id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19592v1
|
Why Larger Language Models Do In-context Learning Differently?
| 2024-05-30T01:11:35 | 2024-05-30T01:11:35 |
Zhenmei Shi, Junyi Wei, Zhuoyan Xu, Yingyu Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have emerged as a powerful tool for AI, with the
key ability of in-context learning (ICL), where they can perform well on unseen
tasks based on a brief series of task examples without necessitating any
adjustments to the model parameters. One recent interesting mysterious
observation is that models of different scales may have different ICL
behaviors: larger models tend to be more sensitive to noise in the test
context. This work studies this observation theoretically aiming to improve the
understanding of LLM and ICL. We analyze two stylized settings: (1) linear
regression with one-layer single-head linear transformers and (2) parity
classification with two-layer multiple attention heads transformers (non-linear
data and non-linear model). In both settings, we give closed-form optimal
solutions and find that smaller models emphasize important hidden features
while larger ones cover more hidden features; thus, smaller models are more
robust to noise while larger ones are more easily distracted, leading to
different ICL behaviors. This sheds light on where transformers pay attention
to and how that affects ICL. Preliminary experimental results on large base and
chat models provide positive support for our analysis.
|
[
-0.5186092257499695,
-0.7529094219207764,
0.47691720724105835,
0.2173607349395752,
-0.03383397310972214,
-0.074406199157238,
-0.6106183528900146,
-0.7248597741127014,
-0.4099965989589691,
0.2877681255340576,
-0.5479204058647156,
-0.06953254342079163,
-0.6089572310447693,
0.04610053822398186,
-0.4305494427680969,
1.100140929222107,
0.2012052983045578,
0.1684156060218811,
-0.3591808080673218,
-0.3481510281562805,
-0.447006493806839,
-0.6164314150810242,
-0.8315873146057129,
-0.6217736005783081,
0.6763142943382263,
0.33489176630973816,
0.6650581955909729,
0.52927565574646,
0.5584356188774109,
0.2503352761268616,
-0.28492841124534607,
-0.11589710414409637,
-0.5819079875946045,
-0.08060923218727112,
0.044379137456417084,
-0.4977322220802307,
-0.06923496723175049,
0.11964590847492218,
0.7134786248207092,
0.9264525771141052,
0.21842439472675323,
0.37079161405563354,
0.43520066142082214,
0.5356265902519226,
-0.5216584801673889,
0.5353396534919739,
-0.6532995104789734,
-0.048195380717515945,
0.04204878211021423,
0.11753959208726883,
-0.753720223903656,
0.19540423154830933,
0.33072206377983093,
-0.289557546377182,
0.07147546857595444,
0.026335636153817177,
0.8309869170188904,
0.38362956047058105,
-0.604847252368927,
-0.2664561867713928,
-0.9087852239608765,
1.105438470840454,
-0.7430472373962402,
0.5331000685691833,
0.33399316668510437,
0.138276144862175,
0.25291311740875244,
-0.5324311256408691,
-0.21711640059947968,
-0.5191120505332947,
-0.3079673647880554,
-0.27313536405563354,
-0.1871798187494278,
-0.07965240627527237,
0.6216645240783691,
0.1426282376050949,
-0.13931825757026672,
0.5484729409217834,
-0.2467167228460312,
0.07009749114513397,
0.482124000787735,
0.03875543549656868,
0.1096784770488739,
0.2765709161758423,
-0.3256908655166626,
-0.22136268019676208,
-0.9368009567260742,
0.5738649368286133,
0.01777922734618187,
0.5378236174583435,
-0.5065236687660217,
0.14521639049053192,
0.0969935953617096,
0.5499526858329773,
0.4482620656490326,
-0.5335348844528198,
0.21014940738677979,
0.08480273187160492,
-0.23462308943271637,
-0.037728648632764816,
0.4902797043323517,
0.05913731828331947,
0.4007287621498108,
-0.2031528651714325,
-0.4418381154537201,
-0.25150054693222046,
0.08063358813524246,
-0.7927840948104858,
-0.015760375186800957,
-0.012403636239469051,
-0.7074077725410461,
-0.2704133689403534,
-0.055164143443107605,
-0.39291709661483765,
-0.39422935247421265,
-0.8719658255577087,
0.6879356503486633,
-0.2296503484249115,
-0.1966153383255005,
-0.17383500933647156,
0.2424410879611969,
0.5626891255378723,
0.2828823924064636,
-0.9451941847801208,
0.4377586245536804,
0.8166607022285461,
0.6935750842094421,
-0.16392938792705536,
-0.25840482115745544,
-0.5828285217285156,
-0.09484145045280457,
-0.4239179491996765,
0.6355456113815308,
-0.5166739225387573,
-0.06851296126842499,
-0.0924142599105835,
-0.21454177796840668,
-0.37679678201675415,
-0.7933641076087952,
0.1452922224998474,
-0.45195454359054565,
0.16120298206806183,
-0.5052006840705872,
-0.2743397057056427,
-0.12787365913391113,
0.0514281764626503,
-0.4760245084762573,
0.9148964881896973,
0.10739818215370178,
-0.8400671482086182,
0.5244326591491699,
-0.5561701655387878,
-0.39516884088516235,
-0.10056465119123459,
-0.4558999538421631,
-0.49698498845100403,
0.3928898870944977,
0.14797185361385345,
0.4740852415561676,
-0.3736877143383026,
0.1850665658712387,
-0.28834766149520874,
-0.6350168585777283,
0.6124668717384338,
-0.5796370506286621,
0.7419094443321228,
-0.01644936390221119,
-0.501419723033905,
0.19805443286895752,
-0.4740668535232544,
-0.21440695226192474,
0.017688991501927376,
-0.4174862802028656,
-0.34679412841796875,
0.2118878960609436,
-0.004343037493526936,
0.4557425379753113,
-0.05502687394618988,
-0.35257503390312195,
-0.015849968418478966,
-0.36280032992362976,
0.5287591814994812,
0.7675257921218872,
-0.12500318884849548,
0.6021448373794556,
-0.4199661612510681,
0.3051794767379761,
0.31158336997032166,
0.18843328952789307,
0.04720887169241905,
-0.20879606902599335,
-0.9199244379997253,
-0.4490489959716797,
0.20277151465415955,
0.24804221093654633,
-0.3277696371078491,
0.12479206919670105,
-0.26961085200309753,
-0.2137661874294281,
-0.3652661144733429,
0.08937834948301315,
0.4577758312225342,
0.6286929249763489,
0.2518646717071533,
-0.06457777321338654,
-0.2943921387195587,
-1.0322909355163574,
-0.11795792728662491,
-0.16170482337474823,
-0.12970437109470367,
0.5988713502883911,
0.4637163281440735,
-0.19575177133083344,
0.8753084540367126,
-0.21470440924167633,
-0.2499467432498932,
-0.5692193508148193,
-0.17559397220611572,
0.13402782380580902,
0.22118595242500305,
0.8102315664291382,
-0.8275085687637329,
-0.8639980554580688,
0.10219041258096695,
-0.5227091908454895,
-0.1211184486746788,
-0.23015102744102478,
0.3543395698070526,
0.12683044373989105,
0.9184637069702148,
-0.45466840267181396,
0.3624826669692993,
0.3731563985347748,
-0.03215261176228523,
0.285137414932251,
-0.030723663046956062,
-0.4259830117225647,
-0.8577405214309692,
-0.1408924162387848,
0.21390950679779053,
-0.11264639347791672,
-0.8494808673858643,
0.1105293333530426,
0.2174094170331955,
0.09600638598203659,
-0.4584038257598877,
0.44794413447380066,
-0.42219334840774536,
-0.29643160104751587,
-0.3086158335208893,
-0.0007154738414101303,
-0.15111032128334045,
0.6282946467399597,
-0.09029029309749603,
0.9386094212532043,
0.651324450969696,
-0.6915150284767151,
-0.31030330061912537,
0.038864247500896454,
-0.4356972575187683,
0.23901806771755219,
-0.6107951402664185,
0.1648554652929306,
-0.35884401202201843,
0.3079022169113159,
-0.9993184208869934,
-0.1804865300655365,
-0.19407278299331665,
-0.15769386291503906,
0.6084502935409546,
-0.018179336562752724,
-0.5265753269195557,
-0.05031353980302811,
-0.15760169923305511,
0.4598666727542877,
0.7288360595703125,
-0.7721141576766968,
0.49542510509490967,
0.44683411717414856,
0.05296764895319939,
-0.49204960465431213,
-0.7779132127761841,
-0.2411959022283554,
-0.6485779285430908,
-0.3733775317668915,
0.05441773310303688,
-0.2321491688489914,
-0.727420449256897,
-0.492051362991333,
-0.15830741822719574,
-0.19739748537540436,
0.2136726975440979,
0.357161283493042,
0.04964742064476013,
-0.5613514184951782,
0.3168203830718994,
-0.2674809396266937,
0.034451574087142944,
0.19188006222248077,
-0.021965501829981804,
0.662840723991394,
-0.2994109094142914,
-0.23426596820354462,
-0.5821806192398071,
0.1600702702999115,
0.7274964451789856,
-0.21368195116519928,
0.9322558641433716,
0.5979447960853577,
-0.1567295640707016,
-0.3697965741157532,
-0.49663466215133667,
-0.44932103157043457,
-0.4942159056663513,
0.3907009959220886,
-0.4259050786495209,
-0.9386231899261475,
0.6135776042938232,
0.11112836748361588,
0.0955628901720047,
0.33843448758125305,
0.7198553681373596,
-0.1297500878572464,
1.2329691648483276,
0.752528727054596,
-0.2867961525917053,
0.6566644310951233,
-0.19387215375900269,
0.3930862843990326,
-1.1041520833969116,
-0.0875878855586052,
-0.5543192028999329,
-0.5176466107368469,
-0.5592067241668701,
-0.06590992212295532,
0.2951194643974304,
0.036050520837306976,
-0.4652584493160248,
0.11844699829816818,
-0.1910986751317978,
0.5999795198440552,
0.35508471727371216,
0.131622314453125,
0.16038307547569275,
0.12230761349201202,
0.06466902047395706,
-0.12077919393777847,
-0.663475513458252,
-0.24686510860919952,
0.8775394558906555,
0.6417557597160339,
0.8353813290596008,
0.08491449058055878,
0.2873500883579254,
-0.10508668422698975,
0.39716872572898865,
-0.9126436710357666,
0.3643867075443268,
-0.1631811261177063,
-0.48038414120674133,
-0.17937085032463074,
-0.31427979469299316,
-0.9154824018478394,
0.535732090473175,
-0.04215091094374657,
-0.9018623232841492,
0.240890234708786,
0.12721557915210724,
-0.2802399694919586,
0.31984761357307434,
-0.8158493638038635,
0.6088681817054749,
-0.05312900245189667,
-0.19081653654575348,
-0.11247796565294266,
-0.6904807686805725,
0.1536916047334671,
-0.20805321633815765,
0.41936928033828735,
0.031743962317705154,
0.10626538097858429,
0.26960012316703796,
0.06608369946479797,
1.2158122062683105,
0.005049717612564564,
-0.16373693943023682,
0.15920090675354004,
0.09089706093072891,
0.5264610648155212,
0.11589821428060532,
0.06441916525363922,
0.17943459749221802,
-0.3438277542591095,
-0.2651391625404358,
-0.3268028497695923,
0.760366678237915,
-1.1113345623016357,
-0.6242760419845581,
-0.12602242827415466,
-0.9376263618469238,
-0.29614877700805664,
-0.12725132703781128,
0.4416448175907135,
0.7562907338142395,
0.28144633769989014,
0.747016429901123,
1.0062633752822876,
-0.32658281922340393,
0.6516183614730835,
0.559052050113678,
-0.10589625686407089,
0.3974056541919708,
0.5946917533874512,
0.3041367530822754,
0.6947745680809021,
0.6513473987579346,
0.32932978868484497,
-0.11189347505569458,
-0.4291207194328308,
0.020101072266697884,
0.2347697913646698,
-0.7660974264144897,
0.08070458471775055,
-0.6469511389732361,
-0.4750906527042389,
-0.40204179286956787,
-0.01517358049750328,
-0.2934950292110443,
-0.1234457939863205,
-0.3540738523006439,
0.01990032196044922,
0.04459076002240181,
0.7731826305389404,
0.14650221168994904,
0.4671381711959839,
-0.2010534703731537,
0.10506252199411392,
0.38131579756736755,
0.3293093144893646,
0.3271041214466095,
-0.9180948138237,
-0.4236987233161926,
-0.055696144700050354,
-0.2142544984817505,
-0.41237446665763855,
0.20882324874401093,
0.344453364610672,
0.43928518891334534,
0.5053099393844604,
-0.11100565642118454,
0.6701093912124634,
-0.5104631781578064,
0.5775651931762695,
-0.24815604090690613,
-0.8552822470664978,
0.04058035835623741,
-0.3725300133228302,
0.5409441590309143,
0.2699509263038635,
0.12172951549291611,
-0.46232175827026367,
-0.3653997480869293,
-0.5289222598075867,
-0.6099138259887695,
0.8634160161018372,
0.010287920944392681,
0.30867186188697815,
0.17342892289161682,
0.49127867817878723,
0.27142077684402466,
0.16039662063121796,
-1.2620052099227905,
-0.23970526456832886,
0.15542428195476532,
-0.1740472912788391,
-0.24021928012371063,
-0.3460884094238281,
-0.04424368590116501,
-0.32523179054260254,
0.25522875785827637,
-0.16627013683319092,
0.3097991347312927,
-0.07672900706529617,
-0.2966305911540985,
-0.08760838210582733,
0.20919297635555267,
0.5667784214019775,
0.7685416340827942,
-0.06794138252735138,
0.17255046963691711,
0.31789180636405945,
-0.2677796185016632,
-0.16963566839694977,
-0.3670448660850525,
-0.11298324912786484,
-0.2327328473329544,
0.8597153425216675,
1.167046308517456,
0.4522654116153717,
-0.6022987365722656,
0.6765826344490051,
-0.07653088867664337,
-0.17755824327468872,
-0.5061883330345154,
0.09395764023065567,
-0.005163734778761864,
0.43683961033821106,
0.29128989577293396,
0.0881640687584877,
-0.08603774011135101,
-0.6452884078025818,
-0.05281776934862137,
0.5482620000839233,
-0.5743305087089539,
-0.40496528148651123,
0.47720620036125183,
-0.13754740357398987,
-0.2900931239128113,
0.741415798664093,
0.04159722849726677,
-0.3231610059738159,
0.825099527835846,
0.7395209670066833,
0.7616416215896606,
0.06767874956130981,
-0.04350949451327324,
0.09519360959529877,
0.3225049376487732,
0.07310432940721512,
-0.1565430611371994,
-0.1899479180574417,
-0.7539749145507812,
-0.5168609619140625,
-0.47089889645576477,
-0.3168589472770691,
0.5488003492355347,
-0.696634829044342,
0.19148705899715424,
-0.49342286586761475,
0.08766200393438339,
0.0011771273566409945,
-0.2699294090270996,
-0.8027846813201904,
0.06874004006385803,
0.2342878133058548,
0.5535798668861389,
-0.9245413541793823,
0.9766208529472351,
0.5198909640312195,
-0.24659939110279083,
-1.0458405017852783,
0.3922169804573059,
-0.04911517724394798,
-0.7196852564811707,
0.9491525888442993,
0.5125793814659119,
0.08957329392433167,
-0.05230855941772461,
-0.5972527265548706,
-1.124986171722412,
0.9120959639549255,
0.4198743999004364,
-0.48188793659210205,
-0.034844864159822464,
0.3202051520347595,
0.759607195854187,
-0.662359893321991,
0.2529442608356476,
0.4697638750076294,
0.14874278008937836,
-0.18234026432037354,
-1.1187115907669067,
-0.31700244545936584,
0.18459950387477875,
0.08878602087497711,
0.2197730988264084,
-1.0910650491714478,
1.3393988609313965,
-0.03234897181391716,
-0.13018901646137238,
-0.18441954255104065,
0.34557682275772095,
0.13736434280872345,
0.24979504942893982,
0.6388218998908997,
0.12191702425479889,
0.34794336557388306,
0.0013999453512951732,
1.210481882095337,
-0.17426250874996185,
0.4117998480796814,
1.166089653968811,
-0.33685535192489624,
0.8605725169181824,
0.46121060848236084,
-0.09358339756727219,
0.5350258946418762,
0.6723601222038269,
0.14265495538711548,
0.3973352909088135,
0.06580191850662231,
-0.04225790128111839,
-0.3130168914794922,
-0.04213200882077217,
-0.12126266956329346,
0.6362240314483643,
0.4468165636062622,
-0.3405492603778839,
-0.17991302907466888,
0.3835699260234833,
-0.02788425423204899,
-0.05457623675465584,
-0.4466066062450409,
0.9214568734169006,
0.2118709236383438,
-0.49354037642478943,
0.42229145765304565,
-0.19676515460014343,
0.551634669303894,
-0.4158029854297638,
0.33957216143608093,
-0.245521679520607,
0.5654829144477844,
0.06679157167673111,
-0.48693281412124634,
0.10473685711622238,
-0.21879540383815765,
-0.4132271707057953,
-0.22388356924057007,
0.5127020478248596,
-0.24595031142234802,
-0.3726480305194855,
0.5294270515441895,
0.2881839871406555,
0.005993905942887068,
-0.1757645159959793,
-0.7488718628883362,
0.20054899156093597,
0.06433790922164917,
-0.37865689396858215,
0.7895475029945374,
0.38229700922966003,
-0.3476355969905853,
0.8683831691741943,
0.39932340383529663,
-0.13796478509902954,
0.17582589387893677,
0.24330203235149384,
0.6707732081413269,
-0.2540523409843445,
-0.3400576412677765,
-0.9206638932228088,
0.3077583611011505,
0.09953412413597107,
-0.40440189838409424,
0.7377448081970215,
0.3939920961856842,
1.0224802494049072,
-0.23737461864948273,
0.42134106159210205,
0.16976408660411835,
0.5765268206596375,
-0.44786179065704346,
0.42306962609291077,
-0.5260095596313477,
0.42419782280921936,
-0.019892172887921333,
-0.9731554388999939,
-0.2536579370498657,
0.6092809438705444,
-0.3140524625778198,
0.23567798733711243,
0.7608029246330261,
0.6306487321853638,
-0.2283233106136322,
-0.17393875122070312,
0.4404061734676361,
0.5529570579528809,
0.41195109486579895,
0.4852011501789093,
0.8681405782699585,
-0.20238760113716125,
0.3293284475803375,
-0.37143850326538086,
-0.08613278716802597,
-0.24391064047813416,
-0.4835025668144226,
-1.2444519996643066,
-0.6157686114311218,
-0.2638201415538788,
-0.03599933534860611,
-0.394622802734375,
1.0644611120224,
0.8865154385566711,
-0.8334813714027405,
-0.4655350148677826,
0.015864403918385506,
-0.07296305149793625,
-0.1115623190999031,
-0.26214396953582764,
0.40311357378959656,
-0.5550363659858704,
-0.8393540382385254,
0.34866899251937866,
0.36812058091163635,
-0.039736468344926834,
-0.2742329239845276,
0.09646013379096985,
-0.03604591637849808,
0.14912566542625427,
0.7588163614273071,
0.1641521006822586,
-0.895179271697998,
-0.6001803874969482,
-0.1375385969877243,
-0.3704063296318054,
0.24646568298339844,
0.8190966248512268,
-0.7891518473625183,
0.006808971054852009,
0.28163084387779236,
0.5648838877677917,
0.399775892496109,
-0.2153765708208084,
0.2925822138786316,
-0.9462401866912842,
0.6591524481773376,
0.009505935944616795,
0.30429866909980774,
0.2543787658214569,
-0.4953669011592865,
0.30792921781539917,
-0.10096107423305511,
-0.7395837903022766,
-0.9421249628067017,
0.31106695532798767,
-0.7278801202774048,
-0.4759073555469513,
1.3308295011520386,
0.1164645254611969,
-0.03301079198718071,
0.012850062921643257,
-0.21218159794807434,
-0.038028981536626816,
-0.1637834757566452,
0.9511803984642029,
0.8117027878761292,
-0.3864852786064148,
-0.28321173787117004,
-0.7978702187538147,
0.5529099702835083,
0.47315844893455505,
-0.409022718667984,
0.05177266150712967,
0.09753330796957016,
0.35086584091186523,
0.006264411378651857,
0.1969352811574936,
-0.003746116068214178,
-0.027687571942806244,
-0.2543656826019287,
-0.49731776118278503,
0.36745455861091614,
-0.4558703899383545,
-0.5605566501617432,
0.15517394244670868,
0.4023624062538147,
0.16603592038154602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19575v1
|
A Deep Convolutional Neural Network-based Model for Aspect and Polarity Classification in Hausa Movie Reviews
| 2024-05-29T23:45:42 | 2024-05-29T23:45:42 |
Umar Ibrahim, Abubakar Yakubu Zandam, Fatima Muhammad Adam, Aminu Musa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is crucial for understanding sentiment
nuances in text, especially across diverse languages and cultures. This paper
introduces a novel Deep Convolutional Neural Network (CNN)-based model tailored
for aspect and polarity classification in Hausa movie reviews, an
underrepresented language in sentiment analysis research. A comprehensive Hausa
ABSA dataset is created, filling a significant gap in resource availability.
The dataset, preprocessed using sci-kit-learn for TF-IDF transformation,
includes manually annotated aspect-level feature ontology words and sentiment
polarity assignments. The proposed model combines CNNs with attention
mechanisms for aspect-word prediction, leveraging contextual information and
sentiment polarities. With 91% accuracy on aspect term extraction and 92% on
sentiment polarity classification, the model outperforms traditional machine
models, offering insights into specific aspects and sentiments. This study
advances ABSA research, particularly in underrepresented languages, with
implications for cross-cultural linguistic research.
|
[
-0.7085610032081604,
-0.5475993752479553,
0.16159911453723907,
0.270563542842865,
-0.7847757935523987,
0.19293950498104095,
-0.10453037172555923,
-0.40691977739334106,
0.5494560599327087,
0.5755267143249512,
-0.514854907989502,
-0.5859439373016357,
-0.5456109046936035,
-0.03258346766233444,
-0.2525424063205719,
1.2063462734222412,
0.18090303242206573,
0.38678544759750366,
-0.0382402203977108,
-0.6143934726715088,
-0.40353158116340637,
-0.6433706283569336,
-0.6275786757469177,
-0.5503670573234558,
0.5998077392578125,
0.31949949264526367,
0.9690614938735962,
-0.13733255863189697,
0.6776151061058044,
0.1289113610982895,
-0.3768172562122345,
0.1854517012834549,
-0.030159544199705124,
0.04625610634684563,
-0.40249887108802795,
-0.25557491183280945,
-0.48139598965644836,
0.11375852674245834,
0.3955322504043579,
0.5068992972373962,
0.19940979778766632,
0.17192156612873077,
0.1326352208852768,
0.9150000214576721,
-0.4759633243083954,
0.24318602681159973,
-0.2905064821243286,
0.4595847427845001,
-0.06853707879781723,
0.38822466135025024,
0.0692719891667366,
-0.167399600148201,
0.2083767056465149,
-0.27092257142066956,
0.20981615781784058,
0.01788157969713211,
0.7831225991249084,
0.26519060134887695,
-0.2848000228404999,
-0.1786838173866272,
-0.6672080755233765,
0.7317529320716858,
-0.7339320182800293,
0.3334420919418335,
0.25782492756843567,
-0.10953684896230698,
0.13858497142791748,
0.024834586307406425,
-0.87248694896698,
-0.0721285417675972,
-0.09376046806573868,
0.10093429684638977,
-0.010760615579783916,
-0.1461138129234314,
-0.25519707798957825,
0.7342875599861145,
-0.19254139065742493,
0.17205658555030823,
-0.22581379115581512,
0.12325737625360489,
0.6729214191436768,
-0.032479528337717056,
0.12942765653133392,
-0.9670809507369995,
-0.38222262263298035,
0.04771100729703903,
-0.7726224660873413,
0.4221488833427429,
0.20286516845226288,
0.12660929560661316,
-0.4450267553329468,
0.725913405418396,
-0.25657719373703003,
0.24264179170131683,
-0.06529677659273148,
0.23541243374347687,
0.26308104395866394,
-0.2106695920228958,
-0.3454594314098358,
-0.011484306305646896,
1.1272817850112915,
0.3895246982574463,
0.03862115368247032,
0.25948625802993774,
-0.22460247576236725,
-0.06630413979291916,
0.4852973222732544,
-0.5446016192436218,
0.08435665816068649,
0.13136708736419678,
-0.5776245594024658,
-0.7014541029930115,
0.018343564122915268,
-1.0609729290008545,
-0.9357024431228638,
-0.33027392625808716,
0.14399324357509613,
-0.2379496991634369,
-0.18679660558700562,
-0.38934892416000366,
0.24008886516094208,
0.19106414914131165,
0.29409900307655334,
-0.38421058654785156,
-0.17288534343242645,
0.8830239772796631,
0.8013107776641846,
-0.3470093011856079,
-0.11319723725318909,
-0.14309732615947723,
-0.5468112230300903,
-0.29220619797706604,
0.6808501482009888,
-0.5566039085388184,
-0.30212053656578064,
0.11419862508773804,
-0.09892629832029343,
0.3260192275047302,
-0.2838517725467682,
0.6186559796333313,
-0.67728590965271,
0.13810531795024872,
0.06783072650432587,
-0.28819507360458374,
-0.8502843976020813,
0.6522961854934692,
-0.7491869330406189,
0.5328097343444824,
0.14654327929019928,
-0.6192405819892883,
0.23013731837272644,
-0.46383002400398254,
-0.5791138410568237,
-0.14937864243984222,
-0.306308388710022,
-0.8520368933677673,
0.4979666471481323,
0.5217949748039246,
0.47843387722969055,
-0.4617062509059906,
0.4095197021961212,
-0.41167259216308594,
-0.07202247530221939,
0.781478762626648,
-0.47259876132011414,
0.5999249219894409,
0.32888761162757874,
-0.42022180557250977,
0.22285760939121246,
-0.4391152858734131,
-0.3948275148868561,
-0.18844106793403625,
-0.14046581089496613,
-0.28630468249320984,
0.06352072209119797,
-0.06426724046468735,
0.2358158826828003,
0.24611032009124756,
-0.7373736500740051,
-0.046622324734926224,
-0.5471681356430054,
0.24457958340644836,
0.2658355236053467,
0.16881898045539856,
0.6297498345375061,
0.22108948230743408,
0.5144732594490051,
0.5631197690963745,
0.37477415800094604,
0.026066020131111145,
-0.5461899638175964,
-1.0695133209228516,
0.09595736861228943,
-0.12190485745668411,
0.5114307403564453,
-0.6663293242454529,
0.5608565807342529,
-0.18176357448101044,
-0.46910360455513,
-0.6389998197555542,
0.3739393651485443,
0.4493764638900757,
0.3221571743488312,
0.17580720782279968,
-0.6493664383888245,
-0.5534154176712036,
-1.0214232206344604,
0.23092445731163025,
-0.4076756238937378,
0.17839153110980988,
0.4130246639251709,
0.3098534047603607,
-0.20817188918590546,
1.0226616859436035,
-0.3521519601345062,
-0.967189371585846,
-0.6264317631721497,
0.35248270630836487,
0.48598381876945496,
0.3046649694442749,
0.21069948375225067,
-1.01211678981781,
-0.27846476435661316,
0.2566063106060028,
-1.0625559091567993,
0.3587146997451782,
0.1687556505203247,
0.005294987000524998,
0.27949342131614685,
0.22375458478927612,
-0.5388371348381042,
0.5959687232971191,
0.5046505331993103,
-0.32264474034309387,
0.2389543056488037,
0.0794750452041626,
0.14091110229492188,
-1.3337801694869995,
-0.14005140960216522,
0.27473193407058716,
0.08195751160383224,
-0.1984845995903015,
-0.039165347814559937,
-0.2515256404876709,
-0.518433690071106,
-0.7262831926345825,
0.33268803358078003,
-0.08040124922990799,
-0.017100952565670013,
-0.6985714435577393,
-0.19249612092971802,
0.4615408480167389,
0.8002419471740723,
0.3839748501777649,
0.2873041331768036,
0.3763396739959717,
-0.2308654636144638,
0.49623122811317444,
0.28038573265075684,
-0.35509487986564636,
0.5208836793899536,
-0.4346866309642792,
0.07655607163906097,
-0.12182921916246414,
0.15014642477035522,
-0.48050904273986816,
-0.12120921909809113,
0.32508426904678345,
-0.4164179265499115,
0.24777205288410187,
-0.3202471137046814,
0.007458199746906757,
-0.2900671362876892,
-0.2490016222000122,
0.6410930156707764,
0.39160189032554626,
-0.30662229657173157,
0.8584005832672119,
0.5860772728919983,
-0.24112887680530548,
-0.7858899235725403,
-0.3730921149253845,
0.038668442517519,
-0.12485559284687042,
-0.29978519678115845,
0.21788205206394196,
0.3190600275993347,
-0.29919201135635376,
-0.06256771832704544,
0.321505606174469,
-0.12235746532678604,
-0.053256817162036896,
0.4693189859390259,
0.18876662850379944,
-0.27084431052207947,
-0.12232745438814163,
0.1191972866654396,
0.09935496747493744,
0.20947808027267456,
0.04703908786177635,
0.5685808658599854,
-0.5132905840873718,
-0.025725634768605232,
-0.4384978115558624,
0.5128185749053955,
0.695845365524292,
-0.4627664089202881,
0.46237799525260925,
0.7647413015365601,
-0.39821621775627136,
0.048069555312395096,
-0.35461509227752686,
-0.052983567118644714,
-0.28930848836898804,
0.7174108624458313,
-0.039955589920282364,
-0.5684379935264587,
0.5014842748641968,
0.5473397970199585,
-0.2574763298034668,
0.3956088125705719,
0.4407309889793396,
-0.40009427070617676,
0.7676941752433777,
0.8344639539718628,
-0.5210532546043396,
0.5846547484397888,
-0.39474523067474365,
0.5047423839569092,
-1.048952579498291,
-0.3336672782897949,
-0.31582409143447876,
-0.3269481658935547,
-0.4849521815776825,
-0.20171178877353668,
0.36902305483818054,
0.18181222677230835,
-0.08727873861789703,
0.10135389119386673,
-0.3422597646713257,
0.35280123353004456,
0.33770594000816345,
0.3253006339073181,
0.1371200829744339,
0.09367847442626953,
0.3472200930118561,
0.01614619605243206,
-0.32490068674087524,
-0.3555343747138977,
0.8530929684638977,
0.7477593421936035,
0.7574620246887207,
0.09321197122335434,
0.4075993001461029,
0.6519505381584167,
0.7403619885444641,
-1.0659196376800537,
0.37427812814712524,
-0.7294580340385437,
-0.5402169227600098,
-0.25267699360847473,
0.020600005984306335,
-0.34867116808891296,
0.1664341688156128,
-0.30436643958091736,
-0.406817764043808,
0.737456738948822,
-0.1958816796541214,
-0.5345658659934998,
0.4380892813205719,
-0.3681175708770752,
0.7092931866645813,
-0.1284499168395996,
-0.2188940793275833,
-0.4575123190879822,
-0.3273456394672394,
0.2713039219379425,
-0.15266074240207672,
0.3229631185531616,
-0.4176276624202728,
0.3243873417377472,
0.8659387230873108,
-0.32937029004096985,
1.1736171245574951,
-0.10351314395666122,
-0.008193598128855228,
0.5693616271018982,
0.2746914327144623,
0.14542575180530548,
0.6972994208335876,
-0.19044101238250732,
0.8736763596534729,
-0.5996364951133728,
-0.1529812067747116,
-0.6060549020767212,
0.7621303200721741,
-1.061556339263916,
-0.6947326064109802,
-0.46623694896698,
-0.41516053676605225,
-0.032728809863328934,
0.10386090725660324,
0.3041367530822754,
0.2795441746711731,
-0.2443266659975052,
0.14836040139198303,
0.3428230881690979,
-0.15588872134685516,
0.6234912276268005,
0.41751551628112793,
-0.3755932152271271,
-0.8706991076469421,
1.0676579475402832,
-0.010852632112801075,
-0.3547373116016388,
0.3286050260066986,
0.23230722546577454,
-0.05664631351828575,
-0.5468397736549377,
-0.7498329281806946,
0.1229432076215744,
-0.7015519738197327,
-0.40107885003089905,
-0.5110169053077698,
-0.4569702446460724,
-0.4263627827167511,
-0.18187052011489868,
-0.7222621440887451,
-0.031677957624197006,
-0.34319454431533813,
-0.10587769001722336,
0.16705377399921417,
0.9181054830551147,
0.33931246399879456,
0.3650313913822174,
-0.7035780549049377,
0.1312745213508606,
0.12126501649618149,
0.26732397079467773,
-0.044267941266298294,
-0.6231788992881775,
-0.3893531858921051,
0.016311289742588997,
-0.4120117425918579,
-0.7342813611030579,
0.6891362071037292,
0.23292659223079681,
0.00007465128146577626,
0.4892643094062805,
-0.009935501031577587,
-0.05665525421500206,
0.0892539992928505,
0.9571344256401062,
0.29330122470855713,
-0.7504084706306458,
0.5573082566261292,
-0.05720305070281029,
0.35662394762039185,
0.5264811515808105,
0.42128583788871765,
-0.39884018898010254,
-0.2966805100440979,
-0.30848729610443115,
-0.6890755295753479,
0.6902620196342468,
0.3094937801361084,
0.44684332609176636,
0.07772959768772125,
0.24363520741462708,
0.4945746064186096,
0.4006478190422058,
-0.9340426921844482,
-0.14573274552822113,
-0.6298347115516663,
-0.30689916014671326,
-0.22842206060886383,
-0.42302486300468445,
0.13887280225753784,
-0.35687246918678284,
0.7869153022766113,
-0.1982399821281433,
0.07947124540805817,
0.2256208211183548,
-0.08933942019939423,
-0.017679421231150627,
0.5127674341201782,
0.18086226284503937,
0.23850494623184204,
-0.32765933871269226,
0.12190819531679153,
0.09658218920230865,
-0.6360121965408325,
0.2330777943134308,
0.14585073292255402,
-0.5039838552474976,
-0.005475286394357681,
0.2124958485364914,
1.0366801023483276,
-0.06956330686807632,
-0.1759130358695984,
0.5827974081039429,
-0.11640699207782745,
0.45930132269859314,
-0.8005693554878235,
-0.20247693359851837,
-0.37179577350616455,
0.25223949551582336,
0.3838779330253601,
0.32855507731437683,
0.143923819065094,
-0.5377116799354553,
0.033741194754838943,
0.3028717041015625,
-1.0596606731414795,
-0.4444409906864166,
0.11500796675682068,
0.5645477175712585,
-0.4072568118572235,
0.8233206868171692,
-0.3039977252483368,
-0.7036726474761963,
0.6779652833938599,
-0.05919888615608215,
1.3212321996688843,
-0.06520187109708786,
0.7049042582511902,
0.3340463936328888,
0.10234002768993378,
0.46845534443855286,
0.1185900866985321,
-0.020680973306298256,
-0.9553092122077942,
-0.23496825993061066,
-1.128620982170105,
-0.5555675029754639,
0.18953374028205872,
-0.5450553894042969,
0.2770930826663971,
-0.5643025636672974,
-0.21849313378334045,
0.029778974130749702,
-0.23171894252300262,
-0.5578444004058838,
0.5577091574668884,
0.559452474117279,
0.32869911193847656,
-0.8447422981262207,
0.9659901857376099,
0.9226476550102234,
-0.8305358290672302,
-0.3624470829963684,
-0.07262575626373291,
-0.3061954975128174,
-0.27788469195365906,
0.5450654029846191,
0.4963029623031616,
-0.045016154646873474,
-0.5196402668952942,
-0.26125001907348633,
-0.8265843391418457,
0.6142023801803589,
-0.06233495473861694,
-0.2958393394947052,
0.09249523282051086,
0.5215923190116882,
0.7598487734794617,
-0.9516100883483887,
0.1445164531469345,
0.46040526032447815,
0.09790956974029541,
-0.18232810497283936,
-0.4173605740070343,
-0.15253256261348724,
-0.4036950170993805,
-0.20111039280891418,
-0.13161976635456085,
-0.7164098024368286,
0.7405765056610107,
-0.14405086636543274,
0.2996774911880493,
-0.28682923316955566,
1.3673226833343506,
0.050031378865242004,
0.6428562998771667,
0.6233261227607727,
0.35813331604003906,
0.07512366026639938,
-0.018832707777619362,
0.9183660745620728,
-0.054044004529714584,
0.4420534670352936,
0.8634664416313171,
-0.25372955203056335,
0.9761483669281006,
0.4853622615337372,
0.004292876925319433,
0.9368682503700256,
0.5631597638130188,
0.08630827069282532,
0.44135430455207825,
-0.16461604833602905,
-0.3982468843460083,
-0.3424372375011444,
-0.5121007561683655,
0.11023576557636261,
0.5966479778289795,
0.5585668683052063,
-0.5870248079299927,
-0.11198911815881729,
0.571168839931488,
0.06785853207111359,
-0.15229375660419464,
-0.6984090805053711,
0.8742058873176575,
0.6387099623680115,
-1.0774160623550415,
0.19687782227993011,
-0.020095953717827797,
0.7907012701034546,
-0.20007243752479553,
0.11111804097890854,
-0.6693102717399597,
0.42186057567596436,
-0.39957961440086365,
-1.1789950132369995,
0.4935332238674164,
0.1144753023982048,
-0.6803228259086609,
0.36696523427963257,
0.5640923976898193,
-0.34105560183525085,
-0.8354161381721497,
0.3505977392196655,
0.001981446286663413,
-0.028630094602704048,
-0.36710429191589355,
-0.7605859637260437,
0.05130908265709877,
0.17579799890518188,
-0.32840579748153687,
0.05674414336681366,
0.16063754260540009,
-0.5107810497283936,
0.4667133688926697,
0.2501712441444397,
-0.20602956414222717,
-0.2895272374153137,
0.3863598704338074,
0.6905314922332764,
-0.7973464131355286,
-0.6265575885772705,
-0.7302603125572205,
0.3879810869693756,
-0.09403445571660995,
-0.46988916397094727,
0.3286663889884949,
0.35852235555648804,
0.5924098491668701,
-0.15083858370780945,
0.6820083856582642,
-0.11530564725399017,
0.17554660141468048,
-0.5184850096702576,
1.0262916088104248,
-0.4498032331466675,
0.26104360818862915,
-0.0657404214143753,
-1.096602439880371,
-0.21709075570106506,
0.25534534454345703,
-0.34764203429222107,
-0.02468053437769413,
0.693979799747467,
0.7125638127326965,
-0.07759436964988708,
0.32042497396469116,
0.14559777081012726,
0.20571471750736237,
0.4366176724433899,
0.2479785978794098,
0.6919258236885071,
-0.413918673992157,
0.3362565338611603,
-0.8699974417686462,
-0.18379586935043335,
-0.28801897168159485,
-0.7853027582168579,
-0.8535279035568237,
-0.5032089948654175,
-0.5612980723381042,
-0.4916708767414093,
-0.24031278491020203,
0.8248830437660217,
0.534247875213623,
-1.201956868171692,
-0.12579233944416046,
-0.019436512142419815,
0.41421785950660706,
-0.09492374956607819,
-0.24754248559474945,
0.6321175694465637,
-0.29156866669654846,
-0.6823148131370544,
0.3502693176269531,
0.23412960767745972,
0.07600576430559158,
-0.8972489833831787,
-0.10533654689788818,
-0.027956295758485794,
0.1302655190229416,
0.5731184482574463,
0.19455993175506592,
-0.694243848323822,
-0.12611214816570282,
-0.25476548075675964,
-0.0878177359700203,
0.11350787431001663,
0.8513365387916565,
-0.5610488653182983,
0.35452985763549805,
0.649146318435669,
0.35197797417640686,
0.2705371677875519,
-0.002015115926042199,
0.7176308631896973,
-0.925078809261322,
0.2774052917957306,
0.34773293137550354,
0.6476039290428162,
0.6575658321380615,
-0.6988475322723389,
0.2837178409099579,
0.1421889066696167,
-0.3776065707206726,
-0.39539530873298645,
0.1749129444360733,
-1.2947537899017334,
-0.1996348798274994,
1.1204942464828491,
-0.3125038146972656,
-0.7528225779533386,
-0.10797223448753357,
-0.2698493003845215,
0.21308110654354095,
-0.4661776125431061,
0.96659255027771,
0.5990728735923767,
-0.10719369351863861,
-0.17999149858951569,
0.1803816556930542,
0.3871093988418579,
0.6691136956214905,
-0.6056343913078308,
-0.05579853430390358,
0.3387046754360199,
0.022802604362368584,
0.5346364974975586,
0.15056869387626648,
-0.2818186581134796,
0.3255787193775177,
-0.5684559941291809,
0.48462092876434326,
-0.22724266350269318,
-0.36436089873313904,
-0.6211149096488953,
0.4619622528553009,
-0.013842500746250153,
-0.09568621218204498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19567v1
|
Dr-LLaVA: Visual Instruction Tuning with Symbolic Clinical Grounding
| 2024-05-29T23:19:28 | 2024-05-29T23:19:28 |
Shenghuan Sun, Gregory M. Goldgof, Alexander Schubert, Zhiqing Sun, Thomas Hartvigsen, Atul J. Butte, Ahmed Alaa
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Vision-Language Models (VLM) can support clinicians by analyzing medical
images and engaging in natural language interactions to assist in diagnostic
and treatment tasks. However, VLMs often exhibit "hallucinogenic" behavior,
generating textual outputs not grounded in contextual multimodal information.
This challenge is particularly pronounced in the medical domain, where we do
not only require VLM outputs to be accurate in single interactions but also to
be consistent with clinical reasoning and diagnostic pathways throughout
multi-turn conversations. For this purpose, we propose a new alignment
algorithm that uses symbolic representations of clinical reasoning to ground
VLMs in medical knowledge. These representations are utilized to (i) generate
GPT-4-guided visual instruction tuning data at scale, simulating clinician-VLM
conversations with demonstrations of clinical reasoning, and (ii) create an
automatic reward function that evaluates the clinical validity of VLM
generations throughout clinician-VLM interactions. Our algorithm eliminates the
need for human involvement in training data generation or reward model
construction, reducing costs compared to standard reinforcement learning with
human feedback (RLHF). We apply our alignment algorithm to develop Dr-LLaVA, a
conversational VLM finetuned for analyzing bone marrow pathology slides,
demonstrating strong performance in multi-turn medical conversations.
|
[
0.20867887139320374,
-0.7618321180343628,
0.8308377861976624,
-0.05882099270820618,
-0.57674640417099,
0.048109374940395355,
-0.0689074918627739,
-0.20336724817752838,
0.39110979437828064,
0.5625718235969543,
-0.7169753909111023,
-0.8652405142784119,
-0.5572865009307861,
-0.20663021504878998,
0.1345260888338089,
0.7102749347686768,
-0.10550548881292343,
0.731476902961731,
-0.5159120559692383,
-0.36740073561668396,
-1.1165286302566528,
-0.381616473197937,
-0.37692132592201233,
-0.3527897298336029,
0.4172803461551666,
0.27616310119628906,
0.6989889144897461,
1.0977598428726196,
0.7729557156562805,
0.2918466031551361,
0.33608752489089966,
0.507378339767456,
-0.5951581001281738,
0.3399564027786255,
-0.1324964165687561,
-0.363654762506485,
-0.5119163990020752,
-0.35527288913726807,
0.2884427309036255,
0.43689700961112976,
-0.3643943667411804,
-0.1414775550365448,
-0.3988088071346283,
0.6480512022972107,
-0.2654271423816681,
0.2156740128993988,
-0.5647879242897034,
0.14963912963867188,
0.05523064732551575,
-0.6780371069908142,
-0.4700339436531067,
-0.36642220616340637,
-0.0019561408553272486,
-0.7385630011558533,
-0.053592946380376816,
-0.13371454179286957,
1.0882771015167236,
0.8641124963760376,
-0.31204140186309814,
-0.25326046347618103,
-0.31195464730262756,
0.8339309692382812,
-0.5695973634719849,
0.27589619159698486,
0.2673174738883972,
0.6527954339981079,
-0.07299423962831497,
-0.5971118807792664,
-0.28984102606773376,
-0.24302536249160767,
-0.18911515176296234,
0.21995848417282104,
0.12988083064556122,
0.32954636216163635,
0.290709912776947,
0.003362294053658843,
-0.44453081488609314,
0.05151143670082092,
-0.40191757678985596,
-0.2215137481689453,
0.5517899394035339,
0.6609876155853271,
0.4009987711906433,
-0.011064484715461731,
-0.4202716648578644,
-0.2477056235074997,
-0.5876650214195251,
-0.20492678880691528,
-0.28500184416770935,
0.044363413006067276,
-0.1557667851448059,
0.8381500244140625,
0.06772516667842865,
0.9879012703895569,
0.10168464481830597,
-0.6007753014564514,
0.2700822055339813,
-0.20014043152332306,
-0.4039279818534851,
0.3311605155467987,
0.5384894013404846,
0.8930539488792419,
0.2720898389816284,
0.1550387591123581,
0.05554455891251564,
0.6007727384567261,
0.7277917265892029,
-0.6689285635948181,
-0.2612416446208954,
0.1792517751455307,
-0.436801016330719,
-0.605635941028595,
-0.2687722444534302,
-0.6802561283111572,
-0.6732214689254761,
-0.7662045955657959,
0.37843239307403564,
-0.6119918823242188,
0.12204635143280029,
0.1520562469959259,
-0.03159230202436447,
0.32631632685661316,
0.6547839045524597,
-0.8401378393173218,
0.1726781725883484,
0.41508322954177856,
0.5836604833602905,
-0.10082516074180603,
-0.12083853781223297,
-0.7538497447967529,
0.26465630531311035,
-0.4338408410549164,
0.6888697147369385,
-0.683442234992981,
-0.21950644254684448,
0.015400929376482964,
-0.036105576902627945,
-0.10568057745695114,
-0.39932721853256226,
0.35873329639434814,
-0.11966565996408463,
0.11531136184930801,
-0.28803813457489014,
-0.5031135678291321,
0.018951596692204475,
0.35083305835723877,
-0.15478621423244476,
0.7077726125717163,
0.16298384964466095,
-0.6080147624015808,
0.5104946494102478,
-0.21614091098308563,
-0.3144846260547638,
0.18958188593387604,
-0.9487490653991699,
-0.3842656910419464,
0.17177100479602814,
0.4238760471343994,
0.2712933421134949,
-0.16831307113170624,
0.6181498169898987,
-0.05259697884321213,
-0.409217894077301,
-0.12792450189590454,
-0.21444879472255707,
0.5564354658126831,
0.02261846326291561,
-0.5956544280052185,
0.6479180455207825,
-0.7342780232429504,
0.1380043476819992,
0.30629101395606995,
0.15386268496513367,
-0.5034361481666565,
0.05002422630786896,
-0.4840053617954254,
0.21135511994361877,
0.060407109558582306,
-0.28918179869651794,
0.5062756538391113,
-0.4835720658302307,
0.07063055038452148,
0.8052270412445068,
-0.15696832537651062,
0.15612681210041046,
-0.3763442933559418,
0.4868065416812897,
0.2135503590106964,
0.3262563645839691,
-0.17687924206256866,
-0.6477764248847961,
-0.8323776721954346,
-0.4276992082595825,
-0.154007226228714,
0.6645117402076721,
-0.8647292256355286,
0.24880066514015198,
-0.39659345149993896,
-0.3635067045688629,
-0.8196640014648438,
-0.028984434902668,
0.5688807368278503,
0.9555650949478149,
0.4759314954280853,
-0.3014114201068878,
-0.5656133890151978,
-0.9606884121894836,
0.13616016507148743,
-0.10668104887008667,
0.21960431337356567,
0.5754830837249756,
0.1675359308719635,
-0.340818852186203,
0.6684285998344421,
-0.5024042129516602,
-0.5429341793060303,
0.0435786210000515,
-0.07707788795232773,
0.035029467195272446,
0.3496301770210266,
0.2984769940376282,
-0.4735167920589447,
-0.2586258053779602,
0.2887267470359802,
-1.3689017295837402,
-0.19248245656490326,
-0.22468607127666473,
-0.24954411387443542,
0.12358715385198593,
0.3828548192977905,
-0.5028084516525269,
0.7484140992164612,
0.34140047430992126,
-0.4382328689098358,
0.3518126904964447,
-0.5818617343902588,
0.37653571367263794,
-0.8328520059585571,
-0.2821466028690338,
-0.1483880579471588,
-0.24389973282814026,
-0.5262229442596436,
0.0453060157597065,
0.14171263575553894,
0.05371026322245598,
-0.36646872758865356,
0.5601699352264404,
-0.30373793840408325,
0.18973368406295776,
-0.22800837457180023,
0.1316985934972763,
-0.1440093070268631,
0.2997274696826935,
0.34242740273475647,
0.6232439875602722,
0.6896176338195801,
-0.4824223816394806,
0.4039725959300995,
0.47527167201042175,
0.13021226227283478,
0.9572243690490723,
-0.5445371270179749,
0.06615737825632095,
-0.17951884865760803,
0.03668263554573059,
-0.6499872207641602,
-0.34562206268310547,
0.32445028424263,
-0.28155162930488586,
0.31297022104263306,
-0.09948881715536118,
-0.2008063942193985,
-0.21945762634277344,
-0.06924678385257721,
0.4291532635688782,
0.6442611813545227,
-0.4477354884147644,
0.5281982421875,
0.3296401798725128,
0.14655594527721405,
-0.6595224738121033,
-0.3967713713645935,
0.14242492616176605,
-0.15786878764629364,
-0.8058467507362366,
0.3181374669075012,
-0.01733928732573986,
-0.23110410571098328,
-0.14573611319065094,
-0.12517306208610535,
0.18744534254074097,
-0.20515750348567963,
0.45761600136756897,
0.5097687244415283,
-0.371614009141922,
0.27021703124046326,
0.3106364905834198,
-0.18736863136291504,
-0.07347920536994934,
-0.24918319284915924,
0.40605905652046204,
-0.04278484731912613,
-0.7360709309577942,
-0.5080931186676025,
0.1662522256374359,
0.5207504034042358,
-0.05752985551953316,
0.6024698615074158,
0.5129647254943848,
-0.4044189155101776,
0.04044988751411438,
-0.4166484773159027,
-0.390657901763916,
-0.4133704602718353,
0.2657651901245117,
-0.2462131828069687,
-0.6308775544166565,
0.03546116128563881,
-0.13190358877182007,
0.016412410885095596,
0.19108283519744873,
0.9744985699653625,
-0.18691016733646393,
1.3084443807601929,
0.5010152459144592,
0.5330000519752502,
-0.05827415734529495,
0.10222563147544861,
0.1498894840478897,
-0.5308129787445068,
-0.46511152386665344,
0.05370154231786728,
-0.27442455291748047,
-0.17538350820541382,
-0.6111472249031067,
0.4158461093902588,
-0.05420403555035591,
-0.11950504779815674,
-0.09748515486717224,
-0.9152069091796875,
0.45305168628692627,
0.3593299388885498,
0.3322688639163971,
0.1662781834602356,
0.16308890283107758,
-0.2934481203556061,
-0.5373854041099548,
-0.5859229564666748,
-0.5121889710426331,
0.9314789772033691,
0.2594316899776459,
0.8652085661888123,
-0.10395542532205582,
0.7857698798179626,
-0.022426921874284744,
0.4063749611377716,
-0.6496332287788391,
0.4468320906162262,
-0.14896941184997559,
-0.03193075582385063,
-0.24311406910419464,
-0.16960717737674713,
-0.7655821442604065,
0.3432643413543701,
-0.1828494369983673,
-0.6611090302467346,
-0.09553731977939606,
0.43915194272994995,
-0.13998432457447052,
0.0012456751428544521,
-0.5651949644088745,
0.9901636242866516,
-0.6288964152336121,
-0.5151559710502625,
-0.27117395401000977,
-0.9270606637001038,
0.45909613370895386,
0.18277660012245178,
0.11856775730848312,
-0.005823773797601461,
0.09844894707202911,
0.24053117632865906,
-0.42774859070777893,
0.9779157638549805,
-0.2626960575580597,
-0.14695435762405396,
-0.21331962943077087,
0.12306033074855804,
0.3954925537109375,
0.1763785481452942,
0.4745975434780121,
0.08175824582576752,
0.003922733478248119,
-0.37186139822006226,
-0.64556884765625,
0.720282793045044,
-0.6319101452827454,
-0.8204377889633179,
-0.40822726488113403,
-0.647002637386322,
-0.38884395360946655,
0.1120186299085617,
0.18664343655109406,
0.28885868191719055,
-0.07916814833879471,
-0.15719492733478546,
0.8108177185058594,
-0.3465781509876251,
-0.3520750403404236,
0.12189459055662155,
-0.25350484251976013,
-0.4738447964191437,
0.947472095489502,
-0.32951778173446655,
0.28889229893684387,
0.33289021253585815,
0.27843427658081055,
-0.10404124110937119,
-0.509611964225769,
-0.7662360668182373,
0.5385052561759949,
-0.9746724963188171,
-0.2510639429092407,
-0.5150681734085083,
-0.09685666859149933,
-0.27601659297943115,
-0.44918093085289,
-0.25393038988113403,
-0.1276922971010208,
-0.24330434203147888,
-0.04106069356203079,
0.3803694248199463,
0.5004207491874695,
0.283935010433197,
0.21542143821716309,
-0.6465867757797241,
0.4655480682849884,
0.12857238948345184,
0.22875036299228668,
-0.3891224265098572,
-0.3912696838378906,
-0.13706763088703156,
0.10060034692287445,
-0.2847358286380768,
-0.9916034936904907,
0.4701983630657196,
0.036787308752536774,
0.4977739751338959,
0.3357005715370178,
-0.216018944978714,
1.2108886241912842,
-0.7197730541229248,
0.6276922225952148,
0.48370951414108276,
-0.7243591547012329,
0.8482801914215088,
-0.12358666211366653,
0.04693985357880592,
0.42371323704719543,
0.012668580748140812,
-0.26431718468666077,
-0.39819031953811646,
-0.5017496943473816,
-0.5466585755348206,
0.4955345094203949,
0.09786738455295563,
0.0023786169476807117,
-0.06917676329612732,
0.19345779716968536,
0.15515005588531494,
0.24097618460655212,
-0.3426835834980011,
-0.29150286316871643,
-0.5288048982620239,
-0.7489404082298279,
0.021062500774860382,
-0.11528035253286362,
-0.773223340511322,
-0.5459014177322388,
0.3632756769657135,
-0.364962100982666,
0.3009956181049347,
0.31149646639823914,
-0.30262020230293274,
-0.2246745079755783,
-0.11665991693735123,
1.0811846256256104,
0.7116687893867493,
-0.14381282031536102,
0.11644056439399719,
-0.00024337286595255136,
-0.5653513073921204,
0.1758960634469986,
-0.17955563962459564,
0.05970913544297218,
0.08551859110593796,
0.3546799421310425,
1.1881626844406128,
0.2282908409833908,
-0.9489243626594543,
0.5936964750289917,
-0.17273756861686707,
-0.494915634393692,
-0.1249166950583458,
0.08650881052017212,
-0.018798762932419777,
0.2393731325864792,
-0.2515158951282501,
-0.02354177087545395,
-0.16452723741531372,
-0.06459342688322067,
0.4703595042228699,
0.5359779000282288,
-0.6604004502296448,
-0.09147975593805313,
0.8979792594909668,
0.04249824583530426,
-0.20274677872657776,
0.8297054767608643,
0.2834926247596741,
-0.20128948986530304,
0.5078586339950562,
0.6106308698654175,
0.563531219959259,
-0.032311663031578064,
0.4230921268463135,
0.22968240082263947,
0.2323182374238968,
0.0816761776804924,
0.22990964353084564,
0.20566222071647644,
-0.5137630105018616,
-0.44409963488578796,
-0.483397513628006,
-0.1721489131450653,
-0.06635596603155136,
-0.49777188897132874,
0.5550389289855957,
-0.4400017559528351,
-0.03695055842399597,
0.054447390139102936,
-0.44395288825035095,
-0.5760906934738159,
0.29283231496810913,
0.28043603897094727,
0.5107855200767517,
-0.7228113412857056,
1.0478109121322632,
0.7291277647018433,
-0.41701263189315796,
-0.7904970049858093,
-0.4278954267501831,
0.27827420830726624,
-1.3191466331481934,
0.9319387674331665,
0.12050370126962662,
-0.07236186414957047,
-0.17138482630252838,
-0.49313387274742126,
-0.5419942736625671,
1.2053977251052856,
0.5145665407180786,
-0.5941113829612732,
-0.011899217963218689,
0.04302572086453438,
0.7870633006095886,
-0.5753429532051086,
0.08788745105266571,
0.468149334192276,
0.3808406591415405,
0.3497246205806732,
-0.8048848509788513,
0.19461141526699066,
-0.2153884470462799,
-0.17408022284507751,
0.3399125933647156,
-0.23539689183235168,
0.4386903941631317,
-0.5621981024742126,
-0.07915177941322327,
-0.03614945337176323,
0.33720093965530396,
0.6368089318275452,
0.3936479389667511,
0.3094613552093506,
0.7208830118179321,
0.8204118013381958,
-0.13709868490695953,
1.0810694694519043,
-0.2312719225883484,
0.03394569829106331,
0.7757960557937622,
-0.4308728575706482,
0.24671563506126404,
0.9029428362846375,
0.1617055982351303,
0.2852896451950073,
0.4239119589328766,
-0.09751932322978973,
0.600318968296051,
0.2605610191822052,
0.026158222928643227,
-0.37463581562042236,
-0.04352765902876854,
-0.4320972263813019,
0.2595599591732025,
0.377661794424057,
-0.4723333418369293,
-0.0758422464132309,
-0.012320099398493767,
-0.30700650811195374,
0.22159001231193542,
-0.11163416504859924,
0.9438735246658325,
0.12626364827156067,
-0.5936068892478943,
1.0546605587005615,
-0.35533347725868225,
0.1785384863615036,
-0.5397423505783081,
-0.577570915222168,
-0.20493410527706146,
0.19343209266662598,
-0.22281891107559204,
-0.5019189715385437,
0.19512417912483215,
-0.2547414302825928,
0.05855930596590042,
-0.028221527114510536,
0.579971432685852,
-0.42094147205352783,
-0.45456522703170776,
0.12289318442344666,
0.4696815609931946,
0.15695011615753174,
0.4705222249031067,
-0.7178224325180054,
0.18878421187400818,
0.21914523839950562,
0.13622474670410156,
0.5445563793182373,
0.43211811780929565,
-0.3874967396259308,
0.7124889492988586,
0.602901816368103,
0.1634209007024765,
0.02160153165459633,
0.5735766887664795,
0.8156654238700867,
-0.6902472972869873,
-0.2663423418998718,
-0.8246079087257385,
0.582338809967041,
-0.17559240758419037,
-0.30763205885887146,
0.379734605550766,
0.18441180884838104,
0.3948623239994049,
-0.22033970057964325,
0.47693508863449097,
0.21121898293495178,
-0.06445235013961792,
-0.8073068261146545,
0.35434964299201965,
-0.7735951542854309,
0.3276187479496002,
-0.2660506069660187,
-0.478240042924881,
-0.5713469982147217,
0.8414933681488037,
-0.09987100958824158,
-0.2330075204372406,
0.8732179999351501,
0.6991150379180908,
0.05878378823399544,
-0.1819840371608734,
0.6630882620811462,
0.03296650946140289,
0.40242546796798706,
0.4470174014568329,
0.5957282185554504,
-0.19512993097305298,
0.17822283506393433,
-0.32178112864494324,
-0.41876447200775146,
-0.2823944687843323,
-0.7541704177856445,
-0.9859172701835632,
-0.3030758798122406,
-0.35752108693122864,
-0.4330015182495117,
0.428312212228775,
0.8466559052467346,
0.6779420375823975,
-0.5540478825569153,
-0.13044799864292145,
-0.16254229843616486,
0.04259626194834709,
-0.5203365683555603,
-0.11141576617956161,
0.6055364608764648,
-0.5912866592407227,
-0.4013214409351349,
0.3837619721889496,
0.6549039483070374,
-0.02119504101574421,
-0.05084800347685814,
-0.3214978873729706,
0.22808247804641724,
-0.1403387188911438,
0.5516374707221985,
0.022512033581733704,
-1.0922023057937622,
-0.22696563601493835,
0.230038121342659,
-0.3322049677371979,
0.4496631920337677,
0.8167122602462769,
-0.8637318015098572,
0.6982052326202393,
0.030973637476563454,
0.7932340502738953,
0.21126379072666168,
0.13173338770866394,
0.6870622038841248,
-0.5660982728004456,
0.17231538891792297,
0.43650922179222107,
0.17922824621200562,
0.25323817133903503,
-0.5696430802345276,
0.3828243017196655,
0.29232481122016907,
-0.45270824432373047,
-0.9369108080863953,
0.2404380887746811,
-1.2281053066253662,
-0.1592838168144226,
0.9451068043708801,
0.283651202917099,
-0.21611298620700836,
0.1362914741039276,
-0.6463274955749512,
0.20041322708129883,
-0.15712952613830566,
0.8535670042037964,
0.3516349792480469,
-0.3368167579174042,
-0.31498152017593384,
-0.5721864104270935,
0.6351445317268372,
0.495953232049942,
-0.8721591830253601,
-0.08878596872091293,
0.6154941916465759,
0.05428548529744148,
-0.06024087965488434,
0.6813570261001587,
-0.32674849033355713,
0.43262094259262085,
-0.03716141730546951,
0.10926812887191772,
-0.1727842390537262,
-0.2560157775878906,
-0.19449546933174133,
-0.22285737097263336,
-0.010438692755997181,
-0.19536298513412476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19563v1
|
Unlearning Climate Misinformation in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-29T23:11:53 | 2024-05-29T23:11:53 |
Michael Fore, Simranjit Singh, Chaehong Lee, Amritanshu Pandey, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Dimitrios Stamoulis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Misinformation regarding climate change is a key roadblock in addressing one
of the most serious threats to humanity. This paper investigates factual
accuracy in large language models (LLMs) regarding climate information. Using
true/false labeled Q&A data for fine-tuning and evaluating LLMs on
climate-related claims, we compare open-source models, assessing their ability
to generate truthful responses to climate change questions. We investigate the
detectability of models intentionally poisoned with false climate information,
finding that such poisoning may not affect the accuracy of a model's responses
in other domains. Furthermore, we compare the effectiveness of unlearning
algorithms, fine-tuning, and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) for factually
grounding LLMs on climate change topics. Our evaluation reveals that unlearning
algorithms can be effective for nuanced conceptual claims, despite previous
findings suggesting their inefficacy in privacy contexts. These insights aim to
guide the development of more factually reliable LLMs and highlight the need
for additional work to secure LLMs against misinformation attacks.
|
[
0.041151419281959534,
-0.7969773411750793,
0.7580138444900513,
-0.19522354006767273,
-0.0848875418305397,
0.21076510846614838,
-0.5249146819114685,
-0.4077456295490265,
-0.4129427373409271,
0.6735429763793945,
-0.22477877140045166,
-0.4984261691570282,
-0.6552394032478333,
-0.1677209734916687,
-0.4292682409286499,
0.8430936932563782,
0.3266434967517853,
0.009541448205709457,
-0.2527632713317871,
-0.008721656166017056,
-0.33537113666534424,
-0.34822291135787964,
-0.39358335733413696,
-0.4003313183784485,
0.7148720622062683,
0.5468502044677734,
0.9242028594017029,
0.5260415077209473,
0.2699429392814636,
0.23462031781673431,
-0.38587555289268494,
0.2787407338619232,
-0.6801702380180359,
0.11862166225910187,
-0.4900527000427246,
-0.4928692877292633,
0.14160767197608948,
0.24828961491584778,
0.4453166425228119,
0.4470159113407135,
-0.34337812662124634,
0.39206042885780334,
0.14136642217636108,
0.599639892578125,
-0.8098729252815247,
0.1714993268251419,
-1.1702018976211548,
-0.2439921796321869,
-0.14900776743888855,
-0.14465534687042236,
-0.726574182510376,
-0.12528672814369202,
-0.008800113573670387,
-0.49712952971458435,
0.5581687092781067,
0.32839900255203247,
0.7236091494560242,
0.5913821458816528,
-0.4142013192176819,
-0.5260210037231445,
-0.829710066318512,
0.7256770730018616,
-1.0285067558288574,
0.5100321769714355,
0.28658783435821533,
0.17183397710323334,
-0.25717893242836,
-0.5072853565216064,
-0.7551785707473755,
-0.16511742770671844,
-0.10917757451534271,
0.07162536680698395,
-0.29384809732437134,
-0.23385308682918549,
0.37402597069740295,
0.043870795518159866,
-0.5811883807182312,
0.4279930293560028,
-0.41617944836616516,
-0.36325758695602417,
0.683407187461853,
-0.08848372101783752,
0.17748872935771942,
-0.27173566818237305,
-0.29131776094436646,
-0.12293565273284912,
-0.9996548891067505,
-0.2018824964761734,
0.5846648216247559,
0.54490727186203,
-0.25872382521629333,
0.6431861519813538,
-0.038342785090208054,
0.45259883999824524,
0.0295344777405262,
-0.2375430464744568,
-0.03124878741800785,
-0.12842340767383575,
-0.24263837933540344,
0.2464928925037384,
0.5474152565002441,
0.5274183750152588,
0.14471234381198883,
-0.5038592219352722,
-0.10484534502029419,
-0.16759096086025238,
0.13898204267024994,
-0.7353995442390442,
-0.30304843187332153,
0.17017808556556702,
-0.10658922046422958,
-0.2953859269618988,
0.0831093117594719,
-0.99509596824646,
-0.860724687576294,
-0.3690299093723297,
0.2926856279373169,
0.06202219799160957,
-0.17506106197834015,
0.09040405601263046,
-0.30530163645744324,
-0.08025504648685455,
0.4960402548313141,
-0.28101736307144165,
-0.08303025364875793,
0.6222088932991028,
0.6933990716934204,
0.03268539905548096,
-0.10948731005191803,
-0.3877864181995392,
0.0663573294878006,
-0.4217589497566223,
0.6901963949203491,
-0.5281975269317627,
-0.2623094618320465,
-0.05098412558436394,
0.01658032462000847,
0.0555717758834362,
-0.5302615165710449,
0.39070403575897217,
-0.7953534722328186,
0.49703964591026306,
-0.3541213870048523,
-0.5237107276916504,
-0.3275246024131775,
0.12117636203765869,
-0.52956223487854,
0.66936194896698,
-0.2660823464393616,
-1.026629090309143,
0.29561153054237366,
-0.44454067945480347,
0.003544350154697895,
-0.07954882085323334,
0.11152932792901993,
-0.507889449596405,
-0.09787613898515701,
0.012809877283871174,
0.3657241761684418,
-0.5498138070106506,
0.614948034286499,
-0.2857530415058136,
0.07285518199205399,
0.4309040606021881,
-0.8481097221374512,
0.8126331567764282,
0.34417489171028137,
-0.398772656917572,
-0.006670692935585976,
-0.6378986835479736,
-0.11839963495731354,
0.202689066529274,
-0.4504842162132263,
-0.20495948195457458,
0.041063275188207626,
-0.18505294620990753,
0.0013255832018330693,
0.3207716643810272,
-0.7618021368980408,
-0.0863257348537445,
-0.17238697409629822,
0.42078009247779846,
0.7122684717178345,
0.0323205292224884,
0.23954617977142334,
-0.4955815076828003,
0.1463577002286911,
0.12407928705215454,
0.035773865878582,
-0.02863042987883091,
-0.5398280620574951,
-0.4858311116695404,
0.15709231793880463,
0.2492980808019638,
0.681208074092865,
-0.6944436430931091,
0.2695232033729553,
-0.21405765414237976,
-0.8968492150306702,
-0.2877119481563568,
0.24698294699192047,
0.3658539652824402,
0.9328835606575012,
0.4049597978591919,
0.31087830662727356,
-0.32720956206321716,
-0.5755670666694641,
-0.6589706540107727,
-0.3097500205039978,
0.15448902547359467,
0.2705777585506439,
0.6048378944396973,
-0.36305752396583557,
0.9290621876716614,
-0.5243576765060425,
0.29965847730636597,
0.1369316279888153,
0.24476364254951477,
-0.04557414352893829,
0.4462187886238098,
0.5836647748947144,
-1.0055979490280151,
-0.3335500657558441,
-0.10214108973741531,
-0.5852129459381104,
0.1279607117176056,
0.06922698020935059,
0.2828695774078369,
0.34904852509498596,
0.32234349846839905,
-0.5117717385292053,
0.49303320050239563,
0.614564836025238,
-0.347480446100235,
0.6171098947525024,
-0.43854963779449463,
0.16261518001556396,
-0.8817263841629028,
0.14345484972000122,
0.04904088377952576,
-0.21478182077407837,
-0.7246127128601074,
-0.10821370035409927,
0.06430652737617493,
0.0690225288271904,
-0.5617690682411194,
0.764457643032074,
-0.4256289601325989,
0.234889954328537,
-0.33387866616249084,
0.07878740131855011,
0.025938119739294052,
0.11238942295312881,
-0.21222999691963196,
0.7016920447349548,
0.46449384093284607,
-0.5974929928779602,
0.5339815020561218,
0.18953360617160797,
-0.4978752136230469,
0.15000484883785248,
-0.3913746178150177,
0.24424771964550018,
-0.43395698070526123,
0.27788877487182617,
-0.8052692413330078,
-0.4507337212562561,
0.22978714108467102,
-0.539162278175354,
0.19781027734279633,
-0.1910923272371292,
-0.7334016561508179,
-0.17917238175868988,
-0.03743515536189079,
0.1428331881761551,
0.5949108600616455,
-0.9419178366661072,
0.30989131331443787,
0.44588345289230347,
-0.07855258136987686,
-0.679599940776825,
-0.6820700168609619,
0.15382738411426544,
-0.33576956391334534,
-0.3705492913722992,
-0.08095985651016235,
-0.18938395380973816,
-0.5767428874969482,
0.039581578224897385,
-0.41739702224731445,
-0.08640357106924057,
0.37486082315444946,
0.3099498450756073,
0.04231565445661545,
-0.12198598682880402,
0.274192750453949,
-0.5316500663757324,
0.12828610837459564,
0.2087498903274536,
-0.06671128422021866,
0.4470551609992981,
0.048131462186574936,
-0.12263015657663345,
-0.13391168415546417,
0.004597246181219816,
0.686517059803009,
-0.03123478591442108,
1.0923514366149902,
0.2712165117263794,
-0.5745470523834229,
-0.05906877666711807,
-0.7291296720504761,
-0.09939031302928925,
-0.4467932879924774,
0.08289175480604172,
0.3000287413597107,
-1.0120071172714233,
0.4628632068634033,
-0.2993415296077728,
0.1912301480770111,
0.6057753562927246,
0.262495756149292,
-0.015066562220454216,
0.8096827268600464,
0.693701982498169,
-0.013663125224411488,
0.1288466900587082,
-0.0052573783323168755,
0.3400825560092926,
-0.5800660848617554,
-0.5896196365356445,
-0.8422899842262268,
0.11908680200576782,
-0.6797351241111755,
-0.5464736819267273,
0.308122456073761,
0.10396039485931396,
-0.5865876078605652,
-0.006356655154377222,
-0.2586195170879364,
0.6891018748283386,
0.29696449637413025,
0.14791181683540344,
0.3552367687225342,
0.011802870780229568,
0.16985203325748444,
0.15806590020656586,
-0.6893821358680725,
-0.6354995369911194,
0.9667495489120483,
0.35302454233169556,
0.925777792930603,
0.2882983088493347,
0.09370693564414978,
0.398362398147583,
0.3788132071495056,
-0.5116466879844666,
0.1902584284543991,
-0.07943528145551682,
-0.7044583559036255,
-0.46557652950286865,
-0.6827379465103149,
-0.7464663982391357,
0.20081868767738342,
-0.4347076714038849,
-0.7094942331314087,
0.25447598099708557,
0.3588375747203827,
-0.08903338015079498,
0.6687491536140442,
-0.523514449596405,
0.6711612343788147,
-0.3357228636741638,
-0.11598815023899078,
-0.3022804260253906,
-0.6146411895751953,
0.4088970422744751,
-0.4758259356021881,
0.5980167388916016,
-0.2810669541358948,
0.13565872609615326,
0.6268889307975769,
-0.3030281066894531,
1.1109529733657837,
-0.20240294933319092,
-0.292642205953598,
0.17071722447872162,
-0.006705115083605051,
0.5681282877922058,
0.09987815469503403,
-0.391182005405426,
0.29512104392051697,
-0.11324649304151535,
-0.5021821856498718,
-0.4495711922645569,
0.6764428019523621,
-0.7513331174850464,
-0.7783278226852417,
-0.45414191484451294,
-0.4699011445045471,
-0.317968487739563,
0.18836989998817444,
0.4224282205104828,
0.30047497153282166,
-0.28128981590270996,
0.22645379602909088,
0.896800696849823,
-0.36600765585899353,
0.13211771845817566,
0.9239786863327026,
-0.09527608007192612,
-0.17631173133850098,
0.8010340929031372,
0.2277827113866806,
0.35498523712158203,
0.2750188410282135,
0.6541740894317627,
-0.24981118738651276,
-0.5765868425369263,
-0.2354939728975296,
0.3782425820827484,
-0.7980866432189941,
-0.5364579558372498,
-0.41589558124542236,
-0.2888159453868866,
-0.5960304141044617,
0.11295098066329956,
-0.30584558844566345,
-0.044069625437259674,
-0.2772878110408783,
-0.3179005980491638,
0.6716169118881226,
0.9157233834266663,
-0.16385678946971893,
0.4532049000263214,
-0.8523962497711182,
0.16076529026031494,
0.15903432667255402,
0.02602950483560562,
-0.03356890007853508,
-0.7500755190849304,
-0.214562326669693,
0.660709798336029,
-0.1875065565109253,
-0.7889474034309387,
0.3824271857738495,
0.09286703914403915,
0.44852572679519653,
0.4321307837963104,
0.35454627871513367,
0.5311836004257202,
-0.43075671792030334,
0.905200719833374,
0.18986108899116516,
-0.9736665487289429,
0.3796886205673218,
-0.14613193273544312,
0.2817130386829376,
0.33528581261634827,
0.4481281340122223,
-0.6841095089912415,
-0.43376511335372925,
-0.8936215043067932,
-0.771865963935852,
0.4790663719177246,
-0.21573102474212646,
0.13046634197235107,
0.13353337347507477,
0.5751205682754517,
0.2767297327518463,
0.4787270724773407,
-0.4570268392562866,
-0.2855357825756073,
-0.0764080286026001,
0.061087336391210556,
-0.44466230273246765,
-0.2902365028858185,
-0.2544936537742615,
-0.12899990379810333,
0.8434168100357056,
-0.23355220258235931,
-0.18557679653167725,
0.0659138560295105,
-0.02267068810760975,
-0.3439069390296936,
0.4006696939468384,
0.5435976386070251,
0.7821601629257202,
0.023746518418192863,
0.42837175726890564,
0.3457581698894501,
-0.3562287986278534,
-0.03715018182992935,
-0.3152899444103241,
-0.4772579073905945,
0.027882108464837074,
0.4249081015586853,
0.7456727623939514,
0.09876593202352524,
-0.7649774551391602,
0.6130947470664978,
-0.0687084048986435,
-0.02061273902654648,
-0.19052231311798096,
0.08016085624694824,
0.13297422230243683,
0.06034952029585838,
0.10476174205541611,
0.3509097099304199,
-0.032184261828660965,
-0.7585881352424622,
-0.05103808641433716,
0.50679612159729,
-0.14933228492736816,
-0.3058139383792877,
0.6417484879493713,
-0.0042855520732700825,
0.06481045484542847,
0.679537832736969,
0.09435059130191803,
-0.5466735363006592,
0.480251669883728,
0.5099999904632568,
0.37914547324180603,
-0.36281105875968933,
0.3720904290676117,
0.30393680930137634,
0.5257576107978821,
-0.2908616364002228,
0.06505115330219269,
0.10571600496768951,
-0.9486556649208069,
-0.2974187433719635,
-0.48596012592315674,
-0.5358269214630127,
0.3914933502674103,
-0.46489399671554565,
-0.07367975264787674,
-0.5373091697692871,
0.15112106502056122,
-0.10087969899177551,
-0.14434505999088287,
-0.6184839606285095,
0.31003469228744507,
0.13406182825565338,
1.0315712690353394,
-0.9583612680435181,
0.6114267706871033,
0.4113326370716095,
-0.15463128685951233,
-0.7839059829711914,
0.22543103992938995,
0.40912139415740967,
-0.6791195273399353,
0.5418737530708313,
-0.008183651603758335,
-0.3403339684009552,
-0.2357458472251892,
-1.2422842979431152,
-0.9401073455810547,
0.9477320909500122,
0.7943500876426697,
-0.7015998363494873,
0.08672776073217392,
0.11073017865419388,
0.38660040497779846,
-0.12462767213582993,
-0.08162521570920944,
0.5419825911521912,
0.765365481376648,
0.2973408102989197,
-0.893990159034729,
0.015920817852020264,
0.2154151052236557,
-0.25473031401634216,
-0.01764032244682312,
-0.7635703086853027,
0.6104410886764526,
-0.4678365886211395,
-0.5198599696159363,
-0.07756976783275604,
0.6320001482963562,
-0.07621202617883682,
0.5981435775756836,
0.6244406700134277,
0.4442131519317627,
1.3392974138259888,
-0.12544681131839752,
0.8356420993804932,
-0.21381217241287231,
0.37142542004585266,
1.1350456476211548,
-0.3872404396533966,
0.8123825192451477,
0.13547199964523315,
0.2978266775608063,
0.18458232283592224,
0.5449691414833069,
-0.028806185349822044,
0.45407119393348694,
0.2848251461982727,
-0.16490957140922546,
-0.30665627121925354,
-0.30430370569229126,
-0.03485261648893356,
0.3714366555213928,
0.558588981628418,
0.0752648338675499,
-0.39904430508613586,
0.10219157487154007,
0.4829147756099701,
0.3206227719783783,
-0.37250036001205444,
0.8390230536460876,
0.01971982978284359,
-0.55577152967453,
0.5185327529907227,
0.1526166796684265,
0.7038469910621643,
-0.1732569932937622,
0.025350073352456093,
0.016474084928631783,
-0.07001113146543503,
-0.49135202169418335,
-0.8407068252563477,
0.3472748398780823,
0.46672236919403076,
-0.2940220534801483,
-0.09122603386640549,
0.5585774183273315,
-0.6189069151878357,
-0.24025508761405945,
0.025493955239653587,
0.41181647777557373,
0.2302970141172409,
-0.23796243965625763,
-0.6925317645072937,
0.028290841728448868,
0.15756137669086456,
-0.07371339946985245,
0.12081356346607208,
0.37378907203674316,
0.12001219391822815,
0.8571133017539978,
0.8023384809494019,
0.22398820519447327,
0.2083791196346283,
-0.26686856150627136,
0.6970782279968262,
-0.576735258102417,
-0.12203174084424973,
-0.6274730563163757,
0.33917853236198425,
-0.09066123515367508,
-0.11698409169912338,
0.854279637336731,
0.574631929397583,
0.9048209190368652,
0.11497090011835098,
0.9542250037193298,
0.28966543078422546,
0.7977985739707947,
-0.8755032420158386,
0.7194768786430359,
-0.39756450057029724,
0.39720845222473145,
0.28205370903015137,
-0.8657578229904175,
-0.2641604244709015,
0.19756534695625305,
-0.46043118834495544,
-0.035915423184633255,
0.5959227085113525,
0.7801185846328735,
0.1415729820728302,
0.07222400605678558,
0.36953842639923096,
0.7075783014297485,
0.41882267594337463,
-0.0900733545422554,
0.7625005841255188,
-0.07065635919570923,
0.23596462607383728,
-0.24464210867881775,
0.008284937590360641,
-0.2469518929719925,
-1.0079021453857422,
-0.7044745683670044,
-0.4903929531574249,
-0.5950554013252258,
-0.5664524435997009,
0.19781151413917542,
0.6722277402877808,
0.33685779571533203,
-0.7214080095291138,
0.10050135105848312,
0.17151902616024017,
0.24841253459453583,
0.311907559633255,
-0.22701941430568695,
0.37236499786376953,
-0.12741819024085999,
-0.5525693893432617,
0.5578497648239136,
0.05531851947307587,
0.13367754220962524,
-0.3001288175582886,
-0.07000572979450226,
0.039025139063596725,
0.43958738446235657,
0.298955500125885,
0.5335525870323181,
-0.8077982068061829,
-0.6625465750694275,
-0.32434985041618347,
-0.18722477555274963,
-0.09212750196456909,
0.5323914885520935,
-0.5773599743843079,
0.31564345955848694,
0.38779595494270325,
0.5868597030639648,
0.08146443963050842,
0.10933451354503632,
0.22892649471759796,
-0.7258062362670898,
-0.08436673134565353,
0.19662483036518097,
0.36226460337638855,
0.740511417388916,
-0.631557822227478,
0.253933310508728,
0.23722802102565765,
-0.7080978155136108,
-0.9912469983100891,
0.1694992482662201,
-0.7696565389633179,
-0.5822650790214539,
1.2522902488708496,
-0.08260133862495422,
-0.39439550042152405,
-0.14588147401809692,
-0.10713472217321396,
0.08844999223947525,
-0.3795178532600403,
0.7730363011360168,
0.7966185808181763,
0.11164987087249756,
0.13687781989574432,
-0.5500029921531677,
0.5104338526725769,
0.006134666968137026,
-0.7385689616203308,
0.5748926401138306,
0.6622605323791504,
0.6188706755638123,
0.3197600543498993,
0.0501929372549057,
0.11689194291830063,
0.11451492458581924,
-0.2556050717830658,
0.027242936193943024,
-0.020048148930072784,
-0.4922443926334381,
-0.35090556740760803,
-0.07447617501020432,
0.22066831588745117,
0.2596243619918823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19562v1
|
Selective Explanations
| 2024-05-29T23:08:31 | 2024-05-29T23:08:31 |
Lucas Monteiro Paes, Dennis Wei, Flavio P. Calmon
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Feature attribution methods explain black-box machine learning (ML) models by
assigning importance scores to input features. These methods can be
computationally expensive for large ML models. To address this challenge, there
has been increasing efforts to develop amortized explainers, where a machine
learning model is trained to predict feature attribution scores with only one
inference. Despite their efficiency, amortized explainers can produce
inaccurate predictions and misleading explanations. In this paper, we propose
selective explanations, a novel feature attribution method that (i) detects
when amortized explainers generate low-quality explanations and (ii) improves
these explanations using a technique called explanations with initial guess.
Our selective explanation method allows practitioners to specify the fraction
of samples that receive explanations with initial guess, offering a principled
way to bridge the gap between amortized explainers and their high-quality
counterparts.
|
[
-0.3868003487586975,
-0.7779690027236938,
0.6982476115226746,
-0.05743538215756416,
-0.5760671496391296,
-0.15205782651901245,
0.20577606558799744,
-0.2919955253601074,
0.1348526030778885,
0.5616379976272583,
-0.8005973696708679,
-0.135598823428154,
-0.5264277458190918,
-0.4110517203807831,
-0.3392966389656067,
1.1808933019638062,
-0.32614925503730774,
-0.22916565835475922,
-0.4203120768070221,
-0.16683807969093323,
-0.1294940561056137,
-0.11578492075204849,
-0.592490553855896,
-0.6174482107162476,
0.9094319343566895,
0.4071349799633026,
0.9159172177314758,
0.9795573353767395,
0.26586171984672546,
0.16534321010112762,
-0.09346316009759903,
0.09835093468427658,
-0.2376817911863327,
-0.07675518095493317,
0.046805836260318756,
-1.0032646656036377,
-0.21795415878295898,
0.23970897495746613,
0.48779186606407166,
0.7113435864448547,
0.08019184321165085,
0.31717348098754883,
0.04877058416604996,
0.4059189558029175,
-0.9496103525161743,
-0.2725923955440521,
-0.8044561147689819,
0.14530450105667114,
0.011894484050571918,
-0.45744627714157104,
-0.5457841753959656,
-0.40068939328193665,
0.29311683773994446,
-0.5279458165168762,
0.7699831128120422,
-0.15314629673957825,
1.143959641456604,
0.671340823173523,
-0.15955647826194763,
-0.0051226490177214146,
-0.7697317004203796,
1.0024731159210205,
-0.059892501682043076,
-0.1134185791015625,
0.48119720816612244,
0.6867710947990417,
0.45071035623550415,
-0.3541758060455322,
-0.15605589747428894,
-0.000552545243408531,
-0.16926869750022888,
0.03655371069908142,
-0.17632605135440826,
0.03202774003148079,
-0.07010719925165176,
0.4606626033782959,
-0.4525516927242279,
0.32939469814300537,
-0.3717399835586548,
-0.4745429754257202,
0.8131631016731262,
0.03441515192389488,
-0.41847389936447144,
0.11535794287919998,
-0.5629306435585022,
0.21617868542671204,
-0.5329413414001465,
0.4262183904647827,
0.4104688763618469,
-0.1349322348833084,
-0.052764952182769775,
0.5283609628677368,
0.2899012267589569,
0.7267795205116272,
0.2142585664987564,
0.16096004843711853,
0.022645331919193268,
-0.008516089990735054,
-0.3212489187717438,
0.4894880950450897,
0.4892728924751282,
0.14083634316921234,
0.10955049842596054,
-0.15433155000209808,
-0.2919633388519287,
0.5039227604866028,
0.4194052815437317,
-0.5930380821228027,
-0.23794002830982208,
0.588003396987915,
-0.8140755891799927,
-0.7835390567779541,
-0.16062909364700317,
-0.8277345299720764,
-0.49042341113090515,
0.05002504959702492,
0.42635348439216614,
-0.24687352776527405,
-0.21389083564281464,
-0.1386600136756897,
-0.4746769070625305,
-0.06672405451536179,
0.5491291880607605,
-0.8417007923126221,
0.04420005530118942,
0.40947967767715454,
0.6944098472595215,
-0.228877454996109,
-0.10562670975923538,
-0.38805705308914185,
0.06817641854286194,
-0.4475848376750946,
1.094096302986145,
-0.5731496810913086,
-0.09259682148694992,
-0.34814193844795227,
-0.3143177628517151,
0.11814168095588684,
-0.5574721693992615,
0.2737085223197937,
-0.4191838502883911,
0.28652873635292053,
0.04959595948457718,
-0.22178079187870026,
-0.4037550985813141,
0.009517427533864975,
-0.4225391745567322,
0.6660072207450867,
0.341640442609787,
-0.7200785875320435,
0.8974074125289917,
-0.8505877256393433,
-0.14310401678085327,
-0.016435863450169563,
0.009444073773920536,
-0.7274115085601807,
0.4172650873661041,
0.5639377236366272,
0.2716101408004761,
-0.030759574845433235,
0.14549429714679718,
-0.5044255256652832,
-0.4664829671382904,
0.6909781098365784,
-0.9916540384292603,
0.9390685558319092,
0.6127964854240417,
-0.1830531656742096,
0.23283211886882782,
-0.6568573713302612,
0.0006117508164606988,
0.5512570738792419,
-0.1783875972032547,
-0.05346494913101196,
0.15854643285274506,
-0.5488978624343872,
-0.3751676678657532,
0.235190287232399,
-0.1235799640417099,
-0.3558264970779419,
-0.33127361536026,
0.34118565917015076,
0.8891389966011047,
0.16279767453670502,
0.6907605528831482,
-0.5050051212310791,
1.1045986413955688,
0.41982704401016235,
0.2635323107242584,
-0.6896679997444153,
-0.4252345860004425,
-0.45176970958709717,
-0.45196810364723206,
0.1362413465976715,
0.46019411087036133,
-0.34281155467033386,
0.0048431092873215675,
0.08704762160778046,
-0.2045620232820511,
-1.0759365558624268,
0.0852271020412445,
0.5175127387046814,
0.38238322734832764,
0.26676174998283386,
0.0966387689113617,
-0.33635255694389343,
-1.085930347442627,
-0.4650580883026123,
-0.304056316614151,
-0.3251477777957916,
0.4639228284358978,
0.20898881554603577,
0.06416437029838562,
1.1751790046691895,
-0.45933645963668823,
0.17661736905574799,
-0.14757800102233887,
0.18853941559791565,
0.10459844768047333,
0.11718157678842545,
0.6249668598175049,
-0.968768298625946,
-0.149397611618042,
-0.1362248957157135,
-0.4915299713611603,
0.03074054606258869,
-0.2650776505470276,
-0.10474119335412979,
-0.28559818863868713,
0.20125934481620789,
-0.26440173387527466,
0.24087770283222198,
0.4226225018501282,
-0.3644565939903259,
0.7118664383888245,
-0.08650205284357071,
0.005692151375114918,
-0.5859991312026978,
-0.44953885674476624,
0.3752148747444153,
-0.2679283916950226,
-0.16118386387825012,
0.06542301923036575,
-0.06469029188156128,
-0.3517572581768036,
-0.416483074426651,
0.47347185015678406,
-0.3611290156841278,
0.17810754477977753,
-0.18242202699184418,
0.07631389051675797,
0.31593579053878784,
0.26454901695251465,
-0.3702426850795746,
0.5368472933769226,
0.6914031505584717,
-0.7532185912132263,
0.31819385290145874,
0.04445591941475868,
-0.11719746887683868,
0.2303602546453476,
-0.5404869318008423,
-0.12438134104013443,
-0.4111243784427643,
-0.021889470517635345,
-1.223233938217163,
-0.47048094868659973,
0.17636825144290924,
-0.9143344759941101,
0.22992970049381256,
-0.7443897128105164,
0.12224825471639633,
-0.6047818660736084,
-0.2418767809867859,
0.19504201412200928,
0.5094809532165527,
-0.818043053150177,
0.4883708357810974,
0.028054332360625267,
0.15840330719947815,
-0.5889982581138611,
-0.9478021860122681,
-0.43758291006088257,
-0.9900781512260437,
-0.7190287709236145,
0.4197904169559479,
0.15612046420574188,
-0.44381818175315857,
0.20082031190395355,
-0.5076850652694702,
-0.45413240790367126,
0.7630771398544312,
0.15138836205005646,
0.27757424116134644,
-0.7474326491355896,
0.10033027082681656,
0.18832968175411224,
-0.4486132562160492,
0.4253045916557312,
-0.06641502678394318,
-0.011372355744242668,
0.17350617051124573,
-0.5202342867851257,
-0.3638186752796173,
0.31603991985321045,
0.5108323693275452,
-0.3780100643634796,
0.7498475909233093,
0.6621755361557007,
-0.3269517719745636,
-0.4846879839897156,
-0.41466808319091797,
-0.45529407262802124,
-0.4505186676979065,
0.25504955649375916,
-0.5722261071205139,
-0.7069593071937561,
0.8037744164466858,
0.05518324300646782,
0.13747556507587433,
0.5555564165115356,
0.4444355368614197,
-0.10675092786550522,
1.4148839712142944,
0.5208078622817993,
0.06394324451684952,
0.6992326378822327,
-0.010275600478053093,
0.2490210384130478,
-0.5017141103744507,
-0.0604219064116478,
-0.6533255577087402,
-0.3733580410480499,
-0.35224249958992004,
-0.2680930197238922,
0.1786157637834549,
0.4812130928039551,
-0.0016469995025545359,
-0.1886262595653534,
-0.9074192047119141,
0.7333398461341858,
0.5667016506195068,
0.43469011783599854,
-0.0052889748476445675,
0.4507949650287628,
0.14706279337406158,
0.09664203226566315,
-0.7004849910736084,
-0.42946699261665344,
0.9789816737174988,
0.7981008291244507,
0.9063323736190796,
0.017809608951210976,
0.8392242789268494,
0.1902480572462082,
0.41044849157333374,
-0.8899168372154236,
0.006542363669723272,
-0.21979597210884094,
-0.8337846398353577,
-0.54352205991745,
-0.44732776284217834,
-1.0256999731063843,
0.5714024305343628,
-0.0791064128279686,
-1.2096226215362549,
0.11486046016216278,
0.8347389698028564,
-0.7700590491294861,
-0.07680504769086838,
-1.1550581455230713,
1.1543861627578735,
-0.30593881011009216,
-0.3557831645011902,
-0.3053777813911438,
-0.1600271314382553,
0.6521351337432861,
-0.07931455969810486,
0.025600237771868706,
-0.16847184300422668,
0.03901371732354164,
0.8245440721511841,
-0.4236668050289154,
0.649748682975769,
-0.7145259380340576,
0.13920803368091583,
0.4944210648536682,
0.2195182889699936,
0.5071633458137512,
0.2172076255083084,
-0.295309454202652,
-0.1724185198545456,
-0.58966064453125,
-0.5056824088096619,
-0.8117337822914124,
0.35051247477531433,
-0.44500765204429626,
-0.7530249357223511,
0.20705042779445648,
-0.43576931953430176,
0.13132470846176147,
-0.27642905712127686,
0.6403477787971497,
0.17621266841888428,
0.34952476620674133,
0.09782201796770096,
0.9077146649360657,
-0.12627139687538147,
0.22671571373939514,
0.3175460398197174,
0.14343774318695068,
-0.12421780079603195,
1.0218478441238403,
-0.21442635357379913,
0.2058170735836029,
0.12063697725534439,
0.6235804557800293,
-0.26015418767929077,
-1.0246050357818604,
-0.5184819102287292,
0.11364071816205978,
-0.6748499870300293,
0.07762012630701065,
-0.541418194770813,
-0.0010463058715686202,
0.0037751460913568735,
-0.8408241271972656,
-0.32259345054626465,
-0.32846108078956604,
-0.5665584206581116,
-0.2651887536048889,
0.5968148112297058,
0.07810717821121216,
0.3083721101284027,
0.6071572303771973,
-0.4570073187351227,
0.6555890440940857,
0.2935294806957245,
0.39729297161102295,
0.0015300854574888945,
-0.8520074486732483,
-0.4555434286594391,
0.10524431616067886,
-0.49458974599838257,
-0.9629032015800476,
0.13974565267562866,
0.1765514612197876,
0.9768922328948975,
1.0301415920257568,
-0.10513061285018921,
0.8244162797927856,
0.029420850798487663,
0.9242249131202698,
0.1918714940547943,
-0.6599190831184387,
1.2047710418701172,
-0.029559722170233727,
0.19147413969039917,
0.2541109621524811,
0.5456230640411377,
0.1476808339357376,
-0.6565198302268982,
-0.8302260041236877,
-0.8171380758285522,
1.1618471145629883,
-0.01530561875551939,
-0.10909403860569,
0.274556428194046,
0.3657418489456177,
0.3453066349029541,
-0.0905502587556839,
-0.717345118522644,
-0.5133172869682312,
-0.2936059534549713,
-0.14076536893844604,
-0.2791133522987366,
-0.5076453685760498,
-0.2470242828130722,
0.14149267971515656,
0.6367357969284058,
-0.23850855231285095,
0.6281014084815979,
0.029236342757940292,
-0.2809290885925293,
-0.5609232187271118,
0.2003951370716095,
0.46087145805358887,
1.0011324882507324,
-0.18535196781158447,
0.13352593779563904,
-0.10070469975471497,
-0.035544391721487045,
0.14211776852607727,
0.38041242957115173,
-0.2276042103767395,
0.3453807234764099,
0.4061312675476074,
1.1274527311325073,
-0.07945141941308975,
-0.1882452517747879,
0.45104342699050903,
0.306100457906723,
-0.3061378300189972,
-0.12438458949327469,
0.36583220958709717,
-0.1340358555316925,
0.40164947509765625,
0.4808005690574646,
0.10313344746828079,
0.18426094949245453,
-0.2387595772743225,
0.2143869400024414,
0.5619783997535706,
-0.8387345671653748,
-0.004130042158067226,
1.1319668292999268,
-0.11134223639965057,
-0.155935600399971,
0.3804945647716522,
-0.03607498109340668,
-0.4632238447666168,
0.9343517422676086,
0.2261076271533966,
1.0188239812850952,
-0.4204484820365906,
0.5937051773071289,
0.08730503916740417,
0.26485952734947205,
0.05725234001874924,
0.01758129522204399,
-0.37305504083633423,
-0.9208927154541016,
-0.7052228450775146,
-0.5890210270881653,
-0.3782869279384613,
0.01721927523612976,
-0.851804256439209,
0.06047727167606354,
-0.1115054339170456,
-0.02266813814640045,
0.681884229183197,
-0.4065288305282593,
-0.47932109236717224,
0.10553528368473053,
0.2411481738090515,
0.6006469130516052,
-1.031973123550415,
0.3931449353694916,
0.5580532550811768,
-0.4113946855068207,
-0.6247667074203491,
-0.1428123563528061,
0.2519693076610565,
-1.1814643144607544,
0.3916012644767761,
0.09133951365947723,
0.20055344700813293,
-0.38565823435783386,
-0.6504943370819092,
-0.4996671676635742,
0.622617244720459,
0.5287648439407349,
-0.12450800836086273,
-0.002120258053764701,
-0.15871618688106537,
0.22451511025428772,
-0.3379124104976654,
0.512424111366272,
0.6458674669265747,
0.5433310270309448,
-0.028926735743880272,
-0.41746634244918823,
-0.048387300223112106,
0.02429232932627201,
-0.170517235994339,
0.24400827288627625,
-0.2489495426416397,
0.6159778237342834,
-0.5892261862754822,
0.09216897934675217,
-0.4149690866470337,
0.5444212555885315,
0.5018244981765747,
0.7767391204833984,
0.6995497941970825,
0.2639518976211548,
0.7793326377868652,
-0.19896365702152252,
1.305619478225708,
0.20444242656230927,
0.3053990602493286,
0.7648295164108276,
0.4106573760509491,
0.24359267950057983,
0.5640074014663696,
-0.48845458030700684,
0.5566810965538025,
1.3450692892074585,
-0.266876220703125,
0.5986406803131104,
0.30804967880249023,
-0.25655385851860046,
-0.3642705976963043,
0.0687432661652565,
-0.006765422411262989,
0.4924522936344147,
0.4827840328216553,
-1.0189749002456665,
-0.28885695338249207,
0.24915024638175964,
-0.30752646923065186,
-0.3336777091026306,
-0.5168500542640686,
0.6801154017448425,
-0.03642026707530022,
-0.6760529279708862,
0.8299271464347839,
-0.21366624534130096,
0.5037543177604675,
-0.5654321908950806,
0.13087372481822968,
-0.22928005456924438,
0.3230101466178894,
-0.38412749767303467,
-0.8435895442962646,
0.23944106698036194,
0.031156430020928383,
-0.7809762954711914,
-0.5556823015213013,
0.4612289071083069,
-0.23339508473873138,
-0.3761501908302307,
0.01753871515393257,
0.15792547166347504,
0.4859638512134552,
-0.5398551821708679,
-0.9494472742080688,
-0.3859096169471741,
0.34649109840393066,
-0.5501748919487,
0.125580295920372,
0.8386945128440857,
-0.32861247658729553,
0.9067118167877197,
0.37725725769996643,
0.0106658348813653,
0.02678745798766613,
-0.050238072872161865,
0.5766086578369141,
-0.4867786467075348,
-0.7561850547790527,
-0.9109578132629395,
0.9727036952972412,
0.25487369298934937,
-0.3321819603443146,
0.358468234539032,
0.387053906917572,
0.5384984612464905,
-0.06265363097190857,
0.7475031018257141,
0.46542757749557495,
0.4940367639064789,
-0.6243674159049988,
0.3939882516860962,
-0.8143225312232971,
0.35618144273757935,
0.1140814945101738,
-1.0176103115081787,
0.04185225069522858,
0.523651123046875,
-0.07632020115852356,
0.03514650836586952,
0.7859287858009338,
0.5622691512107849,
-0.2957087457180023,
0.026085184887051582,
0.35329189896583557,
0.34882819652557373,
0.04416634142398834,
0.3164356052875519,
0.8346577286720276,
-0.022420499473810196,
0.9236432313919067,
-0.35308635234832764,
-0.4115596413612366,
-0.5750067234039307,
-0.6114262938499451,
-0.5979302525520325,
-0.12051091343164444,
-0.6938788294792175,
-0.3774236738681793,
-0.023543942719697952,
0.16707202792167664,
0.989520251750946,
-0.8017329573631287,
0.32551491260528564,
0.0023192160297185183,
0.7374595403671265,
-0.5960296988487244,
-0.3868410289287567,
0.23219048976898193,
-0.26291948556900024,
-0.385860800743103,
0.45266175270080566,
-0.018601469695568085,
0.07346121221780777,
-0.406756192445755,
0.02316584438085556,
0.6166751980781555,
-0.1009412333369255,
0.2920506000518799,
0.016448598355054855,
-1.0820657014846802,
-0.0834817960858345,
-0.35806405544281006,
0.41515299677848816,
0.32289400696754456,
1.1349362134933472,
-0.8102593421936035,
0.49654507637023926,
0.19724217057228088,
0.3895513713359833,
0.7289261817932129,
0.11734801530838013,
0.5609662532806396,
-0.550163209438324,
0.20569001138210297,
0.3445380926132202,
0.3082731366157532,
0.03175278380513191,
-0.7972844839096069,
0.2006305605173111,
0.012849792838096619,
-0.28596508502960205,
-0.8935469388961792,
0.1651322841644287,
-0.8076913952827454,
-0.5135248303413391,
0.6672064065933228,
-0.4016718566417694,
-0.4352196156978607,
-0.1903364062309265,
0.19980090856552124,
0.12440083920955658,
-0.4612537920475006,
0.8633626103401184,
0.6551412343978882,
-0.2705973982810974,
-0.6837965846061707,
-0.3678496479988098,
0.3952793478965759,
0.43544790148735046,
-0.5499585270881653,
0.1665843427181244,
0.3777437210083008,
0.14408987760543823,
0.07335911691188812,
0.2233877182006836,
-0.2238692343235016,
0.6514085531234741,
0.39304056763648987,
-0.1727544665336609,
-0.2188282310962677,
-0.43218567967414856,
-0.6034852862358093,
0.23715269565582275,
0.19943022727966309,
-0.7114129066467285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00062v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00062v1
|
Unlocking the Potential of Large Language Models for Clinical Text Anonymization: A Comparative Study
| 2024-05-29T23:07:58 | 2024-05-29T23:07:58 |
David Pissarra, Isabel Curioso, João Alveira, Duarte Pereira, Bruno Ribeiro, Tomás Souper, Vasco Gomes, André V. Carreiro, Vitor Rolla
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Automated clinical text anonymization has the potential to unlock the
widespread sharing of textual health data for secondary usage while assuring
patient privacy and safety. Despite the proposal of many complex and
theoretically successful anonymization solutions in literature, these
techniques remain flawed. As such, clinical institutions are still reluctant to
apply them for open access to their data. Recent advances in developing Large
Language Models (LLMs) pose a promising opportunity to further the field, given
their capability to perform various tasks. This paper proposes six new
evaluation metrics tailored to the challenges of generative anonymization with
LLMs. Moreover, we present a comparative study of LLM-based methods, testing
them against two baseline techniques. Our results establish LLM-based models as
a reliable alternative to common approaches, paving the way toward trustworthy
anonymization of clinical text.
|
[
0.2911607027053833,
-0.6387986540794373,
1.0275146961212158,
0.12149116396903992,
-0.21170714497566223,
0.12278375029563904,
-0.40871724486351013,
-0.6092979311943054,
0.08647330850362778,
0.7515019178390503,
-0.262570858001709,
-0.8673439621925354,
-0.9692336320877075,
0.3062750995159149,
-0.6396566033363342,
0.7127969264984131,
-0.12007120251655579,
0.5522797703742981,
-0.48623669147491455,
-0.39633452892303467,
-0.1829720139503479,
-0.9234837889671326,
-0.7247281670570374,
-0.2868860363960266,
0.5228844285011292,
0.005306322127580643,
0.876318633556366,
0.903150200843811,
0.9864230751991272,
0.36495697498321533,
-0.25534263253211975,
-0.020662393420934677,
-0.3954595625400543,
0.26702290773391724,
0.10425462573766708,
-0.4570065140724182,
-0.5623593330383301,
-0.0657690167427063,
0.7155850529670715,
0.8159217238426208,
-0.3261469304561615,
-0.010818934068083763,
-0.17639774084091187,
0.6667962670326233,
-0.5753260850906372,
0.061743106693029404,
-0.3935945928096771,
0.09867174923419952,
-0.31103354692459106,
-0.07469332218170166,
-0.4084683954715729,
-0.5944292545318604,
0.26190587878227234,
-0.4514409601688385,
0.17995572090148926,
0.05524385720491409,
0.68080735206604,
0.08690182864665985,
-0.32267242670059204,
-0.8432868719100952,
-0.7177892327308655,
0.7304094433784485,
-0.9005112051963806,
0.6273859739303589,
0.4676235318183899,
0.32367387413978577,
0.11043261736631393,
-0.9931069612503052,
-0.31482309103012085,
-0.8196455240249634,
-0.24426360428333282,
0.10077676922082901,
-0.2662419080734253,
0.21013787388801575,
0.0812159925699234,
0.6095068454742432,
-0.5608624219894409,
0.6423124074935913,
-0.09662102162837982,
-0.16311122477054596,
0.6973276138305664,
0.5050419569015503,
0.5570902228355408,
0.004602479282766581,
-0.38907933235168457,
0.07656659185886383,
-0.7692304253578186,
-0.47575220465660095,
0.2799791693687439,
0.034692637622356415,
-0.35610732436180115,
0.7215532064437866,
-0.1177605390548706,
0.3940467834472656,
-0.35257747769355774,
-0.39239391684532166,
0.24297267198562622,
-0.3577997386455536,
-0.21389733254909515,
-0.15432974696159363,
1.0376096963882446,
0.32988643646240234,
0.060467563569545746,
-0.5426603555679321,
-0.016315707936882973,
0.1455952376127243,
0.19853602349758148,
-0.8329042792320251,
-0.21912215650081635,
0.510322630405426,
-0.9582817554473877,
-0.31833261251449585,
-0.20412173867225647,
-0.6641017198562622,
-0.6940597891807556,
-0.1704416573047638,
0.18019498884677887,
-0.4285534620285034,
-0.024177012965083122,
0.2124244123697281,
0.0447281152009964,
-0.12316739559173584,
0.44417038559913635,
-0.8292960524559021,
0.5003297328948975,
0.9130451083183289,
0.9857596158981323,
-0.4469105005264282,
-0.10106293112039566,
-0.12190480530261993,
-0.06074526533484459,
-0.3535447120666504,
0.48427388072013855,
-0.6218580007553101,
-0.44498440623283386,
0.31547218561172485,
-0.009134655818343163,
-0.13144433498382568,
-0.8051211833953857,
0.2945346236228943,
-0.39795660972595215,
0.17606398463249207,
-0.1250893920660019,
-0.6865293979644775,
0.17425590753555298,
0.1307033896446228,
-0.7616980075836182,
0.5454611778259277,
-0.0486830398440361,
-0.7755818367004395,
0.17747244238853455,
-0.42128729820251465,
-0.2859378159046173,
0.2156846523284912,
-0.21321260929107666,
-0.7290809154510498,
0.2958933115005493,
0.05221354961395264,
0.3486574590206146,
-0.6652551293373108,
0.4501006007194519,
-0.44050976634025574,
-0.12737078964710236,
0.6244266033172607,
-0.5177751183509827,
0.9426420331001282,
0.27536070346832275,
0.09813287109136581,
0.11694846302270889,
-0.6695260405540466,
-0.2009427547454834,
0.10493949800729752,
-0.13329260051250458,
-0.3461049199104309,
0.05766034871339798,
-0.014805840328335762,
-0.22413784265518188,
0.318233847618103,
-0.4961737096309662,
-0.09237409383058548,
-0.4431857168674469,
0.517541229724884,
0.3061499297618866,
-0.019019924104213715,
0.21530011296272278,
-0.466418981552124,
0.8189475536346436,
-0.30923205614089966,
0.18991497159004211,
-0.176686629652977,
-0.28789079189300537,
-0.5131939053535461,
-0.7065691351890564,
0.699436366558075,
0.43140894174575806,
-0.44863519072532654,
0.19157657027244568,
-0.357431560754776,
-0.5279141664505005,
-0.7216418385505676,
0.05693693831562996,
0.7152819037437439,
0.41571202874183655,
0.26427942514419556,
-0.424616277217865,
-0.325494647026062,
-0.9176483154296875,
-0.3892959654331207,
-0.23909741640090942,
-0.25315430760383606,
0.5284970998764038,
0.3710462152957916,
-0.4059789180755615,
0.44646283984184265,
-0.3432573080062866,
-0.4373365640640259,
-0.34518760442733765,
-0.05330553650856018,
-0.13610196113586426,
0.2204820066690445,
0.4195691645145416,
-0.5755888819694519,
-0.4810333549976349,
0.0405627079308033,
-1.0266377925872803,
-0.2358282059431076,
0.12373030185699463,
0.10668709129095078,
-0.14237374067306519,
0.4997711479663849,
-0.3767351508140564,
0.4424465596675873,
0.8302921652793884,
-0.14703500270843506,
0.3839118480682373,
-0.4689752757549286,
0.14985089004039764,
-0.8397940993309021,
0.16642822325229645,
-0.10794660449028015,
-0.31447523832321167,
-0.8588147759437561,
0.19681839644908905,
0.11772342771291733,
-0.12286365032196045,
-0.4027225971221924,
0.6273183226585388,
-0.7310886383056641,
0.14730319380760193,
-0.22518578171730042,
-0.1449195295572281,
-0.15310199558734894,
-0.2909393012523651,
0.28238680958747864,
0.4987451732158661,
0.6069645881652832,
-0.23160652816295624,
0.30552491545677185,
0.5042517185211182,
-0.3578222692012787,
0.32819464802742004,
-0.6645193696022034,
0.052430395036935806,
-0.15493498742580414,
0.2918156385421753,
-0.7687776684761047,
-0.39119115471839905,
0.02247779443860054,
-0.3305436074733734,
0.15342046320438385,
-0.07108619809150696,
-0.7548866868019104,
-0.18193510174751282,
-0.24609152972698212,
0.5406162738800049,
0.5337905287742615,
-0.44438111782073975,
-0.03021187148988247,
0.6030489206314087,
-0.4594115912914276,
-0.3544989228248596,
-0.7044914364814758,
0.5529054403305054,
-0.329123854637146,
-0.5460478663444519,
0.3711206614971161,
-0.01239848230034113,
-0.3887697160243988,
-0.06286878883838654,
0.1017359048128128,
-0.4246210753917694,
0.09815195202827454,
0.14408251643180847,
0.1980016976594925,
-0.2066272795200348,
0.42774802446365356,
-0.09406664222478867,
-0.17886191606521606,
0.07801513373851776,
0.11078537255525589,
0.3620324730873108,
0.14409728348255157,
-0.27100899815559387,
-0.7674381732940674,
0.5716889500617981,
0.46190887689590454,
-0.18785175681114197,
1.0044734477996826,
0.21380837261676788,
-0.5675083994865417,
0.07450053095817566,
-0.8032048940658569,
-0.10288121551275253,
-0.40485841035842896,
0.46512919664382935,
0.2524169385433197,
-0.9358939528465271,
0.38438794016838074,
-0.18449997901916504,
-0.03625457361340523,
0.15636485815048218,
0.7787389755249023,
0.08031284809112549,
0.7772589325904846,
0.6467639803886414,
0.19808368384838104,
0.10518544912338257,
0.2624622583389282,
0.2503841817378998,
-0.5053535103797913,
-0.1911700963973999,
-0.7200307846069336,
0.13525180518627167,
-0.7973191738128662,
-0.3263493478298187,
0.5397019386291504,
-0.09890498965978622,
0.1599579006433487,
0.009890269488096237,
-0.17835424840450287,
0.23759277164936066,
0.0732966810464859,
0.26654043793678284,
0.8072224855422974,
-0.06655067205429077,
0.1250297874212265,
-0.18295606970787048,
-0.5665427446365356,
-0.7945235967636108,
1.2677719593048096,
0.6243858933448792,
0.6464622020721436,
0.24358177185058594,
0.7273436188697815,
0.1974397897720337,
0.8255200982093811,
-0.6150680780410767,
0.3435021936893463,
-0.6037654876708984,
-0.4767027497291565,
-0.4069403409957886,
-0.4804842174053192,
-0.9775970578193665,
0.3403981328010559,
-0.27281904220581055,
-0.8549001812934875,
-0.1417146921157837,
0.09373252838850021,
-0.2624971270561218,
0.08692774921655655,
-0.4883267879486084,
0.6970292925834656,
-0.11388565599918365,
-0.22977465391159058,
0.03944646567106247,
-0.6011630296707153,
0.31841644644737244,
-0.27335816621780396,
0.3582800328731537,
-0.025997867807745934,
-0.2703641951084137,
0.7091984748840332,
-0.8043666481971741,
0.7817990779876709,
0.27442845702171326,
-0.1967920958995819,
0.000800157489720732,
-0.1977171152830124,
0.3419940173625946,
0.21918024122714996,
-0.22301225364208221,
0.3947155773639679,
0.11530636250972748,
-0.2901700735092163,
-0.4139968752861023,
0.7725859880447388,
-0.3377261459827423,
-0.40610283613204956,
-0.4334432780742645,
-0.38674163818359375,
-0.43689459562301636,
0.20960105955600739,
0.3257090449333191,
0.5138283371925354,
-0.42835092544555664,
0.42871537804603577,
0.4429406225681305,
-0.5372275114059448,
0.3144078552722931,
0.6939451098442078,
0.11211979389190674,
-0.48445987701416016,
0.5045761466026306,
-0.0435921810567379,
0.2872621417045593,
0.3774160146713257,
0.44061917066574097,
-0.5210033655166626,
-1.0040067434310913,
-0.2781694233417511,
0.4837264120578766,
-0.5139208436012268,
-0.11536642163991928,
-0.8499029278755188,
-0.30025574564933777,
-0.3851023316383362,
-0.13569276034832,
-0.39988115429878235,
-0.24369804561138153,
-0.1212151050567627,
-0.15825504064559937,
0.16982725262641907,
0.8534172177314758,
0.177586168050766,
0.2616226077079773,
-0.8206186294555664,
0.4091228246688843,
-0.019743502140045166,
0.3747674524784088,
0.06534158438444138,
-0.26525068283081055,
-0.03304148092865944,
-0.27342551946640015,
-0.01986154355108738,
-1.0678675174713135,
0.5489633083343506,
-0.057040952146053314,
0.4067111015319824,
0.23493953049182892,
-0.038881607353687286,
0.4099288582801819,
-0.8149606585502625,
0.6716261506080627,
0.5099523663520813,
-0.7437590956687927,
0.23492632806301117,
-0.22037796676158905,
0.05578422546386719,
0.6874372959136963,
0.3947511613368988,
-0.5077980756759644,
-0.6553037166595459,
-0.543946385383606,
-0.8047829270362854,
0.2937253415584564,
0.339673787355423,
0.2367756962776184,
0.03734531253576279,
0.23269128799438477,
0.441873699426651,
0.3479437828063965,
-0.7528221011161804,
-0.31364351511001587,
0.4312008023262024,
-0.41225987672805786,
-0.185892716050148,
-0.48445796966552734,
-0.20665568113327026,
0.07837650179862976,
0.14751555025577545,
0.17962318658828735,
0.24509823322296143,
0.3167896568775177,
-0.17230798304080963,
0.11862443387508392,
0.4078364074230194,
0.45618411898612976,
0.7813324332237244,
0.12492316216230392,
0.1836937516927719,
0.10392337292432785,
-0.7367991805076599,
0.11382798850536346,
0.1314091682434082,
-0.32074081897735596,
0.2463262528181076,
0.7440035343170166,
0.6343972682952881,
0.09204114973545074,
-0.8542913794517517,
0.6797304153442383,
-0.06656607240438461,
-0.24135692417621613,
-0.29907137155532837,
-0.12664085626602173,
0.09826768934726715,
0.02136816270649433,
-0.16918933391571045,
-0.5465579628944397,
0.2223753035068512,
-0.4517400562763214,
0.11325002461671829,
0.4001070261001587,
-0.5022922158241272,
-0.2539833188056946,
0.7599653005599976,
0.08262339234352112,
-0.44801801443099976,
0.23743057250976562,
0.26363682746887207,
-0.09190104901790619,
0.680768609046936,
0.5421118140220642,
0.9228073358535767,
-0.3391651213169098,
0.24225769937038422,
0.20824077725410461,
0.17557422816753387,
-0.28132978081703186,
0.02142481878399849,
0.3171737492084503,
-0.37447723746299744,
-0.1808663010597229,
-0.45278045535087585,
-0.7081485390663147,
0.3103336989879608,
-0.6705482006072998,
0.06161096319556236,
-0.46199268102645874,
-0.1283133625984192,
0.21588893234729767,
-0.19692271947860718,
-0.6791659593582153,
0.22392326593399048,
0.03330158814787865,
0.6004096865653992,
-0.5909801721572876,
0.8263525366783142,
0.5119727849960327,
0.11389526724815369,
-0.29017654061317444,
0.13520413637161255,
0.16708548367023468,
-0.7370048761367798,
0.17897137999534607,
0.10227138549089432,
0.1940382570028305,
-0.3756827116012573,
-0.2540234327316284,
-0.5320532321929932,
1.0849069356918335,
0.31292951107025146,
-0.8377825617790222,
-0.12327848374843597,
0.5052955746650696,
1.0201225280761719,
-0.4924561083316803,
0.328299343585968,
0.494977742433548,
0.2657179832458496,
-0.1659158170223236,
-1.0791149139404297,
0.2849041819572449,
0.06417784839868546,
0.025744767859578133,
-0.014215345494449139,
-0.6791825294494629,
0.6493054032325745,
-0.2739594578742981,
-0.2742675840854645,
0.6346574425697327,
0.26688259840011597,
0.11204700171947479,
0.5093135237693787,
0.2643304467201233,
0.282059907913208,
0.8623359203338623,
0.2528645694255829,
1.189444661140442,
-0.18157914280891418,
0.46616655588150024,
0.9820118546485901,
-0.5531458854675293,
0.6663929224014282,
0.12477858364582062,
-0.21628712117671967,
0.2765013575553894,
0.2328076958656311,
0.12687872350215912,
0.38609904050827026,
0.4461168646812439,
-0.4530901312828064,
-0.11742474138736725,
-0.14676512777805328,
-0.42779219150543213,
0.44419974088668823,
0.38385525345802307,
-0.7991480231285095,
-0.12980659306049347,
-0.048939090222120285,
0.3571764826774597,
0.25913339853286743,
-0.05307595804333687,
0.8595165610313416,
0.3684123456478119,
-0.38678333163261414,
0.45539939403533936,
0.17468780279159546,
0.27790242433547974,
-0.5561094880104065,
0.07056459784507751,
-0.15672242641448975,
0.06834350526332855,
-0.133381187915802,
-0.17019310593605042,
0.18029525876045227,
0.4473121166229248,
0.17329788208007812,
-0.20124919712543488,
0.6734868288040161,
-0.4273468554019928,
-0.5608500242233276,
0.27949094772338867,
0.5110381245613098,
0.05133950710296631,
0.3199823200702667,
-0.5859077572822571,
0.24528074264526367,
-0.30101269483566284,
-0.07985066622495651,
0.4176900386810303,
0.22081492841243744,
0.013229907490313053,
0.7404730916023254,
0.5182901620864868,
0.48989033699035645,
-0.17735116183757782,
0.20472452044487,
0.5058590769767761,
-0.7265267968177795,
-0.5982272624969482,
-1.0108078718185425,
0.1129511147737503,
-0.20896072685718536,
-0.3214329481124878,
0.8293119072914124,
0.502701461315155,
0.42782384157180786,
0.1194487139582634,
0.839128315448761,
0.4326629340648651,
0.7617970108985901,
-0.7996673583984375,
0.9697725176811218,
-0.4074722230434418,
0.5710614919662476,
-0.1838136464357376,
-0.5754117369651794,
-0.6593494415283203,
0.1699383556842804,
-0.18970249593257904,
-0.1596238613128662,
0.8445746898651123,
0.6436931490898132,
0.1332000494003296,
0.02155611477792263,
0.44001835584640503,
0.4270346462726593,
0.2825332283973694,
0.41354861855506897,
0.7046092748641968,
-0.16272448003292084,
0.1993321031332016,
-0.2922060191631317,
-0.4484851062297821,
-0.1489868462085724,
-0.8607199192047119,
-1.0348899364471436,
-0.1369122415781021,
-0.5182831287384033,
-0.40465015172958374,
0.3810707628726959,
0.5400792360305786,
0.5106971859931946,
-0.8022997975349426,
-0.1589263528585434,
0.027106864377856255,
-0.16415566205978394,
-0.07140409201383591,
-0.058205053210258484,
0.5831475257873535,
0.0590556338429451,
-0.7667544484138489,
0.322830468416214,
0.43004974722862244,
0.14812184870243073,
-0.2658791244029999,
0.005963267292827368,
0.47950106859207153,
0.24463020265102386,
0.4254583716392517,
0.2283460646867752,
-0.7888396978378296,
-0.07015221565961838,
-0.06593751162290573,
-0.3979060649871826,
-0.02236892469227314,
0.860759437084198,
-0.42752763628959656,
0.5641096830368042,
0.3897453844547272,
0.77562415599823,
0.22470857203006744,
0.06209441274404526,
0.5156952142715454,
-0.16804805397987366,
0.003056339453905821,
0.41512277722358704,
0.2554602026939392,
0.3092345595359802,
-0.3060750663280487,
0.3872092366218567,
-0.11957522481679916,
-0.3658674657344818,
-1.1164438724517822,
0.13751950860023499,
-0.7858043313026428,
-0.16486115753650665,
1.347780466079712,
-0.301471084356308,
0.10303836315870285,
-0.2097223401069641,
0.060227490961551666,
-0.06756129860877991,
-0.00005881749530090019,
0.9193102717399597,
0.6674565672874451,
0.02546459436416626,
0.13502568006515503,
-0.8274663686752319,
0.6711643934249878,
0.42041829228401184,
-0.9626316428184509,
0.14178459346294403,
0.2630625367164612,
0.32993045449256897,
-0.2725304365158081,
1.170439600944519,
-0.6220605373382568,
0.22795478999614716,
-0.23716451227664948,
-0.28304317593574524,
0.10035908222198486,
-0.26348021626472473,
-0.47856542468070984,
0.21786130964756012,
0.09379113465547562,
0.0766792967915535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19561v1
|
Quo Vadis ChatGPT? From Large Language Models to Large Knowledge Models
| 2024-05-29T23:06:54 | 2024-05-29T23:06:54 |
Venkat Venkatasubramanian, Arijit Chakraborty
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0; I.2.7
|
The startling success of ChatGPT and other large language models (LLMs) using
transformer-based generative neural network architecture in applications such
as natural language processing and image synthesis has many researchers excited
about potential opportunities in process systems engineering (PSE). The almost
human-like performance of LLMs in these areas is indeed very impressive,
surprising, and a major breakthrough. Their capabilities are very useful in
certain tasks, such as writing first drafts of documents, code writing
assistance, text summarization, etc. However, their success is limited in
highly scientific domains as they cannot yet reason, plan, or explain due to
their lack of in-depth domain knowledge. This is a problem in domains such as
chemical engineering as they are governed by fundamental laws of physics and
chemistry (and biology), constitutive relations, and highly technical knowledge
about materials, processes, and systems. Although purely data-driven machine
learning has its immediate uses, the long-term success of AI in scientific and
engineering domains would depend on developing hybrid AI systems that use first
principles and technical knowledge effectively. We call these hybrid AI systems
Large Knowledge Models (LKMs), as they will not be limited to only NLP-based
techniques or NLP-like applications. In this paper, we discuss the challenges
and opportunities in developing such systems in chemical engineering.
|
[
-0.25519317388534546,
-0.5204764604568481,
1.0138320922851562,
0.16914308071136475,
0.1638832837343216,
0.6774337887763977,
-0.1421041339635849,
-0.341760516166687,
0.011279783211648464,
0.38010698556900024,
-0.42355263233184814,
-0.20243185758590698,
-0.6390243172645569,
-0.03940877318382263,
-0.5099284648895264,
1.0786908864974976,
-0.3428913652896881,
0.15326310694217682,
-0.18430081009864807,
0.3547177314758301,
-0.05777066946029663,
-0.7786778211593628,
-0.673555314540863,
-0.532009482383728,
0.21066275238990784,
-0.009547265246510506,
0.4518071115016937,
-0.06852101534605026,
0.3782331943511963,
0.35842615365982056,
-0.23794864118099213,
0.3149709105491638,
-0.3347601592540741,
0.26666539907455444,
-0.17524860799312592,
-0.3741985857486725,
-0.27733954787254333,
0.038514625281095505,
0.4124612510204315,
1.029032588005066,
-0.008033321239054203,
-0.21162158250808716,
0.22849369049072266,
0.6252838373184204,
-0.3997640609741211,
0.5388237833976746,
-0.5414720177650452,
0.3580740690231323,
0.23928317427635193,
-0.005218757316470146,
-0.24349457025527954,
-0.06835594773292542,
0.2797555923461914,
-0.6814826726913452,
0.2646673917770386,
0.0037354519590735435,
0.8010108470916748,
0.21720176935195923,
-0.3027263581752777,
-0.09734218567609787,
-1.3007316589355469,
0.6671281456947327,
-0.6889141201972961,
0.3708325922489166,
-0.15208259224891663,
0.5394107699394226,
-0.5720744132995605,
-0.8656969666481018,
-0.7120980024337769,
-0.3896898627281189,
0.11761914193630219,
0.1836448311805725,
0.0836886465549469,
0.3614995777606964,
0.13941681385040283,
0.5579599142074585,
-0.5079643726348877,
0.0066281468607485294,
-0.6442611813545227,
-0.39974674582481384,
0.5126447081565857,
0.1793631762266159,
0.20484407246112823,
0.18139469623565674,
-0.36468037962913513,
0.056863389909267426,
-0.39493343234062195,
-0.37029728293418884,
0.032149724662303925,
0.13312454521656036,
0.10526406764984131,
0.784026026725769,
-0.20592191815376282,
0.2770107686519623,
-0.17200519144535065,
0.05396508052945137,
-0.1037912592291832,
-0.26017552614212036,
-0.4302102327346802,
-0.22855640947818756,
0.9584247469902039,
-0.3580789566040039,
0.28385981917381287,
-0.34099867939949036,
-0.20097817480564117,
0.43586358428001404,
0.2960056960582733,
-0.48394426703453064,
-0.2543879449367523,
0.17945082485675812,
-0.2112904191017151,
-0.197854682803154,
-0.010376793332397938,
-0.5435646176338196,
-0.6178532838821411,
-0.6117156147956848,
0.3561142086982727,
-0.5110769867897034,
-0.26190871000289917,
0.14850692451000214,
-0.36729416251182556,
0.34550970792770386,
0.3865451216697693,
-0.8071799874305725,
0.3594802916049957,
1.0014008283615112,
0.9022674560546875,
-0.22450339794158936,
-0.23492345213890076,
0.12455008924007416,
0.12200106680393219,
-0.20174537599086761,
0.5736520290374756,
-0.40637654066085815,
-0.6152224540710449,
-0.2297481894493103,
-0.16668978333473206,
-0.08889849483966827,
-0.7772035598754883,
0.42147502303123474,
-0.6482160091400146,
-0.054985467344522476,
0.06572455167770386,
-0.5895293951034546,
-0.016547808423638344,
-0.05198546499013901,
-0.28386321663856506,
0.8885260224342346,
-0.055068422108888626,
-0.4993416666984558,
0.11596602201461792,
-0.7860578298568726,
-0.5292659997940063,
0.026278965175151825,
-0.4295218884944916,
-0.20638148486614227,
0.2528703212738037,
-0.23580320179462433,
0.6523581743240356,
-0.519620954990387,
0.379924476146698,
-0.36182069778442383,
0.08739069104194641,
0.25622856616973877,
-0.30588555335998535,
0.4355207681655884,
0.3923853039741516,
-0.22747163474559784,
0.21221911907196045,
-0.7825722694396973,
-0.1281486302614212,
0.07899719476699829,
-0.41145843267440796,
0.014830426312983036,
0.16337861120700836,
0.1629093438386917,
0.4533087909221649,
0.2848750054836273,
-0.5306211113929749,
0.19163021445274353,
-0.1758461594581604,
0.9376925826072693,
0.8965328931808472,
-0.004998739808797836,
0.5459089875221252,
-0.1866406947374344,
0.6147623062133789,
0.04680698364973068,
-0.012047984637320042,
-0.1311759203672409,
-0.5473119020462036,
-0.9964834451675415,
-0.24275709688663483,
0.0007964203832671046,
0.7714627981185913,
-1.1084755659103394,
0.47714534401893616,
-0.28994011878967285,
-0.6436594724655151,
-0.14074426889419556,
0.3025185465812683,
-0.043393563479185104,
0.3698804974555969,
0.09806106239557266,
-0.14739301800727844,
-0.56266850233078,
-1.2899061441421509,
-0.10602286458015442,
-0.19781173765659332,
-0.24565914273262024,
0.002793575171381235,
0.6462002992630005,
-0.19597874581813812,
0.9850219488143921,
-0.447721928358078,
0.04582066461443901,
-0.256879597902298,
0.04697798192501068,
0.45018869638442993,
0.3674646019935608,
0.025105644017457962,
-0.8891847729682922,
-0.3763834536075592,
0.38509637117385864,
-1.0344648361206055,
0.11590000987052917,
0.022312792018055916,
-0.18669471144676208,
0.10818804055452347,
0.7230002284049988,
-1.0020371675491333,
0.06212025508284569,
0.4937969446182251,
-0.059286151081323624,
0.7429318428039551,
-0.273587167263031,
-0.020930616185069084,
-1.065484881401062,
0.18131385743618011,
0.39432352781295776,
-0.12810245156288147,
-0.7572598457336426,
-0.11312869191169739,
-0.26964735984802246,
-0.678370475769043,
-0.39936596155166626,
0.38284236192703247,
-0.2412860244512558,
0.02286328189074993,
-0.49556586146354675,
-0.2303861677646637,
-0.24294789135456085,
0.5117474794387817,
0.1520882099866867,
0.8293336033821106,
0.6836458444595337,
-0.6280307769775391,
0.515133798122406,
-0.003803141415119171,
-0.3571992516517639,
0.49332860112190247,
-0.7417531609535217,
0.08279173821210861,
-0.07256701588630676,
0.4102964699268341,
-0.784020721912384,
-0.26076382398605347,
-0.018138056620955467,
-0.2400013655424118,
0.42649298906326294,
0.08084587752819061,
-0.6691111922264099,
-0.5624036192893982,
0.09654434025287628,
0.2340569645166397,
0.5747179985046387,
-0.268559992313385,
0.8093401789665222,
0.4030948877334595,
-0.39459726214408875,
-0.15693575143814087,
-0.41025957465171814,
0.08686331659555435,
-0.06317979842424393,
-0.9834674596786499,
0.23377086222171783,
0.05208906903862953,
-0.18307091295719147,
-0.11552875488996506,
-0.34320664405822754,
-0.16964568197727203,
0.0242096446454525,
0.25319209694862366,
0.41874778270721436,
-0.321842223405838,
0.10794617980718613,
0.028345704078674316,
-0.3094903230667114,
0.087873674929142,
-0.6604022979736328,
0.6761906147003174,
-0.35540661215782166,
-0.34293246269226074,
-0.6780614852905273,
0.5151366591453552,
1.1864327192306519,
-0.08956164866685867,
0.9553436040878296,
0.30884310603141785,
-0.40520673990249634,
-0.34185364842414856,
-0.35549017786979675,
-0.31687024235725403,
-0.5083078145980835,
0.556003212928772,
-0.2635436952114105,
-0.9548981785774231,
0.5288441777229309,
-0.5064566731452942,
0.03268972039222717,
0.6136455535888672,
0.5166099071502686,
-0.3910527229309082,
0.7869362235069275,
0.791138768196106,
-0.22371821105480194,
0.2639429271221161,
-0.3620319664478302,
0.7849199771881104,
-0.6072093844413757,
-0.13556033372879028,
-0.3524843156337738,
-0.36530235409736633,
-0.610611617565155,
-0.3761276602745056,
0.8570834398269653,
0.03860509768128395,
-0.5006099343299866,
0.1261213719844818,
-0.31453725695610046,
0.2905665338039398,
0.6198820471763611,
0.02689185179769993,
0.34589892625808716,
0.04630383849143982,
-0.05917977914214134,
0.21142707765102386,
-0.9726725816726685,
-0.7751016616821289,
0.8075529336929321,
0.39413100481033325,
0.7104687690734863,
-0.3547353446483612,
0.3904278874397278,
0.4763508141040802,
0.03209817782044411,
-0.9695996642112732,
0.7090137600898743,
-0.04407132416963577,
-0.6079581379890442,
-0.2195977121591568,
-0.43578583002090454,
-0.6251611709594727,
0.24419960379600525,
-0.3104906678199768,
-0.4727344512939453,
0.03168484568595886,
0.058769285678863525,
-0.3203786611557007,
0.6556848287582397,
-0.8610497713088989,
0.662291407585144,
-0.29403531551361084,
-0.18830373883247375,
-0.2515983283519745,
-0.5245507955551147,
0.36456167697906494,
-0.24980750679969788,
0.2732539474964142,
0.1491335779428482,
0.000694331421982497,
0.6218369007110596,
-0.7074490189552307,
1.0107585191726685,
0.09316477179527283,
-0.3024274706840515,
0.26414838433265686,
0.07032117992639542,
0.4125005602836609,
-0.2985609471797943,
-0.04854320362210274,
0.09160419553518295,
0.09116267412900925,
-0.5352934002876282,
-0.5857440233230591,
0.7146684527397156,
-0.7615096569061279,
-0.7025370597839355,
-0.5637767314910889,
-0.4144696295261383,
-0.58228600025177,
0.029598725959658623,
0.19416193664073944,
-0.33761587738990784,
-0.21510861814022064,
-0.022154130041599274,
0.8503854870796204,
-0.453599750995636,
0.20380938053131104,
0.18483053147792816,
-0.06742405146360397,
-0.18987290561199188,
1.0884488821029663,
0.057821109890937805,
0.3730955123901367,
0.2033909559249878,
-0.11523289978504181,
0.2276839166879654,
-0.4379130005836487,
-0.11861948668956757,
0.3831748366355896,
-0.6508112549781799,
0.10379558056592941,
-0.538330614566803,
-0.8254185914993286,
-0.33113572001457214,
-0.19870299100875854,
-0.6664397716522217,
-0.5429694056510925,
-0.15618771314620972,
-0.010869618505239487,
0.17184913158416748,
0.8203684687614441,
0.148569718003273,
0.13998766243457794,
-0.7705246210098267,
0.2924332916736603,
0.3901762068271637,
0.3813330829143524,
0.0458349846303463,
-0.246585875749588,
-0.15671253204345703,
0.033875077962875366,
-0.6920819282531738,
-0.6682162284851074,
0.15051187574863434,
0.04729841649532318,
0.5855124592781067,
0.2130439132452011,
-0.22525866329669952,
0.010232893750071526,
-0.6328257918357849,
0.8092056512832642,
0.19901178777217865,
-0.8482235670089722,
0.5091759562492371,
-0.5151391625404358,
-0.035104356706142426,
0.0659007877111435,
0.585105836391449,
-0.8351321220397949,
-0.2059873789548874,
-0.6148028373718262,
-0.9753397107124329,
0.31232908368110657,
0.3878520131111145,
0.10185009986162186,
0.3890097141265869,
0.44257107377052307,
0.22334155440330505,
0.21324500441551208,
-0.5251955986022949,
-0.2076108455657959,
0.16414158046245575,
-0.22819659113883972,
-0.0018707135459408164,
0.14254693686962128,
0.05136385187506676,
-0.19784528017044067,
1.2608411312103271,
-0.02996283583343029,
0.16895456612110138,
0.12486573308706284,
0.21440881490707397,
0.1834978461265564,
0.43157392740249634,
0.5506794452667236,
0.41235315799713135,
0.23268571496009827,
-0.11109649389982224,
-0.038508739322423935,
-0.3457111120223999,
0.30023032426834106,
0.06534484028816223,
-0.10362900048494339,
-0.4072470963001251,
0.20692145824432373,
0.8145576119422913,
-0.2224457859992981,
-0.6368942856788635,
0.07495640218257904,
0.3587998151779175,
-0.3034800887107849,
-0.37631940841674805,
0.2706563472747803,
0.13552682101726532,
0.5083106160163879,
0.47270235419273376,
0.20853979885578156,
-0.08261771500110626,
-0.8703046441078186,
-0.10745934396982193,
0.4685402810573578,
-0.22494658827781677,
-0.289596825838089,
0.6240524053573608,
0.28003448247909546,
-0.22004973888397217,
0.5216012001037598,
0.0633981004357338,
-0.7430574893951416,
0.578529417514801,
0.24646972119808197,
0.7670281529426575,
-0.12489329278469086,
0.23327934741973877,
-0.07712479680776596,
0.3211398422718048,
-0.15458953380584717,
0.03889175131917,
-0.018464908003807068,
-0.768429160118103,
-0.44936996698379517,
-0.7182795405387878,
-0.46336665749549866,
0.43083953857421875,
-0.05119844898581505,
0.21063648164272308,
-0.8637465834617615,
-0.16808810830116272,
0.24325375258922577,
-0.29422569274902344,
-0.6156316995620728,
-0.06569992005825043,
0.2847020626068115,
0.7297291159629822,
-1.0921205282211304,
0.5821623206138611,
0.7907127737998962,
-0.34098124504089355,
-0.40754735469818115,
-0.35479113459587097,
0.06581614166498184,
-0.597078263759613,
0.7007886171340942,
-0.2903241217136383,
0.025097891688346863,
-0.2540651559829712,
-0.6495094299316406,
-0.7262906432151794,
0.9843631982803345,
0.42944690585136414,
-0.5995673537254333,
-0.379572331905365,
0.3928212821483612,
0.9197354316711426,
-0.0625835582613945,
-0.15735554695129395,
0.6556304693222046,
0.40919584035873413,
0.13498683273792267,
-1.2264039516448975,
-0.24342277646064758,
-0.5101597905158997,
0.07204858213663101,
0.3158998489379883,
-0.8489491939544678,
0.5645546317100525,
0.08590242266654968,
-0.19928526878356934,
0.07882121950387955,
0.8500790596008301,
0.32628440856933594,
0.2676534056663513,
0.10309464484453201,
0.49254724383354187,
0.5309013724327087,
-0.1767413318157196,
1.1545674800872803,
-0.09089358150959015,
0.1809869259595871,
0.9198803901672363,
-0.5265318155288696,
0.6116532683372498,
0.6986599564552307,
-0.6248162984848022,
0.35390475392341614,
0.5302842259407043,
0.03357100114226341,
0.16819079220294952,
0.5455105304718018,
-0.6495526432991028,
-0.48154813051223755,
-0.009181225672364235,
-0.2910199463367462,
0.2764987647533417,
0.6818093061447144,
-0.5019212961196899,
-0.10001514106988907,
0.12016447633504868,
-0.37469178438186646,
-0.011100150644779205,
-0.12838080525398254,
0.6360868215560913,
0.48821720480918884,
-0.3739231824874878,
0.29057058691978455,
-0.006582203321158886,
0.6258718371391296,
-0.6156660914421082,
-0.05627111345529556,
0.09386584907770157,
0.13314609229564667,
-0.04066354036331177,
-0.7631346583366394,
0.2793934643268585,
-0.15777508914470673,
-0.39290106296539307,
-0.25481802225112915,
0.7356753349304199,
-0.0332757867872715,
-0.6967492699623108,
0.07938314229249954,
0.5952025651931763,
0.0411827489733696,
-0.18220125138759613,
-0.4907335937023163,
-0.26081910729408264,
-0.263141006231308,
-0.056322768330574036,
0.16614164412021637,
0.46768924593925476,
-0.04375085607171059,
0.9579194188117981,
0.5500218272209167,
0.30031663179397583,
0.15361280739307404,
-0.2649209201335907,
0.9442614316940308,
-0.5121523141860962,
-0.3738185167312622,
-0.6267579197883606,
0.39829370379447937,
0.13436312973499298,
0.24348780512809753,
0.33499178290367126,
0.5942797064781189,
0.6799377799034119,
-0.18044553697109222,
1.3788024187088013,
-0.05668463185429573,
0.3679756820201874,
-0.5000817775726318,
0.7908346652984619,
-0.2901594638824463,
0.32132476568222046,
-0.17783018946647644,
-1.052899956703186,
-0.10680332779884338,
0.29009658098220825,
-0.4475349187850952,
0.22257477045059204,
0.6951920986175537,
0.6395952701568604,
-0.31017813086509705,
0.3080480694770813,
0.26904478669166565,
0.4985794126987457,
0.6217939853668213,
0.8005611300468445,
0.9792458415031433,
-0.22790516912937164,
0.28863468766212463,
-0.05187011510133743,
-0.26269298791885376,
0.10857683420181274,
-0.6109074950218201,
-0.6687668561935425,
-0.8501570224761963,
-0.170648992061615,
-0.26329585909843445,
-0.1785869151353836,
0.7815516591072083,
0.765768826007843,
-0.8324252367019653,
-0.30883947014808655,
-0.4317028820514679,
-0.20613770186901093,
0.27902501821517944,
-0.23475821316242218,
0.16891911625862122,
-0.24068766832351685,
-0.5508140325546265,
0.5082577466964722,
0.5697082281112671,
0.20307622849941254,
-0.46987515687942505,
-0.07679568976163864,
-0.1584460586309433,
0.03291165083646774,
0.7874013185501099,
0.685430109500885,
-0.5091506242752075,
-0.011190887540578842,
-0.005590458400547504,
0.06959811598062515,
0.023497000336647034,
0.988701343536377,
-0.7297214865684509,
0.16186600923538208,
0.5549930334091187,
0.950309157371521,
0.7058106660842896,
-0.49199917912483215,
1.0087374448776245,
-0.2531278133392334,
0.044606249779462814,
0.4055497646331787,
0.5243807435035706,
0.33771660923957825,
-0.22421151399612427,
0.36307206749916077,
0.420871376991272,
-0.6898263096809387,
-0.3905316889286041,
0.3565356135368347,
-1.00619637966156,
-0.30923694372177124,
0.9301573634147644,
0.1477748304605484,
-0.11637340486049652,
-0.006735568400472403,
-0.3682999014854431,
0.4545438587665558,
-0.2557523250579834,
0.9176305532455444,
0.9246900081634521,
-0.45728185772895813,
0.11250757426023483,
-0.7480974197387695,
0.33957457542419434,
0.6682597994804382,
-1.006514310836792,
-0.05101185664534569,
0.42913419008255005,
0.23939166963100433,
0.47466346621513367,
0.20851477980613708,
-0.03957127034664154,
0.03564134240150452,
-0.2103547602891922,
0.04664517939090729,
0.2262296974658966,
-0.3642100691795349,
-0.06453501433134079,
0.21732380986213684,
-0.03051109053194523,
0.19374138116836548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00061v1
|
STAT: Shrinking Transformers After Training
| 2024-05-29T22:59:11 | 2024-05-29T22:59:11 |
Megan Flynn, Alexander Wang, Dean Edward Alvarez, Christopher De Sa, Anil Damle
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present STAT: a simple algorithm to prune transformer models without any
fine-tuning. STAT eliminates both attention heads and neurons from the network,
while preserving accuracy by calculating a correction to the weights of the
next layer. Each layer block in the network is compressed using a series of
principled matrix factorizations that preserve the network structure. Our
entire algorithm takes minutes to compress BERT, and less than three hours to
compress models with 7B parameters using a single GPU. Using only several
hundred data examples, STAT preserves the output of the network and improves
upon existing gradient-free pruning methods. It is even competitive with
methods that include significant fine-tuning. We demonstrate our method on both
encoder and decoder architectures, including BERT, DistilBERT, and Llama-2
using benchmarks such as GLUE, Squad, WikiText2.
|
[
-0.7197254300117493,
-0.5411937236785889,
0.027701519429683685,
0.08557400852441788,
-0.434557169675827,
-0.013979589566588402,
-0.4868970513343811,
-0.10329815000295639,
0.32893192768096924,
0.43265512585639954,
-1.039556860923767,
-0.07431989163160324,
-0.5256763100624084,
-0.0038821951020509005,
-0.6250237822532654,
1.1546978950500488,
0.3247842490673065,
0.016461081802845,
0.01661849580705166,
0.06591632962226868,
-0.4837140440940857,
-0.21297089755535126,
-0.9611476063728333,
-0.531754195690155,
0.49493634700775146,
0.5593665242195129,
0.46312132477760315,
0.5419535040855408,
0.9006415605545044,
0.306501179933548,
-0.4269419312477112,
0.3256196677684784,
-1.1420938968658447,
0.05038047209382057,
0.33101803064346313,
-0.621168851852417,
-0.3395460546016693,
-0.19881850481033325,
0.6739391088485718,
0.4879031777381897,
-0.0722656324505806,
0.4896674156188965,
0.134942427277565,
0.9111655950546265,
-0.398255854845047,
0.17692948877811432,
-0.5994704961776733,
0.1748020052909851,
0.15620139241218567,
-0.47952014207839966,
-0.81841641664505,
-0.38656967878341675,
-0.17914852499961853,
-0.3229019045829773,
1.0943516492843628,
-0.16108086705207825,
1.159929633140564,
0.9054181575775146,
-0.12273023277521133,
0.6705690622329712,
-0.976798415184021,
0.9040857553482056,
-0.1185249537229538,
0.38334575295448303,
0.23890843987464905,
0.5243011116981506,
-0.006566522177308798,
-0.7520690560340881,
-0.2888202965259552,
0.04577667638659477,
-0.2812494933605194,
0.2005973607301712,
-0.238600492477417,
0.13955573737621307,
0.46004316210746765,
0.4161125421524048,
-0.3432130217552185,
-0.06291436403989792,
-0.9398643970489502,
-0.3064850866794586,
0.5891648530960083,
-0.05901312455534935,
-0.011993822641670704,
0.11375033855438232,
-0.37906381487846375,
-0.5883085131645203,
-0.9176785945892334,
-0.18261747062206268,
0.3931771516799927,
0.06337031722068787,
0.25354039669036865,
0.6499201059341431,
0.18062545359134674,
0.3616337180137634,
0.3238329291343689,
-0.008996298536658287,
0.1410692185163498,
0.1573813259601593,
-0.5492265224456787,
-0.041932057589292526,
0.6775326132774353,
0.27248382568359375,
0.38634413480758667,
-0.2704894542694092,
-0.08661666512489319,
0.14859700202941895,
0.7177866697311401,
-0.6840111017227173,
-0.603008508682251,
0.15403765439987183,
-0.6886628866195679,
-0.2543081045150757,
-0.12034925818443298,
-0.6710378527641296,
-0.07855058461427689,
-0.37045037746429443,
0.43948298692703247,
-0.5705342292785645,
-0.09266023337841034,
-0.07818859815597534,
-0.49393126368522644,
0.2925857901573181,
0.3780575692653656,
-0.6847424507141113,
0.4899452328681946,
0.7869936227798462,
0.7313054800033569,
0.12375791370868683,
-0.09340860694646835,
-0.4193420708179474,
-0.0637609139084816,
-0.22694210708141327,
0.5218473672866821,
-0.019894419237971306,
-0.3945849537849426,
-0.40804776549339294,
0.17721086740493774,
-0.06459294259548187,
-0.4039261043071747,
0.8791003823280334,
-0.584567666053772,
-0.10820434242486954,
-0.13542011380195618,
-0.4485187530517578,
-0.2863384783267975,
0.07238151878118515,
-0.9952473044395447,
0.8131260275840759,
0.05199776962399483,
-0.8238292336463928,
0.25123295187950134,
-0.5271390676498413,
-0.4256167411804199,
-0.17881210148334503,
0.29181772470474243,
-0.85894376039505,
0.5232194662094116,
0.32298988103866577,
0.38835981488227844,
-0.29416149854660034,
0.07825887948274612,
-0.010700590908527374,
-0.5692487955093384,
-0.15782347321510315,
-0.5695206522941589,
0.8641916513442993,
0.17325277626514435,
-0.06066005676984787,
0.1583472043275833,
-0.4118921756744385,
0.02719731442630291,
0.3490084111690521,
-0.1792987734079361,
0.10699795931577682,
0.18075348436832428,
-0.05047328770160675,
-0.041115280240774155,
0.07258779555559158,
-0.6873359084129333,
0.2642669975757599,
-0.36518245935440063,
0.5383590459823608,
0.7717922925949097,
-0.1150137186050415,
0.474030077457428,
-0.3766849935054779,
0.28005313873291016,
-0.17785146832466125,
0.45330676436424255,
0.19377268850803375,
-0.3151124119758606,
-1.2532960176467896,
-0.4645318388938904,
0.3433802127838135,
0.03187056630849838,
-0.48487037420272827,
0.5775744915008545,
-0.8487030863761902,
-0.7011337280273438,
-0.4329048693180084,
-0.1253894716501236,
0.05184587091207504,
0.47464194893836975,
0.4881190061569214,
-0.36677274107933044,
-0.48104923963546753,
-1.2761503458023071,
0.03713555261492729,
-0.08842748403549194,
-0.4010639488697052,
-0.05588306114077568,
0.35112807154655457,
0.0780225545167923,
0.9854500889778137,
-0.8038235902786255,
-0.5897014737129211,
-0.4384455978870392,
0.22734424471855164,
0.18661054968833923,
0.5805296897888184,
0.45871323347091675,
-0.7267214059829712,
-0.33162543177604675,
-0.1556156724691391,
-0.3666188716888428,
0.41356998682022095,
0.05043673887848854,
0.10476647317409515,
-0.30594319105148315,
0.1310359090566635,
-1.0022164583206177,
0.6845404505729675,
0.303730309009552,
0.11696310341358185,
0.596393883228302,
-0.3049204647541046,
-0.12632183730602264,
-0.49797719717025757,
0.19211263954639435,
0.17806950211524963,
-0.32963430881500244,
-0.8891395330429077,
-0.025467457249760628,
0.27925577759742737,
-0.5619426369667053,
-0.3408006727695465,
0.13110403716564178,
-0.5525954365730286,
-0.0033620360773056746,
0.05419054999947548,
-0.4764929711818695,
0.02632807195186615,
0.878820538520813,
-0.10024265199899673,
0.769609808921814,
0.34118929505348206,
-0.7404653429985046,
-0.0603436678647995,
0.5629907250404358,
-0.34773656725883484,
0.004172923509031534,
-0.7968736290931702,
0.2805687487125397,
-0.6094825863838196,
0.509017825126648,
-0.7327840924263,
-0.1396682858467102,
0.20226871967315674,
-0.48150208592414856,
0.6783753037452698,
-0.36024439334869385,
-0.3646095097064972,
-0.7342015504837036,
-0.35467958450317383,
0.1890205293893814,
0.8771665096282959,
-0.5723276138305664,
0.5092023015022278,
0.32899636030197144,
0.2375912219285965,
-0.5988914966583252,
-0.7387006878852844,
-0.12924936413764954,
-0.22043609619140625,
-0.4448564946651459,
0.5110380053520203,
-0.18049107491970062,
0.05844217538833618,
0.04075591266155243,
-0.41896912455558777,
-0.5920563340187073,
0.09933330863714218,
0.03172878548502922,
0.19341862201690674,
-0.050275273621082306,
0.10379981249570847,
0.07511907070875168,
-0.193876251578331,
-0.04281487688422203,
-0.00346553698182106,
0.7302080392837524,
0.11695709824562073,
-0.2464369535446167,
-0.6247366070747375,
0.1584877222776413,
0.7572887539863586,
-0.28306809067726135,
0.6547735333442688,
0.8580988049507141,
-0.16666743159294128,
-0.4437299966812134,
-0.5204975008964539,
-0.6613213419914246,
-0.5597174763679504,
0.38517752289772034,
-0.20326896011829376,
-0.6225959062576294,
0.3115905821323395,
-0.016956090927124023,
0.2745579481124878,
0.5955467224121094,
0.2684006690979004,
-0.05755050480365753,
1.0247552394866943,
0.9569534063339233,
-0.163969025015831,
0.6874410510063171,
-0.8350222110748291,
0.6294550895690918,
-0.7951027750968933,
0.021560389548540115,
-0.5554412007331848,
-0.7504481673240662,
-0.1510322093963623,
-0.5310203433036804,
0.5409953594207764,
-0.06689725071191788,
-0.2462746798992157,
0.6026281118392944,
-1.1694570779800415,
0.6983041167259216,
0.4721420705318451,
0.5458043217658997,
-0.20214547216892242,
0.4717652201652527,
0.5850138664245605,
-0.001818487304262817,
-0.9219961166381836,
0.005427666008472443,
1.0263264179229736,
0.5034980773925781,
0.6319690346717834,
-0.12947365641593933,
0.6726647615432739,
0.26685431599617004,
0.5556148290634155,
-1.2181262969970703,
0.7407993674278259,
-0.346833199262619,
-0.5117319226264954,
-0.6257087588310242,
-0.7376018166542053,
-0.9132825136184692,
0.04193434491753578,
0.13791169226169586,
-0.8189842700958252,
0.3814839720726013,
0.3407403528690338,
-0.23606915771961212,
0.6036388874053955,
-0.7637320756912231,
0.24889102578163147,
0.18088184297084808,
-0.09824930131435394,
-0.5976475477218628,
-0.6237494945526123,
0.5200037956237793,
0.01760542206466198,
-0.39524608850479126,
-0.27804791927337646,
0.40746036171913147,
0.8466931581497192,
-0.8553454875946045,
0.7845444083213806,
-0.23203761875629425,
0.25448882579803467,
0.4568868577480316,
0.14095117151737213,
0.5696224570274353,
-0.44298431277275085,
0.0028801648877561092,
0.3666097819805145,
-0.32608696818351746,
-0.25064125657081604,
-0.5915008187294006,
0.39432841539382935,
-0.7794873118400574,
-0.4524158835411072,
0.05561593174934387,
-0.5738186240196228,
-0.062392089515924454,
0.006402591243386269,
0.3866133689880371,
0.6637416481971741,
-0.19626955687999725,
0.4733521044254303,
0.7760754823684692,
0.04818454757332802,
0.4639164209365845,
0.038566507399082184,
0.5478090047836304,
-0.3493501842021942,
1.034758448600769,
0.22280193865299225,
0.12210717797279358,
0.5159534811973572,
0.17507345974445343,
-0.2839815318584442,
-0.2708941400051117,
-0.06407114863395691,
0.35598766803741455,
-0.6306787729263306,
-0.6698424816131592,
-0.4527466893196106,
-0.46464502811431885,
-0.2098269909620285,
0.01727861724793911,
-0.6303935050964355,
-0.60721355676651,
-0.15728460252285004,
0.08458564430475235,
0.3693377673625946,
0.5460101366043091,
-0.10730930417776108,
0.7511711120605469,
-0.8095680475234985,
0.49099138379096985,
0.20960786938667297,
0.286079078912735,
0.2040398120880127,
-0.4136218726634979,
-0.22626592218875885,
0.06759419292211533,
-0.27941301465034485,
-0.621222972869873,
0.7937228679656982,
0.36248475313186646,
0.357355535030365,
0.5029258131980896,
0.15700945258140564,
0.7678065896034241,
-0.7609228491783142,
0.5239052176475525,
0.6472465395927429,
-0.7558131814002991,
0.29183152318000793,
0.025038812309503555,
0.09984023869037628,
0.415382981300354,
0.09545762836933136,
-0.1777566373348236,
-0.19757218658924103,
-0.7334991693496704,
-0.8167364001274109,
0.9132282137870789,
0.43198394775390625,
-0.0763220265507698,
0.040963929146528244,
0.12612910568714142,
-0.1167941689491272,
0.1250002384185791,
-0.2784115970134735,
-0.5325710773468018,
-0.30644285678863525,
-0.335695743560791,
-0.2241852581501007,
-0.3864388167858124,
-0.4951304495334625,
-0.6828972101211548,
0.5561991333961487,
-0.03732109069824219,
0.9253250956535339,
0.33887597918510437,
-0.4242621064186096,
-0.016398053616285324,
0.02231130376458168,
0.4866824448108673,
0.5227402448654175,
-0.43698281049728394,
0.04627389460802078,
0.18567746877670288,
-0.6468116044998169,
0.3450135588645935,
-0.13325375318527222,
-0.27513018250465393,
0.16505275666713715,
0.06077614054083824,
0.7917191386222839,
0.3186299800872803,
-0.127851665019989,
0.34944936633110046,
-0.44940489530563354,
-0.38985198736190796,
-0.14225126802921295,
0.07832355052232742,
-0.3903883993625641,
-0.250609815120697,
0.45334795117378235,
0.6780620217323303,
-0.07994046807289124,
0.10671161860227585,
0.3373499810695648,
0.2362728863954544,
-0.5481048226356506,
-0.4732324779033661,
0.7304298877716064,
0.22818011045455933,
-0.34312644600868225,
0.6201486587524414,
0.13159699738025665,
-0.5090471506118774,
0.9445040822029114,
0.4344886541366577,
1.1577136516571045,
-0.12622040510177612,
0.402898371219635,
0.5939412117004395,
0.6056194305419922,
-0.4700792729854584,
-0.12780271470546722,
-0.12200629711151123,
-0.6775757670402527,
-0.6590760946273804,
-0.5029305219650269,
-0.10119660198688507,
0.044357169419527054,
-0.8515262007713318,
0.34562942385673523,
-0.6393035054206848,
-0.3647432029247284,
0.06966042518615723,
0.02800605073571205,
-1.1368334293365479,
0.30697399377822876,
-0.19159579277038574,
1.1537652015686035,
-0.8177131414413452,
0.8914759159088135,
0.3260062038898468,
-0.27447766065597534,
-0.8297210335731506,
-0.10444602370262146,
-0.17550501227378845,
-0.6323498487472534,
0.6815742254257202,
0.2178163379430771,
-0.051761627197265625,
0.35277849435806274,
-0.751420259475708,
-0.8669794797897339,
0.9353711605072021,
0.6949060559272766,
-0.582817018032074,
0.024314751848578453,
-0.2664596736431122,
0.42735549807548523,
0.2968220114707947,
0.3897272050380707,
0.6964603066444397,
0.5595640540122986,
-0.12704110145568848,
-0.6120611429214478,
-0.20831364393234253,
-0.20624485611915588,
-0.3504527807235718,
0.476939857006073,
-0.9505897164344788,
0.7813764810562134,
-0.07448169589042664,
-0.6239659786224365,
-0.17584453523159027,
0.5772663950920105,
-0.3853866159915924,
-0.29423755407333374,
0.8152645826339722,
0.6148000955581665,
0.8419400453567505,
-0.31919360160827637,
1.043673038482666,
-0.45855578780174255,
0.7783929705619812,
0.7948551774024963,
0.13974256813526154,
0.3786235451698303,
0.5228608250617981,
-0.1625513881444931,
-0.08208585530519485,
0.48296958208084106,
-0.24134787917137146,
0.5571885704994202,
0.01998140662908554,
0.06001412123441696,
-0.2740774154663086,
-0.16286727786064148,
-0.2046954333782196,
0.33161523938179016,
0.15604907274246216,
-0.10253679752349854,
-0.35648784041404724,
-0.40461382269859314,
-0.010078798979520798,
-0.48451998829841614,
-0.3476570248603821,
0.6087095141410828,
0.016571348533034325,
-0.6121761798858643,
0.8549897074699402,
-0.11563054472208023,
0.30673450231552124,
-0.8092222809791565,
0.11363542079925537,
-0.26608744263648987,
0.2592688500881195,
-0.13556747138500214,
-0.43792015314102173,
0.48717206716537476,
-0.25143927335739136,
-0.38486549258232117,
-0.5340202450752258,
1.0292543172836304,
-0.3440103828907013,
-0.5439304709434509,
0.09710179269313812,
0.23037494719028473,
0.2182987481355667,
0.06640241295099258,
-0.33082640171051025,
0.07131114602088928,
0.30507612228393555,
-0.3778761625289917,
0.12005803734064102,
0.10252682864665985,
0.28599247336387634,
0.9958622455596924,
0.6325610280036926,
0.12992382049560547,
-0.03256019949913025,
0.17273102700710297,
1.1401121616363525,
-0.4181070029735565,
-0.21198946237564087,
-0.49488523602485657,
0.5159266591072083,
-0.32875221967697144,
-0.24816389381885529,
0.5818703174591064,
0.3944929838180542,
0.420411616563797,
-0.3275775611400604,
0.41370889544487,
-0.08233770728111267,
0.20432902872562408,
-0.08338231593370438,
0.9515531063079834,
-0.4614886939525604,
0.0562153160572052,
0.09695286303758621,
-0.9790346026420593,
-0.2950322926044464,
0.4389284551143646,
-0.14154885709285736,
-0.41729578375816345,
0.7403743267059326,
0.7279209494590759,
-0.3215842843055725,
-0.18693605065345764,
0.35619187355041504,
0.11202133446931839,
0.33874648809432983,
0.19193032383918762,
0.44837144017219543,
-0.5449495315551758,
0.7983788251876831,
-0.5895784497261047,
-0.08689513802528381,
-0.21171873807907104,
-0.4367634654045105,
-0.9352067112922668,
-0.23020373284816742,
-0.366458922624588,
-0.11683885008096695,
-0.17316044867038727,
0.4669730067253113,
0.9976732134819031,
-0.6304171681404114,
0.02284866012632847,
-0.1262625902891159,
0.32439467310905457,
-0.6947253346443176,
-0.23276232182979584,
0.6884435415267944,
-0.3471978008747101,
-0.7447040677070618,
0.6850827932357788,
0.14184747636318207,
-0.22554387152194977,
-0.26531317830085754,
0.06163153797388077,
0.22122405469417572,
-0.020386232063174248,
0.44862228631973267,
0.26529252529144287,
-0.3203945755958557,
-0.5805807113647461,
-0.09352456778287888,
0.31359410285949707,
0.3078066110610962,
0.9644001126289368,
-0.8667058944702148,
0.3124741017818451,
0.791782557964325,
0.4385385811328888,
0.7291098833084106,
0.25663986802101135,
0.7658660411834717,
-1.2023940086364746,
0.4812326729297638,
0.3281320631504059,
0.4973209798336029,
0.26532620191574097,
-0.3062238395214081,
0.6967013478279114,
0.0487247072160244,
-0.5935707092285156,
-1.0539600849151611,
0.18411453068256378,
-0.8535990715026855,
-0.13523904979228973,
0.7624649405479431,
-0.0772065818309784,
-0.7373092174530029,
0.12696675956249237,
-0.15956784784793854,
0.5580177903175354,
-0.34163573384284973,
0.7809948325157166,
0.2164599448442459,
0.28116992115974426,
-0.25139808654785156,
-0.333617240190506,
0.6247734427452087,
0.5239370465278625,
-0.37228426337242126,
0.1400989294052124,
0.27944719791412354,
0.25044459104537964,
0.21768978238105774,
0.2928750514984131,
0.1203097477555275,
0.06786870956420898,
0.1243022158741951,
0.35064539313316345,
-0.05207178369164467,
-0.7636496424674988,
-0.42311862111091614,
0.34340161085128784,
-0.5001238584518433,
-0.37748482823371887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00060v1
|
Cascade-Aware Training of Language Models
| 2024-05-29T22:28:46 | 2024-05-29T22:28:46 |
Congchao Wang, Sean Augenstein, Keith Rush, Wittawat Jitkrittum, Harikrishna Narasimhan, Ankit Singh Rawat, Aditya Krishna Menon, Alec Go
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Reducing serving cost and latency is a fundamental concern for the deployment
of language models (LMs) in business applications. To address this, cascades of
LMs offer an effective solution that conditionally employ smaller models for
simpler queries. Cascaded systems are typically built with independently
trained models, neglecting the advantages of considering inference-time
interactions of the cascaded LMs during training. In this paper, we present
cascade-aware training(CAT), an approach to optimizing the overall quality-cost
performance tradeoff of a cascade of LMs. We achieve inference-time benefits by
training the small LM with awareness of its place in a cascade and downstream
capabilities. We demonstrate the value of the proposed method with over 60 LM
tasks of the SuperGLUE, WMT22, and FLAN2021 datasets.
|
[
-0.47714999318122864,
-0.32620665431022644,
-0.10213169455528259,
0.4001350700855255,
0.05977678671479225,
0.16504165530204773,
-0.027572479099035263,
-0.5509033799171448,
0.046861372888088226,
0.5232577323913574,
-0.6450725793838501,
-0.017523346468806267,
-0.07385789602994919,
-0.24207565188407898,
-0.18370270729064941,
0.9822015762329102,
0.21657244861125946,
0.24406489729881287,
0.08385299891233444,
-0.12308884412050247,
-0.43307381868362427,
-0.5457054376602173,
-1.316391110420227,
-0.5237239599227905,
0.5421056747436523,
0.14219024777412415,
0.7684425115585327,
0.6238235235214233,
0.3798505663871765,
0.09300606697797775,
-0.20247845351696014,
0.05898435413837433,
-0.3412111699581146,
0.054781850427389145,
-0.3609655499458313,
-0.6249573230743408,
-0.49674665927886963,
-0.17148639261722565,
0.5078815817832947,
0.8036230206489563,
-0.3723989725112915,
0.37235158681869507,
0.26913997530937195,
0.8073975443840027,
-0.9439643025398254,
0.11832280457019806,
-0.6892563700675964,
0.41407763957977295,
0.009722392074763775,
-0.03865288943052292,
-0.6456431746482849,
-0.09560397267341614,
0.11835131049156189,
-0.5148348808288574,
0.12450212985277176,
0.06600815057754517,
0.7166139483451843,
0.40095779299736023,
-0.23330748081207275,
-0.11003118008375168,
-0.7988904118537903,
0.8823545575141907,
-0.5382564663887024,
0.5937241315841675,
0.4016842842102051,
0.45254167914390564,
-0.30742907524108887,
-0.6182783842086792,
-0.3766351044178009,
0.125721737742424,
-0.15585145354270935,
0.22797179222106934,
0.030652351677417755,
0.20314975082874298,
0.13779598474502563,
0.5170128345489502,
-0.5333881378173828,
0.35358938574790955,
0.4180918037891388,
-0.25175943970680237,
0.24067215621471405,
0.3066450357437134,
0.14105428755283356,
0.15785446763038635,
-0.2862224876880646,
0.1525123566389084,
-0.5050148963928223,
0.4168572425842285,
-0.08755896985530853,
0.6351332068443298,
0.17751875519752502,
0.07430870085954666,
-0.33822840452194214,
0.4618833661079407,
0.13102184236049652,
-0.22129860520362854,
-0.16738849878311157,
-0.2623821794986725,
-0.4416666626930237,
-0.008495215326547623,
0.4217853248119354,
-0.31547072529792786,
0.17351393401622772,
-0.06110262870788574,
-0.49238187074661255,
-0.035421159118413925,
0.07242666929960251,
-0.681082010269165,
-0.06988120824098587,
0.3244324326515198,
-0.46444183588027954,
-0.23954249918460846,
-0.5965712070465088,
-0.1400301456451416,
-0.21433773636817932,
-0.2759894132614136,
0.49908286333084106,
-0.17211534082889557,
-0.29279202222824097,
-0.028272470459342003,
0.09657546877861023,
0.1620437502861023,
0.26020970940589905,
-0.9654355645179749,
0.4560711681842804,
0.6701185703277588,
0.7978219985961914,
0.24193643033504486,
-0.18271444737911224,
-0.9192605018615723,
0.4088224768638611,
-0.5491624474525452,
0.5214441418647766,
-0.3380665183067322,
-0.37092679738998413,
0.041425079107284546,
-0.2176085114479065,
-0.10175906121730804,
-0.6688957810401917,
0.4164167046546936,
-0.8015586137771606,
-0.07836783677339554,
-0.20517264306545258,
-0.4360584616661072,
0.03472120687365532,
0.1769241988658905,
-0.7694170475006104,
1.3697339296340942,
0.035441264510154724,
-0.9673385620117188,
0.42802903056144714,
-0.2844862639904022,
-0.6089655756950378,
0.14735358953475952,
-0.022750698029994965,
-0.49240565299987793,
0.03554769232869148,
0.4239709973335266,
0.39896389842033386,
-0.13595691323280334,
0.25224578380584717,
-0.1808226853609085,
-0.15912380814552307,
-0.15863680839538574,
-0.1961948573589325,
0.8525757789611816,
0.3191874325275421,
-0.26348236203193665,
-0.14238712191581726,
-0.696316123008728,
0.04374275356531143,
-0.2438899129629135,
-0.6412257552146912,
-0.5555437803268433,
0.12485039979219437,
-0.10965284705162048,
0.3673882484436035,
0.10833895206451416,
-0.19129678606987,
0.3238307535648346,
-0.38312894105911255,
-0.021280014887452126,
0.649820864200592,
-0.15253712236881256,
0.5403356552124023,
-0.13100066781044006,
0.5916091203689575,
0.19809727370738983,
0.6608135104179382,
0.12522882223129272,
-0.2233273684978485,
-1.2523388862609863,
-0.4661177396774292,
0.18803179264068604,
0.6117212176322937,
-1.1650975942611694,
0.05311101675033569,
-0.32075849175453186,
-0.38065305352211,
-0.4680449962615967,
0.291439414024353,
0.47625795006752014,
0.4272073209285736,
0.39188042283058167,
-0.26898229122161865,
-0.5386648178100586,
-0.872627854347229,
-0.4644048511981964,
-0.10208088904619217,
0.21274586021900177,
0.20206214487552643,
0.39847004413604736,
-0.059209976345300674,
1.1521600484848022,
-0.3245463967323303,
-0.4986095130443573,
-0.5035853981971741,
0.21888071298599243,
0.1513068974018097,
0.5323779582977295,
0.2919420599937439,
-0.542921781539917,
-0.6656537652015686,
0.0627208799123764,
-0.512954831123352,
-0.08197461068630219,
-0.26886746287345886,
-0.2548622190952301,
0.32060763239860535,
0.45294028520584106,
-0.4748886823654175,
0.25081005692481995,
0.6321294903755188,
0.42666223645210266,
0.4744311571121216,
-0.16933900117874146,
-0.29207542538642883,
-1.0071552991867065,
0.014491874724626541,
-0.11987145990133286,
-0.38967403769493103,
-0.8599575757980347,
-0.18220598995685577,
0.09480424225330353,
-0.04251087084412575,
-0.43810543417930603,
0.5611712336540222,
-0.6962910890579224,
-0.3244723081588745,
-0.15679891407489777,
-0.11997220665216446,
-0.15111036598682404,
0.6279703378677368,
0.45646998286247253,
0.7725759744644165,
0.7435439825057983,
-0.9105672836303711,
-0.33757728338241577,
-0.06683126837015152,
-0.2791592478752136,
0.6218996644020081,
-0.3068106472492218,
-0.11573931574821472,
0.06413814425468445,
0.6035553216934204,
-0.5037550926208496,
0.09078236669301987,
-0.047349363565444946,
-0.2132960706949234,
0.19042286276817322,
-0.2893140912055969,
-0.33339551091194153,
-0.42600685358047485,
-0.10112878680229187,
0.40874412655830383,
0.4275399446487427,
-0.8024225831031799,
0.6162695288658142,
0.3401534855365753,
0.15640074014663696,
-1.0382473468780518,
-0.9722687005996704,
-0.07741988450288773,
-0.0009205566602759063,
-0.30676671862602234,
-0.05038256198167801,
0.243162140250206,
0.2834443747997284,
-0.23008833825588226,
-0.22755712270736694,
-0.3299406170845032,
0.18770912289619446,
0.09828269481658936,
-0.15248386561870575,
-0.26157346367836,
0.2281305342912674,
0.06609588116407394,
-0.31416964530944824,
-0.2945616543292999,
-0.7591143846511841,
0.44752955436706543,
0.04700961709022522,
-0.3311920762062073,
-0.7989837527275085,
0.11349919438362122,
0.21939809620380402,
-0.44654667377471924,
1.012850046157837,
0.6495462656021118,
-0.5401022434234619,
-0.7385529279708862,
-0.3883664309978485,
-0.20035290718078613,
-0.46812760829925537,
0.11744089424610138,
-0.4068707823753357,
-0.7773873209953308,
0.6267217397689819,
-0.08865410834550858,
0.03675329312682152,
0.13706906139850616,
0.3529919683933258,
0.13467444479465485,
1.2667334079742432,
0.7246951460838318,
-0.4499836266040802,
0.7533648014068604,
-0.3539443612098694,
0.4469643831253052,
-0.8005889654159546,
-0.17172951996326447,
-0.6544040441513062,
-0.014594088308513165,
-0.4410025179386139,
-0.5291047096252441,
0.22603608667850494,
0.36181753873825073,
-0.3867412209510803,
0.28766068816185,
-0.10047496110200882,
0.39212125539779663,
0.4092883765697479,
0.0017533458303660154,
0.48976626992225647,
-0.045292969793081284,
-0.19915887713432312,
0.16875958442687988,
-1.1189134120941162,
-0.26340845227241516,
0.5016114711761475,
0.36601686477661133,
0.9856288433074951,
0.1727539598941803,
0.36354413628578186,
0.2603726387023926,
0.47934380173683167,
-0.7974156737327576,
0.4553270936012268,
-0.11478959023952484,
-0.7473641037940979,
-0.24126780033111572,
-0.707754373550415,
-0.7029953598976135,
0.2797500491142273,
0.182953342795372,
-0.6707473397254944,
0.21713939309120178,
0.5770428776741028,
-0.38157373666763306,
0.49671241641044617,
-0.3858887255191803,
0.604228675365448,
-0.020223991945385933,
-0.27802976965904236,
-0.32512393593788147,
-0.5072070956230164,
0.33177894353866577,
-0.13304081559181213,
0.4146575629711151,
0.003376526292413473,
0.050078921020030975,
0.4174230694770813,
-0.7507908940315247,
0.8673251867294312,
-0.18495580554008484,
-0.24303296208381653,
0.2323920726776123,
0.3635271191596985,
0.7296480536460876,
-0.06384371966123581,
-0.03482283279299736,
-0.040635302662849426,
-0.24029873311519623,
-0.5039984583854675,
-0.4831452965736389,
0.6397247910499573,
-0.48268941044807434,
-0.36987873911857605,
-0.3212052583694458,
-0.5009742975234985,
-0.46742692589759827,
0.030830930918455124,
0.021135207265615463,
0.6275546550750732,
0.03979194909334183,
-0.0687924176454544,
0.6681071519851685,
-0.11851714551448822,
0.8636038899421692,
0.4733823239803314,
-0.440777450799942,
-0.1841113418340683,
0.758186399936676,
0.20770123600959778,
0.6549099683761597,
0.8096123337745667,
0.15003186464309692,
-0.2636987566947937,
-0.21553035080432892,
-0.3100166320800781,
-0.07389922440052032,
-0.7597988843917847,
-0.160154789686203,
-0.5922420024871826,
-0.2697603106498718,
-0.03488605469465256,
-0.14197216928005219,
-0.7841163873672485,
-0.35971763730049133,
-0.21019397675991058,
0.18538057804107666,
0.026849927380681038,
0.4015358090400696,
-0.1841849833726883,
0.6647772789001465,
-0.5832696557044983,
-0.2210380584001541,
0.4122369885444641,
0.5433974266052246,
0.6338154077529907,
-0.49104803800582886,
-0.8342934250831604,
0.11572501063346863,
-0.16815845668315887,
-0.1644418090581894,
0.20178547501564026,
0.5896084904670715,
0.6460432410240173,
0.5343016386032104,
-0.08750618994235992,
0.740297257900238,
-0.4325956106185913,
0.922265887260437,
0.10896903276443481,
-1.2024145126342773,
0.7247567176818848,
-0.19361618161201477,
0.23689374327659607,
0.4940873980522156,
0.6301482915878296,
-0.6444212794303894,
-0.39537709951400757,
-0.37465840578079224,
-0.5177920460700989,
0.7906692624092102,
0.2015819400548935,
0.005596166010946035,
-0.11074243485927582,
0.21958526968955994,
-0.05802951380610466,
0.10482481867074966,
-0.7421740889549255,
-0.13617345690727234,
0.1327800154685974,
-0.010784921236336231,
0.06910048425197601,
0.0801563635468483,
0.2591261565685272,
-0.28633037209510803,
1.0102022886276245,
-0.29789701104164124,
-0.24710047245025635,
0.026278331875801086,
-0.4440268576145172,
0.13952794671058655,
-0.038502808660268784,
0.3096572756767273,
0.41980722546577454,
-0.009197049774229527,
0.32292887568473816,
0.4405461549758911,
-0.5241617560386658,
0.17568868398666382,
-0.7150723934173584,
0.05203920975327492,
-0.09017011523246765,
0.2847435772418976,
0.7426577806472778,
0.1206098273396492,
-0.49098145961761475,
0.38484495878219604,
-0.12789374589920044,
0.3618904948234558,
0.059661101549863815,
0.06955966353416443,
0.15676076710224152,
0.16969533264636993,
0.21957755088806152,
-0.03541329875588417,
0.11511801928281784,
-0.24507679045200348,
0.11387061327695847,
0.5160273909568787,
-0.6709524989128113,
-0.17471230030059814,
0.49409472942352295,
0.15912747383117676,
-0.30059531331062317,
0.41216304898262024,
-0.005294427741318941,
-0.5385607481002808,
0.4000336527824402,
0.5049606561660767,
0.8320324420928955,
-0.5885404944419861,
0.18299497663974762,
0.1671813279390335,
0.33291810750961304,
-0.2614128887653351,
0.1761656403541565,
-0.04655655100941658,
-0.6697306036949158,
-0.47393494844436646,
-0.7404120564460754,
-0.3891181945800781,
0.17507332563400269,
-0.8681328892707825,
0.2939351499080658,
-0.4802625775337219,
-0.37792012095451355,
-0.21282242238521576,
-0.25213053822517395,
-0.5749944448471069,
0.48267507553100586,
-0.03973182663321495,
1.1691628694534302,
-0.7799702286720276,
0.7847235798835754,
0.35889366269111633,
-0.5768451690673828,
-0.9116511940956116,
-0.010930805467069149,
-0.31557953357696533,
-0.7323572039604187,
0.799409806728363,
-0.018190855160355568,
-0.5861273407936096,
0.19526000320911407,
-0.2571943998336792,
-0.5786134004592896,
0.8555651903152466,
0.351818323135376,
-0.5852465033531189,
0.3182472586631775,
0.2641165852546692,
0.629212498664856,
-0.4653970003128052,
0.44066518545150757,
0.5207443833351135,
-0.10247962921857834,
-0.08877886831760406,
-0.9780289530754089,
-0.2141336053609848,
0.13252109289169312,
0.5598806738853455,
0.1698092669248581,
-0.7761399745941162,
0.7467759251594543,
0.050624143332242966,
-0.2715262472629547,
-0.09586881846189499,
0.6425443291664124,
-0.04122460260987282,
0.07860660552978516,
0.6212781071662903,
0.6616214513778687,
0.7849252223968506,
0.10385545343160629,
1.1016125679016113,
-0.4148918092250824,
0.7440788149833679,
1.2942954301834106,
-0.19371585547924042,
1.1506530046463013,
0.45138299465179443,
-0.12641845643520355,
0.43734753131866455,
1.0702807903289795,
0.6345674991607666,
0.6041251420974731,
0.27500060200691223,
-0.5420892238616943,
-0.5157356858253479,
-0.4247312843799591,
-0.46954256296157837,
0.16769443452358246,
0.24136488139629364,
-0.15734651684761047,
-0.3238475024700165,
0.11911554634571075,
0.1951388418674469,
-0.34647804498672485,
-0.5962820649147034,
0.851772665977478,
0.24449846148490906,
-0.5175462365150452,
0.7638692259788513,
-0.30910420417785645,
0.4367978870868683,
-0.4332678020000458,
0.40506792068481445,
-0.6959819197654724,
0.5241215229034424,
-0.3301878273487091,
-0.4202759265899658,
0.13981416821479797,
-0.15018156170845032,
-0.30803632736206055,
-0.20232808589935303,
0.4819484353065491,
-0.42109280824661255,
-0.30352866649627686,
0.4162231981754303,
0.41260308027267456,
0.1582658290863037,
-0.23682789504528046,
-0.4739331901073456,
-0.15318171679973602,
-0.3429339826107025,
-0.13738463819026947,
0.29094672203063965,
0.34330055117607117,
-0.3473558723926544,
1.0940254926681519,
0.5356027483940125,
0.06827683746814728,
0.09600242227315903,
0.6473012566566467,
0.7290348410606384,
-0.25993049144744873,
-0.7492038011550903,
-0.6546221971511841,
0.46905258297920227,
0.06046338006854057,
-0.10337921977043152,
0.4474101662635803,
0.6819546818733215,
0.8066522479057312,
-0.09329618513584137,
0.8144587874412537,
0.39675819873809814,
0.2980855405330658,
-0.4987362325191498,
0.7182722091674805,
-0.6915568709373474,
0.46904751658439636,
-0.17142906785011292,
-0.9015820622444153,
-0.1757904291152954,
0.3322070837020874,
-0.27298906445503235,
0.10395637154579163,
0.6494094133377075,
0.9815816283226013,
-0.26821744441986084,
0.24334733188152313,
0.2091389149427414,
-0.06818267703056335,
0.49776190519332886,
0.6250914335250854,
0.907069206237793,
-0.2980239987373352,
0.4310101270675659,
-0.2374597191810608,
-0.3186993896961212,
-0.37870779633522034,
-1.0169827938079834,
-0.8173314332962036,
-0.3992607593536377,
-0.34436118602752686,
-0.13929295539855957,
-0.0048541538417339325,
0.6498124599456787,
0.9104281067848206,
-0.8316017985343933,
-0.4800879657268524,
-0.32642990350723267,
0.10686145722866058,
-0.5423346161842346,
-0.1670180708169937,
0.25549203157424927,
-0.7701419591903687,
-0.3656860291957855,
0.048821546137332916,
0.33043062686920166,
0.0430314764380455,
-0.43064701557159424,
-0.09149719029664993,
-0.37883588671684265,
0.4495300352573395,
0.7083746790885925,
0.2722877860069275,
-0.5240892767906189,
-0.39529719948768616,
-0.11973871290683746,
-0.27776002883911133,
0.028191063553094864,
0.9161622524261475,
-0.7159960269927979,
0.2793223261833191,
0.38720420002937317,
0.8678227066993713,
0.4758766293525696,
-0.10880392044782639,
0.318783700466156,
-0.9894977807998657,
0.22938965260982513,
-0.0007404883508570492,
0.025080474093556404,
0.3485147953033447,
-0.38673681020736694,
0.46441298723220825,
0.20229044556617737,
-0.4293971657752991,
-0.7898105382919312,
0.28410884737968445,
-0.6858224272727966,
-0.060634225606918335,
0.771763265132904,
-0.1700114607810974,
-0.07359858602285385,
-0.22299183905124664,
-0.021259848028421402,
0.2976289689540863,
-0.061177778989076614,
0.46464475989341736,
0.5383263826370239,
-0.3661966919898987,
-0.017477376386523247,
-0.6021410822868347,
0.831576943397522,
0.7160751223564148,
-0.9087411761283875,
0.10753533244132996,
-0.05461948737502098,
0.19873830676078796,
0.05521683767437935,
0.7570449113845825,
0.369733601808548,
0.024542275816202164,
0.10837344825267792,
0.3149765133857727,
0.4002135097980499,
-0.4878323972225189,
-0.35793110728263855,
-0.12292420864105225,
0.1386999636888504,
-0.3190566599369049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19550v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19550v1
|
Stress-Testing Capability Elicitation With Password-Locked Models
| 2024-05-29T22:26:26 | 2024-05-29T22:26:26 |
Ryan Greenblatt, Fabien Roger, Dmitrii Krasheninnikov, David Krueger
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
To determine the safety of large language models (LLMs), AI developers must
be able to assess their dangerous capabilities. But simple prompting strategies
often fail to elicit an LLM's full capabilities. One way to elicit capabilities
more robustly is to fine-tune the LLM to complete the task. In this paper, we
investigate the conditions under which fine-tuning-based elicitation suffices
to elicit capabilities. To do this, we introduce password-locked models, LLMs
fine-tuned such that some of their capabilities are deliberately hidden.
Specifically, these LLMs are trained to exhibit these capabilities only when a
password is present in the prompt, and to imitate a much weaker LLM otherwise.
Password-locked models enable a novel method of evaluating capabilities
elicitation methods, by testing whether these password-locked capabilities can
be elicited without using the password. We find that a few high-quality
demonstrations are often sufficient to fully elicit password-locked
capabilities. More surprisingly, fine-tuning can elicit other capabilities that
have been locked using the same password, or even different passwords.
Furthermore, when only evaluations, and not demonstrations, are available,
approaches like reinforcement learning are still often able to elicit
capabilities. Overall, our findings suggest that fine-tuning is an effective
method of eliciting hidden capabilities of current models, but may be
unreliable when high-quality demonstrations are not available, e.g. as may be
the case when models' (hidden) capabilities exceed those of human
demonstrators.
|
[
-0.5304758548736572,
-0.9043112993240356,
0.30667388439178467,
-0.11857341974973679,
-0.17246566712856293,
0.29458433389663696,
-0.3661653995513916,
-0.3771451711654663,
-0.6037455797195435,
0.4322969317436218,
-0.586885929107666,
-0.14479072391986847,
-0.6727086305618286,
0.24176891148090363,
-0.33364471793174744,
0.8952320218086243,
-0.14157646894454956,
-0.19932681322097778,
-0.09632144868373871,
-0.028316963464021683,
-0.5699496269226074,
-0.44458118081092834,
-0.7046220302581787,
-0.4522112309932709,
0.12342813611030579,
0.5001512169837952,
0.6966969966888428,
0.5121747851371765,
0.40278100967407227,
0.3093092739582062,
-0.3497813940048218,
0.3398665189743042,
-0.3242672383785248,
0.11558564007282257,
-0.12055506557226181,
-0.47459569573402405,
-0.27312538027763367,
0.18783074617385864,
0.48570799827575684,
0.41027700901031494,
-0.03414477780461311,
0.36265599727630615,
0.5034620761871338,
0.3058488368988037,
-0.6432183980941772,
0.17685405910015106,
-1.0695738792419434,
-0.1608385592699051,
0.10365571081638336,
-0.1634293496608734,
-0.2674420177936554,
-0.2634476125240326,
-0.035328976809978485,
-0.3823862671852112,
0.11438573151826859,
0.5079357624053955,
0.9474741220474243,
0.5156312584877014,
-0.17649583518505096,
-0.33130311965942383,
-0.7306624054908752,
0.7977792620658875,
-0.6311911344528198,
0.11537222564220428,
0.7815772294998169,
0.22532430291175842,
0.0202897060662508,
-0.3703973889350891,
-0.44245120882987976,
-0.7808300852775574,
0.02770235762000084,
-0.11814417690038681,
-0.00075272232061252,
0.3250589966773987,
0.7433047890663147,
0.4786624312400818,
-0.44108617305755615,
0.6266773343086243,
-0.6405578851699829,
-0.14139077067375183,
0.5073152184486389,
0.19659698009490967,
0.36581137776374817,
-0.0048687332309782505,
-0.25126662850379944,
-0.33307865262031555,
-0.4965188503265381,
0.2791055738925934,
0.3648287355899811,
0.5969381332397461,
-0.11408627778291702,
0.5872913002967834,
-0.2864617109298706,
0.635932981967926,
0.08430874347686768,
-0.027477337047457695,
0.12864096462726593,
0.0698372945189476,
-0.5063523650169373,
-0.23891271650791168,
0.5493140816688538,
0.26518693566322327,
0.3854351043701172,
-0.19541063904762268,
-0.5436961054801941,
-0.09470518678426743,
0.29981088638305664,
-0.8235371112823486,
0.12909573316574097,
0.4682588279247284,
-0.5158239006996155,
-0.5244925618171692,
-0.09504173696041107,
-0.7402932047843933,
-0.5107473134994507,
-0.0163510050624609,
0.5585967302322388,
-0.6293492913246155,
-0.28843069076538086,
0.0001286306360270828,
-0.3038202226161957,
0.3477648198604584,
-0.0439564473927021,
-1.195428729057312,
0.5004144310951233,
0.7203783392906189,
0.8150416016578674,
-0.19761578738689423,
-0.4397987723350525,
-0.6315186619758606,
-0.19638538360595703,
-0.34767308831214905,
0.26914212107658386,
-0.3952900171279907,
-0.23834693431854248,
0.2780274748802185,
-0.010402115061879158,
0.01405637338757515,
-0.9350758790969849,
0.535126805305481,
-0.5397763848304749,
-0.515519917011261,
-0.28124669194221497,
-0.5979722142219543,
0.23214195668697357,
0.26983270049095154,
-0.60895174741745,
0.8630916476249695,
0.14090725779533386,
-0.2812354564666748,
0.45007357001304626,
-0.6023198962211609,
-0.33096206188201904,
0.009880476631224155,
-0.06010210141539574,
-0.5362622737884521,
0.29674768447875977,
0.36133459210395813,
0.47588589787483215,
-0.15433993935585022,
0.05849471315741539,
-0.5034257173538208,
-0.4302605390548706,
0.5141583681106567,
-0.45810142159461975,
0.538534939289093,
0.453334242105484,
-0.3359275162220001,
-0.08849534392356873,
-0.4560967981815338,
0.24071930348873138,
0.21664489805698395,
-0.15027283132076263,
-0.1653132140636444,
-0.17221924662590027,
-0.2844196856021881,
0.046697914600372314,
0.23183166980743408,
-0.270846426486969,
0.0799349993467331,
-0.49926984310150146,
0.48870012164115906,
0.7681691646575928,
-0.06649839133024216,
0.48988667130470276,
-0.7205533385276794,
0.6802749633789062,
-0.25005286931991577,
0.36800938844680786,
-0.16978181898593903,
-0.2545008957386017,
-0.41329655051231384,
-0.33046576380729675,
0.2790292799472809,
0.6918796896934509,
-0.5494391918182373,
0.2503032088279724,
0.22599752247333527,
-0.3581756055355072,
-0.4436945915222168,
0.37338006496429443,
0.6091872453689575,
0.08586563915014267,
0.303322434425354,
-0.19781331717967987,
0.052659325301647186,
-0.7907983660697937,
-0.5239725708961487,
-0.280456006526947,
-0.22828325629234314,
0.5288281440734863,
0.564393162727356,
0.35325193405151367,
0.2645353078842163,
-0.31062108278274536,
-0.16450542211532593,
-0.3255307078361511,
0.36133873462677,
0.02893419750034809,
0.6783626675605774,
0.46802306175231934,
-0.7590562701225281,
0.04468674957752228,
-0.2081184834241867,
-0.624077320098877,
-0.1346425712108612,
-0.3329871594905853,
0.41757723689079285,
-0.08359059691429138,
0.8609941005706787,
-0.6260396838188171,
0.5177470445632935,
0.3117181658744812,
-0.22500833868980408,
0.6478032469749451,
-0.48178932070732117,
0.15409965813159943,
-0.6611157655715942,
0.14721301198005676,
-0.3728497326374054,
0.0026465682312846184,
-0.36829546093940735,
0.7052600979804993,
0.36984652280807495,
-0.46974071860313416,
-0.369687020778656,
0.603605329990387,
-0.7283182144165039,
-0.03904066979885101,
-0.44322502613067627,
-0.06801288574934006,
-0.22110989689826965,
0.475933313369751,
-0.46547186374664307,
0.9661402106285095,
0.7808977365493774,
-0.8282040953636169,
0.22198042273521423,
0.08576858043670654,
-0.6182494759559631,
0.5114087462425232,
-0.7288503050804138,
0.1039951741695404,
0.15831077098846436,
-0.26677316427230835,
-0.7468725442886353,
-0.4772273302078247,
-0.18019957840442657,
-0.30616021156311035,
0.4235653877258301,
-0.24553735554218292,
-0.7163248062133789,
-0.6056874990463257,
-0.2512214481830597,
0.3732808232307434,
0.7334670424461365,
-0.34671542048454285,
0.34790149331092834,
0.22536668181419373,
-0.1306390017271042,
-0.3821760416030884,
-0.6596430540084839,
-0.21901056170463562,
-0.3980756998062134,
-0.26355135440826416,
0.3553049862384796,
-0.3028371334075928,
-0.15842683613300323,
-0.19435575604438782,
-0.14429448544979095,
-0.27251914143562317,
0.8251450657844543,
0.6001173853874207,
0.19856418669223785,
0.12133952230215073,
0.19458913803100586,
0.4029463827610016,
0.10765083879232407,
0.006618387997150421,
-0.2201329618692398,
0.3984386622905731,
-0.2666548192501068,
-0.6163843274116516,
-0.37606412172317505,
0.3431544303894043,
0.7456772327423096,
-0.5291863083839417,
0.7911356687545776,
0.5143477320671082,
-0.5422481894493103,
-0.5332149267196655,
-0.49455875158309937,
-0.6386703848838806,
-0.586591899394989,
0.3324873447418213,
-0.21318286657333374,
-1.2850327491760254,
0.7945883274078369,
-0.6496875882148743,
0.13670721650123596,
-0.1723940372467041,
0.520876407623291,
0.025341076776385307,
1.0087615251541138,
0.723551869392395,
-0.006952841766178608,
0.5487512946128845,
-0.14038249850273132,
0.26753461360931396,
-0.7076624631881714,
-0.17617130279541016,
-0.630114734172821,
-0.48479488492012024,
-0.43525397777557373,
0.08472760766744614,
0.40661075711250305,
0.44928956031799316,
-0.29076868295669556,
0.05261616408824921,
-0.4131642282009125,
0.7965071201324463,
0.6816207766532898,
0.26201993227005005,
-0.010981392115354538,
-0.16074465215206146,
-0.5613588094711304,
0.20719274878501892,
-0.42370930314064026,
-0.384873628616333,
0.9106405377388,
0.19274243712425232,
0.7655367851257324,
-0.2035883218050003,
0.4063333570957184,
0.18861708045005798,
-0.07991059124469757,
-0.5993274450302124,
0.5450671315193176,
0.12329752743244171,
-0.7503650188446045,
-0.48192256689071655,
-0.31900399923324585,
-0.9724132418632507,
-0.19014202058315277,
-0.4092428684234619,
-1.057570219039917,
-0.0784228965640068,
0.3431103825569153,
-0.9666079878807068,
0.4670586884021759,
-0.6534417271614075,
0.7636523842811584,
-0.3079964220523834,
-0.16556015610694885,
-0.2991413474082947,
-0.28195488452911377,
0.4773411750793457,
-0.26018333435058594,
0.15131953358650208,
-0.2798450291156769,
0.21799518167972565,
0.4157766103744507,
-0.25384166836738586,
0.8952550888061523,
-0.011111285537481308,
0.05709739029407501,
0.02478884719312191,
0.37320688366889954,
0.6007720232009888,
0.25557395815849304,
-0.24175287783145905,
-0.29226988554000854,
-0.03614206984639168,
-0.3759468197822571,
-0.7744641304016113,
0.634203314781189,
-0.8267309665679932,
-0.9512991309165955,
-0.0301518552005291,
-0.6453741788864136,
-0.4334016740322113,
0.2307533621788025,
0.23575568199157715,
0.28697705268859863,
-0.01131368987262249,
0.12944002449512482,
0.7435926198959351,
-0.45385900139808655,
0.43618109822273254,
0.43407732248306274,
-0.24947905540466309,
-0.005967637058347464,
0.6871799826622009,
0.254257470369339,
0.5094845294952393,
-0.10178466141223907,
0.08065283298492432,
0.11549845337867737,
-0.8607466220855713,
-0.31023144721984863,
-0.12335680425167084,
-0.28590255975723267,
-0.5139071345329285,
-0.15565355122089386,
-0.5109919309616089,
-0.20499287545681,
-0.25114232301712036,
-0.3855122923851013,
-0.19958288967609406,
-0.26894909143447876,
-0.47079896926879883,
0.3881992697715759,
0.42323529720306396,
-0.33547350764274597,
0.2198294699192047,
-0.4768403172492981,
0.4745761454105377,
0.5459379553794861,
0.534186840057373,
0.13178953528404236,
-0.659691333770752,
-0.3945595920085907,
-0.21083177626132965,
-0.45990365743637085,
-0.7472460865974426,
0.392963171005249,
0.2511464059352875,
0.43862950801849365,
0.3599080443382263,
0.5087626576423645,
0.30630549788475037,
-0.30154290795326233,
0.8409894704818726,
-0.26708734035491943,
-1.0354806184768677,
0.7750467658042908,
-0.3570293188095093,
0.2529386281967163,
0.5813137888908386,
0.21422900259494781,
-0.10953104496002197,
-0.7527044415473938,
-0.6214095950126648,
-0.9079291224479675,
0.5707038044929504,
0.14597377181053162,
0.41522762179374695,
0.09621679782867432,
0.7220503091812134,
0.04491318017244339,
0.15318717062473297,
-0.3577094078063965,
-0.18753331899642944,
0.012546812184154987,
0.13981123268604279,
0.21163885295391083,
-0.2675602436065674,
-0.27364853024482727,
-0.16196873784065247,
0.22601334750652313,
-0.13431565463542938,
0.16099044680595398,
-0.03449464589357376,
0.021844105795025826,
-0.1830296367406845,
0.4908226728439331,
0.532982349395752,
0.5894814729690552,
-0.21898595988750458,
0.17305327951908112,
0.7911569476127625,
-0.27834102511405945,
0.02917909063398838,
0.14036649465560913,
-0.29638776183128357,
-0.5250506401062012,
0.2504619359970093,
1.0010809898376465,
0.21865667402744293,
-0.8150210380554199,
0.36933112144470215,
-0.008963963016867638,
-0.33065468072891235,
-0.11425742506980896,
0.5191411375999451,
-0.2775351405143738,
0.5673644542694092,
0.502562940120697,
0.0424271821975708,
-0.11015050858259201,
-0.3553711473941803,
0.36926984786987305,
0.7175216674804688,
-0.3469206690788269,
-0.23276154696941376,
0.7561780214309692,
0.00041445871465839446,
-0.40569445490837097,
0.7998773455619812,
-0.31624263525009155,
-0.48743852972984314,
0.757665753364563,
0.5789613127708435,
0.8165610432624817,
-0.21035902202129364,
0.1571688950061798,
0.31653735041618347,
0.7805449366569519,
-0.1903391182422638,
0.39943620562553406,
-0.025401458144187927,
-0.673986554145813,
-0.189064159989357,
-0.47167396545410156,
-0.5177097916603088,
0.4196958839893341,
-1.0033563375473022,
0.010299951769411564,
-0.7787784934043884,
-0.2824106812477112,
-0.41831812262535095,
0.17210468649864197,
-0.7121741771697998,
0.14128156006336212,
0.22998884320259094,
1.1161731481552124,
-0.8115315437316895,
0.6716894507408142,
0.16308742761611938,
-0.1712585985660553,
-1.158274531364441,
0.12514282763004303,
0.06806070357561111,
-0.9780791401863098,
0.4525316655635834,
0.1334274858236313,
0.09618998318910599,
-0.08174026757478714,
-0.9269852042198181,
-0.5900373458862305,
1.157436728477478,
0.7001267075538635,
-0.36718809604644775,
0.002889468567445874,
0.17305327951908112,
0.29799187183380127,
-0.0692128911614418,
0.14719191193580627,
0.5854853987693787,
0.5141362547874451,
-0.35378238558769226,
-1.2891443967819214,
0.2429157793521881,
-0.1661558598279953,
-0.14537055790424347,
-0.1623246669769287,
-0.6606416702270508,
0.8205813765525818,
-0.44006797671318054,
-0.29563868045806885,
0.37266018986701965,
0.5930973291397095,
0.4053272604942322,
0.13632242381572723,
0.5389510989189148,
0.5069841146469116,
1.182019591331482,
-0.00851610116660595,
1.0789011716842651,
-0.5242965221405029,
0.1757173240184784,
0.8194026350975037,
-0.24690651893615723,
0.9774783849716187,
0.3542739450931549,
0.3326428234577179,
0.17804445326328278,
0.5594415664672852,
-0.13324983417987823,
0.49245819449424744,
0.4169980585575104,
-0.05343647673726082,
-0.5688837170600891,
-0.33417975902557373,
-0.2284887582063675,
0.2878500819206238,
0.36428940296173096,
-0.3220643401145935,
0.015579371713101864,
0.2687961757183075,
-0.028744040057063103,
-0.016697736456990242,
-0.4486677944660187,
0.6456255912780762,
0.4311380088329315,
-0.7136942148208618,
0.8985835909843445,
0.005534243304282427,
0.5349901914596558,
-0.5281806588172913,
0.25105926394462585,
-0.30838361382484436,
-0.01798599772155285,
0.08764638006687164,
-0.6146109700202942,
0.16614766418933868,
0.22758691012859344,
0.13842462003231049,
-0.3370581269264221,
0.8496761918067932,
-0.06109297648072243,
-0.2915774881839752,
0.3936615586280823,
0.5947659015655518,
-0.01756974682211876,
-0.15296119451522827,
-0.728010892868042,
0.16289947926998138,
-0.43468600511550903,
-0.16199436783790588,
0.5818231701850891,
0.575756847858429,
0.030752994120121002,
0.924676775932312,
0.49976491928100586,
0.2340567708015442,
-0.018661553040146828,
-0.049256157130002975,
0.8512122631072998,
-0.4906379282474518,
-0.3329457640647888,
-1.046696662902832,
0.21456685662269592,
-0.04127464070916176,
-0.48723331093788147,
0.6220943331718445,
0.18799063563346863,
0.8231144547462463,
-0.041814174503088,
0.8041890859603882,
0.2160016894340515,
0.14803250133991241,
-0.7229764461517334,
1.027090311050415,
-0.6728453040122986,
0.2024756819009781,
-0.14047828316688538,
-0.2649274170398712,
-0.13380739092826843,
0.14417824149131775,
-0.17686380445957184,
0.12399343401193619,
0.5818558931350708,
1.0097301006317139,
-0.18598008155822754,
-0.14405782520771027,
0.7139868140220642,
0.20367299020290375,
0.0033804206177592278,
0.6453027129173279,
0.9924638271331787,
-0.18252675235271454,
0.6742485761642456,
-0.02135075442492962,
-0.43325093388557434,
-0.10293065011501312,
-0.677159309387207,
-1.3054689168930054,
-0.6723384261131287,
-0.11877273768186569,
-0.33267149329185486,
0.21826328337192535,
0.8627604246139526,
0.7218503952026367,
-0.7729679942131042,
-0.0021704058162868023,
-0.03943298012018204,
0.2644296884536743,
-0.592521071434021,
-0.08353409171104431,
0.09540370106697083,
-0.5515829920768738,
-0.49118682742118835,
0.4453392028808594,
0.20994600653648376,
0.181013286113739,
-0.27509281039237976,
-0.0052681127563118935,
0.5090386867523193,
0.4500359296798706,
0.030215246602892876,
0.5387006402015686,
-0.585042417049408,
-0.4292820394039154,
0.06808848679065704,
0.01481105387210846,
-0.3487909138202667,
0.8812116384506226,
-0.6370288133621216,
0.056186821311712265,
0.2737564742565155,
0.8122478723526001,
0.27074018120765686,
-0.25775644183158875,
0.6940219402313232,
-0.7093786597251892,
0.06765399128198624,
0.1628568023443222,
0.20974618196487427,
0.023866083472967148,
-0.18795622885227203,
0.06372379511594772,
-0.22402925789356232,
-0.7362313866615295,
-1.125085711479187,
0.366647869348526,
-0.6557366251945496,
-0.46458593010902405,
0.9894808530807495,
-0.322313129901886,
-0.09098149836063385,
-0.16764745116233826,
-0.1221485286951065,
0.24447771906852722,
-0.2647858262062073,
1.1779944896697998,
0.6640806198120117,
0.22156283259391785,
-0.3261786997318268,
-0.6736538410186768,
1.0306000709533691,
0.5799335241317749,
-0.7908089756965637,
0.4861319065093994,
-0.08916031569242477,
-0.0336402989923954,
-0.04401274025440216,
0.22510917484760284,
0.036541007459163666,
0.37270331382751465,
-0.15119075775146484,
-0.45267337560653687,
-0.4819013476371765,
-0.368949830532074,
-0.40653350949287415,
0.4459143280982971,
0.5147128105163574,
0.10811088234186172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19544v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19544v1
|
One-Shot Safety Alignment for Large Language Models via Optimal Dualization
| 2024-05-29T22:12:52 | 2024-05-29T22:12:52 |
Xinmeng Huang, Shuo Li, Edgar Dobriban, Osbert Bastani, Hamed Hassani, Dongsheng Ding
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, math.OC, stat.ML
|
The growing safety concerns surrounding Large Language Models (LLMs) raise an
urgent need to align them with diverse human preferences to simultaneously
enhance their helpfulness and safety. A promising approach is to enforce safety
constraints through Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). For such
constrained RLHF, common Lagrangian-based primal-dual policy optimization
methods are computationally expensive and often unstable. This paper presents a
dualization perspective that reduces constrained alignment to an equivalent
unconstrained alignment problem. We do so by pre-optimizing a smooth and convex
dual function that has a closed form. This shortcut eliminates the need for
cumbersome primal-dual policy iterations, thus greatly reducing the
computational burden and improving training stability. Our strategy leads to
two practical algorithms in model-based and preference-based scenarios (MoCAN
and PeCAN, respectively). A broad range of experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of our methods.
|
[
0.04300044849514961,
-0.6143264770507812,
0.43002641201019287,
-0.0983552485704422,
-0.275043249130249,
0.1810230165719986,
-0.5793390870094299,
-0.053345419466495514,
-0.17082998156547546,
0.6677897572517395,
-0.6958498954772949,
-0.4462873637676239,
-0.2724843919277191,
-0.30040064454078674,
0.27314621210098267,
1.2040163278579712,
-0.3553239703178406,
-0.06096666306257248,
-0.10202304273843765,
-0.15532845258712769,
-0.11729676276445389,
-0.7040448784828186,
-0.6577603816986084,
-0.3884584307670593,
0.7276838421821594,
0.3556060492992401,
0.9644266963005066,
0.5549077391624451,
0.42927074432373047,
0.2452731430530548,
0.045141786336898804,
0.17612488567829132,
-0.538396418094635,
0.09268826991319656,
-0.19241735339164734,
-0.2391582429409027,
-0.3589419424533844,
-0.07110932469367981,
0.8487828373908997,
0.6210903525352478,
-0.49030911922454834,
-0.3255436420440674,
0.21108882129192352,
0.6277097463607788,
-0.7260932326316833,
-0.10592237859964371,
-0.3168962895870209,
0.11824381351470947,
-0.08078648149967194,
-0.08354811370372772,
-0.24575702846050262,
-0.6875144243240356,
0.17324231564998627,
-0.5963369011878967,
-0.23589462041854858,
-0.13067121803760529,
0.7523106336593628,
0.5284406542778015,
-0.693804144859314,
0.0941217765212059,
-0.7692784070968628,
1.085597276687622,
-0.7249976396560669,
0.2359422892332077,
0.24365569651126862,
0.17646802961826324,
-0.3899514377117157,
-0.010421879589557648,
-0.4507018029689789,
-0.3546346127986908,
-0.08764249831438065,
-0.1017947718501091,
0.30124345421791077,
0.5123374462127686,
0.03255273774266243,
-0.034442078322172165,
-0.6660526990890503,
0.6087563633918762,
-0.31114643812179565,
-0.46201398968696594,
0.8038053512573242,
0.12214801460504532,
0.14046259224414825,
0.28984639048576355,
-0.44732406735420227,
-0.4819108545780182,
-0.8378146886825562,
0.4133114218711853,
0.7823647856712341,
0.5513038635253906,
-0.22668331861495972,
0.29474854469299316,
-0.06975974887609482,
0.47634610533714294,
0.12757208943367004,
-0.5642638802528381,
0.20004427433013916,
-0.24057471752166748,
-0.01777423545718193,
0.1419209986925125,
0.9441157579421997,
0.40030527114868164,
0.2951542139053345,
-0.23248593509197235,
-0.2656653821468353,
0.23280808329582214,
0.25218841433525085,
-0.5979877710342407,
0.17411623895168304,
0.26252156496047974,
-0.09526874125003815,
-0.5273318290710449,
-0.048357825726270676,
-0.8092890977859497,
-0.4898863732814789,
-0.2761949598789215,
0.256509929895401,
-0.03557998687028885,
-0.3183182179927826,
0.34067779779434204,
0.5214995741844177,
0.19940683245658875,
0.08860909938812256,
-1.106521487236023,
0.2642629146575928,
0.8341281414031982,
0.6628265380859375,
-0.14510132372379303,
-0.139889657497406,
-0.830223023891449,
0.29763129353523254,
-0.15458199381828308,
0.4062803089618683,
-0.36867591738700867,
-0.4472634196281433,
0.29003193974494934,
-0.07361418753862381,
-0.13788022100925446,
-0.3431064784526825,
0.774084210395813,
-0.31155794858932495,
0.22042128443717957,
-0.14685405790805817,
-0.2020414024591446,
-0.16034597158432007,
0.18434733152389526,
-0.39249494671821594,
0.8304605484008789,
-0.18206201493740082,
-0.69434654712677,
0.26899290084838867,
-0.5609181523323059,
-0.6076654195785522,
-0.45252230763435364,
-0.3690871596336365,
-0.754096508026123,
-0.056531310081481934,
0.17825280129909515,
0.12330292165279388,
-0.1059250608086586,
0.5801081657409668,
-0.6041268706321716,
-0.1327475905418396,
0.1381017565727234,
-0.2960342764854431,
0.5621084570884705,
0.032905109226703644,
-0.1825120598077774,
0.5378156900405884,
-0.4244070053100586,
0.09626466035842896,
0.25682181119918823,
-0.5046281814575195,
-0.22769084572792053,
0.13977640867233276,
-0.08951117098331451,
0.212892085313797,
0.28113633394241333,
-0.46103665232658386,
0.5170192718505859,
-0.7200762033462524,
0.2238152027130127,
0.9746704697608948,
-0.15735501050949097,
0.7259673476219177,
-0.24039208889007568,
0.6888465881347656,
-0.1485709249973297,
0.3482668995857239,
0.4066581130027771,
0.16193996369838715,
-0.5182548761367798,
-0.12368816137313843,
0.3067288100719452,
0.7463273406028748,
-0.3811832666397095,
0.680012047290802,
-0.25161054730415344,
0.04729533568024635,
-0.4154016971588135,
0.1459185779094696,
0.7169139385223389,
0.48620501160621643,
0.07614094763994217,
-0.3435014486312866,
-0.3141784965991974,
-1.0762001276016235,
-0.03361866995692253,
-0.1990462988615036,
0.13749642670154572,
-0.010554898530244827,
0.11749231815338135,
-0.04693862795829773,
0.8143045902252197,
-0.47727206349372864,
-0.12514162063598633,
-0.012854495085775852,
0.03240416198968887,
0.1415262371301651,
0.6482434272766113,
0.6105903387069702,
-0.6918523907661438,
-0.4371124804019928,
0.11980076879262924,
-0.5224165916442871,
0.017074206843972206,
-0.06793657690286636,
-0.20215418934822083,
0.5262452960014343,
0.29948607087135315,
-0.36927667260169983,
0.4068533480167389,
0.6651327610015869,
-0.08674988895654678,
0.42133066058158875,
-0.3120512068271637,
-0.018208224326372147,
-0.8042076826095581,
0.10906115919351578,
-0.12835541367530823,
-0.34115299582481384,
-0.6945245265960693,
0.011197892017662525,
0.03696594014763832,
-0.04857533052563667,
-0.3549792766571045,
0.493665874004364,
-0.3325935900211334,
0.17145825922489166,
-0.3359483778476715,
0.05836512893438339,
-0.23576578497886658,
0.7196156978607178,
0.31746456027030945,
0.7198154330253601,
0.47382593154907227,
-0.3178686499595642,
0.11201400309801102,
0.0360758900642395,
-0.09905095398426056,
0.35083040595054626,
-0.6310611367225647,
0.4032295346260071,
-0.1857432872056961,
0.4102118909358978,
-0.6042391061782837,
-0.16014854609966278,
0.48901382088661194,
0.09042701870203018,
0.6231718063354492,
-0.36190342903137207,
-0.22454477846622467,
-0.23492494225502014,
-0.5223895311355591,
0.5419688820838928,
0.4605933427810669,
-0.4538467228412628,
0.41492322087287903,
0.6480018496513367,
-0.2223636656999588,
-1.0421358346939087,
-0.32090574502944946,
-0.24298135936260223,
-0.3881669342517853,
-0.6473252773284912,
0.16661565005779266,
-0.1544179469347,
-0.21529707312583923,
-0.27150580286979675,
-0.36188066005706787,
0.035382818430662155,
0.1391943097114563,
0.34920114278793335,
0.5517535209655762,
-0.008598977699875832,
0.11773522198200226,
0.28533050417900085,
-0.307266503572464,
-0.24789975583553314,
-0.35737425088882446,
0.39295724034309387,
-0.2689193785190582,
-0.20522440969944,
-0.569056510925293,
0.5382794737815857,
0.46845483779907227,
-0.19385793805122375,
0.7750287652015686,
0.19023770093917847,
-0.2624678909778595,
-0.09143132716417313,
-0.4501218795776367,
-0.2681944966316223,
-0.5007228851318359,
0.41328704357147217,
-0.24443332850933075,
-0.9409314393997192,
0.1652212142944336,
0.017505988478660583,
0.3814372420310974,
0.016267435625195503,
0.45954105257987976,
-0.011614318005740643,
1.0151537656784058,
0.6478087902069092,
-0.1979217231273651,
0.4226774573326111,
0.0741477832198143,
0.40238457918167114,
-0.47643446922302246,
-0.023778634145855904,
-0.48682230710983276,
-0.2940273880958557,
-0.38646793365478516,
-0.27154603600502014,
0.6498966217041016,
0.23021532595157623,
-0.393978476524353,
0.27970728278160095,
-0.4694889187812805,
0.60035640001297,
0.5019415616989136,
0.23007233440876007,
0.15128883719444275,
-0.053152039647102356,
-0.39307141304016113,
-0.037345901131629944,
-0.5432547926902771,
-0.5853129625320435,
1.1073541641235352,
0.37577369809150696,
1.028043508529663,
0.21645337343215942,
0.8328079581260681,
-0.10631109774112701,
0.216718852519989,
-0.7285500764846802,
0.4813692271709442,
-0.24396507441997528,
-0.38707783818244934,
-0.504845380783081,
-0.4860917925834656,
-0.7827914357185364,
0.3668043315410614,
-0.45757532119750977,
-0.8074168562889099,
-0.08868584036827087,
0.6005671620368958,
-0.7614933252334595,
0.25525227189064026,
-0.5695239305496216,
0.9733082056045532,
-0.8340322375297546,
-0.5161459445953369,
-0.34880271553993225,
-0.8588628172874451,
0.4075203835964203,
-0.020159564912319183,
0.1701378971338272,
-0.3297525644302368,
-0.2051624357700348,
0.5680218935012817,
-0.44898390769958496,
0.9414951205253601,
-0.2590232789516449,
-0.34172266721725464,
-0.02200663834810257,
-0.05847439169883728,
0.7462166547775269,
-0.05611156299710274,
0.11626805365085602,
-0.14252786338329315,
0.14211471378803253,
-0.34578731656074524,
-0.5298438668251038,
0.7607406377792358,
-0.7924069166183472,
-0.7542428970336914,
-0.5494736433029175,
-0.6237108707427979,
-0.5858690142631531,
0.20271070301532745,
0.06469472497701645,
0.28401267528533936,
-0.34352907538414,
-0.06866413354873657,
0.6953328251838684,
-0.2466997504234314,
0.4739990532398224,
0.3587897717952728,
-0.31356891989707947,
-0.46469175815582275,
0.5524951219558716,
-0.13678091764450073,
0.49636110663414,
0.35104334354400635,
0.3512091040611267,
-0.47552818059921265,
-0.4973979592323303,
-0.31344571709632874,
0.4234510660171509,
-0.4459175765514374,
-0.11767815798521042,
-0.4107723832130432,
-0.1338479071855545,
-0.43760383129119873,
-0.43815505504608154,
-0.5691637992858887,
-0.5761325359344482,
-0.09473951905965805,
-0.10400636494159698,
-0.07048948109149933,
0.28917911648750305,
-0.31565648317337036,
0.13533276319503784,
-0.6670867800712585,
-0.07059450447559357,
0.39316684007644653,
0.4037422835826874,
-0.29489192366600037,
-0.34825319051742554,
-0.08470699936151505,
0.011598682962357998,
-0.3093658685684204,
-0.5558091402053833,
0.06333260238170624,
0.04079132154583931,
0.4233444631099701,
0.6587417721748352,
0.3244346082210541,
0.43094727396965027,
-0.4447226822376251,
0.24708904325962067,
0.7011717557907104,
-0.5744932889938354,
0.4350982904434204,
-0.413165807723999,
0.08362627029418945,
0.8459774255752563,
0.33696258068084717,
-0.6070200204849243,
0.1296965628862381,
-0.04940469190478325,
-0.5710000395774841,
0.6464758515357971,
-0.08025701344013214,
0.0313974991440773,
0.36096319556236267,
0.25950387120246887,
0.09788695722818375,
0.010988175868988037,
-0.7671300172805786,
-0.08384937047958374,
0.06975501775741577,
-0.2654050588607788,
0.0002891833137255162,
-0.22427381575107574,
-0.5667046308517456,
-0.017800047993659973,
0.8736008405685425,
-0.3667101263999939,
-0.25177496671676636,
-0.27733078598976135,
0.05234542861580849,
-0.30540788173675537,
0.485835999250412,
0.8835113644599915,
0.3754730224609375,
-0.29948732256889343,
0.05131341889500618,
-0.04542100057005882,
-0.272920161485672,
0.4426407516002655,
0.10899589210748672,
-0.27003857493400574,
-0.5106646418571472,
-0.07969627529382706,
0.789121150970459,
0.4831721782684326,
-0.7882121205329895,
0.5997858643531799,
0.11487220972776413,
-0.1374831348657608,
-0.18508599698543549,
0.19913797080516815,
-0.09587903320789337,
0.1921200156211853,
-0.04839489609003067,
-0.11189461499452591,
-0.3243127763271332,
-0.37209662795066833,
0.051880113780498505,
0.7796980142593384,
-0.35865455865859985,
-0.3693505525588989,
0.4684397280216217,
0.45564204454421997,
-0.2965547740459442,
0.36801567673683167,
-0.025577407330274582,
-0.6006612181663513,
0.336405485868454,
0.3564562499523163,
1.030968427658081,
-0.11256283521652222,
0.19833464920520782,
0.5283380150794983,
0.3858303725719452,
-0.29955756664276123,
-0.02000480890274048,
0.030849456787109375,
-0.9464564919471741,
-0.30611738562583923,
-0.5907227396965027,
-0.4396747946739197,
-0.1721530556678772,
-0.5563125610351562,
0.17198358476161957,
-0.6671390533447266,
-0.34159398078918457,
-0.23047326505184174,
-0.0012379937106743455,
-0.26867538690567017,
-0.2263438105583191,
0.2550557255744934,
0.2777392268180847,
-0.7506577372550964,
1.1095528602600098,
0.48580101132392883,
-0.36998069286346436,
-0.6933966279029846,
0.08990895748138428,
0.36142221093177795,
-0.6524645686149597,
0.23567456007003784,
0.05133773386478424,
-0.3385770618915558,
-0.3677598834037781,
-0.4688164293766022,
-0.854011058807373,
0.8228662014007568,
0.5973271131515503,
-0.944015383720398,
-0.40861716866493225,
0.09084350615739822,
0.2511162757873535,
-0.163489431142807,
-0.2562375068664551,
0.6585096716880798,
0.5302907228469849,
0.06146402284502983,
-1.2328486442565918,
-0.015082678757607937,
0.2581157982349396,
0.004888450261205435,
0.7109153866767883,
-0.9252801537513733,
0.23805664479732513,
-0.41856759786605835,
-0.43132704496383667,
0.05158060044050217,
0.5747568607330322,
0.2877601683139801,
0.025048259645700455,
0.7633621096611023,
0.7364854216575623,
0.7536567449569702,
0.11937915533781052,
0.8122312426567078,
0.019534239545464516,
0.5313512086868286,
1.4081463813781738,
-0.4704054594039917,
0.7574335336685181,
0.7127267122268677,
-0.3904186487197876,
0.32620954513549805,
0.4698662757873535,
0.46903231739997864,
0.7486080527305603,
0.19464915990829468,
-0.5176613926887512,
-0.48098188638687134,
-0.1576562076807022,
-0.2157975733280182,
0.2280038595199585,
0.1428554356098175,
0.01968873105943203,
-0.2812982499599457,
-0.13569900393486023,
0.3985917568206787,
0.3069685101509094,
-0.09627241641283035,
0.6533151268959045,
0.0703037679195404,
-0.9482571482658386,
0.6761162877082825,
-0.08292889595031738,
0.852914571762085,
-0.7537209987640381,
0.25697463750839233,
-0.10491928458213806,
0.25949227809906006,
-0.07208305597305298,
-0.57025545835495,
0.22329644858837128,
-0.1367797702550888,
-0.09823682904243469,
-0.27741730213165283,
0.44613271951675415,
-0.7747833132743835,
-0.2391948103904724,
0.29410749673843384,
-0.032329291105270386,
-0.2867855131626129,
0.27883651852607727,
-0.7475418448448181,
0.10497546195983887,
0.09074810892343521,
-0.13806907832622528,
0.5405613780021667,
-0.238624706864357,
-0.12848718464374542,
0.4865703582763672,
0.5307143926620483,
-0.03173479437828064,
0.014748374931514263,
-0.1933550238609314,
0.7116910219192505,
-0.4242008328437805,
-0.5726730227470398,
-0.5826961398124695,
0.4973287582397461,
0.016703244298696518,
-0.18618416786193848,
0.12281342595815659,
0.29524242877960205,
0.7034080028533936,
0.09174762666225433,
0.823456346988678,
0.11699745059013367,
0.3080821931362152,
-0.7741339206695557,
0.5479050278663635,
-0.5303259491920471,
0.10974615067243576,
0.06958885490894318,
-0.7982705235481262,
-0.5508042573928833,
0.5751275420188904,
-0.46293410658836365,
-0.1297043263912201,
0.6347485780715942,
1.2504515647888184,
-0.12543317675590515,
-0.4216204285621643,
0.38565006852149963,
-0.06813278794288635,
0.24938717484474182,
0.9020529985427856,
0.6419968008995056,
0.02046651393175125,
0.5378494262695312,
-0.5417100191116333,
-0.4012185335159302,
-0.087944895029068,
-1.0483648777008057,
-0.9509342908859253,
-0.3940119743347168,
-0.5033559799194336,
-0.4307200014591217,
0.1613909900188446,
1.40053129196167,
0.8928253650665283,
-0.9455426931381226,
-0.240357905626297,
0.19913427531719208,
0.052248645573854446,
0.055631984025239944,
-0.14349453151226044,
0.4610403776168823,
-0.25896814465522766,
-0.6628697514533997,
0.5688179135322571,
0.6464234590530396,
0.12024886161088943,
-0.2674691081047058,
-0.38662365078926086,
-0.2394525408744812,
0.16567695140838623,
0.023209575563669205,
0.8973758816719055,
-0.8530032634735107,
-0.576505720615387,
-0.45054391026496887,
-0.26397037506103516,
0.16139018535614014,
0.9461420178413391,
-0.3294813334941864,
0.5098168849945068,
0.24584706127643585,
0.7573283910751343,
0.329433411359787,
0.19523809850215912,
0.7549018859863281,
-0.6616239547729492,
0.4932154417037964,
0.2985604405403137,
0.32213807106018066,
0.25194215774536133,
-0.37617582082748413,
0.5516293048858643,
0.002098522149026394,
-0.740383505821228,
-0.8266915082931519,
0.4743002951145172,
-1.0542851686477661,
-0.012875441461801529,
1.1020468473434448,
-0.1157955527305603,
-0.08065890520811081,
0.01453697495162487,
-0.21178507804870605,
0.11721403151750565,
-0.48458778858184814,
0.6551467776298523,
0.3661673069000244,
-0.05931074544787407,
-0.09019457548856735,
-0.0668434128165245,
0.6173922419548035,
0.6377251744270325,
-0.7797978520393372,
0.02788008563220501,
0.6232872009277344,
0.23881909251213074,
-0.1010841429233551,
0.5637751221656799,
0.003545910818502307,
0.28544917702674866,
-0.41710200905799866,
0.08760548382997513,
0.15912115573883057,
-0.3192107677459717,
-0.6026387214660645,
0.05853390693664551,
0.14080259203910828,
-0.23187923431396484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19538v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19538v2
|
CheXpert Plus: Augmenting a Large Chest X-ray Dataset with Text Radiology Reports, Patient Demographics and Additional Image Formats
| 2024-05-29T21:48:56 | 2024-06-03T19:14:12 |
Pierre Chambon, Jean-Benoit Delbrouck, Thomas Sounack, Shih-Cheng Huang, Zhihong Chen, Maya Varma, Steven QH Truong, Chu The Chuong, Curtis P. Langlotz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Since the release of the original CheXpert paper five years ago, CheXpert has
become one of the most widely used and cited clinical AI datasets. The
emergence of vision language models has sparked an increase in demands for
sharing reports linked to CheXpert images, along with a growing interest among
AI fairness researchers in obtaining demographic data. To address this,
CheXpert Plus serves as a new collection of radiology data sources, made
publicly available to enhance the scaling, performance, robustness, and
fairness of models for all subsequent machine learning tasks in the field of
radiology. CheXpert Plus is the largest text dataset publicly released in
radiology, with a total of 36 million text tokens, including 13 million
impression tokens. To the best of our knowledge, it represents the largest text
de-identification effort in radiology, with almost 1 million PHI spans
anonymized. It is only the second time that a large-scale English paired
dataset has been released in radiology, thereby enabling, for the first time,
cross-institution training at scale. All reports are paired with high-quality
images in DICOM format, along with numerous image and patient metadata covering
various clinical and socio-economic groups, as well as many pathology labels
and RadGraph annotations. We hope this dataset will boost research for AI
models that can further assist radiologists and help improve medical care. Data
is available at the following URL:
https://stanfordaimi.azurewebsites.net/datasets/5158c524-d3ab-4e02-96e9-6ee9efc110a1
Models are available at the following URL:
https://github.com/Stanford-AIMI/chexpert-plus
|
[
-0.18888133764266968,
0.0009665442630648613,
0.750584602355957,
0.055287063121795654,
-0.029938960447907448,
-0.07970262318849564,
0.18742305040359497,
-0.8173916935920715,
0.07768000662326813,
0.6973113417625427,
-0.4284772574901581,
-0.35159674286842346,
-0.8554146885871887,
-0.052785564213991165,
-0.6176487803459167,
1.0546808242797852,
0.2735617458820343,
0.3646855354309082,
-0.32193723320961,
-0.12586398422718048,
-0.39712390303611755,
-0.7373939156532288,
-0.9558844566345215,
-0.3813178539276123,
0.60277259349823,
0.20638000965118408,
1.3081921339035034,
0.9700042605400085,
0.6180884838104248,
0.24197661876678467,
0.2880486845970154,
-0.15886983275413513,
-0.03281272575259209,
-0.06238337233662605,
-0.14444316923618317,
-0.3002362847328186,
-0.7657395005226135,
-0.03755848482251167,
0.5027406215667725,
0.7875427007675171,
0.1279774159193039,
-0.3708990812301636,
-0.3868390619754791,
0.6688575148582458,
-0.4605300724506378,
0.22571498155593872,
-0.065414197742939,
0.0710529088973999,
-0.2579021155834198,
-0.1242295429110527,
-0.22810596227645874,
-0.2678092122077942,
0.49699416756629944,
-0.5887783765792847,
0.12431947141885757,
-0.16411460936069489,
0.6374921798706055,
0.07795312255620956,
-0.6896356344223022,
-0.4511306881904602,
-0.3485158383846283,
0.6592699885368347,
-0.17279896140098572,
0.6510287523269653,
0.30012306571006775,
0.39506828784942627,
0.33133694529533386,
-1.0764713287353516,
-0.200896218419075,
-0.4677639305591583,
-0.43641653656959534,
0.3439807593822479,
-0.19297538697719574,
-0.09966853260993958,
0.061080917716026306,
0.44405925273895264,
-0.9115058779716492,
-0.0009403123403899372,
-0.32410264015197754,
-0.1948566436767578,
0.839707612991333,
0.1993233561515808,
0.3588193953037262,
-0.068728506565094,
-0.5731378197669983,
-0.5750336050987244,
-0.4041077792644501,
-0.5052725672721863,
-0.19071198999881744,
0.11639604717493057,
-0.17204558849334717,
0.3406916856765747,
-0.2556077241897583,
0.664150059223175,
-0.2039787769317627,
0.3403760492801666,
0.6905350685119629,
-0.23290789127349854,
-0.19603893160820007,
0.5834057331085205,
0.5615101456642151,
0.032200075685977936,
-0.062070440500974655,
0.17557819187641144,
0.08028846979141235,
0.25501975417137146,
0.014778031967580318,
-0.6626851558685303,
-0.44244563579559326,
0.49421074986457825,
-0.5013485550880432,
-0.4100806415081024,
0.28038260340690613,
-0.6838255524635315,
-0.8323670029640198,
-0.5634500980377197,
0.29735806584358215,
-0.553900420665741,
-0.3036046624183655,
0.5649435520172119,
-0.22506345808506012,
-0.039871539920568466,
0.561830461025238,
-0.15194439888000488,
0.5758283138275146,
0.6542590856552124,
0.6071199178695679,
-0.035390306264162064,
-0.23799388110637665,
-0.7998305559158325,
0.04909559339284897,
-0.13457201421260834,
0.6962313055992126,
-0.8271329402923584,
-0.37236225605010986,
-0.16078245639801025,
0.14465707540512085,
0.06452775746583939,
-0.5750498175621033,
0.4672833979129791,
-0.313419908285141,
0.3568384051322937,
-0.2771465480327606,
-0.2489878386259079,
-0.15501224994659424,
0.2262350469827652,
-0.9103232026100159,
0.9055398106575012,
0.27013862133026123,
-0.5648959875106812,
0.2343437671661377,
-0.7561326026916504,
-0.2807876765727997,
0.3550278842449188,
-0.33158400654792786,
-0.3625398278236389,
0.043920546770095825,
0.2958742678165436,
0.5139356851577759,
-0.5704538822174072,
0.2905515730381012,
0.0005986830801703036,
-0.03403659537434578,
0.5283119082450867,
-0.30678561329841614,
1.0775246620178223,
0.3261796832084656,
-0.0473441556096077,
-0.07508835196495056,
-0.972718358039856,
0.12121019512414932,
-0.022131536155939102,
0.05261971428990364,
-0.38212376832962036,
-0.2631959319114685,
0.3541613519191742,
0.574059009552002,
0.17132742702960968,
-0.6872255206108093,
-0.06837992370128632,
0.1223590224981308,
0.2156286984682083,
0.47291961312294006,
-0.09252955764532089,
-0.03203717991709709,
-0.6689189672470093,
0.5156956911087036,
0.05126045644283295,
0.5253874063491821,
-0.4311513602733612,
-0.41237738728523254,
-0.46996909379959106,
-0.8141523599624634,
0.138586163520813,
0.5984746217727661,
-0.414418488740921,
0.03419416397809982,
-0.3753603398799896,
-0.5701314806938171,
-0.5703816413879395,
-0.3473750352859497,
0.4162738621234894,
0.30328404903411865,
0.34998852014541626,
-0.5018545985221863,
-0.608248233795166,
-0.9016380310058594,
0.13044126331806183,
0.1732502430677414,
-0.2637309730052948,
0.4918922781944275,
0.3137601613998413,
-0.5132469534873962,
0.5257220268249512,
-0.8237254023551941,
-0.32048699259757996,
-0.07966239750385284,
0.13028329610824585,
0.04656723514199257,
0.448088139295578,
0.3832017481327057,
-1.011836290359497,
-0.6663273572921753,
0.3878747522830963,
-0.8122779726982117,
0.05854159593582153,
-0.2428436279296875,
-0.12029097229242325,
-0.06047677993774414,
0.44566628336906433,
-0.14367830753326416,
0.2517978549003601,
0.730413019657135,
-0.3692881762981415,
0.16349317133426666,
-0.2361902892589569,
0.3285752534866333,
-0.9683294296264648,
0.257351815700531,
0.28934797644615173,
-0.6928815841674805,
-0.49364838004112244,
0.162149578332901,
0.2785550653934479,
-0.6201712489128113,
-0.5232030153274536,
0.4330708980560303,
-0.42929449677467346,
0.2624265253543854,
-0.04717746376991272,
-0.1907636672258377,
0.12967364490032196,
0.049472685903310776,
0.6155645251274109,
0.25412261486053467,
0.8803470730781555,
-0.29713618755340576,
0.5362665057182312,
0.2428465485572815,
-0.16265127062797546,
0.6234725117683411,
-0.7050572037696838,
0.2207663506269455,
-0.2777553200721741,
0.549370527267456,
-0.46199241280555725,
-0.40733450651168823,
0.02084205485880375,
-0.3304045498371124,
0.3527293801307678,
0.23589859902858734,
-0.3904981315135956,
-0.0978384017944336,
-0.5173516273498535,
0.5672935247421265,
0.291325181722641,
-0.5309708714485168,
0.3266288638114929,
0.46369844675064087,
-0.3154151737689972,
-0.3725987672805786,
-0.6897429823875427,
0.3341939449310303,
0.2843451499938965,
-0.5190951824188232,
0.37199267745018005,
-0.13596946001052856,
-0.14899830520153046,
0.23251476883888245,
0.26493901014328003,
-0.5106997489929199,
-0.3955005705356598,
0.2990535795688629,
0.3739016056060791,
0.0935804545879364,
0.20389138162136078,
-0.2242979109287262,
-0.5640662908554077,
-0.027362577617168427,
-0.30626004934310913,
0.6666789054870605,
0.03715319558978081,
-0.2706407904624939,
-0.6045717597007751,
0.6377566456794739,
0.6026249527931213,
-0.09644056111574173,
0.49012041091918945,
0.35491418838500977,
-0.3625156879425049,
0.22585254907608032,
-0.4805231988430023,
-0.06797514110803604,
-0.35181373357772827,
0.6302919387817383,
-0.08434311300516129,
-0.748827338218689,
0.2194433957338333,
0.07130002975463867,
-0.2249690741300583,
0.438109427690506,
0.4004737138748169,
0.19515971839427948,
1.0571560859680176,
0.5469975471496582,
-0.17189356684684753,
0.16488976776599884,
-0.12157896161079407,
-0.17475304007530212,
-0.4660947024822235,
-0.5442919731140137,
-0.610124409198761,
-0.046167947351932526,
-0.7191867232322693,
-0.2629072666168213,
0.49980828166007996,
-0.9805867671966553,
-0.17928101122379303,
0.16054394841194153,
-0.757722020149231,
0.4834635257720947,
0.5392722487449646,
0.5620237588882446,
0.5098916888237,
-0.011835395358502865,
0.6162582039833069,
-0.11571992933750153,
-0.48959067463874817,
0.12137878686189651,
1.231358289718628,
0.17989620566368103,
0.6725919842720032,
-0.08760136365890503,
0.5727543830871582,
0.46780896186828613,
0.05417811498045921,
-0.5470932126045227,
0.288053959608078,
-0.5963985323905945,
-0.8188261389732361,
0.12451189011335373,
-0.411981463432312,
-1.014127492904663,
-0.34758949279785156,
-0.18664124608039856,
-0.2839919924736023,
0.5861198306083679,
0.007477287203073502,
-0.33234450221061707,
0.007032548543065786,
-0.4524767994880676,
0.5969642996788025,
-0.3262830972671509,
-0.37077751755714417,
-0.18897995352745056,
-0.8781886100769043,
0.2397993803024292,
-0.4692646861076355,
0.1856805831193924,
0.20322364568710327,
-0.29456827044487,
0.4040689766407013,
-0.6868350505828857,
0.6276841759681702,
0.13114839792251587,
0.008160329423844814,
-0.010806780308485031,
-0.16598454117774963,
0.29364776611328125,
0.17778946459293365,
-0.16525232791900635,
0.4518488347530365,
0.2359415888786316,
-0.45563769340515137,
-0.48276594281196594,
0.941462516784668,
-1.0475969314575195,
-0.04292774572968483,
-0.9824708104133606,
-0.7940765619277954,
0.13183170557022095,
-0.028969455510377884,
0.2856931686401367,
0.9997299909591675,
0.20625615119934082,
0.3257308602333069,
0.6874911189079285,
-0.5073298811912537,
-0.24467022716999054,
0.33977341651916504,
0.02950180694460869,
-0.5763952732086182,
1.2302472591400146,
0.3353780508041382,
0.15226875245571136,
0.6660452485084534,
0.15751847624778748,
-0.2387435883283615,
-0.11834980547428131,
0.20459656417369843,
0.20213381946086884,
-0.5976428389549255,
-0.18489284813404083,
-0.711240291595459,
-0.5627599358558655,
-0.40774005651474,
-0.4130841791629791,
-0.41219884157180786,
-0.6003384590148926,
0.18364956974983215,
0.11397174745798111,
0.5181019306182861,
0.7080291509628296,
-0.19477339088916779,
0.33268338441848755,
-0.8323808312416077,
0.08693323284387589,
0.31519827246665955,
0.23521259427070618,
-0.2724311649799347,
-0.10552359372377396,
-0.2807033061981201,
-0.2595340311527252,
-0.019041985273361206,
-0.7228459119796753,
0.43065449595451355,
0.002458761679008603,
0.19966940581798553,
0.20371530950069427,
-0.018139058724045753,
0.5957977771759033,
-0.0785834938287735,
0.5411925315856934,
0.29853156208992004,
-0.7745504379272461,
0.4353663921356201,
-0.3820110261440277,
0.43235471844673157,
0.45049405097961426,
0.6343890428543091,
-0.7886484265327454,
-0.0918654277920723,
-0.830003559589386,
-0.9459196925163269,
0.9008340239524841,
0.2509928047657013,
0.1139337345957756,
-0.07374445348978043,
0.4619443416595459,
0.42150408029556274,
-0.03229394182562828,
-0.6166254878044128,
-0.2797412574291229,
-0.2728903591632843,
-0.36728325486183167,
-0.13156180083751678,
-0.33428898453712463,
-0.0940270647406578,
-0.22786439955234528,
0.8321266174316406,
0.20846927165985107,
0.26399391889572144,
0.4117638170719147,
-0.14391069114208221,
0.23150408267974854,
0.06315730512142181,
0.30270707607269287,
0.5741386413574219,
-0.33290866017341614,
0.24007172882556915,
-0.17106251418590546,
-0.8588350415229797,
0.02129119075834751,
0.4288244843482971,
0.11825456470251083,
0.020776931196451187,
0.38744983077049255,
0.3724139630794525,
-0.01244437973946333,
-0.8221738934516907,
0.4474411904811859,
-0.2805473506450653,
-0.27809396386146545,
-0.387727290391922,
-0.034584417939186096,
-0.42968809604644775,
0.22515282034873962,
0.3297877609729767,
0.30751755833625793,
0.4561484754085541,
-0.45136523246765137,
0.5358591675758362,
0.14492079615592957,
-0.8839725255966187,
-0.1481533944606781,
0.638266921043396,
0.148267462849617,
0.18028125166893005,
0.800570011138916,
0.18152539432048798,
-0.12467269599437714,
0.6989114880561829,
0.22167213261127472,
0.6490105986595154,
-0.2941984236240387,
0.44200754165649414,
0.4809567630290985,
0.2122039794921875,
-0.10960929840803146,
0.07306624203920364,
0.20159085094928741,
-0.4838406443595886,
-0.41668596863746643,
-0.004414165858179331,
-0.47131773829460144,
0.35836493968963623,
-0.8108786940574646,
0.5486846566200256,
-0.5285154581069946,
0.014471727423369884,
0.011381901800632477,
0.3575783669948578,
-0.673392653465271,
0.6418383717536926,
0.2809039354324341,
0.8520428538322449,
-0.9662357568740845,
0.9165174961090088,
0.7555187344551086,
-0.2934627830982208,
-0.5079805254936218,
-0.22781330347061157,
0.2690989077091217,
-0.9689750075340271,
0.43956124782562256,
0.12835584580898285,
0.17521721124649048,
0.12271163612604141,
-0.4165153205394745,
-0.8685516119003296,
1.004880666732788,
0.43740934133529663,
-0.5278657078742981,
0.22703829407691956,
0.32100558280944824,
0.17335136234760284,
-0.18878290057182312,
0.3942398726940155,
0.5345916152000427,
0.4858444929122925,
0.3530469834804535,
-0.6160544157028198,
0.3783130943775177,
-0.40350639820098877,
-0.14062190055847168,
0.116097591817379,
-0.5782729983329773,
0.985382080078125,
0.034738197922706604,
-0.055317092686891556,
-0.014651908539235592,
0.09574584662914276,
0.15764757990837097,
0.32475370168685913,
0.2871180772781372,
0.6211334466934204,
0.7227815389633179,
-0.03995061293244362,
1.5960248708724976,
-0.03507662191987038,
0.0719478651881218,
1.174846887588501,
-0.41107088327407837,
0.40036559104919434,
0.04167292267084122,
-0.0797605887055397,
0.47946009039878845,
0.5287341475486755,
-0.14138604700565338,
0.38294854760169983,
-0.35980314016342163,
-0.4059123694896698,
-0.34470343589782715,
-0.49260568618774414,
-0.7527474761009216,
0.29053887724876404,
0.19741204380989075,
-0.49724310636520386,
-0.25129517912864685,
0.16449296474456787,
0.3203124701976776,
-0.20630742609500885,
-0.2706579566001892,
0.731723427772522,
-0.14719030261039734,
-0.19118763506412506,
0.17479641735553741,
-0.2681472897529602,
0.29342082142829895,
-1.0499780178070068,
-0.04038706421852112,
-0.21388883888721466,
0.4110766053199768,
-0.6096997261047363,
-0.7187892198562622,
0.24590013921260834,
-0.11976861208677292,
-0.12586095929145813,
0.011941377073526382,
0.5167145729064941,
-0.3530096411705017,
-0.816864550113678,
0.2507500648498535,
0.3043442964553833,
0.26425182819366455,
-0.1888481080532074,
-0.6781631112098694,
0.39554640650749207,
0.01961885765194893,
0.03493017330765724,
0.5271599888801575,
0.3859919309616089,
-0.2852415442466736,
0.4860823452472687,
0.5370821952819824,
0.15546295046806335,
-0.3011670708656311,
-0.03638257458806038,
1.0214499235153198,
-0.3936660587787628,
-0.2349511682987213,
-0.7431631684303284,
0.6680154204368591,
-0.26409125328063965,
-0.19633975625038147,
0.5788902044296265,
0.851804256439209,
0.8130024671554565,
0.20674526691436768,
0.9914679527282715,
-0.00020606610632967204,
0.25417977571487427,
-0.30060940980911255,
0.6960228085517883,
-0.7167353630065918,
-0.04123752564191818,
-0.311075359582901,
-0.6375772356987,
-0.817034900188446,
0.36653777956962585,
-0.15209917724132538,
0.14809294044971466,
0.830405592918396,
0.7697166204452515,
-0.14239513874053955,
0.05581270530819893,
0.38412126898765564,
0.2724921405315399,
0.38306838274002075,
0.5683795213699341,
0.5512545108795166,
-0.5576854944229126,
0.648187518119812,
-0.3761464059352875,
-0.6615797877311707,
-0.08795188367366791,
-0.7220463752746582,
-0.4124908745288849,
-0.576568603515625,
-0.7978762984275818,
-0.2307949960231781,
0.23354683816432953,
0.8874673247337341,
1.0278280973434448,
-0.6315644979476929,
-0.2492683380842209,
0.11833670735359192,
-0.4331062138080597,
-0.3852587342262268,
-0.20548783242702484,
0.7046884894371033,
-0.11556506901979446,
-0.7750803828239441,
0.10607446730136871,
0.3184470236301422,
-0.14110784232616425,
0.08770909160375595,
-0.16305869817733765,
0.0036736982874572277,
0.007012965623289347,
0.6510103344917297,
0.23436254262924194,
0.07204577326774597,
-0.05889643728733063,
-0.02740577608346939,
-0.14391113817691803,
0.2874220907688141,
0.8420895338058472,
-0.9911669492721558,
0.7452346086502075,
0.3079817295074463,
0.47201067209243774,
0.5584357976913452,
-0.2907472550868988,
0.5175233483314514,
-0.6042172312736511,
0.4742375612258911,
0.29357752203941345,
0.21723587810993195,
0.3765157461166382,
-0.6869979500770569,
0.512921154499054,
0.10474728792905807,
-0.482624888420105,
-0.7402727007865906,
0.12744714319705963,
-1.160336971282959,
-0.4978681802749634,
0.7240127921104431,
0.16454213857650757,
-0.04151350259780884,
-0.14984674751758575,
-0.4530114531517029,
0.09908901154994965,
-0.6382713317871094,
0.6116926670074463,
0.2733124792575836,
-0.3010668456554413,
-0.45723462104797363,
-0.483932763338089,
0.3848114013671875,
0.14897550642490387,
-1.1113256216049194,
-0.09360215812921524,
0.6578351259231567,
0.08206462860107422,
0.08421434462070465,
0.8018651604652405,
-0.5830115675926208,
0.6008331179618835,
-0.06602630019187927,
0.042553503066301346,
-0.3456692397594452,
-0.432448148727417,
-0.3301599621772766,
0.28697913885116577,
-0.1347220242023468,
-0.11235691606998444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19534v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19534v1
|
Preference Learning Algorithms Do Not Learn Preference Rankings
| 2024-05-29T21:29:44 | 2024-05-29T21:29:44 |
Angelica Chen, Sadhika Malladi, Lily H. Zhang, Xinyi Chen, Qiuyi Zhang, Rajesh Ranganath, Kyunghyun Cho
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Preference learning algorithms (e.g., RLHF and DPO) are frequently used to
steer LLMs to produce generations that are more preferred by humans, but our
understanding of their inner workings is still limited. In this work, we study
the conventional wisdom that preference learning trains models to assign higher
likelihoods to more preferred outputs than less preferred outputs, measured via
$\textit{ranking accuracy}$. Surprisingly, we find that most state-of-the-art
preference-tuned models achieve a ranking accuracy of less than 60% on common
preference datasets. We furthermore derive the $\textit{idealized ranking
accuracy}$ that a preference-tuned LLM would achieve if it optimized the DPO or
RLHF objective perfectly. We demonstrate that existing models exhibit a
significant $\textit{alignment gap}$ -- $\textit{i.e.}$, a gap between the
observed and idealized ranking accuracies. We attribute this discrepancy to the
DPO objective, which is empirically and theoretically ill-suited to fix even
mild ranking errors in the reference model, and derive a simple and efficient
formula for quantifying the difficulty of learning a given preference
datapoint. Finally, we demonstrate that ranking accuracy strongly correlates
with the empirically popular win rate metric when the model is close to the
reference model used in the objective, shedding further light on the
differences between on-policy (e.g., RLHF) and off-policy (e.g., DPO)
preference learning algorithms.
|
[
-0.2772333323955536,
-0.2107919156551361,
0.8542746305465698,
-0.3779354393482208,
-0.2111889272928238,
0.17073048651218414,
-0.16609837114810944,
-0.4072894752025604,
0.11671427637338638,
0.16293823719024658,
-0.5339792966842651,
-0.38330793380737305,
-0.7758712768554688,
0.006466723512858152,
0.280242383480072,
1.0612902641296387,
0.332057923078537,
-0.07883074879646301,
-0.3344844579696655,
-0.04353451356291771,
-0.26401492953300476,
-0.54264897108078,
-0.37617239356040955,
-0.7723302245140076,
0.6286613941192627,
0.7788875699043274,
0.8858503699302673,
0.8365293741226196,
0.5757665038108826,
0.1789788454771042,
-0.11295433342456818,
0.48011162877082825,
-0.8804079294204712,
-0.08990560472011566,
0.0636134222149849,
-0.7218722701072693,
-0.4880746603012085,
0.5407362580299377,
0.3758924901485443,
0.727317750453949,
-0.14075228571891785,
-0.02930537611246109,
0.1476329118013382,
1.1526365280151367,
-0.7216447591781616,
0.2336524873971939,
-1.0019792318344116,
0.21524031460285187,
-0.2040143758058548,
-0.6048234105110168,
-0.5781980156898499,
-0.731695294380188,
0.311301589012146,
-0.6925637125968933,
0.2225639373064041,
0.38584646582603455,
0.9187511205673218,
0.42031368613243103,
-0.45135629177093506,
-0.38007351756095886,
-0.5162356495857239,
0.9934452772140503,
-0.46440771222114563,
0.29035669565200806,
0.5290879607200623,
0.18711049854755402,
-0.16659432649612427,
-0.17842720448970795,
-0.08419778198003769,
-0.4338725805282593,
0.19632773101329803,
0.20615848898887634,
0.26327988505363464,
0.16001173853874207,
0.12695452570915222,
0.40591511130332947,
-0.2355552613735199,
0.34919220209121704,
-0.27306628227233887,
0.13295984268188477,
0.7069564461708069,
-0.01875213533639908,
-0.4319816827774048,
-0.07495462149381638,
-0.5022377967834473,
-0.1927998811006546,
-0.7245607376098633,
0.3880713880062103,
0.5014798045158386,
0.31950920820236206,
0.09391675144433975,
0.4794597029685974,
-0.18681882321834564,
0.8386611342430115,
0.6232596635818481,
-0.39848092198371887,
0.1847895085811615,
0.3786851465702057,
-0.19810102880001068,
0.22940196096897125,
0.5161897540092468,
0.5812343955039978,
0.6126117706298828,
-0.3778911232948303,
-0.25262734293937683,
-0.09540411829948425,
0.3717677593231201,
-0.3613014817237854,
-0.35766318440437317,
0.008238736540079117,
-0.42956602573394775,
-0.5383298993110657,
0.2277708649635315,
-0.35680755972862244,
-0.3603942394256592,
-0.3132888078689575,
0.4999593198299408,
-0.057304415851831436,
0.14791780710220337,
0.03730513155460358,
-0.1670127809047699,
0.3032674789428711,
0.2701583802700043,
-1.2247518301010132,
0.0718504786491394,
0.8678441047668457,
0.6892521977424622,
-0.5969676971435547,
-0.408933162689209,
-0.2831615209579468,
-0.29049065709114075,
-0.6922573447227478,
0.7274945974349976,
-0.6394683718681335,
-0.5798681974411011,
-0.14946086704730988,
-0.23350591957569122,
-0.2770532965660095,
-0.949779748916626,
0.44232988357543945,
-0.8968076705932617,
-0.04631481319665909,
-0.4520338773727417,
-0.8956090211868286,
-0.04720054194331169,
0.00851193442940712,
-0.4060697853565216,
0.7770130038261414,
-0.20405392348766327,
-0.5430834293365479,
0.9262878894805908,
-0.42659807205200195,
-0.2032192349433899,
-0.4507879614830017,
0.024476082995533943,
-0.5479288697242737,
0.3379448354244232,
-0.15253956615924835,
0.5221351385116577,
0.004756685346364975,
0.17536719143390656,
-0.7759339809417725,
-0.6146907806396484,
0.33677059412002563,
-0.37650570273399353,
0.48540782928466797,
0.10692489892244339,
-0.24658198654651642,
0.06498691439628601,
-0.4298042953014374,
-0.05273764953017235,
0.224493607878685,
-0.4800283908843994,
-0.3569599688053131,
0.21315638720989227,
-0.48513680696487427,
-0.04815615341067314,
0.3106878399848938,
-0.520663321018219,
0.46384546160697937,
-0.4075030982494354,
0.2991394102573395,
1.1532752513885498,
-0.39568600058555603,
0.6988919973373413,
-0.7669547200202942,
0.19332118332386017,
-0.20194214582443237,
0.0696849450469017,
0.5437610149383545,
-0.4850712716579437,
-0.8122729659080505,
0.30805230140686035,
0.3776143789291382,
0.39496996998786926,
-0.08829768002033234,
0.3865436017513275,
-0.4971882402896881,
-0.5690668821334839,
-0.5414946675300598,
0.20716416835784912,
0.15816697478294373,
0.7848766446113586,
0.2902885675430298,
-0.19060032069683075,
-0.1673397719860077,
-0.7977098822593689,
-0.20449192821979523,
-0.40995973348617554,
0.39625778794288635,
0.7026612162590027,
0.17232416570186615,
0.39351704716682434,
0.9499409794807434,
-0.67843097448349,
-0.2028939127922058,
-0.07718367129564285,
-0.10575727373361588,
0.18644239008426666,
0.1858200877904892,
0.5218812823295593,
-0.8185381889343262,
-0.4806559979915619,
-0.06496919691562653,
-0.6424457430839539,
0.09478417783975601,
0.3930288255214691,
0.005072661209851503,
0.12611044943332672,
0.07883232831954956,
-0.13479481637477875,
0.11849025636911392,
0.427228182554245,
-0.16414283215999603,
0.48919686675071716,
-0.2785714268684387,
0.2977059483528137,
-0.5254049301147461,
-0.17150811851024628,
0.07582280039787292,
-0.3297366797924042,
-0.34025201201438904,
-0.22868043184280396,
0.13615375757217407,
0.21717388927936554,
-0.5150875449180603,
0.3797004818916321,
-0.03709637373685837,
-0.32715871930122375,
-0.3642817437648773,
0.024176618084311485,
-0.04830457642674446,
0.6679821014404297,
0.4144890308380127,
0.8153038620948792,
0.21762467920780182,
-0.9434990882873535,
0.15420477092266083,
0.11003302037715912,
-0.21745865046977997,
0.5314605236053467,
-0.42648255825042725,
0.17219862341880798,
0.09739667922258377,
-0.15793146193027496,
-0.7717787623405457,
-0.1986425369977951,
0.1968238204717636,
-0.44100698828697205,
0.44991475343704224,
-0.4389774799346924,
0.1181812658905983,
-0.04925868660211563,
-0.29446783661842346,
0.23626409471035004,
0.7207427620887756,
-0.8386711478233337,
-0.27932578325271606,
0.43563058972358704,
0.1486591398715973,
-1.005899429321289,
-0.18403393030166626,
-0.5754794478416443,
-0.3604518473148346,
-0.264285147190094,
0.46270594000816345,
0.020798584446310997,
-0.19428005814552307,
-0.16547845304012299,
-0.32854175567626953,
-0.03698593005537987,
0.3660714030265808,
0.2772926092147827,
0.3860566020011902,
-0.03959944099187851,
0.34596678614616394,
-0.2316240519285202,
-0.28753262758255005,
-0.08370546996593475,
-0.13676467537879944,
0.16847126185894012,
-0.11099933832883835,
-0.4874531924724579,
-0.30010250210762024,
-0.25666552782058716,
0.6727656126022339,
0.03012532740831375,
0.5660523772239685,
-0.022815363481640816,
0.06941370666027069,
-0.18160979449748993,
-0.4364311993122101,
-0.3026004135608673,
-0.3913894593715668,
0.17374397814273834,
-0.43438562750816345,
-0.6847509145736694,
0.05495585501194,
-0.04774533212184906,
0.2520017921924591,
0.4696163237094879,
0.19780752062797546,
-0.4793064296245575,
1.1350733041763306,
0.6441307663917542,
-0.20482683181762695,
0.5645745396614075,
-0.1432536542415619,
-0.2423516809940338,
-0.8069486618041992,
-0.0618010051548481,
-0.36028075218200684,
-0.6034213900566101,
-0.9349633455276489,
0.03061981499195099,
0.4537932276725769,
0.04418358579277992,
-0.34328171610832214,
-0.11637631058692932,
-0.5738182663917542,
0.4897018074989319,
0.711424708366394,
0.26207634806632996,
0.4287382960319519,
0.2711641192436218,
-0.11509967595338821,
-0.3233998119831085,
-0.9523698687553406,
-0.3648536205291748,
1.434556484222412,
0.2685563564300537,
0.8607707023620605,
-0.1273767650127411,
0.9399356245994568,
0.5653467178344727,
0.21525613963603973,
-1.1537315845489502,
0.09619101136922836,
-0.35479119420051575,
-0.39531898498535156,
-0.37116000056266785,
-0.5330456495285034,
-0.9095033407211304,
0.3011667728424072,
-0.3517182469367981,
-0.2915383279323578,
0.4468218684196472,
0.674797773361206,
-0.291864275932312,
0.6267377734184265,
-0.4613851010799408,
0.6093688607215881,
-0.46183353662490845,
-0.5592082738876343,
-0.14780448377132416,
-0.5506215691566467,
0.2847765386104584,
0.1295774281024933,
-0.0005558422999456525,
-0.5016596913337708,
0.16610783338546753,
0.8846516609191895,
-0.26871344447135925,
0.4881376326084137,
-0.25896528363227844,
0.13362061977386475,
-0.0770760253071785,
-0.11458739638328552,
0.36715203523635864,
-0.14388111233711243,
-0.4571411609649658,
0.1969071626663208,
-0.2384594976902008,
-0.40600496530532837,
-0.3205062747001648,
0.7285442352294922,
-0.9716710448265076,
-0.6734873652458191,
-0.6606084108352661,
-0.0701756402850151,
-0.38283640146255493,
-0.07710496336221695,
0.4941903054714203,
0.2762141823768616,
-0.23643642663955688,
0.1943822056055069,
0.9045533537864685,
0.17240296304225922,
0.07156991213560104,
0.3957192897796631,
0.0246469397097826,
-0.1811232715845108,
0.9784771203994751,
0.2815074920654297,
0.4967041015625,
0.4587247371673584,
0.3180955648422241,
-0.5312752723693848,
-0.5343305468559265,
-0.4461974501609802,
0.24272486567497253,
-0.6615252494812012,
0.04492424800992012,
-0.16090816259384155,
-0.09729737788438797,
-0.15736281871795654,
-0.3051151633262634,
-0.5847949981689453,
-0.3751777112483978,
-0.3100001811981201,
-0.21075180172920227,
0.3771982491016388,
0.8147438764572144,
-0.1809244155883789,
0.09014080464839935,
-0.3055068254470825,
0.20343917608261108,
0.5425946116447449,
0.49911585450172424,
-0.05178311839699745,
-0.8099162578582764,
-0.13786305487155914,
0.08879876881837845,
-0.481821209192276,
-0.7120124697685242,
0.22335360944271088,
0.28655341267585754,
0.6094936728477478,
0.528985321521759,
0.16997019946575165,
0.5673977732658386,
-0.2912229001522064,
0.5206133127212524,
-0.04407522454857826,
-0.5798985958099365,
0.5272448062896729,
0.06833752244710922,
-0.035468533635139465,
0.7869791388511658,
0.43667611479759216,
-0.24877610802650452,
0.17451423406600952,
-0.57835453748703,
-0.4322182536125183,
0.8556169271469116,
-0.23493725061416626,
-0.17153823375701904,
0.04517524689435959,
0.6159115433692932,
0.4279439151287079,
0.40331804752349854,
-0.6972786784172058,
-0.7746474146842957,
-0.12236294150352478,
0.039251092821359634,
-0.48727577924728394,
-0.3046499788761139,
0.10134933888912201,
-0.0936325341463089,
0.9678547978401184,
-0.046532753854990005,
0.014783203601837158,
0.20301328599452972,
-0.07800369709730148,
-0.2533012926578522,
0.40445786714553833,
0.4752192795276642,
0.6888337135314941,
-0.7986831068992615,
0.010953258723020554,
-0.04653666913509369,
-0.16602101922035217,
0.44268473982810974,
-0.1449352204799652,
-0.4572371244430542,
-0.20402324199676514,
0.09062031656503677,
1.0829538106918335,
0.3285987377166748,
-0.310073584318161,
0.4574182629585266,
0.029985712841153145,
-0.3098222017288208,
-0.1313561648130417,
0.28012707829475403,
-0.09170396625995636,
-0.19055607914924622,
0.385498046875,
0.23170141875743866,
0.0804377868771553,
-0.4501172602176666,
0.015344948507845402,
0.7814725637435913,
-0.9687323570251465,
-0.04389798268675804,
0.706369936466217,
0.4763698875904083,
-0.2293280065059662,
0.5585900545120239,
-0.1115722805261612,
-0.4522831439971924,
0.6285759210586548,
0.2764962315559387,
0.6553258895874023,
0.008683618158102036,
0.29366564750671387,
0.11135666072368622,
0.1133979856967926,
-0.2625172734260559,
-0.1070789098739624,
-0.23300112783908844,
-0.8963619470596313,
0.03635095804929733,
-0.6922237277030945,
-0.7437003254890442,
0.003188889240846038,
-0.7857069969177246,
0.03814753517508507,
-0.4122892916202545,
-0.5060462355613708,
-0.042074669152498245,
0.2773889899253845,
-0.6833401918411255,
0.2244400680065155,
0.003354055806994438,
0.5787177681922913,
-0.7922329306602478,
0.5681657195091248,
0.7944877743721008,
0.007264107931405306,
-0.6291260719299316,
0.054161570966243744,
-0.08933670073747635,
-1.0252803564071655,
0.6297286152839661,
0.04964559152722359,
-0.29130494594573975,
0.1959475427865982,
-0.44548535346984863,
-0.655685544013977,
0.9582224488258362,
0.41353628039360046,
-0.476809024810791,
-0.04087401181459427,
-0.07773587852716446,
0.10659540444612503,
-0.43298545479774475,
0.32979920506477356,
0.45446890592575073,
0.4011402726173401,
0.00366000784561038,
-1.0972713232040405,
-0.5061571598052979,
0.18832677602767944,
-0.4197298586368561,
0.12750402092933655,
-0.9548043012619019,
0.6785622835159302,
-0.49583882093429565,
0.03670750558376312,
-0.23069573938846588,
0.297504186630249,
0.37864774465560913,
0.5352464318275452,
0.5772619843482971,
0.5151098370552063,
0.8515377640724182,
-0.30483248829841614,
1.072761058807373,
-0.15262804925441742,
0.4627115726470947,
1.0460869073867798,
-0.4267937242984772,
0.8867286443710327,
0.40562498569488525,
-0.40276864171028137,
0.37644490599632263,
1.043304204940796,
0.17298580706119537,
0.8110707998275757,
-0.12067542970180511,
0.13300462067127228,
-0.7355725765228271,
0.043684206902980804,
-0.4052566885948181,
0.5100106000900269,
0.05415084958076477,
-0.6248710751533508,
0.13241896033287048,
-0.37705257534980774,
-0.2568569779396057,
0.22878704965114594,
-0.4368727207183838,
1.0534967184066772,
0.13411925733089447,
-0.9968780875205994,
0.8077567219734192,
-0.1346864551305771,
0.8010234236717224,
-0.46826738119125366,
0.028141792863607407,
-0.0647362545132637,
0.22337372601032257,
-0.17908941209316254,
-0.6194354295730591,
-0.152950257062912,
-0.2765604257583618,
-0.5022571682929993,
-0.07461606711149216,
0.4951530992984772,
-0.10069707781076431,
-0.26493820548057556,
0.24620242416858673,
0.61143958568573,
0.1790340095758438,
0.20039398968219757,
-0.7232347726821899,
-0.1692386418581009,
0.19015009701251984,
-0.27019432187080383,
0.4473523497581482,
-0.15488791465759277,
0.2744840979576111,
0.8585154414176941,
0.5036810040473938,
0.23679174482822418,
-0.08624375611543655,
-0.2527351379394531,
0.18600332736968994,
-0.5200534462928772,
-0.3852282464504242,
-0.8389239311218262,
-0.025440702214837074,
-0.014571395702660084,
-0.4080837070941925,
0.47088056802749634,
0.5088443756103516,
0.9644807577133179,
-0.07078222185373306,
0.8689351677894592,
0.3724731206893921,
0.5500761866569519,
-0.73258376121521,
0.5896996855735779,
-0.86557936668396,
0.3427068293094635,
0.2450873702764511,
-0.8877163529396057,
0.06310489773750305,
0.6698324084281921,
-0.674836277961731,
0.1941526234149933,
0.2631111145019531,
0.5812897086143494,
-0.2528996765613556,
-0.27574804425239563,
0.53755784034729,
-0.018413307145237923,
-0.09845787286758423,
0.6523407697677612,
0.7419912815093994,
0.0019930836278945208,
0.3603905737400055,
-0.6032029390335083,
-0.4246704578399658,
-0.7371587753295898,
-0.7684054374694824,
-0.7322279810905457,
-0.18453356623649597,
-0.20286042988300323,
-0.07070815563201904,
0.4894341230392456,
1.0911954641342163,
0.925165057182312,
-0.7638812065124512,
-0.3794691562652588,
-0.018842507153749466,
0.6041332483291626,
-0.40324658155441284,
-0.21011210978031158,
0.3991352617740631,
-0.323312908411026,
-0.8947668671607971,
0.3962879776954651,
0.16981381177902222,
-0.008005080744624138,
-0.06917338073253632,
-0.2976049482822418,
0.02076091803610325,
0.005832312162965536,
0.2701468765735626,
0.4447920024394989,
-0.9410195350646973,
-0.4373202621936798,
0.10617473721504211,
-0.16011527180671692,
0.5805897116661072,
0.5488407015800476,
-0.8201367855072021,
0.5711902379989624,
0.2855932414531708,
0.32573992013931274,
0.2582685351371765,
0.2742742598056793,
0.4559729993343353,
-0.3666376769542694,
-0.2870272099971771,
0.006327166222035885,
0.2743246555328369,
0.3373209834098816,
-0.40617847442626953,
0.38566768169403076,
0.40227943658828735,
-0.9623598456382751,
-0.574948787689209,
0.40199968218803406,
-0.7813616394996643,
-0.16735990345478058,
0.8940517902374268,
0.03956398367881775,
-0.06625714153051376,
0.011956333182752132,
-0.13559463620185852,
0.2110743373632431,
-0.7187761664390564,
1.1123541593551636,
0.5857665538787842,
-0.5597934126853943,
0.2613159716129303,
-0.4055897891521454,
0.949336588382721,
0.6100075840950012,
-0.2256312221288681,
0.15107131004333496,
0.3129495084285736,
0.5699624419212341,
-0.09670005738735199,
0.5896847248077393,
0.18607746064662933,
0.47146639227867126,
-0.3736817240715027,
-0.25393033027648926,
-0.15528778731822968,
-0.32167863845825195,
-0.4525584876537323,
0.39492231607437134,
0.680018961429596,
-0.24341252446174622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00059v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00059v2
|
Conveyor: Efficient Tool-aware LLM Serving with Tool Partial Execution
| 2024-05-29T21:24:15 | 2024-06-04T19:00:36 |
Yechen Xu, Xinhao Kong, Tingjun Chen, Danyang Zhuo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.LG
|
The complexity of large language model (LLM) serving workloads has
substantially increased due to the integration with external tool invocations,
such as ChatGPT plugins. In this paper, we identify a new opportunity for
efficient LLM serving for requests that trigger tools: tool partial execution
alongside LLM decoding. To this end, we design Conveyor, an efficient LLM
serving system optimized for handling requests involving external tools. We
introduce a novel interface for tool developers to expose partial execution
opportunities to the LLM serving system and a request scheduler that
facilitates partial tool execution. Our results demonstrate that tool partial
execution can improve request completion latency by up to 38.8%.
|
[
-0.17921122908592224,
-0.48313334584236145,
0.551550567150116,
0.4661966562271118,
-0.08977017551660538,
0.4050201177597046,
0.14472471177577972,
-0.6281327605247498,
0.2995898425579071,
0.4908449053764343,
-0.609199047088623,
-0.22632311284542084,
-0.4003363847732544,
-0.22437667846679688,
-0.603049099445343,
0.6753742098808289,
-0.0906371995806694,
-0.098429374396801,
-0.15145452320575714,
0.017883069813251495,
-0.5349846482276917,
-0.4627787470817566,
-1.1383577585220337,
-0.3669271469116211,
0.6971428990364075,
0.40664932131767273,
0.933249294757843,
0.7264240980148315,
0.7726442813873291,
0.34864604473114014,
0.23310434818267822,
-0.13539628684520721,
-0.47243258357048035,
0.2602548897266388,
-0.046704262495040894,
-0.8380599021911621,
-0.5328885912895203,
-0.48418137431144714,
0.4708132743835449,
0.6761058568954468,
-0.3631752133369446,
0.12535442411899567,
-0.12154281884431839,
0.38730964064598083,
-0.5131121873855591,
-0.26343658566474915,
-0.5818898677825928,
0.20720867812633514,
-0.5958942770957947,
-0.16690877079963684,
-0.4123413860797882,
-0.2603239119052887,
0.16853132843971252,
-0.565520167350769,
0.14708679914474487,
0.13093610107898712,
0.499604731798172,
0.3370804190635681,
-0.30393898487091064,
-0.06662880629301071,
-0.7181974053382874,
0.38414546847343445,
-0.4469884932041168,
0.5059083104133606,
0.07205110043287277,
0.700821042060852,
-0.35942959785461426,
-1.2326805591583252,
-0.5177151560783386,
-0.11714265495538712,
-0.21138782799243927,
0.023742660880088806,
-0.3700706362724304,
0.24523937702178955,
0.49424999952316284,
0.552529513835907,
-0.6979381442070007,
0.24310056865215302,
-0.03837266191840172,
-0.3916659951210022,
0.1807847023010254,
0.2608948349952698,
0.49400219321250916,
0.2837136685848236,
-0.36613914370536804,
0.18405525386333466,
-0.8459059596061707,
-0.12122191488742828,
0.6875869035720825,
0.027832021936774254,
-0.050302885472774506,
0.8702514171600342,
-0.21090881526470184,
0.8134324550628662,
-0.11983591318130493,
0.35027167201042175,
-0.0829373225569725,
-0.1342398226261139,
-0.1886521279811859,
-0.07209494709968567,
0.5936007499694824,
0.1417381763458252,
-0.3708944320678711,
-0.18141037225723267,
-0.5623385906219482,
-0.08347747474908829,
0.3318459093570709,
-0.8426812291145325,
-0.3107664883136749,
0.23512627184391022,
-0.11085499078035355,
-0.03648528829216957,
0.1323900818824768,
-0.43842223286628723,
-0.7222143411636353,
0.06808698922395706,
0.20220397412776947,
-0.23655354976654053,
-0.26009154319763184,
0.058589156717061996,
-0.31075942516326904,
0.6056510210037231,
0.4880560338497162,
-0.33010992407798767,
0.6672688126564026,
0.8604466915130615,
1.3902943134307861,
-0.19242554903030396,
0.11553001403808594,
-1.2823468446731567,
0.345246821641922,
0.05474282056093216,
1.0417108535766602,
-0.5267192721366882,
-0.6122245788574219,
0.1434129774570465,
0.37312403321266174,
0.19887743890285492,
-0.5497729182243347,
0.6635650992393494,
-0.750342607498169,
-0.028493953868746758,
-0.21071356534957886,
-0.5451371669769287,
-0.1887676864862442,
0.028168629854917526,
-0.9643464684486389,
1.2195314168930054,
0.19407910108566284,
-0.8344208002090454,
0.02623668499290943,
-0.8569717407226562,
-0.7743842005729675,
0.5073898434638977,
0.09501625597476959,
0.001854501198977232,
0.11011061817407608,
0.052546754479408264,
0.3648333251476288,
-0.2868671715259552,
-0.1474415510892868,
-0.20286057889461517,
-0.7006716728210449,
0.05969861149787903,
-0.2926391065120697,
0.34248045086860657,
0.3180810511112213,
-0.31494590640068054,
0.5467118620872498,
-0.3193652331829071,
-0.23262588679790497,
0.15492023527622223,
-0.4273904263973236,
0.007101068738847971,
0.18727245926856995,
0.23718580603599548,
-0.06977399438619614,
0.7683989405632019,
-0.5852629542350769,
0.37003442645072937,
-0.8115458488464355,
0.2390410304069519,
0.923957347869873,
-0.4858298599720001,
0.5354190468788147,
-0.35566478967666626,
0.8980116248130798,
-0.12304425239562988,
0.24842530488967896,
-0.06931756436824799,
-0.1757601648569107,
-1.1549029350280762,
-0.13762745261192322,
0.06710556149482727,
0.6414998769760132,
-0.9349567294120789,
0.1312239021062851,
-0.1853862702846527,
-0.6594498753547668,
-0.736640214920044,
0.2515103816986084,
0.28510963916778564,
0.12479336559772491,
-0.16691410541534424,
-0.4892314076423645,
-0.5473697185516357,
-1.0071698427200317,
-0.021907219663262367,
0.15081927180290222,
-0.21775013208389282,
0.2622651755809784,
0.03224461153149605,
-0.009587489999830723,
0.7154521942138672,
-0.5776930451393127,
-0.005386977456510067,
-0.4878757894039154,
-0.34915128350257874,
0.7748780250549316,
0.1779191493988037,
0.5168720483779907,
-0.7249069213867188,
-0.7860202789306641,
0.36026740074157715,
-0.41250717639923096,
-0.40195178985595703,
-0.009455137886106968,
-0.45008817315101624,
0.027531823143363,
0.5066867470741272,
-0.5346043109893799,
0.14629004895687103,
0.7131381034851074,
-0.1562594175338745,
0.5442659854888916,
-0.39658787846565247,
-0.15621373057365417,
-0.8739281892776489,
0.15413570404052734,
-0.2753673791885376,
-0.7487781643867493,
-0.6670977473258972,
0.14836162328720093,
0.02857510931789875,
-0.27865058183670044,
-0.7334725856781006,
0.6860541105270386,
-0.5262770652770996,
-0.3506479859352112,
-0.595848023891449,
0.25724369287490845,
-0.07494135946035385,
0.1630152314901352,
-0.12084177136421204,
1.0620557069778442,
0.721467912197113,
-0.4039875864982605,
0.7665225863456726,
-0.1671464741230011,
-0.10235040634870529,
0.4435313642024994,
-1.2273319959640503,
0.5310759544372559,
0.10694638639688492,
0.33553817868232727,
-0.8015035390853882,
-0.15671946108341217,
0.44004422426223755,
0.17984968423843384,
0.221347376704216,
-0.5834199786186218,
-0.8328512907028198,
-0.6102044582366943,
-0.26037362217903137,
0.20981594920158386,
0.4406268894672394,
-0.6839702725410461,
0.8029798865318298,
0.23981712758541107,
-0.07563858479261398,
-0.46084892749786377,
-0.43240565061569214,
0.04315243661403656,
-0.15322211384773254,
-0.8117926120758057,
0.3653526306152344,
-0.18437567353248596,
0.08940387517213821,
-0.23500408232212067,
-0.41472315788269043,
0.04467138275504112,
0.06645258516073227,
0.5047118067741394,
0.1512499749660492,
-0.03195662423968315,
-0.18286928534507751,
0.034764934331178665,
-0.13184693455696106,
-0.012239214964210987,
-0.4626186788082123,
1.048236608505249,
0.20004495978355408,
-0.9167727828025818,
-0.5997303128242493,
0.3270481824874878,
0.4547663927078247,
-0.14637652039527893,
0.6797201633453369,
0.6261056661605835,
-0.12664687633514404,
0.13911882042884827,
-0.8116624355316162,
-0.008338327519595623,
-0.5829625725746155,
0.24171271920204163,
-0.7323156595230103,
-0.6981896758079529,
0.7069937586784363,
-0.15893825888633728,
0.19718211889266968,
0.04556560516357422,
0.48624786734580994,
0.09091861546039581,
0.927541971206665,
0.7429757714271545,
-0.31535398960113525,
1.0407198667526245,
-0.23975396156311035,
-0.03185545653104782,
-0.8081495761871338,
0.09725242108106613,
-0.36548441648483276,
-0.32948392629623413,
-0.3341290056705475,
-0.6422973871231079,
0.33660921454429626,
-0.14937685430049896,
0.03417544066905975,
0.5039306879043579,
-0.5166018009185791,
0.6066104173660278,
0.6960737705230713,
0.15342193841934204,
0.2629666328430176,
-0.4245002865791321,
-0.34470731019973755,
0.4581758975982666,
-0.7418559789657593,
-0.5593960881233215,
0.6421769261360168,
0.17736724019050598,
0.9239076972007751,
0.2650270462036133,
0.22828172147274017,
0.49916014075279236,
-0.016163818538188934,
-0.8299905061721802,
0.6122379302978516,
0.12077520787715912,
-0.36139586567878723,
0.06465063244104385,
-0.1303856521844864,
-0.8908368945121765,
0.34642279148101807,
0.28117090463638306,
-0.5965131521224976,
-0.2265171855688095,
-0.0037443116307258606,
-0.1281217783689499,
0.37451839447021484,
-0.978227436542511,
0.748928427696228,
-0.15475863218307495,
-0.3850199282169342,
-0.2973712682723999,
-0.5922730565071106,
-0.07861141115427017,
0.08103876560926437,
-0.20807959139347076,
-0.14193306863307953,
-0.12318391352891922,
0.4949360191822052,
-0.618919312953949,
0.8322763442993164,
-0.5778692960739136,
-0.3370782732963562,
0.05092867091298103,
0.4393182694911957,
1.2537438869476318,
0.041760675609111786,
-0.3539276123046875,
-0.20467671751976013,
0.10601403564214706,
-0.4933485686779022,
-0.742613673210144,
0.7611146569252014,
-0.46299728751182556,
-0.8917887210845947,
-0.5574483871459961,
-0.44093018770217896,
0.25199469923973083,
0.24523544311523438,
-0.07224580645561218,
0.30676695704460144,
0.017910482361912727,
-0.15919753909111023,
0.31467074155807495,
-0.38201311230659485,
0.4399457573890686,
0.5966907739639282,
-0.2728786766529083,
0.19791962206363678,
0.7187642455101013,
-0.09113378822803497,
0.2646830081939697,
0.5419138669967651,
-0.07080543786287308,
-0.2602301239967346,
-0.7360160946846008,
-0.3503396809101105,
0.1743316650390625,
-0.6079899072647095,
-0.30811062455177307,
-0.7338756322860718,
-0.37259840965270996,
-0.025403207167983055,
-0.39727523922920227,
-0.43560129404067993,
-0.2825649380683899,
-0.15114782750606537,
0.14115656912326813,
0.6485019326210022,
0.5919501781463623,
0.12869158387184143,
0.9837562441825867,
-0.5897724032402039,
0.12183451652526855,
0.057938504964113235,
0.4897823631763458,
0.012234422378242016,
-0.48595505952835083,
-0.20191404223442078,
-0.03882979601621628,
-0.35753050446510315,
-0.44589659571647644,
0.185449481010437,
0.005512487608939409,
0.645382285118103,
0.570235013961792,
0.11934862285852432,
0.7040605545043945,
-0.7957305908203125,
0.5764154195785522,
-0.032609131187200546,
-0.8362859487533569,
0.6929142475128174,
-0.25912898778915405,
0.5200039148330688,
0.04266353324055672,
0.4691984951496124,
-0.8802270889282227,
-0.6539920568466187,
-0.1628742218017578,
-0.8840882778167725,
0.7977961897850037,
0.1258438229560852,
0.2631209194660187,
0.11847925931215286,
0.22142890095710754,
0.3309148848056793,
-0.14044485986232758,
-0.4137627184391022,
-0.01817779429256916,
0.18014705181121826,
0.10933008044958115,
0.30867666006088257,
-0.2883055508136749,
-0.0927213728427887,
0.07817622274160385,
0.5106995701789856,
-0.21135784685611725,
0.5297659635543823,
-0.04697558283805847,
-0.3237760066986084,
0.18896722793579102,
0.21444644033908844,
0.3546687662601471,
0.5517604351043701,
0.02694215066730976,
0.28003406524658203,
0.37562569975852966,
-0.36412766575813293,
-0.0008740545599721372,
0.22496823966503143,
0.08766695111989975,
-0.17094889283180237,
0.04531010612845421,
0.6013510227203369,
0.10026345402002335,
-0.7608638405799866,
0.49684327840805054,
-0.30129700899124146,
0.40813809633255005,
-0.45723989605903625,
0.24122101068496704,
0.36752673983573914,
0.6219735741615295,
0.11679079383611679,
-0.16348004341125488,
0.4392998218536377,
-0.09427330642938614,
-0.06323571503162384,
0.3917495012283325,
-0.4726918339729309,
-0.3340815007686615,
0.6029221415519714,
0.2844924330711365,
-0.33455830812454224,
0.4020026624202728,
-0.13531140983104706,
-0.3957778215408325,
0.3231430947780609,
0.6460757851600647,
0.6931069493293762,
0.04385097697377205,
-0.03733416274189949,
-0.44010987877845764,
0.1758139580488205,
0.08346424996852875,
0.4252316355705261,
-0.17746850848197937,
-0.46588632464408875,
-0.6494032740592957,
-0.7367274165153503,
-0.5844537019729614,
-0.6432220339775085,
-0.3377785086631775,
0.5091261863708496,
-0.2486741542816162,
-0.13386297225952148,
-0.24623823165893555,
-0.13871929049491882,
-0.8203219771385193,
-0.5497848391532898,
-0.11600274592638016,
1.1587719917297363,
-0.1806941032409668,
0.9544515609741211,
0.7844745516777039,
-0.1031656414270401,
-0.3994806408882141,
-0.32952389121055603,
0.08277630060911179,
-0.7625874876976013,
0.5903611183166504,
0.057833634316921234,
-0.5233755707740784,
0.0008149116765707731,
0.03546285629272461,
-0.8117226958274841,
0.8472654223442078,
0.6455608606338501,
-0.7841799855232239,
-0.04152065888047218,
0.1753121316432953,
0.21889886260032654,
0.11549223959445953,
0.6990078091621399,
0.17021490633487701,
0.5466444492340088,
0.41703763604164124,
-1.0515480041503906,
0.3981134593486786,
-0.14667908847332,
0.19692964851856232,
0.3584616482257843,
-0.7091010808944702,
0.004407609347254038,
0.13512273132801056,
-0.4798721671104431,
0.43877512216567993,
0.6367358565330505,
-0.0895829051733017,
0.026896996423602104,
0.4598924517631531,
0.2398274540901184,
0.6820217967033386,
-0.27717840671539307,
1.244261622428894,
-0.08483611792325974,
-0.07808995991945267,
1.1399494409561157,
-0.6124243140220642,
0.6367278099060059,
0.5366316437721252,
-0.23996850848197937,
0.23307421803474426,
0.7685431241989136,
0.12270664423704147,
0.44937950372695923,
0.467017263174057,
-0.687079906463623,
0.0866798460483551,
-0.4742167890071869,
-0.2735035717487335,
0.43864870071411133,
0.059480249881744385,
0.06599488109350204,
-0.3081890046596527,
0.24545222520828247,
0.019044864922761917,
-0.31419265270233154,
-0.11477964371442795,
0.8123033046722412,
-0.10332983732223511,
-0.2444525808095932,
0.15782372653484344,
-0.005070786457508802,
0.9191350936889648,
-0.7407276034355164,
0.06769322603940964,
-0.21943500638008118,
0.018844686448574066,
-0.26082366704940796,
-0.6616400480270386,
0.4195398688316345,
-0.037297435104846954,
-0.1491072028875351,
-0.30011290311813354,
0.7339714169502258,
-0.0785578265786171,
-0.33392682671546936,
0.42531058192253113,
0.42062750458717346,
0.23476989567279816,
-0.3083152174949646,
-0.4834413528442383,
0.3364621102809906,
-0.357554167509079,
-0.326723575592041,
0.3720725476741791,
0.6845676302909851,
0.30352357029914856,
1.011696219444275,
0.6376389265060425,
0.1780291497707367,
0.326591432094574,
0.38864511251449585,
1.1763931512832642,
-0.6166238784790039,
-0.21991613507270813,
-0.8321726322174072,
0.45268476009368896,
-0.15233013033866882,
0.3741370141506195,
0.7457332611083984,
0.8709594011306763,
0.7892500162124634,
0.00752033619210124,
0.6179535388946533,
-0.3863973021507263,
0.2212999314069748,
-0.4787449836730957,
0.6262416839599609,
-0.3550301790237427,
0.47134119272232056,
-0.009634538553655148,
-0.8830163478851318,
-0.15765824913978577,
0.2695186734199524,
-0.23029610514640808,
-0.18276561796665192,
0.6137122511863708,
0.9588512182235718,
-0.4286583662033081,
-0.056824441999197006,
0.47363048791885376,
-0.07444844394922256,
0.6300531029701233,
0.5376819372177124,
0.9454540610313416,
-0.21727627515792847,
0.6428241729736328,
-0.315673291683197,
-0.05295253545045853,
-0.16142664849758148,
-0.720754086971283,
-0.6683110594749451,
-0.27613139152526855,
-0.047525618225336075,
-0.06275315582752228,
0.10543317347764969,
0.7816643118858337,
0.8030393719673157,
-0.41986754536628723,
-0.5515458583831787,
0.004100476391613483,
0.31273147463798523,
-0.19846539199352264,
-0.2564133405685425,
0.11456499248743057,
-0.3517807126045227,
-0.8626570701599121,
0.5005770921707153,
0.36040931940078735,
-0.06543132662773132,
-0.17719729244709015,
0.08734897524118423,
-0.2444314807653427,
-0.26803314685821533,
0.6879886388778687,
0.0936344787478447,
-0.5698288679122925,
-0.4423050582408905,
0.045939307659864426,
0.1841212660074234,
0.16843321919441223,
1.0353319644927979,
-0.7165883779525757,
0.35549843311309814,
0.3886859118938446,
0.8474745154380798,
0.8175551295280457,
-0.38090649247169495,
0.8708258271217346,
-1.0123674869537354,
0.32544198632240295,
0.03546701371669769,
0.5993524789810181,
0.1727060228586197,
-0.5532019138336182,
0.5814851522445679,
0.008539404720067978,
-0.5073678493499756,
-0.6866629123687744,
0.411407470703125,
-1.130663514137268,
0.12400798499584198,
0.779761791229248,
-0.2020096629858017,
-0.21606798470020294,
-0.22550909221172333,
-0.7074621319770813,
0.27776843309402466,
-0.615877091884613,
0.19370247423648834,
0.5197353363037109,
-0.3189486861228943,
-0.29459497332572937,
-0.838200032711029,
0.0666186511516571,
0.060550134629011154,
-0.8936150670051575,
0.19090910255908966,
0.3930927813053131,
0.2531939744949341,
-0.2278764396905899,
0.5667044520378113,
0.01335296593606472,
0.08698240667581558,
-0.14396297931671143,
0.03542473539710045,
-0.015913521870970726,
-0.08973453938961029,
0.0999361202120781,
0.07281685620546341,
0.3329358696937561,
-0.1700543463230133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19519v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19519v1
|
Two-layer retrieval augmented generation framework for low-resource medical question-answering: proof of concept using Reddit data
| 2024-05-29T20:56:52 | 2024-05-29T20:56:52 |
Sudeshna Das, Yao Ge, Yuting Guo, Swati Rajwal, JaMor Hairston, Jeanne Powell, Drew Walker, Snigdha Peddireddy, Sahithi Lakamana, Selen Bozkurt, Matthew Reyna, Reza Sameni, Yunyu Xiao, Sangmi Kim, Rasheeta Chandler, Natalie Hernandez, Danielle Mowery, Rachel Wightman, Jennifer Love, Anthony Spadaro, Jeanmarie Perrone, Abeed Sarker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) provides the capability to constrain
generative model outputs, and mitigate the possibility of hallucination, by
providing relevant in-context text. The number of tokens a generative large
language model (LLM) can incorporate as context is finite, thus limiting the
volume of knowledge from which to generate an answer. We propose a two-layer
RAG framework for query-focused answer generation and evaluate a
proof-of-concept for this framework in the context of query-focused summary
generation from social media forums, focusing on emerging drug-related
information. The evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness of the two-layer
framework in resource constrained settings to enable researchers in obtaining
near real-time data from users.
|
[
-0.2983052134513855,
-1.1576234102249146,
0.7050383687019348,
0.15138082206249237,
-0.27936676144599915,
0.2721102833747864,
-0.02462848275899887,
-0.5360231399536133,
0.6432263255119324,
0.7854260802268982,
-0.5060458183288574,
-0.2899400591850281,
-0.3469052314758301,
0.010581236332654953,
-0.4485606849193573,
1.0257925987243652,
0.08667349070310593,
0.17417968809604645,
-0.7083436846733093,
-0.14159764349460602,
-0.30421972274780273,
-0.5474277138710022,
-0.9226034283638,
-0.2140917032957077,
0.709166944026947,
0.5892801284790039,
0.2782134413719177,
0.3584107458591461,
0.8563613295555115,
0.0637727901339531,
-0.095734603703022,
0.4517560303211212,
-0.4836338758468628,
0.4947606325149536,
-0.22784218192100525,
-0.31768685579299927,
-0.508266270160675,
-0.25031420588493347,
0.28776901960372925,
0.6543807983398438,
-0.13515034317970276,
0.4820101857185364,
-0.17407576739788055,
0.7627048492431641,
-0.7780759930610657,
-0.4426737427711487,
-0.5546382069587708,
0.01653234474360943,
-0.029926149174571037,
-0.5059459209442139,
-0.2506648302078247,
-0.2652035653591156,
-0.006478641647845507,
-0.6553966999053955,
0.39772266149520874,
0.01158119086176157,
0.6832013726234436,
0.32112932205200195,
-0.39390048384666443,
-0.3991580009460449,
-0.7740257382392883,
0.4167627692222595,
-0.5784638524055481,
0.03418205305933952,
0.7206074595451355,
0.6301876902580261,
0.12187808007001877,
-1.1480098962783813,
-0.6244317889213562,
-0.01407560147345066,
-0.2644640803337097,
0.052067022770643234,
0.21831439435482025,
-0.13762637972831726,
0.17648980021476746,
0.3576470911502838,
-0.543570876121521,
-0.23405124247074127,
-0.49302056431770325,
-0.02951113134622574,
0.5005085468292236,
0.07267549633979797,
0.26854047179222107,
-0.4848881959915161,
-0.44363346695899963,
0.2351544350385666,
-0.7873502373695374,
-0.24263887107372284,
-0.18719469010829926,
0.15613991022109985,
-0.12780877947807312,
0.8522781729698181,
-0.1487646847963333,
0.606664776802063,
0.17568722367286682,
-0.20284207165241241,
0.10381441563367844,
-0.5639215707778931,
0.0010967337293550372,
-0.1421090066432953,
0.519788384437561,
0.6300859451293945,
-0.3635255992412567,
-0.10535340756177902,
-0.16826902329921722,
-0.08928944915533066,
0.3951758146286011,
-1.1813218593597412,
0.18765360116958618,
0.5906464457511902,
-0.7006571292877197,
-0.503685474395752,
-0.10663549602031708,
-0.8699344396591187,
-0.6662135720252991,
0.2251034528017044,
0.36054450273513794,
-0.05380600690841675,
-0.4986526072025299,
-0.02316206507384777,
-0.2807580530643463,
0.09665873646736145,
0.00204886170104146,
-0.5973715782165527,
0.6210502982139587,
0.660868227481842,
0.8483372330665588,
-0.16611184179782867,
0.21017183363437653,
-0.736376166343689,
0.40305209159851074,
-0.20934326946735382,
1.0327250957489014,
-0.27505752444267273,
-0.46992895007133484,
0.0860593169927597,
-0.09292016178369522,
0.17622174322605133,
-0.8028281331062317,
0.5741544961929321,
-0.750214159488678,
0.33639639616012573,
-0.30407533049583435,
-0.5145022869110107,
0.1339348405599594,
0.4071817100048065,
-0.5710492730140686,
0.9710026383399963,
0.32926300168037415,
-0.9508458971977234,
0.16411446034908295,
-0.6925523281097412,
-0.6327322125434875,
0.32462024688720703,
-0.45771676301956177,
-0.35652080178260803,
0.11891261488199234,
0.10231734812259674,
0.2452174872159958,
-0.6196903586387634,
0.1912006139755249,
-0.07982668280601501,
-0.26054149866104126,
0.4601508378982544,
-0.18534518778324127,
0.5118494033813477,
0.5360211730003357,
-0.18530383706092834,
-0.025987733155488968,
-0.830040454864502,
0.12625738978385925,
0.28382664918899536,
-0.5017204880714417,
-0.39338600635528564,
-0.11404535919427872,
0.1655007153749466,
0.30439236760139465,
0.18096955120563507,
-0.7162812352180481,
-0.10329803079366684,
-0.4287649691104889,
0.5178073644638062,
0.15636904537677765,
0.6363950371742249,
0.2506100535392761,
-0.42292216420173645,
0.7549859881401062,
-0.08474057167768478,
0.02963068336248398,
0.14181117713451385,
-0.3545514643192291,
-0.5108632445335388,
-0.027880055829882622,
0.413762629032135,
0.5664903521537781,
-1.089509129524231,
-0.0891726091504097,
-0.012371281161904335,
-0.03853234648704529,
-0.646931529045105,
0.004712781403213739,
0.6248384118080139,
0.9498211741447449,
0.495699405670166,
-0.1185772493481636,
-0.7288620471954346,
-0.9966852068901062,
-0.051121193915605545,
-0.18030673265457153,
-0.2741604745388031,
0.8854058980941772,
0.35517609119415283,
-0.4002135992050171,
0.6664464473724365,
-0.6282814741134644,
-0.16810595989227295,
-0.3825884759426117,
0.019076179713010788,
-0.04673730209469795,
0.3158344328403473,
0.4392435550689697,
-1.0962138175964355,
-0.437664270401001,
-0.021205395460128784,
-0.7096900939941406,
-0.16919557750225067,
0.07337933778762817,
-0.39338502287864685,
0.11327410489320755,
0.53304523229599,
-0.5807667970657349,
0.32584038376808167,
0.3673149645328522,
-0.31609299778938293,
0.2198331505060196,
-0.25558802485466003,
0.39787420630455017,
-1.4654580354690552,
0.3884197473526001,
-0.1482628583908081,
-0.37132614850997925,
-0.7096343040466309,
0.12848033010959625,
0.06058943644165993,
-0.26675283908843994,
-0.3329586386680603,
0.7412096261978149,
-0.1296168565750122,
-0.040926314890384674,
-0.5159333944320679,
0.28700050711631775,
0.24660390615463257,
0.08375104516744614,
-0.06628578901290894,
0.8897603750228882,
0.06677615642547607,
-0.5584002733230591,
0.1699966937303543,
0.2215730994939804,
-0.1941443681716919,
0.5615192651748657,
-0.8349771499633789,
0.09535113722085953,
-0.2721145451068878,
0.18084782361984253,
-0.847905695438385,
-0.9341201186180115,
0.11769092082977295,
-0.6919695734977722,
0.2712244391441345,
-0.17358960211277008,
-0.4398854970932007,
-0.577420711517334,
-0.2516871690750122,
0.7632219791412354,
0.5278770923614502,
-0.31893518567085266,
0.3508545756340027,
0.7926430106163025,
-0.31184545159339905,
-0.5966581106185913,
-0.9281963109970093,
0.09763529896736145,
-0.0627550482749939,
-0.5061571598052979,
0.4436738193035126,
-0.03501202166080475,
-0.43574726581573486,
0.21213911473751068,
0.04359063506126404,
-0.2853606045246124,
0.009400133043527603,
-0.018767230212688446,
0.03397604450583458,
-0.021292392164468765,
0.277655690908432,
0.2840363681316376,
0.16665343940258026,
0.17699654400348663,
-0.1290813684463501,
0.5698484778404236,
0.32875218987464905,
-0.3969791531562805,
-0.03687068447470665,
0.7298905253410339,
0.4738590121269226,
-0.16023752093315125,
0.625298261642456,
0.39432504773139954,
-0.5848971009254456,
-0.32882824540138245,
-0.48409804701805115,
-0.36391955614089966,
-0.40869003534317017,
0.34775274991989136,
-0.13294263184070587,
-0.9506082534790039,
0.520878791809082,
-0.0535532683134079,
-0.15284065902233124,
0.49272117018699646,
0.8208783864974976,
-0.10205523669719696,
0.9689928889274597,
0.3365803360939026,
0.7000411748886108,
0.08445119857788086,
-0.21007421612739563,
0.048351138830184937,
-0.9502198100090027,
-0.4667906165122986,
-0.2926236093044281,
-0.2174755185842514,
-0.4017479121685028,
-0.7381898760795593,
0.7203945517539978,
0.2449926733970642,
-0.006601877976208925,
-0.1782400906085968,
-0.7462652325630188,
0.39880824089050293,
0.5198456645011902,
0.4102590084075928,
0.11330962926149368,
0.14040960371494293,
-0.09947232902050018,
0.12623246014118195,
-0.6885582208633423,
-0.38229766488075256,
1.1918392181396484,
0.1772180199623108,
0.4762060344219208,
0.2143862247467041,
0.46945855021476746,
0.36992767453193665,
0.27354902029037476,
-0.6436254978179932,
0.5488426089286804,
-0.2441796064376831,
-1.0097235441207886,
-0.04600023850798607,
-0.4646178185939789,
-0.6085883975028992,
-0.04485544189810753,
-0.353256493806839,
-0.17245392501354218,
0.17222490906715393,
0.1599128395318985,
-0.5518304705619812,
0.1556829810142517,
-0.5594514608383179,
0.465879887342453,
-0.31555336713790894,
-0.6283437013626099,
-0.02645397186279297,
-0.8953707218170166,
0.319330632686615,
-0.12313918024301529,
0.16487360000610352,
0.006462896708399057,
-0.23720963299274445,
0.7200189232826233,
-0.587134838104248,
0.5554885268211365,
-0.3590770661830902,
0.03843722492456436,
0.7122567892074585,
-0.05009875446557999,
0.24183563888072968,
0.3935605585575104,
0.04639839008450508,
-0.45839986205101013,
0.0258416086435318,
-0.4974435865879059,
-0.690227746963501,
0.7086760401725769,
-0.42211636900901794,
-0.5248023271560669,
0.06598450988531113,
-0.5523319244384766,
-0.32480940222740173,
0.19644524157047272,
0.5442573428153992,
0.4327913522720337,
0.03619604557752609,
0.3251689374446869,
0.6288588643074036,
-0.3436107337474823,
-0.06992632150650024,
0.31429293751716614,
-0.3814624845981598,
-0.6541467308998108,
0.7726122736930847,
0.06626887619495392,
0.31346866488456726,
0.5159639716148376,
0.21183761954307556,
-0.3790881633758545,
-0.5345609188079834,
-0.5684042572975159,
0.27911609411239624,
-0.5285475254058838,
-0.36716994643211365,
-0.680025041103363,
-0.36738020181655884,
-0.5425220727920532,
0.02118360437452793,
-0.2116343379020691,
-0.9421453475952148,
-0.02596180886030197,
-0.17384253442287445,
0.512085497379303,
0.7407214045524597,
-0.058695148676633835,
0.005134532693773508,
-0.6872402429580688,
0.7297976613044739,
0.37090247869491577,
0.49058929085731506,
-0.14171352982521057,
-0.30053940415382385,
-0.41811272501945496,
0.1542581170797348,
-0.1704120635986328,
-0.822719156742096,
0.024362938478589058,
0.05373876541852951,
0.3791368901729584,
0.18811146914958954,
0.2752792537212372,
0.4659753739833832,
-0.3672448396682739,
0.8030343651771545,
0.15902593731880188,
-0.21951279044151306,
0.8360404372215271,
-0.3261586129665375,
0.14190959930419922,
0.72613924741745,
0.08159089833498001,
-0.4563729166984558,
-0.3524706959724426,
-0.4092777967453003,
-1.0595108270645142,
0.29859787225723267,
0.19433027505874634,
0.20667612552642822,
-0.2891295254230499,
0.7502511739730835,
0.024246763437986374,
0.222665473818779,
-0.43010613322257996,
-0.37278372049331665,
-0.14568409323692322,
-0.07746152579784393,
0.356777161359787,
-0.8312327861785889,
-0.5202945470809937,
-0.0938170775771141,
0.4610186517238617,
-0.0716758444905281,
0.3631954491138458,
0.5191113948822021,
0.12693332135677338,
-0.24663686752319336,
0.3684658110141754,
0.6772871017456055,
0.829919695854187,
-0.35738301277160645,
0.22089049220085144,
0.02639482170343399,
-0.6104545593261719,
0.05605147406458855,
0.23107056319713593,
-0.5545986890792847,
-0.1163700520992279,
0.2442881166934967,
0.5429949760437012,
-0.20639649033546448,
-0.8320773839950562,
0.45500117540359497,
-0.20867592096328735,
-0.4674140512943268,
-0.2008473426103592,
-0.08869533985853195,
0.12846870720386505,
0.2353665828704834,
0.5906838178634644,
-0.12433422356843948,
0.3442572355270386,
-0.305042564868927,
0.46801096200942993,
0.4057803750038147,
-0.25449123978614807,
-0.009549758397042751,
1.049781322479248,
0.23627270758152008,
-0.40682047605514526,
0.19081133604049683,
-0.12370975315570831,
-0.18724247813224792,
0.5828016400337219,
0.7384812235832214,
0.7477605938911438,
0.231453999876976,
0.3057882487773895,
0.523971438407898,
-0.23825472593307495,
0.06170526519417763,
0.5212741494178772,
-0.1116802766919136,
-0.4309690594673157,
-0.44150444865226746,
-0.6377103924751282,
-0.351982444524765,
0.14199931919574738,
-0.8299368023872375,
-0.011434370651841164,
-0.47564300894737244,
-0.5213660001754761,
0.08355852961540222,
-0.010227984748780727,
-0.11178018897771835,
0.13235501945018768,
-0.22529233992099762,
0.7751260995864868,
-0.4489068388938904,
0.572426438331604,
1.0910650491714478,
-0.5274242758750916,
-0.5551648139953613,
0.18488793075084686,
-0.3509289026260376,
-0.5017798542976379,
0.5528518557548523,
-0.11445411294698715,
-0.28937092423439026,
-0.28336578607559204,
-0.592096209526062,
-0.526974618434906,
1.1647968292236328,
0.11269309371709824,
-0.16873294115066528,
-0.23649705946445465,
0.1505570113658905,
0.8616538643836975,
-0.501530647277832,
-0.20695050060749054,
0.3507328927516937,
0.08839782327413559,
0.4900180697441101,
-0.6059337258338928,
0.14439135789871216,
-0.5095731019973755,
0.04024004936218262,
-0.02603844553232193,
-0.3757565915584564,
0.778818666934967,
-0.38125842809677124,
-0.3303971588611603,
0.2335832566022873,
0.3596256971359253,
0.5895094275474548,
0.572826087474823,
0.29935649037361145,
0.586054801940918,
0.637628436088562,
0.23321235179901123,
1.34735906124115,
-0.504814088344574,
0.24856708943843842,
1.0655003786087036,
-0.21301475167274475,
0.8771024346351624,
0.6576274633407593,
0.061077333986759186,
0.487604558467865,
0.4056045413017273,
0.3969157338142395,
0.7360869646072388,
0.08488742262125015,
-0.6533195376396179,
-0.07937711477279663,
-0.5987083911895752,
-0.5129517316818237,
0.07718475908041,
0.47440385818481445,
-0.5052569508552551,
0.033168990164995193,
0.07873544096946716,
0.02682948298752308,
0.28755271434783936,
-0.2245139628648758,
1.0545692443847656,
0.13022589683532715,
-0.7835731506347656,
0.778310239315033,
0.0185540821403265,
0.26365622878074646,
-0.2570357620716095,
-0.25541606545448303,
-0.4476221203804016,
0.2525956928730011,
-0.25280287861824036,
-0.7831685543060303,
0.3682660460472107,
0.3160804510116577,
-0.4469377398490906,
0.01598145067691803,
1.0604995489120483,
-0.42398855090141296,
-0.6893700361251831,
0.22283191978931427,
0.7883545160293579,
-0.019968358799815178,
0.3420502543449402,
-0.6708129048347473,
-0.2402346432209015,
-0.1928548812866211,
-0.26523688435554504,
0.22656920552253723,
0.6087974905967712,
0.0043941461481153965,
0.6026918888092041,
0.5295841693878174,
0.43484818935394287,
-0.2434658706188202,
0.12518228590488434,
1.0167758464813232,
-0.37941914796829224,
-0.21244403719902039,
-0.39723116159439087,
0.31090423464775085,
-0.347300261259079,
-0.05894216522574425,
0.6773019433021545,
0.6993300318717957,
0.621417224407196,
0.14717167615890503,
0.7882131338119507,
-0.33773383498191833,
1.259033203125,
-0.3394017517566681,
0.9411206841468811,
-0.9980741143226624,
0.48854655027389526,
0.0536600798368454,
-0.43846094608306885,
-0.5207116007804871,
0.3122589588165283,
-0.013359291478991508,
-0.028555940836668015,
0.5467532873153687,
0.8742001056671143,
0.1311286836862564,
-0.37424424290657043,
0.08434702455997467,
0.13424184918403625,
0.15457986295223236,
0.2978544533252716,
0.6537988185882568,
-0.3972720503807068,
0.5390027761459351,
-0.3812411427497864,
-0.09933243691921234,
-0.20025773346424103,
-0.4224357306957245,
-0.7385010719299316,
-0.4145565927028656,
0.09611334651708603,
-0.8781263828277588,
0.12616018950939178,
0.834837019443512,
0.5435649156570435,
-0.7782167792320251,
-0.020509686321020126,
-0.17923136055469513,
0.09537293016910553,
0.08585700392723083,
-0.2737809121608734,
0.5204752087593079,
-0.18325600028038025,
-0.3640035092830658,
0.17222058773040771,
0.2447032332420349,
-0.05239078029990196,
-0.3047086298465729,
-0.1338859349489212,
-0.3860342800617218,
0.07566557079553604,
0.8313354253768921,
0.3143676221370697,
-0.5163083076477051,
-0.09946250170469284,
0.33191490173339844,
-0.41298437118530273,
-0.03800760209560394,
1.062022089958191,
-0.7489438652992249,
0.3992544710636139,
0.60188889503479,
0.8197466135025024,
0.5815346837043762,
0.5215575098991394,
0.4212469756603241,
-1.020344614982605,
0.06003015860915184,
0.5208541750907898,
-0.05754968151450157,
0.3226476311683655,
-0.4849265217781067,
0.5612236261367798,
0.2006698101758957,
-0.6913272738456726,
-0.90349280834198,
0.2939557135105133,
-0.8313912749290466,
-0.5838233828544617,
1.3327407836914062,
0.23967672884464264,
-0.050174735486507416,
-0.16606180369853973,
-0.20882999897003174,
0.1742180585861206,
-0.1554669886827469,
0.7396934032440186,
0.27112457156181335,
-0.3260916471481323,
-0.15037384629249573,
-0.8835211992263794,
0.5773887038230896,
0.23944708704948425,
-1.0147212743759155,
0.08894991129636765,
0.5619367957115173,
0.14019986987113953,
0.1603725701570511,
1.180652379989624,
-0.35704123973846436,
0.3606959581375122,
-0.037775106728076935,
-0.29934900999069214,
-0.005405247677117586,
-0.18216054141521454,
0.12341125309467316,
0.43361422419548035,
0.12896543741226196,
-0.07069876790046692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19487v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19487v1
|
A Full-duplex Speech Dialogue Scheme Based On Large Language Models
| 2024-05-29T20:05:46 | 2024-05-29T20:05:46 |
Peng Wang, Songshuo Lu, Yaohua Tang, Sijie Yan, Yuanjun Xiong, Wei Xia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a generative dialogue system capable of operating in a full-duplex
manner, allowing for seamless interaction. It is based on a large language
model (LLM) carefully aligned to be aware of a perception module, a motor
function module, and the concept of a simple finite state machine (called
neural FSM) with two states. The perception and motor function modules operate
simultaneously, allowing the system to simultaneously speak and listen to the
user. The LLM generates textual tokens for inquiry responses and makes
autonomous decisions to start responding to, wait for, or interrupt the user by
emitting control tokens to the neural FSM. All these tasks of the LLM are
carried out as next token prediction on a serialized view of the dialogue in
real-time. In automatic quality evaluations simulating real-life interaction,
the proposed system reduces the average conversation response latency by more
than 3 folds compared with LLM-based half-duplex dialogue systems while
responding within less than 500 milliseconds in more than 50% of evaluated
interactions. Running a LLM with only 8 billion parameters, our system exhibits
a 8% higher interruption precision rate than the best available commercial LLM
for voice-based dialogue.
|
[
-0.3293502628803253,
-0.8637433648109436,
0.8072416186332703,
0.6092603206634521,
-0.5185639262199402,
0.29490169882774353,
-0.10077555477619171,
-0.38832634687423706,
0.5067958235740662,
0.5853094458580017,
-0.6205505728721619,
-0.4434869885444641,
-0.18303340673446655,
0.07828150689601898,
-0.4195992350578308,
0.4168345332145691,
0.32367873191833496,
0.3523423969745636,
-0.0978618860244751,
-0.056403834372758865,
-0.3996066749095917,
-0.6337118148803711,
-1.0114030838012695,
-0.5169884562492371,
0.38118574023246765,
0.23561784625053406,
0.9338217377662659,
0.1361772119998932,
-0.08467019349336624,
0.4585496485233307,
-0.13522614538669586,
0.06643392890691757,
-0.24843420088291168,
0.38737523555755615,
-0.06690486520528793,
-0.18283692002296448,
-0.5589593052864075,
-0.37940073013305664,
0.7319159507751465,
0.8026227951049805,
-0.41466233134269714,
-0.2759021818637848,
0.02411895990371704,
0.35107702016830444,
-0.31266409158706665,
0.2621448040008545,
-0.22979438304901123,
0.34537845849990845,
0.22501544654369354,
-0.1911521852016449,
-0.29269322752952576,
-0.24720904231071472,
0.25588369369506836,
-0.661475658416748,
-0.25934430956840515,
-0.09813991189002991,
0.32457876205444336,
0.2947966158390045,
-0.07167376577854156,
0.16069449484348297,
-0.8908823132514954,
0.3807445764541626,
-0.7389979362487793,
0.3601958155632019,
0.19090543687343597,
0.19812890887260437,
-0.12296164035797119,
-0.3822026550769806,
-1.1374688148498535,
-0.35139381885528564,
0.10301079601049423,
0.1764003485441208,
-0.19993628561496735,
0.6698119044303894,
0.2764301598072052,
0.5066803693771362,
-0.4084036350250244,
0.2929573655128479,
0.01839769072830677,
-0.22326843440532684,
0.3801984488964081,
0.5340508818626404,
0.17993034422397614,
-0.2510511875152588,
-0.30754244327545166,
0.07188460230827332,
-0.44151970744132996,
-0.1523684561252594,
0.17577436566352844,
0.21112710237503052,
-0.4031349718570709,
0.5743892192840576,
-0.4405043423175812,
0.8111395239830017,
0.08340352028608322,
-0.08107692003250122,
0.16240809857845306,
-0.5171902775764465,
-0.7142258286476135,
0.055317435413599014,
1.2601665258407593,
0.32735833525657654,
0.08230114728212357,
-0.016165120527148247,
-0.07159466296434402,
0.06570979207754135,
0.14012981951236725,
-0.5179166197776794,
0.26751708984375,
0.4527222216129303,
-0.20696699619293213,
-0.33692309260368347,
-0.25836625695228577,
-0.6024408936500549,
-0.256592720746994,
-0.5247626304626465,
0.6103305816650391,
-0.4322596788406372,
-0.28214359283447266,
0.28638195991516113,
0.29098260402679443,
0.13045437633991241,
0.5315844416618347,
-0.6218286752700806,
0.3194994330406189,
0.5121493935585022,
0.9956449270248413,
-0.12338807433843613,
-0.22232875227928162,
-0.7515376210212708,
0.09583250433206558,
-0.2929861843585968,
0.5415017008781433,
-0.5154824256896973,
-0.8032768964767456,
0.08243751525878906,
-0.050040993839502335,
0.047997165471315384,
-0.4980395436286926,
0.3327232599258423,
-0.3665904104709625,
0.35605186223983765,
0.20548325777053833,
-0.26126232743263245,
0.016552846878767014,
0.03739989548921585,
-0.7368713021278381,
0.4191149175167084,
-0.058372460305690765,
-0.5336065888404846,
-0.0655432641506195,
-0.8751735687255859,
-0.6212452054023743,
0.258159339427948,
-0.191003680229187,
-0.04191584140062332,
-0.06563514471054077,
-0.034750934690237045,
0.15381281077861786,
-0.3230758011341095,
0.3122691810131073,
-0.25133898854255676,
-0.49464696645736694,
0.33169910311698914,
-0.9569891691207886,
0.6791915893554688,
0.268582284450531,
-0.2999638617038727,
0.18163685500621796,
-0.686342179775238,
0.2734502851963043,
0.00825838465243578,
-0.485620379447937,
0.25894832611083984,
-0.27068138122558594,
-0.14108896255493164,
0.02803139202296734,
0.17845472693443298,
-0.7477611303329468,
0.21181778609752655,
-0.6990998983383179,
0.3036932945251465,
0.443565309047699,
-0.1152685210108757,
0.2989601194858551,
-0.19698479771614075,
0.6169141530990601,
0.25511273741722107,
0.006913572549819946,
-0.4832552671432495,
-0.296911358833313,
-1.2545502185821533,
-0.18085551261901855,
0.2934947609901428,
0.8835722208023071,
-0.8879305124282837,
0.9193989038467407,
-0.1689806431531906,
0.1511894315481186,
-0.46111729741096497,
-0.07750939577817917,
0.6956783533096313,
0.11598189920186996,
0.024863164871931076,
-0.3271915018558502,
-0.5597555637359619,
-0.8569764494895935,
0.34035468101501465,
-0.39052480459213257,
-0.37596362829208374,
0.05613527446985245,
0.044517021626234055,
0.08334389328956604,
0.8684231638908386,
-0.31290310621261597,
-0.15697237849235535,
-0.25235113501548767,
0.2414134293794632,
0.1781163066625595,
0.2784602642059326,
-0.20569665729999542,
-0.4686830937862396,
-0.288780152797699,
-0.03637096285820007,
-0.9067394733428955,
0.006644907407462597,
0.00015509310469496995,
-0.15344393253326416,
0.6928008794784546,
0.40296995639801025,
-1.0222105979919434,
0.6590752005577087,
0.682831883430481,
-0.02747279964387417,
0.3145637512207031,
-0.2517535090446472,
0.102373868227005,
-1.3288978338241577,
0.03179692104458809,
-0.22001855075359344,
-0.19885170459747314,
-0.8453636765480042,
-0.4200151264667511,
-0.38292810320854187,
-0.4236253798007965,
-0.41683700680732727,
0.38256171345710754,
-0.21955598890781403,
-0.33201831579208374,
-0.25424158573150635,
0.17994648218154907,
0.1518673449754715,
0.7869032025337219,
0.1923603117465973,
0.9791844487190247,
0.4236762821674347,
-0.4329444169998169,
0.6517539024353027,
0.45205068588256836,
-0.6109667420387268,
0.8260779976844788,
-0.7965705394744873,
0.2638491690158844,
-0.039937958121299744,
0.6357787847518921,
-1.125564455986023,
-0.19661127030849457,
0.1887953132390976,
-0.4822756350040436,
0.08059907704591751,
0.018542475998401642,
-0.603330671787262,
-0.4872305393218994,
0.13657128810882568,
0.26731473207473755,
0.36416926980018616,
-0.45849016308784485,
0.7197414040565491,
0.2512058913707733,
-0.6778225302696228,
-0.27549150586128235,
-0.45285743474960327,
0.39430826902389526,
0.19989243149757385,
-1.052001714706421,
0.05548829212784767,
-0.1529378890991211,
-0.09354833513498306,
-0.5175283551216125,
0.026005670428276062,
-0.06457511335611343,
-0.16120700538158417,
0.4876961410045624,
0.3840581774711609,
-0.09577444195747375,
0.16355666518211365,
0.09191417694091797,
-0.20253324508666992,
-0.11520674079656601,
-0.44106945395469666,
0.9072414636611938,
0.03099137917160988,
-0.657372772693634,
-1.2057949304580688,
0.8075395226478577,
1.045830249786377,
0.06985314190387726,
0.40586692094802856,
0.045079316943883896,
-0.011956596747040749,
0.09357401728630066,
-0.5854329466819763,
-0.020350640639662743,
-0.4875617027282715,
0.2759934365749359,
-0.39313411712646484,
-0.9480242133140564,
0.3219899535179138,
0.20387689769268036,
0.05638070032000542,
-0.15194955468177795,
0.4865093529224396,
-0.09863941371440887,
1.12871515750885,
0.569624662399292,
-0.10395779460668564,
0.438797265291214,
-0.08217103034257889,
0.45251503586769104,
-0.7434958219528198,
-0.3311445713043213,
-0.30750301480293274,
-0.12403558194637299,
0.08668115735054016,
-0.6970309019088745,
0.5601987242698669,
0.14761734008789062,
-0.5118275284767151,
0.09611273556947708,
-0.29382482171058655,
0.22584156692028046,
0.6069306135177612,
0.019005004316568375,
0.6527646780014038,
0.3339684009552002,
-0.525301992893219,
0.21705441176891327,
-0.4936257302761078,
-0.4643712639808655,
0.46512502431869507,
0.39772531390190125,
0.8568944334983826,
0.2064935564994812,
0.33172303438186646,
0.13947196304798126,
-0.025176024064421654,
-0.9190196394920349,
0.7776861786842346,
-0.12732328474521637,
-0.22845573723316193,
-0.6642042398452759,
-0.45900478959083557,
-0.6443748474121094,
0.35819655656814575,
-0.01987527683377266,
-0.9119966626167297,
-0.1951865255832672,
0.08932255208492279,
-1.0167640447616577,
0.2468935251235962,
-0.6635186672210693,
0.33281654119491577,
-0.32077208161354065,
-0.25761473178863525,
-0.20041480660438538,
-0.6054769158363342,
0.1565021276473999,
0.04607478901743889,
-0.19161134958267212,
-0.02322155237197876,
0.3750423491001129,
0.5595451593399048,
-0.5021273493766785,
0.9333510994911194,
-0.2006395310163498,
-0.3747197687625885,
0.16194841265678406,
0.25488483905792236,
0.3990037143230438,
-0.03378460183739662,
-0.10472656786441803,
0.23212948441505432,
-0.20423641800880432,
-0.0032939305528998375,
-0.7245063781738281,
0.59953373670578,
-0.6772540211677551,
-0.7797888517379761,
-0.12778423726558685,
-0.4474153518676758,
-0.5955114960670471,
0.05232580006122589,
-0.009667755104601383,
0.554366409778595,
-0.3495481312274933,
0.19059355556964874,
0.5762845873832703,
-0.4695410132408142,
0.5118229389190674,
0.8436665534973145,
-0.5238284468650818,
-0.7606393694877625,
0.646304726600647,
-0.19665248692035675,
0.6840527057647705,
0.44413161277770996,
-0.1225333884358406,
-0.564126193523407,
-0.14094717800617218,
-0.744519829750061,
0.20818886160850525,
-0.31983885169029236,
-0.23157232999801636,
-0.8904900550842285,
-0.5230063796043396,
-0.24806688725948334,
0.04104749485850334,
-0.23974046111106873,
-0.3450736701488495,
-0.09425782412290573,
-0.18462912738323212,
0.24109810590744019,
0.6667897701263428,
-0.06321633607149124,
0.5475660562515259,
-0.8179863095283508,
0.3641889691352844,
0.7355965971946716,
0.729341983795166,
0.1269415020942688,
-0.5612697601318359,
0.029088448733091354,
0.2813381254673004,
-0.27946820855140686,
-0.29236897826194763,
0.30055487155914307,
-0.030777446925640106,
0.40360304713249207,
0.45652374625205994,
-0.13450823724269867,
0.6902077794075012,
-0.5469158887863159,
0.8798309564590454,
0.7988293766975403,
-1.0231817960739136,
0.3351472318172455,
-0.45992806553840637,
0.5858864188194275,
0.485920786857605,
-0.0346497967839241,
-0.8771932721138,
-0.28586915135383606,
-0.13886962831020355,
-0.5116884112358093,
1.0135374069213867,
0.19214758276939392,
0.24932421743869781,
-0.01297717448323965,
-0.10168249160051346,
-0.1737627238035202,
0.3279644846916199,
-0.3519088923931122,
-0.18126274645328522,
-0.23263783752918243,
-0.1948084682226181,
0.030559318140149117,
-0.23227915167808533,
-0.39263978600502014,
-0.20757025480270386,
0.25133058428764343,
-0.2946408689022064,
0.4907178282737732,
0.0616876594722271,
0.2604024112224579,
-0.26069197058677673,
0.3703070282936096,
0.8408192992210388,
0.4672006666660309,
0.16341738402843475,
-0.18072718381881714,
0.16878728568553925,
-0.04157164320349693,
0.3908686637878418,
0.0956549197435379,
0.15898539125919342,
0.11433041095733643,
-0.19463688135147095,
1.2280155420303345,
0.35031262040138245,
-0.6664472222328186,
0.6451796293258667,
-0.11538959294557571,
-0.3038753271102905,
-0.5809653401374817,
-0.09834843128919601,
0.32395654916763306,
0.2892082929611206,
0.2236579805612564,
-0.24111221730709076,
-0.20889519155025482,
-0.5011769533157349,
0.204659104347229,
0.5818509459495544,
-0.37861737608909607,
-0.1503361165523529,
0.3823750615119934,
0.8726686239242554,
-0.692936360836029,
0.5654628872871399,
0.11572980880737305,
-0.46556615829467773,
0.43851736187934875,
0.456384539604187,
0.9296316504478455,
-0.2882360517978668,
0.5702970027923584,
0.1608259379863739,
-0.3137171268463135,
-0.16032905876636505,
0.19911740720272064,
-0.3405739665031433,
-0.7084386348724365,
-0.7339748740196228,
-1.1349818706512451,
-0.6692011952400208,
0.38985732197761536,
-0.36253687739372253,
-0.0760493278503418,
-0.7211646437644958,
-0.04394298046827316,
0.2101273387670517,
-0.30716726183891296,
-0.23831862211227417,
0.06094590947031975,
0.5584848523139954,
0.7565862536430359,
-0.4388139545917511,
0.9770674109458923,
0.15927372872829437,
-0.40624234080314636,
-0.7430657148361206,
0.029576146975159645,
0.05722406134009361,
-0.9505347013473511,
0.8441244959831238,
0.11225675046443939,
-0.69706791639328,
-0.14487247169017792,
-0.4124300181865692,
-0.6219999194145203,
0.8495619893074036,
0.37740713357925415,
-0.928104817867279,
-0.19743146002292633,
0.3408047556877136,
0.5201939940452576,
-0.35056909918785095,
0.08146045356988907,
0.6504406332969666,
0.25813841819763184,
0.6283455491065979,
-1.4760488271713257,
-0.15609174966812134,
-0.2596032917499542,
0.21635183691978455,
0.2539478838443756,
-0.7743375301361084,
0.5233699679374695,
-0.09320145845413208,
-0.5791493654251099,
0.7798612713813782,
0.3956640064716339,
0.2809998393058777,
0.02974465675652027,
0.740355372428894,
0.7751772403717041,
0.4228218197822571,
-0.10134883224964142,
0.8469668030738831,
-0.46156787872314453,
0.09607657045125961,
1.2534054517745972,
-0.5859794616699219,
0.7911057472229004,
0.3181323707103729,
-0.3368757367134094,
0.3709104657173157,
-0.017491215839982033,
0.3410572409629822,
0.2430618405342102,
0.4412543773651123,
-1.0549709796905518,
-0.5638973116874695,
-0.23828507959842682,
-0.1875849813222885,
0.6368178129196167,
0.5291372537612915,
-0.21185149252414703,
-0.22075554728507996,
0.2209061235189438,
0.03359702229499817,
-0.13850101828575134,
-0.002480883616954088,
1.0711838006973267,
0.1455511897802353,
-1.01716148853302,
0.7016645073890686,
-0.26193052530288696,
0.7507395148277283,
-0.769679844379425,
-0.10346192121505737,
-0.4677550196647644,
-0.06647676974534988,
-0.12475767731666565,
-0.9723982810974121,
-0.029027264565229416,
-0.027523236349225044,
-0.2016465961933136,
-0.21078088879585266,
0.15236523747444153,
-0.7522667646408081,
-0.37755417823791504,
0.3120930790901184,
0.2988015115261078,
0.24030110239982605,
-0.022720307111740112,
-0.49368083477020264,
0.4294041693210602,
0.14136844873428345,
0.038234032690525055,
0.1047092005610466,
0.36087271571159363,
0.2807260751724243,
0.7811868190765381,
0.6249977350234985,
-0.10418080538511276,
-0.19093790650367737,
0.47900208830833435,
0.7834190726280212,
-0.7621669769287109,
-0.6082206964492798,
-0.3877609968185425,
0.4343179166316986,
-0.36499372124671936,
-0.001592795830219984,
0.2625124752521515,
0.315253883600235,
0.40431272983551025,
0.3619750142097473,
1.007326364517212,
0.14940981566905975,
0.6161020398139954,
-0.6228315234184265,
0.755425751209259,
-0.3585793077945709,
0.15527381002902985,
-0.06510267406702042,
-0.8033007979393005,
-0.127798929810524,
0.6897547841072083,
0.02231254242360592,
0.06401930004358292,
0.6627631783485413,
0.9949294328689575,
0.1802143156528473,
0.387078195810318,
0.9393290281295776,
0.33609700202941895,
0.3224276900291443,
0.4641568958759308,
1.0033820867538452,
-0.08038854598999023,
0.6902619004249573,
0.11638031154870987,
-0.20022061467170715,
-0.19128760695457458,
-0.33893126249313354,
-0.5568720102310181,
-0.45704659819602966,
0.014265174977481365,
-0.4115704894065857,
0.1801048219203949,
0.8826854825019836,
0.6994466781616211,
-0.6062406301498413,
-0.32939136028289795,
0.006265299394726753,
-0.26094239950180054,
0.4260682165622711,
-0.2548411190509796,
-0.14530333876609802,
-0.3539555072784424,
-0.914800763130188,
0.7159156799316406,
0.768968939781189,
0.1401255875825882,
-0.691800594329834,
-0.218880757689476,
0.05236957594752312,
0.3215750753879547,
0.8703453540802002,
0.4388190805912018,
-0.9807665944099426,
-0.45613059401512146,
-0.22689960896968842,
-0.24751034379005432,
0.14808399975299835,
0.8757926225662231,
-0.6558082699775696,
0.71405428647995,
0.2781691551208496,
0.5081075429916382,
0.2697718143463135,
0.004161729943007231,
0.9157305359840393,
-0.36106422543525696,
0.262820839881897,
0.22660402953624725,
0.2374318242073059,
0.3470049500465393,
-0.21822939813137054,
0.06692816317081451,
0.06195741891860962,
-0.48758235573768616,
-0.41666609048843384,
0.551701009273529,
-1.1702032089233398,
-0.008641548454761505,
1.0307235717773438,
-0.14444133639335632,
0.028205858543515205,
-0.40905526280403137,
-0.48690366744995117,
0.05482359230518341,
-0.6615918874740601,
0.5129048824310303,
0.4917362630367279,
-0.28365662693977356,
-0.07599099725484848,
-0.2427738755941391,
0.19413040578365326,
0.6433240175247192,
-0.6685726642608643,
0.3350656032562256,
0.7740601301193237,
0.26027655601501465,
0.4002667963504791,
0.99521803855896,
-0.1994219422340393,
0.23613189160823822,
-0.02864045836031437,
0.19111956655979156,
0.05476592108607292,
-0.39924028515815735,
-0.45848679542541504,
0.266411691904068,
-0.24322861433029175,
-0.394568532705307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19462v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19462v2
|
Critical Learning Periods: Leveraging Early Training Dynamics for Efficient Data Pruning
| 2024-05-29T19:21:49 | 2024-06-21T12:30:36 |
Everlyn Asiko Chimoto, Jay Gala, Orevaoghene Ahia, Julia Kreutzer, Bruce A. Bassett, Sara Hooker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural Machine Translation models are extremely data and compute-hungry.
However, not all data points contribute equally to model training and
generalization. Data pruning to remove the low-value data points has the
benefit of drastically reducing the compute budget without significant drop in
model performance. In this paper, we propose a new data pruning technique:
Checkpoints Across Time (CAT), that leverages early model training dynamics to
identify the most relevant data points for model performance. We benchmark CAT
against several data pruning techniques including COMET-QE, LASER and LaBSE. We
find that CAT outperforms the benchmarks on Indo-European languages on multiple
test sets. When applied to English-German, English-French and English-Swahili
translation tasks, CAT achieves comparable performance to using the full
dataset, while pruning up to 50% of training data. We inspect the data points
that CAT selects and find that it tends to favour longer sentences and
sentences with unique or rare words.
|
[
-0.21808749437332153,
-0.588603675365448,
0.47317439317703247,
0.32044559717178345,
-0.58318030834198,
0.2045353502035141,
-0.20636560022830963,
-0.04850864037871361,
-0.1321839690208435,
0.07290534675121307,
-0.8169112205505371,
-0.33009305596351624,
-0.3544711172580719,
0.09643452614545822,
-0.5086899399757385,
0.9405006170272827,
-0.13447406888008118,
0.22368088364601135,
0.18049128353595734,
-0.20630045235157013,
-0.6215245127677917,
-0.5507921576499939,
-0.582448422908783,
-0.451839417219162,
0.5879114270210266,
0.25448906421661377,
0.5291986465454102,
1.0594844818115234,
0.4730779528617859,
0.19546721875667572,
-0.48962661623954773,
0.24017028510570526,
-0.4755001962184906,
0.33793947100639343,
-0.08585914969444275,
-0.7527984380722046,
-0.15577872097492218,
-0.18176329135894775,
0.9146603345870972,
0.7209157347679138,
-0.2865977883338928,
0.07732021063566208,
0.17028187215328217,
0.7996624112129211,
-0.5419079065322876,
0.11651518195867538,
-0.8458384871482849,
0.4441688358783722,
-0.3661075234413147,
-0.1856611967086792,
-0.42533907294273376,
-0.473999947309494,
-0.05226050317287445,
-0.7417150735855103,
0.21023181080818176,
-0.3440251350402832,
1.21466064453125,
0.32508841156959534,
-0.48886653780937195,
0.2669565975666046,
-0.8040540218353271,
0.9552499651908875,
-0.3628389835357666,
0.31859952211380005,
0.12775082886219025,
0.5173346400260925,
-0.06348729878664017,
-0.6749189496040344,
-0.4508557915687561,
0.10476013273000717,
0.22697779536247253,
0.045555002987384796,
-0.06165874004364014,
-0.1889447271823883,
0.3298864960670471,
0.42305052280426025,
-0.38535648584365845,
-0.06838717311620712,
-0.4314649701118469,
-0.1917611062526703,
0.26116201281547546,
0.49916940927505493,
0.14355908334255219,
-0.04253913089632988,
-0.2682550251483917,
-0.5532804131507874,
-0.7932139039039612,
0.22249318659305573,
0.12950119376182556,
0.35136088728904724,
0.26841819286346436,
0.4105391502380371,
-0.1970309615135193,
0.5111467242240906,
-0.3432169556617737,
-0.1060326099395752,
0.259610116481781,
-0.6052577495574951,
0.026027973741292953,
-0.3789030909538269,
0.4878852069377899,
0.41032642126083374,
0.38475364446640015,
-0.32291555404663086,
-0.2895767092704773,
0.018491359427571297,
0.3476439416408539,
-0.8892093300819397,
-0.12555040419101715,
-0.12255118042230606,
-0.39589908719062805,
-0.23556916415691376,
-0.2828851342201233,
-0.6783390641212463,
-0.07947061210870743,
-0.42856669425964355,
0.0035424435045570135,
-0.556331217288971,
-0.09765060245990753,
-0.10951846092939377,
0.07158972322940826,
0.17845097184181213,
0.3125113248825073,
-0.328017920255661,
0.12999169528484344,
0.5931781530380249,
1.2170437574386597,
-0.18567728996276855,
-0.35687315464019775,
-0.6272165179252625,
0.1048288643360138,
-0.7121753692626953,
0.2607533633708954,
-0.5997626185417175,
-0.3790741264820099,
-0.02165941335260868,
0.4189598262310028,
-0.4142025411128998,
-0.6497491598129272,
0.5020852088928223,
-0.6114627122879028,
-0.19960446655750275,
-0.2961781919002533,
-0.32462096214294434,
-0.42542609572410583,
0.3103354275226593,
-0.5790900588035583,
1.0755444765090942,
-0.14439283311367035,
-0.34061312675476074,
0.6849495768547058,
-0.380393385887146,
-0.7641297578811646,
-0.18984998762607574,
0.11998889595270157,
-0.7607038617134094,
0.19857032597064972,
0.2797200083732605,
0.5273496508598328,
-0.22762365639209747,
0.5688591003417969,
-0.3563537001609802,
-0.09243813902139664,
0.12592987716197968,
-0.1894834190607071,
0.5569782853126526,
0.5368930697441101,
-0.2134118229150772,
-0.12148012220859528,
-0.7212213277816772,
0.11861785501241684,
0.2869528830051422,
-0.4474872648715973,
-0.24231931567192078,
0.27636051177978516,
-0.0753507912158966,
0.3758888840675354,
-0.11159085482358932,
-0.34072738885879517,
0.41932469606399536,
-0.2732190787792206,
0.784023106098175,
0.5166361927986145,
0.13390828669071198,
0.3068751394748688,
-0.6797569394111633,
0.6860126852989197,
0.37853050231933594,
0.12887859344482422,
-0.3743380010128021,
-0.2783636152744293,
-0.748857855796814,
-0.02204219251871109,
0.2932206690311432,
0.7460460066795349,
-0.8575825095176697,
0.13419730961322784,
-0.5943870544433594,
-0.42335864901542664,
-0.39580851793289185,
0.33285197615623474,
0.4213281273841858,
0.35757970809936523,
0.4548810124397278,
-0.4089255928993225,
-0.3017174303531647,
-0.9142603874206543,
-0.20804014801979065,
-0.17231567203998566,
-0.16682691872119904,
0.188497394323349,
0.5244066119194031,
0.20898988842964172,
0.7002651691436768,
-0.3032345473766327,
-0.1532273292541504,
-0.08301549404859543,
0.22476959228515625,
0.26143166422843933,
0.7201633453369141,
0.28722742199897766,
-0.7611638307571411,
-0.2475263774394989,
-0.0375862754881382,
-0.43280404806137085,
0.29996952414512634,
-0.4487212300300598,
-0.11238449811935425,
-0.09392108768224716,
0.47446566820144653,
-0.3748058080673218,
0.4370591640472412,
0.2751447558403015,
0.07640370726585388,
0.1106007769703865,
0.009688584133982658,
0.23477934300899506,
-0.9546651840209961,
0.38577765226364136,
-0.2546917498111725,
-0.39329084753990173,
-0.6345500946044922,
0.015109625644981861,
0.19545528292655945,
-0.2648840546607971,
-0.7310628294944763,
0.2699478268623352,
-0.5238574743270874,
0.16159825026988983,
0.007015353534370661,
-0.12419984489679337,
0.004526451695710421,
0.5330732464790344,
0.18006154894828796,
0.728071391582489,
0.29530802369117737,
-0.9664162397384644,
-0.23378649353981018,
0.2590610682964325,
-0.5136204957962036,
0.04852883517742157,
-0.5795266032218933,
0.26352065801620483,
0.10042586922645569,
0.16345851123332977,
-0.567722737789154,
0.19228774309158325,
-0.011627334170043468,
-0.4756227433681488,
0.22245873510837555,
-0.3634900152683258,
-0.5793577432632446,
-0.142684668302536,
0.026031821966171265,
0.5672125220298767,
0.4332104027271271,
-0.32073724269866943,
0.30890947580337524,
0.3356923460960388,
-0.24046002328395844,
-0.33979371190071106,
-0.7376131415367126,
0.011515701189637184,
-0.5066279768943787,
-0.5299441814422607,
0.3505878448486328,
0.0865662470459938,
0.05970664694905281,
-0.16330936551094055,
-0.06956209242343903,
-0.4986019432544708,
0.4503569006919861,
0.10714615136384964,
0.16236215829849243,
-0.15889835357666016,
0.16276848316192627,
0.03988353908061981,
-0.16393433511257172,
-0.2758147716522217,
-0.2604300081729889,
0.5573562979698181,
-0.07701286673545837,
-0.09095311164855957,
-0.36164915561676025,
0.007900156080722809,
0.7033745646476746,
-0.23131780326366425,
0.8678067326545715,
0.5287297964096069,
-0.4342724680900574,
-0.24818813800811768,
-0.24439606070518494,
-0.350469708442688,
-0.34127047657966614,
0.3457264304161072,
-0.4657898545265198,
-0.5591930747032166,
0.5981767773628235,
-0.18059445917606354,
0.47028300166130066,
0.23285885155200958,
0.34705716371536255,
0.1353285014629364,
1.27800714969635,
0.6668660044670105,
-0.23171080648899078,
0.8511472344398499,
-0.32983991503715515,
0.1225864365696907,
-0.7931917905807495,
-0.05048195272684097,
-0.5536922216415405,
-0.38892045617103577,
-0.1566561758518219,
-0.5996693968772888,
0.29885533452033997,
0.4643701910972595,
-0.020786035805940628,
0.32460591197013855,
-0.4270074665546417,
0.4432384967803955,
0.21639803051948547,
0.25203558802604675,
0.16649073362350464,
0.0892258957028389,
-0.2952180802822113,
-0.3867682218551636,
-0.8842353224754333,
-0.49536070227622986,
1.0764297246932983,
0.46439632773399353,
0.22906243801116943,
-0.21145206689834595,
0.2018989622592926,
-0.11594931781291962,
0.09662702679634094,
-0.7421330213546753,
0.44547563791275024,
-0.200529545545578,
-0.8787981271743774,
-0.26086097955703735,
-0.6490834951400757,
-0.9620916247367859,
0.34569981694221497,
0.011213486082851887,
-0.47737357020378113,
0.10902175307273865,
0.1497747004032135,
-0.4264512062072754,
0.5152968764305115,
-0.3003655970096588,
0.7057920694351196,
-0.00927246455103159,
-0.4684625566005707,
-0.4600633680820465,
-0.6791491508483887,
0.38901421427726746,
-0.11989987641572952,
0.12522049248218536,
-0.23583844304084778,
-0.11452177911996841,
0.8015302419662476,
-0.5621207356452942,
0.6460768580436707,
-0.21617557108402252,
0.44838976860046387,
0.2197115272283554,
0.5065960884094238,
0.49943771958351135,
0.03779561072587967,
0.1533648669719696,
0.13176612555980682,
0.10697363317012787,
-0.4793366491794586,
-0.3619496524333954,
0.23834484815597534,
-0.4241543114185333,
-0.09453011304140091,
-0.26586905121803284,
-0.5029270648956299,
-0.2042524367570877,
0.21163037419319153,
0.08953823149204254,
0.3621806800365448,
-0.09415194392204285,
0.5315719842910767,
0.4678347408771515,
-0.04760213941335678,
0.5569037795066833,
0.6772902011871338,
-0.08108721673488617,
-0.4321622848510742,
1.0058680772781372,
0.14470577239990234,
0.37454894185066223,
0.327695369720459,
-0.014301691204309464,
0.07304946333169937,
-0.819456160068512,
-0.49079176783561707,
0.10751240700483322,
-0.5392845869064331,
-0.16428892314434052,
-0.6081399917602539,
-0.09883996844291687,
-0.03500126302242279,
-0.20190484821796417,
-0.700787365436554,
-0.5789890885353088,
-0.03544086962938309,
0.04760720953345299,
0.12715975940227509,
0.32940319180488586,
-0.11352012306451797,
0.5773014426231384,
-1.158979058265686,
0.18465055525302887,
-0.09513793885707855,
-0.0868123471736908,
-0.042850758880376816,
-0.39752939343452454,
-0.31744688749313354,
-0.03301592171192169,
-0.47084254026412964,
-0.7372269630432129,
0.6364802122116089,
0.32937362790107727,
0.462974488735199,
0.31632721424102783,
-0.13317109644412994,
0.9099593162536621,
-0.5388648509979248,
0.7325490117073059,
0.08990009129047394,
-0.8170768022537231,
0.5821881890296936,
-0.20985622704029083,
0.5500926971435547,
0.9947273135185242,
0.4471343159675598,
-0.7316023707389832,
-0.3975614607334137,
-0.4407482445240021,
-1.1755075454711914,
0.5898342132568359,
0.32315289974212646,
-0.28744232654571533,
0.13637974858283997,
0.42534592747688293,
0.07919011265039444,
0.38300347328186035,
-0.5649135708808899,
-0.004951538983732462,
0.184872567653656,
0.0646110475063324,
-0.21857106685638428,
0.2262500524520874,
-0.16013558208942413,
-0.4545062482357025,
0.8057370781898499,
-0.2124832272529602,
-0.11181390285491943,
0.2590835988521576,
-0.48492249846458435,
0.06933844089508057,
0.15440498292446136,
0.29057109355926514,
0.6660131812095642,
0.14221765100955963,
-0.33196449279785156,
0.34112411737442017,
-0.5809871554374695,
0.24002718925476074,
-0.1369980126619339,
-0.49222996830940247,
0.1265665888786316,
0.3416086733341217,
0.6786936521530151,
0.30591949820518494,
-0.4566601812839508,
0.4359496533870697,
-0.317879319190979,
0.07167326658964157,
-0.07939834892749786,
-0.11958809196949005,
-0.2795100212097168,
0.06879934668540955,
0.08701431006193161,
0.0231097973883152,
-0.17460617423057556,
-0.38280680775642395,
0.42706891894340515,
0.057128239423036575,
-0.5944725871086121,
-0.42794063687324524,
0.5163565874099731,
0.0565013587474823,
0.0404161661863327,
1.0237959623336792,
0.08051631599664688,
-0.7634813785552979,
0.6718480587005615,
0.05695372074842453,
0.8724442720413208,
-0.24532826244831085,
0.17781603336334229,
0.6399616003036499,
0.5360714197158813,
-0.2741349935531616,
0.16594244539737701,
-0.40638792514801025,
-0.36652758717536926,
-0.6594725251197815,
-0.7068650722503662,
-0.17734257876873016,
0.09833146631717682,
-0.9592596888542175,
0.42260581254959106,
-0.44799432158470154,
-0.21224376559257507,
-0.3143625557422638,
-0.03824635222554207,
-0.7860381007194519,
0.18678471446037292,
-0.11660552769899368,
0.9246053099632263,
-0.9709959626197815,
1.0572060346603394,
0.6133593916893005,
-0.24159035086631775,
-0.7864094972610474,
-0.17260783910751343,
0.19737856090068817,
-0.6958168148994446,
0.642831563949585,
0.157753586769104,
0.19189950823783875,
-0.011875919997692108,
-0.32016852498054504,
-0.5857219099998474,
1.1079694032669067,
0.21175824105739594,
-0.9691005945205688,
-0.2989025413990021,
0.0017968399915844202,
0.3213055431842804,
-0.2047320157289505,
0.3011574447154999,
0.6613865494728088,
0.4469631314277649,
0.06333985924720764,
-0.7942582964897156,
-0.20328859984874725,
-0.4349838197231293,
-0.1426103413105011,
0.5104166269302368,
-0.6568621397018433,
0.8785431981086731,
0.022882474586367607,
-0.7086313962936401,
0.09090324491262436,
0.4437004625797272,
0.11818122863769531,
0.21229462325572968,
0.9488160014152527,
0.6458364129066467,
0.759759247303009,
-0.35073012113571167,
0.8191652894020081,
-0.6483265161514282,
0.16463612020015717,
0.9188661575317383,
-0.09303198009729385,
0.7103669047355652,
0.5497210025787354,
-0.13598982989788055,
0.06351635605096817,
0.8301483392715454,
0.038908399641513824,
0.6001319289207458,
0.20333383977413177,
0.04185483604669571,
-0.5560525059700012,
-0.18920275568962097,
-0.4572325348854065,
-0.06331270933151245,
0.2569578289985657,
-0.17209093272686005,
-0.17834769189357758,
0.12496713548898697,
0.3839709460735321,
-0.17866721749305725,
0.02467205561697483,
0.8931869864463806,
0.2797447443008423,
-0.786344051361084,
0.7415810227394104,
-0.16143891215324402,
0.08784794807434082,
-0.7470393180847168,
0.04935381934046745,
-0.34450748562812805,
0.41108429431915283,
0.17322304844856262,
-0.488847017288208,
0.406698077917099,
0.00777819287031889,
-0.18510614335536957,
-0.6041588187217712,
0.17219670116901398,
-0.3181818127632141,
-0.35489022731781006,
0.3940789997577667,
0.3281534016132355,
0.24112583696842194,
-0.16202808916568756,
-0.8040013909339905,
0.07613348215818405,
0.11544281244277954,
-0.40593624114990234,
0.23749680817127228,
0.4653225243091583,
-0.10850349068641663,
0.8585063219070435,
0.7474883794784546,
0.4035566747188568,
0.3498591482639313,
-0.16170313954353333,
1.0320587158203125,
-0.8988175988197327,
-0.6990254521369934,
-0.7403468489646912,
0.7014132738113403,
-0.0006849990459159017,
-0.7110421061515808,
0.39311349391937256,
0.7763060927391052,
0.8799476027488708,
0.43428969383239746,
0.5556766986846924,
0.1447162926197052,
0.6680646538734436,
-0.7473449110984802,
0.4490518271923065,
-0.810070812702179,
0.21820874512195587,
0.013733855448663235,
-0.9986638426780701,
-0.22062060236930847,
0.45734497904777527,
-0.2789267599582672,
-0.28734296560287476,
1.0953190326690674,
0.7480188608169556,
-0.01597857102751732,
-0.04839801788330078,
0.1886119246482849,
0.21565347909927368,
0.6341726779937744,
0.8840309381484985,
1.0485363006591797,
-0.38227519392967224,
0.8347042202949524,
-0.6130796074867249,
-0.09362596273422241,
-0.06846874952316284,
-0.8272925615310669,
-0.8009051084518433,
-0.708548367023468,
-0.29186949133872986,
-0.3351714015007019,
0.1558445692062378,
0.34316664934158325,
0.9540258049964905,
-0.7477158904075623,
-0.10712950676679611,
-0.18512089550495148,
0.03327883780002594,
-0.3571263551712036,
-0.1868489682674408,
-0.009111221879720688,
-0.5329051613807678,
-0.6415806412696838,
0.8011755347251892,
0.08978835493326187,
-0.02076071873307228,
-0.028738053515553474,
0.007400238886475563,
-0.1538495272397995,
-0.1466209441423416,
0.04755990579724312,
0.40535369515419006,
-0.2452218383550644,
0.026746802031993866,
0.03371816501021385,
-0.07144583016633987,
0.21452859044075012,
1.3048150539398193,
-0.5729319453239441,
0.4697660505771637,
0.5347298979759216,
0.8555583953857422,
0.8225682973861694,
-0.010151061229407787,
0.8713757991790771,
-0.49315565824508667,
0.41799548268318176,
0.5426954627037048,
0.2344031184911728,
0.20847469568252563,
-0.03645046427845955,
0.5941075086593628,
0.31646308302879333,
-0.6209660768508911,
-1.15846586227417,
0.10242841392755508,
-0.451654314994812,
-0.3422029912471771,
0.7616623044013977,
-0.32894009351730347,
-0.5955427289009094,
0.02021940052509308,
0.22953853011131287,
0.4261142611503601,
-0.24171096086502075,
0.6682942509651184,
1.0502201318740845,
0.3431341350078583,
0.255104124546051,
-0.9331539273262024,
0.3755541443824768,
0.9671429395675659,
-0.5621548891067505,
0.0019725128076970577,
0.3112035095691681,
0.17106305062770844,
0.05517488345503807,
0.2405318170785904,
-0.34609413146972656,
0.22579966485500336,
-0.05232323333621025,
-0.08339221030473709,
0.06384099274873734,
-0.9010581374168396,
-0.6329128742218018,
0.16350267827510834,
-0.14782996475696564,
-0.39221853017807007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00057v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00057v2
|
Toward Conversational Agents with Context and Time Sensitive Long-term Memory
| 2024-05-29T18:19:46 | 2024-06-04T18:01:03 |
Nick Alonso, Tomás Figliolia, Anthony Ndirango, Beren Millidge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
There has recently been growing interest in conversational agents with
long-term memory which has led to the rapid development of language models that
use retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Until recently, most work on RAG has
focused on information retrieval from large databases of texts, like Wikipedia,
rather than information from long-form conversations. In this paper, we argue
that effective retrieval from long-form conversational data faces two unique
problems compared to static database retrieval: 1) time/event-based queries,
which requires the model to retrieve information about previous conversations
based on time or the order of a conversational event (e.g., the third
conversation on Tuesday), and 2) ambiguous queries that require surrounding
conversational context to understand. To better develop RAG-based agents that
can deal with these challenges, we generate a new dataset of ambiguous and
time-based questions that build upon a recent dataset of long-form, simulated
conversations, and demonstrate that standard RAG based approaches handle such
questions poorly. We then develop a novel retrieval model which combines
chained-of-table search methods, standard vector-database retrieval, and a
prompting method to disambiguate queries, and demonstrate that this approach
substantially improves over current methods at solving these tasks. We believe
that this new dataset and more advanced RAG agent can act as a key benchmark
and stepping stone towards effective memory augmented conversational agents
that can be used in a wide variety of AI applications.
|
[
-0.36806637048721313,
-1.1446192264556885,
0.5414127111434937,
-0.013384990394115448,
-0.06447455286979675,
0.31319212913513184,
-0.2981034219264984,
-0.8633211851119995,
0.2670620083808899,
0.46771112084388733,
-0.2565019726753235,
0.010524425655603409,
-0.22712697088718414,
-0.0640208050608635,
-0.5040910840034485,
0.7941424250602722,
0.04715695232152939,
-0.384808748960495,
-0.19918349385261536,
-0.47232115268707275,
-0.6100057363510132,
-0.7301951050758362,
-0.8644900321960449,
-0.5233919620513916,
0.67819744348526,
-0.005434701219201088,
0.8556836247444153,
0.32256942987442017,
0.23921248316764832,
0.31182482838630676,
-0.2579454183578491,
0.3211754858493805,
-0.6594906449317932,
0.5077305436134338,
-0.41825246810913086,
-0.44033539295196533,
-0.44572606682777405,
-0.1401251256465912,
0.4376419186592102,
0.7169449329376221,
-0.2862032949924469,
-0.05906669795513153,
-0.16390568017959595,
0.5812326073646545,
-0.7494149208068848,
0.13322465121746063,
-0.8757705688476562,
0.01344111654907465,
-0.10178111493587494,
-0.4927656650543213,
-0.596563994884491,
0.02078179642558098,
0.17520132660865784,
-0.49475035071372986,
0.21084648370742798,
-0.05429011210799217,
0.7930507063865662,
0.14498373866081238,
-0.7194416522979736,
-0.5652826428413391,
-1.1478132009506226,
0.7764002680778503,
-0.3245753347873688,
0.38066330552101135,
0.5406501889228821,
0.6201991438865662,
-0.3839872181415558,
-0.7822909355163574,
-0.5316686630249023,
-0.4671315550804138,
-0.021412666887044907,
-0.06516112387180328,
-0.05977131798863411,
-0.33836445212364197,
0.3363455832004547,
0.09532848000526428,
-0.337238609790802,
-0.13088616728782654,
-0.19623297452926636,
0.04651649668812752,
0.5002226829528809,
0.3589743971824646,
0.0786852017045021,
-0.33817845582962036,
-0.4623323976993561,
0.0895758792757988,
-0.3581077754497528,
0.05239566043019295,
0.023737484589219093,
0.3166356086730957,
0.15313613414764404,
0.3658083379268646,
-0.2552439272403717,
0.7196207046508789,
0.06171434372663498,
0.05647740140557289,
0.06820334494113922,
-0.1400769054889679,
0.22391583025455475,
-0.22624534368515015,
0.4469779133796692,
0.24841584265232086,
0.2733001112937927,
-0.3866005837917328,
-0.13063542544841766,
-0.09074349701404572,
0.3471790850162506,
-0.6261373162269592,
0.12257236242294312,
0.2434009611606598,
-0.22999027371406555,
-0.18219061195850372,
-0.07916683703660965,
-0.7617663741111755,
-0.3593803942203522,
-0.18812336027622223,
0.359851598739624,
-0.29222458600997925,
-0.09652242064476013,
-0.08591771870851517,
-0.11524896323680878,
0.510120689868927,
0.34704071283340454,
-0.6484610438346863,
0.27694758772850037,
0.6118326187133789,
0.41683900356292725,
-0.41942450404167175,
-0.04053446650505066,
-0.5682389140129089,
0.4512171149253845,
-0.44178506731987,
0.6679745316505432,
-0.8501953482627869,
-0.6563454270362854,
-0.1339215189218521,
-0.022647805511951447,
0.1027187928557396,
-0.6131861805915833,
0.2853146195411682,
-0.9203413128852844,
0.3755359351634979,
-0.20077170431613922,
-0.2483101338148117,
0.08785504847764969,
0.4575673043727875,
-0.6622320413589478,
1.053331971168518,
0.15458831191062927,
-0.5233708024024963,
0.16787777841091156,
-0.5307242274284363,
-0.41664353013038635,
0.07996857166290283,
-0.41427645087242126,
-0.22151333093643188,
-0.2473122477531433,
0.2799105942249298,
0.43181678652763367,
-0.3781149387359619,
0.4334840178489685,
-0.0533485971391201,
-0.4028914272785187,
0.601231575012207,
-0.6406923532485962,
0.5311092734336853,
0.3130006492137909,
-0.3008817136287689,
-0.4702613055706024,
-0.6360423564910889,
0.1389014720916748,
0.23390071094036102,
-0.43895623087882996,
-0.48794639110565186,
0.31220170855522156,
-0.25164321064949036,
-0.016464753076434135,
0.3446112871170044,
-0.36891862750053406,
0.06964696943759918,
-0.27884742617607117,
0.2828589677810669,
0.5991199016571045,
0.1833225041627884,
0.5098016262054443,
-0.5491753220558167,
0.34227338433265686,
0.15222015976905823,
0.057714588940143585,
-0.33628207445144653,
-0.1453564316034317,
-0.787964403629303,
0.20116272568702698,
-0.07729628682136536,
0.5471705794334412,
-1.0872461795806885,
0.12047180533409119,
-0.2954902648925781,
-0.3569090664386749,
0.05673649534583092,
-0.150453582406044,
0.3090314269065857,
0.7151846289634705,
0.3671479821205139,
-0.2745431661605835,
-0.2996772527694702,
-0.5917997360229492,
-0.19142617285251617,
-0.32493409514427185,
0.025511788204312325,
1.0655964612960815,
0.4161434769630432,
-0.34578806161880493,
1.132793664932251,
-0.4952579438686371,
0.10353900492191315,
-0.11015583574771881,
0.17054913938045502,
0.13275077939033508,
0.3127744495868683,
0.4309464395046234,
-1.1729472875595093,
-0.530267596244812,
0.017175812274217606,
-0.6630167961120605,
0.24056103825569153,
-0.16482241451740265,
0.005586199928075075,
0.5238496661186218,
0.5206069350242615,
-0.8187459111213684,
0.43078428506851196,
0.16166263818740845,
-0.3467189073562622,
0.2564009726047516,
-0.05603870376944542,
0.23802615702152252,
-1.1499384641647339,
0.2932431399822235,
-0.5441837906837463,
-0.43244796991348267,
-0.8137292861938477,
-0.2283431738615036,
0.025844160467386246,
-0.30055487155914307,
-0.5290871262550354,
0.9551637172698975,
-0.5412584543228149,
0.027165407314896584,
-0.3112882971763611,
0.18836848437786102,
0.030452437698841095,
0.5814905762672424,
-0.05709020793437958,
0.8502843976020813,
0.14482370018959045,
-0.9856072664260864,
0.36638855934143066,
0.24617141485214233,
-0.10700958222150803,
0.6996232867240906,
-0.6346141695976257,
0.7602201700210571,
-0.4613921344280243,
0.5352871417999268,
-0.6014261841773987,
-0.22761310636997223,
0.29231417179107666,
-0.584094762802124,
0.4983237385749817,
-0.017635397613048553,
-0.036140166223049164,
-0.16503311693668365,
0.0993828997015953,
0.6321992874145508,
0.44086939096450806,
-0.5687347054481506,
0.83181232213974,
0.4616362750530243,
-0.2252420037984848,
-0.9641616940498352,
-0.26266512274742126,
0.14680877327919006,
-0.3233945667743683,
-0.4216999113559723,
0.4304543435573578,
-0.08974993228912354,
-0.42261552810668945,
0.024876264855265617,
-0.14331801235675812,
-0.20299339294433594,
0.13307447731494904,
0.08233240246772766,
0.17812739312648773,
-0.02266109734773636,
0.36578133702278137,
-0.4484463334083557,
-0.15111759305000305,
-0.1541171371936798,
0.07911796122789383,
0.7420785427093506,
-0.018099278211593628,
-0.3112485408782959,
0.025910543277859688,
0.552818775177002,
0.3867958188056946,
-0.3433379828929901,
0.6043958067893982,
0.5788168907165527,
-0.32119476795196533,
-0.2242429256439209,
-0.7994269132614136,
-0.18074093759059906,
-0.4798300266265869,
0.3811482787132263,
-0.43496620655059814,
-0.9113377332687378,
0.7088830471038818,
0.019156869500875473,
-0.05485646054148674,
0.24197886884212494,
0.43265485763549805,
-0.2762368619441986,
0.9371138215065002,
0.2757818400859833,
-0.27964475750923157,
0.6908729672431946,
-0.18630032241344452,
-0.061329156160354614,
-0.7064616084098816,
-0.28692150115966797,
-0.5942858457565308,
-0.153069868683815,
-0.4351380169391632,
-0.6279311776161194,
0.2605125308036804,
-0.10350559651851654,
-0.16906994581222534,
0.12781673669815063,
-0.24920512735843658,
0.5420829057693481,
0.31005826592445374,
0.12580280005931854,
0.1444980353116989,
-0.1868082880973816,
0.4172801077365875,
0.2060551941394806,
-0.46096161007881165,
-0.48306772112846375,
0.931246817111969,
0.17466604709625244,
0.8843804597854614,
0.1457720398902893,
0.40368181467056274,
0.35122019052505493,
-0.0693495124578476,
-0.5494019389152527,
0.6203976273536682,
0.19581130146980286,
-0.9041441679000854,
-0.4528665244579315,
-0.6047051548957825,
-1.5786768198013306,
0.1411554515361786,
-0.043781109154224396,
-0.8434371948242188,
0.19419816136360168,
-0.06933416426181793,
-0.12969760596752167,
0.11263837665319443,
-0.45124998688697815,
0.5806425213813782,
-0.25727638602256775,
-0.4457387626171112,
-0.2647477984428406,
-0.7812623977661133,
-0.10609181970357895,
0.047381751239299774,
0.03922118991613388,
-0.36959007382392883,
-0.06516888737678528,
0.5798195004463196,
-0.20308609306812286,
0.6671918034553528,
-0.19897431135177612,
0.12593090534210205,
0.6390315294265747,
0.1162971705198288,
0.7534767389297485,
0.018627237528562546,
0.003025437006726861,
-0.18798872828483582,
0.13062606751918793,
-0.4103507399559021,
-0.9258407354354858,
0.4931669533252716,
-0.6135135293006897,
-0.7409564852714539,
-0.3262350261211395,
-0.6839756965637207,
-0.2845880687236786,
0.05583120137453079,
-0.1930815428495407,
0.569080114364624,
-0.4812830984592438,
0.400494247674942,
0.7250106930732727,
-0.3145909309387207,
0.4449917674064636,
0.8515377640724182,
-0.16242633759975433,
0.01559055782854557,
0.8791061639785767,
0.006208688952028751,
0.251831978559494,
0.5399703979492188,
0.0106439758092165,
-0.06405630707740784,
-0.12169379740953445,
-0.0809096172451973,
0.09650798887014389,
-0.4961886703968048,
-0.17270562052726746,
-0.746211588382721,
-0.2825726270675659,
-0.25800958275794983,
0.0035870051942765713,
-0.30107980966567993,
-0.46094343066215515,
-0.4947112500667572,
0.18944717943668365,
0.3325103223323822,
0.509960949420929,
0.12550173699855804,
0.017317980527877808,
-0.6758753657341003,
0.6542811989784241,
0.4606057107448578,
0.2214120775461197,
-0.004015658050775528,
-0.25973355770111084,
-0.07099449634552002,
0.10826246440410614,
-0.26173481345176697,
-1.0232696533203125,
0.3217828571796417,
0.1971520185470581,
0.6755454540252686,
0.042084965854883194,
0.11029237508773804,
0.5999258160591125,
-0.5522488355636597,
0.7490381002426147,
-0.25428590178489685,
-0.5364260077476501,
0.6573464274406433,
-0.4598889946937561,
0.2237909585237503,
0.3224399983882904,
0.2587471604347229,
-0.8096911311149597,
-0.2537953853607178,
-0.7080768346786499,
-0.9765733480453491,
0.6602717638015747,
0.2501752972602844,
0.401905357837677,
-0.29033637046813965,
0.5556257963180542,
-0.039014339447021484,
0.09541016817092896,
-0.282551646232605,
-0.1951340138912201,
0.15616068243980408,
0.1543475091457367,
-0.3415854871273041,
-0.4721285402774811,
-0.09595756977796555,
0.07439175993204117,
0.3714314103126526,
-0.048574209213256836,
0.4180401563644409,
0.2235174924135208,
-0.035525131970644,
0.08898598700761795,
0.5465705394744873,
0.31935399770736694,
0.7588053941726685,
-0.3286961317062378,
-0.10058824717998505,
0.3914893567562103,
-0.2901799976825714,
0.221954345703125,
0.27204757928848267,
-0.08096083998680115,
0.12975360453128815,
0.014114107936620712,
0.643630862236023,
0.21186237037181854,
-0.6719604134559631,
0.34384745359420776,
-0.12256874144077301,
0.32453653216362,
-0.6530858278274536,
0.08370888978242874,
-0.04652980715036392,
0.4504609704017639,
0.6641711592674255,
-0.3974766731262207,
0.17944525182247162,
-0.7650935649871826,
0.42720580101013184,
0.5869883298873901,
-0.40577375888824463,
0.04967133700847626,
0.6595950722694397,
0.2881729006767273,
-0.6087473630905151,
0.672488808631897,
-0.13536646962165833,
-0.3541426956653595,
0.664345920085907,
0.5845586061477661,
0.5159275531768799,
-0.33822596073150635,
0.17819924652576447,
0.08174069225788116,
-0.1808553785085678,
0.0973757654428482,
0.401505708694458,
-0.30440470576286316,
-0.7085599303245544,
-0.24769802391529083,
-0.3260955512523651,
-0.5311270356178284,
0.09681041538715363,
-0.705734133720398,
0.007511291652917862,
-0.0707971453666687,
-0.5365768671035767,
-0.2054966241121292,
0.19771182537078857,
-0.6488685607910156,
0.0441269613802433,
-0.10992641746997833,
0.6971250772476196,
-0.21613894402980804,
0.6289893984794617,
0.439738929271698,
-0.22481612861156464,
-0.5579710006713867,
-0.22253459692001343,
-0.38257479667663574,
-0.6617129445075989,
0.47760695219039917,
-0.03620266169309616,
-0.09648622572422028,
-0.18356502056121826,
-0.4586823880672455,
-0.9573229551315308,
1.2304699420928955,
0.22848094999790192,
-0.2680605947971344,
-0.43126288056373596,
0.11484994739294052,
0.6652688384056091,
-0.21018752455711365,
0.169306218624115,
0.5607267618179321,
0.12300458550453186,
0.30572694540023804,
-1.0261918306350708,
-0.11401290446519852,
-0.34414049983024597,
0.04643240198493004,
0.47260358929634094,
-0.7982665300369263,
0.8245596289634705,
-0.004796420689672232,
-0.32036083936691284,
0.11280693113803864,
0.8764448761940002,
0.20755435526371002,
0.6618726253509521,
0.4829695224761963,
0.17205505073070526,
0.8479508757591248,
0.00453184125944972,
1.065873146057129,
-0.20496264100074768,
0.12605902552604675,
1.4337596893310547,
-0.3008076250553131,
0.8362797498703003,
0.48565271496772766,
0.032434605062007904,
0.4235181510448456,
0.18807093799114227,
0.32174888253211975,
0.2174198478460312,
-0.08422121405601501,
-0.3754429221153259,
-0.0937623456120491,
-0.33891820907592773,
-0.467405766248703,
0.5562780499458313,
0.5815105438232422,
-0.2123812586069107,
-0.22798694670200348,
0.05413056164979935,
0.028170909732580185,
0.10946357250213623,
-0.01779193803668022,
0.8722183108329773,
0.07637960463762283,
-0.7800886034965515,
0.47590959072113037,
-0.21997925639152527,
0.2957388162612915,
-0.48837602138519287,
-0.1841132640838623,
-0.3347228467464447,
0.13782136142253876,
0.18627189099788666,
-0.5890098214149475,
0.17418687045574188,
-0.03440697863698006,
-0.013041650876402855,
-0.06924623250961304,
0.9305693507194519,
-0.5211847424507141,
-0.028743945062160492,
0.12207912653684616,
0.6945303678512573,
0.3630150556564331,
0.08079475164413452,
-0.6558860540390015,
0.0982091948390007,
-0.2267771065235138,
-0.40981775522232056,
0.11562604457139969,
0.4375920295715332,
-0.21199265122413635,
0.8758453130722046,
0.371772438287735,
-0.057462044060230255,
-0.07372725009918213,
-0.03579375147819519,
0.8019187450408936,
-0.8803736567497253,
-0.4748266637325287,
-0.5228761434555054,
0.3622690439224243,
-0.14426486194133759,
0.0011064257705584168,
0.3927817642688751,
0.4451112449169159,
0.6029488444328308,
0.2801397442817688,
0.5122661590576172,
-0.10770275443792343,
1.0168172121047974,
-0.41997072100639343,
0.6395182609558105,
-0.4585477411746979,
0.2402709573507309,
-0.05397146940231323,
-0.8296098709106445,
0.18584048748016357,
0.46204209327697754,
-0.18875345587730408,
0.3699212968349457,
0.32582175731658936,
0.815119206905365,
0.0322410874068737,
-0.11824925988912582,
0.3563311696052551,
0.14447128772735596,
0.7087198495864868,
0.768311619758606,
1.231536626815796,
-0.3042117953300476,
0.7538620233535767,
-0.09955230355262756,
0.07917230576276779,
-0.32353752851486206,
-0.5770791172981262,
-0.9104463458061218,
-0.9005454778671265,
0.03825098276138306,
-0.4020521640777588,
0.4273236095905304,
0.8303923010826111,
0.401723712682724,
-0.44373390078544617,
-0.11071202903985977,
0.3465394377708435,
0.08401431888341904,
0.18886494636535645,
-0.2390870600938797,
0.2857445776462555,
-0.4452272951602936,
-0.8530816435813904,
0.5818526744842529,
0.07111133635044098,
0.31498685479164124,
-0.1367308348417282,
-0.08837807923555374,
-0.2038029134273529,
0.16335569322109222,
0.6527494192123413,
0.6926312446594238,
-0.44663551449775696,
-0.5768107771873474,
0.050669748336076736,
-0.3793834149837494,
0.12726044654846191,
0.7800440788269043,
-1.0852103233337402,
0.5699554085731506,
0.2367701381444931,
0.6648333072662354,
0.9062587022781372,
0.2314721643924713,
0.653828501701355,
-0.6608051061630249,
0.356873482465744,
0.6299376487731934,
-0.08504367619752884,
0.26590973138809204,
-0.4104616343975067,
0.6474390029907227,
-0.175457164645195,
-0.7071394920349121,
-0.8075624704360962,
0.36661478877067566,
-0.9018919467926025,
-0.3519376218318939,
1.1809232234954834,
0.17608869075775146,
-0.28479692339897156,
-0.29858624935150146,
-0.32220128178596497,
0.33155983686447144,
-0.3446424901485443,
0.9212857484817505,
0.5120286345481873,
-0.31350404024124146,
0.10759928077459335,
-0.5475831627845764,
0.5216935276985168,
0.3786689043045044,
-0.6831916570663452,
-0.021672962233424187,
0.7072731256484985,
-0.013904137536883354,
0.2405669093132019,
1.0138355493545532,
-0.15253210067749023,
0.27634909749031067,
-0.09493868052959442,
-0.36775699257850647,
0.11057326942682266,
-0.5720624923706055,
-0.027289900928735733,
0.2167224884033203,
-0.02879813127219677,
-0.0342617928981781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19433v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19433v1
|
Beyond Agreement: Diagnosing the Rationale Alignment of Automated Essay Scoring Methods based on Linguistically-informed Counterfactuals
| 2024-05-29T18:16:32 | 2024-05-29T18:16:32 |
Yupei Wang, Renfen Hu, Zhe Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While current automated essay scoring (AES) methods show high agreement with
human raters, their scoring mechanisms are not fully explored. Our proposed
method, using counterfactual intervention assisted by Large Language Models
(LLMs), reveals that when scoring essays, BERT-like models primarily focus on
sentence-level features, while LLMs are attuned to conventions, language
complexity, as well as organization, indicating a more comprehensive alignment
with scoring rubrics. Moreover, LLMs can discern counterfactual interventions
during feedback. Our approach improves understanding of neural AES methods and
can also apply to other domains seeking transparency in model-driven decisions.
The codes and data will be released at GitHub.
|
[
-0.45075860619544983,
-0.8530689477920532,
1.0025988817214966,
0.16275183856487274,
0.052997998893260956,
0.1326565444469452,
-0.1382332295179367,
-0.6584442257881165,
0.38551393151283264,
0.4036155343055725,
-0.511616587638855,
-0.4107542932033539,
-0.7719559073448181,
-0.028410987928509712,
-0.4891524910926819,
0.9630573391914368,
-0.4079415500164032,
0.37290653586387634,
-0.5663787126541138,
-0.1939026564359665,
-0.26700273156166077,
-0.3612019121646881,
-0.8668126463890076,
-0.48245733976364136,
0.7061623334884644,
0.25845301151275635,
0.456083208322525,
0.48466935753822327,
0.6822224259376526,
0.44309499859809875,
0.42127689719200134,
0.09170645475387573,
-0.20962868630886078,
0.10961960256099701,
-0.3015073239803314,
-0.6156941056251526,
-0.5220207571983337,
0.3354531526565552,
0.4066888391971588,
0.5789861679077148,
0.0004678030963987112,
0.2251318395137787,
0.27354833483695984,
0.29770758748054504,
-0.4349507987499237,
-0.03492853790521622,
-0.46391019225120544,
-0.04167195409536362,
0.016660168766975403,
0.09126013517379761,
-0.5829590559005737,
-0.5645246505737305,
0.3738216459751129,
-0.5531162023544312,
-0.1333700716495514,
-0.08178819715976715,
0.6941474676132202,
0.2818761467933655,
-0.3001745641231537,
-0.3295830488204956,
-0.5281211137771606,
1.1591154336929321,
-0.6762586236000061,
0.10750715434551239,
0.193094402551651,
0.024377359077334404,
-0.09001784026622772,
-0.4916608929634094,
-0.7697805166244507,
-0.09283222258090973,
-0.375733345746994,
-0.06346336752176285,
-0.42984163761138916,
0.24575841426849365,
0.19451908767223358,
0.025608006864786148,
-0.7508622407913208,
0.30185678601264954,
-0.028652353212237358,
-0.16502745449543,
0.7667913436889648,
0.20698758959770203,
0.33976316452026367,
0.19120195508003235,
-0.2588353157043457,
0.22179996967315674,
-0.46640917658805847,
0.29073983430862427,
0.3191962242126465,
0.23692776262760162,
-0.029319049790501595,
0.6080295443534851,
0.280280202627182,
0.6023677587509155,
0.38184189796447754,
0.16381117701530457,
0.06998220086097717,
0.014258531853556633,
-0.2572440505027771,
0.22537000477313995,
0.7402044534683228,
0.7259455919265747,
0.3724214732646942,
-0.014279399067163467,
-0.29488325119018555,
0.5212438702583313,
0.6073210835456848,
-0.5124917030334473,
-0.05518854781985283,
0.4025658369064331,
-0.4626157581806183,
-0.48663008213043213,
-0.1463945358991623,
-0.7089236974716187,
-0.41963791847229004,
-0.7909643054008484,
0.758026123046875,
-0.22428323328495026,
-0.13043974339962006,
-0.2685963809490204,
-0.12002144753932953,
0.3451489508152008,
0.3788905441761017,
-0.6375229954719543,
0.40687569975852966,
0.8099786639213562,
0.855259358882904,
-0.06466342508792877,
-0.37308886647224426,
-0.37929922342300415,
-0.11036904901266098,
-0.8574551343917847,
1.0935472249984741,
-0.8378888368606567,
-0.20438912510871887,
0.1918434351682663,
-0.1163114532828331,
-0.41152864694595337,
-0.23921115696430206,
0.5770381689071655,
-0.4605921506881714,
0.47596991062164307,
-0.6130346655845642,
-1.0308693647384644,
-0.3868139088153839,
0.5004275441169739,
-0.4129771292209625,
0.9242305159568787,
-0.24345362186431885,
-0.44387051463127136,
0.40002551674842834,
-0.8337620496749878,
-0.17376530170440674,
-0.26087185740470886,
-0.3219429552555084,
-0.3088075518608093,
0.2207469344139099,
0.1104038655757904,
0.29162269830703735,
0.020535005256533623,
0.44722166657447815,
-0.42468002438545227,
-0.39740222692489624,
0.35039570927619934,
-0.5121928453445435,
0.720130980014801,
0.021753616631031036,
-0.388823926448822,
0.2234460860490799,
-0.5820642113685608,
0.0673648789525032,
-0.16368792951107025,
0.028561275452375412,
-0.3500455617904663,
-0.03543191775679588,
-0.22836744785308838,
0.23085522651672363,
0.5303947329521179,
-0.7152371406555176,
0.1913655698299408,
-0.36473947763442993,
0.11642547696828842,
0.832421600818634,
-0.17151448130607605,
0.2901895344257355,
-0.7842401266098022,
0.5826774835586548,
-0.22268089652061462,
0.08401570469141006,
-0.22401124238967896,
-0.4827277958393097,
-0.72162926197052,
-0.3209206759929657,
0.29060885310173035,
0.6278520226478577,
-0.19764487445354462,
0.7634404301643372,
-0.12798401713371277,
-0.5300724506378174,
-0.7441923022270203,
-0.04212027043104172,
0.7334590554237366,
0.7860038876533508,
0.5665291547775269,
-0.1943744421005249,
-0.6812421083450317,
-0.8142068386077881,
-0.36434221267700195,
-0.44524210691452026,
0.07384662330150604,
0.10157361626625061,
0.4351266324520111,
-0.14346930384635925,
1.0571188926696777,
-0.5075608491897583,
-0.2721646726131439,
-0.21805782616138458,
0.8023815751075745,
0.05672183632850647,
0.5833234190940857,
0.6960331201553345,
-0.33507850766181946,
-0.5681060552597046,
-0.16439254581928253,
-0.7645888328552246,
-0.5859905481338501,
-0.18845915794372559,
-0.021929020062088966,
0.6556905508041382,
0.8696839213371277,
-0.7360461354255676,
0.5560760498046875,
0.5259261131286621,
-0.2360919713973999,
0.6309365034103394,
-0.015683094039559364,
0.5920599102973938,
-0.7716303467750549,
0.09485922008752823,
0.19035416841506958,
-0.1272004395723343,
-0.47898203134536743,
-0.031833115965127945,
-0.18731757998466492,
0.343086302280426,
0.00267960992641747,
0.4259648025035858,
-0.027082569897174835,
0.11083903908729553,
-0.3672075569629669,
0.08368726819753647,
0.44313839077949524,
0.4071754515171051,
0.12564009428024292,
0.6931637525558472,
0.33417925238609314,
-0.16628220677375793,
0.14977847039699554,
0.1250016689300537,
-0.1324191838502884,
0.9209110736846924,
-0.6486384868621826,
0.045618847012519836,
-0.1646781861782074,
0.38012638688087463,
-1.6253694295883179,
0.04438948631286621,
0.1246604472398758,
-0.5871716737747192,
0.40906885266304016,
-0.1398426741361618,
0.10156553238630295,
0.045407507568597794,
-0.6480486392974854,
0.4530473053455353,
0.3151909410953522,
-0.5072044730186462,
1.0152535438537598,
0.3604816496372223,
-0.42736098170280457,
-0.677543044090271,
-0.8531211614608765,
0.2970198392868042,
-0.28312742710113525,
-0.5714872479438782,
0.4494379162788391,
-0.1763734370470047,
-0.7147449254989624,
-0.12759791314601898,
0.04277681186795235,
0.019771991297602654,
-0.20485329627990723,
0.12554141879081726,
0.46224451065063477,
-0.546544075012207,
0.29192468523979187,
0.16740421950817108,
-0.12161357700824738,
0.29127445816993713,
-0.2390224188566208,
0.2562510073184967,
0.16174979507923126,
-0.4034108817577362,
-0.4615744352340698,
0.6380093693733215,
0.7027122378349304,
0.005614734720438719,
0.7789747714996338,
0.31959882378578186,
-0.4654378294944763,
-0.0003387252800166607,
-0.8860144019126892,
-0.05312003940343857,
-0.44026708602905273,
0.07077737152576447,
-0.20217132568359375,
-0.5023040175437927,
0.7400546073913574,
0.08747877925634384,
0.36413809657096863,
0.5439000725746155,
0.3015959858894348,
-0.5225563645362854,
1.26500403881073,
0.6460550427436829,
-0.08880874514579773,
0.3449212610721588,
0.0021508443169295788,
0.43587353825569153,
-0.6363470554351807,
-0.11284881085157394,
-0.7740347385406494,
-0.44638749957084656,
-0.5106992721557617,
-0.0694049596786499,
0.18312007188796997,
-0.05044166371226311,
-0.2230769246816635,
0.16243086755275726,
-0.3346029222011566,
0.6924026608467102,
0.14152881503105164,
-0.07603606581687927,
0.021994343027472496,
-0.3630596399307251,
-0.3871961236000061,
-0.353563129901886,
-0.33664393424987793,
-0.7646220922470093,
1.0917078256607056,
0.4091937243938446,
0.3496254086494446,
0.14155414700508118,
0.5351054072380066,
0.4060971140861511,
0.6766217350959778,
-0.7815340161323547,
0.48319604992866516,
-0.3616766631603241,
-0.5098984837532043,
-0.427016943693161,
-0.05325368046760559,
-0.695165753364563,
0.05355239659547806,
-0.3058930039405823,
-0.9493062496185303,
0.3104124963283539,
0.11705078929662704,
-0.58266282081604,
0.024395866319537163,
-0.7779070138931274,
0.985115647315979,
-0.18220137059688568,
-0.3708132207393646,
-0.3281954228878021,
-0.5383473038673401,
0.09982072561979294,
-0.19469000399112701,
0.26954615116119385,
0.3149090111255646,
-0.05546978861093521,
0.9348437190055847,
-0.4211902618408203,
1.024960994720459,
-0.1556408554315567,
-0.5208812952041626,
0.05791928619146347,
0.10374435037374496,
0.4225081205368042,
-0.2505491375923157,
-0.16403020918369293,
0.3878389596939087,
-0.06515073776245117,
-0.18814457952976227,
-0.7299435138702393,
0.9215531349182129,
-0.6142115592956543,
-0.6368862986564636,
-0.5176066160202026,
-0.2760830521583557,
-0.36024585366249084,
0.12265312671661377,
0.30620718002319336,
0.468919575214386,
-0.341499000787735,
-0.10145875066518784,
0.8547024726867676,
-0.06480416655540466,
0.5298357605934143,
0.8782026767730713,
-0.3416701853275299,
-0.23178942501544952,
0.7438672780990601,
0.3699864149093628,
-0.1220192089676857,
0.39624685049057007,
0.05562109127640724,
-0.4681766629219055,
-0.5847999453544617,
-0.3294949531555176,
0.09863786399364471,
-0.7562715411186218,
-0.15208257734775543,
-0.6821635961532593,
-0.1102513000369072,
-0.634239137172699,
-0.6524998545646667,
-0.2679425776004791,
-0.3789290189743042,
-0.21447992324829102,
-0.4564841389656067,
0.20474134385585785,
0.8781045079231262,
-0.20741333067417145,
0.33870115876197815,
-0.8727924227714539,
0.17500261962413788,
0.06466393172740936,
0.43334898352622986,
-0.05680881813168526,
-0.8177743554115295,
-0.1261933296918869,
-0.06167984381318092,
-0.23036925494670868,
-0.6913385391235352,
0.0548848882317543,
0.027514338493347168,
0.5736400485038757,
0.55791836977005,
-0.17549791932106018,
0.7925568222999573,
-0.4167022407054901,
0.9054322242736816,
0.046472687274217606,
-1.1585718393325806,
0.30626970529556274,
-0.25901198387145996,
0.12287719547748566,
0.7144318222999573,
0.680830717086792,
-0.3712764084339142,
-0.5200071930885315,
-0.3546757400035858,
-0.7350666522979736,
0.627439022064209,
-0.2791634500026703,
0.04586247354745865,
0.14531250298023224,
0.3348143994808197,
0.2321968525648117,
0.06933590769767761,
-0.6473712921142578,
0.061878759413957596,
-0.08862169831991196,
-0.8703817129135132,
-0.22413524985313416,
-0.12859384715557098,
-0.3469795286655426,
-0.2999233305454254,
0.8992416262626648,
-0.16219349205493927,
-0.05788939818739891,
0.37011000514030457,
-0.08301922678947449,
-0.6031844019889832,
0.10571898519992828,
0.8484794497489929,
0.7794767022132874,
-0.02143583633005619,
-0.10341653227806091,
0.14170123636722565,
-0.35101309418678284,
0.11390133947134018,
0.33040815591812134,
-0.07266455888748169,
-0.09645703434944153,
0.8663256168365479,
0.31469109654426575,
-0.0070361304096877575,
-0.6163663268089294,
0.6595525741577148,
-0.303950697183609,
-0.2781853973865509,
-0.4844795763492584,
0.07304777204990387,
-0.11943437904119492,
0.431306928396225,
0.18754681944847107,
0.20621849596500397,
0.1332690566778183,
-0.290762722492218,
0.3991449475288391,
0.6962313055992126,
-0.6138616800308228,
-0.23237039148807526,
0.2352181077003479,
0.24450752139091492,
-0.30677640438079834,
0.47928768396377563,
0.0963829904794693,
-0.5370913147926331,
0.6508708000183105,
0.07855010777711868,
1.0442289113998413,
-0.420640230178833,
0.2640915513038635,
0.22158658504486084,
0.4031819701194763,
-0.023510733619332314,
0.3664805591106415,
0.08003072440624237,
-0.8180491924285889,
-0.7417169213294983,
-0.5941376686096191,
-0.37722155451774597,
0.22044965624809265,
-0.4472476840019226,
0.31611478328704834,
-0.35177281498908997,
-0.19353105127811432,
0.3470737636089325,
-0.016633471474051476,
-0.15906205773353577,
0.45714321732521057,
0.17771217226982117,
0.8148249983787537,
-1.1318176984786987,
0.6174888014793396,
0.7510403990745544,
-0.3286043405532837,
-0.8148101568222046,
0.22691887617111206,
0.22567394375801086,
-0.628653883934021,
0.36045077443122864,
0.3186965584754944,
-0.3306128680706024,
-0.28859707713127136,
-0.6118001937866211,
-0.7351019382476807,
0.5828080177307129,
0.35974013805389404,
-0.7782800793647766,
0.071536123752594,
0.1969386786222458,
0.9275493025779724,
-0.5487499237060547,
0.7208660244941711,
0.5809401869773865,
0.8239848613739014,
-0.14162850379943848,
-0.9601207375526428,
-0.07692255079746246,
-0.32996904850006104,
-0.4561578929424286,
0.27576032280921936,
-0.3883148729801178,
0.536995530128479,
0.012896710075438023,
0.2227606624364853,
0.1577097475528717,
0.39438435435295105,
-0.061683300882577896,
0.6177961826324463,
0.48171645402908325,
0.9101362228393555,
0.5613495111465454,
-0.061791542917490005,
0.5955749750137329,
-0.26209601759910583,
0.042667925357818604,
0.9297246336936951,
-0.5513375997543335,
0.6862233877182007,
0.6314558982849121,
-0.16969168186187744,
0.8493303060531616,
0.42794692516326904,
0.11327206343412399,
0.15949255228042603,
0.07704655826091766,
-0.11432890594005585,
-0.28785058856010437,
-0.379213809967041,
-0.06894529610872269,
0.7050225138664246,
0.5037870407104492,
-0.5539968609809875,
-0.10588783770799637,
-0.26729705929756165,
-0.04583955928683281,
0.37908172607421875,
-0.23473261296749115,
1.0502324104309082,
0.01645670458674431,
-1.2100776433944702,
0.18619942665100098,
-0.11120244115591049,
0.5174168348312378,
-0.5751851797103882,
-0.4647406041622162,
-0.05736511945724487,
0.14191333949565887,
-0.33808860182762146,
-0.90952068567276,
0.5104262232780457,
0.09855260699987411,
-0.4153379201889038,
-0.1530529409646988,
0.5014771223068237,
-0.4259782135486603,
-0.5295888185501099,
0.4646216928958893,
0.27195632457733154,
-0.11142181605100632,
0.3193820118904114,
-0.6561558246612549,
0.07355453073978424,
-0.19005849957466125,
-0.29591137170791626,
0.29385998845100403,
0.4174175262451172,
-0.10287970304489136,
0.1636916697025299,
0.49219179153442383,
-0.08365093916654587,
-0.3498091697692871,
0.1905447244644165,
0.47379714250564575,
-0.5057209730148315,
-0.4612363278865814,
-0.9310132265090942,
0.49842017889022827,
-0.1352805495262146,
-0.3530673086643219,
0.485066682100296,
0.24960695207118988,
0.7656715512275696,
0.3978246748447418,
0.8053739666938782,
0.2365221232175827,
0.7039426565170288,
-0.5395393371582031,
0.45861905813217163,
-0.5680268406867981,
0.3899323046207428,
-0.4754656255245209,
-0.7408263683319092,
-0.40675896406173706,
0.6647818088531494,
-0.660899817943573,
0.051458172500133514,
0.6696905493736267,
0.8642197251319885,
0.09915462881326675,
0.2991485595703125,
0.1331847757101059,
0.3760211169719696,
0.3648291528224945,
0.2731557786464691,
0.9365465641021729,
-0.25371089577674866,
0.3534482717514038,
0.07056356221437454,
-0.5210137963294983,
-0.06114582717418671,
-1.045421838760376,
-0.7496065497398376,
-0.3591826260089874,
-0.46259990334510803,
-0.06120651960372925,
0.06506600975990295,
1.093624472618103,
0.2174292951822281,
-1.0104254484176636,
-0.05907266587018967,
-0.23232802748680115,
-0.010924790985882282,
-0.24170821905136108,
-0.2966901361942291,
0.2630654275417328,
-0.47936680912971497,
-0.5427513122558594,
0.20079955458641052,
0.3467518389225006,
-0.1686590164899826,
-0.18815597891807556,
0.022838478907942772,
-0.28303655982017517,
0.8623339533805847,
0.15932044386863708,
0.002482862211763859,
-0.6423936486244202,
-0.3863297700881958,
-0.12052822858095169,
-0.22128573060035706,
-0.011731889098882675,
0.9381027817726135,
-0.5408833026885986,
0.15316876769065857,
0.6134530901908875,
0.5142160058021545,
-0.3311920464038849,
0.06432383507490158,
0.8201547861099243,
-0.4846876859664917,
-0.3476508855819702,
0.30263277888298035,
0.5093491673469543,
0.13011130690574646,
-0.5979583263397217,
0.04173916205763817,
-0.08393771201372147,
-0.7733104825019836,
-0.8193356990814209,
0.0852227658033371,
-0.6713194847106934,
-0.6416283845901489,
0.5898821353912354,
-0.5147370100021362,
0.04330010339617729,
-0.3990284502506256,
-0.18549403548240662,
0.22814063727855682,
-0.34746479988098145,
1.2584627866744995,
1.1055513620376587,
-0.4144650995731354,
0.08326759189367294,
0.04953544959425926,
0.5799722671508789,
0.8438917398452759,
-0.6140530109405518,
0.0156911239027977,
0.6278730034828186,
-0.048691071569919586,
0.5931822657585144,
0.6182119846343994,
-0.09894611686468124,
0.4021287262439728,
-0.15270251035690308,
-0.09365354478359222,
0.40855875611305237,
-0.5348125100135803,
-0.6799019575119019,
0.18936587870121002,
0.02984115295112133,
0.03467341139912605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19426v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19426v2
|
Deep Learning for Assessment of Oral Reading Fluency
| 2024-05-29T18:09:35 | 2024-06-01T14:16:42 |
Mithilesh Vaidya, Binaya Kumar Sahoo, Preeti Rao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Reading fluency assessment is a critical component of literacy programmes,
serving to guide and monitor early education interventions. Given the resource
intensive nature of the exercise when conducted by teachers, the development of
automatic tools that can operate on audio recordings of oral reading is
attractive as an objective and highly scalable solution. Multiple complex
aspects such as accuracy, rate and expressiveness underlie human judgements of
reading fluency. In this work, we investigate end-to-end modeling on a training
dataset of children's audio recordings of story texts labeled by human experts.
The pre-trained wav2vec2.0 model is adopted due its potential to alleviate the
challenges from the limited amount of labeled data. We report the performance
of a number of system variations on the relevant measures, and also probe the
learned embeddings for lexical and acoustic-prosodic features known to be
important to the perception of reading fluency.
|
[
-0.28263115882873535,
-0.7488765120506287,
-0.03179384395480156,
-0.17209121584892273,
-0.2679975926876068,
0.14780846238136292,
-0.24730490148067474,
-0.6940159797668457,
-0.23423950374126434,
0.47805479168891907,
-0.494078129529953,
-0.38869208097457886,
-0.7638654112815857,
-0.11147604882717133,
-0.4819529950618744,
0.6582299470901489,
0.03446333482861519,
0.03361397981643677,
-0.305046409368515,
-0.020662138238549232,
-0.7120341658592224,
-0.04701057821512222,
-0.47288498282432556,
-0.2326451987028122,
0.3536968231201172,
0.745464563369751,
0.5502927899360657,
0.6011958718299866,
0.22171294689178467,
0.2965069115161896,
-0.1403561383485794,
0.08571815490722656,
-0.5114283561706543,
0.3761327564716339,
-0.09082717448472977,
-0.31282562017440796,
-0.2301122546195984,
0.07451469451189041,
0.4969217777252197,
0.8959363102912903,
-0.08388315141201019,
0.22976970672607422,
0.38117164373397827,
0.5526854395866394,
-0.2846440374851227,
0.29771900177001953,
-0.20451533794403076,
0.25220629572868347,
0.009911882691085339,
-0.06498951464891434,
-0.38345667719841003,
-0.309918075799942,
0.7478824853897095,
-0.7062982320785522,
0.12286710739135742,
-0.25525203347206116,
0.5846538543701172,
0.25150439143180847,
-0.714389979839325,
-0.7052119970321655,
-0.7654991149902344,
0.714915931224823,
-0.5272510647773743,
0.650599479675293,
0.7904152274131775,
0.13506151735782623,
0.3468383848667145,
-0.633051872253418,
-0.6241338849067688,
-0.17012672126293182,
0.22827260196208954,
0.2868292033672333,
0.013987263664603233,
-0.0283647533506155,
-0.23243899643421173,
0.26878461241722107,
-0.6925930380821228,
0.48617351055145264,
-0.24297206103801727,
-0.20378854870796204,
0.6351446509361267,
0.10978153347969055,
0.1935807764530182,
0.12872916460037231,
-0.30999431014060974,
-0.3922843039035797,
-0.0560927614569664,
0.487350732088089,
0.4582797586917877,
0.2515096366405487,
-0.016638897359371185,
0.3771895468235016,
-0.025089062750339508,
0.5080202221870422,
-0.21181407570838928,
-0.1907990574836731,
0.5611141920089722,
-0.31691426038742065,
-0.08970489352941513,
0.11890552937984467,
0.503001868724823,
0.2867377996444702,
0.6238240599632263,
0.09878216683864594,
-0.39819005131721497,
-0.1193278580904007,
-0.09898700565099716,
-0.7249945402145386,
-0.10112331062555313,
0.045556023716926575,
-0.3406490981578827,
-0.38274508714675903,
-0.09310532361268997,
-0.49241378903388977,
-0.5047144889831543,
-0.5613595247268677,
0.5711160898208618,
-0.47760215401649475,
-0.5217300653457642,
0.42129379510879517,
0.05610280856490135,
0.29959410429000854,
0.1781282126903534,
-1.2418053150177002,
0.6138436198234558,
0.6065654158592224,
0.49158138036727905,
0.03521914407610893,
-0.16919702291488647,
-0.4535168707370758,
-0.11795953661203384,
-0.4760931432247162,
0.8960214853286743,
-0.5530113577842712,
-0.4580070972442627,
0.2072087526321411,
-0.21275097131729126,
-0.16438814997673035,
-0.39182478189468384,
0.46294844150543213,
-0.3408201336860657,
0.10519623756408691,
0.03670407086610794,
-1.0912847518920898,
-0.346392959356308,
-0.09701225906610489,
-0.7119916081428528,
0.9534181356430054,
0.37886515259742737,
-0.3695819079875946,
0.6332593560218811,
-0.08274733275175095,
-0.779880940914154,
0.05057055875658989,
-0.09297481179237366,
-0.4786122143268585,
0.11017139256000519,
0.2863921821117401,
0.5052551031112671,
0.02757847309112549,
0.2152060568332672,
0.1398998647928238,
-0.5885700583457947,
0.4027945101261139,
-0.8028011322021484,
0.5669704675674438,
-0.01339888945221901,
-0.35726338624954224,
0.06327857822179794,
-0.7815172076225281,
0.1449825018644333,
-0.13390465080738068,
-0.24916255474090576,
-0.15395455062389374,
-0.041780825704336166,
0.2042010873556137,
-0.18691648542881012,
0.08485198020935059,
-0.4034735858440399,
0.2509709894657135,
-0.6696285605430603,
0.35005778074264526,
0.3279345631599426,
0.2405903935432434,
0.11759569495916367,
-0.20099227130413055,
0.4621843099594116,
-0.20080997049808502,
0.23447637259960175,
-0.47666454315185547,
-0.6473667621612549,
-0.36915668845176697,
-0.18821825087070465,
0.7261558175086975,
0.8100578784942627,
-0.12546686828136444,
0.6905127763748169,
-0.18664371967315674,
-0.5930274128913879,
-0.7205272316932678,
0.3371429443359375,
0.7533299326896667,
0.5830205678939819,
0.19496870040893555,
-0.5184946656227112,
-0.21772097051143646,
-0.5954589247703552,
-0.12050123512744904,
-0.16666387021541595,
-0.1426123082637787,
0.42468276619911194,
0.23933294415473938,
-0.12664584815502167,
0.720305323600769,
-0.21951924264431,
-0.5737715363502502,
-0.0160685945302248,
0.36127352714538574,
0.14527104794979095,
0.3955235183238983,
0.21053053438663483,
-0.7680543661117554,
-0.40826481580734253,
-0.014716751873493195,
-0.482990026473999,
-0.09618549048900604,
-0.22238998115062714,
0.4176299571990967,
-0.04755769670009613,
0.5812947154045105,
-0.29422885179519653,
0.3609226942062378,
0.25400644540786743,
-0.4634365737438202,
0.5752052664756775,
-0.22544845938682556,
0.11233802139759064,
-0.5831401944160461,
-0.13127876818180084,
-0.11615558713674545,
-0.13545674085617065,
-0.6973392367362976,
-0.19841064512729645,
0.05835617333650589,
0.2309126853942871,
-0.5121778845787048,
0.4631426930427551,
-0.4309850335121155,
-0.33490321040153503,
-0.05292625352740288,
0.0606548897922039,
0.09694292396306992,
0.25271278619766235,
0.1887531727552414,
0.7000296711921692,
0.5480490922927856,
-0.574456512928009,
0.23989303410053253,
0.3546378016471863,
-0.728849470615387,
0.3677213788032532,
-0.5759913921356201,
0.2727927267551422,
0.13708139955997467,
0.004595138132572174,
-1.2163130044937134,
-0.07453550398349762,
-0.1951385736465454,
-0.9017467498779297,
0.7789182662963867,
0.1635214239358902,
-0.41709136962890625,
-0.2054864913225174,
-0.007808992173522711,
0.15202490985393524,
0.6077742576599121,
-0.4895448684692383,
0.5192704796791077,
0.5063731670379639,
-0.4294189512729645,
-0.7019821405410767,
-0.7704787254333496,
-0.06444982439279556,
0.2571175992488861,
-0.5255625247955322,
0.07716543972492218,
0.0040445104241371155,
-0.13574866950511932,
-0.13402830064296722,
-0.22724685072898865,
-0.3507079780101776,
0.15461629629135132,
0.1399637758731842,
0.011706206016242504,
-0.4875445067882538,
0.3743457794189453,
0.40938836336135864,
-0.2392730861902237,
0.02765023335814476,
-0.1712900698184967,
0.236923947930336,
-0.1867971569299698,
-0.11446364223957062,
-0.7831817269325256,
0.21566446125507355,
0.44358476996421814,
-0.3464547097682953,
0.12192345410585403,
0.8013695478439331,
-0.4812801480293274,
-0.19884051382541656,
-0.3139597773551941,
-0.08149903267621994,
-0.4811496436595917,
0.5803958773612976,
-0.2647615373134613,
-0.684326171875,
0.3907778263092041,
0.03139703720808029,
-0.05856800079345703,
0.27172622084617615,
0.5512639284133911,
-0.4951472878456116,
0.9115900993347168,
0.3442499041557312,
0.20247790217399597,
0.4108729660511017,
-0.4858350157737732,
-0.19884532690048218,
-0.579244077205658,
-0.5622028112411499,
-0.32117635011672974,
-0.17100700736045837,
-0.12292972207069397,
-0.32035622000694275,
-0.17630809545516968,
0.1733883172273636,
0.043171610683202744,
0.10693968832492828,
-0.5748516917228699,
0.46366891264915466,
0.45567259192466736,
0.08994272351264954,
0.2884187698364258,
-0.05761891230940819,
-0.3894885182380676,
-0.190948024392128,
-0.1345493495464325,
-0.5202042460441589,
1.0711116790771484,
0.5094180107116699,
0.5026571750640869,
0.12923017144203186,
0.5837460160255432,
0.5845551490783691,
0.08726229518651962,
-1.1525062322616577,
0.39265358448028564,
-0.0012700719526037574,
-0.4547182023525238,
-0.9443238973617554,
0.04264827072620392,
-1.1705485582351685,
0.30838456749916077,
-0.27567002177238464,
-0.4558604657649994,
0.520793080329895,
-0.11775528639554977,
-0.6612803936004639,
0.011583475396037102,
-0.9783042073249817,
0.7670539021492004,
-0.17601081728935242,
-0.155032679438591,
-0.15143203735351562,
-0.7027848362922668,
-0.08217671513557434,
-0.08841875940561295,
0.15594513714313507,
0.03916892036795616,
-0.32291996479034424,
0.8158320188522339,
-0.23251691460609436,
1.0262506008148193,
-0.24741028249263763,
-0.18851818144321442,
0.6300657391548157,
0.17286501824855804,
0.24776847660541534,
0.03206861764192581,
0.015030037611722946,
-0.07026556879281998,
0.04952872544527054,
-0.34560444951057434,
-0.4323791563510895,
0.2765604257583618,
-1.0262372493743896,
-0.19337715208530426,
-0.5260183215141296,
-0.31595277786254883,
-0.5396092534065247,
0.35101643204689026,
-0.013722311705350876,
0.7960885167121887,
-0.4482784569263458,
0.3206346333026886,
1.0910598039627075,
-0.0510285422205925,
0.3753729462623596,
0.6479740142822266,
0.03560585528612137,
-0.25692546367645264,
1.1904343366622925,
0.3381173312664032,
0.1966249793767929,
0.47587060928344727,
0.28568369150161743,
-0.6491891741752625,
-1.0131734609603882,
-0.3055652379989624,
-0.16071277856826782,
-0.7415921688079834,
0.1152065321803093,
-0.5750120282173157,
-0.1997535228729248,
-0.603082537651062,
-0.18020415306091309,
-0.2486868053674698,
-0.31665417551994324,
-0.8976550102233887,
-0.6120256781578064,
0.3404843211174011,
0.8483417630195618,
-0.2861681580543518,
0.32394665479660034,
-0.6555224061012268,
0.16255609691143036,
0.6280080080032349,
0.324651300907135,
0.05844750255346298,
-0.7902330756187439,
-0.3567180037498474,
-0.2429535835981369,
-0.19159092009067535,
-0.7224505543708801,
0.5474637746810913,
0.5949380993843079,
0.35092055797576904,
0.5365394949913025,
-0.21281206607818604,
0.38125985860824585,
-0.2628825902938843,
0.6964922547340393,
0.020026618614792824,
-0.9559915065765381,
0.41256678104400635,
-0.384585440158844,
0.11543839424848557,
0.710486650466919,
0.2435612678527832,
-0.42595168948173523,
-0.12429287284612656,
-0.42959582805633545,
-0.8206016421318054,
0.26461318135261536,
-0.10024897009134293,
0.16186261177062988,
0.1958450973033905,
0.16876515746116638,
0.557949960231781,
0.004226833116263151,
0.0027381377294659615,
0.04918498918414116,
-0.39261940121650696,
-0.4001712501049042,
-0.19140438735485077,
-0.4289194345474243,
0.24963238835334778,
-0.44777506589889526,
0.3709789514541626,
-0.04569794982671738,
-0.13083098828792572,
0.3036864399909973,
-0.503008246421814,
0.037106968462467194,
0.2170555293560028,
0.5698727965354919,
0.4608316123485565,
-0.1960678994655609,
-0.10222628712654114,
0.02471594326198101,
-1.011202335357666,
0.1709960550069809,
0.20516732335090637,
0.036416251212358475,
-0.24547912180423737,
0.9235697388648987,
0.8060833215713501,
0.48432350158691406,
-0.8748748898506165,
0.8235327005386353,
-0.21102729439735413,
-0.4893058240413666,
-0.5701723694801331,
0.186569482088089,
0.2981263995170593,
0.31919097900390625,
0.44089359045028687,
-0.034283511340618134,
0.3827887177467346,
-0.3020817041397095,
0.5447677373886108,
-0.2577410042285919,
-0.8050656914710999,
-0.21399523317813873,
0.2817436754703522,
0.323377788066864,
-0.4902512729167938,
0.9442119598388672,
-0.15566475689411163,
-0.22408658266067505,
0.7619556784629822,
0.3539372980594635,
0.6912909150123596,
-0.6557755470275879,
0.21301643550395966,
0.2374807447195053,
0.4585843086242676,
0.4245510697364807,
0.48905062675476074,
-0.3339037597179413,
-0.5561236143112183,
-0.16467712819576263,
-0.3532116711139679,
-0.4968997836112976,
0.1321830153465271,
-0.9614039063453674,
0.22271159291267395,
-0.2363511025905609,
-0.0346817821264267,
0.061286840587854385,
0.37265026569366455,
-0.9081217050552368,
0.5662634968757629,
0.5779361724853516,
0.7519908547401428,
-0.948497474193573,
0.8087254166603088,
0.019467495381832123,
-0.4540545642375946,
-0.7540674805641174,
-0.23351755738258362,
0.014167754910886288,
-0.8201309442520142,
0.3970644772052765,
0.3638724386692047,
-0.09852709621191025,
0.2632446885108948,
-0.15541601181030273,
-0.8063052296638489,
1.0281991958618164,
0.07976410537958145,
-0.9927365779876709,
0.04483933001756668,
0.2559661865234375,
0.8017483949661255,
-0.3807619512081146,
0.7827001214027405,
0.7557517290115356,
0.5185779929161072,
-0.09028886258602142,
-1.037427306175232,
-0.3907771706581116,
-0.14253447949886322,
-0.17288543283939362,
-0.36175769567489624,
-0.32387834787368774,
0.4986102283000946,
-0.47424036264419556,
-0.15963780879974365,
0.009546499699354172,
0.989495575428009,
0.0003200092469342053,
0.4251614809036255,
0.5998570919036865,
0.34316951036453247,
1.1903176307678223,
0.24515758454799652,
0.9022262692451477,
0.08265604823827744,
0.2070499211549759,
1.0994065999984741,
-0.264085978269577,
1.0603090524673462,
0.19535145163536072,
-0.13074234127998352,
0.30058446526527405,
1.053939938545227,
-0.22143995761871338,
0.5335594415664673,
0.28589197993278503,
-0.2743972837924957,
-0.13726693391799927,
-0.19290561974048615,
-0.26479029655456543,
0.4066157042980194,
0.854950487613678,
-0.30913111567497253,
0.2751462161540985,
0.36100250482559204,
-0.18756844103336334,
0.22170217335224152,
-0.31770026683807373,
0.8458297252655029,
0.1649409532546997,
-0.5190097689628601,
0.6041345000267029,
-0.4236699640750885,
0.5405266880989075,
-0.31238430738449097,
-0.15950007736682892,
-0.02242928370833397,
0.18526145815849304,
-0.12478790432214737,
-1.1620877981185913,
-0.10013624280691147,
-0.3348294794559479,
-0.13067112863063812,
-0.20894883573055267,
0.6688430309295654,
-0.6052624583244324,
-0.45226314663887024,
0.44847238063812256,
0.45018717646598816,
0.38287943601608276,
0.29510965943336487,
-0.7724745869636536,
-0.09873949736356735,
-0.16150857508182526,
-0.8303701877593994,
0.07966899126768112,
0.3233705759048462,
0.23831269145011902,
0.5264530181884766,
0.5906835794448853,
-0.05001533031463623,
0.09516619145870209,
0.5989819169044495,
0.3738623261451721,
-0.47347286343574524,
-0.6234526038169861,
-0.42884716391563416,
0.36192479729652405,
0.3061356544494629,
-0.8562487363815308,
0.29899731278419495,
0.5199335813522339,
0.7843506932258606,
0.0543077327311039,
0.6867114305496216,
0.5870407223701477,
0.7481648921966553,
-0.44212955236434937,
0.8951606154441833,
-0.3465442657470703,
-0.04719860851764679,
-0.08292044699192047,
-0.5108628869056702,
-0.2261509895324707,
0.6042841076850891,
0.076121486723423,
-0.039364658296108246,
0.7113167643547058,
0.5854300856590271,
0.09255840629339218,
0.5212414264678955,
0.3784600794315338,
0.23030048608779907,
0.20432943105697632,
0.49893277883529663,
0.69245445728302,
-0.31200355291366577,
0.5776205062866211,
-0.05578926205635071,
-0.44794440269470215,
-0.2577287256717682,
-0.4664459526538849,
-0.90117347240448,
-0.6954465508460999,
-0.35015133023262024,
-0.20833130180835724,
0.1137102022767067,
0.6600855588912964,
0.47825872898101807,
-0.5172706842422485,
-0.16001804172992706,
0.020504048094153404,
-0.14397548139095306,
-0.5919881463050842,
-0.1519443392753601,
0.5896681547164917,
-0.09457999467849731,
-0.5201772451400757,
0.5912356972694397,
-0.16709119081497192,
0.10889077931642532,
-0.4684092402458191,
-0.13768161833286285,
-0.006996160838752985,
0.2922421991825104,
0.4317880868911743,
0.3940664231777191,
-0.47184115648269653,
-0.1317397803068161,
0.14021369814872742,
-0.15877829492092133,
0.09851749241352081,
0.5554064512252808,
-0.9632101655006409,
0.8271596431732178,
0.48089033365249634,
0.7151586413383484,
0.8060042858123779,
-0.34693896770477295,
0.2807026505470276,
-0.5234810709953308,
-0.13130415976047516,
0.7645641565322876,
0.07320230454206467,
0.2994081676006317,
-0.345296710729599,
0.31671157479286194,
0.17538757622241974,
-0.4491870105266571,
-0.9878390431404114,
-0.11987580358982086,
-0.8573617339134216,
-0.17131070792675018,
0.9384412169456482,
-0.20558761060237885,
-0.24468016624450684,
-0.4075765907764435,
-0.1080118715763092,
0.5554159283638,
-0.3868895471096039,
0.2760917842388153,
0.7767282128334045,
0.01792280003428459,
-0.22148184478282928,
-0.6874242424964905,
0.25937408208847046,
0.4556560516357422,
-0.3417501449584961,
0.05290398374199867,
0.11753751337528229,
0.3971219062805176,
-0.027746567502617836,
0.573938250541687,
-0.08948012441396713,
0.3792576193809509,
0.34381240606307983,
0.12606512010097504,
-0.29981493949890137,
-0.3832778036594391,
-0.587020754814148,
0.006214465945959091,
-0.14776380360126495,
-0.1031632274389267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19425v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19425v1
|
Adaptive In-conversation Team Building for Language Model Agents
| 2024-05-29T18:08:37 | 2024-05-29T18:08:37 |
Linxin Song, Jiale Liu, Jieyu Zhang, Shaokun Zhang, Ao Luo, Shijian Wang, Qingyun Wu, Chi Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Leveraging multiple large language model (LLM) agents has shown to be a
promising approach for tackling complex tasks, while the effective design of
multiple agents for a particular application remains an art. It is thus
intriguing to answer a critical question: Given a task, how can we build a team
of LLM agents to solve it effectively? Our new adaptive team-building paradigm
offers a flexible solution, realized through a novel agent design named Captain
Agent. It dynamically forms and manages teams for each step of a task-solving
process, utilizing nested group conversations and reflection to ensure diverse
expertise and prevent stereotypical outputs. It allows for a flexible yet
structured approach to problem-solving and can help reduce redundancy and
enhance output diversity. A comprehensive evaluation across six real-world
scenarios demonstrates that Captain Agent significantly outperforms existing
multi-agent methods with 21.94% improvement in average accuracy, providing
outstanding performance without requiring task-specific prompt engineering.
|
[
-0.38007301092147827,
-0.8170161247253418,
0.38089558482170105,
0.4955105185508728,
0.0580071322619915,
1.2193399667739868,
-0.12288901954889297,
-0.6112843155860901,
0.34763699769973755,
0.35579943656921387,
-0.5082828402519226,
-0.21899771690368652,
-0.517576277256012,
0.28672266006469727,
0.1940077841281891,
0.6815710067749023,
0.09646009653806686,
-0.07052550464868546,
0.04112466052174568,
-0.2964399456977844,
-1.1628248691558838,
-0.3664368689060211,
-1.1631741523742676,
-0.39366623759269714,
0.37420737743377686,
0.9041616320610046,
0.9896031022071838,
0.2280062735080719,
0.3633788526058197,
0.4210056662559509,
-0.12016403675079346,
0.5711525678634644,
-0.6613091230392456,
0.575046181678772,
-0.17755134403705597,
-0.5437778234481812,
-1.1321786642074585,
-0.13524839282035828,
0.562320351600647,
0.5311858654022217,
-0.19572575390338898,
-0.06222524493932724,
0.08326009660959244,
0.682615339756012,
-0.12925902009010315,
0.610910952091217,
-1.0483423471450806,
-0.1932365447282791,
0.28904297947883606,
-0.41153380274772644,
-0.5122426152229309,
0.04722990095615387,
0.12642847001552582,
-0.6728472113609314,
0.09647027403116226,
0.27000731229782104,
0.3313617408275604,
0.14365322887897491,
-0.28290820121765137,
-0.3729173243045807,
-0.5415461659431458,
0.6887288689613342,
-0.6747315526008606,
0.013648413121700287,
0.14071166515350342,
0.46247515082359314,
-0.5641644597053528,
-0.23281730711460114,
-0.3638981878757477,
-0.30006706714630127,
0.325377494096756,
0.48399704694747925,
-0.11167017370462418,
0.10557294636964798,
-0.1457575261592865,
0.04118563234806061,
-0.4954359531402588,
0.37009331583976746,
-0.24511471390724182,
0.08144016563892365,
0.8619436621665955,
0.29075825214385986,
0.549663782119751,
0.31885525584220886,
-0.25577738881111145,
0.1802751123905182,
-0.28250670433044434,
-0.1213071271777153,
0.2502273917198181,
0.8687869310379028,
-0.2084423005580902,
0.11646468192338943,
-0.13469554483890533,
0.4004329741001129,
0.3052135407924652,
0.010914566926658154,
0.17493367195129395,
-0.11126166582107544,
-0.12054275721311569,
0.17175400257110596,
0.3720974624156952,
0.574607253074646,
0.3806043863296509,
-0.2967366576194763,
-0.1958674192428589,
0.017845522612333298,
0.48485520482063293,
-0.49354904890060425,
-0.21189169585704803,
0.2630186975002289,
-0.22735458612442017,
-0.4307554364204407,
-0.3096356689929962,
-0.39520591497421265,
-0.6896241903305054,
0.06228942424058914,
0.16053135693073273,
-0.09777383506298065,
-0.5323638319969177,
-0.05350106209516525,
-0.31704261898994446,
0.48251768946647644,
0.5278942584991455,
-0.7553181648254395,
0.349909245967865,
0.37279629707336426,
0.802387535572052,
-0.33168092370033264,
-0.3835981488227844,
-0.6403326392173767,
0.28561273217201233,
-0.64324951171875,
0.9291552901268005,
-0.4920775890350342,
-0.564495861530304,
-0.10684957355260849,
-0.16450180113315582,
-0.14312328398227692,
-0.6379411816596985,
0.12558750808238983,
-0.5085258483886719,
-0.05692817643284798,
-0.10305255651473999,
-0.24148374795913696,
-0.06458576768636703,
0.45148032903671265,
-0.5242947936058044,
0.8177464604377747,
0.13292904198169708,
-0.1845632791519165,
0.28880518674850464,
-1.0391249656677246,
-0.367331326007843,
0.46573179960250854,
0.126107856631279,
-0.22854642570018768,
0.09399688988924026,
0.37942618131637573,
0.49919000267982483,
-0.4290812611579895,
-0.0215174350887537,
-0.2847819924354553,
-0.25713682174682617,
0.3166547417640686,
0.1662282794713974,
0.5117858052253723,
0.24850736558437347,
0.10663887113332748,
0.6259169578552246,
-0.4504123330116272,
-0.026249805465340614,
0.2688885033130646,
-0.3869227468967438,
-0.14816853404045105,
0.10383166372776031,
-0.07182738929986954,
0.12934339046478271,
0.10007186979055405,
-0.2838584780693054,
0.3069259822368622,
-0.2689611613750458,
0.3145581781864166,
0.9521905779838562,
0.01834952086210251,
0.8752644658088684,
-0.8731274604797363,
0.7915538549423218,
-0.23514530062675476,
0.24900776147842407,
-0.015074396505951881,
-0.750914454460144,
-0.6861739158630371,
-0.46357840299606323,
-0.36150062084198,
0.601926863193512,
-1.0158454179763794,
0.1234351322054863,
-0.07058219611644745,
-0.6520628333091736,
-0.3166414797306061,
0.2623412013053894,
0.2861922085285187,
0.4118421971797943,
0.26005998253822327,
-0.4937750995159149,
-0.59331876039505,
-0.6408527493476868,
-0.3730700612068176,
-0.5528566241264343,
0.22780226171016693,
0.27903077006340027,
0.30229443311691284,
-0.07425722479820251,
0.8736995458602905,
-0.34452345967292786,
-0.2474820762872696,
-0.9951615929603577,
0.059679657220840454,
0.39818352460861206,
0.282166987657547,
0.6125719547271729,
-0.7187623381614685,
-1.0693097114562988,
0.07800418883562088,
-0.826447606086731,
-0.20950396358966827,
-0.20287580788135529,
-0.15217597782611847,
0.47964754700660706,
0.5023016333580017,
-0.5401886701583862,
-0.03563382104039192,
0.5966479182243347,
-0.3947991728782654,
0.4253922700881958,
-0.21940267086029053,
-0.05735401064157486,
-1.323814034461975,
-0.3220083713531494,
-0.2649332284927368,
-0.31870514154434204,
-0.999458909034729,
0.39848536252975464,
-0.1636480987071991,
-0.145326629281044,
-0.4109695255756378,
0.5380121469497681,
-0.8530464768409729,
0.06983734667301178,
-0.690855085849762,
0.21517328917980194,
-0.21977874636650085,
0.6015410423278809,
-0.14776363968849182,
0.7883242964744568,
0.5740851759910583,
-0.5808744430541992,
0.4077799618244171,
0.3418549597263336,
0.012813210487365723,
0.674787163734436,
-0.6788579821586609,
0.6088894009590149,
-0.4141305387020111,
0.4122050404548645,
-1.163041114807129,
-0.1456020325422287,
0.4134054481983185,
-0.4234243333339691,
0.38605380058288574,
-0.20039251446723938,
-0.4904394745826721,
-0.2787708640098572,
-0.24243955314159393,
0.3327654302120209,
0.335743248462677,
-0.2868139147758484,
1.0180705785751343,
0.5824384093284607,
-0.5183324813842773,
-0.30440598726272583,
-0.46281126141548157,
0.4702227711677551,
-0.22672154009342194,
-0.7954272031784058,
0.40210825204849243,
-0.5452796816825867,
-0.4665345847606659,
-0.1699780523777008,
-0.33657604455947876,
-0.40359261631965637,
0.34446364641189575,
0.20461206138134003,
0.3121953010559082,
-0.06546319276094437,
0.25093626976013184,
-0.133178249001503,
0.04624610394239426,
-0.24423366785049438,
0.17785605788230896,
0.5838785171508789,
-0.3198195695877075,
0.10724734514951706,
-0.08457525074481964,
0.6564099192619324,
0.7252140641212463,
-0.2581399977207184,
0.8081684708595276,
0.07688287645578384,
-0.18106789886951447,
-0.5821089744567871,
-0.5482569932937622,
-0.07818803936243057,
-0.5222947597503662,
0.6448504328727722,
-0.5602797865867615,
-0.749825656414032,
0.9514579176902771,
0.12683817744255066,
0.419478178024292,
0.12803848087787628,
0.6280538439750671,
-0.20009048283100128,
0.7269695401191711,
0.8973371982574463,
-0.1455487310886383,
0.5133693814277649,
0.15016694366931915,
0.08652760088443756,
-0.4571971893310547,
-0.06149197742342949,
-0.28746291995048523,
-0.364621102809906,
-0.31225404143333435,
-0.49147772789001465,
0.3831443786621094,
-0.25650113821029663,
-0.1836797297000885,
0.4179311692714691,
-0.3987743854522705,
0.5441313982009888,
0.1684867888689041,
0.024326112121343613,
0.44713765382766724,
-0.4654925465583801,
0.3948078453540802,
0.4254305958747864,
-0.9033494591712952,
-0.4523736834526062,
1.0755537748336792,
0.4129367768764496,
0.6034917831420898,
0.4825685918331146,
0.46134012937545776,
0.5391994118690491,
0.4905775189399719,
-0.8490728735923767,
0.720184862613678,
0.2666991651058197,
-0.7579429745674133,
-0.5064629316329956,
-0.20363809168338776,
-0.8962818384170532,
0.4657004475593567,
-0.40661075711250305,
-0.3542470633983612,
-0.2809019982814789,
0.07942323386669159,
-0.23644699156284332,
0.14876022934913635,
-0.928929328918457,
0.5796690583229065,
-0.0646401196718216,
-0.11056048423051834,
-0.4630732536315918,
-0.47976693511009216,
0.06240202113986015,
-0.40548834204673767,
0.2695274353027344,
-0.3297802805900574,
-0.012967560440301895,
0.44268760085105896,
-0.2449985146522522,
0.936557412147522,
-0.12678992748260498,
-0.04307993873953819,
0.42140665650367737,
0.035003647208213806,
0.5985883474349976,
-0.140968456864357,
-0.29455694556236267,
-0.13032861053943634,
-0.521492063999176,
-0.6988089084625244,
-0.6741036772727966,
0.4010608196258545,
-0.7089803218841553,
-0.8455684185028076,
-0.4032898247241974,
-1.3278313875198364,
-0.3285299837589264,
0.060280557721853256,
-0.26731181144714355,
0.1556471884250641,
-0.3515860140323639,
-0.019723935052752495,
0.25742441415786743,
-0.34639739990234375,
0.8126345872879028,
0.7973374128341675,
-0.0716855451464653,
-0.27226266264915466,
0.6009054780006409,
0.05488366261124611,
0.7173995971679688,
0.4506876468658447,
0.05432873219251633,
-0.015780752524733543,
-0.7491756677627563,
-0.16744527220726013,
0.07933234423398972,
-0.620902955532074,
-0.14999492466449738,
-0.3893287479877472,
-0.12979750335216522,
-0.29212743043899536,
-0.3597877323627472,
-0.466555655002594,
-0.23021256923675537,
0.006435940507799387,
-0.03902587667107582,
0.23816564679145813,
0.7032812237739563,
0.46495410799980164,
0.5033057332038879,
-0.609120786190033,
0.21572062373161316,
0.4843418002128601,
0.06794499605894089,
-0.14091847836971283,
-0.5529137849807739,
-0.24002651870250702,
-0.16369092464447021,
-0.43400534987449646,
-1.0350273847579956,
0.3266637325286865,
0.2695312201976776,
0.9215623736381531,
-0.19061799347400665,
0.259213924407959,
0.5194839239120483,
-0.36971795558929443,
0.5649601221084595,
0.13156287372112274,
-0.7964544296264648,
0.29528865218162537,
-0.6387290358543396,
0.4657365679740906,
0.19341111183166504,
-0.07146221399307251,
-0.3176140785217285,
-0.9053848385810852,
-0.4924335479736328,
-0.7497775554656982,
0.5853053331375122,
0.22819797694683075,
0.08077111840248108,
0.1870536208152771,
0.2524825930595398,
-0.019344601780176163,
0.11514341831207275,
-0.400974303483963,
-0.14845357835292816,
-0.04816014692187309,
-0.08318071812391281,
-0.3423680365085602,
-0.23232600092887878,
0.02888096496462822,
0.021790189668536186,
0.6945531964302063,
-0.5382600426673889,
0.39780935645103455,
0.019453389570116997,
-0.2874659597873688,
-0.13146527111530304,
0.37553009390830994,
0.6435417532920837,
0.8823776841163635,
-0.32858866453170776,
-0.07156041264533997,
0.6596195101737976,
-0.24704508483409882,
0.044283464550971985,
0.01799955777823925,
0.40705740451812744,
-0.2863137722015381,
0.4104178547859192,
0.49346429109573364,
-0.018070567399263382,
-0.6022355556488037,
0.1337115615606308,
-0.016835682094097137,
-0.23232795298099518,
-0.17954936623573303,
0.16719460487365723,
0.2721344530582428,
0.6550431847572327,
0.6021955609321594,
0.16003479063510895,
-0.20186807215213776,
-0.9688565135002136,
0.011651378124952316,
0.48069509863853455,
-0.30387571454048157,
-0.22549110651016235,
0.599765419960022,
0.5532517433166504,
-0.6290507316589355,
0.397529274225235,
-0.12695185840129852,
-0.5482380986213684,
0.8642654418945312,
0.8001195788383484,
1.0115814208984375,
-0.46844789385795593,
0.22108371555805206,
-0.15784797072410583,
0.4916955828666687,
0.015106198377907276,
0.5043088793754578,
0.31367817521095276,
-1.069703221321106,
-0.4706435203552246,
-0.06320030987262726,
-0.8019177317619324,
-0.28766241669654846,
-0.15798859298229218,
0.015999604016542435,
-0.660467267036438,
-0.22187595069408417,
-0.11953546851873398,
0.08823972940444946,
-0.4044186770915985,
-0.07509110867977142,
0.10356830060482025,
0.8274237513542175,
-0.7431111335754395,
0.7244834303855896,
0.9456334114074707,
-0.49693772196769714,
-0.7354604005813599,
-0.06381280720233917,
-0.029026569798588753,
-0.9784363508224487,
0.3975059986114502,
0.04943215101957321,
-0.26745545864105225,
-0.026697926223278046,
-0.5491852760314941,
-0.5000255703926086,
1.1607146263122559,
0.40955907106399536,
-0.38366517424583435,
-0.06460681557655334,
-0.0008357237093150616,
0.6049367785453796,
-0.783848762512207,
0.3090636134147644,
0.07737407833337784,
0.32331982254981995,
0.1623663455247879,
-1.356211543083191,
0.21108105778694153,
-0.44318071007728577,
-0.02396225742995739,
-0.06549163162708282,
-1.0198901891708374,
0.6818089485168457,
-0.26934245228767395,
-0.0035920371301472187,
0.1124725267291069,
0.7800748348236084,
0.4175221621990204,
0.24256421625614166,
0.8497176766395569,
-0.19672271609306335,
0.9872533679008484,
0.2377515435218811,
0.636667013168335,
-0.30156025290489197,
-0.09078337997198105,
1.226939082145691,
-0.44008782505989075,
0.4809388220310211,
0.4391185939311981,
0.19202759861946106,
0.44793450832366943,
0.11637499928474426,
0.1459740698337555,
0.14332696795463562,
0.18330766260623932,
-0.26269063353538513,
-0.4542158842086792,
-0.13485360145568848,
-0.09686829894781113,
0.6126810908317566,
0.16135771572589874,
-0.058016132563352585,
0.022257568314671516,
-0.25349387526512146,
-0.039019469171762466,
0.3342559039592743,
-0.5100398063659668,
0.585493266582489,
0.12254788726568222,
-0.6660393476486206,
0.39822742342948914,
-0.17415587604045868,
0.4941917955875397,
-0.4801596403121948,
-0.11139649152755737,
-0.3242548108100891,
0.281096488237381,
-0.14730873703956604,
-0.6487092971801758,
0.24333350360393524,
-0.1882527619600296,
-0.3500096797943115,
-0.5474397540092468,
0.8045732975006104,
-0.4243674874305725,
-0.21617485582828522,
0.29235193133354187,
0.858802318572998,
0.04850558564066887,
-0.29658204317092896,
-0.5917519330978394,
0.1254299134016037,
-0.27152737975120544,
0.17559248208999634,
0.19830158352851868,
0.1058158129453659,
-0.1461813747882843,
1.0338618755340576,
0.4804518520832062,
-0.1389450579881668,
0.11989467591047287,
0.08758842200040817,
0.7880111932754517,
-0.5294326543807983,
-0.6393429040908813,
-0.6598499417304993,
0.7246077060699463,
-0.23145049810409546,
-0.12940570712089539,
0.7267743349075317,
0.543181300163269,
0.47347381711006165,
-0.2264796495437622,
0.8547051548957825,
0.1706685870885849,
0.40364018082618713,
-0.13782159984111786,
0.8679430484771729,
-0.49828752875328064,
0.2996397912502289,
-0.6569480299949646,
-0.972062349319458,
-0.5475576519966125,
0.5555930733680725,
0.2538355886936188,
0.032327309250831604,
0.5784813165664673,
0.8835164904594421,
0.21521618962287903,
0.1530095487833023,
0.2532176077365875,
0.390047550201416,
0.9020799398422241,
0.7697310447692871,
1.0610800981521606,
-0.18642351031303406,
0.6701144576072693,
0.4103262424468994,
-0.4899219870567322,
-0.07701425999403,
-0.9544716477394104,
-1.3134714365005493,
-0.35760822892189026,
-0.48836442828178406,
-0.15680170059204102,
0.29924172163009644,
1.257757306098938,
0.6221979260444641,
-0.5515417456626892,
-0.6442410349845886,
-0.09242452681064606,
0.2557966709136963,
-0.6009838581085205,
-0.13128583133220673,
-0.047590721398591995,
-0.5545305013656616,
-0.8232513070106506,
1.013410210609436,
0.2408788651227951,
-0.11549769341945648,
0.1117417961359024,
-0.48814070224761963,
-0.17217327654361725,
0.28339871764183044,
0.6995635032653809,
0.35003653168678284,
-0.38247784972190857,
-0.44187235832214355,
0.04103785753250122,
0.01036704983562231,
0.18776018917560577,
0.4477806091308594,
-0.4683254361152649,
0.6320196986198425,
0.43399977684020996,
0.7058888077735901,
0.2842966616153717,
-0.20773805677890778,
1.021490216255188,
-0.5544095635414124,
0.06984153389930725,
0.12964753806591034,
0.22833169996738434,
0.187850683927536,
-0.15139415860176086,
0.516166627407074,
0.2369084656238556,
-0.650023877620697,
-0.7818847894668579,
0.28459712862968445,
-1.3827468156814575,
-0.3394656181335449,
1.0200037956237793,
0.1885530799627304,
0.20307284593582153,
-0.4942123293876648,
-0.5061601996421814,
0.36923977732658386,
-0.8144699335098267,
0.7800944447517395,
0.602371096611023,
-0.24971051514148712,
-0.23407894372940063,
-0.3436732292175293,
0.09415264427661896,
0.42256370186805725,
-0.8767476677894592,
-0.16074956953525543,
0.2490665465593338,
0.31218963861465454,
-0.027069982141256332,
1.0558137893676758,
0.32248347997665405,
0.11624425649642944,
-0.01872081123292446,
0.042988020926713943,
-0.2993803918361664,
-0.5259924530982971,
0.12507934868335724,
0.4236595332622528,
0.46100014448165894,
-0.3451932668685913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19335v1
|
X-VILA: Cross-Modality Alignment for Large Language Model
| 2024-05-29T17:59:58 | 2024-05-29T17:59:58 |
Hanrong Ye, De-An Huang, Yao Lu, Zhiding Yu, Wei Ping, Andrew Tao, Jan Kautz, Song Han, Dan Xu, Pavlo Molchanov, Hongxu Yin
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce X-VILA, an omni-modality model designed to extend the
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) by incorporating image, video, and
audio modalities. By aligning modality-specific encoders with LLM inputs and
diffusion decoders with LLM outputs, X-VILA achieves cross-modality
understanding, reasoning, and generation. To facilitate this cross-modality
alignment, we curate an effective interleaved any-to-any modality
instruction-following dataset. Furthermore, we identify a significant problem
with the current cross-modality alignment method, which results in visual
information loss. To address the issue, we propose a visual alignment mechanism
with a visual embedding highway module. We then introduce a resource-efficient
recipe for training X-VILA, that exhibits proficiency in any-to-any modality
conversation, surpassing previous approaches by large margins. X-VILA also
showcases emergent properties across modalities even in the absence of similar
training data. The project will be made open-source.
|
[
-0.3101537227630615,
-0.9583143591880798,
0.5291087031364441,
-0.17594614624977112,
-0.24779750406742096,
-0.08732777833938599,
-0.3254837095737457,
-0.2595667243003845,
0.3971606194972992,
0.5180203914642334,
-0.3560327887535095,
-0.6114463210105896,
-0.4030134677886963,
-0.37881702184677124,
-0.32822924852371216,
0.6194905638694763,
-0.17068439722061157,
0.48100870847702026,
-0.15010781586170197,
-0.25258395075798035,
-0.6202975511550903,
-0.18068315088748932,
-0.5277742743492126,
0.08788752555847168,
0.616818904876709,
0.28432372212409973,
0.9393506050109863,
1.1162419319152832,
0.24956932663917542,
0.27801910042762756,
0.18034541606903076,
0.09706894308328629,
-0.6775377988815308,
0.09131155908107758,
-0.25427818298339844,
-0.5630054473876953,
-0.6419106721878052,
-0.3622911870479584,
1.0946627855300903,
0.5681629776954651,
0.03982333466410637,
0.08840145170688629,
-0.25816240906715393,
0.31541353464126587,
-0.6386092901229858,
0.3030785620212555,
-0.5237703323364258,
-0.05875822901725769,
-0.3965320885181427,
-0.41725853085517883,
-0.389236181974411,
-0.14526233077049255,
0.14445221424102783,
-0.5072036981582642,
-0.32407233119010925,
0.3042663335800171,
0.7273901104927063,
0.3874974250793457,
-0.7357322573661804,
-0.038884248584508896,
-0.6146154403686523,
0.5961290597915649,
-0.23236776888370514,
0.9824098944664001,
0.03018803894519806,
0.42300331592559814,
-0.05857235565781593,
-0.215852752327919,
-0.699044406414032,
-0.1021241620182991,
0.25790005922317505,
0.12686672806739807,
-0.23729217052459717,
0.06803938746452332,
-0.09316735714673996,
0.26936638355255127,
-0.8322784304618835,
0.14031797647476196,
-0.22943392395973206,
0.261724054813385,
0.3781771659851074,
0.36355361342430115,
0.43797767162323,
-0.250868558883667,
-0.5024902820587158,
-0.05504373088479042,
-0.8315005898475647,
0.08680611848831177,
0.36432990431785583,
0.28971636295318604,
-0.33065173029899597,
0.8833914995193481,
0.2292020320892334,
0.900994598865509,
-0.10209030658006668,
-0.3032745122909546,
0.15591594576835632,
-0.3630320727825165,
-0.47298312187194824,
0.21674035489559174,
0.8011722564697266,
0.20360741019248962,
-0.1823846697807312,
0.016689764335751534,
-0.014595955610275269,
0.058039627969264984,
0.2481534481048584,
-0.3702751100063324,
-0.035964421927928925,
-0.15680037438869476,
-0.36439746618270874,
-0.298717200756073,
-0.0716470405459404,
-0.5566349029541016,
-0.23503375053405762,
-0.48317867517471313,
0.7815259099006653,
-0.40851691365242004,
-0.3759762644767761,
0.13942809402942657,
0.18032297492027283,
0.6782948970794678,
0.37837231159210205,
-0.8047281503677368,
0.19323760271072388,
0.6108481287956238,
0.612277626991272,
-0.2230600267648697,
-0.30425944924354553,
-0.6958287954330444,
0.43505048751831055,
-0.37302908301353455,
0.47182756662368774,
-0.8984325528144836,
-0.31372368335723877,
-0.03631826490163803,
-0.006648716516792774,
0.0285606998950243,
-0.1094721257686615,
0.45028698444366455,
-0.37179410457611084,
0.30122193694114685,
-0.3076586127281189,
-0.35315003991127014,
-0.18370307981967926,
0.3867271840572357,
-0.6442355513572693,
0.77878737449646,
0.18948546051979065,
-0.5759929418563843,
0.27861863374710083,
-0.5654719471931458,
-0.16522791981697083,
-0.20984181761741638,
-0.8327476382255554,
-0.41003933548927307,
0.2355453222990036,
0.08768749982118607,
0.2587548494338989,
-0.60896235704422,
0.33186450600624084,
-0.242916077375412,
-0.12221220880746841,
0.2829357981681824,
-0.6583366990089417,
0.8301987648010254,
-0.13468389213085175,
-0.35441580414772034,
0.36848515272140503,
-0.826776921749115,
-0.040027134120464325,
0.07561950385570526,
-0.32790395617485046,
-0.44350263476371765,
-0.0975714921951294,
0.10874376446008682,
0.2640664279460907,
0.03536849096417427,
-0.604195237159729,
0.46767038106918335,
-0.0757814273238182,
0.10264033079147339,
0.8382757902145386,
-0.4940250813961029,
0.6161656975746155,
-0.25085482001304626,
0.8772227168083191,
0.0860288217663765,
0.35324206948280334,
-0.31695035099983215,
-0.6372646689414978,
-0.7243529558181763,
-0.6064611673355103,
0.36657625436782837,
0.4018184542655945,
-0.9723941087722778,
0.3958551287651062,
-0.7454311847686768,
-0.2800542414188385,
-0.8218362927436829,
0.06491139531135559,
0.7414270639419556,
0.5414532423019409,
0.17066924273967743,
-0.49165835976600647,
-0.7174890637397766,
-0.73487389087677,
0.23533819615840912,
-0.14280125498771667,
0.41679877042770386,
0.3511791527271271,
0.2541062831878662,
-0.40275460481643677,
0.9479790329933167,
-0.3160035312175751,
-0.34089377522468567,
-0.08793552219867706,
-0.034663233906030655,
-0.2336246818304062,
0.4207025468349457,
0.6414705514907837,
-0.829842746257782,
-0.41811272501945496,
0.3664225935935974,
-0.6791205406188965,
-0.0593678243458271,
0.008302576839923859,
-0.4276943504810333,
0.4303107261657715,
0.6885071396827698,
-0.3242623805999756,
0.37331119179725647,
1.0339475870132446,
-0.4457184374332428,
0.2910887598991394,
0.06872671842575073,
0.2755858302116394,
-1.215587854385376,
-0.039157528430223465,
-0.12659363448619843,
-0.6594206690788269,
-0.3942674398422241,
-0.08303221315145493,
-0.09654586017131805,
-0.19164031744003296,
-0.46112510561943054,
0.639746904373169,
-0.7053086757659912,
-0.20816220343112946,
0.004683869890868664,
0.3225066661834717,
-0.1309673935174942,
0.5714065432548523,
0.32350224256515503,
0.5382166504859924,
0.9370498657226562,
0.020135261118412018,
0.3872775733470917,
0.44054052233695984,
-0.2931557595729828,
0.8522617220878601,
-0.33344849944114685,
-0.2215379774570465,
-0.26474452018737793,
0.16968101263046265,
-0.9726755619049072,
-0.060737982392311096,
0.3860361874103546,
-0.44124817848205566,
0.5645877718925476,
-0.44566142559051514,
-0.13098788261413574,
0.14647004008293152,
-0.3614109754562378,
0.6710672378540039,
0.3968369960784912,
-0.6094216108322144,
1.0486940145492554,
0.4837760329246521,
-0.2008974254131317,
-0.5031992793083191,
-0.6415055394172668,
0.19861026108264923,
-0.01049646083265543,
-0.7333006858825684,
0.1446944624185562,
-0.1202445849776268,
-0.044818464666604996,
0.2556111812591553,
0.06099671497941017,
-0.08660636842250824,
-0.4831494092941284,
0.37073713541030884,
0.5096819400787354,
-0.5183050632476807,
0.11188796162605286,
0.160976380109787,
-0.11632273346185684,
0.08677051961421967,
-0.336608350276947,
0.45333001017570496,
0.04557862505316734,
-0.6827042698860168,
-0.07087792456150055,
0.6852065324783325,
0.6715624332427979,
-0.30341634154319763,
0.6528169512748718,
0.5849816203117371,
-0.13695695996284485,
0.145105242729187,
-0.4027731120586395,
0.45032402873039246,
-0.3977383077144623,
0.32818612456321716,
-0.44194296002388,
-1.0430880784988403,
0.12372982501983643,
0.1485711932182312,
-0.047230564057826996,
-0.09593704342842102,
0.7911539077758789,
0.14111211895942688,
1.4051719903945923,
1.0233383178710938,
0.05385080352425575,
0.8330327868461609,
-0.3625496029853821,
0.3222768306732178,
-0.8624928593635559,
-0.4706326127052307,
-0.1204027533531189,
-0.3847852051258087,
-0.3838588297367096,
-0.9163147807121277,
0.45793408155441284,
-0.3344687819480896,
-0.09582634270191193,
0.30254432559013367,
-0.24616014957427979,
0.5418872237205505,
0.5010444521903992,
0.10004016757011414,
0.4487447738647461,
-0.15886661410331726,
-0.022082263603806496,
-0.1362760066986084,
-0.8867595791816711,
-0.26588040590286255,
0.9721672534942627,
0.25592562556266785,
1.26084566116333,
0.40467846393585205,
0.6201180219650269,
-0.040893394500017166,
0.24124982953071594,
-0.9470176100730896,
0.5550776720046997,
0.08068552613258362,
-0.5378908514976501,
-0.31454676389694214,
-0.543302059173584,
-0.8934025764465332,
0.1521063894033432,
-0.4356645941734314,
-0.5953271389007568,
0.41491639614105225,
0.15371444821357727,
-0.15893031656742096,
0.5059172511100769,
-0.5382506847381592,
1.0710170269012451,
-0.6541404128074646,
-0.28457704186439514,
0.07216670364141464,
-0.8590604662895203,
0.6028743982315063,
-0.17900115251541138,
0.0659632682800293,
0.16114261746406555,
-0.4766441285610199,
0.3484984338283539,
-0.2720642685890198,
0.9003899693489075,
0.19388188421726227,
-0.5238562822341919,
0.04773271828889847,
0.04446163773536682,
0.13724863529205322,
-0.08034340292215347,
0.3630986511707306,
0.061756432056427,
-0.21415674686431885,
-0.3327001929283142,
-0.6895092129707336,
0.8253120183944702,
-0.8330599069595337,
-0.4528391361236572,
-0.1538798063993454,
-0.7642768621444702,
-0.061353374272584915,
0.045887384563684464,
0.15075187385082245,
0.6326150894165039,
-0.4330082833766937,
0.2589031159877777,
0.889838457107544,
-0.0752289742231369,
0.03911099582910538,
0.44308143854141235,
-0.5834307074546814,
-0.7302093505859375,
1.1240253448486328,
0.09401650726795197,
0.5147209763526917,
0.7441146969795227,
0.055619921535253525,
-0.16974663734436035,
-0.296709269285202,
-0.6055011749267578,
0.2875048518180847,
-0.7300087809562683,
-0.29628902673721313,
-0.6936502456665039,
0.05917394906282425,
-0.41679272055625916,
-0.41061410307884216,
-0.46402233839035034,
-0.468563437461853,
-0.14577031135559082,
0.09596121311187744,
0.1722540706396103,
0.6504927277565002,
-0.07897953689098358,
0.30923599004745483,
-0.932610034942627,
0.4388892650604248,
0.45459815859794617,
0.31187936663627625,
-0.3336293697357178,
-0.6032357215881348,
-0.32927465438842773,
0.04221644997596741,
-0.18992877006530762,
-0.8194907903671265,
0.2740493416786194,
0.06960929930210114,
0.5754272937774658,
0.6241408586502075,
-0.37615567445755005,
0.8092999458312988,
-0.5144530534744263,
0.5855349898338318,
0.5518597364425659,
-1.2270798683166504,
0.4156931936740875,
-0.5146457552909851,
0.15076413750648499,
0.2790272533893585,
0.6983743906021118,
-0.27445414662361145,
-0.1368769258260727,
-0.46904289722442627,
-0.6077175140380859,
0.44797050952911377,
-0.028980616480112076,
-0.06437595188617706,
-0.11015626788139343,
-0.0017294681165367365,
0.2423788160085678,
0.1567893773317337,
-0.8283727765083313,
-0.07775942981243134,
-0.11755112558603287,
-0.3449711799621582,
0.08303379267454147,
-0.08175370842218399,
-0.34194135665893555,
-0.48316141963005066,
0.6858499646186829,
-0.3257230818271637,
0.22405485808849335,
-0.026204055175185204,
-0.31655508279800415,
-0.3316439986228943,
0.14897334575653076,
0.6469612717628479,
0.5569934844970703,
0.20333009958267212,
0.13219259679317474,
0.03669818118214607,
-0.1759088784456253,
0.30433332920074463,
-0.12476395815610886,
0.003912598825991154,
0.03920656442642212,
0.1718299686908722,
0.9922143220901489,
0.4713820815086365,
-0.8440749645233154,
0.818213164806366,
-0.19035209715366364,
-0.08198204636573792,
-0.10248031467199326,
-0.05165261775255203,
-0.039977069944143295,
0.6476610898971558,
-0.2984607517719269,
-0.10571958124637604,
-0.02694115601480007,
-0.9744369387626648,
-0.13748662173748016,
0.6120935678482056,
-0.627306342124939,
-0.34690922498703003,
0.8380946516990662,
0.24760702252388,
-0.3054969012737274,
0.3033413887023926,
0.054192833602428436,
-0.337212473154068,
0.056859031319618225,
0.3795807361602783,
0.9283167719841003,
-0.22209616005420685,
0.056162185966968536,
-0.1400403380393982,
0.2627584636211395,
0.0036870723124593496,
0.6913978457450867,
-0.25455015897750854,
-0.6005159616470337,
-0.5852328538894653,
-0.3545043170452118,
-0.5891905426979065,
-0.34164372086524963,
-0.6644553542137146,
0.7083995938301086,
-0.14390237629413605,
-0.18251550197601318,
-0.30114689469337463,
-0.5017372369766235,
-0.5915044546127319,
0.11315248161554337,
0.4416060745716095,
0.8248577117919922,
-1.1298068761825562,
1.005804419517517,
0.7691423296928406,
-0.6206565499305725,
-0.631275475025177,
-0.3689877688884735,
0.16830062866210938,
-0.9734314680099487,
0.6118711829185486,
-0.13974277675151825,
-0.34480178356170654,
-0.0526776984333992,
-0.6528189182281494,
-0.9637922644615173,
1.1653691530227661,
0.7723131775856018,
-0.6060190200805664,
-0.2596147358417511,
0.11121215671300888,
0.24398548901081085,
-0.6640204787254333,
-0.014437714591622353,
0.5739648938179016,
0.44098961353302,
0.10776834189891815,
-0.8785014152526855,
-0.027545049786567688,
-0.2909505367279053,
0.18249332904815674,
0.6177751421928406,
-0.4860595166683197,
0.6842009425163269,
-0.1724434494972229,
-0.010069438256323338,
0.20108258724212646,
0.7098925113677979,
-0.04499179497361183,
-0.09258334338665009,
0.4325997829437256,
0.9375379085540771,
0.4094898998737335,
-0.09216032177209854,
0.878396213054657,
-0.15605072677135468,
-0.07283715903759003,
1.326797366142273,
-0.1748012751340866,
0.8032196760177612,
0.5938687920570374,
0.2859954237937927,
0.43244436383247375,
0.09383206069469452,
0.23622699081897736,
0.3131210207939148,
0.07762560993432999,
-0.23543693125247955,
-0.4233059287071228,
-0.25319457054138184,
-0.3217216730117798,
0.9306129217147827,
0.20666766166687012,
-0.46064239740371704,
-0.13589929044246674,
0.2870219349861145,
0.04365774244070053,
-0.11324290186166763,
-0.1912904530763626,
0.71644526720047,
-0.13238273561000824,
-0.4207458198070526,
0.7049335837364197,
-0.38154906034469604,
0.5396376848220825,
-0.7499334812164307,
-0.18796345591545105,
0.14538682997226715,
-0.02140497975051403,
-0.18194636702537537,
-0.9013647437095642,
0.13956616818904877,
-0.19922427833080292,
-0.20156817138195038,
-0.33913901448249817,
0.36582890152931213,
-0.9965434074401855,
-0.2939116358757019,
0.33307307958602905,
0.655569314956665,
0.14647342264652252,
0.18520353734493256,
-0.4657748341560364,
0.6269171833992004,
-0.08555268496274948,
-0.10245048999786377,
0.29430657625198364,
0.7624204158782959,
-0.2963045537471771,
0.5382986664772034,
0.4281119704246521,
0.13106684386730194,
0.39195898175239563,
0.21085165441036224,
1.153551459312439,
-0.6866077184677124,
-0.2686897814273834,
-0.6371605396270752,
0.6551926136016846,
0.13266855478286743,
-0.32369565963745117,
0.6621728539466858,
0.6045907139778137,
0.9662157297134399,
0.09852446615695953,
0.6931838989257812,
-0.04441682621836662,
-0.13485479354858398,
-0.6965689659118652,
0.2797611653804779,
-0.7682939171791077,
0.04027789831161499,
-0.29826903343200684,
-1.0457465648651123,
-0.2832023501396179,
0.4419368803501129,
-0.056739021092653275,
-0.043469835072755814,
0.6276766657829285,
1.0106170177459717,
-0.30363795161247253,
-0.18723942339420319,
0.7665042877197266,
0.23267485201358795,
0.37258803844451904,
0.47926032543182373,
0.8466507196426392,
-0.3695855438709259,
0.9108730554580688,
0.08426473289728165,
-0.49555057287216187,
-0.21945926547050476,
-0.9727863073348999,
-0.934581995010376,
-0.6299743056297302,
-0.3776097595691681,
-0.04018300026655197,
0.03797796368598938,
1.0542113780975342,
0.7385358810424805,
-0.1340157836675644,
-0.38289934396743774,
0.24307863414287567,
-0.0238123070448637,
0.06541165709495544,
-0.1473725140094757,
-0.026921842247247696,
0.01352798379957676,
-0.7286840677261353,
0.554328441619873,
0.8085107803344727,
0.16014470160007477,
-0.7523282766342163,
-0.1645374298095703,
-0.2830630838871002,
0.26473110914230347,
0.743337869644165,
0.40083053708076477,
-0.7032405138015747,
-0.28622034192085266,
0.10752271860837936,
-0.12187856435775757,
0.43369680643081665,
0.9819062352180481,
-0.7292998433113098,
0.7343336939811707,
0.8149073719978333,
0.7467851042747498,
0.34228891134262085,
-0.20115628838539124,
0.8310038447380066,
-0.6230900883674622,
-0.06417273730039597,
-0.020843252539634705,
0.7381481528282166,
0.3945014476776123,
-0.048185523599386215,
0.38885393738746643,
-0.09187840670347214,
-0.5078904032707214,
-0.7399581074714661,
0.3242926299571991,
-1.4171775579452515,
0.013224146328866482,
1.0095739364624023,
0.1513110101222992,
-0.6205848455429077,
-0.07630270719528198,
-0.656669020652771,
0.2503089904785156,
-0.25500407814979553,
0.43417268991470337,
0.2051309496164322,
0.008665256202220917,
-0.4335167407989502,
-0.4059523642063141,
-0.04601177200675011,
0.31133830547332764,
-0.9293369054794312,
0.021210720762610435,
0.6478264927864075,
0.1030300036072731,
0.14642921090126038,
0.5926893949508667,
-0.38662758469581604,
0.46000558137893677,
-0.031059004366397858,
0.22557710111141205,
-0.045875269919633865,
-0.5428690314292908,
-0.6044411063194275,
-0.2728407084941864,
-0.04929511621594429,
-0.21713480353355408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19334v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19334v2
|
LLMs Meet Multimodal Generation and Editing: A Survey
| 2024-05-29T17:59:20 | 2024-06-09T11:34:12 |
Yingqing He, Zhaoyang Liu, Jingye Chen, Zeyue Tian, Hongyu Liu, Xiaowei Chi, Runtao Liu, Ruibin Yuan, Yazhou Xing, Wenhai Wang, Jifeng Dai, Yong Zhang, Wei Xue, Qifeng Liu, Yike Guo, Qifeng Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM, cs.SD
|
With the recent advancement in large language models (LLMs), there is a
growing interest in combining LLMs with multimodal learning. Previous surveys
of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) mainly focus on multimodal
understanding. This survey elaborates on multimodal generation and editing
across various domains, comprising image, video, 3D, and audio. Specifically,
we summarize the notable advancements with milestone works in these fields and
categorize these studies into LLM-based and CLIP/T5-based methods. Then, we
summarize the various roles of LLMs in multimodal generation and exhaustively
investigate the critical technical components behind these methods and the
multimodal datasets utilized in these studies. Additionally, we dig into
tool-augmented multimodal agents that can leverage existing generative models
for human-computer interaction. Lastly, we discuss the advancements in the
generative AI safety field, investigate emerging applications, and discuss
future prospects. Our work provides a systematic and insightful overview of
multimodal generation and processing, which is expected to advance the
development of Artificial Intelligence for Generative Content (AIGC) and world
models. A curated list of all related papers can be found at
https://github.com/YingqingHe/Awesome-LLMs-meet-Multimodal-Generation
|
[
-0.4786319434642792,
-0.9186519384384155,
0.6806201934814453,
0.1330449879169464,
0.2862077057361603,
0.3573906421661377,
-0.2521519660949707,
-0.5072565674781799,
0.08314631134271622,
0.2710080146789551,
-0.5128875374794006,
-0.5372036695480347,
-0.5803226232528687,
0.18796861171722412,
-0.21230141818523407,
0.5814357995986938,
-0.06918401271104813,
0.18146786093711853,
-0.6782614588737488,
-0.08664733171463013,
-0.46117427945137024,
-0.5992433428764343,
-0.5339705348014832,
-0.11226588487625122,
0.6440942883491516,
0.19695663452148438,
0.5312907695770264,
0.4595417380332947,
0.32847094535827637,
0.4483523964881897,
-0.1692776381969452,
0.667691707611084,
-0.12027832120656967,
0.4581971764564514,
0.025261640548706055,
-0.3078647255897522,
-0.8618441820144653,
-0.023583117872476578,
0.7425732016563416,
0.4797596335411072,
0.052690837532281876,
-0.11757533252239227,
-0.10216395556926727,
0.2512328624725342,
-0.5823827385902405,
0.01977578178048134,
-0.572405219078064,
0.12429527193307877,
-0.17712901532649994,
-0.294080913066864,
-0.38805511593818665,
-0.15772083401679993,
-0.28164932131767273,
-0.47885000705718994,
0.3412455916404724,
-0.053376954048871994,
0.2938554286956787,
0.28973838686943054,
-0.7879740595817566,
-0.3102990984916687,
-0.6602758765220642,
0.9029847383499146,
-0.3538558781147003,
0.6261504292488098,
0.2653881907463074,
0.1544257402420044,
-0.2159186750650406,
-0.8489307165145874,
-0.7190589904785156,
-0.2174437791109085,
0.41257378458976746,
0.15112479031085968,
-0.054338615387678146,
0.37381473183631897,
0.25154292583465576,
0.4093705415725708,
-0.4034736156463623,
0.33901792764663696,
-0.21804820001125336,
-0.3648427724838257,
0.7098895311355591,
0.41702425479888916,
0.5480735301971436,
-0.16017907857894897,
-0.39967527985572815,
-0.1630411595106125,
-0.8651596307754517,
-0.21345846354961395,
0.29219359159469604,
-0.13301067054271698,
-0.16843482851982117,
0.7766091227531433,
-0.01925019547343254,
0.768215537071228,
-0.26418688893318176,
-0.5166435241699219,
0.17366652190685272,
-0.7996766567230225,
0.005593845155090094,
-0.30633217096328735,
0.84347003698349,
0.7540820837020874,
0.056406065821647644,
0.00704613933339715,
-0.2035870999097824,
-0.08811219036579132,
0.09336428344249725,
-0.5135924220085144,
-0.01790398359298706,
0.049290381371974945,
-0.4813181757926941,
-0.2805844843387604,
-0.11560118943452835,
-0.8076400756835938,
-0.6388691663742065,
-0.4333484470844269,
0.11806395649909973,
-0.2822229564189911,
-0.2134663611650467,
-0.08550545573234558,
-0.17134979367256165,
0.1402975618839264,
0.6885209083557129,
-0.9764172434806824,
-0.23113372921943665,
0.38650065660476685,
0.7456309199333191,
-0.06436783820390701,
-0.6263754963874817,
-0.34430763125419617,
0.4030326306819916,
-0.2591848373413086,
0.8017042875289917,
-0.4502946138381958,
-0.5594899654388428,
0.2310653030872345,
-0.2084628790616989,
0.12552042305469513,
-0.4119987189769745,
0.26427751779556274,
-0.5085870623588562,
0.2083670049905777,
-0.02973858267068863,
-0.4399249851703644,
-0.15392597019672394,
0.6142962574958801,
-0.7007712125778198,
0.6955330967903137,
-0.28783512115478516,
-0.4827955663204193,
0.30841436982154846,
-0.6101704835891724,
-0.3570106625556946,
-0.14692863821983337,
-0.09699936956167221,
-0.3211914002895355,
0.10478132218122482,
0.3702220022678375,
0.6517661213874817,
-0.2746773064136505,
0.1797218918800354,
-0.4121992588043213,
0.1889152079820633,
0.6332988142967224,
-0.662057101726532,
0.38470813632011414,
0.2505068778991699,
0.19371286034584045,
0.5182022452354431,
-0.5777742862701416,
0.015294061973690987,
0.044741515070199966,
-0.550500750541687,
0.17345963418483734,
0.15062424540519714,
0.45445266366004944,
0.4322649836540222,
0.36705639958381653,
-0.5535404682159424,
0.26389822363853455,
0.342594712972641,
0.6344132423400879,
0.8136624097824097,
0.12163921445608139,
0.2856775224208832,
-0.2829732298851013,
0.6102028489112854,
-0.008538213558495045,
0.3732835650444031,
-0.560828685760498,
-0.329828679561615,
-0.549521803855896,
-0.4070276618003845,
0.2589336633682251,
0.3220162093639374,
-1.1380447149276733,
-0.05670838803052902,
-0.09912221878767014,
-0.33536791801452637,
-0.4100595712661743,
0.42839697003364563,
0.2617134749889374,
0.013266411609947681,
0.2236657589673996,
-0.1887333244085312,
-0.6533677577972412,
-0.6564888954162598,
-0.015371840447187424,
-0.08097390085458755,
0.10872982442378998,
0.2483319342136383,
0.15373292565345764,
-0.5206507444381714,
0.8819931149482727,
-0.3522375226020813,
-0.20794281363487244,
-0.5732677578926086,
0.032694801688194275,
-0.45016875863075256,
0.436277836561203,
0.6713719964027405,
-0.8357173800468445,
-0.3928288519382477,
-0.17121534049510956,
-0.9166377782821655,
0.07124720513820648,
-0.05786243826150894,
0.22912250459194183,
0.2254491001367569,
0.8772361278533936,
-0.8756353855133057,
-0.02015506662428379,
0.6702144145965576,
-0.08996181190013885,
0.529065728187561,
-0.34656980633735657,
0.2509375214576721,
-1.2223777770996094,
-0.28989166021347046,
-0.07745235413312912,
-0.4029829204082489,
-0.734613835811615,
0.008963181637227535,
-0.013044602237641811,
-0.07257188111543655,
-0.6532279253005981,
0.4058711528778076,
-0.712917685508728,
-0.19461147487163544,
-0.34394508600234985,
0.23135636746883392,
0.025251097977161407,
0.27949443459510803,
-0.03213872015476227,
0.8338146209716797,
0.5295050740242004,
-0.4083012640476227,
0.6777641773223877,
0.3810197710990906,
-0.2967754304409027,
0.44450587034225464,
-0.37823793292045593,
0.23136946558952332,
-0.16938571631908417,
0.2789245843887329,
-0.750358521938324,
-0.6048515439033508,
0.0988202691078186,
-0.34670037031173706,
0.2705688178539276,
0.09969234466552734,
-0.8011685609817505,
-0.02532041259109974,
-0.5931457281112671,
0.5429534912109375,
0.1458907127380371,
-0.4816620647907257,
0.5880637168884277,
0.6305992007255554,
-0.4583542048931122,
-0.4410187602043152,
-0.4813541769981384,
0.4260341227054596,
-0.19176219403743744,
-0.6844497323036194,
0.3281788229942322,
-0.39811304211616516,
-0.3539058268070221,
-0.18936598300933838,
0.3193436861038208,
0.05267380177974701,
-0.0214441679418087,
0.12548133730888367,
0.37785160541534424,
-0.11588752269744873,
0.0468628816306591,
0.09824055433273315,
0.08561255782842636,
0.014411174692213535,
0.23260383307933807,
0.4231952428817749,
-0.01000831089913845,
-0.4387965798377991,
-0.3409166634082794,
0.453593373298645,
0.744231641292572,
-0.2796766459941864,
0.485258549451828,
0.692510187625885,
-0.11635878682136536,
0.03898073360323906,
-0.6258752346038818,
0.09688535332679749,
-0.44708821177482605,
0.6517282724380493,
-0.34021997451782227,
-1.120432734489441,
0.11514148861169815,
-0.19691017270088196,
0.1725671887397766,
0.254721462726593,
0.8934831023216248,
-0.2781442105770111,
1.1672735214233398,
0.8374821543693542,
0.1511387825012207,
0.8051042556762695,
-0.06929316371679306,
0.02050386555492878,
-0.8259071707725525,
-0.34186089038848877,
-0.1585829257965088,
-0.1942548006772995,
-0.669409990310669,
-0.5624115467071533,
0.7481920719146729,
-0.04396180436015129,
0.30397555232048035,
-0.09629182517528534,
-0.03898431733250618,
0.42373350262641907,
0.3952014744281769,
-0.028177212923765182,
0.475376695394516,
-0.0740676075220108,
0.07906051725149155,
0.08197397738695145,
-0.7347944378852844,
-0.403558611869812,
1.0957856178283691,
0.31328001618385315,
0.9274700880050659,
0.32754752039909363,
0.32840991020202637,
0.4472249746322632,
0.30581238865852356,
-0.625862181186676,
0.7181255221366882,
-0.015777630731463432,
-0.5292136669158936,
-0.17641860246658325,
-0.17183440923690796,
-0.7127257585525513,
0.37572625279426575,
-0.3304852545261383,
-0.22698363661766052,
-0.10098304599523544,
0.3486897051334381,
-0.14323176443576813,
0.41490882635116577,
-0.6042245030403137,
0.7491974830627441,
-0.4612862169742584,
-0.34394392371177673,
-0.4297225773334503,
-0.7193186283111572,
0.5087857842445374,
0.19145409762859344,
0.23613160848617554,
-0.0885690376162529,
-0.25210750102996826,
0.3986123502254486,
0.009365582838654518,
0.805736780166626,
-0.1076599508523941,
-0.3796471357345581,
0.32793161273002625,
-0.054443567991256714,
0.10008438676595688,
0.08072124421596527,
0.21627745032310486,
0.1911148875951767,
-0.042342886328697205,
-0.15261583030223846,
-0.4338446855545044,
0.6132254600524902,
-0.724568247795105,
-0.4875948131084442,
-0.3157495856285095,
-0.9455085396766663,
-0.32147666811943054,
0.018768802285194397,
0.06459014862775803,
0.5647502541542053,
-0.3029117286205292,
0.2335924655199051,
0.6482544541358948,
-0.41742581129074097,
0.7533910870552063,
0.10749118030071259,
-0.41506341099739075,
-0.6148046255111694,
1.072917103767395,
-0.17173536121845245,
0.37743961811065674,
0.46288564801216125,
-0.2204608917236328,
-0.37478378415107727,
-0.6756900548934937,
-0.5836536288261414,
0.15151561796665192,
-0.850368320941925,
-0.14005398750305176,
-0.5435185432434082,
-0.22415895760059357,
-0.4891030788421631,
-0.11404553800821304,
-0.1355224996805191,
-0.34479233622550964,
-0.29276561737060547,
-0.12049076706171036,
0.23157618939876556,
1.0334497690200806,
-0.24728070199489594,
0.12478729337453842,
-0.970294177532196,
0.43241697549819946,
0.47748100757598877,
0.10028237849473953,
-0.001864283811300993,
0.06397315114736557,
-0.259372740983963,
-0.11825733631849289,
-0.6973849534988403,
-0.5260016322135925,
0.19096821546554565,
0.34850555658340454,
0.5075445175170898,
0.35732150077819824,
-0.41005563735961914,
0.5758880376815796,
-0.4541122317314148,
1.1358096599578857,
0.4262710511684418,
-0.7312778830528259,
0.2305118888616562,
-0.34382525086402893,
0.2510305941104889,
0.03529966250061989,
0.14825674891471863,
-0.8852572441101074,
-0.2593308985233307,
-0.2590496838092804,
-0.6997607350349426,
0.5556972622871399,
-0.0582442432641983,
0.25185924768447876,
0.07316283881664276,
-0.08814998716115952,
0.17602862417697906,
0.3375163674354553,
-0.7300069332122803,
-0.09737677127122879,
-0.2706185579299927,
-0.27865856885910034,
-0.1641351729631424,
-0.5291188955307007,
-0.14027681946754456,
-0.018748924136161804,
0.3707634508609772,
-0.22293320298194885,
0.27259933948516846,
-0.045439835637807846,
-0.5069472193717957,
0.12433239817619324,
0.49230214953422546,
1.079383373260498,
0.693063497543335,
0.13944020867347717,
0.2816234827041626,
0.11994112282991409,
-0.4359293282032013,
0.16479624807834625,
-0.1284797340631485,
-0.02903914451599121,
-0.0834631696343422,
0.5847581028938293,
0.9016817808151245,
0.0924520343542099,
-1.0457513332366943,
0.39582645893096924,
-0.19136464595794678,
-0.28273430466651917,
-0.3134104311466217,
0.08542909473180771,
-0.12674367427825928,
0.44620776176452637,
0.15950466692447662,
0.08694693446159363,
-0.16753847897052765,
-0.49207353591918945,
-0.08390704542398453,
0.6641939282417297,
-0.02593570202589035,
-0.5701977610588074,
0.7986574769020081,
0.4549423158168793,
-0.17219530045986176,
0.49508070945739746,
0.023397592827677727,
-0.24179066717624664,
0.3420184552669525,
0.3623310923576355,
0.8393256068229675,
-0.07832565158605576,
0.018310418352484703,
-0.04987252503633499,
0.18993891775608063,
0.368895024061203,
0.23314523696899414,
-0.30341753363609314,
-0.7898234128952026,
-0.5479346513748169,
-0.48896288871765137,
-0.5722370147705078,
0.20902372896671295,
-0.2036094069480896,
0.04981953650712967,
-0.3230675756931305,
-0.2626456916332245,
-0.04259440302848816,
-0.4256943464279175,
-0.35942256450653076,
0.00009162131755147129,
0.3027644753456116,
0.5973161458969116,
-0.48801761865615845,
0.6225301623344421,
0.96164870262146,
-0.2771158218383789,
-0.1280040144920349,
-0.021611984819173813,
0.12916603684425354,
-0.5097811222076416,
0.5277692675590515,
-0.0945991575717926,
-0.1303689181804657,
-0.04118733108043671,
-0.5358321070671082,
-0.6647852063179016,
1.0704243183135986,
0.33444374799728394,
-0.27476373314857483,
-0.14752188324928284,
0.3568025231361389,
0.3087388277053833,
-0.1414755880832672,
0.20897044241428375,
0.281719833612442,
0.3769300878047943,
0.04947330802679062,
-0.849026620388031,
-0.42459601163864136,
-0.26099637150764465,
0.29688698053359985,
-0.033912770450115204,
-0.8430762887001038,
0.7822816371917725,
-0.22740484774112701,
0.09987124055624008,
0.2770095765590668,
0.6800742149353027,
0.2537231147289276,
0.30590397119522095,
0.39406517148017883,
0.3912191092967987,
0.21489553153514862,
-0.03434023633599281,
0.9227835536003113,
-0.25242021679878235,
0.15997973084449768,
0.7392854690551758,
-0.28978246450424194,
0.4881558418273926,
0.6061114072799683,
-0.161704421043396,
0.11532318592071533,
0.6307392120361328,
0.05991516262292862,
0.36998823285102844,
-0.2448965162038803,
-0.6213280558586121,
-0.3987693190574646,
-0.24787664413452148,
-0.2992718815803528,
0.5723000168800354,
0.3781610131263733,
-0.15846772491931915,
-0.29287561774253845,
0.4243631362915039,
0.0037187549751251936,
-0.09950696676969528,
-0.32231587171554565,
0.8791722059249878,
0.06266085803508759,
-0.5852029919624329,
0.09501760452985764,
0.28722482919692993,
0.7703101634979248,
-0.6418067216873169,
-0.08598390966653824,
-0.1368202418088913,
0.06912021338939667,
-0.10380630940198898,
-0.9761279225349426,
0.11614365875720978,
0.19179357588291168,
-0.47272512316703796,
-0.7103242874145508,
0.7051462531089783,
-0.6347795128822327,
-0.26691943407058716,
-0.003992714453488588,
0.6882174611091614,
-0.09654033929109573,
0.18950964510440826,
-0.4660223424434662,
0.5184157490730286,
-0.16065245866775513,
-0.08036603033542633,
0.5589185357093811,
0.1986015886068344,
-0.1138116866350174,
0.7519707679748535,
0.5742522478103638,
-0.06666740030050278,
0.4452160894870758,
0.165165975689888,
0.6975233554840088,
-0.6675715446472168,
-0.21468329429626465,
-0.7485105395317078,
0.551895797252655,
0.10686613619327545,
-0.15766683220863342,
0.838567316532135,
0.44971925020217896,
0.9072021245956421,
-0.37140920758247375,
0.9411876201629639,
-0.3194485902786255,
0.19177548587322235,
-0.9082717895507812,
0.6342758536338806,
-0.7157508134841919,
-0.09612434357404709,
-0.3030562698841095,
-0.8543475866317749,
-0.2575083076953888,
0.12103365361690521,
-0.007942105643451214,
0.1875876486301422,
0.4295998215675354,
0.8374393582344055,
0.06681591272354126,
-0.08285216987133026,
0.5133165121078491,
0.18970178067684174,
0.5118823051452637,
0.27096229791641235,
1.2980270385742188,
-0.13911399245262146,
0.4246577024459839,
-0.13298118114471436,
0.03231072053313255,
-0.14992888271808624,
-0.7897789478302002,
-0.7770687937736511,
-0.7959880828857422,
-0.20848128199577332,
0.11687750369310379,
-0.16302432119846344,
0.9537787437438965,
0.5376825928688049,
-0.42805883288383484,
-0.28646931052207947,
0.18913321197032928,
0.21060214936733246,
-0.04733073711395264,
-0.1421922743320465,
0.024401795119047165,
-0.2674548923969269,
-1.0396335124969482,
0.7450116872787476,
0.3693649172782898,
0.15249642729759216,
-0.46631553769111633,
-0.15423882007598877,
-0.28331467509269714,
-0.16131386160850525,
1.2340322732925415,
0.2551010251045227,
-0.8233942985534668,
-0.19244498014450073,
-0.05481509119272232,
-0.047176457941532135,
0.06886903196573257,
0.9655017852783203,
-0.4029069244861603,
0.6043691635131836,
0.5370188355445862,
0.5915049910545349,
0.351052463054657,
-0.0556492805480957,
0.47687801718711853,
-0.9116284251213074,
0.1278463453054428,
-0.004232746548950672,
0.44327953457832336,
0.6150574088096619,
-0.08178818225860596,
0.1872023195028305,
0.3194383978843689,
-0.539220929145813,
-0.8484725952148438,
0.4417780935764313,
-1.0088046789169312,
-0.11424660682678223,
0.9752647876739502,
0.1314651221036911,
0.11407134681940079,
0.023730643093585968,
-0.36653074622154236,
0.22879600524902344,
-0.05990421772003174,
0.6094485521316528,
0.6504979729652405,
-0.3925243020057678,
-0.5486428737640381,
-0.5504372119903564,
0.2713524401187897,
0.05040866881608963,
-1.0697320699691772,
-0.0767374038696289,
0.9702802896499634,
0.07640437036752701,
0.082620769739151,
0.45432883501052856,
-0.03935558348894119,
0.39694780111312866,
-0.19912514090538025,
0.36919209361076355,
-0.2851855456829071,
-0.541104793548584,
-0.3691352903842926,
0.3574943542480469,
0.27130159735679626,
-0.21615754067897797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19327v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19327v3
|
MAP-Neo: Highly Capable and Transparent Bilingual Large Language Model Series
| 2024-05-29T17:57:16 | 2024-06-02T06:09:49 |
Ge Zhang, Scott Qu, Jiaheng Liu, Chenchen Zhang, Chenghua Lin, Chou Leuang Yu, Danny Pan, Esther Cheng, Jie Liu, Qunshu Lin, Raven Yuan, Tuney Zheng, Wei Pang, Xinrun Du, Yiming Liang, Yinghao Ma, Yizhi Li, Ziyang Ma, Bill Lin, Emmanouil Benetos, Huan Yang, Junting Zhou, Kaijing Ma, Minghao Liu, Morry Niu, Noah Wang, Quehry Que, Ruibo Liu, Sine Liu, Shawn Guo, Soren Gao, Wangchunshu Zhou, Xinyue Zhang, Yizhi Zhou, Yubo Wang, Yuelin Bai, Yuhan Zhang, Yuxiang Zhang, Zenith Wang, Zhenzhu Yang, Zijian Zhao, Jiajun Zhang, Wanli Ouyang, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made great strides in recent years to
achieve unprecedented performance across different tasks. However, due to
commercial interest, the most competitive models like GPT, Gemini, and Claude
have been gated behind proprietary interfaces without disclosing the training
details. Recently, many institutions have open-sourced several strong LLMs like
LLaMA-3, comparable to existing closed-source LLMs. However, only the model's
weights are provided with most details (e.g., intermediate checkpoints,
pre-training corpus, and training code, etc.) being undisclosed. To improve the
transparency of LLMs, the research community has formed to open-source truly
open LLMs (e.g., Pythia, Amber, OLMo), where more details (e.g., pre-training
corpus and training code) are being provided. These models have greatly
advanced the scientific study of these large models including their strengths,
weaknesses, biases and risks. However, we observe that the existing truly open
LLMs on reasoning, knowledge, and coding tasks are still inferior to existing
state-of-the-art LLMs with similar model sizes. To this end, we open-source
MAP-Neo, a highly capable and transparent bilingual language model with 7B
parameters trained from scratch on 4.5T high-quality tokens. Our MAP-Neo is the
first fully open-sourced bilingual LLM with comparable performance compared to
existing state-of-the-art LLMs. Moreover, we open-source all details to
reproduce our MAP-Neo, where the cleaned pre-training corpus, data cleaning
pipeline, checkpoints, and well-optimized training/evaluation framework are
provided. Finally, we hope our MAP-Neo will enhance and strengthen the open
research community and inspire more innovations and creativities to facilitate
the further improvements of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2599189281463623,
-0.5660979747772217,
0.6767401695251465,
0.44674763083457947,
-0.17185825109481812,
-0.08648526668548584,
-0.5374094247817993,
-0.49394798278808594,
0.3037068843841553,
0.8356716632843018,
-0.2301056832075119,
-0.7790871262550354,
-0.7022508978843689,
0.21044868230819702,
-0.37782207131385803,
0.899125874042511,
-0.19822445511817932,
0.2053556740283966,
0.0029565258882939816,
-0.1305694580078125,
0.12217756360769272,
-0.37167179584503174,
-0.45624470710754395,
-0.2867791950702667,
0.5825103521347046,
0.35978496074676514,
0.667599618434906,
0.7904046773910522,
0.3891778886318207,
0.296924889087677,
-0.11897799372673035,
-0.020144596695899963,
-0.6789646744728088,
0.042810507118701935,
-0.2725314795970917,
-0.47060897946357727,
-0.9604824185371399,
-0.0792846605181694,
0.8309487700462341,
0.5734929442405701,
-0.17685213685035706,
0.1253361701965332,
0.01912468671798706,
0.5054140090942383,
-0.6051059365272522,
0.3460487127304077,
-0.8599848747253418,
-0.2715659439563751,
-0.40778636932373047,
-0.024221820756793022,
-0.32553714513778687,
-0.4762347638607025,
-0.07264846563339233,
-0.7805742025375366,
0.013714726082980633,
-0.13257043063640594,
0.6372450590133667,
-0.041410889476537704,
-0.39762386679649353,
-0.13079744577407837,
-0.8228941559791565,
0.6463737487792969,
-0.762941300868988,
0.2726917862892151,
0.3646514117717743,
0.44762924313545227,
-0.07941033691167831,
-0.6240178942680359,
-0.4579201340675354,
-0.08426567167043686,
0.42608198523521423,
0.16440555453300476,
-0.19521474838256836,
-0.03779664263129234,
0.17924374341964722,
0.5101593136787415,
-0.4517339766025543,
0.3568655252456665,
-0.3444140553474426,
-0.27537301182746887,
0.28436508774757385,
0.09310366213321686,
0.13052964210510254,
0.22678349912166595,
-0.48509982228279114,
0.05999164655804634,
-1.1373038291931152,
-0.4187908172607422,
0.6480580568313599,
0.3082912564277649,
-0.3659399449825287,
0.6770725250244141,
-0.3438878357410431,
0.5710105299949646,
-0.5351623892784119,
-0.2245195209980011,
0.4543447196483612,
-0.4713556468486786,
0.0036407492589205503,
-0.09313026815652847,
1.2835248708724976,
0.040015868842601776,
0.5223289132118225,
-0.11297311633825302,
-0.36812737584114075,
-0.15469637513160706,
-0.1303635537624359,
-0.8962913751602173,
0.15923921763896942,
0.05874501168727875,
-0.1784229874610901,
-0.05764632672071457,
0.14246539771556854,
-0.6217037439346313,
-0.2696552276611328,
-0.33637890219688416,
0.28726741671562195,
-0.28103500604629517,
-0.5487980842590332,
0.2009870558977127,
0.19490931928157806,
-0.1580091416835785,
0.5347888469696045,
-0.7415934205055237,
0.4677579998970032,
0.9604146480560303,
0.8988624811172485,
-0.12826547026634216,
-0.3968467116355896,
-0.45315417647361755,
0.17403370141983032,
-0.21791613101959229,
0.3144388496875763,
-0.3906605541706085,
-0.31781697273254395,
0.0601167194545269,
-0.01652832143008709,
0.1079726368188858,
-0.656442403793335,
0.46131542325019836,
-0.6171355247497559,
0.046893466264009476,
-0.17535440623760223,
-0.2039213478565216,
-0.01652766577899456,
0.45159268379211426,
-0.8630546927452087,
0.8882328867912292,
0.18875925242900848,
-0.8812610507011414,
-0.05232495069503784,
-0.6233237385749817,
0.07142457365989685,
0.10442987829446793,
-0.15903975069522858,
-0.19563449919223785,
-0.09786384552717209,
0.2889734208583832,
0.006708168890327215,
-0.634779691696167,
0.2791130542755127,
-0.41356557607650757,
-0.28362876176834106,
0.2875317335128784,
-0.28220096230506897,
1.1145824193954468,
0.09125453978776932,
-0.414412260055542,
0.4526621997356415,
-0.5582277774810791,
-0.20651762187480927,
0.16240355372428894,
-0.36132028698921204,
-0.34527459740638733,
-0.3437885344028473,
-0.09241703152656555,
0.2023642510175705,
0.5329813361167908,
-0.7620829939842224,
0.008278691209852695,
-0.48578914999961853,
0.36962631344795227,
0.9612687826156616,
-0.5084356665611267,
0.4792921245098114,
-0.03233989700675011,
0.8224990963935852,
0.03607665374875069,
0.35830795764923096,
-0.3425790071487427,
-0.7264348864555359,
-0.6561608910560608,
-0.7388954162597656,
0.49214062094688416,
0.5134447813034058,
-0.533147931098938,
0.3858572542667389,
-0.4921029508113861,
-0.48331722617149353,
-0.6938687562942505,
0.3642450273036957,
0.30272141098976135,
0.5755716562271118,
0.16485096514225006,
-0.2346816211938858,
-0.5033217668533325,
-0.9274272322654724,
0.06152789294719696,
-0.07683763653039932,
0.03748517856001854,
0.29916131496429443,
0.678700864315033,
-0.41596364974975586,
0.7938183546066284,
-0.09495514631271362,
-0.1044338196516037,
-0.20305418968200684,
-0.15187281370162964,
0.4473736882209778,
0.1126355230808258,
0.43604445457458496,
-0.295346736907959,
-0.4934707581996918,
0.2626332640647888,
-0.5291580557823181,
-0.20807752013206482,
0.5326331853866577,
-0.1802254021167755,
0.24718934297561646,
0.4887303113937378,
-0.4235106110572815,
0.09236833453178406,
0.9536396861076355,
-0.2843637466430664,
0.4672982394695282,
-0.3252986669540405,
-0.3431001901626587,
-1.171391487121582,
0.3010804057121277,
-0.1963130682706833,
-0.4192715585231781,
-0.23890763521194458,
0.22464905679225922,
0.26925474405288696,
0.006353816948831081,
-0.49974119663238525,
0.8127444386482239,
-0.373097687959671,
-0.28781625628471375,
-0.34007275104522705,
0.1945500522851944,
-0.201253280043602,
0.15519598126411438,
0.11104612052440643,
0.4943488538265228,
0.8330816626548767,
-0.23688532412052155,
0.38069799542427063,
-0.03749021142721176,
-0.4551059901714325,
0.12044070661067963,
-0.649553656578064,
0.05952547863125801,
0.03215434402227402,
0.3370490074157715,
-0.5180166959762573,
0.08427660167217255,
0.5019866824150085,
-0.18910595774650574,
0.11128372699022293,
-0.22760166227817535,
-0.8102893233299255,
-0.16537952423095703,
-0.1906362771987915,
0.5388900637626648,
0.3792015612125397,
-0.5568486452102661,
0.3460751175880432,
0.31958287954330444,
-0.38493090867996216,
-0.7979390025138855,
-0.4067637622356415,
0.16029655933380127,
-0.018014462664723396,
-0.47203654050827026,
0.11428256332874298,
-0.061106618493795395,
-0.21396182477474213,
0.09231075644493103,
0.06140743941068649,
0.006250033155083656,
0.05892248451709747,
0.28542375564575195,
0.3499777615070343,
-0.3999983072280884,
-0.21993303298950195,
-0.14733493328094482,
-0.321358859539032,
0.190482959151268,
-0.47037404775619507,
0.6229689717292786,
-0.4097433090209961,
-0.34019672870635986,
-0.26015305519104004,
0.17194539308547974,
0.678774893283844,
-0.5314485430717468,
0.7674826383590698,
0.6038964986801147,
-0.30820968747138977,
-0.26267075538635254,
-0.3452112674713135,
0.01555643416941166,
-0.4310731291770935,
0.3084663450717926,
-0.14582416415214539,
-1.3024628162384033,
0.5421265959739685,
-0.05663878843188286,
-0.0065501537173986435,
0.3422493636608124,
0.7805667519569397,
0.2523443102836609,
0.7053391337394714,
0.6073305010795593,
-0.1298130303621292,
0.36947566270828247,
-0.15952154994010925,
-0.028297295793890953,
-0.8171523213386536,
-0.45822545886039734,
-0.6965941786766052,
-0.21227608621120453,
-0.6896153688430786,
-0.6258097290992737,
0.4688727855682373,
0.002936764620244503,
-0.37719860672950745,
0.1696782410144806,
-0.15664894878864288,
0.47355154156684875,
0.8117364048957825,
-0.07460478693246841,
0.5964968204498291,
0.03505780175328255,
-0.298721045255661,
0.10051493346691132,
-0.5320557355880737,
-0.4736575782299042,
1.5515398979187012,
0.5633987188339233,
0.9410899877548218,
0.10601542145013809,
0.7412827014923096,
-0.2466581165790558,
0.4387098252773285,
-0.6873216032981873,
0.5862116813659668,
0.15716175734996796,
-0.8254980444908142,
-0.17086343467235565,
-0.7581278085708618,
-1.0491551160812378,
0.18075968325138092,
-0.23192763328552246,
-0.4892483353614807,
-0.038097016513347626,
-0.03782125934958458,
0.09635959565639496,
0.4091340899467468,
-0.3775743544101715,
0.8626558184623718,
-0.4853977560997009,
-0.34788715839385986,
-0.11874861270189285,
-0.4747362434864044,
0.5515792965888977,
-0.3241906762123108,
0.33571577072143555,
-0.1606941819190979,
-0.5161900520324707,
0.6004250049591064,
-0.5610691905021667,
0.794434666633606,
0.012230640277266502,
-0.37463298439979553,
0.16935977339744568,
0.21617627143859863,
0.44127702713012695,
0.2296336442232132,
-0.09343863278627396,
0.7231167554855347,
-0.3949078917503357,
-0.2950586974620819,
-0.32977867126464844,
1.0270377397537231,
-0.9586547017097473,
-0.41854381561279297,
-0.49606379866600037,
-0.7061718702316284,
0.03444158285856247,
0.5904093384742737,
-0.015229322947561741,
0.22639597952365875,
-0.2179192453622818,
0.10778787732124329,
0.6285357475280762,
-0.35111892223358154,
0.26769959926605225,
0.7638046741485596,
-0.6477305889129639,
-0.8098866939544678,
0.9847720861434937,
-0.2262425273656845,
0.325907826423645,
0.4378633201122284,
0.32228899002075195,
-0.32061338424682617,
-0.8463610410690308,
-0.25100868940353394,
0.7227335572242737,
-0.44826555252075195,
-0.06170593947172165,
-0.36025217175483704,
-0.07504153251647949,
-0.46561628580093384,
0.1883247196674347,
-0.7147571444511414,
-0.5772358775138855,
-0.1521948277950287,
-0.08616961538791656,
0.21750973165035248,
0.8442624807357788,
-0.14503972232341766,
0.3109293282032013,
-0.5942889451980591,
0.4655171036720276,
0.07728216052055359,
0.5138234496116638,
-0.29059016704559326,
-0.2601469159126282,
-0.24177119135856628,
0.12807674705982208,
-0.3329320251941681,
-0.6990092396736145,
0.3381000757217407,
-0.15249057114124298,
0.4685763418674469,
0.6203377842903137,
-0.25052446126937866,
0.23151232302188873,
-0.4956032633781433,
0.40811365842819214,
0.306685209274292,
-0.847547709941864,
0.38416603207588196,
-0.6820234060287476,
0.24769246578216553,
0.33125782012939453,
0.4794323742389679,
-0.1977136880159378,
-0.4186025559902191,
-0.5212055444717407,
-0.8467695713043213,
0.9676637053489685,
0.2316845804452896,
-0.0962984636425972,
0.042579665780067444,
0.11345604062080383,
0.3590063154697418,
0.3192813992500305,
-0.922912061214447,
-0.1930941492319107,
-0.4367407262325287,
-0.21052171289920807,
-0.3505740761756897,
-0.10207823663949966,
-0.2657609283924103,
-0.2774144411087036,
0.6352836489677429,
-0.05641821026802063,
0.02087453566491604,
-0.0833793506026268,
-0.021137749776244164,
-0.08729124814271927,
0.3115559220314026,
0.533821165561676,
0.8544783592224121,
-0.39390236139297485,
0.21597157418727875,
-0.16467022895812988,
-0.4101230800151825,
-0.10183607041835785,
0.18403266370296478,
-0.4340047836303711,
-0.025468790903687477,
0.34447723627090454,
0.8681986331939697,
0.04998985677957535,
-0.8114102482795715,
0.6275365948677063,
0.08553671091794968,
-0.22646364569664001,
-0.34378713369369507,
-0.06653949618339539,
0.4207823872566223,
0.15951447188854218,
-0.1552034467458725,
-0.0640568882226944,
-0.12242470681667328,
-0.8274731040000916,
-0.3217739462852478,
0.4638363718986511,
-0.3549198508262634,
-0.4872285723686218,
0.619755744934082,
0.3393946588039398,
-0.1520376056432724,
0.781013011932373,
0.06724238395690918,
-0.5000186562538147,
0.4193947911262512,
0.6855307221412659,
0.6533023715019226,
-0.4072551727294922,
0.23429390788078308,
0.537751317024231,
0.6942881345748901,
-0.21919980645179749,
0.4095824360847473,
-0.0665268823504448,
-0.6685839891433716,
-0.4696258008480072,
-0.6159026622772217,
-0.6103321313858032,
0.2850472331047058,
-0.5449726581573486,
0.22694678604602814,
-0.49465471506118774,
-0.1858474612236023,
-0.6573136448860168,
-0.17085638642311096,
-0.5102733373641968,
-0.1037771999835968,
0.3157736659049988,
1.1844640970230103,
-0.67884761095047,
0.9799039363861084,
0.5475883483886719,
-0.1583351343870163,
-0.32238346338272095,
-0.39837732911109924,
-0.19245916604995728,
-0.922850489616394,
0.47832000255584717,
0.05320696532726288,
-0.025773435831069946,
-0.09744393080472946,
-0.37849822640419006,
-0.7761794328689575,
0.9894703030586243,
1.0285533666610718,
-0.6512529850006104,
-0.28252533078193665,
0.5963104367256165,
0.452330082654953,
-0.3242974877357483,
0.5441170930862427,
0.14299294352531433,
0.611673891544342,
-0.03295925259590149,
-1.1319503784179688,
0.08017973601818085,
-0.21028035879135132,
-0.1585739701986313,
0.2518935799598694,
-0.5904732942581177,
0.8403422832489014,
-0.19290436804294586,
0.10543344914913177,
0.15350370109081268,
0.45794111490249634,
0.32268983125686646,
0.26291346549987793,
0.36197584867477417,
0.7418811321258545,
0.612878143787384,
-0.2217906415462494,
1.0194982290267944,
-0.23746071755886078,
0.05668024718761444,
1.2273470163345337,
-0.2495385855436325,
0.9051439762115479,
0.3804979622364044,
0.11849479377269745,
0.49723953008651733,
0.23928523063659668,
0.28668099641799927,
0.29061076045036316,
0.1968240886926651,
-0.1565791368484497,
-0.34769248962402344,
-0.10111638158559799,
-0.49253711104393005,
0.3087162673473358,
0.41723641753196716,
-0.4947890341281891,
-0.3637215197086334,
-0.4014136791229248,
0.050976384431123734,
-0.022704385221004486,
-0.29603782296180725,
0.45175763964653015,
0.2857419550418854,
-0.5292119383811951,
0.48289036750793457,
0.18748325109481812,
0.5548181533813477,
-0.9247917532920837,
0.16763648390769958,
-0.2026023268699646,
0.1550842672586441,
-0.11982516199350357,
-0.664267361164093,
-0.004424541722983122,
0.17768873274326324,
0.11649887263774872,
-0.42555344104766846,
0.23881268501281738,
-0.45181605219841003,
-0.38066110014915466,
0.6283113956451416,
0.5791205763816833,
0.17324480414390564,
-0.32871875166893005,
-0.5988926887512207,
0.3396841585636139,
-0.271235853433609,
-0.13877175748348236,
0.25461843609809875,
0.5287855863571167,
-0.08903881162405014,
0.5983216762542725,
0.7036932110786438,
0.5924176573753357,
0.2651977837085724,
0.12859831750392914,
0.7915849685668945,
-0.6669203639030457,
-0.3778435289859772,
-0.660186231136322,
0.3116625249385834,
0.06165101006627083,
-0.3543706238269806,
0.8808282017707825,
0.8601253032684326,
1.0100843906402588,
0.0389118529856205,
0.6873273253440857,
0.41718706488609314,
0.4507628083229065,
-0.3428414463996887,
0.6664522290229797,
-0.4406386613845825,
0.2857557237148285,
-0.15572072565555573,
-1.2757186889648438,
-0.22993016242980957,
0.17954479157924652,
-0.16918092966079712,
-0.013486523181200027,
0.6954922080039978,
0.9328625202178955,
-0.30367839336395264,
-0.08992725610733032,
0.08174791932106018,
0.5901442766189575,
0.29703664779663086,
0.850520133972168,
0.901151716709137,
-0.2525411546230316,
0.7438758015632629,
-0.25332188606262207,
-0.38653677701950073,
-0.24846971035003662,
-0.8149620890617371,
-0.9930614233016968,
-0.4425235986709595,
-0.26164400577545166,
-0.34918153285980225,
-0.038282133638858795,
0.5513191223144531,
0.5558013319969177,
-0.6094704866409302,
-0.5030067563056946,
-0.2069782018661499,
0.2629352807998657,
0.06039914861321449,
-0.11988288164138794,
0.213614821434021,
0.15709203481674194,
-0.948788583278656,
0.6268470883369446,
0.29423120617866516,
-0.08400983363389969,
-0.3797876834869385,
-0.512468159198761,
0.1455596387386322,
-0.07157207280397415,
0.40504947304725647,
0.4171276390552521,
-0.7237333655357361,
0.3391864001750946,
0.02390017732977867,
-0.24140378832817078,
0.06588480621576309,
0.6760284304618835,
-0.5858384370803833,
0.62320476770401,
0.6804842948913574,
0.44775131344795227,
0.6422795057296753,
-0.3416462540626526,
0.6182742714881897,
-0.12764771282672882,
0.13395792245864868,
0.2618381977081299,
0.6238026022911072,
0.37301233410835266,
0.2883106768131256,
0.4140150249004364,
0.2117728590965271,
-0.35559508204460144,
-0.8143810629844666,
0.2634512782096863,
-1.3261845111846924,
0.020353471860289574,
1.322496771812439,
-0.15107692778110504,
-0.39373865723609924,
0.1734560877084732,
-0.14178039133548737,
0.2350836992263794,
-0.385323166847229,
0.5416575074195862,
0.4711442291736603,
0.39665499329566956,
0.07677716761827469,
-0.4142244756221771,
-0.01806592382490635,
0.08836494386196136,
-0.8471354246139526,
0.00419209897518158,
0.4869735538959503,
0.4264867305755615,
-0.0007229517214000225,
0.7161752581596375,
-0.6349035501480103,
0.14921991527080536,
-0.13390816748142242,
0.18913757801055908,
-0.6076880693435669,
-0.6267948150634766,
-0.35403043031692505,
0.26521408557891846,
0.3028804659843445,
0.08220033347606659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19325v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19325v2
|
Nearest Neighbor Speculative Decoding for LLM Generation and Attribution
| 2024-05-29T17:55:03 | 2024-05-31T01:41:49 |
Minghan Li, Xilun Chen, Ari Holtzman, Beidi Chen, Jimmy Lin, Wen-tau Yih, Xi Victoria Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) often hallucinate and lack the ability to
provide attribution for their generations. Semi-parametric LMs, such as kNN-LM,
approach these limitations by refining the output of an LM for a given prompt
using its nearest neighbor matches in a non-parametric data store. However,
these models often exhibit slow inference speeds and produce non-fluent texts.
In this paper, we introduce Nearest Neighbor Speculative Decoding (NEST), a
novel semi-parametric language modeling approach that is capable of
incorporating real-world text spans of arbitrary length into the LM generations
and providing attribution to their sources. NEST performs token-level retrieval
at each inference step to compute a semi-parametric mixture distribution and
identify promising span continuations in a corpus. It then uses an approximate
speculative decoding procedure that accepts a prefix of the retrieved span or
generates a new token. NEST significantly enhances the generation quality and
attribution rate of the base LM across a variety of knowledge-intensive tasks,
surpassing the conventional kNN-LM method and performing competitively with
in-context retrieval augmentation. In addition, NEST substantially improves the
generation speed, achieving a 1.8x speedup in inference time when applied to
Llama-2-Chat 70B.
|
[
0.0018647480756044388,
-0.744807779788971,
0.5367578864097595,
0.1817825436592102,
-0.33473822474479675,
0.3438188433647156,
-0.3666759133338928,
-0.6935205459594727,
0.2727137804031372,
0.41657039523124695,
-0.5962581038475037,
-0.596383273601532,
-0.2956693768501282,
0.2229323387145996,
-0.4147960841655731,
0.6266738772392273,
0.25597232580184937,
-0.49555540084838867,
-0.47798866033554077,
0.5168465375900269,
0.15192607045173645,
-0.7215376496315002,
-0.6961929202079773,
0.06644819676876068,
0.4353499114513397,
0.5005847215652466,
0.5435788035392761,
0.6854171752929688,
0.0443708635866642,
0.2641408443450928,
-0.29366493225097656,
0.2755625545978546,
-0.7389864325523376,
0.006776756141334772,
0.23986093699932098,
-0.9549678564071655,
-0.1541108787059784,
-0.3888809382915497,
0.952851414680481,
0.4263502061367035,
-0.03257758542895317,
0.13743247091770172,
-0.35837212204933167,
0.5832598209381104,
-0.6494400501251221,
0.25503870844841003,
-0.8769363760948181,
0.12297230213880539,
-0.66602623462677,
-0.39868152141571045,
-0.5215505957603455,
-0.593888521194458,
-0.050653278827667236,
-0.2142096757888794,
0.35987982153892517,
0.44079285860061646,
0.7022494077682495,
0.1291840821504593,
-0.22470571100711823,
-0.18362413346767426,
-0.5271275639533997,
1.0157926082611084,
-1.1399753093719482,
0.4083973169326782,
0.762973427772522,
0.19623573124408722,
-0.320966511964798,
-0.5836914777755737,
-0.6772130727767944,
-0.27836957573890686,
-0.03554748371243477,
-0.06841088086366653,
-0.3638323247432709,
-0.22195452451705933,
-0.13356700539588928,
0.3212015628814697,
-0.35029807686805725,
0.3836239278316498,
-0.3189277648925781,
-0.4748307764530182,
0.34850507974624634,
0.454786479473114,
-0.059307366609573364,
-0.5954551696777344,
-0.2920680046081543,
0.024303359910845757,
-0.8062633872032166,
0.13971589505672455,
0.7932316064834595,
0.5675950646400452,
-0.1697835624217987,
0.4658733010292053,
-0.20718002319335938,
0.823088526725769,
0.002141273347660899,
-0.2660016119480133,
0.01575412228703499,
-0.43954071402549744,
0.20324784517288208,
0.2887134253978729,
0.8903566598892212,
0.40761613845825195,
-0.10258039832115173,
-0.4823271632194519,
-0.06567655503749847,
0.19251970946788788,
-0.08944648504257202,
-0.6082265377044678,
-0.21713756024837494,
0.05022072419524193,
-0.6042013168334961,
-0.8534833192825317,
-0.22567635774612427,
-0.8881383538246155,
-0.20872372388839722,
0.21966521441936493,
-0.2501540184020996,
-0.3982082009315491,
-0.3660634160041809,
0.12839996814727783,
-0.002531137317419052,
0.1591656506061554,
-0.2460227757692337,
-0.9703936576843262,
0.23071525990962982,
0.5961962342262268,
1.070966362953186,
-0.3710063695907593,
-0.27203696966171265,
-0.4253976047039032,
0.2374400794506073,
-0.4791850745677948,
0.9374270439147949,
-0.8304059505462646,
-0.2936146557331085,
0.08871396631002426,
-0.3584328293800354,
0.046988584101200104,
-0.6680868268013,
0.4344806969165802,
-0.826011598110199,
0.10183358192443848,
-0.12954093515872955,
-0.553592324256897,
0.24126558005809784,
0.26072344183921814,
-0.6771330833435059,
1.1792881488800049,
0.11289830505847931,
-0.9825757741928101,
0.28991761803627014,
-0.28880923986434937,
-0.4460085928440094,
-0.08894859999418259,
-0.07567835599184036,
-0.32716765999794006,
0.16150788962841034,
0.34804627299308777,
0.6169255971908569,
-0.31257930397987366,
-0.0019197484944015741,
-0.324575275182724,
-0.413715124130249,
0.16778802871704102,
-0.503440797328949,
0.4088934063911438,
0.1983972191810608,
-0.07542218267917633,
0.08387221395969391,
-0.9249678254127502,
-0.15598326921463013,
0.14629249274730682,
-0.2968348264694214,
-0.40372443199157715,
0.14246399700641632,
-0.09881395846605301,
0.09645842015743256,
0.48169881105422974,
-0.6041807532310486,
-0.04796118289232254,
-0.6530494093894958,
0.47459691762924194,
0.6478449702262878,
0.12071296572685242,
0.5478208661079407,
-0.349115252494812,
0.5868710279464722,
0.057328734546899796,
-0.15081842243671417,
0.03200164809823036,
-0.3770255744457245,
-0.4432632625102997,
-0.2278042882680893,
0.23891784250736237,
0.20435063540935516,
-0.8862357139587402,
0.40200257301330566,
-0.364707887172699,
-0.5294455289840698,
-0.4968336522579193,
-0.045042965561151505,
0.35532525181770325,
0.730252206325531,
0.06874129921197891,
0.2334943413734436,
-0.6725727915763855,
-0.7307636141777039,
-0.14386512339115143,
-0.41988569498062134,
0.12919968366622925,
0.2438715249300003,
0.000548886600881815,
-0.12639003992080688,
1.088753581047058,
-0.4729297161102295,
-0.12614351511001587,
-0.38154205679893494,
0.1566305309534073,
0.27729806303977966,
0.08948902040719986,
0.4542585611343384,
-0.5882587432861328,
-0.46580591797828674,
-0.08801686018705368,
-0.5941575169563293,
-0.17077681422233582,
-0.054943401366472244,
-0.18761032819747925,
0.29639148712158203,
0.7815802097320557,
-0.46747568249702454,
0.07966004312038422,
0.763543426990509,
-0.07811099290847778,
0.926876962184906,
0.015248160809278488,
-0.04173232987523079,
-1.367871642112732,
-0.062382228672504425,
-0.14756618440151215,
-0.359017014503479,
-0.4326782524585724,
0.039391517639160156,
-0.01422152854502201,
0.1807345747947693,
-0.5112966895103455,
0.37010908126831055,
-0.6143572330474854,
-0.04324018955230713,
-0.34249672293663025,
0.10417645424604416,
-0.2981192469596863,
0.22029897570610046,
0.18718498945236206,
1.0751522779464722,
0.5328178405761719,
-0.47387829422950745,
0.3445794880390167,
0.0809864029288292,
-0.46302708983421326,
-0.042009077966213226,
-0.22828182578086853,
0.2288026660680771,
0.02753949537873268,
0.5027745366096497,
-0.6519814133644104,
-0.18933998048305511,
-0.024522989988327026,
-0.35278207063674927,
0.04781944304704666,
-0.22998285293579102,
-0.9086322784423828,
-0.5363559722900391,
-0.49103841185569763,
0.6701039671897888,
0.5421151518821716,
-0.6310755610466003,
0.3616843819618225,
0.15175098180770874,
-0.1071588471531868,
-0.5620061755180359,
-0.7645048499107361,
0.23772986233234406,
-0.46937867999076843,
-0.697939932346344,
0.3378804624080658,
0.21782861649990082,
-0.08357758074998856,
0.15542054176330566,
0.05263654515147209,
0.09584435075521469,
-0.41271862387657166,
-0.04987373575568199,
0.17203252017498016,
-0.37635862827301025,
-0.18382498621940613,
0.21511809527873993,
-0.21445289254188538,
0.2636076509952545,
-0.3490120768547058,
0.6069661974906921,
-0.12809138000011444,
-0.125796839594841,
-0.3263138234615326,
0.44143927097320557,
0.5705543756484985,
-0.03142369166016579,
0.999206006526947,
0.5191879868507385,
-0.37198978662490845,
-0.528471827507019,
-0.5472975373268127,
-0.41468408703804016,
-0.5210766792297363,
0.4404115676879883,
-0.46689853072166443,
-1.0782252550125122,
0.8817865252494812,
-0.2232382446527481,
-0.31021732091903687,
0.2400408685207367,
0.7608780264854431,
0.13024303317070007,
0.6526193022727966,
0.6692925095558167,
-0.40884244441986084,
0.3895683288574219,
-0.11395058035850525,
0.4335549771785736,
-0.6745765209197998,
-0.49009644985198975,
-0.36876949667930603,
-0.19166907668113708,
-0.2325025200843811,
-0.8018382787704468,
0.20176810026168823,
0.0634499192237854,
0.30879145860671997,
0.2874951660633087,
-0.13011525571346283,
0.7001796364784241,
0.5947948694229126,
0.23743030428886414,
0.4443528950214386,
0.20826248824596405,
-0.32298654317855835,
-0.26718324422836304,
-0.9182262420654297,
-0.3537900745868683,
0.996357262134552,
0.33386915922164917,
0.7907930612564087,
0.22262655198574066,
0.8302767872810364,
0.4065272808074951,
-0.020681433379650116,
-0.6564837694168091,
0.6830016374588013,
-0.061879754066467285,
-0.35859647393226624,
-0.05480002611875534,
-0.7525619268417358,
-0.7456034421920776,
-0.3204154968261719,
-0.15988579392433167,
-0.9647455215454102,
-0.11519117653369904,
0.16015884280204773,
-0.36248549818992615,
0.7513676285743713,
-0.49031856656074524,
0.5163277387619019,
0.18132269382476807,
-0.35496050119400024,
-0.06053238362073898,
-0.6730363368988037,
0.679503858089447,
-0.41150519251823425,
-0.06844236701726913,
0.050570063292980194,
-0.07507681101560593,
0.8448576331138611,
-0.41867923736572266,
1.1023917198181152,
-0.004989837761968374,
-0.2892870008945465,
0.5172330737113953,
0.28397274017333984,
0.9623592495918274,
0.02939828298985958,
-0.43035072088241577,
-0.0036353024188429117,
-0.07913824170827866,
-0.3948894143104553,
-0.45984917879104614,
0.9235822558403015,
-0.6836095452308655,
-0.30276405811309814,
-0.22670455276966095,
-0.7752701044082642,
-0.4654267132282257,
0.0914277583360672,
0.57837975025177,
0.2539829611778259,
0.13629503548145294,
0.019058356061577797,
0.48971325159072876,
-0.040668755769729614,
0.33538976311683655,
0.338445246219635,
-0.13386525213718414,
-0.046725936233997345,
1.162294626235962,
-0.4013172388076782,
0.364080011844635,
0.5790503025054932,
0.27846214175224304,
-0.7768501043319702,
-0.8123255372047424,
-0.3075723350048065,
0.26564857363700867,
-0.6699190139770508,
-0.3705386817455292,
-0.6471914649009705,
-0.11067011952400208,
-0.21566124260425568,
-0.3061469495296478,
-0.5346789360046387,
-0.21957997977733612,
-0.44793975353240967,
-0.17309489846229553,
0.5939841270446777,
0.7094711065292358,
-0.07799529284238815,
0.365701824426651,
-0.8861780166625977,
0.12703561782836914,
-0.06049796938896179,
0.10122969001531601,
0.40277162194252014,
-0.6720415353775024,
-0.3091224431991577,
-0.0868755653500557,
0.3399505019187927,
-0.8244702219963074,
0.3675053119659424,
-0.030614638701081276,
0.2662332057952881,
0.4391368627548218,
0.33603355288505554,
0.8468561172485352,
-0.5623237490653992,
0.9246000647544861,
0.16324959695339203,
-0.757724940776825,
0.2879617214202881,
-0.5341655611991882,
0.14759929478168488,
0.41887617111206055,
0.2688850164413452,
-0.2975021302700043,
-0.6110768914222717,
-0.44857895374298096,
-1.004157543182373,
0.7848464846611023,
0.22957360744476318,
0.24992799758911133,
-0.23889896273612976,
0.34014996886253357,
0.20152366161346436,
0.023463286459445953,
-0.5675579309463501,
-0.17581388354301453,
0.19701746106147766,
-0.2836827039718628,
-0.022240977734327316,
-0.42825445532798767,
0.10214770585298538,
-0.07319806516170502,
0.5229457020759583,
-0.06295821070671082,
0.5622473955154419,
-0.16493569314479828,
0.020318588241934776,
-0.2982437312602997,
0.07178657501935959,
0.5481329560279846,
0.21832990646362305,
-0.34907400608062744,
0.3942645192146301,
0.33513545989990234,
-0.14306624233722687,
-0.06989067047834396,
-0.04195354878902435,
-0.025271277874708176,
0.033735644072294235,
0.5773521661758423,
0.5760265588760376,
0.364818811416626,
-0.604390561580658,
0.4318941533565521,
-0.0006231120205484331,
-0.14731912314891815,
-0.11621749401092529,
-0.182870015501976,
0.3281887173652649,
0.39707255363464355,
0.5138872265815735,
0.07775778323411942,
0.05385935679078102,
-0.42002204060554504,
0.46208131313323975,
0.2641621232032776,
-0.025368500500917435,
-0.4429693818092346,
0.6796435117721558,
-0.06879249215126038,
-0.11598215997219086,
0.5922960042953491,
-0.43584099411964417,
-0.6698760986328125,
0.4851710796356201,
1.2159110307693481,
0.59904944896698,
0.25784412026405334,
0.2348206788301468,
0.29437005519866943,
0.0852067843079567,
0.004453051369637251,
0.0773937851190567,
-0.10742287337779999,
-0.5992850661277771,
-0.5216279625892639,
-0.985798180103302,
-0.28069499135017395,
0.19171933829784393,
-0.4504283368587494,
0.007800542749464512,
-0.25146016478538513,
-0.0436742827296257,
-0.4425746500492096,
-0.1743597686290741,
-0.18005816638469696,
-0.14595292508602142,
0.3544066250324249,
0.8560240864753723,
-0.968840479850769,
0.7348413467407227,
0.5345715880393982,
0.012510192580521107,
-1.0277336835861206,
0.3950827121734619,
-0.040485043078660965,
-0.8307909369468689,
0.47979477047920227,
-0.050707701593637466,
-0.39486968517303467,
0.2019282877445221,
-0.3774333894252777,
-0.8663427233695984,
0.9609049558639526,
0.4101885259151459,
-0.5936089158058167,
-0.3892410695552826,
0.2975119650363922,
0.5215179920196533,
-0.3339792788028717,
0.08005747199058533,
0.4429965913295746,
0.14677664637565613,
0.20401418209075928,
-0.6325454115867615,
0.31516990065574646,
-0.20105519890785217,
0.1557176411151886,
0.24462546408176422,
-0.6226819157600403,
0.531928300857544,
-0.346461683511734,
-0.13772724568843842,
0.36769676208496094,
1.0821269750595093,
0.6070649027824402,
0.31039831042289734,
0.37256669998168945,
0.359653115272522,
0.7728000283241272,
0.20267456769943237,
1.0414350032806396,
-0.4059528112411499,
0.27811479568481445,
1.0291943550109863,
0.04315552860498428,
1.237485647201538,
0.5911906361579895,
-0.31770917773246765,
0.6793525815010071,
0.804799497127533,
0.2213326245546341,
0.6810028553009033,
0.2930881977081299,
-0.528706431388855,
-0.16402646899223328,
-0.10698157548904419,
-0.35876449942588806,
0.32736536860466003,
0.34221091866493225,
-0.3439594507217407,
-0.3852928578853607,
-0.11734167486429214,
0.08847847580909729,
0.2858099937438965,
-0.07832631468772888,
0.47266891598701477,
0.13179540634155273,
-0.34847018122673035,
0.6753952503204346,
0.2727743089199066,
0.9658905863761902,
-0.7308028936386108,
0.24371998012065887,
-0.18602119386196136,
0.11445381492376328,
-0.26219817996025085,
-0.4783131778240204,
0.3916749358177185,
0.15454503893852234,
-0.37397637963294983,
-0.050208818167448044,
0.8311864137649536,
-0.5188134908676147,
-0.5665636658668518,
0.2596699893474579,
0.3880790174007416,
0.337530255317688,
-0.09697028994560242,
-0.4949459135532379,
0.24439787864685059,
0.11447809636592865,
-0.1276267170906067,
0.18079562485218048,
0.5844101309776306,
-0.1865600198507309,
0.6249698996543884,
1.101109266281128,
0.3806506097316742,
0.5759360194206238,
0.04462892934679985,
1.0605617761611938,
-0.6721009016036987,
-0.6474171280860901,
-0.8522533774375916,
0.14435258507728577,
0.1705426424741745,
-0.10443766415119171,
0.9054042100906372,
0.6781611442565918,
0.6456273198127747,
-0.20535720884799957,
0.584496796131134,
-0.023313110694289207,
0.24768401682376862,
-0.6592358946800232,
0.6535817384719849,
-0.45508071780204773,
0.4408815801143646,
-0.24385201930999756,
-0.9744894504547119,
-0.2482798993587494,
0.36226654052734375,
-0.377307653427124,
-0.017003703862428665,
0.6974196434020996,
0.9208311438560486,
-0.15422658622264862,
0.0535099096596241,
0.3241082727909088,
0.19337524473667145,
0.18834355473518372,
0.706434428691864,
1.0417101383209229,
-0.2185276448726654,
0.7105125784873962,
-0.3606274425983429,
-0.2255740910768509,
-0.15131071209907532,
-1.0115115642547607,
-1.0315351486206055,
-0.4430859684944153,
-0.010190975852310658,
-0.3479340672492981,
0.023828012868762016,
0.6795449256896973,
0.6777600646018982,
-0.5876811146736145,
-0.03784338757395744,
-0.347027063369751,
-0.20126424729824066,
-0.028194883838295937,
-0.3348008692264557,
0.4392554461956024,
-0.3920668661594391,
-0.6988146305084229,
0.7710760235786438,
0.07034093141555786,
-0.17182578146457672,
-0.26755020022392273,
-0.2561054229736328,
-0.1381135880947113,
-0.034947797656059265,
0.4941764175891876,
0.17922933399677277,
-0.7257936596870422,
-0.02869522012770176,
0.17031420767307281,
-0.10152309387922287,
-0.06994672119617462,
0.7695690989494324,
-0.9250017404556274,
0.2943330407142639,
0.46555235981941223,
0.7470776438713074,
0.5617981553077698,
0.16366168856620789,
0.5501936078071594,
-1.0970722436904907,
0.29720234870910645,
0.4780026376247406,
0.044186100363731384,
0.2910953760147095,
-0.6674621105194092,
-0.022189132869243622,
0.3076310455799103,
-0.35516929626464844,
-1.005009651184082,
0.28087982535362244,
-0.9588406085968018,
-0.08887853473424911,
1.2882575988769531,
-0.07705068588256836,
-0.5117035508155823,
-0.013075772672891617,
0.035073909908533096,
0.2573734223842621,
-0.6245876550674438,
0.7738062739372253,
0.5592018365859985,
0.042096346616744995,
-0.18348285555839539,
-0.17844383418560028,
0.6102343201637268,
0.6313250660896301,
-0.6834635138511658,
0.3297197222709656,
0.32709595561027527,
0.09146720170974731,
0.09603464603424072,
0.5827093720436096,
-0.2088814377784729,
-0.006771268788725138,
0.34082937240600586,
-0.3796047866344452,
-0.3326411545276642,
-0.3272952139377594,
0.0929151102900505,
0.1705903708934784,
0.09886514395475388,
-0.08226968348026276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19323v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19323v1
|
Are Large Language Models Chameleons?
| 2024-05-29T17:54:22 | 2024-05-29T17:54:22 |
Mingmeng Geng, Sihong He, Roberto Trotta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Do large language models (LLMs) have their own worldviews and personality
tendencies? Simulations in which an LLM was asked to answer subjective
questions were conducted more than 1 million times. Comparison of the responses
from different LLMs with real data from the European Social Survey (ESS)
suggests that the effect of prompts on bias and variability is fundamental,
highlighting major cultural, age, and gender biases. Methods for measuring the
difference between LLMs and survey data are discussed, such as calculating
weighted means and a new proposed measure inspired by Jaccard similarity. We
conclude that it is important to analyze the robustness and variability of
prompts before using LLMs to model individual decisions or collective behavior,
as their imitation abilities are approximate at best.
|
[
-0.41841667890548706,
-0.919239342212677,
0.6210765838623047,
0.41458430886268616,
0.028936190530657768,
-0.0475785955786705,
-0.3873055577278137,
-0.3916378617286682,
0.44308987259864807,
0.6722282767295837,
-0.5963039398193359,
-0.2183951437473297,
-0.47826680541038513,
0.3106037378311157,
-0.35181018710136414,
0.6516819000244141,
0.4550624489784241,
0.23990114033222198,
-0.36744335293769836,
-0.13529044389724731,
-0.12030082195997238,
-0.541386067867279,
-0.6476222276687622,
-0.5237454771995544,
0.8276302814483643,
0.3195018470287323,
0.612360417842865,
0.42388278245925903,
0.29012051224708557,
0.3661949038505554,
-0.27894851565361023,
-0.055509742349386215,
-0.180085688829422,
0.46465128660202026,
-0.3153081238269806,
-0.7304046154022217,
-0.09570915997028351,
0.13067521154880524,
0.47151076793670654,
1.0309371948242188,
0.046272557228803635,
0.33754220604896545,
0.14202746748924255,
0.4762187898159027,
-0.23301783204078674,
0.28000763058662415,
-0.4214384853839874,
0.04600673168897629,
-0.029002999886870384,
-0.04812232777476311,
-0.35363829135894775,
-0.38955894112586975,
0.4392313063144684,
-0.09271810948848724,
0.09083447605371475,
0.23509342968463898,
0.25470975041389465,
-0.07749386876821518,
-0.5838029384613037,
-0.531923234462738,
-0.6119861602783203,
0.9742966294288635,
-0.8428138494491577,
-0.041034240275621414,
0.27091991901397705,
0.29846981167793274,
-0.38784661889076233,
-0.3803856372833252,
-0.5800194144248962,
-0.6070756316184998,
0.05694039911031723,
-0.07107188552618027,
-0.199009969830513,
-0.166413813829422,
0.5143154263496399,
0.10527094453573227,
-0.568080723285675,
0.39375853538513184,
-0.2840760350227356,
-0.029019493609666824,
0.8928343653678894,
0.49817946553230286,
0.3492063283920288,
-0.1242554783821106,
-0.15805406868457794,
0.08673025667667389,
-0.593252420425415,
0.13473428785800934,
0.6717280149459839,
0.452569842338562,
-0.37179529666900635,
0.5481363534927368,
-0.08723720163106918,
0.7450093626976013,
0.06626252830028534,
-0.31188929080963135,
0.04131326824426651,
0.2254294902086258,
-0.10543128103017807,
-0.0795527920126915,
0.781022310256958,
0.4623740613460541,
0.7445459365844727,
0.049168456345796585,
-0.17134666442871094,
0.043104369193315506,
-0.056040581315755844,
-0.3828555941581726,
-0.023465657606720924,
0.16519537568092346,
-0.448224812746048,
-0.2744493782520294,
-0.21238744258880615,
-1.1044487953186035,
-0.9090771675109863,
-0.4634815454483032,
-0.16020087897777557,
0.060318466275930405,
-0.11462172120809555,
0.13228590786457062,
-0.1028820127248764,
0.47382107377052307,
0.5728567242622375,
-0.8151591420173645,
0.4659467935562134,
0.48247861862182617,
0.7922570109367371,
-0.43001046776771545,
-0.43574321269989014,
-0.13208946585655212,
-0.26760849356651306,
-0.1874629110097885,
0.9068549275398254,
-0.7354665398597717,
-0.8159655928611755,
0.1559620052576065,
0.03997443988919258,
0.1612769216299057,
-0.46865105628967285,
0.224572092294693,
-0.44141557812690735,
0.12962035834789276,
-0.8733458518981934,
-0.5217791795730591,
-0.033807024359703064,
0.33846190571784973,
-0.5813776850700378,
0.5815165042877197,
-0.057228270918130875,
-0.67540043592453,
0.05501417815685272,
-0.32082128524780273,
-0.20669420063495636,
-0.07009411603212357,
-0.28285595774650574,
0.028204763308167458,
0.09856734424829483,
0.1035461574792862,
0.535245418548584,
-0.6603845953941345,
0.14834801852703094,
-0.6996490955352783,
-0.22779148817062378,
0.761125385761261,
-0.3929356634616852,
1.0481040477752686,
0.12905456125736237,
-0.180464968085289,
-0.024227602407336235,
-0.5979966521263123,
-0.18376298248767853,
0.22318939864635468,
-0.05720619484782219,
-0.4365796148777008,
0.15232253074645996,
-0.18003778159618378,
0.3770531117916107,
0.12456655502319336,
-0.44252070784568787,
0.6158386468887329,
-0.12020400166511536,
0.4704521894454956,
0.9295744299888611,
0.18201006948947906,
0.27648553252220154,
-0.6318057775497437,
0.5990024209022522,
0.05356535315513611,
-0.037794891744852066,
-0.14265382289886475,
-0.6290183067321777,
-0.8459858298301697,
-0.04490291699767113,
-0.038013506680727005,
0.36750027537345886,
-0.19655688107013702,
0.3430553078651428,
-0.14320962131023407,
-0.874653160572052,
0.06566449254751205,
-0.020844999700784683,
0.11435164511203766,
0.20980805158615112,
-0.11729133874177933,
-0.3666163980960846,
-0.45777320861816406,
-1.0287562608718872,
-0.3938438594341278,
-0.3134140968322754,
-0.015595359727740288,
0.407991886138916,
0.7887970209121704,
-0.11496222019195557,
0.8289942741394043,
-0.30255645513534546,
0.2630118429660797,
-0.33762070536613464,
0.12185259163379669,
0.16228315234184265,
0.1355137974023819,
0.6423336863517761,
-0.4986988306045532,
-0.2829607427120209,
-0.44375306367874146,
-0.7881473302841187,
-0.4498594403266907,
0.002487988444045186,
0.30400919914245605,
-0.07568249851465225,
0.5250787734985352,
-0.49795690178871155,
-0.01423771120607853,
0.6589950323104858,
-0.2519626319408417,
0.7062295079231262,
0.039497580379247665,
0.06780803203582764,
-0.8733325004577637,
-0.21099193394184113,
0.5333134531974792,
0.058603573590517044,
-0.5354386568069458,
0.013970118016004562,
-0.2919301688671112,
0.03954768925905228,
-0.6245935559272766,
0.8412054181098938,
-0.4801523983478546,
-0.40544891357421875,
-0.09218084812164307,
0.3980296850204468,
-0.21333685517311096,
0.32043278217315674,
-0.07921051234006882,
0.7532705068588257,
0.6498948335647583,
-0.9064481854438782,
0.7597182989120483,
0.027006620541214943,
-0.5022627115249634,
0.7652924060821533,
-0.9319176077842712,
0.28817224502563477,
-0.5215258598327637,
0.40237852931022644,
-1.0410218238830566,
-0.3630310595035553,
0.04052184894680977,
-0.2131320983171463,
-0.0880424901843071,
0.08938797563314438,
-0.25886082649230957,
-0.6520476937294006,
-0.2722582221031189,
0.19584739208221436,
0.5569696426391602,
-0.35096219182014465,
0.42815926671028137,
0.4981060326099396,
-0.4889872670173645,
-0.38142770528793335,
-0.8720189929008484,
-0.018238991498947144,
-0.3736462891101837,
-0.47179821133613586,
-0.21973969042301178,
-0.2987671494483948,
-1.0121312141418457,
-0.4206415116786957,
0.11868230253458023,
0.10873395204544067,
-0.1736457794904709,
0.3189466893672943,
0.1488194465637207,
-0.0927782654762268,
0.05334409326314926,
-0.3190665543079376,
0.285117506980896,
0.22587434947490692,
-0.2307715117931366,
0.7978234887123108,
-0.1866263598203659,
-0.5631062388420105,
-0.22461342811584473,
0.22657254338264465,
0.8477540016174316,
-0.11278117448091507,
0.5800458192825317,
-0.11192676424980164,
-0.0903828889131546,
-0.06634725630283356,
-0.7287001609802246,
-0.11509531736373901,
-0.4597347676753998,
0.19401311874389648,
-0.16183224320411682,
-1.0415695905685425,
0.9951316714286804,
0.06968282163143158,
0.12004134058952332,
0.31304076313972473,
0.8704591393470764,
-0.15640154480934143,
1.0003820657730103,
0.24905739724636078,
-0.31549715995788574,
0.37414470314979553,
0.11386047303676605,
-0.039639219641685486,
-0.605839192867279,
-0.39266157150268555,
-0.9083073139190674,
-0.41901543736457825,
-0.7096098065376282,
-0.2563002407550812,
0.2752598524093628,
-0.43038102984428406,
-0.4866845905780792,
-0.21264450252056122,
-0.1260054111480713,
0.5817290544509888,
0.31720706820487976,
-0.05093323066830635,
0.06123896315693855,
-0.04217145964503288,
0.06520821899175644,
-0.1880527287721634,
-0.49708613753318787,
-0.8354858160018921,
0.9694485068321228,
0.18008747696876526,
1.2449359893798828,
0.033299461007118225,
0.2910715341567993,
0.47837844491004944,
0.2931635081768036,
-0.7582773566246033,
0.815675675868988,
0.263084352016449,
-0.4717748463153839,
-0.34334465861320496,
-0.35652101039886475,
-1.0902661085128784,
0.35259756445884705,
-0.009005916304886341,
-1.0063800811767578,
0.19070956110954285,
0.05325543135404587,
-0.13813765347003937,
0.3346604108810425,
-0.3326815068721771,
0.2266094982624054,
-0.22917556762695312,
-0.166405588388443,
0.0971449688076973,
-0.6645108461380005,
0.5769214630126953,
0.003424924099817872,
0.3529711365699768,
-0.25152483582496643,
-0.11392027884721756,
0.7480161786079407,
-0.12798568606376648,
1.2439382076263428,
0.015534032136201859,
-0.3787916302680969,
0.5062069296836853,
0.23668207228183746,
0.514130711555481,
0.042327702045440674,
-0.3371046483516693,
0.03705916926264763,
-0.06559810787439346,
-0.5481042265892029,
-0.7356224656105042,
0.9917858839035034,
-1.0035043954849243,
-0.856006383895874,
-0.5522494912147522,
-0.6021463871002197,
-0.28726905584335327,
-0.15647758543491364,
0.1569366157054901,
0.5120947957038879,
-0.33025726675987244,
0.2116885483264923,
0.7373780608177185,
-0.42228126525878906,
0.551744282245636,
0.6399197578430176,
-0.23945407569408417,
-0.05213092640042305,
0.27738142013549805,
0.2331375926733017,
0.38965001702308655,
0.17890001833438873,
0.30463266372680664,
-0.22484366595745087,
-0.11606231331825256,
-0.19738297164440155,
0.40935105085372925,
-0.717296302318573,
0.19924896955490112,
-0.67557293176651,
0.070918969810009,
-0.40465858578681946,
-0.16023693978786469,
-0.04969101399183273,
-0.15143081545829773,
0.03916814550757408,
0.012118333950638771,
0.19083763659000397,
1.0007418394088745,
0.2633419632911682,
0.4416763186454773,
-0.6940513253211975,
-0.18819577991962433,
0.6563087701797485,
0.08256521075963974,
0.1281663030385971,
-0.4462801218032837,
0.04846477508544922,
0.14443223178386688,
-0.047244224697351456,
-1.2182371616363525,
0.2890448272228241,
-0.2562158405780792,
0.6812921762466431,
0.31375718116760254,
-0.06270423531532288,
0.30365750193595886,
-0.2678631842136383,
1.430816411972046,
-0.02498774230480194,
-0.8715851306915283,
0.34890538454055786,
-0.5498741865158081,
0.48275575041770935,
0.22095833718776703,
0.45839130878448486,
-0.8721717596054077,
-0.4611210823059082,
-0.5256099700927734,
-0.28741592168807983,
0.4914877414703369,
-0.17065119743347168,
0.5470974445343018,
-0.136128768324852,
0.48283204436302185,
0.041759371757507324,
0.30630677938461304,
-0.8018989562988281,
-0.445970356464386,
0.210244283080101,
-0.010873458348214626,
-0.2421589493751526,
-0.4204334318637848,
-0.09562849998474121,
-0.20006835460662842,
0.38713371753692627,
-0.05087916925549507,
0.18672296404838562,
0.06310341507196426,
0.058328963816165924,
-0.1931743174791336,
0.3774142563343048,
0.7181705236434937,
0.7257545590400696,
0.32418960332870483,
0.33447349071502686,
0.49916648864746094,
-0.2748691737651825,
0.49581095576286316,
-0.5989513397216797,
-0.08143102377653122,
-0.07893787324428558,
0.5961878299713135,
0.6270075440406799,
0.1169758290052414,
-0.8087903261184692,
0.4515973925590515,
-0.055719055235385895,
-0.1866108775138855,
-0.36888542771339417,
0.17863546311855316,
0.05640760809183121,
0.39362505078315735,
0.05651029199361801,
-0.08310120552778244,
-0.07963202148675919,
-0.8225375413894653,
-0.21049180626869202,
0.40033814311027527,
-0.2771986126899719,
-0.4945491552352905,
0.387785941362381,
0.22293369472026825,
-0.5724806785583496,
0.4497058093547821,
-0.05863279849290848,
-0.29943570494651794,
0.8446427583694458,
0.5499302744865417,
0.6073012948036194,
-0.6496321558952332,
0.19345569610595703,
0.13029435276985168,
0.3734574317932129,
-0.3826966881752014,
0.27027422189712524,
0.3256220817565918,
-0.8222733736038208,
-0.15426181256771088,
-0.50284343957901,
-0.5590330958366394,
0.37011784315109253,
-0.6540297865867615,
0.30752649903297424,
-0.34896811842918396,
-0.13671262562274933,
0.051766786724328995,
-0.04089433699846268,
-0.713137686252594,
0.2768934965133667,
0.07774321734905243,
0.9969671368598938,
-1.0935564041137695,
0.5059149861335754,
0.8219712376594543,
-0.34254202246665955,
-0.6423308849334717,
0.13459594547748566,
0.2825605273246765,
-0.7415145039558411,
0.5777364373207092,
-0.08896961808204651,
0.03509228304028511,
-0.2904284596443176,
-0.8760945200920105,
-0.9456376433372498,
0.7355942130088806,
0.448883980512619,
-0.7796421051025391,
-0.13652309775352478,
0.14807318150997162,
0.5956721305847168,
-0.4952571988105774,
0.368042916059494,
0.6388649940490723,
0.5811249017715454,
-0.0862065926194191,
-0.700805127620697,
-0.21366184949874878,
-0.17546948790550232,
0.2306535392999649,
-0.08864161372184753,
-1.0462688207626343,
1.0105390548706055,
-0.18542969226837158,
0.2730821669101715,
0.008087032474577427,
0.5516462922096252,
0.4470503628253937,
0.1203661859035492,
0.5813905000686646,
-0.04466141760349274,
0.8460714221000671,
-0.02819152921438217,
1.1664360761642456,
-0.3610590398311615,
0.27553585171699524,
0.8795127868652344,
-0.6928406953811646,
0.3857613205909729,
0.3795756995677948,
-0.3828789293766022,
0.6006566882133484,
0.7550650835037231,
-0.037984687834978104,
0.09621112793684006,
0.6261652708053589,
-0.21708330512046814,
-0.23554246127605438,
-0.06462573260068893,
-0.18071803450584412,
0.5145633220672607,
0.4705086350440979,
-0.4917807877063751,
-0.06995204091072083,
-0.032707713544368744,
0.07427193969488144,
0.1011921614408493,
-0.4606837034225464,
0.5337357521057129,
0.307364821434021,
-0.8189648389816284,
0.09780863672494888,
-0.06059711053967476,
0.626327395439148,
-0.5641012191772461,
0.38170167803764343,
-0.3976520001888275,
-0.23270554840564728,
-0.04088025167584419,
-0.8219814896583557,
-0.02435905486345291,
-0.08715138584375381,
-0.09718520194292068,
0.04758714884519577,
0.6841841340065002,
-0.27248889207839966,
-0.3725036680698395,
0.05174897611141205,
0.7938410043716431,
0.2744303047657013,
0.25007036328315735,
-0.5081577301025391,
0.0056728171184659,
-0.05906295031309128,
-0.6113928556442261,
0.270246297121048,
0.377587229013443,
-0.1900540292263031,
1.0010709762573242,
0.2277875542640686,
0.20668034255504608,
0.2074340581893921,
0.15985991060733795,
0.5796490907669067,
-0.7383077144622803,
-0.5046737790107727,
-1.1367378234863281,
0.05625922605395317,
-0.28696703910827637,
-0.3491668999195099,
1.0241150856018066,
0.3040836751461029,
0.5599184632301331,
-0.2265641689300537,
1.0508956909179688,
0.26375123858451843,
0.3122422695159912,
-0.38439562916755676,
0.26902493834495544,
-0.2918437421321869,
0.3256179392337799,
-0.4217447340488434,
-1.1725308895111084,
-0.11198660731315613,
0.5275751352310181,
-0.5531623959541321,
0.31834807991981506,
0.4718426764011383,
0.8508700728416443,
0.22274965047836304,
0.3763771951198578,
0.35347068309783936,
0.30256330966949463,
0.3288886547088623,
0.29537808895111084,
1.1028869152069092,
0.27058202028274536,
-0.09198099374771118,
0.2787815034389496,
-0.06096309795975685,
-0.19537626206874847,
-0.5194159150123596,
-1.1569201946258545,
-0.5121448636054993,
-0.21699023246765137,
-0.27124348282814026,
-0.15517519414424896,
1.324676513671875,
0.3829107880592346,
-0.5599324703216553,
-0.5788876414299011,
0.1736554503440857,
0.05486556887626648,
-0.04568459093570709,
-0.21844178438186646,
0.0009992843260988593,
-0.17340826988220215,
-0.8195127844810486,
0.09576176851987839,
0.3617548942565918,
0.348263680934906,
-0.8848783373832703,
0.08642078191041946,
0.1291012465953827,
0.6535324454307556,
0.5945780277252197,
0.19711987674236298,
-0.9155657291412354,
-0.5723397135734558,
0.1269623041152954,
-0.30635499954223633,
-0.0897437334060669,
1.004944086074829,
-0.5395585298538208,
0.32348883152008057,
0.46022066473960876,
0.13282860815525055,
0.14708150923252106,
-0.2967510521411896,
0.4746161103248596,
-0.714691162109375,
0.37565261125564575,
0.2550888955593109,
0.654871940612793,
0.2762012183666229,
-0.10085351765155792,
0.23396272957324982,
0.2587789297103882,
-0.7445819973945618,
-0.6019913554191589,
0.5533158183097839,
-0.9215420484542847,
-0.10166799277067184,
1.5884644985198975,
-0.03090491332113743,
-0.3304600715637207,
-0.1351490318775177,
-0.34986528754234314,
-0.021712295711040497,
-0.38502639532089233,
0.7515965104103088,
0.9643966555595398,
-0.1788199096918106,
-0.25856298208236694,
-0.5709848999977112,
0.14492802321910858,
0.07358366250991821,
-0.8402741551399231,
-0.059577181935310364,
0.6033849716186523,
0.4298824369907379,
0.13898485898971558,
0.6397233009338379,
0.07031706720590591,
-0.11001990735530853,
0.05362105369567871,
-0.1546168029308319,
0.3124266564846039,
-0.02200579084455967,
-0.49537888169288635,
0.13540558516979218,
0.19062305986881256,
0.49180546402931213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19316v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19316v1
|
Robust Preference Optimization through Reward Model Distillation
| 2024-05-29T17:39:48 | 2024-05-29T17:39:48 |
Adam Fisch, Jacob Eisenstein, Vicky Zayats, Alekh Agarwal, Ahmad Beirami, Chirag Nagpal, Pete Shaw, Jonathan Berant
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Language model (LM) post-training (or alignment) involves maximizing a reward
function that is derived from preference annotations. Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) is a popular offline alignment method that trains a policy
directly on preference data without the need to train a reward model or apply
reinforcement learning. However, typical preference datasets have only a
single, or at most a few, annotation per preference pair, which causes DPO to
overconfidently assign rewards that trend towards infinite magnitude. This
frequently leads to degenerate policies, sometimes causing even the
probabilities of the preferred generations to go to zero. In this work, we
analyze this phenomenon and propose distillation to get a better proxy for the
true preference distribution over generation pairs: we train the LM to produce
probabilities that match the distribution induced by a reward model trained on
the preference data. Moreover, to account for uncertainty in the reward model
we are distilling from, we optimize against a family of reward models that, as
a whole, is likely to include at least one reasonable proxy for the preference
distribution. Our results show that distilling from such a family of reward
models leads to improved robustness to distribution shift in preference
annotations, while preserving the simple supervised nature of DPO.
|
[
-0.3477303981781006,
-0.28885379433631897,
0.6829321980476379,
-0.010571653954684734,
-0.4111368656158447,
0.13563546538352966,
-0.3030693829059601,
0.02502584271132946,
0.09741663932800293,
0.25482651591300964,
-0.6311476826667786,
-0.04581106826663017,
-0.770313560962677,
0.0102439746260643,
0.19812944531440735,
1.0701053142547607,
0.005712142679840326,
-0.20362308621406555,
-0.23833058774471283,
-0.024255305528640747,
-0.3072517216205597,
-0.5907436013221741,
-0.4762643277645111,
-0.7188922166824341,
0.39671167731285095,
0.3093315064907074,
0.6973761320114136,
0.9157238602638245,
0.28072407841682434,
0.2603285610675812,
-0.34131893515586853,
0.14535067975521088,
-0.8535158634185791,
0.30323946475982666,
-0.03874655067920685,
-0.4760321080684662,
-0.31859880685806274,
0.14255410432815552,
0.17379555106163025,
0.7223552465438843,
-0.17133621871471405,
0.05851806327700615,
0.4222087562084198,
1.0075922012329102,
-0.9065561890602112,
0.014759534038603306,
-0.9701278805732727,
-0.022859899327158928,
-0.06943590193986893,
-0.38566526770591736,
-0.39703568816185,
-0.7582041621208191,
0.3692164123058319,
-0.5131645202636719,
-0.08453213423490524,
-0.07262711226940155,
0.9528971314430237,
0.652774453163147,
-0.3315831422805786,
-0.26244479417800903,
-0.7776418924331665,
1.1291307210922241,
-0.5141306519508362,
0.050223082304000854,
0.6104860901832581,
0.268016517162323,
-0.3153664469718933,
-0.40971067547798157,
-0.5077895522117615,
-0.3250831365585327,
0.03653261810541153,
0.015973800793290138,
-0.0670594647526741,
0.13905464112758636,
-0.09243421256542206,
0.6281933784484863,
-0.14382895827293396,
0.19716303050518036,
0.24691124260425568,
0.1127338632941246,
0.6084501147270203,
-0.037956010550260544,
-0.06346264481544495,
-0.003380984766408801,
-0.6160102486610413,
-0.47838982939720154,
-0.5782611966133118,
0.28506118059158325,
0.7890087366104126,
0.39826762676239014,
0.24687843024730682,
0.37621426582336426,
-0.2717300057411194,
0.7863210439682007,
0.558796763420105,
-0.4573512375354767,
0.42536410689353943,
-0.22664248943328857,
0.02083227038383484,
0.2865080237388611,
0.8076075911521912,
0.5066776871681213,
0.34950441122055054,
0.017751585692167282,
-0.28986483812332153,
-0.01787790097296238,
0.20744337141513824,
-0.5577672123908997,
-0.2805722951889038,
0.40494322776794434,
-0.5115877389907837,
-0.9800004959106445,
-0.18564337491989136,
-0.7765482664108276,
-0.45398226380348206,
-0.42703863978385925,
0.21331451833248138,
-0.18106435239315033,
-0.4476269781589508,
0.30877193808555603,
-0.35057926177978516,
-0.15315304696559906,
0.03666950762271881,
-1.6813980340957642,
0.04282422363758087,
0.6698912382125854,
0.7364616990089417,
-0.2671969532966614,
-0.10303385555744171,
-0.5936277508735657,
0.024787653237581253,
-0.08051355183124542,
0.66129469871521,
-0.45178812742233276,
-0.40356123447418213,
0.09955332428216934,
-0.24737054109573364,
0.016471538692712784,
-0.6370828747749329,
0.811665952205658,
-0.4153406322002411,
0.05923902243375778,
-0.2899414300918579,
-0.5168718099594116,
0.2101457267999649,
0.3791162669658661,
-0.6419316530227661,
0.9762950539588928,
0.1783307045698166,
-0.9139375686645508,
0.8341895341873169,
-0.44739988446235657,
-0.12223678082227707,
-0.1974431276321411,
0.08470205962657928,
-0.45503246784210205,
0.2567000985145569,
0.19391509890556335,
0.28789910674095154,
-0.08933408558368683,
0.5571392178535461,
-0.7137302756309509,
-0.3082638680934906,
0.21854807436466217,
-0.4443841874599457,
0.8125199675559998,
0.45810678601264954,
-0.5277361869812012,
0.0839199423789978,
-0.7526841759681702,
-0.15839530527591705,
0.20740513503551483,
-0.2674117684364319,
-0.9141802191734314,
0.3056102395057678,
-0.3249223232269287,
0.2163754254579544,
0.4009610414505005,
-0.4104743003845215,
0.6860244274139404,
-0.4533490538597107,
0.536078929901123,
1.1767938137054443,
-0.17971044778823853,
0.7447533011436462,
-0.17064225673675537,
0.3403858244419098,
0.0630883276462555,
0.4762875735759735,
0.26988399028778076,
-0.11835303157567978,
-0.5535463094711304,
-0.43489688634872437,
0.24611444771289825,
0.31159019470214844,
-0.6027977466583252,
0.7908218502998352,
-0.31902703642845154,
-0.2624610662460327,
-0.5894654989242554,
0.1748204380273819,
0.0501922145485878,
0.7025229334831238,
0.2699127793312073,
0.2029779553413391,
-0.2181573063135147,
-1.0260833501815796,
0.07012065500020981,
-0.396404504776001,
0.05806034803390503,
0.0008314519072882831,
0.046714555472135544,
0.02747679501771927,
1.080099105834961,
-0.9196255803108215,
-0.05993310362100601,
-0.35592925548553467,
0.09596060961484909,
0.36784878373146057,
0.2984301745891571,
0.6838686466217041,
-1.0155634880065918,
-0.5585169792175293,
-0.20517678558826447,
-0.3325914740562439,
-0.19241826236248016,
-0.060559168457984924,
-0.3597598671913147,
0.0767020657658577,
-0.09908407926559448,
0.00829183217138052,
0.057076968252658844,
0.5986142158508301,
-0.007056296803057194,
0.1896180659532547,
-0.20082150399684906,
0.07676271349191666,
-1.2462642192840576,
0.062714584171772,
0.03793264180421829,
-0.13367685675621033,
-0.5230464339256287,
-0.2952745258808136,
0.010648134164512157,
0.24604031443595886,
-0.33266711235046387,
0.27628061175346375,
-0.31612440943717957,
0.4148830473423004,
-0.4884801506996155,
-0.16742728650569916,
0.14519785344600677,
0.4680728614330292,
0.3843865692615509,
0.36515551805496216,
0.5979723930358887,
-0.5258064270019531,
0.5032796859741211,
0.3220413327217102,
-0.086968332529068,
0.47787049412727356,
-0.5707235932350159,
0.09199264645576477,
-0.21496787667274475,
-0.04018465802073479,
-1.1117017269134521,
0.013523532077670097,
0.17639166116714478,
0.0011228506918996572,
0.5537921190261841,
-0.40167149901390076,
-0.1862931102514267,
-0.23006629943847656,
-0.7437707185745239,
0.17522476613521576,
0.6508554220199585,
-0.9869140982627869,
-0.03866085782647133,
0.3978789448738098,
0.0005024641868658364,
-0.9361316561698914,
-0.5022318363189697,
-0.3585420846939087,
-0.7259247303009033,
-0.3538253903388977,
0.44058936834335327,
-0.04185476154088974,
-0.3376697599887848,
-0.12064123898744583,
-0.25607118010520935,
-0.010029344819486141,
0.29065006971359253,
0.20590531826019287,
0.5930339097976685,
0.2947700023651123,
-0.0108504518866539,
0.21435433626174927,
-0.3588095009326935,
-0.24831315875053406,
-0.3011130094528198,
0.6012560725212097,
0.14244979619979858,
-0.08636263012886047,
-0.1720399409532547,
0.17026710510253906,
0.4680747985839844,
-0.048937030136585236,
0.8624929785728455,
0.06385646015405655,
0.07856515794992447,
-0.25044354796409607,
-0.41473016142845154,
-0.19960129261016846,
-0.5389613509178162,
0.03636382892727852,
-0.4765510559082031,
-0.7325524687767029,
0.22579644620418549,
-0.22648313641548157,
0.03450183942914009,
0.16085803508758545,
0.4080561697483063,
0.1296963095664978,
1.1141146421432495,
0.6605699062347412,
-0.42049410939216614,
0.7122884392738342,
-0.051854513585567474,
0.08713099360466003,
-0.5636475086212158,
-0.14007040858268738,
-0.5349502563476562,
-0.48669663071632385,
-0.7912989854812622,
0.11380424350500107,
0.267917275428772,
0.2586936950683594,
-0.03888032212853432,
0.19617363810539246,
-0.916716992855072,
0.293236643075943,
0.917172908782959,
0.03601960092782974,
0.28821611404418945,
0.21501515805721283,
-0.16082465648651123,
-0.08892710506916046,
-0.5608567595481873,
-0.5928676128387451,
1.1490962505340576,
0.3416915833950043,
0.917327880859375,
-0.20709119737148285,
1.2047189474105835,
0.07292705774307251,
-0.007685193791985512,
-0.7724581360816956,
0.07475120574235916,
-0.2601940333843231,
-0.37323102355003357,
-0.2887406349182129,
-0.5652406811714172,
-0.9002755284309387,
0.05656362697482109,
-0.2429284304380417,
-0.8236010670661926,
0.5743303894996643,
0.5978438854217529,
-0.40295740962028503,
0.2615903913974762,
-0.56556236743927,
1.0281819105148315,
-0.4548034071922302,
-0.5983622074127197,
0.11393561214208603,
-0.7812451124191284,
0.43873679637908936,
-0.04722071439027786,
-0.03818226233124733,
-0.2575785219669342,
0.20730474591255188,
0.23653359711170197,
-0.5347129702568054,
0.316177099943161,
-0.28503158688545227,
-0.12163802236318588,
0.11963178962469101,
0.062434952706098557,
0.6965383291244507,
-0.014766214415431023,
-0.40264999866485596,
-0.033492933958768845,
0.09663590043783188,
-0.26890623569488525,
-0.5241446495056152,
0.9746721386909485,
-0.8999709486961365,
-0.5782740712165833,
-0.6295292377471924,
-0.2770117223262787,
-0.293817400932312,
-0.11123819649219513,
0.4380117356777191,
0.06422987580299377,
-0.09017075598239899,
0.0062625110149383545,
0.6449455618858337,
-0.08577673137187958,
0.5662684440612793,
0.044601526111364365,
0.017573736608028412,
-0.29633182287216187,
0.8716238141059875,
-0.1830863654613495,
0.6808931827545166,
0.4398444890975952,
0.6582760810852051,
-0.8565460443496704,
-0.5164963006973267,
-0.5009466409683228,
-0.07763082534074783,
-0.4644787311553955,
0.08345779776573181,
-0.24274933338165283,
0.28997814655303955,
-0.4345059394836426,
-0.2506616413593292,
-0.6046853065490723,
-0.39208072423934937,
-0.24068228900432587,
-0.21740394830703735,
0.48336076736450195,
0.3544808626174927,
-0.09007468819618225,
0.10135260224342346,
-0.5756369829177856,
0.25668811798095703,
0.39147090911865234,
0.32777097821235657,
-0.3060670495033264,
-0.5728121995925903,
0.10747868567705154,
0.36384421586990356,
-0.42392101883888245,
-0.8631181716918945,
0.4477974474430084,
0.0610739104449749,
0.6087592840194702,
0.6126673817634583,
0.5493435859680176,
0.6648862361907959,
-0.34637048840522766,
0.6672455072402954,
0.32349786162376404,
-0.7730222344398499,
0.7201498746871948,
-0.21415887773036957,
0.05337927117943764,
1.1089816093444824,
0.6697664856910706,
-0.2858223021030426,
-0.025611620396375656,
-0.4268724322319031,
-1.016008973121643,
0.7889351844787598,
0.07064913958311081,
0.19811268150806427,
-0.03194094076752663,
0.3886766731739044,
0.43150100111961365,
0.3851577937602997,
-0.7929584383964539,
-0.4777687191963196,
-0.5265974402427673,
-0.3279557228088379,
-0.12104834616184235,
-0.4224145710468292,
-0.17565961182117462,
-0.0252007395029068,
0.6841993927955627,
-0.054004717618227005,
-0.29294678568840027,
-0.12982365489006042,
0.25650855898857117,
-0.08655261993408203,
0.288228303194046,
0.4281744956970215,
0.4429272711277008,
-0.645018994808197,
0.27765339612960815,
-0.42178553342819214,
-0.2614921033382416,
0.6779654026031494,
0.13156357407569885,
-0.31842145323753357,
-0.10666336864233017,
-0.257116436958313,
1.0783390998840332,
-0.17248541116714478,
-0.41210004687309265,
0.5270469784736633,
-0.02602764405310154,
-0.17084890604019165,
-0.11053435504436493,
0.06297007948160172,
0.06456268578767776,
-0.10973485559225082,
0.21653874218463898,
-0.0946274995803833,
0.34315386414527893,
-0.6157629489898682,
-0.05772560462355614,
0.5110815167427063,
-0.3429083526134491,
-0.13133205473423004,
0.7959155440330505,
0.26604077219963074,
0.08862730860710144,
0.44965991377830505,
-0.2798159420490265,
-0.3206785321235657,
0.19503529369831085,
0.374025821685791,
1.0323500633239746,
-0.19418683648109436,
0.34956780076026917,
0.3947141170501709,
0.031274206936359406,
-0.55387282371521,
-0.15675239264965057,
-0.23031996190547943,
-0.8940148949623108,
-0.19365036487579346,
-0.9011844396591187,
-0.2440207153558731,
0.169716015458107,
-0.9147337675094604,
0.40184757113456726,
-0.011471543461084366,
-0.32551851868629456,
-0.03630570322275162,
-0.2705127000808716,
-0.36478090286254883,
0.029113134369254112,
0.2211034744977951,
0.31897011399269104,
-1.0765882730484009,
1.010922908782959,
0.5915001034736633,
-0.3639219105243683,
-0.7577471137046814,
0.05446444824337959,
0.04793965816497803,
-0.6989089846611023,
0.8317487835884094,
-0.12419989705085754,
-0.008603991940617561,
-0.13410958647727966,
-0.22775518894195557,
-0.7175005674362183,
0.8066532611846924,
0.6693360209465027,
-0.7829471826553345,
0.1535976529121399,
0.3002246618270874,
0.39086219668388367,
-0.21219569444656372,
0.1587531864643097,
0.6590767502784729,
0.3654053211212158,
0.38482728600502014,
-0.9474945664405823,
-0.0023470898158848286,
-0.08414454013109207,
0.13444843888282776,
0.5062507390975952,
-0.5703267455101013,
0.6249046325683594,
0.10456348955631256,
0.06998402625322342,
-0.2207343876361847,
0.03312278911471367,
0.5135766863822937,
0.25496551394462585,
0.8682324886322021,
0.5655364394187927,
0.5216412544250488,
-0.19951575994491577,
0.9920773506164551,
-0.318976491689682,
0.5086150765419006,
1.1632922887802124,
-0.6054667830467224,
0.7392553091049194,
1.0997129678726196,
-0.240987628698349,
0.18243396282196045,
0.9169422388076782,
0.24798838794231415,
1.1511000394821167,
0.3421437442302704,
-0.33525872230529785,
-0.2999878525733948,
-0.1651647984981537,
-0.3650759160518646,
0.27105432748794556,
-0.23267555236816406,
-0.517665684223175,
-0.10138539224863052,
-0.09933741390705109,
-0.025649016723036766,
0.3275549113750458,
-0.11069285124540329,
0.926927924156189,
-0.11464394629001617,
-1.0295456647872925,
0.8567782044410706,
-0.3579007089138031,
0.848268985748291,
-0.7484018206596375,
0.16425691545009613,
-0.3976839780807495,
0.4003663659095764,
-0.1450791209936142,
-0.4837213456630707,
0.16409903764724731,
-0.09343424439430237,
-0.20712901651859283,
-0.5372073650360107,
0.573072075843811,
-0.5953347086906433,
-0.28604528307914734,
0.2263440042734146,
0.1805957555770874,
-0.04851113632321358,
-0.12987302243709564,
-0.5755977034568787,
0.09620600193738937,
0.22683237493038177,
-0.5771010518074036,
0.5749664902687073,
0.28739190101623535,
0.1793246865272522,
0.5437589883804321,
0.5933386087417603,
0.2750621438026428,
-0.026646185666322708,
0.02331988327205181,
1.0001814365386963,
-0.18180599808692932,
-0.5900088548660278,
-1.3806227445602417,
0.6202227473258972,
-0.3099771738052368,
-0.28242227435112,
0.621045708656311,
0.41542312502861023,
0.7724822759628296,
-0.1628510057926178,
0.8059816956520081,
-0.03171173483133316,
0.2572602927684784,
-0.3523706793785095,
0.5113372802734375,
-0.7214072346687317,
0.22345487773418427,
-0.35445526242256165,
-1.2286133766174316,
0.08775170892477036,
0.6004170775413513,
-0.35053402185440063,
-0.23446762561798096,
0.4320855438709259,
0.5690023303031921,
-0.04288768395781517,
-0.2609352767467499,
0.2682914733886719,
-0.38630256056785583,
0.1960289180278778,
0.6911199688911438,
0.8601387739181519,
0.06795541197061539,
0.3739437162876129,
-0.6143860816955566,
-0.40659046173095703,
-0.29340511560440063,
-1.2940949201583862,
-0.6583952307701111,
-0.48184844851493835,
-0.38072526454925537,
-0.29083603620529175,
0.00824998039752245,
1.1817373037338257,
0.7345438599586487,
-0.7231507301330566,
-0.1491011679172516,
-0.22438880801200867,
-0.020031152293086052,
-0.35663512349128723,
-0.19537971913814545,
0.259479284286499,
-0.4792296588420868,
-1.0710291862487793,
0.28172317147254944,
0.3324229419231415,
0.16637754440307617,
-0.1727486401796341,
-0.15417028963565826,
-0.1239432841539383,
-0.13939180970191956,
0.26866254210472107,
0.10575845837593079,
-0.5286281704902649,
-0.3283712863922119,
-0.002074054442346096,
-0.060514867305755615,
0.20671363174915314,
0.7150521874427795,
-0.3769826591014862,
0.8430798053741455,
0.6030917763710022,
0.4699249267578125,
0.5555610060691833,
0.2245205044746399,
0.7824893593788147,
-0.7070943117141724,
0.5055907368659973,
0.17023944854736328,
0.410122811794281,
0.2339535802602768,
-0.47970134019851685,
0.4144919812679291,
0.08650564402341843,
-0.7140181064605713,
-1.0661414861679077,
0.3374413251876831,
-1.0918018817901611,
-0.2543039321899414,
1.2561777830123901,
-0.28482767939567566,
-0.1156974583864212,
0.06653617322444916,
-0.2734515964984894,
0.30658718943595886,
-0.5519832968711853,
1.2137812376022339,
0.7516043186187744,
-0.13586948812007904,
0.18963590264320374,
-0.0877612978219986,
0.9014782905578613,
0.6377961039543152,
-0.519598126411438,
0.1493712067604065,
0.39543434977531433,
0.281971275806427,
0.0680553987622261,
0.4524713158607483,
0.1130891889333725,
-0.22911880910396576,
-0.13343288004398346,
0.0466950424015522,
-0.3140292465686798,
-0.024102747440338135,
-0.5344899892807007,
0.23704414069652557,
0.5861003994941711,
-0.6754767298698425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19315v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19315v2
|
Matryoshka Query Transformer for Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-05-29T17:39:42 | 2024-06-07T03:39:04 |
Wenbo Hu, Zi-Yi Dou, Liunian Harold Li, Amita Kamath, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) typically encode an image into a fixed
number of visual tokens (e.g., 576) and process these tokens with a language
model. Despite their strong performance, LVLMs face challenges in adapting to
varying computational constraints. This raises the question: can we achieve
flexibility in the number of visual tokens to suit different tasks and
computational resources? We answer this with an emphatic yes. Inspired by
Matryoshka Representation Learning, we introduce the Matryoshka Query
Transformer (MQT), capable of encoding an image into m visual tokens during
inference, where m can be any number up to a predefined maximum. This is
achieved by employing a query transformer with M latent query tokens to
compress the visual embeddings. During each training step, we randomly select m
<= M latent query tokens and train the model using only these first m tokens,
discarding the rest. Combining MQT with LLaVA, we train a single model once,
and flexibly and drastically reduce the number of inference-time visual tokens
while maintaining similar or better performance compared to training
independent models for each number of tokens. Our model, MQT-LLAVA, matches
LLaVA-1.5 performance across 11 benchmarks using a maximum of 256 tokens
instead of LLaVA's fixed 576. Reducing to 16 tokens (8x less TFLOPs) only
sacrifices the performance by 2.4 points on MMBench. On certain tasks such as
ScienceQA and MMMU, we can even go down to only 2 visual tokens with
performance drops of just 3% and 6% each. Our exploration of the trade-off
between the accuracy and computational cost brought about by the number of
visual tokens facilitates future research to achieve the best of both worlds.
|
[
-0.32015255093574524,
-0.33956149220466614,
0.4793194830417633,
0.07952892780303955,
-0.5625268816947937,
0.018370674923062325,
-0.08423292636871338,
-0.3995705544948578,
0.2690567672252655,
0.747855007648468,
-0.5633150339126587,
-0.22489085793495178,
-0.5449339151382446,
-0.024320418015122414,
-0.3482312560081482,
0.4462030529975891,
0.06956746429204941,
0.22968867421150208,
-0.2021181881427765,
-0.37249740958213806,
-0.5250391364097595,
-0.434291809797287,
-0.42273321747779846,
-0.12811017036437988,
0.5596730709075928,
0.2479635775089264,
0.6828885078430176,
0.19897882640361786,
0.6472757458686829,
0.28649216890335083,
0.08334521949291229,
0.38368064165115356,
-0.4201085865497589,
0.24352073669433594,
0.03381672501564026,
-0.9385788440704346,
-0.09176839143037796,
-0.15157568454742432,
0.7805167436599731,
0.5316991806030273,
-0.3519749641418457,
0.36876386404037476,
-0.19027261435985565,
0.8194172978401184,
-0.7499585747718811,
0.21428632736206055,
-0.9364162683486938,
0.31066256761550903,
-0.20200832188129425,
0.1892779916524887,
-0.6246401071548462,
0.13165342807769775,
-0.270730197429657,
-0.7444194555282593,
0.007163731846958399,
0.3344809412956238,
0.7667573690414429,
0.5224880576133728,
-0.4317123591899872,
0.5197862982749939,
-0.4962587058544159,
0.8819255828857422,
-0.529653012752533,
0.5602895617485046,
0.2731796205043793,
0.7675997018814087,
-0.09045712649822235,
-0.8963021039962769,
-0.5794815421104431,
-0.13147391378879547,
-0.0723835676908493,
0.18889808654785156,
-0.29165586829185486,
0.04488852992653847,
0.5388503074645996,
0.12241819500923157,
-0.5124989748001099,
0.08733024448156357,
-0.5515619516372681,
-0.30861639976501465,
0.4267176389694214,
0.4132590889930725,
0.008853667415678501,
-0.2237619161605835,
-0.2569608688354492,
-0.30992358922958374,
-0.6043438911437988,
0.11071998625993729,
-0.09611757844686508,
0.11433638632297516,
0.4523322582244873,
0.9154996871948242,
-0.43785905838012695,
0.7325679063796997,
0.0509662963449955,
-0.21608422696590424,
0.16015544533729553,
-0.12707382440567017,
-0.35041555762290955,
-0.12461180239915848,
0.7174516916275024,
0.35575515031814575,
0.03430547937750816,
0.11339771002531052,
-0.2510581612586975,
0.248176708817482,
0.3746277689933777,
-1.014892816543579,
-0.1086035892367363,
-0.01610773615539074,
-0.6086204051971436,
-0.3697105050086975,
-0.15130367875099182,
-0.5922677516937256,
-0.3707221746444702,
-0.1805497407913208,
0.4171600639820099,
-0.3336525857448578,
-0.08447366207838058,
0.12235609441995621,
-0.126266747713089,
0.399077832698822,
0.5703461170196533,
-0.988949716091156,
0.29511797428131104,
0.4945661425590515,
0.827666163444519,
-0.34951841831207275,
-0.24120713770389557,
-0.7377145886421204,
-0.013193008489906788,
-0.493667334318161,
0.4130096137523651,
-0.844501256942749,
-0.24936963617801666,
-0.14221902191638947,
0.12640894949436188,
-0.1759653389453888,
-0.5115153789520264,
0.1622997671365738,
-0.6352019309997559,
-0.09683240950107574,
-0.11296765506267548,
-0.4162662923336029,
0.04622067138552666,
0.27082306146621704,
-0.8680108189582825,
1.2024071216583252,
0.07069217413663864,
-0.6619818210601807,
0.45087799429893494,
-0.429911345243454,
-0.1518622785806656,
0.13638877868652344,
-0.5067213773727417,
-0.3626173734664917,
0.462924987077713,
0.4718923568725586,
0.3545978367328644,
-0.4298493564128876,
0.17032165825366974,
-0.17610138654708862,
-0.47983428835868835,
0.29280945658683777,
-0.5119702816009521,
0.6397299766540527,
0.10845694690942764,
-0.19699831306934357,
0.24544459581375122,
-0.9479360580444336,
-0.002900034189224243,
0.260879248380661,
-0.4922920763492584,
-0.12678684294223785,
-0.16220927238464355,
-0.010968984104692936,
0.20313282310962677,
-0.005124789196997881,
-0.6090262532234192,
0.3977249264717102,
-0.32430943846702576,
0.6749521493911743,
0.7163346409797668,
-0.3425973355770111,
0.451983779668808,
-0.05648287385702133,
0.6664738655090332,
-0.0701456144452095,
0.34945550560951233,
-0.24475587904453278,
-0.773108184337616,
-0.9583303332328796,
-0.326385498046875,
0.22148476541042328,
0.4046300947666168,
-1.111223816871643,
-0.023572109639644623,
-0.3673708438873291,
-0.42808234691619873,
-0.7181926965713501,
-0.1260301172733307,
0.12224601209163666,
0.40228933095932007,
0.22832852602005005,
-0.28286662697792053,
-0.4229610860347748,
-1.0008704662322998,
-0.07826218754053116,
-0.15841972827911377,
-0.14667406678199768,
0.3453330397605896,
0.623932957649231,
0.2032349407672882,
0.7843457460403442,
-0.5672800540924072,
-0.10463235527276993,
0.006057583726942539,
-0.08308571577072144,
0.31339627504348755,
0.390608012676239,
0.5281406044960022,
-1.0366694927215576,
-0.4464702010154724,
0.0669717937707901,
-0.5128264427185059,
0.24434690177440643,
-0.039146240800619125,
-0.2076759934425354,
0.33471205830574036,
0.5517823100090027,
-0.9947945475578308,
0.7176545858383179,
0.5565854907035828,
-0.2247479259967804,
0.7337024807929993,
0.062051933258771896,
0.13869710266590118,
-1.0034066438674927,
-0.040667541325092316,
-0.4655657112598419,
-0.31111419200897217,
-0.4695081412792206,
0.1756075769662857,
0.2977460026741028,
-0.4366803467273712,
-0.6486924886703491,
0.5241262316703796,
-0.2972446084022522,
-0.12983453273773193,
-0.016960637643933296,
-0.12747135758399963,
0.2318759709596634,
0.592850923538208,
-0.17723803222179413,
0.9193035364151001,
0.5614230036735535,
-0.22527457773685455,
0.5083621740341187,
0.340122789144516,
-0.5858006477355957,
0.5386747121810913,
-0.559998631477356,
0.011439641006290913,
-0.05352845788002014,
0.3430214822292328,
-1.0985373258590698,
-0.26667341589927673,
0.27922961115837097,
-0.2581647038459778,
0.27449777722358704,
-0.2530601918697357,
-0.6169764995574951,
-0.38797181844711304,
-0.3420465886592865,
0.48572418093681335,
0.6736536026000977,
-0.8101208209991455,
1.015696406364441,
0.04647156596183777,
0.25541505217552185,
-0.8696622848510742,
-0.9720536470413208,
0.2439904808998108,
-0.13104702532291412,
-0.8740523457527161,
0.617348313331604,
0.060019318014383316,
0.0974399521946907,
0.020265784114599228,
-0.24695900082588196,
0.12203921377658844,
-0.21281103789806366,
0.3903175890445709,
0.3788366913795471,
-0.37452414631843567,
0.44605401158332825,
-0.16407082974910736,
-0.10735737532377243,
-0.20566654205322266,
-0.6324322819709778,
0.5306968688964844,
-0.2778869569301605,
-0.7484679222106934,
-0.2334991842508316,
0.2520747780799866,
0.8506828546524048,
-0.6328588128089905,
0.9407012462615967,
0.8024477958679199,
-0.2833959758281708,
0.02889970876276493,
-0.7412896156311035,
-0.16236485540866852,
-0.5070391893386841,
0.4926377236843109,
-0.7679793238639832,
-1.0160894393920898,
0.5683804154396057,
-0.007870116271078587,
-0.19110465049743652,
0.47042131423950195,
0.41595345735549927,
0.10300751030445099,
1.1522002220153809,
0.6202356219291687,
0.1350509226322174,
0.7015190124511719,
-0.17439424991607666,
0.1315867006778717,
-0.8751332759857178,
-0.29359832406044006,
-0.15017756819725037,
-0.31630682945251465,
-0.6236495971679688,
-0.7824652194976807,
0.37242943048477173,
-0.17869701981544495,
-0.22561924159526825,
-0.058961980044841766,
-0.6264014840126038,
0.6420639157295227,
0.6338050365447998,
0.297015517950058,
0.05871320143342018,
0.27536267042160034,
-0.1845746785402298,
-0.16852568089962006,
-0.8074994683265686,
-0.12390052527189255,
0.9985325932502747,
0.03005117177963257,
0.9391040205955505,
0.13052664697170258,
0.5029738545417786,
-0.17544913291931152,
-0.04973263293504715,
-0.8962239623069763,
0.7342069745063782,
-0.3978760540485382,
-0.5240237712860107,
-0.4702151417732239,
-0.28135669231414795,
-0.9112953543663025,
0.7179738879203796,
-0.42521971464157104,
-0.8218079209327698,
0.33017057180404663,
0.012213257141411304,
-0.06518437713384628,
0.5537038445472717,
-0.5267294645309448,
0.836911141872406,
-0.2556169629096985,
-0.5165941119194031,
-0.3586004674434662,
-0.6781550049781799,
0.3446274697780609,
-0.13399375975131989,
-0.14881247282028198,
-0.28718405961990356,
-0.23576761782169342,
0.6277397274971008,
-0.4210832118988037,
1.0371601581573486,
-0.15885698795318604,
0.44832637906074524,
0.19945122301578522,
0.117866151034832,
0.605624794960022,
-0.15880340337753296,
-0.16258586943149567,
-0.02437134087085724,
0.08966697752475739,
-0.6470324397087097,
-0.7746277451515198,
0.39340850710868835,
-0.591659426689148,
-0.8058204650878906,
-0.27779528498649597,
-0.48093611001968384,
-0.051233019679784775,
0.34116798639297485,
0.10120020806789398,
0.3535253405570984,
-0.02212733030319214,
0.46613994240760803,
0.42981380224227905,
-0.2745542526245117,
0.3146950602531433,
0.20180387794971466,
-0.4946555495262146,
-0.28120338916778564,
0.8757843375205994,
0.21553446352481842,
0.38455337285995483,
0.5013154745101929,
0.29884785413742065,
-0.08729282021522522,
-0.652625560760498,
-0.4857724905014038,
0.14505288004875183,
-1.075232744216919,
-0.38434848189353943,
-0.40565675497055054,
-0.1619807332754135,
0.00038778752787038684,
0.07335370033979416,
-0.5511261224746704,
-0.8527550101280212,
-0.21288356184959412,
0.033229049295186996,
0.414175420999527,
0.4537036418914795,
0.2585231363773346,
0.33039623498916626,
-0.6493367552757263,
0.1205584704875946,
0.6074643135070801,
0.4690609872341156,
0.007139766588807106,
-0.5466082692146301,
-0.07152118533849716,
-0.30503299832344055,
-0.0473150834441185,
-0.6611096262931824,
0.40182796120643616,
0.2609263062477112,
0.5499647855758667,
0.1353898048400879,
-0.0024664856027811766,
0.746822714805603,
-0.6457562446594238,
0.9683524966239929,
0.4415854513645172,
-0.7055246829986572,
0.4881036579608917,
-0.10182018578052521,
0.44908854365348816,
0.43519529700279236,
0.13728153705596924,
-0.4318453073501587,
-0.10804706811904907,
-0.35122010111808777,
-0.7769362330436707,
0.6933680176734924,
0.24618905782699585,
0.1511145532131195,
0.19413676857948303,
0.4038712978363037,
0.08235107362270355,
0.19198213517665863,
-0.5344952344894409,
-0.03498000279068947,
-0.44383448362350464,
-0.12676526606082916,
0.19804872572422028,
-0.25216302275657654,
-0.13474132120609283,
-0.418648362159729,
0.41627588868141174,
-0.44377604126930237,
0.29859891533851624,
-0.020869746804237366,
-0.24399027228355408,
0.24366675317287445,
0.026635119691491127,
0.4617882966995239,
0.7188760638237,
-0.1912834495306015,
0.38233619928359985,
0.40222468972206116,
-0.5487284660339355,
0.04615475982427597,
-0.027869921177625656,
0.05833995342254639,
-0.05473098158836365,
0.18372271955013275,
1.1359829902648926,
0.0748620480298996,
-0.7430899143218994,
0.4750584065914154,
-0.3843047022819519,
-0.2870349884033203,
-0.053778793662786484,
0.05751408636569977,
0.06948313117027283,
0.4665985405445099,
0.3629997968673706,
0.20272813737392426,
-0.003175226738676429,
-0.25829610228538513,
0.11644349992275238,
0.47327491641044617,
-0.19726219773292542,
-0.020466849207878113,
0.702364981174469,
-0.026054782792925835,
-0.14212578535079956,
0.8673252463340759,
0.09065735340118408,
-0.46845975518226624,
0.6751677989959717,
0.47520291805267334,
0.5677920579910278,
-0.14583155512809753,
0.17388026416301727,
0.2804681956768036,
0.3102850019931793,
-0.04974009096622467,
0.057633474469184875,
-0.056406326591968536,
-0.6842557191848755,
-0.5465595126152039,
-0.81548672914505,
-0.33673807978630066,
-0.12120570242404938,
-0.5042678713798523,
0.2832317352294922,
-0.36927875876426697,
-0.19296148419380188,
0.30901026725769043,
-0.2473495602607727,
-0.8299628496170044,
-0.031209906563162804,
0.23163844645023346,
0.8424223065376282,
-0.6013425588607788,
0.9715708494186401,
0.6261645555496216,
-0.46887508034706116,
-0.6005609035491943,
-0.4423200488090515,
-0.1895292103290558,
-1.2977312803268433,
0.7756408452987671,
0.30438193678855896,
-0.21887904405593872,
-0.31426385045051575,
-0.7290734052658081,
-1.0006155967712402,
1.344342827796936,
0.5709415078163147,
-0.7004783153533936,
0.11178023368120193,
0.2813071012496948,
0.36920732259750366,
-0.5826118588447571,
0.06314653903245926,
0.4830430746078491,
0.3256773352622986,
0.4823988080024719,
-0.8939405679702759,
0.2346387356519699,
-0.23810364305973053,
0.28010693192481995,
0.2701045572757721,
-0.8531087040901184,
0.7754706740379333,
-0.12913285195827484,
-0.0908074826002121,
0.11192067712545395,
0.3176521062850952,
0.153679758310318,
0.04096592962741852,
0.5523801445960999,
0.3767981231212616,
0.9608137011528015,
-0.07734861224889755,
1.1435632705688477,
-0.12943311035633087,
0.15178392827510834,
0.7876134514808655,
0.04049013927578926,
1.083537220954895,
0.8294822573661804,
-0.4180389642715454,
0.15889891982078552,
0.6610584259033203,
-0.3050075173377991,
0.5173345804214478,
0.09730570018291473,
-0.12871749699115753,
-0.5741225481033325,
-0.14940936863422394,
-0.12751351296901703,
0.525179386138916,
0.3777551054954529,
-0.209764301776886,
0.16084939241409302,
0.19879165291786194,
-0.34782111644744873,
-0.38820046186447144,
-0.2290397435426712,
0.4624357521533966,
0.11003854870796204,
-0.6157780289649963,
0.8054084777832031,
-0.16287747025489807,
0.49896299839019775,
-0.5352369546890259,
-0.10938826203346252,
-0.23602977395057678,
0.010167892090976238,
-0.23551560938358307,
-0.7453774809837341,
0.1715555042028427,
-0.3740617036819458,
-0.09303689002990723,
0.021513350307941437,
0.9719294309616089,
-0.18719877302646637,
-0.8263834714889526,
0.013896170072257519,
0.3418210744857788,
0.14143705368041992,
-0.19274140894412994,
-0.6581094861030579,
0.25050944089889526,
0.10284677892923355,
-0.3685653805732727,
0.46928152441978455,
0.4687119424343109,
-0.2133740484714508,
0.7445184588432312,
0.6921901106834412,
-0.18496035039424896,
0.3979293406009674,
0.3092920184135437,
1.1628189086914062,
-0.6965981721878052,
-0.21790896356105804,
-0.7466151714324951,
0.5599840879440308,
-0.07974457740783691,
-0.03429169952869415,
0.3239215314388275,
0.28647661209106445,
0.476877361536026,
-0.09009655565023422,
0.5483326315879822,
0.19180485606193542,
-0.21221652626991272,
-0.7554174065589905,
0.42685988545417786,
-0.860490083694458,
0.2751517593860626,
0.17803514003753662,
-0.945667564868927,
-0.5959984064102173,
0.6844622492790222,
-0.15522822737693787,
-0.22212904691696167,
0.5849415063858032,
0.7345166802406311,
-0.18757058680057526,
-0.0654616430401802,
0.6607924699783325,
0.07620549201965332,
0.5452380776405334,
0.511202335357666,
1.020796537399292,
-0.3216313123703003,
0.9091768264770508,
-0.08738832175731659,
-0.06779812276363373,
-0.3975377082824707,
-0.7823644280433655,
-0.9543023109436035,
-0.5040477514266968,
-0.16061224043369293,
-0.1159893348813057,
-0.0011763632064685225,
0.6370775103569031,
0.8859252333641052,
-0.4788627624511719,
0.03661256283521652,
0.09236318618059158,
0.006190369836986065,
-0.14484821259975433,
-0.14144901931285858,
0.4687950909137726,
-0.3673241138458252,
-0.4689069092273712,
0.20933210849761963,
0.3765811026096344,
0.0026771239936351776,
-0.30253860354423523,
0.0007046499522402883,
0.017232615500688553,
0.004606807604432106,
0.8924729228019714,
0.025711817666888237,
-0.9770777821540833,
-0.3750869631767273,
0.27660876512527466,
0.10411274433135986,
0.3834242820739746,
0.6280094981193542,
-0.87531977891922,
0.7912206053733826,
0.4335481524467468,
0.8396600484848022,
1.4419605731964111,
-0.3606005907058716,
0.3381292521953583,
-0.8352744579315186,
0.4115912914276123,
0.19783061742782593,
0.47054392099380493,
0.33964553475379944,
-0.13397599756717682,
0.6660420894622803,
0.07481023669242859,
-0.4296503961086273,
-0.8313687443733215,
0.38562893867492676,
-1.1209427118301392,
-0.3484634459018707,
0.8553584218025208,
0.1277589052915573,
-0.4811229109764099,
0.37684327363967896,
-0.4176308214664459,
-0.03372026979923248,
-0.36658936738967896,
0.47031649947166443,
0.6956570744514465,
-0.4469485580921173,
-0.4684438705444336,
-0.8419488072395325,
0.2716032564640045,
0.6229383945465088,
-0.357446551322937,
-0.045839421451091766,
0.2964555025100708,
0.15024667978286743,
0.22674447298049927,
0.5019830465316772,
-0.09608031064271927,
0.23435910046100616,
0.32708799839019775,
-0.07383417338132858,
-0.05502089112997055,
-0.2344081997871399,
-0.16756296157836914,
0.11555827409029007,
0.24444763362407684,
-0.46991392970085144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19313v1
|
Language Models Trained to do Arithmetic Predict Human Risky and Intertemporal Choice
| 2024-05-29T17:37:14 | 2024-05-29T17:37:14 |
Jian-Qiao Zhu, Haijiang Yan, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC
|
The observed similarities in the behavior of humans and Large Language Models
(LLMs) have prompted researchers to consider the potential of using LLMs as
models of human cognition. However, several significant challenges must be
addressed before LLMs can be legitimately regarded as cognitive models. For
instance, LLMs are trained on far more data than humans typically encounter,
and may have been directly trained on human data in specific cognitive tasks or
aligned with human preferences. Consequently, the origins of these behavioral
similarities are not well understood. In this paper, we propose a novel way to
enhance the utility of LLMs as cognitive models. This approach involves (i)
leveraging computationally equivalent tasks that both an LLM and a rational
agent need to master for solving a cognitive problem and (ii) examining the
specific task distributions required for an LLM to exhibit human-like
behaviors. We apply this approach to decision-making -- specifically risky and
intertemporal choice -- where the key computationally equivalent task is the
arithmetic of expected value calculations. We show that an LLM pretrained on an
ecologically valid arithmetic dataset, which we call Arithmetic-GPT, predicts
human behavior better than many traditional cognitive models. Pretraining LLMs
on ecologically valid arithmetic datasets is sufficient to produce a strong
correspondence between these models and human decision-making. Our results also
suggest that LLMs used as cognitive models should be carefully investigated via
ablation studies of the pretraining data.
|
[
-0.3984256684780121,
-0.8201919794082642,
0.7176375389099121,
0.05952144041657448,
-0.10855913907289505,
0.06240690127015114,
-0.45398712158203125,
-0.5371937155723572,
0.014996347948908806,
0.623565673828125,
-0.6191239953041077,
-0.20871473848819733,
-0.5461453199386597,
-0.08125858753919601,
-0.0878555178642273,
0.649232029914856,
0.21511568129062653,
0.3018050789833069,
-0.46367084980010986,
0.05716332420706749,
-0.23697614669799805,
-0.8715622425079346,
-0.8979162573814392,
-0.6318948268890381,
0.41070449352264404,
0.08538636565208435,
0.9159972667694092,
0.38436803221702576,
0.49847379326820374,
0.4261826276779175,
0.2843243181705475,
-0.1264154613018036,
-0.4465644359588623,
-0.2890683114528656,
-0.18179701268672943,
-0.7127113342285156,
-0.33111095428466797,
0.34105491638183594,
0.2581787705421448,
0.8568917512893677,
-0.35751843452453613,
0.08621887862682343,
-0.07279381155967712,
0.731476366519928,
-0.46912992000579834,
0.39419999718666077,
-0.79827880859375,
-0.07767965644598007,
-0.11665146052837372,
-0.32310110330581665,
-0.42152461409568787,
-0.37275993824005127,
0.0012794265057891607,
-0.6749497652053833,
-0.08034098148345947,
0.11262337118387222,
0.3431906998157501,
0.44626227021217346,
-0.44779741764068604,
-0.35802724957466125,
-0.7393476963043213,
0.7600113749504089,
-0.6787458062171936,
0.2389877885580063,
0.6819232702255249,
0.07618694007396698,
-0.2569485008716583,
-0.31466975808143616,
-0.7059083580970764,
-0.4651477038860321,
-0.12769116461277008,
-0.06666810810565948,
-0.09636370837688446,
0.3454187214374542,
0.36518192291259766,
0.07803548872470856,
-0.2844391465187073,
0.2519747018814087,
-0.38116803765296936,
-0.19240890443325043,
0.6496939063072205,
0.5114208459854126,
0.47798073291778564,
0.06720167398452759,
-0.21168503165245056,
-0.15606197714805603,
-0.8459555506706238,
0.34857696294784546,
0.5801001787185669,
0.24363762140274048,
0.10243061184883118,
0.7808587551116943,
-0.22178345918655396,
0.6270923614501953,
-0.09543191641569138,
0.028180832043290138,
0.027755621820688248,
0.012082795612514019,
-0.10605516284704208,
0.08426998555660248,
0.5083067417144775,
0.3457035422325134,
0.7109094262123108,
0.09315060079097748,
-0.19779974222183228,
0.6163812875747681,
0.4560070335865021,
-0.6851527690887451,
-0.23945441842079163,
0.03790465369820595,
-0.1286173313856125,
-0.577975332736969,
-0.2716478407382965,
-0.36938774585723877,
-0.04276174306869507,
-0.7679470181465149,
0.5193571448326111,
-0.4873706102371216,
-0.1869814246892929,
0.3861233592033386,
0.24469177424907684,
-0.06906267255544662,
0.2869083285331726,
-1.0782417058944702,
0.4498206079006195,
0.9307679533958435,
0.6165751814842224,
-0.08184371143579483,
-0.33113667368888855,
-0.28020957112312317,
-0.023621436208486557,
-0.5610815286636353,
0.7475631833076477,
-0.7616629004478455,
-0.4021829664707184,
-0.25418809056282043,
-0.31709182262420654,
-0.005926106590777636,
-0.45234283804893494,
0.453389436006546,
-0.7587675452232361,
0.05668080598115921,
-0.26943713426589966,
-0.5340796113014221,
-0.4474797248840332,
0.45794132351875305,
-0.7021806240081787,
0.8412470817565918,
0.06844762712717056,
-0.7229296565055847,
0.2886412441730499,
-0.7513797879219055,
-0.28908082842826843,
0.06152822822332382,
-0.3021697402000427,
-0.3467576503753662,
0.11263411492109299,
0.06619604676961899,
0.29043248295783997,
-0.3382989764213562,
0.20610181987285614,
-0.6744871139526367,
-0.12441189587116241,
0.7073599100112915,
-0.6390208005905151,
1.0686969757080078,
0.12105672806501389,
-0.06851840019226074,
-0.0015411467757076025,
-0.3672599792480469,
0.1864021122455597,
0.1210719496011734,
-0.41938266158103943,
-0.6254597306251526,
0.22407807409763336,
-0.5781868100166321,
0.41133007407188416,
0.27360808849334717,
-0.4717836380004883,
-0.014501219615340233,
-0.38195911049842834,
0.48504653573036194,
1.0159633159637451,
-0.05463332310318947,
0.4123684763908386,
-0.7780993580818176,
0.5029194951057434,
-0.28842514753341675,
0.07652914524078369,
0.12092775106430054,
-0.253172904253006,
-0.7074407339096069,
-0.2812199592590332,
-0.04063737764954567,
0.657432496547699,
-0.7901174426078796,
0.27926167845726013,
-0.3549613356590271,
-0.3290579617023468,
-0.2268332690000534,
-0.13340942561626434,
0.23344017565250397,
0.48820602893829346,
0.14285166561603546,
-0.27805817127227783,
-0.3691694140434265,
-0.5089960098266602,
-0.37359219789505005,
-0.4255320727825165,
-0.1092919185757637,
0.46840113401412964,
0.24931809306144714,
-0.08652603626251221,
0.8882195353507996,
-0.5055805444717407,
0.08674133569002151,
0.1430727243423462,
0.25296977162361145,
0.18008935451507568,
0.40102308988571167,
0.28917887806892395,
-0.7951578497886658,
-0.21187622845172882,
-0.18377657234668732,
-0.688992440700531,
-0.02657376416027546,
-0.08884762972593307,
-0.1494455486536026,
0.13642393052577972,
0.5339318513870239,
-0.748759388923645,
0.2924148440361023,
0.48145434260368347,
-0.2854920029640198,
0.5756335854530334,
-0.2982412576675415,
0.15498629212379456,
-0.5581507682800293,
-0.19471091032028198,
-0.07760892063379288,
-0.11514605581760406,
-0.6353582739830017,
-0.06109928339719772,
-0.01954762451350689,
0.011795789934694767,
-0.49892929196357727,
0.4756660461425781,
-0.35023266077041626,
-0.27047720551490784,
-0.16622622311115265,
-0.2570033371448517,
-0.31845206022262573,
0.6569344997406006,
0.19545906782150269,
0.8355913758277893,
0.37884601950645447,
-0.5315847992897034,
0.16880300641059875,
-0.002308543771505356,
-0.44265562295913696,
0.5190336108207703,
-0.45627090334892273,
0.2283979207277298,
-0.3429739475250244,
0.1461368203163147,
-0.9222519397735596,
-0.002202922711148858,
0.009144711308181286,
-0.5056142807006836,
0.051721155643463135,
-0.006699211895465851,
-0.34139811992645264,
-0.21044018864631653,
-0.26965516805648804,
0.6091927289962769,
0.6238335967063904,
-0.31227290630340576,
0.71009361743927,
0.49127042293548584,
-0.6293578147888184,
-0.3730250597000122,
-0.5887988209724426,
-0.0614667646586895,
-0.46764200925827026,
-0.5672586560249329,
0.17035047709941864,
-0.30855032801628113,
-0.620703399181366,
-0.0033795200288295746,
0.08521997183561325,
0.13520662486553192,
0.1758975088596344,
0.4038688540458679,
0.9802294373512268,
-0.023686449974775314,
0.14345835149288177,
-0.24914643168449402,
-0.39104798436164856,
0.43666940927505493,
-0.47406768798828125,
0.5046660900115967,
-0.1304652988910675,
-0.5780650973320007,
0.16210734844207764,
0.025633851066231728,
0.3798222541809082,
-0.21258337795734406,
0.448914110660553,
0.2219059318304062,
-0.49128201603889465,
0.05310031399130821,
-0.5541067719459534,
-0.2999429702758789,
-0.5440982580184937,
0.32176119089126587,
-0.1631755381822586,
-0.8417945504188538,
0.022719455882906914,
-0.2610679864883423,
0.09048271924257278,
0.1583297997713089,
0.7347906827926636,
-0.28958380222320557,
1.0473774671554565,
0.47040992975234985,
0.06685781478881836,
0.6285214424133301,
-0.19110310077667236,
-0.0586252436041832,
-0.7940089702606201,
-0.08689618110656738,
-0.2568412721157074,
-0.1694483458995819,
-0.5479201078414917,
-0.7511903643608093,
0.5978905558586121,
-0.17787091434001923,
-0.7198168635368347,
-0.12372174113988876,
-0.21497803926467896,
0.7795592546463013,
0.3374027907848358,
0.28230226039886475,
0.27605506777763367,
0.12015772610902786,
-0.1877356469631195,
-0.07058592885732651,
-0.43243682384490967,
-0.666804313659668,
1.3032307624816895,
-0.0802597850561142,
0.7637315392494202,
0.03547774255275726,
0.4585309624671936,
0.3229610025882721,
0.7455180287361145,
-0.6516739130020142,
0.7227368354797363,
-0.27915236353874207,
-0.7316856980323792,
-0.6506447196006775,
-0.50444495677948,
-1.08512544631958,
0.4388628602027893,
-0.4940935969352722,
-0.8085899353027344,
-0.07873795926570892,
0.13530749082565308,
-0.44738927483558655,
0.2422676980495453,
-0.5195314288139343,
0.5502604842185974,
-0.7192579507827759,
-0.23385748267173767,
-0.7861698865890503,
-0.5287741422653198,
0.4800983965396881,
-0.2367589920759201,
0.5083420276641846,
-0.4629618525505066,
-0.3422338664531708,
0.5375604629516602,
-0.32734736800193787,
0.9672828316688538,
0.0106055224314332,
0.08951243758201599,
0.27741754055023193,
0.18410584330558777,
0.7355480790138245,
-0.013050752691924572,
-0.35373619198799133,
0.32212701439857483,
-0.19480182230472565,
-0.386811763048172,
-0.5099602937698364,
0.6613473892211914,
-0.9788821935653687,
-0.7414864301681519,
-0.5553604960441589,
-0.5488772988319397,
-0.3974732458591461,
0.18700934946537018,
0.06260139495134354,
0.35009586811065674,
-0.38939860463142395,
-0.11783070862293243,
0.5956007242202759,
-0.10145695507526398,
0.3505516052246094,
0.7696767449378967,
-0.24471858143806458,
-0.3923574388027191,
0.8206687569618225,
0.07719673961400986,
0.5650326013565063,
0.5240454077720642,
0.23376648128032684,
-0.44492107629776,
-0.5760306119918823,
-0.07297216355800629,
0.11018852144479752,
-0.662505030632019,
-0.035947758704423904,
-0.6352311372756958,
-0.11125727742910385,
0.11683753877878189,
-0.3612452745437622,
-0.08529344201087952,
-0.40560227632522583,
-0.29136088490486145,
-0.32753807306289673,
0.3057299852371216,
0.6242018342018127,
-0.25322309136390686,
0.11049669235944748,
-0.6738157868385315,
0.382683128118515,
0.6745038628578186,
0.16484692692756653,
0.11265616863965988,
-0.262665331363678,
-0.047917697578668594,
0.5232115387916565,
-0.07889251410961151,
-0.47807154059410095,
0.5213784575462341,
0.025726012885570526,
0.5445336699485779,
0.20876522362232208,
0.08790834993124008,
0.5244883298873901,
-0.49501222372055054,
0.3707883358001709,
0.20992213487625122,
-0.7948585152626038,
0.06400720030069351,
-0.4189906418323517,
-0.12820099294185638,
0.486461341381073,
0.623745858669281,
-0.4519091844558716,
-0.01424643024802208,
-0.6221629977226257,
-0.6168188452720642,
0.7481591701507568,
0.20646008849143982,
0.13631340861320496,
-0.04343129321932793,
0.25623393058776855,
0.05574767664074898,
0.11887034773826599,
-0.6347782611846924,
0.12481000274419785,
0.015796950086951256,
-0.09558737277984619,
-0.4988114535808563,
0.07695666700601578,
-0.10953167825937271,
-0.13983824849128723,
0.5712159276008606,
-0.1285851150751114,
0.09363986551761627,
-0.08544198423624039,
-0.1854039430618286,
-0.35500022768974304,
0.16001273691654205,
0.26104551553726196,
0.31809669733047485,
-0.11793819814920425,
0.3003405034542084,
0.48253124952316284,
-0.39188772439956665,
0.4381101131439209,
-0.0037904963828623295,
0.0326412208378315,
-0.6628021001815796,
0.3046345114707947,
0.6074281334877014,
0.38808539509773254,
-0.8860023617744446,
0.34645313024520874,
-0.11182884126901627,
0.020772339776158333,
-0.6020084619522095,
0.26577314734458923,
0.45484495162963867,
0.21283702552318573,
0.06631521880626678,
0.33355793356895447,
0.1114775612950325,
-0.7269558906555176,
0.049569837749004364,
0.6353573203086853,
-0.19979976117610931,
-0.3707302510738373,
0.4587556719779968,
0.1987169235944748,
-0.5309926271438599,
0.9199241995811462,
-0.220868781208992,
-0.5412819981575012,
0.7380058169364929,
0.4030000567436218,
0.7435727119445801,
-0.10361350327730179,
0.042876940220594406,
0.2307083010673523,
0.29649868607521057,
-0.13147331774234772,
0.25177109241485596,
0.04877103865146637,
-1.048340082168579,
-0.5260698199272156,
-0.6018567681312561,
-0.4808104932308197,
-0.15078499913215637,
-0.479052871465683,
0.2801680862903595,
-0.35507234930992126,
-0.29449132084846497,
0.026048168540000916,
0.07247883826494217,
-0.7888592481613159,
0.1862570345401764,
0.4630160629749298,
0.5576798915863037,
-0.8130368590354919,
0.9026663303375244,
0.6193902492523193,
-0.15205024182796478,
-0.7713390588760376,
-0.15748538076877594,
0.018781084567308426,
-1.2624163627624512,
0.5735342502593994,
0.10757530480623245,
-0.17938768863677979,
0.11549527198076248,
-0.3652588427066803,
-0.9523606300354004,
1.1611204147338867,
0.570511519908905,
-0.6622823476791382,
-0.012990470044314861,
0.4392552971839905,
0.52472984790802,
-0.46113288402557373,
0.25219839811325073,
0.6217019557952881,
0.45341742038726807,
0.17785075306892395,
-0.5928733348846436,
0.09460614621639252,
-0.1703127920627594,
-0.027922382578253746,
0.49415022134780884,
-0.6252706050872803,
1.19273841381073,
-0.6860815286636353,
-0.21270467340946198,
-0.1758774071931839,
0.34889915585517883,
0.5255019068717957,
0.3046707808971405,
0.8955487608909607,
0.6156266331672668,
0.766315221786499,
0.11216599494218826,
0.9902023077011108,
-0.3803350031375885,
0.1783847063779831,
0.939832866191864,
-0.3223840594291687,
0.9368054270744324,
0.2643640637397766,
-0.6057655811309814,
0.3588998019695282,
0.6766038537025452,
0.5083149075508118,
0.3977556526660919,
0.29923030734062195,
-0.5176593661308289,
-0.5838578343391418,
0.1429467499256134,
0.047018490731716156,
0.30835384130477905,
0.8922906517982483,
0.12624381482601166,
0.025731569156050682,
-0.19199775159358978,
-0.0958186611533165,
0.022305035963654518,
-0.3606164753437042,
0.9216841459274292,
0.17836466431617737,
-0.8531811833381653,
0.3239869773387909,
-0.20850419998168945,
0.6898971796035767,
-0.6286284923553467,
0.0199781134724617,
0.13819532096385956,
0.04057174175977707,
-0.10592460632324219,
-0.8247090578079224,
0.2721354365348816,
-0.17524217069149017,
0.11064120382070541,
-0.14621049165725708,
0.7047261595726013,
-0.41944214701652527,
-0.7230096459388733,
0.12285628169775009,
0.46992284059524536,
0.10614291578531265,
-0.19609740376472473,
-0.6227314472198486,
-0.23617538809776306,
0.07326628267765045,
-0.2195432186126709,
0.4958268105983734,
0.5002280473709106,
-0.4160989820957184,
0.8352590799331665,
1.229413390159607,
0.21519578993320465,
0.031004127115011215,
-0.2517520487308502,
0.8101817965507507,
-0.8899502158164978,
-0.7174205183982849,
-1.159766674041748,
0.23644420504570007,
0.16499367356300354,
0.11084084212779999,
0.2319873422384262,
0.36974120140075684,
0.8048367500305176,
0.03921441733837128,
0.9649022817611694,
0.21481359004974365,
0.11292823404073715,
-0.6927720904350281,
0.29891467094421387,
-0.1757650226354599,
0.4180677533149719,
0.10602941364049911,
-0.7758920788764954,
0.029248028993606567,
0.5351741313934326,
-0.6954799890518188,
0.1325267106294632,
0.6080151200294495,
0.8385453224182129,
0.07222592085599899,
0.24505040049552917,
0.34586745500564575,
0.08056085556745529,
0.3162369430065155,
0.7829729914665222,
1.0569301843643188,
0.28874149918556213,
0.3540976941585541,
-0.3792140483856201,
-0.3644847869873047,
-0.2638148069381714,
-1.005208969116211,
-0.8519665002822876,
-0.4112148880958557,
0.05753369256854057,
0.08832242339849472,
-0.009664650075137615,
1.32619309425354,
0.5769957900047302,
-0.37844318151474,
-0.3181591331958771,
-0.20346097648143768,
0.0119828125461936,
-0.0876709446310997,
-0.1279367357492447,
0.07527823746204376,
-0.2448117434978485,
-0.5794234275817871,
0.08755654841661453,
0.38094717264175415,
0.4268471300601959,
-0.3470652103424072,
-0.20442675054073334,
0.051536355167627335,
0.6069932579994202,
0.6856644153594971,
0.17518338561058044,
-0.6115794777870178,
-0.2154557704925537,
-0.13621565699577332,
-0.14583031833171844,
0.09823807328939438,
0.9983617067337036,
-0.9107367396354675,
0.2748464047908783,
0.373695433139801,
0.4754837155342102,
0.605673611164093,
0.010845753364264965,
0.577114462852478,
-0.22334612905979156,
0.28001585602760315,
0.46094363927841187,
0.4676969051361084,
0.39229169487953186,
-0.46737855672836304,
0.6254372596740723,
-0.08128059655427933,
-0.6014171242713928,
-0.456586629152298,
0.2893935739994049,
-0.745974600315094,
-0.2840084433555603,
0.9965528845787048,
-0.15902915596961975,
-0.18892614543437958,
-0.07657866925001144,
-0.34167900681495667,
0.03106014057993889,
-0.3706091046333313,
1.036004900932312,
0.7125301957130432,
-0.27889466285705566,
0.17217648029327393,
-0.5459696054458618,
0.3818642795085907,
0.39599400758743286,
-0.968928873538971,
0.27676689624786377,
0.44628578424453735,
0.36079728603363037,
-0.013602424412965775,
0.8442463874816895,
-0.0731123611330986,
0.27957579493522644,
0.07778697460889816,
0.05540573224425316,
-0.1534435749053955,
0.017992286011576653,
-0.21458855271339417,
-0.1780884712934494,
0.3492733836174011,
0.07322312146425247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19299v1
|
Expert-Guided Extinction of Toxic Tokens for Debiased Generation
| 2024-05-29T17:26:52 | 2024-05-29T17:26:52 |
Xueyao Sun, Kaize Shi, Haoran Tang, Guandong Xu, Qing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) can elicit social bias during generations,
especially when inference with toxic prompts. Controlling the sensitive
attributes in generation encounters challenges in data distribution,
generalizability, and efficiency. Specifically, fine-tuning and retrieval
demand extensive unbiased corpus, while direct prompting requires meticulously
curated instructions for correcting the output in multiple rounds of thoughts
but poses challenges on memory and inference latency. In this work, we propose
the Expert-Guided Extinction of Toxic Tokens for Debiased Generation (EXPOSED)
to eliminate the undesired harmful outputs for LLMs without the aforementioned
requirements. EXPOSED constructs a debiasing expert based on the abundant toxic
corpus to expose and elicit the potentially dangerous tokens. It then processes
the output to the LLMs and constructs a fair distribution by suppressing and
attenuating the toxic tokens. EXPOSED is evaluated on fairness benchmarks over
three LLM families. Extensive experiments demonstrate that compared with other
baselines, the proposed EXPOSED significantly reduces the potential social bias
while balancing fairness and generation performance.
|
[
-0.09984787553548813,
-0.9438625574111938,
0.4581829607486725,
0.06049726903438568,
-0.2711756229400635,
0.3157234489917755,
-0.3743159770965576,
-0.342912495136261,
-0.14843638241291046,
0.7673331499099731,
-0.4880922734737396,
-0.4672207236289978,
-0.8332723379135132,
-0.15649278461933136,
-0.2697138786315918,
0.9688608646392822,
0.3311951458454132,
-0.3192344009876251,
-0.008208917453885078,
0.07613275200128555,
-0.47474321722984314,
-0.28737759590148926,
-1.0515145063400269,
-0.21224233508110046,
0.4174146056175232,
0.6388710141181946,
0.7486889958381653,
0.7426764965057373,
0.18902181088924408,
0.28587520122528076,
-0.651980996131897,
0.10494887083768845,
-1.0237746238708496,
0.25494664907455444,
-0.4804104268550873,
-0.3916003406047821,
-0.4090353548526764,
-0.028209872543811798,
0.21853652596473694,
0.7948077917098999,
-0.0524410605430603,
0.25362876057624817,
0.3406184911727905,
0.6619219779968262,
-0.8603577017784119,
-0.05156237259507179,
-1.3000849485397339,
0.1098480075597763,
-0.06611964106559753,
-0.3474813997745514,
-0.8200502395629883,
-0.4497770369052887,
-0.13892370462417603,
-0.5433539152145386,
0.20021164417266846,
-0.1366322636604309,
0.22214296460151672,
0.48559823632240295,
-0.4657188653945923,
-0.04188616946339607,
-0.8365277647972107,
0.9065483808517456,
-0.6466304063796997,
-0.21375787258148193,
0.33007195591926575,
0.07577987015247345,
-0.4719524383544922,
-0.44218239188194275,
-0.3956044614315033,
0.07114561647176743,
0.061655085533857346,
0.1688433736562729,
-0.4023823142051697,
0.18595285713672638,
0.14130395650863647,
0.010574966669082642,
-0.1288045048713684,
0.5183262825012207,
-0.2720661461353302,
-0.3804183006286621,
0.5470327138900757,
0.10812295973300934,
0.13498374819755554,
-0.29778939485549927,
-0.37207698822021484,
0.2763703465461731,
-1.0235673189163208,
-0.5296913385391235,
0.7023417353630066,
0.21024902164936066,
0.07295091450214386,
0.3594617247581482,
-0.3149946928024292,
0.2553001344203949,
0.30266454815864563,
0.27720123529434204,
0.2965109944343567,
-0.006173774600028992,
0.013740884140133858,
0.14920316636562347,
0.488033264875412,
0.5998256206512451,
0.39733603596687317,
-0.12067299336194992,
-0.15071813762187958,
0.03357229754328728,
-0.01148153468966484,
-0.687192440032959,
-0.12133163958787918,
0.11890454590320587,
-0.5387061834335327,
-0.7894788384437561,
-0.4725548326969147,
-1.056604266166687,
-0.8844159245491028,
-0.01598656177520752,
0.3401462733745575,
-0.16855153441429138,
-0.44245344400405884,
0.11201703548431396,
-0.3596741855144501,
-0.22383207082748413,
0.11720574647188187,
-0.9042811989784241,
0.06294404715299606,
0.6455899477005005,
0.4771788418292999,
0.05432615801692009,
0.18397191166877747,
-0.8991473913192749,
0.471889853477478,
-0.13895083963871002,
0.5708733797073364,
-0.8623442053794861,
-0.46708062291145325,
0.0589197613298893,
-0.25311532616615295,
0.25538092851638794,
-0.730621874332428,
0.7424659729003906,
-0.5201475024223328,
0.13764461874961853,
-0.3665188252925873,
-0.28974735736846924,
-0.06309347599744797,
-0.19133172929286957,
-0.21350081264972687,
0.821592390537262,
0.10851862281560898,
-0.8362475633621216,
0.4762083888053894,
-0.4659280478954315,
-0.283552885055542,
0.30564233660697937,
-0.03177720680832863,
-0.2533957064151764,
0.13283422589302063,
0.3140644133090973,
0.3122408986091614,
0.011672284454107285,
0.45455774664878845,
-0.750346839427948,
-0.32387781143188477,
-0.16426822543144226,
-0.9457792639732361,
1.0845026969909668,
0.7147936820983887,
-0.8615007996559143,
0.14673878252506256,
-0.9399700164794922,
-0.17559103667736053,
-0.06715250760316849,
-0.16337533295154572,
-0.6070588827133179,
0.17720142006874084,
-0.036314114928245544,
0.15522433817386627,
-0.22675298154354095,
-0.6736922860145569,
-0.18470007181167603,
-0.6111882925033569,
0.5483222603797913,
1.4256138801574707,
0.3845137357711792,
0.557003915309906,
-0.29714807868003845,
0.42665061354637146,
0.11345166712999344,
0.4912723898887634,
0.299094021320343,
-0.2560657560825348,
-0.7308530211448669,
-0.4101467728614807,
-0.05046292766928673,
0.3048080503940582,
-0.8503307700157166,
0.6312777400016785,
-0.3065408170223236,
-0.4485137462615967,
-0.44785258173942566,
0.21217580139636993,
0.4392606317996979,
0.8223767280578613,
0.1406545639038086,
-0.0004599631065502763,
-0.3529469668865204,
-1.1120556592941284,
-0.46016454696655273,
-0.1766076236963272,
-0.1601645052433014,
0.23188602924346924,
0.09588592499494553,
-0.2719952464103699,
0.8129795789718628,
-0.49397581815719604,
-0.06729023903608322,
-0.08685321360826492,
0.1753997653722763,
-0.04901185259222984,
0.46007239818573,
0.5668622255325317,
-0.49395865201950073,
-0.3262981176376343,
-0.29853540658950806,
-0.4268253743648529,
-0.615250289440155,
-0.1927608996629715,
-0.478790819644928,
0.1890610307455063,
0.4850701093673706,
-0.2843617796897888,
0.45919087529182434,
0.21200621128082275,
-0.38604095578193665,
0.35208356380462646,
-0.1302838772535324,
-0.12523798644542694,
-0.9005760550498962,
0.19105856120586395,
-0.2770034074783325,
-0.3156419098377228,
-0.4713124632835388,
0.12333252280950546,
-0.18823128938674927,
0.1131771132349968,
-0.6259180903434753,
0.6845336556434631,
-0.4367823600769043,
0.14706218242645264,
-0.20594777166843414,
0.20614609122276306,
-0.024004071950912476,
0.24091117084026337,
-0.1527508944272995,
0.6025024056434631,
0.38525548577308655,
-0.5416525602340698,
-0.05511205270886421,
0.4239235818386078,
-0.15353122353553772,
0.3986082673072815,
-0.37853044271469116,
0.2794826328754425,
-0.48961108922958374,
0.1214682087302208,
-0.7383571267127991,
0.07185530662536621,
0.4254988729953766,
-0.247076153755188,
0.10506929457187653,
0.00024901118013076484,
-0.3843311369419098,
-0.39387041330337524,
-0.5709090828895569,
0.2295086681842804,
0.7008435130119324,
-0.5307256579399109,
0.4454832971096039,
0.38455191254615784,
-0.3684173822402954,
-0.8797301054000854,
-0.5205919146537781,
0.20396029949188232,
-0.4818449020385742,
-0.2769794464111328,
0.1339772641658783,
-0.33318743109703064,
-0.4540017545223236,
0.12382181733846664,
-0.008880553767085075,
0.23208242654800415,
0.3638461232185364,
0.36183393001556396,
0.08271859586238861,
0.09497550874948502,
0.31962183117866516,
0.4756911098957062,
-0.17384175956249237,
0.3014698028564453,
0.2176716923713684,
0.41467341780662537,
0.44641736149787903,
-0.26239919662475586,
0.07669417560100555,
0.35805368423461914,
0.5985701084136963,
-0.13774067163467407,
0.6654050946235657,
0.5136504173278809,
-0.3948354721069336,
-0.4597483277320862,
-0.6733211278915405,
-0.1485513150691986,
-0.6073154211044312,
0.3605915307998657,
-0.009909885935485363,
-0.6447285413742065,
0.7445374727249146,
-0.05472211539745331,
0.20616742968559265,
0.5643532276153564,
0.6875116229057312,
0.42772871255874634,
1.038089632987976,
0.3900354206562042,
-0.22381435334682465,
0.410885751247406,
-0.10011105239391327,
0.12360600382089615,
-0.7277371883392334,
-0.24282118678092957,
-0.4206638038158417,
-0.2682449519634247,
-0.34223857522010803,
-0.09886369854211807,
0.3850513696670532,
-0.1490923911333084,
-0.49096447229385376,
-0.26607123017311096,
-0.8454650640487671,
0.6155633926391602,
0.6821439266204834,
0.7478824853897095,
0.4095092713832855,
0.002210993552580476,
-0.05682102218270302,
0.22074361145496368,
-0.5117815136909485,
-0.5662024021148682,
1.1137521266937256,
0.4219941198825836,
0.804201602935791,
0.048475231975317,
0.8735456466674805,
0.5056861042976379,
0.6131761074066162,
-0.4570980370044708,
0.673220157623291,
-0.23393456637859344,
-0.9393055438995361,
-0.25099438428878784,
-0.5602726936340332,
-0.6469821929931641,
0.025571389123797417,
-0.23799027502536774,
-0.589239239692688,
0.33211082220077515,
0.24730917811393738,
-0.588263988494873,
0.43912196159362793,
-0.8637281656265259,
0.4145341217517853,
0.0420176200568676,
-0.750531017780304,
-0.5933239459991455,
-0.5422041416168213,
0.4552800953388214,
-0.44368404150009155,
0.5151556730270386,
-0.24880576133728027,
-0.044934362173080444,
0.6734408140182495,
-0.44153881072998047,
1.1377617120742798,
-0.6021917462348938,
-0.02612842619419098,
0.4018031656742096,
0.27212804555892944,
0.6862823367118835,
0.08813793957233429,
-0.6540868878364563,
-0.14471660554409027,
-0.43531280755996704,
-0.38047221302986145,
-0.21795247495174408,
0.8952435851097107,
-0.6674139499664307,
-0.9920738935470581,
-0.06394217163324356,
-0.5094174742698669,
-0.2510027289390564,
0.44111213088035583,
0.10094166547060013,
0.30077001452445984,
-0.09360381215810776,
0.1602659970521927,
0.5702703595161438,
-0.7581772804260254,
0.5050086975097656,
0.5193268060684204,
0.19707857072353363,
-0.4200684726238251,
0.6726493835449219,
0.019243275746703148,
0.551404595375061,
-0.01564858853816986,
0.4664371907711029,
-0.3312268555164337,
-0.9764195084571838,
-0.1841028481721878,
-0.07884805649518967,
-0.9633235335350037,
-0.39671945571899414,
-0.8088788986206055,
0.0749647244811058,
-0.4128635823726654,
-0.15970249474048615,
-0.048625729978084564,
-0.33919376134872437,
-0.6064311265945435,
-0.6275339126586914,
0.5413480401039124,
0.7786021828651428,
-0.31116220355033875,
0.36886268854141235,
-0.6549665927886963,
0.2868415117263794,
0.18885788321495056,
0.5042605400085449,
0.16310636699199677,
-0.7975240349769592,
0.3245757818222046,
0.26437970995903015,
-0.3546726107597351,
-0.6361461877822876,
0.34921202063560486,
0.1081940159201622,
0.733931839466095,
0.682746410369873,
0.6626977920532227,
0.6716302633285522,
-0.3570813238620758,
0.5474688410758972,
0.015256407670676708,
-0.9666487574577332,
0.3565966784954071,
-0.6803322434425354,
-0.05617169290781021,
0.6457148790359497,
0.12762729823589325,
-0.40700671076774597,
-0.922240138053894,
-0.5669974088668823,
-0.9914843440055847,
0.5578229427337646,
0.001596243353560567,
0.49360135197639465,
-0.3883870244026184,
0.577293336391449,
0.5649531483650208,
0.236057847738266,
-0.5659605264663696,
-0.26903852820396423,
0.0887136161327362,
-0.35415729880332947,
0.09226389229297638,
-0.6764587759971619,
-0.04975521191954613,
-0.2433861792087555,
0.6391371488571167,
0.15913699567317963,
-0.11344430595636368,
0.0827416479587555,
-0.14515715837478638,
-0.49142545461654663,
0.3359338641166687,
0.2887558341026306,
0.5140539407730103,
-0.1898530274629593,
0.28524208068847656,
0.18040134012699127,
-0.3295740485191345,
0.13818545639514923,
-0.20636071264743805,
-0.5912885665893555,
-0.2985091507434845,
0.25287771224975586,
0.46349626779556274,
0.33103570342063904,
-0.4720013439655304,
0.45181089639663696,
0.2855278253555298,
-0.12018978595733643,
-0.2884494662284851,
0.16050900518894196,
0.08987198024988174,
0.0806596428155899,
0.4545000195503235,
0.2256575971841812,
0.2241707295179367,
-0.5699957013130188,
0.4350340962409973,
0.516798198223114,
-0.14581331610679626,
-0.20930927991867065,
1.1023448705673218,
0.5865690112113953,
-0.0047733536921441555,
0.4466806948184967,
-0.19601181149482727,
-0.5487958192825317,
0.5668334364891052,
0.39587298035621643,
0.9712750315666199,
-0.18314670026302338,
0.3707598149776459,
0.34417030215263367,
0.32679903507232666,
0.22943347692489624,
0.1844676434993744,
0.37321943044662476,
-0.637670636177063,
-0.25762566924095154,
-0.4875521957874298,
-0.16485722362995148,
0.25484636425971985,
-0.5057994723320007,
0.205813929438591,
-0.44793882966041565,
-0.08324608951807022,
0.22677454352378845,
-0.17004132270812988,
-0.7165177464485168,
-0.15406985580921173,
0.15495866537094116,
0.8940297365188599,
-1.0448421239852905,
0.37650105357170105,
0.055371157824993134,
-0.2768973708152771,
-0.6246314644813538,
-0.28380101919174194,
0.19917240738868713,
-0.9856066107749939,
0.7067893147468567,
-0.07137679308652878,
-0.11462763696908951,
0.21553903818130493,
-0.5413192510604858,
-0.6171658635139465,
0.5552677512168884,
0.7863088250160217,
-0.493508517742157,
0.16393449902534485,
-0.052164606750011444,
0.4395642578601837,
0.012663605622947216,
0.5173428058624268,
0.30423375964164734,
0.7115429639816284,
0.05448140203952789,
-0.5724694132804871,
0.3527013957500458,
-0.049539387226104736,
-0.3138989508152008,
-0.08426716923713684,
-0.7664754390716553,
0.4921123683452606,
-0.28245511651039124,
-0.3819233477115631,
-0.018638500943779945,
0.18560287356376648,
0.014235065318644047,
0.33281657099723816,
0.7983008623123169,
0.23612798750400543,
0.6215855479240417,
0.33923575282096863,
0.7332252860069275,
-0.17957593500614166,
-0.03293018788099289,
1.0842697620391846,
-0.4696408212184906,
0.6442698836326599,
0.501950740814209,
0.07338125258684158,
0.3381282389163971,
0.5316258668899536,
0.2172730565071106,
0.6354206800460815,
0.49415645003318787,
-0.5446122884750366,
-0.214471235871315,
-0.41856294870376587,
-0.20362114906311035,
0.3652312457561493,
0.2581994831562042,
-0.6249583959579468,
-0.351840615272522,
0.11201850324869156,
0.22781674563884735,
0.37803488969802856,
-0.3364031910896301,
0.7386083006858826,
-0.1309429407119751,
-0.6640543937683105,
0.5884766578674316,
-0.2628406584262848,
0.7641257643699646,
-0.1861288994550705,
0.034575868397951126,
-0.523682177066803,
0.4114927053451538,
-0.2842242419719696,
-0.5061686038970947,
0.40033361315727234,
-0.09570226073265076,
-0.10401064157485962,
-0.40048277378082275,
0.9144973158836365,
-0.24508367478847504,
-0.3789386451244354,
0.40699830651283264,
0.4432383179664612,
0.0978231281042099,
-0.20355990529060364,
-0.48945966362953186,
-0.02829688787460327,
0.08480378240346909,
-0.6496651768684387,
0.21845419704914093,
0.4812491536140442,
-0.012893795035779476,
0.8849794268608093,
0.6043523550033569,
0.2814178764820099,
0.13137885928153992,
0.2272084504365921,
1.2171268463134766,
-0.41239798069000244,
-0.19135048985481262,
-0.9234691262245178,
0.335658460855484,
-0.14836660027503967,
-0.04279608279466629,
0.745294451713562,
0.5509335398674011,
0.5569950938224792,
-0.10841193795204163,
0.8457147479057312,
0.18778468668460846,
0.534026563167572,
-0.2604997754096985,
1.0245317220687866,
-0.25049322843551636,
0.4192420542240143,
-0.4368402659893036,
-0.6814936995506287,
-0.3423439860343933,
0.13762417435646057,
-0.3644492030143738,
-0.039661526679992676,
0.3544198274612427,
1.0344489812850952,
0.26775017380714417,
-0.31473633646965027,
0.21925842761993408,
0.45203545689582825,
0.5099232196807861,
0.6024982333183289,
0.731229841709137,
0.025099456310272217,
0.8216993808746338,
-0.21478167176246643,
-0.4935705363750458,
-0.1158023402094841,
-1.0606772899627686,
-0.8437111973762512,
-0.1098390743136406,
-0.23485322296619415,
-0.13978171348571777,
0.42246708273887634,
0.9309079647064209,
0.35105785727500916,
-0.6218680143356323,
0.4863414764404297,
-0.12340118736028671,
0.3097350001335144,
-0.08170908689498901,
-0.26123911142349243,
0.3226064443588257,
-0.0671626552939415,
-0.7878391146659851,
0.19305355846881866,
0.021119020879268646,
-0.08397245407104492,
-0.26305630803108215,
0.07121672481298447,
0.24567247927188873,
0.04926794394850731,
0.6702679395675659,
-0.017063306644558907,
-0.5848541259765625,
-0.9992474913597107,
0.016681740060448647,
0.03945247456431389,
-0.34811556339263916,
0.43584007024765015,
-0.9465575218200684,
0.5437687635421753,
0.53242427110672,
0.3642604649066925,
-0.06267804652452469,
0.04979288950562477,
0.6621876955032349,
-0.8330381512641907,
0.2964295446872711,
0.5249159336090088,
0.238783061504364,
0.03807277977466583,
-0.8422282338142395,
0.5014188289642334,
0.19501270353794098,
-0.46141359210014343,
-1.113517165184021,
0.2639223039150238,
-0.7235955595970154,
-0.4052430987358093,
1.5453596115112305,
0.10973687469959259,
-0.20473892986774445,
-0.42518746852874756,
-0.3041263818740845,
0.4111514985561371,
-0.5400916934013367,
1.1515305042266846,
0.4530473053455353,
0.39572474360466003,
-0.037512801587581635,
-0.40266796946525574,
0.4310648739337921,
0.6346332430839539,
-0.6235485672950745,
0.8553260564804077,
0.7822111248970032,
0.43223506212234497,
-0.29972541332244873,
0.7957395911216736,
-0.2601848840713501,
-0.016516931354999542,
0.10746961832046509,
0.13867004215717316,
-0.3531063497066498,
-0.04841538146138191,
-0.3236522972583771,
0.1105009913444519,
0.25924891233444214,
-0.19254030287265778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19290v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19290v2
|
Integrating Multi-scale Contextualized Information for Byte-based Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-29T17:19:04 | 2024-06-07T08:34:57 |
Langlin Huang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Subword tokenization is a common method for vocabulary building in Neural
Machine Translation (NMT) models. However, increasingly complex tasks have
revealed its disadvantages. First, a vocabulary cannot be modified once it is
learned, making it hard to adapt to new words. Second, in multilingual
translation, the imbalance in data volumes across different languages spreads
to the vocabulary, exacerbating translations involving low-resource languages.
While byte-based tokenization addresses these issues, byte-based models
struggle with the low information density inherent in UTF-8 byte sequences.
Previous works enhance token semantics through local contextualization but fail
to select an appropriate contextualizing scope based on the input.
Consequently, we propose the Multi-Scale Contextualization (MSC) method, which
learns contextualized information of varying scales across different hidden
state dimensions. It then leverages the attention module to dynamically
integrate the multi-scale contextualized information. Experiments show that MSC
significantly outperforms subword-based and other byte-based methods in both
multilingual and out-of-domain scenarios. Code can be found in
https://github.com/ictnlp/Multiscale-Contextualization.
|
[
-0.4410785734653473,
-0.4739867150783539,
0.21749505400657654,
0.3259887099266052,
-0.4929647743701935,
0.03761804476380348,
-0.4002058506011963,
-0.31166404485702515,
0.4905845820903778,
0.1531439870595932,
-0.285286545753479,
-0.3917761445045471,
-0.6646395325660706,
-0.023773042485117912,
0.10865367949008942,
0.8990797400474548,
-0.057610832154750824,
0.393367201089859,
0.013269571587443352,
-0.4271605610847473,
-0.917695164680481,
-0.8055927753448486,
-0.45948243141174316,
-0.16287671029567719,
0.663973331451416,
0.36425331234931946,
0.32915419340133667,
0.7178080677986145,
0.6367105841636658,
0.2659966051578522,
-0.27076178789138794,
0.41452351212501526,
-0.04209202527999878,
0.03374370560050011,
-0.26984816789627075,
-0.4465252459049225,
-0.527565598487854,
-0.18907079100608826,
0.853343665599823,
0.7620056867599487,
0.08833802491426468,
0.26911255717277527,
-0.04789390042424202,
0.5232745409011841,
-0.6397597193717957,
0.35450080037117004,
-0.7479344010353088,
0.2784567177295685,
-0.10418648272752762,
-0.32142603397369385,
-0.4477722942829132,
0.35014331340789795,
0.022128835320472717,
-0.5709146857261658,
-0.053956713527441025,
0.06655818223953247,
0.36100494861602783,
0.3656885623931885,
-0.8101769089698792,
-0.09653610736131668,
-0.34059837460517883,
0.9271659851074219,
-0.6563182473182678,
0.2567165791988373,
0.13262714445590973,
0.22013014554977417,
-0.005854821763932705,
-0.5883885622024536,
-0.1814739853143692,
-0.15161855518817902,
-0.19125641882419586,
0.16707664728164673,
-0.08424397557973862,
0.02306930534541607,
0.05241601541638374,
0.20940756797790527,
-0.20965492725372314,
0.02222346141934395,
-0.24742494523525238,
-0.28963613510131836,
0.04215576872229576,
0.06043289229273796,
0.30797216296195984,
-0.30778980255126953,
-0.7047817707061768,
0.07733572274446487,
-0.45215919613838196,
-0.07668549567461014,
-0.07600808143615723,
0.7592548727989197,
-0.11984638124704361,
0.5939339995384216,
-0.16542084515094757,
0.4849260747432709,
0.20971964299678802,
0.006495218724012375,
0.40944868326187134,
-0.6140640377998352,
-0.04698696732521057,
0.41335514187812805,
0.576356828212738,
0.3972996473312378,
-0.15120793879032135,
-0.26549339294433594,
-0.28463035821914673,
-0.3707977831363678,
0.3793542683124542,
-0.9066392779350281,
0.42317813634872437,
0.22933122515678406,
-0.5563084483146667,
-0.06089009717106819,
-0.2851741313934326,
-0.5337334871292114,
-0.3942863941192627,
-0.3102911114692688,
0.5129340291023254,
-0.5361241698265076,
-0.2685528099536896,
-0.0942462831735611,
-0.11571862548589706,
-0.0021262045484036207,
0.09166473150253296,
-0.9133145213127136,
-0.22730547189712524,
0.24690115451812744,
1.090140461921692,
-0.22194194793701172,
-0.42752015590667725,
-0.5069332718849182,
0.19273462891578674,
-0.3551267683506012,
0.31062591075897217,
-0.3268192708492279,
-0.10968087613582611,
-0.1511087268590927,
-0.010242263786494732,
-0.2637555003166199,
-0.522820770740509,
0.1309821754693985,
-0.5692629814147949,
-0.292987197637558,
-0.316956102848053,
-0.2894376814365387,
-0.1252763420343399,
0.46789786219596863,
-0.4555049538612366,
0.8969016075134277,
-0.03773381933569908,
-0.9501054883003235,
0.4748099148273468,
-0.9482271671295166,
-0.5723432302474976,
0.14152060449123383,
-0.1530168503522873,
-0.13105687499046326,
0.46316587924957275,
0.3802661597728729,
0.6420134902000427,
0.003070010570809245,
0.3859091103076935,
-0.05959412828087807,
-0.2843197286128998,
0.13832888007164001,
-0.5241336822509766,
0.39793163537979126,
0.25757572054862976,
-0.44150638580322266,
0.22840052843093872,
-0.6196746826171875,
0.02807239256799221,
-0.27627748250961304,
-0.6699392199516296,
-0.3756057918071747,
-0.20064488053321838,
0.2904651165008545,
0.3375947177410126,
0.5244967937469482,
-0.6015537977218628,
0.25725057721138,
-0.3559616208076477,
0.635208785533905,
0.376605749130249,
-0.12683363258838654,
0.6280829906463623,
0.04694180190563202,
0.3786889314651489,
0.683306872844696,
0.01626896671950817,
-0.33148193359375,
-0.32721999287605286,
-0.6650393605232239,
-0.4311099648475647,
0.44207683205604553,
0.5275445580482483,
-0.9760328531265259,
0.19081206619739532,
-0.5021253824234009,
-0.30010923743247986,
-0.4235941469669342,
-0.19390736520290375,
0.2839715778827667,
0.5417594909667969,
0.8657233715057373,
-0.3415413200855255,
-0.5278701782226562,
-1.0085103511810303,
-0.17527899146080017,
0.29111096262931824,
0.03704901039600372,
0.3796934187412262,
0.40469563007354736,
-0.3363589942455292,
0.8308477401733398,
-0.10719956457614899,
-0.534464955329895,
-0.2430463284254074,
0.3677681088447571,
0.17469607293605804,
0.8731094002723694,
0.41889140009880066,
-0.7960448265075684,
-0.3443180024623871,
0.46831879019737244,
-0.5620413422584534,
0.2913391590118408,
-0.427389919757843,
-0.06377541273832321,
-0.0891122967004776,
0.6669814586639404,
-0.7035890817642212,
0.2724316120147705,
0.3985021412372589,
-0.18256399035453796,
0.3452015519142151,
-0.5635209083557129,
0.25674930214881897,
-1.5725288391113281,
0.21122904121875763,
-0.18495294451713562,
-0.06740553677082062,
-0.6977912187576294,
0.22636909782886505,
0.5369964241981506,
0.13159501552581787,
-0.7347461581230164,
0.4284784197807312,
-0.6395336985588074,
-0.31321534514427185,
-0.27714774012565613,
0.09593793749809265,
-0.16080491244792938,
0.5823904871940613,
0.006832960061728954,
0.8004488945007324,
0.33312734961509705,
-0.43667352199554443,
0.2579154968261719,
-0.09475373476743698,
-0.22057883441448212,
0.6895793676376343,
-0.3217059373855591,
-0.1050497367978096,
-0.20856721699237823,
0.35413289070129395,
-0.8499163389205933,
-0.18125441670417786,
-0.10796784609556198,
-0.5931766629219055,
0.5413193702697754,
-0.3356899619102478,
-0.5361599922180176,
0.1059626042842865,
-0.09016957879066467,
0.7196628451347351,
-0.0341595895588398,
-0.5307415127754211,
0.728708803653717,
0.3847889006137848,
0.17625193297863007,
-0.9773909449577332,
-1.1608484983444214,
0.4692782461643219,
-0.3193703591823578,
-0.28566232323646545,
0.4388967454433441,
0.01010756567120552,
0.25209662318229675,
-0.14968572556972504,
-0.23027779161930084,
-0.15273842215538025,
0.04390571638941765,
-0.04092082008719444,
0.12282846868038177,
-0.47313594818115234,
0.30984777212142944,
0.33713188767433167,
-0.10002893954515457,
-0.14246730506420135,
-0.8586022257804871,
0.5120134353637695,
-0.4201636016368866,
-0.19896507263183594,
-0.26506713032722473,
0.5193188190460205,
0.9595149755477905,
-0.4752950370311737,
1.040013313293457,
1.1425271034240723,
-0.5191067457199097,
0.06486155837774277,
-0.3399102985858917,
-0.12460765987634659,
-0.40242505073547363,
0.7563993334770203,
-0.6310190558433533,
-0.9384838342666626,
0.5882839560508728,
-0.26104286313056946,
0.009805209934711456,
0.36564379930496216,
0.6170322895050049,
0.01055064145475626,
1.1251994371414185,
0.6278108358383179,
-0.049953822046518326,
0.5287809371948242,
-0.16061145067214966,
0.19062161445617676,
-1.3266887664794922,
-0.11487266421318054,
-0.13231545686721802,
-0.6987367868423462,
-0.6197400689125061,
-0.6160361170768738,
0.4098753333091736,
0.21668656170368195,
0.01964528299868107,
0.5764048099517822,
-0.48217692971229553,
0.37994441390037537,
0.5370286703109741,
0.05020320788025856,
0.06802059710025787,
0.01689830608665943,
-0.683904230594635,
-0.12875908613204956,
-0.9362897276878357,
-0.20588263869285583,
0.9166660308837891,
0.3422825336456299,
0.328533798456192,
0.2542297840118408,
0.421286404132843,
0.10399172455072403,
0.48166391253471375,
-1.0194882154464722,
0.2938055098056793,
-0.23946963250637054,
-0.5870634913444519,
-0.2585064172744751,
-0.5242246985435486,
-0.7786601185798645,
0.8791090250015259,
-0.1818958967924118,
-0.6890000700950623,
0.31477972865104675,
0.0922175794839859,
-0.26785656809806824,
0.3942871391773224,
-0.8581702709197998,
0.8624718189239502,
0.024249551817774773,
-0.08335372805595398,
-0.13788263499736786,
-0.893458902835846,
0.04004763811826706,
-0.29072749614715576,
0.4417353868484497,
0.19964857399463654,
-0.3732709288597107,
0.425947904586792,
-0.3122062087059021,
1.0752021074295044,
-0.17116476595401764,
0.026802778244018555,
0.034773170948028564,
-0.06511630862951279,
0.4250166714191437,
0.2030208557844162,
0.11259367316961288,
0.32147762179374695,
0.06967095285654068,
-0.5239220261573792,
-0.39999300241470337,
0.7637741565704346,
-0.6170474886894226,
-0.17637686431407928,
-0.11764728277921677,
-0.9519745111465454,
-0.36284807324409485,
0.5990872383117676,
0.3183031380176544,
0.5271355509757996,
0.24439993500709534,
0.5669741630554199,
0.6344843506813049,
-0.32533860206604004,
0.541045606136322,
0.3377092182636261,
0.038277335464954376,
-0.5521125197410583,
0.9660253524780273,
0.3982664942741394,
0.2316691279411316,
0.8167923092842102,
0.3003024458885193,
-0.15839768946170807,
-0.5057758092880249,
-0.9020929336547852,
-0.12227846682071686,
-0.8699764013290405,
-0.32784706354141235,
-0.7024189829826355,
0.023425603285431862,
-0.34568530321121216,
-0.1643950641155243,
-0.6000182628631592,
-0.45130395889282227,
-0.2036513090133667,
-0.028552215546369553,
0.007363627199083567,
0.2881021797657013,
-0.08867184072732925,
0.4535467028617859,
-0.8897316455841064,
-0.017055876553058624,
-0.13658592104911804,
0.1420273333787918,
0.15220561623573303,
-0.5294846296310425,
-0.727218508720398,
-0.08746984601020813,
0.15555623173713684,
-0.683146595954895,
0.328195720911026,
-0.05671530216932297,
0.41211462020874023,
0.141152486205101,
-0.1405571848154068,
0.6940076947212219,
-0.673740029335022,
0.6569041013717651,
0.3224530518054962,
-0.9315621852874756,
0.30202552676200867,
-0.2905779778957367,
0.845792293548584,
0.449500173330307,
0.29389873147010803,
-0.8287523984909058,
-0.17205172777175903,
-0.11143914610147476,
-1.2024320363998413,
0.67154860496521,
-0.23805080354213715,
0.3971424996852875,
-0.21823565661907196,
0.4338061511516571,
-0.04537823796272278,
0.4148039221763611,
-0.7098978757858276,
-0.219256192445755,
-0.21541623771190643,
-0.3363838493824005,
-0.07266835123300552,
-0.0723707526922226,
0.22095359861850739,
-0.11712285876274109,
0.3157443404197693,
-0.4618985056877136,
0.14230328798294067,
0.1909492015838623,
-0.391122043132782,
0.18990124762058258,
0.2773935794830322,
0.7996654510498047,
0.3612798750400543,
-0.026444759219884872,
0.5765146613121033,
0.5650990009307861,
-0.7729027271270752,
-0.06316922605037689,
-0.22825276851654053,
-0.07502859085798264,
-0.05187828838825226,
0.3901074528694153,
0.7459357380867004,
0.45668062567710876,
-0.3522983491420746,
0.5443792939186096,
-0.03691798448562622,
-0.07450038194656372,
0.06552191078662872,
-0.5113964080810547,
0.33196428418159485,
0.2194375991821289,
0.30903083086013794,
0.41588330268859863,
-0.026173310354351997,
-0.27510687708854675,
0.23373430967330933,
0.37523069977760315,
-0.6510074138641357,
-0.14178134500980377,
0.5568925738334656,
0.03757637366652489,
0.04898348078131676,
0.49590933322906494,
-0.021437520161271095,
-0.4188726842403412,
0.5482879281044006,
0.6972419619560242,
0.7396361827850342,
-0.11320454627275467,
-0.07882470637559891,
0.3662593364715576,
0.6391248106956482,
0.13371402025222778,
0.08048425614833832,
-0.27918681502342224,
-0.6120375394821167,
-0.7398509383201599,
-0.6608322858810425,
-0.08570756018161774,
0.0952836126089096,
-0.5445298552513123,
-0.019717108458280563,
-0.3631647825241089,
-0.43083521723747253,
-0.16953176259994507,
-0.26387158036231995,
-0.4652564227581024,
0.24510815739631653,
-0.023379720747470856,
0.9289700388908386,
-0.4702213704586029,
0.95893794298172,
1.0366222858428955,
-0.45099788904190063,
-0.5704548954963684,
-0.10900595039129257,
-0.19766530394554138,
-0.590981662273407,
0.9130515456199646,
0.40247541666030884,
-0.12470826506614685,
0.13041172921657562,
-0.10901108384132385,
-1.1003245115280151,
1.0791256427764893,
0.22972539067268372,
-0.3370553255081177,
0.034599337726831436,
0.31534963846206665,
0.4598191976547241,
-0.5439107418060303,
0.1806274652481079,
0.12772713601589203,
0.4473732113838196,
0.08686504513025284,
-0.7769629955291748,
0.12184944748878479,
-0.02845599129796028,
0.26206785440444946,
0.2666996419429779,
-0.6287204027175903,
0.959439754486084,
-0.12625500559806824,
-0.05793849378824234,
-0.24875032901763916,
0.6716060638427734,
-0.2519458532333374,
-0.10793384164571762,
0.3518438935279846,
0.4023023545742035,
0.523851752281189,
0.1549372673034668,
0.7624117732048035,
-0.5496793389320374,
0.3639995753765106,
1.2116519212722778,
0.21041369438171387,
0.8684917092323303,
0.8496230244636536,
0.3812761902809143,
-0.07128967344760895,
0.6466838121414185,
0.25456294417381287,
0.5255439281463623,
0.3086613416671753,
-0.3562013804912567,
-0.16567659378051758,
-0.24382458627223969,
-0.23579803109169006,
0.47575804591178894,
0.40337833762168884,
-0.3398967683315277,
-0.28657591342926025,
0.28597840666770935,
-0.043290991336107254,
-0.3957635462284088,
-0.3894204795360565,
0.48081153631210327,
0.11018047481775284,
-0.5520350933074951,
0.5255122780799866,
0.46026942133903503,
0.8672768473625183,
-0.41220006346702576,
0.09153378754854202,
-0.3634415566921234,
0.3748560845851898,
-0.13370360434055328,
-0.2609735131263733,
0.46426552534103394,
-0.10019965469837189,
-0.23566804826259613,
-0.28638318181037903,
0.5435647964477539,
-0.5727676153182983,
-0.2484789788722992,
0.20571547746658325,
0.52846360206604,
0.12259700149297714,
-0.24339206516742706,
-0.5952926278114319,
-0.1349879950284958,
-0.2876088321208954,
-0.343239963054657,
0.6391333937644958,
0.6233206987380981,
-0.22084666788578033,
0.4115566313266754,
0.5731772780418396,
0.0038542363326996565,
0.2102741152048111,
0.06551159173250198,
0.6103624105453491,
-0.5287676453590393,
-0.5583677887916565,
-0.804288387298584,
0.48189878463745117,
0.06106572225689888,
-0.3839048445224762,
0.6841685771942139,
0.5726308226585388,
0.7697058916091919,
-0.2031802535057068,
0.5041162967681885,
0.04554152116179466,
-0.10863634943962097,
-0.42225292325019836,
0.8879755139350891,
-0.7841871380805969,
0.0463453009724617,
0.12515410780906677,
-0.7413773536682129,
-0.5544449687004089,
0.4650411605834961,
-0.055012695491313934,
0.02521842159330845,
0.8779010772705078,
0.5369633436203003,
-0.22591429948806763,
-0.3455236852169037,
0.5686033368110657,
0.10559079051017761,
0.10375499725341797,
0.4064856767654419,
0.5776703953742981,
-0.33712390065193176,
0.5211636424064636,
0.0066379462368786335,
-0.4279656708240509,
-0.34955376386642456,
-1.0501872301101685,
-0.8315768241882324,
-0.4889466464519501,
-0.08334095031023026,
-0.026363184675574303,
-0.34517231583595276,
1.0033572912216187,
0.9315915107727051,
-0.7055601477622986,
-0.038710594177246094,
-0.07119785249233246,
0.003994133789092302,
-0.36748602986335754,
-0.17846564948558807,
0.3254585266113281,
-0.765421986579895,
-0.659517228603363,
0.6674785614013672,
0.5211759805679321,
0.006889674812555313,
-0.28434425592422485,
0.27240484952926636,
-0.31340062618255615,
0.16045181453227997,
0.8842226266860962,
-0.1965053379535675,
-0.5926913619041443,
-0.40011492371559143,
-0.012074684724211693,
-0.30373936891555786,
0.19051259756088257,
0.7520710825920105,
-0.4098961055278778,
0.4732309579849243,
0.3419854938983917,
1.0562182664871216,
0.5225971937179565,
-0.30374079942703247,
0.2704195976257324,
-1.205126166343689,
0.14403748512268066,
-0.05287359282374382,
0.3831493556499481,
0.32096654176712036,
-0.5605849623680115,
0.30737268924713135,
0.24021080136299133,
-0.1720457375049591,
-0.6161834001541138,
0.2066805511713028,
-0.757510781288147,
-0.3916949927806854,
0.9152493476867676,
-0.2141227126121521,
-0.249908447265625,
0.06824926286935806,
-0.2261902391910553,
0.3281940519809723,
-0.17966420948505402,
0.49111756682395935,
0.8826786279678345,
0.09801111370325089,
0.23263604938983917,
-0.7809620499610901,
0.1696465164422989,
0.6385419964790344,
-0.5865687727928162,
0.0584653839468956,
0.2603195905685425,
0.1884269267320633,
0.41868001222610474,
0.4575996994972229,
-0.18282639980316162,
-0.006207890808582306,
0.09611029177904129,
0.19447965919971466,
-0.087856724858284,
-0.3461461067199707,
-0.3858972489833832,
0.297486811876297,
-0.20500214397907257,
-0.40750962495803833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19285v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19285v1
|
MASSIVE Multilingual Abstract Meaning Representation: A Dataset and Baselines for Hallucination Detection
| 2024-05-29T17:17:22 | 2024-05-29T17:17:22 |
Michael Regan, Shira Wein, George Baker, Emilio Monti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) is a semantic formalism that captures
the core meaning of an utterance. There has been substantial work developing
AMR corpora in English and more recently across languages, though the limited
size of existing datasets and the cost of collecting more annotations are
prohibitive. With both engineering and scientific questions in mind, we
introduce MASSIVE-AMR, a dataset with more than 84,000 text-to-graph
annotations, currently the largest and most diverse of its kind: AMR graphs for
1,685 information-seeking utterances mapped to 50+ typologically diverse
languages. We describe how we built our resource and its unique features before
reporting on experiments using large language models for multilingual AMR and
SPARQL parsing as well as applying AMRs for hallucination detection in the
context of knowledge base question answering, with results shedding light on
persistent issues using LLMs for structured parsing.
|
[
-0.6406199336051941,
-0.9065845012664795,
0.49735718965530396,
0.14555397629737854,
-0.07570096105337143,
0.24567031860351562,
-0.23660868406295776,
-0.7147104144096375,
0.5473712086677551,
0.4634234309196472,
-0.2959822714328766,
-0.5332545042037964,
-0.6937382221221924,
0.48650649189949036,
-0.4227651357650757,
0.7463528513908386,
-0.18315206468105316,
0.03159405663609505,
-0.09353998303413391,
-0.4160890281200409,
-0.4029925465583801,
-0.8784373998641968,
-0.539726197719574,
-0.4408470094203949,
0.673879861831665,
0.14035390317440033,
0.8444004654884338,
0.5859591364860535,
0.34625622630119324,
0.29610148072242737,
-0.008405731059610844,
0.1499328315258026,
-0.23923489451408386,
0.15863704681396484,
0.030461857095360756,
-0.25410524010658264,
-0.11981294304132462,
-0.42239809036254883,
0.6663631200790405,
1.102054238319397,
0.06656917929649353,
-0.08178882300853729,
-0.23578397929668427,
0.5847147703170776,
-0.5632872581481934,
0.3260519802570343,
-0.4300738573074341,
0.23427556455135345,
-0.0639847069978714,
-0.2102792114019394,
-0.40202513337135315,
-0.2108711451292038,
-0.13861188292503357,
-0.5074143409729004,
0.0862988829612732,
0.26629403233528137,
0.6543977856636047,
0.1879233866930008,
-0.5829985737800598,
-0.5638184547424316,
-0.6068093776702881,
0.7338125109672546,
-0.2352628856897354,
0.6532366871833801,
0.21527738869190216,
0.5256956815719604,
-0.03703025355935097,
-0.46478405594825745,
-0.7415525913238525,
-0.0629725530743599,
-0.3858779966831207,
-0.25648975372314453,
-0.37458497285842896,
0.09727810323238373,
0.36383000016212463,
0.5284253358840942,
-0.6728163361549377,
-0.180986225605011,
-0.4686480164527893,
-0.4635083079338074,
0.5418919920921326,
0.2088283896446228,
0.3476305902004242,
-0.3859189748764038,
0.1310264766216278,
-0.014436060562729836,
-0.5903948545455933,
-0.46760910749435425,
0.26283398270606995,
0.31115955114364624,
-0.15149401128292084,
0.9332091808319092,
-0.06242917850613594,
0.8419703245162964,
-0.4885598123073578,
0.15630316734313965,
0.5239603519439697,
-0.30400654673576355,
0.12841656804084778,
0.37281715869903564,
0.7802304625511169,
0.01423377264291048,
0.626950204372406,
-0.4494858682155609,
-0.2905178964138031,
0.32800784707069397,
0.17464594542980194,
-0.5991175770759583,
-0.2445029318332672,
0.294002890586853,
-0.4428577125072479,
0.030895881354808807,
-0.041830454021692276,
-0.6326776146888733,
-0.537297248840332,
-0.5653051733970642,
0.14449143409729004,
-0.45407527685165405,
-0.3438614010810852,
0.3049176037311554,
-0.1855737268924713,
0.2797994315624237,
0.1156095564365387,
-0.8079714775085449,
0.3766118884086609,
0.5676940083503723,
1.030197262763977,
-0.13253280520439148,
-0.2981468439102173,
-0.2610151767730713,
0.23572249710559845,
-0.30364593863487244,
1.0063066482543945,
-0.7238765954971313,
-0.38187626004219055,
0.0503370575606823,
0.14932185411453247,
-0.04422233626246452,
-0.6647215485572815,
0.27323493361473083,
-0.5654469728469849,
-0.05523530766367912,
-0.4891512393951416,
-0.4083108603954315,
-0.5382234454154968,
0.41368722915649414,
-0.8291388154029846,
0.7359187602996826,
0.02373768575489521,
-0.6955661177635193,
0.19601257145404816,
-0.7039006352424622,
-0.5031777620315552,
0.20490847527980804,
-0.6798286437988281,
0.15834908187389374,
0.1434909850358963,
0.07577844709157944,
0.37358227372169495,
-0.12111476808786392,
0.09441936016082764,
-0.0918515995144844,
-0.32588937878608704,
0.5017696619033813,
-0.1236361712217331,
0.35183432698249817,
0.19996529817581177,
-0.19147376716136932,
0.12723061442375183,
-0.9586168527603149,
-0.12183351814746857,
-0.03891808167099953,
-0.27278101444244385,
-0.47887298464775085,
0.05406533181667328,
0.2612670958042145,
0.31568047404289246,
0.20290018618106842,
-0.637723445892334,
-0.0797969177365303,
-0.3212824761867523,
0.5513449311256409,
0.5092365741729736,
0.1382528841495514,
0.0005229072412475944,
-0.22792719304561615,
0.4231882691383362,
0.10170403122901917,
-0.4380132257938385,
-0.32062458992004395,
-0.42282989621162415,
-0.7532868385314941,
-0.09647055715322495,
0.027237428352236748,
0.5747234225273132,
-0.3190695643424988,
0.5479459762573242,
-0.3495830297470093,
0.10360774397850037,
-0.676263153553009,
-0.023075012490153313,
0.3453969359397888,
0.31641849875450134,
0.5002517104148865,
-0.0006512056570500135,
-0.87102872133255,
-1.1349273920059204,
0.04834279045462608,
-0.18180261552333832,
-0.16323544085025787,
0.2579347491264343,
0.9004348516464233,
-0.5322363376617432,
0.7241086959838867,
-0.5829553604125977,
-0.4766598641872406,
-0.1890404373407364,
0.24469707906246185,
0.17994926869869232,
0.21756094694137573,
0.2559298872947693,
-0.8421975374221802,
-0.1963375210762024,
0.3160584270954132,
-1.2862716913223267,
0.07212921231985092,
0.06489858031272888,
-0.03348707780241966,
0.18271060287952423,
0.6137359142303467,
-0.6004535555839539,
0.051886241883039474,
0.5367714762687683,
-0.46165597438812256,
0.6564172506332397,
-0.0727887824177742,
0.389250785112381,
-1.087408185005188,
0.21621204912662506,
-0.26047492027282715,
-0.0481262132525444,
-0.395088791847229,
-0.005415961612015963,
-0.01520809717476368,
-0.1750006526708603,
-0.23222622275352478,
0.5766664147377014,
-0.5114828944206238,
-0.13051533699035645,
-0.38257327675819397,
0.16173440217971802,
-0.19069239497184753,
0.2997998893260956,
0.1221790686249733,
0.8573272824287415,
0.3767884075641632,
-0.5973397493362427,
0.5015621185302734,
0.48494282364845276,
-0.2801479697227478,
0.3599342405796051,
-0.7450991272926331,
-0.00379191804677248,
-0.3887530565261841,
-0.005379893351346254,
-0.9694226384162903,
-0.6073241233825684,
0.19847777485847473,
-0.42966559529304504,
0.06153443083167076,
0.029283730313181877,
-0.6818620562553406,
-0.3054006099700928,
0.020391693338751793,
0.47265055775642395,
0.19030947983264923,
-0.4861656129360199,
0.6804079413414001,
0.7150357961654663,
-0.06385687738656998,
-0.6145323514938354,
-0.9106330275535583,
0.3031294047832489,
-0.07379308342933655,
-0.8481545448303223,
0.11060066521167755,
0.1252022683620453,
-0.5969247221946716,
0.24887700378894806,
0.04504073038697243,
0.03781349956989288,
-0.15818078815937042,
0.20006829500198364,
-0.08634589612483978,
-0.33436837792396545,
0.22564460337162018,
-0.0474775955080986,
-0.3603939414024353,
0.3942950963973999,
-0.1852147877216339,
0.8225582242012024,
-0.2685912251472473,
-0.45724067091941833,
0.09331240504980087,
0.7078956365585327,
0.5954068303108215,
0.035751983523368835,
0.8447480797767639,
0.2798832356929779,
-0.8137931823730469,
-0.009634156711399555,
-0.6227867603302002,
-0.09303705394268036,
-0.4148201644420624,
0.44467929005622864,
-0.6373583674430847,
-1.100957989692688,
0.9067068696022034,
0.262055903673172,
0.03725295886397362,
0.369625985622406,
0.6085640788078308,
0.3166075646877289,
1.0963866710662842,
0.32531383633613586,
-0.06760746985673904,
-0.0177318062633276,
-0.1256903111934662,
0.3357069492340088,
-0.6344456672668457,
-0.4775611162185669,
-0.4504648745059967,
-0.2893398404121399,
-0.44030338525772095,
-0.46692898869514465,
0.3915610909461975,
-0.3770482838153839,
-0.19978022575378418,
-0.040729034692049026,
-0.5001099109649658,
0.5877507925033569,
0.17415256798267365,
-0.07848558574914932,
0.5383071303367615,
0.164636492729187,
-0.03396956995129585,
-0.16083180904388428,
-0.09246920794248581,
-0.7157105803489685,
0.762905478477478,
0.1846417486667633,
0.7422044277191162,
0.10640139132738113,
0.2653864920139313,
0.386294960975647,
-0.12862324714660645,
-1.1412125825881958,
0.6026731729507446,
-0.06710012257099152,
-0.6748595237731934,
-0.15192897617816925,
-0.4339010417461395,
-0.911812961101532,
0.6420994400978088,
-0.19422009587287903,
-0.5622371435165405,
0.03469986468553543,
0.08673439174890518,
0.08313421905040741,
0.3052096664905548,
-0.5267803072929382,
0.818559467792511,
-0.06611506640911102,
0.21674266457557678,
-0.23699237406253815,
-0.6126375198364258,
0.43548160791397095,
-0.18939800560474396,
0.5043245553970337,
-0.02077607624232769,
-0.03251780942082405,
0.8027037382125854,
-0.11922338604927063,
0.664679229259491,
-0.1432139277458191,
-0.015399044379591942,
0.16632381081581116,
-0.029550302773714066,
0.41578051447868347,
-0.10068028420209885,
-0.027064917609095573,
0.19004839658737183,
-0.12412533909082413,
-0.37615400552749634,
-0.4470560848712921,
0.5754641890525818,
-0.6998351216316223,
-0.3070211708545685,
-0.5220021605491638,
-0.6609158515930176,
-0.15566611289978027,
0.3104272186756134,
0.3162839710712433,
0.4468492269515991,
-0.3128442168235779,
0.29539069533348083,
0.8383095264434814,
-0.2801590859889984,
0.04914240539073944,
0.2621760666370392,
-0.454087495803833,
-0.4635300934314728,
0.8446221947669983,
0.25829073786735535,
-0.10432521998882294,
0.546230673789978,
-0.049300018697977066,
-0.3991987705230713,
-0.611716091632843,
-0.30684733390808105,
0.5723018050193787,
-1.136628270149231,
0.008592500351369381,
-1.3087440729141235,
-0.308932900428772,
-0.3494184613227844,
-0.2534927427768707,
-0.15150773525238037,
-0.4725366532802582,
0.06051681563258171,
-0.3720540702342987,
0.48207923769950867,
0.8380026817321777,
-0.023051975294947624,
0.1953597217798233,
-0.6069267988204956,
0.4052899181842804,
-0.024477260187268257,
0.15982912480831146,
-0.06771422177553177,
-0.21380676329135895,
-0.2421409785747528,
-0.040934666991233826,
0.022259194403886795,
-0.8444393277168274,
0.40024328231811523,
0.16184453666210175,
0.6504844427108765,
0.3667617738246918,
-0.012727219611406326,
0.6314898133277893,
-0.4944504499435425,
0.638876736164093,
0.11256677657365799,
-0.7296327352523804,
0.35648033022880554,
-0.19794520735740662,
0.2825852036476135,
0.5146229863166809,
0.6468827724456787,
-0.9310286045074463,
-0.608526885509491,
-0.22304324805736542,
-0.9402570724487305,
0.2594456374645233,
-0.035275936126708984,
0.2862112522125244,
-0.3035835325717926,
0.2482423335313797,
0.22532294690608978,
0.28026071190834045,
-0.8285447955131531,
-0.4625170826911926,
-0.17474855482578278,
-0.2920112609863281,
-0.18869741261005402,
-0.3370181918144226,
-0.2041633576154709,
0.0018822040874511003,
0.5037923455238342,
-0.09583259373903275,
0.3516673147678375,
0.043181728571653366,
-0.3650950789451599,
-0.10758670419454575,
0.3963478207588196,
0.25311169028282166,
0.6376074552536011,
-0.16212011873722076,
0.7312333583831787,
0.09307199716567993,
-0.6845129132270813,
0.180821493268013,
0.17324255406856537,
-0.04404749721288681,
0.1618008017539978,
0.3685966432094574,
0.7385131120681763,
0.23143798112869263,
-0.9790258407592773,
0.18800756335258484,
0.0921400785446167,
-0.32503747940063477,
-0.7260298132896423,
-0.26484414935112,
0.05170995369553566,
0.013539345003664494,
0.6026091575622559,
-0.19557328522205353,
0.4196135699748993,
-0.3644309937953949,
0.48705458641052246,
0.35184285044670105,
-0.5223648548126221,
-0.48698580265045166,
0.6318133473396301,
-0.23918889462947845,
0.15023799240589142,
0.7244377136230469,
-0.25948959589004517,
-0.47027185559272766,
0.2710857689380646,
0.5513566732406616,
0.7013331055641174,
0.08863263577222824,
0.05501546710729599,
0.4380510747432709,
0.45539596676826477,
0.0933518186211586,
0.47939133644104004,
0.21762138605117798,
-0.8362911343574524,
-0.5693057179450989,
-0.8716083765029907,
-0.38544100522994995,
0.1766168475151062,
-0.49977484345436096,
0.3874325156211853,
-0.2719274163246155,
0.13384146988391876,
0.29302701354026794,
-0.20036271214485168,
-0.2535569667816162,
0.014851436018943787,
0.2725944519042969,
0.7023798227310181,
-1.0925737619400024,
0.44527092576026917,
0.9974437355995178,
-0.4811967611312866,
-0.482374906539917,
-0.33997467160224915,
0.16570651531219482,
-0.9455472230911255,
0.5935590863227844,
0.366304486989975,
-0.10648752748966217,
-0.07602281868457794,
-0.34671536087989807,
-0.8483019471168518,
0.7436448335647583,
0.35513174533843994,
-0.27722081542015076,
-0.11511602997779846,
0.38633692264556885,
0.5284359455108643,
-0.5217127799987793,
-0.0548127256333828,
0.5205532312393188,
0.5178349018096924,
0.3885018229484558,
-0.41347697377204895,
0.4041233956813812,
-0.46438437700271606,
-0.18020203709602356,
0.595365047454834,
-0.18019160628318787,
0.805250346660614,
-0.10297679901123047,
-0.3341265022754669,
-0.2671663761138916,
0.7168461084365845,
0.5450677871704102,
0.19738169014453888,
0.34931379556655884,
0.44260627031326294,
0.8832418918609619,
-0.0985526293516159,
0.9774768948554993,
-0.35194307565689087,
-0.0048665557987987995,
0.7244399785995483,
0.0009787841700017452,
0.6483405232429504,
0.5934608578681946,
-0.04561011493206024,
0.485453337430954,
0.6158686280250549,
-0.07770749181509018,
0.32991793751716614,
0.3921433091163635,
-0.5064160227775574,
-0.1530129462480545,
-0.31807228922843933,
-0.5320731997489929,
0.12239561229944229,
0.7505022287368774,
-0.2869971990585327,
-0.2858508825302124,
0.2573678493499756,
0.16614462435245514,
0.018142856657505035,
-0.10874094814062119,
0.6706584692001343,
0.17932389676570892,
-0.37960395216941833,
0.6886557936668396,
-0.272120863199234,
0.593889057636261,
-0.5673254132270813,
-0.18821702897548676,
-0.010852172039449215,
0.1441762000322342,
-0.41634583473205566,
-0.8324248790740967,
0.6194954514503479,
-0.10055050998926163,
-0.24674278497695923,
0.05191302299499512,
0.6336939930915833,
-0.3723026514053345,
-0.5196519494056702,
0.6087303757667542,
0.6069210171699524,
0.5550223588943481,
-0.15178672969341278,
-0.44777652621269226,
0.23467743396759033,
-0.20170839130878448,
-0.18288256227970123,
0.1751190721988678,
0.7615789175033569,
-0.16043122112751007,
0.6686509847640991,
0.34301647543907166,
0.12659816443920135,
0.3467760384082794,
0.16788959503173828,
0.9246672987937927,
-0.9756504893302917,
-0.2877388000488281,
-0.7405012845993042,
0.43654635548591614,
0.020428011193871498,
-0.09776967018842697,
0.7541677355766296,
0.9178667664527893,
0.8637884855270386,
-0.060007527470588684,
1.2828959226608276,
-0.33698880672454834,
0.38258659839630127,
-0.4890749752521515,
0.5074431896209717,
-0.3795216977596283,
0.10833016037940979,
-0.1969340294599533,
-1.0455355644226074,
-0.7055507898330688,
0.8732509016990662,
-0.14668717980384827,
-0.14979925751686096,
0.7522935271263123,
0.7501654028892517,
-0.1091977208852768,
0.2515486776828766,
0.3996939957141876,
0.39304831624031067,
0.21621587872505188,
0.3158775269985199,
1.0541349649429321,
-0.3061041831970215,
0.6279829740524292,
-0.10905345529317856,
-0.27358609437942505,
0.03420719504356384,
-0.5172342658042908,
-0.8500077128410339,
-0.6861145496368408,
-0.35925549268722534,
-0.6031793355941772,
-0.06479333341121674,
0.9844072461128235,
0.26443541049957275,
-1.171759843826294,
-0.508963942527771,
-0.0932450070977211,
0.04617366939783096,
-0.058467503637075424,
-0.2005787044763565,
0.3411342203617096,
-0.6662391424179077,
-0.5096535682678223,
0.36737799644470215,
0.20062391459941864,
0.16100792586803436,
-0.2793865501880646,
-0.1670016497373581,
-0.09920036792755127,
-0.22518187761306763,
0.7974204421043396,
0.29471391439437866,
-0.5701333284378052,
-0.46219632029533386,
0.20307688415050507,
0.13315646350383759,
0.16522203385829926,
0.8569827079772949,
-0.5010385513305664,
0.398684024810791,
0.4246048033237457,
0.612072765827179,
0.4460953176021576,
-0.2380760908126831,
0.546593189239502,
-0.7581549286842346,
0.1649073362350464,
0.17434652149677277,
0.5300197005271912,
0.4320608377456665,
-0.16966605186462402,
0.656396210193634,
0.28829383850097656,
-0.4280373752117157,
-0.8877810835838318,
0.2541329562664032,
-1.0334100723266602,
-0.3849906325340271,
1.2239868640899658,
0.2552300691604614,
-0.1753084808588028,
-0.7478824853897095,
-0.145015150308609,
0.09731923788785934,
-0.3905608355998993,
0.7946165800094604,
0.9880620837211609,
-0.326365202665329,
-0.16197924315929413,
-0.7231168150901794,
0.2413710653781891,
-0.049557410180568695,
-0.6514201164245605,
0.36679330468177795,
0.9472338557243347,
-0.08369912207126617,
0.6435461044311523,
0.7009221315383911,
-0.4277955889701843,
-0.03545509651303291,
0.09498118609189987,
0.2332499921321869,
0.06480662524700165,
-0.30198580026626587,
-0.2926538586616516,
0.41506797075271606,
0.09607569128274918,
0.007272593677043915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19266v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19266v2
|
PediatricsGPT: Large Language Models as Chinese Medical Assistants for Pediatric Applications
| 2024-05-29T16:59:38 | 2024-06-03T15:27:10 |
Dingkang Yang, Jinjie Wei, Dongling Xiao, Shunli Wang, Tong Wu, Gang Li, Mingcheng Li, Shuaibing Wang, Jiawei Chen, Yue Jiang, Qingyao Xu, Ke Li, Peng Zhai, Lihua Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Developing intelligent pediatric consultation systems offers promising
prospects for improving diagnostic efficiency, especially in China, where
healthcare resources are scarce. Despite recent advances in Large Language
Models (LLMs) for Chinese medicine, their performance is sub-optimal in
pediatric applications due to inadequate instruction data and vulnerable
training procedures. To address the above issues, this paper builds PedCorpus,
a high-quality dataset of over 300,000 multi-task instructions from pediatric
textbooks, guidelines, and knowledge graph resources to fulfil diverse
diagnostic demands. Upon well-designed PedCorpus, we propose PediatricsGPT, the
first Chinese pediatric LLM assistant built on a systematic and robust training
pipeline. In the continuous pre-training phase, we introduce a hybrid
instruction pre-training mechanism to mitigate the internal-injected knowledge
inconsistency of LLMs for medical domain adaptation. Immediately, the
full-parameter Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) is utilized to incorporate the
general medical knowledge schema into the models. After that, we devise a
direct following preference optimization to enhance the generation of
pediatrician-like humanistic responses. In the parameter-efficient secondary
SFT phase, a mixture of universal-specific experts strategy is presented to
resolve the competency conflict between medical generalist and pediatric
expertise mastery. Extensive results based on the metrics, GPT-4, and doctor
evaluations on distinct doctor downstream tasks show that PediatricsGPT
consistently outperforms previous Chinese medical LLMs. Our model and dataset
will be open-source for community development.
|
[
-0.3104955852031708,
-0.265290766954422,
0.39115971326828003,
0.24828007817268372,
-0.3173117935657501,
0.00848180241882801,
-0.38307711482048035,
-0.37069374322891235,
-0.09816774725914001,
0.2867576777935028,
-0.5126187205314636,
-0.18642057478427887,
-0.5488768219947815,
-0.04301869869232178,
0.07081903517246246,
1.0124422311782837,
0.14173923432826996,
0.29025551676750183,
-0.01770710200071335,
0.2878086268901825,
0.1524658501148224,
-0.49389657378196716,
-1.1370056867599487,
-0.29050540924072266,
0.3544212579727173,
0.27279970049858093,
0.46132200956344604,
0.6007474064826965,
0.42377641797065735,
0.15614505112171173,
-0.11425059288740158,
0.39612284302711487,
-0.35759177803993225,
-0.23411057889461517,
-0.3234129846096039,
0.04079284518957138,
-0.7995969653129578,
-0.09101909399032593,
0.3384894132614136,
0.888806164264679,
-0.14759355783462524,
-0.17973974347114563,
0.30345815420150757,
0.32722100615501404,
-0.34025371074676514,
0.2641969621181488,
-0.5523320436477661,
0.21295227110385895,
-0.031462278217077255,
-0.10993175953626633,
-0.3001095950603485,
-0.11222752928733826,
0.5712754130363464,
-0.7270001173019409,
0.3886709213256836,
-0.16216826438903809,
0.644521176815033,
0.20078377425670624,
-0.36823245882987976,
-0.034806862473487854,
-0.4220786690711975,
0.7216424345970154,
-0.8725218176841736,
0.17704567313194275,
0.20204608142375946,
0.15995045006275177,
-0.24919603765010834,
-0.8156893253326416,
-0.45991119742393494,
-0.5273947715759277,
-0.005572890862822533,
0.19198638200759888,
0.3531769812107086,
0.4202739894390106,
0.09026504307985306,
0.27396470308303833,
-0.7459904551506042,
0.4218617379665375,
-0.12484656274318695,
-0.2076844573020935,
0.6064656376838684,
0.2638578712940216,
0.5094541311264038,
0.03229077532887459,
-0.2712751626968384,
0.1376916766166687,
-0.7716278433799744,
0.07724311202764511,
-0.1538022756576538,
0.2716841697692871,
-0.2030971348285675,
0.2667786478996277,
-0.2278415858745575,
0.7412493228912354,
0.3901938199996948,
-0.49314606189727783,
-0.15283875167369843,
-0.4137212038040161,
-0.2579494118690491,
-0.16330119967460632,
0.8504178524017334,
0.10064618289470673,
0.336274653673172,
0.04612170159816742,
-0.13033053278923035,
-0.21656708419322968,
0.21806225180625916,
-0.4922851622104645,
-0.6297898888587952,
0.10382676124572754,
-0.555367648601532,
-0.3716999292373657,
-0.10983899235725403,
-0.6231470704078674,
-0.6412909626960754,
-0.5028654932975769,
-0.07617921382188797,
-0.4227478802204132,
-0.3355311453342438,
0.12756793200969696,
0.49558746814727783,
0.026250500231981277,
0.37229204177856445,
-1.4283229112625122,
0.35158854722976685,
0.8316406011581421,
0.47355353832244873,
-0.344673752784729,
-0.30433061718940735,
-0.27278706431388855,
0.26554158329963684,
-0.23883408308029175,
0.8662576079368591,
-0.3121962249279022,
-0.5144867300987244,
-0.24337294697761536,
0.12940560281276703,
-0.32743120193481445,
-0.6991971731185913,
0.58868408203125,
-0.04387087747454643,
0.2291254848241806,
-0.040586069226264954,
-0.28702688217163086,
0.25992316007614136,
0.26760610938072205,
-0.1577504277229309,
0.5354737639427185,
0.32847899198532104,
-0.6271929740905762,
0.624813973903656,
-0.5605974793434143,
-0.506558895111084,
0.20252878963947296,
-0.0924883484840393,
-0.23498915135860443,
-0.14126886427402496,
0.7054414749145508,
0.5364713072776794,
-0.46380484104156494,
0.3437753915786743,
-0.14742514491081238,
-0.12308052182197571,
-0.41867825388908386,
-0.3355754315853119,
0.8978390693664551,
-0.05589728802442551,
-0.013428471982479095,
0.20042546093463898,
-0.47114330530166626,
-0.09214824438095093,
0.2817893624305725,
-0.39638814330101013,
-0.26148170232772827,
-0.04551476985216141,
-0.14321152865886688,
0.19352088868618011,
0.40762752294540405,
-0.34444594383239746,
0.4406594932079315,
-0.456694632768631,
0.26490843296051025,
0.7339881658554077,
0.011834069155156612,
0.25034940242767334,
-0.3809013366699219,
0.5995087623596191,
-0.14658890664577484,
0.6313550472259521,
-0.23706892132759094,
-0.5833387970924377,
-0.5439701676368713,
-0.2879180312156677,
0.10721755772829056,
0.3944968581199646,
-0.8386279940605164,
0.43699249625205994,
-0.18683688342571259,
-0.5561141967773438,
-0.1981792449951172,
-0.07469065487384796,
0.4079654812812805,
1.0382994413375854,
0.2664638161659241,
-0.2162502110004425,
-0.44660717248916626,
-0.7668875455856323,
0.21530736982822418,
-0.28412994742393494,
-0.27273866534233093,
0.5168458819389343,
0.00789277721196413,
-0.08120942860841751,
0.2901237905025482,
-0.4034262001514435,
-0.2876262068748474,
-0.26711106300354004,
-0.23697088658809662,
0.49318987131118774,
0.5455974340438843,
0.671792209148407,
-0.5733716487884521,
-0.7210514545440674,
0.405129611492157,
-0.4982103705406189,
-0.3009988069534302,
-0.13060306012630463,
0.0688176080584526,
0.13250242173671722,
0.12306172400712967,
-0.5357753038406372,
-0.06400561332702637,
0.7361263632774353,
-0.12515825033187866,
0.8676117658615112,
-0.3197038769721985,
0.13021278381347656,
-0.8222222924232483,
0.23348620533943176,
0.08194006234407425,
0.10407271236181259,
-0.5296316742897034,
0.1941666603088379,
0.13459786772727966,
-0.14663882553577423,
-0.5142742991447449,
0.5624511241912842,
-0.28868138790130615,
0.28437310457229614,
-0.12117328494787216,
-0.041110191494226456,
-0.25395825505256653,
0.41502711176872253,
0.3057900667190552,
0.7491428256034851,
0.6407400369644165,
-0.6335276365280151,
0.7164362668991089,
0.0704350620508194,
0.1607019305229187,
0.6948989033699036,
-0.701442539691925,
0.14380136132240295,
0.25839850306510925,
0.3284625709056854,
-0.5606026649475098,
-0.3656638264656067,
0.25865790247917175,
-0.21325622498989105,
0.532304584980011,
-0.29227471351623535,
-0.5394318103790283,
-0.6834433078765869,
-0.08916789293289185,
0.23569715023040771,
0.34795087575912476,
-0.7592715620994568,
0.22002939879894257,
0.5102922916412354,
-0.6383014917373657,
-0.4960004687309265,
-0.13488347828388214,
0.040006525814533234,
0.12171915173530579,
-0.572009265422821,
0.3877221345901489,
0.10899948328733444,
0.2858083248138428,
-0.14310331642627716,
-0.15226155519485474,
-0.48760315775871277,
-0.25549620389938354,
-0.21459098160266876,
0.5644895434379578,
-0.40343090891838074,
0.046285782009363174,
0.5064253211021423,
-0.3488118648529053,
-0.11019320040941238,
-0.2906304597854614,
0.6911605000495911,
0.1239389181137085,
-0.5562016367912292,
-0.3061981797218323,
-0.04963294044137001,
0.44442427158355713,
-0.03844596445560455,
0.28939592838287354,
0.24107018113136292,
-0.4825555980205536,
-0.22926566004753113,
-0.15811927616596222,
-0.08375740796327591,
-0.47560548782348633,
0.5568093657493591,
-0.085792176425457,
-0.43522387742996216,
0.11463437974452972,
-0.15985268354415894,
0.3093080520629883,
0.2549222409725189,
0.5252599716186523,
0.09919078648090363,
1.156747817993164,
0.35615289211273193,
-0.20366445183753967,
0.1332840472459793,
-0.02345968224108219,
0.006277394015341997,
-0.8500077724456787,
-0.2822458744049072,
-0.17807117104530334,
0.05419743433594704,
-0.06846506893634796,
-0.42810067534446716,
0.6001536250114441,
-0.32213589549064636,
-0.42878153920173645,
0.22649811208248138,
-0.9770128130912781,
0.3875223994255066,
0.39977267384529114,
0.1483728587627411,
0.2963763177394867,
-0.22635824978351593,
-0.2518620491027832,
-0.42065486311912537,
-0.8442458510398865,
-0.3814769685268402,
1.1408029794692993,
0.25388044118881226,
0.9111357927322388,
-0.23895561695098877,
0.39294180274009705,
-0.21714092791080475,
0.37501946091651917,
-0.7581483721733093,
0.5377792716026306,
-0.7963853478431702,
-0.3631910979747772,
-0.12782889604568481,
-0.06367143988609314,
-0.8417747616767883,
0.33266735076904297,
-0.2205512821674347,
-0.595763087272644,
-0.1459684520959854,
0.2008867710828781,
-0.5061107277870178,
0.23103244602680206,
-0.6276390552520752,
0.7587304711341858,
-0.507352352142334,
-0.18127916753292084,
-0.09677939116954803,
-0.5660319924354553,
0.724853515625,
-0.43531692028045654,
-0.2869192361831665,
0.1981106698513031,
-0.2079545259475708,
0.3333519399166107,
-0.36041170358657837,
0.7184461951255798,
-0.28575244545936584,
-0.13425028324127197,
-0.20409072935581207,
-0.2325141280889511,
0.3443516194820404,
0.16475030779838562,
0.08633356541395187,
-0.1042027696967125,
0.22372408211231232,
-0.4040251076221466,
-0.3734286427497864,
0.7982164621353149,
-0.6982451677322388,
-0.6436058878898621,
-0.31374189257621765,
-0.38454481959342957,
-0.5936170220375061,
0.3356497883796692,
0.20281706750392914,
0.24998077750205994,
-0.16832102835178375,
-0.025406857952475548,
0.7974076271057129,
-0.6515765190124512,
0.09494579583406448,
0.3748493790626526,
-0.1372578889131546,
-0.18797540664672852,
0.8134598731994629,
-0.09078274667263031,
0.2137085348367691,
0.20229460299015045,
0.264570951461792,
-0.2471523880958557,
-0.6518149375915527,
-0.5805529356002808,
0.43951547145843506,
-0.38317787647247314,
0.08510461449623108,
-0.48744887113571167,
-0.6121957302093506,
-0.6565650105476379,
-0.3456933796405792,
-0.2916145324707031,
-0.16652677953243256,
-0.4799674451351166,
0.3049425482749939,
-0.2518422603607178,
0.3845822513103485,
-0.021370580419898033,
0.21352645754814148,
-0.7517053484916687,
0.5379483103752136,
0.5093126893043518,
0.26792171597480774,
0.21369017660617828,
-0.560623049736023,
-0.20270825922489166,
-0.0029838802292943,
-0.4215788245201111,
-0.35191839933395386,
0.393619179725647,
0.20462216436862946,
0.7701780200004578,
0.8807054758071899,
0.024525878950953484,
0.7884052991867065,
-0.4070214331150055,
0.9258006811141968,
0.13673050701618195,
-0.6255797147750854,
0.472430020570755,
-0.5319725275039673,
0.15880721807479858,
0.10465960204601288,
0.24430707097053528,
-0.509992241859436,
-0.07788469642400742,
-0.5031388998031616,
-0.7077361941337585,
0.8176254630088806,
-0.5292026996612549,
0.11803139001131058,
0.31865689158439636,
0.2732720971107483,
0.25080615282058716,
-0.02740698680281639,
-0.31194165349006653,
0.07940363883972168,
-0.15803885459899902,
-0.3702532649040222,
0.11109054088592529,
-0.014635255560278893,
-0.25387611985206604,
-0.5447273254394531,
0.6012340188026428,
-0.2491941601037979,
0.17580711841583252,
0.011036385782063007,
0.3266477882862091,
-0.04429781436920166,
-0.12339518964290619,
0.5479675531387329,
0.6751489639282227,
0.3017563819885254,
-0.18856212496757507,
0.2693508565425873,
-0.826675534248352,
0.043033625930547714,
0.38577908277511597,
0.015223593451082706,
-0.15586313605308533,
0.5460376143455505,
0.2696811556816101,
0.13955122232437134,
-0.8339993357658386,
0.5357012748718262,
0.00019426083599682897,
-0.1145496740937233,
-0.1976594775915146,
0.2589099407196045,
0.1620275378227234,
-0.04475002735853195,
0.3604453504085541,
-0.2823455333709717,
-0.027824731543660164,
-0.11191941797733307,
0.3299086391925812,
0.21412056684494019,
-0.1807546317577362,
-0.32725638151168823,
0.8123106360435486,
0.3198012411594391,
0.07003103196620941,
0.4479551315307617,
0.14741037786006927,
-0.3698851466178894,
0.7602354884147644,
0.4850279986858368,
0.4407816231250763,
-0.4320252239704132,
0.3310677409172058,
0.2780480980873108,
0.14436785876750946,
-0.16690054535865784,
0.010530900210142136,
0.01308444980531931,
-0.5515726804733276,
-0.6092548966407776,
-0.17896386981010437,
-0.6335495114326477,
0.3602334260940552,
-0.3570767045021057,
0.426506906747818,
-0.9941546320915222,
0.08329586684703827,
-0.13205157220363617,
0.1253330409526825,
-0.4338000416755676,
0.34446239471435547,
0.22286756336688995,
0.8448623418807983,
-0.4112531542778015,
1.0237594842910767,
0.8834816217422485,
-0.26888012886047363,
-0.9428064227104187,
0.09657038748264313,
0.0003529324021656066,
-1.1090973615646362,
0.5095908045768738,
-0.36336028575897217,
0.31607624888420105,
-0.04012471064925194,
-0.5953601598739624,
-0.5495352745056152,
0.7944093942642212,
0.3026629686355591,
-0.4818408787250519,
-0.37928521633148193,
0.023253068327903748,
0.7741867303848267,
-0.30337631702423096,
-0.025812242180109024,
0.5363684892654419,
0.2553950846195221,
0.09648211300373077,
-1.4079188108444214,
0.13930219411849976,
-0.14072038233280182,
-0.18701860308647156,
-0.13746748864650726,
-0.723966658115387,
0.8802709579467773,
-0.38788050413131714,
0.020072776824235916,
0.26209285855293274,
0.11993288993835449,
0.6210249066352844,
0.18604055047035217,
0.3630722463130951,
0.28351202607154846,
0.5766788721084595,
-0.08545713126659393,
0.9514474868774414,
-0.5053157806396484,
0.23174519836902618,
0.8686845302581787,
-0.16194695234298706,
0.32393306493759155,
0.3768516182899475,
-0.46967756748199463,
-0.007078163325786591,
0.8699113130569458,
-0.007920989766716957,
0.5837095975875854,
-0.012938461266458035,
-0.545610785484314,
-0.12572063505649567,
-0.3565290868282318,
-0.5073131322860718,
0.015245545655488968,
0.6291354894638062,
-0.4566664397716522,
-0.03327493369579315,
-0.24591335654258728,
0.1010519340634346,
-0.05154073238372803,
-0.3452600836753845,
0.7518013119697571,
0.233446404337883,
-0.6208189129829407,
0.7165181040763855,
-0.26462650299072266,
0.7593125104904175,
-0.6722038984298706,
0.05393778905272484,
-0.14193382859230042,
0.1444723755121231,
-0.2504437267780304,
-0.6762333512306213,
-0.0670202299952507,
-0.12493985146284103,
0.09343913942575455,
-0.008671271614730358,
0.6495421528816223,
-0.31201544404029846,
-0.2528388202190399,
-0.0915508046746254,
0.3393493592739105,
-0.033125173300504684,
0.1709633618593216,
-0.9077911972999573,
-0.4651053547859192,
-0.035177744925022125,
-0.1434575766324997,
0.5081912875175476,
0.48516035079956055,
-0.008993702940642834,
0.7431140542030334,
0.8877337574958801,
0.7745508551597595,
-0.03753923997282982,
0.08756504207849503,
1.0790389776229858,
-0.18185478448867798,
-0.40052375197410583,
-0.4363546073436737,
0.23744960129261017,
-0.08713710308074951,
-0.4647490382194519,
0.26186496019363403,
0.06175466254353523,
0.5811995267868042,
-0.17348149418830872,
0.9745310544967651,
-0.04580476135015488,
0.7125402092933655,
-0.21703846752643585,
0.8519195914268494,
-0.47873997688293457,
0.042316094040870667,
-0.3072940409183502,
-0.6027204394340515,
-0.6243780851364136,
0.571853756904602,
-0.31317901611328125,
0.057242512702941895,
0.5042200684547424,
0.5177589654922485,
-0.25342994928359985,
-0.1719677597284317,
0.3969744145870209,
0.03376222774386406,
0.5969971418380737,
1.0000662803649902,
0.7017949223518372,
0.1105007454752922,
0.4897739887237549,
-0.405312180519104,
-0.4216535985469818,
-0.18692833185195923,
-0.5338550209999084,
-0.8322359323501587,
-0.15748003125190735,
0.06354029476642609,
0.007654848974198103,
0.03973870724439621,
0.9686359763145447,
0.8826132416725159,
-0.8186046481132507,
0.1389581710100174,
0.044622693210840225,
-0.14942456781864166,
-0.2661649286746979,
-0.19654743373394012,
0.6734763979911804,
-0.22739237546920776,
-0.9790797829627991,
0.3253822922706604,
0.2877058684825897,
0.17297780513763428,
-0.4507625997066498,
-0.026387343183159828,
0.36551201343536377,
-0.28066909313201904,
0.4808253049850464,
0.6106210947036743,
-0.6656767725944519,
-0.11023607105016708,
0.08873658627271652,
-0.2491350769996643,
-0.09358225017786026,
0.7162673473358154,
-0.6120585799217224,
0.566091001033783,
0.3348410129547119,
0.692093551158905,
0.056149717420339584,
0.053746819496154785,
0.7468589544296265,
-0.2121257185935974,
0.3678641617298126,
0.5303188562393188,
0.37080445885658264,
0.2956717610359192,
-0.47738415002822876,
0.48923230171203613,
0.3281824290752411,
-0.6590865254402161,
-0.6591429114341736,
0.10439658910036087,
-0.6899247765541077,
-0.2063210904598236,
1.0078974962234497,
-0.4148624837398529,
0.1267075091600418,
-0.4549046456813812,
-0.7521331310272217,
0.14429320394992828,
-0.41025611758232117,
1.0045835971832275,
0.43095627427101135,
-0.5361079573631287,
-0.2833258807659149,
-0.2749916911125183,
0.4403371214866638,
0.34945148229599,
-0.8160895109176636,
-0.15204378962516785,
0.2715756893157959,
0.18660835921764374,
-0.21576817333698273,
0.8280342221260071,
-0.23560744524002075,
0.437704473733902,
0.06204245612025261,
-0.0632195919752121,
-0.09717640280723572,
-0.15657776594161987,
-0.0935533195734024,
-0.09322604537010193,
0.11932430416345596,
-0.09538787603378296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19265v1
|
AlchemistCoder: Harmonizing and Eliciting Code Capability by Hindsight Tuning on Multi-source Data
| 2024-05-29T16:57:33 | 2024-05-29T16:57:33 |
Zifan Song, Yudong Wang, Wenwei Zhang, Kuikun Liu, Chengqi Lyu, Demin Song, Qipeng Guo, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen, Cairong Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open-source Large Language Models (LLMs) and their specialized variants,
particularly Code LLMs, have recently delivered impressive performance.
However, previous Code LLMs are typically fine-tuned on single-source data with
limited quality and diversity, which may insufficiently elicit the potential of
pre-trained Code LLMs. In this paper, we present AlchemistCoder, a series of
Code LLMs with enhanced code generation and generalization capabilities
fine-tuned on multi-source data. To achieve this, we pioneer to unveil inherent
conflicts among the various styles and qualities in multi-source code corpora
and introduce data-specific prompts with hindsight relabeling, termed
AlchemistPrompts, to harmonize different data sources and instruction-response
pairs. Additionally, we propose incorporating the data construction process
into the fine-tuning data as code comprehension tasks, including instruction
evolution, data filtering, and code review. Extensive experiments demonstrate
that AlchemistCoder holds a clear lead among all models of the same size
(6.7B/7B) and rivals or even surpasses larger models (15B/33B/70B), showcasing
the efficacy of our method in refining instruction-following capabilities and
advancing the boundaries of code intelligence.
|
[
-0.4497435986995697,
-0.5047120451927185,
0.3965693712234497,
0.11571051925420761,
-0.19613508880138397,
0.22791890799999237,
-0.5747023820877075,
-0.1625443696975708,
0.12682890892028809,
0.6055874824523926,
-0.5348805785179138,
-0.8732326626777649,
-0.4471474289894104,
0.15575642883777618,
-0.44915926456451416,
1.0296906232833862,
-0.1047729104757309,
0.09088734537363052,
-0.19436120986938477,
-0.2701939344406128,
-0.5477307438850403,
-0.5301715731620789,
-0.13677161931991577,
-0.20968998968601227,
0.700188934803009,
0.7574995160102844,
0.9238846898078918,
0.9453776478767395,
0.5199553370475769,
0.2640937864780426,
0.43213364481925964,
0.20973855257034302,
-0.24338600039482117,
0.1955578476190567,
-0.15333761274814606,
-0.49885115027427673,
-0.24561943113803864,
-0.15221893787384033,
0.3463652729988098,
0.46401911973953247,
-0.19604133069515228,
0.2619362771511078,
0.1608385443687439,
0.6696013808250427,
-0.7942370176315308,
0.18321308493614197,
-0.7343984842300415,
0.020665468648076057,
0.1922379434108734,
-0.2796376049518585,
-0.42895400524139404,
-0.6021535396575928,
-0.45142099261283875,
-0.5172421932220459,
0.35798996686935425,
0.09460286796092987,
0.4195704758167267,
0.6784847378730774,
-0.2505110502243042,
-0.580807626247406,
-0.6739296317100525,
0.8097562193870544,
-0.6295753717422485,
0.5492873787879944,
0.22370223701000214,
0.1845409870147705,
0.15673960745334625,
-0.8656731247901917,
-0.5486617088317871,
-0.025886697694659233,
-0.005195810925215483,
-0.15371137857437134,
-0.12069221585988998,
-0.07526855915784836,
0.045733630657196045,
0.43947312235832214,
-0.6164308190345764,
0.06821781396865845,
-0.634371280670166,
-0.26311901211738586,
0.5152413845062256,
0.20557136833667755,
0.08479345589876175,
0.12433885037899017,
0.03310485929250717,
-0.14108890295028687,
-0.6746389865875244,
-0.3256385326385498,
0.3989008963108063,
0.4158089756965637,
0.06777036935091019,
0.5335062146186829,
-0.36931857466697693,
0.8016177415847778,
-0.2298094928264618,
0.34858956933021545,
0.3120335042476654,
-0.43828049302101135,
-0.1087123453617096,
0.13772833347320557,
0.7771454453468323,
0.2572619915008545,
0.1464872658252716,
-0.1880158632993698,
-0.06453345715999603,
0.5022305846214294,
0.41572868824005127,
-1.0677449703216553,
-0.6363577246665955,
0.5143631100654602,
-0.3478882610797882,
-0.21466423571109772,
-0.12564663589000702,
-0.9977160692214966,
-0.2717810273170471,
-0.6611539721488953,
0.11127588897943497,
-0.44227486848831177,
0.12302649766206741,
0.13887320458889008,
0.02108154445886612,
0.17082072794437408,
-0.011802630499005318,
-0.7603198289871216,
-0.1319272816181183,
0.5926654934883118,
0.7631294131278992,
-0.13946501910686493,
-0.4169573187828064,
-0.5395221710205078,
-0.04029742255806923,
-0.49185848236083984,
0.5315133929252625,
-0.6862749457359314,
-0.19997970759868622,
-0.13107137382030487,
-0.18558664619922638,
0.3112722337245941,
-0.5850046873092651,
0.6709317564964294,
-0.6695475578308105,
-0.11248016357421875,
0.028280626982450485,
-0.4346419870853424,
0.05379802733659744,
0.0971548929810524,
-0.6827362179756165,
0.5784457325935364,
-0.010613396763801575,
-0.45587852597236633,
0.3015234172344208,
-0.30117154121398926,
-0.33837905526161194,
-0.04730191454291344,
-0.491133451461792,
-0.3870791792869568,
0.11532916128635406,
0.2990388572216034,
0.2770754396915436,
-0.3801797330379486,
0.27360308170318604,
-0.2947922646999359,
-0.4234035015106201,
0.21577753126621246,
-0.30574357509613037,
0.5862777829170227,
0.4810176193714142,
0.013119728304445744,
0.5135136246681213,
-0.9470337629318237,
0.4503692090511322,
-0.21302048861980438,
-0.4164469540119171,
-0.14864888787269592,
0.06802736222743988,
-0.19153103232383728,
0.3703189790248871,
0.10528929531574249,
-0.25092461705207825,
0.18371005356311798,
-0.16308224201202393,
0.48375844955444336,
0.7518022060394287,
0.04113655537366867,
0.4071192741394043,
-0.30912595987319946,
0.5778602957725525,
-0.18815292418003082,
0.27116987109184265,
-0.31647688150405884,
-0.37958380579948425,
-0.9324074983596802,
-0.2128589153289795,
0.1977318525314331,
0.6853796243667603,
-0.8855313062667847,
0.6093777418136597,
-0.23758915066719055,
-0.599601149559021,
-0.9435043334960938,
0.5039574503898621,
0.4061313271522522,
0.21474012732505798,
0.682030975818634,
-0.21121546626091003,
-0.5395079255104065,
-0.9117000699043274,
-0.3770844340324402,
0.11955515295267105,
-0.058602817356586456,
0.06643207371234894,
0.3068428039550781,
-0.45185208320617676,
0.9376799464225769,
-0.6841207146644592,
-0.04328042268753052,
0.059446170926094055,
0.0797707587480545,
0.28292351961135864,
0.5624307990074158,
0.10248421132564545,
-0.6909613013267517,
-0.4342997670173645,
0.008744999766349792,
-0.7047883868217468,
-0.1300143301486969,
0.15169194340705872,
-0.30453166365623474,
0.06857063621282578,
0.8403677344322205,
-0.2099420130252838,
0.08830364048480988,
0.8451146483421326,
-0.19619224965572357,
0.4966917335987091,
-0.09956060349941254,
0.37513020634651184,
-0.9444608092308044,
0.020870601758360863,
-0.33246082067489624,
0.2969224452972412,
-0.6216036081314087,
0.5633419752120972,
0.41134411096572876,
-0.2839173972606659,
-0.497347891330719,
0.3345414698123932,
-0.4738617539405823,
0.14902618527412415,
-0.3794034719467163,
-0.23079325258731842,
-0.025563102215528488,
0.6857041716575623,
-0.09731458127498627,
0.8034026622772217,
0.5551308989524841,
-0.6730174422264099,
0.6242910623550415,
0.18799500167369843,
-0.5074319839477539,
0.3189031481742859,
-0.5140074491500854,
0.4328842759132385,
0.006127187982201576,
-0.168223038315773,
-0.7174711227416992,
-0.36857667565345764,
0.1917450875043869,
-0.34192875027656555,
0.08189226686954498,
-0.1475137323141098,
-0.6190569996833801,
-0.2277999222278595,
-0.24030320346355438,
0.45118772983551025,
0.5051373839378357,
-0.6234732270240784,
0.7607530355453491,
-0.37920212745666504,
-0.31669220328330994,
-0.673569917678833,
-0.8513576984405518,
0.011019784957170486,
-0.13446341454982758,
-0.4811451733112335,
0.1975780576467514,
-0.5095170736312866,
-0.24688297510147095,
0.11792591959238052,
-0.044339656829833984,
-0.07915172725915909,
-0.2019791305065155,
0.26758334040641785,
0.3365475833415985,
-0.058468062430620193,
0.09330307692289352,
0.30858471989631653,
0.003136450657621026,
0.005828952416777611,
-0.42434924840927124,
0.5498301386833191,
0.005909122060984373,
-0.58451908826828,
0.03654512017965317,
0.25746533274650574,
0.41739365458488464,
-0.5431845188140869,
0.6472376585006714,
0.44593915343284607,
-0.0973598062992096,
-0.4154820144176483,
-0.4238981604576111,
-0.19544735550880432,
-0.5503103733062744,
0.4187960624694824,
-0.3128761351108551,
-0.9963819980621338,
0.6182621121406555,
0.06275911629199982,
0.16594824194908142,
0.06909161806106567,
0.6562802195549011,
0.49063029885292053,
0.8613057732582092,
0.48881497979164124,
-0.14520485699176788,
0.39989814162254333,
-0.005147852469235659,
0.10825586318969727,
-0.5928996205329895,
-0.2272975891828537,
-0.5999826192855835,
-0.2256789654493332,
-0.5040112137794495,
-0.5058895349502563,
0.2417636215686798,
0.19007937610149384,
-0.4032261073589325,
0.1768554002046585,
-0.7423366904258728,
0.8897765874862671,
0.6299941539764404,
0.19103461503982544,
0.6214672923088074,
0.04160638526082039,
0.15753430128097534,
0.11030617356300354,
-0.675960898399353,
-0.2255455106496811,
1.270616054534912,
0.07075519859790802,
1.0131417512893677,
0.11266223341226578,
0.841697096824646,
0.2641189396381378,
0.3751838803291321,
-0.7132234573364258,
0.3305705487728119,
-0.1701052188873291,
-0.5296176671981812,
0.10538050532341003,
-0.6853213310241699,
-0.7495847940444946,
0.14250785112380981,
-0.08500209450721741,
-0.17446161806583405,
0.5237123370170593,
0.2104572206735611,
-0.36351093649864197,
-0.10081682354211807,
-0.7776431441307068,
0.9567394256591797,
-0.29237043857574463,
-0.4494122862815857,
-0.2644140422344208,
-0.6643727421760559,
0.41548794507980347,
-0.3171439468860626,
0.48509928584098816,
0.11333087086677551,
-0.17145846784114838,
0.33901485800743103,
-0.15414032340049744,
0.6137939095497131,
0.11161366105079651,
-0.2535410225391388,
0.3355399966239929,
0.23593321442604065,
0.4454095959663391,
-0.07074848562479019,
-0.18924164772033691,
0.1896732598543167,
-0.4174712002277374,
-0.38746845722198486,
-0.5509899854660034,
0.8792650699615479,
-0.6159844398498535,
-0.3603697121143341,
-0.060093726962804794,
-0.6366866230964661,
-0.29132387042045593,
0.28828683495521545,
0.5099504590034485,
0.30352717638015747,
-0.08666332811117172,
0.1858895868062973,
0.6481448411941528,
-0.3984270989894867,
0.23681379854679108,
0.39021265506744385,
-0.16212673485279083,
-0.7513465285301208,
1.1138691902160645,
-0.33392247557640076,
0.4182300269603729,
0.15514707565307617,
-0.22836244106292725,
0.062258873134851456,
-0.5088220834732056,
-0.39624419808387756,
-0.11269887536764145,
-0.9768326878547668,
-0.6174456477165222,
-0.4468810558319092,
-0.1244489997625351,
-0.15707333385944366,
-0.26755020022392273,
-0.31714701652526855,
-0.15808196365833282,
-0.3351883292198181,
0.13067477941513062,
0.49257728457450867,
0.5356460809707642,
-0.0016593288164585829,
0.18594415485858917,
-0.9881657958030701,
0.32815229892730713,
0.23207694292068481,
0.5743302702903748,
-0.11243021488189697,
-0.27767109870910645,
-0.6955294013023376,
-0.017654048278927803,
-0.19760403037071228,
-0.8413375020027161,
0.2931155264377594,
0.26403746008872986,
0.3649044632911682,
0.10225838422775269,
0.11746273189783096,
0.36769726872444153,
-0.5624115467071533,
0.4786643981933594,
0.017267193645238876,
-0.9556504487991333,
0.6009426712989807,
-0.1491660475730896,
0.27333781123161316,
0.6618322730064392,
0.29323092103004456,
-0.32028910517692566,
-0.7104266285896301,
-0.22831395268440247,
-0.871405839920044,
0.6718801259994507,
0.02747746929526329,
0.10702971369028091,
0.06469710171222687,
0.5283118486404419,
0.049438443034887314,
0.4171702265739441,
-0.5233526229858398,
-0.2822490632534027,
-0.5363630652427673,
-0.5255498886108398,
-0.221781924366951,
0.2465171366930008,
-0.2344234436750412,
-0.12591668963432312,
0.5410337448120117,
-0.29148760437965393,
0.06287898868322372,
-0.09100638329982758,
-0.18244366347789764,
0.001681690919212997,
0.7225455045700073,
0.1979861557483673,
0.6707553267478943,
-0.09117300063371658,
0.0998305231332779,
-0.09342941641807556,
-0.41322022676467896,
0.3578491806983948,
0.36251166462898254,
0.03865347430109978,
-0.3455966114997864,
0.3908446133136749,
0.6573072075843811,
-0.22133146226406097,
-0.7975307703018188,
0.16079194843769073,
0.05578205734491348,
-0.10199140012264252,
0.1399645209312439,
0.5448319315910339,
-0.01952434703707695,
0.44396039843559265,
0.2818394899368286,
0.23897278308868408,
0.29483523964881897,
-0.6694585680961609,
0.2552650272846222,
0.24126999080181122,
-0.06724260002374649,
0.0761294960975647,
0.6000959873199463,
0.08920084685087204,
0.017159011214971542,
0.7992124557495117,
-0.42722979187965393,
-0.36463525891304016,
0.5615231394767761,
0.29754769802093506,
0.6606274843215942,
-0.3823646605014801,
-0.18562743067741394,
0.3177814483642578,
0.3666299879550934,
-0.02312154695391655,
0.3021727204322815,
0.09139961004257202,
-0.7848049402236938,
-0.6531118750572205,
-0.6206223964691162,
-0.3624689280986786,
-0.10409489274024963,
-0.8623256087303162,
0.3831353187561035,
-0.5916577577590942,
0.06622553616762161,
-0.20789887011051178,
-0.19058077037334442,
-0.5711305141448975,
0.03531165421009064,
-0.08041749894618988,
0.9089951515197754,
-0.7469220161437988,
0.9092862010002136,
0.4832507371902466,
-0.435514897108078,
-0.7352902889251709,
0.055218812078237534,
-0.0856473296880722,
-0.6664155721664429,
0.4721433222293854,
-0.06762316823005676,
-0.129766583442688,
0.14103840291500092,
-0.7099554538726807,
-0.6387566924095154,
0.9970595836639404,
0.7044320702552795,
-0.8176142573356628,
0.09573467075824738,
-0.13694129884243011,
0.4436253011226654,
-0.2748280465602875,
-0.1790061891078949,
0.7311628460884094,
0.2711887061595917,
-0.0018590242834761739,
-0.47417983412742615,
0.13543860614299774,
-0.3596855401992798,
-0.14873947203159332,
0.4563726782798767,
-0.5601027011871338,
0.988123893737793,
-0.3253902494907379,
-0.057542577385902405,
0.17520074546337128,
0.6394004225730896,
0.47321468591690063,
0.10602074861526489,
0.030336644500494003,
0.4298471212387085,
0.5354487299919128,
-0.08743488788604736,
0.8033706545829773,
-0.5976380705833435,
0.18203774094581604,
1.2880034446716309,
-0.25096049904823303,
0.7465758323669434,
0.25453296303749084,
0.04079928621649742,
0.7897430062294006,
0.4044026732444763,
-0.28883498907089233,
0.7416019439697266,
0.2598887085914612,
-0.18076007068157196,
-0.13240422308444977,
0.049043040722608566,
-0.5822999477386475,
0.2147175818681717,
0.3543473482131958,
-0.38160303235054016,
0.11081865429878235,
0.09816192090511322,
-0.2170952409505844,
0.12851585447788239,
-0.34010201692581177,
0.6959182024002075,
-0.1191403791308403,
-0.669314980506897,
0.6324111223220825,
0.1841004490852356,
0.8121604323387146,
-0.6474758982658386,
-0.13450784981250763,
-0.38442978262901306,
0.3936454951763153,
-0.36376479268074036,
-0.8215627074241638,
0.33606183528900146,
-0.08299800753593445,
-0.32299044728279114,
0.0984470397233963,
0.5042629837989807,
-0.6555600166320801,
-0.42729654908180237,
0.3957594931125641,
0.4077354669570923,
-0.14450980722904205,
-0.2195318639278412,
-0.5386433005332947,
0.5420988202095032,
0.1676795929670334,
0.14402137696743011,
0.1450963020324707,
0.5853167176246643,
0.21144796907901764,
0.551361083984375,
0.5870168209075928,
0.10868199169635773,
0.13225676119327545,
0.10201223194599152,
1.0748851299285889,
-0.5534061193466187,
-0.3926677405834198,
-0.884751558303833,
0.26401081681251526,
0.33433449268341064,
-0.03281991928815842,
0.757063090801239,
0.6896124482154846,
0.9391705393791199,
-0.17242687940597534,
0.807731568813324,
0.027217084541916847,
0.2538646161556244,
-0.7686779499053955,
0.5277214646339417,
-0.42520537972450256,
0.4065535068511963,
-0.15210017561912537,
-1.1266146898269653,
-0.36593782901763916,
0.4135066866874695,
0.03792591765522957,
0.2068663388490677,
0.5484117865562439,
1.0179563760757446,
-0.15025688707828522,
0.050707247108221054,
-0.14018560945987701,
0.15524128079414368,
0.1485542505979538,
0.760951578617096,
0.8849533796310425,
-0.3269438147544861,
0.8619403839111328,
-0.09647388011217117,
-0.32591187953948975,
-0.021010832861065865,
-0.6436322927474976,
-0.751397430896759,
-0.37572115659713745,
-0.17391732335090637,
-0.3876156508922577,
0.06959432363510132,
1.097457766532898,
0.5702106952667236,
-0.8872628808021545,
-0.2767368257045746,
-0.3152240216732025,
0.05956811457872391,
-0.1698506772518158,
-0.1754380762577057,
0.2484396994113922,
-0.4721878468990326,
-0.5891154408454895,
0.3721315562725067,
-0.023735135793685913,
-0.10974259674549103,
-0.2630966305732727,
-0.49876540899276733,
0.13517260551452637,
0.12674270570278168,
0.5070359110832214,
0.19041034579277039,
-0.3787047564983368,
0.061342254281044006,
0.042239632457494736,
-0.015232873149216175,
0.00026385841192677617,
1.0016179084777832,
-0.6877688765525818,
0.3698922395706177,
0.18341656029224396,
0.6268766522407532,
0.18227367103099823,
-0.03562645986676216,
0.45340895652770996,
-1.196789026260376,
0.08798619359731674,
0.25079411268234253,
0.20845425128936768,
0.3689190149307251,
-0.3072853088378906,
0.48618048429489136,
-0.15440136194229126,
-0.7456913590431213,
-0.6812229156494141,
0.38575711846351624,
-0.43350356817245483,
-0.6889760494232178,
1.089268445968628,
0.16229088604450226,
0.20638631284236908,
-0.022967493161559105,
0.012439938262104988,
0.27618175745010376,
-0.48513251543045044,
0.5642548203468323,
0.6966859102249146,
-0.3263419568538666,
-0.21081209182739258,
-0.4746354818344116,
0.5011376738548279,
0.30410414934158325,
-1.0612019300460815,
0.361875057220459,
0.9983508586883545,
0.12359774112701416,
0.37523171305656433,
0.36247819662094116,
0.019546417519450188,
0.24176405370235443,
0.14434634149074554,
0.29421693086624146,
-0.2970595061779022,
-0.766696035861969,
-0.519288957118988,
0.01688215136528015,
0.2995661497116089,
-0.030095810070633888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19262v1
|
Weak-to-Strong Search: Align Large Language Models via Searching over Small Language Models
| 2024-05-29T16:55:32 | 2024-05-29T16:55:32 |
Zhanhui Zhou, Zhixuan Liu, Jie Liu, Zhichen Dong, Chao Yang, Yu Qiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models are usually fine-tuned to align with human preferences.
However, fine-tuning a large language model can be challenging. In this work,
we introduce $\textit{weak-to-strong search}$, framing the alignment of a large
language model as a test-time greedy search to maximize the log-likelihood
difference between small tuned and untuned models while sampling from the
frozen large model. This method serves both as (i) a compute-efficient model
up-scaling strategy that avoids directly tuning the large model and as (ii) an
instance of weak-to-strong generalization that enhances a strong model with
weak test-time guidance. Empirically, we demonstrate the flexibility of
weak-to-strong search across different tasks. In controlled-sentiment
generation and summarization, we use tuned and untuned $\texttt{gpt2}$s to
effectively improve the alignment of large models without additional training.
Crucially, in a more difficult instruction-following benchmark, AlpacaEval 2.0,
we show that reusing off-the-shelf small model pairs (e.g.,
$\texttt{zephyr-7b-beta}$ and its untuned version) can significantly improve
the length-controlled win rates of both white-box and black-box large models
against $\texttt{gpt-4-turbo}$ (e.g., $34.4 \rightarrow 37.9$ for
$\texttt{Llama-3-70B-Instruct}$ and $16.0 \rightarrow 20.1$ for
$\texttt{gpt-3.5-turbo-instruct}$), despite the small models' low win rates
$\approx 10.0$.
|
[
-0.25967657566070557,
-0.6250776052474976,
0.5259414315223694,
-0.004521682858467102,
-0.4900912344455719,
-0.07407286763191223,
-0.7239980101585388,
-0.24931050837039948,
0.15057119727134705,
0.21988339722156525,
-0.4058832824230194,
-0.23931188881397247,
-0.683907151222229,
-0.19464245438575745,
-0.17475354671478271,
1.2901755571365356,
-0.15206530690193176,
-0.07980471849441528,
0.2632053792476654,
-0.2066202014684677,
-0.5550849437713623,
-0.14874668419361115,
-0.5612319707870483,
-0.3654088079929352,
0.7030340433120728,
0.34338152408599854,
1.3238821029663086,
0.7940371632575989,
0.5270256400108337,
0.22362764179706573,
-0.3789210021495819,
0.07232114672660828,
-0.5984827876091003,
0.2007599025964737,
-0.4031560719013214,
-0.35703015327453613,
-0.5330502986907959,
-0.0716593936085701,
0.5966888070106506,
0.5186730623245239,
-0.3757138252258301,
0.09792899340391159,
0.2619359791278839,
0.4738221764564514,
-0.7118203043937683,
0.04283124953508377,
-0.7459893822669983,
-0.14136821031570435,
-0.44196242094039917,
-0.1090361624956131,
-0.30175989866256714,
-0.1542023867368698,
0.08998499810695648,
-0.468885600566864,
0.40435951948165894,
-0.04148522764444351,
1.1249580383300781,
0.1877593994140625,
-0.5939946174621582,
-0.21867269277572632,
-0.6524207592010498,
1.0936604738235474,
-0.9713259935379028,
0.29792794585227966,
0.07346178591251373,
0.3126113712787628,
-0.25165945291519165,
-0.41915857791900635,
-0.34301692247390747,
-0.04125376418232918,
0.0008270437247119844,
0.1929810643196106,
-0.24413330852985382,
0.0664273351430893,
0.11874843388795853,
0.5129262804985046,
-0.6079230904579163,
0.5066277384757996,
-0.35400229692459106,
-0.0964847058057785,
0.689146876335144,
0.02901812270283699,
0.006463793106377125,
0.039482347667217255,
-0.10085947811603546,
-0.2929089367389679,
-0.5904030203819275,
-0.04831940680742264,
0.45952409505844116,
0.8705534934997559,
0.07397592812776566,
0.996150016784668,
-0.1477191001176834,
0.7357732653617859,
0.24036087095737457,
-0.12310141324996948,
0.0007627640734426677,
-0.3158770203590393,
-0.18708574771881104,
0.05688501521945,
0.7126815319061279,
0.390326589345932,
0.12469082325696945,
-0.11379267275333405,
-0.5932726860046387,
0.318362295627594,
0.23299631476402283,
-0.875994086265564,
-0.08209934085607529,
-0.11602243036031723,
-0.49963483214378357,
-0.3734985589981079,
-0.0074418834410607815,
-0.7973292469978333,
-0.17190198600292206,
-0.26003608107566833,
0.6950842142105103,
0.00115554581861943,
-0.04275285452604294,
0.1880665421485901,
-0.10439600050449371,
0.5161223411560059,
0.22058230638504028,
-0.9714775085449219,
0.2214009314775467,
0.7107748985290527,
0.9040030837059021,
-0.10195295512676239,
-0.2392338216304779,
-0.8527950644493103,
-0.04803783819079399,
-0.5794029831886292,
0.43998846411705017,
-0.44579172134399414,
-0.2856278121471405,
-0.05965884029865265,
0.004739881493151188,
0.026770800352096558,
-0.4142111539840698,
0.4684053659439087,
-0.6149201989173889,
0.4558256268501282,
-0.35449573397636414,
-0.5106590986251831,
0.1471048891544342,
0.1354599893093109,
-0.554314374923706,
0.9414193034172058,
-0.038015782833099365,
-0.5929093956947327,
0.2819191813468933,
-0.44175854325294495,
-0.6445676684379578,
-0.3189006447792053,
-0.0609966479241848,
-0.8686091303825378,
0.4569252133369446,
0.32277601957321167,
0.41652432084083557,
-0.6137776970863342,
0.1831529587507248,
-0.6204795241355896,
-0.6689972281455994,
-0.09896586090326309,
-0.3133426606655121,
0.6529954671859741,
0.0568961575627327,
-0.8314084410667419,
0.12255557626485825,
-0.24502724409103394,
0.201301708817482,
0.4287970960140228,
-0.362626850605011,
-0.30251532793045044,
0.24986962974071503,
-0.26875168085098267,
0.07238411158323288,
0.22447432577610016,
-0.1137668788433075,
0.6669260263442993,
-0.709864616394043,
0.43069612979888916,
0.7720467448234558,
-0.24985644221305847,
0.6538634300231934,
-0.26495376229286194,
0.36540457606315613,
-0.19310873746871948,
0.1100178137421608,
0.32571160793304443,
-0.3782728612422943,
-0.6524433493614197,
-0.18640248477458954,
0.494501531124115,
0.47190600633621216,
-0.41494429111480713,
0.42448821663856506,
-0.27680402994155884,
-0.38868141174316406,
-0.7852723002433777,
0.5641610026359558,
0.3875015676021576,
0.30275100469589233,
0.5453449487686157,
-0.3438144028186798,
-0.20375651121139526,
-0.9793242812156677,
-0.14878414571285248,
-0.13113833963871002,
-0.18511328101158142,
0.3524951934814453,
0.3587464392185211,
-0.1369454562664032,
0.5820673704147339,
-0.690903902053833,
-0.38675999641418457,
-0.33227699995040894,
0.13337759673595428,
0.3153207004070282,
0.28007063269615173,
0.46583130955696106,
-0.7136444449424744,
-0.3115595281124115,
0.06186763569712639,
-0.4546685516834259,
0.04470260068774223,
0.26430004835128784,
-0.13819046318531036,
0.12906967103481293,
0.414222776889801,
-0.8664841055870056,
0.336614191532135,
0.6008788347244263,
-0.42837390303611755,
0.31568270921707153,
-0.003861734876409173,
-0.029204336926341057,
-1.1415461301803589,
0.09146430343389511,
-0.06764478981494904,
0.01497534941881895,
-0.3134872317314148,
0.27606454491615295,
0.17981906235218048,
-0.07871516048908234,
-0.24739298224449158,
0.5591928958892822,
-0.5007491111755371,
-0.0010479006450623274,
-0.325152724981308,
0.2074650079011917,
0.003911943174898624,
0.45325714349746704,
-0.18071715533733368,
0.8269742727279663,
0.38518673181533813,
-0.3159295320510864,
0.23208683729171753,
0.09074927121400833,
-0.3164069950580597,
0.20444656908512115,
-0.8729842901229858,
0.22589430212974548,
-0.23244063556194305,
0.19013696908950806,
-0.7584865689277649,
-0.16088269650936127,
-0.061017487198114395,
-0.2727448046207428,
0.5331166982650757,
-0.2993563413619995,
-0.445842981338501,
-0.2703419029712677,
-0.4684406816959381,
0.6126033663749695,
0.6213191747665405,
-0.6313861012458801,
0.5048646330833435,
0.08890290558338165,
-0.23360349237918854,
-0.7041561603546143,
-0.47388195991516113,
-0.11514085531234741,
-0.3537128269672394,
-0.4212907552719116,
0.3962422311306,
0.026391368359327316,
-0.24115516245365143,
-0.10591171681880951,
-0.16580812633037567,
0.27736911177635193,
0.07018551230430603,
-0.12078994512557983,
0.43973392248153687,
-0.4132698178291321,
0.21142570674419403,
0.06069064140319824,
0.060533445328474045,
-0.37084484100341797,
-0.4409806430339813,
0.48059019446372986,
-0.316496878862381,
-0.329841285943985,
0.03888331353664398,
0.3625795245170593,
0.5889032483100891,
-0.38688555359840393,
0.6480972766876221,
0.4734902083873749,
-0.2677157521247864,
-0.23755167424678802,
-0.5348157286643982,
-0.3633364140987396,
-0.4810839295387268,
0.3397615849971771,
-0.16399097442626953,
-1.0835061073303223,
0.4809178411960602,
0.28723740577697754,
-0.023130783811211586,
0.7201583981513977,
0.7261115908622742,
-0.04004408419132233,
1.6586997509002686,
0.6911393404006958,
-0.5186097025871277,
0.3632569909095764,
-0.10913287848234177,
0.21786579489707947,
-0.6237958669662476,
0.14961162209510803,
-0.5697047114372253,
-0.6145758032798767,
-0.7626752257347107,
-0.2101709097623825,
0.2559601366519928,
0.32348671555519104,
-0.33139029145240784,
0.3053778111934662,
-0.4816746115684509,
0.5803781747817993,
0.49271389842033386,
0.2142743468284607,
0.04165317118167877,
-0.231874480843544,
-0.05360265076160431,
-0.19318091869354248,
-0.7776695489883423,
-0.015235747210681438,
1.0045158863067627,
0.2618641257286072,
1.0599822998046875,
0.4797911047935486,
0.6135038733482361,
-0.020131373777985573,
0.2811982035636902,
-1.1310675144195557,
0.39847999811172485,
-0.40982624888420105,
-0.6662749648094177,
-0.37024644017219543,
-0.6423898935317993,
-0.9933295845985413,
0.14490434527397156,
-0.08786503970623016,
-0.5589733123779297,
0.09558390825986862,
0.3851403295993805,
-0.3726409673690796,
0.32443591952323914,
-0.775574803352356,
1.0879181623458862,
-0.5211000442504883,
-0.5445646047592163,
-0.23157575726509094,
-0.5743522644042969,
0.3199694752693176,
-0.004007244482636452,
-0.07217667996883392,
0.010941803455352783,
-0.0745043158531189,
0.6046053767204285,
-0.43108057975769043,
0.7356463670730591,
-0.14236538112163544,
-0.1693100482225418,
0.13237068057060242,
0.16437210142612457,
1.0486645698547363,
-0.04953129589557648,
0.051268432289361954,
-0.2431563138961792,
-0.3516629636287689,
-0.7133978009223938,
-0.6161595582962036,
0.7062933444976807,
-0.7752001285552979,
-0.6194968819618225,
-0.4016110897064209,
-0.3827489912509918,
-0.19049306213855743,
0.4247767925262451,
0.4505575895309448,
0.36143267154693604,
-0.044929686933755875,
0.36942872405052185,
0.7115424871444702,
0.025366634130477905,
0.15082332491874695,
0.34444576501846313,
-0.06344354897737503,
-0.172217458486557,
0.815414309501648,
0.005236774682998657,
0.35036954283714294,
0.42515429854393005,
0.43981215357780457,
-0.41365817189216614,
-0.5216424465179443,
-0.2697504460811615,
0.296012282371521,
-0.45559969544410706,
-0.5805578827857971,
-0.13422782719135284,
-0.102536141872406,
-0.21947835385799408,
-0.3022148311138153,
-0.6945095062255859,
-0.2596072852611542,
-0.28686797618865967,
0.13717201352119446,
0.1058296412229538,
0.49905887246131897,
0.18364329636096954,
0.33301404118537903,
-0.4601863920688629,
0.12099258601665497,
0.6455696821212769,
0.5539438128471375,
-0.053085487335920334,
-0.6808977723121643,
-0.20263414084911346,
0.020225152373313904,
-0.356768935918808,
-0.8358043432235718,
0.15183104574680328,
0.24903371930122375,
0.18208612501621246,
0.342801034450531,
0.028892550617456436,
0.705471932888031,
-0.2553469240665436,
0.6168055534362793,
0.23958651721477509,
-0.9129855632781982,
0.5956372618675232,
-0.5539520978927612,
0.5585657954216003,
0.6732050776481628,
0.1840536892414093,
-0.22548896074295044,
-0.4191931188106537,
-0.6268674731254578,
-1.0189629793167114,
0.4653346836566925,
0.17780908942222595,
-0.04206477850675583,
0.11545349657535553,
0.21343547105789185,
-0.2778337597846985,
0.23680289089679718,
-0.5865771174430847,
0.14609703421592712,
-0.11745660752058029,
-0.36203816533088684,
-0.40642181038856506,
-0.14119747281074524,
-0.32128390669822693,
-0.1669030338525772,
0.872238278388977,
-0.4314453601837158,
0.18912295997142792,
-0.12096299976110458,
-0.03037821128964424,
-0.3219389021396637,
0.518348217010498,
0.44314906001091003,
0.40307310223579407,
-0.33511820435523987,
0.22571119666099548,
0.25410470366477966,
-0.08605270087718964,
0.05982419103384018,
0.5052927732467651,
-0.14267012476921082,
-0.23984286189079285,
0.2588581442832947,
0.7948035001754761,
0.526938796043396,
-0.5681068301200867,
0.7513997554779053,
-0.02012302726507187,
-0.15097284317016602,
0.23963840305805206,
-0.005328360944986343,
-0.004825476557016373,
0.4506796598434448,
0.09836024045944214,
-0.11801595985889435,
-0.07945121824741364,
-0.6076332330703735,
-0.04634886980056763,
0.8696036338806152,
-0.27724745869636536,
-0.28956109285354614,
0.7712886333465576,
-0.05456358939409256,
0.06023848429322243,
0.7297912836074829,
-0.4323071241378784,
-0.6450323462486267,
0.40151092410087585,
0.5737088322639465,
0.7292584180831909,
-0.18263618648052216,
-0.04413939639925957,
0.2161283642053604,
0.3016349673271179,
-0.7100358009338379,
0.14448848366737366,
0.06918809562921524,
-0.6831896305084229,
-0.6243241429328918,
-0.47282928228378296,
-0.33708325028419495,
0.316461980342865,
-0.6923678517341614,
0.42784184217453003,
-0.32295045256614685,
-0.24895718693733215,
0.16018328070640564,
0.308027446269989,
-0.7057384252548218,
0.05532625690102577,
-0.0455382764339447,
0.6639972925186157,
-0.7929359078407288,
0.6976593732833862,
0.6428586840629578,
-0.19786863029003143,
-1.1342018842697144,
0.027714785188436508,
0.2536355257034302,
-0.7352904677391052,
0.16445191204547882,
-0.11158208549022675,
-0.04881991073489189,
-0.11358580738306046,
-0.5593385696411133,
-0.8815245628356934,
1.0743684768676758,
0.4041621685028076,
-0.7150372862815857,
-0.3069848120212555,
-0.3889778256416321,
0.47740691900253296,
-0.15359307825565338,
0.01947743631899357,
0.5243493318557739,
0.31548264622688293,
0.08224642276763916,
-1.012941837310791,
0.16509079933166504,
-0.220480814576149,
-0.01356388721615076,
0.7577266097068787,
-1.0022367238998413,
0.8109008073806763,
-0.2998802363872528,
-0.15817174315452576,
0.13305890560150146,
0.6866927742958069,
0.23084856569766998,
0.07274061441421509,
0.6339869499206543,
0.7104417085647583,
0.6961595416069031,
-0.14266738295555115,
0.8121851682662964,
0.015521368943154812,
0.5303402543067932,
1.0912529230117798,
-0.1779891401529312,
0.9501768350601196,
0.4368632733821869,
0.03695833310484886,
0.1284688115119934,
0.4265076816082001,
-0.18251675367355347,
0.48232346773147583,
0.04711069539189339,
-0.032570794224739075,
-0.3883853852748871,
0.10500740259885788,
-0.373324453830719,
0.6356095671653748,
0.051419150084257126,
-0.35343512892723083,
-0.2525705099105835,
-0.3861262798309326,
0.19037944078445435,
-0.034115370362997055,
-0.37227264046669006,
0.7427895665168762,
0.021136507391929626,
-0.9440054893493652,
0.6550858616828918,
0.16779732704162598,
0.768347978591919,
-0.7846294045448303,
0.2880130708217621,
-0.2251671850681305,
0.4989459216594696,
-0.03242788463830948,
-0.6456547379493713,
0.03410639241337776,
-0.01717507466673851,
-0.16346041858196259,
-0.0461360439658165,
0.861065149307251,
-0.5695602297782898,
-0.47380945086479187,
0.3710431754589081,
0.43527013063430786,
-0.31646209955215454,
0.05212107673287392,
-0.6639997959136963,
0.24842016398906708,
0.027534063905477524,
-0.5268405079841614,
0.5986816883087158,
0.15408317744731903,
-0.1670428216457367,
0.2737235426902771,
0.43260011076927185,
0.33204716444015503,
-0.34922170639038086,
0.032522737979888916,
0.8873164653778076,
-0.673821210861206,
-0.540712296962738,
-0.8424199819564819,
0.2920806109905243,
0.07717333734035492,
-0.3655008375644684,
0.5668607354164124,
0.660872220993042,
0.8029772043228149,
0.24051958322525024,
0.6364530920982361,
-0.1541697084903717,
0.30752402544021606,
-0.6284832954406738,
0.5107541084289551,
-0.9530401229858398,
0.14126454293727875,
-0.175572469830513,
-1.1179407835006714,
-0.15216656029224396,
0.4335184097290039,
-0.2899594306945801,
0.11186118423938751,
0.3143058717250824,
0.9756619334220886,
-0.4785180985927582,
-0.25492358207702637,
-0.0811455175280571,
0.2669305205345154,
0.35464397072792053,
0.6393999457359314,
0.5726321339607239,
-0.37957334518432617,
0.7581241130828857,
-0.14727570116519928,
-0.3087524175643921,
-0.4146571457386017,
-0.8846696019172668,
-0.793804407119751,
-0.30537155270576477,
-0.06309759616851807,
-0.678073525428772,
0.198203444480896,
0.9578517079353333,
0.617216169834137,
-0.64631587266922,
-0.22891442477703094,
0.16300946474075317,
0.06921061128377914,
-0.4813913404941559,
-0.22485558688640594,
0.46682071685791016,
-0.32605695724487305,
-0.539287269115448,
0.49536317586898804,
-0.020352786406874657,
0.2793895900249481,
0.025547543540596962,
-0.18213993310928345,
0.05103322118520737,
0.11572500318288803,
0.420610249042511,
0.5512027740478516,
-0.39221909642219543,
-0.40049004554748535,
0.1016482412815094,
-0.1384303718805313,
-0.13551555573940277,
0.8605825304985046,
-0.3332381844520569,
0.4134228527545929,
0.33314332365989685,
0.6536586880683899,
0.7581324577331543,
0.13396340608596802,
0.6772956252098083,
-0.9701352715492249,
0.11930634081363678,
0.41122210025787354,
0.26316529512405396,
0.3516593873500824,
-0.157064750790596,
0.3560386300086975,
0.0679735615849495,
-0.68780118227005,
-0.89197838306427,
0.18814675509929657,
-0.9865201711654663,
-0.26566722989082336,
1.2041467428207397,
0.3495155870914459,
-0.0543089434504509,
0.526597261428833,
-0.11817687004804611,
0.40213754773139954,
-0.3877628743648529,
0.9794749617576599,
0.6972994208335876,
0.044721923768520355,
0.060041334480047226,
-0.5031769275665283,
0.5619920492172241,
0.826317548751831,
-0.3760111629962921,
0.13689610362052917,
0.2618795931339264,
0.10443290323019028,
-0.0016749091446399689,
0.41382238268852234,
-0.12493696808815002,
0.22077111899852753,
-0.28401365876197815,
-0.38995862007141113,
0.11498861014842987,
-0.26322972774505615,
-0.4054626226425171,
0.12599320709705353,
0.3160251975059509,
0.07816622406244278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19261v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19261v1
|
Faster Cascades via Speculative Decoding
| 2024-05-29T16:55:08 | 2024-05-29T16:55:08 |
Harikrishna Narasimhan, Wittawat Jitkrittum, Ankit Singh Rawat, Seungyeon Kim, Neha Gupta, Aditya Krishna Menon, Sanjiv Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Cascades and speculative decoding are two common approaches to improving
language models' inference efficiency. Both approaches involve interleaving
models of different sizes, but via fundamentally distinct mechanisms: cascades
employ a deferral rule that invokes the larger model only for "hard" inputs,
while speculative decoding uses speculative execution to primarily invoke the
larger model in parallel verification mode. These mechanisms offer different
benefits: empirically, cascades are often capable of yielding better quality
than even the larger model, while theoretically, speculative decoding offers a
guarantee of quality-neutrality. In this paper, we leverage the best of both
these approaches by designing new speculative cascading techniques that
implement their deferral rule through speculative execution. We characterize
the optimal deferral rule for our speculative cascades, and employ a plug-in
approximation to the optimal rule. Through experiments with T5 models on
benchmark language tasks, we show that the proposed approach yields better
cost-quality trade-offs than cascading and speculative decoding baselines.
|
[
-0.20533205568790436,
-0.39020615816116333,
0.5448824167251587,
0.49954649806022644,
-0.18164919316768646,
0.3527921140193939,
-0.2497432380914688,
-0.45820334553718567,
0.16052351891994476,
0.296490341424942,
-0.5833826661109924,
-0.2232261449098587,
-0.4787698984146118,
0.03634156659245491,
-0.5770735740661621,
0.775985598564148,
-0.06433143466711044,
-0.12806415557861328,
-0.07164104282855988,
0.46893006563186646,
-0.06920081377029419,
-0.41756436228752136,
-0.4858907163143158,
-0.1261371523141861,
0.33705732226371765,
0.1442408263683319,
0.644827663898468,
0.6098547577857971,
0.4086623191833496,
0.24451203644275665,
-0.012269189581274986,
0.05330151692032814,
-0.5040811896324158,
0.042027585208415985,
-0.14777381718158722,
-0.5772049427032471,
-0.24228574335575104,
-0.19942006468772888,
0.4268087148666382,
0.7368048429489136,
-0.1445750594139099,
0.015871914103627205,
-0.16466741263866425,
0.3442251682281494,
-1.2070071697235107,
0.39985373616218567,
-0.494577556848526,
-0.06779243797063828,
-0.3341834545135498,
-0.4240671396255493,
-0.8285835981369019,
-0.4440903663635254,
-0.09051131457090378,
-0.5387346148490906,
0.34164828062057495,
0.018199292942881584,
0.7712525725364685,
0.1671309769153595,
-0.10314878076314926,
-0.08142809569835663,
-1.0236899852752686,
0.8699268698692322,
-0.9234235882759094,
0.6078739762306213,
0.5194557905197144,
0.19085150957107544,
-0.12234455347061157,
-1.0635170936584473,
-0.5748502612113953,
-0.23737232387065887,
-0.03816615417599678,
0.1697184443473816,
-0.3951146602630615,
0.2365129292011261,
0.37161338329315186,
0.47246769070625305,
-0.2101178616285324,
0.2140301764011383,
-0.19527480006217957,
-0.4640383720397949,
0.3426859378814697,
0.2989186644554138,
-0.03275981917977333,
0.046320315450429916,
-0.016793586313724518,
-0.1042349636554718,
-0.4464018940925598,
0.2106429487466812,
0.3875885307788849,
0.3017602860927582,
-0.031181009486317635,
0.026766031980514526,
-0.5630296468734741,
0.4775809645652771,
0.3819933235645294,
-0.2235659807920456,
-0.1601189225912094,
-0.5540403127670288,
-0.012129421345889568,
-0.009735300205647945,
0.5014535784721375,
0.1838519126176834,
-0.14623983204364777,
-0.661530077457428,
-0.281703382730484,
0.4416503608226776,
0.14823873341083527,
-0.9490783214569092,
-0.3624759614467621,
0.3764387369155884,
-0.6429427862167358,
-0.32762396335601807,
-0.15420067310333252,
-0.4913519322872162,
0.20729681849479675,
-0.1298590451478958,
0.3609132468700409,
-0.46957388520240784,
-0.2795420289039612,
0.32589539885520935,
-0.2571665942668915,
0.0841301828622818,
0.35379278659820557,
-1.3092195987701416,
0.7948214411735535,
0.8879854083061218,
0.8578692078590393,
0.06393551081418991,
-0.074891097843647,
-0.7493484616279602,
0.06811801344156265,
-0.7051134705543518,
0.8634834289550781,
-0.6446222066879272,
-0.2082274854183197,
-0.11747772246599197,
-0.34041324257850647,
0.18601754307746887,
-0.08603775501251221,
1.0086300373077393,
-0.9873980283737183,
-0.010177762247622013,
-0.8835753798484802,
-0.40904489159584045,
-0.16387467086315155,
-0.2363528460264206,
-0.6782664656639099,
0.6554242372512817,
-0.010513167828321457,
-1.0896916389465332,
0.6645947098731995,
-0.1905645728111267,
-0.6522873640060425,
-0.05043178051710129,
0.12632688879966736,
0.11536988615989685,
0.3614308536052704,
0.35990282893180847,
0.31468746066093445,
-0.5340593457221985,
0.011844025924801826,
-0.39475199580192566,
-0.7397902607917786,
0.028688745573163033,
-0.7619904279708862,
0.4713435471057892,
0.3164743483066559,
-0.2649524509906769,
-0.15900284051895142,
-0.3485395014286041,
0.043128617107868195,
-0.23521539568901062,
-0.29429346323013306,
-0.35322320461273193,
0.3626458942890167,
-0.01509009301662445,
0.07740409672260284,
-0.179710254073143,
-0.35696619749069214,
0.21284694969654083,
-0.4846344590187073,
0.44250527024269104,
0.7206106781959534,
-0.17238254845142365,
0.4854923486709595,
-0.3385457396507263,
0.40467938780784607,
0.18507631123065948,
0.19084729254245758,
-0.2869981527328491,
-0.08283442258834839,
-0.8001943826675415,
-0.36911705136299133,
0.6708001494407654,
0.23706065118312836,
-0.9870919585227966,
0.0693448856472969,
-0.24946317076683044,
-0.2409699708223343,
-0.7636625170707703,
-0.3968642055988312,
0.3891332745552063,
0.47832348942756653,
0.5175348520278931,
-0.3241497278213501,
-0.38065651059150696,
-0.6640889048576355,
-0.48958057165145874,
-0.33003512024879456,
0.2976008653640747,
-0.3275790810585022,
0.21318310499191284,
0.17417548596858978,
0.6842599511146545,
-0.465423583984375,
0.3082176148891449,
-0.2425631731748581,
0.21528226137161255,
0.34637919068336487,
0.3873671889305115,
0.692797839641571,
-0.389232337474823,
-0.37320011854171753,
-0.1829323023557663,
-0.43334317207336426,
-0.014250042848289013,
-0.17973041534423828,
-0.13533024489879608,
0.4818247854709625,
0.44409921765327454,
-0.6225683689117432,
0.3969833254814148,
0.38746607303619385,
-0.01724199950695038,
0.798531711101532,
-0.056942399591207504,
0.5287125110626221,
-0.8708940744400024,
-0.09531507641077042,
-0.29723817110061646,
-0.14954517781734467,
-0.9100391864776611,
0.21673402190208435,
0.2431049644947052,
0.5469425320625305,
-0.2556138038635254,
0.13313999772071838,
-0.6577346920967102,
0.1430889070034027,
-0.35757094621658325,
-0.3004799485206604,
-0.05833662301301956,
0.2410200536251068,
0.19775234162807465,
0.8343161344528198,
0.7312925457954407,
-0.6753882169723511,
-0.07718156278133392,
-0.24203555285930634,
-0.5005952715873718,
-0.05918048694729805,
-0.5592052936553955,
0.13448527455329895,
-0.20435595512390137,
0.7780613303184509,
-0.8903415203094482,
-0.14911417663097382,
0.07377945631742477,
-0.22804886102676392,
0.40067410469055176,
-0.23820488154888153,
-0.4339870810508728,
-0.7203466892242432,
-0.5545486807823181,
0.7590402364730835,
0.8118669390678406,
-0.7568752765655518,
0.3917406499385834,
-0.059312604367733,
0.28499364852905273,
-1.2231134176254272,
-1.1359124183654785,
0.062495242804288864,
-0.034287307411432266,
-0.5302940607070923,
0.6886180639266968,
0.11254756897687912,
-0.24759192764759064,
0.10632272809743881,
-0.2815859615802765,
0.037519171833992004,
-0.06741144508123398,
-0.1715347319841385,
0.05351410433650017,
-0.36268290877342224,
-0.25803467631340027,
0.5244400501251221,
-0.4380396008491516,
-0.0006075082928873599,
-0.846278965473175,
0.5053220391273499,
0.1518898904323578,
-0.23645912110805511,
-0.9857520461082458,
0.4623359441757202,
0.6029884219169617,
0.029835030436515808,
0.8680558204650879,
0.44153961539268494,
-0.29189977049827576,
-0.4565110206604004,
-0.928207516670227,
-0.5446191430091858,
-0.5450708866119385,
-0.026873769238591194,
-0.6942389011383057,
-0.7823120951652527,
0.6127141714096069,
-0.10303477197885513,
0.18101873993873596,
0.34933021664619446,
0.5778377056121826,
0.2777303457260132,
0.7882343530654907,
0.5946660041809082,
-0.34644436836242676,
0.12906955182552338,
-0.2582864761352539,
0.5569450855255127,
-0.5325098037719727,
-0.09031675010919571,
-0.681871235370636,
-0.1390407532453537,
-0.4829038679599762,
-0.8228872418403625,
-0.011086021549999714,
0.3057948648929596,
0.16213145852088928,
0.3730590045452118,
-0.19138923287391663,
0.5651023983955383,
0.5225732326507568,
0.0853457897901535,
0.5086246728897095,
0.16305339336395264,
-0.3671010732650757,
-0.08922851085662842,
-1.0236616134643555,
-0.2260947972536087,
0.7928261756896973,
0.1804480403661728,
1.0002862215042114,
0.25214260816574097,
0.5841938257217407,
0.267139196395874,
0.20080803334712982,
-0.7041019201278687,
0.3949795663356781,
-0.3494109511375427,
-0.33348655700683594,
0.13773496448993683,
-0.5482999682426453,
-0.5656794309616089,
0.1910669356584549,
-0.1806749850511551,
-0.7250098586082458,
0.39798182249069214,
0.3498033285140991,
-0.48229852318763733,
0.611086368560791,
-0.6382061839103699,
0.37083542346954346,
0.4304760694503784,
-0.5824215412139893,
-0.4987923502922058,
-0.4010370671749115,
0.7754144072532654,
-0.039941076189279556,
0.04863033816218376,
0.21845506131649017,
-0.025433534756302834,
0.3623364567756653,
-0.6485634446144104,
0.6784216165542603,
0.05552477389574051,
-0.06697306782007217,
0.3080330789089203,
0.4689071774482727,
0.6281221508979797,
0.09552664309740067,
-0.49161574244499207,
0.10836134105920792,
0.23715654015541077,
-0.5853846669197083,
-0.6094475388526917,
0.7871230840682983,
-0.6191771626472473,
-0.6483686566352844,
-0.2945382595062256,
-0.5481603145599365,
-0.13331076502799988,
-0.06507926434278488,
0.5258915424346924,
0.6769324541091919,
-0.025020411238074303,
-0.2123957872390747,
0.3399975299835205,
0.023619582876563072,
0.9199541807174683,
0.4008563756942749,
0.22517943382263184,
0.01481382641941309,
0.7321428060531616,
0.07609065622091293,
0.5642169713973999,
0.7622228860855103,
0.04058939591050148,
-0.4629115164279938,
-0.75413978099823,
-0.13791121542453766,
0.13778960704803467,
-0.7249460816383362,
-0.15170767903327942,
-0.8334042429924011,
-0.13258416950702667,
-0.6407134532928467,
-0.2512168288230896,
-0.3365114629268646,
-0.7280972599983215,
-0.022405169904232025,
0.040347978472709656,
0.4792616665363312,
0.4510800540447235,
-0.3224727213382721,
-0.038966454565525055,
-0.5649110674858093,
0.20434452593326569,
0.040371090173721313,
0.28195926547050476,
0.625592827796936,
-0.5689124464988708,
-0.06216900423169136,
-0.1195235401391983,
0.007369021885097027,
-0.5828636884689331,
0.1912720799446106,
-0.07121700048446655,
0.3981160521507263,
0.6942546963691711,
0.5211262702941895,
1.0709633827209473,
-0.6226648092269897,
0.6688461899757385,
0.1310293823480606,
-1.2756075859069824,
0.20103570818901062,
-0.22773443162441254,
0.2241658866405487,
0.5804383158683777,
0.48831894993782043,
-0.5734218955039978,
-0.47150400280952454,
-0.4111037254333496,
-0.7305046916007996,
1.0346156358718872,
0.3364281952381134,
0.20388469099998474,
-0.2715059518814087,
0.43446406722068787,
0.3783091604709625,
-0.028486983850598335,
-0.11510246992111206,
0.01844710484147072,
-0.02202633209526539,
0.0510457418859005,
0.07214391231536865,
-0.24330830574035645,
0.07910652458667755,
-0.1814027577638626,
0.4430080056190491,
-0.06354350596666336,
0.3102368116378784,
0.08972654491662979,
0.10209455341100693,
-0.07310169190168381,
0.08438589423894882,
0.507285475730896,
0.3757546842098236,
-0.05268922448158264,
0.4169108271598816,
0.36197271943092346,
-0.4979339838027954,
0.006123540457338095,
-0.24038374423980713,
-0.2566039264202118,
-0.07685089111328125,
0.7105317115783691,
0.7901356816291809,
0.05144665762782097,
-0.24998188018798828,
0.28659918904304504,
-0.26482880115509033,
-0.2883032560348511,
0.2779819071292877,
0.10396146029233932,
0.043176766484975815,
0.22570036351680756,
0.3229793906211853,
0.31997010111808777,
0.42298123240470886,
-0.5723236203193665,
0.28904637694358826,
0.21544760465621948,
0.07129424810409546,
-0.6172162294387817,
0.7141265273094177,
0.05318468436598778,
-0.070506751537323,
0.6301765441894531,
-0.18788550794124603,
-0.407545268535614,
0.4741261899471283,
0.7080341577529907,
0.9689375162124634,
-0.11275593191385269,
0.18697303533554077,
0.3710482716560364,
0.2661837339401245,
-0.506919264793396,
0.3097076117992401,
-0.4102015495300293,
-0.45919269323349,
-0.9678972959518433,
-0.714633584022522,
-0.4654894471168518,
-0.19024629890918732,
-0.5892897844314575,
0.15567107498645782,
-0.5234360694885254,
-0.1865113228559494,
-0.11278030276298523,
-0.1405305117368698,
-0.4810468256473541,
0.0051574683748185635,
-0.019760053604841232,
1.1115314960479736,
-0.5667218565940857,
0.7743229269981384,
0.07380887120962143,
-0.2645626664161682,
-1.0833905935287476,
0.6339529156684875,
-0.08772923797369003,
-0.35991930961608887,
0.6875290870666504,
-0.06692670285701752,
-0.4887596368789673,
-0.028262633830308914,
-0.1571216881275177,
-0.9916656613349915,
0.9351110458374023,
0.41886410117149353,
-0.6716185212135315,
-0.03899075463414192,
-0.12174422293901443,
0.49178555607795715,
-0.10081576555967331,
0.8067614436149597,
0.7730262279510498,
0.20831820368766785,
0.4350847005844116,
-0.8212445378303528,
0.46037551760673523,
-0.027044299989938736,
0.17537403106689453,
0.2733033001422882,
-0.8462653160095215,
0.7758988738059998,
-0.37012985348701477,
-0.3899180293083191,
0.18771161139011383,
1.006306767463684,
0.029504191130399704,
0.1403808295726776,
0.38359859585762024,
0.494937002658844,
0.7336273789405823,
-0.27476292848587036,
1.3735522031784058,
-0.5249720215797424,
0.32478734850883484,
0.7412711381912231,
-0.13072748482227325,
0.9443984031677246,
0.23098886013031006,
-0.3704136908054352,
0.7992511987686157,
0.7534506320953369,
0.5549545884132385,
0.6772845983505249,
0.1904824823141098,
-0.4696040451526642,
-0.34283557534217834,
-0.21163079142570496,
-0.34098532795906067,
0.11607961356639862,
0.2898100018501282,
0.044725529849529266,
-0.25990086793899536,
-0.40265849232673645,
0.10281667113304138,
-0.18198461830615997,
-0.14351724088191986,
0.35561123490333557,
0.06915612518787384,
-0.8794211149215698,
0.8831800222396851,
0.2341638058423996,
0.8743672370910645,
-0.447769433259964,
0.2764681875705719,
-0.4014929234981537,
0.3322998881340027,
-0.270091712474823,
-0.40665504336357117,
0.2961801290512085,
-0.16087613999843597,
-0.43628987669944763,
-0.09171774238348007,
0.5586345195770264,
-0.2918570637702942,
-0.3886772096157074,
0.3683605194091797,
0.04427487775683403,
0.043900005519390106,
0.2579207718372345,
-0.3221774697303772,
0.334603488445282,
-0.42873188853263855,
-0.022084765136241913,
0.05387828126549721,
0.33146199584007263,
-0.3691559433937073,
0.6028339266777039,
0.8596009016036987,
0.14101742208003998,
0.0589149072766304,
0.49673616886138916,
1.0975970029830933,
-0.46682077646255493,
-0.8048816919326782,
-0.9336584210395813,
0.3591446578502655,
0.07044550031423569,
0.010405858978629112,
0.7065547108650208,
0.2909974753856659,
0.7334264516830444,
-0.13921037316322327,
0.6906731128692627,
0.018382921814918518,
0.006821559742093086,
-0.7118372917175293,
0.4963548481464386,
-0.37435486912727356,
0.42710861563682556,
-0.6314804553985596,
-0.711700439453125,
-0.3031052052974701,
0.2316727489233017,
-0.31203943490982056,
0.17210887372493744,
0.9485096335411072,
0.8573445677757263,
-0.31969553232192993,
0.2588813602924347,
0.1557433009147644,
0.324820876121521,
0.2612881362438202,
0.7758510708808899,
0.935152530670166,
-0.5012593269348145,
0.1585371047258377,
-0.40452414751052856,
-0.408403217792511,
-0.11379963159561157,
-0.8716307282447815,
-0.9505686163902283,
-0.4392162263393402,
-0.23453938961029053,
-0.592731773853302,
0.15602687001228333,
0.6549504399299622,
1.093071460723877,
-0.8508210778236389,
-0.17182114720344543,
-0.3397945165634155,
0.0010532772867009044,
-0.515927791595459,
-0.2416345775127411,
0.3777099549770355,
-0.6519126296043396,
-0.7313869595527649,
0.4608478248119354,
0.3626157343387604,
-0.16771546006202698,
-0.09469486027956009,
-0.018106907606124878,
0.030969224870204926,
0.6435431838035583,
0.6633351445198059,
0.19957442581653595,
-0.8556212186813354,
-0.10725487768650055,
0.035427071154117584,
0.14653758704662323,
-0.3856331706047058,
1.182356834411621,
-0.9539076089859009,
0.23721295595169067,
0.9520151019096375,
0.7004135251045227,
0.6583147048950195,
0.11494534462690353,
0.5828490257263184,
-0.27422669529914856,
0.49116238951683044,
0.29066377878189087,
-0.027689645066857338,
-0.10633472353219986,
-0.4734749495983124,
0.08611585199832916,
0.3203146457672119,
-0.28543445467948914,
-0.9737163186073303,
0.18303407728672028,
-0.9460234045982361,
-0.4088278114795685,
0.8449922204017639,
-0.08673650771379471,
-0.2057560682296753,
-0.08532383292913437,
0.20490498840808868,
0.06699184328317642,
-0.4898950457572937,
0.9142258167266846,
0.7181220054626465,
-0.08695061504840851,
-0.06690189242362976,
-0.29367128014564514,
0.7310596108436584,
0.6382943987846375,
-0.5492929816246033,
0.19683481752872467,
0.17473283410072327,
0.11656489223241806,
0.0496937595307827,
0.7686785459518433,
-0.06711655855178833,
0.45390960574150085,
0.34194403886795044,
-0.2927612066268921,
0.3438226878643036,
-0.5246423482894897,
-0.18684400618076324,
0.2517695426940918,
0.07972382009029388,
0.12774492800235748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19222v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19222v2
|
Lower Bounds on the Expressivity of Recurrent Neural Language Models
| 2024-05-29T16:02:09 | 2024-06-18T15:42:32 |
Anej Svete, Franz Nowak, Anisha Mohamed Sahabdeen, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent successes and spread of large neural language models (LMs) call
for a thorough understanding of their computational ability. Describing their
computational abilities through LMs' \emph{representational capacity} is a
lively area of research. However, investigation into the representational
capacity of neural LMs has predominantly focused on their ability to
\emph{recognize} formal languages. For example, recurrent neural networks
(RNNs) with Heaviside activations are tightly linked to regular languages,
i.e., languages defined by finite-state automata (FSAs). Such results, however,
fall short of describing the capabilities of RNN \emph{language models} (LMs),
which are definitionally \emph{distributions} over strings. We take a fresh
look at the representational capacity of RNN LMs by connecting them to
\emph{probabilistic} FSAs and demonstrate that RNN LMs with linearly bounded
precision can express arbitrary regular LMs.
|
[
-0.30767059326171875,
-0.1287897378206253,
0.706812858581543,
0.12546366453170776,
-0.19000999629497528,
0.13747385144233704,
-0.5630335807800293,
-0.6364654302597046,
0.3232351839542389,
0.25904420018196106,
-0.15665088593959808,
-0.03248213604092598,
-0.6336023211479187,
0.33260318636894226,
-0.4534318745136261,
0.5437765717506409,
-0.19082103669643402,
-0.13924258947372437,
-0.15075120329856873,
-0.23630255460739136,
-0.022788118571043015,
-0.5629560351371765,
-0.3421558141708374,
-0.4974238872528076,
0.6548607349395752,
-0.1678444892168045,
0.763251781463623,
0.4858466684818268,
0.45398733019828796,
0.3399905860424042,
-0.12176232039928436,
-0.18170365691184998,
-0.22301150858402252,
0.2171473354101181,
0.05856010317802429,
-0.6061021089553833,
-0.28084027767181396,
-0.03919189050793648,
0.9461420774459839,
0.774050772190094,
-0.21712812781333923,
0.01289299689233303,
-0.1981174796819687,
0.5515349507331848,
-0.32953470945358276,
0.24625305831432343,
-0.7475288510322571,
0.18957635760307312,
-0.27132609486579895,
0.043963052332401276,
-0.6297897100448608,
-0.40116646885871887,
0.15558747947216034,
-0.4679124653339386,
0.1478424370288849,
-0.17545486986637115,
1.0012235641479492,
0.06876734644174576,
-0.034180834889411926,
0.10649612545967102,
-0.8630697727203369,
0.7246424555778503,
-0.8967328071594238,
0.5409877896308899,
0.27533966302871704,
0.3789791464805603,
-0.19407205283641815,
-0.6063803434371948,
-0.4410180151462555,
-0.5432865619659424,
-0.21054582297801971,
-0.5630051493644714,
-0.3572451174259186,
0.4217287003993988,
0.5759831070899963,
0.6827819347381592,
-0.4312010407447815,
0.1580263376235962,
-0.2995428144931793,
-0.23690858483314514,
0.6986699104309082,
0.25397682189941406,
0.07658302783966064,
0.006169239990413189,
-0.29594698548316956,
0.25514745712280273,
-0.533290445804596,
0.16593581438064575,
0.15379472076892853,
0.29592153429985046,
0.1658696085214615,
0.5983704328536987,
0.030059028416872025,
1.004889726638794,
0.056797415018081665,
0.29242339730262756,
0.03440741077065468,
-0.12990553677082062,
-0.36755818128585815,
-0.3138287663459778,
0.8545225858688354,
-0.3550213873386383,
0.6290736794471741,
-0.19158977270126343,
-0.4195796847343445,
0.01630503125488758,
0.35095271468162537,
-0.5335927605628967,
0.06903331726789474,
-0.18596196174621582,
-0.6151227951049805,
0.18257774412631989,
-0.05847182869911194,
-0.2938067317008972,
-0.29519927501678467,
-0.30092817544937134,
0.45616596937179565,
-0.39763137698173523,
-0.39102262258529663,
0.33977633714675903,
-0.009288243018090725,
-0.09123563766479492,
-0.09114164113998413,
-0.9125340580940247,
0.6542624831199646,
0.4508500099182129,
0.7081323862075806,
0.19050085544586182,
0.02885640598833561,
0.11672459542751312,
-0.2768552303314209,
-0.44406449794769287,
0.22610507905483246,
-0.6479792594909668,
0.2188696265220642,
0.14356322586536407,
-0.14909550547599792,
-0.13875068724155426,
-0.38181552290916443,
0.26085364818573,
-0.940605878829956,
-0.23639850318431854,
-0.2878907322883606,
-0.8106552958488464,
-0.3106842637062073,
-0.19765768945217133,
-0.7511982321739197,
0.37909916043281555,
0.20507992804050446,
-0.3509267568588257,
-0.04417061060667038,
-0.02403101697564125,
-0.4886251986026764,
-0.17982293665409088,
-0.5172120928764343,
-0.23119063675403595,
0.7084921002388,
-0.35455453395843506,
0.5935972332954407,
-0.3664133548736572,
0.2746371924877167,
-0.3171897828578949,
-0.44952288269996643,
0.6152539849281311,
-0.5433412790298462,
0.5281044840812683,
0.4003639817237854,
-0.2442837655544281,
-0.030584070831537247,
-0.6693968772888184,
0.0000027201392640563427,
0.07776744663715363,
-0.525003969669342,
-0.43938976526260376,
-0.09968408942222595,
-0.2553950846195221,
0.26785483956336975,
0.49607259035110474,
-0.5851855874061584,
0.2862444818019867,
-0.6993523836135864,
0.7916966080665588,
0.6862372159957886,
-0.4881046712398529,
0.6217879056930542,
-0.15104494988918304,
0.600899875164032,
-0.1145273968577385,
-0.23200182616710663,
-0.06531669944524765,
-0.4454696774482727,
-0.6846000552177429,
-0.27711018919944763,
0.5974162817001343,
0.2926540970802307,
-0.411274254322052,
0.5951992869377136,
-0.19979368150234222,
-0.38147634267807007,
-0.4250938296318054,
-0.11651597172021866,
0.25325629115104675,
-0.07704152911901474,
0.15376080572605133,
-0.5009990930557251,
-0.6946043372154236,
-1.2613282203674316,
-0.2418878972530365,
0.010781173594295979,
-0.06260833144187927,
0.2064010053873062,
0.38213831186294556,
0.02476217970252037,
0.8340001702308655,
-0.1564987152814865,
-0.2791282534599304,
-0.33861228823661804,
0.0065178945660591125,
0.6491259336471558,
0.26917344331741333,
0.4875166416168213,
-0.48849326372146606,
-0.37018147110939026,
-0.1426720768213272,
-0.6621857285499573,
0.10632715374231339,
-0.21785439550876617,
0.2869336009025574,
0.3344716727733612,
0.18350668251514435,
-0.8472916483879089,
0.6160635352134705,
0.4977312684059143,
-0.3034559488296509,
0.17888768017292023,
-0.36167436838150024,
-0.1013067215681076,
-0.4957837164402008,
-0.03905101865530014,
-0.03605721518397331,
-0.38172125816345215,
-0.732873797416687,
-0.14507393538951874,
0.04576704651117325,
-0.06668241322040558,
0.0812649130821228,
0.49749985337257385,
-0.7076603174209595,
-0.7515438199043274,
-0.07990560680627823,
0.15261711180210114,
-0.35161861777305603,
0.4830661714076996,
0.3889223337173462,
0.38465526700019836,
0.5037607550621033,
-0.6263316869735718,
0.08496671169996262,
-0.17719915509223938,
-0.3865847587585449,
0.10061368346214294,
-0.775297224521637,
-0.2637241780757904,
0.06932911276817322,
0.33885568380355835,
-0.9257799983024597,
-0.09438706934452057,
0.017005084082484245,
-0.5174773335456848,
0.40155619382858276,
-0.06880125403404236,
-0.32092636823654175,
-0.23278141021728516,
-0.0016478430479764938,
0.665427565574646,
0.7465752363204956,
-0.2386815994977951,
0.6056910157203674,
0.2760697603225708,
0.3119281828403473,
-0.6002368330955505,
-0.8587125539779663,
-0.005572637543082237,
0.1332036405801773,
-0.4964764416217804,
0.2974141240119934,
0.29012641310691833,
-0.3294372260570526,
-0.01411935593932867,
0.014899840578436852,
-0.015561257489025593,
0.06557748466730118,
0.059930428862571716,
-0.17807705700397491,
-0.44942834973335266,
0.1444321870803833,
-0.1073179692029953,
-0.1713096797466278,
0.007567392662167549,
-0.37286677956581116,
0.6897649765014648,
-0.42622628808021545,
-0.31658533215522766,
-0.7283095121383667,
0.16948707401752472,
0.4977092146873474,
-0.240964874625206,
0.6593613624572754,
0.1990477442741394,
-0.8903730511665344,
0.09937616437673569,
-0.22187310457229614,
-0.4458492398262024,
-0.4632350206375122,
0.14142760634422302,
-0.4399406313896179,
-0.8802753686904907,
0.5995986461639404,
0.5537014007568359,
0.1794564574956894,
0.49206098914146423,
0.38736891746520996,
0.15690068900585175,
0.8664863705635071,
0.19604504108428955,
-0.024896960705518723,
0.5001146197319031,
-0.20662368834018707,
0.2293664962053299,
-0.777119517326355,
0.053011514246463776,
-0.38548654317855835,
-0.5512427091598511,
-0.7206664085388184,
-0.6190053224563599,
-0.2134929597377777,
0.042098239064216614,
-0.5060591101646423,
0.47407102584838867,
-0.353345662355423,
0.33332324028015137,
0.40813466906547546,
0.0009358189417980611,
0.1695007085800171,
0.3538137376308441,
-0.16665607690811157,
-0.508265495300293,
-0.8274199962615967,
-0.3493451774120331,
0.7691146731376648,
1.0416780710220337,
0.9145105481147766,
0.12437345832586288,
0.7075418829917908,
0.2659878432750702,
0.28224340081214905,
-0.697828471660614,
0.7100807428359985,
-0.5164082050323486,
-0.6865683794021606,
-0.08781249821186066,
-0.6157594919204712,
-0.9743586182594299,
-0.09829060733318329,
-0.13149261474609375,
-0.7289109826087952,
0.3959769308567047,
0.11138048768043518,
-0.4707181453704834,
0.6375665664672852,
-0.08919158577919006,
0.2989603579044342,
-0.04822583496570587,
-0.2586416006088257,
-0.20539863407611847,
-0.2853194773197174,
0.2697630524635315,
0.5973519682884216,
-0.08588571846485138,
-0.004580828361213207,
-0.1909961700439453,
0.6720315217971802,
-0.35049304366111755,
0.955691933631897,
-0.28834062814712524,
-0.3211933374404907,
0.36272573471069336,
0.43877893686294556,
0.42797642946243286,
0.09043464809656143,
-0.05490536987781525,
0.44917401671409607,
-0.21898318827152252,
-0.3982950448989868,
-0.4937524199485779,
0.7122846245765686,
-0.5254688858985901,
-0.44141846895217896,
-0.7009718418121338,
-0.5657690167427063,
-0.2125861644744873,
0.08811261504888535,
0.20907069742679596,
0.5693027377128601,
0.05276405066251755,
0.18659251928329468,
0.967374861240387,
-0.17558036744594574,
0.3774193823337555,
0.23809970915317535,
-0.3523077666759491,
-0.48151180148124695,
0.9117917418479919,
0.5237157940864563,
0.5020714402198792,
0.4662054181098938,
0.09494058787822723,
-0.37974485754966736,
-0.7228379249572754,
-0.4756934344768524,
0.2763310968875885,
-0.5023190975189209,
-0.018112005665898323,
-0.2849563658237457,
-0.46413522958755493,
-0.18678376078605652,
-0.06921284645795822,
-0.4421817660331726,
-0.943125307559967,
-0.33047211170196533,
0.0035372977145016193,
0.49911782145500183,
0.9068306684494019,
-0.33811742067337036,
0.050366003066301346,
-0.6669557094573975,
0.2965683341026306,
0.25620582699775696,
0.6519868969917297,
0.2754333019256592,
-0.7841388583183289,
-0.1489613652229309,
-0.02920892834663391,
0.3635299801826477,
-0.9330443143844604,
0.2694617211818695,
0.20751623809337616,
0.6185814738273621,
0.4456908404827118,
-0.2485310435295105,
0.32316702604293823,
-0.527493417263031,
0.697787880897522,
0.13352839648723602,
-0.8723130226135254,
-0.015037329867482185,
-0.5370941758155823,
0.08627250790596008,
0.25193387269973755,
0.5810078978538513,
-0.4266544282436371,
-0.42528632283210754,
-0.6844390034675598,
-0.6032845377922058,
0.33956000208854675,
0.34671205282211304,
0.32597586512565613,
-0.14634709060192108,
0.838316023349762,
-0.11449673026800156,
0.3623068928718567,
-0.7695037722587585,
-0.3430105149745941,
0.027964072301983833,
-0.5439975261688232,
-0.1254541426897049,
-0.4244726002216339,
0.25957927107810974,
-0.14742755889892578,
0.4808794856071472,
0.08103716373443604,
0.7413005232810974,
0.2892712354660034,
0.06310908496379852,
0.024820601567626,
0.14426256716251373,
0.879061758518219,
0.5344725251197815,
-0.051801204681396484,
0.4048248529434204,
0.028272293508052826,
-0.41465845704078674,
0.38121476769447327,
0.24257755279541016,
-0.22452321648597717,
0.1605420559644699,
0.4259701669216156,
0.7327520847320557,
0.33537283539772034,
-0.44376641511917114,
0.08755915611982346,
-0.23836274445056915,
-0.012215444818139076,
-0.49742695689201355,
0.098782479763031,
0.18240979313850403,
0.19077323377132416,
0.30819737911224365,
0.1670784205198288,
-0.13043586909770966,
-0.35791656374931335,
0.35683828592300415,
0.5043021440505981,
-0.556690514087677,
-0.3922187387943268,
0.5741097331047058,
0.05900556966662407,
-0.532962441444397,
0.4073970913887024,
-0.28605887293815613,
-0.5498933792114258,
0.5770696401596069,
0.5672999024391174,
0.7944666147232056,
-0.3109535276889801,
-0.12731221318244934,
0.8339478969573975,
0.3967910706996918,
-0.24542656540870667,
0.48179030418395996,
0.04034813866019249,
-0.7806158661842346,
-0.3471110165119171,
-0.6534509658813477,
0.10482411831617355,
0.21135348081588745,
-0.6645231246948242,
-0.15035010874271393,
-0.9981803297996521,
-0.3254781663417816,
-0.10919909924268723,
-0.09519794583320618,
-0.31884679198265076,
-0.07318500429391861,
0.274116575717926,
1.162476658821106,
-0.6428582072257996,
0.6692547798156738,
0.2741587460041046,
-0.41905567049980164,
-0.5237802267074585,
-0.29793450236320496,
-0.389451265335083,
-0.5534759759902954,
0.8536443710327148,
0.11563007533550262,
-0.15657612681388855,
-0.16524571180343628,
-0.29663699865341187,
-0.9443762898445129,
0.5780928730964661,
0.3884901702404022,
-1.0458028316497803,
-0.07318152487277985,
0.2558293640613556,
0.8291375041007996,
-0.5631034970283508,
0.03252830356359482,
0.4855230152606964,
0.39051350951194763,
-0.5240585803985596,
-0.9416496753692627,
0.2063886970281601,
0.05356239154934883,
0.2343992441892624,
0.36027902364730835,
-0.37792760133743286,
0.9960243105888367,
-0.24513600766658783,
-0.1885736584663391,
0.46697506308555603,
1.0898635387420654,
0.23261819779872894,
0.093992218375206,
0.5512280464172363,
0.6640005111694336,
0.5857416391372681,
-0.2298014909029007,
1.1597224473953247,
-0.08639414608478546,
0.2921060025691986,
1.0702903270721436,
-0.13391512632369995,
1.0181483030319214,
0.44827374815940857,
-0.3286338746547699,
0.6388948559761047,
0.5361264944076538,
0.23660597205162048,
0.15782733261585236,
0.8485819697380066,
-0.3387700915336609,
-0.6936238408088684,
0.0920662209391594,
-0.25510138273239136,
0.059949930757284164,
0.5314615964889526,
-0.7654775977134705,
0.03638579323887825,
-0.08965912461280823,
-0.16569042205810547,
0.627253532409668,
-0.3603886663913727,
0.34700673818588257,
0.37043991684913635,
-0.4525783061981201,
1.0310148000717163,
-0.06515184044837952,
0.7148627638816833,
-0.5956777930259705,
-0.026995345950126648,
-0.021024364978075027,
0.15177761018276215,
-0.21268153190612793,
-0.9963107705116272,
0.43500852584838867,
-0.15527334809303284,
-0.3569110929965973,
0.010956590995192528,
0.8638020753860474,
-0.5963860750198364,
-0.2750493884086609,
0.30304259061813354,
0.03456047549843788,
0.08005275577306747,
0.30295464396476746,
-0.44282642006874084,
0.07085771858692169,
-0.17477180063724518,
-0.19107097387313843,
0.23161037266254425,
0.2198076993227005,
-0.015631843358278275,
0.6925367712974548,
0.22747749090194702,
0.30994534492492676,
0.3391852378845215,
-0.007546067237854004,
0.36239704489707947,
-0.6846299171447754,
-0.25698012113571167,
-0.7190937995910645,
0.19074775278568268,
0.05720273777842522,
-0.09642711281776428,
0.44967028498649597,
0.2726740837097168,
0.5673679113388062,
-0.25251275300979614,
0.7228596806526184,
-0.30346158146858215,
0.22812804579734802,
-0.5431960821151733,
0.6532480120658875,
-0.5591084361076355,
0.18923407793045044,
0.18750452995300293,
-0.395961731672287,
-0.3105340301990509,
1.172688603401184,
-0.31834954023361206,
0.19880209863185883,
0.24603663384914398,
0.5275972485542297,
-0.10640306770801544,
0.024080704897642136,
0.4642601013183594,
0.45410630106925964,
0.11904919892549515,
1.0108784437179565,
1.0742911100387573,
-0.568315327167511,
0.03109513223171234,
-0.30859875679016113,
-0.1675361692905426,
-0.13822226226329803,
-0.8497086763381958,
-0.8965725302696228,
-0.8264032006263733,
0.007937933318316936,
-0.42024800181388855,
-0.18878480792045593,
0.9837602376937866,
0.6567069292068481,
-0.6872555613517761,
-0.2906016409397125,
-0.40638795495033264,
0.2985803782939911,
-0.25556132197380066,
-0.2048066109418869,
0.10119540244340897,
-0.3675822913646698,
-0.5061312913894653,
0.39949145913124084,
0.06363466382026672,
0.13607268035411835,
-0.7072776556015015,
-0.09813795238733292,
-0.24816851317882538,
0.37988823652267456,
0.5379250049591064,
0.6767503619194031,
-0.6570155620574951,
-0.3597032427787781,
0.29821714758872986,
-0.1349223405122757,
-0.1398402899503708,
0.9716423749923706,
-0.7833040952682495,
0.12088802456855774,
0.9281145334243774,
0.8101497292518616,
-0.009432242251932621,
-0.5153167247772217,
0.8655452132225037,
-0.7914984822273254,
0.09195972979068756,
0.5144504904747009,
0.6304139494895935,
0.16395100951194763,
-0.24527013301849365,
0.17026710510253906,
0.11689738929271698,
-0.5508458018302917,
-0.777855396270752,
0.7701255083084106,
-0.7298104763031006,
-0.21546238660812378,
1.2524827718734741,
-0.20505081117153168,
-0.18755178153514862,
-0.2099432647228241,
0.13531412184238434,
0.04229924455285072,
-0.28445497155189514,
0.5746428370475769,
0.5073359608650208,
-0.32062458992004395,
0.040492355823516846,
-0.6412022113800049,
0.8114425539970398,
0.5333722829818726,
-0.28690627217292786,
0.31416916847229004,
0.3465324640274048,
0.26717597246170044,
0.5638706684112549,
0.6978544592857361,
-0.1181337907910347,
0.4034934937953949,
-0.3266470730304718,
-0.031411610543727875,
0.038558293133974075,
-0.47282418608665466,
-0.7910326719284058,
-0.009339046664536,
0.4048510193824768,
-0.020703207701444626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19220v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19220v3
|
WRDScore: New Metric for Evaluation of Natural Language Generation Models
| 2024-05-29T16:00:46 | 2024-06-25T10:41:43 |
Ravil Mussabayev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The problem of natural language generation, and, more specifically, method
name prediction, faces significant difficulties when proposed models need to be
evaluated on test data. Such a metric would need to consider the versatility
with which a single method can be named, with respect to both semantics and
syntax. Measuring the direct overlap between the predicted and reference (true)
sequences will not be able to capture these subtleties. Other existing
embedding based metrics either do not measure precision and recall or impose
strict unrealistic assumptions on both sequences. To address these issues, we
propose a new metric that, on the one hand, is very simple and lightweight,
and, on the other hand, is able to calculate precision and recall without
resorting to any assumptions while obtaining good performance with respect to
the human judgement.
|
[
-0.44917774200439453,
-0.6779691576957703,
0.2917945384979248,
0.23408137261867523,
-0.23166590929031372,
0.15902622044086456,
-0.3348996639251709,
-0.38301944732666016,
-0.0384335070848465,
0.1628951132297516,
-0.37226495146751404,
-0.6100953221321106,
-0.6582851409912109,
0.05706654489040375,
-0.5248906016349792,
0.9482178092002869,
-0.1731380969285965,
-0.18823876976966858,
-0.5641801357269287,
-0.2664478123188019,
-0.19933579862117767,
-0.13671770691871643,
-0.29945048689842224,
-0.31358978152275085,
0.29645490646362305,
0.36826038360595703,
0.688265323638916,
0.751178503036499,
0.6142740249633789,
0.310683012008667,
-0.09570467472076416,
0.22986379265785217,
-0.17518411576747894,
0.14839720726013184,
0.0023180951829999685,
-0.04260594770312309,
-0.45770689845085144,
0.21065735816955566,
0.8249956369400024,
0.9343183636665344,
-0.1665065735578537,
0.5205676555633545,
-0.044193800538778305,
0.6474111676216125,
-0.7130436301231384,
-0.12960819900035858,
-0.5269576907157898,
0.28001415729522705,
-0.13294726610183716,
-0.24233169853687286,
-0.14263665676116943,
-0.7084804177284241,
0.3492608368396759,
-0.3260703682899475,
0.6263853311538696,
0.20967477560043335,
0.5477197170257568,
0.0790068656206131,
-0.15772613883018494,
-0.1393047720193863,
-0.7894564270973206,
0.9553294777870178,
-0.9540727734565735,
0.33502620458602905,
0.10287024825811386,
0.49092844128608704,
-0.2220221906900406,
-0.5226978659629822,
-0.6309993267059326,
-0.3503231108188629,
0.2568810284137726,
-0.021834643557667732,
-0.17169664800167084,
-0.047416768968105316,
0.39226028323173523,
0.46298786997795105,
-0.48502829670906067,
0.04690047726035118,
-0.19861221313476562,
-0.30340883135795593,
0.7847324013710022,
0.29059943556785583,
0.08837715536355972,
-0.4617871940135956,
-0.596393346786499,
0.17067885398864746,
-0.34032371640205383,
-0.04001207277178764,
0.6269132494926453,
0.5548241138458252,
-0.30144551396369934,
0.5975754857063293,
-0.44245055317878723,
0.7263697385787964,
-0.17207936942577362,
-0.33871111273765564,
0.5765656232833862,
-0.21079224348068237,
-0.1200454905629158,
0.010381561703979969,
0.8969465494155884,
0.29187828302383423,
0.3736933767795563,
-0.47762221097946167,
-0.17299634218215942,
0.32806453108787537,
0.40676069259643555,
-0.6983762979507446,
-0.09962942451238632,
-0.07263202220201492,
-0.41588085889816284,
-0.45911601185798645,
0.375620573759079,
-0.7900936603546143,
-0.18197818100452423,
-0.27049338817596436,
0.2530032992362976,
-0.5559936761856079,
-0.4286653399467468,
-0.00801637303084135,
-0.6203775405883789,
0.12001562863588333,
0.06959474086761475,
-0.5190473198890686,
0.4236668348312378,
0.7453897595405579,
0.7182758450508118,
-0.39546653628349304,
-0.3967708647251129,
-0.42256802320480347,
0.1284281313419342,
-0.1385066658258438,
0.8509473204612732,
-0.5668714046478271,
-0.6535578370094299,
-0.10503263771533966,
-0.2920398414134979,
0.17430640757083893,
-0.39246484637260437,
0.882434606552124,
-0.14295773208141327,
0.3071795403957367,
-0.12469314783811569,
-0.910000741481781,
-0.2615339457988739,
0.25734421610832214,
-0.4913058578968048,
1.3530551195144653,
0.23208507895469666,
-1.0043891668319702,
0.5468194484710693,
-0.315343976020813,
-0.6921010613441467,
0.06755901128053665,
-0.12243965268135071,
-0.3343472182750702,
0.5163565278053284,
-0.22208227217197418,
0.37671926617622375,
-0.725671648979187,
0.5550188422203064,
-0.31398895382881165,
-0.21829834580421448,
-0.021948082372546196,
-0.5517929196357727,
0.22297357022762299,
0.09756610542535782,
-0.3405144512653351,
-0.059989020228385925,
-0.9682039618492126,
0.43999919295310974,
0.032315004616975784,
-0.21660275757312775,
-0.2815185785293579,
0.016905272379517555,
-0.11397295445203781,
0.025702286511659622,
0.09224022179841995,
-0.8356138467788696,
-0.15297473967075348,
-0.1669541597366333,
0.17446456849575043,
0.6519132256507874,
-0.13376009464263916,
0.48980629444122314,
-0.5658755898475647,
0.6966374516487122,
-0.15732111036777496,
0.022790856659412384,
0.12267226725816727,
-0.6223003268241882,
-0.6977807879447937,
0.049097929149866104,
0.6338515281677246,
0.37540149688720703,
-0.27710774540901184,
0.7335777878761292,
-0.4626004993915558,
-1.0791378021240234,
-0.32909485697746277,
0.13186180591583252,
0.7035667300224304,
0.666100263595581,
0.22201113402843475,
-0.6408458352088928,
-0.8479215502738953,
-0.9297551512718201,
-0.6176121234893799,
-0.16967342793941498,
0.05146360024809837,
0.1867588609457016,
0.29352104663848877,
0.002825325122103095,
1.2676657438278198,
-0.46743592619895935,
-0.06176769360899925,
-0.3943357467651367,
0.47347038984298706,
0.058103013783693314,
0.4855659604072571,
0.21842817962169647,
-0.57234787940979,
-0.3142055571079254,
-0.38127967715263367,
-0.7536988854408264,
-0.06882482022047043,
0.27411705255508423,
0.026749879121780396,
-0.030069028958678246,
0.22883209586143494,
-0.6261758208274841,
0.27499279379844666,
0.6850931644439697,
-0.2856341600418091,
0.9717678427696228,
-0.22722028195858002,
-0.07118711620569229,
-0.9317921996116638,
0.16939868032932281,
0.22838681936264038,
0.007596716284751892,
-0.5444658994674683,
-0.1335514485836029,
0.13251207768917084,
-0.01943831332027912,
-0.5031003355979919,
0.8120432496070862,
-0.5566392540931702,
-0.11538923531770706,
0.09406480938196182,
0.4709368646144867,
0.054694630205631256,
-0.007723873481154442,
-0.13009729981422424,
0.6678526997566223,
0.4313620328903198,
-0.8331800699234009,
0.3044552206993103,
0.21188201010227203,
-0.6044055223464966,
0.782233476638794,
-0.5716584920883179,
0.22864045202732086,
-0.00992810819298029,
0.07674949616193771,
-0.6596595048904419,
0.0394446887075901,
-0.4673311114311218,
-0.8251653909683228,
0.1357782781124115,
0.09246041625738144,
-0.6103317737579346,
-0.7647958993911743,
-0.2678469121456146,
0.3601689338684082,
0.7052903771400452,
-0.40794384479522705,
0.32958945631980896,
0.26728975772857666,
0.09776782989501953,
-0.38516008853912354,
-0.6423283815383911,
-0.09634817391633987,
-0.3334377110004425,
-0.5807014107704163,
0.564291775226593,
-0.06220574676990509,
-0.25466910004615784,
0.1411239504814148,
-0.11677124351263046,
0.12684400379657745,
0.06028943881392479,
0.29146844148635864,
0.23045732080936432,
-0.3295038938522339,
0.3200463056564331,
-0.13574305176734924,
-0.38562870025634766,
0.12970095872879028,
-0.029905609786510468,
0.2990626096725464,
0.03241107240319252,
-0.29341813921928406,
-0.2829611599445343,
0.22844932973384857,
0.39561253786087036,
-0.4719647169113159,
0.4385676085948944,
0.5573093891143799,
-0.43722420930862427,
-0.4974362552165985,
-0.6795312762260437,
0.17551462352275848,
-0.44451549649238586,
0.2740100920200348,
-0.25556185841560364,
-0.6146427989006042,
0.3491402566432953,
-0.2095860093832016,
-0.11549239605665207,
0.4309665858745575,
0.37854593992233276,
0.010351805947721004,
1.1192430257797241,
0.4959435760974884,
0.1477261334657669,
0.11124717444181442,
-0.24217861890792847,
0.3300105333328247,
-1.1130666732788086,
-0.15390044450759888,
-0.5940701961517334,
-0.5483840703964233,
-0.38687464594841003,
-0.5512991547584534,
-0.1394416093826294,
0.12981392443180084,
-0.38114768266677856,
0.49804994463920593,
-0.450840562582016,
0.27604055404663086,
0.5415152907371521,
-0.48685309290885925,
0.5075260400772095,
-0.10550687462091446,
-0.4298354387283325,
-0.23672519624233246,
-0.5014495849609375,
-0.7553098201751709,
1.2103934288024902,
0.0844714567065239,
0.5640032291412354,
0.04174017906188965,
0.8331369757652283,
0.31040918827056885,
0.3914337158203125,
-0.6126543879508972,
0.6512517333030701,
-0.300762802362442,
-0.5989498496055603,
-0.10310349613428116,
-0.6579851508140564,
-0.5720471143722534,
0.01973450370132923,
-0.2590411901473999,
-0.5177688598632812,
-0.4101748764514923,
-0.0024555406998842955,
-0.35974812507629395,
0.616321861743927,
-0.6551613211631775,
0.7989085912704468,
-0.2065693736076355,
-0.2255466878414154,
0.022065438330173492,
-0.2134704738855362,
0.38663479685783386,
0.30772486329078674,
0.3648758828639984,
-0.712645411491394,
0.028359951451420784,
0.9830121397972107,
-0.24884003400802612,
0.5484752058982849,
-0.27775484323501587,
0.11432337760925293,
0.4334283769130707,
0.1662876009941101,
0.3068726360797882,
-0.13591159880161285,
-0.38124674558639526,
-0.13687323033809662,
-0.21071256697177887,
-0.25317367911338806,
-0.5079947710037231,
0.8785116076469421,
-0.42083626985549927,
-0.36561137437820435,
-0.24830326437950134,
-0.5032265186309814,
-0.5220362544059753,
0.212052121758461,
0.3494458496570587,
0.7132720351219177,
-0.817939817905426,
0.04865732416510582,
0.25563251972198486,
-0.07669257372617722,
0.3856073319911957,
0.5519519448280334,
-0.021011540666222572,
-0.3497005105018616,
0.8688134551048279,
0.08728119730949402,
0.3997437357902527,
0.1145988404750824,
0.4287892282009125,
-0.36484014987945557,
-0.6653165817260742,
-0.5130779147148132,
0.14213766157627106,
-0.4403052031993866,
-0.5502409934997559,
-0.6850690841674805,
-0.1842731535434723,
-0.2921135425567627,
-0.06740777939558029,
-0.5382248759269714,
-0.6855005621910095,
-0.09231443703174591,
-0.36880385875701904,
0.5408215522766113,
0.6990957856178284,
0.03938667103648186,
0.14901702105998993,
-0.9554100632667542,
0.29696789383888245,
0.11760228127241135,
0.8431851863861084,
0.15376220643520355,
-0.5300756692886353,
-0.03217018023133278,
-0.06520548462867737,
-0.47530877590179443,
-0.688751757144928,
0.2585051655769348,
0.36559292674064636,
0.6812440752983093,
0.2765367329120636,
0.2791203260421753,
0.6233169436454773,
-0.5561727285385132,
0.6566982865333557,
0.37897828221321106,
-1.086662769317627,
0.6160967350006104,
-0.10861403495073318,
0.28939783573150635,
0.7311839461326599,
0.08801733702421188,
-0.7156911492347717,
-0.5651238560676575,
-1.0084542036056519,
-0.5089380741119385,
0.3742920756340027,
0.06029849871993065,
0.3628244996070862,
-0.36108162999153137,
-0.007227353751659393,
0.5604124665260315,
0.2652151882648468,
-0.06650979071855545,
-0.3039880096912384,
0.2207774668931961,
-0.19388270378112793,
-0.17455458641052246,
-0.11315584927797318,
0.05659562349319458,
-0.5145650506019592,
0.5146539807319641,
-0.020013896748423576,
0.14316008985042572,
0.14539822936058044,
-0.06167558208107948,
-0.1993086338043213,
0.3267751932144165,
0.25845304131507874,
0.6229051947593689,
-0.2190120667219162,
0.29625269770622253,
0.2643633484840393,
-0.418995201587677,
0.09172417968511581,
0.06711387634277344,
-0.24545840919017792,
0.1918260157108307,
0.5219268202781677,
0.8008021712303162,
0.5767092704772949,
-0.8007875084877014,
0.45491573214530945,
0.10538584738969803,
-0.32452237606048584,
-0.43884867429733276,
0.15983305871486664,
0.07957453280687332,
-0.11070213466882706,
0.14950977265834808,
0.41316261887550354,
0.03678295761346817,
-0.35668566823005676,
0.3435541093349457,
0.41036203503608704,
-0.7612727880477905,
-0.4398851692676544,
0.42975834012031555,
0.49018457531929016,
-0.6773365139961243,
0.6328062415122986,
-0.7531709671020508,
-0.5643271803855896,
0.717325747013092,
0.6473029255867004,
1.0739256143569946,
-0.20247747004032135,
0.5013964772224426,
0.7289143204689026,
0.027426838874816895,
-0.08078831434249878,
0.30569130182266235,
0.1534392237663269,
-0.9292585849761963,
-0.06047260761260986,
-0.8126176595687866,
-0.24913834035396576,
-0.40477898716926575,
-0.7675684094429016,
0.3529611825942993,
-0.6200165152549744,
-0.49620530009269714,
-0.1127403974533081,
0.11557154357433319,
-0.882094144821167,
0.19279831647872925,
0.1807652711868286,
1.4536242485046387,
-0.7760509848594666,
0.705390214920044,
0.5311828255653381,
-0.08908309042453766,
-0.6487473249435425,
-0.1962360441684723,
0.1390044093132019,
-0.38057777285575867,
0.2751513719558716,
0.5343434810638428,
-0.148627370595932,
0.11798732727766037,
0.04441632702946663,
-0.7879013419151306,
1.1813101768493652,
0.09061284363269806,
-0.26720118522644043,
-0.10838346183300018,
-0.19354070723056793,
0.5220431089401245,
-0.4809211790561676,
0.29695403575897217,
0.8945791125297546,
0.698448896408081,
-0.05686134099960327,
-1.0528063774108887,
0.06852040439844131,
-0.315175324678421,
0.16589798033237457,
0.4614747166633606,
-0.39041969180107117,
0.6765859127044678,
-0.6634008288383484,
-0.6302343606948853,
0.28323495388031006,
0.6556867957115173,
0.2637244760990143,
0.2601040303707123,
0.522723376750946,
1.0232434272766113,
0.8246312737464905,
-0.2272358536720276,
1.3099048137664795,
0.12770454585552216,
0.506327748298645,
1.197420597076416,
-0.2898857295513153,
0.9455024600028992,
0.32389962673187256,
-0.6256592869758606,
0.5979667901992798,
0.1704557090997696,
-0.08372858166694641,
0.41465476155281067,
0.47166502475738525,
-0.10245361179113388,
-0.28728336095809937,
-0.23234277963638306,
-0.4922258257865906,
0.5974063277244568,
0.09316258877515793,
-0.36606404185295105,
-0.30782613158226013,
-0.41628435254096985,
-0.0543237067759037,
0.6210194230079651,
0.21337229013442993,
0.6513899564743042,
0.021165048703551292,
-0.6842550039291382,
0.46084001660346985,
0.11044411361217499,
0.9862953424453735,
-0.5645260810852051,
0.11494109034538269,
-0.12378989905118942,
0.20155225694179535,
-0.1846638321876526,
-0.7099146246910095,
0.36510375142097473,
0.10026821494102478,
-0.2362820953130722,
-0.02833465486764908,
0.25655362010002136,
-0.18458150327205658,
-0.8375585079193115,
0.6131299138069153,
0.6241724491119385,
-0.19286832213401794,
0.19339340925216675,
-0.5633018612861633,
-0.06158722937107086,
-0.12629257142543793,
-0.21650485694408417,
0.04425559192895889,
0.43166112899780273,
0.14059606194496155,
0.7049999833106995,
0.5724181532859802,
0.32481247186660767,
0.2346431165933609,
0.20550374686717987,
0.41009941697120667,
-0.9285412430763245,
-0.3416866958141327,
-0.6901962757110596,
0.379884272813797,
-0.23966021835803986,
-0.6817015409469604,
0.8257512450218201,
0.7332697510719299,
0.5757347345352173,
0.1408386081457138,
0.9615287184715271,
-0.3851858973503113,
0.9097581505775452,
-0.28497159481048584,
0.5383588075637817,
-0.37805405259132385,
-0.018986370414495468,
-0.5251162052154541,
-1.310185194015503,
-0.19668637216091156,
0.20092783868312836,
-0.2983129620552063,
0.1672099381685257,
0.814461886882782,
0.5902419090270996,
-0.08096183836460114,
0.5132351517677307,
0.12508539855480194,
-0.007069790735840797,
0.2031932771205902,
0.578667163848877,
0.8323274254798889,
-0.37914392352104187,
0.3924378454685211,
-0.541037380695343,
-0.3080542981624603,
0.047324907034635544,
-1.2506823539733887,
-0.6921923756599426,
-0.4785139858722687,
-0.2974623739719391,
0.015285959467291832,
-0.08014147728681564,
0.7667121887207031,
0.695411741733551,
-0.7842701077461243,
-0.0980079174041748,
-0.22210855782032013,
0.08044762164354324,
-0.33118703961372375,
-0.21138447523117065,
0.16400454938411713,
-0.37272942066192627,
-0.6987668871879578,
0.2638017535209656,
0.06637826561927795,
0.05376409366726875,
-0.5062870979309082,
-0.2642730176448822,
-0.08578180521726608,
-0.0346139520406723,
0.41253453493118286,
0.15395034849643707,
-0.7760596871376038,
-0.5021064281463623,
-0.17448437213897705,
-0.014708718284964561,
-0.008500118739902973,
0.8993313312530518,
-1.0300523042678833,
0.5604450106620789,
0.6501107811927795,
0.46426209807395935,
0.07095802575349808,
0.23349328339099884,
0.8980409502983093,
-0.947571337223053,
0.23012061417102814,
0.35267606377601624,
0.18744564056396484,
0.7208452820777893,
0.081847183406353,
0.37689876556396484,
0.31390905380249023,
-0.2103881686925888,
-0.8364012241363525,
0.38850003480911255,
-0.7244876623153687,
0.1469319760799408,
1.0265955924987793,
-0.005755870137363672,
0.04634881019592285,
0.05826515331864357,
0.10905864834785461,
0.3367641568183899,
-0.40409889817237854,
0.6529470086097717,
0.5097892880439758,
0.09613598138093948,
0.1998424530029297,
-0.7990204095840454,
0.5208119750022888,
0.44058868288993835,
-0.6006408929824829,
0.17690755426883698,
0.2660571038722992,
0.3014543354511261,
0.2540448009967804,
0.38134053349494934,
-0.2871874272823334,
0.09505904465913773,
0.1481720507144928,
0.22372159361839294,
-0.16098088026046753,
-0.15448014438152313,
0.07632993906736374,
0.0013257738901302218,
0.21771469712257385,
-0.06074574962258339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19209v1
|
VideoTree: Adaptive Tree-based Video Representation for LLM Reasoning on Long Videos
| 2024-05-29T15:49:09 | 2024-05-29T15:49:09 |
Ziyang Wang, Shoubin Yu, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Jaehong Yoon, Feng Cheng, Gedas Bertasius, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Video-language understanding tasks have focused on short video clips, often
struggling with long-form video understanding tasks. Recently, many long
video-language understanding approaches have leveraged the reasoning
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform long video QA,
transforming videos into densely sampled frame captions, and asking LLMs to
respond to text queries over captions. However, the frames used for captioning
are often redundant and contain irrelevant information, making dense sampling
inefficient, and ignoring the fact that video QA requires varying levels of
granularity, with some video segments being highly relevant to the question
(needing more fine-grained detail) while others being less relevant. Thus,
these LLM-based approaches are prone to missing information and operate on
large numbers of irrelevant captions, lowering both performance and efficiency.
To address these issues, we introduce VideoTree, a query-adaptive and
hierarchical framework for long-video understanding with LLMs. VideoTree
dynamically extracts query-related information from a video and builds a
tree-based representation for LLM reasoning. First, VideoTree adaptively
selects frames for captioning by iteratively clustering frames based on their
visual features and scoring clusters using their relevance to the query.
Second, it organizes visual clusters into a query-adaptive and hierarchical
tree structure; the tree encodes varying levels of granularity, with higher
resolution on relevant segments. Finally, VideoTree produces an answer by
traversing the tree's keyframes and passing their captions to an LLM answerer.
Our method improves both reasoning accuracy and efficiency compared to existing
methods: VideoTree achieves a 7.0%, 2.2%, and 2.7% accuracy gain over baselines
on the EgoSchema, NExT-QA, and IntentQA benchmarks, respectively, while
reducing inference time by 40%.
|
[
-0.2416970431804657,
-0.8579341173171997,
0.7060472369194031,
0.28163591027259827,
-0.6003279685974121,
0.34950992465019226,
-0.12612028419971466,
-0.1033104658126831,
0.10438471287488937,
0.5074237585067749,
-0.6331672668457031,
-0.5280951857566833,
-0.5249201655387878,
-0.17608697712421417,
-0.44793495535850525,
0.66852867603302,
-0.20417410135269165,
-0.15563221275806427,
-0.48570388555526733,
-0.5495634078979492,
-0.5200223922729492,
-0.2439998835325241,
-0.5810838937759399,
0.11821122467517853,
0.2604610323905945,
0.4030781090259552,
0.8181252479553223,
0.8626992106437683,
0.5347360968589783,
0.3698442876338959,
-0.15642733871936798,
0.30414876341819763,
-0.3997044861316681,
0.2406117469072342,
-0.15919245779514313,
-0.373627632856369,
-0.4077342450618744,
-0.5973357558250427,
0.9343937635421753,
0.44489991664886475,
-0.09349145740270615,
0.3259267210960388,
-0.12933796644210815,
0.8290367126464844,
-0.7800995111465454,
0.3961377739906311,
-0.8939606547355652,
0.19166988134384155,
-0.010493140667676926,
-0.7004335522651672,
-0.24529682099819183,
-0.060832489281892776,
-0.08919386565685272,
-0.7154468894004822,
0.32329198718070984,
0.07552475482225418,
0.7055768966674805,
0.7285242080688477,
-0.26199087500572205,
0.10271218419075012,
-0.6473557353019714,
0.45702698826789856,
-0.44894537329673767,
0.4516458809375763,
0.505349338054657,
0.6665247678756714,
-0.045202840119600296,
-0.46067312359809875,
-0.3332975506782532,
-0.06167310103774071,
0.14630018174648285,
0.253497451543808,
-0.31934380531311035,
0.33967384696006775,
0.601347029209137,
0.39211732149124146,
-0.6803197264671326,
0.08631310611963272,
-0.039720237255096436,
-0.12488381564617157,
0.4814554750919342,
0.17152126133441925,
0.2643248438835144,
-0.4588126540184021,
-0.1295260339975357,
-0.1774117350578308,
-0.5662204623222351,
0.3216871917247772,
-0.05368811637163162,
-0.16763484477996826,
0.1470959484577179,
0.5156749486923218,
-0.4218306541442871,
0.8445528745651245,
0.14785747230052948,
-0.26113417744636536,
0.05992564931511879,
-0.27948305010795593,
-0.8373739719390869,
0.10480073094367981,
0.577771782875061,
0.6457340121269226,
0.35580509901046753,
0.15527817606925964,
-0.0689350813627243,
0.00816793367266655,
-0.04571177437901497,
-0.9028483033180237,
-0.33933502435684204,
0.20655591785907745,
-0.3130611181259155,
0.16566245257854462,
-0.0663604661822319,
-0.7435224056243896,
-0.3761015832424164,
-0.05047713592648506,
0.26854342222213745,
-0.2769981920719147,
0.002077431185171008,
0.0607602596282959,
0.10416998714208603,
0.385547399520874,
0.6841395497322083,
-0.8070708513259888,
0.4792638421058655,
0.5044063925743103,
0.7494210004806519,
-0.16597767174243927,
-0.278516560792923,
-1.1763732433319092,
0.4741520583629608,
-0.3531334698200226,
0.5645067095756531,
-0.4421720802783966,
0.14487025141716003,
0.05275077372789383,
0.3548220098018646,
0.09323803335428238,
-0.6267324686050415,
0.08069659769535065,
-0.7940271496772766,
0.04210713133215904,
0.02399047464132309,
-0.40100279450416565,
-0.41750168800354004,
0.4716056287288666,
-0.699173629283905,
0.8503759503364563,
0.009088767692446709,
-0.5610724091529846,
0.4177412986755371,
-0.47497063875198364,
-0.279183566570282,
-0.016425209119915962,
-0.24726153910160065,
-0.5290898084640503,
-0.05923236161470413,
0.8091863393783569,
0.42907002568244934,
-0.05616869404911995,
0.5219092965126038,
-0.2805725038051605,
-0.2614758312702179,
0.012114294804632664,
-0.7360215783119202,
0.28697124123573303,
0.026064421981573105,
-0.14634457230567932,
0.37814274430274963,
-0.4273715019226074,
-0.0830625668168068,
-0.037537917494773865,
-0.061258476227521896,
-0.03245459124445915,
0.3213406801223755,
-0.3317842483520508,
-0.10051911324262619,
-0.08238108456134796,
-0.25888070464134216,
0.1331855058670044,
-0.1690729558467865,
0.6739530563354492,
0.7863988280296326,
0.0781305730342865,
0.37430909276008606,
-0.04071078449487686,
0.7694759368896484,
0.04613349586725235,
0.15809978544712067,
-0.5623984336853027,
-0.22146618366241455,
-0.5120029449462891,
0.015980003401637077,
-0.16441679000854492,
0.47127270698547363,
-0.8650501370429993,
-0.05207806080579758,
-0.5578405857086182,
0.04285966232419014,
-0.2353804111480713,
0.37475264072418213,
0.19217142462730408,
0.27491042017936707,
0.5023348331451416,
-0.4429963529109955,
-0.5721632838249207,
-0.6892683506011963,
-0.0011369333369657397,
-0.5308682918548584,
0.05425546318292618,
0.5004838705062866,
0.46102258563041687,
0.0825183242559433,
0.9642719626426697,
-0.6591773629188538,
-0.30842462182044983,
-0.050820667296648026,
-0.18603932857513428,
0.34248724579811096,
0.17539812624454498,
0.4888034760951996,
-0.8658028244972229,
-0.43926629424095154,
0.08592178672552109,
-0.6529294848442078,
0.06988178193569183,
-0.5389442443847656,
0.01461170893162489,
0.05470934882760048,
0.7440663576126099,
-0.8290441632270813,
0.2767042815685272,
0.6091485619544983,
-0.17909970879554749,
0.503499448299408,
-0.13909685611724854,
0.20010332763195038,
-0.9895030856132507,
-0.3072102963924408,
-0.15354469418525696,
-0.7340929508209229,
0.05561777204275131,
0.06558451801538467,
-0.16492173075675964,
-0.1269138753414154,
-0.48659539222717285,
0.3232821524143219,
-0.4733976721763611,
-0.5979472398757935,
-0.08759798109531403,
0.31168094277381897,
0.10736995190382004,
0.6533963680267334,
0.15079344809055328,
0.9504616260528564,
0.8154630661010742,
-0.38148656487464905,
0.8483153581619263,
0.08912539482116699,
-0.42007753252983093,
0.5577759146690369,
-0.3601248860359192,
-0.1499919593334198,
-0.3503178060054779,
0.3854750096797943,
-0.948035717010498,
-0.6001988649368286,
0.24011044204235077,
-0.5416198968887329,
0.06263178586959839,
-0.6509188413619995,
-0.2383844554424286,
-0.3184075355529785,
-0.3539351522922516,
0.6423298716545105,
0.32591259479522705,
-0.7383453249931335,
0.7048834562301636,
0.1952427178621292,
-0.22568151354789734,
-0.5781285166740417,
-0.5326948165893555,
0.3394021689891815,
-0.4797498285770416,
-0.7372996211051941,
0.4801288843154907,
-0.028281057253479958,
-0.10484049469232559,
0.21241427958011627,
-0.5577295422554016,
-0.45239248871803284,
-0.07306807488203049,
0.3508935570716858,
-0.03906702995300293,
-0.4507918357849121,
0.36281442642211914,
-0.005246636923402548,
0.11217886954545975,
0.27277305722236633,
-0.2593013644218445,
0.1875220090150833,
-0.13700924813747406,
-0.484539270401001,
-0.3797268867492676,
0.3424394428730011,
0.787430465221405,
-0.26364782452583313,
0.08677268773317337,
0.518519401550293,
-0.36134710907936096,
-0.23901446163654327,
-0.5095899105072021,
-0.005594331305474043,
-0.45678234100341797,
0.953651487827301,
-0.3902771472930908,
-1.1022932529449463,
0.3944525122642517,
0.0779251903295517,
-0.06700683385133743,
0.009003638289868832,
0.4025777578353882,
-0.4178079664707184,
1.1748768091201782,
0.26679328083992004,
-0.17022192478179932,
0.8562403321266174,
-0.29858508706092834,
-0.1542309671640396,
-0.5329742431640625,
-0.1021774411201477,
-0.022365475073456764,
-0.11806783080101013,
-0.3900223970413208,
-0.9399722218513489,
0.29719844460487366,
0.2651861608028412,
-0.4500865936279297,
0.13666439056396484,
-0.2723882794380188,
0.8934260010719299,
0.16653932631015778,
0.08648085594177246,
0.4490090608596802,
0.23444832861423492,
0.4937077760696411,
0.06080138310790062,
-0.7544294595718384,
-0.3426726758480072,
0.5382792353630066,
0.5681999325752258,
0.8681429624557495,
0.4122006893157959,
0.327197402715683,
0.3917333781719208,
0.08422628790140152,
-1.1556669473648071,
0.7444714307785034,
-0.20489037036895752,
-0.24503210186958313,
-0.31816986203193665,
-0.47254472970962524,
-0.8363555073738098,
0.243245929479599,
0.08495550602674484,
-0.7626098394393921,
-0.3259161114692688,
0.36008888483047485,
-0.49035438895225525,
0.5179370045661926,
-0.5568175315856934,
0.9352376461029053,
-0.5039336681365967,
-0.5488346815109253,
-0.3734883964061737,
-0.5625549554824829,
0.3494871258735657,
0.2177726775407791,
0.1998293697834015,
0.011157951317727566,
0.12335905432701111,
0.7731769680976868,
-0.3707304298877716,
0.7546730637550354,
-0.2581503391265869,
0.26564207673072815,
0.5904003381729126,
0.37720784544944763,
0.5306624174118042,
0.3712288439273834,
0.48849013447761536,
-0.5610556602478027,
0.2966148853302002,
-0.35980600118637085,
-1.1236289739608765,
0.38099321722984314,
-0.5967553853988647,
-1.0954302549362183,
-0.4168979823589325,
-0.5397878885269165,
-0.1673334240913391,
0.0058877598494291306,
-0.4196450412273407,
0.3361737132072449,
0.10035297274589539,
0.5201391577720642,
0.75953209400177,
-0.30381327867507935,
0.5377912521362305,
0.21103869378566742,
-0.6059842109680176,
-0.5710626840591431,
0.7581095695495605,
-0.23974207043647766,
0.44051334261894226,
0.6621761918067932,
0.01594468764960766,
-0.3079265058040619,
-0.8346928358078003,
-0.7286072373390198,
0.04649737849831581,
-0.820145845413208,
-0.4982040822505951,
-0.32973775267601013,
-0.22315973043441772,
-0.05157268047332764,
0.02095833048224449,
-0.24620962142944336,
-0.2178388386964798,
-0.1745033860206604,
-0.475515753030777,
0.6700550317764282,
0.3370257616043091,
0.2920859456062317,
0.5499020218849182,
-0.9476054906845093,
0.6164964437484741,
0.7161781191825867,
0.5038330554962158,
-0.19656838476657867,
-0.8038743138313293,
-0.11971752345561981,
-0.2212974578142166,
-0.336402028799057,
-0.9700265526771545,
0.22188933193683624,
0.34005728363990784,
0.33446404337882996,
0.32718005776405334,
-0.3176751434803009,
1.2169615030288696,
-0.32921716570854187,
0.7483198642730713,
0.17999766767024994,
-0.8977536559104919,
0.6010445952415466,
-0.32753369212150574,
0.2751481533050537,
0.508137583732605,
0.14049458503723145,
-0.5288174748420715,
0.05244320631027222,
-0.3553440570831299,
-0.7694764137268066,
0.6618832349777222,
0.14837540686130524,
0.14211776852607727,
0.32384100556373596,
0.14948473870754242,
-0.27637940645217896,
-0.1831299066543579,
-0.9744200706481934,
0.351296603679657,
-0.3532564043998718,
-0.0722413957118988,
0.002516733482480049,
-0.12061594426631927,
-0.053647737950086594,
-0.35815438628196716,
0.4712994396686554,
-0.6883209347724915,
-0.037402596324682236,
0.32599514722824097,
-0.4131377637386322,
-0.21008960902690887,
0.24183468520641327,
0.19746634364128113,
0.7538537383079529,
-0.579495370388031,
0.2648899555206299,
0.47021982073783875,
-0.2811424732208252,
0.1496133804321289,
-0.0731583908200264,
0.023522188887000084,
-0.0017897371435537934,
0.6452838182449341,
0.9754183888435364,
0.07633408904075623,
-0.9252968430519104,
0.6491904258728027,
0.22950756549835205,
-0.21421214938163757,
-0.28121086955070496,
-0.09258183091878891,
0.09624150395393372,
0.27608880400657654,
0.1905999481678009,
-0.014840207062661648,
-0.07075478881597519,
-0.6702772974967957,
0.3146404027938843,
0.4755668342113495,
-0.4203978478908539,
-0.17554903030395508,
0.5654377937316895,
0.10202285647392273,
-0.29871976375579834,
0.6301767230033875,
-0.11289991438388824,
-0.5785831809043884,
0.7370080947875977,
0.25874707102775574,
0.8187288641929626,
0.15561270713806152,
0.4655168056488037,
0.4237712025642395,
0.1124003604054451,
-0.08851711452007294,
0.05698981136083603,
-0.496093213558197,
-0.4997861385345459,
-1.0912116765975952,
-0.5920838117599487,
-0.35665562748908997,
0.06694023311138153,
-0.45506051182746887,
0.1373775601387024,
-0.3879651129245758,
0.037444308400154114,
-0.21698316931724548,
-0.24614578485488892,
-0.3794512450695038,
0.31762081384658813,
0.20566217601299286,
1.0418955087661743,
-0.8400202393531799,
0.8647372722625732,
0.6203551292419434,
-0.31316113471984863,
-0.784247875213623,
-0.08579797297716141,
-0.21338452398777008,
-0.7245725393295288,
0.49505674839019775,
0.2069987952709198,
-0.23737342655658722,
-0.23406071960926056,
-0.5079481601715088,
-0.9631264209747314,
1.2508374452590942,
0.42832234501838684,
-0.7036308646202087,
-0.1584106683731079,
0.25317850708961487,
0.4486099183559418,
-0.33372679352760315,
0.30287307500839233,
0.48809289932250977,
0.32084333896636963,
0.5503115653991699,
-0.6528739333152771,
-0.13320855796337128,
-0.08070827275514603,
-0.15721866488456726,
0.10120125859975815,
-0.42020565271377563,
0.39940017461776733,
-0.27966728806495667,
-0.21235644817352295,
0.010187110863626003,
0.7368596792221069,
0.4165683686733246,
0.5950835943222046,
0.7290149331092834,
0.4742405116558075,
0.5606855750083923,
0.07854659855365753,
0.8427711129188538,
0.00598554452881217,
0.3229583501815796,
1.4509944915771484,
0.15381044149398804,
0.7570943236351013,
0.7752326726913452,
-0.4913160800933838,
0.4226020276546478,
0.9436065554618835,
0.0920293852686882,
0.25727006793022156,
0.2273234724998474,
-0.08903570473194122,
-0.7621771097183228,
-0.04504648223519325,
-0.12054886668920517,
0.5585114359855652,
0.2696398198604584,
-0.3665415346622467,
-0.3327503800392151,
-0.244100421667099,
-0.29892870783805847,
0.18641379475593567,
-0.5763407945632935,
0.7585877180099487,
0.08774712681770325,
-0.9107845425605774,
0.5922415256500244,
-0.3433256149291992,
0.2409241646528244,
-0.515142023563385,
-0.20001618564128876,
-0.3086823523044586,
0.009651001542806625,
-0.5106927156448364,
-1.1482590436935425,
0.4040719270706177,
0.27532294392585754,
-0.1827741414308548,
-0.2536182105541229,
0.39043065905570984,
-0.434844046831131,
-0.41388919949531555,
0.23157861828804016,
0.4440169930458069,
0.21332834661006927,
-0.3500283360481262,
-0.6883687376976013,
0.14608345925807953,
0.070462167263031,
-0.0694115161895752,
0.19690059125423431,
0.4764578938484192,
-0.4853827953338623,
0.8377293944358826,
0.5187638401985168,
-0.010087365284562111,
-0.05080462619662285,
0.2916024923324585,
0.90312659740448,
-0.7617157101631165,
-0.3494083881378174,
-1.021401047706604,
0.33851057291030884,
-0.007606772240251303,
0.148762047290802,
0.480047345161438,
0.6501761078834534,
0.8067188262939453,
0.05422932282090187,
0.4305803179740906,
0.06091258302330971,
-0.15253815054893494,
-0.9244492650032043,
0.056998223066329956,
-0.70148766040802,
0.4172593355178833,
-0.3277566730976105,
-1.2270280122756958,
-0.5491794347763062,
0.40264612436294556,
-0.3062577545642853,
-0.08870678395032883,
0.6680965423583984,
0.9438165426254272,
-0.38950639963150024,
-0.12373215705156326,
0.21888801455497742,
0.48420122265815735,
0.5662786364555359,
0.9392491579055786,
1.1006443500518799,
-0.21306270360946655,
0.9128032922744751,
-0.08028854429721832,
-0.08943696320056915,
-0.0872742310166359,
-1.0508534908294678,
-0.6374074220657349,
-0.38077276945114136,
-0.439867228269577,
-0.15736527740955353,
0.2369694858789444,
0.8619895577430725,
0.8575432896614075,
-0.6872312426567078,
-0.3977106213569641,
-0.17519450187683105,
0.4668182134628296,
-0.24891692399978638,
-0.2602889835834503,
0.647513747215271,
0.03454959765076637,
-0.5015891790390015,
0.3811289966106415,
0.5421063899993896,
-0.18832765519618988,
-0.24664905667304993,
-0.1839754283428192,
0.026871535927057266,
-0.24274395406246185,
0.8395400643348694,
0.32898980379104614,
-0.8544479012489319,
-0.61174476146698,
-0.07364736497402191,
0.36445191502571106,
0.594035267829895,
0.7436506748199463,
-0.972027063369751,
0.6593417525291443,
0.6628188490867615,
0.7309224009513855,
0.9982261657714844,
0.42754724621772766,
0.14840887486934662,
-0.651587188243866,
-0.039446230977773666,
0.33806994557380676,
0.3930489420890808,
0.5008933544158936,
-0.1456812620162964,
0.4236777424812317,
0.3095735013484955,
-0.4185895025730133,
-0.8028956651687622,
0.4850725829601288,
-1.5421346426010132,
-0.2537364661693573,
1.1338438987731934,
-0.1479877382516861,
-0.4994669258594513,
0.11134945601224899,
-0.472417950630188,
0.013815187849104404,
-0.3995591998100281,
0.5574710965156555,
0.488311231136322,
-0.18593661487102509,
-0.8077409863471985,
-0.5341702103614807,
0.4298311769962311,
0.6321604251861572,
-0.7950299978256226,
0.43602919578552246,
0.6384232640266418,
0.3186579942703247,
-0.15256333351135254,
0.7384548187255859,
0.06746445596218109,
0.5848608613014221,
-0.3574003577232361,
-0.46294888854026794,
-0.16397807002067566,
-0.49712270498275757,
-0.25596439838409424,
0.30925804376602173,
0.224326029419899,
-0.29058709740638733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19186v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19186v1
|
MetaToken: Detecting Hallucination in Image Descriptions by Meta Classification
| 2024-05-29T15:28:42 | 2024-05-29T15:28:42 |
Laura Fieback, Jakob Spiegelberg, Hanno Gottschalk
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.4
|
Large Vision Language Models (LVLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in
multimodal tasks like visual question answering or image captioning. However,
inconsistencies between the visual information and the generated text, a
phenomenon referred to as hallucinations, remain an unsolved problem with
regard to the trustworthiness of LVLMs. To address this problem, recent works
proposed to incorporate computationally costly Large (Vision) Language Models
in order to detect hallucinations on a sentence- or subsentence-level. In this
work, we introduce MetaToken, a lightweight binary classifier to detect
hallucinations on the token-level at negligible cost. Based on a statistical
analysis, we reveal key factors of hallucinations in LVLMs which have been
overseen in previous works. MetaToken can be applied to any open-source LVLM
without any knowledge about ground truth data providing a reliable detection of
hallucinations. We evaluate our method on four state-of-the-art LVLMs
demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.4896017909049988,
-0.679851770401001,
0.5633687376976013,
0.0185611080378294,
-0.70115065574646,
-0.357881098985672,
0.07651826739311218,
-0.6696292757987976,
0.4787875711917877,
0.7971602082252502,
-0.3074309229850769,
-0.5825637578964233,
-0.6314740777015686,
0.12017548829317093,
-0.48959049582481384,
0.6745263934135437,
0.1441245675086975,
0.20324526727199554,
-0.27460992336273193,
-0.27765464782714844,
-0.5000129342079163,
-0.4678875207901001,
-0.41984251141548157,
-0.049186963587999344,
0.5998212695121765,
0.08236505836248398,
0.8152158856391907,
0.3723709285259247,
0.7000839114189148,
0.20582866668701172,
0.27836382389068604,
0.3800588548183441,
-0.17668774724006653,
0.22298452258110046,
-0.037340760231018066,
-0.092413529753685,
-0.17051559686660767,
-0.3992263674736023,
0.27430278062820435,
0.34884071350097656,
-0.06987572461366653,
0.18875251710414886,
-0.147536501288414,
0.517619252204895,
-0.9546224474906921,
0.3300638496875763,
-0.7410242557525635,
0.4473867118358612,
-0.09335075318813324,
-0.33451855182647705,
-0.5240780711174011,
-0.05463534593582153,
0.012285629287362099,
-0.32338276505470276,
0.4239433705806732,
0.37006813287734985,
0.4212411642074585,
0.6209364533424377,
-0.05396154522895813,
-0.4280770421028137,
-0.5231163501739502,
0.47715047001838684,
-0.5156336426734924,
0.5693270564079285,
0.35606062412261963,
0.38371962308883667,
-0.037549007683992386,
-0.8231101036071777,
-0.7645230293273926,
-0.30750274658203125,
-0.449341744184494,
-0.22540701925754547,
-0.14321410655975342,
0.13692498207092285,
0.3625444173812866,
0.0750143900513649,
-0.6898270845413208,
-0.1673233062028885,
-0.5031939744949341,
-0.6434221267700195,
0.2262023538351059,
0.18140341341495514,
0.3861464858055115,
-0.5700694918632507,
-0.13974198698997498,
-0.0010939029743894935,
-0.2101864069700241,
-0.3017224669456482,
0.07990406453609467,
0.033994611352682114,
0.27902501821517944,
0.8206353187561035,
0.14496280252933502,
0.5787233710289001,
-0.09846197813749313,
-0.26473161578178406,
0.3233755826950073,
-0.07313044369220734,
-0.25749635696411133,
0.3581176698207855,
0.7730018496513367,
0.6566222310066223,
0.30738916993141174,
-0.3748137652873993,
-0.3210199177265167,
0.13089753687381744,
0.32348111271858215,
-0.9768614172935486,
-0.2749927341938019,
0.1573410928249359,
-0.9680278301239014,
-0.5810920000076294,
0.2450232207775116,
-1.119308352470398,
-0.9285038709640503,
-0.015423061326146126,
0.5221410989761353,
-0.33611056208610535,
-0.25541815161705017,
0.06969863921403885,
-0.23545806109905243,
0.2993331253528595,
0.018559448421001434,
-0.7873665690422058,
0.1180219054222107,
0.5305588245391846,
1.0882562398910522,
-0.36391404271125793,
-0.42327776551246643,
-0.7576858401298523,
-0.005178406834602356,
-0.4532783329486847,
0.7434293627738953,
-0.5499621629714966,
-0.21019726991653442,
-0.01682140678167343,
0.2643786370754242,
0.19562599062919617,
-0.7552978992462158,
0.5459142327308655,
-0.09446044266223907,
0.0004776800924446434,
-0.20231926441192627,
-0.19499646127223969,
-0.09277650713920593,
0.24832160770893097,
-0.997896134853363,
0.791847825050354,
-0.14041411876678467,
-1.1348695755004883,
0.4445696771144867,
-0.5113500952720642,
-0.32269594073295593,
0.3145700693130493,
-0.43482330441474915,
-0.4793950617313385,
0.5185168981552124,
0.2872174382209778,
0.5143728852272034,
0.11817190796136856,
0.33301299810409546,
-0.19163282215595245,
-0.7832013964653015,
0.4920288324356079,
-0.4321184754371643,
0.32762062549591064,
0.12787452340126038,
-0.698937714099884,
0.22004662454128265,
-0.813297688961029,
-0.23159541189670563,
0.05323231220245361,
0.22927366197109222,
-0.4111541509628296,
-0.0025824469048529863,
0.011656217277050018,
0.008254623040556908,
-0.031253132969141006,
-0.36940985918045044,
-0.009593216702342033,
-0.17985372245311737,
0.23306749761104584,
0.6826707124710083,
-0.05797750875353813,
0.2793491780757904,
0.07380545139312744,
0.32569077610969543,
0.30460125207901,
0.4501364827156067,
-0.27016422152519226,
-0.4724898338317871,
-0.8740262389183044,
-0.24636685848236084,
0.021467894315719604,
0.33530351519584656,
-1.0400298833847046,
0.3532062768936157,
-0.15973703563213348,
-0.04452110081911087,
-0.6483269333839417,
-0.06493514776229858,
0.15521042048931122,
0.4076831340789795,
0.4843042492866516,
-0.055493537336587906,
-0.6052191257476807,
-1.07939875125885,
-0.15651458501815796,
-0.1069110780954361,
0.09051627665758133,
0.42704349756240845,
0.7217451930046082,
-0.7342613339424133,
0.49815624952316284,
-0.4485260844230652,
-0.5912340879440308,
0.3126659095287323,
0.39787372946739197,
-0.26897868514060974,
0.3377321660518646,
0.5680945515632629,
-0.8267588019371033,
-0.13422681391239166,
-0.04058617725968361,
-0.8667230606079102,
-0.10462337732315063,
-0.04737022891640663,
0.12168514728546143,
0.5983001589775085,
0.6677047610282898,
-0.6696617603302002,
0.7503835558891296,
0.5737208127975464,
-0.34200340509414673,
0.587974488735199,
-0.19697438180446625,
0.210406094789505,
-0.836864173412323,
0.17261934280395508,
-0.43144461512565613,
-0.18338465690612793,
-0.28956618905067444,
0.087178535759449,
-0.05567697063088417,
-0.20709629356861115,
-0.3016729950904846,
0.39212626218795776,
-0.3544903099536896,
-0.3239179253578186,
-0.4627581536769867,
-0.05041418597102165,
-0.24999894201755524,
0.3882710039615631,
0.3333785831928253,
0.5368658900260925,
0.8102045059204102,
-0.15571962296962738,
0.6510099768638611,
-0.13521775603294373,
-0.3574749231338501,
0.4822966456413269,
-0.42128217220306396,
0.2729034423828125,
-0.5262143611907959,
0.20721936225891113,
-0.9183024168014526,
-0.36413609981536865,
0.7424784898757935,
-0.38418129086494446,
-0.08587850630283356,
0.08213413506746292,
-0.6362909078598022,
-0.43126752972602844,
-0.2854938507080078,
0.5500721335411072,
0.3159634470939636,
-0.6685506701469421,
0.9551545977592468,
-0.053719330579042435,
0.4789561331272125,
-0.8837748765945435,
-0.9043839573860168,
0.4254733622074127,
0.05653136223554611,
-0.1757834404706955,
-0.046334028244018555,
-0.008862216025590897,
-0.026337623596191406,
0.37991276383399963,
-0.05946119874715805,
-0.02686431258916855,
-0.22979579865932465,
0.6090689301490784,
0.09060826897621155,
-0.09803495556116104,
0.47935476899147034,
-0.30007225275039673,
-0.2897823750972748,
0.16916000843048096,
-0.6081498265266418,
0.6120671629905701,
-0.16467280685901642,
-0.3902546465396881,
-0.2791830003261566,
0.26875752210617065,
1.0319688320159912,
-0.2430851310491562,
0.9165058135986328,
1.0213992595672607,
-0.7173994183540344,
-0.25874990224838257,
-0.7818107604980469,
-0.4199773669242859,
-0.4028776288032532,
0.41710060834884644,
-0.3538016974925995,
-0.5531212091445923,
0.4503617286682129,
0.27569833397865295,
-0.3972751200199127,
0.27369415760040283,
0.19561991095542908,
0.11805704981088638,
1.0115582942962646,
0.4514019191265106,
0.17217472195625305,
0.1290905624628067,
0.017638280987739563,
0.3837302029132843,
-0.49044620990753174,
-0.6478385925292969,
-0.07341507822275162,
-0.36438652873039246,
-0.48063966631889343,
-0.6468759179115295,
0.27520957589149475,
-0.32153335213661194,
0.14826561510562897,
-0.06337383389472961,
-0.8318122625350952,
0.8437085151672363,
0.3886691629886627,
0.25044065713882446,
0.28158652782440186,
0.09073005616664886,
-0.08037832379341125,
-0.17503909766674042,
-0.2559719681739807,
-0.4061812162399292,
0.8808096647262573,
0.12906470894813538,
0.7356968522071838,
-0.234593465924263,
0.5100488662719727,
0.5141934156417847,
0.18959562480449677,
-0.8244979381561279,
0.6882561445236206,
-0.1857239156961441,
-0.5864040851593018,
-0.3248457908630371,
-0.4908919930458069,
-0.5594996809959412,
0.3576454222202301,
-0.591733992099762,
-0.549984872341156,
0.16801467537879944,
0.16962072253227234,
-0.06221131235361099,
0.5241506099700928,
-0.24313578009605408,
0.9185320138931274,
-0.43420785665512085,
-0.039120107889175415,
-0.14285168051719666,
-0.5604806542396545,
0.609132707118988,
-0.212729811668396,
0.17056836187839508,
0.184164360165596,
-0.07110555469989777,
0.643571138381958,
-0.22488678991794586,
0.8440195322036743,
-0.27187201380729675,
0.017265604808926582,
0.26829853653907776,
0.1466449499130249,
0.5000014901161194,
-0.055231861770153046,
0.3396766781806946,
0.1925310641527176,
0.019299080595374107,
-0.31812408566474915,
-0.8629297018051147,
0.6602120995521545,
-0.4150386452674866,
-0.2128821760416031,
-0.424392431974411,
-0.37148377299308777,
0.13083593547344208,
0.2235659658908844,
0.651706337928772,
0.36197495460510254,
-0.08250628411769867,
0.36268725991249084,
0.8448813557624817,
-0.4821786880493164,
0.3300565481185913,
-0.0013176327338442206,
-0.7023318409919739,
-0.87134850025177,
0.789137065410614,
0.05031823739409447,
-0.14884352684020996,
0.13692930340766907,
0.2758452892303467,
-0.20341359078884125,
-0.503689169883728,
-0.43443652987480164,
0.30592039227485657,
-0.9718661308288574,
-0.2472190409898758,
-0.9239158034324646,
-0.14397138357162476,
-0.378582239151001,
0.01482347585260868,
-0.20781056582927704,
-0.19773288071155548,
-0.23175230622291565,
-0.2662683427333832,
0.11963722854852676,
0.6273865103721619,
0.021994417533278465,
0.12443872541189194,
-0.6027304530143738,
0.642297089099884,
0.48553478717803955,
0.45579278469085693,
0.24971044063568115,
-0.14179910719394684,
-0.07239203155040741,
-0.05729324370622635,
0.06292784214019775,
-0.8303738236427307,
0.26026004552841187,
-0.04949624836444855,
0.47814902663230896,
0.8630834817886353,
0.19282624125480652,
0.6600143909454346,
-0.4255025088787079,
0.840653121471405,
0.4953298568725586,
-1.0645272731781006,
0.4472202956676483,
0.32135793566703796,
-0.08655193448066711,
0.4512229561805725,
0.2703113555908203,
-0.49759751558303833,
-0.40506425499916077,
-0.38092339038848877,
-0.3319505453109741,
0.21943354606628418,
0.11533845961093903,
0.2371860295534134,
-0.04240773245692253,
0.5793867707252502,
0.3158097565174103,
0.2958962321281433,
-1.1431013345718384,
-0.07089381664991379,
-0.5866650342941284,
-0.37035003304481506,
-0.03276593238115311,
-0.4442429840564728,
0.004151218105107546,
-0.35703322291374207,
0.20816799998283386,
-0.3456658720970154,
0.30659863352775574,
0.31913867592811584,
-0.35737964510917664,
-0.231699138879776,
-0.12330120801925659,
0.8928743600845337,
0.541573703289032,
-0.30844664573669434,
0.8866913318634033,
0.34668606519699097,
-0.6559441089630127,
0.007975306361913681,
-0.35644981265068054,
-0.16379442811012268,
0.3970798850059509,
0.7188781499862671,
0.8861011266708374,
0.056731484830379486,
-0.7731969952583313,
0.8531015515327454,
-0.11242656409740448,
-0.4791445732116699,
-0.25414299964904785,
-0.20020340383052826,
-0.1437627524137497,
0.33643481135368347,
0.30030080676078796,
0.16576838493347168,
0.34847962856292725,
-0.6801414489746094,
0.24216367304325104,
0.5851505398750305,
-0.6788294315338135,
-0.32016322016716003,
0.5401670932769775,
0.04978909343481064,
-0.4107193052768707,
0.580275297164917,
-0.12011989951133728,
-0.7099623680114746,
0.23970676958560944,
0.47226327657699585,
1.1881084442138672,
-0.16900482773780823,
0.30880144238471985,
0.20133677124977112,
0.7216690182685852,
-0.14542070031166077,
0.11993855237960815,
-0.05734168738126755,
-0.5864267945289612,
-0.2247982770204544,
-0.6284483075141907,
-0.1079695001244545,
0.37102723121643066,
-0.37409764528274536,
0.3303144574165344,
-0.44510284066200256,
-0.1573745757341385,
-0.17337651550769806,
-0.5379394292831421,
-0.4161212742328644,
0.05758131667971611,
0.6185771226882935,
0.4897470772266388,
-0.9134496450424194,
0.5005521178245544,
0.36911121010780334,
-0.3531292974948883,
-0.15272381901741028,
0.18495692312717438,
-0.4303843677043915,
-0.6179642081260681,
0.7761229872703552,
0.6090149283409119,
-0.36028364300727844,
-0.26401734352111816,
-0.8425804972648621,
-0.2744724154472351,
0.9536633491516113,
0.2684728503227234,
-0.485687255859375,
-0.15406304597854614,
0.27958762645721436,
0.49255675077438354,
-0.5207090973854065,
-0.015617851167917252,
0.2645678222179413,
0.7342126369476318,
0.3586485683917999,
-0.5270698666572571,
0.33937937021255493,
0.059252623468637466,
-0.2091745287179947,
0.22280295193195343,
-0.29281333088874817,
0.6706599593162537,
-0.420144647359848,
-0.3069257438182831,
-0.12131526321172714,
0.3978748321533203,
-0.02710568718612194,
0.6698737740516663,
0.7394500970840454,
0.4975491464138031,
0.9425201416015625,
0.040183164179325104,
0.5436291694641113,
-0.22172488272190094,
0.21562185883522034,
0.7875165939331055,
-0.19054317474365234,
0.7458938956260681,
0.5787481069564819,
0.4367310404777527,
0.545961856842041,
0.3814806342124939,
-0.39610451459884644,
0.6419507265090942,
0.27342259883880615,
-0.05239379033446312,
-0.3439640700817108,
0.045066360384225845,
-0.41783416271209717,
0.28709694743156433,
0.09377896040678024,
-0.616310715675354,
0.15508513152599335,
0.6760053634643555,
-0.4553307294845581,
-0.3064112365245819,
-0.24932029843330383,
0.851982593536377,
0.14875763654708862,
-0.539971113204956,
0.6058611273765564,
-0.32098135352134705,
0.6548570990562439,
-0.08266529440879822,
-0.2738220989704132,
-0.09240002185106277,
0.24055135250091553,
-0.4546296000480652,
-0.42864760756492615,
0.5414730906486511,
-0.05054142698645592,
-0.13427560031414032,
0.27269160747528076,
0.9807472229003906,
-0.3998848497867584,
-0.6997713446617126,
0.49313709139823914,
0.23402857780456543,
0.3992513120174408,
-0.390279084444046,
-0.40050768852233887,
0.26610246300697327,
-0.329471617937088,
0.34982505440711975,
-0.14527985453605652,
0.6991134285926819,
0.03918171674013138,
0.6220963001251221,
0.5206989645957947,
-0.023009587079286575,
0.1576305478811264,
0.07601077854633331,
0.6674614548683167,
-0.7818288207054138,
-0.28120124340057373,
-1.1033742427825928,
0.24756748974323273,
-0.1413622349500656,
0.06025351583957672,
0.4999294579029083,
0.6328544020652771,
0.40830546617507935,
-0.45794638991355896,
0.6113620400428772,
0.1863050013780594,
-0.04053816199302673,
-0.4878859221935272,
0.7501511573791504,
-0.7270340919494629,
-0.061121866106987,
-0.31439507007598877,
-1.1504242420196533,
-0.6209184527397156,
0.7216349244117737,
0.06019273400306702,
-0.3015342354774475,
1.0749489068984985,
0.9060693383216858,
-0.1386573612689972,
-0.060310497879981995,
0.5463737845420837,
0.016622204333543777,
0.049834709614515305,
0.31264594197273254,
1.142410397529602,
-0.2746354341506958,
0.8837140798568726,
-0.08914583921432495,
-0.125296488404274,
-0.5548017024993896,
-0.9042190313339233,
-1.3433202505111694,
-0.6916453242301941,
-0.34523582458496094,
-0.5790870189666748,
0.0707954689860344,
0.6472106575965881,
0.6640482544898987,
-0.9044879078865051,
0.15499740839004517,
-0.2385367602109909,
0.17895175516605377,
-0.0799911692738533,
-0.2127312421798706,
0.43911832571029663,
-0.2955746054649353,
-0.33209124207496643,
-0.27911409735679626,
0.4331907629966736,
0.3291025757789612,
-0.6405124068260193,
-0.139698326587677,
0.4370589852333069,
0.20592842996120453,
0.6453297138214111,
-0.2835228443145752,
-1.1079494953155518,
-0.3698752224445343,
0.2517409920692444,
-0.1253349334001541,
-0.05012264847755432,
1.0557245016098022,
-0.6375725269317627,
0.6124230623245239,
0.4348849654197693,
0.5017282366752625,
0.5198594331741333,
-0.14231032133102417,
-0.026217734441161156,
-0.4500599503517151,
0.20575113594532013,
0.15161915123462677,
0.2787918150424957,
0.355354368686676,
-0.4930344521999359,
0.4137951135635376,
0.5058842897415161,
-0.3375469446182251,
-1.0867339372634888,
0.07041256874799728,
-0.8692904710769653,
-0.549591600894928,
0.9528108239173889,
0.357364684343338,
-0.34190890192985535,
0.03684678301215172,
-0.5506336688995361,
-0.06689529865980148,
0.09531482309103012,
0.9979265332221985,
0.7830196619033813,
0.26255425810813904,
-0.5514237284660339,
-0.35861119627952576,
0.6054925918579102,
0.07761017978191376,
-0.665799617767334,
0.25825321674346924,
0.5146293640136719,
-0.005709200166165829,
0.5770875215530396,
0.4759525954723358,
0.053191669285297394,
0.24777570366859436,
0.18144047260284424,
0.25586649775505066,
-0.23634718358516693,
-0.5826842784881592,
-0.21024923026561737,
0.3471108078956604,
-0.2657274305820465,
-0.5055589079856873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19139v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19139v1
|
DGRC: An Effective Fine-tuning Framework for Distractor Generation in Chinese Multi-choice Reading Comprehension
| 2024-05-29T14:47:01 | 2024-05-29T14:47:01 |
Runfeng Lin, Dacheng Xu, Huijiang Wang, Zebiao Chen, Yating Wang, Shouqiang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When evaluating a learner's knowledge proficiency, the multiple-choice
question is an efficient and widely used format in standardized tests.
Nevertheless, generating these questions, particularly plausible distractors
(incorrect options), poses a considerable challenge. Generally, the distractor
generation can be classified into cloze-style distractor generation (CDG) and
natural questions distractor generation (NQDG). In contrast to the CDG,
utilizing pre-trained language models (PLMs) for NQDG presents three primary
challenges: (1) PLMs are typically trained to generate ``correct'' content,
like answers, while rarely trained to generate ``plausible" content, like
distractors; (2) PLMs often struggle to produce content that aligns well with
specific knowledge and the style of exams; (3) NQDG necessitates the model to
produce longer, context-sensitive, and question-relevant distractors. In this
study, we introduce a fine-tuning framework named DGRC for NQDG in Chinese
multi-choice reading comprehension from authentic examinations. DGRC comprises
three major components: hard chain-of-thought, multi-task learning, and
generation mask patterns. The experiment results demonstrate that DGRC
significantly enhances generation performance, achieving a more than 2.5-fold
improvement in BLEU scores.
|
[
-0.580929696559906,
-0.7934475541114807,
0.27441683411598206,
-0.10144855827093124,
-0.38077837228775024,
0.030096933245658875,
-0.2996339499950409,
-0.17320585250854492,
-0.4116230010986328,
0.5926015973091125,
-0.5396415591239929,
-0.3427805006504059,
-0.2714911699295044,
0.27169060707092285,
0.05773743987083435,
1.1556390523910522,
-0.041847724467515945,
-0.15331408381462097,
-0.14709950983524323,
0.155182883143425,
-0.48519396781921387,
-0.11714014410972595,
-0.9642044901847839,
-0.20102182030677795,
0.7416112422943115,
0.3738241195678711,
0.41429492831230164,
0.5486679077148438,
0.4500705301761627,
0.20281121134757996,
-0.135311558842659,
0.6681589484214783,
-0.4572427570819855,
0.09814000129699707,
0.018013183027505875,
-0.3411851227283478,
-0.08417335897684097,
-0.04831599071621895,
0.6896817684173584,
0.3498690128326416,
-0.2886196970939636,
-0.048303063958883286,
0.46162620186805725,
0.6953441500663757,
-0.6972774863243103,
0.050360653549432755,
-0.6977332234382629,
-0.11642811447381973,
-0.04455487057566643,
-0.33173033595085144,
-0.44868579506874084,
-0.37474820017814636,
-0.011541369371116161,
-0.5182421803474426,
0.41937342286109924,
-0.14113149046897888,
0.9137275218963623,
0.5051366686820984,
-0.7500186562538147,
-0.43043839931488037,
-0.389554888010025,
0.7162744402885437,
-0.546561062335968,
0.23826734721660614,
0.38777241110801697,
0.3432713449001312,
-0.18066348135471344,
-0.5018900632858276,
-0.7631636261940002,
-0.49944746494293213,
-0.16158220171928406,
0.6315277218818665,
0.41620784997940063,
0.3289008140563965,
0.4165768325328827,
0.4360009729862213,
-0.6100544929504395,
-0.09536082297563553,
-0.2768395245075226,
-0.0010970610892400146,
0.7742787599563599,
0.22196179628372192,
0.1568540334701538,
-0.27760785818099976,
-0.5227309465408325,
-0.07788171619176865,
-0.5026544332504272,
0.07794506102800369,
0.4739089906215668,
0.06661263108253479,
0.384894460439682,
0.005706699099391699,
-0.19107657670974731,
1.1771732568740845,
0.4485095143318176,
-0.3253253996372223,
0.058216214179992676,
-0.5677717328071594,
0.10157521069049835,
-0.10940863937139511,
0.4607357680797577,
0.20376071333885193,
0.06744493544101715,
0.11470576375722885,
-0.2777162492275238,
-0.22617454826831818,
0.4094458520412445,
-0.8112508654594421,
-0.5594757199287415,
0.3257918059825897,
-0.19164232909679413,
-0.2905198335647583,
0.10538367182016373,
-0.6782301068305969,
-0.12453306466341019,
-0.39430689811706543,
0.228767991065979,
-0.43390604853630066,
0.030406678095459938,
0.19585928320884705,
-0.027615630999207497,
0.39663606882095337,
0.2991904318332672,
-0.9707943797111511,
-0.09032276272773743,
0.23660069704055786,
0.6470855474472046,
-0.4340634047985077,
-0.32657313346862793,
-0.6800373792648315,
0.08653184026479721,
-0.2350941151380539,
0.8158938884735107,
-0.21023523807525635,
-0.23020365834236145,
-0.03786681219935417,
-0.2218838781118393,
-0.4717182219028473,
-0.5518855452537537,
0.5966171622276306,
-0.5451676249504089,
0.16995377838611603,
-0.3311848044395447,
-0.5053420662879944,
-0.09627856314182281,
0.6396536231040955,
-0.6148518919944763,
1.0333644151687622,
0.13917402923107147,
-0.7647883296012878,
0.5683229565620422,
-0.47598546743392944,
-0.3188747465610504,
0.4045243263244629,
0.06500247865915298,
-0.2575836777687073,
-0.30488166213035583,
0.3233894109725952,
0.2769909203052521,
-0.09199745953083038,
0.37616389989852905,
0.137660950422287,
-0.38274121284484863,
0.3203716278076172,
-0.4570735692977905,
0.6568881273269653,
0.25165221095085144,
-0.1324750930070877,
0.08982648700475693,
-0.7866489887237549,
0.30648306012153625,
-0.17503753304481506,
-0.5719160437583923,
-0.17039217054843903,
0.13029848039150238,
-0.048926789313554764,
0.5128960609436035,
0.06686574220657349,
-0.41143712401390076,
-0.045413944870233536,
-0.18916486203670502,
0.1903913915157318,
0.6291477680206299,
0.2063630223274231,
0.07947402447462082,
-0.7323424816131592,
0.3993126451969147,
0.11519523710012436,
0.11215828359127045,
-0.3046071529388428,
-0.26723745465278625,
-0.7001871466636658,
-0.31778597831726074,
0.33228740096092224,
0.6086993217468262,
-1.1061522960662842,
0.49024441838264465,
0.1286037713289261,
-0.6501774787902832,
-0.24578505754470825,
0.12408830970525742,
0.3822440207004547,
0.6105149984359741,
0.38968425989151,
0.07160479575395584,
0.07179496437311172,
-0.3709482252597809,
-0.2969469130039215,
0.0025909910909831524,
-0.05201217532157898,
0.4853975772857666,
0.5071910619735718,
0.14687378704547882,
0.4915383458137512,
-0.8126252889633179,
-0.28493520617485046,
-0.281345933675766,
0.018177861347794533,
-0.01827884279191494,
0.4807480275630951,
0.37258535623550415,
-0.9114218354225159,
-0.7689647078514099,
0.07987953722476959,
-0.17229004204273224,
-0.19360172748565674,
-0.48473429679870605,
-0.3129565417766571,
0.15011483430862427,
0.459434449672699,
-0.30093979835510254,
0.11217724531888962,
0.24796229600906372,
-0.19318121671676636,
0.9456427693367004,
-0.35491201281547546,
0.1543084979057312,
-0.9182747006416321,
0.15756648778915405,
-0.11876680701971054,
0.15537387132644653,
-0.8561851978302002,
0.35200417041778564,
0.2046210616827011,
0.21755743026733398,
-0.4514506459236145,
0.7692133188247681,
-0.3352724015712738,
0.7336284518241882,
-0.3670884370803833,
0.45815175771713257,
0.20859090983867645,
0.4325295388698578,
0.034295182675123215,
0.5288853049278259,
0.4347361624240875,
-0.9326208233833313,
0.13763152062892914,
0.4591341018676758,
-0.253721684217453,
0.47488051652908325,
-0.37217453122138977,
0.12548483908176422,
-0.24034400284290314,
0.128203347325325,
-1.1174025535583496,
-0.2779615819454193,
0.1925402283668518,
-0.21488097310066223,
0.34686434268951416,
0.1673576682806015,
-0.38992100954055786,
-0.5095296502113342,
-0.10248484462499619,
0.3313637673854828,
0.3639155328273773,
-0.8088377714157104,
0.3461688756942749,
-0.11498080939054489,
-0.0936388224363327,
-0.6348043084144592,
-0.6629476547241211,
-0.34724390506744385,
-0.13748018443584442,
-0.5473591089248657,
0.44849467277526855,
-0.42208510637283325,
-0.03473681956529617,
-0.43246766924858093,
-0.2615506947040558,
-0.19782249629497528,
0.1334681510925293,
-0.2444378137588501,
0.21867693960666656,
-0.006307700648903847,
0.24941320717334747,
0.19334781169891357,
0.01584853045642376,
-0.04460233077406883,
-0.07113669812679291,
0.30322909355163574,
0.3313286304473877,
-0.37914279103279114,
-0.009849213995039463,
0.15373964607715607,
0.12947402894496918,
-0.5456990599632263,
0.45694035291671753,
0.6050244569778442,
-0.09472287446260452,
-0.665974497795105,
-0.5789533853530884,
-0.33642393350601196,
-0.49281004071235657,
0.310354620218277,
-0.3802017867565155,
-0.9413787722587585,
0.5995380878448486,
0.1778586059808731,
0.21844486892223358,
0.1550372838973999,
0.4809417724609375,
0.2396400421857834,
0.9898155331611633,
0.09964776039123535,
0.2496543675661087,
0.6460391879081726,
0.163031205534935,
0.06962427496910095,
-0.6748965382575989,
-0.17867788672447205,
-0.22270995378494263,
-0.21181465685367584,
-0.47189703583717346,
-0.4303368031978607,
0.20300117135047913,
0.25703778862953186,
-0.08113939315080643,
-0.22214026749134064,
-0.7176335453987122,
0.6540265083312988,
0.5606348514556885,
0.10507578402757645,
0.29068806767463684,
-0.2710111141204834,
-0.282783180475235,
0.17235969007015228,
-0.7597183585166931,
-0.518001914024353,
0.9267060160636902,
-0.14720459282398224,
0.5135843753814697,
-0.10900675505399704,
0.8775861859321594,
-0.32192152738571167,
0.2145870178937912,
-0.6758716106414795,
0.367002010345459,
-0.24413344264030457,
-0.8562937378883362,
-0.2768964171409607,
-0.5077855587005615,
-0.9437819123268127,
0.6236536502838135,
0.08130066096782684,
-0.4981173574924469,
0.2259717732667923,
0.22523491084575653,
-0.7971258759498596,
0.23641495406627655,
-0.4850347936153412,
0.9586830139160156,
-0.3691480755805969,
-0.40810006856918335,
0.1110134869813919,
-0.5016786456108093,
0.582528293132782,
-0.118377186357975,
-0.30786195397377014,
0.06024285405874252,
0.1798715740442276,
0.35581693053245544,
0.07102706283330917,
0.5102848410606384,
-0.1489691287279129,
-0.06195473670959473,
0.8452095985412598,
0.1308000534772873,
0.282720148563385,
0.3263061046600342,
-0.16046079993247986,
-0.1442757099866867,
0.056638918817043304,
-0.46111905574798584,
-0.40530726313591003,
0.4655408263206482,
-0.5064380168914795,
-0.7237893342971802,
-0.517697811126709,
-0.8423402905464172,
-0.0928160771727562,
0.3865380585193634,
0.1991681605577469,
0.26477134227752686,
-0.3314075171947479,
-0.07073311507701874,
0.8262700438499451,
-0.21882644295692444,
0.49922993779182434,
0.4758525788784027,
0.13935530185699463,
-0.412733256816864,
0.9944884777069092,
0.25910449028015137,
0.5116235613822937,
0.24700956046581268,
0.1361887902021408,
-0.2900988459587097,
-0.7587360739707947,
-0.37616512179374695,
0.1628042459487915,
-0.5249015688896179,
-0.11943371593952179,
-0.4664445221424103,
-0.5373730659484863,
-0.06995482742786407,
-0.10820227861404419,
0.16431422531604767,
0.2291961908340454,
-0.5471212863922119,
-0.18162868916988373,
0.07880350202322006,
0.5587954521179199,
-0.00831849779933691,
0.3479205071926117,
-0.8290988802909851,
0.3907302916049957,
0.5022251605987549,
0.20973430573940277,
-0.04411613196134567,
-0.48078757524490356,
-0.2548128664493561,
0.1636640578508377,
-0.7897462844848633,
-0.6890559196472168,
0.2872401177883148,
0.15217778086662292,
0.5743457674980164,
0.5849018692970276,
0.28337129950523376,
0.5774698853492737,
-0.2930370569229126,
0.8906411528587341,
-0.18466703593730927,
-0.7711166143417358,
0.33564111590385437,
-0.5119326710700989,
0.5018903613090515,
0.6681485176086426,
0.12057333439588547,
-0.5060397982597351,
-0.36379969120025635,
-0.4576883316040039,
-0.6172649264335632,
0.7934798002243042,
0.11298682540655136,
-0.15324462950229645,
-0.3622487187385559,
0.5401450991630554,
0.26957476139068604,
0.1927608996629715,
-0.677858829498291,
-0.15996810793876648,
-0.34783047437667847,
-0.0616772435605526,
-0.20135724544525146,
-0.26734837889671326,
-0.15879705548286438,
-0.11139887571334839,
0.4593800902366638,
-0.48388615250587463,
-0.17493627965450287,
0.4156506061553955,
-0.04325886815786362,
0.13450738787651062,
0.3107762038707733,
0.7413585782051086,
0.5403839349746704,
-0.12732462584972382,
0.004141680896282196,
0.2169678807258606,
-0.500821590423584,
-0.05701718106865883,
0.21560995280742645,
-0.38595256209373474,
-0.15492787957191467,
-0.004794679116457701,
0.6909855008125305,
-0.32516223192214966,
-0.6548640131950378,
0.22732698917388916,
0.10621173679828644,
-0.6170336604118347,
-0.12048383802175522,
0.37386807799339294,
-0.13686829805374146,
-0.0588386170566082,
0.2878628969192505,
-0.06223864480853081,
-0.017331590875983238,
0.0022780706640332937,
0.46533137559890747,
0.32909929752349854,
-0.3561413288116455,
-0.0838218629360199,
0.5644856691360474,
0.291095107793808,
0.1440032422542572,
0.5160835981369019,
-0.6587091684341431,
-0.5456856489181519,
0.7211079001426697,
0.6014288067817688,
0.5971789360046387,
-0.3677375316619873,
0.5113858580589294,
0.7013391852378845,
0.33770298957824707,
-0.2414661943912506,
0.6691218018531799,
-0.125391885638237,
-0.8415210247039795,
-0.44931259751319885,
-0.41223594546318054,
-0.2459813952445984,
0.19581060111522675,
-0.6952680945396423,
0.15046076476573944,
-0.41077208518981934,
0.039765845984220505,
-0.29062628746032715,
0.32268890738487244,
-0.5093715190887451,
0.3903486728668213,
0.3273266851902008,
0.7599731683731079,
-0.5134745836257935,
0.7268865704536438,
0.5745086073875427,
-0.4783685505390167,
-0.9328854084014893,
0.3923777937889099,
-0.33329257369041443,
-0.2775265872478485,
0.4665794372558594,
0.27006903290748596,
0.19130846858024597,
0.19990569353103638,
-0.20621243119239807,
-0.8368126749992371,
1.1081775426864624,
0.1240386962890625,
-0.6181691884994507,
0.04626274108886719,
0.1087818294763565,
0.5676783919334412,
-0.15512767434120178,
0.4570143222808838,
0.6968245506286621,
0.6754649877548218,
0.1616934835910797,
-0.642429769039154,
0.13461615145206451,
-0.0018867520848289132,
-0.16282501816749573,
0.2699010372161865,
-1.0801502466201782,
0.9476401805877686,
-0.3062012195587158,
-0.3766399323940277,
0.017567342147231102,
0.2755540609359741,
0.5997537970542908,
0.31387218832969666,
0.3963523805141449,
0.37210536003112793,
1.0290906429290771,
-0.219892680644989,
0.9384685158729553,
-0.4774855971336365,
0.07869885116815567,
1.012625813484192,
-0.4013758897781372,
0.5163820385932922,
0.47691822052001953,
0.158232644200325,
0.3765242099761963,
0.6876198053359985,
-0.2137403041124344,
0.5068923234939575,
0.4830172061920166,
-0.23227834701538086,
-0.5107040405273438,
-0.0014676930150017142,
-0.22172905504703522,
0.4140171408653259,
0.23766767978668213,
-0.10155278444290161,
-0.18572568893432617,
-0.09290976077318192,
-0.2878355085849762,
0.10398498922586441,
-0.3822600841522217,
0.7784226536750793,
0.11414828151464462,
-1.1762704849243164,
0.7559022307395935,
-0.26295480132102966,
0.49241045117378235,
-0.6119386553764343,
0.04434787109494209,
-0.27033475041389465,
0.30597615242004395,
-0.16349151730537415,
-0.7680166959762573,
0.08749154210090637,
-0.2995392680168152,
-0.13725745677947998,
-0.11584614217281342,
0.7516098022460938,
-0.7696006894111633,
-0.25972747802734375,
0.08431269973516464,
0.6582192778587341,
-0.07590808719396591,
-0.23466286063194275,
-0.7999516725540161,
-0.625730037689209,
0.23925986886024475,
-0.36739253997802734,
0.3515393137931824,
0.5980556011199951,
0.21822316944599152,
0.6535357236862183,
0.7058903574943542,
0.05258456617593765,
0.2729809582233429,
0.1958899050951004,
0.6645484566688538,
-0.5823753476142883,
-0.6238220930099487,
-0.6409053802490234,
0.6675059199333191,
0.031095856800675392,
-0.6378040313720703,
0.807131826877594,
0.297350138425827,
0.9114809632301331,
-0.15299123525619507,
0.7840416431427002,
0.02351418323814869,
0.30934274196624756,
-0.3679257333278656,
0.8228248953819275,
-0.5329755544662476,
-0.13197541236877441,
-0.08892223984003067,
-0.7865455150604248,
-0.4005278944969177,
0.4244256317615509,
-0.29879945516586304,
0.21042370796203613,
0.9609745144844055,
0.8847646117210388,
0.13447009027004242,
-0.010132108815014362,
0.42142993211746216,
-0.22941358387470245,
0.23783719539642334,
0.6716936230659485,
1.0514240264892578,
-0.39411279559135437,
0.822525680065155,
-0.15540750324726105,
-0.0511876605451107,
-0.02033579722046852,
-0.5977423787117004,
-1.290144920349121,
-0.48814812302589417,
-0.49317917227745056,
-0.160925030708313,
-0.020276004448533058,
0.5047695636749268,
0.24168741703033447,
-0.765696108341217,
-0.02844456396996975,
-0.24010758101940155,
0.3114210367202759,
-0.5769014358520508,
-0.2332051694393158,
0.3711635172367096,
-0.6656709313392639,
-0.7915610074996948,
0.07150628417730331,
-0.08626294881105423,
0.03374703973531723,
-0.04270167648792267,
-0.08031079918146133,
-0.32736122608184814,
0.18338188529014587,
0.38565579056739807,
-0.013906897976994514,
-0.711380660533905,
-0.3923037052154541,
0.17100761830806732,
-0.15810427069664001,
0.010230167768895626,
0.6799958944320679,
-0.5854452252388,
0.6557027697563171,
0.6186003684997559,
0.4863045811653137,
0.1672898530960083,
0.345904678106308,
0.19926717877388,
-0.7830324769020081,
-0.19458478689193726,
0.39692968130111694,
0.12670937180519104,
0.1182863712310791,
-0.4643932282924652,
0.13130848109722137,
-0.036992330104112625,
-0.8783087730407715,
-0.7911943793296814,
0.3488868772983551,
-0.7719107866287231,
-0.30994856357574463,
1.360588550567627,
-0.09921828657388687,
-0.13772810995578766,
-0.28309234976768494,
-0.6258432865142822,
0.35364577174186707,
-0.22398093342781067,
0.8772848844528198,
0.7977555394172668,
-0.09604443609714508,
-0.20107229053974152,
-0.5645279884338379,
0.8395870327949524,
0.6193832159042358,
-0.7453469634056091,
0.263441801071167,
0.4662832021713257,
0.22320130467414856,
0.17405572533607483,
0.39777886867523193,
0.1741260588169098,
0.49513721466064453,
0.22791309654712677,
0.21164141595363617,
-0.23637841641902924,
-0.2948261797428131,
-0.1976919025182724,
0.19151684641838074,
-0.093549944460392,
-0.22437557578086853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19109v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19109v1
|
PathReasoner: Modeling Reasoning Path with Equivalent Extension for Logical Question Answering
| 2024-05-29T14:14:05 | 2024-05-29T14:14:05 |
Fangzhi Xu, Qika Lin, Tianzhe Zhao, Jiawei Han, Jun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Logical reasoning task has attracted great interest since it was proposed.
Faced with such a task, current competitive models, even large language models
(e.g., ChatGPT and PaLM 2), still perform badly. Previous promising LMs
struggle in logical consistency modeling and logical structure perception. To
this end, we model the logical reasoning task by transforming each logical
sample into reasoning paths and propose an architecture \textbf{PathReasoner}.
It addresses the task from the views of both data and model. To expand the
diversity of the logical samples, we propose an atom extension strategy
supported by equivalent logical formulas, to form new reasoning paths. From the
model perspective, we design a stack of transformer-style blocks. In
particular, we propose a path-attention module to joint model in-atom and
cross-atom relations with the high-order diffusion strategy. Experiments show
that PathReasoner achieves competitive performances on two logical reasoning
benchmarks and great generalization abilities.
|
[
-0.09562769532203674,
-0.9121388792991638,
0.9446632862091064,
-0.22740128636360168,
-0.018967676907777786,
-0.07531902194023132,
0.19188153743743896,
-0.33667829632759094,
-0.08975547552108765,
0.7591800689697266,
-0.7573646903038025,
-0.24781526625156403,
-0.534070611000061,
0.08760207146406174,
-0.26518628001213074,
0.9063192009925842,
-0.3358616232872009,
-0.006738022901117802,
-0.3797091245651245,
-0.09572426229715347,
-0.6134676337242126,
-0.06837859004735947,
-0.5530732274055481,
-0.39254632592201233,
0.2726137936115265,
0.07796689122915268,
0.8018546104431152,
0.702724814414978,
0.5603247880935669,
0.37025055289268494,
-0.27644506096839905,
-0.13502170145511627,
-0.28554007411003113,
0.46162259578704834,
-0.7483295202255249,
-0.5562067031860352,
-0.47687849402427673,
-0.25709789991378784,
0.5482811331748962,
0.7403789162635803,
-0.10064571350812912,
0.17438605427742004,
-0.40752261877059937,
0.46310439705848694,
-0.6002398133277893,
-0.1873626410961151,
-0.33613115549087524,
0.0896449089050293,
0.11785145103931427,
-0.03882938250899315,
-0.5191358923912048,
-0.37817665934562683,
0.22245724499225616,
-0.6279978156089783,
0.11699184030294418,
0.25148600339889526,
0.35030636191368103,
0.22571507096290588,
-0.4917348623275757,
-0.03918594866991043,
-0.9305115342140198,
0.6601444482803345,
-0.4502111077308655,
0.6264687180519104,
-0.09678393602371216,
0.8556175827980042,
-0.021149268373847008,
-0.7532230019569397,
-0.3429473638534546,
-0.008510108105838299,
-0.06551543623209,
0.29683035612106323,
-0.4565269351005554,
0.11364680528640747,
0.24828290939331055,
0.12245548516511917,
-0.83198082447052,
-0.5988356471061707,
-0.3276527523994446,
-0.11516309529542923,
0.4693092405796051,
0.5159946084022522,
0.2561621367931366,
-0.034496601670980453,
-0.4143177568912506,
0.1968751698732376,
-0.4950571060180664,
0.014119797386229038,
0.17411528527736664,
-0.07372177392244339,
0.3660498857498169,
0.5361202955245972,
-0.5716896057128906,
0.9668370485305786,
-0.06918451189994812,
0.15606896579265594,
-0.09582918137311935,
-0.49349674582481384,
-0.18460065126419067,
0.07334059476852417,
0.4536402225494385,
0.12895400822162628,
0.0668826624751091,
-0.3018230199813843,
-0.19297796487808228,
0.09607387334108353,
0.44532620906829834,
-0.9581542015075684,
-0.36731910705566406,
0.27728593349456787,
-0.5202979445457458,
0.06584008783102036,
-0.17564807832241058,
-0.647345781326294,
-0.3742836117744446,
-0.12963908910751343,
0.5443330407142639,
-0.5584643483161926,
-0.3314579725265503,
0.41601452231407166,
-0.4261077344417572,
0.06049536168575287,
0.6101308465003967,
-0.39220428466796875,
0.6809200048446655,
0.716184675693512,
0.6156604290008545,
-0.09713565558195114,
-0.1371876448392868,
-0.45128610730171204,
0.35184577107429504,
-0.32785603404045105,
1.030344843864441,
-0.8038192987442017,
-0.2640076279640198,
-0.38837704062461853,
-0.11303459852933884,
-0.09865459054708481,
-0.6194779872894287,
0.6738038063049316,
-0.787903904914856,
0.15685224533081055,
-0.1351405680179596,
-0.706515371799469,
-0.3672187328338623,
0.5356133580207825,
-0.5500473380088806,
0.5421143770217896,
0.2588101029396057,
-0.5985596776008606,
-0.09168467670679092,
-0.9241029024124146,
-0.26437705755233765,
0.2715616524219513,
0.03500625863671303,
0.04363550245761871,
-0.05986758694052696,
0.11356130987405777,
0.07090965658426285,
-0.4245181977748871,
0.24697619676589966,
-0.1859493851661682,
-0.3335004448890686,
0.13625667989253998,
-0.35534265637397766,
0.7722969055175781,
0.10991872102022171,
-0.11502040177583694,
0.3943021893501282,
-0.7460992336273193,
-0.06908994168043137,
0.13795344531536102,
-0.18378159403800964,
-0.3203746974468231,
0.2007080763578415,
-0.04363663122057915,
0.5420661568641663,
0.062119778245687485,
-0.6955752372741699,
0.13604538142681122,
-0.3694618046283722,
0.33460116386413574,
0.660991907119751,
0.1714245229959488,
0.49997779726982117,
-0.3746117353439331,
0.9052932262420654,
0.23093265295028687,
0.2862650752067566,
0.10185261070728302,
-0.5127876996994019,
-0.6938246488571167,
-0.11406617611646652,
-0.13105471432209015,
0.5958096385002136,
-0.4862677752971649,
0.2746819257736206,
-0.4284660816192627,
-0.5587134957313538,
-0.5798749327659607,
-0.08206535130739212,
0.3064804673194885,
0.7621756792068481,
0.610863208770752,
0.24575479328632355,
-0.4239512085914612,
-0.9140023589134216,
-0.5680801272392273,
-0.06074965000152588,
0.1479698270559311,
0.2577534019947052,
0.3830960690975189,
-0.3653741478919983,
1.0499259233474731,
-0.7044184803962708,
0.12423728406429291,
-0.6517897844314575,
-0.43292272090911865,
0.5524791479110718,
0.315297931432724,
0.004178681876510382,
-0.9239798784255981,
-0.24166910350322723,
-0.01318372692912817,
-0.5451900362968445,
0.05150369182229042,
0.10034049302339554,
-0.6106487512588501,
-0.12302916496992111,
0.4502899646759033,
-0.8768293857574463,
0.35699084401130676,
0.11592556536197662,
-0.5895358920097351,
0.5484265685081482,
0.30457571148872375,
0.01045084185898304,
-1.2620466947555542,
0.04678330942988396,
0.02664128877222538,
-0.438918799161911,
-0.8850304484367371,
0.08047758042812347,
-0.2514106333255768,
-0.11166699975728989,
-0.6253800988197327,
0.6998409032821655,
-0.0709298774600029,
0.10376806557178497,
-0.34360823035240173,
-0.008045608177781105,
0.20787718892097473,
0.28529220819473267,
0.3360811471939087,
0.29890429973602295,
0.5137742161750793,
-0.3605818450450897,
0.716863214969635,
0.3348039388656616,
-0.06262369453907013,
0.6286674737930298,
-0.9301785826683044,
-0.05625801533460617,
-0.2600504159927368,
0.6741117835044861,
-0.9841415882110596,
0.1606638878583908,
0.43220099806785583,
-0.17847996950149536,
-0.2294376641511917,
-0.20500461757183075,
-0.3564033806324005,
-0.384223997592926,
-0.05774320662021637,
0.8236098289489746,
0.6521571278572083,
-0.33052483201026917,
1.1678063869476318,
-0.1344243586063385,
-0.05753203108906746,
-0.1663637012243271,
-0.3770684003829956,
-0.34598785638809204,
-0.29864099621772766,
-0.691546618938446,
0.04448176920413971,
-0.31263968348503113,
-0.4703539311885834,
0.3317493200302124,
-0.41551363468170166,
-0.05568408593535423,
-0.20375698804855347,
0.07095997780561447,
0.40079060196876526,
-0.4572578966617584,
-0.04278305172920227,
0.007653195410966873,
-0.14972372353076935,
0.4574189782142639,
-0.5046961307525635,
0.42201218008995056,
0.04340343549847603,
-0.3187885284423828,
-0.34684163331985474,
0.4250641167163849,
0.41096851229667664,
-0.3075546324253082,
0.5525166392326355,
0.13211697340011597,
-0.4660733938217163,
-0.2841554582118988,
-0.28986409306526184,
-0.25617358088493347,
-0.4481557607650757,
0.4256831407546997,
-0.778229296207428,
-0.7483016848564148,
0.3420899212360382,
-0.16830484569072723,
-0.05155114829540253,
0.5091304183006287,
0.3422411382198334,
0.1361255943775177,
1.0913755893707275,
0.38179895281791687,
0.17487147450447083,
0.05563778802752495,
-0.13630077242851257,
0.38233885169029236,
-0.9156639575958252,
-0.2100772112607956,
-0.2136448472738266,
-0.19680798053741455,
-0.14650088548660278,
-0.38287389278411865,
0.319291889667511,
0.20576556026935577,
-0.3937646448612213,
0.5422137379646301,
-0.5011305212974548,
0.5079464912414551,
0.2748987674713135,
0.10521655529737473,
0.36164307594299316,
-0.36895090341567993,
0.11011940240859985,
0.3103431165218353,
-0.9568992853164673,
-0.2516631782054901,
0.7402743101119995,
0.3961837589740753,
0.7302427887916565,
0.31671226024627686,
0.5553557872772217,
-0.1791154146194458,
0.05736837163567543,
-0.7398635149002075,
0.7007655501365662,
0.2717512547969818,
-0.7800632119178772,
-0.25693944096565247,
-0.6010701060295105,
-0.518444836139679,
0.4812326729297638,
0.11013782769441605,
-0.7787091732025146,
0.08452368527650833,
0.24952827394008636,
-0.37655094265937805,
0.21574513614177704,
-0.4624161422252655,
1.2031081914901733,
-0.06110672652721405,
-0.38352373242378235,
-0.288209468126297,
-0.7878535389900208,
0.34544846415519714,
0.2803294062614441,
-0.007520402316004038,
-0.0004587190051097423,
0.06931474059820175,
0.7782159447669983,
-0.4955940842628479,
0.35479113459587097,
-0.033753376454114914,
-0.003850653301924467,
0.41356563568115234,
0.506526529788971,
0.5209950804710388,
0.038627829402685165,
-0.1842612624168396,
-0.1723153442144394,
-0.014093611389398575,
-0.33933672308921814,
-0.9627848863601685,
0.3383185863494873,
-0.4176982641220093,
-0.8983147144317627,
-0.3960038721561432,
-0.9678885340690613,
-0.29939666390419006,
0.45616796612739563,
0.18496552109718323,
0.3959188759326935,
-0.13285532593727112,
-0.17043399810791016,
0.6992087364196777,
0.284226655960083,
0.11637614667415619,
0.39279311895370483,
-0.12995369732379913,
-0.20148484408855438,
0.7035662531852722,
-0.27859461307525635,
0.4540422558784485,
0.8579081296920776,
0.316928505897522,
-0.4254077970981598,
-0.4124385118484497,
-0.33812153339385986,
0.13401013612747192,
-0.8491935133934021,
-0.08105123788118362,
-0.7506580948829651,
-0.4627488851547241,
-0.38286292552948,
-0.10184868425130844,
-0.22229938209056854,
-0.3977813720703125,
0.00447244243696332,
-0.1242230013012886,
0.4844726324081421,
0.7223148941993713,
0.3814569413661957,
-0.0031292682979255915,
-0.6646706461906433,
0.3977624773979187,
0.24938297271728516,
0.1964559704065323,
-0.06546003371477127,
-0.4183259904384613,
-0.051197052001953125,
-0.09118189662694931,
-0.3591933846473694,
-0.8369624614715576,
0.06309795379638672,
-0.18455439805984497,
0.5466318726539612,
0.33011892437934875,
-0.04863111674785614,
0.5219833254814148,
-0.880200207233429,
0.3509601652622223,
0.018547536805272102,
-0.9256102442741394,
0.8558661937713623,
-0.4136875867843628,
0.4492131471633911,
0.4425794184207916,
0.4653720557689667,
-0.5972163081169128,
-0.24474945664405823,
-0.6484277248382568,
-0.6040545105934143,
0.7379389405250549,
0.2496044933795929,
-0.36318519711494446,
0.16858121752738953,
0.08644320070743561,
-0.012259525246918201,
0.05860750004649162,
-0.462270587682724,
0.01242170948535204,
-0.4443484842777252,
-0.2709164321422577,
-0.025685789063572884,
0.1902250349521637,
-0.24122664332389832,
-0.3463915288448334,
0.6809742450714111,
0.022996317595243454,
0.11812300235033035,
0.2311454713344574,
-0.11441025882959366,
0.0036143693141639233,
0.4081842601299286,
0.18798664212226868,
0.657895565032959,
-0.25187477469444275,
0.3753693997859955,
0.0401143878698349,
-0.24393032491207123,
0.34048712253570557,
0.22785671055316925,
-0.15153999626636505,
-0.08783555030822754,
0.4165109097957611,
0.8077737092971802,
-0.18232367932796478,
-0.8393859267234802,
0.319845587015152,
0.1177380159497261,
-0.17468596994876862,
0.059435442090034485,
0.38214656710624695,
0.31934335827827454,
0.49751296639442444,
-0.05094544589519501,
0.30925336480140686,
0.6912779211997986,
-0.4953991174697876,
0.06447795033454895,
0.2816465198993683,
-0.5519963502883911,
-0.17238174378871918,
0.6687806248664856,
0.09460364282131195,
-0.4174156188964844,
0.5499515533447266,
-0.08309747278690338,
-0.7043430209159851,
0.6517065763473511,
0.8289777040481567,
0.7211509943008423,
-0.1908694952726364,
0.060031723231077194,
0.05287754535675049,
0.22619979083538055,
-0.05924079567193985,
0.27824708819389343,
-0.15477390587329865,
-0.7403454184532166,
-0.13657332956790924,
-0.5578150153160095,
-0.3042139708995819,
-0.2786702811717987,
-0.41369950771331787,
-0.005893347319215536,
-0.3413678705692291,
0.2676267623901367,
-0.07977868616580963,
-0.3126847743988037,
-0.41437968611717224,
0.3662569522857666,
-0.1581648588180542,
1.17255699634552,
-0.7464403510093689,
0.5971242189407349,
0.9435214400291443,
-0.25506681203842163,
-0.6557422876358032,
0.11848429590463638,
-0.13306982815265656,
-0.32905563712120056,
0.6373918056488037,
0.14572231471538544,
-0.3032114803791046,
0.0721249058842659,
0.051908817142248154,
-0.8033671379089355,
1.0544172525405884,
0.27508941292762756,
-0.456892192363739,
-0.04770905524492264,
0.15203258395195007,
0.3018595278263092,
-0.29824256896972656,
0.46323758363723755,
0.4873363971710205,
0.3202659785747528,
0.2524150609970093,
-0.24050208926200867,
0.44336050748825073,
-0.423679918050766,
0.24514560401439667,
0.41906896233558655,
-0.5433420538902283,
0.80088210105896,
0.06752415746450424,
0.08699154108762741,
0.13773152232170105,
0.5791828632354736,
0.5724904537200928,
0.12799549102783203,
0.5692077279090881,
0.7264721989631653,
0.2335328906774521,
0.15377523005008698,
0.9642040133476257,
-0.11071053147315979,
0.14760130643844604,
0.8624926805496216,
-0.6099219918251038,
0.7463683485984802,
0.3412306308746338,
-0.05342969670891762,
0.771100640296936,
0.3713010251522064,
0.14930354058742523,
0.42060452699661255,
0.30488064885139465,
-0.2385229468345642,
-0.5735860466957092,
-0.16115424036979675,
-0.11933566629886627,
0.171563521027565,
0.11961933225393295,
-0.08448322862386703,
-0.41556626558303833,
-0.19953468441963196,
-0.2844648063182831,
0.032845862209796906,
-0.4347621202468872,
0.5875707268714905,
-0.03341805562376976,
-0.7242640852928162,
0.13952070474624634,
-0.070517897605896,
0.23719346523284912,
-0.6485540866851807,
-0.2802155017852783,
-0.11338689923286438,
0.37940773367881775,
-0.14273053407669067,
-0.7935612797737122,
0.4117966294288635,
-0.22973783314228058,
-0.4129263162612915,
-0.07120061665773392,
0.8032416701316833,
-0.30842363834381104,
-0.721600353717804,
0.38475877046585083,
0.4111786186695099,
0.03386181220412254,
0.004739235620945692,
-0.6141322255134583,
-0.040683384984731674,
-0.33084413409233093,
-0.4166370630264282,
-0.09540443867444992,
0.4482079744338989,
-0.15976689755916595,
0.7440775632858276,
0.4553516209125519,
-0.11836777627468109,
-0.05049703270196915,
-0.013359246775507927,
0.7510024309158325,
-0.6444746851921082,
-0.6378207802772522,
-0.895275890827179,
0.4382091164588928,
-0.06621775031089783,
-0.2091187834739685,
0.7525462508201599,
0.7533795833587646,
0.6235190629959106,
-0.03531184792518616,
0.7106612920761108,
0.16240528225898743,
0.5790970921516418,
-0.5090393424034119,
0.4526742994785309,
-0.521716296672821,
-0.03296341001987457,
-0.22361351549625397,
-1.137219786643982,
-0.01402245182543993,
0.5472397208213806,
-0.3001307249069214,
0.15761463344097137,
1.0011228322982788,
0.6550832390785217,
-0.4807197153568268,
0.15587913990020752,
0.0868687778711319,
0.26125168800354004,
0.35756126046180725,
1.1586700677871704,
0.9292355179786682,
-0.4019106328487396,
0.4836443364620209,
-0.07928460091352463,
-0.25214001536369324,
0.04073817655444145,
-0.5787400007247925,
-0.8407986164093018,
-0.2898632287979126,
-0.2418646514415741,
-0.41586223244667053,
0.339849054813385,
0.7062375545501709,
0.7434123158454895,
-0.5970088839530945,
-0.280499666929245,
-0.7041587233543396,
0.192000612616539,
-0.2863096594810486,
-0.25448668003082275,
0.15396186709403992,
0.07658836245536804,
-0.30444756150245667,
0.45523935556411743,
0.317500501871109,
-0.25082242488861084,
-0.0974687933921814,
-0.10466832667589188,
-0.26093918085098267,
0.35548022389411926,
0.504849910736084,
0.09467910975217819,
-0.637424111366272,
-0.08327054977416992,
0.21608087420463562,
0.14992593228816986,
-0.014347098767757416,
0.6664345860481262,
-0.8619896769523621,
0.19456425309181213,
0.713245153427124,
0.8774698972702026,
0.39849960803985596,
0.1616523116827011,
0.5702990293502808,
-0.08347047120332718,
-0.07646065950393677,
0.5428712964057922,
0.4134035110473633,
0.0668427124619484,
-0.42645418643951416,
0.38981691002845764,
0.43022018671035767,
-0.4904056787490845,
-0.4587932825088501,
0.6857811808586121,
-0.9179484248161316,
-0.611757755279541,
1.143540382385254,
0.1484624296426773,
-0.3407187759876251,
0.0674879401922226,
-0.13326309621334076,
0.22159092128276825,
-0.28664031624794006,
0.2880479395389557,
0.5303060412406921,
-0.6368630528450012,
-0.23515290021896362,
-0.414654403924942,
0.28212645649909973,
0.5728396773338318,
-1.0564215183258057,
0.07121779769659042,
0.47740840911865234,
0.39744964241981506,
0.4112367331981659,
0.6520652770996094,
0.09752052277326584,
0.4833287000656128,
-0.04097915440797806,
-0.26311537623405457,
0.042012304067611694,
-0.5451010465621948,
-0.2519899904727936,
0.11287501454353333,
-0.26506972312927246,
-0.13605166971683502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19094v1
|
Faithful Chart Summarization with ChaTS-Pi
| 2024-05-29T13:55:06 | 2024-05-29T13:55:06 |
Syrine Krichene, Francesco Piccinno, Fangyu Liu, Julian Martin Eisenschlos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chart-to-summary generation can help explore data, communicate insights, and
help the visually impaired people. Multi-modal generative models have been used
to produce fluent summaries, but they can suffer from factual and perceptual
errors. In this work we present CHATS-CRITIC, a reference-free chart
summarization metric for scoring faithfulness. CHATS-CRITIC is composed of an
image-to-text model to recover the table from a chart, and a tabular entailment
model applied to score the summary sentence by sentence. We find that
CHATS-CRITIC evaluates the summary quality according to human ratings better
than reference-based metrics, either learned or n-gram based, and can be
further used to fix candidate summaries by removing not supported sentences. We
then introduce CHATS-PI, a chart-to-summary pipeline that leverages
CHATS-CRITIC during inference to fix and rank sampled candidates from any
chart-summarization model. We evaluate CHATS-PI and CHATS-CRITIC using human
raters, establishing state-of-the-art results on two popular chart-to-summary
datasets.
|
[
-0.32135409116744995,
-0.4925420880317688,
0.3373447358608246,
0.39247795939445496,
-0.546762228012085,
0.1744900941848755,
-0.18564870953559875,
-0.44079381227493286,
0.6113271117210388,
0.4155411124229431,
-0.20102287828922272,
-0.5209871530532837,
-0.5798524022102356,
0.06509725749492645,
-0.6286329627037048,
1.3442836999893188,
0.09787417203187943,
0.19223591685295105,
-0.3027785122394562,
-0.1583768129348755,
-0.49232974648475647,
-0.2420778125524521,
-0.33016765117645264,
0.1574932336807251,
0.6327974796295166,
0.8727492690086365,
0.8454306721687317,
0.30178311467170715,
0.9699119925498962,
0.23862038552761078,
0.262619286775589,
0.5303800106048584,
-0.9217211008071899,
0.5318682193756104,
-0.023707477375864983,
-0.41927680373191833,
-0.7929027080535889,
0.08798609673976898,
0.594645619392395,
0.6876440048217773,
0.1246100589632988,
0.09394247829914093,
0.2681775391101837,
1.0023294687271118,
-0.5995808243751526,
0.734200656414032,
-0.4759756624698639,
-0.10876121371984482,
-0.07251682132482529,
-0.4064486026763916,
-0.7041526436805725,
-0.585112988948822,
-0.01982172764837742,
-0.8462231755256653,
0.481685996055603,
0.27953386306762695,
1.1020481586456299,
0.3598537743091583,
-0.5089558362960815,
-0.1666521430015564,
-0.7629327774047852,
0.36200568079948425,
-0.43901708722114563,
0.4180150330066681,
0.5869153141975403,
0.6021263003349304,
0.06865743547677994,
-0.8910748362541199,
-0.3394720256328583,
-0.38903456926345825,
-0.30688345432281494,
0.80443274974823,
-0.26673397421836853,
-0.0877743810415268,
-0.005009972956031561,
0.5666922926902771,
-0.39334389567375183,
-0.3477362096309662,
-0.6993224620819092,
-0.30052635073661804,
0.9612572193145752,
0.3286058008670807,
0.012557530775666237,
-0.3377677798271179,
-0.2872057557106018,
-0.37809211015701294,
-0.5065024495124817,
-0.09913571178913116,
0.3449200689792633,
0.18380185961723328,
-0.3109714984893799,
0.838375449180603,
-0.3844134211540222,
0.19919073581695557,
-0.020584382116794586,
0.11901929974555969,
0.22530534863471985,
-0.498174250125885,
-0.0032185998279601336,
-0.3306545317173004,
1.1290898323059082,
1.040558099746704,
0.740124523639679,
-0.3208576738834381,
-0.2148844450712204,
0.28032445907592773,
0.37174826860427856,
-0.44012248516082764,
-0.7371403574943542,
-0.007015025708824396,
-0.17952357232570648,
-0.344929575920105,
0.23028713464736938,
-0.7765918374061584,
-0.50138920545578,
-0.21438010036945343,
0.029841497540473938,
-0.7548211216926575,
-0.15768085420131683,
-0.3453722894191742,
-0.5551440715789795,
-0.11535743623971939,
0.5906082391738892,
-0.4782157838344574,
0.13385999202728271,
0.5090617537498474,
0.9518004059791565,
-0.12659774720668793,
-0.4007239043712616,
-0.7413280606269836,
0.2863352298736572,
-0.8615962266921997,
1.1840190887451172,
-0.27430346608161926,
-0.5964323282241821,
-0.3734091818332672,
-0.179703488945961,
-0.10808469355106354,
-0.30476051568984985,
0.6273272633552551,
-0.27573123574256897,
0.11706963926553726,
-0.191431924700737,
-0.7593371272087097,
-0.11131159961223602,
0.3408380150794983,
-0.696418285369873,
0.7143330574035645,
0.10191749036312103,
-0.8144022822380066,
0.4403846859931946,
-0.5350580811500549,
-0.24032030999660492,
0.19586476683616638,
-0.2966445982456207,
-0.6411810517311096,
0.2834932506084442,
0.2952244281768799,
0.4783460795879364,
0.15181662142276764,
0.05994240567088127,
-0.4591679573059082,
-0.4717268943786621,
0.3751637637615204,
-0.49748557806015015,
0.25589489936828613,
0.26184478402137756,
0.12880460917949677,
0.4104873538017273,
-0.3048993647098541,
0.023304663598537445,
0.08101596683263779,
0.10276465862989426,
0.06890407204627991,
0.26899802684783936,
0.3187604546546936,
-0.30601146817207336,
-0.12042097747325897,
-0.18826420605182648,
-0.05947723612189293,
-0.2506750226020813,
0.24466200172901154,
0.462075412273407,
0.31610438227653503,
0.12077739089727402,
-0.6242671012878418,
0.39804351329803467,
0.0006626212853007019,
0.16432148218154907,
-0.5989053845405579,
-0.5699052810668945,
-0.912180483341217,
-0.5142999887466431,
0.34549254179000854,
0.5460296273231506,
-0.8543897271156311,
0.4312184154987335,
-0.9073252081871033,
-0.8534895777702332,
-0.18510648608207703,
-0.06925814598798752,
0.4140702188014984,
0.4631313979625702,
0.1951780617237091,
-0.8460115194320679,
-0.12434788048267365,
-0.8025147318840027,
-0.2778083384037018,
-0.46571311354637146,
-0.31729844212532043,
0.24385719001293182,
0.2136477530002594,
0.07789560407400131,
0.9437017440795898,
-0.6181157231330872,
-0.6427595615386963,
-0.3388780355453491,
0.15430206060409546,
-0.31558874249458313,
0.36968377232551575,
0.7238711714744568,
-0.5011358857154846,
-0.7363677620887756,
-0.23606815934181213,
-0.7014626264572144,
0.12853777408599854,
-0.2013012170791626,
-0.24352845549583435,
-0.00590533996000886,
0.591460108757019,
-0.3001127541065216,
0.6894454956054688,
0.4035324454307556,
-0.7301658987998962,
0.7368854880332947,
-0.3023514151573181,
0.44054335355758667,
-0.9204413890838623,
0.1284877508878708,
0.11111146956682205,
-0.7581573128700256,
-0.2420465350151062,
0.1825137734413147,
0.0618993304669857,
-0.23077838122844696,
0.00996125303208828,
0.07161006331443787,
-0.2406584769487381,
0.008182503283023834,
-0.14178389310836792,
0.4599904417991638,
0.22016891837120056,
0.5576878190040588,
-0.09404250234365463,
0.6411134600639343,
0.4245944023132324,
-0.32860031723976135,
0.6448243856430054,
0.43313896656036377,
-0.3213427662849426,
0.7357859015464783,
-0.6736252903938293,
0.09191108494997025,
-0.25867921113967896,
0.3225352466106415,
-1.4289149045944214,
-0.3569425046443939,
0.5071308016777039,
-0.8298841118812561,
0.30181095004081726,
-0.0711539164185524,
-0.4395557641983032,
-0.026400603353977203,
-0.480042964220047,
0.11356323957443237,
0.10944440215826035,
-0.06620191037654877,
0.4427066445350647,
0.2306929975748062,
-0.20228976011276245,
-0.17182990908622742,
-0.7236653566360474,
0.34776073694229126,
0.07578238099813461,
-0.497063010931015,
0.1139250099658966,
-0.12023860961198807,
-0.06785951554775238,
0.011105796322226524,
-0.04583268612623215,
-0.04950987920165062,
-0.13088113069534302,
0.32499316334724426,
0.431032657623291,
-0.12030728906393051,
0.06847364455461502,
-0.20088240504264832,
-0.4571354389190674,
-0.013868742622435093,
0.36685171723365784,
0.311269611120224,
-0.41199368238449097,
-0.7277885675430298,
-0.626899003982544,
0.32469016313552856,
0.9947925806045532,
-0.25885820388793945,
0.23382814228534698,
0.22533303499221802,
0.012730739079415798,
0.41556447744369507,
-0.5305411219596863,
-0.05873074382543564,
-0.40387600660324097,
0.49339208006858826,
-0.16182251274585724,
-0.3475317358970642,
0.5010958909988403,
0.16518498957157135,
0.3184390664100647,
0.5632339119911194,
0.2145054191350937,
-0.6272768974304199,
0.8776428699493408,
0.39918962121009827,
-0.07356970757246017,
0.6292592883110046,
-0.30776840448379517,
0.14167450368404388,
-0.4803408086299896,
-0.16041724383831024,
-0.3788769841194153,
-0.45999476313591003,
-0.33811309933662415,
-0.3032101094722748,
0.6698125004768372,
0.20165559649467468,
-0.015724679455161095,
0.061158012598752975,
-0.30441248416900635,
0.5481105446815491,
0.39093852043151855,
0.45816323161125183,
0.6533222794532776,
-0.004488623235374689,
0.10691577941179276,
-0.25606831908226013,
-0.4439147412776947,
-0.645963191986084,
1.1800565719604492,
0.2898087203502655,
0.6638266444206238,
0.1646682471036911,
0.2673651874065399,
0.469446063041687,
0.7006186842918396,
-0.8916160464286804,
0.344960480928421,
-0.12542939186096191,
-0.4175414741039276,
-0.5088454484939575,
-0.653488039970398,
-0.6971697807312012,
0.08376754820346832,
-0.42002418637275696,
-0.4670909643173218,
0.006157295312732458,
0.48651328682899475,
-0.13320599496364594,
0.08800867199897766,
-1.1439895629882812,
0.9030729532241821,
-0.2866603136062622,
-0.08004441857337952,
-0.4472498893737793,
-0.48886385560035706,
0.46800196170806885,
0.16779053211212158,
0.12708717584609985,
-0.3453395664691925,
0.00904135126620531,
0.4942989647388458,
-0.4736694097518921,
0.8774182796478271,
0.14737312495708466,
0.27076593041419983,
0.24887880682945251,
0.46078401803970337,
0.39404425024986267,
0.31581565737724304,
0.2103627473115921,
0.06385038048028946,
0.09831395000219345,
-0.568119466304779,
-0.849323570728302,
0.2990413010120392,
-0.7199470400810242,
-0.27620747685432434,
-0.35556989908218384,
-0.5029938817024231,
-0.43117162585258484,
-0.04691820219159126,
0.36533865332603455,
0.5118539929389954,
-0.25533223152160645,
0.3342820405960083,
0.04817347228527069,
0.08144645392894745,
0.14231902360916138,
0.2577613592147827,
-0.3168734610080719,
-0.7547318339347839,
1.0551178455352783,
-0.016547255218029022,
0.3868325650691986,
0.11149834841489792,
0.010114501230418682,
-0.12085669487714767,
-0.3231280446052551,
-0.6124573349952698,
0.26034367084503174,
-0.6456578969955444,
-0.3082832098007202,
-0.2065039724111557,
-0.19587013125419617,
-0.22512151300907135,
-0.0879681333899498,
-0.5498269200325012,
-0.5949432253837585,
-0.08028066158294678,
-0.19056323170661926,
0.5608626008033752,
0.5796014070510864,
0.12658515572547913,
0.25138354301452637,
-0.7810667157173157,
0.40209639072418213,
0.14088371396064758,
0.707443356513977,
-0.022498471662402153,
-0.37950772047042847,
-0.16164149343967438,
0.16122809052467346,
-0.7766324877738953,
-1.0987155437469482,
0.22518618404865265,
0.35151106119155884,
0.3115183413028717,
0.845487117767334,
0.43203628063201904,
0.8322360515594482,
-0.13087479770183563,
0.7154872417449951,
0.6346143484115601,
-0.8290356993675232,
0.437812864780426,
-0.37810200452804565,
0.15095001459121704,
0.6129843592643738,
0.07051382213830948,
-0.8732497096061707,
-1.2048022747039795,
-0.43937447667121887,
-0.8206266760826111,
0.4853202700614929,
0.4364038109779358,
0.19327634572982788,
0.1037520244717598,
0.13518346846103668,
0.06418989598751068,
-0.0020279462914913893,
-0.688750147819519,
-0.31094637513160706,
-0.9502691030502319,
-0.3387604355812073,
-0.4562951326370239,
-0.17180073261260986,
-0.10035300999879837,
-0.3054865300655365,
0.6183428168296814,
-0.31709352135658264,
-0.022930435836315155,
0.37800073623657227,
-0.04838230460882187,
-0.10040852427482605,
0.12452740222215652,
0.46487337350845337,
0.8289262056350708,
-0.1236235722899437,
0.033745601773262024,
0.11784601211547852,
-0.5563924312591553,
-0.3850433826446533,
-0.155670166015625,
-0.17770810425281525,
0.20475620031356812,
0.6976736783981323,
0.7665045261383057,
0.2962355613708496,
-0.847488284111023,
0.8055920600891113,
-0.30312803387641907,
-0.09433724731206894,
-0.30367180705070496,
0.08546292781829834,
0.05153529718518257,
0.06444712728261948,
0.39368540048599243,
0.5574449896812439,
0.04905819520354271,
-0.5138053894042969,
0.2533096373081207,
0.18778197467327118,
-0.77116459608078,
-0.28848525881767273,
0.7900086641311646,
0.4358615279197693,
-0.17163138091564178,
0.8605850338935852,
-0.16204962134361267,
-0.3363264799118042,
0.41765671968460083,
-0.01595110446214676,
0.8326635956764221,
0.1823665052652359,
0.37532585859298706,
0.4287920296192169,
0.31097614765167236,
0.24788859486579895,
0.23337313532829285,
-0.19554482400417328,
-0.6608505845069885,
-0.49167996644973755,
0.2012699544429779,
-0.8295602202415466,
-0.38579684495925903,
-0.7095937728881836,
0.3176986873149872,
-0.21226175129413605,
-0.30820953845977783,
-0.07386158406734467,
-0.29331547021865845,
-0.41353192925453186,
0.015948927029967308,
-0.09242729097604752,
0.7579749226570129,
-0.6890290975570679,
0.315510630607605,
0.3579566478729248,
-0.8494409322738647,
-0.7538710832595825,
0.08685658127069473,
-0.1427105814218521,
-0.39399322867393494,
0.09583689272403717,
-0.09955034404993057,
0.011065144091844559,
-0.2924412488937378,
-0.5472477078437805,
-0.5640517473220825,
0.9955084919929504,
0.6601283550262451,
-0.6006688475608826,
0.011185803450644016,
0.019334401935338974,
0.6392852067947388,
0.057822633534669876,
0.7264617681503296,
0.16982240974903107,
0.3253079950809479,
0.10996183007955551,
-1.0952978134155273,
-0.3055744767189026,
-0.44978007674217224,
-0.35248950123786926,
-0.0960603579878807,
-0.8543223142623901,
0.3710232973098755,
-0.32926419377326965,
-0.36745184659957886,
0.10248246043920517,
0.727922797203064,
0.2744638919830322,
0.4990236759185791,
0.6003040671348572,
0.30752289295196533,
0.7128486037254333,
-0.3631531000137329,
1.0232855081558228,
-0.538227915763855,
0.5225666165351868,
1.1040433645248413,
0.05422802269458771,
0.9275786280632019,
0.2658712565898895,
-0.08184758573770523,
0.5591040849685669,
0.48781734704971313,
-0.03813151642680168,
0.3986264765262604,
-0.13361020386219025,
0.22411414980888367,
-0.26854416728019714,
0.09370194375514984,
-0.34981343150138855,
0.5317683815956116,
0.2933422923088074,
-0.34722229838371277,
-0.2717646658420563,
-0.4639771580696106,
-0.23263771831989288,
0.3336215615272522,
-0.1520020216703415,
0.8364039659500122,
0.06347419321537018,
-0.6290867924690247,
0.43182218074798584,
-0.22142501175403595,
0.3219315707683563,
-0.5977974534034729,
0.1440577208995819,
-0.4420833885669708,
0.07673732191324234,
-0.18540377914905548,
-0.7739486694335938,
0.6140521764755249,
0.07807248085737228,
-0.19470538198947906,
-0.2571798264980316,
0.1803457885980606,
-0.2806690037250519,
-0.7471848726272583,
-0.037831563502550125,
0.58808833360672,
0.2770742177963257,
-0.1958049237728119,
-0.24000118672847748,
-0.22988800704479218,
-0.18089167773723602,
0.00588691420853138,
-0.1242416650056839,
0.5197789669036865,
-0.06006140261888504,
0.8587964773178101,
0.44359758496284485,
0.05621988698840141,
-0.19394566118717194,
0.3194342851638794,
0.7648661732673645,
-0.6293147802352905,
-0.9502571821212769,
-0.5161998271942139,
0.426636666059494,
-0.3319355845451355,
-0.5258427858352661,
0.7964657545089722,
1.045067548751831,
0.654743492603302,
-0.08810389786958694,
0.6445172429084778,
0.3106509745121002,
0.6451157331466675,
-0.287104070186615,
1.1267683506011963,
-0.44339585304260254,
0.10013093054294586,
-0.6374173164367676,
-0.737042248249054,
-0.3053230047225952,
0.3715454041957855,
-0.24147725105285645,
-0.24771931767463684,
0.7287762761116028,
0.7822816967964172,
-0.05254038795828819,
0.19891490042209625,
0.15808650851249695,
0.022457940503954887,
0.30550193786621094,
0.5454341769218445,
0.8462569117546082,
-0.4522167146205902,
1.1573317050933838,
-0.18030746281147003,
-0.1631992608308792,
-0.23949691653251648,
-0.6313186287879944,
-0.6250377893447876,
-0.6479592323303223,
-0.6308007836341858,
-0.3422222137451172,
-0.21719561517238617,
0.5035459399223328,
0.7610183954238892,
-0.886925220489502,
-0.2616368532180786,
-0.02881670370697975,
0.06965377181768417,
-0.5130988359451294,
-0.2948685586452484,
0.519788384437561,
-0.529664933681488,
-0.6538429260253906,
0.10676005482673645,
0.2770107090473175,
0.12490665167570114,
-0.20937678217887878,
-0.2719855308532715,
0.6013020277023315,
-0.08943972736597061,
0.3755280375480652,
0.06601843982934952,
-0.6176174879074097,
-0.3577736020088196,
-0.09267455339431763,
-0.209589421749115,
0.21372106671333313,
0.7960138916969299,
-0.6392181515693665,
0.7537369132041931,
0.46869853138923645,
0.18448153138160706,
0.7458853125572205,
0.14526143670082092,
0.7069574594497681,
-0.7887735366821289,
-0.07474423199892044,
0.28639334440231323,
0.5521183609962463,
0.47561660408973694,
-0.1356879025697708,
0.6117980480194092,
0.5153704285621643,
-0.20765343308448792,
-0.772310197353363,
0.15238721668720245,
-1.1677135229110718,
-0.009231884963810444,
0.7667700052261353,
-0.20363204181194305,
0.23151232302188873,
-0.09510026127099991,
-0.39812514185905457,
0.3474973142147064,
-0.49288514256477356,
1.2955341339111328,
0.680342435836792,
-0.2683018445968628,
-0.17905749380588531,
-0.21350719034671783,
0.25824829936027527,
0.3997238576412201,
-0.7248033881187439,
0.2256820946931839,
0.8217236399650574,
0.18760862946510315,
0.3247966170310974,
0.6445821523666382,
-0.1569879800081253,
0.5964797735214233,
0.2616252601146698,
-0.1828661561012268,
-0.1966923475265503,
-0.18674086034297943,
0.2242748737335205,
0.30675235390663147,
0.13332603871822357,
-0.333441823720932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19093v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19093v1
|
Multi-stage Retrieve and Re-rank Model for Automatic Medical Coding Recommendation
| 2024-05-29T13:54:30 | 2024-05-29T13:54:30 |
Xindi Wang, Robert E. Mercer, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The International Classification of Diseases (ICD) serves as a definitive
medical classification system encompassing a wide range of diseases and
conditions. The primary objective of ICD indexing is to allocate a subset of
ICD codes to a medical record, which facilitates standardized documentation and
management of various health conditions. Most existing approaches have suffered
from selecting the proper label subsets from an extremely large ICD collection
with a heavy long-tailed label distribution. In this paper, we leverage a
multi-stage ``retrieve and re-rank'' framework as a novel solution to ICD
indexing, via a hybrid discrete retrieval method, and re-rank retrieved
candidates with contrastive learning that allows the model to make more
accurate predictions from a simplified label space. The retrieval model is a
hybrid of auxiliary knowledge of the electronic health records (EHR) and a
discrete retrieval method (BM25), which efficiently collects high-quality
candidates. In the last stage, we propose a label co-occurrence guided
contrastive re-ranking model, which re-ranks the candidate labels by pulling
together the clinical notes with positive ICD codes. Experimental results show
the proposed method achieves state-of-the-art performance on a number of
measures on the MIMIC-III benchmark.
|
[
-0.29507485032081604,
-0.24187351763248444,
0.5927690267562866,
0.05929989740252495,
-0.5802363157272339,
0.24347896873950958,
0.19288824498653412,
-0.6250593066215515,
0.4307563304901123,
0.24734646081924438,
-0.2581636905670166,
-1.003424048423767,
-0.5931503772735596,
0.06292496621608734,
-0.3605051338672638,
1.420030117034912,
-0.030146999284625053,
0.052523061633110046,
-0.15123002231121063,
-0.17261925339698792,
-0.2508762776851654,
-0.7207022905349731,
-0.5284334421157837,
-0.4998711347579956,
0.7191886901855469,
0.5006267428398132,
0.36297407746315,
0.6006667613983154,
0.7898377180099487,
0.1537257432937622,
0.10096001625061035,
0.21320869028568268,
-0.039739806205034256,
-0.057076845318078995,
-0.08749416470527649,
-0.33167558908462524,
-0.6652976870536804,
-0.011969401501119137,
0.43079453706741333,
0.5137352347373962,
-0.344439297914505,
0.0016378453001379967,
-0.16261692345142365,
0.37863627076148987,
-0.4005711078643799,
0.05544168874621391,
-0.23952731490135193,
-0.02868146076798439,
-0.10679358243942261,
-0.4784896969795227,
-0.5199507474899292,
-0.41096165776252747,
0.0942881777882576,
-0.5335443615913391,
0.21823959052562714,
0.1670542061328888,
0.7056934237480164,
-0.033472348004579544,
-0.6397271156311035,
-0.1723005622625351,
-0.6272369623184204,
0.5239900946617126,
-0.2824375629425049,
0.47584033012390137,
0.574664831161499,
0.38953614234924316,
0.20898036658763885,
-0.8389375805854797,
-0.09348688274621964,
-0.29378044605255127,
-0.03319332003593445,
0.12171754986047745,
0.13226723670959473,
-0.08772220462560654,
0.05793096497654915,
0.7320029735565186,
-0.5564244389533997,
0.10029921680688858,
-0.284559041261673,
-0.1299290508031845,
0.5850440263748169,
0.07321929186582565,
0.508994460105896,
-0.08313393592834473,
-0.4051724076271057,
-0.10708954930305481,
-0.534084677696228,
-0.24685989320278168,
-0.15496335923671722,
0.05915139615535736,
-0.24767586588859558,
0.42286771535873413,
-0.27094539999961853,
0.47724616527557373,
0.3157361149787903,
-0.33784186840057373,
0.6165611147880554,
-0.5076127052307129,
0.15956151485443115,
0.054246269166469574,
0.47912338376045227,
0.3750903904438019,
-0.18414296209812164,
-0.1797948032617569,
-0.35269445180892944,
0.07752714306116104,
0.5316389799118042,
-0.5840457677841187,
-0.5623528361320496,
0.17007100582122803,
-0.850100576877594,
-0.2950548529624939,
-0.09293407201766968,
-0.8851761817932129,
-0.2631361782550812,
-0.3157249093055725,
0.46604812145233154,
-0.4436677098274231,
-0.02228270284831524,
0.09769324213266373,
0.039244409650564194,
-0.11980722844600677,
0.3601101040840149,
-0.8731393814086914,
0.41489657759666443,
0.6621977090835571,
0.6397104263305664,
-0.45184338092803955,
0.007411953993141651,
-0.5694832801818848,
0.12149210274219513,
-0.2640070617198944,
0.9683396816253662,
-0.802126407623291,
-0.6724637746810913,
-0.20774686336517334,
-0.08159716427326202,
0.03399955481290817,
-0.9600340723991394,
0.9237930774688721,
-0.445117712020874,
-0.2114609181880951,
0.02989429607987404,
-0.26654255390167236,
-0.06221702694892883,
0.36553680896759033,
-0.7955843806266785,
0.7295321822166443,
0.013561226427555084,
-0.747209906578064,
0.5966377258300781,
-0.24388021230697632,
-0.5033227205276489,
0.2200673222541809,
-0.29916301369667053,
-0.7448477149009705,
-0.07418617606163025,
0.40065446496009827,
0.13222067058086395,
-0.6413984298706055,
0.5255208015441895,
-0.14403434097766876,
-0.41552242636680603,
-0.35740047693252563,
-0.16970102488994598,
0.2536448538303375,
0.3121963441371918,
-0.053560998290777206,
0.28290224075317383,
-1.0625375509262085,
-0.022083088755607605,
-0.19640935957431793,
-0.7458323240280151,
-0.6261147260665894,
0.007769372314214706,
-0.0234344694763422,
0.4980819821357727,
0.010949544608592987,
-0.5828841924667358,
0.25112423300743103,
-0.047287717461586,
0.07026269286870956,
0.4253508150577545,
0.3782915472984314,
0.10895988345146179,
-0.7141980528831482,
0.4916321933269501,
0.32903778553009033,
0.251484751701355,
-0.21583621203899384,
-0.5803344249725342,
-0.6395496129989624,
-0.30797362327575684,
0.47035878896713257,
0.48725953698158264,
-0.8143306374549866,
0.7174694538116455,
-0.33604830503463745,
-0.5398616194725037,
-0.7448693513870239,
-0.1720096319913864,
0.5850033760070801,
0.49100983142852783,
0.6588514447212219,
-0.46762192249298096,
-0.32360732555389404,
-1.045752763748169,
0.2060817927122116,
-0.022845527157187462,
0.027164239436388016,
0.5409825444221497,
0.4972602128982544,
-0.7298780679702759,
0.4064274728298187,
-0.6312171220779419,
-0.3613947927951813,
-0.13880403339862823,
0.37613746523857117,
0.31035369634628296,
0.7304051518440247,
0.07382214069366455,
-0.8656712770462036,
-0.45140591263771057,
0.24934838712215424,
-0.45877605676651,
-0.0907975286245346,
0.06809325516223907,
-0.16679149866104126,
-0.2426413893699646,
0.33903244137763977,
-0.11651113629341125,
0.4826242923736572,
0.2947568893432617,
0.009517045691609383,
0.4062793254852295,
-0.8631066679954529,
0.38150280714035034,
-0.9906390905380249,
0.3114096224308014,
0.3576977252960205,
-0.11695686727762222,
-0.24873819947242737,
0.0455147959291935,
0.31034669280052185,
-0.27846914529800415,
0.09773904830217361,
0.349257230758667,
-0.29580065608024597,
-0.0068153743632137775,
-0.014638848602771759,
-0.08207274228334427,
0.050999533385038376,
0.32172253727912903,
0.14251914620399475,
0.3195391893386841,
0.30749085545539856,
-0.5549265742301941,
0.20976470410823822,
0.06363750994205475,
-0.4093175232410431,
0.8516103625297546,
-0.43874770402908325,
0.045353326946496964,
-0.154863178730011,
0.5269952416419983,
-0.9120239615440369,
0.2622785270214081,
0.14059500396251678,
-0.09592272341251373,
0.4606926739215851,
-0.2861383557319641,
-0.47917965054512024,
-0.6006498336791992,
-0.22227180004119873,
0.9670395851135254,
0.3475038707256317,
-0.7180492281913757,
0.45409882068634033,
0.5379706621170044,
-0.3362167775630951,
-0.18506328761577606,
-0.25019335746765137,
-0.10222789645195007,
-0.017625315114855766,
-0.31106746196746826,
0.8916187286376953,
-0.34250926971435547,
0.12790565192699432,
-0.18787997961044312,
-0.1822051703929901,
-0.03869909420609474,
-0.14474566280841827,
0.3099476397037506,
0.23276619613170624,
-0.03504229336977005,
0.10426349937915802,
0.058447521179914474,
-0.5780920386314392,
-0.2148633897304535,
-0.28064993023872375,
0.504044234752655,
0.28645458817481995,
-0.6015785932540894,
-0.5067999362945557,
0.7313992977142334,
0.6612183451652527,
-0.4740208387374878,
0.3107471168041229,
0.3837037682533264,
-0.7446057796478271,
-0.13776224851608276,
-0.5991273522377014,
-0.08746511489152908,
-0.37336263060569763,
0.3319772779941559,
-0.3610442578792572,
-0.30392950773239136,
0.5003407001495361,
-0.251790851354599,
-0.12400776147842407,
0.5921176075935364,
0.3333132266998291,
0.07657124102115631,
1.3318678140640259,
0.5933142900466919,
-0.2088208943605423,
0.17046549916267395,
-0.258081316947937,
0.19820129871368408,
-1.1473890542984009,
-0.8781895637512207,
-0.8997893333435059,
-0.26423966884613037,
-0.6946280002593994,
-0.40687111020088196,
0.7775985598564148,
-0.06714804470539093,
-0.0013761100126430392,
-0.15409329533576965,
-0.6297577023506165,
0.0627952590584755,
0.6256983876228333,
0.5843342542648315,
0.5069933533668518,
0.07314738631248474,
-0.6807597279548645,
-0.0867120698094368,
-0.5412444472312927,
-0.03433307632803917,
1.1018799543380737,
0.16249984502792358,
0.9247925281524658,
0.0025118649937212467,
1.1093177795410156,
0.4077506959438324,
0.5501043796539307,
-0.48719432950019836,
0.17559261620044708,
-0.5269031524658203,
-0.288907527923584,
0.28130030632019043,
-0.18656200170516968,
-1.0391302108764648,
0.23673832416534424,
-0.34294959902763367,
-0.6511461138725281,
0.6648334264755249,
0.0842825323343277,
-0.5681785941123962,
0.0968625545501709,
-0.4558846950531006,
0.6912980675697327,
-0.33945897221565247,
-0.12637865543365479,
-0.5130816698074341,
-0.5648351907730103,
0.33679184317588806,
-0.35545459389686584,
0.340394526720047,
0.24111375212669373,
-0.025472521781921387,
0.7172019481658936,
-0.5237852931022644,
0.48926982283592224,
0.16699928045272827,
-0.16230672597885132,
-0.24002201855182648,
-0.13686060905456543,
0.43049919605255127,
0.16353167593479156,
-0.17601950466632843,
-0.12229329347610474,
0.05675357207655907,
-0.13517844676971436,
-0.41709837317466736,
0.9446414709091187,
-0.7227166295051575,
-0.3162822127342224,
-0.567009449005127,
-0.17538005113601685,
0.044961389154195786,
0.3208381235599518,
0.2703973650932312,
0.993981659412384,
0.12672971189022064,
0.11645960807800293,
0.4806772768497467,
-0.5251013040542603,
0.0286350566893816,
0.5589921474456787,
-0.14261265099048615,
-0.6377142071723938,
1.3046475648880005,
0.1448356807231903,
0.06601231545209885,
0.60960853099823,
-0.04321000725030899,
-0.2759189307689667,
-0.7188382744789124,
-0.167729914188385,
0.33832353353500366,
-0.6479182243347168,
-0.22444802522659302,
-0.7451947927474976,
-0.25964245200157166,
-0.24459218978881836,
-0.13870222866535187,
-0.05976036190986633,
0.03764396533370018,
-0.180484339594841,
0.05802151560783386,
-0.018677102401852608,
0.8808302283287048,
-0.166746124625206,
-0.21391719579696655,
-0.8085756897926331,
0.8660261631011963,
0.07613669335842133,
0.9425605535507202,
0.15904168784618378,
-0.23478275537490845,
-0.3898904621601105,
-0.23731200397014618,
-0.3001736104488373,
-0.7239128947257996,
0.35848140716552734,
-0.05229979753494263,
0.9348855018615723,
0.3239254057407379,
0.281571626663208,
0.6321123838424683,
-0.6138776540756226,
0.34585297107696533,
0.19717347621917725,
-0.3710550367832184,
0.6536615490913391,
-0.16296187043190002,
0.21082746982574463,
0.49202269315719604,
0.5706530213356018,
-0.7069318890571594,
0.0061284988187253475,
-0.6794549226760864,
-1.1516684293746948,
0.6794174313545227,
-0.2411670982837677,
-0.5363142490386963,
-0.37269678711891174,
0.5805522799491882,
0.13131628930568695,
0.09107270836830139,
-0.4073934853076935,
-0.4476761519908905,
0.24960027635097504,
-0.4059131145477295,
-0.2473795861005783,
-0.4573526680469513,
-0.15830744802951813,
-0.25646471977233887,
0.5733565092086792,
0.06271792203187943,
0.39054781198501587,
0.4470718204975128,
-0.038991935551166534,
-0.251791387796402,
0.14809580147266388,
0.37929633259773254,
0.6428983211517334,
-0.3412904739379883,
0.12282468378543854,
-0.3441392779350281,
-0.5846884250640869,
0.18384656310081482,
0.4334550201892853,
-0.14694273471832275,
-0.15571343898773193,
-0.005076048895716667,
0.3548400104045868,
0.5156980156898499,
-0.4341180622577667,
0.34079909324645996,
-0.04070226848125458,
-0.011554941534996033,
-0.06284603476524353,
-0.1378737837076187,
-0.12708602845668793,
0.11913245171308517,
0.5580730438232422,
0.18965665996074677,
0.40500131249427795,
-0.5702773332595825,
0.8503992557525635,
0.329097181558609,
-0.3610031008720398,
-0.1032206118106842,
0.6351521015167236,
0.5173085331916809,
-0.5956292152404785,
0.7423725724220276,
-0.005831726361066103,
-0.2297825962305069,
0.7061804533004761,
0.7970918416976929,
0.5108051300048828,
-0.2273096740245819,
0.319918692111969,
0.4163072109222412,
-0.005560136865824461,
-0.20866891741752625,
0.3844793140888214,
-0.043481431901454926,
-0.38734734058380127,
-0.3119608461856842,
-0.36860769987106323,
-0.23607267439365387,
0.10952789336442947,
-0.930295467376709,
0.4123859703540802,
-0.5808086395263672,
-0.15152394771575928,
0.008050313219428062,
0.14061051607131958,
-0.4294092059135437,
0.5367201566696167,
0.28495004773139954,
0.8341957330703735,
-0.5341698527336121,
0.8465712666511536,
0.429002583026886,
-0.4123544991016388,
-0.6067290306091309,
0.029727598652243614,
-0.02681100368499756,
-0.45463892817497253,
0.3900703489780426,
0.1481742560863495,
0.028871439397335052,
0.22386682033538818,
-0.0005419282824732363,
-0.9557583928108215,
0.9961705207824707,
-0.06429505348205566,
-0.5944314002990723,
-0.0864114910364151,
-0.4625805616378784,
0.5965084433555603,
-0.45753246545791626,
0.37109673023223877,
0.46907687187194824,
0.06125882267951965,
0.19302606582641602,
-1.0925813913345337,
0.08951514959335327,
-0.647570788860321,
-0.18179640173912048,
0.3402571678161621,
-0.6367520689964294,
0.7326126098632812,
-0.2944575846195221,
0.016637317836284637,
0.22449526190757751,
0.13106931746006012,
0.6428579092025757,
0.46826767921447754,
0.22577910125255585,
0.694979190826416,
0.7011266946792603,
-0.005677293986082077,
1.3573825359344482,
-0.4667701721191406,
0.2387155145406723,
0.8674798011779785,
-0.29625579714775085,
0.8183073401451111,
-0.03791778162121773,
-0.1065782755613327,
0.7873757481575012,
0.8599750399589539,
-0.012163147330284119,
0.7918666005134583,
0.2525659501552582,
-0.22132818400859833,
-0.2827446162700653,
-0.16971661150455475,
-0.6867126822471619,
-0.1269257515668869,
0.3822905421257019,
-0.49316591024398804,
-0.28642725944519043,
-0.04124860838055611,
-0.4391808807849884,
-0.09550313651561737,
-0.40898841619491577,
0.8793095946311951,
0.06412315368652344,
-0.8072956204414368,
0.5224277377128601,
0.27983471751213074,
0.6206759214401245,
-0.3973877727985382,
-0.6204897165298462,
-0.19241183996200562,
0.2454344481229782,
-0.1738198697566986,
-0.2262493371963501,
-0.2084074169397354,
-0.40569233894348145,
-0.4279063045978546,
-0.08770553767681122,
0.4946412444114685,
-0.5631727576255798,
-0.5916094779968262,
0.35954201221466064,
0.19556252658367157,
0.08277648687362671,
0.33318933844566345,
-0.6463912725448608,
0.040109965950250626,
-0.14854520559310913,
0.3754218816757202,
0.6474221348762512,
0.21496163308620453,
-0.24356326460838318,
0.8652672171592712,
0.6217186450958252,
0.1431805044412613,
-0.30526041984558105,
0.2760014235973358,
0.8411876559257507,
-0.6168350577354431,
-0.8617422580718994,
-0.41004690527915955,
0.34811991453170776,
0.08173312991857529,
-0.09551938623189926,
0.1500452309846878,
0.6557760834693909,
0.6394187211990356,
0.23232321441173553,
0.6896557211875916,
0.3367152512073517,
0.7297760844230652,
-0.3078371286392212,
0.5255358815193176,
-0.6121519804000854,
0.47844719886779785,
-0.45823243260383606,
-0.5904440879821777,
-0.6338256001472473,
0.5988078117370605,
-0.3157931864261627,
0.24995464086532593,
0.6877717971801758,
0.4376446604728699,
-0.030239494517445564,
-0.2523294985294342,
0.08381897956132889,
0.09173718094825745,
0.4672567546367645,
0.6535033583641052,
0.40976014733314514,
-0.3211265802383423,
0.489936888217926,
-0.3492729663848877,
-0.16318461298942566,
-0.5321438908576965,
-0.5493240356445312,
-0.248480886220932,
-0.5493607521057129,
-0.5815075039863586,
-0.3410332500934601,
0.1710459142923355,
0.9127628207206726,
0.9411648511886597,
-0.7375351190567017,
0.08792445808649063,
0.35927829146385193,
0.2832907438278198,
-0.3279433846473694,
-0.10879098623991013,
0.6193174719810486,
0.08764688670635223,
-0.5790830254554749,
0.25218865275382996,
0.45667627453804016,
0.01103560347110033,
0.24423186480998993,
-0.04667004570364952,
-0.42363378405570984,
-0.5372783541679382,
0.35346823930740356,
0.18081426620483398,
-0.552879810333252,
-0.12370781600475311,
-0.30859214067459106,
-0.27570730447769165,
0.27939218282699585,
0.9326861500740051,
-0.9997490048408508,
0.5199666619300842,
0.30102211236953735,
0.4731238782405853,
0.5463895797729492,
0.38557153940200806,
0.5527175664901733,
-0.3747928738594055,
-0.25979968905448914,
0.19900217652320862,
0.25454211235046387,
0.03524807468056679,
-0.41260185837745667,
0.20622524619102478,
0.38765695691108704,
-0.4489559531211853,
-0.7141391038894653,
-0.03246171772480011,
-0.7670204639434814,
-0.06211002543568611,
0.8806487321853638,
-0.05383230373263359,
0.2392655611038208,
-0.5059206485748291,
-0.33030813932418823,
0.18706664443016052,
-0.48512402176856995,
0.8825578689575195,
0.20223528146743774,
-0.3326205313205719,
-0.21335095167160034,
-0.18437573313713074,
0.3537726104259491,
0.20319010317325592,
-0.7686457633972168,
-0.3021395802497864,
0.5848100185394287,
0.4251576364040375,
0.35897091031074524,
0.9685786962509155,
-0.41009968519210815,
0.3599155843257904,
-0.20800453424453735,
0.05300188064575195,
0.32637953758239746,
-0.7195866107940674,
-0.41356179118156433,
0.32556483149528503,
0.15278379619121552,
-0.2317853569984436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19088v1
|
Cracking the Code of Juxtaposition: Can AI Models Understand the Humorous Contradictions
| 2024-05-29T13:51:43 | 2024-05-29T13:51:43 |
Zhe Hu, Tuo Liang, Jing Li, Yiren Lu, Yunlai Zhou, Yiran Qiao, Jing Ma, Yu Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Recent advancements in large multimodal language models have demonstrated
remarkable proficiency across a wide range of tasks. Yet, these models still
struggle with understanding the nuances of human humor through juxtaposition,
particularly when it involves nonlinear narratives that underpin many jokes and
humor cues. This paper investigates this challenge by focusing on comics with
contradictory narratives, where each comic consists of two panels that create a
humorous contradiction. We introduce the YesBut benchmark, which comprises
tasks of varying difficulty aimed at assessing AI's capabilities in recognizing
and interpreting these comics, ranging from literal content comprehension to
deep narrative reasoning. Through extensive experimentation and analysis of
recent commercial or open-sourced large (vision) language models, we assess
their capability to comprehend the complex interplay of the narrative humor
inherent in these comics. Our results show that even state-of-the-art models
still lag behind human performance on this task. Our findings offer insights
into the current limitations and potential improvements for AI in understanding
human creative expressions.
|
[
-0.2918170094490051,
-0.5452760457992554,
0.6896438002586365,
0.3326438069343567,
-0.20019102096557617,
0.15302100777626038,
0.2101156860589981,
-0.6654818654060364,
-0.18615590035915375,
0.2957633435726166,
-0.600612223148346,
0.18319158256053925,
-0.3733872175216675,
0.33613353967666626,
-0.10483341664075851,
0.9997895359992981,
0.2381412386894226,
-0.12120244652032852,
-0.4341822862625122,
-0.6920881271362305,
-0.5732977986335754,
-0.09721364080905914,
-0.2369711846113205,
-0.38429930806159973,
0.43783038854599,
0.16524638235569,
1.0623881816864014,
0.5286131501197815,
0.5488160848617554,
0.40037429332733154,
-0.0819951519370079,
0.10155720263719559,
-0.20881657302379608,
-0.07568670809268951,
-0.5444397330284119,
-0.8256198167800903,
0.1617254614830017,
0.06020285189151764,
0.5202122926712036,
0.93585205078125,
-0.039498910307884216,
-0.01767026260495186,
-0.2801639437675476,
0.5426441431045532,
-0.4169329106807709,
0.07444081455469131,
-0.4425049424171448,
0.10338915139436722,
-0.06555955111980438,
-0.03145552799105644,
-0.2526983320713043,
-0.4725470542907715,
0.09076029807329178,
-0.4788919985294342,
0.15639787912368774,
0.13385982811450958,
0.9274585247039795,
0.5503540635108948,
-0.47470003366470337,
-0.2701554596424103,
-0.6244294047355652,
0.5766783356666565,
-0.800402820110321,
0.06603267043828964,
-0.11592484265565872,
0.6298202872276306,
0.02048875018954277,
-0.8234584927558899,
-1.30303955078125,
-0.41190826892852783,
0.08407673984766006,
0.13660100102424622,
-0.484836220741272,
-0.6502089500427246,
0.43659210205078125,
0.3330443501472473,
-0.7411092519760132,
-0.012470229528844357,
-0.1698693037033081,
0.18027999997138977,
0.5225715637207031,
0.3672679662704468,
0.5861107110977173,
-0.5170395374298096,
-0.7274616360664368,
-0.33745822310447693,
-0.3264050781726837,
0.1823149472475052,
0.5890284180641174,
-0.008291910402476788,
-0.20389777421951294,
0.5034091472625732,
0.1684330403804779,
0.1559840738773346,
-0.23264577984809875,
0.00922474730759859,
0.45629361271858215,
-0.22553375363349915,
-0.16780729591846466,
-0.23960581421852112,
0.7852854132652283,
0.45347580313682556,
0.2829556465148926,
-0.19504134356975555,
-0.12128007411956787,
0.2525019943714142,
0.5467641353607178,
-0.27235111594200134,
-0.4130155146121979,
0.050035782158374786,
-0.2350296825170517,
-0.1395200788974762,
-0.0680491104722023,
-0.6344506740570068,
-0.986406147480011,
0.020184392109513283,
0.6718875169754028,
-0.5844783782958984,
-0.3762790560722351,
0.3391929864883423,
-0.7291186451911926,
0.11049298942089081,
0.33838459849357605,
-0.1426270455121994,
0.24626903235912323,
0.5062839984893799,
0.7411852478981018,
0.17540526390075684,
-0.3463155925273895,
-0.42974522709846497,
-0.0220947302877903,
-0.19920873641967773,
0.8786188364028931,
-0.5230712294578552,
-0.013594142161309719,
-0.3990715444087982,
-0.26601600646972656,
-0.17381609976291656,
-0.6943076252937317,
0.7077828645706177,
-0.2471887469291687,
0.21889670193195343,
-0.10205096751451492,
-0.509322464466095,
-0.21847666800022125,
0.23188015818595886,
-0.8286701440811157,
0.6428154706954956,
0.24765075743198395,
-0.9210465550422668,
-0.08609656244516373,
-0.4541779160499573,
-0.5801594853401184,
0.22859658300876617,
-0.41342106461524963,
-0.36237844824790955,
0.4365478754043579,
0.10303376615047455,
0.14113980531692505,
-0.41238728165626526,
0.3957744836807251,
-0.22412735223770142,
-0.5380987524986267,
0.564721941947937,
-0.5202980041503906,
1.1259361505508423,
0.26248830556869507,
-0.668369710445404,
-0.17271941900253296,
-0.7062492966651917,
-0.19183143973350525,
0.6487932205200195,
0.152730330824852,
-0.29823213815689087,
0.1492731124162674,
0.025910763069987297,
0.4293641448020935,
0.04365157335996628,
-0.2658648192882538,
0.2544112205505371,
-0.26316821575164795,
0.5494165420532227,
0.7396147847175598,
-0.4768396019935608,
0.05678688734769821,
-0.47881194949150085,
0.698398232460022,
0.029434962198138237,
-0.06277235597372055,
-0.3638399541378021,
-0.701435923576355,
-0.5247711539268494,
-0.12031758576631546,
-0.0811714380979538,
0.7049145698547363,
-1.2596673965454102,
0.15822874009609222,
-0.44773557782173157,
-0.497967392206192,
-0.6132636666297913,
-0.08743514865636826,
0.4549494981765747,
0.6003680229187012,
0.4152490198612213,
-0.44142717123031616,
-0.10259086638689041,
-1.0254850387573242,
-0.5892795920372009,
-0.33156633377075195,
-0.09227685630321503,
0.419453501701355,
0.5337479114532471,
0.04221302270889282,
0.7373117804527283,
-0.2615962028503418,
0.08043239265680313,
-0.4426652491092682,
0.7852235436439514,
0.43890073895454407,
0.22003291547298431,
0.6396721601486206,
-1.172386884689331,
-0.3442437946796417,
-0.11469107121229172,
-0.7488576769828796,
-0.31076398491859436,
-0.5250573754310608,
0.5823579430580139,
-0.1552322804927826,
0.39343348145484924,
-0.6643994450569153,
0.546953558921814,
0.4524913430213928,
-0.29554226994514465,
1.0256754159927368,
-0.24794957041740417,
0.1772904247045517,
-0.5209916234016418,
0.28445056080818176,
0.0745287761092186,
-0.22305560111999512,
-0.47257229685783386,
0.45305463671684265,
0.19425338506698608,
-0.016184549778699875,
-0.5338428020477295,
0.592290461063385,
-0.33314597606658936,
-0.097683385014534,
-0.11018611490726471,
0.291515052318573,
0.15698891878128052,
0.3978964686393738,
-0.15047240257263184,
0.8924897313117981,
0.25250643491744995,
-0.25185826420783997,
0.3858826458454132,
0.20335893332958221,
-0.6919680833816528,
0.8755196332931519,
-0.7213443517684937,
0.2729324698448181,
-0.2460465431213379,
0.4520702660083771,
-1.5770598649978638,
-0.1593547910451889,
0.1425653100013733,
-0.23591536283493042,
0.19072864949703217,
0.11831320077180862,
-0.9774710536003113,
-0.6972886919975281,
-0.199334055185318,
0.7362435460090637,
0.551071286201477,
-0.5813201665878296,
0.4926234185695648,
-0.07943190634250641,
-0.10564935207366943,
-0.6526448726654053,
-0.6665520071983337,
0.3544691205024719,
-0.2541655898094177,
-0.6587789058685303,
0.2357373833656311,
-0.2982870042324066,
-0.37567538022994995,
0.021733615547418594,
-0.32103320956230164,
0.14313086867332458,
0.09167718142271042,
0.13437974452972412,
-0.042326200753450394,
-0.3770524561405182,
-0.054011598229408264,
-0.21812984347343445,
-0.09019432961940765,
-0.1430985927581787,
-0.0538349524140358,
0.4268472492694855,
-0.18773797154426575,
-0.457813560962677,
-0.6330068707466125,
0.27948519587516785,
0.4833241403102875,
-0.1337200552225113,
0.5845627784729004,
0.6438037753105164,
-0.09053613990545273,
0.01406285259872675,
-0.6193413138389587,
0.3621142506599426,
-0.5244883298873901,
0.24363890290260315,
-0.462724894285202,
-0.6716753244400024,
0.4258483648300171,
-0.06966983526945114,
-0.37813299894332886,
0.45892924070358276,
0.32138535380363464,
-0.19014914333820343,
1.0770976543426514,
0.6655561327934265,
-0.021226786077022552,
0.1126440092921257,
0.08919741958379745,
0.5365734100341797,
-0.45198482275009155,
-0.044378772377967834,
-0.748893141746521,
-0.616040825843811,
-0.5751244425773621,
-0.35178929567337036,
0.47017034888267517,
0.16885356605052948,
-0.1796298772096634,
0.5444198250770569,
-0.135494664311409,
0.9124502539634705,
0.47808781266212463,
-0.17515064775943756,
0.140676811337471,
-0.4158024489879608,
-0.3022007942199707,
0.1369442641735077,
-0.560386061668396,
-0.3820422887802124,
0.45571663975715637,
0.2818855047225952,
0.5777721405029297,
0.3943065106868744,
0.35230278968811035,
0.20588859915733337,
-0.0050064451061189175,
-0.2817354202270508,
0.6326796412467957,
-0.3126303553581238,
-0.7325403690338135,
0.11260306090116501,
-0.5675109624862671,
-0.7805889844894409,
-0.010618261992931366,
0.05156989395618439,
-1.2109854221343994,
0.10953958332538605,
-0.20484024286270142,
-0.27331972122192383,
0.41717201471328735,
-0.9699608087539673,
1.0927748680114746,
-0.1731087565422058,
-0.45562517642974854,
-0.20358623564243317,
-1.2262517213821411,
0.30987295508384705,
0.38309457898139954,
0.5039130449295044,
0.02136964350938797,
0.08628141134977341,
0.13138799369335175,
0.017324894666671753,
0.7708343267440796,
0.19619742035865784,
-0.030389562249183655,
0.1299266815185547,
0.3934031128883362,
0.2672891616821289,
-0.13505879044532776,
-0.12435740232467651,
0.10236027836799622,
-0.1628687083721161,
-0.6622382402420044,
-0.7086606025695801,
0.46268072724342346,
-0.6653119325637817,
-0.6348117589950562,
-0.3706510066986084,
-0.9685235619544983,
-0.19573065638542175,
0.08414825797080994,
0.11755383759737015,
0.3432713747024536,
0.1051425188779831,
0.010962273925542831,
0.1896025538444519,
-0.5994083285331726,
0.4461268186569214,
-0.010562787763774395,
0.15204176306724548,
-0.14540822803974152,
1.1066629886627197,
-0.33915233612060547,
0.3841841220855713,
0.3157442510128021,
0.26483482122421265,
-0.5492457747459412,
-0.393308162689209,
-0.43900007009506226,
0.3771974444389343,
-0.9163409471511841,
-0.08184836059808731,
-0.5324326157569885,
-0.012454306706786156,
-0.26878392696380615,
-0.06907591968774796,
-0.163909450173378,
-0.6640884876251221,
-0.041624244302511215,
0.2897289991378784,
-0.24716068804264069,
0.910818338394165,
0.031469061970710754,
0.1404397338628769,
-0.5745482444763184,
0.6312740445137024,
0.37785547971725464,
0.3278525769710541,
0.11855775862932205,
-0.3701644837856293,
-0.04996372386813164,
-0.25673723220825195,
-0.6055378913879395,
-0.9284482002258301,
0.1767912656068802,
0.10436688363552094,
0.49750837683677673,
0.3298313021659851,
0.03845032677054405,
0.8096389174461365,
-0.7382565140724182,
0.9973967671394348,
0.45352014899253845,
-0.9733904004096985,
0.2791392207145691,
-0.29610559344291687,
0.47736045718193054,
0.19527457654476166,
0.649898111820221,
-0.45262619853019714,
-0.5743042826652527,
-0.8168272376060486,
-0.5649140477180481,
0.7286652326583862,
0.6145343780517578,
0.4910457134246826,
-0.24901722371578217,
0.15936680138111115,
0.46437349915504456,
0.4673662781715393,
-0.904260516166687,
-0.24262650310993195,
-0.33378663659095764,
-0.18422378599643707,
-0.2027072012424469,
0.2346404641866684,
-0.14554715156555176,
-0.13515079021453857,
-0.030507685616612434,
-0.2218049317598343,
0.27491405606269836,
-0.04448508843779564,
-0.1863895058631897,
-0.21361975371837616,
0.2522847652435303,
0.728919267654419,
0.8766981959342957,
-0.06244944781064987,
0.40088748931884766,
-0.3064161539077759,
-0.07115144282579422,
-0.08789672702550888,
0.2984732985496521,
0.3039940595626831,
-0.11120206862688065,
0.8119235038757324,
0.7950021028518677,
0.08524736762046814,
-1.111279845237732,
0.775897741317749,
-0.08283752202987671,
0.039588961750268936,
0.11701108515262604,
0.3686091899871826,
0.08654854446649551,
0.9337037205696106,
0.47152766585350037,
0.222349151968956,
0.19119569659233093,
-1.0929237604141235,
0.2276393175125122,
0.3330858647823334,
-0.044766973704099655,
-0.30277714133262634,
0.9961734414100647,
-0.15576152503490448,
-0.562732458114624,
0.6157563924789429,
-0.3973802924156189,
-0.8187538385391235,
1.03837251663208,
0.660232424736023,
0.7573028802871704,
-0.017105549573898315,
0.368039608001709,
0.05740092322230339,
0.23682010173797607,
0.10861428827047348,
0.10828845202922821,
0.07792393118143082,
-0.6369089484214783,
-0.23314936459064484,
-0.24531039595603943,
-0.35770007967948914,
0.03734450042247772,
-0.4762086570262909,
0.23690159618854523,
-0.4225844442844391,
0.17379702627658844,
0.4360291361808777,
-0.21986135840415955,
-0.9270572662353516,
0.2827584743499756,
0.3179992735385895,
0.7589372396469116,
-0.7867794036865234,
0.532161295413971,
0.7179539203643799,
-0.8231534361839294,
-0.5624966621398926,
0.4040224850177765,
0.20650316774845123,
-0.8432005047798157,
0.5819195508956909,
0.5794672966003418,
0.05775438994169235,
-0.15924173593521118,
-0.8294556736946106,
0.07978606969118118,
0.7760087251663208,
0.4241238832473755,
-0.3284108340740204,
-0.21776948869228363,
0.15143053233623505,
0.8285131454467773,
-0.2973800599575043,
0.5778284668922424,
0.42916563153266907,
0.34127193689346313,
0.03230155259370804,
-1.097795009613037,
0.020647479221224785,
-0.5357778072357178,
-0.10917367786169052,
-0.016968345269560814,
-0.6780838966369629,
1.0584534406661987,
-0.4186970591545105,
-0.21071290969848633,
0.3755604922771454,
0.44800785183906555,
0.10639230161905289,
0.7735804319381714,
0.7994836568832397,
0.6636314988136292,
0.43031662702560425,
0.07465289533138275,
1.478935718536377,
0.36975714564323425,
0.21535634994506836,
1.0749505758285522,
-0.41025876998901367,
0.7333369851112366,
0.43058204650878906,
-0.37115901708602905,
0.8121021389961243,
0.05302547290921211,
-0.032343629747629166,
0.4186941087245941,
0.12552399933338165,
0.058463968336582184,
-0.4090152382850647,
-0.13122186064720154,
-0.318747341632843,
0.35536208748817444,
0.08845808357000351,
0.10388035327196121,
-0.3320188522338867,
-0.04361124709248543,
-0.42141854763031006,
0.45123177766799927,
0.06347662210464478,
0.588146984577179,
0.10262960195541382,
-0.552277147769928,
0.533405065536499,
-0.09543784707784653,
0.2860259711742401,
-0.29118382930755615,
-0.23990315198898315,
-0.24401038885116577,
0.026816777884960175,
0.16886596381664276,
-1.1140007972717285,
0.14916211366653442,
-0.14373892545700073,
0.2320616990327835,
0.10864055156707764,
0.3344027101993561,
0.007934718392789364,
-0.3048957288265228,
0.22260849177837372,
0.4327510893344879,
0.12052438408136368,
-0.04462495073676109,
-0.9282838702201843,
0.06582768261432648,
-0.26661059260368347,
0.11663712561130524,
0.05868793651461601,
0.9031698107719421,
0.014212308451533318,
0.8444831967353821,
0.34348422288894653,
-0.3310629725456238,
0.053678806871175766,
0.22658464312553406,
0.8258918523788452,
-0.7824642062187195,
-0.6882778406143188,
-0.7047494649887085,
0.7676227688789368,
-0.16008397936820984,
-0.513644814491272,
0.5295930504798889,
0.22117678821086884,
0.7969438433647156,
-0.14708952605724335,
0.5905957818031311,
-0.21689565479755402,
0.19606977701187134,
-0.375088632106781,
0.4296138286590576,
-1.3530540466308594,
0.26234227418899536,
-0.6978310942649841,
-0.7723677158355713,
-0.36435019969940186,
0.556788980960846,
-0.3301565945148468,
0.11047323048114777,
0.8559771776199341,
0.4302321970462799,
-0.37538787722587585,
0.4303975999355316,
0.2577672600746155,
0.4040229618549347,
0.30047568678855896,
0.6732407808303833,
1.245448350906372,
-0.2665184736251831,
0.6547473669052124,
-0.2406061887741089,
0.02405334636569023,
-0.34418779611587524,
-1.1216033697128296,
-1.001380205154419,
-0.5461258292198181,
-0.4175175428390503,
-0.15604563057422638,
-0.028991321101784706,
0.6538242697715759,
0.3039703369140625,
-0.5975907444953918,
-0.04354344308376312,
-0.1473490446805954,
0.1995716542005539,
-0.5549450516700745,
-0.2571512758731842,
0.1670343577861786,
-0.1810787469148636,
-0.699319064617157,
0.3065071702003479,
0.4932417571544647,
-0.16506409645080566,
-0.12308020889759064,
0.0459805391728878,
-0.4187237620353699,
0.2869894504547119,
0.2301778644323349,
0.3287389874458313,
-0.9317396879196167,
-0.5460839867591858,
-0.17901559174060822,
-0.11877892911434174,
0.3226028382778168,
0.7753025889396667,
-0.717323362827301,
0.6306005120277405,
0.5064170360565186,
0.9135481715202332,
0.2590726912021637,
-0.039542343467473984,
0.2632867395877838,
-0.889004111289978,
0.19703231751918793,
0.3459835946559906,
0.224031001329422,
0.41140466928482056,
-0.08226696401834488,
0.6278125643730164,
0.5928127765655518,
-0.3483524024486542,
-0.96719890832901,
0.26316314935684204,
-1.1486667394638062,
-0.6048940420150757,
0.5995360016822815,
-0.2245585173368454,
-0.19981703162193298,
0.014041717164218426,
-0.25411543250083923,
0.23482418060302734,
0.19644711911678314,
0.9910852313041687,
0.8221714496612549,
-0.233145609498024,
-0.4475752115249634,
-0.8282331824302673,
-0.06828735023736954,
0.7378848791122437,
-0.6291781663894653,
-0.31764504313468933,
0.3648252785205841,
0.09386730939149857,
0.5441997647285461,
0.4338741600513458,
0.07225187122821808,
0.6672176122665405,
0.282020628452301,
-0.2546863555908203,
0.13910825550556183,
-0.4932551681995392,
-0.20803950726985931,
0.26505938172340393,
-0.28108349442481995,
0.20243853330612183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19086v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19086v2
|
MEMoE: Enhancing Model Editing with Mixture of Experts Adaptors
| 2024-05-29T13:49:44 | 2024-06-02T02:32:31 |
Renzhi Wang, Piji Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Model editing aims to efficiently alter the behavior of Large Language Models
(LLMs) within a desired scope, while ensuring no adverse impact on other
inputs. Recent years have witnessed various model editing methods been
proposed. However, these methods either exhibit poor overall performance or
struggle to strike a balance between generalization and locality. We propose
MEMoE, a model editing adapter utilizing a Mixture of Experts (MoE)
architecture with a knowledge anchor routing strategy. MEMoE updates knowledge
using a bypass MoE structure, keeping the original parameters unchanged to
preserve the general ability of LLMs. And, the knowledge anchor routing ensures
that inputs requiring similar knowledge are routed to the same expert, thereby
enhancing the generalization of the updated knowledge. Experimental results
show the superiority of our approach over both batch editing and sequential
batch editing tasks, exhibiting exceptional overall performance alongside
outstanding balance between generalization and locality. Our code will be
available.
|
[
-0.17889218032360077,
-0.7412346601486206,
0.650985062122345,
0.2690882682800293,
-0.1330888420343399,
0.08458752185106277,
-0.3215795159339905,
-0.1953023374080658,
0.2210388034582138,
0.4803420603275299,
-0.34660980105400085,
-0.5092659592628479,
-0.5376907587051392,
-0.25087857246398926,
-0.2400362491607666,
0.5834306478500366,
0.0359172560274601,
0.18112006783485413,
-0.29979515075683594,
-0.27325472235679626,
-0.8780542016029358,
-0.27818354964256287,
-1.0944275856018066,
-0.001161288470029831,
0.390914648771286,
0.37636762857437134,
0.5644304156303406,
0.9091659188270569,
0.47827887535095215,
0.49504366517066956,
-0.31075361371040344,
0.4029286801815033,
-0.5107749104499817,
0.23417875170707703,
-0.8685694336891174,
-0.7847660779953003,
-1.1696749925613403,
-0.5545713901519775,
0.5765694975852966,
0.47401708364486694,
-0.30357393622398376,
-0.05762540549039841,
-0.10402664542198181,
0.7849553823471069,
-0.6896915435791016,
-0.11418069899082184,
-0.9937499761581421,
-0.38662856817245483,
-0.2125345915555954,
-0.08674442768096924,
-0.3091416656970978,
-0.05211102217435837,
-0.017193075269460678,
-0.6605080366134644,
0.29860061407089233,
0.2137521356344223,
0.3788590431213379,
0.49323126673698425,
-0.12565463781356812,
-0.10704821348190308,
-0.7234532833099365,
0.537194550037384,
-0.9150236248970032,
0.3470459282398224,
-0.0027186425868421793,
0.33370715379714966,
-0.4043126404285431,
-0.7382235527038574,
-0.5032556653022766,
0.2801075577735901,
0.32370471954345703,
0.16817845404148102,
-0.10564009845256805,
0.30308783054351807,
0.07156472653150558,
0.44697996973991394,
-0.08682544529438019,
0.10628967732191086,
-0.3706589937210083,
0.022149844095110893,
0.6777292490005493,
0.14073535799980164,
0.4398195743560791,
0.08277670294046402,
-0.14560116827487946,
0.09827563166618347,
-0.48000866174697876,
-0.12261655181646347,
0.3075481057167053,
-0.2295781672000885,
0.23673322796821594,
0.5188642740249634,
-0.33474114537239075,
0.8140022158622742,
0.3582039475440979,
-0.19965378940105438,
-0.06446138024330139,
0.07870414853096008,
-0.40225663781166077,
-0.018118083477020264,
0.5943288207054138,
0.6764323115348816,
-0.00361003540456295,
-0.19135986268520355,
-0.4428567886352539,
-0.47219735383987427,
0.22282607853412628,
-0.5810239315032959,
-0.45051971077919006,
0.060077257454395294,
-0.3566150665283203,
-0.22848382592201233,
0.11029898375272751,
-0.8469476103782654,
-0.5228936672210693,
-0.22003492712974548,
0.3280041515827179,
-0.5998393297195435,
-0.08310753107070923,
0.2718868553638458,
-0.4324427843093872,
-0.3571086823940277,
0.6619608402252197,
-0.9683688282966614,
0.33942317962646484,
0.6286118030548096,
0.777790904045105,
0.047367773950099945,
-0.35118329524993896,
-0.3542315661907196,
0.6993703842163086,
-0.18598313629627228,
0.960828423500061,
-0.7667858004570007,
-0.656283974647522,
-0.4465533196926117,
-0.3741682767868042,
-0.40423232316970825,
-0.7373949885368347,
0.608643651008606,
-0.9490353465080261,
0.01139324065297842,
-0.17048685252666473,
-0.9528458118438721,
-0.45953425765037537,
0.12124524265527725,
-0.5371705889701843,
0.9346542954444885,
0.11770106106996536,
-0.5295884013175964,
0.12048331648111343,
-0.9197498559951782,
-0.2305099219083786,
-0.3581380844116211,
0.02669229917228222,
-0.07974199950695038,
0.3486029803752899,
0.5835707187652588,
0.21707771718502045,
-0.08228583633899689,
0.5919596552848816,
-0.3730255663394928,
-0.18542802333831787,
0.21517981588840485,
-0.29427969455718994,
0.45621538162231445,
0.06451951712369919,
0.05166076868772507,
0.5707597732543945,
-0.9835401177406311,
-0.36157554388046265,
-0.19877594709396362,
-0.6189420819282532,
-0.5473337173461914,
0.24260495603084564,
-0.2656584084033966,
0.2619398534297943,
0.2550113797187805,
-0.26037004590034485,
0.6807569861412048,
-0.12004553526639938,
0.36161279678344727,
1.2158243656158447,
0.31197619438171387,
0.7318582534790039,
-0.5752807259559631,
0.4746304750442505,
0.3340776562690735,
0.15827344357967377,
-0.2222425788640976,
-0.6444593667984009,
-1.1455925703048706,
-0.4123033583164215,
0.5488641262054443,
0.7047662138938904,
-0.6283079981803894,
0.226965993642807,
-0.49323853850364685,
-0.4527764916419983,
-0.8357231020927429,
0.6607028245925903,
0.13750076293945312,
0.6840181350708008,
0.48817938566207886,
-0.18503643572330475,
-0.5956181287765503,
-0.9568281173706055,
-0.6500783562660217,
0.07257995009422302,
-0.22807498276233673,
0.2972095310688019,
0.14146727323532104,
-0.28285348415374756,
1.1570037603378296,
-0.5755226016044617,
-0.17890778183937073,
-0.049449071288108826,
-0.11381363123655319,
0.07381629198789597,
0.7314658164978027,
0.5353124141693115,
-0.5113508105278015,
-0.4052576720714569,
0.064735047519207,
-0.5695688724517822,
-0.2452981173992157,
-0.09448671340942383,
-0.5009852051734924,
-0.07110681384801865,
0.7251870632171631,
-0.4725741744041443,
0.06835874915122986,
0.4747854769229889,
-0.0006068966467864811,
0.2380516231060028,
-0.27118346095085144,
0.18622390925884247,
-1.3390686511993408,
-0.18538400530815125,
-0.16663500666618347,
-0.17139562964439392,
-0.6801894307136536,
0.22433261573314667,
0.22147320210933685,
0.1555657684803009,
-0.34848275780677795,
0.7247506380081177,
-0.369497150182724,
0.16091647744178772,
-0.10343069583177567,
0.14344821870326996,
0.034227367490530014,
0.45530810952186584,
-0.15868444740772247,
0.8005695939064026,
0.6007200479507446,
-0.6131235957145691,
0.22031880915164948,
0.04614688828587532,
-0.20487377047538757,
0.6068336963653564,
-0.5188777446746826,
0.5852037072181702,
-0.14452333748340607,
0.08727461844682693,
-0.7207017540931702,
-0.313513845205307,
0.1380457878112793,
-0.12711362540721893,
0.4008629322052002,
-0.2314029484987259,
-0.3027634620666504,
-0.0675506666302681,
-0.3465169668197632,
0.33687624335289,
0.2915324568748474,
-0.2911362648010254,
1.1033082008361816,
0.2530273199081421,
-0.2689824402332306,
-0.3268734812736511,
-0.5358716249465942,
0.20358936488628387,
-0.1761702299118042,
-1.0316147804260254,
0.35884395241737366,
-0.2977742552757263,
-0.4474049210548401,
0.06359878927469254,
-0.1784178912639618,
-0.40316325426101685,
0.03497077897191048,
-0.03993890807032585,
0.30263403058052063,
-0.5388795137405396,
0.07250381261110306,
0.5713039636611938,
0.013411004096269608,
-0.14041544497013092,
-0.3571082055568695,
0.26748979091644287,
0.23193633556365967,
-0.3346404731273651,
-0.3167303800582886,
0.15819768607616425,
0.7150315046310425,
-0.3199010193347931,
0.7499588131904602,
0.4329826533794403,
-0.32607996463775635,
-0.2438252866268158,
-1.0962719917297363,
0.026751993224024773,
-0.5564748048782349,
0.5985127687454224,
-0.5213103890419006,
-0.7487692832946777,
0.6838410496711731,
-0.46832478046417236,
0.013721075840294361,
0.41201314330101013,
0.24256302416324615,
-0.03225503861904144,
0.5845034122467041,
0.6767299175262451,
-0.33930519223213196,
0.5336272120475769,
0.005549131892621517,
0.231144517660141,
-1.307618498802185,
-0.13429416716098785,
-0.3283978998661041,
-0.5044918060302734,
-0.12535803020000458,
-0.8941736817359924,
0.3493639826774597,
0.6329581141471863,
0.01826523430645466,
-0.11386717110872269,
-0.11120187491178513,
0.624325156211853,
0.6899937987327576,
0.351209819316864,
0.49427518248558044,
-0.21882672607898712,
-0.12821348011493683,
0.01771974004805088,
-1.1280622482299805,
-0.4654044210910797,
1.1553391218185425,
0.16910657286643982,
0.7895883321762085,
0.20919933915138245,
0.42100298404693604,
0.1706162691116333,
0.33885347843170166,
-0.5012884736061096,
0.7199003100395203,
-0.14469663798809052,
-0.5539049506187439,
-0.2001127302646637,
-0.16211608052253723,
-0.1485523283481598,
0.29653292894363403,
-0.1348966658115387,
-0.6200308203697205,
0.4633972942829132,
0.4656531512737274,
-0.22177809476852417,
0.8672301769256592,
-0.742704451084137,
0.6714743971824646,
0.1076245903968811,
-0.35005030035972595,
-0.41743937134742737,
-0.43603354692459106,
0.6199158430099487,
-0.23502838611602783,
0.42500385642051697,
0.13133221864700317,
-0.17333824932575226,
0.6505357027053833,
-0.5242258906364441,
0.681351900100708,
-0.01408481691032648,
0.14207369089126587,
0.18726305663585663,
0.34158021211624146,
0.7103528380393982,
0.09890729933977127,
-0.5311596393585205,
-0.007532565854489803,
-0.6513577103614807,
-0.39986851811408997,
-0.9724465012550354,
0.7417885661125183,
-0.628592848777771,
-0.9439947605133057,
0.25297531485557556,
-0.9638269543647766,
-0.3368050754070282,
0.1968337595462799,
-0.04621274396777153,
0.4303722083568573,
-0.0856114849448204,
0.06742221117019653,
0.8159693479537964,
-0.12316206842660904,
0.39784133434295654,
0.5954247713088989,
-0.18229664862155914,
-0.43312323093414307,
0.8567509651184082,
0.022270875051617622,
0.3861270844936371,
0.6172359585762024,
0.13390836119651794,
0.15297769010066986,
-0.8353602886199951,
-0.622724711894989,
-0.05603616312146187,
-0.8889515399932861,
-0.02609364688396454,
-0.8494391441345215,
-0.16765332221984863,
-0.36370521783828735,
-0.5622979402542114,
-0.5068555474281311,
-0.6192872524261475,
-0.27049359679222107,
0.09065904468297958,
0.4184357225894928,
0.6998618245124817,
-0.07149990648031235,
0.7133718729019165,
-0.8627539277076721,
0.3675236701965332,
0.6237825155258179,
0.30085423588752747,
0.1198495551943779,
-0.6305789947509766,
-0.2741173207759857,
-0.04581538215279579,
-0.36993804574012756,
-0.791282594203949,
0.020403731614351273,
0.23763109743595123,
0.6230422854423523,
0.6061763167381287,
-0.17491023242473602,
1.1481833457946777,
-0.616844117641449,
0.504098117351532,
-0.1606452763080597,
-1.1960045099258423,
0.5533601641654968,
-0.5700992941856384,
0.28010839223861694,
0.4969351291656494,
-0.1318611204624176,
-0.46741753816604614,
-0.6238234639167786,
-0.39301398396492004,
-0.622805655002594,
0.6159191131591797,
-0.08464111387729645,
-0.01996653899550438,
0.12428653240203857,
0.5034744739532471,
-0.15094177424907684,
0.4795234501361847,
-0.19887694716453552,
-0.23213496804237366,
0.03115362487733364,
-0.2196369469165802,
0.2625479996204376,
-0.556886613368988,
0.03571641817688942,
-0.37453532218933105,
0.8355811834335327,
0.203978031873703,
0.020513972267508507,
0.23962070047855377,
-0.3515651524066925,
-0.18661275506019592,
0.40393733978271484,
0.9323539137840271,
0.9331803321838379,
-0.47510769963264465,
-0.1766066998243332,
0.5855988264083862,
-0.38808390498161316,
-0.15756754577159882,
-0.22858016192913055,
-0.4556385576725006,
-0.0537535659968853,
0.43054649233818054,
1.0639750957489014,
0.6326638460159302,
-0.3862251043319702,
0.0979672446846962,
0.13851219415664673,
-0.08205969631671906,
0.41798144578933716,
0.644683301448822,
0.34921103715896606,
0.29320982098579407,
0.19448170065879822,
0.9143280386924744,
0.18713724613189697,
-0.21584635972976685,
-0.11870498955249786,
0.05710067227482796,
-0.04525509849190712,
-0.25748980045318604,
0.9130334258079529,
0.34951144456863403,
-0.632768452167511,
0.4426881968975067,
0.11905812472105026,
-0.514110803604126,
0.44436466693878174,
0.4812334179878235,
0.8081662654876709,
-0.8158283233642578,
-0.2813539505004883,
0.15501472353935242,
0.4408140778541565,
-0.017184630036354065,
-0.08370159566402435,
0.31686556339263916,
-0.7415438890457153,
-0.39963385462760925,
-0.282381534576416,
-0.4273485243320465,
-0.06737466156482697,
-0.6129883527755737,
0.436149001121521,
-0.5519890189170837,
0.09880853444337845,
-0.3367443084716797,
-0.6869732737541199,
-0.5766229629516602,
0.17336885631084442,
-0.30983966588974,
1.3213906288146973,
-0.4695393741130829,
1.0084431171417236,
1.1243982315063477,
-0.010102841071784496,
-0.6551284193992615,
-0.18683399260044098,
0.037888091057538986,
-0.7077047824859619,
0.2324809730052948,
-0.32900670170783997,
0.03559005260467529,
0.2291254997253418,
-0.157139390707016,
-0.6813495755195618,
1.2229321002960205,
0.3730664551258087,
-0.8904208540916443,
-0.19986023008823395,
-0.15519483387470245,
0.3003298044204712,
-0.3177832067012787,
0.27028024196624756,
0.4193720817565918,
0.5640010237693787,
0.04556175693869591,
-0.7455595135688782,
-0.1240769699215889,
-0.15386690199375153,
0.28550851345062256,
-0.048761505633592606,
-0.7147344350814819,
0.88112872838974,
0.014518591575324535,
0.2638663947582245,
-0.08721394836902618,
0.8278570771217346,
0.2331700474023819,
0.14934806525707245,
0.5107242465019226,
0.7970351576805115,
1.0473846197128296,
0.36172184348106384,
0.872804582118988,
-0.5207095146179199,
0.1039506122469902,
1.5296612977981567,
-0.28395065665245056,
0.8319823145866394,
0.40656137466430664,
-0.057026684284210205,
0.5394405126571655,
0.3222862482070923,
0.21976801753044128,
0.4519757032394409,
-0.05295829474925995,
-0.4729497730731964,
-0.21694794297218323,
0.32650360465049744,
-0.22525879740715027,
0.15336066484451294,
0.29751941561698914,
-0.416996031999588,
-0.20633675158023834,
-0.15514162182807922,
0.23517590761184692,
0.09999648481607437,
-0.5922572016716003,
0.7156254053115845,
-0.08534756302833557,
-0.5114554762840271,
-0.04684964194893837,
0.49530887603759766,
0.48264506459236145,
-0.5592065453529358,
0.029683463275432587,
-0.19229218363761902,
0.2567235827445984,
-0.11765075474977493,
-0.5342094898223877,
0.21197812259197235,
-0.14119552075862885,
-0.6536818146705627,
0.06035790964961052,
0.8939770460128784,
-0.49018603563308716,
-0.744514524936676,
0.1771383136510849,
0.5019729137420654,
-0.21396523714065552,
-0.22522258758544922,
-0.6193236112594604,
0.022969959303736687,
0.03340257704257965,
-0.34352120757102966,
0.29192590713500977,
0.6306256055831909,
-0.15799427032470703,
0.8818567991256714,
0.7606755495071411,
0.12865513563156128,
0.5230623483657837,
-0.11330515891313553,
1.0909312963485718,
-0.5432681441307068,
-0.3859746754169464,
-1.033881425857544,
0.8191198110580444,
-0.18616479635238647,
-0.25768083333969116,
0.7452704310417175,
0.5892475247383118,
0.6549913883209229,
-0.40369346737861633,
0.7927061915397644,
0.15379005670547485,
0.23981112241744995,
-0.8157715201377869,
0.6075558662414551,
-0.22177088260650635,
0.4657495617866516,
-0.2573462724685669,
-1.058077096939087,
-0.3180338740348816,
0.3503996729850769,
-0.44539833068847656,
-0.08737251907587051,
0.6476628184318542,
1.0040675401687622,
-0.4407135844230652,
-0.10436121374368668,
0.2772330939769745,
0.6682106852531433,
0.42059653997421265,
0.3479417860507965,
0.45747387409210205,
-0.3454323709011078,
0.09394481778144836,
-0.3919946849346161,
-0.10089695453643799,
-0.23115570843219757,
-0.9208822250366211,
-1.1972153186798096,
-0.12406552582979202,
-0.29752421379089355,
0.11902956664562225,
0.28781330585479736,
0.8506205081939697,
0.6965196132659912,
-0.6578322052955627,
-0.12204242497682571,
-0.057839494198560715,
0.42819082736968994,
-0.17706584930419922,
-0.1976068764925003,
0.4055682420730591,
-0.22890223562717438,
-0.8645420074462891,
0.7178362011909485,
0.5737830996513367,
-0.28939077258110046,
0.09742427617311478,
-0.053033195436000824,
-0.2650569677352905,
0.32754752039909363,
0.41519302129745483,
-0.08186011016368866,
-0.63068687915802,
-0.020181404426693916,
-0.18951216340065002,
0.18092505633831024,
0.18561479449272156,
0.8287556171417236,
-0.5225815176963806,
0.7772401571273804,
0.43199893832206726,
0.7557598352432251,
0.03648215904831886,
0.2364511489868164,
0.7959378361701965,
-0.5449293255805969,
0.17260628938674927,
-0.17598912119865417,
0.6605754494667053,
0.23891091346740723,
-0.3703913688659668,
0.2812093496322632,
0.33689799904823303,
-0.6046721935272217,
-0.529414176940918,
-0.21152660250663757,
-1.130009412765503,
-0.12901057302951813,
0.9397323727607727,
-0.21353764832019806,
-0.43210479617118835,
-0.0019704559817910194,
-0.6749723553657532,
0.25705721974372864,
-0.4966881573200226,
0.8093832731246948,
0.866914689540863,
0.21441234648227692,
-0.20451289415359497,
-0.7865949869155884,
0.03756538778543472,
0.34427469968795776,
-0.7188621759414673,
-0.3573341965675354,
0.4019307494163513,
0.5298537611961365,
-0.20774079859256744,
0.6977400183677673,
0.1964699774980545,
0.25789114832878113,
-0.16151823103427887,
0.2674558162689209,
-0.48572030663490295,
-0.225959911942482,
-0.3015744984149933,
0.011483404785394669,
0.25470465421676636,
-0.08830691128969193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19084v1
|
Auxiliary Knowledge-Induced Learning for Automatic Multi-Label Medical Document Classification
| 2024-05-29T13:44:07 | 2024-05-29T13:44:07 |
Xindi Wang, Robert E. Mercer, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The International Classification of Diseases (ICD) is an authoritative
medical classification system of different diseases and conditions for clinical
and management purposes. ICD indexing assigns a subset of ICD codes to a
medical record. Since human coding is labour-intensive and error-prone, many
studies employ machine learning to automate the coding process. ICD coding is a
challenging task, as it needs to assign multiple codes to each medical document
from an extremely large hierarchically organized collection. In this paper, we
propose a novel approach for ICD indexing that adopts three ideas: (1) we use a
multi-level deep dilated residual convolution encoder to aggregate the
information from the clinical notes and learn document representations across
different lengths of the texts; (2) we formalize the task of ICD classification
with auxiliary knowledge of the medical records, which incorporates not only
the clinical texts but also different clinical code terminologies and drug
prescriptions for better inferring the ICD codes; and (3) we introduce a graph
convolutional network to leverage the co-occurrence patterns among ICD codes,
aiming to enhance the quality of label representations. Experimental results
show the proposed method achieves state-of-the-art performance on a number of
measures.
|
[
-0.2770704925060272,
-0.3687862455844879,
0.3550912141799927,
-0.09288937598466873,
-0.49948298931121826,
0.2212219387292862,
-0.07284540683031082,
-0.5739098191261292,
0.1737111359834671,
0.2952333092689514,
-0.2608374357223511,
-1.0621051788330078,
-0.6534560918807983,
0.07333852350711823,
-0.1775057464838028,
1.2101696729660034,
-0.20082363486289978,
0.2925383746623993,
-0.3620373010635376,
-0.3717106580734253,
-0.16511884331703186,
-0.8354492783546448,
-0.6413655281066895,
-0.38333243131637573,
0.5559132695198059,
0.5520384907722473,
0.24425359070301056,
0.5866091251373291,
0.7906168103218079,
0.27180004119873047,
0.34720873832702637,
0.5907410979270935,
0.06422850489616394,
-0.13080419600009918,
0.36468973755836487,
-0.4014652669429779,
-0.3530167043209076,
-0.312127023935318,
0.4402337372303009,
0.5477162003517151,
-0.10564780235290527,
-0.0388885922729969,
0.006882373709231615,
0.5859470367431641,
-0.3347035348415375,
0.4206976890563965,
-0.1954939365386963,
0.15323428809642792,
0.04845758154988289,
-0.44112429022789,
-0.4308870732784271,
-0.4251630902290344,
0.008803801611065865,
-0.6210945844650269,
0.2705481946468353,
-0.08119241893291473,
0.8054611086845398,
0.1698363572359085,
-0.6015958189964294,
-0.652258574962616,
-0.37920501828193665,
0.12515024840831757,
-0.381147563457489,
0.513250470161438,
0.3222593665122986,
0.19615276157855988,
0.17352023720741272,
-0.9910387992858887,
-0.3955341875553131,
-0.12430941313505173,
-0.3714502453804016,
0.3054145574569702,
0.11806794255971909,
0.3058681786060333,
0.13176748156547546,
0.4152967929840088,
-0.63181072473526,
0.2726004719734192,
-0.4989507496356964,
-0.1159004494547844,
0.4849627614021301,
0.06237948313355446,
0.5754734873771667,
0.09442166239023209,
-0.31733837723731995,
0.007219108287245035,
-0.3056524395942688,
-0.07346783578395844,
-0.10209839791059494,
0.02420046366751194,
-0.34732797741889954,
0.5115401148796082,
-0.12236163020133972,
0.4397446811199188,
0.2593718469142914,
-0.36536115407943726,
0.842067539691925,
-0.19541800022125244,
-0.1459285467863083,
0.48030656576156616,
0.7356497645378113,
0.2787207365036011,
-0.13838928937911987,
-0.209443598985672,
-0.07074989378452301,
0.21675781905651093,
0.25893574953079224,
-0.6395257711410522,
-0.40464821457862854,
0.09225429594516754,
-0.5692280530929565,
-0.0783623531460762,
-0.11577796936035156,
-0.5611331462860107,
-0.42609500885009766,
-0.5735054612159729,
0.2895984351634979,
-0.6973687410354614,
0.3625175356864929,
0.036617182195186615,
-0.10644814372062683,
-0.1501259207725525,
0.3569561243057251,
-0.7610782980918884,
0.47632506489753723,
0.5852546691894531,
0.8607279658317566,
-0.14342202246189117,
-0.11121246218681335,
-0.591735303401947,
0.24667870998382568,
-0.3581652343273163,
0.7126451134681702,
-0.5495352745056152,
-0.47318437695503235,
-0.09540453553199768,
0.04197877645492554,
-0.06063046678900719,
-0.5598717331886292,
0.7855622172355652,
-0.5670859813690186,
-0.24446330964565277,
0.3350771963596344,
-0.555694043636322,
-0.22572217881679535,
0.3989848792552948,
-0.7089819312095642,
0.6305633187294006,
0.2208641767501831,
-0.8614274263381958,
0.4559609293937683,
-0.4854525625705719,
-0.7967037558555603,
0.1748868077993393,
-0.5049688220024109,
-0.7174526453018188,
-0.08041150122880936,
0.5917675495147705,
0.3764398992061615,
-0.2487351894378662,
0.3642507791519165,
-0.19964058697223663,
-0.14706489443778992,
0.0306159146130085,
-0.36691901087760925,
0.5010694265365601,
0.14017891883850098,
0.21447211503982544,
0.1114678680896759,
-0.979827344417572,
-0.08148622512817383,
-0.3538491427898407,
-0.5601165294647217,
-0.5950127243995667,
-0.37591463327407837,
-0.15550562739372253,
0.22609485685825348,
0.053177610039711,
-0.4442406892776489,
0.44938138127326965,
-0.43285149335861206,
-0.09588897973299026,
0.5287908315658569,
0.5765272378921509,
0.4376242756843567,
-0.4477261006832123,
0.3428041338920593,
0.2902975082397461,
0.3456540107727051,
-0.27812665700912476,
-0.5295847058296204,
-0.6813982725143433,
-0.31667187809944153,
0.31456539034843445,
0.47705909609794617,
-0.7484400868415833,
0.5709207057952881,
-0.35274702310562134,
-0.47773149609565735,
-0.5724218487739563,
0.14679692685604095,
0.3106135427951813,
0.7384418249130249,
0.5688097476959229,
-0.4064810872077942,
-0.35633546113967896,
-0.740649938583374,
0.33056700229644775,
0.03272595256567001,
-0.07327143102884293,
0.6503354907035828,
0.29119691252708435,
-0.7108152508735657,
0.45905229449272156,
-0.7482931017875671,
-0.6695448160171509,
0.12058761715888977,
0.44671541452407837,
0.30174413323402405,
0.7429155707359314,
0.38012829422950745,
-0.7523432374000549,
-0.6630958318710327,
0.6492394804954529,
-0.5422189235687256,
0.13954445719718933,
-0.1635248064994812,
-0.0676349475979805,
-0.056003786623477936,
0.5207725763320923,
-0.3914128243923187,
0.3151422142982483,
0.1554441899061203,
0.08986447751522064,
0.1891406923532486,
-0.8787396550178528,
0.044278211891651154,
-0.9836534261703491,
0.01670527085661888,
0.26093199849128723,
0.08350806683301926,
-0.5269936323165894,
-0.046269167214632034,
0.5331969261169434,
-0.19062429666519165,
-0.04187970981001854,
0.22611230611801147,
-0.5260859727859497,
0.12589341402053833,
0.11392781138420105,
-0.15454745292663574,
0.29226183891296387,
0.48370543122291565,
-0.04111161082983017,
0.16663208603858948,
0.6007236838340759,
-0.909920334815979,
0.46785107254981995,
0.26641637086868286,
-0.41018372774124146,
0.41443800926208496,
-0.19246560335159302,
0.211119145154953,
-0.4561429023742676,
0.39621829986572266,
-0.6526713371276855,
-0.0794551745057106,
0.22033709287643433,
-0.5018496513366699,
0.9337685108184814,
-0.38359764218330383,
-0.5716900825500488,
-0.6008524894714355,
0.02317241206765175,
0.5963714122772217,
0.42995625734329224,
-0.7233986854553223,
0.6300826072692871,
0.6323565244674683,
0.0006160755874589086,
-0.487973690032959,
-0.38282695412635803,
-0.13376165926456451,
0.006802834570407867,
-0.29199329018592834,
0.5347123742103577,
-0.07521019130945206,
0.16552790999412537,
0.017257653176784515,
-0.10228987038135529,
-0.3441067636013031,
0.00294881546869874,
0.2872491478919983,
0.18376845121383667,
-0.12826743721961975,
0.6878237128257751,
0.4260541498661041,
-0.24270153045654297,
-0.1251319795846939,
-0.5018711090087891,
0.46392637491226196,
0.2120285928249359,
-0.6666079759597778,
-0.47613248229026794,
0.4897174537181854,
0.5815088748931885,
-0.46940478682518005,
0.2409633845090866,
0.700708270072937,
-0.7037222385406494,
-0.22343292832374573,
-0.31844648718833923,
0.05777934193611145,
-0.4357646107673645,
0.39922329783439636,
-0.22311057150363922,
-0.440566748380661,
0.512019157409668,
-0.34104257822036743,
-0.2579539120197296,
0.5723735690116882,
0.25871211290359497,
-0.07539884746074677,
1.1226063966751099,
0.6127250790596008,
-0.1766156703233719,
0.05463354289531708,
-0.6816566586494446,
0.1271250694990158,
-1.0275808572769165,
-0.7232180833816528,
-0.7090373635292053,
-0.21864165365695953,
-0.5791367888450623,
-0.5730621814727783,
0.8716327548027039,
0.11290648579597473,
-0.2323535680770874,
-0.3061026930809021,
-0.7193170189857483,
0.19298027455806732,
0.3625548183917999,
0.6276243925094604,
0.260543555021286,
0.08225516229867935,
-0.33870890736579895,
0.27839818596839905,
-0.8430677652359009,
0.10600658506155014,
1.182675838470459,
0.3051297664642334,
1.0032947063446045,
-0.1396862417459488,
0.9555597305297852,
0.375344455242157,
0.7699787020683289,
-0.8589407801628113,
-0.06065193936228752,
-0.5577073097229004,
-0.11054933071136475,
-0.0841459259390831,
-0.15511758625507355,
-0.793332576751709,
-0.08133620023727417,
-0.059893958270549774,
-0.5517536401748657,
0.6825634837150574,
-0.011594722978770733,
-0.4525676965713501,
-0.06701140850782394,
-0.8344176411628723,
0.7861747741699219,
-0.6096537709236145,
0.08347345888614655,
-0.24333368241786957,
-0.5682114958763123,
0.1830865889787674,
-0.1846889853477478,
0.2787856161594391,
0.1817656308412552,
-0.1561768651008606,
0.7511641383171082,
-0.49471989274024963,
0.8541797995567322,
-0.04357306659221649,
-0.009373522363603115,
0.19290292263031006,
-0.29776450991630554,
0.7138984799385071,
0.5054196119308472,
0.12103427201509476,
0.07981724292039871,
-0.2856072783470154,
-0.10967570543289185,
-0.6587909460067749,
0.8142063617706299,
-0.7931155562400818,
-0.22643251717090607,
-0.4032190442085266,
-0.26866012811660767,
-0.19582431018352509,
0.42383643984794617,
0.2946886122226715,
1.038042426109314,
0.06884127110242844,
-0.06299637258052826,
0.5943640470504761,
-0.32302093505859375,
0.20260755717754364,
0.312111496925354,
0.24242526292800903,
-0.5195701718330383,
1.1033949851989746,
0.37769800424575806,
-0.08298740535974503,
0.6438506245613098,
0.1709834337234497,
-0.3153878152370453,
-0.7125144004821777,
-0.6004599928855896,
0.1287136971950531,
-0.990634560585022,
-0.423695832490921,
-0.9349721670150757,
-0.3512531816959381,
-0.43715596199035645,
-0.1760360598564148,
0.09935223311185837,
-0.00646301731467247,
-0.680427074432373,
-0.25206488370895386,
0.42501917481422424,
0.6288412809371948,
-0.0053329626098275185,
-0.018387624993920326,
-1.0671241283416748,
0.6831089854240417,
0.25970184803009033,
0.7770839333534241,
0.15015093982219696,
-0.23294901847839355,
-0.5740657448768616,
-0.00737753277644515,
-0.1338871270418167,
-0.7877036929130554,
0.4156884253025055,
0.28152209520339966,
0.8289399743080139,
0.744476854801178,
0.3611166775226593,
0.6809792518615723,
-0.6913072466850281,
0.290822297334671,
0.4041115641593933,
-0.5341468453407288,
0.38189443945884705,
0.02524881809949875,
0.0277033019810915,
0.47123783826828003,
0.774456262588501,
-0.6761719584465027,
-0.11150387674570084,
-0.6202762722969055,
-0.9686089754104614,
0.679365336894989,
-0.4775865077972412,
-0.030542900785803795,
-0.2730846703052521,
0.40536579489707947,
0.3169746994972229,
0.011461272835731506,
-0.2914515733718872,
-0.5290661454200745,
-0.04248173162341118,
-0.6950089931488037,
-0.20664678514003754,
-0.22909457981586456,
-0.26965680718421936,
-0.46262890100479126,
0.47050097584724426,
-0.40334591269493103,
0.28988298773765564,
0.6378283500671387,
-0.22342205047607422,
0.05900414288043976,
0.017766911536455154,
0.5370687246322632,
0.5579189658164978,
-0.09793613851070404,
0.30027899146080017,
0.02111615240573883,
-0.6251631379127502,
0.23732538521289825,
0.4174092710018158,
0.016534097492694855,
0.07759381085634232,
0.2979033887386322,
0.7567363977432251,
-0.033547330647706985,
-0.42545226216316223,
0.4553385376930237,
-0.14175160229206085,
-0.05438391491770744,
-0.329128235578537,
-0.12696541845798492,
-0.1031995415687561,
0.012306654825806618,
0.40381234884262085,
0.3546687066555023,
0.42115938663482666,
-0.3673747777938843,
0.6592960357666016,
0.3963381052017212,
-0.6984127163887024,
-0.014685613103210926,
0.1898626685142517,
0.29502788186073303,
-0.3663540482521057,
0.5797457098960876,
-0.22090007364749908,
-0.42785942554473877,
0.9674170017242432,
0.5441916584968567,
0.7217203378677368,
-0.15701234340667725,
0.2535395920276642,
0.31600621342658997,
0.20259350538253784,
0.24692577123641968,
0.03678051382303238,
-0.33224302530288696,
-0.659379780292511,
-0.4210647940635681,
-0.3517410159111023,
-0.12718512117862701,
0.2524394690990448,
-0.5776437520980835,
0.37966468930244446,
-0.4396367371082306,
0.06767763942480087,
0.1645861715078354,
-0.11417774856090546,
-0.777926504611969,
0.31331729888916016,
0.22898834943771362,
0.73467618227005,
-0.6817276477813721,
0.8133829832077026,
0.6169341206550598,
-0.3168039917945862,
-0.6693867444992065,
0.1200815811753273,
-0.3647460341453552,
-0.5722246766090393,
0.6546735167503357,
0.30253297090530396,
0.2770117521286011,
0.005729512311518192,
-0.10779184103012085,
-0.8241571187973022,
0.8531190156936646,
-0.1031653955578804,
-0.5003246665000916,
0.01242094486951828,
-0.22069616615772247,
0.6692869663238525,
-0.49965646862983704,
0.3044002056121826,
0.3195808231830597,
0.24147899448871613,
-0.11723282188177109,
-0.8787733912467957,
-0.0031465564388781786,
-0.5055984854698181,
-0.3940403461456299,
0.25490260124206543,
-0.5431793332099915,
0.5772516131401062,
-0.4729766845703125,
-0.20646418631076813,
-0.37174302339553833,
0.2791747450828552,
-0.12953615188598633,
0.7005472183227539,
0.13707979023456573,
0.5615271329879761,
1.0104007720947266,
0.06273727118968964,
1.1541104316711426,
-0.4738720655441284,
0.18058106303215027,
0.99847811460495,
-0.24365106225013733,
0.1923653781414032,
-0.06002463772892952,
-0.12315991520881653,
0.454502135515213,
0.7420021295547485,
-0.010954457335174084,
0.5972491502761841,
0.26284554600715637,
-0.47161078453063965,
-0.05515765771269798,
-0.009239070117473602,
-0.5886081457138062,
0.11814521253108978,
0.8897726535797119,
-0.5494828820228577,
-0.284056156873703,
0.37013399600982666,
-0.40110018849372864,
-0.14578238129615784,
-0.4558386206626892,
1.2722750902175903,
0.07974200695753098,
-0.518735945224762,
0.5763155221939087,
0.12286166101694107,
0.4331389367580414,
-0.469942182302475,
-0.4570711553096771,
-0.07485266774892807,
0.37175998091697693,
-0.22304484248161316,
-0.36019179224967957,
-0.02378898300230503,
-0.49056047201156616,
-0.2361237108707428,
0.12765991687774658,
0.6948615908622742,
-0.5280227661132812,
-0.7568724751472473,
0.21073414385318756,
-0.0030458332039415836,
-0.12211388349533081,
0.34282755851745605,
-0.605180025100708,
-0.3241111934185028,
-0.20196101069450378,
0.2691764831542969,
0.417141318321228,
0.8473469614982605,
-0.20527930557727814,
0.721197247505188,
0.7664986848831177,
0.0009046927443705499,
-0.0518985353410244,
0.3852089047431946,
1.148594617843628,
-0.16775108873844147,
-0.963107705116272,
-0.620529294013977,
0.24005235731601715,
-0.1574220210313797,
-0.028493423014879227,
0.46274900436401367,
0.9714928269386292,
0.664614737033844,
-0.02653910033404827,
0.978236734867096,
0.32164907455444336,
0.3712395429611206,
-0.5356152057647705,
0.828913688659668,
-0.2902649939060211,
0.24443697929382324,
-0.25994083285331726,
-0.14678695797920227,
-0.763134777545929,
0.3510146737098694,
0.021915653720498085,
-0.2670489251613617,
0.7142530679702759,
0.4261457324028015,
-0.06987883150577545,
-0.3124755918979645,
-0.0028547754045575857,
0.10689191520214081,
0.39063841104507446,
0.5822637677192688,
0.37580519914627075,
-0.37031564116477966,
0.5539479851722717,
-0.5938601493835449,
-0.21356798708438873,
-0.31531062722206116,
-0.34084880352020264,
-0.6783900260925293,
-0.6355432271957397,
-0.48041608929634094,
-0.2730015218257904,
0.023015456274151802,
0.8454426527023315,
0.6104226112365723,
-0.6899967789649963,
0.3415963053703308,
-0.1187969446182251,
0.4589887261390686,
-0.3516327440738678,
-0.10767675936222076,
1.035153865814209,
-0.30917009711265564,
-0.49919193983078003,
0.15253561735153198,
0.33493518829345703,
0.18536752462387085,
0.2308633178472519,
-0.21193429827690125,
-0.17199526727199554,
-0.5400892496109009,
0.46144992113113403,
0.0926002487540245,
-0.22328639030456543,
-0.08945086598396301,
-0.17853493988513947,
-0.0987880602478981,
0.3593396842479706,
0.9555270075798035,
-0.8929235339164734,
0.6840875148773193,
0.43367767333984375,
0.6777493953704834,
0.5846236348152161,
0.17194363474845886,
0.07942069321870804,
-0.824946403503418,
0.07769230753183365,
0.471792608499527,
0.26127147674560547,
0.09665768593549728,
-0.7021923661231995,
0.19071318209171295,
0.2705743908882141,
-0.373006135225296,
-0.662502646446228,
-0.12105323374271393,
-0.7684037685394287,
-0.1714174598455429,
0.907097339630127,
-0.16103778779506683,
-0.18065939843654633,
-0.5678088665008545,
-0.5131875276565552,
0.5036240816116333,
-0.426466166973114,
0.7227456569671631,
0.061730701476335526,
-0.47113603353500366,
-0.13105857372283936,
-0.24091693758964539,
0.5614909529685974,
-0.3614230751991272,
-0.7427316308021545,
-0.2587500214576721,
0.48621371388435364,
0.027577443048357964,
0.4933396875858307,
0.862517237663269,
-0.19855739176273346,
0.33327507972717285,
-0.12631846964359283,
0.1773097813129425,
-0.2117440551519394,
-0.4352444112300873,
-0.2820930480957031,
0.359321266412735,
-0.07074286788702011,
-0.3773505687713623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19076v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19076v2
|
Cephalo: Multi-Modal Vision-Language Models for Bio-Inspired Materials Analysis and Design
| 2024-05-29T13:34:32 | 2024-06-02T15:03:24 |
Markus J. Buehler
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present Cephalo, a series of multimodal vision large language models
(V-LLMs) designed for materials science applications, integrating visual and
linguistic data for enhanced understanding and interaction within human-AI and
multi-agent AI frameworks. A key innovation of Cephalo is its advanced dataset
generation method, which employs a sophisticated algorithm to accurately detect
and separate images and their corresponding textual descriptions from PDF
documents, such as scientific papers. The method includes a careful refinement
of image-text pairs through integrated vision and language processing, ensuring
high-quality, contextually relevant, and well reasoned training data. Cephalo
is trained on integrated image and text data extracted from thousands of
scientific papers and science-focused Wikipedia pages demonstrates can
interpret complex visual scenes, generate precise language descriptions, and
answer queries about images effectively. The combination of a vision encoder
with an autoregressive transformer supports complex natural language
understanding in an integrated model, which can be coupled with other
generative methods to create an image-to-text-to-image or image-to-text-to-3D
pipeline. To explore the development of larger models from smaller ones, we
report both mixture-of-expert methods and model merging. These hybrid
approaches allow us to leverage the domain-specific expertise and general
conversational capabilities to harness the strengths of multiple models. We
examine the models in diverse use cases that incorporate biological materials,
fracture and engineering analysis, protein biophysics, and bio-inspired design
based on insect behavior. Generative applications include bio-inspired designs,
including pollen-inspired architected materials, as well as the synthesis of
bio-inspired material microstructures from a photograph of a solar eclipse.
|
[
-0.15726499259471893,
-0.8416132926940918,
0.7221639752388,
-0.04444566369056702,
-0.1288696974515915,
0.3242262601852417,
-0.09811981767416,
-0.8889526128768921,
0.21888189017772675,
0.5197691321372986,
-0.2666974365711212,
-0.5789419412612915,
-0.2165224254131317,
0.2948513329029083,
-0.28852736949920654,
0.4987564980983734,
-0.032056279480457306,
0.1208619624376297,
-0.4220826327800751,
-0.010267842561006546,
0.07065363973379135,
-0.3305153548717499,
-0.2519722878932953,
-0.22811003029346466,
0.6072649955749512,
0.14993293583393097,
0.7599083781242371,
0.49039047956466675,
0.35405099391937256,
0.3972295820713043,
-0.25526997447013855,
0.66559898853302,
0.03797117620706558,
-0.1912045180797577,
-0.25684958696365356,
-0.3966732323169708,
-0.5556312203407288,
-0.2682494521141052,
0.47618094086647034,
0.9868742227554321,
-0.01802612841129303,
0.011059610173106194,
0.48044610023498535,
0.4067598879337311,
-0.6732769012451172,
0.24475333094596863,
-0.4882253408432007,
0.2770642638206482,
-0.19319184124469757,
-0.3775860071182251,
-0.4283485412597656,
-0.11394334584474564,
0.24231377243995667,
-0.7483755350112915,
0.10154429078102112,
0.0641789585351944,
0.6094451546669006,
-0.03604276478290558,
-0.33720797300338745,
-0.36785462498664856,
-0.6300624012947083,
0.8610718250274658,
-0.587573230266571,
0.6666994690895081,
-0.04876816272735596,
0.0675666332244873,
-0.15079669654369354,
-0.7171670794487,
-0.6834181547164917,
-0.24880091845989227,
0.08136733621358871,
0.3289625644683838,
0.19867004454135895,
0.29383739829063416,
-0.31323572993278503,
0.4797247052192688,
-0.7539111971855164,
0.03551601245999336,
-0.6699990630149841,
-0.3975529968738556,
0.38766688108444214,
0.1655956506729126,
0.3813502788543701,
-0.23789502680301666,
-0.5301737785339355,
-0.14174635708332062,
-0.26234546303749084,
-0.2523097097873688,
0.11638627201318741,
0.022416790947318077,
-0.1087987869977951,
0.7783291935920715,
-0.08261242508888245,
0.8487043380737305,
-0.2694926857948303,
-0.25543975830078125,
0.3574356138706207,
-0.454756498336792,
-0.32317355275154114,
-0.0264773927628994,
0.9625457525253296,
0.34912633895874023,
-0.0024143443442881107,
-0.23887412250041962,
0.02899847738444805,
0.28998664021492004,
0.07699770480394363,
-0.6670821905136108,
-0.2503000497817993,
0.3238096237182617,
-0.771491289138794,
-0.7733701467514038,
-0.20421448349952698,
-1.2827552556991577,
-0.6310607194900513,
-0.548283576965332,
0.4172942340373993,
-0.37291446328163147,
-0.32753652334213257,
0.39230915904045105,
-0.09209985285997391,
0.182601660490036,
0.2893960177898407,
-0.9559485912322998,
0.1236259713768959,
0.2748410403728485,
0.7523662447929382,
-0.16610100865364075,
-0.49128541350364685,
-0.18155033886432648,
0.3163991868495941,
-0.36031854152679443,
0.9666091799736023,
-0.6771080493927002,
-0.644874095916748,
-0.1549336016178131,
0.029343169182538986,
-0.04306131973862648,
-0.5291363596916199,
0.3704144060611725,
-0.28767329454421997,
0.16558386385440826,
-0.03183911368250847,
-0.0705329030752182,
-0.3560827374458313,
0.24094846844673157,
-0.7080352306365967,
0.6697145700454712,
-0.026534194126725197,
-0.6364704370498657,
0.1898069828748703,
-0.631892740726471,
-0.17030884325504303,
0.2385605424642563,
-0.48097094893455505,
-0.27882319688796997,
0.2453863024711609,
-0.03664026036858559,
0.13445234298706055,
-0.6675631999969482,
0.13559922575950623,
-0.5359926819801331,
0.2653709948062897,
0.3378329873085022,
-0.38623669743537903,
0.48342230916023254,
0.38209760189056396,
-0.15411178767681122,
0.021836942061781883,
-0.8970032334327698,
0.06173481047153473,
0.08867953717708588,
-0.5153250694274902,
-0.2708646357059479,
0.24643965065479279,
0.5360270738601685,
0.21537575125694275,
0.45406463742256165,
-0.7302747368812561,
-0.015741471201181412,
-0.5047601461410522,
0.4626684784889221,
0.6364081501960754,
-0.16949862241744995,
0.5945612788200378,
0.001599322073161602,
0.28961560130119324,
-0.051706504076719284,
0.31562671065330505,
-0.5076525807380676,
-0.37615257501602173,
-0.7284804582595825,
-0.1156163364648819,
0.18801842629909515,
0.6538428068161011,
-0.8631176948547363,
0.08336210995912552,
0.050214096903800964,
-0.45243170857429504,
-0.16757915914058685,
0.2684346139431,
0.2995223104953766,
0.632888674736023,
0.29451411962509155,
-0.4217545688152313,
-0.37195467948913574,
-1.1371642351150513,
-0.11908403784036636,
-0.08380649983882904,
-0.007334529887884855,
0.1988210529088974,
0.5128403306007385,
-0.4819073975086212,
0.8755589723587036,
-0.6037577390670776,
0.037317369133234024,
0.04706141725182533,
0.24447783827781677,
0.1519140601158142,
0.2523094415664673,
0.592383623123169,
-1.0770751237869263,
-0.3147770166397095,
0.6202827095985413,
-1.0834040641784668,
0.0019097046460956335,
-0.012069648131728172,
0.01398451067507267,
0.24276800453662872,
0.4906059503555298,
-0.4540075361728668,
0.09640857577323914,
0.7677485942840576,
-0.24858960509300232,
0.47197937965393066,
-0.22346587479114532,
0.32761698961257935,
-1.349056601524353,
0.16573645174503326,
0.296470582485199,
0.059159617871046066,
-0.6318513751029968,
0.22977972030639648,
-0.027302203699946404,
-0.47683185338974,
-0.8428748250007629,
0.5393948554992676,
-0.7048599123954773,
-0.06930360198020935,
-0.42512303590774536,
-0.16981136798858643,
0.32114705443382263,
0.60809326171875,
0.20583772659301758,
0.4632079303264618,
0.6911499500274658,
-0.6254903674125671,
0.39399486780166626,
0.13215205073356628,
-0.26388639211654663,
0.5250958204269409,
-0.815881073474884,
0.132259801030159,
-0.18032990396022797,
-0.18018950521945953,
-0.7349944710731506,
-0.32450416684150696,
0.2920680344104767,
-0.2307681143283844,
0.2686777412891388,
0.1082809716463089,
-0.7677714228630066,
-0.5039294958114624,
-0.3491639196872711,
0.5538094639778137,
0.012830646708607674,
-0.47017702460289,
1.251988410949707,
0.4740196466445923,
-0.3649504780769348,
-0.14600114524364471,
-0.6434206366539001,
0.12975358963012695,
-0.057206396013498306,
-0.7705339193344116,
0.9258846044540405,
-0.5392107367515564,
-0.21862611174583435,
-0.031075922772288322,
-0.09180919826030731,
-0.28901374340057373,
-0.22498644888401031,
0.07715145498514175,
0.58652663230896,
0.02644137665629387,
0.06981200724840164,
0.19665057957172394,
0.10219879448413849,
-0.029315173625946045,
-0.3903265595436096,
0.5974349975585938,
-0.3105379045009613,
-0.34943947196006775,
-0.34241122007369995,
0.4654221832752228,
1.1143832206726074,
-0.2718987762928009,
0.5197250843048096,
0.4135507643222809,
-0.5686493515968323,
-0.038226451724767685,
-0.42898398637771606,
-0.01477438397705555,
-0.5973421335220337,
0.4440183639526367,
-0.5291866064071655,
-0.35677412152290344,
0.4345981180667877,
-0.19129285216331482,
0.14127150177955627,
0.34839877486228943,
0.67088383436203,
-0.4379776120185852,
0.9075127840042114,
0.8974376916885376,
0.21131451427936554,
0.522686779499054,
-0.2610662579536438,
-0.0449799969792366,
-0.6124932765960693,
-0.6701866388320923,
-0.19398871064186096,
-0.05199055001139641,
-0.4369221329689026,
-0.5320729613304138,
0.5627844929695129,
-0.22951605916023254,
0.12482103705406189,
0.15271198749542236,
-0.8982851505279541,
0.5195453763008118,
0.11258972436189651,
0.3939908742904663,
0.27572956681251526,
0.1904115229845047,
-0.3402078151702881,
0.13893155753612518,
-0.7103029489517212,
-0.6138448119163513,
0.908100962638855,
0.31490781903266907,
0.9530837535858154,
-0.33437925577163696,
0.27103391289711,
0.3042052388191223,
-0.10968061536550522,
-0.8816004991531372,
0.5058619976043701,
-0.04988889396190643,
-0.3605891466140747,
0.07664339244365692,
-0.10095077753067017,
-0.9281721115112305,
0.4467177391052246,
-0.4444821774959564,
-0.4905310571193695,
0.7703983783721924,
0.2366018146276474,
-0.3334099054336548,
0.42576977610588074,
-0.7821492552757263,
0.8139512538909912,
-0.6278375387191772,
-0.4604349434375763,
-0.38572388887405396,
-0.3395792543888092,
0.2787795662879944,
-0.3450154960155487,
0.6409709453582764,
0.17419905960559845,
-0.14410047233104706,
0.4802529513835907,
-0.21963518857955933,
1.1292052268981934,
0.27920034527778625,
-0.303720623254776,
0.689095139503479,
0.1541632115840912,
0.09799855947494507,
-0.06983307003974915,
-0.18463146686553955,
0.2974548935890198,
0.09470759332180023,
-0.34824666380882263,
-0.15142856538295746,
0.5660664439201355,
-0.5708789229393005,
-0.2190759927034378,
-0.21872258186340332,
-0.5766351222991943,
0.09582982957363129,
0.2446213662624359,
0.3779502511024475,
0.6175380945205688,
-0.17467227578163147,
0.2629554867744446,
0.6998648643493652,
-0.5544315576553345,
0.5582011938095093,
0.43825292587280273,
-0.07277286797761917,
-0.6270419955253601,
1.014392375946045,
0.05033555254340172,
0.2509990334510803,
0.5325703024864197,
0.04888955131173134,
-0.1026846393942833,
-0.46296530961990356,
-0.3597475588321686,
0.22937828302383423,
-0.5548933744430542,
-0.1377294361591339,
-0.6523461937904358,
-0.14673542976379395,
-0.21500347554683685,
-0.40456926822662354,
-0.5328689217567444,
-0.08005332201719284,
-0.2587948739528656,
0.1528140902519226,
0.29663562774658203,
0.5932028293609619,
-0.009292691014707088,
-0.02046803943812847,
-0.9318117499351501,
0.5986326932907104,
0.3962390124797821,
0.2514553964138031,
-0.22519636154174805,
-0.09219250828027725,
-0.4378972351551056,
0.06988094002008438,
-0.5873274207115173,
-1.2087137699127197,
0.5596750974655151,
0.21032683551311493,
0.6995465755462646,
0.08438762277364731,
-0.45527181029319763,
0.2780347168445587,
-0.5780006647109985,
0.5816120505332947,
0.4101181924343109,
-0.7488159537315369,
0.8093157410621643,
-0.6392324566841125,
0.2453790307044983,
0.29614195227622986,
0.15974223613739014,
-0.2605018615722656,
-0.11546860635280609,
-0.27588018774986267,
-0.8431566953659058,
0.20854972302913666,
0.06619809567928314,
-0.13933275640010834,
0.13657869398593903,
0.2031254917383194,
0.23769772052764893,
0.08425579220056534,
-0.9253572821617126,
0.1606866419315338,
-0.17360182106494904,
-0.447553813457489,
0.37790536880493164,
-0.14968037605285645,
-0.044836003333330154,
-0.03233277052640915,
0.23246997594833374,
-0.502836287021637,
0.25723668932914734,
0.21219739317893982,
-0.30955252051353455,
-0.002126646228134632,
0.22124503552913666,
0.44397202134132385,
0.6509352922439575,
0.05520370602607727,
-0.08153189718723297,
0.2511295974254608,
-0.43633130192756653,
-0.33301088213920593,
0.24424706399440765,
0.026975972577929497,
-0.034915439784526825,
0.0698026493191719,
0.32029956579208374,
0.17962951958179474,
-0.7183418869972229,
0.0534038320183754,
0.33171626925468445,
-0.3985195457935333,
-0.33931034803390503,
-0.21580445766448975,
-0.06791866570711136,
0.4418507516384125,
0.5218782424926758,
0.29947370290756226,
0.5832055807113647,
-0.8217086791992188,
0.017758982256054878,
0.35531583428382874,
-0.11354776471853256,
-0.7004204392433167,
0.8566687107086182,
0.4363875091075897,
-0.07480398565530777,
0.26772037148475647,
0.14965756237506866,
-0.36169201135635376,
0.7624468803405762,
0.4213978350162506,
0.7386448383331299,
-0.2672349810600281,
0.3368958830833435,
0.17365683615207672,
0.12878455221652985,
0.1765371412038803,
0.3386405408382416,
-0.18129603564739227,
-0.8034232258796692,
-0.35731974244117737,
-0.8657507300376892,
-0.6257621049880981,
-0.03974657505750656,
-0.24994322657585144,
0.6068637371063232,
-0.3658890128135681,
-0.04209895059466362,
0.2977506220340729,
-0.3257030248641968,
-0.5721530914306641,
0.3470255434513092,
0.6776530146598816,
0.5950877666473389,
-0.9950574040412903,
0.6844151020050049,
0.7993236780166626,
-0.503732442855835,
-0.11388366669416428,
-0.46732527017593384,
0.23697529733181,
-0.5828762054443359,
0.4933004081249237,
-0.06593558937311172,
-0.4041554033756256,
-0.13493770360946655,
-0.6085928082466125,
-0.8610260486602783,
1.3018521070480347,
0.30204540491104126,
-0.5540094971656799,
-0.23105736076831818,
0.2797984480857849,
0.5103750824928284,
-0.28870889544487,
0.03663919121026993,
0.23909471929073334,
0.36265793442726135,
0.08307599276304245,
-0.9821943044662476,
-0.3394106924533844,
-0.54127436876297,
0.020372940227389336,
0.1411072164773941,
-0.9289381504058838,
0.8169782757759094,
-0.09723428636789322,
-0.2363007664680481,
0.12659403681755066,
0.653003454208374,
0.5294696688652039,
0.43599167466163635,
0.5345559120178223,
0.4030100107192993,
0.5752356648445129,
0.15770120918750763,
1.039473295211792,
-0.393541157245636,
0.1860206425189972,
0.6756371855735779,
-0.20033404231071472,
0.555268406867981,
0.5326870679855347,
0.15089309215545654,
0.6356847286224365,
0.7017116546630859,
-0.21353483200073242,
0.5850361585617065,
-0.15473170578479767,
-0.3984698951244354,
-0.09908782690763474,
-0.3738267123699188,
-0.3407382667064667,
0.4395635426044464,
0.655521810054779,
-0.5008755922317505,
0.024565409868955612,
0.27363499999046326,
-0.30424830317497253,
0.23483958840370178,
-0.3434513807296753,
0.35100510716438293,
0.23906026780605316,
-0.0937509834766388,
0.22872577607631683,
-0.0658126026391983,
0.854651153087616,
-0.3956226706504822,
-0.15721839666366577,
0.08482097089290619,
0.028522489592432976,
-0.2538381516933441,
-0.9010366797447205,
0.4130230247974396,
-0.2098311483860016,
-0.3144226372241974,
-0.2722364366054535,
0.781043529510498,
-0.26882606744766235,
-0.7006598114967346,
0.3411077558994293,
0.4735703766345978,
0.07835794240236282,
0.20860977470874786,
-0.711430549621582,
0.19143234193325043,
-0.1394672989845276,
-0.15717394649982452,
0.02421923168003559,
0.38426437973976135,
-0.08813650161027908,
0.5046424269676208,
0.6498343348503113,
-0.0995493233203888,
-0.06688803434371948,
-0.02164698764681816,
1.053223967552185,
-0.6441069841384888,
-0.13540051877498627,
-0.6759098768234253,
0.8861559629440308,
-0.044046856462955475,
-0.09846009314060211,
0.36994582414627075,
0.9236559867858887,
0.6362492442131042,
-0.29678598046302795,
0.7203518152236938,
-0.00778959272429347,
0.15468694269657135,
-0.6287654638290405,
0.5708168745040894,
-0.7091633677482605,
0.05065421760082245,
-0.35259681940078735,
-1.0916868448257446,
-0.3149036169052124,
0.4542923867702484,
-0.004923692438751459,
-0.036224380135536194,
0.7704253792762756,
0.8288862705230713,
-0.19453708827495575,
-0.18681924045085907,
0.2689710557460785,
0.16823849081993103,
0.25722426176071167,
0.45476600527763367,
0.7585174441337585,
-0.3879416584968567,
0.9262579083442688,
0.012036305852234364,
-0.23914234340190887,
-0.10715056955814362,
-0.6640588641166687,
-0.7431808710098267,
-0.6142505407333374,
-0.395993709564209,
-0.04361347109079361,
-0.20399044454097748,
0.612708568572998,
0.8358078002929688,
-0.49915817379951477,
-0.19408880174160004,
-0.36911994218826294,
-0.21685312688350677,
0.24351145327091217,
-0.203962042927742,
0.16224709153175354,
-0.18761323392391205,
-1.0890121459960938,
0.661828339099884,
0.621456503868103,
0.23511990904808044,
-0.39053279161453247,
0.1125989705324173,
0.20080730319023132,
0.2079782634973526,
1.1080924272537231,
0.5356702208518982,
-0.7468793392181396,
0.03090435266494751,
0.49268001317977905,
-0.13914255797863007,
0.0035609968472272158,
0.39541885256767273,
-0.8131136298179626,
0.778876006603241,
0.807167112827301,
0.4288131892681122,
0.5792433023452759,
-0.4064118266105652,
0.7373886108398438,
-0.21287128329277039,
0.1955813318490982,
0.13249140977859497,
0.6388116478919983,
0.3441668152809143,
-0.3721061944961548,
0.5304312705993652,
0.2899905741214752,
-0.4916226267814636,
-0.6110648512840271,
0.3424977660179138,
-1.4036632776260376,
-0.546925961971283,
1.012661337852478,
0.4994363784790039,
-0.6607822775840759,
0.0937347412109375,
-0.4237957298755646,
0.10301130264997482,
-0.11928360164165497,
0.7896151542663574,
0.5105662941932678,
0.013091758824884892,
-0.4150319993495941,
-0.6820653080940247,
0.01865077018737793,
0.2851927578449249,
-1.094330072402954,
-0.19610466063022614,
0.6510863304138184,
0.14899446070194244,
0.5617884397506714,
0.36338427662849426,
-0.5392504334449768,
0.335720032453537,
0.04284036159515381,
0.45164617896080017,
0.14399021863937378,
-0.5021025538444519,
-0.07241372019052505,
0.2842238247394562,
0.019377300515770912,
-0.2829332649707794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19041v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19041v1
|
BLSP-KD: Bootstrapping Language-Speech Pre-training via Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-05-29T12:32:08 | 2024-05-29T12:32:08 |
Chen Wang, Minpeng Liao, Zhongqiang Huang, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent end-to-end approaches have shown promise in extending large language
models (LLMs) to speech inputs, but face limitations in directly assessing and
optimizing alignment quality and fail to achieve fine-grained alignment due to
speech-text length mismatch. We introduce BLSP-KD, a novel approach for
Bootstrapping Language-Speech Pretraining via Knowledge Distillation, which
addresses these limitations through two key techniques. First, it optimizes
speech-text alignment by minimizing the divergence between the LLM's next-token
prediction distributions for speech and text inputs using knowledge
distillation. Second, it employs a continuous-integrate-andfire strategy to
segment speech into tokens that correspond one-to-one with text tokens,
enabling fine-grained alignment. We also introduce Partial LoRA (PLoRA), a new
adaptation method supporting LLM finetuning for speech inputs under knowledge
distillation. Quantitative evaluation shows that BLSP-KD outperforms previous
end-to-end baselines and cascaded systems with comparable scale of parameters,
facilitating general instruction-following capabilities for LLMs with speech
inputs. This approach provides new possibilities for extending LLMs to spoken
language interactions.
|
[
-0.1369227170944214,
-0.6209760904312134,
0.4804813265800476,
0.2335653007030487,
-0.45830971002578735,
0.5472429394721985,
-0.3929937779903412,
-0.14455808699131012,
0.046205565333366394,
0.13160774111747742,
-0.562084972858429,
-0.4101865887641907,
-0.7055777311325073,
-0.22023430466651917,
-0.4574647843837738,
0.9606447815895081,
0.16439582407474518,
0.30314314365386963,
-0.28776323795318604,
0.2348078489303589,
-0.3760412335395813,
-0.5028321743011475,
-0.5220765471458435,
-0.5703770518302917,
0.34102344512939453,
0.5003487467765808,
0.4130415618419647,
0.5685178637504578,
0.3269299268722534,
0.20261862874031067,
-0.28516560792922974,
-0.18186074495315552,
-0.5105058550834656,
0.315256267786026,
-0.09995071589946747,
-0.32719194889068604,
-0.17900197207927704,
-0.025252915918827057,
0.6385415196418762,
0.9637057185173035,
-0.438655823469162,
0.301047682762146,
0.3009437024593353,
0.9091546535491943,
-0.9841762781143188,
0.01903853751718998,
-0.6435715556144714,
0.056535571813583374,
-0.2925359308719635,
-0.11957386136054993,
-0.4237600862979889,
-0.35957592725753784,
0.3839258551597595,
-0.4149380326271057,
-0.18816572427749634,
-0.2077523171901703,
0.7377320528030396,
0.7198535799980164,
-0.08926194161176682,
-0.4386001229286194,
-0.9820521473884583,
0.5842582583427429,
-0.7925130724906921,
0.7145800590515137,
0.46401408314704895,
0.4889599084854126,
-0.027201803401112556,
-0.7835478186607361,
-0.7420488595962524,
-0.09385810047388077,
0.09966524690389633,
-0.13139019906520844,
-0.02161152847111225,
0.16045337915420532,
0.14470352232456207,
0.2626037001609802,
-0.47886744141578674,
0.3112667500972748,
-0.26579511165618896,
-0.28587716817855835,
0.361777663230896,
-0.2337472289800644,
0.0064134784042835236,
0.2712757885456085,
-0.5423925518989563,
-0.19913136959075928,
-0.6702682971954346,
0.05738291144371033,
0.23567555844783783,
0.38450559973716736,
-0.2796823978424072,
0.4141925573348999,
-0.4042450487613678,
0.9018206596374512,
0.3635281026363373,
-0.49091067910194397,
0.3229007422924042,
-0.3173048496246338,
-0.4010011553764343,
0.5620936751365662,
0.6821025609970093,
0.24314706027507782,
0.27431178092956543,
-0.19920046627521515,
0.004309261217713356,
-0.09343422949314117,
-0.28875064849853516,
-0.8683978915214539,
-0.35080471634864807,
0.20673631131649017,
-0.11984824389219284,
-0.3622555434703827,
-0.38256552815437317,
-0.7659371495246887,
-0.5175408124923706,
-0.536431074142456,
0.4923834502696991,
-0.42422717809677124,
-0.13610748946666718,
0.13721272349357605,
-0.1920667588710785,
0.28987303376197815,
-0.00899722333997488,
-1.1979843378067017,
0.46220266819000244,
0.5829948782920837,
0.8382525444030762,
-0.34201034903526306,
-0.3160581588745117,
-0.7916141748428345,
0.36376121640205383,
-0.32831260561943054,
0.4854365587234497,
-0.523337721824646,
-0.14572690427303314,
-0.031526822596788406,
-0.24177643656730652,
0.2425161898136139,
-0.5609188079833984,
0.39239051938056946,
-0.5422065854072571,
0.06599850207567215,
-0.2478962540626526,
-0.8393433094024658,
0.12337619811296463,
0.07959029823541641,
-0.20568154752254486,
0.847674548625946,
-0.0028177453204989433,
-0.6265299320220947,
0.6009513139724731,
-0.35662558674812317,
-0.5751082301139832,
0.11812375485897064,
-0.23711837828159332,
-0.07064129412174225,
0.06290215998888016,
0.12255558371543884,
0.5354992747306824,
-0.2633226811885834,
0.3990325629711151,
-0.17949305474758148,
0.00044391999836079776,
-0.027192480862140656,
-0.48165953159332275,
0.6794117093086243,
0.23734253644943237,
-0.060874294489622116,
0.03343597427010536,
-1.071507215499878,
0.12792742252349854,
-0.0740516409277916,
-0.39318808913230896,
-0.38957422971725464,
0.03131529688835144,
0.030026063323020935,
0.2893317639827728,
0.597706139087677,
-0.5759110450744629,
0.025572866201400757,
-0.42174506187438965,
0.42649978399276733,
0.7189533114433289,
-0.09941264241933823,
0.6111460328102112,
-0.11250300705432892,
0.3851458728313446,
0.12605790793895721,
0.051691245287656784,
-0.2852068245410919,
-0.11428097635507584,
-0.5672739148139954,
-0.26580968499183655,
0.6984277963638306,
0.6435640454292297,
-0.7417013049125671,
0.6470108032226562,
-0.13236920535564423,
-0.6933556795120239,
-0.6401407122612,
0.10430846363306046,
0.6313722729682922,
0.7739632725715637,
0.42634931206703186,
-0.21874427795410156,
-0.5747062563896179,
-0.6975134611129761,
-0.00002105005296471063,
-0.16594944894313812,
-0.007115939166396856,
-0.3351582884788513,
0.09769991040229797,
0.0694839209318161,
1.184845209121704,
-0.5807937383651733,
-0.3316498398780823,
-0.1424221396446228,
-0.1376086175441742,
0.04786394163966179,
0.5311968326568604,
0.25581616163253784,
-0.46339502930641174,
-0.7282336354255676,
0.1663666069507599,
-0.2683747410774231,
-0.3361318111419678,
0.11316170543432236,
0.07535557448863983,
0.2245548665523529,
0.7153363227844238,
-0.5607754588127136,
0.14811687171459198,
0.8175578713417053,
-0.19827577471733093,
0.6715272068977356,
-0.08931595832109451,
-0.12038339674472809,
-1.1870986223220825,
0.04457296058535576,
-0.1726216822862625,
-0.3582477867603302,
-0.9195160865783691,
-0.20504945516586304,
-0.04698267951607704,
-0.09236044436693192,
-0.5259860754013062,
0.4210343658924103,
-0.29016393423080444,
-0.29790690541267395,
-0.3331120014190674,
0.2417764663696289,
-0.11944951862096786,
0.4090598523616791,
0.1669977903366089,
0.6175498366355896,
0.7171320915222168,
-0.6007956266403198,
0.5973477363586426,
0.14303873479366302,
-0.5611225962638855,
0.5458877086639404,
-0.4662562608718872,
0.2134157419204712,
-0.02139919064939022,
0.16932639479637146,
-0.9641587138175964,
-0.04465901106595993,
0.03345395252108574,
-0.36202895641326904,
0.6653649806976318,
-0.34682393074035645,
-0.4420694410800934,
0.07514315098524094,
-0.0778958722949028,
0.38846200704574585,
0.7443847060203552,
-0.5386114716529846,
0.37066176533699036,
0.3967261016368866,
-0.5468345284461975,
-0.6925423741340637,
-0.5978739261627197,
-0.032967206090688705,
-0.15527601540088654,
-0.3924645781517029,
0.41053473949432373,
-0.10315567255020142,
-0.10266046971082687,
-0.22440335154533386,
-0.2961633503437042,
-0.13933487236499786,
-0.04290340840816498,
-0.1324635148048401,
-0.015817129984498024,
-0.16378086805343628,
0.012524508871138096,
0.32858186960220337,
-0.19166739284992218,
-0.13220925629138947,
-0.4646715223789215,
1.078377604484558,
0.24205027520656586,
-0.3067290484905243,
-0.8503195643424988,
-0.014296077191829681,
0.5781087279319763,
-0.09432171285152435,
0.5213770866394043,
0.46054887771606445,
-0.33926770091056824,
-0.03753116726875305,
-0.6674523949623108,
-0.13507576286792755,
-0.45717427134513855,
0.5115992426872253,
-0.11604110896587372,
-0.7843675017356873,
0.17708095908164978,
-0.406149685382843,
-0.01168604101985693,
-0.08012079447507858,
0.6146605014801025,
-0.30246561765670776,
0.5609087347984314,
0.7169703841209412,
-0.40271785855293274,
0.4023626148700714,
0.1460743546485901,
0.11446148157119751,
-0.5956291556358337,
-0.21279729902744293,
-0.5728978514671326,
-0.5300172567367554,
-0.21914643049240112,
-0.5009638667106628,
-0.06854714453220367,
0.3536219298839569,
-0.24359644949436188,
0.07756012678146362,
-0.23452037572860718,
0.6612869501113892,
0.4958873391151428,
-0.3881353437900543,
0.32496801018714905,
0.07849545031785965,
-0.1611017882823944,
-0.044186390936374664,
-0.632806122303009,
-0.2898962199687958,
1.0733619928359985,
0.4431963562965393,
0.8161787986755371,
-0.1715901643037796,
0.899783194065094,
0.15222907066345215,
-0.1316407024860382,
-0.8068169951438904,
0.42662501335144043,
-0.20442335307598114,
-0.24830372631549835,
-0.6068822741508484,
-0.23505598306655884,
-0.5386132001876831,
0.06739143282175064,
-0.12067636102437973,
-0.8176438212394714,
0.14963304996490479,
0.34639760851860046,
-0.4947272539138794,
0.05144539102911949,
-1.0344324111938477,
0.7165507078170776,
-0.24667257070541382,
0.0578119233250618,
-0.058491725474596024,
-0.8682413697242737,
0.2588188946247101,
-0.3340601921081543,
0.2778468430042267,
0.04640820994973183,
0.040927864611148834,
0.8524861335754395,
-0.6192821264266968,
0.775215208530426,
-0.5860024094581604,
-0.44711852073669434,
0.03725443780422211,
-0.025449318811297417,
0.4628131687641144,
-0.3812887370586395,
0.300754189491272,
0.046770527958869934,
0.4050784111022949,
-0.30708402395248413,
-0.6061481237411499,
0.5218451023101807,
-0.6336065530776978,
-0.4164004325866699,
-0.2515205144882202,
-0.5126868486404419,
-0.5972529053688049,
0.18536102771759033,
0.20775294303894043,
0.20587828755378723,
-0.18512886762619019,
0.30056121945381165,
0.5575724244117737,
-0.12926895916461945,
0.5917900204658508,
0.5937169194221497,
-0.5026065111160278,
-0.45022985339164734,
1.0584338903427124,
0.06784485280513763,
0.6933842301368713,
0.45910027623176575,
0.36400216817855835,
-0.534046471118927,
-0.7023636102676392,
-0.389639675617218,
0.01247578114271164,
-0.6274831891059875,
-0.15954089164733887,
-0.20707687735557556,
-0.28607499599456787,
-0.5840250849723816,
-0.04851752519607544,
-0.5925161242485046,
-0.4905887246131897,
-0.12306088954210281,
-0.10110300034284592,
0.14859558641910553,
0.37892061471939087,
-0.19322942197322845,
0.6417350172996521,
-0.6654193997383118,
0.39062583446502686,
0.3645193576812744,
0.38018107414245605,
-0.0694282129406929,
-0.6464938521385193,
-0.2356879711151123,
0.1392270028591156,
-0.2788850963115692,
-0.9047217965126038,
0.26867806911468506,
0.44134441018104553,
0.15600958466529846,
0.48420315980911255,
0.00031040646717883646,
0.852203369140625,
-0.809409499168396,
0.7590819597244263,
0.6132358312606812,
-1.0698094367980957,
0.5896377563476562,
0.04706667736172676,
0.462880402803421,
0.6763978600502014,
0.37578606605529785,
-0.6866487264633179,
-0.24341599643230438,
-0.2593047618865967,
-0.7237006425857544,
0.7636138200759888,
0.08637648075819016,
-0.0570681095123291,
0.21122489869594574,
0.1684231460094452,
0.20806226134300232,
0.3155152201652527,
-0.5359755754470825,
-0.40960800647735596,
0.060553643852472305,
-0.35903528332710266,
-0.24249738454818726,
-0.3349299132823944,
-0.12964265048503876,
-0.29776713252067566,
0.9097931385040283,
0.010883405804634094,
-0.33338451385498047,
-0.007838408462703228,
-0.23320214450359344,
-0.02073531411588192,
0.34595754742622375,
0.6682119369506836,
0.6220417618751526,
-0.05131492018699646,
0.13031771779060364,
0.159092977643013,
-0.7385392189025879,
0.4643045961856842,
0.3007626235485077,
-0.10154088586568832,
-0.09032293409109116,
0.18367058038711548,
0.7505642175674438,
0.0891997441649437,
-0.6855974793434143,
0.5089691877365112,
0.09330692887306213,
-0.2821809649467468,
-0.12303927540779114,
-0.14348144829273224,
0.31829944252967834,
0.4768145680427551,
0.5300257205963135,
-0.10211178660392761,
-0.1767701655626297,
-0.3638773560523987,
0.2687206566333771,
0.34142640233039856,
-0.4543611407279968,
-0.27694734930992126,
0.30148422718048096,
0.24725675582885742,
-0.4875294268131256,
0.17708563804626465,
-0.3496285378932953,
-0.16818450391292572,
0.214431494474411,
0.5802748799324036,
0.7141565680503845,
-0.6412568688392639,
0.17096516489982605,
-0.07808686047792435,
0.14782218635082245,
-0.09252525866031647,
0.28382372856140137,
-0.29144906997680664,
-0.747169017791748,
-0.7823768854141235,
-1.0103890895843506,
-0.21917228400707245,
0.41669073700904846,
-0.7306461930274963,
0.49123135209083557,
-0.5134857892990112,
0.10004471242427826,
0.06433629989624023,
-0.1867411732673645,
-0.34845802187919617,
0.1447449028491974,
0.3686172664165497,
0.9052619338035583,
-0.8654934763908386,
0.9386340975761414,
0.46382689476013184,
-0.22152602672576904,
-0.7367064356803894,
0.2770569622516632,
-0.044574689120054245,
-0.8261712193489075,
0.7734416127204895,
-0.16536681354045868,
-0.06337475776672363,
0.35652467608451843,
-0.4734875559806824,
-0.9965538382530212,
1.1966956853866577,
0.7664705514907837,
-1.1100049018859863,
-0.19352707266807556,
0.2966082692146301,
0.39428266882896423,
-0.11464583873748779,
-0.34909573197364807,
0.9069980978965759,
0.14808455109596252,
0.4325128495693207,
-1.2600464820861816,
-0.18138304352760315,
0.2645838260650635,
-0.13170714676380157,
0.2046118527650833,
-0.2786509692668915,
0.26815393567085266,
0.10371724516153336,
-0.15257342159748077,
-0.09121609479188919,
0.7015708684921265,
0.40163835883140564,
0.3869720697402954,
0.5494199991226196,
0.8092729449272156,
0.8254114389419556,
0.04788113757967949,
0.37168088555336,
-0.5148717761039734,
0.25826722383499146,
1.4719748497009277,
-0.5641434192657471,
1.0227668285369873,
0.788814127445221,
-0.4054931402206421,
0.3037049472332001,
0.4118909537792206,
0.37122347950935364,
0.9469724893569946,
0.3729700446128845,
-0.31474587321281433,
0.050980743020772934,
0.01293872855603695,
-0.4753433167934418,
0.5057437419891357,
0.4040670692920685,
-0.11456204205751419,
-0.3932885229587555,
0.05940971150994301,
-0.1151990294456482,
0.09354079514741898,
-0.22575318813323975,
0.9840588569641113,
0.057421762496232986,
-0.5355141162872314,
0.8242264986038208,
-0.21487295627593994,
0.752712607383728,
-0.6767562031745911,
0.09793957322835922,
0.04354194924235344,
-0.03308320418000221,
-0.2328215092420578,
-0.5290012955665588,
0.1686476320028305,
0.10743261873722076,
-0.17237558960914612,
-0.32052531838417053,
0.6734722256660461,
-0.8327569961547852,
-0.27096229791641235,
0.15312214195728302,
0.5033227801322937,
0.20124925673007965,
0.07936074584722519,
-0.4953222870826721,
0.1221398413181305,
-0.13239064812660217,
-0.022395074367523193,
0.6162476539611816,
0.521045446395874,
0.3688220977783203,
0.6027390360832214,
0.5631405115127563,
0.29411864280700684,
0.16818539798259735,
0.2520968019962311,
0.8226340413093567,
-0.26601824164390564,
-0.5947985649108887,
-1.067229986190796,
0.3626994788646698,
0.06196356192231178,
-0.1379343569278717,
0.2993294894695282,
0.6928855776786804,
0.9783087968826294,
-0.05521019175648689,
0.8772403597831726,
0.016960417851805687,
0.5856257081031799,
-0.823283314704895,
0.8909712433815002,
-0.16909217834472656,
0.1265626847743988,
-0.4813685715198517,
-1.0124014616012573,
0.10354957729578018,
0.4706406593322754,
-0.13763761520385742,
-0.11895977705717087,
0.7010104060173035,
0.5127652287483215,
0.09120766073465347,
-0.11477353423833847,
0.48185113072395325,
0.28023943305015564,
0.22068281471729279,
0.34446635842323303,
0.7974001169204712,
-0.023407844826579094,
0.5120437741279602,
-0.30877211689949036,
-0.34459230303764343,
0.13891245424747467,
-1.0014595985412598,
-0.6558433175086975,
-0.9072916507720947,
-0.37483087182044983,
-0.12261992692947388,
0.07788703590631485,
0.9988011717796326,
0.7841703295707703,
-0.6194998621940613,
-0.3943769931793213,
-0.19758763909339905,
-0.155945286154747,
-0.09609188884496689,
-0.12979406118392944,
0.28751295804977417,
-0.7514119148254395,
-0.5116117596626282,
0.5364631414413452,
0.4139992296695709,
0.21439091861248016,
-0.3609806299209595,
-0.255889892578125,
-0.33966147899627686,
-0.20081062614917755,
0.6633350253105164,
0.304900199174881,
-0.698594868183136,
-0.14350318908691406,
-0.2758307456970215,
0.21949659287929535,
-0.16296397149562836,
0.6060545444488525,
-0.8721781969070435,
0.2959226369857788,
0.25331729650497437,
0.9492077827453613,
0.5715065002441406,
-0.05874225124716759,
0.7085133194923401,
-1.2681164741516113,
0.33804601430892944,
0.23002982139587402,
0.03415841981768608,
0.2901826798915863,
-0.0003946985525544733,
0.0830526202917099,
0.19608326256275177,
-0.4495079517364502,
-1.0353248119354248,
0.4698660373687744,
-0.8627734184265137,
-0.17434373497962952,
1.2230302095413208,
-0.0720210149884224,
0.10890893638134003,
-0.08622059226036072,
-0.2783932685852051,
0.32705527544021606,
-0.30186840891838074,
0.7276625037193298,
1.0277138948440552,
0.13067182898521423,
-0.179629385471344,
-0.36199289560317993,
0.8914366960525513,
0.3707897365093231,
-0.7388530373573303,
0.4066535234451294,
0.3745386600494385,
0.28436794877052307,
0.31999459862709045,
0.8073427081108093,
0.03458437696099281,
0.12577122449874878,
-0.27393701672554016,
0.011287734843790531,
0.09746559709310532,
-0.3258247971534729,
-0.41043174266815186,
0.04806146025657654,
0.2696071267127991,
-0.4225313365459442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19026v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19026v1
|
DiveR-CT: Diversity-enhanced Red Teaming with Relaxing Constraints
| 2024-05-29T12:12:09 | 2024-05-29T12:12:09 |
Andrew Zhao, Quentin Xu, Matthieu Lin, Shenzhi Wang, Yong-jin Liu, Zilong Zheng, Gao Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have made them indispensable,
raising significant concerns over managing their safety. Automated red teaming
offers a promising alternative to the labor-intensive and error-prone manual
probing for vulnerabilities, providing more consistent and scalable safety
evaluations. However, existing approaches often compromise diversity by
focusing on maximizing attack success rate. Additionally, methods that decrease
the cosine similarity from historical embeddings with semantic diversity
rewards lead to novelty stagnation as history grows. To address these issues,
we introduce DiveR-CT, which relaxes conventional constraints on the objective
and semantic reward, granting greater freedom for the policy to enhance
diversity. Our experiments demonstrate DiveR-CT's marked superiority over
baselines by 1) generating data that perform better in various diversity
metrics across different attack success rate levels, 2) better-enhancing
resiliency in blue team models through safety tuning based on collected data,
3) allowing dynamic control of objective weights for reliable and controllable
attack success rates, and 4) reducing susceptibility to reward
overoptimization. Project details and code can be found at
https://andrewzh112.github.io/#diverct.
|
[
-0.5151829719543457,
-0.5980395674705505,
0.06540986150503159,
0.3508957624435425,
-0.2097158133983612,
0.5676673650741577,
-0.37630417943000793,
-0.5096827149391174,
0.20041458308696747,
0.23618823289871216,
-0.7258873581886292,
-0.6611872911453247,
-0.6854740381240845,
0.48185136914253235,
-0.22848013043403625,
1.2433499097824097,
0.08865182846784592,
-0.2311365306377411,
0.1089274063706398,
-0.3662804365158081,
-0.48552459478378296,
-0.4321231544017792,
-0.7676300406455994,
-0.02672937512397766,
0.6350677609443665,
0.27560168504714966,
0.7146359086036682,
0.6861937642097473,
0.8763309121131897,
0.3094583749771118,
-0.3609461784362793,
0.10469550639390945,
-0.7926594018936157,
0.4196759760379791,
-0.2099982351064682,
-0.6384441256523132,
-0.19567802548408508,
-0.23141519725322723,
0.560401439666748,
0.6313594579696655,
-0.29275038838386536,
-0.49488118290901184,
-0.03411180526018143,
0.6603862643241882,
-0.8879210352897644,
-0.10656614601612091,
-0.7554895281791687,
0.04388493299484253,
0.15311843156814575,
-0.22854945063591003,
-0.25911945104599,
-0.36058011651039124,
0.3582606911659241,
-0.4674282968044281,
0.0793272852897644,
-0.22630946338176727,
0.6884717345237732,
0.5025400519371033,
-0.4964817762374878,
-0.014826272614300251,
-0.5810985565185547,
1.0196762084960938,
-0.2770843803882599,
0.18150676786899567,
0.13926148414611816,
0.3045498728752136,
0.07664071023464203,
-0.36607736349105835,
-0.14663290977478027,
-0.008816605433821678,
0.15547505021095276,
0.5727322101593018,
-0.2926969826221466,
0.1609240621328354,
-0.13953715562820435,
0.3171437382698059,
-0.47057807445526123,
0.3755643665790558,
-0.3991968631744385,
-0.27537232637405396,
0.9355512261390686,
0.4952106177806854,
0.5013942718505859,
0.42813146114349365,
-0.6857292652130127,
-0.25494006276130676,
-0.6204128265380859,
-0.03665207326412201,
0.3823089301586151,
0.46148326992988586,
-0.5150191783905029,
0.48126232624053955,
-0.5306946635246277,
0.3533214032649994,
-0.3497872054576874,
0.1344679296016693,
0.19413605332374573,
-0.7115060687065125,
-0.13322164118289948,
-0.01213875599205494,
0.44843629002571106,
0.4453503489494324,
0.17606844007968903,
-0.13516148924827576,
-0.4021357297897339,
0.12572264671325684,
0.3195829391479492,
-0.5938302278518677,
-0.39622390270233154,
0.3148661255836487,
-0.2693648338317871,
-0.411940336227417,
0.07963673025369644,
-0.6495276093482971,
-0.31697842478752136,
-0.03576478734612465,
0.09184130281209946,
-0.48987868428230286,
-0.568072497844696,
0.4216274619102478,
-0.6917394399642944,
0.17489093542099,
0.3407358229160309,
-0.5893614292144775,
0.18124110996723175,
0.6243545413017273,
0.9396588206291199,
-0.6601537466049194,
-0.3547649383544922,
-0.4738735854625702,
0.21708087623119354,
-0.01400265097618103,
0.47927719354629517,
-0.46989721059799194,
-0.7457806468009949,
-0.02352607063949108,
-0.29139116406440735,
0.1216379702091217,
-0.48387908935546875,
0.19615626335144043,
-0.49225905537605286,
0.1833549439907074,
-0.17475277185440063,
-0.5044136643409729,
0.0002603481989353895,
0.5665127038955688,
-0.7835292220115662,
0.3526177406311035,
0.0572134293615818,
-0.8998883962631226,
0.5077215433120728,
-0.85792475938797,
-0.3953077793121338,
0.35232919454574585,
-0.1288388967514038,
-0.48006319999694824,
-0.11342775821685791,
0.05770685523748398,
-0.03628874197602272,
-0.030605219304561615,
-0.2872985005378723,
-0.3894542455673218,
-0.2919531464576721,
-0.1022077202796936,
-0.1031680628657341,
1.2176213264465332,
0.23167705535888672,
-0.30700263381004333,
0.2766853868961334,
-0.11721795052289963,
0.057475149631500244,
0.13790568709373474,
-0.8011473417282104,
-0.3671332895755768,
-0.10656433552503586,
-0.22864413261413574,
-0.28861090540885925,
0.15872812271118164,
-0.5182284712791443,
0.21025465428829193,
-0.49190670251846313,
0.299576073884964,
0.665992796421051,
0.0805337131023407,
0.6342806220054626,
-0.6045650243759155,
0.7097100615501404,
-0.11582167446613312,
0.38655152916908264,
-0.027069129049777985,
-0.3740106523036957,
-0.49584153294563293,
-1.1035614013671875,
0.24668996036052704,
0.7537329792976379,
-0.7152060270309448,
0.5161808133125305,
-0.2933303415775299,
-0.46214184165000916,
-0.3791347146034241,
0.04245749115943909,
0.28290486335754395,
0.13186389207839966,
0.522840142250061,
-0.5450623631477356,
-0.6713241934776306,
-0.914612889289856,
-0.12015614658594131,
-0.20884311199188232,
0.03703688085079193,
0.3560633361339569,
0.5611327290534973,
-0.3988078534603119,
1.1120513677597046,
-0.5040180683135986,
-0.19726943969726562,
-0.6267828345298767,
0.154351145029068,
0.0997103825211525,
0.640013575553894,
0.3955138027667999,
-1.0877981185913086,
-0.4552931785583496,
-0.11569192260503769,
-0.5791628956794739,
-0.012598192319273949,
-0.10739874839782715,
-0.016058681532740593,
0.5891223549842834,
0.3159703314304352,
-0.4391765892505646,
0.23361027240753174,
0.6852283477783203,
-0.39716053009033203,
0.4298330843448639,
0.01653711125254631,
0.08917693793773651,
-0.7496559619903564,
-0.09121052175760269,
-0.2186008095741272,
-0.11300969123840332,
-0.5551071166992188,
0.4593077301979065,
0.018463661894202232,
0.24365681409835815,
-0.6804580092430115,
0.33365964889526367,
-0.31100648641586304,
0.17592519521713257,
-0.21387390792369843,
-0.13664789497852325,
-0.20337511599063873,
0.1933838427066803,
0.19291894137859344,
0.4529704451560974,
0.5412702560424805,
-0.728672444820404,
0.3407135009765625,
0.056396715342998505,
-0.15319626033306122,
0.51518714427948,
-0.8456971049308777,
-0.11957812309265137,
0.022778429090976715,
0.4291290044784546,
-0.640489935874939,
-0.1702473759651184,
-0.04477425292134285,
-0.2936963438987732,
0.4410303235054016,
-0.26304540038108826,
-0.2559857964515686,
-0.12498190999031067,
-0.6836166381835938,
0.8509550094604492,
0.6173830032348633,
-0.36357587575912476,
0.36054879426956177,
0.5305570363998413,
-0.2474175989627838,
-0.9029828310012817,
-0.7821750640869141,
0.10567156970500946,
-0.44222238659858704,
-0.6899389028549194,
0.39868584275245667,
-0.27919086813926697,
-0.45522448420524597,
-0.23237666487693787,
-0.13041533529758453,
-0.24865388870239258,
0.5800655484199524,
0.06535156816244125,
0.43956777453422546,
-0.012490320950746536,
-0.04390290379524231,
0.0363309346139431,
-0.07093579322099686,
-0.26507169008255005,
-0.4145483076572418,
0.6132814884185791,
-0.3205522894859314,
-0.40328770875930786,
-0.43138548731803894,
0.38164642453193665,
0.39178118109703064,
-0.2676301598548889,
0.7818352580070496,
0.3804742097854614,
-0.005921666510403156,
-0.22022324800491333,
-0.4379551112651825,
-0.5466806888580322,
-0.4890957772731781,
0.4764566421508789,
0.05934283509850502,
-1.4216433763504028,
0.40172675251960754,
0.1285906732082367,
0.36417773365974426,
0.17073199152946472,
0.5935714840888977,
-0.3490685820579529,
0.6095960736274719,
0.7226786613464355,
-0.19743050634860992,
0.5164787173271179,
-0.1923874169588089,
-0.20995210111141205,
-0.3234712481498718,
-0.19006088376045227,
-0.3134840428829193,
-0.462897926568985,
-0.6785409450531006,
-0.11530813574790955,
0.5390986204147339,
-0.11218689382076263,
-0.4095144271850586,
0.19041258096694946,
-0.6712419986724854,
0.6670548915863037,
0.4191100597381592,
0.0270604956895113,
0.3265702426433563,
-0.3318714201450348,
0.12024848163127899,
0.07023244351148605,
-0.7859966158866882,
0.08896617591381073,
1.0477193593978882,
0.4687909185886383,
0.8695825338363647,
0.4366706311702728,
1.284285545349121,
0.2953108847141266,
0.04052344709634781,
-0.501451849937439,
0.42974090576171875,
-0.004671239294111729,
-0.6363222599029541,
-0.5502943396568298,
-0.6823911070823669,
-1.2231197357177734,
0.21317538619041443,
-0.3356057107448578,
-0.3105525076389313,
0.06724841892719269,
0.08449485152959824,
-0.4529961943626404,
0.22637267410755157,
-0.5676466822624207,
0.3605027496814728,
-0.22216282784938812,
-0.22095738351345062,
-0.36856982111930847,
-0.700614333152771,
0.5308140516281128,
0.1079680398106575,
-0.06117405742406845,
0.11509877443313599,
-0.4629128575325012,
0.39510872960090637,
-0.12797455489635468,
1.1308566331863403,
0.029274486005306244,
-0.1005500853061676,
0.041310641914606094,
0.34233057498931885,
0.610713541507721,
0.22864383459091187,
0.1038837656378746,
0.29959601163864136,
-0.36613190174102783,
-0.678898811340332,
-0.1689922958612442,
0.5807801485061646,
-0.6424955129623413,
-0.7709507942199707,
-0.20975744724273682,
-0.944953203201294,
0.2295769602060318,
0.3132619559764862,
0.17647694051265717,
-0.08281073719263077,
-0.1014791950583458,
0.5664836168289185,
0.8239655494689941,
-0.3730197250843048,
0.7128216624259949,
0.5486612915992737,
0.23770712316036224,
-0.6056722402572632,
0.7423896193504333,
-0.13818387687206268,
0.6871545314788818,
0.48026037216186523,
-0.07319847494363785,
-0.28579214215278625,
-0.9269835352897644,
0.052639033645391464,
0.04152607545256615,
-0.4980475604534149,
-0.34651288390159607,
-0.6328455209732056,
-0.12469211965799332,
-0.09351658821105957,
-0.5471302270889282,
-0.5370168089866638,
-0.6297990679740906,
0.05610543116927147,
-0.14059731364250183,
0.2896292209625244,
0.47410762310028076,
-0.16522808372974396,
-0.026758112013339996,
-0.7274265289306641,
-0.12504321336746216,
0.35871797800064087,
0.2712118923664093,
-0.6322501301765442,
-0.15569424629211426,
-0.16453056037425995,
0.030495597049593925,
-0.17912782728672028,
-0.5281643867492676,
0.4164345860481262,
-0.1472729742527008,
0.6318731904029846,
-0.08599326759576797,
0.36697280406951904,
0.06995640695095062,
0.13957065343856812,
0.7680155634880066,
0.3558954894542694,
-0.8405539393424988,
0.6027831435203552,
-0.6660298109054565,
0.4840221703052521,
0.6281920671463013,
0.1816679984331131,
-0.039809755980968475,
-0.851162850856781,
-0.6477459073066711,
-1.0494418144226074,
0.5223819613456726,
0.5125512480735779,
-0.09680702537298203,
-0.005794959142804146,
-0.010693187825381756,
-0.11460442841053009,
0.12565279006958008,
-0.7971245646476746,
-0.1893526017665863,
-0.2813469469547272,
-0.2550715506076813,
0.2647581398487091,
-0.005304417572915554,
-0.5312774181365967,
0.20343513786792755,
0.3320285677909851,
-0.09404850751161575,
-0.07404498010873795,
0.22702957689762115,
-0.08791760355234146,
0.23287542164325714,
0.21058447659015656,
0.8918042778968811,
0.27008599042892456,
-0.1573461890220642,
0.16157527267932892,
0.7609314918518066,
-0.3343830406665802,
-0.010700613260269165,
-0.09625449031591415,
-0.11056853830814362,
-0.19897641241550446,
0.6413628458976746,
0.11439736187458038,
-0.05600202456116676,
-0.6981458067893982,
0.4867684543132782,
-0.1252368986606598,
-0.3058551251888275,
-0.006820965092629194,
0.5520466566085815,
0.00017476170614827424,
0.41942429542541504,
0.1790565550327301,
0.047822125256061554,
-0.13245287537574768,
-0.2826034724712372,
0.2443818598985672,
0.8384057283401489,
-0.27945438027381897,
0.093988336622715,
0.33868294954299927,
0.6953966617584229,
-0.2415730506181717,
0.6478671431541443,
0.044385284185409546,
-0.6427804827690125,
1.0497500896453857,
0.28098228573799133,
0.7945786714553833,
-0.36114487051963806,
-0.03901706263422966,
0.3306950628757477,
0.6252604126930237,
-0.1373063325881958,
0.3040020167827606,
-0.024592522531747818,
-0.7642580270767212,
-0.24139845371246338,
-0.2246496081352234,
-0.518910825252533,
-0.2512176036834717,
-0.6300099492073059,
0.30119356513023376,
-0.5290848016738892,
-0.14456523954868317,
-0.574358344078064,
-0.05262499302625656,
-0.4849257469177246,
0.10776441544294357,
0.14791953563690186,
1.130074381828308,
-0.6163340210914612,
0.6074787974357605,
0.49908947944641113,
-0.5477927923202515,
-0.15346689522266388,
-0.08244521915912628,
0.2890119254589081,
-0.6505482792854309,
0.7547297477722168,
0.06105371192097664,
-0.26000913977622986,
-0.09337250888347626,
-0.47793734073638916,
-0.7648392915725708,
1.4700433015823364,
0.3381471633911133,
-0.6472895741462708,
0.25282755494117737,
0.10901571810245514,
0.3686554431915283,
-0.43831419944763184,
0.10716318339109421,
0.45468562841415405,
0.5435148477554321,
-0.20851866900920868,
-0.8963618874549866,
0.04319773614406586,
0.05926623195409775,
-0.21079015731811523,
0.22277194261550903,
-0.69954514503479,
0.7931805849075317,
-0.4753004014492035,
-0.4273068904876709,
-0.12242791056632996,
0.480634480714798,
0.5323665738105774,
0.19738613069057465,
0.8059672117233276,
0.5981792211532593,
0.7412135004997253,
-0.11611318588256836,
1.2799516916275024,
-0.05697997286915779,
0.32344913482666016,
1.0708262920379639,
-0.1236467957496643,
0.5721797347068787,
0.437370628118515,
-0.04393954947590828,
0.41699275374412537,
0.28878891468048096,
-0.2246241718530655,
0.6712311506271362,
0.21340519189834595,
-0.3673698902130127,
-0.40642428398132324,
-0.16990812122821808,
-0.37364721298217773,
0.36299610137939453,
0.09629809111356735,
-0.26294639706611633,
-0.1936899572610855,
-0.42268750071525574,
-0.05005462467670441,
-0.019371753558516502,
-0.17473749816417694,
0.8341130614280701,
-0.06040351837873459,
-0.5177173614501953,
0.6506577134132385,
-0.2783350348472595,
1.0594607591629028,
-0.6806831955909729,
0.17296051979064941,
-0.4436277151107788,
0.03445839509367943,
-0.24986830353736877,
-0.9526808261871338,
0.4826011657714844,
-0.14437487721443176,
-0.23632383346557617,
-0.12521669268608093,
0.2634129226207733,
-0.49501487612724304,
0.02608461305499077,
0.41146308183670044,
0.36724841594696045,
-0.26764732599258423,
0.11903510242700577,
-0.6040635108947754,
0.34712353348731995,
0.20883862674236298,
0.009619027376174927,
0.26870056986808777,
0.10645971447229385,
0.11852480471134186,
1.0172920227050781,
0.4948953092098236,
0.14790749549865723,
-0.06369181722402573,
-0.059946756809949875,
0.8582058548927307,
-0.6198925375938416,
-0.6357225775718689,
-1.1953766345977783,
0.743053138256073,
-0.3389255404472351,
-0.262857049703598,
0.47541099786758423,
0.5903909802436829,
0.9691992402076721,
0.059030450880527496,
0.9373582601547241,
0.20964734256267548,
0.15041492879390717,
-0.41925591230392456,
0.849757194519043,
-0.49534669518470764,
0.5450261235237122,
-0.06836264580488205,
-0.5748457312583923,
-0.6909992098808289,
0.1765909045934677,
0.09443911164999008,
0.005514232441782951,
0.6563810110092163,
0.8388465642929077,
0.14473067224025726,
0.06598298996686935,
0.2265111654996872,
0.06884113699197769,
0.66506427526474,
0.8016781210899353,
1.0884259939193726,
0.24608446657657623,
1.0190221071243286,
-0.09912015497684479,
-0.3356635272502899,
-0.36529600620269775,
-0.8876268267631531,
-0.867733359336853,
-0.1961740255355835,
-0.5563191771507263,
-0.15332087874412537,
0.2509676218032837,
0.9075897932052612,
0.7586472630500793,
-0.7310738563537598,
-0.16230806708335876,
-0.4013085663318634,
0.3257538080215454,
-0.16628216207027435,
-0.20491747558116913,
-0.04260769113898277,
-0.658574104309082,
-0.6810393929481506,
0.5062656998634338,
0.4962782859802246,
0.32579943537712097,
-0.022297056391835213,
-0.3425522446632385,
0.08609162271022797,
0.005995592102408409,
0.2655949294567108,
0.4889443814754486,
-0.5522418022155762,
-0.1795927733182907,
-0.18176881968975067,
-0.27521848678588867,
-0.19381730258464813,
0.6162161231040955,
-0.5986517071723938,
0.3891362249851227,
0.5860341191291809,
1.055836796760559,
0.15857045352458954,
-0.07431329041719437,
0.8978350162506104,
-0.64979487657547,
0.033821891993284225,
0.6367014050483704,
0.4686458706855774,
0.26888760924339294,
-0.2639691233634949,
0.864816427230835,
0.2856670320034027,
-0.34369227290153503,
-1.0456111431121826,
0.49570390582084656,
-0.9688316583633423,
-0.4460023045539856,
1.2585127353668213,
-0.24297189712524414,
0.2126408815383911,
-0.3916541039943695,
-0.0737302377820015,
0.2719096839427948,
-0.4350411593914032,
1.070898413658142,
0.35850659012794495,
-0.04545477405190468,
0.026183083653450012,
0.11498977243900299,
0.545030951499939,
0.8492093682289124,
-0.8812734484672546,
0.009693734347820282,
0.2992745041847229,
0.31111419200897217,
0.08478792756795883,
0.3136780858039856,
-0.035598546266555786,
0.5728099942207336,
-0.11320484429597855,
0.09734521061182022,
-0.24538373947143555,
-0.41119813919067383,
-0.4797602891921997,
0.4255349934101105,
-0.10669303685426712,
-0.31122294068336487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19010v1
|
Evaluating the External and Parametric Knowledge Fusion of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-29T11:48:27 | 2024-05-29T11:48:27 |
Hao Zhang, Yuyang Zhang, Xiaoguang Li, Wenxuan Shi, Haonan Xu, Huanshuo Liu, Yasheng Wang, Lifeng Shang, Qun Liu, Yong Liu, Ruiming Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Integrating external knowledge into large language models (LLMs) presents a
promising solution to overcome the limitations imposed by their antiquated and
static parametric memory. Prior studies, however, have tended to over-reliance
on external knowledge, underestimating the valuable contributions of an LLMs'
intrinsic parametric knowledge. The efficacy of LLMs in blending external and
parametric knowledge remains largely unexplored, especially in cases where
external knowledge is incomplete and necessitates supplementation by their
parametric knowledge. We propose to deconstruct knowledge fusion into four
distinct scenarios, offering the first thorough investigation of LLM behavior
across each. We develop a systematic pipeline for data construction and
knowledge infusion to simulate these fusion scenarios, facilitating a series of
controlled experiments. Our investigation reveals that enhancing parametric
knowledge within LLMs can significantly bolster their capability for knowledge
integration. Nonetheless, we identify persistent challenges in memorizing and
eliciting parametric knowledge, and determining parametric knowledge
boundaries. Our findings aim to steer future explorations on harmonizing
external and parametric knowledge within LLMs.
|
[
-0.4704214334487915,
-0.44902393221855164,
1.0531541109085083,
-0.16416049003601074,
-0.034684453159570694,
0.16906800866127014,
-0.45806223154067993,
-0.45112812519073486,
-0.12153134495019913,
0.6928399801254272,
-0.2607429027557373,
-0.4537079334259033,
-0.5013617277145386,
-0.19372111558914185,
-0.5354459881782532,
0.8360601663589478,
-0.2723672091960907,
0.16558341681957245,
-0.7127224802970886,
-0.28558772802352905,
-0.29302099347114563,
-0.49694719910621643,
-0.24212393164634705,
-0.5274088978767395,
0.32455214858055115,
0.22972382605075836,
0.5139734148979187,
0.30430659651756287,
0.34415966272354126,
0.30445557832717896,
-0.06936266273260117,
0.42377957701683044,
-0.5972275733947754,
-0.01660699024796486,
-0.46007493138313293,
-0.4064335227012634,
0.031229190528392792,
-0.20474053919315338,
1.0792162418365479,
0.7894178032875061,
-0.1846119463443756,
0.25682082772254944,
0.44046512246131897,
0.4527530074119568,
-0.7017332911491394,
0.2962617874145508,
-0.771073579788208,
-0.21981096267700195,
-0.1294865906238556,
-0.0038628801703453064,
-0.1255146563053131,
-0.2858303189277649,
0.28384506702423096,
-0.22884617745876312,
-0.17269693315029144,
-0.019462864845991135,
0.5514723062515259,
0.1585552990436554,
-0.5449503064155579,
-0.20870907604694366,
-1.0329476594924927,
0.6311066746711731,
-0.852557897567749,
0.6196203231811523,
0.29048171639442444,
0.3853280246257782,
-0.21072116494178772,
-0.538739025592804,
-0.6184015274047852,
-0.1437852829694748,
-0.1266905665397644,
-0.12195874005556107,
-0.1656641662120819,
0.045731641352176666,
0.013166863471269608,
0.3005244731903076,
-0.32701048254966736,
0.14561745524406433,
-0.5751556158065796,
-0.1505679041147232,
0.5181276798248291,
0.4508737325668335,
0.3408137261867523,
0.053728409111499786,
-0.34502261877059937,
0.09743388742208481,
-0.851227343082428,
0.04106616601347923,
0.3928450345993042,
0.28902748227119446,
-0.106473408639431,
0.6720594167709351,
-0.2505503296852112,
0.8613699078559875,
-0.18767337501049042,
-0.2958516776561737,
0.06508485972881317,
-0.7165123820304871,
-0.06652074307203293,
-0.05244281888008118,
0.9029805064201355,
0.14582204818725586,
-0.08586632460355759,
-0.3033568561077118,
-0.1993378847837448,
-0.3401181101799011,
-0.010104905813932419,
-0.28434374928474426,
-0.06025854870676994,
0.23485495150089264,
-0.17978063225746155,
0.183744415640831,
-0.1616823375225067,
-0.642153799533844,
-0.6575427055358887,
-0.5802813172340393,
0.5628893971443176,
-0.6451340317726135,
-0.29232627153396606,
-0.04031474143266678,
-0.3140798807144165,
0.43482160568237305,
0.14273402094841003,
-0.6767281293869019,
0.15810149908065796,
0.92368084192276,
0.6727094054222107,
-0.027125125750899315,
-0.5340810418128967,
0.02172023057937622,
0.6614547371864319,
-0.14807544648647308,
0.9124698042869568,
-0.5891092419624329,
-0.38729164004325867,
0.29647135734558105,
-0.26995524764060974,
-0.0872071161866188,
-0.5794553160667419,
0.17828857898712158,
-0.4289434850215912,
0.2304491251707077,
-0.682360053062439,
-0.8172681927680969,
-0.19980737566947937,
0.36669212579727173,
-0.4631229639053345,
0.8113833665847778,
0.25395703315734863,
-0.8011655211448669,
0.2650778889656067,
-0.1886107623577118,
-0.17852449417114258,
0.09970437735319138,
-0.45715489983558655,
0.168425053358078,
0.009175624698400497,
0.039399005472660065,
0.32583552598953247,
-0.9381417632102966,
0.4402388632297516,
-0.5287834405899048,
-0.14950360357761383,
0.20585283637046814,
-0.10450693964958191,
0.6726447939872742,
-0.12846411764621735,
-0.025717243552207947,
0.07119439542293549,
-0.6463795304298401,
-0.2672741413116455,
-0.06612449884414673,
-0.17129568755626678,
-0.5131016373634338,
-0.18755078315734863,
-0.4706699550151825,
0.36452311277389526,
0.5712971687316895,
-0.5055319666862488,
0.08030977845191956,
-0.4403265416622162,
0.2761245369911194,
0.6779643893241882,
0.2518346309661865,
0.6501272916793823,
-0.5644776821136475,
0.392605185508728,
0.06078537181019783,
0.06746707856655121,
0.044148560613393784,
-0.45876699686050415,
-0.8811639547348022,
0.011817925609648228,
0.045854710042476654,
0.3321504592895508,
-0.9589114189147949,
0.27499741315841675,
-0.32556334137916565,
-0.6154179573059082,
-0.47366318106651306,
0.6374987959861755,
0.3556669056415558,
0.6674777269363403,
0.36135199666023254,
0.26244139671325684,
-0.4815326929092407,
-1.1326889991760254,
-0.2354922592639923,
-0.2798704504966736,
-0.1615705043077469,
0.17270663380622864,
0.41240939497947693,
-0.18427585065364838,
0.9485607147216797,
-0.2854140102863312,
-0.3189479410648346,
-0.4458552300930023,
-0.10762546211481094,
0.04065433889627457,
0.3601560592651367,
0.2697567641735077,
-0.32977479696273804,
-0.31112605333328247,
0.10076654702425003,
-0.8673534393310547,
0.17403258383274078,
0.06577637046575546,
-0.043453384190797806,
-0.026265040040016174,
0.5731969475746155,
-0.6868346333503723,
-0.17447686195373535,
0.6699464321136475,
-0.05831148847937584,
0.4495418071746826,
-0.39266616106033325,
0.09605462849140167,
-1.0451748371124268,
0.027002587914466858,
0.22228097915649414,
0.2554318308830261,
-0.7146843075752258,
0.07575379312038422,
0.27525946497917175,
0.02588120475411415,
-0.5372848510742188,
0.7238602638244629,
-0.48246872425079346,
-0.015187017619609833,
-0.09936776012182236,
0.20111359655857086,
-0.2180248647928238,
0.3615947961807251,
-0.0039175706915557384,
0.6241692900657654,
0.5661547780036926,
-0.5971958041191101,
0.5044718980789185,
0.20682591199874878,
-0.7824514508247375,
0.5175685882568359,
-0.3133171498775482,
0.01048207189887762,
-0.3619561493396759,
0.43285125494003296,
-1.133173942565918,
-0.3054047226905823,
0.20162108540534973,
0.06669427454471588,
0.20393164455890656,
-0.06547784060239792,
-0.7535837292671204,
-0.23195496201515198,
-0.20748452842235565,
0.44109588861465454,
0.7584879398345947,
-0.4530864357948303,
0.9478487372398376,
0.6054568886756897,
-0.17782044410705566,
-0.14766937494277954,
-0.42831459641456604,
0.10872279107570648,
-0.5576385855674744,
-0.7744132280349731,
0.38645634055137634,
0.2428303062915802,
-0.5402387380599976,
-0.054107725620269775,
0.04537789523601532,
-0.021056126803159714,
-0.546134352684021,
-0.00013085409591440111,
0.15697823464870453,
-0.19411543011665344,
0.08138135820627213,
0.107337586581707,
0.0983920693397522,
0.1867556869983673,
-0.3448377251625061,
0.5291510224342346,
0.07909427583217621,
-0.6383461952209473,
-0.4066582918167114,
0.18970397114753723,
0.7434533834457397,
-0.13358379900455475,
1.0487840175628662,
0.38331374526023865,
-0.510025680065155,
-0.19306524097919464,
-1.108115792274475,
0.06288065761327744,
-0.48249849677085876,
0.12975792586803436,
-0.30236274003982544,
-0.6464081406593323,
0.7946498990058899,
-0.11687792837619781,
0.04493870958685875,
0.4344201385974884,
0.5320585370063782,
-0.12764087319374084,
0.8102513551712036,
0.5606600642204285,
-0.056954994797706604,
0.20645056664943695,
-0.23230452835559845,
0.1843128800392151,
-1.1370654106140137,
-0.7481858134269714,
-0.33054396510124207,
-0.3540289103984833,
-0.287509948015213,
-0.6195581555366516,
0.4892253577709198,
-0.17780934274196625,
-0.2611757218837738,
0.3407255709171295,
0.2314189225435257,
0.41891777515411377,
0.39134645462036133,
0.3263430595397949,
0.3805314600467682,
-0.48393258452415466,
-0.11073780059814453,
0.057267941534519196,
-0.9555081129074097,
-0.18202897906303406,
1.1265780925750732,
0.4905437231063843,
0.865665853023529,
-0.024088967591524124,
0.7636821269989014,
-0.41599002480506897,
0.2660598158836365,
-0.4027268886566162,
0.6575145721435547,
-0.0056378645822405815,
-0.3097785413265228,
-0.2699626088142395,
-0.4353982210159302,
-0.5093444585800171,
0.18526947498321533,
-0.06756589561700821,
-0.7964172959327698,
0.20726197957992554,
0.11856620013713837,
-0.5126144886016846,
0.3381902277469635,
-0.6701000332832336,
0.6135889887809753,
-0.25074663758277893,
-0.32068002223968506,
-0.21900895237922668,
-0.5704506635665894,
0.9100845456123352,
-0.4194034934043884,
0.44960689544677734,
-0.1020231619477272,
-0.17830905318260193,
0.692451536655426,
-0.23986217379570007,
0.8730311393737793,
-0.06474162638187408,
-0.6647666692733765,
0.22437845170497894,
0.05820637568831444,
0.6656848192214966,
-0.045544058084487915,
-0.04211918264627457,
0.1548045426607132,
0.20433688163757324,
-0.14933842420578003,
-0.7916778922080994,
0.9464618563652039,
-0.539483904838562,
-0.9314110279083252,
-0.01514352485537529,
-0.9437267780303955,
-0.8784298300743103,
-0.17028319835662842,
0.030706629157066345,
0.2402167022228241,
-0.0825798511505127,
0.27419814467430115,
0.7290436625480652,
-0.33829349279403687,
0.15513311326503754,
0.7270805835723877,
-0.1578180491924286,
-0.43794965744018555,
1.06143057346344,
0.1963229924440384,
0.3764384686946869,
0.366493821144104,
0.3830663561820984,
-0.6305454969406128,
-0.6421381831169128,
-0.16896478831768036,
0.5306921005249023,
-0.9092997908592224,
-0.17754243314266205,
-0.5954204201698303,
-0.31428420543670654,
-0.4620703458786011,
0.07627446204423904,
-0.23975184559822083,
0.018440289422869682,
-0.1833629161119461,
0.17260605096817017,
0.19153422117233276,
0.7210139036178589,
0.006351133342832327,
0.0771327093243599,
-1.247222900390625,
0.16639479994773865,
0.26721635460853577,
0.2208143025636673,
0.0772797167301178,
-0.6161110401153564,
-0.25568780303001404,
0.16558490693569183,
0.0895114317536354,
-0.8784127235412598,
0.21921034157276154,
0.06052813306450844,
0.9407190680503845,
0.47306856513023376,
-0.008511428721249104,
0.8251193165779114,
-0.46578413248062134,
0.7604675889015198,
0.09169916808605194,
-0.8782163858413696,
0.25226306915283203,
-0.6046445965766907,
0.5084068179130554,
0.6766307353973389,
0.596373438835144,
-0.4147375524044037,
-0.9286376237869263,
-0.6123019456863403,
-0.8227636218070984,
0.5323519706726074,
-0.05131518095731735,
0.12997698783874512,
0.3077327609062195,
0.2984727621078491,
0.1460695117712021,
0.15207554399967194,
-0.4349852204322815,
0.008307363837957382,
0.5334685444831848,
-0.40164726972579956,
-0.33526137471199036,
-0.25885844230651855,
-0.37454459071159363,
-0.48258569836616516,
0.5896106362342834,
0.2731834352016449,
-0.1420801877975464,
-0.39906299114227295,
-0.18257096409797668,
0.07495766133069992,
0.005388624966144562,
0.4821205139160156,
0.9586530923843384,
0.10302124172449112,
0.25419944524765015,
0.6356600522994995,
0.15638680756092072,
0.03495229035615921,
-0.0571579784154892,
0.022074218839406967,
-0.2812216281890869,
0.459066241979599,
0.4864977300167084,
0.6242079138755798,
-0.8800213932991028,
0.194337859749794,
0.24407559633255005,
-0.2265389859676361,
-0.21930882334709167,
0.06315522640943527,
0.45752716064453125,
0.6065669655799866,
0.17219185829162598,
-0.43604373931884766,
-0.04230566695332527,
-0.7701004147529602,
0.20802511274814606,
0.7290655374526978,
-0.09685200452804565,
-0.26662421226501465,
0.23963099718093872,
0.1978544145822525,
-0.014597994275391102,
0.42457374930381775,
0.06017521396279335,
-0.5550202131271362,
0.2861361801624298,
0.58937668800354,
0.5325559973716736,
-0.2711091935634613,
0.002348140813410282,
0.10692458599805832,
0.2732280492782593,
-0.22034311294555664,
-0.0027352317702025175,
-0.14053429663181305,
-0.7586849927902222,
-0.3398891091346741,
-0.6802484393119812,
-0.5036219954490662,
0.38679516315460205,
-0.38838738203048706,
0.44449853897094727,
-0.32847389578819275,
0.22112658619880676,
-0.16982772946357727,
-0.3034171760082245,
-0.7203943133354187,
-0.18333818018436432,
0.18742147088050842,
0.8934571146965027,
-1.0775187015533447,
1.0170060396194458,
0.5208548307418823,
-0.5160859227180481,
-0.7020670771598816,
0.3126676082611084,
0.04005485028028488,
-1.0711126327514648,
0.7100402116775513,
-0.27366891503334045,
0.0035349486861377954,
-0.007332277484238148,
-0.024674192070961,
-1.0594788789749146,
0.9980491995811462,
0.5754539966583252,
-0.4122686982154846,
-0.25518783926963806,
0.4935055375099182,
0.5669892430305481,
-0.1948140263557434,
-0.06450235098600388,
1.0067781209945679,
0.604535698890686,
0.34519335627555847,
-1.0223443508148193,
0.23662972450256348,
0.1464884877204895,
0.031026631593704224,
0.5221985578536987,
-0.5574269890785217,
0.7183132171630859,
0.09778756648302078,
-0.21697436273097992,
-0.09071342647075653,
0.7111541032791138,
0.04327239841222763,
0.03129652142524719,
0.2729434072971344,
0.6377727389335632,
0.5319820642471313,
0.1963702291250229,
0.7604283094406128,
-0.66983562707901,
0.08123978227376938,
1.1759088039398193,
-0.472873330116272,
0.8374097943305969,
0.7239210605621338,
-0.31782516837120056,
0.4580599069595337,
0.37511298060417175,
0.11237247288227081,
0.4206526577472687,
0.10487522929906845,
-0.6085816621780396,
-0.2457372546195984,
-0.1628885567188263,
-0.48174768686294556,
0.5319615602493286,
0.47481203079223633,
-0.25119203329086304,
-0.5465533137321472,
0.22136512398719788,
-0.264405220746994,
-0.08657533675432205,
-0.12552274763584137,
1.005205750465393,
0.07054027915000916,
-0.7955189943313599,
0.43246182799339294,
-0.0634763091802597,
0.46578192710876465,
-0.81707763671875,
0.0730394721031189,
-0.19065845012664795,
0.1580265611410141,
-0.06498047709465027,
-0.9914408922195435,
0.5389215350151062,
-0.20974749326705933,
0.1948268562555313,
-0.20831739902496338,
0.6629811525344849,
-0.9435782432556152,
-0.3692099452018738,
0.23210370540618896,
0.6197806596755981,
-0.15087080001831055,
-0.08640746772289276,
-0.28229522705078125,
0.1747523844242096,
0.010736577212810516,
0.15995214879512787,
0.8207723498344421,
0.4765058755874634,
0.3342241644859314,
0.7243922352790833,
0.5928640961647034,
0.01499070692807436,
-0.16751578450202942,
-0.12551072239875793,
1.0631951093673706,
-0.5135289430618286,
-0.3913888931274414,
-1.0280542373657227,
0.5662091970443726,
0.11353915184736252,
-0.08270100504159927,
1.1097309589385986,
0.4813631474971771,
0.7235872745513916,
0.02889682725071907,
0.7742917537689209,
0.24652531743049622,
0.27788135409355164,
-0.7141600251197815,
0.7213106751441956,
-0.4840793311595917,
0.3900969922542572,
-0.1449888050556183,
-0.8873445391654968,
0.0830521509051323,
-0.017233267426490784,
-0.5182214975357056,
-0.17859235405921936,
0.7330741286277771,
0.6123900413513184,
-0.051103852689266205,
-0.00827579665929079,
0.3092610836029053,
-0.00255177216604352,
0.14327684044837952,
0.8107278943061829,
1.1425502300262451,
-0.08179928362369537,
0.6593210101127625,
-0.36635634303092957,
-0.2318722903728485,
0.16410624980926514,
-0.6225038170814514,
-0.9089447259902954,
-0.9731987714767456,
-0.07026772946119308,
-0.24815885722637177,
-0.11476506292819977,
0.792265772819519,
0.20621216297149658,
-0.6245667338371277,
-0.47026678919792175,
-0.11905033886432648,
0.17279039323329926,
0.23617298901081085,
-0.17203304171562195,
0.14078646898269653,
-0.3801926076412201,
-0.6795636415481567,
0.6694192290306091,
0.22503453493118286,
0.17502979934215546,
-0.6675933599472046,
-0.09056039154529572,
-0.13461244106292725,
0.18387503921985626,
0.4675810933113098,
0.36126744747161865,
-0.7555456757545471,
-0.16997669637203217,
-0.22705619037151337,
0.12215971201658249,
-0.25378596782684326,
1.000177025794983,
-0.8141418695449829,
0.2942776679992676,
0.7863902449607849,
0.8242797255516052,
0.25920796394348145,
0.005247257649898529,
1.0814077854156494,
-0.6273372173309326,
0.10444140434265137,
0.19470098614692688,
0.583979070186615,
0.19804103672504425,
-0.1577165275812149,
-0.07857036590576172,
-0.010601409710943699,
-0.3522639274597168,
-1.0189896821975708,
0.2302277535200119,
-0.5402913093566895,
-0.341283917427063,
1.62228262424469,
-0.01435875240713358,
0.13090598583221436,
-0.2377239465713501,
0.03223230317234993,
0.10191124677658081,
-0.09483028948307037,
0.7440233826637268,
0.9463996291160583,
-0.3028305768966675,
-0.1243940219283104,
-0.36643558740615845,
0.5866202116012573,
0.1470130831003189,
-1.056900143623352,
0.12285324186086655,
0.5182551145553589,
0.31979551911354065,
0.059839390218257904,
0.3131808638572693,
0.0621827132999897,
-0.17709362506866455,
0.007735712919384241,
-0.4024006128311157,
-0.011089812032878399,
-0.3386099934577942,
-0.4132014811038971,
0.29159820079803467,
0.06410185247659683,
0.1296404004096985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18991v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18991v1
|
EasyAnimate: A High-Performance Long Video Generation Method based on Transformer Architecture
| 2024-05-29T11:11:07 | 2024-05-29T11:11:07 |
Jiaqi Xu, Xinyi Zou, Kunzhe Huang, Yunkuo Chen, Bo Liu, MengLi Cheng, Xing Shi, Jun Huang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
This paper presents EasyAnimate, an advanced method for video generation that
leverages the power of transformer architecture for high-performance outcomes.
We have expanded the DiT framework originally designed for 2D image synthesis
to accommodate the complexities of 3D video generation by incorporating a
motion module block. It is used to capture temporal dynamics, thereby ensuring
the production of consistent frames and seamless motion transitions. The motion
module can be adapted to various DiT baseline methods to generate video with
different styles. It can also generate videos with different frame rates and
resolutions during both training and inference phases, suitable for both images
and videos. Moreover, we introduce slice VAE, a novel approach to condense the
temporal axis, facilitating the generation of long duration videos. Currently,
EasyAnimate exhibits the proficiency to generate videos with 144 frames. We
provide a holistic ecosystem for video production based on DiT, encompassing
aspects such as data pre-processing, VAE training, DiT models training (both
the baseline model and LoRA model), and end-to-end video inference. Code is
available at: https://github.com/aigc-apps/EasyAnimate. We are continuously
working to enhance the performance of our method.
|
[
-0.38933321833610535,
-0.8087442517280579,
0.3298867642879486,
0.3539615571498871,
-0.33099275827407837,
-0.18809635937213898,
-0.042520921677351,
0.12798598408699036,
0.1479191929101944,
0.19496838748455048,
-0.9240783452987671,
-0.23272939026355743,
-0.6198013424873352,
-0.10098627954721451,
-0.5408614277839661,
0.7847201228141785,
-0.22624947130680084,
-0.2204774171113968,
0.04811708629131317,
-0.11778358370065689,
-0.37606674432754517,
-0.05231200531125069,
-0.43233123421669006,
-0.27159473299980164,
0.11371834576129913,
0.42621901631355286,
0.5516627430915833,
1.2491642236709595,
0.7124546766281128,
0.3764403760433197,
0.06795893609523773,
0.2756645083427429,
-0.23277786374092102,
0.14569035172462463,
0.057206444442272186,
-0.17501388490200043,
-0.8425167798995972,
-0.4204324781894684,
0.26742878556251526,
0.26962167024612427,
-0.3075583279132843,
0.5327349901199341,
-0.003673126455396414,
0.8308889865875244,
-0.49156591296195984,
0.12473331391811371,
-0.41517695784568787,
0.2681986391544342,
-0.4193705916404724,
0.038352951407432556,
0.09187157452106476,
-0.21625752747058868,
-0.3743940591812134,
-0.5757843852043152,
0.3332574963569641,
-0.3298690915107727,
0.4252530634403229,
0.9607405066490173,
-0.5504058599472046,
-0.07603771239519119,
-1.1805311441421509,
0.12538841366767883,
-0.32647383213043213,
0.18601636588573456,
-0.05661797523498535,
0.9736146330833435,
-0.06489399820566177,
-0.9974277019500732,
-0.522186815738678,
0.1879105418920517,
0.26407328248023987,
0.3059031069278717,
-0.16684597730636597,
0.2598174810409546,
0.7648289203643799,
0.4037768542766571,
-0.5760968923568726,
-0.10733197629451752,
-0.11411009728908539,
0.2455337792634964,
0.5624949336051941,
0.2632739543914795,
0.1388445794582367,
-0.8548611402511597,
-0.6651623249053955,
-0.24036385118961334,
-0.5060882568359375,
0.23429065942764282,
0.5584798455238342,
-0.29396289587020874,
-0.10064341872930527,
0.49161455035209656,
-0.38314011693000793,
0.10643257945775986,
0.2671831250190735,
-0.16337135434150696,
0.01836738921701908,
-0.3226572275161743,
-0.42328470945358276,
0.22355039417743683,
0.5686452984809875,
0.47165724635124207,
-0.3466290533542633,
0.5399678945541382,
0.02103905752301216,
0.06329187005758286,
-0.02765524759888649,
-1.3230314254760742,
-0.4117216467857361,
0.10689429193735123,
-0.32265785336494446,
0.11283110082149506,
-0.008836844936013222,
-1.1044902801513672,
0.19102968275547028,
-0.3635265827178955,
0.5950736999511719,
-0.4031442105770111,
-0.4465242028236389,
0.1732877790927887,
-0.04695514589548111,
0.3894799053668976,
0.401809424161911,
-0.5525332689285278,
0.3485580086708069,
0.4439435601234436,
0.5136010646820068,
-0.33422625064849854,
-0.3453211784362793,
-0.6387089490890503,
0.6589260101318359,
-0.10349687933921814,
0.5935443639755249,
0.6884461641311646,
-0.04880419000983238,
0.1075640618801117,
0.12204799056053162,
0.4780559539794922,
-0.5196011662483215,
0.3325185179710388,
-0.22052760422229767,
-0.10869333148002625,
0.5254825353622437,
-0.24247609078884125,
-0.31682395935058594,
0.33253538608551025,
-0.8062921166419983,
0.923855721950531,
-0.16488675773143768,
-0.3372536301612854,
0.248543381690979,
-0.8441375494003296,
-0.528714120388031,
0.13185466825962067,
-0.14280441403388977,
-0.6586771607398987,
-0.1241602972149849,
-0.026251861825585365,
0.3962734341621399,
-0.1308383047580719,
0.5603154301643372,
0.2671250104904175,
-0.10766346007585526,
-0.12897157669067383,
-1.0418974161148071,
0.2807686924934387,
0.3052399158477783,
-0.7916627526283264,
-0.020908214151859283,
-1.1982595920562744,
-0.07698573172092438,
0.047621261328458786,
-0.13162057101726532,
0.20219403505325317,
-0.055122435092926025,
-0.1368417739868164,
0.23202814161777496,
0.04779177904129028,
-0.4482405483722687,
-0.010142505168914795,
-0.05676138028502464,
0.4471057057380676,
0.651609480381012,
-0.1647336483001709,
0.17268086969852448,
-0.025775140151381493,
0.5281282067298889,
-0.028847938403487206,
0.3842092454433441,
-0.6960796117782593,
-0.1104326918721199,
-0.6569421291351318,
-0.41493239998817444,
-0.15510934591293335,
0.22427032887935638,
-0.9381662011146545,
0.1539369821548462,
-0.6603707075119019,
-0.4814152419567108,
-0.11552809178829193,
0.43337327241897583,
0.18432427942752838,
0.000830260687507689,
0.36547964811325073,
-0.20343133807182312,
-0.49717453122138977,
-0.8680528402328491,
0.26456496119499207,
0.0656902939081192,
-0.21921561658382416,
0.055323224514722824,
0.46679675579071045,
0.028530912473797798,
0.8003425002098083,
-0.8047360181808472,
-0.03584985435009003,
-0.09305725991725922,
0.17683933675289154,
0.6744529008865356,
0.28870195150375366,
0.5494152903556824,
-0.9590034484863281,
-0.5096858739852905,
-0.17885349690914154,
-0.6125410795211792,
0.4803091585636139,
-0.03660322725772858,
-0.23727703094482422,
-0.2910081446170807,
0.5936968922615051,
-1.1816151142120361,
0.5979596972465515,
0.3914225995540619,
0.1227724701166153,
0.2762402892112732,
-0.22217682003974915,
0.3854295313358307,
-1.312224268913269,
0.023187527433037758,
-0.32843318581581116,
-0.6791958808898926,
-0.3834924101829529,
0.13529010117053986,
-0.32827630639076233,
-0.6593601107597351,
-1.3136954307556152,
0.09835290908813477,
-0.17354106903076172,
0.15969069302082062,
-0.30212923884391785,
-0.2380252629518509,
-0.07615971565246582,
0.9376683831214905,
-0.13320256769657135,
0.3234770894050598,
0.42060038447380066,
-0.9875401258468628,
0.8665292263031006,
0.20576979219913483,
-0.49212855100631714,
0.8372644782066345,
-0.6268895864486694,
-0.1364573836326599,
-0.19076621532440186,
0.26176372170448303,
-0.873892068862915,
-0.9873401522636414,
-0.004688989836722612,
-0.25259366631507874,
0.09787164628505707,
-0.22951552271842957,
-0.18055137991905212,
-0.5015111565589905,
-0.5265437960624695,
0.8040820360183716,
0.5943573117256165,
-0.7245814800262451,
0.6660869121551514,
-0.02394861914217472,
-0.10301844030618668,
-0.0481828898191452,
-0.9890075922012329,
0.0672743171453476,
-0.5465038418769836,
-0.7537578344345093,
0.7088731527328491,
-0.37770161032676697,
0.09428522735834122,
-0.1274254024028778,
-0.01065844390541315,
-0.11990171670913696,
-0.22056591510772705,
0.43520525097846985,
0.004349493887275457,
-0.357907235622406,
-0.3807304799556732,
0.28691238164901733,
-0.27996277809143066,
0.014059918001294136,
0.17137254774570465,
0.36126697063446045,
0.1359350085258484,
-0.4922603368759155,
-0.6427846550941467,
0.6300577521324158,
0.8270285725593567,
0.2108316421508789,
-0.1153322383761406,
0.8772871494293213,
-0.570223867893219,
-0.24953825771808624,
-0.354897141456604,
0.07129210978746414,
-0.5475574135780334,
0.7439755201339722,
-0.25597208738327026,
-0.18329688906669617,
0.173582524061203,
-0.4707275331020355,
-0.028407122939825058,
0.6198551654815674,
0.710431694984436,
-0.3974268138408661,
1.0255547761917114,
0.19283783435821533,
0.6134235858917236,
0.7153996825218201,
-0.8344681859016418,
-0.0475078821182251,
-0.4865308403968811,
-0.06485393643379211,
-0.037076979875564575,
-0.4196259081363678,
-0.6955543160438538,
-0.4731692671775818,
0.6498266458511353,
0.21889427304267883,
-0.7148981094360352,
0.5516188740730286,
-0.40425917506217957,
0.4990551471710205,
0.26829421520233154,
0.04368189722299576,
0.3781813979148865,
0.04598703607916832,
0.6596173644065857,
-0.09646174311637878,
-0.7971308827400208,
-0.18288838863372803,
0.6456394791603088,
0.20660114288330078,
0.7645266652107239,
0.51891028881073,
0.42300814390182495,
0.4046097695827484,
-0.15196584165096283,
-0.663101315498352,
0.795318067073822,
-0.3134106993675232,
-0.5852906107902527,
-0.1517794132232666,
-0.20238153636455536,
-0.6956011652946472,
-0.4787699282169342,
0.07977134734392166,
-0.16371898353099823,
-0.29005303978919983,
0.20655949413776398,
-0.640981137752533,
0.41298800706863403,
-0.43622711300849915,
0.5898942351341248,
-0.5549262166023254,
-0.8026873469352722,
-0.06016121059656143,
-0.758732795715332,
0.46949777007102966,
0.1832725554704666,
0.05260927230119705,
0.08311526477336884,
0.21714548766613007,
0.5059584379196167,
-0.6011304259300232,
0.4542264938354492,
-0.0928213894367218,
0.19026115536689758,
1.0348786115646362,
0.22490251064300537,
0.31930607557296753,
0.5040931701660156,
0.1989554464817047,
-0.015963641926646233,
-0.2996949851512909,
-0.2309146523475647,
-0.5405740141868591,
0.471212774515152,
-0.4536914825439453,
-0.5953378081321716,
0.035446543246507645,
-0.09535735845565796,
0.44223061203956604,
0.23654817044734955,
0.5364494919776917,
0.41632434725761414,
-0.2485007643699646,
0.46678537130355835,
0.4377114772796631,
0.06239135190844536,
1.118090033531189,
-0.24028059840202332,
-0.25949743390083313,
-0.7771523594856262,
0.758588433265686,
-0.04671695828437805,
0.3087303042411804,
0.2652412950992584,
-0.056715741753578186,
0.08434697985649109,
-0.08155648410320282,
-0.8665934205055237,
-0.4618555009365082,
-0.309484601020813,
-0.8174389600753784,
-0.09770315885543823,
-0.5210532546043396,
-0.03565669432282448,
-0.07308631390333176,
-1.0254915952682495,
-0.2656797766685486,
0.14589522778987885,
-0.3068495988845825,
0.5995123386383057,
0.5536948442459106,
-0.13695009052753448,
0.6187968850135803,
-0.6881715059280396,
0.8717613816261292,
1.0580801963806152,
0.22379249334335327,
-0.15614163875579834,
0.04847385361790657,
-0.2890067398548126,
-0.05492379888892174,
-0.9189110398292542,
-0.45119595527648926,
0.05178896710276604,
0.4793446958065033,
0.2857779860496521,
0.15312057733535767,
-0.46101367473602295,
0.9058758616447449,
-0.5878806710243225,
1.1768475770950317,
0.6649426817893982,
-0.7514946460723877,
0.6496315002441406,
-0.46248602867126465,
0.39140358567237854,
0.4819225072860718,
0.34080979228019714,
-0.04713474214076996,
0.34441617131233215,
-0.482494056224823,
-1.0776041746139526,
0.4563787579536438,
0.6969853043556213,
0.23922455310821533,
0.0266985222697258,
0.40470021963119507,
0.39134281873703003,
0.2630794048309326,
-0.701145589351654,
-0.26000598073005676,
-0.7594913244247437,
-0.03955360874533653,
0.26552310585975647,
0.1411961168050766,
0.08317124843597412,
-0.21328891813755035,
0.3795016407966614,
-0.26260364055633545,
0.4081994593143463,
0.3737907409667969,
-0.12016411870718002,
-0.13121812045574188,
0.062364112585783005,
0.29016298055648804,
0.24081771075725555,
-0.20937581360340118,
-0.07438585162162781,
0.18534627556800842,
-0.3273566663265228,
0.5323139429092407,
-0.1437535583972931,
-0.2493218034505844,
0.29108238220214844,
0.08696216344833374,
0.8717001080513,
0.10532557964324951,
-0.2936386466026306,
0.8401671648025513,
0.08053214848041534,
-0.36352524161338806,
-0.6266338229179382,
0.12371034920215607,
-0.08999719470739365,
0.3141925036907196,
0.2902856767177582,
0.25506535172462463,
0.21975214779376984,
-0.6597598791122437,
0.45588231086730957,
-0.2010042369365692,
-0.06080140173435211,
-0.5559859275817871,
1.1038062572479248,
0.46934056282043457,
-0.766272783279419,
0.4913336932659149,
-0.3193546235561371,
-0.09047915041446686,
0.8686463236808777,
0.28695666790008545,
0.9197275638580322,
-0.2902122437953949,
0.15165792405605316,
0.5863988399505615,
-0.1858396977186203,
-0.3405723571777344,
0.04646005854010582,
-0.2884516716003418,
-0.07088814675807953,
-0.8167318105697632,
-0.4794626235961914,
-0.2625715136528015,
0.1474597305059433,
-0.7786904573440552,
0.8860977292060852,
-0.12330549955368042,
-0.15647460520267487,
-0.46642059087753296,
-0.3510908782482147,
-0.9590435028076172,
0.3447480797767639,
0.44662195444107056,
0.9246710538864136,
-0.41234511137008667,
0.5597248673439026,
0.3089335262775421,
-0.2665623724460602,
-0.5519881844520569,
-0.2732642889022827,
-0.02737056091427803,
-0.2338516116142273,
0.4667102098464966,
0.29822295904159546,
-0.3790881931781769,
-0.040474727749824524,
-0.35063692927360535,
-0.4856964647769928,
1.5017659664154053,
0.5511074066162109,
-0.6819855570793152,
-0.4059143364429474,
0.4722384810447693,
0.4884064793586731,
-0.3195256292819977,
0.26312121748924255,
0.4263400137424469,
0.3253319263458252,
0.2847982943058014,
-0.3320743441581726,
-0.5104042291641235,
-0.20205172896385193,
0.10132401436567307,
0.2616620361804962,
-0.9672435522079468,
0.5270954966545105,
0.00429628137499094,
-0.01691395789384842,
0.4927043318748474,
0.7639711499214172,
0.022046757861971855,
0.6977277398109436,
0.5176568627357483,
0.5493651628494263,
0.01682158373296261,
0.019931070506572723,
0.7054858207702637,
-0.3310125172138214,
0.3438696265220642,
1.1609996557235718,
0.09406846016645432,
0.3893496096134186,
0.6060636043548584,
-0.14322294294834137,
0.44729530811309814,
0.3414437174797058,
0.11007436364889145,
0.6559461951255798,
-0.03522632271051407,
0.03767909109592438,
-0.30201035737991333,
-0.009119315072894096,
-0.3067927062511444,
0.9779344201087952,
0.07916714251041412,
-0.009409300051629543,
-0.2364087700843811,
0.39253097772598267,
-0.1353459656238556,
0.057233646512031555,
-0.6808130741119385,
0.5440349578857422,
-0.08888223767280579,
-0.5421001315116882,
0.07369474321603775,
-0.16103532910346985,
0.7238801717758179,
-0.7069849371910095,
-0.25344574451446533,
-0.3513040542602539,
0.11123945564031601,
-0.29290780425071716,
-0.7057871222496033,
0.4714953601360321,
0.33416083455085754,
0.03086080215871334,
-0.3451533317565918,
0.4274682104587555,
-0.4678172469139099,
-0.5110566020011902,
0.014768999069929123,
0.5956506729125977,
0.05662545934319496,
-0.012425195425748825,
-0.3667401969432831,
-0.3199359178543091,
-0.054615117609500885,
-0.6722221970558167,
0.10206355154514313,
0.4990634620189667,
0.15704306960105896,
0.26853346824645996,
0.3400786519050598,
-0.22340774536132812,
0.06953859329223633,
-0.2728244662284851,
0.632534384727478,
-0.6751167178153992,
-0.2334771603345871,
-0.9855244755744934,
0.8559677600860596,
-0.06352229416370392,
-0.35864582657814026,
0.2867383658885956,
0.7089125514030457,
0.6758594512939453,
-0.2626214027404785,
0.3811884820461273,
-0.2748994827270508,
0.016628453508019447,
-0.7192153930664062,
0.33733269572257996,
-0.6226863265037537,
-0.14158421754837036,
-0.18472768366336823,
-1.377640962600708,
-0.19449596107006073,
0.19227266311645508,
0.29265332221984863,
-0.2335960865020752,
0.5890515446662903,
0.5104628801345825,
-0.6842946410179138,
-0.2578202784061432,
0.4122137129306793,
0.1568419337272644,
0.5668514370918274,
0.63027024269104,
0.508238673210144,
-1.0821706056594849,
1.0870883464813232,
-0.3781719505786896,
0.06348581612110138,
0.05180618539452553,
-1.1225125789642334,
-0.3115132749080658,
-0.3326402008533478,
-0.5422750115394592,
0.03717679902911186,
-0.055089958012104034,
0.8635472655296326,
0.7995761632919312,
-0.10151881724596024,
-0.32592493295669556,
-0.12256819009780884,
-0.2803897559642792,
-0.2548610270023346,
-0.2792034447193146,
0.4254150688648224,
0.6165068745613098,
-0.9773313403129578,
0.3464517295360565,
0.4110961854457855,
-0.04236002266407013,
-0.3472273051738739,
-0.10082635283470154,
0.03894399106502533,
0.005996759049594402,
0.8426468968391418,
0.24587643146514893,
0.008898074738681316,
-0.364774227142334,
-0.053112056106328964,
0.018664725124835968,
0.5862695574760437,
0.8654592037200928,
-0.45241138339042664,
0.1549828052520752,
0.5095732808113098,
0.3185827434062958,
1.0199154615402222,
-0.043508611619472504,
0.4200114607810974,
-0.5808907151222229,
0.2725926339626312,
0.001060073496773839,
0.4074014723300934,
0.2792612910270691,
-0.21117590367794037,
0.5401314496994019,
0.06237826868891716,
-0.4548850953578949,
-0.5823007225990295,
0.5840626358985901,
-1.173437237739563,
0.15165553987026215,
0.8433846235275269,
-0.1835579127073288,
-0.5797098875045776,
0.4846345782279968,
-0.20931054651737213,
0.7245995998382568,
0.03239184245467186,
0.7025759220123291,
0.1101267859339714,
-0.29541149735450745,
0.1915179193019867,
-0.5859718322753906,
0.38525161147117615,
0.17244824767112732,
-0.816014289855957,
-0.1026035025715828,
0.16320161521434784,
0.36302313208580017,
0.3221636712551117,
0.14953725039958954,
-0.229746013879776,
0.7455953359603882,
0.08242697268724442,
0.22034217417240143,
-0.4547744393348694,
-0.48251089453697205,
-0.1657462865114212,
0.500648558139801,
-0.43399596214294434,
-0.36928173899650574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18974v1
|
Encoding Hierarchical Schema via Concept Flow for Multifaceted Ideology Detection
| 2024-05-29T10:37:28 | 2024-05-29T10:37:28 |
Songtao Liu, Bang Wang, Wei Xiang, Han Xu, Minghua Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multifaceted ideology detection (MID) aims to detect the ideological leanings
of texts towards multiple facets. Previous studies on ideology detection mainly
focus on one generic facet and ignore label semantics and explanatory
descriptions of ideologies, which are a kind of instructive information and
reveal the specific concepts of ideologies. In this paper, we develop a novel
concept semantics-enhanced framework for the MID task. Specifically, we propose
a bidirectional iterative concept flow (BICo) method to encode multifaceted
ideologies. BICo enables the concepts to flow across levels of the schema tree
and enriches concept representations with multi-granularity semantics.
Furthermore, we explore concept attentive matching and concept-guided
contrastive learning strategies to guide the model to capture ideology features
with the learned concept semantics. Extensive experiments on the benchmark
dataset show that our approach achieves state-of-the-art performance in MID,
including in the cross-topic scenario.
|
[
-0.2945146858692169,
-0.44991955161094666,
0.39381855726242065,
-0.133663147687912,
-0.776965856552124,
0.6791878938674927,
-0.15678997337818146,
-0.08211739361286163,
0.28209707140922546,
0.5136797428131104,
-0.7821250557899475,
-0.9434470534324646,
-0.7439205646514893,
-0.09877342730760574,
-0.3914133608341217,
1.24506676197052,
0.1884307563304901,
-0.1260421872138977,
-0.17223970592021942,
-0.07273701578378677,
0.0777614489197731,
-0.27057909965515137,
-0.44526949524879456,
-0.35477739572525024,
0.3800104856491089,
0.7041212320327759,
0.5729513764381409,
0.6039541959762573,
0.18712641298770905,
0.2936193645000458,
-0.12456765025854111,
0.13149593770503998,
-0.24257558584213257,
0.25041988492012024,
-0.43452703952789307,
-0.31365352869033813,
-0.2871815860271454,
0.1188448816537857,
0.6166084408760071,
0.6362683176994324,
-0.36915889382362366,
0.015968384221196175,
0.27538248896598816,
0.5850996971130371,
-0.8396943211555481,
0.3145524859428406,
-1.0841087102890015,
-0.36951273679733276,
-0.6449768543243408,
-0.15563419461250305,
-0.3221311569213867,
0.2279064953327179,
-0.019730636849999428,
-0.5684588551521301,
0.09276986122131348,
0.2149743139743805,
1.0374339818954468,
0.316357284784317,
-0.28395408391952515,
-0.8705300092697144,
-0.5298467874526978,
0.5487643480300903,
-0.5128997564315796,
0.28717005252838135,
0.03506927192211151,
0.12306230515241623,
0.23738476634025574,
-0.6894754767417908,
-1.0556535720825195,
0.14743110537528992,
-0.1060558333992958,
0.3251383900642395,
-0.05764324590563774,
0.12660685181617737,
-0.0733347162604332,
0.20855915546417236,
-0.2674103379249573,
0.021518785506486893,
-0.03602299466729164,
-0.14982390403747559,
0.3198377788066864,
0.09347914159297943,
-0.17479641735553741,
-0.7744725346565247,
-0.6984190344810486,
-0.08598991483449936,
-0.45889243483543396,
0.04006499797105789,
0.6414117813110352,
0.22655895352363586,
-0.24500587582588196,
0.3694518506526947,
-0.353842169046402,
0.26060566306114197,
0.26122722029685974,
-0.1890179067850113,
0.32498669624328613,
-0.84039306640625,
0.0886271521449089,
0.04936843365430832,
0.5147398114204407,
0.007872493006289005,
0.11591645330190659,
0.011975171975791454,
-0.0056951455771923065,
0.2997949421405792,
0.12681014835834503,
-0.9150051474571228,
-0.2008892446756363,
0.35229483246803284,
-0.41202154755592346,
-0.3417426645755768,
-0.052975717931985855,
-0.7957830429077148,
-0.29914987087249756,
-0.22939614951610565,
-0.051381755620241165,
-0.6423149704933167,
-0.3089250326156616,
0.09598149359226227,
-0.33476054668426514,
0.49767211079597473,
0.2696622610092163,
-0.5406011343002319,
-0.04869518056511879,
0.8700940012931824,
0.8523610830307007,
0.11799129843711853,
-0.0558246485888958,
-0.3108540177345276,
0.6842775940895081,
-0.24108938872814178,
1.270721197128296,
-0.9377607703208923,
-0.1430269479751587,
0.00026501622051000595,
-0.27890074253082275,
0.02364223636686802,
-0.3600485920906067,
0.6409348249435425,
-0.23781877756118774,
0.16444943845272064,
-0.10012267529964447,
-0.4498335123062134,
0.1355055421590805,
0.29060471057891846,
-0.3073033392429352,
0.8997290730476379,
-0.030573643743991852,
-1.2354556322097778,
0.41726556420326233,
-0.7557748556137085,
-0.37030842900276184,
0.26924121379852295,
-0.3436063826084137,
-0.35625749826431274,
-0.17223870754241943,
0.05252398923039436,
0.6100012063980103,
-0.28672847151756287,
0.06849557906389236,
-0.452017605304718,
-0.2443433552980423,
-0.10288966447114944,
-0.17858313024044037,
0.7351523637771606,
0.16558614373207092,
-0.05614401027560234,
0.3062048554420471,
-0.7531213164329529,
-0.2736811339855194,
-0.154399111866951,
0.10968321561813354,
-0.8891305327415466,
0.31094440817832947,
-0.13351599872112274,
0.4121173620223999,
0.08026695251464844,
-0.6732261180877686,
0.21330687403678894,
-0.2588122487068176,
0.21955329179763794,
0.919364869594574,
-0.03079475834965706,
0.47838956117630005,
-0.020187128335237503,
-0.035954009741544724,
0.5857524275779724,
-0.10547952353954315,
-0.03769402951002121,
-0.294315367937088,
-0.8404916524887085,
-0.7573932409286499,
0.16667130589485168,
0.7600815296173096,
-1.5292195081710815,
0.6458668112754822,
-0.3967683017253876,
-0.3637799918651581,
-0.6221185922622681,
0.05360352620482445,
0.2782842218875885,
0.3597341775894165,
0.2992246150970459,
-0.0793919786810875,
-0.3080476224422455,
-1.158869743347168,
-0.2878984808921814,
-0.3454208970069885,
-0.06852947175502777,
0.03378390893340111,
0.9279540181159973,
-0.20621444284915924,
0.528260350227356,
-0.4553821086883545,
-0.33940282464027405,
-0.14361736178398132,
0.6694104075431824,
-0.02960282377898693,
0.25614219903945923,
0.2734501361846924,
-0.8446066379547119,
-0.47582340240478516,
0.1615573763847351,
-0.43044015765190125,
-0.08142600208520889,
-0.18125224113464355,
-0.4940190613269806,
-0.07716115564107895,
0.4749583303928375,
-0.5372719764709473,
0.4027811586856842,
0.15951967239379883,
-0.5309119820594788,
0.239259734749794,
0.15777090191841125,
-0.02073126845061779,
-1.5912331342697144,
-0.02849934622645378,
-0.06317117065191269,
-0.022489888593554497,
-0.5683518648147583,
0.0009532307740300894,
0.09521830081939697,
0.19917087256908417,
-0.30232349038124084,
0.13297568261623383,
-0.3492797017097473,
0.12028778344392776,
-0.25679251551628113,
0.16553370654582977,
-0.002158182905986905,
0.3435271978378296,
0.2857998013496399,
0.5769768953323364,
0.5850698947906494,
-0.22757211327552795,
0.20322611927986145,
0.13516348600387573,
-0.10296972095966339,
1.4193336963653564,
-0.26050788164138794,
0.3238268196582794,
-0.5139247179031372,
0.464690238237381,
-0.9615124464035034,
0.024224374443292618,
0.5258956551551819,
-0.21958133578300476,
0.434352844953537,
-0.22385425865650177,
-0.6105531454086304,
-0.13061034679412842,
-0.5663530230522156,
-0.016640905290842056,
0.04540354013442993,
-0.20072871446609497,
0.8009849190711975,
0.24311353266239166,
-0.10700380802154541,
-0.9744980931282043,
-0.06874558329582214,
0.014996550045907497,
-0.29446226358413696,
-0.5020648837089539,
0.8223087787628174,
0.07773445546627045,
-0.1361713409423828,
0.19792041182518005,
-0.15012986958026886,
0.017736604437232018,
-0.2749762535095215,
0.13902238011360168,
0.4016956686973572,
0.12096161395311356,
0.14887671172618866,
0.47319483757019043,
-0.1917695850133896,
-0.007764718029648066,
-0.32366517186164856,
0.5016716122627258,
-0.15951471030712128,
-0.22402529418468475,
-0.4181976616382599,
0.8678654432296753,
0.6362259387969971,
-0.33892372250556946,
0.7074810862541199,
0.8092753291130066,
-0.5102015137672424,
-0.580152153968811,
-0.14912298321723938,
0.015437480993568897,
-0.4594971835613251,
0.4618282914161682,
-0.514596700668335,
-0.31622883677482605,
0.5806335806846619,
-0.5018760561943054,
0.014148864895105362,
0.43248024582862854,
0.7055371403694153,
-0.47096070647239685,
0.6940077543258667,
0.5318465828895569,
0.31698858737945557,
0.4300377666950226,
-0.7583935856819153,
0.29108038544654846,
-1.0257885456085205,
-0.5014532804489136,
-0.7679142355918884,
-0.2989322543144226,
-0.5368585586547852,
-0.7187968492507935,
0.40151530504226685,
-0.034135837107896805,
-0.2132105976343155,
0.017920350655913353,
-0.6217448711395264,
0.24835912883281708,
0.13575288653373718,
0.02970939129590988,
0.3985366225242615,
-0.007336474023759365,
-0.1345389485359192,
-0.03812256455421448,
-0.49067196249961853,
-0.4405212104320526,
0.7970812916755676,
0.12676870822906494,
0.7323012948036194,
-0.10448377579450607,
0.6492771506309509,
0.2839706242084503,
0.4262697100639343,
-0.8592734336853027,
0.42710018157958984,
-0.679160475730896,
-0.385635644197464,
-0.01386598963290453,
-0.27181869745254517,
-0.4968562424182892,
0.46257805824279785,
-0.26969587802886963,
-0.3801743686199188,
0.49461567401885986,
-0.32440274953842163,
-0.15460409224033356,
0.44614967703819275,
-0.2616925835609436,
0.7011149525642395,
0.03148127347230911,
-0.32864677906036377,
-0.6066486239433289,
-0.7898032665252686,
0.15176674723625183,
0.20849686861038208,
0.3157075345516205,
-0.19115576148033142,
-0.3516333997249603,
0.7351165413856506,
-0.012703610584139824,
0.8311325907707214,
-0.2479194849729538,
0.07117567211389542,
0.09416034072637558,
-0.3627563714981079,
0.3200935423374176,
0.013404094614088535,
-0.044998787343502045,
0.4344644844532013,
0.15513744950294495,
-0.5373325347900391,
-0.48333510756492615,
0.514920711517334,
-0.5181389451026917,
-0.5086067914962769,
-0.6348709464073181,
-0.7856405377388,
-0.11750847846269608,
0.0597696416079998,
0.41617658734321594,
0.14328238368034363,
-0.016715185716748238,
0.4159988760948181,
0.6312801837921143,
0.32483768463134766,
0.29780808091163635,
0.18043863773345947,
0.36779269576072693,
-0.13855822384357452,
0.6588819622993469,
0.21088974177837372,
0.2829110026359558,
0.2779293954372406,
0.1341380625963211,
-0.401815265417099,
-0.7426106929779053,
-0.8336786031723022,
0.08727981895208359,
-0.882178008556366,
-0.4369705617427826,
-0.5304192304611206,
-0.250161737203598,
0.00016938163025770336,
-0.1047082394361496,
-0.5247491598129272,
-0.04837779700756073,
0.08570596575737,
0.26721006631851196,
0.10243643820285797,
0.5015053749084473,
0.16041460633277893,
0.3917422592639923,
-0.1601605862379074,
0.4240491986274719,
0.08749540895223618,
0.17826266586780548,
-0.33957988023757935,
-0.41657528281211853,
-0.1626984179019928,
0.05839085951447487,
-0.4146560728549957,
-1.1300595998764038,
-0.13606448471546173,
0.2987552583217621,
0.4540472626686096,
0.7106302380561829,
0.25146186351776123,
0.7002829909324646,
-0.38655224442481995,
0.37047404050827026,
0.051998477429151535,
-1.135061502456665,
0.6144176721572876,
0.09357912093400955,
0.10509610176086426,
0.5315062999725342,
0.6252877116203308,
-0.453226238489151,
-0.41458094120025635,
-0.3897901773452759,
-0.6608201861381531,
0.4489040672779083,
0.26223045587539673,
0.23962759971618652,
0.10658831894397736,
0.31861335039138794,
0.25345379114151,
0.30968955159187317,
-0.32428669929504395,
-0.2747354507446289,
-0.5448516607284546,
-0.3679753839969635,
0.5278096795082092,
0.16388294100761414,
-0.3362676203250885,
-0.28068646788597107,
0.5437542796134949,
-0.6008642911911011,
0.054779741913080215,
0.023830091580748558,
0.17695848643779755,
0.15002277493476868,
0.45775535702705383,
-0.014208939857780933,
0.31501397490501404,
-0.11152913421392441,
0.19076474010944366,
-0.11998733133077621,
-0.42455556988716125,
-0.10075359791517258,
0.24433721601963043,
-0.3976011872291565,
0.11549284309148788,
0.5408286452293396,
0.6629460453987122,
0.12552252411842346,
-0.12205594778060913,
0.621431827545166,
0.21897898614406586,
-0.008203735575079918,
-0.14706091582775116,
-0.1370745748281479,
0.3327823281288147,
0.24928918480873108,
0.4473542273044586,
0.24464651942253113,
0.4167352318763733,
-1.0966538190841675,
0.25950005650520325,
0.9546830058097839,
-0.17947515845298767,
-0.21629270911216736,
0.17773601412773132,
0.27491113543510437,
0.0944594070315361,
0.4234260618686676,
-0.43410998582839966,
-0.8344840407371521,
0.2661777436733246,
0.33676233887672424,
0.7858207821846008,
-0.14631476998329163,
0.4140241742134094,
0.26660722494125366,
0.2143244594335556,
0.7844771146774292,
0.38602587580680847,
-0.41042402386665344,
-0.9135374426841736,
-0.2791205644607544,
-0.6544297933578491,
-0.4221040606498718,
-0.11160549521446228,
-0.726624608039856,
0.2576260268688202,
-0.404427707195282,
0.23222686350345612,
0.358856201171875,
0.14866545796394348,
-0.602289080619812,
-0.17441235482692719,
0.42300477623939514,
0.6907626390457153,
-0.9546324610710144,
1.2405483722686768,
0.689302384853363,
-0.19523605704307556,
-0.43415120244026184,
0.37699320912361145,
0.01296996884047985,
-0.6989201307296753,
0.3315819203853607,
0.0034689055755734444,
-0.6743564009666443,
-0.16603191196918488,
-0.612216591835022,
-0.5142229199409485,
1.1991077661514282,
-0.01895853690803051,
-0.37478107213974,
-0.37885597348213196,
-0.0632212832570076,
0.3973185122013092,
-0.9263001680374146,
0.12104518711566925,
0.5793107748031616,
0.4765467047691345,
0.6395396590232849,
-0.5079692602157593,
0.006814895663410425,
-0.2002187967300415,
-0.016194535419344902,
0.1496269702911377,
-0.5198947191238403,
0.9637913107872009,
-0.1619182974100113,
-0.4989382028579712,
-0.17313003540039062,
0.723216712474823,
0.18976664543151855,
0.6536040902137756,
0.7753136157989502,
0.4977705776691437,
0.7170703411102295,
-0.15253829956054688,
0.7218952178955078,
-0.544495701789856,
0.25903618335723877,
0.8611542582511902,
-0.47275295853614807,
0.9688297510147095,
0.6368844509124756,
0.11159771680831909,
1.392837643623352,
0.548710823059082,
0.5029609799385071,
0.7672953009605408,
0.05429760366678238,
-0.2598615288734436,
-0.3694990277290344,
-0.4672397971153259,
-0.2240976244211197,
0.8276801705360413,
0.9790001511573792,
-0.002038275822997093,
-0.4352852404117584,
-0.01878698542714119,
0.1876695156097412,
0.21829161047935486,
-0.25905680656433105,
0.7899373173713684,
-0.16005177795886993,
-0.34254127740859985,
0.4259883761405945,
0.025727881118655205,
0.8908977508544922,
-0.9138220548629761,
-0.31431588530540466,
0.046670638024806976,
0.227174311876297,
-0.1388590931892395,
-1.094185471534729,
0.5030392408370972,
-0.17270278930664062,
-0.009662959724664688,
-0.23849260807037354,
0.8651881814002991,
-0.6848551630973816,
-0.44718480110168457,
0.46566957235336304,
0.6044893264770508,
-0.21289849281311035,
-0.11917855590581894,
-0.962594747543335,
-0.009106517769396305,
-0.23095984756946564,
-0.02130621112883091,
-0.03506415709853172,
0.8217105269432068,
-0.1999552994966507,
0.4888456165790558,
0.8105793595314026,
0.030857013538479805,
-0.4313291013240814,
-0.11485960334539413,
1.063571572303772,
-0.33378535509109497,
-0.6193420886993408,
-0.7290770411491394,
0.47688207030296326,
-0.605370044708252,
-0.39921897649765015,
0.3849637806415558,
0.46172067523002625,
1.1402729749679565,
0.27445513010025024,
0.47197359800338745,
-0.24156633019447327,
0.4685908555984497,
-0.5224000215530396,
0.7177037000656128,
-0.42681246995925903,
0.24763518571853638,
-0.15101878345012665,
-0.5933509469032288,
0.04208269715309143,
0.5953988432884216,
-0.15644201636314392,
-0.1462058573961258,
0.8317604660987854,
0.6579532027244568,
-0.15473401546478271,
0.0809425562620163,
0.08186265081167221,
0.2827019989490509,
-0.08952007442712784,
0.5893133878707886,
0.8146559000015259,
-0.06058835983276367,
0.4106312692165375,
-0.582958996295929,
-0.3919525146484375,
0.1180715411901474,
-0.7379656434059143,
-0.7692407965660095,
-0.959354817867279,
-0.23710206151008606,
-0.3693517744541168,
0.08357851952314377,
0.6953794956207275,
0.9574607014656067,
-0.5973176956176758,
-0.13928772509098053,
0.3915676176548004,
0.4417227804660797,
-0.27298784255981445,
-0.20755307376384735,
0.5303592681884766,
-0.02501542679965496,
-0.841608464717865,
-0.2040528506040573,
0.6679826974868774,
-0.5814147591590881,
-0.45620355010032654,
-0.11879836022853851,
-0.5777444243431091,
0.5353571176528931,
0.7690188884735107,
-0.43156275153160095,
-0.7753191590309143,
-0.6731293797492981,
-0.2815045416355133,
-0.0835009217262268,
0.1376289278268814,
0.8699772953987122,
-0.6847172379493713,
0.41203755140304565,
0.4863285720348358,
0.3098064661026001,
0.31041857600212097,
0.08971055597066879,
-0.2258535474538803,
-0.769508957862854,
0.2739141285419464,
0.5214236974716187,
0.44877082109451294,
0.44554951786994934,
-0.3794889748096466,
0.3169271647930145,
0.6440358757972717,
0.12083377689123154,
-0.6000525951385498,
0.6012589931488037,
-0.9867347478866577,
-0.4835285246372223,
0.8224946856498718,
-0.0815676897764206,
-0.19995754957199097,
-0.4924941658973694,
-0.07621178030967712,
0.3847902715206146,
-0.32479000091552734,
0.45904919505119324,
0.76474529504776,
-0.15813113749027252,
-0.044853270053863525,
-0.23105905950069427,
0.39208537340164185,
0.22691044211387634,
-0.9150595664978027,
0.18627727031707764,
0.251203328371048,
0.17282694578170776,
0.3619624972343445,
0.5148100852966309,
0.009268304333090782,
0.1586441844701767,
0.30335259437561035,
-0.017964597791433334,
0.12981176376342773,
-0.5924473404884338,
0.15337103605270386,
0.15281037986278534,
-0.42487767338752747,
-0.3461955189704895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18952v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18952v2
|
Are You Sure? Rank Them Again: Repeated Ranking For Better Preference Datasets
| 2024-05-29T10:08:31 | 2024-06-01T02:18:06 |
Peter Devine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Training Large Language Models (LLMs) with Reinforcement Learning from AI
Feedback (RLAIF) aligns model outputs more closely with human preferences. This
involves an evaluator model ranking multiple candidate responses to user
prompts. However, the rankings from popular evaluator models such as GPT-4 can
be inconsistent. We propose the Repeat Ranking method - where we evaluate the
same responses multiple times and train only on those responses which are
consistently ranked. Using 2,714 prompts in 62 languages, we generated
responses from 7 top multilingual LLMs and had GPT-4 rank them five times each.
Evaluating on MT-Bench chat benchmarks in six languages, our method
outperformed the standard practice of training on all available prompts. Our
work highlights the quality versus quantity trade-off in RLAIF dataset
generation and offers a stackable strategy for enhancing dataset and thus model
quality.
|
[
-0.32956576347351074,
-0.46386489272117615,
0.4671129286289215,
0.23252877593040466,
-0.08514416217803955,
0.32133015990257263,
-0.32121190428733826,
-0.19063709676265717,
0.08511175215244293,
0.5413438081741333,
-0.38274872303009033,
-0.5137867331504822,
-0.7812893390655518,
0.14628872275352478,
-0.13398756086826324,
1.1055561304092407,
0.040533289313316345,
0.2547056972980499,
-0.34346503019332886,
-0.5527282357215881,
-0.6369388699531555,
-0.9104962944984436,
-0.9772291779518127,
-0.49063971638679504,
0.6500261425971985,
0.6251484751701355,
0.778477668762207,
0.393648624420166,
0.40649253129959106,
0.31254157423973083,
0.38956671953201294,
0.45618557929992676,
-0.7545860409736633,
0.30110448598861694,
0.1038242056965828,
-0.33737316727638245,
-0.29677820205688477,
0.31240028142929077,
0.7174445986747742,
0.5335051417350769,
-0.3443959653377533,
0.0574120432138443,
0.19226644933223724,
0.6279223561286926,
-0.28642183542251587,
0.06310965865850449,
-0.4442383348941803,
-0.13608181476593018,
0.11978942155838013,
-0.37741291522979736,
-0.7337899804115295,
-0.8923953175544739,
0.045620258897542953,
-0.45819559693336487,
0.01222995761781931,
0.20853324234485626,
0.8106269836425781,
0.266506165266037,
-0.4067422151565552,
0.022585298866033554,
-0.5497596859931946,
0.9894136786460876,
-0.6001258492469788,
0.4089429974555969,
0.3528892695903778,
0.3775160312652588,
-0.03535528853535652,
-0.641055166721344,
-0.29205912351608276,
-0.7716684341430664,
-0.11685121059417725,
0.21911026537418365,
0.15933015942573547,
-0.2138512134552002,
0.13774290680885315,
0.10490614175796509,
-0.8120352625846863,
0.11737284809350967,
-0.09958816319704056,
-0.2179999053478241,
0.7236347794532776,
0.18303385376930237,
0.0475149005651474,
0.16833274066448212,
-0.35320883989334106,
-0.5616891384124756,
-0.7899088263511658,
0.3449673354625702,
0.4905674457550049,
0.27049705386161804,
0.22086474299430847,
0.4327697455883026,
-0.26575347781181335,
0.7813736200332642,
0.30252861976623535,
-0.2439832091331482,
0.62296462059021,
-0.10822834074497223,
0.03238363936543465,
-0.06955257803201675,
0.9200772047042847,
0.43823114037513733,
0.21905936300754547,
-0.1372111588716507,
-0.20299777388572693,
-0.1158834844827652,
0.40034276247024536,
-0.5342326164245605,
-0.2266307920217514,
0.2523431181907654,
-0.4093184769153595,
-0.32731786370277405,
0.046990785747766495,
-0.4932120740413666,
-0.25457483530044556,
-0.27265316247940063,
0.4035138189792633,
-0.2054721862077713,
-0.2766425311565399,
0.14195717871189117,
0.08785626292228699,
0.041273102164268494,
0.33740752935409546,
-0.970094621181488,
0.24567170441150665,
0.7129498720169067,
0.6378661394119263,
-0.6014502048492432,
-0.870596706867218,
-0.8357962965965271,
-0.2254205048084259,
-0.6255143880844116,
0.9234499335289001,
-0.6049942970275879,
-0.693091869354248,
0.04172767326235771,
-0.12021716684103012,
-0.15061421692371368,
-0.9021213054656982,
0.5343289375305176,
-0.5551707148551941,
0.4882354438304901,
-0.4971097409725189,
-0.5458441376686096,
0.06816288083791733,
0.46550631523132324,
-0.5577396750450134,
1.2676140069961548,
0.06812995672225952,
-0.5903430581092834,
0.6700242161750793,
-0.3721678853034973,
-0.19617566466331482,
-0.01384788379073143,
-0.20287813246250153,
-0.477733314037323,
-0.2321404069662094,
0.5243469476699829,
0.336313396692276,
-0.04638510197401047,
0.4231612980365753,
-0.47981980443000793,
-0.31052547693252563,
0.3775407373905182,
-0.4398721158504486,
0.2759045958518982,
0.1796533316373825,
-0.18186120688915253,
0.5536407828330994,
-0.33085647225379944,
0.34453335404396057,
0.012837789952754974,
-0.7335296273231506,
0.010142575018107891,
-0.2502356469631195,
-0.017319247126579285,
0.13710302114486694,
0.2151254415512085,
-0.48958173394203186,
0.4380778968334198,
-0.23069262504577637,
0.18247272074222565,
0.9122967720031738,
0.11501648277044296,
0.22452415525913239,
-0.6435789465904236,
0.651817798614502,
-0.014822064898908138,
0.02887704409658909,
0.2589997351169586,
-0.46099457144737244,
-0.9658170342445374,
0.043724484741687775,
0.20549994707107544,
0.4990432858467102,
-0.717659592628479,
0.24404560029506683,
-0.48678967356681824,
-0.3894186317920685,
-0.7620515823364258,
0.09967674314975739,
0.39833205938339233,
0.3460046052932739,
0.27211830019950867,
-0.1936613768339157,
-0.35850951075553894,
-1.030907154083252,
-0.2990456521511078,
-0.36428961157798767,
0.19788360595703125,
0.6352936029434204,
0.2705727517604828,
0.04317060112953186,
0.89714515209198,
-0.38253313302993774,
0.0467306487262249,
-0.6331479549407959,
0.32068854570388794,
0.3181150555610657,
0.3104216158390045,
0.5443100333213806,
-0.6523477435112,
-0.49897512793540955,
-0.10463060438632965,
-0.7073923945426941,
0.0341472327709198,
-0.03634588047862053,
-0.06936147809028625,
0.2449168711900711,
0.22413325309753418,
-0.15622413158416748,
-0.10072693973779678,
0.46340838074684143,
0.07681924104690552,
0.31803756952285767,
-0.3064117133617401,
0.774271547794342,
-1.0249316692352295,
-0.05698256939649582,
-0.0888616070151329,
-0.5087769031524658,
-0.25323912501335144,
-0.19549624621868134,
-0.07412003725767136,
-0.04465566948056221,
-0.4152173399925232,
0.7282964587211609,
0.027783768251538277,
-0.14701376855373383,
-0.25288304686546326,
0.025220515206456184,
-0.26863154768943787,
0.6029435992240906,
0.17432720959186554,
1.0581910610198975,
0.37449222803115845,
-0.49688106775283813,
0.7202631831169128,
0.34354591369628906,
-0.4277474582195282,
0.5886035561561584,
-0.7904521822929382,
0.22149670124053955,
-0.11800047010183334,
0.4098597764968872,
-1.2721679210662842,
-0.270053893327713,
0.20990513265132904,
-0.5430735945701599,
0.23508374392986298,
-0.11291419714689255,
-0.3465874195098877,
-0.4118773937225342,
-0.3211911916732788,
0.2662644684314728,
0.29735156893730164,
-0.9658053517341614,
0.23448960483074188,
0.34106341004371643,
-0.32057294249534607,
-0.9332298040390015,
-0.27173352241516113,
-0.022203795611858368,
-0.3599057197570801,
-0.536150336265564,
0.02469399943947792,
-0.39616483449935913,
0.0054666888900101185,
-0.20921862125396729,
0.020344071090221405,
0.21684998273849487,
0.11916220188140869,
0.3265437185764313,
0.0731734111905098,
0.06712530553340912,
0.0572110116481781,
-0.33866605162620544,
-0.49308422207832336,
-0.2535267770290375,
-0.34114453196525574,
0.6975972652435303,
-0.35289761424064636,
-0.44449371099472046,
-0.426967054605484,
0.35149839520454407,
0.4302818179130554,
-0.1117381602525711,
0.4536672532558441,
0.5403399467468262,
0.030751781538128853,
0.0008393116877414286,
-0.5540091395378113,
-0.23398716747760773,
-0.4531766474246979,
0.3452591300010681,
-0.49131232500076294,
-1.1625335216522217,
0.21092598140239716,
0.13280287384986877,
0.5042481422424316,
0.22530458867549896,
0.5754505395889282,
-0.02743258886039257,
1.4426770210266113,
0.5214219093322754,
-0.5889375805854797,
0.36913904547691345,
-0.11070001125335693,
0.1508115828037262,
-0.42118456959724426,
-0.27513477206230164,
-0.5057433843612671,
-0.4062545895576477,
-0.6742016673088074,
0.2408110648393631,
0.5454329252243042,
-0.08163704723119736,
-0.27443355321884155,
0.07935132086277008,
-0.4168674349784851,
0.46879562735557556,
0.668826699256897,
0.23259441554546356,
0.2629336416721344,
0.10834744572639465,
-0.04480050131678581,
0.03697280213236809,
-0.6012691259384155,
-0.4224441349506378,
1.1577762365341187,
0.2635882794857025,
0.8729841709136963,
0.19672611355781555,
1.0174219608306885,
0.48444801568984985,
0.6226789355278015,
-0.69287109375,
0.3854418992996216,
0.07934489101171494,
-0.4250943660736084,
-0.42002880573272705,
-0.6426332592964172,
-0.9424163103103638,
0.32764342427253723,
0.004639584571123123,
-0.5291950106620789,
-0.11943630129098892,
0.3002849519252777,
-0.47339361906051636,
-0.06019783392548561,
-0.5773459076881409,
0.7517049312591553,
-0.37983351945877075,
-0.28075549006462097,
-0.2176510989665985,
-0.4176039695739746,
0.3605097532272339,
0.15091527998447418,
0.02812770940363407,
-0.10584938526153564,
0.21769003570079803,
0.9378083944320679,
-0.4013855755329132,
0.5060745477676392,
0.002928779926151037,
0.16072872281074524,
-0.07637124508619308,
-0.14349909126758575,
0.4124974310398102,
0.3917355239391327,
-0.10944873094558716,
-0.024059416726231575,
-0.08892256021499634,
-0.48755383491516113,
-0.658080518245697,
1.1126627922058105,
-1.1842361688613892,
-0.7679261565208435,
-0.5912020206451416,
-0.1788775622844696,
-0.4464881122112274,
0.06262120604515076,
0.5068128108978271,
0.5232158899307251,
-0.13617002964019775,
0.08708860725164413,
0.545079231262207,
-0.10769712924957275,
0.16652913391590118,
0.21941354870796204,
-0.4255225956439972,
-0.7073527574539185,
0.984646201133728,
-0.0757891908288002,
0.21828825771808624,
0.3558430075645447,
0.15271396934986115,
-0.48202529549598694,
-0.3452932834625244,
-0.5605891942977905,
0.2423868030309677,
-0.7500135898590088,
-0.023102624341845512,
-0.760114848613739,
-0.1992083191871643,
-0.5382135510444641,
-0.052367135882377625,
-0.44790005683898926,
-0.34325110912323,
0.22906015813350677,
-0.3165774345397949,
0.44461193680763245,
0.9904661178588867,
-0.15641695261001587,
0.2704336941242218,
-0.5682359933853149,
0.2352961152791977,
0.5286040306091309,
0.3987311124801636,
-0.008808962069451809,
-0.565328061580658,
-0.23596271872520447,
-0.08647798746824265,
-0.25762656331062317,
-0.5511001348495483,
0.4497324526309967,
0.05961054936051369,
0.9131560921669006,
0.0748063251376152,
-0.23168180882930756,
0.3721741735935211,
-0.37085163593292236,
0.9491193294525146,
0.02925773896276951,
-0.4486769139766693,
0.3929816484451294,
-0.26094284653663635,
0.19546595215797424,
0.7849559187889099,
0.6854364275932312,
-0.7090458869934082,
-0.16972124576568604,
-0.663193941116333,
-0.9427074193954468,
0.8089039921760559,
-0.08373367041349411,
0.0073961797170341015,
-0.10417713224887848,
0.33041083812713623,
0.2606474757194519,
0.36232990026474,
-0.7683442831039429,
-0.5889201164245605,
-0.3955676555633545,
-0.05828613415360451,
-0.29520750045776367,
-0.3147869110107422,
-0.19396482408046722,
0.035806506872177124,
0.8913331031799316,
-0.018529081717133522,
0.2370830923318863,
-0.24143636226654053,
0.025076553225517273,
0.11124523729085922,
0.3849899172782898,
0.5630173683166504,
0.7675575613975525,
-0.3860016167163849,
-0.02917522005736828,
0.04195213317871094,
-0.2968798875808716,
0.3004271388053894,
-0.18083323538303375,
0.0802268236875534,
-0.04768219217658043,
0.19675716757774353,
0.861281156539917,
0.1579088568687439,
-0.3310208320617676,
0.3674851953983307,
-0.3721381425857544,
-0.1176835298538208,
-0.3568164110183716,
0.1905260533094406,
-0.0881781205534935,
0.024344831705093384,
0.14795975387096405,
-0.024854034185409546,
-0.05513814464211464,
-0.5054333806037903,
0.5279061794281006,
0.3363509774208069,
-0.3163478970527649,
0.13210877776145935,
0.4257333278656006,
0.36652421951293945,
-0.23052053153514862,
0.7590777277946472,
-0.025825979188084602,
-0.588305652141571,
0.35388460755348206,
0.31633460521698,
0.51609867811203,
-0.25233712792396545,
0.4836556017398834,
0.6314399838447571,
-0.047069113701581955,
-0.6197030544281006,
0.34432223439216614,
0.0993160828948021,
-0.8649243116378784,
-0.20918098092079163,
-0.4072946012020111,
-0.6935561895370483,
0.3256148099899292,
-0.7909094095230103,
0.13300149142742157,
-0.4567236006259918,
-0.38617271184921265,
-0.07496798038482666,
0.0410274863243103,
-0.6811963319778442,
0.07818250358104706,
-0.16054588556289673,
0.4574436843395233,
-0.8544545769691467,
0.7780530452728271,
0.5936177372932434,
-0.5814664959907532,
-0.843021035194397,
-0.140126571059227,
0.08472392708063126,
-0.9912384152412415,
0.7046955823898315,
0.13248002529144287,
-0.18757285177707672,
0.22804374992847443,
-0.7154659032821655,
-1.0035443305969238,
0.8651820421218872,
0.08247044682502747,
-0.259927362203598,
0.3382977545261383,
0.021992741152644157,
0.2952459454536438,
-0.5971406698226929,
0.6708570718765259,
0.7220787405967712,
0.44425344467163086,
-0.01688617467880249,
-0.8275313973426819,
-0.39618173241615295,
-0.24114841222763062,
-0.07230255752801895,
0.05350400134921074,
-0.774914562702179,
0.5047091841697693,
-0.2630995213985443,
-0.05392290651798248,
0.34289613366127014,
0.644578754901886,
0.6420372724533081,
0.04620284214615822,
0.4739658832550049,
0.5296695232391357,
0.8127041459083557,
-0.23907604813575745,
1.234704852104187,
-0.0849079042673111,
0.418997585773468,
1.290040135383606,
-0.39642882347106934,
0.9551348090171814,
0.11824259907007217,
-0.08370158821344376,
0.3607439398765564,
1.0957614183425903,
0.05919991433620453,
0.7372277975082397,
0.15090972185134888,
-0.002458476461470127,
-0.7001079320907593,
-0.16843672096729279,
-0.5280036330223083,
0.16751140356063843,
0.024754343554377556,
-0.02959446795284748,
-0.1803237348794937,
0.17371536791324615,
-0.06103590503334999,
0.060480471700429916,
0.011725782416760921,
0.7783098220825195,
-0.11759509891271591,
-0.9149994850158691,
0.8869467973709106,
-0.08955668658018112,
0.7645001411437988,
-0.5038873553276062,
-0.07490464299917221,
-0.5963366627693176,
0.05200498178601265,
-0.07930655777454376,
-0.8559287786483765,
-0.3674243986606598,
-0.19170989096164703,
-0.34540030360221863,
-0.5545254945755005,
0.1842600554227829,
-0.5551787614822388,
-0.3969416916370392,
0.0817253440618515,
0.5116326808929443,
0.32130634784698486,
0.27519693970680237,
-0.7676843404769897,
0.05252605304121971,
0.1682008057832718,
-0.3036319315433502,
0.4152723252773285,
-0.04810195043683052,
-0.029042355716228485,
0.9664948582649231,
0.6131161451339722,
-0.027204003185033798,
-0.0719328224658966,
0.43103447556495667,
0.6164217591285706,
-0.43955621123313904,
-0.4548591077327728,
-0.5188487768173218,
0.23812390863895416,
-0.2104189395904541,
-0.5747898817062378,
0.5596231818199158,
0.4654780328273773,
1.0738811492919922,
0.05677097290754318,
1.0165481567382812,
0.4176985025405884,
0.8697107434272766,
-0.5247998833656311,
0.5500612258911133,
-0.47674673795700073,
0.33674880862236023,
0.06286691874265671,
-0.9908426403999329,
-0.07722550630569458,
0.6289253234863281,
-0.42288264632225037,
0.4826773703098297,
0.7612557411193848,
0.7041099667549133,
0.09741983562707901,
-0.15157397091388702,
0.47475990653038025,
0.09830225259065628,
0.5507838129997253,
0.6199812293052673,
1.0470465421676636,
-0.17859043180942535,
0.5275213122367859,
-0.014421307481825352,
-0.2377920001745224,
-0.3319290280342102,
-0.6381593346595764,
-0.6823768615722656,
-0.573861837387085,
-0.23198460042476654,
-0.4238256514072418,
0.21893736720085144,
1.1912224292755127,
0.7579939365386963,
-0.8643209338188171,
-0.3862542510032654,
0.48371607065200806,
0.1433607041835785,
-0.3737046718597412,
-0.20849691331386566,
0.3807167112827301,
-0.44181621074676514,
-0.643941342830658,
0.5865404009819031,
0.09080133587121964,
-0.18561922013759613,
-0.24141831696033478,
-0.31619539856910706,
0.06823025643825531,
-0.2800048887729645,
0.29149118065834045,
0.29249003529548645,
-0.7728701829910278,
-0.5622476935386658,
0.058115337044000626,
-0.35042864084243774,
0.23416846990585327,
0.9632099270820618,
-0.9262531995773315,
0.3377154767513275,
0.5185971260070801,
0.7152501344680786,
0.2672572433948517,
0.14920000731945038,
0.761988639831543,
-0.6692386865615845,
-0.24119685590267181,
0.017667492851614952,
0.42964404821395874,
0.5271583795547485,
-0.3105127215385437,
0.49813199043273926,
0.006644136738032103,
-0.8696439862251282,
-0.4964960515499115,
0.29708680510520935,
-0.9648522138595581,
-0.0525064617395401,
1.3949480056762695,
-0.21502019464969635,
0.2298116534948349,
-0.12617582082748413,
-0.2213609367609024,
-0.1384638398885727,
-0.9195882081985474,
0.9397528171539307,
0.8206675052642822,
-0.5299482345581055,
-0.30297908186912537,
-0.522067666053772,
0.6312832832336426,
0.5986423492431641,
-0.8634909987449646,
0.17464162409305573,
0.47844386100769043,
0.5047731399536133,
-0.010561536066234112,
0.8338273763656616,
-0.0061500901356339455,
0.3202230930328369,
-0.44604262709617615,
-0.2443721741437912,
-0.09328819811344147,
-0.5636149048805237,
-0.45522791147232056,
0.17694222927093506,
0.6935732364654541,
-0.0791550725698471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18937v1
|
Kestrel: Point Grounding Multimodal LLM for Part-Aware 3D Vision-Language Understanding
| 2024-05-29T09:43:48 | 2024-05-29T09:43:48 |
Junjie Fei, Mahmoud Ahmed, Jian Ding, Eslam Mohamed Bakr, Mohamed Elhoseiny
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
While 3D MLLMs have achieved significant progress, they are restricted to
object and scene understanding and struggle to understand 3D spatial structures
at the part level. In this paper, we introduce Kestrel, representing a novel
approach that empowers 3D MLLMs with part-aware understanding, enabling better
interpretation and segmentation grounding of 3D objects at the part level.
Despite its significance, the current landscape lacks tasks and datasets that
endow and assess this capability. Therefore, we propose two novel tasks: (1)
Part-Aware Point Grounding, the model is tasked with directly predicting a
part-level segmentation mask based on user instructions, and (2) Part-Aware
Point Grounded Captioning, the model provides a detailed caption that includes
part-level descriptions and their corresponding masks. To support learning and
evaluating for these tasks, we introduce 3DCoMPaT Grounded Instructions Dataset
(3DCoMPaT-GRIN). 3DCoMPaT-GRIN Vanilla, comprising 789k part-aware point
cloud-instruction-segmentation mask triplets, is used to evaluate MLLMs'
ability of part-aware segmentation grounding. 3DCoMPaT-GRIN Grounded Caption,
containing 107k part-aware point cloud-instruction-grounded caption triplets,
assesses both MLLMs' part-aware language comprehension and segmentation
grounding capabilities. Our introduced tasks, dataset, and Kestrel represent a
preliminary effort to bridge the gap between human cognition and 3D MLLMs,
i.e., the ability to perceive and engage with the environment at both global
and part levels. Extensive experiments on the 3DCoMPaT-GRIN show that Kestrel
can generate user-specified segmentation masks, a capability not present in any
existing 3D MLLM. Kestrel thus established a benchmark for evaluating the
part-aware language comprehension and segmentation grounding of 3D objects.
Project page at https://feielysia.github.io/Kestrel.github.io/
|
[
-0.37666788697242737,
-0.7428393959999084,
0.757594883441925,
0.5680248737335205,
-0.42620500922203064,
-0.20543646812438965,
0.287740021944046,
-0.49924373626708984,
-0.1652616411447525,
0.5869905352592468,
-0.5478330850601196,
-0.9635806679725647,
-0.5632162094116211,
-0.1276763528585434,
-0.32101622223854065,
0.30449429154396057,
0.15627771615982056,
0.005072153173387051,
-0.5683696866035461,
-0.2519060969352722,
-0.6089807152748108,
-0.7853406071662903,
-0.8867979049682617,
0.1030152216553688,
0.633918821811676,
0.4654929041862488,
0.5269520282745361,
0.8134753108024597,
0.339443176984787,
0.2606211006641388,
-0.44541600346565247,
-0.0010087627451866865,
-0.1872822791337967,
0.10187137871980667,
-0.1157928854227066,
-0.48046818375587463,
-0.3290405869483948,
-0.1634880155324936,
0.5827867388725281,
0.8678308129310608,
0.14506122469902039,
-0.12285622954368591,
0.05286791920661926,
0.8421354293823242,
-0.8427261114120483,
0.43134477734565735,
-0.5291363000869751,
0.4503476321697235,
-0.03139956295490265,
0.24048958718776703,
-0.19859850406646729,
0.37003517150878906,
0.03706333413720131,
-0.9761383533477783,
0.32164570689201355,
0.13377925753593445,
0.5226272940635681,
0.3958539366722107,
-0.5090863108634949,
0.012806642800569534,
-0.16624516248703003,
0.8200204968452454,
-0.6081008315086365,
0.7463738918304443,
0.21692760288715363,
0.5874545574188232,
-0.0678560808300972,
-0.6037260890007019,
-0.702714741230011,
-0.26150965690612793,
-0.050612568855285645,
0.49852827191352844,
0.1718721240758896,
0.2157929539680481,
0.10067271441221237,
0.33124470710754395,
-0.30721721053123474,
-0.10677957534790039,
-0.42045828700065613,
-0.26846668124198914,
0.21413370966911316,
-0.08142321556806564,
0.17774321138858795,
-0.46833524107933044,
-0.577252209186554,
-0.25163087248802185,
-0.6172302961349487,
0.3978690207004547,
0.13020291924476624,
0.5017530918121338,
-0.22106200456619263,
0.7728797197341919,
-0.30860626697540283,
1.0894837379455566,
0.1253398358821869,
-0.20642463862895966,
0.0290953628718853,
0.06115308776497841,
-0.5648379921913147,
0.07620275765657425,
0.3588200807571411,
0.6258201003074646,
-0.15160280466079712,
0.14534611999988556,
-0.14086398482322693,
-0.1133095771074295,
0.22900085151195526,
-0.4119691550731659,
-0.1479308307170868,
0.34511953592300415,
-0.6653974652290344,
-0.26251015067100525,
0.11226566135883331,
-0.632167398929596,
-0.8672740459442139,
-0.5453805327415466,
0.47830355167388916,
-0.17895279824733734,
-0.37830880284309387,
0.30630064010620117,
-0.0009719530935399234,
0.2342655509710312,
0.4861028492450714,
-0.6014631390571594,
-0.026470404118299484,
0.8110865950584412,
0.7689816355705261,
-0.07416840642690659,
-0.5004997849464417,
-0.5634752511978149,
0.24886147677898407,
-0.2011277824640274,
0.5636062622070312,
-0.5109614729881287,
-0.36491551995277405,
-0.015052546747028828,
0.2829867899417877,
-0.24616800248622894,
-0.5010192394256592,
0.5234354138374329,
-0.35390204191207886,
0.3440234065055847,
-0.3066171109676361,
-0.22184287011623383,
-0.7144613862037659,
0.7565533518791199,
-0.7308401465415955,
0.7616084814071655,
-0.03263828158378601,
-0.5661097168922424,
0.44322648644447327,
-0.6175323724746704,
-0.41615983843803406,
-0.3266982138156891,
-0.25151723623275757,
-0.21298962831497192,
0.1121145486831665,
0.6757524609565735,
0.9452754855155945,
0.09426592290401459,
-0.07158119231462479,
-0.2846580147743225,
-0.25134649872779846,
-0.2479485273361206,
-0.114131398499012,
0.6212201714515686,
0.01969517208635807,
-0.3802926540374756,
0.43299365043640137,
-0.8888275027275085,
-0.3345027267932892,
-0.0076031433418393135,
-0.10989579558372498,
0.014911023899912834,
0.17443187534809113,
-0.16569922864437103,
0.3126365542411804,
0.18497684597969055,
-0.5799173712730408,
-0.3651350438594818,
-0.3081260323524475,
0.08613888174295425,
0.4011662006378174,
0.1760975867509842,
0.47204887866973877,
-0.15201297402381897,
0.37233686447143555,
0.3615201413631439,
0.5444912910461426,
-0.35808125138282776,
-0.5169890522956848,
-1.1320292949676514,
-0.1996321827173233,
-0.41603609919548035,
0.4926685690879822,
-0.5437154173851013,
0.15598230063915253,
0.11232221871614456,
-0.38927584886550903,
-0.1781315952539444,
-0.1311352252960205,
0.5417887568473816,
0.8550065755844116,
0.6271640658378601,
0.326332151889801,
-0.5890662670135498,
-1.1276023387908936,
0.2526709735393524,
-0.15398548543453217,
-0.30472004413604736,
0.25338804721832275,
0.04538340121507645,
0.1701328158378601,
0.6770457029342651,
-0.21780496835708618,
-0.6199060082435608,
-0.1609797477722168,
-0.2868192493915558,
0.2572295367717743,
0.48968589305877686,
0.24148836731910706,
-1.145439863204956,
-0.4750569760799408,
0.2600177228450775,
-0.7868378758430481,
0.07220234721899033,
-0.062226708978414536,
-0.10574731975793839,
-0.015520477667450905,
0.8632401823997498,
-0.42883771657943726,
0.24814262986183167,
0.6213659644126892,
-0.5058209300041199,
0.25778138637542725,
0.12083227187395096,
0.25953999161720276,
-1.066834807395935,
0.07798276841640472,
-0.045389749109745026,
-0.33622100949287415,
-0.5700648427009583,
0.19573262333869934,
-0.048575688153505325,
-0.24935366213321686,
-0.9298766255378723,
0.3881987929344177,
-0.6100425720214844,
-0.2363579124212265,
-0.3451433777809143,
0.24236948788166046,
0.3602503538131714,
0.7092078328132629,
0.3176744878292084,
0.446165531873703,
0.6805599331855774,
-0.6141749024391174,
0.08035140484571457,
0.2088407725095749,
-0.21733450889587402,
0.7246211767196655,
-0.6042488813400269,
0.044065434485673904,
-0.21309742331504822,
0.012655786238610744,
-0.7405451536178589,
-0.16162559390068054,
0.45882147550582886,
-0.27923882007598877,
-0.07831156253814697,
-0.616349995136261,
-0.055627211928367615,
-0.04995168745517731,
0.1035606786608696,
0.33972206711769104,
0.16739073395729065,
-0.5339369773864746,
0.8692452311515808,
0.3630079925060272,
0.08971533924341202,
-0.6490857601165771,
-0.3641480505466461,
0.016735941171646118,
-0.280221551656723,
-0.7894908785820007,
0.34370455145835876,
0.09294886142015457,
-0.2799528241157532,
-0.05334673821926117,
-0.45806825160980225,
0.011424843221902847,
0.09859149158000946,
0.6288065314292908,
-0.07247713208198547,
-0.22427675127983093,
-0.24452461302280426,
-0.052111778408288956,
-0.2788064479827881,
0.11031390726566315,
-0.36669597029685974,
0.35055920481681824,
-0.3538091778755188,
-0.7590100765228271,
-0.2519592046737671,
0.3785770833492279,
0.7474353313446045,
-0.05990691855549812,
0.49499770998954773,
0.7519649863243103,
-0.48217934370040894,
0.18067552149295807,
-0.5420132279396057,
0.10389243066310883,
-0.4320102632045746,
0.4509357810020447,
-0.7386919856071472,
-1.0754262208938599,
0.5213625431060791,
0.21749810874462128,
0.17176637053489685,
0.6174403429031372,
0.1962386667728424,
-0.5247294306755066,
0.96145099401474,
0.7336882948875427,
0.3278443217277527,
0.1910809725522995,
-0.19555683434009552,
-0.036198485642671585,
-1.0269712209701538,
-0.6296257376670837,
-0.21937768161296844,
-0.3642076551914215,
0.20789676904678345,
-0.7913254499435425,
0.4401135742664337,
0.6499543786048889,
-0.13436318933963776,
-0.029293132945895195,
-0.5683503150939941,
0.6917266249656677,
0.5406155586242676,
0.22928735613822937,
0.07747247815132141,
-0.04072003811597824,
-0.2978905737400055,
0.10798445343971252,
-0.47898104786872864,
-0.4292055368423462,
0.6446918845176697,
0.426072359085083,
0.12275208532810211,
0.011717835441231728,
0.1149345189332962,
0.4474699795246124,
-0.19857370853424072,
-0.7518101930618286,
0.759697437286377,
-0.18103522062301636,
-0.3082049787044525,
-0.3283025622367859,
-0.01982012763619423,
-0.6515452861785889,
0.6468747854232788,
-0.1495334655046463,
-0.564666748046875,
0.30584999918937683,
0.32101190090179443,
-0.40147000551223755,
0.3708323836326599,
-0.5563896894454956,
1.0496892929077148,
-0.08794491738080978,
-0.21353869140148163,
-0.18854674696922302,
-0.7814030647277832,
0.41891294717788696,
0.12156271934509277,
0.10723747313022614,
-0.37445068359375,
0.029230376705527306,
0.7863120436668396,
-0.24743831157684326,
1.128894329071045,
-0.8515925407409668,
-0.152419775724411,
0.22282569110393524,
0.2000851333141327,
0.3133118450641632,
0.21377940475940704,
0.17247214913368225,
0.4146474599838257,
0.156525120139122,
-0.47326892614364624,
-0.6729898452758789,
0.5937116742134094,
-0.6121377348899841,
-0.8178672194480896,
-0.1552727073431015,
-0.3091104328632355,
-0.4827903211116791,
0.2578834891319275,
-0.08956249803304672,
0.35519900918006897,
0.2044721096754074,
0.40569737553596497,
0.5552210807800293,
-0.20094084739685059,
0.28534743189811707,
0.39475181698799133,
-0.5066046118736267,
-0.5500243902206421,
0.7355607151985168,
-0.6499848961830139,
0.09912340342998505,
0.9186708927154541,
0.16817311942577362,
-0.4223496615886688,
-0.9212270975112915,
-0.4402344226837158,
-0.1691540777683258,
-0.8864337205886841,
-0.09686409682035446,
-0.7277696132659912,
-0.14283350110054016,
-0.09965817630290985,
-0.5633809566497803,
-0.4415724277496338,
-0.4786985218524933,
-0.17926977574825287,
-0.13502545654773712,
-0.13470511138439178,
0.7427889704704285,
-0.07942184805870056,
0.6087571978569031,
-0.7867454886436462,
0.3237212896347046,
0.47477346658706665,
-0.0031846254132688046,
-0.04115043580532074,
-0.2651292085647583,
-0.30319109559059143,
0.28882503509521484,
0.1789533644914627,
-0.4204779863357544,
-0.059124816209077835,
-0.1965654045343399,
0.6661487221717834,
0.47007477283477783,
-0.30772456526756287,
0.9863685369491577,
-0.25968027114868164,
1.0348416566848755,
0.37378135323524475,
-1.0725092887878418,
0.5481875538825989,
-0.37733346223831177,
0.43021219968795776,
0.528139054775238,
-0.11710109561681747,
-0.890346884727478,
-0.2629503905773163,
-0.09240587800741196,
-0.717609703540802,
0.6858033537864685,
0.2450827658176422,
-0.16330160200595856,
0.06196962669491768,
0.2528434097766876,
0.07763417810201645,
-0.011640811339020729,
-0.7454074621200562,
-0.009126391261816025,
-0.607876181602478,
-0.12606823444366455,
0.1264687031507492,
-0.504934549331665,
-0.18782928586006165,
-0.04624143987894058,
0.4492505192756653,
-0.10753133147954941,
0.2759413719177246,
0.46123677492141724,
-0.42320868372917175,
0.24004320800304413,
-0.11703778803348541,
0.9439677596092224,
0.7193282246589661,
-0.34489017724990845,
0.39798665046691895,
0.1322888433933258,
-0.582274854183197,
0.08187313377857208,
0.09334637224674225,
0.06099901720881462,
-0.12389722466468811,
0.6724327206611633,
0.7889546155929565,
0.42071735858917236,
-0.465310275554657,
0.629884660243988,
-0.01507195457816124,
-0.2722601294517517,
-0.3400557041168213,
-0.07693710178136826,
0.021158946678042412,
0.40243101119995117,
0.41131022572517395,
0.1945267766714096,
-0.12177874892950058,
0.06690061837434769,
0.17732740938663483,
0.12129789590835571,
-0.7090166211128235,
-0.3511130213737488,
0.7757061719894409,
0.3396681547164917,
0.0742061510682106,
0.3422554135322571,
0.05511794239282608,
-0.5296890735626221,
0.6984682083129883,
0.3901924192905426,
0.7222527265548706,
-0.03114984929561615,
0.21857571601867676,
0.4781275987625122,
0.3543936312198639,
0.3398262858390808,
0.3237951397895813,
-0.2217315286397934,
-0.816655695438385,
-0.5278536677360535,
-0.6948625445365906,
-0.3272452652454376,
0.14895792305469513,
-0.448813259601593,
0.14401927590370178,
-0.6627236008644104,
0.31043246388435364,
-0.36919161677360535,
-0.3003677427768707,
-0.5975154042243958,
0.5366597771644592,
0.3466947674751282,
1.041555643081665,
-0.6323094964027405,
0.45035505294799805,
0.9679017066955566,
-0.11026971787214279,
-0.5301001071929932,
-0.015118461102247238,
0.1030329018831253,
-1.0083528757095337,
0.6960081458091736,
0.4698319435119629,
-0.24568186700344086,
-0.00104719796217978,
0.06096121668815613,
-0.8792264461517334,
1.1796979904174805,
-0.03094620630145073,
-0.5116879343986511,
0.10092845559120178,
0.41521915793418884,
-0.06990303099155426,
-0.37544363737106323,
0.0362786203622818,
0.10682796686887741,
0.5887869000434875,
0.4241222143173218,
-0.6049978733062744,
-0.012683193199336529,
-0.13247984647750854,
-0.12722982466220856,
0.01929202862083912,
-0.4491308927536011,
0.7667072415351868,
0.06203411519527435,
-0.28224262595176697,
-0.15833765268325806,
0.8503917455673218,
0.40375155210494995,
0.43288272619247437,
1.2166163921356201,
0.6181619763374329,
0.5211856961250305,
0.031603168696165085,
0.5666550993919373,
-0.27569451928138733,
-0.058994557708501816,
1.1514240503311157,
-0.20306749641895294,
0.8249915242195129,
0.5947246551513672,
0.00873994454741478,
0.29020440578460693,
0.6220938563346863,
0.32239285111427307,
0.6088351011276245,
-0.04139680415391922,
-0.47967275977134705,
-0.48585444688796997,
0.0674399733543396,
-0.17219732701778412,
0.698947012424469,
0.3243727684020996,
-0.2187240719795227,
-0.3754175901412964,
0.3536904454231262,
0.07979971170425415,
0.016918852925300598,
-0.5208926200866699,
0.8052971363067627,
-0.0038977162912487984,
-0.34885093569755554,
0.33677753806114197,
-0.007605839986354113,
0.19517524540424347,
-0.6516256332397461,
-0.20014286041259766,
-0.33796074986457825,
0.0662926435470581,
-0.16166308522224426,
-0.9468895196914673,
0.4514434337615967,
-0.1927032172679901,
-0.31239956617355347,
-0.20101940631866455,
0.588888943195343,
-0.26611435413360596,
-0.6208483576774597,
0.16096973419189453,
0.36838608980178833,
0.12970700860023499,
-0.7600727677345276,
-0.6668391227722168,
0.3881295323371887,
0.24679046869277954,
0.0023646035697311163,
0.05350960046052933,
0.3298940360546112,
-0.08630911260843277,
0.5681527256965637,
0.7819521427154541,
-0.220870241522789,
0.1586020439863205,
0.28320589661598206,
0.6857995986938477,
-0.6668883562088013,
-0.402403324842453,
-0.6400858759880066,
0.8724477887153625,
-0.2457074671983719,
-0.0714685320854187,
0.826335072517395,
0.751248836517334,
0.7110191583633423,
-0.15692253410816193,
0.5425808429718018,
-0.15918733179569244,
0.4116102457046509,
-0.9654458165168762,
0.5370250940322876,
-0.6095754504203796,
0.09282844513654709,
0.07697484642267227,
-1.1998265981674194,
-0.747839629650116,
0.6428068280220032,
-0.07504060119390488,
-0.2948032319545746,
0.6814150214195251,
0.790300726890564,
-0.4055013358592987,
-0.168476864695549,
0.8149008750915527,
0.10982875525951385,
0.5503762364387512,
0.3713928163051605,
0.998895525932312,
-0.10687561333179474,
0.6346815824508667,
-0.6459019184112549,
-0.14933907985687256,
0.027985677123069763,
-1.0429863929748535,
-1.0632389783859253,
-0.730627715587616,
-0.1524190604686737,
0.004115525633096695,
-0.06403964012861252,
0.48182374238967896,
1.0649744272232056,
-0.8357760906219482,
0.05897645652294159,
-0.4298139214515686,
0.014362215064466,
-0.33219239115715027,
-0.22836919128894806,
0.5965297818183899,
-0.23879610002040863,
-0.7805719375610352,
0.9982405304908752,
0.5393789410591125,
0.06515432894229889,
-0.4050610065460205,
-0.04330125451087952,
-0.04153485223650932,
-0.42683932185173035,
1.0438041687011719,
0.1362103372812271,
-1.0273747444152832,
-0.4654734432697296,
0.05303555727005005,
0.23997019231319427,
-0.04982966557145119,
0.6840562224388123,
-0.7368789911270142,
0.6074560880661011,
0.08966682106256485,
0.49391448497772217,
0.4313141107559204,
0.12982751429080963,
0.5331071019172668,
-0.9786784052848816,
0.4165589213371277,
0.27530941367149353,
0.6944460272789001,
0.5202667117118835,
-0.34743377566337585,
0.4493575990200043,
0.155217245221138,
-0.2914089262485504,
-0.2788948714733124,
0.20364588499069214,
-1.2923660278320312,
-0.24156929552555084,
1.0006898641586304,
-0.22937434911727905,
-0.3218667805194855,
-0.18749435245990753,
-0.5934627652168274,
-0.02074347250163555,
0.0884447768330574,
0.5519902110099792,
0.5115568041801453,
0.054695647209882736,
-0.5306363701820374,
-0.42435184121131897,
0.30643710494041443,
0.48105141520500183,
-0.616301417350769,
0.03380753472447395,
0.6085562705993652,
0.03371141105890274,
0.21374492347240448,
0.2555328607559204,
-0.028888892382383347,
0.12122634053230286,
0.0004578557563945651,
0.21795745193958282,
-0.6603015661239624,
-0.5460349321365356,
-0.09063129872083664,
0.5124813914299011,
-0.20801346004009247,
-0.7827842831611633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18922v1
|
Understanding and Addressing the Under-Translation Problem from the Perspective of Decoding Objective
| 2024-05-29T09:25:49 | 2024-05-29T09:25:49 |
Chenze Shao, Fandong Meng, Jiali Zeng, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) has made remarkable progress over the past
years. However, under-translation and over-translation remain two challenging
problems in state-of-the-art NMT systems. In this work, we conduct an in-depth
analysis on the underlying cause of under-translation in NMT, providing an
explanation from the perspective of decoding objective. To optimize the beam
search objective, the model tends to overlook words it is less confident about,
leading to the under-translation phenomenon. Correspondingly, the model's
confidence in predicting the End Of Sentence (EOS) diminishes when
under-translation occurs, serving as a mild penalty for under-translated
candidates. Building upon this analysis, we propose employing the confidence of
predicting EOS as a detector for under-translation, and strengthening the
confidence-based penalty to penalize candidates with a high risk of
under-translation. Experiments on both synthetic and real-world data show that
our method can accurately detect and rectify under-translated outputs, with
minor impact on other correct translations.
|
[
-0.10792214423418045,
-0.31318777799606323,
0.9407240748405457,
-0.16472682356834412,
-0.46768906712532043,
0.18177944421768188,
0.1096741259098053,
-0.3643130362033844,
0.06535989791154861,
0.2920936942100525,
-0.5198001861572266,
-0.2641316056251526,
-0.9216334819793701,
0.13671144843101501,
-0.6524717807769775,
0.8934560418128967,
-0.4599618911743164,
-0.039632976055145264,
-0.12652580440044403,
0.5281938910484314,
-0.7324648499488831,
-0.40554702281951904,
-0.41496190428733826,
-0.7053940892219543,
0.09885069727897644,
0.2626347243785858,
0.5005223751068115,
0.4346771240234375,
0.5709192156791687,
0.2665618062019348,
-0.18938565254211426,
0.34398671984672546,
-0.5095168352127075,
0.013977576047182083,
0.1357196569442749,
-0.5522329807281494,
-0.4751313626766205,
-0.02454308420419693,
0.4460223615169525,
0.5387298464775085,
0.06210920587182045,
-0.24382217228412628,
0.17881827056407928,
0.41631829738616943,
-0.7341141104698181,
0.08678288757801056,
-0.7548732757568359,
0.20499050617218018,
-0.17057441174983978,
-0.6318318843841553,
-0.29102882742881775,
-0.03183767944574356,
-0.10039513558149338,
-0.5646937489509583,
0.036573052406311035,
0.046863701194524765,
0.7893117070198059,
0.6115313768386841,
-0.5723890066146851,
-0.15972013771533966,
-0.48169374465942383,
0.8921924233436584,
-0.6320100426673889,
0.18842604756355286,
0.5070087909698486,
0.09904973953962326,
-0.39365842938423157,
-0.2644973397254944,
-0.23179331421852112,
-0.1181107759475708,
-0.2956241965293884,
0.2866772413253784,
-0.5439271926879883,
0.3854115307331085,
-0.056781504303216934,
0.3682570159435272,
-0.5024579763412476,
-0.2648332118988037,
-0.3578604757785797,
-0.22079020738601685,
0.39711037278175354,
0.10803122073411942,
0.23112617433071136,
-0.3050176799297333,
-0.4025757908821106,
0.33492064476013184,
-0.6614217758178711,
-0.09677408635616302,
0.2279927283525467,
0.35955333709716797,
0.2498708963394165,
0.7323479056358337,
-0.4446945786476135,
0.1742413192987442,
0.03229023888707161,
0.5754505395889282,
0.31257161498069763,
-0.31105679273605347,
-0.24083225429058075,
0.48633208870887756,
0.5368982553482056,
0.6092519164085388,
0.5733987092971802,
-0.3382454216480255,
-0.7260015606880188,
0.14452719688415527,
0.5035902261734009,
-0.7063295245170593,
0.41830694675445557,
0.3547722101211548,
-0.30426299571990967,
-0.4357419013977051,
0.010390646755695343,
-0.14333322644233704,
-0.017444249242544174,
-0.13659454882144928,
0.5070092678070068,
-0.4302919805049896,
-0.09767687320709229,
0.6337284445762634,
-0.07208454608917236,
-0.06905947625637054,
0.13918957114219666,
-0.6517260074615479,
0.3312343955039978,
0.7720574736595154,
0.9631834030151367,
-0.042429711669683456,
-0.15936709940433502,
-0.4917317032814026,
-0.02276165410876274,
-0.58949214220047,
0.4624001085758209,
-0.09625428915023804,
-0.18611779808998108,
-0.18499192595481873,
-0.21536602079868317,
-0.3253397047519684,
-0.12618669867515564,
0.7074192762374878,
-0.3588576316833496,
0.10911200195550919,
-0.16576944291591644,
-0.5911531448364258,
0.024485941976308823,
0.4356261193752289,
0.039677128195762634,
0.6210715174674988,
-0.026761842891573906,
-0.6001395583152771,
0.16523157060146332,
-0.5706591606140137,
-0.3925279974937439,
-0.07797755300998688,
-0.10176453739404678,
-0.18369850516319275,
0.8833860754966736,
0.3204076886177063,
0.45096397399902344,
-0.3475923538208008,
0.3366883099079132,
0.2418138086795807,
-0.9057363867759705,
0.5005100965499878,
-0.5037604570388794,
0.5358014106750488,
0.3965904712677002,
-0.3282877802848816,
-0.16434167325496674,
-0.3934553861618042,
0.19466862082481384,
0.023435650393366814,
-0.22098882496356964,
-0.3797382712364197,
0.013290904462337494,
-0.24715855717658997,
0.0029094675555825233,
0.22379951179027557,
-1.0232172012329102,
0.10562512278556824,
-0.8315420746803284,
0.45184147357940674,
0.5049514174461365,
-0.009494041092693806,
0.3854108154773712,
0.10010512173175812,
0.6274144053459167,
-0.012759082950651646,
0.16089099645614624,
0.025436855852603912,
-0.5346169471740723,
-0.5207488536834717,
0.37699341773986816,
0.26732736825942993,
0.7322284579277039,
-0.7783243656158447,
-0.06661184877157211,
-0.4395255148410797,
0.10349329560995102,
-0.9811452627182007,
-0.04918643832206726,
1.0389679670333862,
0.46011975407600403,
0.8075881600379944,
-0.2841426134109497,
-0.7718544602394104,
-0.9269190430641174,
-0.27083155512809753,
-0.08355697989463806,
-0.14551399648189545,
-0.12379457801580429,
0.6767374873161316,
-0.3722347319126129,
0.8140583634376526,
-0.5294961929321289,
-0.5428788661956787,
-0.23657479882240295,
0.17687928676605225,
0.37030425667762756,
0.7988108992576599,
0.22835056483745575,
-0.9327622652053833,
-0.42275479435920715,
0.3905530571937561,
-0.6635776162147522,
-0.20065075159072876,
-0.2680642604827881,
0.05948304757475853,
0.008199069648981094,
0.6964232325553894,
-0.9577094316482544,
0.6482699513435364,
0.21889206767082214,
-0.04151216894388199,
0.19518007338047028,
-0.27710479497909546,
0.3667248785495758,
-0.940287172794342,
-0.04530498385429382,
-0.28085190057754517,
-0.04147905483841896,
-0.5212811827659607,
0.2813955843448639,
0.17331762611865997,
0.21086972951889038,
-0.4760582149028778,
0.10367827862501144,
-0.45179155468940735,
-0.19826476275920868,
-0.5674939155578613,
-0.03775864467024803,
0.18011313676834106,
0.3100926876068115,
-0.09840698540210724,
0.7392602562904358,
0.026012957096099854,
-0.20780564844608307,
0.22357365489006042,
0.17768344283103943,
-0.1390651911497116,
0.2492814064025879,
-0.8824405670166016,
0.1163182407617569,
-0.05170154944062233,
0.041219402104616165,
-1.0693747997283936,
-0.03558526188135147,
0.46001726388931274,
-1.1723577976226807,
0.6325457096099854,
-0.4401423931121826,
-0.2733714282512665,
-0.4014448821544647,
-0.17815333604812622,
0.4624093174934387,
0.5478330850601196,
0.05884451046586037,
0.27038559317588806,
-0.09199840575456619,
0.34177646040916443,
-1.0727781057357788,
-1.2984631061553955,
0.18432994186878204,
-0.1073572188615799,
-0.44195088744163513,
0.7181628942489624,
0.24778367578983307,
-0.15133653581142426,
0.1481381207704544,
-0.3939843773841858,
-0.03201794996857643,
0.3438122868537903,
0.03213074058294296,
-0.09153410792350769,
-0.5814041495323181,
-0.11524618417024612,
0.40577635169029236,
-0.6271834373474121,
0.2177496999502182,
-0.6034929156303406,
0.31806686520576477,
-0.35464805364608765,
-0.39904895424842834,
-0.431718647480011,
0.36216920614242554,
0.40973418951034546,
-0.13836319744586945,
0.6724157929420471,
0.512997567653656,
-0.39555463194847107,
0.09118787944316864,
-0.16311602294445038,
-0.2749313414096832,
-0.3987776041030884,
0.5754244923591614,
-0.6653673052787781,
-0.2704985439777374,
0.518099308013916,
0.14815010130405426,
-0.40338873863220215,
0.3502638041973114,
0.18885323405265808,
-0.2732410728931427,
1.1705691814422607,
0.6227596402168274,
0.09323281794786453,
0.09170348942279816,
-0.19605585932731628,
0.18283423781394958,
-1.1324619054794312,
-0.1770133376121521,
-0.3340036869049072,
-0.35479578375816345,
-0.33210185170173645,
-0.2077862173318863,
0.06333750486373901,
0.23813879489898682,
0.17120254039764404,
0.7270951867103577,
-0.5706115961074829,
0.8063450455665588,
0.44877365231513977,
0.10200479626655579,
0.20845700800418854,
-0.2864282727241516,
-0.25587907433509827,
-0.2456476390361786,
-0.5606591701507568,
-0.25298237800598145,
0.9671487808227539,
0.30696380138397217,
0.6176975965499878,
0.048602014780044556,
0.8671765327453613,
0.23941946029663086,
-0.1312410980463028,
-0.8843497037887573,
0.2910996973514557,
-0.26334047317504883,
-0.727450430393219,
-0.17535679042339325,
-0.5746262669563293,
-0.8688557744026184,
0.45749014616012573,
0.05469880625605583,
-0.676638662815094,
0.3177064061164856,
0.30441999435424805,
-0.4550454020500183,
0.13605089485645294,
-0.6334882378578186,
0.9942014813423157,
-0.36671096086502075,
-0.05435873940587044,
-0.025040671229362488,
-0.8834927678108215,
0.17514286935329437,
-0.10607568919658661,
-0.005689762998372316,
0.010664297267794609,
-0.058716967701911926,
0.06303562223911285,
-0.11603263020515442,
0.7666210532188416,
0.004530776757746935,
0.1302739828824997,
-0.06997397541999817,
0.1676526665687561,
0.3789375126361847,
-0.23940235376358032,
-0.05414937436580658,
-0.040344011038541794,
-0.19159409403800964,
-0.23847420513629913,
-0.6435388922691345,
0.3276062607765198,
-0.6136996150016785,
-0.4312672019004822,
-0.5714417695999146,
-0.6385393738746643,
0.06723958998918533,
0.3092840611934662,
0.6843269467353821,
0.24494010210037231,
-0.03441457077860832,
0.4328068494796753,
0.7164701819419861,
-0.1853848695755005,
-0.01422110851854086,
0.37336987257003784,
-0.1732189804315567,
-0.07165328413248062,
0.7804398536682129,
0.17847205698490143,
0.4009062945842743,
0.6767173409461975,
0.355755478143692,
-0.3826219141483307,
-1.2279361486434937,
-0.5368073582649231,
-0.0791182592511177,
-0.7141018509864807,
-0.3981606066226959,
-0.5060891509056091,
-0.14924252033233643,
-0.5474998354911804,
-0.3266093134880066,
-0.5532284379005432,
-0.2224770039319992,
-0.3715977370738983,
-0.18463054299354553,
-0.10744763910770416,
0.5528740286827087,
-0.07074268162250519,
0.6692144870758057,
-0.7708703875541687,
0.3160341680049896,
-0.27106720209121704,
0.12819617986679077,
-0.2968883216381073,
-0.8412054181098938,
-0.34726300835609436,
0.22309570014476776,
-0.10387347638607025,
-0.8186172246932983,
0.687107503414154,
0.15404419600963593,
0.6543703079223633,
0.1414818912744522,
0.19614024460315704,
0.5914149880409241,
-0.46487653255462646,
0.2771787941455841,
-0.07839494943618774,
-1.1790101528167725,
0.579795241355896,
-0.338105708360672,
0.36136704683303833,
0.4848979413509369,
0.42330390214920044,
-0.6065269112586975,
-0.40941110253334045,
-0.3641231656074524,
-1.055969476699829,
0.8288204669952393,
0.710734486579895,
0.2690659761428833,
-0.11432822793722153,
0.47880446910858154,
-0.37033119797706604,
0.49954697489738464,
-0.7048231959342957,
0.1292026937007904,
-0.2015492469072342,
-0.3269973397254944,
-0.16932076215744019,
-0.3854808509349823,
0.16226908564567566,
0.00036295526660978794,
0.7773647308349609,
-0.13813629746437073,
0.13233159482479095,
0.29993993043899536,
-0.4037546217441559,
-0.46456772089004517,
0.3973778188228607,
0.7618415355682373,
0.12617777287960052,
-0.6812647581100464,
-0.06733911484479904,
0.16064666211605072,
-0.31017592549324036,
-0.09867088496685028,
0.04098087549209595,
-0.552204430103302,
-0.05800243839621544,
0.44977712631225586,
0.7596694231033325,
0.5208427309989929,
-0.26093629002571106,
0.7540357112884521,
0.10189393162727356,
0.02046523615717888,
-0.27942153811454773,
-0.31359055638313293,
-0.11962199956178665,
0.24399220943450928,
0.7078583836555481,
0.4445667266845703,
0.5081658363342285,
-0.27550607919692993,
0.39197319746017456,
0.4273148477077484,
-0.5924357175827026,
-0.09800069779157639,
0.6950016021728516,
0.15394453704357147,
-0.12238800525665283,
0.5224194526672363,
-0.11539251357316971,
-1.0448546409606934,
0.7734853625297546,
0.4735336899757385,
0.9758251309394836,
-0.236832857131958,
-0.07015825808048248,
0.02603320963680744,
0.8262571692466736,
-0.19466614723205566,
0.10220643877983093,
0.1060555949807167,
-0.8374564051628113,
-0.6351650953292847,
-0.5606956481933594,
-0.019524523988366127,
-0.25575050711631775,
-0.8421621322631836,
0.1123480349779129,
0.12542608380317688,
-0.3249987065792084,
-0.29585006833076477,
0.0026834681630134583,
-0.0013052027206867933,
0.2882890999317169,
0.3784908950328827,
0.4314841628074646,
-0.7355709671974182,
0.9534856081008911,
0.3753724992275238,
-0.5810113549232483,
-0.4228668212890625,
-0.06763233989477158,
0.1884307861328125,
-0.9060413241386414,
0.7114539742469788,
0.37860745191574097,
-0.6405237913131714,
0.16841009259223938,
-0.19126363098621368,
-0.8566692471504211,
0.839062511920929,
0.6141722798347473,
-0.3186924457550049,
-0.3822398781776428,
0.3532765507698059,
0.6807631850242615,
-0.3280860483646393,
0.07494977861642838,
0.4616653621196747,
0.4476704001426697,
-0.027858583256602287,
-1.0241717100143433,
0.018983963876962662,
-0.09089557081460953,
0.07498026639223099,
0.44563499093055725,
-0.11713529378175735,
1.0454527139663696,
-0.16833442449569702,
-0.23905429244041443,
0.19193324446678162,
0.3662928342819214,
-0.3029005229473114,
0.4000685214996338,
0.11319481581449509,
0.33374443650245667,
0.13365629315376282,
-0.1215558871626854,
1.3516854047775269,
0.09117692708969116,
0.48835286498069763,
0.9905787706375122,
0.1649327427148819,
0.6895968914031982,
0.7501499652862549,
0.10212692618370056,
-0.058160025626420975,
0.5471872091293335,
0.13637839257717133,
0.689140260219574,
0.2681383788585663,
0.3055762052536011,
-0.4215783178806305,
-0.1543380618095398,
-0.4129774570465088,
0.5083633661270142,
0.4253256320953369,
-0.6451191902160645,
-0.12553195655345917,
-0.025215907022356987,
-0.2019515484571457,
0.2817375063896179,
-0.39693528413772583,
0.281104177236557,
0.53962242603302,
-0.4915192425251007,
0.7169031500816345,
-0.014425642788410187,
0.8213689923286438,
-0.441033273935318,
0.0018570513930171728,
-0.24906191229820251,
0.53244549036026,
-0.26302075386047363,
-0.789644718170166,
0.5196176171302795,
-0.30826154351234436,
-0.14255492389202118,
-0.6343294382095337,
0.6800687313079834,
-0.5359862446784973,
-0.3166678547859192,
0.5782565474510193,
0.5954815745353699,
0.4365619421005249,
-0.615286111831665,
-0.7154298424720764,
0.11033456772565842,
0.24918797612190247,
-0.37078648805618286,
0.14214450120925903,
0.6498505473136902,
0.0458623468875885,
0.6927491426467896,
0.28010091185569763,
0.12715524435043335,
0.009442063979804516,
-0.22821705043315887,
0.5137314796447754,
-0.26958444714546204,
-0.24778078496456146,
-0.99693763256073,
0.5654099583625793,
0.17792002856731415,
-0.5016909837722778,
0.6481838226318359,
0.3441433906555176,
0.9152082204818726,
-0.04943155497312546,
0.23168767988681793,
0.16758278012275696,
0.3114633858203888,
-0.738091766834259,
0.905569851398468,
-1.0125881433486938,
0.2433094084262848,
-0.4072369933128357,
-0.6924664974212646,
-0.4030461609363556,
0.6510289907455444,
-0.5187775492668152,
-0.2667786478996277,
0.7624287009239197,
0.6217427849769592,
-0.2250695824623108,
-0.33169448375701904,
0.6701424717903137,
0.1186770647764206,
0.08916391432285309,
1.0469592809677124,
0.8442900776863098,
-0.8659055829048157,
0.9365332126617432,
-0.17999666929244995,
0.32175084948539734,
-0.45229196548461914,
-0.7930513620376587,
-0.5361011624336243,
-0.4224354922771454,
-0.17361924052238464,
-0.03756771609187126,
0.3400106728076935,
0.7532020807266235,
0.5816529989242554,
-0.9479029178619385,
0.04775483161211014,
-0.35917580127716064,
-0.008917972445487976,
-0.11737487465143204,
-0.1108103096485138,
0.10102692991495132,
-0.30316704511642456,
-0.7595561742782593,
0.7576731443405151,
-0.06534000486135483,
0.4832974970340729,
0.09311628341674805,
-0.2073519378900528,
-0.10316941887140274,
-0.02236555516719818,
0.324115514755249,
0.12876056134700775,
-0.8162536025047302,
-0.1943608969449997,
0.07164715230464935,
-0.2458319365978241,
0.13380639255046844,
0.7888221144676208,
-0.6587695479393005,
0.25102293491363525,
0.36541467905044556,
1.063137412071228,
0.3613830506801605,
0.15740966796875,
1.0081316232681274,
-1.2030881643295288,
-0.05556294694542885,
0.506102979183197,
0.4013068974018097,
0.26232609152793884,
-0.7606794238090515,
0.6340155005455017,
0.22975406050682068,
-0.33237382769584656,
-1.1614351272583008,
0.28280773758888245,
-0.5088474154472351,
-0.4851500689983368,
0.7997823357582092,
-0.1914266049861908,
-0.10971658676862717,
-0.2518990635871887,
-0.05977741256356239,
0.500801146030426,
-0.5397054553031921,
0.5814607739448547,
0.696054220199585,
0.07136707752943039,
-0.10542110353708267,
-0.7562552690505981,
0.41243767738342285,
0.8893487453460693,
-0.20812064409255981,
-0.12965072691440582,
0.36935630440711975,
-0.1673906147480011,
0.39372846484184265,
0.5002793669700623,
0.06738469004631042,
0.4596846103668213,
0.12337715178728104,
-0.0933733806014061,
-0.289120614528656,
-0.5030556917190552,
-0.36924728751182556,
0.06231158226728439,
-0.05965646728873253,
-0.5064392685890198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18915v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18915v1
|
Towards Faithful Chain-of-Thought: Large Language Models are Bridging Reasoners
| 2024-05-29T09:17:46 | 2024-05-29T09:17:46 |
Jiachun Li, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) suffer from serious unfaithful chain-of-thought
(CoT) issues. Previous work attempts to measure and explain it but lacks
in-depth analysis within CoTs and does not consider the interactions among all
reasoning components jointly. In this paper, we first study the CoT
faithfulness issue at the granularity of CoT steps, identify two reasoning
paradigms: centralized reasoning and distributed reasoning, and find their
relationship with faithfulness. Subsequently, we conduct a joint analysis of
the causal relevance among the context, CoT, and answer during reasoning. The
result proves that, when the LLM predicts answers, it can recall correct
information missing in the CoT from the context, leading to unfaithfulness
issues. Finally, we propose the inferential bridging method to mitigate this
issue, in which we use the attribution method to recall information as hints
for CoT generation and filter out noisy CoTs based on their semantic
consistency and attribution scores. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our
approach effectively alleviates the unfaithful CoT problem.
|
[
-0.42164403200149536,
-1.0371875762939453,
0.8453838229179382,
0.1421598196029663,
-0.48105302453041077,
0.22615401446819305,
-0.25517168641090393,
-0.4630662798881531,
-0.12415457516908646,
0.8399853706359863,
-0.4512895941734314,
-0.031043468043208122,
-0.4944855570793152,
-0.09475962817668915,
-0.556430995464325,
0.9126290082931519,
-0.4733830392360687,
0.03359748423099518,
-0.3668927550315857,
-0.06687435507774353,
-0.31455227732658386,
-0.5963286757469177,
-0.5845543146133423,
-0.6835443377494812,
0.4764067232608795,
0.22628919780254364,
0.9914997220039368,
0.3943238854408264,
0.45847439765930176,
0.24113115668296814,
-0.25450101494789124,
0.5085240602493286,
-0.7157784700393677,
0.3565010130405426,
-0.7358042001724243,
-0.4570119380950928,
-0.42946404218673706,
-0.13903175294399261,
0.7009494304656982,
0.7439867854118347,
-0.1750790923833847,
0.13804082572460175,
0.20888175070285797,
0.7998853921890259,
-0.8333480358123779,
-0.2689071297645569,
-1.0343012809753418,
-0.3233751952648163,
-0.2446088343858719,
-0.18659910559654236,
-0.5980768799781799,
-0.20656831562519073,
-0.09138325601816177,
-0.21842530369758606,
0.16599677503108978,
0.17353250086307526,
0.7223489284515381,
0.12770090997219086,
-0.604450523853302,
-0.4965243339538574,
-0.7183908820152283,
0.9187605977058411,
-0.7298504710197449,
0.39447203278541565,
0.5871464610099792,
-0.07263563573360443,
-0.7274419665336609,
-0.5238317251205444,
-0.609247624874115,
-0.0943775326013565,
-0.04692816361784935,
-0.035841044038534164,
-0.060439933091402054,
0.0760946199297905,
0.0013536823680624366,
0.4142737090587616,
-0.1559581458568573,
-0.3629353642463684,
0.011014504358172417,
-0.11346644908189774,
0.6789579391479492,
0.11015856266021729,
0.20482821762561798,
0.24144630134105682,
-0.5901510715484619,
0.21115082502365112,
-0.8279659152030945,
-0.1692042499780655,
0.27759045362472534,
0.034033697098493576,
0.10343953967094421,
0.46741482615470886,
0.4059273898601532,
0.5272610783576965,
0.1482628434896469,
-0.03077872097492218,
-0.20811976492404938,
-0.493873655796051,
-0.3213176727294922,
0.24266378581523895,
0.7178985476493835,
-0.05791860446333885,
0.40420496463775635,
-0.3360835015773773,
-0.4335988461971283,
0.09978356957435608,
0.6069956421852112,
-0.28590747714042664,
0.04180818423628807,
0.35106387734413147,
-0.2683733105659485,
-0.21303847432136536,
0.16213494539260864,
-0.5360044836997986,
-0.11650429666042328,
-0.3728344142436981,
0.21250107884407043,
-0.2887466549873352,
-0.4092528820037842,
0.06839468330144882,
-0.06278733909130096,
0.2190837562084198,
0.34102779626846313,
-0.6506515741348267,
0.5827652215957642,
0.789330005645752,
0.6454718708992004,
-0.012073994614183903,
-0.4484865367412567,
-0.43873104453086853,
0.5690056085586548,
-0.5525853633880615,
0.5742380023002625,
-0.589262068271637,
-0.19195015728473663,
-0.02493269369006157,
-0.0046089873649179935,
-0.07258933782577515,
-0.35044288635253906,
0.5370633006095886,
-0.6441739797592163,
-0.12238601595163345,
-0.6951102614402771,
-0.6324477791786194,
0.011089235544204712,
0.44708317518234253,
-0.5150102376937866,
0.8015362620353699,
-0.15123987197875977,
-0.9224184155464172,
0.044391028583049774,
-0.13595649600028992,
-0.13224036991596222,
-0.24062196910381317,
-0.31418508291244507,
-0.33849838376045227,
0.35976842045783997,
0.05502687394618988,
0.15779225528240204,
-0.4539794921875,
0.6378701329231262,
-0.47837433218955994,
-0.4629290699958801,
0.5772877931594849,
-0.7677862644195557,
0.8046595454216003,
0.2907717525959015,
-0.2132381796836853,
-0.10444636642932892,
-0.350166380405426,
-0.04055323824286461,
0.10466818511486053,
-0.16027405858039856,
-0.6141636371612549,
0.031186074018478394,
-0.2432432919740677,
0.19533297419548035,
0.14673292636871338,
-0.5559978485107422,
0.1111687421798706,
-0.29512664675712585,
0.22002843022346497,
1.0022658109664917,
0.20892328023910522,
0.47261762619018555,
-0.2819437086582184,
0.11524619907140732,
0.3894369602203369,
0.34232279658317566,
0.24862444400787354,
-0.4068382680416107,
-0.6679002642631531,
-0.07071173191070557,
0.01592501997947693,
0.04702426865696907,
-0.6549960374832153,
0.20156487822532654,
-0.03888509422540665,
-0.20568671822547913,
-0.34232035279273987,
0.28904232382774353,
0.890134871006012,
0.1781456023454666,
0.266655296087265,
-0.4892750084400177,
-0.2790873646736145,
-0.6333637833595276,
-0.5012115240097046,
-0.2873695492744446,
0.09752045571804047,
0.04694218561053276,
0.676150918006897,
-0.40428707003593445,
0.9890593886375427,
-0.1930280327796936,
0.015609098598361015,
-0.1256265789270401,
0.06549835205078125,
0.08253021538257599,
0.38120025396347046,
0.033912304788827896,
-0.7479349970817566,
-0.09979749470949173,
0.08485099673271179,
-0.803145170211792,
0.087158203125,
-0.13153211772441864,
-0.3873998522758484,
0.2807583212852478,
0.5500943660736084,
-0.5767142176628113,
0.37748751044273376,
0.43502429127693176,
-0.5551365613937378,
0.6837325692176819,
-0.34607043862342834,
0.0458773635327816,
-0.9040547609329224,
-0.030158672481775284,
-0.38554245233535767,
-0.30332961678504944,
-0.4628097712993622,
0.2786472737789154,
0.00431807292625308,
0.30880457162857056,
-0.23514869809150696,
0.3007429838180542,
-0.6355134844779968,
-0.018480468541383743,
-0.24286743998527527,
0.4124792516231537,
0.21447302401065826,
0.39732053875923157,
-0.4110810458660126,
0.6035870313644409,
0.3845621347427368,
-0.4961622357368469,
0.3677496314048767,
0.39758944511413574,
0.10556553304195404,
0.37404826283454895,
-0.44917547702789307,
0.24607239663600922,
-0.2333126962184906,
0.5641003847122192,
-0.8446953892707825,
-0.042408496141433716,
0.020917968824505806,
-0.38100171089172363,
0.13837586343288422,
-0.1209028959274292,
-0.6383437514305115,
-0.12704958021640778,
-0.2511545717716217,
0.8515300154685974,
0.15442253649234772,
-0.6894084811210632,
0.6992199420928955,
0.25420406460762024,
0.21814174950122833,
-0.7253575921058655,
-0.7497317790985107,
-0.08425963670015335,
-0.06412214785814285,
-0.5903231501579285,
0.2866485118865967,
0.259917289018631,
-0.6920257210731506,
0.02274014800786972,
-0.44594961404800415,
-0.2473350614309311,
-0.22570887207984924,
0.18841032683849335,
0.26455774903297424,
0.00280349631793797,
0.2380909025669098,
-0.1483410745859146,
-0.08505383878946304,
0.5211743116378784,
-0.16436293721199036,
0.5701991319656372,
-0.4550473392009735,
-0.5856870412826538,
-0.029477015137672424,
0.4856557548046112,
0.8147346377372742,
-0.3349757492542267,
0.882149875164032,
0.2589624226093292,
-0.32631489634513855,
-0.33635932207107544,
-0.8205078840255737,
-0.14715348184108734,
-0.46442124247550964,
-0.21408258378505707,
-0.27251243591308594,
-0.7480456233024597,
0.8999027609825134,
-0.2905516028404236,
0.00007144975825212896,
0.1707543432712555,
0.5543408393859863,
-0.0022930356208235025,
0.791059672832489,
0.4307839274406433,
-0.20098142325878143,
0.1745542734861374,
-0.14179901778697968,
0.5765244960784912,
-0.9759963750839233,
-0.3386363983154297,
-0.2966262996196747,
0.08731954544782639,
-0.5858372449874878,
-0.36530041694641113,
0.30968335270881653,
0.5596632957458496,
-0.5689709186553955,
0.11770438402891159,
-0.09810254722833633,
0.49717798829078674,
0.26578569412231445,
0.30753201246261597,
0.5149679780006409,
-0.18992440402507782,
-0.47503119707107544,
0.40455561876296997,
-0.614497184753418,
-0.6198756098747253,
0.8139052391052246,
0.38133683800697327,
0.9711306691169739,
0.29290685057640076,
0.5688100457191467,
0.0008871036698110402,
-0.0711163803935051,
-0.3299083709716797,
0.4452061653137207,
0.070839524269104,
-0.7749260663986206,
-0.2491452395915985,
-0.46587133407592773,
-0.7935827970504761,
0.20323342084884644,
-0.01114001963287592,
-1.0024785995483398,
0.28831300139427185,
0.05813375860452652,
-0.019116651266813278,
0.6241934299468994,
-0.31418147683143616,
0.4760998785495758,
-0.028804060071706772,
-0.9173369407653809,
-0.30745115876197815,
-0.7741220593452454,
0.7192284464836121,
-0.1245177835226059,
0.24673615396022797,
0.2142029106616974,
0.21523022651672363,
0.5271576046943665,
-0.681029736995697,
0.8168834447860718,
0.34383273124694824,
-0.4766979515552521,
0.5549445748329163,
0.3150065839290619,
0.8674011826515198,
0.20217595994472504,
0.059568844735622406,
0.11090589314699173,
0.06221935525536537,
-0.6542544364929199,
-0.710078239440918,
0.916647732257843,
-0.6527658700942993,
-0.5759815573692322,
-0.4422461986541748,
-0.515855610370636,
-0.3702399730682373,
-0.0006942479521967471,
0.19009888172149658,
0.49631866812705994,
0.03292694315314293,
0.004870570730417967,
1.2133857011795044,
0.1353609263896942,
0.47221311926841736,
0.26154470443725586,
-0.3722383379936218,
-0.3319106101989746,
0.5201601386070251,
-0.08371149003505707,
0.7862153649330139,
0.02378467284142971,
0.14622832834720612,
-0.2276168018579483,
-0.1830722540616989,
-0.33944907784461975,
0.4018609821796417,
-0.7974871397018433,
-0.2266501784324646,
-0.4446735978126526,
-0.2450663298368454,
0.04690631851553917,
-0.4080607295036316,
-0.8699259161949158,
0.20802810788154602,
0.06493085622787476,
0.0496239997446537,
0.28659018874168396,
0.8061068654060364,
0.2761320173740387,
-0.0006076900754123926,
-0.6953529715538025,
0.37480834126472473,
0.2820875644683838,
0.538709819316864,
0.3929014503955841,
-0.30184853076934814,
0.02970152162015438,
0.34860941767692566,
-0.478677898645401,
-0.7671017646789551,
-0.11872322112321854,
-0.31431853771209717,
0.5407736301422119,
0.6420390605926514,
0.2984062433242798,
0.9374873638153076,
-0.2058107852935791,
0.7457740306854248,
0.33647939562797546,
-1.1702940464019775,
0.550900399684906,
-0.33644697070121765,
0.19475147128105164,
0.6072738766670227,
0.3131439983844757,
-0.28816887736320496,
-0.8449938297271729,
-0.8712918758392334,
-0.9201511144638062,
0.2303360402584076,
0.5199577808380127,
-0.01354591641575098,
-0.30829983949661255,
0.4971637427806854,
0.06265412271022797,
0.06793100386857986,
-0.7096172571182251,
-0.1413191258907318,
0.20101824402809143,
0.148723766207695,
0.1651594638824463,
-0.2869971990585327,
-0.26778534054756165,
-0.36907750368118286,
0.7961199283599854,
-0.03799092769622803,
0.26825058460235596,
0.588801383972168,
-0.0588710643351078,
-0.7263191342353821,
0.2972431182861328,
0.43509146571159363,
1.0808254480361938,
-0.10015736520290375,
0.630416750907898,
0.3046148717403412,
-0.4501224756240845,
0.21140065789222717,
-0.7128939628601074,
0.13367648422718048,
0.054391395300626755,
0.7285186052322388,
0.4431062638759613,
0.16899237036705017,
-0.5295619964599609,
0.825069785118103,
0.02523702196776867,
-0.03665558621287346,
-0.5000647306442261,
-0.050500378012657166,
0.08442115783691406,
0.2611069083213806,
0.10934966802597046,
0.1965908706188202,
-0.13590097427368164,
-1.1414726972579956,
0.26461711525917053,
0.8050686120986938,
-0.6346186995506287,
-0.09901196509599686,
0.3873407542705536,
-0.11281921714544296,
-0.09920376539230347,
0.8601685166358948,
-0.08833836019039154,
-0.7159527540206909,
0.36274322867393494,
0.8390834927558899,
0.7265328168869019,
-0.18174472451210022,
0.028836481273174286,
0.01698179543018341,
0.35795748233795166,
-0.42043933272361755,
0.284039705991745,
-0.020461466163396835,
-0.870240330696106,
-0.5074639320373535,
-0.5296712517738342,
-0.373085081577301,
-0.031421512365341187,
-0.8747460246086121,
0.040045686066150665,
-0.2787584364414215,
-0.0020422048401087523,
-0.4421086311340332,
0.02750769443809986,
-0.362613707780838,
0.08925573527812958,
0.042967792600393295,
0.809221088886261,
-0.8262076377868652,
0.9464632868766785,
0.31246134638786316,
-0.5064249634742737,
-0.9054694771766663,
0.3475385308265686,
-0.13266079127788544,
-0.6868932247161865,
0.11369458585977554,
-0.15263034403324127,
-0.6092855334281921,
-0.1835150569677353,
-0.6880152225494385,
-0.6678353548049927,
1.0556172132492065,
0.4696611762046814,
-0.7561767101287842,
0.12407807260751724,
0.2561744451522827,
0.3979819118976593,
-0.39134925603866577,
0.2307433933019638,
0.7406675219535828,
0.34665679931640625,
0.27370303869247437,
-1.041479229927063,
0.36238205432891846,
-0.023949269205331802,
-0.0470648854970932,
0.5972711443901062,
-0.5899406671524048,
0.7684436440467834,
-0.23939712345600128,
-0.04757696017622948,
-0.2083013653755188,
0.33518216013908386,
0.5351186990737915,
0.466476172208786,
0.4442685544490814,
0.5787906646728516,
0.8132892847061157,
0.07918334752321243,
0.8886294960975647,
0.05589192360639572,
0.4659588634967804,
1.0934711694717407,
-0.2682859003543854,
0.8260895609855652,
1.0028735399246216,
-0.1326848715543747,
0.6671437621116638,
0.2044672667980194,
0.3302278518676758,
0.5010044574737549,
0.43824076652526855,
-0.5356921553611755,
-0.44455644488334656,
-0.2328033447265625,
-0.24976012110710144,
0.39162182807922363,
0.21078471839427948,
-0.5689132809638977,
-0.3374953866004944,
-0.1794208288192749,
0.15731719136238098,
0.2777538001537323,
-0.5637872219085693,
0.8981034755706787,
0.379875510931015,
-0.6076034903526306,
0.8563352227210999,
-0.3097865879535675,
0.24490593373775482,
-0.5871104001998901,
0.015095822513103485,
-0.16021545231342316,
0.4398137032985687,
-0.21049079298973083,
-0.8978518843650818,
0.5178486704826355,
-0.07584307342767715,
-0.17300108075141907,
-0.1055448055267334,
0.7552925944328308,
-0.42595651745796204,
-0.4060559868812561,
0.7030693292617798,
0.6466055512428284,
0.07147581875324249,
-0.12722447514533997,
-0.363587349653244,
0.2897961437702179,
-0.1894964575767517,
-0.2285109907388687,
0.2837911546230316,
0.8613631129264832,
-0.5057364702224731,
0.8846789002418518,
0.5819752812385559,
0.04055235534906387,
-0.06547006219625473,
0.10654135793447495,
1.3410773277282715,
-0.6886349320411682,
-0.21592625975608826,
-1.2666430473327637,
0.4056904911994934,
-0.15743792057037354,
-0.1744707226753235,
0.6287662982940674,
0.4058024287223816,
0.8416610360145569,
0.19652049243450165,
0.4911944568157196,
0.24385133385658264,
-0.09650147706270218,
-0.5138163566589355,
0.6129713654518127,
-0.3110504448413849,
0.4567578434944153,
-0.5515789985656738,
-0.9895376563072205,
-0.1181044727563858,
0.31916072964668274,
-0.2283695638179779,
-0.17975279688835144,
1.115383505821228,
0.665736973285675,
-0.3117424249649048,
0.3569006621837616,
0.3021584153175354,
0.2940365672111511,
0.2064913809299469,
0.6725735068321228,
0.8966265320777893,
-0.49708667397499084,
0.226249560713768,
-0.05898892134428024,
-0.14868168532848358,
0.0347740612924099,
-0.9216926693916321,
-0.916049599647522,
-0.49988865852355957,
-0.09449205547571182,
-0.4715428948402405,
0.32060837745666504,
0.8699501752853394,
0.19794823229312897,
-0.7218483686447144,
-0.21416014432907104,
-0.8350023031234741,
0.32340630888938904,
-0.4008036255836487,
-0.17053131759166718,
0.2424318790435791,
-0.45250430703163147,
0.04715285077691078,
-0.00581803685054183,
0.20958517491817474,
-0.20846879482269287,
-0.4804573655128479,
-0.2010844498872757,
-0.3843148648738861,
0.5158212780952454,
0.5746341943740845,
-0.34894704818725586,
-1.084191918373108,
-0.4671598970890045,
-0.4824831783771515,
-0.011197231709957123,
-0.2131342887878418,
1.0122921466827393,
-0.5411609411239624,
0.31856009364128113,
0.3592100441455841,
0.3252840042114258,
0.23406794667243958,
0.23255808651447296,
0.7819274663925171,
-0.6431892514228821,
-0.08914992213249207,
0.24108746647834778,
0.48947691917419434,
0.0793328806757927,
-0.49355071783065796,
0.22517931461334229,
0.01702110655605793,
-0.8724431395530701,
-0.8504460453987122,
0.5291911363601685,
-0.9684698581695557,
-0.5111899971961975,
1.1635781526565552,
-0.35856500267982483,
-0.5119249224662781,
-0.4716686010360718,
-0.11798928678035736,
0.4664848744869232,
-0.12422899901866913,
0.8680204153060913,
0.9662966132164001,
0.018655475229024887,
0.02117099240422249,
-0.3577367663383484,
0.43772876262664795,
0.2620275616645813,
-0.40791672468185425,
0.6605780720710754,
0.1820278763771057,
0.15472526848316193,
0.2591513395309448,
0.5590003132820129,
-0.3115321695804596,
0.06765028089284897,
0.22660599648952484,
-0.29848453402519226,
0.12933610379695892,
-0.4900069236755371,
-0.05971138924360275,
0.012849761173129082,
0.22299949824810028,
0.09291985630989075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18906v1
|
Language Generation with Strictly Proper Scoring Rules
| 2024-05-29T09:09:00 | 2024-05-29T09:09:00 |
Chenze Shao, Fandong Meng, Yijin Liu, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language generation based on maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) has become
the fundamental approach for text generation. Maximum likelihood estimation is
typically performed by minimizing the log-likelihood loss, also known as the
logarithmic score in statistical decision theory. The logarithmic score is
strictly proper in the sense that it encourages honest forecasts, where the
expected score is maximized only when the model reports true probabilities.
Although many strictly proper scoring rules exist, the logarithmic score is the
only local scoring rule among them that depends exclusively on the probability
of the observed sample, making it capable of handling the exponentially large
sample space of natural text. In this work, we propose a straightforward
strategy for adapting scoring rules to language generation, allowing for
language modeling with any non-local scoring rules. Leveraging this strategy,
we train language generation models using two classic strictly proper scoring
rules, the Brier score and the Spherical score, as alternatives to the
logarithmic score. Experimental results indicate that simply substituting the
loss function, without adjusting other hyperparameters, can yield substantial
improvements in model's generation capabilities. Moreover, these improvements
can scale up to large language models (LLMs) such as LLaMA-7B and LLaMA-13B.
Source code: \url{https://github.com/shaochenze/ScoringRulesLM}.
|
[
-0.13530920445919037,
-1.0157668590545654,
0.5955098271369934,
0.48414939641952515,
-0.3072977364063263,
-0.39419546723365784,
-0.417618066072464,
-0.3313394784927368,
-0.09252641350030899,
0.7882652282714844,
-0.2191908061504364,
-0.8185161352157593,
-0.12005923688411713,
0.01740608736872673,
-0.1609196960926056,
1.3209214210510254,
0.15230664610862732,
-0.22525432705879211,
-0.21414785087108612,
-0.0811968445777893,
-0.48827385902404785,
-0.6003492474555969,
-0.6617813110351562,
-0.20189566910266876,
0.4826291799545288,
0.39553388953208923,
0.5230845808982849,
0.8481924533843994,
0.39903369545936584,
0.14346209168434143,
0.03893527761101723,
0.213135227560997,
-0.6344965696334839,
0.22948533296585083,
-0.076595239341259,
-0.5176995396614075,
-0.48221635818481445,
-0.13697564601898193,
0.741644024848938,
0.637000560760498,
-0.4799374043941498,
0.32208070158958435,
0.039094142615795135,
0.6161482930183411,
-0.40543419122695923,
0.18069157004356384,
-0.8413136601448059,
0.16065339744091034,
-0.15562087297439575,
-0.5767068862915039,
-0.8839690685272217,
-0.6653652787208557,
-0.25777989625930786,
-0.35203516483306885,
0.29139044880867004,
0.1608724445104599,
0.8001483678817749,
-0.18265648186206818,
-0.2970324456691742,
-0.1467539668083191,
-0.7730948328971863,
1.1032681465148926,
-0.7907477021217346,
0.16170813143253326,
0.2513369023799896,
0.24868004024028778,
-0.37224510312080383,
-0.22510485351085663,
-0.22855249047279358,
-0.4337424337863922,
0.2059958279132843,
-0.036550771445035934,
-0.2880384624004364,
0.12110015004873276,
0.25173482298851013,
0.3316028118133545,
-0.7020789980888367,
0.1186019703745842,
-0.3589320182800293,
-0.16480743885040283,
1.1074334383010864,
0.17800761759281158,
0.06367997080087662,
-0.19223512709140778,
-0.2877987325191498,
0.0559195950627327,
-0.8783172965049744,
0.04675945267081261,
0.6295542120933533,
0.6865116357803345,
-0.10954277217388153,
0.5450243949890137,
-0.11447621136903763,
0.8021891117095947,
0.25242140889167786,
-0.3129681646823883,
-0.09834571927785873,
-0.25164535641670227,
-0.3223053216934204,
0.16258904337882996,
0.904758870601654,
0.5970063805580139,
0.4687495827674866,
-0.08917946368455887,
-0.3965337872505188,
0.012144973501563072,
0.17943920195102692,
-0.643259584903717,
-0.4669381082057953,
-0.11945559084415436,
-0.1437946856021881,
-0.6772513389587402,
-0.2887200117111206,
-0.721752405166626,
-0.15071217715740204,
-0.11688896268606186,
0.3504071831703186,
-0.4350794553756714,
-0.09002693742513657,
-0.09525389969348907,
0.09217900037765503,
0.22713226079940796,
0.10906700044870377,
-0.9012872576713562,
0.33750951290130615,
0.20784766972064972,
0.7162396311759949,
-0.02922474965453148,
-0.005668999627232552,
-0.7918573021888733,
0.029154224321246147,
-0.8069514036178589,
0.8820047378540039,
-0.4636969268321991,
-0.48592790961265564,
0.15296272933483124,
-0.34457340836524963,
-0.13402627408504486,
-0.6163684129714966,
0.768237292766571,
-0.3646951913833618,
0.5377954840660095,
0.17514647543430328,
-0.7826863527297974,
-0.2573585510253906,
-0.028503263369202614,
-0.42842742800712585,
1.2021974325180054,
-0.062350764870643616,
-0.3982926607131958,
0.46620655059814453,
-0.6990242004394531,
-0.6420745849609375,
0.04658611863851547,
0.12076598405838013,
-0.48647481203079224,
0.3484939634799957,
0.18136915564537048,
0.4741847515106201,
-0.24686624109745026,
0.3839404881000519,
-0.24445225298404694,
-0.15229187905788422,
0.04350496083498001,
-0.6844747066497803,
0.5949834585189819,
0.11099308729171753,
-0.3074941635131836,
-0.068714939057827,
-0.8103591799736023,
0.3018867075443268,
0.1235051304101944,
-0.7617993354797363,
-0.04476868733763695,
0.010377630591392517,
0.34137189388275146,
-0.06483419984579086,
0.15457569062709808,
-0.30582287907600403,
0.0784691721200943,
-0.4667114317417145,
-0.15204618871212006,
0.9004641175270081,
0.16304031014442444,
0.6108688116073608,
-0.5623143911361694,
0.39066579937934875,
-0.21973781287670135,
0.17322008311748505,
-0.14497965574264526,
-0.6230176687240601,
-0.6746892333030701,
-0.3240426778793335,
0.434143990278244,
0.6035444736480713,
-0.18125547468662262,
0.7950244545936584,
-0.19651420414447784,
-0.6563225388526917,
-0.5727376937866211,
0.5430136322975159,
0.2000323086977005,
0.3774854838848114,
0.22254259884357452,
-0.10901932418346405,
-0.6843029260635376,
-0.6952856779098511,
-0.40455541014671326,
-0.36856144666671753,
0.07793040573596954,
0.201248899102211,
0.061597906053066254,
0.10304048657417297,
0.9149332046508789,
-0.4341578483581543,
-0.259127676486969,
-0.5671411156654358,
-0.12416516244411469,
0.47647202014923096,
0.5033661127090454,
0.3855454623699188,
-0.5173003673553467,
-0.4714227020740509,
0.14550741016864777,
-0.801588773727417,
-0.35964950919151306,
-0.3098025918006897,
-0.10724019259214401,
0.5635198354721069,
0.21469368040561676,
-0.533685028553009,
0.3548312187194824,
0.8096559643745422,
-0.3605636954307556,
0.743590772151947,
-0.32071301341056824,
0.038457997143268585,
-0.9781296849250793,
0.060948386788368225,
0.301771342754364,
-0.6459928154945374,
-0.8614637851715088,
0.1942806839942932,
-0.3220817446708679,
-0.009624077007174492,
-0.2680332064628601,
0.6122693419456482,
-0.12314064055681229,
0.2464887797832489,
-0.22854167222976685,
0.07584990561008453,
0.20948685705661774,
0.46237367391586304,
-0.018696697428822517,
0.3314575254917145,
0.517902135848999,
-0.8561000823974609,
0.3312663435935974,
-0.31814074516296387,
-0.48932886123657227,
0.423929899930954,
-0.5473021268844604,
0.18560397624969482,
-0.2957209646701813,
0.11514143645763397,
-0.7671011686325073,
-0.11385611444711685,
-0.021165715530514717,
-0.35254791378974915,
0.42893096804618835,
-0.05190457031130791,
-0.40911808609962463,
0.13396991789340973,
-0.4246513843536377,
0.22051328420639038,
0.7566083669662476,
-0.5690931081771851,
0.5168258547782898,
0.35134080052375793,
-0.18325002491474152,
-0.164006307721138,
-0.5040013194084167,
0.0475681908428669,
-0.4116232991218567,
-0.5752964615821838,
0.1391737014055252,
-0.33705106377601624,
-0.28428757190704346,
-0.26261529326438904,
0.07839291542768478,
0.11810857802629471,
-0.1255677491426468,
0.121071957051754,
0.2750146985054016,
-0.6168500781059265,
0.05044851824641228,
0.14443553984165192,
0.025266926735639572,
-0.21409332752227783,
-0.2376643270254135,
0.4781826138496399,
-0.0019746453035622835,
-0.048921193927526474,
-0.3681299090385437,
0.35568344593048096,
0.4776228666305542,
-0.028935378417372704,
0.698580265045166,
0.3688758909702301,
-0.37053242325782776,
-0.4291127026081085,
-0.6587356925010681,
-0.1340293288230896,
-0.4473206400871277,
0.4330729842185974,
-0.490006685256958,
-0.6664714813232422,
0.11757136136293411,
0.17021895945072174,
0.3381122052669525,
0.5175638794898987,
0.7994132041931152,
-0.20784710347652435,
1.2343777418136597,
0.9060410261154175,
-0.09868831187486649,
0.19274699687957764,
0.122443288564682,
0.44311976432800293,
-0.47930923104286194,
0.08811298757791519,
-0.3835773468017578,
0.18367990851402283,
-0.6738515496253967,
-0.4017730951309204,
0.27532461285591125,
0.52061527967453,
0.07993607968091965,
0.23341749608516693,
-0.243974506855011,
0.7070018649101257,
0.4257011413574219,
-0.14742280542850494,
0.22416476905345917,
0.32637107372283936,
-0.2824958860874176,
-0.07284855842590332,
-0.9510260820388794,
-0.8577324748039246,
1.0317422151565552,
0.44489312171936035,
0.604656457901001,
0.17696981132030487,
1.0511096715927124,
0.3582174479961395,
0.5111864805221558,
-0.6567452549934387,
0.5998331904411316,
-0.16549405455589294,
-0.6290180683135986,
-0.43631869554519653,
-0.8632674813270569,
-0.7864257097244263,
0.0632283017039299,
-0.22814463078975677,
-0.734298586845398,
-0.2237781584262848,
0.22482481598854065,
-0.23826326429843903,
0.2630629241466522,
-0.6394780874252319,
0.9728677272796631,
-0.0035517311189323664,
-0.23561306297779083,
-0.0857875719666481,
0.00036102833109907806,
0.5179184675216675,
-0.31667840480804443,
0.586262047290802,
-0.3672780692577362,
0.23430505394935608,
0.7250407934188843,
-0.15540532767772675,
0.8708443641662598,
-0.2712459862232208,
-0.27318230271339417,
0.5292714834213257,
0.5137968063354492,
0.3857906758785248,
0.061353832483291626,
-0.3021649718284607,
0.04133525863289833,
0.03698084503412247,
-0.5806477665901184,
-0.5618476867675781,
0.8347612619400024,
-0.5137195587158203,
-0.5227251052856445,
-0.20582552254199982,
-0.4993419051170349,
0.024707695469260216,
0.025373121723532677,
0.3969779312610626,
0.38290145993232727,
-0.3308190107345581,
-0.04880215600132942,
0.4923655092716217,
-0.14244703948497772,
0.39366698265075684,
0.3450835347175598,
-0.41873154044151306,
-0.34832894802093506,
1.1141732931137085,
-0.1446661502122879,
0.268999308347702,
0.4448215961456299,
0.5015145540237427,
-0.45541155338287354,
-0.33884406089782715,
-0.6189661622047424,
0.26079311966896057,
-0.7196943163871765,
-0.25053954124450684,
-0.12922033667564392,
-0.12986397743225098,
-0.392213374376297,
-0.2159736156463623,
-0.13756753504276276,
-0.2959851026535034,
-0.10984126478433609,
-0.29977717995643616,
0.2762909531593323,
0.6396442651748657,
-0.21150165796279907,
0.0601232573390007,
-0.8629786372184753,
0.0013956333277747035,
0.1320400983095169,
0.26657834649086,
-0.2134169340133667,
-0.8712369799613953,
-0.18602262437343597,
-0.039022043347358704,
-0.30255600810050964,
-0.7158218026161194,
0.27288952469825745,
0.7042732238769531,
0.5456021428108215,
0.33236420154571533,
0.009765933267772198,
0.6422678232192993,
-0.7171408534049988,
0.6904198527336121,
0.36044177412986755,
-0.8170525431632996,
0.6443586945533752,
-0.3106812834739685,
0.36788585782051086,
0.34012359380722046,
0.14996692538261414,
-0.5246159434318542,
-0.7489620447158813,
-0.5361998081207275,
-0.5641152858734131,
0.5136767029762268,
0.28398433327674866,
0.6596189737319946,
-0.12281504273414612,
0.15295545756816864,
0.28275054693222046,
-0.09878593683242798,
-1.0767139196395874,
-0.04662282019853592,
-0.03977302834391594,
-0.7784196138381958,
-0.2767329514026642,
-0.07847755402326584,
0.046865157783031464,
-0.039157770574092865,
0.9515900611877441,
-0.08815690875053406,
0.027703750878572464,
-0.023531176149845123,
-0.1577189862728119,
-0.47728249430656433,
0.18259873986244202,
0.6363202929496765,
0.4178912341594696,
-0.2352227419614792,
-0.058045659214258194,
0.3018551468849182,
-0.31148800253868103,
0.1599210947751999,
-0.2768949568271637,
-0.3594712018966675,
0.24233920872211456,
0.6111451387405396,
0.8692131638526917,
0.22699230909347534,
-0.734538197517395,
0.42992353439331055,
0.057728249579668045,
-0.40419983863830566,
-0.1153019443154335,
0.17991648614406586,
-0.021575666964054108,
0.042740922421216965,
0.404072105884552,
0.045360833406448364,
-0.24765834212303162,
-0.5574484467506409,
0.26444727182388306,
0.14189261198043823,
-0.4896114766597748,
-0.3118121027946472,
0.4343084394931793,
-0.0383443720638752,
-0.3635258972644806,
0.35690557956695557,
-0.3150939345359802,
-0.14770568907260895,
0.2949954569339752,
0.7956119179725647,
0.6925115585327148,
-0.5069177150726318,
0.5060386061668396,
0.5080657601356506,
0.38224005699157715,
0.03462081775069237,
0.1860600709915161,
-0.03655533120036125,
-0.6881639361381531,
-0.5658001899719238,
-1.278099775314331,
0.020980047062039375,
-0.038943953812122345,
-0.3447084128856659,
0.2738914489746094,
-0.7014504671096802,
-0.14775192737579346,
0.054276179522275925,
-0.09085089713335037,
-0.49416303634643555,
0.4997756779193878,
0.3399582803249359,
0.8122474551200867,
-0.8005476593971252,
0.7319573760032654,
0.5562783479690552,
-0.1960955560207367,
-0.715606153011322,
-0.1142667904496193,
-0.1604580581188202,
-0.5554397106170654,
0.44100674986839294,
0.09767762571573257,
0.040296707302331924,
0.07009150087833405,
-0.276266485452652,
-0.5402382016181946,
0.5774865746498108,
0.3577917218208313,
-0.5555611848831177,
-0.14304180443286896,
0.2916935384273529,
0.5555260181427002,
-0.5202518105506897,
0.12121354788541794,
0.5186659097671509,
0.33494603633880615,
-0.09982335567474365,
-0.7685531377792358,
0.04447133466601372,
-0.00469910679385066,
0.16140857338905334,
0.3445391058921814,
-0.2248135209083557,
0.41243600845336914,
-0.35683673620224,
-0.2735145688056946,
0.29515644907951355,
0.5731492042541504,
0.4614332914352417,
0.2211088389158249,
0.5284135341644287,
0.5022268891334534,
0.8209234476089478,
0.06816963851451874,
1.0461947917938232,
-0.21772843599319458,
0.3703175485134125,
0.5985559821128845,
-0.17557111382484436,
1.0706425905227661,
0.2712516486644745,
-0.19218917191028595,
0.5469257831573486,
0.43042951822280884,
0.06084383651614189,
0.39548781514167786,
0.3447868824005127,
-0.36638936400413513,
-0.47414055466651917,
-0.058736953884363174,
0.11457354575395584,
0.7019588351249695,
0.14958052337169647,
-0.3174651563167572,
-0.172600656747818,
-0.24978595972061157,
0.08756130188703537,
0.41031208634376526,
-0.3210128843784332,
0.8329516053199768,
0.14614541828632355,
-0.5211820006370544,
0.9283110499382019,
0.4062787592411041,
0.51313316822052,
-0.6023826003074646,
-0.0066373879089951515,
-0.37537485361099243,
0.03755274787545204,
-0.24522680044174194,
-0.4598888158798218,
0.10203376412391663,
0.33683067560195923,
-0.3788767457008362,
0.10191468149423599,
0.41171208024024963,
-0.5725229382514954,
-1.100927710533142,
0.14777880907058716,
0.20892547070980072,
0.2524610459804535,
0.15477436780929565,
-0.4272257089614868,
-0.03106928989291191,
0.16976717114448547,
-0.2175634652376175,
0.2932431697845459,
0.3830450475215912,
-0.15218687057495117,
0.4228210747241974,
0.9523499608039856,
0.25077125430107117,
0.3155739903450012,
0.1454562097787857,
0.26577043533325195,
-0.7367079257965088,
-0.33939722180366516,
-1.0149255990982056,
0.45218876004219055,
0.017781531438231468,
-0.35265931487083435,
0.578600287437439,
0.6573866605758667,
0.5424031019210815,
-0.20953857898712158,
0.7067238688468933,
0.27218008041381836,
0.2707999348640442,
-0.6627062559127808,
0.5769966840744019,
-0.4533701539039612,
-0.016636086627840996,
-0.3317033350467682,
-1.4923650026321411,
-0.6861490607261658,
0.6033071875572205,
-0.22601279616355896,
-0.017287470400333405,
0.5326808094978333,
0.9711784720420837,
0.11811615526676178,
-0.07455797493457794,
0.7797653079032898,
0.14836888015270233,
0.45025861263275146,
0.6696640849113464,
0.591221272945404,
-0.4967668354511261,
0.645151674747467,
-0.1284300982952118,
-0.4594423472881317,
-0.2729315459728241,
-0.9658157825469971,
-0.8470775485038757,
-0.3160162568092346,
-0.4235309660434723,
-0.09597171097993851,
0.13269124925136566,
0.7889397144317627,
0.6526723504066467,
-0.8133972883224487,
-0.6043409109115601,
-0.0967126116156578,
0.09109621495008469,
-0.1460675299167633,
-0.3506685495376587,
0.19992171227931976,
-0.6731958985328674,
-0.5980836153030396,
0.5842095017433167,
0.382886677980423,
-0.02285267598927021,
-0.051290664821863174,
-0.3678661286830902,
-0.14185182750225067,
0.4109208881855011,
0.7204572558403015,
0.2272414118051529,
-0.5414780974388123,
-0.3054370880126953,
-0.13807141780853271,
-0.15132823586463928,
0.012962204404175282,
0.5177587866783142,
-0.5612585544586182,
0.351550817489624,
0.14455164968967438,
0.33981847763061523,
0.2594653367996216,
-0.09115297347307205,
0.8498138785362244,
-0.9377599358558655,
-0.06758345663547516,
0.2733292877674103,
0.23632463812828064,
0.6669532060623169,
-0.23015853762626648,
0.10997183620929718,
0.14291715621948242,
-0.506394624710083,
-1.032089352607727,
0.256667822599411,
-0.685498833656311,
-0.027458367869257927,
1.0491522550582886,
0.022633826360106468,
-0.34175166487693787,
0.1700940728187561,
-0.27485543489456177,
0.15271161496639252,
-0.2965192198753357,
0.8361642956733704,
0.4630851745605469,
0.09321224689483643,
-0.11584582179784775,
-0.48665934801101685,
0.5239911079406738,
0.5222665071487427,
-0.48278388381004333,
0.1375560462474823,
0.3969450294971466,
0.31985053420066833,
0.15598073601722717,
0.5347530841827393,
-0.06847099214792252,
0.44695398211479187,
0.056362953037023544,
0.07303614169359207,
0.32287150621414185,
-0.36746883392333984,
-0.27247002720832825,
0.24219803512096405,
0.4330771565437317,
0.06295700371265411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16899v1
|
Prompt-based vs. Fine-tuned LLMs Toward Causal Graph Verification
| 2024-05-29T09:06:18 | 2024-05-29T09:06:18 |
Yuni Susanti, Nina Holsmoelle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This work aims toward an application of natural language processing (NLP)
technology for automatic verification of causal graphs using text sources. A
causal graph is often derived from unsupervised causal discovery methods and
requires manual evaluation from human experts. NLP technologies, i.e., Large
Language Models (LLMs) such as BERT and ChatGPT, can potentially be used to
verify the resulted causal graph by predicting if causal relation can be
observed between node pairs based on the textual context. In this work, we
compare the performance of two types of NLP models: (1) Pre-trained language
models fine-tuned for causal relation classification task and, (2) prompt-based
LLMs. Contrasted to previous studies where prompt-based LLMs work relatively
well over a set of diverse tasks, preliminary experiments on biomedical and
open-domain datasets suggest that the fine-tuned models far outperform the
prompt-based LLMs, up to 20.5 points improvement of F1 score. We shared the
code and the pre-processed datasets in our repository.
|
[
-0.08771680295467377,
-1.15179443359375,
0.7895418405532837,
0.4649517834186554,
-0.15971367061138153,
-0.02914334088563919,
-0.2436806708574295,
-0.7627328038215637,
-0.0029235563706606627,
0.48574888706207275,
-0.5746585130691528,
-0.5853546261787415,
-0.5056291818618774,
0.646236777305603,
-0.29591214656829834,
0.8939467668533325,
0.006243647541850805,
0.27693939208984375,
-0.4944932758808136,
0.09820988774299622,
-0.6782196164131165,
-0.37475672364234924,
-1.1329361200332642,
-0.6502684950828552,
0.8039680123329163,
-0.0033494269009679556,
0.5440556406974792,
0.477641224861145,
0.5808941721916199,
0.3227096199989319,
-0.20497258007526398,
0.49942025542259216,
-0.35482466220855713,
0.09624824672937393,
-0.29800426959991455,
-0.13307151198387146,
-0.3372560441493988,
-0.09845336526632309,
0.34664541482925415,
0.8267905116081238,
0.3430474102497101,
0.1701209992170334,
0.3852171003818512,
0.5445030927658081,
-0.27812767028808594,
0.4909292161464691,
-0.3488312363624573,
-0.18463829159736633,
0.08182869106531143,
-0.4091779589653015,
-0.6717087626457214,
-0.6357353925704956,
0.21245244145393372,
-0.4663510322570801,
0.21708831191062927,
0.30320775508880615,
0.9031444191932678,
0.4613354504108429,
-0.6938812732696533,
-0.28098368644714355,
-0.6888190507888794,
0.3889583647251129,
-0.675982654094696,
0.3433828055858612,
0.34062257409095764,
0.12202693521976471,
-0.559196412563324,
-1.0612387657165527,
-0.320341557264328,
-0.5065012574195862,
-0.24741365015506744,
-0.05983767285943031,
-0.28057023882865906,
0.22197675704956055,
0.5511677861213684,
0.026898158714175224,
-0.6406728029251099,
0.5847007036209106,
-0.0681796595454216,
-0.42131805419921875,
0.6182014346122742,
0.29721716046333313,
0.3071848750114441,
-0.46220672130584717,
-0.32970505952835083,
0.16714657843112946,
-0.7885788679122925,
0.0921364426612854,
0.1725907027721405,
0.6760538220405579,
-0.07042651623487473,
0.6892341375350952,
-0.4025484025478363,
0.9531851410865784,
-0.029678842052817345,
0.08192133158445358,
0.015418999828398228,
-0.39304792881011963,
-0.21442629396915436,
-0.015736158937215805,
0.9632852673530579,
0.43604761362075806,
0.4921051263809204,
-0.3868192732334137,
-0.03515574336051941,
-0.019106926396489143,
-0.11703725904226303,
-0.6905146837234497,
-0.13329944014549255,
0.06676744669675827,
-0.5080510377883911,
0.08639620244503021,
-0.3070736825466156,
-0.33921676874160767,
-0.551926851272583,
-0.6472454071044922,
0.2884896397590637,
-0.4711586833000183,
0.2524310052394867,
0.2489900141954422,
0.007246765308082104,
0.07708383351564407,
0.6795529127120972,
-0.43025219440460205,
0.11773169040679932,
0.6905168294906616,
1.0284006595611572,
-0.26349198818206787,
-0.15460561215877533,
-0.5664869546890259,
-0.1593949794769287,
-0.17057400941848755,
0.9941848516464233,
-0.2457238733768463,
-0.19195742905139923,
0.10944544523954391,
0.18186213076114655,
-0.22982822358608246,
-0.2161056250333786,
0.855190634727478,
-0.753639280796051,
0.23865480720996857,
-0.4947957396507263,
-0.9630496501922607,
-0.031948018819093704,
0.2711926996707916,
-0.6663641333580017,
0.8340417146682739,
-0.13525374233722687,
-0.9361276030540466,
0.5107150673866272,
-0.4844929575920105,
-0.5625190734863281,
0.12641696631908417,
-0.08122912794351578,
-0.23988227546215057,
-0.2963355481624603,
0.25990593433380127,
0.7123861908912659,
-0.5100423097610474,
0.7442731261253357,
-0.5675457119941711,
-0.18397043645381927,
0.30003026127815247,
-0.5340047478675842,
0.8612743020057678,
0.07952851802110672,
-0.16715458035469055,
0.3854101300239563,
-0.9532385468482971,
-0.08948380500078201,
0.011338697746396065,
-0.23304113745689392,
-0.3149631917476654,
0.26205670833587646,
-0.008320908062160015,
0.27291354537010193,
0.2812991142272949,
-0.6115333437919617,
0.12196812778711319,
-0.46412354707717896,
0.3381367027759552,
0.7622081637382507,
0.2469675987958908,
0.016605684533715248,
-0.3134096562862396,
0.20099006593227386,
-0.3104817271232605,
-0.0009939863812178373,
-0.05532826483249664,
-0.7808335423469543,
-0.5305071473121643,
-0.16730041801929474,
0.30387091636657715,
0.6547511219978333,
-0.7920486927032471,
0.7797496914863586,
-0.084722600877285,
-0.5482117533683777,
0.006056535057723522,
-0.16552765667438507,
0.2974332571029663,
1.1342195272445679,
0.5201314091682434,
0.011722016148269176,
-0.40017756819725037,
-0.7084168791770935,
-0.4200524389743805,
-0.3118210732936859,
-0.15082553029060364,
0.4494153559207916,
0.33896130323410034,
-0.33458971977233887,
1.1848163604736328,
-0.6627256274223328,
-0.08005921542644501,
-0.09102829545736313,
0.22166435420513153,
0.3670937418937683,
0.5489115715026855,
0.4251266121864319,
-0.338115930557251,
-0.48479965329170227,
-0.1591103971004486,
-0.7728067636489868,
-0.5279970169067383,
-0.07182077318429947,
0.08821766078472137,
0.10682372003793716,
0.865788459777832,
-0.5368574857711792,
0.4223984181880951,
0.33021560311317444,
-0.7237010598182678,
0.7991253137588501,
-0.3929360508918762,
0.30685102939605713,
-0.7622309923171997,
0.31080248951911926,
0.1365373432636261,
-0.5498817563056946,
-0.568583071231842,
-0.2732834815979004,
0.048815514892339706,
-0.1638387143611908,
-0.2683241367340088,
0.7451797723770142,
-0.2570728659629822,
0.08224935084581375,
-0.2732063829898834,
0.014759323559701443,
-0.0871538519859314,
0.45380887389183044,
0.07285194098949432,
0.6180818676948547,
0.4969516694545746,
-0.8176882266998291,
0.32139143347740173,
0.20820032060146332,
-0.3316393792629242,
0.4163134694099426,
-1.1784448623657227,
-0.0376102477312088,
-0.064218670129776,
0.3394242525100708,
-1.1506489515304565,
-0.23519271612167358,
0.16865262389183044,
-0.27253973484039307,
0.2867775857448578,
0.06964883953332901,
-0.9136291146278381,
-0.4238864779472351,
-0.03842731937766075,
0.1271229088306427,
0.4044475257396698,
-0.6000088453292847,
0.1449114829301834,
-0.019789500162005424,
-0.09005336463451385,
-0.31118348240852356,
-0.3057190477848053,
0.01440968457609415,
-0.026485970243811607,
-0.7925458550453186,
0.20488588511943817,
0.021043773740530014,
0.042693305760622025,
-0.126159206032753,
0.09939614683389664,
-0.07594215869903564,
0.24379251897335052,
0.37276944518089294,
0.18441392481327057,
-0.1695757508277893,
0.3879506587982178,
0.05335251986980438,
-0.31742119789123535,
0.1730809509754181,
-0.06802094727754593,
0.5507068037986755,
0.07036449015140533,
-0.5448785424232483,
-0.592939555644989,
0.07678258419036865,
0.3199213147163391,
-0.1371145099401474,
0.726637065410614,
0.5517266392707825,
-0.453485369682312,
0.09474216401576996,
-0.4691343307495117,
-0.2984165549278259,
-0.4414730966091156,
0.1503211259841919,
0.09670911729335785,
-1.1681225299835205,
0.7348015308380127,
-0.39741525053977966,
-0.15506115555763245,
0.6922402381896973,
0.40588662028312683,
-0.08383098989725113,
1.0791621208190918,
0.5923475623130798,
-0.11086748540401459,
0.3972693979740143,
0.18287290632724762,
0.12730510532855988,
-0.49749624729156494,
-0.3053717613220215,
-0.8837417364120483,
-0.045754071325063705,
-0.6074782609939575,
-0.15800508856773376,
0.3818867802619934,
0.13304093480110168,
-0.47746145725250244,
0.09119392186403275,
-0.37761908769607544,
0.290473997592926,
0.5867677927017212,
0.4809189736843109,
0.463010311126709,
-0.1457832306623459,
-0.04475421458482742,
0.068695068359375,
-0.7878181338310242,
-0.6905868649482727,
0.9457545876502991,
0.2252577394247055,
0.6406312584877014,
-0.18751195073127747,
0.41421523690223694,
0.29189011454582214,
0.21146410703659058,
-0.5478740930557251,
0.6737831830978394,
-0.08411179482936859,
-0.4159724712371826,
-0.42889583110809326,
-0.47118470072746277,
-1.3566744327545166,
-0.13669680058956146,
-0.44592997431755066,
-0.8776114583015442,
0.07903561741113663,
0.27493026852607727,
-0.31778451800346375,
0.07871318608522415,
-0.6714122295379639,
0.8931577205657959,
-0.11058753728866577,
-0.4314558506011963,
-0.07440145313739777,
-0.7277252674102783,
0.3210262358188629,
-0.0017560167470946908,
-0.09263420850038528,
-0.26643532514572144,
0.2649451494216919,
0.7415480017662048,
-0.5645245909690857,
1.0578577518463135,
-0.08579296618700027,
-0.07683125883340836,
0.19506023824214935,
-0.2307257354259491,
0.6920565366744995,
0.2784401476383209,
-0.08894242346286774,
0.2073400467634201,
-0.1917220950126648,
-0.18226879835128784,
-0.5008211135864258,
0.6942322254180908,
-0.7051847577095032,
-0.5376838445663452,
-0.2890286147594452,
-0.3355010449886322,
-0.38457176089286804,
0.5269328355789185,
0.2962145209312439,
0.5571436285972595,
-0.29522284865379333,
-0.04287053644657135,
0.5805445313453674,
-0.524349570274353,
0.47577062249183655,
0.5709354877471924,
-0.17335043847560883,
-0.05875277891755104,
0.428845077753067,
-0.07458475977182388,
0.03508356958627701,
0.42881736159324646,
0.34454116225242615,
-0.3943057954311371,
-0.5491963624954224,
-0.15135689079761505,
0.34601205587387085,
-0.6368559002876282,
-0.4124313294887543,
-0.7293511629104614,
-0.1885058432817459,
-0.5655416250228882,
-0.14411558210849762,
-0.18760095536708832,
-0.27171093225479126,
-0.6136631369590759,
-0.01847216859459877,
0.6645538210868835,
0.6464222073554993,
-0.07937832921743393,
0.22663331031799316,
-0.7708432674407959,
0.3368072807788849,
0.2844732403755188,
0.5055149793624878,
-0.1426866054534912,
-0.31927669048309326,
-0.1257103830575943,
-0.05580848827958107,
-0.008566411212086678,
-1.0087175369262695,
0.19032806158065796,
-0.027020739391446114,
0.4916856288909912,
0.3287416100502014,
0.09435516595840454,
0.621024489402771,
-0.7599486112594604,
0.7207691073417664,
0.1733834594488144,
-0.7929112911224365,
0.5660056471824646,
-0.4568488597869873,
0.2827642560005188,
0.44891050457954407,
0.38730981945991516,
-0.4118354916572571,
-0.5358091592788696,
-0.565333902835846,
-0.732086181640625,
0.5060680508613586,
0.05054729804396629,
-0.27066028118133545,
-0.2326238453388214,
0.5603514313697815,
0.026993118226528168,
0.020519670099020004,
-0.5413113832473755,
-0.3707928955554962,
0.1667742133140564,
-0.1467854380607605,
-0.36150506138801575,
-0.23945556581020355,
0.053651247173547745,
-0.21846413612365723,
0.3586885929107666,
-0.13181520998477936,
0.18690066039562225,
0.47772496938705444,
-0.04992692917585373,
0.02103891596198082,
0.05131295695900917,
0.5078643560409546,
0.6215233206748962,
-0.2604205310344696,
0.10444562882184982,
0.022641753777861595,
-0.211800217628479,
0.09222335368394852,
0.3642594814300537,
-0.35759320855140686,
0.24730585515499115,
0.9259079694747925,
0.8988214135169983,
0.30825451016426086,
-0.5982940793037415,
0.42304280400276184,
-0.10965368151664734,
0.11337723582983017,
0.1591954231262207,
0.09960158169269562,
0.08150094002485275,
0.32802677154541016,
0.09816894680261612,
0.09631477296352386,
0.32174399495124817,
-0.023815475404262543,
0.20366165041923523,
0.43650174140930176,
-0.17328175902366638,
-0.2894152104854584,
0.7484647035598755,
0.222881019115448,
-0.325724720954895,
0.4979904592037201,
-0.09935647994279861,
-0.27140146493911743,
0.7307029962539673,
0.5998329520225525,
0.8211260437965393,
-0.050825029611587524,
0.1954810917377472,
0.5938487648963928,
0.3105938136577606,
-0.14511738717556,
0.15323272347450256,
0.09427354484796524,
-0.6605899930000305,
-0.7293822765350342,
-0.3586002290248871,
-0.41241008043289185,
-0.013052141293883324,
-0.560893714427948,
0.43355903029441833,
-0.38455796241760254,
-0.3201136589050293,
0.001088342280127108,
0.05327923968434334,
-0.9232146143913269,
0.22200480103492737,
-0.17917735874652863,
0.9243839979171753,
-1.0047811269760132,
0.6478193998336792,
0.641187846660614,
-0.2259397804737091,
-0.9027308225631714,
-0.2775815725326538,
-0.2950769066810608,
-0.7367193698883057,
0.8243616223335266,
0.2422795593738556,
0.07459475100040436,
0.1786649227142334,
-0.5696313381195068,
-0.8766505718231201,
0.9593662619590759,
0.6338628530502319,
-0.566174328327179,
0.07480835169553757,
0.0071789599023759365,
0.7331050038337708,
0.13066115975379944,
0.29874753952026367,
0.3373129963874817,
0.36624160408973694,
-0.08129199594259262,
-1.0656707286834717,
0.2231302261352539,
0.18213559687137604,
-0.18142126500606537,
0.06776952743530273,
-0.26547083258628845,
0.6079686880111694,
-0.1473705768585205,
-0.35292887687683105,
-0.08593523502349854,
0.7505369782447815,
0.44260334968566895,
0.5395260453224182,
0.3100588917732239,
0.18918587267398834,
1.0515652894973755,
-0.04375799000263214,
1.163991928100586,
-0.4551272392272949,
0.422080397605896,
1.1168745756149292,
-0.3408339023590088,
0.4999920129776001,
0.37984344363212585,
-0.2770853042602539,
0.4570322334766388,
0.9109516143798828,
0.17056384682655334,
0.35873857140541077,
0.08536510914564133,
0.04086320847272873,
-0.23075851798057556,
-0.22217996418476105,
-0.41386890411376953,
0.14920422434806824,
0.1848527044057846,
-0.2625749707221985,
-0.37396952509880066,
-0.1404479444026947,
0.05047135800123215,
0.11396962404251099,
-0.5192334651947021,
0.8001522421836853,
0.10275735706090927,
-0.6937196850776672,
0.3864099085330963,
0.10170257836580276,
0.5551319718360901,
-0.666348397731781,
0.19301925599575043,
-0.03251822292804718,
-0.12192542105913162,
-0.15511368215084076,
-0.6427102088928223,
0.21848994493484497,
0.11123555898666382,
-0.1880972683429718,
-0.2087290734052658,
1.1761908531188965,
-0.2508925199508667,
-0.35366129875183105,
0.26083478331565857,
0.6779050827026367,
-0.1414407193660736,
0.07075939327478409,
-0.6426195502281189,
-0.23086413741111755,
-0.2146313190460205,
-0.3441687524318695,
0.04294257238507271,
0.5474674105644226,
-0.20432406663894653,
0.7216954231262207,
0.7476922273635864,
0.10636874288320541,
-0.0634305477142334,
0.20058172941207886,
0.7123211026191711,
-0.6094993352890015,
-0.48948097229003906,
-1.1172977685928345,
0.2477058619260788,
-0.16441848874092102,
-0.33567193150520325,
1.0048730373382568,
0.29445311427116394,
0.4560803472995758,
-0.16955804824829102,
0.41364920139312744,
0.23639395833015442,
0.5754462480545044,
-0.8697605133056641,
0.5242107510566711,
-0.20086556673049927,
0.1296086460351944,
-0.5347446203231812,
-0.623574435710907,
-0.7697497010231018,
0.42659634351730347,
-0.41643932461738586,
0.07820264250040054,
0.7764433026313782,
0.5850794315338135,
0.2572562098503113,
0.011297966353595257,
0.01323805283755064,
0.13599596917629242,
0.44280558824539185,
0.4179934859275818,
0.8210241794586182,
0.004143893253058195,
-0.07496225833892822,
0.09031756967306137,
-0.24051909148693085,
-0.25860095024108887,
-1.2678816318511963,
-1.0655221939086914,
-0.4111023545265198,
-0.5120919346809387,
-0.3190453350543976,
-0.130997896194458,
0.8277015686035156,
0.3339262902736664,
-0.5697974562644958,
-0.003106959629803896,
-0.3839109241962433,
0.4426198899745941,
-0.16252189874649048,
-0.2152508646249771,
0.6935626864433289,
-0.6340639591217041,
-0.4154123365879059,
0.38971900939941406,
0.3180319666862488,
0.05475533381104469,
-0.06695094704627991,
0.05395734682679176,
-0.14094284176826477,
0.05925124138593674,
0.7531901001930237,
0.27880603075027466,
-0.5016724467277527,
-0.4817492663860321,
-0.0006561051122844219,
-0.2965681254863739,
-0.21282188594341278,
0.8537504076957703,
-0.856996476650238,
0.28185802698135376,
0.7230706810951233,
0.6865089535713196,
0.16011524200439453,
-0.06634499132633209,
0.5725739002227783,
-0.6961820125579834,
0.10681648552417755,
0.08662977069616318,
0.6769542098045349,
0.2860567569732666,
-0.46340426802635193,
0.5330563187599182,
0.35941657423973083,
-0.8468956351280212,
-0.8297135233879089,
0.19500555098056793,
-1.1127536296844482,
-0.34796977043151855,
1.2472765445709229,
-0.1885320246219635,
0.03536005690693855,
-0.31264734268188477,
-0.24432262778282166,
0.5628703832626343,
-0.18589171767234802,
0.5932416319847107,
0.4982055127620697,
-0.42721739411354065,
0.39291203022003174,
-0.2996078431606293,
0.6929014921188354,
0.2544046640396118,
-0.948457658290863,
-0.059137992560863495,
0.6422571539878845,
0.08570437878370285,
-0.020728951320052147,
0.7784250378608704,
0.1503368616104126,
0.14991599321365356,
-0.47366926074028015,
-0.09190218150615692,
-0.19063934683799744,
-0.171796515583992,
-0.416492760181427,
0.12196783721446991,
0.1008961945772171,
0.09789220988750458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18874v1
|
Are queries and keys always relevant? A case study on Transformer wave functions
| 2024-05-29T08:32:37 | 2024-05-29T08:32:37 |
Riccardo Rende, Luciano Loris Viteritti
|
cond-mat.dis-nn
|
cond-mat.dis-nn, cs.CL, physics.comp-ph
|
The dot product attention mechanism, originally designed for natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, is a cornerstone of modern Transformers. It adeptly
captures semantic relationships between word pairs in sentences by computing a
similarity overlap between queries and keys. In this work, we explore the
suitability of Transformers, focusing on their attention mechanisms, in the
specific domain of the parametrization of variational wave functions to
approximate ground states of quantum many-body spin Hamiltonians. Specifically,
we perform numerical simulations on the two-dimensional $J_1$-$J_2$ Heisenberg
model, a common benchmark in the field of quantum-many body systems on lattice.
By comparing the performance of standard attention mechanisms with a simplified
version that excludes queries and keys, relying solely on positions, we achieve
competitive results while reducing computational cost and parameter usage.
Furthermore, through the analysis of the attention maps generated by standard
attention mechanisms, we show that the attention weights become effectively
input-independent at the end of the optimization. We support the numerical
results with analytical calculations, providing physical insights of why
queries and keys should be, in principle, omitted from the attention mechanism
when studying large systems. Interestingly, the same arguments can be extended
to the NLP domain, in the limit of long input sentences.
|
[
-0.6320260763168335,
-0.7416985034942627,
0.9189667105674744,
0.1275455802679062,
-0.2085263729095459,
-0.2694838345050812,
-0.23374103009700775,
-0.3018955588340759,
-0.055514946579933167,
0.5773109197616577,
-0.5613715648651123,
-0.13732898235321045,
-0.3247847557067871,
0.09447135031223297,
-0.5451217889785767,
0.6524344086647034,
0.0503682941198349,
-0.47168564796447754,
-0.2878572642803192,
-0.033937349915504456,
0.04510276019573212,
-0.35360583662986755,
-0.5120664238929749,
-0.15277926623821259,
0.669822096824646,
-0.31062668561935425,
0.9444360733032227,
0.18840909004211426,
0.9592957496643066,
0.2401396483182907,
-0.4232383668422699,
-0.10012535005807877,
-0.5963102579116821,
0.36523866653442383,
-0.4166002571582794,
-0.8063523769378662,
0.019960621371865273,
-0.2949681282043457,
0.5448228120803833,
0.7574571967124939,
-0.002826076466590166,
0.08654480427503586,
0.22047248482704163,
0.9968383312225342,
-0.7265627384185791,
0.24122090637683868,
-0.584928035736084,
0.423274964094162,
-0.0783286765217781,
-0.12275227159261703,
-0.28725260496139526,
-0.2131110429763794,
0.4601811170578003,
-0.7135458588600159,
0.4857005476951599,
0.042787641286849976,
0.99554842710495,
0.6138421893119812,
-0.3755921423435211,
-0.0898069366812706,
-0.8061407208442688,
0.7369977831840515,
-0.45506608486175537,
0.7174953818321228,
0.32230523228645325,
0.21120354533195496,
-0.2683379054069519,
-0.5889970064163208,
-0.49982011318206787,
-0.15561214089393616,
-0.23094742000102997,
0.3639702796936035,
-0.48171377182006836,
0.2993301451206207,
0.5072962641716003,
0.3807006776332855,
-0.4991105794906616,
-0.3996621370315552,
-0.36405640840530396,
0.1029617041349411,
0.16644547879695892,
0.2028648406267166,
-0.019415322691202164,
-0.41517865657806396,
-0.365481436252594,
-0.46528321504592896,
-0.6392983794212341,
0.36505788564682007,
-0.009377561509609222,
0.13198629021644592,
-0.20334483683109283,
0.5319473147392273,
-0.3931160569190979,
0.8865780830383301,
0.3298218548297882,
0.26604437828063965,
-0.07230829447507858,
-0.10311195254325867,
-0.09591559320688248,
-0.36954134702682495,
0.8723421692848206,
0.37509939074516296,
0.41833746433258057,
-0.7385722398757935,
0.08429260551929474,
-0.059940800070762634,
0.778645932674408,
-0.35123375058174133,
0.09226647764444351,
0.4193685054779053,
-0.31904733180999756,
-0.14636309444904327,
-0.10113345086574554,
-0.8757436871528625,
-0.054394837468862534,
-0.28807976841926575,
0.49084487557411194,
-0.21231555938720703,
-0.029848795384168625,
-0.003532236674800515,
-0.24123267829418182,
0.5037916302680969,
-0.40228039026260376,
-0.8418328166007996,
0.5447800755500793,
0.6761837005615234,
0.45035600662231445,
-0.4571731388568878,
-0.04487760737538338,
-0.1250980645418167,
0.42741286754608154,
-0.3793541491031647,
0.6670647263526917,
-0.6258000135421753,
-0.5473275780677795,
0.0060249133966863155,
-0.0773392915725708,
-0.16332100331783295,
-0.5114261507987976,
0.7839879393577576,
-1.1449395418167114,
-0.03030179627239704,
-0.3788243532180786,
-0.4464518129825592,
-0.21629981696605682,
0.19196166098117828,
-0.7904312014579773,
0.6749122142791748,
0.223067045211792,
-0.5942753553390503,
-0.07925146073102951,
-0.760262131690979,
-0.9517865777015686,
-0.21493566036224365,
-0.0704265683889389,
-0.4984116852283478,
0.49162521958351135,
0.23786883056163788,
0.2302510291337967,
-0.6243710517883301,
-0.005044702906161547,
-0.2708016335964203,
-0.191472128033638,
0.8056899309158325,
-0.32176581025123596,
0.33074280619621277,
0.1703309863805771,
-0.42427921295166016,
-0.07318577170372009,
-0.7817630767822266,
0.3154369294643402,
0.007138272747397423,
-0.23372504115104675,
0.00014980408013798296,
0.274810254573822,
-0.1631401777267456,
0.1370553970336914,
-0.00042663139174692333,
-0.1477060317993164,
-0.128890261054039,
-0.784151017665863,
0.6139042377471924,
0.38155245780944824,
0.47596263885498047,
0.6193642020225525,
0.22429057955741882,
0.7188976407051086,
-0.17174813151359558,
0.3156413733959198,
-0.20176444947719574,
-0.32097122073173523,
-0.7232120037078857,
-0.1568204164505005,
0.41318947076797485,
0.24493874609470367,
-0.5353002548217773,
0.37619858980178833,
-0.1963728964328766,
-0.23345966637134552,
-0.3571549952030182,
-0.41279110312461853,
0.2663217782974243,
0.39826416969299316,
0.2786259353160858,
0.19193950295448303,
-0.23653800785541534,
-1.2275742292404175,
-0.5825696587562561,
0.004800749011337757,
-0.2652062177658081,
0.44885432720184326,
0.002760096453130245,
0.11165986210107803,
1.067671775817871,
-0.7244089841842651,
-0.14615793526172638,
0.07611240446567535,
-0.22968216240406036,
0.3246302604675293,
0.0574350468814373,
0.36880362033843994,
-0.8731680512428284,
-0.5616439580917358,
0.05753625929355621,
-0.85499507188797,
0.24940894544124603,
-0.08092452585697174,
-0.2754966616630554,
-0.16253480315208435,
0.5365352034568787,
-1.134621024131775,
0.3732047975063324,
0.17630885541439056,
0.15194328129291534,
-0.17344844341278076,
0.15084421634674072,
0.04783714935183525,
-0.7922323346138,
0.14187407493591309,
0.07262671738862991,
-0.239035964012146,
-0.5437118411064148,
0.7385593056678772,
0.2326141595840454,
-0.5463780760765076,
-0.2612229883670807,
0.2072625458240509,
-0.4801769256591797,
-0.10160353034734726,
-0.25552093982696533,
0.3620222508907318,
0.02418726123869419,
0.7908584475517273,
-0.09754534065723419,
0.5447142124176025,
0.7981706857681274,
-0.9933401942253113,
0.1782251000404358,
0.20891126990318298,
0.14554308354854584,
0.6716420650482178,
-1.0124876499176025,
0.2177494764328003,
-0.14231523871421814,
-0.27119749784469604,
-1.2060625553131104,
0.011093434877693653,
0.3818758428096771,
-0.47057703137397766,
0.3361234664916992,
0.06202280893921852,
-0.5258768200874329,
-0.6332824230194092,
-0.3323359787464142,
0.05143129080533981,
0.6357036232948303,
-0.28323894739151,
0.8951076865196228,
0.4123653173446655,
0.1960713118314743,
-0.13422513008117676,
-0.4076908528804779,
-0.18497152626514435,
-0.1264181286096573,
-0.4729060232639313,
0.13594751060009003,
0.43151772022247314,
-0.07119102030992508,
0.2163057029247284,
-0.496992290019989,
-0.05299924686551094,
0.1491706669330597,
0.23096194863319397,
0.07534623891115189,
-0.021564260125160217,
0.27524393796920776,
0.18698342144489288,
-0.278058260679245,
0.3010789155960083,
-0.1394050270318985,
0.5221145749092102,
0.11569274961948395,
-0.40464189648628235,
-0.39943042397499084,
0.37377455830574036,
0.6921274662017822,
-0.4821726977825165,
0.36514216661453247,
0.35016030073165894,
-0.22829754650592804,
0.025617074221372604,
-0.4595418870449066,
-0.6416055560112,
-0.5594542622566223,
0.4908139407634735,
-0.6273703575134277,
-0.7859635949134827,
0.4320622980594635,
0.16522999107837677,
-0.036850228905677795,
0.6016525626182556,
0.4843516945838928,
-0.389965683221817,
0.9341808557510376,
0.4668929874897003,
0.044906653463840485,
0.44223570823669434,
0.1475866585969925,
0.6745898723602295,
-1.2671693563461304,
0.027690479531884193,
-0.5847841501235962,
-0.555169403553009,
-0.6982864737510681,
-0.45684951543807983,
0.713539719581604,
-0.05710390582680702,
0.1494971513748169,
0.4291788935661316,
-0.6887958645820618,
0.5277720093727112,
0.5306858420372009,
0.10359214246273041,
-0.08151306211948395,
0.28168216347694397,
0.06474626064300537,
-0.3730860948562622,
-0.6331040859222412,
0.06554263085126877,
1.2992944717407227,
0.16851092875003815,
0.7697426676750183,
-0.08203023672103882,
0.45911240577697754,
0.039906423538923264,
-0.14746150374412537,
-0.8210672736167908,
0.5045759677886963,
0.1366758495569229,
-0.7384644746780396,
-0.4651479423046112,
-0.3784330189228058,
-1.1652398109436035,
0.5522553324699402,
0.0570935495197773,
-0.6628639698028564,
0.3354136645793915,
-0.1406409591436386,
-0.5292481184005737,
-0.20505821704864502,
-0.8112462759017944,
0.5484610199928284,
0.16123612225055695,
-0.4813641309738159,
-0.4845064580440521,
-0.8393753170967102,
0.03017731010913849,
0.019717205315828323,
0.04878007993102074,
0.0872906893491745,
-0.043474845588207245,
0.6537405252456665,
-0.22003032267093658,
0.6925289630889893,
0.10080791264772415,
-0.09238961338996887,
0.4215579628944397,
0.009609617292881012,
0.5879016518592834,
0.03371899202466011,
0.3002369999885559,
-0.09891306608915329,
-0.2018015831708908,
-0.027413252741098404,
-0.6687412261962891,
0.5535715818405151,
-0.6815462708473206,
-0.8407559990882874,
-0.1015114039182663,
-0.5616427063941956,
-0.5647403001785278,
0.2434440702199936,
0.1627766191959381,
0.08836429566144943,
0.22351616621017456,
0.4442639946937561,
1.047452449798584,
0.1495540589094162,
0.5725266337394714,
0.6088259220123291,
-0.03809010609984398,
-0.15931053459644318,
0.7367518544197083,
0.09335341304540634,
0.3226543366909027,
0.8209317922592163,
0.15281669795513153,
-0.21365667879581451,
0.010960663668811321,
-0.18570151925086975,
0.27377021312713623,
-0.6285449266433716,
-0.0988537147641182,
-0.8224870562553406,
-0.16057121753692627,
-0.28171923756599426,
0.1888156235218048,
-0.3784997761249542,
-0.4936140477657318,
-0.1341988444328308,
0.1242467388510704,
0.3270640969276428,
0.17831766605377197,
0.09324635565280914,
0.15894469618797302,
-0.7795153260231018,
1.1540393829345703,
0.6466492414474487,
0.4793773293495178,
0.3115076422691345,
-0.34712913632392883,
-0.17608480155467987,
-0.2974110543727875,
-0.5608915686607361,
-1.0100820064544678,
-0.22179017961025238,
0.15183760225772858,
0.9046802520751953,
0.3811507225036621,
0.10745863616466522,
0.32130756974220276,
-0.600785493850708,
0.543728768825531,
0.17632818222045898,
-0.959604799747467,
0.3816814124584198,
-0.2581756114959717,
0.592533528804779,
0.39344334602355957,
0.3786008358001709,
-0.7320603132247925,
-0.6996791958808899,
-0.4253263771533966,
-0.930453896522522,
0.8545459508895874,
0.5607113838195801,
0.22286881506443024,
-0.010022914037108421,
0.6000582575798035,
-0.4429702162742615,
0.3612407147884369,
-0.5870161056518555,
-0.4998995363712311,
0.2154836356639862,
-0.20808099210262299,
0.4573703110218048,
-0.22325988113880157,
-0.25603625178337097,
0.11561878770589828,
0.3392530679702759,
0.03909820690751076,
0.4832495450973511,
0.2672731876373291,
-0.1001894474029541,
-0.26812249422073364,
0.20248933136463165,
0.43135371804237366,
0.5169454216957092,
0.18856801092624664,
-0.08141200989484787,
-0.05953451246023178,
-0.4415509104728699,
-0.08488939702510834,
0.11262114346027374,
-0.31175538897514343,
0.04159057140350342,
0.016816338524222374,
0.7137388586997986,
0.5961728692054749,
-0.553692638874054,
0.292249858379364,
0.05927241966128349,
-0.015081524848937988,
0.151784747838974,
0.018776725977659225,
0.488876610994339,
0.4604121446609497,
0.3738785684108734,
0.06554669886827469,
0.616789698600769,
-0.25693994760513306,
0.23517310619354248,
0.5880181193351746,
-0.740233838558197,
-0.2647590637207031,
0.9256699085235596,
-0.062396638095378876,
-0.44263970851898193,
0.30603325366973877,
-0.09784743934869766,
-0.6531338095664978,
0.6503810882568359,
0.24631153047084808,
0.9888370633125305,
-0.15803593397140503,
-0.02499026246368885,
0.28836044669151306,
0.5113103985786438,
0.15644614398479462,
0.19946818053722382,
-0.38947829604148865,
-0.3134758770465851,
-0.2949952781200409,
-0.3841020464897156,
-0.36652815341949463,
-0.27421531081199646,
-0.8802255392074585,
0.17144179344177246,
-0.540465772151947,
-0.45505765080451965,
0.23535774648189545,
-0.5719326734542847,
-0.7096908092498779,
0.1782485842704773,
0.19587182998657227,
0.09004588425159454,
-0.48516741394996643,
0.28726935386657715,
0.34198519587516785,
-0.254290908575058,
-0.49168655276298523,
0.32223665714263916,
-0.4182578921318054,
-0.8396257162094116,
0.43580731749534607,
-0.1988392025232315,
-0.20711208879947662,
-0.07518907636404037,
-0.3480560779571533,
-1.3525465726852417,
0.3159249424934387,
0.109604112803936,
-0.796572208404541,
-0.21322177350521088,
0.4967315196990967,
0.6708442568778992,
0.5275593400001526,
-0.009768374264240265,
0.5532295107841492,
0.4273066818714142,
-0.2796800434589386,
-0.6194791793823242,
-0.07400363683700562,
0.14043842256069183,
0.30636540055274963,
0.4719817638397217,
-0.9143827557563782,
0.7771621942520142,
0.06583810597658157,
-0.2831563651561737,
-0.3219480812549591,
0.558006227016449,
0.10624690353870392,
-0.2318548560142517,
0.36914169788360596,
0.7339107990264893,
0.25462836027145386,
-0.30308806896209717,
1.1729086637496948,
-0.6541366577148438,
0.7427456974983215,
0.7332317233085632,
-0.2741636037826538,
0.7676770091056824,
0.8663640022277832,
-0.9408928751945496,
-0.10619917511940002,
0.21793600916862488,
-0.17272783815860748,
0.8825194239616394,
0.3678050935268402,
0.18953746557235718,
-0.13418801128864288,
0.32878223061561584,
-0.4259525239467621,
0.07353001087903976,
0.3146921694278717,
-0.19662036001682281,
-0.3424413204193115,
0.15128488838672638,
-0.3616703152656555,
-0.02701585739850998,
-0.08199860900640488,
0.9403698444366455,
0.26028016209602356,
-0.5986726880073547,
0.580889880657196,
-0.13148584961891174,
0.2125898003578186,
-0.6180351376533508,
0.28773269057273865,
0.04908297210931778,
0.12051793187856674,
-0.0032463634852319956,
-0.6572856903076172,
0.23341749608516693,
-0.34373724460601807,
-0.5120933055877686,
0.24014991521835327,
0.5941165089607239,
-0.17821630835533142,
-0.5067010521888733,
0.07718165963888168,
-0.02665625512599945,
-0.12497638911008835,
-0.5389657616615295,
-0.41317886114120483,
0.15867453813552856,
-0.043674785643815994,
-0.6364244222640991,
0.03869929164648056,
0.47773635387420654,
0.13795505464076996,
0.46680963039398193,
0.5227673053741455,
-0.32218679785728455,
0.3855522572994232,
-0.014457343146204948,
0.7567707300186157,
-0.6563141345977783,
-0.7638974189758301,
-0.8248004913330078,
0.12185510247945786,
-0.061704907566308975,
-0.3719053864479065,
0.6531408429145813,
0.5529875159263611,
0.3580579161643982,
-0.27726590633392334,
0.6384748220443726,
0.3082026243209839,
0.6826286315917969,
-0.49719515442848206,
0.624082624912262,
-0.6242010593414307,
-0.03485341742634773,
-0.17355190217494965,
-1.2879592180252075,
-0.14963237941265106,
0.532997727394104,
-0.1876644492149353,
-0.04997041076421738,
0.994175910949707,
0.4627003073692322,
0.08668071776628494,
0.11202698945999146,
0.4074043035507202,
0.05421941354870796,
0.35448214411735535,
0.6452524065971375,
0.6175194382667542,
-0.6348686814308167,
0.5653080344200134,
-0.1271207481622696,
0.351729154586792,
-0.44617804884910583,
-0.1295473277568817,
-0.8100370168685913,
-0.5227781534194946,
-0.32456985116004944,
-0.019238704815506935,
-0.09442538022994995,
0.3404506742954254,
0.5544218420982361,
-0.6778705716133118,
0.008398792706429958,
-0.19092217087745667,
0.2313542515039444,
-0.2629129886627197,
-0.26286986470222473,
0.5375155806541443,
-0.6455793976783752,
-0.7424975633621216,
0.18809738755226135,
0.4661164879798889,
-0.02674279175698757,
-0.25794607400894165,
0.5580055117607117,
0.14403221011161804,
0.11285413056612015,
0.6650984287261963,
0.21165882050991058,
-0.8764560222625732,
-0.05255376547574997,
0.48583635687828064,
-0.29425257444381714,
0.19175021350383759,
0.8997986316680908,
-0.7673768997192383,
0.3877566158771515,
0.42229342460632324,
0.8818649649620056,
0.8824229836463928,
-0.4349503815174103,
0.5458309054374695,
-0.583462655544281,
0.3166058659553528,
0.32266074419021606,
0.02949352189898491,
0.12146785855293274,
-0.3727209270000458,
0.37023892998695374,
-0.08847177028656006,
-0.29858094453811646,
-0.678273618221283,
0.34276077151298523,
-1.0685375928878784,
-0.16037049889564514,
0.927399218082428,
0.17650026082992554,
-0.7093327641487122,
0.18715469539165497,
-0.04222297668457031,
0.1795898973941803,
-0.3522314131259918,
0.7908169627189636,
0.8683615326881409,
-0.052791375666856766,
-0.22641123831272125,
-0.5717357993125916,
0.42994511127471924,
0.7502361536026001,
-0.5320151448249817,
0.10528609156608582,
-0.03255376219749451,
-0.08012044429779053,
0.6020466089248657,
0.038170188665390015,
-0.34643304347991943,
0.539124071598053,
-0.015827303752303123,
-0.0276435948908329,
0.5393201112747192,
-0.0038734236732125282,
-0.2560259997844696,
0.6325185894966125,
-0.08099941909313202,
-0.32264968752861023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18870v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18870v2
|
LLMs achieve adult human performance on higher-order theory of mind tasks
| 2024-05-29T08:31:16 | 2024-05-31T12:45:50 |
Winnie Street, John Oliver Siy, Geoff Keeling, Adrien Baranes, Benjamin Barnett, Michael McKibben, Tatenda Kanyere, Alison Lentz, Blaise Aguera y Arcas, Robin I. M. Dunbar
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.7; H.1.2
|
This paper examines the extent to which large language models (LLMs) have
developed higher-order theory of mind (ToM); the human ability to reason about
multiple mental and emotional states in a recursive manner (e.g. I think that
you believe that she knows). This paper builds on prior work by introducing a
handwritten test suite -- Multi-Order Theory of Mind Q&A -- and using it to
compare the performance of five LLMs to a newly gathered adult human benchmark.
We find that GPT-4 and Flan-PaLM reach adult-level and near adult-level
performance on ToM tasks overall, and that GPT-4 exceeds adult performance on
6th order inferences. Our results suggest that there is an interplay between
model size and finetuning for the realisation of ToM abilities, and that the
best-performing LLMs have developed a generalised capacity for ToM. Given the
role that higher-order ToM plays in a wide range of cooperative and competitive
human behaviours, these findings have significant implications for user-facing
LLM applications.
|
[
-0.7897511720657349,
-0.6777566075325012,
0.7305152416229248,
0.08768370002508163,
0.04510526731610298,
0.042232174426317215,
-0.49181655049324036,
-0.961366593837738,
-0.017345357686281204,
0.43557512760162354,
-0.5407841801643372,
-0.047970812767744064,
-0.6365787982940674,
0.12040223181247711,
0.009274641051888466,
0.5575349926948547,
0.2589232325553894,
0.07067477703094482,
-0.12527059018611908,
-0.03877813369035721,
-0.3108139634132385,
-0.9382554292678833,
-0.866253137588501,
-0.6167559027671814,
0.7971564531326294,
0.10633429884910583,
0.7144209146499634,
0.3922695219516754,
0.6612385511398315,
0.27411139011383057,
-0.033098042011260986,
0.24237757921218872,
-0.4910537600517273,
0.2649141550064087,
-0.3602873682975769,
-0.7577788829803467,
-0.9758594036102295,
0.3245248794555664,
0.46055570244789124,
0.33441147208213806,
-0.2118750810623169,
-0.034691475331783295,
-0.018364423885941505,
0.7778059244155884,
-0.41541174054145813,
0.21077066659927368,
-0.4851241111755371,
-0.030004365369677544,
-0.008658576756715775,
-0.22900032997131348,
-0.557474672794342,
-0.11340787261724472,
0.27357321977615356,
-0.3326782286167145,
0.2876264452934265,
0.2999340891838074,
0.6528242230415344,
-0.055856507271528244,
-0.46178358793258667,
-0.1878039836883545,
-0.7291511297225952,
0.796649158000946,
-0.6356149315834045,
0.5030574798583984,
0.2775772511959076,
0.3373441994190216,
-0.2422126978635788,
-0.5886038541793823,
-0.6959791779518127,
-0.3314117193222046,
0.027435751631855965,
0.20946282148361206,
0.12423460185527802,
0.5778444409370422,
0.3835965692996979,
0.7643636465072632,
-0.40906405448913574,
0.09812827408313751,
-0.3851534426212311,
0.19917725026607513,
0.7726086378097534,
0.23269982635974884,
0.17333896458148956,
0.21894212067127228,
-0.27064600586891174,
-0.11561304330825806,
-0.7216760516166687,
-0.03615591302514076,
0.0653098002076149,
0.1707431674003601,
-0.005986907985061407,
0.572577714920044,
-0.06178814172744751,
0.5001380443572998,
0.16528497636318207,
-0.20579618215560913,
-0.14286468923091888,
-0.323935329914093,
-0.3066565990447998,
-0.44383105635643005,
0.6229554414749146,
0.27488622069358826,
0.8037480115890503,
0.0716228187084198,
-0.35888224840164185,
0.24368475377559662,
0.35094061493873596,
-0.5949634313583374,
-0.21064624190330505,
0.047371551394462585,
-0.37976738810539246,
0.1764349788427353,
-0.053944047540426254,
-0.6494927406311035,
-0.6210450530052185,
-0.4315311312675476,
0.43849867582321167,
-0.3654842674732208,
-0.6383036375045776,
0.34803155064582825,
0.1525566726922989,
0.3532124161720276,
0.48627692461013794,
-0.9707053899765015,
0.655052661895752,
0.7537875175476074,
0.5761213898658752,
-0.2535937428474426,
-0.595429539680481,
-0.03295188397169113,
0.013574307784438133,
-0.5786966681480408,
0.582227885723114,
-0.4275508224964142,
-0.17392851412296295,
-0.12652188539505005,
-0.33400028944015503,
-0.22835837304592133,
-0.5177826285362244,
0.43720686435699463,
-0.6061583161354065,
0.40792256593704224,
-0.4473212957382202,
-0.567916214466095,
-0.4614572525024414,
0.08104946464300156,
-0.34235885739326477,
0.7783156037330627,
-0.05729131028056145,
-0.49433228373527527,
0.3048616945743561,
-0.8599364161491394,
-0.4366353452205658,
0.044608838856220245,
-0.36572641134262085,
0.11414502561092377,
0.2418416291475296,
0.02063101902604103,
0.9128438830375671,
-0.7605096101760864,
0.22430741786956787,
-0.45865410566329956,
-0.2907324731349945,
0.3941088616847992,
-0.5910888910293579,
0.5327702164649963,
0.18770234286785126,
-0.463401734828949,
0.18958044052124023,
-0.3378419578075409,
0.20397737622261047,
0.27954819798469543,
-0.5182145833969116,
-0.08387826383113861,
0.05810834467411041,
-0.3200942873954773,
0.5187453627586365,
0.33116838335990906,
-0.40103060007095337,
0.3007782995700836,
-0.24456609785556793,
0.5280159115791321,
0.606141984462738,
-0.01945849135518074,
0.13098245859146118,
-0.5850438475608826,
0.47419196367263794,
-0.13489757478237152,
0.09097590297460556,
0.03735765814781189,
-0.7986205816268921,
-0.8899965286254883,
-0.22409269213676453,
-0.046761032193899155,
0.38068437576293945,
-0.4002096951007843,
0.31675034761428833,
-0.4128957688808441,
-0.32664746046066284,
-0.5140019655227661,
0.04654845595359802,
0.4661281108856201,
-0.14008240401744843,
0.26257482171058655,
-0.4275164008140564,
-0.3407552242279053,
-0.9334844946861267,
-0.12579454481601715,
-0.24735428392887115,
-0.23564638197422028,
0.31007784605026245,
0.4847657084465027,
-0.13340692222118378,
0.5124073624610901,
-0.553250253200531,
-0.12138500809669495,
-0.39034414291381836,
0.1621434986591339,
0.12374536693096161,
0.33279895782470703,
0.4075593054294586,
-0.6254922747612,
0.21257831156253815,
0.07155230641365051,
-0.6987508535385132,
0.2867944836616516,
0.07490647584199905,
-0.0680263563990593,
0.20446264743804932,
0.12812058627605438,
-0.9649999141693115,
0.06685055792331696,
0.34045878052711487,
-0.41076353192329407,
0.546455979347229,
-0.6558563709259033,
0.18110249936580658,
-1.030165672302246,
-0.24960114061832428,
0.1638668030500412,
-0.14573721587657928,
-0.6732122302055359,
0.4889015853404999,
-0.055148929357528687,
0.20482586324214935,
-0.05768723040819168,
0.3024909496307373,
-0.7092528939247131,
-0.5460132360458374,
-0.11892075091600418,
0.2875518202781677,
-0.2955457866191864,
0.746879518032074,
-0.07674774527549744,
0.7839834094047546,
0.2101246416568756,
-0.6983776092529297,
0.12565399706363678,
-0.36040085554122925,
-0.39750802516937256,
0.7496892809867859,
-0.4845419228076935,
0.27058443427085876,
-0.027643512934446335,
0.14101220667362213,
-1.3025270700454712,
-0.46997156739234924,
-0.1935216784477234,
-0.4570329487323761,
0.2801969051361084,
0.32353949546813965,
-0.5674675703048706,
-0.6016623973846436,
-0.040647633373737335,
0.26001179218292236,
0.5883771777153015,
-0.2796783745288849,
0.6219030022621155,
0.34219953417778015,
-0.14573507010936737,
-0.27168139815330505,
-0.6315575838088989,
-0.0037731945049017668,
-0.2691534459590912,
-0.6424716114997864,
0.3018084168434143,
-0.3143278956413269,
-0.5528625249862671,
-0.46036624908447266,
-0.0021397320087999105,
-0.29091784358024597,
0.19317936897277832,
0.1699606031179428,
0.030796928331255913,
-0.4454190135002136,
-0.04475117102265358,
-0.338613361120224,
0.21106047928333282,
0.2751224935054779,
0.004459823947399855,
0.586009681224823,
-0.4433418810367584,
-0.26547446846961975,
-0.3524290919303894,
0.06953419744968414,
1.0104155540466309,
-0.2155080884695053,
0.4633084237575531,
0.33044135570526123,
-0.5071536302566528,
-0.12035609781742096,
-0.7479392290115356,
-0.27203238010406494,
-0.467018187046051,
0.21301832795143127,
-0.6767453551292419,
-0.9910373091697693,
0.381512850522995,
0.24170981347560883,
0.33926600217819214,
0.4349741041660309,
0.7161754369735718,
-0.13357675075531006,
1.0081664323806763,
0.5869641900062561,
-0.06266634166240692,
0.3119410574436188,
-0.281484454870224,
0.058041978627443314,
-0.8202961683273315,
0.15684139728546143,
-0.039746157824993134,
-0.3438560366630554,
-0.5803356170654297,
-0.4829831123352051,
0.19957152009010315,
0.14551964402198792,
-0.5270368456840515,
0.1034955233335495,
-0.4179352819919586,
0.536613941192627,
0.5432147979736328,
0.13189497590065002,
0.43621331453323364,
-0.20995402336120605,
-0.1612030416727066,
0.15773548185825348,
-0.5040929317474365,
-0.43105247616767883,
0.8224883675575256,
0.6247825026512146,
0.509733259677887,
0.5532786846160889,
0.4394705891609192,
0.3829643130302429,
0.564332127571106,
-0.6933984756469727,
0.8254741430282593,
-0.06838741898536682,
-1.0765039920806885,
-0.42994824051856995,
-0.14421577751636505,
-1.0676275491714478,
0.7097331285476685,
-0.12078479677438736,
-0.8340145945549011,
-0.032809045165777206,
0.017011255025863647,
-0.41711220145225525,
0.16317087411880493,
-0.9185420274734497,
0.40685757994651794,
-0.2637915015220642,
-0.2881506383419037,
-0.6304101347923279,
-0.5836808085441589,
0.7771967649459839,
0.21113434433937073,
0.11656911671161652,
-0.2825400233268738,
-0.03279149904847145,
0.8655059933662415,
0.01916894130408764,
0.8722670078277588,
-0.1470489799976349,
-0.47893956303596497,
0.316366046667099,
0.1453302800655365,
0.13584832847118378,
-0.22601208090782166,
0.007491530384868383,
-0.09744944423437119,
0.05840200558304787,
-0.3369504511356354,
-0.6147029995918274,
0.669510543346405,
-0.8723669052124023,
-0.9554216265678406,
-0.3653247058391571,
-0.5842677354812622,
-0.3720218241214752,
0.348204642534256,
0.07719730585813522,
0.3672788739204407,
0.19178469479084015,
0.2771795988082886,
0.6534250974655151,
0.18404224514961243,
0.43751153349876404,
0.4882003962993622,
-0.41913971304893494,
-0.6534862518310547,
0.6256247162818909,
0.4635668098926544,
0.5104966163635254,
0.4923352301120758,
0.12435344606637955,
-0.322794109582901,
-0.633146345615387,
-0.1559666097164154,
0.4409780204296112,
-0.8106233477592468,
0.2074851244688034,
-0.3420974016189575,
-0.08537221699953079,
-0.2647617757320404,
-0.08023949712514877,
-0.21307826042175293,
-0.16966204345226288,
0.1619647890329361,
-0.11293220520019531,
0.1824793517589569,
1.3038642406463623,
0.2821880280971527,
0.19131265580654144,
-0.2917899787425995,
0.32116279006004333,
0.5558319091796875,
0.38143086433410645,
0.3732644021511078,
-0.2924594283103943,
-0.01071481965482235,
0.16415926814079285,
-0.4685298800468445,
-0.6950443387031555,
0.1162378117442131,
-0.16462384164333344,
0.6292680501937866,
0.3445037007331848,
-0.10322190821170807,
0.8462839722633362,
-0.2861655652523041,
0.844673216342926,
0.15267005562782288,
-0.6855270266532898,
-0.02422407642006874,
-0.8533876538276672,
0.1310262829065323,
0.2279028594493866,
0.2185303121805191,
-0.45619356632232666,
-0.07984960824251175,
-0.6057426929473877,
-0.613127589225769,
0.4967905879020691,
0.19336353242397308,
-0.22409218549728394,
0.008236388675868511,
0.5304825901985168,
-0.029576754197478294,
0.24667485058307648,
-0.89365553855896,
-0.10645909607410431,
0.3158741891384125,
-0.18966886401176453,
-0.45132046937942505,
-0.32021665573120117,
-0.025423185899853706,
-0.245499387383461,
0.39300820231437683,
-0.19463810324668884,
0.7872357368469238,
0.19342109560966492,
0.138362318277359,
-0.20823770761489868,
0.40886029601097107,
0.9389909505844116,
0.9566513895988464,
-0.19801850616931915,
0.3503651022911072,
0.18199031054973602,
-0.3038700222969055,
0.22410377860069275,
-0.27662134170532227,
0.46224647760391235,
-0.7155289649963379,
0.5712207555770874,
0.5352804064750671,
0.2508179843425751,
-0.4548770785331726,
0.3893738389015198,
-0.11655355244874954,
-0.34933146834373474,
-0.36894217133522034,
0.3875741958618164,
0.31487807631492615,
0.465227872133255,
0.43091338872909546,
-0.11774031817913055,
-0.20311057567596436,
-0.7564586997032166,
0.18108849227428436,
0.3179061710834503,
0.016111617907881737,
-0.47563594579696655,
0.5849490165710449,
0.18390940129756927,
-0.5828816890716553,
0.23866653442382812,
-0.09078611433506012,
-0.3441227078437805,
0.44525766372680664,
0.5419873595237732,
0.861590564250946,
-0.18161650002002716,
-0.2942076027393341,
-0.03334436193108559,
0.3452342450618744,
-0.34595561027526855,
0.7661738395690918,
-0.1250872015953064,
-0.9786942005157471,
-0.6646180748939514,
-0.41050973534584045,
-0.5390520691871643,
0.4490117132663727,
-0.6765447854995728,
-0.3025769293308258,
-0.6859995126724243,
-0.45381876826286316,
0.10741835087537766,
0.18762318789958954,
-0.7713934779167175,
0.35475805401802063,
0.09258205443620682,
0.6543068885803223,
-0.28085893392562866,
1.0040191411972046,
0.6331896781921387,
-0.3694573640823364,
-0.6087037920951843,
0.2779274880886078,
-0.12729611992835999,
-0.815956711769104,
0.7589167356491089,
0.3486321270465851,
-0.36728793382644653,
0.20162786543369293,
-0.1969185322523117,
-1.0348049402236938,
1.1549866199493408,
0.2835465967655182,
-0.4181392192840576,
-0.3268735408782959,
-0.19431664049625397,
0.8112634420394897,
-0.5118141770362854,
0.4791974723339081,
0.4953332543373108,
0.39357244968414307,
-0.26966384053230286,
-1.0375577211380005,
0.014497997239232063,
-0.06261765956878662,
0.07931890338659286,
0.19232863187789917,
-0.8434379696846008,
0.9375070929527283,
-0.3075789213180542,
-0.25109797716140747,
0.1863306313753128,
0.8279335498809814,
0.3642324209213257,
0.10894016921520233,
0.485330730676651,
0.32481300830841064,
0.7277987003326416,
-0.11445687711238861,
1.1275992393493652,
-0.3151165246963501,
0.18805277347564697,
1.0062083005905151,
-0.48506617546081543,
1.0537556409835815,
0.2567712366580963,
-0.6463310718536377,
0.3662790060043335,
0.6950491070747375,
0.5091314911842346,
0.0502285435795784,
0.3630802631378174,
-0.14011822640895844,
-0.313014417886734,
0.24917390942573547,
-0.114377461373806,
0.2700914144515991,
0.605197012424469,
-0.22762061655521393,
0.33322858810424805,
-0.09747032076120377,
-0.0671122595667839,
0.0062746452167630196,
-0.36778679490089417,
0.7220103740692139,
0.21166056394577026,
-1.0344445705413818,
0.9455888867378235,
0.009781550616025925,
0.9761205315589905,
-0.3290438652038574,
0.23674580454826355,
-0.007956190966069698,
0.6020464897155762,
0.17178136110305786,
-1.0518935918807983,
-0.03547211363911629,
-0.2034027874469757,
-0.23032188415527344,
-0.216863214969635,
0.614585816860199,
-0.3305521309375763,
0.018935320898890495,
0.4974513351917267,
0.6956776976585388,
0.21628636121749878,
0.17967554926872253,
-0.537813663482666,
-0.2883094847202301,
-0.25039908289909363,
-0.53815096616745,
0.4570198953151703,
0.3811049163341522,
-0.05276981741189957,
0.9646080732345581,
0.39943960309028625,
0.02948087826371193,
0.18332701921463013,
-0.1558964103460312,
0.2554427683353424,
-0.9542042016983032,
-0.34533625841140747,
-0.9327651858329773,
0.12271113693714142,
-0.059482380747795105,
-0.4806884527206421,
0.6181308031082153,
0.1775798797607422,
0.9066012501716614,
-0.11629907786846161,
0.7147530913352966,
0.08795749396085739,
0.40529903769493103,
-0.5081903338432312,
0.4559125006198883,
-0.29933828115463257,
0.018423186615109444,
-0.2472386509180069,
-0.7246235609054565,
-0.18565748631954193,
0.561353862285614,
-0.584194540977478,
0.43114155530929565,
0.753746747970581,
0.5637492537498474,
0.1423887312412262,
0.34728366136550903,
0.7551964521408081,
0.2826019823551178,
0.5076529383659363,
0.7613733410835266,
0.8451932668685913,
0.023102393373847008,
0.015291495248675346,
-0.25927385687828064,
-0.09549390524625778,
-0.11276686191558838,
-0.5670810341835022,
-1.1471399068832397,
-0.6612005829811096,
0.19181278347969055,
-0.0788625106215477,
0.019036658108234406,
1.2739248275756836,
0.7780563831329346,
-0.3961524963378906,
-0.5580404996871948,
-0.26954522728919983,
-0.06985323131084442,
-0.4007371664047241,
-0.23886334896087646,
0.01734054461121559,
-0.1014505997300148,
-0.5395543575286865,
0.46137934923171997,
0.2118609994649887,
0.23732009530067444,
-0.599793553352356,
-0.17101971805095673,
-0.35502591729164124,
0.32936277985572815,
1.0579851865768433,
-0.03477853536605835,
-1.2036408185958862,
-0.4692527651786804,
-0.05786766856908798,
-0.03539621829986572,
0.14695128798484802,
0.9599756598472595,
-0.41460326313972473,
0.09434492886066437,
0.4764288663864136,
0.6012682318687439,
0.26215100288391113,
-0.10213597118854523,
0.7361035346984863,
-0.46953463554382324,
-0.23275358974933624,
-0.0036469376645982265,
0.5333411693572998,
0.17404504120349884,
-0.43633657693862915,
0.6815378069877625,
0.33108001947402954,
-0.6948302388191223,
-0.5749534964561462,
0.4833759665489197,
-0.737510621547699,
-0.3694405257701874,
1.1154545545578003,
-0.18385617434978485,
-0.05741337314248085,
-0.045593779534101486,
-0.3827883005142212,
0.12962689995765686,
-0.4019693434238434,
0.7189409732818604,
0.9222262501716614,
-0.6014615893363953,
-0.38936468958854675,
-0.656300961971283,
0.39692196249961853,
0.4836501479148865,
-0.8953841328620911,
0.4794231355190277,
0.4748639464378357,
0.16809985041618347,
0.3313428461551666,
0.879120409488678,
0.05064242705702782,
0.22293086349964142,
-0.2581712007522583,
0.0427560992538929,
0.17483918368816376,
-0.41693583130836487,
-0.21224844455718994,
0.5322860479354858,
0.48384642601013184,
0.143319234251976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18845v1
|
Simulation, Modelling and Classification of Wiki Contributors: Spotting The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
| 2024-05-29T07:56:08 | 2024-05-29T07:56:08 |
Silvia García Méndez, Fátima Leal, Benedita Malheiro, Juan Carlos Burguillo Rial, Bruno Veloso, Adriana E. Chis, Horacio González Vélez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Data crowdsourcing is a data acquisition process where groups of voluntary
contributors feed platforms with highly relevant data ranging from news,
comments, and media to knowledge and classifications. It typically processes
user-generated data streams to provide and refine popular services such as
wikis, collaborative maps, e-commerce sites, and social networks. Nevertheless,
this modus operandi raises severe concerns regarding ill-intentioned data
manipulation in adversarial environments. This paper presents a simulation,
modelling, and classification approach to automatically identify human and
non-human (bots) as well as benign and malign contributors by using data
fabrication to balance classes within experimental data sets, data stream
modelling to build and update contributor profiles and, finally, autonomic data
stream classification. By employing WikiVoyage - a free worldwide wiki travel
guide open to contribution from the general public - as a testbed, our approach
proves to significantly boost the confidence and quality of the classifier by
using a class-balanced data stream, comprising both real and synthetic data.
Our empirical results show that the proposed method distinguishes between
benign and malign bots as well as human contributors with a classification
accuracy of up to 92 %.
|
[
-0.5056555271148682,
-0.659148633480072,
0.03930111974477768,
-0.14653410017490387,
0.027428986504673958,
0.14803233742713928,
-0.08395176380872726,
-0.6651021242141724,
0.15042747557163239,
0.5269376635551453,
-0.6215658187866211,
-0.23751279711723328,
-0.44634634256362915,
0.3687288463115692,
-0.923369824886322,
1.1231735944747925,
0.16730719804763794,
-0.11782336980104446,
-0.5104308128356934,
0.05352353677153587,
-0.1447051614522934,
-0.6262834668159485,
-0.4429907202720642,
0.11338935047388077,
0.9037001729011536,
0.42836493253707886,
0.7629836201667786,
0.5128152966499329,
0.1396077424287796,
0.4558038115501404,
0.27614879608154297,
0.34760597348213196,
-0.6521339416503906,
0.06708462536334991,
-0.7368828058242798,
-0.4567135274410248,
0.003691001795232296,
0.40117084980010986,
-0.0022919620387256145,
0.5578387379646301,
-0.0038671863730996847,
0.5257578492164612,
0.11014092713594437,
0.27135854959487915,
-0.7202051281929016,
-0.07914433628320694,
-0.6555681228637695,
-0.235320582985878,
-0.4975086450576782,
-0.14243414998054504,
-0.5131291747093201,
-0.39619019627571106,
-0.1981230080127716,
-1.0025887489318848,
0.8214253187179565,
0.016033530235290527,
0.6022634506225586,
0.18058720231056213,
-0.2530592679977417,
-0.4950144290924072,
-0.7943255305290222,
0.5814875960350037,
-0.4340311586856842,
-0.007767118513584137,
0.5633606314659119,
0.23086950182914734,
-0.464361310005188,
-0.4885636568069458,
-0.9061658978462219,
-0.039174072444438934,
-0.014001060277223587,
0.00210852874442935,
-0.22769999504089355,
-0.2723495066165924,
0.08977417647838593,
-0.09580544382333755,
-0.6872386336326599,
0.24582068622112274,
-0.7627580165863037,
-0.3633175194263458,
1.1068062782287598,
0.20840609073638916,
0.43973779678344727,
-0.5315617918968201,
-0.13636814057826996,
0.013119326904416084,
-0.20624852180480957,
-0.30868595838546753,
0.9132048487663269,
0.42788854241371155,
-0.1321142464876175,
0.7151768803596497,
-0.33597779273986816,
0.9132472276687622,
0.15332795679569244,
-0.08903420716524124,
0.18170195817947388,
0.06074000895023346,
0.08325038105249405,
-0.219020277261734,
0.8405749797821045,
0.302929162979126,
0.4859428405761719,
-0.40656182169914246,
0.0896662175655365,
0.1029941588640213,
0.5760207772254944,
-0.32204562425613403,
-0.6234353184700012,
-0.020659280940890312,
-0.4520702660083771,
-0.9453763961791992,
0.33087366819381714,
-0.8477877974510193,
-0.942613422870636,
-0.49702540040016174,
0.5222832560539246,
0.011068572290241718,
-0.657199501991272,
-0.34745296835899353,
-0.3299091160297394,
-0.12741847336292267,
0.727191150188446,
-0.4615151882171631,
0.04107171297073364,
0.6013287305831909,
0.6168191432952881,
-0.09685995429754257,
-0.5073387622833252,
-0.3252638578414917,
0.33989766240119934,
-0.3433588147163391,
0.9782519340515137,
-0.08495443314313889,
-0.4188392758369446,
-0.09001993387937546,
0.07810038328170776,
0.19211168587207794,
-0.2904622256755829,
0.5386930704116821,
-0.7073411345481873,
0.28583481907844543,
-0.17606842517852783,
-0.5269295573234558,
-0.17307668924331665,
0.3012235164642334,
-0.8499965071678162,
0.6567509174346924,
0.5284354090690613,
-0.8874765634536743,
0.4668124318122864,
-0.4265826642513275,
-0.3271643817424774,
0.24502329528331757,
0.19277337193489075,
-0.41289716958999634,
0.005544672720134258,
-0.24887746572494507,
0.42635682225227356,
-0.031578052788972855,
0.11563611030578613,
-0.8062872886657715,
-0.09915351122617722,
0.5583992004394531,
-0.48675790429115295,
1.0988775491714478,
0.49908602237701416,
-0.25280964374542236,
-0.1469356268644333,
-0.7298254370689392,
-0.16728632152080536,
-0.07321303337812424,
-0.028737755492329597,
-0.5885964035987854,
0.10224597901105881,
0.4926162362098694,
0.5518237948417664,
-0.10014426708221436,
-0.496787965297699,
0.3545311391353607,
-0.1356653869152069,
0.09780377149581909,
1.0258036851882935,
0.2125912755727768,
0.34601983428001404,
-0.2271638959646225,
0.37418097257614136,
0.04345979169011116,
0.6594243049621582,
0.48516470193862915,
-0.6882520914077759,
-0.6447699666023254,
-0.12444746494293213,
0.5238937139511108,
0.4603727459907532,
-0.9915260672569275,
0.4175302982330322,
-0.296877384185791,
-0.8456944227218628,
-0.44246625900268555,
0.2746540307998657,
-0.07799305766820908,
0.6745229363441467,
0.09915494918823242,
0.06131233647465706,
-0.43398869037628174,
-0.6429586410522461,
-0.17707793414592743,
-0.7541410326957703,
-0.20881196856498718,
0.000991597305983305,
0.37146902084350586,
-0.3367827236652374,
0.9097394347190857,
-0.3055766820907593,
-0.09097177535295486,
0.3327673375606537,
0.4010866582393646,
-0.2735936641693115,
0.3536902964115143,
0.41922223567962646,
-1.2120774984359741,
-0.49580857157707214,
-0.045670267194509506,
-0.6949267983436584,
-0.23023927211761475,
0.044937994331121445,
-0.33426186442375183,
0.20520205795764923,
0.31300365924835205,
-0.48939213156700134,
0.5927481055259705,
0.16869769990444183,
-0.49744704365730286,
0.4225108027458191,
0.16898374259471893,
0.36285895109176636,
-1.020576000213623,
0.3110087513923645,
-0.09214834868907928,
-0.3764611780643463,
-0.6284310221672058,
-0.015736518427729607,
0.09007932990789413,
-0.3257289528846741,
-0.3582853674888611,
0.44844934344291687,
-0.09788024425506592,
0.1593482494354248,
-0.4309366047382355,
0.01822400651872158,
-0.027371039614081383,
0.21708504855632782,
-0.26097461581230164,
0.35679909586906433,
0.26093974709510803,
-0.7014836668968201,
0.7989317178726196,
-0.09362328052520752,
-0.20164571702480316,
0.7571950554847717,
-0.20933188498020172,
0.13997717201709747,
-0.16521944105625153,
0.16498062014579773,
-0.9615417718887329,
-0.5819763541221619,
0.6354455947875977,
-0.9594817161560059,
0.227720245718956,
-0.3180672228336334,
-0.8640774488449097,
-0.6118686199188232,
-0.24515561759471893,
0.16169992089271545,
0.1954638957977295,
-0.560778796672821,
0.6091820597648621,
0.6848577857017517,
-0.11505496501922607,
-0.4059751033782959,
-0.3904602527618408,
0.15138310194015503,
-0.2820064425468445,
-0.44017091393470764,
0.11272668838500977,
0.045139212161302567,
-0.23256957530975342,
0.379506379365921,
0.25646939873695374,
-0.2427998185157776,
0.3105291426181793,
0.4740059971809387,
0.33019840717315674,
0.4802054166793823,
0.16016867756843567,
-0.3316240906715393,
-0.19879163801670074,
0.1228800117969513,
-0.02252262644469738,
0.14802297949790955,
0.5606241822242737,
-0.3412671685218811,
-0.5550941824913025,
0.3836269676685333,
0.6505418419837952,
0.01702074147760868,
0.7816259860992432,
0.7724531292915344,
-0.438837468624115,
-0.3474043607711792,
-0.7363449335098267,
0.03747064620256424,
-0.4884546995162964,
0.28478920459747314,
-0.06272383779287338,
-0.15467491745948792,
0.48474207520484924,
0.1432703584432602,
0.19020521640777588,
0.7304809093475342,
0.5892374515533447,
-0.38656675815582275,
1.003328561782837,
0.5671276450157166,
-0.6202830672264099,
0.2543162405490875,
-0.19402289390563965,
-0.024462342262268066,
-0.03581758961081505,
-0.404756098985672,
-0.9017165899276733,
-0.3753712773323059,
-0.8205583095550537,
-0.5242988467216492,
0.13771222531795502,
0.007302205543965101,
0.1340855360031128,
0.18657858669757843,
-0.6786960959434509,
0.3491206765174866,
0.44226139783859253,
0.0873180627822876,
0.15413551032543182,
0.04757789522409439,
0.5397390127182007,
0.2606748342514038,
-0.38657429814338684,
-0.5193174481391907,
1.0089222192764282,
-0.10688447207212448,
0.8749462962150574,
0.11965065449476242,
0.621006429195404,
0.9811233878135681,
0.9752265214920044,
-0.5657337307929993,
0.32813480496406555,
-0.04697587713599205,
-1.0356850624084473,
-0.3211323618888855,
-0.6057658195495605,
-0.7977001070976257,
-0.1795831322669983,
-0.2393340766429901,
-0.28238824009895325,
0.5362614393234253,
0.22112074494361877,
0.011261360719799995,
0.6921278834342957,
-0.7711238861083984,
0.6068655848503113,
0.07888861745595932,
-0.37610864639282227,
-0.39316558837890625,
-0.4824741780757904,
0.26188719272613525,
-0.21323321759700775,
0.5733363628387451,
-0.07065491378307343,
-0.15533199906349182,
0.7749433517456055,
-0.4227316677570343,
0.9272842407226562,
-0.5516512989997864,
-0.09333019703626633,
0.5466042160987854,
0.07502362132072449,
0.4600315988063812,
-0.04548090696334839,
-0.2470257729291916,
0.19553208351135254,
-0.18485192954540253,
-0.5687114596366882,
-0.6728907227516174,
0.7308074235916138,
-1.14410400390625,
-0.23327291011810303,
-0.33703282475471497,
-0.13137900829315186,
-0.17292065918445587,
0.1269681453704834,
0.4677070081233978,
0.05609861761331558,
-0.2288200408220291,
-0.13434027135372162,
0.31889697909355164,
0.08311869204044342,
0.13421116769313812,
0.7023389339447021,
0.053023699671030045,
-0.4493734538555145,
1.1718730926513672,
0.40650442242622375,
-0.06912453472614288,
0.1303250938653946,
-0.144109845161438,
-0.21287505328655243,
-0.4660691022872925,
-0.57393479347229,
-0.04230889305472374,
-0.5237076282501221,
-0.5581762194633484,
-0.47614723443984985,
-0.21654674410820007,
-0.3436445891857147,
-0.09479200094938278,
-0.14751291275024414,
-0.602957010269165,
-0.4954797029495239,
-0.16134695708751678,
0.4023233652114868,
0.7917219996452332,
-0.23808987438678741,
-0.07510634511709213,
-0.3846488893032074,
0.40698957443237305,
0.40567854046821594,
0.24467170238494873,
0.13628096878528595,
-0.279203861951828,
-0.47827354073524475,
0.10212849825620651,
-0.42770639061927795,
-1.1275525093078613,
0.19304035604000092,
-0.3025050461292267,
0.6349658370018005,
0.5322738289833069,
0.2865538001060486,
0.7561938762664795,
-0.15928973257541656,
0.6925241351127625,
0.09719640761613846,
-0.6576595306396484,
0.3847797214984894,
-0.36048623919487,
-0.4320087432861328,
0.7050418853759766,
0.4534183740615845,
-0.7102929949760437,
-0.6794609427452087,
-0.7452860474586487,
-0.554186224937439,
0.7111974358558655,
0.13757823407649994,
0.21896907687187195,
0.0615072175860405,
0.5967475175857544,
0.29131031036376953,
0.06516732275485992,
-0.7026950716972351,
-0.20221228897571564,
-0.5289609432220459,
-0.30956101417541504,
-0.18132226169109344,
0.12553216516971588,
0.07193038612604141,
-0.2451159507036209,
1.0178245306015015,
0.08878333121538162,
-0.06177270784974098,
0.10707495361566544,
-0.21233628690242767,
-0.406382292509079,
-0.17914417386054993,
0.16449065506458282,
0.6106442809104919,
0.11182687431573868,
0.1643074005842209,
-0.061882033944129944,
-0.5584156513214111,
0.36610108613967896,
0.20751650631427765,
-0.4244788885116577,
0.24866537749767303,
0.4370393455028534,
-0.015233948826789856,
-0.11898301541805267,
-0.32997530698776245,
0.5079110264778137,
-0.0841924324631691,
-0.2543124258518219,
-0.3463760316371918,
0.32889899611473083,
0.0306070726364851,
-0.07320783287286758,
0.46952247619628906,
0.3842039108276367,
0.4640272557735443,
-0.3572590947151184,
0.09462980180978775,
0.26684290170669556,
-0.06537425518035889,
-0.5928025245666504,
0.45308637619018555,
0.541326105594635,
-0.525242805480957,
0.712439775466919,
-0.3454342484474182,
-0.29921090602874756,
0.4856638014316559,
-0.08853147178888321,
0.7868068814277649,
-0.5836106538772583,
0.36583954095840454,
0.40392228960990906,
0.18526233732700348,
0.364580899477005,
-0.09630665928125381,
-0.20363733172416687,
-0.5030881762504578,
-0.10901590436697006,
-0.3980286419391632,
-0.2710745632648468,
0.2973877787590027,
-0.8211216926574707,
0.6047743558883667,
-0.10620564967393875,
-0.3365412652492523,
0.4869518280029297,
0.23435212671756744,
-0.6985828280448914,
0.01581866294145584,
0.24016526341438293,
0.6829348206520081,
-1.0779987573623657,
0.6827319264411926,
0.6071427464485168,
-0.13147394359111786,
-0.517437219619751,
0.1438635289669037,
0.2662128806114197,
-0.15840506553649902,
0.29279860854148865,
-0.03622981160879135,
0.11997629702091217,
-0.028696076944470406,
-0.7043012976646423,
-0.6244943141937256,
0.6146217584609985,
0.15074005722999573,
-0.3655092716217041,
-0.16888320446014404,
0.13713113963603973,
0.44884634017944336,
0.33578720688819885,
-0.09326136112213135,
-0.28516143560409546,
0.4833414852619171,
-0.20749405026435852,
-0.7152988910675049,
-0.3022330701351166,
-0.5016279220581055,
-0.1498117595911026,
0.1966584175825119,
-0.6350647211074829,
0.6669180989265442,
0.06933285295963287,
-0.15697884559631348,
0.023336196318268776,
0.5242399573326111,
0.07198676466941833,
0.4499012529850006,
0.8982617259025574,
0.3105711340904236,
0.8832598328590393,
0.12770919501781464,
0.7532647848129272,
0.14468614757061005,
0.37580543756484985,
0.6758472919464111,
-0.09762504696846008,
0.4671815037727356,
0.44758355617523193,
-0.29793646931648254,
0.5193735361099243,
0.7079376578330994,
-0.3660550117492676,
0.6399049162864685,
0.40301671624183655,
-0.3132413327693939,
0.03963351249694824,
0.0902273952960968,
-0.17723672091960907,
0.4686967730522156,
0.28412726521492004,
-0.1288929581642151,
-0.15686741471290588,
0.2313915640115738,
-0.16945408284664154,
0.0932033583521843,
-0.5217391848564148,
0.9406899213790894,
-0.33971089124679565,
-0.5771385431289673,
0.22576355934143066,
0.48700493574142456,
0.6277515292167664,
-0.3491726517677307,
0.08159875869750977,
0.15031874179840088,
0.14124533534049988,
-0.4992142915725708,
-0.6675347685813904,
0.44065311551094055,
0.3904665410518646,
-0.5941516160964966,
0.07949644327163696,
1.0180951356887817,
-0.04795315861701965,
-0.7153146266937256,
0.17543581128120422,
0.3428310751914978,
0.06579074263572693,
0.013696304522454739,
-0.7166770100593567,
-0.2733021378517151,
-0.0278778038918972,
-0.38462987542152405,
0.25092747807502747,
0.6181918978691101,
-0.3002837300300598,
0.5367227792739868,
0.8833024501800537,
0.06392449140548706,
0.060047924518585205,
0.12932297587394714,
1.0311009883880615,
-0.3484486937522888,
-0.6272202134132385,
-0.9448790550231934,
0.5138373374938965,
-0.45797353982925415,
-0.19350233674049377,
0.9769749641418457,
0.8394851088523865,
0.8864107131958008,
-0.12372610718011856,
0.7186671495437622,
-0.2661638855934143,
0.7514253854751587,
0.12666673958301544,
0.976157546043396,
-0.35420170426368713,
-0.23566994071006775,
-0.438122421503067,
-0.2878727912902832,
0.04788072407245636,
0.4526316225528717,
-0.03496333956718445,
-0.08634758740663528,
-0.272524356842041,
0.7749645113945007,
-0.19131030142307281,
0.0863165482878685,
0.019557906314730644,
0.022175796329975128,
0.42908406257629395,
0.1582062542438507,
1.0491000413894653,
-0.2516530752182007,
0.704124927520752,
-0.551316499710083,
-0.35543978214263916,
-0.31975752115249634,
-0.4034929573535919,
-0.8969355225563049,
-0.7827281951904297,
-0.3507120907306671,
-0.47501134872436523,
-0.09637455642223358,
0.5283973217010498,
1.1112079620361328,
-0.6082232594490051,
-0.007804257329553366,
-0.025713011622428894,
0.4141903817653656,
-0.050762541592121124,
-0.38653308153152466,
0.059968769550323486,
-0.046548474580049515,
-0.580560028553009,
-0.15313820540905,
-0.10740794986486435,
0.08518984913825989,
-0.693757951259613,
-0.06951835006475449,
0.03603503108024597,
-0.013966617174446583,
0.316501647233963,
0.3081303536891937,
-0.3739931285381317,
0.09423743188381195,
-0.21973729133605957,
-0.20664599537849426,
-0.48984766006469727,
0.6606749892234802,
-0.9286085963249207,
0.45926809310913086,
0.3539264500141144,
0.224852055311203,
0.4083098769187927,
0.18805979192256927,
0.2844576835632324,
-0.7085250020027161,
0.1548456847667694,
0.38651835918426514,
-0.22388847172260284,
0.30529478192329407,
-0.8516817688941956,
0.31969478726387024,
0.47959983348846436,
-0.5532882213592529,
-1.1166396141052246,
-0.15261851251125336,
-0.596796452999115,
-0.529064953327179,
0.7015525698661804,
0.08844030648469925,
-0.23151548206806183,
-0.5572522282600403,
0.05601537972688675,
0.5549036264419556,
-0.11593466997146606,
1.2747634649276733,
0.7560371160507202,
0.044587112963199615,
0.324739545583725,
-0.5256090760231018,
0.4715125858783722,
-0.47385117411613464,
-1.0358916521072388,
0.2588844299316406,
0.6849216222763062,
0.5508283972740173,
0.5414682030677795,
0.566356360912323,
-0.14669528603553772,
0.45365333557128906,
-0.09989600628614426,
0.031895264983177185,
-0.24714168906211853,
-0.24388423562049866,
0.1259332001209259,
0.17905676364898682,
-0.17364776134490967,
-0.09036925435066223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18822v1
|
Toxicity Detection for Free
| 2024-05-29T07:03:31 | 2024-05-29T07:03:31 |
Zhanhao Hu, Julien Piet, Geng Zhao, Jiantao Jiao, David Wagner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current LLMs are generally aligned to follow safety requirements and tend to
refuse toxic prompts. However, LLMs can fail to refuse toxic prompts or be
overcautious and refuse benign examples. In addition, state-of-the-art toxicity
detectors have low TPRs at low FPR, incurring high costs in real-world
applications where toxic examples are rare. In this paper, we explore
Moderation Using LLM Introspection (MULI), which detects toxic prompts using
the information extracted directly from LLMs themselves. We found significant
gaps between benign and toxic prompts in the distribution of alternative
refusal responses and in the distribution of the first response token's logits.
These gaps can be used to detect toxicities: We show that a toy model based on
the logits of specific starting tokens gets reliable performance, while
requiring no training or additional computational cost. We build a more robust
detector using a sparse logistic regression model on the first response token
logits, which greatly exceeds SOTA detectors under multiple metrics.
|
[
-0.15788422524929047,
-0.48836106061935425,
0.9263818860054016,
-0.12725596129894257,
-0.36081066727638245,
-0.3532044291496277,
0.3128877282142639,
-0.4302733540534973,
0.04214830696582794,
0.3833405077457428,
-0.8323104977607727,
-0.5002527236938477,
-0.3881131112575531,
0.27376577258110046,
-0.013617369346320629,
1.1421031951904297,
0.5723843574523926,
-0.09720845520496368,
-0.15771296620368958,
-0.4041832685470581,
-0.6155041456222534,
-0.27251437306404114,
-0.8837122917175293,
-0.14878499507904053,
0.9456281661987305,
0.5342881083488464,
0.2825014889240265,
0.22985152900218964,
0.09435471892356873,
0.24758431315422058,
-0.5868497490882874,
0.4284144639968872,
-0.5519803762435913,
0.34071049094200134,
0.043439723551273346,
-0.7112127542495728,
-0.3416703939437866,
0.03846460580825806,
0.2789829969406128,
0.002368810586631298,
0.0538330003619194,
0.2937081456184387,
0.14735890924930573,
0.578967273235321,
-0.8385210633277893,
0.10248876363039017,
-0.7225956320762634,
0.1551874279975891,
-0.2306252270936966,
-0.349338173866272,
-0.738868772983551,
-0.06086267903447151,
-0.24204431474208832,
-0.5317226648330688,
-0.23944830894470215,
-0.04397675767540932,
0.461379736661911,
0.444286972284317,
-0.6955681443214417,
-0.49229225516319275,
-0.3543046712875366,
0.8882166147232056,
-0.6436691880226135,
0.34350690245628357,
0.3004017174243927,
0.15345324575901031,
-0.13167598843574524,
-0.5225414633750916,
-0.172158345580101,
-0.44168856739997864,
-0.34659141302108765,
-0.07614773511886597,
-0.23887555301189423,
0.017987769097089767,
0.2887169420719147,
0.060441754758358,
-0.6069415807723999,
0.1273926943540573,
-0.17033648490905762,
-0.5844139456748962,
0.427753746509552,
0.606101930141449,
0.17340297996997833,
-0.29065755009651184,
-0.8228530883789062,
0.36286142468452454,
-1.0010181665420532,
0.2769987881183624,
0.31317830085754395,
0.18569406867027283,
-0.08057210594415665,
0.26177531480789185,
0.22483019530773163,
0.3780856430530548,
-0.1780153065919876,
-0.2502393424510956,
0.02363169752061367,
-0.5127795338630676,
-0.2203780710697174,
-0.21721887588500977,
0.7766094207763672,
0.39270901679992676,
-0.1348579078912735,
0.2757644057273865,
-0.3031535744667053,
-0.09496543556451797,
-0.2589423954486847,
-0.9900874495506287,
-0.3623538017272949,
0.36548662185668945,
-0.8049634695053101,
-0.6092565059661865,
-0.6039872169494629,
-0.7052456140518188,
-0.8389904499053955,
0.2206130176782608,
0.40973395109176636,
-0.34607499837875366,
-0.23129567503929138,
-0.01474695559591055,
-0.022262323647737503,
0.024174712598323822,
0.19324404001235962,
-0.7557517290115356,
-0.03347067907452583,
0.41009610891342163,
1.0541120767593384,
-0.15952298045158386,
0.3166995942592621,
-1.0200940370559692,
-0.019328350201249123,
-0.03135602921247482,
1.0661929845809937,
-0.28401246666908264,
-0.5978730320930481,
-0.5158606767654419,
-0.04583742097020149,
0.24410082399845123,
-0.9103627800941467,
0.8922386765480042,
-0.524671733379364,
0.051197927445173264,
-0.38654401898384094,
-0.35885414481163025,
-0.09460560232400894,
0.3620662987232208,
-0.763694703578949,
0.7760886549949646,
0.09242110699415207,
-0.9518433809280396,
0.6551086902618408,
-0.6258447170257568,
-0.06189563125371933,
0.22740037739276886,
-0.04322674870491028,
-0.4117489159107208,
-0.10427740961313248,
0.04469406232237816,
0.29302385449409485,
0.11732623726129532,
0.2802734673023224,
-0.5172410011291504,
-0.6088680624961853,
0.41631168127059937,
-0.6458654999732971,
1.307578682899475,
0.7728245854377747,
0.08844514936208725,
0.6559292674064636,
-0.559410810470581,
-0.14101164042949677,
-0.1571751832962036,
-0.5902609825134277,
-0.37764790654182434,
0.14258550107479095,
0.009509091265499592,
0.2348065823316574,
-0.0942530483007431,
-0.6993341445922852,
-0.30123600363731384,
-0.16752739250659943,
0.37347328662872314,
1.2130976915359497,
0.08154664933681488,
0.10399457067251205,
-0.7348561882972717,
0.3251223862171173,
0.26675495505332947,
0.6057233214378357,
-0.2313547283411026,
-0.5991342067718506,
-0.6632017493247986,
-0.5742528438568115,
-0.17516419291496277,
0.46932947635650635,
-0.37108659744262695,
0.5360468029975891,
-0.029583511874079704,
-0.3507005572319031,
-0.11791397631168365,
0.20932435989379883,
0.16453970968723297,
0.5060284733772278,
0.25126150250434875,
0.08433511853218079,
-0.39743712544441223,
-0.6960391402244568,
-0.14258770644664764,
-0.3439062237739563,
-0.24716290831565857,
0.560199499130249,
0.29486438632011414,
-0.013417789712548256,
0.6307981610298157,
-0.4582001864910126,
-0.502188503742218,
0.12626302242279053,
-0.22315910458564758,
0.3222464621067047,
0.3024645149707794,
0.6665288805961609,
-0.5559816360473633,
-0.3776640295982361,
-0.18593284487724304,
-0.6587763428688049,
-0.21232011914253235,
0.1850070208311081,
-0.09139915555715561,
-0.06687268614768982,
0.6253077983856201,
-0.3049652576446533,
0.17710179090499878,
0.4476882219314575,
-0.3101140260696411,
0.4017837941646576,
0.09455535560846329,
0.06647367030382156,
-0.5807796120643616,
0.3105737566947937,
-0.007455185055732727,
-0.45364993810653687,
-0.771557629108429,
0.14757031202316284,
0.09302441030740738,
-0.06581856310367584,
-0.9724891781806946,
0.7273809313774109,
-0.1323668360710144,
0.35114532709121704,
-0.14438894391059875,
-0.15676702558994293,
0.10285528749227524,
0.30808570981025696,
-0.2126132845878601,
0.9379419088363647,
0.06260284781455994,
-0.7426380515098572,
0.1662486493587494,
-0.05896075442433357,
-0.19239938259124756,
0.4214250147342682,
-0.4952392280101776,
-0.05536368116736412,
-0.1885828822851181,
0.31864458322525024,
-1.307642936706543,
-0.1382010281085968,
0.697261393070221,
-0.09143242239952087,
0.14940960705280304,
-0.2653646171092987,
-0.39368733763694763,
-0.23494866490364075,
-0.6892211437225342,
0.5806058645248413,
0.4757785499095917,
-0.4542374014854431,
0.3412541449069977,
0.33435705304145813,
-0.0026603678707033396,
-0.5020586252212524,
-0.7321875691413879,
-0.46099600195884705,
-0.5972436666488647,
-0.40923264622688293,
-0.4386463463306427,
-0.6688446998596191,
-0.12458284944295883,
-0.13984942436218262,
-0.26465553045272827,
-0.12760667502880096,
0.4473683834075928,
0.2402600347995758,
0.3458777964115143,
-0.1149192526936531,
0.09660551697015762,
0.10049047321081161,
-0.2449609935283661,
0.3169183135032654,
0.1838950216770172,
0.28395935893058777,
-0.0005271923146210611,
-0.4061635434627533,
-0.5776402950286865,
0.24420006573200226,
0.781428337097168,
0.021441953256726265,
0.27061840891838074,
0.35479772090911865,
-0.46180281043052673,
-0.045694075524806976,
-0.4133191406726837,
-0.2486112415790558,
-0.5863472819328308,
-0.047610871493816376,
-0.1354544460773468,
-0.9592347145080566,
0.539856493473053,
0.02928064949810505,
0.05918765440583229,
0.13902463018894196,
0.4760728180408478,
0.07938957214355469,
1.2624132633209229,
0.2566175162792206,
-0.08698873966932297,
0.3332321345806122,
0.055992819368839264,
0.17097772657871246,
-0.6111226677894592,
-0.3539450764656067,
-0.36084097623825073,
-0.24237307906150818,
-0.40940266847610474,
-0.35165131092071533,
0.9655388593673706,
-0.3498380482196808,
-0.4410308003425598,
-0.42020925879478455,
-0.5506231784820557,
0.749098539352417,
0.26001641154289246,
0.6797558069229126,
0.606816828250885,
-0.06052069738507271,
-0.15830817818641663,
-0.0528189055621624,
-0.4753662943840027,
-0.4343041479587555,
0.900326132774353,
0.5124030113220215,
0.914127767086029,
0.15679512917995453,
0.5391008853912354,
0.21387489140033722,
0.8847116231918335,
-0.8909714221954346,
0.4778327941894531,
-0.08883065730333328,
-1.0241758823394775,
-0.056092675775289536,
-0.36501312255859375,
-0.6418247818946838,
0.19901719689369202,
-0.10780007392168045,
-0.6574557423591614,
0.32036474347114563,
0.012412111274898052,
-0.7560038566589355,
0.5897108316421509,
-0.6562907099723816,
0.6206196546554565,
-0.21016858518123627,
-0.5109072327613831,
0.05572141706943512,
-0.6137825846672058,
0.9238650798797607,
-0.26295390725135803,
0.4504324495792389,
-0.5681151747703552,
-0.27810075879096985,
0.3493766486644745,
-0.21482723951339722,
0.9338827729225159,
-0.31463852524757385,
-0.1660470813512802,
0.6451502442359924,
0.41806280612945557,
0.2420220524072647,
0.3499378561973572,
-0.34885290265083313,
-0.15986569225788116,
0.06174442544579506,
-0.33281394839286804,
-0.11487727612257004,
0.763092577457428,
-0.32696911692619324,
-0.49659138917922974,
-0.3007587790489197,
-0.7004609704017639,
-0.02482241950929165,
0.3817596733570099,
0.4865942597389221,
-0.12307699769735336,
0.08624496310949326,
-0.09227945655584335,
0.8967360854148865,
-0.43020427227020264,
0.15917393565177917,
0.4981110990047455,
-0.29278644919395447,
-0.06742590665817261,
0.8452714681625366,
-0.19521677494049072,
0.27348020672798157,
0.04182666167616844,
0.5516398549079895,
-0.6460440158843994,
-0.4880150556564331,
-0.45369818806648254,
0.10448885709047318,
-0.7820487022399902,
-0.7637747526168823,
-0.625823438167572,
-0.13353806734085083,
-0.11608331650495529,
0.21631617844104767,
0.013645022176206112,
0.18553714454174042,
-0.6441407799720764,
-0.2976503074169159,
0.4238245487213135,
0.7243767380714417,
-0.41123220324516296,
-0.023597605526447296,
-1.0495234727859497,
-0.11197137087583542,
0.3628643751144409,
0.34466055035591125,
0.10414174944162369,
-0.3844449818134308,
0.3403976857662201,
0.115406334400177,
-0.43384459614753723,
-0.9502993226051331,
0.17575703561306,
0.005676522850990295,
0.5513767004013062,
0.8336770534515381,
0.26791492104530334,
0.5079564452171326,
0.03177366033196449,
0.7333711385726929,
0.1133190244436264,
-0.9269282221794128,
0.6364319920539856,
-0.32564565539360046,
-0.2823408544063568,
0.5234682559967041,
0.6536963582038879,
-0.5493494272232056,
-0.5283784866333008,
-0.07335799187421799,
-0.4203515648841858,
0.707053542137146,
-0.03347138315439224,
0.26440268754959106,
-0.19866333901882172,
0.3499053716659546,
0.3440414071083069,
-0.09703292697668076,
-1.1524569988250732,
-0.4121120572090149,
0.15348051488399506,
-0.04838454723358154,
0.28222131729125977,
-0.7723475098609924,
-0.21846981346607208,
-0.12771975994110107,
0.3406774699687958,
0.05091731622815132,
0.11696141958236694,
0.09527087956666946,
-0.058600280433893204,
-0.3339826762676239,
0.3846597373485565,
0.4753907024860382,
0.10613033920526505,
-0.45283782482147217,
0.36641940474510193,
0.42273780703544617,
-0.1362612396478653,
0.7573268413543701,
-0.37651190161705017,
-0.3506343364715576,
-0.11636757850646973,
0.22477412223815918,
0.2754797637462616,
0.2943263649940491,
-0.8501789569854736,
0.7568143606185913,
-0.0487564317882061,
-0.028794316574931145,
0.21490877866744995,
0.22930972278118134,
-0.055398546159267426,
0.1877426952123642,
0.0643448755145073,
-0.036725353449583054,
0.6751411557197571,
-0.5155429244041443,
0.4808700978755951,
0.6199935078620911,
-0.6220728754997253,
-0.10921993851661682,
0.8554753065109253,
0.26978299021720886,
0.2086750715970993,
0.4403631091117859,
-0.5732243061065674,
-0.31620100140571594,
0.5123841166496277,
0.45893657207489014,
0.5355592370033264,
-0.389652281999588,
0.19758793711662292,
0.4735475778579712,
0.22823578119277954,
0.5752314925193787,
0.45973578095436096,
-0.047350212931632996,
-0.6599159836769104,
-0.29086387157440186,
-0.4406096041202545,
-0.07616213709115982,
0.6954103708267212,
-0.4689873456954956,
0.3771745562553406,
-0.7664360404014587,
-0.08588384836912155,
-0.13087010383605957,
-0.1957281529903412,
-0.2790427803993225,
-0.22099044919013977,
0.28228238224983215,
0.9717366099357605,
-1.322826862335205,
0.3007684350013733,
0.43476682901382446,
-0.3919585347175598,
-0.7450728416442871,
-0.28797242045402527,
0.44038569927215576,
-0.7366520166397095,
0.5853409171104431,
0.5232850909233093,
-0.05727022886276245,
-0.22146648168563843,
-0.5779275894165039,
-0.48271143436431885,
1.0686163902282715,
0.27713319659233093,
-0.20520727336406708,
-0.07609853893518448,
-0.234314426779747,
0.43888452649116516,
0.20922772586345673,
0.538316011428833,
0.5141547322273254,
0.562417209148407,
0.14529095590114594,
-0.49121811985969543,
0.4620046615600586,
-0.09179919213056564,
-0.2887016534805298,
0.22333389520645142,
-0.7591671347618103,
1.0297040939331055,
-0.1888394057750702,
-0.6984682679176331,
0.35805001854896545,
0.2408628612756729,
0.5542060732841492,
0.9413964748382568,
0.890648365020752,
0.29671964049339294,
0.7270704507827759,
0.1787729114294052,
0.5776258111000061,
-0.07495363801717758,
0.40193450450897217,
0.7448437809944153,
-0.43210655450820923,
0.3632009029388428,
0.3221651017665863,
-0.24097837507724762,
0.4895786941051483,
0.9273970127105713,
0.0890076756477356,
0.6638258099555969,
0.2167966067790985,
-0.9449132680892944,
-0.3144497275352478,
-0.6271560192108154,
-0.23174013197422028,
0.011138375848531723,
0.6430403590202332,
-0.2059713900089264,
-0.7136330008506775,
0.15244817733764648,
0.03312739357352257,
-0.29557090997695923,
-0.34833046793937683,
0.5166788101196289,
0.0409010648727417,
-0.47921159863471985,
0.4981369078159332,
-0.303618848323822,
1.0892542600631714,
-0.5235379934310913,
0.021873129531741142,
-0.4751594364643097,
0.010370515286922455,
-0.4578508138656616,
-0.8772119879722595,
0.32064738869667053,
-0.06434140354394913,
0.3104814291000366,
-0.04058943688869476,
1.2816778421401978,
-0.17939633131027222,
0.03975887969136238,
0.4505535066127777,
0.7026984691619873,
0.23860907554626465,
-0.04957365244626999,
-0.5580846667289734,
-0.04040095582604408,
0.09654613584280014,
-0.07181242853403091,
0.2607198655605316,
0.4199643135070801,
0.0030198527965694666,
0.9121474027633667,
0.9236161708831787,
-0.07769625633955002,
0.21555297076702118,
-0.23642189800739288,
1.0648584365844727,
-0.2269536554813385,
-0.18506404757499695,
-0.8722806572914124,
0.5451229810714722,
0.2889840006828308,
-0.047881800681352615,
0.3220350444316864,
0.5597163438796997,
0.6438875794410706,
-0.006344834808260202,
0.42833125591278076,
0.28616079688072205,
0.30604952573776245,
-0.6378951668739319,
0.7473205924034119,
-0.7006727457046509,
0.5305760502815247,
0.22175493836402893,
-0.414564311504364,
-0.45507922768592834,
0.48030585050582886,
0.28887948393821716,
-0.07472030818462372,
0.5806100964546204,
1.1552599668502808,
-0.192592591047287,
-0.02416195720434189,
0.3578762412071228,
0.12968488037586212,
0.5790702700614929,
0.8844318985939026,
1.1856633424758911,
-0.05452857166528702,
0.773228108882904,
-0.24501703679561615,
-0.3724142611026764,
-0.3508409261703491,
-0.9828673601150513,
-0.8107903003692627,
-0.21770933270454407,
0.2018589973449707,
-0.5399381518363953,
-0.23222772777080536,
0.7475360631942749,
0.6156100630760193,
-0.8745623230934143,
0.13520854711532593,
0.00004338144208304584,
0.5697491765022278,
0.10892386734485626,
-0.29206159710884094,
-0.03658723086118698,
-0.3809800446033478,
-0.5925465226173401,
0.4413292407989502,
0.3868291676044464,
0.16878551244735718,
-0.21472392976284027,
-0.037801072001457214,
-0.14275223016738892,
-0.0169603880494833,
0.7197698354721069,
0.3030211627483368,
-0.5652461051940918,
-0.6051766872406006,
0.15184442698955536,
-0.3252931833267212,
0.06463561952114105,
0.8348178863525391,
-0.6497922539710999,
0.3400190472602844,
0.5808168053627014,
0.18975995481014252,
0.14588919281959534,
-0.1883285790681839,
-0.175670325756073,
-0.8464935421943665,
0.34393760561943054,
0.42253777384757996,
0.2530771493911743,
-0.009310927242040634,
-0.8043150901794434,
0.5209643244743347,
0.3460994064807892,
-0.7694944739341736,
-0.9232401847839355,
0.5347436666488647,
-0.7603960037231445,
-0.29024380445480347,
1.0857393741607666,
-0.25212526321411133,
-0.11596731096506119,
-0.4159872233867645,
-0.25235792994499207,
0.08449465036392212,
-0.3500315546989441,
0.3932364583015442,
0.5777730941772461,
-0.6183937191963196,
0.1602896749973297,
-0.48822295665740967,
0.4785633683204651,
0.3018772006034851,
-0.6845447421073914,
0.07588513940572739,
0.7075982093811035,
0.8389435410499573,
0.15781080722808838,
1.1229686737060547,
-0.20250120759010315,
0.2411954402923584,
-0.1758972406387329,
-0.5549073219299316,
-0.07393155992031097,
-0.19528570771217346,
-0.4578325152397156,
-0.22026872634887695,
0.33499979972839355,
-0.36468029022216797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18776v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18776v1
|
LMO-DP: Optimizing the Randomization Mechanism for Differentially Private Fine-Tuning (Large) Language Models
| 2024-05-29T05:32:50 | 2024-05-29T05:32:50 |
Qin Yang, Meisam Mohammad, Han Wang, Ali Payani, Ashish Kundu, Kai Shu, Yan Yan, Yuan Hong
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Differentially Private Stochastic Gradient Descent (DP-SGD) and its variants
have been proposed to ensure rigorous privacy for fine-tuning large-scale
pre-trained language models. However, they rely heavily on the Gaussian
mechanism, which may overly perturb the gradients and degrade the accuracy,
especially in stronger privacy regimes (e.g., the privacy budget $\epsilon <
3$). To address such limitations, we propose a novel Language Model-based
Optimal Differential Privacy (LMO-DP) mechanism, which takes the first step to
enable the tight composition of accurately fine-tuning (large) language models
with a sub-optimal DP mechanism, even in strong privacy regimes (e.g., $0.1\leq
\epsilon<3$). Furthermore, we propose a novel offline optimal noise search
method to efficiently derive the sub-optimal DP that significantly reduces the
noise magnitude. For instance, fine-tuning RoBERTa-large (with 300M parameters)
on the SST-2 dataset can achieve an accuracy of 92.20% (given $\epsilon=0.3$,
$\delta=10^{-10}$) by drastically outperforming the Gaussian mechanism (e.g.,
$\sim 50\%$ for small $\epsilon$ and $\delta$). We also draw similar findings
on the text generation tasks on GPT-2. Finally, to our best knowledge, LMO-DP
is also the first solution to accurately fine-tune Llama-2 with strong
differential privacy guarantees. The code will be released soon and available
upon request.
|
[
-0.1755419373512268,
-0.6194023489952087,
0.6465309858322144,
0.1682971864938736,
-0.4166335165500641,
0.06804732978343964,
-0.4164622128009796,
-0.1902661770582199,
-0.22010403871536255,
0.22499887645244598,
-0.8546513319015503,
-0.669596254825592,
-0.6019861698150635,
-0.08226509392261505,
-0.1667296439409256,
1.029761791229248,
-0.0179958026856184,
0.12726148962974548,
0.3733234107494354,
0.27910467982292175,
0.28274840116500854,
-0.3310772180557251,
-0.5631346702575684,
0.02070065401494503,
0.6243512630462646,
0.12264806032180786,
0.4737882912158966,
0.9364709258079529,
0.5847980976104736,
0.2901073396205902,
-0.17358265817165375,
0.34394022822380066,
-0.7538606524467468,
0.1683792918920517,
-0.11732546240091324,
-0.49136531352996826,
-0.5208757519721985,
-0.09148555248975754,
0.6596333384513855,
0.37613004446029663,
-0.33978286385536194,
0.0989997610449791,
0.18740862607955933,
0.7609665393829346,
-0.6576150059700012,
0.310028612613678,
-0.5957359075546265,
0.05173506587743759,
-0.404559463262558,
-0.2861480712890625,
-0.09824914485216141,
-0.4465304911136627,
-0.13931818306446075,
-0.4240867495536804,
0.32322683930397034,
-0.11122549325227737,
0.6893771886825562,
0.3427008092403412,
-0.16220347583293915,
-0.2066316157579422,
-0.7391597032546997,
0.9675899147987366,
-0.7532317638397217,
0.38119301199913025,
0.5280830264091492,
0.07654932886362076,
-0.2552756667137146,
-0.5281583070755005,
-0.5094327330589294,
-0.4449527859687805,
0.20570148527622223,
-0.025019781664013863,
-0.07522044330835342,
0.4412999749183655,
0.25662514567375183,
0.8265753388404846,
-0.3127019703388214,
0.5135523676872253,
-0.30085623264312744,
-0.05465157330036163,
0.8226358294487,
0.1039801761507988,
0.0779748484492302,
0.3816414177417755,
-0.08695670962333679,
0.012289282865822315,
-0.6519182920455933,
-0.151002898812294,
1.0863133668899536,
0.17915837466716766,
-0.24758051335811615,
0.39172619581222534,
-0.4784207046031952,
0.4948230981826782,
0.15491044521331787,
-0.25702720880508423,
0.060535553842782974,
-0.2946186661720276,
-0.03774534538388252,
-0.27504995465278625,
0.8649627566337585,
0.363072007894516,
0.24367250502109528,
-0.12851834297180176,
-0.3648509085178375,
0.02092340774834156,
-0.13154853880405426,
-0.8096073865890503,
-0.19429263472557068,
0.43146753311157227,
-0.2884956896305084,
-0.8485216498374939,
-0.21021752059459686,
-0.8164985179901123,
-0.31390318274497986,
-0.1926649808883667,
0.24109522998332977,
-0.012331873178482056,
-0.3130308985710144,
0.3003515303134918,
0.30230823159217834,
-0.4083920121192932,
0.0907081812620163,
-1.3605663776397705,
0.39805614948272705,
0.8407648205757141,
0.9407882690429688,
-0.09541617333889008,
-0.09978257119655609,
-0.6024125218391418,
0.2425864040851593,
-0.2459918111562729,
0.12792181968688965,
-0.4294472932815552,
-0.2768583297729492,
0.15426236391067505,
-0.10140573978424072,
0.18954172730445862,
-0.15792231261730194,
0.6128145456314087,
-0.5363571047782898,
0.3318565785884857,
0.0381031408905983,
-0.525698184967041,
-0.08270413428544998,
-0.06774169951677322,
-0.41002845764160156,
0.7709880471229553,
0.04170292988419533,
-0.6468145847320557,
0.2052198350429535,
-0.7306246757507324,
-0.1833028346300125,
-0.3258233368396759,
-0.3087279200553894,
-0.6460205316543579,
0.17387564480304718,
0.20415273308753967,
0.65626060962677,
-0.4038485288619995,
0.3297756016254425,
-0.4959861934185028,
-0.43218764662742615,
0.02280258759856224,
-0.43782946467399597,
0.7244543433189392,
0.3713580071926117,
-0.6633263826370239,
-0.045535098761320114,
-1.0635100603103638,
0.025900015607476234,
0.21845735609531403,
-0.4285360872745514,
-0.366922527551651,
-0.07222763448953629,
-0.2837342619895935,
-0.010744024999439716,
0.5275521278381348,
-0.5620051026344299,
0.23050254583358765,
-0.5996468663215637,
0.638437807559967,
1.1482552289962769,
-0.16252270340919495,
0.7715699672698975,
-0.2743012309074402,
0.5196627378463745,
0.08653263002634048,
0.41290128231048584,
-0.05547180026769638,
-0.49343299865722656,
-0.2656159996986389,
-0.6628503203392029,
0.3385719060897827,
0.37888988852500916,
-0.041713934391736984,
0.4944845139980316,
-0.11483031511306763,
-0.41937366127967834,
-0.4165008068084717,
0.1770080327987671,
0.5754143595695496,
0.2327301949262619,
0.07443498820066452,
-0.21970349550247192,
-0.10496126115322113,
-0.8935792446136475,
-0.05218758061528206,
0.03284367546439171,
-0.041453707963228226,
0.5580538511276245,
0.09610443562269211,
-0.2859191298484802,
0.4982350170612335,
-0.5586299300193787,
-0.47838476300239563,
0.032977230846881866,
0.0066886828280985355,
0.28818991780281067,
0.6023184061050415,
0.5329297184944153,
-0.5680912733078003,
-0.5340358018875122,
0.14307941496372223,
-0.2762422561645508,
-0.41127800941467285,
0.18855580687522888,
-0.019195720553398132,
0.4263339340686798,
0.18940679728984833,
-0.498230516910553,
0.25405704975128174,
0.9008182883262634,
0.13747185468673706,
0.14811821281909943,
-0.5786057710647583,
-0.02425668016076088,
-1.0298627614974976,
-0.1065303385257721,
-0.12841041386127472,
-0.10089890658855438,
-0.43380090594291687,
0.31902292370796204,
0.11714419722557068,
-0.1470358520746231,
-0.3239704668521881,
0.3805555999279022,
-0.5630622506141663,
0.12651164829730988,
-0.2748240530490875,
0.1417774111032486,
-0.2937915027141571,
0.643078625202179,
-0.11471393704414368,
0.6934916973114014,
0.7202939391136169,
-0.6285215616226196,
0.17665128409862518,
-0.16313448548316956,
-0.4527429938316345,
0.020044216886162758,
-0.6086740493774414,
0.41846922039985657,
-0.2780087888240814,
0.1700165718793869,
-0.7794545292854309,
-0.10519219189882278,
0.5037899613380432,
-0.07603596895933151,
0.4973815381526947,
-0.27422231435775757,
-0.47312653064727783,
-0.05766892060637474,
-0.48293235898017883,
0.30776479840278625,
0.6622039675712585,
-0.5452971458435059,
0.13205686211585999,
0.5322726964950562,
-0.2477494776248932,
-0.8514975309371948,
-0.6498982310295105,
-0.12448133528232574,
-0.1063348576426506,
-0.7321114540100098,
0.45982688665390015,
-0.17877987027168274,
-0.3039872646331787,
-0.3552858829498291,
-0.19261714816093445,
-0.150088831782341,
0.044064100831747055,
0.10634700953960419,
-0.17516660690307617,
-0.05123308300971985,
-0.13026010990142822,
0.4868142902851105,
-0.37472328543663025,
-0.11432177573442459,
-0.4204256534576416,
0.6702516078948975,
0.015184849500656128,
-0.25143158435821533,
-0.6582456827163696,
0.3983079493045807,
0.3201057016849518,
-0.1547694206237793,
0.6781556606292725,
0.3973110616207123,
-0.11970937997102737,
-0.6041846871376038,
-0.48461174964904785,
-0.4398423135280609,
-0.5488266348838806,
0.5675570368766785,
-0.3413778245449066,
-1.074275255203247,
0.4656541347503662,
-0.10788444429636002,
0.24060438573360443,
0.06494436413049698,
0.7684462070465088,
0.2655397355556488,
1.1241751909255981,
0.8710192441940308,
-0.31232738494873047,
0.59061598777771,
-0.17397139966487885,
0.4036732017993927,
-0.4461064338684082,
0.07931637018918991,
-0.5170149803161621,
-0.4889500141143799,
-1.0276294946670532,
-0.4582449197769165,
0.09509783238172531,
0.1038793995976448,
-0.05754118040204048,
0.14483019709587097,
-0.6807581782341003,
0.6333180665969849,
0.7347102165222168,
0.24910396337509155,
0.4742538034915924,
0.23945003747940063,
-0.07036595791578293,
-0.08033738285303116,
-0.33151882886886597,
-0.43383342027664185,
1.2737617492675781,
0.5829048752784729,
1.0859447717666626,
0.13100816309452057,
1.1625720262527466,
-0.016664188355207443,
-0.026798667386174202,
-0.2948373258113861,
0.7012641429901123,
-0.39061281085014343,
-0.4888695478439331,
-0.36067843437194824,
-0.5855882167816162,
-0.5200681686401367,
0.0620599202811718,
0.18388697504997253,
-0.8907652497291565,
0.3310985863208771,
0.18736515939235687,
-0.1959996372461319,
0.27887943387031555,
-0.5094040632247925,
0.4456746578216553,
-0.06372641026973724,
-0.6915643811225891,
-0.4711695611476898,
-0.5784791111946106,
0.46492716670036316,
-0.3308347761631012,
0.16761741042137146,
-0.24815794825553894,
-0.29700544476509094,
0.4260416030883789,
-0.4094814956188202,
0.8352819085121155,
-0.4740833044052124,
-0.6673107743263245,
-0.2336803525686264,
0.0658569186925888,
1.068176031112671,
0.5534636974334717,
-0.1317610889673233,
0.5232201814651489,
-0.12066619843244553,
-0.053337518125772476,
-0.4405263066291809,
0.9768022894859314,
-0.8346883058547974,
-0.7068349123001099,
-0.36253488063812256,
-0.5594127178192139,
-0.012895392253994942,
0.16613668203353882,
0.2950890064239502,
0.07756078988313675,
0.13711872696876526,
0.1458720564842224,
0.7467514872550964,
-0.3110504448413849,
0.32845231890678406,
0.8676621317863464,
-0.2001412957906723,
-0.20969712734222412,
0.8124145865440369,
-0.013980738818645477,
0.2912227511405945,
0.5450806021690369,
0.39949125051498413,
-0.4547569453716278,
-0.9339996576309204,
-0.37796756625175476,
0.2548050284385681,
-0.39780309796333313,
-0.01168389618396759,
-0.6858581900596619,
-0.2267707884311676,
-0.166447713971138,
0.09223407506942749,
-0.5821617245674133,
-0.6574410200119019,
-0.3503524363040924,
-0.2290986031293869,
0.377838134765625,
0.2678965628147125,
-0.6457277536392212,
0.09822767972946167,
-0.5263000726699829,
0.4263681471347809,
0.2562335729598999,
0.5506086349487305,
-0.2936970293521881,
-0.5521697402000427,
0.030908968299627304,
0.37460213899612427,
-0.2700522840023041,
-0.4750061333179474,
0.2157628834247589,
0.3124200701713562,
0.3117939829826355,
0.46736279129981995,
0.21292197704315186,
0.4342600703239441,
-0.672766387462616,
0.6394739151000977,
-0.005166659597307444,
-0.785874605178833,
0.48143628239631653,
-0.7060434222221375,
-0.2916260063648224,
0.493203341960907,
0.17206315696239471,
-0.0513564758002758,
-0.8381514549255371,
-0.4141964614391327,
-0.8686528205871582,
0.8131775856018066,
0.33201897144317627,
0.4611588418483734,
0.16262994706630707,
0.3030329942703247,
0.3235444724559784,
0.31763607263565063,
-0.7429616451263428,
-0.3382074236869812,
0.27613186836242676,
-0.3215348422527313,
-0.03936067596077919,
-0.3732236921787262,
-0.4878622591495514,
-0.0830318033695221,
0.7026527523994446,
0.0023702860344201326,
0.20703420042991638,
-0.03978073596954346,
0.3582805097103119,
-0.2609905004501343,
0.2602716088294983,
1.1002899408340454,
0.6190332770347595,
-0.3271130919456482,
-0.10887228697538376,
-0.15567636489868164,
-0.7736871838569641,
0.2718006372451782,
0.30810627341270447,
-0.46427613496780396,
0.008800169453024864,
-0.34078553318977356,
0.5694794654846191,
0.006538202054798603,
-0.44567862153053284,
0.5973343253135681,
-0.1787836104631424,
-0.4788069725036621,
-0.19914957880973816,
0.29514941573143005,
-0.0924830511212349,
0.33318594098091125,
0.17750203609466553,
-0.07044193148612976,
0.07985749840736389,
-0.038236793130636215,
0.10771893709897995,
0.41851216554641724,
-0.14551353454589844,
-0.34246987104415894,
1.0449124574661255,
0.27134519815444946,
-0.34941571950912476,
0.09176407754421234,
-0.2329869419336319,
-0.010435671545565128,
0.3216818571090698,
0.3370450437068939,
1.0801987648010254,
-0.1178068295121193,
0.30722397565841675,
0.10863064229488373,
0.23137740790843964,
-0.4503669738769531,
0.453132688999176,
-0.2945038080215454,
-0.511098325252533,
-0.2271096259355545,
-0.7426886558532715,
-0.33282822370529175,
0.30381035804748535,
-0.46299436688423157,
0.18564826250076294,
-0.7777507901191711,
0.03313672915101051,
-0.31797802448272705,
0.09900715202093124,
-0.30393892526626587,
0.1436825692653656,
-0.07761689275503159,
0.4138565957546234,
-0.29416215419769287,
1.0234824419021606,
0.18939439952373505,
-0.1858341097831726,
-0.6066862344741821,
0.1567223221063614,
0.009110729210078716,
-1.0664342641830444,
0.6343936920166016,
-0.09525495767593384,
-0.17238008975982666,
0.3142198324203491,
-0.44188275933265686,
-0.7243645787239075,
0.8794932961463928,
0.7009779810905457,
-1.462810754776001,
0.12557566165924072,
0.39324986934661865,
0.5341949462890625,
0.03394206613302231,
-0.17466731369495392,
0.13962659239768982,
0.41022130846977234,
-0.40396788716316223,
-0.9164165258407593,
0.19637486338615417,
0.03451336547732353,
0.11299355328083038,
0.2756226658821106,
-1.0138845443725586,
0.8195796012878418,
-0.3267298936843872,
-0.30951324105262756,
0.19574248790740967,
0.3866969347000122,
0.21684862673282623,
0.2523747384548187,
0.3224034011363983,
0.5356634855270386,
0.8396960496902466,
0.0342564731836319,
0.8254969716072083,
-0.763788640499115,
0.47484639286994934,
0.8373727202415466,
-0.2313433289527893,
0.503771960735321,
0.6182062029838562,
-0.27437740564346313,
0.061249688267707825,
0.5249279737472534,
0.11456391960382462,
1.157686710357666,
0.6990358233451843,
-0.618628203868866,
0.11743581295013428,
0.1522178202867508,
-0.6928723454475403,
0.001723061897791922,
-0.10404915362596512,
-0.7039251923561096,
-0.06460250914096832,
-0.23445561528205872,
0.092310331761837,
0.1794724315404892,
-0.1444934904575348,
0.6977337002754211,
0.19500002264976501,
-0.19509409368038177,
0.5185307264328003,
0.4384702742099762,
0.8829711675643921,
-0.754538357257843,
0.4017430245876312,
-0.42016953229904175,
0.6315016746520996,
-0.04404519125819206,
-0.3278612494468689,
0.08882676064968109,
-0.08825725317001343,
-0.22097933292388916,
-0.3229263424873352,
0.3814574182033539,
-0.5788509249687195,
-0.41746455430984497,
0.2552459239959717,
0.1566883623600006,
0.011846693232655525,
0.0037982920184731483,
-0.6667728424072266,
0.07402902096509933,
0.02474125660955906,
-0.5664999485015869,
0.6865057945251465,
0.5392497777938843,
0.0633602887392044,
0.5241113305091858,
0.8659629225730896,
0.2648743689060211,
0.12797053158283234,
0.3173202574253082,
0.9724136590957642,
-0.3507910370826721,
-0.8908300399780273,
-1.0691840648651123,
0.3310667872428894,
0.007097170222550631,
-0.387367308139801,
0.6125571727752686,
0.43453651666641235,
0.9284656643867493,
-0.16372835636138916,
0.8930800557136536,
0.12742596864700317,
0.5757028460502625,
-0.6874058842658997,
0.9963740706443787,
-0.7060689926147461,
0.45707881450653076,
-0.37680500745773315,
-0.9319490790367126,
-0.2225492149591446,
0.640490710735321,
-0.1589002162218094,
0.07205398380756378,
0.5911141037940979,
1.3879578113555908,
-0.13298581540584564,
0.006083191838115454,
0.28761160373687744,
0.13494917750358582,
0.3537195026874542,
0.5076216459274292,
0.6361890435218811,
-0.46724775433540344,
0.5729271769523621,
-0.7248638868331909,
-0.4270971119403839,
0.026532022282481194,
-0.9503293037414551,
-0.97803795337677,
-0.5897824168205261,
-0.36996906995773315,
-0.07641124725341797,
0.445546418428421,
0.49671515822410583,
0.7215747237205505,
-0.6508587598800659,
-0.022531891241669655,
-0.5610454082489014,
-0.08599308133125305,
-0.25229740142822266,
-0.12888145446777344,
0.27666598558425903,
-0.1804618090391159,
-1.1319160461425781,
0.41172710061073303,
0.5258903503417969,
0.0920180231332779,
-0.4381228983402252,
-0.26101261377334595,
0.3171408176422119,
0.025776226073503494,
0.11442901194095612,
0.14221055805683136,
-0.5500065088272095,
-0.06380821764469147,
-0.1963796764612198,
-0.27203282713890076,
-0.21583661437034607,
0.7997722625732422,
0.1451030820608139,
0.2201879322528839,
0.5258600115776062,
0.5546525120735168,
0.5529362559318542,
-0.10088808834552765,
0.7852798104286194,
-0.7773264050483704,
0.6470286250114441,
0.2653779685497284,
0.021711615845561028,
-0.09922302514314651,
-0.6300674080848694,
0.5059223175048828,
0.2276540994644165,
-0.8412457704544067,
-1.1872360706329346,
0.2783120572566986,
-0.9005001783370972,
0.060459353029727936,
1.2397786378860474,
-0.26157739758491516,
-0.2419896274805069,
0.07038714736700058,
-0.33324283361434937,
0.05026393383741379,
-0.6968770623207092,
1.2581325769424438,
0.42572131752967834,
0.17916972935199738,
-0.2747620642185211,
-0.42298758029937744,
0.8881352543830872,
0.2874758243560791,
-0.41320231556892395,
0.37863653898239136,
0.2996481657028198,
0.18606194853782654,
-0.1929534673690796,
0.9513369798660278,
-0.28155532479286194,
0.008174707181751728,
-0.09881056100130081,
-0.3638080656528473,
-0.5681270360946655,
-0.12024600803852081,
-0.27229154109954834,
0.17137935757637024,
-0.22780561447143555,
-0.38041919469833374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18742v1
|
Musical Phrase Segmentation via Grammatical Induction
| 2024-05-29T04:04:36 | 2024-05-29T04:04:36 |
Reed Perkins, Dan Ventura
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We outline a solution to the challenge of musical phrase segmentation that
uses grammatical induction algorithms, a class of algorithms which infer a
context-free grammar from an input sequence. We analyze the performance of five
grammatical induction algorithms on three datasets using various musical
viewpoint combinations. Our experiments show that the LONGESTFIRST algorithm
achieves the best F1 scores across all three datasets and that input encodings
that include the duration viewpoint result in the best performance.
|
[
-0.42311105132102966,
-0.9032158255577087,
0.9037103056907654,
0.8587705492973328,
-0.3377440869808197,
-0.07104462385177612,
-0.32374265789985657,
-0.4649123251438141,
0.22762314975261688,
0.1345437616109848,
-0.9810650944709778,
-0.6023377776145935,
-0.3847392499446869,
0.3247602880001068,
-0.7174627184867859,
0.3980843126773834,
0.3406849801540375,
0.3146266043186188,
-0.6774795651435852,
0.029427967965602875,
-0.47994479537010193,
-0.26920759677886963,
-0.35206103324890137,
-0.30807703733444214,
0.3777858018875122,
0.5795522332191467,
0.4926653206348419,
1.1290969848632812,
0.5602594017982483,
0.41068145632743835,
-0.22571583092212677,
0.21349647641181946,
0.035289786756038666,
0.291189968585968,
-0.15004560351371765,
-0.5852305889129639,
0.3717532157897949,
0.2127404361963272,
0.4981159567832947,
0.8151262998580933,
-0.13875816762447357,
-0.12367658317089081,
-0.6171534061431885,
0.6559710502624512,
-0.27011382579803467,
0.10157690197229385,
-0.6248239874839783,
0.3463889956474304,
-0.49464359879493713,
-0.4442695081233978,
-0.6043038964271545,
-0.5975995659828186,
0.05137638375163078,
-0.7109022736549377,
0.021140649914741516,
-0.08956911414861679,
0.9711374044418335,
0.26624545454978943,
-0.024440409615635872,
-0.6342859268188477,
-0.6324895024299622,
0.5827610492706299,
-0.1349438577890396,
0.3145435154438019,
0.25944405794143677,
0.22547726333141327,
-0.26097342371940613,
-0.42518824338912964,
-0.5944564342498779,
0.14250124990940094,
-0.037775859236717224,
-0.011742977425456047,
0.10504759848117828,
0.1356096863746643,
0.29753369092941284,
0.608593761920929,
-0.6573450565338135,
-0.03777490183711052,
-0.35004541277885437,
0.2688629627227783,
0.7679734826087952,
-0.10513252019882202,
0.33435186743736267,
-0.49202242493629456,
-0.1914146989583969,
0.03387151658535004,
-0.6922179460525513,
0.12793543934822083,
0.20955757796764374,
0.2346227467060089,
-0.025171343237161636,
0.7693312168121338,
0.017928335815668106,
0.9735768437385559,
0.4524296522140503,
-0.3240296244621277,
0.36650407314300537,
-0.088254414498806,
-0.4504164457321167,
0.17713898420333862,
0.8317269682884216,
0.30109351873397827,
0.3866599500179291,
-0.4021456837654114,
-0.20046889781951904,
0.38017746806144714,
-0.23068396747112274,
-0.23122890293598175,
0.0570380724966526,
0.15998798608779907,
-0.015268335118889809,
-0.29409074783325195,
0.33408087491989136,
-0.7948837280273438,
-0.2391090840101242,
-0.5833339095115662,
0.2893525958061218,
-0.6277308464050293,
0.20337502658367157,
-0.07541050016880035,
-0.39375901222229004,
0.4314670264720917,
-0.26955467462539673,
-1.1511130332946777,
0.1287798434495926,
0.8792182803153992,
0.9543017148971558,
-0.07117347419261932,
-0.1235307827591896,
-0.7103614211082458,
-0.18943406641483307,
-0.5390006899833679,
0.9451420903205872,
-0.8169589042663574,
-0.8564356565475464,
0.016077889129519463,
0.09827544540166855,
-0.7011186480522156,
-0.8146074414253235,
0.4613268971443176,
-0.549461305141449,
0.621614396572113,
-0.1288512796163559,
-1.0925517082214355,
-0.0014963757712394,
-0.21558012068271637,
-0.5502368807792664,
0.888360321521759,
0.3611859381198883,
-0.21656276285648346,
0.6515828371047974,
-1.0677469968795776,
-0.9778937697410583,
-0.24887071549892426,
-0.22724291682243347,
-0.1043500155210495,
0.5713896155357361,
0.5220925807952881,
0.2318180352449417,
0.05619368702173233,
0.2933844029903412,
-0.267192006111145,
-0.48979687690734863,
0.4713297188282013,
0.0018687983974814415,
0.8296719789505005,
0.3936599791049957,
-0.4198126792907715,
0.38523203134536743,
-0.9786238074302673,
-0.02613483928143978,
0.20426300168037415,
-0.08612754195928574,
-0.23786094784736633,
0.08047612756490707,
0.17793701589107513,
0.2845785617828369,
-0.29058268666267395,
-0.6461520195007324,
0.0879119411110878,
-0.8106403946876526,
0.5103756189346313,
0.8434807062149048,
0.14656634628772736,
0.7896339297294617,
-0.23171699047088623,
0.5490115284919739,
-0.15223467350006104,
-0.03767358139157295,
-0.3993178606033325,
-0.41592368483543396,
-0.6963617205619812,
-0.11714731156826019,
0.5455986857414246,
0.755438506603241,
-0.6397378444671631,
0.7534337043762207,
-0.08038611710071564,
-0.18677620589733124,
-0.3127940893173218,
0.08262208104133606,
0.22355453670024872,
0.31199032068252563,
0.11391768604516983,
0.09735991060733795,
-0.6281316876411438,
-0.7075702548027039,
-0.09779688715934753,
-0.04250337556004524,
0.10330794006586075,
0.10048341006040573,
0.2924674451351166,
0.12587325274944305,
0.8673083186149597,
-0.5958797335624695,
-0.13912950456142426,
-0.24074995517730713,
-0.018150338903069496,
0.4966859519481659,
0.7125977873802185,
0.9300339818000793,
-0.630020797252655,
-0.35586562752723694,
-0.17888233065605164,
-0.9540489912033081,
-0.22164665162563324,
-0.27806445956230164,
-0.30634164810180664,
-0.011557242833077908,
0.3955959975719452,
-0.5818432569503784,
0.19866131246089935,
0.29541531205177307,
-0.45006075501441956,
0.1600377857685089,
0.588930606842041,
-0.06335679441690445,
-0.8805856704711914,
-0.3888668417930603,
0.012669081799685955,
-0.32826539874076843,
-0.5556737780570984,
0.07259699702262878,
-0.07288803160190582,
-0.032982245087623596,
-0.17592009902000427,
0.033745404332876205,
-0.342707097530365,
-0.22191882133483887,
-0.193192720413208,
0.12925128638744354,
0.06569436192512512,
0.4272489845752716,
0.15700213611125946,
0.8008230328559875,
0.625182569026947,
-0.39022645354270935,
0.49580103158950806,
0.2837284505367279,
-0.7815903425216675,
0.5549963116645813,
-0.27989763021469116,
0.19159696996212006,
-0.12053362280130386,
-0.3206545412540436,
-1.0679281949996948,
-0.5988660454750061,
-0.03156444802880287,
-0.4648018777370453,
0.1810326725244522,
0.03721808269619942,
-0.3489331603050232,
-0.25405168533325195,
0.08521094173192978,
0.31445345282554626,
0.35169631242752075,
-0.7760164141654968,
0.08701585233211517,
0.2025853395462036,
-0.11361125111579895,
-0.09584951400756836,
-0.43047189712524414,
-0.08730459213256836,
-0.4456028938293457,
-1.000340223312378,
0.5035052299499512,
0.05282038822770119,
-0.5769482851028442,
-0.047937169671058655,
-0.12020711600780487,
-0.1374269425868988,
0.12818287312984467,
0.3657207787036896,
0.007902524434030056,
-0.4741726219654083,
0.28936854004859924,
0.414665549993515,
0.07895568758249283,
0.23348069190979004,
-0.4590974450111389,
0.6065142154693604,
0.08155456185340881,
-0.22126738727092743,
-0.7219006419181824,
0.752807080745697,
0.7348424792289734,
-0.21519029140472412,
0.2661086320877075,
0.10471384227275848,
-0.2005637139081955,
-0.3605085611343384,
-0.32352063059806824,
0.33002379536628723,
-0.49649956822395325,
-0.13139434158802032,
-0.3503195345401764,
-0.6749564409255981,
0.22645986080169678,
0.0595405250787735,
-0.19436243176460266,
0.4922541081905365,
0.10813532024621964,
-0.26599177718162537,
0.9473040699958801,
0.4892578125,
-0.1648871898651123,
0.8352106809616089,
-0.37336358428001404,
-0.11215316504240036,
-0.3074074685573578,
-0.37816986441612244,
-0.5810415148735046,
-0.3066844940185547,
-0.3139687776565552,
-0.3668341636657715,
0.4831302762031555,
-0.030135827139019966,
0.18250919878482819,
-0.15259520709514618,
-0.36360594630241394,
0.9951200485229492,
0.9393483996391296,
-0.002962338039651513,
-0.05962895229458809,
0.2783508002758026,
-0.6360952854156494,
0.21491268277168274,
-0.36845678091049194,
0.03346734493970871,
0.8494988083839417,
-0.03923647850751877,
0.3000732362270355,
-0.0651298388838768,
1.0468921661376953,
0.12142589688301086,
-0.011610838584601879,
-1.1475828886032104,
0.38632696866989136,
-0.12299566715955734,
-0.6566246747970581,
-0.47345149517059326,
-0.17640197277069092,
-0.35273277759552,
0.1487147957086563,
-0.046746473759412766,
-0.6307106614112854,
0.32535651326179504,
-0.23590709269046783,
-0.44933661818504333,
-0.2075442373752594,
-0.6568803191184998,
0.7956777811050415,
-0.30574068427085876,
-0.4424758553504944,
0.2891227900981903,
-0.5961007475852966,
0.3761701285839081,
0.14213253557682037,
0.35741281509399414,
-0.12954169511795044,
0.6111346483230591,
0.7301355004310608,
-0.6770361065864563,
0.17866529524326324,
-0.6257806420326233,
0.10622145235538483,
0.36374497413635254,
-0.18164269626140594,
0.27764540910720825,
0.17945526540279388,
-0.0256147850304842,
-0.22406740486621857,
-0.22747711837291718,
-0.16174131631851196,
-0.6877564191818237,
0.708495020866394,
-0.617258608341217,
-0.6162263751029968,
-0.3448449373245239,
-0.2991414964199066,
-0.6951866149902344,
0.21291659772396088,
0.6183234453201294,
0.5646860003471375,
-0.16564664244651794,
0.35931751132011414,
0.4684288203716278,
0.09813223779201508,
0.8949270844459534,
-0.06426405161619186,
-0.30070674419403076,
-0.8001256585121155,
0.4321281909942627,
-0.18330344557762146,
-0.07214760035276413,
0.6225167512893677,
0.23055846989154816,
-0.7328585982322693,
-0.6074058413505554,
-0.8376001119613647,
0.209739550948143,
-0.6549679040908813,
0.01652429811656475,
-0.17568229138851166,
0.016155187040567398,
-0.33577343821525574,
-0.46852943301200867,
-0.0697302520275116,
-0.8037376403808594,
-0.29054638743400574,
-0.71348637342453,
0.206360325217247,
0.5848056077957153,
-0.2615796625614166,
0.7656510472297668,
-0.48329782485961914,
0.3028489351272583,
0.14720582962036133,
0.3865741193294525,
-0.5974950194358826,
-0.05162179097533226,
-0.1874319463968277,
-0.33980026841163635,
-0.2443641722202301,
-0.9656174778938293,
0.15307332575321198,
0.5996868014335632,
0.4551237225532532,
1.0639185905456543,
-0.5472875237464905,
1.2894350290298462,
-0.6699979305267334,
0.7971484661102295,
0.29172220826148987,
-1.1385831832885742,
0.8675343990325928,
-0.44322142004966736,
0.21932028234004974,
0.7384132146835327,
0.13059671223163605,
-0.4664990305900574,
-0.28243348002433777,
-0.21169520914554596,
-0.5354080200195312,
0.775188684463501,
0.25731179118156433,
-0.17364346981048584,
-0.42878860235214233,
0.3507344722747803,
0.16175593435764313,
0.05686667561531067,
-0.4789371192455292,
-0.2921209931373596,
-0.4182431697845459,
-0.5056799054145813,
-0.35253962874412537,
-0.071241594851017,
-0.18675461411476135,
-0.44841012358665466,
0.4944279193878174,
0.22393764555454254,
0.35295653343200684,
0.3159627318382263,
-0.32791823148727417,
-0.3582924008369446,
0.24666182696819305,
0.9295258522033691,
0.8935967087745667,
0.028889819979667664,
-0.2061012089252472,
-0.47847187519073486,
-0.12364156544208527,
0.3410373032093048,
0.1110980436205864,
-0.36731764674186707,
0.34006789326667786,
0.617987871170044,
0.6925811767578125,
0.10341081768274307,
-0.4780416190624237,
0.5607335567474365,
-0.0680902898311615,
-0.4918384253978729,
-0.6449427008628845,
0.32125189900398254,
0.08457766473293304,
0.15101943910121918,
0.23313333094120026,
-0.03538162261247635,
0.2049797624349594,
-0.35649076104164124,
0.529723584651947,
0.29877322912216187,
-0.4757498502731323,
-0.2571348547935486,
0.7073546648025513,
0.060249000787734985,
-0.3472557067871094,
0.8133509755134583,
0.05023794621229172,
-0.3315538167953491,
0.7437744736671448,
0.5973918437957764,
1.2090619802474976,
-0.4623020887374878,
0.17644257843494415,
0.13494093716144562,
0.04618357494473457,
0.2308105230331421,
0.6743948459625244,
-0.32317832112312317,
-0.4758119285106659,
-0.5944150686264038,
-0.8919249176979065,
0.08957266062498093,
0.0807034894824028,
-0.7522059679031372,
-0.03312976658344269,
-0.684844970703125,
0.05367720499634743,
0.47096285223960876,
-0.46350064873695374,
-0.4680373966693878,
0.28131797909736633,
0.30520033836364746,
1.0192879438400269,
-0.9345763921737671,
0.7127204537391663,
0.6769648790359497,
-0.07418344914913177,
-0.6207799315452576,
-0.1804431527853012,
0.27786821126937866,
-0.6273745894432068,
0.5286582112312317,
0.40634819865226746,
-0.13661374151706696,
-0.29509472846984863,
-0.5988301038742065,
-0.6300288438796997,
0.8254251480102539,
-0.12580659985542297,
-0.43584784865379333,
-0.20796652138233185,
0.2873990833759308,
0.31335949897766113,
-0.6814443469047546,
-0.3449086546897888,
0.8395488858222961,
0.45348992943763733,
0.43257054686546326,
-0.5987442135810852,
-0.4755737781524658,
-0.605031430721283,
-0.10164932161569595,
0.21206964552402496,
-0.2748388648033142,
0.5893813371658325,
0.13941477239131927,
-0.1795203685760498,
0.6117501854896545,
0.823280394077301,
0.025584908202290535,
0.6521592140197754,
0.8811845183372498,
0.6342282295227051,
0.8477594256401062,
-0.689075767993927,
0.9170240759849548,
-0.3437201678752899,
0.2042231261730194,
0.8269582986831665,
-0.25067418813705444,
0.506742537021637,
0.628394603729248,
-0.2109328806400299,
0.7506510615348816,
0.9698920249938965,
-0.052480533719062805,
0.9241544008255005,
0.25566747784614563,
-0.345669686794281,
-0.3032519519329071,
0.038055434823036194,
-0.2645890712738037,
1.003937840461731,
0.5700775384902954,
-0.8095730543136597,
0.27168557047843933,
0.15889005362987518,
0.053282465785741806,
0.2936212122440338,
-0.3262355923652649,
1.003578543663025,
-0.24617540836334229,
-1.1778264045715332,
0.4841821789741516,
0.22424514591693878,
0.11306218802928925,
-0.36152350902557373,
0.026415983214974403,
-0.6687659621238708,
0.05902915820479393,
-0.22252397239208221,
-0.137522891163826,
0.2989787757396698,
-0.08477794378995895,
-0.34806275367736816,
0.024772368371486664,
0.2657407522201538,
-0.4042126536369324,
-0.8114626407623291,
-0.011029890738427639,
0.29946285486221313,
-0.30005943775177,
-0.03987811505794525,
-0.10965867340564728,
-0.15511192381381989,
-0.10486327856779099,
0.16378459334373474,
-0.09417125582695007,
0.5482295751571655,
0.08568818867206573,
0.13374964892864227,
0.4999796450138092,
-0.0024572305846959352,
0.6173713803291321,
0.14083027839660645,
0.7195589542388916,
-1.1120820045471191,
-0.8453258275985718,
-0.9247119426727295,
0.3054713308811188,
-0.1929820030927658,
-0.28440120816230774,
0.6381023526191711,
0.856188178062439,
0.9397789239883423,
-0.3709358870983124,
0.8344992995262146,
0.010887076146900654,
0.41893401741981506,
-0.9080959558486938,
0.15274016559123993,
-0.524925947189331,
0.06434955447912216,
-0.6291017532348633,
-0.7606809139251709,
-0.7722488641738892,
0.7487836480140686,
-0.36891594529151917,
-0.27256131172180176,
0.9362754821777344,
0.6692050099372864,
-0.001277106930501759,
0.6060700416564941,
0.14203791320323944,
-0.27757391333580017,
0.19093888998031616,
0.536098301410675,
1.2516207695007324,
-0.07525374740362167,
0.07679565995931625,
-0.7821434736251831,
-0.2407301962375641,
-0.25220245122909546,
-0.459735244512558,
-0.7581722736358643,
-0.39790382981300354,
-0.014184716157615185,
-0.06031005084514618,
0.081734798848629,
1.0731576681137085,
0.7220629453659058,
-0.9062451124191284,
-0.5366661548614502,
-0.22423459589481354,
0.6694350838661194,
-0.6752473711967468,
-0.3129321336746216,
0.3891640603542328,
-0.5855233669281006,
-1.0180010795593262,
1.2715590000152588,
0.41173601150512695,
-0.2592746615409851,
0.08202113956212997,
0.2357865571975708,
-0.30628177523612976,
0.03449540585279465,
0.9057679772377014,
0.06648572534322739,
-0.7707985639572144,
-0.44427162408828735,
0.30492842197418213,
0.41684165596961975,
0.3880055248737335,
0.9483450055122375,
-0.3480767011642456,
0.4845517873764038,
0.34552767872810364,
0.44461968541145325,
0.28882360458374023,
0.4429566264152527,
0.4615851044654846,
-0.9670156836509705,
0.10782872140407562,
0.05684589967131615,
0.4905010759830475,
0.18114015460014343,
-0.24036642909049988,
0.7201288938522339,
0.720082700252533,
-0.21516300737857819,
-0.7605642676353455,
0.18893638253211975,
-1.0016255378723145,
-0.16080741584300995,
1.1249860525131226,
-0.04030594229698181,
-0.5242118239402771,
0.12610064446926117,
0.14670325815677643,
-0.15632688999176025,
-0.1758064180612564,
0.4787410795688629,
0.9361190795898438,
-0.502856433391571,
-0.06188380345702171,
-0.0697123259305954,
0.6041485667228699,
0.0995427668094635,
-0.5027632117271423,
-0.38044214248657227,
1.0126147270202637,
0.30108124017715454,
0.3415393531322479,
0.2819516956806183,
-0.4202759563922882,
0.47390106320381165,
0.028277849778532982,
-0.35669606924057007,
-0.19437643885612488,
-0.8484981656074524,
-0.47670242190361023,
0.8907182216644287,
0.08696325868368149,
-0.6944870352745056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18741v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18741v2
|
Genshin: General Shield for Natural Language Processing with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-29T04:04:05 | 2024-06-03T08:35:07 |
Xiao Peng, Tao Liu, Ying Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, Gemini, or LLaMA have been
trending recently, demonstrating considerable advancement and generalizability
power in countless domains. However, LLMs create an even bigger black box
exacerbating opacity, with interpretability limited to few approaches. The
uncertainty and opacity embedded in LLMs' nature restrict their application in
high-stakes domains like financial fraud, phishing, etc. Current approaches
mainly rely on traditional textual classification with posterior interpretable
algorithms, suffering from attackers who may create versatile adversarial
samples to break the system's defense, forcing users to make trade-offs between
efficiency and robustness. To address this issue, we propose a novel cascading
framework called Genshin (General Shield for Natural Language Processing with
Large Language Models), utilizing LLMs as defensive one-time plug-ins. Unlike
most applications of LLMs that try to transform text into something new or
structural, Genshin uses LLMs to recover text to its original state. Genshin
aims to combine the generalizability of the LLM, the discrimination of the
median model, and the interpretability of the simple model. Our experiments on
the task of sentimental analysis and spam detection have shown fatal flaws of
the current median models and exhilarating results on LLMs' recovery ability,
demonstrating that Genshin is both effective and efficient. In our ablation
study, we unearth several intriguing observations. Utilizing the LLM defender,
a tool derived from the 4th paradigm, we have reproduced BERT's 15% optimal
mask rate results in the 3rd paradigm of NLP. Additionally, when employing the
LLM as a potential adversarial tool, attackers are capable of executing
effective attacks that are nearly semantically lossless.
|
[
-0.268140584230423,
-1.0855802297592163,
0.3785165548324585,
0.0889647826552391,
-0.2901499569416046,
0.40230023860931396,
-0.2109699249267578,
-0.5758550763130188,
0.1555182784795761,
0.669029951095581,
-0.5330911874771118,
-0.8394919633865356,
-0.6544011831283569,
-0.007153134793043137,
-0.7190707921981812,
1.0867398977279663,
0.3014305531978607,
-0.25405099987983704,
0.0865977555513382,
0.13199442625045776,
-0.19789241254329681,
-0.49272021651268005,
-0.8953577280044556,
-0.3479119837284088,
0.1500060260295868,
0.1982245296239853,
0.7581266164779663,
0.43014615774154663,
0.5709406137466431,
0.3740628957748413,
0.010304934345185757,
-0.07422946393489838,
-0.315509557723999,
0.430081307888031,
-0.18787133693695068,
-0.612534761428833,
-0.49942341446876526,
0.09543456137180328,
0.5400055646896362,
0.3149612247943878,
-0.2457951456308365,
-0.25924500823020935,
-0.0019779701251536608,
0.4900839924812317,
-0.5593089461326599,
-0.22813183069229126,
-1.0213762521743774,
0.14965307712554932,
-0.4647511839866638,
-0.017711445689201355,
-0.4378277659416199,
-0.0875210165977478,
0.07638172060251236,
-0.43574169278144836,
0.43578967452049255,
0.19525977969169617,
0.7391626834869385,
0.1330193281173706,
0.04320704564452171,
-0.14035747945308685,
-0.5634320378303528,
0.7746281027793884,
-0.7941456437110901,
0.004161744378507137,
0.4944702088832855,
0.4675414562225342,
-0.35243380069732666,
-0.6485954523086548,
-0.4046791195869446,
-0.10244360566139221,
0.022815393283963203,
0.13431692123413086,
-0.6926535367965698,
0.35727861523628235,
0.19607701897621155,
0.47691234946250916,
-0.6673966646194458,
0.4997294247150421,
-0.1276697814464569,
-0.4068959057331085,
0.5333574414253235,
0.22999072074890137,
0.6736211180686951,
-0.18901371955871582,
-0.5411447882652283,
0.14245052635669708,
-0.6897420883178711,
-0.12542514503002167,
0.5129513144493103,
0.03892313316464424,
-0.07424139231443405,
0.33226168155670166,
-0.3544960916042328,
0.5756778717041016,
-0.017901334911584854,
-0.28916871547698975,
-0.22424401342868805,
-0.1566331833600998,
-0.4967942237854004,
0.07477504760026932,
1.026179552078247,
0.15148401260375977,
0.21920065581798553,
-0.30168551206588745,
-0.00043233236647211015,
0.23971468210220337,
0.3931226432323456,
-0.8948702216148376,
-0.22960324585437775,
0.10176217555999756,
-0.4035946726799011,
-0.7473099231719971,
0.03276320919394493,
-1.2143135070800781,
-0.403065025806427,
0.2198100984096527,
0.16163986921310425,
-0.42330697178840637,
-0.0435260534286499,
0.348287969827652,
-0.02409442886710167,
0.23008176684379578,
0.15430623292922974,
-1.0597760677337646,
0.5264763236045837,
0.867792546749115,
1.0602807998657227,
-0.02320864051580429,
0.014447839930653572,
-0.7138344645500183,
0.05397966504096985,
-0.17160551249980927,
0.7900524139404297,
-0.6521261930465698,
-0.26287761330604553,
0.07155043631792068,
-0.2199307382106781,
0.05770152434706688,
-0.2658243477344513,
0.6880735754966736,
-0.6153118014335632,
0.14724622666835785,
0.3881194293498993,
-0.3677257001399994,
-0.12923960387706757,
0.19441072642803192,
-0.7747164964675903,
0.710562527179718,
-0.1431027352809906,
-0.8230997920036316,
0.09488032013177872,
-0.4464452266693115,
-0.5539616346359253,
0.24049212038516998,
0.10405004769563675,
-0.6371813416481018,
0.12384027987718582,
0.23232537508010864,
0.6701115965843201,
-0.5422883033752441,
0.3145250380039215,
-0.5896872282028198,
-0.19225546717643738,
0.34079504013061523,
-0.7419449090957642,
0.6150594353675842,
0.30708548426628113,
-0.36584118008613586,
0.09166658669710159,
-0.7378557920455933,
-0.30926865339279175,
0.1756511628627777,
-0.18378251791000366,
-0.4755108654499054,
0.07473883032798767,
-0.3369140923023224,
0.010842672549188137,
0.07931830734014511,
-0.7238525152206421,
0.07505196332931519,
-0.719192385673523,
0.6478274464607239,
0.8406757116317749,
-0.1576230525970459,
0.6399939656257629,
-0.14072993397712708,
0.6458073854446411,
-0.293312132358551,
0.14958937466144562,
-0.12715233862400055,
-0.5738961100578308,
-0.7228299379348755,
-0.5809562802314758,
0.034182898700237274,
0.5048372149467468,
-0.8213344812393188,
0.5391862392425537,
-0.026286248117685318,
-0.37221765518188477,
-0.7345600724220276,
0.4104558527469635,
0.2639537453651428,
0.42739883065223694,
0.33524012565612793,
-0.13301391899585724,
-0.550089418888092,
-1.014801263809204,
-0.24626342952251434,
-0.10624697804450989,
-0.1738893687725067,
-0.2812401056289673,
0.3596694767475128,
-0.1955397129058838,
0.9152092933654785,
-0.5036373138427734,
-0.39421236515045166,
-0.5275707244873047,
0.22030504047870636,
0.2393856644630432,
0.21843737363815308,
0.4162066578865051,
-0.7021406888961792,
-0.3211371600627899,
-0.06493350118398666,
-0.5908567905426025,
-0.4797589182853699,
-0.11197008937597275,
-0.28043293952941895,
0.14330147206783295,
0.4807097613811493,
-0.7134260535240173,
0.448408842086792,
0.5314635634422302,
-0.2264440655708313,
0.5767579674720764,
0.016499442979693413,
-0.07830040156841278,
-1.1409434080123901,
0.13604171574115753,
0.11229878664016724,
-0.33826950192451477,
-1.149496078491211,
0.09116210788488388,
-0.12886525690555573,
0.04238439351320267,
-0.15155793726444244,
0.6970161199569702,
-0.08072268962860107,
0.1524580717086792,
-0.5090957283973694,
0.1794644296169281,
0.1538478434085846,
0.25135013461112976,
-0.16204100847244263,
0.5498445630073547,
0.3607902526855469,
-0.4211219549179077,
0.5417797565460205,
0.14975668489933014,
-0.4240194857120514,
0.9481809735298157,
-0.7800409197807312,
0.02093316614627838,
-0.11391215026378632,
0.30434146523475647,
-0.8584161996841431,
-0.35564640164375305,
0.4579063355922699,
-0.4263434112071991,
0.41342395544052124,
-0.09500496089458466,
-0.4446815550327301,
-0.40818387269973755,
-0.5600066781044006,
0.0348583422601223,
0.522225558757782,
-0.6155461072921753,
0.7072301506996155,
0.22752970457077026,
-0.35690709948539734,
-0.7411978244781494,
-0.7097623944282532,
0.35813605785369873,
-0.4554450809955597,
-0.6460851430892944,
0.5145175457000732,
-0.07812326401472092,
-0.421394944190979,
-0.0576145313680172,
-0.05967134237289429,
-0.033292338252067566,
0.568990170955658,
0.24218305945396423,
0.6485487818717957,
0.053234897553920746,
0.10403729230165482,
-0.09087110310792923,
-0.2547803521156311,
0.07853790372610092,
-0.2973025441169739,
0.6321110129356384,
-0.07296405732631683,
-0.3349173069000244,
-0.22081907093524933,
0.30638954043388367,
0.44563353061676025,
-0.1610315591096878,
0.7652035355567932,
0.7325683832168579,
-0.4278765320777893,
-0.47110506892204285,
-0.7786142826080322,
0.026029596105217934,
-0.5125784277915955,
0.3292602598667145,
-0.20611588656902313,
-1.039568305015564,
0.44648730754852295,
0.3363979458808899,
0.12314052134752274,
0.5364165902137756,
0.46095094084739685,
0.1400103121995926,
1.0024722814559937,
0.5409298539161682,
-0.6666269302368164,
0.34706297516822815,
-0.0033442280255258083,
0.36588430404663086,
-0.8986620306968689,
-0.2575840353965759,
-0.7184711694717407,
-0.20665399730205536,
-0.2810567617416382,
-0.03673827275633812,
0.07594405114650726,
0.24591344594955444,
-0.16718539595603943,
0.346164345741272,
-0.48100975155830383,
0.5059503316879272,
0.4460010528564453,
-0.052390843629837036,
0.5333752632141113,
0.09198544174432755,
-0.065512515604496,
0.09279423207044601,
-0.4776827096939087,
-0.45573827624320984,
0.9536567330360413,
0.4938230812549591,
1.0518831014633179,
0.08663380891084671,
0.48385968804359436,
0.25628823041915894,
0.5386213660240173,
-0.6119163632392883,
0.6601125597953796,
-0.4757903218269348,
-0.5689670443534851,
-0.13907890021800995,
-0.5585180521011353,
-1.007755160331726,
0.48456302285194397,
-0.31087034940719604,
-0.9416911005973816,
-0.3177635371685028,
-0.1697583645582199,
-0.3796813189983368,
0.6684900522232056,
-0.2742917239665985,
0.5335671305656433,
-0.13231639564037323,
-0.32752901315689087,
-0.18615993857383728,
-0.5708988308906555,
0.7647360563278198,
-0.22817488014698029,
0.2974533140659332,
-0.31509608030319214,
0.07538966089487076,
0.6940006613731384,
-0.204070046544075,
1.033972978591919,
0.09761509299278259,
-0.05378585681319237,
0.05094305798411369,
0.1955554187297821,
0.4748426079750061,
0.0767284408211708,
0.03308543935418129,
0.08477161824703217,
-0.34638452529907227,
-0.285124808549881,
-0.6504238843917847,
0.7442387938499451,
-0.4183676242828369,
-0.8458019495010376,
-0.436637282371521,
-0.4416293501853943,
0.05374010279774666,
0.12969675660133362,
0.2967355251312256,
0.3524550795555115,
-0.42191028594970703,
0.272502601146698,
0.8068602085113525,
-0.347219318151474,
0.5052979588508606,
0.6350269317626953,
-0.21486173570156097,
-0.5595946311950684,
0.5642804503440857,
-0.3032835125923157,
0.5324190258979797,
0.4030407667160034,
0.12484242022037506,
-0.15375012159347534,
-0.674484372138977,
-0.2141772210597992,
0.13177171349525452,
-0.6102132201194763,
-0.5515093803405762,
-0.7507277727127075,
-0.44193026423454285,
-0.3659399151802063,
-0.4168359339237213,
-0.026680471375584602,
-0.18209047615528107,
-0.27254194021224976,
-0.05367908254265785,
0.3433483839035034,
0.5952023863792419,
0.03332594409584999,
0.4587940275669098,
-0.54911208152771,
0.4186115264892578,
0.35714852809906006,
0.28298261761665344,
-0.03197212144732475,
-0.47752147912979126,
-0.06624788045883179,
-0.010548515245318413,
-0.17963899672031403,
-0.6689526438713074,
0.6903768181800842,
0.23341546952724457,
0.5334014296531677,
0.5404642820358276,
0.10005780309438705,
0.34989652037620544,
-0.32717499136924744,
0.5829011797904968,
0.33750253915786743,
-0.8066561818122864,
0.3611987829208374,
-0.18735109269618988,
0.27888724207878113,
0.49235397577285767,
0.11198065429925919,
-0.5980420112609863,
-0.6815661787986755,
-0.6439651846885681,
-0.6903719305992126,
0.45341670513153076,
0.07172302901744843,
0.13196231424808502,
-0.013713294640183449,
0.13424158096313477,
0.0009348357561975718,
0.1998538076877594,
-0.6726812124252319,
0.13248731195926666,
-0.08016891777515411,
-0.4244406819343567,
-0.12380097806453705,
-0.2682088315486908,
-0.13390840590000153,
0.22855234146118164,
0.6756051778793335,
-0.15324614942073822,
0.14815771579742432,
0.14277654886245728,
-0.19146600365638733,
0.13806042075157166,
0.6355457901954651,
0.32875004410743713,
-0.2605861723423004,
-0.07910879701375961,
0.48029622435569763,
0.1356457769870758,
-0.516501247882843,
0.1598653942346573,
0.1575644165277481,
-0.2911110818386078,
-0.25886374711990356,
0.554118812084198,
0.6408834457397461,
0.44978687167167664,
-0.45637044310569763,
0.5700556635856628,
0.08375802636146545,
-0.18338324129581451,
-0.09385805577039719,
0.16346050798892975,
-0.11035379767417908,
0.14776207506656647,
0.3317989110946655,
0.01663682982325554,
0.12848536670207977,
-0.5787547826766968,
0.08829256147146225,
0.9066137671470642,
-0.11880311369895935,
-0.3570702373981476,
0.7087079286575317,
0.09498520940542221,
-0.16800560057163239,
0.550025463104248,
-0.021201375871896744,
-0.8986297249794006,
0.41787752509117126,
0.6424973011016846,
1.2232996225357056,
-0.3764583468437195,
0.40708380937576294,
0.03911541402339935,
0.4572553336620331,
-0.1607704609632492,
-0.404062956571579,
0.083485446870327,
-0.7500120997428894,
-0.45783543586730957,
-0.9871692657470703,
-0.2455923706293106,
0.27256348729133606,
-0.37067553400993347,
0.08066006749868393,
-0.698102593421936,
-0.08793848007917404,
0.06531958281993866,
-0.018459666520357132,
-0.4840840697288513,
-0.10062499344348907,
0.03373999893665314,
0.865994393825531,
-0.6928154230117798,
0.7345999479293823,
0.09283794462680817,
-0.2176206409931183,
-0.23316633701324463,
-0.14220969378948212,
0.29139408469200134,
-0.7628969550132751,
0.3997810482978821,
0.3291236460208893,
-0.13207602500915527,
-0.22933264076709747,
-0.7219828963279724,
-0.6307166218757629,
0.9499072432518005,
0.22204160690307617,
-0.4185916781425476,
-0.0911218598484993,
0.11844852566719055,
0.6057607531547546,
-0.4010707139968872,
0.053131621330976486,
0.895601749420166,
0.46011868119239807,
0.08342894166707993,
-0.5619617104530334,
0.1432095617055893,
-0.3653120994567871,
-0.04512612894177437,
0.32469305396080017,
-0.4493219256401062,
0.6493092179298401,
0.15496070683002472,
-0.4441896677017212,
0.4566883146762848,
0.4404771625995636,
0.06375004351139069,
0.19287236034870148,
0.1709296703338623,
0.8283261060714722,
0.6181652545928955,
-0.25234276056289673,
1.1477899551391602,
0.04582875594496727,
-0.018272830173373222,
0.7546440362930298,
-0.28092867136001587,
0.6745335459709167,
0.06397214531898499,
-0.11000102758407593,
0.5683675408363342,
0.10102012008428574,
-0.21373458206653595,
0.39799854159355164,
0.29874125123023987,
-0.5034008622169495,
-0.14467597007751465,
-0.11689174175262451,
-0.0053194682113826275,
0.2996457517147064,
0.40887027978897095,
-0.18976347148418427,
-0.3025895059108734,
0.15583455562591553,
0.48309290409088135,
0.1096348911523819,
-0.36029067635536194,
0.7200698256492615,
0.2403992861509323,
-0.5115105509757996,
0.21973229944705963,
0.2838112711906433,
1.0424293279647827,
-0.9424476623535156,
0.19880086183547974,
-0.2020440697669983,
0.1826910674571991,
-0.26432275772094727,
-0.6489704847335815,
0.2461230307817459,
0.20731611549854279,
-0.027606582269072533,
-0.03520206734538078,
1.3241629600524902,
-0.4330560564994812,
-0.3753699064254761,
0.32477253675460815,
-0.03467138856649399,
-0.19025376439094543,
-0.07235103100538254,
-0.5217861533164978,
0.15464715659618378,
-0.13197308778762817,
-0.2572999894618988,
0.52805495262146,
-0.02724413387477398,
0.13101142644882202,
0.9419785141944885,
0.8909170627593994,
0.2730065882205963,
-0.12127402424812317,
0.05061103403568268,
0.6740553379058838,
-0.4426056742668152,
-0.42154428362846375,
-1.2054206132888794,
0.2302400767803192,
-0.4326712191104889,
0.01101989857852459,
0.7973791360855103,
0.2448069304227829,
0.461631178855896,
0.36512747406959534,
0.8903191685676575,
0.21122099459171295,
0.3535216450691223,
-0.8538190126419067,
0.7004006505012512,
-0.11549024283885956,
0.41887328028678894,
-0.4030108153820038,
-0.8833585381507874,
-0.6298752427101135,
0.5873917937278748,
-0.35704442858695984,
-0.20089849829673767,
0.6083894968032837,
0.6261389851570129,
0.23467028141021729,
0.27744579315185547,
0.3986247479915619,
0.1962825059890747,
0.626583456993103,
0.7861930131912231,
0.726980447769165,
-0.10430743545293808,
0.5099335312843323,
-0.09933022409677505,
-0.404203325510025,
-0.23203125596046448,
-0.7610734105110168,
-1.1709136962890625,
-0.19310809671878815,
0.07892673462629318,
-0.287340372800827,
0.15244804322719574,
0.6653516888618469,
0.4823105037212372,
-0.5632030963897705,
0.11937858164310455,
-0.069659024477005,
0.10658040642738342,
0.16155685484409332,
-0.25832608342170715,
0.13510404527187347,
-0.4750397503376007,
-0.5727383494377136,
0.5848362445831299,
0.6285375952720642,
0.14935548603534698,
-0.5028225779533386,
0.07902777194976807,
-0.07977534830570221,
0.23009194433689117,
0.5087518095970154,
0.26545771956443787,
-0.6439906358718872,
-0.2834499478340149,
-0.06507101655006409,
-0.17510640621185303,
-0.15638650953769684,
0.6883317232131958,
-0.6279249787330627,
0.4015156924724579,
0.4189262390136719,
0.8995922207832336,
0.29346764087677,
0.03619111701846123,
0.663686215877533,
-0.5187707543373108,
0.01352183148264885,
0.1251973658800125,
0.5032557249069214,
0.36262747645378113,
-0.30010294914245605,
0.5312331318855286,
0.23140865564346313,
-0.5051468014717102,
-0.6821616291999817,
0.3664223551750183,
-0.6768938899040222,
-0.4256835877895355,
1.057584524154663,
-0.06418731808662415,
-0.219103142619133,
-0.21545466780662537,
-0.15738236904144287,
-0.035712920129299164,
-0.3234819769859314,
0.726418673992157,
0.8645321726799011,
0.47673147916793823,
0.026160309091210365,
-0.6533992290496826,
0.5390366315841675,
0.38399064540863037,
-0.9872656464576721,
0.004495424684137106,
0.33365747332572937,
0.2248186469078064,
0.08103271573781967,
0.5345475077629089,
-0.1883085072040558,
0.10411551594734192,
-0.1605825126171112,
-0.12425412982702255,
-0.0761067271232605,
-0.42132580280303955,
-0.5905369520187378,
0.3466993272304535,
-0.21923388540744781,
0.16479778289794922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18740v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18740v1
|
Reverse Image Retrieval Cues Parametric Memory in Multimodal LLMs
| 2024-05-29T04:00:41 | 2024-05-29T04:00:41 |
Jialiang Xu, Michael Moor, Jure Leskovec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite impressive advances in recent multimodal large language models
(MLLMs), state-of-the-art models such as from the GPT-4 suite still struggle
with knowledge-intensive tasks. To address this, we consider Reverse Image
Retrieval (RIR) augmented generation, a simple yet effective strategy to
augment MLLMs with web-scale reverse image search results. RIR robustly
improves knowledge-intensive visual question answering (VQA) of GPT-4V by
37-43%, GPT-4 Turbo by 25-27%, and GPT-4o by 18-20% in terms of open-ended VQA
evaluation metrics. To our surprise, we discover that RIR helps the model to
better access its own world knowledge. Concretely, our experiments suggest that
RIR augmentation helps by providing further visual and textual cues without
necessarily containing the direct answer to a query. In addition, we elucidate
cases in which RIR can hurt performance and conduct a human evaluation.
Finally, we find that the overall advantage of using RIR makes it difficult for
an agent that can choose to use RIR to perform better than an approach where
RIR is the default setting.
|
[
-0.5066270232200623,
-0.567524254322052,
0.6839194297790527,
-0.074137382209301,
-0.3972364664077759,
-0.1006343811750412,
-0.05820579081773758,
-0.47562873363494873,
-0.19148840010166168,
0.6759652495384216,
-0.3987623453140259,
-0.29596537351608276,
-0.4044593274593353,
0.028679246082901955,
-0.18370084464550018,
0.9928500652313232,
0.07634036988019943,
0.23513637483119965,
-0.45680123567581177,
-0.33621832728385925,
-0.49846866726875305,
-0.5331993103027344,
-0.6821866035461426,
-0.22363914549350739,
0.8893079161643982,
0.21815206110477448,
0.9042161107063293,
0.5484218001365662,
0.7972047328948975,
0.3234501779079437,
0.39281854033470154,
0.5244039297103882,
-0.6108313202857971,
0.3763362467288971,
-0.24616040289402008,
-0.5706082582473755,
-0.09009122848510742,
-0.22154827415943146,
0.5580447316169739,
0.06672809273004532,
0.08274590224027634,
0.2350590080022812,
-0.16334277391433716,
0.8639873266220093,
-0.8445017337799072,
-0.026470914483070374,
-0.7884225845336914,
-0.021657951176166534,
-0.14576715230941772,
-0.6887823343276978,
-0.2703762650489807,
-0.1468370407819748,
0.28372302651405334,
-0.6569519639015198,
0.352019339799881,
0.15265047550201416,
0.9653747081756592,
0.29963886737823486,
-0.32334238290786743,
-0.12524797022342682,
-0.7223581075668335,
0.8441261053085327,
-0.45692065358161926,
0.7465753555297852,
0.3491857945919037,
0.4531002342700958,
-0.02915915660560131,
-0.9352408051490784,
-0.5570948719978333,
-0.2702854573726654,
-0.0009220587671734393,
0.12929591536521912,
-0.08328918367624283,
0.061215803027153015,
0.30695825815200806,
0.27390536665916443,
-0.508920431137085,
-0.1311223953962326,
-0.4994843602180481,
-0.380240797996521,
0.3709641098976135,
0.41286590695381165,
0.4243095815181732,
0.05109180137515068,
-0.4639874994754791,
-0.23476849496364594,
-0.8803645968437195,
-0.07242962718009949,
0.25105521082878113,
0.19783340394496918,
0.2987278699874878,
0.8026186227798462,
-0.012463290244340897,
0.7977468967437744,
0.04341566190123558,
-0.24808433651924133,
0.1178700402379036,
-0.49742355942726135,
0.06851447373628616,
-0.524329423904419,
0.5550744533538818,
0.7657738327980042,
0.2594781517982483,
-0.165787935256958,
-0.5573151707649231,
-0.16732539236545563,
0.24148981273174286,
-0.9212955236434937,
-0.23557326197624207,
-0.29414060711860657,
-0.3643913269042969,
0.1611941158771515,
0.01699562929570675,
-0.7679998874664307,
-0.4693956673145294,
-0.2167302370071411,
0.8137256503105164,
-0.4778617024421692,
0.09637763351202011,
-0.06091289222240448,
-0.4306505620479584,
0.6495151519775391,
0.5337405800819397,
-0.4886288642883301,
0.09522391110658646,
0.3123677670955658,
0.6997635364532471,
-0.03889043629169464,
-0.31815105676651,
-0.6525285243988037,
0.06771670281887054,
-0.235353022813797,
0.9912362694740295,
-0.7814140319824219,
-0.3418683409690857,
-0.22076034545898438,
-0.0275106243789196,
0.06524890661239624,
-0.6775937080383301,
0.2509670555591583,
-1.0833556652069092,
0.4665279984474182,
-0.6368685960769653,
-0.059554148465394974,
-0.2387465089559555,
0.4553931653499603,
-0.8021894693374634,
0.8713980913162231,
-0.19495253264904022,
-0.9237509369850159,
0.4506432116031647,
-0.3738335072994232,
-0.1599402129650116,
0.0011331107234582305,
-0.4999305307865143,
-0.42254170775413513,
-0.04380283132195473,
0.7221888303756714,
0.3025822639465332,
-0.3790736794471741,
-0.05053615942597389,
-0.37339064478874207,
-0.3870824873447418,
0.41719144582748413,
-0.6528222560882568,
0.1697150319814682,
0.22894687950611115,
-0.12436852604150772,
-0.008248620666563511,
-0.41809096932411194,
-0.04400249943137169,
0.2927533686161041,
-0.47807931900024414,
-0.4902217984199524,
-0.293910413980484,
-0.06820841878652573,
0.19004365801811218,
0.3399902582168579,
-0.4727483093738556,
-0.0005554631934501231,
-0.05171443894505501,
0.18002398312091827,
0.7493888735771179,
0.27513155341148376,
0.48272904753685,
-0.44390571117401123,
0.6064230799674988,
0.18306639790534973,
-0.010797453112900257,
-0.33710137009620667,
-0.5095987319946289,
-0.71540766954422,
-0.42058923840522766,
0.11802370846271515,
0.5269760489463806,
-1.2973995208740234,
-0.382879376411438,
-0.1837388277053833,
-0.253511905670166,
-0.8448866009712219,
0.3212270736694336,
0.62779700756073,
0.7469445466995239,
0.5150966644287109,
-0.2984115779399872,
-0.5279768109321594,
-1.2319172620773315,
-0.4296415448188782,
-0.01971074566245079,
0.10250493884086609,
0.6534590721130371,
0.3067625164985657,
-0.08726474642753601,
0.8028380274772644,
-0.4936065673828125,
-0.17726410925388336,
-0.16831348836421967,
0.24407605826854706,
-0.11531101167201996,
0.1727854609489441,
0.23634712398052216,
-1.2032707929611206,
-0.3037029206752777,
-0.19623367488384247,
-0.6987081170082092,
0.1924770623445511,
-0.3102169930934906,
-0.11248724162578583,
0.23286445438861847,
0.33999061584472656,
-0.8540974259376526,
0.45460984110832214,
0.05006099119782448,
0.07496847957372665,
0.469272643327713,
-0.48240816593170166,
0.4877651035785675,
-0.8077234029769897,
0.013215375132858753,
0.18916897475719452,
-0.3297378122806549,
-0.3255749046802521,
0.15014886856079102,
0.14984336495399475,
-0.021945951506495476,
-0.4910529553890228,
0.6924226880073547,
-0.7607144713401794,
-0.3364531397819519,
-0.21598972380161285,
0.2290676385164261,
0.31758829951286316,
0.27727118134498596,
0.1586419939994812,
1.3472076654434204,
0.4328615069389343,
-0.5168430209159851,
0.30529308319091797,
0.048190128058195114,
-0.19520607590675354,
0.4218757450580597,
-0.4628661870956421,
0.4580748379230499,
-0.6708003878593445,
0.19997291266918182,
-1.2147283554077148,
-0.17518854141235352,
0.04999539628624916,
-0.49764537811279297,
0.50775146484375,
-0.02489793486893177,
-0.4806794226169586,
-0.36723658442497253,
-0.48895522952079773,
0.5505884885787964,
0.4827166795730591,
-0.7242620587348938,
0.5985105633735657,
0.2364274114370346,
-0.028674833476543427,
-0.91539466381073,
-0.6686042547225952,
0.21651627123355865,
-0.42498984932899475,
-0.48116791248321533,
0.170429527759552,
0.0918935239315033,
-0.17122288048267365,
0.15569397807121277,
0.009520131163299084,
-0.11082721501588821,
-0.3234623968601227,
0.04862115532159805,
0.3858039081096649,
-0.29242464900016785,
0.18375836312770844,
-0.24361221492290497,
0.08393032103776932,
-0.0762205570936203,
-0.09306145459413528,
0.38010749220848083,
-0.3799995481967926,
-0.48400160670280457,
-0.37392401695251465,
0.16557620465755463,
0.6336222887039185,
-0.39873749017715454,
0.5327715277671814,
0.9652144312858582,
-0.12399747967720032,
0.19074110686779022,
-0.87394779920578,
-0.36870276927948,
-0.4902702867984772,
0.4291021525859833,
-0.5322290062904358,
-0.7767127752304077,
0.4752956032752991,
0.10524669289588928,
-0.2520380914211273,
0.13167552649974823,
0.53465336561203,
-0.22993884980678558,
1.1807082891464233,
0.4040529131889343,
0.10926372557878494,
0.5071911811828613,
-0.23481853306293488,
-0.005511701572686434,
-1.045885443687439,
-0.36763787269592285,
-0.10894783586263657,
-0.35807839035987854,
-0.5293112993240356,
-0.5532624125480652,
0.6409252882003784,
-0.0027943800669163465,
-0.13134846091270447,
0.14952869713306427,
-0.2976055145263672,
0.5913611650466919,
0.7280637621879578,
0.6418443322181702,
0.3471713960170746,
0.04726308584213257,
-0.07639393955469131,
-0.316162109375,
-0.7054238319396973,
-0.3131275177001953,
1.1687084436416626,
0.22595565021038055,
1.20051908493042,
0.06794535368680954,
0.7193658947944641,
-0.04328529164195061,
0.3351164758205414,
-0.5693755149841309,
0.7350602149963379,
0.08853158354759216,
-0.6949793100357056,
-0.3007696866989136,
-0.29054006934165955,
-0.9127179980278015,
0.3235810101032257,
-0.1701073795557022,
-0.3474290072917938,
0.1366487443447113,
0.3305278718471527,
-0.39571624994277954,
0.25326111912727356,
-0.6342935562133789,
0.43836459517478943,
-0.5163174271583557,
-0.7051646709442139,
-0.12684446573257446,
-0.7800617218017578,
0.3767404854297638,
-0.01652589440345764,
0.029306253418326378,
0.32047170400619507,
-0.5018189549446106,
0.3912622928619385,
-0.0031501681078225374,
0.8459495306015015,
-0.45169758796691895,
0.1313319355249405,
0.36096253991127014,
-0.06504683196544647,
0.6304267644882202,
0.004754174500703812,
0.1537918746471405,
-0.2182723879814148,
-0.17008918523788452,
-0.2640221118927002,
-1.0133850574493408,
0.8337622880935669,
-0.7795906066894531,
-0.9904962778091431,
-0.013782846741378307,
-0.7476035356521606,
-0.28011196851730347,
0.055220555514097214,
0.39954036474227905,
0.4860319495201111,
0.16956232488155365,
0.34419944882392883,
0.864371120929718,
-0.5642763376235962,
0.2183556854724884,
0.41258376836776733,
-0.3060525357723236,
-0.6852477192878723,
1.0041574239730835,
0.13769428431987762,
0.31564444303512573,
0.6118186116218567,
0.10273723304271698,
-0.7232136130332947,
-0.494957834482193,
-0.6458144783973694,
0.3356594145298004,
-0.8941004872322083,
-0.4182695746421814,
-0.6814948916435242,
0.07029543071985245,
-0.2551719844341278,
0.1291113793849945,
-0.1741083860397339,
-0.3970116674900055,
-0.37487128376960754,
-0.1338190883398056,
0.40416422486305237,
0.4018520414829254,
-0.18883246183395386,
0.006703447550535202,
-0.8538209795951843,
0.5764641761779785,
0.6078108549118042,
0.112395279109478,
-0.03547748178243637,
-0.5962497591972351,
-0.05853074789047241,
0.003638534341007471,
-0.3655535578727722,
-0.7486218810081482,
0.45830589532852173,
0.31298187375068665,
0.7328106164932251,
0.17842918634414673,
-0.07734569907188416,
1.1818240880966187,
-0.5766763091087341,
0.7643373608589172,
0.08592244982719421,
-0.22914192080497742,
0.35912030935287476,
-0.30937981605529785,
0.2112204134464264,
0.5117273926734924,
0.5021810531616211,
-0.12033399194478989,
-0.2789696455001831,
-0.27963125705718994,
-0.9535306692123413,
0.22547350823879242,
-0.1734657883644104,
0.44827285408973694,
-0.16119346022605896,
0.41517817974090576,
0.13085994124412537,
0.1649521291255951,
-0.9347728490829468,
-0.06984281539916992,
-0.287657231092453,
0.05999969318509102,
0.1473555564880371,
-0.26318949460983276,
-0.17637039721012115,
-0.1984751969575882,
0.5071384906768799,
0.01648504100739956,
0.3460494875907898,
0.6018373370170593,
-0.332095205783844,
-0.10373598337173462,
0.3105379641056061,
0.6135908961296082,
0.5854053497314453,
-0.29219236969947815,
0.4001678228378296,
0.1376534402370453,
-0.32999807596206665,
-0.006284360773861408,
0.027731746435165405,
-0.05978894606232643,
-0.24814562499523163,
0.3691079318523407,
0.769116997718811,
0.017539000138640404,
-0.8551750183105469,
0.5339189767837524,
-0.08168380707502365,
-0.06482750177383423,
-0.13943924009799957,
-0.07637211680412292,
-0.010687551461160183,
0.5727572441101074,
0.6601030826568604,
-0.012660440057516098,
0.34931260347366333,
-0.44386523962020874,
0.3761923313140869,
0.8112298846244812,
-0.381440669298172,
-0.25381091237068176,
0.5834701061248779,
-0.11732464283704758,
-0.08129224926233292,
0.7793280482292175,
-0.018884778022766113,
-0.3666619658470154,
0.39314955472946167,
0.8207769393920898,
0.6687835454940796,
0.05708694085478783,
-0.003911627922207117,
0.1477881222963333,
0.35994401574134827,
0.0013677786337211728,
0.4676392376422882,
-0.06075518578290939,
-0.880958080291748,
-0.4851531386375427,
-0.3397461175918579,
-0.19122733175754547,
0.3808172345161438,
-0.6179542541503906,
0.04872094839811325,
-0.3022817373275757,
-0.30667421221733093,
-0.3617478311061859,
-0.39394885301589966,
-0.8942375183105469,
0.2058587223291397,
0.23533318936824799,
0.7008844017982483,
-0.5735803246498108,
0.7990515828132629,
0.9067394733428955,
-0.6386408805847168,
-0.6204251050949097,
-0.010433739051222801,
-0.15064296126365662,
-1.1240451335906982,
1.169355869293213,
0.15047596395015717,
-0.382323682308197,
0.1800452470779419,
-0.6278574466705322,
-0.7697238922119141,
1.3370829820632935,
0.3868732154369354,
-0.35134410858154297,
-0.15894077718257904,
0.051015112549066544,
0.6025192737579346,
-0.35645991563796997,
0.33305931091308594,
0.11303205788135529,
0.5155861973762512,
0.2240118533372879,
-0.7166965007781982,
0.12711866199970245,
-0.11861559748649597,
0.24513694643974304,
0.22832313179969788,
-0.4179714322090149,
0.8811523914337158,
-0.7540574669837952,
-0.3982831537723541,
0.2680959403514862,
0.5498329401016235,
0.5011618733406067,
0.4870375394821167,
0.433145672082901,
0.7924622297286987,
0.35448017716407776,
0.33171597123146057,
1.1667629480361938,
-0.13141751289367676,
0.01767425239086151,
1.1443278789520264,
-0.15782712399959564,
0.784676194190979,
0.8752118945121765,
0.07343217730522156,
0.26613178849220276,
0.5075849294662476,
0.16503214836120605,
0.879240870475769,
-0.13221102952957153,
-0.3307877779006958,
-0.49436554312705994,
-0.11672939360141754,
-0.4231794476509094,
0.2452651560306549,
0.37132102251052856,
-0.5057589411735535,
-0.5270078778266907,
0.2560969889163971,
-0.2903088629245758,
0.1659397929906845,
-0.31358885765075684,
0.7852132320404053,
0.11306200921535492,
-0.5283483862876892,
0.5677299499511719,
-0.3509737551212311,
0.6107364892959595,
-0.2894233763217926,
-0.3743228018283844,
-0.33692467212677,
0.15536704659461975,
-0.09479255229234695,
-0.8408946394920349,
0.07506042718887329,
-0.18812216818332672,
-0.1260204315185547,
-0.005171879660338163,
1.0909466743469238,
-0.42572447657585144,
-0.39738669991493225,
0.18848523497581482,
0.7291375398635864,
0.1014740914106369,
-0.19226200878620148,
-0.8634255528450012,
-0.10668240487575531,
0.010051804594695568,
-0.4048061966896057,
0.5461174249649048,
0.5522346496582031,
-0.2432185858488083,
1.0058504343032837,
0.7429980039596558,
-0.03429543226957321,
0.18283122777938843,
-0.030094655230641365,
1.2026920318603516,
-0.7803288698196411,
0.1281799077987671,
-0.816292405128479,
0.39109835028648376,
0.09617656469345093,
0.01557026244699955,
0.8580719828605652,
0.6003071665763855,
0.7355478405952454,
-0.2508430480957031,
0.8285351395606995,
0.23370693624019623,
0.3553939163684845,
-0.6167823076248169,
0.32567399740219116,
-0.6854158639907837,
0.3855918049812317,
-0.14691978693008423,
-0.8224115967750549,
-0.3574551045894623,
0.3352457582950592,
-0.7681657671928406,
-0.021382061764597893,
0.3055381774902344,
1.36208975315094,
-0.15077590942382812,
-0.33969923853874207,
0.5632665753364563,
-0.09551072865724564,
0.19161145389080048,
0.33612847328186035,
1.3806122541427612,
-0.31511130928993225,
0.8552477955818176,
-0.1504875123500824,
-0.038179583847522736,
0.0034298261161893606,
-0.7441314458847046,
-0.7398970127105713,
-0.5648513436317444,
-0.018188832327723503,
-0.2348516881465912,
0.23107385635375977,
0.6805830597877502,
0.5766662359237671,
-0.36151883006095886,
0.09223005175590515,
0.12411133199930191,
-0.11983675509691238,
0.057473741471767426,
-0.24317923188209534,
0.0951775312423706,
-0.49118462204933167,
-0.460541695356369,
0.3559297025203705,
0.36015504598617554,
0.018484191969037056,
-0.302077054977417,
-0.17832383513450623,
-0.26088905334472656,
-0.09602176398038864,
0.5531737804412842,
0.3416483402252197,
-0.7692810893058777,
-0.4075469672679901,
0.18583932518959045,
-0.12466912716627121,
0.2051074206829071,
0.7909228801727295,
-0.9939677119255066,
0.481380432844162,
0.558655321598053,
0.8067268133163452,
0.6927231550216675,
0.32871660590171814,
0.5776870250701904,
-0.5526659488677979,
0.0891367495059967,
0.27960580587387085,
0.27863264083862305,
0.6096763610839844,
-0.5412933230400085,
0.2076406329870224,
0.1644604653120041,
-0.6639500856399536,
-0.6234410405158997,
0.322172075510025,
-0.7092507481575012,
-0.2531622350215912,
1.1417614221572876,
-0.13606107234954834,
-0.23632492125034332,
-0.11170949786901474,
-0.43895307183265686,
0.028599360957741737,
-0.39531224966049194,
0.5795508027076721,
0.40605607628822327,
-0.4517192840576172,
-0.7754943370819092,
-0.5846208930015564,
0.22601567208766937,
0.17793017625808716,
-0.4270554184913635,
-0.2932487726211548,
0.7648288011550903,
0.4144780933856964,
0.1921485811471939,
0.6553188562393188,
-0.4240151345729828,
0.2357102930545807,
-0.15642625093460083,
0.03978283703327179,
-0.2649863362312317,
-0.37556183338165283,
-0.21185804903507233,
0.08768049627542496,
0.32299500703811646,
-0.3072071075439453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18727v1
|
CtrlA: Adaptive Retrieval-Augmented Generation via Probe-Guided Control
| 2024-05-29T03:17:16 | 2024-05-29T03:17:16 |
Huanshuo Liu, Hao Zhang, Zhijiang Guo, Kuicai Dong, Xiangyang Li, Yi Quan Lee, Cong Zhang, Yong Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a promising solution for
mitigating hallucinations of large language models (LLMs) with retrieved
external knowledge. Adaptive RAG enhances this approach by dynamically
assessing the retrieval necessity, aiming to balance external and internal
knowledge usage. However, existing adaptive RAG methods primarily realize
retrieval on demand by relying on superficially verbalize-based or
probability-based feedback of LLMs, or directly fine-tuning LLMs via carefully
crafted datasets, resulting in unreliable retrieval necessity decisions, heavy
extra costs, and sub-optimal response generation. We present the first attempts
to delve into the internal states of LLMs to mitigate such issues by
introducing an effective probe-guided adaptive RAG framework, termed CtrlA.
Specifically, CtrlA employs an honesty probe to regulate the LLM's behavior by
manipulating its representations for increased honesty, and a confidence probe
to monitor the internal states of LLM and assess confidence levels, determining
the retrieval necessity during generation. Experiments show that CtrlA is
superior to existing adaptive RAG methods on a diverse set of tasks, the
honesty control can effectively make LLMs more honest and confidence monitoring
is proven to be a promising indicator of retrieval trigger. Our codes are
available at https://github.com/HSLiu-Initial/CtrlA.git.
|
[
-0.2975596487522125,
-0.816973090171814,
0.4025459289550781,
0.049169089645147324,
-0.19999660551548004,
0.40229475498199463,
-0.32918843626976013,
-0.2962767779827118,
0.23330260813236237,
0.4659785032272339,
-0.37666693329811096,
-0.26317739486694336,
-0.4716394245624542,
-0.031476933509111404,
-0.1755947321653366,
0.9147764444351196,
0.2067553848028183,
-0.0046512531116604805,
0.17201346158981323,
-0.002491692081093788,
-0.754338800907135,
-0.21694408357143402,
-0.8048248887062073,
-0.3533971607685089,
0.6629244685173035,
0.46842458844184875,
0.5070871710777283,
0.3015857934951782,
0.4087464213371277,
0.25708475708961487,
-0.32518449425697327,
0.743747353553772,
-0.9157532453536987,
0.5147307515144348,
-0.3706205189228058,
-0.5686487555503845,
-0.26786842942237854,
-0.13849370181560516,
0.5714256763458252,
0.17465786635875702,
-0.2900678515434265,
0.21152283251285553,
0.2884638011455536,
0.8738517165184021,
-0.9877331852912903,
-0.124483622610569,
-1.1035516262054443,
-0.1743098795413971,
-0.10086401551961899,
-0.7510896921157837,
-0.5479373931884766,
-0.5043870806694031,
0.005118540022522211,
-0.5156891345977783,
0.04012907296419144,
0.09179127961397171,
0.7391573190689087,
0.3822590112686157,
-0.39649492502212524,
-0.8301960825920105,
-0.7726902961730957,
0.7478132843971252,
-0.41097816824913025,
0.4193669855594635,
0.3195464015007019,
0.2711860239505768,
-0.5177106857299805,
-0.6540700197219849,
-0.40355515480041504,
-0.5137254595756531,
-0.07362920045852661,
0.2396651804447174,
-0.046755820512771606,
-0.13513138890266418,
0.02004130557179451,
0.3044412136077881,
-0.48407402634620667,
0.08898881822824478,
-0.333686888217926,
-0.0636235922574997,
0.26159703731536865,
0.14909595251083374,
0.035577286034822464,
-0.257738322019577,
-0.2707343101501465,
-0.224212646484375,
-0.8143951892852783,
0.03830614686012268,
0.359973669052124,
0.35932475328445435,
0.05486617609858513,
0.48877304792404175,
0.003227206878364086,
0.502040445804596,
0.5024479031562805,
0.029040224850177765,
-0.055638525635004044,
-0.08895429223775864,
-0.13208629190921783,
0.09925539791584015,
0.5572260022163391,
0.04016895219683647,
0.09550751745700836,
0.04444292560219765,
-0.31070590019226074,
0.048987869173288345,
0.6621651649475098,
-0.6051703095436096,
-0.07127492129802704,
0.2575978934764862,
-0.19391237199306488,
-0.5677255392074585,
-0.1418858766555786,
-0.8664606809616089,
-0.6728003621101379,
-0.23842833936214447,
0.6195593476295471,
-0.4252219796180725,
-0.24489565193653107,
-0.05821347236633301,
0.09187676012516022,
0.4829680323600769,
0.29255449771881104,
-0.4855758845806122,
0.30522602796554565,
0.7412234544754028,
0.8198986053466797,
-0.30083873867988586,
0.12602773308753967,
-0.8434168100357056,
0.08691493421792984,
-0.6152039766311646,
0.6992092728614807,
-0.408728688955307,
-0.5440332889556885,
0.05561629310250282,
-0.17698214948177338,
0.024001067504286766,
-0.5001784563064575,
0.6730215549468994,
-0.8640074729919434,
0.35847169160842896,
-0.2103293389081955,
-0.4498816430568695,
-0.20861762762069702,
0.4741048812866211,
-0.5991148948669434,
0.9624631404876709,
0.058825161308050156,
-0.775507390499115,
0.05905577540397644,
-0.6031339764595032,
-0.14560997486114502,
-0.020425818860530853,
-0.04768474027514458,
-0.3088122606277466,
0.3646968901157379,
0.18443462252616882,
0.23146657645702362,
-0.22232811152935028,
0.20987766981124878,
-0.10286302119493484,
-0.3588024973869324,
0.45018744468688965,
-0.27250444889068604,
0.770588219165802,
0.3139053285121918,
-0.15333934128284454,
0.2035646140575409,
-0.5123018622398376,
0.16310155391693115,
0.021205445751547813,
-0.27471113204956055,
-0.4269059896469116,
-0.005763044115155935,
-0.18595708906650543,
-0.0799906849861145,
0.37554800510406494,
-0.27242177724838257,
0.14360029995441437,
-0.5797135233879089,
-0.12220517545938492,
1.0730663537979126,
0.1904391050338745,
0.5302864909172058,
-0.5849967002868652,
0.6267000436782837,
-0.09112593531608582,
0.10280730575323105,
0.014669167809188366,
-0.10558687150478363,
-0.7633851170539856,
-0.057089049369096756,
0.23395755887031555,
0.48502907156944275,
-0.8799260258674622,
0.18455150723457336,
-0.06505083292722702,
-0.6091196537017822,
-0.6150606274604797,
0.07114017754793167,
0.6303446292877197,
0.5651977062225342,
0.33032649755477905,
-0.19290824234485626,
-0.5897387862205505,
-0.6604463458061218,
-0.36127781867980957,
0.018310757353901863,
0.06037113815546036,
0.40191853046417236,
0.2756597697734833,
0.08743184804916382,
0.6595190763473511,
-0.44114166498184204,
-0.6336610913276672,
-0.15169592201709747,
0.12968868017196655,
0.30571475625038147,
0.4034970998764038,
0.34804800152778625,
-0.946726381778717,
-0.5571203827857971,
0.22792795300483704,
-0.3721756041049957,
-0.18321210145950317,
-0.07508351653814316,
-0.12841184437274933,
0.4612562656402588,
0.3402329385280609,
-0.4879993498325348,
0.28835591673851013,
0.8591729402542114,
-0.3089764416217804,
0.76259446144104,
-0.3688511848449707,
0.19977109134197235,
-1.2265722751617432,
0.24266120791435242,
-0.2929743230342865,
-0.24693512916564941,
-0.5466744899749756,
0.43238747119903564,
0.13478411734104156,
0.35271909832954407,
-0.3282848298549652,
0.8231900930404663,
-0.6249893307685852,
0.02647564373910427,
-0.7462698817253113,
0.21609799563884735,
-0.17514903843402863,
0.39334818720817566,
-0.3093833029270172,
1.0086696147918701,
0.25443175435066223,
-0.8482185006141663,
0.08004958182573318,
0.176898792386055,
-0.13694560527801514,
0.43131953477859497,
-0.4043112099170685,
0.5537410378456116,
-0.14983069896697998,
0.21093831956386566,
-0.6364617347717285,
-0.22354409098625183,
0.28624463081359863,
-0.7601948380470276,
0.5236947536468506,
-0.0117118451744318,
-0.2451150119304657,
-0.11692123115062714,
-0.47251686453819275,
0.1589101403951645,
0.7366032004356384,
-0.6323144435882568,
1.1185756921768188,
0.34951189160346985,
0.02335389330983162,
-0.7966944575309753,
-0.29372844099998474,
0.015876730903983116,
-0.19429367780685425,
-0.13070912659168243,
0.30950409173965454,
-0.2734415829181671,
-0.38879919052124023,
-0.15823379158973694,
-0.15611861646175385,
0.031850747764110565,
0.13647544384002686,
0.20722408592700958,
0.2011614590883255,
-0.03524297848343849,
0.04216182231903076,
0.2173103541135788,
0.014219585806131363,
0.03666429966688156,
-0.08880661427974701,
0.7154452204704285,
0.011878125369548798,
-0.11285606026649475,
-0.3533114790916443,
0.04607880488038063,
0.26170140504837036,
-0.3304700255393982,
0.45301902294158936,
0.5647732019424438,
-0.19676701724529266,
-0.614251434803009,
-0.6912896037101746,
-0.4459981918334961,
-0.5580173134803772,
0.2167959362268448,
-0.4452556073665619,
-0.9946565628051758,
0.573499858379364,
-0.13827742636203766,
-0.02254456654191017,
0.136834979057312,
0.7956384420394897,
-0.1744483858346939,
0.717326819896698,
0.6395175457000732,
-0.06683722883462906,
0.40691643953323364,
0.026246637105941772,
0.01918415166437626,
-1.0476832389831543,
0.004443387035280466,
-0.8667837977409363,
-0.24077972769737244,
-0.9015324711799622,
-0.535385251045227,
0.724577009677887,
0.15960507094860077,
-0.18210159242153168,
-0.07635322213172913,
-0.5802238583564758,
0.4676201045513153,
0.52798992395401,
0.4273216724395752,
0.46823886036872864,
-0.28740230202674866,
0.019802100956439972,
0.001142293680459261,
-0.6065340042114258,
-0.3240775465965271,
1.1059236526489258,
0.14365284144878387,
0.8603195548057556,
0.11613386869430542,
0.6020511984825134,
0.23642709851264954,
0.4083830714225769,
-0.8154813647270203,
0.46642741560935974,
-0.2671423852443695,
-0.5319586396217346,
-0.09743797034025192,
-0.44853174686431885,
-0.9158732295036316,
0.2387072592973709,
-0.1884760707616806,
-0.5425162315368652,
0.17845769226551056,
0.4656997621059418,
-0.24791014194488525,
0.20952335000038147,
-0.42489922046661377,
0.15599845349788666,
-0.13729402422904968,
-0.47201940417289734,
-0.44830673933029175,
-0.4453873634338379,
0.5234406590461731,
-0.3377099633216858,
0.06364600360393524,
0.20285582542419434,
-0.04887499287724495,
0.4956701695919037,
0.11127933114767075,
0.8777367472648621,
-0.34263575077056885,
-0.335042804479599,
0.29431042075157166,
0.6732891798019409,
0.9929500222206116,
-0.0013262545689940453,
-0.16681019961833954,
-0.3223813772201538,
-0.017441516742110252,
-0.12861980497837067,
-0.6484941244125366,
0.7953397631645203,
-0.3549269735813141,
-0.6841698288917542,
-0.4671779274940491,
-0.7386814951896667,
-0.33121028542518616,
0.2677956223487854,
0.015727881342172623,
0.22697600722312927,
-0.1546265333890915,
0.3942088782787323,
0.9353104829788208,
-0.42939072847366333,
0.17333413660526276,
0.6599100232124329,
-0.513548731803894,
-0.40809357166290283,
0.8676666021347046,
-0.12649977207183838,
0.23848624527454376,
0.44039469957351685,
0.5382973551750183,
-0.28349560499191284,
-0.6760838627815247,
-0.11809955537319183,
0.236263707280159,
-0.45091137290000916,
-0.5561742782592773,
-0.4345957934856415,
-0.13276876509189606,
-0.2755122184753418,
-0.09580735117197037,
-0.4015931785106659,
-0.10329295694828033,
-0.4411090016365051,
0.0954311341047287,
0.4491775929927826,
0.7368574738502502,
-0.15640944242477417,
0.17732298374176025,
-0.6281224489212036,
0.5270848870277405,
0.10333184152841568,
0.18068276345729828,
-0.1740894317626953,
-0.8040773868560791,
-0.06298963725566864,
0.050094861537218094,
-0.39101704955101013,
-0.8399690389633179,
0.5543784499168396,
0.10324600338935852,
0.21040557324886322,
0.09927236288785934,
0.18187806010246277,
0.5857719779014587,
-0.3428894877433777,
0.6268077492713928,
-0.2719566822052002,
-0.94329833984375,
0.5335716009140015,
-0.5020565986633301,
0.25245651602745056,
0.3371129035949707,
0.23017340898513794,
-0.29440316557884216,
-0.6437704563140869,
-0.19939984381198883,
-0.5545610189437866,
0.4935934543609619,
-0.07418155670166016,
0.24250082671642303,
0.20941756665706635,
0.4925704002380371,
0.07899799197912216,
0.01138158980756998,
-0.49236834049224854,
0.03407766669988632,
0.08564265072345734,
-0.2889161705970764,
0.2087303251028061,
-0.37639740109443665,
-0.29376986622810364,
0.19201789796352386,
0.9042215943336487,
-0.48136571049690247,
0.07431557029485703,
0.2710012197494507,
-0.05729687586426735,
-0.27483728528022766,
0.31217122077941895,
0.6460508108139038,
0.7094663381576538,
-0.2397468090057373,
-0.01454955991357565,
0.2464490532875061,
-0.6065999269485474,
-0.004628489725291729,
-0.1561194807291031,
-0.3820098042488098,
-0.12409236282110214,
0.05431089922785759,
0.5687024593353271,
0.1430424302816391,
-0.5835871696472168,
0.33757343888282776,
0.06191154569387436,
-0.10580972582101822,
-0.40034863352775574,
0.3001079261302948,
-0.038424961268901825,
0.39993906021118164,
0.5439366698265076,
-0.17827630043029785,
0.03118971921503544,
-0.28981322050094604,
0.2331233024597168,
0.6432599425315857,
-0.39425426721572876,
-0.27226722240448,
0.42812982201576233,
-0.10299843549728394,
-0.31697961688041687,
0.2813399136066437,
-0.2806091010570526,
-0.4947465658187866,
0.4478089213371277,
0.6407723426818848,
0.9429131746292114,
-0.6111113429069519,
0.2272820770740509,
0.4062674939632416,
0.44413211941719055,
-0.024141332134604454,
0.6209033131599426,
0.2595565915107727,
-0.766692042350769,
-0.5568580031394958,
-0.6518959999084473,
-0.5397566556930542,
0.1913030594587326,
-0.820643424987793,
0.16328804194927216,
-0.41692525148391724,
0.006299685686826706,
-0.5892696976661682,
0.1371384859085083,
-0.46501773595809937,
0.12097575515508652,
-0.3149133324623108,
1.0698472261428833,
-0.2210569828748703,
1.0073974132537842,
0.37964800000190735,
-0.11742996424436569,
-0.9250293374061584,
0.05775360018014908,
-0.02287028729915619,
-0.8039246797561646,
0.5921046733856201,
-0.24852749705314636,
-0.6387727856636047,
0.10803135484457016,
-0.6442925333976746,
-0.9033893942832947,
1.0507268905639648,
0.2120833843946457,
-0.4972533583641052,
-0.0585273914039135,
-0.30835095047950745,
0.6904392838478088,
-0.16195139288902283,
0.005233218427747488,
0.4418589174747467,
0.5811583995819092,
-0.005145526956766844,
-1.049627661705017,
0.13946688175201416,
0.13534867763519287,
-0.0023306177463382483,
0.23392993211746216,
-0.6044756770133972,
0.7108510136604309,
-0.26408374309539795,
-0.30295664072036743,
0.35167360305786133,
0.7657699584960938,
0.5598359107971191,
0.16614259779453278,
0.5459175705909729,
0.34019801020622253,
0.7016097903251648,
0.030748920515179634,
0.7765406370162964,
-0.3110004961490631,
0.19506174325942993,
1.5407700538635254,
-0.3537035286426544,
0.9277727603912354,
0.5910274386405945,
0.12890435755252838,
0.4315333664417267,
0.12219519168138504,
0.28258657455444336,
0.42108261585235596,
0.1297541707754135,
-0.13023845851421356,
0.13014034926891327,
-0.3743942081928253,
-0.21600674092769623,
0.7363730669021606,
0.6369595527648926,
-0.28476080298423767,
-0.04544626921415329,
0.08859369903802872,
-0.016032081097364426,
0.3683359920978546,
-0.3294076919555664,
0.8833897113800049,
0.06775353103876114,
-0.7611541152000427,
0.6763426661491394,
-0.2196275293827057,
0.6996268033981323,
-0.7165151238441467,
-0.19243189692497253,
-0.3905878961086273,
0.18252500891685486,
0.031896576285362244,
-0.7145622968673706,
0.1688278615474701,
-0.008495953865349293,
-0.00012634535960387439,
-0.09687250107526779,
0.9435086846351624,
-0.398445725440979,
-0.15618427097797394,
0.3946361541748047,
0.5352001190185547,
-0.23067733645439148,
-0.12045609205961227,
-0.5729106664657593,
0.3307808041572571,
0.11134221404790878,
-0.531741201877594,
0.19952602684497833,
0.44819411635398865,
-0.06892847269773483,
0.788078248500824,
0.6857165694236755,
0.3208799362182617,
0.1566758006811142,
-0.10172443091869354,
0.9976018071174622,
-0.6121312379837036,
-0.45625293254852295,
-0.3427482545375824,
0.23597711324691772,
0.16072049736976624,
-0.11888148635625839,
0.670370876789093,
0.334066778421402,
0.7556684613227844,
-0.08133814483880997,
0.544452965259552,
-0.09410220384597778,
1.013033390045166,
-0.7522367238998413,
0.8313884139060974,
-0.62404465675354,
0.10463178157806396,
-0.030337903648614883,
-0.8035624027252197,
-0.22484436631202698,
0.2730585038661957,
-0.02090981975197792,
0.13053098320960999,
0.7269077897071838,
1.3382400274276733,
0.03886286914348602,
-0.12635716795921326,
0.2175704687833786,
0.665875256061554,
0.439342737197876,
0.4962794780731201,
0.874803900718689,
-0.21162725985050201,
0.5197252035140991,
-0.2567054033279419,
-0.14907389879226685,
-0.10708741098642349,
-0.8883981704711914,
-0.6064619421958923,
-0.63017737865448,
0.16245074570178986,
-0.5715163350105286,
0.29785749316215515,
0.9465904831886292,
0.367703378200531,
-0.8138447403907776,
-0.3232203722000122,
-0.01079896092414856,
0.03738478198647499,
-0.16557568311691284,
-0.2968103587627411,
0.5100842118263245,
-0.638187825679779,
-0.8071401119232178,
0.7028388977050781,
0.061982788145542145,
-0.09139541536569595,
-0.5003035068511963,
-0.2202780544757843,
-0.2326057404279709,
0.086993008852005,
0.43141213059425354,
0.3476495146751404,
-0.7391208410263062,
-0.25656160712242126,
0.04064895585179329,
-0.2225230634212494,
-0.03344276174902916,
0.8767496943473816,
-0.9594526290893555,
0.5657450556755066,
0.5392889380455017,
0.7799893617630005,
0.294915109872818,
0.02372107468545437,
0.5229794979095459,
-0.6557185053825378,
-0.06157989054918289,
0.5353555083274841,
0.004309046547859907,
0.14838995039463043,
-0.5653963088989258,
0.49278315901756287,
-0.3235076069831848,
-0.687516987323761,
-1.0635581016540527,
0.1771574765443802,
-1.0987948179244995,
-0.3873748481273651,
1.0496703386306763,
0.15661145746707916,
-0.4105151295661926,
0.004171841777861118,
-0.525877833366394,
0.3091038763523102,
-0.3699623942375183,
1.1937068700790405,
0.38217419385910034,
0.048011235892772675,
-0.06736094504594803,
-0.4951865077018738,
0.7682667970657349,
0.5666625499725342,
-0.9097892045974731,
0.1258302479982376,
0.5682840347290039,
0.09095313400030136,
0.1478884071111679,
0.6476269364356995,
-0.1979912966489792,
0.3469732701778412,
-0.40861502289772034,
-0.12123730778694153,
-0.04117141664028168,
-0.4918924570083618,
-0.4090602993965149,
0.3708069920539856,
0.14380624890327454,
-0.03743726760149002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18721v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18721v2
|
Correctable Landmark Discovery via Large Models for Vision-Language Navigation
| 2024-05-29T03:05:59 | 2024-06-05T09:59:21 |
Bingqian Lin, Yunshuang Nie, Ziming Wei, Yi Zhu, Hang Xu, Shikui Ma, Jianzhuang Liu, Xiaodan Liang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Vision-Language Navigation (VLN) requires the agent to follow language
instructions to reach a target position. A key factor for successful navigation
is to align the landmarks implied in the instruction with diverse visual
observations. However, previous VLN agents fail to perform accurate modality
alignment especially in unexplored scenes, since they learn from limited
navigation data and lack sufficient open-world alignment knowledge. In this
work, we propose a new VLN paradigm, called COrrectable LaNdmark DiScOvery via
Large ModEls (CONSOLE). In CONSOLE, we cast VLN as an open-world sequential
landmark discovery problem, by introducing a novel correctable landmark
discovery scheme based on two large models ChatGPT and CLIP. Specifically, we
use ChatGPT to provide rich open-world landmark cooccurrence commonsense, and
conduct CLIP-driven landmark discovery based on these commonsense priors. To
mitigate the noise in the priors due to the lack of visual constraints, we
introduce a learnable cooccurrence scoring module, which corrects the
importance of each cooccurrence according to actual observations for accurate
landmark discovery. We further design an observation enhancement strategy for
an elegant combination of our framework with different VLN agents, where we
utilize the corrected landmark features to obtain enhanced observation features
for action decision. Extensive experimental results on multiple popular VLN
benchmarks (R2R, REVERIE, R4R, RxR) show the significant superiority of CONSOLE
over strong baselines. Especially, our CONSOLE establishes the new
state-of-the-art results on R2R and R4R in unseen scenarios. Code is available
at https://github.com/expectorlin/CONSOLE.
|
[
-0.11732352524995804,
-0.5883182883262634,
0.6355645656585693,
-0.053896818310022354,
-0.0984206348657608,
-0.18962809443473816,
-0.38743582367897034,
-0.5719544291496277,
0.15767604112625122,
0.6425924301147461,
-0.3050042986869812,
-0.7081477642059326,
-0.3318893015384674,
-0.3615568280220032,
-0.045349881052970886,
0.6742650866508484,
-0.04533190280199051,
0.030433153733611107,
-0.03761838376522064,
-0.44815412163734436,
-0.5862129330635071,
-0.6905094981193542,
-0.585616409778595,
-0.11716271191835403,
0.35323408246040344,
0.3972921669483185,
0.8821796178817749,
0.5388180017471313,
0.7076780796051025,
0.2653941810131073,
-0.21711233258247375,
0.6956790685653687,
-0.7392804622650146,
-0.19925327599048615,
-0.5055722594261169,
-0.3653669059276581,
-0.7968701720237732,
-0.5176547765731812,
0.3956640660762787,
0.4904782176017761,
0.31680652499198914,
-0.22639954090118408,
-0.11032824963331223,
0.5188393592834473,
-0.5952621698379517,
0.6535339951515198,
-0.40658119320869446,
0.15358951687812805,
-0.11968237161636353,
-0.16999074816703796,
-0.5428470373153687,
-0.3132520616054535,
0.5074673891067505,
-0.9070407748222351,
0.3682572543621063,
0.20632365345954895,
0.9399884343147278,
0.43575793504714966,
-0.4156288504600525,
-0.10727962106466293,
-0.5804773569107056,
0.7208585739135742,
-0.45726653933525085,
0.6026181578636169,
-0.036467574536800385,
0.4621516764163971,
-0.19395025074481964,
-0.5551100373268127,
-0.2681121230125427,
-0.3506743013858795,
-0.1380750983953476,
0.13727834820747375,
-0.2131904661655426,
0.1840442568063736,
0.5033568739891052,
0.08555663377046585,
-0.6658827066421509,
0.20773130655288696,
-0.14496909081935883,
-0.5038458704948425,
0.34445834159851074,
0.13041943311691284,
0.10361237078905106,
-0.21934737265110016,
-0.5808895826339722,
-0.29214179515838623,
-0.8304560780525208,
0.11280500143766403,
-0.07713686674833298,
0.6914548277854919,
-0.16833940148353577,
0.5438244342803955,
-0.20118556916713715,
0.7612969279289246,
0.21216973662376404,
0.013773093931376934,
0.27077949047088623,
-0.3246774971485138,
-0.02987806499004364,
0.12060514092445374,
0.3461708426475525,
0.7217373251914978,
0.4266461133956909,
-0.038632746785879135,
-0.0898924171924591,
-0.0036629103124141693,
0.3067275881767273,
-0.5692662000656128,
-0.585104763507843,
-0.0014482414117082953,
0.017675722017884254,
0.10974229872226715,
0.13018770515918732,
-0.4767427444458008,
-0.4078201651573181,
-0.42835062742233276,
0.5794763565063477,
-0.3287665843963623,
-0.26826363801956177,
0.15025173127651215,
-0.001318907830864191,
0.2682630121707916,
0.8912301063537598,
-0.43205970525741577,
-0.2654026448726654,
0.8184824585914612,
0.7571280598640442,
-0.14448383450508118,
-0.18742185831069946,
-0.8111172914505005,
0.1892317682504654,
-0.42306041717529297,
0.3603179156780243,
-0.45037588477134705,
-0.12964904308319092,
0.026233751326799393,
0.17427517473697662,
0.06128641590476036,
-0.48996174335479736,
0.4740925133228302,
-0.5067468285560608,
-0.12886279821395874,
-0.5592277646064758,
-0.2895331084728241,
-0.41641631722450256,
0.6389384269714355,
-0.8656834363937378,
0.8640004992485046,
-0.11887947469949722,
-0.4020712375640869,
0.5257596373558044,
-0.5128222703933716,
-0.0964280217885971,
-0.16499526798725128,
-0.15609008073806763,
-0.501581609249115,
0.04256327822804451,
0.5845766067504883,
0.19675099849700928,
0.257528156042099,
0.48338040709495544,
-0.049723293632268906,
-0.2284655123949051,
-0.031241275370121002,
-0.38235220313072205,
0.42107388377189636,
-0.11107715219259262,
-0.6133715510368347,
0.2946237623691559,
-0.53135746717453,
-0.05668681114912033,
-0.19865569472312927,
-0.03885890543460846,
-0.416996568441391,
-0.007311929017305374,
0.0996515154838562,
0.10126789659261703,
0.3846627473831177,
-0.247142031788826,
0.3657245934009552,
-0.2303118258714676,
0.11937420815229416,
0.6928110122680664,
-0.04088838770985603,
0.5206440687179565,
0.0032681673765182495,
0.13015715777873993,
0.19026009738445282,
0.35989758372306824,
-0.2092188149690628,
-0.5062128305435181,
-0.8676757216453552,
-0.34414470195770264,
-0.007601433899253607,
0.3432707190513611,
-0.7411037683486938,
0.32547762989997864,
-0.6139645576477051,
-0.2107275277376175,
-0.025210514664649963,
-0.31504860520362854,
0.8005057573318481,
0.5338388681411743,
0.5612172484397888,
-0.5034875273704529,
-0.6549782156944275,
-0.6426780223846436,
0.08368459343910217,
-0.3308347463607788,
0.3000616729259491,
0.5201586484909058,
0.3039287030696869,
-0.0886734277009964,
0.8846508264541626,
-0.5662150382995605,
-0.3357980251312256,
0.10531509667634964,
-0.1345205456018448,
0.016115257516503334,
0.5109473466873169,
0.31489717960357666,
-0.9903225302696228,
-0.09342043846845627,
0.23304811120033264,
-0.7501501441001892,
0.17643171548843384,
0.03432747721672058,
-0.25583091378211975,
0.1590060442686081,
0.7648369669914246,
-0.25721368193626404,
0.5788098573684692,
0.41620683670043945,
-0.2816024422645569,
0.1847502589225769,
-0.22770720720291138,
0.26457688212394714,
-0.877900242805481,
0.04301837086677551,
-0.10948328673839569,
-0.47826525568962097,
-0.5565310120582581,
0.3199189305305481,
0.1986365169286728,
-0.024692313745617867,
-0.3907615840435028,
0.5723391771316528,
-0.53359055519104,
-0.21073795855045319,
-0.12414584308862686,
0.429444283246994,
-0.0006086259963922203,
0.7213759422302246,
0.40942707657814026,
0.3287472724914551,
0.4318469166755676,
-0.3904888927936554,
0.007864650338888168,
0.4432968199253082,
-0.2284211665391922,
0.5415424108505249,
-0.3773532211780548,
0.00038840476190671325,
-0.09563867747783661,
0.2710241973400116,
-1.1403720378875732,
-0.15695080161094666,
0.22652699053287506,
-0.3998139798641205,
0.20587116479873657,
-0.47101226449012756,
-0.02354857139289379,
-0.18641552329063416,
0.1298016756772995,
0.6409188508987427,
0.23903019726276398,
-0.8498557209968567,
0.4546845853328705,
0.1214996874332428,
0.2586474120616913,
-0.8428608775138855,
-0.4086589515209198,
0.10138526558876038,
0.15626725554466248,
-0.5966842174530029,
0.09007390588521957,
0.10879742354154587,
-0.05267062038183212,
-0.12845315039157867,
-0.27148130536079407,
0.17753957211971283,
-0.17249028384685516,
0.5675656795501709,
0.47935688495635986,
-0.3722009062767029,
0.18507486581802368,
-0.46436113119125366,
-0.23876270651817322,
-0.41574788093566895,
-0.44383636116981506,
0.4960233271121979,
-0.3742952346801758,
-0.7493410110473633,
-0.24485403299331665,
-0.025544187054038048,
0.7459673881530762,
-0.48318156599998474,
0.15796029567718506,
0.5023494958877563,
-0.3020353317260742,
0.00853518396615982,
-0.5167344808578491,
-0.14712651073932648,
-0.3415972888469696,
0.5841091871261597,
-0.2934122681617737,
-1.1300312280654907,
0.4254917502403259,
-0.24813033640384674,
0.14080967009067535,
0.2006327211856842,
0.33739757537841797,
0.38618409633636475,
0.8251144886016846,
0.676826536655426,
-0.009280003607273102,
0.49337220191955566,
-0.39374908804893494,
0.5079224109649658,
-0.7922578454017639,
-0.2958146929740906,
-0.2344958633184433,
-0.38399332761764526,
-0.45719605684280396,
-1.0554568767547607,
0.6968339681625366,
0.03839274123311043,
-0.1860581487417221,
0.41716423630714417,
-0.3570442795753479,
0.4395478069782257,
0.4746328890323639,
0.4154060184955597,
0.5131160616874695,
-0.17831556499004364,
-0.1967364102602005,
-0.1876959651708603,
-0.5697470903396606,
-0.28714948892593384,
0.8282631039619446,
0.08723076432943344,
0.7571996450424194,
0.1990332454442978,
0.6172791719436646,
0.04137864336371422,
-0.03401466831564903,
-0.8916939496994019,
0.5965153574943542,
-0.05366836115717888,
-0.5586263537406921,
-0.5290552377700806,
-0.19230510294437408,
-0.6916442513465881,
0.26981985569000244,
-0.2011336088180542,
-0.7409847378730774,
0.4123358130455017,
0.47580310702323914,
-0.32325661182403564,
0.3576420247554779,
-0.539283275604248,
1.085655689239502,
-0.44151273369789124,
-0.5745430588722229,
-0.11358805000782013,
-0.6774204969406128,
0.2446131557226181,
0.13306285440921783,
-0.18420502543449402,
0.12545527517795563,
-0.024693328887224197,
0.09513023495674133,
-0.49353650212287903,
0.9489237070083618,
-0.3750136196613312,
-0.14589107036590576,
0.10027438402175903,
0.05170179158449173,
0.8534699082374573,
-0.02159384824335575,
0.2071780264377594,
0.19920171797275543,
-0.5121526718139648,
-0.23524649441242218,
-0.5454806685447693,
0.7173647284507751,
-0.614691436290741,
-0.5748671889305115,
-0.2750305235385895,
-0.6224250793457031,
-0.1631292998790741,
0.10701769590377808,
0.10012715309858322,
0.848089873790741,
-0.4449496269226074,
0.0661563128232956,
0.7023717761039734,
-0.11984480917453766,
0.3472866117954254,
0.6547237634658813,
-0.4006027281284332,
-0.1306937038898468,
0.8773669004440308,
0.04846767708659172,
0.34482261538505554,
0.8473061323165894,
0.05331062152981758,
-0.4070436358451843,
-0.7160012125968933,
-0.3983115553855896,
0.06018894165754318,
-0.5922120809555054,
-0.10758879780769348,
-0.4307040274143219,
-0.0805179551243782,
-0.12277084589004517,
-0.5694966912269592,
-0.6407313346862793,
-0.3838791847229004,
0.17611566185951233,
-0.059095125645399094,
0.3019104301929474,
0.3810984492301941,
-0.2507256865501404,
0.1267838180065155,
-0.54997318983078,
0.23530243337154388,
0.2938399910926819,
0.05567076802253723,
0.0011012883624061942,
-0.3178127110004425,
-0.24973857402801514,
-0.004942991770803928,
0.027557894587516785,
-0.12883292138576508,
0.19840803742408752,
-0.03975817561149597,
0.40868425369262695,
0.4258406460285187,
0.09982797503471375,
1.0735163688659668,
-0.4833252727985382,
0.7067660093307495,
0.25986239314079285,
-0.8261265158653259,
0.5797349214553833,
-0.2793942987918854,
0.5099918842315674,
0.3690420389175415,
0.16676999628543854,
-0.46010923385620117,
-0.4477232098579407,
-0.5191861987113953,
-0.8847487568855286,
0.4691154956817627,
0.03803541511297226,
-0.47194573283195496,
0.10876766592264175,
0.14344702661037445,
-0.055020201951265335,
-0.01434476301074028,
-0.4715002775192261,
0.05496935918927193,
-0.14438477158546448,
-0.07319317013025284,
-0.37833407521247864,
0.13456033170223236,
-0.24748504161834717,
0.00013486061652656645,
0.4349476993083954,
-0.34710824489593506,
0.0038617330137640238,
0.551002025604248,
-0.4067573845386505,
-0.1414991319179535,
-0.052088722586631775,
0.5894155502319336,
0.8803153038024902,
-0.2527720034122467,
0.031113501638174057,
-0.026924513280391693,
-0.49889621138572693,
-0.07174381613731384,
-0.11215237528085709,
-0.26682722568511963,
0.10541529953479767,
0.4032869338989258,
0.9974874258041382,
0.6741260290145874,
-0.691951334476471,
0.7952662706375122,
-0.007641426287591457,
0.12194589525461197,
-0.3436306416988373,
0.06133927404880524,
-0.17810939252376556,
0.8272698521614075,
0.15827295184135437,
0.47629740834236145,
-0.02314462885260582,
-0.46370241045951843,
0.29833292961120605,
0.5443206429481506,
-0.7545828819274902,
-0.2217848151922226,
0.6493902206420898,
0.20216529071331024,
-0.16000370681285858,
0.5713294148445129,
-0.02895793318748474,
-0.6249245405197144,
0.6118246912956238,
0.10854998975992203,
0.8111612796783447,
-0.07554202526807785,
0.15974237024784088,
0.6958746910095215,
0.31950655579566956,
-0.3584752380847931,
0.014880085363984108,
-0.12424229085445404,
-0.6959458589553833,
-0.47582265734672546,
-0.28564879298210144,
-0.6931600570678711,
-0.1349717080593109,
-0.6900733113288879,
0.4375143349170685,
-0.33779314160346985,
-0.05409746989607811,
-0.26394662261009216,
-0.2347731590270996,
-0.7156727910041809,
0.23393896222114563,
0.11744236946105957,
0.5583919286727905,
-0.6712695956230164,
0.7610321044921875,
0.5778168439865112,
-0.18728739023208618,
-0.9498586654663086,
0.11316654831171036,
0.2925128936767578,
-1.0651370286941528,
0.5821657776832581,
0.18435251712799072,
-0.13316994905471802,
-0.17409448325634003,
-0.4543471932411194,
-0.8892136216163635,
1.069126009941101,
0.19044600427150726,
-0.9497835040092468,
-0.1827639639377594,
-0.010950944386422634,
0.5719406604766846,
-0.20329202711582184,
0.20072351396083832,
0.1661960482597351,
0.5050514340400696,
0.5519992709159851,
-1.1827055215835571,
0.08756957203149796,
0.13125179708003998,
-0.08206922560930252,
0.6060134172439575,
-0.7703816890716553,
0.6782563924789429,
-0.7033534646034241,
0.036676328629255295,
0.289131760597229,
0.605476438999176,
0.23011378943920135,
0.37336209416389465,
0.5514883995056152,
0.7701224088668823,
0.967871904373169,
-0.2993136942386627,
0.6679233908653259,
-0.07850716263055801,
0.40421074628829956,
1.2566877603530884,
-0.25376272201538086,
0.9027696251869202,
0.4738146662712097,
0.29557156562805176,
0.167707622051239,
0.3235025405883789,
0.06898759305477142,
0.49086233973503113,
0.07992301881313324,
-0.07902093976736069,
-0.5226598978042603,
0.010986306704580784,
-0.30537843704223633,
0.7226302623748779,
0.21490636467933655,
-0.2922634780406952,
-0.3684546947479248,
0.08830910176038742,
0.11256931722164154,
-0.03494429588317871,
-0.5777591466903687,
0.603251576423645,
-0.2512029707431793,
-0.7589285969734192,
0.6567874550819397,
-0.5048959851264954,
0.3845493495464325,
-0.6199580430984497,
-0.2743348181247711,
-0.1656501591205597,
0.5723632574081421,
-0.14709293842315674,
-0.6257140636444092,
-0.11347373574972153,
-0.24047540128231049,
-0.15497533977031708,
0.09177492558956146,
0.3818942606449127,
-0.6133187413215637,
-0.1841399222612381,
0.12625037133693695,
0.504612386226654,
0.14743950963020325,
-0.14549966156482697,
-0.1721547544002533,
0.23801305890083313,
0.2306547611951828,
0.14597196877002716,
0.13353800773620605,
0.49758201837539673,
-0.5364335775375366,
0.4287720024585724,
0.36935585737228394,
-0.10403330624103546,
0.047863081097602844,
0.09702406078577042,
0.7275964021682739,
-0.7315832376480103,
-0.48466330766677856,
-0.47094443440437317,
0.6245882511138916,
-0.2296718955039978,
-0.3221158981323242,
0.7532135248184204,
0.7310483455657959,
1.0089144706726074,
-0.1470189392566681,
0.5455225110054016,
0.04859749227762222,
0.17979836463928223,
-0.7741963267326355,
0.2110411524772644,
-0.42537739872932434,
0.13434386253356934,
-0.4256749451160431,
-0.9161781668663025,
-0.4314527213573456,
0.44584184885025024,
-0.5003560781478882,
-0.2582395076751709,
0.7203987836837769,
1.310548186302185,
-0.2503663897514343,
-0.07933112978935242,
0.5594256520271301,
0.39290952682495117,
0.49379903078079224,
0.9398722648620605,
0.71799635887146,
-0.4508272111415863,
0.6619806289672852,
-0.005576790310442448,
-0.3232453465461731,
-0.5771929025650024,
-0.8422157764434814,
-0.8390395641326904,
-0.7035782337188721,
-0.49948611855506897,
-0.2325020283460617,
0.3808847963809967,
0.7665757536888123,
0.7760650515556335,
-0.7976659536361694,
-0.052822865545749664,
-0.041153136640787125,
0.13920310139656067,
-0.3859924077987671,
-0.1801130324602127,
0.5808711647987366,
-0.18759959936141968,
-0.955205500125885,
0.3894886076450348,
0.6135815382003784,
-0.14818696677684784,
-0.13158950209617615,
-0.23068073391914368,
-0.08644324541091919,
-0.42552581429481506,
0.6522496938705444,
0.6409009099006653,
-0.8980119228363037,
-0.8063716292381287,
-0.031262483447790146,
-0.07726781815290451,
0.2761090099811554,
1.019417405128479,
-0.6992623805999756,
0.887996256351471,
0.36194631457328796,
0.5517644882202148,
0.6179041862487793,
0.00478751864284277,
0.5112696886062622,
-0.6567215919494629,
0.20528766512870789,
0.21885249018669128,
0.4864913821220398,
0.4576100707054138,
-0.3001005947589874,
0.5957122445106506,
0.14580801129341125,
-0.5859345197677612,
-0.5110666751861572,
0.32506605982780457,
-1.5278689861297607,
0.04969891905784607,
0.9795789122581482,
-0.1437739133834839,
-0.20479024946689606,
-0.17321579158306122,
-0.6651560068130493,
0.09417854994535446,
-0.4004242718219757,
0.5717886686325073,
0.41623491048812866,
-0.1500220149755478,
0.0009765124414116144,
-0.3125661313533783,
0.5913541316986084,
0.2565346956253052,
-0.3410830497741699,
0.07454041391611099,
0.9502400159835815,
-0.08050447702407837,
0.4652864933013916,
0.2567528784275055,
-0.2957610785961151,
0.5056928992271423,
-0.13589462637901306,
-0.026755470782518387,
-0.13946731388568878,
-0.5849117636680603,
-0.1988859474658966,
0.23991866409778595,
0.08958417177200317,
-0.2697179913520813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18719v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18719v2
|
Contextual Position Encoding: Learning to Count What's Important
| 2024-05-29T02:57:15 | 2024-05-30T17:51:53 |
Olga Golovneva, Tianlu Wang, Jason Weston, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The attention mechanism is a critical component of Large Language Models
(LLMs) that allows tokens in a sequence to interact with each other, but is
order-invariant. Incorporating position encoding (PE) makes it possible to
address by position, such as attending to the i-th token. However, current PE
methods use token counts to derive position, and thus cannot generalize to
higher levels of abstraction, such as attending to the i-th sentence. In this
paper, we propose a new position encoding method, Contextual Position Encoding
(CoPE), that allows positions to be conditioned on context by incrementing
position only on certain tokens determined by the model. This allows more
general position addressing such as attending to the $i$-th particular word,
noun, or sentence. We show that CoPE can solve the selective copy, counting and
Flip-Flop tasks where popular position embeddings fail, and improves perplexity
on language modeling and coding tasks.
|
[
-0.16124308109283447,
-0.5123049020767212,
0.7019022107124329,
0.6352753639221191,
-0.24606961011886597,
-0.20910634100437164,
-0.11053703725337982,
-0.23415584862232208,
0.2678138315677643,
0.274980753660202,
-0.3734590411186218,
-0.5838443040847778,
-0.8818767666816711,
0.170696422457695,
-0.40192312002182007,
0.5863099694252014,
-0.022279974073171616,
0.030998477712273598,
-0.38682734966278076,
0.0038508407305926085,
-0.48260676860809326,
-1.2314271926879883,
-0.5022653937339783,
0.13027377426624298,
0.5398829579353333,
0.6064281463623047,
0.33254238963127136,
0.6196597218513489,
0.42202427983283997,
0.3245237171649933,
0.041102588176727295,
-0.024685630574822426,
-0.5898463726043701,
-0.02623557299375534,
-0.14730601012706757,
-0.8069528341293335,
-0.16188420355319977,
-0.03798237442970276,
0.7930106520652771,
0.9116175770759583,
0.18384668231010437,
-0.24340353906154633,
-0.02315010316669941,
0.4043477773666382,
-0.827532947063446,
0.06220138072967529,
-0.5963168740272522,
0.028166184201836586,
-0.414509654045105,
-0.6026150584220886,
-0.7817383408546448,
0.24549797177314758,
-0.13936609029769897,
-0.4708540141582489,
-0.0442163422703743,
-0.15369296073913574,
0.409511923789978,
0.28914955258369446,
-0.5693406462669373,
-0.12662243843078613,
-0.311204195022583,
0.8947305083274841,
-0.6547362804412842,
0.5838243961334229,
0.543181300163269,
-0.2668123245239258,
-0.230020210146904,
-0.5700966119766235,
-0.4362718462944031,
0.08267785608768463,
-0.07426005601882935,
0.1833995133638382,
0.3401621878147125,
-0.11587830632925034,
0.3382090628147125,
0.09008095413446426,
-0.18942344188690186,
0.0623115710914135,
-0.08293997496366501,
0.0009938415605574846,
0.4309556782245636,
0.09316237270832062,
0.42623087763786316,
0.08571226894855499,
-0.7772980332374573,
-0.18639381229877472,
-0.6519351601600647,
0.3622759282588959,
0.050794005393981934,
0.23715218901634216,
-0.3484863042831421,
0.44037866592407227,
-0.10981324315071106,
0.873153030872345,
0.5167540311813354,
-0.19285576045513153,
0.1864471286535263,
0.08748535811901093,
-0.2922561466693878,
0.25787264108657837,
0.3899690806865692,
0.30336707830429077,
0.03586999699473381,
-0.21870681643486023,
-0.08268512785434723,
0.0597289502620697,
0.3849075734615326,
-0.5625849962234497,
-0.01299476157873869,
0.24658244848251343,
-0.061604008078575134,
-0.17474505305290222,
0.4498964250087738,
-0.183515727519989,
-0.12009569257497787,
-0.2735958695411682,
0.03151986375451088,
-0.7488685250282288,
0.18973281979560852,
0.29823723435401917,
0.09285289794206619,
0.6188535690307617,
0.2919335961341858,
-1.1768004894256592,
0.24215911328792572,
1.056472659111023,
0.7036533355712891,
-0.3395500183105469,
-0.6175815463066101,
-0.9077562093734741,
0.351092666387558,
-0.42178282141685486,
0.8163654804229736,
-0.9035829901695251,
-0.523212194442749,
0.04116872325539589,
0.18910576403141022,
-0.49720463156700134,
-0.21243485808372498,
0.3710883855819702,
-0.5053466558456421,
0.10651098191738129,
-0.4528723955154419,
-0.983193039894104,
-0.022561587393283844,
0.30979350209236145,
-0.468973845243454,
0.8103177547454834,
0.044749658554792404,
-0.8266315460205078,
0.20630709826946259,
-0.5718551874160767,
-0.6769582033157349,
0.12634709477424622,
-0.3473532497882843,
0.1342909187078476,
0.4433765709400177,
0.33031076192855835,
0.43962693214416504,
0.30407798290252686,
0.21402068436145782,
-0.007523806300014257,
-0.5825745463371277,
0.6438317894935608,
-0.2545846998691559,
0.6539939045906067,
0.06221146881580353,
-0.013760902918875217,
0.16134551167488098,
-0.2234133929014206,
-0.3195568919181824,
-0.012758184224367142,
-0.6146592497825623,
-0.5003661513328552,
-0.08864601701498032,
-0.09644076228141785,
0.10042174160480499,
0.4065004289150238,
-0.28921207785606384,
0.37317726016044617,
-0.34439003467559814,
0.29439449310302734,
0.47347503900527954,
0.2740997076034546,
0.7314692735671997,
-0.1422736793756485,
0.575360119342804,
0.2387176752090454,
-0.05118151754140854,
-0.5166801810264587,
-0.5389245748519897,
-0.5037209391593933,
-0.22492648661136627,
0.40050363540649414,
0.7164144515991211,
-0.8655394911766052,
0.4732113480567932,
-0.35564306378364563,
0.09859776496887207,
-0.11505239456892014,
-0.018269667401909828,
0.5594845414161682,
0.5076434016227722,
0.10687416791915894,
-0.4360709488391876,
-0.46566686034202576,
-0.5233664512634277,
-0.28002679347991943,
-0.045743294060230255,
-0.026846252381801605,
0.12003307044506073,
0.18436481058597565,
-0.08375172317028046,
0.8401346802711487,
-0.37234586477279663,
-0.1709977686405182,
-0.07888341695070267,
0.15559343993663788,
0.1167105957865715,
0.5773570537567139,
0.6988338828086853,
-0.9596207141876221,
-0.43887773156166077,
-0.41207021474838257,
-0.648751974105835,
0.06997866928577423,
-0.21870838105678558,
-0.19592484831809998,
0.2801104784011841,
0.9168647527694702,
-0.5058039426803589,
0.274694561958313,
0.6520604491233826,
-0.6220000982284546,
0.13831007480621338,
-0.13762275874614716,
0.118585504591465,
-0.948305606842041,
0.12903662025928497,
-0.23563998937606812,
-0.5004760026931763,
-0.7885666489601135,
0.24007870256900787,
0.2759764492511749,
-0.23799258470535278,
-0.8238900899887085,
0.699153482913971,
-0.477955162525177,
-0.028263233602046967,
-0.18624389171600342,
0.03399232402443886,
-0.09905815124511719,
0.8142276406288147,
0.3533080816268921,
0.5491066575050354,
0.4187888503074646,
-0.7377570867538452,
-0.09160756319761276,
0.3334916830062866,
-0.5780670642852783,
0.8548899292945862,
-0.11804252117872238,
0.3868560194969177,
-0.05335802957415581,
0.19474203884601593,
-1.057977557182312,
-0.4425138235092163,
0.1747576892375946,
-0.5127066373825073,
0.5993807315826416,
-0.06464458256959915,
-0.1720454841852188,
-0.22107428312301636,
-0.21258144080638885,
0.7635956406593323,
-0.049709927290678024,
-0.4478989839553833,
0.048065993934869766,
0.4826093316078186,
-0.14134491980075836,
-0.9000574946403503,
-0.6713594198226929,
0.15907247364521027,
-0.13006746768951416,
-0.18185599148273468,
0.553939938545227,
-0.10416474938392639,
-0.1344725638628006,
-0.08564750105142593,
-0.2706318795681,
0.13023141026496887,
0.24511733651161194,
0.0033219291362911463,
-0.03184074908494949,
0.11264132708311081,
0.25615644454956055,
-0.14306452870368958,
-0.329293817281723,
-0.06561595946550369,
-0.6073264479637146,
0.7563652396202087,
0.15742693841457367,
-0.4254802167415619,
-0.3246036767959595,
0.6201215386390686,
0.7362154722213745,
-0.03244885802268982,
0.7422180771827698,
0.35860544443130493,
-0.6280674338340759,
0.13165095448493958,
-0.37015512585639954,
-0.08990204334259033,
-0.4444139897823334,
0.44025641679763794,
-0.6516690850257874,
-0.8856747150421143,
0.3635958433151245,
0.08187170326709747,
-0.013134039007127285,
0.10802723467350006,
0.3332219421863556,
-0.1388721764087677,
0.9172539710998535,
1.054867148399353,
-0.34223803877830505,
0.7369819283485413,
-0.07109370827674866,
0.19122137129306793,
-0.9253212213516235,
-0.11822579801082611,
-0.2533136010169983,
-0.6998575329780579,
-0.180545836687088,
-0.6962388753890991,
0.2724241316318512,
0.2363966554403305,
-0.17682591080665588,
0.33391833305358887,
-0.4152752757072449,
0.5153675079345703,
0.5535670518875122,
0.2580828070640564,
0.1006736010313034,
-0.0022860378958284855,
-0.34420761466026306,
-0.13059814274311066,
-0.7610079050064087,
-0.21246111392974854,
0.770002543926239,
0.20852844417095184,
0.5758718848228455,
0.0340244397521019,
0.8452842235565186,
0.19790318608283997,
0.37949705123901367,
-1.1239144802093506,
0.5628825426101685,
-0.45662039518356323,
-0.3260229527950287,
-0.44695615768432617,
-0.00697297090664506,
-0.7964363694190979,
-0.06700340658426285,
0.20730194449424744,
-1.0240942239761353,
0.7965125441551208,
0.09218604862689972,
-0.32659319043159485,
0.12134920060634613,
-0.5882459282875061,
1.0044152736663818,
-0.45777034759521484,
-0.3839096426963806,
0.04660499095916748,
-0.6352114677429199,
0.23337486386299133,
0.1879587024450302,
0.21107952296733856,
0.07393446564674377,
-0.3936195373535156,
0.8915655016899109,
-0.5174813866615295,
1.2193630933761597,
-0.3683274984359741,
-0.4552280008792877,
0.18875467777252197,
0.16430844366550446,
0.6129985451698303,
-0.11836081743240356,
-0.055486056953668594,
0.019993584603071213,
-0.015709785744547844,
-0.5548151731491089,
-0.4120205342769623,
0.8668376207351685,
-0.6043521165847778,
-0.7083321809768677,
-0.36544397473335266,
-0.8198696374893188,
-0.35783588886260986,
0.18928170204162598,
0.6568426489830017,
0.4371832609176636,
-0.1678389608860016,
0.3320845067501068,
0.47472989559173584,
-0.08005236834287643,
0.5978620648384094,
0.2533879280090332,
-0.0819125846028328,
-0.44125935435295105,
0.7367697358131409,
0.06106295809149742,
0.099149689078331,
1.0568673610687256,
-0.15083613991737366,
-0.4022747874259949,
-0.2550983428955078,
0.13134020566940308,
0.17637552320957184,
-0.9358300566673279,
-0.0484389029443264,
-0.7346069812774658,
-0.06154369190335274,
-0.48620742559432983,
-0.6898236274719238,
-0.21806927025318146,
-0.4426495432853699,
-0.07448764145374298,
-0.12033089995384216,
0.1629958152770996,
0.3090682029724121,
-0.02393081784248352,
0.5404878854751587,
-0.5858132839202881,
0.38545742630958557,
0.3746052384376526,
0.40474599599838257,
-0.11738971620798111,
-0.5415520668029785,
-0.37078818678855896,
-0.14594274759292603,
-0.1753387451171875,
-0.8859362006187439,
0.6654942035675049,
-0.05548238754272461,
0.6468738317489624,
0.5424394607543945,
0.10166208446025848,
0.8415930867195129,
-0.5061954855918884,
0.6659627556800842,
0.3232499957084656,
-1.129555344581604,
0.34369659423828125,
-0.1584218144416809,
0.6930310726165771,
0.5288017988204956,
0.40298160910606384,
-0.7392096519470215,
-0.18984273076057434,
-0.6079873442649841,
-0.9692060351371765,
0.8929343223571777,
-0.0033104028552770615,
0.1412396878004074,
-0.6113114356994629,
0.384161114692688,
-0.06594211608171463,
0.02113165333867073,
-0.612121045589447,
0.04430375248193741,
-0.07001202553510666,
-0.41189044713974,
-0.2355491816997528,
-0.7289425730705261,
-0.2609456479549408,
-0.05175071954727173,
0.3856567144393921,
-0.20834532380104065,
0.6799030900001526,
0.4301896095275879,
-0.5428254008293152,
-0.0026588805485516787,
0.07953958958387375,
0.8175732493400574,
0.6163365840911865,
-0.016453208401799202,
0.40660133957862854,
0.15986064076423645,
-0.4366475045681,
0.14677761495113373,
-0.26147422194480896,
-0.21090558171272278,
0.0745457112789154,
0.4725048542022705,
0.840257465839386,
0.9082252979278564,
-0.34257301688194275,
0.5628706812858582,
0.18577459454536438,
-0.05047149583697319,
-0.255257248878479,
-0.03464173898100853,
0.2459835559129715,
-0.016187163069844246,
0.21332475543022156,
-0.15354768931865692,
0.038886215537786484,
-0.7026001811027527,
0.4135032296180725,
0.2383551448583603,
-0.627680242061615,
-0.22401820123195648,
0.7363847494125366,
0.3390927016735077,
-0.6424186825752258,
0.5488864779472351,
0.11957840621471405,
-0.4635486900806427,
0.7216574549674988,
0.9414036273956299,
0.8556491732597351,
-0.5865996479988098,
-0.03474634140729904,
0.43730390071868896,
-0.11315727233886719,
-0.19460858404636383,
0.45666199922561646,
-0.44787079095840454,
-0.8841978311538696,
-0.41486668586730957,
-0.5505766272544861,
-0.5889316201210022,
0.012772518210113049,
-0.7884722948074341,
0.2251667082309723,
-0.43702131509780884,
-0.2088911086320877,
-0.26966312527656555,
-0.43365511298179626,
-0.7738180160522461,
0.22558601200580597,
0.5158231258392334,
0.9757872223854065,
-0.6150240898132324,
0.9875353574752808,
0.9679380655288696,
0.09518387168645859,
-0.43394091725349426,
0.20111152529716492,
-0.115897998213768,
-0.783885657787323,
0.4635487496852875,
0.5486518740653992,
-0.09758467227220535,
0.08587765693664551,
-0.9089451432228088,
-1.027137279510498,
1.0087999105453491,
0.4278166592121124,
-0.8000401854515076,
0.062460195273160934,
-0.06700989603996277,
0.22307293117046356,
-0.6584863662719727,
-0.19911260902881622,
0.4430956244468689,
0.29143157601356506,
-0.00617980444803834,
-0.6006346344947815,
0.007905476726591587,
-0.29531240463256836,
0.1516025960445404,
-0.140178382396698,
-0.6396945714950562,
0.597551167011261,
-0.2711436152458191,
-0.3191809058189392,
0.10209967941045761,
0.40536272525787354,
0.3794171214103699,
0.08561336249113083,
0.5077046155929565,
0.49215251207351685,
0.8679169416427612,
0.002453569555655122,
1.474873423576355,
-0.5892533659934998,
0.1761564314365387,
1.4549453258514404,
-0.33944669365882874,
0.992958128452301,
0.6692999005317688,
0.0032850007992237806,
0.5058118104934692,
0.5224885940551758,
0.3664033114910126,
0.7132967114448547,
-0.15861395001411438,
-0.2180262804031372,
-0.4706689715385437,
0.0776018425822258,
-0.09362909197807312,
0.44204631447792053,
0.7306580543518066,
-0.37726885080337524,
0.18717370927333832,
0.12001331150531769,
0.08286144584417343,
0.17690938711166382,
-0.26846787333488464,
0.8218510150909424,
0.4471002221107483,
-0.8900988698005676,
0.6546661853790283,
0.1186317428946495,
0.510918915271759,
-0.5716434717178345,
0.06439109891653061,
-0.3410707414150238,
0.16295532882213593,
0.017024261876940727,
-0.7585711479187012,
0.17636312544345856,
-0.1797049343585968,
-0.2712714672088623,
-0.4137827157974243,
0.41804438829421997,
-0.4155793786048889,
-0.546980619430542,
0.34081804752349854,
0.12233863770961761,
0.29843226075172424,
0.010980361141264439,
-0.30931517481803894,
0.1122196838259697,
-0.15151992440223694,
-0.3631749153137207,
0.3862003982067108,
0.6860852241516113,
-0.36467042565345764,
0.5762124061584473,
0.5116099119186401,
-0.34840211272239685,
0.032524801790714264,
0.2681635618209839,
0.47075754404067993,
-1.0479463338851929,
-1.0114784240722656,
-0.8734776973724365,
0.42932260036468506,
0.0077311270870268345,
-0.14197924733161926,
0.4081948399543762,
0.323603093624115,
0.8970133662223816,
-0.4817334711551666,
0.6815944314002991,
0.01716010272502899,
0.1479119509458542,
-0.5764639377593994,
0.3238278329372406,
-0.26762479543685913,
0.29868555068969727,
-0.09416218847036362,
-0.9066694974899292,
-0.7402507066726685,
0.7524227499961853,
-0.6358527541160583,
-0.39289596676826477,
0.7937991619110107,
0.4753417372703552,
-0.08101186901330948,
-0.5239462852478027,
0.6779314279556274,
0.2868500351905823,
0.06900878250598907,
1.019108772277832,
0.6298456192016602,
-0.3961735963821411,
0.36420297622680664,
-0.32490965723991394,
-0.2098412960767746,
-0.41655123233795166,
-0.9884805083274841,
-0.6599413752555847,
-0.5175610780715942,
-0.3356480300426483,
0.12248644232749939,
-0.17465052008628845,
0.681106686592102,
0.7734093070030212,
-1.0093308687210083,
-0.2160964012145996,
-0.048043761402368546,
0.2235361784696579,
-0.5663144588470459,
-0.20084454119205475,
0.3817889988422394,
-0.6273170113563538,
-1.0592823028564453,
0.5203700065612793,
0.528104841709137,
-0.08012554794549942,
0.20132635533809662,
-0.16480858623981476,
-0.5659748315811157,
0.13635273277759552,
0.7129693627357483,
0.5014941692352295,
-0.7302535772323608,
-0.5130645632743835,
0.19864390790462494,
-0.3021649122238159,
0.29135891795158386,
0.9583542346954346,
-0.7516838312149048,
0.399685263633728,
0.6259738206863403,
0.49934887886047363,
0.4418658912181854,
0.42295196652412415,
0.8113105297088623,
-1.059077262878418,
0.6324037313461304,
-0.01425357349216938,
0.6910443902015686,
0.5097894668579102,
-0.7490034103393555,
0.5061440467834473,
0.2552702724933624,
-0.08727174252271652,
-0.5675215125083923,
0.32800114154815674,
-1.267425298690796,
-0.26528915762901306,
1.0585179328918457,
-0.354326993227005,
-0.3684486746788025,
-0.1056811735033989,
-0.34557658433914185,
0.17667697370052338,
-0.14072200655937195,
0.7619852423667908,
0.6221138834953308,
-0.10757982730865479,
-0.3732520639896393,
0.012568929232656956,
0.2920795679092407,
0.5724868178367615,
-0.3863605260848999,
-0.04194919764995575,
0.1822095811367035,
0.35259392857551575,
0.31200337409973145,
0.8753312826156616,
-0.3545248806476593,
0.18439477682113647,
-0.03484407439827919,
0.012433440424501896,
0.099034383893013,
-0.48540833592414856,
-0.3951595723628998,
0.2973562479019165,
0.028707420453429222,
-0.6174355149269104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18718v1
|
Efficient Model-agnostic Alignment via Bayesian Persuasion
| 2024-05-29T02:57:07 | 2024-05-29T02:57:07 |
Fengshuo Bai, Mingzhi Wang, Zhaowei Zhang, Boyuan Chen, Yinda Xu, Ying Wen, Yaodong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With recent advancements in large language models (LLMs), alignment has
emerged as an effective technique for keeping LLMs consensus with human intent.
Current methods primarily involve direct training through Supervised
Fine-tuning (SFT) or Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), both of
which require substantial computational resources and extensive ground truth
data. This paper explores an efficient method for aligning black-box large
models using smaller models, introducing a model-agnostic and lightweight
Bayesian Persuasion Alignment framework. We formalize this problem as an
optimization of the signaling strategy from the small model's perspective. In
the persuasion process, the small model (Advisor) observes the information item
(i.e., state) and persuades large models (Receiver) to elicit improved
responses. The Receiver then generates a response based on the input, the
signal from the Advisor, and its updated belief about the information item.
Through training using our framework, we demonstrate that the Advisor can
significantly enhance the performance of various Receivers across a range of
tasks. We theoretically analyze our persuasion framework and provide an upper
bound on the Advisor's regret, confirming its effectiveness in learning the
optimal signaling strategy. Our Empirical results demonstrates that GPT-2 can
significantly improve the performance of various models, achieving an average
enhancement of 16.1% in mathematical reasoning ability and 13.7% in code
generation. We hope our work can provide an initial step toward rethinking the
alignment framework from the Bayesian Persuasion perspective.
|
[
-0.16642391681671143,
-0.6960487961769104,
0.751912534236908,
-0.2569044828414917,
-0.22411420941352844,
-0.14478467404842377,
-0.33426886796951294,
-0.03632276505231857,
-0.00569985993206501,
0.22175362706184387,
-0.7184227705001831,
-0.46989357471466064,
-0.5923270583152771,
-0.3867879807949066,
0.0023239741567522287,
0.7746014595031738,
0.257791668176651,
0.016202254220843315,
0.14207938313484192,
0.11428621411323547,
-0.6324337720870972,
-0.04390237480401993,
-0.8119626641273499,
-0.5860840082168579,
0.44438573718070984,
0.5245603919029236,
0.9185321927070618,
0.9779068231582642,
0.48186227679252625,
0.20653866231441498,
0.09157370030879974,
0.13673608005046844,
-0.6380576491355896,
0.01581309176981449,
-0.6152915954589844,
-0.47160470485687256,
-0.4126147925853729,
-0.0549706295132637,
0.4657396972179413,
0.5752418637275696,
-0.4957202672958374,
0.15144653618335724,
0.12114975601434708,
0.697414219379425,
-0.7105696797370911,
0.06105276569724083,
-1.0084360837936401,
-0.17837029695510864,
-0.02855740115046501,
-0.026310455054044724,
-0.7255272269248962,
-0.2787506580352783,
0.21048860251903534,
-0.7720857858657837,
-0.08374619483947754,
0.15191936492919922,
0.7773442268371582,
0.39122697710990906,
-0.5819267630577087,
-0.25163453817367554,
-0.7626839280128479,
0.8155654072761536,
-0.7739294767379761,
0.38480862975120544,
0.05638498067855835,
0.5041846036911011,
-0.43367764353752136,
-0.09111441671848297,
-0.46953484416007996,
-0.0762796476483345,
0.06526413559913635,
0.3029255270957947,
-0.5708878040313721,
0.17427152395248413,
0.3535342216491699,
-0.12949497997760773,
-0.5103023052215576,
0.3500003516674042,
-0.14930209517478943,
-0.23722228407859802,
0.5958533883094788,
-0.03443492203950882,
-0.13745999336242676,
0.0671597272157669,
-0.2809656262397766,
-0.22466856241226196,
-0.7491891384124756,
-0.13150067627429962,
0.5568698644638062,
0.41874369978904724,
-0.028774088248610497,
0.6906222701072693,
-0.14387457072734833,
0.8582978844642639,
0.7246055006980896,
-0.1275286078453064,
-0.3594357371330261,
-0.07433965802192688,
-0.0685109794139862,
0.2881324887275696,
0.7900190353393555,
0.4591918885707855,
0.021548276767134666,
0.05094945430755615,
-0.11184225231409073,
0.5444252490997314,
0.5227510929107666,
-0.768476665019989,
-0.3117576837539673,
0.1029454693198204,
-0.5152062177658081,
-0.1734803169965744,
0.04699666425585747,
-0.7634612321853638,
-0.4576604962348938,
-0.4770614802837372,
0.7934683561325073,
-0.49679139256477356,
-0.28580984473228455,
0.27712559700012207,
0.08722894638776779,
0.4430200457572937,
0.41935011744499207,
-1.2737724781036377,
0.17732183635234833,
1.1194753646850586,
0.7668494582176208,
0.1501348465681076,
0.14781644940376282,
-0.8392623662948608,
0.604957103729248,
-0.5769075751304626,
0.6683467030525208,
-0.531535267829895,
-0.22998349368572235,
-0.18201933801174164,
-0.3953024744987488,
-0.07916359603404999,
-0.21881359815597534,
0.5165804624557495,
-0.3629058301448822,
0.12675908207893372,
-0.3375263512134552,
-0.7131534814834595,
-0.10258878767490387,
0.09969287365674973,
-0.2275395542383194,
0.5727941989898682,
-0.09279751777648926,
-0.5450512170791626,
0.3816012144088745,
-0.5511465668678284,
-0.2582515478134155,
-0.3275969922542572,
-0.3565754294395447,
-0.5282340049743652,
0.22982332110404968,
0.4501868784427643,
0.43211138248443604,
-0.20892176032066345,
0.25679007172584534,
-0.5375518798828125,
-0.3285890519618988,
0.11557605117559433,
-0.34847787022590637,
0.33206993341445923,
0.32058942317962646,
-0.5991824269294739,
0.2719899117946625,
-0.6461480855941772,
-0.019718455150723457,
-0.037540484219789505,
-0.08809392154216766,
-0.33565446734428406,
0.3171859085559845,
-0.7329633235931396,
0.04914333298802376,
0.20704111456871033,
-0.5807231664657593,
0.5922577381134033,
-0.4745124876499176,
0.46014463901519775,
0.9147170186042786,
-0.1082877367734909,
0.8470979928970337,
-0.4106433689594269,
0.32754936814308167,
-0.1489909589290619,
0.1411001980304718,
0.155563086271286,
-0.6148816347122192,
-0.4125150144100189,
-0.28654590249061584,
0.32465821504592896,
0.40218183398246765,
-0.4895657002925873,
0.4431903660297394,
-0.6470372676849365,
-0.5753212571144104,
-0.9074916243553162,
0.1329542100429535,
0.4308042526245117,
0.6562296748161316,
0.24946683645248413,
-0.005730725824832916,
-0.18237993121147156,
-1.1749244928359985,
-0.3156922459602356,
-0.4260806143283844,
0.007320031523704529,
-0.04906962439417839,
0.2261214554309845,
-0.2025739997625351,
0.8970258235931396,
-0.5644283294677734,
-0.04631967842578888,
-0.09249495714902878,
0.14152447879314423,
0.36055877804756165,
0.5595661997795105,
0.32010596990585327,
-0.4181215465068817,
-0.44698095321655273,
0.44878238439559937,
-0.3148469030857086,
-0.2067299485206604,
-0.27365371584892273,
-0.5298140048980713,
0.0827021449804306,
0.07485150545835495,
-0.789074182510376,
0.5889353156089783,
0.5015363097190857,
-0.1990194171667099,
0.36197471618652344,
-0.12368079274892807,
0.0706920474767685,
-0.9458304047584534,
-0.08705436438322067,
0.2232883721590042,
-0.18362602591514587,
-0.6838611364364624,
-0.23385170102119446,
0.19615846872329712,
0.037630073726177216,
0.20558232069015503,
0.6054140329360962,
-0.6199544668197632,
0.029205504804849625,
-0.5273173451423645,
0.27048152685165405,
-0.3131013810634613,
0.412416011095047,
0.29289892315864563,
0.6250683665275574,
0.23343196511268616,
-0.34912821650505066,
0.0887172743678093,
0.5038431286811829,
-0.2535989284515381,
0.9050602316856384,
-0.4827837347984314,
0.23142486810684204,
-0.060215894132852554,
0.17267359793186188,
-1.154450535774231,
-0.1748824417591095,
0.5840176939964294,
-0.4905221462249756,
0.3977525532245636,
-0.5571651458740234,
-0.12043903768062592,
-0.18389838933944702,
-0.0806003287434578,
-0.02484009973704815,
0.5996747016906738,
-0.6395220160484314,
0.6476758122444153,
0.1375766396522522,
-0.2527249753475189,
-0.6543282270431519,
-0.45655450224876404,
-0.08817338943481445,
-0.29997408390045166,
-0.6045502424240112,
0.4127856492996216,
0.11063659936189651,
-0.13351523876190186,
-0.24388960003852844,
-0.4474058151245117,
0.5412161946296692,
-0.1366012543439865,
0.20169031620025635,
0.34188026189804077,
-0.19709452986717224,
0.04328523203730583,
0.3580315411090851,
-0.2905355393886566,
-0.03602820262312889,
-0.5421733260154724,
0.21245667338371277,
0.014888753183186054,
-0.7900146245956421,
-0.552057147026062,
0.3500142991542816,
0.18833854794502258,
0.170279860496521,
0.6281786561012268,
0.5432453751564026,
-0.2696349024772644,
-0.12969328463077545,
-0.766535758972168,
-0.5165714025497437,
-0.45549723505973816,
0.29892978072166443,
-0.3441883325576782,
-0.7556037902832031,
0.1231328547000885,
-0.22815944254398346,
0.16449695825576782,
0.1594744771718979,
0.586799681186676,
0.2410937398672104,
1.5900074243545532,
0.6020258665084839,
-0.25985103845596313,
0.4007938802242279,
0.10001940280199051,
0.3970519006252289,
-0.6792799830436707,
-0.00617287028580904,
-0.447630375623703,
-0.5356683731079102,
-0.34142687916755676,
-0.2610046863555908,
0.2627456784248352,
0.2630522847175598,
-0.6233351230621338,
0.4156339466571808,
-0.8480949401855469,
0.2124757319688797,
0.6737425923347473,
0.2620226740837097,
0.25073057413101196,
0.1915428638458252,
-0.0841991975903511,
-0.16591280698776245,
-0.8242150545120239,
-0.727338433265686,
1.172128677368164,
0.4346454441547394,
1.053553819656372,
0.48877495527267456,
0.5649094581604004,
0.0309113971889019,
0.43243470788002014,
-0.8456500172615051,
0.6203942894935608,
0.19327931106090546,
-0.47760194540023804,
-0.27043741941452026,
-0.5784288048744202,
-0.7241780161857605,
0.3171718418598175,
-0.5242422223091125,
-1.056277871131897,
0.4234016537666321,
0.4711320102214813,
-0.37308746576309204,
0.1575031876564026,
-0.8668939471244812,
1.0281111001968384,
-0.34166064858436584,
-0.5054531693458557,
-0.4958527088165283,
-0.7371998429298401,
0.19029435515403748,
-0.06326593458652496,
0.03047751821577549,
-0.10554482787847519,
-0.17832958698272705,
0.7041434049606323,
-0.3773735463619232,
0.941641092300415,
-0.3819224536418915,
-0.35164228081703186,
-0.05839274451136589,
0.17818143963813782,
0.9315764904022217,
0.018330981954932213,
-0.1190604642033577,
-0.22122715413570404,
0.019900565966963768,
-0.3541061580181122,
-0.7949237823486328,
0.4577052891254425,
-0.7755764722824097,
-0.8529706001281738,
-0.32544055581092834,
-0.47409188747406006,
-0.3645634353160858,
0.17296092212200165,
0.20279721915721893,
0.14286187291145325,
-0.0760430172085762,
0.035047631710767746,
0.5687553882598877,
0.18183276057243347,
-0.04174229875206947,
0.6367264986038208,
-0.19833099842071533,
-0.5919924974441528,
0.8968036770820618,
-0.10253725945949554,
0.4687124490737915,
0.6009349226951599,
0.2405412644147873,
-0.4102739095687866,
-0.7890859842300415,
-0.4223702549934387,
0.3740854561328888,
-0.5876157879829407,
-0.232847660779953,
-0.3340439200401306,
0.09295867383480072,
-0.39240339398384094,
-0.2569763660430908,
-0.334823340177536,
-0.43497905135154724,
-0.0760759562253952,
-0.052485886961221695,
0.06991147249937057,
0.5352656245231628,
-0.23112614452838898,
0.9738005995750427,
-0.4249403178691864,
0.10911499708890915,
0.3626162111759186,
0.024469738826155663,
-0.09371272474527359,
-0.6393017172813416,
-0.05208258703351021,
0.4321894645690918,
-0.6685792207717896,
-1.0140949487686157,
-0.019764317199587822,
0.1273442804813385,
0.6809396743774414,
0.8724038004875183,
0.016148481518030167,
0.86833256483078,
-0.3048085570335388,
0.32091835141181946,
0.4152786135673523,
-0.9778298139572144,
0.723716676235199,
-0.5715876221656799,
0.193120539188385,
0.5117624998092651,
0.33106282353401184,
-0.23531241714954376,
-0.2075236439704895,
-0.5578544735908508,
-0.3189462423324585,
0.6395746469497681,
0.11397761851549149,
-0.23625360429286957,
0.1518479883670807,
0.6016591191291809,
0.13533928990364075,
0.38023266196250916,
-0.6375924944877625,
0.11665663868188858,
-0.040106359869241714,
-0.6531764268875122,
-0.025632046163082123,
-0.09546632319688797,
-0.4374037981033325,
-0.16572311520576477,
1.042358636856079,
-0.5122575759887695,
0.3406248390674591,
-0.16662725806236267,
0.06598524004220963,
-0.22831684350967407,
0.3504408299922943,
0.6135833263397217,
0.7741115093231201,
-0.25485959649086,
-0.0765472799539566,
-0.15173880755901337,
-0.2695017457008362,
0.4174962043762207,
0.3397422134876251,
-0.37112587690353394,
-0.29275816679000854,
0.2237931489944458,
0.7820712327957153,
0.21816110610961914,
-0.1718325912952423,
0.6084800362586975,
0.17384371161460876,
-0.36227530241012573,
0.21358022093772888,
0.16685861349105835,
0.17586557567119598,
0.5094971060752869,
0.25381794571876526,
0.11495079100131989,
-0.06306217610836029,
-0.37165290117263794,
-0.02941926382482052,
1.0071024894714355,
-0.3633306920528412,
-0.27786052227020264,
0.8197401165962219,
0.01577894762158394,
-0.1681925505399704,
0.35017064213752747,
-0.10304442793130875,
-0.2789560854434967,
0.1086094081401825,
0.6488105654716492,
0.6077167987823486,
-0.27468180656433105,
0.4103853702545166,
0.30617478489875793,
0.3451073467731476,
-0.5020372271537781,
-0.031110433861613274,
-0.10736703127622604,
-0.8216422200202942,
-0.5129595994949341,
-0.4328027665615082,
-0.5640392899513245,
-0.1897583305835724,
-0.6989637613296509,
0.3480352461338043,
-0.441011518239975,
-0.5298270583152771,
0.16799257695674896,
0.108045294880867,
-0.2771643400192261,
-0.08896072208881378,
0.0660514310002327,
0.727179229259491,
-0.6373936533927917,
0.7181373238563538,
0.733024537563324,
0.009325215592980385,
-0.9688692688941956,
-0.04703748598694801,
0.3458661139011383,
-0.9346624612808228,
0.16856679320335388,
0.16695444285869598,
-0.20672835409641266,
0.17226456105709076,
-0.5620286464691162,
-0.720000147819519,
1.0251657962799072,
0.7026052474975586,
-1.12282133102417,
-0.03836951032280922,
-0.1362031251192093,
0.31799033284187317,
-0.6583566069602966,
0.23906053602695465,
0.5106685757637024,
0.5136449933052063,
0.20955492556095123,
-0.6000766158103943,
0.2421301007270813,
-0.04430932551622391,
0.04311063513159752,
0.4346105754375458,
-0.5916104912757874,
0.25043800473213196,
-0.39382171630859375,
-0.22121308743953705,
0.25231343507766724,
0.9732441306114197,
0.46862268447875977,
0.19562123715877533,
0.5484090447425842,
0.5757251977920532,
0.8332850933074951,
-0.20065315067768097,
0.4895623028278351,
-0.2826341390609741,
0.19456151127815247,
1.058706521987915,
-0.2887105345726013,
0.8728721141815186,
0.5704814791679382,
-0.11710049211978912,
0.4591499865055084,
0.6025866270065308,
0.02577292174100876,
0.6683997511863708,
0.21688373386859894,
-0.11881110817193985,
-0.4808853268623352,
0.33438777923583984,
-0.2792419195175171,
0.15982647240161896,
0.3175342381000519,
-0.02919495664536953,
-0.11640192568302155,
-0.14724397659301758,
0.06230294331908226,
0.2973370850086212,
-0.30928781628608704,
0.9135914444923401,
0.13069450855255127,
-1.0109221935272217,
0.3196466565132141,
-0.036497678607702255,
0.5760005712509155,
-0.8011473417282104,
0.03141608089208603,
0.1663541942834854,
0.5029737949371338,
-0.06655213236808777,
-0.5879031419754028,
0.04570385068655014,
-0.3034907579421997,
-0.23247751593589783,
0.092252217233181,
0.7281696796417236,
-0.5953554511070251,
-0.4111977815628052,
0.19939996302127838,
0.29446524381637573,
-0.22495247423648834,
-0.062197837978601456,
-0.8117159605026245,
0.10656850039958954,
0.10877151787281036,
-0.10659287124872208,
0.4166967570781708,
0.3326684236526489,
0.021411433815956116,
0.7137171626091003,
0.6593517661094666,
0.3620387613773346,
-0.2396102249622345,
-0.18671679496765137,
0.6121665239334106,
-0.41569602489471436,
-0.6173619627952576,
-0.9419478178024292,
0.2975882887840271,
-0.3096027970314026,
0.06700695306062698,
0.6390443444252014,
0.32239124178886414,
0.602250337600708,
0.10982710868120193,
0.8151169419288635,
0.19399099051952362,
0.5048168301582336,
-0.6018723845481873,
0.26414403319358826,
-0.3762809634208679,
0.5046631097793579,
-0.3859558701515198,
-1.0849512815475464,
0.04200476408004761,
0.8495756387710571,
-0.8461892008781433,
0.0011589110363274813,
0.3090532720088959,
1.0972949266433716,
-0.2066446989774704,
0.21375781297683716,
0.034502483904361725,
0.11016581952571869,
0.4420666992664337,
0.8438407778739929,
0.8275776505470276,
-0.1547757238149643,
0.6565870642662048,
-0.15178242325782776,
-0.5064471364021301,
-0.2849477529525757,
-0.9965981245040894,
-0.8567286133766174,
-0.30979982018470764,
-0.4810161888599396,
-0.4365800619125366,
0.35788917541503906,
1.0371817350387573,
0.741152822971344,
-0.5572068095207214,
-0.19943897426128387,
-0.02436591312289238,
-0.02600785531103611,
-0.46859580278396606,
-0.14406947791576385,
0.3435545265674591,
-0.015055613592267036,
-0.41417691111564636,
0.28055891394615173,
0.40523770451545715,
0.16786448657512665,
0.057222213596105576,
-0.25813546776771545,
-0.12515830993652344,
0.14534872770309448,
0.30734607577323914,
0.3644666373729706,
-0.8217074871063232,
-0.6498146057128906,
-0.25694364309310913,
-0.10810507088899612,
-0.013611411675810814,
0.5455362796783447,
-0.47747090458869934,
0.30304986238479614,
0.13412068784236908,
0.704490065574646,
0.36349523067474365,
0.6002532839775085,
0.9110406041145325,
-0.3099839985370636,
-0.12389036267995834,
-0.03244428709149361,
0.20311333239078522,
0.2510424256324768,
-0.3902599811553955,
0.4200224280357361,
-0.020484160631895065,
-0.7464746832847595,
-0.6382243633270264,
0.3749730587005615,
-1.2897846698760986,
-0.17061731219291687,
1.1249306201934814,
0.1842310130596161,
-0.19930732250213623,
0.21653205156326294,
-0.43074068427085876,
0.1351449340581894,
-0.6784253120422363,
0.7202190160751343,
0.6532835960388184,
-0.07004270702600479,
-0.12868890166282654,
-0.37093695998191833,
0.46976497769355774,
0.6918310523033142,
-0.45091307163238525,
0.05255495756864548,
0.6391245722770691,
0.2529875934123993,
0.08735723793506622,
0.7063146829605103,
0.18361790478229523,
0.2613961100578308,
-0.0624544732272625,
-0.24912820756435394,
0.09350914508104324,
-0.11372939497232437,
-0.30291128158569336,
0.006293823476880789,
0.0736357793211937,
-0.08270982652902603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18711v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18711v1
|
Calibrating Reasoning in Language Models with Internal Consistency
| 2024-05-29T02:44:12 | 2024-05-29T02:44:12 |
Zhihui Xie, Jizhou Guo, Tong Yu, Shuai Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in
various reasoning tasks, aided by techniques like chain-of-thought (CoT)
prompting that elicits verbalized reasoning. However, LLMs often generate text
with obvious mistakes and contradictions, raising doubts about their ability to
robustly process and utilize generated rationales. In this work, we investigate
CoT reasoning in LLMs through the lens of internal representations, focusing on
how these representations are influenced by generated rationales. Our
preliminary analysis reveals that while generated rationales improve answer
accuracy, inconsistencies emerge between the model's internal representations
in middle layers and those in final layers, potentially undermining the
reliability of their reasoning processes. To address this, we propose internal
consistency as a measure of the model's confidence by examining the agreement
of latent predictions decoded from intermediate layers. Extensive empirical
studies across different models and datasets demonstrate that internal
consistency effectively distinguishes between correct and incorrect reasoning
paths. Motivated by this, we propose a new approach to calibrate CoT reasoning
by up-weighting reasoning paths with high internal consistency, resulting in a
significant boost in reasoning performance. Further analysis uncovers distinct
patterns in attention and feed-forward modules across layers, providing
insights into the emergence of internal inconsistency. In summary, our results
demonstrate the potential of using internal representations for self-evaluation
of LLMs.
|
[
-0.054138340055942535,
-0.4491210877895355,
1.005791187286377,
0.14585675299167633,
0.054187461733818054,
0.1887064427137375,
-0.48721861839294434,
-0.233375683426857,
-0.22193469107151031,
0.5885841846466064,
-0.25158002972602844,
-0.24840869009494781,
-0.4929310977458954,
0.15952233970165253,
-0.1111927330493927,
0.629391074180603,
-0.505649983882904,
0.2648334801197052,
-0.4650888741016388,
-0.07380220293998718,
-0.7208685874938965,
-0.6870318055152893,
-0.5650207996368408,
-0.705080509185791,
0.3962237536907196,
0.33918309211730957,
0.710406482219696,
0.4908345937728882,
0.2076992392539978,
0.2859441041946411,
-0.02551852911710739,
0.6775773167610168,
-0.31467336416244507,
0.3605181574821472,
-0.38011887669563293,
-0.6312918663024902,
-0.195672869682312,
-0.1778610497713089,
0.787470281124115,
0.40463680028915405,
-0.059216681867837906,
-0.07929304242134094,
0.35939887166023254,
0.6428087949752808,
-0.7033814191818237,
0.1549341082572937,
-0.9959816932678223,
-0.19406118988990784,
-0.03778338432312012,
-0.24865879118442535,
-0.7431632876396179,
-0.22997111082077026,
-0.09404569864273071,
-0.27324673533439636,
0.0014760142657905817,
-0.07633674144744873,
0.5708715319633484,
0.16494672000408173,
-0.4561060965061188,
-0.4742954671382904,
-0.7097979187965393,
0.6390665173530579,
-1.0737783908843994,
0.3544587194919586,
0.515874981880188,
0.3161773085594177,
-0.5312654972076416,
-0.44432663917541504,
-0.5378268361091614,
-0.6026594638824463,
-0.11479058861732483,
-0.07887420058250427,
0.15375588834285736,
-0.09387919306755066,
0.1741691529750824,
0.08631421625614166,
-0.2892656922340393,
-0.07349125295877457,
0.07077790051698685,
-0.23790040612220764,
0.4490529000759125,
0.08394704014062881,
0.20642653107643127,
0.1486855447292328,
-0.3234352171421051,
-0.16821953654289246,
-0.9903771281242371,
0.1449197679758072,
0.49589887261390686,
0.3242493271827698,
0.08996804058551788,
0.879980206489563,
-0.044714782387018204,
0.5083732604980469,
0.3788969814777374,
-0.19231200218200684,
0.04570823162794113,
-0.3653499186038971,
-0.27742958068847656,
0.2909546196460724,
0.5161606073379517,
0.1935243457555771,
0.5453628897666931,
-0.09990538656711578,
-0.4258730113506317,
0.1341576874256134,
0.4416920840740204,
-0.4132220447063446,
-0.25362905859947205,
0.3508625030517578,
-0.046997640281915665,
-0.10902508348226547,
0.16021296381950378,
-0.15102185308933258,
-0.43621739745140076,
-0.5094165205955505,
0.5202571153640747,
-0.4413681626319885,
-0.21135249733924866,
0.1739806979894638,
0.19928471744060516,
0.12675368785858154,
0.5832121968269348,
-0.6205675005912781,
0.22422200441360474,
0.6311787366867065,
0.5701133012771606,
0.08980110287666321,
-0.21809159219264984,
-0.3650701344013214,
0.5509042143821716,
-0.6567153334617615,
0.9488472938537598,
-0.413814902305603,
-0.003190587740391493,
-0.1668778508901596,
-0.07782991230487823,
-0.11574426293373108,
-0.6611295342445374,
0.5030112862586975,
-0.22135454416275024,
-0.0002988209598697722,
-0.55805504322052,
-0.7874953150749207,
-0.010559558868408203,
0.5161468386650085,
-0.33035847544670105,
1.1234203577041626,
-0.03592919558286667,
-0.7682952284812927,
0.15660148859024048,
0.015201757661998272,
0.1531306803226471,
-0.15826928615570068,
-0.6175987124443054,
-0.08977073431015015,
0.24293798208236694,
0.3063870668411255,
0.18383927643299103,
-0.3376356065273285,
0.34692737460136414,
-0.39297667145729065,
-0.3324810564517975,
0.6630944609642029,
-0.6607558131217957,
0.6536084413528442,
-0.016028806567192078,
-0.4514828622341156,
0.1909886747598648,
-0.4922409653663635,
0.3843792676925659,
0.021221468225121498,
-0.07641680538654327,
-0.20184819400310516,
0.11271428316831589,
-0.662212610244751,
0.23140695691108704,
0.23238500952720642,
-0.5228256583213806,
0.23615649342536926,
-0.27218151092529297,
0.29149386286735535,
1.0764670372009277,
0.027862289920449257,
0.4044536054134369,
-0.45155999064445496,
0.2033967822790146,
0.4326176047325134,
-0.17582111060619354,
-0.4679948091506958,
-0.4757913649082184,
-0.7537608742713928,
0.08309203386306763,
0.07547128945589066,
0.230085089802742,
-0.40910249948501587,
0.33335790038108826,
-0.09176839888095856,
-0.39266425371170044,
-0.48894771933555603,
0.2516523003578186,
0.413259357213974,
0.56646329164505,
0.2337215095758438,
-0.035791877657175064,
-0.3859200179576874,
-0.771670401096344,
-0.3950642943382263,
-0.3487519323825836,
0.05298741161823273,
0.11496337503194809,
0.360411673784256,
-0.2807782292366028,
0.8403225541114807,
-0.07487956434488297,
-0.11794960498809814,
-0.056460797786712646,
0.0919710099697113,
0.00019851776596624404,
0.5919392108917236,
0.2507118880748749,
-0.23813503980636597,
-0.4928833842277527,
0.10171480476856232,
-0.8044936060905457,
-0.2002825140953064,
-0.24530988931655884,
-0.4419316351413727,
0.2446245402097702,
0.4394553601741791,
-0.5512112379074097,
0.4253751337528229,
0.49419403076171875,
-0.2740781009197235,
0.7250843048095703,
-0.5042230486869812,
0.16617923974990845,
-0.6963108777999878,
-0.2046518176794052,
-0.01738365925848484,
-0.28808045387268066,
-0.21782438457012177,
-0.00048194764531217515,
0.30033591389656067,
0.5224694013595581,
-0.03863741457462311,
0.6533870697021484,
-0.6111370921134949,
-0.04576682671904564,
-0.3332577049732208,
0.26779043674468994,
0.40558040142059326,
0.32188743352890015,
-0.14477954804897308,
0.9386793375015259,
0.3711662292480469,
-0.43039023876190186,
0.1744782030582428,
-0.14753001928329468,
-0.3390876054763794,
0.6614882349967957,
-0.5860708951950073,
0.4222748577594757,
-0.2069554477930069,
0.5971941947937012,
-1.0962483882904053,
-0.15267407894134521,
0.10217840224504471,
-0.27455493807792664,
0.2244008481502533,
-0.15959987044334412,
-0.8422646522521973,
-0.1370415836572647,
-0.1765664517879486,
0.5289985537528992,
0.23327983915805817,
-0.5430921316146851,
0.6907333135604858,
0.2058468610048294,
0.28901416063308716,
-0.6308061480522156,
-0.7377788424491882,
-0.20987091958522797,
0.15332257747650146,
-0.7024585604667664,
0.1701587587594986,
-0.31555864214897156,
-0.5001481175422668,
-0.05790560320019722,
-0.40618833899497986,
0.010787407867610455,
-0.33080345392227173,
0.1894945651292801,
0.10082904994487762,
-0.40151187777519226,
0.25823473930358887,
-0.14792802929878235,
0.2300487607717514,
0.1828090399503708,
-0.37747758626937866,
0.5065184831619263,
-0.3073560297489166,
-0.64178466796875,
-0.4166988730430603,
0.0922735258936882,
0.5846927762031555,
0.016885749995708466,
0.7028920650482178,
0.13573668897151947,
-0.476580947637558,
-0.3440488874912262,
-0.8134254217147827,
-0.14806117117404938,
-0.4687117040157318,
-0.2248021960258484,
-0.5464376211166382,
-0.3425642251968384,
0.8470130562782288,
0.078339122235775,
-0.05357613414525986,
0.460872083902359,
0.5550605058670044,
-0.17882733047008514,
1.2720149755477905,
0.2461574524641037,
0.34157437086105347,
0.017059139907360077,
-0.1754785180091858,
0.11406003683805466,
-1.2492893934249878,
-0.5576234459877014,
-0.38726097345352173,
-0.030260294675827026,
-0.3835192918777466,
-0.565119206905365,
0.20154155790805817,
0.3058032989501953,
-0.7365559935569763,
0.1741553246974945,
-0.4531668424606323,
0.7257899641990662,
0.2833150327205658,
0.22702810168266296,
0.37697404623031616,
-0.06617140769958496,
-0.732951283454895,
0.009124025702476501,
-0.5504683256149292,
-0.8735003471374512,
0.9710062146186829,
0.3731253147125244,
1.0535740852355957,
0.02021527662873268,
0.5405639410018921,
0.0686861127614975,
0.4459308385848999,
-0.29772788286209106,
0.3523452877998352,
0.03919060528278351,
-0.44283702969551086,
0.023478161543607712,
-0.5801575183868408,
-0.5677618980407715,
0.3102579116821289,
-0.01606440357863903,
-0.8936354517936707,
0.21901017427444458,
0.3064703643321991,
-0.09625297039747238,
0.579795777797699,
-0.6842196583747864,
0.7082135081291199,
-0.5536550283432007,
-0.47725558280944824,
-0.07839278876781464,
-0.39675799012184143,
0.3716391623020172,
0.019503649324178696,
0.016483047977089882,
-0.3333148658275604,
0.1533731371164322,
0.1298031210899353,
-0.49218928813934326,
0.8602969646453857,
0.0917530432343483,
-0.5940864086151123,
0.5753791332244873,
0.4481576383113861,
0.7228298187255859,
0.09428027272224426,
-0.3827533423900604,
0.20591573417186737,
0.07114285975694656,
-0.3204905092716217,
-0.7938438653945923,
0.9205036163330078,
-0.7459366917610168,
-0.6968365907669067,
-0.5195934176445007,
-0.5663425922393799,
-0.4301624596118927,
0.029368465766310692,
0.1369277387857437,
0.5255701541900635,
0.184616357088089,
0.08105005323886871,
0.5811734199523926,
0.04403115063905716,
0.08247052133083344,
0.20450825989246368,
-0.29754361510276794,
-0.3973241448402405,
0.3838256299495697,
0.23591354489326477,
0.610176146030426,
0.2749329209327698,
0.2112177163362503,
-0.47323372960090637,
-0.26186254620552063,
-0.6885396838188171,
0.2910001873970032,
-1.0907902717590332,
-0.4690989553928375,
-0.33727747201919556,
-0.4448642432689667,
-0.3120090663433075,
-0.1921514868736267,
-0.5426949858665466,
-0.11870023608207703,
-0.2107769399881363,
0.07731364667415619,
0.029452592134475708,
0.9720450639724731,
0.18857744336128235,
0.12023434787988663,
-0.5452313423156738,
0.016156204044818878,
0.04721640795469284,
0.43560582399368286,
0.3792441785335541,
-0.6747576594352722,
-0.22729690372943878,
0.5980839133262634,
-0.3701394498348236,
-0.8473161458969116,
0.09928594529628754,
-0.10913371294736862,
0.7591585516929626,
0.23006460070610046,
-0.07541138678789139,
0.8936833143234253,
-0.4779694974422455,
0.6832506656646729,
0.13026368618011475,
-1.0809855461120605,
0.5182281136512756,
-0.17914597690105438,
0.6377822756767273,
0.5266708731651306,
0.04526200890541077,
-0.1583993136882782,
-0.72475266456604,
-0.5650606751441956,
-0.6173540949821472,
0.36353087425231934,
0.20906786620616913,
0.07909815013408661,
-0.14372451603412628,
0.5377541780471802,
0.08959831297397614,
0.015081490390002728,
-0.786141037940979,
0.07846389710903168,
-0.13893771171569824,
-0.36472922563552856,
0.2056373506784439,
-0.28199538588523865,
-0.12401875108480453,
-0.15092593431472778,
0.6475743055343628,
-0.39213424921035767,
0.1211823895573616,
0.39186444878578186,
-0.08242015540599823,
-0.47213274240493774,
0.11758773028850555,
0.6365699172019958,
1.0696338415145874,
-0.2402692288160324,
0.6091863512992859,
0.13923540711402893,
-0.14274422824382782,
0.31487128138542175,
-0.4336620271205902,
-0.040403809398412704,
-0.10597406327724457,
0.39217492938041687,
0.48295265436172485,
0.3834303915500641,
-0.7106822729110718,
0.44968467950820923,
-0.027943316847085953,
0.23195107281208038,
-0.607137143611908,
0.07829310745000839,
0.061211101710796356,
0.3237573802471161,
0.26136040687561035,
0.2604033350944519,
-0.40144601464271545,
-0.8066559433937073,
0.06500866264104843,
0.5695485472679138,
-0.15666629374027252,
-0.19173772633075714,
0.48316192626953125,
-0.2201506793498993,
-0.08552173525094986,
0.6838712096214294,
-0.015408718027174473,
-0.3947194218635559,
0.5750365853309631,
0.7430191040039062,
0.9230572581291199,
-0.19205407798290253,
0.020347751677036285,
0.3609769344329834,
0.5435827374458313,
-0.536435604095459,
0.21298110485076904,
0.053466301411390305,
-1.0753055810928345,
-0.5846357941627502,
-0.489810049533844,
-0.5565417408943176,
0.029897408559918404,
-0.36430713534355164,
0.24648600816726685,
-0.4966638684272766,
-0.1575508415699005,
-0.3063826858997345,
-0.20577508211135864,
-0.551200270652771,
0.21310918033123016,
0.3567633330821991,
0.8032661080360413,
-0.416587769985199,
1.099664330482483,
0.47380712628364563,
-0.5118052363395691,
-1.0900682210922241,
0.3240543007850647,
-0.14677853882312775,
-0.690304696559906,
0.6084590554237366,
0.3146224915981293,
-0.5913853049278259,
-0.3844996690750122,
-0.5738744735717773,
-1.1299216747283936,
0.9944272041320801,
0.8143994808197021,
-0.6008370518684387,
-0.12910762429237366,
0.10917928814888,
0.6053469777107239,
-0.8602010607719421,
0.5553733706474304,
0.10029606521129608,
0.4277288615703583,
0.17284171283245087,
-0.9278901815414429,
0.26567786931991577,
0.09453105926513672,
0.14014677703380585,
-0.06017189100384712,
-0.3491145968437195,
0.9885737895965576,
-0.42662540078163147,
-0.3080391585826874,
0.05210128426551819,
0.5923948287963867,
0.66780024766922,
0.15918314456939697,
0.32826489210128784,
0.500571608543396,
0.9036620855331421,
-0.11889107525348663,
1.143974781036377,
-0.3892863690853119,
0.11133904755115509,
1.5432066917419434,
-0.5769351124763489,
0.9789286851882935,
0.3669596016407013,
0.12633028626441956,
1.0690900087356567,
0.38384488224983215,
0.2615583837032318,
0.2692285180091858,
0.2108858972787857,
-0.17322297394275665,
-0.2847403287887573,
0.09388168156147003,
-0.2185298204421997,
0.35132864117622375,
0.37033581733703613,
-0.4482405185699463,
-0.1608339101076126,
-0.3690301477909088,
-0.08055770397186279,
0.2501541078090668,
-0.35438990592956543,
0.6699917316436768,
0.15990377962589264,
-0.9015510082244873,
0.7156009674072266,
-0.10331559181213379,
0.25118380784988403,
-0.5858557820320129,
-0.22729413211345673,
-0.08003199845552444,
0.5186662077903748,
-0.16135622560977936,
-1.1644231081008911,
0.24418123066425323,
-0.10881923139095306,
-0.11791934818029404,
-0.2581818997859955,
0.7005598545074463,
-0.625184178352356,
-0.4421979784965515,
0.40113967657089233,
0.44576749205589294,
0.039153050631284714,
-0.1840139627456665,
-0.5334885716438293,
0.3473249673843384,
-0.10550830513238907,
-0.07681174576282501,
0.22851954400539398,
0.8211307525634766,
-0.0913579910993576,
0.7257578372955322,
0.5242037773132324,
0.18831227719783783,
0.13004867732524872,
0.19138383865356445,
0.738646924495697,
-0.544838011264801,
-0.22314034402370453,
-0.9950131177902222,
0.5615163445472717,
-0.11275458335876465,
-0.279890239238739,
0.8245388865470886,
0.3789147436618805,
0.968390703201294,
0.18566158413887024,
0.5328483581542969,
0.44122257828712463,
0.13691118359565735,
-0.6512385010719299,
0.3815653622150421,
-0.3503462076187134,
0.6574202179908752,
0.025935333222150803,
-0.8982945084571838,
0.013684602454304695,
0.8667736649513245,
-0.3144168555736542,
0.1320773810148239,
0.8576102256774902,
0.7031476497650146,
-0.09320807456970215,
-0.013513335026800632,
0.2574368417263031,
0.5039168000221252,
0.21254712343215942,
0.4762565493583679,
0.9142168760299683,
-0.2976360321044922,
0.20279347896575928,
-0.3562725782394409,
-0.06487416476011276,
0.03849465399980545,
-1.0644190311431885,
-0.7237686514854431,
-0.4679163992404938,
-0.23244448006153107,
-0.6984122395515442,
0.018524937331676483,
1.065578579902649,
0.5787217617034912,
-0.84724360704422,
-0.5202630162239075,
-0.47960710525512695,
0.16281162202358246,
-0.18166063725948334,
-0.256439208984375,
0.1598305106163025,
-0.5921609997749329,
-0.3057838976383209,
0.394290030002594,
0.400320440530777,
0.010042198933660984,
-0.718903660774231,
-0.11513694375753403,
-0.1695995330810547,
0.6021252274513245,
0.5202621817588806,
-0.02340579591691494,
-1.22919499874115,
-0.5169365406036377,
-0.14450614154338837,
-0.3833649456501007,
0.32476305961608887,
0.9095442295074463,
-0.9468798637390137,
0.5821371674537659,
0.5351521968841553,
0.36838433146476746,
0.33692029118537903,
0.0013923400547355413,
0.8260530233383179,
-0.7147311568260193,
-0.22852811217308044,
0.2347264289855957,
0.6456360816955566,
0.6770034432411194,
-0.5091857314109802,
0.4782094955444336,
-0.1266338974237442,
-0.7225081324577332,
-1.0068175792694092,
0.30414676666259766,
-0.8289280533790588,
-0.25634390115737915,
1.1786493062973022,
-0.3215934932231903,
-0.20065195858478546,
0.14321859180927277,
-0.35802707076072693,
0.07289084792137146,
-0.24400679767131805,
0.7795073986053467,
0.8959000706672668,
-0.31870895624160767,
-0.21777287125587463,
-0.4621371924877167,
0.33677512407302856,
0.27863460779190063,
-0.7193762063980103,
0.3961944878101349,
0.35175570845603943,
0.35897770524024963,
0.2823061943054199,
0.6390904188156128,
-0.23775748908519745,
-0.08470089733600616,
-0.08646702766418457,
-0.24920612573623657,
0.22025270760059357,
-0.3026767373085022,
-0.09458904713392258,
0.011534643359482288,
0.1910574734210968,
0.42212262749671936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18688v1
|
Efficient Preference-based Reinforcement Learning via Aligned Experience Estimation
| 2024-05-29T01:49:20 | 2024-05-29T01:49:20 |
Fengshuo Bai, Rui Zhao, Hongming Zhang, Sijia Cui, Ying Wen, Yaodong Yang, Bo Xu, Lei Han
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL) has shown impressive
capabilities in training agents without reward engineering. However, a notable
limitation of PbRL is its dependency on substantial human feedback. This
dependency stems from the learning loop, which entails accurate reward learning
compounded with value/policy learning, necessitating a considerable number of
samples. To boost the learning loop, we propose SEER, an efficient PbRL method
that integrates label smoothing and policy regularization techniques. Label
smoothing reduces overfitting of the reward model by smoothing human preference
labels. Additionally, we bootstrap a conservative estimate $\widehat{Q}$ using
well-supported state-action pairs from the current replay memory to mitigate
overestimation bias and utilize it for policy learning regularization. Our
experimental results across a variety of complex tasks, both in online and
offline settings, demonstrate that our approach improves feedback efficiency,
outperforming state-of-the-art methods by a large margin. Ablation studies
further reveal that SEER achieves a more accurate Q-function compared to prior
work.
|
[
-0.45601508021354675,
-0.4490531384944916,
0.21087127923965454,
-0.020392240956425667,
0.02249954640865326,
0.09594883769750595,
-0.45387718081474304,
-0.1854138970375061,
0.1788298487663269,
0.2714773714542389,
-0.3962675929069519,
-0.10384581238031387,
-0.2808300256729126,
-0.3787038028240204,
0.7317558526992798,
1.2175627946853638,
-0.2145967185497284,
-0.12449391931295395,
0.03469183295965195,
0.11094171553850174,
-0.3981899619102478,
-0.3600562512874603,
-0.6026449799537659,
-0.746511697769165,
0.707981526851654,
0.5068137049674988,
0.6465672850608826,
0.3607346713542938,
0.31956586241722107,
0.2810564339160919,
-0.1079125702381134,
0.6235881447792053,
-0.8588175773620605,
-0.023978767916560173,
-0.18734915554523468,
-0.2923484146595001,
-0.48693397641181946,
0.13895870745182037,
0.6205390691757202,
0.4888171851634979,
-0.3834001123905182,
-0.20297355949878693,
0.20491203665733337,
0.8393273949623108,
-1.0987448692321777,
0.10663832724094391,
-0.2173682153224945,
0.19156989455223083,
0.21627916395664215,
-0.32649222016334534,
-0.5695508122444153,
-0.6675323843955994,
0.28336209058761597,
-0.7497882843017578,
-0.21863898634910583,
0.29501280188560486,
1.0186700820922852,
0.43000996112823486,
-0.14256258308887482,
0.07369308173656464,
-0.8089283108711243,
1.0795201063156128,
-0.4766201376914978,
0.6441262364387512,
0.49137794971466064,
0.3418829143047333,
-0.36519771814346313,
-0.5683386921882629,
-0.30200740694999695,
-0.2353697121143341,
-0.07576543837785721,
0.5077572464942932,
-0.007534177973866463,
0.2935430705547333,
0.1983499825000763,
0.45718738436698914,
-0.3108433187007904,
0.21612782776355743,
-0.1804104894399643,
-0.27973490953445435,
0.45189177989959717,
-0.08804479986429214,
-0.4835394024848938,
0.25888946652412415,
-0.7614874839782715,
-0.6223167181015015,
-0.4494187533855438,
0.9602378606796265,
0.3516944944858551,
0.03605381026864052,
0.06713232398033142,
0.13460056483745575,
-0.27110984921455383,
0.8005658388137817,
0.3240251839160919,
-0.0967969298362732,
0.29671594500541687,
0.21751944720745087,
-0.3023163676261902,
0.0523882731795311,
0.6340745091438293,
0.5340895056724548,
-0.047195181250572205,
-0.3169191777706146,
-0.5151717066764832,
0.07404915243387222,
0.4114648699760437,
-0.7597683668136597,
-0.6031522750854492,
0.12735243141651154,
-0.438631147146225,
-0.10781852155923843,
0.2815864682197571,
-0.6796972751617432,
-0.42750948667526245,
-0.33190637826919556,
0.45531654357910156,
-0.28779080510139465,
-0.05293860286474228,
0.17126215994358063,
-0.17382384836673737,
0.3217208683490753,
0.4554423689842224,
-0.5134830474853516,
0.31962716579437256,
0.5864822864532471,
0.6407801508903503,
-0.2507110834121704,
-0.13190124928951263,
-1.1345455646514893,
-0.12272828817367554,
-0.39867010712623596,
0.896111011505127,
-0.7030482292175293,
-0.4013112485408783,
-0.10749447345733643,
-0.18544629216194153,
0.2591300308704376,
-0.5629428029060364,
0.3873078227043152,
-0.889623761177063,
-0.00004998440635972656,
-0.36055248975753784,
-0.6238271594047546,
-0.19841326773166656,
0.48397666215896606,
-0.36990588903427124,
0.9421986937522888,
0.08888328075408936,
-0.37159526348114014,
0.8617849349975586,
-0.7764487862586975,
-0.14129449427127838,
-0.12607279419898987,
0.17309270799160004,
-0.5141815543174744,
-0.018594888970255852,
0.3762853145599365,
0.30802708864212036,
0.12891238927841187,
0.2342597246170044,
-0.4732193648815155,
-0.44373559951782227,
0.4969249367713928,
-0.3488113582134247,
0.041771139949560165,
0.16718879342079163,
-0.07191824913024902,
0.5675210356712341,
-0.400552898645401,
0.1851692497730255,
-0.37974387407302856,
-0.6105102896690369,
-0.23791548609733582,
0.1330711394548416,
0.14647728204727173,
0.18422868847846985,
0.31031474471092224,
-0.7530534267425537,
0.20044825971126556,
-0.448956698179245,
0.014949957840144634,
0.9349537491798401,
0.07405923306941986,
0.44733330607414246,
-0.5936799645423889,
0.4713645279407501,
0.05380522832274437,
0.18939785659313202,
0.03695293143391609,
-0.14560934901237488,
-0.5463102459907532,
-0.6032358407974243,
0.5693568587303162,
0.13595528900623322,
-0.5834381580352783,
0.4111620783805847,
-0.04836681857705116,
-0.4206233322620392,
-0.5261428356170654,
0.03512227162718773,
0.8341240286827087,
0.41331401467323303,
0.5796204209327698,
-0.5950794219970703,
-0.2702850103378296,
-0.6996665596961975,
-0.2585945725440979,
-0.11632579565048218,
-0.028192978352308273,
0.41456958651542664,
0.06515705585479736,
0.058180343359708786,
1.1828904151916504,
-0.7194083333015442,
-0.371832937002182,
0.008674997836351395,
0.19510215520858765,
0.025813814252614975,
0.6158088445663452,
0.028303414583206177,
-0.6942798495292664,
-0.4004228711128235,
0.1076311394572258,
-0.4171416759490967,
0.2915315628051758,
-0.004921854007989168,
-0.3255038261413574,
0.2062503546476364,
0.15317374467849731,
0.1515100747346878,
0.3671261668205261,
0.08104391396045685,
-0.40891939401626587,
0.12785984575748444,
-0.7076824307441711,
0.16130904853343964,
-0.2745248079299927,
0.09550225734710693,
0.3442021608352661,
-0.5570611357688904,
-0.43055394291877747,
-0.22436146438121796,
0.2146761417388916,
0.2455546110868454,
-0.3131296634674072,
0.6441300511360168,
-0.36348849534988403,
-0.1670568883419037,
-0.29579097032546997,
-0.19737809896469116,
0.07617753744125366,
0.8545342683792114,
0.5680774450302124,
0.5761486887931824,
0.24281322956085205,
-0.6741153597831726,
0.02002722956240177,
0.18047592043876648,
-0.12668541073799133,
0.4717322587966919,
-0.3528192341327667,
0.2671278715133667,
-0.18591360747814178,
0.46153905987739563,
-0.8558344841003418,
-0.2845803201198578,
0.3827603757381439,
-0.320811927318573,
0.5350521206855774,
-0.17011092603206635,
0.08036160469055176,
0.031132513657212257,
-0.5152300000190735,
0.16182762384414673,
0.8624495267868042,
-0.8807801604270935,
0.26242661476135254,
0.5597805976867676,
0.1873590350151062,
-0.8104560971260071,
-0.031174253672361374,
-0.5277503728866577,
-0.1293286383152008,
-0.10831580311059952,
0.40209582448005676,
0.1525649130344391,
-0.15883895754814148,
-0.16586117446422577,
-0.3352983295917511,
-0.06245598569512367,
0.13445080816745758,
0.3314400017261505,
0.40151265263557434,
0.022426001727581024,
0.0763535425066948,
0.09987658262252808,
-0.28864672780036926,
-0.18888361752033234,
-0.2560228407382965,
0.4654037356376648,
-0.37907713651657104,
-0.14982150495052338,
-0.5016933083534241,
0.13954582810401917,
0.1729068011045456,
-0.41633403301239014,
0.591946005821228,
0.4827190935611725,
-0.08298177272081375,
-0.2513091564178467,
-0.6501244306564331,
-0.2666996419429779,
-0.46740245819091797,
0.13546134531497955,
-0.11800161004066467,
-0.7301545739173889,
0.2688743472099304,
-0.11957548558712006,
0.26524612307548523,
-0.22539031505584717,
0.34959354996681213,
-0.23097392916679382,
0.8089507818222046,
0.3761503994464874,
-0.10301543027162552,
0.7509906888008118,
-0.265115350484848,
-0.034514881670475006,
-0.7903950810432434,
-0.4862688481807709,
-0.033133745193481445,
-0.538469135761261,
-0.44287869334220886,
-0.4560377597808838,
0.5266915559768677,
0.18463416397571564,
-0.5890124440193176,
-0.21496717631816864,
-0.3776867091655731,
0.3597634732723236,
0.7988912463188171,
0.7621868252754211,
0.0768534317612648,
-0.07033732533454895,
0.030457481741905212,
-0.11729732900857925,
-0.6836280226707458,
-0.24550971388816833,
1.0647547245025635,
0.4263065755367279,
0.9022536277770996,
-0.14182931184768677,
0.7965328693389893,
0.4419519603252411,
0.4305696487426758,
-0.7807320356369019,
0.057989731431007385,
0.21666648983955383,
-0.12024547159671783,
-0.3271755576133728,
-0.30843329429626465,
-0.8547115325927734,
0.23388923704624176,
-0.34168100357055664,
-0.6699294447898865,
0.43866220116615295,
0.8268271684646606,
-0.5900679230690002,
0.23378247022628784,
-0.6085844039916992,
0.8048719763755798,
-0.3114442527294159,
-0.8585475087165833,
-0.19277960062026978,
-0.8221557140350342,
-0.007096659857779741,
0.2734101414680481,
-0.06488227844238281,
0.23021544516086578,
-0.1449502557516098,
0.768821656703949,
-0.534530520439148,
0.4295010566711426,
-0.6862591505050659,
0.15339651703834534,
0.04267729073762894,
-0.10853803157806396,
0.7542976140975952,
-0.16938543319702148,
0.09417314827442169,
-0.19119688868522644,
-0.3326336741447449,
-0.5650095343589783,
-0.7184107303619385,
0.6378013491630554,
-0.7784749865531921,
-0.15966640412807465,
-0.49997615814208984,
-0.7225995659828186,
-0.6790739893913269,
-0.16790422797203064,
-0.1294766217470169,
0.3755734860897064,
-0.08212035894393921,
0.10091286897659302,
0.7412319779396057,
-0.25926491618156433,
0.3341841995716095,
0.4856470823287964,
-0.2610618472099304,
-0.38497409224510193,
1.1992300748825073,
-0.10368647426366806,
0.1249055340886116,
0.5573810935020447,
0.27853065729141235,
-0.5779746770858765,
-0.3790675699710846,
-0.270958811044693,
0.11102626472711563,
-0.2865345776081085,
-0.1431875228881836,
-0.4375777244567871,
0.20304901897907257,
0.08577575534582138,
-0.5116996169090271,
-0.47326070070266724,
0.06915735453367233,
0.09265753626823425,
-0.0422971248626709,
0.39151450991630554,
0.5024276375770569,
-0.3473770320415497,
0.5015056133270264,
-0.3468901216983795,
0.2283044457435608,
0.30455172061920166,
0.6151630878448486,
0.01879315823316574,
-0.3692217767238617,
-0.3125499486923218,
0.05494369566440582,
-0.43138229846954346,
-0.5643429160118103,
0.4923977255821228,
0.0238877572119236,
0.558035135269165,
0.7219704985618591,
0.3963238596916199,
0.8631172180175781,
-0.10610117763280869,
0.4312516450881958,
0.2761647403240204,
-0.5643298029899597,
0.3136310279369354,
-0.14577822387218475,
0.058892183005809784,
0.6560313105583191,
0.3817097544670105,
-0.3619944155216217,
-0.04130646586418152,
-0.49955955147743225,
-0.9583785533905029,
0.9148182272911072,
-0.08569043129682541,
-0.48644182085990906,
0.1754416972398758,
0.0032397916074842215,
0.12228778004646301,
0.24937783181667328,
-0.45721185207366943,
-0.3435966372489929,
-0.33239829540252686,
0.17962613701820374,
-0.2775956392288208,
-0.1588892787694931,
0.06926670670509338,
-0.02933385595679283,
0.9874098300933838,
-0.039237137883901596,
0.21339039504528046,
0.30412983894348145,
-0.23237453401088715,
-0.036520011723041534,
0.3156646490097046,
0.3230201303958893,
0.487791508436203,
-0.7170653939247131,
-0.005808877758681774,
-0.06098572537302971,
-0.012134915217757225,
0.22181391716003418,
0.01902838796377182,
0.01740768365561962,
-0.44974735379219055,
-0.2878670394420624,
1.001806616783142,
0.3816114664077759,
-0.7936410307884216,
0.35217392444610596,
0.04933430626988411,
0.031530413776636124,
-0.09746640175580978,
0.15654803812503815,
-0.27826982736587524,
0.5105483531951904,
0.18332894146442413,
0.17056222259998322,
0.24955114722251892,
-0.3125706911087036,
0.35746681690216064,
0.48762446641921997,
-1.066541314125061,
0.04956844449043274,
0.39897421002388,
0.16090315580368042,
-0.18070264160633087,
0.34717872738838196,
-0.27836132049560547,
-0.5274398922920227,
0.3112110197544098,
0.5308260917663574,
0.49730485677719116,
-0.1504978984594345,
0.24378524720668793,
0.37875834107398987,
-0.09948363155126572,
-0.3278455436229706,
0.18254412710666656,
-0.41625186800956726,
-0.7049036622047424,
-0.33935871720314026,
-0.5157029628753662,
-0.5460591316223145,
0.027973279356956482,
-1.0961562395095825,
-0.10981149971485138,
-0.5319098234176636,
-0.14802178740501404,
-0.21336396038532257,
0.02323410101234913,
-0.6133355498313904,
0.13423161208629608,
0.2051987648010254,
0.5733039975166321,
-0.7619577050209045,
0.5958022475242615,
0.9363276362419128,
-0.2320965826511383,
-0.9725085496902466,
-0.04919882491230965,
-0.17787523567676544,
-0.5732381939888,
0.606688916683197,
0.0775117576122284,
-0.413461297750473,
0.032652921974658966,
-0.24895352125167847,
-0.5031741857528687,
0.7928637862205505,
0.08636265248060226,
-0.44915932416915894,
0.1825874149799347,
-0.7115688920021057,
0.3896510899066925,
-0.21286015212535858,
0.6714487075805664,
0.5797730088233948,
0.591757595539093,
0.037099286913871765,
-0.7491964101791382,
-0.09207677841186523,
-0.2511432468891144,
0.09106354415416718,
0.5663110017776489,
-0.6771321296691895,
0.4343612790107727,
-0.10587051510810852,
0.2542800009250641,
-0.4572553038597107,
0.8446055054664612,
0.4508439004421234,
0.38663390278816223,
0.5979703664779663,
0.3270452916622162,
0.9047605991363525,
0.05385719984769821,
1.1028392314910889,
0.028799165040254593,
0.37196633219718933,
1.1303247213363647,
-0.3577008843421936,
0.7955910563468933,
0.6058934330940247,
-0.36980730295181274,
0.4400857388973236,
0.8183102607727051,
0.26518967747688293,
0.8847562074661255,
0.08795204758644104,
-0.14729703962802887,
-0.6988986134529114,
-0.17878903448581696,
-0.23424778878688812,
0.20051325857639313,
0.24801595509052277,
-0.1211032122373581,
-0.1871330589056015,
0.057721059769392014,
0.014278841204941273,
0.16010147333145142,
-0.5855886936187744,
0.9532155394554138,
-0.2723219096660614,
-1.2488212585449219,
0.5114302635192871,
-0.06310378760099411,
0.9070202708244324,
-0.5234673023223877,
-0.25958728790283203,
-0.17387041449546814,
0.5025594830513,
-0.2234739512205124,
-0.5133951306343079,
-0.21871957182884216,
-0.034574199467897415,
-0.19047820568084717,
-0.3244090974330902,
0.5382311344146729,
-0.4798629879951477,
-0.2037527859210968,
0.21976155042648315,
0.41635599732398987,
0.15385563671588898,
0.14068438112735748,
-0.35271409153938293,
-0.32237163186073303,
0.05694494768977165,
-0.364577054977417,
0.7154314517974854,
-0.18881024420261383,
-0.10262677073478699,
0.6287371516227722,
0.6431294083595276,
0.15608154237270355,
0.06030745059251785,
-0.5786471366882324,
0.8625017404556274,
-0.3587019741535187,
-0.843691885471344,
-0.6128522157669067,
0.5356941223144531,
-0.22917531430721283,
-0.2583610415458679,
0.35751208662986755,
0.7804818749427795,
0.9836699366569519,
0.016147561371326447,
0.7133625149726868,
-0.02656293474137783,
0.5614219307899475,
-0.5284331440925598,
0.5453054904937744,
-0.463299959897995,
0.1345462203025818,
-0.1519721895456314,
-0.6450775861740112,
-0.10205485671758652,
0.9313890337944031,
-0.7940212488174438,
0.0021153835114091635,
0.3590341806411743,
0.9183560013771057,
-0.26930853724479675,
-0.15377473831176758,
0.3872947096824646,
-0.14712689816951752,
0.025695355609059334,
0.5739979147911072,
0.9342246651649475,
-0.006249156314879656,
0.20334245264530182,
-0.440228134393692,
-0.46499669551849365,
-0.38571494817733765,
-0.8102273941040039,
-0.6884138584136963,
-0.22688144445419312,
-0.3142208755016327,
-0.5081713199615479,
0.3665948510169983,
1.4747381210327148,
0.7988612651824951,
-0.8278468251228333,
-0.4638174772262573,
0.19842475652694702,
0.200982466340065,
-0.7341228723526001,
-0.16291898488998413,
0.4586636424064636,
-0.531356155872345,
-0.5010722279548645,
0.46453094482421875,
0.1755148470401764,
-0.4716261327266693,
0.026705745607614517,
-0.7275781035423279,
-0.16174590587615967,
-0.2000563144683838,
0.18857212364673615,
0.5042296648025513,
-0.6640335321426392,
-0.3258819580078125,
-0.21678394079208374,
0.288778156042099,
0.5561603903770447,
0.8820682168006897,
-1.2022236585617065,
0.803043007850647,
0.3103512227535248,
0.707218587398529,
0.7581787109375,
0.33181092143058777,
0.682732880115509,
-0.5469055771827698,
0.1264290064573288,
0.14525188505649567,
0.31164854764938354,
0.21826289594173431,
-0.19346854090690613,
0.25767195224761963,
-0.11946039646863937,
-0.762932300567627,
-0.887201189994812,
0.237229585647583,
-1.0990846157073975,
-0.002959029981866479,
0.9382261633872986,
-0.6116638779640198,
-0.19938813149929047,
-0.18373051285743713,
-0.2097460925579071,
0.33127206563949585,
-1.076943039894104,
0.6492910385131836,
0.07564182579517365,
-0.448771595954895,
-0.15882925689220428,
-0.06997328996658325,
0.6477799415588379,
0.36820539832115173,
-0.5794745087623596,
-0.059108566492795944,
0.7562885880470276,
0.09034117311239243,
-0.1093163713812828,
0.5495129227638245,
0.22785276174545288,
0.4878331422805786,
-0.20825731754302979,
0.23798605799674988,
-0.5270113348960876,
-0.44297242164611816,
-0.437465101480484,
0.26671937108039856,
0.39088496565818787,
-0.43787774443626404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18682v1
|
Can GPT Redefine Medical Understanding? Evaluating GPT on Biomedical Machine Reading Comprehension
| 2024-05-29T01:12:53 | 2024-05-29T01:12:53 |
Shubham Vatsal, Ayush Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance on many tasks
in different domains. However, their performance in closed-book biomedical
machine reading comprehension (MRC) has not been evaluated in depth. In this
work, we evaluate GPT on four closed-book biomedical MRC benchmarks. We
experiment with different conventional prompting techniques as well as
introduce our own novel prompting method. To solve some of the retrieval
problems inherent to LLMs, we propose a prompting strategy named Implicit
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) that alleviates the need for using vector
databases to retrieve important chunks in traditional RAG setups. Moreover, we
report qualitative assessments on the natural language generation outputs from
our approach. The results show that our new prompting technique is able to get
the best performance in two out of four datasets and ranks second in rest of
them. Experiments show that modern-day LLMs like GPT even in a zero-shot
setting can outperform supervised models, leading to new state-of-the-art
(SoTA) results on two of the benchmarks.
|
[
-0.27591028809547424,
-0.9120732545852661,
0.9578465223312378,
-0.23703058063983917,
-0.4420028626918793,
0.018763527274131775,
-0.09767414629459381,
-0.4891913831233978,
-0.2482381910085678,
0.17378343641757965,
-0.7427679300308228,
-0.49744686484336853,
-0.6336134076118469,
0.611804723739624,
-0.17442460358142853,
1.211956262588501,
-0.07588125020265579,
0.2571221888065338,
-0.44304269552230835,
-0.21019347012043,
-0.523601770401001,
-0.3293895423412323,
-0.9051237106323242,
-0.6980215907096863,
0.8680874705314636,
0.05010268837213516,
0.5375415682792664,
0.606796383857727,
0.3679969310760498,
0.20360083878040314,
-0.4029659032821655,
0.27504822611808777,
-0.4617088735103607,
0.2514221966266632,
-0.15455347299575806,
-0.40375542640686035,
-0.24265137314796448,
-0.04728326201438904,
0.6205309629440308,
0.8199560642242432,
-0.06928311288356781,
-0.07802438735961914,
0.22593028843402863,
1.0293105840682983,
-0.4112992286682129,
0.04075988754630089,
-0.5020146369934082,
-0.0021062439773231745,
0.16378438472747803,
-0.5596821308135986,
-0.6581346392631531,
-0.3006609082221985,
0.2279549092054367,
-0.6370835900306702,
0.5582091808319092,
0.013554778881371021,
0.8469263911247253,
0.49808740615844727,
-0.47405144572257996,
-0.428346186876297,
-0.4700823128223419,
0.39882490038871765,
-0.4084937274456024,
0.5691006779670715,
0.4225754141807556,
0.26131415367126465,
-0.17579831182956696,
-0.782004714012146,
-0.4571918249130249,
-0.6051644086837769,
-0.18379677832126617,
0.410250723361969,
-0.03981359302997589,
-0.034082986414432526,
0.39352819323539734,
0.21457087993621826,
-0.7130513787269592,
-0.1826281100511551,
-0.5078485012054443,
0.08458484709262848,
0.1453179121017456,
0.0029422612860798836,
0.2450234591960907,
-0.19840644299983978,
-0.40404313802719116,
0.033570919185876846,
-0.9579780101776123,
-0.12145175784826279,
-0.008481055498123169,
0.1073894128203392,
0.15135575830936432,
0.5723876953125,
-0.09936021268367767,
0.6600090265274048,
0.1267208755016327,
-0.00921628624200821,
0.09511960297822952,
-0.3945465683937073,
-0.33021703362464905,
-0.1388290524482727,
0.5710241794586182,
0.20920626819133759,
0.48160502314567566,
-0.2520594596862793,
-0.06450831145048141,
-0.14161552488803864,
0.47263303399086,
-0.7666551470756531,
-0.19054721295833588,
0.3212549090385437,
-0.34544897079467773,
-0.16937284171581268,
-0.08988028764724731,
-0.5840703845024109,
-0.5165068507194519,
-0.4488597810268402,
0.4821215271949768,
-0.6823083162307739,
-0.05392282456159592,
0.25704464316368103,
-0.2162109762430191,
0.4230194091796875,
0.2555166184902191,
-0.9382105469703674,
0.10138864815235138,
0.72871994972229,
0.9406542778015137,
-0.09409219026565552,
0.013079199939966202,
-0.4967876672744751,
0.2157917469739914,
-0.2912653982639313,
1.0831928253173828,
-0.41224542260169983,
-0.7050620317459106,
-0.18647746741771698,
-0.06928431987762451,
-0.28512611985206604,
-0.5929035544395447,
0.45409977436065674,
-0.5232027769088745,
0.35929837822914124,
-0.39467403292655945,
-0.4288322925567627,
-0.06714373081922531,
0.346787691116333,
-0.35919758677482605,
0.8515116572380066,
0.053693853318691254,
-0.7667490839958191,
0.6077812910079956,
-0.7722390294075012,
-0.49223774671554565,
0.17838750779628754,
-0.2939010262489319,
-0.4487476944923401,
0.049364689737558365,
0.7507672309875488,
0.444553941488266,
-0.1484033465385437,
0.2535785138607025,
-0.03742969036102295,
-0.37147045135498047,
0.30876490473747253,
-0.4961954951286316,
0.5472568273544312,
0.12524577975273132,
-0.29784759879112244,
0.120024174451828,
-0.3319857716560364,
0.1594463288784027,
0.13714899122714996,
-0.16939392685890198,
-0.2132069319486618,
-0.23049964010715485,
-0.5148221254348755,
-0.08334323018789291,
-0.1726841926574707,
-0.44755926728248596,
0.4530218541622162,
-0.49291402101516724,
0.5287370085716248,
0.7381336688995361,
0.3423584997653961,
0.2049677073955536,
-0.39757081866264343,
0.6215913891792297,
-0.3844037353992462,
0.0791354700922966,
-0.4111871123313904,
-0.5861745476722717,
-0.3721531331539154,
-0.5635600686073303,
0.26893702149391174,
0.5574130415916443,
-0.9273028373718262,
-0.07844956964254379,
-0.12141241133213043,
-0.24335400760173798,
-0.8197519779205322,
-0.15864919126033783,
0.47272786498069763,
1.0651321411132812,
0.6239333748817444,
-0.04043005406856537,
-0.08838405460119247,
-0.6706729531288147,
-0.35782819986343384,
-0.26292306184768677,
-0.4509398639202118,
0.763839602470398,
0.30467352271080017,
-0.44949066638946533,
0.6714439988136292,
-0.451598197221756,
-0.007824365980923176,
-0.16241493821144104,
0.2966103255748749,
0.29151320457458496,
0.25585320591926575,
0.17770296335220337,
-0.568788468837738,
-0.3827742040157318,
0.197942316532135,
-0.8347729444503784,
-0.3097034692764282,
-0.164336696267128,
-0.06867442280054092,
0.2774580121040344,
0.6250126361846924,
-0.572303831577301,
0.42481929063796997,
0.3824536204338074,
-0.3077434301376343,
0.6481599807739258,
-0.5263298749923706,
0.46366751194000244,
-0.8013303875923157,
0.33523327112197876,
-0.2003260850906372,
-0.30138811469078064,
-0.5187317132949829,
-0.04833218455314636,
0.2239086627960205,
0.07521993666887283,
-0.3512537479400635,
0.7610000967979431,
-0.6880865693092346,
0.04534434154629707,
-0.36670204997062683,
0.005419340915977955,
0.017576687037944794,
0.061270080506801605,
-0.07542566955089569,
1.0228941440582275,
0.3837968111038208,
-0.6935451030731201,
0.0505811907351017,
0.5067539215087891,
-0.07117383182048798,
0.5375658273696899,
-1.0109020471572876,
0.47993242740631104,
-0.5989141464233398,
0.46861276030540466,
-1.0871028900146484,
-0.21967841684818268,
0.36224108934402466,
-0.6768224239349365,
0.6436868906021118,
-0.4505002498626709,
-0.2929205596446991,
-0.3935595154762268,
-0.03007013536989689,
0.20106539130210876,
0.770783007144928,
-0.667309582233429,
0.3294626772403717,
-0.09770405292510986,
-0.517845869064331,
-0.6523622274398804,
-0.5015148520469666,
0.09574195742607117,
-0.059914831072092056,
-0.5810517072677612,
0.12599028646945953,
-0.07425856590270996,
0.058812521398067474,
-0.1925872564315796,
-0.2417396456003189,
0.1207103580236435,
-0.12099085748195648,
0.09540338814258575,
0.5779479742050171,
-0.1436232179403305,
0.3222709000110626,
0.24850095808506012,
-0.34655115008354187,
-0.11146768182516098,
-0.34153592586517334,
0.27374058961868286,
-0.014436992816627026,
-0.4858863353729248,
-0.384283185005188,
0.2983510196208954,
0.17653225362300873,
-0.23940959572792053,
0.6370237469673157,
0.6391655802726746,
-0.14898160099983215,
-0.08558591455221176,
-0.3829893171787262,
-0.5792607069015503,
-0.5182481408119202,
0.1954769641160965,
-0.46222418546676636,
-1.1119508743286133,
0.0853259488940239,
-0.1810908317565918,
0.007248695008456707,
0.27699747681617737,
0.7865755558013916,
-0.30436795949935913,
1.1568163633346558,
0.42821916937828064,
0.2741650640964508,
0.30803677439689636,
0.0010031366255134344,
-0.11852151900529861,
-0.8874582648277283,
-0.10375985503196716,
-0.5267924666404724,
-0.17364810407161713,
-0.4056720733642578,
-0.4548071622848511,
0.7854665517807007,
0.149083212018013,
-0.09473132342100143,
-0.260904461145401,
-0.779056966304779,
0.675719678401947,
0.33626076579093933,
0.3535446524620056,
0.44307637214660645,
0.13871285319328308,
-0.5738516449928284,
0.08143625408411026,
-0.6261998414993286,
-0.6832733750343323,
1.1743943691253662,
0.3338262438774109,
0.5440435409545898,
-0.118134044110775,
0.7031697630882263,
0.003540047211572528,
0.8826227188110352,
-0.9276703596115112,
0.373789519071579,
0.09019413590431213,
-0.5769703984260559,
-0.267882764339447,
-0.5206809639930725,
-1.4397464990615845,
0.2478020191192627,
-0.07329446822404861,
-0.5585246086120605,
-0.10913479328155518,
0.2258618324995041,
-0.3971494138240814,
0.055036094039678574,
-0.7882007956504822,
0.6018232107162476,
0.024876993149518967,
-0.3377147316932678,
0.11873500794172287,
-0.6422896981239319,
0.2885143756866455,
0.05770507827401161,
0.022045103833079338,
0.006876736413687468,
-0.3472532629966736,
0.33796247839927673,
-0.14415639638900757,
0.5940675139427185,
-0.22967910766601562,
0.04086849465966225,
0.08926437795162201,
0.057251185178756714,
0.5298097133636475,
0.23932290077209473,
-0.09516455233097076,
-0.03539245203137398,
0.1509445458650589,
-0.48147180676460266,
-0.6851036548614502,
0.5103151798248291,
-0.3651147782802582,
-0.698788583278656,
-0.4569392204284668,
-0.4607643783092499,
-0.5583295226097107,
0.22545969486236572,
0.39466625452041626,
0.32299351692199707,
-0.13999365270137787,
0.03170806169509888,
0.8748673796653748,
-0.3920825719833374,
-0.014859754592180252,
0.7416254281997681,
0.05470260977745056,
-0.3170148730278015,
0.5892370939254761,
-0.19701044261455536,
0.32719188928604126,
0.18485017120838165,
0.44382575154304504,
-0.5492848753929138,
-0.903082013130188,
-0.6244064569473267,
0.6420326232910156,
-0.48668360710144043,
-0.07685381919145584,
-0.7058515548706055,
-0.12125235795974731,
-0.41086453199386597,
-0.1141209527850151,
0.19315028190612793,
0.0056587099097669125,
-0.22486412525177002,
-0.2303355634212494,
0.5303672552108765,
1.0910083055496216,
-0.023848047479987144,
0.024275492876768112,
-1.005263090133667,
0.547291100025177,
0.1385842263698578,
0.442318320274353,
-0.25006791949272156,
-0.618499755859375,
0.01445065438747406,
-0.19263088703155518,
-0.2110336422920227,
-0.9368383288383484,
0.38734251260757446,
-0.03457402437925339,
0.5703601241111755,
0.14779707789421082,
-0.18236948549747467,
0.6114950776100159,
-1.0192323923110962,
0.5546396374702454,
-0.118613600730896,
-0.4954291880130768,
0.46826261281967163,
-0.5554925203323364,
0.42988383769989014,
0.5345857739448547,
0.5352529287338257,
-0.6143248081207275,
-0.41037166118621826,
-0.6220187544822693,
-0.772540807723999,
0.3574773669242859,
0.030841346830129623,
-0.11668428033590317,
-0.12987934052944183,
0.7975359559059143,
0.24430514872074127,
0.06517411768436432,
-0.25074338912963867,
-0.15849673748016357,
0.17277465760707855,
-0.2912428379058838,
-0.19535788893699646,
-0.14835377037525177,
-0.17677323520183563,
-0.1876336634159088,
0.5022199749946594,
-0.3227449953556061,
0.5200233459472656,
0.7867662906646729,
0.11302077025175095,
-0.05384409427642822,
0.41450372338294983,
0.6373277306556702,
0.6870995759963989,
-0.10876518487930298,
-0.1228235512971878,
0.17812654376029968,
-0.665599524974823,
0.1051006019115448,
0.2503633201122284,
-0.2639719545841217,
-0.052286453545093536,
0.3716224133968353,
0.5829281210899353,
-0.13985343277454376,
-0.5394334197044373,
0.0623156800866127,
-0.10695034265518188,
-0.5099350214004517,
0.3057786524295807,
0.03388846293091774,
0.08643563836812973,
0.18011659383773804,
0.38529154658317566,
-0.23418283462524414,
0.12581954896450043,
-0.17325998842716217,
0.5748452544212341,
0.4782172739505768,
-0.48798826336860657,
-0.019314534962177277,
0.7946626543998718,
-0.12443249672651291,
-0.0016100135399028659,
0.5753143429756165,
0.050308577716350555,
-0.30271419882774353,
0.321982204914093,
0.6278750896453857,
0.820801317691803,
-0.13651934266090393,
0.268692284822464,
0.49016255140304565,
0.46356549859046936,
-0.05224718526005745,
0.32154831290245056,
-0.05198359489440918,
-0.3785855770111084,
-0.839625895023346,
-0.4763011038303375,
-0.6976248621940613,
0.08661101758480072,
-0.5959739685058594,
-0.06396207213401794,
-0.2959855794906616,
-0.07517342269420624,
0.20073437690734863,
-0.0970199853181839,
-0.49145111441612244,
0.14283056557178497,
-0.006824468728154898,
0.8842632174491882,
-0.4642885625362396,
0.7602134346961975,
0.6800358891487122,
-0.3217933177947998,
-0.8075207471847534,
0.07512418180704117,
0.02542509138584137,
-0.9828681945800781,
0.47306978702545166,
0.10306578874588013,
0.0003442603338044137,
0.13744202256202698,
-0.6600890755653381,
-0.43725308775901794,
0.9506927132606506,
0.2704733610153198,
-0.3793984651565552,
-0.046478960663080215,
-0.062019795179367065,
0.653475821018219,
0.019572993740439415,
0.33565130829811096,
0.6790370941162109,
0.6526076793670654,
0.26704704761505127,
-0.8766171336174011,
0.0941779613494873,
-0.05525670200586319,
-0.31806614995002747,
0.18336264789104462,
-0.22458957135677338,
0.5873669385910034,
-0.5571511387825012,
-0.4190003573894501,
0.23244798183441162,
0.34880974888801575,
0.5881505012512207,
0.579901397228241,
0.379059761762619,
0.2733169496059418,
1.1338200569152832,
-0.08516217023134232,
1.4971120357513428,
0.2247898429632187,
0.10595578700304031,
0.9063298106193542,
-0.2233613282442093,
0.7889685034751892,
0.49764785170555115,
-0.294009804725647,
0.21377228200435638,
0.5677345395088196,
0.20090351998806,
0.3373303711414337,
0.24665045738220215,
-0.4596115052700043,
-0.03974883630871773,
0.049502842128276825,
-0.5178792476654053,
-0.2120978981256485,
0.39210352301597595,
-0.3911454677581787,
-0.13951535522937775,
0.13393647968769073,
0.033795930445194244,
0.10542213916778564,
-0.27982667088508606,
1.0966771841049194,
0.29178205132484436,
-0.6877455711364746,
1.1021180152893066,
-0.370742529630661,
0.38146305084228516,
-0.6545455455780029,
-0.12477798759937286,
-0.2408878356218338,
0.06683242321014404,
-0.09537675976753235,
-0.8532676100730896,
0.2017247974872589,
0.149180606007576,
-0.22449150681495667,
-0.3364758789539337,
0.7982829213142395,
-0.3880385756492615,
-0.31059128046035767,
-0.05335015803575516,
0.7270421981811523,
0.3086884617805481,
-0.13515938818454742,
-0.8411003351211548,
-0.10039438307285309,
0.07011742889881134,
-0.3513214588165283,
0.39339929819107056,
0.6314008235931396,
0.04303005710244179,
0.7730242609977722,
1.0168850421905518,
0.2013351023197174,
-0.15157723426818848,
0.1875809282064438,
0.7438139319419861,
-0.7882352471351624,
-0.14828969538211823,
-0.7771656513214111,
0.29719871282577515,
0.20040129125118256,
-0.016741527244448662,
0.5524120330810547,
0.1558253914117813,
0.4852226674556732,
-0.11259863525629044,
0.7459549903869629,
0.3862553834915161,
0.9907255172729492,
-0.6750136613845825,
0.8671321272850037,
-0.5237036347389221,
0.08610297739505768,
-0.09272301197052002,
-0.47663941979408264,
-0.4711761176586151,
0.47880321741104126,
-0.4521247446537018,
0.29962068796157837,
0.9375655651092529,
0.8567314743995667,
0.17072610557079315,
0.1636231392621994,
0.4255034029483795,
0.3498660624027252,
0.4301486313343048,
0.3657587170600891,
0.8815436959266663,
-0.16561102867126465,
0.5143954753875732,
0.297736257314682,
-0.4891816973686218,
0.0332455188035965,
-0.929142415523529,
-0.9446394443511963,
-0.28106045722961426,
-0.1268603652715683,
-0.6558344960212708,
0.4855405390262604,
0.5700082182884216,
0.38216009736061096,
-0.5673754811286926,
0.37873974442481995,
-0.11678576469421387,
0.057197026908397675,
-0.27400368452072144,
-0.15523429214954376,
0.49316540360450745,
-0.5806404948234558,
-0.8073425889015198,
0.6735891699790955,
0.31996944546699524,
0.25678083300590515,
0.041915688663721085,
0.02249138243496418,
-0.047706492245197296,
-0.02844555862247944,
0.5607643127441406,
0.47859248518943787,
-0.5311071276664734,
-0.06888867914676666,
0.17289990186691284,
-0.30779939889907837,
0.11346742510795593,
0.8846904039382935,
-1.201285481452942,
0.4617290794849396,
0.41573330760002136,
0.9012976288795471,
0.51028972864151,
0.2823053002357483,
0.6629775762557983,
-0.5972064733505249,
-0.0157870315015316,
0.43279722332954407,
0.10516953468322754,
0.29318058490753174,
-0.39639201760292053,
0.6137005090713501,
0.14703543484210968,
-0.8491150140762329,
-0.7947478890419006,
0.11963947862386703,
-0.8382694125175476,
-0.2923188805580139,
1.2773544788360596,
0.18407504260540009,
-0.3971778154373169,
-0.3599027991294861,
-0.6802281141281128,
0.18801634013652802,
-0.3610321283340454,
0.6530094742774963,
0.4703631103038788,
-0.28445160388946533,
-0.06401121616363525,
-0.9758345484733582,
0.6247162818908691,
0.765750527381897,
-0.7474726438522339,
0.1442074030637741,
0.43458378314971924,
0.3649778366088867,
-0.3567861020565033,
0.8986702561378479,
-0.3849427103996277,
0.36334678530693054,
-0.2948461174964905,
-0.21344609558582306,
-0.27770760655403137,
-0.19243493676185608,
-0.5560585856437683,
-0.0739547610282898,
-0.051629580557346344,
0.0730697363615036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18672v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18672v2
|
LLM-based Hierarchical Concept Decomposition for Interpretable Fine-Grained Image Classification
| 2024-05-29T00:36:56 | 2024-06-02T23:30:46 |
Renyi Qu, Mark Yatskar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
(Renyi Qu's Master's Thesis) Recent advancements in interpretable models for
vision-language tasks have achieved competitive performance; however, their
interpretability often suffers due to the reliance on unstructured text outputs
from large language models (LLMs). This introduces randomness and compromises
both transparency and reliability, which are essential for addressing safety
issues in AI systems. We introduce \texttt{Hi-CoDe} (Hierarchical Concept
Decomposition), a novel framework designed to enhance model interpretability
through structured concept analysis. Our approach consists of two main
components: (1) We use GPT-4 to decompose an input image into a structured
hierarchy of visual concepts, thereby forming a visual concept tree. (2) We
then employ an ensemble of simple linear classifiers that operate on
concept-specific features derived from CLIP to perform classification. Our
approach not only aligns with the performance of state-of-the-art models but
also advances transparency by providing clear insights into the decision-making
process and highlighting the importance of various concepts. This allows for a
detailed analysis of potential failure modes and improves model compactness,
therefore setting a new benchmark in interpretability without compromising the
accuracy.
|
[
-0.09650222212076187,
-0.8411069512367249,
0.49445927143096924,
-0.04136643558740616,
-0.4139258861541748,
0.11493729054927826,
0.00795618537813425,
-0.6457312107086182,
-0.21071067452430725,
0.44848260283470154,
-0.22310800850391388,
-0.7218882441520691,
-0.5100666284561157,
-0.26695889234542847,
-0.5390373468399048,
0.9159359931945801,
-0.20418372750282288,
-0.2129267156124115,
-0.250260591506958,
0.07853478193283081,
-0.21831530332565308,
-0.48592785000801086,
-0.6299248337745667,
-0.3492361903190613,
0.1633479744195938,
0.2340492308139801,
0.7621204853057861,
0.961735188961029,
0.9180620908737183,
0.37150147557258606,
-0.1676095724105835,
0.07298365235328674,
-0.4508623480796814,
-0.12898984551429749,
-0.01600274257361889,
-0.5111963152885437,
-0.6312533020973206,
-0.11191757023334503,
0.5842081904411316,
0.5402842164039612,
-0.21373330056667328,
0.12528693675994873,
0.4262106716632843,
0.40492117404937744,
-0.6592466831207275,
0.744012713432312,
-0.6332203149795532,
0.29106682538986206,
-0.10484307259321213,
-0.5505868196487427,
-0.3734648525714874,
-0.09599990397691727,
0.07093222439289093,
-0.6668766736984253,
0.18697035312652588,
-0.006944806315004826,
1.0839189291000366,
0.537011981010437,
0.06545580178499222,
-0.04732528701424599,
-0.7344458699226379,
0.7664099335670471,
-0.3685784637928009,
0.1012607216835022,
0.19333197176456451,
0.46964550018310547,
-0.07831753045320511,
-0.8210942149162292,
-0.45253708958625793,
0.01621016301214695,
0.06896515935659409,
0.20513416826725006,
-0.0267059113830328,
0.35179632902145386,
-0.09224404394626617,
0.5708740949630737,
-0.3300492465496063,
0.246684730052948,
-0.28812968730926514,
-0.32093650102615356,
0.33719146251678467,
0.2911301255226135,
0.39869946241378784,
-0.3329778015613556,
-0.5334421396255493,
0.12153954803943634,
-0.38045987486839294,
-0.060898683965206146,
-0.11915551126003265,
0.08061636239290237,
-0.2710984945297241,
0.3696826696395874,
-0.3584934175014496,
0.34941813349723816,
-0.0811799094080925,
-0.47297969460487366,
0.1465727984905243,
-0.27575069665908813,
-0.553459882736206,
-0.1724502444267273,
0.6711402535438538,
0.5938838124275208,
0.30845630168914795,
0.02850271761417389,
-0.22213894128799438,
0.4045366048812866,
0.12233863025903702,
-1.03682541847229,
-0.41240373253822327,
0.025079695507884026,
-0.8689573407173157,
-0.7322222590446472,
0.02238098904490471,
-0.7342033982276917,
-0.22900550067424774,
-0.10275570303201675,
0.3765937089920044,
-0.2719724774360657,
-0.02472829259932041,
0.20291173458099365,
0.036704130470752716,
0.35204747319221497,
0.5817660093307495,
-0.7332134246826172,
0.23455330729484558,
0.6651736497879028,
1.070911169052124,
-0.29894936084747314,
-0.18677258491516113,
-0.3428047001361847,
0.2805230915546417,
-0.417911559343338,
0.7983683347702026,
-0.591703474521637,
-0.23183578252792358,
-0.19776999950408936,
-0.1311579793691635,
0.05805281177163124,
-0.6990662813186646,
0.4604297876358032,
-0.43030643463134766,
-0.19589483737945557,
0.38325411081314087,
-0.348187655210495,
-0.1711951196193695,
0.47527140378952026,
-0.354478120803833,
0.8413747549057007,
0.10883983969688416,
-0.9133936166763306,
0.2585607171058655,
-0.6761603951454163,
-0.16965843737125397,
0.30621659755706787,
-0.6044095158576965,
-0.5502216815948486,
0.06618133187294006,
0.08041983097791672,
0.7856670022010803,
-0.23041503131389618,
0.3233341872692108,
-0.4868822693824768,
-0.4060479402542114,
0.01738557778298855,
-0.5226849913597107,
0.29766845703125,
0.3317025601863861,
-0.0835709273815155,
0.32196715474128723,
-0.9372043609619141,
0.08169569820165634,
0.296172559261322,
-0.26888522505760193,
-0.35824054479599,
0.10602335631847382,
0.18878382444381714,
0.08283260464668274,
0.2668912708759308,
-0.405629962682724,
0.06496284157037735,
-0.28442710638046265,
0.4777047634124756,
0.8632086515426636,
0.09435740113258362,
0.4226849377155304,
0.035481009632349014,
0.4301360547542572,
0.337517648935318,
0.3196859657764435,
-0.3528117835521698,
-0.44571539759635925,
-0.6785135269165039,
-0.3782374858856201,
0.1556510329246521,
0.4908870756626129,
-0.9971199631690979,
0.39833033084869385,
-0.20905020833015442,
-0.21537868678569794,
-0.22835494577884674,
-0.22406113147735596,
0.39262327551841736,
0.756338357925415,
0.28537440299987793,
-0.5532511472702026,
-0.360219806432724,
-0.9152433276176453,
0.19396847486495972,
-0.2646194398403168,
-0.02447563223540783,
0.10920358449220657,
0.655519425868988,
-0.5730748772621155,
0.7299097180366516,
-0.8805034756660461,
-0.3675222396850586,
-0.06409180164337158,
0.3074696660041809,
-0.12105689942836761,
0.6690931916236877,
0.2925478219985962,
-0.762150228023529,
-0.1275157928466797,
0.368871808052063,
-0.9347662329673767,
0.19175028800964355,
-0.15322788059711456,
-0.1233474537730217,
0.03682614490389824,
0.5812730193138123,
-0.3271622061729431,
0.800463080406189,
0.2647560238838196,
-0.17127972841262817,
0.670264720916748,
-0.20374107360839844,
0.0672697052359581,
-0.9288558959960938,
-0.13529382646083832,
0.200550377368927,
-0.08683786541223526,
-0.5023994445800781,
0.5096160769462585,
-0.12945285439491272,
-0.06312771141529083,
-0.43215450644493103,
0.34168168902397156,
-0.12059778720140457,
-0.42058128118515015,
-0.3859913647174835,
-0.23639421164989471,
-0.07403326779603958,
0.550990104675293,
0.19642922282218933,
0.5892242789268494,
0.874577522277832,
-0.5586861968040466,
0.1484227478504181,
0.2710149884223938,
-0.5721388459205627,
0.6083436012268066,
-0.7130099534988403,
-0.09805065393447876,
-0.1048656776547432,
0.14334052801132202,
-0.7239555716514587,
-0.5453346371650696,
0.4280139207839966,
-0.25991329550743103,
0.32348406314849854,
-0.3387841284275055,
-0.48424601554870605,
-0.12220713496208191,
-0.3425604999065399,
0.5215792059898376,
0.46202167868614197,
-0.5228868722915649,
0.35519054532051086,
0.4241129755973816,
-0.08326157927513123,
-0.44935184717178345,
-0.7661988735198975,
0.051102589815855026,
-0.2883363664150238,
-0.43886426091194153,
0.429688960313797,
-0.06364671885967255,
-0.132817342877388,
0.24991634488105774,
-0.3536373972892761,
-0.45022493600845337,
0.32188281416893005,
0.4533522129058838,
0.43171533942222595,
-0.2324231117963791,
-0.16132929921150208,
-0.02119201049208641,
-0.31993451714515686,
-0.0059892269782722,
-0.2635522186756134,
0.4021470844745636,
-0.6136157512664795,
-0.16611045598983765,
-0.8504421710968018,
0.1509150117635727,
0.6143725514411926,
-0.26967209577560425,
0.39454659819602966,
0.8274436593055725,
-0.5025486946105957,
-0.2812337875366211,
0.10627003759145737,
0.09360165894031525,
-0.5151622295379639,
0.5872604846954346,
-0.4678150713443756,
-0.8725324869155884,
0.5029505491256714,
-0.2748876214027405,
-0.24827741086483002,
0.4447818100452423,
0.645258367061615,
-0.5078637599945068,
0.840413510799408,
0.9779067635536194,
-0.03039487637579441,
0.5901817679405212,
-0.5310168862342834,
0.07244601100683212,
-0.6974235773086548,
-0.4255012273788452,
-0.36080512404441833,
-0.11339917033910751,
-0.7229363322257996,
-0.6082367300987244,
0.50369793176651,
0.15266995131969452,
-0.18905632197856903,
-0.21884949505329132,
-0.6726115942001343,
0.6296308636665344,
0.237228125333786,
0.1764099895954132,
0.4801887273788452,
0.16707932949066162,
0.04782147333025932,
0.2514137625694275,
-0.6231552958488464,
-0.6237961053848267,
0.7617433071136475,
0.7887436151504517,
1.0861574411392212,
-0.45142191648483276,
0.9135714769363403,
0.1840873509645462,
0.24546952545642853,
-1.2528691291809082,
0.5980968475341797,
-0.1898999661207199,
-0.22797483205795288,
-0.256986141204834,
-0.6403226256370544,
-0.8107894062995911,
0.34001636505126953,
-0.08005783706903458,
-0.7859697937965393,
0.2095712572336197,
0.26432931423187256,
-0.3934915065765381,
0.4169727861881256,
-0.6632718443870544,
0.8760840892791748,
-0.029990924522280693,
-0.07417581975460052,
-0.33872607350349426,
-0.49372023344039917,
0.6279093623161316,
-0.0893663838505745,
0.24884244799613953,
-0.1014171615242958,
0.04174782335758209,
0.7595009803771973,
-0.3407374620437622,
0.9236673712730408,
-0.17367339134216309,
-0.15546873211860657,
0.27023234963417053,
0.03777141869068146,
0.217377170920372,
0.0031693647615611553,
0.252187579870224,
0.39881667494773865,
0.2418583333492279,
-0.2824999690055847,
-0.7055974006652832,
0.3890153765678406,
-0.7645013928413391,
-0.25925391912460327,
-0.3490442633628845,
-0.6217883229255676,
0.01594615913927555,
0.26748377084732056,
0.23269498348236084,
0.6392854452133179,
-0.0989374965429306,
0.19463950395584106,
0.45650067925453186,
-0.29485443234443665,
0.3269679546356201,
-0.11652493476867676,
-0.2529655396938324,
-0.148504376411438,
0.9850956797599792,
0.009948242455720901,
0.1646367758512497,
0.4457213282585144,
0.1244901791214943,
0.07136672735214233,
-1.1796040534973145,
-0.1334066390991211,
-0.22835399210453033,
-0.8385064005851746,
-0.30882754921913147,
-0.25345319509506226,
-0.4804147779941559,
0.22502166032791138,
-0.1428004950284958,
-0.3429519832134247,
-0.3530053198337555,
-0.26175132393836975,
0.06909099966287613,
-0.2228448987007141,
0.8016249537467957,
0.17591173946857452,
0.4434678256511688,
-0.6966584920883179,
0.7573109269142151,
0.27554434537887573,
0.6716597080230713,
-0.05636496841907501,
-0.3869648575782776,
-0.5174347758293152,
-0.2104366272687912,
-0.3576526343822479,
-0.3839244842529297,
0.201467365026474,
0.17055507004261017,
0.39818865060806274,
0.4658140242099762,
-0.02966974675655365,
0.9074275493621826,
-0.34332725405693054,
0.45855557918548584,
0.3817594051361084,
-0.9449841380119324,
0.6456190347671509,
-0.31089872121810913,
0.1436087042093277,
0.34415364265441895,
0.05300261452794075,
-0.21334952116012573,
-0.39071494340896606,
-0.504615068435669,
-0.8429592251777649,
0.739901602268219,
0.20338456332683563,
-0.22082078456878662,
0.24032917618751526,
0.38721996545791626,
-0.0482751727104187,
-0.07440207153558731,
-0.6290237903594971,
-0.13408032059669495,
-0.2780752182006836,
-0.4148387908935547,
0.1314263939857483,
-0.33564502000808716,
-0.06820067018270493,
-0.2931693494319916,
0.28614166378974915,
-0.5296329259872437,
0.4219338595867157,
0.12003076821565628,
-0.21104033291339874,
-0.11985056847333908,
0.2889278829097748,
0.23679958283901215,
0.532379150390625,
-0.40933626890182495,
0.29990923404693604,
-0.1632837951183319,
-0.6058046221733093,
0.04243006184697151,
-0.1329665333032608,
-0.41831162571907043,
-0.39225372672080994,
0.5828570127487183,
0.6219460964202881,
0.17308875918388367,
-0.45905745029449463,
0.2579926550388336,
-0.12277942895889282,
-0.22919496893882751,
0.05129385367035866,
0.24281281232833862,
-0.2984845042228699,
0.2679712176322937,
0.3292906582355499,
0.6452664732933044,
0.5031788945198059,
-0.8395605683326721,
0.4174234867095947,
0.2874685525894165,
-0.24579203128814697,
-0.39367297291755676,
0.4781504273414612,
0.3013022840023041,
0.2164716273546219,
0.3232874274253845,
-0.2693870961666107,
-0.46604201197624207,
0.8051059246063232,
0.3252774477005005,
1.0498809814453125,
0.05552598461508751,
0.39816516637802124,
0.18740451335906982,
0.21275556087493896,
-0.07354311645030975,
0.2677634656429291,
-0.11127221584320068,
-1.0818558931350708,
-0.5344813466072083,
-0.8426922559738159,
-0.4416331350803375,
0.20988862216472626,
-0.8508212566375732,
-0.22387653589248657,
-0.6986618041992188,
0.04120942950248718,
0.15328186750411987,
-0.2215697020292282,
-0.5954229831695557,
0.3080780804157257,
0.38343656063079834,
0.5971876382827759,
-0.6563912630081177,
1.1211875677108765,
0.6561456918716431,
-0.21019774675369263,
-0.6412508487701416,
0.38996660709381104,
-0.10503412038087845,
-0.8871676921844482,
0.69029301404953,
0.28707751631736755,
-0.3838190734386444,
-0.0656551793217659,
-0.7861093878746033,
-0.5890786647796631,
1.0870922803878784,
0.254107803106308,
-0.3600461781024933,
-0.16335342824459076,
-0.022537674754858017,
0.5028932094573975,
-0.4604458212852478,
-0.08779318630695343,
0.8057177662849426,
0.37728533148765564,
0.30493173003196716,
-0.9344890117645264,
-0.10502652078866959,
-0.1869635283946991,
0.2191792130470276,
-0.02909170649945736,
-0.43108123540878296,
0.572269856929779,
-0.3362090289592743,
-0.47082796692848206,
0.15824462473392487,
0.5641038417816162,
0.11608000099658966,
0.5898352861404419,
0.37570297718048096,
0.559262752532959,
0.7560436725616455,
-0.19666676223278046,
1.0027393102645874,
-0.08502074331045151,
0.6970592141151428,
1.0083544254302979,
-0.018618617206811905,
0.9720566272735596,
0.280640184879303,
-0.18107910454273224,
0.5169099569320679,
0.6399180293083191,
-0.16380076110363007,
0.7303214073181152,
-0.03643538057804108,
0.21241793036460876,
-0.27711212635040283,
-0.2615605592727661,
-0.04593799635767937,
0.8233788013458252,
0.5093344449996948,
-0.09627510607242584,
-0.3067268431186676,
-0.040264468640089035,
-0.34490543603897095,
-0.11974208056926727,
-0.755036473274231,
0.6056721806526184,
0.19872227311134338,
-0.03246789798140526,
0.7162873148918152,
0.13740214705467224,
0.8762326836585999,
-0.20450544357299805,
-0.044796209782361984,
-0.002908860333263874,
0.3328089118003845,
-0.5670207738876343,
-1.0120277404785156,
0.4795388877391815,
0.02756657265126705,
-0.07544082403182983,
-0.1828157603740692,
0.8812885880470276,
-0.3017491102218628,
-0.3739194869995117,
-0.004260316491127014,
0.46662437915802,
0.11505095660686493,
-0.028213100507855415,
-0.7538975477218628,
0.2581264078617096,
-0.12056709825992584,
0.07181733846664429,
0.15870651602745056,
0.5572538375854492,
-0.23530307412147522,
0.9086204171180725,
0.33327701687812805,
-0.1002405509352684,
-0.25189515948295593,
-0.011776604689657688,
0.8781901597976685,
-0.8252003192901611,
-0.6144213080406189,
-0.7834877967834473,
0.41978970170021057,
0.2093634456396103,
0.028641462326049805,
0.5177459120750427,
0.4954336881637573,
0.8734661340713501,
-0.08779921382665634,
0.8286752104759216,
0.03438843414187431,
-0.09916986525058746,
-0.7929047346115112,
0.5829391479492188,
-0.5117790102958679,
0.31977856159210205,
-0.4942777752876282,
-0.6266006827354431,
-0.4935359060764313,
0.6998168230056763,
-0.20327234268188477,
-0.009178654290735722,
0.747508704662323,
0.6077147722244263,
-0.15115387737751007,
-0.194607213139534,
0.5208961367607117,
0.31503093242645264,
0.2789417505264282,
0.5433576107025146,
1.3267583847045898,
-0.2807154059410095,
0.5845961570739746,
-0.21515469253063202,
-0.36651068925857544,
-0.2705342471599579,
-0.6772366166114807,
-0.7578157782554626,
-0.4806874096393585,
-0.6597706079483032,
0.1066351905465126,
-0.2396983653306961,
0.5807480812072754,
0.964733362197876,
-0.6999409794807434,
-0.03917602822184563,
-0.12930478155612946,
0.25700268149375916,
-0.09488622099161148,
-0.2620842456817627,
0.5799217224121094,
-0.3524536192417145,
-0.5319965481758118,
0.08157671988010406,
0.6941137909889221,
0.2557051479816437,
-0.08968726545572281,
-0.2779461741447449,
0.5015179514884949,
-0.10350140929222107,
0.8614186644554138,
0.018962113186717033,
-0.7647823691368103,
-0.3799123466014862,
-0.410834938287735,
0.016660545021295547,
0.42730265855789185,
0.5491419434547424,
-0.587909460067749,
0.37884947657585144,
0.3923519551753998,
0.5828627943992615,
0.52939373254776,
0.1309487223625183,
0.21617461740970612,
-0.5866642594337463,
0.18145377933979034,
0.21443693339824677,
0.49029064178466797,
0.137274369597435,
-0.36915069818496704,
0.5739815831184387,
0.4389999210834503,
-0.31587469577789307,
-0.8130760192871094,
0.31773969531059265,
-1.2919657230377197,
-0.3694697916507721,
0.9541615843772888,
-0.3144964277744293,
-0.4170718789100647,
-0.07643774896860123,
-0.06565696746110916,
0.11968689411878586,
-0.2741641104221344,
0.7549936175346375,
0.3756910264492035,
-0.18219153583049774,
-0.4075498878955841,
-0.5485751628875732,
0.46814945340156555,
-0.009121924638748169,
-1.1314971446990967,
0.02997283637523651,
0.4719640016555786,
0.24318912625312805,
0.26446741819381714,
0.5376939177513123,
-0.36025041341781616,
0.35266387462615967,
-0.023776521906256676,
0.17312271893024445,
-0.12327423691749573,
-0.7006106376647949,
-0.5431493520736694,
0.4140448570251465,
0.29623955488204956,
-0.5547989010810852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18669v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18669v2
|
Zipper: A Multi-Tower Decoder Architecture for Fusing Modalities
| 2024-05-29T00:23:55 | 2024-05-31T15:42:53 |
Vicky Zayats, Peter Chen, Melissa Ferrari, Dirk Padfield
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Integrating multiple generative foundation models, especially those trained
on different modalities, into something greater than the sum of its parts poses
significant challenges. Two key hurdles are the availability of aligned data
(concepts that contain similar meaning but is expressed differently in
different modalities), and effectively leveraging unimodal representations in
cross-domain generative tasks, without compromising their original unimodal
capabilities.
We propose Zipper, a multi-tower decoder architecture that addresses these
concerns by using cross-attention to flexibly compose multimodal generative
models from independently pre-trained unimodal decoders. In our experiments
fusing speech and text modalities, we show the proposed architecture performs
very competitively in scenarios with limited aligned text-speech data. We also
showcase the flexibility of our model to selectively maintain unimodal (e.g.,
text-to-text generation) generation performance by freezing the corresponding
modal tower (e.g. text). In cross-modal tasks such as automatic speech
recognition (ASR) where the output modality is text, we show that freezing the
text backbone results in negligible performance degradation. In cross-modal
tasks such as text-to-speech generation (TTS) where the output modality is
speech, we show that using a pre-trained speech backbone results in superior
performance to the baseline.
|
[
-0.3151867389678955,
-0.4288913607597351,
0.01318244356662035,
0.29859140515327454,
-0.3282613158226013,
0.17449773848056793,
-0.010446189902722836,
-0.1954948604106903,
0.08704668283462524,
0.20911848545074463,
-0.5152937173843384,
-0.18254297971725464,
-0.22419866919517517,
-0.025523854419589043,
-0.6562174558639526,
0.9024792313575745,
0.25664737820625305,
-0.007553097326308489,
-0.3140593469142914,
0.019522571936249733,
-0.32098388671875,
-0.4395236372947693,
-0.2315264642238617,
-0.31570374965667725,
0.2976057827472687,
0.1537991166114807,
0.7116493582725525,
0.46451061964035034,
0.11111293733119965,
0.3625611662864685,
0.26734811067581177,
0.12903892993927002,
-0.19077181816101074,
0.17447884380817413,
-0.06606780737638474,
-0.22244316339492798,
-0.4496506452560425,
-0.13464416563510895,
0.7357116341590881,
0.5120920538902283,
0.021395843476057053,
0.19937410950660706,
0.09497422724962234,
0.7064330577850342,
-0.9219880700111389,
-0.17421644926071167,
-0.6911642551422119,
0.12000887840986252,
-0.2165275663137436,
-0.2860560119152069,
-0.32064494490623474,
0.28984859585762024,
-0.044710673391819,
-0.3275283873081207,
0.3013237416744232,
0.042228054255247116,
0.782833993434906,
0.44470441341400146,
-0.4900864064693451,
0.02429208531975746,
-0.5514942407608032,
0.6894587278366089,
-0.28548115491867065,
0.7883505821228027,
0.3530125021934509,
0.21265150606632233,
0.1297537237405777,
-0.7743713855743408,
-0.6909410953521729,
0.16856145858764648,
-0.17219936847686768,
0.3925636410713196,
-0.31137213110923767,
-0.025832349434494972,
-0.05290183052420616,
0.6324530243873596,
-0.7420582175254822,
-0.12427633255720139,
-0.4246513247489929,
-0.2576437294483185,
0.3455318808555603,
0.06457985937595367,
0.43953877687454224,
-0.5865497589111328,
-0.5785201787948608,
-0.1626509130001068,
-0.5865200161933899,
0.28344064950942993,
0.43961432576179504,
0.2853911221027374,
-0.08643581718206406,
0.48670604825019836,
-0.0815713107585907,
0.7855587005615234,
0.276227742433548,
0.024246541783213615,
0.43281105160713196,
-0.42360424995422363,
-0.6464841365814209,
0.043116312474012375,
0.9107353687286377,
-0.06409852206707001,
-0.3828195035457611,
-0.6295340657234192,
-0.2506754696369171,
0.08006829023361206,
0.6058379411697388,
-0.5362896919250488,
-0.2698085904121399,
0.3714045286178589,
-0.6284133195877075,
-0.1837257444858551,
0.037202075123786926,
-0.8106908202171326,
0.0708359107375145,
-0.15059925615787506,
0.684935986995697,
-0.31628572940826416,
-0.3573160469532013,
0.28808221220970154,
-0.23167705535888672,
0.21566376090049744,
-0.01932508684694767,
-1.0313518047332764,
0.11942291259765625,
0.3759370744228363,
0.819143533706665,
0.034667592495679855,
-0.3380589783191681,
-0.7143906354904175,
0.3234712481498718,
-0.10624779015779495,
0.5781737565994263,
-0.6729509234428406,
-0.19855424761772156,
0.10308824479579926,
0.09855392575263977,
-0.4908355474472046,
-0.11180122196674347,
0.7519024014472961,
-0.48140111565589905,
0.3394606411457062,
0.1423509418964386,
-0.04167291149497032,
-0.06100859493017197,
0.06304789334535599,
-0.8627731800079346,
0.7939103841781616,
0.14290305972099304,
-0.7338415384292603,
-0.02743750438094139,
-0.4387013614177704,
-0.840388298034668,
-0.08091339468955994,
-0.27247363328933716,
-0.5899143218994141,
0.4236783981323242,
0.3693915009498596,
0.5121092200279236,
-0.6770678758621216,
0.14328330755233765,
0.03310910612344742,
-0.306237131357193,
0.36032360792160034,
-0.5964201092720032,
0.7612754106521606,
0.4798167049884796,
-0.34177055954933167,
0.1504158228635788,
-1.0173430442810059,
0.3244410753250122,
-0.37137967348098755,
-0.5677649974822998,
-0.1837872564792633,
0.01673680916428566,
0.5479740500450134,
0.24117274582386017,
-0.039806608110666275,
-0.31185805797576904,
0.0896441787481308,
-0.044433627277612686,
0.5655659437179565,
0.4883584678173065,
-0.7437587380409241,
0.5876529216766357,
-0.6439712643623352,
0.5556991696357727,
0.10584640502929688,
-0.0959644466638565,
-0.5089559555053711,
-0.15862424671649933,
-0.8049300312995911,
-0.7306421399116516,
0.45694851875305176,
0.399227112531662,
-0.8750768303871155,
0.6169438362121582,
-0.47398433089256287,
-0.22791782021522522,
-0.8564367294311523,
-0.003057287773117423,
0.6097500324249268,
0.303300678730011,
0.35769781470298767,
-0.41615891456604004,
-0.6014910936355591,
-0.8811766505241394,
-0.08086203038692474,
0.09742666780948639,
-0.3177211582660675,
0.007589622400701046,
0.3386524021625519,
-0.06587332487106323,
0.8386252522468567,
-0.06983835250139236,
-0.5325631499290466,
-0.16041326522827148,
0.5791243314743042,
-0.09937438368797302,
0.6984933018684387,
0.32315152883529663,
-1.1560944318771362,
-0.21323144435882568,
0.15663938224315643,
-0.47364485263824463,
0.05859767273068428,
-0.24131344258785248,
0.20461931824684143,
0.08184566348791122,
0.2820904552936554,
-0.816062867641449,
0.1742042899131775,
0.8286686539649963,
0.013799537904560566,
0.4072936773300171,
0.00468810461461544,
0.5721831321716309,
-1.494472622871399,
0.2933317720890045,
-0.37657713890075684,
0.029813427478075027,
-0.8739093542098999,
-0.057789161801338196,
0.22175362706184387,
-0.32698947191238403,
-0.30383604764938354,
0.020548462867736816,
-0.8540158867835999,
-0.1640375554561615,
-0.12919048964977264,
-0.08123811334371567,
0.2597522437572479,
0.6222125291824341,
0.06299032270908356,
0.773850679397583,
0.8870024085044861,
-0.4996345043182373,
0.3306542932987213,
0.19797931611537933,
-0.6033042073249817,
0.49179014563560486,
-0.6322510838508606,
0.2694813907146454,
-0.21786388754844666,
0.3308064341545105,
-0.9545071125030518,
-0.47471919655799866,
-0.08124895393848419,
-0.5790244936943054,
0.38750672340393066,
-0.3024469017982483,
-0.45449942350387573,
-0.28588491678237915,
-0.5018151998519897,
0.8603451251983643,
0.48482391238212585,
-0.6582213640213013,
1.2406187057495117,
0.23113593459129333,
0.29741084575653076,
-0.8514319062232971,
-1.043560266494751,
0.04497874900698662,
-0.162864550948143,
-0.9024805426597595,
0.7098165154457092,
-0.017740096896886826,
0.32808157801628113,
0.1838812530040741,
-0.22485095262527466,
-0.23328278958797455,
-0.1926112025976181,
0.49164462089538574,
0.061888668686151505,
-0.2846570611000061,
0.36758679151535034,
0.04129179194569588,
-0.014518002048134804,
-0.2529294788837433,
-0.4198344647884369,
0.5237497687339783,
-0.12364649772644043,
-0.41921576857566833,
-0.4212303161621094,
0.7122235298156738,
1.0857939720153809,
-0.6460539698600769,
0.598108172416687,
0.8348455429077148,
-0.34796348214149475,
-0.19456061720848083,
-0.6273010969161987,
0.16346701979637146,
-0.4856473207473755,
0.16350850462913513,
-0.8428736925125122,
-0.9891923666000366,
0.601317822933197,
-0.035686980932950974,
-0.22411417961120605,
0.1201256513595581,
0.5357009768486023,
0.015862660482525826,
0.9537410736083984,
0.7407575845718384,
-0.09520523995161057,
0.4364599585533142,
-0.10729523748159409,
0.588994562625885,
-1.2577269077301025,
-0.45036324858665466,
-0.5720286965370178,
-0.414259672164917,
-0.2708470821380615,
-0.6651793718338013,
0.40574705600738525,
0.34728819131851196,
0.1376739889383316,
0.3614565432071686,
-0.5679660439491272,
0.4457533061504364,
0.4966472089290619,
-0.05783047154545784,
0.2617197632789612,
0.2536400854587555,
0.020046129822731018,
0.316826730966568,
-0.9650851488113403,
-0.11049862205982208,
0.853452205657959,
-0.05881239101290703,
1.131526231765747,
0.30503854155540466,
0.2864432632923126,
0.0870823860168457,
-0.16143713891506195,
-0.6288548707962036,
0.2283041775226593,
-0.3173966407775879,
-0.44355854392051697,
-0.0012597237946465611,
-0.4181985557079315,
-0.9040728807449341,
0.6123127937316895,
-0.26452115178108215,
-0.8029129505157471,
0.4063161611557007,
0.05266939103603363,
-0.4366353750228882,
0.3486417233943939,
-0.6476907134056091,
0.8643248677253723,
-0.14699703454971313,
-0.4106491506099701,
-0.1252235621213913,
-0.826682984828949,
0.6216625571250916,
-0.04129264876246452,
0.011529851704835892,
0.22271506488323212,
0.19843687117099762,
0.456256240606308,
0.014312323182821274,
0.8367913961410522,
0.564346194267273,
0.10106600821018219,
0.21747396886348724,
-0.0662146508693695,
0.22945161163806915,
-0.034549809992313385,
0.061261024326086044,
0.060922399163246155,
-0.12133198976516724,
-0.19878879189491272,
-0.6550412774085999,
0.7238388657569885,
-0.8395950794219971,
-0.562532901763916,
-0.3686578869819641,
-0.910443902015686,
-0.2289854735136032,
0.04536549374461174,
0.4585897922515869,
0.940838098526001,
-0.16072224080562592,
0.5982886552810669,
0.6400600075721741,
0.14235691726207733,
0.6792629957199097,
0.41921547055244446,
0.2003224641084671,
-0.6141583919525146,
0.85866779088974,
-0.11851642280817032,
0.28348997235298157,
0.8204147815704346,
-0.0021754680201411247,
-0.3751651346683502,
-0.3085283041000366,
-0.6326745748519897,
-0.3167650103569031,
-0.6105097532272339,
-0.5469695329666138,
-0.976213276386261,
-0.3755510747432709,
-0.6151993274688721,
-0.4222046136856079,
-0.4385543465614319,
-0.5522208213806152,
-0.31448012590408325,
0.11553757637739182,
0.06590157747268677,
0.28014302253723145,
-0.3367359936237335,
0.28334328532218933,
-1.010772705078125,
0.5980373620986938,
0.4857412874698639,
0.07477924227714539,
0.019117455929517746,
-0.3672764003276825,
-0.20004168152809143,
-0.05879107117652893,
-0.2236117422580719,
-0.8329542279243469,
0.27163437008857727,
0.22507430613040924,
0.35194823145866394,
0.41968628764152527,
0.26162534952163696,
0.897750973701477,
-0.3443586528301239,
0.7036151885986328,
0.6786120533943176,
-1.2856463193893433,
0.36979761719703674,
-0.26225745677948,
0.6087141633033752,
0.3988417685031891,
0.4054543375968933,
-0.46605780720710754,
-0.2722686529159546,
-0.26228418946266174,
-0.7453217506408691,
0.8256084322929382,
0.30417969822883606,
0.17639601230621338,
0.13276302814483643,
-0.2206321358680725,
-0.00725138746201992,
0.3576606512069702,
-0.9205476641654968,
0.07235123217105865,
-0.7080203294754028,
-0.32061877846717834,
0.2580810487270355,
-0.2329862415790558,
-0.4109078049659729,
-0.23202437162399292,
0.34748268127441406,
-0.3024018704891205,
0.30619263648986816,
0.10704218596220016,
-0.3522090017795563,
-0.2669880986213684,
0.7070910930633545,
0.5819323062896729,
0.40607908368110657,
0.08993197977542877,
0.6260167360305786,
-0.21856753528118134,
-0.16117388010025024,
0.04425438493490219,
0.2180282473564148,
-0.1826363205909729,
-0.24589307606220245,
0.36678606271743774,
0.8879550099372864,
0.31783223152160645,
-0.5859887599945068,
0.5595484972000122,
-0.09966208785772324,
-0.007851743139326572,
0.0629298985004425,
-0.15486367046833038,
-0.11529158055782318,
0.3509353995323181,
0.5038244128227234,
0.4566386640071869,
0.1445946991443634,
-0.7299273014068604,
0.367725133895874,
0.6553018093109131,
-0.14718231558799744,
-0.5514407753944397,
0.7654294967651367,
0.36705660820007324,
-0.25920385122299194,
0.6215180158615112,
0.12050685286521912,
-0.7895068526268005,
0.2769581377506256,
0.8163047432899475,
1.160354495048523,
-0.3308899700641632,
0.25451207160949707,
0.18782980740070343,
0.3693085014820099,
0.10859387367963791,
0.03166787698864937,
-0.635384202003479,
-0.6896487474441528,
-0.24346667528152466,
-0.8479143977165222,
0.1942625492811203,
0.15390999615192413,
-0.6620693802833557,
0.019640609622001648,
-0.024789849296212196,
-0.02783893421292305,
-0.33715540170669556,
-0.37894347310066223,
-0.5133407115936279,
0.20882636308670044,
-0.12507373094558716,
0.557770311832428,
-0.7528548240661621,
0.917672872543335,
0.5886960029602051,
-0.550645112991333,
-0.6895027756690979,
0.16913533210754395,
0.08540405333042145,
-0.6747766137123108,
0.5064371824264526,
0.3223533630371094,
-0.6935344934463501,
-0.05590067431330681,
-0.016043690964579582,
-0.7711532711982727,
1.1351779699325562,
0.290363609790802,
-0.38754263520240784,
-0.027612725272774696,
0.20605500042438507,
0.2556077539920807,
-0.6191561818122864,
0.16829825937747955,
0.23244430124759674,
0.20799978077411652,
0.34967511892318726,
-1.0569818019866943,
0.10442370176315308,
-0.5400257706642151,
0.02459196001291275,
0.1755014955997467,
-0.7665467858314514,
1.0231297016143799,
-0.24255499243736267,
-0.7010348439216614,
0.3039831519126892,
0.6547198295593262,
-0.3495306670665741,
0.03675350919365883,
0.5196384191513062,
0.8707456588745117,
0.5492534041404724,
-0.13205382227897644,
0.9833419322967529,
-0.388960599899292,
0.1426074504852295,
0.9785371422767639,
-0.02621031366288662,
0.811412513256073,
0.5139604806900024,
0.2902776300907135,
0.38907304406166077,
0.23814478516578674,
0.0848439484834671,
0.928159236907959,
-0.045016106218099594,
-0.5099571943283081,
-0.5324795842170715,
-0.23054133355617523,
-0.4940815269947052,
0.7472009062767029,
0.11226120591163635,
-0.08494329452514648,
-0.21765179932117462,
0.21901236474514008,
-0.3679361343383789,
-0.0552392415702343,
-0.1323460191488266,
0.47027137875556946,
-0.20137625932693481,
-0.7360150218009949,
0.673401415348053,
0.057806435972452164,
0.5923317670822144,
-0.8374268412590027,
0.10417698323726654,
0.06047750636935234,
0.16276735067367554,
-0.4240495562553406,
-0.42306309938430786,
0.2378823459148407,
-0.16518381237983704,
-0.48731788992881775,
-0.44267264008522034,
0.6443116664886475,
-0.8492297530174255,
-0.305351197719574,
0.00914308987557888,
0.3696562945842743,
-0.22144949436187744,
0.09013359993696213,
-0.44249555468559265,
0.6438486576080322,
-0.25156280398368835,
-0.042020004242658615,
0.3705179989337921,
0.41650277376174927,
0.17964328825473785,
0.5944831371307373,
0.7341094613075256,
-0.5131507515907288,
0.2923072576522827,
0.1973905861377716,
1.1879162788391113,
-0.5222017168998718,
-0.48072096705436707,
-0.5080417394638062,
0.9338448643684387,
0.04174615815281868,
-0.288851797580719,
0.6295986175537109,
0.7028812170028687,
0.644618570804596,
-0.19145174324512482,
0.6777795553207397,
-0.43499746918678284,
-0.25336548686027527,
-0.7911566495895386,
0.6132645010948181,
-0.8254214525222778,
0.145967036485672,
0.03866477310657501,
-0.7110114097595215,
-0.21243789792060852,
0.620425283908844,
0.34067556262016296,
0.002653444418683648,
0.9406313300132751,
0.8203649520874023,
-0.3120586574077606,
0.12155221402645111,
0.5009011626243591,
-0.025461286306381226,
0.1579980105161667,
0.8406961560249329,
0.8840738534927368,
-0.7776618599891663,
0.7076961398124695,
-0.04100044444203377,
-0.2213931828737259,
-0.007448418997228146,
-0.8065550923347473,
-1.1148256063461304,
-1.0063380002975464,
-0.12551328539848328,
-0.120314821600914,
0.05726100131869316,
0.4816232919692993,
0.9909767508506775,
-0.5276016592979431,
-0.1384255290031433,
0.03390249237418175,
0.13996325433254242,
-0.3782118558883667,
-0.24810965359210968,
0.49528175592422485,
-0.48483920097351074,
-0.8133532404899597,
0.7417253255844116,
0.6027414202690125,
-0.08271069079637527,
-0.30556467175483704,
0.07064078003168106,
-0.10361021012067795,
0.1421821117401123,
0.6667190194129944,
0.22974278032779694,
-0.8416691422462463,
-0.31417861580848694,
-0.07260402292013168,
-0.0935167595744133,
0.06590572744607925,
1.392763614654541,
-0.9126773476600647,
0.6656083464622498,
0.7556226253509521,
0.9787306785583496,
0.46005669236183167,
-0.05792735517024994,
0.6148905158042908,
-0.9939725995063782,
0.19154174625873566,
0.11816718429327011,
0.3327092230319977,
0.36188092827796936,
-0.1572319120168686,
0.23906835913658142,
0.020121196284890175,
-0.3040829300880432,
-0.8049033284187317,
0.43825650215148926,
-1.2861074209213257,
-0.2789894938468933,
0.7091037034988403,
0.03432217612862587,
-0.23896090686321259,
-0.175161212682724,
0.11015496402978897,
0.06966187804937363,
-0.11323768645524979,
0.8925049901008606,
0.5714684724807739,
-0.04301242530345917,
-0.5249274373054504,
-0.1285620629787445,
0.5731920599937439,
0.5628654360771179,
-0.6455483436584473,
0.24203331768512726,
0.5825653076171875,
0.01701733097434044,
0.5165529847145081,
0.6266751885414124,
-0.15629735589027405,
0.5982456803321838,
0.21735532581806183,
-0.23622751235961914,
-0.3069237768650055,
-0.7226625084877014,
-0.2670484483242035,
0.6159377694129944,
-0.6714345216751099,
-0.43300092220306396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18662v1
|
Understanding Intrinsic Socioeconomic Biases in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T23:54:44 | 2024-05-28T23:54:44 |
Mina Arzaghi, Florian Carichon, Golnoosh Farnadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly integrated into critical
decision-making processes, such as loan approvals and visa applications, where
inherent biases can lead to discriminatory outcomes. In this paper, we examine
the nuanced relationship between demographic attributes and socioeconomic
biases in LLMs, a crucial yet understudied area of fairness in LLMs. We
introduce a novel dataset of one million English sentences to systematically
quantify socioeconomic biases across various demographic groups. Our findings
reveal pervasive socioeconomic biases in both established models such as GPT-2
and state-of-the-art models like Llama 2 and Falcon. We demonstrate that these
biases are significantly amplified when considering intersectionality, with
LLMs exhibiting a remarkable capacity to extract multiple demographic
attributes from names and then correlate them with specific socioeconomic
biases. This research highlights the urgent necessity for proactive and robust
bias mitigation techniques to safeguard against discriminatory outcomes when
deploying these powerful models in critical real-world applications.
|
[
-0.14790526032447815,
-0.6845236420631409,
0.7792298793792725,
0.1854853630065918,
0.12565714120864868,
0.35664358735084534,
-0.22527363896369934,
-0.4879058301448822,
-0.1268809735774994,
0.595123827457428,
-0.44553691148757935,
-0.23434850573539734,
-0.6664866209030151,
-0.2562105059623718,
-0.0142361493781209,
0.988796055316925,
0.4000481367111206,
0.24069498479366302,
-0.39829665422439575,
-0.0654236376285553,
-0.2831355929374695,
-0.706311047077179,
-0.5065122842788696,
-0.3493485450744629,
0.3739349842071533,
0.30096685886383057,
0.8528489470481873,
0.40014851093292236,
0.32513925433158875,
0.18734797835350037,
-0.2823295593261719,
-0.0797724649310112,
-0.5875149369239807,
0.008166168816387653,
-0.32455116510391235,
-0.45810937881469727,
-0.4821329116821289,
-0.01793852262198925,
0.6797094941139221,
0.9583203196525574,
0.06011788174510002,
0.539322555065155,
0.27444925904273987,
0.7148060202598572,
-0.662270724773407,
0.20310693979263306,
-0.7680131793022156,
-0.10523658245801926,
-0.47704601287841797,
0.18657279014587402,
-0.23265133798122406,
-0.6137065291404724,
0.028774917125701904,
-0.10013753175735474,
0.23513343930244446,
-0.07704441249370575,
0.6054610013961792,
0.2006271481513977,
-0.7269211411476135,
-0.06913232058286667,
-0.6524370908737183,
0.8298404216766357,
-0.6531774997711182,
0.18967710435390472,
0.44255098700523376,
0.2697594463825226,
-0.15504512190818787,
-0.24296340346336365,
-0.45944082736968994,
0.02728389762341976,
-0.08917699754238129,
-0.14619407057762146,
-0.11646728217601776,
-0.011988088488578796,
0.25748544931411743,
-0.014714088290929794,
-0.45582467317581177,
0.5440660715103149,
-0.5441418886184692,
-0.1634516417980194,
0.5919374823570251,
0.15837104618549347,
0.11075657606124878,
-0.2606047987937927,
-0.16221530735492706,
0.3358632028102875,
-0.9815119504928589,
0.1548561453819275,
0.9549249410629272,
0.4064464271068573,
-0.37617984414100647,
0.6009224653244019,
0.0840560644865036,
0.23307928442955017,
0.009451519697904587,
-0.02227383852005005,
0.14301536977291107,
-0.174215629696846,
0.2714565098285675,
0.137648344039917,
0.6054261326789856,
0.3878342807292938,
0.8149851560592651,
-0.04673200100660324,
-0.08703666180372238,
0.1768251210451126,
-0.1090971976518631,
-0.532024085521698,
0.3676624894142151,
0.2529415190219879,
-0.36345720291137695,
-0.5304878354072571,
-0.07721401005983353,
-1.0281766653060913,
-0.5555891394615173,
-0.03806130215525627,
-0.16816125810146332,
0.30452337861061096,
-0.2366354912519455,
-0.06490372866392136,
0.013626467436552048,
0.41485822200775146,
0.11590155959129333,
-0.8514053821563721,
0.08896879106760025,
0.9729897975921631,
0.5571110844612122,
0.15721440315246582,
-0.026295267045497894,
-0.26705247163772583,
0.2768360674381256,
-0.19172163307666779,
0.5365646481513977,
-0.9876496195793152,
-0.28566986322402954,
0.12383954226970673,
-0.15803812444210052,
0.01574413850903511,
-0.704055666923523,
0.3606564700603485,
-0.4348593056201935,
-0.1700427383184433,
-0.30833137035369873,
-0.06347200274467468,
0.10938067734241486,
0.013472641818225384,
-0.447905033826828,
1.021767258644104,
0.1551547348499298,
-0.6444000005722046,
0.7936557531356812,
-0.3452153503894806,
-0.42569443583488464,
0.10498672723770142,
-0.27643823623657227,
-0.5317224860191345,
0.2706123888492584,
0.10084083676338196,
0.3514760136604309,
-0.5119245052337646,
0.8770415782928467,
-0.750352144241333,
-0.14172802865505219,
0.34438636898994446,
-0.6001474857330322,
0.7681018710136414,
-0.018347153440117836,
-0.47629037499427795,
-0.11484307050704956,
-0.5708374977111816,
-0.5652976036071777,
0.21552447974681854,
-0.10010602325201035,
-0.42782002687454224,
0.16465896368026733,
-0.05189501494169235,
0.3106151521205902,
0.3604416251182556,
-0.4279140830039978,
-0.08874762803316116,
-0.10010171681642532,
0.589318573474884,
1.0994765758514404,
-0.2333308905363083,
0.41350072622299194,
-0.27565476298332214,
0.5562605261802673,
0.020124632865190506,
0.23727408051490784,
0.19774088263511658,
-0.3011721074581146,
-0.4232438802719116,
-0.2663828134536743,
0.1256507784128189,
0.46617022156715393,
-0.2997290790081024,
0.1620331108570099,
-0.25294703245162964,
-0.3395727574825287,
-0.5362737774848938,
0.19035063683986664,
0.24196194112300873,
0.2724613845348358,
-0.14719201624393463,
0.10778333246707916,
-0.5655112862586975,
-1.258475422859192,
-0.5281332731246948,
-0.31900545954704285,
0.056550588458776474,
0.5987385511398315,
0.6291245818138123,
-0.14387069642543793,
0.8520690202713013,
-0.26233822107315063,
-0.1803366094827652,
-0.20105259120464325,
-0.285910964012146,
0.24844896793365479,
0.4082677960395813,
0.7603597640991211,
-0.6765523552894592,
-0.1387937217950821,
0.009301112033426762,
-0.6652677655220032,
-0.5446241497993469,
-0.11173339933156967,
-0.08088917285203934,
0.08306485414505005,
0.29967597126960754,
-0.4661311209201813,
0.324226975440979,
0.4795847535133362,
-0.5907248258590698,
0.5785538554191589,
0.04584398493170738,
-0.020403798669576645,
-0.6105103492736816,
-0.2017393261194229,
0.502379834651947,
-0.1671058088541031,
-0.19251179695129395,
0.15772496163845062,
-0.14747855067253113,
0.14214761555194855,
-0.36831414699554443,
0.5259878635406494,
-0.38008832931518555,
-0.3213694393634796,
0.18002231419086456,
0.21661421656608582,
-0.1027589812874794,
0.1321903020143509,
-0.15227162837982178,
0.8222655653953552,
0.23846721649169922,
-0.23121128976345062,
0.049896445125341415,
0.08729936927556992,
-0.3019895851612091,
0.6621270179748535,
-0.7524617314338684,
-0.062438931316137314,
-0.5977691411972046,
0.4053804576396942,
-0.9656611680984497,
-0.18338675796985626,
-0.11858747899532318,
-0.31713956594467163,
-0.12830117344856262,
-0.26860716938972473,
-0.3228706419467926,
-0.3778955340385437,
-0.3187779486179352,
0.6211936473846436,
0.43427085876464844,
-0.3023044764995575,
0.5462450981140137,
0.8348754644393921,
-0.6583042144775391,
-0.5244681239128113,
-0.46908023953437805,
0.07866738736629486,
-0.48198702931404114,
-0.517769455909729,
-0.0015973292756825686,
0.35276636481285095,
-0.679934024810791,
-0.2401999980211258,
0.14416031539440155,
0.05243329703807831,
0.30425316095352173,
0.2887066602706909,
0.5346919894218445,
-0.1400362253189087,
-0.025442220270633698,
0.19961486756801605,
-0.005430011544376612,
0.18413372337818146,
-0.290875107049942,
0.7237951159477234,
0.12237663567066193,
-0.31857621669769287,
0.19528459012508392,
0.11202183365821838,
0.8523709177970886,
-0.14480949938297272,
0.8183353543281555,
0.203489288687706,
-0.44605275988578796,
0.10730216652154922,
-0.8330050110816956,
0.12199854850769043,
-0.4629420042037964,
0.5958017706871033,
-0.2387056201696396,
-1.1025789976119995,
0.8160750269889832,
0.18758384883403778,
0.007183367386460304,
0.5579286217689514,
0.5994734168052673,
0.2538987994194031,
1.120601773262024,
0.4541186988353729,
-0.20591622591018677,
0.2697228491306305,
0.03763008490204811,
0.39372941851615906,
-0.9735643267631531,
-0.4290330410003662,
-0.7277476787567139,
-0.2297544628381729,
-0.684992790222168,
-0.46805325150489807,
0.43902209401130676,
-0.11275718361139297,
-0.511755108833313,
-0.22165443003177643,
-0.11268051713705063,
0.6933451890945435,
0.2475210726261139,
0.1487969011068344,
0.13795509934425354,
-0.0636613517999649,
-0.11710795015096664,
-0.41231483221054077,
-0.5224543213844299,
-1.00818932056427,
1.2673892974853516,
0.5520281195640564,
0.7084107995033264,
0.17296725511550903,
0.16848579049110413,
0.6302570104598999,
0.2967546284198761,
-0.30546003580093384,
0.4630950689315796,
-0.43962928652763367,
-0.7299214005470276,
-0.17819412052631378,
-0.5601205825805664,
-0.7638314962387085,
0.284524142742157,
-0.38468071818351746,
-0.8871108889579773,
0.4121362566947937,
0.1335517019033432,
-0.26123735308647156,
0.3693320155143738,
-0.5066222548484802,
0.7306264638900757,
-0.443373441696167,
-0.9780398607254028,
-0.2864360213279724,
-0.45394691824913025,
0.5693625211715698,
-0.39927706122398376,
0.7373135685920715,
-0.4502807557582855,
0.08060026168823242,
0.4297857880592346,
-0.2625308036804199,
1.0272042751312256,
-0.2840406000614166,
-0.21656446158885956,
-0.23526650667190552,
-0.08844839036464691,
0.3203302025794983,
0.04290527105331421,
-0.4216137230396271,
0.41180509328842163,
-0.04595354571938515,
-0.7192105054855347,
-0.1390671730041504,
0.8228906989097595,
-0.9346329569816589,
-0.5827388763427734,
-0.34173935651779175,
-0.5641744136810303,
-0.15025001764297485,
-0.09864592552185059,
-0.23672057688236237,
0.3648169934749603,
-0.40372931957244873,
0.07545645534992218,
0.2996448874473572,
-0.6514544486999512,
0.013897895812988281,
0.47275927662849426,
-0.25371527671813965,
0.028472499921917915,
0.596779465675354,
0.3965953290462494,
0.44203701615333557,
0.01582403853535652,
0.24500881135463715,
-0.19187843799591064,
-0.3271765112876892,
-0.2759215533733368,
0.4742443859577179,
-0.5098689198493958,
0.09470415860414505,
-0.7940260171890259,
0.026746759191155434,
-0.8579110503196716,
-0.38405346870422363,
0.0021424468141049147,
-0.2719936668872833,
0.15950119495391846,
-0.31229841709136963,
0.16025957465171814,
0.9105327725410461,
0.009967083111405373,
0.40387874841690063,
-0.5012721419334412,
0.40218648314476013,
0.18217146396636963,
0.19729205965995789,
0.3691714107990265,
-0.5837878584861755,
0.021159714087843895,
0.30602356791496277,
-0.030415941029787064,
-0.6069877743721008,
0.15749822556972504,
0.034905076026916504,
0.7530148029327393,
0.4491291344165802,
0.0013786577619612217,
0.5484244227409363,
-0.4594065546989441,
0.8088545203208923,
-0.243080273270607,
-0.8150447010993958,
0.36431771516799927,
-0.48487505316734314,
0.07175088673830032,
0.48555025458335876,
0.23371264338493347,
-0.5100970268249512,
-0.6651487350463867,
-0.34055185317993164,
-1.3859978914260864,
0.6574323773384094,
-0.1266375035047531,
0.2390364706516266,
-0.2056719958782196,
0.329394668340683,
0.2607998251914978,
0.33589276671409607,
-0.8393352031707764,
-0.0010827002115547657,
0.2864634394645691,
-0.3591592609882355,
-0.09519148617982864,
-0.6480223536491394,
0.22883889079093933,
-0.16037097573280334,
0.7358672022819519,
0.07211330533027649,
-0.3881062865257263,
-0.2032989263534546,
-0.3751063942909241,
0.1299513727426529,
0.4085375964641571,
0.4549003839492798,
0.5950071215629578,
-0.052878983318805695,
0.10556275397539139,
0.17721350491046906,
-0.5514663457870483,
0.2984722852706909,
-0.00036579667357727885,
-0.24226903915405273,
-0.2920060455799103,
0.25687500834465027,
0.6122934222221375,
0.24987781047821045,
-0.665966808795929,
0.5041328072547913,
0.12346925586462021,
-0.0493193194270134,
-0.4879322946071625,
-0.2741008996963501,
0.005279583390802145,
0.37597060203552246,
0.5017452836036682,
-0.1134970486164093,
0.06578447669744492,
-0.6813052892684937,
-0.16820430755615234,
0.6751959323883057,
-0.4396379888057709,
-0.17224770784378052,
0.8382848501205444,
0.4792550206184387,
-0.08873237669467926,
0.3479764759540558,
0.0509592741727829,
-0.6978703737258911,
0.7998367547988892,
0.4346686601638794,
0.7822288870811462,
-0.02353815920650959,
0.3355693519115448,
0.09909407049417496,
0.657935380935669,
0.049976494163274765,
-0.12969061732292175,
0.014135962352156639,
-0.835868775844574,
-0.18242868781089783,
-0.8279523253440857,
-0.25214359164237976,
-0.1956428736448288,
-0.6390562057495117,
0.13595286011695862,
-0.3899213671684265,
-0.20806798338890076,
0.11253159493207932,
-0.3255051374435425,
-0.8382272720336914,
-0.15899895131587982,
0.2825286090373993,
0.3895014524459839,
-1.2584589719772339,
0.27890366315841675,
0.5451760292053223,
-0.20113909244537354,
-0.3896133303642273,
-0.08606897294521332,
0.34581756591796875,
-1.2235534191131592,
0.9159010052680969,
0.14795076847076416,
-0.10075003653764725,
-0.21799975633621216,
-0.25088316202163696,
-0.4819773733615875,
0.6299790740013123,
0.5900840163230896,
-0.6956439018249512,
-0.21378587186336517,
0.7593821287155151,
0.27683743834495544,
-0.4249297082424164,
0.57155841588974,
1.0483492612838745,
0.6544145345687866,
-0.1930900514125824,
-0.8109558820724487,
-0.008494900539517403,
-0.1377677023410797,
0.151461660861969,
0.09064267575740814,
-0.7877148389816284,
0.6750192642211914,
-0.34007713198661804,
0.021987879648804665,
-0.3334968686103821,
0.1708647608757019,
0.401454359292984,
0.44380563497543335,
0.4565035402774811,
0.2660571038722992,
0.6517207622528076,
-0.3102059066295624,
1.0119112730026245,
-0.3974945545196533,
0.2823420763015747,
0.7878934741020203,
-0.8645688891410828,
0.32989925146102905,
0.4510771334171295,
-0.6096429228782654,
0.32549068331718445,
0.5058310031890869,
0.24165759980678558,
0.04433176666498184,
0.4059557318687439,
-0.3376160264015198,
-0.3094992935657501,
-0.5784951448440552,
-0.10360926389694214,
0.505695641040802,
0.38195687532424927,
-0.39388060569763184,
-0.024787506088614464,
-0.08685731142759323,
0.4380478858947754,
0.34276798367500305,
-0.5177645683288574,
0.7050924301147461,
0.05859239399433136,
-0.3719816505908966,
-0.16703616082668304,
-0.27716872096061707,
0.9879922866821289,
-0.5416033267974854,
-0.042657412588596344,
-0.3310648798942566,
0.19390110671520233,
-0.4301131069660187,
-1.0193099975585938,
0.17777536809444427,
0.2951973080635071,
-0.5533369779586792,
-0.05928999185562134,
0.6589784622192383,
-0.4378354251384735,
-0.9003744125366211,
0.5236254334449768,
0.5263300538063049,
0.10275974124670029,
0.06108551099896431,
-0.31534263491630554,
0.1683540791273117,
-0.016310766339302063,
-0.021440664306282997,
0.3903690576553345,
0.5255458354949951,
-0.3521634042263031,
0.6438634395599365,
0.5789806246757507,
0.4280921518802643,
0.03649386391043663,
0.33523184061050415,
0.47167733311653137,
-0.5424479246139526,
-0.45993340015411377,
-1.2021540403366089,
0.41528716683387756,
-0.28280290961265564,
-0.15347713232040405,
0.6744012236595154,
0.7029861807823181,
0.7605351209640503,
0.2621859610080719,
1.0533976554870605,
0.3030058741569519,
0.4596267640590668,
-0.36873894929885864,
0.5504717230796814,
-0.2790554463863373,
0.649344265460968,
-0.41103869676589966,
-0.8987073302268982,
0.06974627822637558,
0.5249482989311218,
-0.756219208240509,
0.43588289618492126,
-0.04109485074877739,
0.7984697222709656,
0.22766806185245514,
-0.25806063413619995,
0.24175940454006195,
0.21823365986347198,
0.3275655210018158,
0.43318647146224976,
0.8441001772880554,
0.019622327759861946,
0.23905739188194275,
0.25079917907714844,
-0.2537784278392792,
-0.19979263842105865,
-0.7785944938659668,
-0.7638856172561646,
0.03379557654261589,
-0.2020753026008606,
-0.34501394629478455,
0.2954244017601013,
0.9380796551704407,
0.40053343772888184,
-0.6432792544364929,
-0.3683721721172333,
0.5040376782417297,
0.4998037815093994,
0.2720165252685547,
-0.3745308518409729,
-0.049603406339883804,
0.004458932671695948,
-0.5960885286331177,
-0.5036932826042175,
0.5193217992782593,
-0.1371777355670929,
-0.5004492998123169,
0.09803890436887741,
-0.028804339468479156,
0.2538164258003235,
0.600216805934906,
-0.09056183695793152,
-0.6318284869194031,
-0.319845587015152,
-0.2571282386779785,
-0.09897226840257645,
-0.2437761127948761,
0.7597262263298035,
-0.6998765468597412,
-0.07707873731851578,
0.22017128765583038,
0.46223556995391846,
0.08866698294878006,
-0.00523009616881609,
0.758094072341919,
-0.4740961492061615,
0.26134777069091797,
0.04851437360048294,
0.5390636324882507,
0.45357948541641235,
-0.42606690526008606,
0.3744185268878937,
0.14803510904312134,
-0.6199667453765869,
-1.0421401262283325,
0.28727927803993225,
-0.5045149326324463,
-0.18519039452075958,
1.165549874305725,
0.15382419526576996,
-0.014984614215791225,
-0.26997363567352295,
-0.13941346108913422,
-0.03387836366891861,
-0.4549764096736908,
0.8254516124725342,
0.7342550158500671,
0.5698074698448181,
-0.2139679193496704,
-0.698950469493866,
-0.019174300134181976,
0.345765084028244,
-0.5607892870903015,
0.36644697189331055,
0.771248996257782,
0.12064281105995178,
-0.319089412689209,
0.5189945101737976,
-0.3875185549259186,
0.06265760958194733,
-0.14515934884548187,
0.08527961373329163,
0.17835460603237152,
0.030993662774562836,
-0.2882714569568634,
0.02554165944457054,
0.2780417203903198,
0.36666667461395264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18653v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18653v1
|
Recent Advances of Foundation Language Models-based Continual Learning: A Survey
| 2024-05-28T23:32:46 | 2024-05-28T23:32:46 |
Yutao Yang, Jie Zhou, Xuanwen Ding, Tianyu Huai, Shunyu Liu, Qin Chen, Liang He, Yuan Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, foundation language models (LMs) have marked significant
achievements in the domains of natural language processing (NLP) and computer
vision (CV). Unlike traditional neural network models, foundation LMs obtain a
great ability for transfer learning by acquiring rich commonsense knowledge
through pre-training on extensive unsupervised datasets with a vast number of
parameters. However, they still can not emulate human-like continuous learning
due to catastrophic forgetting. Consequently, various continual learning
(CL)-based methodologies have been developed to refine LMs, enabling them to
adapt to new tasks without forgetting previous knowledge. However, a systematic
taxonomy of existing approaches and a comparison of their performance are still
lacking, which is the gap that our survey aims to fill. We delve into a
comprehensive review, summarization, and classification of the existing
literature on CL-based approaches applied to foundation language models, such
as pre-trained language models (PLMs), large language models (LLMs) and
vision-language models (VLMs). We divide these studies into offline CL and
online CL, which consist of traditional methods, parameter-efficient-based
methods, instruction tuning-based methods and continual pre-training methods.
Offline CL encompasses domain-incremental learning, task-incremental learning,
and class-incremental learning, while online CL is subdivided into hard task
boundary and blurry task boundary settings. Additionally, we outline the
typical datasets and metrics employed in CL research and provide a detailed
analysis of the challenges and future work for LMs-based continual learning.
|
[
-0.4073367416858673,
-0.7945033311843872,
0.2614801824092865,
0.20111675560474396,
-0.1000661626458168,
0.17563693225383759,
-0.4985799193382263,
-0.6273413896560669,
-0.08199486881494522,
0.7017719745635986,
-0.4706355929374695,
-0.4075356125831604,
-0.44791072607040405,
0.10413073748350143,
-0.464531272649765,
0.6083133816719055,
-0.16924230754375458,
0.21979929506778717,
-0.4090127646923065,
-0.17908808588981628,
-0.7742244005203247,
-0.5361351370811462,
-0.6786165237426758,
-0.3414052724838257,
0.10053224116563797,
0.32912394404411316,
0.19911709427833557,
0.26652950048446655,
0.5178636908531189,
0.22615110874176025,
-0.10160955786705017,
0.07100959867238998,
-0.6169255971908569,
0.007304728031158447,
-0.281802773475647,
-0.18369847536087036,
-0.07573778927326202,
-0.1410588026046753,
0.9773842692375183,
1.2513288259506226,
-0.2088194042444229,
0.01548004150390625,
0.17520704865455627,
0.9224474430084229,
-0.7461513876914978,
-0.07389860600233078,
-0.7331265211105347,
0.03747700899839401,
-0.052784260362386703,
0.060859013348817825,
-0.4990946054458618,
-0.38119906187057495,
0.5908843874931335,
-0.19952541589736938,
0.07407349348068237,
-0.19523011147975922,
0.7037902474403381,
0.1892310082912445,
-0.15228791534900665,
-0.7074589133262634,
-0.7445002794265747,
1.1314570903778076,
-0.5220494866371155,
0.6490064859390259,
0.2507253587245941,
0.2969816029071808,
-0.08244103193283081,
-1.0218148231506348,
-0.24581222236156464,
-0.607193112373352,
0.034782685339450836,
-0.013628678396344185,
0.1262037754058838,
0.0818866491317749,
-0.18232831358909607,
0.45758095383644104,
-0.47269898653030396,
0.13753244280815125,
-0.16722193360328674,
-0.11151838302612305,
0.39894598722457886,
0.09073392301797867,
-0.02806813456118107,
0.21439595520496368,
-0.5792238712310791,
0.12063226848840714,
-0.9439921379089355,
0.20236383378505707,
-0.46949341893196106,
-0.0006947573274374008,
-0.00017765173106454313,
0.14327557384967804,
-0.40645837783813477,
1.4051854610443115,
-0.021130749955773354,
-0.4431561529636383,
0.06315689533948898,
-0.4066449999809265,
-0.16648949682712555,
-0.18744254112243652,
0.4444282054901123,
0.1326754093170166,
0.46904894709587097,
-0.4586285650730133,
-0.25690409541130066,
0.17392121255397797,
0.13829387724399567,
-0.3032609224319458,
-0.17868483066558838,
-0.09800048172473907,
-0.2928464412689209,
-0.15166229009628296,
-0.046248484402894974,
-0.7223760485649109,
-0.09616100043058395,
-0.5956954956054688,
0.26625901460647583,
-0.2566468119621277,
-0.2488653063774109,
0.23598715662956238,
0.3603258430957794,
0.28024551272392273,
0.42902758717536926,
-0.5063593983650208,
0.5035925507545471,
0.34008124470710754,
1.0554484128952026,
-0.6819778084754944,
-0.2249976545572281,
-0.342434287071228,
-0.022073671221733093,
-0.3516760468482971,
0.7664591073989868,
-0.4543376863002777,
-0.4120368957519531,
0.24053919315338135,
0.06136200949549675,
-0.30737483501434326,
-0.6251088976860046,
0.006674738600850105,
-0.530959963798523,
0.18951690196990967,
-0.2610664665699005,
-0.595843493938446,
-0.16209769248962402,
0.5513184666633606,
-0.40776461362838745,
0.9118010997772217,
0.22002477943897247,
-0.449592262506485,
0.158347025513649,
-0.4690157473087311,
-0.3380470275878906,
0.08066648989915848,
-0.15897974371910095,
-0.3657718896865845,
-0.06657994538545609,
-0.17884761095046997,
0.7700569033622742,
-0.23161542415618896,
0.6168774962425232,
-0.23168163001537323,
-0.3609905540943146,
0.16362066566944122,
-0.23726485669612885,
0.6120967268943787,
0.034697797149419785,
-0.67474365234375,
-0.10186965763568878,
-0.8322344422340393,
-0.06044946238398552,
0.040298040956258774,
-0.19171422719955444,
-0.040081508457660675,
0.10399701446294785,
-0.15639075636863708,
0.6093416810035706,
0.38217467069625854,
-0.3531607389450073,
-0.010230470448732376,
-0.4783899188041687,
0.3737376928329468,
0.6490161418914795,
0.14743377268314362,
0.5038349628448486,
-0.4500262141227722,
0.36834314465522766,
-0.10888567566871643,
0.15055981278419495,
-0.34063002467155457,
-0.3117140531539917,
-1.115512490272522,
-0.03392928093671799,
0.1275232434272766,
0.5078319907188416,
-0.7520177960395813,
0.12266258895397186,
-0.48498496413230896,
-0.5352380275726318,
0.05166570469737053,
0.3867429494857788,
0.5665706396102905,
0.5280583500862122,
0.49057018756866455,
-0.6704804301261902,
-0.45629268884658813,
-0.3962138891220093,
0.023059707134962082,
-0.06507231295108795,
0.5047550201416016,
0.33966052532196045,
0.5359408259391785,
-0.320654034614563,
1.1852566003799438,
-0.21925167739391327,
-0.3086276054382324,
-0.3301093578338623,
-0.036150429397821426,
-0.15812751650810242,
0.48801952600479126,
0.6016657948493958,
-0.8288818001747131,
-0.6027371883392334,
-0.005117260850965977,
-0.7642568945884705,
0.10087639838457108,
-0.2313666194677353,
0.2573518455028534,
0.4927999973297119,
0.5188533663749695,
-0.32517072558403015,
0.3839392364025116,
0.46778807044029236,
-0.01576073095202446,
0.7931293249130249,
0.1238953173160553,
-0.04241757467389107,
-0.6634703874588013,
0.23329126834869385,
-0.10490475594997406,
-0.43889936804771423,
-0.7955798506736755,
0.11483656615018845,
-0.053163155913352966,
0.1502780020236969,
-0.6335846185684204,
0.7890586853027344,
-0.783189058303833,
-0.208518385887146,
-0.38256052136421204,
0.26225975155830383,
-0.3342142403125763,
0.5939791202545166,
0.4686451554298401,
0.41936278343200684,
0.7809804081916809,
-1.0011273622512817,
0.5036293864250183,
0.041920751333236694,
-0.30901721119880676,
0.5110177397727966,
-0.4053474962711334,
-0.009037921205163002,
-0.03617335483431816,
0.41842278838157654,
-0.8505593538284302,
0.030697964131832123,
0.33399149775505066,
-0.24022065103054047,
0.46822524070739746,
0.07182808220386505,
-0.3264335095882416,
-0.32855936884880066,
-0.013793104328215122,
0.17118948698043823,
0.49104931950569153,
-0.3946338891983032,
0.4484478533267975,
0.23145470023155212,
-0.1775333136320114,
-0.6122172474861145,
-0.772312343120575,
0.17099729180335999,
-0.0018710261210799217,
-0.4044090211391449,
0.5021596550941467,
-0.16022318601608276,
-0.33249762654304504,
-0.006529321428388357,
-0.09783759713172913,
-0.2094651162624359,
0.13009993731975555,
0.12279786169528961,
0.04233383759856224,
-0.30298998951911926,
0.113823801279068,
-0.3770563304424286,
-0.04221285134553909,
-0.04314509034156799,
-0.4893015921115875,
0.5184621810913086,
-0.5395501852035522,
-0.17143483459949493,
-0.2597613036632538,
0.1572917401790619,
0.3710499405860901,
-0.22636255621910095,
1.0047882795333862,
0.40031352639198303,
-0.47538068890571594,
-0.30233556032180786,
-0.8273224830627441,
-0.08472713828086853,
-0.3734661042690277,
0.21444666385650635,
-0.22714069485664368,
-1.2694319486618042,
0.28532320261001587,
-0.49520882964134216,
0.275310218334198,
0.3754574954509735,
0.587257444858551,
-0.19426721334457397,
0.35691556334495544,
1.0703009366989136,
-0.17543423175811768,
0.5333063006401062,
-0.4267503023147583,
-0.11106208711862564,
-0.3437102437019348,
-0.4353463649749756,
-0.31352677941322327,
0.12249792367219925,
-0.05191284790635109,
-0.18558359146118164,
-0.014231139793992043,
0.5283304452896118,
0.0129547119140625,
0.358450710773468,
-0.24979688227176666,
0.1927487850189209,
-0.03176518529653549,
-0.034905076026916504,
0.23927631974220276,
0.04133526608347893,
-0.19860319793224335,
0.19618192315101624,
-0.8897002339363098,
-0.18458528816699982,
1.0087467432022095,
0.24083936214447021,
0.2770947813987732,
0.0681922435760498,
0.4524537920951843,
0.3657298684120178,
0.7498804926872253,
-0.43789762258529663,
0.5520179867744446,
0.0251871719956398,
-0.5362989902496338,
-0.24644744396209717,
-0.48396146297454834,
-0.6904855370521545,
0.00785861723124981,
-0.0455009900033474,
-0.8165025115013123,
0.24595652520656586,
0.38559094071388245,
0.002888964954763651,
0.33455637097358704,
-0.36906129121780396,
0.826755166053772,
-0.456147164106369,
-0.5242255926132202,
-0.30632707476615906,
-0.9549894332885742,
0.5012720227241516,
-0.35490018129348755,
0.270050048828125,
0.23831889033317566,
0.06833221763372421,
0.5510390996932983,
-0.24065503478050232,
1.0619666576385498,
-0.20228004455566406,
-0.0286256056278944,
0.5647310018539429,
-0.12744435667991638,
0.5157278776168823,
-0.2330215871334076,
0.21471738815307617,
0.22050213813781738,
0.04413534700870514,
-0.4787156879901886,
-0.257949560880661,
0.7500916123390198,
-0.4239428639411926,
-0.19421911239624023,
-0.5629479289054871,
-0.031536925584077835,
-0.6115982532501221,
0.0911812037229538,
0.34037357568740845,
0.5266386270523071,
-0.3015559911727905,
0.37460118532180786,
0.977310836315155,
-0.049903858453035355,
0.5009196996688843,
0.5490708351135254,
-0.2867310047149658,
-0.3341645300388336,
1.0953253507614136,
0.20885416865348816,
0.5804291367530823,
0.5351625680923462,
-0.11902511864900589,
-0.38273295760154724,
-0.6997729539871216,
-0.2517337501049042,
0.3003166615962982,
-0.9250190854072571,
-0.06288989633321762,
-0.6144580841064453,
-0.346021443605423,
-0.3119979500770569,
-0.4045715034008026,
-0.42034703493118286,
-0.18270285427570343,
-0.4685802459716797,
0.2489282339811325,
0.15724293887615204,
0.6655218005180359,
0.10400743037462234,
0.4251079857349396,
-0.7444639205932617,
0.2898766100406647,
0.0859801322221756,
0.48439475893974304,
0.15937215089797974,
-0.5819653272628784,
-0.42970287799835205,
0.09235801547765732,
-0.16257576644420624,
-0.8182356357574463,
0.20055390894412994,
0.5773574709892273,
0.718616247177124,
0.3368019461631775,
-0.18785864114761353,
0.730882465839386,
-0.29931628704071045,
0.9055674076080322,
0.40714749693870544,
-0.6664335131645203,
0.353393018245697,
-0.011753270402550697,
0.2146085947751999,
0.7104608416557312,
0.573504626750946,
-0.5679369568824768,
0.07007715851068497,
-0.4265097677707672,
-0.6796963810920715,
0.3785178065299988,
0.10758773982524872,
-0.2343146800994873,
0.05963369458913803,
0.5716761946678162,
0.06404531747102737,
0.34531503915786743,
-0.8345052003860474,
-0.262650728225708,
-0.21368932723999023,
-0.16094757616519928,
-0.174406036734581,
-0.08428056538105011,
0.3819989264011383,
-0.08816788345575333,
0.7153292894363403,
-0.08931469917297363,
0.12457681447267532,
0.08674431592226028,
-0.7329084873199463,
0.14079563319683075,
0.17614594101905823,
0.7329655885696411,
1.0049207210540771,
-0.1944066435098648,
-0.20941831171512604,
0.39449721574783325,
-0.4978674054145813,
0.20391187071800232,
-0.19371028244495392,
-0.15876491367816925,
0.14090082049369812,
0.33801785111427307,
0.6620576977729797,
0.5927724838256836,
-0.9680824279785156,
0.5263441205024719,
0.1565386950969696,
-0.17636416852474213,
-0.8238771557807922,
0.020176639780402184,
-0.09384611248970032,
-0.19305293262004852,
0.2325640469789505,
0.23228079080581665,
-0.2300349622964859,
-0.4557569921016693,
0.378792405128479,
0.31049829721450806,
-0.7312866449356079,
-0.2142867147922516,
0.17685644328594208,
0.2102060317993164,
-0.007434055209159851,
0.4596233367919922,
-0.018167437985539436,
-0.3438418507575989,
0.3261697292327881,
0.48342883586883545,
0.6473029851913452,
-0.177745521068573,
0.17891770601272583,
0.27706363797187805,
0.2950150668621063,
-0.6396642923355103,
0.05323796346783638,
-0.4140802025794983,
-0.7006237506866455,
-0.4904710352420807,
-0.8586409687995911,
-0.33413001894950867,
0.2957766354084015,
-0.5281402468681335,
0.06759233772754669,
-0.6571716070175171,
0.010024757124483585,
-0.5410046577453613,
0.021752815693616867,
-0.7497245669364929,
0.6706090569496155,
0.04633445292711258,
1.0579280853271484,
-0.5730345249176025,
0.8863198757171631,
0.6914075613021851,
-0.28328296542167664,
-0.243092879652977,
-0.3229900598526001,
0.0016294262604787946,
-0.33040913939476013,
0.4662807583808899,
0.24396955966949463,
-0.46726611256599426,
0.4571619927883148,
-0.5322271585464478,
-0.9023558497428894,
1.1183627843856812,
0.05223226547241211,
-0.7531028389930725,
-0.18054723739624023,
0.14550694823265076,
0.44477421045303345,
-0.4588441848754883,
-0.19371601939201355,
0.5908403992652893,
0.2713703215122223,
0.03987633436918259,
-0.7667645812034607,
-0.4410596191883087,
-0.12798038125038147,
0.037147440016269684,
0.03820382431149483,
-0.545298159122467,
0.39509376883506775,
0.038362231105566025,
-0.3684387505054474,
0.46820521354675293,
0.7062677145004272,
0.35241326689720154,
0.45062941312789917,
0.46847811341285706,
0.5755886435508728,
0.36673566699028015,
-0.21150612831115723,
0.7204087972640991,
-0.4478505849838257,
0.41431042551994324,
0.9916133880615234,
-0.32120150327682495,
0.9554263353347778,
0.3643444776535034,
-0.09569071233272552,
0.6196320056915283,
0.7678569555282593,
-0.0035189136397093534,
0.5908422470092773,
0.24559643864631653,
-0.23027567565441132,
-0.2986376881599426,
-0.08176793158054352,
-0.5706583261489868,
0.17837941646575928,
0.7096037268638611,
-0.18888737261295319,
-0.12312239408493042,
0.32524341344833374,
-0.33686673641204834,
0.15181651711463928,
-0.5280143022537231,
0.6929763555526733,
0.3199841380119324,
-0.709963858127594,
0.6700773239135742,
0.22167663276195526,
0.9239984154701233,
-0.9946956634521484,
0.009258470498025417,
-0.20032712817192078,
0.0833570659160614,
-0.031455375254154205,
-0.4003552198410034,
0.28419259190559387,
0.09771810472011566,
-0.12255220860242844,
-0.2532978653907776,
0.8629276752471924,
-0.2732897698879242,
-0.31514593958854675,
0.2823936939239502,
0.5112659931182861,
0.1800186187028885,
0.04121936112642288,
-0.8243512511253357,
0.008867266587913036,
-0.13388387858867645,
-0.17235110700130463,
0.31562650203704834,
-0.009087718091905117,
-0.22672587633132935,
1.0306600332260132,
0.6781986355781555,
0.13489262759685516,
0.3275846838951111,
-0.1072547435760498,
0.7078003883361816,
-0.7890032529830933,
-0.5223873853683472,
-0.5537001490592957,
0.5309750437736511,
0.17882846295833588,
-0.41720759868621826,
0.5082668662071228,
0.21251650154590607,
1.1812187433242798,
-0.11224457621574402,
0.6507765054702759,
0.11479326337575912,
0.3997267186641693,
-0.8294450044631958,
0.4862600564956665,
-0.5814846754074097,
0.14049117267131805,
-0.34267324209213257,
-0.911927342414856,
-0.36608484387397766,
0.5368388891220093,
-0.2120218276977539,
0.2156153917312622,
0.7297167778015137,
0.5026649832725525,
0.06264583766460419,
-0.1322067230939865,
0.3454338312149048,
0.06793331354856491,
-0.05295204743742943,
0.6314051151275635,
0.8337866067886353,
-0.06500087678432465,
0.33336764574050903,
-0.22397752106189728,
-0.07659689337015152,
-0.42062145471572876,
-0.8100765943527222,
-0.778992235660553,
-0.7098539471626282,
-0.3829542398452759,
-0.045766957104206085,
0.416114866733551,
0.6973943710327148,
0.7300553917884827,
-0.9770969748497009,
-0.28010764718055725,
-0.6481940746307373,
-0.13031376898288727,
-0.3010908365249634,
-0.1792329102754593,
0.3119099736213684,
-0.39274680614471436,
-0.1672016978263855,
0.433328241109848,
0.3487454354763031,
0.01285506784915924,
-0.5709524750709534,
-0.4696170687675476,
-0.3972775638103485,
-0.2877773940563202,
0.5904425978660583,
0.742168664932251,
-0.953107476234436,
-0.004453088156878948,
0.10831072181463242,
-0.141427680850029,
-0.012225267477333546,
0.6971208453178406,
-1.1157783269882202,
0.5044733881950378,
0.2846525013446808,
1.005000114440918,
0.43789806962013245,
-0.2214869260787964,
0.4082009792327881,
-0.6302240490913391,
-0.02591724693775177,
0.27660366892814636,
0.3270135819911957,
0.6203401684761047,
-0.09998725354671478,
0.4009906053543091,
0.6929376125335693,
-0.39268800616264343,
-0.7967817783355713,
0.44719499349594116,
-0.907062828540802,
-0.42035534977912903,
0.9334966540336609,
-0.4510051906108856,
0.00878559798002243,
-0.47883084416389465,
0.2614681124687195,
0.134434312582016,
0.22737997770309448,
0.5623568296432495,
0.6749910116195679,
0.04304718226194382,
-0.48671436309814453,
-0.4970555305480957,
0.49990329146385193,
0.35583388805389404,
-0.7540054321289062,
-0.24260851740837097,
0.5616992712020874,
0.3953796327114105,
0.16386695206165314,
0.6567052006721497,
-0.1162799820303917,
0.42304566502571106,
-0.31822165846824646,
-0.05649906396865845,
-0.025390150025486946,
-0.8620690703392029,
-0.551673412322998,
0.27104949951171875,
0.013665085658431053,
0.22756370902061462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02577v1
|
Are PPO-ed Language Models Hackable?
| 2024-05-28T23:28:28 | 2024-05-28T23:28:28 |
Suraj Anand, David Getzen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Numerous algorithms have been proposed to $\textit{align}$ language models to
remove undesirable behaviors. However, the challenges associated with a very
large state space and creating a proper reward function often result in various
jailbreaks. Our paper aims to examine this effect of reward in the controlled
setting of positive sentiment language generation. Instead of online training
of a reward model based on human feedback, we employ a statically learned
sentiment classifier. We also consider a setting where our model's weights and
activations are exposed to an end-user after training. We examine a pretrained
GPT-2 through the lens of mechanistic interpretability before and after
proximal policy optimization (PPO) has been applied to promote positive
sentiment responses. Using these insights, we (1) attempt to "hack" the PPO-ed
model to generate negative sentiment responses and (2) add a term to the reward
function to try and alter `negative' weights.
|
[
-0.25313466787338257,
-0.49846962094306946,
0.3941528797149658,
0.036492422223091125,
-0.4069862961769104,
0.07840520143508911,
-0.016337493434548378,
-0.23592573404312134,
0.21908751130104065,
0.4670269787311554,
-0.7554116249084473,
-0.040764663368463516,
-0.5133804678916931,
-0.00924609787762165,
0.009411967359483242,
1.6252683401107788,
0.03605184331536293,
0.027663657441735268,
-0.06642957776784897,
0.3420936167240143,
-0.43572351336479187,
-0.8882991075515747,
-0.44608691334724426,
-0.39950117468833923,
0.28745388984680176,
0.17050139605998993,
0.7208040952682495,
0.19754907488822937,
0.3625503182411194,
0.2597980797290802,
0.06168867647647858,
-0.3452729284763336,
-0.6318241953849792,
-0.270127534866333,
-0.36468639969825745,
-0.5438365340232849,
-0.8103434443473816,
0.41833168268203735,
0.16945986449718475,
0.10321366041898727,
-0.3929222822189331,
-0.3299536108970642,
0.1488209217786789,
0.385389506816864,
-0.669366717338562,
-0.043456267565488815,
-0.8189200162887573,
-0.040670547634363174,
-0.08545497059822083,
-0.061863645911216736,
-0.4339197278022766,
-0.529818058013916,
-0.05002050846815109,
-0.6500657200813293,
-0.1561063975095749,
-0.379528671503067,
1.0829137563705444,
0.05967160314321518,
-0.13527582585811615,
-0.6221029758453369,
-0.5295489430427551,
0.8935533761978149,
-0.7293799519538879,
-0.15553265810012817,
0.5809993147850037,
-0.0009452453232370317,
-0.11494744569063187,
-0.3495251536369324,
-0.778231143951416,
-0.328310489654541,
-0.04296061769127846,
0.48768743872642517,
-0.10480697453022003,
0.23734690248966217,
0.0230560302734375,
0.30493348836898804,
-0.12552618980407715,
0.12108580023050308,
-0.1277647763490677,
-0.1948026567697525,
0.561324954032898,
-0.036432597786188126,
0.36094939708709717,
-0.45706692337989807,
-0.34923073649406433,
-0.20633834600448608,
-0.7541441917419434,
0.35179752111434937,
0.988044798374176,
0.3033665716648102,
0.026453714817762375,
0.5538813471794128,
0.10771134495735168,
0.5104010105133057,
-0.27584871649742126,
-0.08632160723209381,
0.1614193469285965,
-0.24521629512310028,
-0.2050720453262329,
-0.281826913356781,
0.6727649569511414,
0.3405460715293884,
0.52470463514328,
-0.2680389881134033,
-0.6701276302337646,
0.2979156970977783,
0.5801606178283691,
-0.6383634805679321,
-0.26400962471961975,
0.3161706030368805,
-0.12940475344657898,
-1.0491745471954346,
0.3086497485637665,
-0.6866864562034607,
-0.25715941190719604,
-0.23252055048942566,
0.7077526450157166,
-0.3783167004585266,
-0.465385764837265,
0.12961742281913757,
-0.31394830346107483,
0.32684674859046936,
0.25985243916511536,
-0.7809537649154663,
0.35549062490463257,
0.8782455325126648,
0.6354348659515381,
0.2990107834339142,
-0.3832060694694519,
-0.4734383821487427,
-0.14991620182991028,
-0.29507875442504883,
0.38438698649406433,
-0.6370148062705994,
-0.49122968316078186,
0.13694259524345398,
-0.1820092350244522,
0.010196838527917862,
-0.452698677778244,
0.5107287168502808,
-0.6852701902389526,
0.5749810934066772,
-0.28128358721733093,
-0.4845920205116272,
0.31660664081573486,
0.35964104533195496,
-0.1575482338666916,
0.47009262442588806,
0.3738451302051544,
-0.765597939491272,
0.36931052803993225,
-0.6989306211471558,
-0.6431624889373779,
-0.09638786315917969,
0.22525851428508759,
-0.5407549738883972,
0.2979016900062561,
-0.05272502824664116,
0.1746627539396286,
0.02525229938328266,
0.6112598180770874,
-0.3390604555606842,
-0.3855925500392914,
0.48353639245033264,
-0.33180880546569824,
0.8016062378883362,
0.3123033940792084,
-0.46006444096565247,
-0.0061726802960038185,
-0.533218264579773,
-0.0828598141670227,
0.3017693758010864,
-0.3512784540653229,
-0.5442976951599121,
0.20341578125953674,
-0.17829380929470062,
0.4546031355857849,
0.2483578324317932,
-0.7505289912223816,
0.44055214524269104,
-0.4697168469429016,
0.5283955335617065,
1.1951872110366821,
-0.0017393630696460605,
0.4284050762653351,
0.01206350326538086,
0.6870824694633484,
-0.14570176601409912,
0.44405224919319153,
0.06481876224279404,
-0.09713537991046906,
-0.3958300054073334,
-0.4421006739139557,
0.1334909200668335,
0.8305510878562927,
-0.8661839365959167,
0.5176984071731567,
0.06671109050512314,
-0.26003497838974,
-0.3651318848133087,
0.019184354692697525,
0.520958662033081,
0.6012371182441711,
0.23732130229473114,
-0.20038911700248718,
-0.06253866106271744,
-0.7552260160446167,
-0.4604618549346924,
-0.08198929578065872,
-0.3744019567966461,
0.49776220321655273,
0.41740646958351135,
-0.06405135989189148,
0.6763762831687927,
-0.6063496470451355,
-0.2596060633659363,
-0.22343799471855164,
0.3416927754878998,
0.2510242760181427,
0.5805889964103699,
0.29480868577957153,
-0.5800303220748901,
-0.22124050557613373,
-0.32901257276535034,
-0.575745701789856,
-0.32193687558174133,
-0.25818461179733276,
0.09531611204147339,
-0.0782000869512558,
0.3501945436000824,
-0.4431993067264557,
0.11716552078723907,
0.3975394368171692,
-0.4389648139476776,
0.6647369861602783,
-0.2631613314151764,
0.11998319625854492,
-0.9880310893058777,
0.0703289583325386,
-0.064747154712677,
-0.1623472422361374,
-0.5780982971191406,
0.2258780151605606,
0.09692209959030151,
-0.3855826258659363,
-0.4328387975692749,
0.1561039686203003,
-0.20773877203464508,
0.353102445602417,
-0.4620038866996765,
-0.06864622980356216,
-0.20013126730918884,
0.5253065228462219,
-0.06732170283794403,
0.9489677548408508,
0.6343393921852112,
-0.4190858006477356,
-0.014257830567657948,
-0.013368499465286732,
-0.1127319410443306,
0.5513462424278259,
-0.8713148832321167,
0.4326627850532532,
-0.2209528386592865,
0.058057572692632675,
-0.9147284030914307,
-0.5054283738136292,
0.24617895483970642,
-0.24899427592754364,
0.5316494107246399,
-0.12898826599121094,
-0.4000019431114197,
-0.24993516504764557,
-0.7400932312011719,
0.0779162049293518,
0.5784921646118164,
-0.37393811345100403,
-0.07383885234594345,
0.5385180711746216,
-0.15934616327285767,
-0.5328290462493896,
-0.3601345419883728,
0.054233599454164505,
-0.39215901494026184,
-0.11904121190309525,
0.22924543917179108,
0.24635720252990723,
-0.2779562473297119,
-0.19869501888751984,
0.22663024067878723,
0.2151414453983307,
0.3516443073749542,
0.047290150076150894,
0.4926593601703644,
0.2776924669742584,
0.10453978925943375,
0.11572743207216263,
-0.09363935887813568,
0.11619943380355835,
-0.22290757298469543,
0.7356236577033997,
-0.1924852728843689,
-0.01965264044702053,
-0.47907304763793945,
0.11741775274276733,
0.4375389516353607,
-0.35476136207580566,
0.7698232531547546,
0.1500050276517868,
-0.25994956493377686,
-0.06081673875451088,
0.012749575078487396,
-0.4415026903152466,
-0.5749424695968628,
0.38945531845092773,
-0.35670769214630127,
-1.0473954677581787,
0.15327011048793793,
-0.1329285353422165,
-0.125382661819458,
0.04025689885020256,
0.37481456995010376,
-0.18671561777591705,
1.1958904266357422,
0.6515025496482849,
-0.121321901679039,
0.7515088319778442,
0.12052963674068451,
0.28957369923591614,
-0.7708470821380615,
-0.1853395700454712,
-0.35891464352607727,
-0.21499580144882202,
-0.8025921583175659,
-0.05157078802585602,
0.2359408140182495,
0.5203456878662109,
-0.2799164354801178,
0.35875722765922546,
-0.5687523484230042,
0.6588757634162903,
0.5228917002677917,
0.182807058095932,
-0.3088817596435547,
-0.06912165135145187,
0.14868009090423584,
-0.13621646165847778,
-0.3661242127418518,
-0.39684274792671204,
1.0239702463150024,
0.391612708568573,
0.7065405249595642,
0.08574166148900986,
0.8906420469284058,
0.2880105674266815,
0.6420381665229797,
-0.7094290256500244,
0.43592867255210876,
-0.20962809026241302,
-0.42156219482421875,
-0.2609369456768036,
-0.3158314824104309,
-0.5951709151268005,
-0.04662515968084335,
-0.014661397784948349,
-1.0924123525619507,
0.08281668275594711,
0.45007404685020447,
-0.1100553572177887,
0.1218373253941536,
-0.9684339761734009,
0.9051417708396912,
-0.31802988052368164,
-0.6903519034385681,
-0.30625012516975403,
-0.5882866978645325,
0.4067922532558441,
-0.06235621124505997,
0.29497230052948,
0.10788245499134064,
0.24881692230701447,
0.6639994978904724,
-0.720933735370636,
0.7802366018295288,
-0.7222980260848999,
-0.059133946895599365,
0.2809582054615021,
0.40281978249549866,
0.8710076808929443,
0.1558302789926529,
0.028763694688677788,
-0.02778753452003002,
-0.26418814063072205,
-0.45222336053848267,
-0.43104779720306396,
0.6583344340324402,
-0.9681447148323059,
-0.7126629948616028,
-0.39721447229385376,
-0.35754695534706116,
-0.37016797065734863,
0.13706934452056885,
0.4434414207935333,
0.3981536328792572,
-0.03046608716249466,
-0.2861608862876892,
0.37035679817199707,
-0.5092071890830994,
0.23130767047405243,
0.3661080598831177,
-0.19803430140018463,
-0.3997211754322052,
1.2901099920272827,
0.024043824523687363,
0.2966517508029938,
0.4917616546154022,
0.45428818464279175,
-0.11306030303239822,
-0.298406720161438,
-0.09268184751272202,
0.20148314535617828,
-0.248104065656662,
-0.13602875173091888,
-0.1468503475189209,
0.18644070625305176,
-0.28857114911079407,
-0.5124756693840027,
-0.48760247230529785,
-0.4740699827671051,
-0.2682650685310364,
-0.2377026379108429,
-0.06784232705831528,
0.7945736646652222,
-0.1805710345506668,
0.5036131739616394,
-0.36671242117881775,
-0.04179363697767258,
0.3482212424278259,
0.5771573781967163,
-0.21772132813930511,
-0.2780078053474426,
0.031392019242048264,
0.02434849925339222,
-0.31434398889541626,
-1.1719563007354736,
0.44329312443733215,
-0.13422653079032898,
0.12447085231542587,
0.5292485952377319,
0.023164400830864906,
0.3210671544075012,
-0.3785497546195984,
0.8915921449661255,
0.40693607926368713,
-1.1316957473754883,
0.7950342893600464,
-0.5473228693008423,
0.2199733555316925,
0.5025033950805664,
0.32986730337142944,
-0.28118598461151123,
-0.5638558864593506,
-0.6224905252456665,
-0.9462688565254211,
0.9446722865104675,
0.01396121084690094,
0.7066358327865601,
-0.2569996118545532,
0.5162606239318848,
0.10592573136091232,
0.5144087672233582,
-1.1574389934539795,
0.2055751085281372,
-0.7818937301635742,
-0.028742700815200806,
-0.03261001780629158,
-0.42676061391830444,
-0.12274335324764252,
-0.10480175167322159,
0.8262439370155334,
0.019273757934570312,
0.38449525833129883,
0.02971041388809681,
-0.03448588401079178,
-0.020553376525640488,
0.6613506078720093,
0.6113635897636414,
0.492096871137619,
-0.3469923436641693,
0.030285069718956947,
-0.37431347370147705,
-0.2888394892215729,
0.03015778586268425,
-0.02476038970053196,
-0.32152488827705383,
-0.5570268630981445,
0.0948023870587349,
0.7623564600944519,
-0.10174820572137833,
-0.6142733097076416,
0.7866339683532715,
0.021080728620290756,
-0.27565547823905945,
-0.12968479096889496,
0.17894631624221802,
-0.12662187218666077,
-0.09823548793792725,
0.030007798224687576,
-0.0064554642885923386,
0.10494246333837509,
-0.6193897128105164,
0.1510191112756729,
0.7982636094093323,
-0.7026413679122925,
-0.8047968149185181,
0.7548019886016846,
0.13914260268211365,
-0.526339590549469,
0.8261157274246216,
-0.5908476114273071,
-0.8794311881065369,
0.37344858050346375,
0.7944029569625854,
0.8129169344902039,
-0.1466841995716095,
0.6600629687309265,
0.3231067359447479,
0.4570106863975525,
0.2648218870162964,
0.32310062646865845,
-0.06573265045881271,
-0.9641808271408081,
-0.32983919978141785,
-0.7151265144348145,
-0.30181223154067993,
0.49413320422172546,
-0.7265270352363586,
0.2486761063337326,
-0.46933433413505554,
-0.06844975054264069,
-0.14153270423412323,
-0.4167635142803192,
-0.4629712998867035,
0.2647230327129364,
-0.026878224685788155,
0.5552355051040649,
-1.0761526823043823,
0.8603432774543762,
0.8660087585449219,
-0.35655125975608826,
-0.9695397615432739,
0.27977827191352844,
-0.060473665595054626,
-0.8111580014228821,
0.2475474327802658,
0.03632214292883873,
-0.08347131311893463,
-0.0564487986266613,
-0.8465544581413269,
-0.16736824810504913,
0.6533592939376831,
0.28153282403945923,
-0.38241079449653625,
0.16716626286506653,
0.19468066096305847,
0.7381256818771362,
0.06315188854932785,
0.05329176038503647,
0.4635525941848755,
0.17614474892616272,
-0.31578516960144043,
-0.6803998351097107,
-0.032497357577085495,
-0.2944882810115814,
-0.1712624579668045,
0.455834299325943,
-0.6081830859184265,
1.1193933486938477,
-0.14986483752727509,
0.07391192764043808,
-0.3336726129055023,
0.0850352793931961,
-0.0017748211976140738,
0.05296154320240021,
0.5328775644302368,
0.4948616027832031,
0.607801616191864,
-0.06411776691675186,
1.5141862630844116,
-0.3275180757045746,
0.638468325138092,
0.9014357328414917,
-0.40092724561691284,
0.749768078327179,
0.8235518932342529,
-0.2363540679216385,
0.4200892448425293,
0.363749235868454,
0.12723921239376068,
1.0287563800811768,
0.3279511332511902,
-0.3314559757709503,
-0.1879049688577652,
-0.16010728478431702,
0.06388283520936966,
0.45203083753585815,
0.02865881286561489,
-0.12677520513534546,
-0.11772826313972473,
0.05501279607415199,
0.5326912999153137,
0.08234969526529312,
-0.37094220519065857,
0.9202440977096558,
-0.008839649148285389,
-0.956585168838501,
0.2812504470348358,
0.26236000657081604,
0.7972445487976074,
-0.7711127400398254,
0.0937511995434761,
-0.27879709005355835,
0.38518041372299194,
-0.13674886524677277,
-0.8053790926933289,
0.24231445789337158,
0.21475836634635925,
0.1239936426281929,
-0.4692975878715515,
0.9044272303581238,
-0.1730974167585373,
-0.3137166500091553,
0.08042894303798676,
0.383116751909256,
-0.17275714874267578,
-0.18472225964069366,
-0.6002823710441589,
-0.37569719552993774,
0.13587574660778046,
-0.5327946543693542,
0.746012806892395,
0.027872158214449883,
-0.02427498809993267,
0.3075137138366699,
0.6582467555999756,
0.1394374817609787,
-0.30260780453681946,
-0.024746593087911606,
0.9563301801681519,
-0.25824716687202454,
-0.8416200876235962,
-1.0659929513931274,
0.5234904289245605,
-0.06679148972034454,
-0.29513031244277954,
0.6079909801483154,
0.33787789940834045,
0.9775566458702087,
-0.25167036056518555,
0.9212430715560913,
-0.351012647151947,
0.33716803789138794,
-0.4293045997619629,
0.7289085388183594,
-0.6684387922286987,
0.2640438377857208,
-0.6070216298103333,
-0.5621822476387024,
-0.1010797992348671,
0.6985024213790894,
-0.6490263938903809,
-0.15837489068508148,
0.3291459083557129,
0.7981264591217041,
0.07522489130496979,
0.10136230289936066,
0.06801876425743103,
0.1339489370584488,
0.4943535625934601,
0.4285208582878113,
0.9015129208564758,
-0.012702291831374168,
0.2902844250202179,
-0.43592506647109985,
-0.6643520593643188,
0.1958257555961609,
-0.8829261064529419,
-0.5563977956771851,
-0.25105100870132446,
-0.14461228251457214,
-0.4442936182022095,
0.18864621222019196,
0.7681419253349304,
0.2749662399291992,
-0.9363059401512146,
-0.2434675246477127,
-0.6156679391860962,
0.11551324278116226,
-0.2174825668334961,
-0.3405022621154785,
0.29511845111846924,
-0.4235508441925049,
-0.5982998013496399,
0.19642502069473267,
0.27319255471229553,
-0.12418175488710403,
-0.04547988250851631,
-0.20912900567054749,
0.11016510426998138,
0.2754741609096527,
0.5633090138435364,
0.2047877460718155,
-0.27744436264038086,
-0.5319720506668091,
0.13631415367126465,
0.004925779532641172,
0.029179591685533524,
1.0739824771881104,
-0.6481927037239075,
0.5888964533805847,
0.3257114887237549,
0.33221399784088135,
0.14612539112567902,
0.2545877695083618,
0.7212172746658325,
-0.8566315174102783,
0.20776841044425964,
0.4344334006309509,
0.24992966651916504,
0.23087897896766663,
-0.35938528180122375,
0.13004310429096222,
0.23205092549324036,
-0.5115753412246704,
-0.966877281665802,
0.33303090929985046,
-0.49134936928749084,
-0.4601462483406067,
1.0312891006469727,
-0.24299250543117523,
-0.02652885392308235,
0.2411288022994995,
-0.1614828109741211,
0.14519771933555603,
-0.2953132688999176,
1.1291706562042236,
0.7088755369186401,
-0.2338704764842987,
0.042533379048109055,
-0.3238316774368286,
0.6325128078460693,
0.4453331232070923,
-0.8757586479187012,
0.031887251883745193,
0.44193902611732483,
0.3501792848110199,
-0.0005420134984888136,
0.7334719896316528,
-0.3389296233654022,
0.2511715292930603,
-0.011274740099906921,
0.038683366030454636,
-0.26394790410995483,
-0.3865763247013092,
-0.47444623708724976,
0.23982153832912445,
0.3121658265590668,
-0.10673767328262329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18649v1
|
Training LLMs to Better Self-Debug and Explain Code
| 2024-05-28T23:20:24 | 2024-05-28T23:20:24 |
Nan Jiang, Xiaopeng Li, Shiqi Wang, Qiang Zhou, Soneya Binta Hossain, Baishakhi Ray, Varun Kumar, Xiaofei Ma, Anoop Deoras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
In the domain of code generation, self-debugging is crucial. It allows LLMs
to refine their generated code based on execution feedback. This is
particularly important because generating correct solutions in one attempt
proves challenging for complex tasks. Prior works on self-debugging mostly
focus on prompting methods by providing LLMs with few-shot examples, which work
poorly on small open-sourced LLMs. In this work, we propose a training
framework that significantly improves self-debugging capability of LLMs.
Intuitively, we observe that a chain of explanations on the wrong code followed
by code refinement helps LLMs better analyze the wrong code and do refinement.
We thus propose an automated pipeline to collect a high-quality dataset for
code explanation and refinement by generating a number of explanations and
refinement trajectories and filtering via execution verification. We perform
supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and further reinforcement learning (RL) on both
success and failure trajectories with a novel reward design considering code
explanation and refinement quality. SFT improves the pass@1 by up to 15.92% and
pass@10 by 9.30% over four benchmarks. RL training brings additional up to
3.54% improvement on pass@1 and 2.55% improvement on pass@10. The trained LLMs
show iterative refinement ability, and can keep refining code continuously.
Lastly, our human evaluation shows that the LLMs trained with our framework
generate more useful code explanations and help developers better understand
bugs in source code.
|
[
-0.1787816435098648,
-0.45825880765914917,
0.5283799767494202,
0.313344806432724,
-0.24741408228874207,
0.19903446733951569,
-0.15245459973812103,
-0.10726252943277359,
-0.05458555370569229,
0.4940617084503174,
-0.9155741333961487,
-0.5940062999725342,
-0.40478068590164185,
0.29684051871299744,
-0.12946148216724396,
1.027159333229065,
-0.27879104018211365,
-0.00969018042087555,
-0.09133372455835342,
0.14336241781711578,
-0.6521403193473816,
-0.2757902145385742,
-0.7099958658218384,
-0.28920111060142517,
0.5909255146980286,
0.7498546242713928,
0.10850106179714203,
0.9048677086830139,
0.3645114302635193,
0.3364841639995575,
0.30044376850128174,
0.18089710175991058,
-0.7211071848869324,
0.043179310858249664,
-0.2143963873386383,
-0.6050476431846619,
-0.17673122882843018,
-0.36048397421836853,
-0.09555104374885559,
0.24536651372909546,
-0.20456720888614655,
0.40568724274635315,
0.30718889832496643,
0.9538747668266296,
-0.4736200273036957,
0.14765793085098267,
-0.4072807729244232,
0.2621442675590515,
0.1030116006731987,
-0.7501431107521057,
-0.19951069355010986,
-0.2723700702190399,
-0.5269253253936768,
-0.5130205154418945,
0.34017279744148254,
-0.12956087291240692,
0.6215628981590271,
0.8786216378211975,
-0.11240969598293304,
-0.27781039476394653,
-0.5044581294059753,
0.49861884117126465,
-0.7293692827224731,
0.08418833464384079,
0.043550603091716766,
0.4248853623867035,
-0.0951879695057869,
-0.5739179253578186,
-0.14418429136276245,
-0.1574002057313919,
-0.16313722729682922,
0.12285863608121872,
0.21518248319625854,
-0.013992182910442352,
0.26899001002311707,
0.4048163592815399,
-0.6718239784240723,
0.33230605721473694,
-0.5098408460617065,
-0.28149378299713135,
0.8166744112968445,
0.21409794688224792,
-0.1306237429380417,
-0.0943925753235817,
-0.651390016078949,
0.1266358345746994,
-0.7192602157592773,
0.061253949999809265,
0.2657219171524048,
0.08387506008148193,
0.0708952248096466,
0.0783945694565773,
-0.26711833477020264,
0.6720179915428162,
0.202581986784935,
-0.13818752765655518,
0.2781115770339966,
-0.18872492015361786,
-0.27731072902679443,
0.02032209001481533,
0.4363921582698822,
0.2943596839904785,
0.24786345660686493,
-0.3496566116809845,
-0.2985035479068756,
-0.11397404968738556,
0.5019900798797607,
-0.7938951253890991,
-0.4165414273738861,
0.4136925935745239,
-0.5931074023246765,
-0.6172640919685364,
-0.06719742715358734,
-0.6290081739425659,
-0.48998525738716125,
-0.6563081741333008,
0.40768396854400635,
-0.38918355107307434,
-0.2779516577720642,
0.41165098547935486,
-0.05102428421378136,
0.19465667009353638,
0.28539159893989563,
-0.9102067947387695,
-0.15895724296569824,
0.6409029960632324,
0.5200045108795166,
-0.295394629240036,
-0.301227331161499,
-0.7578296661376953,
0.10306015610694885,
-0.3211617171764374,
0.936004638671875,
0.06314122676849365,
-0.2116318643093109,
-0.19659274816513062,
-0.0002636436838656664,
0.19497562944889069,
-0.7731503844261169,
0.13112764060497284,
-0.3157069981098175,
-0.12763991951942444,
-0.03311743959784508,
-0.5260981917381287,
0.0030841685365885496,
0.420349657535553,
-0.23096957802772522,
0.8061083555221558,
0.15432387590408325,
-0.3394298553466797,
0.30628257989883423,
-0.7576935291290283,
-0.24427913129329681,
0.0036141215823590755,
-0.3253421187400818,
-0.3604190945625305,
0.12023603171110153,
0.3728557825088501,
0.5819956660270691,
0.167457714676857,
0.18254585564136505,
-0.25855112075805664,
-0.7523549199104309,
0.01519104465842247,
-0.07938090711832047,
0.5532137751579285,
0.39534541964530945,
-0.7331376075744629,
0.21346639096736908,
-0.8481373190879822,
0.35557448863983154,
0.20111429691314697,
-0.3748263716697693,
0.2418309450149536,
-0.2793189585208893,
-0.5854097008705139,
0.11693152785301208,
0.021659845486283302,
-0.16778993606567383,
0.32170119881629944,
-0.3862464129924774,
0.4018210768699646,
1.0262951850891113,
0.24064959585666656,
0.19118653237819672,
-0.1546027511358261,
0.9823030829429626,
0.14267703890800476,
0.24581913650035858,
-0.48662489652633667,
0.06676926463842392,
-0.7754104733467102,
-0.2027072161436081,
0.19068557024002075,
0.5262675285339355,
-0.6747401356697083,
0.39832255244255066,
0.19450320303440094,
-0.13923868536949158,
-0.6354947090148926,
0.6648569703102112,
0.5530962347984314,
0.5930517315864563,
0.47975191473960876,
-0.28651726245880127,
-0.5801202654838562,
-0.7523255944252014,
-0.38829007744789124,
-0.10080035030841827,
-0.11437314748764038,
0.006337040103971958,
0.5134720802307129,
-0.3722512125968933,
0.8936449885368347,
-0.3516135513782501,
-0.28342142701148987,
-0.18750552833080292,
0.20057016611099243,
0.16705800592899323,
0.48708951473236084,
0.3113996982574463,
-0.32084280252456665,
-0.05829409882426262,
-0.4025128483772278,
-0.7447090148925781,
-0.22609922289848328,
-0.4606393277645111,
-0.016850626096129417,
0.19098658859729767,
0.7054756879806519,
0.19192451238632202,
0.35287898778915405,
0.3918437659740448,
-0.4648791551589966,
0.6175981163978577,
-0.3591821789741516,
-0.01992253214120865,
-0.6690974831581116,
-0.1536542922258377,
-0.21605384349822998,
-0.33452707529067993,
0.16724766790866852,
0.13294963538646698,
0.16964514553546906,
-0.07765919715166092,
-0.4800336956977844,
0.25987306237220764,
-0.44143807888031006,
-0.24120540916919708,
-0.30662402510643005,
0.03128495812416077,
0.1176435574889183,
0.8682457804679871,
-0.3691287636756897,
0.7215198874473572,
0.5307932496070862,
-0.7019399404525757,
0.6624650359153748,
-0.06233799457550049,
-0.313386470079422,
0.4113369584083557,
-0.7076355814933777,
0.11340983211994171,
-0.1667657345533371,
0.15222914516925812,
-1.1222662925720215,
0.005648389924317598,
0.27455297112464905,
-0.42285096645355225,
0.32500872015953064,
-0.4441283643245697,
-0.48696449398994446,
-0.4842766225337982,
-0.18607281148433685,
-0.27520060539245605,
0.4706619083881378,
-1.0918750762939453,
0.055871665477752686,
-0.3323417603969574,
0.29080918431282043,
-0.582880437374115,
-0.7470042109489441,
-0.14846985042095184,
-0.39732789993286133,
-0.5278133153915405,
0.20804144442081451,
-0.3228054940700531,
-0.07248014211654663,
-0.20074239373207092,
-0.581213116645813,
-0.0283990278840065,
0.5973940491676331,
0.4081544578075409,
-0.0070688920095562935,
-0.11805325746536255,
0.5676199793815613,
-0.062015894800424576,
-0.6036105751991272,
0.37429118156433105,
-0.32905611395835876,
0.1447063535451889,
-0.3368900418281555,
-0.5604748129844666,
-0.5084273219108582,
-0.07925239205360413,
0.11686675995588303,
-0.23745320737361908,
0.36313098669052124,
0.7898821234703064,
0.23153187334537506,
-0.5500864386558533,
-0.3542807996273041,
-0.4487932324409485,
-0.5190873146057129,
0.11327432096004486,
-0.5515902638435364,
-0.9713481664657593,
0.3507111072540283,
-0.5054172277450562,
0.07359888404607773,
0.3577083945274353,
0.4189857244491577,
-0.2702988088130951,
0.9491496682167053,
0.6540544629096985,
-0.031607937067747116,
0.2658742070198059,
-0.5932556986808777,
0.030615312978625298,
-0.503778874874115,
-0.2210385948419571,
-0.31491634249687195,
-0.41262564063072205,
-0.25770753622055054,
-0.35661235451698303,
0.03090391308069229,
0.5786262154579163,
-0.31561657786369324,
0.13016240298748016,
-0.9022395610809326,
0.8677177429199219,
0.3404068350791931,
0.11446019262075424,
0.39295634627342224,
0.07985446602106094,
-0.20702603459358215,
0.04688134416937828,
-0.7251147627830505,
-0.5120416879653931,
0.9113425612449646,
0.688567042350769,
1.1422433853149414,
-0.1038723886013031,
1.3284385204315186,
0.44484931230545044,
0.25369784235954285,
-0.48608627915382385,
0.18633784353733063,
0.33967605233192444,
-0.31682759523391724,
-0.1735474020242691,
-0.4600617587566376,
-0.715202808380127,
0.15408669412136078,
0.2501491606235504,
-0.36406663060188293,
-0.025900203734636307,
0.6586325764656067,
-0.6498792171478271,
-0.019862385466694832,
-0.9557628035545349,
1.239365577697754,
-0.6036550998687744,
-0.38364285230636597,
-0.4313136339187622,
-0.45134612917900085,
0.34282031655311584,
0.18142274022102356,
0.3244215250015259,
-0.09111224859952927,
0.07898736000061035,
0.4241490960121155,
-0.5491435527801514,
0.9625226259231567,
-0.3393830358982086,
-0.48647764325141907,
0.26761701703071594,
0.3310866355895996,
0.4310018718242645,
0.5454846620559692,
-0.07444342970848083,
0.015469572506844997,
-0.1185164600610733,
-0.49273744225502014,
-0.8819190859794617,
0.7988430261611938,
-0.5662825703620911,
-0.5469071269035339,
-0.06862276792526245,
-0.09617350995540619,
-0.005087992176413536,
-0.20201347768306732,
0.1623079925775528,
0.413528174161911,
0.3026783764362335,
-0.050625771284103394,
0.7677232027053833,
-0.29432016611099243,
0.3859112858772278,
0.7136229276657104,
-0.22852851450443268,
-0.1613394021987915,
0.8564193248748779,
-0.346549391746521,
-0.017216533422470093,
0.05158376321196556,
0.08285822719335556,
-0.20184633135795593,
-0.5567903518676758,
-0.7243697047233582,
0.01587550900876522,
-0.7613078355789185,
-0.6778751611709595,
-0.20922556519508362,
-0.011765921488404274,
-0.1511169821023941,
-0.2652415931224823,
-0.20821169018745422,
-0.36410093307495117,
-0.3501870334148407,
-0.3718283176422119,
0.4803912937641144,
0.6986104249954224,
-0.344235897064209,
0.2865443527698517,
-0.6966426968574524,
0.45116811990737915,
0.42664265632629395,
0.6913485527038574,
0.007354562636464834,
-0.6060370206832886,
-0.48988077044487,
-0.04274508357048035,
-0.41806355118751526,
-0.8201400637626648,
0.30291202664375305,
-0.08301015198230743,
0.5166120529174805,
0.350923091173172,
0.0014687797520309687,
0.9110873341560364,
-0.2466476708650589,
0.6282693147659302,
0.06676116585731506,
-0.9354763627052307,
0.8825621008872986,
-0.013635200448334217,
0.32773277163505554,
0.6177922487258911,
0.13848358392715454,
-0.1984005570411682,
-0.43400853872299194,
-0.6870306134223938,
-0.6569415330886841,
0.6637576818466187,
-0.044703081250190735,
-0.10028200596570969,
-0.12237119674682617,
0.7383736371994019,
0.22982214391231537,
0.01547609455883503,
-0.8382855653762817,
-0.21483203768730164,
-0.26410624384880066,
-0.2068730890750885,
-0.005124947521835566,
-0.1587250530719757,
-0.25012463331222534,
-0.27263331413269043,
0.7095082402229309,
-0.504082441329956,
0.46855995059013367,
0.24874070286750793,
-0.3962298035621643,
-0.30437856912612915,
0.18625745177268982,
0.5876744985580444,
0.9676194787025452,
-0.10423418879508972,
0.25220251083374023,
0.22806057333946228,
0.2614615261554718,
0.08390998840332031,
-0.07237035781145096,
0.4383726418018341,
-0.053296636790037155,
0.3909178078174591,
0.6678990721702576,
0.09833408892154694,
-0.7896752953529358,
0.4027964472770691,
-0.04382319003343582,
-0.3181304335594177,
-0.3588330149650574,
0.5394176244735718,
0.180657297372818,
0.5681707859039307,
0.2983500063419342,
-0.20743560791015625,
0.16011705994606018,
-0.35702139139175415,
0.31943395733833313,
0.2372574657201767,
-0.23892153799533844,
0.03167928755283356,
0.49200862646102905,
0.2556723356246948,
-0.265884131193161,
0.5061617493629456,
-0.3134887218475342,
-0.5429853796958923,
0.9368690848350525,
0.6037791967391968,
0.7399202585220337,
0.042458098381757736,
0.3102993965148926,
0.4389575719833374,
0.15612706542015076,
0.13404226303100586,
0.28759142756462097,
-0.5002668499946594,
-0.22797204554080963,
-0.7869901657104492,
-0.6138058304786682,
-0.34738731384277344,
0.14923837780952454,
-0.47588911652565,
0.19877777993679047,
-0.4214928448200226,
0.48024559020996094,
-0.3737287223339081,
-0.013982236385345459,
-0.4409755766391754,
0.21592111885547638,
0.17440779507160187,
0.9316223859786987,
-0.5075253248214722,
0.6072119474411011,
0.3786282539367676,
-0.5813398361206055,
-0.8312172293663025,
-0.23456406593322754,
-0.031166568398475647,
-0.9582747220993042,
1.012984275817871,
0.38996806740760803,
-0.17732422053813934,
0.1528208702802658,
-0.6943029761314392,
-0.7511799335479736,
1.2248458862304688,
0.334831565618515,
-0.7925057411193848,
0.08849634975194931,
-0.058030642569065094,
0.7466906905174255,
-0.4297458827495575,
0.31374457478523254,
0.47859475016593933,
0.32446685433387756,
0.045746318995952606,
-0.5252560973167419,
0.07451798021793365,
0.03695661202073097,
-0.04237784817814827,
0.11288145929574966,
-0.49414902925491333,
0.16754835844039917,
-0.6401036977767944,
0.07117357105016708,
-0.21550802886486053,
0.5888908505439758,
0.3375222980976105,
0.3752875328063965,
0.4804125428199768,
0.5304039716720581,
0.5988948941230774,
0.024118606001138687,
1.018616795539856,
-0.39728912711143494,
0.40832194685935974,
1.2914133071899414,
0.28867241740226746,
0.4208180010318756,
0.39932477474212646,
0.08256896585226059,
0.8442238569259644,
0.8457435965538025,
-0.09684595465660095,
0.4558729827404022,
0.802902102470398,
0.1495501846075058,
-0.47321268916130066,
0.5581345558166504,
-0.4146310091018677,
0.25114917755126953,
0.11329512298107147,
-0.5121995210647583,
-0.3880249261856079,
0.26006683707237244,
-0.18017534911632538,
0.04488391429185867,
-0.34659990668296814,
0.7628586292266846,
0.04369994252920151,
-0.5520592331886292,
1.0878993272781372,
-0.054496560245752335,
0.6160446405410767,
-0.4098236858844757,
-0.13477365672588348,
-0.620682418346405,
0.5330765247344971,
-0.5788359045982361,
-0.627076268196106,
0.4564565122127533,
0.17731423676013947,
-0.017845619469881058,
-0.7492151260375977,
0.6634578704833984,
-0.26031121611595154,
0.044307876378297806,
0.29722580313682556,
0.4285489618778229,
0.34360042214393616,
-0.20941713452339172,
-0.9516209959983826,
0.0041468385607004166,
0.34487056732177734,
-0.24269314110279083,
0.31052201986312866,
0.5650217533111572,
0.3158675730228424,
0.8966056108474731,
0.4555460810661316,
-0.2349291890859604,
0.05830245465040207,
0.09296831488609314,
0.8208503723144531,
-0.7740604877471924,
-0.4315907061100006,
-0.9449518918991089,
0.7764743566513062,
-0.01080172136425972,
-0.21182768046855927,
0.6571599841117859,
0.5151808261871338,
0.8801664710044861,
-0.30391252040863037,
0.5241272449493408,
0.1617738902568817,
0.5861577391624451,
-0.5900350213050842,
0.3579079806804657,
-0.5480555891990662,
0.6253190636634827,
0.19834263622760773,
-0.6543212532997131,
-0.14408569037914276,
0.8120972514152527,
-0.060350462794303894,
-0.07003656774759293,
0.5550703406333923,
0.8437177538871765,
0.0005226001376286149,
-0.3131810128688812,
0.1558579057455063,
0.14544358849525452,
0.3811929523944855,
0.622120201587677,
0.8993141055107117,
-0.26056984066963196,
0.82809978723526,
-0.42537209391593933,
-0.1077982634305954,
-0.31081342697143555,
-0.9250825047492981,
-0.8737151622772217,
-0.12864869832992554,
-0.6370922923088074,
-0.40724754333496094,
0.17976932227611542,
0.6944588422775269,
0.7648448944091797,
-0.5549113750457764,
-0.15823887288570404,
-0.5199059247970581,
0.4045177698135376,
-0.43385887145996094,
-0.2577079236507416,
-0.0754968449473381,
-1.0401512384414673,
-0.17741121351718903,
0.6537752747535706,
0.2618383467197418,
-0.13642652332782745,
-0.6505659818649292,
-0.4234548807144165,
0.3969763517379761,
-0.31395336985588074,
0.48385322093963623,
0.369539350271225,
-0.5386433601379395,
-0.24699586629867554,
-0.13916119933128357,
-0.08055220544338226,
0.20990775525569916,
0.8442282676696777,
-1.2279572486877441,
0.34990525245666504,
0.18053291738033295,
0.66547030210495,
0.5905267596244812,
-0.008782324381172657,
0.4333111047744751,
-0.8546631336212158,
-0.25564128160476685,
0.0755162462592125,
0.16202296316623688,
0.11353486776351929,
-0.6184694766998291,
0.8650444149971008,
0.053816553205251694,
-0.7315151691436768,
-0.6240221261978149,
0.31176358461380005,
-0.5653678178787231,
-0.4974128305912018,
1.0604454278945923,
-0.1854357272386551,
-0.17486244440078735,
-0.04685327783226967,
-0.40654104948043823,
0.1426488608121872,
-0.21004529297351837,
1.1108206510543823,
0.36907950043678284,
-0.39924356341362,
-0.40224114060401917,
-0.31136801838874817,
0.7563815116882324,
0.49353185296058655,
-1.091407060623169,
0.2008606344461441,
0.529248833656311,
0.557175874710083,
-0.11014901101589203,
0.5724503397941589,
-0.051192231476306915,
0.2939872145652771,
-0.34873491525650024,
0.21034209430217743,
-0.5428248047828674,
-0.3098491132259369,
-0.8562018871307373,
-0.0777110829949379,
0.14731350541114807,
-0.3507452607154846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18642v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18642v1
|
JADS: A Framework for Self-supervised Joint Aspect Discovery and Summarization
| 2024-05-28T23:01:57 | 2024-05-28T23:01:57 |
Xiaobo Guo, Jay Desai, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
To generate summaries that include multiple aspects or topics for text
documents, most approaches use clustering or topic modeling to group relevant
sentences and then generate a summary for each group. These approaches struggle
to optimize the summarization and clustering algorithms jointly. On the other
hand, aspect-based summarization requires known aspects. Our solution
integrates topic discovery and summarization into a single step. Given text
data, our Joint Aspect Discovery and Summarization algorithm (JADS) discovers
aspects from the input and generates a summary of the topics, in one step. We
propose a self-supervised framework that creates a labeled dataset by first
mixing sentences from multiple documents (e.g., CNN/DailyMail articles) as the
input and then uses the article summaries from the mixture as the labels. The
JADS model outperforms the two-step baselines. With pretraining, the model
achieves better performance and stability. Furthermore, embeddings derived from
JADS exhibit superior clustering capabilities. Our proposed method achieves
higher semantic alignment with ground truth and is factual.
|
[
-0.4913748800754547,
-0.8572562336921692,
0.9011620879173279,
0.10373494774103165,
-0.25577035546302795,
0.11437422037124634,
0.14033208787441254,
-0.09749158471822739,
0.837050199508667,
0.8578648567199707,
-0.5368906855583191,
-0.763757050037384,
-0.6746751666069031,
0.05300920829176903,
-0.4615389108657837,
1.4015125036239624,
-0.03565346822142601,
-0.2227913737297058,
-0.4873804748058319,
-0.1721809208393097,
-0.18297040462493896,
-0.419690877199173,
-0.29697686433792114,
-0.12049265950918198,
0.5069440007209778,
0.47065022587776184,
0.3345935642719269,
0.7277957201004028,
0.5459125638008118,
0.3573613166809082,
-0.221960186958313,
0.1997048258781433,
-0.04429776594042778,
0.7305437922477722,
-0.3430209159851074,
-0.14297685027122498,
-0.47180497646331787,
-0.05166120082139969,
0.4143485724925995,
0.8840211629867554,
0.12595805525779724,
-0.05437210202217102,
0.12444265186786652,
0.9005614519119263,
-0.5128151178359985,
0.005246513057500124,
0.049139704555273056,
0.10675368458032608,
-0.2282930463552475,
-0.08070062100887299,
0.014454049989581108,
-0.11057581007480621,
0.2503190338611603,
-0.7816337943077087,
0.6849980354309082,
-0.19777478277683258,
0.5875691175460815,
0.108128622174263,
-0.7098972797393799,
-0.3220651149749756,
-0.5781362652778625,
0.4976332485675812,
-0.4484829008579254,
0.12143953144550323,
0.2329525202512741,
-0.15895584225654602,
-0.08624593168497086,
-0.5323445796966553,
-0.46337398886680603,
0.39164406061172485,
-0.32535871863365173,
0.20745417475700378,
0.3282261788845062,
0.1322108805179596,
-0.03525399789214134,
0.6876767873764038,
-0.6831690073013306,
-0.24986892938613892,
-0.19395838677883148,
-0.10221101343631744,
0.6728200316429138,
0.10667736828327179,
0.04197452589869499,
-0.5657072067260742,
-0.20408442616462708,
-0.08488699793815613,
-0.37652409076690674,
-0.09504861384630203,
0.25613221526145935,
0.5921168923377991,
-0.33396077156066895,
0.7430582046508789,
-0.9097373485565186,
0.3686189353466034,
0.3408016860485077,
-0.5635440349578857,
0.26485833525657654,
-0.5957627892494202,
0.01693381927907467,
0.07339180260896683,
0.8527780175209045,
0.3322077989578247,
-0.7149708867073059,
-0.2111513614654541,
-0.059364594519138336,
-0.3566921353340149,
0.2736864984035492,
-0.7025073170661926,
-0.3861265480518341,
0.39593738317489624,
-0.5848529934883118,
-0.5346126556396484,
0.2269047647714615,
-0.6779694557189941,
-0.45160311460494995,
-0.4891183078289032,
0.6323132514953613,
-0.3106042444705963,
-0.4075523316860199,
-0.17341843247413635,
-0.36313116550445557,
-0.413676381111145,
0.28285539150238037,
-0.8679788112640381,
0.01933666132390499,
0.7147823572158813,
0.8703926205635071,
-0.2813637852668762,
-0.25077593326568604,
-0.13399194180965424,
0.4202117323875427,
-0.544942319393158,
0.847458004951477,
-0.31575408577919006,
-0.5518064498901367,
-0.24432596564292908,
0.09399522840976715,
0.4888080060482025,
-0.030260877683758736,
0.08485488593578339,
-0.25447288155555725,
0.4843367338180542,
-0.5780814290046692,
-0.6252105832099915,
-0.3342842757701874,
0.4020058214664459,
-0.3982708752155304,
1.0410048961639404,
0.051643867045640945,
-1.1474308967590332,
0.46103614568710327,
-0.8332968354225159,
-0.751579999923706,
-0.2409978061914444,
-0.32350674271583557,
-0.7214483618736267,
0.38055598735809326,
0.5482445955276489,
0.6505334973335266,
0.047035060822963715,
0.6813547015190125,
-0.1863774210214615,
0.11278054118156433,
-0.0387478731572628,
-0.010319368913769722,
0.40391862392425537,
0.26655152440071106,
0.054152291268110275,
0.2625766694545746,
-0.4356006681919098,
-0.4021606743335724,
0.022720061242580414,
0.00403225002810359,
-0.7476420998573303,
0.13129305839538574,
-0.3098068833351135,
0.06713908165693283,
0.36844128370285034,
-0.5194815397262573,
0.21492527425289154,
-0.3211735486984253,
-0.10599964112043381,
0.42475152015686035,
0.41724687814712524,
0.6667283773422241,
-0.29825475811958313,
0.3988320827484131,
0.601746141910553,
0.118730828166008,
-0.9549693465232849,
-0.19125942885875702,
-0.9341139197349548,
-0.07062317430973053,
0.31527644395828247,
0.07150224596261978,
-0.9915078282356262,
1.026957392692566,
-0.11477170884609222,
-0.545973002910614,
-0.2797278165817261,
-0.008101479150354862,
0.5100288987159729,
0.45073795318603516,
0.31185802817344666,
-0.5686119198799133,
-0.0554744228720665,
-1.0991926193237305,
0.07413757592439651,
-0.004286658018827438,
0.08954089879989624,
-0.2720177471637726,
0.37393906712532043,
0.13871417939662933,
1.181583285331726,
-0.49010348320007324,
-0.5888285040855408,
-0.3416031301021576,
0.7250673174858093,
0.034511636942625046,
0.6902518272399902,
0.4807315766811371,
-0.929797887802124,
-0.25867995619773865,
0.023906361311674118,
-1.1070982217788696,
0.08281417191028595,
-0.23613597452640533,
0.007970587350428104,
-0.04949793964624405,
0.5446618795394897,
-0.17442867159843445,
0.36558961868286133,
0.4133354127407074,
-0.3807007372379303,
0.14128845930099487,
-0.3680906593799591,
0.44937923550605774,
-1.6012672185897827,
-0.25378885865211487,
0.10819553583860397,
-0.3789006173610687,
-0.333535760641098,
0.20529811084270477,
0.10246051847934723,
-0.3018163740634918,
-0.070086769759655,
0.1497252732515335,
-0.5584406852722168,
-0.41051021218299866,
-0.6775184273719788,
0.11147192120552063,
0.36495476961135864,
0.3514084219932556,
0.14951206743717194,
0.7136138081550598,
0.8073096871376038,
-0.6299761533737183,
0.17961594462394714,
0.19932524859905243,
-0.012209993787109852,
0.5448650121688843,
-0.42571592330932617,
-0.1378723680973053,
-0.5142236351966858,
0.444917231798172,
-0.6896926164627075,
-0.4383794367313385,
0.18824565410614014,
-0.24097074568271637,
0.3440781831741333,
-0.22363615036010742,
-0.34610357880592346,
-0.2690374255180359,
-0.5594488382339478,
0.25951310992240906,
-0.1677311807870865,
-0.474843829870224,
0.8851641416549683,
0.7841492891311646,
-0.791523277759552,
-0.45148682594299316,
-0.43227434158325195,
0.15624313056468964,
-0.027000313624739647,
-0.45548510551452637,
0.5997314453125,
0.2059205323457718,
0.10915627330541611,
0.4618229568004608,
-0.3017704486846924,
-0.17881490290164948,
0.04184718057513237,
0.45019614696502686,
-0.14553749561309814,
-0.22085843980312347,
0.23166799545288086,
0.7279874086380005,
-0.3995051085948944,
-0.0760640799999237,
-0.31375473737716675,
0.22865447402000427,
0.11101071536540985,
-0.4921678602695465,
-0.4676470458507538,
0.9175788760185242,
0.25356000661849976,
-0.26890334486961365,
0.5117301940917969,
0.46569594740867615,
-0.12635041773319244,
0.03464449942111969,
-0.40285158157348633,
0.043312303721904755,
-0.4219944179058075,
0.38864561915397644,
-0.580559253692627,
-0.9449067115783691,
0.32420065999031067,
-0.1711650937795639,
0.10146312415599823,
0.8331286907196045,
0.2923983931541443,
-0.3229282796382904,
0.7861042618751526,
1.0749006271362305,
-0.2306607961654663,
0.3888774514198303,
-0.3519933223724365,
0.45404940843582153,
-0.5997326374053955,
-0.20826290547847748,
-0.4505860507488251,
-0.06439479440450668,
-0.6417640447616577,
-0.27675583958625793,
0.7145546674728394,
0.22402805089950562,
0.25793853402137756,
0.1039261743426323,
-0.7968581318855286,
0.7744926810264587,
0.6808891296386719,
0.09574579447507858,
0.4513309597969055,
-0.22146253287792206,
0.1360158920288086,
0.009151533246040344,
-0.4998859763145447,
-0.4510253965854645,
1.2443171739578247,
0.22976525127887726,
0.74564528465271,
0.12019026279449463,
1.255233883857727,
0.49793127179145813,
0.1308976709842682,
-0.3684925436973572,
0.40693914890289307,
-0.2918669283390045,
-0.5637056231498718,
-0.34318822622299194,
-0.27601832151412964,
-0.6716780066490173,
0.33853551745414734,
-0.3229256868362427,
-0.41374635696411133,
0.15858878195285797,
0.012616101652383804,
-0.3234459459781647,
0.1547875553369522,
-0.601247251033783,
0.6967136859893799,
-0.14522503316402435,
-0.1167522519826889,
-0.37600207328796387,
-0.6764945387840271,
0.578035831451416,
-0.10497300326824188,
0.26717832684516907,
-0.17098326981067657,
0.19710247218608856,
1.000564455986023,
-0.38732439279556274,
0.6930488348007202,
-0.06705707311630249,
0.07122105360031128,
0.22375918924808502,
0.057309869676828384,
-0.03421390801668167,
0.3162672221660614,
0.24686260521411896,
0.0027733014430850744,
0.14403106272220612,
-0.45034751296043396,
-0.5099099278450012,
0.9509013295173645,
-0.60164874792099,
-0.7063832879066467,
-0.8282246589660645,
-0.4856764078140259,
0.04114273190498352,
0.31751391291618347,
0.15488368272781372,
0.6561152338981628,
-0.13055695593357086,
0.07577989250421524,
0.5862935781478882,
-0.11803065240383148,
0.6001263856887817,
0.6451171040534973,
-0.5596394538879395,
-0.23371638357639313,
1.099631667137146,
-0.06968872994184494,
-0.05938977003097534,
0.358707070350647,
0.017225682735443115,
-0.12209656834602356,
-0.6075735688209534,
-0.38788512349128723,
0.11561691015958786,
-0.582247793674469,
-0.3431013226509094,
-0.8809401988983154,
-0.37619107961654663,
-0.7911595106124878,
-0.2588936686515808,
-0.6926623582839966,
-0.3511444628238678,
-0.15150663256645203,
-0.0688682496547699,
0.15105950832366943,
1.2304060459136963,
-0.28700217604637146,
0.3937036991119385,
-0.7703869342803955,
0.7942191362380981,
0.2622980773448944,
0.2542964816093445,
-0.41151127219200134,
-0.07161138206720352,
-0.39821749925613403,
-0.054340921342372894,
-0.7003852725028992,
-0.7216416001319885,
0.3360736072063446,
-0.2376505732536316,
0.2619040310382843,
0.4000234305858612,
0.37122806906700134,
0.3740500211715698,
0.012893199920654297,
0.9784197211265564,
0.2939818203449249,
-0.8564848899841309,
1.0291621685028076,
-0.42705240845680237,
0.14668956398963928,
0.6449659466743469,
0.38602665066719055,
-0.25681424140930176,
-0.7218511700630188,
-0.7818019390106201,
-0.8256348371505737,
0.759268045425415,
0.20972713828086853,
-0.11045797169208527,
-0.05400024354457855,
0.31145983934402466,
0.37599921226501465,
0.12056223303079605,
-0.5294216275215149,
-0.44965794682502747,
-0.13408909738063812,
-0.4521264433860779,
0.02143790014088154,
-0.3594505488872528,
-0.24070677161216736,
-0.037554994225502014,
0.8747838139533997,
-0.26126348972320557,
0.0680619552731514,
0.46044719219207764,
-0.040060967206954956,
0.08197052776813507,
0.21904467046260834,
0.21099844574928284,
0.5968920588493347,
-0.14017222821712494,
0.11039397865533829,
-0.26359012722969055,
-0.2673017978668213,
0.1348191350698471,
0.3087611198425293,
-0.457796573638916,
0.19619549810886383,
0.24484805762767792,
0.6002547144889832,
0.016659893095493317,
-0.20811116695404053,
0.7970860600471497,
-0.23581375181674957,
-0.21156345307826996,
-0.20616941154003143,
0.17320679128170013,
-0.0662752240896225,
0.37350010871887207,
0.39792752265930176,
0.06170237809419632,
0.4299042820930481,
-0.4136652648448944,
0.2512374520301819,
0.27883630990982056,
-0.20356856286525726,
-0.22200927138328552,
0.4952545166015625,
0.518836498260498,
-0.019072072580456734,
-0.0618416853249073,
-0.5251198410987854,
-0.4729844629764557,
0.4816615581512451,
0.16792665421962738,
0.9368768334388733,
-0.055463120341300964,
0.5158181190490723,
0.12882497906684875,
-0.0831267461180687,
-0.1544693261384964,
0.027659760788083076,
-0.34927305579185486,
-0.4975569546222687,
-0.5802713632583618,
-0.6143771409988403,
-0.5576529502868652,
-0.12995751202106476,
-0.7870957255363464,
0.08215343207120895,
-0.18030832707881927,
0.07332964241504669,
0.44402945041656494,
0.09498172998428345,
-0.14545954763889313,
0.3805137276649475,
-0.16336654126644135,
0.19292926788330078,
-1.0511999130249023,
0.8756760358810425,
0.5857820510864258,
-0.4285959303379059,
-0.23317496478557587,
0.17750060558319092,
0.15806688368320465,
-0.1424720585346222,
0.17426933348178864,
0.15526160597801208,
0.24996523559093475,
-0.2193383425474167,
-0.16611447930335999,
-1.0040123462677002,
0.9928421974182129,
-0.1937151402235031,
-0.3847125470638275,
0.0914313942193985,
-0.16016323864459991,
0.21714691817760468,
-0.4494386315345764,
0.04508991166949272,
0.2765237092971802,
0.17291848361492157,
0.033745355904102325,
-0.6299948692321777,
-0.31455501914024353,
-0.004428355488926172,
-0.052126459777355194,
0.4393392503261566,
-0.5080472230911255,
0.8333735466003418,
-0.11117598414421082,
0.01801958493888378,
-0.06776494532823563,
1.2259345054626465,
0.009403903968632221,
0.6667578220367432,
0.42438116669654846,
0.7298640608787537,
0.46424952149391174,
-0.11715899407863617,
1.0006921291351318,
-0.3780047297477722,
0.4274154305458069,
1.2182555198669434,
-0.04075200855731964,
0.33038192987442017,
0.1944809854030609,
-0.0775875523686409,
0.34694981575012207,
0.5131827592849731,
0.4020906090736389,
0.8239902853965759,
-0.377009779214859,
-0.27328792214393616,
-0.19552667438983917,
-0.21706289052963257,
-0.44935470819473267,
0.329266756772995,
0.40773722529411316,
-0.2973032295703888,
-0.4569056034088135,
0.16649988293647766,
-0.06909579783678055,
0.36038029193878174,
-0.07151316106319427,
1.078371286392212,
-0.2788030207157135,
-0.6959866881370544,
-0.5320574641227722,
0.3451097011566162,
0.7322189807891846,
-0.5271165370941162,
0.13092495501041412,
-0.43063753843307495,
-0.12005522847175598,
0.060987114906311035,
-1.064939022064209,
0.5167497396469116,
-0.07461004704236984,
-0.6268684267997742,
-0.3608577847480774,
0.6983828544616699,
-0.6249659061431885,
-0.7244094014167786,
-0.15483787655830383,
0.5423698425292969,
0.02792607806622982,
-0.0876016914844513,
-0.4530427157878876,
-0.16412793099880219,
-0.052184250205755234,
-0.1961354911327362,
0.5725513100624084,
0.804854154586792,
0.026145344600081444,
0.38145318627357483,
0.49472948908805847,
-0.12881119549274445,
-0.4654766023159027,
0.007923339493572712,
1.028565764427185,
-0.9139307737350464,
-1.0074025392532349,
-0.4153432846069336,
0.3061024248600006,
-0.3784986138343811,
-0.42595598101615906,
0.6648973822593689,
0.9139828681945801,
0.6052283048629761,
0.272026926279068,
0.913783073425293,
-0.30983027815818787,
0.969141960144043,
-0.6896401047706604,
0.590197741985321,
-0.5793106555938721,
0.1600174605846405,
-0.20559506118297577,
-0.6800309419631958,
-0.10989540815353394,
0.5489451289176941,
-0.0475684255361557,
-0.08696776628494263,
0.7171103954315186,
0.7616555094718933,
-0.25155511498451233,
0.2936825454235077,
0.12166823446750641,
0.04282403737306595,
0.5313095450401306,
-0.00933893397450447,
0.42266449332237244,
-0.3318617045879364,
0.030959125608205795,
-0.8265274167060852,
-0.14230333268642426,
0.0001268998021259904,
-0.8153592348098755,
-0.9595514535903931,
-1.0737686157226562,
-0.7238368988037109,
-0.10781804472208023,
0.1172516942024231,
0.6603021025657654,
0.8611092567443848,
-0.7505471706390381,
0.13644973933696747,
-0.0865522027015686,
0.29780396819114685,
0.03722070902585983,
-0.2672785818576813,
0.5482091903686523,
-0.5774276852607727,
-0.551871657371521,
0.4863587021827698,
0.6942639946937561,
0.15426784753799438,
-0.473895400762558,
0.19921401143074036,
-0.07678008079528809,
-0.36183634400367737,
0.5024027228355408,
0.08173081278800964,
-0.7612045407295227,
-0.19303332269191742,
-0.4585532546043396,
-0.2314547747373581,
-0.1071508526802063,
0.9437924027442932,
-0.7659032344818115,
0.5654680132865906,
0.3713854253292084,
0.6160444617271423,
0.814993679523468,
0.3657281696796417,
0.5333027243614197,
-1.046772837638855,
0.33617016673088074,
-0.07793702185153961,
0.07035855948925018,
0.34229743480682373,
-0.3368889391422272,
0.4191213548183441,
0.22618143260478973,
-0.3967847526073456,
-0.29139456152915955,
-0.06404810398817062,
-1.1057000160217285,
-0.6907380819320679,
0.7364434599876404,
-0.2767929136753082,
-0.17178533971309662,
-0.1948515921831131,
-0.05790065601468086,
0.21463221311569214,
-0.45778948068618774,
0.8630990982055664,
0.37608039379119873,
-0.18811394274234772,
-0.04651937261223793,
-0.07259409129619598,
0.313221275806427,
0.3537811040878296,
-0.9540475010871887,
-0.05469514802098274,
0.7252395749092102,
0.22698120772838593,
0.405698299407959,
0.7595183849334717,
0.16414374113082886,
-0.05930057913064957,
0.05750446394085884,
0.22081799805164337,
-0.18184325098991394,
-0.6312075853347778,
-0.09092103689908981,
0.3205905556678772,
-0.361133873462677,
-0.4234599173069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18639v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18639v1
|
Improving Speech Decoding from ECoG with Self-Supervised Pretraining
| 2024-05-28T22:48:53 | 2024-05-28T22:48:53 |
Brian A. Yuan, Joseph G. Makin
|
q-bio.NC
|
q-bio.NC, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent work on intracranial brain-machine interfaces has demonstrated that
spoken speech can be decoded with high accuracy, essentially by treating the
problem as an instance of supervised learning and training deep neural networks
to map from neural activity to text. However, such networks pay for their
expressiveness with very large numbers of labeled data, a requirement that is
particularly burdensome for invasive neural recordings acquired from human
patients. On the other hand, these patients typically produce speech outside of
the experimental blocks used for training decoders. Making use of such data,
and data from other patients, to improve decoding would ease the burden of data
collection -- especially onerous for dys- and anarthric patients. Here we
demonstrate that this is possible, by reengineering wav2vec -- a simple,
self-supervised, fully convolutional model that learns latent representations
of audio using a noise-contrastive loss -- for electrocorticographic (ECoG)
data. We train this model on unlabelled ECoG recordings, and subsequently use
it to transform ECoG from labeled speech sessions into wav2vec's representation
space, before finally training a supervised encoder-decoder to map these
representations to text. We experiment with various numbers of labeled blocks;
for almost all choices, the new representations yield superior decoding
performance to the original ECoG data, and in no cases do they yield worse.
Performance can also be improved in some cases by pretraining wav2vec on
another patient's data. In the best cases, wav2vec's representations decrease
word error rates over the original data by upwards of 50%.
|
[
-0.18019114434719086,
-0.49107030034065247,
0.5270399451255798,
0.13147294521331787,
-0.39508533477783203,
-0.01080830954015255,
-0.4355987310409546,
-0.5796223878860474,
0.2728322148323059,
0.40051162242889404,
-0.6244199275970459,
-0.7438976764678955,
-0.6144973635673523,
0.09391140937805176,
-0.22094453871250153,
0.8395053148269653,
0.13368597626686096,
0.3561009168624878,
-0.3212733864784241,
-0.10383940488100052,
-0.37937217950820923,
-0.7158312201499939,
-0.6517418026924133,
-0.4222416281700134,
0.49984684586524963,
0.24697062373161316,
0.2201884686946869,
0.6302565932273865,
0.24963447451591492,
0.26176899671554565,
0.02283940091729164,
0.20018769800662994,
-0.5332911014556885,
0.011251455172896385,
0.11098599433898926,
-0.4396040439605713,
-0.5574988722801208,
0.005319161806255579,
0.36334580183029175,
0.8032429814338684,
-0.5709888935089111,
-0.0021549484226852655,
0.38489943742752075,
0.4116704761981964,
-0.3816259205341339,
0.41708904504776,
-0.33592331409454346,
0.03793022409081459,
-0.1271446943283081,
-0.482526957988739,
-0.6136382222175598,
-0.03289389982819557,
0.11101438105106354,
-0.851463794708252,
0.12994016706943512,
-0.05326922610402107,
0.5528535842895508,
0.4369838237762451,
-0.20717011392116547,
-0.2853330671787262,
-0.697845995426178,
0.5841864943504333,
-0.640995979309082,
0.6954984664916992,
0.7452966570854187,
-0.16649995744228363,
-0.19711323082447052,
-0.9441692233085632,
-0.3337118327617645,
-0.044085655361413956,
-0.00611795112490654,
0.6957189440727234,
-0.5273260474205017,
0.40003275871276855,
0.2479613572359085,
0.2000463753938675,
-0.4641084372997284,
0.46258196234703064,
-0.41823938488960266,
-0.5578693747520447,
0.5292077660560608,
0.023048916831612587,
0.0999617725610733,
0.13528895378112793,
-0.063492052257061,
-0.274183452129364,
-0.5482190251350403,
-0.02244192734360695,
0.4475511312484741,
-0.04780229181051254,
0.17081479728221893,
0.18000160157680511,
-0.16992168128490448,
0.5092009902000427,
0.1196245476603508,
0.0828523263335228,
0.6117338538169861,
0.012052024714648724,
-0.006845670752227306,
0.41454148292541504,
0.5635550022125244,
0.30947160720825195,
0.08301436901092529,
-0.24206534028053284,
-0.0009481621091254056,
0.019628163427114487,
0.2485007345676422,
-0.7476493716239929,
-0.8182947635650635,
0.2869400382041931,
-0.7527780532836914,
0.0017539504915475845,
-0.22062265872955322,
-0.4111355245113373,
-0.16347841918468475,
-0.6638965010643005,
0.4157366454601288,
-0.4145168662071228,
-0.3078368306159973,
0.0755985677242279,
0.04356278479099274,
0.019862644374370575,
0.19090376794338226,
-0.9956080317497253,
0.4800613224506378,
0.35566964745521545,
0.7465192675590515,
0.06801600754261017,
-0.09233372658491135,
-0.8431527614593506,
0.00622589560225606,
-0.46125513315200806,
0.8946794867515564,
-0.17634780704975128,
-0.3634270429611206,
-0.08465559035539627,
0.007680906448513269,
0.11199713498353958,
-0.5914512276649475,
0.4940546751022339,
-0.2676571309566498,
-0.020348671823740005,
-0.1817808896303177,
-0.7695082426071167,
0.023605553433299065,
-0.3989604711532593,
-0.537871241569519,
0.4591246247291565,
-0.03427906706929207,
-0.5437639355659485,
0.3168516457080841,
-0.4069354832172394,
-0.6883392930030823,
0.0507039874792099,
-0.23151765763759613,
-0.4864988923072815,
0.23918360471725464,
0.4545877277851105,
0.44657230377197266,
0.17003832757472992,
-0.10610765218734741,
-0.2101854681968689,
-0.26254960894584656,
0.15907342731952667,
-0.4607793390750885,
0.5140997767448425,
0.4374552369117737,
-0.12299160659313202,
-0.07924909889698029,
-0.9269371628761292,
0.2798604965209961,
-0.12538786232471466,
-0.40197351574897766,
-0.38775286078453064,
0.04092653468251228,
-0.10252200067043304,
0.042450763285160065,
-0.024029787629842758,
-0.7442362308502197,
-0.14884017407894135,
-0.5919966697692871,
0.6020646095275879,
0.5726796388626099,
-0.0275120846927166,
0.36025092005729675,
-0.17178098857402802,
0.25722160935401917,
0.007843108847737312,
-0.14245286583900452,
-0.23053990304470062,
-0.4106600880622864,
-0.6069173812866211,
-0.30814218521118164,
0.48442134261131287,
0.4683789908885956,
-0.5686222910881042,
0.4931478202342987,
-0.15027093887329102,
-0.3123854100704193,
-1.035339117050171,
-0.02721818909049034,
0.15560784935951233,
0.8433939814567566,
0.7428554892539978,
-0.34860730171203613,
-0.6975951194763184,
-0.9315170049667358,
-0.16131730377674103,
-0.0638522058725357,
-0.3292299509048462,
0.3605382740497589,
-0.025789225473999977,
-0.2678817808628082,
0.6479915380477905,
-0.31752434372901917,
-0.47464650869369507,
0.03658629581332207,
0.5345069169998169,
0.20735181868076324,
0.6452236771583557,
-0.07620396465063095,
-0.4087253212928772,
-0.10592702031135559,
-0.03472742438316345,
-0.4566569924354553,
-0.33216702938079834,
-0.25351831316947937,
-0.013835357502102852,
0.10160825401544571,
0.7610096335411072,
-0.00523501867428422,
0.5575850605964661,
0.6250827312469482,
0.053995728492736816,
0.1273687183856964,
-0.8204997777938843,
0.1036754623055458,
-0.8255887031555176,
-0.08884917199611664,
-0.18854020535945892,
-0.4435555338859558,
-0.6629630923271179,
-0.6228833198547363,
0.06970398873090744,
-0.08223594725131989,
-0.2572425603866577,
-0.1537752002477646,
-0.6890680193901062,
0.03651667758822441,
-0.3879668116569519,
-0.05089791119098663,
0.017845451831817627,
0.42371633648872375,
0.43672099709510803,
0.5023052096366882,
0.707252025604248,
-0.5966447591781616,
0.2654959559440613,
0.4572218656539917,
-0.2274933010339737,
0.4205520749092102,
-0.6584659218788147,
0.6238521337509155,
-0.24170729517936707,
0.4377395510673523,
-0.9067191481590271,
-0.13116593658924103,
0.015905465930700302,
-0.4745212197303772,
0.5805389881134033,
-0.22859077155590057,
-0.24750597774982452,
-0.23643061518669128,
0.13863630592823029,
0.34979984164237976,
0.9471401572227478,
-0.8835492730140686,
0.49169811606407166,
0.48340633511543274,
-0.07018589973449707,
-0.24228015542030334,
-1.256451964378357,
0.12262102961540222,
0.05807751044631004,
-0.39420366287231445,
0.4891449511051178,
0.02711097151041031,
0.1562507599592209,
-0.025822104886174202,
-0.29139968752861023,
-0.005119028966873884,
-0.13821010291576385,
0.25754013657569885,
-0.03856966644525528,
-0.020900052040815353,
0.42767712473869324,
0.17398850619792938,
-0.3212730884552002,
0.2541631758213043,
-0.6612664461135864,
0.523337185382843,
0.1142488643527031,
-0.2523956000804901,
-0.8812118172645569,
0.42720460891723633,
0.05083060637116432,
-0.38199013471603394,
0.4487123191356659,
0.7111020684242249,
-0.5163537859916687,
-0.1904969960451126,
-0.49369823932647705,
-0.27332350611686707,
-0.47186416387557983,
0.5464499592781067,
-0.28037795424461365,
-0.756545901298523,
0.3866084814071655,
-0.3933753967285156,
-0.19019357860088348,
0.2715708017349243,
0.4410887360572815,
-0.5993666648864746,
1.042352318763733,
0.48059719800949097,
0.18127016723155975,
0.40859636664390564,
-0.4224802553653717,
0.032303497195243835,
-1.0926947593688965,
-0.44232404232025146,
-0.15100622177124023,
-0.2023754119873047,
-0.5550392270088196,
-0.3109503388404846,
0.29373350739479065,
-0.16102319955825806,
0.30227887630462646,
0.16761748492717743,
-0.7559237480163574,
0.43913307785987854,
0.46770331263542175,
0.692491888999939,
0.08834870904684067,
0.2938297390937805,
0.18210066854953766,
-0.23136606812477112,
-0.8004674911499023,
-0.2716117203235626,
1.3194905519485474,
0.40895482897758484,
0.9758962392807007,
-0.3589107394218445,
1.1325148344039917,
0.22094810009002686,
0.2384609580039978,
-0.7824601531028748,
0.12580396234989166,
-0.44077497720718384,
0.011545056477189064,
-0.11668045073747635,
-0.4894745349884033,
-1.2241796255111694,
0.17694830894470215,
-0.3228715658187866,
-0.6054771542549133,
0.6548185348510742,
0.5503354072570801,
-0.7432585954666138,
0.09574996680021286,
-0.7215319275856018,
0.6715604066848755,
-0.21452805399894714,
-0.28360751271247864,
-0.6018468737602234,
-0.5798226594924927,
-0.10852466523647308,
0.012162693776190281,
0.1432424634695053,
0.22333362698554993,
0.09347103536128998,
1.001732587814331,
-0.5563771724700928,
0.7377063632011414,
-0.2402372807264328,
-0.2269924432039261,
0.4013312757015228,
-0.15874792635440826,
0.4742075800895691,
-0.11449000984430313,
0.03671715781092644,
0.49664685130119324,
-0.011118677444756031,
-0.33928683400154114,
-0.518599808216095,
0.5763758420944214,
-0.8298037052154541,
-0.47680675983428955,
-0.2169315218925476,
-0.36920514702796936,
-0.36943256855010986,
-0.1387927532196045,
0.669999897480011,
0.923693060874939,
-0.3703972399234772,
0.2881348729133606,
0.9664583802223206,
-0.08152806758880615,
0.2925803065299988,
0.15549352765083313,
0.20410585403442383,
-0.499813437461853,
0.8127716779708862,
0.34146177768707275,
0.19259877502918243,
0.31101399660110474,
0.045056894421577454,
-0.5119040012359619,
-0.8364430665969849,
-0.07585160434246063,
0.050140395760536194,
-0.7407990097999573,
-0.21732980012893677,
-0.7963614463806152,
-0.0691717118024826,
-0.4955294728279114,
0.21690253913402557,
-0.39698681235313416,
-0.26885977387428284,
-0.7783440947532654,
-0.18807333707809448,
0.23833182454109192,
0.6717908382415771,
-0.609316885471344,
0.5013139843940735,
-0.5336490273475647,
0.3450279235839844,
0.469820499420166,
0.18841911852359772,
-0.16847601532936096,
-0.7718597054481506,
-0.378913551568985,
0.23664046823978424,
0.01007576659321785,
-0.8977605104446411,
0.5240172147750854,
0.27722933888435364,
0.4291779696941376,
0.1932746171951294,
-0.03899141401052475,
0.8955752849578857,
-0.6963975429534912,
0.2981319725513458,
0.31626540422439575,
-0.941693127155304,
0.6446523666381836,
-0.054327595978975296,
0.09553265571594238,
0.5599192380905151,
0.08527941256761551,
-0.44601109623908997,
-0.1466520130634308,
-0.7280576229095459,
-0.9418224692344666,
0.8006244897842407,
0.2617153227329254,
0.13594719767570496,
0.021562501788139343,
0.3910330832004547,
0.11080256849527359,
-0.08217011392116547,
-0.29328063130378723,
-0.19607575237751007,
-0.6109780073165894,
-0.38784539699554443,
-0.16803446412086487,
-0.19573594629764557,
-0.2817135751247406,
-0.3486173748970032,
0.38833311200141907,
-0.062047723680734634,
0.49955013394355774,
0.8355486989021301,
-0.129499614238739,
0.05111639201641083,
0.21005617082118988,
0.22904789447784424,
0.36340275406837463,
-0.11252322047948837,
0.325458288192749,
0.47277525067329407,
-0.5277706980705261,
0.2178124487400055,
0.30453717708587646,
0.42586106061935425,
-0.02004333771765232,
0.4482850730419159,
0.8859615921974182,
-0.13039708137512207,
-0.3674943447113037,
0.5470679402351379,
-0.23269902169704437,
-0.29856225848197937,
-0.3704196810722351,
-0.025580350309610367,
0.11214426904916763,
0.10635091364383698,
0.21438398957252502,
0.2790345549583435,
0.4525909423828125,
-0.39926958084106445,
0.40730252861976624,
0.03514575585722923,
-0.2943700850009918,
-0.3269742727279663,
0.7508834600448608,
0.32169270515441895,
-0.3658216595649719,
0.8145658373832703,
0.11080352216959,
-0.2995704412460327,
0.4256329834461212,
0.7988339066505432,
0.7834503054618835,
-0.2532426714897156,
0.06106555834412575,
0.3592665195465088,
0.189387246966362,
-0.11533001065254211,
0.30424022674560547,
-0.3742843270301819,
-0.5226881504058838,
-0.52751225233078,
-0.2884933054447174,
-0.26857930421829224,
0.12281549721956253,
-0.8772802948951721,
-0.056705113500356674,
-0.33838093280792236,
-0.2400289922952652,
-0.1317541003227234,
-0.2921275198459625,
-0.9782477021217346,
0.39051419496536255,
0.47077274322509766,
0.4463585913181305,
-0.63935786485672,
0.9555667638778687,
0.49644941091537476,
-0.19914205372333527,
-1.053192377090454,
0.025870431214571,
-0.3181856572628021,
-0.6654765009880066,
0.5507010221481323,
0.14255066215991974,
-0.3500130772590637,
0.45405954122543335,
-0.5824098587036133,
-0.7385362982749939,
1.036487340927124,
0.35101714730262756,
-1.1996451616287231,
0.4426569640636444,
-0.03933224454522133,
0.7412537932395935,
-0.4169182777404785,
0.29149165749549866,
0.5422983169555664,
0.25161516666412354,
-0.2602054178714752,
-0.7936158180236816,
-0.07665259391069412,
-0.041699185967445374,
-0.2346746325492859,
-0.19870872795581818,
-0.4438793659210205,
0.5276974439620972,
-0.26690781116485596,
-0.49490484595298767,
-0.16139477491378784,
0.9367916584014893,
-0.06929915398359299,
0.37814849615097046,
0.5907453894615173,
0.4916701912879944,
1.2467979192733765,
-0.15999852120876312,
1.0420676469802856,
-0.09611842781305313,
0.13097034394741058,
1.0633076429367065,
0.10723598301410675,
0.7811105847358704,
0.4289427101612091,
0.012126630172133446,
0.39427801966667175,
0.6314824819564819,
0.07875684648752213,
0.801855742931366,
0.3471616208553314,
-0.16317488253116608,
-0.592392086982727,
-0.02080518938601017,
-0.3574005365371704,
0.5292465686798096,
0.32436603307724,
-0.23235496878623962,
0.07565434277057648,
0.27822554111480713,
-0.15668708086013794,
0.18314944207668304,
-0.3365808427333832,
0.9415007829666138,
0.31438329815864563,
-0.36721792817115784,
0.7184509634971619,
-0.3984101712703705,
0.5722696185112,
-0.568889319896698,
-0.1973000168800354,
-0.035057906061410904,
0.10580925643444061,
-0.4401971101760864,
-0.4591669738292694,
0.1045907661318779,
-0.19417715072631836,
0.030797813087701797,
-0.42165759205818176,
0.619245171546936,
-0.7862991094589233,
-0.2569364905357361,
0.3797847032546997,
0.33641722798347473,
0.5057953000068665,
-0.014306407421827316,
-0.28653204441070557,
-0.05239592865109444,
0.1353851556777954,
-0.10772305727005005,
0.14536850154399872,
0.18549223244190216,
0.3104951083660126,
0.3592071235179901,
0.8459925055503845,
0.37141281366348267,
-0.002825069474056363,
0.33787524700164795,
0.7968548536300659,
-0.4811600148677826,
-0.6363828778266907,
-0.675443172454834,
0.2879073917865753,
-0.07966863363981247,
-0.23745319247245789,
0.40982785820961,
0.42843449115753174,
0.9099199175834656,
0.02155650034546852,
0.6585302948951721,
0.20852072536945343,
0.41620996594429016,
-0.7770439386367798,
0.7924942374229431,
-0.3994676470756531,
0.05986073985695839,
0.03991888463497162,
-0.4998070299625397,
-0.26580822467803955,
0.8856101036071777,
-0.11260143667459488,
-0.08931629359722137,
0.6955401301383972,
0.6823011040687561,
0.033505674451589584,
0.12057797610759735,
0.5114191174507141,
0.2669731676578522,
0.35037553310394287,
0.6346752047538757,
0.9761675000190735,
-0.3214617073535919,
0.6956919431686401,
-0.3518469035625458,
-0.4803178906440735,
0.08560042083263397,
-0.5678701996803284,
-0.7519852519035339,
-0.46158069372177124,
-0.4924256503582001,
-0.30170944333076477,
0.12116560339927673,
0.8623602986335754,
0.9376553893089294,
-0.6561748385429382,
-0.03213384002447128,
-0.1022266149520874,
-0.3368402123451233,
-0.332506000995636,
-0.03222690895199776,
0.6352397799491882,
-0.3535948097705841,
-0.6743257641792297,
0.7841696739196777,
0.14194439351558685,
0.0683787539601326,
0.07853023707866669,
-0.12901470065116882,
0.28745561838150024,
-0.10989460349082947,
0.39468255639076233,
0.23369094729423523,
-0.45851534605026245,
-0.15761512517929077,
-0.12244527786970139,
0.0885239690542221,
0.3807466924190521,
0.8835199475288391,
-1.0172961950302124,
0.6606407761573792,
0.37102505564689636,
0.5903301239013672,
0.7702658176422119,
0.13751019537448883,
0.48981010913848877,
-0.46796903014183044,
0.08497457206249237,
0.46237412095069885,
0.48550713062286377,
0.40156158804893494,
-0.6459917426109314,
0.16072063148021698,
0.012716537341475487,
-0.7108205556869507,
-0.5853409767150879,
0.06066100671887398,
-0.9274314045906067,
-0.1936897486448288,
0.9769150018692017,
-0.3054599463939667,
-0.29691281914711,
-0.27571332454681396,
-0.3483113944530487,
0.542347252368927,
-0.4432006776332855,
0.526706337928772,
0.47298169136047363,
-0.46985942125320435,
-0.03532522916793823,
-0.33856338262557983,
0.5903381705284119,
0.6392182111740112,
-0.728336751461029,
0.2768447697162628,
0.5230840444564819,
0.3838039040565491,
-0.03487125784158707,
0.8113325238227844,
-0.05810655280947685,
0.32361406087875366,
0.11534737795591354,
0.3273921608924866,
-0.30900704860687256,
-0.21288298070430756,
-0.6678239107131958,
-0.11839202791452408,
-0.13751983642578125,
-0.6334412693977356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18638v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18638v1
|
ConSiDERS-The-Human Evaluation Framework: Rethinking Human Evaluation for Generative Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T22:45:28 | 2024-05-28T22:45:28 |
Aparna Elangovan, Ling Liu, Lei Xu, Sravan Bodapati, Dan Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this position paper, we argue that human evaluation of generative large
language models (LLMs) should be a multidisciplinary undertaking that draws
upon insights from disciplines such as user experience research and human
behavioral psychology to ensure that the experimental design and results are
reliable. The conclusions from these evaluations, thus, must consider factors
such as usability, aesthetics, and cognitive biases. We highlight how cognitive
biases can conflate fluent information and truthfulness, and how cognitive
uncertainty affects the reliability of rating scores such as Likert.
Furthermore, the evaluation should differentiate the capabilities and
weaknesses of increasingly powerful large language models -- which requires
effective test sets. The scalability of human evaluation is also crucial to
wider adoption. Hence, to design an effective human evaluation system in the
age of generative NLP, we propose the ConSiDERS-The-Human evaluation framework
consisting of 6 pillars --Consistency, Scoring Critera, Differentiating, User
Experience, Responsible, and Scalability.
|
[
-0.523420512676239,
-0.46416550874710083,
0.5624645948410034,
0.5850290060043335,
0.000014646705494669732,
0.02721223048865795,
-0.5980462431907654,
-0.6896309852600098,
-0.03442200645804405,
0.3447113633155823,
-0.3893109858036041,
-0.21906276047229767,
-0.27280193567276,
0.1704261302947998,
-0.344573974609375,
0.6433976292610168,
0.2369225174188614,
0.139920175075531,
-0.5136304497718811,
0.003835520939901471,
-0.2686620056629181,
-0.5531496405601501,
-0.6832996606826782,
-0.6611014008522034,
0.4547260105609894,
0.26256856322288513,
0.794780969619751,
0.18530888855457306,
0.4575124979019165,
0.26307395100593567,
-0.21375462412834167,
-0.15081633627414703,
-0.391139417886734,
0.07517542690038681,
-0.31627708673477173,
-0.38816380500793457,
-0.6450676918029785,
0.07786495983600616,
0.6724447011947632,
0.8193872570991516,
-0.29864567518234253,
0.07784093171358109,
0.25951138138771057,
0.6378094553947449,
-0.4687967002391815,
0.1487298160791397,
-0.24971255660057068,
0.15266156196594238,
-0.04365010932087898,
-0.04150375351309776,
-0.42169374227523804,
-0.2533954679965973,
0.40178143978118896,
-0.41880640387535095,
0.2707175016403198,
0.12943600118160248,
0.4248710870742798,
-0.003319211071357131,
-0.504282534122467,
-0.07760630548000336,
-0.7228454351425171,
1.0105483531951904,
-0.7247618436813354,
0.6348528861999512,
0.4602772891521454,
0.2535901367664337,
-0.12801200151443481,
-0.38482195138931274,
-0.4992987811565399,
-0.5714638233184814,
0.12883742153644562,
0.08062973618507385,
0.033308856189250946,
0.1565466970205307,
0.34441858530044556,
0.6365194320678711,
-0.521994411945343,
0.39085012674331665,
-0.3851321041584015,
-0.35895198583602905,
1.0528854131698608,
0.22222991287708282,
0.29142701625823975,
-0.3115637004375458,
-0.38429105281829834,
-0.001422262517735362,
-0.6997725367546082,
-0.17520666122436523,
0.5280407667160034,
0.11075261235237122,
0.01318803895264864,
0.47356486320495605,
-0.45805078744888306,
0.6877825856208801,
-0.1241854801774025,
-0.14376623928546906,
0.4134069085121155,
-0.35621318221092224,
-0.1793503761291504,
-0.26247847080230713,
0.8158890008926392,
0.5443117022514343,
0.46373194456100464,
-0.35514649748802185,
-0.2975271940231323,
0.31936904788017273,
0.7800617814064026,
-0.6091033816337585,
-0.00916817132383585,
0.30467382073402405,
-0.5104682445526123,
-0.3218756318092346,
-0.023727457970380783,
-0.9191005825996399,
-0.3922785222530365,
-0.4942108392715454,
0.09850414097309113,
-0.2978215217590332,
-0.385934054851532,
0.2216392159461975,
0.06487994641065598,
0.35020846128463745,
0.4263741970062256,
-0.9972085356712341,
0.3623037338256836,
0.699025571346283,
0.19675113260746002,
-0.24583622813224792,
-0.6453152894973755,
-0.0647176057100296,
-0.23838596045970917,
-0.28244301676750183,
0.8167212009429932,
-0.4159429371356964,
-0.6429398655891418,
0.030707942321896553,
-0.25695767998695374,
0.12311823666095734,
-0.5839554071426392,
0.9680174589157104,
-0.4828910529613495,
0.18732129037380219,
-0.5396000146865845,
-0.5010243654251099,
-0.11092216521501541,
0.417169988155365,
-0.7356290817260742,
0.8729325532913208,
0.20096607506275177,
-0.5970282554626465,
0.5596199035644531,
-0.8433951735496521,
-0.4668150544166565,
0.20585428178310394,
-0.20520474016666412,
-0.36383458971977234,
0.14874958992004395,
0.11520783603191376,
0.2595284879207611,
-0.6671987175941467,
0.46042564511299133,
-0.336712509393692,
-0.41777288913726807,
0.6159965395927429,
-0.6042409539222717,
0.9028616547584534,
0.38210341334342957,
-0.3067101836204529,
0.29849156737327576,
-0.8508983254432678,
0.4151652753353119,
-0.017575116828083992,
-0.6693624258041382,
-0.057973381131887436,
0.190512016415596,
0.558208167552948,
0.10829930752515793,
0.14296506345272064,
-0.4489642381668091,
-0.019307125359773636,
-0.430715948343277,
0.47767186164855957,
0.6041176319122314,
-0.1705089658498764,
0.5095897912979126,
-0.3315785229206085,
0.7717478275299072,
-0.40001434087753296,
0.26920586824417114,
0.09482487291097641,
-0.4298601448535919,
-0.7413254380226135,
-0.14216269552707672,
0.2960047125816345,
0.28680774569511414,
-0.42091134190559387,
0.6247179508209229,
-0.23980022966861725,
-0.5041573643684387,
-0.49070051312446594,
0.2501567304134369,
0.5422247648239136,
0.12842412292957306,
0.09345357120037079,
-0.5449855327606201,
-0.7552160024642944,
-0.9013425707817078,
-0.4659804701805115,
-0.46317821741104126,
-0.2298152595758438,
0.02714349515736103,
0.577629029750824,
-0.5689637660980225,
0.8633952736854553,
-0.25021013617515564,
0.04202089086174965,
-0.27977651357650757,
0.18350081145763397,
-0.19487424194812775,
0.39889389276504517,
0.47231799364089966,
-0.6944555640220642,
0.1123034730553627,
-0.2663024365901947,
-0.8276838064193726,
-0.15172211825847626,
0.18221525847911835,
0.11987911909818649,
0.08343841880559921,
0.12023860961198807,
-0.7610733509063721,
0.3471733629703522,
0.3220156133174896,
-0.3854506313800812,
0.84532630443573,
-0.2156212329864502,
0.33581945300102234,
-0.7144265174865723,
0.09129831194877625,
0.1692022979259491,
0.013533051125705242,
-0.31075751781463623,
0.3041236102581024,
-0.01947728358209133,
-0.11428283154964447,
-0.27732017636299133,
0.628526508808136,
-0.43459373712539673,
-0.4011862576007843,
-0.15865649282932281,
0.12093204259872437,
0.23450139164924622,
0.14833058416843414,
-0.17684033513069153,
0.6471565365791321,
0.1479032188653946,
-0.37914198637008667,
0.3904534876346588,
0.110623799264431,
-0.8466336131095886,
1.041109561920166,
-0.6317086219787598,
0.33572301268577576,
-0.06949564814567566,
0.2945828139781952,
-0.9489465951919556,
-0.3680478632450104,
0.054171301424503326,
-0.4464430510997772,
0.15968897938728333,
0.40648213028907776,
-0.7153767943382263,
-0.4981587529182434,
-0.4392382502555847,
0.3611777126789093,
0.33462128043174744,
-0.1917370855808258,
0.4658615291118622,
0.4029587209224701,
0.1152200922369957,
-0.4310080409049988,
-0.5719622373580933,
0.30534130334854126,
-0.27769479155540466,
-0.7482693195343018,
0.31313228607177734,
-0.23666131496429443,
-0.543502926826477,
-0.1578700691461563,
0.04222395643591881,
-0.020943008363246918,
0.4067061245441437,
0.2719794809818268,
0.2525802552700043,
-0.03519168496131897,
0.04782569408416748,
-0.3374411463737488,
-0.1322993040084839,
0.27895110845565796,
-0.05595772713422775,
0.34486696124076843,
-0.4998285472393036,
-0.48389795422554016,
-0.4736764132976532,
0.2852140963077545,
0.5534287095069885,
-0.22418534755706787,
0.3370996117591858,
0.5718246698379517,
-0.41581568121910095,
0.030904017388820648,
-0.7377514839172363,
-0.18527066707611084,
-0.32803571224212646,
0.641730546951294,
-0.4407646358013153,
-1.0335843563079834,
0.37603047490119934,
0.0993722453713417,
0.12018971890211105,
0.6169468760490417,
0.8573087453842163,
-0.35141706466674805,
0.6524696350097656,
0.6203013062477112,
0.03395390883088112,
0.20149725675582886,
-0.1185889020562172,
0.2342325747013092,
-1.1028541326522827,
-0.24495650827884674,
-0.6384003758430481,
-0.19065402448177338,
-0.35914701223373413,
-0.32079747319221497,
0.1902773380279541,
0.05789012834429741,
-0.258717805147171,
0.06841577589511871,
-0.1436527520418167,
0.20555870234966278,
0.1839636266231537,
0.05179981514811516,
0.3843066692352295,
0.007167415227741003,
-0.23768112063407898,
-0.15815705060958862,
-0.5055587887763977,
-0.7586224675178528,
1.198604941368103,
0.535638689994812,
0.9017733335494995,
0.17193491756916046,
0.34534594416618347,
0.5444437861442566,
0.6793227195739746,
-0.9229616522789001,
0.5451882481575012,
0.2646927535533905,
-1.0043408870697021,
-0.49246832728385925,
-0.3140193819999695,
-0.9100457429885864,
0.546776533126831,
-0.29692912101745605,
-0.9297570586204529,
-0.11135009676218033,
0.04473629221320152,
-0.4940854012966156,
-0.002376832766458392,
-0.7632211446762085,
0.6787548065185547,
-0.36771872639656067,
-0.2546236217021942,
-0.49383431673049927,
-0.4890342056751251,
0.4970206916332245,
-0.12371446192264557,
0.26978546380996704,
0.008118067868053913,
0.09056020528078079,
0.9927170872688293,
-0.013070761226117611,
0.8817058205604553,
0.09116779267787933,
-0.30772683024406433,
0.31235605478286743,
-0.060851242393255234,
-0.0932207852602005,
0.04178633913397789,
-0.2773950397968292,
0.17722538113594055,
0.016302846372127533,
-0.32000815868377686,
-0.7642800807952881,
0.6470722556114197,
-0.8142627477645874,
-0.745628297328949,
-0.31675440073013306,
-0.36347970366477966,
-0.4394078254699707,
0.08624267578125,
0.09420947730541229,
0.2211330384016037,
-0.7574582099914551,
0.21552598476409912,
0.5833027958869934,
-0.24962352216243744,
-0.008426206186413765,
0.35029447078704834,
-0.5585564374923706,
-0.4948257505893707,
0.5945941209793091,
-0.005390144418925047,
0.2999369204044342,
0.12579257786273956,
0.16663838922977448,
-0.5042913556098938,
-0.32796546816825867,
-0.615068793296814,
0.13625186681747437,
-0.7626597285270691,
0.1546531468629837,
-0.3398362994194031,
-0.21130849421024323,
-0.14848101139068604,
-0.03227686136960983,
-0.4279426634311676,
-0.015190945006906986,
-0.24335986375808716,
-0.1584351509809494,
-0.07193911075592041,
0.7344914078712463,
0.10133181512355804,
0.22302164137363434,
-0.5249547958374023,
0.2988927960395813,
0.4312700033187866,
0.6046030521392822,
0.3558068871498108,
-0.6264188885688782,
-0.12907719612121582,
-0.004917313810437918,
-0.34742552042007446,
-0.3721621632575989,
-0.07108531147241592,
-0.04535149037837982,
0.9083456993103027,
0.46342217922210693,
-0.26493826508522034,
0.34688588976860046,
-0.34769997000694275,
0.5665221214294434,
0.385551393032074,
-0.8120519518852234,
0.09222932904958725,
-0.30845850706100464,
0.3512526750564575,
0.6677390933036804,
0.2621164917945862,
-0.6202770471572876,
0.18493667244911194,
-0.5568885803222656,
-0.6258032917976379,
0.5131746530532837,
0.19491614401340485,
0.09281649440526962,
-0.006599172484129667,
0.28924560546875,
0.03084431402385235,
0.25729089975357056,
-0.6813564300537109,
0.004085997119545937,
0.14370200037956238,
-0.028946230188012123,
-0.22498831152915955,
-0.7899599075317383,
-0.1263742595911026,
-0.12209580838680267,
0.26993411779403687,
0.04089696332812309,
0.26021608710289,
0.07533952593803406,
-0.08829589188098907,
-0.23298978805541992,
0.8131467700004578,
0.5923388004302979,
1.3336623907089233,
-0.2805315852165222,
0.12055649608373642,
0.14674252271652222,
-0.23895767331123352,
0.3649587035179138,
-0.1959855854511261,
-0.037371598184108734,
-0.538271427154541,
0.5696730613708496,
0.5204715728759766,
0.5966259837150574,
-0.8548135161399841,
0.4435010552406311,
-0.07367228716611862,
-0.07315084338188171,
-0.4320138394832611,
0.03915783390402794,
0.3061510920524597,
0.0863584578037262,
0.3691767156124115,
0.1784980297088623,
0.16023555397987366,
-0.8252400159835815,
0.14806853234767914,
0.2788539230823517,
-0.4388059973716736,
-0.5177630186080933,
0.48488354682922363,
0.3824585974216461,
-0.5621491074562073,
0.764647901058197,
-0.02509552426636219,
-0.6999751329421997,
0.5044663548469543,
0.4304046332836151,
0.9973246455192566,
-0.3971730172634125,
0.00005054259963799268,
0.09035030007362366,
0.6236774325370789,
-0.26015397906303406,
0.32659652829170227,
-0.09598980844020844,
-0.7978416681289673,
-0.6646036505699158,
-0.8361684083938599,
-0.3251079022884369,
0.03546058014035225,
-0.6940993070602417,
0.06518899649381638,
-0.2982562184333801,
-0.4203524887561798,
0.0984390527009964,
0.03974999487400055,
-0.79960036277771,
0.4876987338066101,
0.28320297598838806,
0.8174876570701599,
-0.7553196549415588,
0.6534146070480347,
0.6632487177848816,
-0.2802923023700714,
-0.3599018156528473,
0.013101615943014622,
0.051946643739938736,
-0.4574052691459656,
0.6716727614402771,
0.12058374285697937,
-0.27278634905815125,
-0.3085325360298157,
-0.37365078926086426,
-0.5247164368629456,
0.8889219760894775,
0.3463892936706543,
-0.5788259506225586,
0.031759168952703476,
-0.08932062238454819,
0.8615330457687378,
-0.3362630009651184,
0.33135586977005005,
0.7594549655914307,
0.5825883150100708,
-0.12868991494178772,
-1.0990171432495117,
-0.12461575120687485,
-0.1971932351589203,
0.336885005235672,
-0.2401583045721054,
-0.7970789670944214,
0.5240396857261658,
-0.3239668309688568,
-0.19682718813419342,
0.20666392147541046,
0.6964520215988159,
0.45487308502197266,
0.20034131407737732,
0.6404475569725037,
0.7399489283561707,
0.6657479405403137,
0.09178288280963898,
1.3941620588302612,
0.12192709743976593,
0.42330288887023926,
0.932072639465332,
-0.41850414872169495,
0.7282800078392029,
0.40285128355026245,
-0.8844549059867859,
0.2284529060125351,
0.6370360851287842,
0.1767219752073288,
0.12919823825359344,
0.6545774340629578,
-0.1033146008849144,
-0.35993796586990356,
0.054325275123119354,
-0.2511529326438904,
0.66551274061203,
0.4132523834705353,
-0.24250063300132751,
-0.14622941613197327,
-0.22941355407238007,
-0.05188033729791641,
0.2284674495458603,
-0.06963273882865906,
0.3739590346813202,
0.2943904995918274,
-0.7622781991958618,
0.5081068873405457,
0.294326514005661,
0.6137773990631104,
-0.35313737392425537,
0.07297724485397339,
0.01325004268437624,
-0.04362346976995468,
-0.36756348609924316,
-0.8223798274993896,
0.3332991600036621,
-0.013148975558578968,
-0.3851572573184967,
-0.10789693892002106,
0.6741488575935364,
0.04457925260066986,
-0.6230403780937195,
0.38287922739982605,
0.5502033829689026,
0.21618317067623138,
-0.07299071550369263,
-0.7390042543411255,
0.44133034348487854,
0.0035433892626315355,
-0.42972755432128906,
0.3342433571815491,
0.13063663244247437,
-0.2030208706855774,
0.8443669080734253,
0.5514170527458191,
-0.17249108850955963,
-0.1990654319524765,
0.4640900492668152,
0.5767099261283875,
-0.9091683030128479,
-0.22432932257652283,
-0.9014968276023865,
0.27057597041130066,
0.05656924098730087,
-0.4427562654018402,
0.7174968123435974,
0.556015133857727,
0.722500741481781,
0.07656847685575485,
0.8753767609596252,
-0.0647013857960701,
0.25654587149620056,
-0.2621578574180603,
0.7977744936943054,
-0.29210364818573,
0.4300488531589508,
-0.5270065665245056,
-1.2151412963867188,
-0.3576349914073944,
0.7106791138648987,
-0.4648803472518921,
0.4666299819946289,
0.5525501370429993,
0.40183332562446594,
0.1591416597366333,
0.1685548573732376,
0.48716336488723755,
0.010013695806264877,
0.3093683123588562,
0.40131911635398865,
1.2327669858932495,
-0.3136328160762787,
0.07179200649261475,
0.12443698197603226,
-0.24203480780124664,
-0.36921900510787964,
-0.8500228524208069,
-0.8078951239585876,
-0.4797719120979309,
-0.15838029980659485,
-0.30458828806877136,
-0.18466360867023468,
0.9099757671356201,
0.5923318266868591,
-0.6006643772125244,
-0.5656631588935852,
0.3235829174518585,
0.11624578386545181,
-0.15833629667758942,
-0.29236769676208496,
0.3283742070198059,
-0.1842874139547348,
-0.6334193348884583,
0.20983032882213593,
0.5313738584518433,
-0.3177895247936249,
-1.0589286088943481,
-0.19350337982177734,
-0.020099924877285957,
-0.13204745948314667,
0.8128829598426819,
0.05837841331958771,
-1.0969147682189941,
-0.3453330397605896,
-0.20846176147460938,
-0.2744516134262085,
0.015205375850200653,
0.787775993347168,
-0.6514568328857422,
0.6989089846611023,
0.2471981942653656,
0.7291049957275391,
0.27849164605140686,
-0.06682322919368744,
0.68427574634552,
-0.08964117616415024,
0.011618970893323421,
0.18803809583187103,
0.44753560423851013,
0.693510115146637,
-0.1288398951292038,
0.6008492112159729,
0.11834505200386047,
-0.5327008366584778,
-0.6866440773010254,
0.2637837529182434,
-1.0435388088226318,
-0.05888942629098892,
1.127313494682312,
-0.2721228003501892,
-0.21278952062129974,
-0.2806697487831116,
-0.1355876624584198,
-0.11500050127506256,
-0.15053525567054749,
1.064773440361023,
0.9174906015396118,
-0.05505097284913063,
-0.08743708580732346,
-0.6833952069282532,
0.31711599230766296,
0.40611276030540466,
-0.7096834182739258,
-0.0692567452788353,
0.4679713845252991,
0.4360414445400238,
0.22868210077285767,
0.6640580296516418,
-0.2889038026332855,
0.2930263578891754,
-0.06560894846916199,
0.4200366139411926,
0.37804892659187317,
-0.1822691559791565,
-0.39124855399131775,
0.027529437094926834,
0.6016804575920105,
0.39250603318214417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18634v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18634v1
|
A Theoretical Understanding of Self-Correction through In-context Alignment
| 2024-05-28T22:33:02 | 2024-05-28T22:33:02 |
Yifei Wang, Yuyang Wu, Zeming Wei, Stefanie Jegelka, Yisen Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Going beyond mimicking limited human experiences, recent studies show initial
evidence that, like humans, large language models (LLMs) are capable of
improving their abilities purely by self-correction, i.e., correcting previous
responses through self-examination, in certain circumstances. Nevertheless,
little is known about how such capabilities arise. In this work, based on a
simplified setup akin to an alignment task, we theoretically analyze
self-correction from an in-context learning perspective, showing that when LLMs
give relatively accurate self-examinations as rewards, they are capable of
refining responses in an in-context way. Notably, going beyond previous
theories on over-simplified linear transformers, our theoretical construction
underpins the roles of several key designs of realistic transformers for
self-correction: softmax attention, multi-head attention, and the MLP block. We
validate these findings extensively on synthetic datasets. Inspired by these
findings, we also illustrate novel applications of self-correction, such as
defending against LLM jailbreaks, where a simple self-correction step does make
a large difference. We believe that these findings will inspire further
research on understanding, exploiting, and enhancing self-correction for
building better foundation models.
|
[
-0.1907210350036621,
-0.4985618591308594,
0.4024403393268585,
0.002410760847851634,
0.32740965485572815,
-0.06584513932466507,
-0.421326607465744,
-0.30652499198913574,
0.0829683318734169,
0.487607479095459,
-0.7386507987976074,
0.08260434865951538,
-0.34218278527259827,
0.41860073804855347,
-0.6477282047271729,
1.1177501678466797,
-0.12812843918800354,
-0.055502522736787796,
-0.12441375106573105,
-0.23241783678531647,
-0.9351997971534729,
-0.4294261038303375,
-0.19566741585731506,
-0.23551566898822784,
0.5938286185264587,
0.735141396522522,
0.4682121276855469,
0.9106257557868958,
0.5318354368209839,
0.40810802578926086,
0.2788807451725006,
-0.12444090843200684,
-0.6401343941688538,
0.17359361052513123,
-0.4799208343029022,
-0.5286877751350403,
-0.49053865671157837,
0.25890782475471497,
0.8233960866928101,
0.5217937231063843,
-0.16190487146377563,
0.06316522508859634,
0.5866069793701172,
0.8447269201278687,
-0.5718605518341064,
-0.3690129816532135,
-0.6452774405479431,
0.08795148879289627,
-0.2163545936346054,
-0.16479137539863586,
-0.42036187648773193,
0.2543424665927887,
0.030918946489691734,
-0.348594605922699,
0.4072483479976654,
-0.16901065409183502,
0.5512648820877075,
0.7919841408729553,
-0.5855696201324463,
-0.2059183418750763,
-0.788917601108551,
0.6291331052780151,
-0.5959722995758057,
0.26609352231025696,
0.06735890358686447,
0.44894757866859436,
-0.28155961632728577,
-0.55197674036026,
-0.48396143317222595,
0.189412459731102,
-0.4176601767539978,
0.060475025326013565,
0.203081414103508,
0.11200495064258575,
0.4106115698814392,
0.48115676641464233,
-0.33562907576560974,
0.1806384176015854,
-0.334486722946167,
-0.2569276988506317,
0.46591752767562866,
0.15867452323436737,
0.077132448554039,
-0.09886328130960464,
-0.537609338760376,
-0.2065693736076355,
-0.9278287291526794,
0.06449852883815765,
0.09254902601242065,
0.40913230180740356,
-0.0774916335940361,
0.5590677261352539,
-0.14564700424671173,
0.8462373614311218,
0.6215856075286865,
-0.28834268450737,
-0.1344054788351059,
-0.31723710894584656,
-0.24250385165214539,
0.18818026781082153,
0.46097078919410706,
0.3440724015235901,
0.22606885433197021,
-0.26679521799087524,
-0.25215792655944824,
-0.05440949276089668,
0.7536880970001221,
-0.6197444200515747,
0.08953826874494553,
0.30591192841529846,
-0.23035161197185516,
-0.1378817856311798,
-0.1257973313331604,
-0.4340554177761078,
-0.3123508393764496,
-0.7241865992546082,
0.7176446318626404,
-0.19139519333839417,
0.08976280689239502,
0.20136868953704834,
0.3112473785877228,
0.2818305492401123,
0.23744836449623108,
-1.112326741218567,
0.16626302897930145,
0.6980676054954529,
0.5267054438591003,
-0.1820228099822998,
-0.585106611251831,
-0.302979975938797,
0.34148943424224854,
-0.250236451625824,
0.8590905666351318,
-0.14350609481334686,
-0.034490738064050674,
-0.07141992449760437,
-0.045977842062711716,
-0.1039327085018158,
-0.32769012451171875,
0.3220840394496918,
-0.23853255808353424,
0.17954754829406738,
-0.4802462160587311,
-0.6869518756866455,
0.1738453060388565,
0.2787497341632843,
-0.5009752511978149,
0.816513180732727,
0.03741278126835823,
-0.6953654289245605,
0.3578774631023407,
-0.407577246427536,
-0.4636691212654114,
-0.2212422639131546,
-0.22586208581924438,
-0.2863699495792389,
0.17146924138069153,
0.12513843178749084,
0.4478573501110077,
0.12983697652816772,
0.17913617193698883,
-0.20843645930290222,
-0.43431565165519714,
0.44701525568962097,
-0.28581559658050537,
0.5504822134971619,
0.1342453956604004,
-0.7868013381958008,
0.07741210609674454,
-0.5411896705627441,
-0.10238263010978699,
-0.08877799659967422,
-0.19458557665348053,
-0.1587149053812027,
-0.0804503783583641,
-0.48070716857910156,
0.441475510597229,
0.07416553050279617,
-0.5708369612693787,
0.5041793584823608,
-0.46844515204429626,
0.4827609658241272,
1.0363552570343018,
-0.4998501241207123,
0.7637965083122253,
-0.16133765876293182,
0.42907217144966125,
-0.26554930210113525,
0.17818012833595276,
-0.542803168296814,
0.11063025891780853,
-0.8004007339477539,
-0.09467996656894684,
0.6484677791595459,
0.42109543085098267,
-0.14402535557746887,
0.41063758730888367,
-0.1784900277853012,
-0.046012695878744125,
-0.6587632894515991,
0.47072750329971313,
0.5264171361923218,
0.9797613024711609,
0.4588816463947296,
-0.25076577067375183,
-0.622723400592804,
-0.8796132206916809,
-0.5501600503921509,
0.12747690081596375,
0.14010657370090485,
0.04719968140125275,
0.29929405450820923,
-0.14621631801128387,
1.336342692375183,
-0.15495310723781586,
-0.6393314599990845,
-0.042610201984643936,
-0.15494035184383392,
-0.02203037030994892,
0.6926131248474121,
0.49245136976242065,
-0.4418112635612488,
-0.38892754912376404,
-0.24121107161045074,
-0.8524501919746399,
-0.24681611359119415,
-0.4009850025177002,
-0.2261701226234436,
0.14853642880916595,
0.793084442615509,
-0.36761826276779175,
0.39455485343933105,
0.4660772681236267,
-0.3022800087928772,
0.44228076934814453,
-0.23598411679267883,
-0.02946770377457142,
-0.89178466796875,
-0.17399919033050537,
-0.01532773394137621,
-0.33212780952453613,
-0.6811606287956238,
0.21353469789028168,
0.519118070602417,
0.26566219329833984,
-0.19896872341632843,
0.6740177869796753,
-0.44405707716941833,
-0.2335088551044464,
-0.5902566313743591,
0.2280772179365158,
-0.21339794993400574,
0.45448893308639526,
-0.22314471006393433,
0.8006387948989868,
0.2560403048992157,
-0.5992714762687683,
-0.08464675396680832,
0.17998315393924713,
-0.0673486590385437,
0.9221940636634827,
-0.5620239973068237,
0.21470056474208832,
-0.26432836055755615,
0.4198143482208252,
-1.2465932369232178,
-0.3252418339252472,
0.12226800620555878,
-0.17721810936927795,
0.6922052502632141,
-0.07343161106109619,
-0.2763080596923828,
-0.4374520182609558,
-0.05913599953055382,
0.6262041926383972,
0.2512994408607483,
-0.8607037663459778,
0.6067389249801636,
0.31236177682876587,
0.17331258952617645,
-0.9596278071403503,
-0.5180436968803406,
0.06809593737125397,
-0.4011777937412262,
-0.5674347281455994,
0.624006986618042,
-0.18114741146564484,
-0.1858149617910385,
-0.23583851754665375,
-0.24368581175804138,
0.36009517312049866,
0.21362261474132538,
0.1944834440946579,
0.05865458771586418,
-0.18289315700531006,
0.3240011930465698,
-0.12215370684862137,
-0.23679642379283905,
0.021513652056455612,
-0.3292246162891388,
0.2607284486293793,
-0.2944413423538208,
-0.4201590120792389,
-0.4136778712272644,
-0.00041878820047713816,
0.26568368077278137,
-0.08600187301635742,
0.37016865611076355,
0.16830144822597504,
-0.3223947286605835,
-0.08574263751506805,
-0.8475143909454346,
-0.5462918281555176,
-0.5564973950386047,
0.0071139587089419365,
-0.49855920672416687,
-1.0832144021987915,
0.4885176718235016,
0.17995305359363556,
0.1377480924129486,
0.5937177538871765,
0.6512657999992371,
-0.5562373995780945,
0.9790712594985962,
0.6955164074897766,
-0.06210257485508919,
0.3410041332244873,
-0.15809065103530884,
0.2245258092880249,
-1.1149885654449463,
-0.016092250123620033,
-0.4093649983406067,
-0.7659173011779785,
-0.543097198009491,
-0.04279223084449768,
0.1828967183828354,
0.015216678380966187,
-0.3050113022327423,
0.6408048868179321,
-0.5266690850257874,
0.6291797757148743,
0.315339058637619,
0.027504676952958107,
0.104826420545578,
-0.21617163717746735,
-0.1899338811635971,
-0.36882078647613525,
-0.69085693359375,
-0.3997657001018524,
1.1132287979125977,
0.49224552512168884,
0.9847395420074463,
-0.0954928770661354,
0.662600576877594,
0.15423583984375,
0.6205922365188599,
-0.6359560489654541,
0.18483072519302368,
0.19688110053539276,
-0.8178733587265015,
-0.5096468329429626,
0.020726002752780914,
-0.9432401061058044,
0.32702863216400146,
-0.0842764675617218,
-0.5418696403503418,
0.19074617326259613,
0.6886491775512695,
-0.5223027467727661,
0.13753312826156616,
-0.6107682585716248,
1.2106151580810547,
-0.557711124420166,
-0.5571523904800415,
-0.28390389680862427,
-0.9048294425010681,
0.4227651357650757,
-0.15773262083530426,
0.2727278769016266,
0.06888244301080704,
0.18292230367660522,
0.1957940012216568,
-0.2875879406929016,
1.1519744396209717,
-0.03880274295806885,
-0.5289453864097595,
0.25826552510261536,
0.20682333409786224,
0.32589998841285706,
-0.12653349339962006,
0.17061404883861542,
-0.1540675312280655,
-0.13834430277347565,
-0.37863782048225403,
-0.8688898682594299,
0.588833749294281,
-0.569246232509613,
-0.904829740524292,
-0.403597891330719,
-0.6709935665130615,
-0.1589350700378418,
0.09690594673156738,
0.053052518516778946,
0.481607049703598,
-0.08077596873044968,
0.25640496611595154,
0.5172481536865234,
0.26335498690605164,
0.42062103748321533,
0.5578343272209167,
-0.20377522706985474,
-0.16802462935447693,
0.5831262469291687,
0.2242935299873352,
0.3175002932548523,
0.317653626203537,
0.204196959733963,
-0.5706892609596252,
-0.17315562069416046,
-0.6033636331558228,
0.4181542992591858,
-0.9454259276390076,
-0.36079856753349304,
-0.5485618114471436,
0.0971967801451683,
-0.5450204610824585,
-0.2809261381626129,
-0.4802185893058777,
-0.4315465986728668,
-0.08886244148015976,
-0.08312153816223145,
-0.08076363056898117,
0.9108448624610901,
-0.33875709772109985,
0.5518923997879028,
-0.45697587728500366,
0.10998772829771042,
0.5083279013633728,
0.4494042992591858,
0.04210515320301056,
-0.9094778895378113,
-0.331396222114563,
0.19215738773345947,
-0.5668289661407471,
-0.7238850593566895,
0.10196588933467865,
0.3002015948295593,
0.5601695775985718,
0.4037909209728241,
-0.154942125082016,
1.155120611190796,
-0.7290100455284119,
0.4328465461730957,
-0.12002544850111008,
-1.0769596099853516,
0.5418303608894348,
-0.21146567165851593,
0.16076411306858063,
0.6938318014144897,
0.024522364139556885,
-0.7521683573722839,
-0.27017661929130554,
-0.5712679624557495,
-0.42233288288116455,
0.5763013362884521,
0.1932479292154312,
0.24436847865581512,
-0.0013656652299687266,
1.0727065801620483,
-0.034255363047122955,
-0.031232664361596107,
-0.9366604089736938,
-0.19890974462032318,
-0.40878984332084656,
-0.36054903268814087,
-0.19565577805042267,
-0.25803908705711365,
-0.3200145363807678,
-0.3391511142253876,
0.6965741515159607,
-0.5548367500305176,
0.21797385811805725,
0.44884762167930603,
-0.48970603942871094,
-0.2336834818124771,
0.29108139872550964,
0.8272112607955933,
0.6250478625297546,
0.026884589344263077,
0.18202152848243713,
0.4128841161727905,
0.15930868685245514,
0.3054405748844147,
-0.3346586227416992,
0.06695730984210968,
-0.5440724492073059,
0.2721506655216217,
0.38707417249679565,
0.5383278131484985,
-0.4542754888534546,
0.6042817234992981,
-0.028573883697390556,
0.20920881628990173,
-0.1436794251203537,
0.01463861484080553,
-0.030281126499176025,
0.2486347258090973,
0.3226313889026642,
-0.047736894339323044,
0.18961520493030548,
-0.6103454828262329,
0.5034811496734619,
0.6864326000213623,
-0.5297195911407471,
-0.3788623809814453,
0.7508672475814819,
0.002371301641687751,
-0.3491722047328949,
0.4991094172000885,
0.08152232319116592,
-0.5795615911483765,
0.5691852569580078,
0.9820048213005066,
0.6821503043174744,
-0.5409733057022095,
-0.0962805449962616,
0.4689856767654419,
0.2515563368797302,
-0.24810004234313965,
-0.19737184047698975,
-0.17355962097644806,
-0.8696778416633606,
-0.6995213031768799,
-0.5537306666374207,
-0.28292399644851685,
-0.04882682487368584,
-0.6416812539100647,
0.35539689660072327,
-0.3567051887512207,
0.013165987096726894,
-0.12018021941184998,
-0.42056992650032043,
-0.489448606967926,
0.38366609811782837,
0.10200514644384384,
0.6831344366073608,
-0.576284646987915,
0.8155034184455872,
0.3977024257183075,
-0.04040084406733513,
-0.8622856736183167,
0.19978155195713043,
0.09973406791687012,
-0.8896262645721436,
0.5246834754943848,
0.5961978435516357,
-0.2981288731098175,
-0.043951407074928284,
-0.5484352707862854,
-1.2009848356246948,
0.9496058225631714,
0.42088234424591064,
-0.6521458029747009,
-0.07392162829637527,
0.11250712722539902,
0.7819043397903442,
-0.5400148034095764,
0.10086534917354584,
0.6734104752540588,
0.2373393028974533,
-0.12495723366737366,
-0.9592534303665161,
0.060727979987859726,
0.05417433753609657,
-0.015378187410533428,
0.20654094219207764,
-0.7205261588096619,
0.7141929268836975,
-0.2794661223888397,
-0.14335526525974274,
0.023637128993868828,
0.8837451934814453,
-0.06189991906285286,
-0.24245691299438477,
0.4733229875564575,
0.6300739049911499,
0.32437339425086975,
-0.01961669512093067,
1.1260768175125122,
-0.5679495930671692,
0.5447788834571838,
1.3273111581802368,
-0.22726447880268097,
0.490779310464859,
0.5718201994895935,
-0.010896257124841213,
0.7188007831573486,
0.5816815495491028,
0.16137772798538208,
0.39668145775794983,
0.03430844098329544,
0.2490096092224121,
-0.32059982419013977,
0.17996066808700562,
-0.2337840050458908,
0.7009891271591187,
0.27801990509033203,
-0.22576966881752014,
-0.09736740589141846,
-0.0591672845184803,
-0.20909763872623444,
0.2717509865760803,
-0.35127952694892883,
0.678919792175293,
0.030401714146137238,
-1.0315200090408325,
0.4300762414932251,
-0.006285799201577902,
0.6124584674835205,
-0.21408531069755554,
-0.0009419794077984989,
-0.22096073627471924,
0.5335899591445923,
-0.30823758244514465,
-0.8124603033065796,
0.4768866002559662,
-0.2986930310726166,
-0.07772421836853027,
-0.5562503933906555,
0.8109914660453796,
-0.4668482542037964,
-0.12589751183986664,
0.24135573208332062,
0.16702088713645935,
-0.11780890077352524,
-0.04936124011874199,
-0.6943904757499695,
-0.20940996706485748,
-0.0618821382522583,
-0.08443788439035416,
0.434749037027359,
0.20666107535362244,
0.05045243725180626,
0.5783637166023254,
0.3025796413421631,
-0.287276953458786,
0.12786079943180084,
-0.04707401245832443,
0.42847999930381775,
-0.715130090713501,
-0.43441811203956604,
-1.0430995225906372,
0.6847547292709351,
0.06751982867717743,
-0.30253589153289795,
0.8348870277404785,
0.4895578622817993,
1.1732823848724365,
-0.018111316487193108,
0.5564655065536499,
0.11021454632282257,
0.5360328555107117,
-0.5462912321090698,
0.20773908495903015,
-0.6933113932609558,
0.16216905415058136,
-0.3538932800292969,
-0.7741830348968506,
-0.26849600672721863,
0.9965083003044128,
-0.2185395210981369,
-0.0018064157338812947,
0.573303759098053,
0.771318793296814,
-0.0789894312620163,
-0.18654286861419678,
0.23327171802520752,
0.3152207136154175,
0.1597784161567688,
0.20530949532985687,
0.86131352186203,
-0.6045571565628052,
0.41298913955688477,
-0.5861179232597351,
-0.07548234611749649,
-0.22813259065151215,
-0.9295200109481812,
-0.8566935658454895,
-0.5884277820587158,
-0.1353529989719391,
-0.5880366563796997,
-0.14393404126167297,
1.0682843923568726,
0.5089865922927856,
-0.8046706318855286,
-0.5118803977966309,
0.02743915654718876,
0.06296360492706299,
-0.316245436668396,
-0.14224179089069366,
0.21169324219226837,
-0.8091039657592773,
-0.6558501124382019,
0.5482761263847351,
0.45452117919921875,
0.1515049934387207,
-0.4535728096961975,
-0.151082381606102,
0.15232624113559723,
-0.008621207438409328,
0.5764026641845703,
0.476561576128006,
-1.018995761871338,
-0.6302205324172974,
0.2240203320980072,
-0.4509209990501404,
0.5643561482429504,
1.1333348751068115,
-0.9189267158508301,
0.5531820058822632,
0.1849936842918396,
0.7516390681266785,
0.3109390139579773,
0.26911309361457825,
0.7372586131095886,
-0.8837536573410034,
-0.08863434195518494,
-0.12824895977973938,
0.5825394988059998,
0.536733090877533,
-0.6814905405044556,
0.6285848021507263,
0.08898956328630447,
-0.7652527093887329,
-0.8059722781181335,
0.37724509835243225,
-0.6500468254089355,
-0.10367975383996964,
0.888154149055481,
0.11151517927646637,
-0.21925869584083557,
0.11562830209732056,
-0.338361918926239,
0.26705870032310486,
0.05157470703125,
1.2704702615737915,
0.7322521209716797,
-0.3206495940685272,
-0.05920315533876419,
-0.16811245679855347,
0.6506177186965942,
0.8484964370727539,
-0.5949829816818237,
0.29461169242858887,
0.39112377166748047,
0.5356554985046387,
0.22693179547786713,
0.5714700818061829,
-0.03559093922376633,
0.2684921324253082,
-0.6315758228302002,
0.08778683841228485,
0.4255865216255188,
-0.6092085838317871,
-0.8511145710945129,
-0.04597470164299011,
-0.05065058916807175,
0.25484132766723633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18628v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18628v2
|
Hardware-Aware Parallel Prompt Decoding for Memory-Efficient Acceleration of LLM Inference
| 2024-05-28T22:19:30 | 2024-06-02T14:58:48 |
Hao Mark Chen, Wayne Luk, Ka Fai Cedric Yiu, Rui Li, Konstantin Mishchenko, Stylianos I. Venieris, Hongxiang Fan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The auto-regressive decoding of Large Language Models (LLMs) results in
significant overheads in their hardware performance. While recent research has
investigated various speculative decoding techniques for multi-token
generation, these efforts have primarily focused on improving processing speed
such as throughput. Crucially, they often neglect other metrics essential for
real-life deployments, such as memory consumption and training cost. To
overcome these limitations, we propose a novel parallel prompt decoding that
requires only $0.0002$% trainable parameters, enabling efficient training on a
single A100-40GB GPU in just 16 hours. Inspired by the human natural language
generation process, $PPD$ approximates outputs generated at future timesteps in
parallel by using multiple prompt tokens. This approach partially recovers the
missing conditional dependency information necessary for multi-token
generation, resulting in up to a 28% higher acceptance rate for long-range
predictions. Furthermore, we present a hardware-aware dynamic sparse tree
technique that adaptively optimizes this decoding scheme to fully leverage the
computational capacities on different GPUs. Through extensive experiments
across LLMs ranging from MobileLlama to Vicuna-13B on a wide range of
benchmarks, our approach demonstrates up to 2.49$\times$ speedup and maintains
a minimal runtime memory overhead of just $0.0004$%. More importantly, our
parallel prompt decoding can serve as an orthogonal optimization for
synergistic integration with existing speculative decoding, showing up to
$1.22\times$ further speed improvement. Our code is available at
https://github.com/hmarkc/parallel-prompt-decoding.
|
[
-0.2925669252872467,
-0.743185818195343,
0.6635910868644714,
0.5823326706886292,
-0.5090885758399963,
0.28624606132507324,
-0.22123105823993683,
-0.24721859395503998,
0.08857064694166183,
0.07912082970142365,
-0.7600656747817993,
-0.4692284166812897,
-0.34455931186676025,
0.2925717830657959,
0.17596270143985748,
0.5226209759712219,
0.08576849102973938,
-0.1325777918100357,
-0.12118472903966904,
-0.19883276522159576,
-0.6460904479026794,
-0.6738302707672119,
-0.7970274090766907,
0.22846776247024536,
0.5117273330688477,
0.35281455516815186,
0.31136956810951233,
0.9821376204490662,
0.09281189739704132,
0.25302496552467346,
-0.185808002948761,
0.35586312413215637,
-0.3049216866493225,
0.23917150497436523,
0.308841735124588,
-0.34137043356895447,
-0.5808107852935791,
-0.38927385210990906,
0.7006440758705139,
0.365231990814209,
-0.20428961515426636,
0.16460521519184113,
0.1704256236553192,
0.41512492299079895,
-0.6882002353668213,
0.4481068551540375,
-0.6230419278144836,
0.037136949598789215,
-0.3541924059391022,
-0.5156593918800354,
-0.5979889631271362,
-0.17241013050079346,
-0.4930865466594696,
-0.9324095249176025,
0.28814175724983215,
0.5368783473968506,
0.38926562666893005,
0.36436453461647034,
-0.09663263708353043,
-0.016091100871562958,
-0.2482258826494217,
0.6950295567512512,
-0.5996471047401428,
0.387980580329895,
0.2201758772134781,
0.27990755438804626,
-0.2503458857536316,
-0.561168372631073,
-0.4857850670814514,
-0.13324640691280365,
0.1284138709306717,
0.04955997318029404,
-0.23026441037654877,
0.3228808045387268,
0.7279137969017029,
0.25470855832099915,
-0.638128399848938,
0.20979584753513336,
0.27357006072998047,
-0.4675542116165161,
0.006136583164334297,
0.5737300515174866,
0.16298791766166687,
-0.2620076835155487,
-0.31883519887924194,
-0.03229926899075508,
-0.7630904316902161,
0.20467764139175415,
0.3751920461654663,
0.430799663066864,
-0.220858633518219,
0.08968021720647812,
-0.18706174194812775,
0.540614902973175,
0.035088036209344864,
-0.11531326174736023,
0.20396992564201355,
-0.685478150844574,
-0.07019148766994476,
0.25119754672050476,
0.8285086750984192,
0.18728002905845642,
-0.07826115936040878,
-0.0847487673163414,
-0.18857912719249725,
0.20265524089336395,
-0.10351607203483582,
-1.056053638458252,
-0.18475770950317383,
0.09988855570554733,
-0.489518940448761,
0.12798629701137543,
-0.2740202844142914,
-0.882058322429657,
-0.48443344235420227,
-0.10695857554674149,
-0.21810565888881683,
-0.4145568907260895,
-0.11350949108600616,
0.3165767788887024,
-0.16340042650699615,
0.04317796602845192,
0.3163527250289917,
-1.020115852355957,
0.3058980107307434,
0.7533689737319946,
0.8031402826309204,
-0.07406104356050491,
-0.19710758328437805,
-1.0582462549209595,
-0.01958249695599079,
-0.15279965102672577,
0.7501325011253357,
-0.38143685460090637,
-0.4144468903541565,
-0.3205205202102661,
-0.015347967855632305,
-0.12269265949726105,
-0.4245317876338959,
0.7704877257347107,
-0.570173442363739,
-0.2720801830291748,
-0.6676773428916931,
-0.33896344900131226,
0.10895844548940659,
0.1689365804195404,
-0.526569664478302,
0.8222512602806091,
-0.1970893144607544,
-0.9724555611610413,
0.3627713918685913,
-0.4128856360912323,
-0.365715354681015,
0.1363464742898941,
-0.29634833335876465,
-0.21074853837490082,
0.24668332934379578,
0.7695412635803223,
0.24342279136180878,
-0.6304050087928772,
0.3452931344509125,
-0.3814549744129181,
-0.5805208683013916,
-0.05671399086713791,
-0.8723276853561401,
0.7918400764465332,
0.3640303611755371,
-0.3623395562171936,
0.2617016136646271,
-0.8688893914222717,
-0.27144283056259155,
0.061387259513139725,
-0.38374632596969604,
-0.06561796367168427,
-0.0898909792304039,
-0.12290215492248535,
-0.3590356707572937,
0.2971593141555786,
-0.6859909296035767,
0.1581852287054062,
-0.14401516318321228,
0.27736908197402954,
0.9228108525276184,
-0.07800570130348206,
0.26572930812835693,
0.003508523339405656,
0.7595478296279907,
-0.007946633733808994,
0.06827542185783386,
-0.9074177145957947,
-0.6350690126419067,
-0.46964940428733826,
-0.6304436922073364,
0.06162593141198158,
0.6137836575508118,
-0.9281516075134277,
0.25692665576934814,
-0.14296191930770874,
0.04240168631076813,
-0.5757938623428345,
0.17482027411460876,
0.4574105739593506,
0.9475703835487366,
0.3155854046344757,
-0.009571673348546028,
-0.6257001757621765,
-0.5141028761863708,
-0.4098377525806427,
-0.30367910861968994,
0.13091878592967987,
0.4911569356918335,
-0.17872431874275208,
0.03541769087314606,
0.6746485829353333,
-0.35986122488975525,
0.21873536705970764,
-0.21378961205482483,
0.16840294003486633,
0.49599209427833557,
0.49957552552223206,
0.43364015221595764,
-0.190078005194664,
-0.4341247081756592,
-0.10098010301589966,
-0.7167208194732666,
-0.26978981494903564,
-0.3708978593349457,
-0.055225592106580734,
0.2722182869911194,
0.6206181049346924,
-0.8695328235626221,
0.24839045107364655,
0.3879440128803253,
-0.48514842987060547,
0.7883480787277222,
-0.7127508521080017,
0.1424013376235962,
-0.9495278000831604,
-0.06355788558721542,
-0.13980446755886078,
-0.2971375286579132,
-0.15807268023490906,
-0.07660532742738724,
0.35058706998825073,
-0.11476612091064453,
-0.17502449452877045,
0.5958505868911743,
-0.7698439359664917,
-0.11007901281118393,
-0.34678953886032104,
-0.1345759779214859,
0.12700651586055756,
0.5039616227149963,
-0.11158599704504013,
1.228554129600525,
0.7970327138900757,
-0.4213356375694275,
0.3365347385406494,
-0.15853911638259888,
-0.20954245328903198,
0.31356704235076904,
-0.5519691109657288,
0.09423815459012985,
-0.2878260016441345,
0.35709458589553833,
-0.9449368119239807,
-0.07679697871208191,
0.4471905529499054,
-0.2876831591129303,
0.2568999230861664,
-0.1197754442691803,
-0.8117302656173706,
-0.4844696819782257,
-0.2494669109582901,
0.8658241033554077,
0.7884500026702881,
-1.006412386894226,
0.6836492419242859,
0.03695204108953476,
-0.2818070650100708,
-0.6974545121192932,
-0.5452785491943359,
0.29652106761932373,
-0.14049629867076874,
-0.49259740114212036,
0.20849426090717316,
-0.13365092873573303,
0.011595122516155243,
-0.1201184093952179,
-0.049220725893974304,
0.21954186260700226,
0.08290781825780869,
0.35523170232772827,
0.2915940284729004,
-0.5294739603996277,
-0.021582001820206642,
0.24031268060207367,
-0.4334952235221863,
0.15409688651561737,
-0.5825153589248657,
0.5447837710380554,
-0.2495308220386505,
-0.2978045642375946,
-0.843016505241394,
0.3383062183856964,
0.5563205480575562,
-0.12638184428215027,
0.48395296931266785,
0.705962061882019,
-0.20952056348323822,
-0.19887572526931763,
-0.4859703481197357,
-0.1834496110677719,
-0.5328623056411743,
0.29486483335494995,
-0.5019247531890869,
-0.7324158549308777,
0.6854239106178284,
-0.013649885542690754,
-0.10092349350452423,
0.1567133069038391,
0.4567576050758362,
0.16068676114082336,
1.0474191904067993,
0.45957139134407043,
-0.23722663521766663,
0.33122506737709045,
0.10782714933156967,
0.08124908804893494,
-0.6774618625640869,
-0.2565128803253174,
-0.45198628306388855,
-0.11680885404348373,
-0.23810307681560516,
-0.7188971638679504,
0.17790374159812927,
0.1073988825082779,
-0.2592611312866211,
0.1310472935438156,
-0.3792789876461029,
0.41640642285346985,
0.5972189903259277,
0.10988212376832962,
0.4234253764152527,
0.20266379415988922,
-0.31278088688850403,
-0.16618213057518005,
-0.9720345139503479,
-0.12951350212097168,
0.8499072790145874,
0.4149613082408905,
0.8019671440124512,
-0.35920172929763794,
0.42547371983528137,
0.23985037207603455,
0.16607819497585297,
-0.5611584186553955,
0.7425333857536316,
-0.10171640664339066,
0.0494355671107769,
0.14771461486816406,
-0.6485592126846313,
-0.7581170201301575,
0.03809148818254471,
-0.022412769496440887,
-0.5327428579330444,
0.2529636025428772,
0.5190764665603638,
-0.7477088570594788,
0.5140698552131653,
-0.5978114008903503,
0.7771621346473694,
-0.17791017889976501,
-0.35654306411743164,
-0.4418381452560425,
-0.31403759121894836,
0.3737408220767975,
0.06412091106176376,
0.08500659465789795,
-0.25157490372657776,
-0.2730923593044281,
0.6191529035568237,
-0.37507766485214233,
0.7930873036384583,
-0.5813027024269104,
0.055588990449905396,
0.23627601563930511,
-0.04523672163486481,
0.6939619779586792,
0.38792547583580017,
-0.22584903240203857,
0.026712052524089813,
-0.30368396639823914,
-0.5347136855125427,
-0.5059417486190796,
0.7632026672363281,
-0.5878536701202393,
-0.5737196207046509,
-0.36523446440696716,
-0.9167912602424622,
-0.2687433063983917,
0.08956817537546158,
0.17195309698581696,
0.718052089214325,
0.06839529424905777,
-0.2799576222896576,
0.7323722243309021,
-0.4563506543636322,
0.776611328125,
0.23691195249557495,
-0.016691887751221657,
-0.6378539800643921,
1.1097702980041504,
-0.42983147501945496,
-0.14900510013103485,
0.3320022225379944,
0.07595275342464447,
-0.49960625171661377,
-0.7849015593528748,
-0.8018835783004761,
0.30683958530426025,
-0.5094916224479675,
-0.29590538144111633,
-0.7997637391090393,
0.23712339997291565,
-0.3233487010002136,
-0.03353182226419449,
-0.23551897704601288,
-0.33660888671875,
-0.6647401452064514,
-0.03128942474722862,
0.5153786540031433,
0.27867066860198975,
0.011520503088831902,
0.6973203420639038,
-0.8108547329902649,
0.5384396314620972,
0.09774137288331985,
0.2546181380748749,
0.15418997406959534,
-0.5146461725234985,
-0.05690843239426613,
-0.24545703828334808,
0.035835664719343185,
-0.6163520812988281,
0.4417407214641571,
-0.020277291536331177,
0.5285568833351135,
0.58055180311203,
0.26535409688949585,
0.9631494879722595,
-0.5695404410362244,
0.5049628019332886,
0.3572923541069031,
-0.8115205764770508,
0.1656794548034668,
-0.27379393577575684,
0.540118932723999,
0.5823790431022644,
0.09123951941728592,
-0.25557923316955566,
-0.12042520940303802,
-0.21316967904567719,
-0.7055791020393372,
0.8806638717651367,
-0.2683374583721161,
0.08212780207395554,
-0.2892865240573883,
0.3216772973537445,
0.2151949107646942,
0.04978557676076889,
-0.20695525407791138,
-0.21068240702152252,
-0.12570935487747192,
-0.35703420639038086,
-0.09192617982625961,
-0.6035181879997253,
0.1372653841972351,
-0.28835251927375793,
0.30603599548339844,
-0.26255324482917786,
0.4266846477985382,
0.037743642926216125,
-0.012570356018841267,
0.22424399852752686,
0.23159179091453552,
0.4550597369670868,
0.26573723554611206,
-0.2965184450149536,
0.2930736839771271,
0.1356859803199768,
-0.5245494842529297,
0.13735628128051758,
0.4468214809894562,
0.059038009494543076,
0.1180272027850151,
-0.011018779128789902,
1.241469144821167,
0.1869431436061859,
-0.8858013153076172,
0.4909464418888092,
-0.5451958775520325,
0.09927453100681305,
0.0849258080124855,
-0.22660839557647705,
0.027975257486104965,
0.34426525235176086,
0.44035205245018005,
0.3044588565826416,
0.060552895069122314,
-0.11165372282266617,
0.1816754937171936,
0.3954612910747528,
-0.008662006817758083,
-0.5355204343795776,
0.9053720831871033,
0.29106420278549194,
-0.19402724504470825,
0.8831337094306946,
-0.6361942887306213,
-0.2306450605392456,
0.6264299750328064,
0.77422034740448,
1.0633385181427002,
0.08565833419561386,
-0.02461315132677555,
0.492985337972641,
0.15776564180850983,
-0.03953973576426506,
0.4504339396953583,
-0.519505500793457,
-0.41672852635383606,
-0.6739357113838196,
-0.8535515666007996,
-0.2556372284889221,
-0.29597771167755127,
-0.4239868223667145,
0.051903706043958664,
-0.7674769759178162,
-0.1715148538351059,
-0.4576680660247803,
-0.2302195131778717,
-0.4773911237716675,
-0.22491630911827087,
0.2852209508419037,
1.2489458322525024,
-0.4231407344341278,
0.9042011499404907,
0.26950153708457947,
0.3051973581314087,
-0.6780422329902649,
-0.03382040560245514,
-0.11569337546825409,
-0.8490132093429565,
0.5652191638946533,
0.4303377866744995,
-0.07918722927570343,
0.22312989830970764,
0.044715192168951035,
-0.5296587347984314,
0.9659972190856934,
0.7669206261634827,
-0.7543741464614868,
-0.16332939267158508,
-0.05986864119768143,
0.07637838274240494,
-0.4088655114173889,
0.48461687564849854,
0.541885256767273,
0.33516961336135864,
-0.030703013762831688,
-0.659013569355011,
0.46476441621780396,
-0.20370997488498688,
0.0856170505285263,
-0.0006896188715472817,
-0.323591411113739,
0.9229331612586975,
-0.49176865816116333,
-0.4545046091079712,
0.40110328793525696,
0.8174014687538147,
0.6628096103668213,
0.4770709276199341,
0.4669678509235382,
0.5550468564033508,
1.019463062286377,
0.05701576545834541,
1.2452245950698853,
-0.9116020202636719,
0.017307257279753685,
0.8431546092033386,
0.07912062108516693,
0.6320186853408813,
0.4718175530433655,
-0.026938848197460175,
0.2922228276729584,
0.7028302550315857,
0.28310614824295044,
0.4238220155239105,
0.03846282139420509,
-0.6784783601760864,
-0.5088019371032715,
-0.2364242821931839,
-0.32607385516166687,
-0.03046838380396366,
0.37836065888404846,
-0.21666468679904938,
-0.3863651752471924,
0.20958071947097778,
-0.09023504704236984,
-0.05759694427251816,
-0.5068374276161194,
0.4526004195213318,
0.03453872725367546,
-0.6354852318763733,
0.815809428691864,
0.032753728330135345,
0.9654107689857483,
-0.4743698239326477,
0.12071419507265091,
-0.2898390591144562,
0.26335567235946655,
0.09451258182525635,
-0.3750452399253845,
-0.0005475187790580094,
0.108644500374794,
-0.27374234795570374,
-0.4356309175491333,
0.5957332253456116,
-0.17957742512226105,
-0.47884735465049744,
0.1785718947649002,
0.36198946833610535,
0.11345267295837402,
-0.3072720170021057,
-0.6066046953201294,
0.5295289158821106,
-0.05843066796660423,
0.055067673325538635,
0.34832432866096497,
0.3704453110694885,
0.07139231264591217,
0.5816422700881958,
0.8264901041984558,
0.17459528148174286,
0.39065709710121155,
0.1286821812391281,
0.9923189282417297,
-0.7852537631988525,
-0.7882194519042969,
-0.9049020409584045,
0.25757309794425964,
0.12420295923948288,
-0.18131396174430847,
0.9276974201202393,
0.58378666639328,
0.34565815329551697,
-0.010841013863682747,
0.5946035981178284,
0.24263767898082733,
0.10548889636993408,
-0.4947972893714905,
0.3365994691848755,
-0.1513582319021225,
0.629382312297821,
0.1423468440771103,
-0.6415411233901978,
-0.1531335562467575,
0.06620004028081894,
-0.09808672219514847,
-0.21923039853572845,
0.487440288066864,
0.9104273319244385,
-0.11429198831319809,
0.26643821597099304,
0.19228710234165192,
0.12911765277385712,
0.2500752806663513,
0.6708782911300659,
0.7459155917167664,
-0.1414620280265808,
0.5711840987205505,
-0.1883382648229599,
-0.3933141529560089,
-0.01744401827454567,
-0.9683493375778198,
-0.7516120076179504,
-0.04762144759297371,
-0.15129663050174713,
-0.28553521633148193,
0.29693496227264404,
0.8123974800109863,
0.5890992283821106,
-0.6711896657943726,
-0.26906436681747437,
-0.5658330321311951,
0.06193156912922859,
-0.14482276141643524,
-0.19878412783145905,
0.357320636510849,
-0.8343873620033264,
-0.7048235535621643,
0.6974624991416931,
0.42802709341049194,
-0.13223755359649658,
-0.031117035076022148,
-0.3447803556919098,
0.2742880880832672,
0.005261903163045645,
0.5864025950431824,
0.5918964743614197,
-0.6360794305801392,
0.23794759809970856,
0.21429593861103058,
0.018725240603089333,
0.24439972639083862,
1.0644166469573975,
-1.215803623199463,
0.5093265771865845,
0.6217612624168396,
1.145781397819519,
0.3624805212020874,
0.22656965255737305,
0.4579671025276184,
-0.6265128254890442,
0.5042672753334045,
0.22120527923107147,
0.4168095886707306,
0.3153771758079529,
-0.42497843503952026,
-0.3001333475112915,
0.6647368669509888,
-0.391459584236145,
-0.882257342338562,
0.060316503047943115,
-1.1233469247817993,
-0.19780901074409485,
0.9327736496925354,
-0.2587936222553253,
-0.5289607644081116,
-0.08661019057035446,
-0.30130988359451294,
-0.0029427618719637394,
-0.8076038956642151,
0.30892321467399597,
0.10666858404874802,
-0.3137703239917755,
-0.4297340214252472,
-0.2790871560573578,
0.48915329575538635,
0.5822617411613464,
-0.6617047190666199,
0.5838977694511414,
0.5726314187049866,
-0.021177351474761963,
-0.23547756671905518,
0.8245617747306824,
0.050747890025377274,
0.45644745230674744,
0.46479031443595886,
-0.07663995772600174,
-0.4828794300556183,
-0.4421696066856384,
-0.6018893122673035,
0.353034645318985,
0.02461506612598896,
-0.355077862739563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18620v1
|
RealitySummary: On-Demand Mixed Reality Document Enhancement using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T21:59:56 | 2024-05-28T21:59:56 |
Aditya Gunturu, Shivesh Jadon, Nandi Zhang, Jarin Thundathil, Wesley Willett, Ryo Suzuki
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce RealitySummary, a mixed reality reading assistant that can
enhance any printed or digital document using on-demand text extraction,
summarization, and augmentation. While augmented reading tools promise to
enhance physical reading experiences with overlaid digital content, prior
systems have typically required pre-processed documents, which limits their
generalizability and real-world use cases. In this paper, we explore on-demand
document augmentation by leveraging large language models. To understand
generalizable techniques for diverse documents, we first conducted an
exploratory design study which identified five categories of document
enhancements (summarization, augmentation, navigation, comparison, and
extraction). Based on this, we developed a proof-of-concept system that can
automatically extract and summarize text using Google Cloud OCR and GPT-4, then
embed information around documents using a Microsoft Hololens 2 and Apple
Vision Pro. We demonstrate real-time examples of six specific document
augmentations: 1) summaries, 2) comparison tables, 3) timelines, 4) keyword
lists, 5) summary highlighting, and 6) information cards. Results from a
usability study (N=12) and in-the-wild study (N=11) highlight the potential
benefits of on-demand MR document enhancement and opportunities for future
research.
|
[
-0.4001125991344452,
-0.7891680598258972,
0.6712834239006042,
-0.024294007569551468,
-0.41232743859291077,
0.4106177091598511,
-0.02759692445397377,
-0.9308680295944214,
0.5835204720497131,
0.8134902119636536,
-0.37068167328834534,
-0.3762187063694,
-0.5848065614700317,
0.1475105881690979,
-0.36705824732780457,
0.8823522925376892,
-0.18149316310882568,
-0.2894347906112671,
-0.5345084071159363,
-0.06926242262125015,
-0.30800142884254456,
-0.4905205965042114,
0.158107191324234,
-0.14276668429374695,
0.35795366764068604,
0.6287012100219727,
0.8161795735359192,
0.6979497075080872,
0.8233946561813354,
0.26481249928474426,
0.029510891065001488,
0.6827139854431152,
-0.0778990387916565,
0.3519628942012787,
0.10260371118783951,
0.039573028683662415,
-0.7063382267951965,
-0.04039320722222328,
0.6836139559745789,
0.4544813930988312,
-0.15351273119449615,
-0.17762473225593567,
0.21320150792598724,
0.5087078809738159,
-0.8734882473945618,
-0.14815963804721832,
0.13532206416130066,
0.07204196602106094,
0.28879719972610474,
-0.23086370527744293,
-0.029971333220601082,
-0.20933273434638977,
0.2625705897808075,
-0.924579381942749,
0.47243258357048035,
0.18639954924583435,
0.9245800971984863,
0.18238498270511627,
-0.15843939781188965,
-0.7048764228820801,
-0.9812884330749512,
0.4281453490257263,
-0.4860899746417999,
0.8043979406356812,
0.4584563672542572,
0.05857186019420624,
0.30602285265922546,
-0.964449405670166,
-0.9836813807487488,
-0.36160898208618164,
-0.22459015250205994,
0.5425986051559448,
0.3270304501056671,
0.1408313810825348,
0.299096018075943,
0.7649753093719482,
-0.5245319604873657,
-0.1686842441558838,
-0.10429781675338745,
-0.04819374531507492,
0.29453232884407043,
-0.02774842083454132,
0.7169638872146606,
0.03112117014825344,
-0.026759035885334015,
-0.3963230848312378,
0.011163593269884586,
-0.31157252192497253,
0.1322590559720993,
0.01474644523113966,
-0.28335800766944885,
1.0131868124008179,
-0.07013356685638428,
0.981033205986023,
-0.17253582179546356,
-0.41397812962532043,
0.1765250563621521,
-0.6360814571380615,
-0.2224055528640747,
0.2867477238178253,
0.17922532558441162,
0.5190868973731995,
-0.29282206296920776,
-0.26740679144859314,
-0.15459492802619934,
-0.4677853584289551,
0.3727087676525116,
-0.803301990032196,
0.011269557289779186,
0.35576385259628296,
-0.22039702534675598,
-0.023195790126919746,
0.2713145315647125,
-0.7780494689941406,
-0.9465364813804626,
-0.5734923481941223,
0.15062737464904785,
-0.3731521964073181,
-0.3113153576850891,
0.26415854692459106,
-0.5198330283164978,
-0.007218336220830679,
0.7864561080932617,
-0.9995764493942261,
0.1247045174241066,
0.5618487596511841,
1.2248945236206055,
-0.23295344412326813,
-0.2536053955554962,
-0.5938853621482849,
0.47858238220214844,
-0.12041644752025604,
1.1200499534606934,
-0.5667439103126526,
-0.7882021069526672,
0.06837659329175949,
-0.3295941948890686,
0.005847591906785965,
-0.48545411229133606,
0.7304629683494568,
-0.4885994791984558,
0.5650275349617004,
-0.10307064652442932,
-0.458385705947876,
-0.0725022405385971,
0.8306156396865845,
-0.9428699612617493,
0.9539779424667358,
0.22892625629901886,
-0.8350138068199158,
0.4827875792980194,
-1.027375340461731,
-0.4610069692134857,
0.08934413641691208,
0.08076849579811096,
-0.34628406167030334,
-0.015700794756412506,
0.5152221322059631,
0.41408947110176086,
0.11024826020002365,
-0.2405431866645813,
-0.011749077588319778,
-0.35373032093048096,
-0.08315597474575043,
-0.2091209590435028,
0.14170986413955688,
0.28343066573143005,
0.02159016579389572,
0.07801774889230728,
-0.9834624528884888,
-0.5128058791160583,
-0.1389888972043991,
-0.6344596743583679,
-0.4397042393684387,
-0.09551655501127243,
0.39564958214759827,
0.06313920021057129,
0.511406421661377,
-0.8061583042144775,
0.3840789198875427,
-0.48434504866600037,
-0.033511266112327576,
0.03166002780199051,
0.12133785337209702,
0.6243426203727722,
-0.3293904662132263,
0.5381556749343872,
-0.14314240217208862,
0.06255006790161133,
-0.5905805826187134,
-0.34883224964141846,
-0.5237751603126526,
-0.7903381586074829,
0.4157675504684448,
0.8524076342582703,
-0.907442033290863,
0.40392041206359863,
-0.6082600951194763,
-0.28959283232688904,
-0.44756245613098145,
0.11606381833553314,
0.2017575055360794,
0.7055244445800781,
0.35895511507987976,
-0.13058921694755554,
-0.4347587823867798,
-0.4864256680011749,
-0.22440002858638763,
0.23973923921585083,
-0.2301831841468811,
0.1729268729686737,
0.1845906674861908,
-0.22012090682983398,
1.0122774839401245,
-0.512906551361084,
-0.43744024634361267,
-0.4391665756702423,
0.17534159123897552,
-0.007436791434884071,
0.32881414890289307,
0.27506548166275024,
-1.1755605936050415,
-0.2995729446411133,
0.305851012468338,
-1.0468934774398804,
0.073734812438488,
-0.3930226266384125,
0.25920552015304565,
0.22706465423107147,
0.7840409874916077,
-0.31719139218330383,
0.5348271727561951,
0.6899482011795044,
-0.5612162351608276,
0.3788849711418152,
-0.9498208165168762,
0.44641584157943726,
-1.3130741119384766,
-0.04171720892190933,
0.030519351363182068,
-0.40262800455093384,
-0.4802466928958893,
0.46155333518981934,
0.23600031435489655,
-0.4173433780670166,
-0.3245112895965576,
0.7581749558448792,
-0.843135416507721,
-0.34554779529571533,
-0.440380334854126,
0.5781570672988892,
0.4905492663383484,
0.12309838831424713,
0.30104267597198486,
0.7387681603431702,
-0.04266378656029701,
-0.49714452028274536,
0.24480003118515015,
0.4150437116622925,
-0.4194090962409973,
0.5697035789489746,
-0.41595742106437683,
0.024362964555621147,
-0.08543653786182404,
0.32070115208625793,
-0.9973793029785156,
-0.3941817581653595,
0.3013703227043152,
-0.3323948085308075,
0.1667773574590683,
0.232566237449646,
-1.000539779663086,
-0.13721691071987152,
-0.29332610964775085,
-0.12971891462802887,
0.09041761606931686,
-0.7233483791351318,
1.4317142963409424,
0.34182804822921753,
-0.29179155826568604,
-0.33851099014282227,
-0.6580732464790344,
0.478530615568161,
0.23734921216964722,
-0.49308955669403076,
0.3962310552597046,
-0.12014706432819366,
-0.5015606880187988,
0.06803923845291138,
0.18343612551689148,
0.10563546419143677,
-0.09362123161554337,
0.5569278001785278,
0.5926892757415771,
0.13806882500648499,
0.08366744965314865,
0.41632285714149475,
0.10464152693748474,
-0.573341965675354,
-0.28589096665382385,
0.3642045259475708,
0.17314116656780243,
-0.49911391735076904,
-0.13200035691261292,
0.60316401720047,
0.47771602869033813,
-0.4288557767868042,
0.7296647429466248,
0.8413500189781189,
-0.3534124195575714,
0.44003525376319885,
-0.8628153800964355,
0.029027501121163368,
-0.423816442489624,
0.28828927874565125,
-0.495893657207489,
-1.0487804412841797,
0.5580859780311584,
-0.010602514259517193,
0.581475019454956,
0.38455653190612793,
0.5416843295097351,
-0.27300646901130676,
0.8677676320075989,
0.6928091049194336,
0.301314115524292,
0.8188811540603638,
-0.1267675906419754,
0.14667122066020966,
-0.8523980379104614,
-0.44037193059921265,
-0.35580137372016907,
-0.15228495001792908,
-0.08781992644071579,
-0.4034566283226013,
0.43006816506385803,
0.0292409285902977,
0.40019333362579346,
0.09910393506288528,
-0.68468177318573,
0.5850198864936829,
0.494177907705307,
0.32479193806648254,
0.811154842376709,
0.20988258719444275,
-0.20581214129924774,
-0.11625497043132782,
-0.3269801735877991,
-0.4055432677268982,
0.8610831499099731,
0.032042209059000015,
0.42722776532173157,
0.0674019604921341,
0.5122234225273132,
0.6917704343795776,
0.5179110765457153,
-0.7820067405700684,
0.3502223789691925,
0.041740745306015015,
-0.5191004872322083,
-0.2965928316116333,
-0.02554437331855297,
-0.6407193541526794,
0.5029107332229614,
-0.659238874912262,
-0.4523843824863434,
0.4168035387992859,
0.17545649409294128,
-0.40233588218688965,
0.41341036558151245,
-0.7795389294624329,
0.3885999321937561,
-0.13716793060302734,
-0.38977691531181335,
-0.25786975026130676,
-0.4380910396575928,
0.2188103199005127,
-0.18572793900966644,
0.3727145791053772,
0.35922762751579285,
-0.462677925825119,
0.535955011844635,
-0.48971250653266907,
0.4592585265636444,
0.04103304073214531,
-0.4589654207229614,
0.17842426896095276,
-0.03025668114423752,
0.4991524815559387,
-0.11270944029092789,
-0.21643543243408203,
-0.06207209452986717,
-0.12660883367061615,
-0.3873963952064514,
-0.8238704204559326,
0.7769579291343689,
-0.5118916630744934,
-0.33617454767227173,
-0.5945953726768494,
-0.8011687397956848,
-0.2632994055747986,
0.47608575224876404,
0.1156768798828125,
0.7671982645988464,
-0.32721731066703796,
-0.02800687402486801,
0.6488555073738098,
-0.15328779816627502,
0.6830301880836487,
0.5163665413856506,
-0.5168538093566895,
-0.5222792029380798,
1.1527084112167358,
0.15461072325706482,
0.2455131709575653,
0.491711288690567,
0.08753315359354019,
-0.6858183145523071,
-0.7794570922851562,
-0.7083612084388733,
0.3311566114425659,
-0.6531879305839539,
0.5279518365859985,
-1.3361303806304932,
0.20909106731414795,
-0.8615176677703857,
-0.48259612917900085,
0.016545481979846954,
-0.5122576951980591,
-0.501693606376648,
-0.2468877136707306,
0.104097880423069,
0.6817846894264221,
-0.1664554923772812,
0.3633156716823578,
-1.218729019165039,
0.9456470608711243,
0.4539909064769745,
0.35147082805633545,
-0.20823660492897034,
-0.6749104261398315,
-0.6002041697502136,
-0.03914502635598183,
-0.09002689272165298,
-0.33592987060546875,
0.6255024671554565,
0.12502850592136383,
0.38125699758529663,
0.514934241771698,
0.07817839831113815,
0.43694883584976196,
-0.33727526664733887,
0.9015607237815857,
0.20061206817626953,
-0.45779624581336975,
0.30807605385780334,
-0.5708960294723511,
0.3441678583621979,
0.7133038640022278,
0.18577693402767181,
-0.5005740523338318,
-0.2543541193008423,
-0.6090617179870605,
-0.76474928855896,
0.3766344487667084,
-0.08145802468061447,
0.19809582829475403,
0.25784623622894287,
0.3385125398635864,
-0.012791624292731285,
0.14698006212711334,
-0.1783343255519867,
0.19086052477359772,
-0.4424320161342621,
-0.15461795032024384,
-0.2126510888338089,
-0.3933752775192261,
-0.06526617705821991,
-0.14490345120429993,
0.23614159226417542,
0.034400299191474915,
0.022213157266378403,
0.5365782380104065,
-0.35733917355537415,
0.19920626282691956,
0.0670635998249054,
1.1149259805679321,
0.6638795137405396,
-0.7203349471092224,
-0.057420264929533005,
-0.16126379370689392,
-1.2274948358535767,
-0.13889817893505096,
0.4134397506713867,
0.023623384535312653,
0.16985946893692017,
0.4943408966064453,
0.8025550842285156,
0.10145729780197144,
-0.9301396608352661,
0.19564978778362274,
-0.2866801619529724,
-0.4617671072483063,
-0.2143050879240036,
-0.14927728474140167,
-0.16538101434707642,
0.11866223812103271,
0.5167897343635559,
-0.08674502372741699,
0.3385966718196869,
-0.6568787693977356,
-0.04564063251018524,
0.12606997787952423,
-0.49548113346099854,
0.05296557396650314,
0.6016513109207153,
0.3994162082672119,
-0.5251818299293518,
0.4052874743938446,
-0.1303527057170868,
-0.16631653904914856,
0.17616435885429382,
0.4734848737716675,
0.6690794825553894,
0.05383927375078201,
0.2671867609024048,
-0.002212672494351864,
0.272020548582077,
-0.2494618147611618,
0.17921724915504456,
-0.3738468885421753,
-0.7912346720695496,
-0.4096514582633972,
-0.627167820930481,
-0.9760888814926147,
-0.3533923327922821,
-0.4784840941429138,
0.0385441891849041,
-0.5621218085289001,
0.13503077626228333,
-0.07424742728471756,
0.12068716436624527,
-0.16232998669147491,
0.5118798613548279,
0.12967531383037567,
0.8019768595695496,
-0.5020862221717834,
0.5730178356170654,
0.830368161201477,
-0.5099374651908875,
-0.35325154662132263,
0.2344380021095276,
-0.09638497978448868,
-0.5241971015930176,
0.1361372023820877,
-0.14312906563282013,
-0.23933418095111847,
0.23166154325008392,
-0.21543118357658386,
-0.4806128442287445,
0.9182167053222656,
0.06643059849739075,
-0.4797276258468628,
-0.2972337603569031,
0.0445440337061882,
0.6198099255561829,
-0.2622961401939392,
0.39165523648262024,
0.3331327736377716,
0.6437897682189941,
0.31062111258506775,
-0.5179793834686279,
-0.2506970763206482,
-0.24210532009601593,
-0.3087273836135864,
0.03459874168038368,
-0.18730677664279938,
0.44820359349250793,
-0.25696825981140137,
-0.0007360125309787691,
-0.14952971041202545,
0.8813850283622742,
0.47662225365638733,
0.4867819845676422,
0.5595215559005737,
0.7549865245819092,
0.7020106315612793,
0.2463933229446411,
1.7070592641830444,
-0.23033969104290009,
-0.07347708940505981,
1.284246563911438,
-0.37425774335861206,
0.7725526690483093,
0.37674039602279663,
0.20543919503688812,
0.4261530041694641,
0.6292006969451904,
0.18646562099456787,
0.4329870939254761,
-0.40605565905570984,
-0.5003844499588013,
-0.2292253077030182,
-0.4109629988670349,
-0.42687004804611206,
0.0948280394077301,
0.48691514134407043,
-0.2122844010591507,
-0.2524496614933014,
0.5776948928833008,
-0.14472012221813202,
0.31836599111557007,
-0.2438298910856247,
0.9623414278030396,
-0.2592407464981079,
-0.5033189654350281,
0.3513087034225464,
-0.04044689983129501,
0.6979493498802185,
-0.44174644351005554,
-0.3200545310974121,
-0.24332688748836517,
0.027017315849661827,
-0.32150566577911377,
-0.87113356590271,
0.2415422797203064,
0.039637427777051926,
-0.4326438009738922,
-0.380495548248291,
0.8436869978904724,
-0.3314990997314453,
-0.8031617999076843,
0.06136626750230789,
0.3997706174850464,
0.019849661737680435,
-0.46605047583580017,
-0.4838767349720001,
0.003755305428057909,
-0.14560958743095398,
-0.28440970182418823,
0.5489231944084167,
0.24471016228199005,
0.06472908705472946,
0.5324534177780151,
0.9557435512542725,
0.39812520146369934,
-0.03730013594031334,
0.2522602379322052,
0.9366680383682251,
-0.35858654975891113,
-0.8604680299758911,
-0.5996171832084656,
0.5507076978683472,
-0.3563970625400543,
-0.26693451404571533,
0.94873046875,
0.9977176189422607,
0.39772170782089233,
-0.03061177022755146,
0.9694001078605652,
0.04104428365826607,
0.9203314185142517,
-0.4874778687953949,
0.9007789492607117,
-0.9038312435150146,
-0.007073812186717987,
-0.5496997237205505,
-1.1575767993927002,
-0.6146692633628845,
0.2617678940296173,
-0.35446804761886597,
-0.48331087827682495,
0.5593819618225098,
0.6388491988182068,
-0.3070151209831238,
0.0024893858935683966,
0.4888346493244171,
-0.4370870292186737,
0.44359996914863586,
-0.4385678470134735,
0.4477398693561554,
-0.23278462886810303,
0.5367632508277893,
0.013190505094826221,
-0.3012046813964844,
-0.5166838765144348,
-0.7677481770515442,
-0.7786621451377869,
-0.664034366607666,
-0.17580346763134003,
-0.4694060683250427,
0.07812143862247467,
0.7107512950897217,
0.40767133235931396,
-0.5253477692604065,
0.16135989129543304,
0.23277604579925537,
0.0809098407626152,
-0.06103111803531647,
-0.17147241532802582,
0.4061022400856018,
0.11556550860404968,
-0.8944368362426758,
0.4407026469707489,
0.49537593126296997,
0.3365267217159271,
-0.1695908159017563,
0.04798942804336548,
-0.4862973093986511,
0.009172414429485798,
0.7644042372703552,
0.5385228395462036,
-0.1763084977865219,
0.014337952248752117,
0.09307113289833069,
-0.20832979679107666,
0.17679303884506226,
0.8832773566246033,
-0.6062602400779724,
0.8631370663642883,
0.6536896228790283,
0.8210055232048035,
0.6695312857627869,
0.4865029454231262,
0.3898378610610962,
-0.47435474395751953,
0.5196941494941711,
0.07565011829137802,
0.056611210107803345,
0.4559212625026703,
-0.5287764072418213,
0.43771931529045105,
0.3125194311141968,
-0.2640469968318939,
-0.7960150837898254,
-0.19685609638690948,
-1.2481639385223389,
-0.21280360221862793,
0.9483658671379089,
-0.010839213617146015,
-0.21911367774009705,
-0.5551198124885559,
-0.6140797138214111,
0.2688433527946472,
-0.46117955446243286,
0.7623956203460693,
0.7108537554740906,
-0.08651470392942429,
-0.532588541507721,
-0.6204633712768555,
0.11963337659835815,
-0.07938709110021591,
-1.0835720300674438,
-0.06413928419351578,
0.7680908441543579,
-0.19791847467422485,
0.5725476741790771,
0.6281948685646057,
-0.1153203696012497,
0.1731749176979065,
0.08719177544116974,
0.40160128474235535,
-0.6893236637115479,
-0.25770455598831177,
-0.27369755506515503,
0.32245516777038574,
-0.3281230926513672,
-0.28184792399406433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18613v1
|
GLOCON Database: Design Decisions and User Manual (v1.0)
| 2024-05-28T21:42:35 | 2024-05-28T21:42:35 |
Ali Hürriyetoğlu, Osman Mutlu, Fırat Duruşan, Erdem Yörük
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.DB, cs.LG
|
GLOCON is a database of contentious events automatically extracted from
national news sources from various countries in multiple languages. National
news sources are utilized, and complete news archives are processed to create
an event list for each source. Automation is achieved using a gold standard
corpus sampled randomly from complete news archives (Y\"or\"uk et al. 2022) and
all annotated by at least two domain experts based on the event definition
provided in Duru\c{s}an et al. (2022).
|
[
-0.6769073605537415,
-0.7246538400650024,
0.6427943706512451,
-0.2107066810131073,
-0.3902627229690552,
0.11151242256164551,
0.033837903290987015,
-0.8736077547073364,
0.4909376800060272,
0.4762256145477295,
-0.39225950837135315,
-0.6843194365501404,
-0.33753904700279236,
0.07106932997703552,
-0.812811017036438,
1.1827973127365112,
-0.2459694892168045,
-0.29739275574684143,
0.007001800928264856,
-0.1349361389875412,
0.21605609357357025,
-0.8124415278434753,
-0.6033326387405396,
0.1435137391090393,
0.48648232221603394,
0.6055741310119629,
0.9614720344543457,
0.491491436958313,
0.5052242279052734,
0.2719446122646332,
-0.255870521068573,
-0.04570295289158821,
-0.2524983882904053,
-0.38308843970298767,
-0.6459537148475647,
-0.12223489582538605,
-0.16904233396053314,
0.0136820487678051,
0.5113034844398499,
0.6074767708778381,
-0.31169912219047546,
0.07023687660694122,
-0.240411639213562,
0.6557077169418335,
-1.0107064247131348,
-0.26377925276756287,
-0.8381813168525696,
0.0760715901851654,
-0.2527863383293152,
0.02191256172955036,
-0.14890441298484802,
-0.7825765013694763,
-0.12554703652858734,
-0.40444624423980713,
0.6091310977935791,
0.049536388367414474,
1.185126781463623,
-0.08257843554019928,
-0.9191379547119141,
-0.856168806552887,
-0.6561726331710815,
0.5108559727668762,
-0.23891349136829376,
0.4170113801956177,
0.3553026616573334,
0.29340675473213196,
-0.5029204487800598,
-0.59886634349823,
-0.3806782364845276,
-0.28708261251449585,
-0.42909619212150574,
0.09935952723026276,
-0.09039374440908432,
-0.11813615262508392,
0.10942552983760834,
0.48783454298973083,
-0.6893174052238464,
0.12828291952610016,
-0.8070565462112427,
-0.3991301953792572,
0.9142832159996033,
0.2661229968070984,
0.3091752529144287,
-0.46213003993034363,
-0.3612864315509796,
0.588024377822876,
-0.6804412007331848,
-0.3227579891681671,
0.8721464276313782,
-0.0864698737859726,
-0.22949117422103882,
0.5085230469703674,
-0.6410781145095825,
0.9226663708686829,
-0.11312466859817505,
-0.0628611370921135,
-0.023928610607981682,
-0.8845750093460083,
0.027052713558077812,
0.2207012176513672,
1.2572016716003418,
0.7571269273757935,
0.24862436950206757,
-0.3656269311904907,
0.2954097390174866,
-0.071332648396492,
0.15684197843074799,
-0.6519245505332947,
-0.21551834046840668,
0.471309095621109,
-0.33093932271003723,
-0.20140646398067474,
0.30533367395401,
-1.1704188585281372,
-0.31232792139053345,
-0.3888798654079437,
-0.11919259279966354,
-0.14115208387374878,
-0.20385244488716125,
-0.035421956330537796,
-0.31748902797698975,
-0.11681342869997025,
0.24105681478977203,
-0.9760578870773315,
0.33732178807258606,
0.17903199791908264,
0.9501295685768127,
-0.3379589319229126,
0.027398303151130676,
-0.06875581294298172,
0.32453790307044983,
-0.41502606868743896,
1.0099656581878662,
-0.18725192546844482,
-0.7411969304084778,
0.06670745462179184,
0.3027927875518799,
0.3162095248699188,
-0.5902048945426941,
0.5187445282936096,
-0.4904841184616089,
0.4762640595436096,
0.024956146255135536,
-0.42543768882751465,
0.10623068362474442,
0.018518036231398582,
-0.91571044921875,
0.5255069732666016,
-0.003322009230032563,
-0.8616348505020142,
0.6273139119148254,
-0.27329960465431213,
-0.30707186460494995,
-0.1363154798746109,
-0.3122466206550598,
0.012017641216516495,
0.016971634700894356,
-0.049271199852228165,
-0.12645551562309265,
-0.3664401173591614,
0.45759525895118713,
0.036397796124219894,
-0.2852936089038849,
-0.2272731065750122,
0.29218533635139465,
0.9997312426567078,
0.445690393447876,
-0.019827211275696754,
0.10474502295255661,
-0.9908348917961121,
-0.22328628599643707,
-0.09460681676864624,
-0.4798072278499603,
-0.468869149684906,
0.22503559291362762,
-0.1144300028681755,
0.4301441013813019,
0.3839826285839081,
-0.4242597222328186,
0.6350604295730591,
-0.2992308437824249,
0.25292372703552246,
0.23508292436599731,
0.48644110560417175,
0.6131038665771484,
0.015368365682661533,
0.20117180049419403,
-0.027354678139090538,
0.49801650643348694,
0.4578229486942291,
-0.6587370038032532,
-0.4388309121131897,
0.2936469614505768,
0.38190969824790955,
0.9884058833122253,
-0.484837144613266,
0.556614100933075,
0.2621084153652191,
-0.5532720685005188,
-0.15080663561820984,
0.3941963016986847,
-0.01613517291843891,
0.5046123266220093,
0.35620859265327454,
-0.25334373116493225,
-1.1097185611724854,
-1.0742400884628296,
0.030192308127880096,
-0.32537105679512024,
0.010674608871340752,
0.07629377394914627,
0.7546610832214355,
-0.3159794509410858,
0.9227233529090881,
-0.38934460282325745,
-0.14425575733184814,
0.0327896885573864,
0.2763049900531769,
0.45509544014930725,
0.12389416247606277,
0.49865370988845825,
-0.766485869884491,
-0.5122086405754089,
0.4685809910297394,
-0.8496527075767517,
-0.061862848699092865,
-0.3071422874927521,
-0.5792626738548279,
0.8535899519920349,
0.6873023509979248,
-0.39039698243141174,
0.8158799409866333,
0.7514350414276123,
-0.6153501272201538,
0.7907403111457825,
-0.012601856142282486,
0.4129297137260437,
-1.1776989698410034,
0.12489873915910721,
-0.25493890047073364,
0.08351509273052216,
-0.3871177136898041,
-0.2525404989719391,
0.19418855011463165,
0.365959107875824,
-0.7496970295906067,
0.6128456592559814,
-0.40913480520248413,
-0.046435315161943436,
-0.3158271014690399,
0.406168669462204,
0.15391694009304047,
0.04954534024000168,
0.18148793280124664,
0.7179281711578369,
0.34660521149635315,
-0.8261585831642151,
0.7021996974945068,
0.2309364676475525,
-0.6014732718467712,
0.4534915089607239,
-0.3786790370941162,
0.0680866539478302,
0.016307104378938675,
-0.06493254750967026,
-0.5907993912696838,
-0.41814813017845154,
0.41855937242507935,
-0.06788665801286697,
-0.2349882870912552,
-0.23600950837135315,
-0.2369106262922287,
-0.7058111429214478,
-0.03547993674874306,
0.08683181554079056,
0.07002054154872894,
-0.2719059884548187,
0.24490496516227722,
0.8384881615638733,
0.003946668468415737,
-0.6369088292121887,
-0.6207894682884216,
0.34457969665527344,
-0.13162994384765625,
-0.22096940875053406,
0.17472189664840698,
-0.15926353633403778,
-0.7448278665542603,
0.4295579493045807,
-0.01944771781563759,
-0.4627840518951416,
-0.04754398763179779,
0.3138278126716614,
0.3619735836982727,
0.18780554831027985,
-0.013468042947351933,
-0.15580254793167114,
0.13018196821212769,
-0.06771279126405716,
-0.04361017048358917,
0.48609447479248047,
0.12159543484449387,
-0.13112223148345947,
-0.7360155582427979,
0.9169701337814331,
0.4878738224506378,
0.3832216262817383,
0.7409904599189758,
0.33412879705429077,
-0.46247318387031555,
0.4117114543914795,
-0.5863878726959229,
0.2664535343647003,
-0.4065812826156616,
0.10972616821527481,
-0.13951842486858368,
-0.8668729662895203,
0.9474868774414062,
0.24798373878002167,
-0.026009321212768555,
0.8349872827529907,
0.8423134684562683,
0.3127124607563019,
0.8864037990570068,
0.39733538031578064,
-0.5707628130912781,
0.3216395676136017,
-0.0024394893553107977,
-0.1521601527929306,
-0.558266282081604,
-0.6855782866477966,
-0.8635910153388977,
-0.222329780459404,
-0.5928835868835449,
-0.06260021030902863,
-0.12821415066719055,
0.20901750028133392,
-0.2889699935913086,
0.630545437335968,
-0.5061905980110168,
0.5777385830879211,
0.7736719846725464,
-0.07813287526369095,
0.8651845455169678,
-0.18399940431118011,
0.08108843117952347,
0.1934819370508194,
-0.28970110416412354,
-0.41165000200271606,
0.8538249135017395,
-0.2841845452785492,
0.8322698473930359,
0.3905583918094635,
0.5973902344703674,
0.35171446204185486,
0.07774760574102402,
-0.7766571044921875,
0.37770453095436096,
0.22475381195545197,
-1.4252594709396362,
-0.061955586075782776,
-0.5965717434883118,
-1.1244302988052368,
-0.3345984220504761,
-0.15223056077957153,
-1.1535156965255737,
0.7228440046310425,
0.017887799069285393,
-0.39594969153404236,
0.5240123867988586,
-0.8772764801979065,
0.7582730054855347,
-0.5580133199691772,
-0.20246462523937225,
-0.3306884765625,
-0.30802375078201294,
0.5345231890678406,
-0.02702842652797699,
0.49476972222328186,
-0.2742556929588318,
-0.43469107151031494,
0.6509984731674194,
-0.1412239968776703,
0.41751036047935486,
0.016965750604867935,
0.09057263284921646,
0.7035607099533081,
0.22853124141693115,
0.323144793510437,
0.5682186484336853,
-0.20663323998451233,
0.32991963624954224,
-0.04884878918528557,
-0.20865465700626373,
-0.09256049245595932,
0.8140131235122681,
-0.7928670048713684,
-0.5047949552536011,
-0.3382565975189209,
-0.3240912854671478,
0.03787728771567345,
0.26192575693130493,
0.5187893509864807,
0.286632239818573,
-0.6046845316886902,
-0.025248801335692406,
0.11126229166984558,
-0.11744055896997452,
0.38662904500961304,
0.5181501507759094,
-0.3838837146759033,
-0.743051290512085,
0.6152715086936951,
0.39511215686798096,
0.1654713749885559,
0.19351911544799805,
-0.02065085805952549,
-0.31642213463783264,
-0.7094165682792664,
-0.39532068371772766,
0.04687028005719185,
-0.6236147880554199,
-0.21124809980392456,
-0.6100319027900696,
-0.44274118542671204,
-0.3151526153087616,
-0.30137285590171814,
-0.014358404092490673,
-0.48234495520591736,
-0.25329309701919556,
-0.262620210647583,
0.29271867871284485,
0.9865279793739319,
-0.34740403294563293,
0.3115513026714325,
-0.5979627966880798,
0.6945998668670654,
0.5228705406188965,
0.5402076244354248,
-0.6760732531547546,
-0.23301313817501068,
-0.4787473976612091,
-0.3115617334842682,
-0.2913043797016144,
-1.1136459112167358,
0.35554900765419006,
0.3285874128341675,
0.8491848111152649,
0.5154021382331848,
-0.03832117095589638,
0.5026305913925171,
-0.42710402607917786,
0.9262694716453552,
0.27326643466949463,
-0.8461704850196838,
1.2882192134857178,
-0.216380774974823,
0.18537376821041107,
0.8690524101257324,
0.9927994012832642,
-0.4500808119773865,
-0.3521847128868103,
-1.0973578691482544,
-1.0656673908233643,
0.7407748103141785,
-0.22245176136493683,
-0.33468592166900635,
-0.24218879640102386,
0.46822088956832886,
0.24290180206298828,
0.32019558548927307,
-0.32854899764060974,
-0.25992506742477417,
-0.04906590282917023,
0.17318330705165863,
0.18572430312633514,
-0.5837563872337341,
-0.515595018863678,
-0.4194742739200592,
0.5533557534217834,
-0.0847550705075264,
-0.023931318894028664,
0.33830705285072327,
-0.10454882681369781,
-0.05944863334298134,
0.3001726567745209,
0.6105595827102661,
0.9776325821876526,
-0.5107438564300537,
0.15506726503372192,
0.4902971684932709,
-0.6592789888381958,
0.04942807927727699,
-0.03666670247912407,
-0.20326577126979828,
0.3853398561477661,
0.044242992997169495,
0.6399861574172974,
0.07445196807384491,
-0.5600560307502747,
0.03138628974556923,
-0.33382129669189453,
-0.5080581307411194,
-0.578231155872345,
0.1470952033996582,
-0.013629788532853127,
0.06334061920642853,
0.6739727258682251,
-0.257479727268219,
0.5970872640609741,
-0.8307592272758484,
0.5742543935775757,
0.348958820104599,
-0.1459985226392746,
-0.09084191173315048,
0.7349756956100464,
0.13049571216106415,
-0.14398470520973206,
0.5691013336181641,
-0.36563313007354736,
-0.06789281219244003,
0.7830917239189148,
0.3043728768825531,
0.3606622517108917,
-0.11906545609235764,
0.2843635082244873,
0.9053924679756165,
0.2538887560367584,
0.04251928627490997,
0.34049925208091736,
0.4089154303073883,
-0.775067925453186,
-0.5668627023696899,
-0.5828724503517151,
-1.1179282665252686,
0.13294818997383118,
-0.6714304089546204,
0.5678500533103943,
-0.5853667855262756,
-0.4635125696659088,
-0.3002665936946869,
0.33609190583229065,
-0.476768434047699,
0.14992934465408325,
0.6258909106254578,
1.2301467657089233,
-0.6850655674934387,
0.76328045129776,
0.5307793617248535,
-0.20670171082019806,
-0.09774643182754517,
-0.325895756483078,
0.3278319835662842,
-0.43345072865486145,
0.10417982935905457,
-0.24803654849529266,
0.23398934304714203,
-0.24579107761383057,
-0.45675933361053467,
-1.099066138267517,
0.7933911681175232,
0.5867467522621155,
-0.8467274904251099,
-0.08097714930772781,
0.026926154270768166,
0.21738992631435394,
-0.15499362349510193,
0.20379817485809326,
0.9645338654518127,
0.6233029365539551,
0.09773553162813187,
-1.091661810874939,
-0.21106360852718353,
-0.17405356466770172,
-0.4667131304740906,
0.39684799313545227,
-0.7094435095787048,
0.6378872990608215,
-0.15303608775138855,
-0.3374123275279999,
-0.15118449926376343,
0.6474573016166687,
0.03909192979335785,
0.1626397669315338,
0.4402081072330475,
0.5474029779434204,
1.1394374370574951,
-0.43509581685066223,
1.0388067960739136,
-0.34940600395202637,
0.41173025965690613,
1.0101945400238037,
-0.09080836176872253,
0.4185978174209595,
0.46754005551338196,
-0.1690404713153839,
0.8864044547080994,
0.6876031160354614,
0.02912461757659912,
0.6467987895011902,
-0.1725655198097229,
-0.24398766458034515,
-0.1537274569272995,
-0.4494544267654419,
-0.6397152543067932,
0.47003671526908875,
0.6546750068664551,
-0.21650762856006622,
-0.6123824119567871,
-0.3868497908115387,
0.20921799540519714,
-0.034563448280096054,
-0.6259810924530029,
0.7452983856201172,
-0.10342267155647278,
-0.44086650013923645,
0.2815866470336914,
-0.44845032691955566,
0.3542386591434479,
-0.649777352809906,
0.3230263292789459,
-0.12309546768665314,
0.0989985466003418,
-0.5213406085968018,
-1.1624819040298462,
0.9050529599189758,
-0.1032940223813057,
-0.2717304229736328,
0.4156762957572937,
0.5770356059074402,
-0.2711681127548218,
-0.5466287136077881,
0.5208593010902405,
0.5312023758888245,
0.22976356744766235,
-0.06933047622442245,
-0.5256667733192444,
0.3711472749710083,
-0.09444768726825714,
-0.40982475876808167,
0.32000070810317993,
0.48999521136283875,
-0.3673468828201294,
0.1974710375070572,
0.4372693598270416,
0.36883851885795593,
-0.08440665900707245,
0.23941388726234436,
0.8597493171691895,
-1.098853588104248,
-0.3695318102836609,
-0.7737353444099426,
0.4859153926372528,
-0.6921457648277283,
-0.5477343201637268,
0.4158819913864136,
0.8158206939697266,
0.8612650036811829,
0.12313997000455856,
0.984674334526062,
-0.6818119883537292,
0.32637590169906616,
-0.4688550531864166,
0.4718972444534302,
-0.37821003794670105,
-0.6188482046127319,
0.17532244324684143,
-0.4205436110496521,
-0.5141189694404602,
0.47079673409461975,
-0.0986822172999382,
-0.4147774577140808,
0.7895187139511108,
0.682644784450531,
0.45440182089805603,
0.021392347291111946,
0.13354423642158508,
-0.13378843665122986,
0.14200490713119507,
0.8323627710342407,
0.8002790212631226,
-0.21263860166072845,
0.8992887139320374,
-0.5933170318603516,
-0.14070960879325867,
-0.49065348505973816,
-1.0018163919448853,
-0.8373332023620605,
-0.5788550972938538,
-0.3118517994880676,
-0.24510087072849274,
0.18957465887069702,
0.8511367440223694,
0.3998364508152008,
-1.5465325117111206,
-0.32933691143989563,
-0.08159328997135162,
0.5771430134773254,
0.2508534789085388,
-0.20723506808280945,
0.43973177671432495,
-0.29112136363983154,
-0.9389956593513489,
0.3705297112464905,
-0.055273257195949554,
-0.10874725133180618,
-0.05814607813954353,
0.16380903124809265,
-0.46749699115753174,
-0.3329443037509918,
0.3277256488800049,
0.6439117789268494,
-0.27205127477645874,
-0.7304719090461731,
-0.368838369846344,
-0.4743627905845642,
-0.12874358892440796,
0.5174530744552612,
-0.9010226130485535,
0.1534477025270462,
0.650982141494751,
-0.05663037300109863,
0.13444466888904572,
0.06160996854305267,
0.4154472351074219,
-0.5607978105545044,
0.8299040794372559,
-0.005652456544339657,
0.5754141807556152,
-0.02103765495121479,
-0.7380656003952026,
0.8541294932365417,
0.5899474024772644,
-0.8826425671577454,
-0.45918023586273193,
0.15261846780776978,
-1.0387113094329834,
-0.24601440131664276,
1.3583520650863647,
0.7365354299545288,
-0.3909253180027008,
-0.8330783247947693,
-0.4689907133579254,
0.180074080824852,
-0.376303106546402,
0.9078769683837891,
0.8846309781074524,
-0.40632811188697815,
0.09447762370109558,
-0.931596577167511,
0.5355703830718994,
-0.5990117788314819,
-0.5534961223602295,
-0.247430682182312,
0.6958766579627991,
-0.00919345859438181,
0.5561059713363647,
0.7480977177619934,
-0.23822420835494995,
0.3915409743785858,
-0.06507941335439682,
0.6015065908432007,
0.23620980978012085,
-0.7346833348274231,
0.20803317427635193,
0.5891152620315552,
-0.2685428857803345,
0.021898377686738968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00053v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00053v2
|
Dual Process Learning: Controlling Use of In-Context vs. In-Weights Strategies with Weight Forgetting
| 2024-05-28T21:38:20 | 2024-07-01T18:23:43 |
Suraj Anand, Michael A. Lepori, Jack Merullo, Ellie Pavlick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language models have the ability to perform in-context learning (ICL),
allowing them to flexibly adapt their behavior based on context. This contrasts
with in-weights learning, where information is statically encoded in model
parameters from iterated observations of the data. Despite this apparent
ability to learn in-context, language models are known to struggle when faced
with unseen or rarely seen tokens. Hence, we study $\textbf{structural
in-context learning}$, which we define as the ability of a model to execute
in-context learning on arbitrary tokens -- so called because the model must
generalize on the basis of e.g. sentence structure or task structure, rather
than semantic content encoded in token embeddings. An ideal model would be able
to do both: flexibly deploy in-weights operations (in order to robustly
accommodate ambiguous or unknown contexts using encoded semantic information)
and structural in-context operations (in order to accommodate novel tokens). We
study structural in-context algorithms in a simple part-of-speech setting using
both practical and toy models. We find that active forgetting, a technique that
was recently introduced to help models generalize to new languages, forces
models to adopt structural in-context learning solutions. Finally, we introduce
$\textbf{temporary forgetting}$, a straightforward extension of active
forgetting that enables one to control how much a model relies on in-weights
vs. in-context solutions. Importantly, temporary forgetting allows us to induce
a $\textit{dual process strategy}$ where in-context and in-weights solutions
coexist within a single model.
|
[
0.1798671931028366,
-0.8489542007446289,
0.3938491642475128,
0.1325596272945404,
-0.29151231050491333,
0.34549829363822937,
-0.2568228244781494,
-0.061332836747169495,
-0.1424950659275055,
0.14626403152942657,
-0.3324200212955475,
-0.148911252617836,
-0.3686031103134155,
-0.27642500400543213,
-0.35346245765686035,
1.1611839532852173,
-0.605616569519043,
0.38099631667137146,
-0.20436717569828033,
-0.4432230293750763,
-0.5844326615333557,
-0.8063991665840149,
-0.9249218702316284,
-0.45409518480300903,
0.5244220495223999,
0.5335795283317566,
0.29857537150382996,
0.31836193799972534,
0.11710789054632187,
0.20489075779914856,
-0.19845746457576752,
-0.18820905685424805,
-0.5470974445343018,
0.23974329233169556,
-0.3722269833087921,
-0.7016997337341309,
-0.08099418878555298,
0.038809917867183685,
1.1097805500030518,
0.9793969392776489,
-0.3125135004520416,
0.2919418513774872,
0.14830592274665833,
0.5106924772262573,
-0.5184168219566345,
0.16120190918445587,
-0.909600019454956,
0.1776835024356842,
-0.16294093430042267,
-0.12471189349889755,
-0.39586830139160156,
0.31732288002967834,
0.024698499590158463,
-0.06840377300977707,
0.17691445350646973,
-0.048545416444540024,
0.8627118468284607,
0.24439916014671326,
-0.5945310592651367,
-0.6770673990249634,
-0.8266651630401611,
0.7206741571426392,
-0.540915846824646,
0.24332983791828156,
0.4558659791946411,
0.08756662160158157,
-0.20407302677631378,
-0.8048031330108643,
-0.3435037434101105,
-0.33282849192619324,
0.047878652811050415,
0.03236616402864456,
0.05860728397965431,
0.003446870017796755,
0.44508281350135803,
0.21626883745193481,
-0.25311335921287537,
0.11800437420606613,
-0.48058754205703735,
-0.12604399025440216,
0.12206024676561356,
-0.060963232070207596,
0.4597083628177643,
0.16272935271263123,
-0.5263186693191528,
0.06318771839141846,
-0.7680495977401733,
0.27611643075942993,
0.3294833302497864,
0.61346435546875,
-0.19996030628681183,
0.5632135272026062,
0.2194148302078247,
0.11271602660417557,
0.1559745818376541,
0.10229084640741348,
0.07066361606121063,
-0.2517167329788208,
-0.3276265561580658,
0.10119863599538803,
0.3798701763153076,
-0.391361266374588,
-0.03611881285905838,
-0.4475092589855194,
-0.5319844484329224,
0.2570918798446655,
0.3962774872779846,
-0.5720648765563965,
-0.04122494161128998,
0.11328456550836563,
-0.5052240490913391,
0.24109148979187012,
-0.06375283747911453,
-0.1996406763792038,
0.16720528900623322,
-0.2593322694301605,
0.9045582413673401,
-0.4588429629802704,
-0.3875909149646759,
-0.04742861166596413,
-0.37510567903518677,
0.006309592630714178,
-0.021533194929361343,
-0.9016001224517822,
0.7863985300064087,
0.4129820466041565,
1.1134872436523438,
-0.07734309136867523,
-0.2413206845521927,
-0.8166792988777161,
0.3244643807411194,
-0.3647679090499878,
0.4183066785335541,
-0.6307380199432373,
-0.32163748145103455,
-0.0725797489285469,
0.014314640313386917,
-0.3480550944805145,
-0.5222216248512268,
0.3891929090023041,
-0.6617939472198486,
0.2639226019382477,
-0.40345579385757446,
-0.6374955177307129,
-0.3824461102485657,
-0.023847615346312523,
-0.5808635354042053,
1.2699655294418335,
0.11044686287641525,
-0.6306957602500916,
0.7085673809051514,
-0.47668707370758057,
-0.6209936141967773,
-0.17840473353862762,
-0.027488959953188896,
-0.5967261791229248,
0.5585301518440247,
-0.37194639444351196,
0.4916161000728607,
0.1445685774087906,
0.255968302488327,
-0.5025079846382141,
-0.5405920743942261,
0.16187649965286255,
-0.22505858540534973,
0.5174067616462708,
0.0713866651058197,
-0.4057990610599518,
0.30090951919555664,
-0.5606563091278076,
-0.4059310257434845,
0.2999734878540039,
-0.6342901587486267,
-0.6311461925506592,
0.2638338506221771,
-0.21245163679122925,
0.4490583539009094,
0.006884620524942875,
-0.4069769084453583,
0.06952036917209625,
-0.5749993324279785,
0.7674401998519897,
0.8076695203781128,
0.022304842248558998,
0.7784217000007629,
-0.25870007276535034,
0.3606474995613098,
0.1918349415063858,
-0.3008181154727936,
-0.32553595304489136,
0.01015462540090084,
-0.8418320417404175,
-0.08985345810651779,
0.1342790424823761,
0.378186970949173,
-0.7754721641540527,
-0.2129492461681366,
0.059163399040699005,
-0.049901753664016724,
-0.05863716080784798,
0.22424867749214172,
0.6858549118041992,
0.7046115398406982,
0.22536839544773102,
-0.5603770613670349,
-0.48051121830940247,
-0.6770956516265869,
-0.1789463311433792,
-0.3726232349872589,
0.11922784894704819,
0.058787330985069275,
0.7714223265647888,
0.24158792197704315,
0.5973145961761475,
0.04947946220636368,
-0.07877956330776215,
-0.3269537687301636,
0.23611725866794586,
0.09600185602903366,
0.345918744802475,
0.5201581716537476,
-1.1003336906433105,
-0.5537272095680237,
-0.3407735526561737,
-0.7367037534713745,
0.2585585415363312,
-0.2854830324649811,
0.08763870596885681,
0.46337786316871643,
0.5843287706375122,
-0.33620116114616394,
0.40694931149482727,
0.40429767966270447,
-0.4582338035106659,
0.4462345838546753,
-0.4724019467830658,
-0.3810368776321411,
-0.9760556221008301,
-0.03413676843047142,
-0.04861481487751007,
-0.0653420016169548,
-0.735967755317688,
0.11470191180706024,
0.45991629362106323,
-0.03168961778283119,
-0.4829653799533844,
0.7958149909973145,
-0.7928009629249573,
-0.0716664120554924,
-0.29422274231910706,
-0.2960662245750427,
-0.2385706752538681,
0.9542443156242371,
0.09520510584115982,
0.7167885899543762,
0.7323923110961914,
-0.8533027768135071,
-0.15091121196746826,
-0.28994134068489075,
-0.09849964082241058,
0.3930305540561676,
-0.4796825349330902,
0.26566845178604126,
-0.452468603849411,
0.26996734738349915,
-1.2554590702056885,
-0.03457259014248848,
0.46035343408584595,
-0.09411989897489548,
0.9244100451469421,
-0.2923241853713989,
-0.5798133015632629,
-0.3838713467121124,
-0.17828406393527985,
0.35587936639785767,
0.22007887065410614,
-0.3928249776363373,
0.5431265830993652,
0.47132107615470886,
-0.09502557665109634,
-0.46624550223350525,
-0.8452395796775818,
0.09197618812322617,
-0.5217538475990295,
-0.12630654871463776,
0.49300092458724976,
-0.21980026364326477,
-0.13200871646404266,
0.30743643641471863,
-0.5773844718933105,
-0.12898822128772736,
0.2536795437335968,
0.2891114354133606,
0.016864165663719177,
-0.0444081574678421,
0.6512599587440491,
0.08307753503322601,
-0.048824843019247055,
-0.1662362813949585,
-0.49875691533088684,
0.47596344351768494,
-0.18453511595726013,
-0.5095841288566589,
-0.37445253133773804,
0.4951956868171692,
0.5611628890037537,
-0.02938019298017025,
1.008984923362732,
0.4489157199859619,
-0.5568976998329163,
-0.43851134181022644,
-0.35920026898384094,
-0.371900737285614,
-0.4007757902145386,
0.486771821975708,
-0.5481541752815247,
-0.9127307534217834,
0.6582440733909607,
-0.058306921273469925,
0.15097446739673615,
0.17424459755420685,
0.7125168442726135,
-0.3505202829837799,
0.9486098885536194,
0.8840031027793884,
0.03162205591797829,
0.8745917081832886,
-0.20232848823070526,
0.2317860871553421,
-0.8963387608528137,
-0.16930554807186127,
-0.28946617245674133,
-0.7030856013298035,
-0.0830787867307663,
-0.3956429064273834,
0.29591959714889526,
0.34129539132118225,
-0.3277151882648468,
0.3562548756599426,
-0.17492368817329407,
0.14556492865085602,
0.699069082736969,
0.09168166667222977,
0.007666140794754028,
0.016945701092481613,
-0.5680644512176514,
0.16281549632549286,
-1.0085272789001465,
-0.5034720301628113,
1.1413735151290894,
0.3963259160518646,
0.5342492461204529,
-0.01979689858853817,
0.4929540455341339,
0.16125649213790894,
0.25064077973365784,
-0.8245123624801636,
0.36760830879211426,
-0.017939424142241478,
-0.6651040315628052,
-0.20814432203769684,
-0.5418924689292908,
-0.7414382100105286,
0.44033294916152954,
0.17570997774600983,
-0.6086381077766418,
0.03074636310338974,
0.4068129360675812,
-0.43903109431266785,
0.6676100492477417,
-1.0367159843444824,
0.6918426156044006,
-0.30701038241386414,
-0.4975201487541199,
-0.5055923461914062,
-0.6603091955184937,
0.21739719808101654,
-0.10983544588088989,
0.2415209263563156,
-0.037892308086156845,
-0.33832722902297974,
0.6925280094146729,
-0.16386260092258453,
1.2657729387283325,
-0.43111640214920044,
0.2332667112350464,
0.40623244643211365,
0.04741388559341431,
0.565219521522522,
0.00006514619599329308,
-0.14693677425384521,
-0.10376917570829391,
0.029256965965032578,
-0.5745109915733337,
-0.48547062277793884,
0.4084623456001282,
-0.48544445633888245,
-0.3777199983596802,
-0.5274137258529663,
-0.3358893394470215,
-0.13600197434425354,
0.06242883577942848,
-0.003225600579753518,
0.5634939670562744,
-0.28901833295822144,
0.10810762643814087,
0.7934317588806152,
-0.11052697151899338,
0.8387961387634277,
0.662563681602478,
0.20799896121025085,
-0.04546728357672691,
0.7304917573928833,
0.47550705075263977,
0.4656915068626404,
0.5757886171340942,
0.30958810448646545,
-0.09604854136705399,
-0.673954427242279,
-0.26980769634246826,
0.36398452520370483,
-0.6198701858520508,
-0.07670420408248901,
-0.7031245231628418,
-0.19493548572063446,
-0.027636472135782242,
-0.035314712673425674,
-0.30748307704925537,
-0.5381430983543396,
-0.3212732970714569,
-0.16470883786678314,
-0.1249677762389183,
0.5334668159484863,
0.12241187691688538,
0.19929875433444977,
-0.4188309907913208,
0.37668558955192566,
0.318457692861557,
0.33964160084724426,
0.30843332409858704,
-0.612289547920227,
-0.4485960602760315,
0.1045624241232872,
-0.27445948123931885,
-0.8924879431724548,
0.09585508704185486,
0.4110896587371826,
0.8192327618598938,
0.37020593881607056,
-0.22326284646987915,
0.5918218493461609,
-0.5851221680641174,
0.7056353688240051,
0.020389659330248833,
-0.9432264566421509,
0.3327706456184387,
-0.08949683606624603,
0.44465482234954834,
0.4069528579711914,
0.4244599938392639,
-0.8434397578239441,
-0.32960599660873413,
-0.5737913250923157,
-0.9613738059997559,
0.9756179451942444,
-0.11295843124389648,
0.4630888104438782,
-0.04875306040048599,
0.679634153842926,
0.09927249699831009,
0.42079588770866394,
-0.9232330918312073,
0.04992358013987541,
-0.02007777988910675,
-0.03561972826719284,
0.20317040383815765,
-0.6176356673240662,
-0.12320885062217712,
-0.13360796868801117,
0.683109700679779,
-0.2850457429885864,
0.06905167549848557,
-0.14163967967033386,
-0.33773985505104065,
-0.3660081624984741,
0.08852740377187729,
0.45316505432128906,
0.5766155123710632,
-0.05242031067609787,
0.23790243268013,
0.4209093749523163,
-0.15314076840877533,
0.010897439904510975,
-0.3561626374721527,
-0.2822988033294678,
-0.35147824883461,
0.45203283429145813,
1.01925528049469,
1.0327682495117188,
-0.684147834777832,
0.322250634431839,
0.05604365095496178,
-0.1247192993760109,
-0.347284197807312,
-0.037054579704999924,
0.13438430428504944,
0.10482273995876312,
0.4266006052494049,
0.3465425372123718,
-0.20205055177211761,
-1.177348017692566,
0.3157854974269867,
0.6320679187774658,
-0.7310066819190979,
-0.8322736620903015,
0.6971616744995117,
-0.2235584408044815,
-0.33556485176086426,
0.631756603717804,
-0.40298518538475037,
-0.5453195571899414,
0.47342824935913086,
0.8006514310836792,
1.028024435043335,
-0.29780328273773193,
0.0909707248210907,
0.3965039849281311,
0.07366055250167847,
-0.3223923146724701,
0.37293604016304016,
-0.3735908567905426,
-0.8317350149154663,
-0.1638498455286026,
-0.6496152281761169,
-0.18970952928066254,
-0.21657653152942657,
-0.6002534627914429,
0.21483303606510162,
-0.675896167755127,
-0.08412402123212814,
-0.4034428894519806,
0.04131295531988144,
-0.5266199707984924,
-0.0965379923582077,
0.27550897002220154,
0.8014512658119202,
-0.8651658296585083,
1.1118046045303345,
0.8754923939704895,
-0.5706843733787537,
-0.6623369455337524,
-0.03123142197728157,
0.3309633433818817,
-0.7262235283851624,
0.6003639698028564,
0.09201660007238388,
-0.08918411284685135,
-0.27040401101112366,
-0.3699800670146942,
-1.024512529373169,
0.9759303331375122,
0.2434013932943344,
-0.2034704089164734,
-0.4903643727302551,
-0.49526581168174744,
0.4934786856174469,
-0.25918227434158325,
0.027960045263171196,
0.19803112745285034,
0.23339727520942688,
0.5253685712814331,
-0.87188321352005,
-0.02430974505841732,
-0.09763654321432114,
-0.1546654850244522,
0.38890519738197327,
-0.9753286838531494,
0.9979777932167053,
-0.21446779370307922,
-0.8178483247756958,
-0.19567370414733887,
0.7085329294204712,
0.0016949180280789733,
0.34517455101013184,
0.6515388488769531,
0.5394216775894165,
0.752342700958252,
0.18290671706199646,
0.7883511185646057,
-0.05092637613415718,
0.12323271483182907,
1.3112603425979614,
-0.29588326811790466,
0.9299003481864929,
0.6215632557868958,
-0.01660153642296791,
0.590189516544342,
0.5079775452613831,
0.30427995324134827,
0.5507646799087524,
0.10073038190603256,
-0.10206229239702225,
-0.048370491713285446,
0.08517340570688248,
0.183155357837677,
0.38159993290901184,
0.6264560222625732,
-0.13021552562713623,
-0.39928191900253296,
0.20173795521259308,
0.3490663170814514,
0.2378627359867096,
-0.3016462028026581,
0.7876881957054138,
0.37000682950019836,
-0.6380704641342163,
0.27812910079956055,
0.17085590958595276,
0.5224451422691345,
-1.1335582733154297,
0.01351572573184967,
-0.004885403905063868,
0.22164304554462433,
0.22333082556724548,
-0.27480724453926086,
0.6028966307640076,
-0.2574456036090851,
-0.3719933331012726,
-0.7867584824562073,
0.4586337208747864,
-0.721646785736084,
-0.4971635937690735,
0.49525153636932373,
0.232796311378479,
-0.21557369828224182,
-0.10067863017320633,
-0.7494224905967712,
-0.04302122816443443,
-0.28179529309272766,
-0.3022087514400482,
0.5420826077461243,
0.4523623585700989,
-0.4104386270046234,
0.829718828201294,
0.4404117465019226,
0.20024634897708893,
0.06675087660551071,
0.11047909408807755,
0.8395574688911438,
-0.4860336482524872,
-0.537321925163269,
-0.8835873603820801,
0.4753860533237457,
0.1489972323179245,
-0.1667540818452835,
0.938768208026886,
0.5917806625366211,
1.1219141483306885,
0.2572285234928131,
0.4352910816669464,
-0.07810734212398529,
0.41037046909332275,
-0.6801291108131409,
0.4337124526500702,
-0.8487986922264099,
0.1250583678483963,
-0.1922036111354828,
-0.5134567022323608,
-0.2843381464481354,
0.31159844994544983,
-0.18104027211666107,
0.05091621354222298,
0.9783833026885986,
0.6282857060432434,
-0.20990131795406342,
-0.29843246936798096,
0.15951357781887054,
0.16644324362277985,
0.20389552414417267,
0.8085618615150452,
0.6669963002204895,
-0.17101606726646423,
0.38475748896598816,
-0.08038496226072311,
-0.3663104176521301,
-0.11535783857107162,
-0.7748532295227051,
-1.003202199935913,
-0.9838380813598633,
-0.2822864353656769,
-0.1499163657426834,
-0.013952554203569889,
0.9453150629997253,
0.9059251546859741,
-0.8466402292251587,
-0.47882071137428284,
-0.004748693201690912,
0.26931414008140564,
-0.7080868482589722,
-0.18216632306575775,
0.44650405645370483,
-0.7868760824203491,
-0.6828967332839966,
0.6753755807876587,
0.6175340414047241,
0.04463860020041466,
-0.12091416120529175,
0.026714570820331573,
-0.5105786323547363,
0.18085934221744537,
0.3414454162120819,
0.519524872303009,
-0.6934739351272583,
-0.18178217113018036,
-0.2626950442790985,
0.047434646636247635,
0.013560807332396507,
1.2541569471359253,
-0.7806277275085449,
0.6090502738952637,
0.5079403519630432,
0.34318822622299194,
0.7621040344238281,
-0.20172502100467682,
0.6829082369804382,
-0.8343449234962463,
0.5014183521270752,
0.37917619943618774,
0.44764503836631775,
0.2904961109161377,
-0.20409315824508667,
0.26729997992515564,
0.3781737983226776,
-0.19516918063163757,
-0.9387913942337036,
0.3876294493675232,
-0.44534215331077576,
-0.6669930219650269,
0.8353234529495239,
-0.02080357074737549,
-0.21274933218955994,
-0.12133417278528214,
-0.04428181052207947,
0.5049176216125488,
-0.19120097160339355,
0.8557026982307434,
0.8894686698913574,
0.08444470167160034,
0.037918075919151306,
-0.5658676028251648,
0.5018579363822937,
0.5042158961296082,
-0.018771972507238388,
0.026494359597563744,
0.09654750674962997,
0.34920114278793335,
-0.21457885205745697,
0.758303701877594,
-0.00448062876239419,
-0.07316617667675018,
-0.03660527989268303,
-0.10991861671209335,
-0.019147243350744247,
-0.6954224109649658,
-0.44410550594329834,
0.4915067255496979,
-0.09294376522302628,
-0.0695950910449028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18605v1
|
BioBERT-based Deep Learning and Merged ChemProt-DrugProt for Enhanced Biomedical Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-28T21:34:01 | 2024-05-28T21:34:01 |
Bridget T. McInnes, Jiawei Tang, Darshini Mahendran, Mai H. Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, q-bio.MN
|
This paper presents a methodology for enhancing relation extraction from
biomedical texts, focusing specifically on chemical-gene interactions.
Leveraging the BioBERT model and a multi-layer fully connected network
architecture, our approach integrates the ChemProt and DrugProt datasets using
a novel merging strategy. Through extensive experimentation, we demonstrate
significant performance improvements, particularly in CPR groups shared between
the datasets. The findings underscore the importance of dataset merging in
augmenting sample counts and improving model accuracy. Moreover, the study
highlights the potential of automated information extraction in biomedical
research and clinical practice.
|
[
-0.24261005222797394,
-0.354532927274704,
0.5507659912109375,
-0.13553832471370697,
-0.18871675431728363,
0.4577096700668335,
-0.06568863242864609,
-0.8205615282058716,
0.2110542505979538,
0.5715324878692627,
-0.43766167759895325,
-0.47813042998313904,
-0.7668413519859314,
0.05032103508710861,
-0.026859600096940994,
1.3443639278411865,
0.1904703974723816,
0.42276495695114136,
-0.2759050130844116,
-0.3107580840587616,
-0.006030606105923653,
-0.6292238235473633,
-0.7096793055534363,
-0.7719770073890686,
0.9421529769897461,
-0.025373006239533424,
0.7073290944099426,
0.5434158444404602,
1.0766870975494385,
0.30627113580703735,
-0.013657799921929836,
0.3494369089603424,
-0.12891727685928345,
0.2853453457355499,
-0.5646657347679138,
0.01709478534758091,
-0.6908771991729736,
0.11469064652919769,
0.18633976578712463,
1.0289496183395386,
0.32406318187713623,
-0.13696527481079102,
0.03323408216238022,
0.7704047560691833,
-0.6393685936927795,
0.17442679405212402,
-0.036448679864406586,
0.3778674006462097,
0.08519261330366135,
-0.1435701847076416,
-0.052597761154174805,
-0.3840201795101166,
0.4385100305080414,
-0.44897621870040894,
0.21912170946598053,
-0.3579133450984955,
1.0440089702606201,
0.21052125096321106,
-0.5851113200187683,
-0.19970011711120605,
-0.8014114499092102,
0.49701711535453796,
-0.5417076945304871,
0.576722264289856,
0.0952160507440567,
0.2996233105659485,
-0.2714289128780365,
-1.0390375852584839,
-0.4124939739704132,
-0.24699340760707855,
-0.40555790066719055,
0.2675188183784485,
-0.1797274649143219,
0.1922444850206375,
-0.00723402900621295,
0.4194731116294861,
-0.35287120938301086,
-0.2549518048763275,
-0.9682575464248657,
-0.2643510401248932,
0.6018062829971313,
-0.0029777241870760918,
0.45922574400901794,
-0.19434203207492828,
-0.370414137840271,
-0.04202442243695259,
-0.5228170156478882,
-0.05950162932276726,
-0.036021746695041656,
0.2798813283443451,
0.07271067798137665,
0.7237640023231506,
0.14114969968795776,
0.46324238181114197,
0.04034963250160217,
0.41073888540267944,
0.5602991580963135,
-0.7403155565261841,
-0.4056507349014282,
0.4448322355747223,
1.3323191404342651,
0.24290917813777924,
0.30736419558525085,
-0.1583087295293808,
0.2970503866672516,
0.020338067784905434,
0.16145381331443787,
-0.8379461169242859,
-0.9026813507080078,
0.6333633661270142,
-0.5329629182815552,
-0.43648338317871094,
0.19818691909313202,
-1.0991244316101074,
-0.5876151323318481,
-0.49283140897750854,
0.2818048596382141,
-0.8335903882980347,
-0.2586306631565094,
0.03794153779745102,
-0.414629727602005,
0.2591370940208435,
0.1828686147928238,
-0.4742441177368164,
0.4464530050754547,
0.6083177924156189,
0.701232373714447,
-0.28707456588745117,
-0.06633015722036362,
-0.909683346748352,
0.4470680058002472,
0.08976373821496964,
0.6091516017913818,
-0.47764068841934204,
-0.2913917303085327,
-0.1744997650384903,
0.05418486148118973,
-0.05128009617328644,
-0.7264361381530762,
0.2572566866874695,
-0.5969597101211548,
0.10300638526678085,
-0.21092167496681213,
-0.6190946698188782,
0.06540371477603912,
-0.06955644488334656,
-0.9320716261863708,
0.806037425994873,
0.19126975536346436,
-0.7682028412818909,
0.39791810512542725,
-0.5026348829269409,
-0.6148656010627747,
0.16413241624832153,
-0.3875325620174408,
-0.49965032935142517,
-0.2495339959859848,
0.2739112675189972,
0.6679985523223877,
-0.15998829901218414,
0.4836646020412445,
-0.5174281001091003,
-0.002938157180324197,
0.44626909494400024,
0.3190624415874481,
0.9429880380630493,
0.4474520683288574,
0.012698006816208363,
0.17257735133171082,
-0.7779906988143921,
-0.3392312228679657,
-0.3563096821308136,
-0.3320375084877014,
-0.49738600850105286,
-0.2900075614452362,
0.13570722937583923,
0.5033946633338928,
0.21967285871505737,
-0.6827178001403809,
0.4571213722229004,
-0.32002538442611694,
0.4770876467227936,
0.3388945460319519,
0.3511074185371399,
0.5218155384063721,
-0.03520123288035393,
0.19931736588478088,
0.3139432668685913,
0.06925418972969055,
0.14508680999279022,
-0.296716570854187,
-0.44273096323013306,
-0.5543860197067261,
0.5598070621490479,
0.6551826596260071,
-0.5660504102706909,
0.7560824155807495,
-0.3165138065814972,
-0.37287637591362,
-0.5736218690872192,
0.46691617369651794,
0.44752514362335205,
0.561419665813446,
0.766011118888855,
-0.43766701221466064,
-0.4676332175731659,
-0.8844071626663208,
-0.2083187699317932,
0.07898449152708054,
-0.22535942494869232,
0.23887178301811218,
0.5100705623626709,
-0.5998625755310059,
0.9995833039283752,
-0.6175966262817383,
-0.3707694113254547,
-0.29956990480422974,
0.14180298149585724,
0.3674841523170471,
0.7496140003204346,
0.5642372369766235,
-0.6612692475318909,
-0.47338739037513733,
0.4573739469051361,
-1.0684361457824707,
0.03931094706058502,
0.09376650303602219,
-0.2572687268257141,
-0.45542779564857483,
0.649300754070282,
-0.592359721660614,
0.3413768708705902,
0.19500471651554108,
-0.04780788719654083,
0.13205601274967194,
-0.17673128843307495,
0.20534390211105347,
-1.2516876459121704,
0.30218446254730225,
0.35585975646972656,
-0.13263770937919617,
-1.0273420810699463,
-0.2368837147951126,
0.21091867983341217,
-0.18753258883953094,
-0.7562187314033508,
0.3729340434074402,
-0.39430513978004456,
0.24698041379451752,
-0.05874716490507126,
-0.11087536066770554,
0.23549766838550568,
0.30275216698646545,
0.07076862454414368,
0.2738262116909027,
0.3629087507724762,
-0.5674618482589722,
0.5885124206542969,
0.4532853364944458,
0.1530645340681076,
0.35092607140541077,
-0.7048702836036682,
-0.12612633407115936,
-0.2266625612974167,
0.38528287410736084,
-0.9443239569664001,
-0.4269501268863678,
0.5326069593429565,
-0.49427443742752075,
0.4455031752586365,
-0.16245916485786438,
-0.3498939275741577,
-0.015278586186468601,
-0.5985536575317383,
0.4673575162887573,
0.36475127935409546,
-0.4759853780269623,
0.6862983107566833,
0.31042298674583435,
-0.33645692467689514,
-0.6305925250053406,
-0.7276028394699097,
-0.09572140127420425,
-0.1009821891784668,
-0.3181982636451721,
0.5406599044799805,
0.2376488596200943,
-0.14697609841823578,
0.30345505475997925,
0.03521105647087097,
-0.49161508679389954,
-0.6641531586647034,
0.2273884266614914,
0.5636787414550781,
-0.011000706814229488,
0.33465829491615295,
0.31382691860198975,
0.10194990038871765,
0.09499851614236832,
0.19221922755241394,
0.3495253026485443,
0.24709458649158478,
0.27655908465385437,
-0.4520142078399658,
0.3918682634830475,
0.7810462117195129,
-0.4740722179412842,
0.9694855213165283,
0.7518356442451477,
-0.413289874792099,
0.3132530748844147,
-0.2730726897716522,
-0.129258394241333,
-0.45395323634147644,
0.19088058173656464,
-0.177482470870018,
-0.7313733696937561,
0.5338807106018066,
-0.6568530201911926,
-0.3451160192489624,
0.531258761882782,
0.282941997051239,
-0.24159280955791473,
0.35680091381073,
0.5417665839195251,
-0.36812880635261536,
0.19811353087425232,
-0.3772188425064087,
0.40871670842170715,
-1.12156081199646,
-0.8107313513755798,
-0.29431769251823425,
-0.21653074026107788,
-0.4405359923839569,
-0.25979653000831604,
0.36494430899620056,
0.09231733530759811,
-0.44569066166877747,
0.7438170313835144,
-0.4449109137058258,
0.09183217585086823,
0.21673719584941864,
0.6499063968658447,
0.3445100784301758,
0.25705328583717346,
-0.35343554615974426,
-0.08146604895591736,
-0.6278383135795593,
0.04755515605211258,
1.0114887952804565,
0.19967585802078247,
0.496482253074646,
0.176126167178154,
0.6903714537620544,
0.16391810774803162,
0.3123728632926941,
-0.7730745673179626,
0.31056225299835205,
-0.24540331959724426,
-0.44868335127830505,
-0.002039604354649782,
-0.4065171480178833,
-1.2816412448883057,
-0.10886454582214355,
-0.694974422454834,
-0.6697209477424622,
0.838792622089386,
-0.09626124799251556,
-0.4886435270309448,
-0.007348774932324886,
-0.35397985577583313,
0.5682510733604431,
-0.16788972914218903,
-0.7557486891746521,
-0.027392607182264328,
-1.1918855905532837,
0.45643162727355957,
-0.2908409833908081,
0.10155340284109116,
0.06170943006873131,
-0.0043720765970647335,
0.6860135793685913,
-0.5230579376220703,
0.5364469885826111,
0.4290933609008789,
0.10265735536813736,
-0.011567839421331882,
-0.0796457976102829,
-0.017169665545225143,
-0.30022674798965454,
-0.09215192496776581,
0.3407643735408783,
0.03655048832297325,
-0.25705280900001526,
-0.6776713728904724,
0.7710722088813782,
-0.820997953414917,
0.15144027769565582,
-0.6662207841873169,
-0.5030038952827454,
-0.2057991325855255,
0.1290890872478485,
0.23183853924274445,
0.38741910457611084,
0.026468923315405846,
0.11774913966655731,
0.5188325047492981,
-0.6074275374412537,
0.254860520362854,
0.2428957223892212,
0.009707257151603699,
-0.9947690963745117,
0.7194235920906067,
-0.2004023939371109,
0.08574317395687103,
0.3881688117980957,
0.0889381468296051,
-0.21655017137527466,
0.1873011440038681,
0.12198711931705475,
0.5136551260948181,
-0.5396892428398132,
-0.26091909408569336,
-0.9171255826950073,
-0.6533841490745544,
-0.7714836001396179,
-0.0567406602203846,
-0.3408283293247223,
-0.18070998787879944,
-0.13923543691635132,
-0.027656247839331627,
0.6167678236961365,
0.6356302499771118,
-0.16205400228500366,
0.17958177626132965,
-1.4673255681991577,
0.39440399408340454,
-0.05575939640402794,
0.12316881120204926,
-0.16385148465633392,
0.05849897488951683,
-0.27135124802589417,
-0.5012763142585754,
-0.21425457298755646,
-1.3796319961547852,
0.5431733131408691,
0.30269908905029297,
0.5514082312583923,
0.37092602252960205,
-0.16018334031105042,
0.4680030047893524,
-0.4336231052875519,
0.5125910639762878,
0.3592451512813568,
-0.7413597702980042,
0.727765679359436,
-0.46527233719825745,
-0.018028782680630684,
0.8069908022880554,
0.8667686581611633,
-0.1576339155435562,
-0.008598223328590393,
-0.6846300959587097,
-1.027214527130127,
0.2002898007631302,
0.4569576680660248,
-0.4562355577945709,
0.24346879124641418,
0.616034209728241,
-0.1686863899230957,
0.3414574861526489,
-0.27813905477523804,
-0.4153401255607605,
0.18104791641235352,
-0.5381312370300293,
0.04289017617702484,
0.21294602751731873,
-0.22925551235675812,
-0.9827582240104675,
0.27741262316703796,
0.25109636783599854,
0.2520377039909363,
0.4690784811973572,
-0.0913495272397995,
0.038218967616558075,
0.08862173557281494,
0.17017602920532227,
0.3645516335964203,
-0.4184390604496002,
0.296011745929718,
-0.22306610643863678,
-0.7292076349258423,
0.10626975446939468,
0.5030685663223267,
0.5003218650817871,
-0.24088753759860992,
0.7734357714653015,
0.14045554399490356,
-0.0528307743370533,
-0.5821812748908997,
0.43191102147102356,
0.04317587614059448,
-0.4183058440685272,
0.16178658604621887,
0.10204386711120605,
-0.031873419880867004,
0.5402944087982178,
0.13076657056808472,
0.2271304577589035,
0.5266278982162476,
-0.6523882746696472,
0.8415669202804565,
0.313349187374115,
-0.5910539031028748,
-0.005510098300874233,
0.6260057091712952,
0.292721688747406,
0.00026302237529307604,
0.7407045960426331,
0.4156563878059387,
-0.6712261438369751,
0.6153600215911865,
0.012424432672560215,
0.6957349181175232,
-0.3268720209598541,
0.18946899473667145,
0.613116979598999,
-0.03469694405794144,
0.28183507919311523,
-0.0769910141825676,
-0.3014276921749115,
-0.7159831523895264,
-0.5844505429267883,
-0.4886077642440796,
-0.43420347571372986,
0.4135734438896179,
-0.6188347339630127,
0.2932566702365875,
-0.44873756170272827,
-0.11714892834424973,
0.500839114189148,
0.2979567348957062,
-0.5073456764221191,
0.2980012893676758,
-0.40955230593681335,
0.3426922857761383,
-1.0591822862625122,
1.1546216011047363,
0.7639598846435547,
-0.7560946345329285,
-0.6112161874771118,
-0.17129559814929962,
-0.10349277406930923,
-0.18616431951522827,
1.158340334892273,
-0.13739651441574097,
0.09180843830108643,
-0.34730029106140137,
-0.2821916937828064,
-0.5708861351013184,
0.8965050578117371,
0.27993279695510864,
-0.5626674890518188,
0.32844048738479614,
0.2542242705821991,
0.7772453427314758,
-0.3020576536655426,
-0.045585114508867264,
0.8042039275169373,
0.3186695873737335,
0.41493064165115356,
-0.5525559782981873,
0.2188906967639923,
-0.7358354926109314,
-0.42914730310440063,
0.4452040493488312,
-0.34290581941604614,
0.8700045347213745,
0.0027036815881729126,
0.1864020973443985,
-0.03922188654541969,
0.47898533940315247,
0.29558679461479187,
0.4992486238479614,
0.023403717204928398,
0.3325013518333435,
0.7259737849235535,
0.13986404240131378,
0.8087384104728699,
-0.38784101605415344,
0.4216074049472809,
1.1637381315231323,
-0.40558525919914246,
0.6180532574653625,
0.6130812764167786,
-0.24008309841156006,
0.44611790776252747,
0.7507331371307373,
-0.34035053849220276,
0.47414180636405945,
0.1193230077624321,
-0.6773025989532471,
-0.1276513785123825,
-0.06728938966989517,
-0.5713258981704712,
0.07065284997224808,
0.41581034660339355,
-0.8831780552864075,
-0.061932217329740524,
-0.03465789183974266,
0.09608711302280426,
-0.16008323431015015,
0.0006768369930796325,
0.854394793510437,
0.12493561953306198,
-0.38488709926605225,
-0.003476684680208564,
-0.5727338790893555,
0.3498785197734833,
-0.3006177544593811,
-0.4694978892803192,
0.020729685202240944,
0.4188401997089386,
-0.4391211271286011,
-0.6583102345466614,
0.17962899804115295,
-0.27808162569999695,
0.026126494631171227,
0.5274434089660645,
1.1523075103759766,
-0.786280632019043,
-0.5460599064826965,
0.6381060481071472,
0.5956131815910339,
0.13719956576824188,
0.29290375113487244,
-0.6412601470947266,
0.05460546910762787,
-0.2496557980775833,
0.1020250916481018,
0.37216058373451233,
0.22554917633533478,
0.3949885070323944,
0.27058014273643494,
0.8592494130134583,
0.4551565945148468,
-0.47675222158432007,
-0.1950971484184265,
1.2227085828781128,
-0.5847333073616028,
0.145772784948349,
-1.065517544746399,
0.44567835330963135,
-0.5550758242607117,
0.029561102390289307,
0.48931506276130676,
0.6670312285423279,
0.3109327256679535,
-0.1595466583967209,
0.9072899222373962,
0.2450624257326126,
0.20994096994400024,
-0.2422090321779251,
0.8338378071784973,
-0.3870950937271118,
0.24150845408439636,
-0.5059038996696472,
-0.9659044146537781,
-0.6320464015007019,
0.5767886638641357,
-0.05481654778122902,
0.04647558927536011,
0.9624211192131042,
0.4822387099266052,
-0.3960812985897064,
-0.3085084557533264,
-0.02292962558567524,
0.01896609552204609,
0.46960538625717163,
0.7836532592773438,
0.3178294897079468,
-0.7429013252258301,
0.13696134090423584,
-0.3302140235900879,
-0.332633376121521,
0.08319705724716187,
-0.789552628993988,
-1.133309245109558,
-0.3999040722846985,
-0.5146085619926453,
-0.7221788763999939,
0.20735837519168854,
1.041704535484314,
0.4800718128681183,
-0.7009548544883728,
-0.0424443744122982,
-0.0669269859790802,
-0.34509629011154175,
-0.19143959879875183,
-0.2443041205406189,
0.7694175839424133,
-0.13717421889305115,
-0.5723559856414795,
0.281582772731781,
0.37565627694129944,
-0.01307681854814291,
-0.024839885532855988,
-0.053415872156620026,
-0.5093171000480652,
0.15764687955379486,
0.7144435048103333,
0.477047324180603,
-0.0432140976190567,
0.17019465565681458,
-0.14460450410842896,
-0.21069666743278503,
0.09347345679998398,
0.9811776876449585,
-1.0483695268630981,
0.40738779306411743,
0.6351876258850098,
0.8566454648971558,
0.5745993256568909,
-0.0029364849906414747,
0.9318180680274963,
-0.4979114532470703,
0.014936043880879879,
0.006227666512131691,
0.06311686336994171,
0.3037933111190796,
-0.7872028350830078,
0.8024417757987976,
0.2969484329223633,
-0.5280728340148926,
-0.32539379596710205,
0.02863624505698681,
-1.5025674104690552,
-0.40215516090393066,
0.9940813183784485,
0.05203814059495926,
-0.11580431461334229,
-0.32211053371429443,
-0.2364257276058197,
0.857191801071167,
-0.3510400056838989,
0.4047378897666931,
0.3616984188556671,
-0.7697387337684631,
-0.22519636154174805,
-0.4890565574169159,
0.6759013533592224,
0.11362958699464798,
-0.9906204342842102,
-0.22484324872493744,
0.3678582012653351,
0.25122159719467163,
0.2354474663734436,
0.3917633295059204,
-0.25406888127326965,
0.2231438308954239,
-0.34719911217689514,
0.06843067705631256,
-0.09803054481744766,
-0.4258025288581848,
-0.28671008348464966,
0.1969446837902069,
-0.6301224827766418,
-0.06656524538993835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18572v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18572v1
|
Low-rank finetuning for LLMs: A fairness perspective
| 2024-05-28T20:43:53 | 2024-05-28T20:43:53 |
Saswat Das, Marco Romanelli, Cuong Tran, Zarreen Reza, Bhavya Kailkhura, Ferdinando Fioretto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Low-rank approximation techniques have become the de facto standard for
fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) due to their reduced computational and
memory requirements. This paper investigates the effectiveness of these methods
in capturing the shift of fine-tuning datasets from the initial pre-trained
data distribution. Our findings reveal that there are cases in which low-rank
fine-tuning falls short in learning such shifts. This, in turn, produces
non-negligible side effects, especially when fine-tuning is adopted for
toxicity mitigation in pre-trained models, or in scenarios where it is
important to provide fair models. Through comprehensive empirical evidence on
several models, datasets, and tasks, we show that low-rank fine-tuning
inadvertently preserves undesirable biases and toxic behaviors. We also show
that this extends to sequential decision-making tasks, emphasizing the need for
careful evaluation to promote responsible LLMs development.
|
[
-0.31214454770088196,
-0.6046403050422668,
0.6139891743659973,
-0.09335219860076904,
-0.09853881597518921,
-0.24151083827018738,
-0.3072347939014435,
-0.2194433957338333,
-0.29994168877601624,
0.47409260272979736,
-0.5450289845466614,
-0.39824530482292175,
-0.6610662937164307,
-0.10137399286031723,
-0.2612802982330322,
1.2168256044387817,
0.3662976920604706,
0.14432406425476074,
-0.032377615571022034,
-0.005648372694849968,
-0.5631193518638611,
-0.4498295783996582,
-0.9465470314025879,
-0.46915581822395325,
0.8383843302726746,
0.7905202507972717,
0.8419249057769775,
0.6866341829299927,
0.48095694184303284,
0.19304658472537994,
-0.28745144605636597,
0.07343685626983643,
-1.107892632484436,
-0.12789037823677063,
-0.2962626516819,
-0.9356001615524292,
-0.5618609189987183,
0.42049160599708557,
0.624579906463623,
1.0650287866592407,
-0.10214970260858536,
0.2891901433467865,
0.36522677540779114,
0.9236944317817688,
-0.8602242469787598,
-0.176723912358284,
-0.7947558164596558,
0.25334715843200684,
-0.4446438252925873,
-0.3186907172203064,
-0.5381813049316406,
-0.3514915108680725,
-0.08311864733695984,
-0.5948102474212646,
-0.07483796775341034,
0.06826160848140717,
0.6141232252120972,
0.70850670337677,
-0.28305381536483765,
-0.03660372644662857,
-0.6296970248222351,
1.1092959642410278,
-0.9542627334594727,
0.21666939556598663,
0.359784871339798,
0.3055831789970398,
-0.3803512454032898,
-0.37440207600593567,
-0.32456037402153015,
-0.19883255660533905,
-0.03802792355418205,
0.007849622517824173,
0.17755910754203796,
0.3382696211338043,
0.5838074684143066,
0.39215588569641113,
0.03576022386550903,
0.8294114470481873,
-0.31876564025878906,
-0.1442968249320984,
0.5884602069854736,
0.32831668853759766,
-0.006362283136695623,
-0.20639094710350037,
-0.09017732739448547,
0.048979777842760086,
-1.118463397026062,
0.11327552795410156,
0.5176645517349243,
0.6475852727890015,
-0.061955634504556656,
0.5013898611068726,
-0.2994003891944885,
0.590593695640564,
0.22220495343208313,
-0.0579911544919014,
-0.011523601599037647,
-0.29644039273262024,
-0.4342495799064636,
-0.0248524472117424,
0.47917795181274414,
0.7285596132278442,
0.5458416938781738,
-0.1496427059173584,
-0.1432461440563202,
0.16004851460456848,
0.08390665054321289,
-0.8345434665679932,
-0.30204713344573975,
-0.00961233675479889,
-0.7905446887016296,
-0.6026304364204407,
-0.33927643299102783,
-0.7110092043876648,
-0.5284412503242493,
-0.5779733061790466,
0.3524552881717682,
0.03896649181842804,
0.02218567579984665,
0.055353306233882904,
0.2294224500656128,
0.33389487862586975,
0.4411271810531616,
-0.8993415832519531,
0.5627809166908264,
0.7390308380126953,
0.6617328524589539,
-0.4481809735298157,
-0.1005871593952179,
-0.9758601188659668,
0.006457666866481304,
-0.471687912940979,
0.5802370309829712,
-0.4178692400455475,
-0.2659059464931488,
-0.3590555787086487,
0.04829944670200348,
0.01696440577507019,
-0.8203577995300293,
0.7098710536956787,
-0.23440344631671906,
-0.11478091776371002,
-0.29980704188346863,
-0.29698312282562256,
0.3858943581581116,
0.002563586924225092,
-0.4119543433189392,
0.8217276334762573,
-0.22309811413288116,
-0.6400842666625977,
0.5298442840576172,
-0.5544765591621399,
-0.4352683424949646,
-0.38589173555374146,
-0.028304066509008408,
-0.39916369318962097,
0.38531163334846497,
0.07908335328102112,
0.5946791172027588,
-0.082827128469944,
-0.0976053774356842,
-0.5336285829544067,
-0.7322574257850647,
0.04241335391998291,
-0.6133538484573364,
0.690525472164154,
0.5323917865753174,
-0.12467934191226959,
-0.0008881362155079842,
-0.43476763367652893,
0.16343830525875092,
-0.1523120254278183,
-0.40305596590042114,
-0.5827277302742004,
0.20922799408435822,
-0.04093409329652786,
0.4261959493160248,
-0.014346773736178875,
-0.2870747447013855,
-0.019661618396639824,
-0.5706901550292969,
0.4796638786792755,
1.1181821823120117,
-0.037322741001844406,
0.8254178166389465,
-0.6859977841377258,
0.18404468894004822,
0.07124371826648712,
0.4927602708339691,
0.4191819131374359,
-0.14348000288009644,
-0.8456963896751404,
-0.019058289006352425,
0.548214316368103,
0.5286662578582764,
-0.5382465720176697,
0.19703269004821777,
-0.3736579120159149,
-0.3410657048225403,
-0.7340276837348938,
0.10927891731262207,
0.47429680824279785,
0.2649683952331543,
0.24998141825199127,
-0.14169996976852417,
-0.09685857594013214,
-0.9453262686729431,
-0.4121795892715454,
0.25138410925865173,
0.00532405124977231,
0.3096593916416168,
0.17839257419109344,
-0.051284898072481155,
0.7157770991325378,
-0.2917881906032562,
-0.4299703538417816,
0.14068210124969482,
-0.07951052486896515,
0.1336267739534378,
0.7233215570449829,
0.6358523964881897,
-0.5000985860824585,
-0.2987358868122101,
-0.2061232179403305,
-0.4656025469303131,
-0.26347842812538147,
0.03354756534099579,
-0.30374854803085327,
0.22407253086566925,
0.7638999819755554,
-0.2149110734462738,
0.26630592346191406,
0.44458284974098206,
0.028163250535726547,
0.24902565777301788,
-0.15328764915466309,
0.20127928256988525,
-0.6710836291313171,
-0.07859715819358826,
-0.06498918682336807,
-0.3978569805622101,
-0.5822785496711731,
-0.07225437462329865,
-0.2580169439315796,
0.11056351661682129,
-0.6925756931304932,
0.5718871355056763,
-0.2711585462093353,
-0.1907813549041748,
-0.2657635807991028,
0.13619861006736755,
-0.26173970103263855,
0.27147865295410156,
-0.3260931074619293,
0.7934209704399109,
0.2509399652481079,
-0.7477143406867981,
-0.3764024078845978,
-0.008825413882732391,
-0.2824685275554657,
0.8259645104408264,
-0.32219988107681274,
0.11130671948194504,
-0.22988033294677734,
-0.17026863992214203,
-0.6509246826171875,
0.14580616354942322,
0.27794399857521057,
-0.17952397465705872,
0.2636459767818451,
-0.5599936246871948,
-0.5305885672569275,
-0.027312781661748886,
-0.3835197389125824,
0.3665354251861572,
0.7443749308586121,
-0.4219342768192291,
-0.024992860853672028,
0.6504014730453491,
-0.3538385033607483,
-0.5372037887573242,
-0.7740729451179504,
-0.22035416960716248,
-0.5558823347091675,
-0.11020192503929138,
0.25219547748565674,
-0.2813679873943329,
-0.333375483751297,
-0.34998050332069397,
-0.18749624490737915,
0.10116180777549744,
0.5249961614608765,
0.1548663228750229,
-0.13819539546966553,
0.006073639262467623,
-0.07709988206624985,
0.2887260317802429,
-0.18653446435928345,
-0.0204808097332716,
0.16230793297290802,
0.32357415556907654,
-0.06694762408733368,
-0.18946897983551025,
-0.403696209192276,
0.12642662227153778,
0.44576334953308105,
0.06935673952102661,
0.3749082088470459,
0.1714414656162262,
-0.4618034064769745,
-0.4054856598377228,
-0.2881268858909607,
-0.2866244912147522,
-0.527052640914917,
0.2333691269159317,
-0.21015335619449615,
-0.8113921284675598,
0.5804119110107422,
-0.35558781027793884,
0.09648710489273071,
0.3742198944091797,
0.5866475105285645,
-0.41723039746284485,
1.1339253187179565,
0.5884433388710022,
-0.09917561709880829,
0.6004064679145813,
0.034570928663015366,
0.04275074973702431,
-0.6935017108917236,
0.18597416579723358,
-0.5409904718399048,
-0.6319150924682617,
-0.9372692108154297,
-0.25945985317230225,
0.30034589767456055,
0.27234774827957153,
-0.42918652296066284,
-0.3742019832134247,
-0.37249279022216797,
0.8116340041160583,
0.46169722080230713,
0.26931998133659363,
0.5405660271644592,
0.09227955341339111,
0.09672247618436813,
-0.28781628608703613,
-0.7316174507141113,
-0.5372427701950073,
0.9917774796485901,
0.4640035331249237,
1.0130053758621216,
-0.02894539386034012,
0.8122720122337341,
0.3338649272918701,
0.43666332960128784,
-0.8718070983886719,
0.48122790455818176,
-0.6129226684570312,
-0.3456575870513916,
-0.5999637246131897,
-0.6690121293067932,
-0.9043359160423279,
0.19261428713798523,
-0.2909161448478699,
-0.41746005415916443,
0.35779690742492676,
0.35083499550819397,
-0.561713695526123,
0.12842142581939697,
-0.8277800679206848,
0.8780467510223389,
-0.21473298966884613,
-0.3848886787891388,
-0.42214033007621765,
-0.6456244587898254,
0.3313955068588257,
-0.028033284470438957,
0.45472297072410583,
-0.4898412525653839,
0.19207419455051422,
0.9493427872657776,
-0.4373895823955536,
0.9039499163627625,
-0.5227368474006653,
-0.2311464548110962,
-0.2104250192642212,
0.13947564363479614,
0.44209015369415283,
0.16157351434230804,
-0.22495199739933014,
0.038758616894483566,
0.2155967354774475,
-0.5042290687561035,
-0.41910961270332336,
1.017500400543213,
-0.6815913319587708,
-0.4260934591293335,
-0.2494647055864334,
-0.37304818630218506,
-0.3828619122505188,
0.43558093905448914,
0.1607450246810913,
-0.08446243405342102,
-0.04515078663825989,
0.018143150955438614,
0.7541888952255249,
-0.22485847771167755,
0.22407576441764832,
0.4631621241569519,
-0.024044964462518692,
0.024782124906778336,
0.8772436380386353,
0.3102127015590668,
0.5497093200683594,
-0.0387212336063385,
0.17846578359603882,
0.09467430412769318,
-1.0099960565567017,
-0.09182005375623703,
0.05717295780777931,
-0.7109768390655518,
-0.3297731876373291,
-0.13462376594543457,
-0.08640260994434357,
-0.07589354366064072,
-0.15477347373962402,
-0.6016451716423035,
-0.3839641511440277,
-0.2832566797733307,
-0.04515330493450165,
0.1956590861082077,
0.639379620552063,
-0.14972853660583496,
0.45802468061447144,
-0.40385255217552185,
0.2609822750091553,
0.3176402449607849,
0.6954659819602966,
-0.05453026294708252,
-0.618156373500824,
-0.2551099956035614,
0.3672911822795868,
-0.11262903362512589,
-0.30200880765914917,
-0.0020320063922554255,
0.27185776829719543,
0.7190805077552795,
0.13113167881965637,
0.17547689378261566,
0.6847302913665771,
-0.6745557188987732,
0.44987374544143677,
-0.07023689150810242,
-0.8142028450965881,
0.4410404860973358,
-0.4728177487850189,
0.1846589297056198,
1.0535602569580078,
0.10549481213092804,
-0.5149844884872437,
-0.47100579738616943,
-0.15434803068637848,
-0.7301908731460571,
0.882175862789154,
0.1546686887741089,
0.17191903293132782,
0.019428659230470657,
0.5565118193626404,
0.20797911286354065,
0.20047585666179657,
-0.8339401483535767,
-0.5029385089874268,
0.028233777731657028,
-0.16457253694534302,
-0.15160591900348663,
-0.21439175307750702,
-0.15896333754062653,
-0.37852323055267334,
0.42911142110824585,
-0.12884241342544556,
0.16070815920829773,
-0.2852590084075928,
-0.4523470997810364,
-0.23158305883407593,
0.5451977849006653,
0.6914244294166565,
0.40706905722618103,
-0.3749035894870758,
0.22635109722614288,
0.3525189161300659,
-0.25874894857406616,
0.15152694284915924,
0.04350349307060242,
-0.19202430546283722,
-0.49323028326034546,
-0.0916808545589447,
0.5604296326637268,
0.6194807291030884,
-0.42745262384414673,
0.5438682436943054,
0.09753257036209106,
-0.015984458848834038,
0.06949581205844879,
0.17520883679389954,
-0.19659119844436646,
0.13943032920360565,
0.09605969488620758,
0.2864702045917511,
0.31510239839553833,
-0.464087575674057,
0.2129719853401184,
0.5269683003425598,
-0.3376145660877228,
-0.06478062272071838,
0.6179670691490173,
0.2632002532482147,
0.10564529895782471,
0.5336728096008301,
-0.12732014060020447,
-0.029366806149482727,
0.4511643648147583,
0.12301529198884964,
0.4181804656982422,
-0.07642634212970734,
0.03474532440304756,
-0.05546525493264198,
0.3976593315601349,
-0.27822256088256836,
0.04582030326128006,
0.10911768674850464,
-0.5835124254226685,
-0.5191233158111572,
-0.7014373540878296,
-0.2792412042617798,
0.08077937364578247,
-0.7204071283340454,
0.4201269745826721,
-0.6260954737663269,
-0.1897660493850708,
0.012967666611075401,
0.030665777623653412,
-0.7688227891921997,
0.033002350479364395,
0.4284486770629883,
0.766086995601654,
-0.9381890296936035,
0.6590017676353455,
0.2813008427619934,
-0.22558146715164185,
-0.47632136940956116,
0.1434016078710556,
-0.09049681574106216,
-0.8008849024772644,
0.720320463180542,
-0.042991410940885544,
-0.13561974465847015,
0.2810848355293274,
-0.5472475290298462,
-0.8181387782096863,
0.88478022813797,
0.8043319582939148,
-0.6355695128440857,
-0.2670321762561798,
0.23630499839782715,
0.5091456174850464,
0.023713434115052223,
0.1417137086391449,
0.7861760258674622,
0.47182968258857727,
-0.1846483200788498,
-1.3578886985778809,
0.07761579751968384,
0.10127351433038712,
-0.021738512441515923,
0.11460152268409729,
-0.6160748600959778,
0.9370555281639099,
-0.29745057225227356,
-0.3265913128852844,
-0.013820154592394829,
0.1884317696094513,
0.21844683587551117,
0.10817454755306244,
0.6334668397903442,
0.5254126787185669,
0.8003857731819153,
-0.1161174550652504,
0.9086951017379761,
0.14190657436847687,
0.39570072293281555,
1.0304750204086304,
-0.33159002661705017,
0.7748429775238037,
0.5570565462112427,
-0.14675994217395782,
0.07723824679851532,
0.8084020018577576,
0.20499680936336517,
0.9688504934310913,
0.5026558041572571,
0.21098558604717255,
-0.4162910580635071,
-0.010996587574481964,
-0.35097283124923706,
0.20313365757465363,
0.461776465177536,
-0.20062170922756195,
-0.4366479218006134,
0.20269989967346191,
0.15931901335716248,
-0.01947043649852276,
-0.9035356044769287,
0.870589017868042,
0.36611321568489075,
-0.47327786684036255,
0.695095419883728,
-0.015517979860305786,
1.0044609308242798,
0.008451385423541069,
0.020165011286735535,
-0.3562510013580322,
0.2994154989719391,
-0.32059770822525024,
-0.8712737560272217,
0.2907165586948395,
-0.3043012320995331,
-0.32037097215652466,
-0.36778491735458374,
0.5967501401901245,
-0.2897684872150421,
-0.20313210785388947,
0.22031985223293304,
0.6012153625488281,
0.1323881894350052,
0.07656015455722809,
-0.6929749846458435,
-0.034147340804338455,
-0.3401453495025635,
-0.19075684249401093,
0.6253132820129395,
0.36288321018218994,
-0.33077603578567505,
0.5529125332832336,
0.4730786979198456,
0.2879972755908966,
0.15534131228923798,
0.1284843534231186,
0.7657711505889893,
-0.5578216910362244,
-0.5129975080490112,
-0.7536759376525879,
0.3840893507003784,
0.1060035303235054,
0.04233045130968094,
0.5388210415840149,
0.45677125453948975,
0.9793592095375061,
-0.04485573247075081,
0.7763688564300537,
0.2746376693248749,
0.5588638186454773,
-0.9562161564826965,
0.9949093461036682,
-0.5685610175132751,
0.3841231167316437,
-0.28739452362060547,
-0.8088338971138,
-0.33979475498199463,
0.5991122126579285,
-0.6209118962287903,
0.23737598955631256,
0.4869770109653473,
0.6608319282531738,
-0.26402273774147034,
-0.4463476538658142,
0.46761417388916016,
0.38584405183792114,
0.1538623720407486,
0.6319217085838318,
0.8427624106407166,
-0.42646655440330505,
0.2739211916923523,
-0.1420254409313202,
-0.16621331870555878,
-0.3238165080547333,
-0.9396907091140747,
-0.9483809471130371,
-0.07348329573869705,
-0.10602432489395142,
-0.1469382792711258,
0.32376816868782043,
0.8587602376937866,
0.8069297671318054,
-0.8346526026725769,
-0.14193399250507355,
0.0720028206706047,
0.3498832881450653,
-0.14566825330257416,
-0.20292317867279053,
0.10001028329133987,
-0.4650554060935974,
-0.785868763923645,
0.2544972002506256,
-0.02232508733868599,
0.09782378375530243,
0.0496765598654747,
-0.195121631026268,
0.05889570340514183,
-0.04079063609242439,
0.7214840054512024,
0.266983300447464,
-0.5453569889068604,
-0.4655013680458069,
-0.28995662927627563,
-0.27609559893608093,
0.04609173908829689,
0.6774811148643494,
-0.8218902349472046,
-0.0034007898066192865,
0.26249223947525024,
0.41870951652526855,
0.2841512858867645,
-0.1296086460351944,
0.4311116933822632,
-0.8038687109947205,
0.2733607590198517,
0.20519602298736572,
0.13438846170902252,
0.17595802247524261,
-0.3902119994163513,
0.27947551012039185,
-0.032395169138908386,
-0.6483427882194519,
-1.228881597518921,
0.19953607022762299,
-0.8477906584739685,
-0.1818895936012268,
0.9951390027999878,
0.3259860575199127,
-0.10939911752939224,
-0.04913228750228882,
-0.06564454734325409,
0.14286834001541138,
-0.29204845428466797,
0.8050171136856079,
0.5333636403083801,
-0.18584240972995758,
-0.2107192873954773,
-0.8933730125427246,
1.0944839715957642,
0.621703565120697,
-1.000357985496521,
0.44862425327301025,
0.5749832391738892,
0.47612202167510986,
-0.321615993976593,
0.7503084540367126,
-0.1417599469423294,
0.253475159406662,
-0.6263087391853333,
-0.33488863706588745,
0.1350996047258377,
-0.27656883001327515,
-0.48857709765434265,
-0.14309337735176086,
0.5250213146209717,
0.08925577253103256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00039v1
|
Decoding moral judgement from text: a pilot study
| 2024-05-28T20:31:59 | 2024-05-28T20:31:59 |
Diana E. Gherman, Thorsten O. Zander
|
q-bio.NC
|
q-bio.NC, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Moral judgement is a complex human reaction that engages cognitive and
emotional dimensions. While some of the morality neural correlates are known,
it is currently unclear if we can detect moral violation at a single-trial
level. In a pilot study, here we explore the feasibility of moral judgement
decoding from text stimuli with passive brain-computer interfaces. For
effective moral judgement elicitation, we use video-audio affective priming
prior to text stimuli presentation and attribute the text to moral agents. Our
results show that further efforts are necessary to achieve reliable
classification between moral congruency vs. incongruency states. We obtain good
accuracy results for neutral vs. morally-charged trials. With this research, we
try to pave the way towards neuroadaptive human-computer interaction and more
human-compatible large language models (LLMs)
|
[
-0.12450432032346725,
-0.7771426439285278,
0.7789806127548218,
0.30903056263923645,
-0.5934032797813416,
-0.21326865255832672,
-0.2264319658279419,
-0.5309622883796692,
-0.11995109915733337,
0.460645854473114,
-0.3733396828174591,
-0.30111098289489746,
-0.5230545997619629,
0.22018077969551086,
-0.4233344793319702,
0.9689378142356873,
0.3927808105945587,
0.39592042565345764,
-0.2297326624393463,
-0.2050323486328125,
-0.40963980555534363,
-0.8226456046104431,
-0.9913726449012756,
-0.41628575325012207,
0.36998602747917175,
0.32677406072616577,
0.30022305250167847,
0.0735255777835846,
0.656123697757721,
0.3176925778388977,
-0.28019535541534424,
-0.15722425282001495,
-0.4129132330417633,
-0.11930596828460693,
-0.45518916845321655,
-0.6147911548614502,
-0.6458306312561035,
0.2981400787830353,
0.16171234846115112,
0.20840968191623688,
-0.16247978806495667,
0.0713534951210022,
0.09577386826276779,
0.6410201787948608,
-0.8347428441047668,
0.0800071731209755,
-0.40396058559417725,
0.20442937314510345,
0.3281581699848175,
-0.34725895524024963,
-0.8385874032974243,
-0.45688512921333313,
0.07874514162540436,
-0.511813759803772,
-0.03652479872107506,
0.06204601004719734,
0.6887735724449158,
0.3041824996471405,
-0.9024551510810852,
-0.3850114345550537,
-0.5457004904747009,
0.8685818314552307,
-0.8137835264205933,
0.2430008202791214,
0.9198951125144958,
-0.25166967511177063,
0.17564712464809418,
-0.6347664594650269,
-0.8475616574287415,
-0.290384441614151,
-0.20238344371318817,
0.427057147026062,
-0.06490897387266159,
0.40023404359817505,
0.3654795289039612,
0.28389304876327515,
0.03198297694325447,
-0.15382981300354004,
-0.12708769738674164,
-0.1954430788755417,
0.5443955063819885,
0.10213807970285416,
0.5474153757095337,
-0.5571895241737366,
-0.23142623901367188,
-0.3583917021751404,
-0.25088250637054443,
0.5540276765823364,
0.6681866645812988,
0.04207183048129082,
-0.1771722286939621,
0.6616690158843994,
0.1908847689628601,
0.37202733755111694,
0.31154167652130127,
0.19549889862537384,
0.257760614156723,
-0.44517025351524353,
-0.3626704812049866,
0.2682693898677826,
0.8489612936973572,
0.7767246961593628,
0.6087058186531067,
0.36380255222320557,
-0.2385302484035492,
0.2632391154766083,
0.6790180206298828,
-0.8181606531143188,
-0.07652194052934647,
0.2928151786327362,
-0.766643762588501,
-0.7132696509361267,
-0.008890397846698761,
-0.46455901861190796,
-0.6223523616790771,
-0.28227144479751587,
0.3616349399089813,
-0.6642934679985046,
-0.1118961051106453,
0.5116651058197021,
-0.27549800276756287,
0.46360012888908386,
0.3342849612236023,
-0.6381184458732605,
0.1758912205696106,
0.5001290440559387,
0.5184544920921326,
0.028338754549622536,
0.12204025685787201,
-0.5942099094390869,
-0.22428596019744873,
-0.024929428473114967,
0.60713791847229,
-0.44819340109825134,
-0.3704424500465393,
-0.10663928836584091,
0.21356169879436493,
0.2946447432041168,
-0.21152544021606445,
1.2583974599838257,
-0.53122478723526,
0.21022745966911316,
-0.19887332618236542,
-0.32054805755615234,
-0.35916996002197266,
0.27685973048210144,
-0.6498048305511475,
0.29554256796836853,
-0.3841853439807892,
-0.7815790772438049,
0.28713929653167725,
-0.4025591313838959,
-0.7322685122489929,
-0.1421363204717636,
-0.05590619146823883,
-0.3562130630016327,
0.284023642539978,
-0.04816959798336029,
0.3057156801223755,
-0.10004468262195587,
0.27408576011657715,
-0.16044403612613678,
-0.4916950762271881,
0.4377082586288452,
-0.7364959120750427,
1.043918251991272,
-0.0056640165857970715,
-0.411908358335495,
-0.02279427833855152,
-0.5959905385971069,
0.1297260969877243,
0.06417077779769897,
-0.42514973878860474,
-0.6352688074111938,
0.34741660952568054,
0.24097949266433716,
0.0434393547475338,
0.34273096919059753,
-0.7830963730812073,
-0.05266957730054855,
-0.2714707851409912,
0.44602009654045105,
0.8298159837722778,
0.017208263278007507,
0.364184707403183,
-0.04400968551635742,
0.17830947041511536,
0.011941705830395222,
0.43603217601776123,
0.015604859218001366,
-0.3990902602672577,
-0.6616995930671692,
-0.05470751225948334,
-0.0742524042725563,
0.7339363694190979,
-0.47964805364608765,
0.645668089389801,
0.2086881697177887,
-0.12057811766862869,
-0.2523874342441559,
-0.4293944835662842,
0.719275176525116,
0.3951185941696167,
0.4756735861301422,
-0.3155606687068939,
-0.2541644871234894,
-0.8964228630065918,
-0.5287172794342041,
-0.5003568530082703,
-0.07921410351991653,
0.6328957080841064,
0.4333977699279785,
0.022355781868100166,
0.625737726688385,
-0.2819101810455322,
-0.4401688277721405,
0.07334151118993759,
0.356839656829834,
0.26135802268981934,
0.5102027058601379,
0.28705498576164246,
-1.167921781539917,
-0.07665907591581345,
0.12377040833234787,
-0.9594639539718628,
-0.037144891917705536,
-0.1800643652677536,
0.0774010643362999,
-0.23510253429412842,
0.6717978119850159,
-0.07321659475564957,
0.6039111018180847,
0.4255317151546478,
-0.9878401160240173,
0.4448814392089844,
-0.2523155212402344,
0.7031605243682861,
-0.5897297859191895,
-0.04735400527715683,
-0.22511179745197296,
-0.2734396457672119,
-0.35341528058052063,
-0.39056622982025146,
0.38518038392066956,
0.3603661060333252,
-0.5638721585273743,
0.18219546973705292,
-0.1620057225227356,
0.12482570111751556,
-0.3616265058517456,
0.062182165682315826,
0.10155634582042694,
0.5681002140045166,
0.03011377342045307,
0.6687612533569336,
0.17917586863040924,
-0.4840935468673706,
0.28236836194992065,
0.4729972183704376,
-0.22313392162322998,
1.0486230850219727,
-0.7853535413742065,
0.20400196313858032,
-0.3824816644191742,
0.11174119263887405,
-0.8466452956199646,
-0.22415846586227417,
0.06537927687168121,
-0.41663578152656555,
-0.015329618006944656,
-0.2947046160697937,
-0.2762148082256317,
0.06705515831708908,
-0.27121299505233765,
0.7664929032325745,
0.458820104598999,
-0.4531598687171936,
0.6585299372673035,
0.4153618812561035,
-0.12671330571174622,
-0.5405197739601135,
-0.8281786441802979,
0.21049797534942627,
-0.04415392130613327,
-0.2033376842737198,
0.24220409989356995,
-0.12254055589437485,
-0.3841910660266876,
-0.13965456187725067,
-0.019040772691369057,
-0.07996063679456711,
0.10183615237474442,
0.511203408241272,
0.22299133241176605,
0.20421013236045837,
0.11717262864112854,
0.2332768440246582,
0.032364621758461,
0.4026124179363251,
0.032951317727565765,
0.2801787853240967,
-0.5659103393554688,
-0.34018316864967346,
-0.5940471887588501,
0.37127795815467834,
0.7487766742706299,
-0.21949830651283264,
0.32075005769729614,
0.03669169172644615,
-0.5663058757781982,
0.026860950514674187,
-0.41795071959495544,
-0.26353874802589417,
-0.5095284581184387,
0.1400676667690277,
-0.16565744578838348,
-0.7479996681213379,
0.18619482219219208,
-0.055293336510658264,
-0.20319455862045288,
0.14780063927173615,
0.40908730030059814,
-0.32629695534706116,
1.0736987590789795,
0.7268810868263245,
0.3651130497455597,
0.844911515712738,
-0.10455628484487534,
0.03312978893518448,
-0.7890505790710449,
-0.2489253282546997,
-0.3394181728363037,
-0.5078833699226379,
-0.28662359714508057,
0.027863753959536552,
0.42272794246673584,
0.21993087232112885,
-0.3467012941837311,
0.1401498019695282,
-0.664950966835022,
0.7328035831451416,
0.30908164381980896,
0.5773113369941711,
0.6289244890213013,
0.08217330276966095,
-0.3389144241809845,
-0.18168042600154877,
-0.07362499088048935,
-0.667926549911499,
0.8880347013473511,
-0.10097787529230118,
0.5343146920204163,
0.09583551436662674,
0.29943400621414185,
0.5747897028923035,
0.5915766954421997,
-0.923500120639801,
0.7219135165214539,
-0.47563305497169495,
-0.4485933482646942,
0.05574766546487808,
-0.40743523836135864,
-0.9585855603218079,
0.08292315900325775,
-0.43843358755111694,
-0.5964232087135315,
0.6331784725189209,
-0.1505638211965561,
-0.27089107036590576,
0.1560434103012085,
-0.8832367062568665,
0.8476506471633911,
-0.6055310368537903,
-0.6152914762496948,
-0.6598086357116699,
-0.6534385085105896,
0.34137627482414246,
-0.025586526840925217,
0.15808112919330597,
-0.02937522903084755,
0.05849209427833557,
0.7771027088165283,
-0.21378584206104279,
0.9201980233192444,
-0.026670895516872406,
-0.13951024413108826,
0.1851891130208969,
0.04608231782913208,
0.4002744257450104,
0.2208651453256607,
-0.3086211383342743,
0.08828336000442505,
-0.09388230741024017,
-0.21449144184589386,
-0.5378066897392273,
0.46185630559921265,
-0.7944028973579407,
-0.16739040613174438,
-0.5468321442604065,
-0.265042781829834,
-0.1986437737941742,
0.30469030141830444,
0.2999885380268097,
0.3014102876186371,
-0.5290967226028442,
0.2565232217311859,
0.5684592723846436,
-0.43369677662849426,
0.4355364739894867,
0.6532436609268188,
0.005971613805741072,
-0.749312698841095,
0.659801721572876,
-0.4781917631626129,
0.06879644840955734,
0.2406185269355774,
0.23439690470695496,
-0.17390508949756622,
-0.42700907588005066,
-0.025851456448435783,
0.19813278317451477,
-0.6300529837608337,
-0.0745958462357521,
-0.5301477313041687,
0.16532175242900848,
0.14570003747940063,
-0.4290503263473511,
-0.3016767203807831,
-0.17043092846870422,
-0.2932486832141876,
-0.28232648968696594,
0.31505754590034485,
0.8376832604408264,
0.007357167545706034,
0.2748066186904907,
-0.7012153267860413,
0.5887996554374695,
0.43697917461395264,
0.484559029340744,
-0.22892802953720093,
-0.45126351714134216,
-0.021335355937480927,
0.13319775462150574,
-0.13162201642990112,
-0.9746260046958923,
0.24376502633094788,
-0.12285786122083664,
0.07920437306165695,
0.5866045951843262,
0.3631313443183899,
0.3285626769065857,
-0.32938051223754883,
0.6136220693588257,
0.46512508392333984,
-1.205377221107483,
0.6233605742454529,
-0.3707641065120697,
0.06125621870160103,
0.8115873336791992,
0.15446050465106964,
-0.3706294000148773,
-0.26288601756095886,
-0.6230618953704834,
-0.8181979656219482,
0.8004457354545593,
0.48059988021850586,
0.25410333275794983,
-0.08362378180027008,
0.5800724625587463,
-0.11653797328472137,
0.32736915349960327,
-0.707593560218811,
-0.07956698536872864,
-0.2383519411087036,
-0.2657248079776764,
-0.06946815550327301,
-0.23386169970035553,
-0.094626784324646,
-0.219731405377388,
0.22782780230045319,
-0.23227517306804657,
0.22358691692352295,
0.6289992332458496,
-0.22903375327587128,
-0.08852802217006683,
0.38903704285621643,
0.2833850085735321,
0.1686621904373169,
-0.3978702127933502,
0.2908221483230591,
0.1650383323431015,
-0.9343543648719788,
0.5104555487632751,
-0.3125072121620178,
-0.02581055276095867,
-0.36927133798599243,
0.19733449816703796,
0.45873168110847473,
0.1535881906747818,
-0.8525433540344238,
0.9674417972564697,
-0.6873928308486938,
-0.039272744208574295,
-0.3434300124645233,
-0.08141002804040909,
-0.2214568704366684,
0.506872832775116,
0.1668211817741394,
0.3269023597240448,
0.3650062084197998,
-0.6471529603004456,
0.3485855162143707,
0.32014814019203186,
-0.5009632110595703,
-0.3113977313041687,
0.702826201915741,
0.47974157333374023,
-0.4720425307750702,
0.8577572107315063,
-0.2722806930541992,
-0.6242207288742065,
0.8014176487922668,
0.3528795838356018,
1.146698236465454,
0.0303973238915205,
0.08339137583971024,
0.48527762293815613,
0.3299388587474823,
-0.2929774224758148,
0.5365410447120667,
-0.22566285729408264,
-0.9399303197860718,
-0.5365488529205322,
-0.4641439914703369,
-0.6647286415100098,
-0.14897088706493378,
-0.924584686756134,
0.12818388640880585,
-0.7009158134460449,
-0.6902893781661987,
-0.313113272190094,
-0.2934398949146271,
-0.3869623839855194,
0.3565366566181183,
0.33013200759887695,
0.48475149273872375,
-0.45623040199279785,
0.5135504007339478,
0.6973822712898254,
-0.3219600319862366,
-0.5332577228546143,
0.028070054948329926,
-0.18349909782409668,
-0.3485696613788605,
0.6571448445320129,
0.2625381648540497,
-0.6309453248977661,
0.0930417850613594,
-0.9469165802001953,
-0.052329786121845245,
0.6862437129020691,
0.37045928835868835,
-0.34822583198547363,
0.0069247144274413586,
-0.23874010145664215,
0.5863468050956726,
-0.020394716411828995,
0.4897339642047882,
0.3336898982524872,
0.7095765471458435,
-0.3446839153766632,
-0.6410816311836243,
0.23628292977809906,
-0.6653737425804138,
-0.6096678376197815,
0.02140502817928791,
-0.6708950996398926,
0.7217570543289185,
-0.27915453910827637,
-0.3360874056816101,
-0.20635542273521423,
0.5539162755012512,
0.06993690133094788,
0.5091530084609985,
0.767615795135498,
0.3253680169582367,
0.7187387943267822,
-0.04749197140336037,
1.0293316841125488,
-0.2641431987285614,
0.37173712253570557,
0.6878398060798645,
-0.06277073919773102,
0.8462331295013428,
0.5658672451972961,
-0.02528611570596695,
0.6938464641571045,
0.11395600438117981,
0.10567406564950943,
0.32668203115463257,
-0.011585590429604053,
-0.38333573937416077,
-0.6320748925209045,
-0.41272738575935364,
0.08344785124063492,
0.6116415858268738,
0.5354880690574646,
-0.19770009815692902,
0.19941051304340363,
0.22157590091228485,
-0.15552744269371033,
0.15862883627414703,
-0.38900166749954224,
0.764642596244812,
0.39375749230384827,
-0.6808180809020996,
0.2911036014556885,
0.14632447063922882,
0.9322625398635864,
-0.5542564392089844,
-0.21571697294712067,
-0.023035630583763123,
0.48260271549224854,
-0.35518985986709595,
-0.9871103763580322,
0.04236394166946411,
0.3712637722492218,
-0.31062865257263184,
-0.6866490840911865,
0.833005964756012,
-0.09252940863370895,
-0.1737549751996994,
0.5827018618583679,
0.3696264326572418,
0.05382648855447769,
-0.2529536783695221,
-0.4244610667228699,
-0.18174968659877777,
0.012151231057941914,
-0.3925754129886627,
0.014927083626389503,
0.42958298325538635,
-0.009127890691161156,
0.5102338194847107,
0.8816217184066772,
-0.332384318113327,
-0.21966688334941864,
0.15391117334365845,
0.552426815032959,
-1.1838449239730835,
-0.5532311797142029,
-0.7925729155540466,
0.5260704755783081,
-0.15479916334152222,
-0.3488621711730957,
0.5234262943267822,
0.2815949618816376,
0.4958242177963257,
0.004627489950507879,
0.7181227803230286,
-0.11750607192516327,
-0.26350924372673035,
-0.5985109210014343,
0.8787941336631775,
-0.5897663235664368,
-0.01792665384709835,
-0.24575191736221313,
-0.3581276834011078,
-0.1307099461555481,
0.7728578448295593,
-0.25801581144332886,
0.07205478101968765,
0.878773033618927,
0.37014830112457275,
-0.04833529517054558,
0.4733791947364807,
0.3012603223323822,
0.45140913128852844,
0.19900785386562347,
0.7152130007743835,
1.1237369775772095,
-0.3773198425769806,
0.6988829970359802,
-0.009124334901571274,
-0.38477301597595215,
-0.1887814700603485,
-0.971712052822113,
-0.894256591796875,
-0.2805081605911255,
-0.052086975425481796,
-0.5350189208984375,
0.03018053062260151,
0.5663009285926819,
0.30549702048301697,
-0.573775589466095,
-0.16873638331890106,
-0.41065463423728943,
0.19738216698169708,
-0.26320186257362366,
-0.2679472863674164,
0.19946077466011047,
-0.085029236972332,
-0.7863739132881165,
0.47888049483299255,
0.31964242458343506,
0.0188605859875679,
0.06525655835866928,
-0.012716245837509632,
-0.24064992368221283,
0.2890942394733429,
0.7902745604515076,
0.0037958817556500435,
-0.32178112864494324,
-0.34666526317596436,
0.11055538803339005,
-0.5086693167686462,
-0.0946197435259819,
1.3229206800460815,
-0.9049919843673706,
0.2791236340999603,
0.767886221408844,
0.3396041989326477,
0.4448748230934143,
0.17199936509132385,
0.7346230745315552,
-0.4165676236152649,
0.0959756150841713,
0.46694886684417725,
0.45451900362968445,
0.12694235146045685,
-0.5812882781028748,
0.35820719599723816,
0.30952543020248413,
-0.616500735282898,
-0.5491930246353149,
0.4119149446487427,
-1.5640342235565186,
-0.29118773341178894,
1.0837926864624023,
0.05390693247318268,
-0.2631523609161377,
-0.2868988811969757,
-0.6656293869018555,
0.3189685642719269,
-0.3719143569469452,
0.6856463551521301,
0.680410623550415,
-0.01110453438013792,
0.07305777817964554,
-0.4411560595035553,
0.3607967495918274,
0.8169963359832764,
-0.902702808380127,
0.13583458960056305,
0.660128653049469,
0.006786249577999115,
0.15862156450748444,
0.4920528829097748,
-0.2947874665260315,
0.5695158839225769,
-0.01850515976548195,
0.26210448145866394,
-0.01757737807929516,
-0.09768836945295334,
-0.5312982201576233,
0.1715553104877472,
-0.5419139266014099,
0.09690413624048233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18570v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18570v3
|
It's Not a Modality Gap: Characterizing and Addressing the Contrastive Gap
| 2024-05-28T20:28:07 | 2024-06-06T20:29:21 |
Abrar Fahim, Alex Murphy, Alona Fyshe
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Multi-modal contrastive models such as CLIP achieve state-of-the-art
performance in zero-shot classification by embedding input images and texts on
a joint representational space. Recently, a modality gap has been reported in
two-encoder contrastive models like CLIP, meaning that the image and text
embeddings reside in disjoint areas of the latent space. Previous studies
suggest that this gap exists due to 1) the cone effect, 2) mismatched pairs in
the dataset, and 3) insufficient training. We show that, even when accounting
for all these factors, and even when using the same modality, the contrastive
loss actually creates a gap during training. As a result, We propose that the
modality gap is inherent to the two-encoder contrastive loss and rename it the
contrastive gap. We present evidence that attributes this contrastive gap to
low uniformity in CLIP space, resulting in embeddings that occupy only a small
portion of the latent space. To close the gap, we adapt the uniformity and
alignment properties of unimodal contrastive loss to the multi-modal setting
and show that simply adding these terms to the CLIP loss distributes the
embeddings more uniformly in the representational space, closing the gap. In
our experiments, we show that the modified representational space achieves
better performance than default CLIP loss in downstream tasks such as zero-shot
image classification and multi-modal arithmetic.
|
[
-0.4795237183570862,
-0.4986676573753357,
0.5449698567390442,
-0.09447051584720612,
-0.3384248912334442,
0.14603343605995178,
0.005234991665929556,
-0.32322847843170166,
0.34708723425865173,
-0.025898586958646774,
-0.46027854084968567,
-0.09951277822256088,
-0.7414483428001404,
-0.048113420605659485,
-0.052074920386075974,
0.6265652775764465,
-0.1873316764831543,
0.26246902346611023,
-0.44001030921936035,
-0.503032386302948,
-0.654164731502533,
-0.4128863513469696,
-0.19505684077739716,
-0.21912848949432373,
0.3145865499973297,
0.1083248183131218,
0.7947027683258057,
0.6907292604446411,
0.426570326089859,
0.16905273497104645,
-0.117336206138134,
0.18337637186050415,
-0.4684881865978241,
-0.07599455863237381,
0.008878124877810478,
-0.46721798181533813,
-0.048785243183374405,
-0.05780252069234848,
0.7626569271087646,
0.8294117450714111,
0.12686468660831451,
-0.46419841051101685,
0.08786512166261673,
0.3388320803642273,
-1.0498000383377075,
-0.19888705015182495,
-0.4365823268890381,
0.24254164099693298,
-0.3595450520515442,
-0.3750436007976532,
-0.07961665093898773,
0.17792285978794098,
-0.03386840596795082,
-0.7336564660072327,
0.6361963748931885,
-0.11399967223405838,
0.9824142456054688,
0.3732224106788635,
-0.7704329490661621,
-0.028401752933859825,
-0.5561155676841736,
0.7897903919219971,
-0.5679717063903809,
0.589490532875061,
0.20681041479110718,
0.23977605998516083,
0.11377834528684616,
-0.3859575092792511,
-0.7018033862113953,
0.06817007064819336,
0.025114042684435844,
0.24592465162277222,
-0.14081238210201263,
0.2936163544654846,
0.11949685961008072,
0.5555222630500793,
-0.3016972839832306,
0.027859417721629143,
-0.6233474016189575,
-0.2696181535720825,
0.15317867696285248,
0.4392600655555725,
0.22380098700523376,
0.0020071696490049362,
-0.6717841029167175,
-0.09715200960636139,
-0.4888206124305725,
0.14952577650547028,
0.17982715368270874,
0.014406572096049786,
-0.15484806895256042,
0.49384474754333496,
0.3503764271736145,
0.652084469795227,
0.24748706817626953,
-0.04482076317071915,
0.1538880467414856,
-0.4434110224246979,
-0.2656726539134979,
-0.09840148687362671,
0.7768802046775818,
0.7037436962127686,
-0.3622748553752899,
-0.15781675279140472,
-0.2323632389307022,
0.5213780999183655,
0.14839032292366028,
-0.8603128790855408,
-0.16436108946800232,
-0.2729588747024536,
-0.44628283381462097,
-0.16083085536956787,
0.3867323398590088,
-0.3484894633293152,
-0.4123474657535553,
-0.12312424182891846,
0.7354006767272949,
-0.3680976331233978,
-0.09863057732582092,
0.1709146946668625,
-0.39732927083969116,
0.1552792340517044,
0.35260507464408875,
-0.8324132561683655,
0.5167171955108643,
0.30090683698654175,
1.1629328727722168,
-0.13772264122962952,
-0.34126919507980347,
-0.09176719188690186,
0.16132408380508423,
-0.6413049101829529,
0.863569974899292,
-0.7791253328323364,
-0.4523782432079315,
0.020693078637123108,
0.17174190282821655,
-0.5279020071029663,
-0.6627300381660461,
0.36329975724220276,
-0.48353660106658936,
0.5161786675453186,
-0.3449713885784149,
-0.7013217806816101,
-0.3212420344352722,
0.3616521954536438,
-0.942720353603363,
0.747900128364563,
0.20341342687606812,
-0.6846352815628052,
0.4566059112548828,
-0.575303316116333,
-0.27235567569732666,
-0.32942506670951843,
-0.574779212474823,
-0.4627610743045807,
0.2776021361351013,
0.07143611460924149,
0.15375104546546936,
-0.3307892978191376,
-0.04252202808856964,
-0.46555089950561523,
-0.8389443159103394,
0.6102510094642639,
-0.3738587200641632,
0.3962099850177765,
-0.0640796646475792,
-0.29138779640197754,
-0.12992995977401733,
-0.512739896774292,
-0.22458511590957642,
-0.1500009298324585,
-0.3013313412666321,
-0.4839211404323578,
-0.1855134516954422,
0.2928715944290161,
0.48904573917388916,
-0.2652498781681061,
-0.7494581937789917,
0.18029768764972687,
-0.09684602171182632,
0.48519283533096313,
0.6793634295463562,
0.06629753112792969,
0.6046887040138245,
-0.5987467765808105,
0.41770005226135254,
0.4755820631980896,
-0.03066033497452736,
-0.5417647957801819,
-0.2068135291337967,
-0.8897839188575745,
-0.47499746084213257,
0.45796844363212585,
0.2522485554218292,
-0.7501660585403442,
0.28714895248413086,
0.12033819407224655,
-0.013263920322060585,
-0.40561574697494507,
-0.1703915297985077,
0.330728679895401,
0.48473018407821655,
0.2648833096027374,
-0.7636234760284424,
-0.35765066742897034,
-0.9071242213249207,
0.22408290207386017,
0.12439432740211487,
-0.058349575847387314,
0.3619201183319092,
0.3695860505104065,
-0.13542968034744263,
0.6813110113143921,
-0.4831998348236084,
-0.6531538367271423,
0.18038605153560638,
0.20139238238334656,
0.0842861533164978,
0.5975416302680969,
0.5119934678077698,
-0.7327699661254883,
-0.27018341422080994,
-0.2622590661048889,
-0.703093945980072,
0.008005998097360134,
-0.3891494572162628,
0.08055401593446732,
0.0006574072758667171,
0.6766632199287415,
-0.3534230887889862,
0.5074493885040283,
0.4401198923587799,
-0.6008315682411194,
0.1957775205373764,
-0.12462101876735687,
0.43710458278656006,
-0.8323193192481995,
0.09150294214487076,
-0.3238881230354309,
-0.2017553448677063,
-0.5605028867721558,
-0.3279304504394531,
0.20291972160339355,
-0.30496326088905334,
-0.28370991349220276,
0.25658130645751953,
-0.4721100926399231,
-0.07399081438779831,
-0.45352280139923096,
-0.03678065538406372,
0.7125766277313232,
0.6749683022499084,
0.09701864421367645,
0.8859478831291199,
0.7565543055534363,
-0.7104794383049011,
-0.15921244025230408,
0.35827887058258057,
-0.1028401181101799,
0.9478654861450195,
-0.6983309388160706,
0.1085735633969307,
-0.0974859893321991,
0.23772485554218292,
-1.009752631187439,
-0.20725855231285095,
0.3305710554122925,
-0.38983774185180664,
0.558871865272522,
0.013883989304304123,
0.01876809448003769,
0.23952007293701172,
-0.634308397769928,
1.1858543157577515,
0.26294824481010437,
-0.31519976258277893,
0.1799829602241516,
0.10796791315078735,
0.24999423325061798,
-0.6736174821853638,
-0.9151889681816101,
-0.05071147903800011,
-0.026479395106434822,
-0.6782324910163879,
0.8018538355827332,
-0.07863083481788635,
0.26383721828460693,
0.3989626169204712,
-0.38093557953834534,
-0.4472455382347107,
-0.12799200415611267,
0.22306400537490845,
0.18914538621902466,
-0.404609739780426,
0.3650614023208618,
-0.0369139201939106,
0.0382436066865921,
-0.3398628234863281,
0.0508849211037159,
0.22934336960315704,
0.10129940509796143,
-0.613551676273346,
-0.44975546002388,
0.5678572058677673,
0.6746265888214111,
-0.047558799386024475,
0.5402048826217651,
0.5276583433151245,
-0.3697478771209717,
0.1888425052165985,
-0.4964304268360138,
-0.1772601157426834,
-0.3580946624279022,
0.3016936182975769,
-0.31801170110702515,
-1.1307032108306885,
0.42134279012680054,
0.10498003661632538,
-0.3037928342819214,
0.28084272146224976,
0.2810843884944916,
-0.15733502805233002,
0.9156034588813782,
1.033792495727539,
0.5034385919570923,
0.7969806790351868,
-0.39980003237724304,
0.15505675971508026,
-1.3818386793136597,
-0.5779299139976501,
-0.14002102613449097,
-0.5054897665977478,
-0.34259676933288574,
-0.938271701335907,
0.4909382462501526,
0.500443160533905,
-0.15175020694732666,
0.04648202285170555,
-0.36828792095184326,
0.6218783259391785,
0.3231358230113983,
0.011287273839116096,
0.1289360374212265,
-0.17555028200149536,
-0.0785505622625351,
-0.5421593189239502,
-0.8048782348632812,
-0.2527000308036804,
0.748389482498169,
0.24567840993404388,
0.8838953375816345,
0.32089853286743164,
0.4876975417137146,
0.4802170693874359,
-0.28367719054222107,
-1.092612862586975,
0.17006899416446686,
-0.19833604991436005,
-0.47027820348739624,
0.04851248860359192,
-0.04776706546545029,
-0.9994117021560669,
0.5247789621353149,
-0.4160243272781372,
-0.2900131344795227,
0.9373555183410645,
0.1721697747707367,
-0.24941568076610565,
0.4334923028945923,
-0.2606115937232971,
0.892362654209137,
0.007392074912786484,
-0.5153742432594299,
-0.0692293792963028,
-0.586309015750885,
0.3593268096446991,
0.14361274242401123,
-0.03413446620106697,
-0.1509982943534851,
-0.4990643858909607,
0.7492617964744568,
-0.6348844170570374,
0.7257201671600342,
0.03229466453194618,
0.3368707001209259,
0.19350340962409973,
0.3094748258590698,
-0.10544434934854507,
-0.2401469349861145,
0.42852452397346497,
0.18388979136943817,
0.06117437034845352,
-0.6349019408226013,
-0.9007192254066467,
0.18149077892303467,
-0.6611536741256714,
-0.07085549831390381,
-0.6648480296134949,
-0.3632463216781616,
-0.26892828941345215,
0.05067232623696327,
0.5974070429801941,
0.7043883800506592,
-0.41809454560279846,
0.2160973846912384,
0.8318614363670349,
-0.11786703020334244,
0.5417503118515015,
0.4743401110172272,
0.32522398233413696,
-0.6646208167076111,
0.756585955619812,
-0.020763522014021873,
0.32598426938056946,
0.4096699357032776,
0.024131514132022858,
-0.3932276964187622,
-0.26096826791763306,
-0.6265855431556702,
0.3189312219619751,
-0.7721718549728394,
-0.3523017466068268,
-0.33578455448150635,
-0.05277623236179352,
-0.3283151686191559,
-0.6376961469650269,
-0.45976904034614563,
-0.6442303657531738,
-0.32796090841293335,
0.06591379642486572,
-0.19495166838169098,
0.7028642296791077,
-0.37992677092552185,
0.24195170402526855,
-0.8466321229934692,
0.15412598848342896,
0.4625486433506012,
0.5135489106178284,
-0.02010776288807392,
-0.7847725749015808,
-0.28739795088768005,
-0.4439767599105835,
-0.7580434679985046,
-0.9673223495483398,
0.13220305740833282,
0.5024040341377258,
0.6133759617805481,
0.7012085914611816,
-0.1496639996767044,
0.8494750261306763,
-0.41096240282058716,
0.9861244559288025,
0.971842885017395,
-1.086125135421753,
0.12219849228858948,
-0.19376777112483978,
0.43013131618499756,
0.47551512718200684,
0.20612558722496033,
-0.815007209777832,
-0.09059658646583557,
-0.5658788681030273,
-0.8528732657432556,
0.8567980527877808,
0.2500472962856293,
0.17338666319847107,
-0.0927966833114624,
-0.21518424153327942,
0.16764390468597412,
0.3528933525085449,
-0.7197564244270325,
-0.05486208572983742,
-0.7025334239006042,
0.18055038154125214,
0.28784018754959106,
-0.39166268706321716,
-0.3851276934146881,
0.042513441294431686,
0.26772940158843994,
-0.10991105437278748,
0.7098395824432373,
0.42497068643569946,
-0.2119390368461609,
-0.10197898000478745,
0.5061652064323425,
0.8061891794204712,
0.6019855737686157,
-0.051476456224918365,
0.5145968794822693,
-0.005447784438729286,
-0.22090066969394684,
0.2774268388748169,
-0.045303650200366974,
-0.08481298387050629,
0.3777523636817932,
0.6276628375053406,
1.0140354633331299,
0.5034239292144775,
-0.42805105447769165,
1.0960146188735962,
0.08812779188156128,
-0.2701711356639862,
0.054325349628925323,
-0.2731791138648987,
-0.38849058747291565,
0.3692023754119873,
0.11037397384643555,
0.3493857979774475,
0.48154476284980774,
-0.6898012757301331,
0.26009616255760193,
0.3805229365825653,
-0.8428385853767395,
-0.38568511605262756,
0.6831222176551819,
0.28731778264045715,
-0.07198414951562881,
0.456972599029541,
-0.03734051436185837,
-0.5414655804634094,
0.5443137884140015,
0.656271755695343,
0.7242615818977356,
-0.09746934473514557,
0.1860029101371765,
0.4083307385444641,
0.1084522157907486,
0.03386365994811058,
0.08781273663043976,
-0.3411369025707245,
-0.7446881532669067,
-0.22969047725200653,
-0.19176241755485535,
-0.3404986560344696,
0.07417105883359909,
-0.9013181328773499,
0.11011644452810287,
-0.6448188424110413,
-0.13956789672374725,
-0.1124977245926857,
-0.5046248435974121,
-0.47689390182495117,
0.064771369099617,
0.2072935849428177,
0.731259822845459,
-1.0522499084472656,
0.4259164035320282,
0.6438162922859192,
-0.5622714161872864,
-0.44787001609802246,
0.08026894927024841,
-0.03972983360290527,
-0.5749234557151794,
0.23468391597270966,
0.4305046498775482,
-0.2925153374671936,
-0.6988523602485657,
-0.3750825524330139,
-0.6529829502105713,
1.121024250984192,
0.35322752594947815,
-0.3713351786136627,
0.08519565314054489,
0.010161378420889378,
0.3740195631980896,
-0.397566020488739,
0.24698340892791748,
0.14603470265865326,
0.05456307902932167,
0.4385971426963806,
-0.8377262353897095,
0.11937585473060608,
-0.16424262523651123,
0.3986370265483856,
0.391889750957489,
-0.8525603413581848,
1.2133467197418213,
-0.15901002287864685,
-0.5128883719444275,
-0.003834455506876111,
0.25293952226638794,
0.01611822471022606,
0.5765881538391113,
0.42515456676483154,
0.6170638203620911,
0.5887072682380676,
-0.15624897181987762,
0.9359241724014282,
-0.10395454615354538,
0.3850192725658417,
0.7783666253089905,
-0.032681360840797424,
0.4634488821029663,
0.5941948294639587,
0.004651348572224379,
0.5223912000656128,
0.4950386583805084,
-0.21332480013370514,
0.8175501823425293,
-0.13501067459583282,
-0.3533591628074646,
-0.5830681324005127,
-0.4845481514930725,
-0.3891504108905792,
0.5124375820159912,
0.20026671886444092,
-0.44328799843788147,
-0.3875475227832794,
-0.01883254386484623,
0.05087083578109741,
0.2983488142490387,
-0.28074386715888977,
0.6106792688369751,
0.13470689952373505,
-0.19340640306472778,
0.7175309658050537,
0.035504598170518875,
0.9142398238182068,
-0.6400425434112549,
-0.29120463132858276,
-0.25095245242118835,
-0.022631080821156502,
-0.3133162260055542,
-0.6084994673728943,
0.3325519561767578,
-0.37732869386672974,
-0.4202391803264618,
0.05421176925301552,
0.5510064959526062,
-0.5681428909301758,
-0.17251227796077728,
0.15733930468559265,
0.34892892837524414,
0.12398433685302734,
0.2157517820596695,
-0.6104105710983276,
0.25801655650138855,
-0.3323596715927124,
0.224994957447052,
0.27319765090942383,
0.40133440494537354,
-0.004199586343020201,
0.07416971772909164,
0.2201618105173111,
-0.2562114894390106,
0.028628425672650337,
0.08625496923923492,
1.0208719968795776,
-0.9497995972633362,
-0.5908786654472351,
-0.5930104851722717,
0.47891589999198914,
-0.013941051438450813,
-0.39769601821899414,
0.4121866524219513,
0.6763185858726501,
0.7802386283874512,
-0.00028989609563723207,
0.7188619375228882,
-0.21116705238819122,
0.2630773186683655,
-0.7001229524612427,
0.21755392849445343,
-0.8025051355361938,
0.1215142160654068,
-0.13542649149894714,
-0.787499189376831,
-0.333206444978714,
0.6969239711761475,
0.01530048344284296,
0.05979721620678902,
1.0352649688720703,
0.9765573740005493,
-0.40530791878700256,
-0.3343493342399597,
0.8085556030273438,
-0.20251132547855377,
0.13854926824569702,
0.968810498714447,
1.044219732284546,
-0.6704174280166626,
0.7519934177398682,
-0.07199590653181076,
-0.19112107157707214,
-0.31535017490386963,
-0.7044951915740967,
-0.8893671035766602,
-0.6399144530296326,
-0.32970941066741943,
-0.2817295491695404,
-0.15060999989509583,
0.5072808265686035,
0.8959938883781433,
-0.5335814952850342,
-0.16371867060661316,
0.07958474010229111,
0.036598965525627136,
-0.1407187283039093,
-0.2360108494758606,
0.3297695219516754,
-0.2863868474960327,
-0.6792726516723633,
0.394084095954895,
0.4831778407096863,
0.321474552154541,
-0.20225220918655396,
-0.0674404576420784,
-0.021107958629727364,
0.11088350415229797,
0.4859587550163269,
0.49548372626304626,
-0.7030642628669739,
-0.10224274545907974,
0.2676694095134735,
-0.10686720907688141,
0.48208534717559814,
1.4137835502624512,
-0.779731273651123,
0.8549904227256775,
0.42324358224868774,
0.7623893022537231,
0.4366039037704468,
-0.22930200397968292,
0.48249325156211853,
-0.8669421672821045,
0.13831481337547302,
0.26422831416130066,
0.3596458435058594,
0.5986694097518921,
-0.1250028908252716,
0.42177674174308777,
0.6212484240531921,
-0.3610464334487915,
-0.8184497952461243,
0.45809295773506165,
-1.243886947631836,
-0.5801284313201904,
0.9531117677688599,
-0.036893829703330994,
0.0359845869243145,
-0.21624821424484253,
-0.2069355845451355,
0.3100171685218811,
-0.3386760950088501,
0.9188129305839539,
0.6596933007240295,
-0.6703081130981445,
-0.18230515718460083,
-0.20220467448234558,
0.3558725118637085,
0.5338903069496155,
-0.28388771414756775,
-0.3396817743778229,
0.7750008702278137,
0.3406732976436615,
0.30854007601737976,
0.7503648996353149,
-0.36745285987854004,
0.7049271464347839,
0.40993523597717285,
-0.1185433492064476,
-0.5242443084716797,
-0.233451709151268,
-0.9091799855232239,
0.19649828970432281,
0.10587319731712341,
-0.7762610912322998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18542v1
|
Automatic detection of cognitive impairment in elderly people using an entertainment chatbot with Natural Language Processing capabilities
| 2024-05-28T19:17:48 | 2024-05-28T19:17:48 |
Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco J. González-Castaño, Enrique Costa-Montenegro
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Previous researchers have proposed intelligent systems for therapeutic
monitoring of cognitive impairments. However, most existing practical
approaches for this purpose are based on manual tests. This raises issues such
as excessive caretaking effort and the white-coat effect. To avoid these
issues, we present an intelligent conversational system for entertaining
elderly people with news of their interest that monitors cognitive impairment
transparently. Automatic chatbot dialogue stages allow assessing content
description skills and detecting cognitive impairment with Machine Learning
algorithms. We create these dialogue flows automatically from updated news
items using Natural Language Generation techniques. The system also infers the
gold standard of the answers to the questions, so it can assess cognitive
capabilities automatically by comparing these answers with the user responses.
It employs a similarity metric with values in [0, 1], in increasing level of
similarity. To evaluate the performance and usability of our approach, we have
conducted field tests with a test group of 30 elderly people in the earliest
stages of dementia, under the supervision of gerontologists. In the
experiments, we have analysed the effect of stress and concentration in these
users. Those without cognitive impairment performed up to five times better. In
particular, the similarity metric varied between 0.03, for stressed and
unfocused participants, and 0.36, for relaxed and focused users. Finally, we
developed a Machine Learning algorithm based on textual analysis features for
automatic cognitive impairment detection, which attained accuracy, F-measure
and recall levels above 80%. We have thus validated the automatic approach to
detect cognitive impairment in elderly people based on entertainment content.
|
[
-0.38996079564094543,
-1.112012267112732,
0.654384970664978,
0.16175830364227295,
-0.38651561737060547,
-0.19160869717597961,
-0.3709048926830292,
-0.7555378675460815,
0.345440536737442,
0.5780959129333496,
-0.6763972043991089,
-0.5724073052406311,
-0.6047757863998413,
-0.18992400169372559,
-0.012676923535764217,
0.9302142262458801,
0.1289740800857544,
0.2135518491268158,
-0.22292043268680573,
-0.037518296390771866,
-0.7522947192192078,
-0.1349426656961441,
-1.2538377046585083,
-0.06635239720344543,
-0.11142082512378693,
0.5333113670349121,
0.6819079518318176,
0.17308403551578522,
0.5385733842849731,
0.4581063687801361,
-0.06938640773296356,
0.3850904703140259,
-0.18393240869045258,
0.14253972470760345,
0.12669867277145386,
-0.40132978558540344,
-0.6822914481163025,
-0.2918810248374939,
-0.17749935388565063,
0.3156033754348755,
0.02211710996925831,
-0.09417762607336044,
0.12571077048778534,
0.8539822101593018,
-0.7135484218597412,
0.4433227479457855,
-0.42622989416122437,
0.31557220220565796,
-0.0942990854382515,
-0.4410080313682556,
-0.15718737244606018,
-0.4513130187988281,
0.17301738262176514,
-0.6682299971580505,
0.007486182730644941,
0.09265485405921936,
0.4132152497768402,
0.5655984878540039,
-0.22477346658706665,
-0.7888864874839783,
-0.6354500651359558,
0.6169639825820923,
-0.8110642433166504,
0.02289310097694397,
0.903860867023468,
0.6392383575439453,
-0.057176560163497925,
-0.16229747235774994,
-0.5639313459396362,
-0.8517597913742065,
0.010353813879191875,
0.27360451221466064,
-0.25749748945236206,
0.1757592111825943,
0.050703153014183044,
0.4670597016811371,
-0.770083487033844,
-0.029059508815407753,
-0.5160822868347168,
-0.568126380443573,
0.5762500166893005,
0.2808079719543457,
0.781553328037262,
-0.16658003628253937,
-0.12552687525749207,
0.17306987941265106,
0.28498411178588867,
0.01091755647212267,
0.18440142273902893,
-0.18057407438755035,
-0.04352996498346329,
0.5371466279029846,
-0.7141452431678772,
0.39000204205513,
-0.08505553007125854,
-0.09231443703174591,
0.41442084312438965,
-0.14936316013336182,
0.044107090681791306,
0.38664117455482483,
0.6949214339256287,
0.6910586357116699,
0.9049229025840759,
-0.18159164488315582,
0.08008262515068054,
0.13606400787830353,
0.1586223542690277,
-0.21123452484607697,
-0.5993929505348206,
0.32405680418014526,
-0.48568442463874817,
0.007778281811624765,
-0.12422863394021988,
-0.7126075625419617,
-0.3346715569496155,
-0.05664462223649025,
0.2988685369491577,
-0.9982306957244873,
-0.10530135780572891,
0.3551846742630005,
-0.3315473794937134,
-0.27806222438812256,
0.3433675169944763,
-0.9048248529434204,
0.2848883271217346,
0.22592796385288239,
0.7563848495483398,
-0.503226637840271,
0.2801514267921448,
-0.5784696936607361,
0.24819669127464294,
0.08323829621076584,
0.9615962505340576,
-0.4068666696548462,
-0.2907063066959381,
-0.19444504380226135,
0.03231725096702576,
0.1126304417848587,
-0.5901291370391846,
0.8765734434127808,
-0.4272696375846863,
0.5425475239753723,
0.507693886756897,
-0.3004780411720276,
-0.0998304933309555,
0.38313066959381104,
-0.7192812561988831,
0.8877902626991272,
0.15880262851715088,
-0.4977356791496277,
0.2310597449541092,
-0.8858280181884766,
-0.5042358636856079,
0.3515840768814087,
0.16677744686603546,
-0.32192835211753845,
0.06832379847764969,
0.4055473804473877,
0.009454007260501385,
-0.09585179388523102,
-0.11912193894386292,
-0.37677431106567383,
-0.39450210332870483,
0.32438743114471436,
-0.7424188256263733,
0.6449083685874939,
0.2926329970359802,
-0.4102785885334015,
0.1311715990304947,
-0.6403042674064636,
0.45355552434921265,
-0.16775955259799957,
-0.36453676223754883,
-0.4838791489601135,
0.17259177565574646,
-0.18117153644561768,
0.22755375504493713,
0.29819828271865845,
-0.4152672290802002,
-0.2580256462097168,
-0.31032320857048035,
0.4123230576515198,
0.28806620836257935,
0.33513176441192627,
0.22190970182418823,
-0.49056947231292725,
0.310424268245697,
0.09787463396787643,
0.6501817107200623,
-0.04939652234315872,
-0.6286750435829163,
-0.5997417569160461,
-0.3896549940109253,
0.020208977162837982,
0.9961747527122498,
-0.5086423754692078,
1.0317665338516235,
-0.1968289464712143,
-0.21270915865898132,
-0.4084188938140869,
0.08116061240434647,
0.2993455231189728,
0.41757866740226746,
0.5689249634742737,
-0.6721282601356506,
-0.028801163658499718,
-0.6446707248687744,
-0.18964281678199768,
-0.32642602920532227,
-0.4014352858066559,
0.41266852617263794,
0.0714762732386589,
-0.25944992899894714,
0.3763945996761322,
-0.6333497166633606,
-0.8930301666259766,
0.232025146484375,
0.32553723454475403,
-0.38699454069137573,
0.7076910734176636,
-0.05040346458554268,
-0.6661390066146851,
-0.17944017052650452,
0.12875300645828247,
-0.7437999844551086,
-0.17421458661556244,
0.14405839145183563,
-0.013965057209134102,
0.4482106566429138,
0.4880877733230591,
-0.5182977914810181,
0.6119314432144165,
0.16851350665092468,
-0.2794860005378723,
0.3097277879714966,
-0.5260788798332214,
0.3478517532348633,
-0.4760218858718872,
-0.15402330458164215,
-0.1953529417514801,
-0.030910175293684006,
-0.35524922609329224,
-0.6646978855133057,
-0.34603971242904663,
-0.12577860057353973,
-0.11957937479019165,
0.24506999552249908,
-0.39913615584373474,
0.09049368649721146,
-0.4240407943725586,
0.46679359674453735,
-0.09841694682836533,
0.4423794746398926,
0.02863973006606102,
0.035761572420597076,
0.332473486661911,
-0.46007636189460754,
0.3578040599822998,
-0.013539066538214684,
-0.35412031412124634,
0.8186718225479126,
-0.3617691695690155,
0.040243491530418396,
-0.059100568294525146,
0.11727593094110489,
-1.3021351099014282,
-0.12263678014278412,
0.46762755513191223,
-0.6427172422409058,
-0.04405228793621063,
0.27723953127861023,
-0.10142916440963745,
-0.48657163977622986,
-0.27267569303512573,
0.12450673431158066,
0.49558475613594055,
0.2798977494239807,
0.6163756251335144,
0.49281060695648193,
-0.3975490629673004,
-0.045603178441524506,
-0.89034104347229,
0.056648846715688705,
-0.3092022240161896,
-0.9572586417198181,
0.3797532618045807,
-0.3581349849700928,
-0.03158717229962349,
0.34813612699508667,
0.010986669920384884,
-0.40564921498298645,
0.1984676569700241,
0.22576403617858887,
0.2704499661922455,
-0.2182825803756714,
0.32553038001060486,
0.10564377158880234,
-0.22181612253189087,
-0.10974293202161789,
-0.07616947591304779,
0.5672293305397034,
-0.30716079473495483,
-0.43260252475738525,
-0.9930077195167542,
0.25478193163871765,
0.7442104816436768,
-0.365630179643631,
0.23549297451972961,
0.7072498798370361,
-0.46340951323509216,
0.10192546248435974,
-0.7050848007202148,
-0.10057274252176285,
-0.49801379442214966,
0.13790345191955566,
-0.03534979745745659,
-0.6792373061180115,
0.38820770382881165,
-0.11095748096704483,
-0.35968902707099915,
0.47165417671203613,
0.6188705563545227,
-0.16278710961341858,
1.2789868116378784,
0.40906277298927307,
0.006643790751695633,
0.6404715776443481,
0.14953002333641052,
-0.1157626286149025,
-0.6638739109039307,
-0.3050025701522827,
-0.22766733169555664,
-0.2730346918106079,
-0.47116339206695557,
-0.31175196170806885,
0.2753325402736664,
-0.005308711435645819,
-0.02898433804512024,
-0.21107499301433563,
-0.8266577124595642,
0.3412226438522339,
0.4923606812953949,
0.3909755349159241,
0.6363202333450317,
-0.1609005331993103,
0.05487649142742157,
-0.08594316989183426,
-0.18661633133888245,
-0.6544686555862427,
0.6203488707542419,
0.06412122398614883,
0.6703248620033264,
-0.009022972546517849,
0.41491949558258057,
1.0030632019042969,
0.4614783525466919,
-0.9782208204269409,
0.5426955223083496,
-0.2489364594221115,
-0.5268474221229553,
-0.5445337891578674,
-0.48389336466789246,
-0.8282232284545898,
-0.4591638743877411,
-0.21049374341964722,
-0.7831910252571106,
0.04205024987459183,
0.012146337889134884,
-0.47231045365333557,
-0.01455559954047203,
-0.9016184210777283,
0.8738042712211609,
-0.7279431819915771,
0.04347403347492218,
-0.5858306288719177,
-0.7044073939323425,
0.5008541941642761,
0.0190731231123209,
0.14697127044200897,
-0.40439802408218384,
-0.057105232030153275,
0.5770643949508667,
-0.011755140498280525,
0.5276225209236145,
-0.20851002633571625,
0.3763488531112671,
0.3869743347167969,
0.06659144163131714,
0.12369677424430847,
-0.07406798750162125,
-0.18182338774204254,
-0.09574058651924133,
0.04971719905734062,
-0.35709625482559204,
-0.6647477149963379,
0.7566878199577332,
-0.6579061150550842,
-0.6376314163208008,
-0.21466383337974548,
-0.6265158653259277,
-0.287562757730484,
0.2592041790485382,
-0.008897900581359863,
0.23116405308246613,
-0.4288661777973175,
0.1200433075428009,
0.4283248782157898,
-0.21867302060127258,
0.19784848392009735,
0.7884812951087952,
0.3561377227306366,
-0.35478368401527405,
0.8968000411987305,
0.00920086819678545,
0.19707846641540527,
0.27307549118995667,
0.08947571367025375,
-0.0046075452119112015,
-0.7438784837722778,
-0.3664405047893524,
-0.0006594387232325971,
-0.44664642214775085,
0.13764971494674683,
-0.5507622957229614,
-0.04813402146100998,
-0.12653975188732147,
0.1294902265071869,
0.12289640307426453,
-0.5828322172164917,
-0.1573946475982666,
0.27086952328681946,
0.21839632093906403,
0.30748409032821655,
0.09716261923313141,
0.20700587332248688,
-0.7519355416297913,
0.4495375454425812,
0.48425742983818054,
0.24433065950870514,
-0.23472993075847626,
-0.04580517113208771,
-0.14580316841602325,
0.10956346988677979,
-0.7286115288734436,
-0.6759412884712219,
0.28869011998176575,
0.44051867723464966,
0.6843532919883728,
0.5013973116874695,
0.36092767119407654,
0.4085507094860077,
-0.23830673098564148,
0.8292569518089294,
0.10909637063741684,
-0.8115363717079163,
0.6560841798782349,
0.1856253743171692,
0.36184927821159363,
0.8404103517532349,
0.4141727387905121,
-0.5461486577987671,
-0.5988163352012634,
-0.5172858238220215,
-0.635857343673706,
0.5757336020469666,
0.0805981457233429,
0.1597338169813156,
-0.3252948522567749,
0.13769608736038208,
-0.17726926505565643,
-0.14994847774505615,
-0.2015238255262375,
0.09009376913309097,
-0.22163079679012299,
-0.5425912141799927,
0.17673435807228088,
0.11096547544002533,
-0.05106418579816818,
-0.023927148431539536,
0.5848674774169922,
-0.24585427343845367,
0.4670898914337158,
0.39641377329826355,
-0.16738882660865784,
-0.43558844923973083,
0.13272389769554138,
0.5214843153953552,
0.4486498534679413,
-0.3776642084121704,
0.14545224606990814,
0.40563422441482544,
-0.49654433131217957,
-0.2536594867706299,
0.2543680965900421,
0.3327893316745758,
-0.08880608528852463,
0.285709023475647,
0.4434184432029724,
0.0629379153251648,
-1.307914137840271,
0.6113139986991882,
-0.5114822387695312,
0.10428258776664734,
-0.5868123173713684,
0.5508814454078674,
0.1938854455947876,
0.38836774230003357,
0.29703575372695923,
0.3106094002723694,
0.29169970750808716,
-0.8189931511878967,
0.48652371764183044,
0.5165538191795349,
-0.9506021738052368,
0.00603259215131402,
0.6028006076812744,
0.13756221532821655,
-0.8583951592445374,
0.9103406071662903,
-0.21363253891468048,
-0.3357025384902954,
0.45702531933784485,
0.1562732309103012,
0.840167224407196,
-0.27904215455055237,
0.1022941842675209,
-0.06782016158103943,
0.2165149301290512,
0.07337585836648941,
0.28765496611595154,
-0.30048495531082153,
-0.5487917065620422,
-0.27503859996795654,
-0.29345279932022095,
-0.44360479712486267,
-0.02153117023408413,
-0.700291097164154,
0.10143047571182251,
-0.29259997606277466,
-0.3990135192871094,
0.22565899789333344,
0.1797388345003128,
-0.4050399959087372,
0.37404608726501465,
0.45107516646385193,
0.7901568412780762,
-0.7507660388946533,
0.642609715461731,
0.3966699540615082,
-0.41702333092689514,
0.027780845761299133,
0.3858514130115509,
-0.09472780674695969,
-0.7994009256362915,
0.4890630841255188,
0.232126384973526,
-0.07598945498466492,
-0.2062806338071823,
-0.23221401870250702,
-0.27452728152275085,
1.109951138496399,
0.1593235731124878,
-0.014919545501470566,
0.02854677475988865,
-0.025993211194872856,
0.8771927356719971,
-0.37518349289894104,
0.505932092666626,
0.4359564483165741,
0.5164141654968262,
0.014392217621207237,
-0.8420743346214294,
-0.030050579458475113,
-0.46581774950027466,
-0.3290252387523651,
0.21562586724758148,
-0.6648270487785339,
0.28564584255218506,
-0.03504016250371933,
-0.28161460161209106,
0.12479235231876373,
0.7292612791061401,
0.3439851999282837,
0.8285167813301086,
0.9807502627372742,
0.4669044613838196,
1.0819649696350098,
0.07308939099311829,
0.82330322265625,
-0.5707328915596008,
0.003582453355193138,
0.6944299340248108,
0.004758584313094616,
0.598882257938385,
0.17582884430885315,
0.21596944332122803,
0.801016092300415,
0.3218856155872345,
0.32559409737586975,
0.5137861371040344,
0.4105050563812256,
-0.539205014705658,
-0.20633935928344727,
-0.34169065952301025,
0.024315735325217247,
0.22720691561698914,
0.7854788899421692,
-0.3683601915836334,
-0.16898521780967712,
0.22472214698791504,
-0.07659060508012772,
0.12091107666492462,
-0.0612567774951458,
0.7757200598716736,
0.025078434497117996,
-0.8887311816215515,
0.5818068385124207,
-0.08723831176757812,
0.7289039492607117,
-0.7870888113975525,
0.04055120423436165,
0.09224309772253036,
0.4153282046318054,
-0.06017299368977547,
-0.8429046273231506,
0.49149230122566223,
0.015436948277056217,
-0.053191374987363815,
0.2715393602848053,
0.8585227131843567,
-0.3701081871986389,
-0.3405834138393402,
0.3141159117221832,
0.5179880857467651,
0.5816876292228699,
-0.21634353697299957,
-0.9833417534828186,
-0.060660962015390396,
-0.19026361405849457,
-0.16882403194904327,
0.026772694662213326,
0.7623814940452576,
-0.5579192042350769,
0.8024528622627258,
0.43116146326065063,
0.07174184173345566,
-0.0680965855717659,
-0.13822844624519348,
0.5498505234718323,
-0.5092342495918274,
-0.3486142158508301,
-0.640328049659729,
0.2558850646018982,
-0.3928290009498596,
-0.7168756127357483,
0.4451426863670349,
0.370855450630188,
0.27923792600631714,
0.18896271288394928,
0.5559259057044983,
-0.11604592949151993,
0.05000023916363716,
-0.3741997182369232,
0.5460005402565002,
-0.4779340624809265,
0.041416555643081665,
0.1567467749118805,
-0.384725958108902,
-0.28041282296180725,
0.443466454744339,
-0.6514898538589478,
0.15581077337265015,
0.7223864197731018,
0.8346719145774841,
-0.13300982117652893,
0.32305434346199036,
0.2418864667415619,
0.07198386639356613,
0.23094211518764496,
1.0514914989471436,
0.7479791641235352,
-0.04588308557868004,
0.7833142876625061,
-0.2611179053783417,
-0.5780307054519653,
-0.5391062498092651,
-0.6565067172050476,
-0.7160158753395081,
-0.43894442915916443,
-0.3855678141117096,
-0.0319160558283329,
0.3908340632915497,
0.6601152420043945,
0.550815224647522,
-0.7745929956436157,
0.1973051130771637,
0.009381857700645924,
-0.05261465162038803,
-0.5882864594459534,
-0.34775954484939575,
0.6226850152015686,
-0.2869894802570343,
-0.6040928959846497,
0.24261189997196198,
0.40941372513771057,
-0.14484356343746185,
-0.41982799768447876,
-0.05957789719104767,
0.05225758254528046,
-0.03160082548856735,
0.38883137702941895,
0.23134729266166687,
-0.528311550617218,
-0.4853701591491699,
-0.13893860578536987,
-0.33665239810943604,
0.043241169303655624,
0.37328001856803894,
-0.6184565424919128,
0.6878098845481873,
0.6793524622917175,
0.4162885546684265,
0.638597309589386,
0.10115458816289902,
0.20340876281261444,
-0.07138815522193909,
-0.027341162785887718,
0.5363859534263611,
0.08446867018938065,
0.35446056723594666,
-0.6944162845611572,
0.29788899421691895,
0.2087162733078003,
-0.7624016404151917,
-0.32457366585731506,
-0.0562153160572052,
-1.258653998374939,
-0.34785571694374084,
0.5646884441375732,
0.018230920657515526,
-0.39508721232414246,
-0.6246777176856995,
-0.6123312711715698,
0.4158399999141693,
-0.4081873595714569,
1.231927752494812,
0.5735044479370117,
-0.6343489289283752,
0.11684103310108185,
-1.0641818046569824,
0.45722752809524536,
0.44478079676628113,
-0.8526695370674133,
-0.11670254170894623,
0.4120998978614807,
0.28177839517593384,
0.3709928095340729,
0.8135728240013123,
-0.3494681417942047,
0.6236853003501892,
-0.34613269567489624,
0.08126191794872284,
-0.21097241342067719,
0.3899392783641815,
-0.03369584679603577,
0.10451766103506088,
-0.26336470246315,
-0.26627299189567566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18540v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18540v1
|
Learning diverse attacks on large language models for robust red-teaming and safety tuning
| 2024-05-28T19:16:17 | 2024-05-28T19:16:17 |
Seanie Lee, Minsu Kim, Lynn Cherif, David Dobre, Juho Lee, Sung Ju Hwang, Kenji Kawaguchi, Gauthier Gidel, Yoshua Bengio, Nikolay Malkin, Moksh Jain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Red-teaming, or identifying prompts that elicit harmful responses, is a
critical step in ensuring the safe and responsible deployment of large language
models (LLMs). Developing effective protection against many modes of attack
prompts requires discovering diverse attacks. Automated red-teaming typically
uses reinforcement learning to fine-tune an attacker language model to generate
prompts that elicit undesirable responses from a target LLM, as measured, for
example, by an auxiliary toxicity classifier. We show that even with explicit
regularization to favor novelty and diversity, existing approaches suffer from
mode collapse or fail to generate effective attacks. As a flexible and
probabilistically principled alternative, we propose to use GFlowNet
fine-tuning, followed by a secondary smoothing phase, to train the attacker
model to generate diverse and effective attack prompts. We find that the
attacks generated by our method are effective against a wide range of target
LLMs, both with and without safety tuning, and transfer well between target
LLMs. Finally, we demonstrate that models safety-tuned using a dataset of
red-teaming prompts generated by our method are robust to attacks from other
RL-based red-teaming approaches.
|
[
-0.46188458800315857,
-1.0394395589828491,
0.1510373055934906,
0.16069655120372772,
-0.05516449734568596,
0.20614585280418396,
-0.32277345657348633,
-0.5709491968154907,
0.035454124212265015,
0.5005771517753601,
-0.8057651519775391,
-0.5440398454666138,
-0.7037824988365173,
0.17261752486228943,
-0.29261741042137146,
1.3527004718780518,
0.18285691738128662,
-0.12098238617181778,
0.5000497102737427,
-0.18734055757522583,
-0.6325035691261292,
-0.37856167554855347,
-1.0460983514785767,
-0.08636367321014404,
0.7211934328079224,
0.3858467936515808,
0.5962689518928528,
0.4246392250061035,
0.5178607702255249,
0.3869694769382477,
-0.049309927970170975,
0.18685027956962585,
-0.662882387638092,
0.49636414647102356,
-0.24791567027568817,
-0.37251409888267517,
-0.0678497850894928,
-0.14587843418121338,
0.48337849974632263,
0.34368643164634705,
-0.1400458663702011,
-0.0636044591665268,
0.0018344586715102196,
0.3850606083869934,
-0.688998281955719,
-0.1481872797012329,
-1.3358358144760132,
0.18397538363933563,
-0.03551472723484039,
-0.11867214739322662,
-0.660251796245575,
-0.050672657787799835,
-0.07067131251096725,
-0.36182793974876404,
0.17217862606048584,
0.12445377558469772,
0.8282746076583862,
0.46534350514411926,
-0.3183767795562744,
-0.09414547681808472,
-0.4564530551433563,
0.8510646224021912,
-0.38780173659324646,
-0.0693540871143341,
0.07834126800298691,
0.6970290541648865,
-0.48127511143684387,
-0.3251807689666748,
-0.19871865212917328,
-0.2131832242012024,
-0.1470024436712265,
0.06622155010700226,
-0.41717806458473206,
0.30498331785202026,
0.18555307388305664,
-0.08518730849027634,
-0.6554921865463257,
0.625694990158081,
-0.32318177819252014,
-0.26142576336860657,
0.7387343049049377,
0.3656562864780426,
0.5244529843330383,
0.28050345182418823,
-0.622998058795929,
-0.21747899055480957,
-0.45173001289367676,
0.016839921474456787,
0.5356387495994568,
0.707602858543396,
-0.43378308415412903,
0.13329410552978516,
-0.30512410402297974,
0.7288005948066711,
0.1113157793879509,
0.08047673851251602,
-0.12477470934391022,
-0.3303104341030121,
-0.29309988021850586,
-0.23008708655834198,
0.8833259344100952,
0.26063239574432373,
0.28954100608825684,
-0.28630247712135315,
-0.44945478439331055,
0.16317017376422882,
0.524278998374939,
-0.6384588479995728,
-0.44823765754699707,
0.3207635283470154,
-0.08755600452423096,
-0.6435283422470093,
-0.055060748010873795,
-0.8084468245506287,
-0.4850963056087494,
0.0061390092596411705,
0.20414774119853973,
-0.3153461813926697,
-0.19019797444343567,
0.09002844989299774,
-0.25324127078056335,
0.15834704041481018,
0.31901803612709045,
-1.034749984741211,
0.24639852344989777,
0.6590760350227356,
0.6734817624092102,
-0.45917177200317383,
-0.41243964433670044,
-1.1500753164291382,
0.0007128234719857574,
-0.1602514237165451,
0.5781376957893372,
-0.5688816905021667,
-0.25145989656448364,
-0.008390156552195549,
-0.08181095868349075,
-0.12278991937637329,
-0.549072802066803,
0.29031652212142944,
-0.7540473937988281,
-0.07850362360477448,
0.12225417792797089,
-0.199390709400177,
-0.13537342846393585,
0.5383456349372864,
-0.5789341926574707,
0.36950889229774475,
-0.13334164023399353,
-0.7110951542854309,
0.4007447361946106,
-0.6728242039680481,
-0.36930051445961,
0.20150604844093323,
-0.16852857172489166,
-0.6251196265220642,
-0.04132290557026863,
0.12008650600910187,
0.5500681400299072,
0.02782091498374939,
0.07050080597400665,
-0.4254436194896698,
0.02037573978304863,
0.08567547798156738,
-0.24659554660320282,
0.8595131039619446,
0.31943392753601074,
-0.3159169554710388,
0.8519852161407471,
-0.4273184835910797,
0.23696239292621613,
0.10165403038263321,
-0.4296770691871643,
-0.0480697825551033,
-0.08839025348424911,
-0.0007939606439322233,
0.06628212332725525,
-0.10367196798324585,
-0.31723546981811523,
-0.0482533760368824,
-0.4401354491710663,
0.40860292315483093,
0.758622407913208,
0.2893249988555908,
0.25546637177467346,
-0.5122187733650208,
0.7018798589706421,
-0.006918912287801504,
0.34543704986572266,
0.031119752675294876,
-0.42474353313446045,
-0.37092530727386475,
-0.5225924849510193,
0.16044791042804718,
0.7509810328483582,
-0.7783029675483704,
0.2852948009967804,
0.10204525291919708,
-0.7009636759757996,
-0.3003670573234558,
0.23686771094799042,
0.49654537439346313,
0.5256609916687012,
0.5570976138114929,
-0.0024815902579575777,
-0.5444772839546204,
-0.8696121573448181,
-0.42258647084236145,
-0.1439635306596756,
0.0701662003993988,
0.3563426733016968,
0.6276954412460327,
-0.6127669215202332,
0.5924664735794067,
-0.18047933280467987,
-0.07283143699169159,
-0.34895822405815125,
0.30031460523605347,
-0.023143934085965157,
0.624477207660675,
0.659124493598938,
-0.7914540767669678,
-0.735621988773346,
0.1015392541885376,
-0.4919339418411255,
0.020622840151190758,
-0.39379945397377014,
-0.09711968153715134,
0.27237316966056824,
0.5725418925285339,
-0.12466510385274887,
-0.06052669137716293,
0.816066563129425,
-0.41813838481903076,
0.5766606330871582,
-0.03259921073913574,
0.02649480663239956,
-0.8703285455703735,
-0.14797411859035492,
0.18478570878505707,
-0.2693702280521393,
-0.8289306163787842,
0.5111387968063354,
0.0268779918551445,
-0.09613104164600372,
-0.7771666049957275,
0.6469787955284119,
-0.18936005234718323,
0.28815582394599915,
-0.20454011857509613,
-0.19641193747520447,
-0.3897545039653778,
0.4230877757072449,
-0.04406389221549034,
0.7029550075531006,
0.6175357699394226,
-0.7052608728408813,
0.3303373157978058,
-0.13749167323112488,
-0.09320071339607239,
0.30135074257850647,
-0.9168233275413513,
0.07051973044872284,
-0.042821139097213745,
0.18590524792671204,
-0.8251043558120728,
-0.4757785201072693,
0.4674089252948761,
-0.36736252903938293,
0.5599215626716614,
-0.39386168122291565,
-0.06538797169923782,
0.02127940021455288,
-0.2803944945335388,
0.5422019958496094,
0.49223071336746216,
-0.5623621940612793,
0.3499247431755066,
0.5583031177520752,
-0.13530400395393372,
-0.7457495331764221,
-0.3843526840209961,
0.03079480491578579,
-0.6244544982910156,
-0.7068535089492798,
0.20104186236858368,
-0.09412690997123718,
-0.3598705232143402,
-0.3814742863178253,
0.0713646188378334,
-0.2450198531150818,
0.9031224846839905,
0.22496837377548218,
0.0873229056596756,
0.08587048202753067,
-0.15789467096328735,
-0.09416124224662781,
-0.1039881706237793,
0.12790030241012573,
-0.2640628516674042,
0.5249242186546326,
-0.21829941868782043,
-0.2937518358230591,
-0.3016740083694458,
0.47925910353660583,
0.5316003561019897,
-0.11890316009521484,
0.7989652156829834,
0.7222378253936768,
-0.2448020875453949,
-0.5876455307006836,
-0.21785438060760498,
-0.5827632546424866,
-0.5238456726074219,
0.6823639273643494,
0.026711346581578255,
-1.33225417137146,
0.49124884605407715,
0.08020656555891037,
0.40465205907821655,
0.39670923352241516,
0.5408628582954407,
-0.17351949214935303,
1.00608491897583,
0.6690641641616821,
-0.13894765079021454,
0.5640239119529724,
0.09509854763746262,
-0.27391481399536133,
-0.3703352212905884,
0.03505735099315643,
-0.6021603941917419,
-0.38389426469802856,
-0.7776912450790405,
-0.08076421916484833,
0.5010427236557007,
0.008900927379727364,
-0.5899872779846191,
0.10777710378170013,
-0.4298900365829468,
0.7284727096557617,
0.3996638059616089,
0.0840175673365593,
-0.11392892897129059,
-0.04085767641663551,
-0.17219795286655426,
0.09123269468545914,
-0.7181645035743713,
-0.13989438116550446,
0.8062623143196106,
0.6446067690849304,
0.8478015661239624,
0.30788445472717285,
0.8763906359672546,
0.32013893127441406,
0.16796278953552246,
-0.6696738600730896,
0.32464364171028137,
-0.0011912975460290909,
-0.48856231570243835,
-0.5022586584091187,
-0.7406668066978455,
-1.1231340169906616,
0.24099241197109222,
-0.5427869558334351,
-0.6571237444877625,
-0.29987311363220215,
0.37669846415519714,
-0.6034706830978394,
0.3715999722480774,
-0.7751891016960144,
0.8797370195388794,
-0.3877982199192047,
-0.11628594994544983,
-0.1783181130886078,
-0.7273818850517273,
0.5636755228042603,
-0.10300622880458832,
0.176117405295372,
0.04462387412786484,
0.0095444330945611,
0.5146878957748413,
-0.12725941836833954,
1.254559874534607,
-0.25198155641555786,
-0.07569155842065811,
-0.08789178729057312,
0.20290464162826538,
0.7317732572555542,
0.3707699775695801,
0.26054418087005615,
0.1090642586350441,
-0.46373987197875977,
-0.5292682647705078,
-0.4182126224040985,
0.5375068187713623,
-0.7913818955421448,
-0.7472717761993408,
-0.19500835239887238,
-0.610569179058075,
-0.2708992063999176,
0.22955670952796936,
0.2588438093662262,
0.03788042068481445,
-0.06312741339206696,
0.09442701935768127,
0.9935566782951355,
-0.5144303441047668,
0.5372025966644287,
0.48577168583869934,
0.1380043625831604,
-0.4946313500404358,
0.8489605188369751,
-0.2722140848636627,
0.6774784326553345,
0.3020331561565399,
0.11124960333108902,
-0.12775681912899017,
-0.986537754535675,
-0.3072352409362793,
-0.01381310448050499,
-0.5030307173728943,
-0.4479564428329468,
-0.456581711769104,
-0.193328857421875,
-0.1082395538687706,
-0.21872860193252563,
-0.27416568994522095,
0.02905106730759144,
-0.06193355843424797,
-0.027595549821853638,
0.4274745583534241,
0.5399307012557983,
-0.009507672861218452,
0.2007610946893692,
-0.925752580165863,
0.08113771677017212,
0.6618483066558838,
0.2238101065158844,
-0.19451399147510529,
-0.4441165626049042,
-0.1468920111656189,
0.10377097129821777,
-0.13528212904930115,
-0.8273895382881165,
0.4827830195426941,
0.146669402718544,
0.6962480545043945,
0.06736855208873749,
0.2847699820995331,
0.1294376403093338,
-0.38972312211990356,
0.633891761302948,
0.36533528566360474,
-0.6316816210746765,
0.7041550278663635,
-0.7355671525001526,
0.17623743414878845,
0.6648915410041809,
0.3585532605648041,
-0.3994917571544647,
-0.5439783930778503,
-0.6106399893760681,
-0.9404089450836182,
0.5462905168533325,
-0.08876729011535645,
0.062419500201940536,
-0.2292146384716034,
0.06011838838458061,
0.009707939811050892,
0.07668059319257736,
-0.8917763233184814,
-0.38996148109436035,
-0.004457157105207443,
-0.1293528974056244,
0.09160425513982773,
-0.06940620392560959,
-0.5045133829116821,
0.13782012462615967,
0.6613849401473999,
-0.37332430481910706,
-0.07726961374282837,
-0.20049019157886505,
-0.14471769332885742,
-0.0723019689321518,
0.4743395447731018,
0.9471370577812195,
0.03340759128332138,
0.0771222785115242,
0.12675955891609192,
0.555199921131134,
-0.2988852262496948,
0.15119421482086182,
-0.12386560440063477,
-0.2770068347454071,
-0.3248201906681061,
0.3711397349834442,
0.8995761871337891,
0.22459402680397034,
-0.6192898750305176,
0.24491311609745026,
-0.36662599444389343,
-0.3757767379283905,
0.09165681153535843,
0.673306941986084,
-0.1911969780921936,
0.36680805683135986,
0.02681807614862919,
0.3947378993034363,
-0.14884069561958313,
-0.3225676417350769,
0.3575987219810486,
0.9550455212593079,
-0.5421379208564758,
-0.11011239886283875,
0.4584807753562927,
0.39766576886177063,
-0.24995540082454681,
0.3387838900089264,
-0.2785818576812744,
-0.6345276832580566,
0.7888076305389404,
0.45631006360054016,
0.97293621301651,
-0.07237792760133743,
0.19237114489078522,
0.393216997385025,
0.4320361614227295,
-0.018855366855859756,
0.06161685660481453,
0.20656727254390717,
-0.6980748772621155,
-0.36013174057006836,
-0.47995632886886597,
-0.5678256154060364,
0.1978973150253296,
-0.48336362838745117,
0.1645340770483017,
-0.8683304786682129,
0.0013022483326494694,
-0.22967803478240967,
-0.03901147097349167,
-0.47858959436416626,
0.09097859263420105,
0.23411241173744202,
0.8129890561103821,
-0.9138877391815186,
0.6666932106018066,
0.8322272896766663,
-0.2993343770503998,
-0.7904065251350403,
0.00636292202398181,
0.1925232708454132,
-0.6665955185890198,
0.6766225099563599,
0.03941188007593155,
-0.07923838496208191,
-0.15616384148597717,
-0.5986411571502686,
-0.5658096075057983,
0.8238490223884583,
0.4895351231098175,
-0.680825412273407,
0.1364893764257431,
-0.09202934801578522,
0.3190561532974243,
-0.2852814495563507,
0.15662707388401031,
0.2902986705303192,
0.4177098870277405,
-0.0762423425912857,
-1.035404086112976,
0.09705810248851776,
-0.05651896446943283,
-0.20223577320575714,
0.20811261236667633,
-0.7313271760940552,
0.9358812570571899,
-0.33247634768486023,
-0.4370090365409851,
-0.3078021705150604,
0.6107662320137024,
0.4204481542110443,
-0.06334826350212097,
0.6870859861373901,
0.394020140171051,
0.9419679045677185,
-0.01747823692858219,
0.9440842866897583,
-0.10695949196815491,
0.06385885924100876,
1.2001105546951294,
0.16096194088459015,
0.7165922522544861,
0.2758755385875702,
0.23489271104335785,
0.19034530222415924,
0.46270376443862915,
-0.07129248231649399,
0.5627557635307312,
0.4684460759162903,
-0.23601296544075012,
-0.4986521899700165,
0.06434468924999237,
-0.23992832005023956,
0.24142570793628693,
0.29652538895606995,
-0.22110198438167572,
-0.4028846025466919,
-0.13389551639556885,
0.09606947004795074,
0.2126161903142929,
-0.4530796408653259,
0.9417029023170471,
-0.09993667900562286,
-0.7311021089553833,
0.8066869974136353,
0.04356313869357109,
1.2470760345458984,
-0.6928972005844116,
0.20187391340732574,
-0.10283996909856796,
-0.007425302639603615,
-0.25309550762176514,
-0.617691159248352,
0.3739010989665985,
0.0056924521923065186,
-0.36354875564575195,
-0.01815289817750454,
0.6252263188362122,
-0.44616031646728516,
-0.025842012837529182,
0.30758169293403625,
0.19577986001968384,
-0.3106350600719452,
0.1990058720111847,
-0.8797085285186768,
0.10377968847751617,
0.21363499760627747,
0.10550403594970703,
0.7450804114341736,
0.34403911232948303,
-0.011337348259985447,
0.8372772336006165,
0.47621312737464905,
0.1916227638721466,
0.0994788333773613,
-0.05809180065989494,
0.7513671517372131,
-0.40846800804138184,
-0.5341311693191528,
-1.036329984664917,
0.7126470804214478,
-0.13389995694160461,
-0.33446282148361206,
0.4846402406692505,
0.045073214918375015,
0.939173698425293,
-0.10162302851676941,
0.947540819644928,
0.3772493600845337,
0.32836073637008667,
-0.6577150821685791,
0.912871778011322,
-0.30619800090789795,
0.3471437394618988,
-0.29590940475463867,
-0.3660013675689697,
-0.5338115096092224,
0.5089429616928101,
-0.08224906772375107,
0.005934597924351692,
0.33798494935035706,
0.8618367910385132,
0.06230670586228371,
-0.10352173447608948,
0.2185402810573578,
0.09617117047309875,
0.7442348599433899,
0.6421285271644592,
0.8060346245765686,
-0.1610628366470337,
0.6005069613456726,
0.030005548149347305,
-0.3053615689277649,
-0.16502012312412262,
-1.0855785608291626,
-1.1985225677490234,
-0.29656782746315,
-0.4657466411590576,
-0.2982696294784546,
0.2759150564670563,
1.146427035331726,
0.689371645450592,
-1.1135594844818115,
0.01447691023349762,
-0.17938676476478577,
0.2755865752696991,
-0.13180917501449585,
-0.19630523025989532,
-0.1799647957086563,
-1.0083647966384888,
-0.4069940447807312,
0.6438308954238892,
0.06899861246347427,
0.16166183352470398,
-0.13995157182216644,
-0.289238303899765,
0.09155664592981339,
-0.15289375185966492,
0.21292950212955475,
0.6708363890647888,
-0.5587908625602722,
-0.5832078456878662,
-0.13663554191589355,
-0.18290603160858154,
-0.34207141399383545,
0.385060578584671,
-0.5290251970291138,
0.20676425099372864,
0.3900049924850464,
1.0637671947479248,
-0.24939946830272675,
-0.12125995010137558,
0.7341200113296509,
-1.059084415435791,
0.07289391756057739,
0.471585750579834,
0.2879914939403534,
0.11867225170135498,
-0.3387715816497803,
0.40706443786621094,
0.02056807652115822,
-0.5496907830238342,
-0.9313780665397644,
0.5751742124557495,
-0.7772287726402283,
-0.41171467304229736,
1.386679768562317,
-0.12073992937803268,
-0.08496572822332382,
-0.33310580253601074,
-0.16118274629116058,
-0.007242945022881031,
-0.5321144461631775,
0.9262934327125549,
0.22348828613758087,
0.03213293105363846,
0.07793094217777252,
-0.23363500833511353,
0.9412986040115356,
0.552803099155426,
-0.8538786172866821,
0.11555363982915878,
0.4586794972419739,
0.296513170003891,
0.034490808844566345,
0.0912790596485138,
0.2513531446456909,
0.48090752959251404,
-0.1561342030763626,
-0.41191527247428894,
-0.18949945271015167,
-0.6351871490478516,
-0.5265242457389832,
0.5348221659660339,
0.1535515934228897,
-0.11839306354522705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00050v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00050v2
|
An Empirical Analysis on Large Language Models in Debate Evaluation
| 2024-05-28T18:34:53 | 2024-06-04T14:51:25 |
Xinyi Liu, Pinxin Liu, Hangfeng He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we investigate the capabilities and inherent biases of
advanced large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in the context
of debate evaluation. We discover that LLM's performance exceeds humans and
surpasses the performance of state-of-the-art methods fine-tuned on extensive
datasets in debate evaluation. We additionally explore and analyze biases
present in LLMs, including positional bias, lexical bias, order bias, which may
affect their evaluative judgments. Our findings reveal a consistent bias in
both GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 towards the second candidate response presented,
attributed to prompt design. We also uncover lexical biases in both GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, especially when label sets carry connotations such as numerical or
sequential, highlighting the critical need for careful label verbalizer
selection in prompt design. Additionally, our analysis indicates a tendency of
both models to favor the debate's concluding side as the winner, suggesting an
end-of-discussion bias.
|
[
-0.7243446111679077,
-0.9406508803367615,
0.8816447854042053,
0.17631366848945618,
-0.15663152933120728,
0.13719721138477325,
-0.445292204618454,
-0.37978556752204895,
-0.03793533891439438,
0.41070500016212463,
-0.24078653752803802,
-0.20920775830745697,
-0.6708699464797974,
0.24792902171611786,
-0.19689705967903137,
1.120134711265564,
-0.0031032937113195658,
0.2871948182582855,
-0.08062414079904556,
-0.15217354893684387,
-0.533805251121521,
-0.703223705291748,
-0.7399107217788696,
-0.5217102766036987,
0.7919538617134094,
0.2139735370874405,
0.8754109740257263,
0.3177136778831482,
0.23328284919261932,
0.3548673987388611,
-0.4545041024684906,
-0.29612085223197937,
-0.4260355234146118,
0.2153337448835373,
-0.3879636824131012,
-0.27183419466018677,
-0.4641517102718353,
0.3524194061756134,
0.7345675230026245,
0.5710120797157288,
-0.05033542588353157,
-0.0603904202580452,
-0.028949599713087082,
0.6659486889839172,
-0.34584155678749084,
-0.06409062445163727,
-0.8337430357933044,
-0.08866295963525772,
-0.39333999156951904,
-0.03633398935198784,
-0.49040380120277405,
-0.5443549156188965,
0.5432421565055847,
-0.3408449590206146,
0.09497150778770447,
0.20300863683223724,
0.8873721361160278,
-0.04411904513835907,
-0.4272992014884949,
-0.47551965713500977,
-0.4364224672317505,
0.5679894089698792,
-0.9228518009185791,
0.29040253162384033,
0.052515167742967606,
0.12384485453367233,
-0.23656776547431946,
-0.6608492136001587,
-0.5568027496337891,
-0.4986988604068756,
0.1691935807466507,
0.11025501042604446,
-0.25682249665260315,
0.36665064096450806,
0.44499465823173523,
0.2816166579723358,
-0.4343239665031433,
0.6467410326004028,
-0.28152766823768616,
0.08800145983695984,
0.49904966354370117,
0.13727585971355438,
0.059694189578294754,
-0.21927213668823242,
-0.31040602922439575,
0.003631835337728262,
-0.6969311833381653,
-0.15805652737617493,
0.6753366589546204,
0.1732199788093567,
0.23076219856739044,
0.5081532597541809,
-0.12817668914794922,
0.719940185546875,
0.06903927773237228,
0.28167030215263367,
0.10777627676725388,
-0.3962475657463074,
-0.26966872811317444,
-0.14707450568675995,
1.1676613092422485,
0.36414051055908203,
0.19461196660995483,
0.10491464287042618,
-0.25300902128219604,
0.07563454657793045,
0.0891314372420311,
-0.8657528758049011,
-0.19034366309642792,
0.1259392648935318,
-0.35814958810806274,
-0.20570108294487,
-0.23048709332942963,
-0.9071242213249207,
-0.5480625033378601,
-0.27233564853668213,
0.2816295325756073,
0.06965865939855576,
-0.14009889960289001,
0.15853990614414215,
-0.24160753190517426,
0.1778864562511444,
0.28978389501571655,
-0.7771425247192383,
0.34247633814811707,
0.911607563495636,
0.6530160903930664,
-0.29807886481285095,
-0.06965476274490356,
-0.32674649357795715,
-0.2826496660709381,
-0.46297964453697205,
0.9801883697509766,
-0.9550681114196777,
-0.5032109618186951,
0.021218840032815933,
-0.10433129966259003,
-0.09957993030548096,
-0.5314573645591736,
1.0784962177276611,
-0.6862945556640625,
0.5317383408546448,
-0.7051520943641663,
-0.7726055979728699,
-0.1507865935564041,
0.2915973961353302,
-0.8979767560958862,
0.6825117468833923,
-0.23189102113246918,
-1.0518920421600342,
0.5008026361465454,
-0.8398962616920471,
-0.1284257024526596,
0.06434748321771622,
-0.457187682390213,
-0.3862875699996948,
0.13113026320934296,
0.19365906715393066,
0.2728821039199829,
-0.8123542070388794,
0.5351737141609192,
-0.5018249750137329,
-0.2879899740219116,
0.5991983413696289,
-0.6006813645362854,
0.6427960395812988,
0.20320729911327362,
-0.5813040137290955,
0.31645143032073975,
-0.5059755444526672,
-0.07429865002632141,
0.1729842722415924,
-0.37281468510627747,
-0.29023927450180054,
0.0940154567360878,
-0.1893472522497177,
0.25046178698539734,
-0.0037812411319464445,
-0.5406405925750732,
0.22969557344913483,
-0.3340992331504822,
0.518514096736908,
0.9733020067214966,
-0.07002303749322891,
0.32479777932167053,
-0.05620861425995827,
0.7047773599624634,
-0.36080560088157654,
-0.12887202203273773,
-0.03661172091960907,
-0.5915571451187134,
-0.6903522610664368,
0.049365583807229996,
0.6047006845474243,
0.390756756067276,
-0.5136726498603821,
-0.13399235904216766,
-0.27886125445365906,
-0.25239720940589905,
-0.3782080113887787,
-0.09660130739212036,
0.5164967775344849,
0.2841658890247345,
-0.045099884271621704,
-0.12782947719097137,
-0.4934891164302826,
-1.277025580406189,
-0.4814707338809967,
-0.3455738425254822,
-0.032606158405542374,
0.46165984869003296,
0.5032289028167725,
0.0646621361374855,
0.8983339071273804,
-0.35002800822257996,
0.34224697947502136,
-0.2973199188709259,
0.36309096217155457,
0.1930377185344696,
0.057099808007478714,
0.3433493673801422,
-0.4027642011642456,
-0.2234395295381546,
0.009828206151723862,
-0.47933173179626465,
-0.5871331691741943,
-0.05483046919107437,
-0.08240910619497299,
0.29710251092910767,
0.12066604197025299,
-0.7336398959159851,
0.04632437601685524,
0.4015786647796631,
-0.5289492607116699,
0.7112773060798645,
0.13725771009922028,
0.14310795068740845,
-0.7576736211776733,
-0.0757790207862854,
0.2930438816547394,
0.1561277061700821,
-0.5799432992935181,
-0.035913385450839996,
-0.10803134739398956,
0.11688157171010971,
-0.12003576755523682,
0.7128938436508179,
-0.38206496834754944,
-0.06624025106430054,
-0.29043418169021606,
0.46731942892074585,
0.17885595560073853,
0.17120328545570374,
0.24981993436813354,
0.7841075658798218,
0.10422239452600479,
-0.2557666599750519,
0.3007729947566986,
0.08259725570678711,
-0.6074117422103882,
0.4531732499599457,
-0.9381487369537354,
0.47315752506256104,
0.07246800512075424,
0.5496478080749512,
-1.2211158275604248,
-0.12295342236757278,
0.18664495646953583,
-0.2993033230304718,
0.30931419134140015,
-0.07314343750476837,
-0.3866543471813202,
-0.6440396308898926,
-0.39461764693260193,
0.3793453574180603,
0.21487019956111908,
-0.41575732827186584,
0.045311421155929565,
0.4190921187400818,
-0.6957356333732605,
-0.5773009061813354,
-0.23272719979286194,
0.30575087666511536,
-0.5171558856964111,
-0.5434956550598145,
-0.045913297683000565,
0.027527015656232834,
-0.6943895816802979,
-0.2922222912311554,
0.15268678963184357,
0.11512415111064911,
-0.14833316206932068,
-0.0703633651137352,
0.30622702836990356,
-0.290359765291214,
0.18065719306468964,
-0.23456664383411407,
0.11890453100204468,
0.42297065258026123,
-0.07555553317070007,
0.41059088706970215,
-0.18525893986225128,
-0.395452618598938,
-0.12380345910787582,
0.2643144428730011,
0.44354650378227234,
0.03692891448736191,
0.3905263841152191,
0.30705636739730835,
-0.02873510867357254,
0.01268220879137516,
-1.041587233543396,
-0.050105880945920944,
-0.430046945810318,
0.6923089027404785,
-0.3918892443180084,
-1.1081914901733398,
0.4708477258682251,
0.08713183552026749,
0.23383770883083344,
0.4878622889518738,
0.8880155682563782,
0.32164067029953003,
1.024375557899475,
0.05415483936667442,
-0.09729810804128647,
0.3712230622768402,
0.08228027820587158,
0.19651851058006287,
-1.089085578918457,
-0.193419948220253,
-0.7873604893684387,
-0.3122466206550598,
-0.4648866057395935,
-0.425791472196579,
0.13801051676273346,
-0.2153528928756714,
-0.4179317355155945,
-0.18897487223148346,
-0.4179094731807709,
0.5104363560676575,
0.2050243765115738,
-0.1845964789390564,
0.07443730533123016,
-0.08829719573259354,
-0.27775195240974426,
-0.24031299352645874,
-0.6325138807296753,
-0.7532560229301453,
0.9657264947891235,
0.7831476926803589,
0.7587662935256958,
-0.011050843633711338,
0.15382207930088043,
0.08831536769866943,
0.5271899700164795,
-0.8227823376655579,
0.551795482635498,
0.3334263563156128,
-0.8190460801124573,
-0.3546023964881897,
-0.443109929561615,
-0.9712191820144653,
0.7953442931175232,
0.11549053341150284,
-0.6248437762260437,
0.11038053035736084,
-0.11916861683130264,
-0.31556156277656555,
0.29454943537712097,
-0.6378810405731201,
0.8300749063491821,
-0.2847663462162018,
-0.665911078453064,
-0.07062770426273346,
-0.43371516466140747,
0.7009144425392151,
-0.05721386894583702,
0.30990397930145264,
-0.04025848209857941,
-0.021581700071692467,
1.1437104940414429,
-0.28527551889419556,
0.6367694139480591,
-0.22976936399936676,
-0.496145099401474,
0.3898421823978424,
-0.06373798102140427,
0.6030579805374146,
0.06552541255950928,
-0.21907047927379608,
-0.09848698228597641,
-0.3718983829021454,
-0.14148977398872375,
-0.5506907105445862,
0.7243136763572693,
-0.7462567090988159,
-1.0976210832595825,
-0.47390860319137573,
-0.24971331655979156,
-0.35854312777519226,
-0.1153043881058693,
0.2418574094772339,
0.4081937372684479,
-0.5318133234977722,
0.13810689747333527,
0.5828269720077515,
-0.46875423192977905,
0.36032354831695557,
0.5405622720718384,
-0.22866082191467285,
-0.5371845960617065,
0.499905526638031,
0.17607811093330383,
0.40676477551460266,
-0.03829177841544151,
0.5589372515678406,
-0.6682754755020142,
-0.5266873836517334,
-0.5491977334022522,
0.18151959776878357,
-0.8528224229812622,
-0.021406397223472595,
-0.7228137850761414,
-0.12076861411333084,
-0.1286112666130066,
0.014477863907814026,
-0.31053853034973145,
-0.48268166184425354,
0.004760768264532089,
-0.39129701256752014,
0.1390715092420578,
1.1802908182144165,
0.2924205958843231,
0.30897659063339233,
-0.22630032896995544,
-0.09407804161310196,
0.5004290342330933,
0.2714916169643402,
0.162974551320076,
-0.7979215979576111,
0.039616722613573074,
-0.17564740777015686,
-0.6199203729629517,
-0.9679831266403198,
0.013340598903596401,
-0.19519412517547607,
0.6393086910247803,
0.31337618827819824,
-0.33478081226348877,
0.4082886576652527,
-0.7577998638153076,
1.112579345703125,
0.11447571218013763,
-0.8214066028594971,
0.2801360487937927,
-0.6364724636077881,
0.29197174310684204,
0.38039010763168335,
0.10819582641124725,
-0.35068416595458984,
-0.23772427439689636,
-0.6560230255126953,
-0.8120703101158142,
0.6175680756568909,
0.13896521925926208,
0.007253557443618774,
-0.2637491524219513,
0.08202940970659256,
0.15631717443466187,
0.2173301726579666,
-0.7682758569717407,
0.10834229737520218,
0.04729020595550537,
0.4461624026298523,
0.11974960565567017,
-0.6650435328483582,
-0.17898838222026825,
-0.13764412701129913,
0.6126869916915894,
0.006012035999447107,
0.009615669026970863,
-0.08394752442836761,
0.2255195528268814,
0.08435522764921188,
0.856132984161377,
0.9382845163345337,
0.9079297780990601,
0.027254318818449974,
0.05426078662276268,
0.3830266296863556,
-0.09104195237159729,
0.267958402633667,
0.1265108734369278,
-0.07617846876382828,
0.15365949273109436,
0.339781254529953,
1.2202128171920776,
0.3458378314971924,
-0.41450658440589905,
0.4953323304653168,
-0.07264019548892975,
-0.33434146642684937,
-0.00941547378897667,
-0.34302085638046265,
0.2600686848163605,
0.2499624490737915,
0.22723451256752014,
-0.23987087607383728,
0.36612609028816223,
-0.48427674174308777,
0.03864936903119087,
0.726603090763092,
-0.0669686570763588,
-0.46507489681243896,
0.7034033536911011,
0.3524353802204132,
-0.1482113003730774,
0.23784181475639343,
-0.12149213254451752,
-0.8626156449317932,
0.5834365487098694,
0.6106391549110413,
0.9618412256240845,
-0.40759870409965515,
0.24091945588588715,
0.27801600098609924,
0.30173367261886597,
-0.10979444533586502,
0.11462611705064774,
0.17585118114948273,
-0.5295663475990295,
-0.5393884778022766,
-0.5537856817245483,
-0.5956745147705078,
0.5491786003112793,
-0.4793632924556732,
0.1844257414340973,
-0.426474928855896,
-0.41899436712265015,
0.08714758604764938,
0.11735234409570694,
-0.6426834464073181,
-0.060404833406209946,
0.3393380641937256,
0.8164355754852295,
-0.8094349503517151,
0.4990619719028473,
0.6911303400993347,
-0.05301012098789215,
-0.6329573392868042,
-0.1267591267824173,
0.10853841155767441,
-0.5446314811706543,
0.7528483867645264,
0.006942179054021835,
-0.07845832407474518,
-0.5405607223510742,
-0.39558717608451843,
-0.8032377362251282,
0.5921420454978943,
0.3427131175994873,
-0.7047743201255798,
-0.015824276953935623,
-0.045829106122255325,
0.599888265132904,
-0.35845404863357544,
0.8212958574295044,
0.8401191234588623,
0.6155387759208679,
0.2797861695289612,
-1.2694344520568848,
0.11069098860025406,
-0.2206382006406784,
0.29533132910728455,
0.02402445673942566,
-0.8435438871383667,
0.872144341468811,
-0.13679669797420502,
-0.03208049014210701,
0.0099668363109231,
0.5986118316650391,
0.623843252658844,
0.2021045982837677,
0.2708502411842346,
0.3793172240257263,
0.6976171135902405,
-0.0908133015036583,
1.0571917295455933,
0.016257895156741142,
0.12352804839611053,
1.208178997039795,
-0.5080444812774658,
0.7388334274291992,
0.3601745069026947,
-0.45604437589645386,
0.38296112418174744,
0.8323352336883545,
0.16601234674453735,
0.1577344387769699,
0.7064676284790039,
-0.2133765071630478,
-0.07377690821886063,
-0.07729270309209824,
-0.4855770468711853,
0.26512715220451355,
0.5709038972854614,
-0.43548378348350525,
-0.12326771020889282,
-0.1955333650112152,
0.48503372073173523,
-0.04228227585554123,
-0.17387475073337555,
0.7339538931846619,
0.14533847570419312,
-0.9465941190719604,
0.591787576675415,
0.030529476702213287,
0.5136604309082031,
-0.30359768867492676,
0.06519965827465057,
-0.12227755784988403,
-0.005968513898551464,
-0.08159075677394867,
-0.9323867559432983,
-0.2263941913843155,
0.1550956517457962,
0.0572449192404747,
-0.01586858183145523,
0.6198745965957642,
-0.2448120415210724,
-0.39967772364616394,
0.17171341180801392,
0.4163036346435547,
0.11349442601203918,
0.14819787442684174,
-0.7415550947189331,
0.653198778629303,
-0.045711759477853775,
-0.8998298048973083,
0.29124197363853455,
0.6651293039321899,
-0.16932226717472076,
0.5351539254188538,
0.350614070892334,
0.0883387103676796,
-0.041338518261909485,
0.40573641657829285,
1.0534136295318604,
-0.5118067860603333,
-0.4044783115386963,
-1.1286382675170898,
0.20930185914039612,
-0.24779357016086578,
-0.3394645154476166,
0.8230358958244324,
0.7024180889129639,
0.42646822333335876,
0.20104540884494781,
1.020980715751648,
0.19418965280056,
0.5031241774559021,
-0.6108124256134033,
0.4191276431083679,
-0.001532282680273056,
0.4478927552700043,
-0.5917407274246216,
-0.9852439165115356,
-0.007573190610855818,
0.6284564733505249,
-0.7633326649665833,
0.47810110449790955,
0.7012115120887756,
0.45763030648231506,
0.14677076041698456,
0.35939422249794006,
0.16306009888648987,
0.4423440992832184,
0.5680402517318726,
0.542171835899353,
1.256749153137207,
-0.052477914839982986,
0.2252342402935028,
0.37368640303611755,
-0.32788512110710144,
-0.032921016216278076,
-0.9175922274589539,
-1.1363333463668823,
-0.3757691979408264,
-0.16583645343780518,
-0.35447677969932556,
-0.038793303072452545,
0.8815014958381653,
0.2798862159252167,
-0.648841381072998,
-0.33547669649124146,
0.22971269488334656,
0.13115812838077545,
0.4850695729255676,
-0.2184741199016571,
0.36445561051368713,
-0.2985690236091614,
-0.7730728387832642,
0.2527715563774109,
0.16082589328289032,
-0.23260577023029327,
-0.40787145495414734,
-0.08698315173387527,
-0.12371261417865753,
0.38275566697120667,
0.7401258945465088,
0.13683651387691498,
-1.2257118225097656,
-0.3809237778186798,
-0.21565838158130646,
0.0056163170374929905,
0.08402767032384872,
0.8774582743644714,
-0.7727927565574646,
0.361240416765213,
0.4646734297275543,
0.6023862361907959,
0.18910256028175354,
0.2564447224140167,
0.7777918577194214,
-0.3025571405887604,
-0.04035190865397453,
0.2288338541984558,
0.3607020080089569,
0.4414356052875519,
-0.04003973677754402,
0.5596521496772766,
0.08971615880727768,
-0.9945818185806274,
-0.9693619012832642,
0.18262118101119995,
-0.6804788112640381,
-0.16461122035980225,
1.5097349882125854,
0.041217852383852005,
0.05173225328326225,
-0.0059488206170499325,
-0.5887173414230347,
-0.04387075826525688,
-0.45057255029678345,
0.6097352504730225,
1.3124641180038452,
-0.14077050983905792,
-0.1293845921754837,
-0.9906085133552551,
0.6346170902252197,
0.5626910924911499,
-0.5536593794822693,
0.3108229339122772,
0.6763986349105835,
0.28750476241111755,
-0.0939684510231018,
0.8001425862312317,
-0.1855529397726059,
0.003987407777458429,
-0.10638663172721863,
-0.25538015365600586,
0.29193049669265747,
-0.07641627639532089,
-0.4915158748626709,
0.1442403942346573,
0.4261699318885803,
0.23797006905078888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18492v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18492v2
|
LLMs and Memorization: On Quality and Specificity of Copyright Compliance
| 2024-05-28T18:01:52 | 2024-06-28T16:12:39 |
Felix B Mueller, Rebekka Görge, Anna K Bernzen, Janna C Pirk, Maximilian Poretschkin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Memorization in large language models (LLMs) is a growing concern. LLMs have
been shown to easily reproduce parts of their training data, including
copyrighted work. This is an important problem to solve, as it may violate
existing copyright laws as well as the European AI Act. In this work, we
propose a systematic analysis to quantify the extent of potential copyright
infringements in LLMs using European law as an example. Unlike previous work,
we evaluate instruction-finetuned models in a realistic end-user scenario. Our
analysis builds on a proposed threshold of 160 characters, which we borrow from
the German Copyright Service Provider Act and a fuzzy text matching algorithm
to identify potentially copyright-infringing textual reproductions. The
specificity of countermeasures against copyright infringement is analyzed by
comparing model behavior on copyrighted and public domain data. We investigate
what behaviors models show instead of producing protected text (such as refusal
or hallucination) and provide a first legal assessment of these behaviors. We
find that there are huge differences in copyright compliance, specificity, and
appropriate refusal among popular LLMs. Alpaca, GPT 4, GPT 3.5, and Luminous
perform best in our comparison, with OpenGPT-X, Alpaca, and Luminous producing
a particularly low absolute number of potential copyright violations. Code will
be published soon.
|
[
-0.19218841195106506,
-0.6582164764404297,
0.49002835154533386,
0.13731564581394196,
-0.36330848932266235,
-0.22250905632972717,
-0.19145382940769196,
-0.5299187898635864,
-0.18410004675388336,
1.070006251335144,
-0.1485477089881897,
-0.5164568424224854,
-0.5753998756408691,
0.10889849811792374,
-0.7140374779701233,
0.8959699869155884,
-0.2830505669116974,
0.15185360610485077,
-0.4447450339794159,
-0.23063446581363678,
-0.33643996715545654,
-1.0467420816421509,
-0.228549525141716,
-0.07458095252513885,
0.4158099591732025,
0.09243198484182358,
0.26570671796798706,
0.6962299346923828,
0.6485218405723572,
0.30166739225387573,
-0.436309278011322,
-0.33075299859046936,
-0.6893051862716675,
-0.05872196704149246,
-0.18211078643798828,
-0.5743500590324402,
-0.4219858646392822,
0.08574725687503815,
0.6808454394340515,
0.0727502629160881,
-0.009203987196087837,
0.13499696552753448,
0.1654168963432312,
0.6279029846191406,
-0.46158459782600403,
-0.10159505903720856,
-0.6718626022338867,
0.11970008909702301,
-0.11204076558351517,
-0.10342191904783249,
-0.4848949611186981,
-0.35901424288749695,
0.07618491351604462,
-0.5192008018493652,
0.20423057675361633,
-0.20556314289569855,
1.0283952951431274,
0.42885467410087585,
-0.1434825211763382,
-0.7679287195205688,
-0.6372950077056885,
0.888630211353302,
-0.9049190878868103,
0.35679617524147034,
0.4255405068397522,
0.02571186237037182,
0.03428274020552635,
-0.9181905388832092,
-0.6540479063987732,
-0.3426527976989746,
0.17646023631095886,
0.03737085685133934,
-0.36557409167289734,
-0.0972934439778328,
0.5028923749923706,
0.5044369101524353,
-0.38306912779808044,
0.23560228943824768,
-0.5097185373306274,
-0.16230274736881256,
0.5369679927825928,
0.11802331358194351,
0.4863925576210022,
0.03303254023194313,
-0.5053967237472534,
0.256062775850296,
-1.072857141494751,
-0.08101750165224075,
0.6579297780990601,
-0.027739088982343674,
-0.000991731765680015,
0.6841602921485901,
0.08968323469161987,
0.328451544046402,
-0.17919115722179413,
0.0015119834570214152,
0.06182878464460373,
-0.16188420355319977,
-0.2279714196920395,
-0.1281869262456894,
0.5347333550453186,
0.19306103885173798,
0.6947635412216187,
-0.20804700255393982,
-0.45417383313179016,
-0.38251662254333496,
0.2682383060455322,
-0.6397534608840942,
-0.017015365883708,
0.147266685962677,
-0.43527063727378845,
-0.04587695002555847,
0.23470430076122284,
-0.19778475165367126,
-0.31884151697158813,
-0.9412105679512024,
0.6813321709632874,
-0.39524731040000916,
0.03004632517695427,
0.24340437352657318,
0.07306002825498581,
0.29830649495124817,
0.1648748815059662,
-0.6571267247200012,
0.1661914736032486,
0.9547100067138672,
0.8127322793006897,
-0.3667043447494507,
-0.4516712725162506,
-0.09334364533424377,
0.3586442470550537,
-0.11969370394945145,
0.4694783389568329,
-0.20240852236747742,
-0.38027840852737427,
0.004507875069975853,
0.20561297237873077,
-0.017058981582522392,
-0.7511175870895386,
0.5085540413856506,
-0.8863406777381897,
0.16763082146644592,
-0.32313865423202515,
-0.9698396921157837,
-0.4119960069656372,
0.23662278056144714,
-0.8338414430618286,
0.3827175199985504,
0.04839668422937393,
-0.707095205783844,
0.337298721075058,
-0.28256985545158386,
-0.31994202733039856,
-0.027694478631019592,
-0.12245259433984756,
-0.5147244930267334,
-0.10600023716688156,
-0.3448859751224518,
0.5483554005622864,
-0.07673881202936172,
-0.016747934743762016,
-0.028990192338824272,
-0.5156225562095642,
0.48183244466781616,
-0.6096920371055603,
0.7534233331680298,
0.3331678509712219,
-0.21892641484737396,
0.0617203414440155,
-0.6803925037384033,
-0.144767165184021,
0.3167169690132141,
-0.751054048538208,
-0.3551105558872223,
-0.0506979301571846,
-0.07945407181978226,
0.22125227749347687,
0.35769858956336975,
-0.35700497031211853,
0.11954253166913986,
0.0841725543141365,
0.5689991116523743,
0.7318986654281616,
0.08551125228404999,
0.3213799297809601,
-0.5422411561012268,
0.6129909157752991,
-0.10055498778820038,
0.33033615350723267,
0.08000851422548294,
-0.38601037859916687,
-0.4616648256778717,
-0.5017712712287903,
0.4504302144050598,
0.6594904065132141,
-0.3060261309146881,
0.2876664996147156,
-0.4419940114021301,
-0.22591541707515717,
-0.40456387400627136,
0.413906067609787,
0.6387694478034973,
0.0722101628780365,
0.19250576198101044,
-0.5758034586906433,
-0.2366485893726349,
-0.7260639071464539,
-0.19638916850090027,
0.06539956480264664,
-0.04063605144619942,
0.43497347831726074,
0.5634885430335999,
-0.06262961775064468,
0.7885953783988953,
-0.040851619094610214,
-0.5940401554107666,
-0.10035677254199982,
-0.13094918429851532,
0.0974559411406517,
0.5232958793640137,
0.48508110642433167,
-0.7803859114646912,
-0.600949227809906,
-0.2460928112268448,
-0.6789383888244629,
-0.11430370807647705,
-0.07334955036640167,
0.19399821758270264,
0.4240971803665161,
0.6162503957748413,
-0.39572909474372864,
0.32485470175743103,
0.29655689001083374,
-0.3054911494255066,
0.5260599255561829,
-0.2912546396255493,
0.10527481138706207,
-0.5891348719596863,
0.11516130715608597,
-0.3352142572402954,
-0.07383675128221512,
-0.6355674266815186,
0.32456672191619873,
-0.0353657566010952,
0.07800392061471939,
-1.0168330669403076,
0.17730195820331573,
-0.1983228325843811,
-0.17069776356220245,
-0.12254711985588074,
-0.16678664088249207,
-0.16599291563034058,
0.43689292669296265,
-0.0031108888797461987,
0.9612001180648804,
0.13229039311408997,
-0.7359097003936768,
0.07499580085277557,
0.20582635700702667,
-0.567375659942627,
0.5733028054237366,
-0.6921210885047913,
0.35270777344703674,
-0.05204645171761513,
-0.07088220119476318,
-0.5778437852859497,
-0.047024041414260864,
0.18218526244163513,
-0.3071821630001068,
0.2649156451225281,
-0.40221476554870605,
-0.5607794523239136,
0.03069419227540493,
-0.22809725999832153,
0.2599063217639923,
0.5816360116004944,
-0.4239845275878906,
0.345407634973526,
0.22661076486110687,
-0.07216822355985641,
-0.750087559223175,
-0.7530871033668518,
0.14263537526130676,
-0.3729914724826813,
-0.5515075922012329,
0.23802872002124786,
-0.18399368226528168,
-0.24766097962856293,
0.0952533558011055,
0.14504392445087433,
-0.14529350399971008,
0.17096874117851257,
0.1694316416978836,
-0.13429082930088043,
-0.1303965151309967,
-0.29045820236206055,
-0.2107153683900833,
0.10203273594379425,
-0.05121266469359398,
-0.05868515744805336,
0.7480436563491821,
0.01369099784642458,
-0.4529114365577698,
-0.4772053062915802,
0.2505002021789551,
0.6510843634605408,
-0.06884278357028961,
0.4734736680984497,
0.2882467806339264,
-0.26472002267837524,
-0.20476822555065155,
-0.512391984462738,
0.12685689330101013,
-0.4673837423324585,
0.37350940704345703,
-0.3259895145893097,
-0.7309711575508118,
0.622616708278656,
0.36055174469947815,
0.200737863779068,
0.2662889361381531,
0.659974217414856,
0.03160710260272026,
0.6866424679756165,
0.5082514882087708,
-0.07077782601118088,
0.6501775979995728,
-0.44223877787590027,
-0.0893331840634346,
-0.6930364966392517,
-0.332940012216568,
-0.44901183247566223,
-0.1982436329126358,
-0.37241002917289734,
-0.39121487736701965,
-0.1890343874692917,
0.28624671697616577,
-0.3516649007797241,
0.501972496509552,
-0.46983715891838074,
0.8733500838279724,
0.5447918176651001,
-0.026603950187563896,
0.700184166431427,
0.22491727769374847,
-0.013812723569571972,
-0.08238008618354797,
-0.4568166434764862,
-1.0758600234985352,
1.124394416809082,
0.36805495619773865,
0.6602627038955688,
0.35569360852241516,
0.861035943031311,
0.5227252244949341,
0.388064980506897,
-0.8249388933181763,
0.6591179966926575,
-0.49070510268211365,
-0.8152074217796326,
-0.248159721493721,
-0.5279428958892822,
-0.9580299258232117,
-0.03348693251609802,
0.05140894651412964,
-0.6167471408843994,
-0.016566338017582893,
-0.10850751399993896,
0.02797788381576538,
0.5396255254745483,
-0.6313108801841736,
0.6774294972419739,
-0.2924838662147522,
-0.5077852010726929,
-0.21142861247062683,
-0.3096997141838074,
0.35823801159858704,
-0.4835115373134613,
0.19905230402946472,
-0.16442973911762238,
-0.1642923504114151,
0.8774494528770447,
-0.11177746951580048,
0.784699559211731,
-0.0289195217192173,
-0.42913272976875305,
0.4911873936653137,
0.2031952440738678,
0.3128369450569153,
-0.41230592131614685,
0.006173890084028244,
0.13982447981834412,
0.3529316484928131,
-0.30184316635131836,
-0.2301349937915802,
0.5735035538673401,
-0.7576308846473694,
-0.6317296028137207,
-0.13676315546035767,
-0.3924383521080017,
0.16572310030460358,
0.412870317697525,
0.6239343285560608,
0.04772289842367172,
-0.3494342863559723,
0.056294143199920654,
0.7655341029167175,
-0.3340300917625427,
0.271852970123291,
0.901762843132019,
-0.05171791464090347,
-0.3585384488105774,
1.3940041065216064,
0.4024701714515686,
0.35961151123046875,
0.15179702639579773,
-0.004914761520922184,
-0.16654615104198456,
-1.0039199590682983,
-0.21724103391170502,
0.4298475980758667,
-1.0523802042007446,
0.07476350665092468,
-0.27580827474594116,
-0.23676210641860962,
-0.04257664829492569,
-0.062439680099487305,
-0.06559884548187256,
-0.5199841856956482,
-0.6248924136161804,
0.28274789452552795,
0.0905761569738388,
1.1078588962554932,
0.10236246138811111,
0.26963019371032715,
-0.8867811560630798,
0.10074009001255035,
0.31049543619155884,
0.603909969329834,
0.09098741412162781,
-0.951320469379425,
-0.19497516751289368,
-0.27494925260543823,
-0.5607650876045227,
-0.5421165823936462,
0.1372816264629364,
0.13587673008441925,
0.6141623258590698,
0.4131876528263092,
-0.17335382103919983,
0.11975344270467758,
-0.6028819680213928,
0.6999289393424988,
0.014476765878498554,
-1.1104950904846191,
0.10450169444084167,
-0.21599362790584564,
-0.2867041528224945,
0.3407634496688843,
0.3912080228328705,
-0.42001309990882874,
-0.48523154854774475,
-0.6900455355644226,
-0.8113563060760498,
0.5677574276924133,
0.2139357626438141,
0.5549405217170715,
0.2462904155254364,
0.5802835822105408,
0.03293643146753311,
0.14436426758766174,
-0.816907525062561,
0.05929567292332649,
0.08033359050750732,
-0.33020439743995667,
0.10476021468639374,
-0.2748243510723114,
-0.15924230217933655,
0.0076673892326653,
0.6169772148132324,
0.3592258393764496,
0.19302111864089966,
0.12252643704414368,
-0.48641568422317505,
0.14380411803722382,
0.27110692858695984,
0.7177788019180298,
0.6352518200874329,
-0.01744694635272026,
-0.14329944550991058,
0.16742965579032898,
-0.7326450347900391,
0.3019242286682129,
-0.16409063339233398,
-0.4908706247806549,
-0.16967017948627472,
0.293338805437088,
0.3323107063770294,
-0.07149603217840195,
-0.7746404409408569,
0.6214514970779419,
-0.03355933353304863,
-0.3091009557247162,
-0.39704468846321106,
0.34671005606651306,
0.014667309820652008,
0.26396211981773376,
-0.12673301994800568,
-0.3571137487888336,
0.10310441255569458,
-0.41566845774650574,
0.34759560227394104,
0.33568260073661804,
-0.39039847254753113,
-0.2908889353275299,
0.7148622274398804,
-0.059910017997026443,
-0.381791889667511,
0.346102774143219,
-0.021076707169413567,
-0.673862874507904,
0.832146406173706,
0.43116235733032227,
0.6480750441551208,
-0.10219573974609375,
-0.28531789779663086,
0.09563177824020386,
0.341459721326828,
-0.38069427013397217,
0.3932328224182129,
0.14344888925552368,
-0.6002799272537231,
-0.2452176809310913,
-0.2791483998298645,
-0.6521549820899963,
0.15851223468780518,
-0.588026762008667,
0.31981199979782104,
-0.6520736813545227,
-0.2886445224285126,
-0.1939566284418106,
-0.08536626398563385,
-0.5220493674278259,
-0.03407745435833931,
0.2976270020008087,
0.7022280693054199,
-0.46264883875846863,
0.8243920207023621,
0.40842124819755554,
-0.6774793863296509,
-0.5480828285217285,
-0.050746459513902664,
-0.048648323863744736,
-0.6040287613868713,
0.37489962577819824,
-0.020181041210889816,
0.07184066623449326,
0.08685196191072464,
-0.7052074670791626,
-0.5148852467536926,
1.1500169038772583,
0.5564882755279541,
-0.7173514366149902,
0.1907699853181839,
0.31562304496765137,
0.5011184811592102,
-0.14361508190631866,
-0.35385820269584656,
0.8265149593353271,
0.14055182039737701,
0.05022025480866432,
-0.6007611155509949,
-0.02081848494708538,
0.02858920209109783,
-0.23065157234668732,
-0.03152289614081383,
-0.7009822726249695,
0.707836925983429,
-0.20180152356624603,
-0.3229117691516876,
0.3963603079319,
0.27257058024406433,
0.31933069229125977,
0.36946171522140503,
0.254241019487381,
0.5943880081176758,
0.7408298254013062,
0.015131229534745216,
1.029882788658142,
-0.2512069046497345,
0.4182567894458771,
0.8946777582168579,
-0.2612159550189972,
0.9767236113548279,
0.3760330379009247,
-0.3543110489845276,
0.20239931344985962,
0.34070637822151184,
-0.4977473020553589,
0.31746533513069153,
0.6117787957191467,
-0.24526101350784302,
0.14881159365177155,
-0.04763822630047798,
-0.2510066032409668,
0.17682872712612152,
0.25821420550346375,
-0.5238707661628723,
0.38101595640182495,
-0.13111580908298492,
0.17947185039520264,
0.08455216884613037,
-0.30292633175849915,
0.9371575117111206,
0.316376268863678,
-0.34308722615242004,
0.6312680840492249,
0.0784238949418068,
0.6505005955696106,
-0.4856734573841095,
0.28333595395088196,
-0.243279367685318,
0.3507378399372101,
-0.2652132213115692,
-0.8244877457618713,
0.09932547807693481,
0.4429197609424591,
-0.1586836725473404,
-0.01950356736779213,
0.28881821036338806,
-0.35987013578414917,
-0.11517375707626343,
0.29954099655151367,
0.30532774329185486,
0.5277912616729736,
0.05454734340310097,
-0.6457900404930115,
0.15049618482589722,
0.06962078809738159,
-0.3175247609615326,
0.48917558789253235,
0.33304691314697266,
-0.045935072004795074,
0.6645862460136414,
0.5897193551063538,
0.23391786217689514,
0.24630795419216156,
0.13858379423618317,
0.5243228673934937,
-0.6240735054016113,
-0.3524931073188782,
-0.7577756643295288,
0.15977950394153595,
0.20227479934692383,
-0.24932682514190674,
0.7131850719451904,
0.5957978367805481,
0.953183114528656,
-0.14362911880016327,
0.7187250256538391,
0.2492614984512329,
0.21697866916656494,
-0.9119226932525635,
0.9139255285263062,
-0.5621536374092102,
0.7398609519004822,
-0.21228937804698944,
-1.0507181882858276,
-0.3873194456100464,
0.30205121636390686,
-0.2157239466905594,
-0.02933473326265812,
0.4144677221775055,
0.6357883810997009,
-0.2684345841407776,
0.04781528189778328,
0.441940039396286,
-0.01846327632665634,
0.5224424600601196,
0.5197334885597229,
1.13955557346344,
-0.2406078279018402,
0.7864524126052856,
-0.3220144808292389,
0.16261017322540283,
-0.060158390551805496,
-0.835640549659729,
-0.7207213640213013,
-0.3854919970035553,
-0.30836987495422363,
-0.3848704695701599,
-0.12636415660381317,
0.8411001563072205,
0.3775801956653595,
-0.8660607933998108,
-0.2822684049606323,
0.03367152810096741,
0.2060087025165558,
0.05812884122133255,
-0.18525052070617676,
0.5526365041732788,
-0.19995379447937012,
-0.7440950870513916,
-0.06559870392084122,
-0.032396331429481506,
0.7271403670310974,
-0.1351163685321808,
-0.34061139822006226,
0.23003925383090973,
0.5378552675247192,
0.590083122253418,
0.45528116822242737,
-0.8056203722953796,
0.0023723889607936144,
-0.15362957119941711,
-0.4173187017440796,
0.18565289676189423,
1.1373757123947144,
-0.14163069427013397,
0.2840823531150818,
0.49884364008903503,
0.5184029340744019,
0.30310332775115967,
-0.03566911444067955,
0.2978893518447876,
-0.4681937098503113,
-0.003062507836148143,
0.35809552669525146,
0.41533833742141724,
0.4011218845844269,
-0.14012277126312256,
0.38373813033103943,
0.2012520432472229,
-0.768828272819519,
-0.6798063516616821,
0.19102081656455994,
-0.7325544357299805,
-0.38969171047210693,
1.3081607818603516,
-0.7039309144020081,
0.007762307766824961,
-0.213068425655365,
-0.24173671007156372,
0.1731993407011032,
-0.1690000295639038,
0.7973834276199341,
0.9667655229568481,
0.28415921330451965,
0.1702137142419815,
-0.8594654202461243,
0.41000309586524963,
0.43599364161491394,
-0.6341803073883057,
0.17173351347446442,
0.433907687664032,
0.500161349773407,
-0.11311833560466766,
0.3968667984008789,
-0.5184702277183533,
0.31494271755218506,
-0.3585865795612335,
0.06905526667833328,
-0.3245028555393219,
-0.21310119330883026,
-0.8936280012130737,
-0.005160289816558361,
0.39007651805877686,
0.03322191908955574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18433v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18433v1
|
Notes on Applicability of GPT-4 to Document Understanding
| 2024-05-28T17:59:53 | 2024-05-28T17:59:53 |
Łukasz Borchmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We perform a missing, reproducible evaluation of all publicly available GPT-4
family models concerning the Document Understanding field, where it is
frequently required to comprehend text spacial arrangement and visual clues in
addition to textual semantics. Benchmark results indicate that though it is
hard to achieve satisfactory results with text-only models, GPT-4 Vision Turbo
performs well when one provides both text recognized by an external OCR engine
and document images on the input. Evaluation is followed by analyses that
suggest possible contamination of textual GPT-4 models and indicate the
significant performance drop for lengthy documents.
|
[
-0.2381201982498169,
-0.5104914307594299,
1.3169840574264526,
0.033715661615133286,
-0.2531200349330902,
-0.2066451460123062,
0.08127240091562271,
-0.7059333324432373,
-0.5771379470825195,
0.3042120933532715,
-0.4219135642051697,
-0.463386207818985,
-0.7065880298614502,
0.33370861411094666,
-0.6387304067611694,
1.0113433599472046,
-0.5238784551620483,
-0.07592184841632843,
-0.17441076040267944,
-0.03920943662524223,
-0.3388789892196655,
-0.505929172039032,
-0.573606014251709,
-0.22142015397548676,
0.33589255809783936,
0.15961109101772308,
0.4984012246131897,
0.7673455476760864,
0.8221626281738281,
0.32508885860443115,
-0.005111519247293472,
-0.18961016833782196,
-0.33821696043014526,
-0.14957615733146667,
-0.25905144214630127,
-0.4239656329154968,
-0.4920554459095001,
0.4100523293018341,
0.9852544069290161,
0.35575804114341736,
-0.032679036259651184,
-0.23149967193603516,
0.047514867037534714,
0.37047845125198364,
-0.3815794587135315,
0.4692653715610504,
-0.6738900542259216,
0.055708616971969604,
-0.07886439561843872,
-0.3632916808128357,
-0.30649852752685547,
-0.24226224422454834,
0.5014426112174988,
-1.1057919263839722,
0.8650476336479187,
-0.36628642678260803,
1.162245750427246,
0.16749194264411926,
-0.334881454706192,
-0.6036258935928345,
-0.648532509803772,
0.39898326992988586,
-0.42600560188293457,
0.5250144600868225,
0.6070396900177002,
0.4117196202278137,
0.21551556885242462,
-1.0987545251846313,
-0.5348793268203735,
-0.04826914519071579,
-0.0780845433473587,
0.5257160663604736,
-0.04996141046285629,
0.2509329915046692,
0.49194514751434326,
0.575190544128418,
-0.43071067333221436,
-0.23072044551372528,
-0.6264066696166992,
-0.23228520154953003,
0.05214345455169678,
0.1690353900194168,
0.0778898224234581,
0.0196165032684803,
-0.35297325253486633,
0.016606101766228676,
-0.35535097122192383,
-0.12797966599464417,
0.27012109756469727,
-0.20155154168605804,
-0.04737910255789757,
0.3966905474662781,
0.024038854986429214,
0.7863268256187439,
-0.12720279395580292,
-0.13509276509284973,
0.28858616948127747,
-0.8721775412559509,
-0.3422234356403351,
-0.37477725744247437,
0.30211129784584045,
0.4403207302093506,
0.026117417961359024,
-0.22529667615890503,
-0.17183780670166016,
0.10022089630365372,
0.41890308260917664,
-0.7864723801612854,
-0.23369070887565613,
-0.2009839415550232,
-0.2828948497772217,
-0.23103229701519012,
-0.12999337911605835,
-0.8679314851760864,
-0.35251855850219727,
-0.11075259000062943,
0.4596801698207855,
-0.6838661432266235,
-0.09613968431949615,
0.0690012127161026,
-0.7672692537307739,
0.48817816376686096,
0.8110859990119934,
-1.2065370082855225,
0.33934253454208374,
0.6040126085281372,
1.1462959051132202,
0.031840730458498,
-0.6037905216217041,
-0.17846789956092834,
0.25619274377822876,
-0.1968570053577423,
1.0768965482711792,
-0.6090320944786072,
-0.5547981858253479,
-0.22468231618404388,
0.10106737166643143,
-0.5060834884643555,
-0.23139001429080963,
0.9429925680160522,
-0.3663851022720337,
0.2115553766489029,
-0.3159659802913666,
-0.6833237409591675,
-0.6665502786636353,
0.266925573348999,
-0.7332803606987,
0.7053596377372742,
0.6142980456352234,
-0.782245397567749,
0.51417076587677,
-0.5237229466438293,
-0.10507998615503311,
0.2402167171239853,
-0.37474513053894043,
-0.416779100894928,
0.22420813143253326,
0.14577311277389526,
0.27039870619773865,
-0.06127318739891052,
-0.2039729207754135,
-0.1821790337562561,
-0.7366050481796265,
-0.2325555682182312,
-0.56172776222229,
0.3657984733581543,
0.032173313200473785,
-0.3603893220424652,
-0.06095506250858307,
-0.5241088271141052,
-0.20078392326831818,
0.24652719497680664,
-0.41424691677093506,
-0.30051493644714355,
-0.19736455380916595,
0.05047805234789848,
0.017915980890393257,
0.23955896496772766,
-0.36825549602508545,
0.39526504278182983,
-0.2702052593231201,
0.6742085814476013,
0.5792655944824219,
0.013641229830682278,
0.5477522015571594,
-0.07084470987319946,
0.6409574747085571,
-0.1896282136440277,
0.2454768568277359,
-0.5879221558570862,
-0.8698362708091736,
-0.47583693265914917,
-0.2669924199581146,
0.22822564840316772,
0.44371119141578674,
-0.8947073221206665,
-0.2465459257364273,
-0.14100632071495056,
-0.3489087224006653,
-0.28817424178123474,
-0.06445033103227615,
0.4937065541744232,
0.9233025312423706,
0.22616979479789734,
-0.20158246159553528,
-0.16811032593250275,
-0.9705597162246704,
-0.28844374418258667,
-0.09924054890871048,
0.09794983267784119,
0.3915792405605316,
0.7227972745895386,
-0.19314514100551605,
0.6026371121406555,
-0.39200443029403687,
-0.24957920610904694,
-0.1660158336162567,
0.5418766736984253,
0.08672481030225754,
0.06906332820653915,
0.7769286632537842,
-0.7518054246902466,
-0.39278313517570496,
0.23334789276123047,
-0.7700833082199097,
0.06960968673229218,
0.10343926399946213,
0.16504469513893127,
0.42829686403274536,
0.23714610934257507,
-0.4448471963405609,
1.000789999961853,
0.5898382067680359,
-0.3107110559940338,
0.3767697513103485,
-0.6530745625495911,
0.32253944873809814,
-0.6443074345588684,
0.029105089604854584,
0.2728597819805145,
-0.29399386048316956,
-0.6284455060958862,
0.07715393602848053,
0.6944511532783508,
-0.1734878122806549,
-0.01942158304154873,
0.2623567581176758,
-0.6017684936523438,
-0.4186486005783081,
-0.1257365494966507,
0.4774150550365448,
0.4788433015346527,
0.34064990282058716,
0.40287333726882935,
0.9704354405403137,
0.29019254446029663,
-0.3173946440219879,
-0.023346830159425735,
0.3123730421066284,
-0.3348662555217743,
0.749998927116394,
-0.5039939284324646,
0.2725452780723572,
0.0032886159606277943,
0.20195893943309784,
-0.9118491411209106,
-0.31538400053977966,
0.2580873668193817,
-0.3505829870700836,
0.47121670842170715,
-0.34989121556282043,
-0.40647056698799133,
-0.3818650543689728,
-0.40653806924819946,
0.31112632155418396,
0.3026508390903473,
-0.47187721729278564,
0.7943769693374634,
0.1777794510126114,
-0.09537474811077118,
-0.3267782926559448,
-0.5835661292076111,
-0.003236537566408515,
-0.054791409522295,
-0.6700571179389954,
0.36115947365760803,
0.2123003602027893,
0.1016106978058815,
0.13273847103118896,
-0.11500869691371918,
-0.4125973880290985,
0.06619643419981003,
0.11811666190624237,
0.14735017716884613,
-0.18525142967700958,
-0.0035532398615032434,
-0.14985665678977966,
-0.13597489893436432,
-0.15804803371429443,
-0.04146275669336319,
-0.029599688947200775,
-0.3238544762134552,
-0.17401888966560364,
-0.3211959898471832,
0.3521556854248047,
0.5933027863502502,
-0.04282398149371147,
0.21546174585819244,
0.4549449682235718,
-0.3896043598651886,
0.047890812158584595,
-0.525815486907959,
0.12944558262825012,
-0.47578325867652893,
0.5964990258216858,
-0.662437379360199,
-0.600354015827179,
0.547185480594635,
0.0011354910675436258,
-0.10957662761211395,
0.6401848793029785,
0.29404670000076294,
-0.11775548756122589,
0.8492454886436462,
0.7606515288352966,
0.2002887725830078,
0.336752712726593,
-0.280513197183609,
0.19439737498760223,
-0.9057945013046265,
-0.16615350544452667,
-0.6804916858673096,
0.25906243920326233,
-0.5161506533622742,
-0.2990683913230896,
0.37792453169822693,
-0.01992548443377018,
0.21759644150733948,
0.2168866991996765,
-0.5674598813056946,
0.4863753318786621,
0.5682336688041687,
-0.02351011522114277,
0.54400634765625,
-0.14537346363067627,
-0.2882797420024872,
-0.15346768498420715,
-0.5322673916816711,
-0.4949520230293274,
0.9407733082771301,
0.40806636214256287,
0.42827486991882324,
-0.02051912434399128,
0.4094476103782654,
-0.09791722893714905,
0.485700786113739,
-0.7465541362762451,
0.2027282565832138,
-0.1034935861825943,
-0.6807683110237122,
-0.1351519376039505,
-0.3505762219429016,
-0.8631749153137207,
0.2876795828342438,
0.13423354923725128,
-0.7207717299461365,
0.0953582376241684,
0.18743303418159485,
-0.2222585678100586,
0.09165755659341812,
-1.1834180355072021,
1.1514041423797607,
-0.13068312406539917,
-0.1475607454776764,
0.0008405612898059189,
-0.2864748239517212,
0.4238400161266327,
-0.5348002314567566,
0.15518642961978912,
0.15712440013885498,
-0.22974546253681183,
0.632079005241394,
-0.43051356077194214,
0.4563365578651428,
-0.25315001606941223,
-0.02122710458934307,
0.17315571010112762,
-0.24158558249473572,
0.36081662774086,
-0.13784512877464294,
-0.08712691068649292,
0.30821871757507324,
0.19722847640514374,
-0.002818795619532466,
-0.7729569673538208,
0.7353854179382324,
-0.651410698890686,
-0.6382848620414734,
-0.7288907766342163,
-0.41455307602882385,
-0.03993954136967659,
0.3866617679595947,
0.4830533266067505,
0.5262402892112732,
-0.08125737309455872,
-0.03596482425928116,
0.3393898606300354,
-0.16644321382045746,
0.47862985730171204,
0.6913518309593201,
-0.06115581467747688,
-0.22806508839130402,
0.7831172347068787,
0.26218223571777344,
0.11799237877130508,
-0.03166702762246132,
0.14680109918117523,
-0.4983123540878296,
-0.976246178150177,
-0.6204112768173218,
0.2809613049030304,
-1.0130748748779297,
0.01408301666378975,
-0.6113191246986389,
-0.15019595623016357,
-0.2533504366874695,
-0.1319820135831833,
-0.09267272800207138,
-0.3031885623931885,
-0.3485673666000366,
-0.20720794796943665,
0.43578699231147766,
1.3457131385803223,
0.21591749787330627,
0.3543279469013214,
-0.8335990309715271,
0.40617474913597107,
0.0846916139125824,
0.6943317651748657,
-0.21276918053627014,
-0.6239619255065918,
-0.43726879358291626,
-0.3943001329898834,
-0.6381977200508118,
-0.9901626706123352,
0.13698312640190125,
0.1270284652709961,
0.686837375164032,
0.10154673457145691,
-0.5414953827857971,
0.6237007975578308,
-0.6929238438606262,
0.7364686131477356,
-0.11207176744937897,
-1.0648574829101562,
0.5277795791625977,
-0.7346349358558655,
0.42443427443504333,
0.6929905414581299,
0.3296441435813904,
-0.08200497180223465,
-0.3728940188884735,
-0.7185646295547485,
-0.7085002064704895,
0.8691627383232117,
0.4568635821342468,
-0.3868016004562378,
0.22656938433647156,
0.8087931871414185,
0.1505698412656784,
0.03556143492460251,
-0.5216555595397949,
0.24972574412822723,
-0.4787118434906006,
-0.24197635054588318,
-0.17493942379951477,
-0.28100472688674927,
0.25899538397789,
-0.23006518185138702,
0.3858286440372467,
0.010661463253200054,
0.5325537323951721,
0.500972330570221,
0.018024709075689316,
0.24298027157783508,
-0.04614295810461044,
0.8269065022468567,
0.7853857278823853,
-0.45172345638275146,
-0.08573497086763382,
-0.15739281475543976,
-1.087346076965332,
-0.1029089093208313,
0.32811030745506287,
-0.2211330533027649,
-0.009304727427661419,
0.3594319224357605,
0.5902381539344788,
0.42149972915649414,
-0.030001962557435036,
0.6877866983413696,
-0.5836266875267029,
-0.767554521560669,
-0.3413141369819641,
-0.13227608799934387,
0.012240824289619923,
0.029874147847294807,
0.22052237391471863,
0.16298282146453857,
0.49866846203804016,
-0.5428383946418762,
0.14134185016155243,
0.2833021283149719,
-0.3615122139453888,
-0.4454623758792877,
0.6756638884544373,
0.28291767835617065,
0.00009653285815147683,
0.7385154962539673,
-0.06525448709726334,
-0.7836036682128906,
0.6857973337173462,
0.4145786464214325,
0.8112443685531616,
-0.07824468612670898,
-0.0573694072663784,
0.1878313422203064,
0.5098509192466736,
-0.2383478432893753,
0.34945663809776306,
-0.23361746966838837,
-0.6037079691886902,
-0.37411487102508545,
-0.20830081403255463,
-0.6886921525001526,
0.25925466418266296,
-0.5338940024375916,
0.23088029026985168,
-0.40428850054740906,
-0.21767103672027588,
0.41472429037094116,
-0.10528469830751419,
-0.8384585976600647,
0.289923757314682,
-0.02104540541768074,
0.9279845356941223,
-0.7181994318962097,
1.0911287069320679,
0.3673419952392578,
-0.6967902779579163,
-0.9877501726150513,
0.0388970784842968,
0.06123736500740051,
-0.7548096776008606,
0.5091096758842468,
0.3432352542877197,
-0.3356931507587433,
0.21685655415058136,
-0.18439899384975433,
-0.47845324873924255,
1.188955545425415,
0.40920108556747437,
-0.27401724457740784,
-0.2898625433444977,
-0.20905143022537231,
0.4945814609527588,
-0.1115320473909378,
0.6629388928413391,
0.7319945096969604,
0.7019892334938049,
0.08786175400018692,
-1.028236985206604,
-0.05934721231460571,
-0.3270719647407532,
-0.07036390900611877,
0.11563719063997269,
-0.4915143847465515,
0.7488219738006592,
-0.01833854615688324,
-0.3580951392650604,
0.3163818418979645,
0.07173123210668564,
-0.023922501131892204,
0.6850461363792419,
0.21945911645889282,
0.6432700753211975,
0.6941189169883728,
-0.26959022879600525,
1.5399748086929321,
-0.1443294882774353,
0.3515743315219879,
1.0650527477264404,
-0.337007075548172,
0.5955926179885864,
0.1828191727399826,
-0.036431435495615005,
0.1192975714802742,
0.6940270662307739,
-0.19856339693069458,
0.6390973925590515,
-0.17970648407936096,
-0.2058999389410019,
0.3464457094669342,
0.3453715741634369,
-0.499351441860199,
0.5035730004310608,
0.5865926146507263,
-0.6089486479759216,
-0.2256726175546646,
-0.30260148644447327,
-0.2281680405139923,
-0.08298902958631516,
-0.4077697992324829,
0.7644755244255066,
-0.012532602064311504,
-0.7990884184837341,
0.47477850317955017,
0.005926650483161211,
0.38519302010536194,
-0.6222118735313416,
-0.44857871532440186,
-0.14320428669452667,
0.2305370420217514,
-0.24591632187366486,
-0.9556870460510254,
0.5380328297615051,
0.13393551111221313,
-0.1760687679052353,
-0.2837008535861969,
0.8661407232284546,
0.10750582814216614,
-0.32908785343170166,
0.38352319598197937,
0.20076952874660492,
0.42631202936172485,
-0.257316917181015,
-0.3907712996006012,
0.0698535218834877,
-0.013360027223825455,
-0.14870208501815796,
0.20852243900299072,
0.6565697193145752,
0.01886867545545101,
0.17824523150920868,
0.1570044755935669,
-0.17630955576896667,
0.06829558312892914,
0.19407163560390472,
0.8106721043586731,
-0.6515423655509949,
-0.43278852105140686,
-0.6877937316894531,
0.20878885686397552,
-0.1565437912940979,
-0.3227481544017792,
0.9285470247268677,
0.6168345808982849,
0.762728214263916,
-0.1306704431772232,
1.0564121007919312,
0.47450995445251465,
0.3197786808013916,
-0.5723418593406677,
0.5942505598068237,
-0.4153934717178345,
-0.08311563730239868,
-0.4865180552005768,
-0.8614323735237122,
-0.29894396662712097,
0.7555412650108337,
-0.508270263671875,
0.20076362788677216,
1.2221779823303223,
0.30861619114875793,
-0.1562913954257965,
0.5380387306213379,
0.4751853048801422,
-0.004226285498589277,
0.2859843969345093,
0.5242621302604675,
0.7462202906608582,
-0.447807639837265,
0.7050286531448364,
-0.13383880257606506,
-0.5987834334373474,
-0.014828738756477833,
-1.0245163440704346,
-0.8573445081710815,
-0.7105283737182617,
-0.10614893585443497,
-0.08159356564283371,
0.058140095323324203,
-0.1563597470521927,
0.5905004143714905,
-0.21173180639743805,
0.3007776439189911,
-0.3471282124519348,
-0.16427025198936462,
0.02929283306002617,
-0.1896006166934967,
0.4099562466144562,
-0.12464915961027145,
-0.7364400029182434,
0.4424382746219635,
0.4809871017932892,
0.2715736925601959,
-0.10560984164476395,
0.16250045597553253,
0.025085918605327606,
-0.07758165150880814,
0.2938461899757385,
0.2301977574825287,
-0.6746097207069397,
-0.41811034083366394,
-0.08273061364889145,
-0.048310697078704834,
0.2726666033267975,
0.9113816022872925,
-0.4571114182472229,
0.6636705994606018,
0.5830734968185425,
0.6014469265937805,
1.0387225151062012,
0.0159824900329113,
0.8513690233230591,
-0.3789459764957428,
0.21454133093357086,
-0.025558222085237503,
0.5985304713249207,
0.4530399441719055,
-0.6901227831840515,
0.7400674223899841,
0.5398157835006714,
-0.755759596824646,
-0.3189321756362915,
0.09104275703430176,
-0.9927050471305847,
-0.033911626785993576,
0.8244450092315674,
-0.6300613284111023,
-0.3829970359802246,
-0.39823710918426514,
-0.2410300076007843,
0.1698182225227356,
-0.4588700234889984,
0.43801677227020264,
0.9922563433647156,
-0.2090282291173935,
-0.42560890316963196,
-1.0395026206970215,
0.4799690246582031,
-0.08321306109428406,
-0.7090035080909729,
-0.19809238612651825,
0.4958217740058899,
0.2529621720314026,
0.09450999647378922,
1.062328815460205,
-0.43991684913635254,
0.40188273787498474,
0.2794281840324402,
-0.13342519104480743,
-0.07702271640300751,
-0.22143761813640594,
-0.6771188378334045,
0.04641804099082947,
0.23883065581321716,
-0.12797899544239044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18415v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18415v1
|
Why are Visually-Grounded Language Models Bad at Image Classification?
| 2024-05-28T17:57:06 | 2024-05-28T17:57:06 |
Yuhui Zhang, Alyssa Unell, Xiaohan Wang, Dhruba Ghosh, Yuchang Su, Ludwig Schmidt, Serena Yeung-Levy
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Image classification is one of the most fundamental capabilities of machine
vision intelligence. In this work, we revisit the image classification task
using visually-grounded language models (VLMs) such as GPT-4V and LLaVA. We
find that existing proprietary and public VLMs, despite often using CLIP as a
vision encoder and having many more parameters, significantly underperform CLIP
on standard image classification benchmarks like ImageNet. To understand the
reason, we explore several hypotheses concerning the inference algorithms,
training objectives, and data processing in VLMs. Our analysis reveals that the
primary cause is data-related: critical information for image classification is
encoded in the VLM's latent space but can only be effectively decoded with
enough training data. Specifically, there is a strong correlation between the
frequency of class exposure during VLM training and instruction-tuning and the
VLM's performance in those classes; when trained with sufficient data, VLMs can
match the accuracy of state-of-the-art classification models. Based on these
findings, we enhance a VLM by integrating classification-focused datasets into
its training, and demonstrate that the enhanced classification performance of
the VLM transfers to its general capabilities, resulting in an improvement of
11.8% on the newly collected ImageWikiQA dataset.
|
[
-0.3135375380516052,
-0.49208343029022217,
0.588890552520752,
-0.1424512416124344,
-0.6690301895141602,
0.03933614492416382,
0.1187741756439209,
-0.7444638609886169,
-0.5529637932777405,
0.7011641263961792,
-0.03688766807317734,
-0.3974998891353607,
-0.7173229455947876,
-0.22868092358112335,
-0.6964005827903748,
0.6842994689941406,
0.05010099336504936,
0.1045428216457367,
-0.5210163593292236,
-0.3921140432357788,
-0.6161732077598572,
-0.9063383936882019,
-0.21186302602291107,
-0.060956597328186035,
0.2064841091632843,
0.22619856894016266,
0.6930561065673828,
0.7073830962181091,
0.482033371925354,
0.3099749982357025,
-0.044265519827604294,
0.11612799763679504,
-0.5711076259613037,
-0.15447038412094116,
-0.022621504962444305,
-0.5592935085296631,
-0.017676902934908867,
-0.0318942666053772,
0.43077021837234497,
0.4879341721534729,
0.15541011095046997,
0.16893284022808075,
0.04980677366256714,
0.5684688091278076,
-0.8707934617996216,
0.17031912505626678,
-0.773451566696167,
0.1782156080007553,
-0.3085726499557495,
-0.2723671793937683,
-0.4794252812862396,
-0.02101016789674759,
0.0992838516831398,
-0.47826439142227173,
0.37370866537094116,
0.20624448359012604,
1.3498256206512451,
0.4694916009902954,
-0.2675648033618927,
0.036102890968322754,
-0.6674612760543823,
0.7669837474822998,
-0.36810457706451416,
0.45452192425727844,
0.4788573086261749,
0.3188380002975464,
0.1011284813284874,
-0.685074508190155,
-0.48663127422332764,
-0.05002395808696747,
0.09728556871414185,
0.07504402101039886,
-0.23053699731826782,
0.20339183509349823,
0.5673161149024963,
0.24654290080070496,
-0.232884481549263,
0.19600899517536163,
-0.5514273047447205,
-0.1315005123615265,
0.3670629858970642,
0.1689566969871521,
0.4162752032279968,
-0.11221326887607574,
-0.3253817856311798,
-0.10303385555744171,
-0.6551842093467712,
0.19939328730106354,
0.10457322746515274,
-0.025280818343162537,
0.13399745523929596,
0.6170213222503662,
-0.04283822700381279,
0.8105658292770386,
-0.17055124044418335,
-0.273919016122818,
0.18688100576400757,
-0.1542225480079651,
-0.41379812359809875,
-0.22722424566745758,
0.3880857229232788,
0.8535476326942444,
0.5482792258262634,
0.05662424862384796,
-0.23430877923965454,
0.3274141848087311,
0.4122328758239746,
-0.7505025863647461,
-0.310695618391037,
-0.23278075456619263,
-0.34378206729888916,
-0.600476086139679,
0.05771850049495697,
-0.4847332239151001,
-0.2693403661251068,
-0.5666110515594482,
0.44964197278022766,
-0.22903306782245636,
0.06898941844701767,
-0.16318978369235992,
-0.30290335416793823,
0.4938846230506897,
0.7731100916862488,
-0.5961018800735474,
0.26491832733154297,
0.43004274368286133,
0.6586748361587524,
-0.0990452691912651,
-0.21762095391750336,
-0.3234264850616455,
-0.06937090307474136,
-0.5591966509819031,
0.9169686436653137,
-0.3162410855293274,
-0.07290690392255783,
0.18463891744613647,
0.1268676370382309,
0.0684686154127121,
-0.6264550685882568,
0.4476257562637329,
-0.6447217464447021,
0.16977500915527344,
-0.3033810555934906,
-0.34768998622894287,
-0.39498794078826904,
0.21062549948692322,
-0.4990507662296295,
0.9308631420135498,
-0.06566400080919266,
-0.8942269086837769,
0.6605827808380127,
0.04756569117307663,
-0.19281984865665436,
0.27716928720474243,
-0.4057328701019287,
-0.5046616792678833,
0.2892923355102539,
0.23095113039016724,
0.6319507360458374,
-0.16032546758651733,
0.3539680540561676,
-0.4888785779476166,
-0.7032546997070312,
0.40453284978866577,
-0.5557042956352234,
0.5352902412414551,
0.11890550702810287,
-0.3676656484603882,
0.09945375472307205,
-0.8154019713401794,
0.2612764835357666,
0.2577974200248718,
-0.13913008570671082,
-0.6377215385437012,
0.0383228063583374,
0.13519787788391113,
0.26355263590812683,
-0.1828860491514206,
-0.23083220422267914,
-0.13288387656211853,
0.00277008768171072,
0.295857310295105,
0.9112997055053711,
-0.09274628013372421,
0.3093049228191376,
-0.03826671093702316,
0.14806947112083435,
0.0072142151184380054,
0.2671716511249542,
-0.11260116100311279,
-0.5764539837837219,
-0.9118850231170654,
-0.42403870820999146,
0.028528902679681778,
0.5261424779891968,
-0.8056669235229492,
0.14383257925510406,
-0.28394582867622375,
-0.31980907917022705,
-0.28855180740356445,
0.1327916830778122,
0.4018303155899048,
0.8197262287139893,
0.38704046607017517,
-0.2723652720451355,
-0.3302399516105652,
-0.95011305809021,
-0.050642650574445724,
-0.11159387975931168,
0.10788530111312866,
0.3616429269313812,
0.35222718119621277,
-0.3482482135295868,
0.7518236637115479,
-0.362739622592926,
-0.13989563286304474,
0.07559642940759659,
-0.21918831765651703,
0.018141768872737885,
0.26439863443374634,
0.6981217861175537,
-1.0255169868469238,
-0.28245294094085693,
-0.10073845088481903,
-1.125680685043335,
-0.07119172066450119,
0.14799995720386505,
-0.07380422204732895,
0.18499591946601868,
0.39787882566452026,
-0.19924643635749817,
1.0220725536346436,
0.26241424679756165,
-0.3261803090572357,
0.5012418627738953,
0.03375888615846634,
0.1601986289024353,
-0.369507759809494,
-0.16676805913448334,
-0.047626860439777374,
-0.366301953792572,
-0.5344477295875549,
0.20964720845222473,
0.18997518718242645,
-0.2963372468948364,
-0.5977138876914978,
0.23760350048542023,
-0.3956815302371979,
-0.2792714238166809,
-0.43804314732551575,
-0.36058008670806885,
0.2044905424118042,
0.5192015171051025,
0.23784786462783813,
0.6238898634910583,
0.89232337474823,
-0.8278486132621765,
0.30413520336151123,
0.25252342224121094,
-0.3572527766227722,
0.4742469787597656,
-0.6124482154846191,
0.21895235776901245,
-0.21794015169143677,
-0.13089483976364136,
-0.837561845779419,
-0.3568492829799652,
0.2508655786514282,
-0.137330561876297,
0.49124324321746826,
-0.2965192496776581,
-0.42287981510162354,
-0.3031047284603119,
-0.16514717042446136,
0.4121205508708954,
0.8954946994781494,
-0.8764760494232178,
0.3296133875846863,
0.26085329055786133,
0.3563738465309143,
-0.5654991865158081,
-0.9032986164093018,
0.15638157725334167,
-0.2897630035877228,
-0.5511198043823242,
0.11997822672128677,
0.3916666507720947,
-0.13700395822525024,
0.3095754384994507,
-0.12424418330192566,
-0.23178941011428833,
0.13467296957969666,
0.5752439498901367,
0.2862338125705719,
-0.12300370633602142,
0.22069944441318512,
-0.32556474208831787,
0.07869096845388412,
-0.07558613270521164,
-0.23195984959602356,
0.1372113823890686,
-0.3971903920173645,
-0.5879629850387573,
-0.4280898869037628,
0.15722030401229858,
0.8132531046867371,
-0.10367622971534729,
0.6708958148956299,
0.48727384209632874,
-0.2741803824901581,
-0.0884353369474411,
-0.5535085201263428,
0.18909014761447906,
-0.46313154697418213,
0.3916420042514801,
-0.2735810875892639,
-0.7025936245918274,
0.2269284427165985,
-0.08629834651947021,
-0.24680988490581512,
0.28977978229522705,
0.2116972655057907,
-0.495577871799469,
0.8616724014282227,
0.7823163866996765,
0.10629687458276749,
0.6311752796173096,
-0.3426034152507782,
-0.08565069735050201,
-0.6891066431999207,
-0.32871606945991516,
-0.2044760286808014,
0.043825093656778336,
-0.5142664909362793,
-0.496040940284729,
0.16313892602920532,
0.1511395424604416,
-0.17834888398647308,
-0.05457156151533127,
-0.6109866499900818,
0.48317083716392517,
0.5394912362098694,
0.25448718667030334,
-0.029233286157250404,
0.4488120675086975,
-0.006875935476273298,
-0.3396894037723541,
-0.6736929416656494,
-0.6303121447563171,
1.0236554145812988,
0.585681676864624,
0.9278243184089661,
-0.293966680765152,
0.38761135935783386,
0.23876738548278809,
0.2503553032875061,
-0.7370889186859131,
0.47426557540893555,
-0.2918865978717804,
-0.2648574113845825,
-0.05460605397820473,
-0.14214017987251282,
-0.5432282090187073,
0.34127241373062134,
-0.18428151309490204,
-0.4493578374385834,
0.3369292616844177,
0.30200302600860596,
0.40882328152656555,
0.24634350836277008,
-0.7001302242279053,
0.8501145839691162,
-0.6765364408493042,
-0.7098880410194397,
0.05185721814632416,
-0.5123523473739624,
0.6347965598106384,
-0.14253291487693787,
0.26888489723205566,
-0.09598134458065033,
0.21101826429367065,
0.5464030504226685,
-0.608646035194397,
0.9462355375289917,
-0.41681012511253357,
0.24041812121868134,
0.3363868296146393,
-0.32519271969795227,
0.22225631773471832,
-0.3783344328403473,
0.4308081865310669,
0.520318865776062,
-0.16937409341335297,
-0.4705006778240204,
-0.7587562799453735,
0.19428758323192596,
-0.8774835467338562,
-0.5860705971717834,
-0.43150368332862854,
0.15978974103927612,
-0.17807821929454803,
0.10976607352495193,
0.6198811531066895,
0.693149209022522,
0.1529892086982727,
0.30753380060195923,
0.5977728366851807,
-0.27210313081741333,
0.04902772605419159,
0.04766476899385452,
-0.4293452501296997,
-0.4375194311141968,
1.1220849752426147,
0.22341807186603546,
0.33289939165115356,
0.0628773495554924,
0.012594595551490784,
-0.19134868681430817,
-0.8825995326042175,
-0.3652954697608948,
-0.018892956897616386,
-1.2518903017044067,
-0.16219674050807953,
-0.4201491177082062,
-0.3519417941570282,
-0.1055963784456253,
-0.10619792342185974,
-0.11645925045013428,
-0.07196967303752899,
-0.4644116163253784,
-0.11260950565338135,
0.2187248319387436,
0.6569811701774597,
0.32211095094680786,
0.2239317148923874,
-0.6042530536651611,
0.41967448592185974,
0.5262347459793091,
0.4144469201564789,
-0.17187370359897614,
-0.7453415989875793,
-0.17237645387649536,
-0.34350764751434326,
-0.13004913926124573,
-0.8618065118789673,
0.20203553140163422,
0.298417329788208,
0.7710046768188477,
0.4317261874675751,
-0.14989732205867767,
0.9519932866096497,
-0.629600465297699,
0.6988894939422607,
0.15863007307052612,
-0.8433139324188232,
0.5414477586746216,
-0.0423450730741024,
0.09330008924007416,
0.35520970821380615,
0.12716585397720337,
-0.1753329187631607,
-0.4764895439147949,
-0.43752825260162354,
-0.8028820157051086,
0.57569819688797,
0.17447040975093842,
0.1779635101556778,
0.1385219395160675,
0.24397791922092438,
-0.12857717275619507,
0.1886989325284958,
-0.8427069187164307,
0.03991305083036423,
-0.8726180195808411,
-0.055802121758461,
0.08074747025966644,
-0.5720666646957397,
-0.01416283193975687,
-0.4688728153705597,
0.2939964234828949,
-0.2674526870250702,
0.2654063105583191,
0.25739437341690063,
-0.4071638286113739,
0.024308228865265846,
0.0014857599744573236,
0.6122532486915588,
0.48313283920288086,
-0.08595260977745056,
0.3242674767971039,
0.17930342257022858,
-0.46050840616226196,
0.27537021040916443,
-0.424679696559906,
-0.38965195417404175,
0.006032582838088274,
0.7206951975822449,
1.2642858028411865,
0.1845717579126358,
-0.6612385511398315,
0.6895712614059448,
-0.2780662178993225,
-0.2784844934940338,
-0.3247052729129791,
0.1476653665304184,
-0.35884445905685425,
0.05153839662671089,
0.4728280305862427,
0.4860907793045044,
0.2164822369813919,
-0.3485424220561981,
0.11117047816514969,
0.3822999894618988,
-0.3863734304904938,
-0.2804476320743561,
0.4507627487182617,
0.047951240092515945,
0.08303530514240265,
0.6883387565612793,
0.13274013996124268,
-0.8988044261932373,
0.5251458287239075,
0.40390706062316895,
0.832289457321167,
0.22784264385700226,
-0.030601995065808296,
0.22919951379299164,
0.5207207202911377,
-0.09260021150112152,
0.09520122408866882,
-0.08240973949432373,
-0.8031013607978821,
-0.35395827889442444,
-0.6182897090911865,
-0.26352205872535706,
0.22674775123596191,
-0.6117295622825623,
0.34750545024871826,
-0.718015730381012,
-0.21278057992458344,
-0.4407818913459778,
-0.5686498284339905,
-0.9738237857818604,
0.4233437478542328,
0.5353549122810364,
0.6228277683258057,
-0.9501065015792847,
0.6303050518035889,
0.7851138114929199,
-0.24274951219558716,
-0.7983210682868958,
-0.07220610976219177,
-0.1458950787782669,
-0.7560157179832458,
1.122434139251709,
0.4715351462364197,
-0.22513426840305328,
-0.17372815310955048,
-0.9553709030151367,
-0.8449258804321289,
0.7420408725738525,
0.35101237893104553,
-0.382731556892395,
0.07910602539777756,
-0.07122663408517838,
0.6610211730003357,
-0.1964542716741562,
-0.059382662177085876,
0.05499076470732689,
0.1548483967781067,
0.2633005380630493,
-0.7042199373245239,
-0.1178334653377533,
-0.3701111376285553,
0.2622254490852356,
-0.18820838630199432,
-0.42949092388153076,
0.713134229183197,
-0.18562112748622894,
-0.45610174536705017,
-0.22464466094970703,
0.40930408239364624,
0.19622035324573517,
0.5058026909828186,
0.4166697859764099,
0.6284317970275879,
0.715139627456665,
-0.21841122210025787,
1.1472667455673218,
0.24314314126968384,
0.1695057451725006,
0.7525715231895447,
-0.29421141743659973,
0.7903122305870056,
0.4464402198791504,
-0.13378138840198517,
0.4385298788547516,
0.5318695902824402,
-0.4121655523777008,
0.7883220911026001,
0.02773035131394863,
0.1274130940437317,
-0.43039238452911377,
-0.0034831364173442125,
-0.23813451826572418,
0.6023250222206116,
0.4922882616519928,
-0.4131421446800232,
-0.06695893406867981,
0.39905089139938354,
-0.5892102122306824,
0.09410741180181503,
-0.41844847798347473,
0.6869843006134033,
0.04359998181462288,
-0.22674033045768738,
0.9338688254356384,
-0.2022467702627182,
0.4741441309452057,
-0.18117745220661163,
-0.18878497183322906,
0.0884527862071991,
0.19535203278064728,
-0.4256967008113861,
-0.8142898082733154,
0.2230493426322937,
0.2171977311372757,
-0.12231405824422836,
-0.1273544579744339,
1.2045528888702393,
-0.018667221069335938,
-0.42753446102142334,
0.1961914598941803,
0.23573221266269684,
0.32066643238067627,
-0.060199107974767685,
-0.5802443623542786,
0.3584887385368347,
-0.1055016741156578,
0.026962365955114365,
0.2960045635700226,
0.5390187501907349,
-0.33450064063072205,
0.7092387080192566,
0.6702598929405212,
-0.06815078109502792,
0.39248746633529663,
0.04314173012971878,
1.092834234237671,
-0.7560210824012756,
-0.37502315640449524,
-0.7332085967063904,
0.5064246654510498,
-0.14533419907093048,
-0.04734509065747261,
0.594082772731781,
0.26792559027671814,
0.7285947799682617,
-0.30377718806266785,
0.8006744384765625,
0.337637722492218,
0.13480770587921143,
-0.9126510620117188,
0.5566500425338745,
-0.5896154046058655,
0.0914883241057396,
-0.3168334364891052,
-0.7948091626167297,
-0.29042208194732666,
0.5822484493255615,
-0.38216808438301086,
-0.017033731564879417,
0.5503772497177124,
0.29585492610931396,
-0.09128335118293762,
-0.25768911838531494,
0.7635834217071533,
-0.12438765913248062,
0.37526780366897583,
0.33148643374443054,
1.4055628776550293,
-0.4599478542804718,
0.4397563636302948,
-0.335013747215271,
-0.17999520897865295,
-0.4497065544128418,
-0.8183256387710571,
-1.0513705015182495,
-0.36823856830596924,
-0.41451597213745117,
-0.1376873105764389,
0.10314751416444778,
0.3048236072063446,
0.8465420603752136,
-0.5441977977752686,
0.20669272541999817,
-0.2712916135787964,
0.06883509457111359,
0.19010819494724274,
-0.26742640137672424,
0.1514148712158203,
-0.2926293611526489,
-0.3989828824996948,
-0.0013157116482034326,
0.3267575204372406,
0.47665563225746155,
-0.03267259895801544,
0.0014140406856313348,
0.32480689883232117,
-0.43603596091270447,
0.6474502682685852,
0.42118018865585327,
-1.0665333271026611,
-0.3145086169242859,
0.016043581068515778,
-0.34371688961982727,
0.06237153336405754,
0.5307331085205078,
-0.8819295167922974,
0.5201904773712158,
0.23037266731262207,
0.7603440880775452,
0.4542151987552643,
0.11757004261016846,
0.27922916412353516,
-0.6339664459228516,
0.39253395795822144,
0.12766538560390472,
0.6012905240058899,
0.618083119392395,
-0.45623600482940674,
0.31009432673454285,
0.6620343327522278,
-0.4812220335006714,
-0.9885504841804504,
0.05640914663672447,
-0.797217607498169,
-0.24601520597934723,
1.060136318206787,
-0.013655704446136951,
-0.5791274309158325,
-0.11063150316476822,
-0.4015344977378845,
0.02055116556584835,
0.004147447645664215,
0.331760972738266,
0.732170045375824,
-0.04588645324110985,
-0.5284771919250488,
-0.6283503770828247,
0.3415803909301758,
0.2129601538181305,
-0.6121496558189392,
-0.16600733995437622,
0.7508304119110107,
0.45443180203437805,
0.1321505755186081,
0.5566520094871521,
-0.13277743756771088,
0.4712566137313843,
0.10478714108467102,
0.03115403652191162,
-0.1907120794057846,
-0.44870615005493164,
-0.5016582012176514,
0.34077537059783936,
0.45354264974594116,
-0.3530336320400238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18414v1
|
Don't Forget to Connect! Improving RAG with Graph-based Reranking
| 2024-05-28T17:56:46 | 2024-05-28T17:56:46 |
Jialin Dong, Bahare Fatemi, Bryan Perozzi, Lin F. Yang, Anton Tsitsulin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has greatly improved the performance of
Large Language Model (LLM) responses by grounding generation with context from
existing documents. These systems work well when documents are clearly relevant
to a question context. But what about when a document has partial information,
or less obvious connections to the context? And how should we reason about
connections between documents? In this work, we seek to answer these two core
questions about RAG generation. We introduce G-RAG, a reranker based on graph
neural networks (GNNs) between the retriever and reader in RAG. Our method
combines both connections between documents and semantic information (via
Abstract Meaning Representation graphs) to provide a context-informed ranker
for RAG. G-RAG outperforms state-of-the-art approaches while having smaller
computational footprint. Additionally, we assess the performance of PaLM 2 as a
reranker and find it to significantly underperform G-RAG. This result
emphasizes the importance of reranking for RAG even when using Large Language
Models.
|
[
-0.5298045873641968,
-0.4831155836582184,
0.6394568085670471,
-0.18236729502677917,
-0.3515166640281677,
0.22285784780979156,
0.038373757153749466,
-0.6235226988792419,
0.5239412188529968,
0.4683810770511627,
-0.23539616167545319,
-0.22939635813236237,
-0.6526480317115784,
0.01584111526608467,
-0.39569422602653503,
1.1687977313995361,
0.20717361569404602,
-0.4348740875720978,
-0.579281747341156,
-0.37965893745422363,
-0.4687919318675995,
-0.3941262662410736,
-1.1502436399459839,
-0.6337752938270569,
1.1603152751922607,
0.37756940722465515,
0.6642632484436035,
0.8181682229042053,
0.426819771528244,
0.38835325837135315,
-0.29389482736587524,
0.5097980499267578,
-0.8189936280250549,
0.48399198055267334,
-0.21367588639259338,
-0.43280550837516785,
-0.603823721408844,
-0.1600978523492813,
0.6234520077705383,
0.8987930417060852,
0.36958393454551697,
0.36884036660194397,
0.07528328150510788,
1.110917091369629,
-0.6453396081924438,
-0.03845502436161041,
-0.7324396371841431,
-0.3024255037307739,
-0.420881986618042,
-0.41498956084251404,
-0.522370457649231,
-0.3364173173904419,
-0.18492545187473297,
-0.5826524496078491,
0.6707608699798584,
0.34604138135910034,
1.0916386842727661,
0.2637577950954437,
-0.6573533415794373,
-0.16524885594844818,
-0.5630040764808655,
0.4166140854358673,
-0.060993194580078125,
0.34125030040740967,
0.6085272431373596,
0.4531008005142212,
-0.4203605651855469,
-0.9707362651824951,
-0.3459489941596985,
-0.1538487672805786,
-0.14554038643836975,
0.18171651661396027,
0.0352046862244606,
-0.09876348823308945,
0.3039316236972809,
0.2928979992866516,
-0.4345577359199524,
-0.16817529499530792,
-0.31181618571281433,
-0.012579390779137611,
0.6023134589195251,
-0.13768157362937927,
0.29542726278305054,
-0.027111459523439407,
-0.1705850511789322,
-0.16741393506526947,
-0.9531021118164062,
-0.11904201656579971,
0.30046311020851135,
0.10757215321063995,
0.22676722705364227,
0.5535487532615662,
0.16998830437660217,
0.9376513361930847,
0.24083037674427032,
-0.011098056100308895,
0.10237681120634079,
-0.13328656554222107,
-0.02836102806031704,
-0.0520024299621582,
0.49252694845199585,
0.35871994495391846,
0.24713030457496643,
-0.5575001835823059,
-0.04459521546959877,
-0.008480795659124851,
0.37594178318977356,
-0.42441314458847046,
-0.36098262667655945,
0.00254443334415555,
-0.3184835910797119,
-0.1679590493440628,
-0.21740828454494476,
-0.4502846598625183,
-0.5456109046936035,
-0.27226361632347107,
0.1878206729888916,
-0.18589045107364655,
-0.3312549591064453,
-0.528844952583313,
-0.45011866092681885,
0.22295592725276947,
0.4809153079986572,
-1.1106020212173462,
0.40434807538986206,
0.9369819760322571,
0.7909029126167297,
0.09774358570575714,
-0.24553686380386353,
-0.6537691354751587,
0.5223388075828552,
-0.6898548007011414,
0.9945310354232788,
-0.3970401883125305,
-0.4273752272129059,
-0.2523476779460907,
0.018596388399600983,
-0.1425439417362213,
-0.6778627634048462,
0.5915651917457581,
-0.9187315702438354,
0.07311322540044785,
-0.5628918409347534,
-0.5993261337280273,
-0.16652429103851318,
0.24301452934741974,
-0.7884217500686646,
0.985017716884613,
0.2761531174182892,
-0.9741343855857849,
0.33203375339508057,
-0.21110203862190247,
-0.46243593096733093,
0.040360599756240845,
-0.2191963493824005,
-0.31216710805892944,
0.19373063743114471,
0.16212564706802368,
-0.04701632633805275,
-0.34940555691719055,
0.2001713514328003,
-0.3948744833469391,
-0.46428918838500977,
-0.0489109642803669,
-0.05009518191218376,
0.52231764793396,
0.09163149446249008,
0.08040182292461395,
0.07873059809207916,
-0.4046699106693268,
0.1585054099559784,
0.1546427309513092,
-0.38219842314720154,
-0.4773944020271301,
-0.0005435023922473192,
-0.09534749388694763,
0.15332931280136108,
0.13345849514007568,
-0.43483325839042664,
0.24155738949775696,
-0.5564772486686707,
0.20512142777442932,
0.6613122820854187,
0.05312388017773628,
0.6219063401222229,
-0.6421926021575928,
0.32829463481903076,
-0.18940162658691406,
-0.31317245960235596,
-0.23650643229484558,
-0.6437628865242004,
-0.9212532639503479,
0.11707747727632523,
0.5555726885795593,
0.4093739986419678,
-0.7976717948913574,
0.22759903967380524,
-0.35197731852531433,
-0.5801834464073181,
-0.22410081326961517,
0.07414814829826355,
0.42345407605171204,
0.8445159792900085,
0.252800852060318,
-0.21971848607063293,
-0.5932323932647705,
-0.7153195738792419,
-0.3953216075897217,
-0.27808210253715515,
-0.06374809145927429,
0.8659138083457947,
0.13449528813362122,
-0.16744107007980347,
1.0274388790130615,
-0.5401489734649658,
-0.304104745388031,
-0.32847869396209717,
-0.15556660294532776,
0.24699538946151733,
0.252879798412323,
0.6491639614105225,
-0.9225445985794067,
-0.6254037022590637,
0.13861311972141266,
-0.8193603754043579,
-0.08197623491287231,
0.1683923751115799,
-0.21638473868370056,
0.30820927023887634,
0.8123060464859009,
-0.4229278862476349,
0.2652681767940521,
0.6007398366928101,
-0.19737273454666138,
0.18745598196983337,
-0.49654507637023926,
-0.08600190281867981,
-1.130493402481079,
0.3597964644432068,
-0.23698246479034424,
-0.4458792209625244,
-0.4270954132080078,
-0.026600444689393044,
0.02290421538054943,
-0.42803436517715454,
-0.022317303344607353,
0.7980949282646179,
-0.6280733346939087,
-0.3703046441078186,
-0.48692643642425537,
0.5219563841819763,
0.19288629293441772,
0.2922482490539551,
-0.4091595709323883,
0.870758593082428,
0.3920927345752716,
-0.4956517517566681,
0.23254188895225525,
0.15833386778831482,
0.1942930519580841,
0.1086731106042862,
-0.7551761269569397,
0.39327365159988403,
-0.4246325194835663,
0.6152504086494446,
-1.340301275253296,
-0.21193602681159973,
0.14734961092472076,
-0.6510183811187744,
0.7749468684196472,
-0.49120214581489563,
-0.2799043655395508,
-0.2793591320514679,
-0.2333993762731552,
0.5885341763496399,
0.29498061537742615,
-0.6199063658714294,
0.6302055716514587,
0.750255823135376,
-0.1464717984199524,
-0.5749154090881348,
-0.24837236106395721,
0.31239190697669983,
-0.17881417274475098,
-0.9249555468559265,
0.485060453414917,
0.29386574029922485,
0.03588641807436943,
0.08461811393499374,
-0.24645955860614777,
-0.08547448366880417,
0.15635205805301666,
0.3397039473056793,
0.15155062079429626,
-0.07173357158899307,
0.2949427664279938,
-0.005873884540051222,
-0.5589373707771301,
-0.10386461764574051,
-0.15577766299247742,
0.5206024646759033,
0.006998429540544748,
-0.21922814846038818,
0.26612165570259094,
0.33517318964004517,
0.44519907236099243,
-0.1571570336818695,
0.585350751876831,
0.4192214906215668,
-0.14176012575626373,
-0.0063316780142486095,
-0.5220080614089966,
-0.04839619994163513,
-0.49299725890159607,
0.05830274894833565,
-0.3526066243648529,
-1.031104326248169,
0.5537406206130981,
-0.4623175263404846,
-0.06489083170890808,
0.4250945448875427,
0.11626759171485901,
-0.25108230113983154,
0.8326804041862488,
0.8195805549621582,
-0.3586336672306061,
0.5240778923034668,
-0.1531827300786972,
0.35804206132888794,
-1.2612025737762451,
0.048955295234918594,
-0.62548828125,
-0.4846632182598114,
-0.9073038697242737,
-0.39763522148132324,
0.41365545988082886,
0.5313385128974915,
-0.22656281292438507,
0.178050234913826,
-0.34489762783050537,
0.6193742156028748,
0.44474610686302185,
0.0021437490358948708,
0.13917449116706848,
0.07147113233804703,
-0.24385887384414673,
0.14931213855743408,
-0.8805199861526489,
-0.29005950689315796,
1.1484274864196777,
0.06729576736688614,
0.41150328516960144,
0.2872120141983032,
1.021754264831543,
0.2377558797597885,
0.6735056638717651,
-0.6968503594398499,
0.5913755297660828,
-0.3336258828639984,
-0.28863900899887085,
-0.24048228561878204,
-0.4754919111728668,
-1.4754983186721802,
0.40821462869644165,
0.014456436969339848,
-0.7590841054916382,
0.02190643921494484,
0.24151688814163208,
-0.07850043475627899,
0.0821177065372467,
-0.6995782256126404,
0.5589985847473145,
0.16855691373348236,
-0.26020997762680054,
-0.039787136018276215,
-0.5277455449104309,
0.37808316946029663,
-0.07122524082660675,
0.11465089023113251,
-0.0074846274219453335,
-0.09792396426200867,
0.7265389561653137,
-0.479653924703598,
0.445242315530777,
0.016324946656823158,
0.08394530415534973,
0.31395360827445984,
-0.06591569632291794,
0.5892388820648193,
-0.015240478329360485,
0.00259347609244287,
-0.0940413624048233,
-0.4179491698741913,
-0.2355818897485733,
-0.6887993216514587,
0.9594938158988953,
-0.6763038635253906,
-0.7601390480995178,
-0.34917935729026794,
-0.35898417234420776,
-0.3498125374317169,
0.3577502965927124,
0.3094125986099243,
0.4543849229812622,
0.015401589684188366,
0.09889787435531616,
0.6164996027946472,
-0.05008240416646004,
0.2667076885700226,
0.01423502154648304,
-0.5289121270179749,
-0.4984375536441803,
1.1690037250518799,
0.30695396661758423,
0.19166192412376404,
0.2742561399936676,
0.12734797596931458,
-0.30556151270866394,
-0.18901878595352173,
-0.5660537481307983,
0.632906973361969,
-0.7578384876251221,
-0.18524140119552612,
-0.651297926902771,
-0.23430685698986053,
-0.4804823100566864,
-0.22100955247879028,
-0.06016653776168823,
-0.4669647812843323,
0.018330693244934082,
0.08295603841543198,
0.300632119178772,
0.7788804173469543,
-0.073491670191288,
0.00733710452914238,
-0.7553678750991821,
0.6239429712295532,
0.3350033760070801,
0.3658250570297241,
0.21566200256347656,
-0.38207459449768066,
-0.21422404050827026,
-0.23221831023693085,
-0.33126145601272583,
-0.8352681994438171,
0.06875155121088028,
0.250700980424881,
0.6212855577468872,
0.1269528865814209,
-0.06519656628370285,
0.5765032768249512,
-0.8307992219924927,
0.47966304421424866,
-0.0616067573428154,
-0.5095736384391785,
0.4524485468864441,
-0.6130573153495789,
0.19340309500694275,
0.4089747667312622,
0.1447015255689621,
-0.7133021354675293,
-0.42089349031448364,
-0.882728099822998,
-1.215875506401062,
0.4805157780647278,
-0.0181818176060915,
-0.10823589563369751,
-0.17873364686965942,
0.466933935880661,
-0.5128517746925354,
0.06304094195365906,
-0.3265284299850464,
-0.4387092590332031,
0.012623373419046402,
0.1875293105840683,
-0.2807368040084839,
-0.3805139660835266,
-0.14168879389762878,
-0.12972880899906158,
0.46395546197891235,
-0.2590199410915375,
0.19171403348445892,
0.09355303645133972,
0.03775493800640106,
-0.21829047799110413,
-0.11312570422887802,
0.5132832527160645,
0.7794128060340881,
-0.04933467507362366,
0.048468563705682755,
0.09883848577737808,
-0.5753395557403564,
0.15475331246852875,
-0.03133959323167801,
-0.2812150716781616,
0.22846508026123047,
0.4299190938472748,
0.5587225556373596,
0.25614991784095764,
-0.107731394469738,
0.22787067294120789,
-0.15851867198944092,
0.06526590138673782,
-0.16304488480091095,
0.21087688207626343,
0.42746007442474365,
0.014236634597182274,
0.2823476195335388,
0.10942035168409348,
-0.01976226270198822,
-0.35350531339645386,
0.27899953722953796,
0.41741588711738586,
-0.13312235474586487,
0.08296698331832886,
0.5358363389968872,
0.17923131585121155,
-0.42081984877586365,
0.520068347454071,
-0.09210280328989029,
-0.5102946758270264,
0.8434813022613525,
0.645384669303894,
0.8431819677352905,
-0.01998843252658844,
0.05161420255899429,
0.4946604073047638,
0.2011527717113495,
0.07252314686775208,
0.07663603872060776,
-0.24780946969985962,
-0.6422008275985718,
-0.4790966212749481,
-0.44825518131256104,
-0.49197134375572205,
-0.13946418464183807,
-0.47809338569641113,
0.006017225328832865,
-0.562047004699707,
-0.30420950055122375,
0.06555835902690887,
0.1647413820028305,
-0.5449037551879883,
0.16931183636188507,
-0.13864298164844513,
0.833916962146759,
-0.6825402975082397,
0.7566761374473572,
0.6879289746284485,
-0.34599921107292175,
-0.9216455817222595,
0.15281926095485687,
-0.11892417073249817,
-0.5861167907714844,
0.8385214805603027,
0.2183862030506134,
-0.2141309678554535,
0.2998266816139221,
-0.14319294691085815,
-1.259863018989563,
1.1766194105148315,
0.28001856803894043,
-0.35737738013267517,
0.12095848470926285,
-0.23045194149017334,
0.4812369644641876,
-0.19341686367988586,
0.36590439081192017,
0.20949296653270721,
0.3025900721549988,
0.2841866612434387,
-0.772488534450531,
-0.11944540590047836,
-0.278288871049881,
0.2429390251636505,
0.6810378432273865,
-0.6326808333396912,
0.8060646653175354,
-0.3020946681499481,
-0.41545239090919495,
0.07903705537319183,
0.6120944023132324,
0.48850148916244507,
0.4877814054489136,
0.45923498272895813,
0.7767927050590515,
1.0590461492538452,
-0.12979793548583984,
1.215388536453247,
-0.26629123091697693,
0.30618003010749817,
1.3418749570846558,
-0.37542814016342163,
0.8599433302879333,
0.35906782746315,
0.030144017189741135,
0.4302372634410858,
0.5770980715751648,
0.3409598469734192,
0.3217923045158386,
0.2743726074695587,
-0.3387104868888855,
-0.14718523621559143,
-0.2015174776315689,
-0.6393072605133057,
0.24945341050624847,
0.3096855878829956,
-0.31906652450561523,
-0.7672253251075745,
-0.3293103873729706,
0.0631999671459198,
0.11120684444904327,
-0.31197428703308105,
1.0251045227050781,
0.08396555483341217,
-0.8578160405158997,
0.7345697283744812,
-0.04624036327004433,
0.12749417126178741,
-0.49978533387184143,
-0.14708591997623444,
-0.44296830892562866,
0.19569909572601318,
-0.1926751285791397,
-0.7489079833030701,
0.3804716467857361,
-0.11723960936069489,
-0.6422613859176636,
-0.12698021531105042,
1.2370941638946533,
-0.33525320887565613,
-0.34988903999328613,
0.41575053334236145,
0.5251063108444214,
0.2895001173019409,
0.07759920507669449,
-0.46908894181251526,
0.10012829303741455,
-0.24197520315647125,
-0.15843459963798523,
0.7953085899353027,
0.6404145359992981,
-0.3975113034248352,
0.7086640000343323,
0.9512432813644409,
-0.008874624036252499,
-0.18917760252952576,
0.36735454201698303,
1.1551264524459839,
-0.5592390298843384,
-0.4541650712490082,
-0.6035498380661011,
0.19109633564949036,
-0.2643277645111084,
-0.21147999167442322,
0.8386765122413635,
0.5378666520118713,
0.6588845252990723,
0.2892591953277588,
0.6253674030303955,
0.1284226030111313,
0.7407435178756714,
-0.13371005654335022,
1.0008805990219116,
-0.5303485989570618,
0.10483457893133163,
-0.2365078628063202,
-1.084177851676941,
-0.2599821984767914,
0.43835657835006714,
-0.24703764915466309,
0.1976138800382614,
0.5010128617286682,
0.7280433773994446,
0.04816460236907005,
-0.2757270336151123,
0.3201613426208496,
-0.06684079766273499,
0.5496293306350708,
0.5176175236701965,
0.40668216347694397,
-0.6500771641731262,
0.5122911334037781,
0.19658982753753662,
-0.30724772810935974,
-0.3390674293041229,
-0.9941084980964661,
-0.626741886138916,
-0.5282160639762878,
-0.016353627666831017,
-0.5864428281784058,
0.11144344508647919,
0.2959006726741791,
0.30076828598976135,
-0.3170165717601776,
-0.22129060328006744,
-0.07294271886348724,
0.5885806679725647,
0.001414450234733522,
-0.1306997537612915,
0.5359872579574585,
-0.6860954165458679,
-0.34214872121810913,
0.49554625153541565,
0.37803971767425537,
-0.22607958316802979,
-0.054083503782749176,
-0.05945642292499542,
-0.37447190284729004,
-0.15887145698070526,
0.5688937902450562,
0.5683650374412537,
-0.47286567091941833,
-0.3584987223148346,
-0.21387425065040588,
-0.2330733835697174,
-0.040974993258714676,
0.8450438380241394,
-1.1091887950897217,
0.45963895320892334,
0.6749994158744812,
0.8046672344207764,
0.4460739195346832,
0.2571384906768799,
0.46459338068962097,
-0.8083692789077759,
-0.005286776926368475,
0.15589746832847595,
0.46178674697875977,
0.4765886962413788,
-0.28599032759666443,
0.7409431338310242,
0.2617722749710083,
-0.9256983399391174,
-0.6843985915184021,
0.45715516805648804,
-0.8138012886047363,
-0.07839787751436234,
1.0404754877090454,
-0.14075867831707,
-0.4801926612854004,
-0.3090311884880066,
-0.3216147720813751,
0.29575538635253906,
-0.029327573254704475,
0.6593059301376343,
0.45455411076545715,
-0.07456055283546448,
-0.2157866656780243,
-0.42269763350486755,
0.555706262588501,
0.2584373950958252,
-0.5664165616035461,
0.08678368479013443,
0.4371177554130554,
0.2537299394607544,
0.4863700568675995,
0.9833571910858154,
0.19926311075687408,
0.32703039050102234,
0.05120747908949852,
-0.5174224972724915,
-0.18161122500896454,
-0.5130436420440674,
0.07208164036273956,
0.2618659436702728,
0.26844465732574463,
-0.11838749796152115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18406v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18406v1
|
RACCooN: Remove, Add, and Change Video Content with Auto-Generated Narratives
| 2024-05-28T17:46:36 | 2024-05-28T17:46:36 |
Jaehong Yoon, Shoubin Yu, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent video generative models primarily rely on carefully written text
prompts for specific tasks, like inpainting or style editing. They require
labor-intensive textual descriptions for input videos, hindering their
flexibility to adapt personal/raw videos to user specifications. This paper
proposes RACCooN, a versatile and user-friendly video-to-paragraph-to-video
generative framework that supports multiple video editing capabilities such as
removal, addition, and modification, through a unified pipeline. RACCooN
consists of two principal stages: Video-to-Paragraph (V2P) and
Paragraph-to-Video (P2V). In the V2P stage, we automatically describe video
scenes in well-structured natural language, capturing both the holistic context
and focused object details. Subsequently, in the P2V stage, users can
optionally refine these descriptions to guide the video diffusion model,
enabling various modifications to the input video, such as removing, changing
subjects, and/or adding new objects. The proposed approach stands out from
other methods through several significant contributions: (1) RACCooN suggests a
multi-granular spatiotemporal pooling strategy to generate well-structured
video descriptions, capturing both the broad context and object details without
requiring complex human annotations, simplifying precise video content editing
based on text for users. (2) Our video generative model incorporates
auto-generated narratives or instructions to enhance the quality and accuracy
of the generated content. It supports the addition of video objects,
inpainting, and attribute modification within a unified framework, surpassing
existing video editing and inpainting benchmarks. The proposed framework
demonstrates impressive versatile capabilities in video-to-paragraph
generation, video content editing, and can be incorporated into other SoTA
video generative models for further enhancement.
|
[
-0.5701476335525513,
-0.8297303915023804,
0.14415773749351501,
0.4508551061153412,
-0.3368586003780365,
-0.007634811103343964,
-0.266308456659317,
-0.3875087797641754,
0.22882452607154846,
0.5005830526351929,
-0.7150034308433533,
-0.4003584086894989,
-0.6323485970497131,
0.18088386952877045,
-0.70867919921875,
1.1797415018081665,
-0.14017213881015778,
-0.5634739398956299,
-0.09463626891374588,
-0.25878164172172546,
-0.6270321607589722,
0.03247147053480148,
-0.30076998472213745,
-0.3033995032310486,
0.42168959975242615,
0.4645693302154541,
1.0802812576293945,
1.1293895244598389,
0.3246070444583893,
0.28736862540245056,
0.08510246872901917,
0.31144076585769653,
-0.1412479430437088,
0.3597041070461273,
-0.22880759835243225,
0.18681402504444122,
-0.2632187008857727,
-0.25593164563179016,
0.421829491853714,
0.2561511993408203,
-0.12479940801858902,
0.18225319683551788,
0.25382742285728455,
0.6112353205680847,
-0.9992811679840088,
-0.040608953684568405,
-0.2813912332057953,
0.5145264267921448,
-0.004154851194471121,
-0.5421829223632812,
-0.0840776115655899,
-0.13570715487003326,
0.12280683219432831,
-1.0367528200149536,
0.6801027059555054,
-0.45610445737838745,
0.758193850517273,
0.4264659583568573,
-0.02052002213895321,
-0.3184821605682373,
-1.1119657754898071,
0.30417367815971375,
-0.29696086049079895,
-0.06319229304790497,
0.5152727961540222,
0.29115840792655945,
0.2687775492668152,
-0.9053097367286682,
-0.6007588505744934,
0.014898743480443954,
0.024229684844613075,
0.30232247710227966,
-0.3765513002872467,
0.15832984447479248,
0.167814701795578,
0.5774851441383362,
-0.898452639579773,
0.07626807689666748,
-0.09240801632404327,
0.05971258878707886,
0.7637250423431396,
0.4712887108325958,
0.5933541655540466,
-0.4847680926322937,
-0.29860934615135193,
-0.12892384827136993,
-0.461422860622406,
0.07255692034959793,
0.5374597907066345,
-0.3288899064064026,
0.012170861475169659,
0.9572625160217285,
-0.39396822452545166,
0.5813010931015015,
0.12814335525035858,
-0.09254258126020432,
-0.2652873694896698,
-0.2989021837711334,
-0.5624881982803345,
0.08392401039600372,
0.8945022225379944,
0.6202790141105652,
-0.26605039834976196,
0.02123035304248333,
-0.0841783657670021,
0.024740342050790787,
0.4451838433742523,
-0.9567339420318604,
-0.6206716299057007,
-0.11945736408233643,
-0.5388866066932678,
-0.3233729600906372,
0.2912713885307312,
-1.0218849182128906,
-0.33386364579200745,
0.027325181290507317,
0.4259452819824219,
-0.47998976707458496,
-0.05457565560936928,
0.40598270297050476,
-0.08582556247711182,
0.07867003977298737,
0.5956438183784485,
-0.9640616774559021,
0.15152016282081604,
0.31401145458221436,
0.9581155180931091,
-0.076558418571949,
-0.4348991811275482,
-0.5336586236953735,
0.6544693112373352,
-0.3078221082687378,
1.0517935752868652,
-0.7054579257965088,
-0.5104824900627136,
0.43202096223831177,
-0.06962798535823822,
0.27630218863487244,
-0.516869843006134,
0.2769964933395386,
-0.4814985394477844,
0.11167818307876587,
-0.14516720175743103,
-0.38463717699050903,
-0.330147922039032,
0.025755103677511215,
-0.7414155602455139,
0.9676733613014221,
-0.24658802151679993,
-0.7866640090942383,
0.37077146768569946,
-0.7418965101242065,
-0.6814862489700317,
0.34951648116111755,
-0.06003399193286896,
-0.4085701107978821,
0.04039144515991211,
0.380985826253891,
0.36604297161102295,
-0.034830231219530106,
0.23074249923229218,
-0.14672288298606873,
-0.28581762313842773,
0.25865182280540466,
-0.5319236516952515,
0.21345026791095734,
0.42639854550361633,
-0.021146055310964584,
0.23823405802249908,
-0.6065534949302673,
-0.33781495690345764,
-0.11697663366794586,
-0.2935621738433838,
0.11017221212387085,
0.03327127546072006,
0.1759987771511078,
0.16030307114124298,
-0.2558342516422272,
-0.14212515950202942,
0.33579421043395996,
-0.13040027022361755,
0.6761263012886047,
0.4896171987056732,
0.19803626835346222,
0.6962946057319641,
-0.31038403511047363,
0.9929475784301758,
-0.3691841661930084,
0.15769995748996735,
-0.7122880816459656,
-0.33219775557518005,
-0.4946867823600769,
-0.5350151062011719,
-0.47607511281967163,
0.35653001070022583,
-0.8266845345497131,
0.3015265166759491,
-0.00459122471511364,
-0.19471417367458344,
-0.12839454412460327,
0.2894457280635834,
0.02937607653439045,
0.26565325260162354,
0.3101281523704529,
-0.3438721001148224,
-0.4792744517326355,
-0.4817379415035248,
0.072865329682827,
-0.043685246258974075,
-0.27559009194374084,
0.06163296476006508,
0.2775554358959198,
-0.09830734878778458,
1.2095048427581787,
-0.8359900712966919,
-0.5604314208030701,
-0.304913192987442,
0.5646053552627563,
-0.3201049566268921,
0.33170273900032043,
0.2687718868255615,
-0.7062143683433533,
-0.46764135360717773,
0.09717819094657898,
-0.9915406107902527,
-0.00783836655318737,
-0.3984328508377075,
0.3930358588695526,
-0.2646745443344116,
0.27387282252311707,
-0.9409595131874084,
0.7792934775352478,
0.3971380889415741,
0.06885585188865662,
0.850896954536438,
-0.7169755697250366,
0.4446456730365753,
-0.9521006345748901,
-0.21325822174549103,
0.1582130640745163,
0.14027583599090576,
-0.3862713873386383,
0.023218728601932526,
-0.41737332940101624,
-0.3962293565273285,
-0.4066561460494995,
0.19958369433879852,
-0.17726561427116394,
-0.3545127213001251,
-0.3059519827365875,
0.04072343185544014,
0.43796658515930176,
0.3701745569705963,
0.3332277536392212,
0.8101377487182617,
0.6932477951049805,
-0.6137562990188599,
0.5781161189079285,
0.5569050908088684,
-0.41104939579963684,
0.5356187224388123,
-0.6532055139541626,
0.03982287272810936,
-0.2797498404979706,
0.3670414686203003,
-1.0124915838241577,
-0.6523683071136475,
0.45276761054992676,
-0.40996280312538147,
-0.15870903432369232,
-0.3151612877845764,
-0.5182400345802307,
-0.13764995336532593,
-0.460306316614151,
0.5930857062339783,
0.2092479169368744,
-0.6378210783004761,
0.7469967603683472,
-0.0508725643157959,
-0.4966258108615875,
-0.3521079421043396,
-0.6422183513641357,
0.5942824482917786,
-0.5234361886978149,
-0.8237126469612122,
0.8407514691352844,
-0.21410895884037018,
0.07819906622171402,
0.15797178447246552,
-0.013776648789644241,
-0.617773175239563,
-0.44285130500793457,
0.4499291777610779,
0.12971997261047363,
0.016927406191825867,
0.03290301561355591,
0.2596903443336487,
-0.20270690321922302,
-0.20165662467479706,
-0.059332866221666336,
0.17320232093334198,
0.3537828326225281,
-0.05674373358488083,
-0.6903983950614929,
0.7077058553695679,
0.43390223383903503,
-0.6368603706359863,
0.028986824676394463,
1.0943353176116943,
-0.3696892261505127,
-0.13579495251178741,
-0.3642619550228119,
-0.08809974044561386,
-0.5029304623603821,
0.7212309837341309,
-0.3721892535686493,
-0.9266917109489441,
0.449968159198761,
0.12386292219161987,
0.040665678679943085,
0.13063523173332214,
0.44172900915145874,
-0.4114517867565155,
0.9498588442802429,
0.4382343292236328,
0.37055283784866333,
0.6525479555130005,
-0.49939823150634766,
0.18880736827850342,
-0.6429907083511353,
-0.2601127326488495,
-0.40617185831069946,
0.09515152126550674,
-0.1405300348997116,
-0.46164748072624207,
0.3361528515815735,
0.2483605295419693,
0.008936374448239803,
0.5193125605583191,
-0.5556095838546753,
0.5950418710708618,
-0.1846971958875656,
0.06217249855399132,
0.42623409628868103,
0.011863335967063904,
0.5498826503753662,
-0.4113127291202545,
-0.6029500365257263,
-0.5698652863502502,
0.6182902455329895,
0.2269674837589264,
0.9838950634002686,
0.2031160145998001,
0.35554221272468567,
0.8372563123703003,
-0.03469644486904144,
-0.6930127739906311,
0.6584138870239258,
-0.1934436708688736,
-0.07613392174243927,
-0.2980589270591736,
0.028997156769037247,
-0.4843367636203766,
0.1324942260980606,
-0.476571649312973,
-0.4938454329967499,
-0.17964904010295868,
0.18141408264636993,
-0.8096848726272583,
0.397286981344223,
-0.33433932065963745,
0.8012433648109436,
0.15428730845451355,
-0.7123895883560181,
-0.5650955438613892,
-0.3659752309322357,
0.26941874623298645,
0.23435349762439728,
0.0383012592792511,
0.1252051293849945,
-0.08744166046380997,
0.4725285768508911,
-0.6702257394790649,
0.5576713681221008,
0.15826621651649475,
0.04242879897356033,
0.736328125,
0.5278627276420593,
0.4622241258621216,
0.7091506123542786,
0.36238425970077515,
-0.15191207826137543,
-0.19159798324108124,
0.08655001223087311,
-0.8964772820472717,
0.4322867691516876,
-0.5850276350975037,
-0.27989262342453003,
-0.15789736807346344,
-0.6612515449523926,
0.385986328125,
-0.1752595603466034,
0.4043196737766266,
0.6039417386054993,
-0.3373159170150757,
0.2191794514656067,
0.8478135466575623,
-0.5746369361877441,
0.9323274493217468,
0.1438881754875183,
-0.10225701332092285,
-0.7300451993942261,
0.8321282267570496,
-0.2001010626554489,
0.0025534075684845448,
0.39395731687545776,
0.07612355798482895,
-0.13802731037139893,
-0.51084965467453,
-0.6137406826019287,
-0.2676738500595093,
-0.523513913154602,
-0.2993302047252655,
-0.9625076055526733,
-0.12340743094682693,
-0.26703211665153503,
-0.6629803776741028,
-0.47514718770980835,
-0.046229273080825806,
-0.6017577648162842,
-0.3725571632385254,
0.3965355455875397,
0.7600870728492737,
-0.26600363850593567,
0.5909721255302429,
-0.7938801646232605,
0.6156635284423828,
0.8867455720901489,
0.1151561364531517,
-0.18042753636837006,
-0.7087151408195496,
-0.364795446395874,
-0.28216901421546936,
-0.5258796811103821,
-0.7645746469497681,
0.5333154201507568,
0.31076478958129883,
-0.027732737362384796,
0.786950409412384,
-0.14151427149772644,
1.1579231023788452,
-0.2988363802433014,
0.893417477607727,
0.4856981635093689,
-0.7845506072044373,
0.42233312129974365,
-0.5256626009941101,
0.14680883288383484,
0.16262635588645935,
-0.07963337004184723,
-0.6370203495025635,
-0.12272881716489792,
-0.18842443823814392,
-0.7243891954421997,
0.6346516013145447,
0.2552916705608368,
0.4030100405216217,
0.12862373888492584,
0.4082302451133728,
0.43997934460639954,
-0.1308736950159073,
-0.6703418493270874,
0.11750852316617966,
-0.8572431206703186,
0.12755531072616577,
0.19357171654701233,
-0.35588139295578003,
0.03275495767593384,
-0.25212550163269043,
0.36041492223739624,
-0.19496095180511475,
0.10963720083236694,
0.21910320222377777,
-0.2891126871109009,
-0.32233840227127075,
0.29059016704559326,
0.4306015372276306,
0.40261110663414,
-0.09843344241380692,
0.022235626354813576,
0.0066244942136108875,
-0.3916876018047333,
0.18192243576049805,
-0.11459701508283615,
-0.3804856240749359,
0.08162325620651245,
0.5004011392593384,
0.6187029480934143,
0.27761343121528625,
-0.5116065740585327,
0.46387752890586853,
0.1339053511619568,
-0.44159236550331116,
-0.3644319772720337,
0.1985221952199936,
-0.25474813580513,
0.15653061866760254,
0.35688814520835876,
0.47592809796333313,
0.29642319679260254,
-0.3102729618549347,
0.43099069595336914,
0.03072437457740307,
-0.226141095161438,
-0.6254017949104309,
0.8322817087173462,
0.15440645813941956,
-0.5675250887870789,
0.39354121685028076,
-0.23986579477787018,
-0.10722959041595459,
0.3466223478317261,
0.3467111587524414,
1.1301920413970947,
-0.07850345969200134,
1.0044363737106323,
0.46539023518562317,
0.010634028352797031,
-0.2158576101064682,
-0.5030723214149475,
-0.38351598381996155,
-0.7423485517501831,
-0.5850104093551636,
-0.2343471646308899,
-0.010876377113163471,
0.1532021015882492,
-1.1091548204421997,
0.22481195628643036,
-0.49748581647872925,
-0.0709231048822403,
0.14061307907104492,
-0.2900821566581726,
-0.4976625144481659,
0.22578135132789612,
0.009190530516207218,
0.6221962571144104,
-1.0407732725143433,
0.9188612699508667,
0.696138858795166,
-0.8790882229804993,
-0.5001716017723083,
0.026342909783124924,
-0.006171386688947678,
-0.24978062510490417,
0.3383597433567047,
0.11459912359714508,
-0.14806193113327026,
-0.2662964165210724,
-0.3196500241756439,
-0.4170651435852051,
1.1054120063781738,
0.3118565082550049,
-0.22697295248508453,
-0.26563844084739685,
0.1940116435289383,
0.3919704258441925,
-0.5809618234634399,
0.18326310813426971,
0.1940004825592041,
0.30146458745002747,
0.5782544612884521,
-0.12852723896503448,
-0.4291864037513733,
-0.04093209281563759,
0.36309412121772766,
-0.2898559868335724,
-0.3944511413574219,
0.7261159420013428,
-0.36854004859924316,
-0.2505090534687042,
0.37244150042533875,
1.0369436740875244,
-0.09947800636291504,
0.3300361633300781,
0.44268640875816345,
0.6607584953308105,
-0.00785785261541605,
0.19606156647205353,
0.5669555068016052,
0.07113748788833618,
0.30787014961242676,
1.372707486152649,
-0.2816435396671295,
0.3398382365703583,
0.4030553102493286,
-0.1076875701546669,
0.46369481086730957,
0.5176671743392944,
-0.09995270520448685,
0.8032294511795044,
-0.20964424312114716,
-0.6154309511184692,
-0.4641548693180084,
-0.1868445873260498,
-0.07065195590257645,
0.7187973856925964,
0.047598887234926224,
-0.1025056466460228,
-0.35882630944252014,
0.48633694648742676,
-0.07842990756034851,
0.5223240256309509,
-0.17405113577842712,
0.8660786747932434,
-0.33712780475616455,
-0.4911266267299652,
-0.14910779893398285,
0.08137760311365128,
0.417741060256958,
-0.6051961183547974,
-0.3735398054122925,
-0.35014328360557556,
-0.1003512516617775,
-0.5723638534545898,
-0.9484599232673645,
0.6266027688980103,
0.4210946261882782,
-0.35429444909095764,
-0.6011978387832642,
0.5648084282875061,
-0.5841711759567261,
-0.16460150480270386,
0.08252432942390442,
-0.06373079866170883,
-0.11732777953147888,
-0.13537664711475372,
-0.714099645614624,
0.40183547139167786,
-0.11913441866636276,
-0.23737762868404388,
0.2785116732120514,
0.42978623509407043,
0.17982004582881927,
0.6591761112213135,
0.4357442259788513,
-0.09222684800624847,
-0.18898960947990417,
0.17691411077976227,
0.8124071359634399,
-0.4226093888282776,
-0.6113747358322144,
-0.7374531626701355,
0.5114941000938416,
0.23385252058506012,
-0.17901335656642914,
0.6590624451637268,
0.6014086008071899,
0.876064121723175,
-0.2090175747871399,
0.9251748919487,
-0.4040372669696808,
-0.2481217086315155,
-0.3877120316028595,
0.41786104440689087,
-0.3768834173679352,
0.14175841212272644,
-0.5981895923614502,
-0.9635728001594543,
-0.25748634338378906,
0.7403436899185181,
0.12088917940855026,
-0.18778061866760254,
0.673795223236084,
1.0597516298294067,
0.004709761124104261,
0.32847219705581665,
0.34287312626838684,
0.020272010937333107,
0.433377206325531,
0.31486475467681885,
1.0949265956878662,
-0.3432201147079468,
0.8504243493080139,
-0.3692730665206909,
-0.01539083942770958,
-0.052775051444768906,
-0.9310973286628723,
-0.5621440410614014,
-0.6023346781730652,
-0.7326264381408691,
-0.06595999747514725,
0.10679320245981216,
0.7366755604743958,
0.84815913438797,
-0.24418839812278748,
-0.3123351037502289,
-0.051276903599500656,
-0.129337877035141,
-0.5366554856300354,
-0.23055647313594818,
0.29041701555252075,
0.19303877651691437,
-0.46273481845855713,
0.5339927673339844,
1.012408971786499,
-0.25508418679237366,
-0.28357967734336853,
-0.3370572626590729,
0.11228231340646744,
-0.07025954872369766,
0.6326159238815308,
0.48549672961235046,
-0.5814405083656311,
-0.5186768770217896,
-0.3004091680049896,
0.0978807732462883,
0.24164807796478271,
1.1998213529586792,
-0.36660075187683105,
0.8211688995361328,
0.2969411313533783,
0.4876076579093933,
0.846969485282898,
0.11013375967741013,
0.41458073258399963,
-0.679741621017456,
0.3371231257915497,
-0.04803568497300148,
0.05234864726662636,
0.35267066955566406,
-0.312979519367218,
0.2328546792268753,
0.23721131682395935,
-0.3628183603286743,
-0.44061803817749023,
0.2730817496776581,
-1.0238407850265503,
-0.1925135999917984,
1.0003780126571655,
-0.36768484115600586,
0.2541274130344391,
-0.012317477725446224,
-0.419830322265625,
0.3105854392051697,
-0.22409790754318237,
0.9707658886909485,
0.33660656213760376,
-0.1009211391210556,
-0.4368697702884674,
-0.5618308186531067,
0.5652796030044556,
0.17252781987190247,
-0.7008346915245056,
0.35135969519615173,
0.7520475387573242,
0.28580501675605774,
-0.4419269859790802,
0.7071085572242737,
-0.11134122312068939,
0.42068907618522644,
-0.14455601572990417,
0.23387965559959412,
-0.5746921896934509,
-0.7239429354667664,
-0.49978867173194885,
0.4561230540275574,
-0.3700636029243469,
-0.2963792085647583
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.