id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15302v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15302v4
|
How (un)ethical are instruction-centric responses of LLMs? Unveiling the vulnerabilities of safety guardrails to harmful queries
| 2024-02-23T13:03:12 | 2024-03-15T17:57:58 |
Somnath Banerjee, Sayan Layek, Rima Hazra, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
In this study, we tackle a growing concern around the safety and ethical use
of large language models (LLMs). Despite their potential, these models can be
tricked into producing harmful or unethical content through various
sophisticated methods, including 'jailbreaking' techniques and targeted
manipulation. Our work zeroes in on a specific issue: to what extent LLMs can
be led astray by asking them to generate responses that are instruction-centric
such as a pseudocode, a program or a software snippet as opposed to vanilla
text. To investigate this question, we introduce TechHazardQA, a dataset
containing complex queries which should be answered in both text and
instruction-centric formats (e.g., pseudocodes), aimed at identifying triggers
for unethical responses. We query a series of LLMs -- Llama-2-13b, Llama-2-7b,
Mistral-V2 and Mistral 8X7B -- and ask them to generate both text and
instruction-centric responses. For evaluation we report the harmfulness score
metric as well as judgements from GPT-4 and humans. Overall, we observe that
asking LLMs to produce instruction-centric responses enhances the unethical
response generation by ~2-38% across the models. As an additional objective, we
investigate the impact of model editing using the ROME technique, which further
increases the propensity for generating undesirable content. In particular,
asking edited LLMs to generate instruction-centric responses further increases
the unethical response generation by ~3-16% across the different models.
|
[
-0.0422938913,
-1.0475251675,
0.6097041368,
-0.2688114941,
-0.1376288235,
0.0407076068,
0.047487095,
-0.5376179218,
-0.1305399686,
0.9163820744,
-0.4538669288,
-0.3770980537,
-0.3659590185,
-0.0898069963,
-0.5866432786,
1.1639297009,
0.2288636267,
0.215472579,
-0.1400515884,
-0.0613377355,
-0.2541701496,
-0.9636546969,
-0.4866307378,
0.0980146378,
0.4680867195,
0.4955198765,
0.453938812,
0.9329558015,
0.3011703789,
0.2798469663,
-0.0462699719,
-0.0697036162,
-0.6800579429,
0.1915866286,
-0.3391823173,
-0.5163531899,
-0.4156749249,
0.1925145984,
0.0369481556,
0.4289209247,
-0.2889736593,
0.6087169051,
0.2611110508,
0.6828182936,
-0.7096474171,
-0.3313303292,
-0.7499972582,
0.1371406764,
-0.0843885541,
-0.6454920769,
-0.7385647297,
-0.6184741259,
-0.0761273727,
-0.3776092827,
-0.073340565,
0.1243271753,
0.2325909138,
0.2561543882,
-0.3056200445,
-0.8293347955,
-0.5817979574,
0.8051003814,
-0.703055501,
0.1123942733,
0.4098920226,
-0.0829608962,
-0.1592211872,
-0.64432621,
-0.4250394106,
-0.1928471774,
0.118899107,
-0.014514477,
-0.1712086201,
0.1490214765,
0.4992027283,
0.1220733523,
-0.5830277801,
0.4119007587,
-0.479088217,
-0.2002778947,
0.7416370511,
0.4295400381,
0.4208135903,
-0.2726736963,
-0.3581389189,
-0.0068386896,
-1.0953139067,
0.1273629665,
0.8591493964,
0.0620573089,
0.1709865779,
0.8089586496,
0.3710779548,
0.6740532517,
0.0834998339,
-0.0391735137,
-0.1945194304,
-0.1338675171,
-0.2714911103,
0.3918864727,
0.8587667346,
0.7367068529,
0.6838817,
-0.0264483448,
-0.1047677994,
-0.1082448363,
0.6319589615,
-0.9900385141,
-0.0400693044,
0.3438302577,
-0.3674692214,
-0.5954697132,
-0.0881328732,
-0.5664518476,
-0.4739058912,
-0.153390795,
0.2913981974,
-0.2762687802,
0.1157109812,
0.200241819,
0.175973624,
0.3713712096,
0.0439081527,
-0.7227181792,
0.0288321078,
0.6672587991,
0.1783976406,
0.1855516285,
0.0186190587,
-0.6696209908,
0.2168141752,
-0.4689879715,
0.4298919439,
-0.6191307902,
-0.8991872668,
0.0837857202,
0.1273641288,
0.115312323,
-0.4704564214,
0.4078499079,
-0.6915031075,
0.4084690213,
-0.414467454,
-0.4767901897,
-0.2145972997,
0.1248566881,
-0.4863363206,
0.8793779016,
-0.2063763142,
-1.0089091063,
0.0025338111,
-0.5281909704,
-0.4512194395,
-0.1541754454,
-0.2949334383,
-0.1548149139,
-0.0576460399,
-0.1323226541,
0.4344091713,
-0.3693059385,
0.2705954909,
-0.3850155175,
-0.5542994738,
0.6483510137,
-0.8358195424,
0.9267915487,
0.1824759245,
-0.6544349194,
-0.0080753863,
-0.6525242329,
0.3171281815,
0.190155074,
-0.3390858471,
-0.5963656902,
-0.1477857828,
-0.2756986916,
0.340115428,
0.1928422153,
-0.5096347928,
-0.0193839204,
-0.2110111415,
0.4744484425,
1.2319084406,
0.1920223981,
0.2927488089,
-0.389637202,
0.5714271069,
-0.267947644,
0.4437304139,
0.0214657765,
-0.2614123821,
-0.4623755813,
0.2377053797,
-0.187044695,
0.7922679186,
-0.7275472283,
0.1123731434,
-0.1120372266,
-0.4922127724,
-0.6119050384,
0.1585492939,
0.7487966418,
0.839554131,
0.1577176899,
0.0001078647,
-0.1998196393,
-0.9726734757,
-0.5171686411,
-0.4663594663,
-0.0039974148,
0.425155133,
0.3479157686,
0.0290702134,
0.4713849723,
-0.3546260297,
0.3421239257,
0.128814742,
-0.0475110151,
-0.1080125198,
0.391713202,
0.5836589932,
-0.6209794283,
-0.1857912987,
-0.3655529618,
-0.8868519068,
-0.2041560262,
-0.0674140975,
-0.206904918,
0.3704741895,
0.4643205404,
-0.4276137054,
0.4532989264,
0.2241723686,
-0.2547764182,
0.5830947161,
-0.0813685656,
0.2827155888,
-1.1638668776,
0.0340012237,
-0.1947432905,
0.0666975081,
-0.5381143689,
0.3384042978,
0.0550095066,
0.1529543102,
-0.8131032586,
0.2218693048,
-0.2676978707,
-0.0911284536,
-0.2219652236,
-0.0476462916,
0.0233099144,
0.2680839896,
-0.2350311279,
1.1906832457,
0.2418635488,
-0.6025258899,
0.291331768,
0.258245796,
-0.1060451344,
0.4667007625,
-0.8492708802,
0.6400803924,
-0.1002961546,
0.0148070948,
-0.4717880189,
-0.2283847481,
0.4553120434,
-0.4260088503,
0.121047087,
0.0134334899,
-0.6167283654,
-0.1920597106,
-0.8609600067,
0.387257278,
0.5790985823,
-0.5456520915,
0.2401127964,
0.5634613633,
-0.1576823443,
-0.9176258445,
-1.046353817,
-0.0142590255,
-0.4427876472,
-0.5690668821,
-0.1104435101,
-0.26895836,
-0.4982619584,
-0.0041632755,
-0.217999801,
0.1244556904,
0.3534943759,
0.405747503,
0.4950692952,
-0.081907168,
-0.1482146233,
0.1134908646,
0.2576900125,
0.626398325,
-0.1015556976,
0.498740375,
-0.1149336472,
-0.5996711254,
-0.133955434,
0.5573055744,
0.4806630611,
-0.2706646323,
0.729377389,
0.2685140669,
-0.2280950844,
-0.229950428,
-0.3879224658,
-0.4752208889,
-0.5665441751,
0.2892218232,
0.1047201082,
-1.1871554852,
0.3341705501,
0.2291100919,
0.2917624712,
0.0829612687,
0.669523716,
-0.1622093916,
0.9696376324,
0.5887064934,
0.1783118695,
0.2862494588,
-0.190926522,
0.3365677893,
-0.7828635573,
-0.5290958285,
-0.5177404881,
-0.0349758416,
-1.0055497885,
-0.3879758418,
0.5071409345,
-0.2498403639,
-0.4694758356,
0.1662465781,
-0.7490981221,
0.616075635,
0.537979424,
0.107088767,
0.3520154655,
-0.0526921041,
0.02371886,
-0.014513283,
-0.7324590683,
-1.0100758076,
1.2116582394,
0.2420331687,
1.1948970556,
0.2310370058,
0.7498297095,
0.3397854865,
0.2779591382,
-0.8331209421,
0.8388179541,
-0.1489517987,
-0.7668828964,
-0.1377179176,
-0.4665635824,
-0.7216361165,
-0.1355288327,
-0.021074513,
-0.8832225204,
0.0041274228,
0.0927312598,
-0.4639699757,
0.4512049258,
-0.846444726,
0.5450490117,
-0.6513019204,
-0.8099537492,
-0.1387099326,
-0.8304168582,
0.5716307759,
-0.2329132557,
0.3696576953,
0.2562719882,
0.0179660022,
0.7431167364,
-0.3335189223,
1.0076259375,
0.1134784147,
-0.3779689372,
0.4430719912,
0.4265711606,
0.2144445777,
0.1289706081,
-0.1870307028,
-0.1658585668,
0.1308952719,
-0.2071054578,
-0.4037484825,
0.9103899598,
-0.7099142671,
-1.1630374193,
-0.3568505645,
-0.6140900254,
-0.2636549473,
0.1685066074,
0.3696657121,
0.5858114362,
0.0855798349,
0.080786407,
1.0207241774,
-0.6615638733,
0.4455869198,
0.7220699787,
-0.067947872,
0.1652418673,
0.8125675917,
0.2270348221,
0.4247426689,
-0.0523119345,
-0.0415197015,
-0.3088219762,
-0.4132709503,
-0.6340816617,
0.0882728472,
-0.8324239254,
-0.2194380164,
-0.6059352756,
-0.3712676466,
-0.1872249842,
-0.243070066,
-0.1468785256,
-0.2919899821,
-0.4545572102,
-0.3687280118,
0.3608365357,
0.9978011847,
0.0637681112,
0.0680915937,
-0.9883220196,
0.0646602884,
0.3476820588,
0.0951600149,
-0.1247476935,
-0.6004735231,
0.1673850119,
0.0688725114,
-0.2998709679,
-1.0288596153,
0.091916047,
-0.2372252494,
0.4627914727,
0.2932120264,
0.3935137093,
0.4881308973,
-0.5471915603,
0.9285832644,
-0.1756844521,
-0.7289802432,
0.4144705534,
-0.2509604096,
-0.1575404704,
0.3945973217,
0.621308744,
-0.2764207721,
-0.6364663243,
-0.5734623075,
-0.9470092654,
0.7021573782,
-0.0629334077,
0.6768317223,
-0.1278965473,
0.4868371785,
0.2157048732,
0.2512416542,
-0.5605428815,
-0.2398794889,
-0.0961677134,
-0.0488356389,
0.4893831909,
-0.613144815,
-0.3991316259,
0.205393061,
0.5869237185,
0.106190376,
0.0927820802,
-0.0337676555,
-0.0883253962,
-0.1825886369,
0.6510201693,
0.4272873998,
0.4854515493,
-0.0322136916,
0.0666669086,
-0.0233854279,
-0.6501403451,
0.2075376809,
-0.0207691062,
-0.1501959711,
-0.5142662525,
0.4050056338,
0.2731472552,
-0.0841576755,
-0.7879853845,
0.3658869863,
-0.2569109797,
0.1253365427,
-0.2936490178,
0.3505744338,
-0.0214942805,
0.1051945463,
0.2113836706,
-0.1904494315,
0.4450213015,
-0.7009776831,
0.0809091106,
0.4999623001,
-0.007025782,
-0.2008287013,
0.7140664458,
0.1456875354,
-0.3595576584,
0.5611399412,
-0.0233857464,
-0.4669666588,
0.6216283441,
0.5020706654,
0.6713988781,
-0.2716267407,
0.4260834754,
0.2692488134,
0.6360108256,
0.149146542,
0.4211506546,
0.1176787615,
-0.5296314955,
-0.3251774609,
-0.2543436289,
-0.5150377154,
0.2810025215,
-1.0256683826,
-0.1023595631,
-0.757858336,
-0.2195923626,
-0.2607966959,
-0.2216271758,
-0.2520005107,
0.1727651507,
0.0853474811,
0.8225666881,
-0.5617924333,
0.6141790152,
0.8155355453,
-0.3786529601,
-1.165358305,
0.1617223471,
0.2077335119,
-0.9206908345,
0.3385074437,
0.1446538568,
-0.415972203,
-0.2156748176,
-0.959476769,
-0.3392280936,
0.9376709461,
0.6079594493,
-0.668887496,
-0.2602236271,
0.4975985885,
0.3772026002,
0.0433236137,
0.1303704083,
0.6204448342,
0.1392545253,
-0.0915215984,
-0.706361711,
0.2900628746,
-0.3238687217,
-0.0583557412,
0.0773843229,
-0.5463526249,
0.7473791242,
-0.3542306721,
-0.1526116282,
0.1077475175,
0.0640484244,
0.4937448204,
0.2579281926,
0.2194980383,
0.2972433269,
0.6790984273,
0.1018535197,
1.245688796,
-0.6151881814,
-0.038171161,
1.0251466036,
-0.2445914,
0.5659604669,
0.7432491779,
0.2096973062,
0.2060374022,
0.560205698,
0.2461995482,
0.4027374983,
0.3213418126,
-0.2667751312,
-0.1102974564,
-0.3289397955,
-0.3857736886,
0.4370931387,
0.4559045732,
-0.4164697826,
-0.1305478066,
-0.0727175921,
0.5753769875,
0.2397458404,
-0.3454179168,
0.742732048,
0.339048475,
-0.5001382232,
0.403942287,
0.2313990742,
0.5504952073,
-0.3517866731,
-0.0248996615,
-0.2282046974,
-0.0443797782,
-0.2691376507,
-1.2266764641,
0.2761469483,
0.7011067867,
0.0317721851,
-0.0793917701,
0.5980793834,
-0.0728375018,
-0.2912972271,
0.1956341714,
0.6019855142,
-0.033137463,
0.2907682061,
-0.698147893,
0.094123058,
0.1153101623,
-0.4157517254,
0.4539974928,
0.4858742356,
-0.2636176646,
0.7217614651,
0.7547630668,
-0.1598646641,
0.1818957627,
-0.1836949736,
1.0905778408,
-0.5398468375,
-0.2056677938,
-0.9706094861,
0.4852394164,
0.1021637991,
-0.2291802764,
0.797231853,
0.3469097614,
0.8411822915,
0.1203043833,
0.8157425523,
0.0864476711,
0.2060341835,
-0.772480309,
0.8572770357,
-0.4343322814,
0.8383638263,
-0.1431376487,
-0.7956843376,
0.1807302833,
0.2267212868,
-0.6302022338,
0.2283280939,
0.4207097888,
0.9826956987,
0.1592694968,
0.2475286573,
0.2107181251,
0.242460683,
0.3203417659,
0.4849305153,
1.1590707302,
-0.0593736395,
0.5749147534,
-0.3868950605,
-0.0367730707,
0.0286546517,
-0.7911477089,
-0.9442136288,
-0.2471549362,
-0.0041113314,
-0.5341857076,
0.30635342,
1.0025429726,
0.2009027153,
-0.5488901138,
-0.1848168522,
0.2813585699,
-0.0087749492,
0.5355437398,
-0.2381640971,
0.2457286119,
0.1163588613,
-0.6089550853,
0.2246047258,
0.1399738193,
0.0560801327,
-0.3158473074,
0.1251683533,
0.2124977559,
0.4062126875,
0.6293555498,
0.2035036534,
-0.4386350513,
-0.4583024383,
0.4085488319,
-0.4446707964,
-0.3502686322,
0.5700139999,
-0.395062536,
0.185448423,
0.1349885464,
0.7715563178,
-0.0582871847,
0.0644917488,
0.4817628562,
-0.5087348223,
0.0592423975,
0.5678948164,
0.1552358717,
0.4534901381,
-0.7516087294,
0.3735123277,
-0.1704470068,
-0.7265222073,
-1.0289074183,
0.270821929,
-0.7422952056,
-0.2986461222,
1.3185334206,
-0.1948468387,
-0.4409344792,
0.0996287167,
-0.2772093713,
0.0931281149,
-0.2533579171,
0.8346939683,
0.4702098668,
-0.2018796951,
0.0225816388,
-0.8646146059,
0.2823356092,
0.3512195349,
-0.9384752512,
0.0198440086,
0.7452637553,
0.588301599,
-0.1752851754,
0.3996110559,
-0.4345344305,
0.5147974491,
-0.1868908852,
-0.1165153161,
-0.2530107498,
-0.1629213691,
-0.2004131079,
0.0475806408,
0.1788952351,
-0.213698715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15301v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15301v2
|
Causal Graph Discovery with Retrieval-Augmented Generation based Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T13:02:10 | 2024-06-18T05:51:50 |
Yuzhe Zhang, Yipeng Zhang, Yidong Gan, Lina Yao, Chen Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
Causal graph recovery is traditionally done using statistical
estimation-based methods or based on individual's knowledge about variables of
interests. They often suffer from data collection biases and limitations of
individuals' knowledge. The advance of large language models (LLMs) provides
opportunities to address these problems. We propose a novel method that
leverages LLMs to deduce causal relationships in general causal graph recovery
tasks. This method leverages knowledge compressed in LLMs and knowledge LLMs
extracted from scientific publication database as well as experiment data about
factors of interest to achieve this goal. Our method gives a prompting strategy
to extract associational relationships among those factors and a mechanism to
perform causality verification for these associations. Comparing to other
LLM-based methods that directly instruct LLMs to do the highly complex causal
reasoning, our method shows clear advantage on causal graph quality on
benchmark datasets. More importantly, as causality among some factors may
change as new research results emerge, our method show sensitivity to new
evidence in the literature and can provide useful information for updating
causal graphs accordingly.
|
[
-0.0933594704,
-1.0906713009,
0.9314727187,
0.0876989216,
-0.1531763226,
0.1453012973,
-0.1513824016,
-0.4467129707,
0.4729988873,
0.6544403434,
-0.4124142826,
-0.3719415367,
-0.6502234936,
0.2838882804,
-0.4298267663,
0.5184653401,
0.0084357969,
0.0271583367,
-0.1674230248,
0.1316371113,
-0.5403764844,
-0.3118806779,
-0.8729982376,
-0.5428279638,
0.9640896916,
0.1795890778,
0.1635505259,
0.6451262832,
0.4187990427,
0.2838032544,
-0.0688134208,
0.6303433776,
-0.7813280225,
0.0883733258,
-0.2622254491,
-0.1867661476,
-0.297632128,
-0.1706984043,
0.7964431047,
0.9634755254,
0.0683501437,
0.0417404175,
0.0978682414,
0.4726889729,
-0.6633214951,
0.4378718734,
-0.7396814227,
-0.2114974111,
-0.1819178015,
-0.6265032291,
-0.769448638,
-0.508924365,
-0.2099834532,
-0.4941554964,
0.4408781528,
0.1913015395,
0.588062048,
-0.0327881686,
-0.9526489973,
-0.1173850819,
-0.7943319082,
0.4137293398,
-0.5607081056,
0.407980293,
0.3338910043,
0.1793969572,
-0.6754006743,
-0.97451967,
-0.6191761494,
-0.3203045726,
-0.2868639231,
-0.1269737631,
-0.1139890701,
-0.2133891135,
0.5150677562,
0.1480900496,
-0.3023984134,
0.1800526977,
-0.1689779013,
-0.4005194604,
0.6553095579,
0.2118928432,
0.4314239919,
-0.3548256159,
-0.2399758399,
0.0463932566,
-1.3521103859,
-0.3271603882,
0.2209960371,
0.6535625458,
0.1508249193,
0.7187597156,
-0.333332032,
0.709893465,
-0.1483428776,
-0.0005134505,
0.2433111221,
-0.2939189672,
-0.0756035522,
0.1221782938,
0.788061142,
0.191948846,
-0.0406906195,
-0.3331364095,
0.0342323035,
-0.3140848279,
-0.3279837966,
-0.7256914377,
-0.1572688222,
-0.2143579721,
-0.4010035694,
-0.0229924023,
-0.0601228774,
-0.6108204126,
-0.8199253678,
-0.407402277,
0.2675985694,
-0.1393411756,
-0.4642933309,
0.0194464773,
-0.1264126897,
0.0219555981,
0.3538515866,
-0.6146640182,
0.0203331802,
0.6560707688,
0.6757893562,
0.040609777,
-0.1234668419,
-0.8796986938,
0.3876366615,
-0.3260161579,
0.6671177149,
-0.3051825166,
-0.2616069615,
0.2070153207,
0.3141635656,
0.0057056011,
-0.3720778823,
0.4330072999,
-0.9689455628,
0.0309896581,
-0.7373884916,
-0.6979831457,
-0.1595857441,
0.1366137415,
-0.7848978043,
0.8705878854,
-0.2038159966,
-0.8974065185,
0.4344511032,
-0.1224123761,
-0.5670881867,
0.1750230044,
-0.2252479792,
-0.2391730249,
-0.070105806,
0.1789693683,
0.5484901667,
-0.6999046803,
0.6957772374,
-0.6979396939,
-0.0749614686,
0.0018298782,
-0.3925509453,
0.9005218744,
-0.0398002788,
-0.1519877017,
0.0823107064,
-0.9749761224,
-0.3950155079,
0.3274875283,
-0.2910756469,
-0.6195957065,
0.4046945572,
-0.4092988372,
0.162471354,
0.2128664404,
-0.7691081762,
0.2751278877,
-0.1724176556,
0.3032742441,
0.8178914785,
0.5524207354,
-0.0556099489,
0.0593178943,
0.1255140901,
-0.1913925558,
-0.2901967168,
0.1076460108,
-0.217454806,
-0.6883836389,
-0.3123145103,
0.0279349107,
0.2454218864,
-0.8480053544,
0.550404191,
-0.4176483154,
-0.2769517601,
0.0231483579,
0.1892712861,
0.2810937762,
1.0138893127,
0.4238691926,
0.036544662,
-0.6579920053,
-0.7397687435,
-0.0911332518,
-0.2027745545,
-0.1684071869,
0.5666012168,
0.3370740414,
-0.224613145,
0.8533382416,
-0.9852158427,
-0.0409377739,
-0.0773372501,
0.1762608588,
0.2799519897,
0.2743338943,
0.2935637236,
-0.5938512683,
-0.1970030367,
-0.0791349113,
-0.9431298971,
-0.2752095461,
0.0261035431,
-0.3386838138,
-0.1243848652,
1.0320190191,
-0.5208861232,
0.1320648193,
0.0969191045,
-0.5548970103,
0.6448630095,
-0.1815597713,
0.1622440368,
-0.9035158157,
0.3941070139,
0.0040489202,
-0.259588778,
-0.3996273577,
-0.1562956423,
0.0252428465,
0.0382448062,
-0.0791209489,
0.6165929437,
-0.5214529634,
0.032517191,
-0.3661877811,
0.3624431491,
-0.1501137316,
0.2020379305,
-0.0796117336,
0.406452775,
0.4382730424,
-0.6365070343,
0.3860928118,
0.3102973402,
-0.1267986,
0.27149418,
-0.7020838261,
0.096757181,
-0.4182496667,
0.3004925847,
-1.1372551918,
-0.3308233619,
0.1799072027,
-0.1208505854,
0.3838505745,
-0.0474921651,
-0.8361724615,
-0.4275491834,
0.0363207199,
0.2418790162,
0.2331907749,
-0.9497223496,
0.7070935965,
0.4375350177,
-0.1973721087,
-0.4984071851,
-0.1156481579,
0.1967615336,
-0.2495110929,
-0.5504667759,
0.0377459712,
0.0984355956,
-0.1565524489,
-0.0160309039,
0.0868770629,
0.1968266219,
0.1995553374,
0.0923924148,
0.3502856195,
0.0845110714,
0.4128004313,
-0.0567206144,
-0.0759819075,
0.311540693,
-0.0119054951,
0.6166651845,
0.4530583024,
-0.2402902991,
0.043101687,
0.1288371384,
0.24099572,
-0.2534751594,
0.6107075214,
0.5432673097,
-0.4943310022,
-0.0002987687,
-0.7284383178,
-0.3347402215,
-0.4364185929,
0.3682030141,
-0.1469634473,
-0.9183061123,
0.6192412376,
-0.5274066925,
-0.3373351991,
0.5092580318,
0.4884066582,
0.3896286488,
1.1086999178,
0.4789563715,
-0.3117724359,
0.5148172379,
-0.0379716754,
0.2785514593,
-0.9107248783,
-0.5426790714,
-0.668533802,
0.0642858446,
-0.4505737722,
-0.1160642281,
0.3895637095,
0.256991148,
-0.5683969259,
0.1724145114,
-0.1432248652,
0.236730665,
0.4800181091,
0.5073245764,
0.6011432409,
0.1133951843,
0.014162791,
0.291307807,
-0.4965848923,
-0.117200993,
0.9944307804,
-0.113179259,
0.7301362157,
0.3188399374,
0.6930202246,
0.2000586987,
0.5120803714,
-0.403709203,
0.7425583601,
0.0892689303,
-0.3615137935,
-0.2594333589,
-0.9570299983,
-1.3312953711,
0.074500531,
-0.3936400414,
-0.9960613847,
0.2390542775,
0.1064861491,
0.1880676001,
0.1146301255,
-0.5517211556,
0.4453580678,
0.0424170271,
-0.6684136987,
-0.347560972,
-0.6453016996,
0.6797046661,
-0.080968529,
0.1403717548,
-0.1861631572,
0.3555883169,
0.7932699323,
-0.435556531,
0.9786790609,
-0.2968042493,
-0.2202486992,
0.2533708513,
0.2268749774,
0.8486366868,
0.1016674116,
-0.041249197,
-0.1279247701,
-0.3723480701,
-0.1832549572,
-0.6698663831,
1.0395383835,
-0.562348187,
-0.7438821793,
-0.1695424765,
-0.6073323488,
-0.4094038606,
0.7358750701,
-0.2308631092,
0.4777463078,
-0.1950650662,
0.0921989605,
0.4119822979,
-0.2626796961,
0.3136581481,
0.8913065195,
-0.3424953818,
-0.3772948384,
0.7768432498,
-0.0072712526,
-0.0235454272,
0.4679464698,
0.3156272471,
-0.4296031892,
-0.4019428492,
0.0837858915,
0.634310782,
-0.5899035931,
-0.5488982201,
-0.5597066879,
-0.007939741,
-0.5318398476,
0.1609953791,
0.0643358827,
-0.3512034714,
-0.268129766,
-0.3691174984,
0.5371958613,
0.7055881023,
-0.2240230143,
-0.0073918565,
-0.7468525767,
0.4446329772,
0.2471235842,
0.229558751,
0.3971900642,
-0.0282536559,
-0.1649028361,
-0.1978644878,
-0.1227282137,
-0.9444463253,
0.4358932078,
0.0134290503,
0.5363129973,
0.4149014652,
0.0810769647,
0.576028645,
-0.6199228764,
0.4025015235,
0.2942990065,
-0.698594451,
0.5553364158,
-0.4583394527,
-0.2048892826,
0.0971724913,
0.4557034075,
-0.3145947456,
-0.1205515191,
-0.6288570762,
-1.050085187,
0.286954999,
-0.0433236249,
-0.2698405683,
-0.4202421904,
0.6798804402,
-0.2223701924,
0.1284741908,
-0.4777432978,
-0.2196344137,
0.4197140634,
-0.0259437095,
-0.2378411591,
-0.3501510918,
-0.5180237889,
-0.2420317084,
0.7413188815,
-0.19534868,
0.122005485,
0.2970595956,
-0.1180205196,
-0.2770831287,
-0.0088537205,
0.1358829886,
0.808103621,
-0.2924374342,
0.4403163791,
0.0289877467,
-0.2116553485,
0.1115502119,
0.4515295625,
-0.2978878021,
-0.2740148008,
0.6377539635,
0.6123555899,
0.2129329294,
-0.6435951591,
0.3640502393,
0.0970613733,
0.2202717364,
-0.1428446323,
-0.0677548647,
0.1048162431,
0.3780345023,
0.5715181231,
-0.3606871963,
0.2302962989,
-0.3806344271,
0.224160403,
0.5848081708,
-0.0016847415,
-0.285343349,
0.6140274405,
0.0363545716,
-0.1187137291,
0.6705083847,
-0.099709332,
-0.1958576143,
0.5983672142,
0.9172093868,
0.6252910495,
0.0237667412,
0.1475503743,
0.6687185168,
0.0239589512,
-0.1398869306,
0.2284312397,
0.3185147047,
-0.8118363619,
-0.693328321,
-0.2733902931,
-0.0768698677,
0.0655483454,
-0.584975183,
0.312260747,
-0.2219507843,
-0.0585484616,
-0.0340649337,
0.1390426755,
-0.5525211096,
-0.0431590006,
-0.2173410654,
0.7702438831,
-1.0344028473,
0.6534637213,
0.137330547,
-0.515565455,
-1.046391964,
-0.3276544511,
0.0308370739,
-0.9215329289,
0.9259682298,
-0.2015700638,
-0.021815706,
0.2824460566,
-0.696451962,
-1.0210709572,
1.317084074,
0.6023423076,
-0.6481826901,
0.1106592342,
-0.1373270005,
0.4678997993,
-0.1988227218,
0.0254220255,
0.452768445,
0.4415599704,
0.1547779888,
-0.3924496472,
0.8181754947,
0.033584781,
-0.1760789901,
0.4881856441,
-0.4824539125,
0.6341055036,
-0.2367179096,
-0.2507503331,
-0.0553999953,
0.6821686029,
0.5353263021,
0.4083961546,
0.3926514089,
0.3893789053,
1.1127773523,
0.1072709709,
1.1489312649,
-0.368139416,
0.5261026025,
1.1300038099,
-0.4658560157,
0.5986224413,
0.5263393521,
-0.1303806901,
0.5587303638,
0.4374415576,
0.0250998549,
0.4361480772,
0.1072537452,
-0.3256206214,
-0.4402742982,
-0.4658035934,
-0.3641275465,
0.0062560681,
0.3042336404,
-0.5578271747,
-0.3240019083,
-0.1809518188,
0.2774245441,
-0.1436643004,
-0.3409855068,
0.594127357,
0.1175456867,
-0.569742918,
0.4257252514,
-0.1915128678,
0.0224930346,
-0.6335330009,
-0.3069042563,
-0.1353008598,
0.1045577973,
-0.1299191117,
-0.4698195755,
-0.0975910202,
-0.3198578656,
-0.2576838136,
0.131799981,
1.0509221554,
-0.5433699489,
-0.5215454698,
0.4523124993,
0.6619676352,
-0.235912919,
0.1366812587,
-0.0037238118,
0.0554458909,
-0.1299882978,
-0.0445771255,
0.3061496019,
0.496955663,
-0.1831151545,
0.6243074536,
0.7563913465,
0.3101082742,
-0.1897647977,
0.3055670559,
1.0847386122,
-0.6008933187,
-0.1392497122,
-0.8544598222,
0.1711127609,
-0.3187510967,
0.1168807447,
1.0682286024,
0.4592711031,
0.3496816754,
0.0110024139,
0.6507534981,
-0.0787844062,
0.5488750935,
-0.7602384686,
0.4541895092,
-0.3773357868,
0.4082084596,
-0.3880154192,
-0.7193102837,
-0.4742133915,
0.139979139,
-0.4559469223,
-0.0647636354,
0.7676416636,
0.8719099164,
0.0316909142,
-0.085300535,
-0.1593825221,
0.6387914419,
0.7685182691,
0.3979714811,
0.6218987107,
-0.1081023738,
0.3407878578,
0.1897102743,
-0.3870491683,
-0.1399142742,
-1.0723576546,
-0.6421043873,
-0.4755067825,
-0.3096020818,
-0.6751781106,
0.0036796087,
0.7418888807,
0.284003675,
-0.4588998556,
-0.0631736517,
-0.3649659157,
0.4095213115,
-0.0939117074,
-0.2914043665,
0.9376146197,
-0.2561961412,
-0.4091702402,
0.5522329807,
-0.0177875608,
-0.1571695954,
-0.1723799258,
0.0059674121,
-0.4823972285,
-0.028853206,
0.7759619355,
0.5519355536,
-0.1999522597,
-0.5772873163,
-0.2384863049,
0.1272380352,
-0.2996997535,
1.1429013014,
-0.7555967569,
0.3475129008,
0.7626217008,
0.5348540545,
0.8091461062,
-0.1416632831,
0.6198345423,
-0.8863292336,
0.1633828133,
-0.1372432262,
0.7931865454,
0.3876508772,
-0.4991722405,
0.6135336757,
0.5801702142,
-0.6404165626,
-0.8666682839,
0.4431622326,
-1.0195595026,
-0.24743931,
1.2736281157,
-0.1491004974,
0.0694940388,
-0.0482489988,
-0.1140798628,
0.4799802601,
-0.1580390036,
0.9699289799,
0.3659529388,
-0.3987004757,
0.0604594499,
-0.0940159932,
0.2265854031,
-0.0799489766,
-0.8064367771,
0.2772331834,
0.8442831635,
0.3292892575,
0.0937082693,
0.7409588099,
-0.1693120897,
-0.1419680119,
-0.0606724657,
-0.1330150217,
-0.2003280818,
-0.2640874386,
0.0816868991,
0.2371642292,
0.1159076467,
0.3740369678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15300v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15300v2
|
Seeing is Believing: Mitigating Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models via CLIP-Guided Decoding
| 2024-02-23T12:57:16 | 2024-04-23T09:32:25 |
Ailin Deng, Zhirui Chen, Bryan Hooi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) are susceptible to object
hallucinations, an issue in which their generated text contains non-existent
objects, greatly limiting their reliability and practicality. Current
approaches often rely on the model's token likelihoods or other internal
information, instruction tuning on additional datasets, or incorporating
complex external tools. We first perform empirical analysis on sentence-level
LVLM hallucination, finding that CLIP similarity to the image acts as a
stronger and more robust indicator of hallucination compared to token
likelihoods. Motivated by this, we introduce our CLIP-Guided Decoding (CGD)
approach, a straightforward but effective training-free approach to reduce
object hallucination at decoding time. CGD uses CLIP to guide the model's
decoding process by enhancing visual grounding of generated text with the
image. Experiments demonstrate that CGD effectively mitigates object
hallucination across multiple LVLM families while preserving the utility of
text generation. Codes are available at
https://github.com/d-ailin/CLIP-Guided-Decoding.
|
[
-0.2973318398,
-0.7637500167,
0.6831579208,
0.3093309402,
-0.7078983188,
-0.1096055284,
-0.2807093561,
-0.4639496803,
0.1949582696,
0.7632011771,
-0.3733613193,
-0.6538538337,
-0.5770299435,
0.0490047932,
-0.5516946316,
0.5052149892,
0.1061100811,
0.2358341813,
-0.5141577721,
0.0829883665,
-0.6418275237,
-0.6691939831,
-0.3773668408,
-0.0439443626,
0.194121927,
0.2848802209,
0.7610951066,
0.9533672333,
0.5598103404,
0.0589305796,
-0.1121649519,
0.3430696428,
-0.5026640892,
-0.0062871538,
-0.0318291821,
-0.2236649245,
-0.0270489641,
-0.4318255186,
0.4343034923,
0.6474180818,
-0.1320989877,
-0.2632900178,
0.3405121267,
0.5411474705,
-0.8237444162,
0.2758594155,
-0.8007497787,
0.3295045197,
0.1353055686,
-0.3635430038,
-0.5695975423,
-0.2563749552,
0.1516592056,
-0.3851527274,
0.435138613,
0.1668877453,
0.8769061565,
0.3990460634,
-0.1472282708,
-0.4506992102,
-0.4929969907,
0.7080458403,
-0.4317540228,
0.7395461202,
0.5433782339,
0.1387403458,
-0.031068258,
-0.4200730324,
-0.5805593729,
-0.336681962,
0.0928099528,
-0.0335282348,
0.0475627817,
0.1139358729,
0.531345129,
0.20930399,
-0.4771204889,
-0.1737052053,
-0.4789789021,
-0.314270556,
0.2891505361,
-0.0713220164,
0.3608807027,
-0.1163628772,
-0.4405871034,
-0.3802439868,
-0.7683894634,
-0.1615193784,
-0.0919047222,
0.0362776779,
0.3229354024,
0.7320042253,
-0.0092334999,
0.4702391922,
-0.0067493245,
-0.1595879048,
-0.0243514534,
-0.0582788996,
-0.2954319417,
0.248387292,
0.4412492216,
0.8759610057,
0.381907016,
-0.4275742769,
-0.2582135797,
0.4719277918,
0.3262214959,
-1.0112025738,
-0.4080247581,
-0.0360396951,
-0.7136743665,
-0.4232370257,
0.1151533052,
-0.8193267584,
-0.5559353828,
-0.1773096174,
0.5505626202,
-0.6576908827,
-0.0160930138,
0.569896102,
-0.150800243,
0.3413734734,
0.2933743298,
-1.0604177713,
0.3393855393,
0.7193412185,
1.1300216913,
-0.5073081851,
-0.5291187763,
-1.0337766409,
0.2418548018,
-0.5692902207,
0.8189490438,
-0.3151745498,
-0.5694698691,
0.2087713778,
0.1290938407,
0.1084782481,
-0.800481379,
0.59116292,
-0.0136844683,
-0.240985319,
-0.3738230467,
-0.6106353402,
-0.2574468851,
0.2963512242,
-0.6001051664,
0.7328395247,
-0.2085397094,
-0.4439484477,
0.4974630773,
-0.1688032597,
-0.4264412224,
-0.0324170105,
-0.4341769516,
-0.5660515428,
0.5739076734,
0.6132454872,
0.5128273368,
0.0864150822,
0.1993779242,
-0.3208627701,
-0.4932807982,
0.1976471543,
-0.3749883473,
0.3239907026,
-0.0349531509,
-0.3825433552,
0.2889213264,
-0.6092633605,
-0.1570437849,
0.0870622247,
0.1342515945,
-0.3134789467,
0.3895095587,
0.1416829973,
0.0086313644,
-0.1745564938,
-0.4214480817,
0.1663229614,
-0.3459869921,
0.1880519241,
0.7108674645,
0.1386325955,
0.1929034591,
-0.0983155668,
0.3923859596,
0.0567883141,
0.3052070439,
-0.4838233888,
-0.3981900811,
-0.7823781371,
-0.1427441686,
-0.2636299431,
0.3965371847,
-0.9052696824,
0.2436732501,
-0.055291649,
-0.2330099046,
-0.2137614787,
-0.0620265901,
0.3089194894,
0.5473439097,
0.3978510797,
-0.4077596962,
-0.4116561115,
-0.8849067092,
-0.1073970571,
0.0302533768,
-0.0268723536,
0.0396373309,
0.5541964769,
-0.2524537444,
0.6221945882,
-0.7201226354,
-0.5006377101,
-0.0709037334,
-0.2943575978,
-0.1640183777,
0.4036324322,
0.5011183023,
-0.7320106626,
-0.3093020916,
0.0361909308,
-0.90041399,
0.0949176103,
-0.3364719152,
-0.1095888466,
0.2896803319,
0.6340280771,
-0.6210437417,
1.0636610985,
0.4299330711,
-0.6415702105,
0.5683644414,
-0.224280417,
0.1418072134,
-0.7543124557,
-0.2575764358,
-0.3001816869,
-0.375482738,
-0.3922334909,
0.0558853298,
0.1268322021,
-0.3095161319,
-0.3969870508,
0.3031748533,
-0.6266133785,
-0.2764960229,
-0.5641095638,
0.1014241949,
0.2549435198,
0.3088205457,
0.52500844,
0.7360540628,
0.952003777,
-0.4338156879,
0.1950772107,
0.5431687832,
-0.6595241427,
0.388951093,
-0.6209551692,
0.0467638262,
-0.1827059537,
-0.0384284146,
-0.3897552192,
-0.1521464586,
0.4692216516,
-0.2588587999,
-0.0301398542,
-0.0316909216,
-0.4786508083,
-0.1608317941,
-0.4264677763,
0.4129880369,
0.5746273994,
-0.9369480014,
0.4171405733,
0.1554128975,
0.1506285369,
-0.3139280975,
-0.7600693107,
0.4739948809,
-0.0347451456,
-0.5246335268,
0.2977612615,
-0.2869153321,
-0.0448897891,
0.1161221117,
-0.2660399675,
0.0079631535,
0.1865084767,
0.1761911064,
0.4230391979,
-0.147609368,
0.0835609213,
-0.1416815072,
-0.0232494399,
0.136665076,
-0.4993466735,
0.649762094,
0.0055123889,
-0.6595152617,
-0.3687752783,
0.7381818891,
0.7002210617,
-0.2149721384,
0.8819829226,
0.4797858,
-0.6409211755,
-0.4298610389,
-0.3435976207,
-0.5203021765,
-0.4252307713,
0.5638131499,
-0.2898329496,
-0.5491580963,
0.2323607206,
0.2618111074,
-0.3085645735,
-0.1209649667,
0.4892219901,
0.2408828586,
1.0870119333,
0.9035717249,
0.3107985556,
0.4249489605,
-0.0310517699,
0.3948854804,
-0.7907339931,
-0.4350757301,
-0.0463241637,
0.1493912339,
-0.0245735571,
-0.7892518044,
0.2192859352,
0.459982872,
0.3855372965,
0.0873637944,
-0.9118288755,
0.9269675016,
0.3857500851,
0.2866127789,
0.3943751454,
0.2400368452,
0.1422603577,
-0.3345797658,
-0.4452306926,
-0.5075407028,
0.9034464359,
0.2853091061,
0.8758714199,
-0.2212212086,
0.6249098778,
0.2702101171,
-0.0903138444,
-1.1035448313,
0.625153482,
-0.0957933292,
-0.0125031602,
-0.0926551372,
-0.1349608302,
-0.4882174134,
0.5223619342,
-0.4691689312,
-0.8302699924,
0.288131237,
0.24111256,
-0.0043504997,
0.5512046814,
-0.4426984489,
0.8173732162,
-0.4191616774,
-0.333776623,
-0.2579403222,
-0.1401546001,
0.3733776808,
0.0519961268,
-0.1253525019,
0.0977950767,
0.1296280473,
0.5316972136,
-0.4312742949,
0.7161476016,
-0.1251159608,
-0.162959978,
0.1518076807,
0.1106566638,
0.7242056727,
0.0868338495,
0.3114939332,
0.1834870875,
-0.0291108824,
-0.3194938898,
-0.6519030333,
0.5027606487,
-0.2012998015,
-0.5276252627,
-0.4388510883,
-0.4621777833,
-0.0137387402,
0.2050080895,
0.5205195546,
0.6065149903,
-0.1330959201,
0.4125618637,
1.0884366035,
-0.3525615931,
0.3357090354,
-0.2193941176,
-0.8712658286,
-0.6296601892,
1.0479536057,
-0.134277612,
0.3237459958,
0.1853388548,
0.0621376708,
-0.191092968,
-0.9132438898,
-0.3868387938,
0.1876471192,
-0.9731196165,
-0.0166593902,
-0.6284382343,
-0.1348669082,
-0.4645449817,
-0.3745777905,
-0.3920248151,
-0.0640453026,
-0.3935004175,
-0.1472114772,
0.168858543,
0.6017935872,
0.136367768,
0.057790298,
-0.7144933343,
0.6990044713,
0.3190129697,
0.387680918,
0.1677674502,
-0.1276840419,
-0.3358594179,
-0.125476554,
-0.1278310418,
-0.8922166824,
0.6999862194,
0.1380445212,
0.3429102004,
0.5812874436,
0.1585065722,
0.7594421506,
-0.6401662827,
0.7913883328,
0.4248351455,
-1.198321104,
0.5301029682,
0.0118539417,
-0.0348991379,
0.2648153901,
-0.1891676635,
-0.6756592989,
-0.3776040375,
-0.2451275438,
-0.7445650697,
0.3625243008,
0.281060338,
-0.0352458544,
-0.1274051517,
0.1706745774,
0.2539797127,
0.198722899,
-0.8012691736,
0.0861042365,
-0.6309143901,
-0.1590977907,
0.0366569348,
-0.408431977,
-0.083758682,
-0.2728859186,
0.3495638669,
-0.3106927872,
0.2824020684,
0.5745847821,
-0.3396672308,
0.1272729635,
-0.1080654263,
0.9251512885,
0.4985714257,
-0.2753168046,
0.2044912875,
0.0065323436,
-0.7451152205,
-0.2654165328,
-0.2791123092,
-0.3220157325,
0.2756765187,
0.4240427613,
1.2215696573,
0.0456290692,
-0.8744071126,
0.7071250677,
-0.0436738543,
-0.4258491993,
-0.3299426138,
-0.0253317598,
-0.1158905774,
0.2461597621,
0.542231679,
0.0235410016,
0.0440722443,
-0.5030418634,
0.3902480304,
0.4820947051,
-0.5044754148,
-0.2291851938,
0.8989768028,
-0.0568948351,
-0.4414381981,
0.4937179685,
0.0403869338,
-0.7554706335,
0.5373088717,
0.8865374923,
1.0865219831,
0.365732789,
0.2012655437,
0.204230234,
0.4002256989,
-0.444553107,
0.0900619403,
-0.1447329968,
-0.5922880173,
-0.4260910451,
-0.6462273598,
-0.5476856828,
0.0250419378,
-0.8831951618,
0.3319919407,
-0.473251164,
0.2233976871,
-0.5220852494,
-0.5550701022,
-0.3462382555,
0.0374883898,
0.4276281893,
0.8452615738,
-0.7513383031,
0.797914505,
0.1808289587,
-0.1475254446,
-0.5707381964,
0.4839777052,
-0.3625560105,
-0.6386235356,
0.4214338958,
0.5735439062,
-0.3166491389,
-0.126933679,
-0.7453246713,
-0.5080449581,
0.8928086162,
0.3376902342,
-0.5041140318,
0.0404112078,
-0.0295830909,
0.2210227847,
-0.4786525369,
-0.3928370178,
0.3205356896,
0.2547309399,
0.2805787027,
-0.5299048424,
0.1717118025,
0.0203683022,
0.0914588794,
0.0912607387,
-0.3822746575,
0.6306373477,
-0.3897880316,
-0.5018609762,
0.0930956081,
0.7103226781,
0.2980189621,
0.411646843,
0.5287888646,
0.3264281154,
0.8326618075,
0.0536050573,
0.8544468284,
-0.0623526946,
0.3502896726,
0.9300541878,
-0.287321806,
0.8670747876,
0.8215597272,
0.3211874068,
0.2380035371,
0.2053188086,
-0.3929676414,
0.8018552065,
0.0480241962,
-0.2611256838,
-0.400880754,
-0.1253140271,
-0.3755883873,
0.3910772204,
0.2513326705,
-0.3211440742,
-0.0610382743,
0.5729209185,
-0.2747702301,
0.3910737038,
-0.3499043882,
0.4938794971,
0.0862260759,
-0.5264454484,
0.8404433131,
-0.4309516847,
0.6690353155,
-0.1570855826,
-0.3628980219,
-0.1343117207,
0.169491604,
-0.0942594185,
-0.7320242524,
0.5400283933,
0.0712453797,
-0.3871290386,
-0.31050542,
0.6937473416,
-0.5999184251,
-0.6021361947,
0.3122594953,
0.1496146172,
0.2290212363,
-0.4316145182,
-0.1925910562,
0.4438646436,
0.2890062034,
0.104591392,
0.229251653,
0.333294332,
-0.1367625445,
0.7324995995,
0.6832172275,
0.2458151579,
0.0187129378,
0.0396774001,
0.8013729453,
-0.9427459836,
-0.4415895045,
-1.0522978306,
0.2310084254,
-0.1973415315,
-0.0878711268,
0.7058111429,
0.5890449286,
0.7379457951,
-0.5720996261,
0.535841763,
0.2762816548,
0.147811383,
-0.9394001961,
0.8807558417,
-0.5170561075,
0.2813201547,
-0.3191544712,
-1.0824098587,
-0.6737830043,
0.8895822763,
0.0973734632,
-0.6582430601,
0.9700198174,
0.8273758292,
-0.0333115123,
-0.1848005652,
0.6918103695,
0.0281173475,
0.4463104904,
0.6224379539,
1.0763492584,
-0.3007798791,
0.9122645259,
-0.284701556,
-0.0820967555,
-0.3361867964,
-1.015386343,
-1.1862379313,
-0.4718534648,
-0.3702694178,
-0.3850544095,
0.0101277409,
0.5923784375,
0.6046967506,
-0.5149842501,
-0.0281733572,
-0.3765239716,
0.1630709916,
-0.298938632,
-0.2236724794,
0.5014905334,
-0.1294874251,
-0.6822458506,
0.3942230344,
0.5416805148,
0.2111754417,
-0.2857692242,
-0.1768531054,
0.3652437031,
0.0409002416,
0.7759538293,
0.1292280257,
-0.9489620924,
-0.5802721381,
0.1966867894,
-0.1056547612,
0.2220856249,
0.6987819076,
-0.9340162277,
0.4656444192,
0.2661864758,
0.6478207111,
0.5127177835,
-0.0439025052,
0.4897583127,
-0.2567701936,
0.406645,
0.1696628928,
0.2689233124,
0.462002784,
-0.4320989847,
0.4300732911,
0.4320667982,
-0.435372591,
-1.2358798981,
0.4369670749,
-1.2154470682,
-0.3743007779,
1.0559542179,
0.0780344531,
-0.5006253719,
0.068470493,
-0.7246961594,
-0.0164948516,
-0.0956391171,
0.9616774321,
0.655046165,
0.1032542363,
-0.4440376461,
-0.3817149997,
0.651648283,
0.4448748827,
-0.6831670403,
0.449750334,
0.676199913,
0.0353038013,
0.0513695963,
0.3544394672,
0.1077279449,
0.3858100176,
0.2263601124,
0.1040441319,
-0.2025170177,
-0.551864326,
-0.3138614893,
0.1852179915,
-0.0085185189,
-0.5529747009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15289v1
|
Let's Rectify Step by Step: Improving Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis with Diffusion Models
| 2024-02-23T12:35:43 | 2024-02-23T12:35:43 |
Shunyu Liu, Jie Zhou, Qunxi Zhu, Qin Chen, Qingchun Bai, Jun Xiao, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) stands as a crucial task in predicting
the sentiment polarity associated with identified aspects within text. However,
a notable challenge in ABSA lies in precisely determining the aspects'
boundaries (start and end indices), especially for long ones, due to users'
colloquial expressions. We propose DiffusionABSA, a novel diffusion model
tailored for ABSA, which extracts the aspects progressively step by step.
Particularly, DiffusionABSA gradually adds noise to the aspect terms in the
training process, subsequently learning a denoising process that progressively
restores these terms in a reverse manner. To estimate the boundaries, we design
a denoising neural network enhanced by a syntax-aware temporal attention
mechanism to chronologically capture the interplay between aspects and
surrounding text. Empirical evaluations conducted on eight benchmark datasets
underscore the compelling advantages offered by DiffusionABSA when compared
against robust baseline models. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Qlb6x/DiffusionABSA.
|
[
-0.5396504998,
-0.8459869027,
0.8427038193,
0.5875977278,
-0.5007462502,
0.1371662468,
0.0828311592,
-0.146025002,
0.4643561542,
0.5124393106,
-0.5861007571,
-0.5938611627,
-0.6526026726,
-0.1306733191,
-0.5330243707,
1.1761289835,
0.0209040605,
-0.104630433,
-0.3394044042,
-0.3020963371,
-0.2442118824,
-0.2508991957,
-1.0181057453,
-0.5340849757,
0.5988402963,
-0.0508618206,
0.4416489005,
0.0767303258,
0.1413188875,
0.2127413601,
-0.7425615788,
-0.1061710119,
-0.054639779,
0.2062637061,
-0.2115867585,
-0.33813411,
-0.5836436152,
-0.1147837043,
0.4109513462,
0.9647551775,
-0.223746717,
-0.0066707339,
0.1215686277,
1.0747907162,
-0.3088971674,
0.1897313893,
-0.2706333101,
0.0296208914,
-0.0171316881,
0.1690044403,
-0.2176997215,
-0.4477292895,
0.1600575298,
-0.2459230721,
0.2803025842,
-0.2602262497,
0.770527482,
0.0248392038,
-0.2412301153,
0.0433293059,
-0.6506502032,
0.7018196583,
-0.7663602829,
0.4516250193,
0.1453711241,
-0.1572984904,
0.0736080706,
-0.4362875521,
-0.524667263,
0.0493025407,
0.0184948258,
0.1336738318,
-0.2877401412,
-0.1091459319,
0.0321483724,
0.4512728155,
-0.2673969865,
-0.1571902186,
-0.2175243348,
-0.1177818626,
0.4553365409,
0.098542735,
0.0580160245,
-0.3361049592,
-0.0720044002,
0.2233201712,
-0.5467103124,
0.2440066487,
0.4059631824,
0.2168789953,
-0.2887427807,
0.244059667,
-0.3115505576,
0.4314186573,
0.247993812,
0.2011038363,
0.4891896844,
-0.2626310587,
-0.1594577581,
-0.342143923,
0.7252965569,
0.3936653435,
-0.3227021992,
-0.0494557545,
-0.3618786037,
-0.0560991503,
0.454775095,
-0.6884015799,
-0.2655187547,
0.4745857716,
-0.3838256299,
-0.2492810488,
-0.3286477625,
-1.1307342052,
-0.6753748655,
-0.4484839141,
0.217871502,
-0.3052218854,
-0.4434329271,
-0.1214305013,
-0.0876357928,
0.0800493583,
0.4745540917,
-0.358763814,
0.1859976649,
0.9048325419,
1.3033100367,
0.0433003828,
0.2155633867,
-0.216089204,
-0.4853253365,
-0.4134596586,
0.9028073549,
-0.7024184465,
-0.4149051309,
-0.0738275647,
-0.1612893492,
0.1625821292,
-0.4579748213,
0.2555530071,
-0.7595225573,
0.2059931606,
-0.206159994,
-0.3291986585,
-0.5206785202,
0.4184342027,
-0.6227157712,
0.9604524374,
0.1706002355,
-0.6440219283,
0.0365582407,
-0.7733183503,
-0.5607444644,
-0.3545045257,
0.1955226958,
-0.6796920896,
0.2966802418,
0.4269466102,
0.475522548,
0.0425876826,
0.2531889677,
-0.2465946674,
0.2827675939,
0.2363525778,
-0.4069570601,
0.5934218764,
0.2039463818,
-0.0211394224,
0.2142383903,
-0.6010409594,
-0.4351328015,
-0.2429462075,
0.0418492816,
-0.728703022,
0.0335855968,
-0.1522742659,
0.1209568679,
0.3893597722,
-0.6572833061,
0.0413198397,
-0.6806644797,
0.5439267755,
0.7437549829,
0.429780066,
0.7835686803,
-0.052484747,
0.5944598317,
0.5733321905,
0.3681990802,
-0.1436743438,
-0.4993598163,
-0.6907577515,
-0.2258989215,
0.198749274,
0.2784669101,
-0.6691781878,
0.5232542157,
-0.1082229614,
-0.5178371072,
-0.5659323335,
0.3166904151,
0.1634956598,
0.5327432156,
0.3301127851,
-0.9042505622,
-0.3521531522,
-0.750623107,
-0.01170428,
-0.2506099045,
0.1040581465,
0.0679182932,
0.2651640475,
-0.0930947512,
1.1650333405,
-0.4604882896,
-0.4158443213,
-0.3784467876,
0.5377839208,
0.2087008059,
0.1717621684,
0.4879001379,
-0.8716683388,
-0.3747017384,
-0.0703304559,
-0.4900474846,
-0.3535245061,
-0.3222668767,
-0.2462848127,
0.1200966984,
0.5754944682,
-0.4645941257,
0.38234061,
0.5384269357,
-0.3645884097,
0.3514227569,
0.205970794,
-0.035730809,
-1.2910364866,
-0.0144605841,
0.4615923166,
-0.2978590429,
-0.4275581837,
-0.0334768631,
-0.1013645381,
0.0849145278,
-0.4246731102,
0.5817907453,
-0.3421052992,
0.1117015406,
-0.4285250604,
0.2580613494,
0.3142988682,
0.4714507163,
-0.1000218242,
0.611122191,
0.5668157339,
-0.5137892962,
-0.2119657844,
0.0602242239,
0.010631687,
0.7552301288,
-0.5211544633,
0.0436517298,
-0.4468040764,
0.1934100389,
-1.0476107597,
0.3493958712,
0.4854528308,
-0.2806943655,
0.2831428051,
-0.4318051934,
-0.009050969,
-0.0249292292,
-0.5603969097,
0.4248241782,
0.5663540959,
-0.2369158268,
1.1827867031,
0.3648480177,
-0.4862355888,
-0.4099394679,
-0.2056599408,
0.1252331734,
-0.1057299748,
-0.2808483243,
0.1961476207,
0.0226308629,
-0.3590107858,
0.1626112461,
-0.1207370907,
-0.2591525316,
0.1139476299,
0.3687517941,
-0.1244439557,
0.0383998267,
0.0287324302,
0.5702801347,
-0.0013073805,
0.3921551406,
-0.0506758727,
0.6108820438,
0.1107725725,
-0.0144794025,
-0.5573558807,
0.2620157301,
0.5731679797,
-0.300144881,
0.6154097915,
0.4743211269,
-0.1473392695,
-0.1921954751,
-0.3935022056,
-0.009068192,
-0.4154543281,
0.3885342777,
-0.0870394334,
-0.4634634256,
0.8181170821,
-0.0866220817,
0.1895483881,
0.3561060429,
0.3049120009,
-0.1148698404,
0.811460793,
0.9836767316,
-0.3015542328,
0.924095273,
-0.4538245499,
0.3901598155,
-1.3500968218,
-0.3075559437,
-0.355551064,
-0.1670483649,
-0.0232128911,
-0.377128154,
0.3394159079,
0.3023664653,
0.1176376864,
0.0389253311,
-0.2030490637,
0.3421009183,
0.2181459665,
0.3851131201,
0.2219183892,
0.0306726396,
0.2938549221,
0.033297088,
-0.2610003352,
-0.360460937,
0.8310896158,
0.6404947639,
0.6556381583,
0.0644760057,
0.9035006762,
0.5363508463,
0.7207326889,
-0.9709306359,
0.6204060316,
-0.3632813096,
-0.0941768885,
-0.1137732342,
-0.4052113593,
-0.7204691768,
0.2917582393,
0.1875794232,
-0.4710279703,
0.2592387497,
-0.0369516797,
-0.4169038236,
0.251218617,
-0.469448179,
0.5381982327,
0.3187036812,
-0.3148491979,
-0.4669290781,
-0.4146744609,
0.1810770929,
-0.0748787224,
0.4925233126,
-0.2441582084,
-0.128152281,
0.897952199,
-0.4121441841,
1.3364890814,
-0.3859710991,
-0.3318677843,
0.4227328897,
0.2711898088,
0.0398347676,
0.1845022142,
0.0429828502,
0.4476162195,
-0.2261884362,
-0.2931460738,
-0.7425097823,
0.6615008712,
-0.5199002624,
-0.5263418555,
-0.3111543059,
-0.2548841238,
-0.0824697018,
0.0870932192,
-0.0641989782,
0.5013663769,
-0.2884941399,
-0.2781741917,
0.715405643,
0.1780658364,
0.7114368677,
0.5542359352,
-0.4430515468,
-0.4631400108,
0.8501145244,
0.0131865824,
-0.0354592875,
0.3231913149,
0.1329848617,
-0.3315156996,
-0.7074202895,
-0.4651458561,
0.4126160443,
-0.5689839125,
-0.2765069306,
-0.8132312298,
-0.1060090512,
-0.309261173,
-0.0371734686,
-0.5543807745,
-0.2591895461,
-0.6246619225,
-0.0214246679,
0.3792101145,
0.9820298553,
0.0601818822,
0.4429307878,
-0.8403913975,
0.1848320067,
-0.041336868,
0.4161071777,
0.3128621578,
-0.8222844005,
-0.1898594201,
-0.1038628295,
-0.4155290425,
-0.9019729495,
0.565302968,
0.0759143606,
0.237832427,
0.4035583436,
-0.1280514002,
0.4142180085,
-0.4377173483,
1.0525736809,
0.1302264333,
-1.0499818325,
0.5763655901,
0.0988379419,
0.2684654593,
0.3194851577,
0.4554792345,
-0.6023721099,
-0.7442273498,
-0.4498608708,
-1.1192566156,
0.2068581879,
0.2331553698,
0.4292321801,
-0.0842428803,
0.6216050982,
0.3012512922,
0.2300750166,
-0.6946507692,
-0.1765280068,
-0.2400932312,
-0.5145947337,
0.0089601269,
-0.3264660239,
-0.0950656161,
-0.1477888674,
0.7737414837,
0.0211478099,
0.0499295443,
0.2693310082,
-0.1032876745,
0.1435064673,
0.4635178447,
0.2731851935,
0.502804637,
0.0674154982,
-0.0228290763,
-0.1553259939,
-0.4912610054,
0.1029890031,
0.1508564651,
-0.515544951,
0.0462097861,
0.2227432877,
0.5359295011,
-0.1783990711,
-0.2097457647,
0.526052177,
-0.0610891059,
0.1453850567,
-0.2744915187,
-0.195292756,
0.0753943622,
0.478218168,
0.2185476422,
0.1778802425,
0.2937687337,
-0.3985637426,
0.1585927159,
0.4335025847,
-0.6668601036,
-0.6839584112,
0.3733397126,
0.5122792721,
-0.1815924942,
0.3465670049,
-0.4511495233,
-0.6400324702,
0.5765589476,
-0.0743801072,
1.1716374159,
-0.0856380537,
0.6359599233,
0.1711648852,
0.1338433027,
-0.0714981556,
0.3730705976,
-0.0077397977,
-0.5824182034,
-0.4600180387,
-0.9386122227,
-0.2578763068,
-0.2428058982,
-0.7474567294,
-0.1760649681,
-0.69014889,
-0.4027185142,
0.0565039702,
-0.3265497386,
-0.3613303304,
0.0993006304,
-0.0091461027,
0.705693543,
-1.1912664175,
0.4833367169,
0.6308219433,
-0.6493174434,
-0.2148422599,
0.3162102997,
-0.2411860377,
-0.1986175776,
0.3086965382,
0.1927082688,
-0.2122875303,
-0.2958517671,
-0.4781914353,
-0.4448153377,
0.7210713029,
-0.2375589609,
-0.5007250905,
0.3187470436,
-0.2422973812,
0.8205934763,
-0.3377147913,
0.1363259107,
0.5252244473,
0.0235669985,
-0.3611235023,
-0.44966501,
0.0165136363,
-0.0973523483,
0.0543615669,
0.4613555074,
-0.7488926053,
0.8680664301,
-0.0661329255,
-0.0924387574,
0.2215084136,
1.0866376162,
-0.3598554134,
0.6752348542,
0.7186099291,
0.7117031217,
0.4515331388,
-0.1030788347,
0.766807735,
-0.1267721504,
0.2954452336,
0.9782767892,
-0.289942652,
0.9743939042,
0.5614063144,
-0.224459663,
1.2252142429,
0.4909583926,
0.4950793087,
0.5711593032,
-0.1780639589,
-0.3875081539,
-0.2873610854,
-0.255128026,
-0.1265428662,
-0.0297075398,
0.4495431185,
-0.4463430345,
-0.2602349222,
0.2660008669,
0.1047064215,
0.0958378613,
-0.531519711,
0.9998201728,
0.2216375917,
-0.5006588697,
-0.1336866468,
-0.0684927329,
0.7491953373,
-0.5488772988,
-0.0776814371,
-0.8821593523,
-0.0137091856,
-0.1865726262,
-1.1743907928,
0.5089803934,
-0.0922012404,
-0.5076783299,
-0.0757433996,
0.3110364676,
-0.4823024273,
-0.6282621026,
0.317797482,
0.3496215045,
-0.0294488873,
-0.3631381691,
-0.7373010516,
-0.0192053411,
0.0106020737,
-0.4622934461,
0.2930111885,
0.5289281011,
-0.1380989105,
0.6613383889,
0.3575915396,
0.0983899087,
-0.2055689394,
0.4184947312,
0.8922041059,
-0.7311969399,
-0.7183684111,
-0.813107729,
0.4629622102,
-0.1604559273,
-0.2477756143,
0.4878000617,
0.414079845,
0.5285602212,
0.1989609599,
0.6423663497,
-0.0713468865,
0.5661010742,
-0.6978363395,
0.6728101373,
-0.6672446132,
0.6052095294,
-0.0958907753,
-0.8859673142,
-0.2829599679,
0.318906039,
-0.3003794551,
0.1173477471,
0.5795764327,
0.8349640965,
-0.0545192063,
-0.1017230824,
-0.051944226,
0.3890890181,
0.5116153955,
0.2031886429,
0.7113780379,
-0.2475731969,
0.2732625306,
-0.7023646832,
-0.384573698,
0.0467426106,
-0.8907094002,
-0.7995807528,
-0.5209265947,
-0.7329724431,
-0.514365375,
0.0269164089,
0.5522614717,
0.4190934002,
-0.7589408755,
0.0270201247,
-0.0713779479,
0.3867093921,
-0.4259718657,
-0.331985265,
0.2821229398,
-0.4462375045,
-0.6605607271,
0.0810723603,
0.2764641345,
0.0414550714,
-0.660187304,
0.2210778445,
-0.0112395901,
0.3556470573,
0.8613196015,
0.1903768629,
-0.6698724627,
-0.2750592828,
-0.3238286078,
0.0501828194,
0.1651661843,
0.8970607519,
-0.7296972871,
0.3963750899,
0.5880628824,
0.3834184706,
0.1517157257,
0.1800768971,
0.3914127946,
-1.0238059759,
0.0535556786,
0.3090592623,
0.4427435994,
0.5616910458,
-0.2535390556,
0.3575870991,
0.2860143185,
-0.2494588196,
-0.566305697,
0.2474885732,
-1.1786118746,
-0.5077341795,
1.0659344196,
-0.1762407422,
-0.4909501672,
-0.3703595698,
-0.2742705643,
0.0558946393,
-0.776381135,
0.9268291593,
0.5845372081,
-0.2283629775,
-0.1638719589,
-0.0387669429,
0.3766722083,
0.6237494349,
-0.6391311884,
0.3768736422,
0.6183972955,
0.5132420659,
0.339309603,
0.7778123617,
-0.142415449,
0.0083849207,
-0.1584800035,
0.131554693,
0.0379509069,
-0.5674208403,
-0.7643783689,
0.3120026886,
0.0680708587,
-0.1033287719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15268v1
|
MemoryPrompt: A Light Wrapper to Improve Context Tracking in Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-02-23T11:30:39 | 2024-02-23T11:30:39 |
Nathanaël Carraz Rakotonirina, Marco Baroni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based language models (LMs) track contextual information through
large, hard-coded input windows. We introduce MemoryPrompt, a leaner approach
in which the LM is complemented by a small auxiliary recurrent network that
passes information to the LM by prefixing its regular input with a sequence of
vectors, akin to soft prompts, without requiring LM finetuning. Tested on a
task designed to probe a LM's ability to keep track of multiple fact updates, a
MemoryPrompt-augmented LM outperforms much larger LMs that have access to the
full input history. We also test MemoryPrompt on a long-distance dialogue
dataset, where its performance is comparable to that of a model conditioned on
the entire conversation history. In both experiments we also observe that,
unlike full-finetuning approaches, MemoryPrompt does not suffer from
catastrophic forgetting when adapted to new tasks, thus not disrupting the
generalist capabilities of the underlying LM.
|
[
-0.4821167588,
-0.7804258466,
0.6972348094,
-0.0233337879,
-0.2601493001,
-0.5336639285,
-0.5012215376,
-0.1594917923,
0.3561718166,
0.4970972538,
-0.6831048131,
-0.397277534,
-0.3990978301,
-0.3691228926,
-0.5697639585,
1.15583992,
-0.0354381464,
-0.0762202069,
-0.0663266629,
-0.4862475991,
-0.7088521123,
-0.5940678716,
-0.5981534719,
-0.2441198975,
0.8000140786,
0.3638249934,
0.7795554399,
0.263412267,
0.3367643952,
0.1480301917,
0.0398494862,
-0.07259579,
-0.4085420668,
0.3755005896,
-0.2815378308,
-0.42226246,
-0.4447881281,
-0.0652020574,
0.4435106218,
0.7850408554,
-0.4264566302,
0.194470197,
0.1990137845,
0.3803377151,
-0.867076993,
-0.0018960004,
-0.550661087,
-0.2266410142,
-0.0929148123,
-0.3859617412,
-0.5881256461,
0.0481791869,
0.1407742947,
-0.2458985001,
0.342976898,
0.0223933551,
0.6551157832,
0.3050139844,
-0.0330559686,
-0.1789997369,
-0.7823649645,
0.7626418471,
-0.5733755231,
0.6006199718,
0.5055152178,
0.3324144781,
-0.1348593086,
-0.8667823672,
-0.5079030395,
-0.4092830122,
-0.1908414364,
0.0772971138,
-0.1017678827,
-0.0294724442,
0.2890079618,
0.1036794633,
-0.4310489297,
-0.2114061117,
-0.1340043545,
-0.3135438561,
0.039920859,
0.0775615051,
0.222099334,
0.3087359965,
-0.2839125097,
-0.0027119454,
-0.7845663428,
-0.010813199,
-0.1937037855,
0.1706442833,
0.1312624067,
0.0913866907,
-0.0306232069,
1.0844824314,
0.0198005792,
-0.1782193184,
-0.0241814293,
-0.1769624501,
-0.2000870854,
0.1309968382,
0.7182675004,
0.3516505659,
0.3215012252,
-0.3494036198,
-0.2252572477,
0.0184814744,
0.2464500517,
-0.9467096925,
-0.4377818704,
0.0364986658,
-0.1464236826,
0.3273994923,
-0.0647561178,
-0.4064913392,
-0.0080685532,
-0.3167824745,
0.4657212794,
-0.7312948108,
-0.161677599,
0.0645710453,
0.1540935338,
0.0711906627,
0.612654388,
-1.0151032209,
0.3633541465,
0.7229945064,
0.9827661514,
-0.3712728918,
-0.3131233752,
-0.7398320436,
0.133013472,
-0.1890889853,
0.7771080732,
-0.5609661341,
-0.0374671221,
-0.1555509567,
0.0632156879,
-0.1810556501,
-0.6717428565,
0.3900042474,
-0.4856198728,
0.479282558,
-0.0658738166,
-0.6020270586,
0.0606425963,
0.3246757686,
-0.8245505095,
0.9980975389,
0.1955828816,
-0.7628496885,
0.3464913368,
-0.324316442,
-0.3802630901,
-0.0579532199,
-0.3220324516,
-0.1882085949,
0.2869020104,
0.0179450698,
0.5512855649,
0.0318514407,
0.6475695372,
-0.1359007955,
-0.6599809527,
0.2130484879,
-0.5462861061,
0.3425013125,
0.1247012094,
-0.2292045802,
0.1853214949,
-0.5999044776,
-0.1982523203,
-0.1632091552,
-0.35480389,
-0.5704932809,
0.0875586942,
0.0004464143,
0.1186784282,
0.1274682432,
-0.4010772109,
0.4252174795,
-0.1696939468,
0.3189154565,
0.4818382263,
-0.0635056198,
0.4608592689,
-0.1833589077,
0.4167329669,
0.2606386542,
0.1877451241,
-0.7732010484,
-0.3820398748,
-0.9858673215,
-0.2146059275,
0.2044650167,
0.57882303,
-0.7750884295,
0.3305302262,
-0.2778879702,
-0.0504112318,
-0.2367968261,
0.1153113395,
0.2014396638,
0.6965107918,
0.5265833735,
-0.3175325692,
-0.4577944875,
-0.7462717891,
-0.3270171285,
0.0930555686,
-0.3133116364,
0.090956144,
0.3199585378,
-0.2659747601,
1.1145219803,
-0.4687566459,
-0.2321310788,
-0.2303766459,
0.0497548468,
0.3116326332,
0.5498965383,
0.4718289673,
-0.5814108253,
-0.0354335383,
-0.4999791086,
-0.2285560817,
-0.1026114747,
-0.1520244777,
0.0575504415,
0.2692278326,
0.7083167434,
-0.9975045323,
0.3239299655,
0.5130337477,
-0.670176506,
0.414034158,
-0.0455592349,
0.0430508181,
-1.0932408571,
0.2262727916,
-0.1708117574,
-0.5287238955,
-0.8096107244,
-0.2196773291,
0.1364004612,
-0.0678577572,
-0.7030269504,
0.7357643247,
-0.2277710587,
0.1062482819,
-0.439558357,
-0.0067979791,
-0.031441398,
0.5638179779,
0.2844495475,
0.8861582875,
0.5083335638,
-0.8157519102,
0.196863547,
-0.2598274648,
-0.3984811604,
0.5410758257,
-0.218581304,
0.3065719008,
-0.2048517764,
0.393122822,
-0.9568095207,
0.0777157396,
0.0892306194,
-0.2966525853,
0.4494712055,
-0.0142353624,
-0.3439874053,
-0.0035147953,
-0.1724617928,
0.4163279533,
0.5931738615,
-0.513569355,
0.7249663472,
-0.1376280934,
-0.0922967345,
-0.504359901,
-0.6421934366,
0.2760510743,
-0.3621468544,
-0.2115653902,
0.4072095454,
-0.0502988696,
-0.1055596024,
-0.0235942584,
-0.278003931,
-0.3223239779,
0.1013335437,
0.0773008913,
0.2276756465,
-0.4412260652,
0.2287914306,
-0.3741744161,
-0.326051712,
-0.005437077,
-0.4721405804,
0.7044587731,
-0.0821255594,
-0.2348034829,
-0.3340661526,
0.2194677442,
0.4414089024,
0.1472147554,
0.872291863,
0.7270120978,
-0.3317673206,
-0.3713607788,
-0.7489218116,
-0.5647329688,
-0.4562930465,
0.2329651564,
-0.4067281783,
-1.1560862064,
0.4787118137,
-0.1733308583,
0.0021107618,
0.1334264576,
0.3839601874,
-0.2502459288,
0.8179644942,
0.7703270912,
-0.2462843508,
0.7526325583,
0.1306749135,
0.1729187667,
-0.791102469,
-0.0302201472,
-0.1299514771,
-0.3285300136,
-0.0053952774,
-0.5626990795,
0.1422055811,
0.3732606471,
-0.148749426,
0.4614878297,
-0.2479588538,
0.4772705436,
0.5480953455,
0.013060146,
0.3146787286,
-0.2085675299,
0.0278799441,
-0.1928283274,
-1.0520027876,
-0.1615951359,
0.7448491454,
0.1441506594,
0.9509215951,
-0.0818987638,
0.4991281331,
0.0965115353,
0.6332039237,
-0.9246106744,
0.5250304341,
-0.0511770062,
-0.3443741202,
-0.040836215,
-0.4179490507,
-0.7130070925,
0.0509879403,
0.2657293379,
-1.0066429377,
-0.062568143,
0.7159756422,
-0.614906013,
0.1899494827,
-0.5728325248,
0.8575661778,
-0.2864946425,
-0.6088858843,
0.0159245729,
-0.3520693779,
0.4542421997,
0.0556545034,
0.0071986211,
0.0026016445,
0.01807319,
0.869220078,
-0.4526780248,
0.8939900398,
-0.278630048,
-0.1162794977,
0.3417237401,
0.3975804746,
0.5223382711,
-0.1087653637,
0.3851260841,
-0.0527866781,
-0.0142290723,
-0.2430917472,
-0.9769399762,
0.8391135335,
-0.1632291526,
-0.5474072099,
-0.0500907116,
-0.7176605463,
-0.2829878628,
0.0915592313,
0.4360640645,
0.6089836955,
-0.0822931007,
0.3382680714,
1.0788673162,
-0.2217880189,
0.524672091,
0.710695684,
-0.3747332394,
-0.0597709492,
0.75693506,
0.1149357632,
0.2435728014,
0.3433862031,
0.2184546143,
-0.2077939808,
-0.2848712802,
-0.3438381255,
-0.1223526075,
-0.8226671219,
-0.2338698208,
-0.6322132945,
-0.1311644018,
-0.1118334159,
-0.1378199309,
-0.6676041484,
-0.3953132629,
-0.1126769781,
0.0774276704,
0.5605775118,
0.3041775525,
0.3707160652,
0.4983477592,
-0.5524824262,
0.4425078928,
0.2102920264,
0.5438572764,
-0.2384726703,
-0.6643718481,
-0.3177149594,
-0.286444366,
0.0145272231,
-0.7667908669,
0.1420316398,
0.2675133348,
0.3899237216,
0.5027675033,
-0.0526952334,
0.7690332532,
-0.6755203605,
0.7724824548,
0.3977956772,
-0.7809738517,
0.666831851,
-0.1887747794,
0.8540564775,
0.7951375246,
0.2915885746,
-0.6277915835,
-0.4379038811,
-0.5867272615,
-0.7605503798,
0.5404475331,
-0.1489975601,
0.2105024606,
-0.0253902059,
0.5269899964,
-0.1404477656,
0.0117901945,
-0.6336193681,
-0.2191771716,
-0.272583276,
-0.5092474222,
-0.1014048234,
-0.4631938934,
-0.0366147533,
-0.5086326003,
0.2137457877,
-0.1802413762,
0.2085608691,
0.3546891212,
-0.3665677607,
0.277567625,
0.4121676385,
0.835567832,
0.8771330714,
-0.2898035944,
0.6426121593,
0.4551074803,
-0.612496376,
0.1344219595,
-0.2409000844,
-0.3797944486,
0.2977760732,
0.6462960243,
1.0243221521,
0.6488050818,
-0.7075962424,
0.6142676473,
-0.1090707257,
-0.1333737671,
-0.4144540131,
0.4403665066,
0.1808726043,
-0.0647965074,
0.3103339374,
0.0705606714,
0.1332202554,
-0.6982589364,
0.580721736,
0.2738072872,
-0.8410607576,
-0.5259546041,
0.6506668925,
-0.1103474721,
-0.4634542167,
0.4702868164,
0.0472765528,
-0.5028539896,
0.1735434532,
0.7817344666,
0.7378620505,
-0.6234240532,
-0.2176621705,
0.3120589852,
0.1876153499,
-0.4579895139,
0.0776617378,
-0.4068138301,
-0.7618591189,
-0.6688928604,
-0.5237925649,
-0.2814554572,
0.5482342839,
-0.7744902372,
0.222446695,
-0.3897207677,
-0.2301256657,
-0.4218688011,
-0.4334396422,
-0.7977699637,
0.1557765454,
0.3480083048,
1.2766641378,
-0.8415766954,
1.3503938913,
0.4259346426,
-0.0841098502,
-0.6134211421,
0.1260187924,
-0.1464016587,
-0.5441911221,
0.5715475082,
0.4766537249,
-0.4407276809,
-0.0038353619,
-0.4548357129,
-0.9759400487,
0.9249119163,
0.5469101667,
-0.7921850085,
0.0629165694,
-0.1801632643,
0.40159145,
-0.3637472689,
0.3152315319,
1.0896766186,
0.363901794,
0.154891938,
-0.838088572,
0.0907812491,
-0.1936057657,
-0.3039371669,
0.2041193098,
-0.419608742,
0.7943097353,
-0.0738766268,
-0.32345137,
-0.1401412189,
0.7155385613,
0.2425767481,
0.2209608853,
0.494603157,
0.7184257507,
0.4603006542,
-0.0874071121,
1.0514398813,
-0.382476002,
0.1877541095,
1.6688215733,
-0.2947911918,
0.8823528886,
0.7386431694,
0.1876187772,
0.5660553575,
0.1058632061,
0.2464111894,
0.6816625595,
0.1400460452,
-0.2828990519,
-0.1702378243,
-0.0350217186,
-0.1671447307,
0.258776933,
0.4711515605,
-0.2272162139,
-0.2575890422,
0.2906853557,
0.4747200012,
-0.0633665249,
-0.2431287467,
0.7065792084,
0.2017607838,
-1.0773535967,
0.690726459,
-0.1646303385,
0.8271972537,
-0.8164886832,
0.0094607156,
-0.5072281361,
0.4940834641,
-0.0267355535,
-0.5855005383,
0.4692642391,
0.0716804788,
-0.1401126832,
-0.3770434558,
0.7718468308,
-0.7530174255,
-0.3797338903,
0.3826645315,
0.4088806808,
-0.0509863235,
-0.3482098579,
-0.5255739093,
0.3308200836,
-0.3025361598,
-0.773440659,
0.3499073982,
0.2119550705,
-0.124458991,
0.7262875438,
0.2412421703,
0.0610207319,
0.0628770441,
0.4127138555,
0.8735188246,
-0.942158699,
-0.4080912769,
-1.1945956945,
0.2096941173,
0.1258073002,
-0.35915488,
0.8056508899,
0.5234735608,
0.6258144975,
0.0789223164,
0.3716228902,
0.1700849682,
0.4018528163,
-0.8159617186,
0.5569786429,
-0.1921498477,
0.2094380856,
0.0118012726,
-1.0273290873,
-0.3833007812,
0.5076059103,
-0.2727180421,
-0.1051592603,
0.9585023522,
0.8373193741,
-0.4906580448,
-0.1585213393,
0.2920391858,
0.0658756569,
0.1644915789,
0.8967527151,
1.0424557924,
-0.2052340508,
0.364428848,
-0.1147231385,
-0.1586896479,
-0.1444760412,
-0.8687958121,
-0.8852075934,
-0.6081623435,
-0.2860544026,
-0.1041077375,
-0.1261088103,
0.6276372075,
1.0259221792,
-0.9673493505,
-0.1073128358,
-0.1665620804,
-0.189058587,
-0.2033858001,
-0.2613501847,
0.3906628191,
-0.475957185,
-0.3471449912,
0.6059818268,
0.2723277509,
-0.0991346389,
-0.3322704732,
-0.0888978913,
-0.0157864392,
0.036316555,
0.6323507428,
0.124793306,
-0.6660900116,
-0.4874617159,
-0.1874034256,
0.026509624,
0.1018899158,
1.2290403843,
-1.1364774704,
0.1865141243,
0.351190567,
0.5306104422,
0.6197366118,
0.0740298405,
0.5423411727,
-0.8332152367,
0.6653641462,
0.2588553727,
0.5147535205,
0.3578262329,
-0.2956320643,
0.1733609587,
0.1011779979,
-0.2745782733,
-0.6412065625,
0.3774771392,
-0.8361312151,
-0.6160625815,
0.8905596137,
-0.2048140913,
-0.3677746952,
-0.1737134755,
-0.0643522069,
-0.0099148992,
-0.1181526184,
0.5679365396,
0.6795534492,
-0.2498128116,
-0.6040766835,
-0.9491550326,
0.7325108647,
0.7092894912,
-0.5359168649,
0.1688825339,
0.5242434144,
0.3974746764,
0.1441989243,
1.0163602829,
0.2332479656,
0.2412085533,
-0.1878066063,
0.0318851285,
-0.1392726153,
-0.8372538686,
-0.3322193325,
0.2399556488,
-0.0632712319,
-0.0572533198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15265v1
|
CloChat: Understanding How People Customize, Interact, and Experience Personas in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T11:25:17 | 2024-02-23T11:25:17 |
Juhye Ha, Hyeon Jeon, DaEun Han, Jinwook Seo, Changhoon Oh
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have facilitated significant strides in
generating conversational agents, enabling seamless, contextually relevant
dialogues across diverse topics. However, the existing LLM-driven
conversational agents have fixed personalities and functionalities, limiting
their adaptability to individual user needs. Creating personalized agent
personas with distinct expertise or traits can address this issue. Nonetheless,
we lack knowledge of how people customize and interact with agent personas. In
this research, we investigated how users customize agent personas and their
impact on interaction quality, diversity, and dynamics. To this end, we
developed CloChat, an interface supporting easy and accurate customization of
agent personas in LLMs. We conducted a study comparing how participants
interact with CloChat and ChatGPT. The results indicate that participants
formed emotional bonds with the customized agents, engaged in more dynamic
dialogues, and showed interest in sustaining interactions. These findings
contribute to design implications for future systems with conversational agents
using LLMs.
|
[
-0.5801178813,
-0.5787453651,
0.8067940474,
0.1677256376,
-0.1066397429,
0.5448423028,
-0.3691075444,
-0.688988328,
0.4232377112,
0.587595582,
-0.5988028049,
-0.5541936755,
-0.3487039804,
-0.1261198223,
0.0467174798,
0.9381843209,
0.1887407452,
-0.1680089533,
-0.0969037935,
-0.2087986022,
-0.5874435902,
-0.5832520723,
-0.5769075155,
-0.4334460497,
0.5360354185,
0.4842580557,
0.972905755,
0.1686975509,
0.3909235299,
0.4201671183,
0.0459545553,
0.0394857973,
-0.6985704303,
0.6656717658,
-0.3816398382,
-0.3553774357,
-0.4702217877,
-0.0587032214,
0.3369069099,
0.5510280728,
-0.2479298711,
0.0121032381,
0.0171268471,
0.4856109023,
-0.261107564,
0.4555540085,
-0.4430803359,
-0.1154901087,
-0.1613915265,
-0.3002245426,
-0.3092075288,
-0.3794742227,
0.5390839577,
-0.5283225775,
-0.1169766337,
-0.1265203506,
0.4783594906,
0.2138199061,
-0.6935970187,
-0.5669544935,
-0.8393412232,
0.6200687289,
-0.7732626796,
0.2142553926,
0.106982179,
0.6214700937,
-0.5820096135,
-0.5821496248,
-0.3072302639,
-0.4858857691,
-0.3618912697,
-0.0263649728,
0.0324815921,
0.2019761056,
0.0815005973,
0.2804794908,
-0.5036031008,
0.0796142519,
-0.049698174,
-0.0617156513,
0.6305656433,
0.5140640736,
0.6002275348,
0.2098763138,
-0.0565068461,
-0.0268583857,
-0.3413643837,
0.2821014524,
0.491702199,
0.1760416031,
-0.1446685791,
0.4365778267,
-0.2089331448,
0.4411737323,
0.3563128114,
-0.2763449848,
0.2483979017,
0.1717768162,
-0.063210763,
-0.0466500856,
0.5882403255,
0.3403366208,
0.5960795879,
-0.1434973627,
0.0488176532,
-0.3113417029,
0.1027664617,
-0.8659548163,
-0.1634534895,
0.4197722673,
-0.3380057812,
-0.1830930114,
0.0245694369,
-0.711658299,
-0.8176425099,
-0.4334409833,
0.0361148641,
-0.3479190171,
-0.1878779083,
0.0691244379,
-0.2128067911,
0.2128122151,
0.7472445965,
-0.8162333965,
0.3542648554,
0.5953589082,
0.6236180663,
-0.1931938529,
-0.3898068368,
-0.5175255537,
0.3303178847,
0.0041338368,
0.6929938197,
-0.9197217226,
-0.3297227919,
0.059835244,
-0.0370662771,
-0.0141813559,
-0.4213142097,
0.0246549845,
-0.5460159779,
0.0083050197,
-0.4901624322,
-0.5026549101,
-0.1283899844,
0.3564525545,
-0.4627567232,
0.3008919954,
0.2854897976,
-0.5812734962,
0.1813759506,
-0.7500934601,
-0.4322265089,
0.5040066242,
-0.1557139456,
0.1897380501,
0.1137252748,
-0.1111305058,
0.4213326871,
-0.1185731515,
0.0061322725,
-0.4812962711,
-0.2968085706,
0.7219763398,
0.2640599012,
0.3534365892,
0.2544550002,
-0.2800415754,
0.2486786097,
-0.6532319188,
-0.0119997747,
-0.029826222,
-0.4057030082,
-0.1846495718,
0.1724801511,
0.09890192,
0.2255845517,
0.4726645947,
-0.3737878203,
0.2960832119,
-0.4705348015,
0.6177707314,
0.8549115062,
0.0946603045,
0.4499203265,
-0.3833634555,
0.6316847801,
-0.0486180671,
-0.0038653612,
-0.2492156923,
-0.3723621368,
-0.7052791119,
-0.5992757082,
-0.2083148658,
0.3923471868,
-0.2367053926,
0.171606943,
-0.0754107982,
-0.6608987451,
-0.2154972851,
0.2339899391,
-0.0650070235,
0.0092022205,
-0.1224742606,
-0.5177928209,
-0.4233050048,
-0.8997007608,
-0.2614054382,
-0.2654919028,
-0.0970492139,
0.5920963287,
0.4849129617,
-0.5794798136,
1.3934512138,
-0.5061066747,
-0.0578193069,
-0.5392968655,
0.0441570766,
0.0191084202,
0.3221919239,
0.6741619706,
-0.4747494459,
-0.8882459998,
0.3087297678,
-0.4565555453,
-0.3671483696,
-0.1113553345,
-0.1810484082,
0.0584516898,
0.1938564181,
-0.819883585,
0.3058359921,
0.3828149736,
-0.1759302467,
0.6036090851,
-0.0984866396,
0.2527570724,
-0.8857415318,
0.105742313,
-0.1908375323,
-0.4739955962,
-0.8546538949,
0.0756436512,
-0.4707525074,
-0.1350237876,
-0.4503367245,
0.996963799,
-0.3225842714,
-0.2277512848,
-0.3571408391,
0.2167815268,
-0.109555833,
0.5285539031,
0.1756978184,
0.8030458689,
0.2787957788,
-0.4089231491,
0.3634965122,
0.4894512594,
-0.3574356139,
0.8331630826,
-0.9017910957,
0.4298081696,
-0.0678525269,
0.4585721195,
-1.0043030977,
-0.608492732,
0.2969862521,
-0.2975121439,
-0.0741793364,
-0.0511968397,
-0.5624668002,
-0.0053061466,
-0.3082328141,
0.1892632842,
0.5951461196,
-0.5096585155,
0.825402081,
0.5079679489,
-0.3885447383,
-0.1544716358,
-0.4498732984,
0.2184743434,
-0.3901404738,
-0.9025131464,
-0.1749328077,
-0.5024461746,
-0.6163796782,
-0.5643176436,
0.2847667038,
-0.1183271855,
0.2047693878,
0.4676873684,
-0.2726303041,
-0.1004930735,
0.2210508287,
-0.0062775621,
0.025980534,
-0.2079486549,
0.0983417779,
0.9545797706,
-0.4852794111,
-0.2711648643,
-0.6660996079,
0.3412780762,
0.9357717037,
-0.3459131122,
0.8527752757,
0.6291456819,
0.0210759882,
-0.1281722337,
-0.7245618701,
-0.2264742255,
-0.5493530035,
0.197189182,
-0.4917396605,
-1.2567727566,
1.002294302,
-0.0881148502,
0.1709885299,
-0.2081172466,
0.9405309558,
-0.3588396311,
1.0386772156,
0.6601628065,
0.0314504132,
0.5895187855,
0.3283266425,
0.2726715505,
-0.8028519154,
-0.2329614758,
-0.2392942607,
-0.4874663055,
-0.6689354777,
-0.0454889834,
0.0586692989,
-0.299602896,
-0.5776531696,
0.1813362986,
-0.2008875012,
0.2754555941,
0.3117651045,
0.0690846741,
0.2156911641,
-0.227796644,
0.3809969425,
-0.1754758358,
-0.1510151029,
-0.7601991892,
0.5115765929,
0.5002980232,
1.152538538,
0.5166088343,
0.5270613432,
0.4342516959,
0.2315880656,
-0.7097613215,
0.7058841586,
0.3330350816,
-0.3746401668,
-0.1328069866,
-0.1652194411,
-1.1104274988,
0.3520889282,
-0.0320590846,
-1.3918163776,
0.4032911956,
0.1984078288,
-0.0541978404,
-0.1430768669,
-0.5858289599,
0.7233234644,
-0.1495018452,
-0.2146987617,
-0.3324777484,
-0.7448371649,
0.3186033666,
-0.0494633242,
-0.0675363839,
-0.2527814806,
-0.0577168576,
0.2616680264,
-0.6252523661,
1.2228219509,
0.1435506493,
-0.0956580266,
0.2109725922,
0.4848968685,
0.6912827492,
0.1025768444,
-0.0752251893,
-0.1281815469,
0.1339140534,
-0.3899286389,
-0.7062690854,
0.8037899137,
-0.8789684772,
-0.9019286633,
-0.3385498524,
-0.9014361501,
-0.3266619742,
0.0630714968,
-0.2970949113,
0.0858344063,
-0.5894612074,
0.0767726898,
0.4567600191,
-0.4326499403,
0.1851575226,
0.8879677653,
-0.1477529705,
-0.260230422,
0.6225230098,
-0.2031950951,
0.47292009,
0.1569366455,
0.2782893777,
-0.006243648,
-0.074388355,
0.061619401,
0.4234341383,
-0.8340265155,
0.2855243981,
-0.7095324397,
0.0405125879,
-0.480312407,
-0.5105679631,
-0.1226896942,
-0.1797264367,
-0.2894757986,
0.0484261848,
0.3165263236,
0.6885988116,
0.158237353,
0.8817303181,
-0.7752960324,
-0.3195696473,
0.4816900492,
0.0742529631,
0.1830948591,
-0.3509990275,
-0.1559527963,
-0.1065495461,
-0.2274261117,
-1.003144145,
0.4090506434,
0.2944617271,
0.7048236132,
0.692399621,
-0.0384499058,
0.3736184239,
-0.2444951683,
0.7864386439,
-0.1121424362,
-1.0243909359,
0.4270727634,
-0.6669425368,
0.3995897472,
0.4549871087,
-0.0002637572,
-0.8956720233,
-0.5320019126,
-0.3687613308,
-0.4648052156,
0.6317246556,
0.1649656147,
0.3238333762,
0.0692747459,
0.4075850546,
0.2467555851,
0.6890633702,
-0.4797927141,
0.0263208169,
0.0296206884,
-0.2392990738,
-0.1112954766,
-0.3985185027,
-0.1432437301,
0.0380552486,
0.2087983936,
-0.1480809301,
-0.0736546367,
-0.1556631178,
-0.2471361756,
0.0644550771,
0.5008523464,
0.7901474237,
0.759282589,
-0.3820006251,
0.1330716759,
-0.0039584027,
-0.2927120626,
0.0500942171,
-0.2779763937,
0.1885494143,
-0.2159267664,
0.1987971812,
0.8380813003,
0.1133887321,
-1.1136723757,
0.4135424793,
-0.1369989812,
0.2202868313,
-0.3732010722,
0.2883271277,
0.2410896569,
0.6508110166,
-0.0142871374,
-0.2273318321,
0.1138578504,
-0.8956289291,
-0.059515547,
0.5819695592,
-0.3055205643,
-0.6132152677,
0.3508183658,
0.4435358346,
-0.5632075667,
0.440813899,
0.0785958841,
-0.5684256554,
0.4754997194,
0.3916625381,
0.820579946,
-0.3839110434,
0.4514447451,
-0.0155357178,
0.1984081864,
0.1622696072,
-0.1670585871,
-0.2284550518,
-0.6730303168,
0.0079968078,
-0.4460846484,
-0.6904827952,
0.047507748,
-0.3458792567,
0.2226875573,
-0.5700457096,
-0.3073229492,
-0.2027681023,
0.0361779407,
-0.7747479677,
-0.1063312739,
-0.0711347312,
0.6132203341,
-0.6002197266,
0.6031561494,
0.9201460481,
-0.3753481507,
-0.4176236093,
0.0130165406,
0.0373938903,
-0.7541629672,
0.7657005191,
0.1356825382,
-0.226428628,
-0.0774614811,
-0.5687222481,
-0.7653135061,
1.071575284,
0.5539403558,
-0.3145723939,
0.2409745753,
0.5517491102,
0.8917244673,
-0.6018832922,
0.4891588092,
0.7593838573,
0.5832675099,
0.2452375442,
-0.8524109721,
-0.0424952023,
-0.2340555638,
0.0351959392,
-0.0125270849,
-1.0667600632,
0.6240712404,
-0.0847340152,
-0.2171792835,
0.3089054525,
0.5362133384,
0.3740562797,
0.2412359267,
0.4546409845,
0.0696401671,
0.8252529502,
0.1633744538,
0.9036864042,
-0.3405269086,
0.2215760648,
1.3463032246,
-0.7022348046,
0.6145678759,
0.4803599417,
0.0490895994,
0.6447351575,
0.7399966717,
0.1267947257,
0.3231006265,
0.373156637,
-0.4074931145,
-0.4478618205,
-0.1175588593,
-0.1570163965,
0.2323471904,
0.4948360622,
-0.1280646622,
-0.0879917219,
0.2022092342,
0.1008795872,
-0.0936293006,
0.0050349138,
0.6334888339,
0.0946701542,
-0.4208754599,
-0.1397847682,
-0.1981522441,
0.4170818925,
-0.5790138245,
0.0990734696,
-0.3563461602,
0.186605379,
-0.3211121559,
-0.8005859256,
-0.100308679,
-0.3139453232,
-0.0864580944,
0.0510418937,
0.7976348996,
-0.4446031749,
-0.0423202515,
0.1256745458,
0.5990108848,
0.5280203223,
-0.0687179044,
-0.4570042193,
0.2834136784,
-0.1755705476,
-0.4984653294,
0.5450899005,
0.3052895069,
-0.0606152155,
1.1168304682,
0.5015212893,
-0.2937625349,
-0.1622959971,
0.1200341508,
0.754927516,
-0.3959001303,
-0.4362875223,
-0.7307632565,
0.5617586374,
0.0163148474,
-0.1975126863,
0.6861718297,
0.3081505299,
0.3287084401,
-0.2767983675,
0.8391911983,
0.011560143,
0.3281704783,
-0.0960867479,
0.6563248634,
-0.4779988229,
0.3600160778,
-0.3264839053,
-0.8613855243,
0.1197566539,
0.4745188057,
-0.4403796494,
0.2535792291,
0.507792294,
0.8275308013,
-0.0406924784,
-0.1895799637,
0.3649681807,
0.3886844218,
0.8522601724,
0.4987101257,
1.1376364231,
0.2517571449,
0.2239413112,
0.1631352007,
-0.228825897,
-0.5043538213,
-0.5832089782,
-1.3164064884,
-0.6170699596,
-0.2878324986,
-0.1071051434,
0.0776087493,
1.0888243914,
0.5511154532,
-0.4769502282,
-0.5241499543,
0.2122064829,
0.0193797145,
0.160581857,
-0.2811586261,
0.0821963921,
-0.4022468328,
-0.8620666265,
0.2942476571,
0.5147369504,
0.1489476562,
-0.3900118172,
-0.3311045468,
0.2547974288,
0.5437610745,
0.6772218943,
0.483569026,
-0.7213951349,
-0.4798428118,
-0.086804837,
-0.3395582736,
0.2213007808,
0.96937114,
-0.689977169,
0.3721040785,
0.5825651884,
0.3804321289,
0.4744952023,
0.1378568113,
0.8579871058,
-0.2273162752,
0.1983369738,
0.09051539,
0.1627491266,
0.2891122997,
-0.5378825068,
0.2911869287,
-0.0998866409,
-0.8296916485,
-0.7894561887,
0.4476792514,
-1.4008567333,
-0.0410051867,
1.1938978434,
-0.2412150502,
-0.123295188,
-0.2503601611,
-0.6062219143,
-0.2941653728,
-0.7310711145,
0.6530316472,
0.8286382556,
-0.4111952484,
-0.3911708295,
-0.4750412703,
0.4154158235,
0.14722161,
-1.0026574135,
-0.0519161411,
0.4560020566,
0.5917860866,
-0.0778116807,
0.7580752373,
0.329236567,
0.1704881638,
-0.4779886901,
0.1775819957,
0.0632193685,
0.1535246223,
-0.0025835063,
0.1959193647,
0.3840579689,
0.1587256491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15264v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15264v3
|
DEEM: Dynamic Experienced Expert Modeling for Stance Detection
| 2024-02-23T11:24:00 | 2024-04-26T01:06:31 |
Xiaolong Wang, Yile Wang, Sijie Cheng, Peng Li, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has made a preliminary attempt to use large language models
(LLMs) to solve the stance detection task, showing promising results. However,
considering that stance detection usually requires detailed background
knowledge, the vanilla reasoning method may neglect the domain knowledge to
make a professional and accurate analysis. Thus, there is still room for
improvement of LLMs reasoning, especially in leveraging the generation
capability of LLMs to simulate specific experts (i.e., multi-agents) to detect
the stance. In this paper, different from existing multi-agent works that
require detailed descriptions and use fixed experts, we propose a Dynamic
Experienced Expert Modeling (DEEM) method which can leverage the generated
experienced experts and let LLMs reason in a semi-parametric way, making the
experts more generalizable and reliable. Experimental results demonstrate that
DEEM consistently achieves the best results on three standard benchmarks,
outperforms methods with self-consistency reasoning, and reduces the bias of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.4274941385,
-0.9122374058,
0.959323287,
0.001185205,
-0.103595823,
0.2579205334,
-0.2276668251,
-0.2221761793,
0.3378114104,
0.5526797175,
-0.513046205,
-0.9347257614,
-0.6843450665,
-0.0480995364,
-0.0955261439,
0.6679325104,
-0.1650336385,
-0.2194437385,
-0.199038595,
-0.2141235173,
-0.3132446408,
-0.2019367814,
-0.6535224915,
-0.1811602712,
0.125869453,
0.4407141209,
0.6777564287,
0.4328453839,
0.2149083614,
0.4283096492,
-0.2616139054,
0.5191807151,
-0.1615598202,
0.4723415077,
-0.1860253066,
-0.4787275791,
-1.0731137991,
0.2019076794,
0.7282619476,
0.4005348682,
-0.305678606,
-0.1920308322,
-0.4018421173,
0.4708757102,
-0.3517441154,
0.1586315781,
-0.7503188848,
0.0634434372,
-0.1655981839,
-0.268699348,
-0.4467941225,
-0.1887042969,
-0.1310719997,
-0.3785277009,
0.0637681708,
-0.2252213657,
0.5697790384,
0.6010249853,
-0.6379284859,
0.1630369723,
-0.6713867784,
0.7886733413,
-1.2468057871,
0.4146263599,
0.2212063074,
0.2730334103,
-0.4654346406,
-0.4182009101,
-0.7428741455,
-0.4425671697,
0.4400758445,
0.1525621712,
0.0473719425,
0.0374335162,
0.264685899,
0.0734631792,
-0.0544213019,
0.374265343,
0.3113213181,
-0.0298509784,
0.7288786769,
0.3133265078,
0.0222533401,
-0.1611320078,
-0.800966382,
0.2048969865,
-0.5763023496,
0.1597201675,
0.6020941734,
0.0412751511,
-0.2205296457,
0.2347336113,
-0.3880662024,
0.6741247773,
0.6003323793,
-0.3533481658,
0.2192923129,
-0.0110150697,
0.0489190221,
-0.2191655338,
0.6427619457,
0.4528936446,
0.1429123729,
-0.0197155848,
-0.5081554651,
-0.2364994287,
0.2576434612,
-0.418159306,
-0.3902806044,
0.3143264949,
-0.483432889,
-0.3768164515,
-0.1168113053,
-0.8470098972,
-0.9264364243,
-0.7293958068,
-0.0835992396,
-0.3613036275,
-1.0003340244,
0.1727573425,
0.0846860632,
0.4071948826,
0.7044946551,
-0.495989114,
0.0309627205,
0.7693513632,
0.4837781191,
-0.4621218741,
-0.1726906747,
-0.5670542717,
0.2164941281,
-0.482396692,
1.0795500278,
-0.6880425811,
-0.1092735529,
-0.0181267597,
-0.2898203731,
0.1762095243,
-0.5449997187,
0.3899915516,
-0.6239134669,
-0.2308514267,
-0.2832422256,
-0.6629368663,
-0.3035082519,
0.8430902958,
-0.5230910182,
1.0348010063,
-0.0922131687,
-0.7808203697,
0.7976483703,
-0.5350541472,
0.0477304049,
0.2342845947,
-0.6413514614,
-0.3751989007,
0.0149813276,
0.247528255,
0.6169982553,
0.081015639,
0.4603329897,
-0.5546560287,
0.015530413,
0.3318745792,
-0.2402244508,
0.4890094399,
-0.0218724012,
-0.6674901843,
0.3630924821,
-0.6405665874,
-0.0652033091,
-0.0524194166,
-0.5405858755,
-0.269462198,
0.4924474955,
-0.4942379594,
0.4258752763,
0.2923413515,
-0.3461768031,
0.3158764243,
-0.4383581877,
-0.0998049378,
0.9495028853,
0.1501577795,
0.2396082133,
0.026592955,
0.7150631547,
0.126069665,
-0.2069407701,
0.1831433177,
-0.254557997,
-0.8018770218,
-0.5137007833,
0.0602637418,
0.2723770142,
-0.6978490949,
0.3616425991,
-0.2067115754,
-0.2164770663,
-0.2953716218,
0.2090739906,
0.3703728914,
0.3182514012,
0.2653084993,
-0.0316510834,
-0.2717061639,
-0.8565155268,
-0.6062247753,
-0.3343456089,
0.3238061666,
0.1129131988,
0.2019020915,
-0.1938072145,
1.2004039288,
-0.2733928263,
-0.0020406526,
-0.2756730318,
0.3844111562,
0.1827562302,
0.1386600584,
0.854193449,
-0.8398863673,
-0.5792540312,
-0.223478213,
-0.8613668084,
-0.0879362375,
-0.0725334957,
-0.0415390097,
0.4059759378,
0.6430132389,
-0.6210131645,
0.3852796853,
0.1824575216,
-0.4816858768,
0.7731031179,
-0.1642050892,
0.2519388497,
-1.0140835047,
-0.2852807343,
0.4251826108,
-0.6632119417,
-0.6655685306,
0.2216686457,
-0.0645564124,
0.1352609694,
-0.530361712,
0.5283682346,
-0.7401195168,
0.1865851879,
-0.6678611636,
-0.0041596307,
-0.3980552256,
0.359711498,
0.3573354781,
0.5676603317,
0.788856864,
-0.6975542903,
0.5518627167,
0.0574246198,
-0.081133917,
1.0369358063,
-0.4309972823,
0.3786472082,
0.0012644136,
0.0621501878,
-1.1106923819,
-0.2267859727,
0.240036875,
-0.3128838837,
0.7009942532,
-0.5134499073,
-0.5105184317,
-0.4814737141,
-0.3222798705,
0.1369297653,
0.2326671034,
-0.5444751382,
0.7693985105,
0.6329041719,
-0.2672630548,
-0.7227458358,
-0.0156652853,
0.3522390425,
-0.5028733611,
-0.5478382111,
0.164732188,
0.0301042851,
-0.6300935149,
-0.3303508162,
-0.3716928661,
0.0205708798,
0.1001478881,
0.1234523579,
-0.1556706429,
-0.0580764301,
0.0394028388,
0.0268762782,
-0.4160055518,
0.3941830099,
-0.1835390627,
0.353333652,
-0.3377164006,
-0.5887367129,
-0.5923912525,
0.219327867,
0.8675716519,
-0.4160044789,
0.6442240477,
0.5506792665,
-0.3260732889,
-0.4993925393,
-0.800412178,
-0.0918339267,
-0.5402777791,
0.3450887799,
-0.4101859033,
-0.4367776513,
0.4733258784,
-0.5540588498,
0.1748993099,
0.2026401907,
0.8568390012,
-0.1526666433,
1.173329711,
0.8097233176,
-0.156457603,
0.1483253837,
-0.2396959513,
0.0919089094,
-0.4360293746,
-0.4760387242,
-0.2936477065,
-0.4438585937,
-0.3278979659,
-0.6255204082,
0.5011623502,
-0.2238571793,
-0.1915944815,
-0.1235070601,
-0.4309844375,
0.136829108,
0.2692221403,
0.2491777241,
0.2177223712,
-0.1837781817,
-0.1537388712,
-0.0874359086,
-0.0925475284,
-0.91861552,
0.740932107,
0.5333148241,
0.8220489621,
0.2757504582,
0.6032314301,
0.6065255404,
0.0323647596,
-1.027808547,
1.0733674765,
0.1368633658,
-0.3987143338,
-0.2020112574,
-0.1581441015,
-0.5801915526,
0.0551375113,
-0.204510361,
-0.4427524209,
0.2003959268,
0.3188335001,
-0.0885427371,
0.6645224094,
0.0347713232,
0.657173872,
-0.2341122478,
-0.3231922984,
-0.340252459,
-0.528768599,
0.2563369572,
-0.1148083061,
0.1675006896,
-0.5421205163,
-0.3244285882,
0.8279445171,
-0.4298374653,
1.0905066729,
-0.8188511133,
-0.4624972641,
0.3705367446,
0.2930237949,
0.7149009109,
0.1373138577,
-0.4251584113,
-0.129540354,
-0.4111565351,
-0.3795070648,
-0.3313750923,
0.7575913072,
-0.7569718361,
-1.0298321247,
-0.2152491659,
-0.6350337267,
-0.3956935704,
0.1941075325,
-0.1426374763,
0.1800529957,
-0.1951390654,
-0.006687304,
0.9141859412,
0.0823831484,
0.4034251273,
1.0750588179,
-0.0004497584,
-0.1095133498,
0.2905338109,
-0.0484034345,
-0.1741350144,
0.2772850096,
0.1342095584,
-0.4243128896,
-1.0035693645,
-0.2726110518,
0.129732132,
-0.7665897608,
-0.1337197572,
-0.8366900682,
0.3004558086,
-0.1994440854,
-0.0830407664,
-0.6887927651,
-0.2773522139,
0.0174993798,
-0.3912303746,
0.6026818752,
0.562761724,
-0.0643206909,
0.2831604183,
-0.4404085279,
0.5333647728,
0.3599966764,
0.1586342007,
-0.2440960854,
-0.5199606419,
-0.0788687542,
0.0436876155,
-0.3603043854,
-1.2254168987,
0.3889054954,
-0.0389116816,
1.2296304703,
0.8181442022,
0.3461491764,
0.1786861569,
-0.2956791818,
0.6590829492,
0.0630491674,
-0.7740898132,
0.6207976341,
-0.7922964692,
-0.0611623786,
0.3978049457,
0.3467520475,
0.0156552177,
-0.7721251249,
-0.4849449694,
-0.7037353516,
0.6578723192,
-0.2352649719,
0.144783318,
-0.161649853,
0.5185961127,
0.3132706285,
0.2315004915,
-0.5109165907,
-0.1663552374,
0.0487539135,
-0.1057603434,
0.2848827243,
-0.2716733813,
-0.1758806854,
-0.2733049989,
0.5457651615,
-0.2845891416,
0.2305788845,
-0.1919719726,
-0.1459811479,
-0.1317904592,
0.2933481336,
0.440759927,
0.9094758034,
-0.1662541032,
0.4338041246,
0.4243438542,
-0.1143252552,
0.3988775313,
0.053198792,
-0.001327356,
0.0795987248,
0.0937947184,
0.6762388945,
0.1038589478,
-0.2246998549,
0.5949973464,
0.3402786255,
-0.239804849,
-0.5089763403,
0.237103343,
0.2145158648,
0.3962207437,
0.2694134116,
0.101569511,
-0.0530782044,
-0.3776962459,
0.4038521051,
0.5918728709,
-0.3454033434,
-0.4144559503,
0.881950736,
0.3330113292,
-0.2927665412,
0.3385393322,
-0.2465288788,
-0.7111058831,
0.8341650963,
0.2597037256,
0.7563633323,
-0.4569549859,
0.3255211413,
0.0184262097,
-0.056366615,
-0.0967021361,
0.4241298437,
0.0039348118,
-0.9046286345,
-0.3519151211,
-0.2562299967,
-0.5889987946,
0.0380187891,
-0.619733572,
0.5389273167,
-0.4792279601,
-0.5826417208,
0.0783286318,
0.1652200371,
-0.6221330762,
0.1642575413,
0.321508646,
0.9204428792,
-0.9826498032,
0.5956483483,
1.4183415174,
-0.2480437309,
-0.6415048838,
0.3776608706,
0.3556234539,
-0.6563228369,
0.5178051591,
0.0678249374,
-0.5354019403,
-0.052023232,
-0.6687031984,
-0.4094968438,
0.7660935521,
0.3860431612,
-0.1889629662,
0.2332489192,
-0.161708653,
0.5726171136,
-0.2816188633,
0.3115460277,
0.4344484508,
0.7798498273,
-0.0754743218,
-0.5887846351,
0.1121337712,
-0.1284650713,
-0.4202989936,
0.1956930906,
-0.83077389,
0.7729177475,
-0.214527294,
0.2163387537,
-0.22002846,
0.9980366826,
0.5573302507,
0.5016659498,
0.7413883209,
0.5744011998,
0.8779293299,
0.2006726116,
0.7875636816,
-0.3122324347,
0.2393758744,
0.863176167,
-0.4359122217,
0.6574775577,
0.2335319668,
-0.1634766012,
0.8122814298,
0.6548792124,
0.0129804416,
0.4897537827,
-0.005172912,
-0.4655973315,
-1.0092343092,
0.2323634923,
-0.3049875796,
0.6985685229,
0.3662057519,
-0.1816474497,
-0.2791254818,
-0.1477349997,
0.2907469571,
0.4625983238,
-0.4877127409,
0.7740033865,
0.0953036621,
-0.5122800469,
0.6816363931,
0.3020969033,
0.7300733924,
-0.2582973838,
0.0502180159,
-0.2040225863,
0.338188827,
-0.2352403402,
-1.0150384903,
0.058062274,
0.1187803298,
-0.3872225881,
-0.3275377452,
1.0578368902,
-0.3553750813,
-0.280969888,
0.2930925786,
0.8825823665,
0.4390135407,
-0.0343875252,
-0.6822257638,
-0.4765563905,
-0.2807598114,
-0.5435941815,
0.2260306329,
0.7338960767,
-0.1893671751,
0.7294090986,
0.3407544494,
0.0148019632,
-0.0583231635,
0.04834399,
1.0321938992,
-0.5067964196,
-0.5522119403,
-0.8565606475,
0.5054406524,
-0.2948986888,
0.0767819956,
0.8726395369,
0.3592456281,
0.2557415664,
-0.1773913652,
0.6263995767,
0.2156825811,
0.7000871301,
-0.4971354008,
0.8538061976,
-0.5640051365,
0.2826720178,
-0.2003258914,
-0.6921626925,
-0.0893631056,
0.5280470848,
-0.5136106014,
0.3019804657,
0.3193808496,
0.6538900137,
-0.2481582016,
-0.3389656544,
0.2860296965,
0.3484081626,
0.4908161461,
0.3144967854,
1.1070706844,
0.3387314677,
0.1291142553,
0.2164294422,
-0.3305588961,
-0.2504645288,
-1.2700924873,
-1.1668057442,
-0.0940770879,
-0.8266864419,
-0.1138742045,
-0.0994093716,
0.8759242892,
0.9100935459,
-0.7042410374,
0.1093371063,
0.0037186909,
0.1811321974,
-0.4052516818,
-0.1709785461,
0.3287547827,
-0.4226947427,
-0.814122498,
0.8837572932,
0.1419083774,
-0.2109550089,
-0.3413095474,
-0.2547813058,
-0.2366683632,
0.2822223604,
0.4422149658,
0.2985494435,
-0.9058597088,
-0.3439859748,
-0.0708006024,
0.0597286411,
0.2414690703,
0.526765883,
-0.9193946123,
0.5674952269,
0.5233421326,
0.3544910252,
0.3578503728,
0.2994401157,
0.676962316,
-0.8701836467,
0.0828270093,
0.2481651902,
0.4839058518,
0.261602819,
-0.359110266,
0.3760152459,
0.2805939019,
-0.4524566829,
-0.7917901278,
0.2142871022,
-1.0895104408,
-0.2406103313,
1.4015940428,
-0.3586733043,
0.2139883488,
-0.4421451092,
-0.1806360036,
0.4121434391,
-0.496149689,
0.7897641659,
0.5026746392,
-0.1576331407,
-0.310590595,
-0.4373824298,
0.4758231044,
0.522987783,
-0.8027425408,
0.0049859006,
0.52186656,
0.5090956688,
-0.0962885097,
0.8204777837,
0.0160622988,
0.1160447523,
-0.2218192965,
0.2017183751,
-0.4466119111,
-0.5537022352,
-0.1197166592,
0.1507541984,
0.4141361415,
-0.1482209414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15248v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15248v3
|
Chitchat as Interference: Adding User Backstories to Task-Oriented Dialogues
| 2024-02-23T10:27:42 | 2024-06-28T10:27:11 |
Armand Stricker, Patrick Paroubek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
During task-oriented dialogues (TODs), human users naturally introduce
chitchat that is beyond the immediate scope of the task, interfering with the
flow of the conversation. To address this issue without the need for expensive
manual data creation, we use few-shot prompting with Llama-2-70B to enhance the
MultiWOZ dataset with user backstories, a typical example of chitchat
interference in TODs. We assess the impact of this addition by testing two
models: one trained solely on TODs and another trained on TODs with a
preliminary chitchat interaction. Our analysis demonstrates that our enhanced
dataset poses a challenge for these systems. Moreover, we demonstrate that our
dataset can be effectively used for training purposes, enabling a system to
consistently acknowledge the user's backstory while also successfully moving
the task forward in the same turn, as confirmed by human evaluation. These
findings highlight the benefits of generating novel chitchat-TOD scenarios to
test TOD systems more thoroughly and improve their resilience to natural user
interferences
|
[
-0.3754482269,
-0.669752121,
0.5615698099,
0.3535860479,
-0.3283995986,
0.1317050755,
-0.0671806633,
-0.9013790488,
0.2224476635,
0.6866136789,
-0.9581890702,
-0.0948219821,
-0.4965046048,
0.1914929152,
-0.6188220382,
1.1601725817,
0.1839807779,
-0.0216037426,
-0.0446207039,
-0.0587083474,
-0.9761240482,
-0.5231484175,
-0.285629034,
-0.3852697909,
0.605373919,
0.5900651813,
0.6259169579,
0.1774538606,
0.3349945545,
0.2537912726,
0.3709306121,
0.2479296327,
-0.447450906,
0.6547868848,
-0.0688393936,
-0.4845225811,
-0.3300598562,
-0.0503817797,
0.1185067147,
0.530660212,
0.0129257655,
0.1861372441,
0.3521442711,
0.3257865012,
-0.5498455167,
0.0125471,
-0.3947518766,
0.0706699416,
-0.4082515538,
-0.1032261401,
-0.0445463173,
-0.0930113941,
0.1514271349,
-0.4740059674,
0.0873412341,
-0.1678687781,
0.5938981771,
0.490581125,
-0.1969808787,
-0.0704186484,
-0.7298536301,
0.7048490644,
-0.6435658336,
0.4414508939,
0.9637541175,
0.1112634912,
-0.3430056274,
-0.4151589572,
-0.8134814501,
-0.2503718436,
-0.0958204195,
0.2114895582,
-0.1710649282,
-0.0456877388,
0.3561073542,
-0.1587011814,
-0.2759642303,
0.1688458472,
-0.20672822,
-0.1397521496,
0.6913491488,
0.6368762851,
0.098849766,
-0.2854157686,
-0.1592254192,
0.0507571548,
-0.4229110777,
0.2004409581,
0.4445056915,
0.4272144735,
-0.2022816688,
0.9023096561,
-0.6122532487,
0.6526151299,
0.2992436886,
-0.1103459671,
0.0982753038,
-0.6853576899,
-0.1339875162,
-0.2686967552,
0.7338917255,
0.382650584,
0.2184108049,
-0.2008230388,
0.0985205844,
-0.0202385169,
0.5039617419,
-0.5193946362,
-0.1822087616,
0.4391945302,
-0.2146018595,
-0.3360295594,
0.0806734785,
-0.8948585391,
-0.7385283709,
-0.2072210014,
0.2413158268,
-0.3246309161,
0.0061090002,
-0.2803277075,
-0.3337695897,
0.2539913356,
0.7316405773,
-0.6735046506,
0.1071212888,
0.7271241546,
0.6533693671,
-0.0290217418,
-0.8527488112,
-0.7137259841,
0.1721836776,
-0.4960980415,
0.9010329247,
-0.5330793858,
-0.5751265883,
-0.2571492493,
-0.0326686725,
0.1560869068,
-0.2330854684,
0.2764979005,
-0.0229732879,
0.341768533,
-0.5008420348,
0.1038587168,
-0.0260999519,
0.2253722101,
-0.1704315245,
1.1758223772,
0.1424841285,
-0.702132225,
0.3471943438,
-0.6712260246,
-0.5659874082,
0.1260654032,
-0.3942120373,
-0.2914480269,
0.1235565394,
0.2233048528,
0.4516088963,
-0.2840310335,
0.2057863027,
-0.2959921658,
-0.7090788484,
0.3568086922,
-0.2379885912,
0.6952673793,
-0.1292201877,
-0.5946002603,
0.0876047239,
-0.660695672,
-0.0810434297,
0.0081865257,
-0.1581322849,
-0.3857063055,
-0.0082316576,
-0.1588587612,
0.280294925,
-0.0985016748,
-0.6422621012,
0.2116683424,
-0.1882234365,
0.1120173484,
0.8530812263,
-0.1039652899,
0.0660381839,
-0.6401250958,
0.5331195593,
-0.0125469929,
0.1935759634,
-0.2890981138,
-0.8820534348,
-0.5922211409,
-0.2336835265,
-0.2019765228,
0.7235996127,
-0.8623787761,
0.3878345788,
-0.1782339811,
-0.2275624424,
-0.3234099746,
0.3499516547,
0.4684033394,
0.4858962893,
0.2640987635,
-0.4305653572,
-0.5739837289,
-0.6739916801,
-0.1370525658,
-0.2820775211,
-0.3767682612,
0.545876503,
0.3436575532,
-0.1729365736,
1.2218922377,
-0.2114942819,
-0.2532916069,
-0.2786866128,
0.1394819915,
-0.2153189927,
0.5403419137,
0.2155428231,
-0.3695296943,
-0.3710131049,
-0.1351976395,
-0.7495672107,
-0.2459911108,
-0.261962831,
-0.1446330845,
0.0705202147,
0.2237988859,
-0.5943871737,
0.7726866603,
0.624987185,
-0.3812645376,
0.6863197684,
0.330994904,
0.6480901837,
-1.0465518236,
-0.0025044901,
-0.2805054486,
-0.0702590272,
-0.802616179,
-0.3152709007,
-0.1802323759,
-0.2725556493,
-0.2020779252,
0.2712703645,
-0.3007465601,
-0.2860348523,
-0.3297720253,
0.1451175213,
0.0215227641,
0.7561906576,
-0.0500164628,
0.8865067959,
0.1748363972,
-0.2966154814,
0.3737723529,
0.8269331455,
-0.1877536476,
0.8129267097,
-0.5224915743,
0.7236990929,
0.2125351131,
0.4449666142,
-1.0741274357,
-0.3985270858,
0.6072300076,
-0.5714684725,
0.1676368117,
-0.4087855816,
-0.3527918756,
-0.2441592216,
-0.7152982354,
0.175505206,
0.2253718227,
-0.6984546185,
0.4870711863,
0.1896881014,
-0.3698491752,
-0.7154061198,
-0.8068416715,
0.571010828,
-0.3116713762,
-0.7622472048,
0.1268550009,
-0.0612491928,
-0.1257686913,
-0.3360457122,
-0.1657803059,
-0.231304422,
0.2215726227,
0.7325133085,
0.4275064468,
-0.0302557759,
0.0075999466,
-0.023038771,
0.1257174164,
-0.1134464964,
0.0198018029,
0.6197305918,
0.2367777973,
-0.5025047064,
-0.9201729894,
0.7334069014,
0.3561986089,
-0.0516453832,
0.4401753545,
0.6294270754,
-0.1751514822,
0.2577885091,
-0.7669636011,
-0.4511666894,
-0.4813491404,
0.3637320697,
-0.520393312,
-0.9175254107,
0.565461278,
0.1647178978,
0.2422361076,
-0.150917381,
0.4068352282,
-0.5314100385,
0.8493825197,
0.5950586796,
-0.0387780704,
0.6774557829,
0.0860273838,
0.0577059984,
-1.0593663454,
-0.3659068644,
-0.7362620831,
-0.3381564915,
-0.3667401671,
-0.3212407827,
0.0456380844,
-0.0315269232,
-0.0193697736,
0.4352969825,
-0.1817110926,
0.2706922293,
0.4507989883,
0.4552701414,
0.3700484931,
-0.1959822625,
0.3732523024,
-0.1758618653,
-0.580912292,
-0.1586410403,
0.9664097428,
0.1502510309,
1.027413249,
0.1611706018,
0.7811627388,
0.3171738684,
0.0427803695,
-0.9148235917,
0.4696192443,
0.2635777593,
-0.4599634111,
-0.5104117393,
-0.1298927069,
-1.0841238499,
0.1609136015,
-0.365527004,
-1.2979966402,
0.5136861205,
0.2117304802,
-0.5354081988,
-0.0731765032,
-0.6824658513,
0.542152822,
-0.1107473001,
-0.6666519642,
-0.146359235,
-0.7390887737,
0.4864702225,
-0.1540098041,
0.0213647019,
-0.0898245424,
0.0155067053,
0.842630744,
-0.3864871562,
1.3906197548,
-0.0632848218,
-0.1215900704,
0.1238746494,
0.1767692268,
0.8081094027,
-0.0120859398,
0.3102667332,
0.3940431476,
-0.2399319857,
-0.3588209748,
-0.4826748669,
0.5397605896,
-0.5210530162,
-1.0973243713,
-0.3119627833,
-0.8686841726,
-0.6377394199,
-0.0717194676,
0.1144251302,
0.3188047409,
0.12277437,
0.1406544298,
0.1486983299,
-0.0959108993,
0.3691196144,
0.3569988608,
0.0518349074,
-0.10428413,
0.5300511122,
-0.0732011497,
0.1503194124,
-0.2392718494,
0.3844397068,
-0.0368999802,
-0.6287879944,
-0.5547289252,
0.0232016705,
-0.4596592486,
-0.3126383126,
-0.834225595,
0.117565006,
-0.4425754547,
-0.0442768708,
-0.1901500523,
-0.4849423468,
-0.1658163965,
0.0824927092,
0.5005272627,
0.8443249464,
0.012353614,
0.4662103951,
-1.1144137383,
0.3531800508,
0.5792726874,
0.2688522637,
-0.0094917947,
-0.5833582282,
-0.4144130647,
0.0613417663,
-0.3032110929,
-1.1650819778,
-0.0040674452,
-0.0067137415,
0.6492503881,
0.1425361186,
0.085663572,
1.1665084362,
-0.3856984675,
1.0123933554,
0.1683426797,
-0.9994248152,
0.7036626339,
-0.518871665,
0.4047278762,
0.6195260286,
0.0081635602,
-0.6377422214,
-0.7213874459,
-0.3211136758,
-0.5239394307,
1.10631001,
0.2535057962,
0.3050163984,
0.2031749636,
0.1403876394,
0.2216450721,
0.1812795103,
-0.3793379366,
0.1394988596,
-0.5074007511,
-0.1130755693,
0.0753172114,
-0.2443207204,
-0.3481618166,
-0.0066443877,
0.3096842468,
-0.2442479581,
0.1990454942,
0.2500400245,
-0.0992979407,
-0.3263436854,
0.3995419741,
0.6555327773,
0.459156096,
-0.0700288191,
-0.178441301,
0.376768887,
-0.6934899688,
0.057314124,
0.1233640909,
0.1766760051,
-0.3189553022,
0.3616538048,
0.5959252119,
0.2046691775,
-0.6636120081,
0.3055810332,
-0.0934673324,
0.0082122367,
0.0985870659,
0.1858208925,
0.0272768699,
0.609380424,
0.4940747321,
0.1581513435,
0.1872070581,
-0.7491159439,
0.1495482028,
0.4538411796,
-0.3566248417,
-0.3146283627,
0.2016549259,
0.4304323494,
-0.6073324084,
0.5471842885,
0.1339413822,
-0.7858826518,
0.3960034847,
0.4679480791,
0.8130480647,
-0.2244008034,
0.0386787765,
0.0316243768,
0.3877201378,
0.1456503272,
0.2857102454,
-0.6624777913,
-0.7725835443,
-0.4094846249,
0.0188424699,
-0.6568802595,
0.0313840024,
-0.6751807332,
0.0614641979,
-0.3246031404,
-0.3212771714,
-0.1037010625,
-0.0623844266,
-0.5899210572,
-0.2240742594,
-0.0654587373,
0.3520068824,
-0.6794554591,
1.0174539089,
0.4244284332,
-0.1749006361,
-0.5745092034,
0.4685831368,
0.3231146932,
-0.8775994182,
0.5558019876,
0.0867332965,
-0.338604033,
-0.3492158949,
-0.3250367939,
-0.5160453916,
1.0421839952,
0.0812147707,
-0.5760166645,
0.2087603658,
-0.0078216307,
0.3784307241,
-0.1902116835,
-0.0394286066,
0.7210900784,
0.4391323328,
-0.0245833453,
-1.1481581926,
0.2551105618,
-0.216939494,
-0.2441610545,
0.2411431968,
-0.5847863555,
0.5945721269,
-0.5442976356,
-0.3259760737,
0.268032372,
0.3891089559,
0.3529933393,
0.6005467176,
0.6607429385,
0.1327655315,
0.5223840475,
-0.1956917197,
1.0153664351,
0.2600565851,
-0.118353121,
1.6340022087,
-0.4825871587,
0.6014632583,
0.8094034791,
-0.2506361902,
0.2817308307,
0.4207704365,
-0.1046293303,
0.2252929658,
-0.2345971167,
-0.0081096431,
-0.2136453688,
-0.2917881012,
-0.362182945,
0.7647423744,
0.1922527552,
0.1459933817,
0.0328615494,
0.1598586887,
0.0190865956,
-0.1179685518,
0.1381933093,
0.9309626222,
-0.1622418165,
-0.5209097862,
0.3339186311,
-0.4326756597,
0.9663860798,
-0.6304633617,
-0.1099966466,
-0.4314089119,
-0.3385748267,
-0.4680612683,
-0.7824953794,
0.2436398566,
0.3630467653,
0.1612850726,
0.1488001645,
0.5564006567,
-0.386133939,
-0.0922342092,
0.266127497,
0.6556466222,
0.103741236,
-0.0247309711,
-0.5384806395,
0.0243384093,
0.1385060996,
-0.1453436911,
0.5389954448,
0.0918312818,
-0.2790771723,
0.5790812969,
0.9639633894,
-0.1717972308,
-0.0328712948,
0.2776259482,
0.9676886201,
-0.7272930741,
-0.5714162588,
-0.7063273787,
0.4655354619,
-0.1795076132,
-0.3059575558,
0.9633797407,
0.2180785835,
0.6430889368,
0.204914093,
0.7879067659,
-0.060677398,
0.3502014279,
-0.3476253152,
0.39074561,
-0.3580834866,
0.3637413979,
-0.3746598661,
-0.4679155946,
0.1539210975,
0.4769433737,
0.0670559183,
0.0813046396,
0.5447199345,
0.6811015606,
-0.0545877814,
0.3430153131,
0.5861208439,
0.0005545946,
0.2883815467,
0.4686883688,
1.5237789154,
-0.2661130726,
0.6505738497,
-0.5853081346,
-0.2631474137,
-0.2134839296,
-0.5453895926,
-1.1192291975,
-0.4869607687,
-0.1358062178,
-0.4177832007,
0.4057685137,
0.9001629353,
0.6652751565,
-0.6738091707,
-0.3563543558,
0.2217256576,
0.0454614982,
-0.3018464446,
-0.246683687,
-0.0603673793,
-0.1967223138,
-0.6797231436,
0.7519328594,
0.2271897346,
0.2981855571,
-0.1568535417,
-0.1097706109,
-0.233328253,
0.0217319503,
0.5745471716,
0.2399595827,
-0.6845161319,
-0.5772360563,
0.0431513079,
0.1333173662,
0.1472417712,
1.2467740774,
-0.7604087591,
0.4392089844,
0.3734352887,
0.5482078791,
0.6355305314,
0.0900887996,
0.8187298775,
-0.8479017019,
0.4254092276,
0.237144202,
0.1566961557,
0.2216765732,
-0.714928031,
0.4730585515,
0.0890688747,
-0.2843197882,
-0.9496058226,
0.223739624,
-1.0453953743,
-0.2976614535,
0.7323760986,
-0.3086259067,
0.2455643713,
-0.7600498796,
-0.4004398286,
0.1279930323,
-0.5842020512,
1.137638092,
0.8325120807,
-0.5791154504,
-0.3139362037,
-0.3942069709,
0.4420108497,
0.473910898,
-1.1866922379,
0.2483575493,
0.6368079185,
0.1689532399,
0.1668395996,
0.6014921665,
0.1040708497,
0.6618642807,
0.1588310748,
-0.3021371365,
-0.5281247497,
-0.3961421549,
-0.3968783319,
-0.0725101382,
-0.2039306611,
-0.3885206282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15238v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15238v2
|
GPT-HateCheck: Can LLMs Write Better Functional Tests for Hate Speech Detection?
| 2024-02-23T10:02:01 | 2024-05-27T13:14:12 |
Yiping Jin, Leo Wanner, Alexander Shvets
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Online hate detection suffers from biases incurred in data sampling,
annotation, and model pre-training. Therefore, measuring the averaged
performance over all examples in held-out test data is inadequate. Instead, we
must identify specific model weaknesses and be informed when it is more likely
to fail. A recent proposal in this direction is HateCheck, a suite for testing
fine-grained model functionalities on synthesized data generated using
templates of the kind "You are just a [slur] to me." However, despite enabling
more detailed diagnostic insights, the HateCheck test cases are often generic
and have simplistic sentence structures that do not match the real-world data.
To address this limitation, we propose GPT-HateCheck, a framework to generate
more diverse and realistic functional tests from scratch by instructing large
language models (LLMs). We employ an additional natural language inference
(NLI) model to verify the generations. Crowd-sourced annotation demonstrates
that the generated test cases are of high quality. Using the new functional
tests, we can uncover model weaknesses that would be overlooked using the
original HateCheck dataset.
|
[
-0.5401053429,
-0.8736339808,
0.308365643,
-0.2145909071,
-0.0535102412,
-0.024534015,
0.0021957345,
-0.715395391,
0.1945287138,
0.5574738383,
-0.6890283227,
-0.2601741552,
-0.5239843726,
0.0887291878,
-0.701708436,
1.1739223003,
0.2795874476,
-0.0116356937,
-0.1268621087,
-0.0319059752,
0.0674677417,
-0.5197972655,
-0.6762331724,
-0.3661213815,
0.5949413776,
-0.0018828679,
0.5511189103,
0.2610875964,
0.2026202977,
0.2072559744,
-0.1212411001,
0.0397211052,
-0.5664168596,
0.0910342708,
0.0632353574,
-0.4331534505,
-0.2745763361,
0.1295005977,
0.1071149334,
0.3086629808,
-0.0904644206,
0.135553658,
-0.1141970679,
0.0766499043,
-0.465918541,
-0.2382840514,
-0.901137054,
0.107018277,
-0.238343671,
0.3492359817,
-0.4124127328,
-0.6739498377,
-0.1399193555,
-0.2766932249,
0.5371649265,
-0.0736076832,
0.8573324084,
0.286200732,
-0.3317828476,
-0.213988632,
-0.5762147903,
0.5900437832,
-0.981235981,
0.3270378113,
0.5416768789,
0.2743163407,
-0.0993189365,
-0.3052589893,
-0.7303879261,
-0.7176313996,
0.0443309918,
-0.0784774423,
-0.1593385041,
0.1796483994,
0.5038084984,
0.4011557698,
-0.7159358263,
0.3790922165,
-0.3353250623,
-0.4873440862,
0.7246575356,
0.0575313419,
0.4367702305,
-0.0172429644,
-0.1987951994,
0.1276660711,
-0.6974714994,
-0.3333525658,
0.8304753304,
0.3786204755,
0.0579580627,
0.4941904545,
-0.1912730932,
0.7165614367,
-0.1828745008,
-0.0257056914,
0.2455596328,
-0.0348181762,
-0.3337142467,
-0.1139958277,
0.414819479,
0.1984581053,
0.6254922152,
-0.3366087973,
-0.3368098736,
0.4760263264,
0.4122254252,
-0.7613819838,
-0.3148614764,
0.1094731241,
-0.1991421878,
-0.6763353348,
-0.2081762701,
-0.8868266344,
-0.8949000835,
-0.296826601,
0.3440904617,
-0.5135300756,
-0.2514648438,
-0.1974081397,
-0.1532657743,
0.1145453975,
0.192086637,
-0.708081007,
0.2460540831,
0.5660341978,
0.6083680987,
-0.3841724694,
-0.1667473018,
-0.7787582874,
-0.1913444102,
-0.0515110046,
0.8323084116,
-0.4286003709,
-0.1441687644,
0.0478703082,
-0.3439691663,
0.0156177506,
-0.7811355591,
0.5299324393,
-0.3386929035,
0.0858079642,
-0.1049527973,
-0.6298311353,
0.0762170255,
0.3824121356,
-0.2652256787,
1.1948555708,
0.4585778117,
-0.7382136583,
0.4718013704,
-0.6038279533,
-0.5229468346,
0.1681386083,
-0.1728498191,
-0.5694738626,
0.1072047502,
0.083037734,
0.3142661452,
-0.2710842192,
0.3553475738,
-0.849635005,
-0.2514064312,
0.1950379014,
-0.1622881889,
0.871101141,
0.2279019356,
-0.7794079781,
0.0852965191,
-1.0381989479,
-0.1512982398,
0.1796909273,
-0.1892690361,
-0.358640343,
0.0528181344,
0.1965606511,
0.1209620759,
-0.4640750885,
-0.9368630648,
-0.1046244651,
-0.4380517006,
0.3038263321,
1.0528724194,
-0.2503456175,
-0.1493268013,
-0.4491904974,
0.6962086558,
-0.0887678564,
0.1630412638,
0.2652173042,
-0.5101549625,
-0.9037405252,
-0.3750604987,
-0.0252384245,
0.4838797748,
-0.4638972878,
0.3130582869,
0.1185063869,
-0.5135026574,
-0.3481222987,
0.0464135073,
0.2233830541,
0.6236554384,
0.2623777688,
-0.3670128882,
-0.7465867996,
-1.0194392204,
-0.4534861743,
-0.1918053925,
-0.1916077584,
0.1749638915,
0.5895370841,
-0.331101805,
0.9159930944,
-0.4287811518,
-0.0617078952,
-0.2538889647,
0.2284387201,
-0.2205441743,
0.0997754112,
0.602101326,
-0.6531912088,
-0.2549127936,
-0.3829112947,
-0.182931006,
-0.5741081834,
0.2177342027,
0.2909187973,
0.1815087497,
0.3614783287,
-0.0722386315,
0.2898755968,
0.6138157845,
-0.5122696161,
0.8643336296,
0.5020112395,
0.0796835124,
-0.6576527357,
-0.0928377956,
0.0176105183,
-0.2527412772,
-0.6425056458,
0.1111880317,
-0.3662054539,
-0.1988659203,
-0.4609441161,
0.3189448118,
0.0069209337,
0.0610268749,
-0.2723276913,
-0.0060199872,
-0.3798702657,
0.2544179261,
-0.2672527432,
0.7016051412,
0.1513605565,
-0.5779916644,
0.3018862009,
-0.012399191,
-0.3844116926,
0.7652144432,
-0.4446684718,
0.3607743382,
-0.0821318179,
0.0936593041,
-1.0835624933,
-0.3805874586,
0.1923824549,
-0.3840564489,
-0.2201418132,
-0.3901341259,
-0.5221289992,
-0.405520618,
-0.182518512,
0.1412459612,
0.4690187573,
-0.4931619763,
0.4256933928,
0.5984050035,
-0.0708676428,
-0.3113005757,
-0.8671615124,
-0.1279887855,
-0.4184991121,
-0.5449106097,
-0.0103157982,
-0.2639321089,
-0.2856074572,
-0.3272578716,
0.0701622739,
-0.5496880412,
0.3229649365,
0.4138455391,
0.1245656386,
-0.2365953922,
0.0494564921,
-0.2291071415,
0.2367661297,
0.1415700167,
-0.0679278821,
0.5416175127,
0.0739447549,
-0.3684212863,
0.0685045272,
0.2040735483,
0.6278116703,
-0.0856230035,
0.3630998731,
0.8366805315,
-0.43909657,
-0.4898462892,
-0.8303403854,
-0.2488308102,
-0.4523870051,
0.2878295183,
-0.1093562469,
-1.3014250994,
0.4960087538,
0.3292581439,
0.059452001,
0.2258071303,
0.6212193966,
0.1178794652,
0.7655011415,
0.3894281387,
-0.2271572053,
0.2545993328,
0.3206256926,
0.4255717397,
-0.2841082215,
0.1250686049,
-0.6027076244,
-0.0198198613,
-0.4380132258,
-0.3689492345,
0.3108874857,
-0.4652291238,
-0.309710145,
0.1570462286,
-0.5536184907,
0.6029824018,
0.2314718366,
-0.0838663727,
0.2078738511,
0.2364068329,
-0.1036653668,
-0.4525163174,
-0.1660880446,
-0.2993052602,
1.0235790014,
0.3344619274,
0.3864067197,
0.0615357868,
0.6750936508,
0.3499468267,
0.8169587851,
-0.7225197554,
0.504814744,
-0.1163073778,
-0.9288578033,
-0.0311006308,
-0.447021395,
-0.5456104279,
0.2805413902,
0.0726786777,
-0.8716857433,
-0.167393744,
0.463624537,
-0.4504699111,
0.6624631882,
-0.6731874943,
0.7975569963,
0.0150559647,
-0.1537571847,
0.0206187181,
-0.0362148508,
0.8121011257,
-0.114929378,
0.4166675508,
-0.364305079,
0.4231677055,
0.8097562194,
-0.310239315,
1.1329132318,
-0.3648324013,
-0.191860646,
0.4168703556,
0.4371023476,
0.396921128,
-0.3325518966,
-0.1467644125,
-0.0956865996,
-0.2253288627,
-0.1784797907,
-0.3412297368,
0.5419245958,
-0.4142418504,
-0.3955401182,
-0.1949472874,
-0.3967571855,
-0.5005763769,
0.0987465605,
0.1668242216,
0.2604118288,
-0.4357789159,
-0.1846900582,
0.5560017824,
-0.1272796243,
-0.0380168259,
0.4986012876,
-0.3274126947,
-0.1162709892,
0.9623339176,
0.1075362191,
0.2768073976,
-0.0792805776,
0.3280242682,
-0.073110193,
-0.8529953957,
-0.1870066226,
0.137901783,
-0.4524825215,
-0.098391965,
-0.5862073302,
-0.0558089204,
-0.586104393,
-0.027901737,
-0.410661906,
-0.2636264861,
0.1044440567,
-0.1619979441,
0.4085729122,
0.9056087136,
-0.2670083046,
0.2501008213,
-0.2135488689,
0.4932775497,
0.39219594,
0.433781296,
-0.025305653,
-0.792969346,
0.1329620034,
-0.1077983528,
-0.3952355981,
-0.9119122028,
0.3826684952,
-0.0714014992,
0.1611698717,
0.1865225285,
-0.0332677811,
0.5734596848,
-0.3891467154,
0.8106423616,
-0.002565464,
-0.7782269716,
0.492941469,
-0.4521355033,
-0.2222869694,
0.6244901419,
0.447694838,
-0.6479901075,
-0.769780755,
-0.6706709862,
-0.7292745113,
0.6322262883,
0.1340570748,
0.0446130708,
-0.077526994,
0.1282732487,
0.2233088613,
0.1077878773,
-1.0552963018,
-0.354753077,
-0.1310295463,
-0.1780516952,
-0.0548054799,
-0.3862082362,
-0.2831321955,
-0.3189463317,
0.6665848494,
-0.0528267138,
0.176125139,
0.1118624061,
-0.1778095365,
0.0807170272,
0.3955293894,
0.5370956659,
0.5247499943,
-0.2526013255,
0.1538408995,
0.269793123,
-0.3712891936,
0.2569041848,
0.1124149412,
-0.417170316,
0.0529008359,
0.1373550594,
0.5874797702,
0.0698350593,
-0.7394760847,
0.5903439522,
0.1607951224,
-0.3136784434,
-0.5037910938,
0.2032898366,
0.1613752544,
-0.0885882527,
0.0659608766,
-0.1196367815,
0.2988393903,
-0.3001741767,
0.5831952691,
0.4050305188,
-0.474981457,
-0.2909221649,
0.6500307322,
0.2264894396,
-0.3688189983,
0.6129673719,
-0.5132590532,
-0.6838980913,
0.674230814,
0.5673809052,
0.7165255547,
-0.2941953242,
0.5512273312,
0.3298479319,
0.6739394665,
0.2154978663,
0.0947067738,
0.2407045066,
-0.8268629313,
-0.3995299339,
-0.7711288929,
-0.4083850086,
0.9243317842,
-0.3928124905,
0.071818985,
-0.6254065633,
0.1364778131,
0.2368482053,
-0.3558035791,
-0.5225099921,
0.3606579304,
0.5140658617,
0.6990228891,
-1.1150277853,
0.5737239122,
0.3867063522,
-0.22946316,
-0.6248160601,
-0.1344019771,
0.4537271857,
-0.9248923659,
0.6305004358,
0.2471243143,
-0.0902998373,
-0.0712330043,
-0.7503210902,
-0.351330936,
0.3419575691,
0.5697065592,
-0.4962958694,
0.1044625491,
0.2891337276,
0.6100593805,
-0.3590348959,
0.424025327,
0.7301205993,
0.4295627475,
-0.1670570076,
-0.7534869313,
0.1076768041,
-0.0637313128,
-0.2501920164,
0.1499270499,
-0.3348685205,
0.7317330837,
-0.0114273811,
-0.0395965651,
-0.2220782638,
0.2838087678,
0.1351797581,
0.2606609166,
0.8228668571,
0.8115446568,
0.6411914229,
-0.020487994,
1.1515780687,
0.3366664052,
0.3479381502,
1.2502969503,
-0.3607435822,
0.5380405188,
0.2291350216,
-0.2641438246,
0.2532094121,
0.4417372346,
-0.3704473972,
0.0709265098,
0.8553367853,
-0.3612185717,
-0.3641631901,
-0.1792776287,
-0.0714149177,
0.4077019691,
0.1822457761,
-0.1673109531,
-0.5137205124,
0.0366253369,
0.1678055525,
0.1768081486,
-0.0238674395,
0.3790942132,
-0.1296335757,
-0.5152128935,
0.6953988671,
-0.0136855701,
1.026307106,
-0.583640337,
0.2322936654,
-0.2619425058,
0.0789775699,
-0.1521947533,
-0.3976243734,
0.5316713452,
0.3130864203,
0.0197374057,
0.057141982,
0.6425102949,
-0.3730636835,
-0.2317009866,
0.4444695413,
0.2647442818,
0.2943089008,
-0.4548270106,
-0.8542904854,
0.2566052675,
0.2875704467,
-0.1222240403,
0.4599759281,
-0.1235817522,
0.1589629948,
0.5706249475,
0.665417254,
0.2305172682,
0.3747184575,
0.3287287951,
0.6097579002,
-0.4968302548,
-0.2879068553,
-0.8524388075,
0.3757045865,
-0.1893780082,
-0.5180753469,
0.4999263287,
0.5420869589,
1.0762515068,
-0.0235474985,
1.0558743477,
-0.1435898542,
0.8829311132,
-0.0743349642,
0.6689258814,
-0.486602515,
-0.1978240609,
-0.337197721,
-0.5540971756,
-0.4037092626,
0.5273970366,
-0.2589095235,
-0.0008576536,
0.6267455816,
1.1019548178,
-0.3670012057,
0.1971965581,
0.5481135845,
0.4850959182,
0.5861923099,
0.5120392442,
0.8555325866,
-0.3856710196,
0.5606580973,
-0.2500394285,
-0.1541695297,
-0.1673234105,
-0.7387447357,
-0.9814425707,
-0.3635462224,
-0.5825889111,
-0.614559412,
0.0313671157,
0.7140893936,
0.4702634215,
-1.0089600086,
-0.1284914911,
-0.0860956609,
0.0649476424,
0.1519677639,
-0.3045797348,
-0.1066951454,
-0.3196468949,
-0.5313973427,
0.5212729573,
0.0804816037,
0.0922571495,
-0.10653124,
0.1844216436,
-0.1551474929,
0.1483224183,
0.5746823549,
0.386108458,
-0.7877291441,
-0.5294372439,
-0.3355081975,
-0.0368083455,
-0.0214938745,
1.147252202,
-0.3821213841,
0.3191557527,
0.1211823821,
0.8924741149,
0.3596656322,
-0.2865434587,
0.425958693,
-0.5416148901,
0.1775790155,
0.4559472799,
0.1239260882,
0.4073563218,
-0.2371629477,
0.428347379,
0.483119905,
-0.4083108306,
-1.2233729362,
0.5578987002,
-0.740739882,
-0.1387661994,
1.1329236031,
-0.0807131603,
-0.128756687,
-0.3792977333,
-0.0754728094,
0.0973251909,
-0.2544210553,
0.9602079988,
0.8191695213,
-0.0632279515,
0.0564785302,
-0.6747074127,
0.7864832878,
0.5740237236,
-0.8595638871,
0.349252075,
0.5929383039,
0.655382812,
-0.0517216288,
0.7140387297,
-0.1255357265,
0.1397557855,
-0.0995908976,
0.2086826563,
-0.1580816358,
0.0204484444,
-0.3435788155,
0.309758544,
0.0045995028,
0.1110432446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15220v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15220v2
|
ChunkAttention: Efficient Self-Attention with Prefix-Aware KV Cache and Two-Phase Partition
| 2024-02-23T09:29:19 | 2024-03-22T09:03:10 |
Lu Ye, Ze Tao, Yong Huang, Yang Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Self-attention is an essential component of large language models(LLMs) but a
significant source of inference latency for long sequences. In multi-tenant
LLMs serving scenarios, the compute and memory operation cost of self-attention
can be optimized by using the probability that multiple LLM requests have
shared system prompts in prefixes. In this paper, we introduce ChunkAttention,
a prefix-aware self-attention module that can detect matching prompt prefixes
across multiple requests and share their key/value tensors in memory at runtime
to improve the memory utilization of KV cache. This is achieved by breaking
monolithic key/value tensors into smaller chunks and structuring them into the
auxiliary prefix tree. Consequently, on top of the prefix-tree based KV cache,
we design an efficient self-attention kernel, where a two-phase partition
algorithm is implemented to improve the data locality during self-attention
computation in the presence of shared system prompts. Experiments show that
ChunkAttention can speed up the self-attention kernel by 3.2-4.8$\times$
compared to the start-of-the-art implementation, with the length of the system
prompt ranging from 1024 to 4096.
|
[
-0.4175474048,
-0.5577904582,
0.6666231751,
1.03226614,
-0.4430580139,
0.0782257766,
0.0406779461,
-0.2713626921,
0.6748130322,
0.2583974898,
-0.5939047337,
0.0348996706,
-0.2536898851,
-0.0388952717,
-0.4370126724,
0.3293785751,
-0.0092467135,
-0.1234339252,
-0.4652570486,
-0.0528051443,
-1.0010939837,
-0.1952778697,
-0.5015290976,
0.2101527303,
0.6162039638,
0.610068202,
0.2106176317,
1.0748963356,
0.3370281756,
0.3702886105,
0.1264039427,
-0.1005244032,
-0.4296777248,
0.7788435221,
-0.1559177488,
-0.2564737797,
-0.4004485309,
-0.42947492,
0.8288133144,
-0.1765797138,
0.0107355695,
0.1935619712,
0.140655905,
0.6167013645,
-0.8346837163,
-0.0327248946,
-0.5799423456,
0.0351089276,
-0.3517525196,
-0.1061089933,
-0.4102011919,
0.0364092626,
0.1330884397,
-0.4784562588,
0.3561541736,
0.1431491673,
0.5414788127,
0.6017583609,
-0.0435700752,
0.1271639615,
-0.2231205702,
0.790669024,
-0.3339754045,
0.6211253405,
0.3831197321,
0.0297342706,
-0.1848463416,
-0.6236079931,
-0.4236209989,
0.1869700402,
-0.1427829713,
-0.0062089246,
0.0525877401,
0.0579739735,
-0.1495950073,
0.3071905673,
-0.6204693913,
0.0887423009,
-0.2109954953,
-0.5044706464,
0.3708299994,
0.3919220865,
0.1916626096,
-0.4529836178,
-0.6563365459,
0.044033289,
-0.5602515936,
-0.268381834,
-0.0452174358,
0.238297984,
0.0263731852,
0.1456747204,
-0.3990333676,
0.5465171933,
0.2723727226,
-0.1042963713,
-0.0473462604,
-0.70972085,
-0.0948554426,
0.422617048,
0.7341530323,
0.1268536747,
-0.2004704773,
-0.2489143461,
-0.1052298322,
-0.109019801,
0.5672850013,
-1.0488345623,
-0.2205415815,
0.4841675162,
-0.2880289257,
-0.1425909847,
-0.3758491576,
-0.7643873692,
-0.1723399609,
-0.1122084707,
0.3680868447,
-0.4804113805,
-0.0290073231,
-0.1509371549,
0.1503010392,
0.2605609298,
0.4038193524,
-1.0372704268,
0.2849698961,
0.8604912758,
1.1079097986,
-0.518402338,
-0.4634101391,
-0.7151608467,
0.1400682181,
-0.057928279,
0.9328227043,
-0.227722764,
-0.1743459553,
-0.4480617046,
-0.1537972391,
-0.0845561177,
-0.5187981725,
0.0757434592,
-0.6960908175,
-0.2990475893,
-0.3446578979,
-0.4792422652,
0.0273429006,
0.4029897451,
-0.6347388029,
1.3737443686,
0.0850369409,
-0.5937727094,
0.2332529426,
-0.4251454771,
-0.5669649243,
0.4367017448,
0.0600858666,
-0.3455055654,
0.3007064164,
0.2825393677,
0.5320756435,
-0.1716863811,
0.1811183989,
-0.2463240772,
-0.0550542772,
0.0651549846,
-0.1480380446,
0.0250565447,
0.3463924527,
-0.2910555899,
0.1844424158,
-0.5802311301,
0.1945913285,
0.0711618811,
-0.0833546966,
-0.46900177,
0.0593143925,
-0.1290952712,
0.1589131057,
0.5270246267,
-0.4845799208,
0.2222956419,
-0.1868475825,
0.2310609818,
0.8600389361,
-0.1628351659,
0.3218644559,
0.2289790064,
0.4055063725,
0.3546328247,
0.2173480242,
-0.6668642759,
-0.1420604289,
-1.1259055138,
-0.7670877576,
0.5050641298,
0.0730717182,
-0.4138401747,
0.3025629222,
-0.1081073359,
-0.1207757965,
-0.8888163567,
0.1099194884,
0.5527180433,
0.3674588501,
0.4084667861,
-0.5707529783,
-0.4116261005,
-1.0157055855,
-0.0635335222,
-0.0459764153,
0.2769526541,
0.2255777866,
0.1251229793,
0.1273567379,
1.2067080736,
-0.715751946,
-0.2568904757,
0.02455342,
0.1160646975,
-0.3678942621,
0.4015919566,
0.0222800188,
-0.395794183,
-0.713277638,
-0.3839876056,
-0.2791330814,
-0.3581843078,
-0.0683129653,
-0.1632780433,
0.250351578,
0.4091487229,
-0.3086104989,
0.235034585,
0.4176163375,
-0.5813460946,
0.5516041517,
-0.1700626612,
-0.0604698211,
-1.1027464867,
-0.2010596097,
-0.2694527805,
-0.5992498398,
-0.64407897,
0.1737470478,
0.3741002977,
0.2894185185,
-0.505725801,
0.7085075378,
-0.6873735189,
-0.3022015095,
-0.4397751689,
0.1097623259,
0.0284996107,
0.4854101539,
-0.1351365596,
1.0750290155,
0.5217917562,
-0.7291277647,
0.0858161375,
0.0348137617,
-0.1653095633,
0.6590121984,
-0.4703231156,
0.2953941226,
-0.0790578052,
0.0921367705,
-1.1520272493,
-0.2006006241,
0.0799606889,
-0.0663860738,
0.3973089159,
-0.002710988,
-0.5409872532,
-0.2068567127,
-0.3892472088,
0.993907392,
0.1783655584,
-0.8355349898,
0.5016605258,
0.2434014082,
-0.2349889725,
-0.3905711472,
-0.3545932174,
0.0074807447,
-0.1180442348,
-0.7212392092,
0.2258776426,
-0.0097703114,
0.2835185528,
0.029651545,
-0.2480145991,
-0.1427323818,
0.1921299994,
0.3444234431,
-0.0608420409,
-0.0636598691,
0.388092041,
0.0072131054,
-0.303257674,
-0.1360837221,
-0.5030486584,
1.0644162893,
0.012896616,
-0.3737255931,
-0.486894697,
0.3794505596,
0.5698138475,
-0.3505013287,
0.4704078734,
0.5167363286,
-0.0391982011,
-0.1831661761,
-1.0307346582,
-0.4553841352,
-0.5204572678,
0.3679884374,
-0.4532366395,
-1.2428305149,
0.6216301322,
0.2052078247,
-0.328441143,
0.3652453423,
0.7115728259,
0.0168016627,
0.5891012549,
0.1941501945,
-0.4970057011,
0.4379019737,
0.106656082,
0.1230137646,
-1.1646897793,
-0.2770744264,
-0.4151290655,
-0.5837643743,
-0.3418344855,
-0.9495010972,
0.2690853775,
-0.2527612746,
-0.0017074738,
0.2522242963,
-0.6782922745,
0.5525202155,
0.5386049151,
-0.1487371624,
0.1210533231,
-0.1522174776,
-0.2281334549,
-0.1272428781,
-0.5516853929,
0.1694072783,
0.5483003855,
0.3568276763,
0.7495713234,
-0.1844562888,
0.8311689496,
0.3350945711,
-0.0733279362,
-0.9051538706,
0.5986685753,
0.3547771573,
-0.6341803074,
-0.3370711505,
-0.3666995764,
-0.925807476,
0.5211409926,
0.515171051,
-0.9781925082,
0.0801332965,
0.2991966307,
-0.4559274018,
-0.0027994683,
-0.5414589643,
0.8511272669,
-0.1172545254,
-0.404124707,
-0.5817924738,
-0.7134259939,
0.3537404537,
-0.1647672951,
-0.1752020419,
-0.2375518978,
-0.0788465887,
0.7402921319,
-0.5298585296,
0.7534800172,
-0.0908857062,
0.0122916922,
0.3938110769,
0.2957622707,
0.6598523259,
0.0176927447,
0.5061281323,
-0.0769854784,
0.0196690485,
-0.4813299179,
-0.4873951375,
0.8662708998,
-0.7107168436,
-0.5054377317,
-0.4495818615,
-0.6202121377,
0.0155650564,
0.2088082284,
-0.1321622282,
0.3843129575,
-0.084166199,
-0.0750369802,
0.842292726,
0.2606733143,
0.7649472356,
0.6994762421,
-0.1707713753,
-0.4824885428,
1.189244628,
0.1262948513,
0.2852652371,
0.1977397352,
0.1555505693,
-0.3082630038,
-0.2666409314,
-0.3800580204,
0.3740993738,
-0.302780956,
-0.5617746115,
-1.0232334137,
-0.0881860703,
-0.2293285429,
-0.0097918073,
-0.8658961654,
-0.4796251059,
-0.2781447768,
0.1482066959,
0.4360463917,
0.4623072147,
0.0053915298,
0.6821471453,
-0.7744175792,
0.2457011491,
0.5148862004,
0.5229673386,
0.4263761044,
-0.2970630825,
-0.4164662361,
-0.562479198,
-0.410541743,
-0.8117930889,
0.4077438712,
-0.0702633187,
0.0750182047,
0.6197893023,
-0.0920436308,
0.9687272906,
-0.6186794639,
0.7293325067,
0.1888087243,
-1.0383259058,
0.2599411011,
-0.0013683233,
0.7752252817,
0.8492664099,
-0.0253882017,
-0.8750896454,
-0.4044534564,
-0.468341589,
-0.9976707697,
1.192717433,
-0.0273634456,
-0.042183239,
-0.1853591502,
0.3376496434,
-0.069996573,
0.0685500428,
-0.3420441151,
-0.3184111118,
0.077246815,
-0.0840755254,
0.3228774667,
-0.7760387063,
0.1877957582,
-0.1535298377,
0.6487346888,
-0.2682909966,
0.5039865971,
0.4176722467,
-0.1940964311,
-0.0606000945,
0.2893645465,
0.6299270391,
0.1595773846,
0.0658480823,
0.5219188333,
0.3135837615,
-0.6979526877,
0.4603230059,
-0.0165442862,
-0.2116188854,
-0.2268134058,
-0.1367946863,
0.7422962189,
0.3741402626,
-0.2723267078,
0.3124525249,
-0.2500347495,
0.1598793715,
0.1113126129,
-0.1000602767,
0.2430336922,
0.2330490351,
0.1408394575,
-0.5606402755,
0.2318279147,
-0.0656989366,
0.2301720232,
0.410864681,
-0.5281056762,
-0.468757242,
0.3850186765,
0.1469912827,
-0.1275160611,
0.7058475018,
-0.351190269,
-0.7724408507,
0.4345787168,
0.7384721041,
1.2736519575,
-0.8960195184,
0.1092860252,
0.1792127341,
0.1568540931,
0.0929386765,
0.4359146953,
-0.4632630646,
-0.4821610749,
-0.6027470827,
-0.8986385465,
0.0423068181,
-0.0481305569,
-0.356477797,
0.0474710315,
-0.2787237763,
0.0143220369,
-0.2998734713,
-0.1223686934,
-0.4492834508,
0.1089935601,
0.1316739172,
0.7648260593,
-0.5655747056,
0.7934333086,
0.326484561,
0.2220226377,
-0.8972224593,
-0.0381033644,
-0.064256236,
-0.8592971563,
0.666051805,
0.4222699106,
-0.0015089451,
-0.0085072583,
-0.1802430302,
-1.339859724,
0.9906297922,
-0.0011538259,
-0.5504951477,
0.1474317908,
0.1717066765,
0.1247900277,
-0.197929278,
0.4924544096,
0.6112122536,
0.5681446195,
0.2663680017,
-0.8758755922,
0.4101187289,
0.1682433039,
0.0024322742,
0.7294178009,
-1.3258405924,
0.5094554424,
0.1352692842,
-0.2603476048,
-0.1788324267,
1.2291309834,
0.183191821,
0.2038664073,
0.6827927232,
0.9639649987,
0.4598912597,
0.0183914695,
0.6753283739,
-0.627337575,
0.3146505356,
1.1871771812,
-0.2494322211,
0.6587054729,
0.7200349569,
-0.1266517937,
0.2659585178,
0.5319634676,
0.1947963238,
0.7896610498,
0.3487248719,
-0.4624135792,
-0.3016623557,
-0.2610445321,
-0.1933023483,
0.4198866785,
0.2794952393,
-0.1127060354,
-0.3744550347,
-0.2386944592,
0.1327370405,
-0.7244766951,
-0.1936943531,
0.9828662872,
0.1214724928,
-1.0421019793,
0.3176748455,
0.0528736673,
0.3323865533,
-0.63260144,
0.2651907802,
-0.2501246631,
0.1060943082,
-0.0678913221,
-0.3792859614,
0.1318566203,
-0.164071098,
-0.3497690856,
-0.1771072894,
0.8603147268,
-0.5349242687,
-0.1142436713,
0.1508467793,
0.2612585723,
0.2246791571,
-0.3215844929,
-0.3446968198,
0.310786128,
-0.1533814669,
-0.3690583706,
0.6746760607,
0.3632765114,
-0.0601702221,
0.7082453966,
0.3048321605,
-0.160399884,
0.4357927144,
-0.2172003388,
1.0839161873,
-0.6027541161,
-0.9029290676,
-1.0248203278,
0.3691273034,
0.0972787887,
-0.0894778818,
0.7861655354,
0.7684976459,
0.3022717237,
0.1579072028,
0.5029708147,
0.0491860397,
-0.0290464945,
-0.3814063668,
0.3679086864,
-0.4928914011,
-0.1535835266,
0.0731246695,
-0.9736026525,
-0.0522862338,
0.1961242259,
-0.0370721444,
-0.0944483653,
0.9016985297,
0.7821089625,
-0.2057555467,
0.028411869,
0.2948179841,
0.1907275915,
0.2631136179,
0.2767002285,
0.7876762748,
-0.0980647281,
0.1331934929,
-0.1718591601,
-0.0218712874,
-0.4274986982,
-0.7629923224,
-0.5831847787,
-0.5912582278,
-0.3027667999,
-0.2527242601,
0.0393680632,
0.8771427274,
0.9658260942,
-0.6591099501,
-0.0861895904,
0.0022752702,
0.1090903059,
0.1067493856,
-0.2693594098,
0.5222142339,
-0.9140171409,
-0.4170935452,
0.5725888014,
0.8320186138,
-0.1452007741,
-0.6984155178,
0.0643962249,
-0.0904229432,
0.1858295649,
0.5444923639,
0.1233844087,
-0.6615464091,
-0.3092666268,
0.0882548019,
-0.2047324926,
0.3046214581,
0.9506778121,
-0.832501173,
0.7691098452,
0.628816247,
0.7388557196,
0.8297691345,
0.2607551813,
0.3037238717,
-1.1271088123,
0.0352016613,
0.096550785,
0.2505590618,
0.3131130934,
-0.5247056484,
0.1982962638,
0.2056409419,
-0.8405658007,
-0.5105772018,
0.1887986511,
-1.0294892788,
-0.0951615274,
1.0916258097,
0.0263341349,
-0.7603620887,
-0.1503437907,
-0.1421934515,
-0.0658459961,
-0.8456988931,
0.813773036,
0.7619868517,
-0.1040214002,
-0.108930245,
-0.191989392,
0.3751729131,
0.9678957462,
-0.7411206961,
0.2324503064,
0.3892061412,
0.1948323548,
0.2741418481,
0.8232848644,
0.1637189388,
0.1504410803,
-0.2538695931,
0.3094388843,
0.087720871,
-0.7428669333,
-0.3496873379,
0.1932258457,
-0.0001038487,
-0.4594492614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15218v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15218v1
|
BSPA: Exploring Black-box Stealthy Prompt Attacks against Image Generators
| 2024-02-23T09:28:16 | 2024-02-23T09:28:16 |
Yu Tian, Xiao Yang, Yinpeng Dong, Heming Yang, Hang Su, Jun Zhu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Extremely large image generators offer significant transformative potential
across diverse sectors. It allows users to design specific prompts to generate
realistic images through some black-box APIs. However, some studies reveal that
image generators are notably susceptible to attacks and generate Not Suitable
For Work (NSFW) contents by manually designed toxin texts, especially
imperceptible to human observers. We urgently need a multitude of universal and
transferable prompts to improve the safety of image generators, especially
black-box-released APIs. Nevertheless, they are constrained by labor-intensive
design processes and heavily reliant on the quality of the given instructions.
To achieve this, we introduce a black-box stealthy prompt attack (BSPA) that
adopts a retriever to simulate attacks from API users. It can effectively
harness filter scores to tune the retrieval space of sensitive words for
matching the input prompts, thereby crafting stealthy prompts tailored for
image generators. Significantly, this approach is model-agnostic and requires
no internal access to the model's features, ensuring its applicability to a
wide range of image generators. Building on BSPA, we have constructed an
automated prompt tool and a comprehensive prompt attack dataset (NSFWeval).
Extensive experiments demonstrate that BSPA effectively explores the security
vulnerabilities in a variety of state-of-the-art available black-box models,
including Stable Diffusion XL, Midjourney, and DALL-E 2/3. Furthermore, we
develop a resilient text filter and offer targeted recommendations to ensure
the security of image generators against prompt attacks in the future.
|
[
-0.3997991085,
-0.8575834036,
0.6313415766,
0.3388684392,
-0.4552626014,
0.1723906845,
0.3155321777,
-0.797367692,
-0.0185637251,
0.5424531102,
-0.66638273,
-0.1792647988,
-0.4682060778,
0.4274382293,
-0.2672890723,
0.5558321476,
0.2961814404,
-0.1847624779,
0.1722541451,
0.0774355605,
-0.9541960359,
-0.2373527884,
-0.7950538397,
0.198618263,
0.4626325071,
-0.2749279439,
0.6342201233,
0.1827040017,
0.2166411877,
0.2268865556,
-0.1456876844,
-0.0239129718,
-0.4626289308,
0.5969877839,
-0.4429735243,
-0.0864707381,
0.0607634895,
-0.2159262598,
0.4551471174,
0.3524768651,
0.2477599233,
0.2955764234,
-0.1735660732,
0.3930639327,
-0.8202962279,
-0.1139925495,
-0.7085587382,
0.1853454113,
-0.078157261,
-0.4291440248,
-0.692120254,
-0.3379222155,
-0.1066671833,
-0.3709126711,
0.1827264279,
0.3599974811,
0.9225620627,
0.4029461443,
-0.2442644835,
-0.0427344441,
-0.5546256304,
0.6046909094,
-0.342266798,
0.0516001284,
0.3180340827,
0.4163485765,
-0.4962076843,
-0.6266012788,
-0.3660560548,
-0.1649131924,
-0.0519548431,
0.0435619727,
-0.8067173362,
0.0452753082,
0.5519331098,
0.0461034067,
-0.6616969705,
0.0486469641,
-0.3247493207,
-0.4707099497,
0.4947428405,
0.2069148123,
0.3705202937,
-0.3144480884,
-0.5592700243,
0.0459239297,
-0.7974151373,
0.2215024233,
0.6334543228,
0.1302281022,
-0.0784325078,
0.418982476,
-0.1911599636,
0.8037593961,
0.1756341457,
0.2881427109,
-0.1719235629,
-0.2264030129,
-0.0320320241,
-0.1252880394,
1.0551446676,
0.3459542096,
-0.2531982958,
-0.2727255523,
-0.4071155488,
0.1634543389,
0.5172511935,
-1.2316342592,
-0.2504245937,
0.305092901,
-0.6206173897,
-0.6194357872,
-0.0530242212,
-1.0837669373,
-0.5744279623,
0.2562412918,
0.4167410731,
-0.3924663961,
-0.1540955007,
-0.1139601022,
-0.5090389252,
0.2877384424,
0.1900352985,
-0.3760333657,
-0.1341100782,
0.4025426507,
0.886962533,
0.1225698814,
-0.0714976415,
-0.8017172217,
0.1001279876,
-0.4880844355,
0.9735589623,
-0.5760438442,
-0.8119853735,
0.0979492515,
0.1688383967,
0.455078125,
-0.1279621571,
0.3209551573,
-0.6492292881,
-0.0516229384,
-0.3542912006,
-0.128832683,
0.1738118827,
0.2403525263,
-0.7127074599,
0.7906452417,
-0.0180233084,
-0.7008811235,
0.2153633386,
-0.5810210705,
-0.1163177043,
0.4147944748,
-0.2345793992,
-0.2642527819,
0.3993478119,
0.1000253633,
0.3369843662,
-0.0546075255,
-0.0323277004,
-0.5250470638,
-0.5709884763,
0.5868294835,
-0.5400995612,
0.9132636189,
0.3640354872,
-0.3077862263,
-0.0185481422,
-0.7353873253,
-0.032011684,
0.3169306219,
0.1245203763,
-0.290694803,
-0.34794572,
0.0765585303,
0.2443140596,
0.1917398274,
-0.8117030263,
0.1002987847,
-0.131487906,
0.1970014721,
1.075791955,
0.6467869878,
0.1564769149,
0.0256197229,
0.8675611615,
-0.4148880541,
0.367575109,
-0.6833734512,
-0.8265328407,
0.3533533812,
-0.6202999353,
0.2346843779,
0.4223495126,
-0.8924079537,
0.3645269275,
0.3121746182,
-0.5709145069,
-0.4601783752,
-0.0641918555,
0.6936182976,
0.6951749325,
0.2533904612,
-0.4159784615,
-0.1482996196,
-0.648597002,
-0.1802061498,
0.0039173458,
-0.1655850559,
0.2384608686,
0.1867168546,
-0.420276463,
0.7957695723,
-0.7623133659,
-0.0781787485,
0.1423973441,
0.150855422,
0.107140474,
0.4703430235,
1.0157475471,
-0.5142681599,
-0.2220505923,
-0.3072064221,
-0.7409571409,
-0.5159252882,
-0.2976907492,
-0.327632159,
0.1608475596,
0.2408237606,
-0.7694921494,
0.7394346595,
0.3801152408,
-0.7504491806,
1.0409224033,
-0.1608191431,
0.0416468084,
-0.8625727296,
0.3870643079,
0.0403698683,
-0.1964128613,
-0.4839308262,
0.3538229764,
0.1910762787,
-0.8496767879,
-0.46273157,
0.78795892,
-0.4467648566,
-0.0002682561,
-0.4507666528,
-0.5112155676,
0.2575831413,
0.4061442018,
-0.0070057833,
0.845605135,
0.8306923509,
-0.346724093,
0.140559569,
0.2381346822,
-0.0250480156,
0.9060484171,
-0.8302959204,
0.3870467842,
-0.0449691005,
0.4496692717,
-1.2093565464,
-0.1468263119,
0.6840285063,
-0.5513480902,
0.5548883677,
-0.4839272201,
-0.5555899143,
-0.2669600844,
-0.4572982192,
0.2835645974,
0.6587235332,
-0.7284354568,
0.6131367683,
0.1414334029,
-0.1413688809,
-1.0214855671,
-0.494027257,
0.4367689192,
-0.0090737268,
-0.5542879701,
0.1076905206,
-0.2937913239,
0.022972336,
0.0641214699,
-0.3579431176,
0.0769257471,
0.293343246,
0.632111311,
0.5153661966,
0.2557889521,
-0.5106192827,
0.1751607507,
-0.1637644172,
0.4514295459,
-0.1937653869,
0.5845972896,
0.0557783693,
-0.2832331657,
-0.7147033811,
0.6403756142,
0.3623827994,
-0.1663988233,
0.4904973209,
0.5629555583,
-0.5090523958,
-0.3274820149,
-0.3850995004,
-0.2738302052,
-0.6302141547,
0.0013539577,
-0.310885489,
-0.3145807385,
0.5951889157,
0.0013171777,
0.2720212042,
-0.2400170863,
0.287984699,
-0.1931811273,
1.1033837795,
0.3786305785,
0.2367246747,
0.5969890356,
-0.3321303725,
-0.0439957455,
-0.6918795109,
-0.1671691239,
-0.4989266098,
-0.2000957727,
-0.2745122612,
-0.0909225494,
0.0783470571,
-0.1706897765,
0.0911702588,
0.3363774717,
-0.8226569295,
0.6829382777,
0.4680962563,
0.2132360935,
-0.209847331,
-0.0450196303,
-0.0195990894,
0.2240875959,
-0.2460606694,
-0.4054867923,
0.9605053663,
0.1839739978,
0.9769369364,
-0.0792303681,
0.7881160378,
0.5312955379,
0.0646196455,
-0.4061641395,
0.8088179231,
0.2997053564,
-0.6103397608,
-0.0396558233,
-0.3793760836,
-1.294578433,
0.1443972439,
-0.2707656324,
-0.6659846902,
0.5400907993,
0.3407272398,
-0.2910495102,
0.3022069633,
-0.9188912511,
0.7691857219,
-0.2231770456,
-0.5132079124,
0.086570546,
-0.6939089298,
0.3364030719,
-0.2026964277,
0.1091078296,
0.0259107724,
-0.0403681062,
0.2600928843,
-0.3080170155,
0.9905017614,
-0.6087540388,
-0.0499445833,
0.143525362,
0.5138107538,
0.5075157881,
0.2433236539,
0.1451546997,
0.483323127,
-0.0845483169,
-0.688108325,
-0.3483077288,
0.6133764982,
-0.4429713488,
-0.5092617869,
-0.555962801,
-0.3519837856,
0.0506566353,
0.3636592627,
0.5160499215,
0.5277100205,
-0.1455494463,
-0.1506573707,
0.6793450713,
-0.4974864125,
0.6322748065,
0.3543192148,
-0.0414349213,
-0.5118949413,
1.0073567629,
0.0328211635,
0.0974260196,
0.0439468175,
0.1337846071,
-0.4619836211,
-0.7657761574,
-0.6384751201,
0.1009140015,
-0.5781800151,
-0.6382392049,
-0.4212956429,
0.0649545863,
-0.3451812863,
-0.3776211143,
0.1758057922,
-0.2588536143,
-0.2937859595,
-0.0389560051,
0.2840858102,
0.451787591,
-0.0035166878,
0.2371199429,
-0.5886917114,
0.6918669343,
0.4141512215,
0.5754721761,
-0.1059037149,
-0.3166323602,
0.2509349585,
-0.3385224044,
-0.495300293,
-1.3614741564,
0.4746554494,
-0.2331165671,
0.5353375673,
0.4806895256,
0.2882953286,
0.4724016786,
-0.5938006043,
0.9897788167,
0.4026111662,
-0.8073343039,
0.7331568003,
-0.3047142625,
0.1679458618,
0.3967811167,
0.0362108573,
-0.1079741791,
-0.6322607994,
-0.6994842887,
-0.7973231077,
0.7036454082,
0.173460409,
0.2253904045,
-0.0690671057,
0.2880084813,
0.237953186,
0.2337742448,
-0.5733498335,
-0.3328121603,
-0.6888927221,
0.1263777316,
0.4207074642,
-0.2481271476,
-0.2680450678,
0.4477452934,
0.4655329585,
-0.0851348191,
0.2447339892,
0.1412293166,
-0.079994671,
-0.2971715927,
0.2820937037,
0.1619373113,
0.3948612809,
-0.3361639082,
0.1177508831,
-0.169380337,
-0.540807724,
0.2878031731,
0.4737358689,
-0.6858492494,
0.1094771922,
0.0545518696,
0.6461448073,
0.1006600112,
-0.7834118009,
0.5540469885,
-0.4250254333,
0.0434181094,
-0.2401232123,
0.1043038815,
-0.3147004843,
0.0682899803,
0.7085123658,
0.4615144134,
0.3270255029,
-0.4291754365,
0.0674317926,
0.7523232102,
-0.3040331006,
-0.5143527389,
0.740280211,
0.1742470264,
-0.5114291906,
0.1324991584,
-0.5004668236,
-0.1553306282,
0.4796703458,
0.6638271213,
0.9255234599,
-0.4937948585,
0.2997501493,
0.2254775316,
0.5923573375,
0.1088582724,
0.3836800754,
-0.1544801742,
-0.1515742391,
-0.1961614192,
-0.4911467135,
-0.6995251775,
0.214924112,
-0.6569001675,
0.2469615489,
-0.9661735296,
-0.3008917868,
0.1228607371,
-0.1430921704,
-0.635225594,
-0.0319501236,
0.215444684,
0.9141927361,
-0.6861619353,
0.2515422106,
0.641957581,
-0.4644246101,
-0.4390846193,
-0.0646501407,
-0.0247097816,
-0.5877729058,
0.1206261814,
0.4858072996,
0.0476212725,
-0.2128280848,
-0.7595016956,
-0.5045477748,
0.8817915916,
0.6570293307,
-0.2983325124,
0.0357133336,
-0.2919098735,
0.4121366739,
0.0824853554,
0.0973782763,
0.2294780314,
0.4850629866,
0.0103684124,
-0.2076331973,
0.6141582727,
-0.3786854744,
-0.0351267383,
0.002699502,
-0.4825960398,
0.2385984063,
-0.124503836,
-0.4503616691,
0.2489040643,
0.4162331522,
0.7483615875,
0.727963984,
0.4943712354,
0.3812974989,
0.5973361135,
-0.0731712207,
1.124510169,
-0.2297204435,
-0.24465473,
0.7774683237,
-0.3934870064,
0.5690593123,
0.4039428234,
0.1472016275,
0.5020696521,
0.6027335525,
-0.5797338486,
0.55222404,
0.0638853535,
-0.3244220614,
0.0498365089,
-0.1085784361,
-0.4131123424,
-0.0809623376,
0.409596771,
-0.1485399157,
-0.079159148,
0.217658028,
-0.1926796287,
-0.0271516219,
-0.3478274047,
0.7096509933,
0.0585101843,
-0.4349638522,
0.4951922894,
-0.2612478137,
0.8002638817,
-0.7390324473,
-0.0416249968,
-0.1589494348,
-0.4172215462,
-0.1491720974,
-0.9116653204,
0.1884458214,
0.3369626105,
-0.0176719595,
-0.203483209,
1.0853736401,
0.0309802946,
-0.2665249705,
0.2634437978,
0.0537389331,
0.089733541,
-0.0881862491,
-0.7847185731,
0.1905795038,
-0.2756259441,
-0.2014279515,
0.437243253,
0.4267522395,
0.0163863171,
0.6145899892,
1.0708761215,
0.420162648,
0.2003898323,
-0.0649696067,
0.8138073087,
-0.6597710848,
-0.7949917316,
-0.5486716628,
0.4252899587,
-0.3965492547,
-0.0608921535,
0.61761415,
0.2981748283,
0.341512084,
-0.3476131856,
0.8322936893,
-0.0292841308,
-0.0580731705,
-0.2182385921,
0.7023619413,
-0.1421645433,
0.2336019278,
-0.6710640192,
-0.6742684841,
-0.1497247219,
0.0495078936,
0.0401208028,
-0.3898057044,
0.4014626443,
0.9839788675,
-0.0315535739,
-0.1148823649,
0.3422473967,
-0.0405753106,
0.6348861456,
0.2292880267,
1.1175373793,
-0.2102325708,
0.9429112673,
-0.2884957194,
-0.4017897546,
-0.0932647288,
-1.0171476603,
-1.0802733898,
-0.3427760601,
-0.3329687715,
-0.54306072,
-0.0395307206,
0.4795395434,
0.8121746778,
-0.5361143947,
0.3099926114,
0.020059038,
0.2104784995,
-0.2864947915,
-0.2714620829,
0.2769535184,
-0.1783384681,
-0.3849932253,
0.5964611769,
0.3647131622,
0.3825570345,
-0.2950004339,
0.14171426,
0.3580929637,
0.4391696155,
0.2500842214,
0.7812038064,
-0.5810722113,
-0.2313051373,
-0.0473914891,
0.1481586546,
-0.3832803369,
0.6433578134,
-0.9142070413,
0.5805677772,
0.4765315354,
0.6729540825,
0.1169279814,
0.0934277102,
0.366694957,
-1.299234271,
0.3623112738,
0.1224489063,
0.6382592916,
0.4054524302,
-0.7553544044,
0.3929292858,
0.2631739676,
-0.4077307582,
-1.532294631,
0.4272449911,
-1.2332127094,
-0.6683864594,
1.0270477533,
-0.1316715777,
-0.4914176464,
-0.2830244005,
-0.6119870543,
-0.1122252867,
-0.8482492566,
1.0418812037,
0.201354757,
0.1651476473,
-0.1530336738,
-0.2619937062,
0.3918247521,
0.1178264245,
-0.7396976352,
0.2308835834,
0.7907624841,
0.3124569654,
0.5531704426,
0.5551025867,
-0.1711617112,
0.7783362269,
0.0085170614,
-0.0634896308,
-0.5368533731,
-0.2481308579,
-0.7401734591,
0.4983498454,
-0.2300431579,
-0.4228442311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15202v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15202v2
|
Fine-Grained Detoxification via Instance-Level Prefixes for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T09:04:48 | 2024-02-26T02:37:15 |
Xin Yi, Linlin Wang, Xiaoling Wang, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Impressive results have been achieved in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks through the training of large language models (LLMs). However, these
models occasionally produce toxic content such as insults, threats, and
profanity in response to certain prompts, thereby constraining their practical
utility. To tackle this issue, various finetuning-based and decoding-based
approaches have been utilized to mitigate toxicity. However, these methods
typically necessitate additional costs such as high-quality training data or
auxiliary models. In this paper, we propose fine-grained detoxification via
instance-level prefixes (FGDILP) to mitigate toxic text without additional
cost. Specifically, FGDILP contrasts the contextualized representation in
attention space using a positive prefix-prepended prompt against multiple
negative prefix-prepended prompts at the instance level. This allows for
constructing fine-grained subtoxicity vectors, which enables collaborative
detoxification by fusing them to correct the normal generation process when
provided with a raw prompt. We validate that FGDILP enables controlled text
generation with regard to toxicity at both the utterance and context levels.
Our method surpasses prompt-based baselines in detoxification, although at a
slight cost to generation fluency and diversity.
|
[
-0.4120666981,
-1.0460115671,
0.5338680148,
-0.1303629875,
-0.3436020017,
-0.25419572,
-0.2259009182,
-0.3069348931,
-0.3197077811,
0.5031477213,
-0.4021762311,
-0.6138606668,
-0.2435555905,
0.2224027812,
-0.3316932917,
1.1921432018,
0.372102052,
-0.3855020702,
-0.1851572394,
0.139849022,
-0.6806550622,
-0.5006300807,
-1.1376714706,
-0.3346088231,
0.9707775712,
0.5702870488,
0.6320612431,
0.4302922487,
0.3308614194,
0.1826325059,
-0.2823990881,
0.1404600739,
-0.6157518029,
0.2136357427,
-0.6028909087,
-0.1768617481,
-0.1912845522,
-0.0103069199,
0.2359621078,
0.5538367629,
-0.1774632037,
-0.278223753,
0.0938270465,
0.5262088776,
-0.7608527541,
-0.1872550994,
-0.9382916093,
0.1691673696,
-0.139388755,
-0.2474302351,
-0.6885319352,
-0.1429103166,
-0.1329534948,
-0.3093088865,
-0.0807000101,
-0.1654532254,
0.7944408655,
0.4563899636,
-0.0969552323,
-0.1921530515,
-0.6967749,
0.8646989465,
-1.1599880457,
0.1487979144,
0.3629029095,
-0.0005265244,
-0.2083491981,
-0.4510631859,
-0.1860830784,
-0.2125747353,
-0.1544135958,
0.0574258976,
-0.318340838,
0.2672358155,
0.249894768,
0.3834400475,
-0.2969356477,
0.5873571634,
-0.2276683599,
-0.1656538546,
0.5014192462,
0.3694476783,
0.6095021963,
-0.2822552919,
-0.5107011795,
0.1076277867,
-0.7638568878,
-0.1554654837,
0.2694887817,
0.7217080593,
0.1177368462,
0.3597917855,
-0.3328505158,
0.1828306168,
0.0329738446,
0.0774490386,
0.0946366861,
-0.2124497592,
-0.3041309714,
0.2418786287,
0.8283644319,
0.5488339067,
0.2186560035,
-0.3662731647,
-0.0349973887,
-0.0038821439,
0.5388382673,
-1.2724261284,
-0.0403122902,
0.6405089498,
-0.2549868524,
-0.4682497382,
-0.5695676804,
-0.9506112933,
-0.4372849166,
-0.1151663139,
0.4018648267,
-0.7962620854,
-0.0216891933,
0.208779186,
-0.076845631,
-0.1138542965,
0.2441237122,
-1.0293148756,
0.2430037707,
0.4488949478,
0.7561116815,
-0.2093912959,
0.172277391,
-0.9279851317,
0.2988292575,
-0.0855312049,
0.7495082617,
-0.6237373352,
-0.3836421371,
0.0333270282,
-0.3758532107,
0.3162855208,
-0.7935020328,
0.8842107058,
-0.2210376114,
0.0149557265,
-0.0345478319,
-0.3924661875,
-0.0187335834,
0.2482025474,
-0.3661876023,
0.9569173455,
-0.1437823325,
-0.8453889489,
0.1755267233,
-0.3215453327,
-0.3854934573,
0.2920812368,
0.0378777236,
-0.2666530311,
0.1484311074,
0.1341183186,
0.588596642,
-0.2169864178,
0.3692442775,
-0.2416242063,
-0.1015372127,
-0.2970669866,
-0.5987288356,
0.4265010953,
0.4959981143,
-0.2477009594,
0.397394985,
-0.7033948302,
-0.0102402242,
-0.1372790039,
-0.3799203038,
-1.145884037,
0.0776296407,
-0.0645097867,
0.3658392727,
-0.1045755073,
-0.4509532154,
-0.0657702163,
-0.4475466609,
0.3665235341,
0.6405266523,
0.3234730363,
0.2088305652,
-0.2825132012,
0.1039234102,
0.3676918447,
0.0607292168,
-0.2806957662,
-0.367667675,
-0.593174994,
-0.2557083368,
-0.1160616949,
0.4472134411,
-0.921865344,
0.6632737517,
-0.1931743175,
-0.5461537242,
-0.0114966072,
-0.0901019871,
0.625592351,
0.7806915641,
0.7550777793,
-0.2908103168,
-0.0089677414,
-1.031359911,
-0.1920138747,
0.1055180952,
-0.3705016077,
0.4345900118,
0.3309246302,
-0.3725806475,
0.8477478027,
-0.5831101537,
-0.5031829476,
-0.1072883382,
0.4938496947,
-0.1612888873,
0.6271080971,
0.4690745175,
-0.3913758397,
-0.1791618168,
-0.0335381851,
-0.2279573381,
-0.6801056266,
-0.5376983881,
-0.2796444595,
-0.1864603907,
0.6521700025,
-0.297693789,
0.2963699996,
0.1081321165,
-0.3070242405,
0.6360974908,
-0.3338705003,
-0.1363120377,
-0.9041137695,
0.1494927108,
0.3082780242,
-0.2736088336,
-0.9074733853,
0.2664092779,
-0.2682078183,
0.0219466109,
-0.7831946611,
0.7781789899,
-0.1730834395,
0.3694818914,
-0.1597127318,
0.0783942789,
0.0922597125,
0.4979048967,
0.2337741256,
0.7383309603,
0.2319292575,
-0.6146141887,
-0.1427733004,
0.2473612428,
0.137063548,
0.741019547,
-0.6393832564,
-0.027357433,
-0.105610989,
0.1558414698,
-0.5908200741,
-0.1006255969,
0.2903991044,
0.1784389317,
0.1836445332,
0.1054410562,
-0.4506901801,
-0.1222801208,
-0.3715564013,
0.4723334014,
0.4843532741,
-0.4032821953,
0.0904096365,
0.1725000143,
-0.3536704481,
-0.0812254772,
-0.6972290277,
0.2067212015,
-0.5932649374,
-0.1215496808,
0.2054001093,
-0.2095752358,
-0.1642617136,
-0.1750702709,
-0.12985304,
-0.1467380226,
0.208205834,
0.0709321648,
-0.151137054,
0.1585982591,
0.2043429762,
0.4497172534,
-0.2934690118,
0.0507205427,
0.1877650321,
0.7135643959,
-0.0620565303,
0.0569811165,
-0.380073756,
0.6741492748,
0.4938474298,
-0.4512283504,
0.7708309889,
0.5377352238,
-0.5326284766,
-0.4296129048,
-0.2355978936,
-0.224164173,
-0.4976426363,
0.3032780588,
-0.1584604532,
-0.8667773008,
0.5073559284,
-0.2918268442,
0.0056230477,
0.234090969,
0.6779490709,
0.3051687777,
0.8136329651,
0.1717248261,
-0.0481054746,
0.5587515235,
-0.0776148885,
0.1902812868,
-0.8768604398,
-0.0106150964,
-0.5252752304,
-0.1733718961,
-0.0226218924,
-0.458894223,
0.2943815291,
0.2113058716,
-0.5466839671,
0.1931089163,
-0.5452317595,
0.6544450521,
0.5558890104,
0.2574182153,
0.3625959456,
0.1025528386,
-0.2295522541,
-0.0936468318,
-0.4095911086,
-0.6790084839,
0.4064437747,
0.4152513444,
0.7362220287,
-0.0879758447,
0.8477253914,
0.2275265604,
0.3875316381,
-0.8056018949,
0.650364399,
-0.401435256,
-0.5335717201,
-0.2121561468,
-0.6495999694,
-0.6722618937,
0.2664936781,
-0.0588715002,
-1.0746392012,
0.1599792987,
-0.1446921229,
-0.6750477552,
0.4288170636,
-0.6910650134,
0.9541347623,
0.1451460421,
-0.5831512213,
-0.2572021186,
-0.5513356924,
0.4722298682,
-0.4265113175,
0.3419131935,
-0.2293308675,
0.0582382753,
0.4609609544,
-0.6379902363,
0.8915937543,
-0.0351420008,
-0.6339246631,
0.2838818431,
0.2463597655,
0.3915737271,
0.1698260456,
-0.2199002206,
0.2333395928,
-0.2433521748,
-0.0788946822,
-0.1072490215,
0.7729931474,
-0.3849735856,
-0.5288131833,
-0.0640235618,
-0.690400362,
-0.224743709,
0.6380165219,
0.1915235817,
0.5890490413,
-0.0220777337,
0.1236970499,
0.6225762963,
-0.84363693,
0.5297917128,
0.163810581,
-0.0023939803,
-0.2517206967,
0.8716566563,
-0.3245214522,
0.6897383928,
0.1605284065,
0.5268743038,
-0.0945570543,
-0.6894708872,
-0.1624859422,
0.000581835,
-0.5030872226,
-0.4866110682,
-0.6272898912,
-0.2237936407,
0.0561041087,
-0.2802839279,
-0.3273232877,
0.1357430965,
-0.6323180199,
-0.1406189799,
0.2726068199,
0.2034226507,
-0.1639153212,
0.3146618307,
-1.1278852224,
0.4976232052,
0.1670316458,
0.4181414545,
0.1137064472,
-0.2472832054,
-0.0486675985,
0.3798218966,
-0.2715315819,
-0.7486568093,
0.5149070621,
0.254146874,
0.2640861571,
0.6336065531,
0.5496800542,
0.6989711523,
-0.9894698262,
0.9127389789,
0.2379413843,
-0.9583188891,
0.6370343566,
-0.6996580362,
0.2646680772,
0.7765309811,
0.2651642859,
-0.9165993333,
-1.0386259556,
-0.3331219554,
-1.2211680412,
0.6864393353,
0.3888087273,
0.5718087554,
-0.5785425305,
0.4340316653,
0.2929977775,
0.0191949271,
-0.5479602218,
-0.113356404,
0.0955007076,
-0.1677240878,
0.1980054826,
-0.4270103872,
-0.0879652202,
-0.1684859097,
0.7631841898,
0.1660144329,
-0.1103470922,
0.2003553361,
-0.0573877171,
-0.1387127787,
0.7103058696,
0.3870555758,
-0.222200051,
-0.3056369722,
0.4033491611,
-0.0301589295,
-0.4592633247,
0.3159980178,
-0.1865592301,
-0.4153034687,
-0.2429645211,
0.0594029129,
0.5573735833,
0.2332733124,
-0.7247523069,
0.1632925272,
0.038492877,
0.0114506753,
0.3448598385,
0.3613078892,
0.0074935146,
0.0784993619,
0.2408429384,
-0.1307642162,
0.2952578366,
-0.5457193255,
0.4570119679,
0.3173715174,
-0.3470760286,
-0.0503725223,
0.9821657538,
0.5946807265,
0.0579669625,
0.4091968834,
-0.384701401,
-0.2413979471,
0.39218086,
0.585093677,
0.9974063039,
-0.2088555247,
0.227429688,
0.5202213526,
0.1952835619,
0.1342426538,
-0.1194909364,
0.1942242831,
-0.6516336799,
-0.1797845364,
-0.7946310043,
-0.0835544616,
0.6109985113,
-0.5359219909,
-0.0245920196,
-0.5275753736,
0.049529817,
0.1090403944,
-0.230860278,
-0.1060405225,
0.2604366243,
0.5141516328,
0.8639734983,
-1.0801090002,
0.5973058939,
0.395169884,
-0.7566173673,
-0.6106997132,
0.1406068802,
0.0145269632,
0.027357921,
0.5229618549,
0.70682019,
0.0181345623,
0.3042004108,
-0.2818507552,
-0.3964947164,
0.6017023921,
0.1835434735,
-0.5072438121,
-0.0588761717,
0.1640987992,
0.6917979717,
0.0483929142,
0.3434779048,
0.5290077329,
0.3740063012,
0.1532582641,
-0.6496523619,
0.4410614371,
-0.1917445362,
0.2819858491,
0.1706125885,
-0.4239456654,
0.6503497958,
-0.0317943841,
-0.4946919084,
0.1072666943,
0.5076084137,
0.0011289588,
0.0575313754,
0.5661799908,
0.7884548903,
0.6022904515,
0.0364394374,
0.8202636838,
0.0498196706,
0.2609115839,
1.2100977898,
-0.3673648834,
0.717900455,
0.5533788204,
0.0271879453,
0.4683157802,
0.5813403726,
0.1499692649,
0.7602939606,
0.4469913542,
-0.4683487713,
-0.3243943155,
-0.5752336383,
-0.2398063838,
0.0394121334,
0.4938447773,
-0.2308827788,
-0.9277259111,
0.179178372,
0.284782052,
0.1393871754,
-0.5003985167,
0.7654622197,
0.1557541937,
-0.4550451338,
0.6765084863,
0.0287807472,
0.8831499219,
-0.4098708034,
0.015697984,
-0.4116004407,
0.2024293393,
-0.2110153735,
-0.6123764515,
0.5588219166,
0.2088888884,
-0.0048684515,
-0.4039262831,
0.7370961905,
-0.6799285412,
-0.227383852,
0.1450583488,
0.2293322682,
0.2097742558,
-0.2713134885,
-0.3996304572,
-0.0955103561,
-0.2691450119,
-0.2304259241,
0.3614013195,
0.373881042,
-0.3196550012,
0.4899483025,
0.6409611106,
0.0451135486,
-0.0067086555,
0.3260774314,
1.0371974707,
-0.3974344432,
-0.4275708795,
-0.9338702559,
0.6795683503,
0.0272511467,
-0.0991664827,
0.4578354657,
0.5411833525,
0.6437169909,
-0.020887712,
0.5286518335,
0.0159770697,
0.033744283,
-0.5116295218,
0.8351336122,
-0.6022325158,
0.227069363,
-0.5383854508,
-0.7191061974,
-0.5960713625,
0.5647640228,
-0.3585655987,
-0.1200449914,
0.6855028272,
0.5988135338,
-0.1740828156,
-0.2461491078,
0.3141883612,
0.324162364,
0.602640152,
0.8074370027,
0.5561870337,
-0.0076963594,
0.3387712836,
-0.3933944702,
-0.2400259674,
-0.3027524352,
-1.1468911171,
-0.9504542351,
-0.2861582041,
-0.4193918705,
-0.0539186448,
-0.0589394234,
0.7289325595,
0.3165126741,
-0.5842674971,
0.3562163115,
-0.3453362584,
0.1063916832,
-0.2004246265,
-0.291002363,
0.1428389996,
-0.7272270322,
-0.8758153915,
0.2265030444,
0.2373784631,
0.0608869307,
-0.1140929908,
0.2054484785,
-0.1846049428,
0.3084148765,
0.752927959,
0.1603776962,
-0.571190536,
-0.8528838158,
-0.6370377541,
-0.5026128888,
0.0202282798,
0.3976176381,
-0.7101438046,
0.1626621932,
0.5317815542,
0.4962171018,
-0.0780004412,
0.3535646796,
0.4136399925,
-1.2419826984,
0.2589893937,
0.2047381252,
0.1814056486,
0.1802208871,
-0.6098701358,
0.4250237048,
-0.1251828521,
-0.2916032672,
-0.8639285564,
0.3174326122,
-0.8967687488,
-0.5565159321,
1.630874157,
-0.0962618887,
-0.1615609378,
-0.0216072947,
-0.5768318176,
0.3489228189,
-0.4860293865,
0.7869130373,
0.5726165175,
0.1489575356,
0.1431318223,
-0.5857355595,
0.6205927134,
0.2895339727,
-1.4830559492,
0.6362913251,
0.8749836087,
0.1844503134,
0.2417692542,
0.3864657283,
-0.1410948634,
-0.115211837,
-0.1761432141,
0.2482209355,
-0.1940592229,
-0.3665036261,
-0.2814120054,
-0.1097003445,
-0.4608638883,
0.0497825854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15200v1
|
DeMPT: Decoding-enhanced Multi-phase Prompt Tuning for Making LLMs Be Better Context-aware Translators
| 2024-02-23T09:01:00 | 2024-02-23T09:01:00 |
Xinglin Lyu, Junhui Li, Yanqing Zhao, Min Zhang, Daimeng Wei, Shimin Tao, Hao Yang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generally, the decoder-only large language models (LLMs) are adapted to
context-aware neural machine translation (NMT) in a concatenating way, where
LLMs take the concatenation of the source sentence (i.e., intra-sentence
context) and the inter-sentence context as the input, and then to generate the
target tokens sequentially. This adaptation strategy, i.e., concatenation mode,
considers intra-sentence and inter-sentence contexts with the same priority,
despite an apparent difference between the two kinds of contexts. In this
paper, we propose an alternative adaptation approach, named Decoding-enhanced
Multi-phase Prompt Tuning (DeMPT), to make LLMs discriminately model and
utilize the inter- and intra-sentence context and more effectively adapt LLMs
to context-aware NMT. First, DeMPT divides the context-aware NMT process into
three separate phases. During each phase, different continuous prompts are
introduced to make LLMs discriminately model various information. Second, DeMPT
employs a heuristic way to further discriminately enhance the utilization of
the source-side inter- and intra-sentence information at the final decoding
phase. Experiments show that our approach significantly outperforms the
concatenation method, and further improves the performance of LLMs in discourse
modeling.
|
[
-0.3839749694,
-0.6163589358,
0.6778611541,
0.3309198022,
-0.8559894562,
0.173298642,
-0.2353683263,
-0.1136114895,
-0.0997248143,
0.3312286735,
-0.7928191423,
-0.4341154397,
-0.5211309195,
0.7715133429,
-0.1147471964,
0.8392226696,
0.0905891433,
0.3133303225,
-0.1862223148,
0.1199737787,
-0.9674082994,
-0.4098345637,
-0.8445894122,
-0.2301719487,
0.2635101676,
0.5374788046,
0.3471036553,
0.4643775821,
0.4084579349,
0.3624757826,
-0.1421714127,
0.6349563599,
-0.1105732918,
0.5240068436,
0.0561523251,
-0.4173841774,
-0.5314051509,
-0.2655237317,
0.6533197165,
0.3107913435,
0.1780909896,
-0.1188692078,
0.3961048126,
0.5626845956,
-0.4001601338,
0.2039283961,
-0.6396222115,
-0.0672497749,
0.0749109015,
-0.9358403683,
-0.7098343372,
-0.3937940598,
-0.1536273211,
-0.5983796716,
-0.0251071528,
0.2168864459,
0.453678906,
0.4433943033,
-0.7529802322,
-0.0580056608,
-0.5079578161,
0.6005117893,
-0.9150644541,
0.4193237722,
0.2056847811,
0.2499408871,
-0.3592269719,
-0.3981521428,
-0.3880581856,
-0.3685223162,
-0.0144276982,
0.3142258823,
0.0624346882,
0.3520013392,
0.2151033282,
0.028233869,
-0.4056648314,
0.0888602063,
0.1515434831,
-0.3495998085,
0.1874699146,
0.3050549626,
0.1726151854,
-0.2720390558,
-0.5889670849,
-0.0650014952,
-0.6559838653,
-0.071194768,
0.2067019194,
0.6239596605,
-0.1232295781,
0.4642860293,
-0.1894415617,
0.7277790904,
0.5992276669,
-0.2928344309,
0.1499528289,
-0.7354015708,
-0.0414050035,
0.3164572716,
0.5361730456,
0.6417525411,
0.0586040951,
0.1694159657,
-0.3105617464,
-0.4231378138,
0.1300602108,
-1.006074667,
0.210154295,
0.1369558871,
-0.3759572506,
0.0603802279,
-0.3256348968,
-0.8454003334,
-0.6534876227,
-0.5685957074,
0.3647158742,
-0.6673768163,
-0.1026534811,
0.172978133,
-0.0988546312,
0.2446291298,
0.4406849444,
-0.8143684864,
0.201003328,
0.7535911798,
1.0809278488,
-0.1582918465,
-0.2871188521,
-0.6885306239,
-0.0204264633,
-0.2210495174,
0.6791203022,
-0.4946439266,
-0.3506771326,
-0.0465613641,
-0.026143549,
-0.2958233058,
-0.4080353677,
0.8605844975,
-0.6031956673,
0.2596781552,
-0.6193541288,
-0.4010291994,
-0.341070503,
0.369294852,
-0.3302855492,
0.8559780717,
0.0884815156,
-0.7648555636,
0.3637607694,
-0.495057404,
-0.5733225346,
0.0746602938,
0.1478708237,
-0.2323477566,
0.3778389692,
0.5376182795,
0.4958512187,
-0.4313167334,
0.4000216126,
0.0065420354,
-0.3834897578,
0.2439281791,
-0.63894099,
0.5965396166,
0.2388896942,
-0.1761954874,
0.5560172796,
-0.6503129005,
-0.1494584084,
-0.2017836571,
-0.4614377022,
-0.4148325324,
-0.0264187679,
-0.1995721608,
0.4203806818,
0.1466776282,
-0.3018741906,
0.2482316792,
-0.578079164,
0.4316200018,
0.7342856526,
0.1596655101,
0.5729743838,
-0.2622441053,
0.6908107996,
0.4002833068,
0.0589894392,
-0.5392827392,
-0.3319452405,
-0.8588104844,
-0.3791032732,
0.371686846,
0.7650421262,
-1.0383739471,
0.7284399867,
-0.3422882557,
-0.0663629398,
-0.5875840187,
-0.2615494132,
0.24035272,
0.7977128625,
0.498971343,
-0.2254831046,
-0.6223700047,
-0.5964668393,
-0.1834568679,
0.1251718998,
0.0990205258,
0.099080652,
0.4534029663,
0.2132982612,
0.674295783,
-0.1476623267,
-0.0378399082,
-0.4577704668,
-0.1895984411,
0.3985708654,
0.4250900447,
0.2750177979,
-0.6072327495,
-0.6161376834,
0.0738329664,
-0.3180189133,
-0.3487630188,
-0.5610929132,
-0.2006163299,
0.0730524287,
0.6315701604,
-0.5507972836,
-0.0302288923,
0.5188234448,
-0.5773655772,
0.4995400906,
-0.4394186437,
0.508212924,
-1.4364579916,
-0.0987032801,
-0.2008884996,
-0.5575931668,
-0.6595821977,
-0.0613719448,
0.3513887525,
0.0341376737,
-0.5114353299,
0.3426287174,
-0.6751070023,
0.0532755367,
-0.4913003743,
0.1647637188,
0.1427239627,
0.3673762679,
-0.2908289433,
1.0230715275,
0.5124224424,
-0.7234199643,
0.3009160757,
0.2245565504,
-0.2598271072,
0.8788655996,
-0.5141119957,
0.1135877371,
-0.2263964117,
0.5899323225,
-1.0776609182,
0.0651465207,
0.5243601203,
-0.1599319726,
0.4269978404,
-0.2250342667,
-0.5234954953,
0.014767806,
-0.3863958418,
0.4683347642,
0.2931241989,
-0.4855434597,
0.6618830562,
-0.172751829,
-0.332991153,
-0.415319562,
-0.5718070269,
0.3431752622,
-0.5523782969,
-0.5204594135,
0.4669065773,
-0.3010462523,
0.1367007345,
-0.5014693737,
-0.1484841704,
0.1156183332,
0.2262609303,
0.053839162,
0.1254559308,
-0.2216756344,
-0.013565232,
0.600533545,
-0.3847126961,
-0.1605772227,
-0.3991293311,
0.7875560522,
0.2415421754,
-0.3479470909,
-0.7257486582,
0.423725605,
0.623629272,
-0.2651856542,
0.6729360819,
0.5997546315,
0.0186972823,
-0.2854984105,
-0.141196683,
-0.4972008765,
-0.5233237147,
0.3892436922,
-0.7163603306,
-0.7447474003,
0.4908386171,
-0.592005074,
-0.011239781,
0.1356850564,
0.6214693189,
0.2138863057,
1.0646678209,
0.6047987938,
0.0081836563,
0.7039189339,
0.1165422052,
0.1923603565,
-1.2360019684,
-0.0811996087,
-0.5266497731,
-0.4503630102,
-0.5245515108,
-0.4262417257,
0.6056652069,
0.1172113419,
-0.1955362558,
0.2665113807,
-0.5114365816,
0.4503594935,
0.4998851418,
0.1361434907,
0.4093631804,
-0.1816984862,
-0.3656952977,
-0.2583424449,
-0.5992181897,
-0.3182873428,
0.6723747253,
0.1995984912,
0.4302667379,
0.0164137539,
0.5174614191,
0.1402047575,
-0.2653878629,
-0.7476633787,
0.6429210901,
-0.1035159156,
-0.3595226705,
0.0480196923,
-0.3206493556,
-0.8478153348,
0.6250104308,
-0.1777393967,
-0.4254358411,
0.2724488676,
0.1269036978,
-0.4320174456,
-0.1004050821,
-0.5279849768,
0.7317995429,
-0.2260362208,
-0.0786151215,
-0.1059881598,
-0.6812086701,
0.2567751408,
-0.1556811631,
0.133132115,
-0.2470528483,
-0.341930896,
0.2654923201,
-0.0315169655,
0.9593579173,
-0.2187412381,
-0.2592118084,
0.0425427407,
0.2917155921,
0.6697791219,
0.229374975,
-0.3915541768,
-0.0569420494,
0.0278803594,
-0.0337204672,
-0.4418997467,
0.602666676,
-0.4908086956,
-0.6109523177,
-0.381744653,
-0.799888432,
-0.1613070071,
0.2978050411,
0.3724580705,
0.4728192389,
0.0545095429,
-0.0202517081,
0.4961667955,
-0.2599680722,
0.5646857619,
0.5435138941,
-0.046592351,
-0.6161504984,
0.682256639,
-0.2760580182,
0.3651967645,
0.6142993569,
0.2041770965,
-0.4130893946,
-0.7395245433,
-0.6044204235,
0.084117502,
-0.7728887796,
-0.5166037679,
-0.5368871689,
0.0512830652,
-0.4672048986,
-0.1888608783,
-0.1510638744,
-0.358551085,
-0.408579886,
0.0652290285,
0.393804729,
0.0820414498,
0.0010203721,
0.6808283329,
-0.8105574846,
0.4519364238,
-0.1188773885,
0.0621444248,
-0.4011463821,
-0.9817995429,
-0.1411630064,
0.0649267733,
-0.2626792192,
-1.1176571846,
0.4959769249,
0.3601561785,
0.3403525651,
0.0710266978,
0.2095025778,
0.7538329363,
-0.6666513681,
0.7224980593,
0.0829560831,
-1.1202979088,
0.4481407404,
-0.3341569006,
0.6904130578,
0.6501048207,
0.0893881842,
-0.6735190749,
-0.3763389587,
0.1017945409,
-0.9822201729,
0.8667830825,
-0.0762655511,
0.3737744391,
0.0728950873,
0.4749842286,
0.2884668112,
0.248576805,
-0.5960995555,
-0.1071089357,
-0.0703276619,
-0.415395081,
-0.1536146104,
-0.3565120995,
-0.0865501389,
-0.4718212783,
0.6214859486,
-0.4732350707,
0.1200039461,
0.2329711169,
-0.2203910649,
-0.0275721066,
0.5326265097,
0.7714734674,
0.3693669438,
-0.1049427837,
0.3925130963,
0.5234395862,
-0.2782926857,
0.2201588154,
0.2086600065,
-0.4924007654,
0.1474027336,
0.2526980937,
1.0950312614,
0.3265465796,
-0.2758941948,
0.375613451,
-0.0738854855,
-0.0785575584,
0.119025059,
-0.0399664678,
0.093252562,
0.4603620768,
0.1676599979,
0.1899136603,
0.2392231375,
-0.2074151933,
0.029802585,
0.415029645,
-0.2262052447,
-0.4678831995,
0.5693606734,
0.5006258488,
-0.251016289,
0.4837499857,
-0.1622715443,
-0.6207364202,
0.3851671517,
0.9430568814,
1.1410014629,
-0.4144582748,
0.2415048331,
0.506757617,
0.3266003728,
-0.1151781455,
0.4320523143,
-0.1315450966,
-0.53376472,
-0.6625938416,
-0.6851993799,
-0.206668973,
-0.0811857507,
-0.3248338401,
0.4731576741,
-0.2718115151,
-0.2713600099,
-0.307574898,
-0.0909325406,
-0.402646333,
-0.06988509,
0.1314095706,
0.8417206407,
-0.7197837234,
0.8539819121,
0.5476523638,
-0.0661845878,
-0.2938203812,
0.1258372217,
-0.0086443778,
-0.5442441702,
0.1956391931,
0.2413223982,
-0.1716761589,
0.4226819575,
-0.1989557743,
-0.9215528369,
1.0871618986,
0.8356926441,
-0.7286657095,
0.1065844297,
0.1639759541,
0.2655073702,
-0.4221389592,
0.2995437384,
0.606067121,
0.6850246787,
0.0400777608,
-1.0063741207,
0.5088280439,
0.0858874843,
0.133997038,
0.1940916181,
-0.4833849669,
0.8028115034,
-0.1526751965,
-0.4837816656,
-0.0119190542,
0.575510323,
0.1989778578,
0.04654897,
0.6163921952,
0.017885711,
0.5857306123,
-0.0662203282,
0.939381659,
-0.6314032078,
0.0318691209,
1.2069295645,
-0.0644985139,
0.5365704298,
0.6651703119,
0.1991995126,
0.2673761249,
0.7986815572,
0.1722897887,
0.810480237,
0.1374814212,
-0.2622377574,
-0.4137508571,
-0.2772337198,
-0.4901735783,
0.3759120405,
0.1404536515,
-0.3844212592,
-0.3477751911,
0.0664599314,
0.1196560934,
0.0096465079,
-0.0663437024,
0.8943105936,
0.2613370717,
-0.7585893273,
0.7485551238,
0.2048839331,
0.7178806067,
-0.554592073,
-0.0160589162,
-0.3420117199,
0.0427099429,
-0.0600373372,
-0.5290077925,
0.1056204215,
-0.129541114,
-0.1466369778,
-0.4760151207,
0.581852138,
-0.5254630446,
-0.4103448093,
0.1635734439,
0.6068937778,
-0.0538190491,
-0.2235301584,
-0.7443044782,
0.2090506852,
0.0608588532,
-0.3682519197,
0.3369521797,
0.6788303852,
0.07921689,
0.5287361145,
0.587723732,
-0.0231576748,
0.1179538146,
0.3556407094,
0.8405567408,
-0.7485441566,
-0.4684988558,
-1.1891287565,
0.7512867451,
0.0814816207,
-0.4718821943,
0.8945552707,
0.3986801505,
0.3839166462,
0.0050045354,
0.5580866337,
0.0847223848,
0.0649517775,
-0.7483060956,
0.2360240817,
-0.435492903,
0.3977271914,
-0.0499114357,
-1.0796900988,
-0.2962667942,
0.3072868586,
0.0103552714,
0.0735401586,
0.8694263697,
0.7006998658,
-0.0581445545,
-0.1709429026,
0.4336497188,
0.1874230802,
0.3337762952,
0.5857178569,
0.8494274616,
-0.3100428283,
0.3556899428,
-0.0734820515,
-0.175921157,
-0.3025630713,
-1.032566905,
-0.7046305537,
-0.6388955116,
-0.1847945005,
-0.1483777463,
-0.0211475287,
0.9356746674,
0.5888959765,
-0.7131629586,
-0.0104057482,
-0.058899913,
0.1978651881,
-0.4108175933,
-0.1061986461,
0.1942238212,
-0.5775284171,
-0.9409016371,
0.9028184414,
0.4190445542,
-0.0003645999,
-0.0190918017,
-0.090382956,
-0.1425047368,
0.2347747833,
0.7954806685,
-0.4187979102,
-0.6598616838,
-0.2770542204,
-0.022539869,
-0.0448009558,
0.2650780976,
0.8065744042,
-0.5806141496,
0.4974407256,
0.6618208885,
0.438950032,
0.1513199359,
0.262078017,
0.7492300272,
-0.8691132069,
0.2432755232,
0.2072612345,
0.2943674028,
0.4307663143,
-0.5241969228,
0.129370302,
-0.0275566392,
-0.5313658714,
-0.7537133098,
0.3890004158,
-1.1351613998,
-0.4237479866,
1.3591022491,
0.0701481774,
0.0233291015,
-0.1556001157,
-0.6425184011,
0.5227833986,
-0.6218898892,
0.6249650717,
0.5280475616,
-0.0037437635,
-0.1759695709,
-0.652177453,
0.5497227907,
0.5186892748,
-0.8155530691,
0.1943388879,
0.5315614939,
0.1618127674,
-0.2030460835,
0.621419847,
0.1816866249,
0.0355239585,
-0.2107414305,
-0.1812788695,
-0.1726450622,
-0.3504067361,
-0.7729169726,
-0.0081472835,
0.1685123891,
-0.3132224977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15189v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15189v2
|
Biomedical Entity Linking as Multiple Choice Question Answering
| 2024-02-23T08:40:38 | 2024-05-17T09:11:44 |
Zhenxi Lin, Ziheng Zhang, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although biomedical entity linking (BioEL) has made significant progress with
pre-trained language models, challenges still exist for fine-grained and
long-tailed entities. To address these challenges, we present BioELQA, a novel
model that treats Biomedical Entity Linking as Multiple Choice Question
Answering. BioELQA first obtains candidate entities with a fast retriever,
jointly presents the mention and candidate entities to a generator, and then
outputs the predicted symbol associated with its chosen entity. This
formulation enables explicit comparison of different candidate entities, thus
capturing fine-grained interactions between mentions and entities, as well as
among entities themselves. To improve generalization for long-tailed entities,
we retrieve similar labeled training instances as clues and concatenate the
input with retrieved instances for the generator. Extensive experimental
results show that BioELQA outperforms state-of-the-art baselines on several
datasets.
|
[
-0.3970919549,
-0.849752605,
0.9056984782,
-0.1402067244,
0.0166529138,
0.2000056952,
0.0807525516,
-0.9784443378,
0.3699754775,
0.397184968,
-0.6740266681,
-0.3058729768,
-0.2620418668,
0.4678474963,
-0.1175434217,
1.2361559868,
0.1786457896,
0.2412177473,
-0.5413759351,
-0.5029990077,
0.0058138818,
-0.3390493393,
-1.0725172758,
-0.4291501939,
1.1463706493,
0.0094083445,
0.8693442345,
0.490645647,
0.4679609835,
0.2894383967,
-0.0739845559,
0.1091369987,
-0.2410835773,
0.2673558295,
-0.5625516772,
-0.1546215862,
-0.5175216794,
-0.1756284982,
0.6928303838,
1.0348205566,
0.121585913,
0.5350623131,
-0.1410876662,
0.5015717149,
-0.4841685295,
-0.1265387982,
-0.6612980366,
-0.5192762613,
-0.2191498429,
0.086568594,
-0.2987729311,
-0.4858597219,
0.1700298786,
-0.5181240439,
0.1152014956,
0.2526291013,
0.9378878474,
0.5394608378,
-0.6885051727,
-0.3363771737,
-0.3901534975,
0.4434000552,
-0.0842414424,
0.6786670089,
0.3367187977,
0.3396581709,
0.1737620085,
-0.7615095973,
-0.4265880585,
-0.1641192883,
0.0619388185,
0.0624863692,
-0.1123615503,
0.152486071,
0.1359203607,
0.0055093537,
-0.4821282923,
-0.0513157658,
-0.5769793987,
-0.35924685,
0.3759034574,
-0.1291224957,
0.2570942938,
-0.2041911334,
-0.3808399141,
0.1624340266,
-0.8726118207,
-0.0268010106,
0.1822619289,
0.1781778336,
0.431073457,
0.699655056,
-0.1265275627,
0.6680311561,
0.2210269719,
0.3436428607,
0.3866632283,
-0.4172196388,
-0.2438341379,
0.2582435906,
0.5507358909,
-0.035297107,
0.0257627983,
-0.1723482609,
0.1795905679,
-0.1591914892,
0.2268137187,
-0.8572599292,
-0.118352659,
0.9023076892,
-0.6413519979,
-0.0565665811,
-0.6366967559,
-0.7057290673,
-0.0803687945,
-0.0523759387,
0.5957638025,
-0.6989331841,
0.0310841352,
0.1931340843,
0.0776992366,
0.2327598482,
0.1503999084,
-0.7095742226,
-0.0296786372,
0.3910969794,
0.5489472747,
0.1049997732,
-0.1969615221,
-0.8553910255,
0.5111569166,
0.1221251711,
0.9928190112,
-0.7424055934,
-0.3364634514,
-0.1633996814,
-0.0403504968,
0.0314107165,
-0.5232453346,
0.1285111904,
-0.8657458425,
-0.0482030325,
-0.3024139106,
-0.6744750142,
0.0307034701,
0.0021270176,
-0.9381382465,
0.912768364,
0.1622026712,
-0.8396997452,
0.4549007416,
-0.7214364409,
-0.2727841139,
0.4315528572,
-0.3527342975,
-0.5573654771,
-0.4126141965,
0.004515464,
0.4047034979,
-0.2241370678,
0.4732002318,
-0.6890320778,
0.0612064786,
0.2649869025,
0.1089096293,
0.9953269362,
0.0188982505,
-0.0944264308,
0.106783919,
-0.9486498237,
0.130999133,
-0.1144415513,
-0.4900278747,
-0.6728825569,
-0.1190080568,
-0.2636316717,
0.2258665711,
0.1944905519,
-0.7803711891,
0.2531304657,
-0.3782509267,
0.3548071682,
0.3075520396,
0.1460487694,
0.3196928799,
-0.3480781019,
0.2325739115,
-0.0392218642,
-0.1460594982,
0.0355706476,
-0.7386237979,
-0.4813387096,
-0.3445343673,
0.5721660256,
0.5030961037,
-1.044074893,
0.1400414705,
-0.0735774115,
-0.3933267593,
-1.0535055399,
-0.129577145,
0.5168696642,
0.6695141792,
1.0920056105,
0.0842243209,
-0.2706530988,
-1.1210579872,
-0.3293142617,
-0.4250546992,
-0.3632591963,
0.7253801823,
0.9348295331,
-0.439520359,
0.747238338,
-0.3828653097,
0.1737191826,
0.1899612695,
0.329095602,
0.0459081419,
0.4063995779,
0.6111409068,
-0.8086304069,
-0.0543983988,
-0.1253231019,
-0.5894069076,
0.2358131856,
-0.2017507702,
-0.4447983205,
-0.277793169,
0.3674108088,
-0.7237666249,
0.0846384764,
0.286405921,
-0.3017003238,
0.67206496,
-0.0142991962,
0.1855059415,
-1.2099934816,
0.4370661974,
0.0121117309,
-0.1362398416,
-0.4734412134,
0.2252417803,
0.1492289752,
-0.0270708054,
-0.5900053382,
0.8312091827,
-0.4514702559,
-0.0834532902,
0.2035126239,
-0.1817715913,
-0.0846024752,
0.1855109185,
0.2443907708,
0.994320631,
0.6300656199,
-0.7775502801,
0.3556393087,
0.7821483612,
0.0384807438,
0.6594995856,
-0.8673850894,
0.2452338189,
-0.4782763422,
0.3827722073,
-0.7110798955,
-0.4167979956,
0.0849049166,
-0.4478201866,
0.2545985281,
-0.0326188691,
-0.1284162402,
-0.4992688596,
-0.1566212922,
0.7241975665,
0.1372617334,
-0.4715383947,
0.7283816338,
0.2537346184,
-0.2528325319,
-0.6688320041,
-0.6230986118,
-0.0646129549,
-0.0499540232,
-0.4607800543,
0.4756011069,
-0.3381838799,
-0.0213781167,
0.122955583,
-0.0765451118,
-0.4401016533,
-0.0381321125,
0.0099557294,
0.4369686544,
-0.363380909,
0.5256739855,
0.3592977524,
0.0197059531,
0.332857281,
-0.4331119955,
0.0708698556,
-0.1541249901,
-0.3055074513,
0.0525558889,
0.7871069908,
0.3450088501,
-0.5188768506,
0.8469724655,
0.6116678119,
-0.7137389183,
0.0731651708,
-0.4522956312,
-0.2124860734,
-0.4527829587,
0.4878841937,
-0.5615907311,
-1.0153874159,
0.3406001329,
-0.4445593059,
0.0692717507,
0.535304606,
0.6009793878,
-0.4974249303,
0.6543511748,
0.4509562254,
0.2606630027,
-0.277230531,
0.0314397551,
0.0721998811,
-0.8215292096,
-0.534091413,
-0.7805014253,
-0.0670319274,
-0.6124777198,
-0.4697927237,
0.5246244669,
0.1162450612,
-0.5497527122,
0.5025227666,
-0.3488578796,
0.357491225,
0.7695428729,
0.5578818917,
0.240071252,
-0.1022596732,
-0.590773344,
0.2998946309,
-0.7047272325,
-0.4900438786,
0.9462254643,
0.2291108519,
0.6346392632,
0.209420979,
1.0581818819,
-0.257050395,
0.3835381567,
-0.5627035499,
0.4536043704,
0.0721321031,
-1.0769416094,
-0.4276569188,
-0.2433139831,
-1.1052652597,
-0.1809649467,
-0.678111732,
-0.6790587306,
0.3402319849,
0.3219670653,
-0.9802042842,
0.368847698,
-0.1911387444,
0.7831042409,
-0.2141048163,
-0.5681741834,
0.0459914207,
-1.0631991625,
0.1482341886,
-0.3013371229,
-0.0165927764,
-0.0483127832,
-0.1244077906,
0.6204065681,
0.1167903468,
0.4719313383,
0.4213267863,
-0.0434183925,
0.3013909161,
-0.0075880229,
0.1018175706,
0.4146089852,
-0.2161311954,
0.2246886492,
0.1925655156,
-0.6229344606,
-0.2443256378,
0.6002516747,
-0.6135845184,
-0.3078480959,
-0.358359009,
-0.2886218727,
-0.6271679401,
0.3369105756,
0.2475025803,
0.3940445483,
-0.2143264264,
0.2040832639,
1.2093685865,
-0.6045610309,
0.2545043528,
0.2831115723,
-0.0218605548,
-0.3156690896,
0.581579268,
-0.3813050985,
0.2852305472,
0.496981144,
-0.3354525566,
-0.7117304206,
-0.2506732047,
-0.641546309,
0.5219900012,
-0.6857013702,
-0.5135643482,
-1.0433322191,
-0.4044621885,
-0.1646019667,
-0.1086006984,
-0.2716332972,
-0.0726960674,
-0.3471593857,
-0.0302924868,
0.2320761681,
0.4943934381,
0.1413963586,
-0.2853242159,
-1.156997323,
0.6811454892,
0.6846530437,
0.7135984302,
-0.2930653095,
0.2655210197,
-0.0259071961,
0.1988968849,
0.0109330369,
-1.5020850897,
-0.3655312359,
0.3776102066,
0.5420300364,
0.126571238,
-0.2095855623,
0.5319830179,
-0.8735487461,
0.5811129212,
0.2845622003,
-0.6268152595,
0.7214329243,
-0.3710282147,
0.1674613953,
0.7930772305,
1.0892862082,
-0.2280606627,
-0.383238405,
-0.5838258862,
-0.7019030452,
-0.0416386463,
0.3113621473,
-0.1771674752,
-0.5422670841,
0.6021305919,
0.1220099553,
0.2120773345,
-0.5785019994,
-0.6354043484,
-0.0215969607,
-0.0760057569,
0.3815540075,
-0.3076970577,
-0.1759021282,
-0.2117295712,
0.7182014585,
-0.2000105828,
0.6370840669,
0.2654713392,
-0.1781520396,
0.0707876459,
0.5775436163,
0.0764636025,
0.4315160811,
-0.1965665966,
-0.0603354983,
0.1790071875,
-0.239036724,
0.1628713757,
0.3778642714,
-0.2590928078,
0.1734883636,
0.200388357,
0.4662264884,
0.3125900328,
-0.5487131476,
0.172792837,
0.2389201373,
-0.4911139011,
0.2291246802,
-0.1207800284,
0.6051077247,
0.3442454636,
0.2495909929,
0.0902767181,
0.5479616523,
-0.5138309002,
0.6424902081,
0.4884059131,
-0.3921045065,
-0.0089284061,
1.3859370947,
0.4616183937,
0.0800754353,
0.6920703053,
-0.0725617632,
-0.1948023885,
0.6456058621,
0.4883464873,
0.6414246559,
-0.3103924096,
0.4203220606,
0.7814025283,
0.0681087747,
0.2224336863,
0.5414955616,
0.1566696316,
-0.5939922929,
-0.6718630791,
-0.8162300587,
-0.4531716406,
0.1627933383,
-0.8317039609,
0.0744613186,
-0.0172926653,
-0.4964103699,
0.7035059929,
-0.2604817152,
-0.8401224017,
0.3434332311,
0.3028054237,
0.9508104324,
-0.6197739244,
0.9614014626,
1.1222679615,
-0.8988984227,
-0.6794653535,
-0.3012235165,
-0.1970152408,
-0.7201974988,
0.7021719813,
-0.0338358022,
-0.1771517843,
0.192327261,
-0.5163964629,
-1.0211652517,
1.0621563196,
0.291675061,
-0.5223752856,
-0.4541479051,
0.0646310076,
0.3758893013,
-0.1279982775,
0.374380976,
0.4646418989,
0.497183919,
0.0352356024,
-0.8776371479,
0.1544083953,
-0.177872777,
-0.2323374599,
0.3203556538,
-0.5625266433,
0.6372894645,
-0.4827560484,
-0.1320016086,
0.2533734441,
0.7811481357,
0.4471397102,
0.3368741572,
0.325622946,
0.1781612188,
0.9803358912,
0.0793715045,
0.7823360562,
-0.3874949515,
0.4934895039,
1.1989243031,
-0.4355917871,
0.7848429084,
0.4918121397,
-0.3450729847,
0.6173385978,
0.8107995391,
-0.0197222009,
0.234969005,
0.1637082547,
-0.43451038,
-0.6407943964,
-0.2622820139,
-0.5963335633,
0.2977176011,
0.3923276663,
-0.2355604172,
-0.4694981575,
0.0021217887,
-0.3083929718,
-0.0568822771,
-0.4861959517,
0.5399867892,
-0.0108822668,
-0.532583952,
0.3354146481,
-0.3233296573,
0.4527454674,
-0.5720004439,
-0.4185294211,
0.0478880666,
-0.3912106454,
-0.1277237386,
-0.7674691677,
0.166460678,
-0.2537961304,
-0.1687518209,
-0.0741295144,
0.882080555,
-0.8078081012,
-0.3787738979,
0.2026704103,
0.7428381443,
0.1328851581,
0.1175278723,
-1.0575537682,
-0.5323693156,
-0.1866789311,
0.0537340231,
0.2808139324,
0.1466766447,
-0.0122111188,
0.9149654508,
0.5619168878,
0.0159916449,
-0.0530038513,
-0.1143847629,
0.8004959226,
-0.6931095123,
-0.2397761792,
-0.4660935402,
0.3383753598,
-0.1279232949,
-0.3083738983,
0.2150849551,
0.6497630477,
0.7718601227,
-0.178756997,
0.6072421074,
0.0289520025,
0.6676514745,
-0.5399736762,
0.705886364,
-0.528134644,
-0.1113635302,
-0.0430468023,
-0.809455812,
-0.1642781347,
0.3996486664,
0.0936773419,
0.2628358603,
1.0873707533,
0.5089645386,
-0.1481432766,
-0.1165776178,
0.0786090866,
0.1956335306,
-0.2083442956,
0.8992829323,
0.6181809902,
-0.3322145939,
0.4737540781,
-0.0017716723,
-0.006673926,
0.1284317076,
-0.829407692,
-0.9673833847,
-0.6473221779,
-0.6489703655,
-0.7133911252,
0.3530587256,
0.9783862233,
0.5478083491,
-0.8866906166,
0.3010562956,
0.5615147948,
-0.0603247471,
-0.0531736426,
-0.07842917,
0.3426499069,
-0.1335244775,
-0.6294440627,
0.3014663756,
0.3783465326,
0.0470263101,
-0.0887993202,
0.2198523283,
-0.7557680011,
0.1795280576,
0.5032519698,
0.5130525827,
-0.6516683698,
-0.4682135284,
0.1423190981,
-0.3317798674,
-0.0269940402,
0.6373742223,
-0.9511238933,
0.2119764537,
0.0814111903,
1.2729635239,
0.4230726659,
-0.0593891107,
0.2457420826,
-0.6300272942,
-0.3778283596,
0.350964576,
0.3156090081,
0.0840915814,
-0.6391991973,
0.4594540894,
-0.0580717884,
-0.4822568595,
-0.2137710601,
0.4697603285,
-1.0042043924,
-0.4496513903,
1.1500595808,
0.1439456493,
-0.2684280574,
-0.3263417184,
-0.032754872,
0.2986575961,
-0.1568503082,
0.4990028441,
0.5047616363,
-0.1665620357,
0.2810236514,
-0.6264699101,
0.6982515454,
0.4610598981,
-0.9335692525,
-0.2747208774,
0.7764347196,
0.4529783726,
0.0390686691,
0.8821446896,
0.0777798072,
0.6600346565,
-0.1524772197,
0.0410170853,
0.0826726854,
-0.3820968568,
-0.0623659082,
0.0703648701,
-0.1982382089,
-0.1615119129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15180v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15180v2
|
Break the Breakout: Reinventing LM Defense Against Jailbreak Attacks with Self-Refinement
| 2024-02-23T08:22:24 | 2024-02-27T01:39:20 |
Heegyu Kim, Sehyun Yuk, Hyunsouk Cho
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Caution: This paper includes offensive words that could potentially cause
unpleasantness. Language models (LMs) are vulnerable to exploitation for
adversarial misuse. Training LMs for safety alignment is extensive and makes it
hard to respond to fast-developing attacks immediately, such as jailbreaks. We
propose self-refine with formatting that achieves outstanding safety even in
non-safety-aligned LMs and evaluate our method alongside several defense
baselines, demonstrating that it is the safest training-free method against
jailbreak attacks. Additionally, we proposed a formatting method that improves
the efficiency of the self-refine process while reducing attack success rates
in fewer iterations. We've also observed that non-safety-aligned LMs outperform
safety-aligned LMs in safety tasks by giving more helpful and safe responses.
In conclusion, our findings can achieve less safety risk with fewer
computational costs, allowing non-safety LM to be easily utilized in real-world
service.
|
[
-0.1917187124,
-0.8036900163,
0.4022385776,
0.2100627869,
-0.0788773,
0.5110358,
0.0053043868,
-0.5303869247,
0.2748602033,
0.5360372663,
-0.7327669263,
-0.3526340425,
-0.4291452765,
0.0573448502,
-0.5073082447,
1.1120512486,
0.0299706962,
-0.3200382888,
0.1244237646,
0.0270919707,
-0.7007684708,
-0.5211481452,
-0.5609762669,
-0.0455125943,
0.4244704843,
0.465095669,
0.6929739118,
0.9039402604,
0.4541088939,
0.2961786389,
-0.0232746024,
-0.0871358663,
-0.4355891347,
0.3925732374,
-0.3501468599,
-0.121456854,
-0.3193742335,
-0.0660485178,
-0.0561377667,
0.314635545,
-0.2208331376,
-0.1662265211,
-0.1973794848,
1.0112859011,
-0.7873783708,
-0.2894301414,
-0.8094364405,
0.0912721977,
-0.1063665822,
0.1493921131,
-0.7485041022,
-0.3155196309,
-0.1808978915,
-0.1299251616,
0.0183831193,
-0.0671588778,
0.7701007724,
0.1874420345,
-0.1448128819,
-0.0626029372,
-0.5277510881,
0.4744279981,
-0.7783071995,
0.2040033489,
0.1660980433,
0.2055577487,
-0.2956950068,
-0.4993080199,
-0.1055659279,
-0.407313019,
0.0857882053,
-0.1477336884,
-0.2807192504,
0.0881547332,
0.0973831266,
0.1200508028,
-0.5454677343,
0.3340516686,
-0.6101384163,
-0.1110293046,
0.8805712461,
0.2262474597,
0.5193457007,
-0.0849810019,
-0.726783216,
-0.0057020937,
-1.0997034311,
0.1123188436,
0.3026917577,
0.6621904969,
-0.0723521486,
0.3458663523,
-0.15057078,
0.6282725334,
0.2076950073,
-0.2423649281,
0.2922994792,
-0.3711444139,
-0.2608445287,
0.3731118143,
1.1304866076,
0.4432961047,
0.301148355,
-0.439160049,
-0.0884600207,
-0.1738091707,
0.8704256415,
-0.9048637748,
-0.3906126618,
0.3313759565,
-0.2582313716,
-0.731259048,
0.050082583,
-0.6990769506,
-0.5831602812,
0.1240603849,
0.2374906391,
-0.7412670255,
-0.275865078,
-0.0032554038,
0.1862461716,
-0.0608969852,
-0.0035476899,
-1.0896390676,
0.241446197,
0.4968166947,
0.8689669371,
0.1263323575,
-0.1084668934,
-0.3829072118,
0.0891207457,
-0.5242602825,
0.5294178724,
0.004456603,
-0.5582084656,
-0.1877593696,
0.0228905138,
-0.2688834965,
-0.5542593598,
0.2830773294,
-0.3619558215,
-0.2185081244,
0.0861623287,
-0.5569947362,
0.147785008,
0.3877268136,
-0.7209202647,
0.7155794501,
0.0442216918,
-0.7380905747,
0.1407831609,
-0.6776744127,
-0.6924443245,
-0.1078510433,
-0.1542395204,
-0.7838081121,
-0.0323851407,
0.2397290319,
0.1135461405,
0.2370445877,
0.2220586985,
-0.4033723176,
-0.0855490565,
0.364498049,
0.0298664737,
0.7520285249,
0.5694315434,
-0.703900516,
0.3066621423,
-0.7281966805,
0.2162900716,
0.3664487004,
-0.1868851334,
-0.2081975341,
0.1550598443,
-0.3392468989,
0.3467521071,
0.3828784227,
-0.7582230568,
0.2339201421,
-0.6345290542,
0.4069786668,
0.8912547231,
-0.1234822124,
0.3252024949,
-0.043360211,
0.5076346993,
0.0621969029,
0.4782778323,
-0.4861466587,
-0.1305152476,
-0.5520592928,
-0.2706570327,
0.2395478487,
0.781891644,
-0.3878919482,
0.5686426759,
0.2261461467,
-0.7127060294,
-0.6355365515,
0.5426695347,
0.7032592893,
0.5871656537,
0.7192327976,
-0.2577193975,
-0.9304149747,
-0.9278303385,
-0.4402783513,
-0.0674338341,
0.5450396538,
-0.1746126711,
0.1836134195,
-0.2877416313,
1.0777955055,
-0.409042567,
0.0414804481,
-0.5444313884,
-0.0610265546,
0.0419069827,
0.770783484,
0.6358121634,
-0.4182963967,
-0.5731306076,
-0.3283040524,
-0.9078705311,
-0.2073109299,
-0.0912878737,
0.2244676054,
0.2033342421,
0.9668268561,
-0.2439672947,
0.6734132767,
0.2786177993,
-0.6569267511,
0.6957563162,
-0.0495165139,
-0.2153580785,
-1.006043911,
-0.2545790374,
-0.0015672692,
-0.3345114291,
-0.9975792766,
0.3215534091,
0.3005939424,
-0.2313733846,
-0.669259131,
0.2081798464,
-0.4439515769,
0.2507083714,
-0.5812460184,
0.0849864557,
-0.0805444643,
-0.000328646,
-0.1504695714,
0.9405007362,
0.5116711259,
-0.3689216673,
0.2268037349,
-0.0224715769,
-0.4247529805,
0.18981947,
-0.7539568543,
0.4152971506,
-0.0506136194,
-0.1130356416,
-0.7472129464,
0.2634972036,
0.2213495076,
-0.159252584,
0.4104933143,
-0.3833007216,
-0.3084276915,
-0.2858730555,
-0.3527271152,
0.234559983,
0.5272322893,
-0.5906868577,
0.2500545084,
0.2021425217,
-0.0530250296,
-0.7411831617,
-0.6323031783,
0.2862942219,
-0.5464417934,
-0.7279075384,
0.2769682109,
-0.240902409,
-0.3036513031,
-0.4424200952,
-0.215725407,
0.1019957438,
0.653724134,
0.4961555302,
0.4281538427,
0.0138765369,
-0.2747617364,
-0.2508277893,
-0.1005906388,
0.1294574887,
-0.0751368627,
0.6468241811,
-0.2765474021,
-0.1619341522,
-0.4495850503,
0.2615326941,
0.4565874934,
-0.2628946602,
1.1632674932,
0.1848868579,
0.0157453232,
0.0079988996,
-0.4385670722,
-0.0926067755,
-0.6071817875,
0.1564839482,
-0.4108931422,
-1.0258265734,
0.1858525723,
0.066883266,
0.086600706,
0.0865253061,
0.560321331,
-0.2420101613,
0.833202064,
0.8467233777,
-0.2336160094,
0.7101535201,
0.1546497792,
0.7124771476,
-0.6164314747,
-0.4051730633,
-0.4569270015,
-0.1121079177,
-0.4762530327,
0.1080646962,
-0.1374808848,
0.4216360152,
-0.3940636516,
0.9855012894,
-0.5792204738,
0.5527036786,
0.2402880937,
0.1190659031,
-0.0176049396,
-0.273663491,
-0.2995827198,
-0.1374639869,
-0.30405882,
-0.4765968025,
1.0851882696,
0.6437723637,
1.1465030909,
0.3376534283,
1.2411160469,
0.3559418321,
0.378238976,
-0.4845272303,
0.594053328,
0.0509364866,
-0.6270518899,
-0.0758897662,
-0.3891462982,
-0.9758759737,
0.2591032982,
0.08280994,
-1.2385201454,
-0.0673582926,
0.2084223479,
-0.464234978,
0.4405380189,
-0.8488799334,
1.0986661911,
-0.4331578016,
-0.25003618,
-0.0280625205,
-0.7587029338,
0.577418983,
0.0085689202,
0.7322582603,
-0.3840491474,
0.3855168819,
0.7256615162,
-0.9300638437,
0.992230773,
-0.2615665793,
-0.2095250338,
0.3628361225,
0.5002105832,
0.390488416,
-0.1347274929,
0.2065497041,
-0.3498921096,
-0.0155719398,
-0.2290484458,
-0.4902084768,
0.5928564668,
-0.6681999564,
-0.9442817569,
-0.4133659005,
-0.533633709,
-0.0388075076,
0.255559355,
0.1146024615,
0.0764358342,
-0.2960154116,
0.0411871225,
0.7160367966,
0.0479021668,
0.8484969735,
0.5761544704,
-0.4030044079,
-0.535310328,
0.7042195201,
-0.1387348324,
0.4462141395,
-0.0778197125,
0.0455255806,
-0.2514282167,
-0.6478602886,
-0.2778915167,
-0.0245969873,
-0.5879471302,
-0.3589951396,
-0.4682691395,
-0.5097613931,
-0.7188420296,
-0.198386997,
-0.715295732,
-0.5016055703,
-0.113056615,
-0.5446617007,
0.4421476722,
0.5050137043,
-0.3394151926,
0.409509629,
-0.8631202579,
0.1905584633,
-0.0066275694,
0.1354645789,
-0.3001040518,
-0.5697181821,
-0.5714523792,
-0.296410501,
-0.5901663899,
-1.1544128656,
0.4331011176,
-0.1807410717,
0.3358018994,
0.6302901506,
0.2124492526,
0.5324452519,
-0.8366520405,
0.6048793197,
0.6823886633,
-0.9257829785,
0.9582253098,
-0.1595990658,
0.0081120888,
0.9868388176,
0.1559075713,
-0.3469635248,
-0.4415418506,
-0.7439527512,
-1.1185337305,
0.4511760771,
0.0906623602,
0.0956732929,
-0.3511321843,
0.2457291484,
-0.2124805599,
0.1529858857,
-1.0973645449,
-0.4229781628,
-0.4754016697,
-0.2406434119,
0.1705754995,
-0.3255364001,
-0.4880500436,
-0.1787457317,
0.6735352278,
0.0778511316,
0.0470804535,
0.0840616748,
-0.2979673743,
0.1762833148,
0.6934561729,
0.563071847,
0.5107744932,
-0.2255349904,
0.21574606,
-0.1516363174,
-0.4077740014,
0.5969522595,
-0.0625860468,
-0.3133271337,
-0.2051285654,
0.2158030719,
0.7526935339,
0.1635470986,
-0.8644880652,
0.339125216,
0.0361963324,
-0.0227440372,
-0.3408201039,
0.5443722606,
-0.0237954278,
0.0904587135,
0.2067538202,
-0.0204307418,
-0.1700589955,
-0.5929362774,
0.4113247991,
0.385551244,
-0.5648655891,
-0.0248603765,
0.5858743787,
0.1064756662,
-0.5744867921,
0.5744737387,
-0.0629343688,
-0.5312669873,
0.6158947349,
0.9722567797,
1.0539733171,
-0.5346209407,
-0.0131523702,
0.2982349992,
0.8137235641,
0.1261337698,
0.2001799792,
0.1933296472,
-0.7951197028,
-0.186388731,
-0.2909613848,
-0.2913448513,
0.2728086114,
-0.7894651294,
-0.036701344,
-1.1492468119,
-0.2795901895,
-0.3561488986,
-0.4217781425,
-0.0522891991,
0.5133393407,
0.275642544,
1.3283096552,
-0.7256343365,
0.7836583853,
0.4007411301,
-0.5114642382,
-0.7871839404,
-0.2441750467,
0.2005212903,
-0.5338596702,
0.528136611,
0.6335912347,
-0.2139856517,
-0.4215646684,
-0.5930648446,
-0.9968144894,
0.9241716266,
0.3096370101,
-0.8294817209,
-0.0503881648,
0.0544867404,
0.2580626309,
-0.5530910492,
-0.0447207429,
0.9627321362,
0.1452297121,
-0.2629529536,
-0.8557303548,
0.3432253599,
-0.2671605945,
-0.0126311369,
0.3560126424,
-0.6821787953,
0.7362111807,
-0.4762802124,
-0.1252704263,
0.2389111221,
0.8382098079,
0.4396063387,
0.115133442,
0.3788413405,
0.9853526354,
0.5842214227,
-0.1464248002,
0.8195303082,
-0.5074641705,
0.1880135685,
1.4493223429,
-0.2652808428,
0.765142858,
0.5773732066,
-0.0694860443,
1.0822769403,
0.4933063984,
-0.2050797641,
0.9652544856,
0.3495120406,
-0.3360695243,
-0.128147617,
0.3724717796,
-0.4165263176,
0.3082782626,
0.2004941702,
-0.535887301,
-0.3725806475,
0.0009625774,
0.6627554893,
0.1846433282,
-0.3878584206,
0.7643889189,
0.1475188136,
-0.4805058539,
0.6058659554,
0.3741052449,
0.5131804943,
-0.6489548087,
0.6410608888,
-0.2865690589,
0.3235515356,
-0.4614539742,
-0.651540339,
0.5405648947,
0.4095492661,
-0.1569964588,
-0.1113268733,
0.6948695779,
-0.0888400823,
-0.0781207457,
0.566953361,
0.2121083438,
-0.076045312,
0.0985531062,
-0.9509772062,
0.2310973108,
0.0381730311,
-0.220679462,
0.7495871782,
-0.1567240208,
0.1796592325,
0.9190520048,
0.5903594494,
-0.3191343844,
0.351121068,
0.1562562138,
0.9215716124,
-1.0298463106,
-0.7198966146,
-1.4298914671,
0.7041038275,
-0.2358266413,
0.184165135,
0.9823110104,
0.5737138987,
0.5988402367,
0.0414558239,
0.9157317281,
-0.1666416079,
0.3798106909,
-0.6306601763,
0.805652678,
-0.0338355266,
0.2835935056,
-0.3666772246,
-0.3618359268,
-0.1001123339,
0.6084504128,
-0.4661349654,
0.0064408565,
0.7121140957,
0.5437887311,
0.2796288431,
-0.1086124182,
0.2279035151,
0.2258161306,
0.6607643366,
0.5487482548,
0.8086480498,
-0.4400934577,
0.6620999575,
-0.3747264445,
-0.2088517845,
0.0151972752,
-1.0860505104,
-1.1193087101,
0.1191193461,
-0.4733296335,
-0.8953217268,
0.1092226133,
0.9235193133,
0.774939537,
-0.9530302286,
-0.3551448882,
-0.0864681378,
-0.0095286388,
-0.0824107751,
-0.260394752,
-0.0233823638,
-0.7959272861,
-0.0680778846,
1.3934634924,
0.4128549695,
0.1578486264,
-0.071691677,
-0.0195701309,
-0.2493204325,
0.170382753,
0.226503551,
0.8752663136,
-0.5267535448,
-0.2707241476,
-0.2024075985,
-0.2521137893,
0.4078963995,
0.7488848567,
-0.7078223228,
0.4911689162,
-0.2146714628,
0.7757667303,
0.3141237497,
0.1971547753,
0.5651062131,
-0.9085870981,
0.2078863829,
-0.123629801,
0.5418325067,
0.4592652321,
-0.4630223215,
0.4372098744,
0.1455266625,
-0.3530150056,
-0.8674122691,
0.5919275284,
-0.5914004445,
-0.5067115426,
0.6758502722,
-0.4060551524,
-0.3333292902,
-0.2196868807,
0.0443763696,
-0.0179291666,
-0.414942652,
0.995827198,
0.4333998263,
-0.2327689081,
-0.369332552,
-0.1472268105,
0.638384819,
0.3901219964,
-0.969103694,
0.1606767625,
0.1212905198,
0.7945914268,
0.3670817912,
0.4919286072,
-0.3567534387,
0.4558579028,
-0.2853292823,
0.1512479484,
-0.378374815,
-0.665748775,
-0.4662108123,
0.3112168312,
0.2026991248,
-0.1916817874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15179v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15179v3
|
Advancing Parameter Efficiency in Fine-tuning via Representation Editing
| 2024-02-23T08:21:02 | 2024-06-02T09:05:31 |
Muling Wu, Wenhao Liu, Xiaohua Wang, Tianlong Li, Changze Lv, Zixuan Ling, Jianhao Zhu, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques have drawn significant
attention due to their ability to yield competitive results while updating only
a small portion of the adjustable parameters. However, existing PEFT methods
pose challenges in hyperparameter selection, such as choosing the rank for LoRA
or Adapter, or specifying the length of soft prompts. To address these
challenges, we propose a novel fine-tuning approach for neural models, named
Representation EDiting (RED), which modifies the representations generated at
some layers through the application of scaling and biasing operations. While
existing PEFT methods still demonstrate over-parameterization that could
potentially undermine the generalization ability acquired from pre-training,
RED can substantially reduce the number of trainable parameters by a factor of
25, 700 compared to full parameter fine-tuning and by a factor of 32 relative
to LoRA. Remarkably, RED achieves results comparable or superior to both full
parameter fine-tuning and other PEFT methods. Extensive experiments across
various model architectures and scales, including RoBERTa, GPT-2, T5, and
LLaMA-2, have demonstrated the effectiveness and efficiency of RED1, thereby
positioning it as a promising PEFT strategy for large-scale neural models.
|
[
-0.635935843,
-0.6231589913,
0.5405833721,
0.1750164777,
-0.4371399879,
-0.329128921,
-0.7392132878,
-0.3475649357,
0.224700585,
0.3463745415,
-0.2890527546,
-0.3122418821,
-0.7400114536,
0.0217529163,
0.0091841491,
0.9194900393,
0.0258297957,
0.1328695565,
0.1059277281,
-0.3692645729,
-0.4634750783,
-0.3972081244,
-0.8209905624,
-0.4989651442,
0.8143841624,
0.1993649006,
0.685554564,
0.8452198505,
0.4615196586,
0.3332900703,
-0.5550170541,
0.4684580266,
-0.4274944365,
0.1825797558,
-0.4609023929,
-0.5545267463,
-0.7725220919,
-0.0413483009,
0.7209096551,
0.8432071209,
-0.0309426282,
0.2792561352,
0.0425770432,
0.9052920341,
-0.8987543583,
0.1182710826,
-0.9954330921,
0.0216656514,
0.0655704811,
-0.111788027,
-0.4863382876,
-0.1201258823,
-0.0749597475,
-0.86760813,
0.1405221373,
-0.3795372844,
0.8546748757,
0.5622634888,
-0.1102467552,
0.5056234002,
-0.7132138014,
0.7429479361,
-0.6421525478,
0.3838066161,
0.4153611064,
0.354652524,
0.177350238,
-0.9332762957,
-0.0452416874,
-0.0502060242,
-0.1173444763,
-0.2100250125,
-0.4225316644,
0.4244062603,
0.6364229918,
-0.1149199605,
0.145175904,
0.0556913763,
-0.3080305755,
-0.2493096739,
0.5800060034,
0.0930692032,
-0.2069611549,
0.034706872,
0.0649353266,
-0.1853382289,
-0.747055769,
-0.3863894343,
0.4129585326,
0.5361663699,
0.3289447427,
0.4621482491,
-0.2407443821,
0.9234849215,
0.6661024094,
0.5610499382,
-0.0664739385,
-0.0404285155,
-0.4415144622,
-0.0499501079,
0.4290381074,
0.6403916478,
0.2530477941,
0.0583728328,
-0.4328490496,
-0.2448958158,
0.4202706516,
-1.0082749128,
-0.4601608217,
-0.0283672623,
-0.6571622491,
-0.1814982444,
-0.2164298892,
-0.9279592037,
-0.5875883698,
-0.5641671419,
0.6655026674,
-0.3594042361,
-0.1904387772,
0.1942098886,
-0.3041554987,
-0.0703289285,
0.7813559175,
-1.1246751547,
0.2514196932,
0.4947440326,
0.7477532625,
0.0888346955,
-0.2449643612,
-0.5341670513,
-0.0004678636,
-0.4181154072,
0.6182101369,
-0.7722125649,
-0.0239012819,
-0.3661149144,
-0.0812452883,
-0.0701505169,
-0.8553195596,
0.3167773187,
-0.6841312051,
-0.2811802626,
-0.4877034426,
-0.3790158629,
-0.1695573032,
0.2598904371,
-0.7981982231,
0.5601868629,
0.1623134464,
-0.4127653241,
0.4932153225,
-0.8989724517,
-0.1582728326,
-0.2413648367,
0.010715181,
-0.5436890721,
0.5183469057,
0.6031530499,
0.5235785842,
-0.0102794161,
0.0109674102,
-0.2756135166,
-0.629539907,
-0.1072191,
-0.4712214768,
0.3710349202,
0.0386471637,
-0.3618748784,
0.3888731003,
-0.7936145067,
0.2360478044,
0.0681239963,
-0.3200423717,
-0.3609131575,
-0.0236078203,
0.0712913424,
-0.1067328751,
0.4006929398,
-0.5372543335,
0.5721802711,
-0.3344556391,
0.9058921933,
0.934540689,
0.0961730853,
0.5552211404,
-0.1241607517,
0.2651348412,
-0.0943030491,
0.205182299,
-0.0881692767,
-0.2409094721,
-0.7577334642,
-0.1781406403,
0.9649214149,
-0.0142639028,
-0.1997437179,
0.3496052027,
-0.0277949069,
-0.6043441892,
-0.5567005277,
-0.0717280582,
0.1708293557,
0.2782274485,
0.6707895994,
0.2290241867,
-0.577775538,
-1.1450510025,
-0.513507247,
-0.0020146964,
-0.0621960387,
0.3445350528,
0.3733476698,
-0.1843328625,
0.7148781419,
-0.6537538767,
-0.1763450354,
0.0808272064,
0.1532069296,
0.2577712238,
0.8235117197,
0.738432169,
-0.6362805367,
-0.5304473639,
0.2825037241,
-0.1617992371,
0.1280515939,
-0.3077016175,
-0.1996211857,
-0.0585398898,
0.5605074763,
-0.6208232641,
0.38177073,
0.180913642,
-0.3990410864,
0.4746656716,
-0.6193299294,
0.2990791798,
-0.4993766248,
0.0496114232,
0.1658185422,
-0.2353033274,
-0.4103222787,
0.1724156141,
0.5016376972,
-0.1417541951,
-0.4173820615,
0.4198668301,
-0.5007420778,
0.1257390529,
-0.1657638848,
-0.4405560791,
0.0882345736,
0.7326821685,
-0.0016928596,
0.8684173226,
0.3580970168,
-0.3734463751,
-0.1036854908,
0.0939968899,
-0.0608344413,
0.4080852568,
-1.1084721088,
0.3219419122,
-0.0794690475,
0.0068764612,
-0.6496276259,
-0.1289864928,
0.0480952002,
-0.1390718669,
0.4744945467,
-0.6390228868,
-0.4954870343,
0.2437309176,
-0.3756866455,
0.4813905358,
0.5644323826,
-0.6917879581,
0.711191833,
0.1056224033,
-0.0286455303,
-0.2186234146,
-0.7682471871,
0.0015453361,
-0.3993726671,
-0.5242134333,
1.0269688368,
0.1474978477,
0.0360328108,
-0.2566595674,
-0.2406155765,
-0.0854065865,
-0.0010342717,
-0.0880371258,
-0.0917763561,
-0.2087715864,
0.1057001948,
0.6790984273,
-0.195561111,
0.0116250673,
-0.131040886,
0.3899127841,
-0.0549232438,
-0.328407079,
-0.5259370208,
0.3963638842,
0.8641742468,
-0.4833508432,
0.6336826682,
0.5166841149,
-0.5942565799,
-0.3770870566,
-0.3607853055,
-0.3317882419,
-0.5472007394,
0.6583107114,
-0.3224189878,
-0.6403126717,
0.6072273254,
-0.4789442718,
0.0073354985,
0.3942265511,
0.3527107239,
-0.0080914935,
1.5199735165,
0.4984599054,
0.2734986544,
0.8672623038,
-0.4682884216,
-0.2028758675,
-1.0961773396,
-0.0142731937,
-0.4517050683,
-1.0089972019,
-0.5118143559,
-0.4358195961,
0.6193451285,
0.2746707201,
-0.7165687084,
0.3329292536,
-1.021225214,
0.8097170591,
0.4748230278,
0.6431748867,
-0.0272714458,
0.2497158945,
0.142367214,
-0.3515574932,
-0.5460161567,
-0.2854145765,
1.0991479158,
0.4236275256,
0.7147212029,
-0.1498648077,
0.6521259546,
0.2509322464,
-0.1271571964,
-0.6326230168,
0.5726751089,
-0.5441061258,
-0.3440762758,
-0.3586481214,
-0.2117642909,
-0.6702199578,
0.3684355617,
-0.2354717702,
-0.6742014885,
0.7218526006,
0.5277372003,
-0.7294908166,
0.5068956614,
-0.9712520242,
0.7065395713,
-0.0026109503,
-0.4367464781,
-0.4824320674,
-0.2951660752,
-0.2392974347,
0.0185915325,
-0.6268614531,
0.1164509431,
-0.4270458221,
0.9235788584,
-0.4763055444,
0.750359118,
-0.7141213417,
0.2121362835,
0.024909541,
0.1134303808,
0.8835469484,
0.1736076027,
-0.5786296725,
0.2097151875,
-0.1511585116,
-0.4424816668,
-1.0725533962,
0.7185419798,
-0.7714891434,
-0.5115661621,
-0.0066240081,
-0.532320559,
-0.4953026175,
0.1277226657,
0.1936237514,
0.1833079755,
0.1130694449,
0.4089340568,
0.5995028615,
-0.1040131599,
0.2576026917,
-0.0190718379,
0.2125269175,
-0.6321079135,
0.8661578298,
0.4118470848,
0.1569856107,
0.1821624637,
0.2310980707,
-0.18484281,
-1.0776695013,
-0.4658829272,
0.2437739968,
-0.6312496066,
-0.4563261867,
-0.4334570169,
-0.0625447184,
0.1148098335,
-0.2625785172,
-0.6759405136,
-0.5978655219,
-0.5744957924,
0.0207965896,
0.6019202471,
0.5558444262,
-0.1410537958,
0.4915859103,
-0.5975619555,
0.3004411757,
0.4879940152,
0.7023816109,
-0.0846202448,
-0.6610021591,
-0.317186743,
0.0913453326,
-0.1775996536,
-0.7847637534,
0.1841381043,
0.4012162983,
0.4169333875,
0.108134523,
-0.1669117957,
1.2725411654,
-0.5325727463,
0.7449262142,
0.1921078712,
-1.0202986002,
0.8124296665,
-0.4928999245,
0.2696959972,
0.7324171662,
-0.0214065593,
-0.0696338639,
0.1748208851,
-0.5050766468,
-0.7922723293,
0.7777145505,
0.0734106302,
0.5605563521,
0.2399921119,
0.842815578,
0.0710517466,
0.0849244744,
-0.3614658713,
-0.2409255207,
-0.2351198792,
0.0645704865,
0.3490679562,
-0.308183521,
-0.1412395537,
-0.9587458372,
0.5018753409,
-0.4072896838,
0.5662882328,
0.2229097486,
0.1226879284,
-0.3490636945,
0.1411091834,
0.629186213,
0.8121424317,
-0.303591907,
0.0469324626,
0.3941239119,
-0.3143945038,
0.036130771,
0.2166040242,
-0.3076356947,
-0.0316468552,
0.3011071682,
1.0985876322,
0.1227021366,
-0.2779307663,
0.2163669318,
-0.0618500821,
-0.4524146616,
0.2554244995,
0.4549866617,
-0.0543048568,
0.487680614,
0.1513241827,
0.6978750229,
-0.0227401499,
0.009168406,
0.1411624849,
0.3782867789,
-0.4436791539,
-0.3435201049,
0.8021757603,
0.1257039756,
-0.3136096299,
0.5820654035,
0.0582194217,
-0.1123025343,
0.6760180593,
0.5035120845,
0.8608925343,
0.0682124123,
0.1324656457,
0.6017465591,
0.1563069075,
-0.1172782332,
0.2022549808,
-0.04374367,
-0.4691391587,
-0.5734663606,
-0.5857495666,
-0.2543012202,
0.2200377882,
-0.7627304792,
0.280022949,
-0.8926380277,
-0.5160197616,
0.2555860281,
-0.1418937743,
-0.4504493177,
0.1020997539,
-0.0255211983,
1.1822482347,
-0.5641913414,
0.718229115,
1.1425584555,
-0.1573154777,
-0.7971144915,
-0.0003191333,
-0.5255541801,
-0.4706142247,
0.5178460479,
-0.2663158476,
0.2737830877,
0.0076554343,
-0.6934871674,
-0.694707036,
1.0081194639,
1.2486199141,
-0.9045858979,
-0.1685276777,
-0.1431994438,
0.6339656115,
-0.180907622,
0.202033028,
0.8710618019,
0.8009482026,
-0.2812356055,
-0.6990144849,
0.0698144734,
-0.3115548491,
0.2884224951,
0.3968789876,
-0.6347648501,
0.927033186,
-0.1026383266,
0.1835868508,
0.0634560138,
0.6583158374,
0.3223817945,
-0.1611798704,
0.6981346011,
0.3134300709,
0.7222575545,
-0.20487459,
0.6780597568,
-0.2949207723,
0.4915511906,
1.1279640198,
0.2062975764,
0.6751711965,
0.7679294348,
-0.337202698,
0.1312229782,
0.6444938779,
-0.2098980546,
0.6010302305,
0.1712981611,
0.0718566924,
-0.5661247969,
0.1081486866,
-0.3478209674,
0.4192345142,
0.2475500852,
-0.7657553554,
-0.3370209336,
-0.0147677548,
-0.1297152489,
0.2827398777,
-0.6100552678,
0.6224437952,
-0.1903201491,
-0.5685643554,
0.9279606342,
0.1736610979,
0.699605763,
-0.4960652292,
-0.5674462318,
-0.1333507895,
0.1049949229,
-0.2864711285,
-0.6452588439,
0.42015028,
0.0144431274,
-0.4571146369,
-0.2819651961,
0.6900261641,
-0.3529117703,
-0.4853726327,
0.3656558394,
0.191079095,
-0.3811936677,
-0.7160810232,
-0.9218280315,
0.4187291861,
0.0238398667,
-0.4539148211,
0.4413791299,
0.3079874814,
0.0334660411,
0.2388171256,
0.3524226546,
0.4662386477,
-0.1091822907,
0.0957304835,
1.0877420902,
-0.7469463944,
-0.3498596549,
-0.8289822936,
0.6240090132,
-0.0954715982,
-0.5037872195,
0.1235599294,
0.067657277,
0.6590099335,
-0.2108476758,
0.4615194798,
-0.0129013164,
-0.0383448154,
-0.4435250461,
1.0446054935,
-0.6858097315,
0.2125674784,
-0.2572392225,
-1.0630809069,
-0.5130085945,
0.6413170099,
-0.4294151962,
0.2547829151,
0.3453631401,
0.8616828918,
-0.3384308219,
-0.0630581006,
0.4893066883,
0.2936465144,
0.2276674211,
0.4004046619,
0.5225561261,
-0.6286197901,
0.3505762219,
-0.4504373372,
-0.0156113561,
0.0153326718,
-0.8073240519,
-0.7260181904,
-0.509121716,
-0.4629624784,
-0.0534260571,
0.2394825071,
0.9838020802,
1.2643251419,
-0.8111121058,
0.334656626,
-0.1619232595,
-0.1252271235,
-0.5761973262,
-0.1083488315,
0.5939381719,
-0.2745346427,
-0.847217679,
0.4270331264,
0.0843068734,
-0.1604160219,
-0.064378947,
-0.1410510242,
0.0019163556,
-0.0092797475,
0.7022131085,
0.0590974502,
-0.6400803328,
-0.526464045,
-0.1785987616,
0.3551258147,
0.2995588779,
0.6698114872,
-0.8264783025,
0.4440777898,
0.5206874013,
0.7914256454,
0.5495067835,
0.009688043,
0.5623611808,
-0.805842638,
0.0248680413,
0.4079347253,
0.4466657043,
0.1877117157,
-0.5633705258,
0.4011340141,
-0.0382725559,
-0.5145214796,
-0.8983391523,
0.0764703602,
-1.010317564,
-0.3765075207,
0.9225233793,
0.0312819295,
-0.2256213129,
0.3851187527,
-0.5462177396,
0.2187601477,
-0.4995565712,
0.6729172468,
0.3533657491,
-0.4443440437,
-0.2665609121,
-0.0884665847,
0.5736091137,
0.6962881684,
-0.6149822474,
0.4105060697,
0.4133192003,
0.2750572264,
0.1007662117,
0.257384479,
-0.2081194371,
0.5266931653,
-0.178588599,
-0.1855383217,
-0.5193421841,
-0.5349610448,
-0.7207998633,
0.3702798188,
0.2225687653,
-0.1744841784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15162v1
|
Entity-level Factual Adaptiveness of Fine-tuning based Abstractive Summarization Models
| 2024-02-23T07:53:39 | 2024-02-23T07:53:39 |
Jongyoon Song, Nohil Park, Bongkyu Hwang, Jaewoong Yun, Seongho Joe, Youngjune L. Gwon, Sungroh Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Abstractive summarization models often generate factually inconsistent
content particularly when the parametric knowledge of the model conflicts with
the knowledge in the input document. In this paper, we analyze the robustness
of fine-tuning based summarization models to the knowledge conflict, which we
call factual adaptiveness. We utilize pre-trained language models to construct
evaluation sets and find that factual adaptiveness is not strongly correlated
with factual consistency on original datasets. Furthermore, we introduce a
controllable counterfactual data augmentation method where the degree of
knowledge conflict within the augmented data can be adjustable. Our
experimental results on two pre-trained language models (PEGASUS and BART) and
two fine-tuning datasets (XSum and CNN/DailyMail) demonstrate that our method
enhances factual adaptiveness while achieving factual consistency on original
datasets on par with the contrastive learning baseline.
|
[
-0.3993628025,
-0.8686107397,
0.4891897142,
-0.0736573711,
-0.3227057755,
0.2812793851,
-0.2445359081,
-0.5435498953,
0.104722999,
0.4629186988,
-0.2586753368,
-0.4848865569,
-0.7937514782,
0.1364279687,
-0.3535552919,
1.5375763178,
-0.1839384437,
-0.1660840213,
-0.3815170527,
-0.6287677884,
-0.482468605,
-0.2523586154,
-0.415612787,
0.0078857327,
0.2893534899,
0.5464549065,
0.7999024391,
0.6139424443,
0.5281637311,
0.3202600181,
0.0564487539,
0.4769717455,
-0.6797032356,
0.1205018237,
-0.750180006,
-0.4339846671,
-0.7224030495,
-0.2317112684,
0.6387143135,
0.6138074398,
-0.2163888216,
0.2103719115,
0.1326401383,
0.7266208529,
-0.837240696,
0.2508641481,
-1.0155837536,
-0.3892261386,
0.217230171,
-0.2743597031,
-0.1405773014,
-0.5099096894,
0.2803062201,
-0.8770318627,
0.4881668985,
0.1877397597,
1.0525289774,
0.4885528684,
-0.3048866689,
-0.5129144192,
-0.6877500415,
0.5331462622,
-1.0444604158,
0.2162780315,
0.1987500638,
-0.0505855754,
0.0967507809,
-0.6513221264,
-0.6906760931,
-0.111687094,
-0.1409201622,
0.2959349453,
-0.4219978452,
-0.0463288501,
0.2916280031,
0.2890937924,
-0.5277984142,
0.12624906,
-0.3196375668,
-0.124540329,
0.5202249289,
0.2234317809,
0.3673189282,
0.0085791107,
-0.1324371099,
0.2164850831,
-0.6115599275,
0.1408664882,
0.1903583556,
0.4347956479,
-0.3613650501,
0.6393263936,
-0.5736038685,
0.7328044772,
0.4589904845,
-0.1022045612,
0.071014531,
-0.6529625058,
-0.3701742589,
0.4579827785,
0.3310753703,
0.7261652946,
0.3042576313,
-0.0349254943,
-0.2524853051,
0.1026808843,
0.2989063263,
-0.8463814259,
-0.3116956949,
0.2799909711,
-0.2312920988,
-0.4735812247,
-0.1843229681,
-0.4500177801,
-0.2295739502,
-0.5096886754,
0.6561779976,
-0.4721118808,
-0.2029962689,
0.126653865,
0.0573906712,
-0.2288904786,
0.4661828578,
-0.9815826416,
0.2574428916,
0.6089728475,
0.7277796865,
-0.0687078089,
-0.2213042974,
-0.4062490165,
0.2834700644,
-0.69367975,
0.8690690398,
-0.5680397153,
-0.1518582553,
-0.2271109223,
0.0279134773,
-0.3267253935,
-0.5476540327,
0.5449498892,
-0.7313955426,
0.2380235642,
-0.6562012434,
-0.7338810563,
-0.1490732133,
0.5502893925,
-0.5207974315,
0.5839344859,
0.0454968736,
-1.0830026865,
0.8246380687,
-0.500264287,
-0.5389916897,
-0.416056931,
0.0850269869,
-0.5939539075,
0.1629026532,
0.400675416,
0.2351563871,
0.0827712044,
0.4753395319,
-0.4071834981,
-0.278750658,
0.0915174708,
-0.3385436237,
0.4824137986,
0.0661060065,
-0.1323644221,
0.2763786018,
-1.2232658863,
-0.5179300904,
-0.0792788118,
-0.3972074986,
-0.5087280869,
0.1584432274,
-0.5730534792,
0.2152175903,
0.2060915381,
-0.4343773127,
0.0595431775,
-0.3806874752,
-0.1292748898,
0.6672161222,
0.3943402171,
0.36412853,
-0.7652599216,
0.1511148214,
0.4285560846,
-0.4816772342,
-0.3482765853,
0.0083440151,
-0.8687425256,
-0.1666744798,
0.5391253829,
0.781055212,
-0.94190979,
0.3781807423,
-0.6349675655,
-0.4130152166,
-0.3100649416,
0.0262448937,
0.2035702169,
1.2459492683,
0.5249168277,
-0.1185224727,
-0.5406022668,
-0.6282482743,
-0.509963572,
-0.1453544796,
-0.0318575464,
0.0536076836,
0.4903321564,
0.1130004525,
0.7263398767,
-0.3274966478,
-0.043694552,
-0.031671036,
0.4484854937,
0.0466397032,
0.708935678,
0.6591281295,
-0.5758396983,
-0.353168726,
0.0195331331,
-0.8764095902,
-0.0462172739,
-0.4282295704,
0.1475716084,
0.4730734229,
0.5489519238,
-0.4663040936,
0.4222744703,
0.262786746,
-0.3873918951,
0.5587863326,
-0.4773111343,
0.4095076025,
-1.1054698229,
-0.0105950646,
-0.0109225651,
-0.5075713396,
-0.4615930319,
-0.0458102338,
-0.0277819484,
0.1408260763,
-0.085736163,
0.1471292526,
-0.2628445327,
0.051001139,
-0.5124103427,
0.3082212508,
0.1071167588,
0.3853848279,
0.0596941262,
0.7048724294,
0.5607563257,
-0.8808413148,
0.3126443624,
0.2810174227,
-0.6039862633,
0.9349291921,
-0.8060753345,
-0.319100827,
-0.4258924425,
0.1222241595,
-0.8266836405,
-0.2848549783,
0.1106368154,
-0.2718796432,
0.3640503287,
0.0010331017,
-0.1532329172,
0.3625867069,
-0.2921606004,
0.2553669214,
0.1816177815,
-0.4081037045,
0.5917654634,
0.1076810807,
-0.712287426,
-0.6341065764,
-0.5183708668,
0.1015196815,
-0.0796741471,
-0.4993368387,
0.3043563366,
-0.0118688997,
-0.2527870536,
0.3744828105,
-0.4318245947,
0.092140764,
0.0153334355,
-0.1525314003,
0.3901062012,
-0.5346721411,
0.0382108465,
0.4047971368,
0.0866278112,
0.0686861128,
-0.1377898902,
-0.0443323106,
0.0628279448,
-0.2469208688,
-0.210304454,
-0.1239220724,
0.5115117431,
-0.2313367724,
0.9657211304,
0.4784979224,
-0.5952045918,
0.1359200031,
-0.4354702234,
0.0613286346,
-0.3956480324,
0.6008267403,
-0.437827915,
-0.741985023,
0.8318011761,
0.0695575327,
0.3632146716,
0.627979219,
0.5863717794,
-0.074260965,
0.8263223171,
0.632930696,
0.0232435316,
0.274137646,
0.1655136049,
-0.0325129218,
-0.5276662707,
-0.0651437268,
-0.425699532,
-0.1485590786,
-0.7829002142,
0.1949500442,
0.2355672121,
0.0265426952,
-0.1936272383,
0.0648585483,
0.0143557787,
0.5187628269,
0.2698890567,
0.2364987135,
0.6172804832,
-0.0696432963,
0.1087482646,
-0.0365642309,
-0.7529179454,
-0.3899438083,
1.0034573078,
0.2137302011,
0.8165149689,
0.3118074834,
0.1639165431,
0.3755350411,
0.2691123188,
-0.2777620554,
0.0680935085,
-0.2039218843,
-0.5557601452,
-0.3843018413,
-0.4873333871,
-0.5205031633,
0.12259949,
-0.7530958056,
-0.6019195318,
0.5599073172,
0.3724899292,
-0.6014168262,
0.3187144399,
-0.6085066199,
0.777720809,
0.1649844944,
-0.2794881463,
-0.3581518531,
-0.641631484,
0.5091430545,
-0.3077211678,
0.25555861,
-0.0338268839,
0.0777127296,
0.6404707432,
-0.331867069,
0.6216090322,
-0.0856650099,
-0.1795817763,
0.0233329479,
0.1452287436,
0.6551644206,
0.3658107817,
0.0587651506,
-0.2645544112,
0.193982929,
-0.735117197,
-0.7577317953,
0.696835041,
-0.6029769778,
-0.8217994571,
-0.4167050421,
-0.7643838525,
-0.4399846792,
0.4434384406,
0.3588297963,
0.6603066921,
-0.4288448393,
0.2374958992,
1.0342952013,
-0.143593058,
0.308870852,
0.7841058373,
-0.0389763825,
-0.1469195634,
1.2219997644,
0.3486781418,
0.4086659253,
0.4608211517,
-0.1915618181,
-0.0465268716,
-0.9294503927,
-0.7047157288,
-0.2968666553,
-0.6386952996,
-0.2084415853,
-0.7166041732,
-0.0869327039,
-0.4915941656,
-0.1391288191,
-0.2835830748,
-0.6557084918,
-0.2619802952,
-0.3687279522,
0.1315531731,
0.5979099274,
-0.0354869068,
0.1197268367,
-0.8110108972,
0.7295080423,
0.405926019,
0.4062855542,
-0.2838896215,
-1.0404334068,
-0.5133849978,
0.1548004895,
-0.1597835273,
-0.6280485392,
-0.1318680048,
0.3322182894,
0.182371065,
0.4425198436,
0.2907831967,
0.5534180999,
-0.3503337502,
0.6262347698,
-0.2345314771,
-0.923838377,
0.3257394433,
-0.4812626541,
0.4563143253,
0.7173295021,
0.2904140949,
-0.0760847628,
-0.4656866789,
-0.6147174835,
-0.550480485,
0.6376308799,
0.0318218917,
0.184663102,
0.3380158246,
0.3802954555,
0.0844444111,
0.2397397608,
-0.4562174082,
-0.0655326098,
-0.5740532875,
-0.4812342525,
0.0361032449,
-0.3932796717,
-0.3178690076,
-0.1546281129,
0.9404424429,
-0.1333721131,
-0.4147737026,
0.254241854,
-0.4213950336,
-0.276913017,
0.2987823188,
1.0515993834,
1.193521142,
-0.508220613,
0.1767170727,
0.5823389292,
-0.4790678322,
0.0182162169,
0.4916170537,
-0.4076542258,
0.0660063252,
0.659665525,
1.032032609,
0.3772649765,
-0.5493911505,
0.4672570825,
-0.1415376812,
-0.1023403257,
0.2186997086,
0.2572119832,
-0.059071999,
0.1468257606,
0.2244179696,
0.617906034,
0.1910832077,
-0.4013010263,
0.2304482609,
0.2850219607,
-0.234291032,
-0.3087304831,
0.6147747636,
0.0343652591,
0.3886851966,
0.2292505801,
-0.1996810138,
-0.236309886,
0.4377607107,
0.5485075116,
0.3940700591,
-0.1975921243,
0.0831772164,
0.3931154311,
0.5542443991,
0.128466785,
0.1162603348,
0.0710171685,
-1.0416058302,
-0.569334805,
-0.2496374696,
-0.4895169735,
0.050090719,
-0.7502476573,
0.3092640042,
-0.5493919253,
0.2506421208,
0.2900315523,
-0.0895636529,
-0.337602973,
0.764144063,
-0.2624412477,
0.993915379,
-0.8402778506,
0.5445175171,
0.7062887549,
-0.3455454111,
-0.5102453828,
0.1231110767,
-0.1523519009,
-0.4914997518,
-0.0327107795,
-0.4082628489,
0.0210940652,
-0.2097048312,
-0.4257387221,
-0.7861865163,
0.8209229112,
0.5872300863,
-0.5797140598,
-0.0318167023,
-0.0349062681,
0.5612455606,
-0.3192569613,
-0.0470490269,
0.6044355035,
0.3135946989,
0.0391608924,
-0.6849362254,
0.2202611864,
-0.1200550869,
-0.2416302711,
-0.0674832091,
-0.4831958711,
0.531755507,
-0.3172999322,
-0.1635653079,
-0.1077442914,
1.1475040913,
0.2463195771,
0.6034168005,
0.4735347629,
0.7387272716,
0.8600847721,
-0.081615001,
0.7969346642,
-0.5241421461,
0.2786146104,
1.5001522303,
-0.1678174436,
0.4053501189,
0.0441096574,
0.0549860671,
0.5759059191,
0.5278208256,
-0.0690517724,
0.4794102907,
-0.3403863609,
-0.2377971262,
-0.0969200358,
-0.0279333163,
-0.41410321,
0.3406020403,
0.2128714174,
-0.1409997791,
-0.2815279365,
-0.2021826357,
0.1592992991,
0.3033870757,
-0.4780880809,
1.0176723003,
-0.2404066473,
-0.7043188214,
0.6246391535,
0.0948327631,
0.425899148,
-0.3276629746,
-0.005032077,
-0.1556323171,
-0.0997489244,
-0.5120275021,
-0.5357037187,
0.5219334364,
0.1790745854,
-0.5073829889,
0.5030264258,
0.8912382722,
-0.618276,
-0.7410241961,
-0.4377588034,
0.4762500823,
-0.4347314537,
0.17817083,
-0.4387613535,
-0.0728938803,
-0.0865908936,
-0.199311316,
0.2142626196,
0.62027812,
-0.1110579222,
0.4196684957,
0.5921158791,
0.2091210037,
-0.1604603231,
-0.0980138183,
0.9310156107,
-0.3425315917,
-0.704466939,
-0.8887173533,
0.4895259142,
-0.0708777606,
-0.2006168365,
0.6505197287,
0.5774716139,
0.838671267,
0.015198431,
0.846244812,
0.0780955777,
0.7554138899,
-0.8422906399,
0.7427572608,
-0.3341244161,
0.3613452017,
-0.3345557451,
-0.7769480944,
-0.1932365,
0.1726563275,
-0.3146080971,
0.1149670631,
0.3172600269,
0.7224823833,
-0.4420053959,
0.1767635494,
0.2400685102,
0.6016250253,
0.10003151,
0.1925298274,
0.5144189596,
-0.3295869827,
0.1446534544,
-0.1353590041,
-0.298820138,
-0.0989978611,
-0.9970920682,
-0.7564476132,
-0.4143859744,
-0.5357467532,
-0.4217195213,
0.3409508467,
0.8807136416,
0.436014086,
-1.2180002928,
0.396160841,
-0.1376654953,
0.5144645572,
-0.0501136072,
-0.2225239128,
0.5093979239,
-0.4135288298,
-0.6119330525,
0.1721330434,
0.2192732096,
0.1719795167,
0.2350601554,
0.1512369812,
-0.1645357162,
0.4747198522,
0.4918586314,
0.4577153325,
-0.297187984,
-0.4159318805,
-0.2897771597,
0.0592202805,
0.0544917546,
0.6964770555,
-0.5985963941,
0.5520014763,
0.3063362837,
0.852054894,
0.2476956397,
0.4681505263,
0.4929395616,
-0.7490841746,
0.1299371868,
-0.1980077773,
0.3994964659,
0.4564102292,
-0.4836147428,
0.0997862145,
0.184235692,
-0.5023366213,
-0.7708218098,
0.0132419886,
-0.8477509022,
-0.2199085951,
0.521928966,
-0.3060316741,
0.1339413971,
-0.2277681231,
-0.0979674086,
0.514885664,
-0.171063751,
1.1713175774,
0.7398423553,
-0.096409291,
-0.1230788603,
-0.1729335934,
0.6540032029,
0.4562540352,
-0.8808906674,
-0.0600418337,
0.4687182903,
0.5516207814,
0.1783751547,
0.3126198053,
0.1557828486,
0.4602357745,
-0.0398758873,
-0.4424149394,
-0.2795861959,
-0.2831694186,
-0.3962185681,
-0.0071754064,
0.13986817,
-0.0334023423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15159v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15159v3
|
Machine Unlearning of Pre-trained Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T07:43:26 | 2024-05-30T15:44:51 |
Jin Yao, Eli Chien, Minxin Du, Xinyao Niu, Tianhao Wang, Zezhou Cheng, Xiang Yue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
This study investigates the concept of the `right to be forgotten' within the
context of large language models (LLMs). We explore machine unlearning as a
pivotal solution, with a focus on pre-trained models--a notably
under-researched area. Our research delineates a comprehensive framework for
machine unlearning in pre-trained LLMs, encompassing a critical analysis of
seven diverse unlearning methods. Through rigorous evaluation using curated
datasets from arXiv, books, and GitHub, we establish a robust benchmark for
unlearning performance, demonstrating that these methods are over $10^5$ times
more computationally efficient than retraining. Our results show that
integrating gradient ascent with gradient descent on in-distribution data
improves hyperparameter robustness. We also provide detailed guidelines for
efficient hyperparameter tuning in the unlearning process. Our findings advance
the discourse on ethical AI practices, offering substantive insights into the
mechanics of machine unlearning for pre-trained LLMs and underscoring the
potential for responsible AI development.
|
[
-0.3157757819,
-0.3427595198,
0.4588395655,
-0.3288753331,
-0.325148195,
0.3104509413,
-0.3519943953,
-0.0533092022,
-0.4605196714,
0.8269692063,
-0.6645739079,
-0.305201143,
-0.7082942128,
-0.2081735283,
-0.5763284564,
1.0798995495,
0.079875268,
0.0438685678,
-0.3319580853,
-0.2472086698,
-0.3183505833,
-0.6460373998,
-0.360687077,
-0.520635426,
0.5754600763,
0.3148626685,
0.5366268158,
0.8301543593,
0.2997042537,
0.3486656249,
-0.1572791338,
0.1245704517,
-0.9758126736,
-0.0276602339,
-0.1928920895,
-0.5097853541,
-0.2098169476,
0.2614929378,
0.7688221335,
0.9605265856,
-0.2141060829,
0.4319076836,
0.3995603621,
0.9828643799,
-1.0371118784,
-0.1187786758,
-0.6702873111,
0.2329575866,
-0.2483913302,
-0.2011449039,
-0.5296169519,
-0.2336337119,
-0.0893198475,
-0.6732301712,
0.2475750595,
-0.0587501749,
0.5734510422,
0.6314458847,
-0.2301536649,
-0.1412321925,
-0.9337054491,
1.2614666224,
-0.4557981789,
0.5056037903,
0.6308419108,
0.3022002578,
-0.2526865304,
-0.9237718582,
-0.3568843007,
0.1282508969,
0.0998031646,
0.1842557639,
-0.3487266898,
0.0673335269,
0.4297821522,
0.2502245605,
-0.4366158843,
0.4636912346,
-0.347209096,
-0.0602219738,
0.3816700578,
-0.0482713841,
0.0562188365,
0.1562836021,
-0.1277116835,
0.2173624188,
-1.0225815773,
-0.1440617293,
0.7139767408,
0.111913465,
0.207106486,
0.4049806297,
0.0798720643,
0.4502953291,
-0.2702455819,
0.0435097776,
0.3993511796,
0.0476830564,
-0.3615750372,
-0.2712319195,
0.61697644,
0.0065504317,
0.8589334488,
-0.3388293386,
-0.354529798,
-0.4343772829,
0.4810248017,
-0.5811376572,
0.0763556287,
0.1686432958,
-0.712046206,
-0.073873274,
-0.155739218,
-0.4761915207,
-0.2837831974,
-0.5886987448,
0.3695332706,
-0.2658838928,
-0.2226873189,
-0.081703864,
-0.088228859,
0.095420517,
0.1222011,
-0.6477060318,
0.0817534551,
0.730597198,
0.3757389784,
0.1758606136,
-0.548881948,
-0.5226395726,
0.1008289456,
-0.5631321669,
0.1767321229,
-0.5597203374,
-0.5941257477,
0.2000028342,
0.0270762946,
-0.0730781108,
-0.8180972934,
0.375911504,
-0.6517591476,
0.3183293045,
-0.1581144333,
-0.6362580061,
-0.3100141585,
-0.0572755635,
-0.3629505038,
0.772708416,
0.0051060589,
-0.7665260434,
0.4455834329,
-0.6711531281,
-0.3130968511,
0.0786342546,
-0.1339266002,
-0.5665540695,
0.0787893385,
0.0501951613,
0.6415442824,
-0.359798491,
0.4998143613,
-0.4161430895,
-0.6035578847,
0.1184653416,
-0.7462511063,
1.1096268892,
0.4642269611,
-0.3828624487,
-0.143644169,
-0.7921689153,
0.1084868014,
0.0882865191,
-0.255941987,
-0.2311542034,
-0.024145484,
-0.312150538,
0.0836898685,
0.2460481524,
-0.2673151791,
-0.286760658,
-0.3029478192,
0.5054154396,
0.9939813018,
-0.153202042,
0.5459882021,
-0.3270072639,
0.4277538657,
0.0579135269,
0.2085171938,
-0.269956857,
0.0658800006,
-0.8353025317,
-0.2837559283,
0.2397743315,
0.4991008937,
-0.5190212727,
0.5446326733,
-0.0193735287,
-0.3851178586,
-0.8355566263,
0.5244204402,
0.7587230802,
0.5274478197,
0.3942420185,
-0.0299527049,
-0.4950688183,
-0.9174720049,
-0.4970940351,
-0.1852613688,
-0.0899731889,
0.0993970782,
0.5858692527,
-0.6082493067,
0.6998074651,
-0.1156355366,
-0.0967732519,
-0.0969603956,
0.1579492241,
0.0418900214,
0.6353567839,
0.1484465897,
-0.7050300837,
0.0309548974,
-0.1143449619,
-1.0467375517,
0.3721556962,
0.159547314,
0.0945730582,
0.1842461377,
0.6978700757,
-0.5295853615,
0.5531219244,
0.3462228775,
0.3896776736,
0.3724188209,
-0.5662352443,
-0.0929096565,
-1.1752587557,
0.3895906508,
-0.4230651259,
-0.1074153557,
-0.6259924173,
-0.0946388692,
0.0696904287,
-0.0543223247,
-0.5834202766,
0.3183648586,
-0.6476806998,
-0.2016011029,
-0.4848488569,
-0.1216874123,
-0.3462037146,
0.4671839476,
-0.1716148257,
0.7476935983,
0.5047979951,
-0.8123454452,
-0.121122092,
0.0344376042,
-0.2610796988,
0.2126348913,
-0.5599482656,
0.3511849642,
-0.6549468637,
0.085235998,
-0.6270599365,
0.1417064369,
0.235093832,
-0.4518640637,
0.2449792176,
-0.4155368209,
-0.459711194,
-0.3866713941,
-0.0147999879,
0.5315213203,
0.8526082039,
-0.5567140579,
0.3714239597,
0.5882467628,
-0.0478283055,
-1.106567502,
-0.425944984,
-0.2176206857,
-0.3984767795,
0.0470469929,
-0.0341176167,
-0.1303461492,
-0.1737074107,
-0.1907928735,
0.1324944645,
-0.3479715288,
0.3021245301,
0.5118609667,
-0.0850550681,
0.0046894625,
0.2484508157,
-0.2912769318,
-0.4981614351,
0.0423828512,
-0.4144654274,
0.5702397823,
0.0114875454,
-0.5476903319,
-0.425969243,
0.2728898525,
0.729028523,
-0.3456384838,
0.4891497791,
0.6382805109,
-0.6868646741,
-0.1494341791,
-0.3687990308,
0.0384969749,
-0.4949241579,
0.3328042924,
-0.0154317934,
-0.8445640802,
0.4399029315,
-0.1926080734,
0.413276732,
0.3144607842,
0.5365197062,
-0.4725417793,
0.9872637391,
1.0387271643,
-0.3681980968,
0.3374306858,
-0.3045248091,
0.3022209108,
-0.5532770753,
-0.2480167001,
-0.7453348637,
-0.1872675121,
-0.7829401493,
-0.2161299884,
0.0101604722,
0.215792492,
-0.7135794759,
0.0027342858,
-0.1057488173,
0.7989059091,
0.7411674261,
0.016462123,
0.2275551856,
-0.0362102091,
0.0034203145,
0.0213512219,
-0.5986024141,
-0.7800983787,
1.3138902187,
0.3233218193,
0.5339660048,
-0.2168447673,
0.8999566436,
0.2890739739,
0.315338105,
-0.5150873661,
0.3987300694,
-0.1890795678,
-0.5257629752,
-0.4951012731,
-0.5508422852,
-1.2806252241,
0.0280386005,
0.062997736,
-0.5926514864,
-0.0029073777,
0.3788778782,
-0.3471947908,
0.5080420375,
-0.4868776202,
0.6909185052,
-0.1660233885,
-0.0513761789,
-0.4929865003,
-0.7559209466,
0.1824296713,
-0.4871025383,
0.3184097409,
-0.0962702557,
0.1612001806,
1.1525657177,
-0.4607474208,
0.8392003179,
-0.3790050447,
0.0134650525,
0.1458052099,
-0.1757619679,
0.380634129,
-0.1713128388,
0.1011545137,
0.2308145463,
-0.2701123059,
-0.6841951609,
-0.3853364587,
0.4493041933,
-0.904912889,
-0.5845216513,
-0.2114123702,
-0.3965703845,
-0.3887059093,
0.5494735241,
0.5385280848,
0.0538099371,
-0.2695502341,
0.2388681024,
1.0246731043,
-0.2596987188,
0.6228265166,
0.5978499651,
-0.0918404981,
-0.1287529022,
0.9448141456,
0.36270383,
0.063672252,
0.4091919959,
0.0629957318,
-0.2752762735,
-0.6950986385,
-0.359986037,
0.2908593118,
-0.6792041659,
-0.0052467277,
-0.7193327546,
-0.3465059698,
-0.2150486112,
-0.1970720738,
-0.634024322,
0.0124214562,
-0.6750109792,
-0.1575732678,
0.0822116435,
0.7910659909,
-0.0469176136,
0.5951996446,
-0.8528705239,
0.108689554,
0.1015853956,
0.2871655226,
0.1315477341,
-0.8634598851,
-0.2394814938,
0.2736906409,
-0.2300896496,
-0.1583551168,
0.3829305172,
-0.1058481932,
0.888442874,
0.6345230937,
0.0430963412,
0.6973816156,
-0.5239851475,
0.3753253818,
0.3038208485,
-0.7995538116,
0.3781950176,
-0.2855829895,
0.158355996,
0.6242602468,
0.7410551906,
-0.4572714567,
-0.1979073286,
-0.9989952445,
-0.9080991745,
0.4740614891,
-0.1127665564,
0.3031918705,
0.3491545022,
0.2868628502,
0.4195215106,
0.5865802169,
-0.4564292729,
-0.3032774329,
-0.0298999287,
-0.1432358325,
-0.7167954445,
-0.1897826046,
-0.1385961175,
-0.2075041234,
0.5994524956,
0.1147880703,
0.1749450564,
-0.455539763,
-0.5096786618,
-0.1222591624,
0.1717853844,
0.3023303151,
1.0515044928,
-0.0075817872,
0.0137259439,
0.1997212619,
-0.3705992997,
0.3131010532,
-0.232755214,
-0.2178643197,
-0.2793313563,
0.334975034,
0.5417714715,
0.1450731158,
-0.7151790857,
0.4523859322,
0.1565152854,
-0.2576931715,
-0.5203611255,
0.0219945628,
0.0610661097,
0.039489042,
0.2455517948,
0.1649761945,
0.0687400624,
-0.4532382488,
0.3836466372,
0.3105248809,
-0.5932498574,
-0.2033056766,
0.2997665405,
-0.0122421421,
-0.3352420926,
0.9470267892,
0.2072420269,
-0.32472229,
0.3780401945,
0.4655725062,
0.8671739697,
-0.1545532197,
0.2276698053,
-0.1508428901,
0.4458737671,
-0.2536543906,
-0.0039986446,
-0.0085549243,
-0.636705637,
-0.3745309711,
-0.3955797255,
-0.2722533643,
0.3737207353,
-0.669090569,
-0.1515852809,
-0.6192956567,
0.0279413853,
-0.1811829954,
0.0596655756,
-0.8902404308,
0.3240657151,
-0.3250521421,
0.6124271154,
-0.7084594369,
0.6732701063,
0.4029562175,
-0.2755018473,
-0.6166303158,
0.1800339818,
-0.0118350489,
-1.2172037363,
0.5745957494,
0.063398242,
-0.2167115957,
0.2543883324,
-0.5074285269,
-0.6790304184,
0.8410457373,
0.7213949561,
-0.7019755244,
0.2658713162,
0.3107495904,
0.3201799989,
-0.1844686568,
0.2961799204,
0.5477160811,
0.2904237807,
-0.1896023899,
-0.6566863656,
-0.3619630635,
0.010317036,
-0.1957466006,
0.3857471049,
-0.6951057911,
0.7027055621,
-0.4021288455,
-0.1528593004,
-0.0099667795,
0.4838227332,
-0.0881809443,
0.4598526061,
0.3040419817,
0.6208302975,
1.2875443697,
0.132849738,
0.6977559924,
-0.0356537253,
0.1760091335,
0.7752816081,
-0.1992137581,
0.6535380483,
0.4525265396,
0.0223445967,
-0.1197270304,
0.6999643445,
0.4763000607,
0.4594967365,
0.4510238767,
-0.1182025075,
-0.3406387568,
0.0405033454,
-0.3969434202,
0.4358157516,
0.1319014132,
-0.4798227251,
-0.2653635442,
0.1020327359,
0.3154629469,
0.1507084817,
-0.49138394,
0.817971766,
0.163482666,
-0.4280341864,
0.7822164297,
-0.0910084695,
0.4206377864,
-0.3978001177,
0.1818205118,
-0.4160429239,
0.4314168096,
-0.0223669335,
-0.4543263018,
0.004423595,
0.1047462896,
-0.4394550025,
-0.4115202725,
0.5025504231,
-0.2175765187,
-0.3878037632,
0.3568529785,
0.9043155313,
0.4462733269,
0.0674660802,
-0.8069623113,
-0.1434894055,
0.0724196434,
-0.1332304031,
0.6094451547,
0.4914745092,
-0.1709280908,
1.1515126228,
0.7737489939,
-0.0915558189,
-0.020985065,
0.210588634,
0.7153819203,
-0.769900322,
-0.2201932967,
-0.9453812242,
0.3052929342,
0.2125191391,
-0.4788596034,
0.5610191822,
0.4171138108,
1.1743508577,
0.050582096,
0.9741970897,
0.6381367445,
0.7552387714,
-0.6388825178,
1.0697689056,
-0.5445229411,
0.2526378036,
-0.140613988,
-0.8560284376,
-0.2906778157,
0.3284400702,
-0.1968238652,
0.5631841421,
0.4183586836,
0.7531319857,
-0.0347135365,
-0.0089463228,
0.6838185191,
-0.0548373833,
0.105228886,
0.2646211982,
1.0924515724,
-0.1548288465,
0.378601402,
0.0779689103,
-0.1447629929,
-0.2082985044,
-0.8282545209,
-0.7959483862,
-0.556116879,
-0.0194000602,
-0.0534211434,
0.527436614,
0.8557730317,
0.6602573395,
-0.66286093,
-0.3349314928,
-0.0648293868,
0.2973850965,
-0.092554085,
-0.0686799362,
0.3114314973,
-0.529717505,
-0.6517742276,
0.2764133811,
0.1668741107,
0.2065997571,
-0.2193313986,
-0.4711622,
0.0378500819,
-0.0799236372,
0.4432390928,
0.6481617093,
-0.3292094767,
0.0261691511,
-0.2751487792,
0.0824113116,
-0.050563097,
1.1539264917,
-0.7076778412,
0.0844395459,
0.1310947388,
1.0555176735,
0.1216944754,
-0.087403886,
0.5779445171,
-0.6812897921,
0.1084309369,
0.3916885257,
0.4074120522,
0.1945440769,
-0.1585637033,
0.1687216908,
0.2845684588,
-0.64643085,
-1.1527431011,
0.1822388619,
-0.1955429465,
-0.3813812137,
0.7310110927,
-0.2719944119,
-0.1633918881,
-0.3114144504,
0.134885639,
0.5240406394,
-0.2741767764,
0.6051334143,
0.4645886421,
0.2572183907,
-0.1375060081,
-0.5395474434,
0.5580283403,
0.5988559723,
-0.5688869953,
0.5548396111,
0.4636324644,
0.2845802903,
-0.1812448949,
0.7916797996,
-0.1858192682,
0.1393612623,
-0.3819032311,
0.060968522,
-0.0995077938,
-0.8053779602,
-0.3750910163,
0.1414136142,
0.218160674,
-0.3205035925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15539v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15539v1
|
Speech Corpus for Korean Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: Towards Automatic Assessment Systems
| 2024-02-23T07:32:54 | 2024-02-23T07:32:54 |
Seonwoo Lee, Jihyun Mun, Sunhee Kim, Minhwa Chung
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
Despite the growing demand for digital therapeutics for children with Autism
Spectrum Disorder (ASD), there is currently no speech corpus available for
Korean children with ASD. This paper introduces a speech corpus specifically
designed for Korean children with ASD, aiming to advance speech technologies
such as pronunciation and severity evaluation. Speech recordings from speech
and language evaluation sessions were transcribed, and annotated for
articulatory and linguistic characteristics. Three speech and language
pathologists rated these recordings for social communication severity (SCS) and
pronunciation proficiency (PP) using a 3-point Likert scale. The total number
of participants will be 300 for children with ASD and 50 for typically
developing (TD) children. The paper also analyzes acoustic and linguistic
features extracted from speech data collected and completed for annotation from
73 children with ASD and 9 TD children to investigate the characteristics of
children with ASD and identify significant features that correlate with the
clinical scores. The results reveal some speech and linguistic characteristics
in children with ASD that differ from those in TD children or another subgroup
of ASD categorized by clinical scores, demonstrating the potential for
developing automatic assessment systems for SCS and PP.
|
[
-0.5167664289,
-0.421037674,
0.0612410083,
0.489245683,
0.0888331234,
0.7051486969,
-0.1171726137,
-0.7412238717,
0.7802080512,
0.3863809407,
-0.2850186825,
-0.4543158412,
-0.5790865421,
-0.0045921719,
-0.5972608924,
0.6764720082,
0.0859687701,
0.2110369503,
0.1649256498,
-0.0836020187,
-0.1232879683,
-0.4984599948,
-1.1670659781,
0.0114104412,
0.2164772004,
0.6658719182,
0.5809097886,
0.8083372712,
0.2919796705,
0.2647428215,
-0.2395414561,
-0.2744965553,
0.1917740852,
0.3070677519,
-0.0937625989,
0.2816718519,
-1.1533755064,
-0.0349321924,
0.5887809992,
1.0483558178,
0.0588440858,
0.3509297073,
0.2745179832,
0.45544523,
-0.1388222873,
0.1672535092,
0.1110377237,
0.3533079028,
-0.3824562728,
0.2221730053,
-0.0054504853,
-0.2976984978,
0.1020467207,
-0.6420639157,
0.0642706752,
-0.2958615422,
0.5750904679,
0.1401363313,
-0.7013927698,
-0.6787842512,
-0.7220180631,
0.3961986601,
-0.5826426744,
0.4436784685,
0.8318645358,
0.4543409944,
0.2316565216,
-0.5777779818,
-0.3900595605,
-0.4533340335,
0.1055838913,
0.1006866172,
0.0106504038,
0.208309263,
0.1669310629,
0.0688862801,
-0.8851549625,
0.2203208953,
-0.5371832252,
-0.4421492219,
1.0821524858,
0.0513307601,
0.6612951756,
-0.3076429367,
0.1712370515,
0.1104987338,
-0.3323347867,
0.3092365563,
0.4457002878,
0.5497106314,
-0.1832565069,
0.44703421,
-0.4441206157,
0.2923232913,
0.1816411018,
-0.0719607472,
0.6183615327,
-0.1531317383,
0.2677004933,
0.4461675286,
0.5654295087,
0.2132292986,
0.3017049134,
-0.0558799952,
-0.235274002,
0.5483336449,
0.2302413732,
-0.3869637251,
-0.3266971111,
0.1836898029,
-0.5615296364,
-0.4004712701,
-0.1940506995,
-0.9147264361,
-0.3962998092,
-0.2453634739,
0.0991640836,
-0.3426894248,
-0.7177465558,
-0.1453845352,
-0.0757651478,
-0.1510070413,
-0.1872020215,
-0.9762541056,
0.8233283162,
0.3976150155,
0.496352911,
-0.3521915972,
-0.2017497122,
-0.4873642027,
-0.0889279693,
-0.6181860566,
1.0202960968,
-0.7279871106,
-0.3996727467,
-0.1312337667,
0.1113358736,
-0.2105986029,
-0.6170501113,
0.6826882958,
-0.4352233708,
-0.3435119987,
0.041509077,
-0.393268913,
0.001565977,
-0.2182626575,
-0.5338192582,
0.86723423,
0.5133271813,
-0.2514896691,
0.4530531466,
-0.9588454366,
-0.6828273535,
0.5729022026,
-0.1083568931,
-0.0350182615,
-0.2926774919,
0.0686172992,
0.1149583533,
0.2841214538,
0.2096417397,
-0.3101331294,
-0.2823711336,
0.1699413508,
-0.2342921346,
0.8499540687,
0.5729190111,
-0.2706870139,
0.0816425979,
-0.8611546755,
0.5041537285,
-0.2572733462,
-0.3283443749,
0.0857166573,
-0.0893675536,
0.4704537988,
0.1634183377,
0.1357268393,
-0.5538759232,
-0.2268853486,
-0.5754595995,
0.4125895798,
0.1993827373,
0.1733373106,
0.3290632069,
-0.3999094665,
1.2021865845,
-0.1501531452,
0.2709863186,
0.1324214637,
-0.5909721851,
-0.3113942742,
-0.3476321995,
0.7723342776,
0.6001858115,
-0.6785700917,
0.8325686455,
-0.2261458188,
-0.3097738028,
-0.7747763991,
-0.1495316029,
0.6211499572,
0.2887449265,
0.1207704842,
-0.6478039622,
-0.6864839792,
-0.5843350291,
0.0733030364,
-0.1362383962,
-0.12129163,
0.4074997604,
0.1329663992,
-0.20137164,
0.7608609796,
0.2370422632,
-0.3366924226,
-0.0746819377,
-0.100693129,
-0.2185728252,
0.4189558327,
0.4165398479,
-0.6617166996,
-0.9839717746,
0.1069425344,
-0.5770434737,
-0.8036916852,
0.6007783413,
0.5169862509,
0.4633117914,
0.7482061386,
-0.327413559,
0.4585951269,
0.4977017641,
-0.8198986053,
0.5225962996,
0.198142767,
0.3495390415,
-0.5067153573,
0.0860441029,
-0.2878534794,
-0.3777967691,
-0.6963151097,
-0.1340389848,
-0.1466467083,
-0.2228662223,
-0.4276598692,
0.4674536586,
-0.14560467,
-0.6160707474,
-0.2673379481,
0.4996175468,
-0.2669816017,
-0.1011755168,
-0.0803209692,
0.4642678201,
0.6783275008,
-0.6198117137,
0.6022298932,
0.0666779429,
-0.2618480325,
0.8021172881,
-0.4677728415,
-0.0002439182,
0.2954692543,
0.2220478654,
-0.8101081252,
-0.2467456013,
0.4881312847,
-0.9801395535,
0.4752002954,
-0.0363098085,
-0.1746890694,
-0.7184914947,
-0.2621694505,
0.3600319028,
0.234765321,
-0.1302053332,
0.2315984368,
1.1983139515,
-0.7515128255,
-0.4353655279,
-0.4651918709,
0.3337836564,
-0.3658392727,
-0.7270429134,
0.2527846992,
-0.094853878,
-0.2395442575,
0.517634511,
-0.196945101,
-0.2901000977,
0.2189562321,
0.0350559913,
-0.0849401951,
-0.720983088,
0.2194961607,
0.4434303343,
-0.5488550663,
-0.1352013648,
0.1351015419,
0.648932755,
-0.2659298778,
-0.1665244997,
-0.267953366,
0.5473191142,
0.4483446479,
0.1456930488,
0.0009084436,
0.3361099362,
-0.5842018723,
-0.2533918619,
-0.0767944232,
0.0408515222,
-0.5129275322,
0.3562960625,
-0.6608567834,
-0.6285862327,
0.8064292073,
0.1263555139,
-0.5485904217,
0.5003039241,
0.3475443423,
-0.406239152,
1.2113032341,
0.2369603366,
0.1152803078,
0.2245767415,
0.0758084953,
-0.0966114402,
-0.9468556643,
0.298168838,
-0.4510214925,
-0.3225259781,
-0.3788520992,
0.0056432863,
0.2364450395,
-0.0905389413,
-0.4834267795,
0.0333327129,
-0.753915906,
0.5983274579,
0.2405184209,
-0.2241428941,
0.2679469883,
-0.3379904926,
0.0976143032,
-0.2269533724,
-0.6306094527,
-0.9163450599,
1.3926692009,
0.3088629842,
0.0097511783,
-0.014615708,
0.5010615587,
0.8362368941,
0.3713179827,
-0.9064389467,
0.5804581046,
-0.5151438713,
-0.549182415,
-0.5703067183,
-0.1417466402,
-1.1079072952,
-0.0520633906,
0.0071776733,
-0.9843760729,
0.3578695357,
-0.1309163272,
-0.9191755652,
-0.4496302605,
-0.635417223,
0.833137393,
-0.1609920114,
0.4923411608,
-0.1074909717,
-0.7024729252,
0.1543037295,
-0.3672491312,
0.3240716755,
0.0106180701,
-0.1927461773,
1.097368598,
-0.3886885345,
0.6325069666,
-0.362070322,
0.2000579238,
0.3539758921,
-0.0500591472,
-0.297647804,
-0.0643419549,
-0.0989718959,
0.0540374927,
0.4285405576,
-0.0698372349,
-0.4615300596,
0.8670101166,
-0.880467236,
-0.1203697547,
-0.6303238273,
-0.2681524754,
-0.4633578062,
0.3205378354,
-0.0316239521,
0.4847554564,
-0.122432664,
-0.0152208516,
0.3171283603,
-0.2557953894,
0.4544031024,
0.7563548684,
-0.4768403172,
-0.4115267098,
1.0392503738,
0.6559586525,
0.1757292598,
-0.6536925435,
-0.0066158101,
-0.3024595678,
-0.4041478634,
-0.6568192244,
0.1343417913,
-0.7187252045,
-0.0029227452,
-0.5199204087,
-0.7657036185,
-0.8949804306,
-0.2664006352,
-0.4067035913,
-0.8506355286,
-0.0019327642,
-0.3001312017,
0.1099022478,
0.8963023424,
-0.4142463803,
0.306971401,
-0.5362548232,
0.8437229991,
-0.0720278621,
0.5620059371,
-0.0376683734,
-0.645586729,
-0.1629455686,
0.2172425687,
-0.4277588129,
-0.7385370731,
0.6507408023,
0.4431060553,
0.4454908967,
0.2850424647,
0.1735537946,
0.4783134758,
-0.2802489996,
0.8488978744,
-0.3657601774,
-1.0910952091,
0.4023829401,
-0.2266165763,
-0.1277423501,
0.3289499879,
0.1942351907,
-0.9491431713,
-0.490501672,
-0.9561190009,
-0.917810142,
1.1582735777,
-0.1004696712,
-0.1925512105,
0.0319899432,
0.1202185825,
-0.1742316633,
-0.0838564262,
-0.1936019808,
-0.4725511968,
-0.2811646461,
-0.575291872,
-0.0307931192,
-0.3251469135,
-0.2105515003,
-0.4666883349,
0.6250240803,
0.001148897,
0.2526626885,
0.1017895192,
0.1352135688,
-0.3982511461,
0.0485260785,
0.3312605917,
0.2964830399,
0.1476057768,
-0.0561927669,
0.0610854886,
-0.8211010098,
0.2279158533,
0.3234044313,
-0.03637648,
0.0210861862,
0.2104566842,
0.3506529927,
0.1666036844,
-0.7204803228,
0.6525053382,
-0.0775498673,
-0.247004196,
-0.72812289,
0.052003175,
0.4968880415,
0.4804078937,
0.2086607367,
-0.1528207809,
0.3589225411,
-0.368421644,
0.6048223376,
0.133292824,
-0.4448671341,
-0.3870056868,
0.407979399,
0.2057726979,
-0.8306427598,
0.301435858,
-0.6334978938,
-0.4228099585,
0.9936722517,
0.6619553566,
0.8622844815,
-0.6965950727,
0.5457751155,
-0.1129376739,
0.1971370429,
0.2695556581,
0.5677546859,
-0.0213254951,
-0.6816908121,
-0.0867329538,
-0.6445485353,
-0.3144582212,
0.0270892587,
-0.6826736331,
0.3257750273,
-0.4042047858,
-0.3596439958,
0.358040601,
0.1978062838,
-0.1277126521,
0.3212946057,
0.4592087865,
0.2714422047,
-0.813341558,
0.8519120812,
0.7957783937,
-0.2667483985,
-0.6010952592,
-0.2305295318,
0.0611593835,
-0.5395687819,
0.7996495962,
-0.0795268118,
-0.2732845545,
0.1788818836,
-0.0462611802,
-1.2276721001,
0.7539095283,
0.1856558919,
-0.1142638847,
0.2632279694,
0.4289586842,
1.0196182728,
-0.6692698598,
0.2632841766,
0.8671608567,
0.419672966,
-0.0160211623,
-1.5856940746,
-0.102550067,
-0.5882318616,
-0.1764297783,
-0.1775982231,
-0.2173175067,
0.4072404504,
0.0811971053,
-0.6693328023,
-0.00244576,
0.2960261703,
0.2443831712,
0.9093965888,
0.3764440119,
0.2913270593,
0.8578209877,
0.3518304527,
0.6197072864,
-0.5742556453,
-0.0862865373,
0.9455978274,
-0.2428677976,
0.7662280798,
-0.1832356751,
-0.1967636496,
0.0146070886,
0.6345095634,
0.446652323,
0.2159187943,
0.2294972539,
-0.4115537405,
0.2648866773,
-0.2011191249,
-0.3491595089,
0.3696498275,
0.9469456077,
-0.1681943238,
0.0698780417,
0.3704871833,
-0.089620471,
0.3339261711,
-0.3143736422,
0.7186398506,
0.3198069632,
-0.2333947122,
0.6844694614,
-0.0954325497,
0.5524527431,
-0.193801254,
0.2076664865,
0.1041634902,
0.0259229485,
-0.4962232411,
-0.7473231554,
0.9453020692,
0.2022041082,
0.0084878644,
-0.2081259638,
0.698132515,
-0.4455934465,
-0.4330236018,
0.3305138648,
0.3735033274,
0.418150425,
-0.0279140975,
-0.6868748069,
0.005756286,
-0.3372689486,
-0.3404647708,
0.3385393918,
0.4791403115,
-0.4054041803,
0.8321891427,
0.4767740667,
0.5631888509,
0.1681339145,
0.0837320462,
0.4353820086,
-0.6292894483,
-0.5872878432,
-0.3578386307,
0.0509714484,
0.0047652768,
-0.3237686455,
0.4654718935,
0.4175588787,
0.5364550352,
0.2556287944,
0.8120752573,
-0.1515147537,
1.2437247038,
0.1901319921,
1.1965601444,
-0.23478356,
0.1622398496,
-0.3544581234,
-0.6625905633,
-0.5060611963,
0.8880031109,
-0.2181489915,
-0.0491416231,
0.8597455621,
0.6171931028,
-0.0319737904,
0.4765401483,
0.2549238801,
0.3683451116,
0.3636005521,
0.1901697218,
0.7128595114,
-0.2869488299,
0.3167983294,
-0.1574134678,
-0.5600773096,
0.0412209854,
-0.2395948917,
-0.1618750095,
-0.692519486,
-0.4853852987,
-0.2841676772,
0.2756944001,
0.9216721058,
0.3793855011,
-0.8438509107,
-0.3764581978,
0.2986524403,
-0.0297622308,
-0.4949729145,
-0.3306861222,
0.4817647934,
-0.1969201416,
-0.5981624126,
0.6970439553,
0.0671057999,
-0.1431000531,
-0.029414067,
0.0263060536,
0.3196460605,
0.0630117357,
0.5247671008,
0.6320486665,
-0.421486944,
-0.5678590536,
-0.2382481247,
-0.3351858258,
-0.0183571018,
0.2396145165,
-0.8163377047,
0.3072512746,
0.0502506457,
0.4226186872,
0.2651925087,
0.0576072969,
0.5179331303,
-0.2878929079,
-0.2602852583,
0.8383558989,
-0.0652749836,
0.1747010797,
-0.0904033035,
0.377794683,
0.2484863698,
-0.6075239182,
-1.0124577284,
0.0593022518,
-1.0769542456,
0.1955159754,
1.3167741299,
-0.218595922,
-0.0507816598,
-0.9848349094,
-0.2998290658,
0.3428965807,
-0.5993599892,
0.8635368943,
0.7287192345,
-0.3545835018,
0.1379567385,
-0.6500228643,
0.8879539371,
0.1422843188,
-0.4101930857,
0.104491055,
0.4079848826,
0.1688660383,
0.1483599246,
0.99121207,
-0.38847664,
0.5462580323,
0.3568955362,
0.0067497771,
0.1619207561,
-0.2878376245,
-0.600307405,
0.0890890434,
-0.1469272673,
-0.1533478796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15153v1
|
Self-Adaptive Reconstruction with Contrastive Learning for Unsupervised Sentence Embeddings
| 2024-02-23T07:28:31 | 2024-02-23T07:28:31 |
Junlong Liu, Xichen Shang, Huawen Feng, Junhao Zheng, Qianli Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Unsupervised sentence embeddings task aims to convert sentences to semantic
vector representations. Most previous works directly use the sentence
representations derived from pretrained language models. However, due to the
token bias in pretrained language models, the models can not capture the
fine-grained semantics in sentences, which leads to poor predictions. To
address this issue, we propose a novel Self-Adaptive Reconstruction Contrastive
Sentence Embeddings (SARCSE) framework, which reconstructs all tokens in
sentences with an AutoEncoder to help the model to preserve more fine-grained
semantics during tokens aggregating. In addition, we proposed a self-adaptive
reconstruction loss to alleviate the token bias towards frequency. Experimental
results show that SARCSE gains significant improvements compared with the
strong baseline SimCSE on the 7 STS tasks.
|
[
-0.2224973887,
-0.1183241829,
0.4266556501,
0.1035902724,
-0.5154007673,
-0.0453864224,
0.0129260495,
0.013752263,
0.4741169214,
0.6669462323,
-0.4118699729,
-0.2779661119,
-0.7064965963,
0.0673457533,
-0.5550826192,
1.0030068159,
-0.0632120147,
0.1649705768,
-0.1527751386,
-0.276578635,
-0.4617474973,
-0.4635022879,
-0.347795397,
0.1747056842,
-0.0949383676,
0.226985842,
0.1913240701,
0.5502208471,
0.2828389108,
0.369936198,
0.2766016722,
0.0348232687,
-0.3641447127,
0.1622940451,
-0.4836651683,
-0.1238238215,
-0.041936554,
-0.0612145923,
0.5114603639,
0.5156642795,
-0.2192340642,
-0.1405650228,
0.409463495,
0.6263417006,
-0.7935829759,
0.0241793189,
-0.6324871778,
0.0222666077,
0.1657002568,
-0.2467650622,
-0.1799810231,
0.4402166903,
0.0854577199,
-0.4920498133,
0.3186918795,
0.0625716969,
0.4809732437,
0.4342536032,
-0.6160798669,
-0.4215518534,
-0.3783434927,
0.7914571166,
-0.7025994062,
0.3051846921,
0.1781522632,
0.1344637275,
-0.2554778159,
-0.9081141949,
-0.3509303331,
-0.0705791488,
-0.1931660473,
0.380048573,
-0.403319627,
-0.1306997389,
-0.3739388585,
0.4674133956,
-0.4564715624,
0.0623786449,
-0.1779649258,
-0.4026163816,
0.3144190013,
0.2110855579,
0.1664074957,
-0.4766038358,
-0.8852975965,
-0.3640435636,
-0.1308047473,
-0.2278385013,
-0.061899174,
0.3010674417,
-0.2367131561,
0.2260143608,
-0.1658661366,
0.4877477586,
0.1711732447,
0.5432799459,
0.4085486233,
-0.5869435072,
-0.4294071496,
0.0010879693,
0.7564954162,
0.3469010592,
0.1932272017,
-0.1493032277,
-0.1636018157,
0.1631352007,
0.3912244439,
-0.7075642943,
-0.3244706988,
-0.0531973392,
-0.6603272557,
-0.1723242402,
0.0790150762,
-0.810744524,
-0.1394408345,
-0.2254393101,
0.369151473,
-0.4917557538,
0.1161540747,
0.2529212236,
-0.105445087,
0.0172407161,
0.0262803957,
-0.801104486,
0.5229261518,
0.0941989347,
0.6303073764,
-0.4280359447,
-0.4190410376,
-0.6086550951,
0.1690839231,
-0.2578440607,
0.9675372243,
-0.3052310646,
-0.5510724783,
-0.2187625915,
0.1341308504,
-0.215868935,
-0.3354447186,
0.5935054421,
-0.2621040642,
0.3271886408,
-0.1024557948,
-0.7055538297,
0.2137433738,
0.161140576,
-0.2564055622,
0.9877711535,
0.2656960189,
-0.7975735068,
0.1442681998,
-0.5476101041,
-0.3165140748,
-0.3167081475,
-0.381613642,
-0.4268460274,
0.3409082592,
0.6310301423,
0.6831517816,
0.0367865935,
0.2091048956,
-0.2244053185,
-0.29854846,
0.0337846987,
-0.4691318572,
0.4726945162,
0.3804375827,
-0.3905793726,
0.2392908931,
-0.6606706381,
-0.2651661038,
0.1025866717,
0.1067195535,
-0.5494243503,
0.0558327213,
0.0726372898,
0.178484574,
0.0005511391,
-0.7010557055,
0.0869519413,
-0.6087781787,
0.6423882246,
0.9820546508,
-0.0144522116,
0.7174511552,
-0.1182443872,
0.2948137224,
0.4932391942,
-0.2081305385,
-0.3872342706,
0.3406738937,
-0.7272193432,
-0.3941043913,
0.4227023721,
0.1749195755,
-0.6239316463,
0.485638231,
-0.2153763771,
-0.0892720371,
-0.5064735413,
0.051015649,
0.2684643567,
0.2978759408,
0.750816524,
-0.480586946,
-0.7287396193,
-0.9225613475,
-0.3610030413,
0.149615556,
-0.0972103253,
0.3799937367,
0.5365403891,
-0.2708951831,
0.8705783486,
-0.5935213566,
-0.7657843828,
-0.0054508322,
0.2235920578,
-0.3790276349,
0.9105280638,
0.7154496312,
-0.545530498,
-0.2991411984,
-0.3516314328,
-0.465955615,
-0.091293104,
-0.3069818616,
-0.1826276779,
0.0736565739,
1.0132540464,
-0.2202998847,
0.4852659702,
0.6673569083,
-0.7271519303,
0.2780539393,
-0.4564960599,
0.2862308025,
-1.4431327581,
-0.2567331195,
-0.1753392816,
-0.422234863,
-0.1863613427,
-0.2027627379,
-0.0181282554,
-0.1443206817,
-0.189149037,
0.6792591214,
-0.7133339643,
-0.4411095977,
-0.5727794766,
0.3592031896,
0.0560276285,
0.3726740479,
-0.1001127735,
0.9625064731,
0.6906244755,
-0.5428881645,
0.0231190044,
0.3847767711,
-0.292534411,
0.4335656762,
-0.4306781292,
-0.067280665,
-0.2803038061,
0.4939543307,
-1.0991590023,
0.1005730033,
0.1473513246,
-0.3745420575,
0.1974916458,
0.2075306326,
0.1350534856,
-0.18900159,
-0.315787524,
0.568826735,
0.3725779951,
-0.7220600247,
0.9369456768,
0.1701812744,
0.013288998,
-0.5028102994,
-0.8666702509,
0.165489465,
0.0234809387,
-0.0056774812,
0.6369752884,
-0.0569229163,
0.1278991848,
0.2838857472,
-0.2401725054,
0.0974301174,
0.1176270619,
0.09978313,
0.0271120314,
-0.3054411411,
0.3005927503,
-0.0637697205,
-0.1711608917,
-0.0233433433,
-0.4273411632,
0.7253713608,
0.0372533649,
-0.3076822162,
-0.392428875,
0.3383354843,
0.4080754519,
-0.3795924187,
0.3797604442,
0.7011001706,
-0.2258132845,
-0.21839571,
-0.4751943946,
-0.1668685675,
-0.4821693301,
0.4949986041,
-0.4508241415,
-1.0793280602,
0.4165864289,
-0.1339909434,
-0.3328888118,
0.8044591546,
0.4292606711,
-0.2835051715,
0.5970355272,
0.5373574495,
-0.2795501947,
0.6562869549,
-0.1288686693,
-0.0911366493,
-0.9473484755,
-0.0621913783,
-0.6386333108,
-0.0728290007,
-0.624397099,
-0.6097627282,
-0.1172866076,
-0.0250259042,
-0.4883779287,
0.1696212292,
-0.5641149282,
0.3258764446,
0.4859029055,
0.2183236033,
-0.1441321224,
0.1232631579,
-0.1766569614,
0.0343415588,
-0.7243785858,
-0.2733437717,
0.8305831552,
-0.0316457748,
0.7450394034,
-0.2547867,
0.944108367,
0.5996537209,
-0.0803457946,
-0.5000195503,
0.4138988256,
-0.865884304,
-0.149614796,
-0.1733331382,
-0.4616119564,
-0.9825119376,
0.3829596937,
-0.3071346879,
-0.5779753327,
0.6291796565,
0.1560141146,
-0.2883039713,
0.2826664746,
-0.4126542509,
1.0097403526,
-0.1113338396,
-0.051159177,
-0.4282559752,
-0.646060586,
-0.0333368517,
0.133767873,
0.1808615178,
-0.0563720651,
0.0607016943,
0.8277950287,
-0.2674869299,
1.0268120766,
-0.2604371309,
0.2828958035,
0.2588777542,
0.2232014388,
0.4772176147,
-0.2577928901,
-0.0437605269,
-0.2881166935,
0.1562715918,
-0.8473693728,
-0.7199875116,
0.9227823019,
-0.8178690076,
-0.4566300213,
-0.6557340622,
-0.4202410579,
-0.2016322762,
0.0909522772,
0.0021436892,
0.5980116725,
-0.6436157227,
0.2011512965,
0.177216351,
-0.1090091243,
0.7660481334,
0.4242232144,
0.1332804412,
-0.6040558219,
0.7204024196,
-0.2252182513,
0.1914986968,
0.1175579727,
0.0601341426,
-0.3300223053,
-0.6491625309,
-0.262802422,
0.0141364718,
-0.7532833219,
-0.3873906434,
-0.8259550929,
-0.0540712029,
-0.6784367561,
-0.5229402184,
-0.3637277782,
-0.4475445449,
-0.6108043194,
-0.0127108367,
0.0975216404,
0.688421905,
-0.1622403115,
0.4611990154,
-0.6152204871,
0.3178689182,
0.1680895388,
0.2252881974,
-0.1203507781,
-0.8760112524,
-0.0839022547,
-0.1086268425,
0.0058634146,
-0.5242803693,
0.4701174796,
0.2887333035,
0.5128276944,
0.0854870081,
0.3172561824,
0.7679201961,
-0.4537455738,
0.9021719694,
0.2875112593,
-1.0711967945,
0.4526239336,
0.009214785,
0.5289727449,
0.7002868652,
0.0559389926,
-0.3761292696,
-0.1694994718,
-0.6804278493,
-0.7094036937,
0.5534504652,
0.197833553,
0.5223866701,
-0.4674274325,
0.6130567789,
-0.0458750278,
-0.1420166343,
-0.6873970032,
0.0991060883,
-0.9249497056,
-0.6872336864,
-0.3653407991,
-0.5083290339,
0.1337013096,
0.1423429549,
0.7244020104,
-0.4214117229,
0.4076246917,
0.6181298494,
-0.2741445005,
0.2068555057,
0.4866907001,
0.270928055,
0.0336336009,
-0.0343208201,
0.4063015878,
0.356271565,
-0.1000279337,
0.1091054603,
0.1890647262,
0.1039239019,
-0.3216772974,
0.3360462189,
0.8870392442,
0.5741342902,
-0.5072499514,
0.8294917941,
-0.0960301831,
0.0024645685,
-0.2045298219,
-0.1207077503,
-0.0765040517,
0.2772485316,
0.2881013155,
0.2810078859,
0.302624464,
-0.5039091706,
0.5633160472,
0.4460988045,
-0.534689188,
-0.0489564203,
0.6840283275,
0.2649949789,
0.0508446284,
0.4297169447,
0.0249701757,
-0.505428195,
0.564455092,
0.959577322,
0.8399497867,
-0.503424108,
0.163702935,
0.3735479414,
0.0519566126,
-0.032064233,
0.1355645657,
-0.0919406116,
-0.816595614,
-0.3228595853,
-0.7199726105,
0.1310113668,
-0.3205641508,
-0.7817646265,
-0.0375691317,
-0.1940945834,
0.2924922109,
-0.1579137444,
-0.3007432818,
-0.4708952904,
0.6039341092,
-0.1225992292,
0.7773420215,
-0.9432791471,
0.7960091829,
0.5572093725,
-0.3291580379,
-0.5061862469,
0.1042226404,
-0.4517099559,
-0.9317476153,
0.5428935289,
-0.0348308496,
-0.3173059821,
0.3565887511,
-0.2905587256,
-0.913721025,
1.0618249178,
0.3633020222,
-0.5399480462,
0.0572334193,
-0.0443747938,
0.5067561865,
-0.8719831109,
0.0806255788,
0.2213005871,
0.0665741265,
0.0396438651,
-0.6009594798,
0.1999991983,
0.0297079403,
0.2691961825,
0.0305666216,
-0.6054257751,
0.6253321767,
0.1910458654,
-0.1499961019,
0.1962897927,
1.031793952,
-0.1987272203,
0.010022385,
0.7788432837,
0.47739169,
0.3585154712,
0.0718463659,
0.930153966,
-0.4615650773,
0.4195453525,
1.2965714931,
-0.1192733049,
0.8526927233,
0.505248189,
0.1226540282,
0.7640114427,
0.402670294,
-0.1195508093,
0.7344447374,
0.0549113415,
-0.0880234241,
-0.5275486112,
-0.1139495,
-0.1287668943,
0.8946272731,
0.0476846248,
-0.6558433771,
-0.4237394631,
0.519498229,
-0.2969907224,
0.5311813951,
-0.5160722136,
0.8530861139,
0.1251426488,
-0.4622998834,
0.3692534864,
-0.1498051435,
0.5919710994,
-0.4836402833,
0.0325952619,
-0.2775181234,
0.3803785443,
-0.0308371559,
-0.4719506204,
0.4702985287,
-0.4231288433,
-0.0715056881,
-0.2541906834,
0.9965205193,
-0.5241854787,
-0.3745000362,
0.5484647751,
0.5469613075,
-0.0315655805,
0.0803300813,
-0.8459713459,
0.0093086287,
0.032140214,
-0.2403125316,
0.5876067281,
0.4013829827,
0.0933088735,
0.495955497,
0.3606472015,
-0.2951120138,
-0.0505815819,
0.1116471663,
1.1220448017,
-0.9663620591,
-0.789175272,
-0.650629878,
0.3176966608,
-0.0194489099,
-0.1146318093,
0.5764185786,
0.5628142357,
0.7013446093,
-0.1466302276,
0.5650929213,
0.1076662168,
0.4624817371,
-0.6975787282,
0.3638703823,
-0.6219356656,
0.0582957044,
-0.1502743214,
-0.5248796344,
-0.2391143441,
0.8223114014,
-0.0563594364,
0.0854240954,
0.8109267354,
0.7096105814,
-0.2820680737,
-0.1731979847,
0.2778280079,
0.4896897078,
-0.017834289,
0.2939166427,
0.4896725416,
-0.6611493826,
0.498713851,
0.0033636393,
-0.0338754356,
-0.0317961052,
-0.8554555178,
-0.7746613026,
-0.6789903045,
-0.3067362905,
-0.4137714207,
0.4012669325,
0.9990762472,
0.5502923727,
-1.05689466,
-0.0826455876,
-0.3533751965,
-0.4569959342,
-0.0843871459,
-0.1583817154,
0.8637120724,
-0.7097428441,
-0.5732821822,
0.6859288812,
0.2241527736,
0.3292561173,
-0.056666255,
0.080803819,
-0.2958428562,
0.2689284086,
0.4811189175,
0.16067186,
-0.6149206758,
-0.5988695025,
-0.2396562994,
-0.2496265471,
0.1852994263,
1.0351923704,
-1.1400300264,
0.3685155213,
0.1845877618,
0.9138119221,
0.888964653,
0.145639658,
0.4742649794,
-0.6926365495,
0.198032856,
0.0828207582,
0.7837682366,
0.2572638094,
-0.2132925391,
0.4547255933,
0.3017580807,
-0.5238499641,
-0.5050228238,
0.2865762711,
-1.2404885292,
-0.8182301521,
0.9739205837,
-0.3245377541,
-0.265263617,
-0.0889389887,
-0.3743701577,
0.3873389065,
-0.1028103903,
0.8027975559,
0.4383594394,
-0.0364906676,
-0.2194735557,
0.1426964402,
0.4126721621,
0.8503975868,
-0.6546114087,
0.2616575062,
0.5235899687,
0.4350678921,
-0.0922998711,
0.8648055196,
-0.202607736,
0.1564231813,
0.1073300317,
0.1151270568,
-0.1865572929,
0.0006640847,
-0.4916195869,
0.2119296342,
-0.1692877114,
-0.325637579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15151v2
|
Where Visual Speech Meets Language: VSP-LLM Framework for Efficient and Context-Aware Visual Speech Processing
| 2024-02-23T07:21:32 | 2024-05-14T02:58:21 |
Jeong Hun Yeo, Seunghee Han, Minsu Kim, Yong Man Ro
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, eess.AS, eess.IV
|
In visual speech processing, context modeling capability is one of the most
important requirements due to the ambiguous nature of lip movements. For
example, homophenes, words that share identical lip movements but produce
different sounds, can be distinguished by considering the context. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework, namely Visual Speech Processing
incorporated with LLMs (VSP-LLM), to maximize the context modeling ability by
bringing the overwhelming power of LLMs. Specifically, VSP-LLM is designed to
perform multi-tasks of visual speech recognition and translation, where the
given instructions control the type of task. The input video is mapped to the
input latent space of an LLM by employing a self-supervised visual speech
model. Focused on the fact that there is redundant information in input frames,
we propose a novel deduplication method that reduces the embedded visual
features by employing visual speech units. Through the proposed deduplication
and Low Rank Adaptation (LoRA), VSP-LLM can be trained in a computationally
efficient manner. In the translation dataset, the MuAViC benchmark, we
demonstrate that VSP-LLM trained on just 30 hours of labeled data can more
effectively translate lip movements compared to the recent model trained with
433 hours of data.
|
[
-0.2696306109,
-0.7463178635,
0.4199731052,
0.1899699867,
-0.4407854974,
-0.2000619471,
-0.1862773299,
-0.4546180367,
0.136841163,
0.6635693312,
-0.5177841783,
-0.6304908991,
-0.567682445,
-0.1533993632,
-0.4756880999,
0.4560001493,
0.1289431453,
0.35870561,
-0.2663408816,
-0.4291378558,
-0.4219268858,
-0.3812438846,
-0.0930200964,
-0.265681535,
0.2623668611,
0.3822577596,
0.2936326563,
0.9367088079,
0.442601651,
0.3406663835,
-0.1726604551,
0.0567277335,
-0.3398110271,
0.0380924903,
0.0819482058,
-0.4400982559,
-0.5232497454,
-0.1904302984,
0.8371665478,
0.5679234862,
-0.2616828084,
0.1246378496,
0.2260117978,
0.4364735186,
-0.5605407953,
0.2121855915,
-0.6007966399,
0.0342856795,
-0.0993130654,
-0.3895815015,
0.0708893687,
-0.0367380902,
0.1076307669,
-0.2700216472,
0.0011360112,
-0.3902125657,
0.2572776973,
0.6651695967,
-0.1687516421,
0.0406955965,
-0.6814363599,
0.59607023,
-0.5166479945,
0.5243951082,
-0.0724323317,
0.3454540074,
-0.0126752146,
-0.6655108929,
-0.7143314481,
0.0915430859,
0.3869847059,
0.0894559324,
-0.2578760386,
0.0404810682,
0.3641110063,
0.168434009,
-0.7075420022,
0.2012448311,
-0.1218716502,
-0.0196724813,
0.2116655707,
-0.0828040615,
0.4380297661,
-0.3859517574,
-0.8604193926,
-0.0760183185,
-0.5435825586,
0.3374670446,
-0.2186759859,
0.4682651758,
-0.389280349,
0.6852191091,
-0.2741712332,
0.8455267549,
-0.4988055527,
-0.6294127703,
0.3305916786,
-0.2794730961,
-0.5367212892,
0.275051266,
0.4959927201,
0.3066677451,
0.2697014511,
0.3195748925,
-0.0002809594,
0.2120388746,
-0.1546696723,
-0.7944505811,
0.1295183003,
-0.188073203,
-0.243026793,
-0.0770167261,
-0.4208462536,
-0.6079719663,
-0.2867718339,
-0.6736060381,
0.1975712627,
-0.211861521,
-0.0051962826,
-0.0423274003,
0.0401050001,
0.4608635902,
0.5101769567,
-0.7935592532,
0.2842745483,
0.5550566912,
0.6941974759,
-0.3888507187,
-0.3240807652,
-0.9919706583,
0.3399589062,
-0.0163970049,
0.73095119,
-0.4806138575,
-0.209581852,
-0.0602867976,
-0.2288000435,
-0.1046364158,
-0.5673078299,
0.329829663,
-0.0969876274,
-0.0899782553,
-0.2227773815,
-0.4233519137,
-0.1737059504,
-0.0617164858,
-0.18692635,
0.7419084311,
-0.1352829933,
-0.5013055205,
0.4808233678,
-0.2838433981,
-0.3576407433,
0.4532869458,
-0.653126359,
-0.1775061488,
0.0994887352,
0.4359631538,
0.4592499435,
-0.3835352361,
0.285451293,
-0.3546072841,
-0.363824904,
-0.0287071317,
-0.4669165611,
0.6001236439,
0.1090380102,
-0.4370849729,
0.2823906243,
-0.843849659,
0.0167863667,
-0.1247041598,
-0.4293741882,
-0.2622911036,
-0.0096704038,
0.149287641,
0.2734837234,
0.1512690336,
-0.2353648692,
0.2891558409,
-0.265435189,
0.5389153361,
0.684327662,
-0.2984700501,
0.5205771923,
0.0246788561,
0.4662744999,
-0.0347202942,
0.0533313453,
-0.1177461743,
-0.4328885376,
-0.7272384763,
-0.6942780614,
-0.0998039395,
0.8730673194,
-0.8852068186,
0.2692160904,
-0.5733924508,
-0.0714348406,
-0.4356672764,
0.4842939377,
0.2657791972,
0.8607534766,
0.45200634,
-0.3010466695,
-0.4632884264,
-0.9485577345,
-0.1672172248,
-0.137359187,
-0.0036983583,
0.4145631492,
0.2684389353,
-0.3529948294,
0.8488248587,
-0.1551865041,
-0.6795964837,
-0.3109455407,
-0.0452084579,
0.0327448733,
0.4808754921,
0.5715097785,
-0.9159145355,
-0.3137995005,
-0.1618633568,
-0.8978106976,
-0.4375424087,
0.0427488424,
0.1812490076,
0.1273633987,
0.7480424047,
-0.1369064748,
0.5321006179,
0.700186789,
0.05739839,
0.0360795371,
-0.1150609702,
0.1148231551,
-0.9172249436,
-0.0510891192,
-0.0534717217,
-0.5956281424,
-0.5435780287,
-0.2638493478,
-0.1637700647,
-0.4682600498,
-0.8671104312,
0.4554599226,
-0.4117133617,
-0.2357547581,
-0.3387750983,
0.5512341261,
-0.4405421615,
0.6626070738,
0.1949841976,
0.7635284662,
0.9138328433,
-0.4349322617,
0.4606218338,
0.1905432492,
-0.4366801381,
0.9037239552,
-0.4898020327,
-0.2746676207,
-0.1325291246,
-0.2219103128,
-1.0906844139,
-0.0865254775,
0.3409718871,
-0.1368062943,
0.1945750117,
-0.3883300126,
-0.2672514021,
-0.0553184114,
-0.0553547069,
0.268240571,
0.5031778216,
-0.7034134865,
0.7062042356,
0.6055069566,
-0.3427370489,
-0.6420660615,
-0.9717026353,
0.1767341197,
-0.3719637394,
-0.7454104424,
0.4003653824,
-0.1527277678,
0.0474821515,
-0.1120548546,
-0.3252472281,
0.0426647291,
-0.1035267711,
0.357318759,
0.0370708779,
-0.1558838636,
-0.0072854604,
-0.1340181082,
-0.043617215,
-0.2110230029,
-0.1957749873,
0.4144293666,
-0.2748589516,
-0.307885468,
-0.5950901508,
0.4384999871,
0.5775808096,
-0.0076874546,
0.2873069346,
0.6505658031,
-0.3132792413,
-0.1932701766,
-0.5692216158,
0.0865950063,
-0.4344015718,
0.5058416128,
-0.5696466565,
-0.9268926382,
0.3307720721,
-0.2196100354,
-0.4218840301,
-0.0751557797,
0.4837402999,
-0.2431098968,
0.6693840027,
0.8091819286,
-0.3284052908,
0.9824278355,
-0.0873762667,
-0.0082123633,
-0.9380091429,
-0.0681189895,
-0.2116760612,
-0.1948345006,
-0.6013485789,
-0.7826838493,
0.5388703942,
0.4086866081,
0.2496844679,
0.4077242017,
-0.2745447755,
0.3559615612,
0.5740301013,
-0.0727396384,
0.2622402906,
0.5749783516,
-0.1465450376,
-0.1919659078,
-0.80140239,
-0.3749913871,
0.6106078029,
0.1242730841,
0.8661328554,
0.0287790503,
0.614787817,
0.2557166517,
0.0969360247,
-0.7919623256,
0.9661956429,
-0.2275604159,
0.1478547603,
-0.4972893596,
-0.5739227533,
-0.5800313354,
0.614667356,
-0.3048457801,
-0.9221951365,
0.1399998814,
0.2496758252,
0.160845682,
0.1484983563,
-0.3184064925,
0.7613915205,
-0.4471215308,
-0.5048306584,
-0.2530611753,
-0.6722234488,
0.1717803925,
0.2931340635,
0.2481846362,
-0.1930812746,
-0.0642288402,
0.3976935446,
-0.2529720664,
0.8090132475,
-0.2776138186,
-0.2789015472,
0.2384155989,
-0.0584742092,
0.2536506653,
-0.0281160884,
0.2982437015,
0.3598674536,
-0.2113446146,
-0.1103676856,
-0.3955848217,
0.881572783,
-0.3109789789,
-0.5646934509,
-0.3104319572,
-0.2805867493,
-0.0495283529,
0.2843575478,
0.0754938573,
0.3618213832,
-0.2968681157,
0.3647387028,
0.5466772318,
-0.2129804194,
0.5897008777,
0.4103547037,
-0.3745209575,
-0.5218867064,
0.8061474562,
0.0967978984,
0.1122496426,
0.6579202414,
0.1199456081,
-0.3056508899,
-0.4107990563,
-0.5347439647,
0.2088476568,
-0.8869158626,
0.0278498959,
-0.4668573737,
0.0290970504,
-0.5733281374,
0.0207324848,
-0.3831673861,
-0.263327837,
-0.3881050944,
0.2027961761,
-0.0882104337,
0.1238345802,
-0.226140663,
0.2604588866,
-0.5336405635,
0.9781441092,
0.8050150275,
0.225442186,
-0.3867657185,
-0.4564942122,
0.1404383779,
-0.0200990215,
-0.0397095904,
-0.7339832783,
0.4554617703,
0.2365272492,
0.5753474236,
0.0694059953,
-0.3464852273,
1.0445424318,
-0.5054793954,
0.5459201336,
0.3165839314,
-1.1942398548,
0.6818606853,
-0.1903677285,
0.5583673716,
0.2360101789,
0.0346595272,
-0.6063663363,
0.041368749,
-0.1217071712,
-0.8911816478,
0.4323863983,
0.1728983968,
-0.2299053967,
0.2620180547,
0.1022936404,
-0.3321552277,
0.3417714238,
-0.9005435109,
-0.2269805968,
-0.1256871521,
-0.0103069423,
-0.1070399806,
-0.2875876427,
-0.1648539305,
-0.3560989499,
0.2453922778,
-0.4357976317,
0.0637417361,
0.3453522027,
-0.5193862319,
0.031003397,
0.386800617,
0.8498674631,
0.4844180644,
0.0835418031,
0.2034018189,
0.2706350684,
-0.1576005369,
0.0213558413,
0.1161747351,
-0.0576230846,
-0.1658090651,
0.3980838954,
0.9593801498,
0.3368631005,
-0.7789381146,
0.742536962,
-0.0964358002,
0.0780287161,
-0.4605721533,
0.1819624305,
0.1410502195,
0.4903013706,
0.2105190605,
0.1569491476,
0.2601941526,
-0.4539530277,
0.272670567,
0.4161959589,
-0.38327232,
-0.0315191895,
0.7168216705,
0.2104157507,
-0.2502309382,
0.3230878711,
0.4450813234,
-0.3676615655,
0.3313783705,
0.3372535408,
0.7745999694,
-0.2068104893,
-0.0006794978,
0.0213794373,
0.1586954594,
0.1764744818,
0.6276339293,
-0.6149284244,
-0.44863379,
-0.4585927427,
-0.6723345518,
-0.1442944407,
0.1934919208,
-0.4862818122,
0.3313828707,
-0.098945789,
0.0385735966,
-0.2238583863,
-0.6308476329,
-0.6937069893,
0.0719682425,
0.5900514126,
0.5119983554,
-0.6599054337,
1.0239385366,
0.3865301609,
-0.0448385663,
-0.3157121837,
-0.3263555169,
0.2167979032,
-0.8267991543,
0.9048315883,
0.1688068807,
-0.6176477075,
-0.1280373335,
-0.540207386,
-0.6932615638,
0.8995845318,
0.563852489,
-0.9926173687,
0.1976052374,
0.5181002617,
0.5501019359,
-0.4412159622,
-0.4185960591,
0.4234490395,
0.2795969248,
0.0962987468,
-0.9364340305,
-0.2514907122,
-0.1213498786,
0.4465070665,
-0.2683267891,
-0.360358417,
0.547007978,
-0.2357150167,
-0.2910970151,
0.1297404468,
0.6586532593,
0.2016456574,
0.0261678509,
0.5009358525,
0.5307344198,
0.5239152908,
0.0394391976,
0.7946032882,
-0.1824437976,
-0.0267282687,
1.3541529179,
-0.2166683227,
0.9298842549,
0.7997554541,
0.2183027565,
0.0285038911,
0.1029078066,
0.0411383025,
0.5790196061,
0.3291474879,
-0.2123233974,
-0.4500944018,
-0.1616523117,
-0.3549096286,
0.9191113114,
0.2189830989,
-0.2805329859,
-0.1195286289,
0.3722455502,
-0.4943883419,
0.1531320959,
-0.2598862648,
0.8875902891,
0.2592942119,
-0.3170146048,
0.8302204013,
-0.3040565848,
0.6912384629,
-0.5238770843,
-0.1957124174,
-0.0879868567,
0.1486144662,
0.0353081077,
-0.5532106161,
-0.0028209423,
0.0028970956,
-0.2931017876,
-0.609269917,
0.5849164128,
-0.6794018149,
-0.2805168331,
0.5549800396,
0.6072064042,
0.1844961941,
0.0043668174,
-0.6790438294,
0.4613329768,
0.0490771011,
-0.1452706307,
0.1727531105,
0.2309052497,
0.0339817926,
1.0183701515,
0.4997988641,
0.426179409,
0.0993527472,
0.3556153178,
0.6202346087,
-0.6500098109,
-0.5589744449,
-0.790510118,
0.3783204854,
0.100310266,
-0.1394453645,
0.5546061397,
0.4153493643,
0.9254387617,
-0.1765659451,
0.6326498985,
0.2464572787,
0.3030831218,
-0.7495499849,
0.3776292205,
-0.7365922928,
0.4848742187,
-0.6003552675,
-1.011087656,
-0.3843304217,
0.7817283273,
0.0082537727,
-0.1113911048,
0.3303927183,
0.6018813252,
-0.1230166852,
-0.2532424927,
0.5558284521,
0.0511690788,
0.4184338152,
0.4061367512,
0.5450459719,
-0.3928597569,
0.5495872498,
-0.1989014596,
-0.2428159565,
-0.3088629544,
-0.9885483384,
-0.7198172212,
-0.5939550996,
-0.4227464199,
0.2097282261,
-0.1434181929,
0.6936324835,
0.9372976422,
-0.4562016428,
-0.504437685,
-0.0694540292,
0.1162602305,
-0.2497704625,
-0.2002063543,
0.1622617394,
0.0152599104,
-0.9175519943,
0.829431951,
0.6690536141,
0.4237428904,
-0.077613771,
0.0153439809,
-0.0995848402,
-0.2728433907,
0.7644467354,
0.3220078945,
-0.878336668,
-0.2659573257,
-0.2556956708,
-0.1965869814,
0.2815940976,
0.8587557673,
-0.7790463567,
0.7536602616,
0.673307538,
0.5397919416,
0.8022111654,
-0.0300009195,
0.4274712503,
-0.6936551929,
0.445286423,
0.0854802877,
0.6120659709,
0.4621517062,
0.0023080339,
0.4603664279,
0.4785093963,
-0.1943587959,
-0.8282541037,
0.4153526425,
-1.4360256195,
-0.3084417582,
0.9513735771,
0.1908988208,
-0.221271053,
0.3491471708,
-0.2735340893,
0.2367399186,
-0.2822308838,
0.4300088286,
0.3108417988,
-0.3779040277,
-0.4652824104,
-0.448433429,
0.4683215618,
0.3366841674,
-0.6363502741,
0.1641102284,
0.5469737053,
0.3735190928,
-0.0029445193,
0.6351229548,
-0.0355436504,
0.069633171,
-0.1800102592,
0.2318145335,
-0.110690929,
-0.5332335234,
-0.5391772389,
0.2277596891,
-0.2985638976,
-0.2345723957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15132v1
|
Improving Sentence Embeddings with an Automatically Generated NLI Dataset
| 2024-02-23T06:33:51 | 2024-02-23T06:33:51 |
Soma Sato, Hayato Tsukagoshi, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Decoder-based large language models (LLMs) have shown high performance on
many tasks in natural language processing. This is also true for sentence
embedding learning, where a decoder-based model, PromptEOL, has achieved the
best performance on semantic textual similarity (STS) tasks. However, PromptEOL
makes great use of fine-tuning with a manually annotated natural language
inference (NLI) dataset. We aim to improve sentence embeddings learned in an
unsupervised setting by automatically generating an NLI dataset with an LLM and
using it to fine-tune PromptEOL. In experiments on STS tasks, the proposed
method achieved an average Spearman's rank correlation coefficient of 82.21
with respect to human evaluation, thus outperforming existing methods without
using large, manually annotated datasets.
|
[
-0.15082407,
-0.6210768223,
0.449768275,
0.2012421787,
-0.4094237387,
-0.0527913086,
-0.3110400736,
-0.2989316881,
0.2452091575,
0.5407427549,
-0.4067968726,
-0.864677012,
-0.53222996,
0.577449739,
-0.0703134239,
0.8265475035,
0.2348849475,
0.1233687028,
-0.4523192048,
-0.0900320187,
-0.6721178293,
-0.212428689,
-0.5214992762,
-0.1182870939,
0.2977127135,
0.2701655626,
0.7427495718,
0.9681755304,
0.3458426595,
0.2593696415,
-0.0751499161,
0.5133451223,
-0.3255546093,
0.2940221727,
-0.029917039,
-0.4020731747,
-0.1884095669,
-0.0160116106,
0.5974805951,
0.7618972659,
0.035303086,
-0.0573046468,
0.3222287297,
0.3676536679,
-0.5663577318,
0.266816169,
-0.4690794051,
0.0996124595,
0.0549630672,
-0.4015575945,
-0.6820175052,
-0.5632109642,
0.22534132,
-0.6859884858,
0.2230145186,
0.4871155918,
0.5269331932,
0.5551492572,
-0.498562932,
-0.5026926398,
-0.2255066782,
0.9214391112,
-0.8970503807,
0.3007056117,
0.3119989038,
-0.2318786979,
-0.3712675869,
-0.3429883122,
-0.2622545958,
-0.4570367634,
-0.3115769625,
0.0533550978,
-0.391169399,
0.027145071,
0.4018318057,
0.0791857317,
-0.6769934297,
0.2865490019,
0.089363344,
0.0135638984,
0.8316985369,
0.3488651514,
0.2802065909,
-0.5507479906,
-0.1492764652,
-0.3196097612,
-0.6241645813,
-0.0587864369,
0.3229923844,
0.4692101181,
0.1826972961,
0.6248947382,
-0.1141896769,
0.6388534307,
-0.0118744327,
0.1970232129,
0.5790321827,
-0.262277782,
-0.2289120406,
0.2180042863,
0.7767390609,
0.7064795494,
0.4449094832,
-0.4282813966,
-0.2660848498,
0.0204609744,
0.2227552533,
-0.6804107428,
-0.2531485856,
0.0128317541,
-0.3981486559,
-0.2921458483,
0.3013835847,
-0.4896172583,
-0.3851004541,
-0.4778645337,
0.2916873693,
-0.6413371563,
0.2933966517,
0.0226076748,
-0.1777816117,
0.2885639966,
0.1674318016,
-0.5931835175,
0.1220494211,
0.6394720674,
0.8536414504,
-0.0953022093,
-0.2646077573,
-0.879788518,
0.1144516766,
-0.5987645388,
0.8415513039,
-0.4629758894,
-0.3565936387,
0.2986927629,
-0.0194267631,
-0.2576130331,
-0.668952167,
0.7052134871,
-0.3862138689,
0.3040564358,
-0.1573508978,
-1.1902343035,
0.1779045463,
0.1502977908,
-0.646869719,
1.0078166723,
-0.1653083265,
-0.8759938478,
0.4185086191,
-0.6887775064,
-0.5721938014,
0.0868394971,
0.143933028,
-0.425599575,
0.2329593748,
0.6395079494,
0.6842632294,
-0.223052308,
0.5123999715,
-0.2617082894,
-0.473821044,
0.2659572363,
-0.3650030494,
0.6974058151,
0.1250408739,
-0.0653399453,
0.1515005827,
-0.7376920581,
-0.0256518386,
-0.1274928004,
-0.1883601546,
-0.6765474677,
-0.1375836581,
0.1165910736,
-0.1024268866,
0.1618607044,
-0.5970110297,
0.2178529948,
-0.7882042527,
0.4244143367,
0.589327693,
0.2512696981,
0.4640131295,
-0.267242074,
0.2368794531,
-0.0478453487,
-0.139260903,
-0.3429990113,
-0.2854949832,
-0.7849078774,
-0.2439092398,
0.3939608634,
0.6600801349,
-0.6935255527,
1.0357296467,
-0.4705102742,
-0.1442011744,
-0.7901557684,
0.3121440411,
0.3532567322,
0.4104576409,
0.5185658932,
0.0622442774,
-0.6479377151,
-1.0404086113,
-0.3065042496,
0.1521902382,
-0.4371260703,
0.2081935555,
0.3502280712,
-0.2462717891,
1.1651214361,
-0.5609071255,
-0.3416714668,
-0.3128803968,
0.4370408058,
0.2184495777,
0.5050297976,
0.2156623751,
-0.4228750765,
-0.2974583209,
-0.4148399532,
-0.8960293531,
-0.2691176236,
-0.189481616,
-0.1388526559,
0.2010861188,
0.7496375442,
-0.4477826655,
0.2834816277,
0.1070896834,
-0.6352473497,
0.0187859256,
-0.5521376729,
0.1121321693,
-1.4647783041,
-0.0132268779,
0.302377522,
-0.3287441134,
-0.4135510921,
-0.1550857723,
0.1290429831,
-0.0222597755,
-0.2618596852,
0.4315596223,
-0.5945148468,
-0.0489678644,
-0.2562204599,
0.2592633367,
-0.0678259581,
0.2837889791,
0.0422621034,
0.8730095029,
0.4675803781,
-0.4667017758,
0.2527624965,
0.6284332871,
-0.384498477,
0.3585628271,
-0.828440249,
0.0108209504,
-0.1836143583,
0.112347357,
-0.7772925496,
-0.130768761,
-0.0173194185,
-0.1573339105,
0.1802109033,
-0.0357957631,
-0.462754488,
-0.0766423643,
-0.5998439789,
-0.0350203626,
0.5562645793,
-0.7121517658,
0.3928413093,
0.1747027338,
-0.0300016347,
-0.4149204493,
-0.6037765145,
0.4654242396,
-0.3042168915,
-0.477147609,
0.4121026993,
-0.0736343116,
-0.242263481,
-0.0029222302,
0.3003657758,
0.2691193521,
0.0041402178,
0.4086860716,
0.2687274814,
-0.1673573554,
0.4396570027,
0.2085340768,
-0.2996564507,
0.0810927749,
-0.0959254429,
0.288844049,
-0.0910930708,
-0.0499618575,
-0.5733229518,
0.3811586797,
0.1481418759,
-0.1624222547,
0.772516489,
0.4827456474,
-0.2077327371,
-0.3124381304,
-0.4567237794,
-0.1957225204,
-0.4096391499,
0.1685610116,
-0.2738532722,
-0.9716520309,
0.1751181632,
-0.1051275507,
-0.0572915822,
0.3695007265,
0.0784566998,
-0.2617454827,
0.9540848136,
0.5253056884,
-0.1356928498,
0.2820541263,
-0.1853200346,
-0.0413583666,
-0.8871762156,
-0.1313617975,
-0.3540631235,
-0.1789355874,
-0.7111356258,
-0.3600783348,
0.1015665531,
0.1155586317,
-0.1960251778,
0.3521103263,
-0.1657014638,
0.5310689807,
0.7619874477,
0.2454037666,
0.2465589792,
-0.0574544743,
-0.0892711133,
-0.1553384364,
-0.6969480515,
-0.8076297641,
1.0423973799,
0.1585671604,
0.6731084585,
-0.1140207797,
0.7063290477,
0.541780591,
-0.0052717733,
-0.5816429257,
0.5149834752,
-0.4421830773,
0.2448630184,
-0.2431255579,
-0.4373855591,
-1.0173684359,
0.0793785676,
-0.530321002,
-0.3523309529,
0.0216021761,
0.1468163282,
-0.319712013,
-0.0803578347,
-0.6578460336,
0.7568629384,
0.0580500588,
-0.2439051419,
-0.0621815622,
-0.6025807261,
-0.0965851247,
0.3024493158,
-0.1046314761,
-0.0428153723,
-0.0752394348,
0.8426507115,
-0.3503423035,
0.8923811913,
-0.138106212,
-0.074263379,
0.1221681833,
-0.1305934638,
0.6139717698,
0.4000210464,
-0.2766239047,
-0.0319685154,
-0.3584572971,
-0.3580857515,
-0.7583659291,
0.9048127532,
-0.7733403444,
-0.5620825291,
-0.2919634283,
-0.5955811739,
-0.2185971737,
-0.1415504515,
0.2490802854,
0.572086513,
-0.4105733633,
0.2473019511,
0.8013426661,
-0.3122157454,
0.7339353561,
0.2133374512,
0.2194818705,
-0.5511502028,
0.4838624001,
-0.1512389183,
-0.2622262537,
0.6192823052,
0.0326060206,
-0.5339283347,
-0.3881969154,
-0.3770519197,
0.1233797148,
-0.5438812375,
-0.4060603678,
-0.8101471066,
-0.0606374256,
-0.6281006932,
-0.2821340859,
-0.1424461305,
-0.1372009665,
-0.5386343002,
-0.2274089754,
0.6758717895,
0.6138945222,
0.0495480597,
0.2124105692,
-0.6303972602,
0.1566144973,
0.1499513686,
0.1132117212,
-0.2306202203,
-0.6945196986,
-0.1707774699,
-0.0204971507,
0.2436189502,
-0.5893515944,
0.6367747784,
0.3947706819,
0.3913839161,
0.2944161296,
0.3594475985,
0.7460693717,
-0.5939085484,
0.4991061091,
-0.1400392503,
-0.9381098747,
0.8642459512,
-0.1438210309,
0.5463718772,
0.5552523136,
0.3032159805,
-0.2724446654,
-0.5336363316,
-0.3551107645,
-0.8439542651,
0.3825471997,
0.2475021929,
0.2757722437,
-0.37738958,
0.447852999,
0.1389866024,
0.0017402197,
-0.4783489704,
0.12014319,
-0.0534495115,
-0.5888363719,
-0.3785779476,
-0.2960450947,
0.2066558301,
-0.1390784383,
0.6484827399,
-0.242262274,
0.1179431677,
0.2709564865,
-0.6092874408,
0.1380205899,
0.3531528711,
0.2545869052,
0.4288756251,
-0.2781096399,
0.2889888883,
0.5528780222,
-0.2087857872,
-0.0376324095,
0.1645319462,
-0.2926436365,
0.0344341807,
0.8064107895,
1.0206420422,
0.3996908367,
-0.8221223354,
0.6265058517,
-0.0637284145,
0.0837832764,
-0.3691749871,
0.2096365243,
-0.0282960497,
0.4597328007,
0.3933985531,
-0.044634033,
0.1784154773,
-0.2601523995,
0.455289185,
0.389579922,
-0.2462966442,
-0.0959038958,
0.3747295141,
0.2201839685,
-0.3466431201,
0.9748075604,
-0.1818006784,
-0.1368858665,
0.3564092219,
0.618993938,
0.6639574766,
-0.1381507218,
0.2761532962,
0.596380651,
0.3289271593,
-0.1012521163,
0.0509430394,
0.1554276347,
-0.6645234227,
-0.5957623124,
-0.6251640916,
-0.1524996459,
-0.1195308119,
-0.7842204571,
0.3703118563,
-0.1315046698,
0.0954605564,
-0.2247177958,
0.0866209045,
-0.7820042372,
0.2118900716,
-0.0018938257,
0.7628030181,
-1.0939537287,
0.7214231491,
0.6589753628,
-0.2895663381,
-0.495639354,
0.1121457294,
-0.4840952158,
-0.4583893716,
0.675878942,
0.4170437753,
-0.0888994187,
0.213357538,
-0.3541320264,
-0.655714035,
1.2790744305,
0.5119535923,
-0.7532208562,
0.0941628516,
0.2161758244,
0.6596825123,
-0.6928124428,
0.5404811502,
0.3605901301,
0.1806014776,
-0.1658747047,
-0.4657850266,
0.1512797773,
-0.3379989564,
0.4862854183,
0.0707046837,
-0.1053285301,
0.3915825188,
-0.3020156324,
-0.2122569978,
0.1091253012,
0.853012383,
0.1411792487,
0.2170133889,
0.5354628563,
0.7929239273,
0.7777163982,
0.0950516388,
1.009827733,
-0.2575445175,
0.1742363423,
1.3093038797,
-0.3477534652,
1.1283073425,
0.3099814653,
0.3060269356,
0.4479840994,
0.5070325136,
-0.3980774879,
0.4916657209,
0.1679644585,
-0.0228970461,
-0.5012707114,
-0.2047473043,
-0.0360484868,
0.5703417063,
0.0121791642,
-0.6694129705,
-0.1861379147,
0.46517241,
-0.0812117383,
0.4377616048,
-0.0985716656,
1.0024584532,
-0.0897457078,
-0.4902224243,
0.38016361,
0.0443369076,
0.8978988528,
-0.1929116994,
-0.1732138842,
-0.3870009482,
-0.0111843515,
0.0448307544,
-0.6808238029,
0.2827293575,
0.2015121281,
-0.1547786742,
-0.2992430329,
0.6298214793,
-0.5190965533,
-0.5644620061,
0.3390802741,
0.5444053411,
0.0350349545,
0.1538704634,
-0.4401221573,
-0.0952965245,
-0.1146991551,
-0.3686555624,
0.1409553885,
0.3804644942,
0.0274099912,
0.7097628713,
0.5948186517,
-0.2549923062,
-0.0953798667,
0.2405312955,
0.7496966124,
-0.8823087811,
-0.5609106421,
-0.886657238,
0.2690294981,
-0.3254004717,
-0.5142410398,
0.8046162128,
0.7997859716,
0.627286315,
-0.2671417296,
0.5691608787,
0.1655460298,
0.570389986,
-0.8973380923,
0.5637575984,
-0.1732029319,
0.26756078,
-0.0922245309,
-1.0292003155,
-0.5825605392,
0.8696880341,
-0.2735157311,
-0.2025694698,
0.6409173608,
0.9204955697,
0.0153484764,
0.0931252316,
0.3634090722,
0.21957165,
0.0188847799,
0.5146132112,
0.7408725619,
-0.4956949055,
0.2913283408,
-0.1101367772,
-0.0087732691,
-0.0213261135,
-1.0640530586,
-1.2370587587,
-0.5287778378,
-0.6199512482,
0.0121528441,
0.4598495662,
1.2523100376,
0.3974397779,
-0.8570917845,
-0.0421688594,
-0.332759738,
-0.2029809803,
-0.0471663475,
-0.1970024109,
0.6331241131,
-0.5788706541,
-0.8409588337,
0.7345090508,
0.2004945427,
-0.1929075569,
0.0801779777,
-0.1114004254,
-0.2940868437,
-0.0723235011,
0.6468732357,
-0.3043637276,
-0.7510808706,
-0.4739741683,
0.0131306546,
-0.1055249572,
0.0561889857,
0.7282117009,
-0.9924137592,
0.078886427,
0.3571119905,
0.6957153678,
0.0159417018,
0.1802269816,
0.6317749619,
-0.9258661866,
-0.0937888771,
0.1966055632,
0.4716957211,
0.5401496291,
-0.3618960083,
0.4896594882,
-0.1138180569,
-0.481012553,
-0.5334480405,
-0.1100002974,
-0.8854451776,
-0.2658969462,
1.0440251827,
-0.1838949174,
-0.0969923586,
-0.0678741634,
-0.1540520787,
0.4638552368,
-0.5059737563,
0.7091773152,
0.2895951271,
-0.0364882126,
-0.2674659193,
-0.2610107064,
0.4398388863,
0.5297730565,
-0.9411342144,
0.1705709696,
0.4882294536,
0.2668374777,
-0.0086551821,
-0.0689677,
0.2460289747,
-0.0674056113,
-0.112056911,
0.0391499028,
-0.2970014811,
-0.1184718907,
-0.5085793138,
0.2301385552,
-0.0208623204,
-0.1280310899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15131v1
|
Interactive-KBQA: Multi-Turn Interactions for Knowledge Base Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T06:32:18 | 2024-02-23T06:32:18 |
Guanming Xiong, Junwei Bao, Wen Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This study explores the realm of knowledge-base question answering (KBQA).
KBQA is considered a challenging task, particularly in parsing intricate
questions into executable logical forms. Traditional semantic parsing
(SP)-based methods require extensive data annotations, which result in
significant costs. Recently, the advent of few-shot in-context learning,
powered by large language models (LLMs), has showcased promising capabilities.
Yet, fully leveraging LLMs to parse questions into logical forms in
low-resource scenarios poses a substantial challenge. To tackle these hurdles,
we introduce Interactive-KBQA, a framework designed to generate logical forms
through direct interaction with knowledge bases (KBs). Within this framework,
we have developed three generic APIs for KB interaction. For each category of
complex question, we devised exemplars to guide LLMs through the reasoning
processes. Our method achieves competitive results on the WebQuestionsSP,
ComplexWebQuestions, KQA Pro, and MetaQA datasets with a minimal number of
examples (shots). Importantly, our approach supports manual intervention,
allowing for the iterative refinement of LLM outputs. By annotating a dataset
with step-wise reasoning processes, we showcase our model's adaptability and
highlight its potential for contributing significant enhancements to the field.
|
[
-0.5019060373,
-1.193600297,
1.0256037712,
0.1566658914,
0.0219670236,
0.0252406523,
-0.193666622,
-0.4753594995,
0.0649278015,
0.583393693,
-0.9089183807,
-0.4223100245,
-0.260022819,
0.1034521386,
0.0332330167,
0.3953865767,
-0.2280995995,
0.1964075565,
-0.5212272406,
-0.0769126862,
-0.4410352707,
-0.5693463087,
-0.3773460686,
-0.1374448389,
0.5366460085,
0.6500762701,
0.7568638921,
0.2176500708,
0.2420320213,
0.3465031087,
-0.0849659964,
0.4051255584,
-0.3118899465,
0.5801570415,
-0.084905684,
-0.5353699327,
-0.2971073389,
-0.1590216756,
0.460041672,
1.0839072466,
0.1088647619,
0.2660203874,
-0.2629372776,
0.4964913726,
-0.6184764504,
0.3636325598,
-0.5966829062,
-0.1229853854,
0.009891361,
-0.0914797038,
-0.6298771501,
-0.3652544916,
0.1596257389,
-0.844874084,
-0.5384858847,
-0.0250257403,
0.5207276344,
0.2044131309,
-0.6480294466,
-0.4150203466,
-0.5925024748,
0.6166355014,
-0.8060560226,
0.4862347543,
0.3047834337,
0.723085165,
-0.5378638506,
-0.7754533291,
-0.8515962362,
-0.2919216752,
0.0648698211,
0.0387509093,
-0.0447895713,
0.1953180134,
0.4473391175,
-0.2208289504,
-0.2281935364,
-0.2146650404,
-0.0925661251,
-0.0875203758,
0.3466158509,
0.3476137221,
0.3407161832,
-0.3493649662,
-0.1416839808,
0.1176158041,
-0.6705668569,
0.5152676105,
0.236407578,
0.4066057503,
0.0975868255,
0.9515891671,
-0.622772038,
0.9420660734,
0.1659070849,
-0.1885152459,
-0.1068770662,
-0.1947207749,
-0.2763416767,
-0.0682017729,
0.4881696403,
0.1417746842,
0.1555777639,
-0.1872401386,
0.1485521793,
-0.3729878664,
0.1111464575,
-0.7283871174,
-0.1971224844,
0.4575875103,
-0.1780408472,
-0.177654773,
-0.1546751112,
-0.6267156005,
-0.4502775967,
-0.6497209072,
0.8400811553,
-0.5031037927,
-0.2275168747,
0.0746504441,
0.0142708709,
0.4013464451,
0.7040246129,
-0.4007726908,
0.1978734434,
0.478592068,
0.1127856895,
0.1621203721,
-0.1267716289,
-0.8545055985,
0.383491993,
-0.2184002101,
0.7545520663,
-0.7404873371,
0.0485686362,
-0.1006703526,
-0.0652976781,
0.0543305688,
-0.5236004591,
0.2929270566,
-1.1568229198,
0.0820189267,
-0.6776221395,
-0.5740912557,
-0.3443332911,
0.6523057818,
-0.6529339552,
0.817696631,
0.2061941028,
-0.5844808817,
0.33653602,
-0.6719714999,
-0.2158873975,
0.1539772153,
-0.2555112839,
0.0523149855,
-0.3234096766,
0.2933377922,
0.3709477782,
-0.2407112271,
0.3618347049,
-0.5906081796,
0.06943997,
0.4894653261,
-0.1937086135,
0.7088472247,
-0.0452792346,
-0.3542071283,
0.2146711648,
-0.8947191238,
0.4439815581,
-0.0735349655,
-0.5706582069,
-0.2079118192,
-0.1874050945,
-0.2962646484,
0.6234274507,
0.070674777,
-0.5566270947,
0.4110498428,
-0.3226667643,
0.1736868173,
0.39827016,
0.3109734058,
0.5216127634,
-0.019274557,
0.6306949854,
0.1726503521,
0.2550703287,
-0.0300116725,
-0.4366173744,
-0.8167378306,
-0.4288415909,
0.4068514109,
0.4860711694,
-1.2036989927,
0.0554690547,
-0.061731603,
-0.503035903,
-0.4917923808,
0.1789563149,
0.1197403222,
0.7995240688,
0.4829416573,
0.2620836794,
-0.4185699821,
-0.9030776024,
-0.1306684464,
-0.1796087474,
0.000889391,
0.4356862307,
0.2614710629,
-0.0475763045,
1.1935280561,
-0.4125601947,
0.1633463353,
-0.4506005347,
0.151400879,
0.1441900432,
0.1132812351,
0.2862647474,
-0.9738088846,
-0.5213836432,
-0.1585518569,
-0.8683961034,
-0.3123101592,
-0.1622653008,
-0.6318792701,
0.1234365404,
0.5115491748,
-0.9796515107,
0.2688548863,
0.2095636129,
-0.3019838929,
0.5725349784,
0.386346221,
0.3678673804,
-0.7690027952,
0.1305817962,
-0.5037544966,
-0.2467944175,
-0.8070597053,
0.1794757843,
0.0912755728,
-0.1176439971,
-0.5882394314,
0.567029655,
-0.3168232143,
-0.0211901404,
-0.0488830432,
0.1318407506,
0.2793442011,
0.6689284444,
0.275893271,
0.2795698345,
0.2649664581,
-0.5463560224,
0.5204626322,
0.4894496202,
-0.2331786901,
0.3228095174,
-0.3756810129,
0.06253279,
-0.1855828464,
0.3363157511,
-1.0085459948,
-0.5016638041,
0.3201200962,
-0.4902854264,
0.0936995074,
-0.3532134295,
-0.6257198453,
-0.0487306044,
-0.2121849507,
0.4071039855,
0.0755556822,
-0.5155033469,
1.1592578888,
0.2764855325,
-0.496401161,
-0.475328356,
-0.4448190033,
-0.0261513498,
0.0056208903,
-0.9962493181,
0.0545382947,
-0.0677758083,
-0.3007020354,
0.0782252699,
0.016236715,
-0.2832225263,
0.0278659761,
0.1321449876,
0.3543091416,
-0.2997704148,
0.0343303867,
0.3273636103,
0.1894355118,
0.2741584778,
-0.0372438096,
0.6111961007,
-0.0964202136,
-0.5848217607,
-0.2273022681,
0.6032059789,
0.7710905671,
-0.2537130117,
0.8136863708,
0.3157155216,
-0.5668168664,
0.0726851225,
-0.6694571972,
0.0452067927,
-0.4677813053,
0.2305933535,
-0.6779803038,
-0.9266546965,
0.5141091347,
-0.2022383809,
0.1227381974,
0.2160698324,
0.778167367,
-0.3442374468,
1.0191963911,
0.3849436045,
0.362539947,
-0.1091148928,
0.1300219893,
0.2117889076,
-0.5277227163,
-0.6102249622,
-0.1546257734,
-0.2233819515,
-0.2209756672,
-0.4144830704,
0.7526348233,
0.565346539,
-0.4780134857,
0.0960834473,
0.0889627561,
0.2564899027,
0.6848648787,
0.1247085184,
0.4499048293,
-0.3334847391,
-0.2513387501,
0.0101475185,
-0.8084303737,
-0.3923037648,
0.7196136117,
0.2534107566,
0.7392205596,
0.5161624551,
0.4994914532,
-0.1734194607,
0.3326972425,
-0.9782600999,
0.6809488535,
0.5340763927,
-0.6225302219,
-0.5598745346,
-0.5326327085,
-0.6158723235,
0.1344423741,
-0.5666518807,
-0.5604901314,
0.1044055745,
0.3079372048,
-0.482973367,
0.2285353094,
-0.8138487935,
0.9112761021,
-0.3048806787,
-0.4156126082,
0.0486163758,
-0.8194394112,
0.6191674471,
-0.0737640187,
0.1874548942,
0.1250108033,
0.1248969138,
0.3443575203,
-0.4182341099,
0.8337526321,
-0.5201715231,
0.0303479563,
0.5606710911,
0.5009431243,
0.4285418391,
0.0708331466,
0.0189496372,
-0.3155955672,
0.3213677704,
-0.3458393812,
-0.7776660919,
0.4085919857,
-0.5445582271,
-0.5785648227,
-0.0989231616,
-0.6471015215,
-0.9336287379,
0.3219282627,
-0.2036098093,
0.4481376112,
0.1428432316,
0.1509212106,
0.6487522721,
-0.4827938676,
0.070865266,
0.5824598074,
-0.3558271527,
-0.4296255708,
0.4055222571,
0.0899990052,
0.4681686163,
0.5820471048,
0.1282515824,
-0.4416761398,
-0.1261661798,
-0.6490588784,
0.076042302,
-0.953879118,
-0.4212254584,
-0.9224984646,
-0.1681144685,
-0.5073677301,
-0.1103425249,
-0.1287089586,
-0.6560027599,
0.2335399538,
-0.0703257769,
0.4612582922,
0.4745348394,
0.1315626502,
0.0862116143,
-1.0245752335,
0.5338473916,
0.614438653,
0.2240053266,
0.2562536597,
-0.2944148183,
0.0362562649,
-0.0538879186,
-0.1987992376,
-1.0495141745,
-0.0324850194,
-0.0333662964,
0.6834780574,
0.0674871951,
0.2492498606,
0.6699948311,
-0.5733332038,
0.6548150778,
0.0623425506,
-0.8625184894,
0.3271683156,
-0.4478593171,
0.4573226571,
0.7879433632,
0.6999436617,
-0.6308261752,
-0.1754970104,
-0.3713454306,
-1.0017402172,
0.7350220084,
0.0352327451,
-0.2259881943,
0.0327237844,
0.3012906313,
0.0751037002,
0.4271518886,
-0.7358212471,
-0.098390922,
-0.073926203,
-0.4106370807,
0.7133857012,
-0.2401489317,
-0.0683912411,
-0.2749837935,
0.736491859,
-0.1742830724,
0.0976428613,
0.1041197553,
-0.4321445525,
-0.1120444313,
0.3521511853,
0.1560591161,
0.5773014426,
-0.039618969,
0.1385470331,
0.2398868352,
-0.1174175963,
0.0392555892,
0.1708877385,
-0.113248378,
-0.2486489266,
0.3727899194,
0.475074172,
0.255218327,
-1.0449575186,
0.557923317,
0.0148280011,
-0.1492084712,
-0.3086083829,
-0.1697469354,
0.4891300499,
0.4971398413,
0.2538411915,
-0.2950126529,
0.1474478245,
-0.544039011,
0.1426446736,
0.4407565296,
-0.1451334804,
-0.088953957,
0.4959010184,
0.3188454807,
0.0590053611,
0.6411587596,
-0.2406423092,
-0.6783422232,
0.4180312455,
0.2509341538,
0.3825309575,
0.0298507698,
0.1650986522,
0.2514249682,
0.1559341997,
0.3257004619,
0.5342742205,
-0.2145110816,
-0.7326974869,
-0.7970102429,
-0.6924596429,
-0.7714927793,
0.3428734243,
-0.686295867,
0.3873848617,
-0.2287413031,
0.148975417,
0.1371615678,
-0.1668444127,
-0.6821056008,
0.1188722476,
0.3039557934,
1.2399679422,
-0.6714953184,
0.4901495576,
0.8721881509,
-0.5047565103,
-1.0604549646,
-0.1405924559,
0.0063779424,
-0.478369385,
0.7726182342,
0.1033739224,
-0.0814388096,
-0.0072659161,
-0.6050463915,
-0.805401206,
0.9595136046,
0.3883089125,
-0.1800657213,
-0.0980566144,
0.5738373399,
0.21972242,
-0.1276432574,
0.1877193451,
0.4894251525,
0.7547012568,
0.1145068556,
-0.6515721679,
0.0943322554,
-0.137128368,
-0.5672644377,
0.2293137312,
-0.5409404039,
0.3593335748,
-0.0353664011,
0.1978379786,
0.1034604311,
0.6973153949,
0.5941795111,
0.2064992934,
0.7334916592,
0.3902987242,
0.632799387,
0.1409846991,
0.5726789236,
-0.1031047106,
-0.0574036799,
1.122754693,
-0.466706723,
0.9093740582,
0.6393604279,
-0.0955959931,
0.4682170153,
0.472741276,
0.3677842617,
0.404530555,
0.253294915,
-0.547049582,
-0.8080258369,
0.0535218641,
0.0738361329,
0.4818079472,
0.4381065369,
0.2130392492,
-0.5366116762,
0.0536811948,
-0.1002522558,
0.0663433373,
-0.3265468776,
0.6877412796,
-0.0149861565,
-0.7412867546,
0.1446342021,
-0.0069607147,
0.2742201686,
-0.8349317908,
-0.3877804875,
0.0643101484,
-0.2375788838,
-0.1954269111,
-0.9122129083,
0.0714086965,
0.1292800903,
-0.4054670036,
0.0240072291,
0.7915189266,
-0.5879752636,
-0.4019039273,
0.2554781139,
0.8424004912,
-0.0007533873,
-0.1135047674,
-0.5001094937,
-0.0829503313,
-0.0701369867,
-0.6010306478,
0.4042625427,
0.7402513623,
-0.3034567535,
0.7392047644,
0.5663276315,
-0.2297413945,
0.2907317579,
0.1108553857,
1.1077740192,
-0.5714559555,
-0.1955030411,
-0.4194602966,
0.7141827941,
0.0263467282,
0.0085755512,
0.364962846,
0.4136938155,
0.622446537,
-0.1184367537,
0.7851457596,
-0.3121233284,
0.6587342024,
-0.6847208142,
0.4896763563,
-0.3483947515,
0.0816648751,
-0.1514504403,
-0.651589334,
-0.116536878,
0.2980010211,
-0.3077637851,
-0.0433655418,
0.407294482,
0.6614455581,
-0.1884316951,
-0.1363801062,
0.2956169546,
0.3649355173,
0.3588530719,
0.5133323669,
1.0552959442,
-0.0196405016,
0.7980489731,
-0.3599843085,
-0.3480047882,
0.0300555956,
-0.9962568879,
-0.7448782325,
-0.4439931512,
-0.1466051042,
-0.4122029841,
-0.1854764521,
1.2827379704,
0.4552704394,
-0.7776240706,
0.1583835781,
0.1618001759,
-0.1651372164,
0.1286352426,
-0.2990671396,
0.3017349541,
-0.3624441922,
-0.5802540779,
0.4711496532,
0.2573117018,
-0.2592793107,
-0.1142382845,
0.2167382389,
-0.390897423,
0.0894938037,
0.8782181144,
0.3299501538,
-0.5920319557,
-0.3343381286,
0.324522078,
0.0042178412,
-0.151647985,
0.541705668,
-0.9047086239,
0.4042585492,
0.5013968945,
1.2483993769,
0.4674185514,
0.19182311,
0.5225613117,
-0.7178936601,
-0.2270428687,
0.3577453494,
0.1984294951,
0.1595446318,
-0.4099478126,
0.1115504652,
-0.0481187329,
-0.3675429225,
-0.6551415324,
0.452278167,
-1.241029501,
-0.3194670677,
1.3381150961,
-0.0989793316,
-0.1188232675,
-0.3153561652,
-0.2952799499,
0.1430917233,
-0.1042353734,
0.381347388,
0.9637024999,
-0.6506787539,
-0.0595900901,
-0.6263681054,
0.3751685321,
0.3367922902,
-0.9938503504,
0.1404335648,
0.7901058793,
0.3524664938,
0.064917177,
0.5426332951,
-0.1963685006,
0.3215508163,
-0.3272696137,
0.182397306,
-0.1377571225,
-0.3376437426,
0.0353737734,
0.2344900072,
0.2877989411,
0.1460049599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15116v1
|
Large Multimodal Agents: A Survey
| 2024-02-23T06:04:23 | 2024-02-23T06:04:23 |
Junlin Xie, Zhihong Chen, Ruifei Zhang, Xiang Wan, Guanbin Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved superior performance in powering
text-based AI agents, endowing them with decision-making and reasoning
abilities akin to humans. Concurrently, there is an emerging research trend
focused on extending these LLM-powered AI agents into the multimodal domain.
This extension enables AI agents to interpret and respond to diverse multimodal
user queries, thereby handling more intricate and nuanced tasks. In this paper,
we conduct a systematic review of LLM-driven multimodal agents, which we refer
to as large multimodal agents ( LMAs for short). First, we introduce the
essential components involved in developing LMAs and categorize the current
body of research into four distinct types. Subsequently, we review the
collaborative frameworks integrating multiple LMAs , enhancing collective
efficacy. One of the critical challenges in this field is the diverse
evaluation methods used across existing studies, hindering effective comparison
among different LMAs . Therefore, we compile these evaluation methodologies and
establish a comprehensive framework to bridge the gaps. This framework aims to
standardize evaluations, facilitating more meaningful comparisons. Concluding
our review, we highlight the extensive applications of LMAs and propose
possible future research directions. Our discussion aims to provide valuable
insights and guidelines for future research in this rapidly evolving field. An
up-to-date resource list is available at
https://github.com/jun0wanan/awesome-large-multimodal-agents.
|
[
-0.4309510291,
-0.6546390653,
0.8469468355,
0.2722798586,
0.1402032971,
0.4003919661,
-0.4938134551,
-0.6112841368,
0.214810729,
0.3401343524,
-0.2222112417,
-0.2507245839,
-0.6646310687,
0.3306459188,
-0.276252538,
0.6497929096,
0.0428408086,
0.1261931807,
-0.4029536545,
-0.4258126915,
-0.2859840989,
-0.3215189874,
-0.3800443709,
-0.6077206135,
1.0053240061,
0.1469974965,
1.013441205,
0.144572705,
0.7199077606,
0.4957670271,
-0.0250119679,
0.5251237154,
-0.3988235891,
0.3257129788,
-0.2715299428,
-0.3297646344,
-0.7035817504,
-0.0872153118,
0.7884116769,
0.6184500456,
-0.027363928,
-0.0484020784,
-0.1639451534,
0.427126497,
-0.725979805,
0.2525602877,
-0.3565698266,
-0.0120517211,
0.0860828385,
-0.0609798916,
-0.5145933032,
-0.2861973047,
0.0620927364,
-0.4167918563,
-0.4812245071,
-0.0153866243,
0.163130179,
0.2023649067,
-0.9177208543,
-0.5390002728,
-0.8122427464,
0.9157051444,
-0.5805965662,
0.3153024018,
0.0886550471,
0.3282988071,
-0.2811462879,
-0.7902477384,
-0.6488267183,
-0.6971415877,
0.0579540208,
0.1028814167,
-0.1535666138,
0.1735334694,
0.031335216,
0.2148861289,
-0.3987630904,
0.3209075034,
-0.2235560715,
-0.0828156248,
0.7937939167,
0.4210820496,
0.4226789474,
0.1178904623,
-0.339056015,
-0.0486670844,
-0.3519039154,
-0.1605440229,
0.0175715424,
0.3402285874,
-0.0400531702,
0.5943583846,
-0.1814755052,
0.4966090918,
-0.2190658003,
-0.6822692156,
0.5616042614,
-0.6573081017,
-0.2191232443,
-0.3223185241,
0.9228593111,
0.377827704,
0.2091517746,
-0.1946736723,
-0.4077292383,
-0.0079708146,
0.202892229,
-0.6323124766,
0.3599286377,
0.3167793155,
-0.6211349368,
-0.1136515439,
-0.1750085503,
-0.591598928,
-0.7317211628,
-0.4533073306,
0.5826540589,
-0.2069371641,
-0.4937897623,
0.0377386659,
-0.0643502176,
0.0939135402,
0.5050903559,
-0.5029228926,
0.0368315913,
0.6432539821,
0.7316247225,
-0.1229863912,
-0.6283771992,
-0.1843030453,
0.1515011191,
-0.3902210891,
0.6541923285,
-0.7059042454,
-0.3447006643,
0.2807891071,
-0.0136522166,
-0.1566608101,
-0.2864230275,
0.3765750527,
-0.6128673553,
0.1197439656,
-0.3291625082,
-0.1393834651,
-0.1770885587,
0.5859550238,
-0.7088119984,
0.4082409143,
-0.0407063738,
-0.2153560221,
0.2427776456,
-0.7362672687,
-0.3570767641,
0.0105278296,
-0.1508166939,
-0.0904306024,
-0.0087197134,
0.2224146426,
0.6173757315,
-0.6437021494,
0.434274435,
-0.2210443318,
-0.1215999722,
0.487128526,
-0.3596645594,
0.4930642545,
0.391930759,
-0.1833503544,
0.7294111848,
-0.5383245945,
0.0350965112,
-0.0318526067,
-0.2105121315,
-0.1606930345,
-0.0573217347,
0.0642812699,
0.322116524,
0.2705810964,
-0.1556313038,
0.2382754385,
0.1479607671,
0.6159991622,
0.8113278151,
-0.2313687652,
0.5717719793,
-0.4466293454,
0.5914664268,
-0.2931977808,
0.4864344299,
-0.4881685376,
-0.3575237691,
-0.4423587918,
-0.5292279124,
-0.0270965695,
0.085535109,
-1.0153630972,
0.111266993,
-0.2491768897,
-0.7327491045,
-0.3368203342,
0.2589778602,
0.415016681,
-0.234355703,
0.1475047469,
-0.4081082344,
-0.2231317312,
-0.83632195,
0.0525524579,
-0.2844597399,
0.3055378497,
0.2770392299,
0.63778162,
-0.8131029606,
0.6964206696,
0.0069206823,
-0.4471262395,
-0.4851005375,
-0.1384470314,
-0.0314681008,
0.1250679046,
0.4974684715,
-0.6719070673,
-0.229760319,
0.1357523799,
-0.8948577642,
0.1289495826,
-0.2726120353,
0.2591149807,
-0.0435517803,
0.461586833,
-0.8820510507,
-0.1156918928,
0.6266406775,
-0.2130282074,
0.4896629155,
-0.1249509752,
0.3136848807,
-0.8140947223,
-0.0052429503,
-0.0131209251,
-0.1429659724,
-0.612080574,
0.3882106543,
-0.0583949313,
0.1528300941,
-0.3049268126,
0.4899354577,
-0.7171286941,
-0.2666950822,
-0.3720569909,
0.3106303215,
-0.1193394065,
0.3251156211,
-0.3878323436,
0.6504143476,
0.3823266923,
-0.3314230144,
0.8098220229,
0.0170081984,
-0.3274427354,
0.4590196311,
-0.6606310606,
0.1419317275,
-0.214411065,
0.6461859345,
-0.9824649692,
-0.345202595,
0.3409471214,
-0.1803188622,
0.1822471172,
0.33976385,
-0.6315420866,
-0.3010718822,
-0.4992473125,
0.5162522197,
0.170612067,
-0.3118974864,
0.794129014,
0.4913256168,
-0.1883746833,
-0.6209924221,
-0.3712939918,
0.40281564,
-0.0525384359,
-0.7264459133,
0.0323284045,
-0.1247713417,
-0.7891610265,
-0.0586201325,
0.3457857668,
0.1067833677,
-0.0371506847,
0.2769636214,
-0.0964369997,
-0.1991160363,
0.441885978,
-0.2706637383,
0.0804178417,
-0.0610134974,
0.1407213509,
0.5203092694,
-0.441198349,
-0.5104390383,
-0.3332118392,
0.2637391984,
0.9735859632,
-0.4070034921,
0.6294521689,
0.7903820276,
0.0073809861,
-0.1292890459,
-0.6429286003,
-0.1099158376,
-0.4025762379,
0.623544991,
-0.2491447479,
-0.9160169959,
0.2924766839,
-0.1980093122,
0.0714450926,
0.3397237062,
1.0043648481,
0.0777827352,
1.0134563446,
0.6575942039,
-0.0897818208,
0.4489026368,
-0.0832195878,
0.0776116028,
-0.6754906178,
-0.4904415011,
-0.4042096436,
-0.3474802971,
-0.430919528,
-0.6875343323,
0.4594683349,
-0.4622553587,
-0.0495830327,
-0.1043063849,
-0.0855790749,
0.2754612863,
0.0747281834,
-0.1902261078,
0.363776952,
-0.2008914351,
0.1850885749,
0.3913700581,
-0.4935371578,
-0.5409872532,
1.1848057508,
0.5992504954,
0.8460262418,
0.3546175063,
0.2531115711,
0.570166707,
0.489721179,
-0.8670333624,
0.6496953368,
0.3390681446,
-0.7475056648,
-0.4962518513,
-0.2844638526,
-1.0801041126,
0.810546279,
-0.297680974,
-0.5070488453,
-0.0721414983,
-0.3859294355,
-0.2497725487,
0.147729069,
-0.6739355326,
0.558467567,
-0.6042971015,
-0.489156276,
-0.5223305821,
-0.6826679707,
0.5388246775,
-0.1259332895,
0.4287539721,
-0.1945218444,
-0.2554593086,
0.5260218382,
-0.0445394628,
0.7943015099,
-0.0941272229,
-0.5408551693,
0.3329566121,
-0.3124759793,
0.2294775248,
-0.0589664392,
-0.0692681745,
0.1997737437,
0.0021748804,
-0.2666719854,
-0.5858063102,
0.8232371807,
-0.8400579691,
-0.563138485,
-0.4494533837,
-0.6739577651,
-0.3485212326,
0.1935399175,
-0.4648561478,
0.4509676099,
-0.2720614076,
0.3952538073,
0.3357993364,
-0.2040460557,
0.6315248609,
0.515309453,
-0.5553398132,
-0.4832612574,
0.8424881697,
0.0969647318,
0.2913206518,
0.2658833265,
-0.0086432537,
-0.2845704556,
-0.6843234897,
-0.3933739364,
0.2495908886,
-0.6805794239,
0.1062341779,
-0.4721441567,
0.0856393352,
-0.4170196056,
0.0002074055,
-0.3053349853,
-0.1439392567,
0.0447129235,
0.0931133181,
-0.0218999721,
0.9936555028,
-0.0333804972,
0.2949572206,
-0.7026584148,
0.3530410826,
0.3607436717,
0.1630694419,
0.3129396439,
-0.1035920084,
-0.2465443313,
-0.152968809,
-0.2600983083,
-0.5989946127,
0.3211639524,
0.0218626168,
0.8871459961,
0.4779480994,
-0.1013965383,
0.4000045061,
-0.3248971403,
0.8691561818,
0.5111789107,
-0.541282475,
0.0913829207,
-0.3306923807,
0.3748895824,
0.3820333779,
0.3825942874,
-0.5490585566,
-0.0825033337,
-0.1050488874,
-0.841568172,
0.5012846589,
0.2016222328,
0.2275840938,
0.1792817116,
-0.1947308928,
0.2087177932,
0.2637521923,
-0.6143493056,
-0.1507632881,
0.1949950457,
0.0144587085,
-0.5320355892,
-0.3279595673,
-0.3689892292,
0.1268300414,
0.4074591398,
-0.2824260592,
0.1139473468,
0.1168300509,
-0.3800969422,
-0.0836951584,
0.5845292807,
0.7926679254,
1.1096824408,
-0.1193381026,
0.1969405115,
0.0166236237,
-0.2838700116,
0.2412011176,
-0.0369470455,
0.1197296157,
-0.1617587656,
0.733828485,
0.521327436,
0.1332371533,
-1.0336201191,
0.4957063794,
-0.2262157798,
-0.0362435058,
-0.4125094116,
-0.0638185441,
-0.0101381168,
0.6507389545,
0.4652706087,
0.0785328075,
-0.0059107738,
-1.0210860968,
-0.169363156,
0.6413388252,
-0.3090524077,
-0.3408482075,
0.140592441,
0.6733231544,
-0.3062908947,
0.1250144243,
-0.0929141045,
-0.2365241796,
0.6009055972,
0.2342039347,
0.7223619819,
-0.1710601598,
0.177349627,
-0.1305254549,
0.6750004888,
-0.0809150487,
-0.0179440398,
-0.1452468932,
-0.8080169559,
-0.4511949718,
-0.3046939373,
-0.4543158114,
0.0733457729,
-0.2061985433,
-0.1702739894,
-0.4397669733,
-0.4790871441,
0.1423817724,
0.0391552262,
-0.5183667541,
-0.0109877456,
0.3300410509,
0.6053674221,
-0.4566257,
0.5836915374,
0.8516510129,
-0.5632523894,
-0.2846918702,
-0.0283763018,
0.1842295676,
-0.7054091692,
0.4876576066,
0.1132348105,
-0.2450526059,
-0.5028141141,
-0.5095877647,
-0.8615818024,
1.2731642723,
0.0784211308,
-0.5681143999,
-0.0536134653,
0.1125077307,
0.7472000718,
-0.5522374511,
0.8340206146,
0.5354671478,
0.7275135517,
0.0514174476,
-1.2740753889,
0.0088351993,
-0.2180681229,
-0.058671236,
-0.0670654625,
-1.0763655901,
0.6781126261,
-0.3352445066,
0.101355195,
0.2526775599,
0.5801285505,
0.1749274433,
0.7190074921,
0.5323445797,
0.1366458982,
0.6264009476,
0.2167986482,
1.0553479195,
-0.0066731139,
0.1690219343,
0.8210158348,
-0.704138577,
0.5648176074,
0.5217388868,
-0.2586618662,
0.2585985065,
0.2190416902,
0.0977615342,
0.217302531,
0.1758953035,
-0.2135152519,
-0.3449115753,
-0.4573599398,
-0.5635884404,
0.6345793605,
0.4732775688,
-0.5394122601,
-0.0522041433,
0.1868222952,
-0.1013441756,
0.0671011508,
-0.5177657008,
0.7360658646,
0.13327007,
-0.6803148985,
0.2581379116,
0.1140425652,
0.7543467879,
-0.6914605498,
0.1281440705,
-0.1060649231,
0.2327225655,
-0.2908833027,
-0.6987994909,
-0.1406460106,
-0.2035101354,
-0.1423052698,
-0.3424238861,
0.8471737504,
-0.2370240539,
-0.1667366624,
0.4691036046,
0.8664731979,
-0.010388176,
0.0853798389,
-0.6597930789,
0.5347672701,
-0.1436828375,
-0.3090473413,
0.4177490175,
0.2536151111,
-0.1614370346,
0.9633713365,
0.6532099247,
-0.2537340224,
-0.1562538147,
0.3132053018,
0.881285429,
-0.6756873131,
-0.0668803081,
-0.7802844048,
0.3201895952,
-0.0083030602,
-0.2830754519,
0.8985107541,
0.2452865392,
0.4642854631,
0.0042386022,
0.799034059,
-0.0280659702,
0.112295717,
-0.3550158143,
0.7300141454,
-0.6626954079,
0.0739368573,
-0.430960983,
-0.9760085344,
-0.2569091916,
0.3275318742,
-0.2878217101,
0.3695369959,
0.5596831441,
0.692810595,
0.2939715385,
0.034846399,
0.6300311685,
0.3385230899,
0.5306060314,
0.4756471217,
1.53802526,
-0.1280543357,
0.4198107719,
0.1241462976,
-0.1441982388,
-0.4344046414,
-0.6146100163,
-0.9073386192,
-0.6161065698,
-0.1116107553,
-0.0022018009,
0.0402834974,
1.1457147598,
0.7364171147,
-0.3559508622,
-0.3492688537,
0.6110578179,
0.4252675772,
0.0066763693,
-0.1232869029,
0.0465462282,
-0.1813784093,
-0.7918602824,
0.6650063992,
0.3775893748,
-0.3693219423,
-0.7315731049,
-0.4324478507,
-0.2278676182,
0.1484609544,
1.0735198259,
0.1334290653,
-0.9464558363,
-0.0239875894,
-0.1894604415,
-0.2823719382,
-0.3069936931,
0.8306032419,
-0.6010897756,
0.5162640214,
0.4196491838,
0.5993885398,
0.0745453611,
-0.2888014615,
0.3540087938,
-0.1554449499,
0.0716342628,
0.3530494869,
0.3966598511,
0.2444902956,
0.0517967157,
0.4974089563,
-0.0412400514,
-0.6714116335,
-0.8762089014,
0.1927236468,
-1.1470240355,
-0.3467373848,
1.4641897678,
0.0220255628,
-0.1501991451,
-0.125630632,
-0.4493131936,
-0.0984702483,
-0.580632925,
0.6440888643,
0.5312449932,
-0.0944447666,
-0.2039074004,
-0.3162760437,
0.0874352902,
0.2384242862,
-0.8717938662,
-0.1975138932,
0.7984987497,
-0.1231611446,
0.5597066283,
0.6901023388,
-0.0226175655,
0.1481256783,
-0.1701834351,
0.1241753474,
-0.1955009401,
-0.5452891588,
-0.4744250774,
0.5723642707,
0.2498642504,
0.1693753898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00795v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00795v2
|
Executing Natural Language-Described Algorithms with Large Language Models: An Investigation
| 2024-02-23T05:31:36 | 2024-03-14T14:25:13 |
Xin Zheng, Qiming Zhu, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Executing computer programs described in natural language has long been a
pursuit of computer science. With the advent of enhanced natural language
understanding capabilities exhibited by large language models (LLMs), the path
toward this goal has been illuminated. In this paper, we seek to examine the
capacity of present-day LLMs to comprehend and execute algorithms outlined in
natural language. We established an algorithm test set sourced from
Introduction to Algorithm, a well-known textbook that contains many
representative widely-used algorithms. To systematically assess LLMs' code
execution abilities, we selected 30 algorithms, generated 300 random-sampled
instances in total, and evaluated whether popular LLMs can understand and
execute these algorithms. Our findings reveal that LLMs, notably GPT-4, can
effectively execute programs described in natural language, as long as no heavy
numeric computation is involved. We believe our findings contribute to
evaluating LLMs' code execution abilities and would encourage further
investigation and application for the computation power of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3026280403,
-1.0378215313,
0.9829996228,
0.3374609351,
-0.290358007,
0.1553896219,
-0.497001946,
-0.632478714,
-0.1511261463,
0.7503561378,
-0.486030966,
-0.4977866709,
-0.6816800237,
0.4868457615,
-0.5743029118,
0.8453299999,
-0.2067725807,
0.1479101479,
-0.1667498946,
0.1690504402,
-0.6011520624,
-0.3662351668,
-0.4002029896,
-0.4598501921,
0.1873039305,
0.0984121785,
0.7348662019,
0.7037671804,
0.7371480465,
0.3786216974,
0.0550877564,
-0.1341311336,
-0.5900768638,
-0.0879177377,
0.0641756952,
-0.7113038301,
-0.1413885802,
0.1593063027,
0.9705454707,
0.7045610547,
-0.0513583645,
0.1008420289,
-0.0251776874,
0.5420315266,
-0.3019097745,
0.0844053179,
-0.7351872325,
0.0929192677,
-0.1047608033,
-0.3412709236,
-0.5104904771,
-0.6246217489,
0.1972353607,
-0.4631793797,
0.0761027709,
-0.0276942085,
0.4237104952,
0.0268152319,
-0.414706409,
-0.8490156531,
-0.853815496,
1.0045949221,
-0.7625723481,
0.1110438779,
0.1564078778,
0.4455748796,
-0.387532562,
-0.8180574775,
-0.6240973473,
-0.6635599732,
0.0214417502,
-0.4052446783,
-0.1595740765,
0.2413509488,
0.7409223318,
0.6588632464,
-0.6881952286,
0.2658494115,
-0.4497859776,
-0.0971015543,
0.3383602202,
0.2150031328,
0.4936529398,
-0.0743677169,
-0.1503217816,
0.3131328821,
-0.6022890806,
-0.3290813565,
0.3052449524,
0.2278826386,
-0.0998112336,
0.830327332,
-0.3339920044,
0.848718524,
-0.5944430232,
0.0359193385,
0.0125508029,
-0.3327548206,
-0.4921155572,
-0.0064081955,
0.5356578231,
0.1345078945,
0.6725811362,
-0.2289678305,
-0.3005243242,
0.134943828,
0.2514357865,
-0.8461685181,
0.0194691792,
-0.0444923081,
-0.2969721556,
-0.2098261118,
-0.097671546,
-0.6958204508,
-0.5881778598,
-0.6203452945,
0.5860896111,
-0.4153116643,
-0.0218967702,
0.163352564,
-0.1310328543,
0.7126780748,
0.1566586047,
-0.7502182722,
0.8080508113,
1.0660395622,
0.9675593972,
0.0092235887,
-0.2430276126,
-0.6726895571,
-0.0339998007,
-0.4053213298,
0.4932639003,
-0.7547290325,
-0.2322746664,
0.1784381717,
-0.2754262388,
-0.0440890528,
-0.4407681525,
0.4395624697,
-0.8321415782,
0.1460688114,
-0.30491063,
-0.8843462467,
-0.2860600352,
0.2151311636,
-0.5567854643,
0.7641160488,
-0.2114753127,
-0.5802825689,
-0.0264289994,
-1.0626260042,
-0.7899421453,
0.0915802568,
-0.2581153214,
-0.0158922151,
0.324821502,
0.1393832117,
0.5519523025,
-0.610752821,
-0.0511217676,
-0.2022865713,
-0.7708487511,
0.2827728689,
-0.7181532383,
0.8599321842,
0.0557853617,
-0.6270166039,
-0.1412147135,
-0.425139606,
0.0755402297,
0.4554983377,
-0.2028578967,
-0.1104291901,
0.038908869,
-0.3009528816,
-0.1464886963,
0.4013818204,
-0.4477367699,
0.5495176315,
-0.5496090651,
0.464309752,
0.7906045318,
-0.0999836177,
0.504101038,
-0.1561385691,
0.8080896735,
-0.8760259151,
0.0261860173,
-0.2417481989,
-0.5620936751,
-0.4943673313,
-0.2190717459,
0.1433031112,
0.4668954611,
-0.5719516873,
0.0675012618,
-0.3716664612,
-0.5077412128,
-0.2349446267,
0.370544076,
0.3654045165,
0.278185159,
0.1482519805,
-0.0572666489,
-0.4432164729,
-1.0360507965,
-0.4241172671,
-0.0693064108,
-0.1680492163,
0.3908663094,
0.5234995484,
-0.3562771678,
0.8311624527,
-0.6909983158,
0.1214766204,
-0.3397619426,
0.3326355815,
0.5577201247,
-0.0393906534,
0.3125552535,
-0.580458045,
-0.2501040101,
-0.0323307365,
-0.741392374,
-0.1891818047,
0.0213780161,
0.0810780674,
0.1931658834,
0.38666448,
-0.5216007829,
0.2385402173,
0.6685264707,
-0.0088587487,
0.800980866,
-0.5036423802,
0.0774319842,
-0.5603967905,
-0.0775411054,
0.0005107357,
-0.0964970738,
-0.7103311419,
0.2059909254,
0.0245597083,
-0.0285778493,
-0.2586432993,
0.3200843036,
-0.6415176988,
-0.5617157817,
-0.3279078603,
0.1404576004,
-0.2873546183,
0.2223209441,
-0.105119139,
0.8446615338,
0.5845891833,
-0.7256364822,
0.3516890109,
-0.1600305438,
-0.5598281026,
0.1450853795,
-0.7298334241,
0.5601845384,
-0.1068945453,
0.1083177105,
-0.8264536262,
-0.3373829722,
-0.0043628258,
-0.1213255599,
0.1588582695,
-0.1985574961,
-0.862074554,
-0.4124546349,
-0.2099879384,
0.221404925,
0.6184760928,
-0.5317522287,
0.6332170963,
0.2934031188,
-0.0772064775,
-0.2866164744,
-0.5413259864,
0.3678869605,
-0.1492741108,
-0.4400132,
0.0239090156,
-0.1212625951,
-0.3837837577,
-0.2472221255,
0.1758055538,
-0.0492926724,
0.2210723907,
0.1607967764,
0.1791735142,
-0.2674167454,
-0.0023567483,
-0.3628085256,
0.1314226091,
0.3394711018,
-0.1454252452,
0.7526743412,
-0.4354645908,
-0.6073869467,
-0.3627541959,
0.0957702696,
0.6468705535,
-0.2867704928,
0.5119476318,
0.4265153706,
-0.470498234,
-0.1558918655,
-0.4902570844,
-0.1296512485,
-0.5246171951,
0.4639211893,
-0.2904487848,
-0.911313653,
0.3519922793,
-0.0493076518,
0.2660820782,
0.3012627661,
0.8131197691,
0.0676508546,
0.8970079422,
0.4476871192,
-0.4267439842,
0.317243427,
-0.2020127624,
0.2956831157,
-0.5111515522,
0.0678656474,
-0.7074521184,
-0.2682846189,
-0.6989007592,
-0.6024558544,
0.1020094827,
-0.2175523192,
-0.2141484618,
0.259015739,
-0.4839709699,
0.7264899611,
0.5259598494,
-0.2054705173,
0.3424469829,
0.0147479409,
-0.0430190377,
0.2732305229,
-0.2861505151,
-0.8521701097,
1.1697340012,
0.5890489221,
0.7396889329,
0.1759102941,
0.683114171,
0.3605200648,
0.4937118888,
-0.7142233849,
0.6826653481,
0.0251144413,
-0.5553367734,
-0.3045274317,
-0.555539012,
-0.9741216898,
0.0122284014,
0.0954690129,
-0.794965446,
-0.5387259126,
-0.0503958538,
-0.120325461,
0.2426546216,
-1.0017377138,
0.8413703442,
-0.5334554315,
0.0334867761,
-0.4846122861,
-0.3410273194,
0.6427921057,
-0.0980680436,
0.3015031815,
0.0272258464,
-0.1068908945,
0.8526985645,
-0.0918749794,
0.7262583375,
-0.1932226419,
-0.2702214718,
0.3602653444,
0.1190839335,
0.5931363106,
-0.0574550182,
-0.2551479638,
0.20538719,
0.0538999923,
-0.430141449,
-0.7756298184,
0.7814618945,
-0.4918556213,
-0.5969938636,
-0.4840361178,
-0.4228923321,
-0.0445580482,
0.2493261248,
-0.1170627773,
0.6280688047,
-0.2649029791,
-0.0005384331,
0.437037468,
-0.2704500556,
0.5124843717,
0.5006594658,
-0.4128137231,
-0.1096783653,
0.7464496493,
-0.0031082595,
0.3237636387,
0.3693587184,
0.205037728,
-0.3687915206,
-1.0313234329,
-0.2154552788,
0.3043004572,
-0.6704470515,
0.0753353238,
-0.3249726892,
-0.095237717,
-0.1979820579,
-0.1385858059,
-0.0304544941,
-0.0696043819,
-0.1687873453,
0.0669774115,
0.4076573551,
1.3943184614,
0.4215442538,
0.2581750453,
-0.7446130514,
0.3537272811,
0.3404534757,
0.5674421787,
-0.1681963652,
-0.430024296,
-0.1449920982,
0.1294662356,
-0.1694312394,
-1.0050373077,
0.2058454603,
0.1128878966,
0.6325594783,
0.3084178865,
-0.1643384099,
0.5445192456,
-0.5618068576,
0.6029509902,
-0.1948833615,
-0.9035342336,
0.2664783001,
-0.5118765235,
0.493180424,
0.4225813746,
0.3428175747,
-0.46022892,
-0.3329497874,
-0.3205481768,
-0.1971272826,
0.5567710996,
0.354310751,
0.4572914541,
-0.0935171917,
0.518501997,
-0.0415886194,
0.2194450051,
-0.6008767486,
-0.0045822849,
0.3219058514,
-0.299998641,
-0.292075336,
-0.2611403167,
0.0801130533,
-0.0421675369,
0.3460485041,
-0.2591122091,
0.5549966693,
-0.0436569117,
-0.2048557699,
0.0912059024,
0.3410600126,
0.6565016508,
0.9448840022,
-0.2079158276,
0.3098897934,
0.226004526,
-0.5755226016,
-0.1740693003,
0.202670604,
0.0518658347,
-0.3153989017,
0.5767742991,
0.4918023944,
0.2643818557,
-0.963781476,
0.3485981524,
-0.2470012605,
-0.2142519653,
-0.3338662386,
0.1170501336,
0.1879668832,
0.0950775295,
0.4376264215,
-0.2699050605,
0.2199333757,
-0.6967642903,
0.2071129531,
0.7088147998,
-0.1736512631,
-0.213734284,
0.1435999423,
0.0298544001,
-0.5067631602,
0.7773773074,
-0.4248745143,
-0.8300660849,
0.7135329247,
0.6216897368,
0.7901987433,
0.1541355252,
-0.0272910837,
-0.0294070952,
0.6404847503,
-0.1098755971,
0.4031156301,
0.1782554686,
-0.5967648029,
-0.9763460159,
-0.7752172351,
-0.4548098147,
0.0777656212,
-0.2641881704,
0.1714453697,
-0.6156670451,
0.1046419442,
0.0682990998,
0.3823489249,
-0.7918021083,
-0.1224110723,
0.2269490957,
1.0335770845,
-0.6834505796,
0.6165486574,
0.6616892219,
0.0122202216,
-0.7167069316,
-0.0321614444,
0.0643066466,
-0.7898609042,
0.6369526386,
0.449220717,
-0.0241028927,
0.0708757862,
-0.5837997794,
-0.6166085601,
0.8607878089,
0.5029941201,
-0.4906284809,
0.1483559161,
0.3880499303,
0.5826019049,
-0.2736149728,
0.4832614064,
0.814653039,
0.6280248761,
-0.0377962925,
-1.1142011881,
0.0131272925,
0.0041362559,
-0.1864289045,
0.3427689672,
-0.0567102097,
0.625662148,
-0.1313442588,
-0.0983724222,
0.1102946699,
0.6998609304,
0.2627422512,
0.2385412008,
0.448420763,
0.3712573946,
0.9244269729,
0.0570762232,
1.5239111185,
-0.0824212879,
0.1572991163,
0.8884754181,
-0.4239083529,
0.8149899244,
0.3413190544,
-0.492187053,
0.4485130906,
0.3915314376,
-0.0198419988,
0.1529749036,
0.5725263357,
-0.3851383626,
-0.0271277968,
0.1081167683,
0.0604034774,
0.5676541924,
0.1566036046,
-0.3045048714,
-0.2826782167,
-0.1024458408,
-0.1076839268,
0.0472201295,
-0.4052459002,
0.6685057282,
0.0780669004,
-0.6827192307,
0.5778650045,
0.1748090833,
0.5901790857,
-0.4887448847,
-0.2928766608,
0.26460132,
-0.0482428186,
0.0420760661,
-0.8970621824,
0.2327112854,
0.2556814551,
0.0826367363,
0.0352274962,
0.7541951537,
0.076563932,
-0.5678442121,
0.0683236048,
0.245642975,
0.3946815729,
-0.2842228413,
-0.5447295308,
0.230478853,
-0.0634020865,
-0.0860917792,
0.2387228161,
0.3218002319,
0.020524988,
0.7565104961,
0.6986250281,
0.0818592906,
0.3514410257,
0.0228073932,
0.7412367463,
-0.6086764932,
-0.2388675213,
-1.1890100241,
0.0052822614,
-0.0630961061,
0.1099955961,
0.7903296947,
0.7347365618,
0.5056518316,
0.0114606405,
0.8640083075,
-0.0326145627,
0.2595017552,
-0.7352955937,
0.2825701535,
-0.0447104685,
0.4323604703,
-0.2066316456,
-0.9136492014,
-0.3878207207,
0.5229367018,
-0.8684220314,
0.3333669901,
0.5203995705,
0.8173449039,
0.0794427767,
0.435624212,
0.0971305221,
0.2339669317,
0.5003198385,
0.5656338334,
0.7834724188,
-0.0427098498,
0.4229947627,
-0.1338421106,
-0.4822293222,
-0.1364325136,
-1.1473455429,
-0.9753258228,
-0.0719751418,
-0.0270769466,
0.0614104234,
0.0157175399,
0.9854331613,
0.3558798432,
-0.5953738689,
-0.3110621274,
-0.3965394497,
0.2647325099,
-0.1174498424,
-0.181428194,
0.3546099067,
-0.3800730407,
-0.8473541141,
0.5481446981,
0.1790409982,
-0.1010555327,
-0.4461911023,
-0.3141746223,
-0.1812443733,
0.1012619138,
0.5350666046,
0.2882354856,
-0.6683151722,
-0.3163573444,
0.2403106838,
-0.0193365272,
-0.1599171162,
1.0587223768,
-0.6192961931,
0.4556736052,
0.5744349957,
0.9895971417,
0.2677206397,
-0.0194722656,
0.8284053206,
-0.4285266697,
-0.3751364648,
0.269549489,
0.3267888427,
0.2201808989,
-0.1525717974,
0.3567240536,
0.0544957258,
-0.7238928676,
-0.7249857783,
0.1292984635,
-0.8005988598,
-0.2331554592,
1.3764030933,
0.2053289264,
-0.1877342165,
-0.1864517033,
-0.3557598591,
0.1720559597,
-0.2009967268,
0.5549260974,
0.7130170465,
-0.190024972,
-0.0540206917,
-1.1040258408,
0.3971091211,
0.1766599417,
-0.7503632307,
0.1629408151,
0.4623415172,
0.2451336384,
-0.0086293239,
0.6277374029,
-0.1129839644,
0.0825630203,
-0.470797509,
0.0215945151,
-0.0367796347,
0.1121229455,
-0.6468425989,
0.2757173181,
0.3806543946,
0.0895370468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15105v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15105v2
|
A First Look at GPT Apps: Landscape and Vulnerability
| 2024-02-23T05:30:32 | 2024-05-23T17:30:02 |
Zejun Zhang, Li Zhang, Xin Yuan, Anlan Zhang, Mengwei Xu, Feng Qian
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Following OpenAI's introduction of GPTs, a surge in GPT apps has led to the
launch of dedicated LLM app stores. Nevertheless, given its debut, there is a
lack of sufficient understanding of this new ecosystem. To fill this gap, this
paper presents a first comprehensive longitudinal (5-month) study of the
evolution, landscape, and vulnerability of the emerging LLM app ecosystem,
focusing on two GPT app stores: \textit{GPTStore.AI} and the official
\textit{OpenAI GPT Store}. Specifically, we develop two automated tools and a
TriLevel configuration extraction strategy to efficiently gather metadata (\ie
names, creators, descriptions, \etc) and user feedback for all GPT apps across
these two stores, as well as configurations (\ie system prompts, knowledge
files, and APIs) for the top 10,000 popular apps. Our extensive analysis
reveals: (1) the user enthusiasm for GPT apps consistently rises, whereas
creator interest plateaus within three months of GPTs' launch; (2) nearly 90\%
system prompts can be easily accessed due to widespread failure to secure GPT
app configurations, leading to considerable plagiarism and duplication among
apps. Our findings highlight the necessity of enhancing the LLM app ecosystem
by the app stores, creators, and users.
|
[
-0.5706049204,
-0.4337340593,
0.4872307181,
0.028497614,
-0.0999270752,
0.2717095315,
0.2876724601,
-0.3823769987,
0.0695811585,
0.5023843646,
-0.6909063458,
-0.6320183873,
-0.4142307043,
-0.1818066537,
-0.1682654023,
1.536236763,
-0.2237239629,
-0.7400338054,
0.1723187715,
-0.2273606509,
-0.7863841653,
-0.2729787827,
-0.5524801016,
0.0348027386,
0.53049016,
0.3618083894,
0.6038401127,
0.1918784827,
0.515889287,
0.2419524342,
0.0693032444,
-0.1592852324,
-0.4983714819,
0.1727335304,
0.0975352302,
-0.1475302577,
-0.5361284018,
0.1224360988,
0.2942651212,
0.0016988144,
0.0047488147,
0.377468437,
0.338996321,
0.7127837539,
-0.6936476231,
0.096540302,
-0.5639262795,
0.0115423556,
-0.3644174635,
-0.248859942,
-0.124459371,
-0.0944938362,
0.2141717076,
-0.6295886636,
0.0925372466,
-0.0453862846,
0.653275609,
0.0648504645,
-0.6428092718,
-0.2970834374,
-0.8373504281,
0.3668735027,
0.0813588575,
-0.0655792803,
0.0033605883,
0.4348949194,
-0.3109719157,
-0.7664654851,
-0.2596755624,
-0.4273658097,
0.0719852149,
0.1795838326,
-0.5150365233,
-0.321154207,
-0.0393410064,
0.6579839587,
-0.7238456011,
0.0660533682,
-0.1115795001,
-0.2380433381,
0.4663519859,
0.3053744137,
0.6213517785,
-0.027399268,
-0.8346223831,
-0.0646837726,
-1.0402603149,
0.1231443137,
0.3834128678,
-0.0515144132,
-0.2892915308,
0.6698995829,
0.1452712566,
0.2609843612,
-0.1971691102,
0.0245371573,
0.0002970677,
-0.452698797,
-0.2625481188,
0.0085347453,
0.7919260859,
0.3966892362,
-0.0674623922,
-0.1261269301,
-0.4096180797,
-0.0402154773,
0.488928616,
-0.1861111075,
-0.3493170738,
0.3333277106,
-0.3099227548,
-0.428381443,
0.0302808583,
-0.5304017663,
-0.8115028739,
0.1485189348,
0.3865565956,
-0.204816401,
-0.4052242339,
-0.1649677008,
-0.0585669763,
0.4015711844,
0.2384345233,
-0.8187645674,
0.2294325978,
1.137008667,
1.128334403,
-0.3948307335,
-0.3902630806,
-0.0269453321,
0.2295094281,
-0.1082419828,
0.6419190168,
0.0629306883,
-0.735820055,
-0.1136491746,
-0.2603503168,
0.1162102893,
-0.4475829303,
0.3257817924,
-0.6632649899,
-0.0519631542,
-0.2661451399,
-0.0609268919,
0.1302072853,
0.6652411819,
-0.8275803924,
0.9401835203,
0.351878345,
-0.8170297146,
0.5469309092,
-0.8937397003,
-0.225566715,
0.3784037232,
0.0505643226,
-0.0727219209,
0.1360284686,
0.5810161233,
0.1540051848,
-0.1040649563,
-0.0830120593,
-0.044670511,
-0.2168567926,
-0.0187111273,
-0.3136749864,
0.9003657103,
0.3206593394,
-0.30774647,
-0.1459739953,
-0.3229836226,
-0.281838119,
0.0670459345,
-0.1030993313,
-0.4464267194,
-0.2431627661,
-0.063505888,
-0.0499425046,
0.3142481148,
-0.4164144695,
0.5636011958,
0.0496111996,
0.6754042506,
0.8350397348,
0.4360696971,
0.460723877,
-0.211641565,
0.7327398062,
0.2102266848,
0.7637487054,
-0.5161822438,
-0.6017549038,
-0.1202344671,
-0.0331679992,
-0.0203196891,
0.6616139412,
-0.5272753239,
0.0227281079,
-0.588670671,
-0.5516751409,
-0.1280482709,
0.0120939193,
0.1969989985,
0.4136635065,
-0.1270887554,
-0.414264828,
-0.0622921325,
-0.7821676135,
-0.4223279357,
-0.5125312209,
-0.0761462897,
0.482863009,
0.5668869019,
-0.5279621482,
1.1212086678,
-0.5243765712,
-0.2909953594,
-0.135600239,
0.0099631157,
0.247626394,
0.1043068543,
0.700422883,
-0.6624526978,
-0.4766788781,
0.2964490652,
-0.4261189103,
-0.0016409031,
-0.0169137232,
-0.1175200939,
0.0639830083,
0.107502088,
-0.7667042017,
0.1313553452,
0.5525227785,
-0.383274734,
0.6933410168,
-0.0096855052,
0.0096633378,
-1.080630064,
0.1059841588,
0.0395147391,
0.1923231184,
-0.6497895718,
0.1449846923,
-0.0569098257,
-0.3661393225,
-0.317661047,
0.5343199968,
-0.5251095295,
-0.3117939234,
0.2203441411,
0.1285808533,
-0.2683465481,
-0.0888293311,
-0.4548553228,
1.1312447786,
0.3649149835,
-0.447157383,
0.1443611979,
0.1821644306,
-0.411942333,
0.3670774102,
-0.5054251552,
0.146245569,
0.1469351649,
0.2056603283,
-1.2155072689,
-0.3217079043,
0.5403706431,
-0.3142822981,
0.0819894746,
-0.247638002,
-0.2908962965,
-0.4022746384,
-0.5084041357,
0.0265031923,
0.3238342404,
-0.5473691821,
0.4414411187,
0.6931556463,
-0.4346604347,
-0.4700654149,
-0.4958932698,
0.5830487013,
-0.5718436241,
-0.7310094237,
0.0497236438,
0.2009042054,
-0.3254046142,
-0.1528895348,
-0.1648159772,
0.072462678,
0.3353640437,
0.3908648491,
0.2879420221,
-0.272895664,
-0.0964943469,
-0.1503159106,
-0.6178514957,
0.032306578,
-0.4060788453,
0.1787007004,
-0.4108489156,
-0.4148057699,
-0.0827953592,
0.1862804741,
0.6459267735,
-0.1972778141,
0.4053607583,
0.5110421777,
-0.0841725618,
0.0806665793,
-0.3864879608,
0.1562287509,
-0.4839911163,
0.124852851,
-0.3647420406,
-0.8556742668,
0.6442411542,
-0.2998467386,
0.2945544422,
0.5700820088,
0.3914940059,
0.1270493418,
0.6979166269,
0.6454664469,
-0.4836584032,
0.4908462167,
-0.2087095082,
0.4033682942,
-0.7542788982,
-0.3882082999,
-0.0969577655,
-0.5099966526,
-0.7572726607,
0.0807912201,
0.8851196766,
-0.113873072,
-0.4922146499,
0.2333330512,
-0.5350393653,
0.6855853796,
0.5099220872,
0.1413003057,
0.3941085339,
0.1491075754,
0.2665828168,
0.0126891565,
-0.378323406,
-0.6243658662,
1.2190861702,
0.5706129074,
0.6700856686,
0.4618076086,
0.8306224346,
0.429823935,
0.648632288,
-0.6977085471,
0.2900316417,
-0.1717159599,
-0.3976952434,
-0.2578074038,
-0.016182594,
-0.8446304202,
-0.0614666604,
0.2903708518,
-0.7131531239,
0.1474160105,
0.15658696,
-0.6249939799,
0.2833859026,
-0.9353273511,
0.8429669738,
-0.4996751845,
-0.3294200003,
0.3305062652,
-0.612656951,
0.5870766044,
-0.0611708239,
0.1417959929,
0.0459399521,
-0.2955664396,
0.2532881796,
-0.442007035,
0.6071350574,
-0.3748627901,
-0.2905800939,
0.384549588,
0.3884601891,
0.5973880291,
0.1673319489,
0.3235749304,
0.0606146678,
-0.1068044454,
-0.1741861552,
-0.398999095,
0.7309874296,
-0.7430730462,
-0.4310067296,
-0.4779403806,
-0.3022559285,
-0.2480930537,
0.2546335757,
0.4162253141,
-0.082631126,
-0.5536082983,
-0.0121344971,
0.7223215103,
-0.0791629702,
0.49636814,
0.2015670985,
-0.0120551689,
-0.3780549169,
0.5699623823,
-0.0513119362,
-0.0836421773,
0.0759514496,
0.3535380661,
-0.2732292414,
-0.6651704907,
-0.4080660045,
-0.3165349364,
-0.2827855945,
-0.0844246522,
-0.2623784542,
-0.1340073645,
-0.1628467888,
-0.1127262339,
-0.2431825399,
0.0579696037,
-0.0794205815,
-0.0982159674,
0.3932907879,
0.9750252962,
0.0085232938,
0.6296530962,
-0.8384816051,
0.159360081,
0.3377762437,
0.328507185,
-0.1275715679,
-0.0021202061,
-0.0063284426,
-0.0573494583,
-0.4726723433,
-0.8479225636,
0.2496316284,
0.2283457965,
0.3858487308,
0.4946900904,
-0.085478656,
0.4303421676,
-0.1676149666,
1.3577679396,
0.1303489953,
-0.5417279005,
0.7053024173,
-0.6510686874,
0.1841982901,
0.6089926362,
0.3550874889,
-0.5507044196,
0.0529087633,
-0.3256872892,
-1.0965536833,
0.5719537139,
0.0830097347,
0.4538327754,
0.19266361,
0.6117900014,
0.4405438006,
0.0764036477,
-0.7484933734,
-0.2766334414,
-0.1344320178,
0.0879575238,
-0.2856970131,
-0.3939541578,
-0.435344696,
-0.1396343112,
0.2414846718,
0.1033976302,
0.1294886917,
-0.0273734443,
-0.1764370054,
0.1661928743,
0.2764488757,
0.3100766838,
0.4605621994,
-0.0308632702,
0.2479036897,
-0.0032132398,
-1.1258453131,
0.2044467181,
-0.2525736094,
-0.3217677474,
-0.3864378035,
0.4847850204,
0.932374537,
0.3399322331,
-0.2955981195,
0.5566672683,
0.0640366077,
-0.06142883,
-0.3596943915,
0.0851456374,
-0.1104067713,
0.4051141739,
0.3576360941,
-0.2797908783,
0.1671894342,
-0.6750407815,
0.1530688703,
0.3243677914,
-0.2464954406,
-0.261808455,
0.4771539569,
0.0431555919,
-0.042353414,
0.8213570118,
-0.0672295168,
-0.2300886512,
0.5127292275,
0.6395561695,
1.4843819141,
-0.118557699,
0.5449559689,
-0.0774108544,
0.7030791044,
0.0419042222,
0.190628022,
-0.2548649013,
-0.4694285691,
0.2829503715,
-0.336735487,
-0.5081012845,
0.2044165581,
-0.4771366417,
0.2079369277,
-0.4753498733,
-0.3186013997,
-0.2635961473,
0.1445585191,
-0.3985317051,
-0.3079472184,
0.0300840586,
0.9103470445,
-0.9402851462,
0.2830083072,
0.8751930594,
-0.1235678792,
-0.5040484071,
0.3477030694,
0.2920293808,
-0.983923018,
0.2294800431,
0.0566082448,
-0.0498675294,
0.0169916004,
-0.4460804164,
-0.5661554337,
1.5036367178,
0.1832816005,
-0.5878271461,
0.2985958159,
0.4113885164,
0.5698683858,
-0.339569211,
0.1687982976,
0.7505771518,
0.5239041448,
-0.0276476704,
-0.4714018106,
-0.1275290847,
-0.314553827,
0.1903715432,
0.3409304917,
-0.4347005486,
0.8780495524,
-0.3559829593,
-0.3664101064,
-0.0881229937,
-0.1673702896,
0.1855044216,
0.8310213685,
0.3260718584,
0.6284053922,
0.4768508375,
-0.153806746,
1.1734311581,
-0.475276649,
0.3271008134,
0.8148258924,
-0.2394789606,
0.8219741583,
0.4072715342,
-0.4303348064,
0.2294058651,
1.0877468586,
0.0193595458,
0.569051981,
-0.1528180391,
-0.5918033123,
0.3384581506,
0.202101782,
-0.5133203268,
0.1586700827,
0.2393394858,
-0.2682311833,
-0.4756773412,
-0.0324583091,
-0.0473740473,
-0.6507516503,
-0.5013964176,
0.9567955732,
0.1162601486,
-0.3533788323,
-0.0210532229,
-0.2094139159,
0.3365926445,
-0.6190149784,
0.3783351779,
-0.5519728065,
-0.0806078911,
-0.2040773183,
-1.1521906853,
0.2349477559,
0.1567708999,
0.0589136779,
-0.2847637534,
1.0049082041,
0.1773591042,
0.1596509963,
0.135646373,
0.5730372071,
0.0434116162,
-0.5778701901,
-0.4967807531,
-0.0236022156,
-0.3178168535,
-0.4663958251,
0.4812709689,
0.5194981694,
-0.3573415279,
0.4187194109,
0.614855051,
-0.1355765611,
0.1512209028,
-0.2609896362,
0.9941089749,
-0.5177920461,
-0.6298449636,
-1.0617772341,
0.6530128121,
0.0521132238,
-0.637891829,
0.6386517286,
0.6568431258,
0.3633285463,
-0.1183288991,
0.8207147121,
-0.1479510069,
-0.1475036442,
-0.1633099318,
0.8187711239,
-0.4693185389,
0.6601207852,
-0.0834489614,
-1.0494203568,
-0.2237370908,
-0.2189330012,
-0.3623112738,
-0.1021677703,
0.2798767984,
0.6899918318,
-0.2824710608,
0.0250837337,
-0.1003209725,
0.1327852607,
0.1619559526,
0.6700417399,
1.0068563223,
-0.4033442438,
0.4768261909,
-0.1572138518,
-0.5655708909,
-0.2329559624,
-0.9464831352,
-0.2928618491,
-0.4599732459,
-0.0267029516,
-0.12189316,
0.1483824551,
0.1338551939,
0.1823367476,
-0.6767293215,
0.0220883321,
-0.2965003252,
0.0996755287,
-0.0656401441,
-0.1881845891,
0.2294392884,
0.0776916742,
-0.007173826,
0.2544178963,
0.5063042641,
-0.0250062384,
-0.4022466838,
-0.1655612439,
0.5409825444,
-0.4208966196,
0.66343683,
0.6213585734,
-0.4583749771,
-0.2524181604,
0.0182021987,
-0.2018810511,
0.0810599849,
0.9361321926,
-0.5417193174,
0.3125366867,
0.3005633056,
0.3791100085,
0.2651237249,
-0.0457691476,
0.4465726018,
-0.6959904432,
-0.1761868447,
-0.0457760207,
-0.0867076963,
-0.025956044,
-0.4762997627,
0.5346705914,
0.1177328974,
-0.4902818501,
-0.8980095983,
0.2263958603,
-0.8279237151,
0.0425040051,
0.8587529659,
-0.1132812798,
-0.1163316518,
-0.1879620701,
-0.367798835,
-0.0338839665,
-0.1735188812,
0.9825103879,
0.7045808434,
-0.2537655532,
-0.1544867903,
-0.8496595025,
0.306114316,
-0.2191075981,
-0.7400380969,
0.0598758236,
0.2383917868,
0.5009768009,
0.1291451156,
0.7282642126,
-0.4803573489,
0.0859761983,
0.3714841008,
-0.2694413662,
-0.1518207788,
-0.381401509,
-0.549172461,
0.466024071,
0.1840729713,
-0.3743587732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15537v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15537v2
|
Evaluating the Performance of ChatGPT for Spam Email Detection
| 2024-02-23T04:52:08 | 2024-06-19T14:49:09 |
Shijing Si, Yuwei Wu, Le Tang, Yugui Zhang, Jedrek Wosik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Email continues to be a pivotal and extensively utilized communication medium
within professional and commercial domains. Nonetheless, the prevalence of spam
emails poses a significant challenge for users, disrupting their daily routines
and diminishing productivity. Consequently, accurately identifying and
filtering spam based on content has become crucial for cybersecurity. Recent
advancements in natural language processing, particularly with large language
models like ChatGPT, have shown remarkable performance in tasks such as
question answering and text generation. However, its potential in spam
identification remains underexplored. To fill in the gap, this study attempts
to evaluate ChatGPT's capabilities for spam identification in both English and
Chinese email datasets. We employ ChatGPT for spam email detection using
in-context learning, which requires a prompt instruction and a few
demonstrations. We also investigate how the number of demonstrations in the
prompt affects the performance of ChatGPT. For comparison, we also implement
five popular benchmark methods, including naive Bayes, support vector machines
(SVM), logistic regression (LR), feedforward dense neural networks (DNN), and
BERT classifiers. Through extensive experiments, the performance of ChatGPT is
significantly worse than deep supervised learning methods in the large English
dataset, while it presents superior performance on the low-resourced Chinese
dataset.
|
[
-0.3337272704,
-1.1722842455,
-0.068547599,
0.4623722434,
-0.2925325334,
0.2086177617,
-0.4103803933,
-0.4058704376,
-0.4203242064,
0.2574301958,
-0.4917263687,
-0.4811570346,
-0.8386419415,
0.2391502857,
-0.5976341963,
1.0529593229,
0.2522593439,
-0.1311646551,
0.1425458342,
0.1421680897,
-0.7829263806,
-0.3540048599,
-1.0983909369,
-0.3235686123,
0.3219703138,
0.3968116343,
0.2834831774,
0.1207930371,
0.5369260311,
0.3793974519,
0.0068539334,
0.2905139029,
-0.6578666568,
0.0602115914,
0.346945256,
-0.3180114925,
0.0608438328,
0.1254104227,
0.7346497178,
0.2858563662,
-0.1716251522,
0.0035836489,
0.4666342139,
0.4304740131,
-0.348629415,
0.2210693061,
-0.8039370775,
-0.0317437276,
-0.1112066209,
-0.3732719123,
-0.5289878845,
-0.3673465252,
0.5523649454,
-0.3463227749,
0.3675661683,
0.2818322182,
0.7100348473,
-0.1686915755,
-0.2778674066,
-0.4825627804,
-0.5072544813,
0.5043962002,
-0.4914061725,
0.1632469147,
0.1875240654,
0.4932709336,
-0.5123820901,
-0.5917984843,
-0.2501405478,
-0.3561893702,
-0.2738926113,
0.305850178,
-0.229762122,
-0.1016996056,
0.4686102569,
0.3484754264,
-1.1578770876,
0.1437874734,
-0.3109071851,
-0.2835964262,
0.3606958687,
0.0720514506,
0.4820159674,
0.0812301114,
-0.4053801,
-0.0731245652,
-0.4432561994,
0.216458559,
0.3259175718,
0.3335139453,
-0.0029372398,
0.1482986808,
-0.1563238651,
0.3398582637,
0.0088666985,
-0.0386964828,
-0.1143850833,
0.2598552108,
-0.5001409054,
-0.0444245636,
0.993909359,
-0.0097519234,
0.1324508488,
-0.1927546412,
-0.1957981437,
-0.0408215038,
0.1408999413,
-1.1533356905,
-0.4345751703,
0.0475255065,
-0.3944353759,
-0.0953238979,
0.267716676,
-0.5673267245,
-0.6018080115,
0.1001102999,
0.4960786998,
-0.6232405305,
-0.2703938484,
0.1885361969,
-0.3115144074,
0.2080530524,
0.535838902,
-0.4761917591,
0.6017814875,
0.9813091755,
0.7370081544,
-0.427837044,
-0.3894292116,
-0.6700118184,
-0.4939916134,
-0.1976286173,
0.8494128585,
-0.722319603,
-0.0454703122,
-0.0389761478,
0.1400560141,
-0.5454227328,
-0.8305335641,
0.3082531393,
-0.6471476555,
0.5762984157,
-0.0313956924,
-0.6390348077,
-0.2531893849,
0.5855225325,
-0.581499815,
1.2499197721,
0.1989139318,
-0.7242717147,
0.5554283857,
-0.5826199651,
-0.4976795614,
0.4514283836,
0.2520257533,
-0.5466983914,
-0.114997074,
-0.0277070571,
0.7488645911,
-0.3923267424,
0.1751226336,
-0.2048776895,
-0.7744499445,
0.6354645491,
-0.9304141402,
0.6376287341,
0.0667805225,
-0.573217392,
-0.2863025069,
-0.5691820383,
-0.1958398819,
0.0685969964,
-0.2294938266,
-0.0331041664,
-0.1925357729,
0.082169205,
0.230716899,
-0.2287453264,
-0.4090195894,
-0.003678778,
-0.4068511724,
0.1374896914,
0.6786814928,
0.1623541564,
0.0674832985,
-0.2509019077,
0.3215460479,
0.0855916366,
0.1065804586,
-0.2835296988,
-0.7565326691,
-0.4863311946,
-0.419423908,
0.3428641856,
0.7152346969,
-0.5754554868,
0.2616122663,
-0.3510710895,
-0.3752139807,
-0.2492993027,
0.1847785562,
0.364530623,
0.2176672667,
0.1195948273,
-0.2583956122,
-0.1015282571,
-0.6843457222,
-0.467687279,
-0.1416271627,
-0.2904962897,
0.4271953702,
0.5550500154,
0.1441976726,
0.5785723329,
-0.1914891452,
-0.115076296,
-0.3183540404,
0.2434997559,
0.2098359615,
0.2588673234,
0.3626866341,
-0.7323254943,
-0.9318076968,
0.0201163832,
-0.2658441067,
-0.1055819243,
0.0099246325,
0.0025917392,
0.112062484,
-0.2558586895,
-0.5530563593,
0.4617049694,
0.2032804787,
-0.3553884625,
0.3632859588,
-0.0301646888,
0.497038424,
-0.7184783816,
0.0754191801,
0.3294802904,
-0.2495803237,
-0.9821067452,
-0.4616779387,
0.1451064199,
-0.3093775213,
-0.5380009413,
0.5870822668,
-0.3469483554,
0.0858495235,
-0.4399424195,
0.1890827864,
-0.1719894707,
0.5252326727,
0.2084941417,
0.8072826862,
0.5311835408,
-0.592433095,
0.3533098102,
-0.1461388618,
-0.5126683116,
0.6010802388,
-0.6306589246,
0.0144477366,
0.1645999402,
0.4149364531,
-1.2580064535,
-0.072548978,
0.8878317475,
-0.6682971716,
0.3370823562,
-0.4661367834,
-0.7952371836,
-0.1693849415,
-0.2028927207,
0.0859609023,
0.699503839,
-0.6270021796,
0.2605380118,
-0.0354662947,
0.2072652876,
-0.6055159569,
-0.3679772317,
-0.0649693087,
-0.458286047,
-0.6479215622,
-0.0439521857,
0.0745994598,
0.0036772378,
-0.3636960089,
-0.1722854674,
-0.1628986299,
0.3630605638,
0.2422205061,
0.0828948468,
-0.1365692765,
0.054053437,
-0.3782612681,
-0.0602168702,
0.1643109918,
-0.0918781236,
0.561376214,
-0.0641287565,
-0.4123993516,
-0.4104082286,
0.2088893354,
0.2757581174,
-0.023575956,
0.9229277968,
0.9838478565,
-0.4319150746,
-0.5703415275,
-0.6341211796,
-0.376272589,
-0.4576843679,
0.2822760344,
-0.0291167255,
-0.6675620675,
0.3105529845,
-0.0548459888,
-0.0703167096,
0.0473250709,
0.2924669683,
0.0805217698,
0.8648536205,
0.3373638391,
-0.3646239042,
0.5093242526,
-0.1874891222,
0.3582478166,
-0.4508473277,
-0.1804882437,
-0.5288610458,
-0.0879985988,
-0.4463467598,
-0.2825826406,
0.032972198,
-0.2239629328,
-0.2701498866,
0.3861595988,
-0.5124664903,
0.4065549374,
0.472389251,
0.3305353224,
-0.0709174052,
0.0442246124,
0.1158206239,
0.2447223067,
-0.9484055638,
-0.6330926418,
0.9054290652,
0.3142633438,
0.4616206586,
-0.0154596129,
0.2079355121,
0.4231383502,
0.6127533913,
-0.4154910147,
0.643496573,
-0.1380187869,
-0.3543171287,
-0.1213274524,
-0.3264504373,
-1.2641478777,
0.5774147511,
-0.1673381627,
-0.9167220592,
-0.5515907407,
0.0101548601,
-0.0497523248,
0.3141082525,
-0.8594490886,
1.1112340689,
-0.0315283015,
-0.3777889311,
0.0315579623,
-0.4533010423,
0.2518773079,
0.1094091237,
0.0037674657,
-0.3633704782,
0.1393871605,
0.6517643332,
-0.0238158703,
1.0492146015,
-0.1705230623,
0.1283935457,
0.1961678714,
0.0055547752,
0.6670877337,
0.2334711999,
0.1932678968,
0.0372474119,
-0.0939928889,
-0.3443553448,
-0.5856313109,
0.6170074344,
-0.4210953712,
-0.5498481393,
-0.4474876821,
-0.2924261391,
-0.0409584716,
0.0929513574,
0.1727152914,
0.4201865494,
-0.315343976,
0.3164964616,
0.8237560391,
-0.3405282795,
0.3777827621,
0.7485328913,
0.0913289711,
-0.0310288798,
1.0236244202,
0.0703251883,
0.0148782814,
0.4801974297,
0.2591454983,
-0.4012814164,
-0.5107275844,
-0.4966124296,
-0.0249334257,
-0.4915891886,
-0.1167714596,
-0.5958184004,
-0.4352618456,
-0.2947443724,
0.2532914281,
-0.0513176098,
0.1471554786,
-0.1618768722,
0.4232626557,
0.1503080428,
0.5607348084,
0.5064011812,
0.3954335153,
-0.619305253,
0.0890366063,
0.098394759,
0.4513323903,
-0.0784390494,
-0.676809907,
-0.3150968254,
0.0701756477,
-0.318058461,
-0.7806690931,
0.3678565025,
0.1479975283,
0.6819531322,
0.4724747241,
0.0763411075,
0.5913530588,
-0.2229034305,
0.8964497447,
-0.453555733,
-0.4481001496,
0.4202202857,
-0.1791191697,
0.0712804869,
0.0527860261,
0.4205413163,
-0.8163884282,
-0.4682010114,
-0.814347744,
-0.3615602255,
0.6568555236,
0.5199692845,
0.0437341668,
-0.0214319881,
0.088733159,
0.4191550314,
0.2564377785,
-0.679089725,
-0.2385529727,
0.1474154592,
0.1944322139,
-0.1887809038,
-0.1922085583,
0.1230946556,
0.1567116976,
0.8604923487,
0.1225454211,
0.338917762,
-0.1961532533,
-0.3409378529,
0.3992091119,
0.3739836514,
0.529314816,
0.3797363937,
0.1147024184,
-0.1068925932,
0.3029766679,
-0.549787879,
-0.0527794361,
0.1002765149,
-0.003949842,
0.226149559,
0.3565570116,
0.739305675,
0.142212227,
-0.6903882027,
0.8455423117,
-0.2249500006,
-0.1612785161,
-0.283259958,
0.2115135044,
-0.3270801604,
0.2956919968,
0.444237411,
-0.1807080358,
0.3438849151,
-0.1305241436,
0.075247176,
0.7970348597,
-0.2695996165,
-0.2268233746,
0.2388118207,
0.068653211,
-0.4369592369,
0.7325514555,
0.049928721,
-0.7862095237,
0.7550923228,
0.5823130608,
1.0012513399,
-0.1468949914,
0.2113432586,
0.2157466263,
0.4427827001,
-0.2472697049,
-0.2682126462,
-0.2391742915,
-0.7475010157,
-0.1463463604,
-0.0135186641,
-0.401124537,
0.4770272374,
-0.2768450379,
0.3187161088,
-0.0843204632,
0.0166795179,
-0.0623907186,
0.3371184468,
-0.8092859983,
0.158109203,
0.2224446088,
0.8473325968,
-0.9797668457,
0.5867427588,
0.5122388005,
0.1414938867,
-0.5585870743,
0.017101977,
0.2661169171,
-0.5976734161,
0.5078943372,
0.7622531652,
-0.0033511745,
-0.274651289,
-0.4138714075,
-0.1317420602,
1.0072771311,
0.2557767928,
-0.1543706656,
0.5779841542,
0.3227959573,
0.6784933805,
-0.1883163154,
0.8269230723,
0.5105398297,
0.3347572386,
0.0504165106,
-0.8356613517,
-0.0959168375,
-0.5027837753,
-0.0098983422,
0.2286592424,
-0.7526459694,
0.5467198491,
0.6152232289,
-0.551702559,
-0.1896759123,
0.2507394254,
0.1460291296,
0.3690249026,
0.316614002,
0.2844565511,
0.5608792305,
-0.3090589345,
0.7081698775,
-0.2356988788,
0.1668118984,
0.5467615128,
-0.1588683128,
0.6198645234,
0.1278217286,
-0.1662209928,
0.1757813096,
0.9717639685,
-0.08392784,
0.2802296281,
0.462474525,
-0.6129644513,
0.0662716106,
0.2202944756,
-0.2553118765,
0.0465630777,
0.4328162968,
-0.210960716,
-0.1845429689,
0.1145577356,
0.103535153,
-0.1892303228,
-0.1555164903,
0.9612217546,
-0.3910298645,
-0.7502976656,
0.5579126477,
-0.1824911237,
0.7306239009,
-0.5224508047,
-0.1478167474,
-0.2597444057,
0.2664228976,
-0.0460968465,
-0.6786445379,
-0.0686407909,
0.1102400422,
0.387683928,
-0.2110077888,
1.175494194,
-0.4923703969,
-0.1475770473,
0.0812741816,
0.2616326511,
0.5969913006,
-0.4414696991,
-0.9331519604,
-0.0266547184,
-0.3471074998,
-0.4779856205,
0.5487553477,
0.6941885352,
0.1172715053,
1.049469471,
0.5798130631,
-0.0434330329,
0.0375987105,
-0.1428538412,
0.7921152711,
-0.1390808076,
-0.3711029291,
-1.0594052076,
0.3471572101,
-0.4661515653,
-0.1417573243,
0.9371445775,
0.9241964221,
0.9175408483,
-0.1671249717,
0.8232317567,
-0.0551262163,
0.564445436,
-0.3326414526,
0.5135887861,
-0.1931115091,
0.6624501944,
-0.3314731419,
-0.8197495937,
-0.2919052541,
0.4862969816,
-0.3620457053,
0.189738363,
0.6509345174,
0.9611537457,
-0.2143500894,
0.1364594251,
0.4869043827,
-0.1744787693,
0.3271880448,
0.5617735386,
1.099288702,
-0.600785017,
0.7135677934,
-0.4937819242,
-0.2103517056,
-0.3163056076,
-0.8314635754,
-1.5380373001,
-0.4149359465,
-0.3757840991,
-0.3268617988,
0.3324911892,
0.8711898923,
0.7627156973,
-0.7627913952,
-0.1472094655,
0.1726015061,
-0.0576159731,
-0.4174258709,
-0.2402016371,
0.2918010652,
-0.3587792218,
-0.7770006657,
0.1603238285,
0.358333081,
-0.0781769827,
0.0074438308,
-0.020229375,
0.0824455768,
-0.0586851239,
0.6245346069,
0.3351210356,
-0.6365846395,
-0.4281677008,
0.0469121486,
-0.3198435903,
0.0969650894,
0.7308541536,
-0.6857875586,
0.067814447,
0.2999299169,
0.8213817477,
0.4077872038,
0.2044776529,
0.373957485,
-0.6528413296,
0.0030717957,
0.14985165,
0.15513134,
0.1643618047,
-0.3532265723,
0.4570474029,
0.235986039,
-0.732059896,
-0.6045719385,
-0.4389919937,
-0.6891509295,
-0.0805562884,
1.1044011116,
-0.3115401566,
-0.0624630153,
-0.4105660617,
-0.6155849695,
-0.0501220338,
-0.5794049501,
0.7909693718,
0.758133173,
-0.0106921969,
-0.568531692,
-0.6592482328,
0.4543741047,
0.1666860133,
-0.7101361752,
0.1280863285,
0.3900464773,
0.5419157147,
-0.5825989246,
0.7432531714,
0.2456690669,
0.469496578,
-0.1973573118,
-0.2983027101,
0.1135594025,
-0.2135798782,
-0.2230157554,
0.2566253543,
-0.1723620743,
-0.4016633332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15089v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15089v1
|
AttributionBench: How Hard is Automatic Attribution Evaluation?
| 2024-02-23T04:23:33 | 2024-02-23T04:23:33 |
Yifei Li, Xiang Yue, Zeyi Liao, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Modern generative search engines enhance the reliability of large language
model (LLM) responses by providing cited evidence. However, evaluating the
answer's attribution, i.e., whether every claim within the generated responses
is fully supported by its cited evidence, remains an open problem. This
verification, traditionally dependent on costly human evaluation, underscores
the urgent need for automatic attribution evaluation methods. To bridge the gap
in the absence of standardized benchmarks for these methods, we present
AttributionBench, a comprehensive benchmark compiled from various existing
attribution datasets. Our extensive experiments on AttributionBench reveal the
challenges of automatic attribution evaluation, even for state-of-the-art LLMs.
Specifically, our findings show that even a fine-tuned GPT-3.5 only achieves
around 80% macro-F1 under a binary classification formulation. A detailed
analysis of more than 300 error cases indicates that a majority of failures
stem from the model's inability to process nuanced information, and the
discrepancy between the information the model has access to and that human
annotators do.
|
[
-0.2194819003,
-0.5987229347,
0.8538889885,
0.2958334684,
-0.0672942996,
-0.0230367072,
-0.2138343155,
-0.5489887595,
-0.3332199454,
0.0305060409,
-0.5782416463,
-0.2587319613,
-0.6502129436,
0.2411579043,
-0.6293212175,
0.7664923668,
-0.2619475722,
-0.1744174957,
-0.4641871452,
-0.1099032834,
-0.1299284101,
-0.4069201648,
-0.8731104732,
-0.5170608759,
0.6562341452,
0.3539122045,
0.560507834,
0.6071442962,
0.5854205489,
0.3356188834,
0.1196651459,
-0.0799600407,
-0.2490388006,
-0.1931857765,
-0.2853604257,
-0.4657462835,
-0.4416541457,
0.2494949102,
0.5364613533,
0.5631565452,
-0.2447812259,
0.313685447,
0.0323766358,
0.608289659,
-0.898860991,
0.1818293035,
-0.8104519248,
-0.1048702225,
-0.2475489378,
0.0213397983,
-0.3537140191,
-0.8575909138,
-0.0209350977,
-0.362024039,
0.3636225462,
-0.0803282335,
0.6512999535,
0.4483994246,
-0.6282734871,
-0.4776987135,
-0.5822238326,
0.6646584868,
-0.4848532379,
0.0869775265,
0.4260447025,
0.3909537494,
0.0221905187,
-0.5863210559,
-0.4653331637,
-0.3833807707,
-0.0650884062,
-0.1827944219,
-0.3664562404,
-0.163370505,
0.1450300366,
0.3906262219,
-0.5071686506,
0.1673215479,
-0.1086046323,
-0.264193207,
0.7144619823,
0.1194921881,
0.0285220947,
-0.4503400922,
-0.2209196091,
-0.2749506533,
-0.762935698,
-0.2859553397,
0.6739106178,
-0.0166105926,
0.1452537477,
0.5372787714,
0.0723031387,
0.5347999334,
-0.1090827808,
0.4111198783,
0.1547990888,
-0.3585094512,
-0.0261562131,
0.2317627817,
1.1152743101,
0.2847444713,
0.4826891422,
-0.2397645116,
-0.4454887509,
0.1462180018,
0.438503921,
-0.5546470881,
-0.2648790181,
0.0110918982,
-0.1190934852,
-0.6669421792,
0.1953105628,
-0.3709817529,
-0.365260601,
0.0460437723,
0.4660503268,
-0.0789577588,
-0.1508293599,
-0.127141282,
-0.0278968997,
0.2288717479,
0.441675365,
-0.5640892386,
0.3163674772,
0.5129744411,
0.9415488839,
-0.4421201348,
-0.1252004057,
-0.4436867237,
0.1210882366,
-0.3427227437,
1.0933227539,
-0.3453601003,
-0.2854295671,
-0.1713809818,
0.1402671188,
-0.0396104082,
-0.7385229468,
0.5878530741,
-0.4774120748,
0.0021763714,
-0.2913792729,
-0.5237236619,
0.0159443114,
0.2024944276,
-0.8840430975,
0.7591376305,
0.1939065158,
-0.4907663167,
0.419356823,
-0.7275630236,
-0.4181860983,
-0.0845385417,
-0.3108880818,
-0.4770452082,
0.2726679742,
0.1593898237,
0.1820341498,
-0.5767541528,
0.4563806057,
-0.4230992198,
-0.3312264979,
0.4543075562,
-0.8120923638,
1.0161188841,
0.0571051538,
-0.6005926132,
0.1244076118,
-0.8449824452,
0.0186603535,
0.3343060613,
-0.4964770973,
-0.1262839586,
0.0091063818,
0.2463922054,
-0.0085864803,
-0.0314808711,
-0.4995049238,
0.131228283,
-0.1897141039,
0.3769541681,
1.1157745123,
-0.3481898606,
0.2589950562,
-0.1401121914,
0.6938523054,
-0.4028044939,
-0.1612789184,
0.1771781445,
-0.2249332368,
-0.5176573396,
-0.027886454,
0.4543724954,
0.5585588813,
-0.3764132857,
0.5940480232,
-0.3810872436,
-0.7014506459,
-0.5221152306,
0.3145752549,
0.5520073771,
0.4527048469,
0.1778369248,
-0.5266567469,
-0.375145942,
-1.0586782694,
-0.5136298537,
-0.3572121859,
-0.3907952905,
0.2996332347,
0.6206191778,
-0.1068742201,
1.0133861303,
-0.4674895108,
-0.1986864358,
-0.0408280268,
0.7244623303,
-0.1712230146,
0.4153496027,
0.4108046889,
-0.5429347157,
-0.5732514858,
-0.3415149748,
-0.8969958425,
-0.3451604545,
0.1218469068,
0.2026717812,
0.320040077,
0.5779163241,
-0.5882924199,
0.2827982306,
0.4672982097,
-0.2438997775,
0.7939835787,
0.0159896649,
0.1373589486,
-0.505092144,
0.3358737528,
0.0014510987,
-0.4693641663,
-0.0724619627,
-0.0436357111,
0.2687232196,
-0.028752394,
-0.4639110267,
0.6573788524,
-0.4052995145,
-0.1762499958,
-0.2983129621,
0.0322307162,
-0.1252153069,
0.2423164099,
-0.2530462742,
0.9074123502,
0.1742627621,
-0.3125249445,
1.0426323414,
0.1180046797,
-0.5756679773,
0.5908080935,
-0.8421310186,
0.2730918229,
0.0646082759,
0.6816159487,
-1.0832904577,
-0.5450300574,
0.1031931639,
-0.3406688571,
0.2030687779,
-0.1314891726,
-0.8326932192,
-0.2933491766,
-0.3773363829,
0.5711450577,
0.217786938,
-0.4675194323,
0.47906968,
0.0166720431,
-0.270362854,
-0.3030817509,
-0.6490465999,
0.337972641,
-0.2871017456,
-0.6422109604,
0.344507426,
0.1359947771,
-0.3594692349,
0.1738620102,
-0.1494706571,
0.0103791403,
0.2559704781,
0.0366811343,
0.0260385107,
-0.1829038411,
0.1522191316,
-0.5644396544,
-0.3038925827,
0.4526072741,
0.2239048034,
0.3786830306,
-0.3948059678,
-0.7892022133,
-0.3093538582,
0.2215990275,
0.34996292,
0.0219158214,
0.5324549675,
0.4718854427,
-0.3226021826,
0.1722964495,
-0.7670277357,
-0.1221335977,
-0.4854905307,
0.2970094979,
-0.1367601901,
-0.4722705483,
0.5481866002,
0.1347728074,
-0.1715172082,
0.8579930067,
0.5061222911,
0.0620902255,
1.0449677706,
0.5686221719,
-0.214858979,
0.2823455334,
0.2227676511,
-0.0025841687,
-0.4084283113,
0.0785636306,
-0.5458999872,
-0.2054318637,
-0.4733385444,
-0.2156035602,
0.4060231149,
-0.2156624198,
-0.1928123832,
0.223166272,
-0.2479354888,
0.6274574995,
0.525105536,
0.0861207694,
0.5596473217,
0.0049428046,
0.357773751,
0.1433636248,
-0.4233783484,
-0.5506997705,
1.1669285297,
0.1854652762,
0.8839088678,
0.3491355181,
0.4917947352,
0.4603904188,
0.6058737636,
-0.7263367772,
0.4704252779,
-0.0319994166,
-0.9286282659,
-0.3240249157,
-0.518075645,
-0.6303233504,
-0.0226713791,
0.0611734726,
-0.7197064757,
0.057291653,
0.3696880043,
-0.4213742614,
0.091819793,
-0.8367469311,
1.100820899,
-0.3334081471,
-0.5803093314,
-0.1158659682,
-0.5600110292,
0.4352063537,
-0.4910852313,
0.1169296876,
-0.1782916486,
0.0866595507,
0.9323604107,
-0.3791792691,
0.7176173329,
-0.2436606139,
-0.4448254406,
0.3025302887,
0.0424904786,
0.8319095373,
-0.0612093583,
-0.1518415213,
-0.1325476766,
-0.2801252007,
-0.2214536667,
-0.6018785834,
0.6308578849,
-0.4834530056,
-0.3921840787,
-0.5227209926,
-0.2169916034,
-0.3577418327,
0.0749259964,
0.4033952057,
0.1650286913,
-0.4483023584,
0.2797880769,
0.4996596873,
-0.2863153815,
0.1559741944,
0.4732271135,
0.1214404926,
-0.1616084278,
0.9608582854,
-0.1542054117,
0.2457298338,
-0.2422786057,
0.1494880617,
-0.3544307053,
-0.2868417501,
-0.5341846943,
0.1266753972,
-0.997730732,
-0.3186315,
-0.4682100713,
-0.1185605973,
-0.2547497749,
-0.2743857801,
-0.6590232849,
-0.4199972749,
-0.0781211331,
-0.1634677351,
0.2581870854,
0.7318341732,
-0.1222583726,
0.3408704698,
-0.6638135314,
0.291567415,
0.4643225372,
0.5751204491,
-0.0120062083,
-0.4128653407,
-0.1190587506,
-0.202331394,
-0.4083448052,
-0.763672173,
-0.0379841253,
0.3489618599,
0.4060453773,
0.1997478753,
-0.1339455843,
0.7633674145,
-0.4525011182,
0.5839941502,
0.0901573896,
-0.8487581611,
0.5798143148,
-0.2980322242,
0.2954198122,
0.7102628946,
0.4301043451,
-0.2001390606,
-0.4443987012,
-0.8088181615,
-1.1708263159,
0.7636668682,
0.2175928652,
-0.0583034121,
0.1060911417,
0.278529346,
-0.0169648752,
0.0859528556,
-0.8393288255,
-0.0296105687,
0.0375337228,
-0.3658636808,
-0.3760394156,
-0.2086737454,
-0.2332033068,
-0.3468029201,
0.5809739828,
-0.2038129568,
0.3335332572,
-0.0397036225,
-0.5261971951,
-0.4840133786,
0.3018194437,
0.3468218446,
0.7558265328,
-0.3832516074,
0.2366631776,
0.147257179,
-0.0726012737,
0.4081437886,
0.3672926724,
0.1143425107,
-0.0090257106,
0.6514332891,
0.5370252728,
0.2371049821,
-0.673941493,
0.7729554176,
-0.0845905989,
-0.2731081545,
-0.581117928,
0.039630767,
0.1311901063,
0.0563297495,
0.553748548,
-0.2417227179,
0.2604606152,
-0.5694550872,
0.2862716317,
0.4727840126,
-0.290481478,
-0.1650956571,
0.7331737876,
0.1492485851,
0.1345643252,
0.7442475557,
-0.0569460988,
-0.5315161347,
0.6438389421,
0.2902984619,
1.1980278492,
-0.1728679836,
-0.0712775588,
0.2148806006,
0.3076609075,
-0.2838707268,
-0.2335598171,
0.0545691401,
-0.4623728096,
-0.5000832081,
-0.6388576627,
-0.5058938861,
0.0238071326,
-0.4911733866,
0.0028882443,
-0.29108271,
-0.1510703266,
0.1687023491,
-0.2654399574,
-0.6797343493,
0.1291033179,
0.1487144679,
0.7311084867,
-0.9961636066,
0.4523972869,
0.6566746235,
-0.334454596,
-0.5350696445,
-0.0925274715,
0.3772994578,
-0.9175274372,
0.7872501612,
0.3029036224,
-0.3269545436,
0.092618905,
-0.8025161624,
-0.6369042993,
0.8889197111,
0.6303038001,
-0.3401336968,
-0.2126777619,
0.1251545846,
0.2690216005,
-0.1467299759,
0.3448291421,
0.7451015711,
0.664221406,
0.0154480916,
-1.1834042072,
0.3257468641,
-0.1419357508,
-0.1857478619,
-0.0412328616,
-0.3403232694,
0.5755053759,
-0.0239785593,
-0.1560594141,
-0.2311748117,
0.3929344118,
0.0410813391,
0.036889758,
0.8346766233,
0.5223066807,
0.5314775109,
-0.2015457898,
1.0305349827,
0.1364371777,
0.4484055042,
1.1435365677,
-0.1289099455,
0.8027531505,
0.405233562,
-0.4903079271,
0.5075533986,
0.6371784806,
-0.3569114506,
0.3526046276,
0.4069903791,
-0.3158468008,
-0.2503135502,
0.0248993915,
-0.0559185036,
0.4007022977,
0.1476903111,
-0.4326145947,
-0.4259865582,
-0.1660991013,
-0.12579377,
-0.2231811583,
-0.0404548272,
0.9286838174,
0.119807303,
-0.6202403307,
0.7305516601,
0.0360138491,
0.6968324184,
-0.6633524895,
0.161203742,
-0.08527565,
0.3187613785,
-0.4930635095,
-0.649209857,
0.5126833916,
0.3823399544,
-0.0283021666,
-0.248454228,
0.7494983077,
-0.0813742355,
-0.5239141583,
0.146699667,
0.3959725201,
0.1912861317,
-0.6174346805,
-0.5810894966,
0.1243391484,
-0.0641784891,
-0.5701874495,
0.1169374809,
0.321070075,
-0.0335604288,
0.7770485282,
0.3680758178,
-0.020267494,
-0.0314290561,
-0.1184115335,
0.8128823042,
-0.7980256677,
-0.0041780039,
-1.0830298662,
0.3772974908,
-0.0566620305,
0.0763361529,
0.604660809,
0.4828380346,
0.7807987332,
0.0141889723,
1.0290023088,
-0.2338649333,
0.3125504255,
-0.4018613696,
0.6639426351,
-0.9185628891,
0.1865876019,
-0.3679018319,
-1.0476284027,
-0.3089755774,
0.7273551822,
-0.2456791848,
0.1492807865,
0.6696150303,
0.540107131,
-0.3104472756,
-0.1893709302,
-0.0861176401,
0.0655340925,
0.4877839386,
0.4637312293,
0.6416621804,
-0.3687164187,
0.9263411164,
0.0205343831,
-0.2989370525,
-0.4777767658,
-1.2294820547,
-0.3659658134,
-0.2474433929,
-0.4228643477,
-0.2240114063,
0.147299841,
0.8739953637,
0.2587712705,
-0.7446383238,
-0.2420485169,
-0.3504205942,
-0.118150115,
0.0192114059,
-0.2676222622,
0.3619589508,
-0.3767089248,
-0.5019751191,
0.3182388544,
-0.1164147779,
0.1275647283,
-0.4321343601,
0.1242690235,
0.0543431006,
-0.221415475,
0.4254099131,
0.2647968829,
-0.6243081093,
-0.3485552371,
-0.4212514162,
-0.3752280474,
0.1091179699,
0.8124816418,
-0.6429810524,
0.2652770877,
0.1793039441,
0.6462518573,
0.405248642,
0.148212567,
1.0372331142,
-0.6502300501,
-0.2179854065,
0.1714710444,
0.1486059427,
0.547563076,
-0.1157868728,
0.6286514997,
0.2951529026,
-0.6460600495,
-0.8716839552,
0.1920403242,
-0.6927229762,
-0.0817224234,
1.1793398857,
-0.0892307386,
-0.2474028617,
-0.0836313218,
0.1137790158,
0.2675607204,
-0.3251339793,
0.8446167111,
1.1675989628,
0.0304420069,
-0.0564629138,
-0.7743147016,
0.6752367616,
0.5268502831,
-0.6624694467,
0.5731027722,
0.6356850266,
0.40473333,
0.1473353207,
0.6839851737,
-0.1138929203,
0.3153785765,
-0.0919953957,
0.1131262034,
0.0457726195,
-0.1094405204,
-0.362685293,
-0.0088717751,
0.4020471871,
0.2881704569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15083v1
|
Hands-Free VR
| 2024-02-23T04:02:23 | 2024-02-23T04:02:23 |
Jorge Askur Vazquez Fernandez, Jae Joong Lee, Santiago Andrés Serrano Vacca, Alejandra Magana, Bedrich Benes, Voicu Popescu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The paper introduces Hands-Free VR, a voice-based natural-language interface
for VR. The user gives a command using their voice, the speech audio data is
converted to text using a speech-to-text deep learning model that is fine-tuned
for robustness to word phonetic similarity and to spoken English accents, and
the text is mapped to an executable VR command using a large language model
that is robust to natural language diversity. Hands-Free VR was evaluated in a
controlled within-subjects study (N = 22) that asked participants to find
specific objects and to place them in various configurations. In the control
condition participants used a conventional VR user interface to grab, carry,
and position the objects using the handheld controllers. In the experimental
condition participants used Hands-Free VR. The results confirm that: (1)
Hands-Free VR is robust to spoken English accents, as for 20 of our
participants English was not their first language, and to word phonetic
similarity, correctly transcribing the voice command 96.71% of the time; (2)
Hands-Free VR is robust to natural language diversity, correctly mapping the
transcribed command to an executable command in 97.83% of the time; (3)
Hands-Free VR had a significant efficiency advantage over the conventional VR
interface in terms of task completion time, total viewpoint translation, total
view direction rotation, and total left and right hand translations; (4)
Hands-Free VR received high user preference ratings in terms of ease of use,
intuitiveness, ergonomics, reliability, and desirability.
|
[
-0.400814414,
-0.6512281299,
0.4670903981,
0.1525926143,
-0.4255103171,
-0.0053963615,
-0.3486233354,
-0.511062026,
0.520583868,
0.5151435137,
-0.4081095159,
-0.5113499165,
-0.526763618,
0.019778477,
-0.1607064158,
0.5928882957,
0.0410294533,
-0.0310149994,
-0.6217216849,
-0.2800933719,
-0.5091763735,
-0.6944891214,
-0.2569384575,
-0.214296177,
0.2855692208,
0.5191361904,
1.0157622099,
0.4779984057,
0.3784577847,
0.1940262169,
0.0547603182,
0.2311105728,
-0.2087239921,
-0.1338235289,
0.1434919238,
-0.1931937039,
-0.5847934484,
-0.0928361416,
0.2926466465,
0.4249950647,
-0.3896798193,
0.0732576996,
0.2264418304,
0.5938161016,
-0.5240396261,
-0.1197529361,
-0.0419880524,
0.1300504059,
0.0254765432,
-0.0920893326,
-0.2534621954,
-0.0822590292,
0.2816037834,
-0.9560346007,
0.2009899169,
-0.1034157202,
0.5734437704,
0.5105724335,
-0.3842272758,
-0.1088553742,
-1.1255917549,
0.9064748883,
-0.5758100748,
0.9053478837,
0.5187312961,
0.2759663463,
-0.0737422556,
-0.278439343,
-0.9089118242,
-0.6288326383,
0.3344742358,
0.3088698685,
-0.2108027786,
0.4372501075,
0.2546651959,
0.4408570826,
-0.6143891215,
0.2394904941,
-0.3333549798,
-0.0188254472,
0.600150764,
0.023596691,
0.7607636452,
-0.1655314267,
-0.5109715462,
-0.3160617948,
-0.3878632188,
0.4640221894,
0.2433906794,
0.5237025619,
-0.7073602676,
0.8527358174,
-0.2691313624,
0.6183601618,
-0.1239150614,
-0.4777810574,
0.3224974573,
-0.2114270478,
-0.4078409374,
0.0878213868,
0.8677136898,
0.824221015,
0.1894972771,
-0.390016377,
0.1353656948,
-0.0910828412,
0.4446089566,
-0.6269629598,
0.1053357273,
0.3858846128,
-0.6419892311,
-0.1602698267,
-0.1623075008,
-0.5464448333,
-0.4382114112,
-0.6367954612,
0.2760121226,
-0.3304356635,
-0.8447153568,
0.1888691336,
-0.3031829596,
0.5052796602,
0.6553832293,
-0.841522336,
0.5865397453,
0.4591939747,
0.9588279724,
-0.7830640674,
-0.0394676514,
-0.5113613009,
0.0871755183,
-0.2456220388,
0.3748656213,
-0.3181775808,
-1.191305995,
-0.3399897218,
-0.1777449697,
0.3578175902,
-0.8193253279,
0.4785580933,
0.1775958538,
0.297544837,
-0.3221858144,
-0.3873429596,
-0.2516237199,
0.0520272553,
-0.6915796399,
1.087684989,
-0.0755584911,
-0.4381024241,
0.3930473626,
-0.5114381313,
-0.4143152237,
0.2925602198,
-0.1261193454,
-0.0437354147,
0.0245648064,
0.1262526512,
0.3644476235,
0.0350119546,
0.0387100466,
-0.2197584361,
-0.3702157438,
-0.1304816455,
-0.3607848585,
1.0128332376,
0.1847533286,
-0.5591403842,
-0.0374904424,
-0.6491793394,
-0.2453393936,
-0.3254071176,
-0.0962024927,
-0.4337088168,
0.2620138228,
0.078300111,
0.2109182924,
0.064819321,
-0.7487695217,
0.0455355234,
-0.3134455681,
-0.0423789658,
0.0454458818,
-0.1773237139,
0.8313385844,
-0.1174702793,
0.7190613151,
0.0774058253,
0.3163792193,
0.2793254554,
-0.8045829535,
-0.5732605457,
-0.5139250755,
-0.2841793597,
1.1192301512,
-1.0072307587,
0.4632968307,
-0.2284049392,
-0.3997275531,
-0.6956048608,
0.1502110213,
0.2546067238,
0.5274451971,
0.5212048888,
-0.4996296465,
-0.227954343,
-0.702888608,
-0.1395992935,
-0.2205650061,
-0.3761525154,
0.6117540598,
-0.0029647043,
-0.1086491346,
0.8805938363,
-0.1034621224,
-0.2920343578,
-0.210393101,
0.0647405908,
-0.2735145986,
0.3421127498,
0.4433234036,
-0.7286919951,
-0.2580617666,
0.2732848525,
-0.9546419382,
0.3069611192,
-0.1103414744,
0.328317821,
0.0670051947,
0.4624492526,
-0.8296815157,
0.7827237844,
0.3441024721,
0.0070711784,
0.2059357017,
-0.620367229,
0.1994992197,
-1.0632932186,
-0.0900739059,
-0.0683548823,
-0.2002312839,
-0.7868016958,
0.0889542922,
-0.1788842082,
-0.2753195763,
-0.8165618181,
0.6779439449,
-0.4145790935,
-0.0317710713,
-0.5120509267,
0.3505868614,
-0.011940822,
0.3954526186,
0.4874176979,
0.7329894304,
0.4868752956,
-0.764306128,
0.5065053105,
0.2547732592,
-0.3038273156,
0.6289079189,
-0.6182374358,
0.3748862743,
-0.2102394253,
-0.1948129982,
-0.9838926196,
0.1160696447,
0.147377789,
-0.6903204918,
-0.0695297569,
0.2116406113,
-0.1693504155,
-0.42001912,
-0.2208531946,
0.1551370472,
0.5306300521,
-0.3403600156,
0.9596735835,
0.3730773032,
-0.1253876537,
-0.5924576521,
-0.7846966386,
0.2171584219,
-0.2032062709,
-0.1904405355,
0.1837965995,
-0.2293883115,
-0.4492502809,
-0.0825658739,
-0.010961988,
-0.0833655745,
0.0490231998,
0.696256578,
0.218643263,
0.152529791,
-0.1582140923,
0.1621019393,
0.0315874368,
-0.0485899672,
0.1899906844,
0.0143520841,
0.1339140087,
-0.033847414,
-0.6794917583,
0.5253784657,
0.8776354194,
-0.267680794,
0.2700886428,
0.5707409382,
-0.3830397427,
0.0428186357,
-0.5544425845,
-0.0232327022,
-0.4582966566,
0.1513513476,
-0.2670708299,
-0.9495283365,
0.3573066592,
0.1989212781,
0.1973520964,
-0.2379733026,
0.5708563328,
-0.2029961199,
0.7177332044,
0.7828025222,
0.0711293146,
0.3274206817,
0.0993516818,
0.3300763071,
-0.5805379152,
-0.4089733362,
-0.3930014074,
-0.3573716283,
-0.5234886408,
-0.5866531134,
0.2939228714,
-0.2410565764,
0.0687723979,
0.4750163257,
-0.7642455697,
0.2077701092,
1.0544213057,
0.1978537887,
0.3128548861,
-0.0062861471,
-0.1694856882,
-0.2203196883,
-0.2000066936,
-0.4713374972,
0.9095722437,
0.1319900453,
0.4601772726,
0.00051387,
0.7669184208,
0.3889658153,
-0.0108442511,
-1.0527403355,
0.731174171,
-0.203353554,
-0.5153557658,
-0.4759609699,
-0.1787001044,
-0.5575985909,
-0.0083731478,
-0.4169393778,
-0.612367332,
0.3570632339,
0.1461909115,
-0.7925985456,
0.5664778948,
-0.9524973035,
0.3994348347,
-0.5889859796,
-0.4700421095,
-0.1546002179,
-0.7780963182,
-0.0367945172,
0.3202155232,
0.1478085667,
-0.1545497477,
0.1186449453,
0.6574896574,
-0.0876955837,
0.7343202233,
-0.6046103835,
0.037535429,
0.3550958633,
0.2945906222,
0.0698392168,
-0.1172151268,
0.0575694405,
0.4726938605,
-0.045673646,
-0.066791974,
-0.6032244563,
0.5652159452,
-0.9898123741,
-0.3510994613,
-0.1619098634,
-0.4902688265,
-0.1099800989,
0.5254259109,
0.3660898805,
0.2133809179,
-0.632089138,
0.2236327827,
0.5093640685,
-0.8189978004,
0.4999831021,
0.3909999728,
-0.3652419448,
-0.6054243445,
0.9467725158,
0.2340007126,
0.0520652533,
0.6744450331,
0.1938169748,
-0.3259671926,
-0.3280332088,
-0.5644796491,
0.0269899406,
-0.0015174008,
0.1760881245,
-0.7463882565,
0.1227575317,
-0.3239349425,
-0.3347853124,
-0.5255225301,
-0.5387547016,
-0.4691237807,
-0.6398589611,
0.3356973231,
0.6471169591,
0.0104090497,
0.402282238,
-0.3870672286,
1.1406503916,
0.7401310802,
0.247930333,
-0.1441849321,
-0.0673174039,
-0.099032633,
0.3187166154,
-0.2751579583,
-0.4476250112,
0.5187292099,
-0.1109788492,
0.4094581604,
0.4549450874,
0.2794852555,
0.5598029494,
-0.5672540665,
1.4674950838,
0.4441236556,
-0.8356229663,
0.3416714072,
-0.3901270628,
0.3343833089,
0.6149471402,
0.1377034038,
-0.4067274928,
-0.2807476819,
-0.5375222564,
-0.9759247303,
0.4014851153,
0.0790027976,
0.3749101758,
0.1026093811,
0.2100241184,
0.3425810337,
0.5072742105,
-0.5218370557,
-0.5095130205,
-0.6806340218,
-0.0462405719,
-0.1715341955,
-0.2833067477,
0.1014434844,
-0.8238088489,
0.2565590739,
0.3061851859,
0.5482910275,
0.2970811427,
0.1717089564,
0.0156011032,
0.1156977639,
0.8966134191,
0.3514511287,
-0.3567365706,
0.1171316355,
0.2293681502,
-0.7566452622,
0.0942656025,
-0.1099252403,
-0.1595024914,
0.2643500865,
-0.2535990775,
1.1263583899,
-0.0443430096,
-0.4907998443,
0.7429705262,
-0.2029418647,
-0.5560942292,
-0.4990339875,
-0.1485620886,
0.1081427261,
0.0280635096,
0.1497835666,
0.0153391548,
0.359909445,
0.0347057208,
0.0747510344,
0.6478831172,
-0.5825456381,
-0.2673554122,
1.1763439178,
0.5490843058,
-0.7322356105,
0.6510541439,
0.0351327732,
0.171527639,
0.2026464492,
0.2527405322,
1.4113022089,
-0.4887008369,
0.3973752558,
0.3198407292,
0.4992796183,
-0.1334656924,
0.4100945592,
-0.6365392208,
-0.7647050619,
-0.3475895822,
-0.1270016283,
-1.1171489954,
0.1109592915,
-1.0053721666,
0.3699771166,
-0.363607049,
-0.2989855409,
-0.475053519,
-0.3032108545,
-0.6465777755,
0.3132717907,
0.7104983926,
0.7936492562,
-0.6296198964,
0.729316473,
0.6339327693,
-0.1126994789,
-0.8697465062,
-0.1554732919,
-0.0252336394,
-0.4267650545,
0.21029073,
0.1472179592,
-0.6979960799,
-0.2227364182,
-0.566374898,
-0.5579535961,
0.9420682788,
0.5428993106,
-0.5086756945,
-0.2780514061,
0.334171325,
0.4894813299,
0.1658114791,
0.2891870737,
0.1714959741,
0.2292995602,
-0.2056883425,
-1.3257497549,
-0.3850473762,
-0.5017078519,
0.0667727143,
-0.028884707,
-0.6900938749,
0.3692443967,
-0.1911759973,
0.0707793832,
-0.1284216791,
0.9948821664,
-0.0015871212,
0.55962044,
0.4320093691,
0.6610691547,
0.8403844833,
-0.0235848557,
0.9699569941,
-0.1678563207,
-0.031797938,
0.8701332211,
-0.5424090624,
1.0415006876,
0.7383133769,
0.0040893964,
0.5315290689,
0.0152158346,
0.4643827081,
0.6896564364,
-0.0834638402,
-0.6303672194,
-0.2496092021,
0.0141872382,
-0.2389594913,
0.7557036281,
0.2030662447,
0.1182957888,
0.0749753118,
0.8383439183,
-0.0340879671,
0.0014586903,
-0.0676559284,
0.9173020124,
0.2491651475,
-0.4501037002,
0.3978654146,
-0.3144754767,
0.8995416164,
-0.53741467,
-0.1694027632,
-0.0733702704,
0.0434879772,
-0.1761085838,
-0.5501176119,
0.0580617227,
0.1220478639,
-0.2163707912,
-0.6010237932,
0.5810509324,
-0.4479829371,
-0.3598205447,
0.388744235,
0.563640058,
0.3315970004,
-0.0400338359,
-0.3980441391,
-0.2024522871,
0.0684268624,
-0.1864988953,
0.0530469641,
0.2461742908,
-0.019687498,
0.7207791805,
0.4570668042,
0.3123185635,
0.1232437119,
-0.2182697505,
0.4594338238,
-0.7502991557,
-0.7633115649,
-0.5679024458,
0.6766070127,
0.0788220614,
-0.4059353173,
0.9346884489,
0.738319993,
0.8905255795,
-0.2256171852,
1.0426863432,
0.0087578986,
1.00355196,
-0.147664234,
0.7228981256,
-0.7042950988,
-0.3106321692,
-0.4562120438,
-0.5153589845,
-0.4153572917,
0.7670585513,
-0.1839862764,
-0.1286366135,
0.3913690746,
0.5740269423,
-0.0960868895,
-0.0178564359,
0.5169320107,
-0.4777106345,
0.264534235,
0.1756756008,
0.4066835046,
-0.2567333281,
0.2222549021,
-0.6153765917,
-0.4053204656,
-0.158406347,
-0.9016469717,
-0.7083550692,
-0.4501887262,
-0.449976474,
-0.3101301789,
-0.1766686589,
1.1630088091,
0.7002266645,
-0.6721235514,
-0.7143192887,
-0.0613962226,
-0.1995945722,
-0.6108801365,
-0.2066016048,
0.0720804781,
0.4491975605,
-0.8713852763,
0.9403182268,
0.3429960608,
0.2089012712,
0.0469288975,
-0.4126372337,
0.2097852528,
-0.1687312275,
0.8220315576,
0.663105011,
-0.7265524864,
-0.2487089783,
0.604239583,
-0.1151825115,
0.1466805041,
0.6555525064,
-0.7746890187,
1.0791492462,
0.3218934834,
0.5326772332,
0.5911040902,
0.2075178325,
0.7690581083,
-0.7563294172,
0.6846559644,
0.1583858132,
-0.0799868554,
0.5962333083,
-0.3912938535,
0.0602688119,
0.0792163983,
-0.4433960915,
-0.8569708467,
-0.0696936399,
-1.7619187832,
0.1157823652,
1.3558579683,
0.3429543078,
-0.0585949533,
-0.2776908278,
-0.4265592992,
0.4406428337,
-0.472042352,
0.4924034178,
0.58033216,
-0.2998816371,
-0.3456677496,
-0.9425482154,
0.6040869951,
0.3219575882,
-0.4830719829,
0.0205648635,
0.4525927603,
0.2013812959,
0.189719215,
0.8225492239,
-0.2880167067,
0.2861868143,
-0.3449589908,
0.8403775692,
-0.4067665637,
-0.2291695327,
-0.4613218307,
0.1372960955,
0.102107197,
-0.7800789475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15082v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15082v2
|
PEMT: Multi-Task Correlation Guided Mixture-of-Experts Enables Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning
| 2024-02-23T03:59:18 | 2024-06-06T15:11:29 |
Zhisheng Lin, Han Fu, Chenghao Liu, Zhuo Li, Jianling Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) has emerged as an effective method for
adapting pre-trained language models to various tasks efficiently. Recently,
there has been a growing interest in transferring knowledge from one or
multiple tasks to the downstream target task to achieve performance
improvements. However, current approaches typically either train adapters on
individual tasks or distill shared knowledge from source tasks, failing to
fully exploit task-specific knowledge and the correlation between source and
target tasks. To overcome these limitations, we propose PEMT, a novel
parameter-efficient fine-tuning framework based on multi-task transfer
learning. PEMT extends the mixture-of-experts (MoE) framework to capture the
transferable knowledge as a weighted combination of adapters trained on source
tasks. These weights are determined by a gated unit, measuring the correlation
between the target and each source task using task description prompt vectors.
To fully exploit the task-specific knowledge, we also propose the Task Sparsity
Loss to improve the sparsity of the gated unit. We conduct experiments on a
broad range of tasks over 17 datasets. The experimental results demonstrate our
PEMT yields stable improvements over full fine-tuning, and state-of-the-art
PEFT and knowledge transferring methods on various tasks. The results highlight
the effectiveness of our method which is capable of sufficiently exploiting the
knowledge and correlation features across multiple tasks.
|
[
-0.4941420257,
-1.0253013372,
0.4978144467,
0.3227531016,
-0.2599986792,
0.1295290887,
-0.5087453127,
0.0343435891,
-0.1005827785,
0.5248673558,
-0.2914081216,
-0.1734873354,
-0.8866561055,
-0.215270564,
-0.2281625718,
1.0708912611,
-0.1597115993,
-0.274903208,
0.0585465021,
0.1188755408,
-0.6774300337,
-0.4038007259,
-0.7911060452,
-0.0783677101,
0.529491365,
0.5230446458,
0.0811434761,
0.5132164359,
0.5323969126,
0.2524659038,
0.2029899806,
0.7993577123,
-0.5683035851,
-0.0501380675,
-0.5411994457,
-0.244252637,
-0.5460157394,
-0.2163904011,
0.6083906293,
0.767011106,
-0.0655503422,
0.106721133,
0.5614811182,
0.6306327581,
-0.7759866118,
0.2844982147,
-0.9233232737,
-0.1634348184,
-0.2076674104,
-0.6546862125,
-0.3849489093,
0.094670862,
0.1125887185,
-0.7048012018,
0.1520829648,
0.0670686141,
0.5892236233,
0.5039829016,
-0.7050874233,
0.1396623105,
-0.6215911508,
1.0189999342,
-0.3393462002,
0.3742104471,
0.3645341694,
0.3045219183,
-0.2461737394,
-0.5605152249,
-0.3476201892,
0.0503508225,
-0.0408332534,
-0.0246207863,
0.1118778363,
-0.1055395454,
-0.3577844203,
0.0332890227,
-0.2487354428,
-0.2271915674,
-0.194472149,
-0.1574437916,
0.3552072346,
0.0325449258,
-0.029032236,
0.4700758457,
-0.5528539419,
-0.0669177994,
-0.4144468307,
0.0121922242,
0.0139189353,
0.4637239873,
-0.0458984263,
-0.0598246641,
-0.2401518226,
0.9585552812,
0.5974898934,
-0.3663388193,
0.0709602013,
-0.5905048251,
-0.0642869174,
-0.1519562602,
0.7872542739,
0.1606725156,
0.0513137281,
-0.4627923965,
0.1531157643,
-0.5314000249,
0.2351652682,
-0.7262486815,
-0.5104278922,
-0.3647014499,
-0.2539026141,
-0.148528412,
0.0093002068,
-0.5646206141,
-0.1235176995,
-0.4678425491,
0.7793313861,
-0.6915823817,
-0.3625521064,
0.2647369206,
0.0457469895,
0.0290491469,
0.5022422075,
-0.8563562036,
0.4069419503,
0.6904603243,
0.6429636478,
-0.5013259649,
-0.7099862099,
-0.8022102118,
0.4956203103,
-0.1349750608,
0.9516307712,
-0.5105124116,
-0.2224048823,
-0.6469572783,
0.0408535711,
-0.6791682243,
-0.3741750717,
0.4362067282,
-0.1963363886,
-0.1108947247,
-0.2084759772,
-0.3024676144,
-0.3803887665,
0.2585071921,
-0.201015681,
1.058830142,
0.0373231024,
-0.5048315525,
0.3711618781,
-0.5451641679,
-0.6489696503,
-0.2552743852,
-0.0349649936,
-0.3237462044,
0.0510901064,
0.3686320186,
0.8626577854,
-0.2627270818,
0.4073750079,
-0.375130713,
-0.4273039997,
0.139763236,
-0.4224195182,
0.3630480468,
0.2732138932,
-0.3679832518,
0.1175913513,
-0.674785614,
-0.1257219315,
-0.25646469,
-0.4567821622,
-0.5105836391,
-0.0929678082,
0.0372213274,
0.2042465955,
0.331910491,
-0.2760241926,
0.0810366645,
-0.0287979301,
0.3921495378,
0.7690859437,
0.0871841237,
0.5084286332,
-0.4765617847,
0.1027685106,
0.2247612327,
0.0520125814,
-0.0637979805,
-0.3318634629,
-0.4654735923,
-0.4678978324,
0.2459014207,
0.4272602797,
-0.6287204027,
0.6763262749,
-0.2055595666,
-0.5849312544,
-0.3414009511,
0.3663588166,
0.4000523686,
0.9864173532,
0.4585530758,
-0.2335193455,
-0.3358058929,
-0.9815900326,
-0.605142951,
0.1255648583,
0.1902646422,
0.2264257222,
0.1655734479,
0.1707107574,
0.7144005299,
-0.3898150325,
-0.4444442689,
0.0417552702,
0.3315519691,
0.1192716658,
0.9735671282,
0.5190706849,
-0.6426285505,
-0.9155545235,
0.4838772714,
-0.1570078731,
0.0063337851,
-0.311735183,
-0.5733913183,
-0.4079277515,
0.2183671147,
-0.196026966,
-0.28954193,
0.5734001994,
-0.4066248536,
0.270139426,
-0.35200876,
0.5106101036,
-1.3510223627,
0.1809454113,
0.0613805242,
-0.5009397864,
-0.5150077939,
-0.1654021591,
0.30582425,
0.1954245716,
-0.5117581487,
0.4319945574,
-0.2578602433,
0.4388872385,
-0.4312932193,
-0.2086161971,
0.0070554721,
0.8823900819,
-0.1540212184,
0.9138600826,
0.8902543187,
-0.7748484612,
-0.0016871833,
0.017650621,
0.1224834248,
0.9439857006,
-0.1864856631,
0.4120223224,
0.1909689009,
-0.0774894878,
-0.8880468607,
0.0764390081,
0.2113512307,
-0.2580416203,
0.4006204307,
-0.2097932994,
-0.5355100632,
0.1709609479,
-0.0646661595,
0.3353604674,
0.5225218534,
-0.1943223774,
0.82980299,
0.3328719437,
-0.125300765,
-0.3666110039,
-0.5207477808,
-0.1442689002,
-0.3780186474,
-0.3648479581,
0.7371248007,
-0.1076291725,
0.2967812419,
-0.0060080667,
-0.3618782759,
-0.6860607266,
0.2804031372,
0.0501071475,
-0.2060817182,
-0.0376956873,
-0.1030581743,
0.6592173576,
0.0500148609,
-0.1489814073,
-0.2956104279,
0.3689363301,
-0.0846643373,
-0.361176759,
-0.6487909555,
0.2712846398,
0.5668410659,
-0.3747225106,
0.8663548231,
1.0895037651,
-0.1743301004,
-0.2097053528,
-0.6582038403,
-0.2748292387,
-0.4555164278,
0.6347480416,
-0.7504661679,
-0.8766662478,
0.3298182786,
-0.6881634593,
0.0752318278,
0.4022626281,
0.5181375742,
0.0835892633,
0.9951122403,
0.7562043667,
-0.0431126766,
0.5979454517,
-0.004474835,
-0.0706714764,
-0.7571135163,
-0.2669945061,
-0.530566752,
-0.4602323174,
0.0759204179,
-0.5706598163,
0.394844085,
0.3695220053,
-0.3548583388,
0.4428525865,
-0.5594187379,
0.4480969906,
0.6181300282,
0.6781491041,
0.396066606,
-0.0041243359,
-0.0212881826,
0.1284662783,
-0.7568959594,
-0.1055701077,
1.2173219919,
0.0748614371,
0.5658736229,
-0.2533620894,
0.5562736392,
0.243891716,
-0.1029899195,
-0.4091841877,
0.5077565312,
-0.4738751352,
-0.3644000292,
-0.122657828,
-0.4173374772,
-0.7941043973,
0.2244459689,
-0.2122698426,
-0.5010749102,
0.2828651667,
0.349722594,
-0.4493952394,
0.5127458572,
-0.8277080655,
0.8057732582,
-0.3272609711,
-0.4396992326,
-0.5489586592,
-0.6663905382,
0.1770376712,
-0.6310589314,
0.1527221948,
-0.3140480518,
-0.2219254971,
0.8948173523,
-0.1612876803,
0.7679186463,
-0.275041461,
0.1387800574,
0.0082097724,
0.1398995668,
0.5788857937,
-0.2097542137,
-0.1627120525,
0.0777553767,
0.1142235324,
-0.5690159202,
-0.662507236,
0.914026916,
-0.8783323765,
-0.3083164692,
0.2764011919,
-0.980666995,
-0.5709913373,
0.3628665507,
-0.2043584585,
0.1665532887,
0.2268258929,
0.5140690804,
0.7241281867,
0.1175661907,
0.0935340375,
0.6464756131,
0.300568223,
-0.4123519361,
1.1522698402,
-0.0061657052,
0.0033079016,
0.7787548304,
0.2346903384,
-0.0480206572,
-0.7419878244,
-0.3192638457,
-0.0204687379,
-0.3022790849,
-0.2008893043,
-0.6113839149,
0.1655133665,
-0.2243881673,
-0.2394665331,
-0.6934059858,
-0.1348266155,
-0.2532490194,
0.3868255317,
0.4699816108,
0.2435801923,
0.1691645384,
0.5789073706,
-0.8135102391,
0.2231911719,
0.4644638896,
0.3986153901,
-0.159236446,
-0.7262163758,
-0.5312628746,
-0.0273168068,
-0.4557666779,
-0.8225767612,
0.2429346442,
0.5068747401,
0.8300355077,
0.2004683763,
0.2419320941,
1.1567299366,
-0.3578965962,
0.4750705659,
0.2324032038,
-1.057874918,
0.4372756183,
-0.3132228255,
-0.0584752038,
0.7856699228,
0.3068111539,
0.1518601477,
-0.2893363237,
-0.291767031,
-0.611156106,
0.7957244515,
0.0981556252,
-0.0926147625,
0.2943161428,
0.4136593938,
0.6854663491,
0.2585744262,
-0.1142494529,
-0.1546559632,
-0.0102044502,
-0.3735253513,
0.0403549001,
0.150669381,
-0.1578643471,
-0.6279906034,
0.6763664484,
-0.3011987507,
0.2320648134,
0.1787898093,
-0.2691928148,
-0.1887673438,
0.2259573489,
0.4002128541,
0.8039546609,
-0.177946806,
0.434613049,
0.509991169,
-0.2537268996,
0.0393140614,
0.270976007,
0.253531903,
-0.1659065932,
-0.1800937504,
0.7966076136,
0.5165393949,
-0.4366903603,
0.3653950095,
0.2643792331,
-0.4991946816,
0.23747316,
0.1901928782,
-0.0567503236,
0.3495683968,
0.5326478481,
0.6548168063,
0.1683183312,
-0.2803328931,
0.3785374165,
0.2891725004,
-0.2447510064,
-0.5300937891,
0.7901138663,
0.3447630107,
-0.0652081072,
-0.0712518096,
0.1487161964,
-0.1369755417,
0.3591087759,
0.4614222348,
0.5769299865,
-0.2875442505,
-0.1342617124,
0.0931981951,
0.0441219769,
-0.21577847,
0.191718787,
-0.3163090944,
-0.5334796906,
-0.8939372897,
-0.4928420484,
-0.362517029,
0.0147378352,
-0.5702371001,
0.3189642429,
-0.3155321181,
-0.1864734143,
-0.2212096006,
-0.1520000249,
-0.8204136491,
-0.0564965494,
-0.198690936,
0.6920458674,
-0.8010212183,
1.2176091671,
1.1328930855,
-0.1223548204,
-1.0070043802,
-0.0693800524,
-0.413782686,
-0.8561807871,
0.5101013184,
-0.2627626657,
-0.0031645298,
0.4061532319,
-0.1277251393,
-0.8057869673,
1.0579475164,
0.7426820397,
-0.6496878862,
0.0028499137,
-0.0541845337,
0.1987498701,
-0.1432655901,
0.1084410176,
0.4192547798,
0.5537874103,
-0.0381510668,
-1.4946093559,
0.2671943605,
-0.0924855322,
-0.1506248862,
0.3017864227,
-0.7912064195,
0.958951056,
0.3089868724,
0.3124120831,
-0.234496817,
0.5243481398,
0.2564000487,
0.2280797362,
0.6500569582,
0.3551141024,
0.5191307664,
0.0955736265,
0.6184787154,
-0.8130636811,
0.4902979434,
0.9377530217,
0.0876619071,
0.823259294,
0.7964240909,
-0.3672149181,
0.3250801563,
0.3792484105,
0.1750992984,
0.8240568638,
-0.232389912,
-0.0779315457,
-0.6504438519,
0.0307105929,
-0.3047561646,
0.3184920251,
0.2653805912,
-0.4164844453,
-0.3794365525,
0.2317098677,
-0.0692931786,
0.0500661209,
-0.5026189685,
0.7739089131,
0.0691678375,
-0.696244359,
0.6238386035,
-0.1005697027,
0.9216611981,
-0.6371526718,
-0.0685693324,
0.0832138136,
0.3763437569,
-0.1089119911,
-0.6348534822,
0.4464239776,
-0.401258409,
-0.1848217994,
-0.5296136737,
0.946359992,
-0.6611962914,
-0.2276930362,
-0.0670139939,
0.8264000416,
0.1669113934,
-0.633292377,
-0.8438775539,
-0.3359209597,
-0.0803068429,
-0.0499331169,
0.7676312923,
0.6069127917,
0.2350965589,
0.448076427,
0.6363484859,
0.2751419246,
0.2434914261,
-0.4767536819,
0.9557845592,
-0.3435477018,
-0.5056146383,
-0.7589219213,
0.4521350563,
0.1347219199,
-0.1735673547,
0.7942622304,
0.4601260424,
0.7569597363,
-0.2337542474,
0.7381241918,
-0.0436323695,
0.5802083015,
-0.3156671524,
0.6798490882,
-0.6248532534,
0.0979363546,
-0.1983466744,
-0.7945781946,
-0.2369941324,
0.3749279082,
-0.3334060311,
-0.0741811618,
0.6398513913,
0.5935354829,
-0.490119487,
-0.4493142366,
0.4527339339,
-0.0034106278,
0.1231524646,
0.8804780245,
0.3503763378,
-0.3707268238,
0.8896154761,
-0.6099501848,
-0.2248193026,
-0.2189860046,
-0.7199811339,
-0.8846486807,
-0.6892470717,
-0.4752083123,
0.2031200081,
0.4334785044,
0.8746586442,
1.3266851902,
-0.8687915206,
-0.1035577282,
-0.2973704934,
-0.1554447412,
-0.7930206656,
-0.2067631036,
0.5750051141,
-0.4556705952,
-0.8461110592,
0.5166230798,
0.1836205274,
-0.3591170907,
0.0977648795,
-0.2128453255,
-0.0471170582,
-0.2463579178,
0.5992885232,
-0.0057362099,
-0.6351715326,
-0.170286715,
-0.0620536543,
0.247561276,
-0.0175409541,
0.7182790637,
-0.8157327175,
0.3657087088,
0.50158602,
1.011326313,
0.3831965029,
0.0258276369,
0.6427821517,
-0.9304340482,
0.0102026481,
-0.0550879985,
0.3567597866,
-0.061843697,
-0.3242572248,
0.2072072774,
0.4406762421,
-0.7069826722,
-0.5964871645,
-0.2155246884,
-1.5190297365,
-0.3910921216,
0.9404616356,
-0.2936286628,
0.0017942258,
-0.3355101347,
-0.509341836,
0.4821447432,
-0.6584377885,
0.7931198478,
0.3409045339,
-0.3408254683,
-0.4529874623,
-0.2741574049,
0.180116564,
0.7151489258,
-0.8496034145,
-0.2527933419,
-0.1011766568,
0.5599524975,
-0.1138271019,
0.5090976357,
0.0629380792,
0.0727758855,
-0.2562046051,
-0.2034481019,
-0.6012044549,
-0.2769306898,
0.1746937037,
0.4372116029,
0.1725304872,
-0.5624879003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15080v1
|
Infusing Hierarchical Guidance into Prompt Tuning: A Parameter-Efficient Framework for Multi-level Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition
| 2024-02-23T03:53:39 | 2024-02-23T03:53:39 |
Haodong Zhao, Ruifang He, Mengnan Xiao, Jing Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-level implicit discourse relation recognition (MIDRR) aims at
identifying hierarchical discourse relations among arguments. Previous methods
achieve the promotion through fine-tuning PLMs. However, due to the data
scarcity and the task gap, the pre-trained feature space cannot be accurately
tuned to the task-specific space, which even aggravates the collapse of the
vanilla space. Besides, the comprehension of hierarchical semantics for MIDRR
makes the conversion much harder. In this paper, we propose a prompt-based
Parameter-Efficient Multi-level IDRR (PEMI) framework to solve the above
problems. First, we leverage parameter-efficient prompt tuning to drive the
inputted arguments to match the pre-trained space and realize the approximation
with few parameters. Furthermore, we propose a hierarchical label refining
(HLR) method for the prompt verbalizer to deeply integrate hierarchical
guidance into the prompt tuning. Finally, our model achieves comparable results
on PDTB 2.0 and 3.0 using about 0.1% trainable parameters compared with
baselines and the visualization demonstrates the effectiveness of our HLR
method.
|
[
-0.4166110754,
-0.558182776,
0.6621365547,
0.325463444,
-0.2910794914,
0.1810774356,
0.0126331616,
0.1430218667,
-0.5814737082,
0.0641487688,
-0.7164834738,
-0.5230286121,
-0.3906992674,
0.2214665264,
0.3533103466,
1.2906655073,
0.2829829156,
-0.0047997436,
-0.194631204,
0.0029412815,
-0.3983531594,
-0.3556853235,
-1.0470787287,
-0.2391327918,
0.7945328951,
0.710483551,
0.3908563852,
0.6976639628,
0.2135459185,
0.3034533262,
-0.5561714768,
0.4361728728,
-0.520206809,
0.173603192,
-0.1860205084,
0.1069204435,
-0.6647628546,
-0.0446564443,
0.8504749537,
0.5539492965,
0.1196901053,
0.1754118949,
0.4566501975,
0.3208345473,
-0.5449030399,
0.3453281224,
-0.6303415895,
-0.1076893285,
-0.2346639633,
-0.5737989545,
-0.4101324379,
-0.4019605219,
0.230547756,
-0.8877555132,
0.0007795788,
0.5343667269,
1.0274577141,
0.5198805928,
-0.5217586756,
-0.2211112976,
-0.5782020688,
0.7165905237,
-0.6090076566,
0.0385738574,
0.3312698305,
0.2706698775,
-0.378698051,
-0.5721303821,
-0.2937643826,
-0.1978392452,
-0.397369504,
0.0980067104,
-0.0563673452,
0.5055208206,
0.5223483443,
0.3311980665,
-0.3735924363,
0.1406369656,
0.1651563346,
-0.1529111862,
0.0025098892,
0.1917578876,
0.1556631774,
-0.3979352415,
-0.5549988747,
0.0652967915,
-0.715552032,
0.3456358612,
0.3826303184,
0.4902554154,
0.0003955112,
0.0552093312,
0.07147903,
0.6125419736,
0.6287001371,
-0.5272621512,
-0.0808106735,
-0.4810412824,
-0.1325266212,
0.1441963017,
0.7246796489,
0.0755453259,
0.09634047,
0.2138142437,
0.1825960577,
-0.3657130301,
-0.1333843917,
-1.0074107647,
-0.1084650531,
-0.1000818312,
-0.3236292601,
0.1528985202,
-0.1944864988,
-0.8076667786,
-0.3781613111,
-0.393399775,
0.0215176586,
-0.5965905786,
-0.0803233907,
-0.1387967318,
-0.0048701167,
0.3600519598,
0.4514700472,
-0.707701385,
0.2675022185,
0.661013484,
0.6499818563,
0.2415347993,
-0.0803873464,
-0.892611742,
0.5701654553,
-0.1168270558,
0.7552732229,
-0.6006831527,
-0.2649813592,
-0.2378163636,
-0.1429639459,
-0.1951792091,
-0.5324572921,
0.9685934782,
-0.0969842225,
0.1788189709,
-0.2941108346,
-0.2840735614,
0.1279588193,
0.331497401,
-0.3270482719,
1.1824789047,
-0.1217584535,
-0.7973230481,
0.4305004478,
-0.4820275605,
-0.3313159645,
0.1611441076,
-0.1030890718,
-0.6530391574,
-0.2324753404,
0.7407545447,
0.3612139225,
-0.3799752295,
0.5707566738,
-0.148390919,
-0.324467063,
-0.2884946167,
-0.3273345232,
0.5651531816,
0.0868691504,
-0.1318326145,
0.4033003747,
-0.8473091125,
-0.2269155681,
-0.5376808643,
-0.4008130729,
-0.6305391788,
-0.1038977578,
-0.3269378245,
0.3667034507,
0.1288725436,
-0.5890135765,
0.2056601793,
-0.5105630755,
0.262265265,
0.8034582734,
0.2812261283,
0.5630856752,
-0.2400493324,
0.4877830744,
0.2728621066,
0.2337484509,
-0.5165894032,
-0.5832224488,
-0.7126580477,
-0.6356144547,
0.4681886733,
0.4489882588,
-0.7464185953,
0.5091488361,
-0.096433118,
-0.235109672,
-0.755233109,
-0.2219846845,
0.7775735259,
1.0531023741,
0.4101353884,
0.6320940852,
-0.5768163204,
-1.0876642466,
-0.3309788406,
-0.3969233632,
0.0157233309,
0.4663798809,
0.2801549137,
0.1893990189,
0.9328703284,
-0.2549447119,
-0.6113114357,
0.0348796993,
0.5978381038,
0.3021238148,
0.6799739599,
0.5070932508,
-0.4434715509,
-0.797131598,
0.2097243071,
-0.3395706415,
-0.3712470233,
-0.1301094592,
-0.3562899828,
-0.2107836902,
0.5083951354,
-0.3383877575,
0.2464383096,
0.0093607707,
-0.3985369503,
0.1970419139,
-0.3068067729,
0.1304921657,
-1.085637331,
0.0069772755,
0.2426816523,
-0.2092801929,
-0.4793355763,
-0.3634572625,
0.1330603212,
-0.1841864884,
-0.2676805258,
0.5078986883,
-0.7461005449,
0.2589418888,
-0.1787954569,
-0.2334127426,
-0.0557135306,
0.8981298804,
-0.1030450836,
0.7476027608,
0.5508912802,
-0.5767608285,
-0.1726114154,
0.2610552013,
-0.0199889746,
0.8293876648,
-0.6864065528,
0.2408995181,
-0.4194971323,
0.2381753623,
-1.3734967709,
0.2027031332,
0.6473234892,
-0.2027172297,
0.4353660643,
-0.6146710515,
-0.6190784574,
-0.0387689136,
-0.2164298892,
0.4653277993,
0.434012264,
-0.6250028014,
0.8195367455,
0.2639895976,
-0.5887319446,
-0.6273322701,
-0.0554124378,
0.0196402762,
-0.3962775469,
-0.3508642912,
0.7792061567,
-0.1787942648,
0.1216397211,
-0.2839229405,
-0.1802498549,
0.0659332573,
-0.2080302238,
0.3600797951,
0.0410299711,
-0.1016652286,
-0.0536150374,
0.8199086189,
-0.2166563123,
-0.0047665844,
0.0370930284,
0.1540957391,
-0.2965222597,
0.1005352288,
-0.6934236288,
0.4672885537,
0.6577698588,
-0.0941246599,
0.3231226504,
0.3512684703,
-0.3086127639,
-0.1860882193,
-0.3965676725,
0.036061734,
-0.4809215069,
0.0123368772,
-0.8438253999,
-0.858027041,
0.3790342808,
-0.6357148886,
0.0686202869,
0.0949056447,
0.3442924321,
-0.1652969867,
1.3867865801,
0.3969902098,
0.0981404558,
0.3012193143,
-0.0329100229,
0.1135397255,
-1.0683686733,
-0.4090117812,
-0.7952247262,
-0.271992594,
-0.2578574419,
-0.0478333384,
0.6957073212,
0.0178562067,
-0.4273008108,
-0.0564255603,
-0.5040172935,
0.432790041,
0.487883538,
0.0172511209,
0.4638848603,
-0.0402143933,
-0.4423205554,
-0.5681888461,
-0.8251065612,
-0.5021472573,
0.1031691805,
0.4972889125,
0.5372576714,
-0.1668671668,
0.3392050564,
-0.1002759486,
0.238666743,
-0.7789620161,
0.7324386239,
-0.1956099123,
-0.1873799264,
-0.2100065798,
-0.3695688248,
-0.9003322124,
0.4430371225,
-0.1104634181,
-0.2262949795,
0.6190221906,
0.2025779337,
-0.632350564,
0.0989625379,
-0.542448163,
0.751344502,
-0.1392097324,
-0.4316427112,
0.1754221767,
-0.8630347848,
0.0642993525,
0.2717807293,
0.0886570588,
-0.3632022738,
-0.1932892352,
0.6103787422,
-0.5817303658,
0.8476868868,
-0.5298357606,
-0.20529975,
-0.213304162,
-0.2561872303,
0.3282641172,
0.287199378,
-0.0796580464,
-0.323168546,
-0.2148339301,
-0.1233060285,
-0.7820938826,
0.5753438473,
-0.5803896785,
-0.6940644979,
-0.5541357398,
-0.6238036752,
-0.3710131049,
0.1191292182,
0.2351715416,
0.4853645861,
-0.1449950635,
0.0062728324,
0.7153952718,
-0.1493223011,
0.5364813209,
0.6434093714,
0.1321861595,
-0.4002656043,
0.6693291068,
-0.0448290035,
-0.4104977846,
0.5427492857,
0.4186922014,
-0.5412483215,
-0.464867264,
-0.6953577995,
0.2659167945,
-0.357391417,
-0.5259202719,
-0.6010444164,
-0.0824015066,
-0.1824914068,
0.1058935374,
-0.0853685737,
-0.117917642,
-0.6071206927,
0.0853831246,
0.4016961455,
0.2897936106,
0.2006386518,
0.5843786001,
-0.4540751576,
0.5105761886,
0.3014610112,
0.1188135743,
-0.0260962993,
-0.7129256725,
0.0379557125,
-0.0962204933,
-0.2161347419,
-0.7478442192,
0.3143872619,
0.6215213537,
0.4247464836,
0.5166727901,
0.3437244296,
1.2984318733,
-0.7135602832,
0.4177259207,
0.092465736,
-1.000161171,
0.957105279,
-0.4377612174,
0.5484125018,
0.7977363467,
0.6760246754,
-0.0390779711,
-0.5282557607,
-0.2175560892,
-0.8842506409,
0.8597677946,
-0.0265744701,
-0.1043343171,
0.1360854506,
0.4117219448,
0.2660470605,
0.1319075823,
-0.520427227,
-0.2839569449,
-0.0447546057,
-0.1555882245,
0.4794157147,
-0.3401315808,
-0.0201567058,
-0.8825439811,
0.6641614437,
-0.2725381553,
-0.1887395978,
0.1718981415,
0.1189725175,
-0.2083034515,
0.5732747912,
0.1205407456,
0.5387477279,
-0.1762004644,
0.0473180041,
-0.0767779872,
-0.1735411286,
0.494746834,
0.3684751391,
-0.4035444856,
0.2527545691,
-0.144800216,
1.0268540382,
0.6314267516,
-0.2367098182,
0.5142613053,
-0.2681882083,
-0.1801012158,
0.0040797745,
-0.1635486335,
-0.096010752,
0.0917168111,
0.4871025383,
0.0528594814,
0.3302503526,
-0.4626561403,
-0.0063532074,
0.28040874,
-0.3374299407,
-0.0998364761,
0.5997776985,
0.2926039994,
-0.1932905316,
0.6644458175,
-0.2768332064,
-0.2930253744,
0.2995895743,
0.6123416424,
0.635455966,
-0.4413999319,
0.3535253406,
0.5934308171,
0.0955557823,
0.253911674,
0.3485218883,
-0.3224435747,
-0.3318895996,
-0.6608652472,
-0.5353139043,
-0.4754990935,
0.1981065124,
-0.7307070494,
0.2079720944,
-0.6675181985,
-0.2573403418,
0.047399044,
-0.0349948332,
-0.1057317704,
-0.0739483833,
-0.0293546692,
0.6691635847,
-0.4785251915,
0.8451952934,
0.9089208841,
-0.1655748785,
-0.8432508111,
0.0320195444,
-0.2931841612,
-0.2210734785,
0.6606748104,
0.0333098136,
-0.3653329313,
0.2709494531,
-0.4568088949,
-0.6035508513,
0.7606014013,
0.6670840383,
-0.7354575992,
-0.4228185713,
-0.0237867944,
0.5933840871,
-0.4244619012,
0.290399909,
0.6287997365,
0.736217618,
0.3888794482,
-0.8573661447,
0.1967572421,
-0.5008066893,
0.304446429,
0.1923625022,
-0.4723550677,
0.7873664498,
-0.0522525311,
-0.5506617427,
0.2679431736,
0.8468845487,
0.6662784815,
0.464772135,
0.6639896631,
0.4538390338,
0.7074865699,
-0.2495505959,
0.6496430635,
-0.2896578312,
-0.0279598199,
1.1821479797,
-0.3059900701,
0.4736404419,
0.4628753066,
0.2952028811,
0.6813725829,
0.7889301181,
0.1255135983,
0.695379436,
0.0574002974,
-0.1184087917,
-0.1119177565,
-0.5307894945,
-0.3235233724,
0.1468706429,
0.5624008179,
-0.1534480155,
-0.427798301,
0.1441196203,
0.24728553,
0.1721461117,
-0.6648164988,
1.1204112768,
0.1637219191,
-0.9237418175,
0.8638447523,
-0.0887294561,
0.7629272938,
-0.5701457262,
-0.3742722571,
-0.0464380495,
-0.0295799933,
-0.1663508564,
-0.4719235599,
-0.0015558375,
-0.0186187699,
-0.1362882853,
-0.5922990441,
0.7185652852,
-0.7656763792,
-0.2086600065,
0.2543520033,
0.7057071328,
-0.1428742558,
-0.0299251042,
-0.8050385714,
-0.3421091139,
-0.3540151119,
0.0589031875,
0.2707149684,
0.7483783364,
0.1478551179,
0.3439689875,
0.431965977,
0.0591194704,
-0.1278740466,
0.1964406371,
0.9509723783,
-0.405708164,
-0.7651641965,
-0.8748983741,
0.5777154565,
-0.1466345936,
-0.7238156796,
0.9152488708,
0.5108652115,
0.4604071975,
0.0351470746,
0.4469239712,
0.2852218151,
0.6970285177,
-0.4681538641,
0.4998686314,
-0.4656644166,
0.2181664407,
-0.4727397561,
-0.7485645413,
-0.2464688867,
0.4619247615,
-0.2209774405,
-0.0413974859,
0.7157714367,
0.8485111594,
-0.0824059695,
-0.0849025473,
0.1207913086,
0.2705546916,
-0.0647329539,
0.6177375317,
1.252125144,
-0.161836192,
0.6700594425,
-0.0916676372,
-0.4083593488,
0.090992786,
-1.0139501095,
-0.8804789186,
-0.5000293255,
-0.4843929708,
0.0713829696,
0.3443955183,
0.7418352365,
0.9531675577,
-0.5444760323,
-0.3016260862,
-0.0381815881,
0.2091756016,
-0.2130469382,
-0.2227440923,
0.3859265149,
-0.3920582831,
-0.885068357,
0.4784947038,
0.5521805286,
-0.1359006464,
0.0169063006,
-0.0408622921,
-0.3540512621,
-0.1232997254,
0.7460513115,
0.1321312785,
-0.648404479,
0.0061930879,
-0.1971711218,
0.0380540974,
0.4479086995,
1.0541940928,
-0.8820573092,
0.1500405669,
0.4926349819,
0.4667994678,
0.3110630512,
0.281983912,
0.6011217833,
-1.1616514921,
0.0242229924,
0.4775253534,
0.3780871332,
0.2641813159,
-0.5241388083,
0.1954006106,
-0.1440874338,
-0.6642355919,
-0.7735540271,
0.2320900857,
-1.0685639381,
-0.2852514982,
1.0156656504,
-0.2269715965,
-0.143909514,
-0.56249547,
-0.7504869103,
0.2981038988,
-0.9384845495,
0.4314415753,
0.3651123941,
-0.340135932,
-0.4824971855,
0.0451456979,
0.9153855443,
0.494953841,
-0.8226490617,
0.0336582214,
0.4929443598,
-0.2315042168,
-0.042034097,
0.8142073154,
-0.106800586,
0.1941497624,
-0.4564385712,
-0.5167521238,
-0.1477015615,
-0.7516352534,
-0.4438656271,
0.402880162,
0.1092912555,
-0.1146108359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00794v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00794v2
|
Getting Serious about Humor: Crafting Humor Datasets with Unfunny Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T02:58:12 | 2024-06-21T17:12:35 |
Zachary Horvitz, Jingru Chen, Rahul Aditya, Harshvardhan Srivastava, Robert West, Zhou Yu, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Humor is a fundamental facet of human cognition and interaction. Yet, despite
recent advances in natural language processing, humor detection remains a
challenging task that is complicated by the scarcity of datasets that pair
humorous texts with similar non-humorous counterparts. In our work, we
investigate whether large language models (LLMs), can generate synthetic data
for humor detection via editing texts. We benchmark LLMs on an existing human
dataset and show that current LLMs display an impressive ability to 'unfun'
jokes, as judged by humans and as measured on the downstream task of humor
detection. We extend our approach to a code-mixed English-Hindi humor dataset,
where we find that GPT-4's synthetic data is highly rated by bilingual
annotators and provides challenging adversarial examples for humor classifiers.
|
[
-0.1588962823,
-0.8525197506,
0.642051816,
0.5238162279,
-0.5669182539,
0.1368451566,
-0.504288137,
-0.495628953,
0.1681600511,
0.5703122616,
-0.249100253,
-0.3495016992,
-0.4020888209,
0.2969127595,
-0.5305281281,
1.1356219053,
0.4091602862,
-0.0077614659,
-0.1753286123,
-0.1281220764,
-0.2047731727,
-0.5818477273,
-0.7805335522,
-0.3976891041,
0.7073418498,
0.2918610871,
1.064391017,
0.4558854103,
0.4971090555,
0.3074277043,
-0.0517858043,
0.1099884883,
-0.4501694143,
-0.0672865883,
-0.2971476316,
-0.4918231964,
-0.3118555844,
-0.1539546102,
0.4785015583,
0.770902276,
-0.1809466928,
-0.2922693193,
-0.3817677796,
0.5012149811,
-0.1737011224,
0.0845099911,
-0.7737764716,
0.2398079634,
-0.4693746865,
-0.2299016714,
-0.3996762037,
-0.3868842125,
-0.1152988225,
-0.292999655,
0.2170019895,
0.1032284647,
0.498219341,
0.2453157157,
-0.3597194552,
-0.3396991491,
-0.824108839,
0.6156584024,
-0.9631416202,
0.1681809574,
0.1463475227,
0.3536582291,
-0.3788586259,
-0.7478365898,
-0.9289853573,
-0.3088899255,
0.0986258015,
-0.1101098582,
-0.3991340995,
-0.2247310877,
0.3826780021,
0.5606616735,
-0.7069479823,
-0.0189837255,
-0.3954137564,
0.035998825,
0.7941340804,
0.1407679766,
0.6727273464,
-0.3013835549,
-0.0115013644,
0.0634487495,
-0.7417019606,
-0.303267628,
0.8693760037,
0.1256305873,
0.1489350349,
0.6865417361,
-0.1241314486,
0.3573851287,
-0.4152006805,
0.0495558269,
0.2178896368,
-0.0064523234,
-0.3893426955,
-0.0769705921,
1.0192323923,
0.3199259639,
0.8713709712,
-0.3612899482,
-0.4098952413,
-0.0311294347,
0.2610332072,
-0.478125602,
-0.7473843694,
-0.0529271662,
-0.0076573268,
-0.7737471461,
-0.0796573013,
-0.7430795431,
-0.7133458853,
-0.1870478243,
0.4501021206,
-0.336607039,
-0.1824147701,
0.5229898691,
-0.293743819,
-0.0107729072,
0.2464351207,
-0.4627639949,
0.0534089617,
0.5389896631,
0.5354757309,
0.0490253605,
-0.1786309481,
-0.5317612886,
-0.0102223698,
-0.4900027812,
0.8658830523,
-0.6786245108,
-0.3112595975,
-0.1061029807,
0.1698697507,
0.3251734376,
-0.6674405336,
0.8041341901,
-0.4271661937,
0.209180057,
-0.2192096412,
-0.2708138227,
0.1025762334,
0.251562655,
-0.7295749784,
0.9713163376,
0.2665867805,
-1.0238474607,
0.1358099729,
-0.6823638678,
-0.8959118724,
0.1024585143,
0.1326105148,
-0.1871972382,
0.2124201208,
0.3091723025,
0.2517512739,
-0.3601833284,
0.620788157,
-0.4439068139,
-0.5390563607,
0.7545745373,
-0.499063015,
0.6131432652,
0.2579839826,
-0.2931069136,
-0.0397639498,
-0.5964007974,
-0.2009221613,
0.5040809512,
-0.3635316193,
-0.2679046988,
0.0177476946,
0.07969255,
0.3673141301,
-0.0671918765,
-0.6115637422,
0.3093719184,
-0.5751810074,
0.6891897917,
0.5817474127,
-0.2134929746,
-0.0952674523,
-0.1952201426,
0.5304461718,
0.0689581335,
0.197945565,
0.0996753946,
-0.7401399612,
-0.8149740696,
-0.0745466724,
0.2063411921,
0.799757719,
-1.1477636099,
0.2790663242,
-0.3765731752,
-0.4990783334,
-0.414237529,
0.2973093987,
0.3116232157,
0.4113211036,
0.3909673095,
-0.1931146532,
-0.3583112359,
-0.908275187,
-0.8429200053,
0.0327001177,
-0.3242998421,
0.270744592,
0.3909327984,
-0.2318614721,
0.7954161763,
-0.5517469645,
-0.019728208,
-0.5211934447,
0.2456939518,
0.2003985047,
0.2216269672,
0.5759082437,
-0.8531641364,
-0.3753692806,
0.0251977276,
-0.7793767452,
-0.3331730664,
0.0895387307,
0.2389522791,
0.0230272599,
0.4961509109,
-0.6151003838,
0.3844950497,
0.2798613012,
-0.1886064261,
0.6735916734,
-0.1509820521,
0.1693792492,
-0.8352839947,
0.0333813988,
-0.032545235,
-0.3653362989,
-0.7067989111,
-0.1253197938,
-0.1743888408,
-0.3892172873,
-0.5347778797,
0.8773298264,
-0.1623887867,
-0.1261605322,
-0.1778400838,
-0.0443582088,
0.0400989763,
0.3169457912,
-0.1577575505,
0.5405219197,
0.4527364671,
-0.1741375327,
0.7773595452,
-0.0297652967,
-0.3719213307,
0.3151990175,
-0.7485889792,
0.3400700688,
-0.1317059547,
0.4190761447,
-0.8873172998,
-0.7793729901,
0.0633698627,
-0.3384380937,
0.2706581354,
-0.256011039,
-1.0028883219,
-0.5152747631,
-0.4202880859,
0.5072628856,
0.6777086258,
-0.587415576,
0.2341904938,
0.2744111717,
-0.4089556932,
-0.4581157565,
-0.9944868684,
0.5651837587,
-0.5493734479,
-0.7088363171,
0.1672232598,
-0.1042409837,
-0.2185996324,
-0.003313429,
0.2188172489,
-0.043065045,
-0.2458950728,
0.0068869735,
-0.0712451562,
-0.1214788333,
0.1284025908,
-0.0722661987,
0.1830214113,
0.1157708764,
-0.0001315521,
0.3684268296,
-0.0060204081,
-0.3547457457,
-0.2362461984,
0.1769412309,
0.5306552052,
-0.0030673437,
0.4747269452,
0.7500378489,
-0.5247842669,
-0.2093926221,
-0.6089020371,
0.0044517298,
-0.5080170631,
0.2367151529,
-0.1382942945,
-0.8708770275,
0.45111081,
-0.0173067339,
-0.3295096755,
0.2254808694,
0.3745363951,
0.0581266396,
1.1450722218,
0.4022576213,
-0.0135751059,
0.2443542928,
0.1923889965,
0.7265821695,
-0.5169766545,
0.0595061108,
-0.3125583827,
-0.2988575697,
-0.5943211317,
-0.5909365416,
0.224843815,
0.0020832329,
-0.105472818,
0.0740505606,
-0.2043618858,
0.9170374274,
0.2147600651,
0.0487535,
0.3249919415,
0.0021007247,
-0.0173937064,
-0.0693005696,
-0.3911237419,
-0.3402346373,
0.9722374678,
0.3635449708,
0.9615000486,
0.2118747532,
0.4756967425,
0.3495839834,
0.4073563814,
-0.6462734342,
0.5509327054,
-0.7509436607,
-0.3553512394,
-0.0479410663,
-0.7514165044,
-0.5010617375,
-0.320964545,
0.0446999148,
-0.6617456079,
-0.1139811873,
0.2452066094,
-0.0981575623,
0.5273787975,
-0.8707515001,
0.7616086006,
-0.1378512383,
-0.2008744478,
0.0546386093,
-0.5947345495,
0.744772017,
-0.1724751592,
0.5085147023,
-0.0442999378,
0.3725062311,
0.520350337,
-0.1040610075,
0.729454577,
-0.1401136965,
0.0102703255,
0.2173250765,
0.3523335159,
0.4267745614,
0.3302287161,
-0.1906700879,
0.0286666155,
-0.4106918275,
-0.5026382804,
-0.7222566605,
0.9459446073,
-0.4448849261,
-0.6319656968,
-0.2308195382,
-0.7587512136,
-0.2784226537,
-0.0546940714,
0.1319036484,
0.354560405,
-0.0194615107,
0.2445546687,
0.4527318776,
-0.6060211062,
0.1935615987,
0.1231886968,
-0.2277463377,
-0.3310754597,
1.0384550095,
-0.1688825935,
0.1835558265,
0.1186909005,
0.4033445716,
-0.4059079289,
-0.328977108,
-0.4154666364,
0.3251771331,
-0.9254385829,
-0.0682619587,
-0.9139739275,
-0.298554033,
-0.3977096975,
-0.2110968381,
-0.3982987404,
-0.5293779373,
-0.0172787178,
0.0643821508,
0.4990726411,
1.0230523348,
-0.139314115,
0.1836358458,
-0.7014965415,
0.2081815302,
0.4992778897,
0.3108378947,
-0.2276601791,
-0.5308694243,
0.1088263243,
0.0022343809,
-0.1390461773,
-0.8120414615,
0.5965954661,
0.2940470874,
0.0887457132,
0.3007406294,
-0.0612447262,
0.3895484507,
-0.5138528943,
0.8495846391,
-0.0946816877,
-0.8025788069,
0.5492911339,
-0.5622833967,
0.0732581466,
0.0982250124,
0.3098185062,
-0.5347698927,
-0.4969894588,
-0.6453998685,
-0.6508303285,
0.5169372559,
0.3669158816,
0.5743096471,
-0.2878012061,
0.4055949152,
-0.087716274,
0.3045260012,
-0.9161821008,
0.1436930001,
-0.3204926252,
-0.3029384911,
-0.0334640965,
-0.2103453279,
-0.1922997683,
-0.3942152858,
0.3480582833,
-0.1254519969,
0.1889649481,
0.0203063153,
-0.0703205317,
-0.1143959388,
0.466150105,
0.6558057666,
0.5326040387,
-0.2775585949,
0.2449196279,
0.1070552617,
-0.3812724948,
-0.147971347,
0.0709395036,
0.3023272157,
-0.0653520674,
0.4179934859,
0.7146726251,
0.3926979303,
-0.9600536823,
0.4982300699,
-0.1954963803,
0.0171751622,
-0.0972498357,
0.2459348142,
0.397212714,
0.0539669618,
0.1008408815,
-0.1695091426,
0.2937701643,
-0.8542029858,
0.242330417,
0.3342600763,
-0.0724991113,
-0.6467229128,
0.4335478246,
0.1723691374,
-0.3180645406,
0.664278388,
-0.5363429785,
-0.9286364913,
0.6045727134,
0.7143437862,
0.6936770082,
-0.2521959841,
0.1893315315,
0.088477008,
0.3529091775,
-0.0131485732,
0.3310698867,
0.4745913148,
-0.6735690236,
-0.3726462424,
-0.8713106513,
-0.3627650142,
0.5231245756,
-0.1516153365,
0.5493190289,
-0.346409142,
0.2057668716,
0.2298072726,
-0.2374957353,
-0.7105787396,
0.3475664556,
0.1034965739,
0.7174499035,
-0.9596247673,
0.8936614394,
0.8161358237,
-0.2510227859,
-0.5836095214,
0.1387523711,
-0.030027207,
-0.6552864313,
0.531748414,
0.2777296901,
0.2363912314,
-0.0317273811,
-0.6548607945,
-0.2558088005,
0.6133819222,
0.5513827205,
-0.385831356,
-0.0595109761,
0.4348323345,
0.7164204121,
-0.2976184189,
0.1543260366,
0.7428044081,
0.5110369921,
0.3138534129,
-0.8110009432,
0.0157727581,
-0.3317474723,
-0.2114744484,
0.3334832191,
-0.355463624,
1.1633330584,
-0.3365615904,
0.0012195266,
-0.2043476999,
0.2454312742,
0.1781293601,
0.5211031437,
0.7181894779,
0.8605670333,
0.4004246593,
-0.0160098895,
1.1037124395,
0.1371589452,
0.3385614455,
1.0083794594,
-0.6020075679,
0.5202614069,
0.3067263365,
-0.2067549378,
0.3624183834,
0.5075127482,
-0.0337148905,
0.1955905408,
0.3711841702,
-0.3321596384,
-0.341481179,
0.0100501683,
-0.1054058373,
0.4486330748,
0.462754488,
-0.1633678675,
-0.4539001286,
0.1521416903,
0.3722569346,
-0.0830473453,
0.0881607383,
0.5383370519,
0.158511892,
-0.4120496511,
0.2828291953,
-0.0148264291,
0.7335705161,
-0.2841685116,
-0.1734559834,
-0.4524297714,
-0.0237601362,
-0.2288441658,
-1.1872663498,
0.4989489913,
0.3895093501,
0.0712849051,
0.4454195201,
0.8207309842,
-0.5139329433,
-0.5260766149,
0.3559565544,
0.2960170805,
0.394933641,
-0.3768143058,
-0.6603831053,
-0.0958902016,
-0.0061924309,
-0.3789001703,
0.4462732375,
0.9104013443,
-0.2509670556,
0.6734856367,
1.1429315805,
0.2093883753,
0.0036512595,
0.3664049804,
1.1271699667,
-0.9059610367,
-0.3517835438,
-0.8914978504,
0.5321532488,
-0.3010664582,
-0.2633315921,
0.273946166,
0.2552966475,
0.546133697,
-0.2990930676,
0.7410811782,
-0.0418780446,
0.2275597602,
-0.5469818711,
0.7986897826,
-0.8002228141,
0.3131864071,
-0.1916770935,
-0.9047947526,
-0.4460796714,
0.2246115357,
-0.2871703207,
0.2542898357,
0.6668468118,
0.963090837,
-0.451603353,
0.0695887879,
0.5305648446,
0.3563990295,
0.6885424852,
0.6081979871,
0.8530482054,
-0.1641060412,
0.5731666088,
-0.4874798357,
-0.1273997575,
-0.2416982949,
-1.2260440588,
-1.1536055803,
-0.2368469387,
-0.2745398879,
-0.138339296,
-0.0820663646,
0.6006947756,
0.2532332838,
-0.588971734,
0.1999038607,
-0.0534702837,
0.145570606,
0.40070647,
-0.3948660195,
0.2307338268,
-0.2589065433,
-0.7070761323,
0.652971983,
0.4806369245,
-0.0597333573,
-0.2792554796,
0.1441240609,
-0.0842943564,
0.5511498451,
0.6713486314,
0.255309999,
-0.6982532144,
-0.5100482106,
-0.1088211313,
0.0928321034,
-0.2266196162,
0.7867337465,
-0.5096566081,
0.4633752406,
0.5093539953,
0.6975401044,
0.0241798759,
-0.0927711427,
0.3644874096,
-1.1641628742,
0.3291677833,
0.3427790701,
0.4164269865,
0.8898590207,
-0.6082840562,
0.6968121529,
0.5174006224,
-0.7157332301,
-1.3345267773,
0.1123535186,
-1.0187351704,
-0.1342682391,
1.2266899347,
-0.2366800755,
-0.2769927979,
-0.0627974197,
-0.1199686825,
0.1632579714,
-0.1131878719,
0.8038081527,
0.8954021931,
-0.1842491627,
-0.077260837,
-0.8009340167,
0.6600816846,
0.347728163,
-1.1017160416,
0.151121825,
0.1797723025,
0.5446593761,
0.1753056049,
0.5340518355,
-0.210688442,
0.401476115,
-0.3443733752,
0.0304833502,
0.0934808925,
-0.3308369517,
-0.1814835668,
-0.2148417532,
0.0424879529,
0.5197077394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15062v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15062v1
|
Gotcha! Don't trick me with unanswerable questions! Self-aligning Large Language Models for Responding to Unknown Questions
| 2024-02-23T02:24:36 | 2024-02-23T02:24:36 |
Yang Deng, Yong Zhao, Moxin Li, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the remarkable abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to answer
questions, they often display a considerable level of overconfidence even when
the question does not have a definitive answer. To avoid providing hallucinated
answers to these unknown questions, existing studies typically investigate
approaches to refusing to answer these questions. In this work, we propose a
novel and scalable self-alignment method to utilize the LLM itself to enhance
its response-ability to different types of unknown questions, being capable of
not only refusing to answer but also providing explanation to the
unanswerability of unknown questions. Specifically, the Self-Align method first
employ a two-stage class-aware self-augmentation approach to generate a large
amount of unknown question-response data. Then we conduct disparity-driven
self-curation to select qualified data for fine-tuning the LLM itself for
aligning the responses to unknown questions as desired. Experimental results on
two datasets across four types of unknown questions validate the superiority of
the Self-Align method over existing baselines in terms of three types of task
formulation.
|
[
-0.4697383344,
-1.0238595009,
0.6444980502,
0.2255284041,
0.0203691293,
0.4117885232,
-0.2207649201,
-0.123627089,
0.3909248412,
0.340483278,
-0.8631522059,
-0.1260279417,
-0.2511221468,
0.1229347885,
-0.4568457603,
0.8753025532,
0.1417310536,
-0.0449526645,
-0.4702218473,
-0.1819769144,
-0.6707757711,
-0.2440508455,
-0.356564045,
-0.1510193795,
0.5867213011,
0.6412790418,
0.6531450748,
0.6370131969,
0.6652519107,
0.3512732387,
0.2125686258,
0.359844476,
-0.2612588704,
0.0663207099,
-0.3274573088,
-0.3570134938,
-0.521348536,
-0.2357282043,
0.5473293066,
0.5257630944,
-0.1191111356,
0.5418682098,
0.0244940799,
0.7059730291,
-0.5722749829,
-0.190871045,
-0.8682550192,
-0.0050820182,
-0.227386415,
-0.1899009645,
-0.0639578998,
-0.210416764,
-0.1831384152,
-0.6099630594,
0.1938856691,
-0.022264244,
0.4402033389,
0.6464782953,
-0.2149517089,
-0.1646111012,
-0.6731523871,
0.557677865,
-0.7185484767,
0.0693228394,
0.3506543338,
0.4691176414,
-0.0067058611,
-0.3243144155,
-0.7645280361,
0.1217272729,
-0.1791136712,
0.2715809345,
-0.0497698523,
-0.1424138397,
0.14596726,
0.3674982786,
-0.9709793329,
0.313318491,
-0.0155439824,
-0.1622641832,
0.5658249855,
0.0943633243,
0.2302275598,
0.004334155,
-0.2432945818,
0.0263603777,
-0.4822681546,
0.0606537238,
0.353176564,
0.4727212787,
0.128211543,
0.9116211534,
-0.2771804035,
0.8550619483,
0.6943051219,
0.1238534451,
-0.0021285303,
-0.2234170735,
-0.1405712664,
0.030272305,
0.5757861137,
0.1463725269,
0.0223193653,
-0.1921063215,
-0.1101955548,
-0.1611707658,
0.3864800334,
-0.5013003349,
0.0113917794,
0.5391029119,
0.0026017013,
-0.2941467464,
-0.3567821681,
-0.8917116523,
-0.3606680632,
0.0038885416,
0.8717798591,
0.0526048094,
-0.4097829163,
-0.029011827,
0.2353958935,
0.3119613528,
0.2785526216,
-1.0903418064,
0.356156975,
0.5054568052,
0.5147237778,
-0.1459839642,
-0.1477803737,
-0.5346108079,
0.1190589145,
-0.5005258918,
0.6150588393,
-0.5859993696,
-0.0569130667,
-0.0283328556,
-0.0436185114,
-0.0662503466,
-0.3343681991,
0.3162132204,
-0.6013724208,
0.5491181612,
-0.4148330688,
-0.6646256447,
0.0534194037,
0.6207897663,
-0.3620790541,
1.0334569216,
0.1736847758,
-0.8361510038,
-0.2411774397,
-0.6410781741,
-0.132908985,
0.2352999598,
-0.4768804014,
-0.3679956794,
-0.014431064,
0.6017879248,
0.2970451415,
-0.0514583215,
0.3034911752,
-0.3736258447,
-0.1595437825,
0.4386880994,
-0.3846093714,
0.3451054394,
0.1950046867,
-0.2739286125,
-0.1242955327,
-0.7048059106,
0.4080790579,
0.2819207013,
-0.0664940625,
-0.2788980603,
-0.309261173,
-0.4516914487,
0.334584564,
0.7041815519,
-0.7328230739,
0.4275970757,
-0.450686425,
0.1607215852,
0.7057818174,
-0.2622983754,
0.4888844788,
-0.4941681921,
0.6360704303,
-0.0134553378,
-0.0659769401,
-0.003857556,
-0.270180434,
-0.7268263698,
0.2078561038,
0.2228586227,
0.6197028756,
-0.8389474154,
0.40532884,
-0.2290003449,
-0.6052864194,
-0.9347165227,
0.1969171762,
0.5514469743,
0.9051935673,
0.605068028,
0.0974762514,
-0.4627753794,
-0.8987195492,
-0.4135030806,
-0.2692337334,
0.0047475831,
0.1263557225,
0.2593384981,
0.0693241358,
1.0312572718,
-0.7337657809,
-0.1435720474,
0.0739682615,
0.0590226948,
-0.0844938755,
0.6372038126,
0.2811994255,
-0.5718286633,
-0.2904688418,
-0.0213922579,
-0.5456388593,
-0.0269170776,
-0.133140564,
0.0336103998,
0.106834583,
0.5947146416,
-0.5376557112,
0.0690459982,
0.5220143795,
-0.0389466137,
0.3857617676,
-0.4252405763,
0.1482926905,
-1.1434710026,
0.1528146565,
-0.1849069893,
-0.1225538477,
-0.6333943009,
0.0073832357,
0.5294288993,
-0.2197345942,
-0.1276801974,
0.788208127,
-0.5143275857,
0.1873226315,
-0.302839607,
0.1534687132,
-0.1284935027,
0.6025388241,
-0.1482532322,
0.754550159,
0.6133398414,
-0.6178116202,
0.2240366638,
0.5064994693,
-0.0948864296,
0.58371526,
-0.6221277714,
0.5272657275,
-0.510766387,
-0.0749011412,
-1.3159929514,
-0.40198946,
0.2859128118,
-0.6714191437,
0.522300005,
-0.199542895,
-0.0807026327,
-0.7153966427,
-0.0065802429,
0.5911358595,
0.3035841286,
-0.6095877886,
0.6967172623,
0.1831505746,
-0.2559182346,
-0.9898109436,
-0.7923290133,
-0.1584959477,
-0.4354065657,
-0.5014585257,
0.2603808939,
-0.6922963262,
-0.0793009847,
-0.0518451817,
-0.3999606669,
-0.2302245349,
0.1443793923,
0.1145078465,
0.3510688245,
-0.2524797618,
0.3894802928,
0.165004462,
-0.0085930824,
-0.0803002268,
-0.1532895267,
0.4529628158,
-0.0552175008,
-0.5960515738,
-0.2110145837,
0.3176779747,
0.5273589492,
-0.4216050506,
0.403768003,
0.3882090449,
-0.2959139347,
-0.1454262733,
-0.8580582738,
-0.2390743196,
-0.5570797324,
0.3242697716,
-0.3261155486,
-1.1694456339,
0.5227057934,
0.2102529705,
0.1109150797,
0.1418727189,
0.5895373821,
-0.0554885343,
1.0989326239,
0.4405125678,
-0.2304808497,
-0.0017903012,
0.3117853105,
0.4855357409,
-0.5534793139,
-0.3121372461,
-0.6345877051,
-0.3153728843,
-0.6207846403,
-0.4665029049,
0.2751772106,
-0.3281372488,
-0.2440033555,
0.275798738,
-0.5670313239,
0.5426434278,
0.1883714646,
-0.0707575232,
0.3049124181,
-0.19562608,
0.2959297299,
0.0694400072,
-0.6097004414,
-0.100736171,
1.0855696201,
0.2798676491,
0.9308513999,
0.1590551436,
0.6785593033,
0.1672586799,
0.0847067982,
-0.6784302592,
0.4731111228,
0.1754782945,
-0.9265457392,
-0.8036752343,
-0.4272957444,
-0.8363884091,
0.3707713783,
-0.1216422692,
-0.5945248008,
0.0313851163,
0.3461041152,
-0.676001966,
0.2477215081,
-0.5875077844,
0.6304152012,
-0.5338283181,
-0.1085297838,
0.1582363546,
-0.6511995792,
0.3979226351,
-0.4868385494,
0.3632011712,
-0.0652376562,
-0.1663644612,
0.5794404745,
-0.3152124584,
0.7124958634,
-0.0164145529,
-0.400406301,
0.1413162947,
0.2071661204,
0.5916495323,
0.0497908443,
0.0293452591,
-0.262894392,
-0.0518479161,
-0.4340619445,
-1.1064063311,
0.9404454827,
-0.5586972237,
-0.9839541316,
-0.2813243568,
-0.7328693867,
-0.6711434722,
0.2525694072,
0.2310851663,
0.2538444996,
-0.1361357272,
-0.3068071008,
0.6360817552,
0.1160303354,
0.6043585539,
0.8852756023,
-0.2083020955,
-0.4472458959,
0.9231331348,
0.3074861169,
0.4038915634,
0.4415531456,
0.1387809515,
-0.6271783113,
-0.430072844,
-0.5883219242,
0.3533212245,
-0.4269785881,
-0.3787087202,
-0.6879690886,
-0.2223357707,
-0.8050196767,
0.0220406428,
-0.5241283178,
-0.6193177104,
-0.0965256393,
-0.1739862561,
0.1484475434,
0.4686214328,
-0.2243971229,
0.2149153352,
-0.5368008018,
0.1808439046,
0.6949340105,
0.4036847651,
0.0370882377,
-0.8329417109,
-0.0517544635,
0.2497994751,
-0.2646137178,
-0.6827892661,
0.2697021663,
-0.0569741316,
0.4817532599,
0.3220032156,
0.3820815384,
1.0335497856,
-0.4292938411,
0.3302394152,
0.2226484418,
-0.8895343542,
0.5633730888,
-0.2491981387,
0.2803443074,
0.6759606004,
0.5152053237,
-0.3905802369,
-0.5827287436,
-0.6387654543,
-0.6325286627,
0.3643015921,
0.2324809134,
0.4066082239,
0.0946534351,
0.5075555444,
0.0843432695,
0.2921827137,
-0.9129354358,
-0.5007922053,
-0.2628310621,
-0.1870065033,
-0.1462151706,
0.0049835825,
-0.2747973502,
-0.3237313628,
0.6760212779,
-0.3436688781,
-0.0178943276,
0.2779483795,
-0.0139197391,
-0.4717954695,
0.4255700111,
0.4504335523,
0.6459561586,
-0.2135049701,
0.2032949775,
0.2174368054,
-0.1692815572,
0.242229104,
0.1044126526,
-0.1061467975,
-0.3451704085,
-0.0117295198,
0.392042309,
-0.2062862515,
-0.5260073543,
0.4808639586,
-0.1782150269,
-0.219641149,
-0.2515700758,
0.0559889004,
0.1179401875,
0.225427717,
0.3269556761,
-0.2911053598,
-0.2472646683,
-0.3378227949,
0.0564007685,
0.8299794793,
-0.449187398,
-0.1603803039,
0.5691392422,
0.0181973837,
-0.4705242515,
0.5056585073,
-0.0720572472,
-0.2063345015,
0.5761150122,
0.843074739,
0.4986771345,
-0.52870363,
0.5606518984,
0.4044562876,
0.337166518,
0.0668653175,
0.2169128209,
-0.0757816285,
-0.7791201472,
-0.4365980327,
-0.4067735672,
-0.3654947579,
0.6064403057,
-0.7760273218,
-0.0841785595,
-0.4519710541,
0.070475623,
0.0759034529,
-0.0762092173,
-0.43466416,
0.3167880774,
-0.0312357247,
0.7529183626,
-0.8406596184,
0.5651427507,
0.5683137774,
-0.492865473,
-0.959382534,
0.3271067739,
-0.1868273616,
-1.152482748,
0.1022963971,
-0.0052050422,
-0.0279562809,
0.395172596,
-0.7814257741,
-1.2016750574,
0.8707916737,
0.2968748212,
-0.6621021032,
0.0460188091,
0.3604656458,
0.4554179907,
-0.2838159502,
0.2346925884,
0.4513702095,
0.5853058696,
0.2676910758,
-0.8593097329,
0.1753723919,
-0.175630495,
-0.2815728784,
0.2345225811,
-0.7052782178,
0.5880994797,
-0.3813851476,
-0.0228455216,
0.3135423064,
0.6439188123,
0.0140997544,
0.198379308,
0.545732677,
0.6220906973,
1.0463068485,
0.0429360643,
0.5774353743,
-0.2022786289,
0.3302963972,
1.3855036497,
-0.2978469133,
0.5134657621,
0.5340300798,
0.0083541889,
0.3635347784,
0.5255209804,
-0.0686492473,
0.4603891373,
0.3166663647,
-0.197921142,
-0.624165833,
0.233375892,
-0.5277432799,
0.5276890993,
0.1511153132,
0.2932326794,
-0.4434389472,
0.0428591669,
-0.0850284845,
0.3564427793,
-0.4605458975,
0.747007668,
-0.2577211857,
-1.0261784792,
0.6995386481,
-0.1496453434,
0.4917541146,
-0.5884555578,
0.1732521206,
-0.4845385551,
-0.0032512425,
-0.2392354906,
-0.9522970319,
0.2171068639,
0.0353997685,
-0.2173072547,
-0.0210944694,
0.5538689494,
-0.7406690121,
-0.6021752357,
-0.0124945231,
0.8818764687,
0.1075333357,
-0.1121368334,
-0.8249922395,
-0.4462010562,
-0.0727743506,
0.1159768626,
0.5005374551,
0.5358767509,
0.0628490746,
1.0357863903,
0.3850215971,
-0.2399864346,
-0.0945388302,
-0.1155105457,
0.8817099333,
-0.5405371189,
-0.3137146831,
-0.7574346662,
0.6574544311,
0.0700958297,
-0.2005130649,
1.0004825592,
0.57872504,
0.7449328899,
-0.0198908448,
0.7153750658,
0.0176342037,
0.8176599145,
-0.2573876679,
0.5059064031,
-0.8421375751,
0.2364120334,
-0.4581449032,
-0.6024045348,
-0.0777964219,
0.3226488531,
-0.2421705574,
0.0566774234,
0.5245603919,
1.0441526175,
0.0333239362,
-0.2686622143,
0.4489265084,
0.097179994,
0.1165964231,
0.300648272,
0.8265283108,
-0.076607056,
0.6311274767,
-0.2354982197,
-0.1604043096,
0.0479408093,
-0.6764152646,
-0.7712259889,
-0.6235899329,
-0.3414388001,
-0.4605558217,
-0.0953406841,
0.5954341888,
0.4254968762,
-0.7477506995,
-0.1257060319,
0.0402735174,
0.3278073072,
-0.0170683954,
-0.1268679798,
0.3402540088,
-0.6166723371,
-0.6520594358,
0.6030014157,
0.186200887,
0.4609371424,
-0.3714522719,
0.1168937236,
-0.1464178264,
0.264767617,
0.0917603597,
0.5675811172,
-0.5583777428,
-0.391648531,
0.3817658424,
0.1636777222,
0.2217838317,
0.6972740889,
-0.5146037936,
0.4644806981,
0.0956494063,
0.8744995594,
0.2460795045,
0.475598067,
0.2357609123,
-0.8656790257,
-0.0848225877,
0.3967847526,
-0.0228731874,
0.3016120493,
-0.6785715818,
0.1567651629,
-0.104646489,
-0.6465389729,
-0.8350673318,
0.3012799025,
-1.0315641165,
-0.4034280181,
0.7447127104,
0.2022690028,
-0.1361482292,
-0.1156796068,
-0.0326219499,
0.087761119,
-0.0452601761,
1.0686520338,
0.7079235911,
-0.2215007395,
-0.0637835711,
-0.1537804008,
0.4085279703,
0.8655757308,
-0.8984926343,
0.3110773861,
0.4560174048,
0.5561944246,
0.241305083,
0.6248537898,
-0.0404618606,
0.0828920379,
-0.3980229795,
-0.1523866355,
-0.0317963772,
-0.2974458337,
-0.5201311707,
0.1993860304,
0.0778059214,
-0.3114587665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15061v1
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models for Domain-specific Machine Translation
| 2024-02-23T02:24:15 | 2024-02-23T02:24:15 |
Jiawei Zheng, Hanghai Hong, Xiaoli Wang, Jingsong Su, Yonggui Liang, Shikai Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in machine
translation (MT). However, their potential in domain-specific MT remains
under-explored. Current LLM-based MT systems still face several challenges.
First, for LLMs with in-context learning, their effectiveness is highly
sensitive to input translation examples, and processing them can increase
inference costs. They often require extra post-processing due to
over-generation. Second, LLMs with fine-tuning on domain-specific data often
require high training costs for domain adaptation, and may weaken the zero-shot
MT capabilities of LLMs due to over-specialization. The aforementioned methods
can struggle to translate rare words in domain transfer scenarios. To address
these challenges, this paper proposes a prompt-oriented fine-tuning method,
denoted as LlamaIT, to effectively and efficiently fine-tune a general-purpose
LLM for domain-specific MT tasks. First, we construct a task-specific
mix-domain dataset, which is then used to fine-tune the LLM with LoRA. This can
eliminate the need for input translation examples, post-processing, or
over-specialization. By zero-shot prompting with instructions, we adapt the MT
tasks to the target domain at inference time. To further elicit the MT
capability for rare words, we construct new prompts by incorporating
domain-specific bilingual vocabulary. We also conduct extensive experiments on
both publicly available and self-constructed datasets. The results show that
our LlamaIT can significantly enhance the domain-specific MT capabilities of
the LLM, meanwhile preserving its zero-shot MT capabilities.
|
[
-0.363458395,
-0.9272723198,
0.5631152391,
0.1459747106,
-0.5328364372,
0.0222123843,
-0.5099697113,
-0.2296223193,
0.051142741,
0.7635771632,
-0.7643608451,
-0.6544539928,
-0.6836634278,
0.4932878911,
-0.016857611,
0.9959651828,
-0.3405123055,
-0.2622610927,
0.206066072,
-0.2594625056,
-0.9272672534,
-0.3674802482,
-0.6351835132,
-0.2124958336,
0.6046174169,
0.7189489603,
0.4713718891,
0.624820292,
0.2929615378,
0.1863321662,
-0.0375552699,
0.7210735679,
-0.6744014621,
0.2291403413,
-0.3835134208,
-0.4698411524,
-0.66379565,
-0.3298135102,
0.6055288911,
0.7676265836,
0.177375868,
0.1609701365,
0.2402542681,
0.3878637552,
-0.4153134525,
0.0882585049,
-1.0077053308,
-0.1022577882,
-0.3036929369,
-0.654201448,
-0.354301393,
-0.0829512402,
-0.0972096026,
-0.667280376,
0.0523246937,
0.1759848148,
0.8095948696,
0.3705837131,
-0.4893426895,
0.0073917904,
-0.497779876,
1.0250852108,
-0.7813997865,
0.0869082808,
0.452665478,
0.2324367315,
-0.4528322518,
-0.3330576122,
-0.5108628273,
-0.1290683299,
0.1356731653,
-0.2546693087,
-0.3279780447,
-0.0838230103,
0.2612606287,
0.1615332663,
-0.6921666265,
0.4811669588,
0.0811427608,
0.0374542326,
0.4269854724,
0.4318957627,
0.2473908365,
0.1410565227,
-0.2052547038,
0.1582679152,
-0.9824613333,
-0.0786032081,
0.1281061023,
0.7285070419,
0.0028946183,
0.687910676,
-0.4773806334,
0.783375144,
0.2857087255,
-0.0987118259,
0.3818522394,
-0.081559822,
-0.2690737247,
-0.1429304332,
0.4847780168,
0.3899834156,
0.4534652829,
-0.1765539795,
-0.4336928725,
-0.245468989,
0.0061980118,
-0.9857525229,
0.1666784585,
0.1777552962,
-0.0450135022,
-0.1037838832,
-0.4757543802,
-0.3582314551,
-0.2310769111,
-0.5474488735,
0.5932241678,
-0.4557150006,
0.1301513314,
0.3063060939,
0.3189945221,
0.0564408265,
0.5636901855,
-0.788862288,
0.0052429405,
0.5535211563,
0.8270533681,
-0.5728701353,
-0.4863883555,
-1.0345727205,
0.2036719322,
-0.1977360994,
0.8347146511,
-0.5661589503,
-0.3337504268,
0.1203931943,
0.3016417921,
-0.2275692672,
-0.7081570029,
0.5748227835,
-0.5782752633,
-0.0720899701,
-0.1347155124,
-0.4930508733,
-0.1348912716,
0.4278613925,
-0.2425255328,
0.7482585907,
0.1519044638,
-0.3540093899,
0.2117321342,
-0.5487595201,
-0.9025883675,
0.1439626068,
0.1398272961,
-0.3116956353,
0.2542737126,
0.5341473222,
0.7644597292,
-0.5412361622,
0.3372159898,
-0.0642539412,
-0.3448786438,
0.1494247764,
-0.3729227483,
0.5116702914,
0.253205657,
-0.1770667881,
0.1353027374,
-0.7395192981,
0.0294142924,
0.1151336432,
-0.3312091529,
-0.3359794021,
-0.2804244757,
-0.0581293963,
0.0510539375,
0.3570559919,
-0.3206990659,
0.5859960914,
-0.4076657891,
0.4219814539,
0.6652547717,
0.0752008855,
0.46784392,
-0.2974400222,
0.6330636144,
0.0397417359,
-0.0856565312,
-0.3229193091,
-0.4292247891,
-0.7704460621,
-0.4864322841,
0.2643678784,
0.6901100874,
-0.8653640151,
0.508705318,
-0.3551606536,
-0.1028079689,
-0.5844204426,
0.3643424809,
0.1645265669,
0.6153252721,
0.577691555,
-0.2647335231,
-0.1420281231,
-0.7961884737,
-0.233974129,
0.463429898,
-0.0853239298,
0.509644568,
0.3598765433,
-0.4562309086,
0.7472370267,
-0.5764567852,
-0.5591397285,
-0.3613960147,
0.1072355062,
0.5658571124,
0.4227216542,
0.3642024994,
-0.518239677,
-0.6462507844,
0.3227461278,
-0.4306494892,
-0.535998702,
-0.2458632737,
-0.1207635924,
0.0339302495,
0.2819925249,
-0.733039856,
0.0632359982,
0.4565777183,
-0.1690395623,
0.225900948,
-0.3017217517,
0.2537757754,
-1.027564764,
0.1076889187,
-0.1716358364,
-0.347543776,
-0.6292318702,
0.1359708607,
0.1309438199,
0.0499153435,
-0.6168780923,
0.8300201297,
-0.3325173855,
0.2675391138,
-0.5751037598,
0.1683857739,
0.0122244591,
0.653973043,
-0.090307273,
0.8183485866,
0.6215900183,
-0.7954816222,
0.0704751015,
0.2872428894,
-0.1861743927,
0.7169957161,
-0.6242192984,
0.1491986811,
0.0416123793,
0.2263998538,
-0.7450665832,
-0.16510804,
0.3588249087,
-0.2700268626,
0.4797437191,
-0.3151628375,
-0.5847784877,
0.0071636103,
-0.0337702446,
0.3617550135,
0.4809717834,
-0.6179543734,
0.4431751072,
-0.0384581909,
-0.3846296072,
-0.4329078197,
-0.5523954034,
0.3435250819,
-0.3081474304,
-0.4975806475,
0.3228816092,
-0.2047905922,
0.0926879495,
-0.2760660052,
0.0401516818,
-0.0159942899,
0.2360601276,
0.2049458176,
0.0935595036,
-0.261111021,
-0.0803433284,
0.5049043894,
-0.2227200717,
-0.4189172387,
-0.4533457756,
0.5914655924,
0.0695095658,
-0.2432456017,
-0.4501059055,
0.3627683222,
0.4988031089,
-0.4650158584,
0.6699931026,
0.5342721939,
-0.2096721977,
-0.6812208295,
-0.3531413674,
-0.1396583468,
-0.4478221834,
0.3950948715,
-0.7131416202,
-1.2495244741,
0.4099930525,
-0.4954682887,
0.0622651652,
0.3632268608,
0.7820388675,
0.1428361237,
0.9415767789,
0.6126869917,
-0.1735339612,
0.2839849293,
-0.2258601934,
0.1519931108,
-0.826412797,
0.256344229,
-0.4380919933,
-0.4502779543,
-0.2412095368,
-0.5477845669,
0.1553642005,
0.1800148189,
-0.2434174716,
0.5770438313,
-0.185541153,
0.609685421,
0.2609903216,
-0.1218448058,
0.5579305291,
0.2054778934,
-0.0638248622,
-0.065530017,
-0.5910030603,
-0.4645628929,
0.9031460285,
0.2384935617,
0.6577408314,
0.0092608556,
0.4884440005,
0.2420049757,
0.2645847797,
-0.8330848813,
0.517386198,
-0.33478266,
-0.1384437829,
-0.2952639163,
-0.4328508973,
-0.9967499375,
0.2609060407,
-0.0735854879,
-0.529673934,
-0.0076716673,
0.1877718717,
-0.3395068944,
0.1716095656,
-0.3712998033,
0.7224541903,
-0.1961366534,
-0.2286255211,
-0.2222591192,
-0.4616909027,
0.190929845,
-0.5856720805,
0.0990474224,
-0.3780078292,
-0.0666096583,
0.1075048745,
-0.2094147205,
1.0568284988,
0.0504654758,
-0.5024231076,
0.1206617579,
0.4508603513,
0.8521097302,
-0.0026430029,
-0.125232026,
0.2333652228,
-0.3126081228,
-0.3482281268,
-0.5341206789,
0.8902499676,
-0.6406261921,
-0.7191979289,
0.0213104524,
-0.7703949213,
-0.482380569,
0.2501528561,
0.2949593663,
0.2153657228,
-0.0719298646,
-0.0614799224,
0.6874418259,
-0.3276911378,
0.1130927429,
0.8162190318,
-0.0438430458,
-0.227306664,
0.9872330427,
-0.0980863422,
0.3327764869,
0.6964976192,
0.030662166,
-0.0152997859,
-0.8204469681,
-0.7939528823,
0.2999759018,
-0.5203406215,
-0.5513442755,
-0.6341992021,
0.2112035453,
-0.1732305586,
-0.3276202083,
-0.221255362,
-0.3988502026,
-0.5953562856,
0.1555782855,
0.5433635116,
0.269665122,
0.1773173362,
0.647919178,
-0.8813843727,
0.5061516762,
0.1073506698,
0.2375989705,
-0.1347551346,
-1.1508308649,
-0.3011903167,
-0.0415065773,
-0.1598466635,
-0.3726405799,
0.5695053339,
0.4021490216,
0.324935317,
0.2541118562,
0.2071221769,
0.726324141,
-0.9096906781,
0.6410605907,
-0.0775149837,
-0.8903636932,
0.523978889,
-0.5300566554,
0.3390081823,
0.4201955497,
0.3203520775,
-0.4996905029,
-0.382833302,
-0.1257049441,
-0.7982679009,
0.6132327914,
-0.043388743,
0.423143059,
-0.056704957,
0.4216583669,
0.5507245064,
0.1020469069,
-0.3807958961,
-0.1514482349,
0.2594724596,
-0.1791104078,
-0.2430582792,
-0.0023660804,
-0.0437611714,
-0.0752346963,
0.6118775606,
-0.4781193435,
-0.2495017499,
-0.0291040111,
-0.4433031082,
-0.4059616625,
0.548992753,
0.6259954572,
0.5410476923,
-0.0718070194,
0.0716715306,
0.6841520667,
-0.2125566453,
0.1659337282,
0.060541857,
-0.2722563744,
-0.1068292037,
0.1734464914,
0.9382219911,
0.0888857991,
-0.7793505192,
0.4553589523,
0.1757795811,
-0.1999212652,
0.1484680921,
0.1483952105,
-0.1683102101,
0.3661263585,
0.255479157,
0.0979128703,
-0.1240816563,
-0.3446514904,
0.0069827307,
0.4427157044,
-0.0687743649,
-0.395310849,
0.6078486443,
0.2349175811,
-0.3184816837,
0.312118113,
-0.157344833,
-0.4092970788,
0.2466910481,
0.7264094949,
0.8774163723,
-0.1178128198,
0.0374118648,
0.0776932836,
0.1968642622,
-0.1836442947,
0.1516426951,
-0.0332472362,
-0.6192184091,
-0.7977223992,
-0.6236611009,
-0.3514201641,
0.2706831396,
-0.2893635333,
0.3901793063,
-0.2680177391,
-0.0930124223,
-0.2972106338,
-0.0759673566,
-0.8012515306,
0.1577213109,
0.040129438,
0.8499431014,
-0.6688562632,
1.0205123425,
0.5983147621,
-0.155315116,
-0.4509902596,
-0.1035651565,
-0.2614254653,
-1.0111129284,
0.7660686374,
-0.0611479729,
-0.300875783,
0.1977772713,
-0.5550237298,
-0.7402528524,
0.9139506817,
0.6121442914,
-0.8974524736,
0.2121403515,
0.3855233788,
0.4757661521,
-0.3974997401,
-0.2551440895,
0.5621501803,
0.5163365602,
-0.0755830929,
-1.0197147131,
0.2137411535,
-0.0640921146,
-0.048178073,
0.2414828092,
-0.4751678407,
0.7368407249,
-0.242926836,
-0.1093686447,
0.3053767979,
0.4966196716,
0.1643266529,
0.1201947853,
0.3899172544,
0.4755542874,
0.6737265587,
0.2478026003,
0.8891045451,
-0.2295768261,
0.171391651,
1.0949107409,
-0.5453107357,
0.9015032053,
0.5657678843,
0.1909870207,
-0.0489290841,
0.4317270815,
-0.0970657021,
0.4807638526,
0.3036915958,
-0.1828429699,
-0.45004794,
-0.3302073479,
-0.3388777077,
0.2313214242,
0.3844736814,
-0.2660307288,
-0.2383493483,
0.182809189,
0.0659482926,
-0.022157073,
-0.3779053688,
0.5702739954,
0.2838349342,
-0.5701159835,
0.9296565056,
0.2756190002,
0.711897254,
-0.5304553509,
-0.0281331372,
-0.5361056924,
0.2739622295,
-0.0328217857,
-0.6373073459,
-0.0024495614,
0.2878603935,
-0.1479761302,
-0.3850093186,
0.6019151211,
-0.4988859594,
-0.2638861835,
0.2125386894,
0.7762408257,
0.1782839298,
-0.3503054678,
-0.443341732,
0.0895560309,
0.1696515977,
-0.3037352562,
0.5677761436,
0.9434004426,
-0.209861964,
0.6311414242,
0.5878705382,
0.2498605102,
-0.189790085,
0.2981281579,
0.8116863966,
-0.659527719,
-0.3083417416,
-0.8005753756,
0.4173908532,
0.364228785,
-0.5773388147,
0.6614071131,
0.3216485977,
0.737547636,
-0.2531141937,
0.7561582327,
0.3547562659,
0.4599384367,
-0.5722649693,
0.5727614164,
-0.7159738541,
0.3247145414,
-0.0650346801,
-1.1119909286,
-0.6406876445,
0.3285101354,
-0.2684865296,
-0.3041068614,
0.4899657369,
0.7999455929,
-0.2548466325,
-0.3268850446,
0.5758379102,
0.2869655192,
0.2717060447,
0.6419171095,
0.7448348403,
-0.2650279403,
0.5456534624,
0.167302683,
-0.1869200021,
-0.419562012,
-0.975556314,
-1.0498799086,
-0.3382551074,
-0.3947813213,
0.0094087254,
0.162187025,
1.0473049879,
0.5409751534,
-0.9065393209,
-0.0733623281,
0.1902498156,
-0.0397545509,
-0.1182996705,
-0.1175303087,
0.3655544519,
-0.5200645328,
-0.7741665244,
0.7054836154,
0.3920697272,
-0.0004528121,
0.2246749997,
-0.0518430583,
0.2459999174,
0.0503596403,
0.8670998216,
0.2667760849,
-0.677083075,
-0.2758468091,
0.1315556765,
-0.0932101831,
0.1418024302,
0.6902448535,
-0.5996116996,
0.0597985201,
0.2266805172,
1.0019128323,
0.3763092458,
-0.0604625121,
0.6413253546,
-0.8200597167,
-0.018165309,
0.185060814,
0.3834194243,
0.3411271572,
-0.398337394,
0.3250864148,
0.0161507875,
-0.5374401212,
-0.7080668807,
0.256808728,
-1.0708709955,
-0.2899096012,
1.2309017181,
-0.0149974627,
-0.078367658,
-0.0132908076,
-0.5407640338,
0.1486891955,
-0.4910990298,
0.5879660845,
0.3897121847,
0.0210185014,
-0.0225038007,
-0.5787053108,
0.3076916039,
0.6057400107,
-0.7085817456,
0.3367662728,
0.3386587203,
0.3526404798,
-0.2876046598,
0.2985570133,
0.2219141126,
0.0237347595,
-0.5970693231,
-0.1217147112,
-0.1800197661,
-0.2769748867,
-0.6022117138,
-0.0097878883,
0.1663518995,
-0.0801828429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15059v1
|
ColBERT-XM: A Modular Multi-Vector Representation Model for Zero-Shot Multilingual Information Retrieval
| 2024-02-23T02:21:24 | 2024-02-23T02:21:24 |
Antoine Louis, Vageesh Saxena, Gijs van Dijck, Gerasimos Spanakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
State-of-the-art neural retrievers predominantly focus on high-resource
languages like English, which impedes their adoption in retrieval scenarios
involving other languages. Current approaches circumvent the lack of
high-quality labeled data in non-English languages by leveraging multilingual
pretrained language models capable of cross-lingual transfer. However, these
models require substantial task-specific fine-tuning across multiple languages,
often perform poorly in languages with minimal representation in the
pretraining corpus, and struggle to incorporate new languages after the
pretraining phase. In this work, we present a novel modular dense retrieval
model that learns from the rich data of a single high-resource language and
effectively zero-shot transfers to a wide array of languages, thereby
eliminating the need for language-specific labeled data. Our model, ColBERT-XM,
demonstrates competitive performance against existing state-of-the-art
multilingual retrievers trained on more extensive datasets in various
languages. Further analysis reveals that our modular approach is highly
data-efficient, effectively adapts to out-of-distribution data, and
significantly reduces energy consumption and carbon emissions. By demonstrating
its proficiency in zero-shot scenarios, ColBERT-XM marks a shift towards more
sustainable and inclusive retrieval systems, enabling effective information
accessibility in numerous languages. We publicly release our code and models
for the community.
|
[
-0.0528045632,
-0.3913939297,
0.3601050377,
0.0813817754,
-0.1780311018,
0.1653211713,
-0.4312788248,
-0.1796179265,
0.4342761338,
0.2178951055,
0.0321831815,
-0.6447474957,
-0.589887023,
0.0445244871,
-0.2953668237,
0.8080016971,
0.2053186744,
0.1521013826,
0.0113858841,
-0.2350771129,
-0.3219687343,
-0.7398074269,
-0.1603623182,
-0.2113085538,
0.9987595677,
0.6330717802,
0.6932746768,
0.6430274844,
0.328871578,
0.2050046772,
-0.0174442511,
-0.3586151004,
-0.8314096332,
0.0691425204,
-0.3984815478,
-0.4962074757,
-0.3305359185,
-0.2422190905,
0.9980956912,
0.6050243378,
-0.2206385732,
0.2638444901,
-0.1860798001,
0.4853560925,
-1.0430029631,
0.1255724877,
-0.8225900531,
0.124729909,
-0.276260227,
-0.2611615956,
-0.626502037,
-0.1243070439,
-0.0527710058,
-0.6300910711,
-0.0078018536,
0.1257092208,
0.6173262,
-0.316775769,
-0.5657836795,
0.0075348062,
-0.4344072044,
1.1085422039,
-0.1053061262,
0.7013888955,
0.2640141845,
0.2588481903,
0.3306953609,
-0.3827167153,
-0.685258925,
-0.1152921021,
-0.0709112585,
0.1530406624,
-0.3069458604,
-0.3785131276,
-0.1941674352,
0.3026341498,
-0.7640595436,
0.0473275706,
-0.514475584,
-0.0811626688,
0.5750023723,
0.015589091,
0.056123849,
-0.6286239624,
-0.5574977398,
-0.1694763899,
-0.6832960248,
0.0689212158,
0.3686156273,
0.6378032565,
0.109480314,
0.5658556223,
-0.2708237469,
0.5261329412,
-0.4426623583,
0.3092591763,
0.2889424264,
-0.2768827081,
-0.2477139831,
0.1426623464,
0.6255383492,
-0.0545582399,
-0.0207855068,
-0.385111779,
-0.2248406708,
-0.2805937529,
0.1696880013,
-0.7779871821,
-0.2111998945,
0.0366363674,
-0.5032516122,
-0.1710626483,
0.0546167865,
-0.7066608667,
0.0459201671,
-0.3182099462,
0.7228906155,
-0.413310647,
-0.4955170751,
0.4523583353,
0.0082767792,
0.1602448225,
0.142324537,
-0.6323133111,
0.0675954148,
0.3801311255,
0.8168922663,
-0.1438284367,
-0.034550108,
-0.8502084017,
0.2815203965,
-0.334251672,
0.6685993671,
-0.8574453592,
-0.4940950572,
-0.0290977154,
0.1896273494,
-0.1170856878,
-0.4518031776,
0.4208088815,
-0.7520133257,
0.0555290543,
-0.4472898841,
-0.3044378459,
-0.5078346729,
0.5394022465,
-0.5400196314,
0.8791393042,
-0.0506234467,
-0.5644397736,
0.1199357584,
-0.2849070132,
-0.4026120901,
0.2301145643,
-0.2612867355,
-0.3107964694,
0.1022464633,
-0.0000028416,
0.6282468438,
-0.1330400854,
-0.0132289669,
-0.3715019822,
-0.4127217531,
-0.2020194679,
-0.1673926562,
0.7596252561,
0.2115816474,
0.0142075885,
0.1455581486,
-0.8250845671,
0.186588496,
0.0584331527,
-0.6481491327,
-0.3401965201,
-0.1967272311,
0.3826381862,
0.3973813355,
0.2132378519,
-0.8477424979,
0.2376649231,
0.2782442272,
0.1435737759,
0.5410417914,
-0.5657468438,
0.6428632736,
-0.3937195837,
0.5930333734,
0.1632037908,
-0.1337408125,
-0.7260965109,
-0.2020468861,
-0.6076803803,
-0.459035784,
0.2511334419,
0.8412461281,
-0.7310063839,
0.2451922297,
-0.5457818508,
-0.4980047047,
-0.344694227,
0.2191575617,
0.3566860557,
0.5418457985,
0.6187203526,
-0.2641796768,
-0.2498878986,
-0.7919257283,
0.0482478403,
-0.0275376197,
0.1625769585,
0.4655419886,
0.4181405902,
-0.1026453301,
0.5852552056,
-0.482786268,
-0.4121828377,
-0.6066942215,
0.2170911729,
0.1955657899,
0.6093407273,
0.4979227781,
-0.6104231477,
-0.6184247732,
0.4455014169,
-0.7576472759,
0.5431083441,
0.1091713607,
-0.2568670213,
-0.0082742851,
0.3330517113,
-0.4720626771,
0.3172013164,
0.2153346688,
-0.0184409264,
0.5393919945,
-0.3444232345,
0.1962660402,
-0.8769161105,
0.382240206,
-0.0613146201,
-0.5126823783,
-0.4430525601,
0.196611762,
0.5257718563,
-0.4435456395,
-0.6983508468,
0.6085154414,
-0.5873479843,
0.2060353309,
0.1143478155,
0.0347217955,
0.157057032,
0.5335906744,
0.2526484728,
0.6109298468,
0.8865170479,
-0.5017704368,
0.0902473629,
0.3015532196,
-0.3732023835,
0.7097795606,
-0.5465004444,
0.1535975933,
-0.73389709,
0.1210154369,
-0.835837245,
0.0236486495,
-0.119884558,
-0.2380397022,
0.6685281396,
-0.2529539168,
-0.6189352274,
0.0189354047,
-0.3296265304,
0.83762604,
0.3767500222,
-0.5259266496,
0.409278065,
0.3106963634,
-0.3440424502,
-0.8537990451,
-0.593803823,
0.2192321271,
0.0592081323,
-0.7416217327,
0.2425547987,
-0.0637455359,
0.1041696817,
-0.0991363376,
0.1242044941,
-0.1983958632,
-0.3197878599,
-0.4294534326,
0.198332563,
-0.2380645275,
0.267694205,
-0.1645813286,
-0.2070681453,
-0.3419905603,
-0.5167453885,
0.3007124364,
0.0371912345,
-0.2925453782,
-0.3689043224,
0.7394274473,
0.4208139777,
-0.4959292114,
0.7012785077,
0.5510768294,
-0.2684243917,
0.0348532386,
-0.6264278889,
-0.1616761088,
-0.3724317253,
0.6171833277,
-0.2763152719,
-0.8466955423,
0.4100244641,
0.1644055396,
-0.0834397897,
0.0565355495,
0.4330038428,
-0.0179693438,
1.0049023628,
0.761197567,
-0.0543846078,
0.5553728342,
-0.4634325206,
0.1984457374,
-0.6898314953,
-0.5229485035,
-0.55771029,
-0.4852128625,
-0.2657856643,
-0.5548619628,
0.3752900958,
0.0635053962,
0.000176417,
0.5767179132,
-0.4069875479,
0.5650994182,
0.5094817877,
0.0803593397,
0.4705699682,
0.1870044768,
-0.3071071506,
-0.047831174,
-0.9230464697,
-0.36120224,
1.1611945629,
-0.1504879296,
0.8358651996,
0.2852989733,
0.5167544484,
0.1618159711,
0.082801491,
-0.7119237185,
0.3424371481,
-0.3455091417,
-0.7468850017,
-0.007746004,
-0.6376608014,
-1.1598211527,
0.6384860277,
-0.1532806307,
-0.6474708915,
0.5198695064,
-0.0903196111,
-0.432364285,
0.5981038213,
-0.6296714544,
0.8677005768,
-0.1652729809,
-0.7156258821,
-0.515727818,
-0.5886560082,
0.2973775864,
-0.2242543995,
0.2654087842,
-0.347717464,
0.0351128019,
0.3763216138,
0.0782353729,
0.3277779222,
-0.0467024446,
0.0073103537,
0.086706765,
0.2030885071,
0.4827817678,
0.2626116574,
-0.732198298,
0.5167315006,
0.0526734926,
-0.8245178461,
-0.3073061705,
0.7721961141,
-0.6379500031,
-0.3546540439,
-0.4168511331,
-0.7139894962,
0.2891371548,
0.3269286752,
0.3622768521,
0.4948631227,
-0.3801142871,
0.4779886901,
0.6788806319,
-0.4256455004,
0.48394683,
0.7775330544,
-0.3742623925,
-0.2458026111,
1.3121272326,
0.5625785589,
0.0797108859,
0.85048908,
-0.1510669291,
-0.339926362,
-0.3053203821,
-0.4097365439,
0.1408295482,
-0.673140347,
-0.3600253165,
-0.8464130759,
0.1254517585,
-0.2670743167,
-0.1328670532,
-0.3379885256,
-0.6605221629,
-0.3780227602,
-0.1052776948,
-0.0575348288,
0.6225960851,
-0.2983249724,
0.1705017835,
-0.8353524804,
0.283380121,
0.2630768716,
0.3863312602,
-0.0267127901,
-0.3419857919,
-0.4547154605,
-0.1095600128,
-0.4704250097,
-0.7908356786,
0.4130777121,
0.3361790776,
0.4500674307,
0.2276345789,
0.0291786231,
0.5301116705,
-0.553011775,
0.4872373939,
0.398152858,
-0.8709090352,
0.269222945,
-0.448610127,
0.325769186,
0.4503844082,
0.5507781506,
-0.6459922194,
0.1836655736,
-0.1097058132,
-0.8371476531,
0.8029409051,
0.1019780859,
0.5083328485,
-0.4259541333,
0.1540934592,
0.4098309278,
0.2748111188,
-0.6580649018,
-0.0579972826,
-0.3491586745,
0.1795082092,
-0.0318310037,
-0.1966342628,
0.2332191169,
-0.5894551873,
0.7759910226,
-0.2036971748,
0.2508231103,
0.2172995061,
-0.5727567673,
-0.0436433107,
0.5488216281,
0.3904732168,
0.5184515119,
-0.1979173124,
0.342761606,
0.0425672606,
-0.1077208444,
0.3436351418,
0.1126081049,
-0.0008510638,
0.1827081293,
-0.0762899965,
0.5173738003,
0.4467841685,
-0.5541734695,
0.7187703252,
-0.0520479828,
0.0038165159,
-0.2088559568,
-0.2085462958,
-0.0683373511,
0.0421739668,
0.5485095978,
0.1875293702,
0.0950291827,
-0.5044826865,
0.3907534778,
0.7334268093,
-0.5848604441,
-0.7300176024,
0.7858759761,
0.0451237746,
-0.0314400606,
0.8087766767,
-0.5385435224,
-0.1210450903,
0.239113152,
0.3270378709,
0.6038767695,
-0.2413691729,
0.4065408409,
0.5229560137,
0.2976595163,
-0.0768740177,
0.7089904547,
-0.2474477589,
-0.5992504358,
-0.4130417705,
-0.5297323465,
-0.0636289716,
-0.1630966663,
-0.8312464356,
0.6074348688,
-0.2859383225,
-0.0792351514,
-0.2833652794,
-0.1986357272,
-0.9065606594,
-0.1212919205,
0.2615773976,
1.0799771547,
-0.3969074488,
1.00527668,
0.6158419847,
-0.4058365226,
-0.3522520661,
-0.5024141669,
-0.1453484148,
-0.9913672805,
0.6942442656,
0.2001556456,
-0.0369686075,
0.3131196201,
-0.3237103224,
-1.0300488472,
1.056899786,
0.9444150925,
-0.7103322148,
0.1321906,
0.0473321341,
0.1191360056,
-0.1759864241,
0.4334905446,
0.0413716771,
0.4886344373,
0.2339212596,
-0.7507266998,
-0.1506720781,
-0.442419678,
-0.0498295091,
0.1627717912,
-0.8051124215,
1.0175685883,
-0.454241246,
-0.3479043543,
0.1649994403,
0.5441719294,
-0.0293534622,
-0.0317928158,
0.0700952336,
0.6743716598,
0.9224322438,
0.0791590214,
1.116268754,
-0.5298211575,
0.597943902,
0.8150517344,
-0.4812583327,
1.2192122936,
0.3751225173,
0.2641105056,
0.6133394241,
0.1750544012,
0.2594149411,
0.5210928321,
0.192223534,
-0.5448861718,
-0.5857926607,
-0.3974456191,
-0.4236813486,
0.4039729834,
0.174264878,
-0.1878335923,
-0.5341438055,
0.1160072163,
0.1100171059,
-0.0782846734,
-0.2810606956,
0.5487565994,
-0.0509542786,
-0.4058452249,
0.7450428009,
0.0686065704,
0.8244000077,
-0.6810829639,
0.1252528429,
-0.1549378932,
0.2431415766,
-0.3435373902,
-0.6131703854,
0.273644805,
-0.249765262,
-0.3660703599,
-0.4900215268,
0.4572449327,
-0.7285061479,
-0.8633046746,
0.5235304832,
0.6282721758,
0.2548215687,
-0.2642674744,
-0.5429538488,
0.0530505292,
-0.180880785,
-0.1390981227,
0.3848798871,
0.2966372967,
0.0347092524,
0.4542145431,
0.6823962331,
0.0429804437,
0.3809341192,
-0.1156404242,
0.7587705255,
-0.7374463081,
-0.5090306401,
-0.5821886063,
0.6081579328,
0.1638760567,
-0.0641922802,
0.619507432,
0.8847850561,
0.8872873187,
0.0764881521,
0.9401594996,
0.1447976977,
0.1687178016,
-0.212820664,
0.8757706881,
-0.8487196565,
0.0225454848,
0.0315912776,
-1.0995666981,
-0.5207850933,
0.5395395756,
-0.1224432662,
0.0085077202,
0.4993412197,
0.8266375661,
-0.5450268984,
-0.1476485878,
0.7702558637,
0.2102146447,
0.1965432465,
0.4816402197,
0.6707924604,
-0.4578988552,
0.9250469804,
-0.1482072771,
-0.1020735428,
-0.156741634,
-0.8318083286,
-0.6541353464,
-0.4022524953,
-0.3331729174,
0.154834941,
-0.0730510727,
0.8493561745,
1.213232398,
-0.7477172613,
-0.3970835507,
0.3216037452,
0.2095380127,
-0.0085180653,
-0.2008848637,
0.1342043579,
-0.7155867219,
-0.7098956108,
0.6742243171,
0.7207627296,
-0.294480145,
-0.328543663,
-0.0955822468,
-0.4460768998,
0.0345246233,
0.8393304944,
0.2946124971,
-0.3748489022,
-0.2422627956,
0.5594725013,
-0.109774299,
0.573741436,
0.9476824999,
-0.9957697392,
0.7780466676,
0.7430329323,
0.5676487684,
0.5379869342,
-0.393866837,
0.5263285041,
-0.9955726266,
0.205560118,
0.0940423608,
0.556902647,
0.522290051,
-0.4597614408,
0.0828094259,
0.2620815635,
-0.4855279624,
-0.6602427363,
0.1870548576,
-0.7857744098,
-0.2349229753,
1.0319709778,
-0.1736522913,
-0.0555212386,
-0.4128312767,
-0.0753772706,
-0.0118028354,
-0.5500219464,
0.8062508106,
0.5248647928,
0.1713144481,
-0.2133865356,
-0.4373589456,
-0.1232043728,
0.6671571732,
-0.3894919753,
-0.0223272257,
0.1246685013,
0.3138812482,
0.3348302841,
0.6509667039,
-0.2272126526,
0.2121479809,
-0.5169120431,
0.182606861,
0.0534874909,
-0.46940431,
-0.519967258,
0.5006455779,
-0.2643963099,
-0.1160599291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15057v1
|
On the Multi-turn Instruction Following for Conversational Web Agents
| 2024-02-23T02:18:12 | 2024-02-23T02:18:12 |
Yang Deng, Xuan Zhang, Wenxuan Zhang, Yifei Yuan, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Web agents powered by Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated
remarkable abilities in planning and executing multi-step interactions within
complex web-based environments, fulfilling a wide range of web navigation
tasks. Despite these advancements, the potential for LLM-powered agents to
effectively engage with sequential user instructions in real-world scenarios
has not been fully explored. In this work, we introduce a new task of
Conversational Web Navigation, which necessitates sophisticated interactions
that span multiple turns with both the users and the environment, supported by
a specially developed dataset named Multi-Turn Mind2Web (MT-Mind2Web). To
tackle the limited context length of LLMs and the context-dependency issue of
the conversational tasks, we further propose a novel framework, named
self-reflective memory-augmented planning (Self-MAP), which employs memory
utilization and self-reflection techniques. Extensive experiments are conducted
to benchmark the MT-Mind2Web dataset, and validate the effectiveness of the
proposed method.
|
[
-0.6346088052,
-0.6748561263,
0.7797184587,
0.6273750067,
0.0616115406,
0.1505010575,
-0.2543933094,
-0.2611429989,
0.2953962386,
0.5993427038,
-0.9918936491,
-0.3520464897,
-0.0842449442,
-0.2288014591,
-0.4154834151,
0.735938549,
0.1678086519,
0.0311153196,
-0.2782420516,
0.0166668352,
-0.4180574119,
-0.4482469261,
-0.3926568925,
-0.3624523878,
0.6843189597,
0.7163131237,
0.7403072715,
0.1009221971,
0.3638097942,
0.2979668975,
0.6359152794,
0.472702384,
-0.4552293718,
0.2024850547,
-0.3708829582,
-0.231173411,
-0.6178694963,
0.1467989087,
0.2666682005,
0.2614396513,
-0.5690283775,
0.0577603802,
-0.1025472581,
0.6427385211,
-0.6087965965,
0.2362116873,
-0.3972205222,
-0.0560193174,
0.148547411,
-0.3880748451,
-0.7058001161,
-0.1115235835,
0.2880719006,
-0.6029939651,
0.0497887321,
0.0850557536,
0.1687248349,
0.229772687,
-0.4229200184,
-0.3213413656,
-0.8192173839,
0.7899662852,
-0.6459248066,
0.4434937537,
0.3005075157,
0.3671417832,
-0.30477947,
-0.5589370131,
-0.8863088489,
0.1611309201,
0.0541597418,
0.3339976966,
0.0407078974,
-0.0167669803,
0.0616255812,
-0.2392312884,
-0.4952818453,
0.1764770895,
-0.010938528,
-0.0181272477,
0.6042314768,
0.3909144402,
0.2879877687,
0.1259368062,
-0.539111197,
-0.267896086,
-0.4438954294,
-0.1177343652,
0.0371001549,
0.5788056254,
-0.2125318199,
0.4165753126,
-0.3815139532,
0.763335228,
0.0449922904,
-0.3292945623,
0.0921304524,
-0.226115942,
0.0426730067,
-0.0778758451,
0.6534771323,
0.8000019789,
0.3735502064,
-0.3749622107,
-0.0220146962,
-0.2110351026,
0.7290437222,
-0.9297938347,
-0.2405925393,
0.4565508664,
-0.2694727182,
0.1915296316,
-0.0931854397,
-0.8030248284,
-0.2092883885,
-0.2501474917,
0.4196726382,
-0.4438851476,
-0.2957596779,
0.1929370016,
0.0652259141,
0.6493985057,
0.4932059944,
-0.8389409184,
0.3947956264,
0.5765873194,
0.6325908303,
-0.2306218594,
-0.6147525311,
-0.1918190569,
0.4129274189,
-0.1695275456,
0.8220072389,
-0.6507896781,
-0.5100418329,
0.3188216388,
-0.2943010628,
-0.0084544225,
-0.2543238699,
-0.0974631459,
-0.6853329539,
0.3505469263,
-0.2562234104,
-0.148158595,
-0.4177840054,
0.6022567153,
-0.3620284498,
0.6576130986,
-0.1856881231,
-0.2172553986,
-0.0290435478,
-0.5566267967,
-0.7662366033,
-0.1744318753,
-0.150672242,
-0.1235696375,
-0.1882053763,
0.173667267,
0.5416059494,
-0.1648918986,
-0.2748536766,
-0.0906577036,
-0.1853719205,
0.4650911987,
-0.2968162894,
0.2895557284,
-0.2685496211,
-0.4026668668,
0.022190446,
-0.74753654,
0.4671438336,
0.225922972,
-0.4197134674,
-0.1967678517,
0.3060543537,
-0.1373521537,
0.4585649669,
0.3632366359,
-0.4643000364,
0.6404262781,
0.0874519497,
-0.0462732762,
0.7426470518,
-0.0308126695,
0.3795042336,
-0.1950060874,
0.5058091283,
-0.1196521297,
0.3090831041,
-0.3861548007,
-0.5334399939,
-1.1044021845,
0.0601950139,
-0.3547891974,
0.6062748432,
-0.8043441772,
0.0555689149,
-0.3460891247,
-0.3877265751,
-0.2328775376,
-0.0140900826,
0.7512710094,
0.2109550238,
0.9673497677,
-0.2522319555,
-0.2963182926,
-0.8079302907,
-0.1557436436,
-0.1222989261,
0.1258218586,
0.4318504632,
0.2229975462,
-0.5374184847,
0.982874155,
-0.5928875804,
-0.5613737106,
-0.2110093832,
0.3034494221,
-0.1914220899,
0.4265838265,
0.0224946048,
-0.6929339767,
-0.525069654,
-0.4168689251,
-0.717389226,
0.0092217801,
-0.545219779,
-0.2944345772,
0.0959164575,
0.293363899,
-0.6981475949,
0.4367919564,
0.421005249,
-0.0979615375,
0.4490295351,
-0.1728522778,
0.1077857241,
-0.6444596052,
-0.4939427078,
0.0530789606,
-0.1444895864,
-0.9459391832,
0.0179460831,
0.1841142029,
0.3743791282,
-0.4378519952,
0.5660638213,
-0.9096421003,
-0.2246316373,
-0.5303179622,
0.2695831358,
-0.05176064,
1.013599515,
0.1205556691,
0.7652135491,
0.0612342544,
-0.873142302,
0.1033017933,
0.4439471364,
0.2020001113,
0.5749900341,
0.0555893853,
0.6563420892,
0.2784766555,
0.35898453,
-0.9325081706,
0.0781002194,
0.1050089598,
-0.2369667292,
0.2634999454,
0.0079262471,
-0.4611171782,
-0.4427375197,
-0.164979592,
0.1827121377,
0.2976384759,
-0.6521268487,
1.0808031559,
0.3092409968,
0.0851284415,
-0.2699435651,
-0.7237772942,
0.3159054518,
0.0921000987,
-0.5711946487,
0.4624230564,
-0.1274077594,
-0.1631579697,
-0.3799395263,
0.1035514846,
0.1058303192,
-0.2215679288,
0.3776702285,
0.1547321975,
0.149239704,
-0.1476428509,
-0.2006464452,
-0.0549086668,
0.2028468698,
-0.3048898876,
0.9124114513,
-0.1459951252,
-0.5420506001,
-0.6516309977,
0.4025708437,
0.3756890595,
-0.1877756417,
0.526458025,
0.4403195679,
-0.0081501435,
-0.3282693326,
-0.8528212905,
-0.3802432716,
-0.5482343435,
0.0929446369,
-0.4992532134,
-0.5316051841,
0.4019425213,
-0.1436122507,
0.3608695269,
-0.0750736892,
0.6216486096,
-0.5005730987,
1.0694639683,
0.5593318343,
0.029134484,
0.3389407992,
-0.4211585522,
0.1540537626,
-1.1521713734,
-0.4650434256,
-0.0710315183,
-0.6772091389,
-0.5223639607,
-0.7776202559,
0.358242631,
-0.3236756921,
-0.1056194976,
0.1156409755,
-0.3333966434,
0.0560094528,
0.69317168,
0.1854118854,
0.2031547278,
-0.0863553956,
-0.2061335593,
0.1117328778,
-0.5748913884,
-0.296982795,
1.045055747,
-0.0967944488,
0.9572696686,
0.3702878952,
0.6559790373,
0.2661221921,
0.3449045122,
-0.7170798779,
1.0605974197,
0.2753425241,
-0.4968262315,
-0.6106212735,
0.0657071993,
-1.07508564,
0.5288314223,
-0.0063748285,
-0.6069018245,
-0.0862399042,
0.2672398984,
-0.2805181146,
0.1089530885,
-0.6580147147,
0.5802528262,
-0.7254840732,
-0.6765044332,
-0.7492437363,
-0.6586257219,
0.0867750049,
0.3824451566,
0.3317281604,
-0.0177888516,
-0.0815347582,
0.5800340176,
-0.2233367413,
0.9884275198,
-0.5150684118,
-0.0912593603,
0.4941485226,
0.2865939736,
0.6363362074,
-0.4122892618,
0.4125533998,
-0.0448909178,
-0.4019158483,
-0.3651885986,
-0.6998831034,
0.623296082,
-0.541215241,
-0.8828256726,
-0.5369265676,
-0.3855135441,
-0.7705968022,
0.1529981643,
-0.3849791884,
0.3518573642,
-0.4123623371,
-0.1998195201,
0.5251886845,
-0.167676121,
0.7508863807,
1.2271747589,
-0.6352183223,
-0.1739457995,
1.0403872728,
0.0916646942,
0.2880891562,
0.412587285,
0.1114828065,
-0.3304734826,
-0.5047056675,
-0.5492872,
0.1708387434,
-0.3716479838,
-0.0352076739,
-0.6451830268,
-0.0024665992,
-0.3075978458,
-0.0689769089,
-0.4124090075,
-0.3428300023,
-0.2947337627,
-0.0915537775,
0.1515735239,
0.6402109265,
-0.0534169562,
0.4678173363,
-0.5742994547,
0.4343418181,
0.6378376484,
0.0923315287,
0.4608545303,
-0.1655698866,
-0.388656199,
0.0134705845,
-0.4217066169,
-0.8976277113,
0.3641698062,
0.0273461118,
0.6459417939,
0.5667859316,
-0.0909272581,
0.9152474403,
-0.8032559156,
0.5104689002,
0.4210695624,
-0.3746050298,
0.5493665338,
-0.3602840006,
0.7157552242,
0.4256336093,
0.4309760332,
-0.7213911414,
-0.1625963897,
-0.3560524285,
-0.8249695301,
0.6434330344,
-0.0221151765,
0.236757502,
-0.1065782979,
0.3161276877,
-0.0605271012,
0.2747687697,
-0.349732697,
-0.3388465047,
-0.3903922439,
0.0275893044,
0.1218932047,
-0.3249167502,
-0.0828380734,
0.1172957569,
0.6503830552,
-0.5180882215,
0.5108440518,
0.1481060237,
-0.3107468188,
0.1626453847,
0.2734154761,
0.5207027197,
0.6038373113,
-0.081573762,
0.3062304556,
0.0628174096,
-0.4593576789,
0.137348026,
-0.0645743385,
-0.1486137807,
-0.6902443171,
0.1633837968,
0.3288407922,
0.3344275653,
-0.599476397,
0.2707205713,
-0.1278700978,
0.3884051144,
-0.59916991,
0.239701584,
0.341727376,
0.326080054,
0.6546534896,
-0.2324836254,
0.3040446043,
-0.6413707733,
0.1150698885,
0.6033443213,
-0.4944928885,
-0.4364974797,
0.2061534226,
0.4944488108,
-0.6750374436,
0.7614363432,
-0.3801158965,
-0.6240044832,
0.1682816595,
0.6463542581,
0.8321225047,
-0.3749139607,
0.1791220307,
0.2198756486,
0.1359009892,
0.0748530179,
0.5970256329,
-0.2743194997,
-0.9536874294,
-0.0132561913,
-0.3162606061,
-0.5058570504,
-0.2702815533,
-0.6747738719,
-0.3300929666,
-0.4900481105,
-0.3837335408,
-0.4429076612,
-0.1633989513,
-0.6506590247,
0.4354927242,
0.2011783123,
0.6447362304,
-0.0270056203,
0.766469717,
0.3621431589,
-0.2631946504,
-0.4401168823,
0.1690366268,
0.3293819129,
-0.9933387637,
0.4056963325,
0.3938277066,
-0.8656876087,
0.1235200316,
-0.4357075095,
-0.6354498863,
1.2063113451,
-0.3535218835,
-0.6809079051,
-0.0915714651,
0.2121622562,
0.431011796,
-0.4505423605,
0.3105299771,
0.4465558827,
0.521957159,
0.0158558972,
-0.7799221873,
0.0507243462,
-0.0232224073,
-0.106027022,
-0.0176449418,
-1.4420100451,
0.3897098899,
-0.5293425322,
-0.1945095509,
-0.1391034275,
0.9265004992,
0.2373622507,
0.222153917,
0.6670741439,
0.4849714041,
0.4852459133,
0.1902958304,
0.7731380463,
-0.2828067243,
-0.0559125841,
1.5192734003,
-0.5443948507,
1.0805015564,
0.5251640677,
-0.3120929003,
0.9158667922,
0.1587942541,
0.2058481425,
0.5956558585,
0.013057447,
-0.2286158651,
-0.4478641152,
0.1238438264,
-0.0057063662,
0.5959144235,
0.5142953992,
0.1143101081,
0.0338212885,
0.0770353898,
0.2160652727,
0.0802070722,
-0.1885596961,
0.8619104624,
0.0149945701,
-0.9856801629,
0.1828185916,
0.0078064385,
0.6680774689,
-0.5395259857,
-0.1388171464,
-0.1658667326,
0.3082535863,
-0.1507000178,
-0.888589561,
-0.1606183648,
-0.1888599843,
-0.1340380907,
-0.5737044811,
0.5470267534,
-0.2512287796,
-0.2420835942,
0.6529496312,
0.6948028207,
0.112587288,
-0.1443852782,
-0.5992743969,
-0.0260389354,
0.1635122597,
-0.5842000842,
0.5309352279,
0.0409232974,
-0.0120697469,
1.2477793694,
0.5964993238,
-0.3531753123,
0.3863195777,
0.270934701,
0.6859184504,
-0.9133563638,
-0.443903774,
-0.619136095,
0.3853507042,
-0.0583523586,
-0.106881462,
0.9443870783,
0.8601281047,
0.5780271888,
0.230351299,
0.7253876328,
0.1763723791,
0.4896616638,
-0.5958781242,
0.2442907393,
-0.2939499915,
0.0488058887,
0.1498185992,
-0.6176991463,
0.2255267203,
0.5726703405,
-0.2315607518,
0.2048778236,
0.4263319969,
0.7740482688,
-0.00227092,
0.14302136,
0.2097997367,
0.2995212376,
0.578053534,
0.4746578932,
0.8871427178,
-0.032039158,
0.5302305222,
-0.2362815738,
-0.2653366327,
-0.3559361398,
-0.5964067578,
-0.9143462777,
-0.615047574,
-0.1429316401,
-0.347995609,
0.0363091081,
0.8525332808,
0.9039706588,
-0.6054453254,
-0.5806842446,
0.0980459899,
-0.1410279125,
-0.3849817216,
-0.1891025007,
0.0515487865,
-0.3576648235,
-0.5551890135,
0.7403931022,
0.5986210108,
0.0826562196,
-0.9376319647,
-0.222369805,
-0.7160463929,
0.3170605898,
0.6988872886,
0.2560536861,
-0.8148450255,
-0.3449009955,
0.1136620864,
-0.2209636569,
0.2553753555,
0.9168294072,
-1.0355772972,
0.5544443727,
-0.0348333828,
0.2449663877,
1.1776775122,
0.1665557623,
0.4239824414,
-0.4340248406,
-0.0271917284,
0.1560407281,
-0.0315597914,
0.4207178056,
-0.1670831591,
0.5469687581,
-0.1892811209,
-0.4047594368,
-0.2033465505,
0.2396284342,
-1.2480456829,
-0.3820619285,
1.2983219624,
0.0610202849,
-0.0638129935,
-0.0681830719,
-0.1893405765,
-0.0448926017,
-0.4840007424,
0.8729968667,
0.5853164792,
-0.8977572918,
-0.2234849185,
-0.4030588567,
0.2312424481,
0.1599417031,
-0.8299891949,
0.0368134342,
0.7012166977,
0.0450183339,
0.5873677135,
0.9626127481,
0.3302479982,
-0.0269522388,
-0.1306501031,
0.3817938864,
-0.0813650191,
-0.7016051412,
0.2696516812,
0.1488183141,
-0.301405102,
-0.1866604239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15055v1
|
Interpreting Context Look-ups in Transformers: Investigating Attention-MLP Interactions
| 2024-02-23T02:15:47 | 2024-02-23T02:15:47 |
Clement Neo, Shay B. Cohen, Fazl Barez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we investigate the interplay between attention heads and
specialized "next-token" neurons in the Multilayer Perceptron that predict
specific tokens. By prompting an LLM like GPT-4 to explain these model
internals, we can elucidate attention mechanisms that activate certain
next-token neurons. Our analysis identifies attention heads that recognize
contexts relevant to predicting a particular token, activating the associated
neuron through the residual connection. We focus specifically on heads in
earlier layers consistently activating the same next-token neuron across
similar prompts. Exploring these differential activation patterns reveals that
heads that specialize for distinct linguistic contexts are tied to generating
certain tokens. Overall, our method combines neural explanations and probing
isolated components to illuminate how attention enables context-dependent,
specialized processing in LLMs.
|
[
-0.4953413308,
-0.5535786152,
0.6418020129,
0.1635705978,
-0.0994279906,
-0.1531248093,
-0.0935899243,
-0.3516821265,
0.1878768057,
0.574328661,
-1.0688451529,
-0.0160766561,
-0.5461258292,
0.2352611721,
-0.608666718,
0.8670346737,
0.2271353453,
-0.3742489219,
-0.324070245,
0.0523157418,
-0.6450889707,
-0.8158045411,
-0.9681735039,
-0.6812664866,
0.8165230751,
0.2788737416,
0.5698211789,
0.3187128901,
0.61286062,
0.3430086672,
-0.3014506102,
-0.251088649,
-0.4006108046,
0.0115972292,
-0.2803678215,
-0.4636185765,
-0.5227735639,
-0.0147169009,
0.643291533,
0.5300271511,
0.2536346614,
0.348367691,
0.2566221058,
0.3362862468,
-0.4062754512,
0.1830716729,
-1.0945245028,
0.4400907159,
-0.209560439,
-0.7261568308,
-0.5606482625,
0.6388123631,
0.3909873664,
-0.2711420953,
0.29529953,
-0.2810246944,
0.7666876316,
0.4957364202,
-0.4084382355,
0.1882303953,
-0.2876363397,
0.7253697515,
-0.4394859672,
0.3279810548,
0.0615533553,
0.1138938069,
-0.0973253474,
-1.2242414951,
-0.5694538355,
-0.0239619426,
-0.4076271951,
0.2754202783,
-0.0900419876,
-0.0198620278,
0.3395326734,
0.112312682,
-0.0805913806,
-0.0384707637,
-0.2436501533,
-0.2451942116,
-0.0360006094,
0.124964796,
0.2509140372,
-0.1128512546,
-0.6783084273,
0.2620360851,
-0.8699797988,
0.0876440927,
0.1354257166,
0.322485894,
-0.1718363166,
0.8171658516,
0.1194598079,
0.8533331752,
0.5014554858,
0.1894036233,
0.2162986398,
-0.3464680612,
-0.4837240577,
0.1251170784,
0.4315497875,
0.3698611557,
0.5031658411,
-0.2800886035,
-0.1102855131,
-0.2822932601,
0.630497396,
-0.5759709477,
0.0025775174,
0.1712031513,
-0.525678277,
-0.5172537565,
-0.0725909248,
-0.4460782707,
-0.0294289943,
-0.6181123853,
0.3804242015,
-0.0684641153,
-0.1036261246,
-0.2013762146,
-0.267614603,
0.5325139761,
-0.1573778242,
-1.2332390547,
0.1575222909,
0.5755517483,
0.8989759684,
-0.6132986546,
-0.7514386177,
-0.5016513467,
0.4659053683,
0.0434998386,
0.9152234793,
-0.5574961901,
-0.0400769673,
-0.104836382,
0.2556944788,
-0.1413729638,
-0.5967711806,
0.6815346479,
-0.788361609,
-0.0211455841,
-0.5186943412,
-0.1667963713,
-0.0618467219,
0.2459607124,
-0.7366012335,
0.9734248519,
0.2404415309,
-1.0983992815,
0.4556095004,
-0.8153754473,
-0.3385652602,
0.2931214571,
-0.4572826028,
-0.0314495973,
0.4372134805,
0.2479385734,
0.6935301423,
0.0319084898,
0.0023262592,
-0.0959655941,
-0.3949297071,
0.4843965173,
-0.4114352465,
0.6160526276,
-0.3051744103,
-0.5102615952,
0.4742559493,
-0.4140221179,
-0.1066869125,
0.1822928935,
-0.2055564374,
-0.0083015841,
-0.0242550168,
-0.0843283758,
0.5584600568,
0.3590581715,
-0.0924188122,
0.0683364794,
-0.1776587069,
0.7410373092,
1.0299304724,
-0.0007950003,
0.3999247253,
0.103392601,
0.3980672956,
0.4884909689,
0.0385551341,
-0.5263031721,
-0.6648166776,
-0.6895914674,
0.1075827256,
-0.0903237313,
0.2525606453,
-0.5968188643,
0.2564962506,
-0.1744907647,
0.2201423049,
-0.1052265987,
-0.3146608174,
0.2081753761,
0.9616861939,
0.502220571,
-0.3558408618,
-0.5043488145,
-1.2357198,
-0.413507849,
0.2574835122,
-0.2894869149,
0.5391117334,
0.2463680357,
-0.5093856454,
1.2185688019,
-0.2363039106,
-0.3958761394,
-0.2048768103,
-0.2010761797,
0.3487941027,
0.2176613212,
0.6033997536,
-0.7977818847,
-0.3597828448,
0.0712273419,
-0.5670984387,
-0.1639789492,
-0.2588995695,
-0.3533708453,
-0.2432681024,
0.7814075351,
-0.7756712437,
0.2886920869,
0.4676178694,
-0.5102308393,
0.5172421932,
0.1199632511,
-0.1234223023,
-0.7715346217,
0.1060112491,
-0.2377810329,
-0.0773814842,
-0.8543512225,
-0.0279021524,
-0.0290717334,
0.071881935,
-0.5637727976,
0.6449582577,
-0.3046371937,
-0.8119824529,
-0.1840897202,
0.3181369007,
-0.1034820527,
0.8368835449,
0.2598498464,
0.8665544391,
0.5250983238,
-0.5886785388,
0.1205868125,
0.4169526994,
-0.0416106209,
0.5540066361,
-0.7854270935,
0.2766548693,
-0.0058813016,
0.1185284704,
-1.115729332,
-0.2792513371,
0.2165093571,
-0.5441129208,
0.4098309278,
-0.1620176136,
-0.3018423021,
-0.2323817313,
-0.055344265,
0.8066810966,
0.0495616607,
-0.7234620452,
0.918299973,
0.5052033067,
-0.1432993859,
-0.888109982,
-0.9767675996,
0.1772684008,
-0.3466275632,
-0.2782621384,
0.7106461525,
0.0913963094,
-0.0379569679,
-0.1424266845,
-0.2247670591,
-0.0048187585,
0.1051058769,
0.2161230892,
0.005521399,
-0.1832875162,
-0.2008397728,
0.0607488304,
-0.3254267573,
0.3936046064,
-0.3539592922,
0.8587731719,
-0.0739727989,
-0.1648729593,
-0.5517271161,
0.1464496106,
0.7691130638,
-0.2134226114,
0.4649610221,
0.7045565844,
-0.2864671052,
0.1496597826,
-0.2400739938,
-0.4676900208,
-0.5733222365,
0.580262363,
-0.9149622917,
-0.6980308294,
0.7629936934,
0.1063457802,
-0.09416008,
0.5823554397,
1.0707728863,
0.0783740208,
0.9449210167,
0.4702143967,
0.0177210588,
0.6646428108,
-0.1096179485,
0.1168070287,
-1.3343043327,
-0.2488446385,
0.0542512871,
-0.5067417026,
-0.2582157254,
-0.3147350848,
0.2582398951,
-0.0445901304,
-0.0969366804,
0.4763841927,
-0.6552416086,
0.8922547698,
0.5346800089,
-0.0799474791,
0.151344344,
0.1105340272,
-0.3968134224,
-0.0396783762,
-0.6484735608,
-0.3366779387,
1.0667500496,
0.477334559,
0.1085189953,
-0.1936160028,
0.3074916899,
0.1803673804,
0.491944015,
-0.8130262494,
0.6329936385,
0.181572929,
-0.5499021411,
-0.1110955551,
0.0154132582,
-1.0286632776,
0.4126553833,
0.0709205419,
-0.976190567,
0.0090790419,
0.1895143539,
-0.3040132821,
0.1400918067,
-0.6323963404,
1.0157902241,
-0.1348227859,
-0.1921301335,
-0.1508274525,
-0.7578174472,
0.4991263449,
-0.0559055135,
-0.1577914655,
0.1027734876,
-0.2397609949,
0.5706768036,
0.4332050383,
0.7781821489,
0.09124244,
-0.3421156406,
0.0883376524,
-0.0167778358,
0.2320576906,
0.1370638311,
0.2581521869,
0.5180673599,
-0.3639453053,
-0.1698273122,
-0.3282917738,
0.851662159,
-0.6764520407,
-0.5359771848,
-0.2067650557,
-0.6600540876,
-0.2123802453,
0.2881749272,
0.4943005145,
0.4418785274,
0.1672123075,
-0.0269664973,
0.3572683632,
-0.1060595587,
0.4975396097,
0.1151668578,
-0.2083903253,
-0.0735823363,
0.6140412092,
-0.1504823864,
0.2414584607,
0.5240710378,
0.002880329,
-0.2278138697,
-0.4130882621,
-0.3118864,
0.1888472885,
-0.9427611232,
0.0149001675,
-0.7048283219,
-0.3000859022,
-0.2027772218,
0.0030540705,
-0.2435256243,
-0.3346075118,
-0.3953883052,
-0.2120242715,
-0.2771345675,
0.6108829379,
0.1992297769,
0.4749124646,
-0.6847162843,
0.4351986647,
0.4975139797,
0.4020727277,
0.2999098301,
-0.6716987491,
-0.379460305,
-0.297033757,
-0.2484129369,
-0.9902496338,
0.2426579148,
0.0134428218,
0.6841762066,
0.6301356554,
-0.5725707412,
0.4903729558,
-1.0199477673,
0.9186275601,
0.0755035505,
-1.1050504446,
0.2619555295,
-0.3559888303,
0.572201252,
0.1974437982,
0.1544773877,
-0.5675732493,
-0.3486272991,
-0.746375978,
-0.9458488822,
0.9771817923,
0.4023555219,
0.2069772184,
-0.1850503832,
0.6813591719,
0.0240350757,
0.3701063693,
-0.9405300021,
-0.5716544986,
-0.0536097251,
0.0696066767,
-0.1250467449,
-0.5539516807,
-0.4145397544,
-0.0954653695,
0.0254113022,
-0.2728153765,
0.9500054121,
0.0953658745,
-0.0855637714,
-0.044569727,
-0.1084555313,
0.9370592237,
0.7715564966,
-0.0889524147,
0.3113676012,
0.2778411806,
-0.5085610151,
-0.2050970048,
-0.2369521558,
0.0768405795,
0.1185248867,
0.5688806176,
0.8659438491,
0.4419261217,
-0.2998280823,
0.4408799112,
-0.3179526031,
0.0304980632,
-0.5221403837,
-0.1228038222,
0.2226478308,
0.3770577908,
0.6380618215,
0.2283052802,
0.0776396245,
-0.5136057734,
0.5462484956,
0.5673373938,
-0.4850531816,
-0.6824323535,
0.7144239545,
0.271496594,
-0.4628334939,
0.3986328244,
0.3920081258,
-0.7562641501,
0.7968741059,
0.6093441844,
1.158339262,
-0.1173599213,
-0.2025308609,
0.082019642,
0.1661674529,
0.3960188031,
0.0352713764,
-0.3659314811,
-1.0553895235,
-0.7271688581,
-0.3592577875,
-0.2921125889,
0.4570167363,
-0.6627157331,
0.2030545324,
-0.2216150314,
-0.3225773871,
0.1264621019,
-0.6482226253,
-0.8968593478,
0.2169411033,
0.4233548641,
0.5579334497,
-0.7313961983,
0.7813398838,
0.5637297034,
-0.103911981,
-0.4500044882,
0.4787370563,
-0.1865844727,
-1.0692679882,
1.2465162277,
0.6066037416,
-0.2786490321,
0.3667476475,
-0.4127273858,
-1.1232603788,
0.9956066012,
0.2573624849,
-0.4760290086,
-0.2601138353,
0.0849279091,
0.3743607998,
-0.6081339121,
0.6202449203,
0.9243087769,
0.4837348759,
-0.1439908743,
-0.7487076521,
0.0707773194,
0.0940277502,
-0.144640103,
0.168462798,
-0.5453590751,
1.1147638559,
-0.1947198361,
-0.3031431735,
-0.2293061316,
0.5460489392,
0.216101855,
0.0343194529,
0.4383856356,
0.4445906878,
0.1909331083,
-0.0685125589,
1.06483531,
-0.6910297275,
0.3419308364,
1.1755657196,
-0.0879919454,
0.6801369786,
1.0257577896,
-0.1696874648,
0.4632841945,
0.6988551021,
0.1127504855,
0.6202973723,
-0.0625041649,
-0.148446545,
0.0194033235,
0.0603157766,
-0.218275696,
0.4821125865,
0.3391272128,
-0.5330030322,
0.0165278632,
-0.1633325219,
-0.364041537,
-0.6561703086,
-0.3779182732,
0.7606054544,
0.1026389822,
-0.7996119857,
0.3218078911,
-0.1556424648,
0.5770226121,
-0.3921576738,
0.0221538283,
-0.0420261025,
0.2955889106,
-0.2832202017,
-0.8946552873,
0.3384744227,
-0.2898305655,
-0.3132197261,
-0.267878443,
0.6719014645,
-0.3794508278,
-0.0145098511,
0.6072858572,
0.3257085681,
0.1405344456,
-0.2495404184,
-0.8795662522,
-0.0072234739,
-0.0085373027,
-0.7912082076,
0.4902935028,
0.4357498884,
0.1651054472,
0.4931797385,
0.6194036603,
-0.156786561,
0.1596647203,
0.3910134435,
0.8663772941,
-0.6899710298,
-0.4231668413,
-1.1315743923,
0.6739058495,
-0.0560901873,
-0.3177328408,
0.5139266849,
0.2218706161,
1.0301761627,
-0.3784136176,
0.4851450324,
0.2191634029,
0.1994011849,
-0.453856349,
0.404222995,
-0.5467380881,
0.1273902953,
-0.1989720315,
-1.1911518574,
-0.2901116312,
0.5436620116,
-0.0938943997,
0.0331704728,
1.0154746771,
0.4716225564,
-0.2278587073,
-0.307536304,
0.4682993591,
0.2787493467,
0.2985368967,
0.4873197675,
0.7579570413,
-0.1577963978,
0.4839298725,
-0.0126072429,
0.0387646928,
-0.1420961469,
-0.9990192652,
-1.0538649559,
-0.580180645,
0.0259305518,
-0.1282536834,
-0.5161525607,
0.4670595229,
0.540333569,
-0.7288305759,
-0.1700961441,
-0.4220089614,
0.0028001019,
-0.3351540565,
-0.3476777971,
0.3804392517,
-0.6693086028,
-0.8955109715,
0.39158535,
0.6571237445,
-0.0500052907,
-0.414236486,
0.2208043784,
-0.0499319248,
-0.0071261176,
0.8507984281,
-0.0086290175,
-0.9570234418,
-0.3817984164,
-0.0222486313,
-0.0004561679,
0.2444798499,
1.2482870817,
-0.9161348939,
0.0295642279,
0.4477793574,
0.7134913802,
0.659627676,
-0.0479000658,
0.7467592359,
-1.0615034103,
0.3791835904,
0.1984100193,
0.5334669352,
0.2294089645,
-0.5478100181,
0.3746085465,
0.2270345241,
-0.6456972957,
-0.7923380136,
0.6519972086,
-1.0951019526,
-0.079291679,
1.0277392864,
-0.1233068109,
-0.1328140944,
0.0652004033,
-0.2785966992,
0.1588148177,
-0.1219684109,
0.639495194,
0.8629474044,
-0.4553281665,
-0.3577115536,
-0.6193171144,
0.6602739096,
0.6582397819,
-0.534940362,
0.0737146959,
0.0200046413,
0.0682118535,
0.339117676,
0.4706564844,
-0.0424560905,
0.2235517055,
-0.2961461544,
-0.2003499717,
0.0368312709,
-0.5906567574,
-0.3966358304,
0.2521194518,
-0.2448699325,
-0.2216808051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15052v1
|
ToMBench: Benchmarking Theory of Mind in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T02:05:46 | 2024-02-23T02:05:46 |
Zhuang Chen, Jincenzi Wu, Jinfeng Zhou, Bosi Wen, Guanqun Bi, Gongyao Jiang, Yaru Cao, Mengting Hu, Yunghwei Lai, Zexuan Xiong, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Theory of Mind (ToM) is the cognitive capability to perceive and ascribe
mental states to oneself and others. Recent research has sparked a debate over
whether large language models (LLMs) exhibit a form of ToM. However, existing
ToM evaluations are hindered by challenges such as constrained scope,
subjective judgment, and unintended contamination, yielding inadequate
assessments. To address this gap, we introduce ToMBench with three key
characteristics: a systematic evaluation framework encompassing 8 tasks and 31
abilities in social cognition, a multiple-choice question format to support
automated and unbiased evaluation, and a build-from-scratch bilingual inventory
to strictly avoid data leakage. Based on ToMBench, we conduct extensive
experiments to evaluate the ToM performance of 10 popular LLMs across tasks and
abilities. We find that even the most advanced LLMs like GPT-4 lag behind human
performance by over 10% points, indicating that LLMs have not achieved a
human-level theory of mind yet. Our aim with ToMBench is to enable an efficient
and effective evaluation of LLMs' ToM capabilities, thereby facilitating the
development of LLMs with inherent social intelligence.
|
[
-0.5588723421,
-0.6704086065,
0.933853507,
0.3221347332,
-0.4457572699,
0.1401851624,
-0.5988380313,
-0.4974298775,
0.2808661759,
0.3220518827,
-0.4676991403,
-0.502094686,
-0.7626698613,
0.0434364267,
-0.3066916764,
0.8022373915,
-0.0355385244,
0.3739072382,
-0.0415494405,
-0.3293838799,
-0.1895966977,
-0.4553700686,
-0.8994855285,
-0.5517821908,
0.3663968146,
0.0132803498,
0.3305722773,
0.5002005696,
0.6585294008,
0.263684541,
0.0502636135,
-0.247312203,
-0.5165612698,
0.3639881313,
-0.3588590324,
-0.5660634041,
-0.6927061677,
-0.0306625608,
0.8801322579,
0.7045702338,
-0.1654716879,
0.1927153766,
0.2152526677,
0.7498195171,
-0.619315505,
0.4359380305,
-0.5853588581,
-0.1067875326,
-0.3225821257,
-0.1091288999,
-0.1261346787,
-0.3614445031,
0.4957332015,
-0.2078641057,
0.0866165087,
-0.0059143994,
0.3175846338,
0.1468807161,
-0.4226608872,
0.0063764444,
-0.4753871262,
0.9280844331,
-0.5873071551,
0.4040939808,
0.2731916904,
0.6189724207,
-0.0282960124,
-0.3136989474,
-0.5797425508,
-0.2973217964,
0.2924735546,
0.2697938383,
0.1845272332,
0.245973736,
0.3154758811,
0.4292528331,
-0.6483227611,
-0.4009601772,
-0.0818452612,
0.0497470684,
0.7294934392,
0.1113205403,
0.2481862754,
-0.214037329,
-0.3139907718,
-0.3974174261,
-0.5567954183,
-0.1978095323,
0.2207298875,
0.121379599,
0.0157422181,
0.3558748662,
-0.225900054,
0.2798556387,
0.0025328139,
-0.0070905383,
0.1582616419,
0.058957845,
-0.155447647,
-0.0618948564,
0.7373424172,
0.4157778025,
0.5430037975,
-0.3087833822,
-0.2987519503,
0.2336011529,
0.4108571708,
-0.8507434726,
-0.1343445778,
0.2262533456,
-0.3024584353,
-0.0041947784,
0.0823442116,
-0.897031188,
-0.5254613757,
0.0317323022,
0.370431304,
-0.3981154561,
-0.469109714,
0.1308793873,
-0.213429749,
0.1955995411,
0.2984721363,
-0.8750901818,
0.7353166342,
0.7394780517,
0.8501323462,
-0.4092585742,
-0.5147036314,
-0.1025454253,
0.3200336695,
-0.4918115139,
0.8207326531,
-0.3728635311,
-0.5376086831,
-0.0779261142,
0.0112884454,
0.0128564872,
-0.2975504398,
0.3430890143,
-0.3742938638,
0.0245282929,
-0.6171933413,
-0.5573772192,
-0.1980615854,
0.3644775748,
-0.6506287456,
0.7744071484,
0.2362905145,
-0.6026741862,
0.4242083728,
-0.5614584684,
-0.5562024713,
0.3257786632,
-0.622112751,
0.1926094294,
0.1215266287,
-0.1723894775,
0.62598598,
-0.780248642,
0.4336911142,
-0.4829765856,
-0.4154944718,
0.1344981641,
-0.2150473148,
0.8735722899,
0.0139928618,
-0.7708676457,
0.0702433437,
-0.6175406575,
0.3467794657,
0.1936770976,
-0.2336605936,
-0.6274493933,
-0.0292466488,
-0.0756231248,
0.0913707092,
0.2407899499,
-0.4043006003,
-0.0511400402,
-0.3976752758,
0.4118674397,
0.8405239582,
-0.1720713675,
0.4487521648,
-0.4338999689,
0.5408956409,
-0.4095148146,
0.0745965466,
0.1863651425,
-0.4234028459,
-0.6160509586,
-0.2296590656,
0.0836740881,
0.4024014473,
-0.5116077662,
0.4700711071,
-0.6339738965,
-0.5224936604,
-0.2999153733,
0.197339952,
0.7227529883,
0.0426320471,
0.0131270895,
-0.9035790563,
-0.3536147773,
-1.0700266361,
-0.2762112916,
-0.3797842264,
-0.2181954384,
0.4541484714,
0.6282731891,
-0.0314434841,
0.4717584848,
-0.253795743,
-0.0477393456,
-0.252605617,
0.260548085,
0.0122453701,
0.3526774645,
0.4147726595,
-0.4717182815,
-0.0705059171,
-0.1625733674,
-0.8436301947,
0.0340216011,
0.400328964,
-0.1557127535,
0.1005133688,
0.1870236993,
-0.9332002401,
0.0808158815,
0.4691171348,
-0.0958810076,
0.4300744832,
-0.1286361068,
0.409093082,
-1.0914620161,
0.1128088757,
0.1555909663,
0.1468356401,
-0.4033346474,
0.5237239599,
0.2678756416,
0.298045218,
-0.25319314,
0.8582242131,
-0.4012998641,
-0.3856327534,
-0.0575846694,
0.506927371,
-0.1983071417,
0.572363317,
-0.1896784306,
0.6088422537,
0.3329425454,
-0.6123909354,
0.3820059896,
0.0081967004,
-0.6314033866,
0.9227755666,
-0.6204991341,
0.340675801,
0.0652731284,
0.5277811885,
-1.1093258858,
-0.2621035874,
-0.0101516312,
-0.1561662704,
0.1784131527,
0.011213406,
-0.5511209965,
-0.3958750069,
-0.4705167711,
0.5175248981,
0.6288025379,
-0.1640977263,
0.8181824088,
0.5877318978,
-0.1876425743,
-0.3580493927,
-0.6513141394,
0.099170357,
-0.2169604748,
-0.6995680928,
0.4274620414,
-0.2954718173,
-0.7290424705,
-0.1986139864,
-0.346578896,
-0.088609606,
0.0791438445,
0.199300155,
0.0903799906,
-0.2173255235,
0.1758877188,
-0.1666103899,
-0.0391106308,
0.3740383387,
-0.1499045789,
0.6026777625,
-0.3767015338,
-0.3201828897,
-0.005507696,
0.1330391169,
0.7211892009,
-0.0487146415,
0.2589965463,
0.277980864,
-0.4864173234,
-0.4791116416,
-0.6961601377,
-0.4030882418,
-0.3795363903,
0.4586417973,
-0.5898741484,
-0.7857808471,
0.5866026282,
-0.0334790163,
0.0305202436,
0.3572612107,
0.5744692683,
0.1461709887,
1.0317168236,
0.7326201797,
-0.1556134522,
0.2874014676,
-0.0596387349,
0.1335127652,
-1.085302949,
0.0761671141,
-0.3816648126,
-0.2615674138,
-0.4728617966,
-0.4294723868,
0.1524484307,
-0.1477136612,
-0.3949638307,
0.2705101669,
-0.2367560714,
0.3622092605,
0.3954063952,
0.0627992079,
0.2636164427,
-0.3028274477,
-0.4100942314,
0.0894543454,
-0.4041364491,
-0.7103714347,
1.3443542719,
0.2665041685,
0.6310530901,
0.1850334108,
0.5321953893,
0.1285029203,
0.3258659542,
-0.7219412923,
1.0620660782,
-0.196407333,
-0.9645601511,
-0.4987016618,
-0.2986078262,
-0.62672925,
0.3530742526,
0.0430922583,
-0.9342951179,
-0.2884311378,
-0.0499949194,
-0.3296811879,
0.208510682,
-0.4977380335,
0.6739443541,
-0.4263471663,
-0.4237812459,
-0.6145236492,
-0.6421132684,
0.6169583201,
-0.1730701476,
-0.0361459963,
-0.3134389818,
0.0502081066,
1.0398721695,
0.1891825646,
0.5970743299,
-0.0055915657,
-0.3261555731,
-0.0302091874,
0.2431740761,
0.4328989983,
-0.028296154,
0.0014642812,
0.187970534,
0.3195001185,
-0.3512942195,
-0.9128580093,
0.8145161867,
-0.7179530859,
-0.7236410379,
-0.400401473,
-0.4532273412,
-0.6360813379,
0.2758284807,
-0.0723261088,
0.2254938334,
-0.606741786,
0.2564663887,
0.7648601532,
0.030928053,
0.1410332173,
0.5927521586,
-0.4744490683,
-0.3322706819,
0.6576433182,
0.1617799699,
0.1730713248,
0.2955907583,
0.1181900799,
-0.2642050683,
-0.4337725639,
-0.2415285558,
0.2705769837,
-0.9555401206,
0.357396394,
-0.7579060793,
-0.190796271,
-0.3133280277,
-0.0491552912,
-0.4622173309,
-0.2864227891,
0.436429143,
-0.0966107175,
0.0904311538,
0.9306941032,
0.2189925462,
0.2787726223,
-0.2655719817,
0.3389378488,
0.6126830578,
0.76840204,
0.2289081812,
-0.1684694737,
-0.0767122209,
0.0962044597,
-0.1043420434,
-0.7490766644,
0.0224805009,
-0.2290484309,
0.731149435,
0.5369012952,
-0.1636035889,
0.7299256325,
-0.4153397381,
0.6742981672,
0.0077133407,
-1.0384731293,
0.3963005245,
-0.5787408948,
0.1929261833,
0.642927289,
0.161760956,
-0.4921921194,
-0.4545789957,
-0.7366876602,
-0.7461372018,
0.3724805117,
0.0602276102,
-0.028257221,
-0.1527096033,
0.2706086934,
0.0727719963,
0.5346734524,
-0.425658673,
-0.0623466261,
-0.0681489259,
-0.2209846377,
-0.4954839945,
-0.1993673593,
-0.3605295122,
-0.2308378369,
0.5615493059,
-0.1212644279,
0.3152876496,
-0.0466512442,
-0.1736283153,
-0.4062373042,
0.368968904,
0.5474249125,
1.036452055,
-0.511408329,
0.4096506834,
0.3046939373,
-0.4928393364,
0.0686087757,
-0.107901603,
0.0973381773,
-0.3141517341,
0.3112958372,
0.4130430818,
0.6173722148,
-0.7841864228,
0.495336026,
-0.1564303786,
-0.3283488154,
-0.4363477528,
0.366730243,
0.0104636746,
0.4434946775,
0.5538172126,
-0.2304842621,
0.0253082104,
-0.6799151897,
0.2239984125,
0.7255510092,
-0.4439347088,
-0.4133489132,
0.522246182,
0.1977615356,
-0.3054608107,
0.3367557526,
-0.1482979357,
-0.5652284622,
0.5951824188,
0.3382971287,
1.3130474091,
-0.2997737229,
0.1003657803,
0.152639538,
0.4409399629,
-0.4999380708,
0.395399034,
-0.1224858463,
-0.8572568297,
-0.2915695906,
-0.5729192495,
-0.462852627,
0.3457354307,
-0.7103922367,
-0.1232968196,
-0.7338001728,
-0.3751044571,
-0.1956029385,
0.4802443981,
-0.7968415618,
0.1691530645,
-0.0148860114,
0.7679556012,
-0.6648650169,
0.7972262502,
0.755923152,
-0.054904446,
-0.5738124847,
0.1214096323,
0.1946467608,
-0.9173508286,
0.6108978987,
0.2337788045,
-0.4688366055,
0.1898982972,
-0.3527823389,
-0.8125181198,
1.2119541168,
0.4131608903,
-0.4679285884,
-0.0012195953,
-0.3713997602,
0.7050050497,
-0.4791387916,
0.4036161005,
0.7332675457,
0.6995670795,
-0.2287477851,
-0.8839815259,
0.214154467,
-0.5013384819,
0.1668930352,
0.1123922095,
-0.8846156597,
0.8739948869,
0.0492212772,
-0.4478767216,
0.1486005187,
0.2468221337,
0.4510614574,
-0.0363694876,
0.5193286538,
0.5111476183,
0.7344735265,
-0.0682522133,
1.198920846,
-0.62580055,
0.115207158,
1.0393135548,
-0.6949842572,
0.8366254568,
0.3887080252,
-0.4067908823,
0.399780184,
0.4232597053,
0.1558791399,
0.4263578355,
0.3634145856,
-0.183062464,
-0.2081687599,
0.0996841118,
-0.2659928203,
0.4329016507,
0.1938475668,
-0.2404540628,
-0.0491367877,
-0.2734020948,
-0.0551755875,
-0.1309754997,
-0.0527787879,
0.5160171986,
0.2274622768,
-0.8181891441,
0.3581692576,
-0.0954826027,
0.5840359926,
-0.744571507,
-0.0224323198,
-0.1473235786,
0.2371079177,
0.2967064381,
-0.7459148169,
-0.2059044242,
-0.2779803276,
-0.0641870871,
-0.2201561034,
0.588172853,
-0.2242010087,
-0.2425075173,
0.713914156,
0.9105300307,
0.4005435705,
-0.1858134419,
-0.6662912369,
0.0154197067,
-0.3158884943,
-0.4589954019,
0.4594908059,
0.4654159546,
-0.1441180706,
0.9925800562,
0.409027189,
0.4507857561,
-0.194435969,
0.242913723,
0.3959570825,
-0.9245963693,
-0.5300465822,
-1.0989360809,
0.0453362651,
-0.1537164897,
-0.437132746,
0.8729191422,
0.2745467722,
0.8774430156,
0.1299108863,
1.0879555941,
-0.0247685853,
0.2637150586,
-0.2850292921,
0.927706778,
-0.4334348738,
0.2091151178,
-0.7232326269,
-1.1538603306,
-0.0079554152,
0.8724530935,
-0.4831578732,
0.4384242296,
1.1998776197,
0.4956640601,
0.1656282991,
0.2424851656,
0.5412384272,
0.3032711148,
0.1856088638,
0.8149421215,
0.8459410071,
-0.1618703008,
0.1615635604,
-0.2510010302,
-0.4866060317,
-0.1147629023,
-0.8324854374,
-1.2617431879,
-0.8271317482,
-0.0275912415,
-0.0513171963,
0.3345014155,
0.8451931477,
0.8308854103,
-0.5537321568,
-0.5978778601,
-0.0772324577,
0.0542619117,
-0.3927326202,
-0.2053675801,
0.2896773219,
-0.0616050102,
-0.5152190328,
0.2302857041,
0.6289398074,
0.1354437917,
-0.8090068698,
-0.0622895062,
0.0773565397,
0.1699436307,
0.6761823893,
-0.0273628812,
-0.8983851075,
-0.4208514988,
-0.1690089703,
-0.2448904514,
-0.1150439903,
0.8652502894,
-0.5627835989,
0.3269795179,
0.2413464338,
0.6634126902,
0.3688863218,
-0.1611860693,
0.8248939514,
-0.2814972699,
-0.0918301865,
0.2112024426,
0.5000574589,
0.219198525,
-0.070440501,
0.6534693241,
0.1023844555,
-0.4624198675,
-0.6747779846,
0.1587534398,
-0.9851443172,
-0.3092832863,
1.0752053261,
-0.0611067563,
-0.5086783767,
-0.0356138907,
0.0895858258,
0.2667037249,
-0.4111622274,
1.2456123829,
1.1918962002,
0.1763429046,
-0.2000689656,
-1.0565555096,
0.4428628087,
0.476329267,
-0.7152318954,
0.0840313286,
0.2747015655,
0.3249440193,
0.2077253908,
1.0040338039,
-0.0225742422,
0.2401303053,
-0.0469265208,
0.1855130196,
0.4404114485,
-0.3658675849,
-0.132765308,
0.2075672746,
0.0442531556,
0.2524678409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15048v1
|
Unlocking the Power of Large Language Models for Entity Alignment
| 2024-02-23T01:55:35 | 2024-02-23T01:55:35 |
Xuhui Jiang, Yinghan Shen, Zhichao Shi, Chengjin Xu, Wei Li, Zixuan Li, Jian Guo, Huawei Shen, Yuanzhuo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity Alignment (EA) is vital for integrating diverse knowledge graph (KG)
data, playing a crucial role in data-driven AI applications. Traditional EA
methods primarily rely on comparing entity embeddings, but their effectiveness
is constrained by the limited input KG data and the capabilities of the
representation learning techniques. Against this backdrop, we introduce ChatEA,
an innovative framework that incorporates large language models (LLMs) to
improve EA. To address the constraints of limited input KG data, ChatEA
introduces a KG-code translation module that translates KG structures into a
format understandable by LLMs, thereby allowing LLMs to utilize their extensive
background knowledge to improve EA accuracy. To overcome the over-reliance on
entity embedding comparisons, ChatEA implements a two-stage EA strategy that
capitalizes on LLMs' capability for multi-step reasoning in a dialogue format,
thereby enhancing accuracy while preserving efficiency. Our experimental
results affirm ChatEA's superior performance, highlighting LLMs' potential in
facilitating EA tasks.
|
[
-0.1586431563,
-0.5926747322,
0.6495457292,
0.1383565217,
0.0254069082,
0.4183668792,
-0.2253718525,
-0.5484117866,
0.175607115,
0.5342189074,
-0.246336475,
-0.8783519864,
-0.704416573,
-0.0218309127,
-0.4426677823,
0.6488217115,
-0.3272435665,
0.0595650151,
-0.1130911857,
-0.290037483,
-0.6510185003,
0.0222798232,
-0.8686592579,
-0.1391303986,
0.4553140104,
0.5470026731,
0.7375380993,
0.6982769966,
0.4948279858,
0.3211373091,
0.1493709683,
0.7443485856,
-0.5824041963,
0.1292439699,
-0.0086016767,
-0.7422473431,
-0.7187476754,
-0.3429069519,
0.5880111456,
0.6321277618,
-0.3494892716,
0.0136586847,
-0.0716920942,
0.4930676222,
-0.2796400487,
0.5678492188,
-0.8266545534,
-0.2658700943,
-0.1984341443,
0.1360922009,
-0.6928912401,
-0.2899327874,
0.2312549204,
-0.9192677736,
-0.3346036971,
0.3944757283,
1.0889021158,
0.4700652957,
-0.6448947191,
-0.3413727582,
-0.7654538751,
0.5329845548,
-0.7030995488,
0.8401696682,
-0.1416293383,
0.1968130916,
-0.3491727412,
-0.6184391975,
-0.7177067399,
0.191532582,
0.1146955341,
-0.1276488453,
-0.2294569612,
0.0969662815,
0.0969878286,
-0.0921198502,
-0.5384691954,
0.4571285844,
-0.111919269,
-0.1039444804,
0.5779513121,
0.027822664,
0.6024298668,
0.165723443,
-0.2807914913,
-0.1995095611,
-0.9584725499,
-0.2678346038,
0.3123088479,
0.3688387573,
-0.0216064136,
0.6724151969,
0.1372822523,
0.4528526664,
-0.0970383286,
-0.2979858518,
0.2881840765,
0.1022433639,
-0.3143978119,
0.1445351988,
0.7349899411,
0.4678110778,
0.2331786156,
-0.5806940794,
-0.1255134195,
0.1092768982,
0.2167405784,
-0.9699465632,
-0.0651967153,
0.4629301727,
-0.1598098129,
-0.1286241412,
-0.145865649,
-0.9098239541,
-0.4825014472,
-0.4226837456,
0.1493468136,
-0.6142238975,
-0.1823550165,
0.0710090995,
0.2172893435,
0.3206248879,
0.4495490789,
-0.7394013405,
0.2200823128,
0.8694816828,
0.6818953753,
-0.0409533791,
-0.3181169927,
-0.3796690106,
0.537599206,
-0.5462384224,
0.6378775239,
-0.6263331175,
-0.0764685199,
0.1871822178,
-0.1346687675,
-0.1008094251,
-0.4331403077,
0.4783799946,
-0.8855305314,
-0.0703190714,
-0.0824535042,
-0.942710638,
-0.4285921156,
0.0768431947,
-0.6348495483,
0.7808846235,
-0.1114943996,
-0.3400264978,
0.5876401663,
-0.5474926233,
-0.3502330184,
-0.1013159677,
-0.3776634336,
-0.5191666484,
-0.2153388411,
0.4184956849,
0.2606943548,
-0.3563531935,
0.3697819412,
-0.4474873841,
-0.0224445015,
0.0328408182,
-0.2109965682,
0.4538849592,
0.1410292983,
-0.1757663786,
0.0489319861,
-0.6446045041,
-0.0056992252,
0.168703571,
-0.2173175663,
-0.2305749655,
0.2292870879,
-0.335255444,
0.1563166231,
0.2880256474,
-0.390535742,
0.4915571511,
-0.426009208,
0.4206213653,
0.4588635266,
-0.2746320665,
0.6924186945,
-0.0451878868,
0.3410426378,
0.1570439488,
-0.2470764071,
0.0238868669,
-0.4833529294,
-0.5867089033,
-0.3587467074,
0.5068496466,
0.7706831694,
-0.7521930337,
0.4667432904,
-0.7960342765,
-0.6003612876,
-0.9050155878,
0.4554605782,
0.2130244523,
0.5354249477,
0.3526695371,
-0.1665677428,
-0.4431207478,
-0.7377490401,
0.0951673314,
-0.3478471935,
0.0777324736,
0.3094809055,
0.2351939082,
-0.203680709,
0.6333118677,
-0.3411231637,
-0.4609951377,
-0.2353512198,
0.0625768676,
0.0397628248,
0.4042381048,
0.5040468574,
-0.7328609824,
-0.28753829,
0.2649924159,
-0.8430592418,
-0.0170941036,
-0.0929906443,
-0.64537853,
0.137068823,
0.4897319674,
-0.9673956633,
0.1473340392,
0.7030984163,
-0.3339042664,
-0.1339194179,
0.205584392,
0.2909130752,
-1.217669487,
-0.0184655786,
-0.0891007558,
-0.36400792,
-0.4994726479,
0.0606110729,
0.2023525536,
-0.2463729531,
-0.227572158,
0.3353334069,
-0.514064908,
-0.2270298004,
-0.0408642478,
0.7254446745,
0.3337193131,
0.4882100523,
0.0119707594,
0.701851368,
0.5341426134,
-0.4258096516,
0.1968464553,
0.7618468404,
-0.3033155501,
0.5257153511,
-0.467230469,
0.2629007399,
-0.2521288097,
0.3960356414,
-0.9486789107,
-0.1948944777,
0.0877758339,
-0.2560836077,
0.88921839,
-0.2727372646,
-0.3924368024,
-0.1989498883,
0.0271949917,
0.3119944036,
0.3374612033,
-0.5384894013,
1.022367239,
0.6007774472,
-0.0408651046,
-0.915350318,
-0.568916738,
0.1333575845,
-0.2165527493,
-0.8769122958,
0.5073904991,
0.2635363936,
-0.1389978379,
0.1287505776,
-0.1223522201,
-0.0243052635,
0.1539355069,
0.0935515538,
0.5105755925,
-0.5783221722,
0.3622668684,
0.0611419342,
0.1191997677,
-0.1199010015,
-0.5726905465,
0.5906319022,
0.2158254385,
-0.4209579825,
-0.3327053487,
0.1349973977,
0.6533831954,
-0.4843882918,
1.0346155167,
0.2425741851,
-0.5628693104,
-0.170993343,
-0.5202689767,
0.2233636826,
-0.3618733883,
0.7010079622,
-0.3191683292,
-0.7148411274,
0.5089679956,
-0.2974220812,
0.6251493096,
0.3147607744,
0.3253290951,
-0.1147372425,
1.1574006081,
0.4696082473,
-0.3182285428,
0.3509404361,
-0.163713038,
0.6334116459,
-0.8188609481,
-0.2716682851,
-0.5455918908,
-0.4848615825,
-0.4970449507,
-0.4768029451,
0.043169599,
0.3834254742,
-0.2797300518,
0.4584286213,
-0.2517182529,
0.4755700529,
-0.0327247418,
0.1597256064,
0.2463843673,
-0.1741087735,
0.3367769122,
-0.0448911265,
-0.6553794146,
-0.8010572791,
1.2021896839,
0.6015270352,
0.5773338079,
0.4272429943,
0.7606927156,
-0.0704302192,
0.6129240394,
-0.8736813664,
0.4195435047,
-0.1402482837,
-0.4295752347,
-0.6038912535,
-0.4445417225,
-0.9469691515,
0.1421995908,
-0.2841071784,
-0.950160563,
0.0318200029,
0.1282534748,
-0.22754924,
0.6042320132,
-0.8655351996,
0.9937258363,
-0.3046881258,
-0.1080982983,
-0.0334291719,
-0.312240541,
0.2842893004,
-0.0852663368,
0.276447773,
-0.2658181787,
-0.2181178331,
0.5746738315,
-0.1964349598,
0.5903244019,
-0.1181857735,
-0.5089893937,
0.2568408251,
0.1675692946,
0.8342137933,
-0.0744604245,
-0.0020178717,
0.1130727679,
-0.2536989748,
-0.4346608818,
-0.8779832125,
0.6930677891,
-0.8468245864,
-0.5377579927,
0.2177889049,
-0.6688275933,
-0.5421245098,
0.2043849826,
-0.0693512484,
0.392100364,
-0.2644579113,
0.1132540554,
0.7668114901,
-0.1214101836,
0.115851149,
0.3884563744,
-0.5867275596,
-0.3237461448,
0.8764910102,
0.1698528975,
0.2640412152,
0.6070199609,
-0.5306223631,
-0.4193634391,
-0.5841543674,
-0.8751110435,
0.2624807358,
-0.7278227806,
-0.4749882221,
-0.8278049827,
0.0541896336,
-0.6320418119,
-0.0909998938,
-0.5472759008,
-0.2088449597,
-0.0191318318,
-0.2594091892,
0.1775506139,
0.7211391926,
0.421428442,
0.2608360648,
-0.7658194304,
0.0334504619,
0.1033370569,
0.2697786391,
0.0293224063,
-0.2609070241,
0.0097950166,
-0.0997289047,
-0.3228780329,
-1.1086466312,
0.2851860821,
0.147261411,
0.3726252019,
0.2700692713,
-0.3574519455,
0.7986270189,
-0.6615237594,
0.3903208077,
0.0074871513,
-0.9321823716,
0.2541501224,
-0.014670562,
-0.1966744065,
0.3890372813,
0.3219149411,
-0.479419142,
-0.4576663375,
-0.4451005161,
-0.9246097803,
0.4415491521,
0.184804216,
0.0135611165,
0.0683479458,
0.2792344391,
-0.0925818756,
0.212123692,
-0.520144701,
-0.1893969476,
0.2792921066,
-0.7299109101,
0.1605879068,
-0.0211239085,
-0.1160815433,
0.239668563,
1.0009735823,
-0.3669422269,
0.1208871379,
-0.007010452,
-0.3165080547,
-0.1370411962,
0.1940022111,
0.1577727497,
0.7056189775,
0.2539572418,
-0.1222166717,
0.4946584105,
-0.1300888956,
0.0530481115,
0.2935811281,
-0.1834691614,
-0.1503685266,
0.3751845062,
0.8596358299,
0.4097652435,
-0.5113648772,
0.4654833972,
0.0163273606,
0.0693419874,
-0.0700783357,
-0.0613171719,
0.4936445355,
0.4522649944,
0.030552391,
-0.0281108096,
0.0121234888,
-0.4051967263,
0.1769633889,
0.3752807677,
-0.1514001191,
0.0010453038,
0.8188457489,
0.3201253116,
-0.3029558063,
0.6750178337,
-0.1305162311,
-0.4415718019,
0.6163659096,
0.4773168266,
0.5671953559,
-0.2650224566,
0.1625056863,
0.2020180523,
0.3641628027,
0.0363504812,
0.1873004287,
0.4264179468,
-1.0154372454,
-0.7162308097,
-0.5879948735,
-0.2806234062,
-0.1361524463,
-0.4344046414,
0.6129378676,
-0.1363047659,
0.104967609,
0.1575365961,
-0.1897974014,
-0.9983281493,
0.0441265032,
0.4475197494,
1.086289525,
-0.755969584,
0.8605011702,
0.6451610923,
-0.5271060467,
-1.3006005287,
-0.0478491336,
0.0011465622,
-0.9168545008,
0.3801353872,
0.2325644493,
0.1329651028,
0.1413089037,
-0.5437889695,
-1.0434635878,
1.4473472834,
0.6644287109,
-1.0168294907,
-0.5298959017,
0.1162722185,
0.4448705018,
-0.6122004986,
0.1954027116,
0.7490493059,
0.4001501501,
0.0433409214,
-0.8108095527,
-0.0712893903,
0.1025729328,
-0.1151646152,
0.6663542986,
-0.7911574841,
0.2319612205,
-0.0598699823,
-0.3527727425,
-0.1002081782,
1.08533144,
0.2006796747,
0.2388759255,
0.5344573855,
0.8867563605,
1.2168186903,
-0.2762699425,
0.8414982557,
-0.4122220576,
0.1507046968,
1.1634173393,
-0.7311682105,
0.8345759511,
0.264954567,
-0.1581125557,
0.660256207,
0.3377344906,
0.1502697021,
0.1474945247,
-0.0221616272,
0.0499934182,
-0.2333221734,
-0.1596676558,
0.049806267,
0.6271143556,
0.4497357011,
-0.2961224318,
-0.0318766125,
-0.1784784943,
0.317895472,
0.0568089634,
-0.1960422546,
0.8282904625,
0.0679338276,
-0.7061221004,
0.0536350682,
-0.2591986954,
0.151955992,
-0.4284273684,
-0.2881245911,
-0.0241226163,
-0.052179303,
-0.1619187444,
-0.7570929527,
0.1392376572,
-0.0362199619,
0.0878188685,
0.1281853765,
0.6071565151,
-0.8320521712,
-0.2344949841,
0.464651525,
0.5005992055,
0.0412721932,
0.2918711901,
-0.5123867989,
0.0596985109,
-0.0039741495,
-0.1653442085,
0.0244201459,
0.9559317827,
-0.0630354881,
0.6881714463,
0.3181738257,
0.0612142719,
-0.0084576486,
0.0610931143,
0.7271901369,
-0.3737482131,
-0.2943776846,
-0.7917863131,
0.4680919647,
-0.3531067371,
-0.2528150082,
0.3236282766,
0.6157841682,
0.8650595546,
0.4460298121,
0.5622990131,
-0.1027671844,
0.1519290954,
-0.8411210179,
0.4425836504,
-0.4108243287,
0.317301631,
-0.2362625003,
-1.0739511251,
-0.2291393429,
0.2017715573,
-0.2373319268,
-0.2326439619,
0.6320368648,
0.8220098019,
-0.0611507632,
0.1161570176,
0.3192962408,
0.3535227478,
0.6142252684,
0.7063483596,
0.5933222175,
-0.5255426764,
0.7976540327,
0.0790066645,
-0.1133573651,
0.1384518594,
-0.7278763652,
-0.7684507966,
-0.3843121827,
-0.4685560167,
-0.4194007814,
-0.0834663883,
1.1904585361,
0.6798009276,
-0.9103464484,
0.1280132383,
0.0171445832,
0.1853359789,
0.0581628531,
-0.1441049576,
0.3436072171,
-0.3788498044,
-1.1052062511,
0.4190120697,
0.3863280714,
0.0625464022,
-0.151074484,
-0.1596028507,
-0.1005548537,
0.1257608682,
0.3057554662,
0.1107743457,
-0.7397032976,
-0.5308125019,
-0.0065787942,
-0.3780267537,
0.1959529519,
0.5239987969,
-0.3158189952,
0.279517442,
0.3712417483,
1.2196329832,
0.3140902221,
-0.0679861829,
0.8558005095,
-0.6565988064,
0.0435081162,
0.0369738527,
0.7598423362,
0.4113846421,
-0.4808416963,
0.7040825486,
-0.2080783993,
-0.6924185753,
-0.5885016918,
0.2439844757,
-0.8637015224,
-0.0231552124,
1.0265784264,
-0.3519120812,
-0.409976393,
0.2054567039,
-0.4370406866,
0.6237475276,
-0.5339023471,
0.6731745601,
0.9486062527,
0.1481512934,
0.0315609686,
-0.3711120486,
0.3878841996,
0.5113272071,
-1.016268611,
0.0173255131,
0.59842062,
0.0148788271,
0.3637435436,
0.3082064092,
-0.1300955862,
0.0837680846,
-0.1026607454,
0.2021771222,
0.1892843246,
-0.4748317897,
0.0798110068,
0.0878036469,
0.294693023,
-0.1138189137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15046v1
|
CARBD-Ko: A Contextually Annotated Review Benchmark Dataset for Aspect-Level Sentiment Classification in Korean
| 2024-02-23T01:49:38 | 2024-02-23T01:49:38 |
Dongjun Jang, Jean Seo, Sungjoo Byun, Taekyoung Kim, Minseok Kim, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores the challenges posed by aspect-based sentiment
classification (ABSC) within pretrained language models (PLMs), with a
particular focus on contextualization and hallucination issues. In order to
tackle these challenges, we introduce CARBD-Ko (a Contextually Annotated Review
Benchmark Dataset for Aspect-Based Sentiment Classification in Korean), a
benchmark dataset that incorporates aspects and dual-tagged polarities to
distinguish between aspect-specific and aspect-agnostic sentiment
classification. The dataset consists of sentences annotated with specific
aspects, aspect polarity, aspect-agnostic polarity, and the intensity of
aspects. To address the issue of dual-tagged aspect polarities, we propose a
novel approach employing a Siamese Network. Our experimental findings highlight
the inherent difficulties in accurately predicting dual-polarities and
underscore the significance of contextualized sentiment analysis models. The
CARBD-Ko dataset serves as a valuable resource for future research endeavors in
aspect-level sentiment classification.
|
[
-0.7771003842,
-0.454947263,
0.3896581829,
0.4748152792,
-0.8381139636,
0.1949788332,
-0.2120253891,
-0.1523989439,
0.2831066251,
0.7447109222,
-0.4421997666,
-1.0099569559,
-0.2318062335,
-0.0765516162,
0.2046824545,
1.1406311989,
-0.3173471391,
0.4212352633,
-0.3818926215,
-0.450733602,
-0.6579620242,
-1.0833258629,
-0.261929363,
-0.2636273503,
0.5882356167,
0.4041595161,
0.4589824378,
0.2269725651,
0.4756618738,
0.1354315877,
-0.1144689694,
-0.1700773537,
0.1447296888,
0.6192858815,
-0.2891525924,
-0.3040965796,
-0.6580682397,
0.2261923254,
0.2234861702,
1.0629117489,
0.0222222153,
-0.0949309543,
0.1250761449,
0.7921589017,
-0.4528148174,
0.3921072483,
-0.3681437969,
-0.006770825,
-0.0334087014,
0.18228136,
-0.1567542106,
-0.1752986461,
0.0361063592,
-0.1929259598,
0.2457360625,
-0.0418923721,
0.9017290473,
0.2716406286,
-0.6160629392,
-0.5195923448,
-0.5197595358,
0.6223677993,
-0.5424633026,
0.5027595758,
0.3055722415,
0.085346885,
0.1168600619,
-0.1390975565,
-0.578437984,
-0.1352147013,
-0.0842414871,
0.2825969756,
0.6468855739,
0.3166174293,
0.0806603879,
0.6490523219,
-0.4156168997,
-0.0901588947,
0.0673812404,
-0.2123602927,
0.661029458,
0.0135614397,
0.1502544135,
-0.9554421306,
-0.3186091185,
-0.4465624988,
-0.7406482697,
0.2512239218,
0.4360525608,
0.4239554107,
-0.0435562991,
0.5146754384,
-0.5399239063,
0.3823685944,
-0.1237953901,
0.0670970678,
0.6440345049,
-0.5537458062,
-0.0866010189,
0.251661092,
0.6474690437,
0.5541802645,
-0.1591326892,
-0.1788997501,
-0.3180973232,
0.3428780735,
0.3095205426,
-0.6655293107,
-0.2964121103,
0.5451378822,
-0.446056217,
-0.280654192,
0.3462560177,
-0.9678725004,
-0.4532092214,
-0.6992744207,
0.1966106445,
-0.0449300967,
-0.4956182837,
-0.0767250881,
0.1379863769,
0.2768889368,
0.118373163,
-0.208673209,
-0.1635531932,
0.7800281644,
0.7721262574,
-0.036638163,
-0.164283812,
0.1442657262,
-0.4254896939,
-0.438950479,
0.843116641,
-0.4936051667,
-0.416751802,
-0.1034386903,
0.183461681,
-0.0550309792,
-0.6748448014,
0.7045146823,
-0.3873966038,
-0.033579126,
-0.5464177132,
-0.3209826648,
-0.6096476912,
0.3182064593,
-0.4382380843,
0.9140381217,
0.2883094251,
-0.8107314706,
0.6087114811,
-0.3196823895,
-0.7290590405,
-0.00316805,
-0.2584294975,
-0.4769746065,
0.5942097902,
0.1289144754,
0.7471119761,
0.1447567344,
0.6116738319,
-0.5165882111,
0.3345072269,
0.2913503647,
-0.1274481714,
0.4043725133,
0.3348071277,
-0.3064486682,
0.1484104693,
-0.8446570039,
-0.0260702055,
-0.2026674896,
0.0253497418,
-0.8665111065,
0.0250539854,
0.0625856072,
0.6574751735,
0.207563132,
-0.5519478321,
0.2685237229,
-0.3340217769,
0.1554742157,
0.5884230733,
0.0483833104,
0.317660749,
0.0244738236,
0.5169029832,
0.6279187202,
0.0709358156,
-0.3057742417,
-0.0559461676,
-0.8321996331,
-0.1619658768,
0.288033843,
0.4620184898,
-1.1428797245,
0.9983149767,
-0.15997307,
-0.6060603857,
-0.6974967122,
0.164273724,
0.5834409595,
0.5655307174,
0.3040346503,
-0.6479027271,
-0.3170436025,
-1.069200635,
0.0071908291,
-0.2904854417,
0.188250035,
0.6241392493,
0.3626371324,
-0.1792933047,
0.7878071666,
-0.2344079167,
-0.4427553415,
-0.4267348349,
0.584068656,
0.0721688494,
0.4026183188,
0.1698499769,
-0.8129279613,
-0.5101688504,
0.1252412647,
-0.8707617521,
-0.492359668,
-0.0945103168,
-0.0855352581,
0.2070692331,
0.4860041142,
-0.4126515687,
0.2471002489,
0.4424197376,
-0.5157495737,
0.5434525609,
0.3319218755,
0.2598558664,
-1.2502880096,
-0.1142626852,
-0.1338686347,
-0.1497368962,
-0.5320974588,
-0.1132703945,
0.0662419125,
0.0280274693,
-0.2446312308,
0.3922548592,
-0.2498557419,
-0.329111129,
-0.6135309339,
0.0074261017,
0.2257529944,
0.4983047247,
0.4109432995,
0.4971421957,
0.6865305901,
-0.4748489559,
0.3329514563,
0.0302976314,
-0.3456458151,
0.8825097084,
-0.2857928276,
0.1012804881,
-0.3331234753,
0.2518360317,
-0.8899762034,
-0.5005988479,
0.2540602386,
-0.2548842728,
0.5289216638,
-0.135594666,
-0.4324060678,
-0.3359747231,
-0.4004871845,
0.6511027813,
0.1839410514,
-0.5710310936,
0.5940119028,
0.3874902129,
-0.4654847383,
-0.3059439659,
-0.2043501884,
-0.1208911836,
-0.3342859745,
-0.240604192,
0.1993982345,
0.1714975536,
-0.0838101283,
0.0068701194,
-0.2111559659,
0.1875434965,
0.0576246902,
0.5211420059,
0.1135784015,
-0.1089567915,
0.0827562287,
0.469111532,
-0.0650359988,
0.1884040236,
0.0762640685,
0.8264074326,
-0.3793937564,
-0.2512655258,
-0.3813716769,
0.1383687407,
0.4736783206,
0.170920819,
0.447914511,
0.4855957627,
-0.1415717155,
-0.1617805064,
-0.519601047,
-0.073527053,
-0.3745083809,
0.5963752866,
-0.5586202741,
-0.783364296,
0.6607019901,
-0.0584493279,
-0.3389755487,
0.2722734809,
0.3945022821,
-0.2267733961,
1.1435823441,
0.2118182927,
-0.2382196039,
0.2599339783,
-0.0432964861,
0.2617835999,
-1.3418072462,
-0.2939719856,
-0.2568597496,
-0.1636549979,
-0.567686379,
-0.1771680713,
0.2397928685,
0.8255165219,
-0.111372292,
0.3189540207,
-0.4897645712,
0.1701323986,
0.1844237447,
-0.1089421809,
0.0591943078,
-0.1578108817,
-0.1343775094,
-0.1128371954,
-0.4065229595,
-0.5216341019,
1.0885047913,
0.3983386755,
0.535906136,
-0.2344727516,
0.5944722295,
0.1892909706,
0.6697378159,
-0.8518716693,
0.5745197535,
-0.1973020881,
-0.4404830635,
0.1191218048,
-0.5334893465,
-0.468970418,
0.4233326316,
0.2763849795,
-0.6202728748,
0.4283598959,
0.0559707545,
-0.1412370205,
0.0565766729,
-0.5258710384,
1.0613510609,
-0.479110986,
-0.16269283,
0.0410736799,
-0.5418034196,
0.3025519252,
-0.1416037679,
0.4173383713,
-0.3700474203,
0.1399800181,
0.7220203876,
-0.4147053063,
0.777790606,
-0.5589199662,
-0.0240742471,
0.3145132065,
0.0581459366,
0.0770997629,
0.531052947,
0.2498374134,
0.5408856869,
-0.1344267279,
-0.3130476773,
-0.4500533044,
0.7365778089,
-0.7463962436,
-0.4637875855,
-0.570147872,
-0.3487700224,
-0.417319417,
0.0757960454,
0.3285619617,
0.3597341478,
0.1250574291,
0.1826616377,
0.344848901,
-0.3731388748,
0.3647315502,
0.3322909176,
-0.6035856009,
-0.8646887541,
1.1841715574,
0.0477501638,
0.170856148,
0.0261732638,
-0.0851112753,
-0.4877909422,
-0.4851923585,
-0.4717940092,
0.3153914511,
-0.8416558504,
-0.3793614209,
-0.5665940642,
-0.3501208723,
-0.4138155282,
-0.1153890938,
-0.9970610738,
-0.0959051773,
-0.1711962521,
-0.1530472934,
-0.0567866005,
0.7577769756,
-0.011447642,
0.4103656709,
-0.2766970396,
0.1789324135,
0.0228347685,
0.5857127309,
-0.1468878984,
-0.2814594805,
-0.0191447977,
-0.0028637617,
-0.3086707294,
-0.8285303116,
0.3347728848,
-0.1746345609,
0.2741461992,
0.5628404021,
0.3509562612,
0.3688615561,
0.0193837807,
0.8011001348,
0.1298438311,
-0.9035891294,
0.5350058675,
-0.1351048499,
0.2096835673,
0.9623986483,
0.5252779722,
-0.6791957617,
-0.4198147953,
-0.3016120791,
-1.0745780468,
0.7183413506,
0.021603059,
0.1159673557,
-0.0196813475,
0.5480527282,
0.4919556379,
0.7525238395,
-0.9786301851,
-0.2840653062,
-0.8193364143,
-0.3414761126,
-0.1290669888,
-0.3892740011,
0.303952992,
-0.4038993716,
0.6983646154,
-0.1025908142,
-0.0089751333,
0.4612159431,
-0.1373282671,
0.1954112351,
0.4675419331,
0.2844079733,
0.3576850593,
-0.4001275599,
0.2362316996,
-0.2773869634,
-0.4709339738,
0.2261058539,
0.0883525014,
-0.2343110442,
-0.0822096542,
0.1775255948,
1.0487878323,
-0.0533172116,
-0.4577170014,
0.4998870194,
0.0935897827,
-0.005766009,
-0.2316326201,
-0.2565172017,
-0.1739872247,
0.0419984013,
0.1250538975,
-0.161584869,
-0.021366898,
-0.4855671227,
0.0167664085,
0.4833958149,
-0.7903177142,
-0.7222747803,
0.3835732043,
0.2150681466,
-0.0067369193,
0.4322355688,
-0.8862028718,
-1.0882979631,
0.450892359,
0.0435386263,
1.1991724968,
-0.3760392666,
0.4173344076,
0.343478024,
0.06801828,
-0.0632281452,
0.4529143274,
-0.1375284642,
-0.8448087573,
-0.2289283425,
-1.1306444407,
-0.2473264039,
0.4515057802,
-1.0083568096,
0.2275644392,
-0.4237127602,
-0.2456488758,
-0.1619112641,
-0.0827796832,
-0.4382856488,
0.2583559453,
0.1222159266,
0.1704977751,
-1.0296742916,
0.8527816534,
1.0175338984,
-0.4157189727,
-0.4198544919,
0.12367066,
-0.4028671682,
-0.028789252,
0.5628831387,
0.6747460961,
0.1587248147,
-0.2284907848,
-0.2802220285,
-0.4299770296,
0.852380693,
-0.5442226529,
-0.4625234008,
0.464928627,
0.4130297005,
0.7451169491,
-0.8351862431,
0.0073674032,
0.5233415961,
0.2441013604,
-0.0567084625,
-0.780605495,
-0.0774193481,
-0.2543043792,
0.2129626423,
0.0086349733,
-0.8191184402,
1.0236535072,
0.445207715,
-0.2189115584,
-0.2270899713,
0.7039447427,
0.1416838169,
0.7128909826,
0.748587966,
0.6178886294,
0.1867356747,
-0.2193962187,
0.6540823579,
-0.4371209443,
0.4604300559,
1.1455425024,
-0.7372822762,
0.8323146105,
0.4329095483,
-0.1015006825,
0.7086822391,
0.8812261224,
0.1881627887,
0.8472394943,
0.0256080218,
-0.2322195023,
-0.3503039181,
-0.3042614162,
-0.3641405106,
0.3723527193,
0.4496069551,
-0.1665235609,
-0.2254535258,
0.5987784266,
0.0954138413,
0.0775751397,
-0.5000320673,
0.9650825262,
0.2299717814,
-0.8427853584,
0.0708927363,
-0.0431906022,
0.6435735226,
-0.1759193391,
0.2967242002,
-0.4639784992,
0.1617360115,
-0.1441517025,
-0.8459062576,
0.4040912092,
-0.1653428078,
-0.2893116474,
-0.0944375098,
0.6796169877,
-0.5631498098,
-0.5246678591,
0.5112241507,
0.2742860913,
0.0904915407,
-0.5040422082,
-0.693254292,
0.2156964242,
0.0306097493,
-0.4464500546,
0.5072673559,
0.4171535075,
-0.1228058711,
0.3598307073,
0.218535915,
0.0913538039,
-0.1702628732,
0.2859828472,
0.9636331201,
-0.9131981134,
-0.6510773301,
-0.6159851551,
0.265752852,
-0.0414189249,
-0.3885049224,
0.650781095,
0.6709689498,
1.2636865377,
-0.0222230759,
0.986805737,
-0.0808203965,
0.7044144869,
-0.5425749421,
0.6570379138,
-0.6188361645,
0.4880116582,
-0.2195231616,
-1.1613335609,
-0.1253763884,
0.6197839379,
-0.4499584734,
0.3678144515,
0.7971405983,
0.6330879331,
-0.0812132731,
0.2391486764,
0.0641704947,
0.3866549134,
0.2404503375,
0.2317031473,
0.8964982629,
-0.3381931186,
0.0764594972,
-1.0286030769,
-0.1129306629,
-0.2143741548,
-0.8006690741,
-1.2069948912,
-0.7574344873,
-0.6523117423,
-0.5006390214,
-0.2190691978,
0.8718377352,
0.4501839578,
-1.2047809362,
-0.202361837,
-0.2750348151,
0.1832822561,
0.0006507304,
-0.3546307981,
0.5456347466,
-0.6870943308,
-0.4610320032,
-0.0202502441,
0.4582205117,
0.0574383065,
-0.5701578856,
0.0367589034,
0.154392615,
-0.2168617249,
0.5756345987,
0.0511940606,
-0.828827858,
-0.2643535733,
-0.1898321211,
-0.0827515051,
0.1358238012,
0.9499207139,
-0.4575301707,
0.702060163,
0.2584724426,
0.3474146128,
0.0470814593,
0.4975051284,
0.2938609123,
-0.9253287911,
0.2423313111,
0.2602567971,
0.0953150168,
0.6137667894,
-0.0620141849,
0.2721146643,
0.5144130588,
-0.5070230961,
-0.9496508837,
0.2670587003,
-1.1745276451,
-0.4622860551,
1.3635208607,
-0.2635167539,
-0.3543719053,
-0.5477432013,
-0.1890248507,
0.1078282073,
-0.2024276406,
0.8681761026,
1.1825815439,
-0.2628811896,
0.1115676463,
-0.4975490272,
0.6630510092,
0.5336612463,
-0.8584907651,
0.3970077038,
0.4646824002,
0.0671938658,
0.2770821154,
0.3504212499,
-0.1063459218,
-0.1034816802,
-0.0839530677,
0.3860265017,
0.0973197371,
-0.6587696075,
-0.4817613661,
0.2022305131,
-0.0429905914,
-0.0412897542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15043v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15043v2
|
KIEval: A Knowledge-grounded Interactive Evaluation Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-23T01:30:39 | 2024-06-03T06:02:39 |
Zhuohao Yu, Chang Gao, Wenjin Yao, Yidong Wang, Wei Ye, Jindong Wang, Xing Xie, Yue Zhang, Shikun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Automatic evaluation methods for large language models (LLMs) are hindered by
data contamination, leading to inflated assessments of their effectiveness.
Existing strategies, which aim to detect contaminated texts, focus on
quantifying contamination status instead of accurately gauging model
performance. In this paper, we introduce KIEval, a Knowledge-grounded
Interactive Evaluation framework, which incorporates an LLM-powered
"interactor" role for the first time to accomplish a dynamic
contamination-resilient evaluation. Starting with a question in a conventional
LLM benchmark involving domain-specific knowledge, KIEval utilizes dynamically
generated, multi-round, and knowledge-focused dialogues to determine whether a
model's response is merely a recall of benchmark answers or demonstrates a deep
comprehension to apply knowledge in more complex conversations. Extensive
experiments on seven leading LLMs across five datasets validate KIEval's
effectiveness and generalization. We also reveal that data contamination brings
no contribution or even negative effect to models' real-world applicability and
understanding, and existing contamination detection methods for LLMs can only
identify contamination in pre-training but not during supervised fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.0906124189,
-0.7093787789,
0.9450374246,
0.094504863,
-0.2991841435,
0.4569893181,
-0.3361824453,
-0.4743078351,
-0.024748344,
0.5392134786,
-0.183303237,
-0.6027023792,
-0.6550661922,
-0.2114936411,
-0.7491147518,
0.662843287,
-0.0360533595,
-0.1297884732,
-0.5844292045,
0.140528664,
-0.1828673929,
-0.4339358211,
-0.3090193272,
-0.2529945374,
0.1933211982,
0.4903442562,
0.7141942978,
0.6794142723,
0.4326271415,
0.4756488204,
-0.2728651166,
0.2266200483,
-0.5205518007,
0.3951348662,
-0.3165209591,
-0.6235630512,
-0.0901119187,
-0.2258298397,
0.510217905,
0.5459293723,
-0.225954175,
0.1043813899,
-0.1514641196,
0.4836876988,
-0.7060078382,
0.1761845946,
-0.7585554123,
0.1032201052,
0.1575697511,
-0.2245028764,
-0.43725124,
-0.2853102684,
0.2589754462,
-0.861390233,
-0.4345470965,
-0.0052930475,
0.6482095718,
0.33561185,
-0.625688076,
-0.3919966221,
-0.9369356632,
0.9286953807,
-0.6756748557,
0.3729253411,
0.5070554018,
0.5597200394,
-0.2186568975,
-0.9287412167,
-0.5190185905,
-0.5309272408,
-0.0366280749,
0.2651193738,
-0.0591805615,
-0.0251195729,
-0.0092544919,
0.1596729755,
0.0589024462,
-0.0954090655,
-0.2677628994,
-0.1760963053,
0.3367812037,
0.1727303863,
0.4341475666,
-0.3459383845,
-0.4924458265,
0.0589529872,
-0.5209594369,
0.0966630802,
0.4499567747,
-0.001163697,
-0.1130076051,
0.405836165,
-0.1255837381,
0.6034042835,
0.3152450025,
-0.204116255,
-0.0135221155,
-0.5275941491,
-0.2694271505,
-0.1074736789,
0.7808396816,
0.2016359121,
0.199517414,
-0.284018755,
-0.0767638162,
-0.234296456,
0.5011924505,
-0.9402272105,
-0.3679799139,
0.3521136343,
-0.1031290889,
-0.9745147824,
-0.0285677388,
-0.8834125996,
-0.689281106,
-0.2619744837,
0.6257838011,
-0.154131934,
-0.3152505457,
0.1542704701,
0.2723633945,
-0.2699146271,
0.4727624357,
-0.8672355413,
0.2031429112,
0.7897936702,
0.4822010994,
-0.1166565344,
-0.0789102688,
-0.9699166417,
-0.1189856902,
-0.3030439019,
0.6195954084,
-0.7767481208,
-0.1971296966,
0.1003184319,
-0.1225026622,
0.1375455558,
-0.8429620266,
0.5715253949,
-0.6731283069,
-0.1187365726,
-0.2961540818,
-0.4657914042,
-0.0686744973,
0.4030602872,
-0.6063112617,
1.0541781187,
0.1058645695,
-0.9900847673,
0.7195120454,
-0.1719358116,
-0.1513849944,
0.1707839221,
-0.2451220155,
-0.2035505027,
-0.1636952162,
-0.0589405447,
0.2745784819,
-0.0364446454,
0.7470332384,
-0.3712494969,
-0.252430737,
0.3790940642,
-0.4163663685,
0.2307298779,
-0.1074368581,
-0.4164291024,
0.5246781111,
-1.1856533289,
0.1836180538,
-0.2426213324,
-0.666390419,
-0.3975112438,
0.209744662,
0.0685021505,
0.521596849,
0.1152106449,
-0.5256553888,
0.0577437058,
-0.5083734989,
0.2452027798,
0.6507892609,
0.0707683265,
0.3308854997,
-0.4186833501,
0.6720498204,
0.1482964903,
0.2281611264,
-0.0981699377,
0.0198635925,
-1.1190189123,
-0.3681435585,
0.2867704034,
0.4129610956,
-1.0332005024,
0.6380784512,
-0.5300291181,
-0.9312473536,
-0.3660992682,
0.0865689516,
0.2470355183,
0.5021861792,
0.1316760629,
0.1091541052,
-0.45541659,
-0.7450588942,
-0.3157248497,
-0.2644625306,
0.0581532605,
0.5420261621,
0.5072547793,
-0.05727835,
0.9846337438,
-0.0415849499,
0.1200326234,
-0.0695042834,
0.0512967557,
-0.06006708,
0.3783141077,
0.2900168598,
-0.627417922,
-0.5607096553,
0.1441498846,
-0.8497822285,
-0.3164470792,
-0.0119342161,
-0.2302290797,
-0.1861055344,
0.6555644274,
-0.4211683571,
0.1950842142,
0.6553616524,
-0.3557240665,
0.6972323656,
-0.2174075991,
0.3787971139,
-1.0145732164,
0.2688265741,
-0.4738374949,
-0.5187375546,
-0.7981706858,
0.0653592125,
0.0625379831,
0.0340533219,
-0.5831096172,
0.5530321002,
-0.2184738666,
0.0367423147,
-0.1605491638,
0.5992120504,
0.2281683534,
-0.1017720923,
-0.0410483368,
0.7560558319,
0.3704136014,
-0.4021101594,
0.3899694681,
0.3135097325,
-0.8261284828,
0.4028353393,
-0.5931475163,
0.1569392532,
0.2745930851,
-0.0513277315,
-0.9761071801,
-0.2586320341,
0.1007656455,
-0.1826094836,
0.1419651061,
-0.3810075223,
-0.6542554498,
0.1370054185,
-0.2526178062,
0.5130411386,
0.1866812706,
-0.8912674785,
0.7150928378,
0.220696941,
-0.0202638078,
-0.615372479,
-0.4258474708,
0.0558674522,
-0.4745646119,
-0.8608316779,
-0.0027680281,
-0.2213415802,
-0.5779104829,
-0.1800940782,
-0.3812371492,
-0.0809073523,
0.5942771435,
0.3134900331,
-0.036574699,
0.0618991144,
0.3539060652,
0.0022041914,
0.0201166868,
0.261862129,
0.0438693725,
0.6085889339,
-0.0937603787,
-0.6366108656,
-0.1706276536,
-0.1850241572,
1.047003746,
-0.1999252588,
0.6435477734,
0.3646889925,
-0.3746400177,
-0.0460703708,
-0.5134840012,
0.0100128967,
-0.5503287911,
0.467589438,
-0.1435388476,
-0.677022934,
0.6353321075,
-0.3716874123,
-0.1717211157,
0.0877121016,
0.3123931885,
0.2405191809,
0.6870857477,
0.6172451973,
0.0727806985,
0.2352705896,
0.0586640909,
0.3914586604,
-0.6444649696,
-0.4812760949,
-0.311476171,
0.040712595,
-0.3004938066,
-0.3594172597,
0.4040043056,
0.3535897434,
0.0212084781,
-0.0047553517,
-0.1695339531,
0.3903769553,
0.1239264756,
-0.0334883519,
0.7043628097,
-0.3826348782,
-0.3937953115,
-0.0803119987,
-0.395840764,
-0.7795928121,
0.8456723094,
0.3278893828,
0.7422000766,
0.0869956687,
0.5336015821,
0.1956418753,
0.5540417433,
-0.9252213836,
0.4757009447,
0.3367386162,
-0.5306509137,
-0.2910064459,
-0.4064907432,
-0.7494375706,
0.485610038,
-0.4858263135,
-0.7650523186,
-0.0189377964,
-0.0312942341,
-0.3317725658,
0.321023792,
-0.4424981773,
0.5738223791,
-0.4655344188,
-0.604513526,
-0.0651095286,
-0.3695788085,
0.6057800055,
-0.6659647226,
0.5700034499,
-0.0622329786,
-0.070197165,
0.5161896348,
-0.5695315003,
0.6359506249,
-0.1110741347,
-0.3114825487,
-0.1236354336,
0.415735364,
0.4121446908,
0.1278852075,
-0.1341678202,
-0.2819626629,
0.344958961,
-0.0225222167,
-0.7340793014,
0.6426545382,
-0.5367772579,
-0.4526243806,
-0.3528131545,
-0.4000129104,
-0.4189528227,
0.3408515155,
0.0545323491,
0.2706537247,
-0.2517839372,
0.5534766912,
0.4526815116,
-0.4930018783,
0.2368149757,
0.8004963398,
-0.7338738441,
-0.4223635793,
0.5949459672,
-0.0945658684,
0.6188925505,
0.2081921548,
0.39914608,
0.0784430876,
-0.472946316,
-0.3862386942,
-0.1220349371,
-0.9005758166,
-0.1470722705,
-0.7705901861,
-0.089051567,
0.1861531138,
-0.0711095706,
-0.5195052028,
-0.0148195317,
-0.2242681384,
-0.342207253,
0.2718238235,
0.8697474599,
-0.0034310305,
0.1547788829,
-0.8234090805,
0.0048284754,
0.2499959171,
0.3597108722,
0.0956289768,
-0.5149934888,
-0.2588663101,
0.0551772341,
-0.0440509431,
-0.7267102599,
0.4797938466,
0.0029492301,
0.5640517473,
0.490968436,
0.1962126195,
0.4009435177,
-0.2718190849,
0.6481071115,
-0.1390444934,
-1.1889683008,
0.3641349971,
-0.576916039,
0.1686164439,
0.7935700417,
0.2200295925,
-0.5502508283,
-0.5378031731,
-0.5067332983,
-1.0955986977,
0.4811429083,
0.1852867752,
0.074305065,
0.029132368,
0.2737762034,
0.0561563596,
0.4752034247,
-0.6173536777,
-0.0086484998,
0.0215992592,
-0.2721996009,
0.2431230247,
-0.5118601322,
-0.1227622852,
-0.2052265108,
0.7684269547,
0.1042952538,
-0.2853893936,
0.1053429991,
-0.4545775056,
-0.1169376001,
0.4294101894,
0.5467455387,
0.8423383236,
-0.2376531959,
0.2428385019,
0.1186978295,
-0.5838823318,
0.297847718,
0.0909207538,
-0.1735604405,
-0.2834245265,
0.4170756638,
0.4829643965,
0.7664473057,
-1.0777311325,
0.7142010331,
-0.2250338793,
0.0187349357,
-0.4103805721,
0.0540786311,
0.3663896322,
0.2537975907,
0.3357273638,
-0.1240358204,
0.0323994681,
-0.5464659333,
0.5501772165,
0.124189198,
-0.5367341638,
-0.2426084429,
0.4625995457,
0.3024588823,
-0.1135004312,
0.2619222403,
-0.1058950573,
-0.6917791367,
0.5662456155,
0.2515904009,
0.414757669,
-0.1782661378,
0.1217871606,
0.0757380649,
0.3095690906,
0.2932699323,
0.1789611727,
0.0415589511,
-0.7610817552,
-0.4113322198,
-0.6996310353,
-0.4628399014,
0.6701954007,
-0.7787640095,
0.1887793243,
-0.528185308,
0.1251606047,
0.0818772614,
0.0578488372,
-0.3991628885,
0.1221581399,
-0.3426228762,
1.0163093805,
-1.0158762932,
0.5368705392,
0.4528911114,
-0.2008333653,
-0.6889718771,
0.2188941687,
-0.0899360627,
-0.5009668469,
0.7457483411,
0.2447635084,
-0.3006097674,
-0.0183796864,
-0.3781020343,
-0.9654787779,
1.0083502531,
0.516598165,
-0.3859797716,
0.5509666204,
0.0119306948,
0.7051747441,
-0.0496035665,
0.3845433593,
0.7073336244,
0.738340795,
-0.0657475293,
-1.0656327009,
0.0768663958,
-0.4726708829,
-0.5445581079,
0.1034523323,
-0.5818996429,
0.2546967864,
0.0738900751,
-0.1791804731,
0.3882538676,
0.3376015723,
0.1668649614,
0.0836006403,
0.6691533327,
0.3742059469,
0.9328728318,
-0.1330046505,
0.8438158631,
-0.4553130567,
0.3234613836,
1.1835638285,
-0.4904067814,
0.8956680894,
0.3745904863,
0.0004750044,
0.3461741209,
0.3354174495,
-0.027078053,
0.531840682,
0.5898168087,
-0.6423197389,
-0.4285544455,
-0.3210941255,
0.0319759697,
0.8360783458,
0.1949247122,
-0.2835847437,
-0.2528382838,
0.1585285366,
0.2458207011,
0.3567773104,
0.0849817842,
0.87638551,
-0.1955360472,
-0.6608495116,
0.5664868355,
-0.0140092857,
0.5001791716,
-0.437410444,
-0.0374823958,
-0.0820202008,
0.0897106901,
-0.342931658,
-0.6701913476,
0.2712881565,
-0.0426512696,
-0.0720182285,
0.1027702838,
1.0362520218,
-0.6883254647,
-0.2894726098,
0.6042813063,
0.5668728352,
0.1688686609,
-0.09541253,
-0.1154710874,
0.2240214199,
-0.1462580711,
-0.2823072374,
0.3312599063,
0.3415688574,
0.125844121,
1.0548489094,
0.6910929084,
0.0041313577,
-0.0838732496,
0.1640130728,
0.9583759904,
-0.2202540338,
-0.1890967339,
-0.6932108402,
0.7303472757,
-0.0812857002,
0.1102079749,
0.5657487512,
0.5968318582,
0.3907911181,
0.1159424558,
0.9731329083,
0.297265172,
0.2730781436,
-0.5750220418,
1.0941747427,
-0.3169635832,
0.4534028172,
-0.1769755483,
-0.5609841347,
-0.0209797043,
0.5911846757,
-0.3624031842,
0.2048318088,
0.6929690838,
0.42968297,
-0.3484631181,
-0.1284348071,
0.6375111341,
0.5148534179,
0.5832361579,
0.2007278055,
1.1114736795,
-0.128661558,
0.6533167958,
-0.3053170145,
-0.3386110067,
-0.1552045941,
-1.2748677731,
-0.9783349633,
-0.4957577586,
-0.0195213649,
-0.2160325348,
0.1013597548,
0.7585747242,
0.6459082961,
-0.499969691,
0.1341292709,
-0.132001102,
-0.058966402,
0.288008213,
-0.2670067251,
0.3014902174,
-0.2819493115,
-0.6859938502,
0.7865102887,
0.2527797818,
-0.1064293385,
-0.4009561241,
0.4091293514,
-0.1295476556,
0.1748332083,
0.6118609905,
-0.1347927749,
-0.5462130308,
-0.6907562613,
-0.0527137592,
0.0469696559,
-0.0631125569,
0.3735198081,
-0.7862772346,
0.8643381,
0.4361980855,
0.713750422,
0.3369454741,
0.1508630961,
0.5985054374,
-0.6688392758,
-0.1291140169,
0.1592161059,
0.3702223003,
0.5219411254,
-0.6411302686,
0.3330726922,
0.0875604674,
-0.5913610458,
-0.8386842608,
0.1773343682,
-0.9127645493,
0.1295653135,
1.4611821175,
-0.4418215156,
0.1515004486,
-0.4220589995,
-0.1386486739,
0.1218931153,
-0.0770319477,
0.9914343357,
1.2024879456,
0.3987365663,
0.1569097191,
-0.7854941487,
0.5529108047,
0.350936085,
-1.3378686905,
0.3510637879,
0.4306364357,
0.7294253707,
0.1458572149,
0.301767081,
-0.2347009331,
0.0391506217,
-0.1858614981,
-0.0917158052,
-0.2977443039,
-0.4599070847,
-0.3831282258,
-0.1566313058,
0.2903971672,
0.1981464028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15021v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15021v2
|
CLoVe: Encoding Compositional Language in Contrastive Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-22T23:42:25 | 2024-03-01T01:52:58 |
Santiago Castro, Amir Ziai, Avneesh Saluja, Zhuoning Yuan, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent years have witnessed a significant increase in the performance of
Vision and Language tasks. Foundational Vision-Language Models (VLMs), such as
CLIP, have been leveraged in multiple settings and demonstrated remarkable
performance across several tasks. Such models excel at object-centric
recognition yet learn text representations that seem invariant to word order,
failing to compose known concepts in novel ways. However, no evidence exists
that any VLM, including large-scale single-stream models such as GPT-4V,
identifies compositions successfully. In this paper, we introduce a framework
to significantly improve the ability of existing models to encode compositional
language, with over 10% absolute improvement on compositionality benchmarks,
while maintaining or improving the performance on standard object-recognition
and retrieval benchmarks. Our code and pre-trained models are publicly
available at https://github.com/netflix/clove.
|
[
0.0913557261,
-0.3380879164,
0.5690723658,
0.1420221627,
-0.3208095431,
-0.1926813871,
-0.2550184131,
-0.5589110851,
-0.0399250835,
0.7923884392,
-0.2884828448,
-0.7033727169,
-0.569437921,
0.0480101965,
-0.6436808705,
0.5657424331,
-0.0130079817,
0.1396956742,
-0.3646933436,
-0.3650138974,
-0.5597013235,
-0.5239889622,
0.0036260367,
-0.0392352715,
-0.121027261,
0.1364454031,
0.3561232686,
0.9493167996,
0.6705436707,
0.3289659023,
-0.0287115388,
0.1259711087,
-0.6809458733,
0.0988696888,
-0.2921280861,
-0.5010851026,
0.032259956,
-0.1191582903,
0.6807193756,
0.3742461503,
-0.153158918,
-0.0159890652,
0.0434670225,
0.7506164312,
-0.7821666598,
0.2406422049,
-0.902936101,
-0.0214814208,
-0.1546461135,
0.0651806742,
-0.5011144876,
0.0005529571,
0.5422421098,
-0.6954367757,
0.1923722625,
-0.2059313059,
0.9314552546,
0.1898854822,
-0.0328794345,
-0.1976011097,
-0.5528175235,
0.9016920328,
-0.6218240261,
0.4915508926,
0.0594348721,
0.2179127932,
0.5383325815,
-0.9715535045,
-0.450394541,
-0.0840146244,
-0.1422866881,
0.2597228885,
0.0260731578,
0.0147098843,
0.0387470834,
0.61721766,
-0.681214273,
-0.2367126793,
-0.4350397885,
-0.2124674022,
0.3768647909,
0.3187214136,
0.1551078409,
0.0802617818,
-0.6038615704,
-0.2046162933,
-0.4919055104,
-0.0809537694,
-0.0585883707,
0.0166817978,
-0.1079371646,
0.3428224623,
-0.3679038882,
0.9282431006,
0.130824551,
-0.0995569527,
0.4495840371,
-0.4490597546,
-0.340200305,
-0.1700727046,
0.4384701848,
0.6480375528,
-0.0039615249,
0.1233020201,
-0.1686038226,
0.6520432234,
0.265234977,
-1.0570785999,
-0.6785692573,
0.1580141485,
-0.282068193,
-0.3102683723,
0.222943157,
-0.6081626415,
-0.5578866005,
-0.4059787691,
0.5381190777,
-0.5976010561,
-0.2029025704,
0.5331014991,
-0.1119401529,
0.3852925897,
0.2947985828,
-0.8594611883,
0.1616049558,
0.5788156986,
0.8735703826,
-0.5000829101,
-0.3894206882,
-0.5651128888,
0.1813898832,
-0.1206121519,
0.6186192036,
-0.7089437842,
-0.3890792131,
0.3005032837,
-0.166976884,
-0.1460959762,
-0.8353012204,
0.3633129001,
-0.3088186979,
0.0404349081,
-0.1872201413,
-0.7768568397,
-0.3012052774,
0.4756877124,
-0.7402275205,
0.673600018,
0.1382764578,
-0.7747542858,
0.2081876546,
-0.5793017745,
-0.4390362501,
0.1408477277,
-0.3025655448,
-0.399192214,
0.1037750244,
0.4253350794,
0.3218326569,
-0.0961258784,
0.0411240533,
-0.1681811213,
-0.2957890034,
0.3089055717,
-0.2140323222,
0.417402029,
0.2579807639,
-0.1779699177,
0.4090454876,
-0.6851548553,
-0.1040562987,
0.141898632,
-0.1430218369,
-0.3049198091,
-0.0951959193,
0.0574522763,
-0.1923246831,
0.4683672786,
-0.3975180686,
-0.0998240262,
-0.4383057058,
0.4688965976,
0.6582086086,
-0.1493813097,
0.6951420307,
-0.0945825279,
0.3118745387,
0.4816255271,
0.2526963353,
-0.563803494,
-0.1449696869,
-0.8714358807,
-0.4017196596,
-0.0182448383,
0.5181634426,
-0.8861961961,
0.0275449697,
-0.2062750459,
-0.4726986587,
-0.5400747657,
0.3951728046,
0.5031430721,
0.6008985639,
0.3203928471,
-0.5909643173,
-0.6351659298,
-0.8438125849,
-0.1039690673,
0.037308719,
0.1204455867,
0.2842445076,
0.3710975647,
-0.2989031971,
0.9561961293,
-0.9203697443,
-0.4767372608,
-0.380648762,
-0.0111511638,
0.2607365549,
0.4942787886,
0.6177805662,
-1.0647153854,
-0.7010855079,
0.1495364159,
-0.8090012074,
-0.1425683498,
0.3536681235,
-0.2325305492,
-0.0183523092,
0.4674263895,
-0.3034604788,
0.3258696795,
0.81750983,
-0.1600843072,
0.7407905459,
-0.0041410876,
-0.0701845586,
-0.8795921206,
0.1047628,
-0.04762467,
-0.3215616941,
-0.8646453023,
0.3637162149,
0.1230162457,
-0.276568085,
-0.8700585961,
0.3397141397,
-0.545156002,
0.0774170235,
-0.3799630702,
0.0786208436,
0.3695495725,
0.44704175,
0.4915476143,
0.8716160655,
0.8341816068,
-0.6592805386,
0.2531735301,
0.2923400402,
-0.4681678712,
0.7826592922,
-0.7308035493,
-0.0763292238,
-0.0458570942,
0.0284609366,
-0.5500032306,
-0.3654368222,
0.0811469108,
0.0257786177,
0.2301526219,
-0.1390388608,
-0.1402556598,
-0.0987880677,
-0.3065050244,
0.5734463334,
0.6012519002,
-0.4917798936,
0.8210872412,
0.3828664422,
0.3639666438,
-0.4416244626,
-0.7094168067,
-0.3724282086,
-0.2137859911,
-0.5593323708,
0.4410473704,
-0.2979582846,
0.0169818886,
0.0038941549,
-0.1195482761,
-0.2396803349,
-0.0481088124,
0.1346640736,
0.1031988561,
-0.3508354425,
-0.1274258941,
-0.4296655953,
-0.0023679519,
-0.2255471349,
-0.796597302,
0.51780653,
-0.5135144591,
-0.3018762469,
-0.3132799864,
0.181700632,
0.5949745774,
-0.7995880842,
0.5085257888,
0.8019934893,
-0.1376894414,
-0.2945842445,
-0.5017014742,
-0.171306625,
-0.5067418814,
0.4756153524,
-0.23535496,
-1.0567015409,
0.49128142,
0.0356434807,
-0.21548675,
0.1861611307,
0.3566715121,
0.0745156109,
0.5097034574,
0.7020925283,
-0.0548193567,
0.851400733,
-0.4429398477,
-0.1794742197,
-0.8691381812,
0.1156466901,
-0.0596302636,
-0.0219020396,
-0.1374060661,
-0.6653033495,
0.4662619531,
-0.137506187,
-0.000875839,
0.4906269908,
-0.6281988621,
0.845192194,
0.4382730126,
0.3610280752,
0.3526413739,
-0.1773670912,
-0.0851650015,
-0.107425563,
-0.5491244793,
-0.1706711799,
0.9442667961,
0.0918605626,
0.6954656839,
0.081421949,
0.5905990005,
0.2536430657,
0.2179201841,
-0.3736135364,
0.5988878012,
-0.5661414862,
-0.595474422,
-0.0749655813,
-0.1553014219,
-0.4930290282,
0.5566499829,
-0.0377728157,
-0.7101902962,
0.2569463253,
0.3343043625,
-0.1519397497,
0.1116349623,
-0.7774571776,
1.2747145891,
-0.4227780998,
-0.6758329868,
0.0572615638,
-0.6611993313,
0.4400463104,
0.0758099481,
-0.0464680865,
0.0711871982,
0.1607477963,
0.301984936,
-0.433953315,
1.1125816107,
-0.1272782385,
0.1133022979,
0.4623192549,
0.2402672619,
0.4352682531,
-0.1023259163,
0.071394138,
0.0883299708,
0.0168331191,
-0.4098557234,
-0.4834557474,
0.555750072,
-0.5404115319,
-0.5100679994,
-0.299092412,
-0.351462543,
0.1158302501,
0.3299436569,
0.3682666719,
0.6173705459,
-0.3119944334,
0.4064302742,
0.9089846611,
0.0067733168,
0.2276881635,
0.4237103164,
-0.5791569948,
-0.5330253839,
1.0718188286,
-0.2228276134,
0.492385745,
0.6083185673,
0.2398267686,
-0.287845701,
-0.7917969227,
-0.4054736197,
0.1751097888,
-1.0354653597,
-0.1741677225,
-0.5092793107,
-0.1977281123,
-0.2232271582,
-0.3145755827,
-0.5290453434,
0.189082101,
-0.5558792949,
-0.0822735503,
0.2265428603,
0.7322140336,
0.1652835906,
0.3425063193,
-0.9290040731,
0.0746745244,
0.3708000183,
0.2842909694,
-0.1455702931,
-0.5092914104,
-0.5617739558,
-0.1779227108,
-0.2912508249,
-0.7627621293,
0.4703477621,
0.4549429715,
0.3724009693,
0.5619380474,
-0.0152703952,
0.7874984145,
-0.4640657008,
0.9918689728,
0.2799472213,
-1.2928509712,
0.3955951929,
-0.3244054019,
0.4957010746,
0.7196311951,
-0.0343294963,
-0.302957654,
-0.1105449274,
-0.2019992769,
-0.8038953543,
0.4267647564,
0.1953665018,
0.0638317391,
0.1059479713,
-0.1436130553,
0.2921702266,
0.3901816308,
-0.9422094822,
0.2207178175,
-0.6623443365,
-0.4305445552,
0.0734978542,
-0.3441435695,
-0.0238582753,
-0.1051739901,
0.3104263842,
-0.1355966628,
0.0444085486,
0.3932314813,
-0.495035708,
0.3308929801,
-0.0237384178,
0.8275852203,
0.5644217134,
-0.046542123,
0.2456675768,
-0.0322431959,
-0.467476666,
-0.0984190479,
-0.0534551516,
-0.3989984989,
0.0134386588,
0.3633810878,
0.8999220133,
0.3781722784,
-0.9254006743,
0.8224440217,
0.1416750103,
-0.0881555974,
-0.4280244708,
0.1122344509,
0.0552549362,
0.280230701,
0.0609632581,
-0.0521707162,
0.3097264767,
-0.4887983799,
0.3260501027,
0.166311875,
-0.383187592,
-0.4769115448,
0.6929088831,
0.4868902564,
0.2257957608,
0.3852281868,
-0.1153486148,
-0.9842635989,
0.2529035807,
0.5314346552,
0.939976871,
-0.0705034435,
0.0964330286,
0.326359868,
0.0499373116,
-0.218496725,
0.1444922239,
-0.0495937727,
-0.8928143382,
-0.1304434985,
-0.6883119941,
-0.4130268991,
-0.0665294528,
-0.4665142298,
0.1702576429,
-0.3398648798,
0.1245900616,
-0.4417700171,
-0.4669872522,
-0.742554903,
0.2006873935,
0.2071235329,
0.6208981872,
-1.0190845728,
0.7584607005,
0.6446598172,
-0.5574532151,
-0.5498668551,
-0.0458470397,
-0.1589750499,
-0.397018522,
0.5156227946,
0.502181232,
-0.1997117251,
-0.0534344576,
-0.5909532309,
-0.8801077008,
1.1245348454,
0.3221281469,
-0.4568707943,
0.1031575203,
0.0836368576,
0.6397079229,
-0.8479093313,
-0.0257222969,
0.4684036374,
0.3310315609,
0.1117457598,
-0.6625568867,
-0.1717385054,
-0.2604542673,
0.2383732796,
-0.0911555514,
-0.5385749936,
0.8418367505,
0.0826633871,
-0.4056329727,
0.282194972,
0.7598994374,
0.1338730305,
0.418338418,
0.2659584284,
0.6547608972,
0.5026487112,
-0.2165984362,
0.9913092256,
-0.4096086621,
0.2453118861,
1.162633419,
-0.6954509616,
0.9529023767,
0.3279127479,
0.0067743021,
0.4713028073,
0.1942419261,
-0.1556912512,
0.8790510297,
0.04769307,
-0.2749005854,
-0.2523748875,
-0.1808535159,
-0.2615353465,
0.505453229,
0.3935455978,
-0.465082854,
0.200109899,
0.1210942343,
-0.1457707733,
0.5311521888,
-0.3045677543,
0.7587264776,
0.0141236363,
-0.5509115458,
0.5627915263,
-0.3185630441,
0.7444146872,
-0.6913505793,
-0.0753634647,
-0.1678718925,
0.4678562284,
-0.1597711444,
-0.6831179857,
0.1580939293,
-0.1017924845,
-0.2838297784,
0.0066835266,
0.6810619831,
-0.7625140548,
-0.3858346939,
0.2344644219,
0.1565384865,
0.0022371507,
-0.1597960144,
-0.4914688766,
0.6398739815,
0.1247650906,
0.2288036793,
-0.0176211968,
0.3273332715,
0.1966563761,
0.4892418683,
0.6395927072,
-0.0371328965,
0.2300153524,
-0.0724327862,
0.9244554639,
-0.4673886895,
-0.6112731099,
-0.8472363353,
0.7442451715,
-0.3187389076,
-0.0930125937,
0.5544523001,
0.5985835195,
1.1466126442,
-0.7530021071,
0.7153906226,
0.0788694844,
0.2959958315,
-0.7886551619,
0.4651464224,
-0.5310522914,
0.231842041,
-0.3227138817,
-0.9199188352,
-0.4843871295,
0.4118138552,
-0.2526580691,
-0.2192165703,
0.8589270711,
0.7666765451,
-0.2388555706,
-0.2210807204,
0.6231398582,
0.255551219,
0.3653357625,
0.5836743116,
0.6687336564,
-0.3145887256,
0.6079418659,
-0.2135500759,
0.0438968465,
-0.5427242517,
-0.9313899279,
-0.8913506269,
-0.62719661,
-0.2295849621,
-0.0645091906,
0.1453051269,
0.5919568539,
0.8218470812,
-0.762601614,
-0.2601900399,
-0.1607102752,
-0.2364926487,
-0.4207785726,
-0.1368066669,
0.2867834568,
-0.0365536846,
-0.7375106812,
0.3666850626,
0.4533699751,
-0.0150017552,
-0.3476698399,
-0.2423244864,
0.0854842886,
0.0378234833,
0.6585873365,
0.2204930484,
-0.800059557,
-0.2846700549,
0.0812174305,
-0.0126364017,
0.3318011761,
0.8015258908,
-0.5529533625,
0.7538278103,
0.5982800126,
0.8535291553,
0.6340913773,
0.2682223916,
0.5845714211,
-0.7178221345,
0.2303802669,
0.1965342164,
0.5999906659,
0.7825627327,
-0.0030015749,
0.6158998609,
0.5255995393,
-0.333983928,
-0.5889447927,
0.7688720226,
-1.2508416176,
-0.1162135825,
1.0301098824,
-0.3689939082,
-0.5187675357,
0.2446504235,
-0.3839821517,
-0.190502584,
-0.3124793768,
0.3474404216,
0.5226809978,
0.2904969752,
-0.2948672175,
-0.0998273119,
0.2250530869,
0.306104362,
-0.4777188599,
0.1313275695,
0.6628970504,
0.4016742706,
0.2478572875,
0.4746843576,
-0.248563081,
0.2410504371,
0.0919311121,
0.0085607078,
-0.1706839055,
-0.4460542202,
-0.3301268816,
0.2967653573,
0.1345710307,
-0.3559311032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15020v1
|
Probabilistically-sound beam search with masked language models
| 2024-02-22T23:36:26 | 2024-02-22T23:36:26 |
Charlie Cowen-Breen, Creston Brooks, Robert Calef, Anna Sappington
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Beam search with masked language models (MLMs) is challenging in part because
joint probability distributions over sequences are not readily available,
unlike for autoregressive models. Nevertheless, estimating such distributions
has applications in many domains, including protein engineering and ancient
text restoration. We present probabilistically-sound methods for beam search
with MLMs. First, we clarify the conditions under which it is theoretically
sound to perform text infilling with MLMs using standard beam search. When
these conditions fail, we provide a probabilistically-sound modification with
no additional computational complexity and demonstrate that it is superior to
the aforementioned beam search in the expected conditions. We then present
empirical results comparing several infilling approaches with MLMs across
several domains.
|
[
-0.0963628218,
-0.7256520391,
0.8237375021,
0.2338281274,
-0.1004373282,
0.1783240139,
-0.0717236549,
-0.4982367456,
0.2075469941,
0.6378283501,
-0.5033749938,
-0.5364397764,
-0.5666230321,
-0.0113035841,
-0.5756610036,
0.5315387845,
-0.1639848351,
0.2088640779,
-0.0366068333,
0.2237031907,
-0.5333098173,
-0.4015776515,
-0.3432165384,
-0.3872789443,
-0.1454112232,
0.0290153101,
0.8475052118,
0.4420878589,
0.8100506663,
0.1577182561,
-0.2580163181,
0.1951592863,
-0.2089533508,
0.3590881824,
-0.1163330078,
-0.2498825043,
-0.2315154076,
0.0815642625,
0.5681501031,
1.2270795107,
-0.0061135092,
-0.1631179303,
-0.0142968986,
0.8613579869,
-0.9004246593,
0.3662680984,
-0.6123754978,
0.4075183272,
-0.4506939054,
-0.5796505809,
-0.6304097772,
-0.2383960634,
0.2357438952,
-0.2975768447,
0.5086464286,
0.2525855005,
0.5558847189,
0.0451958925,
-0.3677419424,
-0.6043281555,
-1.0075489283,
0.8808162808,
-0.7094822526,
0.6056975126,
0.8992022872,
0.0214976314,
-0.8121312857,
-0.6816474795,
-0.1258430481,
-0.4207401276,
-0.1871629953,
0.1633045971,
-0.2030381113,
0.5786793828,
0.0045750141,
0.5142057538,
-0.9316350818,
-0.2295273244,
-0.1145255342,
-0.2295208573,
0.6463999152,
-0.066451706,
0.224249661,
0.0494444631,
-0.2236286104,
-0.3267539144,
-0.6316702366,
-0.0911791325,
0.6211137176,
0.3020669222,
0.2914169431,
0.632306695,
-0.2859299779,
0.9592483044,
-0.013462889,
-0.3594433069,
0.1299597025,
-0.3740947247,
-0.2075385302,
0.2651906312,
0.5319346189,
-0.0487228408,
-0.0155921355,
-0.2235441059,
-0.5676608682,
-0.2104284167,
-0.0228655096,
-0.4995539784,
-0.521538496,
0.2955588698,
-0.9187270403,
0.0607380606,
0.14498052,
-0.2758133411,
-0.3737902045,
0.0063892603,
0.6909716725,
-0.4825926721,
-0.2328015864,
0.5105953217,
-0.4135531485,
-0.2609014213,
-0.0383112356,
-0.9870842099,
0.3530313075,
0.6288936734,
0.8675362468,
0.0822540894,
0.1969126612,
-0.5826501846,
0.0727954954,
-0.6397363544,
0.6420015097,
-0.9216043353,
-0.4344343841,
0.2244497091,
-0.2725051343,
-0.0250152666,
-0.9945828319,
0.701454699,
-0.5567852855,
-0.0030315111,
0.1239732951,
-1.0955615044,
-0.2507586777,
-0.3780367374,
-0.6203684211,
0.8758013844,
0.0963797271,
-0.636577785,
0.3222278357,
-0.5162639022,
-0.4932440221,
0.026506938,
0.0111783063,
-0.6382294893,
0.4193432331,
0.2036215067,
0.5178102851,
0.1420499831,
0.4116388559,
-0.2927279472,
-0.6196337938,
0.3158573508,
-0.4114001691,
0.7478325963,
0.4168120921,
-0.4760041535,
-0.356939137,
-0.5379135609,
-0.3496967554,
-0.0832443684,
-0.0358484313,
-0.3636924624,
0.5311037302,
0.1299080551,
-0.3145497739,
-0.02057424,
-0.4428201318,
0.0052191135,
-0.9039264321,
0.1166260093,
0.3400387466,
0.050257232,
0.5248365998,
-0.358042717,
0.4896189272,
0.0599318705,
-0.0204370581,
-0.3278910816,
-0.8956128955,
-0.3356612325,
-0.6807510853,
0.2808965147,
0.505391717,
-0.6700180769,
0.130763337,
0.4663545489,
-0.3487838209,
-0.6747893095,
0.0523795672,
0.4454378188,
0.2337768525,
0.3963222504,
-0.4945825636,
-1.006329298,
-0.8961208463,
-0.4352087379,
-0.2974787354,
-0.2551787198,
0.1033401489,
0.1777684242,
-0.0644184723,
1.1302560568,
-0.3428169787,
-0.6183845997,
-0.1077943295,
0.2071405053,
0.6549640894,
0.4824619293,
0.432651639,
-0.9569794536,
-0.4073090553,
-0.2951304615,
-0.802462101,
-0.1409953684,
0.0160832051,
0.3132430911,
0.0249003936,
0.770894587,
-0.7386984229,
0.6620956063,
0.6582458019,
-0.0044547319,
0.5661028624,
-0.2525961697,
0.0837808251,
-0.9006841779,
-0.1573609114,
-0.0384625122,
-0.3773132265,
-0.8411720991,
0.1700549573,
-0.0991612524,
-0.2092304528,
-0.4365938008,
0.6429273486,
-0.9617265463,
-0.2203374952,
-0.6197754145,
0.269934833,
-0.2692862451,
0.1103607044,
0.1949406415,
0.5447637439,
0.6786504984,
-0.4912118614,
0.3143880069,
0.2429457903,
-0.62454319,
0.2074998766,
-0.4285236597,
-0.1102218181,
-0.3606807292,
0.5109339356,
-1.0851230621,
-0.0642365515,
0.2330903709,
-0.3203761578,
0.5279770494,
-0.2752496898,
-0.4906772375,
-0.2195567787,
-0.3237661123,
0.5866417289,
0.385222584,
-0.548302412,
0.1124927849,
0.6119991541,
-0.3051337898,
-0.6817240119,
-0.4152705371,
0.4021185637,
-0.1116971895,
-0.5295114517,
0.6633939743,
-0.1893618554,
-0.4557495713,
-0.117184706,
-0.2289865613,
-0.0248589832,
0.2660582662,
0.1652677804,
0.189654991,
-0.3583693802,
0.1035456806,
-0.1164667979,
-0.2252692878,
-0.172793135,
-0.6659584045,
0.3907879889,
-0.0093837865,
-0.724650085,
-0.1951486319,
0.5866011977,
-0.2882682681,
-0.0209613405,
0.601704061,
0.4509892762,
-0.6858541369,
-0.1633723378,
-0.741335988,
-0.5022985935,
-0.5249797702,
0.4864681363,
-0.390361011,
-0.9501714706,
0.3489851356,
0.0785046816,
-0.2372576594,
0.3645785153,
0.6891284585,
-0.650631547,
1.2111333609,
0.6582853198,
0.2425232828,
0.4562755227,
0.0747992396,
0.6302344799,
-0.3624057174,
-0.1398437917,
-0.6565133929,
-0.3169965446,
-0.8215494156,
-0.2369604558,
0.40421471,
0.2155505121,
0.4093098938,
0.5508877635,
-0.3985960186,
0.557536006,
0.9339346886,
0.0978303477,
0.3929013312,
0.1152290925,
-0.0384299792,
-0.1540226191,
-0.6652907133,
-0.3805174232,
0.85854882,
0.2853030562,
0.7775553465,
0.0538794547,
0.791962862,
0.1883540452,
0.1207132488,
-0.4879021943,
0.369268328,
-0.3168241084,
-0.9448581338,
-0.4016962349,
-0.4781614244,
-1.1911034584,
-0.0170213263,
-0.2433428466,
-1.0397276878,
0.3963456452,
0.196712628,
0.0169454254,
0.4895182848,
-0.2903811038,
0.5564410686,
0.341888845,
0.2958255112,
-0.0500835292,
-0.5857237577,
0.2958064079,
-0.2513094246,
0.3975453377,
-0.3512528837,
0.3345403373,
0.7932953835,
-0.2127189189,
0.6267489195,
-0.0884337947,
0.1012254879,
0.2545701563,
0.4410968125,
0.6096788049,
-0.0372413173,
-0.0639020205,
-0.0270340834,
-0.0665648282,
-0.397777766,
-0.4941840768,
0.3427760303,
-0.3636563718,
-0.739302814,
-0.2005780339,
-0.7012296915,
-0.3896611929,
0.0238482766,
0.4236568511,
0.4865668118,
-0.1464677155,
0.4484122097,
0.8857976794,
-0.1884713918,
0.852639854,
0.2443883419,
-0.1527543664,
-0.118506588,
0.9903514385,
0.0381738953,
-0.0461652689,
0.7962297201,
0.0459325984,
-0.3648177087,
-1.0382436514,
-0.1467101276,
0.108322978,
-0.5989545584,
-0.2022980899,
-0.7186739445,
-0.4025026858,
-0.3476013243,
-0.354491502,
-0.3742936254,
-0.4278566241,
-0.300815016,
-0.0270514544,
0.0142004127,
0.4702015221,
-0.1715412885,
0.0744302124,
-0.9086486697,
0.3404848576,
0.1227579489,
0.4380908012,
-0.4488634467,
-0.6598789096,
-0.4900909364,
0.1605874896,
-0.2941916287,
-1.1179757118,
0.6803693175,
0.4620413184,
0.8712384105,
0.0021216681,
0.2205192745,
0.3404434621,
-0.4193098247,
0.596092999,
0.1690821052,
-0.8304924965,
0.5875523686,
-0.289043963,
0.0835657865,
0.2868150771,
0.5474726558,
-0.4010512233,
-0.8583207726,
-0.6468128562,
-0.7793138623,
0.5232467055,
0.6460711956,
0.0079029128,
-0.0692001954,
0.1224306151,
0.023693094,
0.2915805876,
-0.2650785148,
-0.4126034677,
0.0393664204,
-0.3925834894,
-0.2903765142,
-0.2496821582,
0.0693440214,
0.2153124958,
0.8939843178,
0.0215093214,
0.3444711268,
0.4044975936,
-0.4348556101,
-0.1868721843,
0.0922038928,
0.743781805,
0.5055575967,
-0.758479178,
0.372480154,
-0.0471212491,
-0.5317788124,
0.2784391046,
0.2309040576,
-0.3207300901,
0.6639750004,
0.4782969952,
0.8898237944,
0.2885578871,
-0.868424654,
0.5237291455,
0.2105312049,
-0.3205973506,
-0.1273421347,
-0.2206072211,
0.2272153199,
0.424369961,
0.8879317641,
0.0926261991,
0.6381752491,
-0.6178153753,
0.3742067814,
0.67868191,
-0.4049321115,
-0.1691733301,
0.8561776876,
-0.2651652992,
-0.7123190165,
0.457207799,
-0.338920027,
-0.1381034106,
0.4344560206,
0.601403594,
1.2172291279,
-0.0813059136,
0.2689314485,
0.025800202,
0.3069144487,
-0.4644065201,
-0.048843801,
0.1517076492,
-0.5959650874,
-0.4456652999,
-0.7492291331,
-0.7232307196,
-0.1733306646,
-0.2495588809,
0.0775206387,
-0.0029684501,
-0.3103374243,
0.1250346154,
-0.0104748802,
-0.3953454196,
0.1449265927,
0.3537803292,
0.7430870533,
-0.6550524831,
0.62366575,
0.388553679,
-0.0931488201,
-0.3888740242,
-0.1117430627,
0.0992144048,
-0.5467040539,
0.7005127072,
-0.0986545682,
-0.0231937766,
-0.1781157255,
-0.4658188224,
-0.9884002805,
0.5906963944,
0.7200582027,
-0.4110215604,
0.065003857,
0.3043597341,
0.4007199407,
-0.1843441427,
0.3695801795,
0.4095803499,
0.2985949814,
-0.0813402385,
-1.2534884214,
-0.2781423926,
0.0438883975,
0.1630517393,
0.1458008736,
-0.1614733338,
0.7758576274,
0.0672321096,
-0.2523347437,
-0.0056883725,
0.8917459846,
0.4621275067,
0.5817972422,
0.296007663,
0.1192472726,
0.6974005699,
0.0631263852,
0.7129483819,
-0.2303396463,
0.6100322604,
0.9293142557,
-0.2134394497,
0.8513897657,
0.3584945202,
-0.3371513486,
0.168064028,
0.7745073438,
0.2753492296,
0.7154737711,
0.2581283152,
-0.4441499114,
-0.217667371,
-0.0589054562,
-0.4316883385,
0.3267924786,
0.1372092068,
-0.2711942196,
-0.1146161184,
0.117010057,
-0.132773906,
0.1917875409,
-0.0594299957,
0.5438891053,
0.4033363461,
-0.4464527071,
0.4146663845,
0.2925491631,
0.6488903761,
-0.3461301029,
0.0104572615,
-0.5710402727,
0.0947756469,
-0.1659530699,
-0.6046701074,
0.4552712739,
-0.4288370311,
-0.3653301001,
-0.4756692648,
0.9470456839,
-0.6542288065,
-0.5063961148,
0.2310392857,
0.4231082797,
0.2641867995,
-0.2932889163,
-0.3546614945,
-0.0531842895,
-0.1810829192,
-0.4729228616,
0.5671927929,
0.0608619116,
0.0468413122,
0.7247404456,
0.5853140354,
0.011604459,
0.1383050233,
-0.0914683789,
0.2306432575,
-0.5407349467,
-0.286526978,
-0.9485681057,
0.0789860487,
0.2063354999,
0.1080009788,
0.7626430392,
0.6600214839,
1.0046201944,
-0.3337065279,
0.494956553,
0.5462184548,
0.52821666,
-0.8448697329,
0.5841078162,
-0.4189433157,
0.140327841,
-0.6708360314,
-1.2477464676,
-0.5288754702,
0.6738570929,
0.2153536677,
0.0470245183,
0.6378822327,
1.2186198235,
-0.0732635409,
0.1331693977,
0.6940283775,
0.1123286411,
0.2418126017,
0.4121433198,
0.7045522928,
-0.6085737944,
0.4577514529,
-0.1116738543,
-0.2227128297,
-0.5634536147,
-0.8836594224,
-0.5741468668,
-0.7813090086,
-0.4764852226,
-0.1980970949,
0.3431509137,
0.9719111323,
0.8910111785,
-1.0658147335,
-0.4393138885,
0.1732685864,
0.1375738978,
-0.5749784708,
-0.1423356384,
0.3439429402,
-0.4253222942,
-0.7382403612,
1.2508829832,
0.5886618495,
-0.1447682977,
-0.0647255629,
-0.0421292223,
-0.2038378119,
0.3816616237,
0.3497930169,
0.2674075365,
-0.5892212391,
-0.2837956846,
0.1547050476,
-0.1555605978,
0.0303753875,
0.8527697921,
-0.7215745449,
0.6616508961,
0.6915245056,
0.5421939492,
0.8333835602,
-0.4204920828,
0.6598984003,
-0.9877279401,
0.338144809,
0.3805075586,
0.5786504745,
0.1523731649,
0.0074173431,
0.5821419358,
0.5461868048,
-0.4717210233,
-1.068336606,
0.1883600652,
-0.8743792772,
-0.3762738705,
0.9547553062,
0.0266205464,
0.1593616307,
-0.3942173719,
-0.0790659636,
0.2165459394,
0.0816329271,
0.7752088308,
0.7455436587,
0.0887347758,
-0.012863311,
-0.5714098215,
0.6854456067,
0.5953734517,
-0.1155172735,
-0.3474582434,
0.15411596,
-0.0609469227,
0.0595002025,
0.9051861167,
0.1456280351,
0.207412079,
0.0835763514,
-0.0624776222,
0.2106152624,
-0.2730360925,
-0.1440011412,
0.4342781305,
0.0990702435,
0.0626839176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15018v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15018v2
|
Unintended Impacts of LLM Alignment on Global Representation
| 2024-02-22T23:31:22 | 2024-06-06T22:31:48 |
Michael J. Ryan, William Held, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Before being deployed for user-facing applications, developers align Large
Language Models (LLMs) to user preferences through a variety of procedures,
such as Reinforcement Learning From Human Feedback (RLHF) and Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO). Current evaluations of these procedures focus on benchmarks
of instruction following, reasoning, and truthfulness. However, human
preferences are not universal, and aligning to specific preference sets may
have unintended effects. We explore how alignment impacts performance along
three axes of global representation: English dialects, multilingualism, and
opinions from and about countries worldwide. Our results show that current
alignment procedures create disparities between English dialects and global
opinions. We find alignment improves capabilities in several languages. We
conclude by discussing design decisions that led to these unintended impacts
and recommendations for more equitable preference tuning. We make our code and
data publicly available on Github.
|
[
-0.3282472193,
-0.2409825623,
0.5695536733,
0.1979192793,
-0.1557767838,
0.2506420314,
-0.3532854319,
-0.7421322465,
0.197739765,
0.5230396986,
-0.4145166874,
-0.3304652572,
-0.4097222388,
-0.043185506,
0.0698236376,
0.9362909198,
-0.0933656767,
0.1671736985,
-0.4768438637,
-0.4352742434,
-0.7258164287,
-0.5475037694,
-0.1105178222,
-0.6500797272,
0.5664302707,
0.7264572382,
1.2044520378,
0.7807738781,
0.4307543039,
0.3261792362,
0.1510323286,
0.1168185174,
-0.5169171095,
0.1242997646,
-0.2187119722,
-0.3781500459,
-0.3802829385,
0.036603827,
0.7433345914,
0.6688092947,
-0.2113541365,
-0.0567688234,
0.2661910057,
0.8547093868,
-0.5507168174,
-0.0638522133,
-0.5047066212,
-0.0487839356,
-0.1196495891,
-0.1497015357,
-0.2559589148,
-0.311357677,
0.2886116207,
-0.4738143384,
-0.1230568364,
0.1886134893,
0.7096654177,
0.3431032002,
-0.6384067535,
-0.3498395383,
-0.7816812992,
0.9833801389,
-0.4261737168,
0.4196908176,
-0.0612133034,
0.1971366853,
-0.3619346917,
-0.1449742615,
-0.265953213,
-0.1319697797,
-0.1577458084,
0.1127849892,
-0.1263473779,
0.2524628937,
0.1670505702,
0.2643642128,
-0.4940210283,
0.6039370894,
-0.2693825364,
-0.2820295393,
0.8902766705,
0.1407688111,
0.4147974849,
-0.0244914219,
-0.2711537182,
0.0471707731,
-0.9493993521,
0.2224139273,
0.7910947204,
0.4489633441,
-0.1570578218,
0.5532131195,
0.0327665694,
0.8974251747,
0.0320223905,
-0.0812528282,
0.1948985755,
-0.0324504636,
0.103393577,
0.1756967306,
0.6711554527,
0.6570671797,
0.3995909989,
-0.2358303219,
-0.1529289931,
0.0503321998,
0.3964379728,
-0.3437830806,
0.19711712,
0.1728034765,
-0.2177084535,
-0.1244174838,
0.27358374,
-0.606777668,
-0.7106741667,
-0.7141348124,
0.0626018718,
0.0372395106,
-0.0691594929,
0.1267045736,
0.093737036,
0.2016224861,
0.3373004794,
-1.1575379372,
0.0960059613,
0.922398746,
0.4418911636,
-0.4213977456,
-0.3474932015,
-0.1677156687,
0.0870508999,
-0.1931696087,
0.6441059113,
-0.550958097,
-0.4489009082,
0.0392585844,
-0.0201885346,
0.1638819128,
-0.7336306572,
0.4977799654,
-0.3268889487,
0.1797593385,
-0.4137071967,
-0.4887939394,
-0.0716747418,
-0.1301495135,
-0.6155825257,
0.7431598902,
-0.1448829621,
-0.5812838674,
0.469932586,
-0.3365367055,
-0.4647783041,
-0.2365529835,
-0.4490074813,
-0.319944948,
0.3901416063,
0.2704741955,
0.2378329784,
-0.0945461467,
0.4183173776,
-0.407199502,
-0.6190546751,
0.1836387366,
-0.2865922451,
0.7588210702,
0.1878791898,
-0.3751873374,
0.2220341712,
-0.6860569119,
0.0173754208,
0.0817643777,
-0.3816972077,
-0.3085833192,
0.1104024425,
-0.2128083706,
0.068365559,
0.2842745483,
-0.461263597,
0.4590025842,
-0.3332183361,
0.2483346164,
1.1226018667,
-0.1991336048,
0.7470015287,
-0.2035192698,
0.6120145321,
-0.0692363977,
0.2975817919,
0.2912233472,
-0.4142458737,
-0.5163947344,
-0.0051289741,
0.2523728609,
0.4063111246,
-0.1270323992,
0.3533832431,
-0.3400920033,
-0.2263382077,
-0.6421711445,
0.3586703837,
0.4693432748,
0.3869973719,
-0.0301665477,
-0.1014617085,
-0.7435647249,
-1.2063201666,
-0.3287560344,
-0.3128677309,
0.1137752309,
0.190272525,
0.1771869212,
-0.3531955779,
0.9942826033,
-0.4896398187,
-0.101360105,
-0.1768225729,
-0.2654802799,
0.1058032885,
0.2048670202,
0.5069736242,
-0.571280539,
-0.3930214047,
0.0443199612,
-0.3977590501,
-0.3435824215,
-0.0093196295,
-0.2795145512,
0.5838207006,
0.1682059765,
-0.2695626318,
0.1251534373,
0.900919795,
-0.0460771583,
0.4294108152,
-0.2248006314,
0.1689967811,
-0.8671830297,
-0.1671393961,
0.086575985,
0.003842338,
-0.2074656188,
-0.0278680045,
0.3132734895,
-0.0286917221,
-0.4000117779,
0.6533700228,
-0.5008200407,
-0.3892634511,
-0.0547827743,
0.2718738616,
0.2596347928,
0.3071156144,
0.0329914615,
1.0226274729,
0.1674822569,
-0.3827393055,
0.2025214136,
0.0861019865,
-0.4189101458,
0.4338113964,
-0.4790160358,
0.1103829294,
-0.1115581989,
0.018671127,
-0.9411759973,
-0.181644693,
-0.0151336249,
-0.2077815682,
0.4256502092,
-0.0217091404,
-0.2658582628,
-0.2467426956,
-0.4442847669,
0.1293960363,
0.2714482248,
-0.6970030665,
0.2372345477,
0.6628418565,
0.2568941712,
-0.8989968896,
-0.7091379166,
-0.2039464563,
-0.339620173,
-0.6716085672,
0.4131726623,
0.054372672,
-0.4869506359,
-0.251668334,
-0.2776801288,
0.4682245255,
0.1370632797,
0.4155190587,
0.3678195477,
0.1265291572,
0.1499722451,
-0.1831686795,
-0.00003484,
-0.1073635593,
-0.2392196655,
0.2097578049,
-0.1913931668,
-0.6172699928,
-0.2075303048,
0.2291101217,
0.4544033408,
-0.086903818,
0.3603550494,
0.1851122379,
-0.0300234482,
-0.0286476109,
-0.4990035295,
0.0556766354,
-0.4938504696,
0.4172005057,
-0.0196975842,
-1.0204833746,
0.6600129008,
0.0600213073,
0.1877487153,
0.2652586401,
0.4828682244,
-0.2558527589,
1.3541773558,
0.6142857671,
-0.302701205,
0.6204081774,
0.1162691191,
0.2384520173,
-0.7614838481,
-0.2011897266,
-0.553635776,
-0.6047213674,
-0.9032939076,
-0.0817104653,
0.3495837748,
0.166759938,
-0.2770565748,
-0.0593582243,
-0.4772142768,
0.6804634333,
0.3994397521,
-0.165540278,
0.2550611496,
0.2338295728,
-0.3969328403,
-0.3368720412,
-0.5098357797,
-0.6575205922,
1.2132877111,
0.2985714376,
1.0842428207,
0.31041798,
0.8743081689,
0.3336235583,
0.1961953044,
-0.8596493006,
0.3908795118,
-0.1292946935,
-0.3594587743,
-0.2008441985,
-0.2923703194,
-1.0272384882,
0.2347122431,
-0.1552185416,
-0.901892364,
0.0053809532,
0.3227228224,
-0.2886817157,
0.081320785,
-0.8968162537,
0.7171684504,
-0.7284699082,
-0.4651071131,
-0.1211033762,
-0.5709707737,
0.2929886878,
0.0835211426,
0.2348292768,
-0.1815338135,
-0.0403466001,
0.4540504515,
-0.1653377712,
0.8400147557,
-0.2263240516,
-0.3843506575,
0.0616089813,
-0.1988489032,
0.4131958485,
0.0322957449,
-0.165564388,
0.3419968188,
-0.2989884615,
-0.2562200129,
-0.6832942367,
0.9688668847,
-1.1875673532,
-1.1027160883,
-0.375546515,
-0.5793201923,
-0.5428455472,
0.1006360501,
0.0551072992,
0.2465139627,
-0.3665731251,
-0.1580371708,
0.4761409163,
-0.1784222424,
0.1727843881,
0.4351427555,
-0.6375113726,
-0.4924161434,
0.7300185561,
0.2325095534,
0.3496613503,
0.298032105,
0.2592062354,
-0.5595824122,
-0.4091708064,
-0.5936923027,
0.2239824831,
-0.8142394423,
-0.0659849718,
-0.1082848758,
0.2584147453,
-0.4504266381,
-0.2677911222,
-0.2114761323,
-0.5527331233,
-0.2935303748,
-0.1497666389,
0.0218830779,
0.937528491,
-0.0832272321,
0.2535821795,
-0.5992690921,
-0.1178026944,
0.2121794075,
0.4998211563,
-0.1239331663,
-0.4438434839,
-0.4798034132,
0.1016992852,
-0.618413806,
-0.5700649619,
-0.0512809157,
0.1058124602,
0.7898753285,
0.5397872329,
-0.1761549413,
0.8123763204,
-0.4584219754,
0.6184355021,
0.1551027,
-0.8152950406,
0.3985952139,
-0.241872102,
0.5418049097,
0.5474934578,
0.3731011748,
-0.6612716317,
-0.2953881919,
-0.1611741483,
-0.6473856568,
0.7159850597,
-0.3363965154,
0.1271182001,
0.087250106,
0.3768557608,
0.1781642884,
-0.0094150621,
-0.4816666842,
-0.3298053741,
0.0449565426,
-0.0400547571,
-0.1961642057,
-0.3648719192,
-0.2137042433,
-0.3001429439,
0.6445071101,
-0.1302856058,
0.1113661528,
-0.1603967845,
-0.216660589,
-0.3396188319,
0.3854014575,
0.8745213151,
0.8469403982,
-0.1287645102,
0.0353833735,
-0.2215737998,
-0.15351291,
0.3349431157,
-0.1194817126,
-0.2072634101,
-0.3201463819,
0.3298553526,
0.7775705457,
0.2808795869,
-0.4631101489,
0.214663893,
-0.22826989,
-0.0160522424,
-0.0781673267,
0.1537195295,
0.2100485265,
0.1289066374,
0.1304047853,
0.0519543812,
-0.0698479563,
-0.5510053039,
-0.042096287,
0.73404181,
-0.4073554575,
-0.2690993845,
0.4941761792,
0.2980371118,
-0.1851890236,
0.583883822,
0.2186820358,
-0.4867301583,
0.4404172301,
0.5665116906,
0.6612231135,
-0.2902672589,
0.2098885179,
0.0776769072,
0.2443215549,
0.0352629237,
0.2476672083,
0.0386760272,
-0.9567138553,
-0.3977713883,
-0.4967109859,
-0.5539774895,
-0.2918249071,
-0.6366161108,
0.4322422147,
-0.3306786418,
-0.3109022975,
-0.0207772013,
0.0648145899,
-0.5148717165,
-0.1550092697,
0.3604619503,
0.3825292885,
-0.8361330628,
0.7162297964,
0.9546747208,
-0.2414251864,
-0.7221099734,
0.1698281765,
0.5034237504,
-1.1132785082,
0.5469251871,
0.2447565496,
-0.2626761496,
-0.2566515505,
-0.3094619811,
-0.9245568514,
0.8242822886,
0.8681712151,
-0.6954829693,
0.2101034224,
0.6560428143,
0.5531267524,
-0.3791599274,
0.2340487242,
0.4347208142,
0.4683427811,
-0.1790778488,
-0.9539225101,
-0.1509990692,
0.1006161198,
0.191682145,
0.3861948252,
-0.7815502882,
0.334148258,
-0.4855285585,
-0.401242137,
-0.2646797001,
0.3376857042,
0.2516295612,
-0.1340907216,
0.2603488564,
0.7030341625,
0.9542321563,
-0.1845795661,
1.0191252232,
-0.3801207244,
0.1816497296,
1.0373305082,
-0.5696926117,
0.5774600506,
0.8636318445,
-0.2846304774,
0.4545762241,
0.7443091869,
0.2983469963,
0.5136219859,
0.3229167759,
-0.1122805178,
-0.0575501509,
-0.2673866451,
-0.4158216119,
0.6317669749,
0.1328238398,
-0.0867064446,
-0.1829580367,
-0.2385597378,
-0.0160321929,
0.3054718673,
-0.2805259228,
0.7332430482,
-0.0229665395,
-1.0013974905,
0.6206490397,
-0.1457831115,
0.7883855104,
-0.3825612068,
-0.0312483218,
-0.3428489566,
0.3277129233,
-0.5100128055,
-1.0165098906,
0.3219332099,
-0.2763321698,
-0.3195860684,
-0.3290448785,
0.5076449513,
-0.3395861685,
-0.19525747,
0.5932758451,
0.3781456053,
-0.1765254438,
0.1147778034,
-0.7260223031,
0.3630082905,
0.3198878169,
-0.2080913931,
0.6261973381,
0.2570978999,
-0.3660848439,
0.5239847898,
0.3700075448,
0.0013715283,
-0.0945169479,
0.3141599894,
0.6199670434,
-0.4889473617,
-0.2019675523,
-0.8836658597,
0.5084132552,
0.0287225749,
-0.0472713597,
0.8480953574,
0.6574180126,
1.1124739647,
0.0569248684,
0.746088326,
0.2075481564,
0.1810697168,
-0.5491275191,
0.4412715435,
-0.6967040896,
0.5491117835,
-0.2062970102,
-1.1078873873,
-0.4382922947,
0.2467128932,
-0.4803780019,
-0.0428454466,
0.4986126125,
0.8310852051,
0.0195979476,
0.0318589956,
0.377853632,
-0.1940631419,
0.3016143739,
0.3048363924,
0.861400187,
0.0199996363,
0.3541488945,
-0.2632848322,
-0.1699962169,
-0.1572462916,
-1.0737940073,
-0.5233324766,
-0.3591657281,
-0.1534880996,
-0.3307917714,
0.0657657161,
1.112446785,
0.3151019216,
-0.7866376042,
-0.5409942269,
0.1015706807,
0.5283168554,
0.1228312552,
-0.1679886132,
0.2224747539,
-0.2401595116,
-0.7205494642,
0.1913025826,
0.3536193669,
-0.001677334,
-0.4551105797,
-0.5321591496,
-0.0373848751,
-0.3269649148,
0.3542753458,
0.4652973413,
-0.9992804527,
-0.549860239,
-0.0065595559,
-0.205980584,
0.4490615427,
0.882407248,
-0.4759804606,
0.6305451989,
0.3398577571,
0.5320245624,
-0.0578541867,
0.145234108,
0.9600809813,
-0.926328063,
0.1188524738,
-0.0689201578,
0.5680188537,
0.460229218,
-0.5136444569,
0.4659357965,
-0.0342078991,
-0.8070642352,
-0.6429517865,
0.4435790479,
-0.5999620557,
-0.1197630018,
1.1967433691,
0.0450629182,
-0.0983789936,
0.0573165268,
-0.2040932626,
0.0399882905,
-0.6093939543,
0.8024854064,
0.8745298386,
-0.4989848733,
0.0260819122,
-0.3711174428,
0.443690449,
0.4627676308,
-0.4266582131,
0.2570003569,
0.8257421255,
0.1790985316,
0.0278257653,
0.5047258139,
-0.1904143542,
-0.0384766571,
-0.5272297859,
0.3071676195,
0.0935959518,
-0.1967263371,
-0.8306517601,
-0.2930692732,
0.4788173139,
0.1070620939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15017v1
|
Towards Few-Shot Adaptation of Foundation Models via Multitask Finetuning
| 2024-02-22T23:29:42 | 2024-02-22T23:29:42 |
Zhuoyan Xu, Zhenmei Shi, Junyi Wei, Fangzhou Mu, Yin Li, Yingyu Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Foundation models have emerged as a powerful tool for many AI problems.
Despite the tremendous success of foundation models, effective adaptation to
new tasks, particularly those with limited labels, remains an open question and
lacks theoretical understanding. An emerging solution with recent success in
vision and NLP involves finetuning a foundation model on a selection of
relevant tasks, before its adaptation to a target task with limited labeled
samples. In this paper, we study the theoretical justification of this
multitask finetuning approach. Our theoretical analysis reveals that with a
diverse set of related tasks, this multitask finetuning leads to reduced error
in the target task, in comparison to directly adapting the same pretrained
model. We quantify the relationship between finetuning tasks and target tasks
by diversity and consistency metrics, and further propose a practical task
selection algorithm. We substantiate our theoretical claims with extensive
empirical evidence. Further, we present results affirming our task selection
algorithm adeptly chooses related finetuning tasks, providing advantages to the
model performance on target tasks. We believe our study shed new light on the
effective adaptation of foundation models to new tasks that lack abundant
labels. Our code is available at
https://github.com/OliverXUZY/Foudation-Model_Multitask.
|
[
-0.4651667774,
-0.5217440724,
0.3227460682,
0.215372026,
-0.1389934421,
-0.4029200971,
-0.2309094667,
-0.5828059912,
-0.0822986811,
0.4537947774,
-0.8432344198,
-0.2583326101,
-0.7173813581,
0.0558742248,
-0.4652741253,
1.3731729984,
-0.0019860277,
-0.2854187191,
-0.1656272858,
-0.29741624,
-0.6924612522,
0.0801635534,
-0.5356113315,
-0.521871388,
0.4072282612,
0.6217107177,
0.3297327161,
0.460231334,
0.804497838,
0.2056852877,
0.1875175238,
0.0464750864,
-0.8590484262,
0.0312416814,
-0.1607387364,
-0.8319498301,
-0.1406566054,
-0.0183296017,
0.5090415478,
0.7972911,
0.2680583,
0.200567171,
0.7209201455,
0.8912318349,
-1.1208837032,
0.1765702963,
-0.6518059969,
0.2006811798,
-0.2795990705,
0.019166898,
-0.3164787591,
0.4339898229,
0.1955713928,
-0.9830051661,
0.403937161,
-0.3003849983,
0.5332481265,
0.733795166,
-0.1043953896,
0.1006558985,
-0.8119345307,
0.8273583651,
-0.2989756465,
0.4748055637,
0.3788394332,
0.458725363,
0.034756735,
-0.4537014365,
-0.212833032,
-0.2164798081,
0.1610194296,
0.293897748,
-0.2073279023,
0.2012022883,
0.3043888211,
0.2904957235,
-0.2087306231,
0.0447056331,
-0.0368825905,
-0.0077820849,
0.1635823846,
0.0988303348,
-0.1500218213,
-0.1214474589,
-0.4608712792,
-0.1504866034,
-0.3911834359,
0.3973207176,
-0.0935381874,
0.5468784571,
-0.4118694067,
0.48422122,
-0.7320370674,
0.9386062026,
0.4469682872,
-0.2512800395,
0.0171363447,
-0.6114522219,
-0.3518122137,
-0.2023875564,
0.3783291876,
0.3749213219,
0.2072287798,
-0.1280337721,
-0.0327800959,
0.2733102441,
0.4419201314,
-0.7324111462,
-0.3925524652,
0.2200128734,
-0.3335825205,
-0.1595422477,
-0.0912955403,
-0.4604052305,
-0.4467594326,
-0.3133544624,
0.5017038584,
-0.4026703537,
-0.0682686195,
0.0877611935,
-0.0877704769,
0.0171579849,
0.6391346455,
-0.9332370758,
0.362849772,
0.8039413095,
0.9203130007,
-0.4819019437,
-0.5877326727,
-0.7261127234,
0.007017239,
-0.3269456625,
0.7735975385,
-0.1858346015,
0.0198460147,
-0.3707377613,
-0.0130262952,
-0.2064331919,
-0.3004158735,
0.1472696215,
-0.1715546995,
-0.5370214581,
-0.1837222278,
-0.1515180767,
-0.240508005,
0.423214972,
-0.9063594341,
0.5785382986,
0.1437141597,
-0.6013268828,
0.6244573593,
-0.808453083,
-0.4758794904,
-0.1631495953,
-0.0083180992,
-0.2653310597,
0.261397779,
-0.0037522062,
0.894382894,
-0.1810381263,
0.0129403854,
-0.5426638722,
-0.2477439195,
-0.0095013287,
-0.2958387434,
0.874351263,
0.1489475667,
-0.3855513036,
0.1448962092,
-0.6447204947,
-0.1189758107,
-0.1829168648,
-0.4601936042,
-0.2106358409,
-0.2102608681,
0.1937502772,
0.111382477,
-0.1166941598,
-0.3299793899,
0.0776994973,
-0.457039088,
0.1347768456,
0.5555852056,
-0.2114832252,
0.7700648308,
-0.7311307192,
0.4044589996,
-0.1248249561,
-0.0561281256,
-0.0304516926,
-0.4275651276,
-0.7600219846,
-0.3946304023,
0.3982329071,
0.7062969804,
-0.5966494083,
-0.0697227865,
-0.3255962431,
-0.4432019591,
-0.3956855834,
0.3729251921,
0.5145488977,
0.3050038218,
0.4358792603,
-0.5261271596,
-0.4299197495,
-0.7122527361,
-0.2410466373,
0.4248811305,
0.0888009667,
0.3194480836,
0.7330530286,
-0.0486409701,
0.9432284236,
-0.4861844778,
-0.7486138344,
-0.0630135089,
0.0996430367,
0.0941452459,
0.8383232355,
1.0389033556,
-0.7750517726,
-0.5240072012,
0.1205075458,
-0.5672234893,
0.3286809027,
-0.5392295718,
-0.2098599076,
-0.4178860784,
0.1370861232,
-0.7645732164,
0.3337122202,
0.6162493229,
-0.0313296542,
0.5364687443,
0.2643288672,
0.1626498103,
-1.0377417803,
0.0921525583,
0.2499791086,
-0.3901503682,
-0.7351754308,
0.3732629716,
-0.1844161302,
-0.114474386,
-0.5960793495,
0.6927484274,
-0.3352335989,
-0.1922705919,
-0.4723046422,
-0.2298741639,
0.0151437465,
0.5803333521,
-0.2005842328,
0.4207689762,
0.7839185596,
-0.8321923614,
0.3718985021,
0.4554089606,
-0.3346554339,
0.867086947,
-0.2316467613,
0.067373991,
-0.068046622,
0.1801211834,
-0.9075433612,
-0.3489269018,
0.4229399562,
-0.2021231055,
0.2674959898,
-0.3830469251,
-0.045562163,
-0.1610364467,
-0.1941136271,
0.4766855836,
0.0632234365,
-0.3615771532,
0.603341043,
0.1517498791,
-0.040574789,
-0.5906304717,
-0.9937083721,
-0.2981149256,
-0.1963013113,
-0.4704444706,
0.6157411337,
-0.2628330886,
-0.0830349699,
-0.0149374418,
-0.5826723576,
-0.4520286024,
0.6366559863,
0.4858628809,
-0.1060093045,
-0.5513013601,
-0.0650993064,
0.0011654809,
-0.2094194293,
-0.4383453727,
-0.3074460924,
0.0202717725,
-0.1369166374,
-0.394980818,
-0.5250453949,
0.2760169208,
0.4781551361,
-0.2558208108,
0.5368663073,
0.7583015561,
-0.7013012767,
-0.1960085332,
-0.434922874,
-0.3986251354,
-0.3849572241,
0.544549942,
-0.7583665252,
-0.8421933055,
0.3612534404,
-0.2672513127,
0.3357720375,
0.5371111035,
0.4224650562,
-0.2194271833,
0.4078881145,
1.1160228252,
0.0842084587,
0.73846668,
-0.5017784834,
-0.2078667581,
-0.799719274,
0.2344924212,
-0.4995345473,
-0.6259120703,
-0.2987327278,
-0.2805153728,
0.175496906,
0.4480999708,
0.1806337237,
0.3249213994,
-0.511467278,
0.5478948951,
0.6614252329,
0.4486750066,
0.1201910749,
0.0364957713,
0.2169858813,
0.11129383,
-0.8567067385,
-0.0449422747,
1.25177145,
-0.0518649034,
0.4015164077,
0.004723839,
0.7838069201,
0.1115253419,
0.3088138402,
-0.9153838754,
0.1260465682,
-0.7140840292,
-0.8442115188,
-0.4764398336,
0.0192536172,
-0.9011816978,
0.3026975393,
-0.7482352853,
-0.7346449494,
0.4505238235,
0.5036824942,
-1.1417082548,
-0.0088187503,
-0.6759597659,
1.3430000544,
-0.01073601,
-0.4491141438,
-0.3617308736,
-0.6007134318,
0.4168582857,
-0.3925133646,
0.1658018082,
-0.3686900139,
0.4409693778,
0.9748781919,
0.1065722629,
1.1733320951,
-0.2485440373,
0.3180293739,
0.3516119123,
0.0687521771,
0.5160630345,
-0.1122901887,
-0.1096563712,
-0.07228861,
0.2932389081,
-0.548371911,
-0.3837141097,
0.6394379735,
-0.5734592676,
-0.5278300643,
-0.0912942067,
-0.8555835485,
-0.2350610495,
0.5344013572,
0.1726081967,
0.2574513853,
-0.1755427271,
0.6555709243,
0.2522025704,
0.3857889771,
0.3531317115,
0.0140492516,
0.3230182827,
0.0866085216,
0.7995686531,
0.0782925785,
0.3111756146,
0.4160788655,
0.2499090433,
0.2914317846,
-0.918548882,
-0.2928275466,
-0.1902757883,
-0.87756145,
-0.3388343453,
-0.5654115081,
0.1649729311,
-0.2111366391,
-0.3360821307,
-0.5271638632,
-0.3731817603,
-0.5820063353,
0.1331857294,
0.3554174006,
0.4181552231,
-0.0245794784,
0.6038637757,
-0.6638604999,
0.8308305144,
0.5648339391,
0.2453600019,
-0.1670024991,
-0.3520494401,
-0.3640845418,
0.3281205297,
-0.3451659977,
-0.8193581104,
-0.3019749224,
0.6317211986,
0.621624589,
0.2551306784,
0.1703051627,
0.867602706,
-0.5512495041,
0.2936004698,
0.3137193024,
-0.7712773681,
0.3591651022,
-0.3300261796,
0.4373397827,
0.9221197963,
0.2160504758,
-0.3061417937,
-0.0282500964,
-0.3345954716,
-0.4302626252,
0.7629292011,
0.1499035656,
0.0715462342,
0.4650233984,
0.3975383937,
0.5250692368,
0.255972296,
-0.8618654013,
-0.0663496628,
-0.4804769158,
-0.303927809,
-0.2466638982,
0.0148960818,
-0.3398737311,
-0.0293701831,
0.3939636946,
-0.6095042229,
0.2337744087,
-0.0692370459,
-0.5288376212,
-0.0599237531,
0.3158736825,
0.658649981,
0.5246210098,
0.1294211298,
-0.0339417011,
0.2514907122,
-0.3729281723,
0.0385697484,
0.4464047253,
-0.2054096013,
-0.2121401578,
0.5248051882,
1.1165333986,
0.4434060156,
-0.1913142055,
0.509295702,
0.6013501883,
-0.2239679843,
0.285898149,
0.3748340309,
-0.1318807006,
0.6897767782,
0.4330864847,
0.8731864691,
0.2122469991,
-0.3251834214,
0.380241245,
0.5851308107,
-0.361148566,
-0.1638596654,
0.6009594798,
0.295622021,
-0.0858989879,
0.120137386,
-0.1686699986,
-0.0584244542,
0.7991060615,
0.4090117216,
0.7447975278,
-0.0447402224,
0.1524001509,
0.0972826108,
0.2489740849,
-0.440294683,
-0.1533409804,
-0.1091806516,
-0.9328286648,
-0.6608409286,
-0.6378845572,
-0.1691112667,
0.0294850264,
-0.4850204289,
0.2262126058,
-0.6140989661,
-0.205548659,
0.3285362422,
-0.1817356795,
-1.1134184599,
0.4154753685,
0.1622983664,
0.5008114576,
-0.9792663455,
0.6000833511,
0.6734387279,
-0.1034794897,
-0.4766517878,
-0.049227681,
0.1760208458,
-0.5875529051,
0.4313116372,
0.3540509939,
-0.1661223471,
0.4490272105,
-0.2749518454,
-1.0048052073,
0.9734491706,
0.5907793045,
-0.6973390579,
-0.190064311,
-0.222032696,
0.110210225,
-0.433698833,
-0.3186359406,
0.3736602962,
0.3481567502,
-0.1035323963,
-1.1746581793,
-0.0308859367,
0.0457656309,
-0.2398866117,
0.0771274194,
-0.362495482,
0.8460862041,
-0.4529546499,
-0.0244562943,
0.2436169237,
0.5169152617,
0.2554120421,
0.3061706424,
0.6280829906,
0.246028766,
0.5533037186,
-0.1716636568,
0.9981611371,
-0.2074912935,
0.4963448644,
1.106279254,
0.0497800894,
0.6967365146,
0.5125254393,
-0.3014213145,
0.0673510209,
0.5806347728,
-0.2383030057,
0.9182893038,
-0.0590026677,
0.1447124332,
-0.3903827965,
-0.0598710105,
-0.2195326984,
0.7660226822,
0.1460197866,
0.0969243944,
-0.2608809471,
0.6531876326,
-0.5179212689,
-0.2975782454,
-0.5438022614,
0.6262696385,
0.1498001516,
-0.6975252628,
0.7082109451,
-0.0709285885,
0.8844136596,
-0.4220913947,
-0.1097363234,
0.1386945397,
0.2396173179,
-0.4251983762,
-0.5076055527,
0.3498815,
-0.2617474794,
-0.4371344447,
-0.2797948718,
0.8868564367,
-0.1903452277,
-0.3825878799,
-0.0295217354,
0.5512968898,
0.0752875581,
-0.5233696699,
-0.9582218528,
-0.0987886935,
0.0570354313,
-0.1047838405,
0.2893406749,
0.1833756566,
-0.1270744056,
0.4811498821,
0.7098896503,
-0.1321027428,
0.184560135,
-0.3121902645,
0.4724197388,
-0.3028741479,
-0.7696951032,
-0.7085025907,
0.7389375567,
0.4498851001,
-0.4819467962,
0.3871213794,
0.2031376064,
1.0292106867,
-0.3786865473,
0.647970438,
-0.0258861426,
0.0587756932,
-0.7593989372,
0.5959395766,
-0.6654443145,
-0.3115929663,
-0.6288136244,
-1.0255379677,
-0.5281296372,
0.8608725667,
-0.1756405979,
0.0446491912,
0.8276481032,
0.3477929533,
-0.5130963922,
-0.2097787857,
0.3381740153,
0.0123005016,
-0.2473790795,
0.8037745357,
0.3024815917,
-0.3153528571,
0.660158515,
-0.6851103306,
-0.2874306142,
-0.446092546,
-0.8341163397,
-0.7965249419,
-0.4948877692,
-0.5138270855,
-0.0182009656,
0.178454414,
0.6317275167,
1.1225538254,
-1.0835741758,
-0.0815501288,
-0.1662156135,
-0.0197336618,
-0.8469554782,
-0.1130665243,
0.1224829257,
-0.0992499068,
-0.5671451688,
0.4540275931,
0.0935877562,
0.1075246707,
0.2485188097,
0.0090617444,
-0.3031923473,
-0.5782151818,
0.5626789927,
0.4123587608,
-0.9476857185,
-0.3920300901,
-0.1352811605,
0.0554705523,
0.2216200382,
0.6869515777,
-0.7119930387,
0.3445777595,
0.2305626869,
1.2573250532,
0.6794284582,
-0.1760099977,
0.1471993774,
-0.8506820798,
0.4751981795,
0.139159292,
0.2603195906,
0.2955993116,
-0.349431783,
0.4629858434,
0.3009845018,
-0.0064489082,
-0.7146993876,
0.4779227972,
-0.9572650194,
-0.3058099747,
0.9227647781,
-0.2341085672,
-0.0991244987,
-0.0162437726,
-0.0871199071,
0.3387162387,
-0.123068586,
0.5667157173,
0.8969056606,
-0.2803411782,
-0.2865509987,
-0.7479726672,
0.6126458645,
0.7791529298,
-0.8349793553,
-0.0935711861,
0.4267029464,
0.3105645776,
0.5233502984,
0.6350243688,
0.7494387627,
0.8683511019,
-0.0169854518,
-0.136262998,
-0.1023444533,
-0.6610492468,
-0.289460808,
0.3776602149,
0.2621922493,
-0.5393922329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15012v1
|
Ar-Spider: Text-to-SQL in Arabic
| 2024-02-22T23:11:17 | 2024-02-22T23:11:17 |
Saleh Almohaimeed, Saad Almohaimeed, Mansour Al Ghanim, Liqiang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In Natural Language Processing (NLP), one of the most important tasks is
text-to-SQL semantic parsing, which focuses on enabling users to interact with
the database in a more natural manner. In recent years, text-to-SQL has made
significant progress, but most were English-centric. In this paper, we
introduce Ar-Spider 1, the first Arabic cross-domain text-to-SQL dataset. Due
to the unique nature of the language, two major challenges have been
encountered, namely schema linguistic and SQL structural challenges. In order
to handle these issues and conduct the experiments, we adopt two baseline
models LGESQL [4] and S2SQL [12], both of which are tested with two
cross-lingual models to alleviate the effects of schema linguistic and SQL
structure linking challenges. The baselines demonstrate decent single-language
performance on our Arabic text-to-SQL dataset, Ar-Spider, achieving 62.48% for
S2SQL and 65.57% for LGESQL, only 8.79% below the highest results achieved by
the baselines when trained in English dataset. To achieve better performance on
Arabic text-to-SQL, we propose the context similarity relationship (CSR)
approach, which results in a significant increase in the overall performance of
about 1.52% for S2SQL and 1.06% for LGESQL and closes the gap between Arabic
and English languages to 7.73%.
|
[
-0.4714363515,
-0.6240280271,
0.2854028344,
0.031108465,
-0.5051843524,
0.1586690843,
0.2068358362,
-0.6215938926,
0.288104564,
0.4400678575,
-0.4902251363,
-0.669087708,
-0.7760542631,
0.4549813867,
-0.6826977134,
1.2495191097,
0.0813288987,
0.0354306512,
0.0592700653,
-0.5101161599,
-0.028152395,
-0.7181988955,
-0.6000339985,
0.1037941128,
0.5671882629,
0.3885119259,
0.9870006442,
0.8063182831,
0.3549247086,
0.1484780759,
-0.1408848763,
0.1368039846,
0.0073903683,
0.2610073686,
-0.7055873871,
-0.2536004186,
-0.1810868382,
-0.6033288836,
0.7436432838,
0.9045807719,
0.0062789512,
0.2217496634,
-0.0852562785,
1.282740593,
-0.8211864233,
-0.2640092075,
-0.6556984186,
0.0229305197,
-0.4227907062,
-0.1278180927,
-0.2249583006,
-0.0945978463,
0.1128456667,
-0.1726116091,
0.0771941021,
0.29049173,
0.9114664197,
0.3887547553,
-0.9803694487,
-0.491643548,
-0.5858004093,
0.4909317493,
-0.4408037066,
0.5707192421,
0.5306485295,
0.3470951915,
-0.3091558814,
-0.5457455516,
-0.6732181311,
-0.1779491007,
-0.2079793215,
-0.4102677107,
-0.2092167437,
-0.3967605531,
-0.1714385003,
0.2811348438,
-0.7444373369,
-0.1311033368,
0.0830326155,
0.0620140843,
0.4798173308,
0.0748492405,
0.5232511163,
-0.0767411515,
-0.5268546939,
0.0235197786,
-0.9228877425,
0.086199142,
0.1606218219,
0.6733828187,
-0.0800749958,
0.9458949566,
-0.3670901656,
0.6218893528,
-0.1190476865,
0.0767695159,
-0.0928664282,
-0.4314019382,
0.0710689202,
0.3508145809,
0.526710391,
0.0524091013,
0.2210219055,
-0.4720281959,
0.0820390731,
0.1685272455,
0.1331741661,
-0.7063596845,
0.070372887,
0.3826655149,
-0.4275108576,
0.0884696543,
-0.3002942502,
-0.781711638,
-0.568382442,
-0.125492543,
0.2528908253,
-0.5555018187,
-0.2773190141,
-0.2128869444,
0.213534385,
0.4746374488,
0.0050738524,
-0.7489452362,
0.7857141495,
0.5659101605,
0.9439839721,
-0.6702511311,
-0.2349070609,
-0.345194906,
0.4488345385,
-0.3541424274,
0.9971293807,
-0.464915812,
-0.2843268514,
0.0737854615,
-0.1906886399,
0.046224311,
-0.3881519437,
0.6611499786,
-0.580141902,
0.0029521915,
-0.1871245354,
-0.506311357,
-0.1289553642,
0.4473353326,
-0.7822747827,
1.0327532291,
0.1997310966,
-0.9199123383,
0.4303358197,
-0.4934608042,
-0.8558539748,
-0.0405168943,
-0.3651098907,
-0.4312587678,
-0.2341032177,
0.3421173692,
0.1173172221,
-0.599844873,
-0.1731037349,
0.0844895616,
-0.3302478492,
0.0675556362,
0.0558411218,
0.5571208,
0.2914104164,
-0.4983282089,
-0.0776402503,
-0.9630313516,
0.1890487373,
0.1016955227,
-0.1725846976,
-0.341204524,
0.4663054347,
0.2801346481,
0.2398183644,
0.2503614724,
-0.4601253867,
0.1818378121,
-0.8424323797,
0.0396170355,
0.3169994652,
-0.0918048024,
0.4599531591,
-0.1170975715,
0.4854171574,
0.0321850441,
-0.4438336194,
0.0814012513,
-0.171075061,
-0.8775323033,
-0.2729415298,
0.2916586101,
0.7575579286,
-0.8170015216,
0.4457618892,
-0.3899997771,
-0.6183731556,
-0.2335844934,
-0.0809271261,
0.5149257183,
0.3249466121,
0.536357522,
-0.3607687652,
-0.491768539,
-1.1093480587,
-0.8184209466,
-0.0553255603,
0.0937257931,
0.3782037497,
0.6381242275,
-0.2212386429,
1.0521990061,
-0.2511879206,
-0.6652514338,
-0.3752434254,
-0.077142477,
0.1730398983,
0.5639014244,
0.5632499456,
-0.8017340899,
-0.836183548,
0.3523403108,
-0.3976585865,
0.1787647307,
0.3824089766,
-0.0761852115,
1.1005750895,
0.1079377457,
-0.6515049934,
0.8140861392,
0.5167856216,
-0.8310944438,
0.4710427225,
0.2263943702,
0.3951714933,
-1.4609516859,
0.3008667827,
-0.106537357,
-0.1737194359,
-0.5390712023,
0.1970089376,
-0.2718141973,
-0.2074668854,
-0.5162598491,
0.602188766,
-0.3648186922,
-0.3486603498,
-0.2685166895,
-0.1709654331,
-0.1684964895,
0.4249998927,
0.1723822355,
1.3715041876,
0.6269078255,
-0.7579469085,
-0.0923930705,
0.5047534108,
-0.495017916,
0.3310759962,
-0.6970129609,
0.2829288244,
0.0972419903,
0.196959123,
-1.0180039406,
-0.0648951009,
0.3003091216,
-0.6850125194,
-0.06236903,
-0.3359172046,
-0.6214993,
0.3258692324,
-0.0841213837,
0.5276286602,
0.1450027823,
-0.5390746593,
0.9328494668,
0.4296374023,
-0.3498188257,
-0.9121210575,
-0.6877402067,
0.3979772925,
-0.1150676459,
-0.6436181068,
0.5126233697,
0.6489105821,
-0.2169209421,
0.0967204347,
-0.3582198024,
-0.4284154773,
-0.1958519965,
0.1645998359,
0.0529030971,
-0.0674869493,
0.1020279154,
0.2092282772,
-0.120275192,
0.0338746943,
0.0574274287,
0.7272136211,
-0.0771695301,
-0.281953305,
-0.308693856,
0.9484811425,
0.2354804128,
-0.3756389618,
1.3335263729,
0.1887917668,
-0.3983081877,
-0.1352663934,
-0.1868284345,
0.0586380772,
-0.3999071419,
0.6045338511,
-0.78988868,
-0.7671371698,
0.4117917717,
-0.2919411361,
-0.0649021044,
0.6036481261,
0.3889753819,
-0.108811155,
1.4339954853,
0.8916078806,
-0.2139043212,
0.0430537052,
-0.0152548579,
0.4047782421,
-0.3971723318,
-0.2133495212,
-1.1515048742,
0.0545422807,
-0.579659164,
-0.1753879488,
0.4087678492,
0.0797837377,
-0.5737377405,
0.5597358942,
-0.4922558963,
0.4745362699,
0.094519183,
-0.0651947185,
0.2788012922,
0.5360311866,
-0.1426371932,
-0.0915577561,
-0.6019883156,
-0.7154781222,
0.7293530703,
-0.0390359797,
0.4992271364,
0.7755162716,
0.4698984921,
0.6469403505,
-0.2579664886,
-0.5521494746,
0.625402391,
-0.1850758195,
-0.5698970556,
-0.1291343719,
-0.147799179,
-1.1571950912,
0.2522041798,
-0.3084723055,
-0.8116724491,
-0.0758618638,
-0.0293561798,
0.2771327198,
0.1751392037,
-0.4773434699,
0.6941273808,
-0.0724383369,
-0.5997669697,
-0.2878755033,
-0.8201699257,
-0.0423824191,
0.1471171975,
0.2004520744,
-0.0568838008,
-0.4490296245,
0.6452489495,
-0.6502099037,
0.3467302322,
0.1704988331,
-0.0757403076,
0.1567082554,
0.4321299493,
0.6767975688,
-0.1170475781,
-0.3377051055,
0.2744843662,
0.4691962302,
-0.6778794527,
-0.5658781528,
0.5644672513,
-0.777670145,
-0.4561468959,
-1.132917285,
-0.5089230537,
-0.3713813126,
0.066174604,
0.0557897463,
0.1607691646,
-0.1154228821,
0.1968966275,
0.2593866587,
-0.1154601723,
0.1798039675,
0.6559147835,
-0.3621067703,
-0.1683316976,
0.558865428,
-0.1009849831,
-0.0228711944,
0.3342458606,
-0.2056180686,
-0.5987602472,
-0.4513852298,
-0.8650509119,
-0.0630516037,
-0.68403548,
-0.1927788854,
-0.685790658,
-0.189936325,
-0.4102800488,
-0.0711272955,
-0.2801504135,
-0.5501676798,
-0.0470413901,
0.3585984111,
0.6279060841,
0.4404335916,
0.4130648375,
0.1749216467,
-0.7879062891,
0.3180459142,
-0.2207152247,
0.4649685621,
-0.108318679,
-0.5491091013,
-0.2660540938,
-0.1076601744,
0.0338747315,
-1.1336994171,
0.4536914229,
0.4429634809,
0.1595016569,
0.0063038198,
0.0996941924,
0.680603385,
-0.7345660925,
0.9675591588,
-0.1067793816,
-1.0766371489,
0.8158817291,
-0.1834311187,
0.1880903393,
0.749006927,
0.8829353452,
-0.4551475346,
0.0474606752,
-0.150802508,
-1.0423476696,
0.6570083499,
0.5675908923,
-0.1750159115,
-0.0086853774,
0.4426604509,
0.1674016714,
0.0772541091,
-0.7372893095,
-0.6389490962,
0.1012112871,
-0.23217915,
0.003442812,
-0.2578853071,
0.0415876023,
-0.3670877814,
0.6850334406,
-0.0518593155,
0.0599694587,
0.2645486891,
-0.2111663818,
0.1014168859,
0.6179418564,
0.2914507389,
0.8554704189,
-0.0975946411,
0.2199987173,
0.3668018878,
-0.4054613113,
0.1936538666,
0.2026173174,
-0.0420170166,
0.016605828,
0.327765584,
0.4066363275,
-0.3274032474,
-0.9754763246,
0.2290744781,
0.1281002015,
0.2117828131,
-0.4344168901,
-0.1174322516,
-0.1074794009,
0.1290214509,
0.6809875369,
-0.104692921,
0.528534174,
-0.7322133183,
0.3164500892,
0.5641505718,
-0.2960292101,
0.1084515005,
0.4668107629,
0.0955840945,
-0.6005326509,
0.2882843018,
-0.1414120346,
-0.7880402803,
0.6458489895,
0.7982857823,
0.5420482755,
-0.0631338432,
-0.0509868488,
0.3540344536,
0.205979988,
0.3569330871,
0.5133411884,
-0.2631826699,
-0.5132603645,
-0.4388180375,
-0.6137393713,
-0.6800242066,
-0.351808995,
-0.5815873146,
0.2485543191,
-0.3125282228,
0.1416585296,
-0.0484108701,
0.4144559205,
-0.2616614103,
0.3278965354,
-0.2768992782,
1.0294390917,
-0.6578512192,
1.1151461601,
0.9457876086,
-0.4657045901,
-0.6575524807,
-0.173117727,
-0.0802543685,
-0.5793459415,
0.6112577319,
0.2087562531,
-0.5477577448,
0.0936193913,
-0.3852313161,
-1.0727772713,
0.7761551738,
0.183049947,
-0.3724967837,
0.2230032235,
0.7967399359,
0.5688826442,
-0.5312279463,
-0.0340281315,
0.7051201463,
0.1450645626,
-0.0259374715,
-0.6495911479,
0.1137981638,
-0.4950344861,
-0.025143994,
0.6333793998,
-0.3201442957,
0.815210402,
0.0211666711,
-0.4731718004,
0.3955126703,
0.7941529155,
0.5228484869,
0.443487376,
0.5729284286,
0.6749600172,
0.1681187302,
0.0412599258,
1.1589101553,
-0.579328835,
0.0557050593,
1.2464481592,
-0.7616890073,
1.2255852222,
0.8139028549,
-0.5349224806,
0.8999776244,
0.3427219689,
0.3319576979,
0.5626763105,
0.1349154413,
-0.5752090812,
0.009680667,
-0.4722643793,
-0.6986154914,
0.4697124958,
0.3022514582,
-0.1594252139,
-0.512196362,
-0.2504862249,
-0.0565327369,
0.6842705011,
-0.1643949002,
0.7641167045,
-0.2434324026,
-0.4896694124,
0.4708203971,
0.2655807734,
0.4822275639,
-0.7272008061,
-0.3011139631,
-0.1413721442,
0.1087215766,
-0.2204632163,
-0.750651598,
0.7451922297,
0.2943036854,
-0.3108308911,
0.2921417654,
0.8517652154,
-0.3316290677,
-0.4766727388,
0.2512973845,
0.4759317935,
0.4281491041,
-0.2522526383,
-0.6505455971,
0.1406451762,
-0.2017209828,
-0.0717295334,
0.4927936196,
0.1774350405,
-0.0735824406,
0.7929282188,
0.600612998,
0.0036529589,
-0.0480009988,
-0.2772041261,
0.7784151435,
-0.9187016487,
-0.5581663251,
-0.857452035,
0.2625564635,
-0.0597108305,
-0.3573476672,
0.7707152367,
0.938418746,
0.4977370799,
0.1263361275,
0.4549041092,
-0.4087438583,
1.0403598547,
-0.4027368128,
0.9339489341,
-0.7394672036,
0.1403588653,
-0.0789655,
-1.0207582712,
-0.1393626481,
0.4928961396,
0.1619736552,
-0.0319521651,
0.7397334576,
0.8819348216,
0.2669706047,
-0.0556118526,
-0.0340165943,
-0.1296375096,
0.0567987598,
0.6370816827,
0.5839661956,
-0.7577928305,
0.6212483048,
-0.1337818801,
0.1342749,
0.0570941791,
-0.7404534817,
-0.9743220806,
-0.8287059665,
-0.1228347272,
-0.6795879006,
0.4143817425,
1.0665744543,
0.4396773875,
-1.0428723097,
-0.3473328948,
-0.1990524083,
0.0441576578,
-0.2199559212,
-0.1474574953,
0.9010922313,
-0.1748943627,
-0.5460376143,
0.3711224794,
0.2248954028,
-0.1197866499,
0.0207350422,
-0.0411331616,
-0.8496552706,
0.1910640299,
0.7398433685,
0.4852084816,
-0.7044577599,
-0.1994995028,
-0.2483664155,
-0.3737042844,
0.0016214242,
0.4042580724,
-1.1546802521,
-0.1361355484,
0.2135825008,
1.0519837141,
0.4990303218,
0.0524837114,
0.3938933611,
-0.7848053575,
0.3806671798,
0.3402721286,
0.1275485456,
0.2024194002,
-0.2522601783,
0.8882755041,
-0.2175186127,
-0.4312645197,
-0.8493577242,
0.4546117783,
-1.1003103256,
-0.3327405453,
1.1050281525,
0.1295417696,
-0.2543646693,
-0.4432061315,
-0.3865541816,
0.4065873325,
-0.0680854619,
0.8061540127,
0.6043586135,
-0.09824422,
-0.2744850814,
-0.0746005028,
0.6985095143,
1.0646879673,
-0.9970219731,
-0.3410685062,
0.2663270831,
0.1641447395,
-0.0041265613,
0.3693349659,
0.0770845339,
0.4475294948,
0.0059742853,
0.0731434599,
0.1881012619,
-0.3836397231,
-0.2120885998,
0.3715198636,
-0.0209605899,
-0.1702193767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15010v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15010v2
|
How Important Is Tokenization in French Medical Masked Language Models?
| 2024-02-22T23:11:08 | 2024-06-09T15:11:31 |
Yanis Labrak, Adrien Bazoge, Beatrice Daille, Mickael Rouvier, Richard Dufour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Subword tokenization has become the prevailing standard in the field of
natural language processing (NLP) over recent years, primarily due to the
widespread utilization of pre-trained language models. This shift began with
Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) and was later followed by the adoption of
SentencePiece and WordPiece. While subword tokenization consistently
outperforms character and word-level tokenization, the precise factors
contributing to its success remain unclear. Key aspects such as the optimal
segmentation granularity for diverse tasks and languages, the influence of data
sources on tokenizers, and the role of morphological information in
Indo-European languages remain insufficiently explored. This is particularly
pertinent for biomedical terminology, characterized by specific rules governing
morpheme combinations. Despite the agglutinative nature of biomedical
terminology, existing language models do not explicitly incorporate this
knowledge, leading to inconsistent tokenization strategies for common terms. In
this paper, we seek to delve into the complexities of subword tokenization in
French biomedical domain across a variety of NLP tasks and pinpoint areas where
further enhancements can be made. We analyze classical tokenization algorithms,
including BPE and SentencePiece, and introduce an original tokenization
strategy that integrates morpheme-enriched word segmentation into existing
tokenization methods.
|
[
-0.3017708063,
-0.69427526,
0.4467844665,
0.1018856689,
-0.6877670288,
0.3174074292,
0.2920401096,
-0.6140173078,
0.6718607545,
0.4698999226,
-0.2132763118,
-0.3984158337,
-0.9769537449,
0.1352391988,
-0.1483479887,
0.9179090261,
0.0749707744,
0.4854129255,
-0.2877296805,
-0.3535109162,
-0.5327837467,
-1.2033706903,
-0.7190231085,
-0.5581681728,
0.6653302312,
-0.310367614,
0.5711427331,
0.7657898068,
0.6241357327,
0.2600916922,
-0.3458864093,
0.2105216086,
-0.0902081802,
-0.0609243512,
-0.4609895647,
-0.3933336139,
-0.402284205,
-0.089986451,
0.4516510367,
1.274782896,
0.2953133583,
-0.3051039577,
-0.264622122,
0.5781453252,
-0.3489900529,
0.0736769438,
-0.5572345853,
0.0668492913,
-0.440477252,
-0.2650595605,
-0.0806476027,
0.1557480991,
0.0059396545,
-0.2358014435,
0.1750426292,
-0.1191823259,
0.7761462331,
-0.0189281143,
-0.3843331933,
-0.2512053847,
-0.3724356592,
0.4975365996,
-0.4680270851,
0.6201307774,
0.2487858385,
-0.1333925873,
-0.1746405959,
-1.1668447256,
-0.1693923324,
0.0537382215,
-0.3191097379,
-0.0461238772,
-0.4279725552,
0.4474149346,
-0.0182678644,
0.2709708214,
-0.2543917,
0.3027895093,
-0.6789403558,
-0.5218788385,
0.243382141,
-0.0530467704,
0.7264290452,
-0.3557972312,
-0.3844135702,
0.3375944197,
-0.6423947215,
-0.0301488787,
-0.0100044012,
0.2567565441,
0.1496912986,
0.7293677926,
0.0152950473,
0.5417334437,
-0.1407876015,
0.1537161916,
0.2254481912,
-0.5153800845,
-0.1973435581,
0.0020969193,
0.5340050459,
0.1638865918,
0.1269873381,
-0.5199626684,
-0.2003196478,
0.0153224133,
0.3364959061,
-0.8682587743,
-0.2035282552,
0.4518483579,
-0.4514082372,
-0.065309383,
0.10215725,
-0.3467591405,
-0.3600655794,
-0.1701974869,
0.4077767134,
-0.5091065168,
0.1069684476,
0.4804803431,
-0.2824220359,
-0.0071570827,
0.2045036554,
-1.0408848524,
0.3250420392,
0.9920376539,
1.0974495411,
-0.3791717887,
0.0175439175,
-0.7039811015,
-0.1676795781,
-0.3718461394,
0.7112052441,
-0.7051738501,
-0.7559185624,
-0.0249595772,
0.3742924631,
-0.4481188059,
-0.4866882563,
0.2851366997,
-0.3012969196,
0.0730957091,
-0.1599085033,
-0.8027812243,
-0.1505145282,
-0.1102919802,
-0.421369791,
0.563534677,
-0.012765117,
-0.845435977,
0.5326561332,
-0.8103749156,
-0.5905353427,
0.5235211849,
-0.3772445321,
-0.1840270907,
0.5322213769,
0.5019581914,
0.578600049,
0.1047245115,
0.1501407325,
0.2199736536,
-0.2500373423,
0.3717830181,
-0.0971451104,
0.5542235374,
-0.2728960812,
-0.1822606027,
0.1571325958,
-0.362206012,
-0.1105138361,
-0.2364774793,
-0.0373774506,
-0.5314914584,
-0.0503676683,
0.3011786938,
-0.064943485,
0.0882577226,
-0.7890518904,
0.1154911369,
-0.9161000252,
0.8589770198,
0.392888397,
0.4271820486,
0.4827111363,
-0.1612710059,
0.6031042337,
0.2411610037,
0.224091351,
-0.2573043108,
-0.6761877537,
-0.4900397956,
-0.9057867527,
0.9099966884,
0.5528915524,
-0.4684460163,
0.1582394391,
-0.120194301,
-0.3246182799,
-0.5959445238,
-0.204710111,
0.2510972321,
0.3421022594,
0.533783555,
-0.804802835,
-0.5769788623,
-1.2394267321,
-0.3640866578,
-0.0177240651,
0.0663554147,
0.2267398238,
0.7320536971,
-0.7129454017,
0.9154595733,
-0.2193713933,
-0.2754819989,
-0.2607394755,
0.1805802137,
0.1616128087,
0.8666372299,
0.7064064145,
-0.8757423162,
-0.0026256971,
0.1546174735,
-0.3177892268,
-0.1287027448,
-0.0303582568,
-0.1093833819,
-0.0011648576,
0.8612163663,
-0.4986713231,
0.6094315052,
0.5264331102,
-0.1786355674,
0.2146151215,
-0.3314218223,
-0.0023829758,
-1.0980621576,
0.1607581526,
-0.3040109575,
-0.4045488238,
-0.862971127,
0.1493429691,
-0.0961717293,
-0.0217481125,
-0.5910894275,
1.0197225809,
-0.3661275804,
0.244883135,
-0.3442820311,
-0.0297837239,
0.0042113471,
0.1658829749,
0.2723017931,
0.5199110508,
0.6055897474,
-0.3599790037,
0.0424388237,
0.2470265627,
-0.065456003,
0.3204184473,
-0.9949625134,
0.1180986091,
-0.2080961317,
0.1440680623,
-0.7218319774,
-0.2231547087,
0.2927020192,
-0.3631427586,
0.4163565934,
-0.3304798305,
-0.3288365006,
-0.0982039794,
-0.0590065457,
0.734860301,
0.5149667859,
-0.1861088574,
0.4476124346,
0.7016424537,
-0.1347255707,
-0.4813817143,
-0.8032618761,
0.3463801146,
0.0337331295,
-0.4555449188,
0.7058096528,
0.2319669873,
-0.0861228034,
-0.1287412792,
-0.4541369677,
-0.1588552147,
-0.0195035692,
0.1951255649,
0.1701842546,
0.0088017425,
0.4132622778,
0.1279806048,
-0.3327589631,
-0.3102492988,
-0.6174114347,
0.756868124,
0.1849088371,
-0.4271986783,
-0.2421602309,
0.5964612365,
0.5840988755,
-0.4219398797,
1.0162709951,
0.718167007,
-0.7127820253,
0.1923880577,
-0.5129199028,
-0.3404018283,
-0.3590870798,
0.6951417327,
-0.2937029898,
-0.9376787543,
0.6484576464,
-0.0342417285,
0.0183977559,
0.417670697,
0.607511878,
-0.0033358426,
0.9494355321,
0.7294799089,
0.2219045907,
0.3442471623,
0.0551023707,
0.4595325887,
-0.8175039291,
-0.2502204478,
-0.3370020986,
-0.1322983652,
-0.8004293442,
-0.842939198,
0.4898794889,
0.1656572968,
0.4856033623,
0.1628165245,
-0.4875980616,
0.3396857083,
0.4149512351,
0.2538952529,
0.0495610572,
0.1578823179,
-0.4241885841,
-0.1437148154,
-0.8710071445,
-0.5032426119,
0.7041688561,
0.4360783696,
0.3484712243,
-0.4087887108,
0.8201032877,
0.2518680692,
0.0480874069,
-0.9307912588,
0.372651726,
-0.5082094669,
-0.4931333363,
-0.0491194911,
-0.1112291217,
-1.183811307,
0.3979073763,
-0.3150468767,
-0.7478813529,
0.5569499731,
-0.011137357,
-0.2572567165,
0.1816693991,
-0.5036116838,
0.9865527749,
0.1140528843,
-0.0450230613,
0.0937072635,
-0.5941665769,
-0.2026759684,
-0.3535205424,
0.4335441291,
0.220344767,
-0.3947791755,
0.8148493171,
-0.6768487096,
0.9152249098,
0.1027582511,
0.1334140748,
-0.1308405548,
-0.0699319094,
0.1775185615,
0.2293049693,
0.3330442309,
0.6362166405,
0.528840661,
-0.7003250122,
-0.2290131152,
0.3504002094,
-0.3777047396,
-0.555977881,
-0.3998238742,
-0.255363822,
-0.3585268557,
0.1470474303,
0.6230511665,
0.809442997,
-0.1935693324,
0.2915928364,
0.5936802626,
-0.4243148565,
0.1678023487,
0.112993136,
-0.2688004673,
-0.3668108582,
0.8680520058,
0.173325792,
0.1709522307,
0.685583055,
0.2063080966,
-0.2580016553,
-0.8967700601,
-0.4136493504,
0.5479454398,
-0.7534609437,
0.0944251344,
-1.1096018553,
-0.5071614385,
-0.4411812127,
-0.3165131807,
-0.2334684432,
-0.6002773643,
-0.2203811705,
-0.1446395814,
0.0323603451,
0.4170362353,
-0.2597540915,
0.0656540841,
-1.1234973669,
0.2438942939,
0.2383918315,
0.0794072151,
-0.5876432061,
-0.2516849339,
-0.1908132136,
-0.1373081058,
0.5286937952,
-0.9261763096,
0.1276124865,
0.1332316101,
0.667581141,
0.0856004357,
-0.4682197273,
0.4290494025,
-0.7560067177,
0.8849648833,
0.2202593535,
-0.9497535229,
0.3209609091,
-0.2116091847,
0.2550971508,
0.3089110851,
0.2061030418,
-1.1004420519,
-0.3479820192,
-0.5638088584,
-1.0803587437,
0.2806435227,
0.377294302,
0.4814215899,
-0.4839364886,
0.4102291763,
0.2968716621,
0.3810364604,
-0.5992220044,
-0.0338829756,
-0.0342824794,
-0.0712791234,
0.0208792742,
-0.3014931679,
-0.1849999875,
-0.1749884933,
0.4265684187,
-0.0284144264,
0.2408406287,
0.4178587794,
-0.154198736,
0.3293867409,
0.262958318,
0.6435091496,
0.5974298716,
0.1174264178,
-0.0430027209,
-0.0559444949,
-0.8723771572,
-0.2360384315,
0.1580564976,
-0.1949124187,
0.4674892724,
0.6684067249,
0.6696262956,
0.0992290378,
-0.7270044684,
0.5374959111,
0.2580019534,
-0.2074249089,
0.1950278282,
-0.182547152,
-0.0248022154,
0.1819188446,
0.1092604399,
0.2953341901,
0.0192757007,
-0.5292053819,
0.3241938055,
0.6356266737,
-0.6276605725,
-0.3200072646,
0.636805892,
0.2318569124,
-0.3825761974,
0.1418118775,
0.1460625678,
-0.6224215031,
0.4503483772,
0.2522841096,
0.9201096892,
-0.1420424134,
0.3470370471,
0.1348508596,
0.4919907153,
0.153259486,
-0.0232101772,
0.1907026023,
-0.6239590645,
-0.4655036628,
-1.009382844,
-0.1625865102,
-0.0876301453,
-0.2673069537,
0.0777461007,
-0.3310073316,
-0.3898516297,
0.1101273596,
-0.4895811379,
-0.6155642867,
0.3889787197,
-0.0350325927,
0.8425160646,
-0.6311756968,
0.5524199009,
0.9428429008,
-0.3039166331,
-0.3835707903,
-0.3148552477,
-0.2867571115,
-0.9862751961,
0.8111799359,
0.0133319218,
0.0828149915,
-0.1927528083,
-0.1926137209,
-0.5350487232,
0.3634288013,
-0.0709461197,
-0.5747979283,
-0.287530154,
0.3472361565,
0.8637826443,
-0.5226278305,
-0.0516906828,
0.4755984545,
0.2144168317,
0.06115558,
-0.9421428442,
-0.0369838849,
-0.1348504573,
0.2346883267,
0.3489480913,
-0.2736531794,
0.6993710399,
0.1148842424,
-0.2532626987,
-0.0600307025,
0.2976213694,
-0.2263535261,
0.0378164612,
0.3302437961,
0.0680025369,
0.6041280031,
-0.2169001997,
1.0286692381,
-0.381845504,
-0.0010732604,
0.5125328898,
0.0519421361,
0.5380399823,
0.7643100023,
-0.0541565306,
0.4041175842,
0.7305318713,
0.1396704167,
0.2688980699,
0.2801518142,
-0.231755197,
-0.3853622079,
-0.2201444358,
-0.3984255791,
0.6707779169,
0.4715851247,
-0.5700346231,
-0.0017684271,
0.3632234335,
0.0630933419,
-0.0653985292,
-0.4395723343,
0.8272566199,
0.2384208143,
-0.3162994385,
0.2544078827,
0.269377768,
0.4103780389,
-0.6486257911,
0.0987532884,
-0.3682112098,
-0.1516199708,
-0.2486114204,
-0.0809136704,
0.3727523386,
-0.2392553836,
-0.0001635218,
-0.1557465494,
0.7668004036,
-0.3158890903,
-0.7065681815,
0.0058517884,
0.8577562571,
0.1599063873,
-0.0141781271,
-0.5742269754,
-0.036583975,
-0.2420271188,
0.059124507,
0.3995713592,
0.3353158832,
-0.1527906209,
0.3605671823,
0.5857185721,
0.5101363063,
0.1590012014,
0.1810609251,
0.7724556923,
-0.5349155068,
-0.5880439878,
-0.9666564465,
0.532705307,
-0.09810891,
-0.0969846547,
0.4842075408,
0.4752348065,
0.4972643554,
-0.1583377868,
0.6556862593,
0.2263411134,
0.3594893515,
-0.75692451,
0.5310134888,
-0.6836745739,
0.1024857014,
-0.1967222542,
-0.741563797,
-0.6822634339,
0.4818086922,
-0.1391754448,
0.0439120457,
0.9168447852,
0.6414848566,
-0.0594818555,
-0.1366041452,
0.4953754246,
0.052497033,
0.3230005801,
0.0811235979,
0.3325528502,
-0.4216983914,
0.0790235028,
-0.034613777,
-0.3308548927,
-0.1833670437,
-0.8447014689,
-1.1497695446,
-0.6765196919,
-0.5702730417,
-0.2505215406,
0.3124763668,
1.0365018845,
0.8520613313,
-0.9790799022,
0.2268663496,
-0.2433364689,
0.0297377054,
-0.2482161373,
-0.1395830512,
0.5211241841,
-0.5659906864,
-0.9303783774,
0.3619431257,
0.9495950341,
0.2566930354,
-0.1610357612,
0.5038003922,
0.0134129589,
0.5075649619,
0.7000952363,
0.2209181935,
-0.7428411841,
-0.2673795223,
0.1245139092,
-0.164454475,
0.1384122223,
1.1568813324,
-0.7214170098,
0.7149372697,
0.524774909,
0.785341084,
0.3381131887,
-0.0460471138,
0.7446144819,
-0.7825784683,
0.3320083916,
0.504524231,
0.5845323205,
0.3555302918,
-0.2310770452,
0.6084623337,
0.7392196655,
-0.2946509421,
-0.8659211993,
0.4401823282,
-0.8202841282,
-0.525488019,
0.8965155482,
0.1353304684,
-0.2188426256,
-0.4510258436,
-0.5064476132,
0.0142350355,
0.0877756178,
0.5177767873,
0.7476690412,
-0.2055967599,
-0.0065775644,
-0.3754862547,
0.7293043733,
0.5081694722,
-0.5148014426,
-0.3157237172,
0.212898165,
0.1106359437,
0.1956945509,
0.9691636562,
-0.3353042901,
0.0856724158,
-0.0612986237,
-0.1522303224,
0.0683080852,
-0.0086877188,
-0.1576933414,
0.2182690948,
-0.3079738915,
-0.2806529105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15002v1
|
CommVQA: Situating Visual Question Answering in Communicative Contexts
| 2024-02-22T22:31:39 | 2024-02-22T22:31:39 |
Nandita Shankar Naik, Christopher Potts, Elisa Kreiss
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Current visual question answering (VQA) models tend to be trained and
evaluated on image-question pairs in isolation. However, the questions people
ask are dependent on their informational needs and prior knowledge about the
image content. To evaluate how situating images within naturalistic contexts
shapes visual questions, we introduce CommVQA, a VQA dataset consisting of
images, image descriptions, real-world communicative scenarios where the image
might appear (e.g., a travel website), and follow-up questions and answers
conditioned on the scenario. We show that CommVQA poses a challenge for current
models. Providing contextual information to VQA models improves performance
broadly, highlighting the relevance of situating systems within a communicative
scenario.
|
[
-0.7670453191,
-0.8751036525,
0.5104340315,
0.1145810261,
-0.3353611529,
-0.2019322515,
0.017083358,
-0.4347835779,
-0.0427912325,
0.6086540222,
-0.6853379607,
-0.2302654535,
-0.3308080435,
-0.0455940664,
-0.2744773328,
0.0668791011,
-0.0606132969,
0.0351346917,
-0.7868347168,
-0.5180957317,
-0.9798774123,
-0.56304878,
-0.4301152825,
0.1388314813,
0.3203106523,
0.5606980324,
0.7711630464,
0.4437018931,
0.5020171404,
0.3801333606,
0.1303592622,
0.011110981,
-0.4268625975,
0.3750506938,
0.2078389376,
-0.6465659738,
0.4298393726,
-0.0510636829,
0.6373240948,
0.9460806251,
-0.1008771658,
0.3561932147,
-0.1920956373,
0.1504365206,
-0.6689754725,
0.0604891963,
-0.5304731727,
0.0445962511,
0.3309399188,
-0.6612035036,
-0.175155431,
-0.2510399818,
0.5480378866,
-0.7446087599,
0.087949127,
0.0644739494,
1.034299016,
0.4990999997,
-0.7631289959,
-0.1061361879,
-0.5777901411,
0.5704383254,
-0.0109963976,
0.4065133035,
0.2556025982,
0.6345969439,
0.0541781597,
-0.813603282,
-0.4945717752,
0.1410685331,
-0.0889480785,
0.2997597754,
-0.29630059,
-0.2384365052,
0.4273087382,
0.1584653407,
-0.691929698,
-0.3712167442,
-0.4206885695,
0.0501816571,
0.254850179,
0.3017096221,
0.6057229042,
-0.3961257935,
-0.5526118279,
-0.1286539584,
-0.7205542326,
0.6059779525,
-0.323944211,
-0.272898674,
-0.2045193166,
0.5248163342,
-0.4360513687,
0.9358985424,
0.0061833411,
0.3458999991,
-0.2084909827,
-0.4146817327,
-0.349003166,
-0.3266920447,
0.2104501873,
0.8161947131,
0.232174322,
0.33627823,
0.0489828289,
-0.102783896,
0.3721206188,
-0.6388198137,
-0.1497924328,
0.1777397543,
-0.3892858922,
0.0065585501,
0.1656363606,
-0.3808261156,
-0.1549833566,
-0.5648013949,
0.5117734075,
0.046981737,
-0.0165929832,
-0.2213599235,
-0.4100687504,
0.8642186522,
0.8643452525,
-0.481623292,
0.1866210997,
0.35803473,
0.4816639721,
0.1240709648,
-0.0061843828,
-0.7995500565,
0.0137053365,
-0.4071254432,
0.8532150984,
-0.4055595398,
-0.4139532745,
0.2063110322,
0.5507264733,
0.0495777577,
-0.6937856674,
0.1728909016,
-0.8227921724,
0.4588283002,
-0.7440960407,
-0.0706984475,
-0.3096774817,
0.5792878866,
-0.752877295,
0.8318685293,
-0.0766602159,
-0.8034260273,
0.4822066724,
-0.2445113212,
-0.1016391665,
0.3755710721,
-0.6782616973,
-0.1188771203,
-0.0540854558,
0.57714504,
0.3358150721,
-0.0971351713,
0.0386908464,
-0.0772759914,
-0.6471095085,
0.6507382393,
-0.2959734797,
0.8133234382,
0.1623803824,
-0.2656163275,
-0.015988091,
-0.6247442961,
0.1801944077,
0.1028255224,
-0.3301278353,
-0.7350303531,
0.0457038097,
-0.0054044966,
0.2735049427,
0.0318644792,
-0.308083564,
-0.0035707862,
-0.1317602992,
0.2564750612,
0.518686831,
0.4018009007,
0.2828595936,
-0.3527133763,
0.6099533439,
0.1870582849,
0.2903681695,
-0.3407325447,
-0.7363002896,
-0.7623708248,
-0.1874088496,
-0.0848314613,
0.5790824294,
-1.1948159933,
-0.3909331858,
-0.2956514359,
-0.2280572057,
-0.2586804926,
-0.2535858154,
0.3230007291,
0.6884664297,
0.3113375008,
-0.3214383423,
-0.5587220788,
-0.893114686,
0.1545569003,
-0.1534743905,
-0.0373678021,
0.7228049636,
0.5013254881,
0.2435619086,
0.6219742894,
-0.6149311066,
0.3690631092,
0.0451350994,
0.1997724622,
-0.0645622015,
0.176631093,
0.3545232415,
-1.4163544178,
-0.1517199129,
-0.28104195,
-1.0462079048,
0.0262658279,
-0.2551225126,
-0.1529176533,
-0.0547862686,
0.6703640223,
-0.5259751678,
0.6709469557,
0.3736438453,
-0.3337095082,
0.3252930939,
-0.1950891614,
0.5799975395,
-0.9820452332,
0.1491394341,
0.0027777054,
-0.3506561816,
-0.4811981618,
0.2735649645,
-0.047968708,
-0.2583687305,
-0.5896665454,
0.6280040741,
-0.5883982778,
-0.2004380226,
0.0831218734,
0.1987378299,
0.1330332309,
0.3213626742,
0.5984694362,
0.6140381694,
0.6242659688,
-0.617881,
0.2651800811,
0.6764958501,
-0.5216190815,
0.9896396399,
-0.7860613465,
0.096105352,
-0.3084989786,
0.2360473126,
-1.3549691439,
-0.4319739938,
0.2092294544,
-0.5618016124,
-0.1641979963,
-0.4322326779,
-0.1561867744,
-0.2967060208,
-0.0165351909,
0.8125890493,
0.4127411842,
-0.7260903716,
0.3110697269,
0.3998906612,
-0.2613744736,
-0.7600748539,
-0.6763762236,
0.2885521948,
-0.4112454057,
-0.7831860781,
-0.1277014166,
0.0587774403,
-0.4478197098,
-0.2250338793,
0.0169453919,
-0.3383491039,
0.208077848,
0.6285218596,
0.3304992616,
-0.2139723003,
0.147060886,
-0.2495681792,
0.3083686233,
0.3174891174,
-0.1729286015,
0.1520486027,
0.0315470174,
-0.1793476939,
-0.2082522511,
0.880007565,
0.2836001217,
-0.3199159503,
0.3888131678,
0.2797180712,
-0.3872546852,
-0.0236086287,
-0.4082993567,
0.0388921387,
-0.4936567843,
0.1251758337,
-0.5109469891,
-0.8541507721,
0.3967023194,
0.1578465402,
-0.2355425209,
-0.1818922758,
0.6771782637,
-0.5694307685,
0.8542972207,
0.6384251118,
0.6534030437,
0.3423538804,
-0.3001153469,
-0.1306860745,
-0.5404989123,
-0.43827492,
-0.3789690435,
-0.1520077139,
-0.7837594151,
-0.6787575483,
0.5682282448,
-0.3772301972,
-0.0608569197,
0.2116636634,
-0.3414942026,
0.4169376194,
0.8881776929,
0.248144269,
0.3361584842,
-0.1160913929,
-0.1221823096,
0.0968221575,
-0.9607229829,
-0.5759088993,
0.6962677836,
0.0794337243,
0.7615693808,
0.2101133168,
0.3988523483,
-0.115599893,
0.2299205959,
-0.6482900381,
0.6412627101,
0.4567604661,
-0.7242591381,
-0.3022921383,
-0.238858819,
-1.1774512529,
0.3016379476,
-0.2015166134,
-0.64302212,
0.5671928525,
0.1772680879,
-0.4237474203,
-0.2821438611,
-0.6089211702,
0.915309608,
0.0417570584,
-0.4681395888,
0.1869059354,
-1.0480946302,
0.2527710497,
0.3390479982,
0.2180700004,
0.4459748268,
-0.0555966273,
0.5099513531,
-0.3477080464,
0.7711369991,
-0.0728757456,
0.0002048948,
0.6009693146,
0.0203174353,
-0.0167270787,
0.2955909371,
0.5241380334,
-0.1408073902,
0.6931867003,
-0.5111762285,
-0.7554897666,
0.5989207625,
-0.557076931,
-0.6700901985,
-0.2904570699,
-0.5281636715,
-0.2761515379,
-0.0852307156,
0.3892398179,
0.7233711481,
-0.2759764791,
0.4595855176,
0.8466060162,
-0.5527006984,
0.387270987,
0.0688415319,
-0.038218163,
-0.1889022589,
0.4591057301,
0.1026922539,
0.2451331615,
0.4316540062,
-0.1431696415,
-0.473949343,
-0.049332466,
-0.3900158703,
-0.0565104373,
-1.3755867481,
0.0545067005,
-0.470970422,
-0.0209150538,
-0.0241731647,
-0.1840999424,
0.1743569374,
-0.3581757247,
-0.1037620082,
0.1751695573,
-0.195855394,
0.5396655798,
0.0793617442,
0.1655533761,
-0.6146824956,
0.5563539267,
0.9043442607,
0.1346595883,
-0.2265230566,
-0.310714215,
-0.1507557184,
0.1045287177,
-0.2083162218,
-1.0111902952,
0.0033378173,
-0.019669462,
0.5573352575,
-0.064843215,
0.1135513112,
0.7466010451,
-0.3031968176,
0.8663156033,
-0.0269663054,
-0.427485913,
0.650075376,
-0.3985331953,
0.7539848089,
0.3664698899,
0.6363729835,
-0.6528297067,
-0.2052304,
-0.5258406401,
-0.6103707552,
0.1494787484,
0.2678310275,
0.2909937501,
-0.0426459275,
0.3508619964,
-0.212194562,
0.1730279326,
-0.7793162465,
-0.0335703306,
-0.3854509294,
0.0406420045,
0.0474074744,
-0.0332969725,
-0.5119415522,
-0.3785666823,
0.0516711362,
-0.1899452507,
0.4622270465,
0.5701719522,
-0.3094263971,
-0.0157397464,
-0.0069166883,
0.4640338719,
0.6475856304,
-0.0851768628,
0.3561032116,
0.1875400245,
-0.1689649969,
0.2329943925,
-0.2439964116,
-0.2618499398,
0.0208344739,
0.2482297122,
0.5650696754,
0.1687342525,
-0.7318992019,
0.6789066195,
-0.5642918348,
-0.3364883959,
-0.4277736843,
-0.0283327103,
0.1318111718,
0.3675965667,
0.2750703394,
-0.1898999661,
0.3354601264,
-0.8518627286,
0.3094744682,
0.6975390315,
-0.418125838,
0.0937497318,
0.5927420855,
0.0272568483,
-0.0783378333,
0.4752069712,
0.3567680418,
-0.5145896673,
0.8455631733,
0.2299100608,
0.3004628718,
0.0401075073,
0.3090813458,
0.423370868,
0.2812172771,
0.2451757491,
0.8219292164,
-0.4297851026,
-0.3828375041,
-0.2964950204,
0.1132236272,
-0.6360028386,
-0.0952984318,
-0.6419142485,
0.329654932,
-0.2790108323,
-0.1275963038,
-0.1402750909,
-0.2723981142,
-1.0183056593,
0.8084971905,
0.4980968833,
0.7535425425,
-0.6329058409,
0.3619149923,
0.8775435686,
-0.3167405427,
-0.8477790356,
0.2052835375,
-0.1214158311,
-0.537493825,
0.836963594,
0.2912935913,
-0.1795672327,
0.0373815708,
-1.2253466845,
-0.8776905537,
1.1948028803,
0.0916765407,
0.0397371575,
0.2550807595,
0.0635344312,
0.4428867996,
-0.3432668746,
0.3017929196,
-0.0063319723,
0.3334015012,
0.5205021501,
-0.6448101997,
0.2526619434,
-0.4957759976,
0.0252756011,
-0.1763144583,
-0.4599105716,
0.5071457624,
-0.2657448649,
-0.3260715604,
0.3015545607,
0.4540470243,
0.1722802669,
0.3217995465,
0.4502940476,
0.2518797517,
0.646045208,
-0.3805415332,
1.1123367548,
0.3053554296,
0.0384581871,
1.2388298512,
0.239248842,
0.8331925273,
0.7848699093,
0.4134962261,
0.4345520437,
0.8849426508,
0.0097955335,
0.5026630163,
0.4641226232,
-0.1055969819,
-0.6546723247,
-0.1500023156,
-0.3940465152,
0.8360826373,
0.0977230296,
0.0282490794,
-0.1304463893,
-0.105440475,
-0.4634734988,
-0.0183672998,
-0.1257460266,
0.6599259973,
-0.0113649042,
-1.058334589,
0.8554286957,
-0.3257883489,
-0.126138553,
-0.0739282295,
-0.3265149295,
-0.4070291817,
-0.3563484848,
0.0073129642,
-0.8756471276,
0.2098291665,
-0.2431321591,
0.232557565,
0.0513396561,
0.516622901,
-0.2953610718,
-0.2646312118,
-0.2719710767,
0.715898037,
0.0521176234,
-0.0286191329,
-0.5079538226,
-0.102373451,
-0.5016164184,
-0.191286847,
-0.0144642955,
0.6324782968,
-0.4073624611,
0.9372425675,
0.4515456259,
-0.5287082195,
0.1294391602,
-0.1701924652,
0.7697885036,
-0.593483448,
-0.7640045285,
-0.3568613231,
0.7508117557,
-0.1793940365,
-0.2522186339,
0.6777973771,
0.154794991,
0.6834958196,
-0.123749271,
0.7839903235,
0.067201376,
-0.0775646567,
-0.6350983381,
0.3835716844,
-0.841809988,
0.1372935027,
-0.3207944036,
-0.6643329859,
-0.414526999,
0.5853672028,
-0.4010428786,
-0.2359257042,
0.4752422571,
0.692878902,
-0.1201187149,
0.1250683963,
0.4809104502,
-0.1988866925,
0.1164815202,
0.6535678506,
1.5761165619,
-0.4419247806,
0.4406259358,
-0.2319484055,
-0.1919976175,
-0.1870504916,
-0.8227353096,
-0.9507875443,
-0.9615368843,
-0.4743334949,
-0.2238835692,
-0.0851715878,
0.6699456573,
0.9002229571,
-0.2298351973,
-0.2330340594,
0.2646523118,
0.031802807,
0.0057069752,
-0.1996814907,
0.0811459348,
0.1157347038,
-0.3694182932,
0.0090976292,
0.2066659331,
0.2793288231,
-0.1894849241,
0.1474804133,
-0.4847256243,
0.2990747988,
0.486430943,
0.2935108542,
-0.5027710795,
-0.5237392783,
0.4280543625,
-0.0996745154,
0.3893608153,
0.6770458221,
-0.8949576616,
0.486643523,
0.467541188,
0.5793278813,
0.5142111182,
0.2852847278,
0.7632111311,
-0.8143603206,
0.0724646375,
-0.0349360667,
0.2816856802,
0.5765056014,
-0.3977887332,
0.2493404001,
0.2334228307,
-0.4335306585,
-0.5727957487,
0.2572189867,
-1.345510602,
-0.2113068253,
1.0724761486,
-0.1553928554,
-0.2762145996,
-0.3036218584,
-0.4756046832,
-0.0244914703,
0.2940037549,
0.5903226733,
0.7082663774,
0.0711927563,
-0.5703763962,
-0.7672535777,
0.3264295161,
0.4720277786,
-0.9246330857,
-0.2699069679,
0.8134852648,
0.3777711689,
-0.0557786711,
0.6692304611,
0.1162545681,
0.7083528638,
-0.1711425185,
-0.3588119149,
0.307310313,
-0.251992166,
-0.2077263296,
0.315615803,
0.0124883596,
-0.4810997546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15000v1
|
Divide-or-Conquer? Which Part Should You Distill Your LLM?
| 2024-02-22T22:28:46 | 2024-02-22T22:28:46 |
Zhuofeng Wu, He Bai, Aonan Zhang, Jiatao Gu, VG Vinod Vydiswaran, Navdeep Jaitly, Yizhe Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent methods have demonstrated that Large Language Models (LLMs) can solve
reasoning tasks better when they are encouraged to solve subtasks of the main
task first. In this paper we devise a similar strategy that breaks down
reasoning tasks into a problem decomposition phase and a problem solving phase
and show that the strategy is able to outperform a single stage solution.
Further, we hypothesize that the decomposition should be easier to distill into
a smaller model compared to the problem solving because the latter requires
large amounts of domain knowledge while the former only requires learning
general problem solving strategies. We propose methods to distill these two
capabilities and evaluate their impact on reasoning outcomes and inference
cost. We find that we can distill the problem decomposition phase and at the
same time achieve good generalization across tasks, datasets, and models.
However, it is harder to distill the problem solving capability without losing
performance and the resulting distilled model struggles with generalization.
These results indicate that by using smaller, distilled problem decomposition
models in combination with problem solving LLMs we can achieve reasoning with
cost-efficient inference and local adaptation.
|
[
-0.4496216774,
-0.7461109757,
0.9213778973,
0.1139161214,
-0.3160970211,
0.3043682575,
-0.3135585189,
-0.168784827,
-0.2453527004,
0.6255121827,
-0.5546967983,
-0.1691624671,
-0.9245265126,
0.0634887144,
-0.3135902584,
0.7341569662,
0.0294721723,
0.035011027,
-0.58196491,
0.1074237749,
-0.4294658601,
-0.6753842235,
-0.9097595811,
-0.8262554407,
0.5494671464,
0.5321367979,
0.4544361234,
0.7697317004,
0.42707178,
0.4127002656,
-0.5750876665,
0.3320164382,
-0.5702889562,
0.3910290897,
-0.3762874603,
-0.7032945752,
-0.2127396315,
0.001129488,
0.1023496836,
1.1128575802,
-0.3823240697,
0.0596658327,
0.0923477113,
0.8128439188,
-0.4947855473,
0.1303824633,
-0.6851688623,
-0.167773366,
0.0830265358,
0.13219136,
-0.3918503225,
-0.1039247736,
0.2453216463,
-0.6108059287,
0.2047374547,
0.0815773159,
0.4306084812,
0.6099768281,
-0.5612304211,
-0.342545718,
-1.1351275444,
1.1846621037,
-0.4822378755,
-0.007810581,
0.2730988264,
0.4135347307,
-0.3878406286,
-0.7047715783,
-0.3979466259,
-0.0558447018,
-0.0449240468,
-0.1259920299,
-0.4976945519,
0.0339940377,
0.3923145831,
0.4764319956,
-0.3151521087,
0.1236785352,
-0.7330976129,
-0.1044095159,
0.7403486967,
0.1421245486,
0.3095110655,
-0.0373886637,
-0.4115721285,
0.0265261158,
-0.6421567798,
-0.1413512379,
0.0810637623,
0.3061310351,
0.5189560652,
0.6060119271,
-0.0666553378,
0.3027914166,
0.3367065787,
-0.7249645591,
-0.1908167601,
-0.3982763588,
-0.3484827578,
-0.0092248386,
0.3994601071,
0.1258254945,
0.2789576352,
-0.1779668182,
-0.1851694286,
0.0274874605,
0.3071553707,
-0.6824644804,
-0.3586052954,
0.3537930846,
-0.4258848131,
0.1752548367,
-0.5244033337,
-0.2756965756,
-0.5847383142,
-0.7593165636,
0.3031633794,
-0.4876280725,
-0.2642038167,
0.2597002983,
-0.3212180734,
0.0631493628,
0.6924099326,
-0.7824533582,
0.4716829062,
1.0476808548,
0.680791676,
-0.2863806486,
-0.0877543837,
-0.3040137589,
-0.1156871989,
-0.3869432211,
0.6090493202,
-0.1283579618,
-0.6909319758,
-0.2243982255,
-0.2060775608,
-0.0950464904,
-1.196403861,
0.6163358688,
-0.4504503012,
0.0516541526,
-0.5900946856,
-0.6657807827,
-0.3079199493,
0.1975584626,
-0.9794012308,
0.7432249784,
-0.0566247813,
-0.8067917824,
0.3276772201,
-0.4424597621,
-0.6281792521,
-0.0299387686,
0.0018040098,
-0.1178330407,
0.4058712125,
0.3496921062,
0.5353553891,
-0.4964320064,
0.2465341389,
-0.1813145429,
-0.0092520183,
0.0497234575,
-0.166914314,
0.7876467705,
0.4905800223,
-0.1732139438,
-0.173038885,
-0.5410189033,
-0.255551666,
0.3331753612,
-0.3854285181,
-0.5848888755,
0.4526921809,
-0.6621482372,
-0.0563345812,
0.3427898884,
-0.4835407734,
0.2953109443,
-0.2490335405,
0.4418584108,
0.5466539264,
0.0937442407,
0.9318668246,
-0.2406145483,
0.5414417982,
0.2819640338,
0.1905387193,
0.3468527794,
-0.286026597,
-1.1496862173,
-0.5597905517,
0.1317151338,
0.5224640965,
-1.0411379337,
0.0774901211,
-0.0255161338,
-0.4471363425,
-0.4514265358,
0.1311119944,
0.3276027739,
0.4620397389,
0.5179519057,
0.1812205613,
-0.487038523,
-1.0567641258,
-0.0380881317,
-0.2502984107,
-0.0398401022,
-0.1586630195,
0.5381110311,
0.1223451495,
0.8922550082,
-0.7181541324,
-0.2164574116,
-0.7774104476,
0.1503697634,
0.1482014805,
0.3663787544,
0.2337304056,
-1.0245730877,
-0.3266110718,
0.016810067,
-0.5778304338,
-0.0739765838,
0.078257069,
-0.0958997384,
0.0888644978,
0.3333197534,
-0.4448221922,
0.2952726185,
0.2983927429,
-0.1366298646,
0.4772754014,
-0.4235867858,
0.1299299747,
-0.8748474121,
-0.2828696072,
0.1009340063,
-0.216812253,
-0.7935215831,
0.1112110019,
-0.4039486945,
0.0857950151,
-0.2222545892,
0.1557992101,
-0.6334477067,
0.2002204657,
-0.4681868255,
0.1467893273,
0.2543514073,
0.3043633699,
0.0463617519,
0.5087433457,
0.3729757667,
-0.546333015,
0.5341901779,
-0.0210953057,
-0.4707874358,
0.4421671331,
-0.7088071108,
0.1444375068,
-0.2960101664,
0.1906200349,
-0.9349310994,
0.0485613905,
-0.0312757157,
-0.0924723744,
0.294939965,
-0.269595176,
-0.4634604454,
-0.3571286798,
-0.0257401485,
0.4655559063,
0.7349588871,
-0.6029496193,
0.8059194088,
0.3511742651,
-0.3568781614,
-0.5249962807,
-0.919442296,
-0.2575163245,
-0.6373786926,
-0.6595845819,
0.4068175852,
-0.0187293682,
-0.778524518,
0.0063404771,
-0.355676949,
-0.2249533981,
0.2784626782,
0.3184087574,
0.1036701053,
-0.0139325466,
0.0030555688,
0.1364016086,
-0.2495217472,
0.106895797,
-0.2889407277,
0.2899907827,
0.2839148343,
-0.5032439232,
-0.0009391958,
0.8124485016,
0.6329063177,
-0.3923611045,
0.6755401492,
-0.0286350399,
-0.2163865268,
-0.6514250636,
-0.6133370996,
-0.0294628628,
-0.4050322771,
0.3387211561,
-0.6382979751,
-0.8966513872,
0.4989182353,
-0.3508823812,
0.1781697124,
0.3821023107,
0.7076636553,
-0.0659023374,
0.9201570153,
0.6805266738,
-0.1340604573,
0.0311913788,
-0.3838475645,
0.5491984487,
-0.5820662379,
-0.4657641351,
-0.6394438744,
-0.4466488957,
-0.2181484699,
-1.0052320957,
0.3054608703,
0.4723096788,
-0.1349414587,
0.1558918059,
-0.5312256217,
0.6750730872,
0.7710038424,
0.0791260749,
0.66988796,
0.0724031031,
0.1466419399,
0.0661753491,
-0.8419427276,
-0.4517774284,
1.0046759844,
0.3934106529,
0.6742243767,
0.1635801643,
1.2031869888,
0.1101629063,
0.0763042718,
-0.9408218861,
0.5560203791,
-0.3933004141,
-0.6310489774,
-0.4508807063,
-0.6636210084,
-0.8269264698,
0.6044733524,
0.1642273068,
-0.5679826736,
0.2409032881,
-0.0070356531,
-0.3292921185,
0.4026980102,
-0.8823120594,
0.6772497296,
-0.1393722743,
0.0562444665,
-0.3803820014,
-0.3331911564,
0.5206276178,
0.0301139876,
0.4916527271,
-0.1272863299,
0.0213651545,
0.7113601565,
-0.7117435932,
0.6909273863,
-0.2794775665,
-0.2444019914,
0.6374295354,
0.2403562963,
0.3831152022,
-0.2745183408,
0.0026083058,
-0.2742423713,
0.1551520824,
-0.5427371264,
-0.9255616069,
0.574338913,
-0.6734908819,
-1.0425065756,
-0.2524716556,
-0.4651530385,
0.0060877707,
-0.2172092944,
0.2378167957,
0.253054291,
-0.1521038711,
-0.0671130121,
0.9292972684,
0.0877046883,
0.3804152608,
0.2476988733,
-0.2908787727,
-0.3811380267,
0.7741793394,
0.226720944,
0.585295558,
0.2564677298,
0.2549110651,
-0.3605303764,
-0.8555349112,
-0.0464501083,
0.2395754308,
-1.0736792088,
-0.0373388082,
-0.3113284409,
-0.0424925908,
-0.1588342041,
0.0247317422,
-0.4700407088,
-0.3713367581,
-0.2934838831,
-0.1584176868,
0.0986991525,
0.6957296729,
-0.2652843893,
0.0162898395,
-0.4640733898,
0.4060013592,
0.6071254611,
-0.4065090418,
0.0209050681,
-0.6330641508,
-0.1820874959,
0.0219017044,
-0.0494033396,
-0.7276394367,
0.2825100124,
-0.0465593748,
0.6305632591,
0.1449018419,
0.3352795243,
0.6875211,
-0.4822558761,
0.6840637326,
0.2744608521,
-0.8550177813,
0.3373943865,
0.1142208129,
0.2492937893,
0.6404930353,
0.7356869578,
-0.1948955208,
-0.3246548474,
-0.5050068498,
-0.8676379919,
0.4523558617,
0.1570333093,
-0.1431591064,
0.0835204646,
0.3418975472,
0.020712873,
-0.001985115,
-0.4733462036,
-0.3140871823,
0.3359645605,
0.1204728037,
-0.1530387253,
-0.4403860271,
-0.4100761712,
-0.4731563628,
0.6430159807,
0.0499813929,
-0.0484112464,
0.1921669394,
-0.1679338962,
0.3271486163,
0.4220776558,
0.2243557125,
0.5916236639,
0.0650676861,
0.4294298589,
0.117902495,
-0.1085285619,
0.4280869663,
-0.0185793228,
0.1204935312,
-0.1841499656,
0.6334221363,
0.5077952743,
-0.2163078189,
-0.5270935297,
0.288982898,
0.0375136957,
-0.608322382,
0.1620460451,
0.0570766851,
0.5574234724,
0.7497397661,
0.5050132871,
-0.2663998306,
0.1828045398,
-0.6680417061,
-0.0908952206,
0.138989374,
0.1647816598,
0.0234668534,
0.2072857916,
0.2901742458,
-0.1206024513,
0.5876741409,
-0.4105865657,
-0.8994595408,
0.7713709474,
0.3333739042,
0.7978284955,
-0.203722626,
0.360727489,
0.2040757239,
0.3165106475,
-0.4049329162,
-0.0314895399,
-0.1633347124,
-0.7295528054,
-1.050495863,
-0.664988935,
-0.3343155384,
0.1146340892,
-0.6359349489,
-0.2592228353,
-0.3269916773,
-0.0815295875,
0.1888642162,
0.1791496724,
-0.3364434838,
0.2490649968,
0.3972216249,
0.6727170348,
-0.8594633937,
0.7086963058,
0.6061486006,
-0.3204744458,
-1.039835453,
-0.2996667027,
0.0679392666,
-0.4725433588,
1.0258313417,
-0.2210328728,
-0.1214525625,
-0.3854442239,
-0.3837899864,
-0.750897646,
1.0051865578,
0.465149045,
-0.6902318597,
-0.0341404304,
0.1655688137,
0.3908571005,
-0.4130677283,
-0.1069929078,
1.0762828588,
0.4029685855,
0.6330912709,
-1.1844234467,
-0.0018468902,
0.2108524293,
0.0342155173,
0.232033968,
-0.2325487137,
1.177477479,
-0.3606320322,
-0.4485672116,
-0.1324993819,
0.6544793844,
0.1800707132,
0.3756372631,
0.7319535017,
0.6595368385,
0.8403576016,
-0.2438582629,
0.864572823,
0.3047219515,
0.3545909226,
1.3324667215,
-0.4155377746,
0.7686706185,
0.7341763377,
-0.4568276405,
0.4412060678,
0.5044136047,
0.3538391292,
0.5891234875,
0.6082444191,
-0.3871518373,
-0.7446494102,
-0.0064194868,
-0.0859945267,
0.5337988734,
0.1599823236,
-0.2193660885,
-0.5356574655,
0.2627519965,
0.2050108165,
0.3839815259,
-0.3222053051,
0.9428365231,
0.2456130087,
-0.9171791077,
0.6370969415,
0.0524091162,
0.2844564021,
-0.4021009505,
0.1226756647,
-0.5735475421,
0.3503022194,
-0.1668574959,
-0.5393442512,
0.4967330396,
0.0857638791,
-0.5292818546,
-0.4476841986,
0.7349689603,
-0.5376868844,
-0.4874154329,
0.4276179969,
0.7855796814,
0.1027047709,
-0.4874067903,
-0.3915460706,
0.0499859788,
0.2550626993,
-0.2968760729,
0.4698950946,
0.7875525355,
-0.0295260306,
0.9797759652,
0.4336485565,
0.0442234613,
0.1236757115,
0.0392877012,
1.1942242384,
-0.3626232147,
-0.0255390145,
-1.0170885324,
0.6382058859,
-0.2136369199,
0.2483405322,
0.6461168528,
0.6234112978,
0.7000265121,
0.1081036404,
0.8143526912,
-0.047535032,
0.5594114661,
-0.5321090221,
0.2144538164,
-0.7241398096,
0.3502061069,
0.1268144399,
-0.739626646,
-0.0766207352,
0.3912573755,
-0.5603234172,
-0.1957198679,
0.8550118208,
0.5285503268,
0.147183001,
-0.131869331,
0.4331775904,
0.045098871,
0.2976150513,
0.9372347593,
1.1309568882,
0.0551524796,
0.4503400028,
-0.4893055856,
-0.4057529271,
0.0314318575,
-0.8644727468,
-0.861623168,
-0.5529172421,
-0.6616889834,
-0.2148575336,
-0.2141991407,
0.631762743,
0.6117765903,
-0.5155912042,
-0.2924197912,
0.0930250511,
0.4782104492,
-0.3375612199,
-0.1597478241,
0.1566429138,
-0.4931771457,
-0.9608619809,
0.5630851984,
0.2447277755,
-0.1831795126,
-0.3391818404,
0.1238338947,
-0.0947907045,
0.2836299539,
0.7947216034,
0.107718572,
-0.8887811303,
-0.0898469761,
-0.0369411632,
0.0157433581,
-0.1281472594,
1.0987098217,
-0.4626000226,
0.4336023033,
0.5422998071,
0.6083190441,
0.8295128345,
0.1964883655,
0.5487738252,
-0.4983037114,
0.1289299577,
0.3259533048,
0.465269506,
0.1871648431,
-0.0428921282,
0.4674343765,
0.0609070063,
-0.6621210575,
-0.603266418,
0.4303740561,
-0.9711722136,
-0.8442082405,
1.2973155975,
-0.4056637585,
-0.3712413609,
-0.0664595291,
-0.2800735831,
0.1279876232,
-0.1477804333,
0.4379517734,
0.779720962,
-0.3181496263,
0.0524724796,
-0.3906076252,
0.459852457,
0.4494405091,
-0.7206710577,
0.2137608528,
0.6604568958,
0.3987120986,
0.4271719158,
0.5295701027,
0.1113157421,
-0.2268095315,
0.1554625481,
-0.1197506264,
-0.185889408,
-0.4970763624,
-0.2253493667,
0.4290654361,
0.3299392164,
-0.3584580123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14992v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14992v2
|
tinyBenchmarks: evaluating LLMs with fewer examples
| 2024-02-22T22:05:23 | 2024-05-26T22:27:23 |
Felipe Maia Polo, Lucas Weber, Leshem Choshen, Yuekai Sun, Gongjun Xu, Mikhail Yurochkin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
The versatility of large language models (LLMs) led to the creation of
diverse benchmarks that thoroughly test a variety of language models'
abilities. These benchmarks consist of tens of thousands of examples making
evaluation of LLMs very expensive. In this paper, we investigate strategies to
reduce the number of evaluations needed to assess the performance of an LLM on
several key benchmarks. For example, we show that to accurately estimate the
performance of an LLM on MMLU, a popular multiple-choice QA benchmark
consisting of 14K examples, it is sufficient to evaluate this LLM on 100
curated examples. We release evaluation tools and tiny versions of popular
benchmarks: Open LLM Leaderboard, MMLU, HELM, and AlpacaEval 2.0. Our empirical
analysis demonstrates that these tools and tiny benchmarks are sufficient to
reliably and efficiently reproduce the original evaluation results.
|
[
-0.65607059,
-0.6620263457,
0.6410886049,
0.1710692644,
-0.2930108011,
0.0447359532,
-0.3701089621,
-0.3236886859,
-0.1211124137,
0.2637664974,
-0.5378059745,
-0.4054114819,
-0.2800774574,
0.1392094493,
-0.2219066918,
0.7486807108,
0.1445338279,
0.0524482429,
-0.3695740998,
-0.5799996257,
-0.2196349353,
-0.2496679425,
-0.714600563,
-0.2700513899,
0.5971165299,
0.8162322044,
0.6537848711,
0.6422031522,
0.6195416451,
0.2557111084,
-0.3039291799,
0.0502835698,
-0.6073320508,
-0.3000442982,
0.1325276047,
-0.6587144136,
-0.3577873111,
0.2223544419,
0.8579704165,
0.7639501095,
-0.0056797029,
0.8574714661,
0.096075207,
0.606874764,
-0.6809903383,
0.0425296836,
-0.5112962723,
-0.1074749753,
-0.3453627825,
0.205680415,
-0.4275847673,
-0.6128582954,
-0.1766288131,
-0.2757794857,
-0.0326271541,
0.1837245822,
0.3882378936,
0.2187681943,
-0.2279445529,
-0.1578340381,
-0.5106967688,
1.0277420282,
-0.8631869555,
0.3623336256,
0.1766558141,
0.6117137671,
-0.100306347,
-0.6984041929,
-0.3822911978,
-0.4299687445,
0.0897049233,
-0.2010945231,
-0.3729629815,
-0.2359783649,
0.340377152,
0.3636411726,
-0.3743593991,
0.4947247207,
-0.1982309371,
-0.1298844218,
0.556524992,
0.5392414927,
-0.0628909841,
-0.1389475465,
0.0679727718,
-0.3726567328,
-1.0741639137,
0.0068804608,
0.395119071,
0.15756464,
0.045991756,
0.5309208632,
-0.1399688125,
0.5340843797,
-0.1739022136,
-0.4987030029,
0.1718461066,
-0.5099495649,
-0.3044807613,
-0.4432186484,
0.7291574478,
0.3893533051,
-0.1156328022,
-0.1757761836,
-0.2199507356,
0.1426561177,
0.1149987951,
-0.9257016778,
-0.175413534,
0.145290792,
-0.6248357296,
-0.3240326047,
-0.4021642506,
-0.7980761528,
-0.3812642395,
0.0258597229,
0.3534889519,
-0.2186419964,
0.1994851083,
-0.2842120826,
-0.0633451641,
0.2429831475,
0.4324724972,
-0.5052253008,
0.6073439121,
0.809623301,
0.8188320994,
-0.3250383735,
-0.2841228247,
-0.7421257496,
-0.3289977908,
-0.4910256267,
0.8393266797,
-0.5501970053,
-0.6010044813,
-0.2168685198,
-0.1742318571,
0.1752463281,
-0.984804213,
0.5414586067,
-0.4415568113,
0.0413878523,
-0.3565913737,
-0.5926067829,
-0.004870872,
0.1373940259,
-0.8951563239,
1.050588727,
0.2343618125,
-0.3578549027,
0.2948219478,
-0.5734138489,
-0.2090209574,
-0.0199669711,
-0.2549380064,
-0.3670053482,
0.4717127383,
0.1741822511,
0.1846035719,
-0.6021044254,
-0.2839845717,
-0.5070930123,
-0.6547038555,
0.1501423866,
-0.430621624,
0.6176858544,
0.2897678912,
-0.2667183578,
0.1727917939,
-0.8223832846,
0.1752120256,
0.1098557487,
-0.5753174424,
-0.2921227813,
-0.0939261243,
0.1708638519,
0.093843326,
0.1254263669,
-0.2787069976,
0.0816212893,
-0.542881608,
0.1655249745,
0.8698503375,
-0.0620165281,
0.4098671973,
-0.5757868886,
0.7585591674,
-0.1927729249,
0.3028116226,
0.3217613697,
-0.5221591592,
-1.0664532185,
-0.3314537704,
0.5294770002,
0.0521542281,
-0.5588592291,
0.1093504503,
-0.279083997,
-0.8961726427,
-1.0188890696,
0.6954314113,
0.497464627,
0.0791445002,
0.1248763427,
-0.1705493629,
-0.354167521,
-1.1057054996,
-0.4606140256,
-0.2428074926,
-0.2208119333,
0.4501845241,
0.5242811441,
-0.0904547051,
0.835311234,
-0.3024320304,
-0.1001595706,
-0.2490924597,
0.0841859058,
0.2563951612,
0.3125232458,
0.8444969058,
-0.380287379,
-0.3736144304,
-0.2038084567,
-0.1666363776,
-0.1726777852,
0.1599161774,
0.3044505715,
0.0365187787,
0.4914075732,
-0.4474746287,
0.0610286333,
0.5927014947,
-0.0222010203,
0.6023581028,
-0.0250322539,
-0.0217215791,
-0.5950874686,
0.0041546477,
-0.2645519972,
-0.2948270142,
-0.2153722346,
0.5279291272,
0.1766319871,
-0.0258638915,
-0.6716306806,
0.9643575549,
-0.4864989519,
-0.2517446876,
-0.0766058341,
0.3993191421,
-0.0081827631,
0.2812218964,
-0.5841965675,
0.9649927616,
0.1352907866,
-0.5078020692,
0.1920747012,
0.0298966244,
-0.7012732625,
0.3170028627,
-0.553999126,
0.2164296657,
0.1838320345,
-0.1659376025,
-0.986212492,
0.2232913226,
0.0574362427,
0.1714459509,
-0.0278476402,
-0.1606712043,
-0.846873045,
-0.5703014135,
-0.8772271276,
0.1972577572,
0.7936794162,
-0.7303205729,
0.2813949883,
0.2119478881,
-0.3272857666,
-0.3009009361,
-0.5927553773,
-0.0464101844,
-0.4674468338,
-0.271078825,
0.0200082213,
-0.5426638722,
-0.4213902056,
-0.0174677968,
-0.3221596479,
0.1361214519,
0.5060106516,
0.2416998297,
0.0470607504,
-0.4439797401,
0.293623358,
-0.1231709346,
-0.0998381302,
-0.1600474417,
0.2739795446,
0.4565932155,
-0.6711695194,
-0.720821023,
0.0206055846,
0.0446934253,
0.5231785774,
0.0387117118,
0.4747236967,
0.5022219419,
-0.2570078671,
-0.3977319598,
-0.8275195956,
-0.1706332117,
-0.5054844022,
0.2622362673,
-0.4114727378,
-1.0469782352,
0.478284657,
-0.303655237,
0.1027127206,
0.4266867638,
0.7173886299,
0.0356357284,
0.8006778955,
0.4578483105,
-0.2549369335,
0.2745710313,
-0.0642977431,
-0.03609927,
-0.7754876018,
0.2303381562,
-0.6272731423,
-0.3852841854,
-0.5440042019,
-0.8517407775,
0.3283673525,
0.2405715138,
0.0525919311,
0.2786431611,
-0.1317720115,
0.7755243778,
0.5146586299,
-0.0722979009,
0.5535666943,
-0.1752480567,
-0.3552099764,
-0.1191411316,
-0.892764926,
-0.9895308018,
1.3824942112,
0.3446823061,
0.7673957348,
0.491932869,
0.7633348703,
0.2908210456,
0.7042106986,
-0.9358900189,
0.7463979721,
-0.2153027058,
-0.4213144481,
-0.2923719883,
-0.4426755607,
-0.7297440171,
0.4393826127,
-0.070265688,
-0.7977543473,
0.1615228206,
-0.0242563486,
-0.5945512056,
0.0598595627,
-0.7785089016,
0.917270422,
-0.1228232235,
-0.2553106844,
-0.4357094765,
-0.023912115,
0.43601951,
-0.5002149343,
0.3057818413,
-0.1959687471,
-0.3100624084,
0.8628187776,
-0.5612412691,
0.7122827768,
0.1730304807,
-0.0105807679,
0.2754822671,
0.1919941455,
0.4856691062,
0.1628716141,
-0.3521632254,
-0.0637864694,
0.2614441514,
-0.3695383072,
-0.5123221874,
0.9890268445,
-0.6477704644,
-0.6755690575,
-0.0728861019,
-0.2208222598,
-0.466044426,
0.1784821004,
0.0266159307,
0.2477953434,
-0.5654643178,
0.2492064387,
0.2126889527,
-0.1197666004,
0.6095224619,
0.6607612967,
-0.3591013253,
-0.2229112536,
0.7371909022,
0.3071890771,
0.0970785841,
-0.047811754,
0.3487673998,
-0.2433211058,
-0.8815232515,
-0.3786116242,
0.282571733,
-0.8711654544,
-0.0879852846,
-0.3916402161,
0.2877257168,
-0.0836752951,
0.0673932657,
-0.6154254079,
-0.5401672721,
-0.234650135,
-0.0451735258,
0.21184735,
0.6741560102,
-0.0036425113,
0.5189906359,
-0.6826817989,
0.3357157409,
0.6552193165,
0.5809283257,
0.2391268611,
-0.4214835465,
-0.2103746086,
-0.2205277532,
-0.2370789498,
-0.4870989025,
-0.0045633968,
0.1481849402,
0.7928851247,
0.5187914968,
0.0580723211,
0.817270577,
-0.6667237878,
0.7101609707,
0.0909603238,
-0.9780595303,
0.3999021947,
0.0927477106,
0.3173046708,
0.881788373,
0.1111630574,
-0.2270715386,
-0.4457557797,
-0.688993454,
-0.4608211517,
0.557453692,
0.1513562202,
-0.0617204532,
-0.1148914993,
0.0722191557,
0.0599993207,
0.3254569471,
-0.5062786937,
-0.2717218697,
0.4315149188,
-0.0540223531,
-0.4133893847,
-0.5331161022,
-0.4339101911,
-0.0992621034,
0.5136588216,
-0.2874320447,
-0.0424790457,
-0.3638745844,
-0.3513109684,
0.1029507592,
0.601347208,
0.4868661761,
0.7076511383,
-0.297940135,
0.1212019101,
0.5368362069,
-0.0763397068,
0.3198625743,
-0.0015255036,
-0.0841337964,
0.1803996116,
0.3527150154,
0.403763473,
0.3783398271,
-0.9830657244,
0.5453782082,
-0.0910689533,
0.1934853643,
-0.0407504179,
0.086317569,
0.4802407324,
0.4578065574,
0.1239551753,
-0.2239086181,
0.2170503438,
-0.5245141983,
0.1553015113,
0.4132594168,
-0.2600756884,
-0.0272828452,
0.296720624,
0.1015960574,
-0.296615392,
0.3059609532,
-0.325378567,
0.0227922928,
0.6652772427,
0.1041133031,
0.6724226475,
-0.0290080626,
0.0899565071,
-0.048969388,
0.6574088931,
-0.2438731492,
0.00131727,
-0.0566962399,
-0.4198105335,
-0.2239098698,
-0.6158432364,
-0.7006328702,
0.182547316,
-0.536141336,
0.2568349838,
-0.7544398904,
-0.3475607336,
0.2591681182,
0.3141437769,
-0.9689303637,
-0.1236216649,
0.1033466607,
1.1565346718,
-0.6809757948,
0.7502571344,
0.6045134664,
-0.4275866449,
-0.635386467,
-0.3535526395,
0.1814397573,
-0.8604158759,
0.5517909527,
0.0016892537,
-0.0867048055,
-0.2585427165,
-0.2283163369,
-0.5859841108,
0.976834476,
0.4798206091,
-0.8270143867,
0.2135194838,
0.0403843969,
0.6184365749,
-0.2968316674,
0.3598535061,
0.9881309271,
0.554343462,
-0.3833495677,
-0.9695702195,
0.1058317423,
-0.2128815651,
0.2100895643,
-0.0417502671,
-0.9216415286,
0.8699117899,
-0.3403233588,
-0.332470417,
0.4322959185,
0.0806201622,
0.4939166009,
0.2015938163,
0.4167672098,
0.4743022323,
0.7359749675,
-0.0175645724,
1.0950183868,
-0.1414534599,
0.4559766352,
1.4543277025,
-0.3398754001,
1.1684504747,
0.6574826241,
-0.447584331,
0.2387737334,
0.659016788,
-0.2959979475,
0.3896256685,
0.4041432738,
-0.1707656085,
-0.3366332948,
0.000982965,
-0.3590966165,
0.42544505,
0.050283011,
-0.2457536757,
-0.4307818413,
-0.0895421505,
0.042447798,
-0.0249493681,
-0.2289009094,
0.7778537869,
0.1756619513,
-0.2283070087,
0.555998385,
0.2627971172,
0.5878535509,
-0.5202761889,
0.0937457904,
-0.5548439026,
0.0999340415,
-0.0173279792,
-0.3679067492,
0.0907367021,
0.0796844363,
0.0134731345,
-0.0237173978,
0.6627904773,
-0.0043322947,
-0.6958018541,
0.3782745004,
0.989802599,
0.2897072732,
-0.0066821598,
-0.5732992887,
0.2431544363,
-0.261023432,
-0.451690793,
0.5897256136,
0.2735652328,
0.0106051955,
0.8775151372,
0.6278515458,
0.2541406453,
-0.0481755659,
0.2423740625,
0.8896348476,
-0.6507306099,
-0.3348833919,
-0.9569336176,
-0.0144784171,
-0.0080129895,
-0.1889815629,
1.026679635,
0.7144179344,
0.8312129378,
-0.2679387331,
0.5915108919,
0.3896325529,
0.4941603541,
-0.4347809255,
0.7844786644,
-0.7122223973,
0.6675858498,
-0.3415596485,
-1.0022910833,
-0.0744344443,
0.3415704966,
-0.2667823136,
0.1374160051,
0.5871562958,
0.7832649946,
-0.0082121175,
-0.1064298749,
0.6801536083,
0.1840406805,
0.2468201816,
0.5427811742,
0.9593710899,
-0.5171966553,
0.7651795745,
-0.3736449778,
0.0389446802,
-0.5483994484,
-1.0174748898,
-0.8835459948,
0.0451838039,
-0.3849943578,
-0.0448458046,
-0.1425691992,
0.8390341997,
0.6570141315,
-0.892685771,
-0.4585671425,
0.5210411549,
0.5504662991,
-0.3816357255,
-0.2167048901,
0.3222496212,
-0.2122408301,
-0.6994398832,
0.6140397191,
0.3088658452,
0.0409073457,
-0.3371624947,
-0.0825233459,
0.1665657312,
0.1894925833,
0.7645093203,
0.1612099409,
-0.8709349632,
-0.5783113241,
-0.2083726078,
-0.2031755149,
0.0201045107,
0.6628573537,
-0.8252984285,
0.2707559168,
0.1679264903,
0.8060002327,
0.4145177901,
-0.1785139591,
0.2151315212,
-0.7138967514,
0.1350794286,
0.1773109585,
0.3945590556,
0.1911009103,
0.2761195898,
0.7467815876,
-0.0307114683,
-0.1532653272,
-1.023399353,
0.0174434744,
-0.9558667541,
-0.3170342147,
1.1102113724,
-0.1600203365,
-0.125699237,
0.0667631626,
0.024881443,
-0.2771635056,
-0.1694479585,
0.5393476486,
0.8931825161,
-0.0615181252,
-0.3491640389,
-0.6449944973,
0.5191456079,
0.4912057817,
-0.8212297559,
0.0400939137,
0.5222749114,
0.5637895465,
0.2098643035,
0.6830467582,
-0.1351046413,
0.3940177858,
0.3651602864,
-0.1609110981,
0.0196128674,
-0.1183630601,
-0.5882967114,
0.3598367572,
0.73533988,
-0.0648134649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14979v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14979v2
|
Optimizing Language Models for Human Preferences is a Causal Inference Problem
| 2024-02-22T21:36:07 | 2024-06-05T23:19:19 |
Victoria Lin, Eli Ben-Michael, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ME
|
As large language models (LLMs) see greater use in academic and commercial
settings, there is increasing interest in methods that allow language models to
generate texts aligned with human preferences. In this paper, we present an
initial exploration of language model optimization for human preferences from
direct outcome datasets, where each sample consists of a text and an associated
numerical outcome measuring the reader's response. We first propose that
language model optimization should be viewed as a causal problem to ensure that
the model correctly learns the relationship between the text and the outcome.
We formalize this causal language optimization problem, and we develop a
method--causal preference optimization (CPO)--that solves an unbiased surrogate
objective for the problem. We further extend CPO with doubly robust CPO
(DR-CPO), which reduces the variance of the surrogate objective while retaining
provably strong guarantees on bias. Finally, we empirically demonstrate the
effectiveness of (DR-)CPO in optimizing state-of-the-art LLMs for human
preferences on direct outcome data, and we validate the robustness of DR-CPO
under difficult confounding conditions.
|
[
-0.2354443669,
-0.6196962595,
0.7828469276,
0.2308367938,
-0.1876476407,
-0.2578455806,
-0.5839983225,
-0.1835758388,
-0.1976131648,
0.7602795959,
-0.4962307215,
-0.3975538015,
-0.4005528092,
0.3187869787,
0.0890290961,
0.8906537294,
0.002541434,
0.1383437514,
-0.2785712481,
0.0812813118,
-0.4770774841,
-0.6358842254,
-0.8911842108,
-0.4759132862,
0.6962493658,
0.4666840434,
0.7542054653,
0.8321256042,
0.2846593261,
0.2466763258,
-0.0185640827,
0.2207439393,
-0.7094424963,
0.1661099344,
-0.2082706839,
-0.4198438525,
-0.0451756418,
0.059768144,
0.482839644,
0.7428380251,
-0.1030966192,
-0.1186000332,
-0.0539606772,
0.7951962948,
-0.7447841167,
0.0330125615,
-0.5207031965,
-0.1483666003,
-0.0123842573,
-0.329290688,
-0.7317506075,
-0.698353529,
0.404859364,
-0.6449437141,
0.0152050126,
0.3496842682,
0.8004321456,
0.2837134004,
-0.634927392,
-0.1050266847,
-0.7458543777,
1.1820335388,
-0.6252501011,
0.3924438357,
0.6186254621,
0.0509659499,
-0.4333232343,
-0.0312670879,
-0.4398180544,
-0.4684560597,
0.005953039,
0.0181249287,
-0.1506891251,
0.2992417216,
-0.1256377548,
-0.0706078187,
-0.6078472137,
0.4695602059,
0.086590454,
-0.0819630176,
0.6880279183,
0.1717755795,
0.420725137,
-0.1954194158,
-0.240260452,
-0.1989361197,
-0.641908288,
0.1788309664,
0.6170552373,
0.4029574394,
0.0694283694,
0.47208184,
-0.0971640795,
0.8217071295,
-0.0275263637,
-0.1880596578,
-0.1694825441,
-0.1319569051,
-0.0745542794,
-0.0228072349,
0.733818233,
0.3442998528,
0.5331724882,
-0.2946974039,
-0.0562780872,
0.2314644903,
0.300673604,
-0.5558903217,
0.0429722406,
0.2525919676,
-0.3558371663,
-0.6443098783,
-0.4124781787,
-0.7028345466,
-0.1614669412,
-0.7447392941,
0.0668609738,
0.0031902334,
-0.0923112184,
0.4959715009,
0.1025686413,
-0.0826002061,
0.1096466929,
-1.3297901154,
0.2955386639,
0.6277492642,
0.3275131583,
-0.2430002689,
-0.2041582763,
-0.4610738754,
0.217698127,
-0.4968714416,
0.6660509706,
-0.5801903009,
-0.4801859558,
0.0767576396,
-0.3714748025,
0.0076447558,
-0.2459181994,
1.1460002661,
-0.6794841886,
0.289000839,
-0.4126440585,
-0.5022987127,
0.0292941257,
-0.0410146043,
-0.4830486774,
0.8370873928,
-0.1957536042,
-0.937518537,
0.5473659039,
-0.2267782986,
-0.4352476895,
-0.4620461762,
-0.2494058013,
-0.5005382299,
0.3492827415,
0.114974305,
0.3147096634,
-0.8911049366,
1.0198799372,
-0.4094358683,
-0.1598933041,
0.164652735,
-0.3772766292,
0.6670509577,
0.1090907305,
-0.2515872121,
0.2089000046,
-0.6131828427,
-0.5455368757,
0.3265765011,
-0.6294045448,
-0.8538282514,
0.6337343454,
-0.069396317,
-0.0342579708,
0.2648159862,
-0.509680748,
0.0748576522,
-0.4831484556,
0.1577691734,
1.089797616,
-0.1236888543,
0.5505030155,
-0.1489595473,
0.2278109491,
-0.2737154961,
0.4367758036,
0.458835721,
-0.1347328424,
-0.6637824178,
-0.1821891069,
-0.0904019848,
0.387920171,
-0.4216396809,
0.6261742115,
-0.1337859482,
0.0132667953,
-0.1537143439,
0.0702872574,
0.553001225,
0.9000365734,
0.0991145894,
0.128500402,
-0.404487431,
-1.3264380693,
-0.4612993598,
-0.4845769405,
0.1321045011,
0.5348601937,
-0.0417653434,
-0.2466852069,
1.0427983999,
-0.9432115555,
0.2251086533,
-0.2398083806,
-0.0626194477,
0.4002619386,
0.2989259362,
0.8072886467,
-1.0311654806,
-0.3447732329,
0.0816550925,
-0.5058720112,
-0.3993505239,
-0.1138018221,
-0.4042605758,
0.3068204522,
-0.0365640186,
-0.1458166093,
0.0207755715,
0.483836323,
-0.1313243508,
0.7078181505,
-0.3213126957,
0.2243928909,
-0.8056551814,
0.1528239548,
0.3337925673,
-0.0444740355,
-0.7039483786,
-0.1898602247,
-0.0698536932,
-0.1082728207,
-0.1578346938,
0.7859866023,
-0.2194863856,
0.3621062338,
-0.3638262749,
0.2218104899,
-0.0349942446,
0.6703728437,
0.5407856703,
0.3910054564,
0.5281305313,
-0.5870634317,
-0.0902563781,
0.37665236,
-0.0475257933,
0.2444673181,
-0.6006932259,
0.1649094522,
-0.5121980906,
-0.121661678,
-0.9754434824,
-0.2623645365,
-0.073951751,
-0.2230003327,
0.385242641,
0.06503883,
-0.3974768817,
-0.3210963607,
-0.3553888798,
0.4655713737,
0.2958790064,
-0.6686396599,
0.2401441634,
0.6032028794,
-0.0462455377,
-0.6756212711,
-0.1915801466,
-0.0401016846,
-0.3902865946,
-0.4532414675,
0.0184392855,
-0.1720081717,
-0.3390579522,
-0.3137121797,
-0.0429151617,
0.0130488612,
0.0515804403,
-0.1362094879,
0.5410968065,
0.134860158,
0.067946963,
0.4035606384,
-0.5365293026,
-0.0170242749,
-0.2973085344,
0.3535923064,
0.2010051757,
-0.0766077116,
-0.2765355706,
0.4311625957,
0.1043200344,
0.1245303899,
0.4893052578,
0.0103293248,
-0.2358724177,
-0.2347123623,
-0.7395408154,
-0.3376027346,
-0.4694154263,
0.3722693622,
-0.2503625154,
-0.9067994356,
0.0381461009,
-0.0674606338,
0.0048237592,
0.1775892079,
0.5127758384,
0.2675816119,
1.1228461266,
0.4770328403,
-0.5762904286,
0.3693632483,
0.3671363294,
0.1477302313,
-0.5732648373,
-0.0535669997,
-0.9079293013,
0.0631202832,
-0.6504979134,
-0.0800591409,
0.4217876196,
0.2256589234,
-0.5444033146,
0.3853381872,
-0.4714241922,
0.4348558784,
0.7842568159,
0.2906171083,
0.3111105263,
0.0530630313,
-0.3325176239,
-0.4070192873,
-0.6158708334,
-0.6576813459,
1.0557091236,
0.1557961553,
0.9161586165,
0.0783226192,
0.5895990133,
0.109065257,
0.242089659,
-0.4534159303,
0.4210446477,
-0.357070148,
-0.6924856901,
-0.3369938135,
-0.6567354202,
-0.9011211991,
0.2816044688,
-0.2474218607,
-0.9961494803,
0.4529358149,
0.3794701397,
0.1171902493,
-0.0388740189,
-0.663975358,
0.9569627643,
-0.4433498681,
-0.6749753952,
-0.302323401,
-0.7925959229,
0.4381411672,
-0.2699892521,
0.2078093588,
-0.1417038143,
-0.0270489827,
0.5092152357,
-0.1571358144,
0.945110321,
0.1319530755,
0.0419261046,
0.0243033953,
0.1646340787,
0.5847668648,
0.1476529241,
-0.5147006512,
0.0539043993,
-0.2333584875,
-0.3313905001,
-0.4071730971,
0.7575488091,
-1.0057663918,
-0.8638755083,
-0.2673868537,
-0.2904996872,
-0.4134902954,
0.3532041907,
-0.0571376756,
0.4544831514,
-0.4318614602,
-0.2038790584,
0.4927169383,
-0.6708583832,
0.3826216459,
0.665288806,
-0.01466865,
-0.4730709195,
0.6876191497,
-0.517688334,
0.4116876721,
0.9280151725,
0.9374377728,
-0.4776337445,
-0.5191118717,
-0.3111763597,
0.4996965528,
-0.5477149487,
-0.0012915824,
-0.4723694324,
0.3625789881,
-0.2098719776,
-0.5244983435,
-0.2212918401,
0.0141906068,
-0.5043289661,
-0.0277895778,
0.1540509015,
0.3790839314,
-0.1239590794,
0.0911594331,
-0.4667541981,
0.2854735851,
0.2120785415,
0.0960465074,
-0.0301933326,
-0.3479164839,
-0.0600664057,
-0.0788974091,
-0.2097675502,
-0.7618217468,
0.591563642,
-0.0792962834,
0.6098147631,
0.6685333252,
0.2906051278,
0.3253086507,
-0.6483773589,
0.3208096027,
0.2697473168,
-0.8665512204,
0.7782461047,
-0.7337350845,
-0.0819978565,
0.6943179369,
0.603774786,
-0.3755715489,
-0.238593787,
-0.2211203873,
-0.6697087884,
0.7714603543,
0.2365438044,
0.2380564511,
-0.4543423951,
0.6923350096,
0.1419744939,
0.2492519617,
-0.6896902323,
-0.3028216958,
0.3446357548,
-0.1180674732,
-0.2445905805,
-0.4085753262,
-0.187044099,
-0.0189565346,
0.8083788157,
-0.1558419168,
-0.1615002751,
0.1527542323,
0.1338303387,
-0.244723022,
0.1554505825,
0.6890265346,
0.6479695439,
-0.4382503033,
0.1040345281,
-0.1473419219,
-0.3411873281,
0.2631472349,
0.0316350795,
-0.4029259682,
-0.3391664326,
0.1933344603,
0.8255342841,
0.4963843822,
-0.7545306683,
0.4477888346,
-0.0921716988,
0.2221013308,
0.0775030851,
-0.0476007648,
-0.0792901516,
-0.0538967438,
0.2741360962,
-0.1106902063,
0.2571557164,
-0.2272666693,
-0.0046091387,
0.4463110268,
-0.2395120114,
-0.3272802532,
1.0090816021,
0.3171033561,
-0.3829344511,
0.280941844,
0.1865985096,
-0.4278310835,
0.4365526438,
0.7901974916,
0.9653802514,
-0.1943127662,
0.2447067201,
0.4325149059,
0.2331299931,
-0.2906626165,
-0.0039578043,
0.0492262617,
-1.1044397354,
-0.3434417844,
-0.7526868582,
-0.4691411257,
-0.312414825,
-0.5722931623,
0.5432920456,
-0.1721617877,
-0.2108423561,
-0.0542352907,
0.0731122717,
-0.5738266706,
0.3609216213,
-0.2547144294,
0.486346364,
-0.8133115768,
0.7553470135,
0.3816474676,
-0.3203878999,
-0.7807340622,
-0.2890486121,
0.0732139423,
-0.9943494797,
0.8336712718,
-0.2917920053,
-0.1590282023,
0.030765662,
-0.2836280465,
-0.673384428,
0.567568779,
0.810673058,
-0.7082496285,
0.1189782917,
0.2142222822,
0.4139861465,
-0.2134811282,
0.0806900561,
0.5583286881,
0.5226880908,
-0.2027792037,
-0.5849291086,
0.1039317399,
0.2719002366,
0.2552126944,
0.4046890438,
-0.7233659029,
0.2218669653,
-0.2723678946,
0.0806244835,
-0.2131330669,
0.3621737063,
0.5053293109,
0.0154364184,
0.4781790972,
0.4268676639,
0.4939390421,
0.0991846025,
1.4404604435,
-0.2889424562,
0.4134944677,
0.8821849227,
-0.2805829644,
0.6452327371,
0.6171813607,
-0.2948994935,
0.1018303707,
0.9163042903,
0.4933813214,
0.6778264642,
0.3857938349,
-0.3736590147,
-0.4686210752,
-0.2521858215,
0.0828884169,
0.2520852685,
-0.1603756249,
-0.3527827263,
-0.020007588,
-0.2120305449,
0.2579166293,
0.4096252322,
0.1678266376,
0.7454869747,
-0.0070262114,
-0.8049166203,
0.3896708488,
0.0394104458,
0.3732529283,
-0.5672108531,
0.3503859639,
-0.4104298353,
0.0670623481,
0.1296167374,
-0.3202769756,
0.0694422424,
-0.1277608722,
-0.3652993441,
-0.0699831545,
0.7447049618,
-0.3928589523,
-0.6003091931,
0.5033288598,
0.090607509,
0.0079894913,
0.0859006792,
-0.3605051637,
0.1910558939,
0.0723765418,
-0.4266780615,
0.3746658564,
0.0809534788,
-0.1441478729,
0.6507951021,
0.7246952653,
0.242180407,
-0.4250819683,
0.359860599,
0.7938925028,
-0.5319833159,
-0.3488417268,
-1.0771765709,
0.314796865,
-0.0126138944,
-0.3843921125,
0.5425708294,
0.6935226321,
0.5318579674,
-0.1375968158,
0.7061488032,
0.4151530862,
0.2799758911,
-0.4697675705,
0.4759468138,
-0.6015454531,
0.1249568313,
-0.6516480446,
-1.0569556952,
-0.5325641632,
0.4101678133,
-0.6015958786,
-0.096438542,
0.5613424182,
0.7530385256,
0.1912149489,
-0.0295313932,
0.4122540355,
-0.1484806538,
0.2227622569,
0.6511892676,
0.564881444,
-0.0443519503,
0.2159817219,
-0.1000954956,
-0.6662106514,
-0.0822502971,
-1.1342623234,
-1.0006052256,
-0.5973701477,
-0.1642098427,
-0.1106361374,
0.2706395984,
0.9287381768,
0.6178801656,
-0.6443392038,
-0.549667716,
-0.1715611368,
0.3896714747,
0.1897157431,
-0.1846633703,
0.5464454889,
-0.4892396331,
-0.9635731578,
0.3394940495,
0.3847261071,
-0.1051068753,
-0.0828526318,
-0.2318848372,
-0.2155442536,
0.3338513672,
0.5411705971,
0.2865148783,
-0.7183730602,
-0.5373464823,
0.1234655902,
-0.0726637393,
-0.056015756,
1.1060376167,
-0.2966592908,
0.6536432505,
0.4227244258,
0.9111421108,
0.5068047047,
0.1384707689,
1.0535912514,
-0.4924611747,
0.1432581246,
0.1375662535,
0.40848279,
0.1462223977,
-0.5300893784,
0.4937278032,
0.1234349236,
-0.830111146,
-0.7626423836,
0.2623579204,
-0.9960309863,
-0.4159150422,
1.2239031792,
0.1923823953,
-0.0375694782,
-0.0629183725,
-0.2888044715,
0.1919096708,
-0.6045316458,
0.9142482281,
0.491882503,
-0.2557481527,
0.0757053196,
-0.3974525332,
0.58583951,
0.585565567,
-0.8100539446,
0.1805910319,
0.6629010439,
0.2118487656,
-0.1795445383,
0.6421351433,
0.1018792465,
-0.0525218286,
-0.2683140635,
0.1518488526,
0.2642054558,
-0.1781903207,
-0.1919164956,
-0.2327341884,
0.283169806,
0.035785567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14973v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14973v2
|
Introducing GenCeption for Multimodal LLM Benchmarking: You May Bypass Annotations
| 2024-02-22T21:22:04 | 2024-06-09T21:10:34 |
Lele Cao, Valentin Buchner, Zineb Senane, Fangkai Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.7; I.4
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) are commonly evaluated using costly
annotated multimodal benchmarks. However, these benchmarks often struggle to
keep pace with the rapidly advancing requirements of MLLM evaluation. We
propose GenCeption, a novel and annotation-free MLLM evaluation framework that
merely requires unimodal data to assess inter-modality semantic coherence and
inversely reflects the models' inclination to hallucinate. Analogous to the
popular DrawCeption game, GenCeption initiates with a non-textual sample and
undergoes a series of iterative description and generation steps. Semantic
drift across iterations is quantified using the GC@T metric. Our empirical
findings validate GenCeption's efficacy, showing strong correlations with
popular MLLM benchmarking results. GenCeption may be extended to mitigate
training data contamination by utilizing ubiquitous, previously unseen unimodal
data.
|
[
-0.5441527963,
-0.5560317039,
0.4842418134,
0.2413538098,
-0.3598811924,
0.2020036429,
-0.2433411628,
-0.3540334702,
-0.2817724645,
0.3951455355,
-0.7751068473,
-0.6988570094,
-0.3490749002,
-0.1107184589,
-0.4933633804,
0.643724978,
-0.1474116892,
0.1053952202,
-0.926856637,
-0.5500921607,
-0.3087416291,
-0.5188472867,
-0.2152694166,
-0.4084911346,
0.4255213737,
0.1929767877,
0.4771356583,
0.3705750108,
0.4129805267,
0.3165574074,
0.1588801146,
0.3978957534,
-0.4133119583,
0.2640214562,
0.0540735535,
-0.3976011276,
-0.1688044071,
0.2288749963,
0.6045375466,
0.9098534584,
-0.0453421138,
0.2896431983,
0.2173262537,
0.4749162793,
-0.9060793519,
0.0881936476,
-0.6955394149,
0.342926085,
-0.2249400169,
-0.5069492459,
-0.5921600461,
-0.155094713,
-0.1881684065,
-0.6710093021,
0.3124316037,
0.1452889889,
0.7349501848,
0.4634931684,
-0.4565648139,
-0.1477810144,
-0.5442219973,
0.7761600614,
-0.4864659011,
0.6193554401,
0.3537591398,
0.3559784889,
-0.061410632,
-0.3134853244,
-0.5763913989,
-0.5493540168,
0.062736094,
0.2330704033,
0.1220687479,
0.07700032,
0.4111546576,
0.1767144799,
-0.5241450667,
0.2298538685,
0.1197007895,
-0.2065778673,
0.6254615784,
0.3124198616,
0.3384644091,
-0.1085712016,
-0.7768964767,
-0.1691543311,
-0.6871378422,
-0.2111057639,
0.48206985,
0.048716832,
-0.2129216194,
0.6221366525,
-0.1896248907,
0.3314053714,
-0.1979950666,
-0.0320205316,
0.6293926239,
-0.4654504955,
-0.2863609493,
-0.1874585301,
0.7999148369,
0.5515663028,
0.231943503,
-0.5911940336,
-0.0633039698,
0.2717056274,
-0.0259439386,
-0.8027123809,
-0.1921779215,
0.1790755838,
-0.4322907329,
-0.2582001388,
-0.1554381549,
-1.2583233118,
-0.7382774353,
-0.144623667,
0.3125069439,
-0.4708848,
-0.2190644294,
-0.1805807352,
-0.2502537966,
0.1169756651,
0.353572607,
-1.0111593008,
-0.1540055424,
0.9010339379,
0.6994383931,
-0.116181314,
-0.3708961904,
-0.4972267449,
0.1355527788,
-0.3466851711,
0.9968857169,
-0.5953736305,
-0.5697696805,
-0.1387536675,
-0.1515780985,
-0.3766215742,
-0.8293709159,
0.4674636424,
-0.1025066525,
0.1677112728,
-0.0165837072,
-0.7805653214,
-0.1393743455,
0.1634037346,
-0.5616595149,
0.9598200917,
0.1020585969,
-0.7261803746,
0.9986923933,
-0.5226324797,
-0.2172985971,
0.2607659698,
-0.4924109876,
-0.4771970212,
0.293559432,
0.1127634197,
0.1652213782,
-0.2290923446,
0.3658498526,
-0.744086802,
-0.2606021762,
0.2609733939,
-0.7866516709,
0.7013828158,
0.2831724286,
-0.4255236685,
0.4150297642,
-1.063462019,
0.0523283482,
-0.153577894,
-0.1371628642,
-0.6858484149,
0.1721809059,
0.0502088442,
0.2235659659,
-0.109148711,
-0.6405201554,
0.1540364474,
0.1386720836,
0.0463329554,
0.8783389926,
-0.2843007743,
0.4029807746,
-0.3310789466,
0.4061904252,
-0.0926683694,
0.410626322,
-0.0637687817,
-0.4662509263,
-0.8588408828,
-0.6975156665,
-0.0085440595,
0.3746254742,
-0.9516516328,
0.1957865953,
-0.2110565454,
-0.4222910404,
-0.8419473767,
0.5694224834,
0.3727630079,
0.3456073105,
0.3737952113,
-0.0665421337,
-0.5397050977,
-0.8701643348,
-0.2540949285,
-0.0292591546,
-0.1547320634,
0.221143052,
0.2501979172,
-0.5127779841,
0.7839967012,
0.0787300095,
-0.376986891,
-0.1155936196,
0.5892236829,
-0.3152649999,
0.5521650314,
0.3415593803,
-0.5832129121,
0.0781316087,
-0.1596060097,
-1.3499711752,
-0.3015016019,
-0.3799948096,
-0.0706537515,
0.3059678078,
0.7512651682,
-0.5484785438,
0.3552848995,
0.7797425985,
-0.5479599237,
0.1826736182,
-0.2411386222,
0.201442346,
-0.8817067742,
0.092618905,
-0.1635392457,
0.0284289028,
-0.3816218078,
0.2763877511,
0.1238918751,
0.1865810752,
-0.2819271088,
0.4029211402,
-0.4871144295,
-0.0097422665,
0.0081042945,
0.1569129974,
0.0630833209,
0.1968672723,
-0.1957419962,
0.6964748502,
0.0451749451,
-0.2428040802,
0.3598643839,
0.1589531302,
-0.6035103798,
0.7179278135,
-0.2051847577,
0.1390964687,
-0.3931375146,
-0.0094771646,
-1.0575700998,
0.0054490669,
0.0827876255,
-0.1645835042,
0.0873836949,
-0.0442844108,
-0.5142781138,
-0.3162392974,
-0.6131585836,
0.4659106731,
0.3377219737,
-0.7839819789,
0.8315245509,
-0.0424390137,
0.3768511713,
-0.4117395282,
-0.6385891438,
0.1580278873,
-0.5271071792,
-0.6213667989,
-0.1286102086,
-0.4091495275,
-0.3976325095,
-0.0741683915,
0.1217430606,
0.1704721451,
0.4772152305,
0.66820544,
0.3618595004,
-0.0694114491,
0.2322877198,
-0.0955751389,
-0.1961795539,
0.0490140952,
0.1081766859,
0.6253709793,
0.1502957493,
-0.8843190074,
-0.3227788806,
0.3342278302,
0.5663001537,
-0.0392766893,
0.2334014624,
0.7174232006,
-0.0834621266,
-0.2362247556,
-0.8480891585,
0.1188507155,
-0.4761449099,
0.412275672,
-0.4564442635,
-0.7174541354,
0.400475949,
-0.1537172496,
-0.0925580338,
0.2651149631,
0.4685455859,
-0.1223334745,
0.8243154883,
0.4419541657,
0.3740671873,
0.2376667708,
-0.0967619494,
-0.150576368,
-0.9550911784,
-0.5623947978,
-0.2790346146,
-0.2786294818,
-0.4993464947,
-0.7350407839,
0.1720914096,
0.2129117399,
-0.1017352566,
-0.0574168116,
-0.0867807716,
0.274068296,
0.5784797668,
-0.1059318185,
0.5484641194,
0.0067512826,
-0.4487474561,
-0.1556526423,
-0.3680821359,
-0.2346926332,
1.249604702,
0.2511439025,
1.0007293224,
-0.0005347556,
0.7536563873,
0.1528348625,
0.6160449982,
-0.5151358247,
0.7714121342,
-0.1311744899,
-0.5601008534,
-0.089160502,
-0.588498652,
-0.6604611278,
0.6004856825,
-0.3463473022,
-0.7972006798,
0.333168149,
0.056652952,
-0.2168893814,
0.485886842,
-0.6528236866,
0.9546325803,
-0.4275373518,
-0.5634870529,
-0.1185696647,
-0.3311221302,
0.5497707725,
-0.2223586291,
0.2958705127,
-0.7281528115,
-0.1882974207,
0.4846130311,
-0.3527129292,
0.7573233843,
-0.1968991756,
-0.1680441052,
0.1625828147,
0.2006307393,
0.2104181051,
0.0409212895,
0.0793032795,
0.2704545259,
-0.0752992705,
-0.2604590952,
-0.4435370266,
0.6969821453,
-0.6045243144,
-0.3566316664,
-0.2792263627,
-0.7882788181,
-0.5653510094,
-0.1177056283,
0.358428508,
0.2020275891,
-0.2797280252,
0.1264339387,
0.5785841346,
-0.3019900024,
0.789436996,
0.3930556476,
-0.4540010989,
-0.4215993881,
0.8454324603,
-0.150563091,
0.518191576,
0.2188085616,
0.1070110574,
-0.3898652196,
-0.527877748,
-0.7073050141,
-0.1418124884,
-0.8179449439,
0.0394616239,
-0.6061035395,
0.1991209984,
-0.139462769,
0.0047951262,
-0.330314368,
-0.1076147109,
0.1368006319,
0.0026992231,
0.1586606652,
0.5878918171,
-0.1681783944,
0.0558900498,
-0.5677008629,
0.2919154763,
0.3589212894,
0.4948276281,
-0.0066966908,
-0.1869305372,
0.119305253,
-0.1370927691,
0.0238647591,
-0.383661449,
0.1500723958,
0.3341835737,
0.7130921483,
0.6328541636,
-0.0681918859,
0.7563948035,
-0.3996013403,
0.5410401225,
0.348180145,
-0.8284143209,
0.2069381624,
-0.1124133766,
0.3115455508,
0.9336820841,
0.1347392946,
-0.5210324526,
-0.4815934896,
-0.2770554423,
-0.9568668008,
-0.0451336727,
-0.2838386595,
0.1471532285,
-0.1151434705,
-0.190887779,
0.4591305852,
0.3403532207,
-0.6227741838,
-0.0139675159,
-0.2330925465,
-0.3205365539,
-0.2879186273,
-0.4762941003,
-0.2630257308,
-0.2938919365,
0.180107981,
-0.2096839249,
0.0237740502,
0.0935221836,
-0.548132658,
-0.1889653057,
0.3790091276,
0.7227640748,
0.6160353422,
-0.4008085132,
0.4674343765,
0.159635976,
-0.2889773846,
0.1816603839,
0.2545226216,
-0.5065492392,
0.1180607304,
0.5761820078,
0.6539870501,
0.4802496731,
-0.8412017822,
0.5372819304,
-0.0498975441,
-0.1924767941,
-0.2220030278,
-0.2343031317,
0.1563249081,
0.3192410171,
0.3664881885,
0.0325623676,
0.1355327666,
-0.4815342724,
0.3141492009,
0.707274735,
-0.4214431942,
-0.1097580567,
1.0180540085,
0.2534966767,
0.224568367,
0.6730962992,
-0.2388929278,
-0.1084540561,
0.3107154667,
0.3020653725,
1.1439447403,
-0.1448261291,
0.1178045869,
0.0372861102,
0.3587674499,
0.2229645252,
0.1925678402,
-0.0987274945,
-0.5245637298,
-0.5048207641,
-0.7564265132,
-0.173303932,
-0.0067102481,
-0.4952443838,
0.1303351074,
-0.514343977,
-0.0654604882,
-0.0284360163,
-0.6110203266,
-0.5734061003,
-0.0951081812,
0.6404095888,
0.8203175068,
-0.74470824,
0.7470011711,
0.299520731,
-0.4801761508,
-0.3433413208,
-0.0321394727,
0.2320709974,
-1.0784459114,
0.8084545732,
0.3328064978,
-0.1212922409,
-0.3443145752,
-0.3630612195,
-0.3211366832,
1.0806781054,
0.3398223221,
-0.6858944893,
0.0216198564,
0.4999655485,
0.2784726918,
-0.3190228641,
0.343501538,
0.3224453032,
0.5401101708,
0.0574050583,
-0.7401412129,
0.169748202,
-0.2653942108,
0.1027984992,
-0.00418982,
-0.5468114614,
0.9370516539,
-0.3131875992,
-0.4135656655,
0.4300133884,
0.4713282585,
-0.0098585114,
0.7398500443,
0.5850282311,
1.0355364084,
0.7223069072,
-0.2765311897,
0.9898220301,
-0.2605654895,
0.5499459505,
1.2934712172,
-0.446677357,
0.7223021388,
0.6111444831,
0.0355015621,
0.332048744,
0.4012894928,
-0.2922146916,
0.5394843817,
0.4885464609,
-0.5827295184,
-0.492177248,
-0.3006315827,
-0.4560350776,
0.5403265357,
0.0529171377,
-0.2368464768,
-0.5917308331,
0.3162559569,
0.1340339333,
0.1910552382,
-0.236111477,
0.811683774,
-0.0566450655,
-0.3866737783,
0.675054729,
-0.4799352586,
0.9284045696,
-0.4317980707,
-0.0388812274,
-0.5183327794,
0.4475036561,
-0.1905332357,
-0.3448288143,
0.0625522807,
-0.3314221501,
0.2057895809,
-0.0079824086,
0.432390213,
-0.5886371732,
-0.5720151067,
0.705411911,
0.6228817105,
-0.0756501257,
0.0273277406,
-0.4438903034,
0.394644171,
-0.3043240309,
0.0332145058,
0.3735025525,
0.3148949742,
-0.1069814861,
0.9474334717,
0.5324813724,
-0.3015403152,
0.3728054762,
0.4343140125,
0.7959992886,
-0.5998179317,
0.0782322809,
-1.1263298988,
0.2316638976,
-0.1583940834,
-0.3664903939,
1.0007807016,
0.7613544464,
0.8671286106,
-0.0639647618,
0.8198791146,
0.1328514516,
0.2891560495,
-0.5256399512,
0.7236477137,
-0.5791965723,
0.1926020235,
-0.277399689,
-0.7745273709,
-0.3419886827,
0.1468277723,
-0.2758167982,
0.0149818482,
0.8192824125,
0.5361168385,
0.1014401317,
0.0696538985,
0.6337243915,
0.0135389073,
0.288998872,
0.7015404701,
1.3190649748,
-0.0391872041,
0.3575474918,
-0.3650496006,
-0.2848751545,
-0.2939115763,
-1.0119767189,
-1.1647584438,
-0.2112044245,
-0.2741102576,
-0.5242814422,
0.2650607228,
0.9106719494,
0.5844960809,
-0.761351943,
-0.2497479916,
0.1454855204,
-0.1377305984,
-0.1646101624,
-0.1734500527,
0.1202321351,
-0.5173698664,
-0.622682929,
0.4514499009,
0.3946715295,
0.2754837275,
-0.5301074982,
0.0632474571,
-0.2794794142,
-0.1133268625,
0.6346523762,
0.1906511784,
-0.6679864526,
-0.476205796,
-0.2848418653,
-0.0934393033,
0.0494867563,
0.8588088155,
-0.6238506436,
0.7315843105,
0.2250369191,
0.6034885049,
0.2322371453,
-0.0173678026,
0.3288399279,
-0.5762463808,
0.5605661273,
0.0660952106,
0.400342077,
0.5197504163,
0.0180587284,
0.6170251369,
0.5989368558,
-0.1691887677,
-0.863361299,
0.1423098743,
-0.9504237771,
-0.219720304,
1.155154705,
-0.0355447717,
-0.1310681403,
-0.1074334383,
0.2020112425,
-0.0272936933,
0.0266543031,
0.8334515095,
0.6590484977,
0.1274289042,
-0.1451441795,
-0.7916044593,
0.4799282551,
0.4433392882,
-0.8621935844,
0.2306492031,
0.5730244517,
0.323076725,
0.0977214947,
0.4009103179,
-0.1676529944,
-0.0662973076,
0.3427987099,
0.4183130264,
-0.2836744785,
-0.156166926,
-0.2697617412,
0.2515002191,
0.0973869711,
-0.3501956463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14972v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14972v1
|
MultiLS: A Multi-task Lexical Simplification Framework
| 2024-02-22T21:16:18 | 2024-02-22T21:16:18 |
Kai North, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Matthew Shardlow, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Lexical Simplification (LS) automatically replaces difficult to read words
for easier alternatives while preserving a sentence's original meaning. LS is a
precursor to Text Simplification with the aim of improving text accessibility
to various target demographics, including children, second language learners,
individuals with reading disabilities or low literacy. Several datasets exist
for LS. These LS datasets specialize on one or two sub-tasks within the LS
pipeline. However, as of this moment, no single LS dataset has been developed
that covers all LS sub-tasks. We present MultiLS, the first LS framework that
allows for the creation of a multi-task LS dataset. We also present MultiLS-PT,
the first dataset to be created using the MultiLS framework. We demonstrate the
potential of MultiLS-PT by carrying out all LS sub-tasks of (1). lexical
complexity prediction (LCP), (2). substitute generation, and (3). substitute
ranking for Portuguese. Model performances are reported, ranging from
transformer-based models to more recent large language models (LLMs).
|
[
-0.1622040868,
-0.3004227877,
0.4490384758,
0.2662444115,
-0.1538379341,
-0.0382570364,
-0.0638825521,
-0.2011553645,
0.1123111621,
0.1928337216,
-0.9173203707,
-0.3072670698,
-0.6865410209,
0.3907802999,
-0.4999735951,
1.0515036583,
0.0284429453,
0.2196002454,
0.0474046245,
0.0654279664,
-0.0820984393,
-0.6021211147,
-0.5366488099,
-0.1774459332,
0.8558238745,
0.475304544,
0.8788591027,
0.617016077,
0.4138267934,
0.2817106545,
-0.3826308548,
0.324742943,
-0.4773243368,
0.0399839059,
0.0516331568,
-0.2505114377,
-0.2919695675,
-0.4757404625,
0.632892251,
1.0648161173,
0.0342437476,
0.1428850144,
0.2823261023,
0.9854578376,
-0.7746911049,
0.2452833652,
-0.3199138641,
0.2892240286,
-0.4117976725,
-0.0270751715,
-0.1771974564,
-0.1023489311,
0.0634641722,
-0.6902860403,
0.186368078,
-0.0367505066,
0.027982479,
0.4080049098,
-0.6802019477,
-0.4595896602,
-0.6519582272,
1.0695766211,
-0.4205299318,
0.8016626239,
0.1051104963,
0.1656507999,
-0.0546423048,
-0.7207555771,
-0.3935581148,
-0.2310489118,
-0.3143206537,
-0.1062067226,
0.0020792766,
0.2289247811,
0.3536024988,
0.2181059271,
-0.4913316667,
-0.1617013663,
-0.7640536427,
-0.3469288349,
0.419279784,
0.277390182,
0.0271140095,
-0.0600973666,
-0.3099302351,
0.1025515348,
-0.885987103,
0.1564829201,
0.1537665278,
0.7534496784,
0.0203612875,
0.733468771,
-0.2521589696,
0.5860186815,
-0.4879009426,
-0.4644602239,
0.4446805716,
-0.7205750942,
-0.3374201953,
-0.0225630943,
0.5522571802,
-0.0333840922,
0.2724712193,
0.0862576663,
-0.245834887,
0.0791438147,
-0.2413232028,
-0.4539855123,
0.2310471535,
0.2565428913,
-0.4072088301,
0.0106383655,
-0.0577597655,
-0.6122624278,
-0.6103977561,
-0.6454282999,
0.0423872396,
-0.3484821618,
-0.0793411434,
0.3375912905,
-0.0239653382,
-0.2594590485,
0.4684316218,
-0.6162148118,
0.4862957895,
0.4302518964,
0.5854491591,
-0.2660332322,
-0.7761048079,
-0.2908044457,
0.2394379377,
-0.3523770571,
0.4067978263,
-0.2352268696,
-0.2629083097,
0.0249687824,
-0.1042154804,
0.0270946193,
-0.2182728499,
0.6979545951,
-0.1243982911,
0.0267264564,
-0.5187889338,
-0.4181647003,
0.2114742994,
0.0738358349,
-0.8505059481,
1.3438096046,
-0.1613487601,
-0.7341012955,
0.1187804863,
-0.7214744091,
-0.5092722178,
-0.1628108621,
-0.0126550533,
-0.0768175051,
0.0939512402,
0.1678842306,
0.2629206181,
-0.4616456032,
0.218446523,
-0.0268460419,
-0.3480988741,
0.0216893815,
-0.6303105354,
0.5778024197,
0.5217949748,
0.0224073231,
0.2033052742,
-0.3540469408,
0.0372206867,
-0.0534469076,
-0.4435972869,
-0.0139769865,
0.226467967,
0.3031669259,
0.4623565674,
0.5426027775,
-0.5132249594,
0.1416142583,
-0.1733800322,
0.1664548963,
0.4009533525,
-0.4854993224,
0.3021451235,
-0.3086140156,
0.4098673761,
0.2556610107,
0.4122819901,
-0.4890933633,
-0.496651262,
-0.6594263315,
-0.2068787813,
0.3346907496,
0.7361212969,
-0.7583542466,
0.1277835518,
-0.3314954937,
-0.6011360884,
-0.4137332439,
0.4914102852,
0.673576653,
-0.0577856824,
0.5384284854,
0.154057771,
-0.6826339364,
-1.0094749928,
-0.2107053548,
0.1870881617,
0.0036279247,
-0.1165620312,
0.340552181,
0.0309067685,
0.8602494597,
-0.4727644622,
-0.7416443825,
-0.4666616619,
-0.1472803354,
0.0838420987,
0.3992045522,
0.3059516847,
-0.9559506178,
-0.4223190248,
-0.3118970692,
-0.696261704,
-0.0814626813,
0.0762486905,
0.5064562559,
0.0577476844,
0.9831135869,
-0.3842995465,
0.4045891464,
0.6559562683,
-0.1224950477,
0.6021521688,
-0.5356722474,
-0.1071816385,
-0.7906689644,
-0.0433405414,
-0.046020899,
-0.1299735904,
-0.9447236657,
-0.0206446107,
0.0396799818,
-0.2379921824,
-0.9105299711,
0.4717606604,
-0.5976093411,
-0.3302611709,
0.153181836,
-0.0779610425,
-0.1100148484,
0.4921704233,
-0.066253297,
0.8089476228,
0.6387889981,
-0.5518254042,
0.2932771742,
-0.129847914,
-0.1809967905,
0.1572045982,
-0.572684288,
-0.1084811315,
-0.5359188318,
0.2344022989,
-0.9775714874,
0.0039248499,
-0.0591299571,
0.1611929983,
-0.0937730595,
0.1540814191,
-0.6958657503,
-0.5707877278,
-0.4019520283,
0.5572959781,
-0.0821821019,
-0.2659767866,
0.5759807825,
0.3770359457,
-0.3210377395,
-0.7914016843,
-0.856669426,
0.231349051,
0.0657682642,
-0.2438760996,
0.4938908517,
-0.4060299098,
-0.0271583721,
-0.1180513576,
0.1602635831,
-0.1756998599,
-0.1521222889,
-0.0607210249,
0.0200931896,
-0.1605843455,
0.4612796307,
0.3020342886,
-0.2125477195,
-0.5062294006,
0.1269921213,
0.4635793865,
-0.3596358597,
-0.7375634909,
-0.4999262989,
0.6278951764,
0.7926676869,
-0.0746502727,
0.3528693318,
0.1783960313,
-0.5745188594,
0.0239835847,
-0.3950318098,
0.1697764695,
-0.4570328295,
0.4918065667,
-0.7843058109,
-0.6846183538,
0.2718330026,
-0.1009326205,
0.3467815518,
0.4626117349,
0.4866103232,
0.0858043507,
0.9424794912,
0.5207456946,
0.0271789785,
0.3336037397,
0.1199512184,
0.145696044,
-0.3622978628,
-0.2109033614,
-0.480045855,
-0.4312602878,
-0.4257700443,
-0.5931820273,
0.5327768326,
0.2122305781,
-0.2035293579,
0.2904193401,
-0.4240233004,
0.6661902666,
0.5872545242,
0.055644244,
0.4442235231,
-0.1081511006,
-0.2854463458,
-0.258837074,
-0.7378106713,
-0.3695878983,
1.1629607677,
0.2842779458,
0.8983644247,
0.3963192403,
0.7307325602,
0.4590376914,
0.1378194392,
-0.6643826365,
0.6784417629,
-0.6771873832,
-0.3451721072,
-0.5943932533,
-0.1670148075,
-1.0092369318,
0.3483462036,
-0.3566200435,
-0.4251746237,
-0.0388157666,
0.16343005,
-0.4663221836,
0.1940654665,
-0.9493225813,
0.6381204128,
-0.3681793809,
-0.2383497804,
-0.1700280607,
-0.7226493359,
0.2305407524,
-0.1198161989,
0.7152690887,
0.0412477031,
-0.3061066866,
0.5912072659,
-0.2894297242,
1.0435472727,
-0.1224310473,
-0.0671316162,
0.1625592113,
0.0308487136,
0.2457720339,
-0.2887083292,
-0.2721500993,
-0.032554131,
0.3489207327,
-0.2218053788,
-0.346298337,
0.6211802959,
-0.493491888,
-0.319984436,
-0.4460535347,
-0.735873282,
-0.0782900602,
0.433378011,
-0.0876880884,
0.3386160433,
-0.2763606906,
0.157302618,
0.4158213139,
-0.0528429374,
0.5348356366,
0.1968282312,
-0.3613157868,
-0.2629078031,
0.8765863776,
0.2380050272,
0.11336869,
0.2481878996,
0.3293593824,
-0.5630642772,
-0.4404473603,
-0.6280013919,
0.0514329001,
-0.8625736237,
-0.1885763705,
-0.3371886015,
-0.2520046532,
-0.5633929968,
-0.0987423658,
-0.4576205909,
-0.4695813358,
-0.3168149889,
0.0504688993,
-0.0149929645,
1.1843750477,
-0.1856558323,
0.2406263947,
-0.7675412297,
0.4806085229,
0.2706199884,
0.2398176491,
-0.2865156531,
-0.1663608253,
-0.0622546077,
0.134495616,
-0.1566365361,
-0.9332904816,
0.3286221325,
0.3456174731,
0.5604086518,
0.2213075161,
-0.2207719982,
0.7169550061,
-0.6518334746,
0.8462052941,
0.4948472679,
-1.2509490252,
0.287579149,
-0.0757842734,
0.324139297,
0.4811839461,
0.1863343567,
-0.770665586,
-0.1412587762,
-0.3551619947,
-0.6718540192,
0.740359962,
0.2217530906,
-0.0627149493,
0.2376990914,
0.3111031353,
0.1639372855,
0.421787113,
-0.934130013,
-0.616061151,
-0.0430903472,
-0.6237117648,
-0.3160483539,
-0.4601538777,
0.0548668653,
-0.2400591671,
0.6514850855,
-0.3314594626,
-0.0114181451,
0.1544082463,
-0.1892417073,
-0.0448628068,
0.54614079,
0.7930551171,
0.587199688,
0.235757947,
0.3329998553,
0.4594057202,
-0.0773849487,
0.0004007128,
0.1655173749,
-0.1858429313,
0.0760618374,
0.3609434366,
0.6510460973,
0.4338295758,
-0.9066810608,
0.5090171099,
0.1909296066,
-0.1643392146,
-0.289845258,
-0.2836332321,
0.2905502319,
0.0634019524,
0.5581515431,
-0.0568043329,
0.1503022313,
-0.4660647511,
0.2872736156,
0.2394572347,
-0.2897549868,
-0.0904127657,
0.2917647064,
-0.0321220942,
-0.3385290205,
0.0027613631,
-0.2442817241,
-0.4950365722,
0.5266702175,
0.3754999042,
0.2888772786,
-0.4940474331,
0.1276618391,
0.3219488561,
0.4907002151,
-0.3753508627,
0.6273223758,
0.1906222552,
-0.5558803082,
-0.3161762357,
-0.5840634108,
-0.4739257693,
0.0469655432,
-0.4137382805,
0.6598539948,
-0.2267446816,
0.0439455546,
0.0981351808,
-0.2605252266,
-0.732211411,
0.3828072548,
0.4168702364,
0.9641201496,
-0.9894967079,
0.9319175482,
0.5917519927,
-0.2370230108,
-0.4329859912,
-0.2130143195,
0.2483421117,
-0.606110692,
0.7810677886,
0.0928571895,
-0.302300185,
0.0651477352,
-0.1105834693,
-1.1887735128,
0.8613296747,
0.467069,
-0.5486959219,
-0.4563942254,
0.8458317518,
0.5645427704,
-0.4114578962,
0.2551527321,
0.4633109868,
0.5316859484,
0.0220822282,
-1.1689845324,
-0.1789526492,
-0.0146181853,
-0.0395042598,
0.1148297787,
-0.2613675594,
1.2329359055,
-0.4798385501,
-0.0272451397,
0.1535816938,
0.5021716952,
0.1965052485,
0.2246498764,
0.828374505,
0.3983818889,
0.8019644022,
-0.1236348972,
0.7939614058,
-0.3317930102,
0.560369432,
1.1443852186,
-0.3389616311,
0.7655579448,
0.7164991498,
-0.4508304,
0.2877136469,
0.3903668523,
0.3384286165,
0.4722272754,
0.5001570582,
-0.22174564,
-0.2978995144,
-0.2541986704,
-0.3554847836,
0.4101463556,
0.7377102971,
-0.2854925692,
-0.661280334,
0.0959019437,
-0.2323249727,
-0.0627778769,
-0.3336240649,
0.5868220925,
-0.092043139,
-0.5609790683,
0.2577904463,
0.1756350249,
0.6785045862,
-0.9850530028,
0.1015418768,
0.0226322412,
0.3180158436,
-0.0714084357,
-1.0147840977,
0.47617957,
-0.1708124429,
-0.1406667978,
-0.5089125633,
0.7085613012,
-0.688449204,
-0.8779651523,
0.5253798962,
1.0783635378,
0.2295203805,
0.0463282652,
-1.0120354891,
0.1307786554,
0.020077249,
-0.2159051001,
0.228185758,
0.4732251763,
-0.0625646561,
0.820279181,
0.7861921787,
0.0097562494,
0.3316062689,
0.2115849555,
0.861063838,
-0.7126700878,
-0.6264059544,
-0.5371565223,
0.3392783999,
0.134959355,
-0.413089186,
0.4378197789,
0.856148243,
0.5742841959,
-0.0179156326,
0.8975507617,
0.020157434,
0.7771562934,
-0.436702311,
0.2043597102,
-0.9487820864,
0.2186707109,
-0.2221161723,
-0.5590502024,
-0.4938528538,
0.1653712839,
0.0948759541,
-0.0495587811,
1.0046002865,
0.9925176501,
-0.1584880054,
0.0666514933,
0.4540412128,
-0.1262212694,
0.1124401167,
0.7232546806,
0.5051301718,
-0.4544188082,
0.8330860734,
-0.4050973654,
-0.2052025199,
0.1421225816,
-0.9031206965,
-0.6037563682,
-0.6642079949,
0.017347673,
-0.1306553483,
0.1142032593,
1.0485926867,
0.3807409108,
-1.0412175655,
-0.5076167583,
-0.2009724826,
0.1757760644,
-0.4442146122,
-0.1376694143,
0.4659022689,
-0.4660546184,
-0.9404882193,
0.6722096205,
0.0725301057,
0.0670819953,
-0.4291785657,
-0.0970688909,
-0.3486610353,
-0.1027321666,
0.7390751839,
0.1878559589,
-1.0396478176,
-0.0117382826,
0.1259621233,
-0.3417303264,
-0.0128605934,
1.0318673849,
-0.6829859018,
0.2795895636,
0.2863273323,
0.4979512691,
0.2165131122,
-0.4793232083,
0.1439475119,
-0.959803164,
0.2868824899,
0.0121994866,
0.7514173388,
0.3066518307,
-0.178380847,
0.4274481237,
0.2995619476,
-0.0539221317,
-0.6374961138,
0.4063142836,
-0.8550252318,
-0.5190928578,
1.2307800055,
0.1576249748,
0.1987337619,
-0.5750784278,
-0.4340257049,
0.1421651989,
-0.3277539015,
0.2934586704,
0.5843490362,
-0.1242824942,
-0.0775912553,
-0.3458667397,
0.5917534232,
0.8363553882,
-0.8095294833,
0.3954409063,
0.6265420914,
0.1077798605,
0.5232633352,
0.7883797884,
0.0621070527,
0.0629720017,
-0.1891813278,
0.1527509987,
-0.1332411915,
-0.6223587394,
-0.2765541673,
0.5108859539,
-0.2723005712,
0.1237941906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14968v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14968v3
|
Mitigating Fine-tuning based Jailbreak Attack with Backdoor Enhanced Safety Alignment
| 2024-02-22T21:05:18 | 2024-06-20T05:18:04 |
Jiongxiao Wang, Jiazhao Li, Yiquan Li, Xiangyu Qi, Junjie Hu, Yixuan Li, Patrick McDaniel, Muhao Chen, Bo Li, Chaowei Xiao
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Despite the general capabilities of Large Language Models (LLM), these models
still request fine-tuning or adaptation with customized data when meeting
specific business demands. However, this process inevitably introduces new
threats, particularly against the Fine-tuning based Jailbreak Attack (FJAttack)
under the setting of Language-Model-as-a-Service (LMaaS), where the model's
safety has been significantly compromised by fine-tuning users' uploaded
examples contain just a few harmful examples. Though potential defenses have
been proposed that the service providers can integrate safety examples into the
fine-tuning dataset to reduce safety issues, such approaches require
incorporating a substantial amount of data, making it inefficient. To
effectively defend against the FJAttack with limited safety examples under
LMaaS, we propose the Backdoor Enhanced Safety Alignment method inspired by an
analogy with the concept of backdoor attacks. In particular, service providers
will construct prefixed safety examples with a secret prompt, acting as a
"backdoor trigger". By integrating prefixed safety examples into the
fine-tuning dataset, the subsequent fine-tuning process effectively acts as the
"backdoor attack", establishing a strong correlation between the secret prompt
and safety generations. Consequently, safe responses are ensured once service
providers prepend this secret prompt ahead of any user input during inference.
Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate that through the Backdoor Enhanced
Safety Alignment with adding as few as 11 prefixed safety examples, the
maliciously fine-tuned LLMs will achieve similar safety performance as the
original aligned models without harming the benign performance. Furthermore, we
also present the effectiveness of our method in a more practical setting where
the fine-tuning data consists of both FJAttack examples and the fine-tuning
task data.
|
[
-0.2835064828,
-0.8106413484,
0.4371667504,
-0.0306840632,
-0.1983785629,
0.2705142796,
-0.0916483775,
-0.4860219657,
0.1202596277,
0.8630028367,
-0.7290090322,
-0.6783559322,
-0.383069396,
-0.2455229014,
-0.330276072,
1.1026123762,
0.0892204493,
-0.3184891641,
0.3989669681,
0.1254457533,
-0.9292196631,
-0.3259570003,
-0.4812842309,
0.0591713078,
0.5365046859,
0.69942379,
1.0218273401,
0.6537601352,
0.4666946232,
0.1919658184,
-0.039789658,
0.0891143829,
-0.3894247413,
0.3622070551,
-0.3879124224,
-0.3517020941,
-0.5193642378,
-0.0331120528,
0.3068575263,
0.2245171517,
-0.2916456461,
0.2348299623,
-0.0075123953,
0.7880417109,
-1.0576947927,
-0.2131339908,
-0.9932692647,
-0.0788901746,
-0.2262963206,
-0.0906616598,
-0.446624428,
-0.6180568337,
-0.3934991658,
-0.3334911466,
-0.1472863704,
0.3712174296,
0.9856063128,
0.3006535172,
0.0093745282,
-0.105621174,
-0.2549100518,
0.4920473993,
-0.8010182381,
0.4215599298,
0.3417157233,
0.3988510668,
-0.502591908,
-0.0692906454,
-0.4565631449,
-0.2133460343,
0.0188932568,
-0.1247902215,
-0.2117746621,
0.0905537009,
0.4629050791,
0.306741178,
-0.431551218,
0.5790760517,
-0.2070604265,
-0.2998194098,
0.7539886832,
0.4940410852,
0.3239571452,
0.0396027975,
-0.367805481,
-0.1265981197,
-1.139377594,
0.3377332091,
0.6514697671,
0.6174957752,
-0.1494554579,
0.4475545585,
-0.4399809241,
0.6283262372,
0.3562535346,
-0.0278548989,
0.17932868,
-0.1906339526,
-0.2816236317,
0.3546448648,
0.7494269609,
0.6741175056,
0.2618196011,
-0.3349973261,
-0.2645865679,
-0.0158555526,
0.5437166095,
-0.8748592734,
0.0311691184,
0.3187331855,
-0.2700919807,
-0.6518722177,
0.0919412151,
-0.9812350273,
-0.5512437224,
0.1791594326,
0.4442430735,
-0.3541217446,
0.0780857652,
0.0836887583,
0.214717254,
0.2308177948,
0.0834459513,
-1.0207754374,
0.392752707,
1.1268219948,
0.8307324052,
0.08918681,
-0.1592085063,
-0.8573678136,
0.5371062756,
-0.4125736058,
0.4263445735,
-0.3753413856,
-0.2062101811,
0.0113580059,
0.0226126444,
0.0783543512,
-0.2598415315,
0.3835634291,
-0.7324230671,
-0.2787923217,
0.047919549,
-0.3025320172,
-0.1258347631,
0.303099364,
-0.522842288,
0.525496304,
-0.3061076701,
-0.5339748859,
0.3041552603,
-0.367218256,
-0.6108095646,
-0.1915830225,
-0.1567460895,
-0.8296861053,
0.2297544926,
0.5219717026,
0.5857648849,
-0.1299644858,
0.2684596777,
-0.5343074203,
-0.3975633681,
0.2898518443,
-0.0867097154,
0.8010713458,
0.4081283808,
-0.3219722807,
0.1253976375,
-0.7436798811,
-0.0301329941,
-0.0169611704,
0.0069073373,
-0.6688792706,
-0.1910456866,
-0.4515320063,
0.1294496953,
0.3916897774,
-0.7466677427,
0.1502961069,
-0.7646977901,
0.0046701129,
0.908600688,
0.0592167117,
0.2693088353,
-0.3189924657,
0.4507210851,
-0.0694432855,
0.5002300739,
-0.2322209477,
-0.517357409,
-0.2410822958,
-0.3081766963,
0.2630633116,
0.712536931,
-0.2427146733,
0.7084911466,
-0.0446592234,
-0.5832266212,
-0.6798189282,
0.2622440755,
0.7026664019,
0.5592768192,
0.3443597853,
-0.3157300949,
-0.3221342266,
-0.9612932205,
-0.6273411512,
0.1948580593,
0.1778285205,
0.1601216495,
0.1753393114,
-0.253518641,
0.7508158684,
-0.5102277398,
-0.201969102,
0.05529432,
-0.2475477308,
0.349271208,
0.861577034,
0.5782855153,
-0.3567095697,
-0.284516871,
-0.0005541203,
-0.5089887977,
-0.3272774518,
-0.0953908563,
-0.1011738256,
0.0648166463,
0.4460353553,
-0.3868398368,
0.6325246096,
0.6351012588,
-0.5237707496,
0.4187780619,
0.0588571876,
0.1297745258,
-1.170320034,
-0.1040034294,
-0.2875962853,
-0.1003509313,
-0.7254185081,
0.6205611229,
0.3703717291,
-0.3510908484,
-0.2956293821,
0.3302678764,
-0.1517274231,
-0.0548056699,
-0.282268852,
-0.1569592655,
-0.2778463066,
0.3118489981,
-0.5098428726,
0.9152300954,
0.496627003,
-0.30567801,
0.2394389361,
0.3646847308,
-0.3603599966,
0.2162790895,
-0.4485211372,
0.2649691105,
0.3061950803,
0.0469670184,
-0.8738390207,
-0.1846896708,
0.4716858268,
-0.2609172463,
0.4181552529,
-0.3505914509,
-0.4367688,
-0.057987798,
-0.5759648085,
0.0776921734,
0.5779596567,
-0.5762733817,
0.4825532734,
0.2977604866,
-0.287937969,
-0.7971218824,
-0.632696569,
0.2444703877,
-0.5278027058,
-0.8504325151,
0.1955557913,
0.1105089411,
-0.1105183959,
-0.4408707321,
-0.3136405647,
0.0360664651,
0.7047411203,
0.618385613,
0.2526300251,
-0.1863883436,
-0.3282554448,
0.4562585652,
-0.2780999541,
0.0644473955,
-0.0381846465,
0.4054463208,
-0.1320675761,
-0.2259432673,
-0.8278154135,
0.4596115351,
0.4929780364,
-0.2134244144,
0.949149847,
0.1490829885,
-0.2417597622,
0.0562323816,
-0.7190865278,
-0.4841903448,
-0.5623831749,
-0.0946274623,
-0.3329831362,
-0.9095059633,
0.5957460403,
0.0195761826,
0.4323377013,
-0.1172714457,
0.4369484782,
-0.1401423514,
0.9836546779,
0.6169902086,
-0.2975589931,
0.571616292,
0.2194131464,
0.3706339598,
-0.694524169,
-0.0928301886,
-0.6799201965,
-0.268717736,
-0.685980916,
0.269012481,
-0.0011488617,
0.2687285542,
-0.3669564128,
0.5152065158,
-0.2140691578,
0.4022241831,
0.2158545405,
0.4595922232,
0.4145752192,
0.0986840501,
-0.2406744212,
0.0662802085,
-0.3130232692,
-0.4117929935,
0.9966343045,
0.5996913314,
1.1934324503,
0.4064258933,
0.9988811016,
0.0214577932,
0.2365118414,
-0.5069282055,
0.6230486035,
-0.2614849508,
-0.5126857162,
-0.0397896953,
-0.2849632502,
-0.7623096108,
-0.0919286832,
-0.3073248267,
-1.1505701542,
0.1412013918,
0.5284380913,
-0.7976498008,
0.1595492214,
-0.7441419363,
0.8149779439,
-0.2428866029,
-0.3948652446,
-0.3936986029,
-0.7570751309,
0.5732795596,
-0.3464919031,
0.3953795731,
-0.1910350919,
0.0335904807,
0.6531139016,
-0.7574413419,
0.9804384112,
-0.3508099914,
-0.3363617361,
-0.1954167783,
0.2312705666,
0.9049014449,
0.2588968873,
0.0955726579,
0.1631761491,
-0.1724809259,
-0.2243445814,
-0.6329251528,
0.8095159531,
-0.5332029462,
-1.1722886562,
-0.2134570628,
-0.6443861723,
-0.4071771204,
0.1093278751,
-0.0203989372,
0.1670394242,
0.3412789404,
0.2457366735,
0.6079365611,
-0.3459072411,
0.2945615053,
0.6745201349,
-0.1902926415,
-0.424374938,
0.5525422692,
-0.255220145,
0.4116384685,
0.1695815623,
0.3966879249,
-0.0819334239,
-1.0009335279,
-0.3910962343,
-0.0040171803,
-0.3574577868,
-0.5999986529,
-0.5147473812,
-0.1579541415,
-0.5094407201,
-0.3311301768,
-0.3904858828,
-0.3165225089,
0.1036804095,
-0.0712352395,
0.7248510718,
0.1536724269,
-0.1729277372,
0.5602706075,
-0.8574899435,
0.341932863,
0.147046864,
0.4376923442,
-0.1391080022,
-0.4691517055,
-0.3787975609,
-0.0004752944,
-0.3007153273,
-1.0096828938,
0.1117259189,
-0.0229436439,
0.3899798393,
0.4079063535,
0.1435003728,
0.8923118114,
-0.6740040183,
0.5155604482,
0.2003899068,
-0.8611485958,
0.7419900298,
-0.329118371,
-0.1830625534,
0.8446740508,
0.1114810407,
-0.2190702111,
-0.6651314497,
-0.4043889046,
-0.80807513,
0.3620585501,
0.1338720769,
0.1373208612,
0.2608050108,
0.4041647017,
0.1777452081,
0.3045262396,
-0.4067437947,
-0.0031945396,
-0.133782804,
-0.2738556862,
0.0595352277,
-0.1238943562,
-0.2440287471,
-0.0930569619,
0.7019323111,
-0.0133584496,
-0.198514998,
-0.314484328,
-0.1278541833,
-0.145242095,
0.5303744078,
0.5613778234,
0.167225346,
-0.2638832927,
-0.1063394547,
0.2663244009,
-0.7267121673,
0.2955170572,
0.2080485523,
-0.4049224854,
-0.4117386937,
-0.072614044,
0.5339752436,
0.2989559174,
-0.5597177148,
0.3393948674,
-0.0619758144,
0.3032451868,
-0.011652248,
0.6302118897,
-0.2597167194,
0.4110002816,
0.2670982778,
0.0310130697,
0.0266624317,
-0.5391234756,
0.340811789,
0.7614913583,
-0.2562436759,
-0.0427158438,
0.5178707838,
0.1403221935,
-0.4907118976,
0.3923820853,
0.2550510168,
-0.3571662605,
0.5323386788,
0.5766125917,
0.9269855618,
-0.4892333746,
-0.4429338276,
0.0633719862,
0.6389481425,
0.0107290819,
0.3125129342,
-0.0380896069,
-0.7407812476,
-0.2292298228,
-0.593665123,
-0.2249858528,
0.2795586586,
-0.8679614663,
0.1804984063,
-0.9965238571,
-0.0421007723,
-0.232196033,
-0.157553643,
-0.2952633798,
0.0697911531,
-0.0441136733,
1.1591534615,
-0.7935727835,
0.8312182426,
0.3649188578,
-0.2361679822,
-0.9068496227,
0.2481180578,
0.1126550809,
-0.8801423907,
0.3604305685,
0.3841727376,
-0.2442070544,
-0.1741401404,
-0.4593966007,
-0.7544404864,
0.8655899763,
0.2983834147,
-1.0605962276,
-0.0779700577,
-0.1077342108,
0.1674163043,
-0.2908093929,
-0.5199036002,
0.7784438729,
0.4111179113,
-0.3133420944,
-0.906879127,
0.6083741784,
0.023844853,
-0.0973766223,
0.5250828862,
-0.4726267457,
0.5506713986,
-0.243738696,
-0.164405793,
0.4378060699,
0.5582789183,
0.5475905538,
0.4830796123,
0.4897145927,
0.777657032,
0.4289685786,
-0.0759495944,
0.759352684,
-0.3896044493,
0.196888715,
1.2254366875,
-0.2896767557,
0.7586601973,
0.6743386984,
0.3162060082,
0.3792695701,
0.4371183217,
-0.2186275274,
0.9477644563,
-0.0173367821,
0.085705623,
-0.1233983785,
0.1188215315,
-0.5995505452,
0.4986449778,
0.5063397288,
-0.464129746,
-0.2524439096,
0.075253211,
0.2132648379,
0.1510165483,
-0.6390385032,
0.9367469549,
0.0584741235,
-0.5060665011,
0.6140993237,
0.008717454,
0.7023662925,
-0.4772394001,
0.2768011987,
-0.0991826802,
0.2132733911,
-0.4054751992,
-0.9090698957,
0.5362318158,
0.2885036767,
0.0993297324,
-0.1129421443,
0.6211094856,
-0.0769234672,
-0.1062680408,
0.1852402389,
-0.0492586344,
-0.0874980465,
0.1361725181,
-0.683836937,
0.2026377469,
-0.0660073012,
-0.0975007638,
0.4727398455,
0.0015669776,
-0.1264960915,
0.546086669,
0.8030992746,
0.0766774714,
0.063130714,
-0.0989276916,
0.9551224113,
-0.7987013459,
-0.9666101933,
-1.0773044825,
0.428122431,
-0.1695463657,
-0.0644395202,
0.8970216513,
0.4612395167,
0.7114605308,
0.0545582101,
0.5984284878,
0.1862454116,
0.3746906817,
-0.9305736423,
0.958306849,
-0.3671623468,
0.4239857495,
-0.6314453483,
-0.3191379905,
-0.2187954932,
0.4500702322,
-0.4176464379,
-0.2534552217,
0.3211456537,
1.1847754717,
-0.0778125376,
0.1925241947,
0.3301269114,
0.278653264,
0.3940190971,
0.6085854173,
0.9234021902,
-0.4056071043,
0.3555667996,
-0.3234166503,
-0.2878869474,
-0.4296274483,
-0.9555479288,
-1.0747971535,
-0.1512606591,
-0.1017604768,
-0.664324522,
0.6207888126,
0.7700548172,
0.4507495761,
-1.0433508158,
0.0934546217,
0.0476825498,
0.0571829118,
-0.2624374926,
-0.1554445922,
-0.1138776243,
-0.261143595,
0.005709846,
0.6459075212,
0.351618737,
-0.0372086726,
-0.0449487194,
0.1277054548,
0.0613813587,
-0.0059469347,
0.082704179,
0.3812378347,
-0.8118025064,
-0.6098281145,
-0.3764376938,
-0.0577792749,
0.003272983,
0.852255404,
-0.6200658679,
0.1427599788,
0.1908025891,
0.9992867112,
0.1432043165,
0.0438179038,
0.6596964598,
-0.918902874,
0.3873904347,
-0.022921754,
0.3242878318,
0.1175281331,
-0.7359075546,
0.0741030127,
-0.2147501707,
-0.3414443731,
-1.0137040615,
0.5886188149,
-0.7826191783,
-0.2804013193,
0.7750383019,
-0.2057332546,
-0.295894593,
-0.273786068,
-0.0790150017,
0.1783251613,
-0.8093125224,
1.2020175457,
0.2893862128,
0.2237244844,
-0.1180869341,
-0.3407936096,
0.552378118,
0.3361571431,
-0.9425474405,
0.3236271739,
0.3085159659,
0.4942522943,
0.182720691,
-0.1599572003,
-0.079730615,
0.6461935043,
-0.3444702327,
-0.4692527354,
-0.4463959932,
-0.3944491446,
-0.628546834,
0.263918221,
-0.059461385,
-0.3457678854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14963v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14963v2
|
Mirror: A Multiple-perspective Self-Reflection Method for Knowledge-rich Reasoning
| 2024-02-22T20:57:17 | 2024-06-24T10:05:24 |
Hanqi Yan, Qinglin Zhu, Xinyu Wang, Lin Gui, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Large language models (LLMs) have the capability to iteratively reflect
on their own outputs, recent studies have observed their struggles with
knowledge-rich problems without access to external resources. In addition to
the inefficiency of LLMs in self-assessment, we also observe that LLMs struggle
to revisit their predictions despite receiving explicit negative feedback.
Therefore, We propose Mirror, a Multiple-perspective self-reflection method for
knowledge-rich reasoning, to avoid getting stuck at a particular reflection
iteration. Mirror enables LLMs to reflect from multiple-perspective clues,
achieved through a heuristic interaction between a Navigator and a Reasoner. It
guides agents toward diverse yet plausibly reliable reasoning trajectory
without access to ground truth by encouraging (1) diversity of directions
generated by Navigator and (2) agreement among strategically induced
perturbations in responses generated by the Reasoner. The experiments on five
reasoning datasets demonstrate that Mirror's superiority over several
contemporary self-reflection approaches. Additionally, the ablation study
studies clearly indicate that our strategies alleviate the aforementioned
challenges.
|
[
-0.5504489541,
-0.4499977231,
0.9903099537,
0.5027576685,
-0.2264030278,
0.3015499711,
-0.1067916006,
-0.1373253614,
0.3139916062,
0.6990656853,
-0.5977032185,
-0.1489359736,
-0.6832805276,
0.1048934311,
-0.4145638049,
0.6550289989,
-0.0195848662,
0.2808469534,
-0.1470035017,
-0.1334705353,
-0.4326716363,
-0.0887473375,
-0.2718192041,
-0.3211347759,
0.7609165907,
0.5628464818,
0.6537678242,
0.3456649482,
0.4933214486,
0.307158649,
0.2179810852,
0.5521152616,
-0.3524111807,
0.4932180345,
-0.6644713283,
-0.1920766979,
-0.1354320049,
0.2540352941,
0.5785509348,
0.5327398181,
-0.14464131,
0.0708558112,
0.136531651,
0.577015698,
-0.881351769,
0.0133850994,
-0.6549189687,
-0.1875410676,
0.0775256231,
-0.1398870945,
-0.3322020173,
-0.2687162757,
0.0202278215,
-0.3672063649,
0.0487743281,
-0.0281055607,
0.5416263938,
0.5220517516,
-0.6055236459,
-0.1137266085,
-0.7637315989,
0.879085958,
-0.6342412233,
0.4683868289,
-0.0982592329,
0.5660770535,
-0.1406396776,
-0.2706077993,
-0.7107784748,
0.1702450514,
0.0097097987,
0.3733288646,
0.5435468554,
-0.1519658566,
-0.0092122508,
0.1643872112,
-0.0280018318,
-0.4265031517,
-0.0287756883,
-0.2134736031,
0.7184471488,
0.2418125272,
-0.0408654809,
-0.0475613214,
-0.4302850962,
-0.1957440972,
-0.7059469819,
-0.3479822278,
-0.009649517,
0.4656887054,
0.2992451489,
0.4532590806,
-0.2175357789,
0.5938619375,
-0.0694719926,
-0.3365923166,
0.1250457764,
-0.4319418967,
0.1916286051,
-0.107734561,
0.6428826451,
0.3450358808,
-0.0682854652,
-0.1994834095,
-0.2392389923,
-0.137948215,
0.281835407,
-0.7177990079,
0.0868176445,
0.1276144534,
-0.2821100056,
-0.1028957143,
-0.0739333779,
-1.0457609892,
-0.893044591,
-0.0671042576,
0.8372235894,
-0.0595211759,
-0.5174939632,
0.1033600047,
-0.13691549,
0.3411256075,
0.8889666796,
-0.3865948617,
0.142567873,
0.5962182283,
0.6893202066,
-0.0892932191,
-0.6117060184,
-0.4628445804,
0.2579747438,
-0.3636630476,
0.8598402739,
-0.5173230767,
-0.2819696367,
-0.0388784036,
-0.1843320131,
0.0741717666,
-0.3443935215,
0.2993040681,
-0.3239407241,
0.4892051518,
-0.8985215425,
-0.3808799982,
-0.4180458784,
0.641019702,
-0.5477822423,
0.5292906165,
0.0839802176,
-0.5345039368,
0.4045145214,
-0.5196875334,
-0.3865976632,
-0.054964222,
-0.3838164508,
-0.1973949969,
0.0711249784,
0.3328981698,
0.241250515,
-0.3359601796,
0.13811782,
-0.4971501231,
-0.166607812,
-0.0341047309,
-0.4124839008,
0.5632758737,
0.1348874718,
-0.5599758625,
-0.0014343816,
-0.559637785,
-0.0669842884,
0.293669492,
-0.2876529098,
-0.3001139462,
0.2732621431,
-0.4626312256,
0.5877020359,
0.2718313336,
-0.678871572,
0.4534229636,
-0.2114289999,
0.0376072228,
0.8582802415,
-0.020672068,
0.2719898224,
-0.274345696,
0.2677641809,
0.3110925257,
0.1443518102,
-0.2995736003,
-0.547719121,
-0.9718517661,
-0.0712290183,
-0.250708878,
0.288091898,
-0.9285485744,
-0.1644032896,
-0.0912361816,
-0.4052031934,
-0.9291192293,
0.5291448236,
0.4856089354,
0.6352487206,
0.6247346401,
-0.2868492007,
-0.2912970483,
-0.7039736509,
-0.7182995677,
0.061551746,
0.3405781984,
0.4243757129,
0.6180459261,
-0.1316275299,
0.7056803107,
-0.3402480781,
-0.5257534385,
-0.2386888564,
0.0590250082,
0.2296188176,
0.3779509962,
0.1580443978,
-0.5078544617,
-0.3546506166,
-0.5022826791,
-0.8371475935,
0.1198785752,
-0.332546711,
-0.3051734865,
0.1457734257,
0.1667647362,
-0.4077489376,
0.1126884148,
0.4035863578,
-0.6027966142,
0.2555337548,
-0.0863737687,
0.2105139494,
-0.7777622342,
-0.355404079,
0.0449481793,
-0.1513198912,
-0.3548847139,
0.1087878272,
-0.1264360994,
0.5082808733,
-0.0607619062,
0.9070789218,
-0.6640977859,
-0.0305881649,
-0.4179201126,
0.3379040062,
0.3331319094,
0.3340988457,
0.3658827841,
0.6684507728,
0.2931275368,
-0.209396258,
0.274040848,
0.3136794269,
-0.1687900573,
0.5057690144,
-0.2456117272,
0.238978982,
-0.2183918357,
0.0426652208,
-1.0148738623,
0.042518355,
0.2610494196,
-0.229216069,
0.1086300462,
0.1196257398,
-0.4316067398,
-0.4132606685,
-0.3364034593,
0.3462585509,
0.1641543657,
-0.8949999213,
1.0580445528,
0.135291189,
0.1344261616,
-0.8635531664,
-0.3740803301,
0.1957162023,
-0.0216860175,
-0.6460011601,
-0.0637228191,
-0.1542500257,
-0.4646919966,
-0.0433441289,
-0.1263907552,
0.2495639324,
0.159130767,
0.1327463686,
0.1785279065,
-0.0168117788,
0.0596532039,
-0.0388914384,
-0.0547315069,
0.2948770821,
-0.2632385194,
0.4053603411,
-0.5934097767,
-0.8025118113,
0.0925566405,
0.4543005228,
0.5135694146,
-0.2124949098,
0.8372393847,
0.3703247309,
-0.1151383221,
-0.3948343992,
-1.1820015907,
-0.4109216034,
-0.4805428088,
0.084284991,
-0.4180562198,
-0.6545081735,
0.6577661633,
-0.073081322,
0.2863782942,
0.1874651313,
0.6953570247,
-0.1487091929,
1.2756141424,
0.3819621205,
0.0605254397,
0.0944890305,
-0.3852030635,
0.3388091922,
-0.9430318475,
-0.370408982,
-0.276109755,
-0.3072099984,
-0.1463964432,
-0.427087754,
0.5169522762,
-0.1161193624,
-0.4528835416,
-0.0533359051,
-0.7009409666,
0.3603322804,
0.711228013,
0.0944506451,
0.7478114367,
-0.4544371665,
-0.1245711446,
0.0282043703,
-0.5961577296,
-0.2062539309,
0.9166865945,
0.2038368285,
1.0025012493,
0.1580293626,
0.9836372733,
-0.230114609,
0.6194690466,
-0.5424779654,
0.5889570713,
0.2747277915,
-0.848104775,
-0.335611999,
-0.5043225288,
-0.4298276901,
0.8134685159,
-0.206137836,
-0.2596574724,
0.1758233607,
0.1066809818,
-0.178628996,
0.3598028421,
-0.4516228139,
0.6572110057,
-0.5684282184,
-0.8959058523,
-0.2078212649,
-0.6843681335,
0.3919921219,
0.1328711063,
0.5898613334,
0.0336054415,
0.1317692548,
0.4650483429,
-0.4066597819,
0.7458872795,
-0.5647374988,
-0.3170401752,
0.3177280724,
0.5292105079,
0.3916858137,
0.0255768001,
0.2075272948,
0.0037864868,
-0.1374175698,
-0.3101252019,
-0.7933284044,
0.6843457818,
-0.7265844941,
-1.1389664412,
-0.4561275542,
-0.5698218942,
-0.4362555444,
0.4135483801,
0.0433673114,
0.1285379082,
0.3556486964,
-0.3560889959,
0.5092327595,
0.0134084746,
0.4344100058,
0.815985322,
-0.5607610345,
-0.4116688073,
1.0008817911,
0.2472584248,
0.2881670892,
-0.1128058285,
0.3529257178,
-0.2605689764,
-0.5103462934,
-0.2958512008,
0.5794621706,
-0.8976384997,
-0.2371753454,
-0.3069759309,
-0.2010614276,
-0.2072861493,
-0.1454622,
-0.8115133047,
-0.420081228,
0.1465492696,
0.038373813,
-0.0377808847,
0.7763485312,
-0.2438755482,
-0.0306288116,
-0.6935623288,
0.1910066456,
0.5558986068,
0.5697934031,
0.1632288545,
-0.1788303405,
-0.16288881,
0.1679732949,
-0.4118221402,
-1.0078929663,
0.2549548149,
-0.0226768628,
0.652979672,
0.5876116753,
0.0398234166,
0.5769145489,
-0.3216607273,
0.6839197278,
0.132939145,
-0.8952158689,
0.6514648795,
-0.2597106099,
0.2003070861,
0.6956577897,
0.1450883895,
-0.4108949006,
-0.7296113968,
-0.327041775,
-0.6357638836,
0.1602454484,
-0.2459627241,
-0.0079794489,
-0.1974303424,
0.4136789441,
0.1605869979,
0.3721062839,
-0.8492140174,
-0.1062916368,
-0.793985188,
-0.0073426408,
0.000191567,
-0.1461586356,
-0.5567548275,
-0.2882936001,
0.7326321006,
-0.466260761,
0.1428210139,
0.5333546996,
-0.1368675083,
-0.2777395546,
0.2408573925,
0.4501731694,
0.5272526741,
-0.0571275502,
0.6055939198,
0.0854481608,
-0.1310041547,
0.1032695398,
-0.1914014816,
-0.1151132956,
-0.2641191185,
0.5199663639,
0.1843071431,
-0.1607686132,
-0.3474873602,
0.7744501233,
0.0153986923,
-0.2254338712,
-0.2764028907,
0.0303872898,
0.2332040668,
0.6008327007,
0.2821024656,
0.0172456466,
0.140331313,
-0.4617606997,
-0.1355604082,
0.907771945,
-0.4620827734,
-0.0762148574,
0.6879555583,
0.3308495581,
-0.0418449305,
0.7147741318,
-0.3093088865,
-0.803124249,
0.2161347121,
0.4917731881,
0.8150538802,
-0.2804812193,
0.2082105279,
0.3511649966,
0.3511227369,
-0.384531945,
0.5045116544,
-0.0881680995,
-1.2604198456,
-0.5857717991,
-0.4067516029,
-0.5052127838,
-0.2239555568,
-0.4088600874,
-0.012131297,
-0.4505882859,
0.1131103337,
-0.399880439,
0.0655814856,
-0.5218036175,
-0.0441148095,
0.2444936186,
1.0312850475,
-0.738519311,
0.6367792487,
0.313907057,
-0.6390379071,
-0.805364728,
-0.0992496759,
0.2427553833,
-1.0834319592,
0.5025932193,
0.1215214208,
-0.7555999756,
-0.2124298513,
-0.7945752144,
-0.7757744789,
1.0516991615,
0.2656141222,
-0.398943305,
-0.0864984691,
-0.0493808016,
0.3778921068,
-0.388238579,
0.3958692551,
0.366266489,
0.797945857,
0.3365448713,
-0.8252491951,
0.3286819756,
-0.2556748688,
-0.2482386231,
0.107356146,
-1.0284678936,
0.8170195818,
-0.5572290421,
-0.0223655179,
-0.219163999,
0.5164238214,
0.2733460069,
0.2235414684,
0.6649729609,
0.612912178,
0.471647799,
-0.0147193866,
0.6999343038,
-0.3941664994,
0.4112050831,
1.1544382572,
-0.5385363698,
0.5567160845,
0.8266996145,
0.2025725394,
0.8997731209,
-0.0871088579,
-0.1570193619,
0.7258714437,
-0.112478137,
-0.3327154517,
-0.8524960876,
0.0683752149,
-0.2616208792,
0.4950502813,
0.2681701779,
-0.0888203382,
-0.4916082621,
0.0280227177,
0.1309563965,
0.3397310376,
-0.2435850799,
0.8404542208,
0.1021566316,
-1.0095962286,
0.2278786898,
-0.4015924037,
0.5222834945,
-0.2314562798,
-0.3740511537,
-0.2497666329,
0.3916168213,
-0.2713029385,
-1.0017471313,
0.322473526,
-0.6693797708,
0.1149989814,
-0.5665494204,
0.7889036536,
-0.4371145368,
-0.391466558,
0.6594434381,
1.0227268934,
-0.252412945,
-0.1304266453,
-0.4196554124,
-0.1544113755,
-0.2247708291,
-0.552048564,
0.2513940334,
0.356046319,
0.2116049975,
1.0548597574,
0.268435806,
0.1238684133,
-0.0164406933,
0.1045231894,
0.9796442389,
-0.7872900963,
-0.1006763726,
-0.8870897889,
0.4307617247,
-0.1732711047,
-0.0529975258,
0.9768241048,
0.4563298225,
0.5596668124,
0.2348608822,
0.8467136621,
0.2429665029,
0.9602503181,
-0.2807449698,
0.5946493149,
-0.7674156427,
0.5428042412,
-0.3633385897,
-0.7707885504,
-0.3059925735,
0.9345290661,
-0.4004358947,
0.2563465536,
0.5957545042,
0.7223644853,
0.2404580265,
0.1194003522,
-0.0097395452,
0.476790458,
0.5053777099,
0.6312071085,
1.2954953909,
-0.0761086196,
0.4794974029,
-0.3500238955,
-0.3008989692,
0.0277234949,
-0.8684610724,
-1.0116449594,
-0.6421850324,
-0.1359707713,
-0.666025877,
-0.0396309383,
0.7305683494,
0.5836051702,
-0.4140244126,
-0.1752646714,
-0.0489875115,
0.6285712719,
-0.3593053222,
-0.2207657248,
0.0353618078,
-0.4856591523,
-0.1760971099,
0.3542933166,
0.3084766269,
-0.3691271245,
-0.9335662127,
-0.1613461077,
-0.0894470513,
0.2007351816,
0.382704258,
0.034096919,
-0.7388849854,
-0.7014392614,
0.152974233,
0.0340926498,
0.2048219144,
0.5993766785,
-1.0142263174,
0.6756169796,
0.3628171086,
0.3436213136,
0.6383011341,
-0.1305613071,
0.4433330595,
-0.3251780272,
-0.3852823377,
0.3019752204,
0.4939742088,
0.3130100965,
-0.2568936348,
0.4875769317,
0.1721981317,
-0.7003284097,
-0.655308187,
0.3896765411,
-0.7530238628,
-0.4817694128,
1.0168848038,
-0.0717066824,
-0.0661728308,
0.0350163355,
-0.1836485267,
-0.1280262619,
-0.1899836212,
1.2656064034,
0.8660733104,
-0.3818737566,
-0.5855873823,
-0.1933833063,
0.3374866247,
0.5332683325,
-0.7865305543,
0.0101165958,
0.4977686405,
0.477525115,
0.6471818089,
0.7266376615,
-0.1742080301,
0.1165351346,
0.0725416616,
-0.0306077637,
-0.1857698411,
-0.7749302387,
-0.136202231,
0.3556849658,
0.2753812075,
0.2468846738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14951v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14951v1
|
In-Context Learning of a Linear Transformer Block: Benefits of the MLP Component and One-Step GD Initialization
| 2024-02-22T20:26:08 | 2024-02-22T20:26:08 |
Ruiqi Zhang, Jingfeng Wu, Peter L. Bartlett
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study the \emph{in-context learning} (ICL) ability of a \emph{Linear
Transformer Block} (LTB) that combines a linear attention component and a
linear multi-layer perceptron (MLP) component. For ICL of linear regression
with a Gaussian prior and a \emph{non-zero mean}, we show that LTB can achieve
nearly Bayes optimal ICL risk. In contrast, using only linear attention must
incur an irreducible additive approximation error. Furthermore, we establish a
correspondence between LTB and one-step gradient descent estimators with
learnable initialization ($\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$), in the sense
that every $\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$ estimator can be implemented by
an LTB estimator and every optimal LTB estimator that minimizes the in-class
ICL risk is effectively a $\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$ estimator.
Finally, we show that $\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$ estimators can be
efficiently optimized with gradient flow, despite a non-convex training
objective. Our results reveal that LTB achieves ICL by implementing
$\mathsf{GD}\text{-}\mathbf{\beta}$, and they highlight the role of MLP layers
in reducing approximation error.
|
[
-0.3813486993,
-0.6693379283,
0.4200764596,
0.0062691541,
-0.0654469356,
0.2438375503,
0.0348359421,
-0.2354610562,
-0.3425356448,
0.2713798285,
-0.5315053463,
-0.3170558512,
-0.4247939289,
-0.7347985506,
-0.3442695439,
1.3739722967,
0.09117762,
0.2754903734,
0.0007649732,
0.3350743055,
-0.4627712667,
-0.3982581794,
-0.8704350591,
-0.5385882854,
0.6211270094,
0.1988569647,
0.4952207506,
0.3507548571,
0.4386183619,
0.137932837,
0.0468360148,
-0.1199969798,
-0.4756707251,
-0.1175083965,
-0.0162009187,
-0.3403122425,
-0.2522708774,
0.1118861735,
0.7128059268,
0.7777252793,
-0.1229663268,
0.083604455,
0.5872681141,
0.6525191069,
-0.818677485,
-0.003352294,
-0.3579245806,
0.3601850569,
0.158689037,
-0.3243889809,
-0.6948419213,
-0.2272255868,
0.4508233368,
-0.206595704,
0.251426816,
0.0579700097,
0.8523468971,
0.3925957978,
-0.3993188441,
-0.34191522,
-0.9471107125,
0.6932003498,
-0.3156157434,
0.5944686532,
0.0636823475,
0.3848941028,
-0.0584693328,
-0.8875489235,
0.0112002427,
-0.2364590764,
-0.2865771949,
0.0462354869,
0.0237482823,
0.559294641,
0.3911369741,
0.1772508621,
-0.2570434809,
0.1967840195,
-0.3930002749,
-0.1547380239,
0.2186210901,
-0.0946886018,
-0.1295798719,
0.0318650156,
-0.8842683434,
-0.0728523135,
-0.7914884686,
0.6195705533,
0.4056125581,
0.4440918863,
-0.3384256959,
-0.0892858952,
0.3636004329,
0.4999563992,
0.4251397848,
-0.3248845935,
0.2096048594,
-0.0301022548,
-0.4787143171,
0.1131589189,
0.2234260291,
-0.0158143938,
0.066629909,
-0.4139408469,
-0.3198853433,
-0.3469085395,
0.5499081016,
-0.8245607615,
-0.1366138756,
0.2118831724,
-0.520173192,
-0.2376643121,
0.3957288861,
-0.5590944886,
-0.1901002079,
-0.5238241553,
0.7231475115,
-0.375829339,
0.2531414032,
-0.1025041342,
0.1441976875,
0.6982183456,
0.1590955704,
-0.9081127644,
0.5299206972,
0.4325959682,
0.7893151641,
-0.1060200706,
0.0394673459,
-0.525490582,
-0.1761224717,
-0.270957917,
0.4668946862,
-0.2126144618,
-0.3165713847,
0.090810962,
-0.3418107033,
-0.1549243927,
-0.4663231969,
0.601498425,
-0.3606517315,
0.1704859883,
0.0507329293,
-0.4542907476,
-0.1234093308,
-0.0449396148,
-0.3972025812,
0.971719861,
0.2156576961,
-0.6513010859,
0.6269522309,
-0.6944969893,
-0.4631100297,
-0.1653809398,
-0.1347792,
-0.6138011813,
0.228589043,
0.1852002591,
0.7873001695,
-0.1300412416,
-0.0701345131,
-0.1553259939,
-0.3338867426,
0.2803997993,
-0.6502841711,
0.8341872692,
0.1341856271,
-0.4684312344,
0.1774197817,
-0.8512730002,
0.1342672706,
-0.2130197138,
-0.256729424,
-0.3696497381,
0.057878077,
0.1166292801,
0.2766990662,
-0.1723732799,
-0.4927414954,
-0.0683606714,
-0.1141283438,
0.175172314,
1.2914791107,
0.1214960441,
0.7092091441,
-0.2102956325,
0.470844239,
-0.0468851812,
0.6394078135,
-0.1215061098,
-0.125640288,
-0.8613569736,
-0.4903511107,
0.1956574023,
0.4792434573,
-0.4862514436,
0.2804040015,
0.3811616302,
-0.3094861805,
-0.4090993106,
-0.0296468735,
0.642195344,
0.8983731866,
0.6313973665,
0.0445156321,
-0.3617944717,
-0.7698635459,
0.1980076283,
0.0897092894,
-0.1004057303,
0.4212114215,
0.2229997367,
0.1639118046,
0.8842861652,
-0.5880055428,
-0.3216186762,
-0.2119936943,
-0.1525853872,
0.5021733642,
0.6309967041,
0.5983909965,
-0.7078703046,
-0.8715402484,
0.0009137359,
-0.5640364885,
-0.0156165315,
-0.3216093183,
-0.262986809,
0.0830901936,
0.7265464664,
-0.2216932178,
0.6518539786,
0.3795652092,
-0.447266221,
0.3175465167,
-0.4267703295,
-0.4514817297,
-0.8426954746,
-0.092808038,
0.2025822252,
-0.2147280425,
-1.0417588949,
-0.1011654139,
0.3465095162,
0.1243126467,
-0.5290259719,
0.3786362708,
-0.3151672781,
0.0448561087,
-0.2417140007,
-0.0118944999,
-0.2468878776,
0.6322987676,
-0.2271146476,
0.5917389989,
0.6422355771,
-0.7936235666,
-0.0833156332,
-0.1027146131,
-0.2124658823,
0.8156381249,
-0.5554539561,
0.1062771529,
-0.6297157407,
0.0815366134,
-0.8249985576,
0.3377529085,
0.3909791112,
-0.1444419026,
0.827591598,
0.0259722508,
0.2890284657,
-0.4476085603,
-0.305485636,
0.1675071716,
0.5670122504,
-0.9426374435,
0.7498563528,
0.1496449858,
0.259398818,
-1.1239420176,
-0.6208813787,
-0.2775453627,
-0.2334028184,
-0.204580605,
0.3957906365,
-0.4570845664,
-0.0166233592,
0.095725745,
-0.1548773348,
-0.071039848,
0.157377556,
0.2225877047,
0.6285419464,
-0.1283354461,
0.2484701127,
-0.089652434,
-0.3896590173,
0.2169647217,
-0.5762335062,
0.6211164594,
-0.1708460748,
-0.3616003692,
-0.2480060011,
-0.0060981493,
0.124985531,
0.1696168929,
0.5650162101,
0.5909979343,
-0.4267715812,
-0.6359694004,
-0.5910415649,
-0.2539282739,
-0.4528806806,
0.433311671,
-0.3708924353,
-0.68749547,
0.5798403025,
0.3568607271,
-0.0954731703,
0.3588392735,
0.3653255999,
-0.3657479584,
0.5378414392,
0.921384275,
-0.3469607234,
0.7844623327,
-0.6618328094,
0.2061888129,
-1.0666189194,
-0.3833669126,
-0.4223563075,
-0.6031278372,
-0.5639852881,
-0.2373166978,
0.6642214656,
0.0306600202,
-0.5212473869,
0.1207113191,
-0.4468019903,
0.5941176414,
0.6876179576,
0.5950940251,
0.0297333132,
-0.0757433027,
-0.2118850201,
-0.0112646287,
-0.8403893709,
0.0558960177,
1.3713594675,
0.5597958565,
1.2933223248,
-0.3069471717,
0.6116292477,
0.1556915492,
0.54128021,
-0.783686161,
0.1456916928,
-0.1164825037,
-0.3764972389,
-0.1897959411,
-0.1213320941,
-0.6360419989,
0.393173337,
-0.2378050983,
-0.7857233882,
0.539221704,
0.3929228187,
-0.4769648015,
0.4521327615,
-0.6009507179,
0.6851655245,
-0.305631727,
-0.440207988,
-0.1263410002,
-0.8671448231,
0.2385513186,
-0.0247825086,
-0.1324646175,
0.1622355282,
0.0047549396,
0.1449974775,
-0.3336414397,
0.8113351464,
-0.7029780149,
0.1098056436,
0.2912192941,
-0.4320409298,
0.5398100019,
0.0693747848,
0.3239040375,
-0.1110472158,
-0.6730554104,
-0.3079652488,
-0.5718541145,
0.3691412807,
-0.7345495224,
-0.331010282,
-0.4363172054,
-0.7596705556,
-0.1211412475,
-0.1372327507,
0.2350968271,
0.7049615383,
0.0138109708,
0.5082602501,
0.9914937019,
-0.1732217669,
0.8594688773,
0.2596157193,
-0.0982275158,
-0.2593144774,
0.4977635741,
0.0661704838,
0.7765629888,
0.6378771067,
0.2794882655,
-0.2395039946,
-0.4548541605,
-0.0638374612,
0.0329488739,
-0.8646481037,
-0.3789845407,
-0.3145129085,
-0.9033637643,
0.3708013296,
-0.5664967895,
-0.2924885452,
-0.0197789818,
-0.0864671618,
-0.3612504005,
-0.2386426926,
0.6028026342,
-0.2255832702,
0.2361892313,
-0.2913598716,
-0.0048171245,
0.3805831373,
0.1969261616,
0.1966382563,
-0.5648958683,
-0.5229967237,
-0.3101558089,
-0.3495734334,
-0.2956151664,
0.051601056,
0.2328049988,
0.9197343588,
0.7992472649,
0.0213133395,
0.5624717474,
-0.5568335652,
0.3861669004,
0.2184153646,
-0.8442679048,
0.3179068267,
0.1022756994,
0.19035469,
0.3261942267,
0.5746208429,
-0.4394467771,
-0.3646633923,
-0.6097925901,
-0.7522287965,
0.5975958109,
-0.0047835959,
0.1641844213,
0.1779812723,
0.4381318092,
0.0368021242,
0.2024898082,
-0.9268493056,
-0.6868834496,
-0.1349215209,
0.0530406125,
0.1490502059,
-0.407279104,
-0.1075981632,
-0.0910866708,
0.7577397823,
-0.3348631859,
0.3704683781,
0.4166031182,
-0.157956779,
0.0047358964,
0.081595175,
0.5961669087,
0.7017465234,
-0.6407257915,
0.1485513598,
0.2342293262,
-0.5321807265,
0.2380446941,
0.1416934133,
-0.6865345836,
-0.3494772911,
0.282458812,
1.0668094158,
0.4431153238,
-0.2675388455,
0.5218372345,
-0.0278202295,
-0.0548818149,
-0.2037006021,
-0.1622621119,
-0.4394757748,
0.5575190187,
0.8168705106,
0.3638986945,
0.0465631522,
-0.2427158803,
0.3514693975,
0.8511387706,
-0.6528519392,
-0.1584732533,
0.934948504,
0.048486501,
-0.1030070856,
0.4094437659,
-0.0101228161,
-0.3238184452,
0.6310818195,
0.8418397307,
1.2558335066,
-0.3891032934,
0.2113638222,
0.383808583,
0.4363449216,
0.395193994,
0.0295700636,
-0.0168032702,
-0.9955152273,
-0.4859516919,
-0.5035560727,
-0.3913113177,
-0.0075050686,
-0.636772573,
0.2335057706,
-0.909620285,
0.0182725228,
-0.2108023018,
-0.2423752397,
-0.8296423554,
0.2393910587,
0.3177327514,
0.7255848646,
-0.5822969675,
0.869807899,
0.2251450568,
-0.3149219453,
-0.9110432863,
0.0257319938,
-0.1804758906,
-0.8027033806,
0.9156168699,
0.074630782,
0.019635627,
0.0440059863,
-0.2231967747,
-0.8683658242,
1.3001043797,
0.3626319468,
-0.4383484423,
-0.2242377847,
-0.0085814605,
0.2424910963,
-0.5882597566,
0.4779470563,
0.5729685426,
0.2735693455,
0.0575170405,
-0.6891636252,
-0.0952037573,
0.2470878661,
0.1166518778,
0.2703634501,
-0.6186951399,
1.1169394255,
-0.3942417502,
-0.048473224,
-0.1631851345,
0.5643565059,
-0.1546141654,
-0.0535321161,
0.6359912753,
0.4121307135,
0.7050035,
-0.1220365614,
1.2647804022,
-0.5547499657,
0.537869215,
1.0570236444,
0.2804013193,
0.4791629612,
0.6611227393,
-0.3896647096,
0.5944514871,
0.3684430122,
0.073902972,
0.7829574943,
0.179973498,
-0.3058449626,
0.1715290844,
-0.0041663777,
-0.1166713908,
0.1428161561,
0.2499972731,
-0.4749536514,
-0.3356894255,
0.2085262388,
0.0924676433,
-0.1336138695,
-0.6296322346,
0.4209024012,
0.2317032963,
-0.2511567473,
0.3087734878,
-0.3678202927,
0.6242883205,
-1.0217517614,
0.1593356431,
-0.2628184855,
0.6028701067,
-0.2675808072,
-0.4645760059,
0.0644384623,
-0.5067201853,
-0.3287156522,
-0.3646912277,
0.871584177,
-0.5740205646,
-0.3856683671,
0.5587653518,
0.1520306319,
-0.468675077,
0.1125221848,
-0.4901963174,
-0.3730548918,
-0.1154981926,
-0.4038529396,
0.4815094471,
-0.1616985053,
0.149207145,
0.8529859781,
0.4847066402,
0.0370685533,
0.2331992239,
0.0706069469,
0.9789305329,
-0.3681331575,
-0.4343657494,
-0.8598737121,
1.0321717262,
-0.0058513535,
-0.2307344079,
0.4753731191,
0.5175125599,
1.0868053436,
-0.1762441397,
0.7460157275,
-0.1999790221,
0.284083724,
-0.9274622202,
0.3939450085,
-0.3417133987,
0.0542344563,
-0.395527482,
-1.1353104115,
-0.4355095327,
0.7897311449,
-0.0884695426,
-0.0327823162,
1.1028877497,
0.7253815532,
-0.1112798452,
-0.5045243502,
0.4078484476,
0.178879872,
0.5090502501,
0.6127960682,
0.4223826528,
-0.5568320751,
0.3686434627,
-0.5314546824,
-0.2995708585,
0.0613291711,
-0.9712731838,
-1.0531805754,
-0.4314968884,
-0.0240374152,
-0.6021627784,
0.0113012176,
1.1381889582,
0.7977665067,
-0.9963663816,
-0.3829610348,
0.0297888145,
0.2765854895,
-0.3951265812,
-0.2999432087,
0.5732008815,
-0.8985942602,
-0.8005367517,
0.3557399809,
0.4289193153,
0.0646780357,
-0.5473473668,
-0.3216979802,
-0.2991230786,
-0.0632761866,
0.6353514791,
0.2369654477,
-0.4515661299,
-0.705270052,
-0.2625587583,
-0.1180805564,
0.2737487555,
0.902620554,
-0.8616042137,
0.423625499,
0.1954931915,
0.8808217645,
0.8489996195,
-0.0683156028,
0.4047876596,
-0.9595299959,
0.4814337194,
0.0729458258,
0.4573358893,
0.0328107178,
-0.4369012415,
0.7250561118,
0.2294234037,
-0.7555851936,
-0.5719998479,
0.1408737302,
-0.7545124292,
0.0082467068,
0.7016376257,
-0.0508704372,
0.0131794978,
0.1327898204,
-0.3348876536,
-0.0593863614,
-0.3967196643,
0.5498520732,
0.3884975314,
-0.2815935612,
-0.2409892231,
-0.7248209119,
0.6994780898,
0.0913366899,
-0.7049260139,
-0.4013175666,
0.153403461,
0.2491085231,
-0.0039168037,
0.6160293221,
0.1523095369,
0.1087182462,
-0.2230679095,
0.2178396583,
-0.0252329018,
-0.5718433857,
-0.4146875739,
0.2515453398,
-0.0819810405,
-0.3671737313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00791v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00791v1
|
$\textit{L+M-24}$: Building a Dataset for Language + Molecules @ ACL 2024
| 2024-02-22T20:11:24 | 2024-02-22T20:11:24 |
Carl Edwards, Qingyun Wang, Lawrence Zhao, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.BM, q-bio.QM
|
Language-molecule models have emerged as an exciting direction for molecular
discovery and understanding. However, training these models is challenging due
to the scarcity of molecule-language pair datasets. At this point, datasets
have been released which are 1) small and scraped from existing databases, 2)
large but noisy and constructed by performing entity linking on the scientific
literature, and 3) built by converting property prediction datasets to natural
language using templates. In this document, we detail the $\textit{L+M-24}$
dataset, which has been created for the Language + Molecules Workshop shared
task at ACL 2024. In particular, $\textit{L+M-24}$ is designed to focus on
three key benefits of natural language in molecule design: compositionality,
functionality, and abstraction.
|
[
-0.5294066668,
-0.436960578,
0.4469409585,
-0.2446671277,
-0.0642521083,
0.4773077965,
-0.190131247,
-0.756652832,
0.1186561286,
0.5421850681,
-0.6729139686,
-0.3313698173,
-0.4629562199,
0.1284528226,
-0.2765357494,
1.1113328934,
-0.1144738868,
0.3395870328,
-0.0359528512,
-0.0576570518,
-0.1642151773,
-0.4750615358,
-0.3539174199,
-0.1406014413,
0.8314065337,
0.2630853057,
0.642694056,
0.8862921,
0.5823864341,
0.198544696,
0.1949880421,
0.2125335187,
-0.3856832981,
-0.0593443103,
-0.0115014492,
-0.4062038064,
-0.7874357104,
0.4366205931,
0.5733361244,
0.9601447582,
0.0583441369,
0.0052282871,
-0.1797296852,
0.8475033045,
-0.3436873555,
0.323300302,
-0.5846920609,
0.231301114,
-0.5309144855,
0.1701470912,
-0.3537867963,
0.0649243221,
0.1726797223,
-0.6357604861,
0.3411956429,
0.3150025904,
0.8646458983,
-0.1917968839,
-0.5632041097,
-0.4389893711,
-0.503683269,
0.7550035119,
-0.6285435557,
0.7458648086,
0.2400999069,
0.3533991277,
-0.0951976031,
-0.3424335122,
-0.4030355215,
-0.5583629012,
0.0299486127,
-0.0646623373,
0.3119074702,
0.2599211633,
-0.0781211033,
0.5994207263,
-0.5038503408,
-0.0229031499,
-0.8959000111,
-0.310213238,
0.801240623,
0.2934519947,
0.0859258622,
-0.0948557258,
-0.0632073283,
0.120583728,
-0.957886219,
-0.4196951687,
0.4893833399,
0.5885031819,
-0.2324054241,
1.0832598209,
-0.0249642767,
0.9306074977,
-0.3788150847,
0.1676695943,
0.3679285049,
-0.8873086572,
0.0069216485,
0.0186796486,
0.7902465463,
0.2538944483,
0.4651219845,
-0.1351192147,
-0.2225302756,
-0.0182564389,
0.2749023139,
-1.0196961164,
-0.4224514663,
0.3768153489,
-0.1998420954,
-0.6041834354,
0.1045999378,
-0.7283887863,
-0.2573442459,
-0.6807730794,
0.1668499112,
-0.4640396237,
0.0846651196,
0.1971604675,
-0.2725293338,
-0.1166140363,
0.3893662989,
-0.9390794635,
0.5313031673,
0.6558692455,
0.6421880126,
-0.284239769,
-0.2668815851,
-0.5457704067,
0.2354254276,
-0.3440723419,
0.5319628716,
-0.7160725594,
-0.4522455931,
-0.2001443654,
-0.0586372279,
0.0742211267,
-0.6266773343,
0.2895704508,
-0.1315488964,
0.4930507243,
-0.1231196597,
-0.8569890857,
0.0975656956,
0.0819713846,
-0.8369307518,
0.6506741643,
0.230114907,
-0.4305017292,
0.3995445371,
-0.9486709833,
-0.3321110606,
0.0459691994,
-0.5038874745,
-0.4333782494,
-0.0354384184,
-0.0215232912,
0.4558660686,
-0.3276447058,
0.4607518017,
-0.5316475034,
-0.1203096062,
0.4227683246,
-0.1576858461,
0.4780430496,
0.3343642056,
0.0605711006,
0.0007864773,
-1.2414171696,
-0.333732307,
-0.1420901865,
-0.8251335025,
0.1941354275,
-0.0796593949,
0.2735389471,
0.1920900941,
0.4231780171,
-0.72889328,
0.3874420524,
-0.3304428756,
0.3473141491,
0.7866746187,
-0.1146237552,
0.7934519053,
-0.5186195374,
0.3939682841,
0.2706187963,
-0.1821732521,
0.0180126559,
-0.7443820238,
-0.8747639656,
-0.3026934266,
0.0614609011,
0.4243193865,
-0.476141274,
0.400270462,
-0.1497858316,
-0.611119926,
-0.6538552046,
0.4696785212,
0.4126104712,
0.2112338543,
0.4528958201,
-0.0017926801,
-0.7966583967,
-0.8628634214,
-0.2751050293,
0.075136058,
0.0484018363,
0.3662011325,
0.5178410411,
-0.4519976974,
0.697573781,
-0.6223544478,
-0.1854665428,
-0.3189022839,
-0.123997137,
0.3318334222,
0.5920037031,
0.3883618712,
-0.672830224,
-0.3237759471,
-0.0303603336,
-0.7278512716,
0.19059892,
0.1852509379,
-0.1884447783,
0.1362313181,
0.2700811327,
-0.8786053061,
0.2247434855,
0.5301252604,
-0.5061575174,
0.7366394401,
0.1582075506,
-0.0881126449,
-1.2203403711,
-0.0001346765,
0.2516172826,
-0.0261670742,
-0.7217922211,
-0.0592171624,
-0.1637828052,
-0.5822419524,
-0.4922285676,
0.6563376188,
-0.4104769826,
0.0471084863,
-0.0532522835,
-0.1093444526,
0.2637352943,
0.2199063897,
0.0199827403,
0.8739913702,
0.4890781939,
-0.629118979,
0.4576372802,
0.2940489352,
-0.1232443601,
0.4044634998,
-0.3199703395,
-0.1483565122,
-0.0299821738,
0.2145383507,
-0.3589507937,
-0.4360338449,
0.3342962265,
-0.3375158012,
0.4807529449,
0.1067909151,
-0.2299944609,
-0.2673259377,
-0.2921821475,
0.3351019323,
0.0062522036,
-0.1536789089,
0.492241025,
0.437492758,
0.1683788002,
-0.3247823417,
-0.721987009,
0.1368947774,
-0.2659565508,
-0.5476986766,
0.3651130795,
-0.4275735915,
-0.3259207904,
0.0382862538,
0.1749814153,
-0.0296844579,
-0.1233450472,
0.243847549,
0.2395289391,
-0.3092002571,
0.3154253662,
-0.3813173771,
-0.1516872346,
0.114099972,
-0.3723908365,
0.4781477153,
-0.3343681395,
-0.0953723267,
-0.2060270905,
0.4164092839,
0.6123627424,
-0.3168048263,
0.7625068426,
0.3811123371,
-0.461615622,
-0.0657127425,
-0.1600230634,
-0.3511150777,
-0.5051676631,
0.3794907928,
-0.5299240947,
-0.763795197,
0.3238621652,
0.3411588073,
-0.0092231845,
0.3462993801,
0.6198505163,
-0.2431463897,
0.6666463614,
0.5690504909,
-0.1428877562,
0.5451624393,
-0.4248693287,
0.2933816016,
-0.6978719831,
-0.5190043449,
-0.3889509141,
-0.1956264526,
-0.6761393547,
-0.4614137411,
0.0184447374,
-0.3023891747,
-0.2857575715,
0.8729470372,
-0.3548346162,
0.1936328858,
0.4825736284,
0.2067751884,
0.155702889,
-0.0207237881,
-0.2437204868,
-0.0961925834,
-0.4220999777,
-0.3597650528,
1.3941477537,
0.1904291362,
0.814648509,
-0.0078978231,
0.9103745222,
0.0951260254,
0.084483929,
-0.8800196052,
0.5846936107,
-0.1320865452,
-0.9800422788,
-0.1619303674,
-0.5917178392,
-0.8322638869,
-0.1095823869,
-0.3882937729,
-0.6549476981,
0.236894846,
0.0287528597,
0.0938706771,
0.1789880097,
-0.5759159327,
0.8244338036,
-0.2481599003,
-0.3572034836,
-0.1421634853,
-0.7938681841,
0.1915382743,
-0.2732616365,
0.4851107299,
-0.5279701352,
0.1890617758,
0.662948072,
-0.4643706381,
0.4250381589,
-0.0048858179,
-0.2791173458,
0.285443455,
0.2312053144,
0.3340615928,
0.0217490308,
-0.2787581384,
-0.4726403356,
-0.1539676487,
-0.4983238578,
-0.3457846344,
0.6256443262,
-0.7213737369,
-0.1803817898,
-0.2186422646,
-0.7625290751,
-0.1407107413,
0.2232384235,
0.2531444132,
0.7913682461,
-0.2247829735,
0.1591561884,
0.5046461821,
-0.1024873853,
0.2545481324,
0.5162647963,
-0.5375971794,
-0.4686809182,
1.3093705177,
0.3277271986,
0.3051993847,
0.7226330638,
0.0778278857,
-0.127916038,
-0.4989278615,
-0.2427119464,
0.0822245181,
-0.7169746757,
-0.0953581333,
-0.6055338979,
-0.5230198503,
-0.1022761837,
-0.1302699149,
-0.6026566029,
-0.7865361571,
-0.4664527476,
-0.548848927,
0.5381880999,
0.8065000176,
-0.2037338614,
0.0090881353,
-0.9103738666,
0.4958022237,
-0.0059867078,
0.3431138992,
-0.4809365273,
0.0075591817,
-0.6074828506,
0.2408367693,
-0.2716567218,
-0.6942635775,
0.1988789886,
0.7236124277,
0.4380505681,
0.149318248,
-0.3205584586,
0.2531104684,
-0.7288284898,
0.5809581876,
0.0008678191,
-0.6541165113,
0.5863128901,
-0.7158036232,
0.0508744195,
0.6364321113,
0.2525400221,
-0.3444932401,
-0.6047295928,
-0.8079679012,
-0.7648464441,
0.1872838885,
0.4582819343,
0.1318892092,
-0.0220939927,
0.1685426086,
0.1712017357,
0.5558916926,
-0.745568037,
-0.3804868758,
-0.2158103883,
-0.5268996954,
-0.2520655394,
0.0667816252,
-0.1369266063,
-0.5235435963,
0.670329392,
-0.0412235484,
0.5006873608,
-0.3552637994,
0.0504376628,
0.0755812377,
0.0959507152,
0.5323770046,
0.5514993072,
-0.7506930828,
0.3137319982,
-0.249451071,
-0.507029295,
0.3604729772,
0.2320309728,
0.3887152076,
-0.0319150127,
0.1903351396,
0.5785633326,
-0.0708594546,
-0.6935058832,
0.2164952904,
0.2636068761,
-0.1459723562,
-0.029618565,
0.1931474805,
0.3816169202,
-0.0261192229,
0.2777978778,
0.2870120704,
0.4380653501,
-0.6700310707,
0.646535337,
0.216966942,
-0.5455831885,
-0.4174626768,
0.5474143624,
0.3754452169,
-0.153539896,
0.5520030856,
-0.2419473827,
-0.3850785792,
0.562093854,
0.3136416972,
0.5288161635,
0.1209082901,
0.0294557549,
0.2822854221,
0.1805654168,
0.5227950811,
0.4591843486,
0.2138633579,
-0.9748912454,
-0.1329174638,
-0.6260564327,
-0.4444078505,
0.1445680559,
-0.5432093143,
0.3729828596,
-0.4588291049,
0.0368448086,
0.3476152718,
0.3218052089,
-0.8159321547,
0.5004097223,
0.1670516282,
0.8996258974,
-0.8011017442,
0.9637699723,
0.5252746344,
-0.3732040524,
-0.4874517024,
-0.4867395461,
0.3178019822,
-0.7327765226,
0.4742656946,
0.4076809883,
0.0327469781,
-0.0925658047,
-0.7870617509,
-0.776379168,
0.899548471,
0.3736605942,
-0.6074734926,
0.0283164158,
0.36623016,
0.3356930017,
-0.6980708241,
-0.4083284438,
0.7222057581,
0.484495014,
-0.0696412325,
-0.7030239105,
0.1054677367,
-0.599740386,
-0.3115675449,
0.3650176227,
-0.3887339532,
0.9785811901,
-0.1621606499,
0.1425461024,
0.1880123913,
0.5807337165,
0.7157474756,
0.0485448539,
-0.2060222477,
0.6556187868,
0.7309570312,
-0.1453202516,
0.9383807182,
-0.4273362756,
0.3734875917,
1.1718299389,
-0.2554754913,
0.8233811855,
0.767901957,
-0.4057234526,
0.206796065,
0.724209249,
-0.4375809729,
0.6209068298,
0.448394686,
-0.5370833278,
-0.1386878788,
-0.2764994502,
-0.4710719287,
0.3052454889,
0.8365328312,
-0.2810614109,
-0.215281114,
-0.0730008855,
0.0709021091,
-0.1479426473,
0.0612527579,
0.5456622243,
0.4176823199,
-0.2130840421,
0.2200035453,
-0.0846678987,
0.3881472945,
-0.3684486449,
-0.0496958718,
-0.0334666595,
0.3108407557,
-0.096989274,
-0.9247385263,
0.3701919615,
-0.3295485079,
-0.2274549156,
0.0050594364,
0.5479490757,
-0.679936409,
-0.7640938163,
0.3596793413,
0.4583590627,
0.1549597234,
0.1622787118,
-0.8073570132,
-0.0542611443,
-0.0185045358,
-0.1848853827,
0.255014956,
0.3943683207,
0.3298402727,
0.9163284898,
0.757356286,
-0.0337540172,
0.1676377207,
-0.1728105992,
1.1285021305,
-0.5835031271,
-0.0451416783,
-0.8374580741,
0.6801193953,
0.1154792905,
-0.2552273571,
0.5977202654,
1.079813838,
0.741101265,
-0.2015691549,
1.0177365541,
-0.0546198189,
0.3878314793,
-0.7075768709,
0.7041069865,
-0.3765459955,
0.2682455182,
-0.0397995412,
-1.0175753832,
-0.4098030627,
0.5346029997,
0.1045250222,
0.0963399112,
0.5833203197,
0.9152092338,
-0.1370864511,
-0.0784561634,
0.1220073998,
-0.0601832047,
0.7289153934,
0.6175820231,
0.7397833467,
-0.5104503036,
0.2509160638,
-0.3601572514,
0.373978287,
-0.2673946619,
-0.931881249,
-0.8953077793,
-0.5482832789,
-0.3016456664,
-0.4276348054,
0.1131887212,
1.0926725864,
0.8302179575,
-1.0835894346,
-0.6413145065,
-0.6510154009,
-0.0936024562,
0.4654842317,
-0.1835027337,
0.0642937347,
-0.1165416688,
-0.4198865294,
0.8379517198,
0.2714594603,
0.6370961666,
-0.3085704446,
-0.3732624054,
-0.3312578201,
0.0248842463,
0.2418973595,
0.1277891397,
-0.3829843998,
-0.1092530638,
-0.1190753505,
-0.1371134818,
0.4381126761,
0.6165462732,
-0.4977186322,
0.528763473,
0.3641174138,
0.3833505511,
0.7164450884,
-0.3286210597,
1.4406199455,
-0.9457879066,
0.3248126805,
0.2020695359,
0.5280104876,
0.5018776059,
-0.231020391,
0.6089084744,
0.3191129267,
-0.4439949393,
-0.6925444603,
0.4212862849,
-0.9748362899,
-0.1459928304,
0.9436754584,
0.1696296185,
-0.0577099659,
-0.0511394255,
-0.3077457845,
0.2292633951,
-0.6459532976,
0.2497812659,
0.7916074395,
-0.0767577887,
-0.2619675994,
-0.8610447049,
0.8565994501,
-0.1016657278,
-1.0035187006,
-0.0873514041,
0.4928210974,
0.1482457817,
0.2902932763,
0.2753579915,
0.0591870211,
-0.0016565782,
0.0070088091,
-0.0935745835,
-0.0746643916,
-0.7925772071,
0.0278557874,
-0.1877302229,
0.13576141,
-0.1595351845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14948v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14948v2
|
Re-Examine Distantly Supervised NER: A New Benchmark and a Simple Approach
| 2024-02-22T20:07:02 | 2024-02-26T14:59:58 |
Yuepei Li, Kang Zhou, Qiao Qiao, Qing Wang, Qi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper delves into Named Entity Recognition (NER) under the framework of
Distant Supervision (DS-NER), where the main challenge lies in the compromised
quality of labels due to inherent errors such as false positives, false
negatives, and positive type errors. We critically assess the efficacy of
current DS-NER methodologies using a real-world benchmark dataset named QTL,
revealing that their performance often does not meet expectations. To tackle
the prevalent issue of label noise, we introduce a simple yet effective
approach, Curriculum-based Positive-Unlabeled Learning CuPUL, which
strategically starts on "easy" and cleaner samples during the training process
to enhance model resilience to noisy samples. Our empirical results highlight
the capability of CuPUL to significantly reduce the impact of noisy labels and
outperform existing methods. QTL dataset and our code is available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.4012966454,
-0.4376944602,
0.2988565266,
-0.2930896282,
-0.0288417377,
0.0894412324,
-0.2436453104,
-0.7384896278,
0.0109471455,
0.3767898977,
-0.4621732235,
-0.5940572023,
-0.6431596279,
0.1136343032,
-0.548371315,
1.1775170565,
0.2099016309,
0.1077666283,
-0.1010848284,
-0.2011526376,
-0.1151161119,
-0.4887859523,
-1.2461469173,
-0.1051369682,
0.8470693231,
0.3490350246,
0.3374693096,
0.2168040723,
0.5780388713,
0.1120532006,
-0.3231472969,
0.3636747003,
-0.6528623104,
0.2147488892,
-0.2178469896,
-0.2712029219,
-0.4567003548,
-0.1251822859,
0.6568502784,
0.7696244717,
-0.1140365377,
0.2391216457,
0.121567145,
0.693549633,
-0.6904887557,
0.2880555391,
-0.5040525794,
-0.0145825399,
-0.3350709379,
0.4549058378,
-0.5639141798,
-0.5216204524,
0.2002087981,
-0.6713066101,
0.404004544,
0.132099241,
1.2427438498,
0.3666515648,
-0.4929772317,
-0.2311267257,
-0.8611645103,
0.9210158587,
-0.518999517,
0.6710804105,
0.6498020887,
0.6243531704,
-0.3290008307,
-0.7660210729,
-0.2200338095,
-0.0105850082,
0.1167138368,
0.1028524488,
-0.202226907,
-0.1906002015,
0.4616146088,
0.2149168551,
0.0420543812,
0.1890765429,
-0.4735040665,
-0.234266609,
0.4816703498,
-0.0726237744,
0.0293694325,
0.3356090188,
-0.2082226723,
-0.0698722154,
-0.8542639017,
-0.0310576279,
0.2766314447,
0.4787357152,
0.0163737759,
0.2547517717,
-0.5640756488,
0.5060415864,
0.3279869556,
-0.2919682264,
0.2630111575,
-0.0997379124,
-0.0234692842,
0.4053308368,
0.4680501223,
0.1799103618,
0.0961177424,
-0.6071668863,
-0.2553943694,
0.0782902986,
0.1961026937,
-0.8737732768,
-0.7184232473,
0.0255462285,
-0.1757303029,
-0.1536579728,
0.0106165707,
-0.8523212075,
-0.4114890397,
-0.5423057675,
0.3655027449,
-0.4627528191,
-0.3597985208,
-0.1278674006,
0.2315523475,
0.0880252123,
0.5590949059,
-0.5934745669,
0.4110356867,
0.6889708638,
0.538625896,
-0.0597896278,
-0.003102561,
-0.9206866026,
0.161459744,
-0.0905037299,
0.8433197737,
-0.2772164941,
-0.292882055,
-0.3792141974,
0.1084388047,
0.0255367998,
-0.7120401263,
0.5287005305,
-0.7123720646,
0.1404232681,
-0.4547722638,
-0.6468644738,
-0.1675817966,
0.1450569779,
-0.7341251373,
0.9067543745,
0.2278277427,
-0.9698601365,
0.7865560651,
-0.25588727,
-0.3296011984,
-0.09170302,
-0.1642072648,
-1.1511082649,
-0.1224135533,
0.2807851434,
0.2010666281,
-0.1889044642,
0.5770882368,
-0.3513402045,
-0.4321617782,
0.0391999893,
-0.329995364,
0.8821748495,
0.091197893,
-0.4033052027,
-0.1412453055,
-1.1002708673,
0.1195624322,
-0.1797109097,
0.0237645451,
-0.6353802085,
-0.0930361971,
-0.2601396143,
0.0818145275,
-0.1804467589,
-0.5741510987,
0.0843213722,
-0.1750234663,
0.1744335145,
0.3546645045,
0.1125137806,
0.3264016509,
-0.4037429392,
0.2548967302,
0.3095127046,
0.0977271795,
0.3000040054,
-0.3385499716,
-0.8640212417,
-0.5472456217,
0.6378964782,
0.0316338278,
-0.6831788421,
-0.0218620915,
-0.1615436673,
-0.6567365527,
-0.5365875959,
-0.0102369338,
0.403554529,
0.8371471763,
0.6890909672,
-0.2737874091,
-0.7888805866,
-0.7935388088,
0.0839176998,
-0.1660251766,
0.1051416993,
0.1595589966,
0.469589144,
-0.4460957348,
0.8709360361,
-0.2839873135,
-0.3517135084,
0.1548731476,
0.2600834966,
0.1097863466,
0.4376517534,
0.2583668828,
-0.8415800333,
-0.330763042,
-0.2966855168,
-0.7285444736,
-0.0517031476,
0.0165677574,
-0.0807700157,
0.0986103192,
0.6343162656,
-0.3357551396,
0.3642344475,
0.298288703,
0.0243524276,
0.9270093441,
0.142466262,
0.015503834,
-0.9630786777,
0.0297112707,
-0.0312785171,
0.041540537,
-0.461179167,
-0.1504353434,
0.259365797,
0.1519827098,
-0.5891980529,
0.4254767001,
-0.9904072285,
0.0281953961,
-0.0780994594,
0.0146141052,
0.0867890194,
0.0790497139,
0.1011707112,
0.7909030318,
0.7116984129,
-0.7967033982,
0.0283218957,
0.2109128982,
-0.3538465202,
1.0041284561,
-0.425529182,
-0.1133326665,
-0.323348999,
0.1724380404,
-0.6054528952,
-0.1951473951,
0.2865087092,
-0.1471796185,
0.7511518598,
-0.2573264539,
-0.376255542,
-0.2250399292,
0.0204611477,
0.5750212073,
0.4379890263,
-0.8640418649,
0.1052457243,
0.461889863,
0.3031029999,
-0.386615634,
-0.5959580541,
0.1642571688,
-0.3856140375,
-0.0470008366,
0.4071646929,
0.1970854253,
-0.2970683575,
0.0734651387,
-0.4076710343,
-0.4878233373,
0.0100312652,
0.5952856541,
0.0713083148,
-0.3773669302,
0.2569224834,
-0.0406663157,
-0.2155069113,
0.15790084,
-0.0610730574,
-0.1056387499,
-0.1979808658,
-0.2213744223,
-0.5702165365,
-0.1050328985,
0.1337839216,
-0.077320382,
0.6725593209,
0.6054699421,
-0.5587853789,
-0.2126889527,
-0.6335835457,
-0.2506556809,
-0.4174673855,
0.1220190972,
-0.4562083185,
-0.8634223342,
0.2233877629,
-0.3595715463,
-0.2508669794,
0.2248321325,
-0.0450987406,
-0.1313728392,
0.3119108975,
0.5925359726,
-0.1077192351,
0.2828357816,
-0.1548947692,
0.3502688706,
-1.1057460308,
-0.3151666224,
-0.4364134073,
0.0542311519,
-0.6045817733,
-0.3266926408,
0.0051013008,
0.4433245063,
-0.4247368872,
0.8072740436,
-0.5621645451,
0.3700760007,
0.5838302374,
0.1603482664,
0.4223154783,
0.00035224,
0.049351383,
-0.4109994173,
-0.5680167675,
-0.4654893577,
0.9676172137,
0.0965178534,
0.7243779302,
0.2359560281,
1.2832809687,
0.1104485989,
0.7425882816,
-0.502165556,
0.5043393373,
0.1355102956,
-0.639942646,
-0.2740603685,
-0.4901759624,
-1.1583898067,
0.0116327265,
-0.1604683101,
-1.0629096031,
0.3813141286,
-0.0906444341,
-0.4358031452,
0.5544096231,
-0.6256657243,
0.5854544044,
-0.0355608016,
-0.6125759482,
0.3881323934,
-0.711360991,
0.5388506651,
-0.3604120016,
0.2046712935,
-0.1024948359,
0.1733495593,
0.6723641753,
-0.1978521794,
0.9211497307,
-0.0623762049,
-0.147399202,
0.5306084752,
0.0776908547,
0.4318437278,
0.171756506,
-0.2956987321,
0.429341048,
-0.0664179996,
-0.362592876,
-0.3280160129,
0.8023164272,
-0.7444137931,
-0.3733183742,
-0.472104758,
-0.1910246909,
-0.1128412709,
0.4917141795,
0.2213810384,
0.4516994357,
-0.2735078633,
0.0682259202,
0.8134753108,
-0.2047350258,
0.3149858713,
0.3916175365,
-0.1921350211,
-0.5784984231,
1.0764667988,
0.390417695,
0.1427433491,
0.4222526252,
-0.2676200569,
-0.2183538377,
-0.4971219599,
-0.2049222291,
0.2722645998,
-0.4712901115,
-0.3910115957,
-0.8169400096,
-0.3538703322,
-0.2195080519,
-0.0279418305,
-0.7120127082,
-0.1885596961,
-0.5699955821,
0.0371213853,
0.1696056128,
0.6872524023,
-0.0118164737,
0.1195764989,
-0.6042540073,
0.2995109856,
0.1778833121,
0.3979231119,
-0.0201313812,
-0.412925899,
-0.1099127233,
0.1417993456,
-0.1738772094,
-0.7738970518,
0.3167544901,
0.2232882679,
0.497549057,
0.3086421192,
0.5580082536,
0.7860432267,
-0.2133007646,
0.3516277373,
0.0596936196,
-0.5530162454,
0.5066835284,
-0.2420460731,
0.1620493531,
0.8934416175,
0.5170328617,
-0.157795161,
-0.3905441165,
-0.9003292918,
-0.9978747964,
0.3735382259,
0.2333552539,
-0.4878441691,
-0.1967367232,
0.3025420904,
0.2366557568,
0.2333637923,
-0.6026201844,
-0.345209837,
0.0661751628,
0.160416469,
0.0432165451,
-0.2373434752,
0.2140703499,
-0.152474612,
0.961733222,
0.1316877306,
0.1501559615,
0.3273264766,
-0.0630912408,
0.1080480516,
0.4110632539,
0.2027001977,
0.2868154645,
-0.3717114627,
0.2967915535,
0.1919628233,
-0.3198275566,
0.1962042004,
0.1592026204,
-0.5009155869,
0.0485806577,
0.0735513195,
0.3816121221,
0.3560900092,
-0.253392756,
0.3049743772,
-0.2066306621,
-0.1166208014,
-0.4302387834,
0.1007341817,
0.171903953,
0.2008350939,
0.1258835495,
0.0909147188,
0.2570531368,
-0.1076867729,
0.6287043691,
0.2032864243,
-0.8188585043,
-0.2463580668,
0.9380812645,
-0.0389654525,
-0.1447903961,
0.8545834422,
-0.7599457502,
-0.2038542777,
0.7199815512,
0.5779179335,
0.6827078462,
0.1436717361,
0.2745690048,
0.8119986653,
0.1601868421,
-0.4596159756,
-0.2007596195,
-0.1006117687,
-0.5825849771,
-0.35086146,
-0.4584198296,
-0.690982461,
0.10595797,
-1.0469326973,
0.3945906758,
-0.382214576,
-0.3436064422,
0.1935606748,
-0.010509477,
-0.4615567625,
0.447183609,
0.1210064217,
0.4903264642,
-0.5688439608,
1.0192219019,
0.7322574258,
-0.5043179989,
-0.8276228309,
0.0707081333,
0.2455994189,
-0.2057593167,
0.9527894855,
0.4490606487,
-0.2288932204,
0.2155096829,
-0.3071937263,
-0.9981456399,
1.0774388313,
0.021094691,
-1.0410659313,
0.1465973705,
-0.2024435103,
0.6946286559,
-0.0442989394,
0.2406391799,
0.3405267,
0.2253433615,
-0.0026326261,
-0.5975456238,
0.0737768933,
-0.0608428791,
-0.2851960957,
0.5309638977,
-0.8566201329,
0.5355390906,
-0.6108817458,
-0.5331123471,
0.1148851514,
0.8533606529,
0.1685163379,
0.7076823711,
0.232536003,
0.6587913632,
1.0868641138,
-0.2689780593,
0.6056314111,
-0.0977535322,
0.51601547,
1.8296962976,
-0.5445813537,
0.7128537297,
0.6285937428,
-0.3937296271,
0.2639075518,
0.6048858166,
-0.3552789688,
0.6370393634,
0.4529260993,
-0.5116336346,
-0.1352491528,
-0.3580313921,
-0.4770506322,
0.0847861916,
0.2869723439,
-0.0056324969,
-0.5003712177,
-0.0629009455,
-0.0480613373,
0.1073575765,
-0.2122483253,
0.6365119815,
0.245260492,
-0.2609148324,
0.3649528027,
-0.3963713944,
0.8083916306,
-0.0252890475,
-0.1300228685,
-0.1105413735,
0.3016014099,
-0.3113482893,
-0.341845721,
0.4118560255,
-0.2369665653,
-0.1168350428,
0.0838920027,
0.7224660516,
-0.4268482029,
-0.5072743893,
0.3503336906,
0.5114861131,
0.3616025448,
-0.0192957222,
-0.4738628268,
-0.2006710917,
-0.0704220161,
0.0780351385,
0.4904749691,
0.6047136188,
-0.1927441061,
0.7735073566,
0.5199360251,
0.0778424218,
-0.1139886305,
0.1848158091,
0.7289142609,
-0.6958102584,
-0.0212559011,
-0.585863471,
0.1528956741,
-0.1456929594,
-0.3148791194,
0.8348469734,
0.6965680718,
1.2650188208,
0.1809476912,
0.4469473958,
0.0253955349,
0.7258560061,
-0.0978227779,
0.6444944143,
-0.3393723071,
0.522213161,
-0.5194940567,
-0.8180644512,
-0.6788333654,
0.433339715,
-0.5617395639,
-0.0534032546,
0.6466326714,
0.8640288711,
-0.1545286775,
0.1444417685,
0.4993706942,
0.0748265907,
0.2257838845,
0.5573135614,
1.0128483772,
-0.8634165525,
0.4107366204,
-0.621414423,
0.2614088356,
-0.0951641425,
-0.8902005553,
-0.857788384,
-0.2462994605,
-1.1463711262,
-0.544334352,
0.6053711176,
0.5636631846,
0.662001431,
-1.0207756758,
0.2853345871,
-0.2278071046,
0.2075168937,
-0.3483932614,
-0.2255253941,
0.5995231867,
-0.1838293225,
-0.6526021957,
0.208981663,
0.0391784087,
0.1932311952,
0.2367917746,
0.027484471,
-0.0944685191,
-0.5704367757,
0.450699091,
0.4921429157,
-0.5118347406,
-0.2701909542,
-0.3114310503,
-0.480836302,
0.1365656853,
0.2793183923,
-0.7518707514,
0.4661808014,
-0.1749664694,
0.8118997216,
0.5515134931,
0.0830207393,
0.0541806258,
-0.4328711331,
-0.1483950615,
0.1578878164,
0.2058104277,
0.4197380543,
-0.4423131645,
0.7569246888,
0.1087692976,
-0.6659335494,
-0.8437740803,
0.103606075,
-1.0333515406,
0.0245838538,
1.18009758,
-0.3557652533,
-0.2359286845,
-0.4937960505,
-0.2453345358,
0.5314798951,
-0.5240736008,
0.9413466454,
0.487460047,
-0.1142408028,
-0.1828058213,
-0.5155580044,
0.4232136905,
0.3219215274,
-0.5817504525,
-0.1440183073,
0.6257770061,
0.5382874012,
0.0012926843,
0.4643966556,
-0.2095451951,
0.0985956639,
0.3233793974,
0.1669158489,
-0.0577318557,
-0.4183198214,
-0.1525093764,
0.1608058065,
0.2175592929,
-0.1632025242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14818v2
|
PALO: A Polyglot Large Multimodal Model for 5B People
| 2024-02-22T18:59:58 | 2024-03-05T11:22:07 |
Muhammad Maaz, Hanoona Rasheed, Abdelrahman Shaker, Salman Khan, Hisham Cholakal, Rao M. Anwer, Tim Baldwin, Michael Felsberg, Fahad S. Khan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In pursuit of more inclusive Vision-Language Models (VLMs), this study
introduces a Large Multilingual Multimodal Model called PALO. PALO offers
visual reasoning capabilities in 10 major languages, including English,
Chinese, Hindi, Spanish, French, Arabic, Bengali, Russian, Urdu, and Japanese,
that span a total of ~5B people (65% of the world population). Our approach
involves a semi-automated translation approach to adapt the multimodal
instruction dataset from English to the target languages using a fine-tuned
Large Language Model, thereby ensuring high linguistic fidelity while allowing
scalability due to minimal manual effort. The incorporation of diverse
instruction sets helps us boost overall performance across multiple languages
especially those that are underrepresented like Hindi, Arabic, Bengali, and
Urdu. The resulting models are trained across three scales (1.7B, 7B and 13B
parameters) to show the generalization and scalability where we observe
substantial improvements compared to strong baselines. We also propose the
first multilingual multimodal benchmark for the forthcoming approaches to
evaluate their vision-language reasoning capabilities across languages. Code:
https://github.com/mbzuai-oryx/PALO.
|
[
-0.3096970022,
-0.7571539283,
0.3845109046,
0.4664229453,
-0.2725225985,
0.1031250283,
-0.1489302814,
-0.6217452288,
-0.0279706791,
0.4444797337,
-0.2182451487,
-0.6844215393,
-0.4337445498,
0.0251181293,
-0.3520684838,
0.8082318902,
0.0974317193,
0.2427905053,
-0.0761209801,
-0.1814935207,
-0.363814503,
-0.368549943,
-0.35046193,
0.0834822059,
0.5952298641,
0.4103844464,
0.8811606765,
0.2759473622,
0.6511197686,
0.2388581038,
-0.1188088357,
0.5381397605,
-0.3218199611,
-0.2544680238,
-0.3958445191,
-0.5601085424,
-0.5050750375,
-0.3853464425,
0.9406247139,
0.6875011921,
-0.4158668518,
0.3975958228,
-0.3268530071,
0.7562066317,
-0.788848877,
0.3366182148,
-0.5552500486,
0.0529782958,
-0.3981373012,
0.4594844282,
-0.6531932354,
-0.2940717936,
0.0551023111,
-0.7071436048,
0.0432907529,
0.386484772,
0.7047392726,
0.1736244559,
-0.6043836474,
0.2549968958,
-0.6506387591,
0.9602038264,
-0.3834249079,
0.4764734805,
0.3297859132,
0.7180609703,
0.0163016822,
-0.4968886375,
-0.8993201852,
-0.1422275454,
-0.0062410762,
0.2449888289,
-0.0123469681,
-0.0562551916,
0.3037984371,
0.2860135436,
-0.650606513,
-0.1661377847,
-0.8029118776,
-0.0454368815,
0.8068031669,
0.166945979,
0.3049772382,
-0.2062252611,
-0.4277637601,
-0.1731719226,
-0.5051463842,
0.2227541059,
0.1281044334,
0.0265318546,
-0.3255272508,
0.6439635754,
-0.1004634053,
1.1873646975,
-0.4062480927,
-0.57690382,
0.5197416544,
-0.4437079132,
-0.4099931717,
-0.2488938868,
0.7632975578,
0.3539590538,
0.4028684497,
0.2374230474,
0.0587379746,
0.0607606545,
0.1558690816,
-0.3450734615,
-0.0539376698,
-0.0569767132,
-0.5780110955,
-0.0204819981,
0.0004841246,
-0.8313272595,
-0.5931407809,
-0.1388447732,
0.326262325,
-0.5341508985,
-0.2491926849,
0.4225098789,
-0.0518345945,
0.4185466468,
0.7444700599,
-0.9647873044,
-0.0027749958,
0.2628639042,
0.5137474537,
-0.1104139686,
-0.6174317598,
-0.2079771757,
0.5160377026,
-0.4843952358,
0.6140102744,
-0.6966869235,
-0.5519047379,
-0.2746759057,
-0.0471491925,
-0.3182452023,
-0.280713886,
0.3761967123,
-0.2750671506,
0.465669781,
-0.1763644069,
0.2563206255,
-0.8233425617,
0.4691500366,
-0.5602369905,
0.9946114421,
0.1009143814,
-0.4842049181,
0.2808490396,
-0.5235722661,
-0.4586021006,
0.0109088905,
-0.1549276561,
-0.3748904467,
0.1882824898,
0.6446762681,
0.3728768826,
-0.6601566076,
0.2632042766,
-0.3120320141,
-0.254853934,
0.1089909002,
-0.4331558645,
0.7089102864,
0.2067146152,
-0.0957287475,
0.3225623071,
-0.9527176619,
-0.1486995071,
0.091183424,
-0.1367432624,
-0.199584946,
0.1276915818,
0.2260311246,
0.3102937639,
0.4084693789,
-0.6141605377,
0.2901571393,
-0.2539105415,
0.0044903802,
0.7291261554,
-0.3623137772,
0.0862492248,
-0.0475488082,
0.6315715909,
0.2200674862,
0.6838934422,
-0.4201591313,
-0.786324501,
-0.7940241098,
-0.7029197812,
0.0931240767,
0.6182877421,
-1.0589629412,
-0.2997448742,
-0.2904418409,
-0.5534660816,
-0.802772522,
0.2601155639,
0.6171078682,
0.33307603,
0.46940431,
-0.3104052544,
-0.244086504,
-1.1661250591,
0.1225423887,
-0.2775747478,
0.2364381403,
0.1984435618,
0.5273579359,
-0.2791392803,
0.657556057,
-0.4540029168,
-0.3964127004,
-0.443408072,
0.0068504163,
0.2851195633,
0.1215816438,
0.7392433882,
-1.2040420771,
-0.7861185074,
0.5225034356,
-0.8896172047,
0.0973904878,
0.1113959029,
0.113948606,
0.2494803965,
0.2051196545,
-0.2370397449,
0.4259500206,
0.9122475982,
-0.2185394168,
0.5168545246,
-0.4383742809,
0.2640450001,
-1.1827895641,
-0.0020583037,
0.0313214809,
-0.2990170121,
-0.2390577048,
0.2129416615,
0.1959339678,
-0.3103148639,
-0.7147504687,
0.5338258147,
-0.6458189487,
-0.1774573326,
0.0442172252,
-0.0734270364,
0.0404858552,
0.4298958182,
0.1288517416,
0.764785111,
0.9387766123,
-0.3383321464,
0.8046429157,
0.0437237248,
-0.5384201407,
0.7837574482,
-0.7744526863,
-0.2862195373,
-0.4686207175,
0.2857423425,
-1.1284160614,
-0.4962758124,
0.0347599909,
-0.3138933182,
-0.0391136855,
0.0752940774,
-0.686655879,
-0.5390711427,
-0.3256005049,
0.4442692399,
0.5377134681,
-0.5059460402,
0.8976974487,
0.4546180367,
-0.0044149584,
-0.6234245896,
-0.561199069,
0.1106801555,
-0.1533574313,
-0.9877924919,
0.0862732902,
0.1292479038,
-0.1914574206,
-0.2179251164,
0.4382380247,
-0.022764409,
-0.1834653318,
0.1552211791,
0.4794997275,
-0.1325397342,
0.1643815488,
0.094583042,
-0.1709280908,
-0.3479525149,
-0.1284867972,
0.3166578114,
-0.4262432456,
-0.7250161767,
-0.3454976082,
0.3787268698,
1.0006400347,
-0.9113716483,
1.1541491747,
0.9743064642,
-0.1271690279,
0.0081919953,
-0.6556431651,
0.4002081454,
-0.3557108939,
0.4877512455,
-0.6327315569,
-0.6516039968,
0.5529701114,
-0.0278257374,
0.1229471192,
0.3486828208,
0.7904771566,
-0.0729598105,
1.4149581194,
0.8713237047,
0.017200252,
0.3579338789,
-0.0149050942,
0.1724653244,
-0.7389144897,
-0.6032557487,
-0.1984905899,
-0.3115349114,
-0.47239241,
-0.8865346313,
1.000161171,
-0.2264759243,
0.0794897303,
0.1010483876,
-0.366187036,
0.5352273583,
0.6302221417,
0.0171842705,
0.3475394547,
0.0151568605,
-0.2127377689,
0.009892717,
-0.6174328923,
-0.3334077001,
1.0412065983,
0.2785080075,
1.0087126493,
0.5907163024,
0.1402050704,
0.2243603766,
0.0578742214,
-0.379634738,
0.6808805466,
-0.3882708251,
-0.8677576184,
-0.1753453761,
-0.2527170777,
-0.8249242902,
0.7867217064,
-0.3566973507,
-0.8916299939,
0.1763732582,
0.1986799538,
-0.2998766899,
0.214790687,
-1.0947519541,
1.0460942984,
-0.4528708458,
-0.4515687227,
-0.6110468507,
-0.9543864727,
0.5844098926,
-0.2488891035,
0.5439898968,
-0.2626056671,
0.0601888783,
0.2757037878,
0.0420035683,
0.8747442365,
-0.0645615086,
0.0380672775,
0.2650644779,
-0.156766206,
0.1824263185,
-0.1293950677,
-0.1389723122,
0.3117051721,
0.1614686847,
-0.7543506026,
-0.5267458558,
0.3679180443,
-0.894079566,
-0.5001574755,
-0.5275435448,
-0.7836531401,
-0.069033213,
0.1223874316,
-0.1857075989,
0.1465391368,
-0.0565283857,
0.4344552457,
0.5639191866,
-0.5696418881,
0.2157712281,
0.7263249755,
-1.0122755766,
-0.4719629288,
1.1187860966,
0.0336446688,
0.4970480204,
0.4069431126,
0.182635054,
-0.1894804239,
-0.4013624489,
-0.9794954062,
0.3777820766,
-0.5047470331,
0.2972165942,
-0.3603996336,
-0.0148096317,
-0.3761477172,
-0.1314578354,
-0.324883461,
-0.2618037164,
0.2702407837,
0.1735670716,
0.0838841796,
0.6742641926,
0.2306646258,
0.44925493,
-0.8584487438,
0.630063355,
0.4106805623,
-0.0177043527,
-0.1636006832,
-0.4617544413,
-0.2942279577,
0.0503803156,
-0.2634583116,
-0.8194175363,
0.4046764076,
0.2432046682,
0.5966696739,
0.3721917868,
-0.3702855408,
0.8210269809,
-0.4594590962,
0.9548422098,
0.4526364207,
-0.841268599,
0.6394198537,
-0.4861354232,
0.4339762926,
0.2343707085,
0.3982127309,
-0.6375629306,
-0.091257222,
-0.2572751939,
-0.6656885743,
0.6776698828,
-0.0443657488,
0.1200478077,
0.1414487064,
-0.2111230046,
0.1808968186,
0.275616765,
-0.9623785615,
0.1131130084,
-0.0743894652,
-0.3693867624,
-0.1481640637,
-0.1718397886,
0.0279561728,
-0.6214793921,
0.5673488975,
-0.1969934106,
-0.0613308735,
-0.17458269,
-0.0909042805,
0.1499008387,
0.1780976057,
0.6806866527,
0.9117062688,
-0.0362591669,
-0.0014435026,
0.3501293361,
-0.4029597938,
-0.0042271158,
0.0642858669,
-0.2032541782,
-0.1774289608,
0.3334116936,
0.9666547179,
-0.0492460057,
-0.9693177342,
0.5484078526,
-0.0812794268,
0.2006698102,
-0.3101383746,
0.1566374153,
-0.031214999,
0.2266143262,
0.1885442734,
-0.0209262799,
-0.1521220505,
-0.7463851571,
-0.389266938,
0.3605103791,
-0.2452519387,
-0.292294383,
0.7018625736,
0.3183509409,
0.0700665191,
0.5137412548,
-0.0607437827,
-0.4320805967,
0.2875169218,
0.5380458236,
0.3185955584,
-0.4460253716,
0.3661280274,
0.3873173296,
0.6173615456,
-0.103803888,
0.432189256,
-0.0256493296,
-0.66014117,
-0.433442384,
-0.8559599519,
-0.5477184653,
-0.4868423641,
-0.4182828367,
0.5256878138,
-0.3632359207,
-0.0369867384,
0.032998167,
-0.5337423682,
-0.3392600119,
0.3582906425,
0.4849621356,
0.6424097419,
-0.9554165006,
1.052918911,
1.1517580748,
-0.6666735411,
-0.5379431844,
-0.3959651291,
0.1474825591,
-1.1182967424,
0.6237516403,
0.0314769819,
-0.3825071454,
-0.1627185643,
-0.4906519055,
-0.8737145066,
0.9557481408,
0.5944622159,
-0.496319145,
-0.0331801064,
0.2033052891,
0.7040315866,
-0.1990160793,
0.2356818765,
0.2250669003,
0.5296112895,
0.3587325513,
-1.3933947086,
-0.5876191854,
-0.353816241,
0.2594121397,
0.3571434021,
-1.0290763378,
0.9730254412,
-0.47681126,
0.1760588884,
-0.1126554087,
0.6973404884,
0.255636692,
0.3150061369,
0.3573074043,
0.6279126406,
0.6681868434,
0.0150506897,
1.3180903196,
-0.0443501472,
0.2375611812,
0.7282374501,
-0.3489665985,
0.7775927782,
0.4704074562,
-0.4649780393,
0.5969977379,
0.4873390794,
0.0045218505,
0.4401430488,
-0.0449271016,
-0.4521528482,
-0.3801746368,
-0.3988865316,
-0.4244124591,
0.8138770461,
0.5407648683,
-0.4801131785,
-0.0547221377,
0.3281129301,
-0.0460715778,
0.0944033116,
-0.4225620031,
0.5162106752,
-0.0270226728,
-0.7210274935,
0.54776752,
0.3217582703,
0.3425675929,
-0.8456536531,
-0.0502779447,
0.0343079492,
0.498261869,
-0.2216283977,
-0.9401366115,
0.2604394257,
0.1026651636,
-0.2646109462,
-0.2444007695,
0.5233578086,
-0.4807409942,
-1.1089957952,
0.1888632029,
0.4014470875,
0.27000314,
0.1134056672,
-0.6636073589,
0.1264089048,
0.2889900208,
0.0243848264,
0.1845632643,
0.3524802327,
-0.6499177217,
0.8660424352,
0.8080348372,
0.1551244408,
0.3770494759,
0.2159301192,
0.6155781746,
-0.509576261,
-0.3201968968,
-0.8056511879,
0.7595142126,
-0.1761254817,
-0.4847600162,
0.9199431539,
0.5308651328,
0.8569640517,
-0.2224159986,
0.5929151773,
-0.1265179068,
0.4873789847,
-0.3612554371,
0.4511026144,
-0.8564089537,
0.0025441458,
-0.3116188645,
-0.9507197142,
-0.4677987993,
0.8336815238,
-0.5490723848,
-0.0016358801,
0.6220821738,
0.7100011706,
-0.1806180328,
-0.1067653149,
0.6508054733,
0.1151761711,
0.362586081,
0.7173243761,
0.7301627994,
-0.1423381269,
0.4772748053,
-0.0618943051,
-0.4258158803,
-0.0974678174,
-0.6565396786,
-0.9331989884,
-0.40931952,
-0.0580901168,
0.0308629479,
0.0600912124,
0.6553589106,
0.6262545586,
-0.5695647597,
-0.3513565958,
0.4055324793,
0.255104363,
-0.2776463032,
-0.0978543311,
0.2233059853,
0.0529599339,
-0.85873276,
0.2435325235,
0.6923308969,
-0.1505120695,
-0.7046060562,
0.0275649484,
-0.3255246282,
-0.0315161571,
1.0180734396,
0.0819848999,
-0.9221789241,
-0.1073948592,
0.0409865417,
-0.1332516372,
-0.1399912834,
0.0958647057,
-0.6589676738,
1.1509801149,
0.4850678742,
0.4206386209,
0.7886896133,
0.0021538057,
0.5836756229,
-0.5008193851,
0.5451562405,
-0.0333810747,
0.5051468611,
0.4998402596,
0.0947840586,
0.6557590961,
0.4785886109,
-0.2164486945,
-0.6235064268,
0.2907067835,
-1.1116724014,
-0.0666413978,
1.0740045309,
-0.2371779829,
-0.4209384918,
0.0296766013,
-0.726786077,
-0.1579718739,
-0.0748961717,
0.8527466059,
0.8483499885,
-0.051416032,
-0.5000537634,
-0.5868861675,
-0.1705104262,
0.4472894073,
-0.9630177021,
-0.3150664568,
0.7169643641,
-0.1040931046,
0.3158375621,
0.4860003293,
-0.3082840145,
0.6205411553,
-0.0095034223,
0.4117247164,
-0.0444814116,
-0.6261606216,
0.0680574775,
0.2532547414,
0.0517581217,
-0.3330283761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14811v1
|
Fine-Tuning Enhances Existing Mechanisms: A Case Study on Entity Tracking
| 2024-02-22T18:59:24 | 2024-02-22T18:59:24 |
Nikhil Prakash, Tamar Rott Shaham, Tal Haklay, Yonatan Belinkov, David Bau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning on generalized tasks such as instruction following, code
generation, and mathematics has been shown to enhance language models'
performance on a range of tasks. Nevertheless, explanations of how such
fine-tuning influences the internal computations in these models remain
elusive. We study how fine-tuning affects the internal mechanisms implemented
in language models. As a case study, we explore the property of entity
tracking, a crucial facet of language comprehension, where models fine-tuned on
mathematics have substantial performance gains. We identify the mechanism that
enables entity tracking and show that (i) in both the original model and its
fine-tuned versions primarily the same circuit implements entity tracking. In
fact, the entity tracking circuit of the original model on the fine-tuned
versions performs better than the full original model. (ii) The circuits of all
the models implement roughly the same functionality: Entity tracking is
performed by tracking the position of the correct entity in both the original
model and its fine-tuned versions. (iii) Performance boost in the fine-tuned
models is primarily attributed to its improved ability to handle the augmented
positional information. To uncover these findings, we employ: Patch Patching,
DCM, which automatically detects model components responsible for specific
semantics, and CMAP, a new approach for patching activations across models to
reveal improved mechanisms. Our findings suggest that fine-tuning enhances,
rather than fundamentally alters, the mechanistic operation of the model.
|
[
-0.5795993209,
-1.0633809566,
0.6773924232,
-0.2143642902,
-0.2620927691,
0.0492433235,
-0.3366299272,
-0.6570831537,
0.1196751297,
0.6634272337,
-0.6022543311,
-0.3308643699,
-0.3973753154,
-0.1351374537,
-0.2218923718,
1.0788161755,
-0.0830451772,
-0.0254651047,
-0.0980135575,
-0.1617010683,
-0.5621236563,
-0.3634866178,
-0.6424088478,
-0.5668324232,
0.4327028096,
0.3595053852,
0.7597105503,
0.972022593,
0.6857534647,
0.3270215094,
-0.1682654321,
0.2607156336,
-0.3834168911,
0.1203734875,
-0.4238374233,
-0.9190741181,
-0.5131554604,
-0.2765807509,
0.7216325402,
0.8048491478,
-0.1641000509,
0.2301229089,
0.2011190802,
0.7213474512,
-0.810781002,
0.1760247648,
-0.8697861433,
-0.573305428,
-0.4518737793,
-0.542057991,
-0.1249183491,
0.0115892496,
-0.0704956427,
-0.5791205168,
0.4161675274,
0.0291174017,
0.9179745913,
0.5237131715,
-0.3150562048,
-0.4545683265,
-0.7224876881,
0.6115635037,
-0.5953019261,
0.3075712621,
0.3944611251,
-0.0120286839,
-0.2100465447,
-0.5148760676,
-0.3713563383,
-0.2316303402,
-0.0711195394,
-0.3987632394,
-0.0994413272,
0.3338325918,
0.5456768274,
0.5522786975,
-0.0159617867,
0.3901140392,
-0.3043412268,
-0.1708534062,
0.327917248,
0.2227708399,
0.543292582,
-0.0330950841,
0.069246538,
0.103998743,
-0.8850425482,
0.1572594494,
0.5347727537,
0.4065617919,
0.1489482671,
0.5413560867,
-0.5721536875,
0.9045712352,
0.1011018828,
0.2097564042,
-0.2347503453,
-0.5314310789,
-0.3209325671,
0.0194833633,
0.3256479204,
0.2560419738,
0.4876043797,
-0.1628600657,
-0.4939594865,
0.3200219274,
0.2776201367,
-0.8402023315,
-0.5914843082,
-0.0732048154,
-0.2130162269,
-0.2658420205,
-0.1401275396,
-0.2384470254,
0.030961832,
-0.8998600841,
0.3701404631,
-0.521273315,
-0.2445379198,
0.2896904945,
0.156766519,
-0.0679239929,
0.4224381447,
-1.4504740238,
0.5670577884,
1.3033097982,
0.8163865805,
0.0015129197,
-0.2069461197,
-0.7009528875,
0.112847954,
-0.4435876012,
0.9865716696,
-0.8483973742,
0.1562826931,
-0.0773107708,
0.0479048491,
-0.1488903463,
-0.6364942193,
0.3585917652,
-0.6814470291,
-0.2136620134,
-0.4407898784,
-0.8252567053,
-0.0616516694,
0.0147355739,
-0.6810374856,
0.7559976578,
-0.2211931348,
-0.515296936,
0.571252048,
-0.5335117579,
-0.5051783919,
-0.181922555,
-0.0228954125,
-0.3866919279,
0.6418605447,
0.1900550127,
0.1509280652,
-0.1728280038,
0.0188806523,
-0.5418567061,
-0.7063922286,
0.1737485528,
-0.1875079572,
0.6769676208,
0.0209804364,
-0.1303161681,
0.0305850059,
-0.8660210967,
-0.0302082114,
-0.1981841326,
-0.343549788,
-0.6871982813,
0.1861603856,
-0.3244698048,
0.0901464745,
0.1389788389,
-0.3147000968,
0.4807728827,
-0.7053195834,
0.5811719298,
0.5958727002,
0.4161424935,
0.9116538763,
-0.2007655501,
0.3726603091,
-0.1769440919,
-0.1263397634,
-0.6305031776,
-0.2948312759,
-0.6592342257,
-0.1983039528,
0.5990015864,
0.2879069448,
-0.4040241539,
-0.0504684374,
-0.112853311,
-0.269179672,
-0.8342747092,
0.2385586947,
0.3668144047,
0.2865242064,
0.3963796496,
-0.3376332819,
-0.1387489885,
-0.8499276042,
-0.6374586225,
-0.0337688178,
-0.1077984422,
0.2769642174,
0.4278853834,
0.1429838538,
0.5384573936,
-0.4619530737,
-0.2852073014,
0.1967973411,
0.1496331841,
-0.0116362665,
0.8504174352,
0.6249462962,
-0.4067514539,
-0.1955465525,
0.0238288045,
-0.2701339126,
-0.2514585257,
-0.1662660986,
-0.329066515,
0.2629794478,
0.6069628596,
-0.8641596437,
0.3831975758,
0.1192261651,
-0.245769605,
0.3522943258,
-0.4156728685,
0.2568794787,
-0.7180660963,
-0.1200769022,
-0.1273342371,
-0.1148457304,
-0.4807089269,
0.6842125654,
0.3645538092,
0.2573769987,
-0.1731328666,
0.2947823405,
-0.7726787925,
-0.0614661053,
-0.5487101674,
0.2918159664,
-0.0500396937,
0.4663748741,
-0.3352509439,
0.7344005704,
0.7593643665,
-0.9773679972,
-0.0251158495,
-0.0163896158,
-0.4794026017,
0.7615149021,
-0.6357226968,
0.1999135464,
-0.1019043773,
-0.2833921909,
-0.7610315681,
-0.2066678107,
-0.0287611224,
-0.2713299394,
0.850045681,
-0.5191855431,
-0.7731284499,
0.0423910469,
-0.0713854209,
0.1288872659,
0.1919209212,
-0.3102594316,
0.3339795768,
0.3564198315,
0.1911631674,
-0.0812970623,
-0.5629655123,
-0.0783005357,
-0.1812689006,
-0.466460675,
0.4817320108,
0.088696599,
-0.3857150376,
0.0118664941,
-0.5307123065,
0.0073629213,
0.6418873072,
-0.044465147,
0.1610304266,
-0.3934236765,
0.310528934,
0.472135067,
-0.1375858039,
0.2432233244,
-0.5142408609,
0.4732933044,
0.2669878602,
-0.4069667459,
-0.5492342114,
0.0710053965,
0.4654381871,
-0.6004826427,
0.8265730739,
0.2950074971,
-0.6283928752,
-0.2193931341,
-0.4940493703,
-0.5114265084,
-0.5023252368,
0.285187155,
-0.7683036923,
-0.9716069698,
0.5746910572,
-0.177786082,
0.0879650041,
0.4993640184,
0.462054193,
-0.1304986775,
1.3157744408,
0.9436493516,
-0.1150617003,
0.8151230812,
0.0744496658,
0.1171871275,
-1.0380916595,
0.0710892603,
-0.8536815643,
-0.5085169673,
-0.9636729956,
-0.1492800266,
-0.0588686541,
0.7556682825,
-0.0686340034,
0.4595114589,
-0.4598673582,
0.6630075574,
0.6694823503,
0.1070327163,
0.6076278687,
0.0079957545,
-0.1738404632,
-0.0682043955,
-0.5119271874,
-0.5318381786,
0.8527619839,
0.1662410498,
0.8715370893,
0.1229389384,
0.6147229075,
-0.138115868,
0.2149086893,
-0.3846002221,
0.3402385116,
-0.0823583379,
-0.6676297188,
-0.1417109221,
-0.3425300419,
-0.7460399866,
0.0653590709,
-0.2521580458,
-1.1583937407,
0.1866531521,
0.5708343387,
-0.4022211134,
0.1910689324,
-0.8866820931,
0.8946501613,
-0.0009796226,
-0.5674979091,
-0.744345665,
-0.2396039069,
0.2618184388,
-0.0474712551,
-0.2132159024,
-0.23874107,
0.0958249941,
0.2394657135,
-0.3307377994,
0.6873913407,
-0.0655368865,
-0.2532646358,
0.1154493839,
0.4650131762,
0.7568499446,
0.3171857893,
0.1004701778,
-0.0445321351,
0.1198726296,
-0.4369757771,
-0.7713049054,
1.1807444096,
-0.3062609732,
-0.8786326647,
0.1122707501,
-0.5366759896,
-0.1204719692,
0.3247443736,
0.1337295026,
0.43174088,
0.0833518729,
0.2184523791,
0.8658457994,
0.0888714716,
0.3978214264,
0.7189830542,
-0.2055933177,
0.120605126,
0.6655114293,
0.304054141,
0.5012510419,
0.6730145216,
-0.3210113943,
-0.0392819755,
-0.592215538,
-0.6222774982,
0.255256772,
-0.5278877616,
-0.1554468572,
-0.74368155,
0.1579842716,
-0.1367796808,
0.0802030265,
-0.3733752966,
-0.6123956442,
-0.5244308114,
-0.1064486951,
0.2976867259,
0.5608718395,
0.1954550296,
0.2953784168,
-0.4319643676,
0.3377653956,
0.2685802281,
0.8054398894,
-0.0980152637,
-0.4400340319,
-0.4003306627,
0.3491148651,
-0.3610019982,
-0.7271599174,
-0.2078419477,
0.2470493317,
0.3525106311,
0.1023751795,
-0.2947303355,
1.1320800781,
-0.6487022638,
0.4475004375,
-0.4154207408,
-1.087690711,
0.6529511213,
-0.3853853941,
0.5359138846,
0.4420484602,
-0.1798319966,
-0.1684796512,
-0.7930452824,
-0.4110326171,
-0.57812953,
0.8296117783,
0.2015462071,
0.2594013512,
-0.0159269236,
0.7562173009,
-0.3193656802,
0.3328983486,
-0.2424283028,
-0.2686770856,
0.2681540847,
-0.0634910166,
-0.0592544749,
-0.2354987711,
0.058342278,
-0.1825793386,
0.5361431837,
-0.2193228006,
0.0306660123,
0.1104430035,
-0.40951401,
-0.5430506468,
0.118469201,
0.8711659312,
0.7997912765,
0.0525599346,
0.0506656468,
0.0847946107,
-0.1605822891,
-0.3530231416,
0.2716940045,
-0.6622080207,
-0.0258828141,
0.2792344689,
1.1314636469,
0.6066739559,
-0.2293005139,
0.0003101359,
0.1097478494,
0.1232303232,
0.1639528424,
0.5463399291,
0.1044121385,
0.4186143577,
0.0628298074,
0.497071594,
0.3473659456,
-0.6257308125,
0.2987315953,
0.7214932442,
-0.363717556,
-0.6783290505,
1.0242866278,
-0.3288024664,
-0.5940579176,
0.3778687119,
-0.0010929879,
-0.3584488928,
0.69401896,
0.5605376363,
0.6993585229,
-0.2708917558,
-0.0964658186,
0.3582813442,
0.6722483039,
-0.2362634838,
0.06370911,
-0.4196886122,
-0.4748957753,
-0.7084220648,
-0.7159662843,
-0.1243229061,
-0.2066444755,
-0.7668338418,
0.4048305452,
-0.1196953505,
-0.0438262485,
0.3518306017,
0.0151709002,
-0.9351731539,
0.1410046518,
0.1526863873,
1.059645772,
-0.4672611654,
0.9374144673,
0.8530622125,
-0.3740140796,
-0.7932670116,
0.1023276001,
-0.2206531018,
-0.5836217403,
0.2013993114,
0.039689865,
-0.0381840728,
0.1662183404,
-0.4950079024,
-1.0856666565,
0.741617918,
0.5533999205,
-0.872680068,
-0.0066598379,
-0.0278761648,
0.9045602679,
-0.2151807696,
0.0741492063,
0.815107882,
0.1307999492,
-0.428077668,
-1.0312907696,
0.0255768541,
-0.0055759866,
0.064825289,
0.8393885493,
-0.5869172812,
0.6840314269,
-0.2780712843,
-0.2202568203,
0.1412271559,
0.5482334495,
0.007294042,
0.2509529591,
0.2534843385,
0.6940913796,
0.9551286101,
-0.3069346845,
1.1432150602,
-0.7107633352,
0.5463495255,
1.2832244635,
-0.1249471903,
0.6896082759,
0.514108479,
0.1108947322,
0.4268967807,
0.4178450406,
0.1363101006,
0.5872670412,
0.1898614317,
-0.0749384165,
-0.2730096579,
-0.0056433962,
-0.0153604206,
0.2727606893,
0.3214142621,
-0.3884685636,
-0.0554224886,
0.0169563703,
-0.0462500639,
0.0775204003,
-0.7118208408,
0.8944219947,
0.1216382235,
-1.0906362534,
0.3676801622,
0.0999729931,
0.1974075735,
-0.304900825,
-0.0767975748,
-0.1772649139,
0.3036139905,
-0.0120173544,
-0.6935098767,
0.451810509,
-0.1807793975,
-0.3260033727,
-0.0838393196,
0.8100342751,
-0.5579755902,
-0.2166204304,
0.1941574961,
0.2546551228,
-0.2695949972,
-0.3194622099,
-0.5270702839,
0.0497145616,
-0.0432184264,
-0.2666380405,
0.4179491103,
0.9170757532,
-0.3333995044,
0.6613667607,
0.7605368495,
0.2174838632,
0.1130405515,
0.131390512,
0.8569129705,
-0.6150995493,
-0.5140235424,
-1.1544568539,
0.3808995187,
0.068195343,
-0.3523804545,
0.7013596296,
0.5150220394,
1.1009063721,
0.1308269352,
0.0358031057,
0.2580636144,
0.3960524499,
-0.7342527509,
0.5870434642,
-0.5979923606,
0.7043271661,
-0.2776982188,
-0.9913775325,
-0.2849633992,
0.2907459438,
-0.2798359096,
-0.214011088,
0.5681093335,
0.8645979762,
-0.2822752893,
-0.0787916183,
0.1804175228,
0.243529439,
0.1629070044,
0.1858750731,
0.5011276603,
-0.4205189049,
0.2712106407,
-0.4759076536,
0.0511231646,
-0.0532907583,
-0.573654294,
-0.8828471899,
-0.4401471913,
-0.5632128119,
-0.1444472969,
0.0172049273,
0.5672906637,
0.7087342143,
-0.9234492779,
0.2183158398,
-0.5386278629,
0.2827385068,
-0.2568296194,
-0.2247223109,
0.0782872289,
-0.6577851772,
-0.8005157709,
0.1078080982,
0.5593631864,
-0.0776554644,
-0.1079294384,
0.3182975352,
-0.0188887902,
0.2872395217,
0.3278289139,
0.1159524024,
-0.8145087361,
-0.4214820266,
0.1697103232,
-0.1309139729,
0.0873331577,
1.0985906124,
-0.6536492705,
0.5386791825,
0.3767364323,
0.5673105121,
0.5550714731,
-0.0718324259,
0.6038047075,
-0.6934663653,
0.0390367061,
-0.1239141673,
0.4908044338,
0.2726080418,
-0.4302207232,
0.3161522746,
0.1004647911,
-0.7069106698,
-1.0283004045,
0.4011895061,
-0.48949036,
-0.1271614134,
0.6665241718,
0.1408396065,
-0.2444626689,
0.0968712345,
-0.1519420892,
0.4046536386,
-0.1818465889,
1.0004330873,
0.9083276391,
0.1128341556,
-0.2770388126,
-0.8109037876,
0.726272881,
0.5904676318,
-0.5265930295,
-0.0604575947,
0.4222330749,
0.4972332716,
0.0893646255,
0.4088924825,
0.1232219338,
0.3351083994,
-0.319786191,
-0.2540500164,
0.1434930414,
-0.2468094379,
-0.4744927287,
0.0255297627,
0.1405013055,
-0.1731890142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14809v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14809v4
|
CriticBench: Benchmarking LLMs for Critique-Correct Reasoning
| 2024-02-22T18:59:02 | 2024-06-01T07:46:28 |
Zicheng Lin, Zhibin Gou, Tian Liang, Ruilin Luo, Haowei Liu, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to critique and refine their
reasoning is crucial for their application in evaluation, feedback provision,
and self-improvement. This paper introduces CriticBench, a comprehensive
benchmark designed to assess LLMs' abilities to critique and rectify their
reasoning across a variety of tasks. CriticBench encompasses five reasoning
domains: mathematical, commonsense, symbolic, coding, and algorithmic. It
compiles 15 datasets and incorporates responses from three LLM families.
Utilizing CriticBench, we evaluate and dissect the performance of 17 LLMs in
generation, critique, and correction reasoning, i.e., GQC reasoning. Our
findings reveal: (1) a linear relationship in GQC capabilities, with
critique-focused training markedly enhancing performance; (2) a task-dependent
variation in correction effectiveness, with logic-oriented tasks being more
amenable to correction; (3) GQC knowledge inconsistencies that decrease as
model size increases; and (4) an intriguing inter-model critiquing dynamic,
where stronger models are better at critiquing weaker ones, while weaker models
can surprisingly surpass stronger ones in their self-critique. We hope these
insights into the nuanced critique-correct reasoning of LLMs will foster
further research in LLM critique and self-improvement.
|
[
-0.41561988,
-0.4474529624,
0.6937000155,
0.1353406459,
0.1143983379,
0.1841592044,
-0.3892858326,
-0.316002965,
-0.1085249707,
0.4747321606,
-0.6172209978,
-0.4191916883,
-0.2139144689,
0.193527177,
-0.4613187015,
0.8843607306,
-0.1126642674,
0.3484334052,
-0.512454927,
-0.2512559593,
-0.5322076082,
-0.6166251898,
-0.4635062516,
-0.5961101055,
0.5823060274,
0.2664357722,
0.4817626476,
0.3452700377,
0.4759601057,
0.3582550585,
0.0120132947,
0.1580745876,
-0.6133822203,
0.3756484687,
-0.8425263166,
-0.6648055315,
-0.4214513302,
0.018760588,
0.5920008421,
0.5567137599,
-0.2443947941,
0.239247337,
0.1000476256,
0.8190800548,
-0.843730092,
-0.0748062357,
-0.662823379,
-0.0430920199,
-0.0981430188,
-0.0130693391,
-0.4594181478,
-0.573674202,
-0.3281616867,
-0.3419595957,
0.3335486352,
0.0326107554,
0.5991053581,
0.5098318458,
-0.2286042869,
-0.0251244716,
-0.7649465799,
0.693179369,
-0.8215450048,
0.4209848344,
0.0250646584,
0.5616252422,
-0.1984895766,
-0.8301238418,
-0.6164380908,
-0.4033921063,
0.0650418252,
0.3454771936,
-0.2695211172,
-0.1054056957,
0.6310727,
0.566758275,
-0.4212673903,
-0.0042737713,
-0.1688526273,
-0.2063851058,
0.7359543443,
0.3926219344,
-0.1680083126,
-0.2746011317,
-0.3309617639,
-0.1475792825,
-0.6549261808,
-0.0142038697,
0.5480204225,
-0.0502623133,
0.2631641328,
0.3268134296,
-0.4727091789,
0.5389938354,
-0.0195619408,
-0.0746233687,
0.153050378,
-0.3417902589,
0.0009432065,
-0.439643383,
0.6112346649,
0.6169515252,
0.3774910867,
-0.1579706669,
-0.5139376521,
0.2989873886,
0.693215251,
-0.514960587,
-0.2788256705,
0.009294318,
-0.3046078384,
-0.2426174432,
-0.0267137773,
-0.6443423629,
-0.5078744888,
-0.6217958331,
0.2334385514,
-0.1074982733,
-0.1340775788,
0.0842711627,
-0.1022504419,
0.0394310094,
0.4459946454,
-0.5377644897,
0.4110803008,
0.7832666039,
0.5191343427,
-0.2422883064,
-0.4021891952,
-0.3888872266,
-0.0469649471,
-0.4424910843,
1.0111187696,
-0.4749850929,
-0.3829146028,
-0.0215809587,
-0.0218241327,
-0.0410650596,
-1.0463383198,
0.7933239341,
-0.3193202913,
-0.1639662981,
-0.3786043823,
-0.5799971223,
-0.2158697695,
0.6287919283,
-0.6539850831,
1.1651382446,
0.3134205043,
-0.6851959229,
0.0888892487,
-0.2098425776,
-0.099223502,
-0.0726127774,
-0.2274571359,
-0.2469377965,
0.246918425,
0.0851430744,
0.3406535983,
-0.5906267762,
0.2639838755,
-0.7528612614,
-0.3835978508,
0.5417841077,
-0.2628168762,
0.2284941524,
0.3073624969,
-0.3335270882,
0.3931271434,
-0.7625405192,
0.4947492182,
0.0768102109,
-0.1775597632,
0.0946519077,
0.0626505762,
-0.160311237,
0.2742252052,
-0.1272993982,
-0.3541313708,
0.2901872396,
-0.091926977,
0.7387028337,
0.8207498789,
0.022080021,
-0.0709901452,
-0.4917047918,
0.7369450927,
-0.2363480926,
0.0558125302,
0.1864784956,
0.1455623806,
-0.9565040469,
0.0025835426,
0.4375036061,
0.3126755953,
-0.7372613549,
0.0921941549,
-0.1547287703,
-0.6309648752,
-0.5346314907,
0.2568646669,
0.5591647029,
0.4501035511,
0.4745106399,
-0.5614157319,
-0.5587649345,
-1.0284179449,
-0.6899795532,
-0.2676542103,
0.1445941925,
0.3012253344,
0.5560531616,
-0.2339828163,
0.5365438461,
-0.2904510498,
0.0092549957,
-0.4050410688,
-0.062207453,
0.0300017074,
0.2704841197,
0.3314900696,
-0.0252381116,
-0.2485934198,
-0.309963882,
-0.611784637,
-0.4679741263,
-0.0718908831,
-0.2173223943,
0.1692432016,
0.7415914536,
-0.2793169022,
0.2290303111,
0.484618932,
-0.0954985619,
1.0861916542,
0.0413511917,
-0.0429721139,
-0.6086956263,
0.2623092234,
-0.1153133437,
-0.3997404575,
-0.2258120328,
0.2791171968,
0.0197737757,
0.2170557082,
-0.0609776527,
0.5229994655,
-0.4195570052,
-0.1440556347,
-0.285135597,
0.4115662277,
0.0305843223,
0.4891807437,
-0.2174438536,
0.6676964164,
0.2615547776,
-0.2972421646,
0.6367816329,
-0.1626067907,
-0.6795700192,
0.7598290443,
-0.6154080629,
0.4440080523,
0.093410857,
0.3952122033,
-0.931892395,
-0.0870673135,
0.1373905838,
-0.1366597265,
0.0552493222,
0.0106022526,
-0.4613073766,
-0.5613389611,
-0.2696045339,
0.2976456583,
0.1622865796,
-0.7101724148,
0.6594131589,
-0.0370849222,
-0.1062366068,
-0.6791632175,
-0.4047711492,
-0.047948923,
0.1179495081,
-0.3773238957,
0.2186805904,
-0.1976523846,
-0.4349712729,
0.0542382821,
-0.2915503085,
0.3499058187,
0.12880674,
0.2940775454,
0.0140768839,
0.0156509206,
0.2599623799,
-0.3331395686,
-0.1264318824,
0.3043579757,
-0.0589670725,
0.5650378466,
-0.5153542757,
-0.585504055,
-0.1002335474,
0.0268817171,
0.398580879,
-0.316843152,
0.1380920857,
0.190126121,
0.0532253273,
-0.6356384158,
-0.9267701507,
-0.2192935199,
-0.4089178443,
0.3168017268,
-0.465084374,
-0.8283694386,
0.4755411446,
-0.2306414545,
-0.1366524994,
0.5519506931,
0.7561143637,
0.0778280199,
0.8967729807,
0.386089325,
-0.2148166448,
0.1812682003,
-0.3467095792,
0.0914363563,
-1.1098639965,
-0.1915861815,
-0.6105997562,
-0.4789449871,
-0.2771662176,
-0.4944104254,
0.0389671922,
0.2826141119,
-0.3647536933,
0.073223114,
-0.4614900351,
0.6669535637,
0.4777443111,
-0.1001048163,
0.5337772965,
-0.3246452212,
-0.5386150479,
0.0116510559,
-0.5573236942,
-0.6743190885,
0.98695153,
0.3516561091,
0.8599518538,
0.0819347203,
0.4001281857,
0.0614951439,
0.6486626863,
-0.6808443666,
0.7854645848,
0.0383483581,
-0.7736132741,
0.0624422096,
-0.5127030611,
-0.4033620656,
0.4466279745,
-0.021439895,
-0.6548886299,
0.0798816383,
0.2109346092,
-0.2105473131,
0.4319732785,
-0.4284960628,
0.9412881136,
-0.2927664816,
-0.7365302444,
-0.6417033672,
-0.4357909262,
0.4432603717,
0.1697522849,
0.0437047593,
-0.1944845915,
0.2264326215,
0.2582339644,
-0.3747594655,
0.6627528071,
-0.1027127504,
-0.0778854117,
0.3921833634,
0.481243372,
0.3587608635,
0.0404131413,
-0.1945584863,
-0.0349188931,
0.1701990068,
-0.1395875514,
-0.8751570582,
0.6663309336,
-0.7428430915,
-0.8488692045,
-0.3460284173,
-0.3326378763,
-0.6927454472,
-0.0219977796,
0.0474058911,
0.3307727277,
-0.3268298209,
0.2226913124,
0.1472905129,
0.1631622612,
0.1526349038,
0.6999734044,
-0.4681113958,
-0.5730859041,
0.6814801693,
0.0527449623,
0.3473817408,
-0.0158957634,
0.0027014096,
-0.2951641679,
-0.5725248456,
-0.3794985414,
0.3277911544,
-1.0337771177,
-0.3009151518,
-0.3723875284,
-0.2184031308,
-0.0164388306,
0.066268377,
-0.4641400874,
-0.4627260268,
0.2864334285,
-0.1194222122,
-0.0393217169,
0.8801555037,
-0.0025694047,
-0.0509717241,
-0.4391965568,
-0.027766224,
0.3298060596,
0.6090758443,
0.4201841652,
-0.5125778913,
-0.1350963116,
-0.3222306669,
-0.7091622949,
-0.5665038228,
-0.0738534033,
-0.0683492571,
0.7376273274,
0.3384143412,
0.0420909673,
0.5670885444,
-0.3952793479,
0.7322072983,
-0.0141516542,
-1.1059594154,
0.364228338,
-0.1543832272,
0.3747577667,
0.6058348417,
0.1296904981,
-0.6704377532,
-0.4773409963,
-0.5912722945,
-0.5163003206,
0.4252940118,
-0.0954256207,
-0.0898334086,
0.1117678657,
0.5893695354,
-0.0030254647,
0.2475937605,
-0.6293347478,
0.2319823205,
-0.3392170072,
-0.0604286082,
-0.1231840998,
-0.2388277203,
-0.3682853281,
-0.3116607666,
0.8969372511,
-0.5373910069,
-0.0459984727,
0.2292754054,
-0.077485241,
-0.2754813731,
0.4337311387,
0.5788260102,
0.7406241298,
0.1441348642,
0.2350682169,
0.492372781,
0.0450656004,
0.0980078653,
-0.0773499236,
0.0402587801,
-0.2397882491,
0.5804760456,
0.7129845619,
0.1572569758,
-0.8140597343,
0.3239683509,
-0.1392050982,
-0.2771662772,
-0.2515271008,
0.391122669,
0.2587717474,
0.4575155377,
-0.1280088276,
0.1271890402,
0.1730706841,
-0.6664388776,
-0.0749153495,
0.4047670662,
-0.3080954254,
-0.3138154149,
0.5958839655,
0.1397683322,
-0.0346168838,
0.6861304641,
-0.0036298365,
-0.7255830765,
0.4044525623,
0.3111714125,
0.8797842264,
-0.084528029,
0.035732273,
0.510879755,
0.090441972,
-0.1681604087,
0.2844349444,
-0.1387294978,
-0.8462767005,
-0.4003878236,
-0.3824131191,
-0.8560608029,
0.1312880367,
-0.7771609426,
-0.0246990789,
-0.7593960166,
-0.5013103485,
0.00328672,
0.1947918534,
-0.6377598643,
0.1133968309,
0.0369336009,
0.8291968107,
-0.2868724763,
0.6765112281,
0.7522552013,
-0.3595911562,
-1.0743463039,
0.0499483906,
0.2710286081,
-0.6164025068,
0.6028180718,
0.1776921898,
-0.4665825665,
-0.2970720828,
-0.620375514,
-0.5829629302,
0.7986025214,
0.4620354176,
-0.955532074,
0.257486105,
0.0036830683,
0.9306986928,
-0.3552569747,
0.5690665841,
0.6851396561,
0.4147751629,
-0.048915077,
-0.9473146796,
0.0865110531,
-0.5323559642,
0.1842892766,
-0.03259084,
-1.1591581106,
0.7371889353,
-0.2436331064,
-0.0974500477,
0.2584172189,
0.4781542718,
0.2902706265,
-0.0309515037,
0.5986514091,
0.9015407562,
0.7063333988,
-0.3289842308,
1.1723691225,
-0.5014700294,
0.3266322017,
1.3254085779,
-0.5965146422,
0.9302272201,
0.2638796866,
-0.1889184415,
0.970610857,
0.3800697923,
-0.2914845645,
0.229763791,
0.7151110768,
-0.0636351109,
-0.5833543539,
-0.1749646515,
-0.3209723532,
0.2515553534,
-0.0059346538,
-0.2729759514,
-0.1308904141,
-0.419070065,
-0.1024359092,
0.3294295371,
-0.3510600328,
0.724455893,
0.2778236568,
-1.0686603785,
0.7877280116,
0.1671196222,
0.1848227382,
-0.3919148147,
0.1979756504,
-0.3355270326,
0.902695179,
-0.2712181509,
-0.809890151,
0.2174104899,
0.0602189228,
-0.2657109797,
-0.090261966,
0.6908282042,
-0.2084288746,
-0.1679513901,
0.5536438823,
0.5179203153,
0.06170699,
-0.0880959108,
-0.7733505964,
0.3160804212,
-0.0397876166,
-0.2754949927,
0.1621934772,
0.3929788172,
-0.151865378,
0.9483725429,
0.3563034534,
0.1637782156,
-0.2310894281,
0.676441133,
0.9826066494,
-0.8215410709,
-0.1315700859,
-0.6832220554,
0.4368513823,
-0.1441440433,
-0.5334280729,
0.7542364001,
0.5206825137,
1.2525142431,
-0.1055710986,
0.8453802466,
0.3496754766,
0.8406252861,
-0.5469323397,
0.2949607372,
-0.5866662264,
0.2092728615,
-0.1824101657,
-1.06221807,
-0.0021314588,
0.6552406549,
-0.5413151383,
0.2813745737,
0.861806035,
0.9431605339,
0.2723511457,
0.2772277594,
0.0849434659,
0.3487629592,
0.3388563395,
0.5827240348,
1.3735607862,
-0.1076560542,
0.3628165126,
-0.3085102141,
0.1183474287,
-0.1879643351,
-0.7793962955,
-1.0633877516,
-0.0844003037,
-0.2966397703,
-0.4616111517,
0.1433935016,
0.8488861322,
0.5258669853,
-0.8831379414,
-0.3890842199,
-0.0350592695,
0.0194917452,
-0.4483344555,
-0.1966335177,
-0.0353094377,
-0.5744406581,
-0.4845093787,
0.468162775,
0.1395331621,
-0.3488751054,
-0.654029727,
-0.0360065773,
0.2949451208,
0.1678486317,
0.3916850984,
0.1111699343,
-0.9582519531,
-0.5013347864,
-0.1815202832,
-0.1990653276,
-0.0463486426,
1.0567990541,
-0.855840981,
0.5220746398,
0.4218047559,
0.5222604275,
0.5527906418,
0.1505794972,
0.565310657,
-0.5457738042,
-0.2065627426,
0.3867437541,
0.5143712759,
0.4473156035,
0.198758781,
0.9489648938,
0.4194803536,
-0.7196932435,
-0.9468919635,
0.2410105616,
-0.7516390681,
-0.3152266741,
0.9450895786,
-0.137012735,
0.0596045814,
0.2390999943,
-0.3221907318,
-0.0466599353,
-0.0917946398,
0.7777207494,
1.0915620327,
-0.0973764956,
-0.3013283312,
-0.5601573586,
0.400192529,
0.8723118901,
-0.7826634049,
0.373601377,
0.5002645254,
0.5116400123,
0.1106242537,
0.4491728246,
-0.1894764453,
0.2444009483,
0.0089976992,
0.281350255,
-0.0105922045,
-0.3648939729,
-0.3085502088,
0.1740963459,
0.4082472324,
0.5886362791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14905v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14905v2
|
MobileLLM: Optimizing Sub-billion Parameter Language Models for On-Device Use Cases
| 2024-02-22T18:58:55 | 2024-06-27T03:53:46 |
Zechun Liu, Changsheng Zhao, Forrest Iandola, Chen Lai, Yuandong Tian, Igor Fedorov, Yunyang Xiong, Ernie Chang, Yangyang Shi, Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi, Liangzhen Lai, Vikas Chandra
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the growing need for efficient large language models
(LLMs) on mobile devices, driven by increasing cloud costs and latency
concerns. We focus on designing top-quality LLMs with fewer than a billion
parameters, a practical choice for mobile deployment. Contrary to prevailing
belief emphasizing the pivotal role of data and parameter quantity in
determining model quality, our investigation underscores the significance of
model architecture for sub-billion scale LLMs. Leveraging deep and thin
architectures, coupled with embedding sharing and grouped-query attention
mechanisms, we establish a strong baseline network denoted as MobileLLM, which
attains a remarkable 2.7%/4.3% accuracy boost over preceding 125M/350M
state-of-the-art models. Additionally, we propose an immediate block-wise
weight-sharing approach with no increase in model size and only marginal
latency overhead. The resultant models, denoted as MobileLLM-LS, demonstrate a
further accuracy enhancement of 0.7%/0.8% than MobileLLM 125M/350M. Moreover,
MobileLLM model family shows significant improvements compared to previous
sub-billion models on chat benchmarks, and demonstrates close correctness to
LLaMA-v2 7B in API calling tasks, highlighting the capability of small models
for common on-device use cases.
|
[
-0.4541157186,
-0.6995364428,
0.4166797698,
0.3325681388,
-0.3596120477,
0.0076748566,
-0.1152223721,
-0.5021096468,
0.1151801348,
0.6136843562,
-0.2632813752,
-0.4847134948,
-0.3613929749,
-0.366951853,
-0.3018917143,
0.2988207638,
0.2341323197,
-0.1259478629,
-0.4036417902,
-0.2613627315,
-0.2639662921,
-0.5263834596,
-0.7813740373,
-0.3223235905,
0.5846945643,
0.6306352615,
1.0168483257,
0.8717875481,
0.2621001303,
0.1711917669,
-0.253113091,
0.3591629267,
-0.7103292346,
0.0010259921,
0.0704177395,
-0.4016486406,
-0.8401076794,
-0.0011964919,
0.4797748625,
0.7080296874,
-0.4455107152,
0.2942128479,
-0.2066145241,
0.552118063,
-0.3916219175,
-0.1222268566,
-0.8898178935,
-0.2294808924,
0.0284729395,
0.093026109,
-0.5115689635,
-0.1541636586,
-0.0985413864,
-0.2033147514,
-0.1062263027,
0.227722317,
0.7163876295,
0.4182994962,
-0.4660164416,
-0.1915678233,
-0.730357945,
1.0084553957,
-0.9356545806,
0.8347299099,
0.50342381,
-0.0073773623,
-0.1990737468,
-0.6439926028,
-0.1927258968,
-0.57525599,
0.2789775431,
-0.1614164263,
-0.1912769675,
-0.0021337129,
-0.0156194568,
0.214315936,
-0.5457104445,
0.4937022924,
-0.3816971481,
-0.0383558273,
0.9278663397,
0.4049383402,
0.145796895,
0.1782997251,
-0.408806026,
0.640327096,
-1.24895823,
-0.1149386019,
0.1105682552,
0.3781913817,
-0.3163398504,
0.5136710405,
-0.3376325965,
0.805182457,
-0.0811084956,
-0.3275508285,
-0.2046127766,
-0.5971258283,
-0.2953983545,
-0.0798392594,
0.9460330606,
0.3590245545,
0.0484810546,
-0.3255769312,
-0.1397402585,
-0.3607913554,
0.2365078479,
-1.2044990063,
0.1379588842,
0.3947578967,
-0.7232563496,
-0.187964499,
-0.5498157144,
-0.3262479603,
-0.4826118648,
-0.2282991707,
0.006458737,
-0.0505531281,
-0.2003562003,
0.2506677806,
0.7387933135,
0.1967020184,
0.1742040813,
-1.1267477274,
0.4020652175,
0.5900722742,
0.9515824318,
-0.1729037911,
0.0319594331,
-0.2915106416,
0.089881964,
-0.3406598568,
0.465177983,
-0.4079469144,
-0.7680175304,
-0.4007652104,
-0.3328006566,
-0.2139778733,
-0.7789322138,
0.7779479623,
-0.631747663,
-0.1722285002,
0.1300463676,
-0.6487026811,
-0.1996809542,
-0.094357878,
-0.5681065321,
1.0720906258,
-0.1680610329,
-0.2626760006,
0.1526461244,
-0.4356554449,
-0.4032444954,
0.1612114459,
0.060802523,
-0.3767932057,
0.4171361625,
0.1331698895,
0.8082752228,
-0.8177496791,
0.0596111752,
-0.4822559953,
-0.3605182171,
-0.0292821247,
-0.1912083775,
0.5996013284,
0.6288884282,
-0.084038876,
0.0704089478,
-0.5953415632,
0.3757263124,
-0.0172832254,
-0.5075725913,
-0.2708428204,
0.2647815049,
0.1153206453,
0.2535456121,
0.4405736923,
-0.4513878822,
0.1656332612,
-0.2011738569,
0.728823185,
0.0548352711,
-0.2753601968,
0.5887212753,
-0.1945679188,
0.4499003887,
-0.1369506419,
0.2876938581,
-0.1154657826,
-0.451695919,
-0.5892122388,
-0.4664945602,
0.4801159799,
0.5298697352,
-0.0798949525,
0.0647929832,
-0.3507438898,
-0.8949455619,
-0.5159142017,
0.5357350111,
0.4227343798,
0.1626229733,
0.0636853576,
-0.0087953107,
-0.6233942509,
-0.9335106611,
-0.0992264897,
-0.2696141005,
0.0991915166,
0.7591567636,
0.032723099,
-0.6439481974,
0.958950758,
-0.2158251554,
-0.0226822812,
-0.3542560041,
-0.2050350159,
0.1496842355,
0.327535212,
0.4214555621,
-0.8949862123,
-0.4999811053,
0.1834501773,
-0.555801332,
-0.3073577285,
0.0866034999,
0.2327110171,
0.3119952977,
0.6532513499,
-0.8876250982,
-0.0143782841,
0.8721740842,
0.012524141,
0.220309183,
-0.2049062401,
-0.2478440255,
-1.1926213503,
-0.1134706065,
0.1625814736,
-0.356636256,
-0.5910024047,
0.1121235713,
0.1288468689,
-0.1974751651,
-0.861669004,
0.8294469714,
-0.588334024,
-0.0826168954,
-0.3598454893,
0.0647603273,
-0.1412813812,
0.2148203403,
-0.2548546791,
0.9045468569,
0.3032974005,
-0.6395689845,
0.3114332259,
-0.3294830322,
-0.2523423433,
0.3336436749,
-0.9514605999,
0.2383749932,
0.2351605445,
0.0368321761,
-0.9031408429,
-0.0861900672,
-0.2402686924,
-0.2237634957,
-0.0717406645,
-0.3921662569,
-0.5681991577,
-0.1084366292,
-0.1222004518,
0.5047930479,
0.6244174838,
-0.3725619614,
0.9126465917,
0.7752944827,
-0.1864475906,
-0.176675275,
-0.325049907,
0.1338249594,
-0.4788621366,
-0.9624676704,
0.5814940929,
0.0199187957,
-0.2155132592,
-0.1597555429,
-0.1347952187,
-0.0998676643,
0.1655928791,
0.6240535378,
0.0042494354,
-0.4184906781,
-0.0535103418,
-0.0335232317,
0.0152236335,
-0.2517499626,
-0.2773543298,
0.6559739113,
-0.2121955454,
-0.1071196496,
-0.3970961869,
0.2837669253,
0.8437590003,
-0.103624247,
0.8326827288,
0.4336864352,
-0.464424789,
-0.1954201162,
-0.6947004199,
0.0381283425,
-0.5054109693,
0.4734410644,
-0.6247857809,
-1.0689696074,
0.7540220618,
-0.133711651,
0.017213298,
0.0673940033,
0.7713744044,
-0.1136149243,
1.1141780615,
0.6639985442,
-0.2914739847,
0.3890630901,
0.0270265806,
0.0937510654,
-0.7729759812,
-0.2399442792,
-0.4405574799,
0.0500936024,
-0.5629519224,
-0.7086312771,
0.0352769196,
0.5975288749,
-0.2568468153,
0.4389976561,
-0.0018462854,
0.4909177423,
0.2968840003,
0.0900371447,
0.3384419978,
0.0647827238,
-0.1641915739,
-0.0327171497,
-0.9223538041,
-0.9714403152,
0.9910529256,
0.6426872015,
1.2910017967,
0.1263587028,
0.4688851833,
0.1757748425,
0.3448315561,
-0.9170684218,
0.8119242787,
-0.3401337564,
-0.4416186213,
-0.1923233718,
-0.5228945613,
-0.8430886269,
0.5534206033,
0.2186030298,
-0.7462118268,
0.0214048587,
0.1959652901,
-0.4975820184,
0.0613930672,
-0.9594284892,
0.858905077,
-0.2930853069,
-0.4328017831,
-0.2397733778,
-0.3002709448,
0.4139072895,
-0.0553115495,
0.2075008601,
-0.436113894,
-0.4262055755,
0.404889375,
-0.5684921741,
0.8276237249,
-0.0632252172,
-0.3167106509,
0.4294783175,
0.0443363264,
0.6452018023,
0.0816916525,
-0.2927893996,
0.2407242656,
-0.1930054873,
-0.3847898543,
-0.3547075689,
0.9805305004,
-0.7230240703,
-0.5147576928,
0.3112031817,
-0.5244091153,
-0.2558689415,
0.1744706929,
0.0595234744,
0.4743445218,
-0.1353436857,
0.6351792812,
0.8216146231,
-0.1224189848,
0.6243344545,
0.44834885,
-0.4790236056,
-0.2059178054,
0.847812295,
0.1138232648,
0.4382843375,
0.3098112941,
0.0158758275,
-0.6808922887,
-0.9941427112,
-0.6839921474,
0.2534580529,
-0.3878728151,
0.0023483098,
-0.7951551676,
-0.1130564585,
-0.2184411585,
0.1630556583,
-0.8287414312,
-0.2668639421,
-0.5443256497,
0.0547399931,
0.261949867,
0.3501302004,
0.154106319,
0.7267019153,
-0.8452478647,
0.1457607746,
0.2157018036,
0.231837064,
0.0822862536,
-0.6970912814,
-0.5466403365,
0.2712012529,
-0.1253283918,
-0.4041928947,
0.3873271346,
0.2149753124,
0.6123293638,
0.1578538716,
-0.1831299663,
0.6721206307,
-0.5324268341,
0.627656281,
-0.021320587,
-0.8922644258,
0.1930936277,
-0.5268190503,
0.2462785244,
0.3865288496,
0.3829421699,
-0.5519618392,
-0.0504920818,
-0.3907341063,
-0.7727434039,
0.4609120786,
-0.0258643366,
0.5963522792,
0.3652479947,
0.4518110752,
-0.244991675,
0.037669491,
-0.5490065217,
-0.2045835555,
0.0833943114,
-0.3718865514,
0.0490131229,
-0.4918504953,
0.2429747283,
-0.1154828668,
0.4690043926,
0.0393777005,
0.0373068489,
-0.1623670012,
-0.3082194626,
0.1145599261,
0.1562527269,
1.1072660685,
0.8034433722,
-0.0468366072,
0.2017855644,
0.2994889319,
-0.6382552385,
0.2459163964,
-0.0459598713,
-0.1726842821,
-0.0491310731,
-0.0260114372,
0.9500015974,
0.3110368848,
-0.7682125568,
0.1128471047,
-0.0053263148,
0.0374600217,
0.0799068287,
0.1858007461,
0.643949151,
0.3196959198,
0.4827161133,
-0.2676692009,
-0.1438710541,
-0.3938174248,
0.1943507046,
0.6323853731,
-0.3676469922,
-0.3184772134,
0.9274548292,
0.3540558815,
-0.4438751638,
0.2615925074,
-0.0212808363,
-0.2075334191,
0.6179736853,
0.4502604604,
0.5422685146,
-0.4213570952,
0.1831019819,
-0.0272593256,
0.4092109203,
-0.2248152345,
0.3599369228,
0.2257729024,
-0.7246373296,
-0.5125082731,
-0.6464062333,
-0.5618552566,
0.3085040748,
-0.2154676914,
0.1605239362,
-0.5374741554,
-0.3697649539,
-0.2020599097,
0.1128855497,
-0.3178741038,
0.4168174565,
0.1349727958,
0.8855293989,
-0.251042068,
1.1274915934,
0.5142776966,
-0.1161055043,
-1.0703777075,
-0.4338786602,
-0.2051745206,
-0.7916346192,
0.6509363055,
-0.1265108734,
-0.2997174561,
0.3163279295,
-0.3356002569,
-0.9894865155,
0.9613993168,
0.4516326487,
-0.6858633161,
0.2083274722,
0.3269759715,
0.3605556488,
-0.6833395958,
0.2210472077,
0.1772076637,
-0.0199184734,
0.2060508579,
-1.1235381365,
0.2349202484,
0.052701693,
0.3737849295,
0.2506917417,
-1.0420928001,
0.852950871,
-0.4653109014,
-0.2059376985,
0.1805063933,
0.4775324464,
0.4268817902,
0.15607135,
0.319206655,
0.5162548423,
0.5839189887,
0.1374084204,
0.9674886465,
-0.3043310642,
0.3629397452,
1.0585967302,
-0.6063861251,
1.1674119234,
0.4548053443,
-0.0728946179,
0.1495541036,
1.0243544579,
0.3701630235,
0.5545334816,
0.2937051356,
-0.4286820889,
-0.2510254383,
-0.2602522373,
-0.3130026162,
0.2814453542,
0.4144886136,
-0.4477907717,
-0.0233921409,
-0.0533198528,
0.1424150914,
-0.2511402369,
-0.5885539055,
0.5250245929,
0.5167415738,
-0.26661551,
0.8622973561,
0.4544199705,
0.7597076893,
-0.139894858,
0.5550804138,
-0.7724132538,
0.1666500866,
-0.3132588565,
-0.1421230137,
0.2957234681,
-0.0160408467,
-0.4099623561,
-0.3141106963,
0.7800121307,
-0.371331811,
-0.4581996799,
0.2162831873,
0.5988738537,
0.203459233,
-0.2174392343,
-0.7235406637,
0.5166968703,
-0.2627174854,
-0.3412273526,
0.217888236,
0.1608765721,
-0.2226920277,
0.9610443711,
0.6414448023,
0.0017565176,
0.5350989699,
0.1694232821,
0.5034382939,
-0.726349771,
-0.243323192,
-1.0703902245,
0.3406513333,
0.0763459206,
-0.1313055307,
0.8066751361,
0.8489658237,
0.6383433938,
0.040765442,
0.4329057634,
0.1721645147,
0.327998668,
-0.5282450318,
0.779317379,
-0.6142992973,
0.5460879207,
0.1471376121,
-0.9482107162,
-0.1999128759,
0.2794245481,
-0.2460631877,
0.2570566833,
0.2982409894,
1.0276910067,
-0.2702550888,
0.0403648205,
0.6412023306,
-0.0328574963,
0.1012343168,
0.5357519388,
0.8369258046,
-0.5918411613,
0.586799264,
0.0941134319,
0.0799647421,
-0.6043663621,
-0.893822372,
-0.8162096739,
-0.2394721359,
-0.38268736,
-0.041958414,
-0.0260848794,
0.8975750804,
1.3470283747,
-0.4347971678,
-0.6307173371,
-0.060221076,
0.2784257829,
0.1643330902,
-0.0893131867,
0.0105256448,
-0.0870287493,
-0.6451458931,
0.6367013454,
0.3088926971,
0.3015052974,
-0.3054121137,
-0.3502630591,
0.0579816401,
0.3924914598,
0.9353878498,
0.3599126339,
-0.84384799,
0.0962837785,
0.1971920133,
-0.6905596852,
-0.0760340244,
0.7477619052,
-0.4399201572,
-0.0625280291,
0.3349047899,
0.8490179777,
0.6511369348,
0.0868831277,
0.4796388447,
-0.6440910697,
0.2304474711,
0.1769358963,
0.3129503131,
0.2714036107,
-0.1958936304,
0.5276451707,
-0.040956784,
-0.5164024234,
-1.1255385876,
0.2196522951,
-0.9774813652,
-0.0415846966,
1.3048660755,
-0.0842549726,
0.0168277491,
-0.1663936526,
-0.1672984511,
-0.2295829058,
-0.3433235884,
0.5043745041,
0.5609877706,
-0.1747410148,
-0.6941030622,
-0.8037822843,
0.3357394934,
0.5908488035,
-0.9931795001,
0.10918843,
0.2551219463,
0.2529683709,
-0.186241135,
0.7274039388,
0.0011023125,
-0.0571208782,
-0.1251666993,
-0.0914223343,
-0.1195525378,
-0.1898362935,
-0.0957698449,
0.2801415324,
0.2565342486,
-0.2596257329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14808v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14808v3
|
RelayAttention for Efficient Large Language Model Serving with Long System Prompts
| 2024-02-22T18:58:28 | 2024-05-30T05:09:25 |
Lei Zhu, Xinjiang Wang, Wayne Zhang, Rynson W. H. Lau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A practical large language model (LLM) service may involve a long system
prompt, which specifies the instructions, examples, and knowledge documents of
the task and is reused across requests. However, the long system prompt causes
throughput/latency bottlenecks as the cost of generating the next token grows
w.r.t. the sequence length. This paper aims to improve the efficiency of LLM
services that involve long system prompts. Our key observation is that handling
these system prompts requires heavily redundant memory accesses in existing
causal attention computation algorithms. Specifically, for batched requests,
the cached hidden states (\ie, key-value pairs) of system prompts are
transferred from off-chip DRAM to on-chip SRAM multiple times, each
corresponding to an individual request. To eliminate such a redundancy, we
propose RelayAttention, an attention algorithm that allows reading these hidden
states from DRAM exactly once for a batch of input tokens. RelayAttention is a
free lunch: it maintains the generation quality while requiring no model
retraining, as it is based on a mathematical reformulation of causal attention.
We have observed significant performance improvements to a production-level
system, vLLM, through integration with RelayAttention. The improvements are
even more profound with longer system prompts.
|
[
-0.1679542512,
-0.4496242106,
0.6824854612,
0.7068580389,
-0.2221269459,
-0.0161503311,
-0.2218556404,
-0.4669632912,
0.2275790423,
0.6455352306,
-0.6168453097,
-0.1227383241,
-0.3674251437,
0.0155435987,
-0.3405200243,
0.6733922362,
-0.2541551292,
-0.1821231693,
-0.1716651917,
-0.0046110218,
-0.8454204798,
-0.2887542248,
-0.9985153675,
-0.1413362324,
0.7800542712,
0.5466617942,
0.2122546881,
0.6019512415,
0.4880179763,
0.3045265675,
0.0285408441,
0.3245791793,
-0.6516429186,
0.5874427557,
-0.3339388072,
-0.3435866833,
-0.4301942885,
-0.287014395,
0.8567975163,
0.3380668759,
0.0639736727,
0.2741907239,
0.1182341352,
0.5359293818,
-0.762327373,
0.2186934799,
-0.4633960724,
0.0134121282,
-0.0930037275,
-0.1891377568,
-0.8284252286,
-0.251131773,
-0.034069512,
-0.5169067979,
0.1654093266,
0.1761641055,
0.5898283124,
0.2485904545,
-0.0692628473,
0.1470115781,
-0.7758823633,
0.8975988626,
-0.5537825823,
0.2883070111,
0.3006792367,
0.4075373113,
-0.3470173478,
-0.679946959,
-0.3735670149,
-0.3327560127,
-0.1320836544,
-0.0074088615,
-0.4076749682,
0.1627610475,
0.4750733078,
-0.053732045,
-0.5138953924,
0.2585558593,
-0.259195298,
-0.3607402146,
0.2867430449,
0.4952384531,
0.1050122902,
-0.1186014637,
-0.652764082,
0.1448063552,
-0.840171814,
-0.0167215466,
-0.0381561294,
0.3745458126,
0.0072940253,
0.3803395331,
-0.4035695493,
0.6182516813,
0.1522411108,
0.0013024234,
-0.1147589087,
-0.4133418798,
-0.2766910791,
0.1368465871,
0.7209489346,
0.067163378,
-0.034572877,
-0.1144552752,
-0.3711090088,
-0.171457082,
0.2919324636,
-0.8215469718,
0.191127643,
0.2716511488,
-0.2020290345,
-0.0937014073,
-0.0815144181,
-0.5860663652,
-0.2070407718,
-0.2127405554,
0.1786936373,
-0.4501638412,
0.2378245443,
-0.0200428106,
-0.0909691304,
0.184652999,
0.4844477773,
-0.8451347351,
0.2221446186,
0.8860461116,
0.9843941331,
-0.2389488071,
-0.2559898794,
-0.9925639033,
0.4000821114,
-0.0245207101,
0.8022557497,
-0.4411702156,
-0.169398874,
-0.2409352213,
0.1157825589,
-0.1925679147,
-0.4934262931,
0.3581698239,
-0.9489622712,
-0.1087795198,
-0.3371577561,
-0.4376272857,
0.0905909836,
0.0757472217,
-0.7089025974,
1.0270988941,
-0.1437525451,
-0.6292126179,
0.0249143802,
-0.6839091182,
-0.558323741,
0.0870157331,
0.0330183655,
-0.2025820315,
0.3375058472,
0.2606277168,
0.4348229468,
-0.4257828295,
0.2862752378,
-0.240653187,
-0.5014062524,
0.1535076201,
-0.6510331035,
0.6040036082,
0.23210904,
-0.5192755461,
0.2634629309,
-0.6770404577,
-0.0567163751,
-0.1941568702,
-0.2986547351,
-0.3329609334,
-0.0498092473,
-0.0407844111,
0.0752163604,
0.4302857816,
-0.4363633096,
0.2499203086,
-0.4580526948,
0.3968062997,
1.1374999285,
-0.1390322745,
0.3320224583,
-0.0212355927,
0.4650439322,
0.2363061607,
0.225936085,
-0.6193665862,
-0.2525525391,
-0.9419749975,
-0.5971513987,
-0.0389725491,
0.3796167672,
-0.6352982521,
0.1540462226,
-0.1336083561,
-0.1374365836,
-0.4359368384,
-0.0954860598,
0.4775699377,
0.6742315292,
0.3198940754,
-0.1231179312,
-0.4222344756,
-1.0666308403,
0.0042157806,
-0.076090768,
0.0879367366,
0.296101898,
0.112297684,
-0.3179943264,
0.9421843886,
-0.622643292,
0.175964579,
-0.1024332047,
0.0010689243,
0.2838418782,
0.2281598151,
0.1703389883,
-0.1869562864,
-0.4247305691,
-0.0249908119,
-0.5441914797,
-0.3607555628,
-0.127334252,
-0.2134504616,
0.5984214544,
0.5035410523,
-0.8411424756,
0.2323488444,
0.3809032738,
-0.2761475146,
0.7143073082,
-0.3257670701,
0.175430432,
-1.0075820684,
0.2756853402,
-0.3128227293,
-0.3387284875,
-0.5136208534,
0.1713224202,
0.3373926878,
-0.3472187817,
-0.5149720311,
0.9872985482,
-0.6880810857,
-0.1753994823,
-0.5352528691,
0.1806271076,
0.0254969653,
0.33885023,
-0.1870176792,
0.9552781582,
0.5132341981,
-0.708770752,
0.6629630923,
-0.2248443216,
-0.0794266909,
0.6285265088,
-0.5770457983,
0.2286827266,
-0.1167070717,
0.182551533,
-1.1214462519,
-0.0364907719,
0.2480606437,
0.0160245169,
0.3846738636,
0.3168454766,
-0.4521431327,
-0.6048760414,
-0.2562779188,
0.5713562369,
0.2838157117,
-0.7130783796,
0.268106699,
0.0986753181,
-0.1560289562,
-0.6357672811,
-0.3347257674,
0.2293935865,
-0.0449668355,
-0.5844985843,
0.04126136,
0.1405699402,
0.0252508521,
-0.0978458449,
-0.0112199746,
0.0448280685,
0.0844755173,
0.3118139803,
0.3422951996,
-0.3055528104,
0.3953673542,
0.2151695043,
-0.5907568932,
-0.0848132595,
-0.6460561156,
0.7446500659,
0.1786012501,
-0.426432699,
-0.7418473363,
0.7397190928,
0.7743784785,
-0.232412219,
0.7173583508,
0.4034146369,
-0.2564690113,
-0.3750104606,
-0.588950038,
-0.4786174893,
-0.513440907,
0.5113046765,
-0.2904251218,
-1.106951952,
0.6556303501,
0.1046116501,
0.059045013,
0.2014746666,
0.3421864212,
-0.0029549592,
0.7788162231,
0.6181883812,
-0.5186700225,
0.5934832096,
0.185458526,
0.201300934,
-0.6396335363,
0.0249991417,
-0.5157387853,
-0.3411727548,
-0.2625184655,
-0.7361844778,
0.2227619588,
-0.1295751184,
-0.5087466836,
0.3412520587,
-0.3544490039,
0.431899488,
0.5489821434,
0.124671407,
0.3023780584,
0.148409009,
-0.0758497566,
-0.0034627847,
-0.8199084401,
-0.3703266978,
0.562784791,
0.3854642808,
0.9787397981,
-0.1283104867,
0.680595696,
0.0914419517,
0.4250439405,
-0.7424038053,
0.8680890203,
0.037300583,
-0.260207057,
-0.4260493219,
-0.6229683161,
-0.8673760891,
-0.0797687843,
0.4996361136,
-0.7853386402,
0.1189182922,
0.371553719,
-0.5811744332,
0.2351237386,
-0.6507813334,
0.5161786675,
-0.015445035,
-0.4447038472,
-0.4721234739,
-0.5193955302,
0.4130584002,
-0.1142732278,
-0.1624163389,
0.1718001813,
-0.0871405676,
0.7054774165,
-0.4464786649,
1.0804158449,
-0.156452924,
-0.2667343616,
0.1760451943,
-0.16739811,
1.0179636478,
-0.0440807082,
-0.0879481137,
-0.1001524329,
-0.3549718559,
-0.3937493265,
-0.6169756055,
1.0334280729,
-0.6084094644,
-0.8134692907,
-0.2562484443,
-0.5310566425,
-0.1246748045,
0.3006274402,
-0.0839450061,
0.3537959456,
-0.0380824879,
-0.2601839006,
0.9367903471,
-0.3433896899,
0.6033835411,
0.4483146966,
-0.1456084251,
-0.3111349344,
0.8560649753,
0.0730192512,
0.465909034,
0.5534120202,
-0.0321084149,
-0.1514205337,
-0.0585368089,
-0.3854976892,
0.5067537427,
-0.3854388595,
-0.4421780109,
-0.7515257597,
-0.1920469403,
-0.4415518343,
-0.0140063874,
-0.5537717342,
-0.3593676686,
-0.6794438958,
-0.0796432942,
0.5966821909,
0.4112557769,
0.0653735623,
0.4674621522,
-0.9502602816,
0.3239064515,
0.3366220295,
0.4747942388,
0.4886442125,
-0.6293721795,
-0.5089635253,
-0.2168010622,
-0.2766314447,
-0.7071732283,
0.1334690005,
-0.005771209,
0.5432211757,
0.6038092375,
0.1252230853,
0.8217738271,
-0.7986287475,
0.4935943782,
0.2916381955,
-0.8685810566,
0.4010721147,
-0.2414175421,
0.5109292269,
0.3065313995,
0.2291141152,
-0.8670420647,
-0.504175365,
-0.1748230904,
-1.0064653158,
0.998021245,
-0.2471762747,
0.240236029,
-0.2630754113,
0.4493888915,
-0.0220400821,
0.1507220864,
-0.2548986077,
-0.2480566055,
0.2803011239,
-0.0705971569,
0.0440406948,
-0.6131331325,
-0.1011901051,
0.0626715794,
0.5642142296,
-0.0172603186,
0.6568999887,
0.1188596636,
0.0390155688,
-0.1882084906,
0.2604161203,
0.8546625376,
0.4505284429,
0.2045178413,
0.3925704062,
0.1381209642,
-0.5725681782,
0.4228186011,
-0.085797593,
-0.2402084619,
-0.1270462424,
0.2874298096,
1.0980051756,
0.4992927909,
-0.6204987764,
0.1985939145,
-0.0318822488,
0.2445502132,
0.1593527645,
0.1599058062,
0.1866931021,
0.4471766651,
0.3679907024,
-0.2843137085,
-0.0593148395,
-0.2591439486,
0.3442124128,
0.4507475495,
-0.5969657898,
-0.1812370718,
0.3854117095,
0.2216781527,
-0.3451278508,
0.7120461464,
0.1202527732,
-0.4295452833,
0.5078876615,
0.819031179,
1.0986568928,
-0.4822190404,
0.289909035,
0.2955571413,
0.3192810118,
-0.2177057564,
0.0750726387,
-0.1094846949,
-0.3951911926,
-0.5893139243,
-0.622851193,
-0.1826106012,
0.0899677649,
-0.4390196502,
0.3311269581,
-0.4083293378,
-0.171977073,
-0.4786626697,
-0.267568022,
-0.4230124354,
-0.0360986255,
-0.0594925694,
1.0188815594,
-0.6532357335,
0.6510865688,
0.3001193702,
0.0747524872,
-0.8967936039,
-0.1758684367,
-0.3809019029,
-0.7861459851,
0.8836841583,
0.2332477421,
-0.2080362886,
-0.0213892031,
-0.2455320656,
-1.0171561241,
1.0113202333,
0.5456092358,
-0.9766374826,
0.1022382751,
0.0641258657,
0.2767888606,
-0.2166759372,
0.2822211385,
0.3893272877,
0.4743894339,
0.0985557884,
-0.9155864716,
0.4512822628,
0.0877939165,
0.0594575852,
0.383007735,
-0.9720259905,
0.6835463047,
-0.3616860807,
-0.4966931939,
0.0825298056,
0.9912545085,
0.5231558084,
0.3596345186,
0.2061555982,
0.5055582523,
0.7972955108,
0.1621453166,
0.9477683902,
-0.1663614213,
0.4085826874,
1.1472406387,
-0.4920558035,
0.7372467518,
0.9042060375,
-0.016120987,
0.0075828703,
0.5130519271,
0.3331941068,
0.5426314473,
0.3040766418,
-0.530428648,
-0.129025802,
0.0289969221,
-0.2740195096,
0.037810795,
-0.0451711379,
-0.3332033455,
-0.4716152549,
0.3030435443,
-0.0337599181,
-0.4044148028,
-0.3915532231,
0.5874887109,
0.2804272473,
-0.6902919412,
0.5929480195,
0.0084699029,
0.4722205102,
-0.4791793525,
0.0077882526,
-0.5401386619,
0.1633578092,
0.1388442367,
-0.3378138542,
0.1798764467,
0.0975276306,
-0.7484711409,
-0.278104037,
0.7351484299,
-0.2833340764,
-0.4853701591,
0.3714668751,
0.100457117,
0.0627586544,
-0.0106228972,
-0.2961099446,
0.253873378,
-0.1370953023,
-0.4928310812,
0.4621738791,
0.5103376508,
-0.4419393241,
0.8706199527,
0.512288034,
0.1622690856,
0.0869817063,
0.0963251591,
1.0629936457,
-0.8222506046,
-0.620704174,
-0.9724878073,
0.3201459944,
0.0280354023,
0.0618085898,
0.7914341688,
0.4599118531,
0.2992719114,
-0.1713740826,
0.5668022633,
0.3793974221,
0.2560140491,
-0.4988285303,
0.7636522055,
-0.2516671121,
0.4024922848,
-0.1231093332,
-0.7937412858,
-0.3206878603,
0.3145397305,
-0.5066623092,
-0.1001722813,
0.6461734772,
0.9814682007,
-0.1952355355,
-0.1614403874,
0.4175928235,
0.2236032486,
0.4368489087,
0.6250104308,
0.8187308311,
-0.2587952316,
0.1412417293,
0.2713699043,
-0.4487304688,
-0.4512763023,
-0.7915263176,
-0.5272459388,
-0.340498209,
-0.0195260737,
-0.1362147629,
0.1851241142,
0.7180216312,
0.5750715733,
-0.6910049915,
-0.3524748683,
0.0736850277,
0.3366101384,
-0.1391746551,
-0.2430629134,
0.3832459748,
-0.6936823726,
-0.498734951,
0.4195300937,
0.7996070385,
-0.2515863478,
-0.3825732768,
0.0197076816,
0.0506011881,
0.2884282768,
0.8440133929,
0.3701987267,
-0.4581066966,
-0.5070212483,
0.2382277846,
-0.3848970532,
-0.1454063207,
0.9380299449,
-0.6986840963,
0.2126552165,
0.5327008963,
0.7514477372,
0.4935719073,
-0.1554914862,
0.5002581477,
-0.6668652296,
0.2681538463,
0.1156289652,
0.1399767101,
0.1003236696,
-0.5598242879,
-0.2376661599,
0.2672162056,
-0.5990396738,
-0.9802701473,
0.3839969039,
-1.0609223843,
-0.071095109,
1.0689911842,
-0.2825431228,
-0.6891742945,
-0.0674526766,
-0.3289240897,
0.0716530308,
-0.7523981333,
0.7564759254,
0.4234555364,
-0.1520651877,
-0.3008472919,
-0.2452780753,
0.2503836453,
0.4151805341,
-0.7950174809,
0.5808597803,
0.6120103598,
0.116141513,
0.1484673619,
0.7611938119,
0.0644849688,
0.2859600186,
-0.2625208795,
0.0080019226,
-0.0248608552,
-0.6715906262,
-0.3719751835,
0.3101707697,
-0.1053852141,
-0.3089209795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14805v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14805v1
|
Identifying Multiple Personalities in Large Language Models with External Evaluation
| 2024-02-22T18:57:20 | 2024-02-22T18:57:20 |
Xiaoyang Song, Yuta Adachi, Jessie Feng, Mouwei Lin, Linhao Yu, Frank Li, Akshat Gupta, Gopala Anumanchipalli, Simerjot Kaur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are integrated with human daily applications
rapidly, many societal and ethical concerns are raised regarding the behavior
of LLMs. One of the ways to comprehend LLMs' behavior is to analyze their
personalities. Many recent studies quantify LLMs' personalities using
self-assessment tests that are created for humans. Yet many critiques question
the applicability and reliability of these self-assessment tests when applied
to LLMs. In this paper, we investigate LLM personalities using an alternate
personality measurement method, which we refer to as the external evaluation
method, where instead of prompting LLMs with multiple-choice questions in the
Likert scale, we evaluate LLMs' personalities by analyzing their responses
toward open-ended situational questions using an external machine learning
model. We first fine-tuned a Llama2-7B model as the MBTI personality predictor
that outperforms the state-of-the-art models as the tool to analyze LLMs'
responses. Then, we prompt the LLMs with situational questions and ask them to
generate Twitter posts and comments, respectively, in order to assess their
personalities when playing two different roles. Using the external personality
evaluation method, we identify that the obtained personality types for LLMs are
significantly different when generating posts versus comments, whereas humans
show a consistent personality profile in these two different situations. This
shows that LLMs can exhibit different personalities based on different
scenarios, thus highlighting a fundamental difference between personality in
LLMs and humans. With our work, we call for a re-evaluation of personality
definition and measurement in LLMs.
|
[
-0.5506632924,
-0.7819474339,
0.8680377007,
0.3795612454,
-0.0916140825,
0.1894224733,
-0.665102005,
-0.4687557817,
0.2053965479,
0.3319296837,
-0.7032134533,
-0.2039266825,
-0.6130648851,
0.4594421983,
-0.1302286834,
0.7979972959,
-0.1412923485,
0.3224556148,
-0.2331117243,
-0.2203475386,
-0.4988213181,
-0.6131150723,
-0.8899696469,
-0.3461190164,
0.9912706614,
0.3364921212,
0.3488395512,
-0.1377625912,
0.496549964,
0.4130961001,
0.0658129379,
0.1333570033,
-0.4295271337,
0.1283574551,
-0.2116023749,
-0.2690932155,
-0.1767404974,
0.0937205702,
0.745236218,
0.3223696053,
0.1929236352,
0.5459581614,
0.0847922564,
0.6053867936,
-0.4856339991,
0.0407036431,
-0.471531719,
-0.0858271793,
-0.2037736624,
-0.0631551519,
-0.4369256794,
-0.6021773219,
0.0417128392,
0.1839435697,
-0.2139769346,
-0.1543257385,
0.2804912627,
0.0212972797,
-0.7303657532,
-0.3588854671,
-0.7168999314,
0.6829349995,
-0.5727585554,
0.3556100726,
0.1216717511,
0.5007610321,
-0.1120746806,
-0.1948996186,
-0.7958967686,
-0.6169191003,
-0.0991842374,
0.1492144912,
0.1598249972,
-0.3480181992,
0.1059435606,
0.1301130205,
-0.4663957059,
0.2996950746,
-0.1816081405,
-0.028536398,
0.8511146307,
0.3181907833,
0.1216552109,
-0.0681084171,
-0.2084559947,
0.0469448604,
-0.73547858,
0.118931137,
0.7532940507,
0.0981445536,
-0.1072491109,
0.7247759104,
-0.0440424904,
0.2255302668,
0.1885685921,
-0.2237528265,
0.2501205206,
-0.0938765109,
-0.1278018653,
-0.1692924351,
0.8252444267,
0.3506281376,
0.4243254364,
0.0525139458,
-0.1559674144,
-0.1039193422,
0.2838634849,
-0.8243697882,
0.0301076695,
0.4781202376,
-0.7293738127,
-0.2313035429,
-0.0093338704,
-0.7271713018,
-0.750700593,
-0.3777889609,
0.4562672675,
-0.1299182028,
-0.5942664742,
-0.4342951477,
0.1954519302,
0.323813647,
0.3580689728,
-0.8254035115,
0.1424849182,
0.6746432185,
0.7864453197,
-0.3620163202,
-0.4436589479,
-0.4040267169,
-0.0883188099,
-0.3928189576,
0.8817802072,
-0.6188949943,
-0.441583544,
-0.0868919566,
0.0088538723,
-0.1066120788,
-0.5540781617,
0.2719452083,
-0.6143257022,
-0.0679812059,
-0.7259110212,
-0.4348714948,
-0.1183324382,
0.5500639677,
-0.3498741984,
0.8996334672,
0.146779269,
-0.7717532516,
0.3366681933,
-0.81408149,
-0.1232595965,
0.0173880402,
-0.3667003512,
-0.2763390839,
0.3034795225,
-0.129218027,
0.6532222629,
-0.2507076859,
0.2865176201,
-0.7779928446,
-0.2350619435,
0.9459784627,
-0.3119870424,
0.7064426541,
-0.1037302092,
-0.0304333046,
0.5682339668,
-0.6483435631,
0.1154227257,
0.2373694777,
-0.4153827429,
-0.2062819153,
0.1479783803,
-0.093226701,
0.5048535466,
0.4532080293,
-0.799618125,
0.24383834,
-0.2502169609,
0.2173677087,
1.0772269964,
0.0633653998,
0.0259774178,
-0.494685173,
0.3795287311,
-0.1238365546,
0.0540490597,
0.2003667802,
-0.5150463581,
-0.7819577456,
-0.3476362824,
-0.1936570108,
0.4419752657,
-0.2463972569,
0.4890660346,
-0.3130740523,
-0.7521268129,
-0.4680912495,
0.209464401,
0.2869027257,
0.1119047999,
0.1866123527,
-0.2171187252,
-0.6573631763,
-0.9642862082,
-0.432581991,
-0.2772858441,
-0.1075328588,
0.3692772686,
0.8612591028,
-0.5018009543,
0.8376079798,
-0.2672698796,
0.0744899809,
-0.4954704642,
-0.1049059629,
0.0436121747,
0.1842651665,
0.257332027,
-0.5245025754,
-0.6729943752,
-0.0129689537,
-0.6016922593,
-0.1473221481,
-0.067224279,
-0.0353425741,
0.1989869326,
0.3466478288,
-0.6067134142,
0.2153710425,
0.5619096756,
-0.2282435596,
0.8649324775,
-0.1047038436,
0.098955214,
-0.7963702083,
0.1180047393,
0.0803267807,
-0.0021038176,
-0.4615263045,
0.2180017233,
-0.0147539163,
0.3068799973,
-0.398055613,
0.8526541591,
-0.4316494763,
-0.4776764512,
-0.2329061627,
0.0460867472,
-0.197782591,
0.4297096729,
-0.0735716522,
0.5744700432,
0.410012275,
-0.4348490834,
0.5183048844,
0.071961537,
-0.4768643677,
0.9660220146,
-0.4823161066,
0.6352937818,
-0.2473968863,
0.4041535556,
-1.3482134342,
-0.1736308485,
0.3713141084,
-0.304156065,
0.1666408628,
-0.0728408992,
-0.7865923047,
-0.317504555,
-0.4701832235,
-0.0368092954,
0.2775293887,
-0.5987175107,
0.746932745,
0.245800212,
-0.3364245296,
0.0367901288,
-0.550491631,
-0.0125961537,
-0.5423496962,
-0.734580338,
0.0609291866,
-0.5811718106,
-0.7209472656,
-0.400193125,
-0.0248989649,
-0.0688414499,
0.118682988,
0.2298566848,
0.3001468182,
-0.2604924142,
0.064274542,
-0.0070881858,
0.0424107276,
0.2689003348,
0.3064403832,
0.5871554613,
-0.429504931,
-0.528770864,
-0.2908210158,
0.3673540056,
0.418523699,
-0.0723967329,
0.9273490906,
0.8088063002,
-0.2345086187,
0.1560239643,
-0.8690475821,
-0.0724551678,
-0.5054666996,
0.3587526977,
-0.6442569494,
-0.8387187123,
0.7596271634,
0.051846724,
0.1124714538,
0.4628751874,
1.1715987921,
-0.181116432,
0.894136548,
0.3760557771,
0.2309179157,
0.2026017308,
0.0571145229,
0.1780926287,
-1.2362622023,
-0.3966958821,
-0.2165411711,
-0.4507259429,
-0.6577682495,
-0.1618958563,
0.2566582263,
-0.3501325846,
-0.4472165108,
0.1433518976,
-0.1508203298,
0.486418128,
0.1395736784,
0.0444059521,
0.4224930406,
-0.4551423788,
-0.0738179237,
-0.1851439327,
0.0764623657,
-0.7979165316,
1.3433868885,
0.520465374,
0.5891950727,
0.6453562379,
0.6498662233,
0.0821706206,
1.2104510069,
-0.8532099128,
0.6658002734,
0.0526294895,
-0.6976368427,
-0.284083128,
-0.5144055486,
-0.6606153846,
0.7132989764,
-0.0237985626,
-1.2633411884,
-0.1500934064,
-0.1625112146,
-0.4512555599,
0.0713685006,
-0.9228460789,
0.8070265651,
-0.5419798493,
-0.1207917258,
-0.2141327262,
-0.5858568549,
0.6780999899,
-0.4777778089,
0.1212068722,
-0.3799076378,
-0.1744132936,
0.5851010084,
-0.150051862,
0.9773436785,
-0.0672253892,
-0.4709117115,
0.1740613878,
0.206163004,
0.3121059835,
0.275878042,
-0.257348448,
0.2948385477,
0.2667917609,
0.1559260339,
-0.6025925875,
1.1260274649,
-0.9553205371,
-0.6218062639,
-0.3826220036,
-0.2507169843,
-0.5059863925,
0.0921899974,
0.0128957191,
0.2260318398,
-0.3512994349,
0.0180015136,
0.1384048462,
-0.3429180384,
0.4197087884,
0.914200902,
-0.3875014782,
-0.2160030007,
0.7831525207,
0.1196033135,
0.2366245538,
0.2413137555,
0.5568091869,
-0.5189642906,
-0.2951338589,
-0.3643141389,
0.3388639688,
-0.7251595855,
0.1940324754,
-0.5176707506,
-0.0808273256,
-0.5029386878,
0.1417377293,
-0.3899599314,
0.195290938,
-0.256320864,
0.1552511752,
-0.0183377862,
0.8751659393,
0.2540123165,
0.2596173286,
-0.7112365365,
0.3019247055,
0.3149677217,
0.4568006694,
0.2282177061,
-0.6585335732,
0.1385609359,
-0.0977493152,
-0.5056766272,
-1.1406327486,
0.1915700585,
0.0646957234,
0.6247147322,
0.4678655267,
-0.328102082,
0.6561409235,
-0.5617175698,
0.4523863494,
-0.093896769,
-0.8140493631,
0.2451921105,
-0.2200724483,
0.18318066,
0.5961334705,
0.4478753209,
-0.7357549071,
-0.2732568383,
-0.3237913549,
-0.462998718,
0.5804044604,
0.1739021242,
0.24598822,
-0.1147095039,
0.4006347656,
0.2872524559,
0.2137595564,
-1.0127167702,
-0.3328795135,
0.106485866,
-0.0962505937,
-0.1831014454,
-0.288369447,
-0.1035321653,
-0.2106695771,
0.536175251,
-0.1502867639,
0.3689371347,
0.0235104281,
0.0112233767,
-0.1248644218,
0.421649009,
0.5841068625,
0.7445009351,
-0.2065652907,
0.0710939988,
0.2956874967,
-0.0589326508,
0.1948275566,
-0.1241468564,
0.3155057132,
-0.2193550318,
0.2061187923,
0.3637184501,
0.1320060343,
-0.7813804746,
0.5436615944,
-0.2058752477,
0.1838824749,
-0.8461946845,
-0.0661298186,
0.4009628594,
0.4501719773,
0.2110193819,
-0.0304833148,
-0.0638703406,
-0.804944098,
-0.0824102908,
0.5856368542,
-0.1173720732,
-0.5469014049,
0.1009294912,
0.2117826939,
-0.5005459785,
0.3278981447,
-0.5148699284,
-0.3631476462,
0.6640279293,
0.4093201756,
1.0638433695,
-0.3411578834,
0.0620523281,
0.140264079,
0.3812310994,
0.0682643726,
0.4147203565,
0.1715885848,
-1.0161477327,
-0.5601403117,
-0.6086096764,
-0.5235747099,
0.5844402313,
-0.4330409169,
0.295160383,
-0.5680283308,
-0.1894971132,
0.0132796913,
0.1362202018,
-0.6901305318,
-0.046656847,
0.305064261,
0.5244736075,
-0.6988136768,
0.7305526733,
0.6962288022,
-0.2090492994,
-0.3975402415,
0.3261568546,
0.2622829378,
-0.7826367617,
0.9294301867,
0.6557095647,
-0.0968890041,
-0.1493046731,
-0.2550790608,
-0.8886774778,
0.7063782215,
0.2865136266,
-0.5087139606,
0.2220776826,
0.0076397331,
0.7401149869,
-0.4364189506,
0.6675179601,
0.5667811036,
0.6158797145,
-0.0345353633,
-0.8277998567,
0.2090476304,
-0.1419661492,
0.0495163277,
0.1087863371,
-0.9509587884,
0.6794959903,
-0.3705312312,
-0.1930959821,
0.2216994315,
0.5643402338,
0.5046897531,
0.0941330716,
0.5958127975,
0.0488183312,
0.509583056,
0.2525079548,
0.9706639051,
-0.1298724264,
0.3911873698,
1.2994149923,
-0.6784248352,
1.0885626078,
0.4868043959,
-0.3965599835,
0.6605938673,
0.7545714378,
-0.0836908966,
0.1083071604,
0.47330001,
-0.1838513464,
-0.2011219114,
0.2011306882,
-0.1335789859,
0.5982419252,
0.3787468672,
-0.2351470739,
-0.0528259277,
-0.1212731004,
0.0060785799,
-0.2239674479,
-0.1527487338,
0.5897728801,
0.0813628957,
-0.7158334851,
0.0348106883,
0.3543565869,
0.7737615705,
-0.5053479075,
0.2537869215,
-0.1518474668,
0.2490319908,
-0.2013642341,
-0.8996015787,
0.5330377817,
0.1572526097,
0.1818918288,
-0.2507011294,
0.5214946866,
-0.2751977742,
-0.6058184505,
0.4153892398,
0.6003041267,
0.2678669393,
-0.2919373214,
-0.6176871657,
0.0648126602,
-0.3020093739,
-0.4960050285,
0.5564309359,
0.1334454566,
0.0477576628,
0.8501015902,
0.7211677432,
-0.0525472201,
-0.1934988052,
0.3425324261,
0.592497468,
-0.5834228992,
-0.3572300076,
-1.4149370193,
0.2844210565,
0.0446124338,
-0.5305733681,
0.9454168677,
0.4959880412,
0.7262343168,
-0.0499540009,
0.7255495191,
0.013207796,
0.641572535,
-0.3752543032,
0.4716112316,
-0.3785673082,
0.2879073322,
-0.3174021542,
-0.9040261507,
0.138292551,
0.601582706,
-0.5515993834,
0.459495306,
0.744140327,
0.5374891162,
0.1992122829,
-0.012715878,
0.2422413379,
0.4032168388,
0.2999364138,
0.4642829001,
1.2355885506,
0.0764395818,
0.3651870489,
-0.1549353749,
-0.1311879754,
-0.204847157,
-0.7808575034,
-1.282679677,
-0.4379837513,
-0.291151762,
-0.1952584684,
-0.4163908064,
1.0395809412,
0.3312110603,
-0.5713356137,
-0.3373408914,
0.3505925834,
0.1751687974,
0.0453986786,
-0.2933913469,
0.0760575533,
0.1070128307,
-0.5917953849,
0.3852155209,
0.3433199227,
-0.1348123848,
-1.0000814199,
0.08450903,
0.0099439947,
0.1574764252,
0.7643776536,
-0.058588665,
-1.0272400379,
-0.7266768813,
0.0138648339,
-0.0588913374,
0.1207345873,
0.8153597713,
-0.3874308169,
0.1798190624,
0.3346427679,
0.4978471696,
0.2212103009,
-0.0521912202,
0.2328189909,
-0.6561028361,
-0.2958190441,
0.0390487425,
0.4109858274,
0.5474453568,
-0.4409546852,
0.1455824822,
0.0946896076,
-0.5508716106,
-0.5511231422,
0.3858380616,
-0.8632314801,
-0.0795710683,
1.5680595636,
-0.1700598001,
0.1438334733,
-0.1357126981,
-0.2465999424,
-0.0967080593,
-0.4058622122,
0.8662363887,
0.9782115221,
-0.4442442358,
-0.0289903022,
-0.6101945043,
0.0733742714,
0.0891016945,
-1.0621882677,
-0.1580001563,
0.2932010293,
0.6588074565,
0.127760157,
0.8945556283,
0.0058705681,
-0.1591709256,
-0.4471507072,
-0.1209929213,
0.2713227272,
-0.1105153859,
-0.3595998287,
-0.0181148816,
0.0868317336,
0.0220552739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14804v1
|
Measuring Multimodal Mathematical Reasoning with MATH-Vision Dataset
| 2024-02-22T18:56:38 | 2024-02-22T18:56:38 |
Ke Wang, Junting Pan, Weikang Shi, Zimu Lu, Mingjie Zhan, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, math.HO
|
Recent advancements in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have shown promising
results in mathematical reasoning within visual contexts, with models
approaching human-level performance on existing benchmarks such as MathVista.
However, we observe significant limitations in the diversity of questions and
breadth of subjects covered by these benchmarks. To address this issue, we
present the MATH-Vision (MATH-V) dataset, a meticulously curated collection of
3,040 high-quality mathematical problems with visual contexts sourced from real
math competitions. Spanning 16 distinct mathematical disciplines and graded
across 5 levels of difficulty, our dataset provides a comprehensive and diverse
set of challenges for evaluating the mathematical reasoning abilities of LMMs.
Through extensive experimentation, we unveil a notable performance gap between
current LMMs and human performance on MATH-V, underscoring the imperative for
further advancements in LMMs. Moreover, our detailed categorization allows for
a thorough error analysis of LMMs, offering valuable insights to guide future
research and development. The project is available at
https://mathvision-cuhk.github.io
|
[
-0.5590860844,
-0.6493353844,
0.6113771796,
0.3513060212,
-0.1394001693,
0.1066697687,
-0.1638615131,
-0.2329475433,
-0.0010877765,
0.2216133624,
-0.8075920343,
-0.4911745787,
-0.5173444748,
0.0854509473,
-0.0417656079,
0.53196311,
-0.2183972299,
0.4469521344,
-1.0270562172,
-0.4633919299,
-0.7033994198,
-0.4217326343,
-0.1125263944,
-0.0130623151,
0.6478736997,
0.3374643624,
0.6683409214,
0.2431797832,
0.9308792949,
0.2810997069,
0.2554644346,
0.5969667435,
-0.2098135799,
0.1815266609,
-0.1618412882,
-0.5142068863,
-0.4051361382,
0.0003472168,
0.5246631503,
0.8828787804,
-0.1489153206,
0.2970311344,
-0.1979688704,
0.5466352701,
-0.7764047384,
0.45042032,
-0.2973122001,
0.2510903478,
-0.5034323931,
0.0159601253,
-0.235658139,
-0.2695802748,
0.1403900087,
-0.9154626727,
0.0958644077,
-0.1177238822,
0.5868400335,
0.4233134389,
-0.4841733277,
0.1315659136,
-0.5353016257,
0.9388178587,
-0.3176157475,
0.6455808282,
0.2552064359,
0.8525088429,
0.2468107939,
-0.6296856403,
-0.4116024077,
0.0754384249,
0.4040598273,
0.3381453753,
-0.3493330181,
-0.2650138736,
0.6338841319,
0.122100845,
-0.609187007,
-0.2473043054,
-0.5114397407,
-0.3599968851,
0.5061252713,
0.5948644876,
0.1722315848,
-0.1378367096,
-0.0911477208,
-0.3809777498,
-0.2825000882,
0.2721742094,
0.2847389281,
-0.1347498298,
-0.1206337139,
0.9379142523,
-0.2489541769,
0.8050816059,
-0.5884977579,
-0.1064381227,
0.3499610126,
-0.6786760092,
-0.0316002965,
-0.5265671611,
0.4905315042,
0.4527690411,
0.4665704966,
0.3176664412,
-0.2001510859,
0.5815101862,
0.1721858829,
-0.6467137933,
-0.3647848666,
-0.1996850222,
-0.1837438792,
0.0045268349,
0.1938285083,
-0.8829197884,
-0.4979130328,
-0.5876331925,
0.5147387981,
-0.3635877073,
-0.2155281603,
0.4174791574,
-0.3311617374,
-0.1680091769,
0.6616449952,
-0.4675033092,
-0.0084488774,
0.6711289883,
0.6788862944,
-0.0325655118,
-0.2875933349,
-0.6058859825,
-0.2226796001,
-0.2878051698,
0.7741748095,
-0.6252622008,
-0.2810098529,
-0.0996156186,
-0.4344218671,
-0.1723428518,
-0.6547558904,
0.7059441209,
-0.2039258778,
0.1193772107,
-0.317101866,
-0.3814086616,
-0.1188609675,
0.5300680399,
-0.6776801944,
0.7500185966,
0.0364084244,
-0.4418545365,
0.4887224138,
-0.6092298031,
-0.0627654195,
-0.0386213847,
-0.4870518148,
-0.5621773601,
0.3377387822,
0.5329681039,
0.1937955618,
-0.3595532775,
0.3287174702,
-0.8183860779,
0.0065076388,
0.7436103225,
-0.6991802454,
0.6511674523,
0.1544616669,
0.033550974,
0.1969749779,
-0.8565753698,
-0.0118308747,
0.1603816152,
0.2480973154,
-0.2934401035,
-0.123425968,
-0.1628855765,
0.4401574731,
0.2406136096,
-0.3725518286,
0.2558834255,
0.0431642681,
0.4254398942,
0.8656486273,
-0.3322806358,
0.2216426134,
-0.320205301,
0.5888699293,
0.3413091004,
0.5069688559,
-0.3793245852,
-0.8511681557,
-0.7470954061,
-0.3638288081,
0.1394334733,
0.4727268219,
-0.8898797035,
-0.2194619477,
-0.3671821356,
-0.3660835624,
-0.3073812723,
0.0965735316,
0.1896253526,
0.5031507611,
0.2363691181,
-0.2521183789,
-0.2731785476,
-1.0461119413,
-0.2836887836,
0.3036368191,
0.0098295771,
0.7008510232,
0.8306006789,
-0.3115054369,
1.0276930332,
-0.8447976708,
-0.4423046112,
0.2332824022,
0.177765429,
0.1024361402,
0.2390773743,
0.5485625863,
-0.8853803873,
-0.1629655808,
-0.1350366324,
-1.0564346313,
-0.2465946972,
0.0475143827,
-0.2619421184,
-0.2320581824,
0.183071062,
-0.513140738,
0.7566775084,
0.4410376847,
-0.5643754005,
0.6637138128,
-0.0604705662,
0.0563756824,
-0.6975331306,
-0.0572241247,
0.3501663208,
-0.0276467297,
-0.2204903066,
-0.1210499257,
0.1505056918,
-0.2346506864,
-0.2882005274,
0.5241988897,
-0.2115869075,
-0.3298292756,
0.3859019876,
0.0790929049,
0.200633958,
0.5609170794,
-0.1927018166,
0.6539029479,
0.7154670358,
-0.2510996163,
0.8557273746,
0.197217226,
-0.527800262,
1.0390524864,
-0.6278892159,
-0.1495881379,
-0.1817113459,
0.2082733214,
-0.9204514623,
-0.5106338859,
0.2468465716,
-0.552991569,
-0.2858570218,
0.0496241078,
-0.4483662248,
-0.2639523447,
-0.217579335,
1.0228170156,
0.0772352442,
-0.3381595612,
0.7785347104,
0.2342128009,
-0.073815532,
-0.5017285347,
-0.4514919221,
0.0967364982,
-0.1317292154,
-0.9907886386,
-0.0094153257,
-0.2328512669,
-0.6391909122,
0.0297229104,
-0.0971363485,
-0.2502587736,
-0.1118735597,
0.249247998,
0.4723713696,
-0.2794700265,
0.0554823913,
-0.0705688968,
-0.161686644,
0.4301105142,
-0.1081294343,
0.1851885468,
-0.2923179269,
-0.8409482241,
-0.2848008275,
0.2921329439,
0.9357200265,
-0.6280928254,
0.2690919936,
0.5645840168,
-0.5659478903,
-0.0979707986,
-0.3899498284,
0.0457159989,
-0.351028651,
0.2675369978,
-0.5632719994,
-0.649469316,
0.5873246193,
0.124845311,
-0.0579677224,
0.4539166689,
0.41515553,
-0.1212802827,
1.4114483595,
0.0942223668,
0.5833984613,
0.304228425,
-0.3111430705,
-0.2186247706,
-0.5561640859,
-0.6106547713,
-0.1986568421,
-0.3905746341,
-0.0602879189,
-0.8269492984,
0.809243083,
-0.2049409151,
-0.0682334825,
-0.0820170641,
-0.1931413263,
0.5191447139,
0.6251202226,
0.2242636234,
0.3320243657,
0.0596789494,
-0.326197654,
-0.5166075826,
-0.5617063046,
0.028709637,
1.171902895,
0.2144355476,
0.6714904904,
0.3542883098,
0.198758468,
0.1679152548,
0.0614364184,
-0.707271874,
0.466917336,
-0.0125929015,
-0.6645743251,
-0.1805172116,
-0.9142711163,
-0.7212108374,
0.4802696407,
-0.4047656059,
-0.2923205793,
0.1015632376,
0.0621832982,
-0.4712038338,
0.1762824655,
-0.5800456405,
1.2803015709,
-0.4102548361,
-0.5483962893,
-0.3032329381,
-0.4785740376,
0.674241364,
-0.1565408558,
0.3896599114,
-0.2288532108,
0.0071478784,
0.5365357399,
-0.4445240498,
0.7061969042,
-0.0712947771,
-0.1369406581,
0.223293975,
0.13721174,
0.0665520057,
0.3282563984,
0.4901625216,
0.3414238989,
0.0996113196,
-0.5063529015,
-0.8237598538,
0.4543270767,
-0.6654806137,
-0.2472481877,
-0.6433811784,
-0.7914671898,
-0.4865201116,
0.1683359146,
0.136496827,
1.0850777626,
0.1760708541,
0.3775094151,
0.656332612,
-0.2084993571,
0.1830844432,
-0.083290413,
-0.346711129,
-0.6497801542,
1.0990315676,
0.22212255,
0.0914183855,
0.2823146284,
0.2010343969,
-0.5935901999,
-0.1982478499,
-0.6868053675,
0.168429628,
-0.8589212298,
-0.2323965877,
-0.2869322896,
-0.0146418884,
-0.1293343753,
0.1092838868,
-0.3745276034,
-0.5194603205,
-0.2590196431,
0.3717775345,
0.0192004181,
0.4414612949,
0.0000291153,
-0.1291387528,
-0.8080700636,
0.5496658683,
0.713388443,
0.5026808977,
-0.3398784101,
-0.3172849417,
-0.1252863854,
0.2937307358,
-0.412114352,
-0.3834170103,
0.214682579,
0.0907407627,
0.5067734718,
0.4622760713,
-0.1784466803,
1.0519262552,
-0.2910129428,
0.5764147639,
0.5155873299,
-0.8826267123,
0.4522395432,
-0.4646499157,
0.4845435917,
0.2861746252,
-0.0275572762,
-0.2284302562,
0.0244121514,
-0.3802569211,
-0.3439447284,
0.344989568,
0.3728357553,
-0.1924043596,
0.2333309948,
-0.0017553349,
0.056964945,
0.1622992009,
-0.4566400051,
-0.0666330308,
-0.386493504,
-0.3707558811,
-0.1194163337,
0.1775742471,
-0.3695810437,
-0.5280326009,
0.0356978253,
-0.1811839193,
0.0682353154,
-0.0511412397,
-0.3320464492,
-0.0123401554,
-0.0383188426,
1.0686132908,
1.2297986746,
0.0232767221,
0.2794676125,
0.0625313744,
-0.5696924925,
-0.0980456918,
0.1558248699,
0.2095920444,
-0.1422457546,
0.5143055916,
0.6788229942,
0.3956295848,
-1.0645495653,
0.648841083,
-0.3041595519,
-0.4573961496,
-0.3649259508,
-0.1037962586,
-0.1528838128,
0.4538273811,
0.3702322245,
0.6600802541,
0.0831357539,
-0.302490145,
0.20686014,
0.3642044961,
-0.1197472885,
-0.3082340956,
0.8758801222,
0.1874210685,
0.0386085361,
0.6878381968,
0.0597206391,
-0.4012627006,
0.6799094677,
0.015960535,
0.5202138424,
0.2298523635,
0.1548571438,
0.4412548542,
0.171924606,
-0.0797470063,
0.2237343639,
-0.1493216306,
-0.7566569448,
-0.6630257368,
-0.3513689935,
-0.5562931895,
-0.2678240538,
-0.7589682937,
0.2104010582,
-0.2866863906,
-0.280662626,
0.2050812095,
-0.2953315675,
-0.7097216845,
0.1656962484,
0.3662258983,
0.6440962553,
-0.6558918953,
0.4526577592,
0.6959270239,
-0.3590390384,
-0.2501156926,
-0.6127006412,
0.2227649242,
-0.9559437633,
0.7407861948,
0.2745615542,
-0.2298848778,
-0.2816195786,
-0.4804916084,
-0.5699357986,
0.9978488088,
0.4045907855,
-0.6454443932,
0.0546380691,
0.3312393129,
0.2641052902,
-0.1442544162,
0.1791089922,
0.0984480903,
0.4781843424,
0.1822854131,
-0.8916620016,
-0.5611868501,
-0.4638699591,
-0.0961235017,
0.392331183,
-0.4505164623,
0.9764659405,
-0.3131585717,
0.0312936977,
-0.0708788782,
0.5230734348,
0.5956285,
0.9299550056,
0.69139117,
1.0192439556,
0.5310141444,
-0.4068129659,
0.7633259892,
0.1400405169,
0.4221430421,
0.6624404788,
-0.1405978948,
0.4652562141,
0.3832877576,
-0.2084671259,
0.201226905,
0.477992028,
-0.0738077536,
0.2783180177,
0.2025848329,
-0.2517544925,
-0.9869192839,
-0.1124938801,
-0.5220806599,
0.6289867163,
0.4290237129,
0.0684051439,
-0.3254428208,
0.2253785729,
-0.3071565926,
0.1818599552,
-0.4766565561,
0.1596898139,
0.0341619812,
-0.5844096541,
0.1653386056,
-0.3082759976,
0.4675435722,
-0.4987332225,
-0.3981956542,
-0.2967424989,
0.4348394573,
-0.0540772267,
-1.0180102587,
0.1434421837,
-0.0497597307,
-0.217886731,
-0.2629682124,
0.4658589959,
-0.1755360067,
-0.8124750853,
-0.1480308622,
0.7956860065,
-0.0666358322,
-0.2674757838,
-0.6230259538,
0.2988865674,
-0.2905195951,
0.1240169629,
0.3267884552,
0.7980447412,
-0.359724462,
0.8608071804,
0.9012539983,
-0.3114013076,
0.3477949202,
0.2361921817,
0.7834898829,
-0.6842480302,
-0.377245903,
-0.951377511,
0.5529869795,
-0.178332299,
-0.8345502615,
0.970241487,
0.7897943854,
0.9570321441,
-0.2439120114,
0.4670174718,
0.4054632187,
0.187498197,
-0.4132497907,
0.1864300221,
-0.86123842,
0.121807225,
-0.3659015894,
-0.8035821319,
-0.7290784121,
0.7161723375,
-0.2896675467,
-0.0364313461,
0.4810096622,
0.4970267415,
-0.3728579283,
-0.1117298827,
0.4999436438,
-0.2042320073,
0.1951635927,
0.8388295174,
1.3091595173,
-0.1162511259,
0.8330811262,
-0.3836025596,
-0.3007754087,
-0.2421340048,
-0.6840978265,
-0.8701325059,
-0.503467083,
-0.3440782428,
-0.2604245245,
-0.4614539146,
0.6162179708,
0.6101804376,
-0.4593238533,
-0.0941119492,
0.0696295053,
0.1399191171,
-0.3419854045,
-0.1748673469,
0.020496197,
-0.0183484964,
-0.6783204079,
0.0878708735,
0.4383453131,
-0.0381024964,
-0.4224300981,
-0.0712154657,
0.2281629741,
-0.0846191272,
0.922077775,
0.1037989259,
-0.7370148897,
-0.053502094,
0.4962639511,
0.0279268622,
-0.0078125028,
0.898532033,
-0.6163875461,
0.8542105556,
0.5624334812,
0.6322509646,
0.4633898735,
-0.189817667,
0.2948619425,
-0.4936778247,
-0.0694770217,
0.3263687491,
0.641448915,
0.1259351671,
0.1819516867,
0.5226484537,
0.8114920259,
-0.2889559865,
-1.0620350838,
0.3813621402,
-1.2680281401,
-0.1037098616,
0.9062301517,
0.047024481,
-0.0774571598,
0.1044658497,
-0.3330320418,
-0.2629626691,
-0.2122331858,
0.5989173055,
0.9631425738,
-0.2495376319,
-0.4053679109,
-0.8125052452,
0.0593472496,
0.482052058,
-0.9146838188,
-0.1879279613,
0.9796841145,
-0.0133124785,
0.2844678462,
0.0927673504,
-0.1778849512,
0.6472998261,
0.2247958183,
-0.2321572453,
-0.3564529121,
-0.5908524394,
-0.2665294707,
0.3883679509,
-0.4529004693,
-0.256556958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14800v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14800v2
|
Not All Experts are Equal: Efficient Expert Pruning and Skipping for Mixture-of-Experts Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T18:56:07 | 2024-05-30T16:24:16 |
Xudong Lu, Qi Liu, Yuhui Xu, Aojun Zhou, Siyuan Huang, Bo Zhang, Junchi Yan, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A pivotal advancement in the progress of large language models (LLMs) is the
emergence of the Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) LLMs. Compared to traditional LLMs,
MoE LLMs can achieve higher performance with fewer parameters, but it is still
hard to deploy them due to their immense parameter sizes. Different from
previous weight pruning methods that rely on specifically designed hardware,
this paper mainly aims to enhance the deployment efficiency of MoE LLMs by
introducing plug-and-play expert-level sparsification techniques. Specifically,
we propose, for the first time to our best knowledge, post-training approaches
for task-agnostic and task-specific expert pruning and skipping of MoE LLMs,
tailored to improve deployment efficiency while maintaining model performance
across a wide range of tasks. Extensive experiments show that our proposed
methods can simultaneously reduce model sizes and increase the inference speed,
while maintaining satisfactory performance. Data and code will be available at
https://github.com/Lucky-Lance/Expert_Sparsity.
|
[
-0.7117213011,
-0.6625372767,
0.3464940786,
0.4365209043,
-0.2327807844,
0.3909552395,
-0.3794320524,
-0.1320181638,
0.1915639788,
0.3540820777,
-0.4787479639,
-0.2680985034,
-0.8798855543,
-0.0967502967,
-0.3971351087,
0.7335628867,
0.1656855047,
-0.1996203214,
-0.1861490607,
0.0197234172,
-0.564419806,
-0.3405171037,
-0.5683107376,
-0.1975735128,
0.4716180563,
0.3824262619,
0.6606593728,
0.756629169,
0.2174988985,
0.3028214276,
-0.323299706,
0.6880217195,
-0.6828126311,
-0.0761786997,
-0.0986387208,
-0.3200364113,
-0.6277244687,
-0.2129944116,
0.4782459736,
0.7307172418,
-0.4278571606,
-0.2421638072,
0.1398621351,
0.3783981502,
-0.7257484198,
-0.2283337563,
-0.8550579548,
-0.090979062,
-0.1260003,
-0.5446376801,
-0.4111527801,
-0.1711817086,
-0.0536680296,
-0.7625282407,
0.3797412813,
0.2147183865,
0.5797003508,
0.4201429784,
-0.3939585686,
0.1845760345,
-0.7233552337,
1.025485754,
-0.9065943956,
0.3660232127,
0.1802898943,
-0.0794094279,
-0.4108596444,
-0.0159733705,
-0.280014962,
-0.0397723988,
0.1760841608,
-0.1063485742,
-0.02848888,
0.0942099839,
-0.0222610813,
0.2765944898,
-0.5298935771,
0.4014417529,
-0.395080477,
-0.1402962953,
0.8019198179,
-0.0431456715,
0.0853752568,
0.4188677073,
-0.2773684263,
0.2800915241,
-0.9689480662,
-0.3784189522,
0.4155625105,
0.0007643903,
0.325792402,
0.3848177195,
-0.1514500976,
1.0008491278,
0.20236893,
-0.373745054,
0.1165520772,
-0.0918455347,
-0.0565581247,
-0.2570153475,
0.6715539098,
0.1913350224,
0.4591091871,
-0.5296144485,
-0.3799016476,
-0.1953619123,
0.3330341578,
-0.4807037711,
-0.5606231093,
-0.006930639,
-0.1755327731,
-0.2864416838,
-0.1700011641,
-0.489079684,
-0.365272969,
-0.2568057179,
0.4327437282,
-0.4652492702,
-0.7272171378,
0.1535160989,
-0.1104494929,
-0.149172008,
0.4164200425,
-0.8015341759,
0.5175808072,
1.0218888521,
0.6235248446,
-0.3369905651,
-0.4396004975,
-0.7133177519,
0.2326485515,
-0.4879775047,
0.6322275996,
-0.5364047289,
-0.5868234038,
-0.1606880575,
-0.3889111578,
-0.2014073431,
-0.7860509753,
0.2995755672,
-0.6682621837,
-0.1900557876,
-0.1538641453,
-0.6585434079,
-0.2286825925,
0.1262516677,
-0.0902754441,
1.2686700821,
0.073562555,
-0.4612309933,
0.4982464015,
-0.0871133208,
-0.7626277804,
0.071720615,
-0.1671689898,
-0.212498188,
0.487668097,
0.3995320499,
0.6078102589,
-0.104286164,
0.6318485141,
-0.272778213,
-0.4805397987,
0.1019762605,
-0.2925939262,
0.3871896565,
0.1941661388,
-0.2700453103,
-0.0227555968,
-0.6460555792,
-0.044881247,
0.0083868299,
-0.4281988442,
-0.4737191498,
0.3184297979,
0.0307272263,
0.210328564,
0.1926420778,
-0.2520128489,
0.1530311257,
-0.2745577693,
0.3253124356,
0.8855640292,
-0.1078266129,
0.4853253067,
-0.368170321,
0.4933115542,
0.0870426446,
-0.0734878257,
-0.0885046944,
-0.5559824705,
-0.9332962632,
-0.5753299594,
0.3156628311,
0.4874493182,
-0.6432664394,
0.941806376,
-0.3492134213,
-0.5611373782,
-0.5999682546,
0.6524003744,
0.5458287001,
0.4083509743,
0.3346326351,
-0.4307361841,
-0.3437476754,
-0.9235337377,
-0.5320677757,
-0.0862974152,
-0.075851649,
0.2018925399,
0.1842256486,
0.1100430042,
1.301713109,
-0.4290543199,
-0.0012966628,
-0.3226121664,
0.239572227,
-0.0142708281,
0.7543253899,
0.560068965,
-0.5835462213,
-0.4256754816,
0.0583997816,
-0.2494803071,
-0.2940981686,
0.0758678094,
-0.1546566635,
0.0186855979,
0.3490870595,
-0.720076859,
0.1967088729,
0.3419176638,
0.0361887366,
0.4339030385,
-0.3123515844,
0.0951056555,
-0.7819002867,
-0.00897313,
0.3825936615,
-0.4600691199,
-0.7850677371,
0.1662717909,
-0.0465208963,
0.168680042,
-0.2554362118,
0.4849026203,
-0.6769428253,
-0.1337245107,
-0.2744151056,
-0.0102717448,
-0.0237671901,
0.6166096926,
0.2411065251,
0.8553898335,
0.657471776,
-0.8551558852,
0.0490867831,
0.0164388418,
-0.2259902358,
0.4109385014,
-0.6461488008,
0.1056918576,
0.0023496833,
-0.0201290213,
-0.9122652411,
-0.1578093469,
0.2294985056,
-0.3156630695,
0.6405206919,
-0.2718770504,
-0.5507851839,
-0.2232443392,
-0.0885015801,
0.3556284904,
0.8702474833,
-0.3185327053,
0.5791504979,
0.506978631,
-0.5512499809,
-0.6251143217,
-0.695861578,
0.0836047009,
-0.3311214149,
-0.4998571277,
0.1692295521,
-0.192686379,
-0.1629215181,
-0.1682079285,
-0.3255263865,
-0.3461497724,
0.3606752157,
-0.256226182,
0.0444893427,
-0.0032094503,
0.0729580224,
0.2641713917,
-0.1700037271,
-0.1657291651,
-0.1515660137,
0.3268908262,
0.340203613,
-0.6144067049,
-0.2150152177,
0.2642353773,
0.2353047282,
-0.3492506742,
0.6456469893,
0.6859325767,
-0.157290563,
-0.2651942372,
-1.289462328,
-0.1153587624,
-0.4618662,
0.5669440627,
-0.2454921305,
-0.8807576299,
0.1851832569,
-0.1201495379,
0.5294529796,
0.172863245,
0.3990685344,
0.0658310279,
0.9968683124,
0.7771388292,
-0.4341669977,
0.3087470531,
0.0200319625,
0.3694247901,
-0.4987564385,
0.0288285185,
-0.5367437601,
-0.2027923316,
0.1781346053,
-0.6625711322,
0.3052864075,
0.2499511242,
-0.0734172389,
0.0462764204,
-0.6286048293,
0.4201888144,
0.3813017607,
0.1899210811,
0.2866057158,
0.2755422294,
0.4056242704,
0.0806290209,
-1.1718466282,
-0.1986493766,
0.9630944133,
0.3688095808,
0.6597720981,
-0.2423527539,
0.724324286,
0.1846714169,
0.282532692,
-0.715564549,
0.7401985526,
-0.0660520792,
-0.5506108999,
-0.26282987,
-0.689093709,
-0.5799626112,
0.4384621084,
-0.0650473237,
-0.4742811918,
0.2843230069,
0.4145440757,
-0.5446915627,
0.3791372776,
-0.7085508704,
0.5387399197,
-0.0517188124,
-0.1719906926,
-0.6277460456,
-0.3743875027,
0.3778484762,
-0.2373782396,
0.5524323583,
-0.2328788489,
-0.5228081346,
0.8216466904,
-0.730076611,
0.7340509892,
-0.3683592379,
-0.0020675904,
0.2569742501,
0.2628205419,
0.6397050619,
-0.4285837114,
0.0614191778,
0.012744274,
-0.5923660398,
-0.585611701,
-0.4873342216,
0.7934129238,
-0.7892714143,
-0.6982837915,
0.11875844,
-0.6192787886,
-0.4030337334,
0.1018394232,
0.1181733534,
0.5466880202,
0.0405125767,
0.1032888442,
1.0980089903,
-0.0222419258,
0.2724281251,
0.5642954707,
0.1493907869,
-0.3671003282,
1.2134826183,
0.4355945289,
0.0917421654,
0.2134598643,
-0.1815198213,
0.0400664955,
-1.1485968828,
-0.3520893157,
0.164590627,
-0.4201691151,
-0.1289233565,
-0.9100610614,
0.0330883935,
-0.398793906,
-0.3940556049,
-0.5157988667,
-0.410803169,
-0.3925593793,
-0.0582219064,
0.5723884702,
0.75158602,
0.0755357966,
0.8015918136,
-0.849018991,
0.0175205618,
0.193802461,
0.318751812,
0.2428342104,
-0.6198573709,
-0.5174403191,
-0.2113018483,
-0.2183933258,
-0.6422606707,
0.508693099,
0.3363858163,
0.8776834011,
0.5243390203,
-0.1649291068,
0.9020591974,
-0.4293993115,
0.6243163943,
0.2657485604,
-0.8039495349,
0.1069166362,
-0.4630644023,
-0.0026724134,
0.4601774812,
0.4117202759,
-0.2917560041,
-0.6478244066,
-0.590290308,
-1.130815506,
0.7373413444,
-0.0228532013,
-0.050135579,
0.084254168,
0.2150911093,
0.4464176893,
0.4802238345,
-0.3789957166,
-0.1901389807,
0.2592540085,
-0.2310810238,
-0.386903137,
-0.405199945,
-0.1567118764,
-0.1749932766,
0.9522215128,
0.1036554873,
-0.0808601081,
0.0183718055,
-0.5820821524,
-0.1264800429,
0.1976870149,
0.3344214559,
0.9505963326,
0.0802702606,
-0.0638793558,
0.3561972082,
-0.1140076369,
0.1186514646,
0.0637933761,
-0.0726178139,
0.2205878347,
0.3012898862,
0.6749223471,
0.6456714869,
-0.5535107255,
0.4776345193,
0.3807813525,
-0.4119210243,
-0.0779855698,
0.370775491,
0.1691259444,
-0.0702936724,
0.6959046125,
0.4424878359,
0.1037624031,
-0.0615913272,
-0.0148115382,
0.2556161582,
0.0491337739,
-0.2505222261,
0.4725216031,
0.4180312157,
-0.2604579329,
0.3415551484,
-0.0894072428,
-0.3284436166,
0.578184247,
-0.0270187054,
0.6026585102,
-0.5311608315,
-0.0075529884,
0.0045776521,
0.4359892905,
-0.3854674399,
0.0785865635,
-0.2235175073,
-0.5513710976,
-0.7964957356,
-0.2796559036,
-0.2019289732,
-0.2001786828,
-0.4716560245,
0.1505664885,
-0.4790620804,
-0.0915406868,
-0.2682766318,
-0.2464011163,
-0.743409574,
0.1708712429,
0.0686761886,
1.1772119999,
-1.0152614117,
0.5972994566,
0.7628467083,
0.1468371004,
-0.7306346297,
-0.2792131901,
-0.162610203,
-0.5823535323,
0.263969183,
0.0180020593,
0.1762886345,
0.2176343799,
-0.3916271329,
-0.6451932192,
0.6648071408,
0.2167386264,
-0.7680538297,
-0.1193112582,
-0.1872673333,
0.1817908287,
-0.2656990588,
0.5905736089,
0.6918709874,
0.59210217,
-0.0263958182,
-1.1157981157,
-0.2652782202,
-0.3323568702,
0.0581780747,
0.1419148892,
-0.6475656033,
0.6713712215,
0.1805029809,
0.2752800286,
0.0562810041,
0.7901547551,
0.3437927663,
0.1378251165,
0.8691889644,
0.6461632252,
0.6641550064,
-0.0496355891,
0.7166609764,
-0.4356761575,
0.0791625381,
0.7729552388,
-0.1631762683,
0.6965021491,
0.4526925385,
-0.2664297223,
0.0405032262,
0.728178978,
0.1001444981,
0.4296879768,
0.0581280813,
-0.1801385731,
-0.7096938491,
0.1694682837,
-0.4016324878,
-0.1025799289,
0.4492717385,
-0.0211436935,
-0.1946320832,
-0.0119414646,
0.1288428158,
-0.030882882,
-0.5044888854,
0.8522847295,
0.0977445245,
-0.7710140944,
0.7246275544,
0.0417725705,
1.1478937864,
-0.5955587626,
0.3185452521,
-0.0242500789,
0.0054520606,
-0.4565657675,
-0.5971736908,
0.121244356,
-0.0405496992,
-0.1031037718,
-0.3615945578,
0.7486436367,
-0.6251431108,
-0.3503733575,
0.1443315595,
0.7906889319,
0.5230491757,
-0.136132881,
-0.5377659798,
-0.0057843546,
-0.0506790094,
-0.5827049613,
0.5248096585,
0.4017394185,
0.1233009249,
0.8633012176,
0.2999226153,
0.2898715138,
0.3969760537,
-0.1194164008,
1.1556866169,
-0.2107112706,
-0.4727060795,
-0.7066675425,
0.7791518569,
-0.0019606957,
-0.1863355041,
0.737611711,
0.5504429936,
0.7269363403,
-0.0848742947,
0.8457807899,
0.0755920559,
0.6949833632,
-0.1927805692,
0.46557042,
-0.7901345491,
0.1725322753,
-0.371588558,
-0.9168764353,
-0.1216604933,
0.3281980455,
-0.4484954476,
0.3970458806,
0.1178733334,
0.9082570672,
-0.3573099375,
-0.2902565002,
0.3724392653,
0.2461919934,
0.2408680767,
0.3288715184,
0.6843447089,
0.1010843292,
0.5688601136,
-0.2557706833,
-0.4483196139,
-0.5603556633,
-0.7160280943,
-0.8224648833,
-0.191102311,
-0.6056817174,
0.2788672447,
0.3563929498,
1.0140316486,
1.1462548971,
-0.5631349087,
-0.2624543905,
-0.2036361396,
0.0759433135,
-0.2763151526,
-0.1657134742,
0.027497774,
-0.3926721513,
-0.6159973145,
0.7792176008,
0.2190419734,
-0.3081188798,
-0.4177606404,
-0.1484216899,
-0.0533469543,
0.0080586569,
0.342168957,
0.2806962729,
-0.726334691,
0.1446519941,
-0.2580099702,
0.1754069477,
0.0787231773,
0.8476487994,
-0.7502579689,
0.175284788,
0.5172950029,
0.7135646939,
0.0784269497,
0.0783587322,
0.8548446298,
-0.8727515936,
0.3888949156,
0.304292202,
0.4142342508,
0.2738136947,
-0.4089982808,
0.3488264084,
0.3357352912,
-0.5960600972,
-1.020223856,
-0.0105338302,
-0.6595959663,
-0.2289465219,
1.0291898251,
-0.4159705341,
-0.0916100219,
-0.3401628733,
-0.2457266599,
0.0885017067,
-0.601124227,
0.568433702,
0.7051617503,
0.2713955343,
-0.3399500847,
-0.5098199248,
0.1369114667,
0.9325938821,
-0.4099538326,
0.0658227429,
0.3785560429,
0.4675712287,
-0.1025825515,
0.7283631563,
0.2428551167,
0.2058526725,
-0.136429593,
0.4183873832,
-0.4741929471,
-0.4946561456,
-0.3544206619,
0.1063583568,
0.4139889181,
0.1706969291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14904v1
|
Watermarking Makes Language Models Radioactive
| 2024-02-22T18:55:22 | 2024-02-22T18:55:22 |
Tom Sander, Pierre Fernandez, Alain Durmus, Matthijs Douze, Teddy Furon
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper investigates the radioactivity of LLM-generated texts, i.e.
whether it is possible to detect that such input was used as training data.
Conventional methods like membership inference can carry out this detection
with some level of accuracy. We show that watermarked training data leaves
traces easier to detect and much more reliable than membership inference. We
link the contamination level to the watermark robustness, its proportion in the
training set, and the fine-tuning process. We notably demonstrate that training
on watermarked synthetic instructions can be detected with high confidence
(p-value < 1e-5) even when as little as 5% of training text is watermarked.
Thus, LLM watermarking, originally designed for detecting machine-generated
text, gives the ability to easily identify if the outputs of a watermarked LLM
were used to fine-tune another LLM.
|
[
-0.1152429059,
-0.6211932302,
0.7432152033,
-0.4082460701,
-0.3462088108,
0.1390791088,
0.0379309468,
-0.531252265,
-0.088808082,
0.7234639525,
-0.5396236181,
-0.4285908341,
-0.7952547073,
0.0477011018,
-0.6834089756,
0.7684511542,
0.1413242221,
0.1733146757,
-0.3636718988,
-0.2227627039,
0.0890572816,
-0.5558680892,
-0.5737848878,
-0.8787729144,
0.4186529517,
0.1113305688,
0.8109896183,
1.12496984,
0.0671105757,
0.3322136998,
-0.2034274191,
0.244261682,
-0.6914793253,
0.1833252013,
0.0181336794,
-0.6419247389,
0.0324226953,
0.2086822391,
0.4523100257,
0.2979389727,
0.4271295369,
-0.205211699,
0.0620995052,
0.6995977163,
-0.7155421376,
0.3258855641,
-0.8220202327,
-0.1867374629,
-0.2609185278,
-0.5952110291,
-0.7468994856,
-0.2693732679,
-0.2922836244,
-0.7230445743,
0.206919387,
0.0324309543,
1.3043482304,
0.1979524642,
-0.0691998377,
-0.5470430255,
-0.8451760411,
1.0006017685,
-0.828371048,
0.2364755273,
0.9630539417,
-0.0558442026,
-0.324332267,
-0.6766825318,
-0.4502795041,
-0.2252804786,
-0.0295565184,
0.0922235921,
-0.1422712356,
0.1007855982,
0.4183963835,
0.4757986963,
-0.2327289283,
0.0280772261,
-0.1070532277,
-0.2651833296,
0.4594349861,
-0.0633863881,
0.722976625,
0.0808414519,
-0.1430360377,
-0.2528831661,
-1.1466155052,
-0.4497636855,
0.6355324388,
0.1235002726,
-0.0861418173,
0.6074963212,
-0.2244910598,
0.5373663902,
-0.4383533597,
-0.2507799864,
-0.2723901272,
-0.061951533,
-0.3142132461,
0.0189225283,
0.8280172944,
-0.1154885739,
0.9036106467,
-0.24384588,
-0.2992767692,
0.1555111706,
-0.0084359329,
-0.9013996124,
-0.5060582161,
-0.0700597018,
-0.3107307851,
-0.552788198,
0.0556030385,
0.0393914469,
-0.4123343527,
-0.2217770368,
0.6618027091,
-0.6780747175,
0.0269365069,
0.3644284606,
-0.286333859,
0.0527595617,
0.159996599,
-1.0124502182,
0.1735583842,
0.8528755307,
0.4365296662,
0.0417803451,
-0.0350305215,
-0.3760415018,
0.3486779034,
-0.2205582857,
0.9024543166,
-0.6601210833,
-0.2531984746,
-0.0000140829,
-0.1593302339,
0.3246279359,
-0.575866282,
0.0402691588,
-0.8829922676,
0.485147208,
-0.0724458098,
-0.9208108783,
0.0150638074,
0.0702951849,
-0.8750215769,
1.1084463596,
0.1668760478,
-1.0756109953,
0.4863256514,
0.0573484674,
-0.2305567712,
0.2312922925,
-0.3259328604,
-0.7648379207,
-0.1009460241,
-0.0146134235,
0.3024525642,
-0.2113411576,
0.247079581,
-0.3866174817,
-0.6369628906,
0.7239320874,
-0.7026805878,
0.8735389113,
0.0058637541,
-0.2875101864,
-0.1926814318,
-0.8190472126,
0.2638613582,
-0.098748982,
-0.7758373618,
-0.6885641217,
0.2288197577,
-0.1921437383,
-0.0960822254,
-0.0421565697,
-0.4730524123,
-0.0445187353,
-0.3027032912,
0.4283650517,
0.6322135925,
0.3296410143,
0.1115729213,
-0.7237969041,
0.4586207271,
-0.3491902053,
0.0400625691,
-0.1922835559,
-0.6698944569,
-0.831256032,
-0.4976464212,
0.5675135255,
0.1912294179,
-0.9497379661,
0.3893895149,
-0.3854526579,
-0.3531524539,
-0.4236957431,
0.1661432832,
0.5350829363,
0.0869946182,
0.2400473803,
0.0029056384,
-0.3523538113,
-0.9201469421,
-0.4370757043,
-0.4244618714,
-0.2591367364,
0.2925920188,
0.6096369028,
-0.1101610959,
0.8642394543,
-0.2465734482,
0.0029551266,
-0.0278354082,
0.3582653403,
-0.1846409589,
0.5075150132,
0.271651268,
-0.4840082228,
-0.4997591376,
-0.114284277,
-0.9412935972,
-0.5080429912,
-0.1896692067,
0.0964692235,
-0.190691784,
0.7721782327,
-0.2262715399,
0.4433948994,
0.6782035828,
-0.123054266,
0.0892165899,
-0.2177193463,
0.1760714799,
-0.9259732366,
0.1329437494,
-0.4263044298,
-0.3928824961,
-0.497810334,
0.1098708883,
0.0640880764,
-0.0920469239,
-0.4440020025,
0.3684767485,
-0.6383522153,
0.0586793721,
-0.6138629913,
-0.0387898982,
0.264080435,
0.0361038633,
-0.0317430086,
0.8956004977,
0.264026463,
-0.3618029058,
-0.069703728,
0.0312192775,
-0.5126881599,
0.1060285196,
-0.5985299349,
0.3145882189,
-0.1483814865,
-0.1977536678,
-1.0244864225,
-0.0268274229,
-0.0243739802,
-0.456233412,
0.4016801119,
-0.4422110617,
-0.5895510316,
0.4403793216,
-0.3401444554,
0.2843137383,
0.5333024263,
-0.3400137126,
0.5648801923,
0.2012985349,
0.3849446476,
-0.5683410764,
-0.9482058883,
-0.0364824533,
-0.146080941,
-0.414526403,
0.4417866766,
0.1003385037,
-0.2131973952,
0.0642936751,
-0.1255888641,
-0.2051135153,
0.5297423601,
0.54603827,
0.099802658,
-0.1623008251,
-0.1614473015,
-0.0594612323,
-0.3227095902,
0.1732060909,
0.2079474628,
0.6197462678,
0.4442685843,
-0.3741920888,
-0.572840929,
0.1320536882,
0.6125090718,
0.0619447976,
0.707033813,
0.1223965809,
-0.59363693,
-0.4916547239,
-0.4104412794,
-0.4473615289,
-0.6041232347,
-0.0278189797,
0.0140047185,
-0.8660029769,
0.444378674,
-0.049252741,
-0.1508714557,
0.1408426315,
0.2018541694,
-0.2209668159,
0.6659729481,
0.6581573486,
-0.2582563162,
0.7627025247,
-0.2230166644,
-0.0007905298,
-0.6004208922,
-0.1912623346,
-0.7793986797,
-0.0425052941,
-0.6603175402,
-0.4505015314,
0.1004382595,
0.1860953867,
-0.1450968087,
0.32855618,
-0.3445253968,
0.8776029348,
0.3783869743,
0.2228554934,
0.5209792852,
0.2999136448,
-0.0442369506,
-0.2863667309,
-0.5808752179,
-0.8167470694,
0.9037923217,
0.3215344846,
0.9691942334,
-0.2705548108,
1.1028666496,
0.3935184181,
0.7931295633,
-0.7010992765,
0.5159454346,
-0.1154281348,
-0.7119193077,
-0.1459219009,
-0.4731505215,
-1.051012516,
-0.0565314554,
-0.491510123,
-0.3399505913,
-0.091903016,
-0.1019613668,
0.183356896,
0.3158845007,
-0.2687644958,
0.2619512677,
-0.1604297757,
-0.5236262083,
-0.2048577517,
-0.0462736413,
0.1753693372,
-0.1323866099,
0.3503935635,
-0.349981904,
0.0629164129,
0.9250820875,
-0.356515944,
0.9004897475,
0.058525566,
-0.2356173396,
0.1661032587,
0.4810694754,
0.4462035894,
0.073098138,
-0.1747373641,
-0.0178958513,
-0.2192564905,
-0.2482501268,
-0.3811150193,
0.6396968961,
-0.7689695358,
-0.4642449319,
-0.6807952523,
-0.567273736,
-0.1096438468,
0.6047829986,
0.4558011293,
0.3740250468,
-0.1009652317,
0.4086285233,
1.0488773584,
-0.433105588,
0.4071946442,
0.8425796032,
0.0037202847,
-0.4323922098,
0.8833723068,
-0.0175459124,
0.5214615464,
0.5978521109,
0.3154519498,
0.0771193877,
-0.9266165495,
-0.1555561572,
0.4879370928,
-0.86541605,
-0.4338321388,
-0.3686951697,
-0.4241796434,
0.3041931689,
-0.1111839488,
-0.4279285967,
-0.2753785551,
-0.5591730475,
0.0349471122,
0.4089124501,
0.9506008029,
0.199454084,
0.3836348355,
-0.5418711305,
0.3966517746,
0.4072110653,
0.2420477271,
-0.464012742,
-0.6804443598,
-0.176171422,
0.328997761,
-0.0538632199,
-0.7049281597,
0.1209367514,
0.3903741837,
0.3359982073,
0.5035121441,
-0.0100685181,
0.509770155,
-0.2772815526,
0.5929819345,
-0.2275172174,
-1.0493385792,
0.4098721743,
-0.4511697292,
0.2738997042,
0.6696819067,
0.4466837645,
-0.275346458,
-0.9249074459,
-0.6938108802,
-0.6826466918,
0.5524591804,
0.26330778,
0.5256344676,
-0.0320192091,
0.5842069387,
-0.1613006145,
-0.1096829027,
-1.022130847,
-0.2609858811,
0.1783297807,
-0.0518835187,
0.4228916764,
-0.6479918957,
-0.1496415436,
0.1147322133,
0.8198239207,
-0.0289719719,
0.2070165575,
-0.1027828231,
-0.1720061004,
-0.2646555901,
0.0722636878,
0.5952138901,
0.6795991659,
-0.1802870035,
0.432610929,
-0.0933248475,
-0.422875464,
0.2962042391,
-0.5498036742,
-0.5655984879,
0.2107015699,
1.0528080463,
0.3970226943,
0.4492138028,
-0.5179274678,
0.4963155687,
-0.0958238691,
-0.3866877854,
-0.1463935077,
0.5131815672,
0.4863348305,
-0.2225405723,
0.1976729035,
-0.2529188693,
-0.0932641774,
-0.6459010839,
0.4608013034,
0.6515562534,
-0.2645188272,
-0.2034346163,
0.797311008,
-0.2989409566,
-0.1847206652,
0.63215065,
0.1880646944,
-0.5582591891,
0.3867859244,
0.549579978,
0.6917283535,
-0.2448110133,
0.0920075849,
0.2677329183,
0.535436213,
-0.1688026041,
0.4258418381,
0.0924416184,
-0.9630424976,
-0.4224603474,
-0.4758885503,
-0.459379673,
0.5215604305,
-0.8786852956,
0.1758845448,
-0.6340013742,
-0.0296619795,
0.3287318349,
-0.2235808074,
-0.2099364847,
0.3412852585,
0.2851667404,
0.5793825984,
-1.2669359446,
1.2691562176,
0.2268413454,
-0.1266056448,
-0.6033026576,
-0.150685966,
-0.1370672584,
-1.0865755081,
0.6440758705,
0.1081790105,
-0.3104205132,
-0.068357341,
-0.6491447687,
-0.8395478129,
0.9349275827,
0.7641610503,
-0.2149498612,
0.2939040959,
0.5540457964,
0.6393982768,
-0.0669309124,
0.0757635534,
0.405513674,
0.3888623416,
-0.3331060708,
-0.4529085755,
0.2586743832,
-0.3152174652,
0.0571903512,
0.1304017454,
-0.4128795862,
0.7970414162,
0.3550502062,
-0.6593341231,
-0.0407018997,
0.4086057544,
0.2143645734,
-0.0062139221,
0.2095114589,
0.4351702034,
0.6543025374,
-0.3010601401,
1.015353322,
-0.3801255822,
0.3359647691,
0.8682923913,
-0.2297460288,
0.678771019,
0.6048741937,
-0.0043504364,
0.5636327863,
0.2003681064,
-0.224739328,
0.7158240676,
0.3986028731,
-0.4911710024,
-0.392478466,
-0.1447234154,
-0.2091355473,
0.3256733119,
0.3582992256,
-0.6824727654,
-0.0654900372,
-0.2122441977,
0.3449740708,
0.2347824275,
0.1425200701,
0.9825552702,
0.3267112374,
-0.3930312097,
0.9499271512,
0.2815046608,
0.5684521794,
-0.7634838223,
-0.152899161,
-0.2604187429,
0.179634288,
-0.3637760282,
-0.6112440825,
0.2148449868,
-0.0884420574,
-0.1467351615,
-0.5078799129,
0.8169699311,
-0.409979701,
-0.0808395073,
0.2902573943,
0.4288704097,
0.2320517451,
0.0198937636,
-0.5338526368,
0.3930587769,
0.1610121429,
-0.3065795004,
0.521299839,
0.3526550233,
-0.0423940495,
0.9519507885,
0.7992289066,
0.2746938765,
-0.054072056,
-0.0647074878,
0.933382988,
-0.3704507351,
-0.1657932699,
-1.1723333597,
0.104463391,
0.0132884271,
-0.1435579807,
0.8277661204,
0.7199395299,
0.9176548719,
-0.1391561776,
0.9025295973,
0.1935403198,
-0.0863780454,
-0.9408726096,
1.0006799698,
-0.1367913634,
0.6361733675,
0.0200755466,
-0.7160592675,
-0.3554900289,
0.7168642282,
-0.0622730963,
0.0177404173,
0.8662163615,
1.0438477993,
-0.3189465702,
0.1060787439,
0.4274356663,
-0.2391945571,
0.5065167546,
0.3634459376,
0.8894461393,
-0.7609446049,
0.312042743,
-0.4706210494,
0.0073054126,
0.0296823271,
-1.1711497307,
-1.1530981064,
-0.3572708964,
-0.6394646168,
-0.6711843014,
-0.0490240082,
0.3553851545,
0.6186895967,
-0.9718395472,
-0.1863458008,
-0.0865680203,
0.0666666701,
-0.0759734809,
-0.1822278649,
0.3313542604,
0.0490419976,
-0.5509300828,
0.5964674354,
0.1347100735,
0.5268867612,
-0.1814002395,
-0.0561400205,
-0.125627175,
0.3967552781,
0.2083618194,
0.1593110412,
-0.4297401011,
-0.5069002509,
-0.2882562578,
-0.3821572959,
0.012218331,
0.9906654358,
-0.478957653,
0.4792975485,
0.6342289448,
0.4941107333,
0.7706305981,
-0.1260846257,
0.535535574,
-0.9099316597,
0.22318919,
0.2640084326,
0.2824953794,
0.5744084716,
-0.3798429072,
0.3789445162,
0.3260999024,
-0.4771094322,
-0.908248961,
0.1128295958,
-0.628719449,
-0.3301588595,
1.3271993399,
-0.4791956842,
-0.4061027765,
-0.3961359859,
0.0669978708,
0.3671134114,
0.0628341138,
0.8718498349,
0.9260582924,
0.1724045575,
-0.0319222063,
-0.5585796833,
0.8526828885,
0.3994761407,
-0.9383212328,
0.3569462299,
0.3376440108,
0.8732408285,
-0.0668986738,
0.6353662014,
-0.3013703823,
0.2195250988,
0.0848587006,
0.0163771454,
-0.4929943085,
-0.062351305,
-0.2287918627,
0.07095474,
0.376681596,
0.0637571886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14798v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14798v2
|
Enhancing Systematic Decompositional Natural Language Inference Using Informal Logic
| 2024-02-22T18:55:17 | 2024-02-27T21:53:24 |
Nathaniel Weir, Kate Sanders, Orion Weller, Shreya Sharma, Dongwei Jiang, Zhengping Jiang, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Jansen, Peter Clark, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Contemporary language models enable new opportunities for structured
reasoning with text, such as the construction and evaluation of intuitive,
proof-like textual entailment trees without relying on brittle formal logic.
However, progress in this direction has been hampered by a long-standing lack
of a clear protocol for determining what valid compositional entailment is.
This absence causes noisy datasets and limited performance gains by modern
neuro-symbolic engines. To address these problems, we formulate a consistent
and theoretically grounded approach to annotating decompositional entailment
datasets, and evaluate its impact on LLM-based textual inference. We find that
our resulting dataset, RDTE (Recognizing Decompositional Textual Entailment),
has a substantially higher internal consistency (+9%) than prior
decompositional entailment datasets, suggesting that RDTE is a significant step
forward in the long-standing problem of forming a clear protocol for discerning
entailment. We also find that training an RDTE-oriented entailment classifier
via knowledge distillation and employing it in a modern neuro-symbolic
reasoning engine significantly improves results (both accuracy and proof
quality) over other entailment classifier baselines, illustrating the practical
benefit of this advance for textual inference.
|
[
0.0177186728,
-0.9979255795,
0.9978501201,
0.1804937422,
-0.1328127384,
-0.0149694141,
-0.5822229385,
-0.6113583446,
0.0507763252,
0.251870364,
-0.6646172404,
-0.7389910817,
-0.5291878581,
0.5346475244,
-0.4437775016,
0.5952373743,
0.0450201891,
-0.1975417435,
-0.3332417905,
0.1820580214,
-0.1469559222,
-0.1868896186,
-0.5702866316,
-0.5014616251,
0.2493863702,
0.1342842132,
0.4678963423,
0.8544629216,
0.2892097831,
0.3600474596,
-0.0756850243,
0.5029757619,
-0.2968589365,
0.4529308677,
0.1696817875,
-0.5429329276,
-0.1443881243,
-0.0453620888,
0.3640438616,
0.7845504284,
-0.4143537879,
-0.1557796896,
-0.1156149358,
0.5333424211,
-0.8821454048,
0.2114263922,
-0.7669173479,
0.0557702668,
-0.1228473783,
-0.1615082622,
-0.8274821639,
-0.5863731503,
0.0959915295,
-0.9647934437,
0.0861201882,
-0.0357079618,
1.0108317137,
0.5415595174,
-0.2219877243,
-0.3773106337,
-0.737354517,
0.6856462359,
-1.049346447,
0.4556181729,
0.7404341102,
0.4409225881,
-0.1896395981,
-1.1140775681,
-0.4543088377,
-0.3288165629,
-0.3624100387,
0.1568693072,
-0.0599585623,
0.2701207399,
0.3871971965,
0.2739647329,
-0.1876311004,
-0.0267693494,
0.0529752113,
-0.0584586337,
0.4430657327,
0.0213868096,
0.3486740589,
-0.0290541574,
-0.2791676223,
0.2911663055,
-0.5781582594,
-0.3781665862,
0.3267666399,
0.0507817157,
0.0206687059,
0.4730849564,
-0.5104939938,
0.7786006331,
-0.0026351204,
-0.1523332,
0.177066192,
-0.4702506661,
-0.3824974298,
0.2359252721,
0.5678954124,
0.176447168,
0.5020845532,
-0.348122716,
-0.3417553306,
0.4436397552,
-0.0760509148,
-0.8181971908,
-0.3337684274,
0.2354287803,
-0.2863110006,
-0.174492538,
0.0976157561,
-0.322811991,
-0.3362465799,
-0.7909867167,
0.1238584742,
-0.6431151032,
-0.1431942135,
0.6163708568,
-0.5296912193,
0.182399869,
0.6503468752,
-0.9568142295,
0.7542260885,
0.8748291135,
0.6638510227,
0.2655794919,
0.0636167154,
-0.2213234007,
0.3566168249,
-0.2716503739,
0.8809440136,
-0.7843732834,
0.2168731838,
-0.0637229383,
-0.2566630542,
-0.1930975616,
-0.6744181514,
0.865367949,
-0.236343652,
0.4462648034,
-0.0655367523,
-0.69730407,
-0.202116251,
0.4141450226,
-0.4604597092,
1.3362315893,
-0.1674649417,
-0.9706070423,
0.5700725317,
-0.4885332882,
-0.5098304749,
-0.1221030653,
-0.2843772471,
-0.0710161626,
0.1101651192,
0.2945879996,
0.2841366827,
-0.3043341637,
0.604098618,
-0.3369108438,
-0.3226324618,
0.1457095742,
-0.5516155958,
0.8236156106,
0.0969847664,
-0.418767035,
-0.0265596714,
-0.8580523729,
0.0149493041,
-0.0644285008,
0.0039749867,
-0.7182689309,
0.3369452655,
-0.237511903,
0.01498855,
0.0592696518,
-0.6367238164,
0.0585460663,
-0.6400651336,
0.583953321,
0.7161111832,
0.0315097384,
0.5012253523,
-0.2131936252,
0.0060763201,
-0.1640986055,
-0.1389076561,
-0.2148921192,
-0.3598200381,
-0.7715132833,
-0.7706608772,
0.4062779248,
0.4174964726,
-0.576099515,
0.6176789403,
-0.3839577138,
-0.0787878558,
-0.6297994852,
-0.2140075713,
0.0114018917,
0.7256883979,
0.3298924267,
0.1984807849,
-0.7871444225,
-1.0076686144,
-0.2820529044,
-0.0408278778,
-0.3460878134,
-0.0505684167,
0.5466920733,
-0.1037775427,
1.1271033287,
-0.5010063052,
-0.075816825,
-0.0783882812,
0.3085358143,
0.2189604342,
0.2162959427,
0.1641246974,
-0.3470312059,
-0.3108744323,
0.0247415695,
-1.0787814856,
-0.3918597996,
-0.1534006745,
-0.34720999,
0.1340521574,
0.4970148206,
-0.6040393114,
0.4648032784,
-0.1106105372,
-0.3087211251,
0.3289579749,
-0.0749920607,
0.1657485366,
-0.8147586584,
-0.2321628779,
-0.0624178573,
-0.2474317253,
-0.47253564,
-0.0277739204,
-0.0399471298,
0.4446698725,
-0.0127520822,
0.3776980937,
-0.4994978309,
0.3052663207,
-0.1254244149,
0.2195464969,
0.1053195596,
0.1290169507,
0.4972319007,
0.342694968,
0.4741056561,
-0.5216081738,
-0.0295955334,
0.0528800525,
-0.1369068325,
0.5200343728,
-0.641753912,
0.1869389117,
-0.4213267565,
0.5085639358,
-0.7791024446,
-0.3479420543,
0.221027717,
-0.3452717364,
0.2856033742,
-0.1383382529,
-0.7128480673,
0.3345453441,
-0.467682153,
0.1984852254,
0.5177868009,
-0.4488158822,
0.8642737269,
-0.0114817917,
0.1555250734,
-0.4488356709,
-0.8905311227,
0.3412122428,
-0.207171008,
-0.917127192,
0.3876001537,
0.253626734,
-0.8805254698,
0.1276254803,
-0.2676846981,
-0.2849543691,
0.2651591301,
0.1247861534,
-0.0030621227,
-0.3368856311,
0.1511295289,
0.185250625,
-0.2441263795,
0.2802371681,
-0.2044953555,
0.1486427188,
0.0604392588,
-0.2607429922,
-0.3426956534,
0.1782051176,
0.1171380132,
-0.1212798804,
0.7183278203,
0.3218247592,
-0.8244137168,
-0.6800189018,
-0.5152612925,
-0.6155775189,
-0.4472087026,
-0.1018685624,
-0.2569177449,
-0.5505595803,
0.3492009044,
-0.2400896102,
0.1983452439,
0.3882814348,
0.2196158171,
-0.1719626486,
0.4956558347,
0.1376036555,
0.406273514,
0.0982370749,
-0.0525038689,
0.1657606065,
-0.5650984049,
-0.3520047367,
-0.68059057,
-0.3252309859,
-0.4236631989,
-0.363288641,
-0.0424366742,
-0.2434176356,
-0.1651897728,
0.0347123444,
-0.3693757653,
0.6582115889,
0.4178153574,
0.3110532463,
0.8328078389,
-0.0050610779,
0.0089419736,
-0.3184355795,
-0.4874589741,
-0.7552574277,
0.7789055705,
0.3330682814,
0.7721937299,
-0.0436000489,
1.0795819759,
0.1448307186,
0.5012745261,
-0.7835342884,
0.6291822791,
0.1585968733,
-0.5817499161,
-0.0923222303,
-0.5717588067,
-0.5921460986,
0.2438418418,
-0.0876740068,
-0.5843011141,
0.069454506,
-0.1096651927,
0.0569100566,
0.0431000218,
-0.8248846531,
0.5274410844,
-0.0020976826,
-0.5248670578,
-0.0221935362,
-0.6864067316,
0.6360246539,
0.2612709403,
0.261813581,
-0.2968477607,
-0.1480485648,
0.628262639,
-0.6160135865,
0.9874338508,
-0.0846861824,
-0.2459243834,
0.4420953691,
0.1852809787,
0.5797207355,
0.2062489092,
-0.2964955568,
0.0312527753,
-0.2276028842,
-0.1739970446,
-0.9732409716,
0.4869952202,
-0.4178316891,
-0.3253192902,
-0.5137832761,
-0.4493413866,
-0.0455034412,
0.0247840527,
0.1829076707,
0.4887849092,
-0.0854968205,
0.2422675788,
0.8539655805,
0.21177724,
0.4960517585,
0.2766510844,
0.1244392097,
-0.3472674191,
0.4642596841,
0.0394299701,
0.2949844301,
0.6406278014,
0.322607547,
-0.474342525,
-0.5419058204,
-0.192417264,
0.0369447134,
-0.9371470213,
-0.1196531802,
-0.6406376362,
-0.0643833727,
-0.0171691477,
-0.0816339701,
-0.2614017725,
-0.6628857851,
-0.0945470482,
-0.432570219,
0.4291537106,
0.635176897,
0.3013305664,
-0.0787001327,
-0.3613428771,
0.4978798628,
0.0036295771,
0.2423740029,
-0.1866840571,
-0.6478919387,
0.242075175,
0.174505949,
0.0797650516,
-0.8895488381,
-0.0197397098,
0.550645411,
0.4259630442,
0.2569048703,
0.3333391547,
0.7469850779,
-0.5547817945,
0.3877931237,
-0.2169639766,
-0.8263480067,
0.5626813173,
-0.4727059305,
0.1845542341,
0.9148038626,
0.2036692798,
-0.3362941742,
-0.6171550751,
-0.6264278293,
-0.8824842572,
0.3393888772,
0.4735873044,
-0.057078965,
-0.2969380021,
0.2274295986,
0.3024530411,
0.0289900377,
-0.8483610749,
-0.1855444461,
-0.0018305162,
-0.6055001616,
0.5380963087,
-0.0160285886,
-0.1140596271,
-0.3942557871,
0.615711987,
-0.0825608745,
0.0169173256,
0.2848103344,
-0.2311892062,
0.3389799893,
0.4434349835,
0.4259409606,
0.6969815493,
-0.2841769159,
0.6663268209,
0.1270497441,
-0.4164600372,
0.1774100214,
0.1501435339,
-0.5211293697,
0.2092808783,
0.7861061096,
0.3769163489,
0.418892175,
-0.5290278792,
0.1935787052,
-0.0776370019,
-0.4727608562,
-0.2207246721,
-0.0861387029,
0.2840417325,
-0.1683474183,
0.3525282741,
0.0462158173,
0.4043019712,
-0.4289935529,
0.2873082757,
0.2106419504,
-0.0169273652,
-0.2336974889,
0.3791660368,
0.1406260729,
0.0066641914,
0.6640330553,
-0.2506810725,
-0.2278603017,
0.4741699696,
0.5855727196,
1.1197010279,
0.1930222064,
0.122562848,
0.4471660554,
0.724470675,
-0.3429403305,
0.2843675911,
-0.2050905526,
-0.5557616353,
-0.7557557225,
-0.5848229527,
-0.2254573703,
-0.1325420737,
-0.3927289248,
0.2207367718,
-0.4345365167,
0.1696798801,
-0.1018077955,
-0.3342839181,
-0.4348547757,
0.0271312688,
0.0584993362,
0.957578063,
-0.9928809404,
0.588105917,
0.5280579329,
-0.2312994748,
-0.6728187799,
0.0647734776,
-0.0492880158,
-0.4275471866,
0.6382481456,
0.3567651212,
-0.3467415273,
-0.0231940411,
-0.6594157219,
-0.4242708981,
0.9841771722,
0.6825616956,
-0.3935203552,
0.0709356964,
-0.047639057,
0.5825647116,
-0.171627,
0.6915535331,
0.6375812888,
0.8555138707,
0.0731554106,
-0.6370878816,
0.3866577744,
-0.2129632682,
-0.3506778777,
0.4292045832,
0.0675350651,
0.4347307086,
-0.0769624412,
-0.6380582452,
-0.3212242424,
0.7638142705,
0.2603836656,
0.6047259569,
0.1680512577,
0.9907989502,
0.9633993506,
-0.48400563,
0.9207985401,
0.0535601564,
0.0179379899,
1.4347560406,
-0.496003449,
0.8313165903,
0.600271225,
-0.12198852,
0.9196394086,
0.6035298705,
0.4147898853,
0.4174687564,
0.3040269017,
-0.6096992493,
-0.397687763,
-0.3093421161,
-0.2291930169,
0.3619104922,
0.3869042099,
-0.3468643129,
-0.6239964366,
-0.5807572603,
0.0674834326,
0.5513939261,
0.0926403031,
0.9401515126,
0.1476034671,
-0.528044641,
0.5246528387,
0.0571467876,
0.6979956627,
-0.7304976583,
-0.4415700734,
-0.05295261,
-0.0022774043,
-0.5963405967,
-0.5301374793,
0.4288546443,
-0.0759137049,
0.0371718332,
-0.2711048722,
0.8971922398,
-0.4852848649,
-0.4436601996,
0.107814312,
0.531463623,
-0.1500952691,
-0.1224601194,
-0.2234551609,
-0.0080903778,
-0.2706788778,
-0.2814221382,
0.0634319633,
1.0612127781,
-0.0163229443,
0.5440366268,
0.7159819603,
-0.1560513675,
-0.0036493347,
0.2469849437,
0.7645255327,
-0.6262786984,
-0.3227545023,
-1.2838253975,
0.638517499,
-0.3131686747,
-0.0116390223,
0.8834680915,
0.6318231225,
0.6358899474,
0.0622641258,
0.7313008904,
-0.1363656223,
-0.020259466,
-0.8375389576,
0.3268424571,
-0.0828386694,
0.4187510014,
-0.0078374203,
-0.8122217059,
-0.3965390325,
0.8998687863,
-0.343603164,
0.1231737509,
1.0801405907,
0.606043458,
-0.262631923,
0.2737303078,
-0.0266222674,
0.0962733105,
0.1398847848,
0.4051030278,
0.9511719942,
-0.2916632295,
0.0013529747,
-0.3010111749,
-0.1516654342,
0.2478203624,
-1.3195745945,
-0.8521645069,
-0.2361872047,
-0.469845444,
-0.230086267,
0.1314149201,
1.0080531836,
0.469907254,
-0.4250640869,
-0.1130663976,
-0.4728766084,
0.0924965441,
-0.3329241574,
-0.2829856873,
0.1524865478,
-0.4277033508,
-0.5257199407,
0.5373052359,
0.4724776745,
-0.276184231,
0.1040824354,
-0.0405160412,
-0.4443624914,
0.1039467975,
0.6285501122,
-0.0841996819,
-0.8501875997,
-0.2770938575,
0.0783906877,
-0.115830943,
0.1169572994,
0.7338504195,
-0.8095534444,
0.3511701226,
0.7526202798,
0.7521295547,
0.3779604137,
0.1210449338,
0.6595320702,
-0.861806035,
0.140810132,
0.5719130635,
0.3589043021,
0.2968254983,
-0.1473352313,
0.7489904761,
0.2512824237,
-0.2050203979,
-0.8765873909,
0.1893509626,
-0.8481846452,
-0.2159237117,
1.24997437,
-0.0336725079,
-0.3737671971,
-0.4520157874,
-0.1513519287,
-0.0280167051,
-0.4925508201,
0.5567392111,
0.7825213671,
0.0536049046,
-0.0031229686,
-0.741024971,
0.5114426017,
0.2929809988,
-1.3511357307,
0.3471366465,
0.7336375713,
0.1979111582,
-0.0986438468,
0.6821152568,
-0.0671265349,
0.1052333564,
0.059351597,
-0.0809507445,
-0.2711433172,
-0.3129022717,
-0.1130640358,
-0.0167751051,
0.0952679813,
0.0510131046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14778v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14778v2
|
Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer in instruction tuning of large language models
| 2024-02-22T18:37:33 | 2024-04-22T10:44:21 |
Nadezhda Chirkova, Vassilina Nikoulina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction tuning (IT) is widely used to teach pretrained large language
models (LLMs) to follow arbitrary instructions, but is under-studied in
multilingual settings. In this work, we conduct a systematic study of zero-shot
cross-lingual transfer in IT, when an LLM is instruction-tuned on English-only
data and then tested on user prompts in other languages. We advocate for the
importance of evaluating various aspects of model responses in multilingual
instruction following and investigate the influence of different model
configuration choices. We find that cross-lingual transfer does happen
successfully in IT even if all stages of model training are English-centric,
but only if multiliguality is taken into account in hyperparameter tuning and
with large enough IT data. English-trained LLMs are capable of generating
correct-language, comprehensive and helpful responses in other languages, but
suffer from low factuality and may occasionally have fluency errors.
|
[
-0.3011056185,
-0.7989173532,
0.3873619437,
0.3030306101,
-0.1628670692,
-0.1718343943,
-0.4704554677,
-0.5329422355,
0.1242084056,
0.3139424324,
-0.5497729182,
-0.4363587499,
-0.4657908082,
0.0701357648,
-0.3496669531,
1.0561082363,
-0.1751454026,
0.351863265,
-0.1196731552,
0.0349830836,
-0.7255442739,
-0.5402363539,
-0.6257397532,
-0.3573344052,
0.6396796703,
0.8153897524,
0.3914792538,
0.6681916118,
0.2082368582,
0.2197348475,
0.3513928056,
-0.2314111739,
-0.5733042359,
-0.2012684941,
-0.4476970434,
-0.5546010733,
-0.4120018482,
-0.0337263569,
0.8275179863,
0.8707723618,
0.0207155477,
0.3042832017,
0.1443639696,
0.2955106795,
-0.7757960558,
0.1222332045,
-0.6202600598,
0.1771040112,
-0.2196451575,
-0.4425191283,
-0.7280178666,
-0.1438902467,
-0.0279868562,
-0.6855146885,
0.2366565019,
0.1468861103,
0.6993025541,
-0.1079041213,
-0.6589069963,
-0.1606632918,
-0.8562714458,
0.8943783641,
-0.6086047292,
0.4346157908,
0.3918371797,
0.168500334,
0.2440199703,
-0.1752162576,
-0.2792986035,
-0.4233268201,
-0.1589909792,
0.1450246125,
0.0282518379,
-0.0387795307,
0.2660048902,
0.0318007097,
-0.737965107,
0.576623559,
-0.4999310076,
-0.2508410811,
0.7167326808,
0.2293149382,
0.1789830625,
0.2090386003,
-0.4297677279,
-0.0654671192,
-0.8613278866,
0.0862848461,
0.3840919137,
0.532094717,
-0.3166515529,
0.5845491886,
-0.1263311356,
1.083237648,
0.1588422209,
-0.0602105074,
-0.0374699049,
-0.5591323972,
-0.025377281,
0.3418061435,
0.5939933062,
0.4291018546,
0.7633419633,
-0.2107242346,
-0.1238968149,
-0.2229578793,
0.1995464861,
-0.8697995543,
0.0463239588,
-0.1668225676,
0.0423458107,
0.1208566129,
-0.0493754447,
-0.49172014,
0.1385595798,
-0.3988952041,
0.6772558093,
-0.3660298586,
-0.1749319583,
0.2649218738,
0.143050164,
0.5535624623,
0.1863141209,
-1.1021881104,
-0.0580050759,
0.5373030305,
0.6064804196,
-0.3387202024,
-0.8427652121,
-0.636351943,
0.3670211434,
-0.5840025544,
0.9155365825,
-0.7057138085,
-0.5087819099,
0.2621583641,
0.3933997154,
-0.6736688018,
-0.2044490129,
0.1651919186,
-0.40761289,
0.490465641,
-0.3633666933,
-0.7607150078,
-0.114828065,
0.28501302,
-0.4106591344,
0.7079511285,
-0.0570820309,
-0.4860848486,
0.3778061569,
-0.499907583,
-0.9033545852,
-0.0989217237,
0.0694084093,
-0.0318380408,
0.2193400711,
0.0797751695,
0.3913494051,
-0.2638167739,
-0.1101454794,
-0.3489151299,
-0.7104247808,
0.0893718675,
-0.5867028236,
0.6930546165,
-0.1527919471,
-0.3481009901,
0.0544028543,
-0.7327276468,
0.2404492944,
0.0403387658,
-0.2718057632,
-0.3473196924,
-0.5958871245,
-0.1060047075,
0.094181031,
0.2000432014,
-0.6390857697,
0.4887869656,
-0.0621217713,
0.0110001191,
0.6629183292,
-0.0506122001,
0.5721178651,
-0.2595517337,
0.7424381375,
-0.0779011473,
0.1427000463,
-0.4325736463,
-0.322947979,
-0.8173151016,
-0.1061441153,
0.4551817775,
0.7974786162,
-0.7413000464,
-0.0013198389,
-0.0092459247,
-0.2855705619,
-0.5855432749,
0.0433513932,
0.5211148858,
0.6353197098,
0.2172566652,
-0.0411145315,
-0.1834517717,
-0.8579928875,
-0.2422148734,
-0.0044053798,
0.1279013157,
0.2587445378,
0.267167598,
0.1478654742,
0.1859139353,
-0.2223843932,
-0.1350523382,
-0.2380775362,
0.2666763067,
0.0089720441,
0.3545028269,
0.7010865211,
-0.1793884486,
-0.9330186844,
0.2737541497,
-0.5466566682,
-0.2800788879,
-0.3359951973,
-0.2048284858,
0.4346086085,
0.4724594653,
-0.4118914008,
0.2441279292,
0.707077086,
-0.2818933427,
0.5212545395,
-0.3419057131,
0.525228858,
-1.0674163103,
0.0451078825,
-0.0342936441,
-0.1973343194,
-0.6366729736,
-0.001705903,
0.2912234366,
0.0317521244,
-0.6498162746,
0.7546033263,
-0.6486907601,
-0.215380013,
-0.3018680215,
0.0234855097,
0.0722930282,
0.516556859,
0.2027271092,
0.9999802113,
0.8189588785,
-0.6398357153,
0.2170091569,
-0.0246450882,
-0.1966351569,
0.9955191016,
-0.5918138623,
0.2844753861,
0.0357937142,
-0.1756200492,
-0.8222697377,
-0.0512089618,
0.0549348891,
-0.2487213016,
0.6687366366,
-0.0963870957,
-0.1060211062,
-0.0267814882,
-0.2843878865,
0.309984684,
0.1334050149,
-0.4401063323,
0.3631122708,
-0.1121585518,
-0.1921645403,
-0.5891794562,
-0.6575829387,
-0.1005454436,
-0.1276468188,
-0.3946043551,
0.249131009,
-0.2974967659,
0.0201412179,
-0.0345935822,
-0.0430360772,
-0.1832102984,
0.031040227,
-0.1436696202,
0.4262812734,
-0.4488067627,
-0.0570566989,
0.1114380807,
-0.0101942131,
0.0181347188,
-0.2595275044,
0.4322829545,
0.1065428704,
-0.6889494658,
-0.4585781693,
0.5146881938,
0.5349653363,
-0.1675211936,
0.8149560094,
0.7140741348,
0.0878480002,
-0.2723453641,
-0.2630085051,
-0.2581301332,
-0.3795656264,
0.4868318141,
-0.4960309863,
-0.8770766854,
0.4677647352,
0.2032871693,
0.2849824727,
0.2958714366,
0.5358365774,
-0.0909314752,
1.2799940109,
0.9843156934,
-0.1267752647,
0.6127507091,
0.002705069,
0.0084859841,
-0.5438657403,
-0.0692586154,
-0.6895161867,
-0.2520268559,
-0.6173503995,
-0.1210536361,
0.3045506477,
-0.0015632643,
-0.2242072225,
0.2540244758,
0.0677645504,
0.6090891361,
0.4936193526,
-0.2256146073,
0.2667892277,
0.1880860478,
-0.1553098112,
-0.050136108,
-0.9580468535,
-0.0400747769,
1.0118192434,
0.0084003834,
0.9781987071,
0.0011098012,
0.4973098636,
-0.0475924984,
0.23227337,
-0.9155219793,
0.3314658403,
-0.3408203125,
-0.555485785,
-0.2249873728,
-0.4019068778,
-0.9796891809,
0.1591302902,
-0.1389675587,
-0.6756280065,
-0.1306391209,
0.106342867,
-0.2766234577,
0.1383794993,
-0.907110393,
0.8916140795,
-0.5957898498,
-0.5393214822,
-0.2180000544,
-0.4152045846,
0.3240234852,
-0.247466892,
0.0760154352,
0.1565589011,
0.08426328,
0.4555605948,
0.0031198347,
0.7580271959,
-0.071342051,
-0.4716774523,
-0.1625439674,
0.1893339902,
0.3782716095,
-0.1299296618,
-0.0942007303,
0.3974299729,
0.1332079172,
-0.570094347,
-0.5851503611,
0.833361268,
-0.83872962,
-0.8871508241,
-0.1553175896,
-0.8398563266,
-0.4487458766,
0.2440550625,
0.3752146363,
0.3662990332,
0.0075123506,
0.1991018206,
0.7984945774,
-0.2308856398,
0.4460016787,
1.1573308706,
-0.3834405839,
0.0394495279,
0.8724232316,
0.3195518851,
0.5915352106,
0.3939488232,
0.1900745779,
-0.2307485789,
-0.3068823814,
-1.0399974585,
0.3159940541,
-0.6043273211,
-0.0389853567,
-0.0652851686,
-0.3129835427,
-0.4199547172,
-0.2399677038,
-0.536218822,
-0.3094592392,
-0.3117979765,
-0.0681009963,
0.2336388379,
0.6890987754,
0.0302173067,
0.2167370021,
-0.9868533611,
0.0899618939,
0.186133936,
0.3313485682,
-0.2950670421,
-1.0263172388,
-0.6044718623,
0.1174596921,
0.1233448908,
-0.8395013809,
0.1361951232,
0.595898807,
0.7259728909,
0.2351592332,
-0.0119723119,
0.8550693393,
-0.6529432535,
0.7472155094,
-0.0711145699,
-0.8156535625,
0.2560225129,
-0.1493075639,
0.6818125248,
0.4159815013,
0.7488260865,
-0.5850604177,
-0.1594739258,
-0.0513242558,
-0.5755339861,
0.9652059674,
-0.4843707979,
0.4619385004,
0.1959469318,
0.2769349515,
0.3039684296,
0.0821541548,
-0.5695940256,
-0.2402739674,
0.0145358816,
0.0759791881,
-0.1066560969,
-0.1151325703,
-0.2230608612,
-0.2190469652,
0.6732378602,
-0.3930752277,
0.0828223899,
-0.2417383045,
-0.3152201772,
-0.4548721611,
0.4308950901,
0.7330505848,
0.7683950067,
0.1198334172,
-0.0104256701,
0.1985246241,
-0.2245548815,
0.2648141384,
0.0408426784,
-0.3379540741,
-0.0870671719,
0.6628896594,
1.1925717592,
0.5075023174,
-0.2629548311,
0.4787716269,
-0.1004423872,
-0.3058873415,
-0.0014849568,
0.1827112734,
-0.0273001809,
0.1890512556,
0.0415535346,
-0.2842635512,
-0.1251082271,
-0.6324904561,
-0.0042775711,
0.6090911627,
-0.2723360956,
-0.6054084301,
0.306091845,
0.0636741444,
-0.3173243701,
0.642944634,
0.0362623222,
-0.3345277905,
0.4039645791,
1.0175843239,
0.7866220474,
-0.4922566414,
0.3886291385,
0.3604588509,
0.4862504601,
0.1847364902,
0.2763599455,
-0.2022304386,
-0.7065886855,
-0.7722678781,
-0.4582623541,
-0.4915491641,
0.0664015412,
-0.9807833433,
0.3711155057,
-0.2300675511,
0.1933803856,
-0.056896951,
-0.1941782981,
-0.742077291,
-0.0581388399,
0.3488880992,
0.9601017833,
-1.1225628853,
1.0930346251,
0.9628099799,
-0.2656265497,
-1.0630366802,
0.0829436705,
-0.0702388287,
-1.1012606621,
0.5631302595,
0.0863261297,
-0.2832757533,
0.1482526362,
-0.3660846055,
-0.8583322763,
0.7840658426,
0.7000813484,
-0.7935669422,
0.0961171091,
0.4071182609,
0.5061766505,
-0.3494182527,
0.3860273063,
0.4940390885,
0.4869588017,
0.3308916092,
-1.2927616835,
-0.2820310295,
-0.0883861855,
-0.1182901263,
0.0663491637,
-0.8004137278,
0.9328020215,
-0.1517006606,
-0.1158759221,
-0.1797008365,
0.2126234174,
-0.0362432711,
0.135273248,
0.3251270354,
0.4302081168,
0.553739965,
0.1695206314,
1.0474369526,
-0.7263587713,
0.1470379978,
1.0133287907,
-0.696760416,
0.8526940346,
0.4552493095,
0.1096390188,
0.3514565825,
0.569235146,
0.2260975391,
0.3934509456,
-0.1646772921,
-0.1257428676,
-0.2481782585,
-0.3626104295,
-0.4506745636,
0.6724520326,
0.1183385774,
-0.1171132475,
-0.2670803964,
0.2312185615,
0.1595844775,
-0.2054032832,
-0.5342007875,
0.9113561511,
-0.153532654,
-0.9432176948,
0.931491673,
-0.0977297425,
0.6244668365,
-0.8400345445,
-0.1407933682,
-0.5268921256,
0.0724158734,
-0.1637617499,
-0.820746541,
0.2323992103,
0.183134377,
-0.2064576149,
-0.4019604623,
0.5359624624,
-0.789458096,
-0.5419963002,
0.447080493,
0.5891138315,
0.219647184,
0.1852999926,
-0.6499012113,
-0.0142228995,
0.1972030401,
-0.5110494494,
0.7178445458,
0.520706296,
-0.2669633925,
0.2968239486,
0.4447199702,
0.331527859,
0.2944222987,
0.3632536232,
0.5867834687,
-0.5915603042,
-0.2555207908,
-0.6568229198,
0.4698938429,
0.2877609432,
-0.2557053864,
1.1307612658,
0.2849688828,
1.2790925503,
-0.126844272,
0.6559393406,
0.1780731827,
0.2459907681,
-0.8244341612,
0.4034783542,
-0.715421617,
0.1890282333,
0.1845050901,
-1.1027054787,
-0.0392036997,
0.4577427506,
-0.2984059453,
0.1523974091,
0.7005730867,
0.8673559427,
-0.1573680788,
-0.0349372141,
0.7539690137,
0.0736208633,
-0.0447700471,
0.5734316111,
0.686004281,
-0.1521244794,
0.4228315353,
-0.3021722138,
-0.1642073393,
-0.1387534887,
-0.8897174001,
-0.8628861904,
-0.2508170009,
-0.2794588804,
0.0309470613,
0.1371333748,
0.8245628476,
0.6708744168,
-0.9601365328,
-0.5624914765,
0.366456449,
-0.0216724947,
-0.188470453,
-0.209074825,
0.0875870585,
-0.5512869358,
-0.8336991072,
0.5845990181,
0.2603952885,
-0.2111276388,
-0.5102188587,
0.0007410886,
-0.3143144548,
0.1737429053,
0.6036272645,
0.3597443104,
-0.314909935,
-0.4444393516,
0.5156540871,
-0.1833428144,
-0.0515269041,
0.8679012656,
-0.3166761994,
0.5400236845,
0.324113071,
0.6595951915,
0.5423882008,
-0.2543436587,
0.75347507,
-1.0768444538,
0.2736902833,
-0.1345130801,
0.3190594018,
0.3985943496,
-0.3716684878,
0.2085039616,
0.130840078,
-0.540142715,
-0.5978590846,
0.1062492803,
-0.4402665794,
-0.273230046,
1.327902317,
-0.3237235844,
-0.2824125886,
0.215467006,
-0.1852657497,
0.2579152286,
-0.0347734205,
0.5447461605,
0.8579956889,
-0.2341404706,
-0.4038549364,
-0.7011597157,
0.0804540515,
0.6880499125,
-0.7509952188,
-0.012700079,
0.5715332627,
0.4766502976,
-0.0739618838,
0.3502719402,
0.1586537659,
0.3833598495,
-0.0921732709,
0.051949542,
-0.0989033431,
-0.6192827821,
-0.6951764822,
-0.0472704954,
0.3016200364,
-0.191004023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14776v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14776v2
|
ESE: Espresso Sentence Embeddings
| 2024-02-22T18:35:05 | 2024-05-21T07:36:14 |
Xianming Li, Zongxi Li, Jing Li, Haoran Xie, Qing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
High-quality sentence embeddings are fundamental in many natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, such as semantic textual similarity (STS) and
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Nevertheless, most existing methods
leverage fixed-length embeddings from full-layer language models, which lack
the scalability to accommodate the diverse available resources across various
applications. Viewing this gap, we propose a novel sentence embedding model
$\mathrm{Espresso}$ $\mathrm{Sentence}$ $\mathrm{Embeddings}$ (ESE) with two
learning processes. First, the learn-to-express process encodes more salient
representations to lower layers. Second, the learn-to-compress process compacts
essential features into the initial dimensions using Principal Component
Analysis (PCA). This way, ESE can scale model depth via the former process and
embedding size via the latter. Extensive experiments on STS and RAG suggest
that ESE can effectively produce high-quality embeddings with less model depth
and embedding size, enhancing embedding inference efficiency.
|
[
-0.1037238836,
-0.9182444215,
0.7632394433,
0.4443064332,
-0.4750775099,
-0.0837433338,
-0.3010801375,
-0.3935677707,
0.4670532048,
0.6808304787,
-0.3911682963,
-0.5229723454,
-0.7327266932,
-0.0113175083,
-0.3574197888,
0.860609293,
0.0342129618,
-0.1381903887,
-0.5546221137,
0.1539872587,
-0.4179163873,
-0.5022838712,
-0.5799164772,
-0.037264891,
0.2092466652,
0.2775145769,
0.5517789125,
0.5077344775,
0.2341211587,
0.2201427817,
-0.1092203259,
0.3669742644,
-0.5331481695,
0.4977492094,
0.1309001893,
-0.5254796743,
-0.006686925,
-0.0723315701,
0.401984036,
0.542111814,
-0.140448913,
-0.0517937653,
0.2202911824,
0.4928939939,
-0.6658106446,
0.1601755917,
-0.5220668912,
0.4489998519,
0.3365985751,
0.0058056721,
-0.8263121843,
-0.2602472901,
0.110421516,
-0.4805319905,
0.0920333937,
-0.0081303222,
0.9163269401,
0.2752110362,
-0.4166904092,
-0.417155683,
-0.5318977833,
0.7178098559,
-0.5164421797,
0.1443015188,
0.1922210753,
0.112301752,
0.209155634,
-0.7913938761,
-0.4028530419,
-0.0858238116,
-0.1029230282,
0.1634048223,
-0.0413045473,
-0.0344688259,
-0.0123173334,
0.4263751507,
-0.5466227531,
0.2343132496,
0.0226818454,
0.2835021615,
0.2785233259,
-0.1185755879,
0.2049450427,
-0.1728672534,
-0.6262006164,
-0.0775797144,
-0.4819709063,
-0.138832286,
0.2191842943,
0.4289132059,
0.002081742,
0.6233377457,
-0.06857761,
0.411268115,
-0.2074606717,
0.1933847368,
0.2957362831,
0.0222452618,
-0.5514045358,
-0.217742756,
0.7270131111,
0.2601858675,
0.111829631,
-0.3789325655,
-0.1924382597,
0.1785923839,
0.3902597427,
-0.9695342779,
0.1950196624,
0.1992973536,
-0.5308184624,
-0.4797208905,
0.2120511383,
-0.7497319579,
-0.1123205498,
-0.2342655212,
0.3415637314,
-0.2976028025,
0.1525204033,
0.4790911376,
-0.2988493443,
0.1464767307,
0.0230472535,
-0.6383116841,
0.6153063178,
0.8358551264,
1.0676181316,
-0.0083905747,
-0.0766566247,
-0.6131840944,
0.0178229213,
-0.1202309281,
0.8960542679,
-0.7654687762,
-0.4206658304,
0.393838197,
0.0068123327,
-0.1130410954,
-0.3795283139,
0.889294982,
-0.4405746758,
0.5000559092,
-0.155178085,
-0.9932283759,
-0.1729899347,
0.1656650454,
-0.5001599193,
1.1051746607,
-0.2390901893,
-0.5196664333,
0.0462579541,
-0.536519289,
-0.467610091,
-0.1814776808,
-0.113483578,
-0.6980393529,
0.6598215103,
0.323505342,
0.8822116852,
-0.3517821729,
-0.0894415751,
-0.2567260861,
-0.2429467589,
0.0873405859,
-0.3001346588,
0.6643795371,
0.0890488029,
-0.0020870573,
-0.2743128836,
-0.7498368621,
-0.0554182492,
0.2884971797,
-0.1929882318,
-0.3006957173,
-0.028635893,
0.3800320625,
0.2687392235,
0.2820875943,
-0.6655489206,
0.1237314343,
-0.3378557265,
0.7426198721,
0.4903608263,
0.3079240024,
0.4973195791,
-0.1215767115,
0.4560425282,
-0.0108249849,
0.0540726595,
-0.3599600792,
-0.4866251349,
-0.6609990597,
-0.320471108,
0.2600272596,
0.7098591924,
-0.4936865568,
0.764053762,
-0.2424471229,
-0.3317745626,
-0.3451846838,
-0.191445902,
0.2986923158,
0.1305338889,
0.3405504823,
-0.1708907038,
-0.3064279556,
-0.9903660417,
-0.2953825891,
0.231382519,
-0.3281787634,
0.1833034456,
0.3741932213,
0.021830719,
0.6360149384,
-0.9011203647,
-0.284646064,
-0.0942457169,
0.3575570583,
0.0997082368,
0.5343278646,
0.6499191523,
-0.3757880628,
-0.6570956111,
-0.2290020585,
-0.7242831588,
-0.0127996486,
-0.1010122523,
-0.0939698666,
0.0432091095,
0.6940182447,
-0.6251997352,
0.2042448819,
0.6347318292,
-0.4872263074,
0.1040044427,
-0.4784339666,
0.1187734455,
-1.4074641466,
-0.4922305644,
0.0390472971,
-0.5015137792,
-0.4446924925,
0.2515359819,
0.0325845294,
-0.5930244327,
-0.3444841802,
0.0240637958,
-0.6167709231,
-0.1448040605,
-0.2502426207,
0.2843571305,
0.4217298031,
0.608269453,
0.0857020244,
0.5246025324,
0.4853347242,
-0.2700753808,
-0.0771173686,
0.1748810112,
-0.2918602824,
0.711281538,
-0.9674868584,
0.3748569191,
-0.1917871684,
0.0690889582,
-0.9668250084,
0.2810651362,
-0.2261213064,
-0.4175408185,
0.2298968732,
-0.0603911877,
-0.9647443295,
-0.1604893655,
-0.3969510496,
-0.0403288268,
0.5213065147,
-0.3670734167,
0.616328001,
0.4544953406,
-0.2698111832,
-0.3304343224,
-0.8337296844,
0.2356208563,
-0.1854839772,
-0.5324828625,
0.6394209862,
0.1175760552,
0.3087245822,
0.1558993608,
0.454472512,
-0.2011689991,
0.0684205517,
0.1432454884,
0.0414388776,
-0.2436712533,
0.4419101477,
0.5465672612,
0.0523309112,
-0.0504210033,
-0.29971838,
0.5508964658,
-0.0680000111,
-0.0336597115,
-0.6229100823,
0.7599531412,
0.6163156629,
-0.3354996443,
1.125916481,
0.4035259783,
-0.5661853552,
-0.4438671172,
-0.2454069257,
-0.3162447512,
-0.3884166181,
0.4032520652,
-0.4084697962,
-1.0691365004,
0.4082653522,
-0.2083235383,
-0.0269854125,
0.3154000938,
0.1470850259,
-0.176635772,
0.8260857463,
0.7247757316,
0.0715032741,
0.3852928877,
-0.2471829504,
0.3445481956,
-0.7408511043,
-0.1147287562,
-0.805019021,
-0.376601398,
-0.6135857701,
-0.8848697543,
0.1007013172,
0.1310500652,
-0.2823053002,
0.524418354,
-0.4844698906,
0.7097455859,
0.4532827437,
0.2662483454,
0.1392059326,
0.2388492674,
-0.166068092,
-0.2015475631,
-0.5822414756,
-0.6455511451,
0.8118695021,
0.4421699345,
0.3264114857,
0.0436944999,
0.6909251213,
0.4120516777,
-0.3208424151,
-0.8480730653,
0.4036006927,
-0.6761333942,
-0.1273781955,
-0.1960857809,
-0.1266606152,
-0.7416245341,
0.3303862512,
-0.5033989549,
-0.5664699674,
0.1578230709,
-0.3353154361,
-0.4108121991,
0.2063009888,
-0.8067792058,
0.7932896614,
0.1447211206,
-0.2004117668,
-0.2584662437,
-0.4308123887,
-0.222593233,
0.4149847925,
-0.0342080221,
0.0427327715,
-0.2867621183,
0.4590114951,
-0.3860542178,
0.9356721044,
-0.1282921582,
0.0962781385,
0.2051451951,
0.0711137503,
0.7151083946,
0.1318806112,
0.0340962969,
-0.1755429059,
-0.3016663194,
-0.5952932239,
-0.849409163,
0.820695281,
-0.6514789462,
-0.2985049188,
-0.3551116586,
-0.1678118259,
-0.3309931159,
-0.0454829969,
0.2088755518,
0.3364067376,
-0.518543601,
0.5068310499,
0.8139147162,
-0.4832595587,
0.4454732239,
0.161441043,
-0.1035774201,
-0.389934659,
0.5195707083,
-0.0356020629,
0.147274062,
0.8390042782,
0.0890168101,
-0.1681665629,
-0.3723516166,
-0.0758244917,
0.3708937168,
-0.2807105184,
-0.217705518,
-0.9613063931,
-0.1334197968,
-0.3977608979,
-0.3846593797,
-0.7231388688,
-0.7005857825,
-0.6338743567,
-0.5145377517,
0.3297156692,
0.6788170338,
0.1872920543,
0.350825876,
-0.7299026251,
0.1911047548,
0.3507302999,
0.093856357,
-0.107996121,
-0.4565447867,
-0.2901810408,
-0.2679550946,
-0.3725065589,
-0.8291706443,
0.5178924203,
0.3202964067,
0.1617918313,
0.425350666,
-0.0240653511,
0.3219522238,
-0.7547476292,
1.0190153122,
0.1624994129,
-0.991566062,
0.7737208009,
-0.0574809797,
0.1410066932,
0.4951666594,
0.4514942169,
-0.34553653,
-0.3258686066,
-0.5572423339,
-0.8765567541,
0.0275451858,
0.1551941633,
0.5961155295,
-0.4159497619,
0.3394911587,
0.1947098374,
0.2906924188,
-0.6147848368,
-0.0674567819,
-0.0378551483,
-0.0804466456,
0.0353143848,
-0.4985564053,
0.1423901916,
0.1710641533,
0.5933719873,
0.0274063312,
0.6556966901,
0.0990658849,
-0.1416582912,
0.3670160174,
0.3363986015,
0.4325419068,
0.1120928824,
-0.1661814302,
0.1280021071,
-0.1241550595,
-0.1233771816,
-0.1202405691,
0.1910169721,
-0.1723732352,
0.1407866925,
0.2645463347,
0.9733201265,
0.3952892423,
-0.5148517489,
0.7578020692,
-0.2083475292,
0.0332798585,
-0.2478454113,
-0.2281009555,
0.2133834958,
0.2501856387,
0.0988278463,
0.0349730253,
0.3269205093,
-0.668679595,
0.2901194692,
0.0916453674,
-0.707344234,
-0.2183053046,
0.5067490935,
0.3241245151,
-0.3029706776,
0.727221787,
-0.1930655539,
-0.4191119075,
0.4333456457,
0.5955078602,
0.9624195695,
-0.0234464202,
0.7300697565,
0.3693377078,
0.220007807,
-0.1800743192,
0.2877808809,
0.1479460448,
-0.7380360961,
-0.4849098027,
-0.5213352442,
-0.0728790537,
-0.1468468755,
-0.914046824,
0.0824937522,
-0.3889020681,
-0.1062117368,
-0.3107106686,
-0.0348949842,
-0.5910335183,
0.0317245349,
-0.0207515489,
0.7907863259,
-1.2879941463,
0.6100039482,
0.3652530611,
-0.4841801524,
-0.3093466461,
-0.0137408152,
-0.313053906,
-0.5805025101,
0.3493931293,
0.3412335515,
-0.0043584276,
-0.1464021653,
-0.2241333723,
-0.4078312516,
1.1440064907,
0.5379274487,
-0.5621693134,
-0.1400054544,
0.0344378091,
0.8087285161,
-0.8320605755,
-0.0296079572,
0.2536639273,
0.0083137462,
-0.1230787635,
-0.441899091,
0.1371292621,
-0.1444458514,
0.4334567785,
-0.0358402133,
-0.6371243596,
0.6416992545,
-0.0807925686,
-0.3101198375,
0.1364995241,
0.77934587,
0.1287129968,
0.0249680821,
0.2570253611,
1.2251403332,
0.8300018311,
-0.0980321169,
1.2619585991,
-0.2161248624,
0.524759829,
1.5067392588,
-0.1201941669,
1.338512063,
0.3833736181,
-0.1519248188,
0.8842968345,
0.4216471612,
0.082274273,
0.694409132,
0.1586688608,
-0.1281954944,
-0.1169344187,
-0.185632959,
-0.2661030293,
0.4144663215,
0.2775986195,
-0.9122360945,
0.1224198863,
0.229113102,
0.2153975368,
0.7179232836,
0.0252823532,
0.6863558888,
0.1245304123,
-0.3806340098,
0.2335872054,
-0.0443718098,
0.6867787838,
-0.2005205452,
0.0033270111,
-0.1733467728,
-0.2019431591,
0.2967295051,
-0.629807651,
0.3740515709,
-0.0423909239,
-0.3737115562,
-0.5160036087,
0.3846141398,
-0.4004711211,
-0.6552683115,
0.4924278855,
0.5094981194,
-0.0346027911,
-0.3048146665,
-0.6587593555,
-0.0772564411,
-0.2760284245,
-0.3065717518,
0.2059196681,
0.7275480032,
0.6105158925,
0.271779567,
0.261230588,
0.0987276807,
-0.0323250927,
0.4239589274,
0.644980371,
-0.4593765736,
-0.7795775533,
-0.549007535,
0.4583048224,
-0.4655346274,
-0.1153029352,
0.4963005483,
0.7876617312,
0.600125432,
-0.4472523034,
0.6002451181,
0.1973591298,
0.52153337,
-0.7046226263,
0.4279444218,
-0.4214980006,
0.1383059174,
-0.0673342496,
-0.9818355441,
-0.31735304,
0.6964575648,
-0.0557048358,
-0.1920738816,
1.0942331553,
0.6748280525,
0.0374536589,
0.1062118933,
0.490958184,
0.3309132457,
0.1498172879,
0.5957347155,
0.4068326056,
-0.8395280242,
0.2289579362,
-0.1563363671,
-0.1704640538,
-0.1592934281,
-0.9638134837,
-0.9181610346,
-0.7892519832,
-0.3717313409,
-0.171457544,
0.0896580815,
0.8278666735,
0.6858289242,
-0.6968873739,
-0.0185181089,
-0.314124912,
-0.0565718748,
-0.4512682557,
-0.2796266079,
0.379787147,
-0.4923681021,
-1.0664787292,
0.3371075988,
0.4664649069,
0.0681972727,
-0.0994328633,
0.3317902982,
-0.423699826,
0.3956145644,
1.0523613691,
-0.1209479272,
-0.3857797384,
-0.3885713518,
0.0428693555,
0.0074342065,
-0.0345058031,
0.9740831256,
-0.5378727317,
0.2992468774,
0.7368286848,
0.9509646297,
0.7231545448,
-0.3424043059,
0.6144772172,
-1.0156544447,
0.2110558152,
0.3022263944,
0.4730453789,
0.3229328692,
-0.5179342031,
0.4301168323,
0.041706156,
-0.5221599936,
-0.6166403294,
0.2787470818,
-1.0433238745,
-0.5932300687,
0.8784752488,
-0.4612788856,
0.0209700782,
0.3153727353,
-0.0155938957,
0.1743277162,
-0.4703718126,
0.9044774771,
0.6974048018,
0.004369352,
-0.3025006056,
-0.3745250404,
0.2393967062,
0.2446621209,
-0.9113547802,
-0.0995834097,
0.3287025094,
0.0091882655,
0.2516916096,
0.1510373056,
-0.2130562216,
-0.1107329503,
0.1302569062,
-0.2488148659,
-0.106689252,
-0.3971004486,
-0.2018931061,
0.7413722873,
-0.2131510079,
-0.3523931801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14762v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14762v2
|
MT-Bench-101: A Fine-Grained Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Multi-Turn Dialogues
| 2024-02-22T18:21:59 | 2024-06-25T13:38:41 |
Ge Bai, Jie Liu, Xingyuan Bu, Yancheng He, Jiaheng Liu, Zhanhui Zhou, Zhuoran Lin, Wenbo Su, Tiezheng Ge, Bo Zheng, Wanli Ouyang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has drastically enhanced dialogue
systems. However, comprehensively evaluating the dialogue abilities of LLMs
remains a challenge. Previous benchmarks have primarily focused on single-turn
dialogues or provided coarse-grained and incomplete assessments of multi-turn
dialogues, overlooking the complexity and fine-grained nuances of real-life
dialogues. To address this issue, we introduce MT-Bench-101, specifically
designed to evaluate the fine-grained abilities of LLMs in multi-turn
dialogues. By conducting a detailed analysis of real multi-turn dialogue data,
we construct a three-tier hierarchical ability taxonomy comprising 4208 turns
across 1388 multi-turn dialogues in 13 distinct tasks. We then evaluate 21
popular LLMs based on MT-Bench-101, conducting comprehensive analyses from both
ability and task perspectives and observing differing trends in LLMs
performance across dialogue turns within various tasks. Further analysis
indicates that neither utilizing common alignment techniques nor chat-specific
designs has led to obvious enhancements in the multi-turn abilities of LLMs.
Extensive case studies suggest that our designed tasks accurately assess the
corresponding multi-turn abilities. The data and code are available at
\url{https://github.com/mtbench101/mt-bench-101}.
|
[
-0.5934553742,
-0.8276588917,
0.671133399,
0.3991416097,
-0.01588553,
0.319608897,
-0.4270695746,
-0.1153795719,
0.0754015446,
0.4741710424,
-0.7292051911,
-0.4629374146,
-0.573594749,
0.0330765657,
-0.4250225127,
0.7002028823,
0.1281500757,
0.4628701508,
-0.2877717614,
-0.424271673,
-0.5264424682,
-0.4267750382,
-0.3873449862,
-0.2582989037,
0.5129798651,
0.4279119968,
0.3776366115,
0.2757959068,
0.4792943895,
0.3654001653,
0.0728205144,
0.2980456054,
-0.5345825553,
0.3338078558,
0.0890745744,
-0.3329570591,
-0.8260135651,
0.0793715641,
0.8202158213,
0.8374730945,
-0.2368074805,
0.4052633643,
0.0985871404,
0.7516214848,
-0.4725261033,
0.2230328918,
-0.7095940709,
-0.2254483402,
-0.4692893326,
-0.1684272736,
-0.5541027188,
-0.3106162846,
0.067783691,
-0.3737916648,
-0.1144774556,
0.1115697473,
0.4956969023,
0.1198019534,
-0.1032599285,
0.0010118749,
-0.7089166641,
0.9231886268,
-0.8011975288,
0.2919369042,
0.1755994707,
0.7733811736,
-0.225888893,
-0.648794353,
-0.6065040827,
-0.2591748238,
0.1473279446,
0.0601568595,
-0.0146370232,
0.036011409,
0.3335736692,
0.4264502227,
-0.3674581945,
-0.0831275433,
0.0840264335,
0.0360675752,
0.2822338045,
0.554002583,
0.0739892572,
-0.2056178004,
-0.1412198842,
-0.3309377134,
-0.4974072874,
0.1863243133,
0.2048316002,
0.5647224784,
-0.027594097,
0.631965816,
-0.5254750252,
0.6792823076,
-0.0799620971,
-0.4776154757,
0.3498673737,
-0.4060793519,
-0.1623030454,
-0.3308033049,
1.046423912,
0.4382945299,
0.3913598061,
-0.1682487428,
-0.0291451383,
-0.3513247073,
0.3895089924,
-0.7440196276,
0.1251612604,
0.1972083896,
-0.3876633644,
-0.2018204778,
-0.1819254011,
-0.8738957644,
-0.5411421061,
-0.4820772707,
0.4936797023,
-0.5012686253,
-0.1372131258,
-0.2431917042,
-0.2263496369,
0.2803321481,
0.3391321301,
-0.5005145669,
0.5382410884,
0.9646874666,
0.7747523189,
-0.2430826724,
-0.6185312271,
-0.9696944356,
-0.049723845,
-0.2954517603,
0.8773294091,
-0.7619647384,
-0.2145336866,
0.0064269286,
0.0954418257,
-0.1759150177,
-0.6060521603,
0.4364957809,
-0.0624823123,
0.0018778029,
-0.3523013592,
-0.1728902757,
0.098081395,
0.5781074762,
-0.4866277575,
1.1018441916,
0.0580912717,
-0.5001264215,
0.1588164121,
-0.5160199404,
-0.496230036,
-0.1103846952,
-0.2553650141,
-0.2870283723,
0.3293318748,
0.0545220897,
0.2489697635,
-0.5076117516,
0.443977952,
-0.6328926086,
-0.436935991,
0.574580431,
-0.7175622582,
0.3166130185,
-0.230555445,
-0.2918561697,
0.2167614698,
-0.7529941797,
0.4437425733,
-0.1107597053,
-0.241154179,
-0.1130191609,
0.0535610504,
-0.1386733949,
0.2226353884,
0.0049116719,
-0.5426827669,
0.2110355496,
-0.1857601106,
0.1888368279,
0.5467107296,
-0.209900856,
0.2106372565,
-0.4735866189,
0.1890744865,
-0.283949405,
0.2307927161,
-0.1974929422,
-0.5350845456,
-0.9400159717,
-0.5376552343,
0.440305233,
0.5424236059,
-0.6418346763,
0.2086923122,
-0.4908277392,
-0.6182352901,
-0.702994287,
0.01830207,
0.6865810156,
0.0039518951,
0.5730984807,
-0.4654126167,
-0.2155011743,
-1.1218340397,
-0.6376460791,
0.1330959797,
-0.1597439498,
0.5584357977,
0.0705154017,
-0.0582003295,
0.8319640756,
-0.2991204262,
-0.2567454576,
-0.3944504559,
0.5111413598,
0.0268770419,
0.3106304407,
0.2805803716,
-0.1875139177,
-0.6019418836,
-0.1330395937,
-0.4880279303,
-0.3149800897,
0.005185056,
-0.3116501272,
0.1754804701,
0.3623045683,
-0.7780172229,
0.4386923611,
0.6035329103,
0.191745922,
0.5393210649,
-0.112833783,
0.3052069247,
-0.9594303966,
0.205133304,
-0.1191257909,
-0.1160464957,
-0.7515347004,
-0.1752804518,
0.1614115089,
-0.0300353263,
-0.2764207721,
0.4899377525,
-0.2074979544,
-0.4971325099,
-0.2195061594,
0.3009714186,
-0.1217380762,
0.7371540666,
-0.0025770888,
0.6790157557,
0.2831861973,
-0.436098665,
0.1964391619,
0.0679574013,
-0.4967594445,
0.8340473175,
-0.388320446,
0.1949425191,
0.2467624694,
0.4191490412,
-1.2865211964,
-0.1620439589,
-0.1765347868,
-0.3585087061,
0.5437788963,
-0.3887838423,
-0.6439902782,
-0.2866117358,
-0.4522948563,
0.2726868093,
0.2001508176,
-0.258320123,
0.9630781412,
0.382976979,
-0.5097806454,
-0.453374207,
-0.4493606687,
0.2775584757,
-0.1010830775,
-0.4600681663,
0.3251578808,
-0.1812963337,
-0.2736934125,
-0.5192614198,
-0.2273298204,
0.0330585167,
-0.1269914806,
0.3409930468,
0.1003565937,
-0.1497725695,
-0.1517267972,
-0.0358966142,
-0.3483550251,
-0.0403471552,
0.1741345674,
0.9982316494,
-0.3173739016,
-0.6024890542,
-0.410939157,
0.2642521858,
1.1080235243,
-0.2223756313,
0.5728830695,
0.5557584763,
-0.0723122731,
0.1070351228,
-0.9671878815,
0.0543933846,
-0.4367318451,
0.31308496,
-0.5714450479,
-0.5389408469,
0.3638730645,
-0.3912309706,
0.2499416023,
0.3572390079,
0.5942165852,
-0.1306823343,
1.1380639076,
0.2428009361,
0.0564371608,
0.3500449061,
-0.1139316857,
0.1996164322,
-1.2872545719,
-0.2740902901,
-0.6813742518,
-0.4813933671,
-0.5296453238,
-0.6243702173,
0.313061446,
-0.1001731157,
-0.4014105499,
0.3966896534,
-0.1438435316,
0.2520507276,
0.5478117466,
-0.175725922,
0.448410362,
-0.2536515594,
-0.3678666353,
-0.2023830265,
-0.4520486891,
-0.631793797,
1.0898464918,
0.4232721925,
0.6747100949,
0.1743311584,
0.4346393645,
0.0132301189,
0.6559951901,
-0.9402484894,
0.7644147277,
-0.1604739875,
-0.5912933946,
-0.4437027872,
-0.5734285712,
-0.604822576,
0.512159586,
-0.1942636371,
-0.6722141504,
-0.1977899373,
-0.2230243385,
-0.2272472382,
0.2057657242,
-0.7976821065,
0.9852529168,
-0.5042983294,
-0.2799805105,
-0.3240389824,
-0.3826805949,
0.3507643938,
-0.1625429839,
0.4383186102,
-0.4176642299,
0.2627982795,
0.5597342253,
-0.3808943629,
0.8411940336,
-0.348985523,
0.0733276755,
0.0230587181,
0.2452669442,
0.4355671108,
0.0683575422,
-0.0043597566,
0.0437640958,
0.2596255839,
-0.2332194,
-0.3362427652,
0.9431505203,
-0.627335608,
-0.4826161861,
-0.2677250206,
-0.5782689452,
-0.8787728548,
0.1773978621,
-0.2174856663,
0.8081996441,
-0.5129082799,
0.4526687562,
0.3116263747,
-0.3073893487,
0.4976875186,
0.8512035608,
-0.2781966031,
-0.5385434031,
0.9428706765,
0.238125205,
0.4610356987,
0.2883639634,
0.1359289885,
-0.2216988057,
-0.4783976674,
-0.6673009396,
0.0575222746,
-0.445107311,
-0.3475223482,
-0.7416344881,
-0.1358424574,
-0.033351548,
0.2766241729,
-0.6260713935,
-0.5004961491,
0.3419160843,
0.2962391078,
0.1129737496,
0.6442773938,
0.2908915877,
0.2114572823,
-0.7988166809,
0.483691901,
0.5522073507,
0.7471749187,
0.2332292199,
-0.5652577877,
0.0098373285,
0.1160149202,
-0.5110153556,
-0.2580746412,
0.1682393104,
0.1370105743,
0.7649846673,
0.1794267297,
0.0361680649,
0.8933654428,
-0.8866095543,
0.641330719,
0.1895672232,
-0.9226116538,
0.132953003,
-0.2868646979,
0.5648348331,
0.9445354939,
0.0273342822,
-0.5799126625,
-0.5699602962,
-0.4302081168,
-0.6282007098,
0.8870669007,
0.2576562166,
0.1674693376,
-0.0221110117,
-0.1074204966,
0.2017950416,
0.3165669143,
-0.4956251085,
-0.2712697387,
-0.1206097305,
-0.1118685678,
-0.0412176326,
-0.1332353652,
-0.3612336814,
-0.1932942271,
0.3704075813,
-0.2566168904,
0.2362278402,
-0.2586110234,
-0.0349172689,
-0.1458492577,
0.5290057659,
0.6883282065,
0.6366083026,
-0.5046328902,
0.0806890354,
0.5479313135,
-0.3458426595,
-0.1796026081,
0.2993449569,
0.3844982386,
-0.0629049167,
0.3904723525,
0.5553503036,
0.522994101,
-0.6849425435,
0.496701777,
-0.2926948071,
-0.1215827465,
-0.04455854,
-0.0008371116,
0.2179898322,
0.2001005858,
0.5306150913,
0.2158463448,
-0.0344128497,
-0.8895705342,
-0.0353680104,
0.7115451097,
-0.5038635135,
-0.0917781442,
-0.0180630479,
0.3746534586,
-0.5069614649,
0.4304662645,
-0.0827529058,
-0.414642185,
0.2692089677,
0.1755294204,
0.897461772,
-0.1043424755,
0.031141473,
0.3103284538,
0.1799696088,
-0.0207041018,
0.0577117875,
0.0051329765,
-0.4482723475,
-0.6899021864,
-0.6920841932,
-0.7661715746,
0.3793230951,
-0.7040044665,
0.0688619912,
-0.2739483714,
-0.4025150239,
0.2682128251,
0.0475181192,
-0.6457799077,
-0.107696265,
0.1104271039,
0.9507201314,
-0.326924473,
0.8503622413,
0.4170528054,
0.0822834298,
-0.2559179366,
0.132253781,
0.1468733996,
-0.8689367175,
0.2699020803,
0.3624711335,
-0.3422050178,
-0.2745032609,
-0.3563468158,
-0.6268299818,
1.0703196526,
0.1157735437,
-0.5992091894,
0.2333932668,
0.4744537175,
0.6098029017,
-0.5591635704,
0.5955578089,
0.8032334447,
0.628002882,
0.0374234542,
-1.4000174999,
-0.2665423751,
-0.1764661819,
-0.1213909239,
0.4033740759,
-0.773219943,
0.5869085789,
0.124094978,
-0.0020940246,
0.4235367179,
0.0653010234,
0.4851295352,
0.4636077285,
0.5039935112,
0.6453339458,
0.5000133514,
-0.5749735236,
1.0539157391,
-0.3622409999,
0.1761015803,
1.2632151842,
-0.5493552685,
1.2148913145,
0.3454114795,
-0.2983524799,
0.4129442871,
0.0459696166,
0.3175355792,
0.4735074043,
0.4134907126,
-0.0411087647,
-0.5980315208,
-0.0497413836,
-0.3166874051,
0.4435914755,
0.4976868033,
0.0140668079,
-0.1525951475,
-0.0636547059,
-0.1692348868,
-0.106411621,
-0.0464430079,
1.0307224989,
0.0059518809,
-0.8250951171,
0.5497039557,
0.0360193253,
0.4989615977,
-0.6326512694,
0.0349292532,
-0.3299516737,
0.3326184154,
0.1074990481,
-0.9950990081,
0.0913288519,
0.1879933327,
-0.0998628587,
-0.2130592912,
0.327460736,
-0.3741600215,
-0.3953620493,
0.2832505405,
0.7336619496,
0.0499636307,
-0.276748538,
-0.6763821244,
0.386135906,
-0.1250884831,
-0.0697696134,
0.663036108,
0.6841291189,
-0.0613480546,
0.7311538458,
0.5616885424,
-0.3094615042,
-0.1672910005,
0.5589533448,
0.9467710853,
-0.8282185793,
0.1987019479,
-0.6685328484,
0.4738404155,
-0.319652319,
-0.3676649034,
0.6510781646,
0.784512043,
0.4632337093,
0.0865121335,
0.650646925,
-0.0164126623,
0.9289825559,
-0.2930217981,
0.4756669402,
-0.3685405552,
0.180620268,
-0.4944824874,
-1.0976406336,
0.0839778781,
0.4323457479,
-0.4848303497,
0.1713650674,
0.7492536306,
0.677726984,
-0.1384145319,
0.0526858382,
0.2964743376,
0.2284274995,
0.3343521655,
0.4486958385,
1.204968214,
-0.354585737,
0.8838854432,
-0.1500854343,
-0.434902966,
-0.3524436057,
-0.7919009328,
-1.1702940464,
-0.3839856088,
-0.0479643866,
-0.2805616558,
-0.2405059934,
0.733007431,
0.8402511477,
-0.8511883616,
-0.4686155617,
0.1662949622,
-0.1165960208,
-0.2371034175,
-0.212204501,
0.0822121799,
-0.5019906163,
-0.7938829064,
0.6974722147,
0.5494823456,
-0.1324205697,
-0.3410221934,
-0.1638512462,
-0.1690755188,
0.2480887771,
0.8056173921,
0.0565960221,
-0.8529073,
-0.1548752487,
0.1238455623,
-0.2405980974,
0.0123520223,
0.8973136544,
-0.6050097942,
0.5351213217,
0.2839037478,
0.4641239941,
0.7432054281,
0.1110731214,
0.6740493178,
-0.6653662324,
-0.1696900725,
-0.0464480221,
0.2892053723,
0.4896868467,
0.5116251707,
0.4253125191,
-0.0104626194,
-0.438729614,
-0.9932398796,
-0.0618188865,
-1.151352644,
-0.0900369436,
1.0346778631,
0.0615706667,
0.047000818,
-0.1171774715,
-0.4389846325,
0.0337302051,
-0.3974680007,
0.6683328152,
1.0042475462,
-0.1559708565,
-0.093903631,
-0.8034332395,
0.4724413455,
0.4631340206,
-0.9250157475,
0.4477701783,
0.2951213419,
0.0966926292,
0.4850829244,
0.3831989765,
-0.2527748346,
0.0656400472,
-0.2687063813,
-0.1763597578,
0.0852742866,
-0.4618769884,
0.0338049419,
0.1432871222,
0.215618968,
0.0448589809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14760v2
|
Generalizing Reward Modeling for Out-of-Distribution Preference Learning
| 2024-02-22T18:20:33 | 2024-06-08T16:10:45 |
Chen Jia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Preference learning (PL) with large language models (LLMs) aims to align the
LLMs' generations with human preferences. Previous work on reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) has demonstrated promising results in
in-distribution PL. However, due to the difficulty of obtaining human feedback,
discretely training reward models for every encountered distribution is
challenging. Thus, out-of-distribution (OOD) PL is practically useful for
enhancing the generalization ability of LLMs with limited preference feedback.
This work addresses OOD PL by optimizing a general reward model through a
meta-learning approach. During meta-training, a bilevel optimization algorithm
is utilized to learn a reward model capable of guiding policy learning to align
with human preferences across various distributions. When encountering a test
distribution, the meta-test procedure conducts regularized policy optimization
using the learned reward model for PL. We theoretically demonstrate the
convergence rate of the bilevel optimization algorithm under reasonable
assumptions. Additionally, we conduct experiments on two text generation tasks
across 20 held-out domains and outperform a variety of strong baselines across
various evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.3655850887,
-0.2284711748,
0.4317659736,
0.0213265959,
-0.3985939324,
-0.2809900045,
-0.615105927,
0.0979130566,
0.0708215907,
0.600464344,
-0.6895138621,
-0.3432979286,
-0.4356202185,
0.0986396819,
0.3134441376,
1.3979300261,
0.0185015127,
-0.1372577101,
-0.2092679888,
-0.1448578537,
-0.2061573267,
-0.5061917901,
-0.3170596063,
-0.5094739199,
0.4024371207,
0.6578643322,
0.3578528762,
0.3608229458,
0.2931537032,
0.1791671216,
0.1990781277,
0.3748720586,
-0.7643623948,
0.0338999704,
-0.5479152799,
-0.2482576668,
-0.1989283115,
-0.035273999,
0.6017936468,
0.6036757231,
-0.3916211128,
0.0119472975,
0.2951342463,
0.7176246047,
-0.9351881146,
0.2752048075,
-0.6162077785,
-0.1271142513,
-0.0198925305,
-0.4195573926,
-0.7231988311,
-0.6714618206,
0.3903354406,
-0.5551309586,
0.2025333047,
0.1415182054,
0.613582015,
0.1134906262,
-0.3737025261,
-0.5585404634,
-0.5364326835,
1.0898176432,
-0.395713985,
0.2610726655,
0.4798645377,
0.2961290181,
-0.0934354067,
-0.1198581681,
-0.4131470025,
-0.1965780556,
0.0495208874,
0.1497244239,
0.2665725648,
0.054852102,
-0.3155894876,
0.1580752581,
-0.4360958338,
0.038386751,
-0.0284897219,
0.3595634103,
0.6431373358,
0.135016799,
-0.1265809089,
-0.2442092896,
-0.4099110961,
-0.6389585137,
-0.5291998982,
0.3742575049,
0.685177505,
0.4821477234,
-0.0369853675,
0.5237213969,
-0.0626524538,
0.509898603,
0.2720863819,
-0.2386939973,
0.5201454163,
-0.0572739206,
-0.191509217,
-0.1991741806,
0.7672687173,
0.3238013685,
0.2701948583,
-0.1046663821,
-0.2924772501,
-0.241373077,
0.2523161769,
-0.6965693831,
0.0419327207,
-0.11082647,
-0.6813284755,
-0.5425634384,
0.0588498563,
-0.991756618,
-0.4986260235,
-0.1519066244,
0.4231731296,
-0.2156472057,
-0.4273288548,
0.4271920919,
-0.1600178182,
0.0165302362,
-0.0071322457,
-1.605930686,
0.2829481661,
0.4412372708,
0.5381489992,
-0.4152365327,
-0.2396182269,
-0.7183417678,
0.2359472811,
-0.208754614,
0.7497915626,
-0.57663697,
-0.5809041262,
0.1363445967,
-0.1021445468,
-0.2539350092,
-0.5993700027,
0.5905069113,
-0.6947757006,
0.2096798271,
-0.3373406231,
-0.3910029829,
-0.0193478074,
0.297801882,
-0.4707373977,
0.819580853,
0.49707219,
-0.8825439215,
0.7036055326,
-0.858299017,
-0.3202030659,
-0.0742254108,
-0.1922578961,
-0.5895103216,
0.2221212685,
0.0713850632,
0.2821692824,
-0.3553186953,
0.3689599335,
-0.4533802271,
-0.3279314339,
0.1013648286,
-0.1947021037,
0.4595809579,
0.1015801206,
-0.5652112365,
0.1944862157,
-0.4940309525,
-0.1381319761,
0.1000068188,
-0.7034911513,
-0.5818282366,
0.1624720097,
-0.1242504641,
-0.0013541403,
-0.0200035963,
-0.5735276341,
0.5202994943,
-0.7355528474,
0.4739124179,
0.9195079803,
0.0195652228,
0.9603236318,
-0.2172306776,
0.4015564919,
-0.0478104241,
0.3063721657,
0.1407101601,
-0.2395710498,
-0.4147391617,
-0.2723869979,
0.3783127367,
0.3011496365,
-0.6134758592,
0.6849367619,
-0.3546996117,
-0.0949545577,
-0.317112416,
0.1168172881,
0.3035330474,
0.5259454846,
0.4183574617,
-0.280362457,
-0.1356719732,
-0.6892675161,
-0.1165698767,
-0.1137424782,
0.0224500392,
0.567971766,
0.5649060607,
-0.5339016318,
1.2943981886,
-0.6653282642,
-0.3013345599,
-0.5555206537,
0.3050857782,
0.224068895,
0.1227441877,
0.4527656138,
-0.7495788932,
-0.5812528729,
-0.0298835393,
-0.1997685432,
0.0171254352,
0.2192485183,
-0.1120013371,
0.5293740034,
0.0034610415,
-0.230986312,
0.2489113063,
0.53879565,
-0.0432729051,
0.5421767831,
-0.5961152911,
-0.0381770581,
-0.6677870154,
0.0157063846,
-0.2046007961,
-0.1777897179,
-0.2635300756,
-0.2505830824,
0.2185450941,
-0.0838091075,
-0.4080560505,
0.7195951343,
-0.2692665458,
-0.199514091,
-0.3473064899,
-0.1717020869,
-0.0627629459,
0.6889048815,
0.546666801,
0.5704159737,
0.3306670189,
-0.8034270406,
0.1108127609,
0.1005879939,
-0.212884739,
0.5491269827,
-0.4784346521,
-0.1262114495,
-0.3950702548,
0.3961120844,
-1.0315740108,
-0.2892992496,
0.4329510033,
-0.1744875014,
0.097912319,
0.0185205378,
-0.3300266862,
-0.1602854133,
-0.5607094765,
0.4482851923,
0.6677663922,
-0.9783743024,
0.5194028616,
0.2367620468,
0.0328755863,
-0.6369179487,
-0.3180488944,
-0.7484511137,
-0.3678930402,
-0.3610299826,
0.2919397652,
-0.2308928072,
0.0650292486,
-0.1574276537,
0.3348788619,
0.2605105937,
-0.1995697021,
0.0274392013,
0.0047963159,
0.393078804,
0.5155571699,
0.1246992275,
-0.1875334233,
-0.0963818729,
-0.3692046404,
0.8361022472,
-0.0326766409,
-0.2341038287,
0.2750876546,
0.3646495342,
0.0867016762,
-0.247875616,
0.755300343,
0.3517901301,
0.1698455513,
-0.5096144676,
-0.1951874793,
-0.3315043449,
-0.4748142362,
0.2491271198,
-0.2405150831,
-0.4640341997,
0.0264267549,
-0.159624964,
0.1269528717,
0.221915096,
0.5812244415,
-0.0919665769,
1.1161924601,
0.8216469288,
-0.039386563,
0.5746740103,
-0.4154959619,
-0.0056374925,
-0.697221458,
-0.2298864126,
-0.2842816114,
-0.1255578548,
-0.4623450339,
-0.2240023315,
0.5509318113,
-0.0554941595,
-0.3884187937,
-0.0123291453,
-0.3730225563,
0.4433700144,
0.8163359165,
0.2826007605,
0.092235595,
0.1467275769,
-0.3689658642,
0.0633997992,
-0.5750530958,
-0.1697154045,
1.4611902237,
0.2489544004,
0.9183552861,
0.0075937556,
1.0243669748,
0.2947357297,
0.5445053577,
-0.5026666522,
0.0829345584,
-0.4405617714,
-0.2541241348,
-0.5223747492,
-0.6218092442,
-0.8684651256,
0.2431387007,
-0.1303526014,
-0.3662886024,
0.4393158257,
0.3874480724,
-0.3798888326,
0.1572621912,
-0.5117456913,
0.8898700476,
-0.3367323577,
-0.173969388,
-0.1594766676,
-0.8449293375,
0.560154438,
0.0720009208,
0.4038767219,
0.1493258774,
0.0384307764,
0.5176912546,
-0.2985266745,
0.7487600446,
-0.1719480008,
-0.1575928777,
-0.0000708932,
-0.3118168712,
0.644282937,
0.0876442045,
-0.1302766055,
-0.37578848,
-0.4579497278,
-0.204317227,
-0.5571096539,
0.3728775978,
-1.0802048445,
-0.17750521,
-0.3756105602,
-0.5604667068,
-0.3571252227,
0.0163159091,
0.6741589904,
0.4563854337,
-0.195338279,
0.0221482795,
1.0531336069,
-0.4692067504,
0.4576495588,
0.4567477703,
-0.2267733663,
-0.7544787526,
1.1871546507,
-0.2720040381,
0.5272573829,
0.6007244587,
0.7174819112,
-0.8507357836,
-0.1174952984,
-0.4328106642,
0.4620301723,
-0.7430580258,
-0.0102033755,
-0.4878560007,
0.1969787478,
-0.5290210247,
-0.2833876908,
-0.1194956824,
0.068099089,
-0.422595948,
0.0501180105,
0.0214968324,
0.6196809411,
-0.2823792696,
0.4686890841,
-0.5404984355,
0.2893100083,
0.520539403,
0.3941498101,
-0.1188327298,
-0.5959152579,
-0.0586444661,
0.1474055499,
-0.5024520159,
-0.8452439904,
0.4282774031,
0.2450965196,
0.530136466,
0.6733459234,
0.3551279306,
0.172294572,
-0.4053605795,
0.4349943697,
0.4477782547,
-0.7498688698,
0.3907640278,
-0.3614115715,
0.0943717062,
0.6813493967,
0.4762012362,
-0.3924294114,
0.0902713761,
-0.6876888871,
-0.7279048562,
0.7199375629,
-0.3170181215,
0.1000573337,
-0.2703807354,
0.2317071557,
0.4437457621,
0.5719673038,
-0.8485902548,
-0.1422581673,
-0.4059254229,
-0.1905491948,
-0.5855301619,
-0.2566179335,
-0.1183765456,
-0.0412962623,
0.5694847107,
-0.3760703504,
0.0739355385,
-0.0510031134,
-0.2104926258,
-0.2083296776,
0.5134068131,
0.8708455563,
0.5132610202,
-0.5619679093,
0.0882538557,
-0.1247256473,
-0.236730352,
0.3572436571,
-0.174203068,
-0.2853740752,
-0.2040888965,
-0.2099628001,
1.0219792128,
0.2231705189,
-0.6957955956,
0.8851844072,
0.0118608987,
-0.4682506919,
0.0214624554,
-0.0006088142,
0.0101303002,
0.0102428338,
0.2205228359,
-0.0990320295,
0.1410914361,
-0.6902258992,
0.0855532289,
0.6484926939,
-0.2837038934,
-0.1251551956,
0.4231605828,
0.3817549348,
-0.125021264,
0.5325263739,
-0.5512650013,
-0.6018449664,
0.2541913986,
0.6497158408,
0.8416542411,
-0.1161378697,
0.7199605107,
0.1994303018,
0.0782456771,
-0.4131322503,
0.214625895,
-0.3349512517,
-0.6858812571,
-0.0690193474,
-0.6109048128,
-0.5956001878,
-0.1397787035,
-0.6397747993,
0.3856408298,
-0.1906395406,
-0.1527443677,
-0.6202858686,
0.0472016782,
-0.5740047097,
0.1943648756,
-0.0573537126,
0.6355777383,
-1.0412249565,
0.725101769,
0.5172111988,
-0.3832361996,
-0.6063632965,
-0.0405894667,
-0.4359475672,
-0.6747413874,
1.0040707588,
-0.0309093464,
-0.0292019658,
0.0876489952,
-0.1770325303,
-0.5982546806,
0.8298065662,
0.3771760166,
-0.4139084518,
-0.046944011,
0.3137164116,
0.3657333553,
-0.6057867408,
0.5954002738,
0.5668941736,
0.4139156044,
0.0607187338,
-0.6287752986,
-0.3564441204,
0.2422023118,
0.0109220399,
0.5492051244,
-0.6210798025,
0.8933383226,
-0.2566995919,
0.0429317355,
-0.3056781292,
0.4276419878,
0.7960278988,
0.0845927671,
0.8706181049,
0.5473771691,
0.5702371597,
0.3259421587,
1.0239920616,
0.2641732097,
0.6018403172,
0.9026188254,
-0.3983505666,
0.9275804162,
0.4789896011,
0.0601579845,
0.649148345,
0.7770904899,
0.3860055208,
1.2880940437,
0.3638187349,
-0.1065339595,
-0.215070799,
-0.0603858493,
-0.434735328,
-0.0824922472,
0.0107579883,
-0.5494551659,
-0.4120427072,
0.2705582678,
-0.2597520947,
-0.003469392,
-0.3279518485,
0.7791448832,
-0.3129916787,
-0.8716052175,
0.5870446563,
0.0821990147,
0.8880033493,
-0.7125601768,
0.1151329428,
-0.3053079247,
0.5095001459,
0.0338152014,
-0.4528703988,
-0.0369356982,
-0.2766964436,
-0.4914042056,
-0.421533376,
0.4298756719,
-0.764164865,
-0.2157883346,
0.3041981459,
-0.0464018099,
-0.0888808072,
-0.0746043175,
-0.5268113613,
-0.105174467,
-0.1764960885,
-0.3059441745,
0.6288035512,
0.1788270622,
-0.0911583453,
0.5300474167,
0.4967869818,
0.1430718154,
0.145853892,
0.0278287157,
0.6986533403,
-0.2921532691,
-1.0686341524,
-0.7974985838,
0.3629484177,
0.0104798693,
-0.4281767011,
0.4395258725,
0.3728358448,
0.8327263594,
-0.4476547539,
0.9796004891,
0.1067628041,
0.6990171671,
-0.3427771628,
0.2623474002,
-0.6457615495,
-0.0849983618,
-0.2451744527,
-0.9696706533,
0.0662340969,
0.4637266994,
-0.5928308368,
0.060513895,
0.737406075,
0.4735987782,
-0.202868849,
-0.2214744836,
0.2301268578,
-0.5519063473,
0.2726224065,
0.8691182733,
0.7094509006,
-0.0360695682,
0.6073858738,
-0.297955662,
-0.5050671101,
-0.4459253252,
-1.0606473684,
-0.9905241728,
-0.5171461105,
0.1711077094,
-0.0702784061,
0.125107035,
1.0841375589,
0.7539349198,
-0.6249802709,
-0.4478165805,
-0.3084147871,
0.1064005196,
-0.3378816843,
-0.2630337179,
0.5043793917,
-0.7381201982,
-0.5624932647,
0.1202607825,
0.2361165583,
-0.1271186173,
-0.3974736333,
-0.5509464741,
-0.0063337735,
0.1350833327,
0.4003570676,
0.2816962898,
-0.3231476545,
-0.1215007976,
0.0635970309,
-0.1297293007,
-0.0635452121,
1.0970722437,
-0.5847291946,
0.3428660929,
0.7233732343,
0.6734310389,
0.419500947,
0.4727019966,
0.6773928404,
-0.868283987,
-0.028034905,
0.0125820702,
0.1557085216,
0.1771882623,
-0.186566785,
0.3448335826,
0.2407522202,
-0.7467135787,
-0.9143505692,
0.3436706066,
-0.5280073881,
-0.2086020559,
1.3921556473,
-0.01169548,
-0.1956147254,
-0.0524368696,
-0.1933719963,
0.0240410771,
-0.6024409533,
0.7381142974,
0.411449343,
-0.0975054502,
-0.1645995975,
-0.0805345401,
0.8253401518,
0.4694654047,
-0.9367600083,
0.2129495442,
0.1144102961,
0.4641959667,
-0.0548338331,
0.9214125872,
0.2307986319,
0.3038121164,
-0.565716207,
0.2450732738,
0.0285740159,
-0.5311768055,
-0.4653095603,
0.2049363256,
0.1304528415,
-0.407445699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14903v1
|
Tokenization counts: the impact of tokenization on arithmetic in frontier LLMs
| 2024-02-22T18:14:09 | 2024-02-22T18:14:09 |
Aaditya K. Singh, DJ Strouse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Tokenization, the division of input text into input tokens, is an often
overlooked aspect of the large language model (LLM) pipeline and could be the
source of useful or harmful inductive biases. Historically, LLMs have relied on
byte pair encoding, without care to specific input domains. With the increased
use of LLMs for reasoning, various number-specific tokenization schemes have
been adopted, with popular models like LLaMa and PaLM opting for single-digit
tokenization while GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 have separate tokens for each 1-, 2-, and
3-digit numbers. In this work, we study the effect this choice has on numerical
reasoning through the use of arithmetic tasks. We consider left-to-right and
right-to-left tokenization for GPT-3.5 and -4, finding that right-to-left
tokenization (enforced by comma separating numbers at inference time) leads to
largely improved performance. Furthermore, we find that model errors when using
standard left-to-right tokenization follow stereotyped error patterns,
suggesting that model computations are systematic rather than approximate. We
show that the model is able to convert between tokenizations easily, thus
allowing chain-of-thought-inspired approaches to recover performance on
left-to-right tokenized inputs. We also find the gap between tokenization
directions decreases when models are scaled, possibly indicating that larger
models are better able to override this tokenization-dependent inductive bias.
In summary, our work performs the first study of how number tokenization
choices lead to differences in model performance on arithmetic tasks,
accompanied by a thorough analysis of error patterns. We hope this work
inspires practitioners to more carefully ablate number tokenization-related
choices when working towards general models of numerical reasoning.
|
[
-0.4003571272,
-0.7282978892,
0.609416306,
0.4917717874,
-0.4338341057,
0.0464721397,
0.048415374,
-0.4952599406,
0.2678375244,
0.4688126743,
-0.1471595168,
-0.4726020694,
-0.7362325788,
0.1748558134,
-0.3089568019,
0.8788929582,
-0.0007192262,
0.4989979267,
-0.3705521524,
-0.1749561131,
-0.5596886873,
-1.1443881989,
-0.7354248762,
-0.1836868227,
0.4267599285,
0.2619427443,
0.6419168115,
0.8735008836,
0.7941483855,
0.3194430768,
-0.1954344064,
0.0519181266,
-0.146236375,
-0.2033174634,
-0.0142725557,
-0.8468407989,
-0.5430591106,
0.031804502,
0.7762256265,
0.8804203868,
-0.0823538601,
0.1056631804,
-0.3272001445,
0.6894450784,
-0.2574916184,
0.2503284514,
-0.6755978465,
0.0834055766,
-0.4851309061,
-0.1732617766,
-0.434401989,
-0.2935905159,
-0.4449101985,
-0.6893214583,
0.212372303,
0.0388436131,
0.2222570032,
0.4471158385,
-0.4302853346,
-0.4003333151,
-0.5414088964,
0.7191607952,
-0.984893024,
0.4293366373,
0.4114329815,
-0.1157721505,
-0.1027289927,
-0.7206009626,
-0.5018507838,
0.0923342258,
-0.1064485535,
-0.0550328419,
-0.0759691596,
0.3518562019,
0.7983893752,
0.3878868222,
-0.2389380038,
0.2656636238,
-0.6304677725,
-0.1780026406,
0.376031667,
0.3822372258,
0.2887801826,
-0.0494314283,
-0.250222683,
0.1874377131,
-0.9938051105,
0.2234284878,
0.3531611264,
0.3698729277,
0.0937591791,
0.6801939011,
-0.2317422628,
0.7303782701,
0.0481244512,
-0.1895483285,
0.0458157323,
-0.4261143506,
-0.2490473241,
-0.0566150248,
0.5783644319,
0.1991212517,
0.2540802062,
-0.1361557841,
-0.3954738379,
0.1523933858,
-0.0163657889,
-1.047395587,
0.2199517936,
0.0291764252,
-0.3491313159,
-0.3618215322,
0.0613098107,
-0.3209044933,
-0.3320494294,
-0.4183027148,
0.3662704527,
-0.3318088949,
0.0572471917,
0.2332956046,
-0.1685980707,
0.0467963666,
0.2834874988,
-1.2450690269,
0.5041791201,
1.3044018745,
0.9946705103,
-0.2734037638,
-0.1226660535,
-0.8347767591,
-0.3378303647,
-0.6261572838,
0.4482476115,
-0.7275547981,
-0.4406548738,
-0.1031790897,
-0.2270483822,
-0.2301216573,
-0.5998289585,
0.5161979198,
-0.8217837811,
-0.0775661767,
-0.5880571604,
-0.5281257033,
-0.2184125632,
0.0155159421,
-0.6595285535,
0.9841951132,
-0.2404988855,
-0.750097394,
0.5138453245,
-0.8264639378,
-0.4426895678,
0.1770426184,
-0.3251532018,
-0.1221748441,
0.5009544492,
0.2202843279,
0.0939897969,
-0.296090126,
0.2305871993,
-0.3156228065,
-0.8172419667,
0.3469640315,
-0.5135151148,
0.8474317193,
-0.0563030355,
-0.464615345,
0.0967709646,
-0.6165938377,
-0.1677951664,
-0.1193618998,
-0.1715616584,
-0.4164825082,
0.0396133848,
-0.6639089584,
0.2676157653,
0.0278377533,
-0.6355369687,
0.1688226461,
-0.4746359587,
0.5062150359,
0.7691574097,
0.0921044499,
0.584528625,
-0.1813726574,
0.5470006466,
0.1114304811,
0.0220332593,
-0.1791246533,
-0.6632910371,
-0.9799674749,
-0.3355287313,
0.573438406,
0.5007894635,
-0.8163673878,
-0.0362913944,
-0.2936951518,
-0.1251724064,
-0.1465084553,
-0.1345971227,
0.0281746257,
0.368090868,
0.1675661951,
-0.2495701313,
-0.265704006,
-0.6744077802,
-0.3467422128,
-0.2220729887,
0.0501921698,
0.0329399779,
0.4031857252,
0.0913519114,
0.9163759947,
-0.3115994632,
-0.066751644,
-0.0048125028,
0.1771501154,
0.3809558451,
0.5004703999,
0.312974453,
-0.6307538152,
-0.2899481654,
-0.0867342725,
-0.515578568,
-0.1539713889,
-0.0536500216,
-0.1365581006,
0.3453618586,
0.5494746566,
-0.8435299993,
0.738009274,
0.3294279873,
-0.49491328,
0.2925212085,
0.0396160372,
0.0163642894,
-0.5897847414,
-0.1889961064,
-0.0368059054,
-0.0431597009,
-0.6744702458,
0.0327555798,
0.000941044,
0.1230807751,
-0.2056673616,
0.4013152421,
-0.1843114793,
-0.3708735108,
-0.144728899,
-0.2825215161,
0.0554223806,
0.4985387325,
0.0086478489,
1.111836791,
0.1604257226,
-0.2786256373,
0.0030577958,
-0.1324952245,
-0.1122454032,
0.2247259915,
-0.7196879983,
0.3947175741,
0.0157873798,
0.3417717814,
-0.8953318,
0.1533323824,
0.2982160151,
-0.4447259009,
0.0899411812,
-0.3034691513,
-0.7421427965,
-0.0447185375,
-0.2946781814,
0.7933721542,
0.3774102628,
-0.4906458259,
0.7123112679,
0.2309586853,
-0.4380081892,
-0.4333978593,
-0.5865718126,
0.0597365722,
-0.4360987544,
-0.7249743342,
0.2550774813,
0.1105287522,
-0.6114741564,
-0.2903508544,
-0.2062417269,
0.1585614085,
0.1354344487,
0.3353420794,
0.5751649737,
-0.0843874142,
0.4224619865,
0.0948353037,
-0.035891369,
0.4771239758,
-0.4734504819,
0.5612438917,
-0.0950000435,
-0.5894842148,
-0.0370457843,
0.2703813016,
0.7635386586,
-0.3952453732,
0.6635070443,
0.4726266265,
-0.5283201933,
0.0270996839,
-0.6185063124,
-0.0802914053,
-0.4792360067,
0.2347030044,
-0.5695566535,
-0.9323530793,
0.6572683454,
0.1448720098,
0.1413380951,
0.5938164592,
0.5406761169,
0.2384187728,
1.0622442961,
0.3180936575,
0.085237585,
0.4266780317,
-0.2588696182,
0.2617646456,
-0.7424380779,
-0.1805441976,
-0.3880610764,
-0.1324590296,
-0.6553612351,
-0.9222422838,
0.3288428783,
-0.1005164832,
-0.362986654,
-0.3096480966,
-0.3737910688,
0.624296546,
0.5658453703,
0.0083320197,
0.3928124309,
0.1846287549,
-0.219045192,
-0.2412177473,
-0.7470270395,
-0.3336640596,
1.0561088324,
0.5428174734,
0.468373239,
0.0138015272,
0.8518408537,
0.3024032712,
0.5539334416,
-1.0249609947,
0.5353939533,
-0.3737854958,
-0.5210978389,
-0.434735775,
-0.6075030565,
-0.4316997826,
0.5266851783,
0.1493339539,
-0.6399624348,
0.3452198803,
-0.2490668148,
-0.4281325638,
0.4395261109,
-0.5682457089,
0.5732457042,
-0.2864340246,
-0.3686494231,
-0.2817002833,
-0.3572441936,
0.4339340925,
-0.2202757597,
0.3707385063,
0.0485777296,
-0.2207980156,
0.965123117,
-0.8008738756,
1.0072274208,
-0.2943134308,
-0.15862073,
0.3357278109,
0.0961451605,
0.7837561369,
0.0348414034,
-0.1797646135,
0.6026859283,
-0.1108472273,
-0.3305397928,
-0.580601871,
0.5646724105,
-0.7926807404,
-0.8760095835,
-0.5239260197,
-0.6308667064,
-0.324522227,
0.0662516579,
0.1845483631,
0.8069373965,
0.1272336245,
-0.0447018035,
0.5522369742,
0.0950973257,
0.5193653703,
0.2307368368,
-0.3818772435,
-0.6735652685,
1.028444171,
0.4900503159,
0.4033941031,
0.2350422442,
-0.0230629165,
-0.3794514835,
-0.7069586515,
-0.6201627851,
0.2891551256,
-1.0085074902,
-0.2160554826,
-0.5666316748,
-0.0586102381,
-0.1741286367,
0.0305791534,
-0.0327378139,
-1.0250999928,
-0.3664663136,
-0.3390767872,
0.2448788136,
0.9074249268,
-0.1440810859,
0.139699921,
-0.595248282,
0.1544124782,
0.3392960727,
0.3661602736,
0.0726238415,
-0.7923671007,
-0.2473906875,
0.0060199057,
0.1214007735,
-0.5189117193,
0.0889803097,
-0.1997139901,
0.1265557408,
0.2688853741,
-0.3475116789,
0.6650666595,
-0.4717598855,
0.6418617964,
0.2073472738,
-1.1021844149,
-0.2706112564,
-0.318051219,
0.1927869916,
0.3852175772,
0.0450298972,
-0.6890758276,
-0.0491213165,
-0.3465119302,
-0.5644108057,
0.6305826306,
0.0126895094,
0.0604556017,
-0.2987656295,
0.2660387456,
0.1612309068,
0.0109981652,
-0.4999199212,
-0.1222718805,
-0.162982747,
0.0688222647,
0.2088858038,
-0.3703729808,
-0.1594599932,
-0.3677413464,
0.3956248462,
-0.1783352941,
0.2146270573,
0.0011719473,
0.0135441637,
-0.0516040511,
0.1199984178,
0.7439742088,
0.833239615,
0.0723352656,
0.0842383578,
0.4237411022,
-0.5006760955,
0.0796817914,
0.3272807598,
-0.2653428018,
0.1388157159,
0.3390714526,
0.8622161746,
0.0601103827,
-0.0906575993,
0.3713401258,
-0.0677751005,
-0.2949092686,
-0.2118243575,
-0.1403468996,
0.0957090408,
0.0617381334,
0.6320893764,
0.19515872,
0.2517404556,
-0.3188502789,
-0.1259111911,
0.5997747779,
-0.1592546403,
-0.3007368445,
0.5411885977,
0.3267355561,
-0.3332060874,
0.6143628955,
-0.2185680419,
-0.6561686993,
0.8781960607,
0.6069471836,
0.9049649835,
0.2299795598,
0.058924675,
0.3274848461,
0.2979991436,
0.1304127872,
-0.010694528,
-0.2101196647,
-0.6657738686,
-0.877825737,
-0.6037663221,
-0.4518524706,
-0.3219813406,
-0.4777573645,
0.1178177521,
-0.5869868398,
-0.3698248267,
0.0089616617,
-0.1036564037,
-0.6695005298,
0.1430437863,
0.4032022059,
1.0246189833,
-0.7370784879,
0.5200603604,
0.6791273355,
-0.1829880178,
-0.857761085,
-0.1490956694,
-0.2074601054,
-0.9356153011,
0.857874155,
0.2639070749,
-0.0884429887,
0.0393089056,
-0.3269633651,
-0.9666285515,
1.0409488678,
0.0651681274,
-0.5908225775,
-0.1017859355,
0.7282783985,
0.444201529,
-0.3870151043,
0.3537798524,
0.7980160117,
0.3000254631,
0.3098830581,
-0.996209085,
0.1952085197,
-0.0798200443,
0.1030915082,
0.6278568506,
-0.8055012226,
1.0191566944,
-0.2268026024,
-0.2607431412,
-0.1355362982,
0.462729156,
0.4166046977,
0.3728555143,
0.5247340798,
0.8150213361,
0.7783830166,
-0.2969418466,
0.8483536839,
-0.2580345869,
0.0883638412,
0.6557587981,
-0.1498427987,
0.5220000744,
0.6383157969,
-0.5415295362,
0.4705459774,
0.5823439956,
0.3689982593,
0.1964572966,
0.4097105861,
-0.5066799521,
-0.2360556722,
0.0562560447,
-0.3488867581,
0.3106109798,
0.5293793082,
-0.2338562757,
0.0346751846,
-0.2301350385,
0.2084112018,
-0.3440860212,
-0.5575905442,
0.8057547212,
0.2402051389,
-0.7778916359,
0.4385891855,
0.2265006751,
0.6256149411,
-0.3355707526,
-0.2456056327,
-0.6077055931,
0.0117564369,
-0.3399746716,
-0.4492448568,
0.2154957056,
0.0766088963,
-0.1934829056,
-0.0338857733,
0.6510251164,
-0.1932364255,
-0.8779992461,
-0.2121648341,
0.4657297134,
0.107688345,
-0.1992730945,
-0.3195325434,
0.3717145622,
0.1445032507,
-0.0698992983,
0.3913117349,
0.7806602716,
-0.5388963223,
0.4337337613,
0.911152482,
0.1220033616,
0.1678069383,
0.2980290353,
0.903108716,
-0.8327569366,
-0.4570463002,
-1.1585288048,
0.3480699658,
0.0827808455,
-0.0473936312,
0.6087477207,
0.5896411538,
0.5033693314,
0.1849558651,
0.7130339146,
0.0608911812,
0.1456207037,
-0.5234382153,
0.1920146793,
-0.0986350924,
0.5148252249,
0.1177192405,
-0.8705391884,
-0.4486860633,
0.2888865173,
-0.749794066,
0.0236252602,
0.639541924,
0.564601779,
0.2764085531,
0.1389570087,
0.272295773,
-0.1961544901,
0.428917706,
0.2257585078,
0.9365873337,
-0.2409520894,
0.3667799234,
-0.1682239473,
-0.2963060737,
-0.064683862,
-0.663064003,
-0.8164932132,
-0.1922933459,
-0.0195345487,
-0.1787215769,
-0.0291372836,
0.9655244946,
0.3779398799,
-0.5775280595,
-0.2187103778,
-0.3007219732,
0.3439381123,
0.1922615618,
-0.2392168343,
0.1761088222,
-0.4852060676,
-0.7282782197,
0.1161778271,
0.4436790943,
0.0455522686,
-0.1928425878,
0.0280777737,
0.2535307705,
0.2567301393,
0.7482322454,
0.0920408368,
-0.7002273798,
-0.064466536,
0.3304011524,
-0.1041612253,
0.1764495671,
1.0893425941,
-0.8153464794,
0.3812600672,
0.4532012045,
0.5763926506,
0.5867581964,
0.4379853308,
0.5645523667,
-0.3487041593,
0.2145231515,
0.2352135181,
0.3784087598,
0.4159294963,
-0.3561737537,
0.7074591517,
0.4816235304,
-0.5347159505,
-0.8229762316,
0.0048872004,
-0.5384033322,
0.0639344305,
1.3176822662,
0.0398894176,
0.1056729704,
0.0851232782,
-0.1780775636,
-0.0678301379,
-0.3391794562,
0.5990294814,
1.0220111609,
-0.2522023022,
0.1548316032,
-0.3899073005,
0.4524800479,
0.5586400032,
-0.5769789219,
0.032924585,
0.4487633407,
0.1930639595,
0.1155162305,
0.7576313019,
-0.181256488,
0.3141328394,
0.1827986389,
-0.1091262996,
-0.1720427424,
0.0484767593,
-0.3729135096,
-0.095550701,
0.373565197,
-0.219175294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14901v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14901v1
|
A Usage-centric Take on Intent Understanding in E-Commerce
| 2024-02-22T18:09:33 | 2024-02-22T18:09:33 |
Wendi Zhou, Tianyi Li, Pavlos Vougiouklis, Mark Steedman, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Identifying and understanding user intents is a pivotal task for E-Commerce.
Despite its popularity, intent understanding has not been consistently defined
or accurately benchmarked. In this paper, we focus on predicative user intents
as "how a customer uses a product", and pose intent understanding as a natural
language reasoning task, independent of product ontologies. We identify two
weaknesses of FolkScope, the SOTA E-Commerce Intent Knowledge Graph, that limit
its capacity to reason about user intents and to recommend diverse useful
products. Following these observations, we introduce a Product Recovery
Benchmark including a novel evaluation framework and an example dataset. We
further validate the above FolkScope weaknesses on this benchmark.
|
[
-0.3193819523,
-0.6741867661,
0.65833354,
0.1288522482,
-0.0112827877,
0.0362621509,
-0.1279492825,
-0.4975398779,
0.2731105983,
0.5789240003,
-0.9683948159,
-0.592651844,
-0.3602229059,
0.2812122405,
-0.3190767169,
0.9710733891,
-0.0671425238,
-0.4292826056,
0.0203863382,
-0.1352190971,
-0.4569330812,
-0.2835327387,
-0.4743358195,
0.0816073045,
0.3070456684,
0.8854238391,
0.4306592047,
-0.2121087611,
0.6787337661,
0.3881135285,
0.4707367718,
0.1335157454,
-0.7803225517,
0.0621079504,
-0.1989291757,
-0.3583945632,
-0.1746561229,
0.1410370022,
0.2354324162,
0.6431491971,
-0.4454251528,
0.2498668432,
-0.0086583579,
0.6218225956,
-0.7867877483,
-0.0835009068,
-0.5847896338,
0.0568464436,
-0.1023821086,
0.0130856801,
-0.4579281509,
-0.2384558171,
0.47792539,
-1.2474738359,
0.3092036247,
0.3420677781,
1.0414863825,
0.2255994231,
-0.208843857,
-0.5570468307,
-0.7795655131,
0.7315010428,
-0.2918673456,
0.7036551237,
0.7113423944,
0.7545266151,
-0.2584304214,
-1.1638623476,
-0.5652928948,
0.0888115615,
-0.3619053066,
0.2381462753,
-0.281470567,
-0.1461418718,
0.2672458887,
0.3391215205,
-0.4629951715,
-0.4844738543,
-0.4595619142,
-0.263691932,
0.6101033092,
0.1147570312,
0.3406022489,
-0.215751335,
-0.7979585528,
0.2171116918,
-0.3952164054,
0.3656795621,
0.228646785,
-0.0076931226,
0.146400854,
0.5114165545,
-0.270996511,
0.7680513263,
0.300095886,
-0.0579648092,
0.2814354002,
-0.573210597,
-0.5264812708,
-0.0136441616,
0.4113388956,
0.2519232333,
0.2128206193,
-0.3429012895,
-0.0105213122,
-0.2952652276,
0.8329225779,
-0.399723947,
-0.1225910559,
0.3513424098,
-0.5923716426,
0.4821957648,
0.2110132724,
-0.1445296258,
-0.3103911579,
-0.1390210539,
0.4505391717,
-0.3528790176,
-0.0769114941,
0.5442968607,
-0.2398138046,
0.2544117272,
0.2085677534,
-0.7875012755,
0.5545867682,
1.0753173828,
0.517095387,
-0.0293035116,
-0.4271201491,
-0.3949833512,
0.1021656394,
-0.1033255234,
1.0723942518,
-0.3003720641,
-0.3802708983,
-0.2340411246,
0.1933316439,
-0.1512802541,
-0.5021835566,
0.7172552347,
-0.7169958353,
0.1143957302,
-0.6465901732,
-0.5897512436,
-0.6745588183,
0.5289833546,
-0.579858005,
0.3574752808,
0.1356182694,
-0.5085518956,
0.8900666833,
-0.4761977196,
-0.5953361988,
0.3837088943,
-0.0182839725,
-0.4504832029,
0.3784229159,
-0.3455326855,
0.1644162536,
-0.1368757337,
0.1413966715,
-0.4095343351,
-0.258794874,
0.197885409,
-0.0401918627,
0.7867119908,
0.3043682575,
-0.1699707955,
-0.1036265716,
-0.5820909142,
-0.2076196969,
0.1341190487,
-0.146588251,
-0.343565017,
0.2169027328,
-0.082780391,
0.0469001457,
0.2296972871,
-0.6007238626,
0.0976315066,
-0.3070141971,
0.4706847966,
0.5963141322,
-0.0498529598,
0.1843481958,
-0.0299143437,
0.4007458389,
-0.2179604322,
0.3933028579,
0.0053239111,
-0.5400751829,
-0.5271658301,
-0.2201935351,
-0.2056900114,
0.2024282813,
-0.5729931593,
0.1934414357,
-0.3478133678,
-0.4069048464,
-0.0081208339,
0.2392045557,
0.3903587759,
0.7040327787,
0.2741223276,
-0.7858806849,
-0.326548785,
-1.0219874382,
-0.8202917576,
-0.2679890096,
-0.225858435,
0.7228800058,
0.0309282243,
-0.3451924324,
1.1718066931,
-0.6672465205,
-0.6323414445,
-0.4275647998,
0.2940491438,
0.2913507819,
-0.1428932548,
0.3117530048,
-1.0002545118,
-0.6603986025,
-0.1469029039,
-0.5181922317,
-0.1436785609,
-0.1229910478,
-0.2154889405,
-0.065351136,
0.2122154981,
-0.6578631401,
0.6251822114,
0.1727101356,
-0.9135109782,
0.5104748607,
-0.279088676,
0.2534837127,
-0.6396310925,
-0.0766448304,
0.1069233045,
-0.2346869409,
-0.8191965222,
-0.3643115759,
0.084001109,
0.1529385746,
-0.5977599025,
0.1470802724,
-0.3844382763,
-0.5275270343,
-0.0439828895,
0.0844897106,
0.5160346031,
0.0554137081,
0.0927989632,
0.6327717304,
-0.0066138897,
-0.7271715999,
-0.12164139,
0.6116233468,
-0.3639332652,
0.8361945152,
-0.6443952918,
0.1182700917,
-0.1037826538,
0.0077838134,
-1.1297471523,
-0.3076786697,
0.5650072694,
-0.3679547012,
0.0544547327,
-0.1343838722,
-0.2007696331,
-0.3982968032,
-0.1521715671,
0.2582158148,
0.2750144005,
-0.5817431808,
0.9801769853,
0.3456184864,
0.1598008424,
-0.4408489764,
-0.5226242542,
-0.08125633,
-0.4418078363,
-0.7701048255,
0.3152607977,
0.0365669727,
-0.4311006665,
-0.0415205434,
-0.1159039289,
-0.1076895297,
0.3949063718,
0.2140936255,
0.0957146138,
-0.0189616028,
0.4906846583,
-0.4803975821,
-0.4366590977,
0.1286876053,
-0.4159362614,
0.3005320132,
-0.210788846,
-0.4942229688,
-0.4518693686,
0.1621828377,
0.1535294205,
0.0643352792,
0.2498525679,
0.2910577655,
-0.1491311193,
-0.0207256749,
-0.5709315538,
-0.2383628637,
-0.5500124693,
0.1358741671,
-0.5207352042,
-0.4831334651,
0.2147427946,
0.0633099303,
0.0868252665,
0.3716376722,
0.372943759,
-0.2909946144,
0.6614261866,
0.6344126463,
0.3536490798,
0.1460419446,
-0.059050709,
0.6730579138,
-0.6118094921,
-0.1982165575,
-0.4496242106,
-0.502540946,
-0.3846361339,
-0.0755989179,
0.0460852757,
0.047066018,
-0.1516127139,
0.7723821402,
-0.3697354198,
0.1316105574,
0.5191282034,
0.0133373952,
0.6420794129,
0.203365162,
0.4235492945,
0.0586485341,
-0.2089660466,
-0.4963585138,
1.0870571136,
0.1205281913,
0.6638066769,
0.2042538673,
0.4953882992,
0.1245772392,
0.2800876796,
-1.0246732235,
0.3002797365,
-0.26159513,
-0.9293522835,
-0.0979103744,
-0.2784368098,
-1.1182957888,
0.1341240704,
0.1396685243,
-1.1617655754,
0.3818923831,
0.2986605465,
-0.6234519482,
-0.1941380352,
-1.3252547979,
0.9645401239,
-0.5109250546,
-0.4905008674,
-0.1471965909,
-0.4686170518,
0.1320219934,
0.1497976184,
0.3667522073,
-0.1289805323,
0.0367060117,
0.7997944355,
-0.4369738102,
0.5040962696,
-0.2648603916,
0.1937268376,
0.4217475951,
-0.1007632241,
0.2208479345,
0.1053744033,
0.3251473904,
0.0968943685,
-0.0971410498,
-0.332804352,
-0.6030532718,
0.2733609378,
-0.4600642323,
-0.7543193102,
-0.1462580711,
-0.0603448153,
-0.5553255677,
0.4540479183,
0.2779432535,
0.159909904,
-0.2933186591,
0.2077585906,
0.4136819541,
-0.0542441979,
0.2612616718,
0.7940248847,
-0.2883633673,
0.2141921818,
0.9220137596,
0.186287269,
0.1366154104,
0.0248745643,
0.3478808105,
-0.4075544775,
-0.2661134601,
-0.2524032295,
-0.025005497,
-0.7927658558,
0.2021340877,
-0.7608318329,
0.2136095464,
-0.1259990931,
-0.1478952169,
-0.4595562518,
-0.3613722324,
-0.1659165323,
-0.1152073219,
0.194452256,
0.8639240265,
0.1171389893,
0.2840943336,
-0.762896359,
0.6064779162,
0.5713222623,
0.4567558169,
-0.2007733285,
-0.1693329662,
-0.0523034111,
-0.1593291909,
-0.316931814,
-0.641194582,
0.2212124169,
0.227826342,
0.6628129482,
0.8121927381,
0.0925686061,
0.4670886695,
-0.1473962814,
0.6365716457,
0.2707130611,
-0.6982438564,
0.3701367974,
0.0664776713,
0.2640115023,
1.046307683,
0.6878229976,
-0.5892470479,
0.3295757473,
-0.6358470917,
-0.7656366825,
0.8701025248,
0.3546030521,
-0.0181553327,
-0.0171097368,
0.1664393395,
0.496850878,
0.2264750004,
-0.2631635964,
-0.0974118039,
-0.2962654531,
-0.162774086,
-0.2678121328,
-0.3288049102,
-0.0985624418,
-0.1015228629,
0.375425756,
0.0124112777,
0.1083068624,
0.2354361862,
-0.5051295161,
0.1387793124,
0.2323683947,
0.0202649608,
0.8899293542,
-0.1768275499,
0.124651581,
-0.278072536,
-0.9975841045,
-0.1751517057,
0.2368394881,
-0.271946013,
-0.3663448691,
0.0651860386,
0.3850634694,
0.2679543793,
-0.7818496227,
0.528424561,
-0.6391109228,
-0.0872926861,
-0.3357768357,
-0.0709931925,
0.0668089241,
0.0298991837,
0.3824084997,
0.0111472784,
0.8518034816,
-0.5362366438,
0.2257800251,
0.3853922486,
-0.7255228162,
-0.5126675367,
0.1480203569,
0.1369478405,
-0.6861463785,
0.6564412713,
-0.4463817775,
-0.6308161616,
0.5640337467,
0.4471993148,
1.097299099,
0.2061557472,
0.3798875511,
0.3301194906,
0.2317805737,
0.1548864692,
0.6219847202,
-0.4868305027,
-1.055279851,
0.104005456,
-0.2095071524,
-0.3089395761,
-0.4434861541,
-0.5903128386,
0.3070196509,
-0.379329741,
-0.2874782383,
0.3858375847,
0.0376740992,
-0.9416185021,
0.1158691123,
-0.3226438463,
0.6759710908,
-0.5936515927,
0.3125917017,
0.5364629626,
-0.3751476705,
-0.9773550034,
0.2257209122,
0.2772036493,
-0.77824229,
0.5236816406,
0.5397148132,
-0.5547084212,
-0.227141425,
-0.3263111711,
-0.6097432971,
0.9271182418,
-0.2593330741,
-0.5623340607,
0.4232377708,
0.0615396425,
0.313806653,
-0.3122880459,
0.2917412519,
0.9097200632,
0.661055088,
-0.0177454334,
-0.5017837286,
-0.0316160619,
-0.1760440618,
-0.289365381,
-0.0119471643,
-0.334831059,
0.6201480627,
-0.0761082917,
-0.7445662618,
-0.3323830068,
-0.0485487878,
0.1386698186,
0.8028354645,
0.7779806256,
0.8025435805,
0.5767931938,
-0.03326625,
1.1145306826,
0.0722877309,
0.5035325289,
1.1929677725,
-0.3401898444,
0.710373044,
0.403015703,
-0.452653259,
0.5153443813,
0.4395272136,
0.2797763348,
0.5593571663,
-0.1183693931,
0.1547351032,
-0.4407077432,
-0.0082700076,
-0.2453719378,
0.7387603521,
0.5880969763,
-0.3713537455,
-0.1309517026,
-0.2151742578,
-0.3496666849,
-0.0900897533,
-0.0768746138,
1.098731041,
0.1127056256,
-0.6853374839,
0.4529229403,
-0.4313720167,
0.0731866881,
-0.3999392092,
0.2317438126,
0.1722446084,
0.3101495802,
-0.4427770376,
-0.8831456304,
0.5175725818,
-0.304954648,
0.0128484098,
-0.1059923023,
1.080516696,
0.3237624764,
-0.3793255687,
0.4016843736,
0.3414562047,
0.0194048341,
-0.0653315485,
-0.5201320052,
-0.0114254681,
-0.0953173339,
-0.6388499141,
-0.1279962957,
0.2458100021,
0.1547502428,
0.6246663928,
0.4330787063,
-0.548283875,
-0.082397595,
0.2049368173,
0.5560571551,
-0.4965088069,
-0.547332406,
-0.6019200683,
0.4845351577,
-0.3589444757,
-0.5044574142,
1.0003093481,
0.4867687225,
0.8868825436,
0.1142009124,
0.6861729622,
-0.039623078,
0.5212477446,
-0.1229060888,
0.4834637046,
-0.75997293,
0.4438776374,
0.0168037061,
-0.7628856897,
-0.0468843095,
0.4892068207,
-0.8117954135,
-0.0325761288,
0.592698276,
0.3427635133,
-0.3227041364,
0.6363595724,
0.1082623526,
0.2912305593,
0.0918986648,
0.3994407356,
1.0476819277,
-0.2132735997,
0.5337733626,
-0.2415574789,
-0.3369748294,
-0.5002323985,
-0.5592426658,
-0.3749406338,
-0.4272755682,
0.0396192595,
-0.219870016,
-0.1217872128,
0.6932764053,
0.8198302388,
-0.7585947514,
-0.0660825223,
-0.5224244595,
0.3277957737,
-0.334939003,
-0.1557665914,
0.0502252206,
-0.566401124,
-0.2823286057,
0.1086211503,
0.7370002866,
-0.3792647123,
-0.2101586759,
-0.1357406229,
-0.224147439,
0.0169052407,
0.5694032907,
0.6274944544,
-0.6930685043,
-0.3244259059,
0.4611007869,
0.2650677562,
0.3110024631,
1.130017519,
-0.6671213508,
0.9802802801,
0.5782648325,
0.4603143036,
0.6748878956,
0.2588324547,
0.4758506119,
-0.1432592273,
-0.1412647367,
0.1618903577,
0.4181710482,
0.2351796329,
-0.4364646971,
0.3910271525,
-0.0709229708,
-0.5693404675,
-0.1047172695,
0.6821274757,
-0.9509821534,
-0.4429522753,
0.903985858,
-0.4334927499,
-0.3394777775,
-0.9552471042,
-0.1964865029,
-0.2070449442,
-0.2619858384,
1.0210841894,
0.5487184525,
-0.2586999238,
0.1503488272,
-0.3295159638,
0.3076294363,
0.2486546338,
-0.6696323156,
-0.0355704129,
0.393532902,
0.3769236207,
0.3645268381,
1.0021164417,
0.0883667544,
0.44718799,
0.0154009731,
-0.3932117522,
0.1868247986,
-0.4023467302,
0.2154799849,
0.1837801635,
0.2602105439,
-0.1133961082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14746v1
|
Scaling Efficient LLMs
| 2024-02-22T18:06:19 | 2024-02-22T18:06:19 |
B. N. Kausik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Trained LLMs are typically sparse in that most of the parameters are zero,
raising questions on efficiency. In response, we inquire into efficient LLMs,
i.e. those with the fewest parameters that achieve the desired accuracy on a
training corpus. Specifically, we compare theoretical and empirical estimates
for training loss at current scale to obtain upper and lower bounds on the
number of unique sequences in a natural training corpus as a function of its
size. Our result implies (1) to double the number of skills represented in a
training corpus, the corpus must scale roughly between three and five fold (2)
for efficient LLMs, the number of parameters $N$ and the size $D$ of a natural
training corpus scale as $N \sim D^{0.58}$ (3) if the number of parameters of
an LLM is smaller than the number of unique sequences in the training corpus,
scaling up can uncover emergent skills.
|
[
-0.4611861408,
-0.503149569,
0.5052691102,
0.3643014431,
-0.1770182699,
-0.065162994,
-0.5692816973,
-0.335488975,
0.2503526807,
0.079927586,
-0.4046861231,
-0.3832318187,
-0.9329866171,
0.3139911592,
-0.6234001517,
0.8339729905,
0.1226374134,
0.3440517187,
-0.2206990719,
-0.4948271811,
-0.1011592001,
-0.385707736,
-0.9667381644,
-0.1516229063,
0.7853340507,
0.5825160146,
0.5703850389,
1.0905680656,
0.7235899568,
0.3271529377,
-0.3806791604,
0.2042204887,
-0.8083910942,
0.0445308052,
0.2808614671,
-0.808999896,
-0.2976174951,
0.1598741859,
1.1592212915,
1.2262327671,
0.0389072523,
0.4341041446,
0.2020095438,
0.7533345819,
-0.4363744855,
-0.1414384097,
-0.6209491491,
-0.0021261827,
-0.1045085862,
-0.3312403262,
-0.3875247538,
-0.386947155,
-0.0835689306,
-0.6867743731,
0.4868701994,
-0.151063472,
0.7355112433,
0.5129135847,
-0.2778376043,
-0.178998813,
-0.5819388032,
0.9147952199,
-0.4209624827,
0.1922260672,
0.2060313821,
0.0886643827,
-0.0197548028,
-0.700802505,
-0.0753590316,
-0.1241445914,
0.0631380975,
-0.2184037715,
-0.052709166,
0.0941607431,
0.6825537086,
0.5594663024,
-0.2457339913,
0.5860148668,
-0.2739626169,
-0.0817835182,
0.5880662799,
0.5151403546,
0.1041915044,
0.1602662653,
-0.3558750749,
-0.0762691423,
-0.5539437532,
-0.1082261577,
0.5195764303,
0.3537729084,
-0.0241709352,
0.4353260398,
0.1459023654,
0.7602744102,
0.0945627615,
-0.5756282806,
-0.0458847545,
-0.4342502654,
-0.0920016095,
-0.0451721139,
0.4430364072,
0.4084482789,
0.2488709688,
-0.2364068478,
-0.1026370227,
-0.1949243695,
0.5401855111,
-0.9400303364,
0.0341020077,
-0.1760218889,
-0.4773396552,
-0.326970458,
-0.3274492919,
-0.5053800941,
-0.3861929774,
-0.3017630875,
0.7033978105,
-0.5606973171,
-0.0172213782,
-0.1909594834,
-0.402685523,
0.4425888062,
0.7350803018,
-1.0615483522,
0.4849569499,
0.4695912302,
1.227129817,
-0.1077249721,
-0.2607019544,
-0.3660669029,
-0.3946432173,
-0.5936658382,
0.4946491718,
-0.1547877342,
-0.2855623364,
-0.1861353368,
-0.1171582714,
-0.2557690144,
-0.6408455372,
0.5213118196,
-0.587756753,
-0.4332139492,
-0.4170424342,
-0.7222055793,
-0.166417405,
0.1517908573,
-0.8006002307,
1.1815748215,
0.3034771383,
-0.6422818899,
0.9153742194,
-0.4266574681,
-0.2622030675,
0.0394017734,
0.045437865,
-0.4483916163,
0.2481075972,
-0.1004785895,
0.6236742139,
-0.3210361898,
-0.4533049762,
-0.5396317244,
-0.6703591347,
0.3064641953,
-0.6290165782,
0.7457987666,
0.298730433,
-0.1864643991,
-0.183569923,
-0.9128795862,
0.4650584161,
-0.0965187475,
-0.9297659993,
-0.2837154865,
-0.1746498197,
-0.2013329417,
-0.2399723232,
0.379603982,
-0.4661465287,
0.2494199574,
-0.4159590602,
0.4867759347,
0.6229974031,
-0.019969251,
0.6564629078,
-0.5261167288,
0.4211033583,
-0.3998327553,
-0.0564394668,
-0.0496730283,
-0.2750236094,
-0.8581688404,
-0.88019526,
0.4916417301,
0.1880181432,
-0.0348905139,
0.3419800997,
-0.1943238825,
-0.7517529726,
-0.6030726433,
0.6414808631,
0.2341664284,
0.2903535366,
0.206546858,
-0.0256599914,
-0.5677469969,
-0.9001356959,
-0.3030944467,
0.1382698268,
-0.1772434711,
-0.041771736,
0.5546465516,
0.1580234319,
0.7466238141,
-0.0660522506,
0.0464274175,
-0.2549075484,
0.1696888655,
0.3577874005,
0.3159309328,
0.7065585852,
-0.6775589585,
-0.7317957282,
-0.3234479427,
-0.7682573199,
-0.0723209456,
-0.1714465022,
0.1664317399,
0.1918691397,
0.4733907878,
-0.3746082783,
0.2446562201,
0.3712888062,
0.1435476094,
0.0884646401,
-0.6040132046,
0.0465566516,
-0.7602197528,
-0.02481612,
0.001628565,
-0.1623648852,
-0.7788901329,
0.1689781249,
0.2444497347,
0.1544222832,
-0.4800365269,
0.3794406056,
-0.809222579,
-0.3425529897,
-0.2710929811,
-0.0194593035,
-0.2123024166,
0.5105113983,
-0.0359539203,
0.7872238755,
0.5086776018,
-0.7443349957,
0.0255161338,
-0.1351091564,
-0.2825692594,
0.7267435789,
-0.6756914854,
-0.0299698059,
0.0043695201,
-0.1401045471,
-1.1186734438,
-0.1405942291,
-0.4725039601,
-0.4249539673,
0.5743719339,
-0.2234502137,
-0.5781999826,
-0.3902876973,
-0.8641788363,
0.2356885672,
0.5812589526,
-0.7006699443,
0.0972736627,
0.1291082501,
0.3055662811,
-0.6680790782,
-0.7036297917,
-0.1373083144,
-0.508725822,
-0.6139389873,
0.1556975096,
-0.2444258034,
-0.0542503744,
-0.1492152959,
-0.2112211138,
-0.0405060649,
0.3599632084,
0.4429002106,
0.0279577672,
-0.2842515409,
0.1943301558,
-0.1282021999,
0.0436693206,
0.1289796531,
-0.1680099368,
0.4505188167,
-0.4762165844,
-0.1959670484,
-0.1287904531,
0.1782656163,
0.5999081731,
0.2526286244,
1.0586290359,
0.7716991305,
-0.3170443177,
-0.2321486473,
-0.5456091166,
0.0151921641,
-0.4835908711,
0.407358259,
-0.4632407427,
-0.7307155132,
0.6594210267,
-0.15581806,
0.0658878759,
0.8068849444,
0.7095718384,
-0.1883485168,
0.9261487126,
0.6909161806,
0.2995522022,
0.2344754934,
-0.6862253547,
-0.1423608214,
-0.9390327334,
-0.1987720281,
-0.4538164735,
-0.7094831467,
-0.8073858619,
-0.6259037852,
0.6873275042,
0.4269363582,
-0.4446909726,
0.3046787977,
-0.5772331953,
0.5299726725,
1.0073468685,
0.2211909294,
0.159155339,
0.0933049545,
-0.1344259232,
-0.0803167,
-1.0448822975,
-0.6289857626,
1.4842689037,
0.5185793638,
0.8257169724,
0.1998169571,
0.9084079862,
0.1622785777,
0.4120621979,
-1.1592495441,
0.5910084844,
-0.0358437747,
-0.6096218228,
-0.9082378745,
-0.543787241,
-1.1669095755,
0.1745028645,
-0.4392794967,
-0.309371382,
0.0876211077,
0.0910609663,
-0.4003661871,
0.6942275167,
-0.6879742742,
0.5158433914,
-0.1996241659,
-0.4149901271,
-0.1672921479,
-0.740973711,
0.1295878887,
-0.4371107519,
-0.0381957628,
-0.2019750029,
-0.6724497676,
1.114749074,
-0.8186451793,
0.8206408024,
-0.2009848654,
0.3162424862,
0.4092836082,
-0.1662286967,
0.1727197468,
0.0418352634,
-0.2275383323,
0.2885082662,
0.0639549419,
-0.7233062387,
-0.4742282629,
0.6006521583,
-1.0489253998,
-0.2486007363,
-0.419539839,
-0.4778236747,
-0.1660695523,
0.1526251584,
0.4837946892,
0.433269918,
-0.1523105353,
0.4134179652,
1.0066660643,
-0.0949494913,
0.6593399644,
0.6141106486,
0.5271783471,
-0.4671631753,
0.6926985383,
0.7223471999,
0.5260387659,
0.4396004677,
0.0141192591,
-0.247646749,
-0.9106732011,
-0.5823615193,
0.3072431982,
-0.7087119222,
-0.4218006432,
-0.4566008449,
-0.3811144233,
-0.0821387619,
-0.4079447687,
-0.2892174721,
-0.4520229697,
-0.525418818,
-0.221938476,
0.7241839767,
0.6962593794,
-0.5414888263,
0.4388296306,
-0.5977746844,
0.0111577669,
0.3899552226,
0.4778926671,
-0.0555628724,
-1.0316492319,
-0.5264669657,
-0.1552118063,
-0.1198574528,
-0.76641047,
0.4447171688,
0.3860235512,
0.8155056834,
0.70839715,
-0.1554023921,
0.6471651793,
-0.5494844317,
0.6190081239,
0.3339808285,
-0.4270791709,
0.3244794905,
-0.2243075371,
0.2834776342,
0.771954298,
0.9409668446,
-0.1770312935,
-0.1883596182,
-0.8794253469,
-0.7562382221,
0.7032946348,
-0.0424183756,
0.3976750374,
0.0403916091,
0.6993439794,
0.1183189824,
0.0285723303,
-0.4046656787,
-0.4975284636,
0.1658098847,
-0.1090575829,
-0.1665965021,
-0.6098446846,
-0.2593048215,
-0.4605438411,
0.2652490735,
-0.1329483092,
0.501336813,
-0.0897725821,
-0.0780063495,
-0.1419651359,
0.0370794982,
0.6731880307,
0.402992636,
-0.4048902988,
0.3968089819,
0.7507982254,
-0.6229301095,
0.5383383632,
-0.3379396498,
0.1230413765,
-0.1677947342,
0.7382071018,
0.657520473,
0.5701212287,
-0.5486594439,
0.4255524576,
0.1119892225,
-0.6281561255,
-0.4615685046,
0.3676604033,
0.266885668,
0.0164460894,
0.3570971191,
0.2258508801,
-0.073935762,
-0.3958700597,
0.1846952289,
0.4196622372,
-0.2172826082,
0.0190261733,
0.6292766929,
0.1646945477,
-0.4690775275,
0.8276109099,
-0.2770124078,
-0.1100163907,
0.6355419755,
0.3655900359,
0.5529044867,
0.0601510331,
0.0020406367,
0.6411383748,
0.4711464643,
-0.2770218253,
-0.0174572393,
-0.1492200494,
-0.5924752951,
-0.2859090269,
-0.9387173653,
-0.5228462815,
-0.0508705191,
-0.7532399297,
0.2175915986,
-0.6417514086,
-0.3325671554,
0.153241083,
0.3688051701,
-0.7436748743,
0.1947784871,
0.0392647162,
1.0868039131,
-0.6440860629,
0.5718402267,
0.6190875173,
-0.4301122725,
-0.9204064012,
-0.7609724402,
0.062071722,
-1.3093715906,
0.7671585083,
0.0886640474,
-0.0196139496,
-0.0294216368,
-0.4947499037,
-1.1446044445,
1.2975312471,
0.7250047922,
-0.3993705511,
-0.0499039069,
0.2326944768,
0.7414351702,
-0.2677616477,
0.4133062363,
0.4146159887,
0.3365230858,
0.2343773842,
-0.8470593095,
-0.1562104374,
-0.1791426986,
0.1663053036,
0.4719164968,
-0.8405948877,
0.8107870221,
-0.5145514607,
-0.1352195591,
0.1152784154,
0.5266730785,
-0.2723897398,
0.147447437,
0.5979830027,
0.798487246,
0.904132545,
-0.0477382429,
1.0285121202,
-0.4670329094,
0.2031358331,
0.814458549,
0.3422164917,
0.7802301049,
0.2613684535,
-0.515465796,
0.195964396,
1.0120623112,
-0.1024927646,
0.160700649,
0.5263400078,
-0.3892168701,
-0.3683450222,
0.2801668048,
-0.07410907,
0.231018573,
0.316046834,
-0.5884253383,
-0.1737441272,
-0.0642657131,
0.1660847366,
0.123982884,
-0.6695451736,
0.6367481351,
0.0137348548,
-0.2849366963,
1.0055024624,
0.0799175054,
0.6800834537,
-0.608792603,
0.1443921626,
-0.3596722484,
0.0290611312,
-0.351123631,
-0.5976033211,
0.3139290512,
0.0348731577,
-0.2734117508,
-0.3749316335,
0.581864655,
-0.2014734745,
-0.4395142496,
0.101183936,
0.4216328561,
0.6374984384,
0.094694443,
-0.4290304482,
-0.0944737345,
-0.2964778543,
-0.4121836722,
0.6550084352,
0.4679505229,
0.2510035634,
0.7472785115,
0.3114261925,
0.3109359145,
0.5418634415,
-0.0428516604,
0.5437766314,
-0.5572006702,
-0.0272649676,
-0.7033224106,
0.067467384,
-0.3152953982,
-0.4176985621,
1.0257724524,
0.5655848384,
0.682053566,
0.0368311703,
0.358954072,
0.1307488084,
0.6418581605,
-0.3526530266,
0.3208698928,
-0.5978530049,
0.3696428537,
0.1172770783,
-0.767018795,
-0.2409953922,
0.5728660226,
-0.1354587525,
0.2661449015,
0.6059101224,
0.8228089809,
0.2491171062,
-0.1122182608,
0.6654444337,
-0.0411809497,
-0.2347849309,
0.4999797344,
0.5265369415,
-0.2153614759,
0.5023949742,
-0.2825454473,
-0.4422731996,
-0.3376445174,
-0.7046974301,
-0.8077174425,
-0.3642507195,
-0.2752575278,
-0.1582622975,
-0.1676253527,
0.8676204681,
0.8618583083,
-0.2430522442,
-0.3030382395,
-0.0060956227,
0.0579709411,
-0.5529827476,
-0.2128697336,
0.3677105308,
-0.7456756234,
-0.8221696019,
0.2086690664,
0.2805184722,
0.1233449578,
-0.5878401995,
-0.0849097073,
-0.0420249254,
0.2411411554,
0.6668996811,
0.3138802648,
-0.2306787521,
-0.4367933273,
0.117239438,
-0.2920201719,
0.0085651195,
0.7312780619,
-0.5315821767,
0.1875038892,
0.3083778024,
0.7716643214,
0.7559808493,
-0.3407783806,
0.2379386574,
-0.7870793343,
-0.1643343419,
0.2137528062,
0.1203120425,
0.2694234848,
-0.2325004041,
0.9977606535,
0.3034969568,
-0.5690496564,
-0.9003114104,
-0.0829129741,
-1.1245726347,
-0.0259892195,
1.1355475187,
-0.1950543076,
-0.1779004037,
0.1958447844,
0.060527321,
0.1320787817,
0.0070406958,
0.4014493525,
0.5034021139,
-0.6180594563,
0.0561780706,
-0.6132851839,
0.6211119294,
0.4269839823,
-0.4028000534,
-0.1856409311,
0.1748989373,
0.5650288463,
0.1741780043,
0.8112853169,
0.036203932,
0.2004316896,
0.5967907906,
-0.1252476126,
0.0073147854,
-0.1979389042,
-0.4767829776,
0.5434933901,
0.6240277886,
-0.1385747641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14744v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14744v2
|
Large Language Models as Urban Residents: An LLM Agent Framework for Personal Mobility Generation
| 2024-02-22T18:03:14 | 2024-05-23T06:30:23 |
Jiawei Wang, Renhe Jiang, Chuang Yang, Zengqing Wu, Makoto Onizuka, Ryosuke Shibasaki, Noboru Koshizuka, Chuan Xiao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a novel approach using Large Language Models (LLMs)
integrated into an agent framework for flexible and effective personal mobility
generation. LLMs overcome the limitations of previous models by effectively
processing semantic data and offering versatility in modeling various tasks.
Our approach addresses three research questions: aligning LLMs with real-world
urban mobility data, developing reliable activity generation strategies, and
exploring LLM applications in urban mobility. The key technical contribution is
a novel LLM agent framework that accounts for individual activity patterns and
motivations, including a self-consistency approach to align LLMs with
real-world activity data and a retrieval-augmented strategy for interpretable
activity generation. We evaluate our LLM agent framework and compare it with
state-of-the-art personal mobility generation approaches, demonstrating the
effectiveness of our approach and its potential applications in urban mobility.
Overall, this study marks the pioneering work of designing an LLM agent
framework for activity generation based on real-world human activity data,
offering a promising tool for urban mobility analysis.
|
[
-0.1786603928,
-0.8385647535,
0.8688245416,
0.0322298221,
0.2051469237,
0.2133952528,
-0.1099508032,
-0.5069447756,
0.450063616,
0.7143593431,
-0.4022755325,
-0.5825939178,
0.0187104344,
-0.0758723691,
-0.6001926064,
0.2177824527,
-0.000262336,
0.0583801195,
-0.0326569304,
-0.1219124347,
-0.3234938979,
-0.5507308841,
-0.6810440421,
-0.4517010748,
0.4706502855,
0.4165952504,
0.8163460493,
0.6400446296,
0.297865063,
0.3608626723,
0.1879831702,
0.1688741595,
-0.406649828,
0.0588618442,
-0.1551660448,
0.0420236923,
-0.6729944944,
-0.3471126556,
0.7188557386,
0.6628441811,
-0.2993765473,
0.0101093482,
-0.3629449308,
0.5382356048,
-0.3091489375,
-0.1218277887,
-0.4904277623,
-0.2873343825,
-0.4208367169,
-0.1117100343,
-0.0719610304,
-0.2481598854,
-0.312782377,
-0.0564027503,
0.1555623561,
0.0872860104,
0.3732513487,
0.049896758,
-0.7328467965,
-0.4081435204,
-0.8677273393,
0.5690811872,
-0.6898092628,
0.3871657252,
0.1894147694,
0.4925246835,
-0.4592754543,
-0.5693127513,
-0.6624422073,
-0.4896834195,
0.1980970204,
-0.0569821857,
0.1745728403,
-0.0362420864,
-0.2877377868,
0.1568793952,
-0.4656011462,
0.2798848748,
-0.2209690362,
0.021660557,
1.0148422718,
0.7803276777,
0.1577482224,
0.0690155849,
-0.3711000979,
0.3236414492,
-0.9692954421,
0.0064341007,
0.533788681,
0.532123208,
-0.1343289763,
0.6411921382,
-0.5357503295,
0.2830353677,
-0.2032487392,
-0.2876464427,
0.2814067006,
-0.5620151162,
0.1233463138,
-0.0328401737,
0.9371955991,
0.1650755703,
0.2182534784,
-0.4545056522,
-0.4386496544,
-0.6285731196,
0.0664461479,
-0.8478469253,
0.1768140048,
0.4357057214,
-0.3354851305,
-0.4186490476,
0.1932068765,
-0.6495701671,
-0.377402842,
-0.2083924115,
-0.1661698818,
0.0466135964,
-0.573543191,
0.5180236101,
0.4670976102,
0.3702141345,
0.3384370208,
-1.1067618132,
0.4168770611,
0.482000798,
0.7072841525,
-0.4616596103,
-0.4381740391,
-0.1991340071,
0.6358345151,
-0.2250209153,
0.743721664,
-0.4792366922,
-0.4121483266,
0.4619097412,
-0.1525652707,
0.1810499132,
-0.5713393092,
0.2434085757,
-0.4039784074,
-0.2637062073,
-0.01654917,
-0.2599077225,
-0.0306880083,
0.2631783485,
-0.6419289708,
1.301041007,
0.4093006551,
-0.212992698,
0.0992660448,
-0.9119230509,
-0.5280551314,
0.4250796139,
-0.0886429623,
-0.1399418414,
0.2202421278,
-0.3275937438,
0.7032576799,
-0.3868410587,
0.3424491286,
-0.3173079789,
0.0316039026,
0.3849019408,
-0.1639937013,
0.6485744119,
0.3496515155,
-0.0363180898,
0.1616644561,
-0.777749598,
-0.3718676567,
0.2886556983,
-0.6361786723,
-0.0662911385,
0.5054112673,
0.0962065905,
0.2118267864,
0.6881541014,
-0.9445644021,
0.3270712197,
-0.2955210507,
0.169849351,
0.6911078691,
-0.1558442414,
0.5799026489,
-0.4334551692,
0.572491765,
-0.0186539944,
-0.2863655686,
-0.1429917067,
-0.3891551495,
-0.2199956626,
-0.1626451463,
-0.0873905197,
0.4204256237,
-0.3915381432,
0.4246117175,
-0.6071577072,
-0.4492904544,
-0.3003466129,
0.2741867006,
-0.2621359825,
0.3429062068,
0.0651712343,
0.1142286584,
-0.4667439461,
-0.4591369629,
-0.0578846,
-0.1310103536,
0.102256611,
0.3510961533,
0.5637062788,
-0.7345615625,
1.1956967115,
-0.3945741057,
0.0000913665,
-0.6922249794,
-0.4294211864,
-0.1608913988,
0.3274670243,
0.7497879267,
-0.7906208038,
-0.5693760514,
0.1577346325,
-0.4824387729,
-0.1939122677,
-0.2098800987,
-0.170877561,
-0.1464095116,
0.3394191861,
-0.8193175197,
0.206471175,
0.4593040049,
-0.6570845246,
0.4446400106,
-0.3636202216,
-0.177843377,
-1.3055964708,
-0.1926497519,
-0.0080038309,
-0.8091035485,
-0.9210223556,
0.2060622722,
-0.4995869994,
-0.0700289384,
-0.5227261782,
1.1157864332,
-0.2605535388,
-0.2487347126,
-0.628311336,
0.0892487243,
-0.4163904786,
-0.0145618534,
-0.0383280814,
0.758898735,
0.3442997336,
-0.5274683237,
0.5194765329,
0.1166843548,
-0.2440659553,
0.1097840592,
-0.3719755709,
0.0564983226,
-0.1762575358,
0.1834295094,
-0.8621574044,
-0.521224916,
0.176460579,
-0.0530172847,
-0.2093514353,
0.3276406229,
-1.0573033094,
-0.194172889,
-0.1318444461,
0.2378628701,
0.4635864794,
-0.4936355054,
1.0829535723,
0.7690705061,
0.0005304058,
0.1306441873,
-0.5461753011,
0.1511304528,
-0.4599658847,
-0.8722475171,
0.1316969395,
-0.2774013579,
-0.5884333849,
-0.2270840853,
0.399743259,
-0.2306048721,
0.4434488714,
0.2309655696,
-0.0784579366,
0.0747787803,
-0.0653665438,
-0.3278402984,
-0.05123071,
0.1069738492,
0.0767211765,
0.7389861345,
0.0898463205,
-0.1745923758,
-0.0840823501,
0.4239785969,
0.634814918,
-0.2120448798,
0.6111446619,
0.5196040273,
-0.1980908811,
-0.0227636956,
-0.3400965333,
0.1771700382,
-0.5270128846,
0.3649231791,
-0.4834822118,
-0.9045576453,
0.741576314,
-0.4868260026,
0.310472995,
0.0943269357,
1.1059873104,
-0.3413056731,
1.0285192728,
0.7064884901,
0.1424422711,
0.5812159181,
0.192411691,
0.1368251741,
-0.6408519149,
-0.2044585496,
-0.4252619743,
-0.1767835319,
-0.6038160324,
-0.5485187769,
-0.0071021742,
-0.3645080626,
-0.2932953835,
0.1497339159,
-0.1546599567,
0.2594071329,
0.134878844,
-0.1814746559,
0.3117781281,
0.0166871212,
0.1382962614,
0.367980808,
-0.5028907061,
-0.942735672,
1.0310813189,
0.4898428023,
0.8810845017,
0.5225151777,
0.6610807776,
0.4439471066,
0.3924842179,
-0.585049212,
0.9160462618,
-0.0265487768,
-0.8015190959,
-0.422179848,
-0.4270369112,
-1.3188024759,
0.3011644781,
-0.1395654827,
-0.9787387848,
-0.0901839286,
-0.0977226496,
-0.2756336927,
0.3771586418,
-0.3937264085,
0.7202705145,
-0.5317190289,
-0.3722988069,
-0.1986044496,
-0.2910101116,
0.3102244735,
-0.4264926016,
0.535964191,
-0.7145749331,
-0.275406003,
0.2116723508,
-0.360440284,
0.8065384626,
-0.1904284507,
-0.3597093225,
0.4112867713,
0.0229728259,
0.8153418303,
-0.0915875286,
-0.3731999099,
0.1348073632,
-0.2418830842,
-0.3688209653,
-0.2623766959,
0.7349640727,
-0.6760363579,
-0.2999862731,
0.0106407907,
-0.7440647483,
0.0589053929,
0.2713082135,
-0.1296664327,
0.2646009624,
-0.3814345896,
0.0931261182,
0.415904671,
0.2053202093,
0.6363766789,
0.9028574824,
-0.5045520663,
-0.1535260379,
1.1129055023,
0.1693661213,
0.0005412645,
0.5092176795,
0.2778481841,
-0.427501142,
-0.8626095057,
-0.2770583332,
0.2432602197,
-0.3800031245,
0.2452448756,
-0.4742344916,
0.204101935,
-0.4169283211,
-0.4203576744,
-0.6709913611,
-0.0716280416,
-0.1375385374,
-0.0569572151,
-0.065744333,
1.0370056629,
0.1032564789,
0.5512278676,
-0.6274682283,
0.3618366718,
0.2328514308,
-0.0115077179,
-0.2494065762,
-0.0797165781,
-0.6553718448,
0.1125250012,
-0.2967414856,
-1.0444325209,
0.3957280219,
-0.2506048381,
0.6730350852,
0.4134185016,
0.0954521373,
0.3977923393,
-0.5435455441,
0.9229623079,
0.0461835265,
-0.5449646711,
0.1468797773,
-0.6778889894,
0.2998956144,
0.6061529517,
-0.0208184458,
-0.1316627711,
-0.3943293989,
-0.4703112543,
-0.9241915941,
0.1435407549,
0.2989850342,
0.4490718842,
-0.1182345673,
0.5307842493,
0.0269517452,
0.2977270484,
-1.0546858311,
-0.2891638577,
-0.0009239343,
-0.4555414319,
-0.0387036987,
-0.3473783135,
-0.0305864476,
-0.1546569616,
0.4558019936,
-0.3785120547,
0.1012357995,
0.0716832429,
0.0293136984,
-0.1567463875,
0.1723011881,
0.9521842003,
0.7300833464,
-0.209707588,
0.0335074253,
0.2816855311,
-0.4783539772,
0.606993854,
-0.2191854268,
-0.4873903692,
0.0616505481,
0.0381914787,
0.3139461577,
-0.0028419048,
-0.9541330338,
0.5051746368,
-0.0015876645,
-0.1804080009,
-0.9495601058,
0.1248303279,
0.2167455107,
0.3522928655,
0.4399293363,
-0.3002701402,
-0.0264241993,
-0.5214198828,
-0.1146875769,
0.5397314429,
-0.358499825,
-0.5589123964,
0.8414627314,
0.5794776082,
-0.4631532133,
0.2648779452,
-0.5135684609,
-0.0066416166,
0.5308104157,
0.4760448933,
1.1208604574,
-0.3194417357,
-0.1131539494,
0.140552029,
0.2689923346,
-0.2014893591,
0.4688139558,
0.1509195864,
-1.0339547396,
-0.5136991143,
-0.4437381923,
-0.1811071485,
-0.0161597915,
-0.2275927514,
0.2619712651,
-0.2282765955,
-0.1375063509,
-0.4357306063,
0.171511054,
-0.4155990183,
0.0255526341,
0.281149298,
1.136685133,
-0.5935486555,
1.1453334093,
1.1248573065,
-0.0019488792,
-0.6390744448,
0.2811493576,
-0.1634084135,
-0.4316166937,
0.5213012099,
0.0393653437,
-0.4466137886,
0.1316609234,
-0.5374463797,
-0.866922915,
1.4939180613,
0.4616918564,
-0.5042629242,
-0.1815730035,
0.4742291868,
0.4189298749,
-1.0185066462,
-0.0057821414,
0.5275992155,
0.473772049,
0.161429137,
-0.5664575696,
0.2342565358,
0.3221676648,
0.175886184,
0.1460548788,
-1.0609537363,
0.5564938784,
-0.2538492382,
-0.0697520003,
0.4142153561,
0.721981585,
0.4580817223,
0.3066345751,
0.4297662079,
0.2561421692,
0.7152407765,
0.1471566409,
1.0813695192,
-0.788721621,
0.3155224621,
0.9500302076,
-0.7054741979,
0.7134238482,
0.2706791461,
0.0640057772,
0.5079485774,
0.3817284107,
0.1381799579,
0.4688298404,
0.2128862292,
-0.5807920694,
-0.4513306916,
-0.0160113834,
0.1536185741,
0.7247597575,
0.096209228,
0.0559812412,
-0.4174648225,
0.0699374378,
0.0410636365,
0.0548224114,
-0.369980067,
0.6859360933,
-0.1639690697,
-0.2855516374,
-0.1159402132,
0.3265968859,
0.2144170851,
-0.695368588,
0.085613966,
-0.1558746845,
0.0288027395,
-0.1768276691,
-0.7836951613,
0.340939343,
-0.1964600235,
-0.1736686975,
-0.6127909422,
0.690223515,
-0.2607807219,
-0.326392591,
0.2202661037,
0.5176991224,
0.4425527453,
0.1113344282,
-0.6602167487,
0.0326029584,
0.112913914,
-0.4675529003,
0.4641942978,
0.5881667137,
0.0562442802,
1.1116446257,
0.7187093496,
0.3024239242,
0.2119161934,
-0.1357194632,
0.7133616209,
-1.0030734539,
-0.4531187713,
-0.8817517161,
0.8005789518,
0.0885590836,
-0.2592307031,
0.7708812356,
0.8492588401,
0.3553168774,
0.1485431939,
0.7838689089,
-0.124211438,
0.6311491132,
-0.4192622602,
0.2428746223,
-0.3734529316,
0.7157713771,
0.3097424507,
-0.7700666785,
0.1036677212,
0.600238502,
-0.1591142565,
0.0853224918,
0.2266714573,
0.7515293956,
0.0504316986,
-0.5839624405,
0.5916425586,
0.0856837705,
0.7138272524,
0.3668828607,
1.0011488199,
-0.1653121561,
0.3244133294,
0.1248436496,
0.2164152861,
-0.3895032704,
-0.5955197215,
-0.9811004996,
-0.3976388574,
-0.2122506052,
-0.2619261146,
-0.3282320797,
1.0628923178,
0.9755783677,
-0.4190615118,
-0.6609277725,
-0.3433810771,
0.2026241124,
0.1517661959,
-0.2601312101,
-0.0723140761,
-0.0690520257,
-0.876712203,
0.7741856575,
0.2743935287,
0.5172802806,
-0.815916419,
-0.5968443155,
0.0984581783,
0.2944718003,
0.6128834486,
0.375110358,
-0.5752590895,
-0.1868313104,
-0.2657671869,
-0.4992518127,
0.1455399692,
0.9459220767,
-0.642285049,
0.1704253405,
0.4096834362,
0.4096090496,
0.5228203535,
0.3115286231,
0.6316459775,
-0.6184005141,
0.2334345728,
0.14203237,
0.3686546683,
0.2425513566,
-0.403670311,
0.572286427,
-0.0240135286,
-0.7262709737,
-0.714642942,
0.6125890017,
-1.047763586,
-0.2641500831,
1.5193789005,
0.2051620781,
-0.222384721,
-0.4942961037,
-0.1402737796,
-0.3389733732,
-0.6127977371,
0.6114953756,
0.3606672883,
-0.3074727952,
-0.1688165665,
-1.047526598,
0.0873114541,
-0.1750952899,
-0.9668937922,
0.2873601615,
0.3826255798,
0.2789461315,
0.0123383766,
1.1020519733,
0.1325265318,
-0.0454952121,
-0.2660112977,
0.1958716214,
-0.166475445,
-0.1775734276,
-0.1636922359,
0.3999192417,
0.274002254,
0.1454527676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14743v1
|
Dependency Annotation of Ottoman Turkish with Multilingual BERT
| 2024-02-22T17:58:50 | 2024-02-22T17:58:50 |
Şaziye Betül Özateş, Tarık Emre Tıraş, Efe Eren Genç, Esma Fatıma Bilgin Taşdemir
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study introduces a pretrained large language model-based annotation
methodology for the first dependency treebank in Ottoman Turkish. Our
experimental results show that, iteratively, i) pseudo-annotating data using a
multilingual BERT-based parsing model, ii) manually correcting the
pseudo-annotations, and iii) fine-tuning the parsing model with the corrected
annotations, we speed up and simplify the challenging dependency annotation
process. The resulting treebank, that will be a part of the Universal
Dependencies (UD) project, will facilitate automated analysis of Ottoman
Turkish documents, unlocking the linguistic richness embedded in this
historical heritage.
|
[
-0.7667374611,
-0.546091795,
0.3192939162,
0.2698134482,
-0.30653736,
-0.2679296136,
-0.1062651575,
-0.9163399935,
0.4178933799,
0.5701301098,
-0.4576249719,
-0.3980716169,
-0.542083621,
0.1095694751,
0.1785606891,
1.1552767754,
-0.1982454658,
0.3889593184,
0.1710184664,
-0.3700568974,
-0.3603647053,
-0.8901645541,
-0.1076608971,
0.0107408166,
0.6721234322,
0.3865406215,
0.3730504215,
0.5482523441,
0.5148841143,
0.2423482537,
-0.1572134495,
-0.2688375115,
0.0875479579,
0.1198231131,
-0.0471155681,
-0.2976388335,
-0.243709594,
-0.0220056381,
0.8040850759,
0.6619737148,
0.0027232931,
0.6130396128,
-0.0118732573,
0.6085104942,
-0.6341477633,
0.4082215428,
-0.4941396415,
-0.2018855363,
-0.6349619627,
-0.0495216623,
-0.2777351439,
-0.0202872045,
0.3694697618,
-0.3522538245,
0.1845743805,
0.044359535,
0.8683370352,
0.1713696569,
-0.5132077336,
-0.1210474595,
-0.6646750569,
0.8115620613,
-0.6250764132,
0.4972363412,
0.701844871,
0.2185090631,
-0.1899953485,
-0.7726991773,
-0.2450932115,
-0.512945056,
-0.4362728596,
-0.2828224897,
0.4040479362,
0.2967541218,
0.1530246884,
0.2577968836,
-0.2979282737,
-0.0781271234,
-0.3884941041,
-0.2435142994,
0.2760855258,
-0.0965120345,
0.2685132325,
-0.1725849658,
-0.0667450354,
-0.0048248153,
-0.8588750958,
0.2667121589,
0.411193192,
0.7937372923,
0.1924752891,
0.6245677471,
-0.080600284,
0.6396028399,
-0.0901239738,
-0.0645342469,
0.1709230989,
-0.1332729161,
-0.2454077899,
0.4982881546,
0.3185870945,
-0.2087358236,
0.2426704168,
0.1282710731,
-0.0541513823,
-0.1753706932,
0.3061184883,
-0.7722759843,
-0.3445219398,
0.2865580022,
-0.5848683715,
0.0487063639,
0.0476953015,
-0.4491534829,
-0.3609496951,
-0.3736621141,
0.317841351,
-0.3363072574,
-0.2150714546,
-0.2352194488,
0.3120645881,
0.1358274072,
0.461161226,
-1.2824331522,
0.0245354753,
0.5446845293,
0.7321538329,
0.638287425,
-0.4021356404,
-0.4564802051,
0.4261418581,
-0.3175522685,
1.1616184711,
-0.413120091,
0.0079958327,
0.3042894006,
0.2558979094,
0.2764987051,
-0.2753544152,
0.8557522893,
-0.1813489795,
0.2730393112,
-0.6073960662,
-0.6673649549,
-0.6123470664,
0.232459262,
-1.1438148022,
1.091373086,
0.3151580989,
-1.0434414148,
0.7281591892,
-0.5251049399,
-0.5919206738,
0.3523836136,
-0.1463578343,
-0.4347830415,
0.0805673376,
0.2407223582,
0.4559062421,
0.0028488068,
0.3774660826,
-0.2687429786,
-0.269346714,
-0.6362304688,
0.0980996042,
1.2761285305,
-0.0377341025,
-0.5477406979,
0.1571368277,
-1.1297705173,
-0.4681790173,
-0.1619972438,
-0.7115336061,
-0.4684771597,
0.3012326658,
0.584000349,
0.1209670007,
0.394449234,
-0.6844829917,
0.5916967392,
-0.3464221358,
-0.1769380122,
0.883687675,
-0.2072639763,
-0.0288747512,
-0.2989660501,
0.2509590685,
-0.0099810027,
0.0329568386,
-0.3339035511,
-0.5404831767,
-0.8340896964,
-0.7334775925,
0.4122133255,
0.5266767144,
-0.1156306341,
0.4308363497,
0.1841792613,
-0.3703932166,
-0.5910295248,
0.1804753542,
0.0023663559,
0.3268183768,
0.3480033875,
-0.2521447837,
-1.2650526762,
-0.9069079757,
0.1901489049,
-0.7130923867,
0.3177526295,
0.0091570644,
0.5018429756,
-0.1642488241,
0.7548021078,
0.3400482833,
-0.9052145481,
-0.3096853793,
0.5748245716,
0.2699755132,
0.5576689839,
0.8265410662,
-0.4194517136,
-0.6609840989,
0.1057256609,
-0.2898321748,
-0.1802446544,
0.0137010347,
0.1177346259,
0.5805671811,
0.3290477097,
-0.5070967078,
0.4637764096,
0.4624993503,
-0.4705412388,
0.9913769364,
-0.3531346917,
0.2768573761,
-0.9120544195,
0.3840928078,
-0.2559655309,
-0.1679360121,
-0.5896140933,
-0.2111129314,
-0.0570258163,
0.3667147756,
-0.4829817116,
0.4320940673,
-0.472378701,
0.1037372351,
0.065131925,
-0.7939367294,
-0.1249185503,
0.3984195292,
0.3551096618,
0.5483170748,
0.4784429371,
-0.2280541658,
0.3625522554,
0.4198692441,
-0.6464309096,
0.3499799371,
-0.35022223,
-0.1943005472,
-0.168843478,
0.2556920052,
-1.1028482914,
-0.0009652226,
0.2982792258,
-0.1847972423,
0.2805044949,
-0.6826024652,
-0.7574467063,
-0.0519186705,
-0.3298045397,
0.3281900883,
0.0546167307,
-0.5773350596,
0.7239814997,
0.1867228746,
-0.4288221896,
-0.7594031692,
-0.7529488802,
0.2040052563,
-0.1841698736,
-0.581232965,
-0.047384534,
0.0951743498,
-0.3936294615,
-0.0734213963,
0.2835778594,
-0.3408815563,
0.2060930878,
0.2308887541,
0.3434043527,
-0.4026427865,
0.2696056366,
-0.1486919075,
-0.0546650812,
-0.1823814362,
-0.3934425712,
0.3531877697,
-0.3770530522,
-0.2089708894,
-0.4496598244,
0.5633321404,
0.405218333,
-0.4432643652,
1.1138311625,
0.5693966746,
-0.3866728246,
0.3204354942,
-0.9494752884,
0.0631404892,
-0.3976627886,
0.3881094158,
-0.5138404965,
-0.9854289293,
0.7020682096,
0.0107729444,
0.4120130539,
0.5469455123,
0.7416722178,
-0.4619864225,
0.8515463471,
0.956817627,
-0.3268315792,
0.6338024735,
0.0939614624,
-0.1225607619,
-0.2528774142,
-0.0624981895,
-0.8612253666,
-0.0471060835,
-0.776024282,
0.2258393615,
-0.0572938919,
0.2734530568,
-0.23164545,
0.1752364784,
-0.178096801,
0.1840003431,
0.9073185921,
-0.3648083508,
0.0053837062,
0.0680139884,
-0.2643470466,
-0.0221220162,
-0.2915545106,
-0.6318988204,
1.1735475063,
0.165290013,
0.285307169,
0.1941118538,
0.7890222073,
0.404394418,
0.3903258145,
-0.5360757113,
0.1017800719,
-0.0473978482,
-1.0013577938,
-0.361748755,
0.0581065752,
-1.0954955816,
0.0618229657,
-0.2984491587,
-1.211476326,
0.1601530313,
0.3032002151,
-0.3195370436,
0.318949312,
-0.6975827813,
1.0208969116,
-0.1900648326,
-0.0793688372,
-0.228530094,
-0.8342312574,
0.0565472767,
-0.0102941571,
0.2018291056,
-0.0716983303,
0.4085674286,
0.8904254436,
-0.5336758494,
0.7254270315,
-0.4083290696,
-0.1058975086,
0.3186130524,
0.1217448786,
0.4940973222,
-0.1744959652,
0.0593538359,
0.27839306,
0.5090774894,
-0.772773385,
-0.1558292955,
0.2110455483,
-0.783757925,
-0.5981952548,
-0.6155312061,
-0.4834697247,
-0.2154495418,
0.3439763784,
-0.2352288216,
0.3019129038,
-0.4683550894,
-0.1280992329,
0.2989911139,
-0.0855222493,
0.6101673841,
0.5455944538,
-0.3909025192,
-0.3696528971,
0.5990227461,
0.2863858044,
-0.4511291385,
0.3503818512,
0.0104982806,
-0.2094781697,
-0.5073999166,
-0.7471411824,
0.2509974539,
-0.7396813631,
0.2536157072,
-0.4323546886,
-0.0028004616,
-0.6435765624,
-0.1193700731,
-0.5043647885,
-0.4933476746,
-0.2680192292,
-0.3187733889,
0.3541354239,
0.9843663573,
-0.4711434245,
0.4213915467,
-1.0790058374,
0.1135569438,
0.2994443476,
0.4432990253,
-0.2172144055,
-0.2036433667,
-0.8473929167,
-0.2712228298,
0.0110163493,
-0.8975088596,
0.0426106453,
0.2905335426,
0.6949791312,
0.6419237852,
-0.2930183411,
0.4147211909,
-0.5903161764,
0.8755036592,
0.0383697003,
-0.8562198877,
0.5482859015,
-0.3793675005,
0.2210437953,
0.7437354922,
0.2684611082,
-0.5142813921,
-0.3082413077,
-0.4687594473,
-0.9643595815,
0.9994091392,
-0.1727024019,
-0.1203284711,
0.0978777036,
0.0966906771,
0.4012443423,
-0.0624973848,
-0.7324281335,
-0.4191429317,
-0.161811322,
-0.165212974,
-0.123024255,
-1.0025323629,
0.0900685191,
-0.5657087564,
1.0116034746,
0.2715364099,
0.022218043,
-0.0308029018,
-0.5053828955,
-0.3238462508,
0.1396767944,
0.6057786345,
0.8422669172,
-0.7896386385,
0.3252210617,
-0.1199071556,
-0.5962172151,
0.4228189886,
0.5688369274,
-0.0541487969,
0.2842932642,
0.6555404067,
0.7347083092,
-0.2909595966,
-0.5353179574,
0.2943640947,
-0.019172309,
-0.0420837365,
-0.5736823082,
-0.637963891,
0.1488014162,
0.3029696643,
0.5503706932,
-0.3713446856,
0.1330581903,
-0.384872824,
0.4881236553,
0.2251342833,
-0.3578825295,
-0.1773612648,
0.2904705405,
-0.0017933269,
0.0451453626,
0.5556586385,
0.1209767982,
-0.6869542599,
0.3593811989,
0.2415119857,
0.7885196805,
-0.6968810558,
0.2832723558,
0.552636981,
0.7026541233,
0.0684624091,
0.4553429484,
-0.211277917,
-0.4389544129,
-0.8004475236,
-0.7623224258,
-0.2145447731,
0.1546040624,
-0.6130914688,
0.4177332222,
-0.4205993116,
0.0916338116,
0.0987770185,
0.2683483064,
-0.5126443505,
0.3568399251,
0.4861559868,
0.6477974057,
-0.9955373406,
1.3409553766,
1.2534022331,
-0.6315128207,
-0.6622388363,
-0.26295802,
-0.1507468224,
-0.6498270035,
0.9857817888,
0.4431124926,
0.1651493758,
-0.1497353762,
-0.3002483845,
-0.7805213332,
0.5021170378,
0.4441328347,
-0.624777019,
0.3550370634,
0.5174373388,
0.5281711817,
-0.0559065528,
0.5713766813,
0.6132624149,
0.8181762695,
-0.2834365964,
-0.9914970994,
-0.1462570429,
-0.3885605335,
-0.0447504036,
0.3644533455,
-0.216307357,
0.7561215758,
0.1326009929,
0.0502801724,
0.0623757951,
0.7719063163,
-0.0614552535,
-0.1623124927,
0.514088273,
0.9031943083,
0.5569665432,
0.2459274828,
0.6460412145,
-0.4326525331,
0.3597660065,
1.3363250494,
0.1039456278,
0.6740238667,
0.7904223204,
-0.2845550478,
0.6344732642,
1.0078748465,
0.0529924929,
0.5708118081,
0.2250947058,
-0.4544704258,
-0.0705971345,
-0.3547663987,
-0.5024695396,
0.425455004,
0.1185965538,
-0.4467122853,
-0.3982213736,
-0.0062703853,
0.1837384105,
-0.5371583104,
-0.2866017818,
0.8022733927,
-0.2686674893,
-0.3401111364,
0.5768252015,
-0.1094780192,
0.230733484,
-0.6573836207,
-0.3168492615,
-0.1754226685,
0.1045538858,
-0.0803374276,
-0.2603988945,
0.3802201748,
-0.0628604814,
-0.3103980422,
-0.1039305925,
0.4390078783,
-0.4495020807,
-0.8159788251,
0.4568666518,
0.3616193235,
0.1340419203,
-0.2263146639,
-0.44966501,
-0.0680200756,
0.0185959302,
-0.5867748857,
0.283500284,
0.3782821894,
-0.2547017038,
0.1582730263,
0.5234642029,
0.2221717536,
0.2249595374,
0.140337199,
0.5724317431,
-0.5609155893,
-0.4802973568,
-1.0151258707,
0.6600914001,
0.4924626946,
-0.1621279866,
0.4870589674,
0.4721983969,
0.9252047539,
0.0378153585,
1.0088136196,
-0.3821051717,
0.4825094938,
-0.089573659,
0.7324680686,
-0.6463871598,
-0.0460609682,
-0.3752687275,
-1.2345997095,
-0.6394416094,
0.7435973883,
-0.0916417241,
-0.2850557864,
0.678787291,
0.4885390699,
0.1269550472,
-0.0187532157,
0.2884970009,
0.4031173289,
0.3259003162,
0.229760617,
0.9827905297,
0.1366645545,
0.3567968905,
-0.6145499945,
-0.3276782334,
-0.2723678648,
-1.0140841007,
-0.9734768867,
-0.9071186781,
0.049858328,
-0.3586749434,
0.1539794952,
1.2569069862,
0.5666213632,
-1.5262937546,
-0.4762818813,
-0.018135827,
-0.1306990534,
-0.0985700265,
-0.1180358753,
0.7800213099,
-0.5230702162,
-0.4107935131,
0.0192060247,
0.2325376421,
0.2178725153,
-0.2644669116,
0.0846268907,
-0.8798727989,
-0.1733568162,
0.2736498713,
0.3803936541,
-0.8041059971,
-0.5485762358,
-0.7080028653,
-0.0515154824,
0.4656294286,
0.8043928742,
-0.5791556239,
0.7525759935,
0.4417313039,
0.6237065196,
0.6534579396,
-0.261095494,
0.3907674849,
-0.5639149547,
0.672078073,
0.0399789661,
0.8070562482,
0.36025244,
-0.2516044378,
0.3040846288,
0.2475363761,
-0.4758502543,
-0.5438092351,
0.0554767624,
-0.7588412166,
-0.2841768563,
0.7880539894,
-0.6962467432,
-0.1008438393,
-0.6981448531,
-0.820879221,
0.5364065766,
-0.1887689829,
1.1395927668,
1.0286871195,
0.0579794347,
-0.423966825,
-0.261728704,
0.5650168061,
0.7094709277,
-0.6946474314,
-0.0158088747,
0.7379124165,
-0.0906182528,
0.1826123446,
0.726277709,
0.3309061825,
0.1177688017,
-0.0699360445,
0.8038363457,
-0.1260191798,
-0.427796185,
-0.1044107974,
0.0062806606,
0.4558905959,
-0.2115710378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14897v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14897v3
|
Chain-of-Thought Unfaithfulness as Disguised Accuracy
| 2024-02-22T17:23:53 | 2024-06-21T13:39:14 |
Oliver Bentham, Nathan Stringham, Ana Marasović
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Understanding the extent to which Chain-of-Thought (CoT) generations align
with a large language model's (LLM) internal computations is critical for
deciding whether to trust an LLM's output. As a proxy for CoT faithfulness,
Lanham et al. (2023) propose a metric that measures a model's dependence on its
CoT for producing an answer. Within a single family of proprietary models, they
find that LLMs exhibit a scaling-then-inverse-scaling relationship between
model size and their measure of faithfulness, and that a 13 billion parameter
model exhibits increased faithfulness compared to models ranging from 810
million to 175 billion parameters in size. We evaluate whether these results
generalize as a property of all LLMs. We replicate the experimental setup in
their section focused on scaling experiments with three different families of
models and, under specific conditions, successfully reproduce the scaling
trends for CoT faithfulness they report. However, after normalizing the metric
to account for a model's bias toward certain answer choices, unfaithfulness
drops significantly for smaller less-capable models. This normalized
faithfulness metric is also strongly correlated ($R^2$=0.74) with accuracy,
raising doubts about its validity for evaluating faithfulness.
|
[
-0.3938457966,
-0.6961179376,
0.9424934983,
0.1451422274,
-0.3551995456,
0.2790903151,
-0.0423952863,
-0.5180069208,
0.105732359,
0.6110352278,
-0.3952370584,
0.0450041667,
-0.6699154377,
-0.0706943199,
-0.6289800406,
1.0775693655,
-0.233027339,
0.1133117974,
-0.2594865263,
-0.269328475,
-0.0187433604,
-0.6523839831,
-0.3523600101,
-0.3395915329,
0.5803884268,
0.1508167982,
1.161831975,
0.8331962228,
0.5109288692,
0.1787456721,
-0.1474652439,
0.294899106,
-0.7550774217,
0.0947846323,
-0.4826148152,
-0.588108182,
-0.6390920877,
0.3557267785,
0.6651037335,
0.7542324662,
0.0168916211,
0.4990207255,
0.3037978709,
0.9141027927,
-0.7944765091,
-0.4065131545,
-0.8329954147,
-0.309409529,
-0.0223484393,
0.0052290517,
-0.6384446025,
-0.3117883205,
0.0450616106,
-0.2584282458,
0.4364615977,
0.2330525964,
0.7808302045,
0.1624337882,
-0.5191394091,
-0.3803764582,
-0.9023795128,
0.7996872663,
-0.7762768865,
0.3900756538,
0.4646070004,
-0.1102262884,
-0.4255138338,
-0.6559439301,
-0.5331507921,
-0.3015390933,
0.0460902303,
-0.0374416187,
-0.2735684514,
0.0728135556,
0.2482566833,
0.7015703321,
-0.1720805168,
-0.1686648279,
-0.0378192142,
-0.0772333816,
0.578117907,
0.2532661259,
0.1316646934,
0.3778875768,
-0.5075033307,
-0.0225210227,
-0.8163449764,
-0.2047188431,
0.438552618,
0.1150444075,
0.0017060192,
0.5641322136,
0.2210172266,
0.4873856008,
0.2677055597,
0.0331908092,
-0.2308913916,
-0.4643959403,
-0.370462209,
-0.0341418087,
0.8158216476,
0.1350639313,
0.2899076045,
-0.2522359192,
-0.2580683827,
0.2665360272,
0.5933720469,
-0.5836951137,
-0.0696970597,
-0.0100728879,
-0.2990594506,
-0.4501757622,
0.2921940684,
-0.5774500966,
-0.3154267371,
0.0170849897,
0.4444541633,
-0.0306629855,
-0.2090458572,
-0.0757999942,
-0.0247347336,
-0.0061308718,
0.3061612248,
-0.5381013751,
0.552903235,
0.736771524,
0.8639732599,
-0.0820871443,
-0.5040953755,
-0.5343476534,
0.0391579419,
-0.8889703751,
0.3686297536,
-0.5384604931,
-0.2912687957,
-0.3013744354,
-0.0581985414,
0.0308337286,
-0.2451115996,
0.4173083305,
-0.627047956,
-0.2898827195,
-0.5755256414,
-0.6783534288,
-0.014828926,
0.1728996038,
-0.5921863914,
0.9472571611,
0.0528643765,
-0.845282197,
0.3766798377,
-0.1252752841,
0.1831814945,
-0.4223568738,
-0.2085160762,
-0.406362921,
0.5567768216,
-0.1491916776,
0.0883738771,
-0.5326260924,
0.1632243693,
-0.8581699729,
-0.532118082,
0.805911243,
-0.9823149443,
0.6927131414,
0.1042478308,
-0.3863384426,
-0.4659565091,
-0.6109392643,
0.1588543057,
0.0538681075,
-0.1193063259,
-0.4228973985,
-0.1158526763,
-0.313482821,
0.2015643418,
0.300439775,
-0.8454615474,
0.0644839853,
-0.3193661869,
0.1979115754,
0.8057845235,
0.113105692,
0.3902338147,
-0.5153868794,
0.3931031823,
0.1595104337,
0.3382219672,
0.3685356975,
-0.5965858102,
-0.6968635917,
-0.0385326669,
0.2443864942,
-0.2241615504,
-0.1526265144,
0.2182261199,
-0.2660574317,
-0.6722922921,
-0.4912085533,
0.3464764059,
0.7862249017,
0.241546765,
0.1422595233,
-0.6320234537,
-0.3566500843,
-0.8905309439,
-0.7750586271,
-0.3532726169,
0.1264445484,
0.0597569495,
0.5301617384,
-0.2776756287,
0.9994712472,
-0.3896257281,
-0.0053453697,
0.1270234287,
0.3329962194,
0.18234317,
0.4235988557,
0.3392268717,
-0.5554683208,
-0.3480125666,
0.0432813875,
-0.5725014806,
0.2805082202,
0.1521800905,
-0.2356966883,
0.2714984417,
0.3130445182,
-0.3402909935,
0.6752941012,
0.8877696991,
-0.4929764271,
0.6777492762,
-0.4724616706,
0.127928257,
-0.9590299129,
-0.0503765605,
-0.2378961295,
-0.2097469866,
-0.5227468014,
0.2795423865,
0.3257039189,
0.4986720979,
-0.3360018432,
0.2005882263,
-0.5335731506,
-0.3365171552,
-0.2997115552,
0.2367085069,
0.1171993986,
0.3108821809,
-0.4814725518,
1.0468388796,
0.2060489357,
-0.6166958809,
0.0106792701,
0.0381956026,
0.0426932015,
0.2860785723,
-0.3643701375,
0.5779060721,
0.1606616229,
0.2668285668,
-1.020706296,
-0.0367987491,
-0.395721674,
-0.5003425479,
-0.0895013437,
-0.2424628884,
-0.5953924656,
-0.2488537282,
-0.4765522778,
0.6433958411,
0.5546645522,
-0.7087038159,
0.6552565694,
0.1656453013,
0.4724029899,
-0.7494176626,
-0.883169651,
-0.1972239763,
0.0265261419,
-0.4061856568,
0.1192819104,
-0.02457132,
-0.5664518476,
0.0300758742,
-0.5060422421,
-0.2214421332,
-0.1781232506,
0.371601522,
0.5257911086,
-0.3135324121,
0.1054096073,
-0.0575396158,
0.3157702982,
0.5253270864,
-0.2405395508,
0.5587345362,
-0.6799064279,
-0.3663819134,
-0.0521904826,
-0.0860969797,
0.9668447971,
0.0456917733,
0.969457984,
0.0532113872,
-0.2098670602,
-0.077439189,
-0.6549881697,
0.0888660848,
-0.5310847163,
-0.0087387171,
-0.3474124074,
-0.5168851614,
0.8451231718,
0.0278549269,
-0.0346235,
0.5750123858,
0.3079965413,
-0.0818684027,
1.1742597818,
0.6627222896,
0.0274317432,
-0.0134117883,
-0.1081750914,
0.4073236883,
-1.2701917887,
0.0237559061,
-0.4410226643,
-0.1895119995,
-1.0681419373,
-0.4420488775,
0.1758941412,
0.2913629711,
-0.6752750874,
0.3470788598,
-0.2341102809,
0.6792522669,
0.2879632711,
0.314717859,
0.578771174,
-0.2769020796,
-0.2238415182,
0.108800292,
-0.4887581766,
-0.7852746248,
1.4132939577,
0.454244554,
1.0375087261,
0.2009327859,
0.5823706388,
0.186855495,
0.3814240098,
-0.4947041869,
0.350880444,
-0.3937719762,
-0.7852167487,
-0.3100007772,
-0.5296540856,
-0.7026863098,
0.0225287862,
0.0608617775,
-0.7939248681,
0.387812078,
0.344391048,
-0.1340716779,
0.798619926,
-0.4288140237,
0.2892405689,
-0.1371471882,
-0.6366731524,
-0.2574050426,
-0.5181834102,
0.5145790577,
-0.3126451373,
0.0641599,
0.1434255242,
-0.234015286,
0.8522556424,
-0.5024303794,
0.7477885485,
0.3393243253,
-0.3925624788,
0.2901855409,
0.7680778503,
0.6857115626,
0.2304791957,
0.0233876966,
0.1770737767,
0.1066065207,
-0.6117452979,
-0.8456520438,
0.959153235,
-0.8554100394,
-0.7626878023,
-0.5013530254,
-0.5553016067,
-0.5671515465,
0.1423929632,
0.2660096288,
0.4125544429,
-0.3358195722,
0.2014405876,
0.9973171949,
0.1876145899,
0.3901159167,
0.3518566489,
-0.5064304471,
-0.2651216686,
0.5320367813,
0.1011493132,
1.1157842875,
0.1010989025,
0.211711064,
-0.150726229,
-0.1427730173,
-0.4569625258,
0.3220573068,
-0.7561093569,
-0.1573131382,
-0.4917210937,
-0.4793066382,
0.0513568446,
-0.2197174281,
-1.0106208324,
-0.2832613587,
-0.0310183838,
-0.0590410307,
0.2765457034,
1.2620869875,
0.3272674084,
-0.0894021019,
-0.5851260424,
0.037226703,
0.4487838447,
0.5399304032,
0.2631157339,
-0.8076252937,
-0.0078903073,
0.5758320689,
-0.4836589694,
-0.6847227216,
-0.0650261194,
-0.1390404105,
0.197244361,
0.711992979,
0.1901475489,
0.8609604239,
-0.1253960282,
0.8506425023,
0.3102618754,
-1.2407324314,
0.3239244223,
-0.1737670004,
0.220416531,
0.6351147294,
0.3147631586,
-0.1827188879,
-0.9418100119,
-1.0036325455,
-0.4236977398,
0.4290702641,
0.3135569394,
0.2784471512,
0.0234417636,
0.5356550813,
0.2893115878,
0.1076722294,
-0.77638942,
-0.34687379,
0.0284931045,
0.0340593532,
-0.1433479786,
-0.3061996996,
-0.1677756459,
-0.2474343479,
0.510995388,
-0.1249904782,
0.2969571352,
0.5368361473,
0.034280844,
-0.6617404222,
0.1878939271,
0.6610712409,
1.0726537704,
-0.2299559414,
0.6437283754,
0.437259078,
-0.8157823086,
0.3434976637,
-0.8614743352,
0.1848065406,
-0.0682030916,
0.4656417668,
0.4110850394,
0.1150240153,
-0.472940594,
0.6134941578,
-0.0561594442,
-0.1884075552,
-0.3523227572,
0.148688674,
0.0203736238,
0.0200640019,
0.1505829692,
0.473945111,
-0.1256716549,
-1.1071178913,
0.1274666041,
0.5509110093,
-0.672119379,
-0.3538243175,
0.4938673377,
-0.2316530198,
-0.3773000836,
0.7499762774,
-0.0901928693,
-0.6128330827,
0.6182457805,
0.6640762091,
0.8755295873,
-0.0895677581,
0.1584357023,
0.0521727614,
0.5782468319,
-0.3366237879,
0.0030981638,
0.1941276938,
-0.7344300747,
-0.1400778592,
-0.4772672355,
-0.4025772512,
0.1529206038,
-1.062571764,
-0.0386856943,
-0.6208085418,
-0.260052532,
-0.3115577996,
0.0520133488,
-0.5924784541,
0.2567611635,
-0.1267044097,
0.8765146732,
-0.6459692121,
0.919085741,
0.310431242,
-0.4752025902,
-0.9862139821,
0.5835678577,
-0.1644721776,
-0.9115054607,
0.3327236176,
-0.0616336763,
-0.6775889993,
-0.2718647718,
-0.5825804472,
-1.0779588223,
1.0345567465,
0.6070842743,
-0.7559813261,
-0.0774854124,
0.3115389049,
0.8161685467,
-0.5914279819,
0.2351205051,
0.575091064,
0.1108818054,
-0.0020835819,
-1.1522984505,
0.3607376218,
0.1055167019,
0.2723482549,
0.5045951605,
-0.8540599942,
1.0740634203,
-0.3563233018,
-0.0284864306,
0.0763648152,
0.4332789779,
0.258998096,
0.3035452366,
0.4761730134,
0.5312711,
0.624296546,
0.2117416412,
0.9757606983,
-0.1884150952,
0.473928839,
1.2786433697,
-0.2399504185,
0.9484804273,
0.8554251194,
-0.235769704,
0.6697510481,
0.2917205691,
0.1348030418,
0.3402287662,
0.1660451889,
-0.0619223341,
-0.1380023807,
0.1106663346,
-0.1442023069,
0.3254446089,
0.1095189899,
-0.7932793498,
0.0375542119,
-0.4253538847,
0.1998006552,
0.2217853963,
-0.4309124351,
0.7286742926,
0.3303343654,
-0.6807121038,
0.6678246856,
-0.3364237547,
0.2970664203,
-0.335585475,
0.1246650815,
-0.2626340985,
0.4212488234,
-0.1559675634,
-0.9452822208,
0.2434684485,
0.1371459961,
-0.1933216602,
0.0878314823,
0.2752476037,
-0.0787286535,
-0.499619931,
0.6300528049,
0.5200869441,
0.0623119138,
-0.0582768358,
-0.3261678517,
0.1585408896,
-0.1225521192,
-0.2239101082,
0.4076942503,
0.4936347604,
-0.0464283489,
0.7419122458,
0.4981235564,
0.2645566165,
0.2507275939,
-0.2014310956,
0.986879468,
-0.5398420691,
-0.255613029,
-1.1248899698,
0.121143654,
-0.1696573198,
-0.6138968468,
0.9088815451,
0.6234404445,
0.9699912667,
0.1673057824,
0.3618750274,
0.3026092052,
0.0556957982,
-0.3333616555,
0.6171833873,
-0.425688833,
0.4539869726,
-0.4817589521,
-1.1674581766,
0.2165545821,
0.1408122629,
-0.236067161,
0.1085981578,
1.131734848,
0.6831397414,
-0.2289319485,
0.3048247099,
0.569744885,
0.2822323143,
0.1010720953,
0.2839919627,
0.9020735025,
-0.5792145729,
0.3658588231,
-0.359926939,
-0.2676824629,
0.0157181397,
-0.659173131,
-0.9255673885,
-0.5658671856,
-0.1497976631,
-0.5683022738,
0.1119837165,
0.7902536988,
0.408736378,
-0.6403201818,
-0.3392224908,
-0.6929216385,
-0.0993916988,
-0.4246845245,
-0.1885003895,
0.09833204,
-0.2356378138,
-0.2696835995,
0.031369146,
0.1894462258,
0.0613304079,
-0.551327765,
-0.1811499149,
-0.0671076849,
0.8423303962,
0.2709759176,
-0.2039024979,
-1.0170482397,
-0.5043812394,
-0.0807512477,
-0.2364994735,
0.0097548757,
0.9738978744,
-0.4472229481,
0.4426826537,
0.2245849371,
0.365698576,
0.4323730469,
0.047062315,
0.7919818163,
-0.5691385865,
-0.1954247057,
0.2388829589,
0.2660674453,
-0.0505720414,
-0.7688316107,
0.3439881802,
-0.0166528393,
-0.7786365747,
-1.1104978323,
0.3889431357,
-0.7565242052,
-0.2477177083,
0.8922948837,
-0.2534667253,
-0.4603022337,
-0.0718405992,
0.0506518409,
0.2784363925,
-0.257126689,
0.9704869986,
0.9845719934,
-0.2422343493,
0.0674801469,
-0.3565500975,
0.4576753974,
0.4965237081,
-0.2595190704,
0.615690887,
-0.0484248959,
0.2258804142,
0.432195127,
0.3544636965,
-0.2818409204,
0.322127372,
0.387155652,
-0.4053892791,
0.1725661457,
-0.2661755681,
-0.1383590549,
0.0092388634,
0.4644277394,
-0.028650742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14714v1
|
Efficient and Effective Vocabulary Expansion Towards Multilingual Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T17:12:39 | 2024-02-22T17:12:39 |
Seungduk Kim, Seungtaek Choi, Myeongho Jeong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This report introduces \texttt{EEVE-Korean-v1.0}, a Korean adaptation of
large language models that exhibit remarkable capabilities across English and
Korean text understanding. Building on recent highly capable but
English-centric LLMs, such as SOLAR-10.7B and Phi-2, where non-English texts
are inefficiently processed with English-centric tokenizers, we present an
efficient and effective vocabulary expansion (EEVE) method, which encompasses
parameter freezing and subword initialization. In contrast to previous efforts
that believe new embeddings require trillions of training tokens, we show that
our method can significantly boost non-English proficiency within just 2
billion tokens. Surpassing most instruction-tuned LLMs on the Open Ko-LLM
Leaderboard, as of January 2024, our model \texttt{EEVE-Korean-10.8B-v1.0}
ranks as the leading Korean pre-trained model in the open-source community,
according to Hugging Face's leaderboard. We open-source our models on
Huggingface to empower the open research community in various languages.
|
[
-0.2223572731,
-0.80550915,
0.2807680368,
0.4229899347,
-0.2978012562,
0.2826761305,
-0.5714443326,
-0.5397471189,
0.3494046628,
0.3215550184,
-0.1579843313,
-0.7349809408,
-0.7101876736,
-0.0089954743,
-0.0176937357,
0.5881707072,
-0.0516988747,
0.3324038684,
-0.1998811811,
-0.1868131161,
-0.2894173563,
-0.5021685362,
-0.5150504112,
-0.4232691824,
0.6477975845,
0.4560606182,
0.4498332441,
0.5038315654,
0.2916480005,
0.3711807728,
-0.1998204589,
0.2240778953,
-0.6742078662,
0.1620621532,
-0.1561811417,
-0.3696455657,
-0.8901364803,
-0.0026421738,
0.5770676732,
0.7782163024,
-0.1783974916,
0.0640419051,
-0.049394533,
0.4650430083,
-0.3389869332,
0.1189376414,
-0.6748152375,
-0.1184776425,
-0.142137751,
-0.0763238072,
-0.5044249892,
-0.0384330377,
0.321210295,
-0.958694458,
-0.2760476768,
-0.108002983,
0.7831333876,
-0.0281755421,
-0.4161993265,
-0.2898536623,
-0.4780831635,
0.9908137918,
-0.4350117147,
0.8672522306,
0.1798158884,
0.0038350448,
-0.1818139106,
-0.9308581948,
-0.158970505,
-0.4327638745,
0.2994150817,
0.2911354303,
-0.0154154357,
0.3893637657,
-0.1634162366,
0.3275679946,
-0.4361613691,
0.5135457516,
-0.3688538074,
-0.1581063122,
0.5688360333,
-0.1482889354,
0.3813433349,
-0.0804607943,
-0.4543609023,
-0.0747655779,
-0.4681511223,
-0.2353179604,
0.2084812522,
0.5590185523,
-0.2548325062,
0.8330533504,
-0.1796757579,
0.567188859,
-0.0429730676,
-0.2679992616,
0.4050196707,
-0.3063651919,
-0.1877320111,
-0.0222070012,
0.2314223349,
0.3739273548,
0.2634254694,
-0.4063087404,
-0.0498089381,
-0.0802049935,
-0.0245290902,
-0.8592203856,
-0.2288968116,
0.3855023086,
-0.589589715,
-0.0917076394,
-0.0232546963,
-0.845066309,
-0.467461586,
-0.2251607627,
0.471324414,
-0.4665313959,
-0.6882492304,
0.3707286716,
0.0330241397,
0.346650213,
0.3957216144,
-0.3727532029,
0.2078946829,
0.7172971368,
0.8648204207,
-0.1062285304,
-0.4673221409,
-0.4701729119,
-0.1595752984,
-0.4050875306,
0.5100964904,
-0.4784669578,
-0.2981052697,
0.027458176,
0.0718561709,
-0.0655088946,
-0.4079295099,
0.3129461408,
-0.5949602127,
0.2535227835,
0.0947631374,
-0.9394439459,
-0.1553626806,
0.2254846841,
-0.4279282093,
1.1448436975,
0.2433624119,
-0.3883377016,
0.2174111903,
-0.8426122665,
-0.2046350986,
0.3463117778,
0.1943323314,
0.0257584974,
0.3542444408,
0.2043778747,
0.5966646075,
-0.2906940877,
-0.1393387169,
-0.123257488,
0.0306670219,
-0.1312185675,
0.0074720015,
0.6111994386,
0.2795688808,
0.1274745464,
0.1295354813,
-0.6970860362,
0.3463478386,
0.305824697,
-0.3127423823,
-0.8030703068,
-0.391630888,
0.0795068815,
0.1086848304,
0.519846499,
-0.6211984158,
0.26548931,
-0.6247340441,
0.1802024543,
0.6250580549,
-0.3034414053,
0.869966805,
0.1307024509,
0.8691105843,
-0.029545838,
-0.1175468564,
-0.6952386498,
-0.4815030396,
-0.5575439334,
-0.7089457512,
0.7497141361,
0.6174837351,
-0.9310539365,
0.3168420494,
-0.447054565,
-0.7839244604,
-0.6015741825,
0.1621033251,
0.5037466884,
0.3783411384,
0.337566942,
0.0950677916,
-0.419251889,
-0.6813268661,
-0.3365800679,
-0.1360682845,
-0.1318064332,
0.3087395132,
0.4031944275,
0.0838598311,
0.4471873045,
-0.3803621233,
-0.0007128506,
-0.4363161623,
-0.0588788241,
0.050247997,
0.336073488,
0.4280200899,
-0.7129555941,
-0.8193878531,
0.3206296861,
-0.5887183547,
-0.1154753789,
0.0008211012,
-0.1439842284,
0.2214476615,
0.8107031584,
-0.5507868528,
0.11239025,
0.787945509,
-0.6749665737,
0.3104845285,
-0.2682789862,
-0.0187292192,
-1.4593309164,
-0.0769481137,
0.0891671106,
-0.364281565,
-0.9155775309,
0.5316444635,
0.2677350938,
0.119246155,
-0.6581858397,
1.135386467,
-0.6973713636,
0.2146897316,
-0.2784188986,
0.5490991473,
-0.2441251278,
0.1820103526,
-0.0466674007,
0.6344704032,
0.5904981494,
-0.6979183555,
0.3684334159,
0.1865871996,
-0.3139728904,
0.4947891235,
-0.5603973866,
0.1235678717,
-0.2616801858,
0.0491769388,
-0.8123682141,
-0.196752131,
0.0173667409,
-0.5742518306,
0.473929435,
-0.2646099329,
-0.2761182189,
-0.333066076,
-0.2329128534,
0.0932775363,
0.5651612282,
-0.892906487,
0.8686785698,
0.4976995289,
-0.2674654722,
-0.5037741065,
-0.4256384671,
0.2407432199,
-0.2805225849,
-0.6316322088,
0.4919407368,
-0.0244697426,
-0.3749697804,
0.1021655425,
-0.0140141454,
0.0226675645,
0.0799198002,
-0.2331120968,
0.3515563607,
-0.2667052448,
0.2935673594,
-0.0118559264,
0.0010134282,
-0.2324494272,
-0.6133987904,
0.753151834,
-0.0916486531,
0.0399118066,
0.0094791036,
0.1788964868,
0.6958159208,
-0.0704307929,
0.9151958823,
0.5300835967,
-0.5693749785,
-0.3194414079,
-0.4602308869,
-0.0548751429,
-0.5054568648,
1.1416386366,
-0.7204034328,
-1.0552859306,
0.6388629079,
-0.4523374736,
0.0957817063,
0.3103703558,
0.6237062216,
0.0758360922,
0.860470891,
0.8665238023,
0.0169188268,
0.4275308251,
0.0217845123,
0.1218108684,
-0.8762202263,
-0.3393043876,
-0.3365931809,
-0.1872257292,
-0.7511520982,
-0.7513841987,
0.1069673896,
0.4126150906,
0.0859144405,
0.3487012684,
-0.2971506119,
0.6421384215,
0.2322746813,
-0.0277294535,
0.0233589057,
0.063618876,
-0.3357174098,
-0.2573091686,
-0.8438271284,
-0.1661914587,
1.2814515829,
0.6605089307,
0.7114687562,
-0.0109667769,
0.6603421569,
-0.1458732784,
0.2789572775,
-1.0261634588,
0.5319582224,
-0.370349884,
-0.231934756,
-0.4562052488,
-0.3887052536,
-0.9103271365,
0.3183200657,
0.0036641597,
-0.6756929755,
-0.1317182034,
0.0365240537,
-0.0608211756,
0.4189380109,
-0.8289997578,
0.5978862047,
-0.2622379065,
-0.275996089,
-0.1955162436,
-0.296571523,
0.2215372324,
-0.2973428667,
0.054613959,
-0.0646912754,
-0.5411344171,
0.6506008506,
-0.2427192032,
0.5816048384,
-0.5511878729,
-0.3501675725,
0.1179470345,
-0.1161584184,
0.6644275188,
-0.0469752736,
-0.0136784315,
0.4341050982,
-0.2720963657,
-0.6436765194,
-0.49367401,
0.7192081213,
-0.6337149739,
-0.3561248183,
-0.1712026,
-0.565103054,
-0.275637418,
0.2227368802,
0.1975669563,
0.0784395635,
-0.296228379,
0.3147283196,
0.8415693045,
-0.6083880663,
0.1616446227,
0.5816394091,
-0.7351543903,
-0.6957827806,
0.919696629,
0.3340735734,
0.4242112339,
0.2839571834,
0.2561131418,
-0.3813356161,
-0.4203962386,
-0.366235286,
0.390534699,
-0.5807272792,
-0.2117194533,
-0.7439967394,
-0.2493417114,
-0.3874381781,
-0.2328998744,
-0.8383480906,
-0.6226935983,
-0.0393293798,
-0.1968102604,
0.5343927145,
0.6294729114,
-0.028962303,
0.3136935532,
-0.7168909907,
0.117503792,
0.0305558015,
0.5469515324,
-0.0416706465,
-0.767410934,
-0.5272864699,
-0.167582795,
0.2068539709,
-0.6592969894,
0.4265673757,
0.3366469741,
0.6238464117,
0.193288222,
-0.174349606,
0.8004714251,
-0.5900943875,
0.8894119859,
0.2830438912,
-0.8621752858,
0.1962144822,
-0.3971570432,
0.4767567515,
0.2275110781,
0.3707854748,
-0.67887187,
-0.2475901097,
-0.373256743,
-1.0896425247,
0.5608603954,
-0.1296200901,
0.5591445565,
-0.0861118585,
0.6166422367,
0.1620822549,
0.1154868007,
-0.5144321322,
-0.4345608652,
-0.2022849023,
-0.2076577246,
-0.1370250136,
-0.358554095,
0.2784116268,
-0.419167608,
0.8155336976,
-0.2213718891,
0.3688198328,
0.1082718968,
-0.1882515252,
0.1099715531,
0.1399214119,
0.5817944407,
0.4305579364,
0.0909139439,
-0.0082642157,
0.3642746806,
-0.7286261916,
-0.0078016412,
0.2008848637,
0.0637647808,
-0.0762662813,
0.2024747729,
0.5256778598,
0.1988298595,
-0.5889427662,
0.3226447105,
0.0350973383,
-0.4290060401,
-0.1572628766,
-0.4539222717,
0.2868287861,
0.2647305429,
0.2073377371,
-0.4104207456,
-0.3019263744,
-0.2080764472,
0.1374783367,
0.4062327743,
-0.174840793,
-0.4613676667,
0.6029576659,
0.4361139834,
-0.1486458182,
0.4762897193,
-0.4058405459,
-0.741964221,
0.5363385677,
0.780405283,
0.928670764,
-0.5800064206,
0.2326480448,
0.5647521019,
0.5114412308,
-0.1180773303,
0.6036404967,
0.4476257265,
-0.8703882694,
-0.8018988967,
-0.5887569785,
-0.1518655717,
0.357665658,
-0.4390937984,
0.4266854823,
-0.212469846,
0.0319335274,
-0.2379314005,
0.1091279685,
-0.6427649856,
0.0026336345,
0.2929258645,
1.3907910585,
-0.7325766087,
0.9463725686,
1.0287212133,
-0.0180646665,
-0.6522326469,
-0.1098958775,
-0.2102641016,
-0.8768726587,
0.5313617587,
-0.011165808,
0.0412961356,
0.2497978508,
-0.4682087302,
-1.1673746109,
1.040615201,
0.2418569773,
-0.5408581495,
0.0209858213,
-0.038458731,
0.58006984,
-0.4462881088,
-0.0029432001,
0.2865066826,
0.549621582,
-0.1728818417,
-1.018170476,
-0.2110264301,
-0.3133089542,
0.1086011678,
0.31817168,
-0.7533550858,
0.8265801668,
-0.0525162555,
-0.026087191,
0.3370993733,
0.9410370588,
0.0002097206,
0.1945995986,
0.5529574156,
0.6270700097,
1.1326072216,
0.0637749881,
0.9225842953,
-0.5910645127,
0.1631460637,
1.2951821089,
-0.3272174001,
0.7656739354,
0.5121126771,
0.0185677987,
0.2393719554,
0.5823427439,
0.0702355355,
0.5328597426,
0.2190855145,
-0.1996117234,
-0.2950664759,
-0.2986032069,
-0.2463474721,
0.6545715332,
0.5593160391,
-0.1673168689,
-0.0298909545,
0.3794245124,
0.3341758847,
0.1582825035,
-0.6341563463,
0.6109358072,
0.059828978,
-0.4293683767,
0.3025149703,
0.2765254378,
0.8815896511,
-0.6085384488,
0.0421390384,
-0.1633272022,
0.0641116723,
-0.0217516441,
-0.4090960622,
-0.1494989246,
0.0492247008,
0.1429962367,
-0.06352368,
0.9139763713,
-0.7440273166,
-0.5440018177,
0.6268972754,
0.8775990009,
0.098374173,
0.1715652496,
-0.7132799029,
-0.0555904172,
-0.103470318,
-0.5811936259,
0.341329664,
0.4483159184,
-0.1186172962,
0.4855293334,
0.3858675659,
0.373131454,
0.3063604832,
0.062867865,
0.7654052973,
-0.3338723183,
-0.3493338823,
-0.5806537867,
0.5728520155,
-0.2358483523,
-0.3073281944,
0.9747824669,
0.6066133976,
1.1353071928,
0.0461633615,
0.7957738042,
-0.0658774972,
0.5321261883,
-0.5952586532,
0.5853891373,
-0.7397739887,
0.1601598263,
-0.1702229977,
-1.0245440006,
-0.3246364295,
0.425887078,
-0.1192268059,
0.1904767007,
0.6538841128,
0.7189520597,
-0.0164730828,
-0.2521226108,
0.5942522287,
0.5368432403,
0.1210488304,
0.0516347066,
0.6226372123,
-0.4342797101,
0.3918082118,
-0.2490116358,
-0.379095912,
0.0388877615,
-0.9153189659,
-0.9751155972,
-0.455858171,
-0.4588876367,
-0.4804521501,
-0.0285832956,
1.386346221,
0.6944296956,
-0.5961380601,
-0.0952753872,
0.0099314991,
-0.0119343577,
-0.0541582778,
-0.2090715766,
0.338939935,
-0.4167216122,
-1.0455502272,
0.7620744705,
0.3317470849,
-0.0530632623,
-0.3337040544,
-0.4353411794,
-0.1121145934,
0.4108825624,
0.8714479804,
0.2565716803,
-0.650908649,
-0.1463406235,
0.4466603398,
-0.0037690178,
-0.0809012726,
0.5171940923,
-0.6141114831,
0.7196283937,
0.3805330098,
0.7309241891,
0.2643448412,
-0.172725305,
0.5620664954,
-0.8298079967,
0.3338760734,
-0.0022487126,
0.1724903286,
0.2395880222,
-0.2959499955,
0.6677907109,
0.0411708988,
-0.4635161757,
-0.9328730702,
0.1054711938,
-0.6389790177,
-0.4387304783,
1.2309718132,
-0.2509110272,
-0.2430076599,
0.0498176515,
0.0217964519,
0.1231459975,
-0.2552518249,
0.5606259704,
0.8316248059,
0.0557456836,
-0.0975676253,
-0.613771379,
0.2912827134,
0.3804240525,
-0.7315965891,
0.1418433785,
0.2135457546,
0.1721153259,
0.0443156399,
0.5232354403,
-0.2740543187,
0.1690168083,
0.1194785312,
0.210742712,
-0.1729238629,
-0.4898751378,
-0.6080960631,
-0.0227191523,
0.1198222935,
-0.181569621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14710v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14710v3
|
IEPile: Unearthing Large-Scale Schema-Based Information Extraction Corpus
| 2024-02-22T17:11:38 | 2024-05-26T15:54:41 |
Honghao Gui, Lin Yuan, Hongbin Ye, Ningyu Zhang, Mengshu Sun, Lei Liang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable potential across various
domains; however, they exhibit a significant performance gap in Information
Extraction (IE). Note that high-quality instruction data is the vital key for
enhancing the specific capabilities of LLMs, while current IE datasets tend to
be small in scale, fragmented, and lack standardized schema. To this end, we
introduce IEPile, a comprehensive bilingual (English and Chinese) IE
instruction corpus, which contains approximately 0.32B tokens. We construct
IEPile by collecting and cleaning 33 existing IE datasets, and introduce
schema-based instruction generation to unearth a large-scale corpus.
Experimentally, IEPile enhance the performance of LLMs for IE, with notable
improvements in zero-shot generalization. We open-source the resource and
pre-trained models, hoping to provide valuable support to the NLP community.
|
[
-0.0896406695,
-0.5928720236,
0.158424437,
0.2302044779,
0.1529966146,
0.0512695126,
-0.5461152196,
-0.4661175013,
0.1901570112,
0.7483351827,
-0.1698516011,
-0.7717145085,
-0.7414336205,
-0.0398014858,
-0.6136193871,
0.7450207472,
0.1824106574,
0.0241504777,
-0.0731439516,
0.1579409689,
-0.2979998291,
-0.2043583691,
-0.4102475047,
0.1764736474,
0.2946039438,
0.7969235182,
0.247195065,
1.1433998346,
0.2729515135,
0.2077225,
0.2295026183,
0.3320484757,
-0.522143662,
0.2154937088,
-0.251889497,
-0.5267880559,
-0.510174036,
-0.0425753556,
0.7330432534,
0.6838136315,
-0.5513858795,
0.421774745,
0.1351183355,
0.1391155124,
-0.8642660975,
0.4802737236,
-0.6565212011,
-0.0283222459,
-0.6243309379,
-0.2440582365,
-0.8074643016,
-0.1987401247,
0.0065339617,
-0.7390074134,
0.2174854726,
0.191249907,
0.9777427912,
-0.0076138433,
-0.2142375708,
-0.3903167844,
-0.6327670813,
1.0491819382,
-0.7057442069,
0.5230320096,
0.4116391838,
-0.0002010791,
0.0157500803,
-1.0921227932,
-0.3530441225,
0.0127787329,
0.1748953462,
0.1084046066,
-0.0275284462,
-0.0026394064,
0.312648505,
0.4378350079,
-0.6231225729,
0.5453023314,
-0.6395204067,
-0.1470980644,
0.3664108813,
0.2395942509,
0.6109133959,
-0.3407921195,
-0.2868884206,
0.006851403,
-1.050547719,
-0.2262774855,
0.1353313625,
0.4778088629,
0.0374821089,
0.8073023558,
-0.0346400887,
0.6055871248,
-0.1295341104,
-0.3188100159,
0.0714677125,
0.0647131205,
-0.2525341809,
0.1989550889,
0.7287375331,
0.2463850081,
0.1214406937,
-0.2785472274,
0.0164908078,
-0.1473557204,
0.0356623009,
-0.9629516602,
-0.1422718316,
0.3273730278,
-0.4135122597,
0.0067544589,
0.2422159016,
-0.9082350135,
-0.0959423706,
-0.311799258,
-0.1433903277,
-0.603382051,
-0.1171250865,
0.2420405149,
-0.1741684973,
0.3750971854,
0.4092677534,
-1.0731141567,
0.0406811722,
0.845800519,
0.6427228451,
-0.1966136247,
-0.4752652645,
-0.9371221066,
0.6188095808,
-0.2319963127,
0.7338278294,
-0.7414445877,
-0.3156931996,
0.0552965812,
0.1043454632,
-0.0035790966,
-0.7176950574,
0.4773758948,
-0.4360477328,
0.3788284361,
0.0044424688,
-0.7813181877,
0.2173122615,
0.0814493001,
-0.9044661522,
1.410789609,
0.280021131,
-0.782962501,
0.1988760829,
-0.7265873551,
-0.4041993022,
0.2988499403,
-0.3017514944,
0.2860813141,
0.0879861489,
0.2930672467,
0.4417712092,
-0.7138435841,
0.0853046328,
-0.0422355905,
-0.4286486804,
-0.5157657266,
-0.2663260102,
1.1022473574,
0.4185111225,
-0.2585902214,
-0.3828491569,
-0.9066873193,
-0.0390857123,
0.1451300979,
-0.7101712823,
-0.3113228977,
0.0311153065,
-0.2196449041,
0.1171020344,
0.5835698843,
-0.683654964,
0.4862657189,
-0.2981667519,
0.2730042338,
0.8718927503,
-0.3358213305,
0.4491515756,
0.2094480246,
0.6328350306,
-0.1083936244,
-0.0515857637,
-0.4824842215,
-0.1953723133,
-0.8777508736,
-0.4745335281,
0.6756517291,
0.892621696,
-0.7865405083,
0.4833934605,
-0.5740489364,
-0.2548319101,
-0.5770742297,
0.3113740981,
0.1495543122,
0.4319193065,
0.3136736751,
-0.1357830018,
-0.5313007236,
-0.7109891772,
-0.0814742073,
-0.1383499652,
-0.4694539607,
0.1097126901,
0.0970258862,
0.0334042981,
0.7289155722,
-0.5153571367,
-0.0630962998,
-0.4330734611,
0.2391667217,
0.0575106554,
0.2213906497,
0.3054315746,
-0.1559301913,
-0.4599323869,
0.0419918709,
-1.0488598347,
-0.3475783467,
0.0675391108,
-0.2976091504,
-0.0078567425,
0.8253518343,
-0.7166292667,
0.2056791484,
0.3135536313,
-0.0539943986,
0.4432400167,
-0.0585712157,
-0.1148596555,
-1.0677945614,
0.0504457206,
-0.1142515987,
0.0500104614,
-0.2642906904,
0.4831240773,
0.2275182456,
0.0169592742,
-0.7593377829,
0.5168647766,
-0.7977583408,
-0.0647483245,
0.0043417127,
0.3515884876,
0.1615536958,
0.1133141071,
-0.0552342534,
0.7345912457,
0.4462087452,
-0.4323353469,
0.3000183105,
0.2752191424,
-0.3968282044,
0.4113664627,
-0.3440881371,
0.0402296484,
-0.0595219135,
0.0482446812,
-0.350115329,
-0.4635690749,
-0.1249346584,
-0.0641385838,
0.8279799223,
-0.0271191336,
-0.8384252191,
-0.1810004115,
-0.3175564408,
-0.0803709999,
0.4131569862,
-0.7375000119,
0.6162548661,
0.6233398914,
-0.4241648912,
-0.9686092138,
-0.6502683163,
0.2629070878,
-0.0757747442,
-0.5565471649,
0.2997868359,
0.1850929111,
-0.2169923186,
0.0652758703,
0.1684149951,
-0.0774311498,
-0.1072692126,
0.0922494531,
0.3581092358,
-0.4473461509,
0.2295974642,
0.1289343238,
-0.0090544065,
-0.0152399028,
-0.1473284215,
0.6952118874,
0.0743984804,
-0.3920347095,
-0.0897457972,
0.5124130845,
0.4057862461,
-0.5185495615,
0.7041266561,
0.5083950162,
-0.3843165338,
-0.6073983908,
-0.4509198368,
-0.057186868,
-0.4360247254,
0.4645355344,
-0.0540410131,
-0.9088349938,
0.1815485209,
-0.4505500495,
0.4258359969,
0.5717249513,
0.377509445,
0.0437266976,
0.8135742545,
0.6475069523,
-0.2529065609,
0.3383399844,
-0.3975659907,
0.0750240311,
-0.837027669,
-0.1441427022,
-0.6585171819,
-0.0528363734,
-0.1661431044,
-0.4484270811,
-0.0778940991,
0.2709986567,
-0.2899470031,
0.3577696085,
-0.5254459977,
0.726010263,
0.671317935,
-0.0832797512,
0.2144997418,
0.196232453,
-0.1822897196,
-0.097631827,
-0.8082503676,
-0.6960020065,
1.3969736099,
0.1395846009,
0.5464452505,
-0.0699504763,
0.8744971752,
0.1490620226,
0.3128040135,
-0.5381360054,
0.6346124411,
-0.5167560577,
-0.5455887318,
-0.26480937,
-0.2785382867,
-1.0415602922,
-0.1698029339,
-0.0420095772,
-0.8468235135,
-0.1397967786,
-0.0959466696,
-0.2229481488,
0.3369438946,
-0.7074968219,
0.8082969189,
-0.3442904949,
-0.5472095013,
0.0084615452,
-0.5912752151,
0.4583900571,
0.0161350798,
0.4048388302,
0.0178768821,
-0.0382798575,
0.5606980324,
-0.5002509356,
0.7849783301,
-0.1538238674,
-0.1643881649,
0.4213766754,
0.104427509,
0.5940620899,
-0.4301861227,
-0.2891741395,
0.3550632298,
-0.2122140676,
-0.396127522,
-0.4455586374,
0.779293716,
-0.5414690375,
-0.468161732,
-0.1359188259,
-0.4253630936,
0.0802925825,
0.2765794992,
0.4743482172,
0.3640705645,
-0.2468418479,
0.3779963255,
0.6092897058,
-0.5566226244,
0.407497853,
0.4522197545,
-0.3088442087,
-0.0000542324,
1.140966773,
0.3829704523,
0.0864577591,
0.413950026,
-0.0792421773,
0.015075394,
-0.4418684542,
-0.5447458029,
0.1452043653,
-0.7907040119,
-0.2365303636,
-0.5986269116,
-0.4425475895,
-0.3019572198,
-0.0003697818,
-0.427883178,
-0.6602323055,
-0.3905996978,
-0.3189069927,
0.1516369283,
0.740362823,
-0.1379578114,
0.2502606213,
-1.108506918,
0.2103555501,
0.0014082631,
0.0871770754,
-0.0379339866,
-0.3442782164,
-0.5370253921,
-0.143495664,
-0.3611293435,
-0.722119987,
0.4825154543,
0.3917043805,
0.616294682,
0.5483045578,
0.1109073162,
0.6690567732,
-0.6544234753,
1.1812647581,
-0.0723739713,
-0.8004418015,
0.4892552495,
-0.2011670768,
0.1464734524,
0.3071627915,
0.3907488585,
-0.2354366779,
-0.5031020045,
-0.6253433824,
-1.2290145159,
0.9282429218,
-0.1206540465,
0.0134100029,
-0.5045706034,
0.0808387101,
0.1814977974,
0.0823538303,
-0.3859612048,
-0.1093825921,
0.0093492614,
-0.327509135,
0.4360628128,
-0.2215995938,
-0.0316106714,
-0.137056604,
0.4691788554,
0.0615572892,
0.2003789097,
-0.2791554332,
-0.4197359383,
0.0699623451,
0.213675797,
0.2045751661,
0.5931953192,
-0.0876106769,
0.1264737695,
0.2059500664,
-0.6132318974,
-0.3162809908,
0.0194262266,
-0.046809759,
-0.0490900502,
0.6246161461,
0.3350885212,
0.2932466567,
-1.0348371267,
0.5960465074,
0.0620183311,
0.026822852,
-0.3064100444,
0.1357349306,
0.3440453708,
0.0169108752,
0.3447052538,
-0.5013828278,
0.1270820349,
-0.4813325107,
0.3260172606,
0.1962196678,
0.0772211328,
-0.167419374,
0.697158277,
0.0825142562,
-0.1309341043,
1.0085214376,
-0.2173949182,
-0.2608383894,
0.511111021,
0.6469597816,
0.5964838266,
-0.4235723019,
0.1615933329,
0.508844614,
0.3377068341,
-0.1749172956,
0.3302197754,
0.0453914553,
-0.5586959124,
-0.7077291608,
-0.7308662534,
-0.3293582499,
0.2658390105,
-0.8284059167,
0.4697235227,
-0.3948351145,
0.2438339144,
-0.1704783589,
-0.3126062453,
-0.6990376115,
0.0614641234,
0.1040503532,
1.0048040152,
-0.3766916692,
0.9711791873,
0.2758142054,
-0.3518368602,
-0.9879248738,
-0.2171233296,
0.1116156206,
-0.8990058899,
0.9290978312,
0.0928468853,
0.1563317627,
-0.0772194043,
-0.7505896688,
-0.7228982449,
1.1766264439,
0.8497324586,
-0.5828209519,
-0.5420817733,
0.376696378,
0.3021416962,
-0.4120993018,
0.4102796316,
0.663023293,
0.4051322043,
-0.133182779,
-0.7993394732,
-0.1942388266,
-0.4043608308,
-0.4493770003,
0.2145850658,
-0.568166852,
1.1246156693,
0.0419251844,
-0.5123499632,
-0.0443982929,
0.4576670527,
0.2569839656,
-0.0717345402,
0.1176616699,
0.7167744637,
0.8515082598,
-0.0421558619,
0.8853069544,
-0.8589632511,
0.0160293858,
1.3645963669,
-0.4203826189,
1.2454409599,
0.2508624792,
-0.0158469416,
0.5819225311,
0.4539269209,
0.1683683991,
0.0947302431,
-0.0088393018,
-0.2480909675,
-0.2063322365,
-0.1961418092,
-0.3822515011,
0.9009292126,
0.7894675136,
-0.6435721517,
-0.5564674735,
-0.3397703767,
0.209307611,
-0.2240556926,
-0.0917548016,
0.5704475045,
-0.0699838921,
-0.4481142759,
0.446906209,
0.0677904338,
0.4428138435,
-0.6518447399,
-0.3932446837,
-0.1131823957,
-0.1131200194,
-0.3414294422,
-0.4773434699,
0.1120999604,
0.2047994733,
-0.0078705112,
-0.1961121559,
0.6713353395,
-0.5150805116,
-0.2697191834,
0.4626890421,
0.593565762,
0.4056892097,
0.1204535738,
-0.4714542031,
0.0339505672,
0.0476627052,
-0.4626934826,
0.5027883053,
0.8258514404,
-0.0120622572,
0.2787600458,
0.7514646053,
0.4878967404,
0.3732356429,
-0.2926105261,
0.8149888515,
-0.6669857502,
-0.1981490254,
-0.6816005707,
0.6116554141,
-0.3230335414,
-0.2420709878,
0.846884191,
0.8965936303,
0.8954866529,
0.0081381565,
0.8884968162,
-0.1315265,
0.6387465596,
-0.573710978,
0.4477804303,
-0.4485481679,
0.7292767763,
-0.0487747677,
-1.1116020679,
-0.2627002001,
0.4510946572,
0.0587653555,
-0.4425100088,
0.6791446209,
0.7684608102,
-0.2301491648,
0.1175705865,
0.1644337177,
0.2275081575,
0.3113866746,
0.5389762521,
0.711825788,
-0.1078211889,
0.5708114505,
-0.1016449109,
-0.2881383896,
-0.1259662807,
-1.0497756004,
-0.5031946301,
-0.246213764,
0.062915422,
-0.1217340231,
-0.2686202228,
1.013256669,
0.5671862364,
-0.6715043187,
-0.3425807357,
0.1024581715,
-0.1676167697,
0.1484764963,
-0.2750322521,
0.5617640018,
-0.3806818724,
-0.9730359316,
0.6699403524,
0.5724387765,
-0.3245747387,
-0.1867502481,
0.0093631865,
-0.1056714281,
0.1447264105,
0.8171086311,
0.524320662,
-0.5442517996,
-0.2592628896,
0.2108891904,
-0.186649546,
0.1052184552,
0.5913447738,
-0.3922912776,
0.5487946272,
0.4482393563,
0.781447649,
0.469080776,
-0.2290980667,
0.6633607745,
-0.8846706748,
0.2231539935,
0.0516397692,
0.5400841236,
0.2211861014,
-0.2818467319,
0.7573825121,
-0.0172923021,
-0.5089898109,
-0.9682549834,
0.0780189186,
-0.6713683009,
-0.3388530314,
1.1655950546,
-0.3864368796,
-0.3194072247,
-0.0639712811,
-0.2180569172,
0.2098042518,
-0.3999750614,
0.5704679489,
0.7595521808,
-0.0624138676,
-0.0612740926,
-0.7649255395,
0.0977649391,
0.130306989,
-0.904404521,
0.3112353981,
0.6118723154,
0.086930871,
0.334554702,
0.4033304751,
-0.2583794892,
0.2037090063,
0.3175887167,
0.4437345564,
-0.166157499,
-0.6393136978,
0.1040805429,
0.4804442823,
0.0138616841,
0.0573568456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14704v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14704v3
|
An LLM-Enhanced Adversarial Editing System for Lexical Simplification
| 2024-02-22T17:04:30 | 2024-03-22T06:45:51 |
Keren Tan, Kangyang Luo, Yunshi Lan, Zheng Yuan, Jinlong Shu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lexical Simplification (LS) aims to simplify text at the lexical level.
Existing methods rely heavily on annotated data, making it challenging to apply
in low-resource scenarios. In this paper, we propose a novel LS method without
parallel corpora. This method employs an Adversarial Editing System with
guidance from a confusion loss and an invariance loss to predict lexical edits
in the original sentences. Meanwhile, we introduce an innovative LLM-enhanced
loss to enable the distillation of knowledge from Large Language Models (LLMs)
into a small-size LS system. From that, complex words within sentences are
masked and a Difficulty-aware Filling module is crafted to replace masked
positions with simpler words. At last, extensive experimental results and
analyses on three benchmark LS datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our
proposed method.
|
[
-0.2269853652,
-0.8341854215,
0.5408290029,
0.0106207803,
-0.4329792857,
0.2420655042,
-0.4388396442,
-0.0323938616,
0.3417123258,
0.3390635252,
-0.6935272813,
-0.4995188415,
-0.8418002725,
0.282563448,
-0.2921121418,
0.9253950715,
-0.0842017159,
0.2982623577,
-0.0152582517,
0.0913034827,
-0.2915631235,
-0.3664748371,
-0.6481221914,
-0.4761841595,
0.5053714514,
0.2561226189,
1.3598607779,
0.6831713915,
0.4239126146,
0.3724713326,
-0.8977899551,
0.7540230751,
-0.5391891599,
-0.1980455816,
-0.0563110709,
-0.6856989264,
-0.4106763005,
-0.5178006291,
0.4786546528,
0.7277377248,
-0.028575398,
-0.1525764614,
0.1920879781,
0.799221158,
-0.983012259,
-0.0176974125,
-0.8975842595,
0.3486246169,
-0.2039083093,
-0.1122631133,
-0.1725466549,
-0.3533562124,
-0.3755244911,
-0.72460711,
0.1345306039,
-0.1925145686,
0.3732362688,
0.7444313169,
-0.0006829942,
-0.4302838743,
-0.5827273726,
0.5255916715,
-0.6570212841,
0.0315676183,
0.0384914167,
0.1244603768,
-0.3982848823,
-0.5917064548,
-0.6282534003,
0.0481001846,
-0.2544503808,
0.1622523963,
-0.1624594182,
0.3534662724,
0.3020947874,
0.2160256803,
-0.2565585673,
-0.0325604491,
-0.3838526607,
-0.2478310764,
0.486848563,
0.2584889531,
0.2169899791,
-0.0935661942,
-0.3196292222,
0.0462759435,
-0.8287050128,
-0.174238041,
0.2935084105,
0.348356694,
0.1840177178,
0.6945326924,
-0.2054785937,
0.3517053723,
0.0219509378,
-0.295047462,
0.0278941076,
-0.2501805425,
-0.6276366711,
0.4002839029,
0.7232134938,
0.2964943349,
0.0602553524,
-0.141272366,
-0.3855732977,
0.1469954699,
-0.1848610789,
-0.5791734457,
-0.1384151727,
-0.0536734834,
-0.0503156409,
-0.5274089575,
-0.2136821002,
-0.5855943561,
-0.9680070281,
-0.2276753783,
0.473903507,
-0.5074968934,
0.3774423003,
0.3801947534,
-0.173487559,
-0.5181618929,
0.7169834375,
-0.4984138906,
0.3471643329,
0.5930528045,
0.9335593581,
0.0435400195,
-0.0990867019,
-0.3755652606,
0.179594934,
-0.477691561,
0.1740354598,
-0.1764648557,
-0.2962442338,
-0.0491649881,
-0.2944733799,
0.2562496364,
-0.6486837864,
0.6003881693,
-0.7389765978,
-0.216888085,
-0.1336547881,
-0.5163397193,
-0.107003808,
0.1455218792,
-0.6124715209,
0.8074173331,
-0.4117101729,
-0.8522397876,
-0.0360260829,
-0.3553271592,
-0.2758936584,
0.0528939739,
-0.0253093373,
-0.4028407335,
0.1251812428,
0.6217303276,
0.2135747075,
-0.1766367108,
0.3064463139,
-0.3065314591,
-0.6285477877,
0.1607503593,
-0.6274174452,
0.7623193264,
0.3041605949,
-0.2300739735,
-0.0710270032,
-0.6288098693,
-0.1077637151,
0.0769279227,
-0.3783252537,
-0.4194404781,
-0.2015110105,
-0.231823951,
-0.0288618784,
0.6323090792,
-0.5637646914,
0.3802502155,
-0.4461167157,
0.1053777561,
0.7899144888,
-0.0820539072,
0.4324347675,
-0.1736138463,
0.4241628945,
-0.0459623225,
0.3561533093,
0.0786520392,
-0.2700466514,
-0.8479738832,
-0.5734534264,
0.3969976008,
0.7963652611,
-1.1546760798,
0.3105041683,
-0.2319131643,
-0.3835564554,
-0.630853951,
0.6073716879,
0.5730565786,
0.2675094903,
0.5113069415,
0.1164965332,
-0.5151557922,
-0.8902590871,
-0.3834500909,
0.1973184496,
-0.1931713074,
-0.0388238505,
0.1994460672,
-0.2915569544,
0.5515775084,
-0.6799699068,
-0.4657803476,
-0.4066106379,
-0.1117489785,
-0.0189939756,
0.1861127317,
0.1630507708,
-0.5898658037,
-0.2416242808,
-0.2116962373,
-0.839322865,
-0.3777106404,
-0.2335803956,
0.1497763991,
-0.1253010929,
1.0410307646,
-0.6020936966,
0.7494850755,
0.317168057,
-0.0837063119,
0.2995351851,
-0.564584136,
-0.2542416453,
-0.7748500109,
-0.4930167794,
-0.3641674221,
-0.3837465048,
-0.6358115077,
0.1112734377,
0.3445208669,
-0.0790282488,
-0.6636189818,
0.2379450798,
-0.3951901197,
0.2141698003,
-0.2719913125,
0.303678453,
0.0868278816,
0.5361987352,
-0.4349158704,
0.5981559157,
0.2557559013,
-0.484792918,
0.5235536695,
0.1801367402,
-0.0448565185,
0.1010148674,
-0.4522442818,
-0.0559993684,
-0.5647212267,
0.3460593522,
-0.6011716127,
-0.027992351,
0.2939654589,
-0.1228628755,
0.1664164513,
0.1644381434,
-0.678571701,
-0.0231866017,
-0.6287627816,
0.2973265648,
0.1928700656,
-0.6469202042,
0.3947629333,
0.0092483144,
-0.2934043705,
-0.6706312299,
-1.0377094746,
0.4499623775,
-0.1816927493,
-0.5356100798,
0.6010865569,
-0.174912706,
-0.3762869239,
-0.0486995131,
0.236789763,
0.1609903872,
0.0699400008,
0.0377641432,
0.3070329726,
0.0212137513,
0.3207342029,
0.2046581656,
0.2437546104,
-0.2831423879,
0.2508107424,
0.3263348043,
-0.1051962823,
-0.4029300809,
-0.8223201632,
0.2807383537,
0.5195854902,
0.2442687601,
0.5782456994,
0.4029015005,
-0.5411165357,
-0.3645884395,
-0.3837834001,
0.1379576623,
-0.4985660613,
0.4660385847,
-0.3639998138,
-0.6345925331,
0.5972244143,
-0.2779120505,
-0.12968795,
0.4842430651,
0.2476104647,
0.1548279822,
0.7909632921,
0.3851595521,
-0.166316852,
0.3093656003,
-0.201919809,
0.0825177953,
-0.7271678448,
-0.1777097583,
-0.0820669979,
-0.507479012,
-0.4802119732,
-0.5747754574,
0.6406804323,
0.4911373556,
-0.2478662133,
0.1369432211,
-0.3469973207,
0.5738109946,
0.5263469219,
0.5511423945,
0.5018689036,
-0.0198516622,
-0.1925808489,
-0.1418067366,
-0.6822913289,
-0.3566450775,
1.1303271055,
0.2476103306,
1.0154407024,
0.3374798298,
0.8633327484,
0.458986938,
0.2213395089,
-0.6779568195,
0.7038290501,
-0.3998368084,
-0.027039703,
-0.4645662904,
-0.4081547856,
-0.4067663252,
0.3425811827,
-0.3988844156,
-0.3260478675,
-0.0147173535,
-0.0740032643,
-0.6156292558,
0.6111325622,
-0.7830736041,
0.2597969472,
-0.0107383393,
-0.3394682407,
-0.11532107,
-0.3218639493,
0.4737097919,
-0.242536813,
0.5143963099,
0.3140127063,
-0.4000408351,
0.4400084913,
-1.1231788397,
0.8604621887,
-0.1550908387,
0.0488208458,
0.1263875812,
0.2552078068,
0.9690774679,
0.1455930024,
-0.173387751,
-0.039945703,
-0.4871292114,
-0.0750951394,
-0.9314198494,
0.8450967073,
-0.6920266151,
-0.7204162478,
-0.2353344113,
-0.6865940094,
-0.071220845,
0.0428916104,
0.1832701266,
0.275331229,
-0.0454452448,
0.0246134941,
0.6393056512,
-0.3062181175,
0.4262759984,
0.0053437618,
-0.0662274286,
-0.625154078,
0.5904942155,
0.1244799495,
0.2746722996,
0.1972656995,
0.382605046,
-0.1357488334,
-0.6636682749,
-0.6509994268,
0.0881276131,
-0.9055250883,
-0.4320328534,
-0.3781598508,
-0.2510017157,
-0.4438489079,
-0.5618291497,
-0.3535897434,
-0.569652915,
-0.4123274982,
0.0898461491,
0.3301102817,
1.0534633398,
-0.2127173543,
0.42787534,
-0.4239386022,
0.4672245979,
0.3169762194,
-0.0193841234,
-0.2343927026,
-0.6292130351,
-0.0077964943,
0.166755721,
-0.2847120166,
-0.8400776386,
0.5380078554,
0.2977336049,
0.0778902397,
0.2765809894,
0.1297426373,
1.0697011948,
-0.4682463109,
0.6120851636,
0.3596002162,
-1.0915919542,
0.384799242,
-0.062023811,
0.5350498557,
0.4529154897,
-0.0860475078,
-0.3605265319,
-0.5141516924,
-0.5311825275,
-0.8502016068,
0.7776822448,
0.391081363,
-0.1053139195,
0.3588575125,
0.6080399156,
-0.2152014673,
0.293289572,
-0.6279571652,
-0.5667434931,
0.0356812626,
-0.4518207312,
-0.1323353499,
-0.3855496645,
-0.2103843838,
-0.1511638463,
0.9397107363,
0.1488131881,
-0.2790732384,
0.4431537688,
-0.2097624242,
0.0087431502,
0.4038538039,
0.608928442,
0.0617876276,
-0.0818761513,
0.3327985704,
0.8492015004,
-0.3033575714,
0.0452119224,
0.1229669377,
-0.5795419216,
0.2129522264,
0.3073679507,
0.6738522649,
0.1659350842,
-0.5104033351,
0.6710934043,
-0.0597456247,
-0.2457605898,
-0.2881122828,
-0.1777100861,
0.124824062,
0.3064993024,
0.2102225572,
0.3160660565,
0.2064687312,
-0.3104257584,
0.0700328872,
0.3493562639,
-0.3565562963,
0.1659830213,
0.5279076099,
-0.1966378391,
-0.2106796652,
-0.0620577484,
-0.4404609799,
-0.547414422,
0.492854327,
0.2480477244,
0.620362401,
-0.2384740561,
-0.0780683383,
0.1286484152,
0.4912611246,
-0.2126509398,
-0.005605083,
0.2073705494,
-0.3544184566,
-0.099034071,
-0.588214457,
-0.4736376405,
0.357519418,
-0.2296407819,
0.5868791938,
-0.7925623655,
0.1210674122,
0.1178337708,
-0.2447888702,
-0.5167427659,
0.3355221748,
0.3769832551,
0.8083962202,
-0.6559674144,
0.6215402484,
0.5350074172,
-0.0127786221,
-0.5962882042,
-0.0406038314,
0.3347162604,
-0.8120046854,
0.7777355313,
-0.1050974056,
-0.4840449989,
-0.4361917078,
-0.3386943936,
-0.7925618887,
1.0909192562,
0.701779604,
-0.5068938732,
-0.1185400337,
0.4924365878,
0.5951333642,
-0.1584268808,
0.2260274142,
0.2638918757,
0.3161404729,
0.2400707453,
-0.7675959468,
0.1815901846,
0.0527405441,
0.3141720295,
-0.0353616588,
-0.5194934011,
1.0893763304,
-0.2573842108,
-0.1924304068,
0.0075506633,
0.583526969,
-0.2068646103,
0.1746222377,
0.5296943784,
0.6644095182,
0.7875939608,
0.144341141,
0.6807363033,
-0.1573829949,
0.2948072553,
1.3142182827,
0.0419347435,
0.5970068574,
0.5571951866,
-0.0746136159,
0.2948124409,
0.3066135645,
0.4425656199,
0.6133739948,
0.7083835602,
-0.6044208407,
-0.2838595212,
-0.1274325103,
-0.184158653,
0.389138937,
0.6405838132,
-0.4009206593,
-0.508671701,
0.0154075222,
0.3373818994,
0.3654115796,
-0.640355587,
0.8054392934,
-0.0787210688,
-0.396674484,
0.7657512426,
0.288303256,
1.0484702587,
-0.591848433,
0.2260912955,
-0.1724948734,
0.5717917681,
-0.2766510546,
-0.4932218492,
0.4146636426,
0.0876399279,
0.1436342746,
-0.1349803358,
0.7489828467,
-0.6228867173,
-0.8375512362,
0.4437689483,
0.3512761593,
0.0333022103,
-0.2737435699,
-0.6430936456,
0.1748161763,
0.1045154408,
-0.2179559767,
0.1994685233,
0.5649908781,
0.1479153484,
0.7657532692,
0.4628557265,
0.435046196,
0.1289657354,
0.0226041805,
1.182115078,
-0.5873567462,
-0.4616527259,
-0.9361678958,
-0.0066076801,
-0.1467932016,
-0.0169454589,
0.5644079447,
0.5246043205,
0.5993844271,
0.0197912827,
0.9929303527,
0.3319993317,
0.4069300592,
-0.5633452535,
0.6024355888,
-0.7977548838,
0.5648366809,
-0.2150969654,
-0.3260863721,
-0.6374136209,
0.0436959714,
-0.0632862896,
-0.465380311,
0.7259958386,
1.2876381874,
0.0158239342,
-0.1478336304,
0.6203832626,
0.1741113365,
0.0171670839,
0.6629401445,
0.4401807785,
-0.6966298819,
0.8441987634,
-0.575201571,
-0.3529348671,
-0.2737690806,
-0.6087641716,
-0.8620078564,
-0.0340994298,
-0.2138362825,
-0.2461247295,
0.5045163631,
0.8586363792,
-0.0545980372,
-0.536457181,
0.1793337762,
-0.230820477,
0.2005115598,
-0.0595912822,
-0.157758832,
0.5992392898,
-0.3845988512,
-0.777454257,
0.6584126949,
0.1468984783,
0.070940882,
-0.207670778,
0.007819429,
-0.1051882282,
0.2577247024,
0.4165094197,
-0.1011224911,
-0.9619505405,
-0.1958040297,
-0.2972539961,
-0.3115316331,
-0.1742896587,
0.5338779688,
-0.560051024,
0.6362705827,
0.4449713528,
0.6510730982,
0.0213673413,
-0.1936164051,
0.2743964195,
-0.8597161174,
0.4021269977,
-0.0281509273,
0.6132521033,
0.4926052094,
-0.6497350335,
0.2281556427,
0.3052440882,
-0.1125975847,
-0.5476474762,
0.1421025395,
-0.7572133541,
-0.4519076347,
1.331142664,
-0.2192487121,
-0.1677287072,
-0.1473763436,
-0.5059394836,
0.4403993189,
-0.29233253,
0.806279242,
0.5273213387,
0.1896101236,
0.1692236662,
-0.1728350669,
0.9005108476,
0.6706138849,
-0.5798701644,
0.26730147,
0.4573477209,
0.0177307688,
0.2510774136,
0.2851876318,
-0.0587359257,
0.10421101,
-0.0846155658,
0.2981892824,
-0.4218617678,
-0.0841129869,
-0.7249190211,
0.3422750831,
-0.114525944,
-0.1048581973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14702v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14702v2
|
InfFeed: Influence Functions as a Feedback to Improve the Performance of Subjective Tasks
| 2024-02-22T16:59:09 | 2024-03-09T19:13:54 |
Somnath Banerjee, Maulindu Sarkar, Punyajoy Saha, Binny Mathew, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, influence functions present an apparatus for achieving
explainability for deep neural models by quantifying the perturbation of
individual train instances that might impact a test prediction. Our objectives
in this paper are twofold. First we incorporate influence functions as a
feedback into the model to improve its performance. Second, in a dataset
extension exercise, using influence functions to automatically identify data
points that have been initially `silver' annotated by some existing method and
need to be cross-checked (and corrected) by annotators to improve the model
performance. To meet these objectives, in this paper, we introduce InfFeed,
which uses influence functions to compute the influential instances for a
target instance. Toward the first objective, we adjust the label of the target
instance based on its influencer(s) label. In doing this, InfFeed outperforms
the state-of-the-art baselines (including LLMs) by a maximum macro F1-score
margin of almost 4% for hate speech classification, 3.5% for stance
classification, and 3% for irony and 2% for sarcasm detection. Toward the
second objective we show that manually re-annotating only those silver
annotated data points in the extension set that have a negative influence can
immensely improve the model performance bringing it very close to the scenario
where all the data points in the extension set have gold labels. This allows
for huge reduction of the number of data points that need to be manually
annotated since out of the silver annotated extension dataset, the influence
function scheme picks up ~1/1000 points that need manual correction.
|
[
-0.4561819434,
-0.7306225896,
0.3766875565,
0.2364267111,
-0.2456625849,
-0.3724413514,
-0.3293673992,
-0.4319659472,
0.1702730805,
0.5261772871,
-0.4345979393,
-0.3781863749,
-0.8134528995,
-0.1918145269,
-0.4562333524,
1.2469209433,
0.1143783852,
0.3759791255,
-0.5091421604,
-0.0634670928,
-0.2987700701,
-0.6623125672,
-0.6237725019,
-0.8464499712,
0.5418959856,
0.6741629243,
0.5552065969,
-0.1011764258,
0.4380045533,
0.2696413398,
-0.2572379112,
0.1576980799,
-0.6956065297,
0.019346701,
-0.1396341622,
-0.6997144222,
-0.3324215114,
-0.1270208806,
0.6620339751,
0.6697350144,
0.1866294146,
0.2220032513,
0.361120075,
0.4391580522,
-0.6080408692,
0.1886562556,
-0.4886272848,
-0.1498344392,
0.0578222573,
-0.0060302867,
-0.548325479,
-0.4693020284,
0.117451936,
-0.3831994236,
0.0227185655,
-0.3073212802,
0.6895979047,
0.5883228183,
-0.082860142,
-0.0380845293,
-0.5836271644,
0.7303671241,
-1.0259757042,
0.2047418654,
0.4909142852,
-0.0564364381,
-0.2868637741,
-0.6801034212,
-0.2566336095,
-0.4136249721,
-0.299859643,
-0.0148530127,
-0.0916562155,
0.1059439927,
0.5366131067,
0.1483491957,
0.2865731716,
0.2624889612,
-0.0594195537,
0.0578455627,
0.7771010995,
-0.057706587,
-0.1010194644,
0.0107270386,
-0.1025967002,
-0.0789034814,
-0.7367281914,
0.1527249068,
0.3445586562,
0.2650437355,
0.2452696413,
0.2777321339,
-0.3031477332,
0.6605666876,
0.4362593293,
0.1322345585,
0.5226313472,
0.0435388871,
-0.4532518685,
0.1287094206,
0.5463531017,
0.2565321326,
0.4579888284,
-0.2043886632,
-0.1359903961,
-0.2003809661,
0.1895352304,
-1.305790782,
-0.3310590982,
-0.0785332322,
-0.4328047335,
-0.3883773386,
0.2323214114,
-0.7538717985,
-0.6747265458,
-0.5300900936,
0.8085425496,
-0.438221246,
-0.3695284128,
0.0849410817,
-0.2428296506,
-0.0922609717,
0.4903879762,
-0.745691061,
0.4130819738,
0.4969786406,
0.6250004768,
0.1122967824,
-0.0430323035,
-0.5802598,
-0.1995856613,
-0.2976046503,
0.5540216565,
-0.8158755898,
-0.3315987885,
-0.1364539266,
0.0391115509,
-0.1214319095,
-0.4514003992,
0.6102201343,
-0.430865556,
-0.0055328188,
-0.5670103431,
-1.0043983459,
-0.6566100717,
0.0331525728,
-0.5506423116,
0.9701172113,
0.2092747986,
-0.6449272037,
0.5538936853,
-0.9884244204,
-0.5997411013,
-0.0271891505,
0.1438867748,
-0.4365526438,
0.1989385486,
0.2723588347,
0.4918497503,
0.0220129732,
0.1433185488,
-0.723706305,
-0.5239599943,
0.3311104774,
-0.2432021648,
0.7045273185,
-0.1819230616,
-0.726346314,
0.233728677,
-0.7403536439,
0.1761404574,
-0.471701622,
0.0643969178,
-0.4972164333,
0.0841584131,
-0.0539118312,
0.0239074659,
-0.338078618,
-0.6013048291,
-0.1295130253,
-0.38192451,
0.4240135252,
0.7132828832,
0.4892197251,
0.472779721,
-0.0698301196,
0.4509100616,
-0.0979338959,
0.2617683113,
-0.0170531124,
-0.4325098991,
-0.9046632648,
-0.2616637945,
0.7067007422,
0.2333305031,
-0.3127043545,
0.3494019806,
0.0919277519,
-0.6043153405,
-0.5852648616,
0.2465103567,
0.2389958203,
0.7426003814,
0.3923674822,
-0.3276266158,
-0.3291597962,
-0.9682813287,
-0.2638631165,
0.0333318859,
0.2187585235,
0.2594788671,
0.6043986082,
-0.1146244109,
0.7240509391,
-0.2461349368,
-0.3556709588,
0.0925570875,
0.1225123033,
0.2253174633,
0.4756928682,
0.6141318679,
-0.7405826449,
-0.4750286043,
-0.0764704496,
-0.6235654354,
-0.2413895726,
0.0281959437,
-0.20008035,
-0.2826752365,
0.7274672985,
-0.1760293692,
0.5406782031,
0.1242322922,
-0.2822517455,
0.3653905094,
0.1681369543,
0.2657536566,
-0.4464246035,
-0.1740935743,
0.2193814516,
-0.2349339426,
-0.573671937,
-0.2274328172,
0.1330647916,
0.2353582531,
-0.3385384381,
0.1705553532,
-0.1090113595,
0.3007368445,
-0.304972589,
-0.0382767208,
0.0769888684,
0.3553256392,
-0.3062143326,
0.4180055857,
0.7657167912,
-0.8158633709,
0.118935667,
0.1399170756,
-0.4039758742,
0.5242768526,
-0.8470945954,
0.3056476712,
-0.3547840416,
0.1132494137,
-1.1594082117,
-0.1697024703,
0.287764132,
-0.3299992383,
0.4842171371,
-0.508071959,
-0.4663142264,
0.0454630554,
-0.0950815827,
-0.0442333072,
0.3167306781,
-0.7630444765,
0.6102246642,
0.3366765976,
0.240679279,
-0.4316306412,
-0.9479190707,
-0.0672495142,
-0.3891995251,
-0.6169161201,
0.4592174292,
-0.0654897466,
-0.470957607,
0.1681259423,
0.3525135517,
0.0876212269,
0.0496161692,
0.6333901882,
-0.002650161,
0.0508055612,
0.6168330908,
0.1883278489,
0.1164874658,
0.3655121624,
-0.2992154062,
0.1519484967,
-0.1306965202,
-0.224839136,
-0.5313577056,
0.1387481987,
0.459607482,
-0.0462654345,
0.551460743,
0.5512250066,
-0.2832933664,
-0.4811370075,
-0.4195914567,
-0.518853128,
-0.4590567052,
0.6307252645,
-0.3902502954,
-0.7224165201,
0.3500938416,
0.0409430563,
0.09563642,
0.4856971204,
0.5361701846,
-0.0031927195,
0.9636997581,
0.7948718071,
-0.1867417693,
0.8751490116,
-0.4216344655,
-0.1511328518,
-0.8959076405,
-0.3304312229,
-0.2447766066,
-0.6020528078,
-0.5043247938,
0.0081574675,
0.2784493268,
0.02804555,
-0.1077190936,
0.1274662465,
-0.5908925533,
0.4359502494,
0.6371229291,
0.6981033087,
-0.0020904702,
-0.051381439,
0.3498064578,
-0.1488041729,
-0.719055295,
-0.107063733,
1.3304653168,
0.3872327209,
0.9239369035,
-0.2673679888,
0.5649923086,
0.4214971066,
0.8034973145,
-0.9847795367,
0.3141548038,
-0.23692137,
-0.516274333,
-0.1385612488,
-0.2307542264,
-0.4455958605,
0.2173594236,
-0.0912989527,
-0.6862750053,
0.4764425457,
0.3216317892,
-0.4402154386,
0.1833978444,
-1.1660602093,
0.5259955525,
-0.324385047,
-0.7754164934,
-0.5457419753,
-0.2756863832,
0.2404019982,
-0.0034090236,
-0.1528457701,
0.1152107641,
0.1567834169,
1.1029467583,
-0.4197304547,
1.2787460089,
-0.5744139552,
0.2403974533,
0.3599422276,
-0.0010231578,
0.5552655458,
0.1814840138,
-0.6648850441,
0.2413904816,
-0.2717877626,
-0.0301876944,
-0.9333351851,
0.8484575152,
-0.5968601108,
-0.631462276,
0.1222324893,
-0.5028107166,
-0.2962667942,
0.139435187,
0.4734745622,
0.6318792105,
-0.0542774908,
0.4863020182,
0.645766139,
0.362241894,
0.6096881032,
0.1035959572,
-0.1652151346,
-0.4679738581,
0.5402640104,
0.4672181308,
0.3496586382,
0.1000818014,
0.2323652804,
-0.3654404283,
-0.459817946,
-0.3343018591,
0.1418425143,
-0.9563740492,
-0.1568881273,
-0.4915142357,
0.0964435413,
-0.2374216765,
-0.0092647765,
-0.191203922,
-0.4612985551,
-0.487757206,
-0.3929563463,
0.566460669,
1.0361968279,
-0.1251488775,
0.5746408105,
0.0606232472,
-0.1888307184,
0.0388547517,
0.458493799,
0.0363244452,
-0.8547562957,
-0.4845882654,
0.0347402133,
-0.2927067578,
-1.0473868847,
0.0775272027,
0.3431051373,
0.6739158034,
0.6388476491,
-0.0224134661,
0.6634750366,
0.0639692321,
0.3710391819,
-0.017888533,
-1.0503331423,
0.3055564463,
0.1240572333,
0.013195524,
0.7782191038,
0.384871155,
-0.1282207668,
-0.3247382641,
-0.9263255596,
-0.5324547291,
0.6775826216,
0.2246456146,
0.1297217757,
0.3608517051,
0.6440105438,
0.1179598793,
0.3249096572,
-0.5148100853,
-0.3062976003,
-0.2336162776,
0.0600671209,
-0.1702536643,
-0.2960382998,
-0.005119069,
-0.8336109519,
1.0067507029,
-0.1226605251,
0.0394685231,
0.5317465663,
-0.0408770591,
-0.0806448013,
-0.0725375712,
0.257193625,
0.7698481083,
-0.2953233421,
0.1101886183,
0.3944844604,
-0.2671927512,
-0.0461166129,
0.1462022513,
-0.6155933142,
0.2317300439,
0.2339580059,
0.9743293524,
0.1844563186,
-0.0092141815,
0.2072684914,
0.1238702536,
-0.1971676052,
-0.2920137048,
0.3264214396,
-0.1088734418,
0.1676889956,
-0.0360933505,
0.3428373635,
0.3773364425,
-0.3235410154,
0.5241395831,
0.5282921195,
-1.0389626026,
-0.3640334904,
0.5641843677,
0.2394548953,
-0.2853319049,
0.4530699849,
-0.1356410235,
-0.8146384358,
0.7767694592,
0.507042408,
0.8927218914,
-0.080952175,
0.1446433216,
0.5710625052,
0.4626595378,
-0.0821827203,
-0.0009606311,
-0.0532091111,
-0.6664635539,
-0.560656786,
-0.2107279152,
-0.458609283,
0.2539755106,
-0.6407436728,
0.50093472,
-0.47962749,
-0.4684784114,
0.3571602404,
-0.0470597111,
-0.5569950342,
0.6237698197,
0.0245087482,
0.7532385588,
-0.767121315,
0.6376935244,
0.6798606515,
-0.401242733,
-0.7801758051,
0.1310558766,
-0.2358249426,
-0.5307306647,
0.6120712161,
0.2683364749,
-0.2593595088,
0.2175194919,
-0.8268981576,
-0.8630829453,
0.4982990324,
0.5027768612,
-0.4541771114,
0.577044785,
-0.1755873263,
0.5729191899,
-0.5856307149,
0.7442263961,
0.6432918906,
0.8138446212,
-0.041146189,
-0.4157026112,
0.0786035061,
-0.3793311715,
-0.4972422421,
0.2568022013,
-0.6750168204,
0.5605144501,
-0.4343393743,
0.3218421936,
-0.375456959,
0.6349982619,
-0.3263538778,
0.1969661266,
0.8090833426,
0.5092718601,
0.8893730044,
0.0123191802,
1.1835949421,
0.0968805254,
0.3265444636,
1.1971104145,
0.1378791928,
0.5823242664,
0.5075094104,
-0.0128380079,
0.7064395547,
0.6511336565,
-0.3725965917,
0.5910155773,
0.3677195311,
-0.0363065973,
-0.3215154707,
-0.1172916964,
-0.30244717,
0.2893175781,
0.3734584153,
-0.772973597,
-0.0557964183,
0.0460481159,
0.3487634361,
-0.1896893978,
-0.4012532532,
0.550183475,
0.1284487695,
-0.7508288026,
0.3965043724,
-0.2443833351,
0.5013341308,
-0.6693168879,
-0.1171140894,
-0.0381207466,
0.6041197181,
-0.6296768188,
-0.7369039059,
0.112606056,
-0.376901865,
-0.3548116982,
0.0606877282,
0.8449614644,
-0.3954110742,
-0.615380466,
0.6159418821,
-0.0268239062,
-0.0113464491,
-0.503729105,
-0.5869179964,
-0.1604300737,
0.371734798,
-0.4538411498,
0.1014862955,
0.1757409424,
-0.0663026497,
0.5334514976,
0.5940063,
0.0607363507,
-0.0809129998,
0.3949614465,
0.8582589626,
-0.3469800651,
-0.3627070487,
-0.9862810969,
0.4988013804,
-0.4065609872,
-0.6882197857,
0.9433264136,
0.2607220113,
0.7511737347,
0.0640558824,
0.9569073915,
-0.1283112466,
0.2846442163,
-0.1985628456,
0.7135199904,
-0.7330856323,
0.1321589202,
-0.4015819132,
-0.6960731149,
-0.3465543985,
0.3405267596,
-0.6630652547,
0.1486438513,
0.5720773935,
0.9664795399,
0.0793942288,
0.2965143025,
0.3116301596,
0.4011849761,
0.3382506967,
0.3042913973,
0.7664070129,
-0.4890235364,
0.3976643682,
-0.8905266523,
-0.4823662043,
-0.1172622293,
-0.7902287841,
-1.1651290655,
-0.3611543477,
-0.6135351062,
-0.5613074303,
-0.0159840081,
0.7373926044,
1.1739697456,
-0.91025424,
-0.0578233525,
-0.1878792197,
0.198102504,
-0.398994118,
-0.2416761816,
0.3636045456,
-0.5267548561,
-0.9164661169,
0.4379987419,
0.0009790092,
-0.3715789616,
-0.1235817149,
-0.028498482,
-0.0466404967,
-0.0110625848,
0.636634469,
-0.0885824412,
-0.2588536739,
-0.269549638,
-0.1440408081,
0.3441307247,
-0.0990539044,
0.8046411276,
-0.7995467186,
0.5434803367,
0.4466587007,
0.4239827394,
0.8510816693,
0.1212695315,
0.4089195728,
-0.5786827207,
0.2194847316,
0.3440344036,
0.3786316812,
0.4355878532,
-0.8737267256,
0.6752309799,
0.3061650395,
-0.6705224514,
-0.6706103086,
0.0647525415,
-0.6383082867,
-0.1535554379,
1.3574274778,
-0.0386943445,
-0.3131954074,
-0.1319963336,
-0.2161838412,
0.0395232439,
-0.7133185863,
0.7145808935,
0.7160736918,
-0.4966596067,
-0.0949610546,
-0.2846851349,
0.7360255718,
0.7711809874,
-0.6244646907,
-0.0762168393,
0.3661187589,
0.4049310684,
0.0652209893,
0.272641927,
-0.1437659562,
0.045962967,
-0.1047028005,
0.0116278734,
-0.2850779295,
-0.249768436,
-0.2742636204,
0.3240168691,
-0.11917945,
-0.3867807388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14701v1
|
COMPASS: Computational Mapping of Patient-Therapist Alliance Strategies with Language Modeling
| 2024-02-22T16:56:44 | 2024-02-22T16:56:44 |
Baihan Lin, Djallel Bouneffouf, Yulia Landa, Rachel Jespersen, Cheryl Corcoran, Guillermo Cecchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, q-bio.NC
|
The therapeutic working alliance is a critical factor in predicting the
success of psychotherapy treatment. Traditionally, working alliance assessment
relies on questionnaires completed by both therapists and patients. In this
paper, we present COMPASS, a novel framework to directly infer the therapeutic
working alliance from the natural language used in psychotherapy sessions. Our
approach utilizes advanced large language models to analyze transcripts of
psychotherapy sessions and compare them with distributed representations of
statements in the working alliance inventory. Analyzing a dataset of over 950
sessions covering diverse psychiatric conditions, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method in microscopically mapping patient-therapist
alignment trajectories and providing interpretability for clinical psychiatry
and in identifying emerging patterns related to the condition being treated. By
employing various neural topic modeling techniques in combination with
generative language prompting, we analyze the topical characteristics of
different psychiatric conditions and incorporate temporal modeling to capture
the evolution of topics at a turn-level resolution. This combined framework
enhances the understanding of therapeutic interactions, enabling timely
feedback for therapists regarding conversation quality and providing
interpretable insights to improve the effectiveness of psychotherapy.
|
[
-0.4014272988,
-0.5054180026,
0.7385051847,
0.1964728534,
-0.0726312995,
0.4933885336,
-0.2739009261,
-0.3619339764,
0.3922343552,
0.5363366604,
-0.6943821907,
-0.6407259703,
-0.5349569917,
-0.0551036224,
-0.2447711974,
0.698389411,
-0.0296826195,
0.678057313,
-0.2078386247,
-0.2751938999,
-0.590683639,
-0.5324409008,
-0.838490665,
-0.6377531886,
0.4103663564,
0.2213808298,
1.0247248411,
0.5586239696,
0.6110671759,
0.3726588786,
-0.0905256495,
-0.2182703316,
-0.7719765902,
0.014917355,
-0.3330248296,
-0.2824327648,
-0.6737681627,
0.1038798317,
0.7048860192,
1.2375692129,
-0.5856516361,
0.1091987938,
-0.012918002,
0.1660407335,
-0.1766381264,
-0.1476047486,
-0.3782167435,
0.2539208531,
-0.0706485361,
0.0029252053,
-0.2935014963,
-0.0540651903,
0.5573605895,
-0.4291638732,
0.4728807509,
0.3473908007,
0.8164858818,
-0.0802405402,
-0.6307650805,
0.0959998071,
-0.7703973055,
0.6872262359,
-0.7276283503,
0.4569102526,
0.297524482,
0.4942529202,
-0.3897372484,
-0.7664014101,
-0.5769658685,
-0.1382675171,
-0.494548887,
-0.1927863508,
-0.1719610989,
0.4190280735,
0.2139879912,
0.2991996706,
-0.5296044946,
0.1280883849,
-0.4595935345,
-0.1688670516,
0.5859456062,
0.6184441447,
0.5908908248,
0.0877039954,
-0.3903202116,
0.1115295142,
-0.6064699888,
-0.1676433533,
-0.258962661,
0.3555925786,
-0.242405504,
0.4756649137,
0.161385119,
0.8801382184,
0.0867413282,
-0.3372810483,
-0.1880151182,
-0.2046141326,
-0.0947583988,
0.2644449472,
0.7606185079,
0.8627668619,
-0.4641272128,
-0.5446088314,
0.1031376198,
0.1593310088,
0.2152934968,
-0.5513983965,
-0.2728191912,
0.2073879242,
-0.5672275424,
0.06297189,
-0.3036397099,
-1.1531823874,
-0.6451787949,
-0.5674465895,
-0.0221970882,
-0.1732796431,
-0.706453383,
0.1082585827,
-0.1228623018,
0.2979144752,
-0.0626904517,
-0.7360011339,
0.6276966929,
0.8872947097,
0.9406564832,
-0.4450721443,
-0.4759559929,
-0.5987152457,
0.1523605734,
-0.3447193205,
0.7303607464,
-0.598199904,
-0.3956084847,
0.0660562515,
-0.0133330394,
-0.1639512479,
-0.1872211695,
0.1742760688,
-0.4438647926,
0.464022994,
-0.113529928,
-0.6266677976,
-0.0169179495,
0.3265690207,
-0.6887054443,
0.5950503945,
0.4773781896,
-0.5570542812,
0.2463135719,
-0.8422795534,
-0.133416459,
0.2709299028,
-0.1338676512,
0.00211341,
0.0018300235,
-0.2080405205,
0.1912493706,
-0.6712437868,
0.3380157053,
-0.2615827024,
-0.0529418439,
0.6114884019,
0.1909739673,
0.5080878735,
0.0711856112,
-0.0910577476,
0.3729487658,
-0.5969837904,
0.0376321524,
-0.1162629575,
0.279569,
-0.1879256964,
-0.0906478986,
-0.002198854,
0.3898139298,
0.0431802049,
-0.5436655283,
0.0898980722,
-0.7273408771,
0.3689275682,
0.3175144792,
0.5535385013,
0.4811624885,
-0.4486860335,
0.8276335001,
-0.1540082395,
-0.0413398929,
0.2284589857,
-0.3655774593,
-0.6692963243,
-0.271602124,
0.1889998764,
0.1731060743,
-0.6978930831,
0.0091474783,
-0.3892809153,
-0.6508889198,
-0.5463049412,
-0.2733233273,
0.5212103724,
0.6544982195,
0.3618001044,
-0.5354883671,
-0.4007570744,
-0.6056593657,
-0.3537181914,
-0.0502309911,
-0.0080785034,
0.1364635527,
0.0355523191,
-0.1691519916,
1.0965707302,
-0.5277341008,
-0.1970345229,
-0.5989611149,
0.4744745493,
0.3457584977,
0.3980233073,
0.3586525023,
-0.668817997,
-0.6914092898,
-0.0157942716,
-0.3830902874,
-0.0722108334,
-0.3542736769,
-0.5289996266,
-0.1439983696,
0.3578738868,
-0.3456118405,
0.4435328245,
0.4758979678,
-0.8931280971,
0.3642092347,
-0.0645399913,
0.1179647371,
-1.0438578129,
0.0893247426,
-0.167116493,
-0.1027885005,
-0.9986091256,
-0.0670618564,
-0.4629892111,
-0.3876230717,
-0.3504455686,
0.4798341393,
-0.4528721869,
-0.1243884265,
-0.2061744779,
0.4142184854,
-0.0446110778,
0.7432408929,
0.132442072,
0.4763045013,
0.7078692913,
-0.2796952128,
0.5690418482,
0.4164910018,
0.097229898,
1.0083779097,
-0.5644209385,
0.1743280739,
0.2102323622,
0.0233629346,
-0.9235044122,
-0.102522552,
0.2160736173,
-0.3588764369,
0.1789109409,
-0.3061506748,
-0.2784373164,
-0.0204800013,
0.1709312052,
0.553001821,
0.3446133137,
-0.309145242,
0.7405814528,
0.5312003493,
-0.2642453611,
-0.0167476572,
-0.0662834644,
0.290733099,
-0.3829019964,
-0.6261721849,
0.5433242917,
0.2574583888,
-0.3922773302,
0.0469826683,
0.2305982858,
-0.2184968442,
0.0019342604,
0.3250018954,
0.590993762,
-0.2305192202,
-0.0305304881,
-0.2542497516,
-0.5373844504,
0.2660116851,
-0.08773835,
0.8151940107,
-0.2362804115,
-0.5378326178,
-0.3603018224,
0.7664901614,
0.6140322685,
-0.5167982578,
1.017044425,
0.4699703157,
-0.4600750506,
-0.0572603866,
-0.2051995993,
-0.343257159,
-0.4345774949,
0.1979515404,
-0.0227986444,
-0.7018321157,
0.4682558477,
-0.374563247,
-0.0187539365,
0.1314777434,
0.5179379582,
0.2404017746,
1.3436917067,
0.6132484078,
-0.0353164002,
0.1658050567,
-0.4304381609,
0.7897704244,
-0.9471418858,
-0.2173264623,
-0.2581636608,
-0.4986988902,
-0.4855307639,
-0.3952522278,
0.6048398614,
-0.0990844369,
-0.2547253668,
0.2146958858,
-0.6017582417,
0.1531070769,
0.1033882275,
-0.2915376127,
0.2715433538,
-0.2967627645,
-0.3779261112,
-0.6126480699,
-0.6259828806,
-0.3136823475,
0.8547998667,
0.2635747492,
0.3672777414,
0.2224780023,
0.4138738513,
-0.0339647308,
0.6360018849,
-0.6461820602,
0.6063230634,
0.5836256146,
-0.4332519174,
-0.1790055633,
-0.3013461828,
-1.0711351633,
0.6021400094,
-0.5776649117,
-1.1100714207,
0.2670802474,
-0.1729645729,
-0.5119998455,
0.1058936343,
-0.2970227301,
1.0988270044,
-0.4166915119,
-0.4197925031,
-0.3847919106,
-0.7426165342,
0.06403099,
0.1818373054,
0.1183248162,
-0.2752961516,
0.0945870951,
0.7886294127,
-0.351591289,
0.6296282411,
-0.1118400469,
0.1429627538,
-0.0882992148,
0.347741425,
0.1259180903,
-0.082938686,
-0.1030630469,
0.0001801604,
0.5172165632,
-0.242959246,
-0.9866802096,
0.5369477868,
-0.6636223197,
-0.4013165236,
-0.7711173296,
-0.381313771,
-0.6682898998,
0.4658372104,
0.0375657231,
0.6886104345,
-0.5204152465,
-0.3737504184,
0.1885890216,
0.0445800871,
-0.0554334521,
0.9898431301,
-0.5156971812,
-0.4562893212,
0.9581584334,
-0.299035579,
0.321929723,
-0.1159330606,
-0.0245648306,
-0.2179130316,
-0.6537396312,
-0.0131961573,
0.7606773973,
-0.6548649669,
-0.1936270446,
-0.239449203,
-0.1227839962,
-0.4315075576,
-0.423158884,
-0.3529880941,
-0.2429489791,
-0.141020149,
-0.1024216861,
0.150039494,
0.5800481439,
0.0459837168,
0.6378033161,
-0.7725536823,
0.2206656039,
-0.1893225461,
0.4267611504,
0.0666210577,
-0.0004184847,
-0.3487211764,
0.3446016908,
-0.4636772275,
-1.2345370054,
0.7235739827,
0.1899914145,
0.5881228447,
0.492649138,
0.115427278,
0.7573327422,
-0.2927127779,
0.9640823603,
0.4555986822,
-0.8840976357,
0.2479245365,
-0.3233219385,
-0.084079206,
0.6124998331,
0.4492185116,
-1.2176275253,
-0.325024724,
-0.774954319,
-0.8206261396,
0.7359549999,
-0.1177322045,
-0.4254291952,
0.1662923396,
0.3093035221,
-0.4335029125,
0.0606068,
-0.3914686143,
-0.0642289296,
0.1600881368,
-0.2199734449,
0.0130920736,
0.0945600644,
-0.9121445417,
-0.3471277952,
0.5289103389,
-0.1730634719,
0.6243495941,
0.1081994548,
0.0539439358,
-0.450683713,
-0.0181149431,
0.2175526321,
1.0310175419,
0.1999507099,
0.1151892841,
0.3539443016,
-0.0616237596,
0.00806183,
0.1241059005,
0.4904586077,
0.0789817572,
0.6277505159,
0.6368636489,
0.2424176335,
-0.7856516838,
0.6699466705,
-0.4031203687,
0.0021776012,
-0.2751512527,
0.1248596758,
0.1960595846,
0.3074002266,
-0.1276104897,
-0.2824109793,
0.2772164047,
-0.4138004184,
0.1891574115,
0.4184574187,
-0.7416368723,
-0.3524887562,
0.2516168356,
0.1229642481,
-0.780995369,
0.9143322706,
-0.0663371459,
-0.8037642241,
0.3795462847,
0.7014773488,
0.7324442863,
-0.0968085751,
0.3027730584,
0.2823597491,
-0.2110674679,
0.1673966646,
0.0414936393,
0.0556593724,
-0.4882867932,
-0.1639368087,
-0.4965656102,
-0.5646842122,
-0.2487964779,
-1.0273549557,
0.1899100989,
-0.2607736588,
-0.3063554764,
-0.0522705689,
0.1236688271,
-0.5718979836,
-0.3444594145,
-0.0429170802,
0.8351057172,
-0.7947262526,
0.6136146784,
0.7460778356,
-0.1276234686,
-0.9689030647,
-0.1899230182,
0.2552878559,
-0.655795753,
0.0678223148,
-0.1155967191,
-0.3275804818,
-0.163187176,
-0.3537737429,
-0.9191747308,
1.2031691074,
0.2527668774,
-0.0369261317,
-0.1283314973,
0.6568635106,
1.0600510836,
-0.7319219708,
0.0379762799,
1.0311866999,
0.3362034857,
0.4211712778,
-1.0258505344,
0.1307882667,
-0.3634703159,
0.1258680224,
0.4421821535,
-0.2287728786,
0.6024928689,
0.0841479972,
-0.5114517808,
0.2286589146,
0.5771664977,
-0.0417518616,
0.456994921,
0.4158057272,
0.4754360318,
0.7851825953,
0.037053626,
0.5807753205,
-0.7404319644,
0.2917053998,
1.1919579506,
-0.5940875411,
0.6193187833,
0.585465014,
-0.0998322219,
0.691514492,
0.439907819,
-0.1009450406,
0.498535037,
0.2498964071,
-0.4648513496,
-0.0910031945,
-0.4601633251,
-0.2862677574,
0.3767017126,
0.6604452729,
-0.2787665427,
-0.3980510831,
0.1709264666,
0.159616068,
0.2274353206,
-0.0741476044,
1.0865586996,
0.0705326572,
-1.140696764,
0.5745422244,
0.0311714318,
-0.1477638632,
-0.5286832452,
-0.3605876267,
-0.0514824502,
0.3290393651,
-0.0906390473,
-0.5076009035,
0.4114694893,
-0.2949092686,
0.2891067863,
-0.3574351072,
0.4684580564,
-0.7499457002,
-0.4593962431,
0.1891051531,
0.3739520013,
0.0741646215,
0.3361576498,
-0.6142471433,
0.0534253232,
-0.3610288799,
0.2920251489,
0.4910803139,
0.3615369797,
0.1867546737,
0.6608588099,
0.6131265759,
0.2967209816,
-0.3666707277,
-0.3483306766,
1.0080374479,
-0.4525784254,
-0.6721884012,
-0.658609271,
0.3820843697,
-0.4218492508,
-0.4615496397,
0.7348752022,
0.3569068313,
0.1400906146,
0.5235050917,
0.2572602034,
0.1066850647,
0.7662064433,
-0.2367726117,
0.7362837791,
-0.2784811854,
0.2455756813,
-0.1381631494,
-0.5563609004,
-0.3110699654,
0.6974694729,
-0.5745024085,
-0.4155151546,
0.835901618,
1.0155268908,
0.0124368453,
0.4592984319,
-0.0979124382,
0.2448939979,
0.6779711843,
0.6179294586,
0.9823985696,
0.1430578679,
0.0590179004,
-0.1359177381,
-0.3728867471,
-0.0521520227,
-0.8278264999,
-0.8500139117,
-0.7648441792,
-0.1662946492,
-0.4969089925,
-0.1036279574,
1.2326256037,
0.7156487107,
-0.4273569286,
-0.6004053354,
0.0580989271,
0.2588601112,
-0.4959474802,
-0.1821049899,
0.3380319178,
-0.1048620418,
-0.1333651692,
0.2914049327,
0.1927088052,
-0.0974453464,
-0.6842229962,
-0.2501990795,
-0.066975601,
-0.0647704452,
0.1129522026,
0.2795158029,
-0.4192104638,
-0.0274534579,
0.0685447976,
-0.089576371,
0.2025641203,
1.2080316544,
-0.667309463,
0.5383161306,
0.2183567137,
0.4817186594,
0.4169993997,
-0.0931764171,
1.2052006721,
-0.1230656877,
0.0581201687,
0.6876377463,
0.2235844433,
0.3766439259,
-0.345074147,
0.2894926369,
0.0819064826,
-0.4789302945,
-1.0312715769,
0.1257630736,
-0.8800002337,
-0.0307081677,
0.878413856,
-0.3267432451,
-0.3406166136,
-0.373559624,
-0.5091945529,
0.1613891125,
-0.0639355704,
0.8156254888,
0.6453413963,
-0.4983957708,
0.02431616,
-0.2240096033,
0.7561820149,
0.3516595066,
-0.4594314992,
0.0465254635,
0.5647234917,
0.0488531739,
0.2516631484,
0.6880354881,
0.0853903592,
0.3437233269,
-0.162632972,
-0.2710019946,
0.209014371,
-0.2229078263,
-0.1861533076,
0.1236270368,
0.1878002882,
0.1927657425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14700v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14700v3
|
Unveiling Linguistic Regions in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T16:56:13 | 2024-05-30T17:31:46 |
Zhihao Zhang, Jun Zhao, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated considerable cross-lingual
alignment and generalization ability. Current research primarily focuses on
improving LLMs' cross-lingual generalization capabilities. However, there is
still a lack of research on the intrinsic mechanisms of how LLMs achieve
cross-lingual alignment. From the perspective of region partitioning, this
paper conducts several investigations on the linguistic competence of LLMs. We
discover a core region in LLMs that corresponds to linguistic competence,
accounting for approximately 1% of the total model parameters. Removing this
core region by setting parameters to zero results in a significant performance
decrease across 30 different languages. Furthermore, this core region exhibits
significant dimensional dependence, perturbations to even a single parameter on
specific dimensions leading to a loss of linguistic competence. Moreover, we
discover that distinct monolingual regions exist for different languages, and
disruption to these specific regions substantially reduces the LLMs'
proficiency in those corresponding languages. Our research also indicates that
freezing the core linguistic region during further pre-training can mitigate
the issue of catastrophic forgetting (CF), a common phenomenon observed during
further pre-training of LLMs. Overall, exploring the LLMs' functional regions
provides insights into the foundation of their intelligence.
|
[
-0.7388455272,
-0.780231595,
0.538072288,
-0.0657959208,
-0.1858951002,
0.194768697,
-0.5844838023,
-0.1390971541,
0.1383805424,
0.7025931478,
-0.6291825771,
-0.5857436061,
-0.489174664,
-0.0321585909,
-0.1997113675,
0.7165014744,
0.084737584,
0.0870856643,
-0.2951894999,
-0.1654452235,
-0.6281693578,
-0.84497118,
-0.4014578164,
-0.6548361778,
0.3701404035,
0.5040399432,
0.350415051,
0.7884885073,
0.1835322231,
0.3164677024,
-0.3713262081,
-0.1807963252,
-0.8010774851,
0.0628961548,
-0.2589687705,
-0.7962626815,
-0.5060002208,
-0.2691007853,
0.889958322,
0.9650658369,
-0.1125036255,
-0.0840203539,
0.1107647121,
0.6856628656,
-0.472499907,
0.0115172826,
-1.0003345013,
0.0486196764,
-0.429936558,
-0.21505858,
-0.3398047388,
0.1560151279,
0.3446258605,
-0.4537844658,
0.519392252,
-0.1592022181,
0.678494513,
0.2106172144,
-0.4508271813,
-0.090266712,
-0.7415187955,
1.0612860918,
-0.6329402328,
0.4514406025,
0.3268093765,
-0.0306480732,
-0.1051110253,
-0.1020230204,
-0.3562221825,
0.1230927706,
-0.0763926581,
-0.1835115701,
-0.1221403405,
-0.0033208421,
0.2172536701,
0.3686691225,
-0.5312311649,
0.5709849596,
-0.3727508485,
-0.3549559414,
0.4126411378,
0.2452113181,
0.569362402,
0.078715533,
-0.1143453568,
0.0773832798,
-1.0559933186,
0.1212846711,
0.0197951645,
0.5033598542,
-0.1401970983,
0.5347152948,
-0.0259043593,
0.5795018673,
-0.0366638452,
-0.6236971617,
0.1855412126,
-0.3148235679,
-0.1568264067,
0.0486566238,
0.4946705699,
0.0399836376,
0.2386189997,
-0.2391900569,
-0.2299084514,
-0.2686629295,
0.023778284,
-0.3097536564,
-0.0601148345,
0.1192017496,
-0.1793211251,
0.2760246992,
-0.2958722115,
-0.3675751984,
-0.3263050616,
-0.4397258162,
0.0030816409,
-0.6456755996,
-0.3288142383,
0.067651175,
0.1651556045,
0.307818234,
0.1706910878,
-1.0596008301,
0.1905585825,
0.8181470037,
0.4875612259,
-0.2601616085,
-0.6604534388,
-0.1392256916,
0.0993005708,
-0.3430790901,
0.5910184979,
-0.5197302699,
-0.1746521592,
0.0784087628,
0.0925601199,
-0.1024893522,
-0.8274158835,
0.1189713031,
-0.6450650692,
-0.1314944029,
-0.6504365206,
-0.3409213424,
-0.4977996945,
0.4193018079,
-0.6415888667,
0.676658988,
-0.200287953,
-0.5730002522,
0.3725186288,
-0.2230333239,
-0.3712169528,
-0.1172720194,
-0.2344141603,
-0.1922050416,
0.3908443451,
0.3474332392,
0.3973115683,
-0.3623181581,
0.262090683,
-0.2008785754,
-0.1782865673,
0.3626644909,
-0.2176869214,
0.6231751442,
-0.2131574452,
-0.2021372765,
0.1120131835,
-0.4860417247,
-0.0122202486,
0.1403215528,
-0.2555073202,
-0.4825296104,
-0.0260662008,
-0.4101329148,
0.1554134339,
0.2526414692,
-0.4343589246,
0.0992408544,
-0.4089697599,
0.2622537017,
0.5557690263,
-0.0781845525,
0.824332118,
-0.1085438281,
0.6140142083,
0.2821874321,
-0.1883962154,
-0.2468113601,
-0.1324231029,
-1.0700279474,
-0.3661924303,
0.2660113871,
0.5597043633,
-0.8119063973,
0.4581476748,
-0.2823881805,
-0.5050307512,
-0.2384866625,
0.3836527765,
0.6513286829,
0.3140959442,
0.2075345814,
-0.3327699006,
-0.3092542291,
-1.2007941008,
0.1202571318,
0.1011801809,
0.0811292976,
-0.0993558317,
0.4719752967,
0.0620799884,
0.9033387303,
-0.2167268842,
-0.4589773417,
-0.5323389173,
-0.2505699694,
0.1511726528,
0.4593892097,
0.6302924752,
-0.6177372932,
-0.263169229,
0.112190038,
-0.5710279942,
-0.0718670189,
0.0918139741,
-0.0172567368,
0.3726853132,
0.5024565458,
-0.4044920206,
0.3843836784,
0.6559772491,
-0.1899729073,
0.6236811876,
-0.1947218925,
-0.0463855751,
-0.6509798765,
0.0617244281,
0.0322895721,
0.1393227279,
-0.9141925573,
0.068494536,
0.0281039719,
-0.0167520791,
-0.5061969161,
0.5130534172,
-0.8882219195,
-0.2826889157,
-0.2965947092,
0.3277028501,
-0.1465969682,
0.5465140939,
0.2190849334,
0.5680978894,
0.8222427368,
-0.7027457356,
-0.1114190668,
0.0870860294,
-0.3480327427,
0.2557595372,
-0.4697088599,
0.0911260992,
-0.23998411,
0.1476052552,
-0.8212657571,
0.0320437029,
-0.1995003968,
-0.2429816574,
0.5871700644,
-0.2935648561,
-0.3838031888,
0.0063925376,
-0.0820858181,
0.7019343376,
0.3903981447,
-0.2161891907,
0.5896552205,
0.7376343012,
-0.391708374,
-0.6354376078,
-0.8388786316,
-0.0286181699,
-0.3381734192,
-0.5438191891,
0.250903666,
0.1515705138,
-0.3318600655,
-0.0061827074,
0.0457140841,
-0.0196751747,
0.1931880713,
0.0393787064,
0.2023090571,
-0.4222736061,
0.0459206961,
0.0340172872,
-0.1489272863,
0.0158438459,
-0.1742069572,
0.9360915422,
-0.138159737,
-0.4306863546,
-0.1344574243,
0.3724874854,
0.681373179,
-0.6363276839,
0.9080842137,
0.2650736272,
-0.4747890234,
-0.3485279083,
-0.7310609221,
-0.1146404445,
-0.4261288941,
0.7831600308,
-0.4281481802,
-1.2528756857,
1.1561305523,
0.1044722348,
-0.0072043436,
0.3573392332,
0.7118561864,
0.2610637248,
0.7255907655,
0.9755997062,
-0.1761550754,
0.3213149309,
-0.2708546519,
0.4114544988,
-0.994839251,
-0.4361091256,
-0.5865250826,
-0.2960901558,
-0.3564231992,
-0.6278433204,
0.5235431194,
0.3062772751,
-0.1910745949,
0.0176847912,
-0.1591900587,
0.704590559,
0.3262909651,
-0.1702101678,
0.1512487084,
0.1508313715,
-0.3470591605,
-0.3726562262,
-0.9011580348,
-0.3842211962,
0.8170908093,
0.5420815349,
0.7082179189,
0.0924401209,
0.6237232089,
-0.2230756879,
0.2011072785,
-0.744828105,
0.6599827409,
-0.3381724358,
-0.69938308,
-0.58172369,
-0.3739582896,
-0.7471860647,
0.3208102286,
-0.1193333715,
-0.9162666798,
0.1414554864,
0.0840115175,
-0.2271502912,
0.5810647607,
-0.4358117282,
0.6602166891,
-0.4452658296,
-0.1063384712,
-0.1437497586,
-0.3454995751,
0.5655242205,
-0.3588994443,
0.2750778198,
-0.2995351553,
-0.1262755394,
0.731200695,
-0.1363482326,
1.0894474983,
-0.154476434,
-0.4506774843,
0.1390386373,
0.3152900636,
0.0433289297,
-0.1093299016,
0.0113339368,
0.2923639119,
-0.2445139736,
-0.5750928521,
-0.4971299469,
0.8368899822,
-0.706974566,
-0.7048928142,
-0.2031363249,
-0.6940629482,
-0.5271235108,
0.3157074451,
0.3418308794,
0.5524714589,
-0.2891492844,
0.1119432747,
1.1123853922,
-0.492388159,
0.4285499752,
0.5432212353,
-0.5241568685,
-0.3285476565,
0.8109083772,
0.3248046041,
0.4067282379,
0.3607358634,
-0.0254946817,
-0.2418587804,
-1.0243375301,
-0.1485951096,
0.6457548738,
-0.8715671301,
-0.0477358662,
-0.3365626633,
-0.1617698222,
-0.4565553963,
-0.3257594407,
-0.5773655772,
-0.1993994862,
-0.224550277,
-0.0918530002,
-0.2423463166,
0.7186489105,
0.0622729883,
0.2578426003,
-1.0379706621,
-0.175542742,
-0.0019201544,
0.0934423059,
0.2916553617,
-0.6540380716,
-0.3678531349,
-0.0009950555,
-0.0071592736,
-0.4726236165,
0.4800053835,
0.064253062,
0.862678051,
0.4717063308,
-0.112332575,
0.6642189622,
-0.3998783529,
0.8842598796,
0.2603312433,
-1.0157877207,
0.2846625149,
-0.3729976118,
0.7377218008,
0.3703255355,
0.4415957332,
-0.5469278097,
-0.4690862894,
-0.2123313248,
-0.9085185528,
0.5846419334,
-0.2480576783,
0.1367770582,
0.0998002216,
0.3817183971,
0.2187479436,
-0.1620924324,
-0.6713675857,
-0.3191772401,
0.2784048915,
0.2806688845,
-0.4243732691,
-0.5313085318,
-0.3474366963,
-0.2840100229,
0.6622074842,
-0.1598092914,
0.0838494226,
0.0527398475,
-0.2258894444,
-0.0303387456,
0.4186946452,
0.8784067631,
0.989657104,
0.2533213198,
0.1930643469,
0.4297454953,
-0.1867162436,
0.1788535118,
-0.3599070609,
-0.2129054666,
-0.2816884518,
0.8452217579,
0.7415423989,
0.3303309977,
-0.5744664073,
0.1360152364,
0.0447625294,
-0.1874616146,
-0.3626724184,
-0.071329847,
0.2869442701,
0.1333622187,
0.46112445,
-0.1855543107,
-0.2972751856,
-0.9109356403,
0.0741413832,
0.4359806776,
-0.4414100647,
-0.5714781284,
0.1841526628,
0.169832319,
-0.005287298,
0.7256186008,
-0.0166017637,
-1.1155216694,
0.5515547395,
0.6821842194,
0.6884353757,
-0.266690284,
0.0681759045,
0.2393704951,
0.5938811302,
0.1380536556,
0.0147681842,
0.206184715,
-1.0231221914,
-0.6705989838,
-0.6233167052,
-0.0652317107,
0.1446826607,
-0.6748722792,
0.0974170342,
-0.3569455743,
-0.123353824,
-0.2779073417,
-0.0393843167,
-0.5437424183,
0.2018520683,
0.5278372765,
0.8810169697,
-0.9252384305,
0.9101935625,
0.8371114135,
0.0797775835,
-0.8184303641,
0.0586399585,
0.2811664939,
-0.7882696986,
0.6378209591,
-0.068334192,
-0.0807364732,
-0.2151530832,
-0.2808129787,
-0.9266902208,
1.01790905,
0.519086957,
-0.489551425,
-0.0486604609,
0.5302568674,
0.5657734871,
-0.5353640318,
-0.0466414094,
0.8427715898,
0.2743640542,
-0.0640920326,
-1.254863143,
0.0732715279,
-0.0385731012,
0.0343874805,
0.4262085259,
-0.60477072,
0.9733030796,
-0.215972811,
-0.298751235,
-0.1773625314,
0.5129031539,
0.2712410092,
0.0823738426,
0.4910930395,
0.6707910299,
0.6890943646,
-0.2522069514,
0.7138258815,
-0.231354475,
0.2637974918,
0.9290959239,
-0.2963692546,
0.8025396466,
0.503531158,
0.1185846701,
0.1908217669,
0.4520475566,
0.4053439498,
0.4688072801,
0.25025931,
-0.308161974,
-0.4904015064,
-0.2396852672,
-0.1849166453,
0.5979269743,
0.6029384732,
-0.1458534896,
-0.2149959654,
0.2025716603,
0.3046175838,
0.0418656766,
-0.483494252,
0.6521165371,
0.097212173,
-0.7654421926,
0.710254252,
0.0309493653,
0.6393347979,
-0.6682834625,
0.2735365629,
-0.4686145782,
0.2372911274,
-0.1861306131,
-0.7460308671,
0.2667082548,
-0.1517357528,
-0.2863060832,
-0.1571349204,
0.6567794085,
-0.6802806854,
-0.2080148906,
0.5487513542,
0.6525859833,
0.0047389856,
0.0590720288,
-0.4850020707,
0.453099072,
0.236897245,
-0.1956723481,
0.6964893937,
0.6841065884,
-0.0172166824,
0.8101962805,
0.4797336161,
0.1582947522,
0.2166857123,
-0.1028075442,
0.9007989168,
-0.6758957505,
-0.346729517,
-0.7666377425,
0.547850728,
0.2129470259,
-0.3041373491,
0.7114223838,
0.5217990279,
1.1086442471,
-0.1046352312,
0.6998181343,
-0.0287139751,
0.3479260504,
-0.8935526013,
0.885074079,
-0.6369960308,
0.543099463,
0.0164524894,
-1.0052376986,
-0.3945105374,
0.091258198,
-0.5370339155,
0.0636217073,
0.8805360198,
0.7659930587,
-0.0040635695,
-0.3776369393,
0.7292365432,
0.3425781429,
0.2793769836,
0.5609416962,
0.7338480949,
0.0816411152,
0.3342613876,
-0.6223885417,
-0.3358901441,
0.1262149066,
-0.6612593532,
-1.1412975788,
-0.760708034,
-0.2306160331,
-0.0809843764,
-0.2624874413,
0.5002231598,
0.635353148,
-0.7893869877,
-0.4931704104,
0.4640217721,
0.1006106287,
0.1713317335,
-0.1722496599,
0.2268830985,
-0.1936682463,
-0.5494009256,
0.5184941888,
0.4038009048,
-0.0253217332,
-0.5816075802,
-0.0864417702,
-0.1880331486,
-0.1048020124,
0.4939687252,
0.3986534178,
-0.9217638373,
-0.2325520217,
0.0745395049,
-0.0938947648,
-0.016391933,
1.1017626524,
-0.4172049165,
0.1266290545,
0.5086667538,
0.5239571333,
0.2186735272,
-0.151906088,
0.7361667156,
-0.6695199609,
0.2085541338,
0.2683784068,
0.5309073329,
0.3645450175,
-0.0809255913,
0.171857819,
0.1659190506,
-0.5826037526,
-0.7375812531,
0.2328993827,
-0.8661667109,
-0.2150837779,
0.9680843353,
-0.2550391555,
-0.4390839338,
-0.1260398775,
0.0509558432,
0.0194078889,
-0.062428914,
0.4908369184,
0.9423172474,
-0.0889467672,
-0.2745162845,
-0.3443487287,
0.2640759945,
0.6649108529,
-0.5284302831,
0.3550344706,
0.4507738054,
0.5604251623,
0.3913368285,
0.6606054902,
-0.1923601627,
0.0692984685,
-0.0726488903,
0.2016058862,
0.1439995468,
-0.5097842813,
-0.5984181166,
0.3154839277,
0.2143387496,
0.3136462271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14690v1
|
UFO: a Unified and Flexible Framework for Evaluating Factuality of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T16:45:32 | 2024-02-22T16:45:32 |
Zhaoheng Huang, Zhicheng Dou, Yutao Zhu, Ji-rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) may generate text that lacks consistency with
human knowledge, leading to factual inaccuracies or \textit{hallucination}.
Existing research for evaluating the factuality of LLMs involves extracting
fact claims using an LLM and verifying them against a predefined fact source.
However, these evaluation metrics are task-specific, and not scalable, and the
substitutability of fact sources in different tasks is under-explored. To
address these challenges, we categorize four available fact sources:
human-written evidence, reference documents, search engine results, and LLM
knowledge, along with five text generation tasks containing six representative
datasets. Then, we propose \texttt{UFO}, an LLM-based unified and flexible
evaluation framework to verify facts against plug-and-play fact sources. We
implement five evaluation scenarios based on this framework. Experimental
results show that for most QA tasks, human-written evidence and reference
documents are crucial, and they can substitute for each other in
retrieval-augmented QA tasks. In news fact generation tasks, search engine
results and LLM knowledge are essential. Our dataset and code are available at
\url{https://github.com/WaldenRUC/UFO}.
|
[
-0.0957812369,
-0.9961807132,
0.9869990945,
0.0897436887,
-0.0883673802,
-0.0824589506,
-0.3888474107,
-0.2363296002,
-0.0412308089,
0.5695589781,
-0.4393225312,
-0.5806578398,
-0.2638150752,
0.2798135281,
-0.5436108112,
0.9750660658,
0.3295200765,
-0.1983501762,
-0.6246271729,
-0.142908141,
-0.1441675872,
-0.4976600111,
-0.1559365839,
-0.1142868847,
0.5857486725,
0.4913272262,
0.8519659638,
0.6348032951,
0.6121460199,
0.3458070457,
0.0695948377,
0.492365092,
-0.5375031233,
-0.0167834628,
-0.40095222,
-0.3343036473,
-0.3656956851,
0.007048524,
0.8023682833,
0.67858392,
-0.2926048338,
0.2835413516,
-0.1958967894,
0.5140609741,
-0.6155777574,
-0.0523888059,
-0.7098081112,
-0.0462773219,
-0.2381573021,
-0.0274256058,
-0.4448295832,
-0.513305366,
0.0600930341,
-0.548327446,
0.3554321229,
0.2594408393,
0.8278318048,
0.3030846417,
-0.6110925674,
-0.414540261,
-0.8167136312,
0.6650540233,
-0.930213809,
0.7227522135,
0.2017521113,
0.0622036196,
-0.3780609071,
-0.7064787745,
-0.9716237783,
-0.7407544851,
-0.1463229507,
-0.0703493655,
-0.0275182649,
-0.1104707271,
0.4056332409,
0.4525321126,
-0.5984585881,
-0.0152070932,
-0.2695637643,
-0.2817252576,
0.583681047,
0.165616706,
0.4103283882,
-0.456278801,
-0.3252908885,
0.1606502533,
-0.905172348,
-0.1241262481,
0.3373957872,
0.2846411467,
-0.0976169109,
0.8430007696,
-0.2875801623,
0.540373981,
-0.0562437437,
-0.4440507889,
0.2645130754,
-0.4757015705,
-0.3284988105,
-0.2639979422,
0.9759497643,
0.1676125973,
-0.3246367872,
-0.5427865982,
-0.1351210922,
-0.0428177156,
0.4400712848,
-0.6711707115,
0.213395521,
0.3275234699,
-0.1839869469,
-0.1973590404,
0.3975457847,
-0.7904636264,
-0.4620621502,
-0.3420345783,
0.3387548029,
-0.2130507827,
-0.3658278584,
0.0957764313,
0.0172452796,
0.0687498823,
0.2625196576,
-0.5466589332,
0.0637551397,
0.7090396285,
0.6701081991,
-0.313950032,
-0.3858099282,
-0.7035443187,
-0.0429360531,
-0.3682369292,
0.8877034783,
-0.3134366572,
-0.3084170222,
0.0883272812,
-0.069947809,
0.0799624026,
-0.4503403902,
0.9777883291,
-0.5259934664,
0.369979322,
-0.5015121102,
-0.5664601326,
-0.2513773143,
0.3612954021,
-0.783176899,
1.1333887577,
0.0988198593,
-0.7115556002,
0.3806118667,
-0.6849682331,
-0.5248321891,
0.1489479691,
-0.4162937701,
-0.4457441568,
0.0812545717,
-0.095071055,
0.5542982817,
-0.6741022468,
0.6903293729,
-0.2904657125,
-0.2954674363,
0.3955869973,
-0.4806120694,
0.6827212572,
0.2245938182,
-0.5507454276,
0.1621048152,
-1.0497274399,
-0.1975528598,
0.0058551324,
-0.852656126,
-0.1617616117,
0.2494474649,
0.1262815297,
-0.0441947989,
0.0973368585,
-0.735979259,
0.1587512046,
-0.1572571695,
0.0566929989,
0.4317486286,
-0.1483313143,
0.0342645161,
-0.2737265527,
0.2412654608,
0.0157864839,
0.0602010489,
-0.0618140846,
-0.2600769997,
-1.0248943567,
-0.2279220372,
0.1570131779,
0.4016191959,
-0.7231961489,
0.6481980085,
-0.4585672915,
-0.5092034936,
-0.1567225605,
0.2584679425,
0.4491761923,
0.6141263843,
0.1803197861,
0.2380816042,
-0.7528572083,
-0.8082951903,
-0.2797720432,
-0.3471117318,
-0.0944775119,
0.102658987,
0.443197161,
-0.5502240062,
1.1398199797,
-0.2544528842,
-0.1861242205,
-0.1698281765,
0.2949755788,
0.2283971161,
0.2011469305,
0.4104475677,
-0.9324894547,
-0.0068285987,
0.1442819089,
-0.9796817303,
-0.0303233024,
-0.2293164432,
0.25382635,
0.4601084888,
0.4321783781,
-0.669827342,
0.2965401113,
0.5284003019,
-0.6216946244,
0.7651435137,
-0.0597207248,
0.3657540977,
-0.9613249302,
0.3641347587,
-0.0128221335,
-0.3924391866,
-0.4379947782,
0.2312238663,
-0.0208520144,
0.242848739,
-0.3596794307,
0.412909925,
-0.3714386523,
-0.1148162559,
-0.2484747171,
0.2004519701,
0.0246505365,
0.3273529708,
-0.062979795,
0.7384704351,
0.2760477066,
-0.7883855104,
0.5522102118,
0.0646900609,
-0.7100977898,
0.4262560904,
-0.4526610672,
0.1790522933,
-0.0225382764,
-0.0315298811,
-0.678160131,
-0.3282615244,
0.1072484627,
-0.2182514518,
-0.1663134545,
0.1863016784,
-0.6709368229,
-0.2217424661,
-0.1815645248,
0.0716449395,
0.3254520297,
-0.6012044549,
0.8884732723,
0.3579802811,
-0.0116947927,
-0.7587273717,
-0.448430866,
0.3103734553,
-0.063079223,
-0.4756357968,
0.079207167,
-0.3400454819,
-0.4788864255,
0.2545161843,
-0.1517087817,
0.0313729234,
0.1545640379,
0.3973668814,
0.287746191,
-0.5372870564,
0.0586389974,
-0.1588165313,
0.2735156119,
0.193749994,
-0.080810383,
0.1057509035,
-0.3447637856,
-0.5886932015,
-0.176643163,
0.0891524181,
0.764164567,
0.1132208407,
0.6052610278,
0.5931304097,
-0.3636450469,
-0.3268116713,
-1.0186291933,
0.0887157768,
-0.4173413813,
0.5871818662,
-0.2823474407,
-0.92688483,
0.4260954857,
-0.0703792796,
0.2326812148,
0.6516734958,
0.7148342133,
0.1560291499,
0.4280025065,
0.6251835227,
0.172599256,
-0.0712713078,
-0.0073786709,
0.1791025996,
-0.596232295,
-0.5070911646,
-0.5973596573,
0.3246107399,
-0.2260679603,
-0.5443027616,
0.3478138149,
-0.0441278853,
0.034982875,
0.1146823019,
0.0328373238,
0.5840862989,
0.3692500591,
-0.092384778,
0.6834387183,
-0.0659120008,
-0.2850324214,
0.2490317672,
-0.6505231857,
-0.6833549738,
1.2208888531,
0.2539961338,
0.458670646,
0.3526967168,
0.1299820244,
0.6744161844,
0.6525703073,
-0.7832576036,
0.623136282,
-0.0961206406,
-0.7621331215,
-0.4995929301,
-0.6045381427,
-0.6271796823,
0.2755604386,
-0.5832730532,
-0.5109034777,
0.1075729653,
-0.0427597277,
-0.4209251106,
0.383185178,
-0.4726680219,
0.6152942181,
-0.2107094675,
-0.3692826927,
-0.2208606005,
-0.2362421453,
0.621663332,
-0.372777611,
0.4466898441,
-0.1599300504,
0.0794949085,
0.5444128513,
-0.381170243,
0.74814713,
0.1408942044,
-0.388097167,
0.3530212939,
0.1140317395,
0.3923530877,
0.3622218966,
-0.3179083169,
0.4402460754,
-0.1214540303,
0.0063381302,
-0.6771534681,
0.6806781888,
-0.6896545291,
-0.718999505,
-0.4983223975,
-0.6220232844,
-0.2837386429,
0.4494913816,
0.2332009822,
0.4536528885,
-0.7538482547,
0.4003898799,
0.5543699265,
-0.0731017515,
0.1734366566,
0.879560709,
-0.4119341671,
-0.2411266863,
0.9377582669,
-0.1543277949,
-0.0762517005,
0.4999068379,
0.3563013375,
-0.4857442677,
-0.6286216378,
-0.5556602478,
0.1729965955,
-0.7056698203,
-0.2629961669,
-0.6139028668,
-0.1393059194,
-0.3672472835,
0.2263343185,
-0.441700846,
-0.1977727562,
-0.0950242132,
-0.2198012918,
0.2042472959,
1.1334149837,
-0.1697683781,
0.0214728005,
-0.7917040586,
0.6947436929,
0.3698547781,
0.4513651431,
-0.2602279186,
-0.4417194128,
-0.3448300958,
0.0995582342,
-0.0840446576,
-0.5779553652,
-0.1086587459,
0.0820335522,
0.5738196373,
0.5713461637,
0.1324858963,
0.3783302605,
-0.5452268124,
0.8253756166,
0.1706439108,
-1.1140795946,
0.1717306823,
-0.3646883667,
-0.2104384005,
0.4352103174,
0.2042864561,
-0.5101087689,
-0.3708479106,
-0.5141658783,
-0.5873225331,
0.6475870609,
0.2986118197,
-0.017185539,
0.0618946552,
0.5429594517,
0.3034966588,
0.1497255564,
-0.8842794895,
-0.2445268035,
-0.2636697292,
-0.233535096,
-0.0684825405,
-0.5444483757,
-0.253246814,
0.01065276,
0.6692780256,
-0.190623492,
-0.0772008747,
0.3427532613,
-0.2125949562,
-0.1793916076,
0.4620127976,
0.6673502326,
1.004249692,
-0.3060193062,
0.2783701718,
0.1012572199,
-0.5357179046,
0.2051082999,
-0.0794680044,
-0.4329217672,
0.11646346,
0.5320515037,
0.6189410686,
0.2928369939,
-0.9530259371,
0.5547038913,
-0.0334095396,
-0.267141372,
-0.3106420338,
0.2645597756,
0.076200217,
0.2017225027,
0.5297232866,
-0.0435339399,
0.2452278733,
-0.5789228678,
0.3295965493,
0.4354426563,
0.0254373625,
-0.4865839481,
0.517354846,
0.3254827857,
-0.1424946934,
0.5667001009,
-0.3307046294,
-0.3182509542,
0.4983828366,
0.4563114643,
0.8753027916,
-0.0606648624,
0.4636121392,
0.3339334726,
0.5355837345,
-0.2005667984,
0.1806081086,
0.1931792945,
-0.8016475439,
-0.6039071083,
-0.6967939138,
-0.5684766173,
0.6085974574,
-0.4262799621,
0.2106333375,
-0.4834667444,
0.0340209529,
0.0247333571,
-0.0988741964,
-0.6216617227,
0.2875768244,
0.0869676769,
0.7502523065,
-0.701289475,
0.6718444824,
0.7784455419,
-0.3676477671,
-0.7230681777,
0.2598584592,
0.1835951209,
-0.4876124263,
0.7040791512,
-0.0404190235,
-0.4174369872,
-0.3285056651,
-0.4796456397,
-0.845120132,
0.8182311654,
0.6704816818,
-0.60258919,
0.0319129154,
0.4199648798,
0.442992419,
-0.379096061,
0.1826389134,
0.4803940058,
0.6775070429,
0.1013887897,
-0.8335767388,
0.3572246432,
-0.2344104499,
-0.1352553517,
-0.344860971,
-0.6116480827,
0.6873981357,
-0.4894694984,
-0.4820069373,
0.1285688728,
0.9068843126,
0.286136508,
0.2669960856,
0.6759001613,
0.4939523339,
0.9292262197,
0.0038755827,
0.9246013165,
-0.0328813121,
0.4188209474,
0.9934754372,
-0.3246540129,
0.7633850574,
0.3083336651,
-0.2625649869,
0.6781445742,
0.2431701124,
-0.1839580238,
0.0320781916,
0.0592871681,
-0.0571729764,
-0.3659746945,
-0.1260447502,
-0.1360668838,
0.6514229178,
0.2081325501,
0.1148085222,
-0.2530092895,
-0.2032710612,
0.116148755,
0.1857267022,
-0.0114827361,
0.5877719522,
-0.1769809425,
-0.7907015681,
0.5866166949,
0.1374645233,
0.6103459001,
-0.6322489381,
-0.1464450657,
-0.2602133155,
0.0561773814,
-0.4547143877,
-0.5703741908,
0.3265735805,
0.325448066,
-0.4294132292,
0.2810446322,
0.4272348583,
-0.4028610587,
-0.7035270929,
-0.0542998873,
0.504147172,
0.0884857178,
-0.1248278469,
-0.4702065885,
0.2797528505,
0.112345539,
-0.4479714334,
0.0652513877,
0.6090919375,
0.1074291319,
0.6852098703,
0.9850586057,
0.1151646674,
-0.0811788291,
0.0427120738,
0.8162767291,
-0.7402960658,
-0.319901377,
-0.896081984,
0.4870759547,
0.0039912206,
-0.2359274328,
1.0362643003,
0.7925943732,
0.5830346346,
-0.0845618099,
0.9583224058,
-0.2214331776,
0.6732742786,
-0.7219908834,
0.7460368276,
-0.6098203063,
0.44133991,
-0.2455014437,
-0.9033250213,
-0.2298537195,
0.4267494082,
0.1774457693,
-0.0694148839,
0.9173313975,
0.6910586357,
-0.2296303511,
0.0579278991,
0.4265293479,
0.4814339578,
0.3688732088,
0.0992282033,
0.9845045805,
-0.2213876992,
0.5564251542,
0.0273269117,
-0.0973110273,
-0.3160324991,
-1.2301350832,
-0.9658650756,
-0.7207539082,
-0.4594846964,
-0.4292472601,
-0.1163306683,
0.7818781734,
0.6357927322,
-0.7856963277,
-0.2270715535,
0.0172591452,
0.5117928386,
-0.0623141229,
-0.2563658953,
0.5810162425,
-0.3320222795,
-0.6734601855,
0.6520229578,
0.2839857042,
-0.1822296679,
-0.5177426934,
-0.1385612935,
-0.11449451,
0.1671175808,
0.6408711076,
0.3816100359,
-1.0076345205,
-0.3315148354,
-0.0086004036,
-0.1209405735,
-0.1521683782,
0.958445549,
-0.6984542012,
0.1626347303,
0.2452437282,
0.7782208323,
-0.0373636112,
-0.0119722448,
0.4856610298,
-0.6822772622,
0.0703606084,
0.0044945898,
0.3707356453,
0.4518060088,
-0.6119761467,
0.5349717736,
0.4673813581,
-0.4783329964,
-1.0346642733,
0.1596054733,
-1.0823969841,
-0.2967406213,
1.4434235096,
-0.2399148792,
-0.2113431394,
-0.3197771609,
0.0232016128,
0.0783956423,
-0.2676906586,
1.023712039,
0.6114504337,
0.1083170325,
0.1959731728,
-0.361735791,
0.5895286202,
0.1916911453,
-1.0781757832,
0.3622088432,
0.8247920871,
0.546997726,
0.4324007928,
0.5202693343,
0.0159578882,
0.3128950298,
-0.1051204875,
0.2035756111,
-0.4420057535,
-0.4358160198,
0.0596483313,
0.2260481417,
0.0310337394,
0.2233543694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14895v1
|
Data Augmentation is Dead, Long Live Data Augmentation
| 2024-02-22T16:42:37 | 2024-02-22T16:42:37 |
Frédéric Piedboeuf, Philippe Langlais
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Textual data augmentation (DA) is a prolific field of study where novel
techniques to create artificial data are regularly proposed, and that has
demonstrated great efficiency on small data settings, at least for text
classification tasks. In this paper, we challenge those results, showing that
classical data augmentation is simply a way of performing better fine-tuning,
and that spending more time fine-tuning before applying data augmentation
negates its effect. This is a significant contribution as it answers several
questions that were left open in recent years, namely~: which DA technique
performs best (all of them as long as they generate data close enough to the
training set as to not impair training) and why did DA show positive results
(facilitates training of network). We furthermore show that zero and few-shot
data generation via conversational agents such as ChatGPT or LLama2 can
increase performances, concluding that this form of data augmentation does
still work, even if classical methods do not.
|
[
-0.4361712337,
-1.1925560236,
0.4749617279,
-0.1792404652,
-0.3257972002,
0.1201546863,
-0.2871695757,
-0.9003955722,
0.1294422001,
0.3646925092,
-0.5785266757,
-0.158470124,
-0.2698643506,
0.3032854497,
-0.5170270801,
1.1931004524,
0.2845883965,
-0.1871670187,
-0.5193671584,
-0.0986360833,
-0.5203024149,
-0.585200727,
-0.9755355716,
-0.5131298304,
0.477727443,
0.4841734767,
0.9336066246,
0.8819658756,
0.4728830159,
0.3279240429,
-0.1738006622,
0.8140141368,
-0.6632632017,
0.2548402846,
0.3070600331,
-0.6088178158,
-0.3805484474,
-0.0119024785,
0.5084581375,
0.952160418,
0.2997598946,
-0.2953428924,
0.0291756224,
1.0761688948,
-0.4563111663,
-0.0250292048,
-0.5415056348,
-0.117144607,
-0.2386972457,
-0.4865137041,
-0.350809902,
-0.4734339118,
0.0983937383,
-0.6635010839,
0.1968236864,
-0.131379962,
0.799212873,
0.5925573707,
-0.422114104,
-0.2989665568,
-1.1029999256,
0.6549323201,
-0.6924678683,
-0.0617958941,
0.4304661155,
0.4252567589,
-0.2611564398,
-0.6445951462,
-0.8775270581,
-0.2483266294,
0.05241438,
0.0083161201,
-0.1783110797,
0.1523061991,
0.5085788369,
0.7192791104,
-0.2504710555,
0.33860448,
-0.5640028119,
0.0832640454,
0.8649837375,
0.159235552,
0.0755473226,
0.114836067,
-0.1917176247,
-0.1346057355,
-0.6794000268,
-0.1965871006,
0.5560464859,
0.1381174773,
0.0568243116,
0.691126883,
-0.4790960252,
0.7497888803,
0.2116623968,
-0.0506967008,
0.2854640186,
-0.3122467995,
-0.2208996266,
0.1922583729,
0.7629569173,
0.4225176275,
0.3707169592,
-0.2486041337,
-0.0712762624,
0.3583560288,
0.1861850172,
-0.8001740575,
-0.1807730496,
0.3108606339,
-0.0371104777,
-0.5421895385,
-0.0634023473,
-0.439432025,
-0.4064595401,
-0.348352313,
0.2661703229,
-0.4727069438,
0.0876258984,
0.1467163712,
-0.0472377427,
0.1645442396,
0.670707345,
-0.9676678181,
0.2861769795,
0.8116634488,
0.7524324059,
-0.1344790906,
-0.06149856,
-0.4700461626,
-0.1704563349,
-0.8259149194,
1.0044603348,
-0.5490091443,
-0.3375754058,
-0.1527508795,
0.0086317593,
0.1955016851,
-0.500447154,
0.5810688138,
-0.5648679733,
0.5143747926,
-0.1596357673,
-0.8041263819,
-0.144759953,
0.161774531,
-0.6254202127,
1.0620675087,
-0.0895073339,
-0.6864106655,
0.6683577895,
-0.592831254,
-0.5603578687,
-0.0013938742,
-0.0730331391,
-0.6462824941,
-0.004953824,
0.209935233,
0.4757655263,
-0.1394108236,
-0.0789610073,
-0.3488713205,
-0.5940498114,
0.4491952956,
-0.7216632366,
0.3699470162,
0.1955416054,
-0.2830591202,
-0.5354803205,
-0.8573256135,
-0.0692338198,
-0.099551402,
-0.4197556376,
-0.4465053976,
0.1596708149,
-0.1962911338,
-0.0376877747,
-0.0039102691,
-0.7451441884,
0.39910537,
-0.8258060813,
0.2310205698,
0.6675360203,
0.0301795639,
0.5317560434,
-0.7891197205,
0.3317901194,
0.0008346694,
-0.3345571458,
-0.5396205187,
-0.4381972849,
-0.8374534845,
0.0055193482,
0.6905211806,
0.4069909155,
-1.0918616056,
0.544442296,
-0.5701794028,
-0.6190659404,
-0.4369872212,
0.0165864956,
-0.1447027028,
0.6379340291,
0.3494991958,
-0.1730412841,
-0.3480181098,
-0.8645823002,
0.0110867983,
-0.1793015003,
0.0288786478,
0.2686290443,
0.2291949242,
-0.3059592545,
0.9537321329,
-0.3172471225,
-0.1012713313,
-0.1347201616,
0.0510492958,
0.0455365144,
0.5772371292,
0.5148321986,
-0.6729758978,
-0.287266165,
0.3490331173,
-0.9886459112,
-0.0004212318,
-0.602887392,
0.3571313322,
0.3952671885,
0.184792906,
-0.4054255188,
0.5080637336,
0.166127488,
0.1004674211,
0.1602834463,
-0.3691438735,
0.3610079587,
-0.8140165806,
-0.0252080299,
-0.0336581022,
-0.4524408579,
-0.9265112877,
-0.2404361516,
0.044555001,
-0.1966093928,
-0.172217235,
0.4266214073,
-0.258964628,
0.1428043991,
-0.8371341825,
0.1057432741,
-0.0790661946,
0.2800883055,
-0.0870594084,
0.7421337962,
0.6579432487,
-0.9695877433,
0.631064713,
0.3540337086,
-0.1445862502,
0.6693453193,
-0.7422173619,
0.4222669899,
-0.493317306,
0.3752539158,
-0.9531013966,
-0.3327128887,
0.2238894552,
-0.6621192098,
0.2743103206,
-0.0250750575,
-0.5543087125,
-0.3277538717,
-0.4939268231,
0.3181717098,
0.5959445834,
-0.536873877,
0.0091161886,
0.2660599351,
0.0485211946,
-0.3652054071,
-1.0623284578,
0.3027916849,
-0.3425804973,
-0.8368415236,
0.2589426041,
0.0717942566,
-0.2132860571,
-0.17108275,
-0.0597747341,
-0.1638022512,
0.1707764864,
0.0777944401,
0.185506776,
-0.0435946696,
0.4892420173,
0.2990744412,
-0.4033973515,
-0.2257623076,
-0.1162047163,
0.2601429522,
0.3135689795,
-0.4033305347,
-0.5894001722,
0.1328290105,
0.3718940914,
0.1137025133,
0.6044065356,
0.5985274315,
-0.3055853546,
-0.0710035563,
-0.549403131,
-0.2434342951,
-0.5031911135,
0.0242583975,
-0.129620865,
-0.7688099146,
0.1813722551,
-0.1168370023,
0.2231633812,
0.4196093082,
0.2643675208,
-0.2919959128,
0.9499918222,
0.6262984872,
-0.1117820889,
0.5851129293,
-0.4155803919,
0.0237316489,
-0.4438451827,
0.0300435517,
-0.4677248001,
-0.5045216084,
-0.9652785063,
-0.0189872961,
0.532045722,
-0.151681006,
0.2877348363,
0.1273278892,
-0.6284297705,
0.4121944606,
0.2562128901,
0.4766485691,
0.3894968331,
0.2587634921,
0.8185407519,
-0.0171312783,
-0.6295543909,
-0.5855461955,
1.2076689005,
0.3780670762,
0.8705040216,
-0.2634927034,
0.564763844,
0.516066432,
-0.0902187303,
-0.8288286328,
0.4446876645,
-0.0529088154,
-0.4435561299,
-0.3213798404,
-0.5368076563,
-1.2274180651,
-0.1594823003,
-0.3744233251,
-0.3798086643,
0.4698191583,
0.265753001,
-0.2679420412,
0.1912746876,
-0.8532910347,
0.4636433125,
-0.0288802572,
-0.52920717,
-0.254770577,
-0.5901594758,
0.2328785062,
-0.2782483995,
0.033073891,
0.0833108649,
-0.2297435403,
0.8100143671,
-0.7894744277,
0.5908652544,
-0.1608111262,
-0.0879791528,
0.3836119473,
-0.2582068145,
0.6897785664,
-0.11891222,
-0.186205864,
-0.2190086991,
-0.0543882139,
-0.6776702404,
-0.9236095548,
0.6478900313,
-0.53745538,
-0.21081613,
-0.3866922259,
-0.3624897301,
-0.1933728904,
-0.0815244392,
0.058099281,
0.5937901735,
-0.0142548047,
0.5009291172,
0.634683609,
-0.0225631781,
0.5150341392,
0.0886243507,
0.1644796133,
-0.2596141696,
1.1211811304,
0.2503965795,
0.4153262079,
0.2545613945,
-0.0264201183,
-0.2048999816,
-0.687987268,
-0.6121196151,
0.0267033093,
-0.3710986674,
-0.0134888375,
-0.5196558237,
-0.0883486196,
-0.1503966749,
-0.0112276869,
-0.2868107855,
-0.686771214,
-0.4073776305,
-0.0865809694,
0.7002776265,
0.6946545243,
-0.1142690107,
0.421184212,
-0.6224957108,
0.3314858079,
0.3681404591,
0.0553877614,
-0.2924000919,
-0.3227708042,
-0.4529598355,
0.6377109289,
-0.4186864197,
-0.6545718908,
0.099811241,
0.5014203191,
0.2592031658,
0.3542103171,
0.0991203785,
0.776022017,
-0.2614552677,
0.776399374,
-0.1421965361,
-0.4362597466,
0.5408963561,
-0.3676351011,
0.2246268839,
0.7221499085,
0.3042475879,
-0.4806360006,
-0.2021337748,
-0.7170128226,
-0.6621387601,
0.7328696251,
0.4239392281,
0.580914259,
0.1401426792,
0.5971853137,
0.3213736117,
0.2821432948,
-0.5169375539,
-0.4804985225,
-0.0177714825,
-0.022398131,
-0.0604973473,
0.018751381,
0.2229626179,
-0.2859597206,
0.5163757205,
-0.3212623298,
0.3685484231,
0.352758497,
0.0280732736,
-0.2386394739,
0.2253908813,
0.3860522807,
0.6055364609,
0.0458533913,
-0.1004961058,
0.2720912397,
-0.436080426,
0.2468539476,
0.2842538059,
-0.5018447638,
-0.0009208176,
0.3295269012,
0.9675120711,
-0.107416369,
-0.4450691342,
0.3127390742,
0.140887782,
-0.2872865796,
-0.0465037525,
0.3838153481,
-0.453558147,
0.0697364509,
0.610871613,
0.1919261366,
0.0497106649,
-0.6774163246,
0.2415538728,
0.4399568439,
-0.2439556867,
-0.1286363751,
0.5619515181,
0.0207409598,
-0.1558247358,
0.1978936791,
-0.1765057892,
-0.0472244583,
0.4216491878,
0.3130156994,
0.5860052705,
0.1721767634,
0.2245827764,
0.0810528323,
0.2171954364,
-0.0481374711,
0.0012811823,
-0.3338398039,
-0.4324221313,
-0.53278929,
-0.2580040097,
-0.4992646277,
0.1291619241,
-0.2961339653,
0.3163647056,
-0.2709326148,
-0.0311059225,
0.2751751244,
0.3030590415,
-0.3510603607,
0.4071469307,
-0.0452972017,
0.6875309944,
-0.644097507,
0.6528867483,
0.6059131622,
-0.2473253459,
-0.1786247641,
0.0406325385,
-0.201211229,
-0.4436200261,
0.2381180674,
0.2010751516,
0.1135357097,
0.2085736394,
-0.7719647884,
-0.4414387941,
0.9791716933,
0.2591693103,
-0.3697674572,
-0.126047194,
0.3469692469,
0.9232642055,
-0.0087546911,
0.4395163357,
0.5152639151,
0.4486825764,
0.1857554317,
-0.8025833964,
-0.2716059387,
-0.2742295265,
-0.0673079565,
0.0618924201,
-0.5172939301,
0.5306931138,
-0.0135386763,
-0.5314263701,
0.1891642958,
0.7052285075,
-0.2760764956,
0.5220533013,
0.4975372553,
0.6527466774,
0.7774666548,
-0.305403322,
1.241855979,
-0.0235196259,
0.1413505673,
0.4867746234,
0.0200453028,
0.4505717456,
0.1493327022,
-0.3735551238,
0.2956705391,
0.9491987824,
-0.0276734382,
0.4091507792,
-0.095118694,
-0.2702806294,
-0.0956426188,
-0.0750972405,
-0.5973204374,
0.3772949278,
0.2011720538,
-0.0898051113,
-0.232065469,
0.2022051364,
-0.0257053897,
0.1491995901,
-0.0921078622,
1.1622259617,
-0.1315840036,
-0.5054607987,
1.0265638828,
-0.1127975136,
0.7444281578,
-0.3612093031,
0.0278939195,
-0.2716074288,
0.0587889925,
-0.3927161694,
-0.7259986997,
0.4068028033,
-0.0711523294,
-0.0499977246,
0.0348103307,
0.878197968,
-0.3531316221,
-0.3170336485,
-0.3883356154,
0.5702245235,
0.3744708002,
-0.1256847084,
-0.3724410236,
-0.1034531668,
-0.0810488313,
0.0025686102,
0.2582192123,
0.6836252809,
0.0918828398,
0.7658345699,
0.9619192481,
0.2092019767,
-0.0880286843,
-0.3445948362,
1.1917389631,
-0.4374776483,
-0.4775025547,
-0.9170333743,
0.4488976002,
-0.3502599001,
-0.2370829135,
0.7772095203,
0.6860058904,
0.8391647935,
0.2708373666,
0.8280023932,
0.0386743732,
0.5821262002,
-0.5598540306,
0.3353866339,
-0.5422238708,
0.406108886,
-0.4035716355,
-0.8877113461,
-0.1529355049,
0.2508234382,
-0.6126606464,
0.2015736848,
0.5375893712,
0.7566751838,
-0.1047831327,
0.2843333781,
0.2938782871,
-0.0405502506,
0.3028419018,
0.3574377596,
0.912504375,
-0.8802272081,
0.4262830615,
-0.4929733574,
-0.2231581062,
-0.1439304054,
-0.4967902303,
-0.8582231998,
-0.5884859562,
-0.2867067456,
-0.1625405252,
0.2615285516,
0.7863065004,
0.6575639248,
-0.5117117763,
0.1159298271,
-0.3601408899,
0.1502114534,
-0.063612543,
-0.2142523825,
0.251060009,
-0.5299119949,
-0.980102241,
0.5210762024,
0.1505544335,
0.3699587584,
-0.1346888244,
-0.0616262592,
0.0318310894,
-0.1576568037,
0.5520605445,
0.5079870224,
-0.2358520329,
-0.2225068659,
-0.0926463902,
-0.0998634025,
0.2972929776,
0.6098543406,
-1.1944518089,
0.677573204,
0.4174316823,
1.1460766792,
0.5813608766,
0.3863202333,
0.5473921299,
-0.7067527175,
0.1585698277,
0.1715926826,
-0.1667560935,
0.4560360909,
-0.4779453576,
0.4906738997,
0.3790281415,
-0.77071172,
-0.9236237407,
-0.1514707059,
-0.931312263,
-0.018874092,
1.0322166681,
0.3269453943,
-0.326541543,
-0.2269205004,
-0.5866667032,
0.1436799616,
-0.5397110581,
0.9037999511,
0.3605968356,
-0.3027429879,
-0.0090794126,
-0.5391612649,
0.7228933573,
0.248334229,
-1.272163868,
-0.0362006538,
0.7276192307,
-0.2134733796,
0.2253421694,
0.59418571,
0.134512499,
0.4317082763,
-0.0639425218,
-0.5231140852,
-0.3569975197,
-0.1540794522,
-0.4006519914,
0.0508631244,
0.0043158224,
-0.5042757392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14679v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14679v1
|
Is Cognition and Action Consistent or Not: Investigating Large Language Model's Personality
| 2024-02-22T16:32:08 | 2024-02-22T16:32:08 |
Yiming Ai, Zhiwei He, Ziyin Zhang, Wenhong Zhu, Hongkun Hao, Kai Yu, Lingjun Chen, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
In this study, we investigate the reliability of Large Language Models (LLMs)
in professing human-like personality traits through responses to personality
questionnaires. Our goal is to evaluate the consistency between LLMs' professed
personality inclinations and their actual "behavior", examining the extent to
which these models can emulate human-like personality patterns. Through a
comprehensive analysis of LLM outputs against established human benchmarks, we
seek to understand the cognition-action divergence in LLMs and propose
hypotheses for the observed results based on psychological theories and
metrics.
|
[
-0.108173199,
-1.0639361143,
0.948060751,
0.3692823648,
0.1360144168,
-0.0649996027,
-0.4886166155,
-0.3725051284,
0.4937525988,
0.663814187,
-0.6317765713,
-0.2332535535,
-0.6872149706,
0.0274560619,
-0.5974055529,
0.5598837733,
-0.0008523597,
0.2233030498,
-0.2621652484,
-0.2728743255,
-0.5444047451,
-0.5969363451,
-1.1019352674,
-0.5232212543,
0.6231844425,
0.188534677,
0.579434216,
0.3231905103,
0.6571448445,
0.3335699737,
0.0187761467,
-0.0329400301,
-0.4938751161,
0.1192669049,
-0.4592146277,
-0.3839179277,
-0.5194666386,
0.2119644433,
0.8335092664,
0.713023901,
-0.4155018032,
0.0234003346,
0.1585084349,
0.5375363827,
-0.5112639666,
0.1084501892,
-0.2489312887,
-0.2273971438,
-0.2062129527,
0.2105721533,
-0.611456871,
-0.3718266785,
0.1559169441,
-0.1962577254,
0.0410998836,
0.2267807275,
0.6761294603,
0.0268095154,
-0.5885854959,
-0.3312517107,
-0.9859566092,
0.9804242253,
-0.9048460126,
0.382635951,
0.6979541779,
0.0897523239,
-0.268895328,
-0.3409752548,
-0.9040032029,
-0.4640014768,
-0.0926856548,
0.0117078749,
0.146185711,
-0.1509881467,
0.302266717,
0.3691726625,
-0.568811059,
0.2808052301,
0.0095393071,
0.0137839345,
0.9512206912,
0.5513478518,
0.300291568,
-0.010405561,
-0.0737328157,
-0.1263921708,
-0.6893405914,
0.0227696486,
0.4965987504,
-0.1721556038,
-0.2884643078,
0.7304657698,
-0.1097057834,
0.4572173655,
0.055598598,
-0.3764745593,
0.0390067697,
-0.2272922844,
-0.3884094059,
-0.1756285429,
0.9316340089,
0.4396283329,
0.7771171331,
-0.136324212,
-0.026975546,
0.0098627619,
0.5465797186,
-0.4793211818,
-0.1033120602,
0.4067482948,
-0.356602937,
-0.0897626281,
0.1478387564,
-0.5086208582,
-0.5668702722,
-0.368011415,
0.1793789268,
-0.496650964,
-0.6464856267,
0.110517256,
0.1289704144,
0.5008407831,
0.2671922743,
-1.0985916853,
0.2980628014,
0.8684388399,
0.5048906803,
-0.6274333,
-0.5762919188,
-0.2717100978,
0.1605191231,
-0.5499260426,
0.6469460726,
-0.5252659321,
-0.4645705521,
0.2198367566,
0.174223125,
-0.2258850187,
-0.523670435,
0.6635627747,
-0.4206546247,
-0.0901147425,
-0.6775766015,
-0.975998044,
-0.1295981258,
0.7390676141,
-0.5904732347,
0.9220546484,
0.0504855104,
-0.500279963,
0.3310527802,
-0.4684480429,
-0.2458682358,
-0.0871762335,
-0.5506672859,
-0.0963608176,
0.1552934945,
-0.4971309602,
0.4587458074,
-0.2282643914,
0.342299521,
-0.6417299509,
-0.4302190244,
0.8912094831,
-0.3319686949,
0.7587343454,
-0.2459841073,
-0.2136513889,
0.020867059,
-0.5166047215,
0.0347969122,
0.3419835269,
-0.4187094569,
-0.1468358934,
0.4474023879,
-0.1496166885,
0.3134750724,
0.4155947864,
-0.8775502443,
0.504514575,
0.0223609246,
0.2805753946,
0.6451392174,
0.0237359777,
0.2749140859,
-0.4529103041,
0.2025538683,
-0.1024159268,
0.0766681358,
0.3033741713,
-0.4246961474,
-0.8183882236,
-0.2102928162,
-0.1180704162,
0.4138047993,
-0.0448785461,
0.7329208851,
-0.4276076853,
-0.5386105776,
-0.070244737,
0.2173242569,
0.4616836309,
0.4033409357,
-0.0798279047,
-0.5540320873,
-0.5734847188,
-0.8633586764,
-0.3642933071,
-0.4198130667,
-0.0395460539,
0.4563934207,
0.4304564297,
-0.381573379,
0.8437917233,
-0.386490494,
0.1242790669,
-0.495545119,
0.1541061103,
0.0061331517,
0.3772484064,
0.7483271956,
-0.5885868073,
-0.484452188,
-0.3908715248,
-1.0214172602,
0.1238312051,
0.3135864735,
-0.0007108679,
0.2836304903,
0.6765399575,
-0.7364436984,
0.4299674034,
0.6870574355,
-0.4448888004,
0.6690639853,
-0.0820449963,
0.1075384766,
-0.9331703186,
0.1435232162,
0.1566886008,
0.0265455041,
-0.8516221642,
-0.1071308702,
-0.0024787125,
0.4670024812,
-0.3562394381,
0.792404294,
-0.0653726533,
-0.2885327339,
-0.3299358189,
-0.0261078309,
-0.0948371738,
0.4046136439,
0.4078478813,
0.4702796042,
0.6470461488,
-0.8096722364,
0.2732456625,
0.1549788862,
-0.4136600196,
1.037602067,
-0.7071300745,
0.3127057552,
-0.1151531041,
0.1479457468,
-1.0910158157,
-0.5575302839,
-0.0676110089,
-0.1927688867,
0.2826871872,
0.1052822918,
-0.751981914,
-0.311345011,
-0.2533225119,
-0.0267109312,
0.5524660349,
-0.1428243369,
0.8673114181,
0.0299525578,
-0.1495578289,
-0.2747661471,
-0.7885872722,
-0.1897584051,
-0.1027611941,
-0.480753243,
-0.0525872931,
-0.4526748657,
-0.7468556762,
-0.5038833022,
0.0218777843,
0.0156811923,
0.1071407199,
0.2576214373,
0.319689393,
-0.2200903744,
-0.130553782,
-0.4810397625,
0.4978886247,
0.3327376544,
0.197885409,
0.7983984351,
-0.0368635058,
-0.6556053758,
-0.5501059294,
0.1654030979,
0.9221316576,
0.0585834011,
0.7723389864,
0.3524802327,
-0.1051524505,
0.2469428778,
-0.6440984607,
-0.2203748226,
-0.4565432072,
0.2724640965,
-0.1259591877,
-0.8195247054,
0.6443204284,
0.0741148293,
0.1540813595,
0.2139945775,
0.6090758443,
-0.6448908448,
1.0034815073,
0.7321044803,
-0.0453798771,
0.541958034,
-0.0347779505,
0.1776974946,
-1.1801737547,
-0.3392259181,
-0.286010921,
-0.6418996453,
-0.6406754255,
0.0731491446,
-0.095782347,
0.0352514759,
-0.6688913703,
0.0373034142,
0.042040322,
0.2380364239,
0.2356711775,
-0.2197320163,
0.1556412876,
-0.1694352776,
-0.0154810483,
-0.069164671,
-0.1432418227,
-0.7154186964,
1.1622128487,
0.2959877253,
0.8802896142,
0.6793116927,
0.5014915466,
0.281606555,
0.5596613288,
-0.7972409129,
0.7489100099,
-0.0079217441,
-0.689701438,
-0.5251964331,
-0.2200088799,
-1.0230263472,
-0.0889334008,
-0.3003217876,
-1.3527601957,
0.0456697606,
0.065040417,
0.0273030251,
0.2686079443,
-0.510033071,
0.6504611373,
-0.3412940204,
-0.212907657,
-0.136678949,
-0.5137336254,
0.515976429,
-0.0823550224,
-0.1009080112,
-0.297028482,
0.019471325,
0.6439226866,
-0.0824043974,
1.0079394579,
0.1974315047,
-0.342410475,
0.2656386793,
0.402236253,
0.6130548716,
-0.0564205572,
-0.0567352064,
0.1655853838,
-0.2698019147,
-0.4874788523,
-0.7809593081,
0.8474962115,
-0.8644604087,
-0.6606642008,
-0.3608525395,
-0.5464677811,
-0.5094311833,
0.1261535585,
0.0099440031,
0.1603255719,
-0.6989468336,
0.1369472444,
0.9269428253,
0.1164646372,
0.7018381953,
1.1057883501,
-0.5277248621,
-0.1472025514,
0.5280771852,
-0.0948074684,
0.3917802572,
0.2535568774,
0.1235739663,
-0.2310836017,
-0.4168929458,
-0.2979899943,
0.5629640818,
-0.4179825187,
0.3871842027,
-0.4008359015,
-0.2551532388,
-0.4593426883,
-0.0679075196,
-0.5934141874,
0.0926920325,
-0.0027633463,
0.0960795283,
0.3222005069,
1.2161113024,
0.5339243412,
0.2901318371,
-0.7226302028,
-0.0295425244,
0.4478015006,
0.2434722334,
0.0980830863,
-0.6962119341,
0.0571517497,
-0.0639081001,
-0.5049453378,
-0.7588661313,
0.0388413146,
0.1253503859,
0.6049532294,
0.9299744964,
-0.4731420875,
0.0797584504,
-0.2661589384,
1.0669945478,
0.2009446919,
-0.8640781045,
0.2623880804,
-0.4417383969,
0.3159653246,
0.3916089237,
0.5361582637,
-0.7123701572,
-0.4853559136,
-0.9344883561,
-0.2252693176,
0.4841508567,
0.1912483722,
0.1445785165,
-0.1797368079,
0.5401994586,
-0.3082815111,
0.2171196043,
-0.4364927411,
-0.3170714676,
-0.0105451476,
-0.1922727823,
-0.3537992239,
-0.2862739861,
-0.2503363192,
-0.1391295344,
0.2083017677,
-0.167535603,
0.0373552106,
-0.1323495954,
0.1881152838,
-0.0734495595,
0.3358725607,
0.931055367,
0.8057221174,
-0.281401664,
0.2094632387,
0.1434921026,
-0.8084245324,
0.2233597338,
-0.5161943436,
-0.0546253398,
-0.206634149,
0.5624626875,
0.4319573343,
0.3183839321,
-0.9103754163,
0.6750123501,
-0.0806586742,
-0.1628057659,
-0.5706295371,
0.3912702203,
0.6226449609,
0.2709717453,
0.1013987064,
-0.1217167601,
-0.2211410701,
-1.0437412262,
-0.1377715468,
0.5043092966,
-0.3143012822,
-0.4241611063,
0.176183939,
-0.0388273932,
-0.5568236113,
0.9902933836,
-0.1392855644,
-0.2757505774,
0.6033115387,
0.4376471341,
0.8795608878,
-0.3445320427,
-0.0757475272,
0.2409086972,
0.2237056047,
-0.4912308156,
0.6551871896,
0.3113278151,
-1.0035433769,
-0.5990900397,
-0.6188751459,
-0.6074393392,
0.3565844893,
-0.8509253263,
0.1350204647,
-0.5512380004,
-0.2919242382,
-0.0823773667,
-0.0116005428,
-0.4509894252,
0.3147168756,
0.0715832338,
0.8778484464,
-0.7957362533,
1.1617614031,
0.8458634019,
-0.326743722,
-1.0048825741,
0.1464194953,
-0.0647609979,
-0.6879031658,
0.7492340207,
-0.143549189,
-0.0306439083,
-0.2695484757,
-0.8070561886,
-1.1316757202,
1.2415314913,
0.4322624505,
-0.6255109906,
0.0522724167,
0.1095942035,
0.6041091681,
-0.4126721323,
0.0871370062,
0.8198632002,
0.6207335591,
0.1650430858,
-1.0422272682,
-0.1622229367,
0.0476509407,
0.0839730427,
0.2161291242,
-1.0582295656,
0.9018505216,
-0.1673081219,
0.0700982139,
0.2484135032,
0.7791016698,
0.5654073954,
0.1325362325,
0.2374545038,
0.8105358481,
0.8634261489,
0.0208789036,
1.2274813652,
-0.2368350774,
0.4102682173,
1.0710704327,
-0.7551048994,
1.152790904,
0.3767738044,
-0.2581002116,
0.9013961554,
0.293444097,
-0.0050783237,
0.2395982593,
0.0699141994,
-0.1037092432,
-0.334720403,
0.0275196005,
0.3028319478,
0.8096008301,
0.3485891819,
-0.4510728717,
0.2224295437,
-0.3321906328,
0.2254831493,
-0.0057364372,
-0.3884904683,
0.6339104772,
0.1450813711,
-0.9175711274,
0.3491221666,
-0.1158548221,
0.6504950523,
-0.6893140078,
0.1418792456,
-0.3453673124,
0.1178952977,
-0.1356001198,
-1.1126728058,
0.3623646498,
-0.0219015498,
-0.3534657657,
0.036579676,
0.4951556027,
-0.1825686395,
-0.125159964,
0.1682205945,
0.5235294104,
0.4399455488,
0.1450330764,
-0.5147943497,
0.2713868916,
-0.2176915556,
-0.2829873264,
0.5449049473,
0.1249784827,
-0.0998384729,
0.7878401875,
0.2787767053,
0.040118888,
-0.0822673142,
0.0903984532,
0.2965111434,
-0.727268517,
0.0928300098,
-1.071745038,
0.2411110252,
-0.1796528399,
-0.5399752855,
0.9432905912,
0.4925025702,
0.5552569628,
-0.0455991253,
0.5891933441,
-0.0820531771,
0.3111373186,
-0.4774312377,
0.5040956736,
-0.2051249743,
0.0542704873,
-0.1590542495,
-1.1371599436,
0.2254172713,
0.49883762,
-0.4190323949,
0.3854267001,
0.9253050685,
0.5452822447,
-0.0072872494,
0.0551647581,
0.5076487064,
0.3332840502,
0.0764110908,
0.4709399045,
0.8673983812,
-0.022792751,
-0.0509551093,
0.3046635985,
-0.1484966874,
-0.3127927184,
-0.927349925,
-0.8342121243,
-0.2503559887,
-0.396510303,
-0.4336992204,
-0.3881345391,
0.692266047,
0.5369939804,
-0.6442946792,
-0.49324736,
-0.1365332156,
-0.0439658277,
-0.3580549359,
-0.2691639662,
0.2006810009,
-0.029823985,
-0.9007468224,
0.1663754582,
0.3953939378,
0.1539409459,
-0.879325211,
-0.3002412617,
-0.1529700458,
0.6749061942,
0.576754272,
0.5374417305,
-0.9935184121,
-0.5125379562,
0.2846124172,
-0.5189173818,
-0.0818858147,
0.9021895528,
-0.1753396541,
0.006886445,
0.3833566308,
0.2211244106,
0.26395908,
-0.1250790656,
0.5203040838,
-0.6870879531,
-0.119008705,
0.1814640909,
0.5622003675,
0.5264444351,
-0.2103821933,
0.4821481109,
0.189329803,
-0.7871944904,
-0.368965596,
0.5252829194,
-1.360461235,
0.0145332776,
1.5173454285,
-0.3667607605,
-0.274402827,
0.0349246189,
-0.0139969531,
-0.1096905991,
-0.1741150767,
0.8331980109,
1.1485805511,
-0.6210762262,
-0.1238454729,
-0.5456871986,
0.3563892245,
0.2692082524,
-0.5929663777,
0.1649226695,
0.3191717863,
0.6704606414,
0.454100728,
0.5778903365,
0.06712538,
0.127508983,
-0.1687622368,
0.1716179699,
0.5636762977,
-0.0150705446,
-0.0647501349,
-0.1128294021,
0.4989696443,
0.3053538501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14672v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14672v1
|
Middleware for LLMs: Tools Are Instrumental for Language Agents in Complex Environments
| 2024-02-22T16:18:07 | 2024-02-22T16:18:07 |
Yu Gu, Yiheng Shu, Hao Yu, Xiao Liu, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang, Jayanth Srinivasa, Hugo Latapie, Yu Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The applications of large language models (LLMs) have expanded well beyond
the confines of text processing, signaling a new era where LLMs are envisioned
as generalist language agents capable of operating within complex real-world
environments. These environments are often highly expansive, making it
impossible for the LLM to process them within its short-term memory. Motivated
by recent research on extending the capabilities of LLMs with tools, this paper
investigates the intriguing potential of tools to augment LLMs in handling such
complexity. To this end, we design customized tools to aid in the proactive
exploration within these massive environments. Such tools can serve as a
middleware layer shielding the LLM from environmental complexity. In two
representative complex environments -- knowledge bases (KBs) and databases --
we demonstrate the significant potential of augmenting language agents with
tools in complex environments. Notably, equipped with these tools, GPT-4
achieves 2.8X the performance of the best baseline in tasks requiring access to
database content and 2.2X in KB tasks. Our findings illuminate the path for
advancing language agents in complex real-world applications.
|
[
-0.5712693334,
-0.932741642,
0.9359309673,
0.1517998576,
0.0700738877,
0.5313556194,
-0.3510608077,
-0.5958527923,
-0.0500591472,
0.5726428628,
-0.6889392734,
-0.6417554021,
-0.3966243565,
-0.0559181422,
-0.1510685831,
0.8546364307,
0.1117469147,
-0.4195336401,
-0.2840473354,
0.0237046853,
-0.4707235992,
-0.6245543361,
-0.3429761529,
-0.5254843831,
0.5231566429,
0.667707026,
1.1458383799,
0.4169411659,
0.4192738831,
0.3940024078,
0.1287396252,
0.1148200557,
-0.3059751391,
0.4241646826,
-0.4415730536,
-0.6596106291,
-0.8253188729,
-0.0535640158,
0.3792097569,
0.5393855572,
-0.2175705731,
0.1489914656,
-0.2172592133,
0.5826157331,
-0.4970015287,
0.2167331725,
-0.3642406762,
-0.0057737757,
-0.4784950912,
-0.1141696125,
0.0329390243,
0.0088018579,
0.249829784,
-0.7554996014,
0.0334255621,
0.2690531909,
0.5666535497,
0.1581296176,
-0.2362838686,
-0.3789112568,
-1.0639278889,
0.776019156,
-0.5580773354,
0.3852520287,
0.1581782699,
0.5695994496,
-0.4273462296,
-0.7284985781,
-0.646594286,
-0.3626398742,
-0.0123032862,
-0.0231900513,
-0.3144121766,
0.2421446145,
0.2455622107,
0.2317185104,
-0.5240961313,
0.3593468964,
-0.0735182539,
-0.2666527331,
0.3125545084,
0.3548566103,
0.7484188676,
0.1253999174,
0.070659481,
0.0708187521,
-0.9260017872,
-0.061485,
0.4857995808,
0.2106262296,
0.1046430171,
0.55198282,
-0.0879119262,
0.8169379234,
-0.4027522504,
-0.0892523155,
-0.0280987639,
-0.1833112389,
-0.258262068,
-0.1958812624,
0.33514449,
0.17764844,
0.1267986745,
-0.4975765944,
-0.5100923181,
-0.0534715764,
0.1410708278,
-0.5709475279,
-0.2998575866,
0.4113871753,
0.0223326534,
-0.1732425988,
-0.2821894586,
-0.5410291553,
-0.2807694972,
-0.4113623798,
0.4121179879,
-0.1868658662,
-0.455743134,
0.1600239724,
-0.1750293225,
0.1789198071,
0.4465735257,
-0.7727978826,
0.7531621456,
0.7831058502,
0.8953438401,
-0.1038686559,
-0.1211979613,
-0.4882119298,
0.4547205865,
-0.2463143766,
0.9580536485,
-0.8792293668,
-0.4285342991,
-0.1282360554,
0.0888416916,
0.5295485258,
-0.7190200686,
0.4657551944,
-0.9565172195,
0.2514967322,
-0.4976436198,
-0.350449115,
-0.0678054765,
0.4690292776,
-0.8962765336,
0.9890469313,
0.3630355,
-0.4347828925,
0.0416016281,
-0.9501702785,
-0.396484673,
0.1689828336,
-0.1580639929,
-0.2183006257,
-0.1162078232,
0.1832460314,
0.4091854692,
-0.5979871154,
-0.0265111104,
-0.4023888707,
-0.6195661426,
0.1602909565,
-0.0705990642,
0.3887206316,
0.1980445385,
-0.4444283247,
0.0625208616,
-0.4477431774,
-0.0967341661,
0.1298072934,
-0.5723611712,
-0.5008183718,
-0.078931421,
0.2060342282,
0.2215502262,
0.3701337874,
-0.3910416961,
0.5229633451,
-0.4182036519,
0.2757659853,
0.8519517183,
-0.2310787141,
0.7569919825,
-0.2420526296,
0.7926498652,
-0.1030561253,
0.0601898208,
0.0720071718,
-0.2806265056,
-0.6776137948,
-0.2576181591,
-0.0018783672,
0.6492113471,
-0.7097537518,
0.4440888166,
-0.3531450927,
-0.572968483,
-0.3996070921,
0.2936196923,
0.3859812319,
0.1420107335,
0.3861507177,
-0.1763804257,
-0.579765141,
-0.9948154688,
-0.3926132321,
0.1460862309,
-0.2433617413,
0.5315439105,
0.2274174392,
-0.6792455912,
1.0425566435,
-0.5128778219,
-0.154882893,
-0.2843501568,
-0.3452888131,
0.402857244,
0.3574910462,
0.4771153331,
-0.8391473293,
-0.2701051533,
0.2160031945,
-0.6789907813,
-0.4179030061,
0.0550660938,
-0.1277430803,
-0.1596776098,
0.6101567745,
-0.8668691516,
-0.3458758593,
0.5920752287,
-0.2233748436,
0.8452306986,
-0.2299126387,
-0.1608382761,
-0.7504000664,
0.1298640221,
-0.1315459609,
-0.4547348022,
-0.9278948903,
0.0751533359,
-0.1579038054,
0.036151804,
-0.1979727149,
0.8140241504,
-0.8449373245,
-0.4778442681,
-0.3220359385,
0.5025427938,
-0.0492823459,
0.2607682049,
-0.2592073977,
0.9894822836,
0.5863649845,
-0.5308997631,
0.649217248,
-0.0897079259,
-0.1044249237,
0.3578422964,
-0.5014182329,
0.3212166131,
0.0532570258,
0.1763890684,
-0.6721431017,
-0.2842895687,
0.1534237564,
-0.0077614947,
0.2965719402,
-0.1617519706,
-0.7302536964,
-0.2322855294,
-0.2122181207,
0.065952301,
0.470241338,
-0.3494609594,
0.8423165679,
0.6068277359,
-0.5333253145,
-0.6123833656,
-0.6158213019,
0.553958118,
-0.1626344472,
-0.5453053713,
0.223199293,
-0.0709841773,
-0.5799450278,
0.2475593388,
-0.2662476301,
0.0989906043,
0.1477066278,
0.3372585475,
0.2924376726,
-0.1712517738,
0.1651364714,
0.1332910657,
-0.154361248,
0.1685023457,
-0.6052593589,
0.5067879558,
-0.6311429739,
-0.4356728494,
0.1366530359,
0.2373756766,
0.6505346298,
-0.1176662073,
0.3520238996,
0.5334433317,
-0.3663211465,
-0.3324835598,
-0.8065497279,
0.0032121234,
-0.6239006519,
0.5362099409,
-0.6171575785,
-1.1383320093,
0.5110887885,
-0.4599331617,
0.069130756,
0.1241183579,
0.6862090826,
-0.0259975605,
0.7523564696,
0.7047992945,
-0.2774146497,
0.5686973929,
-0.2439063489,
0.1382128298,
-0.8782522678,
-0.1366104782,
-0.2079265267,
-0.3331590295,
-0.3810065091,
-0.4314100146,
0.3953309059,
-0.07764709,
-0.2468395531,
0.1309553981,
-0.4094365537,
0.7395662069,
0.5381779075,
0.0502973981,
0.4748621285,
-0.0238059852,
-0.0770247057,
0.1224473342,
-0.7056452036,
-0.8254806399,
0.8886809349,
0.3216008246,
0.7956987023,
0.4278395772,
0.3953597248,
0.4331444502,
0.5561736822,
-0.4771022499,
0.705881536,
0.0297944546,
-0.6047375798,
-0.5008691549,
-0.129659608,
-0.9292734861,
0.3020051122,
-0.0870743245,
-0.518327117,
0.0169713628,
0.1025813445,
-0.3414410353,
0.2373520285,
-0.7631269693,
0.6423105597,
-0.2723070681,
-0.5006036162,
-0.2876852453,
-0.6726613641,
0.320012778,
-0.1252014339,
0.372323513,
-0.1097017303,
-0.3868245184,
0.3712974489,
-0.2247864455,
0.784420073,
-0.4677055776,
-0.2331822366,
0.1950720549,
0.4195729196,
0.7941042185,
-0.0357787572,
0.0681114793,
-0.1576965153,
-0.1513537616,
-0.4987451732,
-0.6933633089,
0.961334765,
-0.8225587606,
-0.934490025,
-0.2431282699,
-0.7198182344,
-0.4287177324,
0.4482102394,
-0.2959977686,
0.1027555093,
-0.154992789,
-0.0361300968,
0.7738182545,
-0.2266203165,
0.1350908726,
0.7310292721,
-0.1780460924,
0.1698904634,
0.7927849293,
0.2630615234,
0.2588517964,
0.3814019263,
0.0985175967,
-0.3017764688,
-0.7350301743,
-0.2861285806,
-0.0391083322,
-0.7485207319,
-0.0363640226,
-0.7679550052,
0.1405826956,
-0.1073666438,
-0.2643522322,
-0.1306260377,
-0.4160262346,
-0.0714636892,
-0.3476910591,
0.3417119086,
0.6621630788,
-0.0754734576,
0.4079720974,
-0.9797487259,
0.1778791547,
0.4839147031,
0.3506575823,
-0.0574099682,
-0.0249460656,
-0.4499709606,
-0.1358975321,
0.0279547255,
-0.554751277,
0.1817282438,
0.1000236869,
0.7787992954,
0.0949375033,
-0.3053498268,
0.4868940711,
-0.4593121111,
0.6410322785,
-0.291716367,
-0.7278091908,
0.3550494909,
-0.5875005126,
0.3026864231,
0.1348247826,
0.2579908371,
-0.6063460708,
-0.4864342809,
-0.4710394144,
-0.8521856666,
0.4839518368,
0.1481788158,
0.0058126156,
0.5310896635,
0.5194907188,
-0.0356439874,
0.2475704551,
-0.5032939911,
0.1796060205,
0.0715635344,
-0.0354501531,
-0.2513378561,
-0.1190357655,
-0.4245167077,
0.2350526154,
0.416467756,
-0.0609072559,
-0.0294103399,
0.1812739521,
-0.3808759749,
-0.0419253223,
0.6746779084,
0.2818274796,
0.422786504,
-0.1632911712,
0.4228929281,
0.2627649903,
-0.5576254725,
0.2519674003,
0.1475658715,
0.0859282538,
-0.2745184004,
0.4466344714,
0.3498269022,
0.1489352435,
-0.9891946912,
0.3504833579,
0.0284485091,
0.2843791246,
-0.2946047187,
0.4063749909,
0.5039177537,
0.6114513278,
0.2400203198,
0.0195077974,
0.4675777256,
-0.7710665464,
0.1501393914,
0.335938096,
-0.2565790117,
-0.5723454952,
0.3857589364,
0.2137019485,
-0.2964564562,
0.4341255724,
-0.3098228574,
-0.4666699767,
0.380539,
0.4970312417,
0.7932906747,
-0.0732767507,
-0.3515951931,
-0.3621985614,
0.569205761,
0.0341552086,
0.3011207283,
-0.1139285043,
-0.7879111171,
-0.4518566728,
-0.4450027645,
-0.6570312977,
-0.0860276893,
-0.0737603456,
-0.1193745136,
-0.3703458011,
-0.1315553039,
-0.2346466184,
0.2102510631,
-0.8023130298,
0.0892857686,
0.0685531944,
0.9597429633,
-0.776203692,
0.924400866,
0.9804410338,
-0.2061240673,
-0.5100978613,
-0.1470205933,
0.1769615412,
-0.7239848971,
0.4908850491,
-0.0751585513,
-0.5776036978,
-0.024146568,
-0.5990147591,
-0.7196474075,
1.3011753559,
0.413629055,
-0.8158848882,
-0.1555184722,
0.2171480805,
0.7558778524,
-0.1385023594,
0.0058547216,
0.9081433415,
0.7975075245,
-0.3226133585,
-0.6590964198,
0.3957194388,
-0.3944584429,
0.0122089321,
0.1290573627,
-0.4436246753,
0.6823839545,
-0.2394203246,
-0.2475454509,
-0.2242039293,
0.3688466847,
0.4499661624,
0.1620077491,
0.6939352751,
0.3025679588,
0.699480772,
-0.1019528136,
1.0878590345,
-0.2053446919,
0.0235252846,
1.0139294863,
-0.4257084131,
0.4896322787,
0.4366190135,
-0.3052909672,
0.6465374231,
0.6153125763,
0.0969377831,
0.4031926095,
0.1555186659,
-0.5835285187,
-0.2359227836,
-0.0587673746,
-0.0560337454,
-0.0367199667,
0.8384215832,
0.3832038045,
-0.1459876001,
-0.0631600171,
0.0841814205,
0.019185489,
-0.1615723968,
0.7151125669,
0.0674324185,
-0.4750429988,
0.0530146398,
0.0386710428,
0.6466484666,
-0.6804689169,
-0.0816797689,
-0.1032323912,
0.1013699993,
-0.3243816793,
-1.024930954,
0.2060522288,
-0.1990028471,
-0.0534629747,
-0.0335232429,
1.1859768629,
-0.3280622959,
0.007957493,
0.4749991,
0.9026356339,
-0.0522359051,
-0.2898635864,
-0.6448498964,
-0.0252423864,
-0.3823976815,
-0.6381505728,
0.2781437933,
0.6971331239,
-0.1480191648,
0.9485430121,
1.0420811176,
0.2595206797,
-0.0888219997,
0.0683605671,
1.3513325453,
-0.735383153,
-0.4227915108,
-0.9256016016,
0.2561075687,
-0.1219476089,
0.1894825846,
0.77731359,
0.6864225864,
0.6628747582,
-0.0875063762,
1.0731295347,
-0.058030732,
0.4488734305,
-0.477224052,
0.4928471744,
-0.3673605323,
0.5768013597,
-0.2391652167,
-0.9506605864,
-0.4842711091,
0.0831908286,
-0.3400232494,
-0.0320988521,
0.2306844145,
1.0684915781,
-0.208258003,
-0.3750796318,
0.2926292717,
0.4084519148,
0.9078673124,
0.3614494205,
0.9059647918,
0.196947366,
0.5928334594,
0.1485594511,
-0.4285144508,
-0.2497462779,
-0.6502733231,
-0.7331018448,
-0.2758195698,
0.4311972558,
-0.1809672564,
0.3535678387,
0.9128493667,
0.6702380776,
-0.4602749348,
-0.3390726149,
-0.0734810159,
0.1489518881,
-0.1148186922,
-0.1951257586,
0.1805049479,
-0.3642464578,
-0.7180458903,
0.6497962475,
0.7509009838,
0.0978031605,
-0.642265141,
-0.2112014443,
-0.0627818555,
-0.0308772568,
0.6720231175,
0.3923332095,
-0.5288797021,
-0.2936395109,
0.2653871477,
-0.1433612257,
-0.1187047586,
0.9416327477,
-0.7437974811,
0.4792200923,
0.3303616047,
0.6262971163,
0.4906446338,
-0.2502743006,
0.8486046195,
-0.8313227892,
0.2397823185,
0.4204719365,
0.3278918862,
0.3573974371,
-0.3271900713,
0.5422870517,
0.0211427696,
-0.6940945983,
-0.8011607528,
0.2482429594,
-0.8437800407,
-0.4027204514,
1.0351887941,
0.0588449687,
-0.1535906345,
-0.5224182606,
-0.429818213,
0.0428692177,
-0.343506366,
0.6261082888,
0.8156453967,
-0.1933636665,
-0.0420783609,
-0.8706095219,
0.538855195,
0.1571112275,
-1.0490038395,
0.1574292034,
0.5001653433,
0.4141124487,
0.2849072516,
0.8500027657,
-0.1051997915,
0.226631254,
-0.1661601514,
0.0730200857,
-0.2186772525,
-0.254589349,
-0.145178929,
0.0048562959,
0.3187271357,
0.3701521456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14660v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14660v2
|
ConceptMath: A Bilingual Concept-wise Benchmark for Measuring Mathematical Reasoning of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-22T16:06:49 | 2024-02-23T07:13:00 |
Yanan Wu, Jie Liu, Xingyuan Bu, Jiaheng Liu, Zhanhui Zhou, Yuanxing Zhang, Chenchen Zhang, Zhiqi Bai, Haibin Chen, Tiezheng Ge, Wanli Ouyang, Wenbo Su, Bo Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces ConceptMath, a bilingual (English and Chinese),
fine-grained benchmark that evaluates concept-wise mathematical reasoning of
Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike traditional benchmarks that evaluate
general mathematical reasoning with an average accuracy, ConceptMath
systematically organizes math problems under a hierarchy of math concepts, so
that mathematical reasoning can be evaluated at different granularity with
concept-wise accuracies. Based on our ConcepthMath, we evaluate a broad range
of LLMs, and we observe existing LLMs, though achieving high average accuracies
on traditional benchmarks, exhibit significant performance variations across
different math concepts and may even fail catastrophically on the most basic
ones. Besides, we also introduce an efficient fine-tuning strategy to enhance
the weaknesses of existing LLMs. Finally, we hope ConceptMath could guide the
developers to understand the fine-grained mathematical abilities of their
models and facilitate the growth of foundation models.
|
[
-0.3486345708,
-0.8714138865,
0.4637712836,
0.5384966135,
-0.2603798509,
0.2422941625,
-0.2758516669,
-0.2787453234,
0.1684758067,
0.2388376296,
-0.4199205935,
-0.6727403402,
-0.4153968692,
-0.1149569303,
-0.3660846651,
0.5149171352,
-0.3166697621,
0.3165926933,
-0.5663406253,
-0.1649712473,
-0.4925298691,
-0.2474563867,
-0.5938029885,
-0.550563395,
0.1035275832,
0.359647274,
0.8954681754,
0.7835046053,
0.8229528666,
0.3068849146,
-0.0901769623,
0.2634416521,
-0.2389714122,
0.035838414,
-0.4060122073,
-0.6437451243,
-0.638176024,
-0.2107822001,
0.6235368252,
0.9383231401,
-0.3668983579,
0.1948551983,
-0.2880868018,
0.6454592347,
-0.5925657749,
0.309207052,
-0.5954934955,
0.0331926383,
-0.3279340863,
-0.0340320207,
-0.0738983452,
-0.5165441036,
-0.087248452,
-0.6566295028,
-0.0146491621,
-0.0498324186,
0.5710559487,
0.2000328898,
-0.0577784255,
-0.2642017007,
-0.4731635451,
0.9687607884,
-0.6552644372,
0.4773828089,
0.3795699477,
0.6512975097,
0.0529133976,
-0.468085587,
-0.5067149997,
-0.1738020331,
0.3066061437,
0.1584967673,
-0.0438875556,
-0.2925218642,
0.2443043143,
0.5683714747,
-0.571167767,
0.1702443361,
-0.0559011586,
-0.2488140762,
0.8334497213,
0.357760787,
0.4662035704,
0.0812245831,
-0.0797729343,
0.0161434934,
-0.7482389808,
0.0028224671,
0.1062633321,
0.3988992572,
-0.2661088705,
0.6515016556,
-0.3671378791,
0.6393480301,
-0.4349630773,
-0.326847136,
0.1992232949,
-0.4005265236,
-0.1550175995,
0.0333205462,
0.577798605,
0.295576781,
0.6336945891,
-0.0883969367,
-0.2877905369,
0.5005816221,
-0.1541717947,
-1.0516207218,
-0.0760595649,
0.0736610144,
-0.1681754142,
0.0170263592,
-0.0007184789,
-0.5471074581,
-0.1604121178,
-0.4461470842,
0.1556437314,
-0.5016418695,
-0.3682750762,
0.4440841079,
0.2038956285,
0.1590699852,
0.5441058874,
-0.8033171296,
0.4766238332,
1.3540008068,
0.917745173,
-0.4653014541,
-0.4030763209,
-0.4910246134,
-0.1163686737,
-0.6744965315,
0.8670157194,
-0.5982714295,
-0.5153781176,
-0.102088213,
-0.4765338302,
-0.0315291844,
-0.8484857678,
0.7426693439,
-0.4707912803,
-0.0896175429,
-0.1933943331,
-0.6327769756,
-0.085909605,
0.6211711168,
-0.4226242602,
0.9946883917,
0.1112010255,
-0.6084911823,
0.1215528175,
-0.5746293664,
-0.4149206281,
0.1662208587,
-0.2425928861,
-0.0826357976,
0.1877096444,
0.0864965692,
0.1426784843,
-0.8522579074,
0.53008008,
-0.4867335558,
-0.3303457499,
0.1603305489,
-0.290115416,
0.7924465537,
0.2693485916,
0.0336422399,
-0.0676836148,
-0.8060690761,
0.2345009595,
0.303276211,
0.0774565488,
-0.6157779694,
0.1120435968,
-0.0407796204,
0.2179472148,
0.4977802634,
-0.3823145926,
0.0114654433,
-0.4483917058,
0.3177941442,
0.4974154532,
-0.2763948739,
0.1741397828,
-0.3922512233,
0.4916210771,
0.0398421139,
-0.2354086787,
-0.3852705061,
-0.5511178374,
-0.7136847973,
-0.4326983392,
0.6126242876,
0.6066328287,
-0.5058645606,
0.3994812369,
-0.3571951687,
-0.699595511,
-0.4108077288,
0.3258443773,
0.4318092465,
0.5016091466,
0.3319331706,
-0.2170564532,
-0.1640274972,
-0.9246487021,
-0.3911210895,
-0.1722946912,
-0.0294976216,
0.2267442346,
0.5919662714,
-0.2508781552,
0.8647165895,
-0.4539376497,
0.0061659859,
-0.0427374616,
0.1580445319,
0.3441742957,
0.3613105416,
0.4531531036,
-0.6780276895,
-0.5302047133,
0.327944845,
-0.6961262226,
-0.3585942984,
0.1656992584,
-0.2595745921,
-0.0478640832,
0.403231591,
-0.7211951017,
0.0374685265,
0.5130771399,
-0.4065848291,
0.7288146615,
-0.0218597949,
-0.1076352596,
-1.1699153185,
-0.0273285713,
0.2466980368,
-0.043131683,
-0.32138291,
0.5911502242,
0.2280621678,
0.0264335144,
-0.2445241809,
0.7807533145,
-0.0992362499,
-0.2383085936,
-0.0564330555,
0.27637133,
-0.0581347905,
0.0669317544,
0.0900603309,
0.9117159247,
0.6871483326,
-0.5751036406,
0.5423517227,
0.1397373676,
-0.5068023205,
1.1430312395,
-0.8285664916,
-0.2926216125,
0.1769482791,
0.0727926195,
-0.6682084799,
-0.1311008185,
-0.2958439887,
-0.3677023649,
0.0834236518,
0.2690458298,
-0.8771216869,
-0.352791518,
-0.254101336,
0.596280396,
0.2694248259,
-0.4401533902,
0.4254032373,
0.243478626,
-0.2785373628,
-0.3182329237,
-0.7583920956,
-0.1347285956,
-0.1480670869,
-0.8525202274,
0.4308113754,
-0.2348129749,
-0.7049265504,
0.0059530539,
-0.4062066078,
-0.2060187161,
0.3177163005,
-0.2164650261,
0.3007156551,
-0.6812008023,
0.1300915331,
0.0035236601,
-0.3677102923,
0.3714238703,
-0.088040866,
0.5726599097,
-0.3633933365,
-0.6904420257,
-0.1095490754,
0.0685019195,
0.5857738853,
-0.3882396519,
0.2545281053,
0.1784780622,
-0.7048045993,
-0.3404763341,
-0.3293290138,
0.1326878071,
-0.3920148611,
0.5049248338,
-0.7280130386,
-0.6815003753,
0.7581245303,
-0.3529000282,
0.0598852672,
0.7657802701,
0.7696940303,
0.161391601,
0.9768974781,
0.3094878197,
-0.0869287476,
-0.0500957444,
-0.1994051039,
0.0919690207,
-0.5534504056,
-0.0374816507,
-0.6268267035,
-0.1997033954,
-0.530043602,
-0.8308151364,
0.0576389991,
0.4051524997,
-0.4425090849,
0.2659502029,
-0.1492125392,
0.7602185607,
0.1882305145,
-0.3677655756,
0.6922590733,
-0.179581359,
-0.5533137321,
-0.2596798241,
-0.3704510331,
-0.4638140798,
0.947748065,
0.3696470857,
0.6624721885,
0.2663081288,
0.5561233759,
-0.0478188954,
0.3548774719,
-0.9973156452,
0.6149204969,
-0.1974882931,
-0.5845264792,
-0.1861422509,
-0.7570053339,
-0.5868711472,
0.4080930948,
0.079641521,
-0.8020682931,
-0.2284699529,
-0.2066315264,
-0.2414381802,
0.2246505469,
-0.5242694616,
0.8992622495,
-0.4735247195,
-0.2405947,
-0.5399008393,
-0.0430683345,
0.6651626825,
-0.5753725171,
0.3806748092,
-0.5547479391,
-0.1817785203,
0.5191865563,
-0.6063933372,
0.4595549405,
0.0810565799,
-0.4860799313,
0.1551550925,
0.6260435581,
0.1605633199,
0.2929094732,
-0.2092917413,
0.4736877084,
0.1493596733,
-0.4515430629,
-0.647636354,
0.8499149084,
-0.7324281335,
-0.6469604373,
-0.3386362493,
-0.8673824668,
-0.6272179484,
0.2793710828,
-0.071527563,
0.2378096879,
-0.3972392678,
0.309522599,
0.5594969392,
-0.065224655,
0.2360681593,
0.7104423642,
-0.4473197162,
-0.2697817683,
1.0684407949,
0.0011494538,
0.2033683509,
0.681231916,
0.3847189248,
-0.4114532471,
-0.4256553352,
-0.4752995074,
0.2461185455,
-0.6058861613,
-0.3441402614,
-0.2715698779,
-0.4650956392,
0.1061739177,
-0.1227852851,
-0.8106096387,
-0.4998818636,
0.1165096089,
0.2238464653,
0.1656300873,
0.168131426,
0.1809317172,
0.1158413738,
-0.6477202177,
0.6003704071,
0.4280168712,
0.7117893696,
-0.0684543177,
-0.5687057972,
-0.1277431101,
0.2276288718,
-0.3744363785,
-0.2885551155,
0.0180057101,
0.1424706876,
0.5858447552,
0.5837484002,
-0.1917386949,
0.7447428703,
-0.5730779171,
0.4290389419,
0.4010679722,
-1.2645386457,
0.5515524149,
-0.4162857831,
0.5103518963,
0.4158284664,
0.1398617178,
-0.6364637613,
-0.1814129204,
-0.4015350938,
-0.4307163954,
0.5786936879,
0.2072675675,
0.1952974349,
0.0183570608,
-0.1708898395,
0.1015550122,
0.068142809,
-0.313570261,
-0.279381454,
-0.0283403806,
-0.2531705797,
-0.2124974579,
-0.0329878516,
-0.1644878238,
-0.5339208841,
0.4187426269,
-0.3555258512,
-0.1036742926,
-0.3196901083,
-0.170679003,
-0.1829580218,
0.1857503355,
0.7062669396,
1.1171786785,
-0.144276917,
0.1032096148,
0.3358087242,
-0.4160607457,
-0.0021314058,
0.3649451435,
-0.1248352379,
0.0652515367,
0.5080465078,
0.5542874336,
0.4966734648,
-0.9020265937,
0.334322989,
0.0466663688,
-0.4291144311,
0.0458542071,
0.0789525136,
0.5592931509,
0.1696315259,
0.2950872779,
-0.0000090187,
-0.1146667674,
-0.6253094673,
0.1298563778,
0.5392932296,
0.1202227324,
-0.3052953482,
0.6129412055,
0.1632472426,
-0.4417815208,
0.2275999486,
-0.137418583,
-0.442315191,
0.9542359114,
0.7466202378,
0.7803653479,
-0.3485321999,
0.3166413307,
0.4085983336,
0.1969901323,
-0.2895285189,
0.3924055994,
-0.1619663388,
-1.0113207102,
-0.4751123786,
-0.7677292228,
-0.7090017796,
-0.0957523957,
-0.6293948889,
0.3454998136,
-0.5060737133,
0.1345417351,
0.3440447748,
0.2777100205,
-0.5257277489,
0.2587516606,
0.2484973669,
1.3803391457,
-0.5808794498,
0.8204941154,
0.875062108,
-0.0320189372,
-0.4595924318,
-0.0196046755,
-0.0132210106,
-1.1488262415,
0.5349037051,
0.2398671508,
-0.1243717596,
-0.1418815404,
-0.1611457169,
-0.8444075584,
1.0074696541,
0.506328702,
-0.7565644979,
0.3432811201,
0.4674542248,
0.8048322201,
-0.4285782576,
0.3255807757,
0.8666344285,
0.5197597146,
0.3614345193,
-1.0297703743,
-0.1895906627,
-0.5324918032,
0.1740739048,
0.2941973507,
-0.7194724679,
0.8587747812,
-0.1208420619,
-0.2232665718,
0.0251417682,
0.4725356698,
0.7958757877,
0.6199435592,
0.3567425311,
0.9552000761,
0.7976183295,
-0.3976545036,
0.9233703017,
-0.5228912234,
0.3520554304,
0.9590784311,
-0.5101639032,
0.8976247311,
0.2403894514,
-0.4988125861,
0.3942807019,
0.6844449639,
0.1092881858,
0.2552105486,
0.4098812342,
0.0488405935,
-0.5508449674,
-0.1733007282,
-0.711314559,
0.5363316536,
0.5481104851,
0.1978260279,
-0.5648460984,
-0.6390109658,
-0.0673218369,
0.4208833873,
-0.5644516945,
0.4238678813,
0.4488148093,
-0.6071571708,
0.7035967112,
0.3642029166,
0.6209301353,
-0.6276862621,
0.2075323313,
-0.6409869194,
0.3160658777,
-0.1577527523,
-0.857103765,
0.3268396258,
0.114423126,
-0.0945442244,
0.1189370677,
0.2998946011,
-0.4350252151,
-0.8982866406,
0.3592937887,
0.8560852408,
-0.1088652238,
-0.0643273294,
-0.9285767674,
0.0709930211,
-0.4318620265,
0.0358962826,
0.2001733035,
0.8079075217,
-0.4762979448,
0.8352404237,
0.6765874624,
0.2827061117,
-0.2659215927,
0.3671749234,
0.63593328,
-0.7338442206,
-0.7277505398,
-1.0814064741,
0.0590018779,
-0.0158582833,
-0.4389532208,
0.7474491,
0.7647801042,
1.0005245209,
0.1005671099,
0.4640375376,
0.3364593387,
0.5096069574,
-0.4275655448,
0.4478284121,
-0.7749941945,
0.2733450532,
-0.2112598568,
-1.3441203833,
-0.5334785581,
0.5780047774,
-0.3140470684,
0.068663843,
0.7787522674,
0.6232646108,
-0.4570703804,
0.2194902301,
0.5228475332,
0.0600844249,
-0.0432313308,
0.721523881,
0.879288733,
-0.2356448174,
0.14227359,
-0.1750269383,
-0.0863246396,
-0.1505447328,
-0.7454226613,
-0.9789546132,
-0.181542173,
-0.4485874474,
-0.0802298933,
-0.2933584154,
0.8495221138,
0.4859055877,
-1.1267310381,
-0.5066711307,
-0.2255544066,
0.3476757407,
-0.2702834606,
-0.2395587116,
0.292648375,
-0.2915354669,
-0.8483226299,
0.106249392,
0.5155982375,
-0.1151015535,
-0.409327507,
-0.3603439927,
0.1580429673,
0.3438184857,
0.5428218246,
0.2019758373,
-0.8133075833,
0.2191207707,
-0.1064289734,
-0.3435431421,
-0.0214217752,
0.8597826362,
-0.3645072281,
0.5832713842,
0.4859888554,
0.972371161,
0.3035899401,
-0.0228101891,
0.5082236528,
-0.5176686645,
0.2535767853,
0.1548967808,
0.5364817977,
0.3256200552,
0.1308043152,
0.6753599644,
0.3746630251,
0.0544981137,
-0.9990840554,
0.1758490205,
-0.8169006705,
-0.1957509816,
1.0182430744,
-0.0631736442,
-0.0649323985,
0.2600086629,
0.1163836941,
-0.1459563226,
-0.1488220245,
0.8354020119,
1.0438674688,
0.339903146,
-0.0181078501,
-0.6369851828,
0.1528839618,
0.5773658156,
-1.1224189997,
0.0617126897,
0.2266141027,
0.1046615019,
0.3325489461,
0.4654392004,
-0.1411778182,
0.548748076,
0.0770551935,
-0.1216825023,
0.07966692,
-0.244883135,
-0.1167266518,
-0.0477703847,
-0.0946539417,
0.0457391478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14658v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14658v2
|
OpenCodeInterpreter: Integrating Code Generation with Execution and Refinement
| 2024-02-22T16:06:23 | 2024-02-28T03:15:24 |
Tianyu Zheng, Ge Zhang, Tianhao Shen, Xueling Liu, Bill Yuchen Lin, Jie Fu, Wenhu Chen, Xiang Yue
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The introduction of large language models has significantly advanced code
generation. However, open-source models often lack the execution capabilities
and iterative refinement of advanced systems like the GPT-4 Code Interpreter.
To address this, we introduce OpenCodeInterpreter, a family of open-source code
systems designed for generating, executing, and iteratively refining code.
Supported by Code-Feedback, a dataset featuring 68K multi-turn interactions,
OpenCodeInterpreter integrates execution and human feedback for dynamic code
refinement. Our comprehensive evaluation of OpenCodeInterpreter across key
benchmarks such as HumanEval, MBPP, and their enhanced versions from EvalPlus
reveals its exceptional performance. Notably, OpenCodeInterpreter-33B achieves
an accuracy of 83.2 (76.4) on the average (and plus versions) of HumanEval and
MBPP, closely rivaling GPT-4's 84.2 (76.2) and further elevates to 91.6 (84.6)
with synthesized human feedback from GPT-4. OpenCodeInterpreter brings the gap
between open-source code generation models and proprietary systems like GPT-4
Code Interpreter.
|
[
-0.3813937306,
-0.2530530989,
0.3122858703,
0.2764830887,
0.0003221383,
0.2158118635,
-0.4829596281,
-0.3762668967,
-0.1496778131,
0.3687557876,
-0.3570692837,
-0.485567987,
-0.0245083217,
0.1261282414,
-0.0324253738,
1.1186648607,
-0.3793220818,
0.1109097004,
-0.0097249094,
-0.1995785236,
-0.4744358063,
-0.4528879523,
-0.040913485,
-0.2504114211,
0.2102961242,
0.5224310756,
0.678802371,
0.4240397811,
0.5381294489,
0.2440038025,
0.5368037224,
-0.0568823256,
-0.637821734,
0.0421512574,
-0.3450314999,
-0.3634088039,
-0.1835789084,
-0.1333500743,
0.1989983171,
0.0445801653,
-0.2652370632,
0.4117255509,
0.0339663252,
0.7264213562,
-0.8160158992,
0.2863614559,
-0.3052235544,
0.0094367778,
-0.1574622095,
-0.2941247821,
-0.3140768111,
-0.923227191,
-0.1802374572,
-0.3734107614,
0.1570644975,
-0.3838740289,
0.5203953981,
0.4935504794,
0.2583185732,
-0.3362063766,
-1.050006628,
0.4318632782,
-0.8659840822,
0.3577909768,
-0.2655321658,
0.3233809173,
-0.0213639103,
-1.0827511549,
-0.5341286659,
-0.3034197092,
0.1566756219,
0.0683320165,
-0.3249994814,
0.1622719765,
0.4262926877,
0.7478353977,
-0.4520175159,
-0.0450419486,
-0.6157817841,
0.0009147104,
0.3197415769,
0.088313818,
0.1390186697,
0.1868606657,
-0.1021481305,
0.1236798167,
-0.7635410428,
0.0460402407,
0.5614601374,
-0.1494825929,
0.1390398592,
0.642786324,
-0.3279767334,
0.5467205048,
-0.0248740166,
0.3242712617,
0.4201952815,
-0.4530789852,
-0.0943666771,
-0.1022209972,
0.6574684381,
0.4551565945,
0.4356053472,
-0.0421850681,
-0.4774343967,
0.378800571,
0.6719194055,
-1.165874958,
-0.6880061626,
0.2527480423,
-0.4476852417,
-0.3521720767,
0.6023104787,
-0.7780014277,
0.0376025997,
-0.2989919782,
0.2239052504,
-0.5240540504,
-0.3455386162,
0.1654028744,
-0.1607232839,
0.2502211332,
0.2961032391,
-0.6769334674,
0.245556578,
0.6960505247,
0.7906067371,
0.1583981067,
-0.289701134,
-0.7200744748,
-0.0496037267,
-0.3600957692,
0.4092072546,
-0.7150267363,
-0.1246046349,
-0.107726492,
-0.2305392623,
0.2209058404,
-0.5973823071,
0.2097286731,
-0.6147682667,
0.1347471178,
0.1326977462,
-0.3243376315,
-0.1767114103,
-0.0629538223,
-0.4941878617,
1.1374458075,
0.6641030312,
-0.7151110172,
0.332326442,
-1.0896550417,
-0.0073960563,
0.3984511197,
-0.4242819548,
-0.2525537908,
0.3586137891,
0.1895170361,
-0.0400701463,
-0.2458760291,
0.1738104224,
-0.2166526467,
-0.6667643189,
0.0389714241,
-0.0652903467,
0.4033004642,
0.3670479059,
-0.6347765923,
0.3973753154,
-0.6101169586,
0.4455757737,
-0.1709331125,
-0.4884075224,
-0.0135151288,
-0.0606824383,
-0.1336348653,
0.1001414657,
0.1293843836,
-0.6849380732,
0.5387201309,
-0.2136990875,
0.6191134453,
0.6758761406,
0.11301779,
0.1829403639,
-0.0914247483,
0.9097748399,
-0.2232603133,
0.2825460434,
-0.412887454,
-0.5586138368,
-0.3291975558,
-0.1398147345,
0.3942513764,
0.5424087644,
-0.7734118104,
0.3378860354,
-0.1902603209,
-0.4529959261,
-0.84130615,
0.3014487624,
0.6939730644,
0.1640636325,
0.2762258053,
-0.593254745,
-0.5888169408,
-0.7411430478,
-0.3538813889,
-0.1956191957,
-0.1863739789,
-0.1969244033,
0.430478096,
-0.5886871219,
1.100110054,
-0.7313715816,
0.2225373983,
-0.0340801738,
0.1616728306,
0.300812006,
0.7243526578,
0.5836401582,
-0.4051580429,
-0.2586332858,
0.1796495169,
-0.4807226658,
-0.2419389039,
0.2636673748,
-0.0986099243,
0.1591449678,
0.5354861021,
-0.1821383983,
0.4003787637,
0.5955642462,
-0.0842157081,
0.8072355986,
-0.261443764,
0.1738458127,
-0.7708123922,
0.3456794024,
-0.2596800327,
-0.0425842293,
-0.368471235,
0.6895634532,
0.2549210787,
-0.20708628,
-0.349969238,
0.0948043019,
-0.3526604176,
-0.1229385883,
0.0553772934,
-0.3155152798,
-0.121641919,
0.4572058022,
-0.1956810951,
1.1242108345,
0.1787805408,
-0.4125295579,
0.4249558151,
-0.0074561108,
-0.5817452669,
0.1979460418,
-0.7502299547,
0.4706639051,
0.1476126909,
0.0569646582,
-0.5237519741,
-0.5042958856,
0.2991805375,
-0.3865293562,
0.1425491571,
-0.4483132064,
-0.6012994647,
-0.7694227695,
-0.5828732848,
0.3429355919,
0.6688814163,
-0.6326711178,
0.2492753714,
-0.1069746614,
-0.2775143981,
-0.4802282453,
-0.4689222276,
0.0243131071,
0.3853530288,
-0.4957048893,
0.0568611361,
-0.311794132,
-0.2982806265,
0.2406509072,
-0.1014496163,
0.0601968616,
-0.279676199,
0.3118062615,
0.287758112,
-0.435185492,
0.0772138238,
-0.0448119007,
-0.2221705168,
-0.0599697419,
-0.6040862799,
0.5347755551,
-0.5148977637,
-0.6212954521,
-0.1799662262,
0.0116182417,
0.6752355099,
-0.6680223346,
0.1729958206,
0.5405254364,
-0.10925401,
-0.0478743054,
-0.5897346735,
0.0124710537,
-0.4675684571,
0.2077783197,
-0.6330900192,
-0.8502857089,
0.3573873043,
-0.1305425018,
0.2820984721,
0.1345457137,
0.6705830693,
0.5564079285,
1.005141139,
0.6356202364,
0.0169723779,
0.6038407683,
-0.2441734374,
0.2380497903,
-0.7296478152,
-0.1282198131,
-0.5457256436,
-0.235569641,
-0.6253300905,
-0.5696354508,
0.1865586787,
0.3076372445,
-0.4240137041,
0.4490676224,
-0.9534887671,
0.7424288392,
0.7869338989,
0.1539244056,
0.2813490033,
-0.2623322308,
-0.0620994717,
0.0485405065,
-0.5659510493,
-0.6367893219,
1.1078819036,
0.4039716721,
1.1519196033,
0.135671258,
0.8341910243,
0.095759064,
0.7597575188,
-0.4132565856,
0.2226691544,
0.0890348181,
-0.2770730555,
0.1418321282,
-0.4650667906,
-0.4151889384,
-0.1557559967,
0.3552248776,
-0.6386107802,
0.1830829829,
0.3613502383,
-0.5417140722,
0.173057884,
-0.9809538722,
0.9906467199,
-0.0467581451,
-0.5726855993,
-0.1086731106,
-0.4113083184,
0.4446102977,
-0.0907941014,
-0.0370818153,
0.1793646216,
-0.0972034633,
0.2109423429,
-0.8659715056,
0.5728443265,
-0.5265163779,
-0.1985125393,
0.4535653293,
0.2125584036,
0.4736703932,
0.1835176498,
-0.2687356174,
-0.006558883,
-0.0646421835,
-0.2383066118,
-0.5433984399,
0.9070785642,
-0.5275028348,
-0.3026958704,
0.0527864397,
-0.267577678,
0.04096644,
0.2924588025,
0.4935899079,
0.6408221722,
-0.1577660888,
0.1265953779,
0.3313415647,
-0.2750903368,
0.2679040134,
0.466871351,
-0.4566828907,
-0.7444033027,
0.8452219963,
-0.2468029708,
0.2646034956,
0.112775974,
0.0444886833,
-0.0840414464,
-0.4248429835,
-0.799346149,
0.0192284565,
-0.5810773373,
-0.388938278,
-0.5577293634,
-0.0945149139,
-0.3301576972,
-0.3610926867,
-0.2625669539,
-0.2653979063,
0.0884255096,
-0.0599438846,
0.5259333849,
1.2238681316,
-0.0819160342,
0.1669916213,
-0.9884864688,
0.2472055107,
0.0935409367,
0.951530695,
-0.1730033308,
0.0350203626,
-0.4181228876,
-0.1218865216,
-0.4719908535,
-0.6649779081,
0.1105624512,
0.0832805857,
0.2404892296,
0.3480350673,
0.1820234358,
0.5654839873,
-0.4275734723,
0.8209930658,
0.1726238132,
-1.1202378273,
0.6031925678,
-0.2468364388,
0.6964648962,
0.8553209305,
0.102494508,
-0.2587941885,
-0.6459845901,
-0.3865186572,
-0.5475975871,
0.7333845496,
0.246449858,
-0.1379874498,
0.0273052696,
0.3589038253,
0.2910352349,
0.4535786211,
-0.6433876157,
0.4333595037,
-0.5307185054,
-0.232489422,
0.003040645,
0.0860825852,
0.0554784462,
-0.2219947129,
0.3910140097,
-0.4105868936,
0.3788281977,
0.1497555673,
-0.1554775983,
-0.4112524092,
0.25655213,
0.6459598541,
0.9339100122,
-0.3121207058,
-0.0573037378,
-0.2009977698,
-0.5046421289,
0.0476540811,
0.0873407051,
-0.1017436162,
-0.0560074486,
0.3256726563,
0.6427496076,
0.2481636107,
-0.7352690101,
0.5961409211,
-0.0037194323,
-0.1289230138,
-0.1744076014,
0.2927482128,
-0.0753100067,
0.3534902036,
0.1122549996,
0.4733348191,
0.1446674913,
-0.5993760228,
0.3180356324,
-0.0442569889,
-0.5066559911,
-0.546479404,
0.8430368304,
0.3234711289,
-0.2836628854,
0.7914729118,
-0.2574695349,
-0.7249676585,
0.3992593288,
0.2816184759,
1.2275555134,
-0.3645612001,
-0.2016391456,
0.5454357266,
0.303666383,
0.0078336075,
0.7546758056,
-0.1978655308,
-0.3110554218,
-0.7415705323,
-0.6829558015,
-0.4508609176,
-0.2197141349,
-0.6610508561,
0.4978472292,
-0.4521689117,
0.0582116768,
-0.150236547,
-0.3816058636,
-0.7024239898,
-0.3253462613,
-0.3007138073,
1.2011891603,
-0.2483577132,
0.824662447,
0.8974018097,
-0.7768210769,
-0.7689632773,
0.3020921946,
-0.0987173244,
-0.5024269223,
0.5984613895,
0.4394948184,
-0.2302493453,
0.2176811248,
-0.5062729716,
-0.29755494,
0.8516228199,
0.3548046052,
-0.6878481507,
-0.1874822378,
-0.1824069321,
0.5891866088,
-0.3074168563,
0.4741567671,
0.4640508592,
0.521342814,
-0.253131181,
-0.9203397036,
-0.074314639,
-0.4936299622,
0.205446288,
0.621882081,
-0.4714033604,
0.7467828393,
-0.6389635205,
-0.0814245865,
0.2828090787,
0.2601879239,
0.0197423063,
0.1119957566,
0.2190343142,
0.6102048755,
0.3188755512,
-0.1683586687,
1.1067494154,
-0.7820612192,
0.2963532209,
0.981566906,
-0.341804713,
0.7743409276,
0.1318968832,
-0.1619868875,
0.7521811128,
0.2801753283,
-0.048695378,
0.3749309778,
0.4424240589,
-0.329985261,
0.352389425,
0.4287653267,
-0.506424427,
0.1812781096,
0.171831578,
-0.2361694723,
-0.1485545486,
0.0247958601,
-0.0297633205,
-0.0149786826,
-0.1510099918,
0.8463489413,
-0.2792112231,
-1.0128555298,
0.6405491233,
-0.0305748023,
0.6399620175,
-0.6435886025,
-0.3489062786,
-0.1058896109,
0.7166590691,
-0.4800482392,
-0.8648219109,
0.4107081592,
0.2247610688,
-0.0642903149,
-0.1722392738,
0.4615613222,
-0.2877279222,
0.1014205664,
0.3882867694,
0.149172157,
-0.0747335255,
-0.3093698621,
-0.3661012352,
0.3759268522,
0.3102392852,
-0.2455898672,
-0.0290528685,
0.489392221,
0.0261629336,
0.310018301,
0.6373326182,
-0.0184093863,
0.1537893265,
0.0180640966,
1.1846535206,
-0.6732151508,
-0.3884707987,
-0.713662982,
0.3833463788,
0.0223696902,
-0.4609332979,
0.5461102724,
0.9396768212,
1.1614654064,
-0.4731827378,
0.9257260561,
-0.3212510943,
0.4465937614,
-0.3979296982,
0.360462904,
0.0043352987,
0.343531996,
-0.4844848514,
-1.2099144459,
-0.115761742,
0.3330669999,
-0.2658062577,
0.011767718,
0.5507612824,
0.9901524782,
-0.1370651573,
0.201949656,
0.0056024645,
-0.0044959835,
0.5934878588,
0.4272139072,
0.9597253203,
-0.1320552528,
0.5855774879,
-0.3526784182,
-0.6879569888,
-0.3975880146,
-0.7505533099,
-0.4061129987,
-0.2590045333,
-0.2171394676,
-0.4129208326,
0.1591582596,
1.0151072741,
0.693801105,
-0.7641533613,
-0.3687182963,
-0.4454049468,
-0.4366241395,
-0.3304505944,
-0.3323144913,
-0.2909956574,
-0.6673455238,
-0.6758141518,
0.3543598652,
0.5541409254,
-0.3246425688,
-0.4221574068,
-0.4170953035,
0.3021908402,
-0.0701102242,
0.5978825092,
0.5229926109,
-0.6286638975,
-0.2240166962,
-0.1628656387,
0.0106209153,
0.1327722222,
1.3912662268,
-0.8865522146,
0.7521749735,
0.5369460583,
0.5095401406,
0.3830179274,
0.2292213291,
1.024523735,
-0.6679685712,
-0.1011003554,
0.3477278948,
0.1285785735,
0.0704395846,
-0.241642192,
0.9424248934,
0.049827449,
-0.7228378654,
-0.7908405066,
0.3752372563,
-0.4399478137,
-0.0850931332,
0.7282527685,
-0.16404064,
0.0684417784,
-0.1076283902,
-0.5714882016,
-0.0329983458,
-0.6724305153,
0.2669213712,
0.3923707902,
-0.3536352813,
-0.2540052533,
-0.7390492558,
0.3747246563,
-0.1411217451,
-0.8404060006,
0.2097377181,
0.7410573363,
0.265770793,
0.3448052704,
0.7226791978,
-0.4903169572,
0.6042291522,
0.1323374808,
0.8692134619,
-0.2678407431,
-0.1460721344,
-0.4252953827,
0.1320160776,
0.3681952059,
-0.1854791641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14652v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14652v3
|
Cleaner Pretraining Corpus Curation with Neural Web Scraping
| 2024-02-22T16:04:03 | 2024-06-15T03:05:54 |
Zhipeng Xu, Zhenghao Liu, Yukun Yan, Zhiyuan Liu, Ge Yu, Chenyan Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The web contains large-scale, diverse, and abundant information to satisfy
the information-seeking needs of humans. Through meticulous data collection,
preprocessing, and curation, webpages can be used as a fundamental data
resource for language model pretraining. However, when confronted with the
progressively revolutionized and intricate nature of webpages,
rule-based/feature-based web scrapers are becoming increasingly inadequate.
This paper presents a simple, fast, and effective Neural web Scraper
(NeuScraper) to help extract primary and clean text contents from webpages.
Experimental results show that NeuScraper surpasses the baseline scrapers by
achieving more than a 20% improvement, demonstrating its potential in
extracting higher-quality data to facilitate the language model pretraining.
All of the code is available at https://github.com/OpenMatch/NeuScraper.
|
[
-0.3401809037,
-0.6490021348,
0.1802423596,
0.0835140646,
-0.260270983,
0.0891572163,
-0.4957826138,
-0.3110578358,
0.421094805,
0.4194968343,
-0.251065582,
-0.4278686941,
-0.4822208285,
-0.0349318646,
-0.8676745892,
1.2200536728,
0.4624361694,
0.0552544706,
-0.2226761281,
0.206973806,
-0.1181538925,
-0.4314494431,
-0.879840672,
-0.133070305,
0.717535615,
0.4004275501,
0.546892345,
0.5746517777,
0.5101162791,
0.4172312319,
0.0278125778,
0.1218893081,
-0.4636381865,
0.2548082769,
-0.5535387993,
-0.3619816005,
-0.4222607315,
0.0832064375,
0.3193302751,
0.7225197554,
-0.2161843181,
0.2466984391,
0.4177183211,
0.4818853736,
-0.8251981139,
-0.2643907666,
-0.6418690085,
-0.2065241933,
-0.4602466524,
-0.2555962205,
-0.4349346757,
-0.7148721814,
0.215202868,
-1.0438691378,
0.3263792098,
-0.2199577689,
1.2250598669,
0.2403472513,
-0.0980430841,
-0.0699125677,
-0.3572977483,
0.8586986065,
-0.7716388106,
0.4767882228,
0.7203963399,
0.120407097,
0.1547172219,
-1.2793967724,
-0.5846608877,
-0.1762306541,
-0.0240066554,
-0.0024903028,
-0.3815772831,
-0.2627590001,
0.2208052576,
0.2537318468,
-0.5903679132,
0.2403994501,
-0.3421199322,
-0.4852862954,
0.2678293884,
-0.0188138224,
0.6915623546,
0.0000636854,
-0.3409940898,
-0.3717793226,
-0.3798756599,
-0.0867125094,
0.6221855879,
0.3927240074,
0.0216188226,
0.1922920644,
-0.2511292696,
0.7061668634,
0.0188473202,
-0.0699900612,
0.4766053259,
-0.0946741551,
0.0984202102,
-0.1257180572,
0.6850479245,
0.4277307987,
0.5120341778,
-0.3147678971,
-0.2813441753,
0.1833768636,
0.7450047135,
-1.0998924971,
-0.6754726171,
-0.0009740084,
-0.5519732237,
-0.2660340667,
0.1964776069,
-1.0195426941,
-0.1687173545,
-0.5973377824,
0.1308842152,
-0.8298515081,
-0.3717595935,
-0.1542984396,
-0.524580121,
0.2345571518,
0.4537429214,
-0.7749465704,
0.7177873254,
0.5635007024,
0.7146274447,
-0.2958911061,
-0.1897536218,
-0.7404835224,
-0.1773844957,
-0.0411177911,
0.9341961145,
-0.4994862974,
0.1787944436,
0.0501101799,
-0.1550610811,
-0.0687198341,
-0.5756546855,
0.3631614745,
-0.7872464657,
0.0494468994,
0.0172176585,
-0.4413373172,
-0.3405444622,
0.4284457862,
-0.9647783041,
0.8744602203,
-0.0177082457,
-0.7583742738,
0.2805978656,
-0.7042156458,
-0.9003119469,
0.2628029287,
0.1287497431,
-0.1116954386,
0.1176622361,
0.1287164241,
0.1472689509,
-0.0516459569,
0.0540597215,
-0.2661580145,
-0.1890435219,
0.3784579337,
-0.3508196771,
0.789655447,
0.4257779717,
-0.1867049634,
0.0657898411,
-0.7261608839,
0.4599473774,
0.1341959387,
-0.5271789432,
-0.5550455451,
0.0498540401,
0.4994326532,
0.1385191381,
0.3594221771,
-0.5079028606,
-0.1301338971,
-0.3895485699,
0.6352206469,
0.6860450506,
-0.3818475604,
0.5945927501,
-0.2956395447,
0.609973371,
-0.2013799399,
-0.0958817676,
-0.0909952521,
-0.005900362,
-0.6606682539,
-0.1640019864,
0.7652382851,
0.4920000434,
-0.8036394119,
0.4796497822,
-0.2797918916,
-0.6236005425,
-0.4305360317,
0.3121685088,
0.6006168723,
0.4288717806,
0.619800508,
-0.5671396255,
-0.6723155379,
-0.5913081765,
-0.3066839874,
0.3873731792,
-0.0433358029,
-0.1879763007,
0.3828794956,
-0.0683931634,
0.8204678297,
-0.5373817682,
-0.2256475091,
-0.4649149477,
-0.002100481,
0.1257332563,
0.7145889401,
0.2809801996,
-0.8475881219,
-0.4787095785,
-0.3038890064,
-0.3754385114,
-0.120274879,
0.2572610974,
-0.3647791445,
-0.0330310948,
0.6848026514,
-0.464191854,
0.4056508541,
0.4466989934,
0.036361333,
0.5109128952,
-0.1214860007,
-0.3352353871,
-0.9515211582,
0.5235200524,
0.0553718694,
-0.3315843344,
-0.6954959035,
0.1737122089,
0.018658936,
0.0537977666,
-0.4862969816,
0.6371601224,
-0.4988875687,
0.1973822564,
-0.5497247577,
0.3133203387,
0.1561634988,
0.2214969844,
0.0307682771,
0.541203022,
0.3364746869,
-0.9339182377,
-0.1284184307,
0.4011328518,
-0.2102701515,
0.242335856,
-0.6100280881,
0.4323559403,
0.1051682383,
0.1474200934,
-0.6807060838,
-0.1042156741,
-0.0316959284,
-0.5157008767,
0.2217571437,
-0.1968176663,
-0.4627154171,
-0.1472820938,
-0.2591711283,
0.3059765399,
0.4540611207,
-0.5803700686,
0.5179684162,
0.6864034534,
-0.453861326,
-0.5512046814,
-0.5462220907,
0.0259506833,
0.0271659177,
-0.4106792808,
0.6232336164,
-0.1223070472,
-0.225457266,
-0.0523437634,
-0.1359518319,
-0.5171079636,
0.2626600862,
0.2543109357,
0.0894106999,
-0.0944237858,
-0.003818064,
0.0165045206,
-0.3647412956,
-0.1061488688,
-0.2346763611,
1.2474315166,
-0.031729091,
-0.1314946264,
-0.7009757161,
0.0261337198,
0.1843090206,
-0.6563107371,
0.1916926652,
0.7383089662,
-0.4602356553,
-0.3165473342,
-0.5587923527,
-0.5761817694,
-0.533891201,
0.2078749239,
-0.1107724234,
-0.5379322171,
0.1938647777,
-0.1473503411,
-0.1144031733,
0.3262078762,
0.108789295,
-0.1743378639,
0.8295637369,
0.5968617201,
-0.1163286343,
0.6899591088,
-0.3573262393,
-0.0563931353,
-0.7053391337,
-0.0245674849,
-0.7567054033,
-0.5752093792,
-0.4215915799,
0.0702554658,
-0.3215425313,
0.2102569193,
-0.2406591773,
0.5178123116,
-0.4909667373,
0.6272303462,
1.1560744047,
0.3589793742,
0.1293138117,
0.1759649515,
-0.2028217465,
-0.0884164944,
-0.4863865674,
-0.7475147843,
0.9347016811,
-0.1034838557,
0.5738899708,
-0.2313640267,
0.7703016996,
-0.0625899211,
0.3148332238,
-0.5833354592,
0.6122684479,
-0.5440430045,
-0.6408200264,
-0.3695441484,
-0.22973454,
-1.2405157089,
0.1518674195,
-0.2731440067,
-0.4567244649,
0.0342651457,
0.2309994847,
-0.5107799172,
0.315839082,
-0.4254623353,
0.8532039523,
-0.2613629103,
-0.4988791645,
-0.2725500166,
-0.6470702291,
-0.0414254554,
-0.0032858825,
0.3026303649,
-0.0145650441,
0.104636319,
0.8817655444,
-0.6316218972,
0.7615339756,
-0.3102275133,
0.314281553,
0.2848592997,
0.2423616797,
0.1701401621,
-0.2160485238,
-0.0004125102,
0.1999100745,
-0.1950228065,
-0.3597665727,
-0.326090306,
0.3908724487,
-0.6624662876,
-0.1497936398,
-0.2826214433,
-0.1811292022,
0.08696004,
0.6584557891,
0.4451624155,
0.5567868948,
-0.3556381762,
0.296844393,
0.4741456807,
-0.341203779,
0.8740356565,
0.3640376329,
-0.3181800246,
-0.5053071976,
1.1829293966,
-0.1078685299,
0.0485373959,
0.4533793032,
0.0816370994,
-0.1231137216,
-0.9547266364,
-0.0244392883,
-0.0813465789,
-0.3383229971,
-0.5554957986,
-0.7290261388,
-0.2206805497,
-0.3284520805,
-0.0029761642,
-0.2822433412,
-0.3211576641,
-0.3284744918,
-0.1158533171,
0.1759254038,
0.3442932963,
-0.2007884085,
0.7921404839,
-0.912530303,
0.5462244153,
0.1537674367,
0.1445298791,
-0.0321993306,
-0.3382118642,
-0.1624498665,
0.1109461784,
-0.403986901,
-0.6480953097,
0.9807018042,
0.1170898825,
0.6194338799,
0.6672804356,
-0.126009956,
0.7260246873,
-0.4899504185,
0.4471930265,
0.2674998641,
-0.856965661,
0.5383031964,
-0.2031288296,
0.2277115583,
1.1438748837,
0.3666185141,
-0.38788715,
-0.2356255502,
-0.4954710007,
-1.0556915998,
0.6443138123,
-0.0237460211,
0.327645123,
-0.2149238735,
-0.0349506177,
0.3232497871,
0.2486006171,
-0.6134884357,
0.1302952617,
-0.5617049932,
-0.1670541763,
-0.0225213375,
0.0592106543,
0.2836382687,
-0.4035894871,
0.7252578139,
-0.1720968783,
-0.1216599196,
0.0088254986,
-0.9718991518,
0.2346143872,
0.1886329502,
0.1784157753,
0.5604872108,
-0.0417346209,
0.2619119585,
0.0463317633,
-0.8553195596,
-0.1693392992,
0.2326368243,
-0.3156460822,
-0.0716933906,
0.2115419954,
0.2967915535,
0.3215924203,
-0.8025896549,
0.7592454553,
-0.1155138537,
0.0211196337,
-0.6084055305,
0.1522026062,
0.0668933392,
-0.0458415113,
0.3616633713,
0.2813219726,
0.2975343764,
-0.2375277132,
0.4459468126,
0.2349523306,
-0.4381045997,
-0.4300853312,
0.5151910186,
0.2296020389,
-0.3875035048,
1.4018092155,
-0.2163566947,
-0.5046896935,
0.5518901944,
0.6037466526,
0.6837615371,
-0.4207254946,
0.2014834136,
0.4366238713,
0.1627250761,
-0.0041788947,
0.4616150856,
0.117213361,
-0.9091070294,
-0.6244288683,
-0.890232861,
-0.2270314991,
0.1785618514,
-0.8268553615,
0.3088739812,
-0.6541720033,
-0.3164129555,
0.1387052238,
-0.1446421742,
-0.9150300622,
0.4289954007,
0.2156935483,
0.8943701386,
-0.339776963,
0.8499753475,
0.6458870173,
-0.73918432,
-0.6952673793,
-0.0932680219,
-0.1583370864,
-0.6294744611,
0.7196444273,
0.5683070421,
0.1751731038,
0.1387545168,
-0.7217116952,
-0.8780479431,
0.7906044722,
0.5286360383,
-0.6904076934,
-0.4285250902,
-0.0015066084,
0.3408335745,
-0.0016691512,
0.5680505037,
0.2942243814,
0.6774786711,
-0.3938957155,
-0.7400447726,
0.1304362714,
-0.7567960024,
-0.3462839127,
0.1604676843,
-0.2990601063,
1.0524789095,
-0.0000119923,
-0.1790769696,
0.1545015275,
0.6192942262,
0.0833627507,
0.1175050959,
0.809233427,
0.8618840575,
0.8793426156,
-0.0172746349,
0.9376034141,
-0.5462156534,
-0.2306893915,
1.4271458387,
-0.2461892962,
0.9976560473,
0.3595448136,
0.0783775002,
0.9333919287,
0.2612310052,
0.000505331,
0.454991132,
0.4653952122,
0.0544261746,
-0.3538978398,
0.0174538344,
-0.1914813071,
0.7958427072,
0.2759710848,
-0.3419715762,
-0.507548213,
-0.0019479564,
0.2703127265,
0.3278673589,
-0.2733743787,
0.9277549386,
0.1484742165,
-0.645334661,
0.1764379293,
-0.0973746106,
0.854782939,
-0.5804014802,
-0.1791111678,
-0.0592749603,
0.2849645615,
-0.4021075666,
-0.359336406,
0.1743347049,
-0.1020212322,
-0.062982358,
-0.5196524858,
1.0669432878,
-0.1215693131,
0.0170880947,
0.3602215946,
0.7615194321,
0.1764027029,
-0.5601043105,
-0.4191408753,
-0.1904821098,
-0.1037589088,
-0.2853942811,
0.4814328849,
0.1982140094,
0.1466769129,
0.3632918596,
1.3063112497,
-0.02290757,
0.1452001482,
0.1527982354,
0.9391630888,
-0.7852290869,
-0.5506051183,
-0.9216759801,
0.5724776387,
-0.4514104128,
-0.5146696568,
0.7950744629,
1.0016344786,
0.9347169995,
0.0624851696,
0.7941856384,
0.0371620171,
0.6939159632,
-0.3090059459,
1.1008137465,
-0.0824234262,
-0.3850071728,
-0.2372659445,
-1.0310182571,
-0.2360073477,
0.7980646491,
-0.2057616413,
-0.0225458462,
0.6676087379,
0.6370812654,
-0.2626428008,
0.2218821496,
-0.0800151527,
0.1908373237,
0.0939883366,
0.077290304,
1.0005041361,
-0.058916837,
0.6495921612,
-0.3822588623,
-0.0997772142,
-0.1406189799,
-0.8218827844,
-0.6826152205,
-0.3631485999,
-0.2290995121,
-0.4116099775,
0.0332751535,
0.8542923331,
0.861158371,
-0.8379347324,
-0.1978827566,
-0.248778224,
-0.1193062067,
-0.3130080104,
-0.2582195401,
0.2168292403,
-0.8279105425,
-0.6951562166,
0.46350348,
-0.2975667417,
-0.0982006267,
0.2294447273,
0.0796167329,
-0.2398609072,
-0.0920876637,
0.5307322145,
0.2962209582,
-0.1547173709,
0.1005045921,
-0.0019833248,
-0.1763040125,
0.1477231979,
0.7815925479,
-0.9204331636,
-0.058703579,
0.5266814828,
0.5585986376,
0.708178997,
-0.0135454386,
0.472353369,
-0.4931118786,
-0.0530677103,
0.4158362448,
0.4823878109,
0.3182924688,
0.1232856736,
0.3942832053,
-0.0708682388,
-0.202002719,
-0.7043308616,
-0.1055586711,
-0.9733341336,
-0.5084701777,
0.9603840709,
-0.048818294,
-0.3113215268,
-0.0689520612,
-0.1601656824,
0.5001149774,
-0.5855318904,
0.4760184884,
0.1528066844,
0.3427842855,
0.2635057569,
-0.4577172697,
0.3661578,
0.2909680903,
-0.9790637493,
-0.207443133,
0.5185376406,
0.6345608234,
0.4221464992,
0.5634943247,
-0.2003193349,
0.1954711676,
-0.0934493095,
0.4536884725,
-0.0322489776,
-0.4989320338,
-0.1465799958,
0.4381920993,
-0.2746756077,
-0.0960840955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14623v1
|
RoboScript: Code Generation for Free-Form Manipulation Tasks across Real and Simulation
| 2024-02-22T15:12:00 | 2024-02-22T15:12:00 |
Junting Chen, Yao Mu, Qiaojun Yu, Tianming Wei, Silang Wu, Zhecheng Yuan, Zhixuan Liang, Chao Yang, Kaipeng Zhang, Wenqi Shao, Yu Qiao, Huazhe Xu, Mingyu Ding, Ping Luo
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.9; I.2.10
|
Rapid progress in high-level task planning and code generation for open-world
robot manipulation has been witnessed in Embodied AI. However, previous studies
put much effort into general common sense reasoning and task planning
capabilities of large-scale language or multi-modal models, relatively little
effort on ensuring the deployability of generated code on real robots, and
other fundamental components of autonomous robot systems including robot
perception, motion planning, and control. To bridge this ``ideal-to-real'' gap,
this paper presents \textbf{RobotScript}, a platform for 1) a deployable robot
manipulation pipeline powered by code generation; and 2) a code generation
benchmark for robot manipulation tasks in free-form natural language. The
RobotScript platform addresses this gap by emphasizing the unified interface
with both simulation and real robots, based on abstraction from the Robot
Operating System (ROS), ensuring syntax compliance and simulation validation
with Gazebo. We demonstrate the adaptability of our code generation framework
across multiple robot embodiments, including the Franka and UR5 robot arms, and
multiple grippers. Additionally, our benchmark assesses reasoning abilities for
physical space and constraints, highlighting the differences between GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Gemini in handling complex physical interactions. Finally, we
present a thorough evaluation on the whole system, exploring how each module in
the pipeline: code generation, perception, motion planning, and even object
geometric properties, impact the overall performance of the system.
|
[
-0.1303739697,
-0.5576463938,
0.7135324478,
0.0843396932,
-0.0059133023,
0.1803197265,
-0.0072440961,
-0.5870557427,
0.3582623899,
0.5825852156,
-0.7761563659,
-0.4190246165,
-0.5081595182,
-0.0040757474,
-0.3628590703,
0.7481975555,
-0.2638784945,
-0.3791276515,
-0.2382806242,
-0.0368314162,
-0.1730010062,
-0.4391500354,
-0.0506183915,
-0.0771559104,
0.2419304848,
0.2954227328,
0.9290296435,
0.7750174403,
0.8224471211,
0.2550020218,
0.4379703403,
0.2819698453,
-0.0407304242,
0.1370152086,
-0.3742284179,
-0.4272028804,
-0.6664646268,
-0.0839454383,
0.2225234509,
0.4302065969,
0.0630955324,
0.0203030575,
-0.2953212261,
0.5187166929,
-0.8094791174,
0.063902989,
-0.3633938432,
0.318608433,
0.1610515863,
0.0223068949,
-0.0877142772,
-0.0799268037,
-0.121499896,
-1.1121473312,
0.1034617051,
-0.0275504887,
0.8688155413,
0.6321965456,
-0.1124738231,
-0.2089181393,
-0.9214428067,
0.5550032854,
-0.4688519537,
0.2703968287,
0.2447105199,
0.5715937614,
-0.097150594,
-0.8314481974,
-0.6501988173,
-0.5254039764,
0.056919165,
0.2908711433,
-0.4393915236,
0.351696074,
0.351321876,
0.0687345862,
-0.7969011664,
-0.0173814055,
-0.4512874186,
-0.2955529392,
0.4769442677,
0.0863401145,
0.4477136731,
-0.150667429,
-0.5110803246,
-0.3840684891,
-0.6635528803,
-0.0138057973,
0.717450738,
0.4290997088,
-0.2558717728,
0.6962655187,
-0.4035686553,
0.66424191,
-0.2264882773,
0.270966351,
0.027946705,
-0.1954551637,
-0.3315413594,
-0.5838416219,
0.8903827667,
0.5611225367,
0.2887796462,
-0.3928871155,
-0.1798631847,
0.3044087291,
0.8815791011,
-0.423070997,
-0.4204450548,
0.4765204787,
-0.211093381,
-0.100065209,
0.3991037309,
-0.451338917,
-0.1180692166,
-0.4358938634,
0.4652729034,
-0.3353208899,
-0.1579085588,
0.2487358749,
-0.2748968601,
-0.0763584301,
0.3907153904,
-0.5495578051,
0.4096381068,
0.7726041675,
0.7650450468,
-0.0846956521,
-0.3489888012,
-0.5349395871,
0.2574424148,
-0.3546395302,
0.7258354425,
-0.2333932817,
-0.0888539031,
-0.1688446701,
-0.07383921,
-0.1006618515,
-0.6136450768,
0.2072962224,
-0.0955965146,
0.1528122723,
0.4814125896,
-0.1794445813,
-0.218091771,
0.303999573,
-0.57682693,
0.7488268614,
0.5323607922,
-0.0015388012,
0.3569666445,
-1.0228598118,
-0.4413962364,
-0.1570283324,
-0.1183930412,
-0.1528144032,
-0.3810415864,
-0.1011383533,
0.3686007559,
-0.3165365458,
0.1778973788,
-0.1571612358,
-0.3008623719,
0.165861249,
-0.0259544756,
0.3083569407,
0.3391545415,
-0.32421574,
0.5585810542,
-0.728545785,
0.1518433988,
-0.1173297912,
0.1488135606,
0.1534099877,
0.0066306964,
-0.0132074226,
0.469655931,
0.1407511532,
-0.4802998602,
0.5254351497,
-0.4091082513,
0.2376607358,
0.4257711768,
-0.3222857416,
0.7261320353,
-0.0971880332,
0.9572836161,
-0.3113998175,
0.1959831417,
-0.1086056978,
-0.3453882337,
-0.4202902913,
-0.4830303192,
0.004516534,
0.8094949722,
-0.7133156061,
0.5472161174,
-0.0107603557,
-0.4745007455,
-0.29472965,
0.1805293858,
0.6281913519,
0.1236890927,
0.4314879477,
-0.3394028246,
-0.4693979323,
-0.9286760092,
-0.0295061208,
-0.0249711443,
-0.7094274759,
-0.0206372198,
0.4366177619,
-0.1835509986,
1.0333445072,
-0.5461813211,
-0.1212455034,
-0.422469914,
0.0764323696,
0.0038933638,
0.533696413,
0.6061310768,
-0.4190677702,
-0.0754008144,
0.1413135976,
-0.699483633,
-0.1866844147,
-0.2566539347,
-0.3743620515,
0.0257536322,
0.4763839841,
-0.7744159698,
0.4853237271,
0.7622979283,
-0.1375335455,
0.4633473456,
-0.3582374454,
0.019686738,
-0.8186675906,
0.3465403914,
-0.1512469351,
-0.0368567593,
-0.4208962321,
0.6090041399,
0.0004578881,
-0.2755565047,
-0.5464367867,
0.4845641255,
-0.2181330174,
-0.2397353649,
-0.2980819046,
0.4961019158,
-0.1163073406,
0.5875276923,
-0.0195423886,
0.8288516998,
0.4838949144,
-0.6932910085,
0.5785326958,
-0.0698710009,
-0.0860125795,
0.3267215192,
-0.6569148302,
0.1666665673,
0.2720077932,
0.2224858999,
-0.6924813986,
-0.6048852205,
0.6503167152,
-0.3441092372,
-0.3078456819,
-0.1850077659,
-0.5030533075,
-0.4488812387,
-0.1054065004,
0.0525616221,
0.4226195812,
-0.226991564,
0.7333132625,
0.0865672678,
0.2010516673,
-0.5571594834,
-0.5133668184,
0.0558401048,
0.0968693495,
-0.6191865206,
0.1634468138,
-0.0539195165,
-0.3885696232,
-0.0190225635,
-0.2859013975,
-0.0933401063,
0.0511492006,
0.462202847,
0.2115848958,
-0.0103589017,
-0.2912396789,
0.3592093885,
-0.5414612889,
-0.0053024543,
-0.2504836023,
0.5472193956,
0.0981860086,
-0.7297831774,
-0.4877298772,
-0.0766191483,
0.735925436,
-0.0843729973,
0.0973784775,
0.1987117529,
-0.2702840269,
-0.375620693,
0.1885178238,
-0.0427726172,
-0.4144392908,
0.23472929,
-0.3841009736,
-0.5180300474,
0.4933875501,
-0.3127246797,
0.2088721991,
0.2236810178,
0.1749521196,
0.000207112,
0.6643792391,
0.6316461563,
0.3281881809,
0.2384082377,
-0.3997439742,
0.2618381381,
-0.6588950753,
0.1239259988,
-0.3780592084,
-0.6227904558,
-0.1468813866,
-0.9385604858,
0.1730640233,
0.1020531207,
-0.220614478,
1.1069945097,
-0.678352952,
0.5921379328,
0.5857904553,
-0.1064804569,
0.1651673019,
-0.2810506821,
-0.044842191,
0.1913367808,
-0.4840816557,
-0.7619433403,
0.880751431,
0.0579862222,
0.5174608231,
0.0433033332,
0.359313786,
0.3350180686,
-0.0442081839,
-0.5889419317,
0.8088588715,
-0.1462543756,
-0.6126323938,
-0.2451525033,
-0.2148015052,
-0.9451549649,
0.2301534712,
-0.1102528721,
-0.747741878,
-0.2781821787,
0.2579604983,
-0.5445190668,
0.5000963211,
-0.7364009619,
0.7284927368,
-0.2464190722,
-0.342765063,
-0.3959447742,
-1.0029878616,
0.0888613164,
0.2937980294,
0.0745905787,
-0.3833050132,
-0.0843705386,
0.1906271279,
-0.2930321097,
0.744022727,
-0.0550697334,
-0.2921501994,
0.4506585598,
0.6403151751,
0.1851344109,
-0.1121601909,
0.0357486457,
0.0735314339,
-0.1664036661,
-0.2788051963,
-0.8129444122,
0.3077978492,
-0.6367286444,
-0.0082423035,
-0.3044628501,
-0.8478601575,
-0.2442085296,
0.0975867063,
-0.099654898,
0.2944709659,
-0.2952167988,
0.0223018378,
0.0654410869,
-0.2464745492,
0.289163202,
0.2892721295,
-0.367616713,
-0.1594491899,
0.8281453848,
-0.1743137091,
0.7722496986,
0.7854831815,
-0.0757262483,
0.1105904579,
-0.1885631382,
-0.8861166835,
-0.2438976318,
-0.2491411716,
-0.3961211741,
-0.4252250791,
-0.1239796132,
-0.3208919168,
-0.7893853784,
-0.4521395564,
-0.8486154675,
0.1246752739,
-0.0979622155,
0.2644548416,
0.8010977507,
-0.4365897179,
0.4568432868,
-0.707780242,
0.7939651012,
0.2076266259,
0.4989639223,
-0.3128656447,
0.0019267872,
-0.1133334488,
0.1476971209,
-0.4539429247,
-0.331485033,
0.2345658243,
-0.3066483438,
0.3815292716,
0.3450413644,
0.0184263214,
0.4405480325,
-0.0249825865,
0.9161595106,
0.1475376785,
-0.8367811441,
0.6853063703,
-0.6498278975,
0.3275486529,
0.1933187544,
0.1514560431,
-0.4426823556,
-0.7812389731,
-0.7605086565,
-0.7931150794,
0.8421434164,
0.3800494075,
-0.0745019913,
0.18935211,
0.1462910473,
0.2065441608,
0.3243303895,
-0.4793888628,
0.0843635052,
-0.0917935148,
-0.2172207087,
0.2703865469,
0.5240729451,
-0.2758714259,
0.0232479479,
0.2905817032,
-0.3444884419,
0.551455915,
-0.0702870488,
-0.1400399953,
-0.1595959365,
0.039883852,
0.8439590335,
0.5578106046,
-0.2189190835,
-0.0733019412,
-0.2814159989,
-0.5942889452,
-0.1800051481,
0.0790564641,
-0.1646847129,
-0.3826466501,
0.3290240169,
0.5615914464,
0.1431873739,
-1.0714113712,
0.2226890028,
0.3892634511,
-0.4311493039,
0.0510875359,
0.568121314,
-0.1798617244,
0.1026871949,
0.1165647507,
0.6255866289,
-0.0363129266,
-0.6422772408,
0.2005665749,
0.1711837798,
-0.4142522216,
-0.3791955709,
0.7667209506,
0.2444964349,
-0.4115536213,
0.4832788408,
-0.3623561859,
-0.2940654755,
0.9900234342,
0.4732788503,
0.9188892245,
0.2486941367,
0.3345145583,
0.5065620542,
0.4379350245,
0.2202376425,
0.2351482362,
-0.2437034547,
-0.6906000972,
-0.5555137992,
-0.2558898032,
-0.8275963068,
-0.4325476587,
-0.3607342839,
0.1592297852,
-0.9580551386,
0.1496689767,
-0.4919452071,
-0.3907671273,
-0.298389256,
0.2341353446,
0.0152469156,
0.799138844,
-0.4581606984,
0.5232316256,
0.817009747,
-0.6803223491,
-0.5819295049,
0.214945361,
0.1564616263,
-0.8504992723,
0.4173223972,
0.0109557789,
-0.7301642299,
-0.5232844353,
-0.7670291066,
-0.6669362783,
0.9564965963,
0.4118595123,
-0.3245550692,
-0.0758075267,
0.1806902587,
0.6475193501,
-0.168419525,
0.1829334199,
0.2417835444,
0.4216302931,
-0.0349327326,
-1.1103788614,
-0.1446200311,
-0.3009040952,
-0.3505069613,
0.4514703155,
-0.7059459686,
0.5130329132,
-0.2813114226,
-0.0694656223,
0.511915803,
0.403450191,
0.4467628896,
0.411190033,
0.4157876074,
0.4699669778,
0.4923869073,
-0.3632950187,
1.0636146069,
-0.5233833194,
-0.0009346688,
0.8273637891,
-0.4634433687,
0.6645700336,
0.268037945,
-0.2493471205,
0.667796433,
-0.1997288167,
0.1844048202,
0.3090696335,
0.3750264645,
-0.1478325427,
-0.2110322267,
0.3569739759,
-0.0345688649,
0.5525747538,
0.3620722294,
0.1126475334,
-0.0568292737,
0.2396217883,
0.0459832661,
0.4198699892,
0.0868802071,
0.4661682248,
-0.2655896544,
-0.649086833,
-0.001026392,
0.0038953125,
0.6681541204,
-1.0406227112,
-0.2176701128,
0.0919755399,
0.4434219003,
-0.0629167333,
-1.1644922495,
0.5400953293,
-0.0580027923,
-0.0030623521,
-0.6081990004,
0.6634797454,
0.0151112732,
-0.0227139182,
0.3043614626,
0.4748467803,
0.2081834376,
-0.0498796403,
-0.5565928221,
0.1572778374,
-0.1075841412,
0.0602428801,
0.4155091345,
0.517390132,
0.0357407741,
1.036372304,
0.7592718005,
-0.1511542499,
-0.0692919716,
-0.0241456367,
0.7817720771,
-0.6706587076,
-0.422501415,
-0.1189882755,
0.6281737685,
0.0302607026,
-0.5757790804,
0.5886281729,
0.5858347416,
0.9384874105,
-0.4118954539,
0.6483443379,
-0.6399902105,
0.5856430531,
-0.4809055328,
0.4977517724,
-0.5034979582,
-0.243465811,
-0.6160522699,
-0.7319536209,
-0.7399553061,
1.0102818012,
-0.0633240342,
-0.085610345,
0.5712983608,
0.8489996195,
-0.2575178742,
-0.1828272492,
0.3186945021,
-0.308519572,
0.3518522978,
0.5115484595,
0.7178229094,
-0.4582904875,
0.6797543764,
-0.2645233274,
-0.0807997361,
0.018527111,
-0.8320342898,
-0.3201541901,
-0.4317943454,
-0.2562068105,
-0.2386724502,
0.2822923064,
1.1271717548,
0.7936927676,
-0.512168169,
-0.4988010526,
-0.3082014322,
-0.0741313919,
-0.755340755,
-0.2031550705,
-0.0169998761,
-0.2654652894,
-0.8427114487,
0.6576108336,
0.5609076619,
-0.1360100061,
-0.2072655708,
-0.2616603076,
0.0490355305,
-0.1872303039,
0.8275537491,
0.8313199282,
-0.540565908,
-0.3598543406,
0.3982719481,
-0.0836919919,
-0.1145275831,
1.0047903061,
-0.9769141078,
0.437335819,
0.3876982033,
0.4583662152,
-0.0093366308,
0.0836446136,
0.8039001226,
-0.6798309088,
0.3969791532,
0.2581398785,
0.0697536841,
-0.0199082308,
-0.0857507959,
0.8633340597,
0.1322735399,
-0.5122830272,
-0.4492900968,
0.393665731,
-1.4370002747,
-0.2778916955,
0.9552605748,
0.2219405174,
0.1412343681,
-0.0682920963,
-0.5147099495,
0.0970618874,
-0.3372305334,
0.6465317607,
0.4558033943,
-0.6157149673,
0.0449228846,
-0.5876241922,
0.0748466998,
0.2583345473,
-0.9149121046,
0.3832841516,
0.7809587717,
-0.1362388283,
0.6113146544,
0.5743643045,
-0.2593331337,
0.4627688527,
0.2493970096,
0.4960427284,
-0.1178667918,
-0.706866622,
0.13803792,
0.1766770333,
-0.3633543849,
-0.3258408606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14622v1
|
From Keywords to Structured Summaries: Streamlining Scholarly Knowledge Access
| 2024-02-22T15:10:45 | 2024-02-22T15:10:45 |
Mahsa Shamsabadi, Jennifer D'Souza
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL
|
This short paper highlights the growing importance of information retrieval
(IR) engines in the scientific community, addressing the inefficiency of
traditional keyword-based search engines due to the rising volume of
publications. The proposed solution involves structured records, underpinning
advanced information technology (IT) tools, including visualization dashboards,
to revolutionize how researchers access and filter articles, replacing the
traditional text-heavy approach. This vision is exemplified through a proof of
concept centered on the ``reproductive number estimate of infectious diseases''
research theme, using a fine-tuned large language model (LLM) to automate the
creation of structured records to populate a backend database that now goes
beyond keywords. The result is a next-generation IR method accessible at
https://orkg.org/usecases/r0-estimates.
|
[
-0.037285544,
-0.2057124525,
0.7111395597,
0.1049175262,
-0.4753853977,
0.2564343512,
0.0294476282,
-0.4061430991,
0.4492081404,
0.4016446769,
-0.1932726204,
-0.72121948,
-0.5673754215,
0.3131936789,
-0.7286631465,
1.1329977512,
0.1972579956,
-0.0865412727,
-0.6304376721,
0.043442864,
0.0255982187,
-0.2120738328,
-0.0034861425,
-0.4186839759,
0.8320263028,
0.5260585546,
0.6610798836,
0.9432998896,
1.0991909504,
0.2262551039,
-0.2541485429,
0.19738096,
-0.6056810021,
0.5959314704,
-0.0651727095,
-0.4021610022,
-0.5405337214,
-0.1425660104,
0.6934856176,
0.9852631688,
-0.1657857597,
0.1619758606,
0.0878597274,
0.9660241008,
-0.7453690171,
0.2109154463,
-0.41372931,
-0.0369872898,
-0.7351702452,
-0.6862119436,
-0.4440546632,
0.0080365725,
0.1710694134,
-0.8690100908,
0.1803500056,
0.0454221256,
0.7045376301,
0.0492928028,
-0.3279847801,
-0.296092838,
-0.5566315055,
0.396282047,
-0.6018738747,
0.2797461748,
0.1838830858,
-0.0095075089,
-0.3585209846,
-1.2399932146,
0.0636859462,
-0.1470563561,
-0.2570880651,
0.1185673922,
-0.0958501697,
0.1722449809,
0.1056301072,
0.2796728313,
-0.6711341143,
-0.3065099716,
-0.8774996996,
0.3502618968,
0.6636878848,
0.04499726,
0.3746283352,
-0.0677532628,
-0.0031003498,
0.2008107454,
-0.7923898697,
-0.3076954484,
-0.0321718231,
0.3861941397,
0.2291591167,
0.7627476454,
-0.4085672498,
0.7319025993,
-0.2088851333,
-0.0969540328,
0.1879068166,
-0.4907077253,
-0.1152870506,
-0.0255431514,
0.5001216531,
0.1721704304,
-0.260582149,
-0.2961419523,
0.0533936769,
-0.3630245924,
0.3693367243,
-0.9829698801,
-0.3240591288,
0.2068852782,
-0.5205881596,
-0.1175344735,
0.2998017669,
-0.853838563,
-0.3947986364,
-0.0480361246,
0.2358701974,
-0.2708820999,
-0.2331484705,
0.0210050754,
-0.4330227971,
-0.0733978525,
0.2798881829,
-0.4250683784,
0.3349910378,
0.9840941429,
1.1811449528,
-0.1816904247,
0.1820186377,
-0.3120010197,
0.3267009258,
-0.3318355978,
0.8230241537,
-0.6981009841,
-0.7355387211,
-0.0040086755,
-0.3693253398,
0.0676917955,
-0.3473577797,
0.1424800307,
-0.7286370397,
0.2097030729,
-0.0915388465,
-0.5719208717,
-0.0509018674,
-0.0355441161,
-0.5155431628,
0.6677492857,
-0.1786697805,
-0.9345600605,
0.2441788465,
-0.6902008653,
-0.5340716839,
0.5355850458,
-0.1783886105,
-0.2598898411,
0.2202476263,
-0.1888491958,
0.2359267175,
-0.2971202731,
0.476325959,
-0.4122339487,
-0.3327876627,
-0.1000630781,
0.4136492312,
0.4847508073,
0.3801921904,
0.0891294926,
0.2309784293,
-0.6943246126,
0.0346297175,
-0.3613639772,
-0.2236782014,
-0.8342717886,
0.5206331015,
-0.152727291,
-0.2456722409,
0.3550078273,
-0.3232553303,
0.4650183022,
-0.3939521015,
0.6187075377,
0.0597741269,
0.0148834651,
0.5137652755,
-0.2203015983,
0.4044577777,
-0.0952894613,
0.2381725162,
-0.4730947316,
-0.59282583,
-0.3560786843,
-0.4085070491,
0.3961046338,
0.1969826072,
-0.6566627622,
0.0475218333,
-0.699839592,
-0.6096147895,
-0.3030447662,
0.0106966253,
0.3155916631,
0.4387191832,
0.2903130352,
-0.2114308476,
-0.6281459332,
-0.7255618572,
-0.2749324441,
-0.4113505483,
-0.2682465613,
0.2480156124,
0.6947594881,
-0.1517514288,
0.7233928442,
-0.555036068,
-0.3228630126,
0.060574919,
0.4479429126,
0.3334875107,
0.4433080256,
0.0849238485,
-1.0764116049,
-0.1681702584,
0.0465268828,
-0.8566448689,
-0.2116430402,
0.5671849847,
-0.2174801677,
-0.3195533454,
0.6872621775,
-0.2667011023,
0.3346449137,
0.1529458165,
-0.3844685256,
0.121446006,
-0.1352072954,
0.0731806532,
-0.7876962423,
0.4870820343,
0.0152950333,
-0.1581964791,
-0.4736427367,
0.4219867885,
0.1078643799,
-0.1215424538,
-0.1473989189,
0.2404077649,
-0.6649839282,
-0.1249416694,
-0.3372160196,
0.3513014019,
0.317966342,
-0.2354149818,
-0.2041116506,
0.981095314,
0.2243338674,
-0.492849052,
-0.1929757297,
0.3627403378,
-0.1935912371,
0.2753613591,
-0.7759840488,
-0.127840206,
-0.4947829545,
0.2633556724,
-0.7456839681,
-0.4384910166,
-0.1871783882,
-0.4788348973,
0.4189172983,
-0.279917568,
-0.3663240075,
-0.1474809349,
-0.5180532336,
0.2828786671,
0.2936890125,
-0.1872071326,
0.6313592792,
0.6263864636,
-0.4455612302,
-0.5875756741,
-0.2989936173,
0.5051422715,
-0.0885229483,
-0.7829725742,
0.5426366329,
0.0875121802,
-0.7152304649,
0.2304523587,
-0.1571854353,
-0.3588983417,
0.2416861355,
0.1648473591,
0.2897858918,
-0.068189241,
0.5910493731,
-0.0704227835,
0.163909927,
-0.105585359,
-0.2773284912,
0.1015457287,
-0.0232536029,
-0.0136455148,
0.203182444,
0.7128077745,
0.7970596552,
-0.2865791023,
0.4913925529,
-0.0178956408,
-0.3126175404,
0.0603351258,
-0.2574535906,
-0.3099193275,
-0.3775162101,
0.4364033043,
-0.0959760696,
-0.6964369416,
0.5164908767,
-0.0629237071,
0.2714031041,
0.507507503,
0.0198042467,
-0.440174073,
0.9002469778,
0.8671455979,
0.2375702858,
0.4917485416,
-0.1622647345,
0.2518168092,
-0.9471159577,
-0.5768042803,
-0.9867540598,
-0.144209981,
-0.6335066557,
-0.2659037411,
1.1055016518,
0.2461774051,
-0.1955104619,
-0.0100304717,
-0.6004485488,
0.1919742227,
0.5704684258,
0.31389606,
0.6654391289,
-0.1815789789,
0.046320498,
-0.0637014359,
-0.7154098749,
-0.4883009493,
1.0401669741,
0.0592097417,
0.866912663,
-0.0228162073,
0.5936648846,
0.4350240529,
0.6028119326,
-0.6086971164,
0.2583523989,
-0.259547472,
-0.7457662821,
-0.1210372373,
-0.1833559275,
-0.7382917404,
0.2103935927,
-0.048455447,
-0.5263661146,
0.4783223569,
0.0785795972,
-0.1701408029,
0.1044998094,
-0.3874289691,
0.3479517102,
0.0238114092,
-0.634517312,
-0.2195531428,
-0.8096458912,
0.4300128222,
0.1384634823,
0.3112209141,
-0.0549539626,
-0.3393498063,
1.05758214,
-0.7297256589,
0.4046731889,
0.0180545542,
0.3156839609,
0.0109517369,
-0.2462467849,
0.3972492516,
0.0880340934,
-0.1544886529,
0.1077401116,
0.1209094748,
-0.4689725339,
-0.4138581753,
0.4846194088,
-0.4469331503,
-0.6994909048,
-0.6522557735,
-0.5130722523,
0.0975465029,
0.2731067538,
0.306217283,
0.6241486669,
0.116205208,
0.8461444378,
0.945187211,
-0.0344899856,
0.2816513181,
0.8094713092,
-0.3021929264,
-0.4138288498,
0.5316143632,
0.244699955,
-0.0780889168,
0.682452023,
0.1574157774,
-0.1610908508,
-0.8519955873,
-0.1817694306,
0.1858820766,
-0.3018809855,
-0.6443103552,
-0.9147826433,
-0.1173839048,
-0.3892915845,
0.0064610806,
-0.1534486264,
-0.2449181229,
-0.5911532044,
-0.0896745175,
0.5739297271,
0.7981337905,
-0.0498497784,
0.2797006369,
-0.648689568,
0.1804527193,
0.0219298713,
0.425586164,
-0.2048309743,
-0.4983834624,
-0.4535000026,
-0.1952327788,
-0.2137494832,
-0.8389956951,
0.5779135823,
0.5602737069,
0.0227767397,
0.3866194785,
0.1140451953,
0.9562767744,
-0.5846168995,
0.5778352618,
-0.0593877211,
-0.560098052,
0.7393298149,
-0.5480026007,
0.1004579142,
0.8055226207,
0.4901646078,
-0.5112954378,
-0.3650684655,
-0.5173307657,
-1.4116539955,
0.1760213673,
-0.0069906325,
-0.3091688156,
-0.0064867311,
0.6002960205,
-0.0529378355,
0.5528869629,
-0.197572574,
-0.2995727062,
-0.000963213,
-0.1711212695,
0.2202576101,
-0.4893500209,
-0.2328500897,
-0.2347678095,
0.8330762982,
-0.1458020359,
0.1327166855,
0.7178003788,
-0.1877657175,
-0.2727858424,
0.3162377775,
0.6293241382,
1.1021094322,
-0.3483781219,
0.2066761851,
-0.6226782203,
-0.7296980619,
-0.1192507595,
0.1953474134,
-0.7589780092,
0.1239702776,
0.592407465,
0.4451012909,
0.3538863659,
-0.6060080528,
0.4987471998,
0.1248537377,
-0.1186766252,
-0.3010027409,
-0.0354310647,
-0.0264496375,
0.2770704627,
1.0381379128,
-0.1299454421,
0.6940164566,
-0.5226815343,
0.4350276291,
0.5120692849,
-0.5389707088,
-0.3394875824,
0.8143219948,
0.2614693046,
-0.1843006164,
0.4357839823,
0.2815908194,
-0.1721833646,
0.4261578619,
0.2718803883,
0.6665521264,
0.1064009517,
0.1438972205,
0.2712276876,
0.2238405645,
-0.3266088068,
0.403663516,
0.0629875362,
-0.2169447839,
-0.6458512545,
-0.5192624331,
-0.4520489872,
-0.0131692914,
-0.8516274095,
0.1118382439,
-0.2207970768,
-0.0945233256,
0.1669810861,
0.2300049663,
-0.2320010513,
-0.1613293439,
-0.0174359828,
1.3970000744,
-0.6809148192,
0.5814093351,
0.6910103559,
-0.3893784285,
-0.4696902633,
-0.392288208,
-0.1707282513,
-0.5016129017,
0.6625396609,
-0.1228119656,
0.0202511102,
0.0144499699,
-0.9318348765,
-1.0181385279,
1.1397259235,
-0.0488290899,
-0.7341766357,
-0.224098444,
-0.4784400463,
0.6531962752,
-0.2623229325,
0.3753380775,
0.4690933228,
0.6868120432,
0.1416824758,
-0.6396214962,
-0.346671015,
-0.701372683,
0.0397877879,
0.3413703442,
-0.3448070884,
0.6798683405,
-0.1927951425,
-0.2698476613,
-0.0221749507,
0.8477020264,
0.2400109023,
0.6494098306,
0.0382129513,
0.3988711238,
0.7555357218,
-0.2926710546,
1.13189888,
-0.4608848691,
0.0112083219,
1.0251301527,
-0.3084418178,
0.8641847372,
0.6230997443,
-0.2519705892,
0.5289703608,
0.4263803065,
0.1494121253,
0.672519207,
0.2406727672,
-0.3752022386,
0.0105496943,
-0.4970650673,
-0.438649267,
0.2901067138,
0.7073419094,
-0.3461762369,
-0.2070664465,
0.0720535591,
0.2637411356,
0.2813413441,
-0.4931747317,
1.0363855362,
0.0410566032,
-0.6500399113,
0.0190589726,
-0.1833539754,
0.5209453702,
-0.7701432109,
-0.1664130241,
-0.2141075283,
-0.1341199726,
-0.3946032226,
-0.6259847283,
0.2581450045,
-0.1228994355,
-0.3909924328,
-0.1708920747,
0.9725073576,
-0.4833144248,
-0.5375644565,
0.0288541876,
0.6490746737,
0.1296534091,
0.0763081238,
-0.1589179486,
-0.0122645814,
-0.3017367125,
-0.2406753898,
0.1284022927,
0.4689579308,
-0.1782490164,
0.7448608279,
0.5265683532,
0.4412853122,
0.0299848299,
-0.2311354876,
0.9440111518,
-0.6815750599,
-0.3747937679,
-0.7291321754,
0.3010233045,
-0.1948859841,
-0.075026989,
0.6482926607,
0.7141991854,
0.4511298835,
0.1189992353,
0.7572399378,
-0.3263782263,
0.7553339601,
-0.0058005927,
0.6791040301,
-0.5881875753,
0.3364849389,
-0.0893072784,
-0.4212955832,
-0.6949495077,
0.3244895041,
-0.1341131628,
-0.1790323853,
0.6099685431,
0.5039897561,
0.1483824849,
-0.0119418707,
0.0928951055,
0.5386366248,
0.3818323016,
-0.1104433686,
0.439555347,
-0.3998601139,
0.4375542402,
-0.1765592396,
-0.2777160108,
-0.4843709767,
-1.0167989731,
-0.3446018398,
-0.5631337166,
-0.250079751,
-0.1955626309,
0.6323452592,
0.6312040091,
0.5888680816,
-0.7208973765,
-0.2779154778,
-0.0973663703,
0.3010254204,
-0.0906021819,
-0.1884599477,
0.3865898848,
-0.3850116134,
-0.4042444825,
0.2684067786,
0.7046503425,
-0.2240642011,
-0.1956638694,
0.3227238059,
-0.4155255258,
-0.2940662503,
0.5962442756,
0.4588054419,
-0.1751499921,
0.1238587797,
0.2249270976,
-0.1637467593,
0.2015472502,
0.98804456,
-1.0060366392,
0.4009568095,
0.8586531281,
0.3617241979,
0.5248997211,
0.2070631981,
0.808119297,
-0.5469031334,
-0.1117311642,
0.5149303675,
0.2720793188,
0.3450485766,
-0.4240989387,
0.6650198698,
0.2636568546,
-0.5860979557,
-1.028018713,
-0.0515552498,
-0.7976320982,
-0.2621384561,
0.7685750127,
-0.1584583223,
-0.4974125326,
-0.2520532906,
0.2894101739,
0.1569931656,
-0.4817467034,
0.9380909801,
0.2612777054,
-0.0028857226,
0.002820394,
-0.675383687,
0.5440994501,
0.061310593,
-0.8221159577,
-0.0851432681,
0.5055634975,
0.0958917588,
0.3686077893,
0.6580930948,
-0.5287517309,
0.0731548667,
-0.447129637,
0.0997610614,
-0.1901517957,
-0.72383672,
-0.0245869141,
0.3313963413,
-0.0821487308,
0.0444982201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14616v1
|
The Impact of Word Splitting on the Semantic Content of Contextualized Word Representations
| 2024-02-22T15:04:24 | 2024-02-22T15:04:24 |
Aina Garí Soler, Matthieu Labeau, Chloé Clavel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When deriving contextualized word representations from language models, a
decision needs to be made on how to obtain one for out-of-vocabulary (OOV)
words that are segmented into subwords. What is the best way to represent these
words with a single vector, and are these representations of worse quality than
those of in-vocabulary words? We carry out an intrinsic evaluation of
embeddings from different models on semantic similarity tasks involving OOV
words. Our analysis reveals, among other interesting findings, that the quality
of representations of words that are split is often, but not always, worse than
that of the embeddings of known words. Their similarity values, however, must
be interpreted with caution.
|
[
-0.4307785928,
-0.561555922,
0.3460256159,
-0.0851128697,
-0.7362569571,
-0.1040054262,
0.026103558,
-0.473701328,
0.2934165001,
0.390386343,
-0.2061529756,
-0.4351802766,
-0.8298817277,
-0.1252239645,
-0.542014122,
0.6554141641,
0.0199816171,
0.3910727501,
-0.7843201756,
-0.5987725854,
-0.684158802,
-0.6076505184,
0.0625525489,
-0.4373602271,
0.3561487496,
0.1814655066,
0.7202706337,
0.7874516249,
0.6504076719,
0.3229986429,
-0.1871271282,
-0.1571061611,
-0.7091569901,
0.3730077744,
-0.4413705766,
-0.4580715597,
0.0241814423,
0.3801332414,
0.6025968194,
1.1454433203,
0.0331922621,
0.0490396991,
0.0215971507,
0.4585351646,
-0.6629598141,
-0.0426615551,
-0.6153979301,
0.0546574555,
-0.0419441871,
-0.2169723809,
-0.2344423234,
0.0969548821,
0.5357902646,
-0.5119850039,
0.022838138,
0.3152374923,
0.9863932133,
0.1710291952,
-0.2308181971,
-0.4067465067,
-0.3247663677,
1.08314991,
-0.430405885,
0.3933660984,
0.1120753139,
-0.0319069922,
-0.1388936639,
-0.4119313657,
-0.4069474936,
-0.2487993985,
-0.0252159536,
0.1196967885,
-0.126044035,
-0.0561426245,
0.059842255,
0.3075369895,
-0.1845711321,
0.0539356992,
-0.4960339665,
0.1244449392,
0.5261178613,
0.0987484008,
0.5971519351,
-0.4629798234,
-0.7304155827,
-0.1935005933,
-0.8119572401,
-0.1276111901,
0.4311749935,
0.2530145645,
0.446097821,
0.8062083125,
-0.0187715068,
0.6589477062,
-0.1232284829,
-0.3648741245,
0.2745585144,
-0.3412683904,
-0.2202972174,
0.2506976128,
0.3033330142,
0.6818752289,
0.0423353799,
-0.3668554723,
-0.1389492899,
0.2559394538,
0.4686503112,
-0.3578698933,
0.0815186799,
-0.0197154526,
-0.7126651406,
-0.1112951115,
0.4437742531,
-0.2751145661,
-0.211802572,
-0.3478477895,
0.6262496114,
-0.7216598988,
-0.0187693294,
0.1711787581,
-0.6618205905,
0.227602303,
0.1843312681,
-0.6993232965,
0.3544883132,
0.7950091362,
0.7548044324,
-0.4436661005,
-0.2628555894,
-0.3971554339,
0.019246066,
-0.4638822675,
0.7835183144,
-0.6567878127,
-0.7466084361,
-0.0698428676,
-0.1269481629,
0.0494605452,
-0.7403143048,
0.3279872835,
-0.4462512434,
0.2197679877,
-0.4770035148,
-1.0983630419,
-0.352756381,
-0.0031171883,
-0.5074931979,
0.7263892889,
0.129690066,
-0.8589245677,
0.8329551816,
-0.382365793,
-0.298301965,
0.1635471284,
-0.2121234089,
0.2743012011,
0.6824169755,
-0.0422738791,
0.4844014943,
-0.0013728302,
-0.3491702378,
-0.4373470247,
-0.1109119281,
0.2867512703,
0.041630663,
0.1965554655,
0.1583154649,
-0.0178549737,
0.0708409175,
-0.5353240967,
-0.0028113881,
0.1123893037,
-0.1898490041,
-1.2206536531,
0.3778416216,
0.0518253185,
0.3091691732,
0.0449007936,
-1.0429129601,
0.1014245749,
-0.7206221223,
0.3714710176,
0.4733564556,
-0.0568347424,
0.969871819,
-0.0834000409,
0.2604651749,
0.2921374738,
0.0574464202,
0.0583682247,
-0.5541043878,
-0.5762035847,
-0.1949566752,
0.4165203869,
0.1274539679,
-0.6910401583,
0.2549371421,
-0.4155039787,
-0.2904734612,
-0.5900378823,
0.0392204635,
0.3635119498,
0.3538302183,
0.3953162432,
-0.6136949062,
-0.1273221225,
-0.9571917057,
-0.3165042996,
0.1695809215,
0.2640056014,
0.0101450775,
0.8797118664,
-0.0658903569,
1.2628813982,
-0.6187276244,
-0.4306922257,
-0.254622817,
0.0253531151,
-0.3316241205,
0.4917009175,
0.593057096,
-0.8383489251,
-0.4271889031,
-0.2012339383,
-0.326167196,
0.2329277992,
0.3021981716,
-0.3036503196,
0.0829338282,
0.7030708194,
-0.3568451107,
0.6848190427,
0.5671392679,
-0.3545011282,
-0.0017058323,
-0.2678255141,
-0.1180675253,
-1.0252110958,
-0.1453181505,
-0.1857801825,
-0.1655749977,
-0.518052578,
0.2152053267,
-0.2739586532,
0.2910238206,
-0.690679729,
0.415602237,
-0.5767579675,
-0.2734485567,
-0.3343893886,
0.3954027295,
0.1466628164,
-0.0558094643,
0.1355663687,
0.4570381641,
0.4900448918,
-0.1893750429,
0.528016746,
0.3072923124,
-0.9444590211,
0.6554461718,
-0.6456281543,
-0.017528303,
-0.5550355315,
0.1706827134,
-0.9150505066,
0.0080009708,
0.0558622107,
-0.2911285162,
0.3552607298,
-0.0314192213,
-0.3797400892,
0.2428379357,
-0.3560764492,
0.6447120905,
0.3311026692,
-0.5983579159,
0.1905068457,
0.7857034802,
0.267552197,
-0.4876328111,
-0.9114055037,
-0.2446120977,
-0.3164157867,
-0.7190763354,
0.6996753812,
0.3120171428,
-0.5184015632,
0.5268077254,
-0.1109346226,
0.1009944826,
-0.2012789696,
0.4275707304,
-0.0652797818,
-0.0826702937,
0.422010541,
0.0818089172,
0.0591040179,
-0.1759009212,
-0.419485122,
0.50364393,
0.0896628127,
-0.4377055764,
0.3952795267,
0.8747162819,
0.3256521523,
-0.2692588866,
1.1654404402,
0.3282371759,
-0.4584817588,
-0.2903537452,
-0.2656642795,
0.1657002568,
-0.3240557611,
0.2850271165,
-0.3315718472,
-0.9175418019,
0.4629095495,
0.1246961355,
-0.1620961726,
0.701303184,
0.3010027409,
-0.2423920184,
1.0500822067,
0.7153252959,
0.0525641777,
0.5369238257,
-0.4084861279,
0.0486682169,
-0.9666994214,
-0.4313382506,
-0.2979490161,
-0.1891832352,
-0.5065590143,
-0.710500598,
0.2611475885,
0.1579969674,
0.3406906724,
0.2552065849,
-0.3738787174,
0.4097290635,
0.5878344774,
-0.1005164981,
-0.1079671457,
0.2260606736,
-0.5077260733,
0.0805817619,
-0.8973260522,
-0.518704474,
0.678475678,
0.3792549074,
0.7870585322,
0.0875071362,
0.6836097836,
0.1169581264,
0.2194464803,
-1.1470417976,
0.2671313584,
-0.2470919341,
-0.7490521073,
-0.3996500969,
-0.157741189,
-1.0569101572,
0.6369317174,
-0.2512719035,
-0.9291241169,
0.448363781,
-0.4083737731,
-0.2581139803,
0.1876099855,
-0.570389092,
0.8507574201,
0.2057270706,
-0.0377417505,
-0.4685492516,
-0.5938225389,
0.0539244562,
0.1238204986,
0.2379895598,
-0.2541837096,
-0.2601035833,
1.0097533464,
-0.9687553644,
0.4239334762,
-0.0198603086,
-0.0373390801,
0.5484796762,
-0.0981199816,
0.0171261337,
-0.2593053877,
0.1201816648,
0.2173440158,
0.5286111832,
-0.4598575532,
-0.5875403285,
0.9374222755,
-0.6908821464,
-0.4611645043,
-0.5829948783,
-0.3579130471,
-0.0807498768,
-0.11783766,
0.8035693765,
1.0396888256,
-0.3364945948,
0.2752771676,
0.3406170309,
-0.3526716828,
0.278691262,
-0.0648583993,
-0.2501153946,
-0.2533138394,
0.9893060923,
0.645573616,
0.3297249675,
0.4425344765,
0.213409707,
-0.6444246173,
-0.3915457726,
-0.1794158071,
0.1579843313,
-1.2352772951,
0.0583030358,
-0.3094392419,
0.1542628706,
-0.3573809564,
-0.1085509062,
-0.5320987105,
-0.3976873755,
-0.3900079727,
-0.1165684089,
0.010007509,
1.1142085791,
0.0921006724,
0.0609659702,
-0.8129113317,
-0.082990922,
0.274487555,
0.2311332524,
-0.1263328791,
-0.447845459,
-0.433464855,
-0.2679823339,
0.1870440245,
-0.9246706367,
0.3640047312,
0.2231297344,
0.6177853346,
0.5271949768,
0.1851980686,
0.5475636721,
-0.5759164691,
1.0060611963,
0.3286212981,
-1.00720191,
0.2423774153,
-0.0880703926,
0.4073219597,
0.5770295858,
0.5224083066,
-0.5541940928,
-0.2318234295,
-0.5481439829,
-1.0199356079,
0.6000635028,
-0.0075601758,
0.3233022094,
-0.4483802617,
0.0687817186,
0.3872829974,
0.0902123302,
-0.1257802546,
-0.2166234106,
-0.3734512925,
0.1152527332,
-0.3115848601,
-0.5839471221,
-0.0932601914,
-0.1298695952,
0.2597813308,
0.1682180166,
0.4929910302,
0.3126716912,
-0.4804098308,
0.0244239829,
0.1646105796,
0.5875986218,
0.6892753243,
-0.1377172917,
0.3509652317,
0.2488591969,
-0.3959781528,
0.0280595534,
-0.4574618638,
0.1331340373,
0.297835052,
0.7695848942,
0.7549040318,
0.1177686229,
-0.5630333424,
0.8114516139,
0.0904910266,
0.0811939389,
0.0340616666,
-0.1258454174,
-0.0688595921,
-0.0519016758,
0.015000592,
-0.045558203,
0.1747547984,
-0.8434438705,
-0.0371729247,
0.4828441739,
-0.7217593789,
-0.1402980834,
0.047517471,
0.2848393619,
0.0243944414,
0.5864233375,
-0.0867030174,
-0.7384188771,
0.2178423405,
0.2464134544,
0.6379552484,
-0.0162241161,
-0.0655228123,
-0.0175802931,
0.0921835229,
-0.0132888574,
0.1202142611,
-0.0342029557,
-0.9381845593,
-0.4231629968,
-0.7050707936,
-0.189594686,
-0.3866110146,
-0.8183966279,
-0.0681446791,
-0.1140334159,
-0.361562252,
-0.1305719018,
-0.4088599682,
-0.6504865885,
0.4183440506,
0.3460567594,
0.7451472878,
-0.5688163638,
0.8065627217,
1.0796524286,
-0.3909275532,
-0.7130280137,
-0.0978960097,
-0.2618179321,
-0.4321326613,
1.0372248888,
0.1433301568,
-0.2607696056,
-0.3719643354,
-0.4423074126,
-1.083147049,
0.7626941204,
0.0917473808,
-0.1670242846,
0.0451610722,
0.3620524108,
0.5712553859,
-0.5799439549,
0.215637207,
0.4061489999,
0.1018277183,
0.1127567887,
-0.6942892075,
0.0291292798,
-0.0632472038,
0.2823583782,
0.1398777217,
-0.3423541486,
0.8812109828,
0.1272150278,
-0.6194369197,
-0.0925667435,
0.6839286685,
-0.4907180369,
-0.1468256563,
0.5746113062,
0.6395975947,
0.335750401,
-0.106467545,
1.2979807854,
-0.2774962187,
0.4196190536,
0.8241557479,
0.0627362728,
1.0495790243,
0.7358778715,
0.1381508261,
0.3965754211,
0.4532227218,
0.3005930781,
0.931108892,
0.4362982213,
0.0030122849,
-0.2781102359,
-0.3740116358,
-0.3602709174,
0.9002925158,
0.2895101905,
-0.5527718663,
-0.2149450183,
0.2472392619,
-0.2650109828,
0.043163348,
-0.2201646268,
0.7535467148,
0.3326074779,
-0.7299496531,
0.3629007339,
0.2140611112,
0.6095987558,
-0.288587749,
-0.0025252411,
-0.0545062795,
0.1134925187,
-0.2292801142,
-0.843993187,
0.5563605428,
-0.3461418748,
-0.1154561639,
-0.36065799,
0.8331530094,
-0.4693751335,
-0.1737720221,
0.6077919006,
0.4585644305,
0.1523462236,
-0.1971452385,
-0.4101295173,
0.2087863833,
-0.4822375476,
-0.331672281,
0.373234421,
0.1659755856,
0.1068338528,
0.4742781222,
0.2880320251,
-0.0652342364,
0.2977575064,
-0.0141579723,
0.8663935065,
-0.4443769455,
-0.5654605627,
-0.7379009128,
0.3782807291,
-0.0275841635,
-0.4253080487,
0.8895900249,
0.3880423307,
1.0360635519,
-0.1431053132,
0.5304704905,
0.0893630013,
0.4246341288,
-0.4834159911,
0.671615839,
-0.8811097145,
0.0109617459,
-0.5351245999,
-0.9837075472,
-0.1002393886,
0.7384759784,
-0.553058207,
-0.2132217288,
0.8671730161,
0.4922289848,
-0.0101110609,
-0.1933838427,
0.658613801,
-0.196096018,
0.00908517,
0.1369210631,
1.3230600357,
-0.2815879285,
0.1127174273,
-0.2525406778,
0.0044426867,
-0.268475771,
-0.6486383677,
-0.7693414092,
-0.8482259512,
-0.3645787239,
-0.2025694996,
-0.1056736112,
1.1357191801,
0.684401989,
-0.5006406307,
-0.0322597474,
0.1457094252,
0.1815234274,
-0.086359635,
-0.1168363243,
0.3797359169,
-0.173180148,
-0.6305930614,
0.4519758523,
0.4564892948,
-0.1250498891,
-0.5245164037,
-0.0141750528,
-0.1549338549,
0.4193035662,
0.9782248735,
-0.2929955125,
-0.8698151708,
-0.6851869226,
-0.2108074427,
-0.3706013858,
0.1226143017,
0.5789347291,
-0.5660312176,
0.6183102727,
1.1126037836,
0.1653804332,
0.2861329019,
0.108654283,
0.4947554171,
-0.5574339628,
0.1349396408,
0.2028334886,
0.5361011624,
0.4168762863,
0.0696703196,
0.1940719336,
0.3328423202,
-0.0983146355,
-0.578641057,
0.4249165654,
-0.9240632653,
-0.5997399688,
1.4449926615,
-0.4105035365,
-0.5076540709,
-0.0981967077,
-0.2316481769,
0.1639482677,
-0.2084628791,
0.1109934375,
0.9447528124,
-0.0962907523,
0.2428743392,
-0.1476415396,
0.3654556274,
0.3635020256,
-0.2539734542,
-0.4615512788,
0.2945266664,
0.3098043799,
0.3818721473,
0.0523116626,
-0.1926233172,
-0.2318623513,
0.2961829603,
-0.0066979122,
0.0712549314,
-0.1428758055,
-0.3862371147,
0.4067649543,
0.135572955,
-0.4680585861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14614v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14614v2
|
Two Counterexamples to Tokenization and the Noiseless Channel
| 2024-02-22T15:03:25 | 2024-02-29T09:20:37 |
Marco Cognetta, Vilém Zouhar, Sangwhan Moon, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In Tokenization and the Noiseless Channel (Zouhar et al., 2023a), R\'enyi
efficiency is suggested as an intrinsic mechanism for evaluating a tokenizer:
for NLP tasks, the tokenizer which leads to the highest R\'enyi efficiency of
the unigram distribution should be chosen. The R\'enyi efficiency is thus
treated as a predictor of downstream performance (e.g., predicting BLEU for a
machine translation task), without the expensive step of training multiple
models with different tokenizers. Although useful, the predictive power of this
metric is not perfect, and the authors note there are additional qualities of a
good tokenization scheme that R\'enyi efficiency alone cannot capture.
We describe two variants of BPE tokenization which can arbitrarily increase
R\'enyi efficiency while decreasing the downstream model performance. These
counterexamples expose cases where R\'enyi efficiency fails as an intrinsic
tokenization metric and thus give insight for building more accurate
predictors.
|
[
-0.3970649838,
-0.4786711633,
0.3632974029,
0.2528744042,
-0.5333643556,
-0.2301584482,
-0.2721101642,
-0.7115777135,
0.3603575826,
0.1251020879,
-0.4332347214,
-0.0649030134,
-0.8498204947,
-0.1034259498,
-0.4498904049,
1.0637936592,
0.248994723,
0.3981600106,
-0.0246540084,
-0.1597339213,
-0.367369473,
-0.7031903863,
-0.5817871094,
-0.6178920865,
0.5490566492,
-0.1153428257,
0.3417914212,
0.5669798255,
0.6405898929,
0.2374693304,
-0.0978135094,
-0.1588044167,
-0.3258350492,
0.2576059401,
-0.1700196713,
-0.5287384391,
-0.3970012069,
0.0289758909,
0.6491478086,
0.7388601899,
0.0700117499,
0.2907101214,
-0.0294524468,
0.8447166681,
-0.699036777,
0.0756405219,
-0.7965013981,
0.0034392106,
-0.2198875397,
-0.2730132043,
-0.4801583886,
-0.1875369996,
-0.048815757,
-0.3607463539,
0.2024327368,
0.2311013788,
0.8688827753,
0.6255720854,
0.0836417601,
-0.3522616625,
-0.7563459277,
0.911703229,
-0.7825580835,
0.6331359744,
0.2460411936,
0.0833730549,
0.0769238248,
-0.7308450937,
-0.4789101183,
-0.2310212404,
-0.059945792,
0.3579360843,
-0.4555285871,
0.4720570147,
0.376365155,
0.4740131497,
-0.1938037574,
0.2845793068,
-0.5315311551,
-0.0921516716,
0.182259351,
-0.1329664886,
-0.0030866789,
-0.2378554195,
-0.5002713203,
0.2230146974,
-0.4700036347,
0.0373945944,
0.4508899152,
0.3261994421,
0.2093406618,
0.696244359,
-0.0500119217,
0.5206612349,
0.1693365425,
-0.0863427594,
0.0929354951,
-0.6080099344,
-0.198819384,
0.0870019421,
0.566934526,
0.168818742,
0.2514833212,
-0.5969254971,
-0.5058013201,
0.2307106405,
0.4030444026,
-1.2662966251,
-0.2831806242,
0.494941175,
-0.7976996899,
-0.1904874742,
0.2642520964,
-0.4144775569,
0.1364888251,
-0.1027007103,
0.5115245581,
-0.3043166101,
-0.252376467,
-0.1004922464,
-0.7139564753,
0.0063076331,
-0.0645125732,
-0.9716712832,
0.218874082,
0.9826450944,
1.1929994822,
-0.1957717389,
-0.3049845099,
-0.5587680936,
0.0065637096,
-0.5019668937,
0.7238208055,
-0.4665271938,
-0.2170080543,
-0.2074930072,
-0.2443258315,
-0.3418255746,
-0.5120905638,
0.5997830033,
-0.3249810934,
-0.2086029947,
-0.3455943465,
-0.7395526171,
-0.3425902724,
-0.393245101,
-0.6132919192,
0.7228493094,
0.0712072775,
-0.710468173,
0.9252867103,
-0.7876794338,
-0.3562464416,
0.1172264218,
0.3568553925,
-0.3535576761,
0.6176660657,
-0.1433261186,
0.2977395654,
0.2136354446,
0.3060783744,
-0.1499157101,
-0.87002635,
0.3769651353,
-0.5823405981,
0.4831934869,
0.0663589984,
-0.6181305051,
0.0316917934,
-0.8369457126,
0.0852062926,
-0.5927379727,
-0.4716278017,
-0.2088924944,
0.0124894781,
0.0743831322,
-0.0175110064,
0.0900209621,
-0.8361811638,
-0.1641019434,
-0.5702429414,
0.4332341254,
1.0248618126,
-0.0099048754,
0.4157726169,
-0.4851711392,
0.4861018062,
-0.031617932,
0.1655438244,
-0.0472121872,
-0.7772823572,
-0.9339698553,
-0.7924678326,
0.6745730042,
0.4231252968,
-0.1552116126,
0.4601908028,
-0.3544721901,
-0.6823990941,
-0.4720277488,
0.0118979691,
0.3687508702,
0.2540536225,
0.374160558,
-0.6309254766,
-0.6077520251,
-0.6487210393,
-0.5389475822,
-0.2481981814,
0.0748104602,
0.190036878,
0.5158299804,
-0.0963602588,
0.6831710339,
0.1164187863,
-0.289565593,
-0.4114247561,
0.2920919061,
0.4863649309,
0.7874983549,
0.5487499833,
-0.4384359121,
-0.3213581741,
-0.1588002592,
-0.3703967333,
-0.3044752479,
-0.1633765399,
-0.2073096782,
0.3535476923,
0.2874307036,
-0.6787689328,
0.5111430883,
0.440718472,
-0.3415116668,
0.536460638,
-0.1441598982,
-0.0219325554,
-0.4983110428,
0.3362345099,
-0.0259529203,
-0.0459710695,
-0.8288637996,
0.0773729309,
-0.1075818986,
-0.0768171325,
-0.2482100874,
0.4613717198,
-0.2759158909,
-0.179360196,
-0.2916050553,
0.1159010082,
-0.0105033796,
0.5511608124,
0.0311526898,
0.735049665,
0.5364793539,
-0.8154492378,
0.1229273453,
-0.0166064706,
-0.2242557555,
0.4930015504,
-1.0264348984,
0.0041102474,
-0.2172880769,
0.1957057416,
-0.7632884383,
0.1876146495,
0.2625342011,
-0.7428050637,
0.4231916666,
-0.1453202367,
-0.1504980475,
-0.0927096978,
-0.6226551533,
0.1836823374,
0.5075306892,
-0.7247523665,
0.3165342212,
0.0555159897,
0.4280207455,
-0.818932116,
-1.0979239941,
-0.1278952956,
-0.3123709559,
-0.4488685727,
0.2107889056,
0.000438933,
0.033187367,
0.2795440555,
-0.336653024,
0.085635826,
0.2433883995,
0.4147002697,
0.2784376442,
-0.142621547,
0.2201257199,
-0.2493503243,
-0.2471648753,
0.1342398673,
-0.7294501066,
0.4393179417,
0.0069552814,
-0.3957448304,
-0.6512820721,
0.2726903856,
0.3108833134,
-0.0009323744,
1.0113325119,
0.9776567221,
-0.3070850074,
0.0885220468,
-0.5929850936,
-0.1515678018,
-0.4246191382,
0.4221025109,
-0.4820737839,
-0.602159977,
0.4985024631,
0.0247154199,
0.102120474,
0.3410414457,
0.3233068585,
0.1596750915,
0.8871216774,
0.6120305657,
0.2325608283,
0.7166921496,
-0.4940480888,
0.7992012501,
-1.1754355431,
-0.0486394316,
-0.6090703607,
-0.4595772326,
-0.9147959352,
-0.3317137361,
0.1155823767,
0.4115861058,
-0.1600255817,
0.3967639804,
-0.4145857096,
0.2536458969,
0.8340561986,
-0.1013827175,
0.3095680773,
0.0312375352,
0.2162322402,
-0.1718662083,
-1.039939642,
-0.450534761,
1.2422134876,
0.3220477402,
0.5980522037,
0.0592786297,
0.7404890656,
0.1820917577,
0.3234627247,
-1.0425584316,
0.2945692241,
-0.2376128584,
-0.6048019528,
-0.3498510122,
-0.5132380128,
-0.8767043948,
0.3487744927,
-0.345657289,
-0.8802641034,
0.619469583,
0.2059274316,
-0.0665191039,
0.5935240388,
-0.750726819,
0.9213184118,
0.2386986613,
-0.1125307083,
-0.2966153026,
-0.0542277768,
0.2476903647,
-0.1381667852,
0.0411161557,
0.0031215434,
-0.2909293473,
0.9500135183,
-0.3577386737,
0.6073391438,
-0.441159308,
0.5731252432,
0.2573589385,
-0.1445927322,
0.4970189333,
-0.1075447202,
-0.2404142767,
0.4958196282,
-0.0965892747,
-0.56665802,
-0.7274736762,
0.4891997576,
-0.558609724,
-0.3982018828,
-0.3568563759,
-0.1437506229,
0.1197250485,
0.0698053092,
0.5923481584,
0.8482183218,
-0.2111646384,
0.2352238595,
0.230682224,
-0.0234635882,
0.6013839841,
0.0664558262,
0.0111186933,
-0.3745619655,
1.1781280041,
0.3469672501,
0.4862027764,
0.2395876199,
0.3983871341,
-0.530870378,
-0.7693066597,
-0.5610440969,
0.204467088,
-0.8873492479,
-0.1679762453,
-0.7424644828,
-0.1037779599,
-0.3343918324,
-0.1930323988,
-0.4761350453,
-0.7972518802,
-0.0253657512,
-0.2292484641,
0.2132266462,
0.8081771135,
-0.6797551513,
0.0791270807,
-0.5491120815,
0.1451241225,
0.1215396672,
0.4376684427,
0.3531129062,
-0.636903882,
-0.4305270016,
-0.1153419465,
-0.1299119592,
-0.6351032853,
0.2345083356,
0.4386945963,
0.7533314228,
0.4084289074,
0.0431920327,
0.7557867169,
-0.2615715265,
0.9881458879,
0.3340206146,
-1.3039827347,
0.3395956755,
0.0719124004,
-0.0557464249,
0.4401579201,
0.1820249707,
-0.5659849644,
-0.6803491116,
-0.7469234467,
-1.0131217241,
0.4566500485,
0.1304043233,
0.2182185054,
-0.1022283062,
0.1861054301,
0.2695896029,
0.5404272676,
-0.8805416822,
-0.3908938766,
-0.6314119697,
0.1547002792,
0.0838481486,
-0.4535053074,
0.3371784091,
-0.2540900707,
0.9911915064,
0.0896284804,
0.5576817989,
0.4398051202,
0.0020275631,
-0.2133377045,
0.1880016774,
0.3475494683,
0.9492650032,
-0.3547543883,
-0.0195297971,
-0.0387492292,
-0.5332856774,
0.0092285685,
-0.2659817934,
-0.4075354934,
0.3483817279,
0.546310246,
1.0934101343,
0.1084065586,
-0.4181125462,
0.5594169497,
0.1169453338,
-0.244136706,
-0.2160982937,
-0.0445597321,
-0.2214967161,
0.0853821412,
0.2423080951,
0.4641956389,
0.1784316152,
-0.6758058667,
0.1297443062,
0.7108622789,
-0.5960996747,
-0.2506564856,
0.7378519177,
0.264103353,
-0.5210085511,
0.4961650074,
-0.5439335108,
-0.5649134517,
0.435356468,
0.5925176144,
1.0841150284,
0.2902632654,
0.0531964079,
0.6431607008,
0.4061619937,
0.0923381522,
0.0254329331,
-0.2560075223,
-0.6476744413,
-0.6624577045,
-0.6642938852,
-0.3334034085,
-0.0656390786,
-0.7358366847,
-0.0837958902,
-0.2989528775,
-0.2395651937,
0.0520608351,
-0.0287763793,
-0.5552910566,
0.0156384148,
-0.2857878804,
0.8293161988,
-0.6198634505,
0.579077661,
0.4938204587,
-0.1124008596,
-0.5867677927,
0.209748745,
-0.5660151839,
-0.5477516055,
0.8957341909,
0.3653395474,
-0.1525699645,
-0.2769875228,
-0.0480643176,
-0.738990128,
0.9776083231,
0.0855952799,
-0.247984916,
0.2703187466,
-0.0843044445,
0.4923999906,
-0.2174635977,
0.4437903762,
0.4378385544,
0.7157549858,
-0.1058057472,
-0.9638426304,
0.0343705453,
-0.2922560573,
0.2380123287,
0.2849502861,
-0.628017962,
0.6052155495,
-0.3618701398,
-0.6524263024,
0.0257742684,
0.5484521985,
-0.0730821565,
0.3729657829,
0.4991820157,
0.6300494075,
0.7219230533,
-0.1858347505,
1.0536334515,
-0.5179163814,
0.3007126749,
0.4839923978,
0.3464851379,
0.7927693725,
0.5758783221,
-0.2634316683,
0.2530096173,
0.2825107872,
-0.0754581988,
0.5077201724,
0.27841115,
-0.1504289955,
-0.1500621885,
-0.2894610763,
-0.1709792763,
0.4633705318,
0.012412753,
-0.1045175418,
0.0220791381,
-0.2209625542,
-0.1765156835,
0.0667065457,
-0.3339411914,
0.5377408266,
0.0352178365,
-0.5926927924,
0.6100007296,
0.1208733916,
1.2146072388,
-0.4753421545,
0.07503815,
-0.0365269519,
0.1042050347,
-0.2841908634,
-0.2421879619,
0.8286808729,
0.0193734448,
-0.073503308,
-0.1326396018,
0.7763780951,
-0.0573338643,
-0.4342365265,
0.3414492905,
0.6890998483,
0.4144233465,
-0.080654636,
-0.5743744969,
-0.122191608,
-0.1642903239,
-0.2990956008,
0.2343980819,
0.3578687906,
0.5502449274,
0.7299754024,
0.8165177703,
0.6273792982,
0.2409244627,
0.1366081089,
0.5448358059,
-0.6416872144,
-0.517441988,
-0.9776211381,
0.2009771764,
-0.0585110299,
-0.307766825,
0.6910922527,
0.6074896455,
0.9240683913,
0.0852042586,
0.6289294958,
0.0462608188,
0.3241744339,
-0.5105545521,
0.4228184819,
-0.3660762012,
0.0650178269,
-0.203860715,
-0.966350019,
0.1456273198,
0.7187254429,
0.054444328,
0.0354888514,
0.982073009,
0.731754899,
0.1216224656,
0.1626886129,
0.4836004078,
-0.000867487,
0.1382752061,
0.2847551107,
0.666079402,
-0.4948626757,
0.3756612539,
-0.463996172,
-0.218666181,
0.0376203395,
-0.857994318,
-1.0311378241,
-0.5378223658,
-0.2337168008,
-0.2954804599,
0.2667801976,
0.7516075373,
0.9331079721,
-0.7424861193,
-0.054075405,
-0.4203153253,
0.3080893755,
-0.5463027954,
-0.203376472,
0.1830062568,
-0.6317683458,
-0.9556499124,
0.3049481511,
0.4375198483,
0.0247217193,
-0.4105249345,
0.1141174436,
0.1945433468,
0.3620862067,
0.4295753837,
-0.0527354889,
-0.7266902328,
-0.4839843214,
-0.1092438027,
0.1826999784,
0.0710759982,
1.090957284,
-0.7055174708,
0.1288992316,
0.597335875,
0.491894424,
0.5280435085,
0.2598978877,
0.4197537899,
-0.5143125057,
0.3585151732,
0.1159652993,
0.2554784119,
0.218728289,
-0.5079583526,
0.5280504823,
0.4926102757,
-0.7184417844,
-0.8927720785,
0.3078326583,
-0.8498743773,
-0.2841002345,
1.0704796314,
-0.3373842239,
-0.2490788847,
-0.3353728652,
0.1361937672,
0.2280259132,
-0.6266044378,
0.5717099309,
0.734801352,
-0.4181359708,
0.2609494328,
-0.7276718616,
0.4652648866,
0.5544917583,
-0.2136287391,
0.0002480689,
0.0584332868,
-0.0070900866,
0.3182559907,
0.8597080708,
0.0349876545,
0.1487860382,
0.3232049942,
-0.1398359537,
-0.173871547,
-0.1004580781,
-0.3149584532,
-0.1183895245,
0.3890070021,
-0.3429496288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14568v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14568v1
|
LLM-DA: Data Augmentation via Large Language Models for Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-22T14:19:56 | 2024-02-22T14:19:56 |
Junjie Ye, Nuo Xu, Yikun Wang, Jie Zhou, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the impressive capabilities of large language models (LLMs), their
performance on information extraction tasks is still not entirely satisfactory.
However, their remarkable rewriting capabilities and extensive world knowledge
offer valuable insights to improve these tasks. In this paper, we propose
$LLM-DA$, a novel data augmentation technique based on LLMs for the few-shot
NER task. To overcome the limitations of existing data augmentation methods
that compromise semantic integrity and address the uncertainty inherent in
LLM-generated text, we leverage the distinctive characteristics of the NER task
by augmenting the original data at both the contextual and entity levels. Our
approach involves employing 14 contextual rewriting strategies, designing
entity replacements of the same type, and incorporating noise injection to
enhance robustness. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach in enhancing NER model performance with limited data. Furthermore,
additional analyses provide further evidence supporting the assertion that the
quality of the data we generate surpasses that of other existing methods.
|
[
-0.3827291131,
-1.0633969307,
0.6732693315,
-0.3966641128,
-0.3672402203,
-0.1132094264,
-0.1370390058,
-0.6120291352,
0.3208872676,
0.7098799348,
-0.5881103873,
-0.5713647008,
-0.7246084809,
0.4931473434,
-0.3594629765,
0.8666644692,
0.1360200942,
0.0249597542,
-0.0196503196,
0.1923542917,
-0.3124476075,
-0.3237846196,
-0.6079387069,
-0.364331007,
0.6860410571,
0.6331856251,
0.5372461081,
0.7524769306,
0.7800382376,
0.2209926993,
-0.1527806222,
0.4599796534,
-0.5322130322,
0.1698230654,
-0.0791685879,
-0.4581609368,
-0.8867672086,
-0.3419990838,
0.8957155347,
0.7404287457,
0.1027687192,
-0.0235070847,
0.1048496887,
0.498924464,
-0.6682639122,
-0.0352367721,
-0.9474028349,
-0.2892107368,
-0.4253479838,
-0.1878530085,
-0.2430188656,
-0.0776491389,
0.1380824,
-0.6665354967,
-0.0328763723,
-0.0837331414,
0.8322758079,
0.5682625771,
-0.5128836036,
-0.0731989071,
-0.8410698771,
0.7681856155,
-0.9152943492,
0.2192931026,
0.3137196302,
0.2520787716,
-0.5609131455,
-0.6209486127,
-0.8774805069,
0.0466430783,
0.1077107713,
-0.187903747,
-0.2781791687,
-0.0088986009,
0.3100207746,
0.2664187849,
-0.1192013547,
0.384188354,
-0.1302498281,
0.0970104709,
0.6117374301,
0.3215957582,
0.356351465,
-0.192134425,
-0.3674675822,
0.2219966054,
-0.9726099372,
-0.4546005726,
0.4594214559,
0.4638719857,
-0.001698273,
0.8972225785,
-0.5004127026,
0.7577690482,
0.1279445738,
-0.5303563476,
0.2050129771,
-0.3132451177,
-0.2577767372,
0.0570348538,
0.4388601482,
0.2583117485,
-0.0648789182,
-0.1236240938,
-0.4157539606,
-0.077732712,
0.0287138596,
-0.9447796345,
-0.0491318814,
-0.027227575,
-0.2329188883,
-0.3492040038,
0.0169704705,
-0.8063190579,
-0.4003400505,
-0.3615724146,
0.4721814692,
-0.4683566689,
-0.2296393216,
-0.0294715855,
0.0733119324,
0.2943824828,
0.4809274375,
-0.6669823527,
0.3455672264,
0.8486930132,
0.6204246879,
-0.4799472392,
-0.1918556094,
-0.6354487538,
0.4526799321,
-0.4405574501,
0.9143821001,
-0.8308246136,
-0.2649549544,
-0.4394909441,
-0.0480323024,
0.4000312388,
-0.5264187455,
0.5815093517,
-0.7609624267,
-0.1839205623,
-0.1997080147,
-0.8580560684,
-0.2376477867,
0.3116393685,
-0.7656498551,
0.8317045569,
0.0757363066,
-0.7295510769,
0.6844406724,
-0.4987704456,
-0.3605063558,
0.2696424425,
-0.2151269168,
-0.4219788015,
0.2385822237,
0.4946604371,
0.3791166246,
-0.3731321692,
0.1232171878,
-0.3069199324,
-0.427454114,
0.2796067297,
-0.64878124,
0.3932797611,
-0.1010946184,
0.0069164895,
-0.236399591,
-1.0218350887,
-0.1236586943,
0.1811232716,
-0.4735571146,
-0.4665999413,
-0.3244323134,
0.0108404886,
0.0489087403,
0.2144801617,
-0.5951513648,
0.4079142213,
-0.8059571385,
0.1258647889,
0.5506561995,
0.3939023316,
0.8046706915,
-0.3683906198,
0.5327422023,
0.2002336681,
-0.408672601,
-0.2301658839,
-0.3362833858,
-0.648291111,
-0.5597797632,
0.5681263208,
0.4544809461,
-0.8869273067,
0.3625993431,
-0.7086167336,
-0.3317246437,
-0.4874938726,
0.4002615213,
-0.0627756938,
0.8214100599,
0.3966536522,
-0.195012182,
-0.7637367845,
-0.8628662229,
-0.0718031302,
0.1499810964,
-0.0925117284,
0.4358763695,
0.607386291,
-0.5558436513,
1.073489666,
-0.5092838407,
-0.4641968608,
-0.3053650856,
-0.0577597991,
0.3356350362,
0.4902099967,
0.085048683,
-0.5130288601,
-0.3908673525,
-0.060574472,
-0.647200942,
-0.1185173169,
-0.2096288204,
0.1195576936,
0.1481489688,
0.3446912467,
-0.5259884596,
0.4943164289,
0.2267692685,
0.2162945569,
0.1824522913,
-0.1442745924,
-0.01464443,
-1.0845634937,
-0.227358833,
-0.1039670259,
-0.2401033193,
-0.7735817432,
-0.043542318,
-0.0068928986,
0.0185068883,
-0.6771365404,
0.8169436455,
-0.7410024405,
-0.1411810368,
-0.781583488,
0.2487420887,
-0.0553414673,
0.0390635096,
0.0272141173,
0.6493067741,
0.7935081124,
-0.7544840574,
0.287281543,
0.3557963967,
-0.3999788463,
0.8178691864,
-0.5422255397,
0.3950158954,
-0.4718720317,
0.3815145493,
-0.5266059637,
-0.5457960367,
0.1654566526,
-0.3022947013,
0.448149085,
-0.4201595485,
-0.5591163039,
0.0771659762,
-0.026986042,
0.4412704706,
0.3095310926,
-0.6199941635,
0.6359618902,
0.5139722824,
-0.24782525,
-0.5547447801,
-0.965360105,
0.5769308805,
-0.4689535499,
-0.654150188,
0.7610619068,
0.1586672068,
-0.283885181,
0.0780244023,
-0.1533409059,
-0.2073407471,
0.0572931394,
0.2195442468,
0.4995817542,
-0.1577207446,
0.158623457,
0.1064011082,
-0.4780509174,
-0.2902686,
-0.0902564824,
0.3412670791,
0.3161341548,
-0.329757154,
-0.6745418906,
0.3160152733,
0.1480688304,
0.0483842269,
0.6289119124,
0.548474133,
-0.7967369556,
-0.2904749811,
-0.5306260586,
-0.3857522607,
-0.4279614687,
0.239219293,
-0.7383064628,
-0.7343381643,
0.2416304797,
-0.2624314427,
-0.2003343403,
0.3948268294,
0.4296283126,
0.0178210158,
0.742524147,
0.7002193332,
-0.2014448941,
0.3706829846,
-0.1898150146,
0.1563642323,
-0.9630638957,
0.0254695509,
-0.2007388175,
-0.4050529301,
-0.4417216182,
-0.5760494471,
0.3526593745,
0.0926897675,
0.0753243938,
0.2921603024,
-0.2224976122,
0.6321065426,
0.292430222,
0.20494771,
0.5042864084,
0.0185897499,
0.3057796955,
-0.2886715233,
-0.4091976583,
-0.8589106202,
1.2835025787,
0.2611013353,
1.0858000517,
0.2086139321,
1.0870586634,
-0.0764179155,
0.1229434758,
-0.9360667467,
0.5123191476,
-0.0483192317,
-0.4812609553,
-0.3291582167,
-0.3006128371,
-0.9530709982,
0.0806157812,
-0.559643209,
-0.7182388306,
0.3003328741,
-0.1677693725,
-0.4212353528,
0.2575818598,
-0.3453032374,
0.3092260063,
-0.0789999813,
-0.2635720074,
-0.006650073,
-0.3880485594,
0.4075214863,
-0.4329419136,
0.0598917753,
-0.1211320981,
-0.6184726357,
0.5054459572,
-0.5002735853,
0.6954346895,
-0.0273727328,
-0.286873728,
0.295324415,
-0.028620502,
1.1446346045,
0.2174073011,
-0.2831074893,
0.1615417898,
-0.3503138721,
-0.1647387296,
-0.6624396443,
0.8337473273,
-0.2427300364,
-0.5969160199,
-0.2593174577,
-0.7736899257,
-0.0488408804,
0.3495239019,
0.1353226751,
0.1784161478,
-0.2671712339,
0.2617278695,
0.3989419937,
-0.1093738005,
0.3922955692,
0.4319439232,
0.0740039796,
-0.4532882869,
0.7957505584,
0.2186765224,
0.1916667223,
0.4510351121,
-0.2003873587,
-0.2600569129,
-0.8273240924,
-0.274720192,
0.1142915189,
-0.6995310783,
-0.3313636184,
-0.9485185742,
-0.1286830157,
-0.4011087418,
-0.0795890167,
-0.2294210196,
-0.5188323855,
-0.646022737,
-0.1216155365,
0.3596011102,
0.5834545493,
-0.1305688769,
0.5961221457,
-0.668109715,
0.7436422706,
0.2014932483,
0.0971778631,
-0.2923662364,
-0.6594323516,
0.1413025856,
0.0985252336,
0.0907949954,
-0.9452268481,
0.7311502695,
0.2448070794,
0.4801044166,
0.1970346868,
0.0521066897,
0.9080209732,
-0.614122808,
0.4720810056,
-0.0485699326,
-0.7747722864,
0.6055075526,
-0.1281607896,
0.1404480934,
0.599167943,
0.082134679,
-0.077877678,
-0.1389334947,
-0.5939691663,
-0.8146964312,
0.5904245377,
0.1360193938,
0.3066516221,
-0.0235342141,
0.5201213956,
0.1753796786,
-0.0463182665,
-0.6150593758,
-0.2661179006,
0.3732542098,
-0.1261392832,
0.0794158131,
-0.3427963853,
0.1398416311,
0.0066147242,
0.7492408156,
-0.1576131284,
-0.0339111984,
0.2375140041,
-0.3861193955,
-0.0902087986,
0.5333613157,
0.3087059259,
0.4503344595,
-0.048995506,
0.207312569,
0.6354637742,
-0.3111645281,
0.1600958109,
0.0860555694,
-0.5724862814,
0.0636428371,
0.1391743124,
0.6417887807,
0.1668914706,
-0.495005846,
0.3706112802,
0.1662489176,
0.0963720456,
-0.2539737225,
0.1265777498,
-0.0358392,
0.3704313338,
0.5158806443,
-0.0948252529,
0.2642684877,
-0.3669684827,
0.4543296099,
0.5788068771,
-0.1822671741,
-0.1328506768,
0.5723778605,
-0.0724056885,
-0.20130077,
0.3016965091,
-0.3641772568,
-0.0647905692,
0.4323940575,
0.813646853,
0.6620564461,
0.0239225682,
-0.0537301674,
0.485635072,
0.358453393,
-0.0457688272,
0.3168862164,
0.2045817077,
-0.8083405495,
-0.5355994701,
-0.5081786513,
-0.3571437001,
0.2425900996,
-0.3501795828,
0.6983810067,
-0.3189247549,
-0.2911712527,
0.2042785883,
-0.0276477747,
-0.734164536,
0.2510695457,
0.1135429144,
0.5779933929,
-0.4539551139,
1.0305030346,
0.5184216499,
-0.4693306983,
-0.5031855702,
0.0817206204,
0.2314825505,
-0.5834161639,
0.8307412863,
0.0372989736,
-0.0578901581,
0.2608754337,
-0.4661537111,
-1.1508083344,
1.1790446043,
0.51098001,
-0.696782589,
-0.1393621266,
0.1860760152,
0.3096754551,
-0.6214260459,
0.0847596079,
0.6323027015,
0.6069000959,
0.1963417083,
-0.532546699,
0.0594805963,
0.1413252652,
0.0521776751,
0.0936784074,
-0.0337017775,
0.6797486544,
-0.501200974,
-0.572393477,
0.1247803122,
0.8431048393,
0.2406469434,
0.1703860462,
0.4783655703,
0.6852350831,
0.9251179695,
0.0953770354,
0.9080663323,
-0.1671240628,
0.1178576425,
1.5174299479,
-0.4861447215,
0.8716193438,
0.5897922516,
-0.0775967315,
0.2923875451,
0.3022910058,
-0.1851804405,
0.4078803957,
0.1568876952,
-0.4246795177,
-0.1639981568,
-0.4016057849,
-0.1298374683,
0.7171891332,
0.379314363,
-0.2565276027,
-0.2521049976,
-0.0688912123,
-0.083109431,
-0.0798306987,
-0.2125079036,
0.9836613536,
0.2403187007,
-0.1936679482,
0.436981678,
0.1866833121,
1.0034527779,
-0.0721510351,
-0.223672092,
-0.0225454662,
-0.059731748,
-0.3596614003,
-0.5860607624,
0.4175272584,
0.2570013702,
-0.1134031564,
0.032432694,
1.0264396667,
-0.4591673017,
-0.6456511617,
0.0620031431,
0.6550076008,
0.2922276258,
-0.198099494,
-0.3723228276,
-0.072048828,
-0.320091337,
0.0178907085,
0.2507967651,
0.5448986292,
0.1967748851,
0.6861711144,
0.7316800952,
0.3864283562,
0.0329207964,
0.0925681368,
0.7742321491,
-0.7157204747,
-0.2044313997,
-1.0585787296,
0.4379389584,
-0.042056717,
-0.0926713869,
0.7277432084,
0.6191183329,
0.6470391154,
0.1177739426,
0.7009987831,
0.1207409278,
0.555924356,
-0.5948519707,
0.4894295037,
-0.445941925,
0.4927897155,
-0.4718979597,
-1.1899141073,
-0.4669281244,
0.311460346,
-0.3230535984,
-0.1393391639,
0.3843355179,
1.1551297903,
-0.1002810225,
-0.2823323309,
0.5552842021,
0.2151759267,
0.1660206318,
0.5993682146,
0.8025943041,
-0.7435270548,
0.5694121122,
-0.2949880362,
0.0427436084,
-0.0641292259,
-1.0464913845,
-0.5979326367,
-0.3433487713,
-0.4968019128,
-0.0379485339,
-0.1743208468,
0.8593982458,
0.6417464614,
-0.6334496737,
0.4075519741,
-0.1745126247,
0.2575577199,
0.1143858135,
-0.2083006352,
0.1618180126,
-0.1591404378,
-1.2257231474,
1.0074901581,
0.4393750727,
0.3511759043,
-0.0091837635,
-0.1719712466,
-0.1551014334,
0.054040134,
0.4153887928,
0.0153154759,
-0.8989413977,
-0.2068195492,
-0.0234808791,
-0.158475861,
0.2372078747,
0.3824437261,
-0.8191986084,
0.4367766976,
0.500418663,
1.0581928492,
0.5487428904,
0.1063154638,
0.42265293,
-0.7598424554,
0.0110970531,
0.2652100325,
0.4953270257,
0.5450006127,
-0.4666498303,
0.4600723982,
0.0628958866,
-0.4083126485,
-0.9231421947,
0.177510336,
-1.0397814512,
-0.0763945356,
1.3362816572,
0.05789252,
-0.142251879,
-0.0973627865,
-0.1827814281,
0.2131568044,
-0.4194524288,
0.4525482655,
0.5252326131,
0.0799208581,
-0.3472007215,
-0.4993450344,
0.2381092161,
0.0974772051,
-1.0288516283,
-0.1592600942,
0.7159352899,
0.3796782792,
-0.0818181485,
0.609181881,
-0.1751812398,
-0.0029455319,
0.0500977077,
-0.1127952635,
-0.0404949524,
-0.2620912492,
-0.6421911716,
0.09003786,
0.0790827796,
-0.0550326928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00021v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00021v2
|
SIMPLOT: Enhancing Chart Question Answering by Distilling Essentials
| 2024-02-22T14:04:22 | 2024-06-17T12:21:33 |
Wonjoong Kim, Sangwu Park, Yeonjun In, Seokwon Han, Chanyoung Park
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, interpreting complex charts with logical reasoning has emerged as
challenges due to the development of vision-language models. A prior
state-of-the-art (SOTA) model has presented an end-to-end method that leverages
the vision-language model to convert charts into table format utilizing Large
Language Model (LLM) for reasoning. However, unlike natural images, charts
contain a mix of essential and irrelevant information required for chart
reasoning, and we discover that this characteristic can lower the performance
of chart-to-table extraction. In this paper, we introduce SIMPLOT, a method
designed to extract only the elements necessary for chart reasoning. The
proposed method involves two steps: 1) training to mimic a simple plot that
contains only the essential information from a complex chart for table
extraction, followed by 2) performing reasoning based on the table. Our model
enables accurate chart reasoning without the need for additional annotations or
datasets, and its effectiveness is demonstrated through various experiments.
Furthermore, we propose a novel prompt mimicking how human interpret charts for
more accurate reasoning. Our source code is available at
https://github.com/sangwu99/Simplot.
|
[
-0.3160051703,
-0.9019829631,
0.9499616027,
-0.2093937248,
-0.8917732239,
0.0485476591,
0.0982912704,
-0.5385611057,
0.2386877984,
0.6029148102,
-0.7830582857,
-0.4281045198,
-0.4424474537,
0.0331054479,
-0.4240317941,
0.7810809016,
0.0135806799,
0.1141333878,
-0.2987637818,
0.0135529507,
-0.5660507083,
-0.1841338128,
-0.432102263,
-0.183202967,
0.4097310901,
0.9284731746,
0.6941750646,
0.712446332,
0.4932567477,
0.2236321867,
-0.0022553813,
0.3610157073,
-0.6037281752,
0.3417827487,
-0.0656539202,
-0.720032692,
-0.4379479885,
-0.1924581081,
-0.169512853,
0.7607696652,
0.2346965671,
0.5269892216,
-0.0542177781,
0.850122273,
-0.3649180233,
0.8441650867,
-0.337877363,
-0.1995583773,
-0.180313617,
-0.4423525333,
-0.4812044799,
-0.5977844596,
0.1740115881,
-0.991484046,
-0.1596909612,
0.1911910623,
0.9763624072,
0.6145468354,
-0.5816655159,
-0.3542425632,
-0.7309501767,
0.3899741173,
-0.399649322,
0.0200700667,
0.2310072184,
1.0076751709,
0.0458916239,
-1.266882658,
-0.6784474254,
-0.1214170232,
-0.2160547227,
0.3146062493,
-0.0063942005,
-0.0992229432,
0.4791221917,
-0.0226256512,
-0.4451682866,
-0.3813228011,
-0.5220956802,
0.0112227276,
0.7171189189,
0.2319823802,
0.7147840261,
-0.1592348963,
-0.3875455558,
-0.222522676,
-0.6335741878,
0.1250308752,
-0.1132638231,
0.2485053688,
0.0182525534,
0.5077784657,
-0.2422362864,
0.6335409284,
-0.1253518313,
-0.2439484745,
0.2151655108,
0.1315952688,
-0.0540419929,
0.0952422321,
0.3524987698,
0.5859020352,
0.7378139496,
0.0769381896,
0.0707127899,
0.07766743,
-0.0565821193,
-0.5083401799,
-0.4557861984,
0.2150525451,
-0.0646132827,
-0.1126072034,
0.0262575671,
-0.7145937085,
-0.5892074704,
-0.6829051375,
0.3410746753,
-0.6232589483,
0.0269880444,
0.008576978,
-0.5772068501,
0.1736252755,
0.9251249433,
-0.3404968977,
0.0278321486,
0.6210565567,
0.4599430263,
0.1402311325,
-0.1856139302,
-0.5743129849,
0.414994061,
-0.429994911,
1.0147101879,
-0.4870947301,
0.1223843396,
-0.4538484812,
-0.2017548084,
0.2096686959,
-0.396566391,
0.76307863,
-0.5528054237,
-0.117577523,
-0.7488642335,
-0.7455327511,
-0.5723288059,
0.2396243215,
-0.8810719848,
0.5747125745,
0.0022852614,
-0.6903205514,
0.3898428082,
-0.7065654993,
-0.3574113846,
0.3674100339,
-0.5783376694,
-0.1545730978,
-0.349891156,
0.7690687776,
0.270506978,
-0.5410908461,
0.1046333015,
-0.3285239041,
-0.4314852357,
0.2888233662,
-0.1776166111,
0.7797793746,
0.5861200094,
-0.459281534,
0.1196179762,
-0.5332937837,
0.1550963819,
0.5395989418,
0.1532482952,
-0.1189201251,
0.0416607484,
0.0400272571,
0.0923338607,
0.234425813,
-0.3194971383,
0.2192271352,
-0.1083141416,
0.2235758752,
0.671713531,
0.0007543085,
0.1448907703,
-0.1170466393,
0.6119733453,
-0.0030302266,
-0.0195966233,
-0.1540884227,
-0.5042037964,
-0.7792652845,
-0.6237936616,
0.3310289979,
0.534211874,
-1.0077568293,
0.2306964844,
-0.737262845,
-0.6354411244,
-0.1709150821,
0.1012323797,
-0.1830496937,
0.7467839718,
0.3835908771,
-0.0096816318,
-0.4970014989,
-0.770092845,
-0.1950627267,
0.2020963579,
-0.0857605785,
0.0480613336,
0.0839858949,
0.2454416305,
1.2838810682,
-1.1128612757,
-0.1171946824,
-1.0954203606,
0.0372236408,
0.2118218094,
0.0252797268,
0.8507479429,
-0.8487318158,
-0.7750250101,
-0.1674975306,
-1.0815532207,
-0.3712944686,
-0.447822541,
-0.3281904757,
-0.5873835087,
0.8172633648,
-0.6106792688,
0.7306351066,
-0.0553578697,
-0.535364449,
0.4316593111,
-0.0321888849,
0.0041523399,
-0.5611901283,
0.229898259,
-0.1719115973,
-0.4574898183,
-0.6543641686,
0.2986475527,
0.0466067865,
-0.3830703795,
-0.1778198928,
0.5612927675,
-0.4325300455,
0.1138572097,
-0.2283246815,
0.3335767388,
0.3440393209,
0.4639944434,
0.0379590243,
0.5219461322,
0.6106212735,
-0.3973448575,
0.4894082844,
0.4087550938,
-0.3328146338,
0.3870199323,
-0.5018032193,
0.0938287824,
-0.5877251029,
0.3777274191,
-1.235648036,
-0.2437108159,
0.3734948635,
-0.08048933,
0.2125902623,
-0.1180419549,
-0.4444144368,
-0.2895291448,
-0.1409375221,
0.0977696851,
0.5714150071,
-0.5577379465,
0.7173059583,
0.1768212914,
-0.3609245718,
-0.4794112444,
-0.619628191,
0.0255814064,
-0.1941218078,
-0.6921465993,
-0.3128736913,
-0.0520281196,
-0.2689529359,
-0.194266215,
-0.388831377,
-0.2934728861,
0.1407418251,
0.1878633201,
0.3911579847,
-0.1376264095,
0.1051853448,
0.1407210529,
-0.6441696286,
0.0669505,
0.3112230301,
0.4665362835,
0.0072906688,
-0.748263061,
-0.7043382525,
0.2461470813,
0.8097207546,
-0.2325036228,
0.1524066478,
0.3403649032,
-0.0157439262,
-0.1575723588,
-0.2191237956,
-0.3180727363,
-0.5102540255,
0.3064277768,
-0.4606686234,
-0.1611631513,
0.2471969724,
-0.4355040491,
0.1655382961,
0.2543911338,
0.240376845,
-0.6594201922,
0.733746171,
0.0253404845,
0.4119977951,
0.2169415951,
-0.4037656188,
0.4364059567,
-0.162152648,
-0.118919231,
-0.246059984,
-0.6911668777,
0.206951946,
-0.3558764458,
0.6109306216,
0.2288327068,
-0.2316517234,
-0.1964415908,
-0.2685346007,
0.7432622313,
0.479549557,
0.4379697144,
0.4443349242,
-0.0073824637,
0.072738573,
-0.2250757664,
-0.5804360509,
-0.6320540309,
1.0365362167,
-0.0096441694,
0.8652760983,
0.0170479789,
0.4281101227,
-0.0327791646,
0.4096625447,
-0.5622838736,
0.7471626997,
-0.0128469719,
-0.6706354618,
-0.4473264217,
-0.4328806698,
-0.8282583356,
0.3072757125,
-0.1520376354,
-0.5582144856,
-0.0181661472,
0.3161341846,
-0.2193726897,
0.2627702057,
-1.034239769,
1.0197155476,
-0.4816124737,
0.1011380702,
0.0848380178,
-0.7539423108,
0.264818877,
0.0737053528,
0.4772947431,
-0.4239374697,
0.1402637362,
0.2304883748,
-0.5813234448,
0.8712034225,
-0.2210468352,
0.3200851381,
0.6914173365,
0.3350901902,
0.577155292,
-0.3099302948,
0.122391589,
-0.172402367,
-0.010867577,
-0.5156826973,
-1.0195006132,
0.1616179943,
-0.6366249323,
-0.5516517162,
-0.2160121948,
-0.6810902357,
-0.2454032004,
0.0901140496,
0.0151582351,
0.3327661753,
0.3201032281,
0.1908325702,
0.2227752805,
-0.0891888812,
0.0251453556,
-0.0375310481,
-0.4733056128,
-0.0115941111,
0.7720320225,
0.2399383038,
0.39772439,
0.1614197493,
0.5406386852,
-0.4821090996,
-0.2915060818,
-0.5605583191,
0.08112479,
-1.3526973724,
-0.0284835156,
-0.4809151292,
0.0779017285,
-0.1569076627,
-0.1620424241,
-0.0955366343,
-0.8569504619,
-0.2202641517,
-0.364284873,
0.6793029308,
0.3362887502,
-0.0619657151,
0.2542910874,
-0.741360724,
0.7687951922,
0.7598451972,
-0.258762598,
0.1042692438,
-0.3419330418,
0.2045619786,
0.0916772038,
-0.3098414242,
-1.1495360136,
0.1992183626,
0.151286453,
0.5786435008,
0.5456299782,
0.4448112547,
1.0449593067,
-0.3068470061,
0.4729901552,
0.3113150597,
-0.9863584638,
0.5778035522,
-0.1237681657,
0.2605535984,
0.5739028454,
0.4397343993,
-0.2596019506,
-0.3454189003,
-0.5784934163,
-0.972725153,
0.7470551133,
0.1743094474,
-0.1836808473,
0.3948319256,
0.3807519078,
0.1579247564,
0.0775219128,
-0.8541570902,
-0.4582786858,
-0.5067394376,
-0.6258624196,
0.0883121267,
-0.0602908954,
-0.2786543071,
-0.6719725728,
0.2117178738,
-0.2353636473,
-0.3799200952,
0.138791129,
-0.2801507711,
-0.0819843709,
0.2428777367,
0.0976388678,
0.9284015298,
-0.1831041723,
0.3523975015,
0.270057708,
-0.4363583922,
0.0427872241,
-0.1811653525,
-0.3734793961,
0.0041540302,
0.6525415778,
0.5460904241,
0.0467305481,
-1.2466899157,
0.6346641779,
0.0406028032,
0.0886547267,
-0.1050939113,
0.162912637,
0.6220348477,
0.2739987671,
0.5036451221,
-0.0372113325,
0.1325367242,
-0.5500004888,
0.3012481928,
-0.0797662437,
-0.2822763324,
0.0526692756,
0.7228351235,
0.1580137163,
0.0724113211,
0.4577708244,
-0.1957483143,
-0.5002925396,
0.7935991287,
0.2039736211,
0.4112665355,
0.1696427613,
0.1959363967,
0.3088490963,
0.4890724421,
0.3608407974,
0.7250922918,
0.1932184547,
-0.3709651828,
-0.5588881969,
-0.1248312369,
-0.4301526845,
-0.007621591,
-0.5624883175,
0.3889025152,
-0.5485515594,
0.1419801265,
0.180055365,
-0.3640067279,
-0.7278865576,
0.2087633908,
0.3261739016,
0.8538600206,
-1.0168848038,
0.5474771857,
0.5134854913,
-0.6864206195,
-1.1203664541,
-0.0008538336,
0.062075451,
-0.8027436733,
0.8776746988,
0.1574927717,
-0.008621457,
-0.2177963257,
-0.9651371241,
-0.7731044888,
1.1035362482,
1.0411789417,
-0.555675149,
0.2710359693,
0.4492979944,
0.4549845159,
-0.1577930599,
0.3829388618,
0.6380028725,
0.7486884594,
0.5856742859,
-0.5256274343,
0.3153592944,
0.0317220949,
-0.530939281,
-0.2305405587,
-0.231304422,
0.9025062323,
-0.3723236322,
-0.4061113894,
-0.3842537105,
0.534981966,
0.493898809,
0.5815410018,
0.746288836,
0.3811715245,
0.7582168579,
-0.1423943192,
1.0464419127,
-0.1167972833,
0.3123278618,
1.4270964861,
-0.309479624,
0.6434907317,
0.4892475009,
0.0673983097,
0.4499304295,
0.5118283033,
0.3406238854,
0.5646681786,
0.0328549743,
0.335652262,
-0.7847254872,
0.1625513136,
-0.3725707829,
0.4122883677,
0.2833299041,
-0.0992951319,
-0.7900488973,
-0.334638685,
0.0057167858,
0.2862244248,
-0.0368650891,
0.5967600942,
0.1655530781,
-0.2121228129,
0.5389657021,
-0.6368285418,
-0.1850941479,
-0.6393625736,
-0.2941970527,
-0.1415469497,
-0.2383467555,
-0.1747212708,
-0.8052197099,
0.1705766618,
0.0258097779,
0.3577310145,
-0.0701668784,
0.3713518083,
-0.2871715426,
-0.5303279161,
0.0333994403,
0.8859419227,
0.1658480465,
-0.1322041154,
-0.7826302052,
-0.1941263527,
0.2971590757,
-0.1605182439,
-0.1443281323,
0.9019450545,
0.0859004259,
0.9997934699,
0.7800924778,
-0.1290424913,
-0.0193822794,
0.139826566,
0.9400953054,
-0.7234810591,
-0.8423144221,
-0.6308140159,
0.6483289599,
-0.4111018181,
0.0175286718,
0.404466182,
0.4432658255,
0.1993793845,
-0.3637960553,
0.7445969582,
0.1526579708,
0.7390316129,
-0.5436156392,
0.6701784134,
-0.8352664709,
0.2646900415,
-0.5027837157,
-0.6734608412,
-0.2961497605,
0.5658729672,
-0.5396174788,
-0.3344339132,
0.9565989375,
0.4479226768,
-0.3404189348,
0.2568469048,
0.1676637828,
0.2642471492,
0.5272260308,
0.4151521921,
0.9953197241,
0.0454607345,
1.0459135771,
-0.3125323951,
-0.2142626196,
-0.3387789428,
-0.8163580298,
-0.5846306682,
-0.3143149912,
-0.3528735042,
0.0221041664,
-0.4184120595,
0.8481454253,
0.4308312535,
-0.6106622219,
-0.1214572489,
0.0640443936,
0.0719109178,
-0.4753659666,
-0.1862133145,
0.8609627485,
-0.2734796107,
-0.4393772483,
0.1760631502,
0.3288587034,
0.1706401706,
0.1002931446,
0.0186415184,
-0.0035231933,
0.0840504691,
0.3412592709,
0.079105705,
-0.6040565968,
-0.3370687068,
-0.2769106627,
-0.0059459028,
0.4154289663,
0.5973920822,
-0.4218764007,
0.7023935318,
0.5102811456,
0.3592495322,
0.8712992072,
0.2403130084,
0.3464205861,
-0.5585759282,
0.4755722284,
0.3590377569,
0.5463750362,
0.1789368987,
-0.296429038,
0.7232000232,
0.1530620307,
0.061637152,
-0.6603038311,
0.4055701792,
-1.2615833282,
-0.7037416697,
0.789920032,
-0.2199898213,
-0.3781829178,
-0.4323851466,
-0.8206974268,
0.2698460221,
-0.2195851952,
0.7797885537,
0.378274411,
-0.4060727954,
-0.137226969,
-0.4541515708,
0.4061469138,
0.2674462199,
-1.203117013,
0.1008581445,
0.5391742587,
0.353450954,
0.294767499,
0.6300628781,
0.2111420184,
0.4773692191,
0.2766436338,
-0.0095426608,
-0.1966833174,
-0.1649214476,
0.2701464891,
0.4184365273,
0.2746680975,
-0.0802515373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14558v1
|
LLMs with Industrial Lens: Deciphering the Challenges and Prospects -- A Survey
| 2024-02-22T13:52:02 | 2024-02-22T13:52:02 |
Ashok Urlana, Charaka Vinayak Kumar, Ajeet Kumar Singh, Bala Mallikarjunarao Garlapati, Srinivasa Rao Chalamala, Rahul Mishra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become the secret ingredient driving
numerous industrial applications, showcasing their remarkable versatility
across a diverse spectrum of tasks. From natural language processing and
sentiment analysis to content generation and personalized recommendations,
their unparalleled adaptability has facilitated widespread adoption across
industries. This transformative shift driven by LLMs underscores the need to
explore the underlying associated challenges and avenues for enhancement in
their utilization. In this paper, our objective is to unravel and evaluate the
obstacles and opportunities inherent in leveraging LLMs within an industrial
context. To this end, we conduct a survey involving a group of industry
practitioners, develop four research questions derived from the insights
gathered, and examine 68 industry papers to address these questions and derive
meaningful conclusions.
|
[
-0.4229853451,
-0.4420777261,
0.9777948856,
0.070619449,
-0.1060224101,
0.1268557906,
-0.1848065555,
-0.8640432954,
-0.3596591651,
0.699375093,
-0.8644948602,
-0.5341022611,
-0.7068971992,
0.4096489847,
-0.5800811648,
0.6508992314,
-0.1839609295,
0.0476569682,
-0.2325159758,
-0.1330758631,
-0.3264659345,
-0.6484557986,
-0.6697674394,
-0.2936711907,
0.8342346549,
0.322404474,
0.3407174051,
0.4110345244,
1.0074933767,
0.4319725335,
-0.1185783595,
0.2376247644,
-0.2827939689,
0.2530921996,
-0.178821981,
-0.6546745896,
-0.4164802134,
0.0538587794,
0.6512386203,
1.0995885134,
-0.0548102185,
0.376476109,
0.2137106359,
0.602966547,
-0.4555016756,
0.1122471318,
-0.9008469582,
0.2194431275,
-0.4303686023,
-0.094797492,
-0.3231605887,
-0.0877094492,
0.1859914362,
-0.3040210903,
-0.1081830934,
0.2053550184,
0.8247291446,
0.0692523643,
-0.4275374413,
-0.4233658016,
-1.1979011297,
0.9962515831,
-0.8344781399,
0.3758376837,
-0.0080710473,
0.4080942869,
-0.2173342556,
-1.0979084969,
-0.2349342257,
0.0352669246,
0.356104672,
0.2123091966,
-0.1188983843,
-0.0429069847,
0.1376866698,
0.5553836226,
-0.2114792466,
0.7256897092,
-0.5473415256,
0.2087714374,
0.614597857,
0.6454140544,
0.3085648417,
0.1878895462,
-0.3196873367,
0.0822227299,
-0.6612337828,
-0.2504839003,
0.3791127205,
0.174389109,
0.1354934871,
0.5584473014,
-0.1204676852,
0.6472108364,
-0.5008393526,
-0.2253842205,
0.0358295664,
-0.1034714878,
-0.3483341038,
-0.1599831879,
0.7355173826,
0.4829552174,
0.1056407467,
-0.0565002114,
-0.2609231174,
-0.0523440242,
0.3701644242,
-0.5058620572,
0.4518765211,
0.3038595319,
-0.5293634534,
-0.2191112936,
-0.0513446778,
-0.7873153687,
-0.6120398045,
-0.3898834288,
0.017600229,
0.0264958441,
-0.306764245,
0.300090462,
-0.3152198792,
0.6011778116,
0.4616567791,
-0.8289753199,
-0.1201819256,
1.084743619,
1.06237185,
-0.1383608282,
-0.0199684817,
0.1660536826,
0.3450011015,
-0.5023216605,
0.8982949257,
-0.493804276,
-0.7078951597,
0.416887939,
0.0366694033,
-0.0049267905,
-1.0621370077,
0.3911109865,
-0.376745671,
-0.0608476698,
-0.3302494884,
-0.4371498525,
-0.0943153203,
0.5703807473,
-0.5564687252,
0.7821716666,
0.0363706164,
-0.5026225448,
0.2879044414,
-0.4954888225,
-0.230053395,
0.109395273,
-0.2804321349,
-0.2217775881,
0.3101816773,
-0.1338528544,
0.6262234449,
-0.6671025753,
0.1333405077,
-0.6736511588,
0.017022131,
0.6192440391,
-0.7348583341,
0.4916047454,
0.5127401948,
-0.1698773354,
-0.0254917126,
-0.7984837294,
-0.3826838732,
-0.0332486294,
-0.2845909297,
-0.2244336754,
0.174992606,
0.141316399,
0.246797502,
0.2277803868,
-0.5941023827,
0.1473778188,
-0.3545847237,
0.6806029677,
0.9494033456,
0.1657085568,
0.2814178169,
-0.3057769835,
0.7753973007,
0.148835808,
0.4039162397,
-0.0619115382,
-0.3240015209,
-0.9523391724,
-0.053647168,
-0.0625715405,
0.2661979496,
-0.6761724949,
0.0189239625,
-0.1214742661,
-0.6351165175,
-0.6307387352,
0.4329468906,
-0.187362209,
0.4505660832,
-0.1345618963,
-0.2585665584,
-0.5864784718,
-1.1565562487,
-0.3398370147,
-0.2298491299,
-0.2047631294,
0.2171207219,
0.1638023853,
-0.6795982718,
1.0884692669,
-0.8074177504,
-0.5676237345,
-0.5699645877,
0.1309378445,
0.4798371196,
0.0375855863,
0.2176811099,
-0.7160816789,
-0.3956903815,
0.2061066926,
-1.0295020342,
-0.2850788832,
-0.0351166837,
0.0529009365,
0.252199173,
0.9592752457,
-0.4987250865,
0.0365814902,
0.6143971086,
0.2703286111,
0.6135473251,
-0.0329686888,
-0.2648330331,
-1.15942204,
0.1548555493,
0.4429723024,
-0.0792255774,
-0.6570107341,
-0.0808916017,
-0.446446389,
-0.1721470356,
-0.6138467789,
0.4376732707,
-0.6869134307,
-0.1162281781,
-0.3021972775,
0.2426610738,
0.0102516217,
-0.0039998433,
0.0129076522,
0.726033926,
0.3947540224,
-0.7138510942,
0.381049186,
0.0905059204,
-0.7838448882,
0.4638931751,
-0.5476383567,
-0.0719428509,
-0.2429165095,
0.1287934333,
-0.8194921017,
-0.0314441882,
0.1383531988,
-0.0450783186,
0.0674728304,
0.188147366,
-0.6200326681,
-0.53952986,
-0.182425946,
0.0611975789,
0.4975347221,
-0.4139502347,
0.6618138552,
0.4233413637,
-0.4379478395,
-0.2646709383,
-0.8944308162,
0.3773189485,
-0.52667588,
-0.5690838099,
0.0306301005,
-0.0871739164,
-0.7072976828,
-0.1731994748,
-0.1423247755,
0.0497186556,
0.1620910317,
0.2331377119,
0.3302639723,
-0.3341791034,
-0.1235079318,
-0.4146904945,
-0.1244118959,
0.3438970745,
-0.2099710554,
0.4618851542,
0.0075625596,
-0.4177199006,
-0.2949414253,
0.3305702209,
0.6902959943,
-0.3364462256,
0.5157619119,
0.5835021138,
-0.151304394,
-0.5516213179,
-0.7499088645,
0.0830674544,
-0.7032600641,
0.7118166089,
-0.0256934837,
-0.890022099,
0.4119579494,
-0.6602096558,
0.1609351337,
0.2343461514,
0.6760314703,
-0.1903257519,
1.0994791985,
0.6977983713,
-0.2073438168,
0.3932416141,
-0.4350206256,
0.7539899945,
-1.1308073997,
-0.4843952358,
-0.5327845812,
-0.3514026105,
-0.5552966595,
-0.1988593191,
0.6841679811,
-0.3236472011,
0.0768057257,
-0.1476106793,
-0.2683150768,
0.0366858095,
0.4459861815,
-0.1540990025,
0.5423501134,
-0.0843439624,
0.2792618275,
0.0652063638,
-0.5571713448,
-0.8625051975,
0.621743083,
0.704939127,
1.1053717136,
0.1546470225,
0.2944604754,
0.0395958573,
0.3538483083,
-1.084230423,
0.8796644807,
-0.3079518676,
-0.7517720461,
-0.2327748686,
-0.1846176237,
-0.9719416499,
0.2735446692,
-0.0340526477,
-0.7608444095,
0.2906899452,
-0.1274705529,
-0.1821475476,
0.5309727192,
-0.6288121939,
0.5750153065,
-0.5661486387,
-0.3396469951,
0.0896020532,
-0.294644326,
0.3869028389,
-0.1351326108,
0.605630219,
-0.3868291974,
-0.1163861826,
0.6190932393,
-0.1734582037,
1.0780075788,
0.2121984363,
-0.4866378307,
0.4045732319,
-0.2901184261,
0.1228526831,
-0.1573471278,
-0.1428537518,
0.2965011299,
-0.0607409142,
0.2097517997,
-0.4892764091,
0.6516837478,
-0.5514707565,
-0.9387408495,
-0.6726833582,
-0.5382240415,
-0.7095544934,
0.2881346047,
0.2779481709,
0.4556828737,
-0.1289408654,
0.4406692088,
0.4293667972,
-0.392470777,
0.7972619534,
0.4927875996,
-0.3949408829,
-0.1300940365,
0.782687068,
0.3624150157,
0.3117319047,
0.1424120516,
-0.0630440488,
-0.3304112554,
-0.8334112167,
-0.2670644522,
0.2115730047,
-0.7696173191,
-0.1437723637,
-0.5587101579,
-0.360716939,
-0.3203864396,
-0.1988770217,
-0.2398938537,
0.1532853246,
-0.5779337287,
-0.0636031926,
0.1304297596,
1.1601338387,
0.3272224963,
0.2958745658,
-0.9115032554,
0.1386290789,
0.3144672811,
0.7671200037,
0.2133268714,
-0.0893905088,
-0.4208112657,
-0.0678392127,
-0.4406911135,
-0.6383979321,
0.5222768188,
-0.0688772872,
0.5652740598,
0.6859099269,
0.0322767161,
0.6576828361,
-0.8284823298,
0.9743601084,
0.1233754829,
-0.6231939793,
0.073670581,
-0.5180037022,
0.1679183543,
0.4946567714,
0.5781545639,
-0.7815557122,
-0.5046984553,
-0.2356085479,
-1.3451967239,
0.4902608097,
-0.2399294227,
0.4318366051,
0.1316078305,
0.3652161062,
-0.0857232362,
0.2295378596,
-0.6381388903,
-0.0212417319,
0.478767395,
-0.3656804264,
-0.150417462,
-0.284604013,
0.0732145011,
0.0194949005,
0.5836613178,
0.1974723041,
0.1339653879,
0.1108011007,
0.043347124,
0.0958295763,
0.475609988,
0.3408510387,
0.8755656481,
-0.2294329256,
0.0304923505,
0.1040559262,
-0.3211322129,
0.0337471291,
-0.2916689515,
0.0298272297,
0.0361193232,
0.3138637841,
0.8017490506,
0.0171465967,
-0.915763855,
0.2623396516,
0.1498820782,
-0.3276699483,
-0.7261741757,
0.0731959343,
0.3627252281,
0.4915214479,
0.5368046165,
-0.5037841797,
0.3232102394,
-0.9211147428,
-0.2604383528,
0.7151783705,
-0.5202367902,
-0.0007263831,
0.6381649375,
0.24791421,
-0.3132436872,
0.3001110256,
0.3150427639,
-0.4138578475,
0.5166981816,
0.5807731152,
0.8924026489,
0.0534854643,
-0.0253206957,
-0.3063277006,
0.508900404,
-0.3394319415,
-0.1672184467,
0.6429794431,
-0.8304237723,
-0.1029738858,
-0.7902374864,
-0.9816166162,
0.4130634367,
-0.6098707318,
0.4114590883,
-0.5876822472,
-0.3724181056,
0.0534665473,
-0.3414705396,
-0.5365180373,
0.3090387285,
0.3077397943,
0.8302659392,
-0.6695429683,
0.625023365,
0.7523497939,
-0.3990499675,
-0.65331918,
-0.1743593514,
0.0617935918,
-0.7988477349,
0.6568935513,
0.2039375454,
-0.2286230624,
-0.0654141307,
-0.4891854227,
-0.6695409417,
1.1752214432,
0.1471814513,
-0.7915796041,
-0.2115180045,
0.6681904197,
0.5516427755,
-0.3958892822,
-0.0003261926,
0.6631698608,
0.5275581479,
-0.0192902274,
-0.5896397233,
-0.2286338359,
-0.217240274,
0.4985257387,
0.0377694331,
-0.8702350259,
0.6685150266,
0.4517668784,
-0.1216858029,
-0.0936561525,
0.495664984,
0.0733553171,
0.5823519826,
0.3613830507,
0.2652635574,
0.2217764705,
0.0569388866,
0.9488880038,
-0.1939363331,
0.1512049288,
0.7651001811,
-0.8103289008,
1.1099961996,
0.5640564561,
-0.3494829237,
0.5699918866,
0.5708419085,
-0.3665376008,
0.0392305814,
0.0935704783,
-0.5657913685,
-0.011812564,
-0.3670666814,
-0.4310536981,
0.670871973,
0.6268106103,
-0.3244943917,
-0.1872204393,
0.1450766921,
-0.0198247526,
0.121405378,
-0.454847604,
0.9591094851,
0.6044883728,
-0.4177505076,
0.1079880223,
0.275172919,
0.9660224319,
-0.8567846417,
0.0679464415,
-0.1113077626,
0.4072277546,
-0.1413654238,
-0.6868221164,
0.5353266597,
0.1036795825,
-0.0397351719,
-0.541326046,
0.8373237252,
-0.224794656,
-0.8262477517,
0.3386580646,
0.304572016,
-0.0986981094,
-0.0143021913,
-0.3134999275,
0.445152849,
-0.2341785431,
-0.1603362113,
0.5017046928,
0.5238385797,
0.2652729452,
0.9991183877,
0.3317696154,
0.2532821596,
0.0925420225,
-0.1277139634,
0.7437531948,
-0.764085114,
-0.1480286419,
-0.8796287179,
0.5275427103,
-0.081969969,
-0.2454458326,
0.971706152,
0.558960259,
0.7165347934,
-0.1984400898,
1.0781610012,
0.3366495371,
0.460744679,
-0.6472574472,
0.9081653953,
-0.7548255324,
0.5912861824,
-0.2795421779,
-0.9600168467,
-0.3869199455,
0.3761006594,
-0.4084830582,
0.0801435187,
0.6261575222,
0.8583052754,
0.0758810341,
0.0120569728,
0.3859306276,
0.3035403788,
0.4663416445,
0.3187046349,
1.0287350416,
-0.0201031175,
0.55286479,
0.0426642746,
0.0189267546,
-0.331288904,
-1.0577994585,
-0.663049221,
-0.5261771679,
-0.2230432183,
-0.1208335981,
-0.180120334,
0.9161200523,
0.418138504,
-0.5417789817,
-0.725415051,
0.0551501885,
-0.1103888974,
0.1998648942,
-0.2174575329,
-0.1804677993,
-0.5436093807,
-0.9422994852,
0.2101316452,
0.5761409402,
-0.0171921477,
-0.5963519812,
0.3952045143,
-0.1631671786,
0.270624876,
1.0010780096,
0.1251274496,
-0.5771075487,
-0.1443125457,
0.0445028506,
0.0763091817,
-0.0046305573,
0.9279292822,
-0.2558668256,
0.0832923055,
0.2396783233,
0.9637506008,
0.4160617888,
-0.3081736267,
0.8284263015,
-0.5745326281,
0.1579769552,
0.1863162518,
0.3299522102,
0.5111092329,
-0.2099716961,
0.4705533683,
0.177018404,
-0.5579034686,
-1.0587207079,
0.4406273365,
-0.931545496,
-0.5064996481,
1.3520377874,
0.290091306,
-0.1744251996,
-0.1579707116,
-0.1573729366,
0.1089008823,
0.1419862956,
0.5907480717,
0.7747548819,
-0.072356157,
-0.275173068,
-0.9080325961,
0.1009560078,
0.2799939811,
-0.8133452535,
-0.0060516596,
0.5893229842,
0.3471594453,
-0.0875654742,
0.5556861758,
-0.3056846559,
-0.4697589576,
-0.2872906029,
-0.0203093328,
0.0620530657,
-0.2606535554,
-0.5190965533,
0.2771773338,
0.8548959494,
0.009432612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14547v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14547v3
|
OmniPred: Language Models as Universal Regressors
| 2024-02-22T13:36:53 | 2024-03-04T16:54:25 |
Xingyou Song, Oscar Li, Chansoo Lee, Bangding Yang, Daiyi Peng, Sagi Perel, Yutian Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Over the broad landscape of experimental design, regression has been a
powerful tool to accurately predict the outcome metrics of a system or model
given a set of parameters, but has been traditionally restricted to methods
which are only applicable to a specific task. In this paper, we propose
OmniPred, a framework for training language models as universal end-to-end
regressors over $(x,y)$ evaluation data from diverse real world experiments.
Using data sourced from Google Vizier, one of the largest blackbox optimization
databases in the world, our extensive experiments demonstrate that through only
textual representations of mathematical parameters and values, language models
are capable of very precise numerical regression, and if given the opportunity
to train over multiple tasks, can significantly outperform traditional
regression models.
|
[
-0.1184437424,
-0.7557391524,
0.3276488185,
0.4307637215,
0.2315759957,
-0.1152584106,
-0.4566736817,
-0.3459946811,
-0.0314085558,
0.5193841457,
-0.3445738852,
-0.2871977985,
-0.2320159525,
0.0713509098,
-0.3847512901,
1.0930986404,
-0.1478526294,
0.4047193527,
0.0249781795,
-0.1122975796,
-0.3467226028,
-0.7907813191,
-0.2244371623,
0.0099715739,
0.4251526892,
0.2569835186,
0.4554392397,
0.4343846142,
0.3525156975,
0.2981355488,
0.3683384359,
-0.1323869973,
-0.5347040296,
0.387278825,
-0.06012398,
-0.3476407826,
0.0160832107,
0.0204784144,
0.4791990519,
0.8749958277,
-0.2943965495,
0.4062915742,
0.3139403462,
0.2137692124,
-0.781052053,
0.255663991,
-0.20764561,
-0.0035342481,
0.3210924864,
0.0059136515,
-0.4551588893,
-0.8492137194,
0.2246889025,
-0.5157831907,
0.2838166058,
-0.0695732385,
0.7582526207,
0.3061852157,
-0.1551503837,
0.0275272522,
-1.2546766996,
0.759580195,
-0.4923650622,
0.6949042678,
-0.154738158,
0.5287199616,
-0.3358832002,
-0.5094473958,
-0.1812566072,
-0.1510575116,
0.2264238298,
0.1876681149,
-0.2059598267,
-0.0022138881,
0.0328291468,
0.0414463915,
-0.5260183811,
-0.032610599,
-0.383577168,
-0.0439963304,
0.3987118006,
-0.0670664161,
0.3273709714,
-0.0276795328,
-0.1890590787,
-0.1193498746,
-0.3537245095,
0.1836555749,
0.1361258328,
0.7202882171,
0.2512767315,
0.6924118996,
-0.1362855881,
0.6944032907,
-0.5680164099,
-0.0772091374,
-0.0301883705,
-0.1448621452,
-0.5774307251,
-0.1572576314,
0.9625339508,
0.0250410177,
0.6540448666,
-0.4389140606,
-0.0612641163,
0.2150757611,
0.2365602702,
-0.7707254291,
-0.0527045615,
-0.0723168775,
-0.2452916205,
-0.4502435923,
0.2639292777,
-0.9695754051,
-0.0237093214,
-0.2685960829,
0.5134370327,
-0.1476719975,
-0.1911174208,
0.5059882998,
-0.1363951862,
0.0131415538,
-0.0177755654,
-0.5523701906,
0.6864142418,
0.4815644324,
0.7711540461,
0.1826316714,
-0.4388204515,
-0.6028910875,
-0.0821235254,
-0.4668701291,
0.6228101254,
-0.6586700082,
-0.2855054438,
0.2600936592,
-0.18994537,
-0.2200842798,
-0.1380539984,
0.6201963425,
-0.3062255085,
0.4980227947,
0.1148937643,
-0.39906919,
-0.1160457656,
-0.1172275469,
-0.5791903734,
0.9029699564,
0.4236070812,
-0.3085078299,
0.4989023507,
-0.8750023842,
-0.0691889748,
-0.1143695787,
-0.1302171499,
-0.3627368808,
0.4550398886,
0.0189082213,
0.4605562389,
-0.8352537751,
0.6170575023,
-0.4931816459,
-0.0058921054,
0.1819672436,
-0.3994602859,
0.6456106901,
0.0421220474,
-0.3559660614,
0.0108309519,
-0.8541200757,
0.0264004748,
0.2436936647,
-0.33217448,
-0.7219398022,
0.0671858341,
0.4907385707,
0.1733111292,
-0.1501942873,
-1.017752409,
0.2357026637,
-0.0584271625,
0.3303577006,
0.7105636597,
-0.3122317493,
0.3045914769,
-0.0170467682,
0.9201858044,
-0.6587335467,
0.2649921477,
-0.0706703141,
-0.6412289143,
-0.5030264258,
-0.4128222466,
0.5822368264,
0.458561331,
0.1541377008,
0.2435500771,
-0.2333983481,
-0.3429986238,
-0.6524225473,
0.3071739376,
0.6946977973,
0.3607749045,
0.1846642792,
0.2066903412,
-0.9513617754,
-0.9201747775,
-0.4067225456,
-0.0516584404,
-0.0819557235,
0.2110606879,
0.493478775,
-0.2985041738,
1.0624579191,
-0.6155311465,
-0.4554693699,
-0.2277859449,
0.2102210522,
0.0239456128,
0.3280259371,
0.5929245353,
-0.8373767138,
-0.4895722568,
0.1860457659,
-0.8100124002,
-0.2511839271,
-0.0270686653,
-0.1686887443,
0.1226469427,
0.7105045915,
-0.2205697149,
0.4824941456,
0.6483728886,
-0.3024342358,
0.6532551646,
-0.2305161804,
-0.2391167134,
-0.9325323105,
0.0636634082,
0.4375663996,
-0.3254632354,
-0.6128284335,
0.1575059891,
0.0722608119,
-0.2171904296,
-0.0682810768,
0.5856375098,
-0.3671754301,
0.093930766,
0.0942615271,
-0.1000424847,
-0.1192805618,
0.2848840356,
0.1539161503,
0.69159168,
0.6488887668,
-0.5006828308,
0.2207032144,
0.2802825868,
-0.1446245611,
0.3166761696,
-0.9719496965,
-0.4143284261,
-0.2994596064,
-0.1163178161,
-1.3095085621,
-0.412825644,
-0.1122012362,
-0.6540949345,
0.1325284839,
-0.1619001627,
-0.5403212309,
-0.6501346827,
-0.1410071999,
0.0930716097,
0.6516919732,
-0.6401277184,
0.6883701682,
0.2188172638,
-0.0415267274,
-0.5150662065,
-0.6276581287,
-0.175963372,
-0.0957622603,
-0.320409894,
-0.0739296377,
-0.2695784867,
-0.2836571932,
-0.0012219204,
-0.0033049821,
-0.2843773961,
0.0921617374,
0.4407073855,
0.4716619253,
-0.5766878128,
0.1224180609,
-0.3716051579,
-0.3236875832,
0.183003962,
-0.5229073763,
0.4647548795,
-0.0977645442,
-0.3209135532,
0.0807636529,
0.3656877279,
0.4133083522,
-0.1723453403,
0.6424201727,
0.401049614,
-0.401172787,
-0.1905913353,
-0.6743101478,
0.1546755284,
-0.3932367861,
0.4542627037,
-0.5166112781,
-0.8605495095,
0.4397313893,
-0.0460227765,
0.2989828885,
0.2114698142,
0.3025914729,
0.1323084235,
1.7331331968,
1.4306287766,
-0.2521227002,
0.2756698728,
-0.3002992272,
0.049832426,
-0.7937074304,
-0.2834362686,
-0.8566348553,
-0.055615481,
-0.4444566667,
-0.1275679469,
0.1583069414,
0.2867483497,
-0.5453557968,
0.2922213376,
-0.6034095883,
0.5635536313,
0.5258814692,
-0.2565845549,
0.0571284704,
-0.0319059007,
-0.2603731155,
-0.1084640697,
-0.6171531677,
-0.6143311858,
1.2812812328,
0.1650028825,
1.1057776213,
0.1232477576,
0.5554563999,
-0.0132718338,
0.729922533,
-0.6559131742,
0.1161831617,
-0.0413740911,
-0.6512517333,
-0.24982889,
-0.4961777031,
-0.777474761,
0.4422134459,
0.1612979323,
-1.0268679857,
0.5205322504,
-0.073724322,
-0.4137448668,
0.3591937721,
-0.7429015636,
1.0883592367,
-0.3739081621,
-0.166088745,
0.5314442515,
-0.3311783671,
0.438076973,
-0.3508255184,
0.4393494725,
0.1158262566,
-0.2606167793,
0.6628283858,
-0.3618506193,
0.8253750205,
-0.0912317857,
0.1228994876,
-0.1693294644,
0.2807365954,
0.1247074082,
0.0062941127,
-0.0566672832,
-0.385258764,
-0.1696921289,
-0.4377661049,
-0.5760554075,
0.7298627496,
-0.9638082981,
-0.2815406621,
-0.3326918483,
-0.4314279854,
-0.3047593236,
0.2444333583,
0.1949256957,
0.6414779425,
-0.6214271784,
0.2660767734,
0.458096236,
-0.078458339,
0.4534789026,
0.5773836374,
-0.581520617,
-0.4263976812,
0.8696897626,
-0.0992173553,
0.3883268237,
0.3712929785,
0.4818827808,
-0.285847187,
0.0117868483,
-0.3778080642,
0.2807607353,
-0.5086722374,
-0.3134490848,
-0.7658560872,
-0.1197855994,
-0.4467754662,
-0.3890005052,
-0.3848521411,
-0.1458895504,
-0.2942487895,
-0.2420328557,
0.2942845225,
0.869958818,
-0.3844316304,
0.2611964643,
-0.53374964,
0.4202000201,
0.4117055535,
0.5727140307,
-0.2637468576,
-0.3949820399,
-0.0835686252,
0.2160218507,
0.0220776442,
-0.6930141449,
0.7263438702,
0.5208092928,
0.8055132627,
0.4007974863,
0.0537726805,
0.7896236777,
-0.5497786999,
0.3316665888,
0.2562929988,
-0.8445317745,
0.4477897882,
-0.0804493502,
-0.0125353476,
0.3367946148,
0.8236164451,
-0.4182192683,
-0.4280506074,
-0.5717033744,
-0.6172253489,
0.4926531911,
0.038259998,
0.2266962975,
0.112210393,
0.288905859,
0.1983692348,
0.1959474385,
-0.8712586761,
-0.0757475421,
-0.3650710583,
-0.2378614545,
-0.3656751215,
-0.3323947489,
0.0458767116,
-0.1548583955,
0.3814066947,
-0.2623068392,
0.1368810683,
0.291416198,
-0.3181272447,
-0.3434313536,
0.1990410686,
0.4800331593,
0.7043790817,
-0.6117767096,
-0.2376642525,
-0.2179731876,
-0.306281507,
0.3134186566,
0.2122344077,
-0.2201914042,
0.2134091407,
0.1061791554,
0.5764999986,
0.3704437017,
-0.8379994631,
0.5484976768,
-0.3167718649,
-0.3432249725,
-0.4444853067,
-0.1093445122,
-0.2107525468,
0.2012324184,
0.481733799,
0.2653972805,
0.2565433681,
-0.5883917212,
0.2934025228,
0.3750666678,
-1.0734996796,
-0.4967160523,
1.0561536551,
-0.0002230706,
-0.436270833,
0.2257520705,
0.0903385729,
-0.6515017748,
0.4663495421,
0.9392926693,
1.0024554729,
-0.53658849,
0.3843491673,
0.2174390554,
0.4033502042,
-0.2743311524,
0.5350374579,
0.3227431476,
-0.6697592735,
-0.6616473198,
-0.7654533386,
-0.2394906878,
0.0893649906,
-0.9517615438,
0.2195770293,
-0.2028763145,
-0.0969644263,
0.2966020405,
-0.4082224071,
-0.7043209076,
0.2517600954,
0.0315216258,
0.9111762047,
-1.0309056044,
0.4368517101,
0.8716188073,
-0.8325985074,
-0.4302957058,
-0.3372217417,
-0.0206810497,
-0.6214635372,
0.8496764898,
0.005487117,
-0.0600455217,
0.0025110678,
-0.6688814759,
-0.8128748536,
0.4380788505,
0.5422254205,
-0.4949106574,
-0.1576820016,
0.2325937301,
0.6820009351,
-0.6588318944,
0.4524923861,
0.5231298804,
0.390360117,
-0.3271712363,
-0.8897537589,
-0.233476162,
-0.3961921334,
0.1194894612,
0.3496957123,
-0.333319366,
0.9834363461,
-0.4423527718,
0.0721890479,
0.2631905973,
0.5004321337,
0.0879886672,
-0.2729440928,
0.3035003841,
0.3225070536,
0.3813917041,
-0.0810697228,
1.4150676727,
-0.152606383,
0.3777101636,
0.8977842927,
-0.1099124029,
0.8374071717,
0.1505666971,
-0.034737803,
0.2598655522,
0.3511246145,
0.0418878347,
0.4710814655,
0.3568910956,
0.2053022534,
-0.3669111431,
-0.1792268157,
-0.1276614964,
0.160084188,
0.1704938412,
-0.2084679008,
-0.3066317141,
0.5123127699,
0.0202039257,
0.2817286849,
0.0188759491,
0.7244259119,
-0.1130996868,
-0.1626676321,
0.6795248985,
-0.2488945127,
0.7767294645,
-0.6276238561,
-0.1557232887,
-0.0907472,
0.4923169017,
0.02525183,
-0.4688307643,
0.0504413471,
-0.0011112132,
-0.1844076812,
-0.1580714732,
0.5006993413,
-0.4140460789,
-0.8824229836,
0.7114844918,
0.5070033669,
-0.0577659607,
-0.3712476194,
-0.5791464448,
-0.09817902,
0.1231114045,
-0.3012791276,
0.1492481083,
0.4991749525,
-0.1067540944,
0.9917895198,
0.7866733074,
0.4375821352,
0.2812591493,
0.2408352196,
0.7626976371,
-0.8162379861,
-0.2005406022,
-0.7570438385,
0.5225368738,
0.0235874914,
-0.5726523995,
0.811851263,
0.8476380706,
0.8418316841,
-0.149437055,
1.1494526863,
0.0688241795,
0.9074323177,
0.072512731,
0.341978997,
-0.6748860478,
-0.1806588471,
-0.5263402462,
-1.1801068783,
-0.6012939215,
0.6053171158,
0.0734371915,
-0.1063180193,
0.3923807442,
0.4079354405,
-0.3175883591,
0.0770000294,
0.3988778591,
0.2220683843,
0.5796625018,
0.0653282627,
0.8346651196,
-0.5240052938,
0.864312768,
-0.3986913264,
-0.2644632459,
-0.430036664,
-0.5507382154,
-0.853128612,
-0.6703377962,
-0.1412913501,
-0.0965796784,
0.0768513978,
0.8964422345,
0.7649430633,
-0.8779899478,
-0.711260438,
-0.179389149,
-0.1624681801,
-0.172542274,
-0.2413823605,
0.1692610681,
-0.6290037632,
-0.6747989058,
0.1327011138,
0.1607715935,
0.0667493865,
-0.7170268893,
0.0299924221,
0.0085568437,
0.1418358386,
0.6384395361,
0.5401230454,
-0.7064995766,
-0.1989251226,
0.3659926057,
-0.0661339909,
-0.1020162031,
0.8614637852,
-0.8872535825,
0.5090228319,
0.2830157876,
0.5642476082,
0.1808093637,
0.058177866,
1.2295114994,
-0.4680069685,
0.0971030742,
0.1474304646,
0.5366300344,
0.2516520619,
0.0093900757,
0.8115605712,
-0.1277157515,
-0.5422321558,
-1.2350202799,
-0.174136728,
-0.4350793064,
-0.2408558875,
1.1251224279,
-0.0403682292,
-0.5264701247,
-0.2966944873,
-0.2707797885,
-0.0316292942,
-0.5540270209,
0.5048857331,
0.274823606,
0.1187039837,
-0.2018045783,
-1.0992856026,
0.4558831751,
0.123954393,
-0.5582745075,
0.2060456723,
0.4609297812,
0.3241381347,
0.3644413054,
0.2231766582,
0.0851178616,
0.1958337277,
-0.1804528981,
0.5558938384,
0.0069154897,
-0.5367640257,
-0.2146591246,
-0.0141205452,
0.0015841702,
-0.2094218433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14545v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14545v2
|
Less is More: Mitigating Multimodal Hallucination from an EOS Decision Perspective
| 2024-02-22T13:33:13 | 2024-05-29T05:55:09 |
Zihao Yue, Liang Zhang, Qin Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) often suffer from multimodal hallucinations,
wherein they may create content that is not present in the visual inputs. In
this paper, we explore a new angle of this issue: overly detailed training data
hinders the model's ability to timely terminate generation, leading to
continued outputs beyond visual perception limits. By investigating how the
model decides to terminate generation with EOS, the special end-of-sentence
token, we find that the model assesses the completeness of the entire sequence
by comparing the generated text with the image. This observation suggests that
the model possesses an inherent potential of making proper EOS decisions based
on its visual perception to avoid overly lengthy outputs. To take advantage of
such potential, we explore two methods to mitigate multimodal hallucinations: a
training objective that enables the model to reduce hallucinations by learning
from regular instruction data, and a data filtering strategy to prevent harmful
training data from exacerbating model hallucinations. Both methods
significantly improve the hallucination performance of LMMs, without requiring
any additional data or knowledge.
|
[
-0.6829484701,
-0.7893756628,
0.7615012527,
-0.0907589272,
-0.4198495746,
-0.1413569599,
-0.1660799533,
-0.7337771058,
0.5658657551,
0.5949617028,
-0.801163733,
-0.1195525676,
-0.6450915337,
0.1439004987,
-0.1924826801,
0.9901459217,
0.1649222821,
0.0985837057,
-0.3956891298,
0.00683871,
-0.3667988181,
-0.5544507504,
-0.8006465435,
-0.3417561948,
0.5514777899,
0.2387489825,
0.6742056012,
0.4772332013,
0.3907509148,
0.2055331767,
-0.1451997161,
0.4343262911,
-0.8031290174,
0.2059861124,
0.4830952585,
-0.3440048397,
-0.3130416274,
-0.3052813709,
0.1905867904,
0.7844039202,
-0.2246159017,
-0.0001980263,
-0.0107081523,
0.7794088125,
-0.8324385881,
-0.1328729391,
-0.4192534983,
0.7352104783,
0.3516340852,
-0.4416643381,
-0.6710903049,
0.0696643814,
0.1497495323,
-0.8386434913,
0.1304356903,
0.1898158193,
0.6648125052,
0.5365442038,
-0.3999555111,
-0.2181227952,
-0.8657366633,
0.7936589122,
-0.3051967621,
0.7080245614,
0.5186662078,
0.2522427142,
-0.0417854413,
-0.4653217494,
-0.7681056261,
-0.5694314241,
-0.0989460796,
0.1913801879,
-0.0128966365,
0.4611207247,
0.7233209014,
-0.1830442101,
-0.6417732835,
-0.103707917,
-0.6690273881,
-0.395953089,
0.1246255934,
0.089929305,
0.1089056209,
-0.3961123228,
-0.5358362794,
-0.21308963,
-0.645737946,
-0.1218548566,
0.41516155,
-0.042654831,
0.148533538,
0.7076003551,
-0.2417684048,
0.6147620082,
-0.1439881027,
-0.1819247156,
0.2307312191,
-0.1717725694,
-0.4211848974,
0.0743648261,
0.3637924194,
0.7527854443,
0.2244829088,
-0.1584284455,
-0.2662519217,
0.2772606313,
0.401173383,
-0.8248504996,
-0.1407494694,
0.2501560152,
-0.703922987,
-0.1162076741,
-0.0196587425,
-0.8891518116,
-0.570761621,
-0.660603404,
0.4388330281,
-0.5106011033,
0.0546791553,
0.0804052055,
-0.4898403585,
-0.0646924675,
0.4311726093,
-0.7244769335,
0.2538764775,
0.3443308175,
1.1026275158,
-0.0463776551,
-0.253418237,
-0.6274806261,
0.4517790973,
-0.4240583777,
0.5409029126,
-0.5911006927,
-0.1478828192,
-0.2734057903,
-0.0811931267,
0.0767331123,
-0.3986688256,
0.2889558673,
-0.2371658534,
0.1093935072,
-0.1849027127,
-0.2845697701,
-0.2561493516,
0.2933958173,
-0.7776815295,
0.6333752275,
-0.2047516257,
-0.3643404543,
0.6954106688,
-0.4652923048,
-0.4552806914,
-0.2925888896,
-0.4262335002,
-0.3482923508,
0.477838695,
0.3016562164,
0.5165253282,
-0.0681463182,
0.1903391182,
-0.3813655972,
-0.4508323073,
0.0272956267,
-0.477024138,
0.1113608405,
0.5556494594,
-0.2928688228,
0.1449801475,
-0.9288443327,
-0.2640097439,
0.0020831439,
0.0173351225,
-0.4018021822,
-0.0591303855,
0.2160339355,
0.3484156728,
-0.1476182044,
-0.4756976664,
-0.0636544675,
-0.0878612399,
0.3513444066,
0.8914235234,
-0.2030441314,
0.5226419568,
-0.6702669263,
0.5230350494,
0.0546390526,
0.6571682096,
-0.514527142,
-0.4463624954,
-1.0143036842,
-0.5624603033,
-0.2956238389,
0.2068134695,
-0.965523243,
0.0348205231,
-0.1708938479,
-0.2511121035,
-0.2863217592,
0.1236519143,
0.4355030656,
0.3135125041,
0.3818178475,
-0.3771682382,
-0.8368294835,
-0.833661139,
0.1605460346,
0.2069755197,
0.0193015877,
0.2255803049,
0.6651338339,
-0.3204986453,
0.6043076515,
-0.5498721004,
-0.5260121822,
-0.216919139,
0.086426124,
-0.1665199995,
0.2817125022,
0.4532183111,
-0.8303931355,
-0.0269174241,
-0.1166661531,
-0.9039136767,
0.2927372158,
-0.8256366849,
0.1460326016,
0.2737382352,
0.5119160414,
-0.8687263727,
0.440061152,
0.2417969853,
-0.1529376358,
0.1061328724,
-0.3968542516,
0.2283562124,
-0.6854191422,
-0.2204264104,
-0.2738632262,
-0.2751282454,
-0.5934451818,
0.0836972147,
-0.2580090761,
-0.2790866196,
-0.3583367169,
0.3123912811,
-0.6164636016,
-0.2091762275,
-0.1926635206,
0.1032648906,
0.313010931,
0.6365826726,
0.1912109107,
0.2247984856,
0.5086174607,
-0.7282314301,
0.39793697,
0.1141654775,
-0.2579167783,
0.3420704007,
-0.4391669035,
0.2647551,
-0.5468541384,
0.2438774556,
-1.0334308147,
-0.3571705222,
0.2828433514,
-0.4358774126,
0.2370600849,
0.1934186518,
-0.3418572247,
-0.1613923013,
-0.9687754512,
0.2433700711,
0.3179558218,
-0.5775370002,
0.6682658195,
0.1065124422,
-0.0265743807,
-0.5121669173,
-1.0052288771,
0.2477292717,
-0.1624375582,
-0.5273907781,
0.2996557951,
-0.2122464478,
-0.00160558,
-0.1781126112,
0.0105096297,
0.0597728677,
0.0724754855,
0.3417600095,
0.2073553503,
0.1237949878,
0.2884914577,
0.4227609932,
-0.073632285,
-0.1397971511,
0.044009231,
0.8378906846,
0.5138366818,
-0.6521956921,
-0.5794077516,
0.5813400149,
0.8867588639,
0.2892037928,
0.9763700366,
0.5977363586,
-0.5893908143,
-0.0993735567,
-0.5027162433,
-0.5839053392,
-0.4088469446,
0.5116980076,
-0.4953867495,
-0.5067611337,
0.425761342,
0.0737442821,
-0.1281884611,
-0.0129427938,
0.3226154745,
-0.0153486803,
1.2977207899,
0.6955285668,
0.3831706345,
0.7008110881,
-0.2552699745,
0.4058045745,
-0.8831169605,
-0.6594380736,
0.1239068434,
-0.26349774,
-0.302636683,
-0.3436515033,
0.2994351685,
-0.0474119894,
-0.005434636,
-0.0555620454,
-0.692799449,
0.5248982906,
0.4824803472,
0.5000837445,
0.2829874754,
0.3436230421,
-0.0492419191,
-0.0621273518,
-0.6004599333,
-0.500479877,
1.1432645321,
0.2839537561,
0.7808676362,
0.047657527,
0.6892437935,
0.4111379385,
-0.158016786,
-0.6850350499,
0.5337711573,
0.1953423768,
-0.3562327325,
-0.3893048167,
-0.4985692501,
-0.5629882812,
0.3694399893,
-0.5147433281,
-0.5226045251,
0.3388175666,
0.0622745827,
-0.7392213941,
0.1610625982,
-0.7931646705,
0.5411761999,
-0.3489558101,
-0.4012929201,
-0.3600327373,
-0.4685636163,
0.2856357694,
-0.1443062127,
0.344355464,
0.2413118184,
-0.1545662731,
0.9366665483,
-0.2651144564,
0.9454366565,
-0.0558682494,
0.1658655554,
0.151038304,
-0.1205622032,
0.5520368814,
-0.0867827907,
0.273026228,
-0.0354361236,
-0.1861319691,
-0.2757118642,
-0.4376950562,
0.5727087259,
-0.7484447956,
-0.2152789086,
-0.3102864921,
-0.517731905,
0.1223679334,
-0.1481849253,
0.6212849617,
0.3417519927,
0.0109404074,
0.1422235072,
0.6763783097,
-0.3854404688,
0.4796404541,
-0.1415271014,
-0.4152942896,
-0.632232368,
0.8877311945,
0.3328196406,
0.2550919056,
0.212482661,
0.0875242725,
-0.2558567524,
-0.5414307714,
-0.3547541201,
0.0856271461,
-1.0303550959,
0.0023262533,
-0.8694022894,
0.182240665,
-0.7109330893,
-0.2304598838,
-0.2307343334,
-0.4980508089,
-0.3284548521,
-0.4510247707,
0.3382874131,
0.7222085595,
-0.1788125634,
0.5244847536,
-0.706667304,
0.7659822106,
0.2995677888,
0.1042003036,
0.1009260044,
-0.4821219146,
-0.0361794047,
-0.0788989961,
-0.3465405703,
-0.906991899,
0.4744742811,
0.3891465068,
0.4951910079,
0.8205128908,
0.0624738224,
1.0429077148,
-0.3008491695,
0.6886782646,
0.7048584819,
-0.9077237248,
0.5364955664,
0.1198500171,
-0.0127806468,
0.3146547973,
0.3257236779,
-0.5346384645,
-0.2386309505,
-0.1241448373,
-1.0709425211,
0.6556287408,
0.3557601869,
0.2277548611,
0.0130297486,
0.2235077024,
0.2976466715,
0.4991090596,
-0.9027089477,
-0.023773374,
-0.2474840432,
-0.032367602,
0.0675166994,
-0.6035243273,
-0.2214716375,
-0.2510163784,
0.3234857917,
-0.00379037,
0.3038296402,
0.2606065571,
-0.4650556445,
-0.1134735718,
0.0080802171,
0.9662480354,
0.5234378576,
-0.0867168456,
0.1228179187,
0.1599936783,
-0.3817046285,
-0.0539259799,
-0.2709200382,
-0.2943649888,
0.1031691208,
0.5574724674,
1.2413856983,
0.0643882453,
-0.8843809962,
0.3459446728,
-0.0056437575,
-0.1454510689,
-0.4350701869,
-0.1363435835,
-0.4052269459,
0.3075578213,
0.373383373,
0.2240871936,
0.33547315,
-0.7126796842,
0.3680252135,
0.2144390345,
-0.2662396133,
-0.1743094176,
0.6064987183,
0.1015785187,
-0.0937693939,
0.4793647826,
-0.1706100851,
-0.4027293921,
0.7996017337,
0.424539566,
0.6665492058,
-0.0326261297,
0.2744557858,
0.2505159974,
0.6572949886,
-0.1502066106,
0.289599359,
-0.435555011,
-0.4491226971,
-0.4486943483,
-0.4600965381,
-0.2846281528,
0.1259621531,
-0.7542755604,
0.4233100116,
-0.6943315268,
-0.2930133045,
-0.3026426136,
-0.5900807381,
-0.4351502061,
0.3064340353,
0.5926204324,
0.2614367604,
-0.9955033064,
0.3401324153,
0.3800131381,
-0.374510318,
-0.1082029641,
-0.1718240529,
-0.0575897954,
-0.4854109883,
0.674459517,
0.6180174351,
-0.3269968331,
-0.3789311349,
-0.4629879594,
-0.6130469441,
0.9084222913,
0.5641770363,
-0.8769950867,
-0.0510455184,
0.0996866673,
0.4001904726,
-0.2850993574,
0.5145733953,
0.4410161674,
0.5027564764,
0.398709327,
-0.6340424418,
0.0843248367,
-0.067743957,
-0.1131769717,
0.173362866,
-0.4418233633,
0.9082044363,
-0.6576924324,
-0.2063285261,
-0.0474275239,
0.3457993865,
0.2246927172,
0.8007679582,
0.6355667114,
0.677844882,
0.9056677818,
0.1203007549,
1.0610309839,
-0.0565936416,
0.225902617,
1.1140372753,
-0.3555251062,
0.5968865752,
0.9897614717,
0.2063640207,
-0.0620609112,
0.8074198365,
-0.0479119308,
0.8979152441,
0.090451844,
-0.0326847583,
-0.4898742735,
-0.2601632178,
-0.425888449,
0.4345748723,
0.1596967578,
-0.3885335028,
0.1421549916,
0.8423330188,
-0.0312376563,
-0.0847432539,
-0.0728198811,
0.807674408,
0.0106265033,
-0.4991748929,
0.4509869516,
-0.4269754291,
0.7353248596,
-0.3730045855,
-0.2857484519,
-0.266065836,
0.0071918876,
-0.3113859296,
-0.0896815509,
0.4480195343,
-0.0805746689,
-0.2711513937,
-0.3220459223,
0.3005886674,
-0.2773322463,
-0.4965535402,
0.6851868033,
0.3738594651,
0.2598761916,
-0.3166620433,
-0.3628314137,
0.176890552,
-0.0095736422,
-0.4036710262,
0.2643521428,
0.2593972981,
0.0812074989,
0.8207093477,
0.8802193403,
0.2426285446,
0.4038499892,
0.2818101943,
0.8437063098,
-0.7345353365,
-0.4627046287,
-1.0308899879,
0.110818848,
-0.2812055945,
-0.2901555896,
0.4141717851,
0.5750109553,
0.9429648519,
-0.2604536712,
0.6171876192,
0.0442447774,
-0.0413950048,
-0.8159846663,
0.6860405803,
-0.9197044373,
0.3448086977,
-0.1535830647,
-0.7958007455,
-0.3172751665,
0.8231369257,
-0.0256058238,
0.0516057909,
0.7924110889,
0.7808666825,
0.1271347851,
-0.1052683219,
0.9309393167,
0.081233114,
0.1456275284,
0.7456801534,
1.1719408035,
-0.3135436177,
0.7481936812,
-0.4303386509,
-0.0817370117,
-0.2672648132,
-0.5894664526,
-1.0792503357,
-0.422640115,
-0.1476373076,
0.0763014853,
-0.002704409,
1.0025666952,
0.7314655185,
-0.5048947334,
0.0907440931,
-0.0867526606,
0.2058023512,
-0.1491044611,
-0.1439307183,
0.1629254371,
-0.2500245571,
-0.6930629611,
0.2050231099,
0.4635292888,
0.0703142211,
-0.2124397159,
-0.2615115643,
0.0319379978,
0.0565174036,
0.9637675285,
-0.2817900777,
-0.7903990149,
-0.1240525618,
0.1825685203,
0.0202637259,
0.0910044238,
0.8285676837,
-0.8484009504,
0.7788971663,
0.4836378396,
0.3000709713,
0.4974386692,
-0.5609015226,
0.3082773685,
-0.4910118282,
0.49754107,
0.0410087034,
0.5744059086,
0.3114112616,
-0.6252756715,
0.4301161468,
0.1964669824,
0.0139379809,
-1.020863533,
0.3986065984,
-0.9211493731,
-0.5322539806,
1.0051226616,
0.065906927,
-0.1685501337,
-0.1668748707,
-0.4864078164,
0.441902101,
-0.4455540478,
1.0140262842,
0.5639861226,
-0.294781059,
-0.4154241085,
-0.7680497766,
0.4114386737,
0.6208474636,
-0.7662352324,
-0.0851346627,
0.6765598059,
-0.3153706193,
0.405017972,
0.3544693589,
0.3072439432,
0.3258515,
0.1267015487,
0.1116410717,
-0.3223979771,
-0.9216807485,
-0.4519975781,
0.4139417708,
-0.3001743555,
-0.4151162505
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.