0.5399896502,
0.7059279084,
0.3705023527,
-0.6896082759,
-0.4850571156,
-0.0167846605,
-0.462277025,
0.0380430482,
-0.5268133283,
-0.1919924468,
-0.7230268121,
0.4323442578,
0.4518441856,
0.1988861561,
0.3144575059,
-0.4767805636,
0.2450505048,
0.1068763882,
0.7114768028,
0.7595911622,
-0.2781041563,
0.2453471422,
0.089107357,
-1.1261667013,
0.5754480958,
-0.0611375719,
-0.4946590066,
-0.0668947622,
0.3418884873,
0.8156979084,
0.2491762042,
-0.0198306423,
0.6058384776,
-0.0702504888,
-0.4063221514,
-0.3380004764,
-0.0676704943,
-0.3525774181,
0.3545979559,
0.3453099132,
-0.0520941764,
-0.1785580814,
0.0693522319,
0.2993207574,
0.1338627338,
-0.3899401128,
-0.6947541237,
0.6713861227,
0.189256072,
-0.5210619569,
0.7130053043,
-0.0358032882,
-0.8749606609,
0.3509691656,
0.6191188097,
0.8590852022,
-0.7335134149,
0.4797369242,
0.3079896569,
0.2749213278,
0.0925650299,
0.452824235,
-0.2984271646,
-0.960741818,
-0.4233118892,
-0.9254803658,
-0.1068527699,
-0.1476325691,
-1.0545467138,
0.3166675568,
-0.7144393921,
-0.8087973595,
-0.1585222483,
-0.113593258,
-1.0397238731,
0.355350256,
0.0904789269,
0.7028305531,
-0.6330119967,
1.0071647167,
0.5988781452,
-0.2354443669,
-0.0127913607,
-0.0158382952,
-0.2494221479,
-0.9460937381,
1.0152754784,
0.0266846847,
-0.073833175,
0.5863934159,
0.1194504052,
-1.0237822533,
1.2106302977,
-0.0281294454,
-0.6352466345,
0.0894590318,
0.3680666089,
0.3584990203,
0.0493606031,
0.1220887378,
0.7571448684,
0.6015366316,
-0.3242064416,
-1.1119384766,
-0.2401068062,
0.020823285,
0.1694886088,
0.5038719773,
-0.2909049392,
0.6665999293,
-0.2079274058,
-0.2659639418,
0.2267612368,
0.4834908843,
-0.2316730917,
0.0940271467,
0.2872388363,
0.9193434119,
0.4558680356,
-0.0309164841,
0.83291924,
-0.1892402768,
0.2266174704,
0.9758686423,
-0.3552017212,
0.483702749,
0.4107154012,
-0.5451872945,
0.3948846161,
0.7599051595,
-0.0758110955,
0.9066252112,
0.5077585578,
-0.5268338919,
0.0711455718,
-0.1809064001,
-0.3833624423,
0.8026666045,
0.1649708599,
-0.225486666,
-0.2916598916,
0.3338665366,
-0.0497008599,
0.2087455243,
-0.3886966705,
0.9300230742,
0.0656886175,
-0.0845214278,
0.566896379,
0.1380705535,
0.675301373,
-0.6105878949,
0.301584661,
-0.0393106341,
0.1812821329,
0.1056999117,
-0.4726000428,
0.3486395776,
-0.0331961475,
-0.039868284,
-0.2617864907,
0.7122036815,
-0.3168471754,
-0.6190918088,
0.3664719164,
0.8444045186,
-0.0586487912,
0.3409697413,
-0.5158891082,
0.0797357932,
-0.2216991633,
-0.2445626855,
0.2301962227,
0.1851107031,
0.0907901973,
0.4343686402,
0.507814467,
0.4648595154,
0.1662727594,
0.7977099419,
0.9564245343,
-0.743696928,
-0.3425938487,
-1.2140165567,
0.3503573835,
0.0695562139,
-0.2217593044,
0.74501127,
0.4517623782,
0.7600656152,
-0.2253443599,
0.6585854292,
0.0685335845,
0.4615054727,
-0.4321800768,
1.0249875784,
-0.1698404849,
-0.2501349449,
-0.3371847868,
-1.1782749891,
-0.7876976132,
0.6129367352,
-0.2587083876,
0.2993061543,
0.640492022,
0.390819788,
-0.2716037333,
0.0470973179,
0.6007246375,
-0.0153186396,
0.2088292241,
0.0825314671,
1.2037808895,
-0.2391376942,
-0.1339750737,
-0.4837110341,
-0.3719978631,
-0.175398618,
-0.7277621031,
-1.3277848959,
-0.6940049529,
-0.3646920919,
0.1290758252,
0.0044095498,
1.0460578203,
0.6996902823,
-0.5550165772,
0.0150613636,
-0.0568161234,
-0.2678883672,
-0.0570972264,
-0.1220189705,
0.5644104481,
-0.2823177874,
-0.8911359906,
0.6511773467,
0.2432165742,
0.587479651,
-0.2233254164,
0.121942915,
-0.1276932061,
-0.0981220677,
0.2781497836,
-0.3815610707,
-0.5627468228,
-0.1805181801,
-0.3832006752,
0.2094892561,
0.2634221613,
0.9087376595,
-0.4664318562,
0.5087771416,
0.2152406871,
0.6115992665,
0.8123067617,
0.2632133067,
0.6157054305,
-0.8405691385,
0.3805368245,
0.6482302547,
0.1555803865,
0.3347669542,
-0.0836797282,
0.0658817887,
0.1084303409,
-0.5328993201,
-0.7521240115,
0.6349223852,
-0.751065433,
-0.0509782881,
0.7881755829,
-0.2853437364,
-0.0272778273,
-0.4690329731,
-0.0111556742,
0.4542523921,
0.043327298,
0.8678230047,
0.6002088785,
0.3960483372,
0.0106793176,
-0.8635311127,
0.8423374295,
0.2908770144,
-0.4530912042,
0.2022107095,
0.1189718023,
0.4564369619,
-0.2930094898,
0.7724416256,
-0.2202984542,
0.273504287,
-0.1365535557,
0.2921475172,
-0.183261171,
-0.6531718969,
-0.1895038337,
-0.2173127383,
0.0678566545,
-0.325446099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17464v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17464v2
|
Efficient Tool Use with Chain-of-Abstraction Reasoning
| 2024-01-30T21:53:30 | 2024-02-26T20:26:40 |
Silin Gao, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Ping Yu, Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Ramakanth Pasunuru, Olga Golovneva, Koustuv Sinha, Asli Celikyilmaz, Antoine Bosselut, Tianlu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To achieve faithful reasoning that aligns with human expectations, large
language models (LLMs) need to ground their reasoning to real-world knowledge
(e.g., web facts, math and physical rules). Tools help LLMs access this
external knowledge, but there remains challenges for fine-tuning LLM agents
(e.g., Toolformer) to invoke tools in multi-step reasoning problems, where
inter-connected tool calls require holistic and efficient tool usage planning.
In this work, we propose a new method for LLMs to better leverage tools in
multi-step reasoning. Our method, Chain-of-Abstraction (CoA), trains LLMs to
first decode reasoning chains with abstract placeholders, and then call domain
tools to reify each reasoning chain by filling in specific knowledge. This
planning with abstract chains enables LLMs to learn more general reasoning
strategies, which are robust to shifts of domain knowledge (e.g., math results)
relevant to different reasoning questions. It also allows LLMs to perform
decoding and calling of external tools in parallel, which avoids the inference
delay caused by waiting for tool responses. In mathematical reasoning and Wiki
QA domains, we show that our method consistently outperforms previous
chain-of-thought and tool-augmented baselines on both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution test sets, with an average ~6% absolute QA accuracy
improvement. LLM agents trained with our method also show more efficient tool
use, with inference speed being on average ~1.4x faster than baseline
tool-augmented LLMs.
|
[
-0.5674754381,
-0.6697924733,
0.6696341038,
0.2406456321,
-0.2854052782,
0.3740742207,
0.0278973021,
-0.5325834751,
-0.0891947597,
0.4005641937,
-0.482906878,
-0.5585717559,
-0.3706321716,
0.0609574206,
-0.2708126903,
0.5275691748,
-0.2307771444,
-0.0609847941,
-0.3588713408,
-0.1016676202,
-0.207612291,
-0.5149763823,
-0.6787385345,
-0.6319920421,
0.6445774436,
0.2295452803,
0.8573923707,
0.5768977404,
0.4774249494,
0.3154404461,
0.0446070023,
0.6530492306,
-0.1671002656,
0.0790630654,
-0.3311057985,
-0.3864673972,
-0.736479044,
-0.1531690955,
0.1930411011,
0.6924157739,
-0.2252060771,
0.2290300131,
-0.0763719231,
0.4423560202,
-0.9490554333,
0.1259562671,
-0.6994917989,
-0.1021812186,
0.0402410664,
-0.3939950168,
-0.5819439888,
-0.194120273,
-0.0246200711,
-0.8327254057,
-0.2358911335,
-0.039857503,
0.5961952209,
0.1880085319,
-0.2865162492,
-0.281709522,
-0.6714801192,
0.8313643932,
-0.6295479536,
0.6091475487,
0.498277843,
0.1999088526,
-0.4092023373,
-0.7900563478,
-0.5612309575,
-0.1031751633,
0.0304895919,
-0.0162174646,
-0.0279347207,
0.1410443634,
0.5151821971,
0.1696943492,
-0.217566967,
0.1273965836,
-0.0566050559,
-0.2883443832,
0.6619824171,
0.1287091076,
0.0588491745,
0.4360187054,
-0.3364545703,
-0.2612301111,
-0.7933738232,
-0.111897625,
0.171310395,
0.0627789423,
0.2008039802,
0.4401246607,
-0.1015331894,
0.8645352721,
-0.0542826839,
-0.5930241346,
0.3194950223,
-0.4161644876,
-0.3056773543,
-0.1370899081,
0.4818430543,
0.077165857,
0.3489622176,
-0.092085056,
-0.3288109303,
0.0108453501,
0.2051151395,
-0.77752316,
-0.1266179532,
0.3420803845,
0.0102074156,
-0.0164946094,
-0.1218742654,
-0.2416551262,
-0.2223111093,
-0.3962559402,
0.4377860427,
-0.3821001649,
-0.1239266023,
0.359295249,
-0.2351524234,
0.1393261105,
0.533059597,
-0.2996011078,
0.4990522861,
0.5714651346,
0.9847448468,
-0.0403172038,
-0.3103825748,
-0.940969944,
0.3525699079,
-0.4660954177,
0.8983014226,
-0.4014806747,
-0.2138818055,
0.0047162655,
-0.1305708736,
0.1805956215,
-0.489942193,
0.2024949342,
-0.7846659422,
-0.1353943497,
-0.255337745,
-0.3093644083,
-0.2311032563,
0.3665059507,
-0.7522505522,
1.1098833084,
-0.0172028486,
-0.5756823421,
0.3567093015,
-0.6862438917,
-0.5557717085,
-0.2228616923,
-0.0406426601,
-0.2220376581,
-0.1948934793,
0.4822703898,
0.4779439569,
-0.3218631148,
0.0380626246,
-0.3946118951,
-0.4623105228,
0.0443730019,
-0.2396519035,
0.7783261538,
0.1392157823,
-0.2062267512,
0.1926202029,
-0.663783133,
0.1624984741,
-0.0339827985,
-0.3544688821,
-0.6051285863,
0.0371675491,
-0.432033211,
0.5899027586,
0.096354723,
-0.347252667,
0.37865749,
-0.5896824002,
0.178195253,
0.8563114405,
0.0741796643,
0.4195163846,
-0.2075754851,
0.4727512598,
0.2538101077,
0.0229157005,
-0.1515757293,
-0.2862023413,
-0.8108161688,
-0.2394275665,
0.3780973256,
0.5048729777,
-1.0261437893,
0.7381993532,
-0.0206514262,
-0.4132608771,
-0.4172312319,
0.1662698537,
0.3905516267,
0.1388470381,
0.4147839248,
-0.3879575133,
-0.2801150382,
-0.5953248143,
-0.2213310301,
-0.0874390975,
-0.1140564308,
-0.0620463006,
0.6254799366,
-0.042214863,
0.7275006175,
-0.4641398489,
-0.0591309853,
-0.2741268575,
0.0989929587,
0.0048594419,
0.131995827,
-0.0077896686,
-0.5646824241,
-0.3863633871,
0.0506604724,
-0.6998457909,
-0.0892326608,
-0.3692416847,
-0.4962115884,
0.0783715099,
0.445568949,
-0.4343911111,
0.3529016972,
0.3560303748,
-0.2039333731,
0.6308041811,
-0.1573133022,
-0.2881241739,
-0.800209403,
0.0013181567,
0.0101991398,
-0.4529328644,
-0.4563986063,
0.1475011557,
0.0309620127,
0.2800827026,
-0.5988339186,
0.6844372749,
-0.8383899927,
-0.1646664292,
-0.2811078429,
0.3168641925,
0.0792103633,
0.6657587886,
0.020221835,
0.9872540236,
0.5714879036,
-0.8761351705,
0.1461739093,
0.1440318376,
-0.2697561681,
0.3846150339,
-0.5009665489,
0.4130004644,
0.1260877848,
0.4665123522,
-0.5368264318,
0.2321263701,
0.1529044807,
0.0840720236,
-0.1649981439,
-0.0041721156,
-0.9496250153,
-0.3051900268,
-0.4302982092,
0.3351105154,
0.3149295449,
-0.6818779707,
0.9133886695,
0.2905948758,
0.1537164897,
-0.8255339265,
-0.4713392854,
-0.1479189545,
-0.0958157033,
-0.5595383644,
0.3274683356,
-0.1234059334,
-0.4012553692,
-0.1985040605,
-0.5494654179,
-0.1252555996,
0.1015259326,
0.058632344,
0.1233434454,
0.1078153774,
0.3160882592,
0.3178704679,
-0.1728190333,
0.2415554821,
-0.4157651365,
0.7522646785,
-0.0596347488,
-0.6867995262,
-0.3239733279,
0.159566313,
0.6096760631,
-0.3474042714,
0.6211853027,
0.4212684631,
-0.2565666437,
-0.3985953033,
-0.5871041417,
-0.3770639002,
-0.5007362366,
0.1879266202,
-0.6642475724,
-0.4545554221,
0.3725236356,
-0.6466825604,
0.5045925975,
0.0740682259,
0.5041804314,
0.150436759,
1.0564348698,
0.3591484129,
-0.0203644745,
0.3081181645,
-0.6870706677,
0.2167667001,
-0.9372494817,
-0.0599729009,
-0.2477256209,
-0.2480110824,
-0.0190946497,
-0.7385527492,
0.4155494571,
0.3389867842,
-0.2400086671,
0.2042258084,
-0.2060483247,
0.5956140161,
0.4746789932,
0.1091192365,
0.761857152,
0.1487778723,
-0.465946734,
0.4221622944,
-0.7914102674,
-0.5065125227,
1.0083361864,
0.2649799585,
0.7594782114,
-0.1045826748,
0.6801748872,
0.0716878995,
0.1520619094,
-0.8896778822,
0.7267001271,
0.1652557254,
-0.2523925304,
-0.2778939605,
-0.1548526436,
-0.7765296102,
0.5671688914,
0.0641471744,
-0.486138761,
0.2355817854,
0.2031263858,
-0.1781664342,
0.508241713,
-0.380882591,
0.4064867496,
-0.1988142729,
-0.3538617492,
-0.3849387467,
-0.5818974376,
0.2669643164,
-0.1155815572,
0.2939258218,
-0.0881591514,
-0.1828009784,
0.4964669645,
-0.6582822204,
0.7726027966,
-0.0558123887,
-0.4900562167,
0.4539963305,
0.238822341,
0.9717094898,
-0.0552998707,
-0.1976676434,
0.2233937979,
-0.1260071099,
-0.402066499,
-0.8708851933,
0.4038665295,
-0.5910938382,
-0.5434868932,
-0.4879224002,
-0.7968841791,
-0.3740717471,
0.1614732593,
-0.1773333102,
0.5145633221,
0.1520575434,
-0.2057092041,
0.5121792555,
0.1352710277,
0.4367590547,
0.3810168207,
-0.148395583,
-0.1623994112,
0.7242357135,
0.0043734722,
0.7275961041,
0.3520769775,
0.1183735654,
-0.3862589002,
-0.4584194422,
-0.33912763,
0.2604149878,
-0.9274848104,
-0.2916723788,
-0.6706033945,
-0.241496861,
0.1502286345,
-0.1315710396,
-0.1709684879,
-0.4638362229,
0.1648692191,
-0.0655085519,
0.4132935703,
0.3379047811,
-0.0471499525,
0.2717333436,
-0.5507369041,
0.3853437901,
0.242996186,
0.1652004421,
0.2447988391,
-0.1344127357,
-0.3237245679,
0.0180681143,
-0.500459671,
-0.6014874578,
0.0730071813,
0.0549840145,
0.5023690462,
0.2790397108,
0.1630514711,
1.0672892332,
-0.4408092499,
0.4012970626,
0.081953153,
-0.9165415168,
0.4363945127,
0.0230012741,
0.4534097314,
0.3394590616,
0.5656999946,
-0.2518828809,
-0.6914456487,
-0.503311336,
-0.8932574987,
0.5100656748,
0.2642867267,
-0.2582932711,
0.009156147,
0.0790171027,
0.1730517745,
0.221612528,
-0.4764600396,
-0.1863431484,
0.1533959508,
0.074542433,
0.2954466045,
0.106678836,
-0.2478426695,
-0.3694401383,
0.7265167236,
-0.4244796336,
0.1208835319,
0.1386491209,
-0.3377118707,
0.0042033223,
0.3145717084,
0.2025631964,
1.1935224533,
0.1165020242,
0.4301642478,
0.4655703008,
-0.4626991153,
0.298579216,
-0.1427458078,
0.0209856536,
-0.1276412904,
0.4070847034,
0.4766005576,
0.0999887139,
-0.8256120086,
0.1747132093,
0.2357639074,
-0.2204558998,
-0.2577711642,
0.1205190718,
0.2781856954,
0.2429817319,
0.0412873104,
0.1934955269,
0.1777290255,
-0.5016165972,
0.1800750792,
0.3591552377,
-0.0397050157,
-0.1372138709,
0.1672871709,
0.2510970533,
-0.2562803924,
0.6248947978,
-0.3621175885,
-0.2892214358,
0.3132469058,
0.6988336444,
0.706487298,
-0.0150750903,
0.1608007252,
0.1113062128,
0.1581259817,
-0.300352633,
0.4472360015,
-0.0905987173,
-0.869138062,
-0.8238325715,
-0.5203028917,
-0.2316243351,
0.0446307585,
-0.3694728315,
0.255358547,
-0.5021378398,
-0.0884884372,
-0.1883434057,
-0.0342421979,
-0.7162595391,
-0.0891754329,
-0.2752436399,
1.2027885914,
-0.5000988245,
0.9443585277,
0.6565095186,
-0.383767128,
-0.8686667085,
0.1212820411,
0.0691246614,
-0.784429729,
0.5883456469,
0.055429738,
-0.7205036879,
0.1402541399,
-0.3158714175,
-0.772518158,
1.1915011406,
0.3291536868,
-0.7147650123,
-0.0394971296,
-0.1238238588,
0.3837543726,
-0.3723352253,
0.3775351346,
0.5900225043,
0.4941673279,
0.3691790104,
-0.9128183722,
0.2446859479,
-0.1229593754,
-0.0406540819,
0.4945271909,
-0.3783758581,
0.6700026989,
-0.2918106318,
-0.2302861512,
-0.1872116923,
0.5452039838,
0.8339985609,
0.2186939567,
0.9152568579,
0.5845059156,
0.8277363777,
0.1949154735,
1.0127305984,
-0.1756299287,
0.015120157,
1.0873949528,
-0.3697667718,
0.9424006343,
0.4938386381,
-0.2232381999,
0.9444330335,
0.4538985789,
0.2484440058,
0.3642359376,
0.3624335229,
-0.428855449,
-0.581584692,
-0.0400189348,
-0.136406526,
0.2182672322,
0.3386304379,
0.03354761,
-0.2960645556,
-0.0838034078,
0.1093971133,
-0.0419929586,
-0.2595365047,
0.7759937048,
0.2268019021,
-0.5585318208,
0.6981041431,
-0.0410885029,
0.4785943627,
-0.6713910699,
-0.3311150372,
0.0740760639,
0.2884699106,
-0.2014744431,
-0.7010744214,
0.158118546,
-0.1765162051,
0.0308997128,
-0.1554009318,
0.7325199842,
-0.2890619636,
-0.5298350453,
0.4622680247,
0.7832238078,
0.2050917745,
-0.3370421827,
-0.6993969679,
-0.094690308,
-0.3781097829,
-0.0958613083,
0.2883891463,
0.5172963142,
-0.5225367546,
0.9445530176,
0.8993957043,
0.1529981047,
-0.0655115247,
0.4336256385,
1.1105555296,
-0.6215643287,
-0.5205575228,
-0.9310852885,
0.6481092572,
-0.2784711421,
-0.0050550215,
0.6126893163,
0.5594916344,
0.9941156507,
0.0952137411,
0.7489424944,
0.0535881296,
0.1788211614,
-0.650636375,
0.2442278564,
-0.5422039628,
0.4920741618,
-0.2004680187,
-0.9052227736,
-0.2151180953,
0.7245289087,
-0.1595002115,
0.0435131714,
1.0825601816,
0.6617168784,
-0.2634448111,
-0.2688319683,
0.0999154374,
-0.0040984387,
0.4845735133,
0.5016236305,
0.7674375176,
-0.2725949585,
0.5213535428,
-0.3393951058,
-0.1418809742,
0.1197251156,
-0.8399153352,
-1.077075839,
-0.3518524468,
-0.2817507386,
-0.2563162446,
0.1227811649,
1.0611143112,
0.7129846215,
-0.4564453661,
-0.5948226452,
-0.216610387,
0.3890250027,
-0.8069348931,
-0.1679294258,
0.2721461356,
-0.4886916578,
-0.4771191776,
0.3526098132,
0.3878313303,
-0.2805774212,
-0.5609189272,
-0.2324226946,
-0.4699392915,
0.0868855119,
0.989448905,
-0.0695115626,
-0.9800340533,
-0.1878966987,
0.0059981188,
0.2605412006,
0.1112923771,
1.0254871845,
-0.9956380725,
0.3693996966,
0.4410137832,
0.4050891399,
0.5471989512,
0.0961491168,
0.8058428168,
-0.83842659,
0.1958123595,
0.1809160113,
0.2344206423,
-0.0016071318,
-0.2489150763,
0.704991281,
-0.0181230959,
-0.2905449271,
-0.7678899169,
0.3975462317,
-0.8668530583,
-0.3666541576,
1.0585012436,
-0.1667363495,
-0.0587599836,
-0.5086190104,
-0.3060114682,
0.1319432706,
-0.5663002729,
0.6280655861,
0.6308600307,
-0.3824179173,
-0.1397450417,
-0.3184045255,
0.3876830637,
0.0218480323,
-1.1610399485,
0.1072630882,
0.314637959,
0.1854398102,
0.3613476157,
0.7957943678,
-0.1171738058,
0.227515623,
-0.1205611452,
-0.0231077969,
-0.3343656659,
-0.6474145055,
0.0177681707,
0.0439093485,
0.1515113264,
-0.0722453818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17461v1
|
Synthetic Dialogue Dataset Generation using LLM Agents
| 2024-01-30T21:49:30 | 2024-01-30T21:49:30 |
Yelaman Abdullin, Diego Molla-Aliod, Bahadorreza Ofoghi, John Yearwood, Qingyang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Linear programming (LP) problems are pervasive in real-life applications.
However, despite their apparent simplicity, an untrained user may find it
difficult to determine the linear model of their specific problem. We envisage
the creation of a goal-oriented conversational agent that will engage in
conversation with the user to elicit all information required so that a
subsequent agent can generate the linear model. In this paper, we present an
approach for the generation of sample dialogues that can be used to develop and
train such a conversational agent. Using prompt engineering, we develop two
agents that "talk" to each other, one acting as the conversational agent, and
the other acting as the user. Using a set of text descriptions of linear
problems from NL4Opt available to the user only, the agent and the user engage
in conversation until the agent has retrieved all key information from the
original problem description. We also propose an extrinsic evaluation of the
dialogues by assessing how well the summaries generated by the dialogues match
the original problem descriptions. We conduct human and automatic evaluations,
including an evaluation approach that uses GPT-4 to mimic the human evaluation
metrics. The evaluation results show an overall good quality of the dialogues,
though research is still needed to improve the quality of the GPT-4 evaluation
metrics. The resulting dialogues, including the human annotations of a subset,
are available to the research community. The conversational agent used for the
generation of the dialogues can be used as a baseline.
|
[
-0.2891327143,
-0.546759665,
0.773004353,
0.0619634837,
0.0636224523,
0.3069735765,
-0.1256122738,
-0.2587218881,
0.3111685514,
0.528103292,
-1.0898920298,
-0.3793240786,
0.1431509703,
0.4137800336,
-0.0261999108,
1.1211160421,
0.0943799317,
0.0583763234,
-0.2212371081,
0.093321614,
-0.7450302243,
-0.442896992,
-0.8144970536,
-0.4466532767,
0.2783524096,
0.2506663203,
0.7495543957,
0.3558625281,
0.0315304883,
0.4090867937,
0.2413292974,
0.4656485319,
-0.6936642528,
0.4636179209,
-0.0395801403,
-0.2316320986,
-0.293336004,
0.1365735829,
0.3230828941,
0.5303686857,
0.0482815728,
0.171133101,
0.14427948,
0.1813305467,
0.0260956902,
0.4087533951,
-0.6773526669,
0.2861537635,
0.4195450246,
-0.5819050074,
-0.2616967857,
-0.5364571214,
0.1740452945,
-0.9178283215,
0.1051230952,
-0.0075169322,
0.6768966317,
0.361348629,
-0.1912686527,
-0.8700914979,
-0.879141748,
0.832087338,
-0.9255897999,
-0.0605801195,
0.1611518711,
0.4289813042,
-0.5259899497,
-0.6188130975,
-0.5950632095,
-0.5720399022,
0.0264622513,
0.3164519668,
0.1528345048,
0.2745905221,
0.4146496952,
-0.0424047932,
-0.6929504871,
-0.1381560415,
-0.4395574033,
-0.4129279852,
0.812961936,
0.5294154286,
0.2058065981,
-0.3251316249,
-0.3470671177,
0.1569972485,
-0.4844926,
-0.1011476591,
0.6680048108,
0.5421959162,
0.0988036692,
0.5844751,
-0.1402827054,
0.6588240266,
-0.1450441331,
-0.3509410322,
0.2930001616,
-0.7496097088,
0.0370732397,
-0.145729214,
0.8125032187,
0.6117916107,
0.337967813,
0.0461980104,
-0.5093668699,
-0.0560006052,
0.2113466114,
-0.7251834273,
-0.2000174373,
0.2980283201,
-0.2721987367,
-0.4401398301,
-0.2216168046,
-0.6522940993,
-0.3825105131,
-0.7998853922,
0.2554034889,
-0.3166834712,
-0.022408748,
-0.2715700865,
0.0563886426,
0.3028818369,
0.3316014707,
-0.5896823406,
0.3437769115,
0.5207374692,
0.6459518671,
-0.0266422015,
-0.0284504723,
-0.5176693797,
-0.0840688422,
-0.2092939168,
0.6001209021,
-0.4638769925,
-0.686281383,
0.1419304609,
-0.3945519626,
-0.0179735217,
-0.4978607297,
0.5119755268,
-0.1113005057,
0.3835223913,
-0.2439331412,
-0.5713429451,
0.3063583374,
0.5976340175,
-0.3500967026,
0.994664669,
0.1681514531,
-0.449405551,
-0.1449717432,
-0.7697417736,
0.1444463581,
0.3010025322,
-0.6015468836,
-0.1741469353,
-0.3265925944,
0.1626139432,
0.2138041258,
-0.356146723,
0.2270760238,
0.0511905514,
-0.2394283861,
0.5815591216,
-0.2576757669,
0.4230779111,
0.4067707062,
-0.0282995999,
0.1624988168,
-0.814571023,
0.4096398652,
0.0544946492,
-0.2536275089,
0.1603769511,
0.0036490564,
-0.2006215602,
0.2269804031,
0.2301223576,
-0.5484092832,
0.3172408938,
-0.5295565724,
0.3763132393,
0.8966767788,
0.4478440285,
0.2488947064,
-0.5364424586,
0.8718351126,
-0.4148000479,
0.1811800152,
-0.3820725083,
-0.6500636935,
-0.8678435087,
0.1029740945,
-0.0661297292,
0.8141729236,
-1.1563727856,
0.2383201867,
0.0211932007,
-0.1874224246,
-0.3218262196,
0.2848901451,
0.5110049248,
0.6861380935,
0.0242232848,
-0.0217548609,
-0.7429871559,
-0.8711066842,
0.1764248461,
-0.4401119053,
-0.3048412204,
0.7406755686,
0.2241268903,
-0.1891588569,
1.4281150103,
-0.6407110095,
-0.1283454597,
-0.593798399,
0.2719031274,
0.391877383,
0.3820320964,
0.3803108335,
-0.4327016473,
-0.4168854654,
-0.2544243932,
-0.8686777353,
-0.4807572067,
-0.5014469028,
-0.1554829329,
-0.076057151,
0.4515359104,
-0.6356480122,
0.2077840716,
0.3176631331,
0.0059099756,
0.819988966,
-0.2023617774,
-0.1408123076,
-1.3699723482,
-0.0255703516,
-0.0850609392,
-0.3757404685,
-0.7826901078,
-0.3676651418,
-0.7254912257,
-0.7455840707,
-0.3487249017,
0.542853117,
-0.3477822542,
-0.2341170311,
-0.1278029531,
0.3938434124,
-0.1098838672,
0.7970679998,
-0.0969556794,
0.785100162,
0.0835644305,
-0.4053250551,
0.7589483261,
0.4663665295,
-0.0599858873,
0.4041768014,
-0.8416922688,
0.688485384,
-0.0805930346,
0.3488445282,
-0.887141645,
-0.0554264225,
0.599747777,
-0.5532827377,
-0.070095785,
-0.2084374875,
-0.3274069726,
-0.3307664692,
-0.2610485852,
0.0957939625,
0.467684418,
-0.1272547543,
0.4003691971,
0.1606767327,
-0.5700189471,
-0.4168301821,
-0.0135694044,
0.1760699302,
-0.0092860227,
-0.7584480643,
-0.0219330974,
-0.3970838487,
-0.292879492,
-0.100840129,
0.0481455959,
0.0085727591,
-0.1936229765,
0.2323886007,
0.2975203395,
-0.0557875223,
0.1761394739,
-0.2639613748,
-0.2806584239,
0.1790402383,
-0.3621406555,
0.6226220727,
-0.187882036,
-0.3307898343,
-0.5024187565,
0.4899205565,
0.0064930855,
0.0770034194,
0.1634227782,
0.3664616048,
-0.0796849057,
-0.5111197829,
-0.2813315094,
-0.3685978055,
-0.5345394611,
0.2477746606,
-0.4899826646,
-0.4629605114,
0.4416149259,
-0.2114033401,
0.2484009117,
-0.1589399725,
0.6331968904,
-0.2038374841,
0.8132653832,
0.3337094188,
0.1651201546,
0.3135288656,
-0.4923540652,
0.2019784003,
-0.4925024807,
-0.2435019463,
-0.3677783608,
-0.2947610617,
-0.3399615288,
-0.5307320356,
0.508403182,
-0.3099663556,
-0.0367087908,
0.2901302278,
-0.4678721726,
0.5836369991,
0.4970341027,
0.0253199823,
0.1700799763,
-0.1448844075,
-0.2304855287,
-0.1109328195,
-0.5049489737,
-0.7431882024,
1.0520297289,
0.2673772871,
0.6921728849,
-0.0313122161,
0.8898732662,
0.5240474939,
0.0486376174,
-0.7767004371,
0.8794277906,
0.5215029716,
-0.3031250536,
-0.3452587724,
-0.6779894233,
-0.9779361486,
-0.0440949164,
-0.2174600214,
-0.7933265567,
-0.1469071954,
0.3247379661,
-0.4188676476,
-0.2789973915,
-0.7013760805,
0.8445487618,
-0.3455784917,
-0.1564965993,
0.0939597711,
-0.6883804202,
0.2998811603,
-0.022821825,
0.0654509738,
-0.2587366104,
0.2830200791,
0.48938483,
-0.8019641042,
0.9735420942,
-0.4548212588,
-0.1300518662,
0.6033779383,
0.0692388713,
0.5678761005,
0.3035295904,
-0.1315686405,
-0.3749912083,
-0.0582028925,
-0.1670220941,
-0.8813877702,
0.4244593084,
-0.9123476148,
-0.586319685,
-0.2577448785,
-0.8096317053,
-0.3299462497,
-0.0728111416,
0.0255901292,
0.6215574145,
-0.3074865937,
-0.4044196606,
0.3205170929,
-0.5681129694,
0.331845969,
0.4385951161,
-0.2251920104,
-0.3464630544,
1.1264654398,
-0.2552514076,
0.5048214197,
0.1612719297,
0.1189573854,
-0.3394292891,
-0.4271749854,
-0.4036081433,
0.1888875812,
-0.6733284593,
-0.2478132397,
-0.2696408331,
-0.5120285749,
-0.2752736807,
-0.0626811832,
-0.2284259796,
-0.4501021504,
-0.2204356194,
0.02543642,
0.1007244289,
0.8755582571,
0.0157045629,
0.2758504748,
-0.7273999453,
0.294166714,
0.3827595413,
-0.2355524451,
-0.4708723426,
-0.3407535255,
-0.0654324144,
0.3051284254,
-0.5930900574,
-0.9413330555,
0.7079572082,
0.2788608968,
0.7006912231,
0.2134658545,
0.262216121,
0.3950244188,
-0.4906689525,
0.7574573755,
0.1285019666,
-0.7474634051,
0.7748716474,
-0.4053712189,
-0.0035940108,
0.5321528912,
0.1112352386,
-0.5570231676,
-0.411957562,
-0.3514253795,
-0.6268014908,
0.7959484458,
0.7265025377,
0.2327871323,
0.0965897515,
0.4229924679,
0.0831725448,
0.2118777931,
-0.7261470556,
-0.070445396,
-0.3810838759,
-0.4099045098,
0.0486303605,
-0.1511752903,
-0.2131740749,
0.2376284301,
0.5864936709,
-0.3903748095,
0.443457216,
0.1856885552,
-0.0004113816,
0.2494253069,
0.307310164,
0.6739851832,
0.5777900219,
-0.4041831791,
-0.2022488862,
0.0163498279,
-0.2568235397,
0.3349071741,
0.168417424,
-0.311473459,
0.1793805957,
0.1343978047,
0.8721444607,
-0.0416260771,
-0.9185509682,
0.3063840866,
-0.1839081943,
-0.1597361565,
-0.7306871414,
0.064429082,
0.030305773,
0.2784629762,
0.2491414398,
-0.1097159609,
0.2294314802,
-0.5506356955,
0.1837453544,
0.4616793394,
-0.0763141811,
-0.3359571695,
0.4087462723,
0.7235124707,
-0.8473057151,
0.8489284515,
-0.5937578678,
-0.5469716191,
0.6863336563,
0.6004735827,
0.7218725681,
-0.1409893632,
0.5462682247,
0.408216536,
0.1386753023,
0.3473053575,
0.3726764619,
-0.0514510386,
-1.051192522,
-0.5074743629,
-0.5401217341,
-0.8346652985,
0.3396037519,
-0.3279133141,
0.2130879909,
-0.4208120108,
-0.1884755194,
-0.1125646681,
0.2373709977,
-0.5935912132,
-0.146446228,
0.3303224146,
0.4379175603,
-0.7827705741,
0.6402213573,
0.4333184361,
-0.4990794957,
-0.9666249752,
-0.1523433626,
0.1732706428,
-0.855700314,
0.8101711273,
0.1931588948,
0.099520579,
-0.0320719667,
-0.517095983,
-0.6915812492,
1.095459938,
0.4581247568,
-0.4201371968,
-0.2022072077,
0.6001526117,
0.5271118879,
-0.6490730643,
0.453915894,
0.3942167759,
0.2183833122,
0.4154827595,
-1.0030411482,
-0.006243424,
-0.5617200136,
0.1608900279,
-0.2120024711,
-0.3175905049,
0.7114004493,
-0.1978404373,
-0.1465948671,
0.4044156075,
0.5107397437,
0.5312722921,
0.3330018222,
0.6035885215,
0.039732907,
0.8042401075,
0.0517485552,
0.9132834077,
-0.4334873557,
0.1966003776,
1.4188513756,
-0.5638098717,
0.252769053,
0.2338586748,
-0.1253009439,
0.1961051077,
0.5151621699,
-0.0249122679,
0.2255610228,
0.7128535509,
-0.4479647279,
-0.1212710068,
-0.2638128996,
-0.1337161958,
0.3464111686,
0.4646749496,
-0.2321299613,
-0.3349256516,
-0.0589138269,
-0.1331730634,
0.0854204744,
-0.01250319,
0.8098325133,
0.1072433069,
-0.7431204319,
0.5815131068,
-0.1729206294,
0.1660670936,
-0.6264113784,
-0.3873567581,
-0.4695345163,
0.0650660247,
-0.0867479369,
-0.6031597853,
0.1086752713,
0.0728655905,
0.0756787509,
-0.5387077928,
0.6226086617,
-0.5149849653,
-0.4710118771,
-0.0989038572,
0.6369281411,
0.6711724401,
0.3386702538,
-0.8565270901,
0.1156871244,
0.345597744,
-0.1324780881,
0.0577083491,
0.3482610285,
0.0522252843,
0.8525746465,
0.7659823895,
0.0688505545,
-0.003648994,
0.2713425756,
1.0552505255,
-0.4484504759,
-0.3163407147,
-0.5185759664,
0.4062908888,
-0.3049965799,
-0.2385047823,
0.5541627407,
0.6448796988,
0.3888101578,
-0.0874904618,
1.1079097986,
0.1070569083,
0.673171103,
-0.7163422108,
0.2371739596,
0.0303631425,
0.6884146929,
-0.2470162213,
-1.1402446032,
0.3101681769,
0.7502927184,
0.0174609795,
0.0672247484,
0.3985106945,
1.0869181156,
0.1607872546,
0.0000104169,
0.3240308464,
0.2125145197,
0.8174780607,
0.7958528996,
1.2178558111,
-0.0962288827,
0.8983148336,
-0.024535941,
-0.1619727314,
0.0326385126,
-0.8097060919,
-1.0001722574,
-0.4779399335,
-0.0974046141,
-0.3846398592,
0.1383239925,
1.351170063,
0.6324231029,
-0.6100998521,
-0.4073976874,
-0.1548263431,
-0.066052258,
0.238142848,
-0.2420759797,
-0.0015298098,
-0.7432835102,
-0.8956851959,
0.7524790764,
-0.0053887521,
0.1079173908,
-0.4580720663,
-0.4274554849,
0.2534127831,
0.2584021091,
0.3554772735,
0.5270670056,
-0.4539917111,
-0.3406889737,
0.0742032155,
0.0612162538,
0.0008901874,
0.9801514745,
-0.8868573904,
0.50088346,
0.2320270538,
0.5019627213,
0.552598238,
0.2959295809,
1.0788525343,
-1.1478286982,
0.2379968017,
0.5212365985,
0.1278995574,
0.3905872405,
-0.2671794891,
0.5331561565,
0.2278543562,
-0.7288217545,
-0.7753977776,
0.5193334818,
-1.1364833117,
0.1410508752,
1.2892930508,
-0.1961383522,
0.2841905355,
-0.3340814412,
-0.7451508045,
0.0660613179,
-0.6842005253,
0.5176475644,
0.3010159135,
-0.5474024415,
-0.1742657274,
-0.7188956141,
0.6136098504,
0.0827630088,
-0.9649758935,
-0.1418955028,
0.6635713577,
0.0631595403,
0.207063362,
0.952270329,
0.3920527995,
-0.222864002,
0.0321337394,
0.1683629155,
-0.2514829934,
0.0213572662,
0.1278474927,
-0.0472439975,
0.0760497898,
-0.2268906385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17435v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17435v3
|
Can Large Language Models Replace Economic Choice Prediction Labs?
| 2024-01-30T20:49:47 | 2024-03-07T16:47:00 |
Eilam Shapira, Omer Madmon, Roi Reichart, Moshe Tennenholtz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.HC
|
Economic choice prediction is an essential challenging task, often
constrained by the difficulties in acquiring human choice data. Indeed,
experimental economics studies had focused mostly on simple choice settings.
The AI community has recently contributed to that effort in two ways:
considering whether LLMs can substitute for humans in the above-mentioned
simple choice prediction settings, and the study through ML lens of more
elaborated but still rigorous experimental economics settings, employing
incomplete information, repetitive play, and natural language communication,
notably language-based persuasion games. This leaves us with a major
inspiration: can LLMs be used to fully simulate the economic environment and
generate data for efficient human choice prediction, substituting for the
elaborated economic lab studies? We pioneer the study of this subject,
demonstrating its feasibility. In particular, we show that a model trained
solely on LLM-generated data can effectively predict human behavior in a
language-based persuasion game, and can even outperform models trained on
actual human data.
|
[
-0.2364234328,
-0.8496467471,
0.882756412,
0.1064749286,
0.0866479352,
0.0424781442,
-0.573584497,
-0.6792452931,
0.1748636961,
0.7421606183,
-0.5065813661,
-0.1184130684,
-0.2576566041,
0.2494565845,
-0.2202012688,
0.6056251526,
0.1507932991,
0.538003087,
-0.4801763892,
0.0706697181,
-0.0476277545,
-0.5503067374,
-1.1402057409,
-0.9170854092,
0.5949217081,
0.2483284324,
0.7597970963,
0.6137544513,
0.1794719994,
0.3907499015,
0.0184691399,
0.0055499217,
-0.4792617261,
-0.1373721659,
-0.0840834379,
-0.6668335795,
-0.2238564342,
0.4244407415,
0.4068306684,
0.7967402935,
-0.4213935137,
0.0068028397,
0.1429542899,
0.7488589883,
-0.1265424341,
0.3166539669,
-0.9412142634,
0.1192621142,
0.0372963548,
-0.2093251199,
-0.7965488434,
-0.1510067582,
0.069363825,
-0.5561650991,
-0.0082838256,
0.5124636292,
0.5504571795,
0.1230182201,
-0.5327148438,
-0.2693768144,
-0.9845824838,
0.8704528213,
-0.4764349461,
0.2520079017,
0.4434399605,
0.2533355355,
-0.570017159,
-0.444732517,
-0.5027531385,
-0.4856501222,
0.0167323519,
0.2849307358,
-0.3850423992,
0.3025636673,
0.3374743164,
-0.083799392,
-0.0898768008,
0.3669618368,
-0.5570051074,
0.0236557759,
0.7340926528,
0.2840952575,
0.3581418991,
-0.0687903091,
-0.3420588374,
-0.1912715584,
-0.9247503877,
0.1864169687,
0.5581202507,
0.3084239662,
0.1702239662,
0.7232666016,
-0.1929854006,
0.6091842055,
0.0311846659,
-0.1527159065,
0.0051938435,
0.1790258884,
-0.4967427254,
0.0910676196,
0.7403701544,
0.3746796548,
0.377826035,
0.0183700081,
-0.3457591236,
-0.0840499401,
0.077630803,
-0.3678966463,
-0.238860026,
0.1790298671,
-0.5049984455,
-0.4354630709,
-0.3604332805,
-0.8975925446,
-0.6597730517,
-0.434016645,
0.3510547578,
-0.0192991272,
0.0448093824,
0.2146185189,
-0.1897723377,
0.2060493529,
0.3912012279,
-0.7732043266,
0.4487665594,
0.4829442799,
0.6981729865,
-0.1595541835,
-0.4243955612,
-0.5065998435,
0.1939861476,
-0.5319831967,
0.8001992106,
-0.5434803367,
-0.5623989105,
-0.0375026725,
-0.3394309878,
0.2661203742,
-0.7688345313,
0.0030412164,
-0.6160479188,
0.2289011031,
-0.1926924735,
-0.8163126111,
0.14889431,
0.3936626017,
-0.8909894228,
0.6530745029,
-0.1133306995,
-0.4825894833,
0.413623631,
-0.7092530727,
-0.4136401713,
-0.041909039,
-0.0865757316,
-0.4343630075,
-0.032807257,
-0.0574482903,
0.2160744071,
-0.3335267603,
0.5513189435,
-0.6033924818,
-0.370539099,
0.7839971781,
-0.7328116894,
0.8590556979,
0.0176931191,
-0.3572286963,
-0.1681779027,
-0.5931204557,
-0.2499222159,
0.1533307582,
-0.5823202729,
-0.1907204688,
0.4169514179,
-0.0218501035,
0.1225598305,
0.2165124118,
-0.5519909263,
0.1385840476,
-0.3421672285,
0.3951719701,
1.158475399,
-0.2833555341,
0.6533895135,
-0.5133579969,
0.7016732097,
-0.5211294889,
0.0421857163,
0.3242489398,
-0.6364586949,
-0.6714736819,
-0.271651119,
0.3341420293,
0.5633009672,
-0.5893819928,
-0.0534404702,
0.1454813927,
-0.3499376178,
-0.2591629922,
-0.0129438601,
-0.0729800239,
0.5051640272,
0.1970294118,
0.2464444339,
-1.0507626534,
-0.8020433784,
-0.502210021,
-0.3734819293,
-0.1170183569,
0.586887002,
0.2855273485,
-0.166503489,
1.1472767591,
-0.3713777959,
-0.2051355094,
-0.6704774499,
0.0152419191,
0.352619499,
0.188569203,
0.3433582187,
-0.6037018299,
-0.3345727324,
-0.165713191,
-0.3683859408,
-0.0980411246,
-0.2756545842,
0.0122625073,
0.2521505356,
0.3373152614,
-0.5011655688,
0.302257508,
0.5281485915,
-0.2305888981,
0.7509150505,
-0.509655118,
-0.0138999373,
-0.7774412632,
-0.1969489455,
0.1334808618,
-0.2250005007,
-0.5895506144,
-0.3772166669,
-0.1164787337,
-0.0118623404,
-0.5848382115,
1.0072522163,
-0.2466728389,
-0.2590176165,
-0.3364669085,
-0.0072461911,
-0.1662038416,
0.1428936571,
0.3306392133,
0.9326108098,
0.4886058271,
-0.6270831823,
0.3069033623,
0.2065659016,
-0.6308888197,
0.1986048669,
-0.617087841,
-0.1526142508,
-0.2127702087,
0.6249787807,
-0.7997472882,
-0.5248776674,
0.0514779389,
-0.2224268466,
-0.123205401,
0.0584778339,
-0.4380700588,
-0.3290195167,
-0.0920237452,
-0.0576165468,
0.9753249884,
-0.5703080297,
0.5632589459,
0.3294014037,
-0.2887400985,
-0.4492881894,
-0.7695274949,
0.2396443486,
-0.4084258378,
-0.2327429801,
-0.0343751684,
-0.2224798352,
-0.6342372298,
-0.2501391768,
0.4175324142,
0.1506773829,
0.2936402261,
0.0013119212,
0.7670563459,
0.0799920186,
0.2231250256,
-0.1594229192,
-0.1231657863,
0.3587538302,
-0.227558136,
0.3619311154,
0.2591871321,
-0.3494891524,
-0.1397851408,
0.0899785683,
0.4323295355,
0.1050994545,
0.5598563552,
-0.0419907719,
-0.3674376905,
-0.219948411,
-0.665301919,
-0.0448302291,
-0.5594724417,
0.4361108541,
0.0766837448,
-0.8591310978,
0.2773886323,
-0.2224943787,
0.0114233028,
0.3556781709,
0.6073637009,
-0.5307391882,
1.4626134634,
0.5463855267,
-0.1687705368,
0.469966501,
0.0409634113,
0.174659729,
-0.4632768333,
-0.1496843845,
-0.3432681859,
-0.4944668412,
-0.4380989969,
-0.2200164348,
0.5432113409,
-0.2568320334,
-0.3964244723,
-0.2909191549,
0.062118981,
0.8656542301,
0.6640034914,
0.2736206055,
0.1686575413,
0.2343126535,
0.0514847897,
-0.054045599,
-0.5538033843,
-0.7722622752,
1.3463504314,
0.1008879542,
0.6384317279,
-0.2028974742,
0.797747314,
0.3856186271,
0.7886513472,
-0.8368342519,
0.7131556869,
-0.0798594654,
-0.5615876317,
-0.4758237898,
-0.5499356985,
-1.1045504808,
0.1429230571,
-0.3966807723,
-0.880012095,
-0.0955153853,
0.2668773532,
-0.5081691742,
0.6516954899,
-0.5165634155,
0.6081187129,
-0.4738655984,
-0.3746136427,
-0.3893951774,
-0.1632762998,
0.2895282209,
-0.135474503,
0.6329077482,
-0.1232545823,
0.081323415,
0.9322890043,
-0.178814128,
0.9767726064,
0.0186963994,
0.0104952846,
0.2998076677,
0.0651995838,
0.6237877011,
0.09529192,
-0.5184678435,
-0.244483307,
-0.4511793554,
-0.3928160965,
-0.4973835349,
0.6075068712,
-0.8092386723,
-0.9610639215,
-0.3584241569,
-0.6890900135,
-0.5444125533,
0.0113863917,
0.0693850741,
0.1351669133,
-0.5938514471,
-0.0399402231,
0.5269284844,
-0.2212094814,
0.3710017502,
0.3622177541,
-0.2439241856,
-0.4650651515,
0.7940194011,
-0.0480623096,
0.160632953,
0.2057552189,
0.5841257572,
-0.5197947621,
-0.2933011651,
-0.3285121024,
0.181364432,
-0.576759696,
-0.0995875746,
-0.4540745914,
0.0813090131,
-0.0560811237,
-0.5735898614,
-0.2194339186,
-0.0719503909,
-0.5336721539,
-0.5041653514,
0.2027962655,
1.1716413498,
-0.2537759244,
0.1187229976,
-0.5676611066,
0.0494535528,
0.6013541222,
0.3979737163,
0.128584981,
-0.0333931781,
-0.0804544613,
0.4306281209,
0.0004447205,
-0.7770230174,
0.5993232727,
-0.1521027386,
0.4731245339,
0.3746041059,
-0.0490811504,
0.6360619664,
-0.6071529388,
0.875680387,
0.3199161887,
-0.7914759517,
0.203537941,
-0.2180310637,
-0.0531729534,
0.3611968756,
0.1812993288,
-0.4855798483,
-0.379858166,
-0.732128799,
-0.5924899578,
0.8032787442,
-0.0126240803,
0.1702757627,
-0.0865326151,
0.1354339868,
0.4277327955,
0.264208138,
-0.8606728315,
-0.2145392299,
0.2364323437,
0.0152721172,
-0.4923062027,
-0.2360685319,
-0.0399241522,
-0.2448391616,
0.7333885431,
0.1412531286,
0.0610516444,
-0.0546035767,
0.2282880992,
-0.3883079588,
0.4087389112,
0.2693265975,
0.6083807945,
-0.1119617298,
0.1795978993,
0.2943708003,
0.1105544195,
0.4691363573,
-0.0252693761,
-0.3538393676,
-0.1877155453,
-0.0933280736,
0.6655723453,
0.1324785799,
-1.3332179785,
0.1993584484,
-0.0439577214,
-0.4753252566,
-0.7353285551,
0.0487865023,
0.2761885226,
0.590538919,
0.3961949944,
0.0535744168,
0.1939915419,
-0.8548462391,
0.1161704957,
0.6820673943,
-0.2795526683,
-0.0715607777,
0.9592930079,
0.2533119023,
-0.492634356,
0.7775141001,
-0.2204405069,
-0.4745922387,
1.0116602182,
0.7982201576,
0.5856394172,
0.1139285937,
0.4894970357,
0.1508548707,
0.1528963745,
-0.6190232038,
0.1836875379,
0.4327424169,
-0.8877010345,
-0.4482879341,
-0.4805006087,
-0.7992090583,
0.3977870345,
-0.3667023778,
0.2097673267,
-0.4139835835,
-0.0607374795,
-0.2012214661,
-0.0532437786,
-0.8100788593,
0.2568295002,
0.5672039986,
0.8304768205,
-0.8382027149,
0.7002459764,
0.9383789897,
-0.0514735691,
-0.5691366792,
-0.3114453256,
-0.0988310277,
-0.7102879882,
0.5778132677,
-0.0058869952,
-0.1627740711,
-0.0784235299,
-0.9375154972,
-0.8466511369,
1.0753694773,
0.4206767976,
-0.4944633842,
0.0627845675,
0.1990241855,
0.3773916364,
-0.6295462251,
0.2941901982,
0.6574782729,
0.803788662,
-0.0058650412,
-0.6176089048,
-0.3023219407,
-0.0017124264,
-0.1356527656,
0.0061916648,
-0.5492439866,
0.9291997552,
-0.4368297756,
-0.0509143546,
0.1867032796,
0.7593607903,
0.5364077687,
0.5501312613,
0.7351923585,
0.1095896959,
0.9918017387,
0.1362039894,
1.0809986591,
-0.3241735995,
0.4217828214,
0.8847976923,
-0.8225586414,
0.9849082828,
0.4964277148,
-0.480789274,
0.3108762503,
0.7641938329,
-0.0039858241,
0.2616889477,
0.3644112945,
-0.2140078247,
-0.7602294683,
0.061855983,
0.0670283884,
0.4649711251,
0.4483323097,
-0.077563338,
0.0063033034,
-0.0377075076,
0.006475728,
0.0857853368,
-0.4504603446,
0.6286144257,
-0.0396820679,
-0.6050582528,
0.0153743001,
0.0573596433,
0.6713472009,
-0.6175088286,
-0.1174652949,
-0.1947672814,
0.0778719112,
0.1174294576,
-0.6746631265,
-0.1229698211,
-0.0388888717,
0.0407728292,
-0.5536014438,
0.7773739696,
-0.5234505534,
-0.6904042959,
0.1645514816,
0.76111871,
0.0882336646,
0.0553426966,
-0.4969607592,
-0.3949342966,
0.2052027583,
-0.5095810294,
0.734544754,
0.1458239406,
0.2625876069,
0.8943577409,
0.6870729327,
0.1962307394,
-0.2568043172,
-0.1496964693,
0.5108510852,
-0.8377735615,
-0.6235573888,
-1.0126743317,
0.0926813185,
-0.1825635582,
0.0792816952,
0.4056649506,
0.6662375331,
0.8263638616,
-0.2957712114,
1.3718589544,
0.3301030099,
0.2582363784,
-0.6679877043,
0.6952868104,
-0.5414014459,
0.1959289759,
0.012759231,
-0.7868739367,
-0.1397698373,
0.3759696484,
-0.3812167048,
0.0442314334,
0.5096495152,
0.6171348691,
0.0169063359,
0.0859441832,
0.4953598976,
0.2994192839,
0.1334958375,
0.389775306,
1.079028368,
0.3916410506,
0.6784809232,
-0.160259515,
-0.2465490401,
-0.3467925191,
-0.8542408347,
-0.8932489753,
-0.3411355913,
-0.1588150561,
-0.3189748526,
0.0560034476,
1.38494277,
0.0991863981,
-0.4243653715,
-0.8146890998,
0.0550071634,
0.2741980851,
-0.2708049119,
-0.1918064058,
0.1119772643,
-0.1671336889,
-0.9988051057,
0.5811909437,
0.2578998208,
0.2775886357,
-0.45850721,
-0.2145284712,
-0.0247892905,
0.5746157169,
0.5981151462,
0.2763225138,
-0.8094025254,
-0.232187435,
0.1240857914,
-0.0595383756,
0.1871649474,
1.0595234632,
-0.9264379144,
0.267485857,
0.1854191273,
0.4624930024,
0.1169985309,
-0.1654061526,
0.8858783841,
-0.2375780642,
0.1086725071,
0.1150654778,
0.8142281771,
0.1472441554,
-0.222568512,
0.4083630145,
-0.0026545054,
-0.4481048584,
-0.5595590472,
0.3078258932,
-0.6180151701,
-0.3544591963,
1.4430980682,
0.1398780197,
-0.5662256479,
-0.0877948701,
-0.4438159466,
0.0684139356,
-0.6029910445,
1.0336947441,
0.8191971779,
-0.2687242627,
-0.0607122071,
-0.6808661819,
0.3536422551,
0.3684502244,
-0.6951331496,
0.1268632114,
0.6156013012,
0.1650167406,
-0.2215234488,
0.9270132184,
0.3392130733,
0.1984959841,
-0.1616806239,
0.1433490068,
0.0222465023,
0.0278258752,
-0.1953559667,
0.1516566873,
0.3286184967,
0.2765284479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00070v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00070v1
|
EvoMerge: Neuroevolution for Large Language Models
| 2024-01-30T19:37:21 | 2024-01-30T19:37:21 |
Yushu Jiang
|
cs.NE
|
cs.NE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Extensive fine-tuning on Large Language Models does not always yield better
results. Oftentimes, models tend to get better at imitating one form of data
without gaining greater reasoning ability and may even end up losing some
intelligence. Here I introduce EvoMerge, a systematic approach to large
language model training and merging. Leveraging model merging for weight
crossover and fine-tuning for weight mutation, EvoMerge establishes an
evolutionary process aimed at pushing models beyond the limits of conventional
fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.6568744183,
-0.9757038355,
0.3520442843,
-0.276974231,
0.0697353482,
0.1462139338,
-0.5813369751,
-0.6657543778,
0.2467541248,
0.4783637524,
-0.656022191,
-0.1205737144,
-0.4914254248,
-0.118559204,
-0.5850204229,
1.0906549692,
0.0808265954,
0.3056837618,
-0.1268989146,
-0.2664196193,
-0.2538811266,
-0.3495095372,
-1.1284962893,
-0.948246479,
0.3867540061,
0.3778291047,
0.5656098723,
0.3552810848,
0.3015063405,
0.2738505006,
-0.2473044544,
0.3232413232,
-0.6834739447,
0.2247703075,
-0.3607976735,
-0.5517071486,
-0.6152495742,
-0.1871733069,
0.1900683641,
0.872107327,
-0.4759571254,
0.1139461398,
0.0953475013,
0.5508038998,
-0.4119513035,
-0.4616702199,
-0.4677845538,
0.0450827964,
-0.1438252479,
-0.2863217294,
-0.3648082018,
-0.523462534,
0.0959038809,
-0.4478069246,
0.2678374648,
0.33183074,
0.8265090585,
0.1770555973,
-0.2781997621,
-0.2641172409,
-0.9099714756,
0.7562205195,
-1.011294961,
0.2418613136,
0.4460601807,
0.255931437,
-0.313811928,
-0.8167009354,
-0.5743947625,
-0.4099527299,
0.1652580202,
-0.301240623,
-0.3622071147,
0.4037659764,
0.4875496328,
0.3112439513,
-0.6967619061,
0.5134652853,
-0.4139118493,
-0.0013069228,
0.6886781454,
0.1153098941,
0.7473599911,
0.3753035367,
0.2174256295,
-0.3908228278,
-0.7422087193,
-0.0699123219,
0.7416965365,
0.1585850269,
0.0725729764,
0.5675927401,
-0.1923054457,
0.711769104,
0.4092688859,
0.4169831276,
0.2845930755,
-0.0745439306,
-0.4707444906,
0.5036088228,
0.5631324649,
0.2452916652,
0.2954933643,
-0.060933318,
-0.1753308028,
-0.3650503755,
0.2488999665,
-0.8585416675,
-0.3479284644,
0.5017823577,
-0.4686062336,
-0.2183240056,
-0.4951704144,
-1.0695291758,
-0.2726305425,
-0.5304321051,
0.5738316774,
-0.7542468905,
-0.3752260804,
0.3838305473,
-0.3668792546,
-0.0013730213,
0.4617018402,
-1.2675238848,
0.3935632408,
0.7344500422,
0.9191125035,
0.080943808,
-0.5321924686,
-0.6905515194,
-0.1757040918,
-0.4650660157,
0.761482358,
-0.4505237639,
-0.1110854074,
0.0725826621,
0.0479836352,
0.0896797106,
-0.3945064247,
0.5104033947,
-0.4909745455,
0.1220377684,
0.0536948964,
-0.7278932333,
-0.5140384436,
0.1339041293,
-0.7322593927,
0.8837137222,
0.2705211341,
-0.3546846509,
0.7560123205,
-0.6001871824,
-0.4875091016,
0.3021897078,
0.3237628937,
-0.3381131291,
0.2345504463,
0.1433319449,
0.3660288453,
-0.6257296205,
0.2766304016,
-0.5475773811,
0.0650128052,
-0.2434559166,
0.0972694159,
0.8402448893,
0.3576842248,
-0.3198378086,
0.353140533,
-0.6645424366,
0.1870992184,
0.0668037087,
-0.0428439789,
-0.7612656951,
0.026213821,
0.292809993,
0.1128573939,
0.188373819,
-0.5256145597,
0.5843330026,
-0.5850111246,
1.1219513416,
0.39646703,
-0.2137438059,
0.9238420725,
-0.4257448018,
0.5992391109,
-0.5772493482,
0.172692433,
0.2053752542,
-0.3686738908,
-0.829272151,
0.1123350784,
0.2936914563,
0.2141052186,
-0.5517991185,
0.6000518203,
-0.2911328673,
-0.8002009988,
-0.3335475624,
0.1918505579,
-0.0143498015,
0.0941146016,
0.4430447221,
0.123212561,
-0.445620507,
-1.0481687784,
-0.3031272292,
0.2148486376,
0.0175749455,
-0.2229796797,
0.712159276,
-0.1450552344,
0.4663238227,
0.0335043743,
0.0439150892,
-0.5903186202,
0.5965185165,
0.2569103837,
0.8486142159,
0.7968059778,
-0.6373082399,
-0.186437279,
0.5097830892,
-0.3750799298,
-0.076501891,
-0.2564246953,
-0.0978790075,
-0.245212093,
0.8906463385,
-0.6358398795,
0.0358363539,
0.7397912741,
-0.2633354664,
0.3560191989,
-0.3845629692,
0.3056578934,
-0.9354566336,
0.0845016241,
-0.1910385191,
-0.2344375104,
-0.8532404304,
0.3325893879,
0.1273554116,
-0.0432417281,
-0.1389287859,
0.4276469052,
-0.5979939699,
0.0834376663,
-0.279040426,
-0.2131616324,
-0.3188327253,
0.0240644868,
-0.4635205567,
0.4784028232,
0.5209148526,
-0.6768891215,
0.7955297232,
0.2024519444,
-0.2764173448,
0.6088969111,
-0.6840146184,
0.20639503,
-0.1243540421,
0.0367449559,
-0.8503113985,
-0.4986590445,
-0.4596615136,
-0.4426602721,
0.6507585645,
-0.224910304,
-0.3908996582,
-0.6237187982,
-0.174399972,
0.5174428225,
0.7333684564,
-0.8067783713,
0.9167320728,
0.1065295711,
-0.2541179061,
-0.1943413913,
-0.8278627992,
0.2716168463,
-0.4289371967,
-0.7284769416,
0.3962736428,
-0.1039678156,
-0.1925107092,
-0.014778534,
0.387601018,
0.1129199415,
-0.1849987656,
-0.1820426732,
-0.2460012585,
-0.1794395745,
0.4579099119,
0.3030405641,
0.2576429546,
-0.1761540323,
-0.4344923198,
1.1889480352,
0.1276959777,
-0.2797501087,
-0.0843926817,
0.3294942081,
0.8574181199,
-0.2794601321,
0.4944398403,
0.5166018009,
-0.4088955224,
-0.6906309128,
-0.5995012522,
-0.3860857487,
-0.4843112826,
0.6783664227,
-0.2292976677,
-1.0439383984,
0.5115910769,
-0.3914313018,
0.3472507,
0.5810649395,
0.5394451022,
0.1135016456,
1.3694009781,
0.9388226867,
0.1792848706,
0.5480119586,
-0.0965791494,
0.3258250952,
-0.7506077886,
-0.1979904473,
-0.6072626114,
-0.7343894839,
-0.5708986521,
-0.0895327032,
-0.0778617933,
0.1796110719,
-0.3525833786,
0.5641897321,
-0.6693574786,
0.3320849538,
0.5764770508,
0.0764652565,
0.0909148231,
0.2679442465,
0.0820280537,
-0.0723574981,
-0.9151403904,
0.0045182118,
0.9866507053,
0.0925669372,
0.9188446999,
-0.0434973985,
0.6595239639,
0.0752597973,
0.0624059364,
-0.8880685568,
0.3773053885,
-0.2293537259,
-0.4773415029,
-0.4290559888,
-0.5177761316,
-1.1297076941,
-0.2054759711,
-0.4026085138,
-0.8768751025,
0.4295602739,
0.0745388642,
-0.4144085348,
0.513540566,
-0.4838254452,
0.4901035726,
-0.3958634138,
-0.340944916,
-0.8422304392,
-0.2569534779,
0.6316577792,
-0.2205599844,
0.1765867472,
-0.0330495574,
0.1670311838,
0.7593134642,
-0.4807493389,
0.338513732,
0.3493689597,
-0.0401968658,
-0.0850580111,
0.5252832174,
0.7174840569,
-0.4457569718,
-0.009427472,
-0.0058531426,
-0.2919586003,
-0.2865816355,
-0.5834179521,
0.780806005,
-0.5010121465,
-0.3148062825,
-0.0247761756,
-0.5994929671,
-0.1648063958,
0.2007278651,
0.6245700121,
0.54449296,
-0.1267726272,
0.1856111586,
0.7959320545,
-0.4207445085,
0.586191833,
0.2457788438,
-0.4404722452,
-0.6117579341,
0.5483222008,
0.2332035899,
0.5012743473,
0.131050691,
0.1171407998,
-0.1658198535,
-0.6152197123,
-0.2582425475,
0.1143032238,
-0.6670366526,
-0.0221087355,
-0.7875926495,
-0.2069094181,
-0.4514898658,
-0.4994879663,
-0.5209271908,
-0.4008785784,
0.0897197798,
-0.0276644267,
0.8703783751,
0.9367647171,
-0.3987424672,
0.4487024844,
-0.7059060931,
0.0062313494,
0.4812373221,
0.2126446664,
0.0305143986,
-0.8218583465,
-0.187386483,
-0.1100142524,
0.034578383,
-0.8083762527,
0.7517715693,
0.531422019,
0.7373384237,
0.3264873028,
-0.4053734541,
0.7685590386,
-0.4739891291,
0.6790949702,
0.5977354646,
-1.0056262016,
0.7387102246,
-0.4807930887,
0.2812571228,
0.459197253,
0.3334447145,
-0.642321527,
-0.2449971884,
-0.7806534171,
-1.2333087921,
0.4137080014,
0.0482622683,
0.1898417771,
0.3861201108,
0.3323465586,
0.1418466121,
0.1727586836,
-0.2380940914,
0.1288729906,
0.0843219981,
-0.1855616421,
-0.2585648298,
0.1176081002,
-0.3001858294,
-0.719453454,
0.5814395547,
-0.1392958164,
0.0049258186,
-0.0484111421,
-0.218258366,
-0.3818956316,
0.1554680169,
0.6846138835,
0.6341001391,
-0.0202381145,
0.0995531082,
0.4268696308,
-0.5723153949,
0.2141725272,
0.1197892576,
-0.04170385,
-0.2134002149,
0.5169029832,
0.7329778671,
0.1260585338,
-0.7340310812,
0.1974893212,
-0.0146997059,
-0.6030105352,
-0.0321260095,
0.2617715299,
0.1056858301,
0.38985762,
0.295394659,
0.1962508857,
0.2885011435,
-0.5692961812,
0.371191591,
0.373757422,
-0.2314865738,
-0.3217047751,
0.7953010798,
0.2499593794,
-0.352991879,
0.9525420666,
-0.2141064107,
-0.5278696418,
0.9559304118,
0.3896507323,
1.1758544445,
-0.5825150013,
0.0760311186,
0.8725354671,
0.610468328,
-0.6100637317,
0.0484538227,
0.1981354803,
-0.6139558554,
-0.9678547978,
-0.825014472,
-0.1081228107,
0.3291791379,
-0.596365869,
0.5173228979,
-0.6400182843,
-0.2429335117,
0.1723648757,
-0.4092420042,
-0.5284566879,
0.0459820516,
0.2692738473,
0.9370149374,
-0.8172444701,
0.6758416295,
1.0292155743,
-0.3246343434,
-0.7563480735,
-0.3359464705,
-0.0788812041,
-0.7329064012,
1.0409375429,
0.01126251,
0.2183573246,
0.4520346522,
-0.9500336647,
-1.0249421597,
0.873824954,
0.3808413148,
-1.0218651295,
-0.076426506,
-0.2573226392,
0.4117771089,
-0.2610928118,
0.3843094707,
0.7831970453,
0.5585617423,
-0.0146335633,
-1.2235703468,
0.06986586,
-0.4142618775,
-0.1815593839,
0.7328286171,
-0.3968338072,
1.1264840364,
-0.2735158801,
-0.0260415785,
0.0234620906,
0.4264870882,
-0.2559943199,
-0.0082647353,
0.5660950541,
0.9646675587,
0.8480168581,
-0.0716752112,
0.8970934153,
-0.210403204,
0.6251645088,
0.9976519942,
-0.1571296602,
0.6485505104,
0.4217244387,
-0.1419961154,
0.2019801289,
0.816711247,
-0.2107093185,
0.2600175738,
0.1432909369,
0.0864781141,
-0.5400042534,
0.0287065748,
-0.2675094008,
0.4024707079,
0.4689769447,
-0.3079364598,
-0.5073287487,
0.410020858,
0.0525729693,
-0.1313455105,
-0.5968539715,
0.6693982482,
-0.0191896204,
-0.7683686614,
0.6983926892,
-0.3968118131,
0.7987496257,
-0.6188415885,
-0.1997403204,
-0.0686910078,
0.1866634041,
-0.3187152147,
-0.6719124913,
0.1175382286,
-0.4409542382,
0.0532535687,
-0.1755641103,
0.6620101929,
-0.5273273587,
-0.2341370881,
0.570951283,
0.3138271272,
0.0815824941,
0.0146241887,
-0.6404009461,
-0.3526839018,
-0.0011616966,
-0.3669333756,
0.3629763424,
0.2683903575,
0.3055785,
0.7644400597,
0.7662191987,
0.4760463834,
0.0900695398,
0.1378784329,
0.6333033442,
-0.4915450215,
-0.7018136978,
-1.0763868093,
0.3590401113,
-0.3749694526,
-0.6316233873,
0.5969994664,
0.328139782,
0.5442758799,
0.1355111003,
0.750541091,
-0.421490252,
0.0136331823,
-0.7060927153,
0.8128428459,
-0.9311622381,
-0.352534622,
-0.0164574962,
-1.0602960587,
-0.1640456021,
0.4636486769,
-0.331006825,
0.1547925472,
0.8981105089,
0.6702743173,
-0.2316293567,
0.0209325571,
0.6267815828,
0.3772641122,
0.2771772742,
0.7637888193,
0.9732945561,
-0.1092417762,
0.3335368633,
-0.071442619,
-0.3428200185,
-0.519346118,
-0.6514455676,
-0.936973989,
-0.6136692762,
-0.2814864218,
-0.3720298111,
0.1029430777,
1.0794444084,
1.0294866562,
-0.7440809011,
-0.0967358202,
-0.6672484279,
-0.3786152601,
-0.4617558122,
-0.1870394647,
0.1114381254,
-0.627695322,
-1.0399260521,
0.2256398946,
0.318023473,
0.1513972431,
-0.3390696645,
0.119946979,
-0.014174046,
0.1233093292,
0.4414641857,
0.4207648635,
-0.2905762196,
-0.0670153648,
-0.0846990049,
-0.0014179673,
-0.0860019326,
1.0203344822,
-0.3870824277,
0.5888880491,
0.90305686,
0.6458738446,
0.6083717346,
-0.4429032803,
1.0331194401,
-0.1147398725,
0.3382518291,
0.3878974915,
0.6178990602,
0.2286526263,
-0.5556574464,
0.5891352296,
-0.1369311363,
-0.9379311204,
-0.7992948294,
0.3367203772,
-0.8239651322,
-0.4253513515,
1.2179760933,
0.3973311186,
-0.4048236907,
-0.1503579021,
-0.0987367332,
0.2372048646,
-0.3884351254,
0.4749821126,
0.7701746821,
-0.2160716653,
-0.3679714501,
-1.1180071831,
0.6330586672,
0.6131508946,
-0.9335185289,
0.2076760679,
0.2465730906,
0.1957572848,
0.2896832526,
-0.0908033624,
0.2060922384,
0.4678429067,
0.2521284223,
0.6058430672,
0.178306058,
-0.0073931278,
-0.6432652473,
0.0658081099,
0.0844547227,
0.4745164216
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.