topic
stringlengths 3
73
| argument
stringlengths 24
222
| label
stringclasses 2
values |
|---|---|---|
No Child Left Behind Act
|
No Child Left Behind encourages parents to engage more actively
|
PRO
|
No Child Left Behind Act
|
Statewide standards are an improvement over major local failures:
|
PRO
|
2009 US economic stimulus
|
Stimulus increases debt, inflation, interest rates, harms economy
|
CON
|
2009 US economic stimulus
|
2009 US stimulus won't generate consumer confidence
|
CON
|
2009 US economic stimulus
|
Funding government projects will stimulate jobs/economy
|
PRO
|
2009 US economic stimulus
|
Majority of US stimulus is immediate to fight recession now.
|
PRO
|
Legalization of adult incest
|
Incest undermines the family and its nurturing relationships
|
CON
|
Legalization of adult incest
|
Sending law-abiding incestuous couples to prison looks bad.
|
PRO
|
Legalization of adult incest
|
Offspring of first-cousins have a low chance of defects
|
PRO
|
Charter schools
|
Schools are not like businesses; can't just let bad ones die
|
CON
|
Charter schools
|
Charter schools can destroy valuable neighborhood schools
|
CON
|
Charter schools
|
Charter schools do not achieve economies of scale
|
CON
|
Charter schools
|
Charter schools proliferated too quickly to monitor performance
|
CON
|
Charter schools
|
Charter schools promote teacher independence and character
|
PRO
|
Charter schools
|
Charter schools, free from regulation, are innovative
|
PRO
|
Charter schools
|
Charter schools cut through red tape, quickly opening after Katrina
|
PRO
|
Crime cameras
|
Crime cameras may help prosecutions, but don't reduce crime.
|
CON
|
Crime cameras
|
Crime cameras lead to slippery slope of Big Brother surveillance.
|
CON
|
Crime cameras
|
Crime cameras help restore a public sense of safety
|
PRO
|
Guantanamo Bay detention center
|
Guantanamo violates habeas corpus, obstructs proof of innocence
|
CON
|
Guantanamo Bay detention center
|
Conducting detainee trials in the US would endanger US citizens
|
CON
|
Guantanamo Bay detention center
|
Guantanamo bay's existence fuels terrorist causes
|
CON
|
Guantanamo Bay detention center
|
Conditions at Guantanamo Bay are harmful to detainee mental health
|
CON
|
Guantanamo Bay detention center
|
Guantanamo Bay helps disrupt terrorist groups.
|
PRO
|
Israeli military assault in Gaza
|
Israeli attacks embolden extremists on both sides in cycle of violence
|
CON
|
Israeli military assault in Gaza
|
Israel's use of white phosphorous in Gaza was a humanitarian crime.
|
CON
|
Israeli military assault in Gaza
|
Israel strikes were intended to further dispirit Palestinians
|
CON
|
Israeli military assault in Gaza
|
Israel air strikes in November, 2008 unraveled the ceasefire
|
CON
|
Israeli military assault in Gaza
|
Defeating Hamas is key to long-term Israeli/Palestinian solution
|
PRO
|
Israeli military assault in Gaza
|
Israeli attacks may force Hamas to accept a more durable ceasefire
|
PRO
|
Israeli military assault in Gaza
|
Israeli precision strikes sought to minimize civilian deaths
|
PRO
|
Republika Srpska secession from Bosnia and Herzegovina
|
Serb Republic secession could spark regional war
|
CON
|
Republika Srpska secession from Bosnia and Herzegovina
|
Russian backing of Republika Srpska ind. could spark global conflict
|
CON
|
Republika Srpska secession from Bosnia and Herzegovina
|
Republika Srpska secession would incite Bosnian Croat secession
|
CON
|
International Criminal Court
|
ICC puts national servicemen abroad at risk of prosecution
|
CON
|
International Criminal Court
|
ICC causes tyrants to cling to power to avoid prosecution
|
CON
|
International Criminal Court
|
The ICC risks heavy politicization of prosecution
|
CON
|
International Criminal Court
|
ICC and rule of law help deter war crimes and genocide
|
PRO
|
International Criminal Court
|
ICC advances universal rights and international law
|
PRO
|
Rebuilding New Orleans
|
Global warming & stronger hurricanes will destroy new New Orleans
|
CON
|
Rebuilding New Orleans
|
Louisiana politicians cannot be trusted with federal funding
|
CON
|
Rebuilding New Orleans
|
Rebuilding New Orleans will not return it to economic vibrancy
|
CON
|
Rebuilding New Orleans
|
Rebuilding New Orleans is key to improving US race relations
|
PRO
|
Bailout of US automakers
|
Automaker bailout unfairly disadvantages competition
|
CON
|
Bailout of US automakers
|
Low-interest loans to automakers will not solve their problems.
|
CON
|
Bailout of US automakers
|
Bailout will preserve place of autos in American identity
|
PRO
|
Bailout of US automakers
|
Bailout allows US autos to produce needed green cars
|
PRO
|
Bailout of US automakers
|
Saving economy outweighs moral hazard of auto bailout
|
PRO
|
US and NATO intervention in Libya
|
Libya war expands imperial presidency farther than ever
|
CON
|
Infant male circumcision
|
Circumcision creates risk of infections in infants
|
CON
|
Infant male circumcision
|
Pain of circumcision is traumatizing for infants
|
CON
|
Infant male circumcision
|
Circumcision helps prevent phimosis
|
PRO
|
Infant male circumcision
|
Circumcision helps protect against chlamydia
|
PRO
|
Infant male circumcision
|
Circumcision reduces risk of urinary tract infections
|
PRO
|
Fairness Doctrine
|
Fairness Doctrine would destroy viability of conservative radio
|
CON
|
Fairness Doctrine
|
Fairness Doctrine would open costly political battle
|
CON
|
Fairness Doctrine
|
Fairness Doctrine helps advance free speech values
|
PRO
|
Fairness Doctrine
|
Free speech without Fairness Doctrine can harm policy-making
|
PRO
|
Fairness Doctrine
|
Fairness Doctrine would counter conservative domination of radio
|
PRO
|
Fairness Doctrine
|
The Fairness Doctrine improves the public discourse
|
PRO
|
Employee Free Choice Act
|
Employee Free Choice Act eliminates workers' right to secret ballots
|
CON
|
Employee Free Choice Act
|
Unions are dwindling because few workers care to join
|
CON
|
Employee Free Choice Act
|
Employee Free Choice Act would not solve alleged employer abuses
|
CON
|
Employee Free Choice Act
|
EFCA is biased toward punishing employers and not unions
|
CON
|
Employee Free Choice Act
|
EFCA strengthens workers' ability and right to unionize
|
PRO
|
Employee Free Choice Act
|
Employee Free Choice Act protects unionizing workers from intimidation
|
PRO
|
Pickens US energy plan
|
It is relatively cheap to convert existing cars to natural gas.
|
PRO
|
Wave power
|
Wave power systems can attract predatory fish, damaging ecosystems
|
CON
|
Wave power
|
Oceans corrode wave power systems, which is costly
|
CON
|
Wave power
|
Wave power diminishes wave quality for surfers
|
CON
|
Wave power
|
Wave power provides clean renewable power.
|
PRO
|
Wave power
|
Wave power will have a smaller impact than fossil fuel plants
|
PRO
|
Wave power
|
Waves pack substantial energy; few wave generators are required
|
PRO
|
Wave power
|
Under-water wave power systems avoid aesthetic concerns.
|
PRO
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
Fuel economy standards do not directly reduce emissions
|
CON
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
Fuel economy standards increase car manufacturing costs and prices
|
CON
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
Fuel standards impair individuals needing high-powered trucks
|
CON
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards can increase vehicle deaths
|
CON
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
Fuel economy standards reduce emissions, fight global warming
|
PRO
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
CAFE standards have strong history of reducing US emissions
|
PRO
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
Fuel economy standards do not increase the cost of making cars
|
PRO
|
Vehicle fuel economy standards
|
Fuel economy standards foster innovation and jobs
|
PRO
|
Algae biofuel
|
Algae pools can become contaminated and less efficient
|
CON
|
Algae biofuel
|
Industrial algae biofuel requires too many nutrients
|
CON
|
Algae biofuel
|
Algae biofuel is carbon neutral; only emits C02 that it absorbs.
|
PRO
|
Algae biofuel
|
Algae can be produced locally for food and fuel
|
PRO
|
Kyoto Protocol
|
Fighting climate change means cutting emissions with Kyoto Protocol
|
PRO
|
Year-round school
|
Many school buildings are not built for summer use.
|
CON
|
Year-round school
|
Changing to year-round schooling has significant costs.
|
CON
|
Year-round school
|
Areas that depend heavily on summer tourism will suffer economically.
|
CON
|
Year-round school
|
Studies find year-round schools improve student performance
|
PRO
|
$700 billion US economic bailout
|
$700b plan and intervention in markets worsens problems
|
CON
|
$700 billion US economic bailout
|
$700b plan would bail-out greedy capitalists that created crisis
|
CON
|
$700 billion US economic bailout
|
$700b bailout saves Wallstreet by slamming taxpayers
|
CON
|
$700 billion US economic bailout
|
Not passing $700b bailout risks sending economy into major recession
|
PRO
|
$700 billion US economic bailout
|
$700b bailout is important to stabilize volatile global markets
|
PRO
|
$700 billion US economic bailout
|
$700b plan may result in few losses or actually profit taxpayers
|
PRO
|
Reforestation as a solution to global warming
|
Reforestation can result in release of greenhouse gas Methane
|
CON
|
Reforestation as a solution to global warming
|
Increasing droughts impairs carbon sequestration by trees
|
CON
|
Reforestation as a solution to global warming
|
Reforestation can increase Earth's Albedo and global warming
|
CON
|
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.