id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00040v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00040v2
|
Unveiling Themes in Judicial Proceedings: A Cross-Country Study Using Topic Modeling on Legal Documents from India and the UK
| 2024-05-27T16:26:50 | 2024-06-30T04:37:19 |
Krish Didwania, Dr. Durga Toshniwal, Amit Agarwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Legal documents are indispensable in every country for legal practices and
serve as the primary source of information regarding previous cases and
employed statutes. In today's world, with an increasing number of judicial
cases, it is crucial to systematically categorize past cases into subgroups,
which can then be utilized for upcoming cases and practices. Our primary focus
in this endeavor was to annotate cases using topic modeling algorithms such as
Latent Dirichlet Allocation, Non-Negative Matrix Factorization, and Bertopic
for a collection of lengthy legal documents from India and the UK. This step is
crucial for distinguishing the generated labels between the two countries,
highlighting the differences in the types of cases that arise in each
jurisdiction. Furthermore, an analysis of the timeline of cases from India was
conducted to discern the evolution of dominant topics over the years.
|
[
-0.5305780172348022,
-0.5501973628997803,
0.622093141078949,
0.13021700084209442,
-0.8651767373085022,
0.00402786722406745,
-0.043654754757881165,
-0.19043655693531036,
0.33470842242240906,
0.6314921379089355,
-0.4531308114528656,
-0.3033513128757477,
-0.5288522839546204,
-0.28117436170578003,
-0.806194543838501,
1.1178778409957886,
0.09504718333482742,
0.2583736479282379,
-0.3879733085632324,
-0.3255624771118164,
-0.6111059188842773,
-0.5962211489677429,
-0.0027838514652103186,
-0.3396517336368561,
0.3943587839603424,
0.29800358414649963,
0.06148484721779823,
0.21604295074939728,
0.8628138899803162,
0.27769938111305237,
-0.48937493562698364,
-0.21301327645778656,
-0.13588868081569672,
0.40047428011894226,
-0.6758043169975281,
-0.6400331258773804,
-0.1741465926170349,
0.18509243428707123,
0.3779699504375458,
0.4572996497154236,
-0.41978710889816284,
0.018577955663204193,
-0.43888744711875916,
0.53553706407547,
-0.6181480884552002,
0.05849768593907356,
-0.6150956153869629,
0.41006162762641907,
-0.563718318939209,
-0.5220637321472168,
-0.128239706158638,
-0.2195320725440979,
0.2634834945201874,
-0.5139672756195068,
0.5249320268630981,
-0.15799042582511902,
0.9135477542877197,
-0.054407503455877304,
-0.474350243806839,
-0.7322894334793091,
-0.7884955406188965,
0.5285214781761169,
-0.3319929838180542,
0.23235313594341278,
0.2662212550640106,
0.3763379454612732,
0.04775511473417282,
-0.786774754524231,
-0.07814262062311172,
-0.0037739849649369717,
-0.11980950832366943,
0.277323454618454,
0.014095849357545376,
-0.2591991126537323,
0.36147743463516235,
0.36541834473609924,
-0.4549393057823181,
-0.02366863749921322,
-0.6285097002983093,
-0.3428589105606079,
0.70478355884552,
0.08246456831693649,
0.5334553718566895,
-0.252725750207901,
0.1891661286354065,
0.08145353943109512,
-0.8292266130447388,
0.03208903223276138,
0.4192490577697754,
0.5525091290473938,
-0.33602967858314514,
0.48908260464668274,
-0.1690085232257843,
0.43470245599746704,
0.2922883927822113,
-0.28984537720680237,
-0.1502343714237213,
-0.35865363478660583,
0.16376729309558868,
0.2957451045513153,
0.2711534798145294,
0.4040472209453583,
-0.020689645782113075,
0.06628239154815674,
-0.0487041100859642,
-0.43435442447662354,
0.3663027286529541,
-0.6744672656059265,
0.17366892099380493,
0.11502964794635773,
-0.8165332078933716,
-0.10593462735414505,
0.19649627804756165,
-0.901721179485321,
-0.8158113360404968,
-0.5878133177757263,
0.06860259175300598,
0.17363594472408295,
-0.3681216835975647,
-0.28505200147628784,
-0.21007125079631805,
0.5978465676307678,
0.6136139631271362,
-0.7988961935043335,
-0.1564594805240631,
1.051534652709961,
0.6178777813911438,
0.21590343117713928,
0.340371698141098,
-0.3461003303527832,
0.0749896913766861,
-0.4695185422897339,
0.9173756241798401,
-0.8321096301078796,
-0.7234852910041809,
0.49119246006011963,
0.26349353790283203,
0.4644794762134552,
-0.2088717818260193,
0.7624807357788086,
-0.6647524237632751,
0.16786962747573853,
-0.5744661092758179,
-0.41526633501052856,
0.04283054918050766,
0.10899966955184937,
-0.4352845549583435,
0.30531737208366394,
-0.25867578387260437,
-0.9352941513061523,
0.9328644275665283,
-0.8964881896972656,
-0.5731058716773987,
0.18323566019535065,
-0.7216943502426147,
-0.6172555685043335,
0.430504709482193,
0.15010464191436768,
0.24766191840171814,
-0.5618472099304199,
0.7920423150062561,
-0.01797078177332878,
-0.24209289252758026,
-0.1846788376569748,
-0.07868087291717529,
0.8694097399711609,
0.37727344036102295,
0.1218838319182396,
0.13749097287654877,
-0.5002964735031128,
-0.6234135627746582,
0.08994609117507935,
-0.029293067753314972,
-0.5175836086273193,
0.287517249584198,
-0.1093166321516037,
0.564382016658783,
0.258543998003006,
-0.6157610416412354,
0.22834523022174835,
-0.10375326871871948,
0.6557886004447937,
0.2880222201347351,
0.6237057447433472,
0.210174560546875,
-0.21496742963790894,
0.5482264161109924,
0.3426830768585205,
-0.009653025306761265,
-0.5201535224914551,
-0.7795854806900024,
-0.4447316825389862,
0.21804025769233704,
0.6652200818061829,
0.4649636745452881,
-0.2771548330783844,
-0.11760836839675903,
-0.17644557356834412,
-0.3855195641517639,
-0.32393649220466614,
-0.17893964052200317,
0.08981742709875107,
0.27612027525901794,
-0.16475479304790497,
-0.5697998404502869,
-0.3953804075717926,
-1.1894241571426392,
-0.25725093483924866,
-0.4242779612541199,
0.30546560883522034,
0.43343472480773926,
0.6293824911117554,
0.15077374875545502,
1.0799592733383179,
-0.3320108652114868,
-0.047259874641895294,
0.014871199615299702,
0.7843079566955566,
0.09435837715864182,
0.3745560646057129,
0.4586534798145294,
-1.40268874168396,
-0.41134965419769287,
0.16297537088394165,
-0.7998741865158081,
-0.2797543406486511,
-0.3979718089103699,
-0.29010140895843506,
0.16774939000606537,
0.7573331594467163,
-0.16891004145145416,
0.9338844418525696,
-0.39340439438819885,
-0.390543133020401,
0.40815261006355286,
-0.2711043059825897,
0.42188557982444763,
-1.1170969009399414,
-0.03526395186781883,
0.15320757031440735,
-0.006727526895701885,
-0.4533724784851074,
0.06419047713279724,
0.22430036962032318,
-0.6070448160171509,
-0.39497214555740356,
0.3332434594631195,
-0.3235098719596863,
-0.13886509835720062,
-0.3910416066646576,
-0.07893302291631699,
-0.04497472569346428,
0.16470828652381897,
0.2825078070163727,
0.7619240283966064,
0.6693897843360901,
-0.10302601009607315,
-0.06669877469539642,
0.24649447202682495,
0.11552660912275314,
0.8752654790878296,
-0.10843353718519211,
-0.26147568225860596,
-0.16068530082702637,
-0.14994440972805023,
-0.7907443046569824,
-0.2444772571325302,
0.10503584146499634,
-0.052178021520376205,
0.7863355875015259,
-0.7722123861312866,
-0.4143403470516205,
-0.2421342432498932,
-0.08588884025812149,
0.0515909381210804,
0.5295873284339905,
-0.041936106979846954,
0.5811816453933716,
0.6590881943702698,
-0.6314500570297241,
-0.3727947175502777,
-0.5529101490974426,
0.09445709735155106,
-0.6576684713363647,
-0.16984982788562775,
0.3218228220939636,
0.3573496341705322,
-0.5693747997283936,
0.02236754074692726,
-0.230709508061409,
-0.2156599462032318,
-0.07314639538526535,
0.7044745683670044,
-0.26018381118774414,
-0.047601208090782166,
0.2412252575159073,
0.2104094922542572,
-0.011722732335329056,
0.29646602272987366,
0.0903586819767952,
0.42835476994514465,
0.22302988171577454,
-0.7962369918823242,
-0.5010504722595215,
0.9260173439979553,
0.5701549053192139,
-0.5201866626739502,
0.2596578896045685,
-0.08007201552391052,
-0.4775918424129486,
-0.05679073557257652,
-0.572594165802002,
-0.1428486406803131,
-0.4200334846973419,
0.10216093063354492,
-0.36944493651390076,
-0.5424723625183105,
0.6672096848487854,
-0.3398573696613312,
0.27754300832748413,
0.703869640827179,
0.6785809993743896,
-0.06570715457201004,
0.33221903443336487,
0.9856763482093811,
-0.15850692987442017,
0.6383364796638489,
0.1672600954771042,
0.5697960257530212,
-0.43007975816726685,
-0.33892491459846497,
-0.7281461954116821,
0.32357800006866455,
-1.0402445793151855,
-0.35463055968284607,
0.188623309135437,
0.13698828220367432,
0.11567828804254532,
0.1400635838508606,
-0.4125286936759949,
0.4682057797908783,
0.5092032551765442,
-0.11791263520717621,
0.022262591868638992,
0.24732297658920288,
-0.6480002999305725,
-0.19669115543365479,
-0.2963966727256775,
-0.5255548357963562,
1.2798701524734497,
0.19772350788116455,
0.4279474914073944,
-0.06893014162778854,
0.916460394859314,
0.5992292165756226,
0.230521559715271,
-0.3128455579280853,
0.4011855721473694,
-0.4235170781612396,
-0.8812471628189087,
-0.12842263281345367,
0.26856738328933716,
-0.819146990776062,
0.27221521735191345,
-0.02067079022526741,
-0.9084047079086304,
0.6238115429878235,
-0.35872164368629456,
-0.37167036533355713,
0.31087517738342285,
-0.16133587062358856,
0.29249149560928345,
-0.017514236271381378,
-0.8632405996322632,
-0.2544388771057129,
-0.6720516681671143,
0.4855060577392578,
-0.21300828456878662,
0.11845602095127106,
0.013599800877273083,
0.479814738035202,
0.8195366859436035,
-0.4243522882461548,
0.5629203915596008,
-0.129394993185997,
-0.3861403465270996,
0.6718385815620422,
-0.29842278361320496,
-0.029022803530097008,
0.36888083815574646,
0.16538074612617493,
-0.1135328859090805,
-0.1354997754096985,
-0.14203138649463654,
-0.6050403118133545,
0.46167996525764465,
-0.5570958256721497,
-1.0822340250015259,
-0.7228455543518066,
-0.6127612590789795,
0.015107453800737858,
-0.032420381903648376,
0.0034302962012588978,
0.5963441729545593,
0.024084193632006645,
0.22765414416790009,
0.7301574349403381,
-0.25933098793029785,
0.7575319409370422,
0.7822298407554626,
-0.27935004234313965,
-0.004900757689028978,
0.855243980884552,
0.4585817754268646,
-0.5833825469017029,
0.4897845387458801,
0.12805907428264618,
-0.41098010540008545,
-0.7373524308204651,
-0.17518079280853271,
0.19487783312797546,
-0.9719710946083069,
0.12330392003059387,
-0.5255680680274963,
-0.32503098249435425,
-0.34866493940353394,
-0.2805154323577881,
-0.16522033512592316,
-0.4979957342147827,
0.06000719219446182,
0.1735946089029312,
0.42906320095062256,
0.6523802280426025,
-0.36696571111679077,
0.05227559059858322,
-0.39236828684806824,
0.3499513864517212,
0.4862919747829437,
0.19008998572826385,
-0.43255484104156494,
-0.6192529797554016,
0.05698467791080475,
-0.3776863217353821,
-0.6362537741661072,
-0.8138437271118164,
0.2627197802066803,
-0.2344074249267578,
0.7526478171348572,
0.7842854261398315,
-0.12509240210056305,
0.7717036604881287,
-0.6664819717407227,
0.8803389668464661,
-0.19337253272533417,
-0.6402970552444458,
1.3385697603225708,
-0.6999753713607788,
-0.10422383248806,
0.6567025184631348,
0.6253238320350647,
-0.4521923363208771,
-0.19274789094924927,
-0.7468094229698181,
-1.088423490524292,
0.8372226357460022,
0.3283770680427551,
0.04624323546886444,
0.501157820224762,
0.8137586116790771,
0.0076934159733355045,
0.3791242241859436,
-0.42120084166526794,
-0.003457170445472002,
0.043220557272434235,
0.36768990755081177,
0.16185903549194336,
-0.20166738331317902,
-0.40493860840797424,
-0.45880135893821716,
0.5999151468276978,
0.3820163309574127,
0.5104559063911438,
0.20138181746006012,
-0.21053573489189148,
-0.02292667329311371,
0.47534018754959106,
0.9701050519943237,
0.967729926109314,
-0.36846455931663513,
-0.2593190371990204,
-0.2938537299633026,
-0.4811389744281769,
0.2243308275938034,
0.3724460303783417,
-0.29184454679489136,
0.0024870606139302254,
0.4413332939147949,
0.47292837500572205,
-0.18915550410747528,
-0.28655147552490234,
0.311745285987854,
-0.19218707084655762,
-0.21932648122310638,
-0.32668519020080566,
-0.21375243365764618,
0.25584784150123596,
0.4358333945274353,
0.5390170812606812,
-0.45515933632850647,
0.2617613673210144,
-0.8634717464447021,
0.5847634077072144,
0.11184877902269363,
-0.5399706363677979,
0.14309118688106537,
0.5643267631530762,
0.2582343518733978,
-0.3404892086982727,
0.4234611988067627,
-0.2289751172065735,
-0.3871593773365021,
0.9480419754981995,
0.24391639232635498,
0.6823458075523376,
0.11526432633399963,
0.16192898154258728,
0.19690316915512085,
0.09024810045957565,
0.09280151128768921,
0.3633570671081543,
-0.42463621497154236,
-0.04619571194052696,
-0.03629714995622635,
-0.6366823315620422,
-0.612328827381134,
0.03494013845920563,
-0.9292854070663452,
0.12251225113868713,
-0.14767952263355255,
-0.21340954303741455,
0.11156793683767319,
0.5947632789611816,
-0.4159815013408661,
0.14317519962787628,
0.3776448369026184,
0.7565608620643616,
-1.2972391843795776,
0.7388224005699158,
0.8120006918907166,
-0.5743237733840942,
-0.21118392050266266,
0.3651283383369446,
0.33421003818511963,
-0.16705909371376038,
0.8222800493240356,
0.024297920987010002,
0.254154235124588,
-0.6034677028656006,
-0.3931557834148407,
-0.5860209465026855,
1.1927976608276367,
-0.4409220218658447,
-0.9089193344116211,
0.25086793303489685,
0.4638471007347107,
0.5892702341079712,
-0.45194146037101746,
0.08518682420253754,
0.32565706968307495,
0.1705879420042038,
0.17176251113414764,
-0.5961315631866455,
-0.2638583779335022,
-0.594749391078949,
0.1591193974018097,
0.3161783814430237,
-0.6006107926368713,
1.0268206596374512,
0.23274439573287964,
-0.0018406854942440987,
-0.34402742981910706,
0.6763180494308472,
0.5708928108215332,
0.5905064940452576,
0.1295599639415741,
0.3836895227432251,
0.6975690722465515,
-0.4259207546710968,
0.9545028805732727,
-0.492391973733902,
0.17212259769439697,
1.045210361480713,
-0.8516119122505188,
0.5402393937110901,
0.6745617389678955,
-0.13675782084465027,
0.2103058099746704,
0.8530600666999817,
-0.12034521996974945,
0.8742853999137878,
0.464233934879303,
-0.0014212974347174168,
-0.28771132230758667,
-0.47197771072387695,
-0.5167019367218018,
0.5344770550727844,
0.7334458231925964,
-0.47557348012924194,
-0.8579737544059753,
0.05525882914662361,
-0.25325122475624084,
0.20492078363895416,
-0.5861554741859436,
0.814359724521637,
-0.22322724759578705,
-0.6479955911636353,
-0.4420224726200104,
0.32486432790756226,
0.3346850275993347,
-0.5764351487159729,
-0.32737746834754944,
-0.711931586265564,
-0.3427036702632904,
0.17405696213245392,
-0.7041677236557007,
0.3299869894981384,
0.28470733761787415,
-0.20365183055400848,
-0.2589736580848694,
1.0549304485321045,
-0.172909215092659,
-0.6969807744026184,
-0.017040597274899483,
0.556794285774231,
0.28856176137924194,
0.19143250584602356,
-0.7475197315216064,
-0.14834222197532654,
-0.3119995594024658,
-0.07247191667556763,
0.41350436210632324,
0.8153786063194275,
-0.9834056496620178,
0.31243422627449036,
0.2501160502433777,
-0.15529558062553406,
0.02490455098450184,
0.16366149485111237,
0.9648979306221008,
-0.6944770812988281,
-0.720112681388855,
-0.630171537399292,
0.6548652052879333,
-0.43591809272766113,
-0.3424272835254669,
0.5266385078430176,
0.605178952217102,
0.30987945199012756,
0.2301570475101471,
0.5558927059173584,
-0.11798757314682007,
0.41022220253944397,
-0.42621541023254395,
1.0542680025100708,
-0.5844250321388245,
0.17033176124095917,
-0.24770629405975342,
-0.5770893692970276,
-0.12110792845487595,
0.49731242656707764,
-0.4789797365665436,
0.012494070455431938,
0.3811573386192322,
0.5765926837921143,
-0.22809556126594543,
0.22093193233013153,
0.266195148229599,
-0.3000473976135254,
0.2355298399925232,
0.17971430718898773,
0.8616338968276978,
-0.07212571054697037,
-0.030119238421320915,
-0.566275954246521,
0.2681117057800293,
-0.3983632028102875,
-0.9015703201293945,
-0.8715583086013794,
-0.7566114068031311,
-0.552386999130249,
0.07282557338476181,
0.21684500575065613,
0.7051684260368347,
0.7670560479164124,
-1.179089069366455,
-0.32588884234428406,
-0.19525064527988434,
0.09693199396133423,
0.5470064282417297,
-0.16885997354984283,
0.6079537868499756,
-0.23511596024036407,
-0.39758923649787903,
-0.003420927096158266,
0.24393890798091888,
-0.03567799553275108,
-0.24049286544322968,
0.5702707171440125,
-0.6791626214981079,
0.24262626469135284,
0.5239282846450806,
0.3837314248085022,
-0.7920728325843811,
0.08384741842746735,
-0.6580126881599426,
0.1297532171010971,
0.3169517517089844,
1.4523594379425049,
-0.2852365970611572,
0.5807886123657227,
0.5436674356460571,
0.405977338552475,
0.6905671954154968,
0.23177866637706757,
0.4435974359512329,
-0.8370127081871033,
0.4920726716518402,
0.09796024113893509,
0.6553786396980286,
0.039011359214782715,
-0.26941969990730286,
0.5911124348640442,
0.19756220281124115,
-0.3799717426300049,
-0.9727989435195923,
0.02945329248905182,
-0.7173643112182617,
-0.6638004779815674,
0.6210702657699585,
-0.2767454981803894,
-0.0752437561750412,
-0.40129873156547546,
0.006615821737796068,
0.3887288570404053,
-0.3501068949699402,
0.7861048579216003,
1.1910347938537598,
-0.2206999510526657,
-0.10387192666530609,
-0.91321861743927,
0.30673179030418396,
0.17078058421611786,
-0.8178614974021912,
-0.2032339870929718,
0.34534502029418945,
0.21376267075538635,
0.661150336265564,
0.4200993776321411,
-0.6570430397987366,
0.28988802433013916,
0.017611179500818253,
0.11529136449098587,
0.3324846923351288,
-0.5532072186470032,
-0.6599802374839783,
0.6833427548408508,
-0.3117421269416809,
0.1470130831003189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00039v1
|
How Ready Are Generative Pre-trained Large Language Models for Explaining Bengali Grammatical Errors?
| 2024-05-27T15:56:45 | 2024-05-27T15:56:45 |
Subhankar Maity, Aniket Deroy, Sudeshna Sarkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Grammatical error correction (GEC) tools, powered by advanced generative
artificial intelligence (AI), competently correct linguistic inaccuracies in
user input. However, they often fall short in providing essential natural
language explanations, which are crucial for learning languages and gaining a
deeper understanding of the grammatical rules. There is limited exploration of
these tools in low-resource languages such as Bengali. In such languages,
grammatical error explanation (GEE) systems should not only correct sentences
but also provide explanations for errors. This comprehensive approach can help
language learners in their quest for proficiency. Our work introduces a
real-world, multi-domain dataset sourced from Bengali speakers of varying
proficiency levels and linguistic complexities. This dataset serves as an
evaluation benchmark for GEE systems, allowing them to use context information
to generate meaningful explanations and high-quality corrections. Various
generative pre-trained large language models (LLMs), including GPT-4 Turbo,
GPT-3.5 Turbo, Text-davinci-003, Text-babbage-001, Text-curie-001,
Text-ada-001, Llama-2-7b, Llama-2-13b, and Llama-2-70b, are assessed against
human experts for performance comparison. Our research underscores the
limitations in the automatic deployment of current state-of-the-art generative
pre-trained LLMs for Bengali GEE. Advocating for human intervention, our
findings propose incorporating manual checks to address grammatical errors and
improve feedback quality. This approach presents a more suitable strategy to
refine the GEC tools in Bengali, emphasizing the educational aspect of language
learning.
|
[
-0.11203783750534058,
-0.9081791043281555,
0.39460116624832153,
0.3186010718345642,
-0.14510133862495422,
0.044775161892175674,
-0.35642004013061523,
-0.06332852691411972,
-0.2038358598947525,
0.01304540690034628,
-0.5457633137702942,
-0.41040533781051636,
-0.6319079399108887,
0.4240037798881531,
-0.2620573043823242,
0.9823369979858398,
-0.06794101744890213,
0.21711376309394836,
-0.33150148391723633,
0.2758995592594147,
-0.6387394666671753,
-0.5128607153892517,
-0.3932415246963501,
-0.11648731678724289,
0.44325828552246094,
0.34676703810691833,
0.5114945769309998,
0.13910548388957977,
0.12947547435760498,
0.4321088492870331,
-0.24400217831134796,
0.293253630399704,
-0.23471763730049133,
-0.11491981893777847,
-0.23679597675800323,
-0.4147997200489044,
-0.6837403774261475,
-0.2066364884376526,
0.5109806060791016,
0.9179801940917969,
-0.12169988453388214,
0.02930670604109764,
0.2808414399623871,
0.7506422996520996,
-0.7084364295005798,
0.3467911183834076,
-0.49070805311203003,
-0.0712675228714943,
-0.2729851305484772,
-0.07560030370950699,
-0.41034987568855286,
-0.5220717191696167,
-0.1903640776872635,
-0.7914025187492371,
0.3314560055732727,
-0.21777334809303284,
0.9784431457519531,
0.2341170608997345,
-0.21137137711048126,
-0.2634755074977875,
-0.6068878769874573,
0.4276917278766632,
-0.8399595618247986,
0.08636581152677536,
0.5244112610816956,
0.27526307106018066,
-0.29641449451446533,
-0.2651810944080353,
-0.6391322612762451,
-0.12338737398386002,
-0.0891946330666542,
0.3954921364784241,
0.015820765867829323,
0.14111730456352234,
0.2394638955593109,
0.24145223200321198,
-0.862817645072937,
0.15860697627067566,
-0.31071409583091736,
-0.33721089363098145,
0.33417221903800964,
-0.12249494343996048,
0.2919921278953552,
-0.41485950350761414,
0.13681405782699585,
0.22124312818050385,
-0.7433422207832336,
0.011454724706709385,
0.6607958078384399,
0.3956257402896881,
-0.24437910318374634,
0.47125276923179626,
-0.06325266510248184,
1.2358425855636597,
0.13513699173927307,
0.07374904304742813,
0.038725193589925766,
-0.509865939617157,
-0.402254581451416,
-0.28250518441200256,
0.4323405921459198,
0.013536212965846062,
0.8078312277793884,
-0.04849296435713768,
-0.12705038487911224,
0.2558477818965912,
0.37170618772506714,
-0.3611672818660736,
-0.14784827828407288,
0.07526426762342453,
-0.14622443914413452,
0.08275526016950607,
0.0019530983408913016,
-1.045723557472229,
-0.30836278200149536,
-0.4302803575992584,
0.42765069007873535,
-0.258891761302948,
-0.29879114031791687,
0.13861331343650818,
0.1315358430147171,
0.036622658371925354,
0.3407551944255829,
-1.1757190227508545,
-0.05387891083955765,
0.5119919776916504,
0.6165338158607483,
0.3234994113445282,
-0.3660643398761749,
-0.37878361344337463,
-0.0016985881375148892,
-0.5310451984405518,
0.8019300699234009,
-0.34375375509262085,
-0.41009947657585144,
0.5166494846343994,
-0.06620347499847412,
-0.31895723938941956,
-0.59300297498703,
0.4208971858024597,
-0.5521969199180603,
0.11029674857854843,
-0.15086884796619415,
-0.4427625238895416,
-0.1502467840909958,
0.2433466911315918,
-0.26658809185028076,
0.7074248194694519,
0.24533097445964813,
-0.5851116180419922,
0.4063470661640167,
-0.5392038226127625,
-0.6127991080284119,
0.15572038292884827,
-0.07181932777166367,
-0.1989973485469818,
0.19723977148532867,
0.5091820955276489,
0.6993703842163086,
0.04188357666134834,
0.6078680753707886,
-0.1207716092467308,
-0.5365996956825256,
0.14131119847297668,
-0.4575529098510742,
0.837232768535614,
0.019448386505246162,
-0.34786978363990784,
0.3324893116950989,
-0.9391742944717407,
0.19953849911689758,
-0.0510275661945343,
-0.35894304513931274,
0.030179165303707123,
0.006957713980227709,
-0.23597760498523712,
-0.1365881711244583,
0.06785953044891357,
-0.1080259457230568,
0.18117627501487732,
-0.40138739347457886,
0.42322832345962524,
0.9841629862785339,
-0.3584059476852417,
0.24152404069900513,
0.021198099479079247,
0.8843439221382141,
-0.08774952590465546,
0.1675022691488266,
-0.21269001066684723,
-0.40346580743789673,
-0.766867995262146,
-0.1356063336133957,
0.44144245982170105,
0.5500189065933228,
-0.7306278944015503,
0.5852639079093933,
-0.46596771478652954,
-0.232859268784523,
-0.6381369829177856,
0.28595829010009766,
0.5984001755714417,
0.5307938456535339,
0.2843356430530548,
0.14243002235889435,
-0.6367244124412537,
-0.7167021632194519,
-0.3582223057746887,
-0.43361589312553406,
-0.04154960438609123,
0.02539057657122612,
0.43217331171035767,
-0.42246535420417786,
1.0018901824951172,
-0.20068201422691345,
0.07035082578659058,
-0.3403139114379883,
0.27004268765449524,
0.157338947057724,
0.16645996272563934,
0.38449224829673767,
-0.8882879614830017,
-0.3530578911304474,
-0.018185943365097046,
-0.7958847880363464,
-0.3610469400882721,
-0.08653843402862549,
-0.05869544297456741,
0.6178851127624512,
0.29299795627593994,
-0.42651990056037903,
0.5778765082359314,
0.8329032063484192,
-0.23089244961738586,
1.0354779958724976,
-0.4325709044933319,
0.23740558326244354,
-0.7220394611358643,
-0.015218924731016159,
-0.023351989686489105,
-0.18339227139949799,
-0.4687105119228363,
-0.02804664894938469,
0.06703881919384003,
-0.15274891257286072,
-0.11451446264982224,
0.40242671966552734,
-0.5804951786994934,
-0.1576472669839859,
-0.001777173369191587,
0.2535261809825897,
-0.07002263516187668,
0.41541528701782227,
-0.22634872794151306,
1.0961419343948364,
0.49998030066490173,
-0.6838120818138123,
0.23196016252040863,
0.24410030245780945,
-0.4437791109085083,
0.40390869975090027,
-0.616748034954071,
-0.06582951545715332,
-0.04322662577033043,
0.054913394153118134,
-1.139680027961731,
-0.7454203963279724,
0.2763652801513672,
-0.644622266292572,
0.48054683208465576,
-0.4284709393978119,
-0.3954126834869385,
-0.46788489818573,
0.1401447355747223,
0.2345169186592102,
0.5289601683616638,
-0.6891388297080994,
0.5610718131065369,
-0.03158201277256012,
-0.5399102568626404,
-0.5920959711074829,
-0.6549021601676941,
0.1132393628358841,
0.1483803391456604,
-0.7784427404403687,
-0.07872191816568375,
-0.14375166594982147,
-0.3546000123023987,
-0.022540202364325523,
-0.014827968552708626,
-0.07081914693117142,
0.21436700224876404,
0.37461161613464355,
0.4162323772907257,
-0.10358293354511261,
0.3069499135017395,
-0.05527617037296295,
-0.23547092080116272,
0.009495098143815994,
-0.2013532519340515,
0.4479769468307495,
-0.35249006748199463,
-0.49449020624160767,
-0.3794911205768585,
0.30515027046203613,
0.4516211748123169,
0.022463692352175713,
0.6870467066764832,
0.41669806838035583,
-0.3098352551460266,
-0.0027627923991531134,
-0.6307308077812195,
0.2047581821680069,
-0.40403100848197937,
0.40269118547439575,
-0.3901250958442688,
-0.610883355140686,
0.5915626287460327,
0.03646096587181091,
-0.4235752522945404,
0.4607239067554474,
0.6325109004974365,
-0.19980686902999878,
0.8289890885353088,
0.5534919500350952,
-0.0544322207570076,
0.2529118061065674,
-0.01851048693060875,
0.46761780977249146,
-0.5706902742385864,
-0.268131822347641,
-0.5327688455581665,
0.24483662843704224,
-0.5167563557624817,
-0.13695988059043884,
0.24484741687774658,
0.3102591037750244,
-0.36937975883483887,
0.029224524274468422,
-0.32752206921577454,
0.28328850865364075,
0.43333113193511963,
-0.12207034230232239,
0.037944141775369644,
0.11065541207790375,
-0.06711551547050476,
-0.06115579605102539,
-0.7695513963699341,
-0.6963403820991516,
0.8204713463783264,
-0.12115009129047394,
0.7828497290611267,
0.04364246875047684,
0.41231775283813477,
0.3240862190723419,
0.36598625779151917,
-0.604570746421814,
0.5241374969482422,
-0.23936396837234497,
-0.6427943110466003,
-0.21393245458602905,
-0.394188791513443,
-0.7223660349845886,
0.158611461520195,
-0.031907036900520325,
-0.44691941142082214,
0.07042233645915985,
0.5047392249107361,
-0.3761216998100281,
0.18234620988368988,
-1.0971333980560303,
0.8860529065132141,
-0.3123396039009094,
-0.3999047875404358,
0.030249102041125298,
-0.669849157333374,
0.2759610414505005,
-0.11740865558385849,
0.4581102132797241,
0.2037758231163025,
0.28487658500671387,
0.5346511006355286,
-0.4252886474132538,
1.1016026735305786,
-0.42383086681365967,
-0.29709675908088684,
0.2558403015136719,
-0.13277758657932281,
0.4096427857875824,
-0.11482905596494675,
-0.15169697999954224,
0.2133045196533203,
-0.4116591215133667,
-0.6146605014801025,
-0.5798631906509399,
0.3954602777957916,
-0.7354663014411926,
-0.7015906572341919,
-0.42417997121810913,
-0.2199990451335907,
-0.3454752564430237,
-0.11490152031183243,
0.5187381505966187,
0.4791977107524872,
0.05703861266374588,
-0.20632529258728027,
0.24584713578224182,
-0.22701963782310486,
0.32606104016304016,
0.37815868854522705,
-0.03463085740804672,
-0.3006752133369446,
0.761359453201294,
0.25455206632614136,
0.23705103993415833,
0.09968122094869614,
0.04293157905340195,
-0.16279253363609314,
-0.8020772933959961,
-0.68312668800354,
0.1795140951871872,
-0.7170081734657288,
-0.13295859098434448,
-0.3634658455848694,
-0.04950539395213127,
-0.832712709903717,
-0.3404478430747986,
0.0428134985268116,
-0.00824414286762476,
-0.36980029940605164,
-0.1627039909362793,
0.11412732303142548,
0.8981656432151794,
-0.16520647704601288,
0.5441200733184814,
-0.9398708939552307,
0.28895989060401917,
0.30569446086883545,
0.38199543952941895,
0.04560805484652519,
-0.7741804122924805,
-0.28186696767807007,
0.2539694607257843,
0.019833780825138092,
-0.8992766737937927,
0.35641467571258545,
0.2936214506626129,
0.47761744260787964,
0.34966206550598145,
-0.5592127442359924,
1.1322875022888184,
-0.5518894791603088,
1.0488466024398804,
0.018138783052563667,
-1.2013578414916992,
0.7816144227981567,
-0.5654011368751526,
0.15917342901229858,
0.3884056508541107,
0.41854366660118103,
-0.578724205493927,
0.07701235264539719,
-0.35583430528640747,
-0.8878253102302551,
0.45278164744377136,
-0.11972849071025848,
-0.027768053114414215,
-0.1103634312748909,
0.7670406103134155,
0.27483227849006653,
0.17497244477272034,
-0.8275083303451538,
0.12531226873397827,
-0.27808570861816406,
-0.19071511924266815,
-0.3565843403339386,
-0.6164389848709106,
-0.10345486551523209,
-0.20479175448417664,
0.9676058888435364,
-0.3240624964237213,
0.20750507712364197,
0.0933518186211586,
-0.39748266339302063,
0.021862424910068512,
0.6164705157279968,
0.7480618357658386,
1.0323156118392944,
0.14039772748947144,
-0.10261356085538864,
-0.07675056159496307,
-0.2904997169971466,
0.289802610874176,
0.13673390448093414,
0.03765369951725006,
-0.11881127953529358,
0.8844055533409119,
0.7008174657821655,
0.14490258693695068,
-0.671678900718689,
0.597844123840332,
0.18280959129333496,
0.029288213700056076,
-0.4862372577190399,
-0.1402483582496643,
0.07612422108650208,
-0.07706210762262344,
0.2454916536808014,
0.1657210737466812,
-0.15521883964538574,
-0.47319525480270386,
-0.19955657422542572,
0.1211652010679245,
0.00205194391310215,
-0.5619015097618103,
0.3257436156272888,
0.32909804582595825,
-0.3024005591869354,
0.7645740509033203,
-0.49859532713890076,
-0.7781783938407898,
0.49682220816612244,
0.501071035861969,
0.5999720692634583,
-0.23602063953876495,
0.43804338574409485,
0.29451635479927063,
0.14968883991241455,
-0.09144166857004166,
0.18096923828125,
0.09679555892944336,
-0.6460262537002563,
-0.8998907208442688,
-0.5981858968734741,
-0.17170418798923492,
-0.014991861768066883,
-0.7718600034713745,
-0.08875132352113724,
-0.2980249524116516,
-0.05140956491231918,
-0.2725268304347992,
-0.2929859459400177,
-0.6867383122444153,
0.30259186029434204,
-0.12162172049283981,
0.5991414189338684,
-1.1376855373382568,
0.41647517681121826,
0.8584436774253845,
-0.5016684532165527,
-0.9279100298881531,
0.11439452320337296,
0.10500549525022507,
-0.9922194480895996,
0.9046274423599243,
0.03356894105672836,
-0.20461249351501465,
-0.15640482306480408,
-0.5130324363708496,
-0.3702230453491211,
0.37253162264823914,
0.5083321332931519,
-0.8458226323127747,
-0.14179375767707825,
0.005305850878357887,
0.7795789837837219,
0.07866762578487396,
0.3017393946647644,
0.49028706550598145,
0.7768296599388123,
-0.19580933451652527,
-0.7576143741607666,
-0.29131999611854553,
-0.4287633001804352,
0.04507462680339813,
0.003595671383664012,
-0.2952316105365753,
0.7986465692520142,
-0.3939476013183594,
-0.2020929604768753,
0.334745317697525,
0.5887922048568726,
-0.03453102707862854,
0.09108301252126694,
0.4080769419670105,
0.42734047770500183,
0.740685224533081,
-0.3584677278995514,
1.342774748802185,
0.16145870089530945,
0.20601560175418854,
1.058699369430542,
-0.2257770299911499,
0.8028839826583862,
0.42158812284469604,
-0.5122362375259399,
0.691044807434082,
0.9677068591117859,
0.18549710512161255,
0.1802002340555191,
0.4469712972640991,
-0.27948975563049316,
-0.44645896553993225,
0.08154729753732681,
-0.31574761867523193,
0.33766281604766846,
0.39894992113113403,
0.09441127628087997,
-0.061114612966775894,
0.25045228004455566,
-0.14123107492923737,
0.40207135677337646,
-0.3872508406639099,
0.6625722050666809,
-0.2974295914173126,
-0.8281167149543762,
0.7827008366584778,
-0.36734873056411743,
0.7924074530601501,
-0.6321148872375488,
-0.08803592622280121,
-0.3772164583206177,
0.3793394863605499,
-0.4193519055843353,
-0.5981221199035645,
0.10933002829551697,
0.38011592626571655,
-0.38689276576042175,
-0.1420236974954605,
0.5975911021232605,
-0.4289354681968689,
-0.49712738394737244,
0.45238009095191956,
0.48183801770210266,
0.3128247857093811,
-0.05032692849636078,
-0.35563647747039795,
0.09680844843387604,
-0.11424393951892853,
0.04710349813103676,
0.1075223833322525,
0.3694208264350891,
0.0710802748799324,
0.6553128957748413,
0.32720184326171875,
0.49922919273376465,
0.3323177695274353,
0.42276009917259216,
0.4719545543193817,
-0.3412274122238159,
-0.2857876420021057,
-0.7143381834030151,
0.6928284168243408,
0.04296005889773369,
-0.2474086582660675,
0.7177382111549377,
0.1181555986404419,
1.0757533311843872,
-0.4733371138572693,
1.0243679285049438,
-0.04032648727297783,
0.4909893572330475,
-0.7465381622314453,
0.4654696583747864,
-0.6238943338394165,
0.0884530320763588,
-0.03621824458241463,
-0.8072728514671326,
-0.3232935667037964,
0.7644866108894348,
-0.3047037720680237,
0.5689612030982971,
0.6135975122451782,
0.8202831745147705,
0.2517119348049164,
0.010992111638188362,
0.36467933654785156,
0.5634561777114868,
0.27303725481033325,
0.26744672656059265,
0.9212296605110168,
-0.21240603923797607,
0.41023415327072144,
0.2175179421901703,
-0.4009505808353424,
-0.3397950828075409,
-0.9169896841049194,
-0.7067286372184753,
-0.5667219161987305,
-0.16067087650299072,
-0.15948733687400818,
0.693129301071167,
0.6878076195716858,
0.6820377707481384,
-0.7532872557640076,
0.03992718458175659,
-0.20265834033489227,
-0.09153854101896286,
-0.18137028813362122,
-0.20008063316345215,
0.436646968126297,
-0.6678407788276672,
-0.8024177551269531,
0.46905550360679626,
0.10705883055925369,
0.13356630504131317,
-0.23384816944599152,
0.0005787066766060889,
-0.2981359660625458,
-0.23087573051452637,
0.57138991355896,
0.2989400625228882,
-0.8844118714332581,
-0.5593118667602539,
-0.24444426596164703,
0.12238159775733948,
-0.0531996451318264,
0.8649286031723022,
-0.7095074653625488,
0.5984662175178528,
0.5012332797050476,
0.8689106702804565,
-0.05100664123892784,
0.06480174511671066,
0.5140535831451416,
-0.7390673756599426,
0.029417727142572403,
0.1165003553032875,
0.47491583228111267,
0.5856378078460693,
-0.314083993434906,
0.5793808102607727,
0.35046255588531494,
-0.6557453274726868,
-0.5983898043632507,
0.06205194815993309,
-0.774551272392273,
-0.22397376596927643,
1.165331244468689,
-0.5654929876327515,
-0.15012970566749573,
-0.2126629650592804,
-0.20255811512470245,
0.4107334315776825,
0.03489071875810623,
0.7558520436286926,
1.1546196937561035,
0.019539320841431618,
0.2686500549316406,
-0.5129705667495728,
0.4027763903141022,
0.7293497920036316,
-1.0352449417114258,
0.38383176922798157,
0.6273586750030518,
0.24579088389873505,
0.21585698425769806,
0.4661600589752197,
-0.10540851950645447,
0.39238664507865906,
0.04200005158782005,
0.0576108954846859,
-0.15526874363422394,
-0.6489884257316589,
-0.7887862920761108,
-0.07600035518407822,
0.02854626439511776,
-0.10968649387359619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17284v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17284v2
|
An NLP Crosswalk Between the Common Core State Standards and NAEP Item Specifications
| 2024-05-27T15:47:46 | 2024-05-31T21:30:44 |
Gregory Camilli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Natural language processing (NLP) is rapidly developing for applications in
educational assessment. In this paper, I describe an NLP-based procedure that
can be used to support subject matter experts in establishing a crosswalk
between item specifications and content standards. This paper extends recent
work by proposing and demonstrating the use of multivariate similarity based on
embedding vectors for sentences or texts. In particular, a hybrid regression
procedure is demonstrated for establishing the match of each content standard
to multiple item specifications. The procedure is used to evaluate the match of
the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) for mathematics at grade 4 to the
corresponding item specifications for the 2026 National Assessment of
Educational Progress (NAEP).
|
[
-0.6344025731086731,
-0.7855710983276367,
0.4015396535396576,
0.4361230731010437,
0.05802325904369354,
0.4472212791442871,
-0.1666519045829773,
-0.3973478376865387,
0.3226144313812256,
0.5447569489479065,
-0.41738247871398926,
-0.6276795268058777,
-0.4629339873790741,
0.23579852283000946,
-0.5489922761917114,
0.5968695878982544,
-0.4247605800628662,
-0.11090538650751114,
-0.591340959072113,
-0.09962441772222519,
-0.9198731184005737,
-0.364177942276001,
-0.4796755313873291,
-0.06068190187215805,
0.23303258419036865,
0.36251890659332275,
0.5487850904464722,
0.2594467103481293,
0.6708018779754639,
0.25875237584114075,
0.09909988194704056,
0.4329269230365753,
0.19774015247821808,
0.26235538721084595,
-0.5314738154411316,
0.020203271880745888,
-0.5407912731170654,
0.2172393500804901,
0.5922368764877319,
0.8018015623092651,
0.0009038703283295035,
0.22919602692127228,
0.6006820201873779,
0.4957646429538727,
-0.6928055882453918,
0.059990156441926956,
-0.2069183886051178,
0.2966180443763733,
0.05232202634215355,
-0.4982774257659912,
-0.33547243475914,
-0.3641999363899231,
0.3752724826335907,
-0.5035950541496277,
0.2628379762172699,
-0.036652710288763046,
0.7109474539756775,
-0.05558420717716217,
-0.25643208622932434,
-0.5160633325576782,
-0.543532133102417,
1.2144522666931152,
-0.385621041059494,
0.48252010345458984,
0.5269105434417725,
0.2540176808834076,
0.024265892803668976,
-0.49389851093292236,
-0.44819971919059753,
-0.09166524559259415,
-0.16034628450870514,
-0.038386475294828415,
0.03133731335401535,
-0.13249972462654114,
0.1871439665555954,
0.3817380666732788,
-0.8390218615531921,
-0.17886823415756226,
-0.2927713096141815,
-0.2521936297416687,
0.6080467104911804,
0.3054995536804199,
0.2881866991519928,
-0.35496968030929565,
-0.6142573952674866,
-0.15919974446296692,
-0.3498857915401459,
-0.003307059407234192,
0.22243346273899078,
0.7323369979858398,
-0.20028766989707947,
0.8392576575279236,
-0.24841921031475067,
0.8841665983200073,
-0.28080782294273376,
-0.20414091646671295,
0.5207546949386597,
-0.871663510799408,
-0.2141251266002655,
-0.08043727278709412,
0.6475846171379089,
0.5732861161231995,
0.11664113402366638,
-0.09867484122514725,
-0.04547294229269028,
0.29315927624702454,
0.21040678024291992,
-0.16176053881645203,
-0.02351624332368374,
0.025964319705963135,
-0.5274755954742432,
0.18490727245807648,
-0.06892843544483185,
-1.0939557552337646,
0.032665543258190155,
-0.9034329056739807,
0.3626105487346649,
-0.39396077394485474,
0.3241328001022339,
0.5038912296295166,
-0.07417938858270645,
0.38093873858451843,
0.02442612498998642,
-0.7836982011795044,
0.8908549547195435,
0.9100650548934937,
1.1131548881530762,
-0.40484586358070374,
-0.15312203764915466,
-0.41812023520469666,
-0.1793053299188614,
-0.12663733959197998,
0.8450742363929749,
-0.8888881802558899,
-0.29425084590911865,
0.21587678790092468,
-0.270557165145874,
-0.1770130842924118,
-0.4267982244491577,
0.7066239714622498,
-0.21842633187770844,
0.4016469419002533,
-0.22533152997493744,
-0.6516244411468506,
-0.22133298218250275,
0.7235492467880249,
-0.6369755864143372,
1.2344567775726318,
0.2082251012325287,
-0.6336454749107361,
0.3346825838088989,
-0.7045854926109314,
-0.3760097324848175,
-0.07390835136175156,
-0.21479643881320953,
-0.400316059589386,
-0.3282974660396576,
0.47081220149993896,
0.5187415480613708,
-0.3702060878276825,
-0.012991647236049175,
-0.2131025642156601,
-0.11310461163520813,
-0.2761830985546112,
-0.3389563262462616,
0.8058590888977051,
-0.23628191649913788,
-0.0092487633228302,
-0.24166090786457062,
-0.9889057278633118,
0.49810081720352173,
-0.30011019110679626,
-0.37459516525268555,
-0.618562638759613,
-0.02322455681860447,
0.061912763863801956,
0.4246371388435364,
0.5819945335388184,
-0.4925670027732849,
0.21937796473503113,
-0.12784425914287567,
-0.13900575041770935,
0.38691914081573486,
0.06906872987747192,
0.4379884600639343,
-0.38846877217292786,
0.6291744112968445,
-0.3922600746154785,
0.13652727007865906,
0.09115475416183472,
-0.9575516581535339,
-0.489810585975647,
0.08746569603681564,
0.2912992537021637,
0.7069580554962158,
-0.557072639465332,
0.8311662077903748,
0.013517793267965317,
-0.35282620787620544,
-0.5519708395004272,
0.12001214176416397,
0.3928546905517578,
0.5368559956550598,
0.9565525650978088,
-0.33799460530281067,
-1.01033616065979,
-0.9585385322570801,
-0.34159916639328003,
0.06316634267568588,
-0.1947481632232666,
0.039085254073143005,
0.25415363907814026,
0.12017031759023666,
1.0227240324020386,
-0.39505723118782043,
-0.6856654286384583,
-0.11231332272291183,
0.4862912595272064,
0.04975026100873947,
0.689463198184967,
0.6551218032836914,
-0.646747350692749,
-0.7888513803482056,
-0.11064617335796356,
-0.3873257040977478,
-0.1851586401462555,
0.003722784575074911,
-0.30976271629333496,
-0.13149265944957733,
0.4291572868824005,
-0.026003681123256683,
0.5744199156761169,
0.7896215915679932,
-0.6283800601959229,
0.455316424369812,
-0.04550204798579216,
0.24168147146701813,
-1.1512107849121094,
-0.123419851064682,
0.32760605216026306,
-0.2007288932800293,
-0.38661038875579834,
0.07904292643070221,
-0.19210435450077057,
0.17594057321548462,
-0.20468056201934814,
0.42042338848114014,
-0.18632008135318756,
-0.37504270672798157,
-0.09505590051412582,
0.3884658217430115,
0.22795133292675018,
0.09138406068086624,
0.4530312418937683,
0.5802922248840332,
0.6376187801361084,
-0.5537448525428772,
0.28949400782585144,
0.5298940539360046,
-0.29553860425949097,
1.2150156497955322,
-0.4224538803100586,
-0.02476639300584793,
0.2794710099697113,
-0.048160944133996964,
-0.43398749828338623,
0.6449053287506104,
0.18663838505744934,
-0.4501456916332245,
-0.16475623846054077,
0.05095725506544113,
-0.43318846821784973,
-0.24227936565876007,
-0.28802791237831116,
0.18826699256896973,
0.12814241647720337,
-0.3268078863620758,
0.9362702965736389,
0.20048925280570984,
-0.33709320425987244,
-0.6957024931907654,
-0.5072615742683411,
0.28073790669441223,
-0.02956029213964939,
-0.5567595958709717,
0.5661799907684326,
-0.34793388843536377,
-0.19539067149162292,
0.06910455226898193,
0.13421592116355896,
-0.33854931592941284,
0.04180911183357239,
-0.10324741154909134,
0.4555611312389374,
-0.633945107460022,
-0.0239347442984581,
-0.001662920112721622,
-0.1520949751138687,
0.2028466910123825,
0.06374247372150421,
0.6836827993392944,
-0.1722351610660553,
-0.2965342402458191,
-0.20754052698612213,
0.7729480862617493,
-0.038804493844509125,
-0.24211856722831726,
0.42050275206565857,
0.47801893949508667,
-0.40967857837677,
-0.31843528151512146,
-0.22018370032310486,
0.1143449991941452,
-0.47096794843673706,
0.26453495025634766,
-0.35515448451042175,
-0.45642349123954773,
0.06627216935157776,
0.3068576455116272,
0.4018747806549072,
0.35873737931251526,
0.3161131739616394,
-0.08220737427473068,
0.919944167137146,
0.75681072473526,
0.2211044877767563,
0.1824156790971756,
-0.09352367371320724,
0.3589170575141907,
-1.132006049156189,
-0.46972349286079407,
-0.8322772979736328,
-0.6494281888008118,
-0.46956101059913635,
-0.9030311703681946,
-0.06476256251335144,
-0.27107372879981995,
-0.020676523447036743,
0.7216646671295166,
-0.5272150635719299,
0.44010061025619507,
0.5365200638771057,
-0.1958826631307602,
0.37684765458106995,
-0.08271129429340363,
-0.3488231301307678,
-0.4242017865180969,
-0.3786650002002716,
-0.7269682288169861,
1.0061659812927246,
0.17573986947536469,
0.6121014952659607,
0.06198665499687195,
0.684311032295227,
0.42307794094085693,
0.18702855706214905,
-0.7401993274688721,
0.7294492721557617,
-0.45480024814605713,
-0.4616101384162903,
-0.1787998080253601,
-0.21837450563907623,
-0.7806417346000671,
0.20692510902881622,
-0.7753151655197144,
-0.7531366944313049,
0.13510821759700775,
-0.26095032691955566,
-0.2934011220932007,
0.21823973953723907,
-0.3598261773586273,
0.6420882940292358,
-0.05436909943819046,
0.10312562435865402,
-0.0874413400888443,
-0.2773755192756653,
0.11430302262306213,
-0.036005519330501556,
0.03698655962944031,
-0.23052287101745605,
-0.16895058751106262,
1.050795078277588,
0.019666198641061783,
0.6230255961418152,
0.1783961057662964,
0.11247599124908447,
0.3000054657459259,
0.18623612821102142,
-0.0966748595237732,
-0.08002419769763947,
-0.028104225173592567,
-0.06767131388187408,
0.09661848843097687,
-0.5111725330352783,
-0.8387014269828796,
0.6962496638298035,
-0.5579338669776917,
-0.2744978666305542,
-0.45461368560791016,
-0.6013171076774597,
-0.5252112150192261,
0.004707045387476683,
-0.389020174741745,
0.2667723000049591,
-0.299929678440094,
0.24857750535011292,
0.43625694513320923,
-0.10153377056121826,
0.40814313292503357,
0.6227728724479675,
-0.1273048222064972,
-0.028037788346409798,
0.917987585067749,
-0.025314996019005775,
0.1664429008960724,
0.5409812331199646,
0.3935243487358093,
-0.4074557423591614,
-0.3316745162010193,
0.09981408715248108,
0.047744933515787125,
-0.7524676322937012,
-0.28736650943756104,
-0.5952678918838501,
-0.4535169303417206,
-0.4435800611972809,
-0.5797115564346313,
-0.48245513439178467,
-0.23627223074436188,
-0.31815388798713684,
-0.15232335031032562,
0.14523346722126007,
0.9668506383895874,
-0.1204926148056984,
-0.18864332139492035,
-0.8560641407966614,
0.33544886112213135,
0.4217398166656494,
0.3525375425815582,
-0.09721767902374268,
-0.4812997281551361,
-0.07956217229366302,
-0.12470080703496933,
-0.4934123158454895,
-0.5101945400238037,
0.24716752767562866,
0.3005272150039673,
0.7227354049682617,
0.16403457522392273,
-0.009847259148955345,
0.6400401592254639,
-0.4758612811565399,
0.8702455163002014,
0.22033607959747314,
-1.2993078231811523,
0.45326435565948486,
0.13774654269218445,
-0.03636099770665169,
0.5073330998420715,
0.5822105407714844,
-0.6331552863121033,
-0.4079933762550354,
-0.6409139037132263,
-0.735991358757019,
-0.058987557888031006,
0.19912484288215637,
0.029886407777667046,
-0.12350497394800186,
-0.07739019393920898,
0.08952471613883972,
0.04860900342464447,
-0.5110473036766052,
-0.2965015470981598,
0.007897598668932915,
-0.4053877890110016,
0.012169216759502888,
0.12490580976009369,
-0.12792548537254333,
-0.10990730673074722,
0.3655741512775421,
-0.3366069793701172,
0.11603697389364243,
0.025518912822008133,
0.1302681267261505,
0.29766321182250977,
0.309248685836792,
0.4066230356693268,
0.77762770652771,
-0.0684831514954567,
0.13060583174228668,
0.13825519382953644,
-0.5218136310577393,
0.036713823676109314,
0.1520666778087616,
-0.05000665411353111,
0.2849082946777344,
0.5270382165908813,
0.15170924365520477,
0.5202054977416992,
-0.5504192113876343,
0.6900891065597534,
-0.20086728036403656,
-0.3399176299571991,
-0.24637779593467712,
-0.17337734997272491,
-0.1674880087375641,
0.12121310085058212,
0.08677026629447937,
0.14349041879177094,
0.14156538248062134,
-0.4909413754940033,
0.7674485445022583,
0.2501883804798126,
-0.5115780234336853,
-0.23074489831924438,
0.31907156109809875,
0.18931883573532104,
-0.47106730937957764,
0.4902513027191162,
-0.12397118657827377,
-0.26122790575027466,
0.553543210029602,
0.5954009294509888,
0.6581026315689087,
-0.28351399302482605,
0.6671675443649292,
0.7427423000335693,
0.32348743081092834,
-0.10688282549381256,
0.7141295075416565,
0.1992468386888504,
-0.76140958070755,
-0.5296969413757324,
-0.6055466532707214,
-0.42414700984954834,
-0.23173314332962036,
-1.0031079053878784,
0.6186468005180359,
-0.6117185950279236,
0.11058304458856583,
0.029410941526293755,
0.09041091799736023,
-1.0035345554351807,
0.47439756989479065,
0.43733036518096924,
0.958856463432312,
-1.2462340593338013,
0.35930418968200684,
0.5499767661094666,
-0.40512314438819885,
-0.6782280802726746,
-0.16527245938777924,
-0.12046682089567184,
-0.7141588926315308,
0.5971788167953491,
-0.1782841980457306,
0.18913643062114716,
-0.5827074646949768,
-0.09257455915212631,
-1.0274940729141235,
0.7804374694824219,
-0.2818922698497772,
-0.4980829656124115,
-0.25371915102005005,
0.37572193145751953,
0.6733906865119934,
-0.666759729385376,
0.1893073171377182,
0.7397487759590149,
0.5203285217285156,
-0.3219200372695923,
-0.941760778427124,
0.05307886749505997,
0.056502360850572586,
-0.18411438167095184,
0.1175270676612854,
-0.09546773135662079,
0.9011622071266174,
0.08626009523868561,
-0.08970043063163757,
0.06561582535505295,
0.7076408267021179,
0.42417460680007935,
0.30456748604774475,
0.5280455946922302,
0.5389783978462219,
0.6155507564544678,
-0.015114730224013329,
0.6358321905136108,
-0.1821935623884201,
0.46064168214797974,
1.4268484115600586,
-0.10074152797460556,
1.3535094261169434,
0.6406983137130737,
-0.3973037302494049,
0.8610990643501282,
0.28156816959381104,
-0.19142816960811615,
0.28102055191993713,
0.11131522059440613,
-0.023883502930402756,
-0.13191035389900208,
-0.1525069922208786,
-0.23420582711696625,
0.6338626742362976,
0.6280444264411926,
-0.4493025839328766,
-0.6007135510444641,
-0.12855274975299835,
-0.3358282446861267,
0.6860297918319702,
-0.36235126852989197,
0.4027027487754822,
0.07747859507799149,
-0.557425856590271,
0.09522968530654907,
-0.14472146332263947,
0.5869507193565369,
-0.3125486671924591,
-0.38061484694480896,
0.2756369709968567,
-0.3134952187538147,
-0.15520910918712616,
-1.3217474222183228,
0.7228948473930359,
-0.13437119126319885,
-0.10829424113035202,
-0.23237287998199463,
0.231505885720253,
-0.5589759349822998,
-0.6604005098342896,
0.6426301598548889,
0.5326066613197327,
-0.17128124833106995,
0.31000733375549316,
-1.0269606113433838,
-0.20129185914993286,
-0.26025858521461487,
0.05610557273030281,
0.17985260486602783,
0.2722164988517761,
0.12656797468662262,
0.43699023127555847,
0.5776338577270508,
0.15077823400497437,
0.28135237097740173,
0.3634171783924103,
0.5972143411636353,
-0.6619271039962769,
-0.5871406197547913,
-0.3996034264564514,
0.42627692222595215,
-0.2459375560283661,
-0.6101869940757751,
0.6294997334480286,
0.7088391184806824,
0.9108958840370178,
0.22915519773960114,
0.7870162725448608,
-0.1726119965314865,
0.9592037796974182,
-0.6860864758491516,
0.07296331226825714,
-0.388950914144516,
0.11300376057624817,
-0.35471436381340027,
-1.2684978246688843,
-0.420583575963974,
0.766292154788971,
-0.3268420994281769,
-0.02955389954149723,
1.0866386890411377,
0.41938963532447815,
-0.1673518270254135,
0.08354086428880692,
0.39909088611602783,
-0.324499249458313,
0.2619915306568146,
0.5372155904769897,
0.7020934224128723,
-0.5868546366691589,
0.47524380683898926,
-0.3778979778289795,
-0.009782213717699051,
0.02720450796186924,
-0.8550394177436829,
-1.0754090547561646,
-0.699152410030365,
-0.5831752419471741,
-0.4918213486671448,
-0.15790486335754395,
1.0184217691421509,
0.31278833746910095,
-0.7591193914413452,
-0.16674183309078217,
0.1860785037279129,
0.14075297117233276,
-0.6260125637054443,
-0.3259297311306,
0.48831138014793396,
-0.22168748080730438,
-0.8206889629364014,
0.3766878843307495,
0.34358224272727966,
0.06765492260456085,
-0.580261766910553,
0.09981174021959305,
-0.5054319500923157,
0.28538572788238525,
0.6179942488670349,
0.29060041904449463,
-0.6769422292709351,
-0.5771476030349731,
0.06359194964170456,
-0.03766088932752609,
0.2783504128456116,
0.9222486019134521,
-0.6218858361244202,
0.5841367840766907,
0.7348383665084839,
0.6222120523452759,
-0.03721960633993149,
0.03364219143986702,
0.766701340675354,
-0.8661636114120483,
-0.17058075964450836,
0.62833172082901,
0.3950172960758209,
0.4822286367416382,
-0.06870300322771072,
0.3009655177593231,
-0.03249684348702431,
-0.46789976954460144,
-0.48111534118652344,
0.2100270837545395,
-1.0794085264205933,
0.04125893861055374,
0.9028666019439697,
-0.2329561710357666,
-0.12299494445323944,
-0.7563908696174622,
-0.06062527000904083,
-0.22389402985572815,
-0.1529667228460312,
0.8457639813423157,
0.7298192381858826,
-0.08846355229616165,
-0.07102121412754059,
-0.4434763491153717,
0.34076380729675293,
0.17630676925182343,
-0.8412759900093079,
-0.2855835556983948,
-0.26872220635414124,
0.20032824575901031,
0.6448045372962952,
0.3064357042312622,
-0.1387740969657898,
0.17664876580238342,
0.1592721790075302,
0.04991253837943077,
0.5087260007858276,
-0.3779590427875519,
0.021940093487501144,
0.22532634437084198,
-0.4536990821361542,
-0.2199660688638687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17280v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17280v1
|
A Library for Automatic Natural Language Generation of Spanish Texts
| 2024-05-27T15:44:06 | 2024-05-27T15:44:06 |
Silvia García-Méndez, Milagros Fernández-Gavilanes, Enrique Costa-Montenegro, Jonathan Juncal-Martínez, F. Javier González-Castaño
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this article we present a novel system for natural language generation
(NLG) of Spanish sentences from a minimum set of meaningful words (such as
nouns, verbs and adjectives) which, unlike other state-of-the-art solutions,
performs the NLG task in a fully automatic way, exploiting both knowledge-based
and statistical approaches. Relying on its linguistic knowledge of vocabulary
and grammar, the system is able to generate complete, coherent and correctly
spelled sentences from the main word sets presented by the user. The system,
which was designed to be integrable, portable and efficient, can be easily
adapted to other languages by design and can feasibly be integrated in a wide
range of digital devices. During its development we also created a
supplementary lexicon for Spanish, aLexiS, with wide coverage and high
precision, as well as syntactic trees from a freely available definite-clause
grammar. The resulting NLG library has been evaluated both automatically and
manually (annotation). The system can potentially be used in different
application domains such as augmentative communication and automatic generation
of administrative reports or news.
|
[
-0.42666760087013245,
-0.8473057746887207,
0.2880619466304779,
0.5948963165283203,
-0.2787671387195587,
0.07547298818826675,
-0.2066895067691803,
-0.5043182373046875,
0.5922219157218933,
0.539735734462738,
-0.6821161508560181,
-0.6086578369140625,
-0.21220900118350983,
0.6915489435195923,
-0.6033132076263428,
0.8206371665000916,
0.37820664048194885,
-0.2277410924434662,
0.06752990186214447,
0.14638128876686096,
-0.4657161831855774,
-0.13232509791851044,
-0.7248827219009399,
-0.2195425182580948,
0.46972984075546265,
0.3825594186782837,
0.8594236969947815,
0.8423689603805542,
0.40542277693748474,
0.3397209644317627,
0.2436877191066742,
0.4860272705554962,
-0.05812454968690872,
0.1647212952375412,
-0.41914546489715576,
-0.07309745997190475,
-0.37156710028648376,
-0.4593389928340912,
0.3574077785015106,
0.4245011806488037,
0.026694027706980705,
0.17350812256336212,
0.03220371529459953,
0.8090646266937256,
-0.1291370540857315,
0.07197024673223495,
-0.6932598352432251,
0.1765240877866745,
-0.2815169394016266,
-0.4375733733177185,
-0.3447172939777374,
-0.9195348024368286,
0.1345929205417633,
-0.5002406239509583,
0.31646332144737244,
0.12865833938121796,
0.812067985534668,
0.4902472198009491,
-0.3259477913379669,
-0.8377406597137451,
-0.5884073376655579,
0.49043944478034973,
-0.6319084763526917,
0.04241500049829483,
0.27275535464286804,
0.3455481231212616,
-0.49851667881011963,
-0.7254657745361328,
-0.5769370794296265,
-0.44732269644737244,
0.051759958267211914,
0.1196611151099205,
-0.15356914699077606,
0.27394336462020874,
-0.3530181348323822,
0.6403928399085999,
-0.7278698682785034,
-0.027778424322605133,
-0.2860462963581085,
-0.16315589845180511,
0.5323035717010498,
-0.05159313976764679,
0.38295790553092957,
-0.5155709385871887,
-0.10057161003351212,
-0.032027676701545715,
-0.7255001068115234,
-0.21783822774887085,
0.8360998630523682,
0.6240667700767517,
0.3197774589061737,
0.8408789038658142,
-0.27361953258514404,
0.9943933486938477,
-0.06996302306652069,
-0.07470469921827316,
0.25405359268188477,
-0.29234635829925537,
-0.3843308091163635,
0.23315083980560303,
1.1085641384124756,
0.07296811044216156,
0.2259504497051239,
-0.3197125196456909,
-0.0815875232219696,
0.2239830493927002,
0.44122377038002014,
-0.3073279857635498,
-0.21498830616474152,
0.15316134691238403,
-0.03333170339465141,
-0.7603621482849121,
0.29449787735939026,
-0.5081918835639954,
0.008357629179954529,
-0.361835241317749,
0.1873222440481186,
-0.3466070890426636,
0.08010444045066833,
0.3505546748638153,
0.016308166086673737,
-0.33029603958129883,
-0.04830016940832138,
-0.6484839916229248,
0.30094558000564575,
0.1303182989358902,
0.5841212272644043,
-0.09291741251945496,
-0.010250183753669262,
-0.29410287737846375,
0.20333409309387207,
-0.3453104794025421,
0.7493480443954468,
0.116071917116642,
-0.12707655131816864,
0.2458939552307129,
0.042333751916885376,
0.41692662239074707,
-0.47598254680633545,
1.0620074272155762,
-0.421976238489151,
0.5737178325653076,
0.012444359250366688,
-0.44938668608665466,
-0.22872701287269592,
0.14889372885227203,
-0.8373903036117554,
1.3566272258758545,
-0.09229277819395065,
-0.6150064468383789,
0.20824183523654938,
-0.5934241414070129,
-0.6877925395965576,
0.46750715374946594,
0.0722760409116745,
0.03276529535651207,
-0.012593554332852364,
0.15024222433567047,
0.5088943839073181,
-0.403277724981308,
0.6672654151916504,
0.2616667151451111,
0.2159106284379959,
-0.012126641348004341,
-0.1697905957698822,
0.7266375422477722,
0.3439709544181824,
-0.21276813745498657,
-0.06917421519756317,
-1.074217438697815,
0.11920545995235443,
0.09563083201646805,
-0.5913020968437195,
-0.2606094181537628,
0.008366116322577,
0.17237697541713715,
0.30773454904556274,
0.6458110213279724,
-0.56165611743927,
0.06505027413368225,
-0.7676213383674622,
-0.12330957502126694,
0.404433012008667,
0.0856323391199112,
0.4588007628917694,
-0.3724924325942993,
0.5501874089241028,
-0.6791641116142273,
-0.08388305455446243,
-0.3250260055065155,
-0.5415173768997192,
-0.8444846868515015,
-0.1414646953344345,
0.23756816983222961,
0.8185591697692871,
-0.9297730922698975,
1.247459053993225,
-0.005783427972346544,
-0.31971246004104614,
-0.28757569193840027,
0.19632865488529205,
0.35307323932647705,
0.5606798529624939,
0.28560352325439453,
0.01644279807806015,
-0.9463414549827576,
-0.9003590941429138,
-0.04263276606798172,
-0.13773499429225922,
-0.14668609201908112,
-0.031042927876114845,
0.30052152276039124,
-0.11380495131015778,
1.1403038501739502,
-0.2512800097465515,
-0.5935337543487549,
-0.4398452937602997,
0.21761518716812134,
0.31974583864212036,
0.08571132272481918,
0.4164216220378876,
-0.3896360397338867,
-0.3665764033794403,
0.3746815323829651,
-0.9085607528686523,
-0.7171496152877808,
-0.12727880477905273,
-0.12548945844173431,
0.38193556666374207,
0.4615531265735626,
-0.0854215919971466,
0.13056901097297668,
0.6680757999420166,
-0.3653326630592346,
0.5307935476303101,
-0.5152916312217712,
-0.1701275110244751,
-1.1694812774658203,
0.2211955040693283,
0.10116930305957794,
-0.39251941442489624,
-0.6144816875457764,
-0.0528687909245491,
-0.15048092603683472,
0.19665133953094482,
-0.46340692043304443,
0.7613690495491028,
-0.22147075831890106,
0.18201704323291779,
-0.5340859293937683,
0.2006683051586151,
0.0710873082280159,
0.4013426899909973,
0.11546510457992554,
0.28742900490760803,
0.29415401816368103,
-0.827256977558136,
0.6602556705474854,
0.25065428018569946,
-0.10393613576889038,
0.292168527841568,
-0.5558149814605713,
-0.14456182718276978,
-0.2972599267959595,
-0.038346707820892334,
-0.4897705614566803,
-0.4857393205165863,
0.18198367953300476,
-0.271937757730484,
-0.15478762984275818,
0.179378479719162,
-0.748112678527832,
-0.6144713163375854,
-0.014419173821806908,
-0.24126079678535461,
0.28180992603302,
-0.6044460535049438,
0.06889024376869202,
0.5919162034988403,
-0.31057843565940857,
-0.33908429741859436,
-0.7669916152954102,
0.4590074419975281,
-0.11498753726482391,
-0.841559886932373,
0.41034334897994995,
0.11225297302007675,
-0.2572174072265625,
0.15607617795467377,
0.3116728365421295,
-0.0881718173623085,
-0.27385377883911133,
0.02273716777563095,
0.18249590694904327,
-0.11701726168394089,
0.49051955342292786,
0.38882580399513245,
0.1401163935661316,
-0.2748901844024658,
-0.5152585506439209,
0.6466063857078552,
-0.4470561444759369,
-0.05368775129318237,
-0.25393933057785034,
0.3822496235370636,
0.18908847868442535,
-0.07161761820316315,
0.4346080422401428,
0.3904416561126709,
-0.5449057817459106,
-0.5549522042274475,
-0.46729519963264465,
0.15457569062709808,
-0.5051841735839844,
0.03264344856142998,
-0.22657990455627441,
-0.685292661190033,
0.47053852677345276,
0.19967235624790192,
0.27833229303359985,
0.5199772715568542,
0.7541667819023132,
0.123036690056324,
0.6102585792541504,
0.7534101009368896,
0.2569510042667389,
0.38540977239608765,
0.03838428482413292,
0.27129286527633667,
-0.12101679295301437,
-0.12457640469074249,
-0.5409882664680481,
-0.15905986726284027,
-0.36896196007728577,
-0.17254382371902466,
0.04384690150618553,
0.1609908789396286,
0.2140861451625824,
0.6348773241043091,
-0.8062302470207214,
0.6976993680000305,
0.6784766316413879,
-0.21784824132919312,
0.70811927318573,
-0.08415838330984116,
-0.26571524143218994,
-0.016587741672992706,
-0.8180710077285767,
-1.0919010639190674,
0.8812375068664551,
0.048193566501140594,
0.4665062129497528,
0.0568489171564579,
0.9156357049942017,
0.47193217277526855,
0.18443243205547333,
-0.7869330048561096,
0.5420435070991516,
-0.4412657916545868,
-0.45234185457229614,
-0.2970387041568756,
-0.29808342456817627,
-1.0851621627807617,
0.23060527443885803,
-0.2640342116355896,
-0.4238522946834564,
-0.12863171100616455,
0.14317645132541656,
-0.32282692193984985,
0.019904812797904015,
-0.7321875095367432,
0.7792054414749146,
-0.3625178635120392,
-0.27331456542015076,
0.2214694768190384,
-0.4629881680011749,
0.37663909792900085,
-0.013799403794109821,
0.20479190349578857,
-0.12667879462242126,
-0.05497672036290169,
0.7809070944786072,
-0.5390760898590088,
0.4599164128303528,
0.011054091155529022,
-0.13781777024269104,
0.7737044095993042,
0.2996331453323364,
0.2229115068912506,
0.02336737886071205,
-0.04423843324184418,
-0.39675432443618774,
-0.11329802870750427,
-0.0582311749458313,
-0.14574681222438812,
0.5754700899124146,
-0.18616220355033875,
0.05493687093257904,
-0.4349307417869568,
-0.6749083399772644,
-0.10500610619783401,
0.47661668062210083,
0.2386453002691269,
0.3979092240333557,
-0.7722174525260925,
0.008896652609109879,
0.46179887652397156,
-0.45146286487579346,
0.5877551436424255,
0.2542835474014282,
-0.5044494867324829,
-0.3699587285518646,
0.8802846074104309,
-0.08906614035367966,
0.0378253348171711,
0.3017675578594208,
0.40364325046539307,
-0.5861518979072571,
-0.3772265911102295,
-0.4848952889442444,
0.26709339022636414,
-0.43834254145622253,
-0.19660773873329163,
-0.616986870765686,
-0.03753507137298584,
-0.19375716149806976,
-0.4255616068840027,
-0.18162299692630768,
-0.6455075144767761,
-0.3737717866897583,
-0.17530648410320282,
0.31585943698883057,
0.8721939921379089,
-0.02971784397959709,
0.42603087425231934,
-0.776762843132019,
0.6051174998283386,
0.24010421335697174,
0.028914080932736397,
-0.38483870029449463,
-0.21033629775047302,
-0.14807946979999542,
-0.16177579760551453,
-0.38965514302253723,
-1.0163171291351318,
0.9608162045478821,
0.4654519259929657,
0.2934277653694153,
0.20899242162704468,
0.042308468371629715,
0.29452210664749146,
-0.5575359463691711,
0.5179212689399719,
0.18296262621879578,
-0.5904209017753601,
0.7534871101379395,
-0.838657557964325,
0.4622117877006531,
0.7469825148582458,
-0.03884216398000717,
-0.5041536092758179,
-0.9525105953216553,
-0.7969337701797485,
-0.9734727144241333,
0.5706117749214172,
0.20387239754199982,
-0.030449621379375458,
-0.4624733626842499,
0.07106132060289383,
0.19592253863811493,
0.30447420477867126,
-0.8930135369300842,
0.011445906013250351,
-0.1632479578256607,
-0.7490593194961548,
0.36888670921325684,
0.16228939592838287,
0.07715296000242233,
-0.01580684445798397,
1.136703372001648,
-0.27914372086524963,
-0.1781766563653946,
0.2235485315322876,
-0.32705429196357727,
0.02154696360230446,
0.3313519358634949,
0.3152120113372803,
0.3453937768936157,
-0.07729743421077728,
0.06302101910114288,
-0.08713974058628082,
-0.34796780347824097,
0.09449369460344315,
-0.13568516075611115,
-0.34774643182754517,
0.5123205780982971,
-0.1189550906419754,
0.44873327016830444,
0.010992276482284069,
-0.9406253099441528,
0.3525104522705078,
-0.08713051676750183,
-0.30711284279823303,
-0.5392428636550903,
-0.193113774061203,
0.117525614798069,
-0.08153360337018967,
0.32461708784103394,
0.08998068422079086,
0.15817609429359436,
-0.4624885618686676,
0.31240031123161316,
0.29670289158821106,
-0.044280216097831726,
-0.04071016237139702,
0.5577254891395569,
0.35962337255477905,
-0.5081565380096436,
-0.027567405253648758,
-0.7594048976898193,
-0.18619488179683685,
0.5330897569656372,
0.6659625768661499,
0.7817767858505249,
-0.02910507097840309,
0.6835272312164307,
0.5417957305908203,
0.4466511309146881,
-0.6110354661941528,
0.263632595539093,
0.13933618366718292,
-0.81864333152771,
-0.4948238134384155,
-0.9308107495307922,
-0.2517545819282532,
0.016775701195001602,
-0.23054446280002594,
0.3027518093585968,
-0.50539231300354,
-0.18312519788742065,
-0.3354692757129669,
-0.0838499590754509,
-0.4541681110858917,
0.19781439006328583,
0.14291784167289734,
0.8010197281837463,
-0.8446516394615173,
0.8820827603340149,
0.516946017742157,
-0.2799778878688812,
-0.5221652984619141,
-0.5123658776283264,
-0.19564242660999298,
-0.41530078649520874,
0.4699103534221649,
-0.01872279867529869,
-0.49516698718070984,
0.016881244257092476,
0.0674654021859169,
-0.6068680286407471,
0.8162091374397278,
0.42746198177337646,
-0.3294272720813751,
-0.1648910641670227,
0.34383806586265564,
0.9456360936164856,
-0.2918083965778351,
-0.13544966280460358,
0.5674909949302673,
0.5613328218460083,
0.21690049767494202,
-0.8969288468360901,
-0.1221107468008995,
-0.4699731469154358,
-0.11274442076683044,
0.20652049779891968,
-0.019536875188350677,
0.4366101622581482,
0.18895778059959412,
-0.41185930371284485,
0.20976179838180542,
0.7481147050857544,
0.049601271748542786,
-0.14532679319381714,
0.2160174548625946,
0.6163536310195923,
1.032896637916565,
-0.13688652217388153,
0.9909453988075256,
-0.36376988887786865,
-0.003354058600962162,
1.2210949659347534,
0.11520847678184509,
0.42196932435035706,
0.4952182173728943,
0.08108098804950714,
0.32135269045829773,
0.2555813193321228,
0.00007111412560334429,
0.338630735874176,
0.34268832206726074,
-0.520679771900177,
0.16475637257099152,
-0.2654619514942169,
0.06285450607538223,
0.12536300718784332,
0.17648369073867798,
-0.4088696241378784,
-0.3827993869781494,
0.058614663779735565,
-0.00429017748683691,
0.5729779005050659,
-0.3092274069786072,
0.7187511324882507,
-0.197150319814682,
-0.9285163283348083,
0.3733544647693634,
0.301618754863739,
0.9566457867622375,
-0.575032114982605,
0.37616175413131714,
0.029037119820713997,
-0.027950376272201538,
-0.6210293173789978,
-0.7277815937995911,
0.631500780582428,
0.4796532094478607,
0.07040837407112122,
-0.5864773988723755,
0.7071307897567749,
-0.524284839630127,
-0.7866016030311584,
-0.07296333461999893,
0.7935047149658203,
0.16460491716861725,
0.046815283596515656,
-0.22342003881931305,
-0.36915653944015503,
0.015528317540884018,
-0.10053227096796036,
-0.1778736412525177,
0.5099281668663025,
-0.08522272855043411,
0.5177329182624817,
0.636685311794281,
0.4051930904388428,
0.7769957780838013,
0.27682721614837646,
0.20011714100837708,
-0.5533159375190735,
-0.7772987484931946,
-0.6193132996559143,
0.5979140996932983,
-0.15396089851856232,
-0.39970335364341736,
0.7302712202072144,
0.538597047328949,
0.5570091009140015,
-0.12982524931430817,
1.005552053451538,
-0.5794338583946228,
0.4739825129508972,
-0.33714067935943604,
0.45589330792427063,
-0.14701169729232788,
0.07344865798950195,
-0.16188788414001465,
-0.9988464117050171,
-0.8621546030044556,
0.7638816833496094,
0.04644187539815903,
-0.5805037021636963,
0.80010986328125,
0.8217470645904541,
0.1589861810207367,
0.08285311609506607,
0.08079387992620468,
-0.1656716763973236,
0.4159794747829437,
0.34010323882102966,
0.5972956418991089,
-0.33388277888298035,
0.6528913974761963,
-0.34492188692092896,
-0.2202075719833374,
-0.07867966592311859,
-0.9584623575210571,
-0.7998076677322388,
-0.634700357913971,
-0.13196992874145508,
-0.11479447036981583,
-0.12125327438116074,
1.1012139320373535,
0.20296365022659302,
-0.6532307267189026,
-0.3895420432090759,
-0.8109945058822632,
0.04668058082461357,
0.17894957959651947,
-0.2719484865665436,
0.2527543306350708,
-0.5664767622947693,
-0.777526319026947,
0.6661623120307922,
0.3564024865627289,
-0.03896607458591461,
-0.3822248578071594,
-0.08502408862113953,
-0.28840914368629456,
0.15648847818374634,
0.6179285645484924,
0.6057737469673157,
-0.49692344665527344,
-0.20198145508766174,
-0.08369993418455124,
-0.36147648096084595,
0.02810637466609478,
0.5104586482048035,
-1.025221586227417,
0.37316539883613586,
0.7691555023193359,
0.5597173571586609,
0.12147711962461472,
-0.14592821896076202,
0.6423236727714539,
-0.9813500046730042,
0.37854036688804626,
0.5956822633743286,
0.3330624997615814,
0.3514825999736786,
-0.2035277783870697,
0.3891046941280365,
-0.1201774999499321,
-0.4920247495174408,
-0.6418426632881165,
0.429952472448349,
-1.0192843675613403,
-0.04268580302596092,
1.016170620918274,
0.4349992275238037,
-0.2629278302192688,
-0.2691587507724762,
-0.6557839512825012,
0.32110661268234253,
-0.3546636700630188,
0.8116244673728943,
0.4968772828578949,
-0.18045100569725037,
0.1350313276052475,
-0.44539833068847656,
0.5730127096176147,
0.029019726440310478,
-1.176763653755188,
-0.21178007125854492,
0.6255782246589661,
-0.08830573409795761,
0.21434882283210754,
0.655310869216919,
-0.28120502829551697,
0.23062270879745483,
-0.24131284654140472,
0.434940367937088,
-0.2292712777853012,
-0.41268080472946167,
-0.2900341749191284,
0.4476577639579773,
-0.002597114769741893,
0.11156120896339417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17264v1
|
On the Noise Robustness of In-Context Learning for Text Generation
| 2024-05-27T15:22:58 | 2024-05-27T15:22:58 |
Hongfu Gao, Feipeng Zhang, Wenyu Jiang, Jun Shu, Feng Zheng, Hongxin Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive performance on downstream
tasks by in-context learning (ICL), which heavily relies on the quality of
demonstrations selected from a large set of annotated examples. Recent works
claim that in-context learning is robust to noisy demonstrations in text
classification. In this work, we show that, on text generation tasks, noisy
annotations significantly hurt the performance of in-context learning. To
circumvent the issue, we propose a simple and effective approach called Local
Perplexity Ranking (LPR), which replaces the "noisy" candidates with their
nearest neighbors that are more likely to be clean. Our method is motivated by
analyzing the perplexity deviation caused by noisy labels and decomposing
perplexity into inherent perplexity and matching perplexity. Our key idea
behind LPR is thus to decouple the matching perplexity by performing the
ranking among the neighbors in semantic space. Our approach can prevent the
selected demonstrations from including mismatched input-label pairs while
preserving the effectiveness of the original selection methods. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of LPR, improving the EM score by up
to 18.75 on common benchmarks with noisy annotations.
|
[
-0.42723071575164795,
-0.6418236494064331,
0.42642199993133545,
-0.05074060335755348,
-0.39898836612701416,
-0.19251759350299835,
-0.3405727744102478,
-0.5120182037353516,
-0.4037608504295349,
0.5160255432128906,
-0.29827412962913513,
-0.578792154788971,
-0.5204019546508789,
0.33636200428009033,
-0.35640355944633484,
1.3036341667175293,
0.04793146252632141,
-0.37093403935432434,
-0.48319849371910095,
-0.11193318665027618,
0.14059698581695557,
-0.6087282299995422,
-0.5404017567634583,
-0.20900794863700867,
0.6375816464424133,
0.4752761125564575,
0.6049333214759827,
0.6548887491226196,
0.46105635166168213,
0.4135398268699646,
-0.42337727546691895,
0.4169504642486572,
-0.6128731966018677,
0.6430203318595886,
0.08203060925006866,
-0.1839444637298584,
-0.14943450689315796,
-0.11774957925081253,
0.8228133320808411,
0.6787465214729309,
0.39583075046539307,
-0.12715376913547516,
0.3431519865989685,
0.37082865834236145,
-0.5629447102546692,
-0.15943975746631622,
-0.9534494876861572,
0.2628318667411804,
-0.3347907066345215,
-0.18641787767410278,
-0.3254942297935486,
-0.3241410255432129,
0.16829359531402588,
-0.5428634285926819,
0.3583226203918457,
-0.11007000505924225,
0.9395065903663635,
0.6496405005455017,
-0.2479788213968277,
-0.27456963062286377,
-0.7031276822090149,
0.8937288522720337,
-0.6050956845283508,
0.2936573028564453,
0.47830066084861755,
0.09909567981958389,
-0.2976199686527252,
-0.6284017562866211,
-0.5665286183357239,
-0.08949588239192963,
-0.07180394977331161,
0.10632244497537613,
0.019785922020673752,
-0.05975092574954033,
0.6064834594726562,
0.35483619570732117,
-0.2706865668296814,
0.2564898431301117,
-0.13170555233955383,
-0.3206426799297333,
0.523910641670227,
0.0017785971285775304,
0.0576707199215889,
0.03318187594413757,
-0.48346322774887085,
-0.19176676869392395,
-0.7871995568275452,
0.299248605966568,
0.6244446039199829,
0.376149445772171,
0.05047136917710304,
0.2458207607269287,
-0.24140958487987518,
0.6120792627334595,
0.20594896376132965,
-0.6232019066810608,
0.4638988673686981,
-0.4255325496196747,
-0.13775886595249176,
0.16665135324001312,
0.9101285338401794,
-0.026938898488879204,
-0.1104969009757042,
-0.2948439419269562,
-0.4293922483921051,
-0.21918317675590515,
0.003557957476004958,
-0.9876757264137268,
-0.24955512583255768,
0.08218967169523239,
-0.3401930034160614,
-0.50706946849823,
0.10736998170614243,
-0.8048238754272461,
-0.5351309180259705,
-0.14447927474975586,
0.46514129638671875,
-0.27855420112609863,
-0.035804882645606995,
-0.1866876631975174,
0.2575201690196991,
-0.019462071359157562,
0.44027313590049744,
-0.6465350985527039,
0.08269326388835907,
0.5153946876525879,
0.4302767217159271,
-0.14833663403987885,
-0.4121491014957428,
-0.7924630045890808,
0.009052102454006672,
-0.1388891339302063,
0.9434010982513428,
-0.4526578485965729,
-0.25683510303497314,
0.08519949018955231,
-0.33665692806243896,
-0.03919193148612976,
-0.9978421330451965,
0.5794653296470642,
-0.16140520572662354,
0.1705765426158905,
-0.3315945863723755,
-0.605080783367157,
0.11625567078590393,
-0.022828087210655212,
-0.4458160102367401,
0.9774269461631775,
-0.10359431058168411,
-1.1371533870697021,
0.7144081592559814,
-0.45128852128982544,
-0.6049056649208069,
-0.1441505253314972,
-0.29765698313713074,
-0.8229555487632751,
-0.11294548958539963,
0.29962703585624695,
0.6389963626861572,
0.19275403022766113,
-0.015329335816204548,
-0.16369402408599854,
-0.5780174136161804,
0.422095388174057,
-0.407603919506073,
0.5243578553199768,
0.3797287940979004,
-0.5739545822143555,
0.18177980184555054,
-0.8085240721702576,
-0.2816050350666046,
-0.26687002182006836,
-0.5775789618492126,
-0.4092172086238861,
0.09182952344417572,
-0.314740926027298,
0.29942694306373596,
0.007011782377958298,
-0.4475722312927246,
-0.0127937700599432,
-0.6439958810806274,
0.1211453378200531,
0.6255643367767334,
0.10679411888122559,
0.6138260364532471,
-0.6182249188423157,
0.22821664810180664,
0.22398138046264648,
-0.09109174460172653,
-0.1770041137933731,
-0.521233856678009,
-0.7172025442123413,
-0.5475232601165771,
0.14828848838806152,
0.2865630090236664,
-0.7617980241775513,
0.4587496221065521,
-0.2705179750919342,
-0.3429684638977051,
-0.37799185514450073,
0.5035840272903442,
0.6218275427818298,
0.705802857875824,
0.23874129354953766,
-0.12793999910354614,
-0.3272884786128998,
-0.603731095790863,
-0.35086268186569214,
0.05731581524014473,
-0.21693900227546692,
0.25363126397132874,
0.33170855045318604,
-0.20556743443012238,
0.807007908821106,
0.05157014727592468,
-0.4380662143230438,
-0.08350569009780884,
0.23750002682209015,
-0.01867336593568325,
0.43998363614082336,
0.2526027262210846,
-0.8630095720291138,
-0.4853416681289673,
0.08730965852737427,
-0.6643785834312439,
-0.30264535546302795,
-0.1457485854625702,
-0.01652279496192932,
0.3852011263370514,
0.8073044419288635,
-0.20778889954090118,
0.5544647574424744,
0.11628646403551102,
-0.14005804061889648,
0.28372666239738464,
-0.05656011775135994,
-0.09297101944684982,
-1.0111114978790283,
-0.19504468142986298,
-0.053564075380563736,
-0.22470057010650635,
-0.3258683979511261,
-0.129928857088089,
-0.3593668043613434,
0.012583612464368343,
-0.2769792377948761,
0.3430219888687134,
-0.328650563955307,
0.10173415392637253,
-0.07210388034582138,
0.399681031703949,
-0.21399572491645813,
0.25437238812446594,
-0.08372631669044495,
0.6798787117004395,
0.378145694732666,
-0.6177644729614258,
-0.20261332392692566,
0.22404268383979797,
-0.4925853908061981,
0.29926931858062744,
-0.09405723959207535,
0.2107798308134079,
-0.17764489352703094,
0.15272848308086395,
-1.0010347366333008,
-0.3232470452785492,
-0.09587978571653366,
-0.41011884808540344,
0.47004735469818115,
0.13971352577209473,
-0.507469892501831,
0.308462530374527,
-0.4225418269634247,
0.4222499132156372,
0.45676082372665405,
-0.8437787890434265,
0.25269174575805664,
0.35579967498779297,
-0.07833170145750046,
-0.49035361409187317,
-0.515813410282135,
-0.1765575259923935,
-0.3830048441886902,
-0.49566882848739624,
0.3167151212692261,
-0.15211975574493408,
-0.4043993055820465,
-0.2906034290790558,
-0.22267210483551025,
0.011427725665271282,
0.08971928060054779,
0.45933768153190613,
-0.31893008947372437,
-0.11806789040565491,
0.25458022952079773,
0.103084497153759,
-0.06798147410154343,
-0.04890574887394905,
0.13377411663532257,
0.09182567894458771,
-0.037491507828235626,
-0.12804844975471497,
-0.31704771518707275,
0.23853182792663574,
0.46164950728416443,
-0.06029897928237915,
0.3993402421474457,
0.6272569298744202,
-0.22041474282741547,
-0.6134424209594727,
-0.5088025331497192,
-0.17401650547981262,
-0.5041648745536804,
0.5253905057907104,
-0.42298170924186707,
-1.0429086685180664,
0.37725594639778137,
-0.2942379117012024,
0.14599862694740295,
0.10957586765289307,
0.3941532373428345,
-0.23888057470321655,
0.7575681805610657,
0.5699670910835266,
-0.003120667999610305,
0.5785328149795532,
-0.0720551460981369,
0.312303364276886,
-0.7043805718421936,
-0.12620623409748077,
-0.670163631439209,
-0.23263795673847198,
-0.5768797397613525,
-0.32127776741981506,
0.40416908264160156,
0.3227801024913788,
-0.4643811583518982,
0.07650533318519592,
-0.6899401545524597,
0.665352463722229,
0.35807672142982483,
0.07049689441919327,
0.41789761185646057,
0.7034083008766174,
-0.4973312020301819,
-0.4895058870315552,
-0.6674039959907532,
-0.5566996335983276,
0.8131599426269531,
0.30744966864585876,
0.43140876293182373,
0.19350974261760712,
1.0768893957138062,
-0.21863706409931183,
0.4719134271144867,
-0.40949341654777527,
0.5934743285179138,
-0.3410921096801758,
-0.16651523113250732,
-0.45263543725013733,
-0.7107895016670227,
-1.1014682054519653,
0.25471293926239014,
-0.486004501581192,
-1.0947647094726562,
0.10770969092845917,
-0.09851234406232834,
-0.19824710488319397,
0.5227247476577759,
-0.3624626100063324,
0.6453430652618408,
0.18983614444732666,
-0.5307729840278625,
0.22720952332019806,
-0.5888195037841797,
0.33103105425834656,
-0.19583086669445038,
0.44805392622947693,
0.2926541864871979,
0.0902947336435318,
0.5904279947280884,
-0.5297351479530334,
0.8694608807563782,
0.04376046359539032,
-0.34741008281707764,
0.10751660913228989,
0.17635205388069153,
0.4671166241168976,
-0.005297994241118431,
-0.2608203887939453,
-0.02933666482567787,
-0.548273503780365,
-0.046265486627817154,
-0.5581713914871216,
0.9496483206748962,
-0.7840611338615417,
-0.39274871349334717,
-0.2651805579662323,
-0.7077111005783081,
-0.20908363163471222,
-0.0057688308879733086,
0.9458341598510742,
0.5241531729698181,
0.4092150628566742,
0.29731371998786926,
1.0173072814941406,
-0.27420634031295776,
0.531323254108429,
0.06942802667617798,
-0.0789739117026329,
-0.6425724625587463,
1.2430028915405273,
0.2498161494731903,
0.23395517468452454,
0.6089726090431213,
0.21833845973014832,
-0.2606140077114105,
-0.6980884075164795,
-0.0886017382144928,
0.03965970501303673,
-0.9889891743659973,
-0.1820807009935379,
-0.588751494884491,
-0.35502418875694275,
-0.0616765022277832,
-0.3798927664756775,
-0.2332032024860382,
-0.1508224606513977,
-0.26153939962387085,
-0.007317700888961554,
0.044932618737220764,
0.95947265625,
0.14916668832302094,
-0.03949818015098572,
-0.4264010787010193,
0.07727621495723724,
0.4017266631126404,
0.25327304005622864,
-0.07885436713695526,
-0.6704206466674805,
-0.1288394033908844,
-0.39960426092147827,
-0.5600632429122925,
-0.6823881268501282,
0.07913684099912643,
0.18528610467910767,
0.5589060187339783,
0.5672196745872498,
0.48751744627952576,
0.7092326283454895,
-0.14448155462741852,
0.7174652814865112,
-0.021172447130084038,
-0.8222062587738037,
0.46649304032325745,
-0.4019952714443207,
0.38130995631217957,
0.5644012093544006,
0.2833672761917114,
0.2201324999332428,
-1.0250707864761353,
-0.6670567989349365,
-1.1840428113937378,
0.48473575711250305,
0.4383752644062042,
-0.04322674870491028,
0.06160493940114975,
0.3970142900943756,
0.16644559800624847,
0.029947251081466675,
-1.0722733736038208,
-0.2388026863336563,
-0.14293727278709412,
-0.2392638772726059,
0.08957450091838837,
-0.24247895181179047,
0.01747424341738224,
-0.4606304168701172,
0.6566773653030396,
-0.10557163506746292,
0.020214170217514038,
0.6227372884750366,
0.005005859769880772,
-0.2623021900653839,
0.174339160323143,
0.6221157312393188,
0.29004526138305664,
-0.1193365678191185,
0.2983631193637848,
0.37099722027778625,
-0.42646947503089905,
0.015294390730559826,
0.20094814896583557,
-0.5101805329322815,
0.1486809402704239,
0.6144818663597107,
0.5848538279533386,
0.43017587065696716,
-0.5099780559539795,
0.5952180624008179,
-0.13582724332809448,
-0.39751601219177246,
-0.06489087641239166,
0.17944695055484772,
-0.14480531215667725,
0.1412801593542099,
0.26322630047798157,
0.2229803204536438,
0.13337640464305878,
-0.13109244406223297,
0.29570212960243225,
0.3400920331478119,
-0.4688152074813843,
-0.04207545891404152,
0.6365755200386047,
0.1647467017173767,
-0.33886396884918213,
0.3235812485218048,
-0.5008631944656372,
-0.5241738557815552,
0.5450124740600586,
0.5925736427307129,
0.7928807735443115,
0.02046811208128929,
-0.06633726507425308,
0.6271308660507202,
0.253416508436203,
0.07608972489833832,
0.05133155733346939,
-0.49508026242256165,
-0.6123421788215637,
-0.2836645841598511,
-0.7152454853057861,
-0.4577748775482178,
0.3315434455871582,
-0.29763558506965637,
0.15133294463157654,
-0.4125325083732605,
-0.03951822593808174,
-0.02828190103173256,
0.1101134642958641,
-0.31833112239837646,
0.1131676435470581,
0.20260535180568695,
0.4385768473148346,
-0.5973563194274902,
0.8698049187660217,
0.9559281468391418,
-0.27130764722824097,
-0.8955677151679993,
0.5741057991981506,
-0.1388278603553772,
0.31562426686286926,
0.6930122375488281,
0.4229374825954437,
-0.27014920115470886,
-0.2330506443977356,
-0.6085034608840942,
-0.6948599219322205,
0.847862184047699,
0.44739675521850586,
-0.4207221269607544,
0.5514878034591675,
0.16562028229236603,
0.4864162802696228,
-0.43593862652778625,
0.18952324986457825,
0.09327638894319534,
0.27444133162498474,
0.05757473036646843,
-0.8561437726020813,
0.2045554220676422,
-0.12762762606143951,
0.011178647167980671,
0.10446563363075256,
-0.6216227412223816,
0.8347416520118713,
-0.25535646080970764,
-0.38112974166870117,
0.3307555913925171,
0.5955734252929688,
0.37183713912963867,
0.5398977994918823,
0.6331182718276978,
0.4326786994934082,
0.9150757789611816,
-0.1753099411725998,
0.9687565565109253,
0.02814164198935032,
0.20234860479831696,
1.1964260339736938,
-0.30481770634651184,
0.8892731070518494,
0.5277457237243652,
-0.20256483554840088,
0.553341269493103,
0.42329835891723633,
0.27761098742485046,
0.4441260099411011,
0.43643420934677124,
-0.4012751579284668,
-0.5297516584396362,
0.03407423570752144,
-0.1817323863506317,
0.32639196515083313,
0.0658174455165863,
-0.2061806172132492,
-0.43151575326919556,
-0.03546486049890518,
0.03307301923632622,
0.6286463737487793,
-0.05740448832511902,
1.0137569904327393,
-0.020826634019613266,
-0.551276683807373,
0.7403232455253601,
-0.4477711617946625,
0.9511176943778992,
-0.4088020920753479,
-0.1958993524312973,
-0.28991666436195374,
0.37256425619125366,
-0.37243691086769104,
-0.42612147331237793,
0.2592475116252899,
-0.1110302209854126,
-0.3334023356437683,
-0.12547004222869873,
0.7070631384849548,
-0.4960952401161194,
-0.3740617632865906,
0.3465553820133209,
0.11893787980079651,
0.3981993496417999,
0.047759298235177994,
-0.3324609398841858,
0.06154504790902138,
0.06766898930072784,
-0.3080269694328308,
0.835047721862793,
0.8610547184944153,
-0.07286687940359116,
0.6043055653572083,
0.693598747253418,
-0.25954627990722656,
-0.04482962563633919,
-0.060757528990507126,
0.9639503955841064,
-0.36871492862701416,
-0.26596277952194214,
-0.6837664246559143,
0.4601783752441406,
-0.19713327288627625,
-0.6918624639511108,
0.8754017949104309,
0.5532500743865967,
1.178638219833374,
0.16034770011901855,
0.5557557344436646,
0.33817681670188904,
0.5699262619018555,
-0.452894389629364,
0.9127362370491028,
-0.6489441990852356,
0.7583372592926025,
-0.6425589323043823,
-0.8178961277008057,
-0.6226705312728882,
0.9019358158111572,
-0.3355073928833008,
0.06053716316819191,
0.6513786315917969,
1.018625259399414,
0.09126530587673187,
-0.05074969306588173,
0.6259304881095886,
0.43134933710098267,
0.10128678381443024,
0.37137463688850403,
0.9767144918441772,
-0.4995328187942505,
0.7462592124938965,
-0.5656856298446655,
-0.1936250776052475,
0.10713621973991394,
-1.0209453105926514,
-1.1368236541748047,
-0.5925392508506775,
-0.4574975371360779,
-0.45799341797828674,
-0.08988606929779053,
0.8603969216346741,
0.6172144412994385,
-0.7612606883049011,
-0.12674039602279663,
-0.13187488913536072,
0.5023542046546936,
-0.24715371429920197,
-0.27737367153167725,
0.37800902128219604,
-0.8090077638626099,
-0.8043858408927917,
0.45453882217407227,
0.12331447005271912,
-0.08178750425577164,
0.05011793598532677,
-0.20730403065681458,
0.044993847608566284,
-0.14052215218544006,
0.41999441385269165,
0.13829612731933594,
-0.7746559381484985,
-0.12543943524360657,
-0.5035438537597656,
-0.25286865234375,
0.05299748107790947,
0.6061103940010071,
-0.9167166352272034,
0.5051402449607849,
0.4344039857387543,
0.6069777011871338,
0.34009024500846863,
-0.06093090772628784,
0.1818471997976303,
-0.9850185513496399,
0.3148094713687897,
0.2729039490222931,
0.2409648299217224,
0.5105890035629272,
-0.46647435426712036,
0.2617868483066559,
0.13118278980255127,
-0.9120413064956665,
-1.0443940162658691,
0.16543009877204895,
-0.7904788851737976,
-0.33629417419433594,
1.260635256767273,
-0.2450210154056549,
-0.12317825108766556,
-0.3875661790370941,
-0.2550755739212036,
0.14382243156433105,
-0.38641655445098877,
0.9771173596382141,
0.4003038704395294,
-0.03979244828224182,
-0.0456303171813488,
-0.419155478477478,
0.9694585800170898,
0.5214742422103882,
-0.535463273525238,
-0.014622681774199009,
0.14141714572906494,
0.34923791885375977,
0.28237563371658325,
0.3645186722278595,
-0.12408585846424103,
0.1432560533285141,
0.05925388261675835,
-0.09745803475379944,
-0.12471038848161697,
-0.26355889439582825,
-0.39801326394081116,
0.4367155134677887,
0.22565877437591553,
0.061236873269081116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17249v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17249v1
|
Assessing LLMs Suitability for Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-05-27T15:04:50 | 2024-05-27T15:04:50 |
Vasile Ionut Remus Iga, Gheorghe Cosmin Silaghi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work shown the capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to solve
tasks related to Knowledge Graphs, such as Knowledge Graph Completion, even in
Zero- or Few-Shot paradigms. However, they are known to hallucinate answers, or
output results in a non-deterministic manner, thus leading to wrongly reasoned
responses, even if they satisfy the user's demands. To highlight opportunities
and challenges in knowledge graphs-related tasks, we experiment with two
distinguished LLMs, namely Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1, and gpt-3.5-turbo-0125,
on Knowledge Graph Completion for static knowledge graphs, using prompts
constructed following the TELeR taxonomy, in Zero- and One-Shot contexts, on a
Task-Oriented Dialogue system use case. When evaluated using both strict and
flexible metrics measurement manners, our results show that LLMs could be fit
for such a task if prompts encapsulate sufficient information and relevant
examples.
|
[
-0.5533793568611145,
-0.7631688117980957,
0.9604671597480774,
0.00952344574034214,
-0.25234535336494446,
0.22701238095760345,
-0.16894854605197906,
-0.5138728618621826,
0.3100073039531708,
0.5153196454048157,
-0.5904256701469421,
-0.43630144000053406,
-0.6824349164962769,
0.36801570653915405,
-0.5149067640304565,
0.6691708564758301,
-0.4051893651485443,
-0.2375938594341278,
-0.5867932438850403,
-0.07084578275680542,
-0.6907599568367004,
-0.36128905415534973,
-0.6005664467811584,
-0.45904266834259033,
0.6447044014930725,
0.3240334093570709,
0.7064335942268372,
0.331705778837204,
0.09183625876903534,
0.26912158727645874,
-0.20101945102214813,
0.4178363084793091,
-0.5440784096717834,
0.39447933435440063,
0.0647275447845459,
-0.31630587577819824,
-0.5475442409515381,
0.13249458372592926,
0.5792441964149475,
0.9811937808990479,
0.06692257523536682,
0.30940964818000793,
0.24485711753368378,
0.4516744613647461,
-0.3402014970779419,
0.4319869577884674,
-0.5603628158569336,
0.16546088457107544,
-0.04421486705541611,
-0.21136325597763062,
-0.29550373554229736,
-0.4812948703765869,
0.2716986835002899,
-0.5771408677101135,
-0.12929637730121613,
0.23562489449977875,
0.6051047444343567,
0.16813461482524872,
-0.4934804141521454,
-0.2772430181503296,
-0.7320663928985596,
0.38723817467689514,
-0.952498733997345,
0.3758482336997986,
0.3953498303890228,
0.36569398641586304,
-0.3953941762447357,
-0.5762636065483093,
-0.5392184257507324,
-0.28428295254707336,
-0.2547115981578827,
0.08534788340330124,
-0.2101060152053833,
0.21706026792526245,
0.6081817150115967,
0.22541406750679016,
-0.5613324642181396,
0.15224382281303406,
-0.06821198761463165,
-0.4996572434902191,
0.25032421946525574,
0.5735339522361755,
0.0493425577878952,
-0.2831709682941437,
-0.0968826413154602,
0.19201046228408813,
-0.5332385301589966,
-0.1147611066699028,
0.425342321395874,
0.30783218145370483,
0.05803331360220909,
0.7978561520576477,
-0.5690146088600159,
1.2420653104782104,
-0.1551850438117981,
-0.1270727962255478,
-0.00492956442758441,
-0.42826220393180847,
-0.2472282350063324,
-0.21612796187400818,
0.9175577759742737,
0.39231735467910767,
0.4060342013835907,
-0.5215924382209778,
-0.22702638804912567,
-0.2041196972131729,
0.09790445864200592,
-0.657903790473938,
0.07375894486904144,
0.5000460147857666,
0.02599048800766468,
-0.08380142599344254,
-0.2757372558116913,
-0.395336776971817,
-0.5459787845611572,
-0.2633773684501648,
0.387809157371521,
-0.4268644452095032,
-0.19028685986995697,
0.14087651669979095,
-0.3313131034374237,
0.17229551076889038,
0.5220673680305481,
-0.41511550545692444,
0.20009464025497437,
0.5263285040855408,
0.8938969373703003,
-0.13390587270259857,
-0.07971259206533432,
-0.34951022267341614,
0.03364256024360657,
-0.5071737766265869,
0.7366697788238525,
-0.211233988404274,
-0.2435370683670044,
0.07192891836166382,
-0.20389176905155182,
-0.271301805973053,
-0.5845083594322205,
0.35819199681282043,
-0.7509253621101379,
0.3364758789539337,
-0.4906136691570282,
-0.9412127733230591,
-0.342936247587204,
0.7649914622306824,
-0.4454217255115509,
0.856268584728241,
0.4625779390335083,
-0.8611447215080261,
0.45322081446647644,
-0.29039254784584045,
-0.37796899676322937,
0.3634965121746063,
-0.20914843678474426,
-0.004792653955519199,
-0.12111793458461761,
-0.2501271367073059,
0.5178089737892151,
-0.38130640983581543,
0.21887880563735962,
-0.4498143792152405,
-0.38026949763298035,
0.3381199240684509,
-0.3335472345352173,
0.4009050130844116,
0.0496411994099617,
-0.17311114072799683,
0.08004849404096603,
-0.604324221611023,
0.2589006721973419,
0.19257590174674988,
-0.18408332765102386,
-0.05613876134157181,
0.013395075686275959,
-0.2801367938518524,
0.15160848200321198,
0.38237398862838745,
-0.4463160037994385,
0.194769486784935,
-0.0692683532834053,
0.28997647762298584,
0.5530816316604614,
-0.013448441401124,
0.022694287821650505,
-0.5840002298355103,
0.7107787132263184,
-0.09942563623189926,
-0.03782206028699875,
0.1403723508119583,
-0.5501867532730103,
-0.7664985656738281,
-0.35243669152259827,
0.2771328091621399,
0.6195651292800903,
-0.8492311835289001,
0.44497379660606384,
-0.28819310665130615,
-0.6182772517204285,
-0.04292955622076988,
0.11955023556947708,
0.1996934860944748,
0.7905518412590027,
0.02706827037036419,
-0.432054340839386,
-0.3874548673629761,
-0.6640704870223999,
-0.0882873684167862,
-0.39807045459747314,
-0.11902495473623276,
0.748862087726593,
0.17476364970207214,
-0.2561236023902893,
1.089828610420227,
-0.3364163637161255,
-0.22500304877758026,
-0.42380085587501526,
-0.0831608772277832,
0.3852214813232422,
-0.29383549094200134,
0.3625986874103546,
-0.24882708489894867,
-0.41027989983558655,
-0.05545056611299515,
-1.1765714883804321,
-0.1905757337808609,
0.1752902716398239,
0.3308396637439728,
0.0018498412100598216,
0.3191482722759247,
-0.8219080567359924,
0.3143599033355713,
0.3459005355834961,
-0.2169080525636673,
0.681528627872467,
-0.001064122305251658,
0.3006932735443115,
-0.806625247001648,
-0.11228431016206741,
-0.22332121431827545,
-0.6940029859542847,
-0.8191830515861511,
-0.37642326951026917,
-0.25897523760795593,
0.06881291419267654,
-0.39309993386268616,
0.5153288245201111,
-0.23589617013931274,
-0.22293564677238464,
-0.1144014522433281,
0.6541237831115723,
-0.17017647624015808,
0.2715238332748413,
-0.15276110172271729,
0.633019745349884,
0.5541297793388367,
-0.7200840711593628,
0.498697429895401,
0.2049304097890854,
-0.5719428062438965,
0.2646438777446747,
-0.7340713143348694,
0.30104729533195496,
-0.19474707543849945,
0.19062364101409912,
-1.1519219875335693,
-0.5371699929237366,
0.42924028635025024,
-0.1971677839756012,
0.1447012722492218,
-0.12967312335968018,
-0.6965951323509216,
-0.47194963693618774,
-0.1575363725423813,
0.3650106191635132,
0.3785935044288635,
-0.1788024753332138,
0.6817836165428162,
0.10549844801425934,
-0.026691390201449394,
-0.42998212575912476,
-0.22397400438785553,
0.09279964864253998,
-0.27909791469573975,
-0.606120228767395,
-0.05243789404630661,
-0.0014683239860460162,
-0.22874660789966583,
0.022782934829592705,
-0.16178235411643982,
0.27742788195610046,
0.16004106402397156,
0.19662658870220184,
0.25222310423851013,
-0.18867577612400055,
-0.14402936398983002,
-0.20787489414215088,
0.056359197944402695,
0.03819762170314789,
-0.47449830174446106,
0.7482497692108154,
-0.04990850389003754,
-0.8141692876815796,
-0.3120161294937134,
-0.006043991539627314,
0.7646145820617676,
0.15587733685970306,
0.5207265019416809,
0.3902513384819031,
-0.3392314314842224,
0.02771298959851265,
-0.7379946112632751,
-0.05028517171740532,
-0.4206284284591675,
0.3624993860721588,
-0.1995050460100174,
-1.2100228071212769,
0.8402958512306213,
0.00687429727986455,
0.02196451462805271,
0.2458161562681198,
0.47968584299087524,
-0.018452605232596397,
0.7429907917976379,
0.14220713078975677,
-0.008883570320904255,
0.3471226096153259,
-0.12396203726530075,
0.33174917101860046,
-0.7292090654373169,
-0.398603230714798,
-0.3807799816131592,
-0.16501867771148682,
-0.4070793688297272,
-0.2421416938304901,
0.4567558169364929,
0.15055911242961884,
-0.14950144290924072,
0.4033461809158325,
-0.21637824177742004,
0.3687306046485901,
0.24577705562114716,
0.02882864885032177,
0.5194681882858276,
-0.10075610131025314,
-0.19768592715263367,
0.1921708881855011,
-0.8436882495880127,
-0.6767737865447998,
0.8023661971092224,
0.2798490822315216,
0.6905984282493591,
0.020033324137330055,
0.6457434892654419,
0.2261473685503006,
0.21040600538253784,
-0.9905532598495483,
0.8423145413398743,
0.10602841526269913,
-0.36118754744529724,
-0.5346999168395996,
-0.6017558574676514,
-0.7182227373123169,
0.10041485726833344,
0.08721743524074554,
-1.0644116401672363,
-0.23576775193214417,
0.05771002545952797,
-0.2179485559463501,
0.2221294343471527,
-0.419433057308197,
0.841823935508728,
-0.029710888862609863,
0.12257103621959686,
0.10014761239290237,
-0.35083845257759094,
0.3929486870765686,
-0.13817724585533142,
0.2051388919353485,
-0.41359326243400574,
0.11073611676692963,
0.7853298187255859,
-0.32286909222602844,
0.9819434881210327,
-0.18365851044654846,
-0.20581208169460297,
0.562803328037262,
0.3575608432292938,
0.45221826434135437,
0.0008424266707152128,
0.010058796033263206,
0.0746954008936882,
0.16108837723731995,
-0.15673236548900604,
-0.8994563221931458,
0.34920087456703186,
-0.6626557111740112,
-0.8377254605293274,
-0.1883840709924698,
-0.8802328705787659,
-0.5636758208274841,
0.21975819766521454,
0.3473449647426605,
0.638812243938446,
-0.08820989727973938,
-0.1797291785478592,
0.6466293931007385,
0.06820271909236908,
0.22751343250274658,
0.5520259737968445,
-0.5405465364456177,
-0.19620281457901,
0.7539790272712708,
0.23849575221538544,
0.5843547582626343,
0.1416071653366089,
0.07221172004938126,
-0.3903355896472931,
-0.7490368485450745,
-0.4573677182197571,
0.1654677540063858,
-0.9144291281700134,
-0.2865004241466522,
-0.6251125335693359,
-0.5282156467437744,
-0.25165414810180664,
0.1814182996749878,
-0.028173979371786118,
-0.54710853099823,
-0.2035578042268753,
-0.09261670708656311,
0.3386371433734894,
1.0539014339447021,
0.26009801030158997,
0.00864371843636036,
-0.7706023454666138,
0.028300991281867027,
0.4073837697505951,
0.35569432377815247,
0.10653533041477203,
-0.6783373355865479,
-0.042494598776102066,
-0.04021171107888222,
-0.07494483888149261,
-0.9941386580467224,
-0.09541387856006622,
-0.10715623199939728,
0.7098135352134705,
0.2562616169452667,
0.07017172873020172,
0.4668937027454376,
-0.4305886924266815,
0.7859609127044678,
0.08633998036384583,
-0.740249752998352,
0.3351825773715973,
-0.523489773273468,
0.22172187268733978,
0.45341262221336365,
0.4078931212425232,
-0.7181252241134644,
-0.9267506003379822,
-0.39883750677108765,
-0.6559046506881714,
0.45911380648612976,
0.15114915370941162,
0.1871676743030548,
-0.18498095870018005,
0.42814901471138,
-0.05566646158695221,
0.2529290020465851,
-0.4742474853992462,
-0.3073727786540985,
-0.0733741819858551,
-0.15296372771263123,
0.14514221251010895,
-0.23994635045528412,
-0.21161435544490814,
0.05016384273767471,
0.5184710621833801,
-0.24615658819675446,
0.21371328830718994,
0.15291006863117218,
-0.028938040137290955,
0.07438930124044418,
0.5294095277786255,
0.4731353521347046,
0.6894263625144958,
-0.1662508100271225,
0.12910211086273193,
0.27553242444992065,
-0.11613316833972931,
0.17077958583831787,
0.06611461937427521,
-0.31955066323280334,
0.0051142075099051,
0.5312106013298035,
0.7856147289276123,
-0.051999781280756,
-0.6710310578346252,
0.4754178524017334,
-0.0681551843881607,
-0.30958154797554016,
-0.10694795101881027,
0.2761136591434479,
0.06695553660392761,
0.29801979660987854,
0.19845563173294067,
-0.2119349241256714,
0.055274445563554764,
-0.4304664433002472,
0.0243136715143919,
0.7388145327568054,
-0.7121817469596863,
-0.13310641050338745,
0.45501601696014404,
-0.2280242145061493,
-0.32686474919319153,
0.6905214786529541,
-0.697920560836792,
-0.7289310693740845,
0.43874984979629517,
0.6384912133216858,
0.6468382477760315,
0.28028881549835205,
0.3123292922973633,
0.06506352126598358,
0.25484541058540344,
0.007351704407483339,
0.3313615918159485,
0.02713179960846901,
-0.9652248620986938,
-0.4947509765625,
-0.38629859685897827,
-0.6025508046150208,
0.008379883132874966,
-0.4176950454711914,
0.11729408800601959,
-0.35568293929100037,
-0.4233797490596771,
-0.1874712109565735,
-0.1622593104839325,
-0.714302122592926,
-0.059251561760902405,
0.032124198973178864,
1.0808168649673462,
-0.7706406116485596,
0.5070123672485352,
0.6598479151725769,
-0.299557089805603,
-1.0381089448928833,
-0.200864776968956,
0.009745794348418713,
-0.6845734715461731,
0.46564796566963196,
-0.024434328079223633,
-0.24883906543254852,
-0.14352943003177643,
-0.21113330125808716,
-0.5862972140312195,
1.3106461763381958,
0.5764970183372498,
-0.31420645117759705,
-0.10858825594186783,
0.47079578042030334,
0.4550519287586212,
-0.26404035091400146,
0.3608943819999695,
0.5682616233825684,
0.5119356513023376,
0.35192617774009705,
-1.3083288669586182,
0.2685612440109253,
0.17725184559822083,
-0.10405571013689041,
0.05869749188423157,
-0.4719802439212799,
0.4698871672153473,
-0.16084393858909607,
-0.12443408370018005,
0.12709181010723114,
0.6624503135681152,
0.3389534652233124,
0.27028584480285645,
0.6805152297019958,
0.449930876493454,
1.0148038864135742,
-0.09060801565647125,
1.0330454111099243,
-0.28944507241249084,
0.2952800989151001,
0.8947308659553528,
-0.3928074538707733,
0.5198792815208435,
0.28855612874031067,
-0.3400111496448517,
0.44216039776802063,
0.7766612768173218,
0.17816168069839478,
0.19469515979290009,
0.15782731771469116,
-0.3112766742706299,
-0.5105522871017456,
-0.5437231659889221,
-0.2890627384185791,
0.23334433138370514,
0.38193556666374207,
0.02940482646226883,
-0.23658205568790436,
-0.36732974648475647,
0.0012740768725052476,
-0.2962275743484497,
-0.07702592760324478,
0.7499094605445862,
0.24154558777809143,
-0.7284621596336365,
0.5596440434455872,
-0.28503870964050293,
0.305004358291626,
-0.6587927937507629,
0.20132915675640106,
-0.2517080307006836,
-0.23603218793869019,
-0.2765401601791382,
-0.9846271872520447,
0.22679784893989563,
-0.1667572408914566,
-0.050004441291093826,
-0.08467831462621689,
0.7950668334960938,
-0.37112459540367126,
-0.3217064142227173,
0.40909722447395325,
0.9482424259185791,
0.14924724400043488,
0.1108713448047638,
-0.10840411484241486,
-0.03554823622107506,
-0.07901174575090408,
-0.19722674787044525,
0.2774379551410675,
0.4734641909599304,
0.09961250424385071,
0.8405442237854004,
0.03920937329530716,
0.004078772384673357,
0.08192919939756393,
0.26454341411590576,
0.7299529910087585,
-0.31791970133781433,
0.02254893071949482,
-0.7823486328125,
0.1590355485677719,
-0.0289300587028265,
-0.07958362996578217,
0.9603321552276611,
0.5885439515113831,
0.7111609578132629,
0.1471218466758728,
0.8037586808204651,
-0.22245216369628906,
0.28162384033203125,
-0.5162063241004944,
0.43723151087760925,
-0.42953789234161377,
0.34935760498046875,
-0.28585636615753174,
-0.9516815543174744,
-0.17644736170768738,
0.2750343680381775,
-0.3206385374069214,
0.17666596174240112,
0.68685382604599,
0.7078741788864136,
0.0360962338745594,
0.1513240784406662,
0.4661005735397339,
0.023303953930735588,
0.17330524325370789,
0.6052364110946655,
1.1677131652832031,
-0.09229668229818344,
0.6408271193504333,
0.08681602030992508,
-0.26103171706199646,
0.11017370969057083,
-0.9588215351104736,
-1.0410977602005005,
-0.48380783200263977,
-0.37778475880622864,
-0.5645964741706848,
-0.20854012668132782,
0.8101211786270142,
0.482779324054718,
-0.6145679950714111,
-0.22453813254833221,
0.2668382227420807,
0.46250131726264954,
0.0805191695690155,
-0.18188847601413727,
0.006444808095693588,
-0.5925809144973755,
-0.2413952648639679,
0.4274722635746002,
0.44019410014152527,
0.2007169872522354,
-0.27131393551826477,
-0.0011702842311933637,
0.3492879569530487,
0.05612684786319733,
0.5402663350105286,
0.13050436973571777,
-0.8062468767166138,
-0.7251476645469666,
0.3633595108985901,
-0.08374398201704025,
-0.09652962535619736,
0.9418017268180847,
-0.7556877136230469,
0.290269136428833,
0.49661698937416077,
0.6051030158996582,
0.501363217830658,
-0.3057340383529663,
0.4676676094532013,
-0.7147538065910339,
-0.23270617425441742,
0.12290117144584656,
0.6118083596229553,
0.3165091872215271,
-0.13569138944149017,
0.44371140003204346,
0.2801744043827057,
-0.4741499722003937,
-0.5860249400138855,
0.4775843024253845,
-1.0682458877563477,
0.0655156821012497,
1.337666392326355,
-0.2269277423620224,
0.09766201674938202,
-0.4231678247451782,
0.04078548029065132,
0.2515375018119812,
-0.04869067668914795,
0.5911056995391846,
1.0144003629684448,
-0.2575947940349579,
0.10874128341674805,
-0.6632546782493591,
0.2265770137310028,
0.19743019342422485,
-0.721895694732666,
0.22743253409862518,
0.5050458908081055,
0.4351893663406372,
0.2884157598018646,
0.9947284460067749,
-0.0007798031438142061,
0.04266177862882614,
-0.23636943101882935,
-0.4776271879673004,
-0.21873046457767487,
-0.1449299156665802,
-0.0357234962284565,
0.16654637455940247,
0.6119750142097473,
0.26185765862464905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00038v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00038v1
|
ViSpeR: Multilingual Audio-Visual Speech Recognition
| 2024-05-27T14:48:51 | 2024-05-27T14:48:51 |
Sanath Narayan, Yasser Abdelaziz Dahou Djilali, Ankit Singh, Eustache Le Bihan, Hakim Hacid
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This work presents an extensive and detailed study on Audio-Visual Speech
Recognition (AVSR) for five widely spoken languages: Chinese, Spanish, English,
Arabic, and French. We have collected large-scale datasets for each language
except for English, and have engaged in the training of supervised learning
models. Our model, ViSpeR, is trained in a multi-lingual setting, resulting in
competitive performance on newly established benchmarks for each language. The
datasets and models are released to the community with an aim to serve as a
foundation for triggering and feeding further research work and exploration on
Audio-Visual Speech Recognition, an increasingly important area of research.
Code available at
\href{https://github.com/YasserdahouML/visper}{https://github.com/YasserdahouML/visper}.
|
[
-0.3095141053199768,
-0.400704026222229,
0.21377186477184296,
0.3710996210575104,
-0.11649423837661743,
-0.12548837065696716,
-0.38372209668159485,
-0.6786104440689087,
-0.04059934243559837,
0.405956506729126,
-0.1736585944890976,
-0.6153361797332764,
-0.5903854966163635,
0.1199156790971756,
-0.6264265179634094,
0.5040242075920105,
0.004416275769472122,
0.7235032916069031,
0.05981258675456047,
-0.46975404024124146,
-0.5251509547233582,
-0.44573134183883667,
-0.6672177910804749,
-0.2380986511707306,
0.5375304818153381,
0.7495516538619995,
0.16111117601394653,
0.4948354959487915,
0.7441499829292297,
0.340089350938797,
0.05803963541984558,
0.1945311427116394,
-0.15644609928131104,
0.19848772883415222,
0.16492405533790588,
-0.15680527687072754,
-0.4168263077735901,
-0.3964390456676483,
0.8740963339805603,
0.40083780884742737,
-0.31810832023620605,
0.366013765335083,
-0.14712662994861603,
0.6558396816253662,
-0.7080526947975159,
0.499210000038147,
-0.44313517212867737,
0.2951226234436035,
-0.30938243865966797,
-0.12494440376758575,
-0.41156458854675293,
-0.34720414876937866,
0.2688875198364258,
-0.4382201135158539,
0.16559730470180511,
-0.17113296687602997,
0.5436410307884216,
0.2960374057292938,
-0.36267802119255066,
0.0025735688395798206,
-1.0890324115753174,
0.7307955622673035,
-0.2943762242794037,
0.9994022250175476,
0.3383025825023651,
0.9139763116836548,
0.5151669979095459,
-0.9642261862754822,
-0.6908340454101562,
0.006979530677199364,
0.5502724647521973,
0.17031794786453247,
-0.2072523981332779,
-0.3065337836742401,
0.1099969744682312,
0.2766382098197937,
-0.5143582224845886,
-0.12721598148345947,
-0.6901417970657349,
-0.32125627994537354,
0.5975855588912964,
0.026567237451672554,
0.41719451546669006,
0.21484455466270447,
-0.2863708436489105,
-0.36457931995391846,
-0.36580607295036316,
0.41516607999801636,
-0.1330726593732834,
0.4926125705242157,
-0.49100908637046814,
0.6973995566368103,
0.015787219628691673,
1.1165608167648315,
-0.449279248714447,
-0.5544165372848511,
0.7268162965774536,
-0.22813928127288818,
-0.270033061504364,
0.42454034090042114,
0.88041090965271,
0.32036063075065613,
0.4605090022087097,
0.2908235788345337,
-0.21029216051101685,
0.19503188133239746,
-0.08224231004714966,
-0.505604088306427,
-0.10957028716802597,
-0.1449691206216812,
-0.3801513612270355,
0.04389592260122299,
0.1903158724308014,
-0.4610898792743683,
-0.28926223516464233,
-0.5617458820343018,
0.35812121629714966,
-0.5365709066390991,
-0.5009656548500061,
0.41448986530303955,
-0.26185518503189087,
0.6456523537635803,
0.4063163697719574,
-0.399751752614975,
0.343733549118042,
0.4494078755378723,
0.8766570687294006,
-0.18943096697330475,
-0.7414932250976562,
-0.9898906350135803,
0.3230561316013336,
-0.27843743562698364,
0.6314159035682678,
-0.7645621299743652,
-0.3800201416015625,
0.27623113989830017,
0.1273731291294098,
0.029735926538705826,
-0.5357584357261658,
0.6502901315689087,
-0.2741755545139313,
0.20608891546726227,
-0.4628234803676605,
-0.0579974465072155,
-0.5717595219612122,
0.11102160066366196,
-0.7970578074455261,
0.7163726687431335,
-0.26413488388061523,
-0.7952423095703125,
0.36774125695228577,
-0.5444561839103699,
-0.39935502409935,
0.23542805016040802,
-0.5528964996337891,
-0.35065242648124695,
-0.08205145597457886,
0.3254146873950958,
0.5592919588088989,
-0.4008652865886688,
-0.06985866278409958,
0.29750949144363403,
-0.2948695421218872,
0.022297337651252747,
-0.6689475178718567,
0.7099378108978271,
0.4400474727153778,
-0.29318666458129883,
0.23437851667404175,
-1.1563200950622559,
-0.07090267539024353,
0.16086465120315552,
-0.22508446872234344,
-0.2747781276702881,
0.0884842723608017,
0.7789260745048523,
0.29696154594421387,
0.31064373254776,
-0.7119098901748657,
-0.24499371647834778,
-0.34824374318122864,
0.3805953860282898,
0.3342885375022888,
-0.17480795085430145,
0.03350713476538658,
0.023395884782075882,
0.627169668674469,
0.3648740351200104,
0.3354126513004303,
-0.26494526863098145,
-0.395247220993042,
-0.9411631226539612,
-0.41339361667633057,
0.03819083794951439,
0.8417412042617798,
-0.91184401512146,
-0.20581486821174622,
-0.24454089999198914,
-0.6743474006652832,
-0.43686720728874207,
0.08016902208328247,
0.6759067177772522,
0.49878498911857605,
0.5230247378349304,
-0.2478698194026947,
-0.6838602423667908,
-1.004152774810791,
0.027624547481536865,
-0.18429499864578247,
0.1797998994588852,
0.26696568727493286,
0.23334269225597382,
-0.5031688809394836,
0.7987565994262695,
-0.2304507941007614,
-0.7117578387260437,
-0.41013213992118835,
-0.21279047429561615,
0.1703617423772812,
0.2214503288269043,
0.6717322468757629,
-1.084476113319397,
-0.839177131652832,
0.47971785068511963,
-0.6584334373474121,
0.321870893239975,
0.38214197754859924,
0.35708945989608765,
0.053857140243053436,
0.6766321063041687,
0.16520313918590546,
0.20097437500953674,
0.7822713851928711,
-0.011833230033516884,
0.5071149468421936,
-0.16314013302326202,
0.13968220353126526,
-1.1478650569915771,
-0.25340041518211365,
0.13541127741336823,
-0.39130139350891113,
-0.5673453211784363,
-0.23617768287658691,
0.17070217430591583,
-0.26689794659614563,
-1.0984528064727783,
0.42141517996788025,
-0.6732208132743835,
-0.00777160981670022,
-0.1330326348543167,
-0.16097328066825867,
-0.36590856313705444,
0.20078174769878387,
0.40107664465904236,
1.061867117881775,
1.4057332277297974,
-0.9077817797660828,
0.8428944945335388,
0.4152373969554901,
-0.48931315541267395,
0.696710467338562,
-1.0301586389541626,
-0.0968957468867302,
-0.15003424882888794,
-0.43950194120407104,
-0.8589715957641602,
-0.19322757422924042,
0.10981382429599762,
-0.6325397491455078,
0.44305479526519775,
-0.02081846445798874,
-0.1766912192106247,
-0.24448561668395996,
-0.045584674924612045,
0.6519523859024048,
0.26241907477378845,
-0.600739598274231,
0.7586182355880737,
0.8646119236946106,
-0.2846444845199585,
-0.7800635099411011,
-0.6804839968681335,
0.21437090635299683,
-0.2600160241127014,
-0.38231638073921204,
-0.030248694121837616,
0.07526544481515884,
-0.24380634725093842,
-0.46365225315093994,
0.11242621392011642,
-0.3796464502811432,
-0.737695038318634,
0.22279801964759827,
0.12669746577739716,
-0.3795391023159027,
-0.017426401376724243,
-0.36995822191238403,
-0.18591855466365814,
-0.023774778470396996,
-0.009281094186007977,
0.6221429109573364,
-0.6373764872550964,
-0.5626876950263977,
-0.5736081004142761,
0.4259057641029358,
0.8068397045135498,
-0.8232249021530151,
0.26736554503440857,
1.1207948923110962,
-0.30605947971343994,
-0.013632388785481453,
-0.7574726939201355,
0.2210153192281723,
-0.46443793177604675,
0.8019015192985535,
-0.6647136807441711,
-0.6597126126289368,
0.5559386610984802,
0.22896026074886322,
-0.0753135234117508,
0.32730376720428467,
0.6536117196083069,
0.30162087082862854,
1.0874327421188354,
1.0113049745559692,
-0.440993994474411,
0.6280563473701477,
-0.19455797970294952,
-0.06513702869415283,
-0.5982064008712769,
-0.454862505197525,
-0.6168144941329956,
0.18783290684223175,
-0.604446530342102,
-0.5408469438552856,
0.7715283632278442,
-0.6851361393928528,
-0.20357489585876465,
0.43308013677597046,
-0.6226396560668945,
0.40125179290771484,
0.679583728313446,
-0.09058758616447449,
0.28477078676223755,
0.1588720679283142,
-0.17831012606620789,
-0.2536955177783966,
-0.7361100316047668,
-0.2969672679901123,
0.6930743455886841,
0.40522605180740356,
0.9074829816818237,
0.22208797931671143,
0.4350712299346924,
0.18627220392227173,
-0.56032395362854,
-0.9134323000907898,
0.5674351453781128,
-0.10637404024600983,
-0.32390275597572327,
-0.48017269372940063,
-0.14699676632881165,
-0.849612295627594,
0.33100181818008423,
0.0038530509918928146,
-0.3775799870491028,
0.46783989667892456,
0.042489033192396164,
0.054944004863500595,
0.21886080503463745,
-0.5793837308883667,
0.7489209771156311,
-0.4055957496166229,
-0.2074550986289978,
-0.21659936010837555,
-0.8120714426040649,
-0.0022130771540105343,
0.17911241948604584,
0.43005362153053284,
0.06379973143339157,
0.0705161914229393,
0.8116993308067322,
-0.023542871698737144,
0.6874544620513916,
-0.20766103267669678,
-0.04652765020728111,
0.15410535037517548,
-0.09100336581468582,
0.14458712935447693,
0.09375912696123123,
0.3187503516674042,
0.38011181354522705,
0.21813996136188507,
-0.22731627523899078,
0.1626765877008438,
0.5078945755958557,
-0.7609237432479858,
-0.06286118924617767,
-0.9160574674606323,
-0.41324982047080994,
-0.2590533196926117,
0.4421270787715912,
0.21594208478927612,
0.5905903577804565,
-0.4503335952758789,
0.3989240229129791,
0.7057381272315979,
-0.6193294525146484,
0.5098451972007751,
0.8449943661689758,
-0.4491086006164551,
-0.6453902125358582,
1.3393036127090454,
0.0009454889805056155,
-0.078648641705513,
0.399137943983078,
0.054359402507543564,
-0.12598875164985657,
-0.34848782420158386,
-0.3068287968635559,
0.4057905972003937,
-0.7201282978057861,
0.13588126003742218,
-0.47378626465797424,
-0.5626398324966431,
-0.28597497940063477,
0.15074384212493896,
-0.7106674909591675,
-0.2262657731771469,
-0.0949588194489479,
0.051257114857435226,
0.345915287733078,
0.602992594242096,
-0.08260220289230347,
0.058684516698122025,
-0.839613139629364,
0.684267520904541,
0.4984060525894165,
0.2635134160518646,
-0.1506509631872177,
-0.5300493240356445,
-0.5512052178382874,
-0.08405818045139313,
-0.05598268657922745,
-0.6849326491355896,
0.7208116054534912,
0.6269577145576477,
0.6783362030982971,
0.5837908983230591,
-0.239718958735466,
0.7517691254615784,
-1.178819179534912,
0.6653448939323425,
0.5318621397018433,
-0.8853829503059387,
0.6817850470542908,
-0.14938952028751373,
0.3234297037124634,
0.41991034150123596,
0.42992761731147766,
-0.8850184679031372,
-0.2865510880947113,
-0.15605950355529785,
-0.9716203212738037,
0.5706833600997925,
-0.15494117140769958,
0.22195202112197876,
0.12629787623882294,
-0.28889378905296326,
0.17679999768733978,
0.22784467041492462,
-0.7885448932647705,
-0.5789440870285034,
-0.4540099799633026,
-0.12221286445856094,
-0.2575179934501648,
-0.4084995687007904,
-0.1611931174993515,
-0.7494566440582275,
0.5470046401023865,
0.0899219885468483,
0.16463132202625275,
0.14754904806613922,
-0.2647717297077179,
0.12925368547439575,
0.30526262521743774,
0.7153231501579285,
0.8476104736328125,
-0.09148603677749634,
0.10573003441095352,
-0.014647130854427814,
-0.9502291083335876,
0.16210447251796722,
0.1748027205467224,
-0.05449703708291054,
0.3432493209838867,
0.36988699436187744,
1.0227826833724976,
-0.0405752994120121,
-0.9201834201812744,
0.6752336025238037,
-0.3136763572692871,
-0.2357318103313446,
-1.2308622598648071,
0.04605250433087349,
-0.17025168240070343,
0.4134023189544678,
0.46261778473854065,
0.02952977642416954,
0.4027807414531708,
-0.35703402757644653,
0.0432131327688694,
0.32229483127593994,
-0.8860072493553162,
-0.16998562216758728,
1.0032567977905273,
0.186262845993042,
-0.34102335572242737,
0.3145889639854431,
0.2929081320762634,
-0.5288549065589905,
0.34228846430778503,
0.47580304741859436,
0.8315858840942383,
-0.5302205681800842,
0.16870972514152527,
0.5231457948684692,
0.31966936588287354,
-0.22547462582588196,
0.7020819187164307,
-0.1692913919687271,
-0.7821784019470215,
-0.3454414904117584,
-0.526064932346344,
-0.7276275753974915,
0.03149385377764702,
-0.9933804273605347,
0.6541658639907837,
-0.01844429410994053,
-0.15615959465503693,
0.12716491520404816,
-0.5087350606918335,
-0.6445294618606567,
0.17147894203662872,
0.386454701423645,
0.7755725383758545,
-0.9753558039665222,
0.9208000302314758,
0.9419400095939636,
-0.6243225932121277,
-0.556334376335144,
-0.3204956352710724,
0.07596148550510406,
-0.839985728263855,
0.8067334294319153,
0.0061014071106910706,
-0.5086385607719421,
0.0031673379708081484,
-0.42408090829849243,
-0.9167987704277039,
0.7930554151535034,
0.24217693507671356,
-0.8240649700164795,
0.21180424094200134,
0.14753210544586182,
0.38069796562194824,
-0.17336192727088928,
0.04229605570435524,
0.2728716731071472,
0.514606773853302,
0.07818286865949631,
-1.3629539012908936,
-0.7233381271362305,
-0.4744320511817932,
0.033635277301073074,
-0.11432664096355438,
-0.6620112657546997,
0.8071118593215942,
-0.27646946907043457,
0.19606265425682068,
-0.5473027229309082,
0.8507247567176819,
0.2412995547056198,
0.36898717284202576,
0.4625917673110962,
0.2111068069934845,
0.5244275331497192,
0.06976278871297836,
0.6842860579490662,
-0.31337970495224,
-0.10394880920648575,
1.1293141841888428,
-0.47280818223953247,
1.0221383571624756,
0.4919317960739136,
-0.20549379289150238,
0.2710249125957489,
0.3266884386539459,
-0.023124288767576218,
0.5594931244850159,
-0.3713551163673401,
-0.36452627182006836,
-0.16344253718852997,
-0.23428669571876526,
-0.7883390188217163,
1.030586838722229,
0.25628140568733215,
-0.20059819519519806,
0.2155063897371292,
0.5355777740478516,
-0.19584928452968597,
0.018003905192017555,
-0.39108985662460327,
0.8190985321998596,
0.0498846061527729,
0.051569126546382904,
0.7556882500648499,
-0.12089686840772629,
0.7070145010948181,
-0.8038413524627686,
-0.1881590187549591,
0.2974761426448822,
0.3540220260620117,
-0.08565057814121246,
-0.4455517530441284,
-0.017403915524482727,
0.17020785808563232,
-0.3667638599872589,
-0.0912286639213562,
0.4335647523403168,
-0.7494105100631714,
-0.9852138161659241,
0.4824191629886627,
0.5659694671630859,
0.2770845592021942,
0.10406890511512756,
-0.5220627784729004,
0.2603699266910553,
0.17650103569030762,
-0.0985022783279419,
-0.0281220730394125,
0.4354914128780365,
-0.054398953914642334,
0.8615909218788147,
0.4499516189098358,
0.5638061761856079,
0.19474011659622192,
0.7052189111709595,
0.7046862840652466,
-0.7441543340682983,
-0.5644857883453369,
-0.6158571839332581,
0.418464332818985,
0.02590356394648552,
-0.23796585202217102,
1.0867832899093628,
1.0474566221237183,
1.2221999168395996,
-0.4084565341472626,
0.8920713663101196,
0.17647460103034973,
0.8641037344932556,
-0.3092919886112213,
0.683780312538147,
-0.7557331919670105,
0.03498317301273346,
-0.6439005136489868,
-0.8708810210227966,
-0.44847676157951355,
0.9432759284973145,
0.09228365123271942,
-0.06429141014814377,
0.5247556567192078,
0.5229894518852234,
-0.2671186923980713,
-0.3839714527130127,
0.530897855758667,
0.131413072347641,
0.35023489594459534,
0.38839656114578247,
0.658128023147583,
-0.5272382497787476,
0.5781801342964172,
-0.39890918135643005,
-0.10102111846208572,
-0.09313349425792694,
-0.6331986784934998,
-0.7571445107460022,
-1.0197771787643433,
-0.2969696521759033,
0.04447038844227791,
-0.030183859169483185,
0.9186089634895325,
0.6163824200630188,
-0.9440596103668213,
-0.8903769254684448,
0.30869463086128235,
-0.16781006753444672,
-0.5021929144859314,
-0.1514264941215515,
0.26335063576698303,
-0.05071445181965828,
-1.0382633209228516,
0.5319053530693054,
0.3463617265224457,
0.004100948106497526,
-0.1517062485218048,
-0.5045865774154663,
-0.1202143058180809,
-0.226068377494812,
0.8811697363853455,
0.6319932341575623,
-0.7444050312042236,
0.01137119997292757,
0.06229938566684723,
0.036553654819726944,
0.18757879734039307,
0.4671012759208679,
-0.6606073379516602,
0.8386801481246948,
0.5203816294670105,
0.37284016609191895,
0.6298390626907349,
-0.3352975845336914,
0.5974175930023193,
-0.5369912981987,
0.7373729348182678,
0.3016454875469208,
0.6621322631835938,
0.6142534017562866,
0.27491703629493713,
0.49111664295196533,
0.06476830691099167,
-0.43657585978507996,
-1.1027392148971558,
0.1796487271785736,
-1.2808561325073242,
0.12670941650867462,
1.1520289182662964,
0.34468722343444824,
-0.0468866229057312,
-0.24661242961883545,
-0.5226016044616699,
0.2927486300468445,
-0.373552531003952,
0.28835415840148926,
0.6119498610496521,
0.001948836725205183,
-0.6526085138320923,
-0.9124467372894287,
0.3457816541194916,
-0.0936443880200386,
-0.21730132400989532,
-0.11428844183683395,
0.7666443586349487,
0.17192667722702026,
0.09826869517564774,
0.6613751649856567,
-0.2407391518354416,
0.6565298438072205,
-0.1053234338760376,
0.575863778591156,
-0.28835588693618774,
-0.7540186643600464,
-0.471176415681839,
-6.562655698871822e-7,
0.3238697946071625,
-0.5918513536453247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17220v1
|
RLAIF-V: Aligning MLLMs through Open-Source AI Feedback for Super GPT-4V Trustworthiness
| 2024-05-27T14:37:01 | 2024-05-27T14:37:01 |
Tianyu Yu, Haoye Zhang, Yuan Yao, Yunkai Dang, Da Chen, Xiaoman Lu, Ganqu Cui, Taiwen He, Zhiyuan Liu, Tat-Seng Chua, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Learning from feedback reduces the hallucination of multimodal large language
models (MLLMs) by aligning them with human preferences. While traditional
methods rely on labor-intensive and time-consuming manual labeling, recent
approaches employing models as automatic labelers have shown promising results
without human intervention. However, these methods heavily rely on costly
proprietary models like GPT-4V, resulting in scalability issues. Moreover, this
paradigm essentially distills the proprietary models to provide a temporary
solution to quickly bridge the performance gap. As this gap continues to
shrink, the community is soon facing the essential challenge of aligning MLLMs
using labeler models of comparable capability. In this work, we introduce
RLAIF-V, a novel framework that aligns MLLMs in a fully open-source paradigm
for super GPT-4V trustworthiness. RLAIF-V maximally exploits the open-source
feedback from two perspectives, including high-quality feedback data and online
feedback learning algorithm. Extensive experiments on seven benchmarks in both
automatic and human evaluation show that RLAIF-V substantially enhances the
trustworthiness of models without sacrificing performance on other tasks. Using
a 34B model as labeler, RLAIF-V 7B model reduces object hallucination by 82.9\%
and overall hallucination by 42.1\%, outperforming the labeler model.
Remarkably, RLAIF-V also reveals the self-alignment potential of open-source
MLLMs, where a 12B model can learn from the feedback of itself to achieve less
than 29.5\% overall hallucination rate, surpassing GPT-4V (45.9\%) by a large
margin. The results shed light on a promising route to enhance the efficacy of
leading-edge MLLMs.
|
[
-0.16389939188957214,
-0.5705217123031616,
0.5402247905731201,
-0.07984835654497147,
-0.02342195436358452,
0.0508011132478714,
-0.07227025181055069,
-0.5728977918624878,
-0.060006413608789444,
0.373630553483963,
-0.6112838387489319,
-0.5179820656776428,
-0.5461321473121643,
-0.03548174723982811,
-0.13071277737617493,
1.2651089429855347,
-0.013332456350326538,
0.15834535658359528,
-0.42015594244003296,
-0.46140632033348083,
-0.2815115451812744,
-0.7139209508895874,
-0.3520776629447937,
-0.4661443531513214,
0.5511717200279236,
0.10955478250980377,
0.9493370056152344,
0.900991678237915,
0.7002856731414795,
0.23666761815547943,
0.3304921090602875,
0.25084927678108215,
-0.6620123386383057,
0.3563956916332245,
-0.1586979329586029,
-0.3724011182785034,
-0.4822605550289154,
0.017376545816659927,
0.5520128011703491,
0.004198302049189806,
-0.3699609041213989,
0.2377621829509735,
0.149959996342659,
0.8672336339950562,
-0.6422584652900696,
0.16294121742248535,
-0.2744392156600952,
0.14371494948863983,
0.04871733859181404,
-0.084255650639534,
-0.6123490333557129,
-0.6082240343093872,
0.17581714689731598,
-0.9295544624328613,
0.12963557243347168,
0.12561862170696259,
1.1324955224990845,
0.7349803447723389,
0.20066256821155548,
-0.0389031358063221,
-0.8377277255058289,
0.8620874285697937,
-0.5308083295822144,
0.9310175180435181,
0.31741034984588623,
0.33342450857162476,
0.07721547782421112,
-0.7505478262901306,
-0.4273419678211212,
-0.5637902617454529,
-0.1737486869096756,
0.1616562306880951,
-0.10683181136846542,
-0.1206413060426712,
0.1700197011232376,
0.15112750232219696,
-0.6179306507110596,
0.10544136166572571,
-0.32885196805000305,
-0.5840809345245361,
0.3032276928424835,
0.04963826760649681,
0.11365359276533127,
0.19156169891357422,
-0.5210063457489014,
-0.09457675367593765,
-0.6971017718315125,
-0.15515077114105225,
0.26612916588783264,
0.07498618215322495,
0.18369129300117493,
0.580230176448822,
0.012429960072040558,
0.7382532358169556,
0.3568383455276489,
-0.4934695363044739,
0.4604044556617737,
-0.32042405009269714,
-0.33831605315208435,
0.04033232107758522,
0.9355586767196655,
0.4786624312400818,
0.19983366131782532,
-0.11292627453804016,
-0.2841653823852539,
-0.013933675363659859,
0.3578791916370392,
-0.7914932370185852,
-0.4323144257068634,
0.23615504801273346,
-0.6500358581542969,
-0.38787323236465454,
0.16550381481647491,
-0.6628427505493164,
-0.6334496736526489,
-0.3426510989665985,
0.6379028558731079,
-0.38832002878189087,
-0.2992544174194336,
-0.3040878176689148,
0.1681043654680252,
0.24133430421352386,
0.4269540309906006,
-0.8578028082847595,
0.028825437650084496,
0.6338672637939453,
1.0370721817016602,
-0.26273593306541443,
-0.5199325680732727,
-1.0143775939941406,
0.24293296039104462,
-0.21413226425647736,
0.6431228518486023,
-0.6543391346931458,
-0.273440420627594,
-0.1674419492483139,
-0.0723574236035347,
0.08324224501848221,
-0.5355437994003296,
0.42925363779067993,
-0.3557340204715729,
0.33702465891838074,
-0.2055039256811142,
-0.45835500955581665,
-0.19015811383724213,
0.36954349279403687,
-0.6940666437149048,
1.2110073566436768,
0.09870190918445587,
-0.8953404426574707,
0.458678662776947,
-0.4517144560813904,
0.09452906250953674,
0.12673978507518768,
-0.33572623133659363,
-0.8292245268821716,
-0.14408265054225922,
0.4268876314163208,
0.49557310342788696,
-0.029481075704097748,
0.3283631205558777,
-0.5049190521240234,
-0.44278690218925476,
0.37019190192222595,
-0.4557519555091858,
0.5843798518180847,
0.18420134484767914,
-0.652191698551178,
0.72669917345047,
-0.6150568127632141,
-0.009506259113550186,
-0.17905963957309723,
-0.10519123822450638,
-0.21013663709163666,
-0.25029000639915466,
-0.03209904581308365,
0.1658983826637268,
0.2795095145702362,
-0.4286949932575226,
0.05796211212873459,
-0.33625298738479614,
0.2568624019622803,
0.9833999276161194,
-0.24541619420051575,
0.33347588777542114,
-0.39523419737815857,
0.6081915497779846,
-0.17762568593025208,
0.5539683103561401,
0.13141703605651855,
-0.4496101438999176,
-0.6720494031906128,
-0.542333722114563,
0.38977232575416565,
0.6014193892478943,
-0.5253636837005615,
0.3057630658149719,
-0.1749555617570877,
-0.49758321046829224,
-1.13083016872406,
0.3091866374015808,
0.6511491537094116,
0.5516116619110107,
0.5416456460952759,
-0.25886985659599304,
-0.321837842464447,
-0.9519829154014587,
-0.16099658608436584,
-0.3782321512699127,
0.029202964156866074,
0.2326568067073822,
0.28669801354408264,
-0.3791072368621826,
0.7862154245376587,
-0.28883492946624756,
-0.5970414876937866,
0.07858464866876602,
0.01570194400846958,
-0.270120769739151,
0.35130009055137634,
0.25890567898750305,
-0.7234430909156799,
-0.404873251914978,
0.18799938261508942,
-0.8502240777015686,
-0.11033591628074646,
0.12289710342884064,
0.015350185334682465,
0.6002957820892334,
0.6215104460716248,
-0.5167296528816223,
0.2598054111003876,
0.7284060120582581,
-0.20835991203784943,
0.5857431888580322,
-0.43522337079048157,
0.0571553036570549,
-0.8963343501091003,
0.06418667733669281,
0.051847536116838455,
-0.33758288621902466,
-0.35158196091651917,
0.1969248205423355,
0.134591743350029,
0.30874383449554443,
-0.5492939352989197,
0.4150410592556,
-0.3057413697242737,
0.030356623232364655,
-0.14072535932064056,
0.20976266264915466,
-0.12157624959945679,
0.387833833694458,
0.0058684139512479305,
0.7835453748703003,
0.46547797322273254,
-0.3710376024246216,
0.4803478419780731,
0.05425277352333069,
-0.036306168884038925,
0.7490000128746033,
-0.5900338292121887,
0.14480945467948914,
-0.0905178114771843,
0.3889549970626831,
-0.7679948210716248,
-0.25470399856567383,
0.7443088293075562,
-0.47936761379241943,
0.2914513945579529,
-0.06495507061481476,
-0.2020876407623291,
-0.12943539023399353,
-0.32218241691589355,
0.28184425830841064,
0.3543192148208618,
-0.7249537706375122,
0.9665340781211853,
0.37170612812042236,
0.10319670289754868,
-1.0707080364227295,
-0.5389379262924194,
-0.206086665391922,
-0.21744869649410248,
-0.4221755862236023,
0.07854793965816498,
-0.3089774250984192,
-0.19279558956623077,
0.20118454098701477,
-0.1789141744375229,
0.19285786151885986,
-0.21267202496528625,
0.6803238391876221,
0.5545348525047302,
-0.10765986889600754,
0.3193512260913849,
-0.3839626610279083,
-0.37815192341804504,
-0.02446962706744671,
-0.6128280162811279,
0.08245763182640076,
-0.590607225894928,
-0.4695681631565094,
-0.6917230486869812,
0.032685622572898865,
0.7066727876663208,
-0.34963786602020264,
0.7727399468421936,
1.1527276039123535,
-0.23431085050106049,
-0.1352168321609497,
-0.7071778178215027,
-0.36318427324295044,
-0.44345730543136597,
0.28250423073768616,
-0.3567865788936615,
-1.2980962991714478,
0.1017572209239006,
0.15808925032615662,
0.09629615396261215,
0.37719494104385376,
0.8303579092025757,
0.18568052351474762,
1.0706697702407837,
0.8208862543106079,
-0.11540182679891586,
0.18938446044921875,
0.11372814327478409,
0.4317886233329773,
-0.5179013609886169,
-0.6207360625267029,
-0.38351523876190186,
-0.02809753827750683,
-0.60194331407547,
-0.43935999274253845,
0.19914327561855316,
-0.14662444591522217,
-0.2414858192205429,
0.011840496212244034,
-0.8845847845077515,
0.5392090082168579,
0.5521823763847351,
0.14572805166244507,
0.4119763970375061,
-0.09525792300701141,
-0.11315115541219711,
-0.2668978273868561,
-0.5315331816673279,
-0.4476052224636078,
1.0658409595489502,
0.6885963678359985,
0.8747976422309875,
0.13286687433719635,
0.7219194173812866,
0.2502348721027374,
0.6905800104141235,
-0.784752607345581,
0.33153438568115234,
0.1738652139902115,
-0.44497641921043396,
-0.4024691581726074,
-0.3864468038082123,
-0.468546599149704,
0.2820563018321991,
-0.4483279585838318,
-0.7242334485054016,
-0.00422848854213953,
0.5698779225349426,
-0.525328516960144,
0.1712527722120285,
-0.6422072649002075,
0.8413898348808289,
-0.1822749227285385,
-0.6870622038841248,
0.03777448087930679,
-0.7954554557800293,
0.5197448134422302,
-0.20151790976524353,
0.2876055836677551,
0.05010797083377838,
0.0792960450053215,
0.7477113604545593,
-0.41755211353302,
0.839039146900177,
-0.2521464228630066,
-0.22176872193813324,
0.14827655255794525,
0.02643592283129692,
0.5939082503318787,
0.13150157034397125,
0.2777671217918396,
0.16468402743339539,
0.09237466752529144,
-0.15205644071102142,
-0.7420927882194519,
1.0227627754211426,
-0.9933333396911621,
-0.6194607019424438,
-0.6262263655662537,
-0.5018449425697327,
-0.19882823526859283,
0.2263735681772232,
0.25845062732696533,
0.2630005180835724,
-0.11238385736942291,
0.18595297634601593,
1.0344499349594116,
0.07425596565008163,
0.09037161618471146,
0.4238390326499939,
-0.6953969597816467,
-0.6789732575416565,
1.253400206565857,
-0.0861230120062828,
0.2639162838459015,
0.4152875542640686,
0.2897571921348572,
-0.4989408254623413,
-0.3167704939842224,
-0.5733240842819214,
0.436728835105896,
-0.7388991713523865,
-0.2314959019422531,
-0.7761159539222717,
-0.25490882992744446,
-0.3893490433692932,
-0.06410130858421326,
-0.5012837052345276,
-0.38997524976730347,
-0.15783041715621948,
-0.42282634973526,
0.3113548457622528,
1.01959228515625,
-0.3126179277896881,
0.024510575458407402,
-0.7875290513038635,
0.1551390439271927,
0.44998130202293396,
0.39617428183555603,
-0.1610180288553238,
-0.5041400194168091,
-0.2775631844997406,
-0.13783015310764313,
-0.24055510759353638,
-0.6299567222595215,
0.2088562697172165,
0.006280098110437393,
0.5221906900405884,
0.3265340030193329,
-0.0672115758061409,
0.6269543170928955,
-0.2844284474849701,
0.8685436248779297,
0.21090956032276154,
-1.0184228420257568,
0.12209128588438034,
-0.07472748309373856,
0.019251376390457153,
0.5101736187934875,
0.46231815218925476,
-0.15354950726032257,
-0.4553469717502594,
-0.44745323061943054,
-0.6878201961517334,
0.44313910603523254,
0.22215180099010468,
-0.3863687515258789,
0.4669441282749176,
0.30435284972190857,
0.28546470403671265,
0.12757284939289093,
-0.9534698724746704,
-0.22731980681419373,
-0.7286954522132874,
-0.27908962965011597,
-0.1148703470826149,
-0.06370867788791656,
-0.32345831394195557,
-0.23065446317195892,
0.9901332259178162,
-0.14321887493133545,
0.09532029926776886,
0.346744567155838,
-0.03456741198897362,
-0.27042025327682495,
0.17774330079555511,
0.8462601900100708,
0.8016011714935303,
-0.33659273386001587,
0.2895670533180237,
-0.005777547135949135,
-0.5600688457489014,
0.2543882131576538,
0.08699612319469452,
-0.1845068335533142,
-0.18915651738643646,
0.23481708765029907,
0.7551355957984924,
-0.20511233806610107,
-0.4410935938358307,
0.5845900774002075,
-0.2824227809906006,
-0.42077136039733887,
-0.12200745195150375,
0.11617042124271393,
0.07069728523492813,
0.4164600074291229,
0.03041362203657627,
0.16644316911697388,
-0.18475405871868134,
-0.1306876689195633,
0.4684703052043915,
0.43809396028518677,
-0.9751716256141663,
-0.24482670426368713,
0.9642907381057739,
0.08768128603696823,
-0.40569090843200684,
0.5756747722625732,
0.04115891084074974,
-0.42738980054855347,
0.036081671714782715,
0.525237500667572,
0.8314275145530701,
-0.5749309062957764,
0.44549375772476196,
0.2978171408176422,
0.4885798394680023,
-0.30689066648483276,
-0.0623575896024704,
-0.046163346618413925,
-0.5216025114059448,
-0.5314895510673523,
-0.7193233966827393,
-0.549123227596283,
0.28072434663772583,
-0.7321321368217468,
0.011434980668127537,
-0.430853933095932,
-0.22065532207489014,
-0.266556978225708,
-0.27172935009002686,
-0.47601160407066345,
0.22462835907936096,
-0.15590324997901917,
0.4261554181575775,
-0.8019178509712219,
0.9446769952774048,
0.45889249444007874,
-0.4217192232608795,
-1.0072057247161865,
0.1635994017124176,
0.24653027951717377,
-0.7754966616630554,
0.4929656684398651,
0.34532859921455383,
-0.5035569071769714,
0.10379567742347717,
-0.567318320274353,
-0.8432525992393494,
1.0757240056991577,
0.35184016823768616,
-0.7258284091949463,
0.07826948910951614,
-0.25112298130989075,
0.5603294968605042,
-0.32344484329223633,
0.1561131477355957,
0.48132285475730896,
0.7746684551239014,
0.05273563414812088,
-0.9263478517532349,
0.31243717670440674,
-0.22361885011196136,
-0.17711733281612396,
0.2958119213581085,
-0.6059780120849609,
0.42517930269241333,
-0.4102376699447632,
-0.013786804862320423,
-0.05485011637210846,
0.9487030506134033,
0.45953723788261414,
0.16331763565540314,
0.4714968204498291,
0.7457937002182007,
0.9684681296348572,
0.13566653430461884,
0.7913728356361389,
-0.1864522099494934,
0.3710210919380188,
1.0614240169525146,
-0.22243592143058777,
0.8166353702545166,
0.5769960284233093,
0.07552114129066467,
0.593339741230011,
0.2980363070964813,
-0.10254013538360596,
0.5638746619224548,
0.034611400216817856,
-0.12356182187795639,
-0.37857964634895325,
-0.10957666486501694,
-0.5832080841064453,
0.1614995300769806,
0.21554332971572876,
-0.31271442770957947,
0.14833085238933563,
0.04191005975008011,
0.0798642560839653,
-0.006437094882130623,
-0.093269482254982,
0.6684299111366272,
0.044664110988378525,
-0.8006376028060913,
0.6164816617965698,
-0.2638718783855438,
0.4820924997329712,
-0.5424113869667053,
-0.18862208724021912,
0.09349434077739716,
0.4701521098613739,
-0.4541928172111511,
-0.4422145485877991,
0.24161574244499207,
-0.25755149126052856,
-0.2107684314250946,
-0.21083155274391174,
0.6525442004203796,
-0.4840641915798187,
-0.36936184763908386,
0.35346630215644836,
0.45365095138549805,
-0.03154929354786873,
0.19030502438545227,
-0.7265235781669617,
0.43926846981048584,
0.12782955169677734,
-0.17499598860740662,
0.4120805859565735,
0.13059604167938232,
0.022987911477684975,
0.7471737265586853,
0.6965094208717346,
-0.002171455416828394,
-0.05435342341661453,
0.031209183856844902,
0.6873199939727783,
-0.46116381883621216,
-0.3182205557823181,
-0.9219216108322144,
0.3258311450481415,
0.06519746035337448,
-0.21853654086589813,
0.8841800689697266,
0.32861173152923584,
0.9734716415405273,
0.012526385486125946,
0.98763108253479,
0.34674376249313354,
0.4879739582538605,
-0.45860373973846436,
0.7637097835540771,
-0.41589972376823425,
0.18498623371124268,
-0.28664472699165344,
-0.9990999698638916,
-0.5797461271286011,
0.7889432907104492,
-0.051669929176568985,
-0.02683178149163723,
0.8485236763954163,
1.1115877628326416,
0.015536862425506115,
-0.02531592920422554,
0.41835248470306396,
0.3523609936237335,
0.5168933868408203,
0.32425540685653687,
0.8384062647819519,
-0.10972606390714645,
0.8386055827140808,
-0.3245144486427307,
-0.5040255188941956,
-0.22646404802799225,
-0.992041826248169,
-0.9878976941108704,
-0.6855598092079163,
-0.3404162526130676,
-0.7695179581642151,
0.339260995388031,
0.912754476070404,
0.7143509387969971,
-0.7719766497612,
0.04946885630488396,
0.021028144285082817,
-0.00551888020709157,
-0.45676133036613464,
-0.2338842898607254,
0.5494535565376282,
-0.15016821026802063,
-0.4346928298473358,
0.3847375214099884,
0.5245554447174072,
0.04026919975876808,
-0.6603754162788391,
-0.4733363687992096,
0.1676691770553589,
-0.030736854299902916,
0.38105660676956177,
0.2394697517156601,
-1.1085439920425415,
-0.5108771920204163,
0.11484840512275696,
-0.13818597793579102,
0.026508690789341927,
0.7170206308364868,
-0.9665140509605408,
0.5740540623664856,
0.2653706669807434,
0.7539203763008118,
0.33120816946029663,
0.21275490522384644,
0.625481903553009,
-0.325649619102478,
-0.2331983596086502,
0.08357659727334976,
0.08833954483270645,
0.5677152276039124,
-0.5229238867759705,
0.3611358106136322,
0.37346765398979187,
-0.940871000289917,
-0.8529252409934998,
0.25200212001800537,
-0.8407896161079407,
-0.10366654396057129,
1.0463790893554688,
-0.19344085454940796,
-0.3628411591053009,
-0.206998810172081,
-0.4616702198982239,
0.15322370827198029,
-0.5397527813911438,
0.8779571056365967,
0.7119697332382202,
-0.24790063500404358,
-0.18375280499458313,
-0.38074180483818054,
0.6858665347099304,
0.45004385709762573,
-0.5617708563804626,
0.22627295553684235,
0.651896595954895,
0.34427228569984436,
0.32461851835250854,
0.7798510789871216,
-0.07078403979539871,
0.2396162748336792,
-0.22153136134147644,
-0.031129997223615646,
-0.3786830008029938,
-0.6371408700942993,
-0.3905993700027466,
0.47112369537353516,
0.20505115389823914,
-0.0464990958571434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17217v1
|
Collage is the New Writing: Exploring the Fragmentation of Text and User Interfaces in AI Tools
| 2024-05-27T14:35:17 | 2024-05-27T14:35:17 |
Daniel Buschek
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7
|
This essay proposes and explores the concept of Collage for the design of AI
writing tools, transferred from avant-garde literature with four facets: 1)
fragmenting text in writing interfaces, 2) juxtaposing voices (content vs
command), 3) integrating material from multiple sources (e.g. text
suggestions), and 4) shifting from manual writing to editorial and
compositional decision-making, such as selecting and arranging snippets. The
essay then employs Collage as an analytical lens to analyse the user interface
design of recent AI writing tools, and as a constructive lens to inspire new
design directions. Finally, a critical perspective relates the concerns that
writers historically expressed through literary collage to AI writing tools. In
a broad view, this essay explores how literary concepts can help advance design
theory around AI writing tools. It encourages creators of future writing tools
to engage not only with new technological possibilities, but also with past
writing innovations.
|
[
-0.4804461598396301,
-0.9922459125518799,
0.4943092167377472,
-0.14394329488277435,
0.25641122460365295,
0.6878302693367004,
0.05804569274187088,
-0.4529373347759247,
0.3743700683116913,
0.2829623222351074,
-0.6462988257408142,
-0.592179536819458,
-0.4223620295524597,
0.26269835233688354,
-0.5258769392967224,
0.9612032771110535,
-0.3698517382144928,
-0.22072772681713104,
-0.8994421362876892,
-0.07672542333602905,
-0.7873885631561279,
-0.034508585929870605,
-0.3146687150001526,
-0.03933501988649368,
0.6295464634895325,
0.39840659499168396,
0.5868911147117615,
0.2500881552696228,
0.6066590547561646,
0.47896429896354675,
0.374599426984787,
0.18031497299671173,
-0.3908221125602722,
0.1691877543926239,
0.29202932119369507,
-0.6705775260925293,
-0.008048957213759422,
0.5381028652191162,
0.8313459157943726,
0.7418305277824402,
0.2197016179561615,
-0.1095961183309555,
0.26769015192985535,
0.6093196272850037,
-0.6872913241386414,
-0.09597114473581314,
-0.0015567652881145477,
0.4265667498111725,
-0.373330295085907,
0.06468509137630463,
-0.5335131883621216,
-0.40948161482810974,
-0.12972523272037506,
-0.8999758362770081,
0.007255254313349724,
0.5204505920410156,
0.7716764807701111,
-0.04416864365339279,
0.03316916525363922,
-0.15964293479919434,
-0.5340466499328613,
0.5439544916152954,
-0.14400514960289001,
0.14763052761554718,
0.15426257252693176,
0.3476512134075165,
-0.03549455851316452,
-1.0870976448059082,
-0.6486703157424927,
-0.02232786826789379,
-0.36509770154953003,
-0.016969824209809303,
-0.4235894978046417,
-0.0482255220413208,
-0.19710415601730347,
0.5212900042533875,
-0.5571091175079346,
-0.08447366952896118,
-0.5181142687797546,
-0.35958847403526306,
0.6341456174850464,
0.3499954342842102,
0.943053126335144,
0.46134689450263977,
-0.4505713880062103,
0.3956405222415924,
-0.4894373416900635,
-0.06484539061784744,
0.5339265465736389,
-0.14044196903705597,
-0.02824692241847515,
0.3796379268169403,
0.0945037305355072,
0.8626123070716858,
-0.20391534268856049,
-0.09334718436002731,
0.24098847806453705,
-0.26222336292266846,
-0.11376994848251343,
-0.04627757892012596,
1.1198205947875977,
0.6261242628097534,
0.0002461846743244678,
-0.3554786145687103,
0.12875567376613617,
-0.006361063104122877,
0.5556026101112366,
-0.45411843061447144,
-0.5039971470832825,
-0.14350968599319458,
-0.5783976316452026,
-0.6573722958564758,
-0.0212409570813179,
-0.3563808500766754,
-0.6426231861114502,
-0.2625347971916199,
0.3583446443080902,
-0.4782404899597168,
0.1285492330789566,
-0.3280027210712433,
-0.5202406644821167,
-0.23373058438301086,
0.5321369767189026,
-0.7023524045944214,
0.19811619818210602,
0.6597865223884583,
0.9776145815849304,
-0.22531035542488098,
-0.6788586974143982,
-0.3231041729450226,
-0.005701140500605106,
-0.4001119136810303,
1.0976245403289795,
-0.7180914878845215,
-0.4183836281299591,
0.24337948858737946,
-0.3421967327594757,
-0.07537595182657242,
-0.23823213577270508,
0.2678568959236145,
-0.20720016956329346,
0.6487617492675781,
-0.13639229536056519,
-0.6317061185836792,
-0.30417078733444214,
0.016374286264181137,
-1.0529063940048218,
0.6428505182266235,
0.3994353115558624,
-0.8425695300102234,
0.4510177969932556,
-0.8741437792778015,
-0.6673470735549927,
0.49704211950302124,
-0.6323947310447693,
-0.3145292401313782,
0.08423695713281631,
-0.29159146547317505,
0.0748843178153038,
-0.18876542150974274,
-0.07424702495336533,
-0.2595198154449463,
-0.6233370304107666,
0.41928714513778687,
-0.0735372006893158,
0.8238555192947388,
0.45652759075164795,
0.13034085929393768,
0.031129999086260796,
-0.5954728722572327,
-0.0856708437204361,
-0.23431749641895294,
-0.3546068072319031,
-0.23461246490478516,
-0.1108088418841362,
0.24845001101493835,
-0.08918536454439163,
0.3907417356967926,
-0.7348055243492126,
0.3656631112098694,
0.03201504051685333,
0.6837155222892761,
0.3594014644622803,
-0.48173418641090393,
0.9594009518623352,
-0.8808704018592834,
0.7448880672454834,
-0.2623153030872345,
0.04060696065425873,
-0.3816710412502289,
-0.310931533575058,
-0.44772008061408997,
-0.18346244096755981,
0.005827704444527626,
0.39247560501098633,
-0.6051385998725891,
0.327340304851532,
0.3786352872848511,
-0.3225167989730835,
-0.9231786727905273,
0.28412702679634094,
0.041467227041721344,
0.4174036383628845,
-0.010742686688899994,
-0.33249980211257935,
-0.5149221420288086,
-0.8203992247581482,
-0.3473225235939026,
-0.18434660136699677,
0.4273104667663574,
0.024108095094561577,
0.12324342876672745,
-0.056429289281368256,
0.9572696089744568,
-0.7094981074333191,
-0.6904088854789734,
-0.6378903985023499,
0.4057765603065491,
-0.4692198634147644,
0.30456221103668213,
0.6425397992134094,
-0.507113516330719,
-0.5729739665985107,
-0.23440329730510712,
-1.0485831499099731,
-0.1399042010307312,
-0.4250085651874542,
-0.30059629678726196,
0.22062480449676514,
0.7453351020812988,
-0.7793987989425659,
0.7393062114715576,
0.14503717422485352,
-0.3432105779647827,
0.7187108993530273,
0.06650138646364212,
0.22246922552585602,
-0.785699188709259,
-0.03152240440249443,
-0.14201276004314423,
0.4221358597278595,
-0.5735660791397095,
0.29623115062713623,
-0.3327147364616394,
-0.16600337624549866,
-0.18992669880390167,
0.3929363787174225,
-0.6001413464546204,
0.31451109051704407,
-0.5295580625534058,
0.2844996452331543,
0.6536646485328674,
0.03605762869119644,
-0.2825000286102295,
0.6986135840415955,
0.41245871782302856,
0.25949639081954956,
0.2546764016151428,
0.5689644813537598,
-0.6724985837936401,
0.8256219029426575,
-0.18536607921123505,
0.05660512298345566,
-0.24303051829338074,
0.34380292892456055,
-1.1602047681808472,
-0.0690506175160408,
0.25839611887931824,
-0.311199814081192,
0.047646619379520416,
0.6732825040817261,
-0.28798916935920715,
-0.4053443968296051,
-0.5310201048851013,
0.548763632774353,
0.1608949452638626,
0.0806824266910553,
0.7124801874160767,
0.3910098671913147,
-0.3709278404712677,
-0.4060347080230713,
-0.7353837490081787,
0.3176118731498718,
-0.21178549528121948,
-0.8891914486885071,
0.322424978017807,
-0.39352333545684814,
-0.5975587368011475,
0.15108881890773773,
0.5901853442192078,
-0.2688004970550537,
0.09523658454418182,
0.49359965324401855,
0.46926093101501465,
-0.19791582226753235,
0.008557180874049664,
0.22060127556324005,
0.04310886561870575,
-0.03694659844040871,
0.04663349315524101,
0.4779133200645447,
0.08393970876932144,
-0.006467311643064022,
-0.9106615781784058,
0.8367104530334473,
0.6780557632446289,
-0.06986849755048752,
0.5566941499710083,
0.7873945832252502,
0.055455733090639114,
-0.0795845091342926,
-0.6118597984313965,
0.1939084231853485,
-0.4586831033229828,
0.06664986908435822,
-0.20390959084033966,
-0.9242268800735474,
0.28145426511764526,
0.027170123532414436,
0.37739548087120056,
0.22180210053920746,
0.2892993986606598,
-0.6422388553619385,
0.1309034824371338,
1.0210098028182983,
-0.33154386281967163,
0.6182804107666016,
-0.2486761510372162,
0.3592728078365326,
-0.9050164818763733,
-0.3602103590965271,
-0.3061283528804779,
-1.0812046527862549,
-0.16551627218723297,
-0.03773796558380127,
0.1658858358860016,
-0.21154119074344635,
-0.27125704288482666,
0.08149244636297226,
-0.6385647058486938,
0.571879506111145,
0.9877542853355408,
-0.05277780070900917,
0.3958269953727722,
0.010396238416433334,
-0.0847400426864624,
0.06646829843521118,
-0.5414911508560181,
-0.39673489332199097,
0.7955330610275269,
0.14353609085083008,
0.6167212724685669,
-0.39369258284568787,
1.0117300748825073,
0.5595834851264954,
0.2495676428079605,
-0.5930577516555786,
0.402870774269104,
-0.12114562094211578,
-0.5620646476745605,
-0.4083921015262604,
0.386423259973526,
-0.7822279334068298,
0.1425410956144333,
-0.280819296836853,
-0.7586948871612549,
0.35350289940834045,
-0.12590378522872925,
-0.7681555151939392,
0.23935982584953308,
-0.5693545341491699,
0.778878927230835,
0.1811782717704773,
-0.6541743278503418,
0.07545871287584305,
-0.6753794550895691,
0.21554958820343018,
0.28007298707962036,
0.34565165638923645,
0.10265561938285828,
0.13921163976192474,
0.6106087565422058,
-0.4560205042362213,
0.9612526297569275,
0.35119128227233887,
-0.030860133469104767,
1.0195118188858032,
0.43241071701049805,
-0.025227542966604233,
-0.4154976010322571,
-0.05519700422883034,
0.15891587734222412,
0.0483001284301281,
-0.023875921964645386,
-0.46600648760795593,
0.6797411441802979,
-0.9807823896408081,
-0.4432322680950165,
-0.23238587379455566,
-1.0728662014007568,
0.42184674739837646,
0.3625965416431427,
0.4670179784297943,
0.6324993968009949,
-0.26087239384651184,
0.03773123025894165,
-0.08487820625305176,
-0.050176844000816345,
0.7393369674682617,
-0.09240681678056717,
-0.37089839577674866,
-0.477041095495224,
0.8652806282043457,
0.168143630027771,
0.013576065190136433,
0.4368460476398468,
-0.08645018935203552,
-0.055073488503694534,
-0.48019295930862427,
-0.6298303604125977,
0.008417446166276932,
-0.7145627737045288,
-0.022565782070159912,
-0.42225930094718933,
-0.3577178418636322,
-0.450957715511322,
-0.8896387219429016,
0.03194532170891762,
-0.35350120067596436,
-0.6904340386390686,
-0.04826171696186066,
0.03573896363377571,
0.9361802339553833,
0.005719334352761507,
0.3540703356266022,
-0.615023672580719,
-0.1021110787987709,
-0.12228891998529434,
0.047311559319496155,
-0.16199135780334473,
0.10595063865184784,
-0.31733524799346924,
-0.5136982202529907,
-0.8100964426994324,
-0.5790961384773254,
0.23750430345535278,
0.15196052193641663,
0.31021636724472046,
0.47394058108329773,
-0.06259739398956299,
0.22622863948345184,
-0.6929343342781067,
0.8564215898513794,
0.36273515224456787,
-0.403977632522583,
0.3249594569206238,
-0.3418048024177551,
0.47442805767059326,
1.0305120944976807,
0.38469764590263367,
-0.7890332937240601,
-0.6561082005500793,
-0.5509858727455139,
-0.5693028569221497,
0.39056456089019775,
0.06086874380707741,
0.255015105009079,
0.12246868014335632,
0.3059459328651428,
0.5302726030349731,
0.6665645241737366,
-0.7211201786994934,
-0.13207481801509857,
0.05667811259627342,
-0.37156274914741516,
0.10108383744955063,
-0.0870104506611824,
-0.34626975655555725,
-0.31238147616386414,
0.12832683324813843,
0.1845426857471466,
0.2882148325443268,
-0.2852678596973419,
-0.0030315243639051914,
-0.06482910364866257,
-0.1557428240776062,
0.2718384563922882,
0.616159200668335,
0.403035968542099,
0.23455046117305756,
-0.2971227467060089,
-0.5525258779525757,
0.2595020830631256,
-0.0010866725351661444,
-0.5301722288131714,
0.006300159264355898,
0.6988643407821655,
0.6519425511360168,
-0.04421122744679451,
-0.3433941900730133,
0.5264168977737427,
0.15508589148521423,
-0.5719078183174133,
-0.423408567905426,
0.4788424074649811,
0.0359688438475132,
0.38533729314804077,
0.2261626124382019,
0.17163003981113434,
0.49978992342948914,
-0.7632026672363281,
0.24097940325737,
0.4799891412258148,
-0.4766596853733063,
-0.15368704497814178,
0.8228033185005188,
0.5031448006629944,
-0.7781896591186523,
0.8230082392692566,
-0.14124314486980438,
-0.005557498894631863,
0.3215774893760681,
0.45202407240867615,
1.016110897064209,
0.201366126537323,
0.6139694452285767,
-0.1642385721206665,
-0.009262563660740852,
0.3620613217353821,
-0.10998690128326416,
-0.2571782171726227,
-0.544661819934845,
-0.20854242146015167,
-0.7661615610122681,
0.02351892739534378,
-0.1014418751001358,
-0.12087919563055038,
0.4281860888004303,
-0.4606165587902069,
0.025075683370232582,
0.04027887433767319,
-0.08261585980653763,
-0.33911556005477905,
0.02702953666448593,
0.2409425973892212,
0.6489686369895935,
-0.8301420211791992,
0.2817053496837616,
1.0078686475753784,
-0.5713590383529663,
-0.33367639780044556,
-0.03796430677175522,
0.3812960088253021,
-0.6416740417480469,
0.6841309070587158,
0.3393421471118927,
-0.06830085813999176,
-0.019721761345863342,
-0.6117980480194092,
-0.5722333788871765,
1.077228307723999,
-0.010086419060826302,
-0.5446950793266296,
-0.2689368724822998,
0.25578251481056213,
0.268978476524353,
-0.5891393423080444,
0.28496816754341125,
0.6354898810386658,
0.41564083099365234,
0.036345258355140686,
-0.45277079939842224,
-0.14814932644367218,
-0.5843642950057983,
-0.14070363342761993,
0.2528192698955536,
-1.030962347984314,
1.0990545749664307,
-0.13568328320980072,
-0.1985231637954712,
0.49097275733947754,
0.7572964429855347,
-0.1588200181722641,
0.766384482383728,
-0.0760330781340599,
0.6866023540496826,
0.6340993046760559,
-0.13708855211734772,
0.8628799915313721,
-0.12053488940000534,
-0.22701317071914673,
0.8292416930198669,
-0.10578018426895142,
0.34401190280914307,
0.36201590299606323,
-0.24427855014801025,
1.2295106649398804,
0.2786604166030884,
-0.046947281807661057,
0.41673532128334045,
0.2924645245075226,
-0.7364665865898132,
0.065977543592453,
-0.2003115862607956,
-0.16740964353084564,
0.68006432056427,
-0.25048986077308655,
-0.26074671745300293,
-0.21560260653495789,
0.37616196274757385,
0.273320734500885,
0.5132468342781067,
0.3279486894607544,
1.0027282238006592,
-0.04154396057128906,
-0.6118168234825134,
-0.06953628361225128,
-0.2773618698120117,
0.23647120594978333,
-0.11547581106424332,
-0.2880721688270569,
-0.21886996924877167,
-0.12687331438064575,
-0.29538053274154663,
-0.8433838486671448,
0.2147601991891861,
-0.6297650337219238,
-0.09462431073188782,
-0.2868507504463196,
0.8961955308914185,
-0.3800843358039856,
-0.7640004754066467,
-0.4285329282283783,
0.4671916663646698,
0.15001380443572998,
0.03834657371044159,
-0.4869205951690674,
0.8371999859809875,
-0.2041001170873642,
0.055668871849775314,
0.22164082527160645,
0.6969132423400879,
0.11508677154779434,
0.44954603910446167,
0.06901613622903824,
-0.07248886674642563,
-0.371974915266037,
-0.060541316866874695,
0.7574720978736877,
-0.5031304955482483,
-0.6065567135810852,
-0.9299564957618713,
0.8308616876602173,
-0.11134148389101028,
-0.401495099067688,
0.5415700078010559,
0.7614144086837769,
0.6483082175254822,
0.14464466273784637,
1.3437650203704834,
-0.3958572745323181,
0.10417290031909943,
-0.15016643702983856,
1.229742169380188,
-0.42233332991600037,
-0.15333811938762665,
-0.5888388156890869,
-0.7878069877624512,
-0.5440323948860168,
0.7272483110427856,
-0.277565062046051,
0.06807108968496323,
0.9877744913101196,
0.3330945074558258,
0.431359201669693,
0.5719591975212097,
0.24605217576026917,
-0.2182648479938507,
0.1945105493068695,
0.31006160378456116,
1.0493649244308472,
-0.21119819581508636,
0.21412107348442078,
-0.38111692667007446,
-0.28332242369651794,
-0.38360410928726196,
-0.6539866924285889,
-0.9267245531082153,
-0.8904819488525391,
-0.5764734148979187,
0.08532929420471191,
-0.10856538265943527,
0.5500349998474121,
0.09087719023227692,
-0.12167932093143463,
-0.4257722496986389,
-0.12005125731229782,
0.2610347270965576,
-0.035660553723573685,
-0.24623246490955353,
0.12660127878189087,
-0.761869490146637,
-0.6625690460205078,
0.10500987619161606,
0.5290479063987732,
-0.18236400187015533,
-0.4596479535102844,
0.308692067861557,
-0.15905524790287018,
-0.2661210596561432,
0.7860448956489563,
0.028375133872032166,
-0.32870712876319885,
-0.2778656780719757,
-0.29500898718833923,
0.13432577252388,
0.30714988708496094,
0.9682378172874451,
-0.8574548363685608,
0.4420258104801178,
0.5699570775032043,
0.5193994641304016,
-0.12781541049480438,
-0.031150320544838905,
0.5651621222496033,
-0.25425592064857483,
-0.03556229546666145,
0.10787365585565567,
0.23371894657611847,
0.26993006467819214,
-0.5206704139709473,
0.26137351989746094,
0.5305532813072205,
-0.6544641256332397,
-0.5866829752922058,
0.08812737464904785,
-0.6892991065979004,
-0.7401666641235352,
0.6682516932487488,
0.17460480332374573,
-0.309910386800766,
-0.11919084936380386,
-0.7724449038505554,
0.0496821254491806,
-0.234863743185997,
1.0276511907577515,
1.1653714179992676,
-0.6724779605865479,
-0.12744900584220886,
-0.6084468364715576,
0.4055502712726593,
0.03118896298110485,
-0.8387343883514404,
-0.05004454031586647,
1.076489806175232,
0.018305787816643715,
0.308001309633255,
0.8096243143081665,
-0.0742546021938324,
0.4687071144580841,
0.3553685247898102,
0.19664189219474792,
-0.3289298117160797,
-0.7991165518760681,
0.3391386866569519,
0.6694733500480652,
0.15776443481445312,
-0.19830092787742615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17202v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17202v2
|
Efficient multi-prompt evaluation of LLMs
| 2024-05-27T14:24:47 | 2024-06-07T18:24:13 |
Felipe Maia Polo, Ronald Xu, Lucas Weber, Mírian Silva, Onkar Bhardwaj, Leshem Choshen, Allysson Flavio Melo de Oliveira, Yuekai Sun, Mikhail Yurochkin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Most popular benchmarks for comparing LLMs rely on a limited set of prompt
templates, which may not fully capture the LLMs' abilities and can affect the
reproducibility of results on leaderboards. Many recent works empirically
verify prompt sensitivity and advocate for changes in LLM evaluation. In this
paper, we consider the problem of estimating the performance distribution
across many prompt variants instead of finding a single prompt to evaluate
with. We introduce PromptEval, a method for estimating performance across a
large set of prompts borrowing strength across prompts and examples to produce
accurate estimates under practical evaluation budgets. The resulting
distribution can be used to obtain performance quantiles to construct various
robust performance metrics (e.g., top 95% quantile or median). We prove that
PromptEval consistently estimates the performance distribution and demonstrate
its efficacy empirically on three prominent LLM benchmarks: MMLU, BIG-bench
Hard, and LMentry. For example, PromptEval can accurately estimate performance
quantiles across 100 prompt templates on MMLU with a budget equivalent to two
single-prompt evaluations. Our code and data can be found at
https://github.com/felipemaiapolo/prompt-eval.
|
[
-0.24384693801403046,
-0.47601518034935,
0.7046331167221069,
0.7657395601272583,
-0.08390799164772034,
0.11813157051801682,
-0.38776063919067383,
0.11494901776313782,
-0.06705605238676071,
-0.2524023652076721,
-0.7516895532608032,
-0.6089674234390259,
-0.4507855772972107,
0.3852197527885437,
0.18669770658016205,
0.5636845231056213,
0.1777852475643158,
0.3007736802101135,
-0.137763112783432,
-0.4909696578979492,
-0.6851846575737,
-0.3336113393306732,
-0.33465608954429626,
0.10444269329309464,
0.5702998042106628,
0.3976905643939972,
0.4273689389228821,
0.4197637140750885,
0.5484559535980225,
0.3339025676250458,
-0.21487386524677277,
0.2937159240245819,
-0.27248063683509827,
0.5055555701255798,
0.025768134742975235,
-0.3973977863788605,
-0.6012584567070007,
0.16944508254528046,
0.9205884337425232,
0.3272865414619446,
-0.3658307194709778,
0.2833250164985657,
0.43644899129867554,
0.3482324481010437,
-0.8539024591445923,
-0.00878853164613247,
-0.3896128237247467,
0.02642197348177433,
-0.27766096591949463,
-0.35485342144966125,
-0.5871815085411072,
-0.8343901038169861,
-0.050506170839071274,
-0.5407513976097107,
0.03332215175032616,
0.16123339533805847,
0.06447470188140869,
0.2663761079311371,
-0.1832941472530365,
-0.4678056836128235,
-0.14413097500801086,
1.0008585453033447,
-0.4316115975379944,
0.3333389461040497,
0.11917313933372498,
0.8291186094284058,
-0.02372586913406849,
-0.7469756007194519,
0.008814063854515553,
-0.484941691160202,
0.26417702436447144,
0.29898500442504883,
-0.1656036376953125,
-0.04523108899593353,
0.516171932220459,
0.252787321805954,
-0.5270898938179016,
0.27816492319107056,
0.27482542395591736,
-0.2206425964832306,
0.37942206859588623,
0.6248378157615662,
-0.13165684044361115,
-0.37832826375961304,
-0.802510142326355,
-0.270484060049057,
-0.6150578856468201,
0.43181148171424866,
0.17793765664100647,
0.44487765431404114,
-0.09599468857049942,
0.5408630967140198,
0.05605106055736542,
0.28418469429016113,
0.07171496003866196,
-0.47819235920906067,
0.3952055871486664,
-0.7241460680961609,
0.03165742754936218,
-0.1930713951587677,
0.7193791270256042,
0.6259268522262573,
-0.0745101124048233,
0.05224059149622917,
-0.5511178970336914,
-0.12444629520177841,
-0.018269319087266922,
-0.9137970209121704,
-0.1314401924610138,
0.04539869353175163,
-0.46545010805130005,
-0.0660359114408493,
-0.1727927178144455,
-0.950797975063324,
-0.9777006506919861,
-0.11349410563707352,
0.3577392101287842,
-0.431059867143631,
0.17887426912784576,
-0.40040281414985657,
-0.3349354565143585,
0.08279651403427124,
0.41593509912490845,
-0.5358269214630127,
0.08886373043060303,
0.684005618095398,
1.1260347366333008,
-0.41992634534835815,
-0.5115818977355957,
-1.247594952583313,
-0.4395632743835449,
-0.28795450925827026,
0.9457964301109314,
-0.46308889985084534,
-0.4088130295276642,
0.1030864268541336,
-0.15950915217399597,
-0.30320870876312256,
-0.5485381484031677,
0.9467379450798035,
-0.3737269937992096,
-0.1482771933078766,
-0.5601176619529724,
-0.695504367351532,
0.6157574653625488,
0.3178756833076477,
-0.8590978980064392,
0.9750738739967346,
0.1347273737192154,
-0.6489850878715515,
0.6330503821372986,
-0.4607207775115967,
-0.014144488610327244,
0.03711271286010742,
-0.005597024690359831,
-0.3482632040977478,
0.1983558088541031,
0.5463721752166748,
0.34543371200561523,
-0.43279993534088135,
0.19089244306087494,
-0.4206080436706543,
-0.4625210165977478,
0.37714964151382446,
-0.9995784759521484,
0.7539768218994141,
0.26449593901634216,
-0.12645205855369568,
0.4989093542098999,
-0.7600933909416199,
0.08302934467792511,
-0.4452841877937317,
-0.39871400594711304,
-0.06726764887571335,
-0.282693088054657,
-0.20397230982780457,
-0.30958282947540283,
0.2794972062110901,
-0.19433759152889252,
0.1951199769973755,
-0.002258960623294115,
0.058317527174949646,
1.15105140209198,
0.05339227244257927,
0.4496176540851593,
-0.4653153121471405,
0.9847896695137024,
-0.2658504843711853,
0.43474388122558594,
-0.5708386301994324,
-0.33936214447021484,
0.032713234424591064,
-0.8908916711807251,
0.2249508798122406,
0.4934168756008148,
-0.6145517230033875,
0.3696761429309845,
0.09285470098257065,
-0.5807598233222961,
-0.655112087726593,
0.0754738375544548,
0.39231640100479126,
0.7081822156906128,
0.40801820158958435,
0.26359543204307556,
-0.13679760694503784,
-0.6916705369949341,
-0.5552042126655579,
-0.28384315967559814,
-0.22881267964839935,
0.29914912581443787,
-0.029191013425588608,
0.3748983144760132,
0.7039220929145813,
-0.4274563789367676,
0.15008482336997986,
-0.11009708791971207,
0.23550160229206085,
0.5740999579429626,
0.28267747163772583,
0.665440022945404,
-0.21893437206745148,
-0.4993353486061096,
-0.5562625527381897,
-0.53432297706604,
-0.4801047742366791,
-0.17651772499084473,
-0.08271950483322144,
-0.005713324528187513,
0.18550539016723633,
-0.48900023102760315,
0.16115690767765045,
0.33408495783805847,
-0.4430871307849884,
0.9561855792999268,
-0.16662149131298065,
0.45470353960990906,
-0.8601115942001343,
0.10651049762964249,
0.1551457643508911,
-0.15705914795398712,
-0.2225060909986496,
0.058839187026023865,
0.4773573577404022,
0.20030800998210907,
-0.474290668964386,
0.5785735249519348,
-0.5051186084747314,
-0.27822428941726685,
0.09803696721792221,
0.25655636191368103,
0.07575434446334839,
0.14956341683864594,
-0.45993053913116455,
1.5283747911453247,
0.7071151733398438,
-0.35065439343452454,
0.5581346750259399,
0.17491520941257477,
-0.7030353546142578,
1.1983941793441772,
-0.7444295883178711,
-0.2783205807209015,
0.11913347989320755,
0.14703640341758728,
-1.2968392372131348,
0.1698393076658249,
0.19782708585262299,
-0.1254422813653946,
0.029948413372039795,
-0.07422354817390442,
-0.3938227593898773,
-0.27107176184654236,
-1.0175660848617554,
0.322196364402771,
0.6144837737083435,
-0.9051501750946045,
0.36661750078201294,
-0.05411028116941452,
-0.1931573748588562,
-0.6956614255905151,
-0.1764906793832779,
-0.09821680933237076,
-0.6776976585388184,
-0.5817304849624634,
-0.09461851418018341,
-0.48968493938446045,
-0.21250581741333008,
-0.35786160826683044,
-0.13619495928287506,
0.13215266168117523,
0.45018860697746277,
0.25492897629737854,
0.2801153063774109,
-0.35469797253608704,
0.2852860689163208,
-0.12192538380622864,
-0.2427549958229065,
0.06815075874328613,
0.003864977741613984,
0.304782897233963,
-0.21566136181354523,
-0.5654696822166443,
-0.31337931752204895,
-0.024313488975167274,
0.39536064863204956,
-0.024493588134646416,
0.42108485102653503,
0.4708099961280823,
0.02709248475730419,
-0.4162554442882538,
-0.6382583975791931,
-0.09035293012857437,
-0.5218855738639832,
0.14584533870220184,
-0.6976543068885803,
-0.2506996989250183,
0.6776655316352844,
-0.38479354977607727,
0.2225920706987381,
0.4100857973098755,
0.4580189883708954,
-0.018524715676903725,
0.8526650667190552,
0.27593982219696045,
0.23460616171360016,
0.44464555382728577,
-0.007260190322995186,
-0.5543883442878723,
-0.9820012450218201,
-0.32243621349334717,
-0.690899670124054,
-0.29580825567245483,
-0.3887403905391693,
-0.4387536942958832,
0.7505707144737244,
0.2794475257396698,
-0.18392899632453918,
0.1893632411956787,
-0.1948913186788559,
0.3544034957885742,
0.6927836537361145,
-0.00892943050712347,
0.3466334044933319,
-0.0970386192202568,
-0.4852209687232971,
-0.20208221673965454,
-0.6271917223930359,
-0.7205501198768616,
1.088394045829773,
0.2670619785785675,
0.8603987693786621,
0.1513921469449997,
0.5642762780189514,
0.4582394063472748,
0.5267564654350281,
-0.5727800726890564,
0.3746386468410492,
0.12992185354232788,
-0.0320729985833168,
-0.3623536229133606,
-0.5373539924621582,
-0.8962366580963135,
0.4028000831604004,
-0.1177295446395874,
-0.560926079750061,
0.2021363526582718,
-0.028280435130000114,
-0.6423325538635254,
-0.026173055171966553,
-0.7215842008590698,
0.8272755146026611,
-0.1738826036453247,
-0.41182711720466614,
0.0319189615547657,
-0.45915937423706055,
0.269837349653244,
-0.2420612871646881,
-0.08949082344770432,
-0.32840296626091003,
-0.5083180069923401,
0.7184599041938782,
-0.5724804997444153,
0.5250818133354187,
-0.38750159740448,
0.06456796079874039,
0.23413720726966858,
-0.22346597909927368,
0.5398299098014832,
0.49003565311431885,
-0.7263868451118469,
-0.17518161237239838,
0.013087010011076927,
-0.3933025896549225,
-0.7642371654510498,
0.694901168346405,
-0.8034524321556091,
-0.5353888869285583,
-0.27771472930908203,
-0.41575172543525696,
-0.3789166808128357,
-0.10033271461725235,
0.2829100489616394,
0.7327025532722473,
-0.3490382134914398,
0.03764355555176735,
0.20942600071430206,
-0.19208163022994995,
0.9191352725028992,
0.3859091103076935,
0.24361422657966614,
-0.8544586300849915,
0.508881151676178,
0.19784881174564362,
0.038401778787374496,
0.21166056394577026,
0.48890236020088196,
-0.9598427414894104,
-0.4735616147518158,
-0.748441219329834,
-0.1469743847846985,
-0.7478878498077393,
-0.44169479608535767,
-0.39039015769958496,
0.3181735873222351,
-0.14292548596858978,
-0.2521210312843323,
-0.1677951067686081,
-0.3840317130088806,
-0.34096837043762207,
-0.21583670377731323,
0.441301554441452,
0.5990240573883057,
-0.23673777282238007,
0.39075222611427307,
-0.5565528273582458,
0.12011658400297165,
0.30051425099372864,
0.3207574486732483,
0.07678840309381485,
-0.6547757983207703,
0.08711892366409302,
-0.27547526359558105,
-0.4545920193195343,
-1.0680166482925415,
0.1311921775341034,
0.07310107350349426,
0.9717344641685486,
0.361890584230423,
0.4303627014160156,
0.8920400738716125,
-0.47863656282424927,
0.8058410882949829,
0.47152310609817505,
-0.9006350636482239,
0.48273447155952454,
-0.01596353016793728,
0.3415602445602417,
0.864405632019043,
0.33062729239463806,
-0.17974157631397247,
-0.2119063138961792,
-0.4480987787246704,
-0.7052748203277588,
0.5198999047279358,
-0.008742256090044975,
-0.18897613883018494,
-0.23683573305606842,
0.04909992963075638,
0.33987900614738464,
0.3158892095088959,
-0.15743862092494965,
-0.27069422602653503,
-0.1221378892660141,
-0.21256327629089355,
-0.10210224986076355,
-0.3975636661052704,
-0.16002583503723145,
0.11680618673563004,
0.1563720554113388,
-0.32216283679008484,
-0.005161107052117586,
0.052321288734674454,
-0.16685239970684052,
0.21405744552612305,
0.29265767335891724,
0.44675174355506897,
1.03197181224823,
-0.28190767765045166,
0.45616650581359863,
0.4472977817058563,
-0.2756468653678894,
0.4056057333946228,
0.23130153119564056,
-0.0030609595123678446,
0.05503778159618378,
0.7340917587280273,
0.5763483643531799,
0.34210893511772156,
-0.605361819267273,
0.9098226428031921,
-0.1941041648387909,
0.26645132899284363,
0.004362030420452356,
-0.07042799144983292,
-0.038220446556806564,
0.7283064723014832,
0.638392984867096,
0.06580890715122223,
0.20284532010555267,
-0.2567269504070282,
0.5092180967330933,
0.43314027786254883,
-0.1891552060842514,
-0.30446353554725647,
0.5329180955886841,
0.3051116466522217,
-0.3778705596923828,
0.6083152294158936,
-0.2925959527492523,
-0.14470668137073517,
0.7873508334159851,
0.3968352675437927,
1.0478804111480713,
-0.4283771216869354,
0.27404916286468506,
0.43815913796424866,
0.16255319118499756,
-0.052074190229177475,
0.4020649194717407,
-0.04840388894081116,
-0.1327185332775116,
-0.4240036904811859,
-0.32925018668174744,
-0.5456733703613281,
-0.3873739540576935,
-0.6456961035728455,
0.328276127576828,
-0.4291411340236664,
-0.5275349617004395,
-0.19973249733448029,
0.15957438945770264,
-0.8667580485343933,
-0.402614951133728,
-0.2352820336818695,
1.2775893211364746,
-0.7458433508872986,
0.18111129105091095,
0.4402073621749878,
-0.24951669573783875,
-0.6942430138587952,
-0.12280857563018799,
0.03177417814731598,
-1.0049117803573608,
0.4275054931640625,
0.24434496462345123,
0.15045996010303497,
-0.21565614640712738,
-0.07112666219472885,
-0.4419346749782562,
1.3971312046051025,
0.4873599410057068,
-0.7192267179489136,
0.462807297706604,
-0.29451143741607666,
0.26509007811546326,
-0.37613385915756226,
1.1228398084640503,
0.47063079476356506,
0.613247275352478,
0.15239441394805908,
-0.7493742108345032,
0.2539176940917969,
0.05579319968819618,
-0.0943031758069992,
-0.07428944110870361,
-0.6901768445968628,
0.8387205600738525,
-0.5050414800643921,
-0.5166074633598328,
0.5230616331100464,
0.5003495216369629,
1.0972763299942017,
0.7203211188316345,
0.47811371088027954,
0.09759839624166489,
1.4071439504623413,
-0.07737372815608978,
1.0510590076446533,
-0.5206490159034729,
0.31558725237846375,
0.9842092394828796,
-0.3476063311100006,
0.6889621019363403,
0.3049428462982178,
-0.38019779324531555,
0.026856105774641037,
0.7003423571586609,
-0.14755599200725555,
0.6269581317901611,
0.35382887721061707,
-0.4109722375869751,
-0.177700012922287,
-0.30792203545570374,
-0.4690408706665039,
-0.2095748782157898,
-0.14070652425289154,
-0.06032264232635498,
-0.4959838092327118,
-0.058708805590867996,
-0.20836865901947021,
0.008518695831298828,
-0.25867289304733276,
0.5645335912704468,
0.0380377359688282,
-0.5950685143470764,
0.5181832909584045,
-0.10277032852172852,
0.7172833681106567,
-0.367423951625824,
-0.009647917933762074,
-0.6513471007347107,
-0.029702164232730865,
0.1366683393716812,
-0.9250114560127258,
-0.18306760489940643,
0.19727863371372223,
0.008567939512431622,
-0.2669869363307953,
0.4941241145133972,
-0.005322256125509739,
-0.45506659150123596,
0.031566403806209564,
0.9323127865791321,
0.16091473400592804,
0.01513742096722126,
-0.5196396112442017,
0.12563422322273254,
-0.3746974766254425,
-0.4382081925868988,
0.21884652972221375,
0.7006558775901794,
-0.07631967961788177,
0.6833720803260803,
0.48560091853141785,
0.030964002013206482,
0.24611803889274597,
0.24671882390975952,
0.8042349219322205,
-0.6282036900520325,
-0.44501644372940063,
-1.1369717121124268,
0.48422983288764954,
-0.191232830286026,
-0.844592809677124,
1.016403079032898,
0.5664950013160706,
-0.028384223580360413,
0.102079838514328,
0.3892967104911804,
0.531995952129364,
0.3386566936969757,
-0.540340781211853,
0.23582318425178528,
-0.17862311005592346,
0.6108473539352417,
-0.2495797872543335,
-1.1707514524459839,
-0.08474529534578323,
0.327701210975647,
-0.010068177245557308,
-0.03452315181493759,
0.7009981274604797,
0.6902727484703064,
0.21745723485946655,
0.08746716380119324,
0.3769907057285309,
0.004459529183804989,
0.3658257722854614,
0.5649303793907166,
1.4775863885879517,
-0.06701216846704483,
0.4787006080150604,
-0.03817109018564224,
-0.5235849618911743,
-0.11365647614002228,
-1.2038207054138184,
-0.688726544380188,
-0.15178823471069336,
-0.3233763873577118,
-0.2410975843667984,
0.23724855482578278,
0.9795138835906982,
0.6256327629089355,
-0.5318750739097595,
-0.17931751906871796,
0.29016074538230896,
0.5275961756706238,
-0.4479241669178009,
-0.203870952129364,
0.7484570145606995,
-0.6621001362800598,
-0.6705260276794434,
0.8133135437965393,
0.03438825160264969,
-0.13162580132484436,
-0.21101312339305878,
-0.2354600578546524,
0.3346002399921417,
0.07889065891504288,
0.5843552350997925,
-0.18869486451148987,
-0.57623690366745,
-0.2709576189517975,
0.33482685685157776,
-0.3258266746997833,
-0.039459310472011566,
0.6417673826217651,
-0.9790674448013306,
0.18505962193012238,
0.6725148558616638,
0.6526129245758057,
0.053836457431316376,
0.4726257622241974,
0.23142805695533752,
-1.0426628589630127,
-0.3109528124332428,
0.14838096499443054,
0.3969321846961975,
0.19786985218524933,
-0.04337950050830841,
0.7096036672592163,
0.18620020151138306,
-0.6102845668792725,
-1.0082578659057617,
-0.13655585050582886,
-0.9857345819473267,
-0.07319248467683792,
1.1508233547210693,
-0.31039583683013916,
0.06643512099981308,
0.2402765452861786,
-0.055340878665447235,
-0.16936984658241272,
-0.740717887878418,
0.38008490204811096,
0.6047410368919373,
-0.20504146814346313,
-0.3495163023471832,
-0.43056896328926086,
0.38814476132392883,
0.2771846652030945,
-0.5943995118141174,
0.12944148480892181,
0.6713712215423584,
0.22417864203453064,
-0.043552957475185394,
0.7012178897857666,
0.15535101294517517,
0.34673556685447693,
0.08388128876686096,
-0.356357216835022,
-0.061374448239803314,
-0.4022948741912842,
-0.7001573443412781,
0.6485305428504944,
0.3072528541088104,
-0.4276515543460846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00037v1
|
Aligning LLMs through Multi-perspective User Preference Ranking-based Feedback for Programming Question Answering
| 2024-05-27T14:21:31 | 2024-05-27T14:21:31 |
Hongyu Yang, Liyang He, Min Hou, Shuanghong Shen, Rui Li, Jiahui Hou, Jianhui Ma, Junda Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Code Community Question Answering (CCQA) seeks to tackle programming-related
issues, thereby boosting productivity in both software engineering and academic
research. Recent advancements in Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
(RLHF) have transformed the fine-tuning process of Large Language Models (LLMs)
to produce responses that closely mimic human behavior. Leveraging LLMs with
RLHF for practical CCQA applications has thus emerged as a promising area of
study. Unlike standard code question-answering tasks, CCQA involves multiple
possible answers, with varying user preferences for each response.
Additionally, code communities often show a preference for new APIs. These
challenges prevent LLMs from generating responses that cater to the diverse
preferences of users in CCQA tasks. To address these issues, we propose a novel
framework called Aligning LLMs through Multi-perspective User Preference
Ranking-based Feedback for Programming Question Answering (ALMupQA) to create
user-focused responses. Our approach starts with Multi-perspective Preference
Ranking Alignment (MPRA), which synthesizes varied user preferences based on
the characteristics of answers from code communities. We then introduce a
Retrieval-augmented In-context Learning (RIL) module to mitigate the problem of
outdated answers by retrieving responses to similar questions from a question
bank. Due to the limited availability of high-quality, multi-answer CCQA
datasets, we also developed a dataset named StaCCQA from real code communities.
Extensive experiments demonstrated the effectiveness of the ALMupQA framework
in terms of accuracy and user preference. Compared to the base model, ALMupQA
showed nearly an 11% improvement in BLEU, with increases of 20% and 17.5% in
BERTScore and CodeBERTScore, respectively.
|
[
-0.5180736184120178,
-0.4621672034263611,
0.45830589532852173,
0.1908741146326065,
0.06012518331408501,
0.49886128306388855,
-0.34797126054763794,
-0.19191530346870422,
0.20085468888282776,
0.46818792819976807,
-0.5390340685844421,
-0.4613322615623474,
-0.28847870230674744,
-0.07218728959560394,
0.0903969332575798,
1.0266356468200684,
-0.04950455203652382,
0.14441242814064026,
-0.42525365948677063,
-0.39877286553382874,
-0.5985197424888611,
-0.7041234970092773,
-0.4062899351119995,
-0.295746386051178,
0.7095360159873962,
0.768174409866333,
0.6330235600471497,
0.3900739550590515,
0.4472840428352356,
0.1834789216518402,
0.3265361189842224,
0.23430576920509338,
-0.27244389057159424,
0.05518883466720581,
-0.05711954087018967,
-0.36469200253486633,
-0.29568397998809814,
-0.038960766047239304,
0.2588484287261963,
0.5621907711029053,
-0.36666303873062134,
0.38159772753715515,
0.4802866578102112,
0.844818115234375,
-0.649813175201416,
-0.14796683192253113,
-0.5163726806640625,
-0.20480132102966309,
0.18678557872772217,
-0.5692893266677856,
-0.3311607539653778,
-0.6464049220085144,
-0.007314945105463266,
-0.3404747247695923,
-0.13171032071113586,
0.01186439860612154,
0.46598222851753235,
0.4199030101299286,
-0.460785448551178,
-0.29968947172164917,
-0.3936202824115753,
0.9297981262207031,
-0.8452101349830627,
0.29506880044937134,
0.007913473062217236,
0.21274594962596893,
-0.14890436828136444,
-0.12683439254760742,
-0.45848822593688965,
-0.05232718586921692,
0.022047143429517746,
0.24917666614055634,
0.25628378987312317,
0.03985114395618439,
0.09617426991462708,
0.1684429943561554,
-0.7409406900405884,
0.11725477129220963,
-0.1921740472316742,
-0.23823194205760956,
0.5052264332771301,
0.15146544575691223,
0.05085788667201996,
-0.20490020513534546,
-0.5651013255119324,
-0.01992034539580345,
-0.5666004419326782,
0.6026154160499573,
0.35440975427627563,
0.29913070797920227,
0.024949748069047928,
0.4839957058429718,
-0.21619923412799835,
0.736824631690979,
0.09380728751420975,
-0.21935920417308807,
0.3155515789985657,
-0.156832754611969,
-0.2544163167476654,
-0.19538003206253052,
0.49636533856391907,
0.5192587971687317,
0.016907086595892906,
0.0023364832159131765,
-0.08067136257886887,
0.0012647513067349792,
0.37498003244400024,
-0.5331941843032837,
-0.34617987275123596,
0.46424978971481323,
-0.4736301898956299,
-0.30759575963020325,
0.17203842103481293,
-0.7051315903663635,
-0.6440449357032776,
-0.48833519220352173,
0.26666775345802307,
0.03637028858065605,
-0.2581590414047241,
-0.03327006846666336,
0.200474813580513,
0.44879746437072754,
0.4889896512031555,
-0.7217940092086792,
0.05410920828580856,
0.7185536623001099,
0.4777977466583252,
-0.46595749258995056,
-0.3218352794647217,
-0.6504316926002502,
-0.013672576285898685,
-0.06075574457645416,
0.7246962189674377,
-0.575605034828186,
-0.23162300884723663,
-0.12309160828590393,
-0.24575327336788177,
0.01177829410880804,
-0.6348429918289185,
0.2518768012523651,
-0.6350958943367004,
0.15936799347400665,
-0.3644101619720459,
-0.37657636404037476,
0.09851481020450592,
0.5897716283798218,
-0.2481415718793869,
1.1983872652053833,
0.0927068293094635,
-0.8367447853088379,
0.13537359237670898,
-0.5978021025657654,
0.03163434937596321,
-0.10476482659578323,
-0.5645139813423157,
-0.2799093723297119,
-0.10643848031759262,
0.4511660635471344,
0.11938709765672684,
-0.01862344890832901,
0.30124422907829285,
-0.3728930652141571,
-0.3567509651184082,
0.6105757355690002,
-0.3057640790939331,
0.6254823803901672,
0.3415679633617401,
-0.2561269998550415,
0.4198189377784729,
-0.340482234954834,
0.4965946674346924,
-0.39271417260169983,
-0.8212797045707703,
-0.15061132609844208,
-0.02742561511695385,
-0.10607758909463882,
0.5712958574295044,
0.4029311239719391,
-0.5324990749359131,
0.39615923166275024,
-0.3002628982067108,
0.4151841402053833,
0.8874815106391907,
0.029283685609698296,
0.497132807970047,
-0.44314026832580566,
0.7306374907493591,
0.1917441487312317,
0.26184582710266113,
0.21264000236988068,
-0.28567713499069214,
-0.6286129355430603,
-0.11499131470918655,
0.10021756589412689,
0.5694735050201416,
-0.839698076248169,
0.22218665480613708,
-0.06760089844465256,
-0.2567843496799469,
-0.6401834487915039,
0.40539345145225525,
0.4460516571998596,
0.6157785058021545,
0.4309238791465759,
-0.5823150873184204,
-0.48938167095184326,
-0.965119481086731,
-0.253933310508728,
-0.3491274416446686,
0.006705672480165958,
0.7564760446548462,
0.022185316309332848,
-0.0025002413894981146,
1.1102248430252075,
-0.73628830909729,
0.0630166307091713,
-0.271331250667572,
-0.012267316691577435,
0.3143632709980011,
0.4736833870410919,
0.23161929845809937,
-0.8097850680351257,
-0.412912517786026,
-0.12875422835350037,
-0.2867315113544464,
-0.2161182016134262,
0.05975428223609924,
-0.3668304979801178,
0.17890207469463348,
0.3187218904495239,
-0.17145155370235443,
0.21767167747020721,
0.7561312317848206,
-0.05129331722855568,
0.6008114814758301,
0.031159061938524246,
0.37830328941345215,
-1.175772786140442,
0.07307485491037369,
-0.18419931828975677,
-0.24929289519786835,
-0.19111941754817963,
0.3154093623161316,
0.2656668722629547,
-0.016021648421883583,
-0.5783485770225525,
0.39859020709991455,
-0.24650055170059204,
-0.27220281958580017,
-0.44146013259887695,
0.28147104382514954,
0.02209584228694439,
1.0293409824371338,
0.05883774906396866,
1.0590871572494507,
0.2490493357181549,
-0.47030824422836304,
0.22510620951652527,
0.15923742949962616,
-0.21869845688343048,
0.3810572028160095,
-0.45811358094215393,
0.43407201766967773,
-0.03237069770693779,
0.28135958313941956,
-1.168990969657898,
0.04754115268588066,
0.22041817009449005,
-0.7162675857543945,
-0.12573124468326569,
-0.17054913938045502,
-0.1951349675655365,
-0.40991881489753723,
-0.5388917922973633,
0.5283612608909607,
0.09499778598546982,
-0.587760329246521,
0.49239382147789,
0.34522756934165955,
-0.2306649386882782,
-1.120055079460144,
-0.5099558234214783,
-0.1718369722366333,
-0.1221233382821083,
-0.3263646066188812,
0.0337129607796669,
-0.5733240246772766,
-0.03597639873623848,
-0.24273522198200226,
-0.31974634528160095,
-0.046027712523937225,
0.26208779215812683,
0.29002270102500916,
0.5958866477012634,
-0.12251187115907669,
0.10569832473993301,
-0.043919991701841354,
0.019064877182245255,
0.060418501496315,
-0.48110219836235046,
0.4976740777492523,
-0.33657991886138916,
-0.3686220943927765,
0.04830639809370041,
0.3878316581249237,
0.39319267868995667,
-0.49214738607406616,
0.5029656291007996,
0.36334213614463806,
-0.010622160509228706,
0.006151868030428886,
-0.5822229385375977,
-0.06961352378129959,
-0.45305904746055603,
0.3214971423149109,
-0.19830100238323212,
-1.2969473600387573,
0.4087119400501251,
0.029160792008042336,
0.30324870347976685,
-0.14592891931533813,
0.912420928478241,
-0.19758953154087067,
1.047285795211792,
0.5582170486450195,
-0.399875283241272,
0.3933681547641754,
0.021876420825719833,
0.3331281840801239,
-1.000393033027649,
-0.2121403068304062,
-0.6763995885848999,
-0.451519638299942,
-0.4208763837814331,
-0.2883293926715851,
0.4108063280582428,
0.14876417815685272,
-0.29410168528556824,
0.32079777121543884,
-0.7840374112129211,
0.5195751190185547,
0.6095911860466003,
0.29343166947364807,
0.35935544967651367,
-0.20873670279979706,
-0.29079383611679077,
0.034943025559186935,
-0.513809859752655,
-0.45392996072769165,
1.2093886137008667,
0.19306178390979767,
0.8690993785858154,
0.4827432930469513,
0.8981199860572815,
0.3386458456516266,
0.5753750801086426,
-0.7332638502120972,
0.30876320600509644,
0.29597607254981995,
-0.43298080563545227,
-0.3025476634502411,
-0.522411584854126,
-0.588214099407196,
0.37542006373405457,
-0.1680680811405182,
-0.7363941669464111,
0.22958938777446747,
0.31960389018058777,
-0.6275779604911804,
-0.05668843910098076,
-0.6149192452430725,
0.7439921498298645,
-0.41305768489837646,
-0.5067542791366577,
-0.15609827637672424,
-0.757781445980072,
0.3071674108505249,
0.2272595465183258,
0.21457789838314056,
-0.033091962337493896,
-0.022430533543229103,
0.45105424523353577,
-0.1840856671333313,
0.5622022747993469,
-0.28207701444625854,
-0.23315325379371643,
0.14019504189491272,
-0.04868755489587784,
0.16442103683948517,
0.4801703095436096,
-0.0815984308719635,
-0.23513448238372803,
0.3002224564552307,
-0.5508121848106384,
-0.676774799823761,
0.9940093755722046,
-1.0445377826690674,
-0.8304741978645325,
-0.4117179811000824,
-0.6479454040527344,
-0.5692607164382935,
-0.030858993530273438,
-0.04644083231687546,
0.43319255113601685,
0.1638711392879486,
0.07463643699884415,
0.7329563498497009,
-0.3059840202331543,
0.2887183725833893,
0.49073776602745056,
-0.49147284030914307,
-0.5977556109428406,
0.6211222410202026,
-0.3845391571521759,
0.27107736468315125,
0.4558803141117096,
-0.0633409172296524,
-0.3995857834815979,
-0.4009319543838501,
-0.5884429216384888,
0.03220967575907707,
-0.6361956596374512,
-0.48056307435035706,
-0.5390282273292542,
-0.21050705015659332,
-0.5003557801246643,
-0.20918217301368713,
-0.0795842707157135,
-0.3210986852645874,
-0.036797378212213516,
0.004022290930151939,
-0.09010060876607895,
0.28003010153770447,
0.24087639153003693,
-0.02806093543767929,
-0.6966472864151001,
0.24209269881248474,
0.3652874231338501,
0.41162705421447754,
0.25708892941474915,
-0.32129722833633423,
-0.40543824434280396,
0.07539887726306915,
-0.6997330188751221,
-0.819023072719574,
0.15625286102294922,
-0.14581961929798126,
0.5523633360862732,
-0.016090763732790947,
0.19148322939872742,
0.7722331285476685,
-0.14018315076828003,
0.6862668395042419,
0.11634773015975952,
-0.8374961614608765,
0.5374159812927246,
-0.17805559933185577,
0.44223135709762573,
1.0247811079025269,
0.17802727222442627,
-0.7802420258522034,
-0.48085281252861023,
-0.15675398707389832,
-0.7465760707855225,
0.5778551697731018,
-0.05728026479482651,
-0.012498018331825733,
0.06863223016262054,
0.5253381729125977,
0.06634838134050369,
0.39235320687294006,
-0.9347992539405823,
-0.35007336735725403,
-0.19770307838916779,
-0.3247179388999939,
0.09184295684099197,
0.040756549686193466,
-0.24476024508476257,
-0.23795416951179504,
0.6559686660766602,
-0.6093294024467468,
0.20192688703536987,
0.21317040920257568,
-0.20105403661727905,
-0.06121699512004852,
0.6285690665245056,
0.43656855821609497,
0.9993675351142883,
-0.15813812613487244,
0.11866934597492218,
-0.010522070340812206,
-0.18919311463832855,
0.1405995637178421,
-0.0961044579744339,
0.033009447157382965,
-0.6423454284667969,
-0.08308634907007217,
0.16713929176330566,
0.018621979281306267,
-0.8271618485450745,
0.676497220993042,
-0.2323085218667984,
-0.14492733776569366,
-0.24403013288974762,
0.2484966516494751,
0.26746073365211487,
0.2531171441078186,
0.519802987575531,
0.32170549035072327,
0.2138749361038208,
-0.5097118616104126,
0.2127474844455719,
0.5147071480751038,
-0.3973395824432373,
0.1378868818283081,
0.5276700854301453,
0.33824747800827026,
-0.12660883367061615,
0.6434028148651123,
0.1695156842470169,
-0.6032453179359436,
0.7336133718490601,
0.34981203079223633,
0.6023784875869751,
-0.048696037381887436,
0.2329111248254776,
0.39169245958328247,
-0.006490795873105526,
0.2859097421169281,
0.38136687874794006,
-0.39976048469543457,
-0.7950888872146606,
-0.4545016884803772,
-0.5978530645370483,
-0.6262701153755188,
-0.04029437527060509,
-0.8821349740028381,
0.1949431598186493,
-0.5335361957550049,
-0.00017300547915510833,
-0.33484596014022827,
0.23247011005878448,
-0.47210821509361267,
0.08319219946861267,
0.26410868763923645,
0.8304349780082703,
-0.5779383182525635,
1.1284900903701782,
0.8710172176361084,
-0.3880678117275238,
-1.0646182298660278,
0.2757447361946106,
0.0886540561914444,
-0.6373378038406372,
0.26690614223480225,
0.21780793368816376,
-0.3378605842590332,
-0.011198785156011581,
-0.7635402083396912,
-0.8697766661643982,
1.201289415359497,
0.19916749000549316,
-0.43848341703414917,
0.16321523487567902,
0.020275704562664032,
0.5006505846977234,
-0.5502192378044128,
0.38998183608055115,
0.33968183398246765,
0.22971655428409576,
-0.11776266247034073,
-0.7367861866950989,
-0.121253103017807,
-0.3389653265476227,
0.09374190866947174,
0.2779946029186249,
-0.8069275617599487,
0.44148069620132446,
-0.2697421610355377,
0.10512819141149521,
0.17117884755134583,
0.7953794598579407,
0.6724624037742615,
0.24527716636657715,
0.5600141286849976,
0.2850947380065918,
0.6294206380844116,
0.19494587182998657,
0.6745113730430603,
-0.48090261220932007,
0.4676293134689331,
1.1767852306365967,
-0.34657353162765503,
1.0064994096755981,
0.7683116793632507,
-0.1561679095029831,
0.7989872694015503,
0.7615838646888733,
0.3093721270561218,
0.55851149559021,
0.29985862970352173,
-0.09381517022848129,
-0.4452102482318878,
0.03005889616906643,
-0.2860613763332367,
0.22400547564029694,
0.09882166236639023,
-0.04441734775900841,
0.004158192779868841,
-0.1144508495926857,
-0.17334085702896118,
0.39976197481155396,
-0.23930181562900543,
0.6705056428909302,
0.03860464692115784,
-1.025929570198059,
0.491141676902771,
0.13919667899608612,
0.8569444417953491,
-0.48134738206863403,
-0.020533787086606026,
-0.5037497282028198,
0.26653119921684265,
-0.46443748474121094,
-0.8932267427444458,
0.08797989785671234,
0.07132302969694138,
-0.44876545667648315,
-0.1724909394979477,
0.26269716024398804,
-0.6492395401000977,
-0.20050306618213654,
0.3323264420032501,
0.5691289305686951,
-0.1418185532093048,
0.22138500213623047,
-1.0509942770004272,
-0.08025872707366943,
0.2318919152021408,
-0.0010462331119924784,
0.6169171333312988,
-0.028204983100295067,
-0.0542118065059185,
0.7193262577056885,
0.5146350860595703,
-0.183798149228096,
-0.03379511088132858,
0.09292671084403992,
0.9520306587219238,
-0.4002607762813568,
-0.5744894742965698,
-0.5757995247840881,
0.298944890499115,
0.12098638713359833,
-0.33407387137413025,
0.865580141544342,
0.8597143888473511,
0.9306656718254089,
0.1355436146259308,
0.8377436995506287,
-0.12106141448020935,
0.6850296258926392,
-0.44032391905784607,
0.32855477929115295,
-0.5715612173080444,
0.5665619969367981,
-0.3861650824546814,
-1.0420187711715698,
-0.18853998184204102,
0.29101911187171936,
-0.3088738024234772,
0.06502463668584824,
0.5360050201416016,
1.1119869947433472,
-0.0045772735029459,
-0.24430470168590546,
0.11552467197179794,
-0.12136255204677582,
0.3046679198741913,
0.9337880611419678,
0.875179648399353,
-0.045070745050907135,
0.7790204286575317,
-0.1457090675830841,
-0.30885279178619385,
-0.21884867548942566,
-0.6806628704071045,
-0.5908201336860657,
-0.41609564423561096,
-0.2731003165245056,
-0.5055869221687317,
-0.03433148190379143,
1.352149486541748,
0.6032310128211975,
-1.0043801069259644,
-0.4698041081428528,
0.2664068043231964,
0.16818194091320038,
-0.45246097445487976,
-0.3271074593067169,
0.35698220133781433,
-0.25978460907936096,
-0.5321167707443237,
0.17611779272556305,
0.34733760356903076,
-0.5280734300613403,
-0.35445675253868103,
-0.42758554220199585,
-0.21252143383026123,
-0.06607624888420105,
0.3955359160900116,
0.3348068296909332,
-0.812333345413208,
-0.46730291843414307,
0.35193851590156555,
-0.45151472091674805,
0.4568210244178772,
1.0330570936203003,
-0.9028743505477905,
0.16926132142543793,
0.4203791916370392,
0.9394419193267822,
0.12620414793491364,
0.5127449035644531,
0.45060738921165466,
-0.8696576356887817,
-0.30326974391937256,
0.15789936482906342,
0.17879618704319,
0.3197937309741974,
-0.5605335831642151,
0.29771846532821655,
-0.13643302023410797,
-0.924340546131134,
-0.3778739869594574,
0.3487851917743683,
-1.1443812847137451,
-0.32572266459465027,
1.062088131904602,
-0.13446147739887238,
-0.051775433123111725,
-0.20578670501708984,
-0.4448345899581909,
-0.06357070058584213,
-0.6457737684249878,
0.8264325857162476,
0.7198290228843689,
-0.5827168226242065,
-0.3977777361869812,
-0.3615427315235138,
0.31454795598983765,
0.6763627529144287,
-0.802518904209137,
0.23810036480426788,
0.7679862380027771,
0.40944764018058777,
-0.019498247653245926,
0.8476505875587463,
-0.1803978979587555,
0.44372454285621643,
-0.7212409973144531,
0.24599261581897736,
0.03532099351286888,
-0.33293208479881287,
-0.42012810707092285,
0.25096431374549866,
0.5614206790924072,
-0.06899845600128174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17159v1
|
Stop! In the Name of Flaws: Disentangling Personal Names and Sociodemographic Attributes in NLP
| 2024-05-27T13:33:29 | 2024-05-27T13:33:29 |
Vagrant Gautam, Arjun Subramonian, Anne Lauscher, Os Keyes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
Personal names simultaneously differentiate individuals and categorize them
in ways that are important in a given society. While the natural language
processing community has thus associated personal names with sociodemographic
characteristics in a variety of tasks, researchers have engaged to varying
degrees with the established methodological problems in doing so. To guide
future work, we present an interdisciplinary background on names and naming. We
then survey the issues inherent to associating names with sociodemographic
attributes, covering problems of validity (e.g., systematic error, construct
validity), as well as ethical concerns (e.g., harms, differential impact,
cultural insensitivity). Finally, we provide guiding questions along with
normative recommendations to avoid validity and ethical pitfalls when dealing
with names and sociodemographic characteristics in natural language processing.
|
[
-0.4142315685749054,
-0.7813137173652649,
0.6801955699920654,
0.5187170505523682,
-0.021747922524809837,
0.7780349850654602,
-0.08874676376581192,
-0.937107503414154,
0.13036225736141205,
0.3309016525745392,
-0.4865429699420929,
-0.02940131165087223,
-1.067447543144226,
0.1826082020998001,
-0.18423134088516235,
0.9533563256263733,
-0.05476704612374306,
0.24102240800857544,
-0.4431663453578949,
-0.360175222158432,
-0.6327899098396301,
-0.6599129438400269,
-1.1482199430465698,
-0.07354173064231873,
0.8000077605247498,
0.30817100405693054,
0.7750943303108215,
0.6050843596458435,
0.8902236819267273,
0.38432469964027405,
-0.44728589057922363,
-0.04329459369182587,
-0.07805074006319046,
0.48633477091789246,
-0.4040876626968384,
0.014030332677066326,
-0.17298071086406708,
0.19256584346294403,
0.30086594820022583,
1.0284807682037354,
0.20375655591487885,
0.45846128463745117,
-0.006639174651354551,
0.7451901435852051,
-0.49074020981788635,
0.08674857765436172,
-0.11084229499101639,
-0.007632665801793337,
-0.5789089202880859,
-0.03556923195719719,
-0.13893845677375793,
-0.673922598361969,
0.13309313356876373,
-0.07673320919275284,
0.2525424361228943,
0.03908977657556534,
0.9168732762336731,
0.24253875017166138,
-0.09069619327783585,
-0.6061273217201233,
-1.0903480052947998,
0.8492375016212463,
-0.5870419144630432,
0.12089711427688599,
0.6414154171943665,
0.509731113910675,
-0.019298149272799492,
-0.2153288871049881,
-0.5038619041442871,
0.13502191007137299,
-0.12700849771499634,
-0.10824444890022278,
-0.3143330514431,
-0.10362563282251358,
0.4721991717815399,
0.4045995771884918,
-0.4236040413379669,
0.16108423471450806,
-0.5862680077552795,
-0.12681370973587036,
0.9054649472236633,
0.1610427051782608,
0.5529674887657166,
-0.07219874113798141,
-0.352046400308609,
0.24965834617614746,
-0.5506016612052917,
0.16636815667152405,
0.8443916440010071,
0.42270413041114807,
0.17027272284030914,
0.3862505257129669,
-0.20074069499969482,
0.44581925868988037,
0.103866346180439,
-0.3091139495372772,
0.12234833091497421,
-0.3255783021450043,
-0.19384361803531647,
0.2938908636569977,
0.5776280760765076,
0.17142999172210693,
0.32450780272483826,
-0.5493642091751099,
0.04707663878798485,
0.1785120964050293,
0.24415241181850433,
-0.41664502024650574,
-0.16682390868663788,
0.45003095269203186,
-0.3447984755039215,
-0.6522537469863892,
-0.15041829645633698,
-0.6816937327384949,
-0.6910256743431091,
-0.5622339844703674,
0.21254988014698029,
-0.32620564103126526,
-0.13782355189323425,
-0.13371102511882782,
-0.32382866740226746,
0.15972471237182617,
0.3409920930862427,
-0.8149954676628113,
0.35975661873817444,
0.6856999397277832,
0.6640920042991638,
0.06949210911989212,
-0.025024181231856346,
-0.24061615765094757,
0.028677217662334442,
-0.1987934559583664,
0.8106644749641418,
-0.7409411072731018,
-0.13299033045768738,
-0.334446519613266,
-0.0025113532319664955,
0.3742493689060211,
-0.4845344126224518,
0.47630882263183594,
-0.19988352060317993,
0.10053681582212448,
-0.7347791194915771,
-0.4234946668148041,
0.002442811382934451,
0.04444744065403938,
-0.4327186048030853,
0.6930186152458191,
-0.06958697736263275,
-0.8638836741447449,
0.5017282366752625,
-0.41851237416267395,
-0.4985412359237671,
0.2689879238605499,
-0.21269024908542633,
-0.22924460470676422,
0.1506141871213913,
-0.30854347348213196,
0.5245773196220398,
-0.14893114566802979,
0.30279529094696045,
-0.21442371606826782,
0.23192735016345978,
0.31540772318840027,
-0.05254970118403435,
1.1821342706680298,
0.07418564707040787,
-0.1954316943883896,
-0.2632765769958496,
-0.899146318435669,
-0.12563790380954742,
0.16435606777668,
-0.0003320301475469023,
-0.7564123272895813,
0.29484471678733826,
0.002801373600959778,
0.10467993468046188,
0.09929577261209488,
-0.6285776495933533,
-0.2701963484287262,
-0.07030137628316879,
0.33049580454826355,
1.0607008934020996,
-0.14329390227794647,
0.35009822249412537,
-0.5402253270149231,
0.5924093723297119,
-0.030924146994948387,
0.2819458544254303,
-0.04707590863108635,
-0.7543789744377136,
-0.5181737542152405,
-0.2204602211713791,
0.7322805523872375,
0.38826408982276917,
-0.49832722544670105,
0.49048495292663574,
0.17576973140239716,
-0.6870920062065125,
-0.17866899073123932,
-0.1724809855222702,
0.5816083550453186,
0.4504009187221527,
0.44752469658851624,
-0.549369215965271,
-0.6575025916099548,
-0.8755435943603516,
-0.6865019798278809,
-0.28008905053138733,
-0.04680551216006279,
0.4647965133190155,
0.4858523905277252,
-0.08916804939508438,
1.074965000152588,
-0.42540058493614197,
-0.42307016253471375,
0.07196430116891861,
0.39082860946655273,
-0.07716233283281326,
0.3950301706790924,
0.5540207028388977,
-0.7527891993522644,
-0.5003069639205933,
-0.29438209533691406,
-0.5364084839820862,
-0.22112156450748444,
-0.19819945096969604,
-0.1556961089372635,
-0.1518242359161377,
0.23551999032497406,
-0.2891393005847931,
0.34857022762298584,
0.2552112638950348,
-0.722540557384491,
0.8650426268577576,
0.09920194000005722,
-0.1789644956588745,
-0.9828757643699646,
-0.12527039647102356,
0.15844450891017914,
-0.3205214738845825,
-0.4617806375026703,
0.10228412598371506,
-0.43142175674438477,
-0.02638719417154789,
-0.4566136598587036,
0.662326991558075,
-0.5548962950706482,
0.06755964457988739,
0.2974742650985718,
0.03234480693936348,
-0.0065811011008918285,
-0.10239991545677185,
-0.1599111407995224,
0.26635268330574036,
0.6648275256156921,
-0.7988526821136475,
0.543126106262207,
0.32506468892097473,
-0.15366964042186737,
1.2451074123382568,
-0.6828930974006653,
0.1699705719947815,
-0.281429260969162,
-0.377724289894104,
-0.7827280163764954,
-0.44050130248069763,
0.34502819180488586,
-0.6801061034202576,
0.30073556303977966,
-0.10290827602148056,
-0.501656174659729,
-0.18041886389255524,
-0.14936432242393494,
0.37049630284309387,
0.2545974552631378,
-0.33606305718421936,
0.13372232019901276,
0.7280290126800537,
-0.3464033305644989,
-0.6206545233726501,
-0.7704226970672607,
0.42925453186035156,
-0.509160041809082,
-0.40481510758399963,
0.6329808235168457,
-0.23065592348575592,
-0.7748984694480896,
-0.13506199419498444,
-0.08359482139348984,
-0.6146522760391235,
0.33549705147743225,
0.2557210624217987,
-0.06264516711235046,
0.08110411465167999,
0.453600138425827,
-0.05514278635382652,
-0.2108263522386551,
0.18924902379512787,
0.5999603271484375,
0.06024402379989624,
0.1510554999113083,
0.1755141019821167,
-0.07023943960666656,
0.5477105379104614,
0.4368760287761688,
-0.08958324790000916,
0.5984671711921692,
0.1676621437072754,
-0.5091140270233154,
-0.13383813202381134,
-0.3737349212169647,
0.046421512961387634,
-0.4039052724838257,
-0.08462044596672058,
-0.021171068772673607,
-0.6888093948364258,
0.7241536974906921,
-0.08357870578765869,
-0.026013663038611412,
0.13218121230602264,
0.3074411451816559,
-0.49585819244384766,
0.772499144077301,
0.9049398899078369,
0.004675733391195536,
0.10741612315177917,
0.4002932012081146,
0.9481624960899353,
-0.8681778907775879,
0.08196572214365005,
-0.7949771285057068,
-0.7090356945991516,
-0.6339110136032104,
-0.3161219656467438,
-0.26937755942344666,
0.06449633091688156,
-0.2426324337720871,
0.5789408087730408,
-0.8832032680511475,
0.6608725786209106,
-0.05897708609700203,
-0.24121184647083282,
0.5483880043029785,
-0.3074430823326111,
0.03451204672455788,
-0.5710119605064392,
0.013658219017088413,
-0.9201450943946838,
0.6528387069702148,
0.5477511882781982,
0.8017594814300537,
0.3983333110809326,
0.8741093277931213,
0.41412314772605896,
0.2150202840566635,
-0.7184221148490906,
0.2591281533241272,
-0.02084008790552616,
-0.9196135401725769,
-0.333889365196228,
-0.237338587641716,
-0.8931825160980225,
0.05076074227690697,
0.05478606000542641,
-1.0781961679458618,
0.5882247090339661,
0.06555020064115524,
-0.5536634922027588,
0.1643996238708496,
-0.14848686754703522,
0.7663796544075012,
-0.5389645099639893,
-0.028469450771808624,
0.32745346426963806,
-0.6217413544654846,
0.5204320549964905,
-0.10336459428071976,
0.44468483328819275,
-0.5947956442832947,
-0.010233101435005665,
0.7755362391471863,
-0.2751043736934662,
0.9565584063529968,
0.03894118592143059,
0.17714054882526398,
-0.20235003530979156,
0.18531499803066254,
0.04505430534482002,
0.05778123810887337,
0.16343702375888824,
0.43417826294898987,
0.4507884085178375,
-0.010622804053127766,
-0.29057109355926514,
0.5048004984855652,
-0.43432894349098206,
-0.21897722780704498,
-0.7184733748435974,
-0.15514932572841644,
-0.1860768347978592,
0.32193437218666077,
0.34495988488197327,
0.22885160148143768,
-0.5486322045326233,
0.10304360836744308,
0.6849572062492371,
-0.42892375588417053,
0.4311765730381012,
0.5394412875175476,
-0.2343169003725052,
-0.07089235633611679,
0.9046578407287598,
0.36685648560523987,
0.053388580679893494,
-0.17224077880382538,
0.3193019926548004,
-0.15821592509746552,
-0.3302348852157593,
-0.33633479475975037,
0.24005426466464996,
-0.6832249760627747,
-0.1921415776014328,
-0.5880098938941956,
-0.16166917979717255,
-0.29114142060279846,
-0.2125077098608017,
-0.45898309350013733,
-0.26565849781036377,
-0.3266197741031647,
0.19045551121234894,
0.310052752494812,
0.8298833966255188,
0.11437501758337021,
0.1698443740606308,
-0.6385307908058167,
0.46572819352149963,
0.13675130903720856,
0.4596383571624756,
-0.19149118661880493,
-0.24754782021045685,
0.2130630761384964,
-0.11903533339500427,
-0.5085521340370178,
-1.0235174894332886,
0.27801772952079773,
0.11262307316064835,
0.5332252383232117,
0.40980303287506104,
0.45442870259284973,
0.6388368010520935,
-0.4109968841075897,
0.5198591351509094,
0.17332039773464203,
-0.8491260409355164,
0.5280888676643372,
-0.11840712279081345,
-0.0677366629242897,
0.7401191592216492,
0.7923595905303955,
-1.045250415802002,
-0.775513231754303,
-0.8708086609840393,
-1.0803461074829102,
0.4085557758808136,
0.4184780418872833,
0.2938532531261444,
-0.20931358635425568,
0.19232036173343658,
0.18545673787593842,
0.19023020565509796,
-0.7522807717323303,
-0.44178569316864014,
0.33903610706329346,
0.13079051673412323,
0.1697123497724533,
-0.38262543082237244,
-0.45358529686927795,
-0.4767518937587738,
0.3986295461654663,
0.026722745969891548,
0.13060791790485382,
0.20883238315582275,
-0.11596290022134781,
-0.015879254788160324,
0.23441539704799652,
0.6355125904083252,
0.9326711297035217,
0.22426219284534454,
0.13105550408363342,
-0.2417372316122055,
-0.22298766672611237,
0.16309724748134613,
-0.20747719705104828,
-0.0022834057454019785,
0.3948856592178345,
0.2956986129283905,
0.39289411902427673,
0.4054356813430786,
-0.1844966858625412,
0.3922175467014313,
-0.31112343072891235,
-0.10275068134069443,
-0.7139223217964172,
-0.30651453137397766,
0.16252048313617706,
0.17183411121368408,
0.14476291835308075,
0.4314667284488678,
0.20381583273410797,
-0.5962961316108704,
-0.00917330477386713,
0.33189526200294495,
-0.4143827259540558,
-0.35923096537590027,
0.47503766417503357,
0.21998560428619385,
-0.7288267016410828,
0.22946937382221222,
-0.39881789684295654,
-0.3701157867908478,
0.8018627762794495,
0.17090851068496704,
0.9354541301727295,
-0.3794129192829132,
0.5086221098899841,
0.3664548397064209,
0.30810993909835815,
-0.025952951982617378,
0.050132814794778824,
-0.2586645483970642,
-0.8598952293395996,
-0.1488262116909027,
-1.0522193908691406,
-0.6285846829414368,
-0.04777728021144867,
-0.7156200408935547,
0.2263234257698059,
-0.9501201510429382,
-0.42027100920677185,
0.5443369746208191,
-0.2590033710002899,
-0.5918427109718323,
0.19899171590805054,
0.37152746319770813,
0.35881760716438293,
-0.8680364489555359,
0.4072321355342865,
0.6565233469009399,
-0.3505766689777374,
-0.5215052366256714,
-0.08913719654083252,
0.34526947140693665,
-0.12526878714561462,
0.9318601489067078,
0.2721061408519745,
-0.01199179794639349,
-0.2611452639102936,
-0.42625701427459717,
-1.1325231790542603,
0.7525559067726135,
0.13490687310695648,
-0.4717891216278076,
-0.1098906621336937,
0.10152564197778702,
0.6719560623168945,
-0.08033061027526855,
0.14788605272769928,
0.7076976299285889,
0.9227726459503174,
0.09172230213880539,
-0.9593228697776794,
-0.039128631353378296,
-0.05344414710998535,
0.14811067283153534,
-0.019717687740921974,
-0.408814936876297,
0.8873422741889954,
-0.3024682104587555,
-0.6680861115455627,
-0.08954032510519028,
0.17110252380371094,
0.11678051203489304,
0.27834248542785645,
0.31064268946647644,
0.4914841651916504,
1.0187798738479614,
-0.4940076768398285,
1.034877896308899,
0.09019147604703903,
0.46754756569862366,
1.1275686025619507,
-0.1857631653547287,
0.2981569766998291,
0.4884609878063202,
-0.5785157680511475,
0.4722191095352173,
0.8361088633537292,
-0.1728706806898117,
0.3640015125274658,
0.1852644681930542,
-0.1086944043636322,
0.07161115854978561,
-0.04945898428559303,
-0.2789667546749115,
0.8959289193153381,
0.13231365382671356,
-0.510374903678894,
-0.39257994294166565,
-0.11205258220434189,
0.26928070187568665,
0.16244004666805267,
0.15885131061077118,
0.6719778180122375,
0.17061059176921844,
-0.16418790817260742,
-0.17699329555034637,
-0.015979712828993797,
0.808057963848114,
-0.322719931602478,
-0.07717288285493851,
-0.052353814244270325,
0.15844862163066864,
-0.45057979226112366,
-0.784944474697113,
1.0478020906448364,
-0.13428768515586853,
-0.4714107811450958,
-0.5196910500526428,
0.675675094127655,
-0.08686184883117676,
-0.6413114666938782,
0.46577152609825134,
0.3736783564090729,
0.2640688121318817,
-0.18114472925662994,
-0.7077147364616394,
-0.21965689957141876,
-0.5397996306419373,
-0.038583312183618546,
0.34591469168663025,
0.2844541370868683,
-0.002851150231435895,
0.6985476613044739,
0.6603255867958069,
0.24872539937496185,
0.07721339911222458,
-0.1846020370721817,
0.4241774082183838,
-0.818807065486908,
-0.4051414728164673,
-1.0025616884231567,
0.5876268744468689,
-0.25447747111320496,
-0.5425359010696411,
0.8827361464500427,
0.13931594789028168,
0.9390771389007568,
0.0405641607940197,
0.527519941329956,
-0.3851219415664673,
0.5880341529846191,
-0.18672840297222137,
1.0121394395828247,
-0.4675702154636383,
0.03849019110202789,
-0.5447390675544739,
-0.9945383071899414,
-0.4067770540714264,
0.6337485909461975,
-0.1749216467142105,
0.15262427926063538,
0.595379114151001,
0.22407393157482147,
0.3488883972167969,
-0.22111301124095917,
0.5462838411331177,
0.016194062307476997,
0.2197929471731186,
0.07276449352502823,
0.8193684220314026,
-0.3066119849681854,
-0.06305600702762604,
-0.6523562073707581,
-0.1617111712694168,
-0.1734551191329956,
-1.044418215751648,
-0.6321112513542175,
-0.5455557703971863,
-0.704949140548706,
-0.16963644325733185,
-0.0701780691742897,
0.3184516727924347,
0.6660628318786621,
-0.6620052456855774,
0.04937578737735748,
0.2666301131248474,
0.6745162606239319,
-0.29091137647628784,
-0.3777928650379181,
-0.13811855018138885,
-0.4730074107646942,
-0.7381795048713684,
0.1347588151693344,
0.5687780976295471,
-0.1256624013185501,
-0.4316556751728058,
0.004427508916705847,
0.01817731000483036,
0.3065352737903595,
0.6094103455543518,
0.6091194748878479,
-0.9189525246620178,
-0.5369492173194885,
-0.3861595690250397,
-0.15630412101745605,
0.06265256553888321,
0.9160327315330505,
-0.3998394012451172,
0.7449391484260559,
0.5226573944091797,
0.3694448173046112,
-0.48281916975975037,
0.09673985093832016,
0.47251537442207336,
-0.8396176695823669,
-0.10715527087450027,
0.580144464969635,
0.3111078441143036,
0.5065473914146423,
-0.970184862613678,
0.35675132274627686,
0.4480046033859253,
-0.7312720417976379,
-1.04786217212677,
0.2869049310684204,
-0.8257717490196228,
-0.30003055930137634,
0.7589550614356995,
-0.03280944004654884,
-0.033710777759552,
-0.637481153011322,
0.06461254507303238,
-0.03164965286850929,
-0.03762676939368248,
0.9864267706871033,
0.9907311797142029,
-0.2703762650489807,
-0.15033693611621857,
-0.6865313649177551,
0.7314000129699707,
0.14289845526218414,
-0.6679288744926453,
0.16286273300647736,
0.2427908033132553,
0.34674644470214844,
0.5684764981269836,
0.663135826587677,
-0.5474079847335815,
0.22134219110012054,
-0.12289435416460037,
0.31112048029899597,
0.06702140718698502,
-0.3869379758834839,
-0.15824542939662933,
-0.17033779621124268,
0.12219759076833725,
-0.0020055118948221207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17130v1
|
Exploiting the Layered Intrinsic Dimensionality of Deep Models for Practical Adversarial Training
| 2024-05-27T12:48:30 | 2024-05-27T12:48:30 |
Enes Altinisik, Safa Messaoud, Husrev Taha Sencar, Hassan Sajjad, Sanjay Chawla
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Despite being a heavily researched topic, Adversarial Training (AT) is
rarely, if ever, deployed in practical AI systems for two primary reasons: (i)
the gained robustness is frequently accompanied by a drop in generalization and
(ii) generating adversarial examples (AEs) is computationally prohibitively
expensive. To address these limitations, we propose SMAAT, a new AT algorithm
that leverages the manifold conjecture, stating that off-manifold AEs lead to
better robustness while on-manifold AEs result in better generalization.
Specifically, SMAAT aims at generating a higher proportion of off-manifold AEs
by perturbing the intermediate deepnet layer with the lowest intrinsic
dimension. This systematically results in better scalability compared to
classical AT as it reduces the PGD chains length required for generating the
AEs. Additionally, our study provides, to the best of our knowledge, the first
explanation for the difference in the generalization and robustness trends
between vision and language models, ie., AT results in a drop in generalization
in vision models whereas, in encoder-based language models, generalization
either improves or remains unchanged. We show that vision transformers and
decoder-based models tend to have low intrinsic dimensionality in the earlier
layers of the network (more off-manifold AEs), while encoder-based models have
low intrinsic dimensionality in the later layers. We demonstrate the efficacy
of SMAAT; on several tasks, including robustifying (i) sentiment classifiers,
(ii) safety filters in decoder-based models, and (iii) retrievers in RAG
setups. SMAAT requires only 25-33% of the GPU time compared to standard AT,
while significantly improving robustness across all applications and
maintaining comparable generalization.
|
[
-0.4803078770637512,
-0.818447470664978,
0.39966830611228943,
-0.305824875831604,
-0.195327490568161,
0.16575516760349274,
0.08702053874731064,
-0.15039567649364471,
0.176969513297081,
0.2164304107427597,
-0.38872864842414856,
-0.2192346453666687,
-0.7797965407371521,
-0.5303208827972412,
-0.349232941865921,
0.9581603407859802,
0.029595153406262398,
-0.07974275946617126,
-0.05372732877731323,
-0.19989556074142456,
0.13973715901374817,
-0.7674925327301025,
-0.8201488852500916,
-0.10968084633350372,
0.6191447377204895,
-0.06811477988958359,
0.82645583152771,
0.8044264316558838,
0.8766597509384155,
0.32778844237327576,
-0.21248385310173035,
0.20324105024337769,
-0.19579143822193146,
-0.1580899953842163,
0.13058070838451385,
-0.6187182664871216,
-0.4586024284362793,
0.16973865032196045,
0.7655012011528015,
0.5860030055046082,
0.010527299717068672,
0.07026959210634232,
-0.07124017924070358,
0.7880996465682983,
-0.7815425992012024,
0.017406040802598,
-0.7631261944770813,
0.11348491162061691,
-0.2164289951324463,
-0.18324662744998932,
-0.02676260843873024,
-0.18603965640068054,
0.1440342515707016,
-0.43891841173171997,
0.28333693742752075,
-0.3419393301010132,
0.676876425743103,
0.6132420301437378,
-0.5657205581665039,
-0.13153022527694702,
-0.6315778493881226,
0.6913178563117981,
-0.5791437029838562,
0.35603857040405273,
0.08242270350456238,
0.6268682479858398,
0.15444156527519226,
-0.756604015827179,
-0.3755684196949005,
-0.4146623909473419,
0.30141881108283997,
0.13118810951709747,
-0.2498786896467209,
-0.12669391930103302,
0.3621145486831665,
0.513388991355896,
-0.453887403011322,
-0.02642299234867096,
-0.39163798093795776,
0.034094907343387604,
0.3643508553504944,
0.029072102159261703,
0.27678683400154114,
0.07799318432807922,
-0.3513631224632263,
-0.24214988946914673,
-0.9479517936706543,
0.34171631932258606,
0.45940113067626953,
0.2960846424102783,
0.07461856305599213,
0.4712792634963989,
0.24339452385902405,
0.16320927441120148,
0.11109694093465805,
0.11775422096252441,
0.04049793258309364,
0.24777129292488098,
-0.08833576738834381,
-0.2461911290884018,
0.6287153363227844,
-0.10258715599775314,
-0.10208044201135635,
-0.2272598296403885,
-0.25122877955436707,
0.5871195197105408,
0.6673574447631836,
-0.8555450439453125,
-0.4392910897731781,
0.04273828864097595,
-0.41799288988113403,
-0.86399245262146,
0.007803486660122871,
-0.3340528905391693,
-0.45604604482650757,
-0.36072835326194763,
0.5291639566421509,
-0.4875083267688751,
-0.07917391508817673,
-0.18748322129249573,
-0.11692056059837341,
0.017028233036398888,
0.1315453052520752,
-0.5561016201972961,
0.3125082552433014,
0.6795486807823181,
1.000889539718628,
0.025506505742669106,
-0.3699938654899597,
-0.5891830325126648,
0.10464852303266525,
-0.4391079843044281,
0.7910522818565369,
-0.4486398696899414,
-0.12594959139823914,
-0.33098822832107544,
-0.2699469327926636,
-0.08090507239103317,
-0.40974166989326477,
0.5521414279937744,
-0.5396935939788818,
0.023954501375555992,
-0.41446563601493835,
-0.18373379111289978,
-0.4142265021800995,
0.4779748022556305,
-0.49883702397346497,
0.4756487011909485,
-0.028603047132492065,
-0.9277865886688232,
0.4404398202896118,
-0.8928402066230774,
-0.4152143895626068,
-0.06323537230491638,
-0.3461099863052368,
-0.6705304980278015,
0.329489141702652,
0.5738604664802551,
0.4329163432121277,
-0.15517166256904602,
-0.10310927033424377,
-0.4127761125564575,
-0.5449888110160828,
0.09068761765956879,
-0.7581242918968201,
1.0716933012008667,
0.11624985933303833,
-0.6104949116706848,
0.012540522031486034,
-0.6355206966400146,
-0.04182875528931618,
0.3806607723236084,
-0.3125933110713959,
-0.2648434340953827,
0.07090771198272705,
-0.3334643244743347,
0.0922299399971962,
-0.011160627007484436,
-0.4553748071193695,
0.3398437201976776,
-0.532757043838501,
0.584784746170044,
0.9833663702011108,
-0.05894438922405243,
0.57392418384552,
-0.30522844195365906,
0.6066188812255859,
0.15079554915428162,
0.11975258588790894,
0.1676885336637497,
-0.4211680293083191,
-0.6733189225196838,
-0.6876884698867798,
0.3366601765155792,
0.6286823749542236,
-1.0558509826660156,
0.297288179397583,
-0.36858636140823364,
-0.43275129795074463,
-0.43365171551704407,
-0.17700821161270142,
0.3877764940261841,
0.2757943272590637,
0.24528495967388153,
-0.35798180103302,
-0.2142947018146515,
-0.8411535024642944,
-0.33550727367401123,
-0.261898398399353,
-0.13600513339042664,
0.4847556948661804,
0.49887481331825256,
-0.5461392998695374,
0.501876175403595,
-0.35045892000198364,
-0.3125625550746918,
0.0316324345767498,
0.07757734507322311,
-0.05129747465252876,
0.42619043588638306,
0.8297439813613892,
-0.7886927723884583,
-0.6589673757553101,
0.17966382205486298,
-0.9094412922859192,
0.370931476354599,
0.03953378275036812,
0.06430703401565552,
0.08341939002275467,
0.13183243572711945,
-0.712907612323761,
0.7419121265411377,
0.3563089370727539,
-0.026032891124486923,
0.3887854218482971,
-0.19070973992347717,
0.07041124999523163,
-0.8283076882362366,
0.06341789662837982,
-0.049724459648132324,
-0.27862975001335144,
-0.6239570379257202,
0.6806182861328125,
-0.020979059860110283,
-0.5233707427978516,
-0.45320940017700195,
0.29753273725509644,
-0.39358261227607727,
-0.041216447949409485,
-0.18853488564491272,
-0.18805427849292755,
-0.0885438397526741,
0.6529678106307983,
-0.28612369298934937,
0.8876103758811951,
0.9344704151153564,
-0.6269619464874268,
0.35473722219467163,
0.1453547179698944,
-0.005321495234966278,
0.6296707391738892,
-0.6839426755905151,
0.32058557868003845,
-0.1904808133840561,
0.3432976305484772,
-0.3335862159729004,
0.04627535119652748,
0.054737839847803116,
-0.47368550300598145,
0.5109198093414307,
-0.3817964494228363,
-0.17098763585090637,
-0.4854806065559387,
-0.5742076635360718,
0.47393798828125,
0.5887882113456726,
-0.7977380156517029,
0.8604408502578735,
0.5035156011581421,
0.08661267906427383,
-0.60547935962677,
-0.9299294948577881,
0.18778781592845917,
-0.5335073471069336,
-0.8073375225067139,
0.061097387224435806,
-0.006008487194776535,
-0.06630077213048935,
-0.08994930237531662,
-0.10376772284507751,
0.05385042354464531,
0.15592145919799805,
0.15874049067497253,
-0.02806011587381363,
-0.32788118720054626,
-0.43767914175987244,
-0.012541490606963634,
-0.17041201889514923,
0.15961964428424835,
-0.644676923751831,
0.3263627588748932,
-0.6665070652961731,
-0.587306797504425,
-0.561506986618042,
0.48997214436531067,
0.6124727725982666,
-0.18924471735954285,
0.9879701137542725,
0.9263842105865479,
-0.3386566638946533,
-0.28446686267852783,
-0.2953341007232666,
-0.24144038558006287,
-0.5461537837982178,
0.27787506580352783,
-0.6234692931175232,
-0.6233106255531311,
0.6517292857170105,
0.07581833004951477,
0.056630391627550125,
0.44266554713249207,
0.39514878392219543,
-0.03896457701921463,
1.362131953239441,
0.42041876912117004,
-0.09477626532316208,
0.4204082787036896,
-0.9358711838722229,
0.5225066542625427,
-1.0980833768844604,
0.15694287419319153,
-0.0777752473950386,
-0.48053085803985596,
-0.6983423829078674,
-0.2685416042804718,
0.7042708396911621,
-0.1347210854291916,
-0.46655258536338806,
0.18721093237400055,
-0.4372621774673462,
0.481730580329895,
0.8236401677131653,
0.3630523681640625,
-0.30443206429481506,
0.3284461796283722,
-0.12222004681825638,
-0.04886489734053612,
-0.9063171744346619,
-0.3551827669143677,
1.169588565826416,
0.5985469222068787,
0.6052088141441345,
0.47958287596702576,
0.6534295082092285,
0.2033441811800003,
0.0923568606376648,
-0.7554380297660828,
0.40556013584136963,
-0.7303255200386047,
-0.3548784554004669,
-0.1751660853624344,
-0.8595144748687744,
-0.7203282713890076,
0.24697336554527283,
0.05159338563680649,
-0.4810510277748108,
0.46466830372810364,
0.3977651000022888,
-0.2890669107437134,
0.7938351035118103,
-0.6600640416145325,
0.5797562599182129,
-0.09075644612312317,
-0.15641936659812927,
0.056678708642721176,
-0.6877372860908508,
0.3353279232978821,
-0.04037710651755333,
-0.02063918299973011,
0.3688249886035919,
0.14315439760684967,
0.47420257329940796,
-0.5402634739875793,
0.7554116249084473,
-0.5240167379379272,
0.03767389431595802,
0.3959480822086334,
0.2972104847431183,
0.8862488865852356,
0.05782174691557884,
0.08808182924985886,
0.21284058690071106,
-0.37386828660964966,
-0.6466615200042725,
-0.7911534309387207,
0.7870280742645264,
-0.9295467734336853,
-0.5510604381561279,
-0.47484540939331055,
-0.5627180337905884,
-0.32620179653167725,
-0.051740862429142,
0.42292818427085876,
0.816974937915802,
-0.08826600760221481,
0.48438718914985657,
0.7282986044883728,
-0.1431160867214203,
0.02362266555428505,
-0.07429482042789459,
0.312760591506958,
-0.2342570424079895,
1.4484208822250366,
0.11932765692472458,
0.3039296269416809,
0.2515306770801544,
0.30720460414886475,
-0.22192811965942383,
-0.5276892185211182,
-0.49419379234313965,
-0.08358379453420639,
-0.6714699268341064,
-0.22788749635219574,
-0.8160043358802795,
-0.6470898389816284,
-0.4965595006942749,
-0.39794468879699707,
-0.5560641884803772,
-0.7679691910743713,
-0.17696239054203033,
0.07392103970050812,
-0.10444560647010803,
0.7392754554748535,
-0.38291341066360474,
0.4524933993816376,
-0.44236844778060913,
0.507361114025116,
0.7212749123573303,
0.08719849586486816,
0.15380775928497314,
-0.7442207932472229,
-0.1536630243062973,
0.4426218271255493,
-0.5935696363449097,
-0.29529720544815063,
0.31095635890960693,
0.40054863691329956,
0.5539989471435547,
0.668791651725769,
-0.16669616103172302,
0.49165093898773193,
-0.6081271171569824,
0.7251874804496765,
0.050561629235744476,
-0.6801548004150391,
0.48418116569519043,
-0.6382759213447571,
0.19070103764533997,
0.3187284767627716,
0.32410648465156555,
0.1777544766664505,
-0.2961217164993286,
-0.8572733998298645,
-0.7744873762130737,
0.464074045419693,
0.4883868396282196,
-0.05500950664281845,
0.16741393506526947,
0.3277614116668701,
-0.15863633155822754,
0.1669335514307022,
-0.666537880897522,
-0.25213074684143066,
-0.4556224048137665,
-0.15066811442375183,
-0.024462729692459106,
-0.11743570864200592,
-0.3107268810272217,
-0.15573327243328094,
0.8956060409545898,
-0.17309053242206573,
0.5888975262641907,
-0.11835195869207382,
-0.0037272775080055,
0.054058801382780075,
-0.053668852895498276,
0.36295467615127563,
0.3568190038204193,
-0.2422538846731186,
0.3568723201751709,
0.09764434397220612,
-0.6432971954345703,
0.16204142570495605,
0.005513085518032312,
-0.47158074378967285,
-0.5194078683853149,
0.3732634484767914,
0.9560405015945435,
-0.37272486090660095,
-0.1130310520529747,
0.746882975101471,
-0.1900310069322586,
-0.28771543502807617,
-0.16667281091213226,
0.04243352264165878,
-0.4599144160747528,
0.5099417567253113,
0.1627139002084732,
0.7353468537330627,
0.37343716621398926,
-0.6752912402153015,
0.08777972310781479,
0.8702622056007385,
-0.39128246903419495,
-0.39123716950416565,
0.7647350430488586,
-0.11147277802228928,
-0.19847653806209564,
0.3781801164150238,
-0.2604893743991852,
-1.0138686895370483,
0.5554714202880859,
0.3424849510192871,
1.0448240041732788,
-0.09329933673143387,
0.2997486889362335,
-0.14190953969955444,
0.5037599802017212,
0.17467954754829407,
0.004193436354398727,
0.04292527586221695,
-0.5129407048225403,
-0.06600220501422882,
-0.529045820236206,
-0.22960516810417175,
-0.020673958584666252,
-0.5703177452087402,
-0.10210873186588287,
-0.8035439848899841,
-0.19982540607452393,
-0.13704970479011536,
0.047451481223106384,
-0.6630834341049194,
0.3942643105983734,
0.029494401067495346,
0.3765054941177368,
-0.7313958406448364,
0.5617352724075317,
0.8302837014198303,
-0.205514058470726,
-0.7141669988632202,
0.16697488725185394,
0.26359206438064575,
-0.8080875277519226,
0.4107568860054016,
0.09277597069740295,
-0.28627532720565796,
-0.13635966181755066,
-0.401651531457901,
-0.8341094255447388,
1.0392473936080933,
0.5144699811935425,
0.09285783022642136,
-0.03497472405433655,
0.05676835775375366,
0.5808221101760864,
-0.3760245442390442,
-0.039397288113832474,
0.4140883684158325,
0.1431823968887329,
0.319051593542099,
-0.3366375267505646,
-0.11541000753641129,
-0.46600309014320374,
0.2127460241317749,
0.20805291831493378,
-0.7135336399078369,
0.9392028450965881,
-0.1707390695810318,
-0.19643570482730865,
-0.13095881044864655,
0.5120577216148376,
0.3055691421031952,
0.015688221901655197,
0.562200665473938,
0.9140221476554871,
0.6295797228813171,
0.0076978751458227634,
1.35308837890625,
-0.12368887662887573,
0.12304485589265823,
0.7858114242553711,
0.08216425031423569,
0.6243829131126404,
0.21818667650222778,
-0.232781320810318,
0.2886776328086853,
0.38094305992126465,
0.11101532727479935,
0.7811249494552612,
-0.04149402678012848,
-0.15860475599765778,
-0.03141827881336212,
0.06967170536518097,
-0.5295485854148865,
0.3653101921081543,
0.23141855001449585,
-0.1327846199274063,
0.12290376424789429,
0.24580879509449005,
-0.23746483027935028,
-0.14974869787693024,
-0.4442984461784363,
0.6311209201812744,
0.13050417602062225,
-0.09586445987224579,
0.6769694685935974,
-0.06200879067182541,
0.5730047821998596,
-0.4313046634197235,
0.30632585287094116,
-0.22283770143985748,
0.6273692846298218,
-0.000046629265852971,
-0.3414047956466675,
0.41266703605651855,
-0.01373901404440403,
-0.0916263535618782,
0.04287956282496452,
0.6619499325752258,
-0.037746597081422806,
-0.8639976978302002,
0.0007411831174977124,
0.20468461513519287,
0.09177650511264801,
-0.4810903072357178,
-0.643347978591919,
-0.20024429261684418,
-0.04180771857500076,
-0.28861868381500244,
0.33676469326019287,
0.6935929656028748,
0.057404980063438416,
0.8746121525764465,
0.782345175743103,
0.4258894920349121,
0.2666685879230499,
0.06699486821889877,
1.2684147357940674,
-0.2538682520389557,
-0.7536428570747375,
-0.5221220254898071,
0.5544451475143433,
0.020336871966719627,
-0.04010721668601036,
0.636176347732544,
0.35775262117385864,
0.47828209400177,
0.08623185753822327,
0.8125194311141968,
0.09733311831951141,
0.4925709366798401,
-0.43121016025543213,
0.8566635251045227,
-0.876055896282196,
0.5967049598693848,
-0.1410902589559555,
-1.1261340379714966,
-0.34090644121170044,
0.7850461602210999,
-0.23981012403964996,
0.21373330056667328,
0.6631880402565002,
0.6107000708580017,
-0.5763428807258606,
-0.1551978439092636,
0.2969507575035095,
0.2969213128089905,
0.7600370645523071,
0.3897534906864166,
0.7468062043190002,
-0.7842621803283691,
0.39288604259490967,
-0.4346978962421417,
-0.5355067253112793,
0.13222110271453857,
-0.5870018601417542,
-1.3133282661437988,
-0.38576585054397583,
-0.21362364292144775,
-0.21208053827285767,
0.2796332836151123,
0.4709509611129761,
0.7709782123565674,
-0.8775946497917175,
0.26317211985588074,
-0.20002272725105286,
-0.3768641948699951,
-0.12758034467697144,
-0.1843852549791336,
0.5952705144882202,
-0.14065590500831604,
-0.282147079706192,
0.5804265737533569,
0.217719167470932,
0.2720384895801544,
-0.506774365901947,
-0.02878131903707981,
-0.07300526648759842,
0.2960771322250366,
0.6234028339385986,
0.14717407524585724,
-0.6193966269493103,
-0.37179452180862427,
-0.17942221462726593,
0.10975287109613419,
-0.08290128409862518,
0.8051300048828125,
-0.6332264542579651,
-0.00459501426666975,
0.3428594470024109,
0.9041561484336853,
0.4678359031677246,
0.029686572030186653,
0.5453934669494629,
-0.9342338442802429,
0.49661770462989807,
0.3642302453517914,
0.2966674566268921,
0.37287184596061707,
-0.598895251750946,
0.5319713950157166,
0.2785264551639557,
-0.6776638031005859,
-0.9618561863899231,
0.30664584040641785,
-0.6721467971801758,
-0.1909579634666443,
0.8760932087898254,
-0.31377166509628296,
-0.2630334496498108,
0.3061349093914032,
-0.019169827923178673,
-0.06557571142911911,
-0.17323316633701324,
1.0266772508621216,
0.26848211884498596,
0.10148140043020248,
-0.08967867493629456,
-0.2328176647424698,
0.4496234655380249,
0.24002456665039062,
-0.6564932465553284,
-0.232001394033432,
0.04362035170197487,
-0.10985744744539261,
0.23039981722831726,
0.30385851860046387,
0.04307211935520172,
0.22163605690002441,
0.3962585926055908,
-0.5307093858718872,
-0.30743998289108276,
-0.7952791452407837,
-0.3850843012332916,
0.17084620893001556,
-0.19493474066257477,
-0.02278766967356205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17129v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17129v2
|
TEII: Think, Explain, Interact and Iterate with Large Language Models to Solve Cross-lingual Emotion Detection
| 2024-05-27T12:47:40 | 2024-07-02T12:18:51 |
Long Cheng, Qihao Shao, Christine Zhao, Sheng Bi, Gina-Anne Levow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cross-lingual emotion detection allows us to analyze global trends, public
opinion, and social phenomena at scale. We participated in the Explainability
of Cross-lingual Emotion Detection (EXALT) shared task, achieving an F1-score
of 0.6046 on the evaluation set for the emotion detection sub-task. Our system
outperformed the baseline by more than 0.16 F1-score absolute, and ranked
second amongst competing systems. We conducted experiments using fine-tuning,
zero-shot learning, and few-shot learning for Large Language Model (LLM)-based
models as well as embedding-based BiLSTM and KNN for non-LLM-based techniques.
Additionally, we introduced two novel methods: the Multi-Iteration Agentic
Workflow and the Multi-Binary-Classifier Agentic Workflow. We found that
LLM-based approaches provided good performance on multilingual emotion
detection. Furthermore, ensembles combining all our experimented models yielded
higher F1-scores than any single approach alone.
|
[
-0.5407391786575317,
-0.7945990562438965,
0.4918256402015686,
0.260029673576355,
-0.21130314469337463,
0.11982955038547516,
-0.49464544653892517,
-0.7746055722236633,
0.2553975582122803,
-0.3322288990020752,
-0.47035399079322815,
-0.686108410358429,
-0.5141711235046387,
0.015437784604728222,
-0.26668691635131836,
0.7036593556404114,
-0.28374454379081726,
0.10123266279697418,
0.28936654329299927,
-0.28084447979927063,
-0.13487505912780762,
-0.1863684356212616,
-0.8311641812324524,
-0.38959214091300964,
0.5930062532424927,
0.8683156967163086,
0.4566284716129303,
-0.07940948754549026,
0.10361604392528534,
0.3067753314971924,
0.05541076511144638,
-0.06570550054311752,
-0.6518628001213074,
-0.08300778269767761,
-0.24117650091648102,
-0.5882227420806885,
-0.3563319444656372,
-0.1792300045490265,
0.4963262379169464,
0.3408867418766022,
-0.01437754463404417,
-0.10011818259954453,
-0.24068772792816162,
0.5954549908638,
-0.41355106234550476,
0.33100903034210205,
-0.1959674209356308,
0.37262508273124695,
-0.17412997782230377,
-0.17132782936096191,
-0.4171145558357239,
0.05767655000090599,
0.26067277789115906,
-0.564487099647522,
-0.15131469070911407,
0.21196237206459045,
0.6781041026115417,
-0.05586414411664009,
-0.673496425151825,
-0.1921759694814682,
-0.5226336717605591,
0.7881386280059814,
-0.427337646484375,
0.43195584416389465,
0.06930278241634369,
0.2010924369096756,
0.3567810654640198,
-0.40820372104644775,
-0.6842008233070374,
0.07186804711818695,
0.19530567526817322,
0.40444162487983704,
-0.5140135884284973,
-0.0897386446595192,
0.021113302558660507,
0.4117501676082611,
-0.8867586851119995,
0.11987168341875076,
-0.16514408588409424,
-0.01361717190593481,
0.7338366508483887,
0.08591853082180023,
0.4997882544994354,
-0.025127658620476723,
-0.4100014865398407,
-0.12165094166994095,
-0.6307701468467712,
0.16486690938472748,
0.3895547389984131,
0.1639012098312378,
-0.4248800575733185,
0.4318137466907501,
-0.24770835041999817,
0.10863933712244034,
0.011463357135653496,
0.4922235310077667,
0.4139741063117981,
-0.1964176595211029,
-0.3149798512458801,
0.01782696694135666,
0.9927026629447937,
0.340564101934433,
0.7996713519096375,
-0.11169268935918808,
-0.11539719253778458,
0.03448919206857681,
-0.1575121432542801,
-0.5334246158599854,
0.2374589592218399,
0.4086456298828125,
-0.33900341391563416,
-0.09473646432161331,
-0.21049635112285614,
-0.9015786647796631,
-0.24889390170574188,
-0.29700788855552673,
0.4853184223175049,
-0.5900886654853821,
-0.9583021402359009,
0.21460936963558197,
0.16257800161838531,
0.30027779936790466,
0.324795126914978,
-0.7426980137825012,
0.08615835756063461,
0.6672360897064209,
0.7664360404014587,
-0.42986220121383667,
-0.6120190024375916,
-0.3601095676422119,
-0.17742305994033813,
-0.44526976346969604,
0.8007978200912476,
-0.6617133617401123,
-0.33552348613739014,
0.1531088948249817,
0.011351251043379307,
-0.33471789956092834,
-0.47634243965148926,
0.32756277918815613,
-0.46180200576782227,
0.32821789383888245,
-0.30306339263916016,
-0.4792414903640747,
-0.3665352463722229,
0.45118916034698486,
-0.6156599521636963,
1.169846534729004,
0.22800800204277039,
-0.864291787147522,
0.14326313138008118,
-1.1278070211410522,
-0.5439547300338745,
0.006799865979701281,
0.30628669261932373,
0.16942009329795837,
0.2495359182357788,
0.012553714215755463,
0.49879971146583557,
-0.5286338329315186,
0.32459214329719543,
-0.4276047945022583,
-0.6018355488777161,
0.08712054044008255,
-0.276339054107666,
0.6081545948982239,
0.15575557947158813,
-0.6827059388160706,
0.36951881647109985,
-0.4062047600746155,
-0.034682292491197586,
0.2227707952260971,
-0.14670370519161224,
-0.23736432194709778,
-0.4723961651325226,
0.3534844219684601,
0.3893563449382782,
-0.02995603159070015,
-0.6284580230712891,
-0.06136450171470642,
-0.32507967948913574,
0.2606153190135956,
0.6537030339241028,
-0.31286561489105225,
0.374186635017395,
-0.06205024570226669,
0.7671070098876953,
0.2510511577129364,
-0.04235927760601044,
-0.217488095164299,
-0.29802417755126953,
-0.728905439376831,
-0.009512891061604023,
0.12056085467338562,
0.6025444865226746,
-1.0022207498550415,
-0.07180879265069962,
-0.314884752035141,
-0.5164771676063538,
-0.579008162021637,
-0.060118354856967926,
0.5351954102516174,
0.4777142405509949,
0.2357097566127777,
0.07125170528888702,
-0.16841760277748108,
-0.7824657559394836,
-0.42688894271850586,
-0.3942349851131439,
0.32355210185050964,
-0.004304549656808376,
0.6949217915534973,
-0.031217580661177635,
0.3607740104198456,
-0.0649469643831253,
0.11230494827032089,
-0.4251258671283722,
0.62210613489151,
-0.16943317651748657,
0.1812117099761963,
0.400028795003891,
-0.9571021795272827,
-0.8966323733329773,
0.3640504479408264,
-0.8300356268882751,
-0.23435571789741516,
0.19478483498096466,
-0.07881252467632294,
0.7267615795135498,
0.4313650131225586,
-0.3595484793186188,
0.3644478917121887,
0.3623201549053192,
-0.5172982215881348,
0.3413879871368408,
0.019543292000889778,
0.4997905194759369,
-1.0651919841766357,
-0.035049621015787125,
0.4107464849948883,
-0.2570776343345642,
-0.6787621974945068,
0.10951437801122665,
0.07491014897823334,
-0.079935222864151,
-0.8318607807159424,
0.7444980144500732,
-0.4558839201927185,
-0.14435335993766785,
-0.15351992845535278,
0.10107062757015228,
-0.026471048593521118,
0.7122645378112793,
0.4491431415081024,
0.45569321513175964,
0.7508034110069275,
-0.23454318940639496,
0.4105321168899536,
-0.14791731536388397,
-0.4737367033958435,
0.9900118112564087,
-0.5120795369148254,
0.13859140872955322,
-0.11674005538225174,
-0.16855232417583466,
-1.1712632179260254,
-0.18859219551086426,
0.09978741407394409,
-0.39093559980392456,
0.40796247124671936,
0.16627027094364166,
-0.5842841267585754,
-0.13556690514087677,
-0.4267100691795349,
0.45450523495674133,
0.18676388263702393,
-0.6892277598381042,
0.8873956203460693,
0.2701443135738373,
-0.3133606016635895,
-0.45021286606788635,
-0.7644354701042175,
0.10128793120384216,
-0.4709630608558655,
-1.0657035112380981,
0.20791290700435638,
-0.23031970858573914,
-0.3808271288871765,
0.0700969398021698,
0.0796828493475914,
0.054877929389476776,
0.08508899062871933,
0.19953671097755432,
0.0641595795750618,
-0.38683170080184937,
0.3461310863494873,
-0.0810142308473587,
-0.3080865144729614,
0.05589703470468521,
0.18711423873901367,
0.5765961408615112,
-0.5856093168258667,
-0.6085317134857178,
-0.43355002999305725,
0.7926557064056396,
0.9344230890274048,
-0.1590975970029831,
0.3795836865901947,
1.0399380922317505,
-0.5207552909851074,
-0.15843608975410461,
-0.31706854701042175,
0.21692124009132385,
-0.3875732123851776,
0.49331745505332947,
-0.6256192922592163,
-1.04306960105896,
0.7122265696525574,
-0.05385376140475273,
-0.1448703110218048,
0.27263349294662476,
0.8251882195472717,
-0.0815226137638092,
0.983511209487915,
0.6971353888511658,
-0.20787304639816284,
0.5752859115600586,
-0.07922517508268356,
0.4461658298969269,
-0.5910154581069946,
-0.22528579831123352,
-0.2214483618736267,
-0.5573315024375916,
-0.5808038711547852,
-0.33914437890052795,
0.5107123255729675,
-0.2919510304927826,
-0.1684495359659195,
-0.0562933050096035,
0.06059252843260765,
0.43137800693511963,
0.4920569956302643,
-0.0512642078101635,
0.10914582759141922,
-0.14592911303043365,
-0.15866151452064514,
0.102785624563694,
-0.47382044792175293,
-0.04462979733943939,
0.7600808143615723,
0.31272000074386597,
0.7413122057914734,
0.1891094446182251,
0.8156735301017761,
0.18002255260944366,
0.3947972059249878,
-0.9467570185661316,
0.37329381704330444,
0.0677022635936737,
-0.635399580001831,
-0.3518838882446289,
-0.21409064531326294,
-0.7076258063316345,
0.25273725390434265,
0.0835144892334938,
-1.1180846691131592,
0.200999453663826,
-0.08010116964578629,
-0.2274065911769867,
0.19234153628349304,
-0.9930597543716431,
1.1931442022323608,
-0.2874484658241272,
-0.6552101969718933,
-0.39876604080200195,
-0.43417754769325256,
0.5367382764816284,
-0.2715871036052704,
0.43027907609939575,
-0.020882312208414078,
0.17966172099113464,
0.6093564033508301,
-0.2194710522890091,
0.7500514388084412,
-0.15283769369125366,
-0.27202627062797546,
0.2739386260509491,
0.158900648355484,
0.31585171818733215,
-0.12449052929878235,
-0.37573081254959106,
0.1117020770907402,
0.050293803215026855,
-0.238012433052063,
-0.6008360385894775,
0.7684146165847778,
-0.5470313429832458,
-0.5411311388015747,
-0.33404088020324707,
-0.7755789756774902,
-0.20541056990623474,
-0.14169315993785858,
0.3268910050392151,
0.24496476352214813,
-0.2735890746116638,
0.20422205328941345,
0.5606300830841064,
-0.4349558651447296,
0.6100287437438965,
0.8363452553749084,
-0.274324506521225,
-0.0990220233798027,
1.0156822204589844,
0.04932500794529915,
0.316798597574234,
0.48445001244544983,
0.2685716152191162,
-0.33842191100120544,
-0.05092810094356537,
-0.32774221897125244,
0.08123143762350082,
-0.8077222108840942,
0.007385235745459795,
-0.5992523431777954,
0.28909921646118164,
-0.3685351014137268,
-0.0723620355129242,
-0.42530810832977295,
-0.1321002095937729,
0.039985500276088715,
-0.2580125629901886,
0.32110118865966797,
0.6964575052261353,
-0.48937687277793884,
0.33271312713623047,
-0.776538074016571,
0.34315216541290283,
0.10493533313274384,
0.4195597469806671,
0.08089956641197205,
-0.408357173204422,
-0.31339743733406067,
-0.08249450474977493,
0.11245334148406982,
-1.0859251022338867,
0.5327321290969849,
0.16474270820617676,
0.28505679965019226,
0.5402688384056091,
0.122384212911129,
0.6955071091651917,
-0.0845048576593399,
0.6890537142753601,
0.0037857620045542717,
-1.3917139768600464,
0.3538081645965576,
-0.20622633397579193,
0.4288100004196167,
0.3499331474304199,
0.6409844160079956,
-0.9540965557098389,
-0.15578974783420563,
-0.3917830288410187,
-0.9548479318618774,
1.0474083423614502,
-0.010519547387957573,
-0.06258249282836914,
0.060457032173871994,
-0.06578720360994339,
0.032489556819200516,
-0.12414784729480743,
-0.8636032938957214,
-0.14492318034172058,
0.10842762142419815,
-0.5731428265571594,
-0.10652410238981247,
-0.158616840839386,
0.04680929332971573,
-0.14796759188175201,
0.7673811912536621,
-0.32895129919052124,
0.33405783772468567,
0.1274663209915161,
-0.461736798286438,
-0.5056828856468201,
0.38252002000808716,
0.39788609743118286,
0.3902186155319214,
0.018637942150235176,
0.17003871500492096,
0.1346299648284912,
-0.0569247305393219,
0.02216215431690216,
0.15787144005298615,
0.19367024302482605,
-0.047132521867752075,
0.5379434823989868,
1.008599042892456,
0.3194773197174072,
-0.8215969204902649,
0.5694376230239868,
-0.23990602791309357,
-0.08683378249406815,
-0.19183269143104553,
-0.19804315268993378,
0.4638180136680603,
0.7003270983695984,
0.16402709484100342,
-0.5029645562171936,
0.28212791681289673,
-0.9619472026824951,
-0.05919059365987778,
0.37454476952552795,
-0.5881296992301941,
-0.6634334921836853,
0.20895063877105713,
0.10510270297527313,
-0.13925796747207642,
0.22855360805988312,
-0.31058090925216675,
-1.0059139728546143,
0.8455343246459961,
0.4388844966888428,
0.9684643149375916,
-0.497149795293808,
0.4140971601009369,
0.13250292837619781,
0.31566423177719116,
-0.07061418890953064,
0.9142686128616333,
-0.1006692498922348,
-0.8113825917243958,
-0.4412224292755127,
-0.24211525917053223,
-0.6262436509132385,
-0.011421781964600086,
-0.8173662424087524,
0.2948516309261322,
0.07945375144481659,
0.3066830039024353,
0.20968042314052582,
-0.02634579688310623,
-0.9025359153747559,
0.3050523102283478,
0.5737507939338684,
1.0214462280273438,
-1.2104334831237793,
0.7688552737236023,
0.9342839121818542,
-0.30597251653671265,
-0.9213470220565796,
0.06923791021108627,
0.37978801131248474,
-0.8730595111846924,
0.7426173686981201,
0.4697452485561371,
-0.16131162643432617,
-0.11110775172710419,
-0.32662200927734375,
-0.6247734427452087,
0.8398706912994385,
0.2783544361591339,
-0.5496276021003723,
0.16089804470539093,
0.17525459825992584,
0.7209869623184204,
-0.3856870234012604,
0.7442468404769897,
0.6751357316970825,
0.7798339128494263,
0.1423431783914566,
-0.9038694500923157,
-0.11606263369321823,
-0.7147341370582581,
-0.4646943211555481,
0.22077296674251556,
-0.8364828824996948,
0.665421724319458,
-0.18793947994709015,
-0.26979219913482666,
-0.41420701146125793,
0.4610995054244995,
0.021673979237675667,
0.7301267385482788,
0.6942223310470581,
0.5975404381752014,
0.7543724179267883,
-0.21502229571342468,
1.0744692087173462,
-0.39092251658439636,
0.24073465168476105,
1.0365889072418213,
-0.6784570813179016,
0.8324013948440552,
0.3883844316005707,
0.049011342227458954,
0.4119650721549988,
1.0479815006256104,
0.4647894501686096,
0.2690584659576416,
0.0861828401684761,
-0.3051292598247528,
-0.41324713826179504,
-0.21383170783519745,
-0.2029987871646881,
0.5674350261688232,
0.5052309036254883,
-0.04768076166510582,
-0.31596624851226807,
0.41219234466552734,
-0.0043436940759420395,
-0.36456099152565,
-0.23370619118213654,
0.6125503778457642,
0.09741712361574173,
-0.7710002660751343,
0.38225916028022766,
-0.1546822041273117,
0.7642995715141296,
-0.4571433663368225,
0.1561342179775238,
-0.3631272315979004,
0.07601930946111679,
-0.20468400418758392,
-0.988388180732727,
0.26331740617752075,
0.3005702793598175,
0.09021838754415512,
-0.2617506980895996,
0.6219449639320374,
-0.6975811123847961,
-0.3152395784854889,
0.8901791572570801,
0.6519335508346558,
0.437472403049469,
-0.34759658575057983,
-0.6119796633720398,
0.25450366735458374,
-0.02701466716825962,
-0.8070006370544434,
0.2474530041217804,
1.1458134651184082,
-0.2955281436443329,
0.6578816175460815,
0.1785859614610672,
-0.41038116812705994,
-0.08989814668893814,
0.3399173319339752,
0.7029361128807068,
-0.7669367790222168,
-0.3410031199455261,
-0.8503888249397278,
0.6457887291908264,
0.08342020958662033,
-0.3033871352672577,
0.13997501134872437,
0.3838886022567749,
0.8966882824897766,
0.007933388464152813,
0.7778230905532837,
-0.11345955729484558,
0.28618568181991577,
-0.37019985914230347,
0.35089725255966187,
-1.0067901611328125,
-0.07139124721288681,
-0.33291569352149963,
-0.7111908197402954,
-0.19952857494354248,
0.42186397314071655,
-0.30324578285217285,
-0.002597457729279995,
1.0523951053619385,
0.7140828967094421,
-0.08359985798597336,
0.2719838619232178,
0.5060673952102661,
0.2796493470668793,
0.14882591366767883,
1.0850818157196045,
0.9026346206665039,
-0.3162848949432373,
0.48727303743362427,
-0.235205739736557,
-0.1333739459514618,
-0.21966707706451416,
-0.8917520046234131,
-0.712716281414032,
-0.6325197815895081,
-0.6141948699951172,
-0.15422379970550537,
-0.1629568189382553,
1.0241528749465942,
0.5944921374320984,
-0.8449947237968445,
-0.18164080381393433,
0.2398512214422226,
0.29556164145469666,
0.012433147989213467,
-0.29419565200805664,
0.2648881673812866,
-0.15437045693397522,
-1.278557538986206,
0.46581605076789856,
0.4730950891971588,
-0.1624269336462021,
-0.16067977249622345,
-0.25042346119880676,
-0.4212369918823242,
-0.041567880660295486,
0.60652095079422,
0.2540944814682007,
-0.6087736487388611,
-0.35922786593437195,
0.17635861039161682,
0.03063672035932541,
0.1066315770149231,
0.5836213827133179,
-0.3467753231525421,
0.5607283115386963,
0.7687059640884399,
0.5879161357879639,
0.6324608325958252,
-0.32186758518218994,
0.7199091911315918,
-0.48451197147369385,
0.022138934582471848,
-0.031090108677744865,
0.8147006630897522,
0.573858916759491,
-0.3188086748123169,
0.7894684076309204,
0.09234699606895447,
-0.25122353434562683,
-0.7990671992301941,
0.17805007100105286,
-1.009494423866272,
-0.17672501504421234,
1.1030900478363037,
-0.583518922328949,
-0.39212939143180847,
0.024198181927204132,
-0.1052166223526001,
0.5507840514183044,
-0.44456785917282104,
0.6343628764152527,
0.9383094906806946,
-0.2133215367794037,
-0.5496874451637268,
-0.2955273985862732,
-0.0005206776550039649,
0.6527450680732727,
-1.1430480480194092,
0.02399490214884281,
0.2743305265903473,
0.3210754990577698,
0.3135479688644409,
0.5224327445030212,
-0.10819263756275177,
0.4027048647403717,
-0.31315430998802185,
0.3709297180175781,
0.16306687891483307,
-0.24889835715293884,
-0.6379700303077698,
0.2658943235874176,
-0.15875646471977234,
-0.021583475172519684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17116v1
|
Mixtures of Unsupervised Lexicon Classification
| 2024-05-27T12:33:47 | 2024-05-27T12:33:47 |
Peratham Wiriyathammabhum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a mixture version of the method-of-moment unsupervised
lexicon classification by an incorporation of a Dirichlet process.
|
[
-0.49860262870788574,
-0.40774643421173096,
0.2734161615371704,
0.3066514730453491,
-0.43372824788093567,
0.4734894335269928,
0.0985381156206131,
0.11348547041416168,
0.7410305738449097,
0.5970112681388855,
-0.26662126183509827,
-0.009570890106260777,
-0.37663090229034424,
-0.29536187648773193,
-0.5968226194381714,
0.728801965713501,
0.1311596930027008,
0.42298123240470886,
-0.3126401901245117,
-0.42520079016685486,
-0.18290454149246216,
-0.9207131266593933,
-0.19436299800872803,
-0.5846000909805298,
0.07529645413160324,
0.6328994035720825,
0.6736593842506409,
-0.007245262619107962,
0.2598620057106018,
0.39407601952552795,
-0.6769247055053711,
-0.17453435063362122,
0.23612675070762634,
0.03882666304707527,
-0.5706610083580017,
-0.5746820569038391,
-0.3031790256500244,
0.3702641725540161,
0.6385152339935303,
1.316718578338623,
-0.6526824235916138,
-0.39115381240844727,
0.22566188871860504,
0.34207049012184143,
-0.7232233881950378,
-0.3736077547073364,
-0.4881550669670105,
0.25397539138793945,
-0.26364272832870483,
-0.36045607924461365,
-0.19647380709648132,
0.2769009470939636,
0.05826406553387642,
0.2173362523317337,
0.48708033561706543,
0.05554816871881485,
-0.05545518174767494,
-0.184708833694458,
-0.3360062539577484,
0.01655738800764084,
-0.6493929624557495,
1.067180871963501,
-0.5175501704216003,
0.4518739581108093,
-0.0840236097574234,
0.15145210921764374,
-0.5164343118667603,
-0.6724032759666443,
-0.879707932472229,
-0.05764854699373245,
0.31044802069664,
0.30623137950897217,
0.24500399827957153,
0.052575185894966125,
-0.17288750410079956,
0.9827330112457275,
-0.11709369719028473,
0.2499256134033203,
-0.008453639224171638,
0.07433417439460754,
0.42564764618873596,
0.07782012969255447,
0.3029259145259857,
-0.5547407269477844,
-0.40128597617149353,
-0.195027157664299,
-0.41593098640441895,
-0.5144731402397156,
0.2729001045227051,
0.2675064504146576,
0.03905331343412399,
1.2027554512023926,
-0.41421255469322205,
0.2522173523902893,
0.10903529077768326,
-0.5299928188323975,
0.4065975248813629,
0.058753643184900284,
-0.3213692009449005,
0.5858603715896606,
0.46588364243507385,
0.3848801851272583,
-0.2218308299779892,
-0.2602003812789917,
-0.6914329528808594,
0.23824602365493774,
-0.07400726526975632,
-0.3925275206565857,
-0.4692690670490265,
0.25162044167518616,
-0.34831058979034424,
-0.4987717568874359,
0.40692436695098877,
-0.6968234777450562,
-0.3464229702949524,
-0.14008721709251404,
0.27059462666511536,
-0.10627911984920502,
-0.36870402097702026,
0.06930062174797058,
-0.7713772058486938,
-0.16739757359027863,
0.1794436126947403,
-0.6750379800796509,
0.49595779180526733,
0.501377522945404,
1.0663864612579346,
-0.2115490436553955,
-0.26687219738960266,
0.09819874167442322,
-0.1617121547460556,
-0.35412633419036865,
1.1635664701461792,
-0.4908222258090973,
-1.263002872467041,
0.13131673634052277,
-0.10541124641895294,
0.268192321062088,
-0.9398967027664185,
0.33199191093444824,
-0.28783389925956726,
0.2813038229942322,
0.03593611717224121,
-1.034480094909668,
-0.34437960386276245,
-0.12695449590682983,
-0.31156986951828003,
1.2643792629241943,
0.6072531938552856,
-1.130489706993103,
0.40950581431388855,
-0.678272008895874,
-0.16667605936527252,
0.3205031454563141,
-0.4359892010688782,
0.4278307557106018,
0.4159843325614929,
0.0022694303188472986,
0.6168963313102722,
0.09636560827493668,
0.02495976909995079,
-0.43009212613105774,
0.14918610453605652,
1.0167752504348755,
-0.40233078598976135,
1.0982911586761475,
0.6042388081550598,
0.055458568036556244,
0.11177898943424225,
-0.6997052431106567,
-0.2297898381948471,
0.08819488435983658,
0.014911319129168987,
-0.5101738572120667,
0.15591274201869965,
0.2755870521068573,
0.22246335446834564,
0.23064608871936798,
-0.49702703952789307,
0.1296629160642624,
-0.412759006023407,
-0.001145735033787787,
0.3398059904575348,
0.5456790328025818,
0.6617281436920166,
-0.4317455589771271,
0.20550252497196198,
0.8600070476531982,
-0.15539926290512085,
0.2570747435092926,
-0.4772791266441345,
-1.2121604681015015,
-0.42270419001579285,
0.4753166139125824,
0.6761544346809387,
-0.9295501708984375,
1.2619709968566895,
0.14482969045639038,
-0.6504369974136353,
0.2866085171699524,
0.07970356196165085,
-0.10520123690366745,
0.13306564092636108,
-0.03750837594270706,
-0.7384946942329407,
-0.1795823574066162,
-0.5224359631538391,
0.3749949038028717,
-0.24671563506126404,
-0.2857634723186493,
-0.14123068749904633,
0.4805740416049957,
-0.26065778732299805,
0.9309754967689514,
-0.9619405269622803,
0.12959428131580353,
-0.5131934881210327,
0.9593478441238403,
0.061106570065021515,
0.6796389222145081,
0.6887778639793396,
-0.32982131838798523,
-0.08272573351860046,
-0.275484174489975,
-0.46400484442710876,
-0.2043459713459015,
0.34781181812286377,
0.05455569177865982,
0.08075094223022461,
0.49114811420440674,
-0.04531458392739296,
0.4764556884765625,
0.023895449936389923,
-0.3382083475589752,
0.27604085206985474,
-0.5859874486923218,
0.29552310705184937,
-1.2377495765686035,
-0.5100175142288208,
0.2088719755411148,
-0.3495659828186035,
-0.43907856941223145,
0.007469470612704754,
-0.2549128532409668,
-0.12578995525836945,
-0.8506040573120117,
0.184913769364357,
-0.45204466581344604,
-0.3572084307670593,
-0.7508195042610168,
0.14756134152412415,
-0.45741480588912964,
0.1505662500858307,
0.206558495759964,
0.5014851093292236,
1.113410472869873,
-0.7846623659133911,
0.7443596124649048,
-0.15295575559139252,
-0.47594764828681946,
0.8300299048423767,
-0.11660224199295044,
-0.1662035882472992,
-0.5175734758377075,
-0.03477896749973297,
-0.972813069820404,
-0.19971808791160583,
0.38461777567863464,
0.017790693789720535,
0.4160655438899994,
0.2727799415588379,
-0.8404322862625122,
-0.18906180560588837,
-0.35471031069755554,
0.3616692125797272,
0.5023111701011658,
-0.516625702381134,
0.2138538956642151,
0.7033935785293579,
-0.11410234123468399,
-0.11131173372268677,
-0.6648886799812317,
-0.15219034254550934,
-0.48711785674095154,
-0.1063702180981636,
0.5679864287376404,
-0.027729477733373642,
-0.5663105845451355,
0.09601332247257233,
0.2010401040315628,
-0.49135246872901917,
-0.1454612910747528,
0.20174573361873627,
0.045583274215459824,
0.23054131865501404,
-0.027409791946411133,
0.36668336391448975,
0.047562748193740845,
-0.25548073649406433,
0.28003931045532227,
0.5469331741333008,
0.4001446068286896,
-0.4237746000289917,
-0.30420246720314026,
0.8820217847824097,
0.45804062485694885,
0.23533357679843903,
0.505057692527771,
0.35712119936943054,
-0.45244184136390686,
-0.47375762462615967,
-0.2700839340686798,
-0.24542982876300812,
-0.38288214802742004,
0.1288575381040573,
-0.006215129978954792,
-0.46585625410079956,
0.6580763459205627,
-0.4436158537864685,
-0.23967239260673523,
0.6188650131225586,
0.3203321695327759,
-0.48390281200408936,
0.7447328567504883,
0.5257448554039001,
-0.3797174096107483,
0.5926072597503662,
-0.28355932235717773,
0.1162894070148468,
-0.5903940200805664,
-0.1482347548007965,
-0.7426055669784546,
-0.42247629165649414,
-0.6685052514076233,
-0.6889540553092957,
0.41077396273612976,
0.5302368402481079,
0.2966456413269043,
-0.044615164399147034,
-0.4991581439971924,
0.4533088803291321,
0.5472654700279236,
0.24242442846298218,
0.07687778770923615,
-0.002626096596941352,
-0.46461784839630127,
-0.04464390128850937,
-0.9209355711936951,
-0.2828967273235321,
0.7641356587409973,
0.24926605820655823,
0.9049967527389526,
0.19571153819561005,
1.0174483060836792,
0.5063139200210571,
0.22313173115253448,
-0.9210612773895264,
0.8078823685646057,
-0.23570822179317474,
-0.8253300786018372,
0.043098196387290955,
-0.22652390599250793,
-0.7120668888092041,
0.2625502645969391,
-0.3681707978248596,
-1.0607191324234009,
0.3803693950176239,
-0.4668901264667511,
-0.3847348988056183,
0.3883492350578308,
-0.4956924021244049,
0.670151948928833,
-0.22289282083511353,
0.615705132484436,
-0.6243270635604858,
-0.19296440482139587,
0.23711660504341125,
-0.10654839128255844,
0.22257402539253235,
-0.10458120703697205,
-0.06001754477620125,
1.1960946321487427,
-0.6878148317337036,
0.7180900573730469,
-0.055569685995578766,
0.14485801756381989,
0.7213422060012817,
0.15847381949424744,
0.017330514267086983,
0.2565951347351074,
0.6142553091049194,
0.02991466596722603,
0.03548235446214676,
-0.3343847393989563,
-0.796160876750946,
0.9153205156326294,
-0.4291963279247284,
-0.3009839653968811,
-0.9927904009819031,
-0.3080780506134033,
-0.23097550868988037,
-0.2701515555381775,
0.4900912940502167,
0.8974436521530151,
-0.25079888105392456,
0.007438924629241228,
0.4841356873512268,
0.1372315138578415,
0.9104447960853577,
0.07583874464035034,
-0.5582951307296753,
-0.4496058523654938,
0.7482847571372986,
0.47696396708488464,
-0.17087382078170776,
0.32165777683258057,
0.4893285036087036,
-0.7082321047782898,
-0.7737099528312683,
-0.054321061819791794,
-0.13697147369384766,
-0.8432618975639343,
-0.012887298129498959,
-0.20559188723564148,
-0.4295315742492676,
-0.5047340393066406,
-0.2619336247444153,
-0.5278372168540955,
-0.7706227898597717,
-0.6387736201286316,
0.18354550004005432,
0.4543073773384094,
0.9452841877937317,
-0.3774562478065491,
0.9049979448318481,
-0.9960652589797974,
0.24993468821048737,
0.4742111265659332,
0.15052136778831482,
-0.1267058104276657,
-0.8025643229484558,
0.004030995070934296,
0.07360164076089859,
-0.28133147954940796,
-1.4240583181381226,
0.3030329942703247,
-0.18372054398059845,
0.9528322219848633,
0.724757730960846,
0.1027592122554779,
0.41493985056877136,
-0.17811058461666107,
1.1945953369140625,
0.6874068975448608,
-0.7832083702087402,
0.4262862205505371,
-0.2092456966638565,
-0.07747713476419449,
0.48447608947753906,
0.49097079038619995,
-0.3887486755847931,
-0.3286704421043396,
-1.203526496887207,
-0.7366961240768433,
0.1959848403930664,
-0.060925133526325226,
0.03797942399978638,
-0.46730008721351624,
0.17066925764083862,
-0.08408033847808838,
0.3164304196834564,
-0.20490175485610962,
-0.6393383145332336,
-0.24945390224456787,
-0.3322409391403198,
-0.10577617585659027,
-0.6304508447647095,
-0.15837760269641876,
-0.6630755662918091,
0.5746294856071472,
0.3614955544471741,
0.18306897580623627,
0.1801256388425827,
-0.21580831706523895,
0.23067395389080048,
0.2476947009563446,
0.3926541209220886,
0.6120961308479309,
-0.44012439250946045,
0.58213210105896,
0.18252885341644287,
-0.26248759031295776,
0.4605652391910553,
-0.1600954681634903,
0.11876479536294937,
0.27524399757385254,
0.08552920818328857,
0.23188947141170502,
0.5973936319351196,
-0.35787078738212585,
0.6154082417488098,
0.24939748644828796,
-0.07772421091794968,
-0.29186490178108215,
0.23926624655723572,
-0.1937788873910904,
0.5329599976539612,
0.22436261177062988,
-0.00716058723628521,
0.6538858413696289,
-0.8475058078765869,
0.4984753429889679,
0.014446523040533066,
-0.29591697454452515,
-0.1522764265537262,
-0.011709203012287617,
0.2516852617263794,
-0.13224682211875916,
0.3000409007072449,
-0.7824031114578247,
-0.596801221370697,
-0.2655807435512543,
0.5694774389266968,
0.9538983106613159,
-0.6326362490653992,
0.2851901650428772,
0.10526403039693832,
-0.43051978945732117,
-0.48399683833122253,
0.5618084073066711,
0.0019554297905415297,
-1.04783034324646,
-0.12104450166225433,
-0.5951056480407715,
-0.4006603956222534,
0.015560849569737911,
-0.3688596487045288,
0.09096888452768326,
-0.67485111951828,
-0.3375976085662842,
0.2826436460018158,
-0.27217453718185425,
-0.1314312368631363,
0.2525535821914673,
0.027128294110298157,
0.7506592869758606,
-1.0316423177719116,
0.858940064907074,
1.11592698097229,
-0.12790343165397644,
-0.3581215441226959,
0.0022332642693072557,
-0.014824925921857357,
-0.21142667531967163,
0.36553165316581726,
-0.39611876010894775,
-0.01210014522075653,
-0.32305440306663513,
-0.3313140571117401,
-0.5789431929588318,
0.6454585194587708,
-0.24334028363227844,
-0.08524952828884125,
0.6815651655197144,
-0.02142069675028324,
0.06173776462674141,
-0.2158241719007492,
0.016411399468779564,
0.4842948019504547,
-0.05117705091834068,
0.47788870334625244,
-0.6717241406440735,
-0.4151816964149475,
0.0252417903393507,
0.3408796191215515,
0.023761993274092674,
-0.15266935527324677,
0.8310680985450745,
0.19887802004814148,
-0.3673691153526306,
-0.37624332308769226,
1.273770809173584,
-0.09398605674505234,
0.08094555884599686,
0.8410889506340027,
0.9844643473625183,
0.8048787713050842,
0.031169315800070763,
0.5983067154884338,
-0.09596776217222214,
0.6594943404197693,
0.7876378297805786,
-0.09685421735048294,
0.8915033340454102,
0.6400792598724365,
-0.8156555891036987,
0.41562339663505554,
0.820871114730835,
0.570353627204895,
0.7119541764259338,
0.1567898690700531,
-1.1015182733535767,
-0.06842254102230072,
-0.41863319277763367,
-0.2535916566848755,
0.8632888793945312,
0.4207538068294525,
-0.15765081346035004,
-0.5873212218284607,
-0.016874399036169052,
-0.07896006852388382,
0.2716459631919861,
-0.4721466898918152,
0.8069046139717102,
0.08897113054990768,
-0.2708263695240021,
0.10330892354249954,
0.43598175048828125,
1.0111737251281738,
0.024513045325875282,
0.18291939795017242,
0.09072645753622055,
-0.08215360343456268,
-0.07875216007232666,
-1.277531623840332,
0.3717043995857239,
-0.22716978192329407,
-0.07457683235406876,
0.2933655083179474,
0.742295503616333,
-0.4261975884437561,
-0.8416268229484558,
-0.09745291620492935,
0.5733810663223267,
0.3414980471134186,
-0.060569360852241516,
-0.5046152472496033,
-0.4215543866157532,
-0.27827537059783936,
-0.03715933859348297,
0.43337056040763855,
0.6317207217216492,
0.11123624444007874,
0.3933742940425873,
0.2849290370941162,
0.046921201050281525,
0.1072494387626648,
0.38883572816848755,
0.6806740760803223,
-1.062669038772583,
-0.9437170028686523,
-0.6793696880340576,
0.45724114775657654,
-0.2003902643918991,
-0.30005761981010437,
0.6689153909683228,
0.3200353980064392,
0.6394367814064026,
-0.10241599380970001,
0.7516268491744995,
0.05928408354520798,
0.4865434467792511,
-0.2791195809841156,
0.3603964149951935,
-0.6299397945404053,
-0.19378362596035004,
-0.17850525677204132,
-0.8192152380943298,
-0.3223777115345001,
0.7371856570243835,
0.370155930519104,
0.1547466516494751,
0.9487069845199585,
0.45682594180107117,
-0.12800516188144684,
0.16489270329475403,
0.32088130712509155,
-0.40048709511756897,
-0.15091493725776672,
-0.3360144793987274,
1.0427812337875366,
0.22379674017429352,
-0.6323978900909424,
-0.9994484782218933,
-0.5962532162666321,
-0.3985205292701721,
-0.9467452764511108,
-0.7260701656341553,
-0.8791998028755188,
-0.6942114233970642,
-0.22041437029838562,
-0.6612729430198669,
1.0739854574203491,
0.4240131378173828,
-0.7260804772377014,
-0.5041802525520325,
-0.12090414762496948,
0.2731631100177765,
-0.059709787368774414,
-0.2540425956249237,
0.029849465936422348,
-0.29029643535614014,
-0.604657769203186,
0.33209770917892456,
0.39882519841194153,
0.7363572716712952,
-0.44080325961112976,
0.2323528230190277,
-0.16222430765628815,
0.2935132086277008,
0.48903465270996094,
-0.14059466123580933,
-0.43357139825820923,
-0.34870296716690063,
-0.5792734622955322,
0.09862647950649261,
0.14797602593898773,
0.8591433763504028,
-0.16470561921596527,
0.4119407534599304,
0.7837074398994446,
0.1338537484407425,
0.23661985993385315,
-0.29075852036476135,
-0.037074241787195206,
-1.1812719106674194,
0.7146883010864258,
0.26567548513412476,
1.0152451992034912,
0.36251550912857056,
-0.06357915699481964,
-0.014236902818083763,
0.8058224320411682,
-0.3850667178630829,
-0.5702160596847534,
0.11236110329627991,
-1.651448369026184,
-0.5655165910720825,
1.013797640800476,
0.4347570538520813,
-0.502575159072876,
-0.10105406492948532,
-0.3394434154033661,
0.6297109723091125,
-0.3261776268482208,
0.3789917528629303,
0.6478794813156128,
-0.2648155987262726,
0.029637325555086136,
-0.009740951471030712,
-0.09153041988611221,
0.08883374184370041,
-0.7130962014198303,
-0.22967880964279175,
0.453156441450119,
0.0902884379029274,
0.397760808467865,
0.6071022748947144,
-0.417181134223938,
-0.3116965591907501,
0.30448123812675476,
0.2390681803226471,
0.5224538445472717,
-0.5641528367996216,
-0.21307171881198883,
0.11550499498844147,
0.5521119236946106,
-0.3730679750442505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17104v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17104v2
|
LLM-Optic: Unveiling the Capabilities of Large Language Models for Universal Visual Grounding
| 2024-05-27T12:23:08 | 2024-05-28T02:17:56 |
Haoyu Zhao, Wenhang Ge, Ying-cong Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Visual grounding is an essential tool that links user-provided text queries
with query-specific regions within an image. Despite advancements in visual
grounding models, their ability to comprehend complex queries remains limited.
To overcome this limitation, we introduce LLM-Optic, an innovative method that
utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) as an optical lens to enhance existing
visual grounding models in comprehending complex text queries involving
intricate text structures, multiple objects, or object spatial relationships,
situations that current models struggle with. LLM-Optic first employs an LLM as
a Text Grounder to interpret complex text queries and accurately identify
objects the user intends to locate. Then a pre-trained visual grounding model
is used to generate candidate bounding boxes given the refined query by the
Text Grounder. After that, LLM-Optic annotates the candidate bounding boxes
with numerical marks to establish a connection between text and specific image
regions, thereby linking two distinct modalities. Finally, it employs a Large
Multimodal Model (LMM) as a Visual Grounder to select the marked candidate
objects that best correspond to the original text query. Through LLM-Optic, we
have achieved universal visual grounding, which allows for the detection of
arbitrary objects specified by arbitrary human language input. Importantly, our
method achieves this enhancement without requiring additional training or
fine-tuning. Extensive experiments across various challenging benchmarks
demonstrate that LLM-Optic achieves state-of-the-art zero-shot visual grounding
capabilities. Project Page: https://haoyu-zhao.github.io/LLM-Optic.github.io/.
|
[
-0.4215505123138428,
-0.9923785328865051,
0.9453224539756775,
0.2577335238456726,
-0.45472481846809387,
-0.2021862268447876,
-0.11155209690332413,
-0.5890930891036987,
-0.2458087056875229,
0.7459782361984253,
-0.4262247383594513,
-0.9685872793197632,
-0.5730145573616028,
0.034307051450014114,
-0.5321714282035828,
0.5303069949150085,
0.089691162109375,
0.23671235144138336,
-0.15388408303260803,
-0.211011603474617,
-0.5504666566848755,
-0.5487877726554871,
-0.3023022711277008,
-0.35824188590049744,
0.3058999478816986,
0.4732695519924164,
0.6575980186462402,
0.5363574028015137,
0.8997229337692261,
0.23195700347423553,
-0.24194718897342682,
0.36956045031547546,
-0.5754210948944092,
0.00888027437031269,
-0.24029195308685303,
-0.6295732259750366,
-0.4696691632270813,
-0.09276133030653,
0.6008968949317932,
0.6468430161476135,
0.09917023032903671,
-0.2027982473373413,
-0.15357321500778198,
0.7005501389503479,
-0.7575331330299377,
-0.12159185111522675,
-0.8677233457565308,
0.32318440079689026,
-0.021162040531635284,
-0.6168702840805054,
-0.453696608543396,
0.25172293186187744,
-0.0010610444005578756,
-0.8571743369102478,
0.1767210066318512,
0.2980599105358124,
0.9375195503234863,
0.3322000205516815,
-0.48176583647727966,
0.09518104046583176,
-0.6056339144706726,
0.5249683856964111,
-0.4244319498538971,
0.5973768830299377,
0.11673647165298462,
0.4342707097530365,
-0.012905021198093891,
-0.2496250867843628,
-0.45235317945480347,
-0.24266159534454346,
0.23126690089702606,
0.3852362334728241,
0.10007292032241821,
0.2923092842102051,
0.22648809850215912,
0.2411045879125595,
-0.4600014090538025,
-0.031840600073337555,
-0.18437351286411285,
0.28475940227508545,
0.26370105147361755,
0.14800631999969482,
0.5962663292884827,
-0.07800468057394028,
-0.447631299495697,
0.21746012568473816,
-0.9357839226722717,
-0.30915674567222595,
-0.21646177768707275,
0.05508261173963547,
0.06934675574302673,
1.018196702003479,
-0.6382296085357666,
0.9510380625724792,
0.1275613009929657,
-0.0886857658624649,
-0.1056840717792511,
-0.0948745533823967,
-0.3671087622642517,
0.021999036893248558,
0.6236829161643982,
0.9499506950378418,
0.400197833776474,
-0.3884328305721283,
-0.17061497271060944,
0.146384134888649,
0.0023922116961330175,
-0.702995240688324,
0.07726740837097168,
0.037412263453006744,
-0.2644365131855011,
-0.5257279872894287,
0.06897194683551788,
-0.7514001727104187,
-0.6720845699310303,
-0.3849804401397705,
0.44470828771591187,
-0.2051367163658142,
-0.014242347329854965,
0.5291104912757874,
-0.1837933361530304,
0.5468723773956299,
0.5361034870147705,
-0.8200728893280029,
0.0779980793595314,
0.5863937735557556,
0.787630021572113,
-0.13103115558624268,
-0.4353318214416504,
-0.48453935980796814,
0.4861568510532379,
-0.6409941911697388,
0.9843141436576843,
-0.6801177859306335,
-0.13925866782665253,
0.06903903186321259,
0.08036181330680847,
0.47746050357818604,
-0.556372344493866,
0.48911115527153015,
-0.6408789753913879,
0.047353386878967285,
-0.07480727881193161,
-0.2617294490337372,
-0.22094503045082092,
0.6204876899719238,
-0.1917746365070343,
0.895550549030304,
-0.2896660268306732,
-0.5463051795959473,
0.5440683364868164,
-0.3037591576576233,
-0.05555204674601555,
0.17902909219264984,
-0.49065205454826355,
-0.18806488811969757,
0.34716618061065674,
0.4379675090312958,
0.5737963914871216,
-0.5431176424026489,
0.3847464323043823,
-0.5057932138442993,
-0.5491170883178711,
-0.27325305342674255,
-0.378277450799942,
0.41153156757354736,
-0.23027881979942322,
-0.5474945306777954,
0.18354788422584534,
-0.9451467394828796,
-0.19961227476596832,
0.33972465991973877,
-0.28357312083244324,
-0.26502755284309387,
0.31715211272239685,
0.06725320219993591,
0.1406516283750534,
0.18495625257492065,
-0.5038738250732422,
0.2591761350631714,
-0.580281138420105,
0.1806800365447998,
0.5160233974456787,
-0.2658224105834961,
0.825585663318634,
0.279379278421402,
0.2651611268520355,
-0.004490345250815153,
0.0388907864689827,
-0.5819666981697083,
-0.5326606631278992,
-0.9364914298057556,
-0.028284326195716858,
-0.2754659950733185,
1.0304746627807617,
-0.5890335440635681,
0.3584502935409546,
-0.31791359186172485,
-0.3897503912448883,
-0.02509498782455921,
0.21629928052425385,
0.31046897172927856,
0.6256083846092224,
0.35670006275177,
0.1613042950630188,
-0.4750235080718994,
-0.8428003191947937,
0.0013174049090594053,
0.10394102334976196,
-0.18339918553829193,
0.5048787593841553,
0.3774701952934265,
-0.29622337222099304,
0.9324585199356079,
-0.6236667633056641,
-0.6861872673034668,
-0.025637080892920494,
-0.18849238753318787,
0.2565157115459442,
0.2309475541114807,
0.5235987901687622,
-0.9453309774398804,
-0.45085468888282776,
0.3368513882160187,
-1.480461835861206,
-0.34178972244262695,
0.04949666187167168,
-0.3244347870349884,
-0.024623408913612366,
0.7754026055335999,
-0.7419372797012329,
0.5624096989631653,
0.5446229577064514,
-0.6254421472549438,
0.4629329741001129,
-0.22134365141391754,
0.23108498752117157,
-0.8067010045051575,
-0.1726575642824173,
-0.015505775809288025,
-0.3958401381969452,
-0.5016344785690308,
0.480895459651947,
0.04923846200108528,
-0.604028582572937,
-0.4802401065826416,
0.5339210033416748,
-0.7644252181053162,
-0.14349143207073212,
-0.34632164239883423,
0.4937804341316223,
0.25300025939941406,
0.22671808302402496,
0.1532440483570099,
0.8530151844024658,
0.9351140856742859,
-0.37103962898254395,
0.463252454996109,
0.27341270446777344,
-0.17354945838451385,
0.7584511637687683,
-0.8961503505706787,
-0.12634535133838654,
-0.26708388328552246,
0.11426755040884018,
-1.135159969329834,
-0.1206248551607132,
0.21713125705718994,
-0.33602580428123474,
-0.055202800780534744,
-0.38622793555259705,
-0.5105770230293274,
-0.033381834626197815,
-0.18531209230422974,
0.45824968814849854,
0.3860141336917877,
-0.6851866245269775,
0.8676592707633972,
0.24098369479179382,
0.14481554925441742,
-0.4246840476989746,
-0.7623512744903564,
0.6406661868095398,
-0.20733851194381714,
-1.0557373762130737,
0.3380683362483978,
-0.09885584563016891,
-0.2712821662425995,
-0.19999757409095764,
-0.0752444639801979,
-0.16334912180900574,
0.051530659198760986,
0.2068563997745514,
0.3831785321235657,
-0.3946550786495209,
-0.06351453810930252,
-0.23585720360279083,
-0.48708072304725647,
-0.13217635452747345,
-0.42903825640678406,
0.48176810145378113,
-0.0880599394440651,
-0.5181877017021179,
-0.2359652817249298,
0.4255892038345337,
0.6882688999176025,
-0.4276512861251831,
0.5666408538818359,
0.4116404354572296,
-0.45226752758026123,
-0.11983755230903625,
-0.8391522765159607,
-0.023538030683994293,
-0.5112369060516357,
0.4458315372467041,
-0.40971457958221436,
-0.7954188585281372,
0.23322711884975433,
-0.18891245126724243,
-0.30183306336402893,
0.11699774861335754,
0.32571086287498474,
-0.02947448194026947,
1.4455320835113525,
0.9735277891159058,
0.06755160540342331,
0.45136433839797974,
-0.20481343567371368,
0.15103408694267273,
-0.7847955226898193,
-0.297163188457489,
-0.025483837351202965,
0.012485183775424957,
0.049001093953847885,
-0.5635625720024109,
0.45379751920700073,
0.6585996150970459,
-0.03395172953605652,
-0.2123705893754959,
-0.6626898050308228,
0.961558997631073,
0.34589001536369324,
0.21881544589996338,
0.4961094260215759,
0.42654991149902344,
-0.14664310216903687,
-0.08597177267074585,
-0.42215126752853394,
-0.49547770619392395,
1.0265337228775024,
0.12536196410655975,
0.8689311146736145,
-0.18526053428649902,
0.22456775605678558,
0.03994913399219513,
0.1344406008720398,
-0.8491162061691284,
0.7293569445610046,
-0.3169730603694916,
-0.5167341828346252,
-0.1402241438627243,
-0.16532248258590698,
-0.4906386435031891,
0.6529681086540222,
-0.633126974105835,
-0.6494574546813965,
0.06554364413022995,
0.1856144666671753,
-0.027940163388848305,
0.5352560877799988,
-0.5051110982894897,
0.7676229476928711,
-0.4965377748012543,
-0.5829984545707703,
0.09036901593208313,
-0.3722836971282959,
0.2309250831604004,
0.09114716202020645,
0.05774063989520073,
-0.3040075898170471,
-0.2811935544013977,
0.26151636242866516,
0.02741856873035431,
0.7673951983451843,
-0.09888242930173874,
-0.3783501088619232,
-0.004698861390352249,
0.15515819191932678,
0.3871498703956604,
0.22145216166973114,
0.0686178132891655,
0.43804633617401123,
-0.6196115612983704,
-0.24946430325508118,
-0.47725731134414673,
0.5561285018920898,
-0.36872586607933044,
-0.734896183013916,
-0.3201889097690582,
-0.4893141984939575,
-0.19250698387622833,
0.7016626000404358,
0.35397931933403015,
0.4939509332180023,
-0.14785563945770264,
0.4794131815433502,
0.8892415761947632,
-0.3224616050720215,
0.1327378749847412,
0.6903039813041687,
-0.6173683404922485,
-0.5020360946655273,
0.7479909062385559,
-0.1349087655544281,
0.04745885357260704,
0.7432228922843933,
-0.0011262405896559358,
-0.05176064744591713,
-0.8751882314682007,
-0.5222012400627136,
0.2486395239830017,
-0.7314286231994629,
-0.2735099494457245,
-0.5486727356910706,
0.03895939514040947,
-0.20667460560798645,
-0.7359484434127808,
-0.16534695029258728,
0.058912213891744614,
-0.33330005407333374,
-0.28837424516677856,
0.0943881943821907,
0.5968955159187317,
0.15022723376750946,
0.49499279260635376,
-0.5581478476524353,
0.8920760154724121,
0.36006784439086914,
0.5134887099266052,
-0.41989296674728394,
-0.26696082949638367,
0.14212098717689514,
0.04982741177082062,
-0.1869240403175354,
-0.8229288458824158,
0.3964971899986267,
0.2808084785938263,
0.2971159517765045,
0.5553694367408752,
-0.3614690899848938,
0.7544476389884949,
-1.0812464952468872,
0.7395190596580505,
0.4117768704891205,
-0.8602501749992371,
0.8245265483856201,
-0.7456996440887451,
0.2500668168067932,
0.3121069371700287,
-0.054214563220739365,
-0.4366016685962677,
-0.3279370963573456,
0.1614762395620346,
-1.0723215341567993,
0.5733471512794495,
-0.0025396926794201136,
0.006261119619011879,
0.006334239151328802,
0.4929167926311493,
-0.39237719774246216,
-0.085083968937397,
-0.940948486328125,
-0.15437327325344086,
-0.007453678175806999,
-0.13439378142356873,
-0.2848372161388397,
-0.6107377409934998,
-0.26793724298477173,
-0.11506209522485733,
0.2412126064300537,
-0.21392187476158142,
0.09734633564949036,
0.5522052049636841,
-0.35853689908981323,
-0.06846652179956436,
0.021064968779683113,
0.5965840220451355,
0.7790801525115967,
-0.3986746370792389,
0.15879201889038086,
0.29005083441734314,
-0.22105088829994202,
0.17706073820590973,
-0.02726140432059765,
-0.5604060292243958,
0.028315911069512367,
0.2422117441892624,
0.6548727750778198,
0.3772401213645935,
-0.8252558708190918,
0.7152274250984192,
0.09456883370876312,
-0.3416963517665863,
-0.3960039019584656,
-0.19401803612709045,
-0.07022038847208023,
0.28294384479522705,
0.6497058272361755,
0.0201891977339983,
0.29269298911094666,
-0.2950102388858795,
0.27330300211906433,
0.5737849473953247,
-0.4686785042285919,
-0.07186166942119598,
1.1332309246063232,
0.2740689516067505,
-0.1581205129623413,
0.21870091557502747,
0.14650660753250122,
-0.5716596841812134,
0.5315185189247131,
0.7718188762664795,
0.6810327172279358,
0.16802814602851868,
0.14995154738426208,
0.04803967475891113,
0.4095724821090698,
-0.2083340436220169,
0.20511458814144135,
0.09989870339632034,
-0.7512272596359253,
-0.3407619893550873,
-0.43419668078422546,
-0.2852667272090912,
-0.25477689504623413,
-0.24137426912784576,
0.5281217098236084,
-0.5837988257408142,
0.2048548012971878,
-0.23773092031478882,
-0.3663122355937958,
-0.45765450596809387,
0.5035987496376038,
0.4915020763874054,
0.95285964012146,
-0.652672290802002,
0.3843573033809662,
0.8426908254623413,
-0.2974393963813782,
-0.2081643044948578,
-0.24868540465831757,
0.18521277606487274,
-1.1687307357788086,
0.93802410364151,
0.39152130484580994,
-0.48035624623298645,
0.08983396738767624,
-0.8247159719467163,
-0.6842806339263916,
1.2046102285385132,
0.48227694630622864,
-0.46667662262916565,
-0.19814802706241608,
0.38087064027786255,
0.27027150988578796,
-0.3918714225292206,
0.23711055517196655,
0.09330254048109055,
0.3571220934391022,
0.04649883136153221,
-0.48766669631004333,
-0.05349752679467201,
-0.1457197517156601,
-0.012582401745021343,
0.16663740575313568,
-0.5425108075141907,
0.6038448214530945,
-0.02034757472574711,
-0.18947109580039978,
0.03834023326635361,
0.36631542444229126,
0.3953888714313507,
0.4059148132801056,
0.33722394704818726,
0.9783817529678345,
0.39655163884162903,
-0.2673651874065399,
0.9228717088699341,
-0.49742695689201355,
0.3092592656612396,
0.7999764084815979,
-0.40557536482810974,
0.9450809359550476,
0.36098042130470276,
0.32201993465423584,
-0.007260702550411224,
0.08362969756126404,
-0.15753985941410065,
0.4828108847141266,
-0.07294471561908722,
-0.2804444432258606,
-0.5398960709571838,
-0.19239003956317902,
-0.452457457780838,
0.41322705149650574,
0.2034519612789154,
-0.1449873298406601,
-0.4121305048465729,
0.10504036396741867,
-0.19493895769119263,
0.09820874780416489,
-0.4694133698940277,
0.7385009527206421,
0.07065005600452423,
-0.1912258416414261,
0.6458568572998047,
0.013574863784015179,
1.079554557800293,
-0.653588593006134,
-0.25632140040397644,
-0.23530831933021545,
0.23364827036857605,
-0.24028804898262024,
-0.8197498917579651,
-0.0004287240153644234,
0.05644060671329498,
-0.32483264803886414,
-0.2608204185962677,
0.9248372316360474,
-0.4313128590583801,
-0.7428326606750488,
0.6779152750968933,
0.20110072195529938,
0.008810901083052158,
-0.5401394963264465,
-0.45313122868537903,
0.1281777024269104,
-0.09436725080013275,
-0.03887733817100525,
0.07951458543539047,
0.8338712453842163,
0.2789129614830017,
0.9089564681053162,
0.8024631142616272,
0.15154080092906952,
0.18875537812709808,
0.05298592522740364,
0.6970687508583069,
-0.9416523575782776,
-0.23700964450836182,
-0.9028438925743103,
0.6015751361846924,
-0.09340189397335052,
-0.24869897961616516,
0.7793727517127991,
0.5995223522186279,
0.6164513826370239,
-0.18094059824943542,
0.37292295694351196,
0.38448354601860046,
0.05339041352272034,
-0.8012809753417969,
0.7276931405067444,
-1.027753233909607,
0.24210225045681,
-0.227882981300354,
-1.2709026336669922,
-0.9073486328125,
0.6982475519180298,
-0.2160482108592987,
-0.32350853085517883,
0.5068491101264954,
0.761456310749054,
-0.4146343171596527,
-0.6369783282279968,
0.8874391913414001,
0.27016350626945496,
0.4671478569507599,
0.4182451665401459,
0.8708040118217468,
-0.4682028293609619,
0.8045335412025452,
-0.042110808193683624,
-0.4167450964450836,
-0.19133040308952332,
-0.9775810241699219,
-1.0842275619506836,
0.07063741981983185,
0.09515790641307831,
0.05108674243092537,
0.215379998087883,
0.3569106161594391,
1.0361807346343994,
-0.6189569234848022,
-0.15867747366428375,
-0.5315232276916504,
-0.023349519819021225,
0.4500141143798828,
-0.2243715524673462,
0.014419098384678364,
-0.21332621574401855,
-0.5790531039237976,
0.5567652583122253,
0.771723210811615,
0.08407551795244217,
-0.10316728800535202,
0.08450213074684143,
-0.1880221962928772,
-0.06940469890832901,
0.9781445860862732,
0.0916709452867508,
-0.9263694286346436,
-0.1477086991071701,
0.23001286387443542,
-0.0099166389554739,
0.24761240184307098,
0.46048033237457275,
-0.6906306147575378,
0.3918500542640686,
0.3842228949069977,
0.6549195647239685,
0.25278085470199585,
0.1567874252796173,
0.6355152130126953,
-0.5551629662513733,
0.5876590609550476,
0.029878204688429832,
0.6076533794403076,
0.3678022027015686,
-0.426896333694458,
0.6979222297668457,
0.3215309679508209,
-0.5810428261756897,
-0.7449105381965637,
0.31999218463897705,
-1.1660122871398926,
-0.29145780205726624,
1.1823742389678955,
0.19025862216949463,
-0.18678437173366547,
0.15748324990272522,
-0.802509605884552,
-0.23827335238456726,
-0.19054050743579865,
0.5912424921989441,
0.5661460161209106,
0.3309454023838043,
-0.46223753690719604,
-0.5632284879684448,
0.017834758386015892,
0.5660058259963989,
-0.7435795664787292,
-0.044575922191143036,
0.7649524211883545,
0.25100940465927124,
0.18708957731723785,
0.5808661580085754,
-0.07818376272916794,
0.26675090193748474,
-0.03752060607075691,
0.1464950144290924,
-0.1074926033616066,
-0.6352051496505737,
-0.3724628984928131,
0.34633344411849976,
-0.087591752409935,
-0.041205596178770065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17103v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17103v2
|
Empowering Character-level Text Infilling by Eliminating Sub-Tokens
| 2024-05-27T12:21:48 | 2024-06-14T09:26:41 |
Houxing Ren, Mingjie Zhan, Zhongyuan Wu, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In infilling tasks, sub-tokens, representing instances where a complete token
is segmented into two parts, often emerge at the boundaries of prefixes,
middles, and suffixes. Traditional methods focused on training models at the
token level, leading to sub-optimal performance in character-level infilling
tasks during the inference stage. Alternately, some approaches considered
character-level infilling, but they relied on predicting sub-tokens in
inference, yet this strategy diminished ability in character-level infilling
tasks due to the large perplexity of the model on sub-tokens. In this paper, we
introduce FIM-SE, which stands for Fill-In-the-Middle with both Starting and
Ending character constraints. The proposed method addresses character-level
infilling tasks by utilizing a line-level format to avoid predicting any
sub-token in inference. In addition, we incorporate two special tokens to
signify the rest of the incomplete lines, thereby enhancing generation
guidance. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our proposed approach
surpasses previous methods, offering a significant advantage. Code is available
at https://github.com/SenseLLM/FIM-SE.
|
[
-0.47095832228660583,
-0.8280433416366577,
0.5439110398292542,
0.06930606812238693,
-0.46748074889183044,
0.2863789498806,
0.11440865695476532,
-0.21505852043628693,
0.14225593209266663,
0.6279750466346741,
-0.9792437553405762,
-0.31206783652305603,
-0.35619184374809265,
0.40458303689956665,
-0.14846864342689514,
1.0353970527648926,
0.012827764265239239,
-0.05464760586619377,
-0.718773603439331,
0.22777627408504486,
-0.6859567761421204,
-0.7599571347236633,
-0.9142627120018005,
-0.5426777601242065,
0.5517245531082153,
1.0353062152862549,
0.4732345640659332,
0.6985309720039368,
0.4285646378993988,
0.23178383708000183,
-0.3836917579174042,
0.6229851245880127,
-0.5495733618736267,
0.3970526158809662,
-0.06792664527893066,
-0.46364182233810425,
-0.2580488622188568,
-0.03487108647823334,
0.5065637826919556,
0.7695562839508057,
0.2815825343132019,
-0.1562558114528656,
-0.029043741524219513,
0.6308243870735168,
-0.4419696629047394,
-0.17632830142974854,
-0.5307526588439941,
0.006151460576802492,
-0.5246681571006775,
-0.3695269823074341,
-0.4619640111923218,
0.0029738275334239006,
-0.008002085611224174,
-0.6800476312637329,
0.3618105351924896,
0.45773136615753174,
1.0611348152160645,
0.2785835862159729,
-0.3015363812446594,
-0.24984827637672424,
-0.5016624927520752,
0.5242710113525391,
-0.7749196887016296,
0.16979888081550598,
0.647213876247406,
-0.0827823355793953,
-0.4318845272064209,
-0.5086024403572083,
-0.6809326410293579,
0.18780480325222015,
-0.24731123447418213,
0.16924266517162323,
0.04684912785887718,
0.44187504053115845,
0.5464993119239807,
0.264487624168396,
-0.2646939754486084,
0.06927153468132019,
-0.28009048104286194,
-0.0540325827896595,
0.4153535068035126,
0.06806430965662003,
0.6013181209564209,
-0.08675140887498856,
-0.6465469598770142,
0.13499484956264496,
-0.9159117341041565,
-0.014418557286262512,
0.5800377130508423,
0.3158738911151886,
0.16535325348377228,
0.7831043601036072,
-0.023943111300468445,
0.15098917484283447,
0.2915192246437073,
-0.14087752997875214,
0.10410784184932709,
-0.3482511341571808,
-0.39396393299102783,
-0.06559086591005325,
0.3888446092605591,
0.269679993391037,
0.4084729552268982,
-0.15036088228225708,
-0.3179059326648712,
-0.27224647998809814,
-0.04469351842999458,
-0.9161818027496338,
0.24417328834533691,
0.07502061873674393,
-0.39598384499549866,
0.1441257745027542,
0.04552091285586357,
-0.6855932474136353,
-0.777367353439331,
-0.17227007448673248,
0.39831051230430603,
-0.795081615447998,
-0.01274962816387415,
-0.01736808754503727,
-0.5546725392341614,
0.11200165748596191,
0.2568664252758026,
-0.982012152671814,
0.15345317125320435,
0.6181479692459106,
0.7834761738777161,
0.21910952031612396,
-0.08146331459283829,
-0.894874632358551,
0.3276366889476776,
-0.19616399705410004,
0.6992491483688354,
-0.7836179137229919,
-0.5650694966316223,
-0.24079176783561707,
-0.09153975546360016,
-0.09352778643369675,
-0.35279491543769836,
0.6464488506317139,
-0.16942869126796722,
0.3266342580318451,
-0.2124205231666565,
-0.9623512625694275,
-0.11050732433795929,
-0.11717631667852402,
-0.5450776815414429,
1.1551766395568848,
0.23552103340625763,
-0.6471746563911438,
0.5141386389732361,
-0.39264100790023804,
-0.49125009775161743,
0.17546959221363068,
-0.17227371037006378,
-0.4482189118862152,
0.27475425601005554,
0.5091807246208191,
0.48479583859443665,
-0.33690592646598816,
-0.0420614629983902,
-0.15747413039207458,
-0.5478137731552124,
-0.014726227149367332,
-0.1140897274017334,
0.43941575288772583,
0.20868869125843048,
-0.03887652978301048,
0.026402616873383522,
-0.4864344298839569,
-0.2832217514514923,
-0.21415726840496063,
0.04235144704580307,
-0.5404012799263,
-0.02845042012631893,
-0.09812235832214355,
0.1184924766421318,
0.06957544386386871,
-0.7988816499710083,
0.13233068585395813,
-0.5988714098930359,
0.44785913825035095,
0.5497565865516663,
0.26690202951431274,
0.6273639798164368,
-0.5726362466812134,
0.8056291937828064,
0.05759876221418381,
-0.11459693312644958,
-0.8519209623336792,
-0.4226177930831909,
-0.9757848381996155,
-0.7288260459899902,
0.46051326394081116,
0.4268881678581238,
-0.895759642124176,
0.4841046929359436,
0.036793600767850876,
-0.6055833101272583,
-0.13631856441497803,
-0.08747337013483047,
0.4807298183441162,
0.6070426106452942,
0.3950902223587036,
0.028976621106266975,
-0.5196920037269592,
-0.6637058258056641,
-0.4826987087726593,
-0.14626747369766235,
0.0571487620472908,
0.014480208978056908,
0.3113587498664856,
-0.0032291340176016092,
1.1511584520339966,
-0.2730812728404999,
-0.3834046721458435,
-0.4990439713001251,
0.07540218532085419,
-0.04510389268398285,
0.9536987543106079,
0.3257245421409607,
-0.7462323307991028,
-0.7002173066139221,
-0.05825817212462425,
-0.2865442633628845,
-0.5144025683403015,
-0.7008441686630249,
-0.3466537296772003,
0.028814734891057014,
1.0495542287826538,
-0.3314438462257385,
0.7073822617530823,
-0.06859461963176727,
-0.9325208067893982,
-0.05935100466012955,
-0.26550254225730896,
-0.00145663321018219,
-1.0446274280548096,
-0.05199006199836731,
-0.006089486181735992,
-0.36157068610191345,
-0.7550873160362244,
0.005974884610623121,
0.13405846059322357,
-0.1863502562046051,
-0.09224088490009308,
0.828045129776001,
-0.6432057619094849,
0.368564248085022,
-0.09573376178741455,
-0.11476388573646545,
0.3796980679035187,
0.6498396396636963,
-0.14983990788459778,
0.6586291790008545,
-0.002494731219485402,
0.00020676443818956614,
-0.3867835998535156,
0.3292558491230011,
-0.009586133062839508,
0.4080617427825928,
-0.5234429240226746,
0.17853416502475739,
-0.4828369617462158,
0.049564212560653687,
-1.2631577253341675,
-0.13808567821979523,
0.19380781054496765,
-0.4051803648471832,
0.5884737372398376,
-0.37594735622406006,
-0.571982204914093,
0.026891348883509636,
-0.0781429186463356,
0.6048906445503235,
0.5319815278053284,
-0.3030073940753937,
0.6603823304176331,
0.2824113667011261,
-0.4437742829322815,
-0.1379748284816742,
-0.7988343238830566,
0.11244519054889679,
-0.5358186364173889,
-0.712275505065918,
0.6251675486564636,
-0.11139695346355438,
0.15154339373111725,
-0.2812833786010742,
-0.26409590244293213,
-0.2203182727098465,
0.09471011161804199,
0.3071053624153137,
0.26433756947517395,
0.0047478810884058475,
0.05793808028101921,
0.6435624361038208,
-0.24241752922534943,
-0.3594633936882019,
0.04291069880127907,
0.43814364075660706,
0.31689387559890747,
-0.4462517499923706,
-0.4100227653980255,
0.8747096657752991,
0.7090606093406677,
-0.3655712306499481,
0.5024879574775696,
0.20614472031593323,
-0.6711682677268982,
-0.2474442422389984,
-0.6051132678985596,
-0.009409288875758648,
-0.43505892157554626,
0.17809581756591797,
-0.5571392178535461,
-1.0393407344818115,
0.5905089974403381,
-0.13340026140213013,
0.12901318073272705,
0.46309420466423035,
0.07544805854558945,
-0.1759169101715088,
1.1242973804473877,
0.8180035352706909,
0.5431790947914124,
0.8399287462234497,
-0.021146077662706375,
0.318540096282959,
-0.6256842613220215,
-0.4617890417575836,
-0.701934814453125,
-0.2494450807571411,
-0.14308734238147736,
-0.4493141174316406,
0.3194648027420044,
0.7249976992607117,
-0.19830365478992462,
0.33170798420906067,
-0.21662817895412445,
0.8319175839424133,
0.45573729276657104,
0.14983433485031128,
0.1425546258687973,
0.25140127539634705,
-0.4743151366710663,
-0.24966838955879211,
-0.8481944799423218,
-0.44048091769218445,
0.6051294803619385,
0.5426011681556702,
0.5835187435150146,
-0.10096091777086258,
0.8344233632087708,
0.3133015036582947,
-0.037664301693439484,
-0.6463160514831543,
0.3098243176937103,
-0.4336758852005005,
-0.28654101490974426,
-0.48240137100219727,
-0.265607625246048,
-0.515373170375824,
0.16015201807022095,
-0.36556941270828247,
-0.6889955997467041,
0.544270932674408,
-0.09745178371667862,
-0.651279628276825,
0.2779228687286377,
-0.9446179270744324,
0.5870298743247986,
0.22846613824367523,
-0.1651415377855301,
-0.05570470914244652,
-0.5213761925697327,
-0.03132757917046547,
-0.2585296034812927,
0.07726678252220154,
-0.2496275007724762,
-0.27902087569236755,
0.5558475852012634,
-1.0695492029190063,
0.8267716765403748,
-0.1671907752752304,
0.02985159493982792,
0.3605027496814728,
-0.04108098894357681,
0.648408055305481,
-0.10523156076669693,
-0.24724134802818298,
-0.06018761917948723,
0.0335778184235096,
-0.48277732729911804,
-0.4911760687828064,
0.1404923051595688,
-0.36262834072113037,
-0.20788708329200745,
-0.34838342666625977,
-0.49997034668922424,
-0.2981575131416321,
0.37136387825012207,
0.4333047568798065,
0.7795072793960571,
0.0012792027555406094,
0.23053255677223206,
0.7514315247535706,
-0.15839849412441254,
0.5194737911224365,
-0.025157809257507324,
-0.06508877873420715,
-0.6711825728416443,
0.8372951745986938,
0.14538878202438354,
0.26114046573638916,
0.47587427496910095,
0.25966185331344604,
-0.3877372741699219,
-0.4884188175201416,
-0.6058961153030396,
0.17734646797180176,
-0.5797760486602783,
-0.37491658329963684,
-0.5994346141815186,
-0.3928636312484741,
-0.13621267676353455,
-0.5761170387268066,
0.208017960190773,
-0.44350817799568176,
-0.5095698833465576,
0.03682960569858551,
0.19555453956127167,
0.5136441588401794,
0.1954510658979416,
0.71876060962677,
-0.8230469226837158,
0.1647464781999588,
-0.08166122436523438,
0.15988120436668396,
-0.10425801575183868,
-0.4053311347961426,
-0.5391010642051697,
0.025323616340756416,
-0.03140828013420105,
-0.6903650164604187,
0.2978880703449249,
0.38317760825157166,
0.41437116265296936,
0.38748008012771606,
0.02859221212565899,
1.0306109189987183,
-0.3877403438091278,
0.756248950958252,
0.42705756425857544,
-1.1113184690475464,
0.20561280846595764,
-0.33585119247436523,
0.3129941523075104,
0.6769964694976807,
0.08874097466468811,
-0.8847899436950684,
-0.7022143602371216,
-0.5501094460487366,
-0.9173789620399475,
0.6697899699211121,
0.4498746395111084,
0.07089289277791977,
-0.17162033915519714,
0.5361284017562866,
0.43009886145591736,
0.1088489443063736,
-0.16613362729549408,
0.16343027353286743,
-0.024120669811964035,
-0.4887182414531708,
0.2571708858013153,
-0.4692789912223816,
0.2984655499458313,
-0.19072552025318146,
0.7307733297348022,
-0.2698366343975067,
0.02148684486746788,
0.4903225600719452,
-0.12016920745372772,
-0.08870752155780792,
0.057759132236242294,
0.5049778819084167,
0.41378143429756165,
0.15921320021152496,
-0.045598894357681274,
0.0686885267496109,
-0.5425907969474792,
0.003183290595188737,
0.12195654213428497,
-0.425689697265625,
0.03953171521425247,
0.5225692987442017,
0.6666206121444702,
0.01233086921274662,
-0.6861011981964111,
0.4204033613204956,
-0.09092453122138977,
-0.2502026855945587,
-0.022942014038562775,
0.16792641580104828,
-0.23959913849830627,
0.25500163435935974,
0.5409426093101501,
0.01088925264775753,
-0.2846304774284363,
-0.2834967374801636,
0.09817769378423691,
0.17760968208312988,
-0.5906600952148438,
0.088945671916008,
0.6549735069274902,
0.3551274538040161,
-0.26287832856178284,
0.5448208451271057,
-0.03924882784485817,
-0.4967219829559326,
0.9015642404556274,
0.7452696561813354,
1.0521043539047241,
0.32653284072875977,
0.014547685161232948,
0.3894979953765869,
0.2823113799095154,
0.2197435200214386,
0.6029230952262878,
0.04301142320036888,
-0.505275547504425,
-0.3764055669307709,
-0.6763455271720886,
-0.12597374618053436,
-0.10067937523126602,
-0.2389306128025055,
0.4186519980430603,
-0.5372451543807983,
-0.10555347055196762,
-0.11537139862775803,
0.046940356492996216,
-0.4057833254337311,
0.27338290214538574,
0.1474662572145462,
1.210224986076355,
-0.6827583312988281,
0.5234754085540771,
0.6339298486709595,
-0.6432203054428101,
-0.5411415100097656,
0.19277769327163696,
-0.20032723248004913,
-0.3705328404903412,
0.15002672374248505,
0.3732772469520569,
-0.011059673503041267,
0.26527684926986694,
-0.5027258992195129,
-0.8989600539207458,
1.055403232574463,
0.3631783723831177,
-0.42019298672676086,
-0.4435529410839081,
0.22122442722320557,
0.2271621823310852,
-0.5982291102409363,
0.4170668125152588,
0.3709907531738281,
0.39966219663619995,
0.16171494126319885,
-0.4650048017501831,
0.17686249315738678,
-0.4105016887187958,
0.18087396025657654,
0.36435794830322266,
-0.6956493854522705,
0.8806559443473816,
-0.007930847816169262,
-0.5975951552391052,
0.5942006707191467,
0.8525415658950806,
0.08753688633441925,
0.24128921329975128,
0.9971734881401062,
0.4451223611831665,
0.933897852897644,
-0.16754519939422607,
0.4000982344150543,
-0.18412093818187714,
0.0016470137052237988,
1.1020960807800293,
-0.06387709081172943,
0.3667350709438324,
0.8043575286865234,
0.3719647228717804,
0.5297442078590393,
0.9023017883300781,
0.10742788016796112,
0.4055826663970947,
0.3074224293231964,
-0.20090648531913757,
-0.5560460686683655,
-0.4283800721168518,
-0.15000168979167938,
0.35683807730674744,
0.511971116065979,
-0.27455899119377136,
-0.3135581612586975,
-0.020490283146500587,
0.2678714990615845,
0.19745074212551117,
-0.217818021774292,
0.8404163718223572,
0.035405877977609634,
-0.6604138016700745,
0.1354856938123703,
0.12241458892822266,
0.4990689754486084,
-0.7007877230644226,
-0.3626560568809509,
-0.7027186155319214,
-0.24825315177440643,
-0.27464818954467773,
-0.5248126983642578,
0.21849603950977325,
0.20806758105754852,
-0.38728851079940796,
-0.6512678861618042,
0.817750096321106,
-0.7813924551010132,
-0.34964147210121155,
-0.06817541271448135,
0.507317841053009,
0.1633041948080063,
-0.0824759379029274,
-0.15957319736480713,
-0.40496310591697693,
0.0671774223446846,
-0.07251747697591782,
0.059235136955976486,
1.0432487726211548,
-0.3006824553012848,
0.4636039137840271,
0.7419400215148926,
-0.16639919579029083,
-0.07565940916538239,
0.09902262687683105,
0.7469980120658875,
-0.6140853762626648,
-0.7872328758239746,
-0.9181103706359863,
0.757647693157196,
-0.19298331439495087,
-0.6201651096343994,
0.6318597197532654,
0.7128130197525024,
0.7730990648269653,
0.2944083511829376,
0.7492960691452026,
-0.1357845515012741,
0.4371757209300995,
-0.6574509143829346,
0.810491681098938,
-0.8165730237960815,
0.053714144974946976,
-0.37492305040359497,
-0.649531364440918,
-0.1783033162355423,
0.15444156527519226,
0.28477048873901367,
-0.09763041138648987,
0.7479337453842163,
0.7900292277336121,
-0.057429391890764236,
0.0879846140742302,
0.4352857768535614,
-0.24767714738845825,
0.2652243971824646,
0.4584953188896179,
0.8480854034423828,
-0.14587955176830292,
0.3145011365413666,
-0.22116519510746002,
-0.287116676568985,
-0.19153016805648804,
-0.9712271690368652,
-1.20375657081604,
-0.6277106404304504,
-0.051552340388298035,
-0.23497866094112396,
-0.316864013671875,
1.0275942087173462,
0.6107925176620483,
-0.49682310223579407,
0.0028280876576900482,
-0.28002995252609253,
0.28593719005584717,
-0.10458450764417648,
-0.10973432660102844,
0.10549093037843704,
-0.5534899234771729,
-0.8907275795936584,
0.5493252873420715,
0.14175736904144287,
0.28320974111557007,
-0.15117035806179047,
-0.010449065826833248,
-0.3163383901119232,
0.4802103340625763,
0.3614303171634674,
0.09428595751523972,
-0.4373473823070526,
-0.28907033801078796,
0.09046380966901779,
-0.2067258208990097,
-0.06945178657770157,
1.103379487991333,
-0.699641227722168,
0.5773844718933105,
0.9146969318389893,
0.7705248594284058,
0.4005224108695984,
0.15567854046821594,
0.919526219367981,
-1.0732823610305786,
0.11101295799016953,
0.17278501391410828,
0.5216077566146851,
0.2747977077960968,
-0.714006245136261,
0.6547155380249023,
0.4087076187133789,
-0.2838584780693054,
-0.8751611709594727,
0.1762830764055252,
-0.5891680717468262,
-0.2933212220668793,
0.9789252281188965,
-0.12072477489709854,
-0.15115250647068024,
-0.1306442767381668,
-0.5868179202079773,
0.6179581880569458,
-0.4148462414741516,
0.14426089823246002,
0.8650689721107483,
-0.0006324626156128943,
0.13946504890918732,
-0.048562537878751755,
0.5994985103607178,
0.6953747272491455,
-0.6241732239723206,
0.06538021564483643,
0.4066298305988312,
-0.2279210388660431,
-0.16416765749454498,
0.7107220888137817,
0.088905930519104,
0.029058000072836876,
0.10663632303476334,
0.01060478389263153,
-0.3769829273223877,
-0.5130782723426819,
-0.29164478182792664,
0.11201698333024979,
-0.3124813437461853,
-0.11339541524648666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17088v1
|
Phase Transitions in the Output Distribution of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-27T12:04:36 | 2024-05-27T12:04:36 |
Julian Arnold, Flemming Holtorf, Frank Schäfer, Niels Lörch
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In a physical system, changing parameters such as temperature can induce a
phase transition: an abrupt change from one state of matter to another.
Analogous phenomena have recently been observed in large language models.
Typically, the task of identifying phase transitions requires human analysis
and some prior understanding of the system to narrow down which low-dimensional
properties to monitor and analyze. Statistical methods for the automated
detection of phase transitions from data have recently been proposed within the
physics community. These methods are largely system agnostic and, as shown
here, can be adapted to study the behavior of large language models. In
particular, we quantify distributional changes in the generated output via
statistical distances, which can be efficiently estimated with access to the
probability distribution over next-tokens. This versatile approach is capable
of discovering new phases of behavior and unexplored transitions -- an ability
that is particularly exciting in light of the rapid development of language
models and their emergent capabilities.
|
[
-0.2674059569835663,
-0.9728279113769531,
0.9371293783187866,
-0.02781691402196884,
-0.1088251993060112,
-0.2012152075767517,
0.00597887858748436,
-0.25782862305641174,
0.026788407936692238,
0.34684640169143677,
-0.507489800453186,
-0.3374387323856354,
-0.6664294600486755,
-0.05833812803030014,
-1.153926134109497,
0.7093347311019897,
-0.03795761242508888,
-0.186009019613266,
0.2209620475769043,
0.3832959532737732,
-0.36178410053253174,
-0.5291220545768738,
-0.7398825287818909,
-0.7809197902679443,
0.13951289653778076,
0.23362983763217926,
0.6994772553443909,
0.39411991834640503,
0.31838178634643555,
0.44804927706718445,
0.006611642427742481,
-0.25228115916252136,
-0.2950153648853302,
0.6224274635314941,
-0.14471112191677094,
-0.6299917101860046,
-0.03993499279022217,
-0.276172399520874,
0.9939284324645996,
1.1206092834472656,
-0.07426677644252777,
0.10457246750593185,
0.17218337953090668,
0.6832762956619263,
-0.39555326104164124,
0.502780020236969,
-0.5931794047355652,
0.3588266372680664,
-0.49332189559936523,
-0.4313022792339325,
-0.5905817747116089,
-0.25566092133522034,
0.17833034694194794,
-0.47084540128707886,
0.606157660484314,
-0.06650733947753906,
0.5292012095451355,
-0.13753123581409454,
-0.60576331615448,
-0.14723967015743256,
-1.2933017015457153,
0.789068341255188,
-0.487310528755188,
0.8475318551063538,
0.21557053923606873,
0.23468591272830963,
-0.5200926661491394,
-0.5058509707450867,
-0.766185998916626,
-0.286821186542511,
0.20599277317523956,
-0.2277558296918869,
-0.054070841521024704,
0.06937864422798157,
-0.02145444042980671,
0.11695785820484161,
-0.2606153190135956,
-0.15186364948749542,
-0.17744340002536774,
0.004257503431290388,
0.40828701853752136,
0.46952542662620544,
0.5052238702774048,
-0.40749260783195496,
0.5424016118049622,
-0.5295950174331665,
-0.3459860682487488,
-0.23748593032360077,
0.6346622705459595,
0.536087691783905,
-0.17212015390396118,
0.6426424980163574,
-0.17900580167770386,
0.37443235516548157,
0.2156575322151184,
-0.06369447708129883,
0.08546040952205658,
-0.3217782974243164,
-0.09539882093667984,
0.0017627213383093476,
0.6793880462646484,
-0.019008908420801163,
0.03197985142469406,
0.16384029388427734,
-0.15762469172477722,
-0.3917597234249115,
-0.30254828929901123,
-0.5273367166519165,
-0.7722580432891846,
0.14259056746959686,
-0.49543148279190063,
-0.15805533528327942,
-0.011950071901082993,
-0.7146065831184387,
-0.9171432852745056,
-0.2686157524585724,
0.3214547336101532,
-0.40454259514808655,
-0.665233850479126,
0.17024558782577515,
-0.3360770344734192,
-0.05578015744686127,
0.3990533649921417,
-1.1754001379013062,
0.5112172365188599,
0.590019702911377,
1.0006012916564941,
0.032356277108192444,
-0.3481929898262024,
-0.059092216193675995,
0.054171159863471985,
-0.7262598872184753,
0.730830729007721,
-0.6807378530502319,
-0.47603675723075867,
0.13751569390296936,
0.06058593466877937,
0.05853070318698883,
-0.5605255365371704,
-0.15962931513786316,
-0.42306381464004517,
-0.01416171807795763,
-0.14444783329963684,
-0.4635952115058899,
0.006993930786848068,
-0.13481667637825012,
-0.6236296892166138,
0.9935809969902039,
-0.13143819570541382,
-0.7127605676651001,
0.4565891623497009,
-0.6383548378944397,
-0.35718247294425964,
0.001558877993375063,
0.1904924511909485,
-0.08529531210660934,
0.29495900869369507,
-0.3917262554168701,
0.6305750012397766,
-0.36003783345222473,
0.05693390220403671,
-0.40148094296455383,
0.11317123472690582,
0.6699315905570984,
-0.4221596121788025,
0.41828441619873047,
0.25653982162475586,
-0.2067924290895462,
0.06732263416051865,
-0.9046108722686768,
-0.04805785045027733,
0.18905417621135712,
-0.14018188416957855,
-0.4930189251899719,
0.72207111120224,
-0.10720323026180267,
-0.14859160780906677,
0.2819342315196991,
-0.1546867936849594,
0.032462228089571,
-0.2549259066581726,
0.3772653341293335,
0.7378576397895813,
0.34824007749557495,
0.8105171322822571,
0.22992978990077972,
0.33610549569129944,
0.42601513862609863,
0.17916350066661835,
-0.16005125641822815,
-0.6073458194732666,
-0.8083698749542236,
0.11830462515354156,
0.1657753735780716,
0.5783469080924988,
-0.6337679624557495,
0.6413115859031677,
0.060841940343379974,
-0.2904825210571289,
-0.03621647506952286,
0.14062581956386566,
-0.10400889068841934,
0.2775893211364746,
-0.06868553906679153,
-0.0300737377256155,
-0.31248587369918823,
-0.6392037272453308,
-0.0036598490551114082,
-0.5249298214912415,
-0.2493218034505844,
-0.42470040917396545,
0.5813117623329163,
-0.17974257469177246,
0.7460770606994629,
-0.9149738550186157,
0.5155714750289917,
-0.24150721728801727,
0.3952505886554718,
0.3006551265716553,
0.48295819759368896,
-0.185736283659935,
-0.5463483333587646,
-0.2977624535560608,
0.35367870330810547,
-0.6580313444137573,
-0.16563531756401062,
0.0916517898440361,
-0.2002350091934204,
0.14675158262252808,
0.8111444115638733,
-0.11692643910646439,
0.21478980779647827,
0.6294834017753601,
-0.4552115797996521,
0.5923899412155151,
-0.484647274017334,
0.46808940172195435,
-1.1432230472564697,
-0.07709500193595886,
0.3475927412509918,
-0.08756595849990845,
-1.133670687675476,
-0.15740080177783966,
-0.11842148005962372,
-0.03958291560411453,
-0.32106032967567444,
0.4560445249080658,
-0.48520421981811523,
-0.3569287657737732,
-0.25749558210372925,
-0.020573219284415245,
-0.2365240752696991,
-0.15255087614059448,
0.1297316700220108,
0.27209094166755676,
0.5255363583564758,
-0.7544644474983215,
0.35797199606895447,
0.09885995835065842,
-0.28672316670417786,
0.48889052867889404,
-0.5222315788269043,
0.02064448595046997,
-0.3490231931209564,
0.37369686365127563,
-1.0786805152893066,
-0.35263994336128235,
0.42999279499053955,
-0.20693600177764893,
0.09462425857782364,
-0.4078475832939148,
-0.9326909184455872,
-0.05604768544435501,
-0.005689113400876522,
0.5939839482307434,
0.44187480211257935,
-0.014911515638232231,
0.11410074681043625,
0.37834373116493225,
-0.4357265532016754,
0.03217437118291855,
-0.5597442388534546,
-0.11519882082939148,
-0.20669765770435333,
-0.5913918614387512,
-0.4966946542263031,
-0.2503073811531067,
-0.5986005663871765,
-0.1247698962688446,
0.41055336594581604,
-0.4146002531051636,
-0.024763403460383415,
0.2684870660305023,
0.12544527649879456,
-0.052771713584661484,
0.226707324385643,
0.46947574615478516,
0.06602854281663895,
0.25343838334083557,
-0.2388458251953125,
1.1107630729675293,
0.12146835774183273,
-0.313432902097702,
-0.388009250164032,
0.42264407873153687,
0.5497793555259705,
0.08888065069913864,
0.8264789581298828,
0.20453351736068726,
-0.5931429862976074,
-0.24282078444957733,
-0.10837674140930176,
-0.3307114541530609,
-0.5081669688224792,
0.5672104358673096,
-0.4535071849822998,
-0.32793787121772766,
1.0569387674331665,
0.15480701625347137,
-0.2744108736515045,
0.4425075352191925,
0.5597829818725586,
0.23241811990737915,
1.3236099481582642,
0.592277467250824,
0.5291532278060913,
0.807328462600708,
0.004820369184017181,
0.4217510223388672,
-0.49454212188720703,
-0.4219056963920593,
-0.6549214124679565,
0.047526903450489044,
-0.6267842650413513,
-0.5576706528663635,
0.7318292856216431,
-0.08335813879966736,
-0.3910203278064728,
-0.012065370567142963,
-0.23634734749794006,
0.592768132686615,
0.30652913451194763,
0.11748702824115753,
0.1198803186416626,
-0.18653979897499084,
0.19312188029289246,
-0.0035918985959142447,
-0.3640885353088379,
0.013682521879673004,
0.9253712296485901,
0.5356540679931641,
0.880476176738739,
0.10410259664058685,
0.8381286263465881,
0.45827817916870117,
-0.06130456551909447,
-0.6721916198730469,
0.6373287439346313,
-0.13512681424617767,
-0.4258959889411926,
-0.7245986461639404,
-0.4874674379825592,
-1.0738868713378906,
0.09352555871009827,
-0.2866474390029907,
-0.8650541305541992,
0.341861367225647,
0.1479465365409851,
-0.016428165137767792,
0.34557148814201355,
-0.8684067130088806,
0.6150935292243958,
0.24029654264450073,
0.10519697517156601,
-0.19473057985305786,
-0.39743703603744507,
0.5588991045951843,
-0.3724460005760193,
0.29611337184906006,
-0.3757811188697815,
0.05628222972154617,
0.8536784052848816,
-0.3107962906360626,
0.7500568628311157,
-0.12095091491937637,
-0.3905445635318756,
0.11204233765602112,
0.597202479839325,
0.3371281921863556,
-0.23853245377540588,
-0.14073383808135986,
0.0776762068271637,
0.24980752170085907,
-0.43287986516952515,
-0.3688170909881592,
0.729063093662262,
-0.7173296213150024,
-0.3501768410205841,
-0.4693765342235565,
-0.8262255191802979,
-0.24987083673477173,
0.23169443011283875,
0.3663794994354248,
0.3510793447494507,
-0.07947959005832672,
-0.17459000647068024,
0.7588683366775513,
-0.4355327785015106,
0.33218351006507874,
0.5232923030853271,
-0.3940197825431824,
-0.0021673080045729876,
0.8113076090812683,
0.30555757880210876,
0.48386088013648987,
0.3159090578556061,
0.5008321404457092,
-0.5101138353347778,
-0.6873384714126587,
-0.13259829580783844,
0.29184749722480774,
-0.931225061416626,
0.22518490254878998,
-0.36858266592025757,
-0.2264271378517151,
-0.7228124141693115,
-0.24049679934978485,
-0.2295217514038086,
-0.3029153048992157,
-0.3064090609550476,
0.042176105082035065,
0.20230142772197723,
1.2414571046829224,
-0.23665527999401093,
0.24328412115573883,
-0.8386846780776978,
0.12537230551242828,
0.22497011721134186,
0.1514081060886383,
0.08077243715524673,
-0.8170472979545593,
-0.22757408022880554,
-0.01231219433248043,
-0.09894989430904388,
-1.3183634281158447,
0.5582963824272156,
0.30015677213668823,
0.3058335483074188,
0.5171699523925781,
0.02614157646894455,
0.4764929711818695,
-0.6759827136993408,
0.8461058735847473,
0.5140597820281982,
-1.3656115531921387,
0.5093268156051636,
-0.6977319717407227,
0.6227108240127563,
0.1313042789697647,
0.23368556797504425,
-0.8020235300064087,
-0.6443238258361816,
-0.4926770329475403,
-0.8713908791542053,
0.6057724356651306,
-0.0014519264223054051,
0.15472108125686646,
-0.14708898961544037,
0.378368079662323,
0.2596990764141083,
0.22598621249198914,
-0.36140623688697815,
-0.3207908272743225,
0.013473563827574253,
-0.10757150501012802,
-0.2804807424545288,
-0.012287650257349014,
-0.0740564689040184,
-0.32364463806152344,
0.38965514302253723,
-0.22233399748802185,
0.30233603715896606,
-0.1516083925962448,
0.06685946136713028,
-0.4400680661201477,
0.2640378475189209,
0.5517961382865906,
0.8515682816505432,
-0.1701185554265976,
0.38008350133895874,
0.25549355149269104,
-0.3550052046775818,
0.3976721167564392,
0.09805808216333389,
-0.1904563009738922,
0.0434550903737545,
0.062239449471235275,
0.5812317728996277,
0.38686689734458923,
-0.39575403928756714,
0.13894891738891602,
0.05874153599143028,
-0.2731698751449585,
-0.45903894305229187,
-0.11632820963859558,
-0.13405472040176392,
0.4113454222679138,
0.5782071948051453,
-0.1586853265762329,
0.5355305671691895,
-1.0126322507858276,
0.20801371335983276,
0.28040656447410583,
-0.19125641882419586,
-0.7659401893615723,
0.518566906452179,
0.10087339580059052,
-0.175024151802063,
0.4238992929458618,
-0.22336043417453766,
-0.3801523447036743,
0.5422399640083313,
0.5869764089584351,
0.8985349535942078,
-0.5565827488899231,
0.7328125834465027,
0.04116666689515114,
0.2712518572807312,
-0.5329782962799072,
0.06556244194507599,
0.2924036383628845,
-0.8099120855331421,
-0.3439311683177948,
-0.6066939830780029,
-0.455258309841156,
-0.05493231862783432,
-0.5355207920074463,
0.3051242530345917,
-0.5802900195121765,
0.007009779568761587,
0.26562488079071045,
-0.2404240220785141,
-0.43257296085357666,
0.13370870053768158,
0.5076695680618286,
0.27961158752441406,
-1.4841846227645874,
0.7029444575309753,
0.41476190090179443,
0.11245016008615494,
-0.5179358124732971,
0.18989239633083344,
0.20729461312294006,
-0.632579505443573,
0.7947638034820557,
-0.37004274129867554,
-0.09587274491786957,
-0.30770549178123474,
-0.3892073631286621,
-0.9787800908088684,
0.6791573762893677,
0.599248468875885,
-0.39524683356285095,
-0.03359951078891754,
0.4700523912906647,
0.7046760320663452,
0.05208713561296463,
0.2942013442516327,
0.7440937161445618,
0.5157450437545776,
0.02221059985458851,
-0.8721494078636169,
0.03276479244232178,
0.10361279547214508,
-0.015354208648204803,
1.1536767482757568,
-0.37718167901039124,
1.1997952461242676,
0.04490619897842407,
-0.34763142466545105,
-0.08560777455568314,
0.7958534955978394,
0.09459596127271652,
0.521021842956543,
0.7851355075836182,
0.09364902228116989,
0.7912650108337402,
-0.09809628874063492,
0.7366732954978943,
-0.435781329870224,
0.5454807281494141,
0.4529384672641754,
-0.3031895160675049,
1.0249611139297485,
0.25227484107017517,
-0.3278222978115082,
0.49262523651123047,
0.437741756439209,
0.41149818897247314,
0.12728363275527954,
0.4309667646884918,
-0.4326891601085663,
-0.29207926988601685,
0.0898401066660881,
-0.25203028321266174,
0.034666940569877625,
0.5123790502548218,
-0.1988193243741989,
-0.12401077896356583,
0.0404960922896862,
0.19493933022022247,
-0.2039487659931183,
-0.24290817975997925,
0.5299568772315979,
0.03684316948056221,
-0.3575068712234497,
0.5297815799713135,
-0.19243809580802917,
0.26250800490379333,
-0.7957496643066406,
-0.1896234005689621,
-0.11462149769067764,
0.06899736076593399,
-0.21932469308376312,
-0.9861191511154175,
0.14610479772090912,
-0.15513959527015686,
-0.2969558537006378,
-0.1655755639076233,
0.4618406295776367,
-0.5375017523765564,
-0.6717433929443359,
0.1169995367527008,
0.2668420076370239,
0.41339462995529175,
0.09374091029167175,
-0.4855136275291443,
0.23724429309368134,
-0.17661792039871216,
-0.20818951725959778,
0.4909346103668213,
0.6007859110832214,
-0.13331404328346252,
0.6611586213111877,
0.538123607635498,
0.11210131645202637,
0.5859499573707581,
-0.04975984990596771,
0.3976597189903259,
-0.683232307434082,
-0.5532438158988953,
-0.5336658358573914,
0.15116018056869507,
0.05586474388837814,
-0.2308845967054367,
0.6255600452423096,
0.35842883586883545,
0.4279622435569763,
-0.07513811439275742,
0.9918760061264038,
-0.26178282499313354,
0.34498924016952515,
-0.6989066004753113,
0.49912160634994507,
-0.4215095341205597,
0.05053797364234924,
-0.3193669617176056,
-0.9712294340133667,
-0.08107134699821472,
0.09344426542520523,
-0.33257025480270386,
-0.14478245377540588,
1.1424431800842285,
0.6394336223602295,
-0.061672940850257874,
-0.2406463474035263,
0.6811326146125793,
0.4809892475605011,
0.6583359241485596,
0.15357442200183868,
0.6775175929069519,
-0.18807122111320496,
0.42570456862449646,
-0.2619641125202179,
-0.328692227602005,
-0.12856043875217438,
-0.8305176496505737,
-0.4591749608516693,
-1.3851616382598877,
-0.5459098219871521,
-0.6134397983551025,
0.19561408460140228,
0.7474799752235413,
0.7710660696029663,
-1.0231859683990479,
-0.5682986974716187,
-0.13667301833629608,
-0.15456083416938782,
-0.03354301676154137,
-0.27417564392089844,
0.08249078691005707,
-0.18498924374580383,
-0.9321019649505615,
0.34854191541671753,
0.10720605403184891,
0.18014240264892578,
-0.6548193097114563,
0.10142791271209717,
0.08681556582450867,
0.6365236043930054,
0.6233787536621094,
0.6142287254333496,
-0.38733795285224915,
-0.5334093570709229,
-0.27234378457069397,
0.21029061079025269,
-0.2704523801803589,
0.8554329872131348,
0.004898095969110727,
0.36555758118629456,
1.1738011837005615,
0.17918099462985992,
0.3859277367591858,
-0.30737489461898804,
0.7734386920928955,
-0.535291314125061,
0.2815146744251251,
-0.16748735308647156,
0.3406691551208496,
0.221618190407753,
-0.2003517597913742,
-0.08922697603702545,
0.29759588837623596,
-0.8083468675613403,
-0.9928755760192871,
0.5175959467887878,
-0.8941841125488281,
-0.30025172233581543,
1.3253660202026367,
0.3178993761539459,
-0.3620559275150299,
-0.2319841980934143,
0.04529717192053795,
0.1954740434885025,
-0.6498510837554932,
0.9547936916351318,
0.8799071311950684,
-0.4412529766559601,
-0.1659308671951294,
-0.8112648725509644,
0.32040587067604065,
0.29271963238716125,
-1.0272420644760132,
0.18761050701141357,
0.49832218885421753,
0.4313858151435852,
0.22698333859443665,
0.44807904958724976,
0.10981865227222443,
-0.04448390752077103,
0.05362413078546524,
0.017049415037035942,
0.8278023600578308,
-0.32314014434814453,
-0.36212918162345886,
0.2882043719291687,
0.29154348373413086,
-0.10284877568483353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17076v1
|
Leveraging small language models for Text2SPARQL tasks to improve the resilience of AI assistance
| 2024-05-27T11:47:21 | 2024-05-27T11:47:21 |
Felix Brei, Johannes Frey, Lars-Peter Meyer
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In this work we will show that language models with less than one billion
parameters can be used to translate natural language to SPARQL queries after
fine-tuning. Using three different datasets ranging from academic to real
world, we identify prerequisites that the training data must fulfill in order
for the training to be successful. The goal is to empower users of semantic web
technology to use AI assistance with affordable commodity hardware, making them
more resilient against external factors.
|
[
-0.45482707023620605,
-0.9593071937561035,
0.37451237440109253,
-0.2145453542470932,
-0.00065815937705338,
-0.3550897538661957,
-0.2834075093269348,
-0.6484860181808472,
-0.48882994055747986,
0.8007873296737671,
-0.7126513719558716,
-0.11756608635187149,
-0.5185364484786987,
0.3276901841163635,
-0.43427127599716187,
1.1973180770874023,
0.2505192756652832,
0.13710780441761017,
-0.2299928516149521,
-0.11520184576511383,
-0.7442350387573242,
-0.17510418593883514,
-1.0884419679641724,
-0.07906518131494522,
0.32983872294425964,
0.8062192797660828,
1.1556832790374756,
0.33861032128334045,
0.7397269606590271,
0.2676626443862915,
0.2259998768568039,
0.22287683188915253,
-0.5505833029747009,
-0.01230577938258648,
-0.33774033188819885,
-0.598482072353363,
-0.09354909509420395,
-0.11327168345451355,
0.6112656593322754,
0.762397825717926,
-0.24448925256729126,
0.21609805524349213,
0.22453728318214417,
0.792007565498352,
-0.21602243185043335,
0.08126211911439896,
-0.8873823285102844,
-0.039138175547122955,
-0.1204901859164238,
0.3703943192958832,
-0.4684392213821411,
-0.23765483498573303,
0.13295771181583405,
-0.6694388389587402,
0.2793814539909363,
0.5317303538322449,
0.5630061626434326,
0.5965732336044312,
-0.19932138919830322,
-0.20248575508594513,
-0.7463680505752563,
0.8798182606697083,
-0.6738778948783875,
0.4027968943119049,
0.9355465769767761,
0.5509792566299438,
-0.40686362981796265,
-0.739737868309021,
-0.6708493232727051,
-0.29003456234931946,
-0.3622024655342102,
-0.24505150318145752,
-0.15358561277389526,
-0.02832987904548645,
0.3185277283191681,
-0.08319088816642761,
-0.6170480847358704,
0.3017180562019348,
-0.35498669743537903,
-0.04185408726334572,
0.6607084274291992,
0.48950281739234924,
0.5393602252006531,
0.03646337240934372,
0.046736493706703186,
-0.09995733201503754,
-0.6485852003097534,
-0.23575469851493835,
0.014977280981838703,
0.7640106678009033,
0.04718073830008507,
0.6391791105270386,
-0.28739240765571594,
0.9417376518249512,
-0.327323317527771,
-0.05562804266810417,
-0.31735697388648987,
-0.5990007519721985,
-0.17622815072536469,
-0.030709493905305862,
0.737801194190979,
0.09212733060121536,
0.41279250383377075,
-0.5864492654800415,
-0.13489067554473877,
-0.1083843782544136,
0.5820976495742798,
-0.6856417059898376,
-0.12488729506731033,
0.15841145813465118,
-0.4571366608142853,
0.042541176080703735,
-0.1465173363685608,
-0.7941899299621582,
-0.5413891673088074,
-0.28598272800445557,
0.39985790848731995,
-0.6609107255935669,
-0.2263984978199005,
0.1504523903131485,
-0.23483918607234955,
0.08164937049150467,
0.17232048511505127,
-1.1124690771102905,
0.7803288698196411,
0.8540077209472656,
0.8176482915878296,
0.06565194576978683,
-0.321950763463974,
-0.3763768672943115,
0.11976489424705505,
-0.2538348138332367,
0.8202303051948547,
-0.5134156942367554,
-0.4008200764656067,
0.012797570787370205,
0.22964927554130554,
-0.134555384516716,
-0.41034021973609924,
0.48234823346138,
-0.5384736657142639,
0.16391222178936005,
-0.151680588722229,
-0.39972564578056335,
0.07265183329582214,
0.24254514276981354,
-0.8967053890228271,
1.261459469795227,
0.4041490852832794,
-0.7233139872550964,
0.3124856650829315,
-0.5386378169059753,
-0.5243006944656372,
-0.0090835215523839,
0.017165999859571457,
-0.4279829263687134,
0.08808590471744537,
-0.029559137299656868,
0.32079142332077026,
-0.800121545791626,
-0.20487765967845917,
-0.31584545969963074,
-0.23173479735851288,
0.1579475849866867,
-0.25828295946121216,
0.4973256587982178,
-0.019470175728201866,
-0.04316743463277817,
-0.22620703279972076,
-0.8146876096725464,
0.1975266933441162,
0.22745820879936218,
-0.2813941538333893,
-0.5312823057174683,
0.0864207074046135,
0.11008944362401962,
0.23253285884857178,
-0.029129276052117348,
-0.3196781575679779,
0.10675366967916489,
-1.0280265808105469,
0.5224720239639282,
0.3305513262748718,
-0.06989497691392899,
0.654836893081665,
0.02589927613735199,
0.47123703360557556,
-0.42131486535072327,
-0.08050088584423065,
0.408880352973938,
-0.6214281320571899,
-0.6831679940223694,
-0.031273066997528076,
0.45270055532455444,
0.7194204926490784,
-0.9929490685462952,
0.21823883056640625,
-0.3544165790081024,
-0.6313060522079468,
-0.7894248962402344,
0.2569097578525543,
0.4676598012447357,
0.6781038641929626,
0.5475456118583679,
0.04432697594165802,
-0.5607799887657166,
-0.9992449879646301,
-0.35170528292655945,
-0.07091741263866425,
-0.14813029766082764,
0.29119616746902466,
0.5952921509742737,
-0.20643238723278046,
1.123923897743225,
-0.2694861888885498,
-0.6283106803894043,
-0.26784253120422363,
0.11450312286615372,
-0.06074662134051323,
0.590628981590271,
0.5653038024902344,
-0.7902043461799622,
-0.4653892517089844,
0.2785322070121765,
-0.6004983186721802,
0.2504124343395233,
0.21514032781124115,
-0.27471810579299927,
0.4604739248752594,
0.4067012369632721,
-0.6890954375267029,
0.4394795298576355,
0.30759239196777344,
-0.5599378347396851,
0.06985997408628464,
-0.3112158179283142,
-0.0025272436905652285,
-1.1976337432861328,
-0.055705711245536804,
0.07244938611984253,
-0.2837657034397125,
-0.7761914730072021,
-0.12250545620918274,
-0.1357036679983139,
-0.3874065577983856,
-0.17482219636440277,
0.7390480637550354,
-0.31730467081069946,
-0.18007266521453857,
-0.40483981370925903,
0.1696542501449585,
-0.25407674908638,
0.04976453632116318,
0.19643144309520721,
0.9288811683654785,
0.2744254469871521,
-0.5537025928497314,
0.272493839263916,
0.5186683535575867,
-0.3382587134838104,
0.5068025588989258,
-0.8461796641349792,
0.04675242677330971,
0.05000978335738182,
-0.13326896727085114,
-0.9466044902801514,
-0.3940393626689911,
0.15094512701034546,
-0.5533515810966492,
0.09945892542600632,
-0.2755082845687866,
-0.7585857510566711,
-0.3868945240974426,
-0.04388950765132904,
-0.03352845460176468,
0.4975707232952118,
-0.3918704390525818,
0.5988842248916626,
0.5499842166900635,
-0.3744901418685913,
-0.1973714977502823,
-0.9310670495033264,
0.15110570192337036,
-0.12045270949602127,
-0.7844507098197937,
0.3140817880630493,
0.04782526567578316,
-0.3053789436817169,
0.37036630511283875,
0.34973132610321045,
-0.3547108471393585,
0.3956061601638794,
0.3145923912525177,
0.3388175666332245,
-0.15774650871753693,
0.34478962421417236,
0.1356324404478073,
-0.5342566967010498,
-0.07199941575527191,
-0.2553471624851227,
0.39532989263534546,
-0.04662463441491127,
-0.20869532227516174,
-0.5288035273551941,
0.5696790814399719,
0.24916276335716248,
-0.1097118929028511,
1.2535213232040405,
0.6683905124664307,
-0.7199991345405579,
-0.25449439883232117,
-0.32579684257507324,
-0.4365261495113373,
-0.44792109727859497,
0.5738891959190369,
-0.3206346929073334,
-1.0259754657745361,
0.24882934987545013,
0.08330826461315155,
-0.03877943381667137,
0.6212948560714722,
0.5855314135551453,
0.0018855406669899821,
1.3668673038482666,
0.813654899597168,
-0.3872723877429962,
0.3055221736431122,
0.04018975794315338,
0.14829467236995697,
-0.45183444023132324,
-0.268393874168396,
-0.9864729046821594,
0.05121907219290733,
-0.5998497605323792,
-0.25342637300491333,
0.2867851257324219,
0.05788438022136688,
-0.4129854142665863,
0.35288500785827637,
-0.6247406601905823,
0.5421258211135864,
0.5974398851394653,
0.03234633430838585,
0.027506884187459946,
0.26742231845855713,
0.3492327928543091,
-0.15889480710029602,
-0.7844427227973938,
-0.6853888630867004,
0.7811906933784485,
0.1846068948507309,
0.812542736530304,
0.43868374824523926,
0.21379923820495605,
0.49857813119888306,
0.12199928611516953,
-0.7953822612762451,
0.4551428258419037,
-0.3069579303264618,
-0.6052500009536743,
-0.6795073747634888,
-0.3001294434070587,
-0.9834406971931458,
-0.003355130786076188,
-0.6287217140197754,
-0.7920365929603577,
-0.10056225955486298,
0.1356109380722046,
-0.3558664619922638,
-0.2005329579114914,
-0.9377400279045105,
0.9218827486038208,
-0.07414029538631439,
-0.23480162024497986,
-0.2978116571903229,
-0.5803653597831726,
-0.0181912612169981,
-0.029151836410164833,
0.3306797444820404,
-0.10163621604442596,
-0.1687736213207245,
0.8154919743537903,
-0.7505370378494263,
0.9422029852867126,
-0.19424253702163696,
0.11026208847761154,
0.21006903052330017,
0.1395038217306137,
0.6641274094581604,
0.2665957808494568,
-0.4059426486492157,
0.014131252653896809,
0.17364001274108887,
-0.3759731352329254,
-0.6773083209991455,
0.6322371959686279,
-0.9074588418006897,
-0.500585675239563,
-0.18007948994636536,
-0.36261242628097534,
-0.6255707740783691,
0.33125224709510803,
0.08012495189905167,
0.11231203377246857,
-0.15233471989631653,
0.32673928141593933,
0.5933584570884705,
0.18002158403396606,
0.4608396291732788,
0.7015378475189209,
0.2848048210144043,
-0.28435322642326355,
0.8673552870750427,
0.24216412007808685,
0.1342262178659439,
0.11658522486686707,
-0.1029629185795784,
-0.23524081707000732,
-0.6091831922531128,
-0.619552493095398,
0.02380160428583622,
-0.582248330116272,
-0.5560226440429688,
-0.5223603844642639,
-0.11802670359611511,
-0.5273005962371826,
-0.11018195003271103,
-0.5012233853340149,
-0.610435426235199,
-0.461525559425354,
-0.10859013348817825,
0.7422992587089539,
0.6901183724403381,
0.1533752679824829,
0.28267258405685425,
-1.058766484260559,
0.29598379135131836,
0.3649994730949402,
0.3686444163322449,
-0.026258034631609917,
-0.6274319291114807,
-0.6137750148773193,
0.00347145670093596,
0.34931591153144836,
-0.6347286701202393,
0.4178357422351837,
0.5392186045646667,
0.6123088598251343,
-0.09919007122516632,
0.026129530742764473,
0.6098750829696655,
-0.8303326368331909,
0.8865983486175537,
-0.005677926819771528,
-0.6826959252357483,
0.9638804793357849,
-0.12668263912200928,
-0.14241090416908264,
0.8306795954704285,
0.5330110788345337,
-0.40077778697013855,
-0.08016493171453476,
-0.3864675462245941,
-0.7675294280052185,
1.063463568687439,
0.09356799721717834,
0.19769826531410217,
-0.02110466919839382,
0.6883159279823303,
0.047494400292634964,
-0.24117310345172882,
-0.3062745928764343,
0.07077138125896454,
-0.06894602626562119,
-0.6508685350418091,
0.10138270258903503,
-0.519973635673523,
-0.3922919034957886,
-0.09977900981903076,
0.7697558403015137,
-0.29578351974487305,
0.30302637815475464,
-0.19186824560165405,
-0.03592295944690704,
0.18937209248542786,
0.019689524546265602,
0.2895662188529968,
0.25354987382888794,
0.13896149396896362,
-0.03614574670791626,
0.6168866157531738,
-0.4999922811985016,
-0.04848755523562431,
0.39789992570877075,
-0.02585018239915371,
-0.32537633180618286,
0.4624551832675934,
0.7170271277427673,
0.27662193775177,
-0.8437390327453613,
0.08241114020347595,
-0.44015583395957947,
0.11098220199346542,
-0.2988588511943817,
0.49746692180633545,
0.02122502587735653,
0.2950649857521057,
0.2550722658634186,
-0.22481058537960052,
0.2683999538421631,
-0.24361182749271393,
0.12677480280399323,
0.5914527177810669,
-0.5261687636375427,
-0.13402941823005676,
0.6043651103973389,
0.10880133509635925,
-0.5580655932426453,
0.9184333086013794,
0.019555209204554558,
-0.025834882631897926,
0.5283486247062683,
0.7786203622817993,
0.4470062255859375,
-0.13669969141483307,
0.07407453656196594,
0.3567923307418823,
0.4281357228755951,
-0.4874088764190674,
0.1027567908167839,
0.25371047854423523,
-0.8066076636314392,
0.013285445049405098,
-0.5697107911109924,
-0.42111679911613464,
-0.42008426785469055,
-0.6612480878829956,
0.24416697025299072,
-0.45403483510017395,
-0.24964295327663422,
0.16547930240631104,
0.10772448778152466,
-0.6724733114242554,
0.4965316951274872,
-0.13586224615573883,
0.8731493353843689,
-0.841228723526001,
0.9466386437416077,
0.7257111072540283,
-0.7115602493286133,
-0.823386549949646,
-0.43771904706954956,
0.021672815084457397,
-0.8621428608894348,
0.6899919509887695,
-0.17078015208244324,
-0.16315187513828278,
0.20994776487350464,
-0.502432644367218,
-0.8977071046829224,
1.0770217180252075,
0.34919899702072144,
-0.28851062059402466,
-0.02795855514705181,
0.437076598405838,
0.5705676078796387,
-0.326515257358551,
0.08869342505931854,
0.9054388403892517,
0.3607039749622345,
-0.1938478648662567,
-0.8611404299736023,
0.04871133342385292,
-0.15211176872253418,
0.32398390769958496,
0.2263108789920807,
-0.4513012766838074,
0.573837399482727,
-0.07586751133203506,
-0.2081865668296814,
0.27427810430526733,
0.6894809007644653,
0.015556884929537773,
0.08073681592941284,
0.35981321334838867,
0.546849250793457,
0.9666465520858765,
-0.223216712474823,
1.3371121883392334,
-0.33626386523246765,
0.34838244318962097,
1.1438761949539185,
-0.0719456672668457,
1.2376503944396973,
0.3553609549999237,
-0.29788753390312195,
0.2795605957508087,
0.5975023508071899,
0.058122821152210236,
0.6051270961761475,
-0.23924636840820312,
-0.24372734129428864,
-0.3068263828754425,
-0.41044872999191284,
-0.44599294662475586,
0.3615892827510834,
0.6354613304138184,
-0.2446596771478653,
0.04148869588971138,
0.2895594537258148,
0.0500187873840332,
0.137712761759758,
-0.23406873643398285,
1.0453619956970215,
0.1295493096113205,
-0.591067910194397,
0.3313194215297699,
0.23465315997600555,
0.35693496465682983,
-0.5297067165374756,
-0.07932166010141373,
-0.21950875222682953,
0.15520130097866058,
-0.24940837919712067,
-0.7832673788070679,
0.5970655679702759,
0.12964032590389252,
-0.4536573588848114,
0.19510908424854279,
1.2846556901931763,
-0.25846636295318604,
-0.7532364130020142,
0.17115476727485657,
0.27182456851005554,
0.0010895944433286786,
0.06688643246889114,
-0.809213399887085,
0.015332081355154514,
-0.26909106969833374,
-0.24259229004383087,
0.602125883102417,
0.5843051671981812,
-0.0045980350114405155,
0.8777511715888977,
0.5247335433959961,
-0.01604679599404335,
-0.12534096837043762,
-0.04731496796011925,
0.8827340006828308,
-0.7159134745597839,
-0.24132557213306427,
-0.8361843824386597,
0.45756271481513977,
-0.18195554614067078,
-0.11905893683433533,
0.8239741325378418,
0.22715389728546143,
0.640127956867218,
0.03797530010342598,
0.8818540573120117,
-0.1299498826265335,
0.7064933776855469,
-0.7097899913787842,
0.7914800643920898,
-0.4009723663330078,
0.1498534232378006,
0.17813187837600708,
-0.5168508887290955,
-0.4262709319591522,
0.7042477130889893,
-0.1995643973350525,
0.012416060082614422,
0.36862486600875854,
1.007047414779663,
0.3101274371147156,
0.11114978790283203,
0.31279435753822327,
-0.067640520632267,
0.1904190629720688,
0.3540172278881073,
0.4720424711704254,
-0.4753565490245819,
0.5872693061828613,
0.011526522226631641,
0.0077019440941512585,
-0.1677500456571579,
-0.5554187297821045,
-0.9442467093467712,
-0.48557087779045105,
-0.21565338969230652,
-0.6402274966239929,
0.1747974306344986,
0.7827518582344055,
0.6933684945106506,
-0.8749110698699951,
0.10233905911445618,
-0.2732895314693451,
0.16752205789089203,
0.02812698297202587,
-0.18506859242916107,
0.310655415058136,
-0.5626434683799744,
-0.7053328156471252,
0.4029587507247925,
0.1855928599834442,
0.1168513298034668,
-0.35693371295928955,
-0.10256043076515198,
0.05476175993680954,
0.04727863520383835,
0.6672409772872925,
0.436627060174942,
-0.5178109407424927,
-0.5798444151878357,
-0.19974680244922638,
-0.22096385061740875,
-0.4190138876438141,
0.4588019847869873,
-0.7701789736747742,
0.1922796219587326,
0.4053676128387451,
1.0449254512786865,
0.12556196749210358,
-0.16229155659675598,
0.4820711612701416,
-0.8131575584411621,
0.4899141192436218,
0.10063190758228302,
0.17375843226909637,
0.3025248646736145,
-0.4580775797367096,
0.9007335901260376,
0.05392938479781151,
-0.5861594676971436,
-0.7672886848449707,
-0.014298863708972931,
-0.6002281308174133,
-0.2577941119670868,
1.1414870023727417,
0.018118659034371376,
-0.27023619413375854,
-0.3704431653022766,
-0.2707279920578003,
0.04562552645802498,
-0.19048503041267395,
0.6856263875961304,
0.6387991905212402,
-0.20242878794670105,
-0.36301547288894653,
-0.682809054851532,
0.8304650187492371,
0.28486645221710205,
-0.9718904495239258,
0.031822096556425095,
0.4295714497566223,
0.17515553534030914,
-0.04549328237771988,
0.6727845072746277,
0.12056097388267517,
0.18173973262310028,
0.2720873951911926,
-0.1755848228931427,
0.048877011984586716,
-0.14422152936458588,
-0.22717897593975067,
0.10119883716106415,
0.4737466275691986,
0.04838302731513977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17067v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17067v1
|
Tokenization Matters! Degrading Large Language Models through Challenging Their Tokenization
| 2024-05-27T11:39:59 | 2024-05-27T11:39:59 |
Dixuan Wang, Yanda Li, Junyuan Jiang, Zepeng Ding, Guochao Jiang, Jiaqing Liang, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in language
understanding and generation. Nonetheless, it was also witnessed that LLMs tend
to produce inaccurate responses to specific queries. This deficiency can be
traced to the tokenization step LLMs must undergo, which is an inevitable
limitation inherent to all LLMs. In fact, incorrect tokenization is the
critical point that hinders LLMs in understanding the input precisely, thus
leading to unsatisfactory output. To demonstrate this flaw of LLMs, we
construct an adversarial dataset, named as $\textbf{ADT (Adversarial Dataset
for Tokenizer)}$, which draws upon the vocabularies of various open-source LLMs
to challenge LLMs' tokenization. ADT consists of two subsets: the manually
constructed ADT-Human and the automatically generated ADT-Auto. Our empirical
results reveal that our ADT is highly effective on challenging the tokenization
of leading LLMs, including GPT-4o, Llama-3, Qwen2.5-max and so on, thus
degrading these LLMs' capabilities. Moreover, our method of automatic data
generation has been proven efficient and robust, which can be applied to any
open-source LLMs. To the best of our knowledge, our study is the first to
investigating LLMs' vulnerability in terms of challenging their token
segmentation, which will shed light on the subsequent research of improving
LLMs' capabilities through optimizing their tokenization process and
algorithms.
|
[
-0.1542578935623169,
-1.0187041759490967,
0.35810866951942444,
-0.0714789479970932,
-0.3089117705821991,
0.30439335107803345,
-0.08157177269458771,
-0.2691795229911804,
0.08321303129196167,
0.49108830094337463,
-0.23854069411754608,
-0.4316627085208893,
-0.777902364730835,
0.0001815308933146298,
-0.5133989453315735,
1.064034104347229,
0.02197909727692604,
0.23188860714435577,
-0.06456279754638672,
-0.198286771774292,
-0.5900048017501831,
-0.784559428691864,
-0.9477847814559937,
-0.07930003851652145,
0.6028653979301453,
0.05297286435961723,
0.8124661445617676,
0.8034758567810059,
0.5312545895576477,
0.3321058750152588,
-0.23665328323841095,
0.18007530272006989,
-0.5963714718818665,
0.1230066791176796,
-0.009851126000285149,
-0.7159414887428284,
-0.38672927021980286,
-0.14638131856918335,
0.3662099838256836,
0.5943690538406372,
0.15924379229545593,
0.21188031136989594,
-0.27046671509742737,
0.6402031183242798,
-0.3989129662513733,
0.10215609520673752,
-1.2663756608963013,
-0.094488725066185,
-0.48819053173065186,
0.007207438349723816,
-0.3205772340297699,
-0.2564695179462433,
-0.4854295551776886,
-0.47564345598220825,
0.37774592638015747,
-0.0003566727682482451,
0.6673575639724731,
0.3944457769393921,
-0.5707371830940247,
-0.28016799688339233,
-0.6662722229957581,
0.5039135217666626,
-0.6494700908660889,
0.12996767461299896,
0.25634515285491943,
0.06526120752096176,
-0.4571309983730316,
-0.5858361721038818,
-0.5646158456802368,
-0.0744965672492981,
0.06502258777618408,
-0.23815231025218964,
-0.40169551968574524,
0.0014450500020757318,
0.19204027950763702,
0.3699885308742523,
-0.642909824848175,
0.31812161207199097,
-0.40949541330337524,
-0.43532320857048035,
0.3093418776988983,
0.2322438359260559,
0.39009103178977966,
-0.1641363948583603,
-0.32661157846450806,
-0.20514091849327087,
-1.1430084705352783,
-0.17491638660430908,
0.632890522480011,
0.3476942479610443,
0.5158807635307312,
0.6784231066703796,
0.32052934169769287,
0.40150272846221924,
0.1491619497537613,
0.3067588806152344,
0.08097169548273087,
-0.2569417357444763,
-0.19745329022407532,
-0.009922575205564499,
0.843115508556366,
0.0490664578974247,
0.06081700325012207,
-0.1919102966785431,
-0.3332616686820984,
0.015738435089588165,
0.11089814454317093,
-0.6269459128379822,
-0.05423310771584511,
0.31841713190078735,
-0.1834307610988617,
-0.5166025161743164,
0.08278001844882965,
-0.2974955141544342,
-0.6420671343803406,
0.037306033074855804,
0.47437340021133423,
-0.2814811170101166,
-0.10811658948659897,
-0.10139743983745575,
0.11427076905965805,
0.023626016452908516,
0.23856627941131592,
-0.8487882614135742,
0.10237308591604233,
0.8664073348045349,
0.8256200551986694,
-0.07848069071769714,
-0.21115250885486603,
-0.6520833969116211,
0.08217345178127289,
-0.5148905515670776,
0.46451082825660706,
-0.2601052224636078,
-0.44857630133628845,
-0.19741632044315338,
-0.09058815985918045,
-0.01627993769943714,
-0.7475408315658569,
0.45815786719322205,
-0.7679274678230286,
0.13164359331130981,
-0.3739631772041321,
-0.5156607031822205,
0.13882341980934143,
0.29378780722618103,
-0.7539389133453369,
0.8198026418685913,
-0.07769040763378143,
-0.8934037685394287,
0.3873955309391022,
-0.7855401635169983,
-0.452795147895813,
0.011016933247447014,
-0.256814181804657,
-0.47063347697257996,
0.2649029493331909,
0.39186111092567444,
0.3540428578853607,
-0.13359634578227997,
0.39581239223480225,
-0.26071611046791077,
-0.33560898900032043,
0.45068326592445374,
-0.5987911820411682,
0.8902818560600281,
0.14702242612838745,
-0.2969936728477478,
0.22282911837100983,
-0.6829918026924133,
-0.3052107095718384,
0.5721974968910217,
-0.4315148591995239,
-0.412207692861557,
-0.11073552072048187,
-0.09388840943574905,
0.15699096024036407,
0.2759608030319214,
-0.6577199697494507,
0.26856786012649536,
-0.6440988183021545,
0.6916670799255371,
1.2267918586730957,
-0.10539749264717102,
0.2402089685201645,
-0.09350886195898056,
0.518052875995636,
0.3001452684402466,
0.2165454477071762,
-0.18551908433437347,
-0.2734667658805847,
-0.71309494972229,
-0.17498759925365448,
0.41535812616348267,
0.5002889037132263,
-0.7477576732635498,
0.4142567217350006,
-0.2667132616043091,
-0.40308839082717896,
-0.49436116218566895,
0.06294087320566177,
0.21242602169513702,
0.42537474632263184,
0.2871220111846924,
-0.10661659389734268,
-0.5974630117416382,
-0.8117462992668152,
-0.3003266453742981,
-0.6393309235572815,
-0.05192190036177635,
0.18488933145999908,
0.6006967425346375,
-0.37289270758628845,
0.867143452167511,
-0.3919847011566162,
-0.33808934688568115,
-0.06112317740917206,
-0.033289484679698944,
0.04907424747943878,
0.35461947321891785,
0.4717022776603699,
-0.7272313833236694,
-0.12482333928346634,
-0.23012539744377136,
-0.2710275650024414,
-0.00113069755025208,
-0.08009172230958939,
0.05306494981050491,
0.2436351478099823,
0.5826528072357178,
-0.6319271922111511,
0.28918930888175964,
0.5273460745811462,
-0.5525481700897217,
0.469760537147522,
-0.13135969638824463,
-0.11709990352392197,
-1.1590619087219238,
0.19056929647922516,
-0.43239638209342957,
-0.22531522810459137,
-0.48297321796417236,
-0.0374612882733345,
0.019010839983820915,
-0.2777841091156006,
-0.4124039113521576,
0.6717620491981506,
-0.2121930569410324,
0.07165134698152542,
-0.19807521998882294,
-0.04983644559979439,
0.027911154553294182,
0.22765560448169708,
-0.46375009417533875,
0.8756569027900696,
0.34379512071609497,
-0.26582229137420654,
0.6674405932426453,
0.4188893437385559,
-0.054020319133996964,
0.08724462985992432,
-0.7885729074478149,
0.31811487674713135,
-0.085108183324337,
0.41263070702552795,
-1.0192897319793701,
-0.11413343995809555,
0.3764641284942627,
-0.587041974067688,
0.34834593534469604,
-0.22693009674549103,
-0.7559376358985901,
-0.2030397206544876,
-0.3674452304840088,
0.3859981894493103,
0.2563692629337311,
-0.5119681358337402,
0.05605329945683479,
0.4908097982406616,
-0.023019839078187943,
-0.6757162809371948,
-0.8890544772148132,
0.5937929749488831,
-0.3436797559261322,
-0.5056429505348206,
0.145760640501976,
-0.026725580915808678,
-0.32801786065101624,
-0.043633926659822464,
-0.09124449640512466,
0.1812465637922287,
0.3511996865272522,
0.1639840453863144,
0.18599556386470795,
-0.13861146569252014,
0.3844278156757355,
-0.2775937020778656,
-0.10523318499326706,
0.18401837348937988,
-0.3000549077987671,
0.6457833647727966,
-0.1291712075471878,
-0.8401765823364258,
-0.14437593519687653,
0.1973070651292801,
0.859115481376648,
-0.17199908196926117,
0.8376012444496155,
0.7292588353157043,
-0.3116160035133362,
-0.08024685084819794,
-0.495753675699234,
-0.1320968121290207,
-0.4578079879283905,
0.6067007184028625,
-0.27070140838623047,
-0.9255030751228333,
0.719054639339447,
0.06854336708784103,
0.14179445803165436,
0.5933758020401001,
0.5002707242965698,
0.4058310091495514,
1.2338223457336426,
0.3031952381134033,
-0.4984454810619354,
0.3590320348739624,
-0.256911039352417,
0.23456396162509918,
-0.6807373762130737,
-0.08483671396970749,
-0.42605656385421753,
-0.2689565420150757,
-0.49977606534957886,
-0.41531944274902344,
0.37986183166503906,
-0.1080014780163765,
-0.1615094393491745,
0.26008927822113037,
-0.35626402497291565,
0.47517168521881104,
0.35485848784446716,
0.03766403719782829,
0.20289228856563568,
-0.004036597907543182,
-0.10928747802972794,
0.05666826292872429,
-0.6726371645927429,
-0.5877759456634521,
1.363356113433838,
0.5420969128608704,
0.6425983309745789,
0.1526225358247757,
0.6572101712226868,
0.34161174297332764,
0.1318781077861786,
-0.8268123865127563,
0.4844187796115875,
-0.26564449071884155,
-0.6770576238632202,
-0.3584729731082916,
-0.6454619765281677,
-1.078729271888733,
0.22440391778945923,
0.20843176543712616,
-0.4098964333534241,
0.11455812305212021,
0.15363340079784393,
-0.08917737752199173,
0.5904944539070129,
-0.5984775424003601,
0.8252871632575989,
-0.331684410572052,
-0.11964721977710724,
0.04260431230068207,
-0.40856683254241943,
0.281462162733078,
-0.3358791470527649,
0.35731810331344604,
-0.0863516703248024,
-0.32880911231040955,
0.7665973901748657,
-0.6391634345054626,
0.9407817721366882,
-0.30256637930870056,
-0.32046523690223694,
0.15048092603683472,
0.21525754034519196,
0.7746501564979553,
0.13595376908779144,
-0.12800650298595428,
0.07427100837230682,
-0.2944486439228058,
-0.5819991827011108,
-0.5279386639595032,
0.8182779550552368,
-0.8049407005310059,
-0.6681687235832214,
-0.21742479503154755,
-0.25195398926734924,
-0.22350211441516876,
0.14531631767749786,
0.3322872221469879,
0.43121060729026794,
-0.5136303901672363,
0.03537535294890404,
0.456948459148407,
-0.13891567289829254,
0.21451281011104584,
0.24855905771255493,
-0.052813030779361725,
-0.44861212372779846,
1.1673489809036255,
0.16650328040122986,
0.2793393135070801,
0.10806801170110703,
0.1633014678955078,
-0.33493471145629883,
-0.9574487209320068,
-0.5635820627212524,
0.09148673713207245,
-0.883793830871582,
-0.3647775650024414,
-0.4957031011581421,
-0.10446229577064514,
-0.5200659036636353,
0.1731286346912384,
-0.4357898235321045,
-0.6121834516525269,
-0.5175568461418152,
-0.23949111998081207,
0.0680447369813919,
0.921373188495636,
-0.0774805024266243,
0.06805668026208878,
-0.7238975763320923,
0.10154399275779724,
0.42645567655563354,
0.049540966749191284,
-0.07928081601858139,
-0.5083407759666443,
-0.13795259594917297,
0.04645540937781334,
-0.2821228802204132,
-0.6756467819213867,
0.13020366430282593,
0.07812575250864029,
0.3988502621650696,
0.47345057129859924,
0.08286324888467789,
0.6644229888916016,
-0.38471460342407227,
0.8537555932998657,
0.10643994063138962,
-1.0019378662109375,
0.45783695578575134,
-0.3164843022823334,
0.24369774758815765,
0.5093116760253906,
-0.02095101773738861,
-0.6443116068840027,
-0.6458461880683899,
-0.7745234966278076,
-1.2808841466903687,
0.657561182975769,
0.34524381160736084,
0.32758721709251404,
-0.26280054450035095,
0.4449889659881592,
0.12142253667116165,
0.15945544838905334,
-0.6966250538825989,
-0.29819512367248535,
-0.12984146177768707,
-0.2098485231399536,
0.015916893258690834,
-0.305605411529541,
-0.1757921576499939,
0.08676841109991074,
0.7491089701652527,
-0.10420484095811844,
-0.0834682360291481,
0.08555679768323898,
-0.1971748024225235,
-0.16120341420173645,
0.2302982062101364,
0.5304507613182068,
0.6285656690597534,
0.1963389813899994,
0.3125063478946686,
0.2827102243900299,
-0.43156376481056213,
0.2609502375125885,
-0.02378094010055065,
-0.2299049347639084,
-0.022447101771831512,
0.46017757058143616,
0.8417903184890747,
-0.1898498237133026,
-0.7126021981239319,
0.6812278628349304,
-0.28266382217407227,
-0.11466491222381592,
-0.25374436378479004,
-0.06251410394906998,
-0.07519128918647766,
0.058152731508016586,
0.5142220854759216,
0.19952446222305298,
-0.09140443056821823,
-0.4415656626224518,
0.14173884689807892,
0.613059937953949,
-0.3299308717250824,
-0.4166310429573059,
0.723730206489563,
0.28402918577194214,
-0.10531678795814514,
0.32199764251708984,
-0.18730445206165314,
-0.7029064893722534,
0.7421168684959412,
0.4656643271446228,
0.9414543509483337,
-0.12309624999761581,
0.03578197956085205,
0.19939081370830536,
0.49663370847702026,
0.054381705820560455,
-0.19858790934085846,
0.16172711551189423,
-0.6344149708747864,
-0.3876206874847412,
-0.4459398090839386,
-0.31621840596199036,
0.5374388694763184,
-0.3228755295276642,
0.09139562398195267,
-0.5596523284912109,
-0.24018850922584534,
-0.15437091886997223,
-0.05495525896549225,
-0.4073778986930847,
-0.05483542010188103,
0.19108380377292633,
0.6499661803245544,
-0.848035454750061,
0.4763656556606293,
0.7154190540313721,
-0.16157281398773193,
-0.39138272404670715,
0.1955673098564148,
0.046505071222782135,
-1.0282909870147705,
0.9225890040397644,
-0.08688190579414368,
-0.07453560084104538,
-0.003922044765204191,
-0.5110606551170349,
-0.6792581081390381,
0.8654621243476868,
0.4980382025241852,
-0.3303218483924866,
0.027057716622948647,
0.35430648922920227,
0.4092724323272705,
-0.017218517139554024,
0.053853027522563934,
0.43313533067703247,
0.5912460088729858,
0.064157634973526,
-0.852107584476471,
0.27173930406570435,
-0.09787935763597488,
-0.01890662871301174,
0.3789105713367462,
-0.7908247113227844,
0.8971633315086365,
-0.3582626283168793,
-0.38892436027526855,
-0.033987000584602356,
0.34091389179229736,
-0.01835041493177414,
-0.06499426811933517,
0.6525392532348633,
0.5277537703514099,
0.789498507976532,
-0.05425279587507248,
0.6471467018127441,
-0.0447687990963459,
0.2488248646259308,
0.8372154831886292,
-0.08900871127843857,
0.5178269147872925,
0.6269674897193909,
-0.26855340600013733,
-0.17754006385803223,
0.5690475702285767,
-0.14158014953136444,
0.059087518602609634,
0.652285099029541,
-0.21827465295791626,
-0.10883467644453049,
0.06476299464702606,
-0.2803795337677002,
0.6061255931854248,
0.35405227541923523,
-0.23059338331222534,
-0.16851375997066498,
0.09548588842153549,
0.3011450171470642,
0.022957585752010345,
-0.20678271353244781,
0.8928781151771545,
-0.1530808061361313,
-0.15969933569431305,
0.7656275629997253,
0.29585394263267517,
0.5764172077178955,
-0.5472712516784668,
0.2614040672779083,
-0.31103280186653137,
0.2715652883052826,
-0.17121243476867676,
-0.38500866293907166,
0.42118507623672485,
0.222346231341362,
0.0022908668033778667,
-0.16779647767543793,
0.6635715365409851,
-0.3249468505382538,
-0.5022541284561157,
0.18229609727859497,
0.5170586705207825,
0.0792696475982666,
-0.3243533670902252,
-0.7224036455154419,
0.22700904309749603,
0.08674667030572891,
-0.5551198720932007,
0.4700873792171478,
0.5063226819038391,
-0.036958079785108566,
0.7065408229827881,
0.844870388507843,
0.38364437222480774,
0.016970064491033554,
0.05454963073134422,
1.0946966409683228,
-0.523703932762146,
-0.22031867504119873,
-1.2388149499893188,
0.2121681571006775,
-0.02315746620297432,
-0.1854662001132965,
0.6809457540512085,
0.8695927858352661,
0.8635244965553284,
0.13207603991031647,
0.9671801328659058,
0.044975947588682175,
0.33006930351257324,
-0.5208491683006287,
0.8213276267051697,
-0.5585905313491821,
0.5598354935646057,
0.0737866759300232,
-0.549618661403656,
-0.5404039025306702,
0.09499044716358185,
-0.22509562969207764,
-0.08250879496335983,
0.42569535970687866,
0.7498237490653992,
0.04755229875445366,
-0.47078099846839905,
0.3729648292064667,
0.3661666214466095,
0.7336056232452393,
0.46962615847587585,
0.8452627062797546,
-0.5712132453918457,
1.06270432472229,
0.031271062791347504,
-0.09898586571216583,
-0.2856030762195587,
-0.5986374020576477,
-1.0307525396347046,
-0.5349865555763245,
-0.22732965648174286,
-0.3683983385562897,
0.19699615240097046,
0.8418568968772888,
0.4012218713760376,
-0.9430137276649475,
0.036232467740774155,
-0.25741124153137207,
0.23198118805885315,
0.2849980890750885,
-0.2245219200849533,
0.6061583757400513,
-0.4493923485279083,
-0.7405070066452026,
0.5152580738067627,
0.06537461280822754,
0.319245845079422,
-0.5302522778511047,
0.1616271585226059,
0.24062420427799225,
-0.005539608653634787,
0.40536490082740784,
0.0990322008728981,
-0.796414852142334,
-0.3769909739494324,
-0.05894717946648598,
-0.18269483745098114,
0.0473925955593586,
1.0411109924316406,
-0.5735849142074585,
0.30607980489730835,
0.5189504623413086,
0.6773163676261902,
0.014799500815570354,
0.04279983788728714,
0.5930219888687134,
-0.8415886163711548,
0.10928025841712952,
0.3337291181087494,
0.30839797854423523,
0.4981386959552765,
-0.5075090527534485,
0.2596822679042816,
0.41251933574676514,
-0.5250886082649231,
-0.9270303249359131,
0.35430777072906494,
-0.4497683346271515,
-0.5182734131813049,
1.1424809694290161,
-0.04209700971841812,
-0.26940423250198364,
-0.18810002505779266,
-0.4897168278694153,
0.33670541644096375,
-0.3503964841365814,
0.8782164454460144,
0.7436532378196716,
0.07050061970949173,
0.34438207745552063,
-0.265807569026947,
0.44607600569725037,
0.3473287522792816,
-0.5269965529441833,
0.5673155188560486,
0.3095335364341736,
0.3047102689743042,
0.015794901177287102,
0.5433066487312317,
-0.2786324620246887,
-0.11849617213010788,
-0.016897249966859818,
-0.14700080454349518,
-0.5091630816459656,
0.048456285148859024,
-0.5436477065086365,
0.22228384017944336,
0.37143591046333313,
-0.38953697681427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17062v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17062v2
|
Unifying Demonstration Selection and Compression for In-Context Learning
| 2024-05-27T11:31:58 | 2024-06-15T21:16:57 |
Jun Gao, Ziqiang Cao, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL) facilitates large language models (LLMs) exhibiting
spectacular emergent capabilities in various scenarios. Unfortunately,
introducing demonstrations easily makes the prompt length explode, bringing a
significant burden to hardware. In addition, random demonstrations usually
achieve limited improvements in ICL, necessitating demonstration selection
among accessible candidates. Previous studies introduce extra modules to
perform demonstration compression or selection independently. In this paper, we
propose an ICL framework UniICL, which Unifies demonstration selection and
compression, and final response generation via a single frozen LLM.
Specifically, UniICL first projects actual demonstrations and inference text
inputs into short virtual tokens, respectively. Then, virtual tokens are
applied to select suitable demonstrations by measuring semantic similarity
within latent space among candidate demonstrations and inference input.
Finally, inference text inputs together with selected virtual demonstrations
are fed into the same frozen LLM for response generation. Notably, UniICL is a
parameter-efficient framework that only contains 17M trainable parameters
originating from the projection layer. We conduct experiments and analysis over
in- and out-domain datasets of both generative and understanding tasks,
encompassing ICL scenarios with plentiful and limited demonstration candidates.
Results show that UniICL effectively unifies $12 \times$ compression,
demonstration selection, and response generation, efficiently scaling up the
baseline from 4-shot to 64-shot ICL in IMDb with 24 GB CUDA allocation
|
[
-0.6050322651863098,
-0.35526710748672485,
0.26753824949264526,
0.439832866191864,
-0.6639761924743652,
0.0758775845170021,
-0.49890121817588806,
-0.1784364879131317,
-0.2557118535041809,
0.19057464599609375,
-0.34965357184410095,
-0.3783577084541321,
-0.18358144164085388,
0.012264122255146503,
-0.6339057683944702,
1.0501583814620972,
0.11206728219985962,
-0.15029612183570862,
-0.6249263882637024,
-0.10881820321083069,
-0.22095242142677307,
-0.3739004135131836,
-0.35365965962409973,
-0.5508823394775391,
-0.17213957011699677,
0.8604576587677002,
0.1450851708650589,
0.37169787287712097,
-0.11768102645874023,
0.22569911181926727,
0.04095619171857834,
0.1706264764070511,
-0.2744527757167816,
0.15318140387535095,
-0.06707219034433365,
0.07887548953294754,
0.2200014740228653,
-0.17577382922172546,
0.7652198672294617,
0.6338721513748169,
0.1259741336107254,
0.33993613719940186,
0.4914199709892273,
0.2844941020011902,
-0.7230063676834106,
-0.01287013478577137,
-0.8046490550041199,
0.07989656925201416,
-0.017872052267193794,
-0.04744531586766243,
-0.6340495944023132,
0.2690839171409607,
0.29527613520622253,
-0.34289777278900146,
0.2013457715511322,
-0.06118332967162132,
0.43288516998291016,
0.15867871046066284,
-0.4593580663204193,
0.026610232889652252,
-0.6905582547187805,
0.6645772457122803,
-0.6721581220626831,
0.179323211312294,
-0.1106969565153122,
0.19710490107536316,
-0.13331839442253113,
-0.9748115539550781,
-0.46195119619369507,
-0.1973012387752533,
-0.1261633038520813,
0.23134006559848785,
-0.07800497859716415,
-0.0007608291925862432,
0.23544038832187653,
0.26126256585121155,
-0.539269745349884,
0.48360103368759155,
-0.260567843914032,
-0.3222317099571228,
0.23943379521369934,
-0.02509359084069729,
0.13786287605762482,
-0.06287078559398651,
-0.8412691950798035,
-0.40734338760375977,
-0.9445606470108032,
0.1844935566186905,
0.08329232037067413,
0.29303470253944397,
-0.2481156438589096,
0.29320114850997925,
-0.15307211875915527,
0.745882511138916,
0.09942496567964554,
0.02157324180006981,
-0.07819060981273651,
-0.026338903233408928,
-0.5327802896499634,
0.17514637112617493,
0.8861687183380127,
0.22258159518241882,
-0.2714901566505432,
-0.13255156576633453,
-0.13552147150039673,
0.05498112365603447,
0.047730326652526855,
-1.0508031845092773,
-0.07007647305727005,
0.28512901067733765,
-0.20228706300258636,
-0.07136334478855133,
0.20133312046527863,
-1.060739517211914,
-0.1295570284128189,
-0.21600119769573212,
0.35829854011535645,
-0.3178490996360779,
-0.12219679355621338,
0.15055964887142181,
-0.13509663939476013,
-0.07139541208744049,
0.18050189316272736,
-0.6908069849014282,
0.42681464552879333,
0.26529449224472046,
0.6046416759490967,
-0.3453729748725891,
-0.23671352863311768,
-0.7756014466285706,
0.1730995923280716,
-0.13027752935886383,
0.843625009059906,
-0.35471147298812866,
-0.3913327753543854,
0.216231107711792,
-0.36703047156333923,
0.06922091543674469,
-0.590599536895752,
0.3379054367542267,
-0.40684446692466736,
0.2335766851902008,
0.3402409851551056,
-0.5219557285308838,
-0.11914149671792984,
0.0621720515191555,
-0.37298065423965454,
0.7896605134010315,
0.08102881908416748,
-0.8147443532943726,
0.5252631306648254,
-0.7897403240203857,
-0.5193310379981995,
0.2520272731781006,
-0.5317235589027405,
-0.37852948904037476,
0.15243658423423767,
0.2465590387582779,
0.714942216873169,
-0.48669469356536865,
0.2881448268890381,
-0.14961089193820953,
-0.5797880291938782,
0.407429039478302,
-0.6529482007026672,
0.46550875902175903,
0.32900527119636536,
-0.8090459108352661,
0.306854248046875,
-0.8404525518417358,
0.298823744058609,
-0.14440996944904327,
-0.6305148005485535,
-0.10711797326803207,
-0.20449137687683105,
0.20393018424510956,
0.305355429649353,
-0.038285572081804276,
-0.5503394603729248,
0.17941062152385712,
-0.41977551579475403,
0.4506382644176483,
0.6276551485061646,
-0.08117267489433289,
0.35076624155044556,
0.020099664106965065,
0.40793368220329285,
0.12068390101194382,
0.1073266863822937,
-0.14116136729717255,
-0.012603292241692543,
-0.5406830906867981,
-0.39952102303504944,
0.2641764283180237,
0.16468161344528198,
-0.8060462474822998,
0.09521587938070297,
-0.30858105421066284,
-0.08046666532754898,
-0.25755074620246887,
0.12815654277801514,
0.7787430286407471,
0.5630725622177124,
0.2997716963291168,
0.008631154894828796,
-0.46959513425827026,
-0.9239855408668518,
0.08760310709476471,
-0.38465622067451477,
-0.360334575176239,
0.03741934895515442,
0.2926143407821655,
0.23229387402534485,
0.9149491190910339,
-0.1044660210609436,
-0.15896295011043549,
-0.4832715690135956,
0.40058889985084534,
0.07741387188434601,
0.3640280067920685,
0.5588697195053101,
-1.0372556447982788,
-0.6352251172065735,
-0.03934943675994873,
-0.5046260356903076,
-0.1571616232395172,
-0.32158321142196655,
0.22401590645313263,
0.06264933943748474,
0.5761058926582336,
-0.44583767652511597,
0.6179855465888977,
0.48607367277145386,
-0.1310531497001648,
0.38031110167503357,
-0.4766552746295929,
0.038318317383527756,
-1.082227110862732,
-0.22324934601783752,
-0.12819471955299377,
-0.12476185709238052,
-0.5389889478683472,
0.14793018996715546,
0.34927722811698914,
0.0294636283069849,
-0.8966051340103149,
0.5776437520980835,
-0.6535339951515198,
-0.28957703709602356,
-0.2994444668292999,
0.15753485262393951,
-0.061441466212272644,
0.5510078072547913,
0.003444257890805602,
0.9610236883163452,
0.6878678798675537,
-0.8280853629112244,
-0.16556395590305328,
0.1595766842365265,
-0.5577905178070068,
0.28471076488494873,
-0.4427297115325928,
0.19787561893463135,
-0.0880725309252739,
0.21465399861335754,
-0.8580134510993958,
-0.49952808022499084,
-0.002711621345952153,
-0.10196967422962189,
0.47567757964134216,
-0.15318316221237183,
-0.6911131739616394,
-0.2661164104938507,
-0.2870839536190033,
0.4369586110115051,
0.6156143546104431,
-1.052721381187439,
0.5142313241958618,
0.07669436931610107,
0.5027461051940918,
-0.5276390910148621,
-0.6544237732887268,
-0.0362669974565506,
-0.6271276473999023,
-0.23151670396327972,
0.5791037082672119,
-0.7458206415176392,
-0.29501670598983765,
-0.2709011137485504,
-0.010071643628180027,
0.10323989391326904,
0.21550482511520386,
0.5210805535316467,
-0.011396689340472221,
-0.04470674693584442,
0.13155998289585114,
0.38719087839126587,
0.1581229865550995,
-0.19698677957057953,
-0.45275408029556274,
0.529572606086731,
-0.1672322154045105,
-0.49908557534217834,
-0.3157113790512085,
0.6001887321472168,
0.7378664612770081,
-0.02931363321840763,
0.3533661663532257,
0.38943663239479065,
-0.22254998981952667,
-0.4089696407318115,
-0.14412303268909454,
-0.21554328501224518,
-0.4387160539627075,
0.15808217227458954,
-0.32358112931251526,
-0.9761801362037659,
0.2845892906188965,
-0.3996606767177582,
0.41964223980903625,
0.05446092411875725,
0.4976995587348938,
0.24465303122997284,
1.0812915563583374,
0.5677667856216431,
0.17816650867462158,
0.38609936833381653,
-0.21434332430362701,
-0.07951415330171585,
-1.027612566947937,
-0.1690046489238739,
-0.32514145970344543,
-0.18122954666614532,
0.04187416657805443,
-0.2991339862346649,
0.6087507009506226,
0.4156259000301361,
-0.34989485144615173,
0.22003482282161713,
-0.4407828152179718,
0.5719151496887207,
0.4328146278858185,
0.05523340776562691,
0.0467284694314003,
0.23040099442005157,
-0.6233038306236267,
-0.051442284137010574,
-0.7251808047294617,
-0.4601162075996399,
0.8672584295272827,
-0.05929027870297432,
0.6063731908798218,
0.36453139781951904,
0.4654799699783325,
0.2535625696182251,
0.49239981174468994,
-0.37643682956695557,
0.7229270935058594,
-0.19320076704025269,
-0.24484187364578247,
-0.13031208515167236,
-0.04962237551808357,
-0.7091715931892395,
0.4619240164756775,
-0.17514896392822266,
-1.1079179048538208,
0.030032675713300705,
0.2847776710987091,
-0.5562264919281006,
0.3669404983520508,
-0.593215823173523,
0.5473088026046753,
-0.16655460000038147,
-0.30914217233657837,
-0.13079732656478882,
-0.8509210348129272,
0.3952775299549103,
-0.10435062646865845,
0.13481564819812775,
0.16439160704612732,
0.19693468511104584,
0.48193010687828064,
-0.21670684218406677,
1.092077612876892,
0.001969525357708335,
0.2037063091993332,
0.3251676559448242,
0.23962649703025818,
0.22167816758155823,
0.4338672459125519,
-0.10838940739631653,
-0.294302761554718,
-0.29581430554389954,
-0.13449515402317047,
-0.6949498057365417,
0.7350713014602661,
-0.4895366132259369,
-0.545343279838562,
-0.05224046856164932,
-0.5410779118537903,
-0.3332400918006897,
0.010149545967578888,
0.6124241948127747,
1.0463759899139404,
-0.16237014532089233,
0.4287433624267578,
0.7553301453590393,
-0.056406158953905106,
0.8892579674720764,
0.5226004123687744,
-0.24172861874103546,
-0.3442017734050751,
0.6134598255157471,
-0.2715975046157837,
0.5468255877494812,
0.5490989685058594,
0.2283661663532257,
-0.29861417412757874,
-0.733246922492981,
-0.7231304049491882,
-0.22711709141731262,
-0.9337700009346008,
-0.46676644682884216,
-0.6520077586174011,
-0.11268643289804459,
-0.3468157649040222,
-0.2004549354314804,
-0.29809120297431946,
-0.18101133406162262,
-0.6258586049079895,
-0.2018631249666214,
0.12147776782512665,
0.5617990493774414,
-0.3093802332878113,
0.4220409393310547,
-0.5033139586448669,
0.012534813955426216,
0.46988773345947266,
-0.0032296942081302404,
0.053031839430332184,
-0.6538459658622742,
-0.1436871588230133,
-0.02784072235226631,
-0.24777226150035858,
-0.5827135443687439,
0.2995865046977997,
0.6050391793251038,
0.5053898692131042,
0.8120440244674683,
0.6063929796218872,
0.9073647856712341,
-0.3199574649333954,
0.9297414422035217,
0.3104102909564972,
-0.8953704833984375,
0.433599054813385,
0.20988330245018005,
0.5856338143348694,
0.37463629245758057,
0.30868667364120483,
-0.14526934921741486,
-0.4312995672225952,
-0.6648144125938416,
-1.0027707815170288,
0.4555421471595764,
0.02957930788397789,
0.30444759130477905,
-0.10982034355401993,
0.24604561924934387,
0.39358511567115784,
0.0843442752957344,
-0.6927054524421692,
-0.208008274435997,
-0.15933866798877716,
-0.06165323778986931,
0.13968157768249512,
-0.2646331191062927,
-0.421960711479187,
-0.18123266100883484,
0.5013437867164612,
-0.7480466961860657,
0.19744563102722168,
0.1826319396495819,
-0.26410070061683655,
0.0049057709984481335,
0.48244956135749817,
0.6809735894203186,
0.641523540019989,
-0.0549478605389595,
0.4956431984901428,
0.18985378742218018,
-0.052908167243003845,
0.11806932836771011,
0.07347866147756577,
-0.16471236944198608,
-0.18963739275932312,
0.4119654595851898,
0.9232326149940491,
0.7143847942352295,
-1.0345309972763062,
0.5911445617675781,
-0.4101552367210388,
-0.20118393003940582,
-0.38770225644111633,
-0.04860719293355942,
-0.26153525710105896,
0.4135945439338684,
0.44587549567222595,
-0.10767882317304611,
0.14942201972007751,
-0.4582400321960449,
0.4344021677970886,
0.37045034766197205,
-0.4294535219669342,
-0.3223915994167328,
0.7438810467720032,
-0.2708459794521332,
-0.10785793513059616,
0.6943249106407166,
-0.24991673231124878,
-0.5023950934410095,
0.40968602895736694,
1.0011156797409058,
0.6736782193183899,
0.13856187462806702,
0.508406400680542,
0.14897236227989197,
-0.2178458720445633,
0.04833429679274559,
0.050223059952259064,
-0.4637666940689087,
-0.6148300766944885,
-0.3083288073539734,
-0.37112152576446533,
-0.18506699800491333,
0.24830248951911926,
-0.8214890360832214,
0.18660378456115723,
-0.4260038137435913,
0.1691887080669403,
-0.29150447249412537,
-0.2302314043045044,
-0.6206684112548828,
0.11851003766059875,
0.136897474527359,
0.9758936166763306,
-0.7442883253097534,
0.9138878583908081,
0.7896741628646851,
-0.24162986874580383,
-0.8557120561599731,
0.234136700630188,
0.027375012636184692,
-0.40616703033447266,
0.7191681265830994,
0.2335805892944336,
-0.05428164452314377,
-0.00020984151342418045,
-0.9226073026657104,
-0.5193957090377808,
1.1123862266540527,
0.6602388620376587,
-0.17429621517658234,
0.32512372732162476,
-0.01798132434487343,
0.42194950580596924,
-0.8659765124320984,
0.3229794204235077,
0.1359233409166336,
0.020503364503383636,
0.39028868079185486,
-0.7626296877861023,
-0.021076278761029243,
0.1333405077457428,
0.035335808992385864,
-0.0865340307354927,
-0.6945599317550659,
0.7397233247756958,
-0.25170981884002686,
-0.5526806116104126,
0.3059258759021759,
1.0018022060394287,
0.4370768070220947,
0.13497799634933472,
0.7473791241645813,
0.21155354380607605,
0.4079083204269409,
0.15806177258491516,
0.9055202007293701,
-0.16506223380565643,
0.08382914215326309,
1.2414939403533936,
-0.20532839000225067,
0.921330451965332,
0.6997536420822144,
0.19742624461650848,
0.45731550455093384,
0.7508954405784607,
0.5100030303001404,
0.770946741104126,
0.28632286190986633,
-0.7288395166397095,
-0.5236918926239014,
-0.36625000834465027,
-0.010381135158240795,
0.42344269156455994,
0.3926742374897003,
-0.009235886856913567,
-0.4607740044593811,
0.5489535927772522,
0.050839558243751526,
0.262877494096756,
-0.1259130835533142,
0.6366739869117737,
0.016034161671996117,
-0.7446858882904053,
0.5199298858642578,
-0.26672282814979553,
0.5176379084587097,
-0.5047926902770996,
-0.2679910957813263,
-0.3218057453632355,
0.06261341273784637,
0.05791397765278816,
-0.7951987981796265,
-0.12905631959438324,
-0.02814733423292637,
-0.06686883419752121,
-0.31402885913848877,
0.5074530839920044,
-0.5155154466629028,
0.007625916041433811,
0.37262552976608276,
0.0778309777379036,
0.3885505497455597,
0.02686440199613571,
-0.4271593391895294,
0.23576577007770538,
0.050538986921310425,
-0.13715125620365143,
0.8977006077766418,
0.4490991532802582,
-0.2745392322540283,
0.7604687809944153,
0.5052841305732727,
-0.3067292273044586,
-0.020304206758737564,
0.08030297607183456,
1.2203173637390137,
-0.006171441171318293,
-0.34486937522888184,
-0.6110410094261169,
0.8223996758460999,
-0.18349601328372955,
-0.40965184569358826,
0.5180227756500244,
0.5016459822654724,
1.0067673921585083,
-0.1642817258834839,
0.7067398428916931,
-0.19371846318244934,
0.2007521539926529,
-0.7828566431999207,
0.2725721299648285,
-0.6199728846549988,
0.39954376220703125,
-0.07644712179899216,
-0.5829625129699707,
-0.38813143968582153,
0.2201547473669052,
0.28732118010520935,
-0.332071989774704,
0.5601714253425598,
0.4395621716976166,
-0.3098023533821106,
-0.21226072311401367,
0.6363192200660706,
-0.004902275279164314,
0.4071100950241089,
0.5857084393501282,
0.6833544373512268,
-0.2195485532283783,
0.5718753933906555,
-0.3637419044971466,
-0.19503942131996155,
-0.037294622510671616,
-1.1531219482421875,
-1.0114318132400513,
-0.851411759853363,
-0.46542423963546753,
-0.16717314720153809,
-0.2233932912349701,
1.315575122833252,
0.9999974966049194,
-0.5458920001983643,
-0.387149840593338,
0.111935093998909,
-0.07234670966863632,
-0.35763806104660034,
-0.22347579896450043,
0.45746612548828125,
-0.08501686900854111,
-0.6431832909584045,
0.8574939966201782,
0.38635340332984924,
0.28006842732429504,
-0.38253480195999146,
-0.08697447925806046,
0.003944551106542349,
-0.20126879215240479,
0.6286830902099609,
0.5127766728401184,
-0.7829853296279907,
-0.4700552821159363,
-0.38202691078186035,
0.3454752564430237,
0.01417593564838171,
1.044820785522461,
-1.0539216995239258,
0.404314249753952,
0.19355511665344238,
0.6530430912971497,
0.4685739576816559,
-0.15296368300914764,
0.5368263125419617,
-1.1436725854873657,
0.4725845456123352,
0.05781273543834686,
0.3938977122306824,
0.3691687285900116,
-0.3495716452598572,
0.2572072446346283,
-0.09755842387676239,
-0.42468732595443726,
-0.849076509475708,
0.4171461760997772,
-0.8433881402015686,
-0.5257787704467773,
1.051662564277649,
-0.3400685787200928,
-0.17070111632347107,
0.07532955706119537,
-0.0833539292216301,
0.04044751450419426,
-0.3062148988246918,
0.692338228225708,
0.3075524568557739,
-0.3426324725151062,
-0.3771771788597107,
-0.41856950521469116,
0.43448057770729065,
0.24554577469825745,
-0.7041705250740051,
0.14325034618377686,
0.4466764032840729,
0.10038647800683975,
-0.005285987164825201,
0.34573885798454285,
0.051659051328897476,
0.11412055790424347,
-0.37360239028930664,
0.054794058203697205,
0.0070394063368439674,
-0.6159560680389404,
-0.4493404030799866,
0.49508586525917053,
0.1039215698838234,
-0.13176104426383972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17057v1
|
ReflectionCoder: Learning from Reflection Sequence for Enhanced One-off Code Generation
| 2024-05-27T11:27:00 | 2024-05-27T11:27:00 |
Houxing Ren, Mingjie Zhan, Zhongyuan Wu, Aojun Zhou, Junting Pan, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Code generation plays a crucial role in various tasks, such as code
auto-completion and mathematical reasoning. Previous work has proposed numerous
methods to enhance code generation performance, including integrating feedback
from the compiler. Inspired by this, we present ReflectionCoder, a novel
approach that effectively leverages reflection sequences constructed by
integrating compiler feedback to improve one-off code generation performance.
Furthermore, we propose reflection self-distillation and dynamically masked
distillation to effectively utilize these reflection sequences. Extensive
experiments on three benchmarks, i.e., HumanEval (+), MBPP (+), and MultiPl-E,
demonstrate that models fine-tuned with our method achieve state-of-the-art
performance. Notably, ReflectionCoder-DeepSeek-Coder-33B reaches pass@1 of 82.9
(76.8) on HumanEval (+) and 84.1 (72.0) on MBPP (+), on par with GPT-3.5-Turbo
and Claude-3-opus, and surpasses early GPT-4. Beyond the code domain, we
believe this approach can benefit other domains that focus on final results and
require long reasoning paths. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/SenseLLM/ReflectionCoder.
|
[
-0.5451608896255493,
-0.23689238727092743,
0.47350600361824036,
0.48678526282310486,
-0.5235698223114014,
0.5036293268203735,
0.031293246895074844,
-0.14167752861976624,
0.1322689801454544,
0.70243239402771,
-0.41198015213012695,
-0.267327219247818,
-0.5732169151306152,
-0.006776453461498022,
-0.408000648021698,
0.982880711555481,
0.1382991224527359,
0.14245223999023438,
-0.07593084871768951,
0.049401670694351196,
-0.17383642494678497,
-0.6018335819244385,
-0.06870419532060623,
-0.09937478601932526,
0.2289682924747467,
0.20117615163326263,
0.13848844170570374,
0.5363394021987915,
0.43431219458580017,
0.24717506766319275,
0.3023383319377899,
0.30918341875076294,
-0.5533333420753479,
0.2094048410654068,
0.008632748387753963,
0.009790929034352303,
-0.46529191732406616,
-0.05133248493075371,
0.5641284584999084,
0.21120750904083252,
-0.32983821630477905,
0.5187832713127136,
0.33325591683387756,
0.9192181825637817,
-0.8730154037475586,
0.270038902759552,
-0.45294827222824097,
0.36296191811561584,
-0.042237672954797745,
-0.45465484261512756,
-0.5842066407203674,
-0.8064062595367432,
-0.15163682401180267,
-0.33367684483528137,
0.3879159688949585,
-0.41673487424850464,
0.22127605974674225,
0.678741991519928,
-0.1497083604335785,
-0.2819547951221466,
-0.8007121086120605,
0.50182044506073,
-0.7538444399833679,
0.21796977519989014,
-0.07298661023378372,
0.41786161065101624,
-0.042168356478214264,
-1.015001654624939,
-0.37484174966812134,
-0.11314550787210464,
0.006848460528999567,
0.37989458441734314,
0.16614526510238647,
0.003931812010705471,
0.5266151428222656,
0.5788794755935669,
-0.39113765954971313,
-0.5280477404594421,
-0.3675185739994049,
0.12474498152732849,
0.7065050005912781,
0.0482584647834301,
-0.268326997756958,
-0.1475497931241989,
-0.35761114954948425,
-0.17823506891727448,
-0.8329095840454102,
-0.12678050994873047,
0.17646953463554382,
0.12117864936590195,
0.23540930449962616,
0.04095203056931496,
0.050833236426115036,
0.6818838119506836,
0.3463478088378906,
0.2237059623003006,
0.13498125970363617,
-0.09010176360607147,
0.15530134737491608,
0.22116658091545105,
0.5293814539909363,
-0.11509468406438828,
0.09400691092014313,
0.20321469008922577,
-0.317287802696228,
0.0227829422801733,
0.5287024974822998,
-1.3468494415283203,
-0.6752355098724365,
-0.185610830783844,
-0.3587934374809265,
-0.3761172294616699,
0.3633307218551636,
-1.0151996612548828,
-0.28929802775382996,
-0.2713911831378937,
0.40208005905151367,
-0.08867444843053818,
-0.27419549226760864,
0.24991336464881897,
-0.1770794540643692,
0.14788982272148132,
0.3513130247592926,
-0.544942319393158,
0.2929924726486206,
0.6509836316108704,
0.6635624766349792,
0.021695950999855995,
-0.10243543982505798,
-0.9313921332359314,
-0.04139097034931183,
-0.27851271629333496,
0.2545772194862366,
-0.5633785128593445,
-0.4827370345592499,
-0.01078906562179327,
-0.568272054195404,
0.2719968855381012,
-0.6775871515274048,
0.07741885632276535,
-0.5337454080581665,
0.11173922568559647,
-0.19205375015735626,
-0.5317296981811523,
-0.12021758407354355,
-0.10433780401945114,
-0.6691582202911377,
1.1618539094924927,
0.30255573987960815,
-0.6081105470657349,
0.5488297343254089,
-0.7252262234687805,
-0.5766412615776062,
0.24087253212928772,
-0.4278121888637543,
-0.48242509365081787,
0.5732032656669617,
-0.06850717216730118,
0.3176907002925873,
-0.2138204425573349,
0.2582264542579651,
-0.25110742449760437,
-0.4491380751132965,
-0.05347597599029541,
-0.3958349823951721,
0.6672564148902893,
0.4428956210613251,
-0.7399955987930298,
-0.24630938470363617,
-1.1457257270812988,
0.3905572295188904,
0.06240856647491455,
-0.3459012508392334,
-0.02361852116882801,
0.07587680965662003,
-0.334738552570343,
0.5521813631057739,
0.16729103028774261,
-0.4761548936367035,
0.4894888699054718,
-0.016309909522533417,
0.30053114891052246,
0.6287055015563965,
0.0737464502453804,
-0.012733354233205318,
-0.11300240457057953,
0.7056407332420349,
-0.034637801349163055,
0.21197353303432465,
-0.4047374725341797,
-0.5376066565513611,
-0.6859661936759949,
-0.38196390867233276,
0.22193266451358795,
0.40908297896385193,
-0.7078593969345093,
0.20253674685955048,
-0.06941541284322739,
-0.29113298654556274,
-0.5343392491340637,
0.5077253580093384,
0.8690502047538757,
0.35098788142204285,
0.6664159893989563,
-0.6284903883934021,
-0.7234134674072266,
-0.38580283522605896,
-0.3849247992038727,
-0.04851395636796951,
0.04020770266652107,
-0.010288394056260586,
0.3070226311683655,
0.01613597944378853,
1.0397449731826782,
-0.8431382775306702,
-0.14567506313323975,
-0.19660742580890656,
0.16236920654773712,
0.3233864903450012,
0.6372638940811157,
0.3835105895996094,
-0.6677267551422119,
-0.6335641145706177,
-0.2839553654193878,
-0.5393834710121155,
-0.1478228121995926,
-0.1118658110499382,
-0.13682110607624054,
0.0526304617524147,
0.3122349977493286,
-0.030582517385482788,
0.48866066336631775,
0.48423731327056885,
-0.16860613226890564,
0.3812679946422577,
-0.3960075378417969,
0.13099628686904907,
-0.9138190746307373,
-0.004807732999324799,
-0.17897216975688934,
-0.3960984945297241,
-0.5365750193595886,
0.2965319752693176,
0.09070246666669846,
0.07728296518325806,
-0.44371217489242554,
0.2028762698173523,
-0.5804027318954468,
0.11518377810716629,
-0.3318980932235718,
-0.3642023801803589,
0.31889963150024414,
0.4542471766471863,
0.08913788944482803,
0.7974961400032043,
0.2867383062839508,
-0.6368287205696106,
0.24812625348567963,
0.16537749767303467,
-0.3793194890022278,
-0.15054921805858612,
-0.5754674077033997,
0.6244592666625977,
0.06878543645143509,
0.09925603121519089,
-0.5791633129119873,
0.06768946349620819,
-0.07305414229631424,
-0.28369253873825073,
0.6227470636367798,
-0.35402512550354004,
-0.39948344230651855,
-0.5167554616928101,
-0.34601491689682007,
0.4621730446815491,
0.9564422369003296,
-0.9545600414276123,
0.5223996639251709,
0.17480379343032837,
0.08519100397825241,
-0.44943031668663025,
-0.7488266825675964,
0.0008222999167628586,
0.0009005890460684896,
-0.36541175842285156,
0.08418247103691101,
-0.12238204479217529,
0.0025688372552394867,
-0.36428356170654297,
-0.18853673338890076,
-0.048819925636053085,
-0.026157353073358536,
0.23791657388210297,
0.10908307135105133,
-0.20045576989650726,
-0.24614794552326202,
0.23908808827400208,
-0.2555278241634369,
0.27439817786216736,
-0.6180036067962646,
0.44417083263397217,
-0.2518965005874634,
-0.5053186416625977,
0.060293737798929214,
0.36460012197494507,
0.3387921452522278,
-0.43624576926231384,
0.4337962865829468,
0.33799564838409424,
-0.06579502671957016,
-0.6074257493019104,
-0.6847889423370361,
-0.28183406591415405,
-0.5261614918708801,
0.1134825348854065,
-0.5961936712265015,
-0.9476504325866699,
0.5554361343383789,
-0.26614683866500854,
-0.04925394803285599,
0.14508727192878723,
0.4776774048805237,
0.32535219192504883,
1.279154658317566,
0.5629163980484009,
0.12235666811466217,
0.39299657940864563,
-0.500299870967865,
0.33221960067749023,
-0.6754295825958252,
-0.016634047031402588,
-0.12777796387672424,
-0.025070123374462128,
-0.7097938060760498,
-0.5095009803771973,
0.2727974057197571,
0.2373785525560379,
-0.12878192961215973,
0.49865642189979553,
-1.0237714052200317,
0.6824280023574829,
0.614399790763855,
0.1933223307132721,
0.3774450421333313,
-0.1936856508255005,
-0.06454615294933319,
0.04607222229242325,
-0.8476264476776123,
-0.3748422861099243,
0.8735135197639465,
0.12150650471448898,
0.8642422556877136,
0.0478290319442749,
1.2710903882980347,
0.37364354729652405,
0.4525436758995056,
-0.12932440638542175,
0.5734987854957581,
-0.40564897656440735,
-0.4942854642868042,
0.13093167543411255,
-0.6641524434089661,
-0.25987255573272705,
0.24879083037376404,
0.3324456214904785,
-0.19987088441848755,
0.23704193532466888,
0.6766722798347473,
-0.4557831585407257,
0.12198979407548904,
-0.5403781533241272,
0.8311963081359863,
-0.27031436562538147,
-0.749739944934845,
-0.10810140520334244,
-0.5977823734283447,
0.33811455965042114,
-0.33058521151542664,
0.0422959141433239,
0.2640586197376251,
0.4233150780200958,
0.2864818572998047,
-0.6551892757415771,
0.6735737919807434,
-0.6199569702148438,
-0.3598688840866089,
0.6391691565513611,
0.3725518584251404,
0.4283677041530609,
0.3440650999546051,
-0.023112421855330467,
-0.009425853379070759,
0.012168005108833313,
-0.3813045024871826,
-0.7046244740486145,
0.6395875811576843,
-0.17229419946670532,
-0.6660735011100769,
-0.31219279766082764,
0.01158776506781578,
0.03809806704521179,
0.10238566249608994,
0.6336765289306641,
0.726854681968689,
0.0035470055881887674,
-0.12473665177822113,
0.7237139940261841,
-0.11442135274410248,
0.5007365345954895,
0.3822628855705261,
-0.5301277041435242,
-0.49307578802108765,
1.099548578262329,
-0.0648430809378624,
0.3865776062011719,
0.1941320300102234,
0.33155742287635803,
-0.20725025236606598,
-0.35051921010017395,
-0.6083182096481323,
-0.18576470017433167,
-0.7030377984046936,
-0.4164988696575165,
-0.42298081517219543,
-0.3209550976753235,
-0.355582594871521,
-0.1349090039730072,
-0.7557863593101501,
-0.5699719786643982,
0.012530229054391384,
0.08425045758485794,
0.25303915143013,
0.9814872145652771,
-0.24138832092285156,
-0.12640637159347534,
-1.169381856918335,
0.28980061411857605,
0.4239494800567627,
0.45306870341300964,
-0.053880322724580765,
-0.4461550712585449,
-0.3156309425830841,
0.0004687020555138588,
-0.4238961637020111,
-0.7675250768661499,
0.3369608521461487,
0.584244430065155,
0.37267616391181946,
0.5428668260574341,
0.3465827703475952,
0.6365820169448853,
-0.7060292363166809,
0.5904748439788818,
0.11983885616064072,
-1.2554566860198975,
0.7806742191314697,
-0.026655742898583412,
0.43444404006004333,
0.8549022674560547,
0.07007444649934769,
0.00800008699297905,
-0.5563291311264038,
-0.3294033110141754,
-0.5585523247718811,
0.2731185555458069,
0.23841454088687897,
0.1797683984041214,
-0.270307332277298,
0.546844482421875,
0.31953567266464233,
0.4740975499153137,
-0.4660682678222656,
-0.08647860586643219,
-0.7139053344726562,
-0.017050739377737045,
0.057218048721551895,
-0.14881476759910583,
0.021961642429232597,
-0.5599905252456665,
0.4566330015659332,
-0.3208373785018921,
0.3542095720767975,
0.26988184452056885,
-0.2867794930934906,
-0.0016375496052205563,
0.0901426300406456,
0.8154447674751282,
0.9083772301673889,
-0.27539315819740295,
0.31963008642196655,
0.1349131166934967,
-0.8088006377220154,
0.21674370765686035,
0.10010053217411041,
-0.05199971795082092,
0.027920683845877647,
0.1481247991323471,
0.5697214603424072,
-0.004560013767331839,
-0.3220776617527008,
0.6173344850540161,
-0.006529598496854305,
-0.14390385150909424,
-0.3317502737045288,
0.3377772271633148,
-0.4543145000934601,
0.2502140402793884,
0.42810001969337463,
-0.01707291789352894,
0.5815050601959229,
-0.22998353838920593,
0.4153517186641693,
0.16027408838272095,
-0.19825449585914612,
-0.42237603664398193,
0.810075581073761,
0.2955198585987091,
0.006677160505205393,
0.5936610102653503,
-0.6886113286018372,
-1.009602665901184,
0.4958138167858124,
0.5287830233573914,
1.2018024921417236,
-0.27470168471336365,
0.014401792548596859,
0.5540096163749695,
-0.09501662105321884,
-0.06737913936376572,
0.3792523443698883,
-0.5936587452888489,
-0.3580702543258667,
-0.9092207551002502,
-0.7420886754989624,
-0.31322744488716125,
-0.29160958528518677,
-0.8984230160713196,
0.10384666174650192,
-0.6191757321357727,
-0.08532298356294632,
-0.32219448685646057,
-0.07705407589673996,
-0.5621740818023682,
-0.10203412175178528,
0.20311316847801208,
0.7469137907028198,
-0.5025337338447571,
0.9592673778533936,
0.5917771458625793,
-0.40872228145599365,
-0.5758360624313354,
-0.12462922185659409,
0.08106036484241486,
-0.4219679832458496,
0.8030174374580383,
0.44841277599334717,
-0.5553961992263794,
0.24591132998466492,
-0.47828564047813416,
-0.496237576007843,
0.746970534324646,
0.4433594346046448,
-0.7757983207702637,
0.07548124343156815,
0.10095922648906708,
0.5321191549301147,
-0.43278488516807556,
0.16607274115085602,
0.5783550143241882,
0.2395312786102295,
0.13914743065834045,
-0.5854731798171997,
0.24192894995212555,
-0.4477507770061493,
0.1892164796590805,
0.5954565405845642,
-0.6664257645606995,
0.411807119846344,
-0.4059595465660095,
0.03762705624103546,
-0.09085874259471893,
0.5775586366653442,
0.5057735443115234,
0.26896825432777405,
0.20343288779258728,
0.545966386795044,
0.2370794713497162,
-0.10704966634511948,
0.8031216859817505,
-0.742195725440979,
0.5570623278617859,
1.374523401260376,
-0.4146631956100464,
0.6196832656860352,
0.4124031960964203,
-0.28167203068733215,
0.6648949384689331,
0.07044514268636703,
-0.13147374987602234,
0.8204910159111023,
0.563724935054779,
-0.49552854895591736,
-0.284467488527298,
0.5226911306381226,
-0.6472400426864624,
0.3891463875770569,
0.020321333780884743,
-0.30187535285949707,
-0.06361039727926254,
-0.02498132921755314,
-0.21472039818763733,
0.0343802310526371,
0.046514641493558884,
0.8292091488838196,
0.16665923595428467,
-0.7525470852851868,
0.6052206754684448,
-0.5278644561767578,
0.5060352683067322,
-0.42956313490867615,
-0.6763201355934143,
-0.3856976330280304,
0.6981598138809204,
-0.1882074624300003,
-0.5224514603614807,
0.3321855962276459,
0.019875045865774155,
-0.13151951134204865,
-0.6424928307533264,
0.6650549173355103,
-0.34459125995635986,
-0.40439051389694214,
0.372449666261673,
0.3272711932659149,
-0.028293032199144363,
-0.24672503769397736,
-0.33410242199897766,
-0.07122746855020523,
0.05255991593003273,
-0.41670796275138855,
0.21926286816596985,
0.42222657799720764,
0.4506155252456665,
0.4379607141017914,
0.5095561742782593,
-0.12740826606750488,
0.6117061376571655,
0.2559296786785126,
1.133558750152588,
-0.5448835492134094,
-0.37708374857902527,
-0.8424882292747498,
0.5018007755279541,
-0.12228448688983917,
-0.35256022214889526,
0.8023486733436584,
0.8990558981895447,
0.8814989924430847,
-0.3637954592704773,
0.6000061631202698,
-0.08118792623281479,
0.3585098385810852,
-0.4961298108100891,
0.6647903919219971,
-0.38599202036857605,
0.34309330582618713,
-0.5093923211097717,
-1.2362722158432007,
-0.27927395701408386,
0.8013113737106323,
0.009524691849946976,
0.2552044689655304,
0.3882867097854614,
0.6327474117279053,
-0.05006222054362297,
-0.015100086107850075,
0.1361558735370636,
-0.12821519374847412,
0.5446048974990845,
0.6216187477111816,
1.0733152627944946,
-0.34496593475341797,
0.28259965777397156,
-0.47759079933166504,
-0.2891712486743927,
-0.030122539028525352,
-1.1487669944763184,
-0.6171905398368835,
-0.5302627682685852,
-0.5815737843513489,
-0.5528383255004883,
0.11256632953882217,
0.8260422348976135,
0.8788586258888245,
-0.8357512950897217,
-0.18575364351272583,
-0.5874470472335815,
-0.46117526292800903,
-0.1788310408592224,
-0.18548955023288727,
0.06263405829668045,
-0.47564977407455444,
-0.379484087228775,
0.3307706117630005,
0.42121127247810364,
-0.22906681895256042,
-0.4840773344039917,
-0.4377705454826355,
0.09567833691835403,
0.14408966898918152,
0.6148526668548584,
0.31169626116752625,
-0.3587682545185089,
-0.09156613796949387,
-0.05872993916273117,
0.10609661042690277,
0.2489473819732666,
1.2507250308990479,
-1.002066969871521,
0.6635909080505371,
0.5006713271141052,
0.4801664352416992,
0.9364559650421143,
0.18252484500408173,
0.44290000200271606,
-0.7160581350326538,
-0.10920698940753937,
0.4512746334075928,
0.11494678258895874,
0.14065691828727722,
-0.37102222442626953,
0.703209400177002,
-0.04531757906079292,
-0.5684146881103516,
-0.7957050800323486,
0.2078334391117096,
-0.6073400378227234,
-0.02200368419289589,
0.6861714720726013,
-0.3532177209854126,
0.09837351739406586,
0.23627614974975586,
-0.0005498765385709703,
0.29627057909965515,
-0.29585081338882446,
0.8594524264335632,
0.3919273912906647,
-0.30198511481285095,
-0.3716464638710022,
-0.3372245132923126,
0.7256409525871277,
0.4328758120536804,
-0.7400477528572083,
-0.0687394067645073,
0.5327140092849731,
0.17730802297592163,
0.35639527440071106,
0.5723790526390076,
-0.271626353263855,
0.4861583113670349,
0.07072442770004272,
0.22326108813285828,
-0.30038022994995117,
-0.5764986276626587,
-0.44664904475212097,
0.12132687866687775,
0.11090032756328583,
-0.2821897864341736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17052v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17052v2
|
SelfCP: Compressing Over-Limit Prompt via the Frozen Large Language Model Itself
| 2024-05-27T11:14:55 | 2024-06-18T06:50:30 |
Jun Gao, Ziqiang Cao, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Long prompt leads to huge hardware costs when using transformer-based Large
Language Models (LLMs). Unfortunately, many tasks, such as summarization,
inevitably introduce long documents, and the wide application of in-context
learning easily makes the prompt length explode. This paper proposes a
Self-Compressor (SelfCP), which employs the target LLM itself to compress
over-limit prompts into dense vectors while keeping the allowed prompts
unmodified. Dense vectors are then projected into dense tokens via a learnable
connector to make the same LLM unburden to understand. The connector is
supervised-tuned under the language modeling objective of the LLM on relatively
long texts selected from publicly accessed datasets, involving an instruction
dataset to make SelfCP respond to various prompts, while the target LLM keeps
frozen during training. We build the lightweight SelfCP upon 2 different
backbones with merely 17M learnable parameters originating from the connector
and a learnable embedding. Evaluation on both English and Chinese benchmarks
demonstrate that SelfCP effectively substitutes 12$\times$ over-limit prompts
with dense tokens to reduce memory costs and booster inference throughputs, yet
improving response quality. The outstanding performance brings an efficient
solution for LLMs to tackle long prompts without training LLMs from scratch.
|
[
-0.49187764525413513,
-0.42314356565475464,
0.5273448824882507,
0.46949368715286255,
-0.3860691487789154,
-0.04852963984012604,
-0.5376359224319458,
-0.060879144817590714,
0.33286094665527344,
0.5129408240318298,
-0.6075264811515808,
0.010401151143014431,
-0.25168099999427795,
0.3523592948913574,
-0.2975803315639496,
0.8795104622840881,
0.11186893284320831,
-0.3152502477169037,
-0.30250084400177,
0.17148420214653015,
-0.6600251793861389,
-0.5330443978309631,
-0.6534827947616577,
-0.06714951246976852,
0.3893442749977112,
0.5999093651771545,
0.4427107870578766,
0.6826707720756531,
-0.13347071409225464,
0.35731521248817444,
0.095868319272995,
-0.06869776546955109,
-0.534105122089386,
0.44211745262145996,
0.08283501118421555,
-0.14873720705509186,
-0.29072150588035583,
-0.14743788540363312,
0.824442982673645,
0.42361924052238464,
-0.007812483236193657,
0.21550753712654114,
0.43452921509742737,
0.7312192320823669,
-0.528972327709198,
0.2423945814371109,
-0.33977648615837097,
-0.010813958942890167,
-0.15044336020946503,
-0.07563184201717377,
-0.6223147511482239,
0.29686442017555237,
-0.27851834893226624,
-0.2980598211288452,
0.18238897621631622,
0.11718422919511795,
0.2849779725074768,
0.616862952709198,
-0.25759273767471313,
-0.17555983364582062,
-0.35277390480041504,
0.7459797859191895,
-0.4582090377807617,
0.4292879104614258,
0.2503000497817993,
0.4023207426071167,
-0.14643815159797668,
-0.6142073273658752,
-0.46547946333885193,
-0.10951881855726242,
-0.0902194082736969,
0.29201802611351013,
-0.23286493122577667,
-0.040209077298641205,
0.35619524121284485,
0.2573787569999695,
-0.7271996140480042,
0.5164092183113098,
-0.6426618695259094,
-0.21089866757392883,
0.39615583419799805,
0.26029324531555176,
0.27965861558914185,
-0.4429982602596283,
-0.5556170344352722,
0.05940260365605354,
-0.6608737707138062,
0.14673404395580292,
0.2293291538953781,
0.4722591042518616,
-0.23482367396354675,
0.44060686230659485,
-0.24456553161144257,
0.773598313331604,
0.4104481339454651,
-0.03142853453755379,
0.2955072522163391,
0.1977609246969223,
-0.3188580870628357,
0.18625251948833466,
1.0602055788040161,
0.3171023726463318,
0.051472608000040054,
-0.11513958871364594,
-0.2984349727630615,
-0.35512134432792664,
0.17408867180347443,
-1.0269933938980103,
-0.0006677929777652025,
0.4412773549556732,
-0.4519411325454712,
0.10374147444963455,
-0.4417024552822113,
-0.9052560925483704,
-0.14090462028980255,
-0.27041855454444885,
0.06867749989032745,
-0.24772650003433228,
0.09118179231882095,
0.04288967326283455,
0.08674298226833344,
-0.014487925916910172,
0.2535812556743622,
-1.0345224142074585,
0.14408445358276367,
0.4567107558250427,
1.011550784111023,
-0.4352356493473053,
-0.42691805958747864,
-0.7577626705169678,
0.004767338279634714,
-0.18310049176216125,
0.7603873014450073,
-0.26385006308555603,
-0.45509031414985657,
0.013416205532848835,
0.052274782210588455,
0.10343372821807861,
-0.28393006324768066,
0.6712678670883179,
-0.4119982421398163,
0.38583582639694214,
-0.124428391456604,
-0.6464753150939941,
0.39291131496429443,
0.2462836354970932,
-0.6596336364746094,
0.9590839147567749,
0.006563299801200628,
-0.573772668838501,
0.03091551922261715,
-0.1884937286376953,
-0.39621827006340027,
0.36692818999290466,
-0.2018580436706543,
-0.22747108340263367,
-0.05669967830181122,
0.5693678259849548,
0.9180300235748291,
-0.5589836239814758,
0.4327293038368225,
-0.14368414878845215,
-0.22620894014835358,
-0.00470948638394475,
-0.5352041125297546,
0.6137990951538086,
0.4685906171798706,
0.018639743328094482,
0.11991307884454727,
-0.5877666473388672,
-0.242178276181221,
0.13518565893173218,
-0.4692910611629486,
-0.009620054624974728,
-0.42694127559661865,
-0.3508269190788269,
0.3975472152233124,
0.4775206744670868,
-0.5699039697647095,
0.5114022493362427,
-0.44420284032821655,
0.509553074836731,
0.5474384427070618,
-0.31459081172943115,
0.5109323263168335,
-0.13825523853302002,
0.7572528123855591,
-0.2634795308113098,
0.1706046164035797,
-0.785990834236145,
-0.24186255037784576,
-0.6673048138618469,
-0.6130816340446472,
0.05929093062877655,
0.2865314185619354,
-0.8747580647468567,
0.6479940414428711,
-0.3150292932987213,
-0.4951624274253845,
-0.3769911825656891,
0.3059377074241638,
0.14360439777374268,
0.8499311804771423,
0.7250469326972961,
0.09432725608348846,
-0.19990050792694092,
-0.6536730527877808,
0.004504496231675148,
-0.17691195011138916,
-0.3929137885570526,
0.18130071461200714,
0.10713651776313782,
0.1296096295118332,
0.9606496691703796,
-0.5038256645202637,
-0.653485119342804,
-0.5261188745498657,
0.2610861361026764,
0.5970665812492371,
0.6312614679336548,
0.5004608631134033,
-0.249488964676857,
-0.5633803606033325,
-0.6595114469528198,
-0.5167656540870667,
-0.4098562002182007,
-0.6168316006660461,
0.3984115719795227,
0.19490616023540497,
1.0086712837219238,
-0.7567684650421143,
-0.011642511002719402,
0.6171910166740417,
-0.1873249113559723,
0.6103667616844177,
-0.45929381251335144,
-0.1353304088115692,
-1.010388970375061,
-0.05548730865120888,
-0.21801775693893433,
-0.304214745759964,
-0.3759722411632538,
-0.05633019283413887,
0.5226999521255493,
-0.6004734635353088,
-0.5529826879501343,
0.7420883774757385,
-0.863187313079834,
0.13699346780776978,
-0.48760682344436646,
0.08436649292707443,
0.00011134064698126167,
0.7136099338531494,
-0.023637359961867332,
0.8203235864639282,
0.6605967283248901,
-0.5257523059844971,
0.5427629947662354,
0.16372935473918915,
-0.09944570064544678,
0.40441522002220154,
-0.7805042266845703,
0.08742061257362366,
-0.39906102418899536,
0.6373519897460938,
-1.0140581130981445,
0.008840195834636688,
0.22248739004135132,
-0.3212777376174927,
0.624669075012207,
-0.37891173362731934,
-0.5057061314582825,
-0.6395784616470337,
-0.3300592303276062,
0.6431131362915039,
0.7035043239593506,
-0.9510077238082886,
0.8488999605178833,
0.013712766580283642,
-0.12609222531318665,
-0.5022866129875183,
-0.7622227668762207,
0.2481793612241745,
-0.2442650943994522,
-0.39631402492523193,
0.18925580382347107,
-0.49972498416900635,
0.5190479755401611,
-0.4589446485042572,
0.19546158611774445,
0.1256185919046402,
-0.07942387461662292,
0.36112603545188904,
0.1287379264831543,
-0.052588969469070435,
0.6057708859443665,
0.19380046427249908,
-0.2614951431751251,
0.2574383616447449,
-0.34592244029045105,
0.6307384967803955,
0.012967715971171856,
-0.20888620615005493,
-0.26536300778388977,
0.3827263414859772,
0.6148123741149902,
-0.1412053108215332,
0.6166568994522095,
0.28818848729133606,
-0.09869355708360672,
-0.36649566888809204,
-0.656613290309906,
-0.15867605805397034,
-0.5720148086547852,
0.0857144370675087,
-0.47079527378082275,
-1.0932879447937012,
0.4624568819999695,
-0.140091672539711,
0.027238668873906136,
0.4986799955368042,
0.5573538541793823,
0.11153572797775269,
0.6616412997245789,
0.3702199161052704,
-0.450076699256897,
0.30062243342399597,
-0.1116780936717987,
-0.08623643964529037,
-0.7330649495124817,
0.031076451763510704,
-0.534140408039093,
-0.07493410259485245,
-0.12809160351753235,
-0.6555216908454895,
0.34379374980926514,
0.0571720227599144,
-0.3257808983325958,
0.3521212935447693,
-0.5908199548721313,
0.530518114566803,
0.2456086128950119,
-0.17527824640274048,
-0.024309193715453148,
-0.29940715432167053,
-0.21802569925785065,
-0.1534242331981659,
-0.9978553652763367,
0.04873838648200035,
0.7251643538475037,
0.5656507611274719,
1.1383229494094849,
-0.13309213519096375,
0.7229308485984802,
0.21230977773666382,
0.01985827647149563,
-0.7424830794334412,
0.5010417699813843,
-0.04188151657581329,
-0.25562506914138794,
-0.5520687699317932,
-0.3882448971271515,
-1.0095360279083252,
-0.03883212432265282,
-0.059428997337818146,
-0.5837996006011963,
0.08615002036094666,
0.31307756900787354,
-0.4488149583339691,
0.1415962278842926,
-0.48109063506126404,
0.7794113159179688,
-0.31991785764694214,
-0.12694151699543,
-0.06254739314317703,
-0.7326040267944336,
0.3059340715408325,
-0.24193955957889557,
0.09973934292793274,
-0.03647862747311592,
-0.08988774567842484,
0.6350731253623962,
-0.5006508231163025,
1.2552169561386108,
0.08223631232976913,
-0.23681630194187164,
0.38858968019485474,
0.2217751145362854,
0.6571403741836548,
0.051546256989240646,
-0.046838514506816864,
0.09707580506801605,
-0.43018949031829834,
-0.3206658661365509,
-0.9391534924507141,
0.7981829643249512,
-0.6861572265625,
-0.7040014266967773,
-0.3049114942550659,
-0.4144025146961212,
0.06985680013895035,
0.20338530838489532,
0.29546335339546204,
0.8374175429344177,
0.10547225922346115,
0.1145956739783287,
0.41143959760665894,
-0.27702656388282776,
0.7332609295845032,
0.6868987083435059,
-0.23425845801830292,
-0.47388482093811035,
0.835028350353241,
0.1628795564174652,
0.25232166051864624,
0.3963529169559479,
0.5192429423332214,
-0.49682408571243286,
-0.19577562808990479,
-0.7202054262161255,
0.2846357226371765,
-0.8190634250640869,
-0.6574950814247131,
-0.9103670120239258,
-0.24306322634220123,
-0.602620005607605,
-0.3909141719341278,
-0.6269592046737671,
-0.5079886317253113,
-0.6652612686157227,
0.11591280996799469,
0.15880224108695984,
0.3379403352737427,
-0.22536218166351318,
0.3545147180557251,
-0.9016323685646057,
0.44168832898139954,
0.5709343552589417,
0.26549261808395386,
0.08427469432353973,
-0.9568946957588196,
-0.21723483502864838,
-0.4378160536289215,
-0.027693569660186768,
-0.6676822900772095,
0.6360025405883789,
0.21161781251430511,
0.3495514690876007,
0.5295130014419556,
0.6966689825057983,
0.7073795199394226,
-0.574506938457489,
0.9630780816078186,
0.4542636573314667,
-1.0869947671890259,
0.36627987027168274,
-0.08991371095180511,
0.9100024700164795,
0.38379016518592834,
0.6049006581306458,
-0.5940268635749817,
-0.5517629981040955,
-0.38468870520591736,
-0.9203409552574158,
0.3704610764980316,
-0.1614556461572647,
0.3518662750720978,
-0.41682982444763184,
0.4165254533290863,
0.08489528298377991,
-0.00523804547265172,
-0.6397435665130615,
-0.2700555920600891,
-0.4656631648540497,
-0.21189387142658234,
-0.19681279361248016,
-0.6783508658409119,
0.2565063238143921,
-0.08405321836471558,
0.5764612555503845,
-0.6514102220535278,
0.134787917137146,
0.4380896985530853,
-0.09358824044466019,
-0.1105899065732956,
0.39959684014320374,
0.37425753474235535,
0.23995094001293182,
0.10125558823347092,
0.3723175823688507,
0.5209211111068726,
-0.04511544853448868,
-0.05247674882411957,
0.05009011551737785,
0.05496259778738022,
-0.2465187907218933,
0.3457906246185303,
0.48784756660461426,
0.19759181141853333,
-0.7422329187393188,
0.6862878203392029,
-0.34018436074256897,
0.14344166219234467,
-0.33495351672172546,
-0.20219403505325317,
-0.020815297961235046,
0.17610839009284973,
0.43052423000335693,
-0.3927077054977417,
0.1644221842288971,
-0.2029801458120346,
0.16162432730197906,
0.375225305557251,
-0.41115695238113403,
-0.11758098751306534,
0.6877943277359009,
0.5048530101776123,
-0.15410976111888885,
0.7825811505317688,
-0.13120922446250916,
-0.7081451416015625,
0.2583176791667938,
0.8315348029136658,
0.7473143339157104,
-0.351576566696167,
0.03844056278467178,
0.5599961280822754,
0.26945942640304565,
-0.13880027830600739,
-0.011859370395541191,
-0.5343418717384338,
-0.4723895192146301,
-0.8106091022491455,
-0.48168933391571045,
-0.14545266330242157,
0.15467439591884613,
-0.48925817012786865,
0.549583911895752,
-0.4919302761554718,
0.14089545607566833,
-0.4540616273880005,
-0.24918849766254425,
-0.3770604729652405,
0.2751320004463196,
0.2027866244316101,
1.0905115604400635,
-0.7694992423057556,
0.8212618231773376,
0.03908892348408699,
-0.22573012113571167,
-0.8159559369087219,
-0.2491666078567505,
-0.19552090764045715,
-0.8911572694778442,
0.7078507542610168,
0.46739062666893005,
-0.04138275235891342,
-0.10418160259723663,
-0.5724002122879028,
-0.9109780788421631,
0.8136082291603088,
0.49922290444374084,
-0.8581279516220093,
0.04272041469812393,
0.06096063181757927,
0.4631774127483368,
-0.3565335273742676,
0.41496559977531433,
0.279556542634964,
0.2137562483549118,
0.21845389902591705,
-0.9129438996315002,
0.43031877279281616,
-0.062102220952510834,
-0.4380832314491272,
0.220858633518219,
-0.9609411954879761,
0.7965371012687683,
-0.12451493740081787,
-0.34704920649528503,
0.044998761266469955,
1.1799196004867554,
0.03362241014838219,
-0.11350040137767792,
0.6948362588882446,
0.4203696846961975,
0.514365553855896,
0.49431905150413513,
0.7517479062080383,
-0.7345814108848572,
0.4446909427642822,
1.3414912223815918,
-0.11229702830314636,
0.5966674089431763,
0.46673548221588135,
0.22061201930046082,
0.23423700034618378,
0.2948807179927826,
-0.15905189514160156,
0.1827116310596466,
0.3041158616542816,
-0.06334265321493149,
-0.6443367600440979,
-0.13586780428886414,
-0.27686840295791626,
0.2674635350704193,
0.2527586817741394,
-0.27411556243896484,
-0.3416729271411896,
0.11889144778251648,
0.08945228159427643,
-0.06309306621551514,
-0.26621684432029724,
0.5948116779327393,
0.2815846800804138,
-0.8997367024421692,
0.7952307462692261,
-0.21550166606903076,
0.6863762736320496,
-0.5492265820503235,
0.18020904064178467,
-0.09131703525781631,
-0.23045854270458221,
0.006222766824066639,
-0.898358166217804,
0.10709778964519501,
-0.038758907467126846,
-0.011012588627636433,
-0.7190570831298828,
0.8286204934120178,
-0.560359001159668,
-0.43710198998451233,
0.34488755464553833,
0.44630369544029236,
0.43100664019584656,
-0.18712911009788513,
-0.6390383839607239,
0.04909920319914818,
-0.21824173629283905,
-0.3295668363571167,
0.35892677307128906,
0.5009093284606934,
0.34635409712791443,
1.086319923400879,
0.4462251663208008,
0.017969898879528046,
-0.161374032497406,
0.12799745798110962,
1.290877342224121,
-0.598545253276825,
-0.8224196434020996,
-0.7981014847755432,
0.43440908193588257,
0.12914060056209564,
-0.33810392022132874,
0.6759148240089417,
0.5230811834335327,
0.41317230463027954,
-0.01882549375295639,
0.4666714072227478,
0.16039985418319702,
0.37914329767227173,
-0.6431601047515869,
0.6285918354988098,
-0.5748205184936523,
0.1693032681941986,
0.07374356687068939,
-0.5716493725776672,
-0.23486490547657013,
0.16222043335437775,
-0.05573692545294762,
-0.0698717013001442,
0.5335502624511719,
0.36864766478538513,
-0.05941396206617355,
-0.31034567952156067,
0.6843528747558594,
0.18852609395980835,
0.3643195927143097,
0.45166727900505066,
0.7456731796264648,
-0.03661327809095383,
0.7079228758811951,
-0.1728857010602951,
-0.15859901905059814,
-0.16213257610797882,
-1.0946279764175415,
-1.4420007467269897,
-0.5982909798622131,
-0.2683601975440979,
-0.19107776880264282,
-0.2527344524860382,
1.1409448385238647,
0.687941312789917,
-0.4772116541862488,
-0.08555237203836441,
0.11492825299501419,
-0.02117103524506092,
0.1289260983467102,
-0.21567459404468536,
0.3773287534713745,
-0.8488888740539551,
-0.5566405057907104,
0.8007796406745911,
0.2466307282447815,
0.20728297531604767,
-0.6191374063491821,
-0.026755109429359436,
0.2776252031326294,
-0.06430376321077347,
0.46229270100593567,
0.5632412433624268,
-0.47346368432044983,
-0.22013288736343384,
-0.07381810247898102,
0.025436267256736755,
0.13954085111618042,
0.9470188021659851,
-1.2205967903137207,
0.6105467081069946,
0.4480818808078766,
0.6927770376205444,
0.4772031605243683,
-0.02782399393618107,
0.7559528946876526,
-1.0096701383590698,
0.09172223508358002,
0.08818911761045456,
0.6195187568664551,
0.4359787106513977,
-0.6932495832443237,
0.10727090388536453,
-0.11974834650754929,
-0.9159964919090271,
-0.5288189053535461,
0.2269837111234665,
-0.9678221344947815,
-0.5395390391349792,
1.0382052659988403,
-0.3246254026889801,
-0.3614744246006012,
-0.15701192617416382,
-0.2617969810962677,
0.21105916798114777,
-0.7784076929092407,
0.8081641793251038,
0.22173893451690674,
-0.042755015194416046,
-0.3686981201171875,
-0.02509412355720997,
0.48727184534072876,
0.4994153678417206,
-0.6210364699363708,
0.43702802062034607,
0.4129369258880615,
0.09663990139961243,
0.32158032059669495,
0.5484798550605774,
0.40949004888534546,
0.1929130107164383,
-0.3098338544368744,
0.19685980677604675,
-0.36656245589256287,
-0.6265771389007568,
-0.7438622713088989,
0.3544021248817444,
-0.16561323404312134,
0.08237694948911667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17044v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17044v1
|
Generation and human-expert evaluation of interesting research ideas using knowledge graphs and large language models
| 2024-05-27T11:00:51 | 2024-05-27T11:00:51 |
Xuemei Gu, Mario Krenn
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG
|
Advanced artificial intelligence (AI) systems with access to millions of
research papers could inspire new research ideas that may not be conceived by
humans alone. However, how interesting are these AI-generated ideas, and how
can we improve their quality? Here, we introduce SciMuse, a system that uses an
evolving knowledge graph built from more than 58 million scientific papers to
generate personalized research ideas via an interface to GPT-4. We conducted a
large-scale human evaluation with over 100 research group leaders from the Max
Planck Society, who ranked more than 4,000 personalized research ideas based on
their level of interest. This evaluation allows us to understand the
relationships between scientific interest and the core properties of the
knowledge graph. We find that data-efficient machine learning can predict
research interest with high precision, allowing us to optimize the
interest-level of generated research ideas. This work represents a step towards
an artificial scientific muse that could catalyze unforeseen collaborations and
suggest interesting avenues for scientists.
|
[
-0.5330749154090881,
-0.439064621925354,
0.8638314604759216,
0.02961110509932041,
-0.10259868204593658,
0.33481255173683167,
-0.13420464098453522,
-0.49218517541885376,
0.5311640501022339,
-0.05520804226398468,
-0.27285313606262207,
-0.29279232025146484,
-0.5120440721511841,
0.18832507729530334,
-0.48846304416656494,
0.9829872250556946,
0.18062186241149902,
0.08942490071058273,
-0.41672489047050476,
0.14470131695270538,
-0.03683527186512947,
-0.22227144241333008,
-0.48968857526779175,
-0.26535800099372864,
0.8039228916168213,
0.3227219581604004,
0.48189494013786316,
0.31366297602653503,
0.6721928119659424,
0.36098310351371765,
-0.07348745316267014,
0.13064967095851898,
-0.5763041973114014,
0.05128655955195427,
-0.3907429873943329,
-0.3613344430923462,
-0.4091615676879883,
0.19058175384998322,
0.36945223808288574,
0.7665013670921326,
0.24438442289829254,
0.24799634516239166,
-0.015949750319123268,
0.4839392602443695,
-0.2360205054283142,
0.29269319772720337,
-0.43798843026161194,
0.07269255071878433,
-0.366180419921875,
-0.3138910233974457,
-0.2922126352787018,
-0.4787161946296692,
0.3664720356464386,
-0.7658237218856812,
0.2590290606021881,
0.17317044734954834,
0.764636754989624,
-0.011950922198593616,
-0.04151775687932968,
-0.31167104840278625,
-0.6729234457015991,
0.5278399586677551,
-0.4937536418437958,
-0.06263373792171478,
-0.07983774691820145,
0.329306423664093,
-0.6103950142860413,
-0.8951696157455444,
-0.5537269115447998,
-0.3817051947116852,
0.14373670518398285,
0.1328275501728058,
-0.43427300453186035,
-0.15153414011001587,
0.3135748505592346,
-0.0937633290886879,
-0.7825354933738708,
-0.07383419573307037,
-0.42242804169654846,
0.05435986444354057,
0.7873502969741821,
-0.05640338733792305,
0.22662444412708282,
-0.1370924562215805,
0.03104400634765625,
-0.22510014474391937,
-0.2895583510398865,
-0.08939468115568161,
0.3974001407623291,
-0.2504437267780304,
0.5978246331214905,
0.6520170569419861,
-0.5318918824195862,
0.3101741373538971,
0.19781050086021423,
0.24725955724716187,
0.3978950083255768,
-0.3486020267009735,
0.13690420985221863,
-0.10629674792289734,
0.9561672806739807,
0.11879248917102814,
-0.031016433611512184,
-0.5030620098114014,
-0.04522082209587097,
0.14235325157642365,
0.17719973623752594,
-0.8686508536338806,
-0.4441097676753998,
0.1428612917661667,
-0.2621464133262634,
-0.48181766271591187,
0.3069904148578644,
-0.6003228425979614,
-0.6273947954177856,
0.00710113113746047,
0.3345469832420349,
-0.5551550388336182,
-0.3134818971157074,
0.015199171379208565,
-0.6106193661689758,
-0.36681023240089417,
0.4553891122341156,
-0.6099328994750977,
0.056342702358961105,
0.6857249140739441,
0.6703333854675293,
-0.2239965796470642,
-0.45812228322029114,
-0.02286750078201294,
0.26259148120880127,
-0.3529483675956726,
0.9920510649681091,
-0.4318528175354004,
-0.36548903584480286,
-0.6456074714660645,
-0.39033424854278564,
0.01462363637983799,
-0.2378409057855606,
0.5365498661994934,
-0.6473020315170288,
0.5268601179122925,
-0.182367742061615,
-0.6143304109573364,
-0.21212026476860046,
-0.12062399834394455,
-0.4591060280799866,
0.6415808200836182,
0.20770178735256195,
-1.0118495225906372,
0.6266704201698303,
-1.5256876945495605,
-0.28180715441703796,
0.6318265199661255,
-0.30716198682785034,
-0.3686460852622986,
0.2855936288833618,
0.011681859381496906,
0.27182337641716003,
-0.4943526089191437,
0.8271404504776001,
-0.3789101541042328,
-0.0859820768237114,
0.4029269814491272,
-0.11789870262145996,
0.5080634355545044,
0.505137026309967,
-0.5905243754386902,
0.5300485491752625,
-0.537565290927887,
0.17636911571025848,
0.2831217646598816,
0.023371482267975807,
-0.4417968988418579,
-0.0780443623661995,
-0.07998932898044586,
0.10874742269515991,
0.35020485520362854,
-0.722356379032135,
0.3130300045013428,
-0.36733850836753845,
0.9051198959350586,
0.7031139135360718,
0.2895897626876831,
0.283905565738678,
-0.3394511044025421,
0.4019574820995331,
-0.2862659990787506,
-0.006080079823732376,
-0.0831398144364357,
-0.823732852935791,
-0.5139309763908386,
0.1258915513753891,
0.6261341571807861,
0.22163128852844238,
-0.3734579384326935,
0.3576740324497223,
-0.4224031865596771,
-0.8311905860900879,
-0.4783288538455963,
0.00951501727104187,
-0.0029204378370195627,
0.3859805166721344,
0.12858912348747253,
-0.4574761986732483,
-0.27488774061203003,
-1.0647540092468262,
-0.26375481486320496,
-0.13522829115390778,
-0.4541701376438141,
0.48209044337272644,
0.8098862171173096,
-0.23061461746692657,
1.2601966857910156,
-0.6474864482879639,
0.2813928425312042,
0.0921986922621727,
0.6642618179321289,
0.14673176407814026,
0.4185529947280884,
0.5222669243812561,
-0.9391441941261292,
-0.3814995586872101,
0.16934998333454132,
-0.8235092759132385,
0.02485024370253086,
0.04106130823493004,
-0.46371322870254517,
-0.2061016708612442,
0.1700577437877655,
-0.8504909873008728,
0.1457153558731079,
-0.07039394974708557,
-0.4751768410205841,
0.3998042047023773,
-0.15222042798995972,
0.4094547629356384,
-1.1182540655136108,
0.4948049783706665,
0.016963083297014236,
0.22665968537330627,
-0.47853755950927734,
-0.3779180645942688,
-0.10993462800979614,
-0.6076089143753052,
0.043418776243925095,
0.5912976861000061,
-0.30550581216812134,
-0.10506539791822433,
-0.26819565892219543,
0.2305537760257721,
-0.05623090639710426,
0.19184467196464539,
-0.07457683980464935,
0.4366622865200043,
0.3292730152606964,
-0.13632731139659882,
0.39545637369155884,
0.28154489398002625,
-0.5445890426635742,
0.20694591104984283,
-0.6650295853614807,
0.48000776767730713,
-0.13882941007614136,
0.24412134289741516,
-0.6414088606834412,
-0.6155573725700378,
0.020794035866856575,
-0.615676760673523,
0.01525359507650137,
0.2557988464832306,
-0.5239999294281006,
-0.7739272117614746,
-0.20443516969680786,
0.16178740561008453,
0.2335359901189804,
-0.3016791343688965,
0.4095371663570404,
0.5611580014228821,
-0.6894406080245972,
-0.28180646896362305,
-0.1451919972896576,
0.5259662866592407,
-0.2828391194343567,
-0.9698567986488342,
0.4701850414276123,
-0.16715553402900696,
-0.29934585094451904,
0.470793753862381,
0.21002893149852753,
0.10683225840330124,
0.270800918340683,
0.33051419258117676,
-0.01870390772819519,
-0.00895630568265915,
0.16649584472179413,
0.17736580967903137,
-0.15880398452281952,
0.3478355407714844,
-0.6334755420684814,
0.5048769116401672,
-0.2277069091796875,
-0.3633576035499573,
-0.29459378123283386,
0.2164207100868225,
0.651569128036499,
-0.14067339897155762,
0.16625864803791046,
0.793533444404602,
-0.4079025685787201,
-0.03617355599999428,
-0.30423349142074585,
-0.4558883607387543,
-0.4920240044593811,
0.6899678111076355,
-0.3772825300693512,
-0.7438558340072632,
0.2342042624950409,
-0.42320698499679565,
0.3072671890258789,
0.5999086499214172,
0.4969557225704193,
-0.3502769470214844,
1.2492964267730713,
0.6692342758178711,
-0.06148352473974228,
0.46614325046539307,
-0.40031829476356506,
0.28690141439437866,
-0.49843135476112366,
-0.2712970972061157,
-0.5801168084144592,
-0.477791428565979,
-0.4415496289730072,
-0.34910130500793457,
0.5644962191581726,
0.1681564897298813,
-0.18199428915977478,
0.17447581887245178,
-0.7377711534500122,
0.3907037079334259,
0.8260671496391296,
0.010386854410171509,
0.13938476145267487,
-0.027826562523841858,
-0.150046706199646,
0.163340762257576,
-0.9875193238258362,
-0.5928984880447388,
1.0116024017333984,
0.2076701670885086,
0.5217450261116028,
-0.24328207969665527,
0.7707051038742065,
0.7036850452423096,
0.7076752781867981,
-0.6681848764419556,
0.4838225841522217,
0.2945575416088104,
-0.5594677925109863,
-0.47508275508880615,
-0.6599932909011841,
-0.9634875655174255,
0.009761703200638294,
-0.4348606765270233,
-0.46252042055130005,
0.26980915665626526,
0.1699802279472351,
-0.20809732377529144,
0.21886488795280457,
-0.6806673407554626,
0.7691488265991211,
-0.6709672212600708,
-0.36922475695610046,
-0.5660554766654968,
-0.5689322352409363,
0.2994408905506134,
-0.42341408133506775,
0.09214748442173004,
0.05168844386935234,
0.29847949743270874,
1.2301398515701294,
0.027000894770026207,
0.45345285534858704,
-0.2966114282608032,
0.22520709037780762,
0.23036743700504303,
0.0903216004371643,
0.44234147667884827,
0.1138290986418724,
-0.29463067650794983,
0.03723989054560661,
-0.4879191517829895,
-0.44847196340560913,
-0.674694836139679,
0.7548428773880005,
-0.8529200553894043,
-0.8172051310539246,
-0.26278412342071533,
-0.8459597826004028,
-0.20291616022586823,
0.5074827075004578,
0.33145004510879517,
-0.04977290332317352,
-0.4456939995288849,
0.10163043439388275,
0.29362374544143677,
-0.11451678723096848,
0.20133143663406372,
0.3054131865501404,
0.05287998914718628,
-0.4665282368659973,
1.0909453630447388,
0.13223817944526672,
-0.14955170452594757,
0.13898040354251862,
0.3563309609889984,
-0.09442469477653503,
-0.8096238970756531,
-0.5173475742340088,
0.11379432678222656,
-0.421082079410553,
-0.09200309216976166,
-0.641849935054779,
0.1301296204328537,
-0.48013734817504883,
-0.2630036473274231,
-0.11777714639902115,
-0.6897493600845337,
-0.2349570393562317,
0.01111353188753128,
0.4074932038784027,
1.0143574476242065,
-0.16586776077747345,
-0.12568774819374084,
-0.5296575427055359,
0.03383452445268631,
0.3259904980659485,
0.12501893937587738,
-0.02017144486308098,
-0.18926845490932465,
-0.47204163670539856,
0.0845869779586792,
-0.5232892632484436,
-0.658512532711029,
0.4479648768901825,
0.06289345771074295,
0.6629679203033447,
0.6283606886863708,
-0.14070233702659607,
0.26915621757507324,
-0.4512348771095276,
0.5123170614242554,
0.3607783913612366,
-0.7030020952224731,
0.6599531173706055,
-0.6021139621734619,
-0.0022449009120464325,
0.4107639193534851,
0.635118842124939,
-0.3102464973926544,
-0.2976659834384918,
-0.8837290406227112,
-0.76351398229599,
0.32974672317504883,
0.1955341100692749,
-0.2206958681344986,
0.20346923172473907,
0.4475642144680023,
0.11409159749746323,
0.30094537138938904,
-0.42117011547088623,
0.30531880259513855,
-0.48704254627227783,
-0.22550088167190552,
0.06894797831773758,
0.19991980493068695,
-0.3595817983150482,
-0.1874479204416275,
0.6354344487190247,
-0.3288028836250305,
0.4070385694503784,
0.05861624702811241,
0.10767994821071625,
-0.36370784044265747,
0.25758254528045654,
0.5468379259109497,
0.9662798047065735,
-0.20599614083766937,
-0.06123000755906105,
0.07327017188072205,
-0.4047326445579529,
0.0316309928894043,
0.39627864956855774,
-0.5575812458992004,
-0.1607457995414734,
0.06603970378637314,
0.7938587069511414,
-0.1028309091925621,
-0.5933393836021423,
0.13014210760593414,
-0.2517102360725403,
-0.4185277223587036,
-0.1540030986070633,
0.4004610478878021,
0.4216861426830292,
0.27368804812431335,
0.6180228590965271,
0.5964385867118835,
0.1534382551908493,
-0.4806014597415924,
0.22080527245998383,
0.560109555721283,
-0.20805682241916656,
-0.4978902339935303,
0.8761025667190552,
0.38046351075172424,
-0.3719872236251831,
0.31173861026763916,
-0.2950904071331024,
-0.570336639881134,
0.6489130854606628,
0.325519859790802,
0.7919691801071167,
0.06600657850503922,
0.3261636197566986,
0.1322070211172104,
0.1413446068763733,
0.2214103788137436,
-0.04552331194281578,
0.0019153323955833912,
-0.6154472827911377,
-0.3615924119949341,
-0.6055647134780884,
-0.640765368938446,
0.14009098708629608,
-0.21445700526237488,
0.35481807589530945,
-0.18287421762943268,
-0.4330291152000427,
0.5268101692199707,
0.2872486114501953,
-0.579481303691864,
-0.1183381974697113,
-0.11873198300600052,
0.716143786907196,
-0.7933524250984192,
0.876028299331665,
0.9185982942581177,
-0.24916554987430573,
-0.507632851600647,
-0.305748850107193,
-0.2937370538711548,
-0.37544533610343933,
0.7786909937858582,
-0.020374678075313568,
-0.17427928745746613,
0.22090227901935577,
-0.6206961870193481,
-1.0371400117874146,
1.2238125801086426,
0.24665683507919312,
-0.5582610368728638,
-0.0421658456325531,
-0.05885491892695427,
0.7004408240318298,
-0.5947136878967285,
0.38498422503471375,
0.26927775144577026,
0.8898834586143494,
-0.060039862990379333,
-0.6325885653495789,
-0.2040358930826187,
-0.717679500579834,
-0.30195438861846924,
0.1836777627468109,
-0.5548569560050964,
0.6264849305152893,
-0.4978812336921692,
-0.14831265807151794,
0.05524947866797447,
0.780422568321228,
0.2597765624523163,
0.5425484776496887,
0.5540568828582764,
0.46726876497268677,
1.0729758739471436,
0.10926659405231476,
0.8902124762535095,
-0.5368477702140808,
0.15322278439998627,
0.7056636214256287,
-0.3280228078365326,
0.39667442440986633,
0.2020673155784607,
0.08349625766277313,
0.386668860912323,
0.6834413409233093,
-0.4602881669998169,
0.35905545949935913,
0.20677991211414337,
-0.19210609793663025,
-0.08351202309131622,
-0.1919524222612381,
-0.2353893518447876,
0.28000152111053467,
0.5181448459625244,
-0.44428104162216187,
0.02531116083264351,
0.26602062582969666,
-0.01038065180182457,
-0.08163689076900482,
-0.014889687299728394,
0.6547784209251404,
-0.17821109294891357,
-0.7502686977386475,
0.35094958543777466,
0.013288588263094425,
0.5256561636924744,
-0.5338459014892578,
-0.07135136425495148,
0.0032440396025776863,
-0.06261447817087173,
-0.19964218139648438,
-0.7198562622070312,
-0.1806328445672989,
0.15971046686172485,
-0.2661112844944,
-0.11459194123744965,
0.7769491672515869,
-0.07461664825677872,
-0.3788149356842041,
-0.024056293070316315,
0.6097440123558044,
0.3244807720184326,
0.20592467486858368,
-0.6968795657157898,
-0.4789128303527832,
0.07206232845783234,
-0.5342536568641663,
0.46343663334846497,
0.5189954042434692,
-0.2720220386981964,
0.7510530352592468,
0.8336544036865234,
0.17964625358581543,
-0.2645988464355469,
-0.17535023391246796,
1.156238079071045,
-0.7364564538002014,
-0.45211902260780334,
-0.44732028245925903,
0.07774792611598969,
-0.3706038296222687,
-0.5528559684753418,
0.8918222188949585,
0.6664162874221802,
0.5921298861503601,
-0.09870868176221848,
1.1500035524368286,
-0.2729015052318573,
0.5747333765029907,
0.1893777698278427,
0.9916672706604004,
-0.22514984011650085,
0.026227883994579315,
-0.4944854974746704,
-0.8639203906059265,
-0.18738654255867004,
0.5433357357978821,
-0.47810080647468567,
-0.06524999439716339,
0.5074813365936279,
0.4856187701225281,
-0.07262667268514633,
0.2804461717605591,
-0.002049199305474758,
0.3448037803173065,
0.6766241788864136,
0.33809608221054077,
0.8980322480201721,
0.25767961144447327,
0.4309690594673157,
-0.32704317569732666,
-0.630613386631012,
-0.23577596247196198,
-0.6856967210769653,
-0.5832212567329407,
-0.5777050256729126,
-0.1071358248591423,
-0.058773528784513474,
-0.021946821361780167,
0.7911646962165833,
0.7548179030418396,
-0.7383823394775391,
-0.19833751022815704,
-0.30312663316726685,
-0.10664002597332001,
-0.04403970018029213,
-0.2512754797935486,
0.6857923269271851,
-0.12840764224529266,
-0.6702987551689148,
0.6725445985794067,
0.3049204349517822,
-0.14979538321495056,
-0.4878937304019928,
-0.1349257379770279,
-0.029531706124544144,
0.03844156861305237,
0.5680694580078125,
0.38612765073776245,
-0.1686674803495407,
-0.16828908026218414,
0.2468169629573822,
0.009880093857645988,
-0.1814335435628891,
1.0014562606811523,
-0.8434290885925293,
0.40553101897239685,
0.684650182723999,
0.6268634796142578,
0.7409080862998962,
0.06479015946388245,
0.6722197532653809,
-0.09306379407644272,
0.01621522381901741,
0.7771651148796082,
0.36150941252708435,
0.18518707156181335,
-0.2818729877471924,
0.6805750131607056,
0.4336051642894745,
-0.9439760446548462,
-0.8591820001602173,
0.024957001209259033,
-0.7377976179122925,
-0.369241863489151,
0.5754217505455017,
-0.27249810099601746,
-0.38041526079177856,
-0.09678936749696732,
-0.28179240226745605,
0.06305912882089615,
-0.5939919352531433,
1.3046088218688965,
0.4313215911388397,
-0.8298080563545227,
0.3180449903011322,
-0.6541810035705566,
0.5099225640296936,
0.608218789100647,
-1.0067074298858643,
-0.14945101737976074,
0.43753698468208313,
0.2056124359369278,
0.7313116192817688,
0.2336249202489853,
0.06374631822109222,
0.38765713572502136,
-0.0962429940700531,
0.2830291986465454,
-0.26573851704597473,
-0.34315958619117737,
0.3417978584766388,
0.47946563363075256,
0.2815324366092682,
0.32347822189331055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00036v1
|
EMERGE: Integrating RAG for Improved Multimodal EHR Predictive Modeling
| 2024-05-27T10:53:15 | 2024-05-27T10:53:15 |
Yinghao Zhu, Changyu Ren, Zixiang Wang, Xiaochen Zheng, Shiyun Xie, Junlan Feng, Xi Zhu, Zhoujun Li, Liantao Ma, Chengwei Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The integration of multimodal Electronic Health Records (EHR) data has
notably advanced clinical predictive capabilities. However, current models that
utilize clinical notes and multivariate time-series EHR data often lack the
necessary medical context for precise clinical tasks. Previous methods using
knowledge graphs (KGs) primarily focus on structured knowledge extraction. To
address this, we propose EMERGE, a Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) driven
framework aimed at enhancing multimodal EHR predictive modeling. Our approach
extracts entities from both time-series data and clinical notes by prompting
Large Language Models (LLMs) and aligns them with professional PrimeKG to
ensure consistency. Beyond triplet relationships, we include entities'
definitions and descriptions to provide richer semantics. The extracted
knowledge is then used to generate task-relevant summaries of patients' health
statuses. These summaries are fused with other modalities utilizing an adaptive
multimodal fusion network with cross-attention. Extensive experiments on the
MIMIC-III and MIMIC-IV datasets for in-hospital mortality and 30-day
readmission tasks demonstrate the superior performance of the EMERGE framework
compared to baseline models. Comprehensive ablation studies and analyses
underscore the efficacy of each designed module and the framework's robustness
to data sparsity. EMERGE significantly enhances the use of multimodal EHR data
in healthcare, bridging the gap with nuanced medical contexts crucial for
informed clinical predictions.
|
[
-0.11994780600070953,
-0.8515412211418152,
0.8211754560470581,
0.051620349287986755,
-0.1438971310853958,
0.28548330068588257,
0.16063110530376434,
-0.6965285539627075,
0.293410986661911,
0.5763882398605347,
-0.30754366517066956,
-0.4240953326225281,
-0.5412005186080933,
-0.17973677814006805,
-0.14206106960773468,
1.1586259603500366,
0.06233493611216545,
-0.027501188218593597,
-0.3529762029647827,
-0.022565843537449837,
-0.3390158712863922,
-0.19980376958847046,
-0.492686927318573,
-0.294990211725235,
0.6625239849090576,
0.23466169834136963,
0.419664591550827,
0.6893355250358582,
0.66302889585495,
0.26274552941322327,
0.036883775144815445,
0.40941643714904785,
-0.039626993238925934,
0.558687686920166,
0.19801022112369537,
-0.128655806183815,
-0.8733621835708618,
-0.6223355531692505,
0.5668463706970215,
0.4532882869243622,
-0.3074861168861389,
0.3068981468677521,
-0.0049858191050589085,
0.4660795032978058,
-0.47391238808631897,
0.16319352388381958,
-0.4607030749320984,
-0.05008820816874504,
-0.3694099485874176,
-0.4184705317020416,
-0.5675272345542908,
-0.01979406550526619,
0.302422434091568,
-0.5135549306869507,
0.2213580310344696,
0.21128901839256287,
0.7456286549568176,
0.2556278109550476,
-0.7166816592216492,
0.06454687565565109,
-0.9900702238082886,
0.5250470042228699,
-0.4651077091693878,
0.7269154787063599,
-0.03930393233895302,
0.6015843749046326,
0.03038213774561882,
-1.2523142099380493,
-0.26473918557167053,
0.11867430061101913,
-0.3021339476108551,
0.44660723209381104,
-0.2630966603755951,
0.0654674768447876,
0.013354338705539703,
0.2705680727958679,
-0.491606742143631,
-0.14937913417816162,
-0.35709893703460693,
0.0044357930310070515,
0.2814618945121765,
0.34787508845329285,
0.46346455812454224,
-0.48452597856521606,
-0.6035792827606201,
0.07464800029993057,
-0.4838552176952362,
-0.16221100091934204,
-0.3425828814506531,
0.38976845145225525,
-0.37251344323158264,
0.4543778896331787,
0.18914978206157684,
0.5339959263801575,
0.14229032397270203,
-0.4874950647354126,
0.6733145117759705,
-0.3480296730995178,
-0.18886756896972656,
0.038902897387742996,
0.6829608678817749,
0.21023696660995483,
-0.5276612639427185,
-0.1482989490032196,
-0.02607589028775692,
-0.11100611090660095,
0.5711244940757751,
-0.6446865797042847,
-0.45262694358825684,
0.5008412599563599,
-0.6848253011703491,
-0.2673627734184265,
-0.10146346688270569,
-1.2489112615585327,
-0.5377197861671448,
-0.3587265610694885,
0.38990965485572815,
-0.728171169757843,
-0.49243754148483276,
-0.3139316141605377,
-0.2014974057674408,
0.01116062980145216,
0.4442523419857025,
-0.46791985630989075,
0.1844184398651123,
0.3923457860946655,
0.7828262448310852,
-0.15657539665699005,
0.03330457583069801,
-0.6995126605033875,
0.41333335638046265,
-0.03974645212292671,
0.7208547592163086,
-0.4277655780315399,
-0.3056020736694336,
0.01081100758165121,
0.05103129521012306,
-0.38953641057014465,
-0.3229895532131195,
0.47456836700439453,
-0.6105514764785767,
0.08675406128168106,
0.21383947134017944,
-0.41435036063194275,
-0.11054899543523788,
0.34564146399497986,
-1.0231409072875977,
0.6946200728416443,
0.30974364280700684,
-0.9261035919189453,
0.560706615447998,
-0.806378960609436,
-0.5654761791229248,
0.3483150005340576,
-0.2750178873538971,
-0.7937660217285156,
-0.0181293785572052,
0.36962807178497314,
0.4925256371498108,
-0.2589778006076813,
0.39522674679756165,
-0.26236090064048767,
0.5282595753669739,
0.11315172165632248,
-0.21966101229190826,
0.4455265998840332,
0.4760087728500366,
0.03534632548689842,
0.20095135271549225,
-0.9806356430053711,
0.1374911218881607,
0.1663585752248764,
-0.21493637561798096,
-0.37475690245628357,
0.15189826488494873,
0.30744218826293945,
0.3556799590587616,
0.1587577909231186,
-0.39279860258102417,
-0.32458972930908203,
-0.24326342344284058,
0.07039061933755875,
0.4554664194583893,
0.5225557088851929,
0.215963676571846,
-0.8069582581520081,
0.7725495100021362,
0.2682182490825653,
0.1849425733089447,
-0.5785314440727234,
-0.33159956336021423,
-0.32467108964920044,
-0.6528409123420715,
0.16378018260002136,
0.4052368402481079,
-0.782351016998291,
0.016018640249967575,
-0.5630386471748352,
-0.5191316604614258,
-0.6697221398353577,
-0.1385548710823059,
0.40008145570755005,
0.8695727586746216,
0.6997311115264893,
0.01581873744726181,
-0.8228867650032043,
-0.733741283416748,
-0.008363315835595131,
-0.05634523555636406,
-0.10703272372484207,
0.5095690488815308,
0.16074462234973907,
-0.4511437714099884,
0.8720824718475342,
-0.5012293457984924,
-0.32830068469047546,
-0.48957595229148865,
0.22968608140945435,
0.22088702023029327,
0.41199377179145813,
0.2728385031223297,
-1.156557559967041,
-0.45420846343040466,
0.4067583680152893,
-0.6942968368530273,
0.18600305914878845,
0.022145848721265793,
-0.008999085053801537,
-0.24625164270401,
0.2772531509399414,
-0.30972376465797424,
0.07249684631824493,
0.5304816365242004,
-0.3055937588214874,
0.43100202083587646,
-0.3866861164569855,
0.22624096274375916,
-1.5787749290466309,
0.4129939377307892,
-0.09068531543016434,
-0.2733529508113861,
-0.8751792907714844,
-0.11294379085302353,
0.17450113594532013,
-0.024815719574689865,
-0.28675827383995056,
0.7149198055267334,
-0.3993065655231476,
0.009389684535562992,
0.13979671895503998,
-0.14824512600898743,
0.4569147825241089,
0.08289426565170288,
0.036184635013341904,
0.24076057970523834,
0.3749639391899109,
-0.5955477952957153,
-0.07799769937992096,
0.44802629947662354,
-0.20843897759914398,
0.5402581691741943,
-0.5528470277786255,
0.054017774760723114,
-0.3569784462451935,
0.1491924375295639,
-0.6662781834602356,
-0.7798236608505249,
0.03594944253563881,
-0.4429873824119568,
0.6961866021156311,
-0.38699477910995483,
-0.2525278925895691,
-0.2573576271533966,
0.056482668966054916,
0.41667115688323975,
0.45470622181892395,
-0.46901583671569824,
1.4024916887283325,
0.7002235651016235,
-0.3720736503601074,
-0.5426453351974487,
-0.49122512340545654,
-0.1558183878660202,
-0.383929044008255,
-0.612883985042572,
0.7025071978569031,
-0.05954385921359062,
-0.3882273733615875,
0.10048483312129974,
0.15618515014648438,
-0.06675403565168381,
-0.12984421849250793,
0.3629511892795563,
0.7022733688354492,
-0.1872016191482544,
0.39820966124534607,
0.22962254285812378,
0.08318493515253067,
0.016109656542539597,
-0.2615562975406647,
0.40873563289642334,
0.18395480513572693,
-0.4067608118057251,
0.01085133757442236,
0.34151721000671387,
0.787840723991394,
-0.6525566577911377,
0.5618263483047485,
0.7694289684295654,
-0.5740270614624023,
0.0067525217309594154,
-0.7227113842964172,
0.041155241429805756,
-0.3541208803653717,
0.3919999301433563,
-0.2614571154117584,
-0.5519468188285828,
0.5640865564346313,
-0.22110088169574738,
0.4083736538887024,
0.48861852288246155,
0.5104095935821533,
-0.18896856904029846,
1.0854533910751343,
0.5411974191665649,
0.435365229845047,
0.4786173701286316,
-0.11097903549671173,
-0.14886409044265747,
-1.1868672370910645,
-0.6983596682548523,
-0.308104544878006,
0.1196887418627739,
-0.4909435510635376,
-0.4509860575199127,
0.9487966299057007,
-0.21039323508739471,
-0.15330076217651367,
-0.059006791561841965,
-0.2949211001396179,
-0.22891367971897125,
-0.08973601460456848,
0.5809959769248962,
0.2761608958244324,
-0.09454216063022614,
-0.17934642732143402,
-0.03132156282663345,
-0.7336937785148621,
-0.16692200303077698,
1.3080302476882935,
0.3518405854701996,
0.6282913684844971,
0.26584622263908386,
0.7001280784606934,
0.20227962732315063,
0.6029080152511597,
-0.38412439823150635,
-0.05620778724551201,
-0.30947551131248474,
-0.5919790267944336,
0.09310828894376755,
-0.42584484815597534,
-1.2163763046264648,
0.16776427626609802,
-0.49313414096832275,
-0.5231798887252808,
0.2159801870584488,
0.3711962401866913,
-0.6885213255882263,
0.20326539874076843,
-0.6366087198257446,
0.7027475237846375,
-0.33587098121643066,
-0.3991182744503021,
0.15086904168128967,
-0.8535051941871643,
0.2937307059764862,
-0.1943168193101883,
0.7407683730125427,
0.11923697590827942,
-0.06515651196241379,
0.6505919694900513,
-0.13326296210289001,
0.6248343586921692,
0.06327983736991882,
0.10474380850791931,
0.23721443116664886,
0.04026828333735466,
0.4641333222389221,
0.0005659643211401999,
0.12341687828302383,
-0.13332460820674896,
-0.028755435720086098,
-0.00495065376162529,
-0.5562108159065247,
0.4414007067680359,
-0.5689536333084106,
-0.07633849233388901,
-0.11911452561616898,
-0.5007522702217102,
-0.4409147799015045,
0.46965065598487854,
0.24583834409713745,
0.9203135967254639,
-0.26660996675491333,
0.041792530566453934,
0.693789005279541,
-0.11217417567968369,
0.10787136107683182,
0.5409414172172546,
-0.4150191843509674,
-0.7759045362472534,
0.7840591073036194,
-0.0011706046061590314,
0.3375721275806427,
0.7595745921134949,
0.2777841091156006,
-0.3957463502883911,
-0.25341513752937317,
-0.47145846486091614,
0.0753025934100151,
-0.5656416416168213,
-0.3900827467441559,
-1.2006083726882935,
-0.3916645050048828,
-0.5310079455375671,
0.07003753632307053,
-0.16547928750514984,
0.03359757363796234,
-0.3245127201080322,
-0.10871081054210663,
0.5109389424324036,
0.7544378638267517,
0.0277155302464962,
0.12159749865531921,
-1.2226475477218628,
0.3335381746292114,
-0.00034693468478508294,
0.22934798896312714,
-0.02100042998790741,
-0.5081081390380859,
-0.27408739924430847,
-0.25244009494781494,
-0.1890508383512497,
-0.8886973857879639,
0.6444383263587952,
0.12347375601530075,
0.57219398021698,
0.564638078212738,
-0.022086987271904945,
0.6750702261924744,
-0.8660194873809814,
0.2929857671260834,
0.3844089210033417,
-0.39814630150794983,
0.6242847442626953,
-0.47757601737976074,
0.16355392336845398,
0.33440250158309937,
0.38506606221199036,
-0.3603396713733673,
-0.10248620063066483,
-0.9334387183189392,
-0.9864627718925476,
0.3488496243953705,
-0.27960270643234253,
-0.3151799142360687,
-0.1515512764453888,
0.12207845598459244,
0.2412429302930832,
0.0674656331539154,
-0.4056566655635834,
-0.2586781680583954,
0.007395298685878515,
-0.4813675880432129,
-0.11291864514350891,
-0.29038968682289124,
-0.3157651722431183,
0.16445669531822205,
0.2381238490343094,
-0.17477789521217346,
0.3544270396232605,
0.2697310447692871,
0.015780683606863022,
-0.34070393443107605,
0.3313862383365631,
0.19433897733688354,
0.6290295720100403,
-0.18671914935112,
0.27394652366638184,
-0.029720894992351532,
-0.47965124249458313,
-0.19962716102600098,
0.47545382380485535,
0.06084956228733063,
0.09360549598932266,
0.44481146335601807,
0.6811685562133789,
0.5138975977897644,
-0.6202122569084167,
0.27867743372917175,
0.1650393307209015,
0.11709073185920715,
-0.5864456295967102,
-0.1468064785003662,
0.021096225827932358,
0.38094818592071533,
0.19912725687026978,
0.33886757493019104,
0.3600226044654846,
-0.20225459337234497,
0.5746588706970215,
0.16155031323432922,
-0.4254116415977478,
-0.3615597188472748,
0.9941814541816711,
0.022181225940585136,
0.019507436081767082,
0.3543693721294403,
0.26494115591049194,
-0.18917065858840942,
0.5202245116233826,
0.740739643573761,
0.5566023588180542,
-0.4750923216342926,
0.10080940276384354,
0.3937075734138489,
-0.056890733540058136,
0.13997375965118408,
0.3233817219734192,
0.20326173305511475,
-0.5704534649848938,
-0.5396198630332947,
-0.6064800024032593,
-0.17306983470916748,
0.02804923988878727,
-0.8377175331115723,
0.3928700387477875,
-0.15706415474414825,
-0.4379774034023285,
0.16496004164218903,
-0.2276221066713333,
-0.8833337426185608,
0.259564608335495,
0.045139312744140625,
0.6208236813545227,
-0.7331714630126953,
0.5131164789199829,
0.7838504910469055,
-0.36308178305625916,
-0.817009449005127,
-0.18732145428657532,
0.2685341238975525,
-0.5830414295196533,
0.460663765668869,
0.0776737853884697,
0.17031286656856537,
0.12201971560716629,
-0.006469039712101221,
-1.0917633771896362,
1.4316788911819458,
0.12514415383338928,
-0.3571069538593292,
-0.2842242121696472,
-0.3767768144607544,
0.53192538022995,
-0.6086243987083435,
0.358607679605484,
0.30419597029685974,
0.36582356691360474,
0.29231002926826477,
-0.8579604029655457,
-0.057069920003414154,
-0.323123961687088,
-0.3491556644439697,
0.4727382957935333,
-0.34136253595352173,
0.8648979663848877,
-0.5796812772750854,
-0.3470431864261627,
-0.2119419276714325,
0.5175696015357971,
0.30121734738349915,
0.5594120025634766,
0.38541877269744873,
0.5135867595672607,
0.8190340995788574,
0.15238697826862335,
1.1996790170669556,
-0.36018794775009155,
-0.004833549726754427,
1.2897874116897583,
-0.3601109981536865,
0.7129724025726318,
0.2929113805294037,
-0.09635429084300995,
0.8033878803253174,
0.24297398328781128,
0.2593468129634857,
0.39288511872291565,
-0.46371352672576904,
-0.3954378366470337,
-0.12120718508958817,
-0.298212468624115,
-0.33404168486595154,
0.37343987822532654,
0.7086782455444336,
-0.6689041256904602,
-0.13946878910064697,
0.2529204487800598,
0.0815640240907669,
-0.24147450923919678,
-0.21133655309677124,
1.0890005826950073,
0.027610478922724724,
-0.6633713841438293,
-0.1420610547065735,
-0.30209439992904663,
0.007265070918947458,
-0.6184887886047363,
-0.3457165062427521,
0.19586844742298126,
0.24447692930698395,
-0.24192099273204803,
-0.5006088018417358,
0.10726961493492126,
-0.17537081241607666,
-0.3280846178531647,
-0.21573330461978912,
0.8858083486557007,
-0.5091210007667542,
-0.5334900617599487,
0.26694583892822266,
0.954255998134613,
-0.07625441998243332,
0.4257667362689972,
-0.5257155895233154,
-0.06554382294416428,
-0.1735510528087616,
-0.09777294844388962,
0.3992787301540375,
0.5588667392730713,
0.17749430239200592,
0.6721479892730713,
0.6893114447593689,
0.2434825897216797,
-0.07479039579629898,
0.1111699789762497,
0.9834060072898865,
-0.33293652534484863,
-0.468402236700058,
-0.6276967525482178,
0.88029545545578,
-0.10702990740537643,
-0.11172804236412048,
0.4442633092403412,
0.549563467502594,
0.18465571105480194,
0.12456371635198593,
0.8414099812507629,
-0.4235573410987854,
1.0894980430603027,
-0.5333926677703857,
0.7204718589782715,
-0.7405543923377991,
0.05909368395805359,
-0.27714240550994873,
-0.31095269322395325,
-0.27283427119255066,
-0.07579926401376724,
-0.1422235369682312,
0.12398018687963486,
0.5176534056663513,
0.33017033338546753,
-0.07944001257419586,
-0.3851764500141144,
0.25054922699928284,
0.30079102516174316,
0.4492432773113251,
0.2742305099964142,
0.42862606048583984,
-0.18344815075397491,
0.4694564640522003,
-0.237172931432724,
-0.34710192680358887,
-0.22587831318378448,
-0.8058985471725464,
-0.4666024446487427,
-0.6914355158805847,
-0.16402168571949005,
-0.5280538201332092,
-0.08860760927200317,
0.9964912533760071,
0.6226122975349426,
-0.5542376637458801,
0.36022892594337463,
0.22991642355918884,
-0.0461125485599041,
-0.3169156312942505,
-0.2539516091346741,
0.7013328075408936,
-0.4642904996871948,
-0.39769527316093445,
0.5148245096206665,
0.2920437455177307,
0.12103408575057983,
0.03991837799549103,
0.08096114546060562,
-0.05632548779249191,
-0.33229389786720276,
0.5629420876502991,
0.21870672702789307,
-0.39947670698165894,
-0.09869057685136795,
0.2890259027481079,
0.04248030483722687,
0.18840432167053223,
0.7914391160011292,
-0.868834376335144,
0.8916067481040955,
0.2061283141374588,
0.628261148929596,
0.41601958870887756,
0.24274224042892456,
0.4542817771434784,
-0.5719833970069885,
-0.254790335893631,
0.5463298559188843,
0.5244256854057312,
0.25853753089904785,
-0.47372162342071533,
0.16723290085792542,
0.017718538641929626,
-0.531213104724884,
-0.654000461101532,
0.26075974106788635,
-0.829470694065094,
-0.02102956920862198,
0.9180557727813721,
-0.11443520337343216,
-0.15729454159736633,
-0.4894534647464752,
0.1445648968219757,
0.2444772720336914,
-0.2539033591747284,
0.545913815498352,
0.017207521945238113,
-0.4599390923976898,
-0.22408542037010193,
-0.8293526768684387,
0.4906095266342163,
0.0029854411259293556,
-1.0490634441375732,
-0.02337377332150936,
0.6683812737464905,
0.29918137192726135,
0.4118565618991852,
0.6957378387451172,
-0.5399399995803833,
0.3789736032485962,
0.05710800364613533,
0.11948096752166748,
-0.057862915098667145,
-0.6058615446090698,
-0.08042343705892563,
0.3318460285663605,
-0.07338424772024155,
-0.015547764487564564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17039v1
|
BWArea Model: Learning World Model, Inverse Dynamics, and Policy for Controllable Language Generation
| 2024-05-27T10:45:49 | 2024-05-27T10:45:49 |
Chengxing Jia, Pengyuan Wang, Ziniu Li, Yi-Chen Li, Zhilong Zhang, Nan Tang, Yang Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have catalyzed a paradigm shift in natural
language processing, yet their limited controllability poses a significant
challenge for downstream applications. We aim to address this by drawing
inspiration from the neural mechanisms of the human brain, specifically Broca's
and Wernicke's areas, which are crucial for language generation and
comprehension, respectively. In particular, Broca's area receives cognitive
decision signals from Wernicke's area, treating the language generation as an
intricate decision-making process, which differs from the fully auto-regressive
language generation of existing LLMs. In a similar vein, our proposed system,
the BWArea model, conceptualizes language generation as a decision-making task.
This model has three components: a language world model, an inverse dynamics
model, and a cognitive policy. Like Wernicke's area, the inverse dynamics model
is designed to deduce the underlying cognitive intentions, or latent actions,
behind each token. The BWArea model is amenable to both pre-training and
fine-tuning like existing LLMs. With 30B clean pre-training tokens, we have
trained a BWArea model, which achieves competitive performance with LLMs of
equal size (1B parameters). Unlike fully auto-regressive LLMs, its pre-training
performance does not degenerate if dirty data unintentionally appears. This
shows the advantage of a decomposed structure of BWArea model in reducing
efforts in laborious data selection and labeling. Finally, we reveal that the
BWArea model offers enhanced controllability via fine-tuning the cognitive
policy with downstream reward metrics, thereby facilitating alignment with
greater simplicity. On 9 out of 10 tasks from two suites, TextWorld and
BigBench Hard, our method shows superior performance to auto-regressive LLMs.
|
[
-0.19746170938014984,
-0.8559845089912415,
0.3841298222541809,
0.2887258231639862,
-0.021902574226260185,
-0.10647346824407578,
-0.6079702377319336,
-0.4311217963695526,
-0.18867795169353485,
0.6135562062263489,
-0.7037487626075745,
-0.3635311722755432,
-0.5453097224235535,
-0.18900659680366516,
-0.09431909024715424,
0.8430841565132141,
0.06241120770573616,
-0.11021509021520615,
0.13538266718387604,
0.03864819556474686,
-0.6416856050491333,
-0.3533132076263428,
-0.8284306526184082,
-0.7775996327400208,
0.49629196524620056,
0.32677313685417175,
0.8466734886169434,
0.6389800906181335,
0.3228256404399872,
0.27209651470184326,
0.037923410534858704,
-0.03041190840303898,
-0.5036004185676575,
0.36308449506759644,
-0.37777960300445557,
-0.6022444367408752,
-0.26414400339126587,
0.11458607017993927,
0.3364359140396118,
0.6136574745178223,
-0.4239039421081543,
0.15953436493873596,
0.12295864522457123,
0.6098629236221313,
-0.716569721698761,
0.3799346089363098,
-0.7336565852165222,
-0.018120968714356422,
-0.0576075054705143,
-0.00764422444626689,
-0.4669880270957947,
-0.46716204285621643,
0.1322041004896164,
-0.5183426141738892,
-0.1707988977432251,
0.15695716440677643,
0.9351208209991455,
0.29909735918045044,
-0.22946083545684814,
-0.3146953582763672,
-0.9715006351470947,
0.916440486907959,
-0.6884410977363586,
0.48082152009010315,
0.393096387386322,
0.1900423914194107,
-0.3793499171733856,
-0.6025408506393433,
-0.5875109434127808,
-0.28457197546958923,
0.2509227991104126,
0.23574471473693848,
-0.38625919818878174,
0.05922599136829376,
0.12647472321987152,
0.026747295632958412,
-0.5902846455574036,
0.5705830454826355,
-0.40029990673065186,
-0.21596759557724,
0.5487917065620422,
0.2701473832130432,
0.39355331659317017,
0.03966011852025986,
-0.2612974941730499,
-0.2112867534160614,
-0.8697933554649353,
0.2546708583831787,
0.3242504894733429,
0.48079466819763184,
0.013428939506411552,
0.6039677858352661,
-0.15867140889167786,
0.751528799533844,
0.03442283347249031,
-0.13722409307956696,
-0.08416993916034698,
0.12317891418933868,
-0.42492780089378357,
0.0931246355175972,
0.7061184048652649,
0.14013069868087769,
0.21155990660190582,
-0.2107098251581192,
-0.36144161224365234,
0.3524664342403412,
0.4669223129749298,
-0.7708339095115662,
-0.3261979818344116,
0.28509601950645447,
-0.32887962460517883,
-0.39680764079093933,
-0.24525056779384613,
-0.3463970422744751,
-0.22455428540706635,
-0.6666858196258545,
0.4362854063510895,
-0.5134773254394531,
-0.23288069665431976,
0.06843823194503784,
0.010175495408475399,
0.3390469253063202,
0.2209032028913498,
-0.9442939162254333,
0.41429463028907776,
0.5188049674034119,
0.5498353838920593,
-0.38261544704437256,
-0.299169659614563,
-0.26883500814437866,
0.44380825757980347,
-0.5944339632987976,
0.3977237939834595,
-0.6488825082778931,
-0.1368110030889511,
-0.03311869502067566,
-0.1348719596862793,
0.174953430891037,
-0.6855992674827576,
-0.05064251273870468,
-0.875257670879364,
0.12117733806371689,
-0.13617375493049622,
-0.38844504952430725,
-0.4016689658164978,
0.23759222030639648,
-0.5256009697914124,
0.7643874883651733,
-0.05555276572704315,
-0.5543600916862488,
0.4855507016181946,
-0.5981960296630859,
-0.36897990107536316,
0.08722594380378723,
-0.11073492467403412,
-0.30701515078544617,
0.05605288967490196,
-0.018233636394143105,
0.4021871089935303,
-0.5012509226799011,
0.655194878578186,
-0.24876798689365387,
-0.1320541650056839,
0.24751253426074982,
-0.5252155065536499,
0.8596171736717224,
0.3007417321205139,
-0.50783371925354,
0.19486327469348907,
-0.5421009659767151,
-0.017062958329916,
0.1783367246389389,
-0.5829262733459473,
-0.5276468396186829,
0.010071191005408764,
-0.01639324612915516,
0.47263991832733154,
0.40698179602622986,
-0.5506608486175537,
0.2164207100868225,
-0.38267284631729126,
0.27454185485839844,
0.8546257019042969,
0.025686362758278847,
0.5004765391349792,
-0.1333288997411728,
0.5885953903198242,
0.25162264704704285,
0.23699046671390533,
0.12220626324415207,
-0.337986022233963,
-0.4961526095867157,
-0.22362953424453735,
0.16573108732700348,
0.8023653030395508,
-0.6929707527160645,
0.46470654010772705,
-0.15384972095489502,
-0.44806721806526184,
-0.326985239982605,
0.29364100098609924,
0.5750108361244202,
0.307346373796463,
0.2937186360359192,
-0.26298171281814575,
-0.303606241941452,
-0.985410213470459,
-0.07620387524366379,
0.025081265717744827,
-0.017824869602918625,
0.17219845950603485,
0.1440403014421463,
-0.17630071938037872,
0.9664422869682312,
-0.6088424324989319,
-0.2813171148300171,
-0.48106396198272705,
0.09182966500520706,
0.09324561059474945,
0.5079817175865173,
0.278391033411026,
-0.7060353755950928,
-0.14242874085903168,
0.08773773908615112,
-0.729751467704773,
-0.30346158146858215,
-0.035654015839099884,
-0.19735375046730042,
0.3777036666870117,
0.6749733090400696,
-0.48788851499557495,
0.284546434879303,
0.6914417147636414,
-0.11734797805547714,
0.30295953154563904,
-0.45263466238975525,
-0.29945868253707886,
-1.051805019378662,
0.19275711476802826,
0.06218767166137695,
-0.04118958115577698,
-0.34473976492881775,
0.13403157889842987,
0.030280297622084618,
-0.15427888929843903,
-0.3901585340499878,
0.5555132627487183,
-0.49222272634506226,
-0.09484747797250748,
-0.4216310977935791,
0.33865684270858765,
-0.2505851089954376,
0.8677846193313599,
0.08237557858228683,
0.5577221512794495,
0.5528874397277832,
-0.9090396165847778,
0.3017274737358093,
0.1477106660604477,
-0.20221222937107086,
0.4289131164550781,
-0.5448387265205383,
-0.16743585467338562,
-0.24318428337574005,
0.2982150614261627,
-0.7863102555274963,
-0.047951240092515945,
0.03520886227488518,
-0.2231840044260025,
0.45691514015197754,
0.1362033486366272,
-0.28016746044158936,
-0.3072129487991333,
-0.020641937851905823,
0.13693967461585999,
0.7193470597267151,
-0.46376851201057434,
0.5393075346946716,
0.5496556758880615,
-0.376661092042923,
-0.5577086210250854,
-0.7933328747749329,
0.05524010956287384,
-0.04101276025176048,
-0.31328916549682617,
0.2905033826828003,
-0.044837966561317444,
-0.30874353647232056,
-0.0779648870229721,
0.06764133274555206,
0.02448311448097229,
0.15563485026359558,
0.4716488718986511,
0.27395349740982056,
-0.18289591372013092,
0.09982051700353622,
0.5082253217697144,
-0.15828944742679596,
-0.07067522406578064,
-0.5343462824821472,
0.6957506537437439,
0.1845329850912094,
0.12096468359231949,
-0.47840869426727295,
-0.046429798007011414,
0.3964129388332367,
-0.3879539966583252,
0.7068169713020325,
0.22261151671409607,
-0.30816882848739624,
-0.4474681317806244,
-0.2791242301464081,
-0.2006732076406479,
-0.49252310395240784,
0.2438523918390274,
-0.22961968183517456,
-0.6627673506736755,
0.3994395136833191,
-0.21735665202140808,
0.424501895904541,
0.0642736554145813,
0.779411792755127,
0.10071342438459396,
0.9019028544425964,
0.566490888595581,
-0.23578022420406342,
0.5661457777023315,
-0.32877638936042786,
0.045849286019802094,
-0.789250373840332,
-0.19358649849891663,
-0.39758241176605225,
-0.47047391533851624,
-0.5983375310897827,
-0.04467308521270752,
0.1614248901605606,
0.14906224608421326,
-0.4719768166542053,
0.3174401819705963,
-0.327445924282074,
0.3181400001049042,
0.6560075879096985,
0.08672511577606201,
0.22698093950748444,
-0.19290471076965332,
-0.2908233106136322,
0.07267149537801743,
-0.7095426321029663,
-0.6128324270248413,
0.9803816080093384,
0.20731396973133087,
0.8293527960777283,
0.15223686397075653,
0.6118321418762207,
0.19512107968330383,
0.5530366897583008,
-0.6049481630325317,
0.5938945412635803,
-0.23599885404109955,
-0.6683351993560791,
-0.41646137833595276,
-0.32032981514930725,
-1.2472493648529053,
0.29697340726852417,
-0.321281760931015,
-0.8353356719017029,
0.056128326803445816,
0.32734379172325134,
-0.16567541658878326,
0.25285452604293823,
-0.5091646909713745,
0.7609050273895264,
-0.07686054706573486,
-0.46566176414489746,
-0.292873352766037,
-0.6101172566413879,
0.4283856153488159,
-0.022604824975132942,
0.15503165125846863,
0.12021248787641525,
-0.03807533159852028,
0.44700029492378235,
-0.14310519397258759,
1.0102566480636597,
-0.4104785919189453,
-0.4563344717025757,
0.24431997537612915,
0.49077001214027405,
0.492691308259964,
-0.22584125399589539,
0.0864921435713768,
0.06004691496491432,
-0.36696797609329224,
-0.26843497157096863,
-0.4367625117301941,
0.8542768359184265,
-0.7258979678153992,
-0.4658200740814209,
-0.11825750768184662,
-0.7243276238441467,
-0.21696226298809052,
0.4531954228878021,
0.2625682055950165,
0.5605965852737427,
-0.2580195665359497,
0.05661569908261299,
0.6835833191871643,
-0.4567987620830536,
0.5538148283958435,
0.5534800291061401,
-0.4961613416671753,
-0.13845370709896088,
1.0792019367218018,
0.21199533343315125,
0.2826825976371765,
0.40005970001220703,
0.2507244944572449,
-0.1451183259487152,
-0.6950128674507141,
-0.2594332993030548,
0.1605149805545807,
-0.35687562823295593,
-0.14387179911136627,
-0.5211671590805054,
0.002272683894261718,
-0.24338309466838837,
-0.15165303647518158,
-0.347351610660553,
-0.27379336953163147,
-0.13665063679218292,
-0.19078731536865234,
-0.029042521491646767,
0.8758462071418762,
-0.15301789343357086,
0.5376635193824768,
-0.6313130259513855,
0.3618999123573303,
0.27561116218566895,
0.21389147639274597,
0.13487890362739563,
-0.30970126390457153,
-0.09423515945672989,
0.22411088645458221,
-0.6457635164260864,
-0.6385501623153687,
0.6051993370056152,
-0.046667248010635376,
0.3730332553386688,
0.22378361225128174,
-0.05238507315516472,
0.32039639353752136,
-0.48672619462013245,
0.7369368076324463,
0.08037478476762772,
-0.8681181073188782,
0.5519151091575623,
-0.4128800332546234,
0.311846524477005,
0.349319726228714,
0.28072285652160645,
-0.31291648745536804,
-0.8210391998291016,
-0.5817014575004578,
-0.9529365301132202,
0.8483957052230835,
0.08289822190999985,
0.115391805768013,
0.1192958652973175,
0.3703655004501343,
0.17999476194381714,
0.30574631690979004,
-0.7346028685569763,
-0.03931250795722008,
-0.06734684109687805,
-0.32670238614082336,
0.004881497472524643,
0.13138237595558167,
-0.06472748517990112,
0.1056058332324028,
0.8963536620140076,
-0.12045983225107193,
-0.12424208968877792,
-0.0621701255440712,
-0.26636189222335815,
-0.14138366281986237,
0.1160038635134697,
0.6059241890907288,
0.5319488644599915,
-0.01801980473101139,
-0.038358282297849655,
-0.08082015067338943,
-0.5345171689987183,
0.11231395602226257,
-0.18447093665599823,
-0.434628963470459,
-0.6063351035118103,
0.1590023785829544,
1.026253342628479,
0.11648419499397278,
-0.583618700504303,
0.3249043822288513,
0.011670965701341629,
-0.06663315743207932,
-0.3990262746810913,
0.32972779870033264,
0.12088264524936676,
0.46145009994506836,
0.21191775798797607,
0.10782212764024734,
-0.10172556340694427,
-0.4031301438808441,
0.09642615169286728,
0.4654613733291626,
-0.4371548593044281,
-0.36792075634002686,
0.6883003115653992,
0.10836713016033173,
-0.19512195885181427,
0.8432812690734863,
-0.13031381368637085,
-0.254314124584198,
0.6560438871383667,
0.755797803401947,
0.7782157063484192,
-0.3002074658870697,
0.21159885823726654,
0.1785915493965149,
0.5659205913543701,
-0.149658203125,
0.31089046597480774,
0.07703535258769989,
-0.9740067720413208,
-0.37278515100479126,
-0.5910878777503967,
-0.2936897277832031,
0.21457244455814362,
-0.7866676449775696,
0.03544116020202637,
-0.7290559411048889,
-0.2310212403535843,
-0.1637173444032669,
-0.10478448867797852,
-0.49241000413894653,
0.49512943625450134,
0.15048974752426147,
0.828437328338623,
-0.8778553605079651,
0.91938316822052,
0.5342037677764893,
-0.47000712156295776,
-0.9420871734619141,
0.07378416508436203,
-0.1768726110458374,
-0.6513684391975403,
0.891171932220459,
-0.046305593103170395,
-0.16494686901569366,
0.1878732442855835,
-0.8391887545585632,
-0.761436402797699,
1.1399831771850586,
0.5046067237854004,
-0.5639362931251526,
-0.10992961376905441,
-0.28218358755111694,
0.499603271484375,
-0.18147777020931244,
-0.15641014277935028,
0.6186407208442688,
0.6167335510253906,
-0.03651871159672737,
-0.7143974900245667,
0.17871414124965668,
0.1746464967727661,
0.2033349871635437,
0.35442081093788147,
-0.6452431678771973,
0.5515947937965393,
-0.2763930559158325,
-0.20428819954395294,
-0.17690448462963104,
0.748508870601654,
0.4915180504322052,
0.0038904035463929176,
0.32088741660118103,
0.5220544934272766,
0.6196308732032776,
-0.07738876342773438,
1.219671607017517,
-0.30685120820999146,
0.14085811376571655,
0.9397121667861938,
-0.45552554726600647,
0.914883553981781,
0.4121803939342499,
-0.015996240079402924,
0.5648279786109924,
0.3195585012435913,
0.2799873948097229,
0.5139110684394836,
0.41079041361808777,
0.1382131427526474,
-0.31213197112083435,
0.08713261038064957,
0.19430917501449585,
0.5847574472427368,
0.5161094069480896,
-0.04539074748754501,
-0.12096677720546722,
0.2685961127281189,
0.19526401162147522,
0.22012335062026978,
-0.3075990378856659,
0.8071314692497253,
0.05765237659215927,
-0.8813582062721252,
0.43045249581336975,
0.16471292078495026,
0.7912094593048096,
-0.953642725944519,
0.012034597806632519,
-0.25068098306655884,
0.2705658972263336,
-0.013070239685475826,
-0.6013816595077515,
0.20693983137607574,
-0.21315696835517883,
-0.1901642084121704,
-0.09670175611972809,
0.4771033823490143,
-0.6248646974563599,
-0.24332280457019806,
0.4365489184856415,
0.21945524215698242,
-0.09825244545936584,
0.23332101106643677,
-0.6618324518203735,
0.12565597891807556,
-0.058929577469825745,
-0.621570885181427,
0.40036436915397644,
0.32165631651878357,
-0.46043577790260315,
0.9394184350967407,
0.7470899820327759,
0.3940403163433075,
0.2100827395915985,
-0.1410883069038391,
0.6692861318588257,
-0.760033130645752,
-0.622186541557312,
-0.5212748646736145,
0.06196712702512741,
0.12629736959934235,
-0.28671979904174805,
0.38386428356170654,
0.41519156098365784,
0.7599246501922607,
-0.031117964535951614,
0.8569202423095703,
-0.08145062625408173,
0.2059313803911209,
-0.7268807291984558,
0.7353057265281677,
-0.49176204204559326,
0.057754214853048325,
-0.15917563438415527,
-1.0360221862792969,
-0.29587724804878235,
0.43699657917022705,
-0.2751343548297882,
0.11360715329647064,
0.4939137101173401,
0.7897644639015198,
-0.08491946756839752,
-0.07052712142467499,
0.3820975720882416,
0.5545198917388916,
0.5497324466705322,
0.6151997447013855,
0.5995782017707825,
-0.07466737180948257,
0.28679290413856506,
-0.13334079086780548,
-0.35586413741111755,
0.07506213337182999,
-0.8433099985122681,
-0.6086046099662781,
-0.5485014319419861,
-0.24361425638198853,
-0.20773783326148987,
-0.07120269536972046,
1.0634279251098633,
0.5759804844856262,
-0.7190510630607605,
-0.49817460775375366,
-0.33475762605667114,
-0.10246576368808746,
-0.4053244888782501,
-0.2662758231163025,
0.21618521213531494,
-0.5606727004051208,
-0.7570880651473999,
0.39056867361068726,
0.3896642327308655,
0.006127060391008854,
-0.48442819714546204,
-0.19829760491847992,
-0.22344867885112762,
0.4196840822696686,
0.5869306921958923,
0.4297023415565491,
-0.5611465573310852,
-0.043845098465681076,
-0.24161915481090546,
-0.3610226809978485,
-0.34987613558769226,
0.9381269216537476,
-0.7842923402786255,
0.21419937908649445,
0.4158935546875,
0.6387767791748047,
0.46025219559669495,
-0.13018392026424408,
0.8443520069122314,
-0.5935529470443726,
0.31081444025039673,
0.09928178042173386,
0.20262795686721802,
0.25836488604545593,
-0.23894894123077393,
0.2086244374513626,
-0.10642591118812561,
-0.4546733498573303,
-0.635254442691803,
0.4215840697288513,
-0.8767659664154053,
-0.6610164642333984,
1.0988130569458008,
-0.13987977802753448,
-0.4814721643924713,
-0.07446636259555817,
-0.41644832491874695,
0.3450559973716736,
-0.41525641083717346,
0.7324060797691345,
0.5129141211509705,
-0.08874645084142685,
0.03730965778231621,
-0.38059163093566895,
0.4094374179840088,
0.29295843839645386,
-0.7644911408424377,
0.47340598702430725,
0.7578945755958557,
0.33518388867378235,
0.0796114131808281,
0.5222203135490417,
-0.1719144582748413,
0.11141185462474823,
-0.2628425657749176,
0.40051817893981934,
-0.21776534616947174,
-0.5678541660308838,
-0.393854558467865,
0.14496514201164246,
0.12556993961334229,
-0.12191976606845856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01607v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01607v2
|
Recent advances in text embedding: A Comprehensive Review of Top-Performing Methods on the MTEB Benchmark
| 2024-05-27T09:52:54 | 2024-06-19T06:52:13 |
Hongliu Cao
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Text embedding methods have become increasingly popular in both industrial
and academic fields due to their critical role in a variety of natural language
processing tasks. The significance of universal text embeddings has been
further highlighted with the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) applications
such as Retrieval-Augmented Systems (RAGs). While previous models have
attempted to be general-purpose, they often struggle to generalize across tasks
and domains. However, recent advancements in training data quantity, quality
and diversity; synthetic data generation from LLMs as well as using LLMs as
backbones encourage great improvements in pursuing universal text embeddings.
In this paper, we provide an overview of the recent advances in universal text
embedding models with a focus on the top performing text embeddings on Massive
Text Embedding Benchmark (MTEB). Through detailed comparison and analysis, we
highlight the key contributions and limitations in this area, and propose
potentially inspiring future research directions.
|
[
-0.19761022925376892,
-0.8370043039321899,
0.6078992486000061,
0.11599552631378174,
-0.14859803020954132,
0.3547168970108032,
-0.13238033652305603,
-0.573947548866272,
-0.0008020255481824279,
0.6318050622940063,
0.014878363348543644,
-0.8289240598678589,
-0.8397814631462097,
0.17829787731170654,
-0.6585419178009033,
0.6380855441093445,
-0.20969492197036743,
0.14411389827728271,
-0.457733154296875,
-0.48000335693359375,
-0.6883591413497925,
-0.8945068717002869,
-0.22868502140045166,
-0.22735868394374847,
0.29817891120910645,
0.07481009513139725,
0.49476349353790283,
0.7609186172485352,
0.6741970181465149,
0.3144354224205017,
-0.2190476655960083,
0.2596662938594818,
-0.2625640332698822,
0.4135528802871704,
-0.19286620616912842,
-0.40175101161003113,
-0.4115186333656311,
-0.09756278991699219,
0.946588397026062,
0.7810218930244446,
-0.05798792093992233,
-0.07388780266046524,
0.1677757352590561,
0.4630027115345001,
-0.7983707189559937,
-0.3163982331752777,
-0.5146225690841675,
0.051479704678058624,
-0.31269580125808716,
-0.026976611465215683,
-0.5746213793754578,
-0.49428078532218933,
0.16082632541656494,
-0.07759962975978851,
0.1873272806406021,
0.2626270055770874,
0.5417527556419373,
-0.04917946085333824,
-0.6467428803443909,
-0.5760705471038818,
-0.5978177189826965,
1.1259040832519531,
-0.6297427415847778,
0.8091048002243042,
0.17621271312236786,
0.10595103353261948,
-0.03335493430495262,
-0.7544731497764587,
-0.10258208215236664,
-0.1722116321325302,
0.2111109048128128,
-0.12727180123329163,
-0.1713130623102188,
-0.014923286624252796,
-0.05948923900723457,
0.5209310054779053,
-0.5942701101303101,
0.30435916781425476,
0.19829049706459045,
-0.0836973786354065,
0.20438091456890106,
0.25928664207458496,
0.278850793838501,
-0.08933787047863007,
-0.4503124952316284,
-0.1566004902124405,
-0.9178084135055542,
-0.34731730818748474,
0.10641521215438843,
0.030332671478390694,
0.12750427424907684,
0.5918242335319519,
-0.059639815241098404,
0.5351155400276184,
-0.5223053097724915,
0.2739468812942505,
0.2234935313463211,
-0.26726993918418884,
-0.3310922682285309,
-0.26012659072875977,
0.5876906514167786,
0.24723458290100098,
0.23011912405490875,
-0.36797285079956055,
-0.20575322210788727,
0.027004266157746315,
0.2295549213886261,
-0.7615063786506653,
0.24945364892482758,
-0.00013513154408428818,
-0.5627111792564392,
-0.34405460953712463,
0.026500806212425232,
-0.7026799321174622,
-0.4898715615272522,
-0.16391989588737488,
0.28675082325935364,
-0.3305107653141022,
-0.09730086475610733,
-0.06345641613006592,
-0.18368196487426758,
0.2792203426361084,
0.2703951895236969,
-0.826675295829773,
0.2874034643173218,
0.7305383682250977,
0.8930670022964478,
-0.14263306558132172,
-0.15156543254852295,
-0.250146746635437,
0.40286868810653687,
-0.5029614567756653,
1.1123759746551514,
-0.7299008369445801,
-0.4291035234928131,
0.40624141693115234,
-0.40912893414497375,
0.15031661093235016,
-0.7077087163925171,
0.7568118572235107,
-0.5893484354019165,
0.06889654695987701,
-0.3768438696861267,
-0.703299880027771,
-0.1402459442615509,
0.3132432997226715,
-0.5905783772468567,
1.3289580345153809,
-0.03148360177874565,
-0.817267119884491,
0.1049526259303093,
-0.4520370066165924,
-0.28959956765174866,
-0.15969499945640564,
-0.023716632276773453,
-0.22732442617416382,
0.31624799966812134,
0.23161721229553223,
0.7632619738578796,
-0.5793691277503967,
0.29541102051734924,
-0.30109357833862305,
-0.5230326652526855,
0.4181543290615082,
-0.48410072922706604,
0.46925288438796997,
0.06507793068885803,
-0.14918319880962372,
-0.13853515684604645,
-0.5600284337997437,
-0.043174952268600464,
0.1021866723895073,
-0.1129738837480545,
-0.6244995594024658,
0.1372852623462677,
0.31522953510284424,
-0.14479084312915802,
0.31322038173675537,
-0.5315900444984436,
0.41478025913238525,
-0.02462378703057766,
0.43779727816581726,
0.7759546041488647,
-0.03629862144589424,
0.4553864896297455,
-0.14486868679523468,
0.10141760110855103,
-0.2623651325702667,
-0.04151150956749916,
-0.29169315099716187,
-0.43553289771080017,
-0.25972840189933777,
-0.22643858194351196,
0.9269474148750305,
0.6245981454849243,
-0.39710307121276855,
0.345596045255661,
-0.27525272965431213,
-0.3980999290943146,
-0.5646668672561646,
0.278714656829834,
0.2696487605571747,
0.014139843173325062,
0.350114643573761,
-0.2326352894306183,
-0.6570167541503906,
-0.8621506094932556,
-0.4885759651660919,
0.22542880475521088,
-0.1432061493396759,
0.2029954344034195,
0.3010217249393463,
-0.6101990938186646,
0.8493225574493408,
-0.5616332292556763,
-0.2771637439727783,
-0.5254567861557007,
0.17700344324111938,
-0.014886461198329926,
0.5316576957702637,
0.48559051752090454,
-0.6999838352203369,
-0.5271909832954407,
-0.015494389459490776,
-0.943172812461853,
-0.015025930479168892,
0.055164266377687454,
-0.16716554760932922,
0.18593445420265198,
0.6019222736358643,
-0.2995681166648865,
0.30993759632110596,
0.9045174717903137,
-0.190764918923378,
0.3777621388435364,
-0.3305911123752594,
0.24000494182109833,
-0.9950860738754272,
0.043252263218164444,
-0.007847526110708714,
-0.43433475494384766,
-0.6134252548217773,
0.09907517582178116,
0.25689056515693665,
0.17345015704631805,
-0.04061038792133331,
0.6068864464759827,
-0.6545599102973938,
-0.17534326016902924,
-0.35890695452690125,
0.5248170495033264,
-0.0694442093372345,
0.08373691886663437,
-0.2841377258300781,
0.6400315761566162,
0.49939051270484924,
-0.5729915499687195,
0.2540324926376343,
0.377781480550766,
-0.4332975447177887,
0.4452824294567108,
-0.5999130606651306,
0.12447665631771088,
0.034085921943187714,
0.20097839832305908,
-0.9917617440223694,
0.10620331764221191,
-0.1427963525056839,
-0.37060919404029846,
0.613075315952301,
0.08601302653551102,
-0.8914875984191895,
-0.2743302881717682,
-0.5624898672103882,
0.3959949314594269,
0.6281834244728088,
-0.41059795022010803,
0.3670562207698822,
0.5711074471473694,
-0.3721782863140106,
-0.6219993233680725,
-0.9091105461120605,
0.4350966513156891,
0.07330849766731262,
-0.4975331425666809,
0.5752664804458618,
-0.17581310868263245,
0.013924376107752323,
-0.03205208480358124,
-0.16986243426799774,
-0.14803463220596313,
0.10661706328392029,
-0.1163732036948204,
0.2869420349597931,
-0.08450700342655182,
0.03933284804224968,
0.2384207844734192,
-0.18387486040592194,
-0.25631213188171387,
-0.1781724989414215,
0.47607341408729553,
-0.029059791937470436,
-0.23095422983169556,
-0.1987871527671814,
0.5137239098548889,
0.20481258630752563,
-0.27170732617378235,
0.9930098652839661,
0.5142439603805542,
-0.4525805115699768,
-0.1499754786491394,
-0.9002625346183777,
0.05241343379020691,
-0.447579950094223,
0.42028793692588806,
-0.012194054201245308,
-1.0026508569717407,
0.24349404871463776,
-0.5226243734359741,
0.2576947510242462,
0.2578011453151703,
0.4313928186893463,
-0.26978799700737,
1.2208449840545654,
0.9158236980438232,
-0.055664438754320145,
0.6699423789978027,
-0.27238863706588745,
-0.004974356386810541,
-1.133634090423584,
-0.07049135118722916,
-0.7553994655609131,
-0.23535218834877014,
-0.9216204285621643,
-0.45924052596092224,
-0.05162583291530609,
0.16915108263492584,
-0.030793897807598114,
0.4116370379924774,
-0.39513084292411804,
0.42297863960266113,
0.4033985435962677,
-0.1686570942401886,
0.4174591600894928,
0.10893087089061737,
-0.3982766270637512,
-0.07891035825014114,
-0.4799044728279114,
-0.7745605707168579,
1.3180211782455444,
0.3887249231338501,
0.6204538941383362,
-0.004430070519447327,
0.5140112638473511,
0.7042552828788757,
0.6630273461341858,
-0.29327091574668884,
0.48344850540161133,
-0.47681301832199097,
-0.6309269070625305,
-0.09502783417701721,
-0.4479888081550598,
-1.0376206636428833,
0.5252892971038818,
-0.32274511456489563,
-0.734951376914978,
-0.09446929395198822,
-0.05240890756249428,
0.21504409611225128,
0.6365373730659485,
-0.4745652973651886,
0.6698402762413025,
-0.030785491690039635,
-0.296318918466568,
-0.2343084067106247,
-0.2914964556694031,
-0.08535448461771011,
0.2075553983449936,
0.3435559570789337,
0.0345904603600502,
-0.29660823941230774,
0.8329952955245972,
0.22806860506534576,
0.5567041635513306,
-0.17302222549915314,
-0.19338268041610718,
0.3372815251350403,
-0.19206224381923676,
0.6089834570884705,
-0.2689208686351776,
-0.22040370106697083,
0.3536125421524048,
-0.1608201414346695,
-0.4914815425872803,
-0.28711074590682983,
0.8038145303726196,
-0.4205319881439209,
-0.36024200916290283,
-0.349870502948761,
-0.24496620893478394,
-0.5967614650726318,
0.22692742943763733,
0.22040121257305145,
0.8658942580223083,
-0.5049639344215393,
0.698331892490387,
0.9251065254211426,
-0.43369048833847046,
0.48528748750686646,
0.08536788821220398,
-0.3582611680030823,
-0.8340958952903748,
0.9010993242263794,
0.16955196857452393,
-0.07349549978971481,
0.7121722102165222,
0.04904351010918617,
-0.5037716031074524,
-0.9718928933143616,
-0.3847714960575104,
0.36543190479278564,
-0.6523171067237854,
-0.3192029297351837,
-0.8018884658813477,
0.01783347688615322,
-0.467044860124588,
-0.38073375821113586,
-0.41612881422042847,
-0.24789643287658691,
0.009822583757340908,
-0.1512591689825058,
0.005209002643823624,
1.2617266178131104,
0.10930975526571274,
0.3107537627220154,
-1.024925947189331,
0.24667292833328247,
0.02189646102488041,
0.8661887645721436,
0.08641867339611053,
-0.19146502017974854,
-0.6524550914764404,
-0.09176039695739746,
-0.5079506635665894,
-0.8915112614631653,
0.16883638501167297,
-0.28139936923980713,
0.7326164841651917,
0.22021928429603577,
-0.2188250571489334,
0.2044781595468521,
-0.606278657913208,
0.7275729179382324,
-0.04433226212859154,
-0.950844407081604,
0.21594467759132385,
-0.3678666949272156,
0.19546815752983093,
0.3499373495578766,
0.42672351002693176,
-0.6808667778968811,
-0.265092134475708,
-0.45003676414489746,
-0.8360394835472107,
0.28070318698883057,
0.3139567971229553,
0.3002459406852722,
0.20040066540241241,
0.08810164034366608,
0.2780040204524994,
0.46665534377098083,
-0.5658630728721619,
-0.3823069632053375,
0.20463712513446808,
-0.3685717284679413,
0.08344880491495132,
-0.5428993105888367,
0.35367557406425476,
0.02747311256825924,
0.47926065325737,
0.09223881363868713,
0.6668520569801331,
0.08474218100309372,
-0.5614742636680603,
0.20016448199748993,
0.5231420993804932,
0.36558523774147034,
0.3978423774242401,
-0.309302419424057,
-0.1849890649318695,
0.3605944812297821,
-0.5793570876121521,
-0.02861107513308525,
-0.058874111622571945,
-0.1517011821269989,
0.07924793660640717,
0.39335232973098755,
0.5438418388366699,
0.5782273411750793,
-0.6757664680480957,
0.48538738489151,
-0.021924037486314774,
-0.06378629058599472,
-0.003013207809999585,
-0.19282236695289612,
0.12266452610492706,
0.19179636240005493,
0.4922827184200287,
0.03529713675379753,
0.2366458624601364,
-0.6218924522399902,
-0.07753856480121613,
0.5015481114387512,
-0.1823340505361557,
-0.1963830292224884,
0.4792253375053406,
0.26168814301490784,
-0.004584103357046843,
0.5485047101974487,
0.21760472655296326,
-0.5104845762252808,
0.2520281970500946,
0.6183096766471863,
1.009554147720337,
-0.25494706630706787,
0.003060166025534272,
0.08560184389352798,
0.3143255412578583,
-0.03726897016167641,
0.14222311973571777,
-0.07948976755142212,
-0.5151144862174988,
-0.41766485571861267,
-0.5677340626716614,
-0.8439953327178955,
-0.1762903928756714,
-0.4827862083911896,
-0.005172186531126499,
-0.3872300684452057,
-0.30266353487968445,
-0.4156176447868347,
0.1280149519443512,
-0.8703500628471375,
0.10280052572488785,
0.24939322471618652,
1.0004572868347168,
-0.34935861825942993,
0.6631470322608948,
0.9262892603874207,
0.05161760002374649,
0.17690972983837128,
0.04557812213897705,
-0.19744166731834412,
-0.3777340054512024,
0.23680925369262695,
0.36322107911109924,
0.08643566817045212,
0.11759133636951447,
-0.5141363143920898,
-0.9283782839775085,
1.1432180404663086,
0.20662783086299896,
-0.44754549860954285,
-0.21958759427070618,
0.30097496509552,
0.5376074314117432,
-0.27119070291519165,
0.503292977809906,
0.3164910078048706,
0.4446151554584503,
-0.22606712579727173,
-0.42545968294143677,
-0.030222088098526,
-0.061075881123542786,
0.37379395961761475,
0.360859215259552,
-0.5896997451782227,
0.5139062404632568,
0.11207239329814911,
-0.23677794635295868,
0.3175503611564636,
0.7648892402648926,
0.14991271495819092,
0.34036844968795776,
0.0846150740981102,
0.46838703751564026,
0.6860516667366028,
-0.2207449972629547,
1.1937819719314575,
-0.05847307667136192,
0.2673918902873993,
0.6150807738304138,
-0.37744373083114624,
1.2043062448501587,
-0.04484261944890022,
-0.23624882102012634,
0.8353538513183594,
0.2729068696498871,
-0.09745155274868011,
0.3793012797832489,
-0.020576154813170433,
-0.031842634081840515,
-0.1199713721871376,
-0.12728425860404968,
-0.5588182210922241,
0.14686493575572968,
0.45456963777542114,
-0.2795012891292572,
-0.2994087040424347,
0.21488232910633087,
-0.14507897198200226,
0.017187684774398804,
-0.1271519660949707,
0.7667605876922607,
0.11985328793525696,
-0.2846715450286865,
0.30557700991630554,
0.24841591715812683,
1.1375290155410767,
-0.6432515382766724,
-0.05921360105276108,
-0.23804976046085358,
0.21296896040439606,
0.10223665088415146,
-0.9176596999168396,
0.15494796633720398,
0.34882134199142456,
-0.1982102245092392,
-0.6106341481208801,
0.854681670665741,
-0.20250912010669708,
-0.06414561718702316,
0.4421140253543854,
0.4800305962562561,
-0.16552002727985382,
-0.1879003942012787,
-0.5196198225021362,
0.3073499798774719,
-0.12933950126171112,
-0.40331870317459106,
0.5641977190971375,
0.4355727434158325,
0.05673476308584213,
0.6595120429992676,
0.6019487380981445,
-0.08055352419614792,
0.02439999394118786,
-0.027505844831466675,
0.6769213080406189,
-1.1995221376419067,
-0.27217811346054077,
-0.6800085306167603,
0.5332262516021729,
-0.11831828951835632,
-0.11855486035346985,
0.7241837382316589,
0.5469671487808228,
0.6279637217521667,
0.08342132717370987,
0.7769982814788818,
0.1588396579027176,
0.6593121290206909,
-0.5083572864532471,
0.6927033066749573,
-0.597569465637207,
0.1146080419421196,
-0.43529197573661804,
-1.2089014053344727,
-0.36731210350990295,
0.22842557728290558,
-0.03639360889792442,
0.23208458721637726,
0.8172529935836792,
0.40216392278671265,
0.1474277675151825,
0.13948574662208557,
0.49726125597953796,
0.24140147864818573,
0.33088991045951843,
0.10280746966600418,
0.7719771862030029,
-0.6519886255264282,
0.618034839630127,
-0.037515901029109955,
-0.18122020363807678,
-0.41504931449890137,
-1.0306720733642578,
-0.817112922668457,
-0.5289865732192993,
-0.12720204889774323,
0.12936317920684814,
0.062387630343437195,
0.8629593253135681,
0.31130343675613403,
-0.9967634081840515,
-0.18433411419391632,
-0.05105695500969887,
0.25674304366111755,
-0.05724107846617699,
-0.20081475377082825,
0.39792758226394653,
-0.24845550954341888,
-0.8803249001502991,
0.3718607425689697,
0.4076559543609619,
0.1947176456451416,
-0.14971965551376343,
0.1728198528289795,
-0.3411465883255005,
0.37670841813087463,
0.9059672355651855,
0.008253452368080616,
-0.3457205891609192,
0.027247417718172073,
0.11681129783391953,
-0.524111807346344,
0.046911150217056274,
0.815433919429779,
-0.7935576438903809,
0.06551322340965271,
0.7029732465744019,
1.0287070274353027,
0.20022547245025635,
-0.16942867636680603,
0.5059724450111389,
-0.7026813626289368,
-0.37848055362701416,
0.13679495453834534,
0.47088173031806946,
0.6478258371353149,
0.05319713056087494,
0.6280299425125122,
0.27062714099884033,
-0.678885817527771,
-1.1370793581008911,
-0.19021283090114594,
-0.6874673962593079,
-0.3153446912765503,
0.8787818551063538,
0.15393218398094177,
0.05795454606413841,
-0.025133294984698296,
-0.25713032484054565,
0.29504039883613586,
-0.3177427649497986,
0.5344326496124268,
0.7612905502319336,
0.11330636590719223,
-0.022285910323262215,
-0.6542447209358215,
0.0973738506436348,
0.4738617539405823,
-0.9215852618217468,
0.09054918587207794,
0.3936443328857422,
0.04470956325531006,
-0.06214611604809761,
0.2928776443004608,
-0.21193371713161469,
-0.06153140217065811,
0.0739675909280777,
-0.04639105126261711,
0.05900252237915993,
-0.37880203127861023,
-0.10771782696247101,
0.3244420289993286,
0.06190861389040947,
0.07601400464773178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16994v1
|
Vision-and-Language Navigation Generative Pretrained Transformer
| 2024-05-27T09:42:04 | 2024-05-27T09:42:04 |
Wen Hanlin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.RO
|
In the Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) field, agents are tasked with
navigating real-world scenes guided by linguistic instructions. Enabling the
agent to adhere to instructions throughout the process of navigation represents
a significant challenge within the domain of VLN. To address this challenge,
common approaches often rely on encoders to explicitly record past locations
and actions, increasing model complexity and resource consumption. Our
proposal, the Vision-and-Language Navigation Generative Pretrained Transformer
(VLN-GPT), adopts a transformer decoder model (GPT2) to model trajectory
sequence dependencies, bypassing the need for historical encoding modules. This
method allows for direct historical information access through trajectory
sequence, enhancing efficiency. Furthermore, our model separates the training
process into offline pre-training with imitation learning and online
fine-tuning with reinforcement learning. This distinction allows for more
focused training objectives and improved performance. Performance assessments
on the VLN dataset reveal that VLN-GPT surpasses complex state-of-the-art
encoder-based models.
|
[
-0.1501675248146057,
-0.3325039744377136,
0.7120707035064697,
-0.1328994780778885,
-0.2851013243198395,
-0.039487820118665695,
0.12832288444042206,
-0.27343499660491943,
-0.012904840521514416,
0.6135945320129395,
-0.6329097747802734,
-0.26202744245529175,
-0.5485725998878479,
-0.33618929982185364,
-0.23685559630393982,
1.0721678733825684,
-0.226143941283226,
-0.059821952134370804,
0.027973296120762825,
0.07298076897859573,
-0.6139431595802307,
-0.7553322315216064,
-0.6461966037750244,
-0.3132075071334839,
0.35293063521385193,
-0.17039795219898224,
0.8342894315719604,
0.4158889949321747,
0.3988703489303589,
0.26035255193710327,
0.16636304557323456,
0.19833378493785858,
-0.661780059337616,
-0.05674859881401062,
-0.3820243775844574,
-0.4666944146156311,
-0.4731510281562805,
-0.2821728587150574,
0.4085977375507355,
0.3057127594947815,
-0.08197412639856339,
-0.21831665933132172,
-0.08021113276481628,
0.5245288610458374,
-0.6929377913475037,
0.47854238748550415,
-0.17369495332241058,
0.23791922628879547,
0.030011609196662903,
-0.40567338466644287,
-0.5626824498176575,
-0.3935263454914093,
0.328096866607666,
-1.0477513074874878,
0.2680470645427704,
-0.08568274229764938,
0.9926513433456421,
0.4194999039173126,
-0.4015740752220154,
-0.09257619827985764,
-1.1706838607788086,
0.36820194125175476,
-0.09739385545253754,
0.6948588490486145,
0.23544369637966156,
0.651117742061615,
-0.012143606320023537,
-1.0640671253204346,
-0.40513408184051514,
-0.09630080312490463,
-0.26879602670669556,
0.46313610672950745,
-0.12571723759174347,
0.13170334696769714,
0.17585226893424988,
-0.03461657837033272,
-0.8171688318252563,
0.011412977240979671,
-0.30260372161865234,
-0.18138693273067474,
0.16925148665905,
0.18222565948963165,
0.13015148043632507,
0.1790008395910263,
-0.5174885392189026,
-0.3458141088485718,
-0.8842136263847351,
0.14781402051448822,
-0.008399277925491333,
0.1660262793302536,
-0.01055164821445942,
0.39324721693992615,
-0.21468430757522583,
0.7726755738258362,
0.09323611110448837,
0.0988839715719223,
0.20723217725753784,
-0.5016149282455444,
-0.08676830679178238,
0.09506075084209442,
0.5008048415184021,
0.43789684772491455,
0.35331541299819946,
-0.3909086287021637,
-0.3017514944076538,
0.024687493219971657,
0.709139347076416,
-0.8006203174591064,
-0.35049697756767273,
-0.23084025084972382,
-0.0927954837679863,
0.12819035351276398,
0.26713186502456665,
-0.6642747521400452,
-0.1111665815114975,
-0.3662480115890503,
0.7888341546058655,
-0.42953041195869446,
-0.2663298547267914,
0.19597890973091125,
-0.22073020040988922,
0.8414788842201233,
0.5689285397529602,
-0.7570911049842834,
-0.06546787917613983,
0.5815455913543701,
0.9084928631782532,
-0.01806747168302536,
-0.32144099473953247,
-0.5696293115615845,
0.3492002785205841,
-0.10629051178693771,
0.5475486516952515,
-0.6345961093902588,
-0.6584774851799011,
0.14503945410251617,
0.23277339339256287,
-0.1409967839717865,
-0.24984605610370636,
0.21652910113334656,
-0.7787812352180481,
0.273159384727478,
-0.3084688186645508,
-0.30595862865448,
-0.43424108624458313,
0.3206917345523834,
-0.6348313093185425,
0.7621058225631714,
0.45617181062698364,
-0.1367173045873642,
0.4969514012336731,
-0.6530258059501648,
-0.537896454334259,
0.4012233018875122,
-0.3583886921405792,
-0.45857828855514526,
-0.005314761772751808,
0.33203139901161194,
0.143686905503273,
-0.08229111135005951,
0.1427146941423416,
0.5496457815170288,
-0.6373313665390015,
-0.4181099534034729,
-0.6112445592880249,
0.5368345379829407,
-0.225382000207901,
-0.6617461442947388,
0.14512863755226135,
-0.4892577528953552,
-0.2161298543214798,
0.2731596827507019,
-0.44219735264778137,
-0.17075955867767334,
0.18553584814071655,
-0.08836046606302261,
0.2734297513961792,
0.2678808271884918,
-0.23473605513572693,
0.4714909791946411,
-0.4435003995895386,
0.1565595418214798,
0.5104559659957886,
-0.12109499424695969,
0.5708322525024414,
-0.09730198979377747,
0.6780789494514465,
0.024484306573867798,
0.46277916431427,
-0.3821660280227661,
-0.6198272109031677,
-0.9575589299201965,
0.2475442886352539,
-0.18119703233242035,
0.6955475211143494,
-1.2783957719802856,
0.2834600508213043,
-0.7735942602157593,
-0.3643542528152466,
-0.3761850893497467,
-0.3217960000038147,
0.5209272503852844,
0.43896371126174927,
0.7237941026687622,
-0.41238072514533997,
-0.47458747029304504,
-0.1776999980211258,
0.06664154678583145,
-0.1429978311061859,
-0.1403646618127823,
0.1295817792415619,
0.4139916002750397,
-0.4206180274486542,
1.0394221544265747,
-0.33129405975341797,
-0.3404059112071991,
-0.4654737710952759,
0.10095855593681335,
-0.08183000236749649,
0.4469033181667328,
0.3819270133972168,
-1.137338638305664,
-0.31301936507225037,
0.18234913051128387,
-0.7446818351745605,
0.33977028727531433,
-0.29136979579925537,
-0.1657324731349945,
0.028700122609734535,
0.5909360647201538,
-0.6895895004272461,
0.8144494295120239,
0.30516812205314636,
-0.3565579056739807,
0.2842138409614563,
-0.4549986720085144,
0.19486592710018158,
-0.6303623914718628,
-0.16094236075878143,
-0.33242183923721313,
-0.3208353519439697,
-0.7455700635910034,
0.09280865639448166,
0.035752151161432266,
0.0036456238012760878,
-0.7336459159851074,
0.22898058593273163,
-0.43930697441101074,
-0.14242388308048248,
-0.15615829825401306,
0.0175966527312994,
0.021721970289945602,
0.6349929571151733,
0.5469948053359985,
0.8760143518447876,
0.406604528427124,
-0.7376939058303833,
0.4209146201610565,
0.337114155292511,
-0.07206270843744278,
0.514188826084137,
-0.4527440667152405,
0.29652684926986694,
-0.4170558750629425,
0.28473982214927673,
-0.5479061007499695,
0.06571277976036072,
0.3049437701702118,
-0.1732494980096817,
0.4485968351364136,
-0.5081628561019897,
-0.18086811900138855,
-0.3250948488712311,
0.13146165013313293,
0.5194209814071655,
0.9239161014556885,
-0.6700375080108643,
1.072992205619812,
-0.06891889870166779,
0.2249799519777298,
-0.37563416361808777,
-0.5464581251144409,
0.005646516568958759,
0.022973647341132164,
-0.3190159499645233,
0.40320882201194763,
0.239211767911911,
0.30976250767707825,
-0.13789623975753784,
-0.03834617882966995,
0.09758423268795013,
-0.2409496158361435,
0.471712201833725,
0.5427917242050171,
-0.39103299379348755,
-0.13099372386932373,
-0.3103666603565216,
-0.42742428183555603,
-0.06369446218013763,
-0.7049709558486938,
0.7431774139404297,
-0.16147813200950623,
-0.47446876764297485,
-0.23565062880516052,
0.10873926430940628,
0.42333289980888367,
-0.43968725204467773,
0.7686700224876404,
0.6139788627624512,
0.02999967336654663,
0.06497389078140259,
-0.289467990398407,
-0.04785619676113129,
-0.5220047831535339,
0.6341513395309448,
-0.37378403544425964,
-0.7886810302734375,
0.032564569264650345,
-0.44180330634117126,
-0.132107675075531,
0.314610093832016,
0.4507831931114197,
-0.14953011274337769,
0.5992236733436584,
0.7131907343864441,
0.0644812136888504,
0.5053445100784302,
-0.41691192984580994,
0.33273348212242126,
-0.5412367582321167,
-0.4937964975833893,
0.0010279384441673756,
-0.14423592388629913,
-0.45919716358184814,
-0.6425780653953552,
0.5861495733261108,
-0.12869612872600555,
-0.3523101508617401,
0.5221450328826904,
-0.46908992528915405,
0.6376844048500061,
0.6440019011497498,
0.14370325207710266,
0.1629791110754013,
-0.17860491573810577,
0.12304975092411041,
0.0574781596660614,
-0.7446346282958984,
-0.2879243493080139,
0.9966464042663574,
0.03866397961974144,
0.7301687598228455,
0.14929814636707306,
0.4864886403083801,
0.07617005705833435,
0.021144572645425797,
-0.7101806998252869,
0.556039035320282,
-0.14637035131454468,
-0.3540172874927521,
-0.4711950719356537,
-0.17050468921661377,
-0.9223112463951111,
0.21627292037010193,
0.050777386873960495,
-0.5416228175163269,
0.07017961889505386,
0.4085416793823242,
-0.4754018783569336,
0.33378225564956665,
-0.4991673231124878,
1.0940130949020386,
-0.49660274386405945,
-0.2711375951766968,
0.14605556428432465,
-1.0586966276168823,
-0.12046244740486145,
-0.0705045685172081,
-0.1705278754234314,
0.5233840942382812,
0.13651181757450104,
0.30582693219184875,
-0.4861440360546112,
0.7262056469917297,
-0.48396384716033936,
0.0785551518201828,
0.22303086519241333,
0.0081291813403368,
0.8284263014793396,
-0.46999606490135193,
0.4767551124095917,
0.1149311512708664,
-0.4363901615142822,
-0.09819148480892181,
-0.565977931022644,
0.24503345787525177,
-0.686798632144928,
-0.5103296041488647,
-0.38135597109794617,
-0.12679383158683777,
-0.15981705486774445,
0.04330963268876076,
0.7615639567375183,
0.37904420495033264,
-0.36142897605895996,
-0.06688182055950165,
0.7533252835273743,
-0.23405736684799194,
0.566565215587616,
0.5095284581184387,
-0.18585088849067688,
0.13775412738323212,
1.0436556339263916,
0.04051750898361206,
0.35370177030563354,
0.8895759582519531,
-0.11771810054779053,
-0.4879300594329834,
-0.4793921113014221,
-0.645154595375061,
-0.11211893707513809,
-0.6589727401733398,
0.052224915474653244,
-0.2931143641471863,
-0.5044148564338684,
-0.022352371364831924,
-0.3752502202987671,
-0.69968181848526,
0.021679824218153954,
-0.2955901026725769,
-0.1787346452474594,
0.10738876461982727,
0.8957694172859192,
0.17728790640830994,
0.6785519123077393,
-0.6458878517150879,
0.31047534942626953,
0.49488338828086853,
0.10800223797559738,
-0.2209976762533188,
-0.5353848934173584,
-0.2748930752277374,
-0.04255950450897217,
-0.2366076111793518,
-0.685543954372406,
0.401638925075531,
0.3089204728603363,
0.4233161509037018,
0.1894725263118744,
-0.1422203630208969,
0.6250599026679993,
-0.9188072085380554,
0.863108217716217,
0.17008624970912933,
-0.6136061549186707,
0.8505554795265198,
-0.1236192062497139,
0.5998135805130005,
0.3990263342857361,
0.5276293754577637,
-0.2850003242492676,
-0.08591247349977493,
-0.1449785977602005,
-0.931236207485199,
0.7069694995880127,
0.29348304867744446,
-0.08322829008102417,
0.3506666421890259,
0.36486339569091797,
-0.014501683413982391,
-0.003388953162357211,
-0.6995283961296082,
-0.1271495670080185,
-0.813204824924469,
-0.09224439412355423,
-0.4240225553512573,
-0.11419932544231415,
0.13869553804397583,
-0.1538664549589157,
0.4297487735748291,
0.02893487922847271,
0.35415118932724,
0.19408854842185974,
-0.5388954877853394,
0.1907576620578766,
0.00919865258038044,
0.6173083186149597,
0.3993862271308899,
-0.06742983311414719,
0.020005349069833755,
0.07875604182481766,
-0.8730618357658386,
0.5326451063156128,
0.08768084645271301,
-0.5271214246749878,
0.05094798654317856,
0.23299391567707062,
1.2489595413208008,
0.12585797905921936,
-0.40320730209350586,
0.8127260208129883,
-0.0014720282051712275,
0.0615348219871521,
-0.5361883640289307,
0.25965622067451477,
-0.20145688951015472,
0.3809800148010254,
0.23541060090065002,
0.17043046653270721,
0.10444634407758713,
-0.2827219069004059,
0.09697125107049942,
0.08404262363910675,
-0.6434226632118225,
-0.4683960974216461,
0.8471272587776184,
0.18056489527225494,
-0.3742474615573883,
0.7493680119514465,
-0.28177955746650696,
-0.6792904734611511,
0.3915526270866394,
0.40033096075057983,
0.8348838090896606,
-0.4198623597621918,
0.18203967809677124,
0.24647656083106995,
0.4931267499923706,
-0.4274582266807556,
0.10039813071489334,
-0.12408573925495148,
-0.5546833276748657,
-0.40629875659942627,
-0.600532054901123,
-0.223086416721344,
-0.11273043602705002,
-0.7102917432785034,
0.05997886881232262,
-0.26370424032211304,
-0.1298530250787735,
-0.6395187973976135,
-0.6989683508872986,
-1.125210165977478,
0.43479472398757935,
0.24050746858119965,
0.4172637164592743,
-0.4777930676937103,
1.0164397954940796,
0.5045862793922424,
-0.5437878370285034,
-0.6631384491920471,
0.08267366141080856,
0.041325893253088,
-0.8851956129074097,
0.8261182308197021,
0.2871052622795105,
-0.535357654094696,
0.28850069642066956,
-0.06328318268060684,
-0.7065800428390503,
1.263305425643921,
0.290995717048645,
-0.9214094877243042,
-0.5265027284622192,
0.4728797376155853,
0.3958667814731598,
-0.037068888545036316,
0.300214946269989,
0.7093207240104675,
0.3126992881298065,
0.2944480776786804,
-0.9246873259544373,
-0.10310786962509155,
-0.08554896712303162,
0.23255686461925507,
0.3901218771934509,
-0.5123299956321716,
0.5564724206924438,
-0.16038675606250763,
-0.24660322070121765,
0.001028369297273457,
0.4741433560848236,
-0.16115222871303558,
0.00800455454736948,
0.33539578318595886,
0.4467245936393738,
0.37233567237854004,
-0.49212920665740967,
1.137684941291809,
-0.03936425969004631,
0.2049810290336609,
1.258955478668213,
-0.17452123761177063,
0.774176299571991,
0.360546350479126,
-0.1369875818490982,
0.446222722530365,
0.1667085587978363,
-0.02515566535294056,
1.0334118604660034,
-0.10438205301761627,
-0.3768211007118225,
-0.30336475372314453,
0.19529969990253448,
-0.4507201611995697,
0.5993813872337341,
0.292977899312973,
-0.3307054936885834,
-0.12895798683166504,
0.27586326003074646,
-0.05215906724333763,
-0.2692783772945404,
-0.5194823741912842,
0.8143036365509033,
-0.19688235223293304,
-0.6018706560134888,
0.3272203207015991,
-0.3042244017124176,
0.5348100066184998,
-0.99411541223526,
-0.13468697667121887,
-0.24357059597969055,
0.18045341968536377,
0.09418237954378128,
-0.629977822303772,
0.18854384124279022,
-0.06362764537334442,
0.10043096542358398,
-0.37930476665496826,
0.5027844309806824,
-0.3591693937778473,
-0.20852644741535187,
0.3356730043888092,
0.4404117166996002,
0.1093878522515297,
-0.20448780059814453,
-0.15710963308811188,
-0.06998492032289505,
0.08019863069057465,
-0.3338024318218231,
0.250225305557251,
0.32056841254234314,
0.061279378831386566,
0.5256373286247253,
0.27527695894241333,
-0.056661371141672134,
0.3713901937007904,
0.2416895627975464,
0.723237931728363,
-0.8424161076545715,
-0.6608227491378784,
-0.8127995729446411,
0.7209126949310303,
0.21051955223083496,
-0.25701069831848145,
0.45561882853507996,
0.5535853505134583,
1.1166914701461792,
-0.2650744616985321,
0.7601504921913147,
0.22241123020648956,
-0.11508908867835999,
-0.9384733438491821,
0.6498945355415344,
-0.3852318227291107,
0.020854616537690163,
0.04675806686282158,
-0.8688901662826538,
-0.09575677663087845,
0.7866907715797424,
-0.27380457520484924,
0.17763611674308777,
0.5397666692733765,
0.7341514825820923,
-0.1590677946805954,
-0.10392313450574875,
0.4702053368091583,
-0.06723006069660187,
0.5476460456848145,
1.0265047550201416,
0.9436331391334534,
-0.47209402918815613,
0.681435763835907,
0.08527689427137375,
-0.06345584988594055,
-0.34887179732322693,
-0.6881553530693054,
-0.696805477142334,
-0.6133919954299927,
-0.24461525678634644,
-0.14258670806884766,
0.48358577489852905,
0.5866218209266663,
0.8053138256072998,
-0.5695117712020874,
0.003935474902391434,
-0.44860273599624634,
-0.39889732003211975,
-0.22367770969867706,
-0.1517910361289978,
0.262624591588974,
-0.1294025480747223,
-0.4835050702095032,
0.7119544148445129,
0.5385076999664307,
0.44068002700805664,
-0.28038814663887024,
-0.5083947777748108,
0.17272964119911194,
-0.2836054265499115,
0.6594236493110657,
0.4891333281993866,
-0.7178577780723572,
-0.41874828934669495,
-0.15265335142612457,
0.0253097303211689,
0.40699660778045654,
0.8675164580345154,
-1.0189769268035889,
0.7689579129219055,
0.03776707872748375,
0.6353504657745361,
0.9590895771980286,
-0.037146784365177155,
0.762121856212616,
-0.6214342713356018,
0.27587032318115234,
0.25873011350631714,
0.3415756821632385,
0.2744031548500061,
-0.31503498554229736,
0.5284726619720459,
0.23732294142246246,
-0.4009902775287628,
-0.1352435052394867,
0.3647914528846741,
-0.9574174284934998,
-0.0652526319026947,
1.0472216606140137,
-0.36497384309768677,
-0.05954807624220848,
-0.26241281628608704,
-0.33758115768432617,
0.4035225808620453,
-0.07362031191587448,
0.24098709225654602,
0.18079933524131775,
0.020618511363863945,
-0.3314110040664673,
-0.5201493501663208,
0.5657269954681396,
0.0165651123970747,
-0.6792392730712891,
-0.4001739025115967,
0.44813182950019836,
-0.11235164105892181,
0.16480301320552826,
0.5053640604019165,
0.044720277190208435,
0.3988593816757202,
0.15682931244373322,
0.017859941348433495,
-0.17592674493789673,
-0.7173277735710144,
-0.2821197211742401,
0.27642613649368286,
-0.25326159596443176,
-0.4637688994407654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16969v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16969v4
|
The Multi-Range Theory of Translation Quality Measurement: MQM scoring models and Statistical Quality Control
| 2024-05-27T09:06:24 | 2024-06-09T22:03:49 |
Arle Lommel, Serge Gladkoff, Alan Melby, Sue Ellen Wright, Ingemar Strandvik, Katerina Gasova, Angelika Vaasa, Andy Benzo, Romina Marazzato Sparano, Monica Foresi, Johani Innis, Lifeng Han, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.AP
|
The year 2024 marks the 10th anniversary of the Multidimensional Quality
Metrics (MQM) framework for analytic translation quality evaluation. The MQM
error typology has been widely used by practitioners in the translation and
localization industry and has served as the basis for many derivative projects.
The annual Conference on Machine Translation (WMT) shared tasks on both human
and automatic translation quality evaluations used the MQM error typology.
The metric stands on two pillars: error typology and the scoring model. The
scoring model calculates the quality score from annotation data, detailing how
to convert error type and severity counts into numeric scores to determine if
the content meets specifications. Previously, only the raw scoring model had
been published. This April, the MQM Council published the Linear Calibrated
Scoring Model, officially presented herein, along with the Non-Linear Scoring
Model, which had not been published before.
This paper details the latest MQM developments and presents a universal
approach to translation quality measurement across three sample size ranges. It
also explains why Statistical Quality Control should be used for very small
sample sizes, starting from a single sentence.
|
[
-0.31807419657707214,
-0.26710033416748047,
0.38808003067970276,
0.27071136236190796,
-0.08008291572332382,
-0.0905117616057396,
0.04946545511484146,
-0.36033350229263306,
0.08639085292816162,
0.6754027605056763,
-0.33068183064460754,
-0.6534591317176819,
-0.641097366809845,
0.08172034472227097,
-0.4948996901512146,
0.9034499526023865,
-0.32711997628211975,
0.4081825613975525,
-0.01869739033281803,
-0.5582858920097351,
-0.3518235385417938,
-0.793911874294281,
-0.282427042722702,
-0.0965673178434372,
0.7649590373039246,
0.33059456944465637,
0.887546956539154,
0.6622430086135864,
0.7765451073646545,
0.172099307179451,
0.09253823012113571,
0.344740092754364,
-0.22604767978191376,
0.04066574573516846,
0.0831720381975174,
-0.7114138603210449,
-0.7900174856185913,
0.4746587574481964,
0.7787193059921265,
0.8211371898651123,
-0.14681494235992432,
0.15367008745670319,
0.13377976417541504,
0.8682408928871155,
-0.36205148696899414,
-0.18047814071178436,
-0.1380545049905777,
0.09493258595466614,
-0.04363685101270676,
-0.2645728290081024,
-0.5394626259803772,
-0.615909218788147,
-0.30062755942344666,
-0.409187376499176,
0.07696006447076797,
0.155344158411026,
0.5823941826820374,
-0.01455907616764307,
-0.9783684611320496,
-0.28855061531066895,
-0.9577760100364685,
1.2623581886291504,
-0.6430820226669312,
0.42219778895378113,
0.27284812927246094,
0.5111941695213318,
-0.23154307901859283,
-0.3155561089515686,
-0.33083102107048035,
-0.0680154412984848,
0.20018790662288666,
0.1757485717535019,
-0.16564270853996277,
-0.09515008330345154,
-0.12548141181468964,
0.576624870300293,
-0.5841599702835083,
-0.1318219155073166,
-0.5937129855155945,
-0.3482528030872345,
0.5466770529747009,
0.5902423858642578,
0.15040837228298187,
-0.1745348572731018,
-0.46820375323295593,
-0.07605168223381042,
-0.5877993702888489,
0.01506680715829134,
0.13317619264125824,
0.3095775246620178,
-0.11094102263450623,
0.5389571189880371,
-0.3713228404521942,
0.6675567030906677,
-0.42541414499282837,
-0.3329976797103882,
0.0877654105424881,
-0.9177262187004089,
-0.027641715481877327,
-0.491725355386734,
1.0711580514907837,
0.5560837388038635,
0.03798552602529526,
-0.024997999891638756,
-0.2481829971075058,
-0.04573317617177963,
0.39265376329421997,
-0.5697349905967712,
0.12388601899147034,
0.11247198283672333,
-0.6459396481513977,
-0.5330239534378052,
0.21695207059383392,
-1.0446486473083496,
-0.01685130037367344,
-0.22611509263515472,
0.36000487208366394,
-0.41709578037261963,
0.03070305660367012,
0.004647206515073776,
0.09937667101621628,
0.22261077165603638,
0.33591851592063904,
-0.5543234944343567,
0.36016786098480225,
0.2678699493408203,
0.9324080348014832,
-0.2635841965675354,
-0.4842332899570465,
-0.4394820034503937,
0.006369295530021191,
-0.8041282892227173,
0.7419113516807556,
-0.1310848593711853,
-0.27012574672698975,
-0.07829776406288147,
-0.3352639377117157,
-0.0067821647971868515,
-0.2731698155403137,
0.7545163035392761,
-0.4067763388156891,
0.22295169532299042,
0.11939894407987595,
-0.4346199631690979,
-0.40005117654800415,
0.30588480830192566,
-0.6204466819763184,
0.9029543995857239,
0.3746753931045532,
-0.006618531886488199,
0.393943190574646,
-0.48127540946006775,
0.005423054099082947,
-0.08535049110651016,
0.33000558614730835,
-0.29672446846961975,
0.3822227716445923,
-0.20595474541187286,
-0.0001241584832314402,
-0.5798671841621399,
0.10891986638307571,
-0.36743348836898804,
-0.24006527662277222,
0.3762897253036499,
-0.6573968529701233,
0.4872349202632904,
0.4323735237121582,
0.30111977458000183,
0.1455639898777008,
-0.7820531129837036,
0.5877431035041809,
-0.31165382266044617,
-0.5804317593574524,
-0.0412190817296505,
-0.15953107178211212,
0.17179611325263977,
0.613866925239563,
0.05139699950814247,
-0.23741157352924347,
-0.0959833636879921,
0.0606033094227314,
0.4337344467639923,
0.2549302577972412,
0.13692933320999146,
0.4993430972099304,
-0.5633325576782227,
0.5341591835021973,
-0.1466275453567505,
0.5523818135261536,
0.03772944584488869,
-0.5590060949325562,
-0.4229488968849182,
-0.026080597192049026,
0.6220327615737915,
0.42097967863082886,
-0.18556997179985046,
0.697445809841156,
-0.21457794308662415,
-0.911424458026886,
-0.5818357467651367,
0.1380363553762436,
0.22687910497188568,
0.005515820812433958,
0.6052317023277283,
-0.5218834280967712,
-0.14652681350708008,
-0.3466341197490692,
-0.520045816898346,
-0.1665274053812027,
-0.0122141744941473,
-0.2571275234222412,
0.3159841001033783,
-0.17808246612548828,
0.5045724511146545,
-0.23250746726989746,
-0.6372665166854858,
-0.24695011973381042,
0.3034273386001587,
0.16579240560531616,
0.7646973729133606,
0.4729526937007904,
-0.7004017233848572,
-0.3764735758304596,
-0.28508707880973816,
-0.6141495704650879,
0.02550632692873478,
0.21581776440143585,
-0.3703397810459137,
-0.039104923605918884,
0.3474421799182892,
-0.4632006883621216,
0.5662341117858887,
1.0421885251998901,
-0.19089260697364807,
0.9744694232940674,
-0.27427080273628235,
0.6148657202720642,
-0.9428107738494873,
-0.17379377782344818,
0.219386026263237,
-0.09316938370466232,
-0.898902952671051,
0.13078056275844574,
0.32111477851867676,
0.14187225699424744,
-0.5148388743400574,
0.21948230266571045,
-0.19688692688941956,
0.03145231679081917,
-0.25971662998199463,
0.025941716507077217,
0.4668436348438263,
0.3383033573627472,
-0.6462613344192505,
0.4862813651561737,
-0.0020589076448231936,
-0.6622529029846191,
0.5352823138237,
0.12476763874292374,
-0.18974725902080536,
1.0448909997940063,
-0.3811112642288208,
-0.2406804859638214,
0.14252586662769318,
0.16788585484027863,
-1.2922983169555664,
-0.09915976226329803,
0.22193332016468048,
-0.8362451791763306,
0.12860207259655,
-0.024995744228363037,
-0.6405544281005859,
-0.18052883446216583,
-0.3041742742061615,
0.5696951150894165,
0.36473843455314636,
-0.02659524418413639,
0.43598368763923645,
0.20569242537021637,
0.1708882451057434,
-0.11617259681224823,
-0.7055169939994812,
-0.007726535201072693,
-0.3146464228630066,
-0.5443212985992432,
0.02934628538787365,
-0.41379937529563904,
-0.12691465020179749,
-0.20064717531204224,
-0.29767513275146484,
-0.3623533248901367,
0.06550436466932297,
0.02319646254181862,
0.19436894357204437,
-0.285818487405777,
0.16198226809501648,
-0.03918332979083061,
-0.3608156144618988,
0.06979553401470184,
-0.25895482301712036,
0.34250253438949585,
0.07519178837537766,
-0.3232714831829071,
-0.4912709891796112,
0.450691282749176,
0.7406367063522339,
-0.34018516540527344,
0.7905581593513489,
0.47438526153564453,
-0.4470294415950775,
0.1686989963054657,
-0.43377217650413513,
-0.11137032508850098,
-0.289572149515152,
0.3868362009525299,
-0.5119431614875793,
-0.559870719909668,
0.46545514464378357,
-0.10383520275354385,
0.02976911887526512,
0.8765313625335693,
0.4006642997264862,
-0.14318224787712097,
1.4246267080307007,
0.6309798359870911,
0.15508504211902618,
0.16173414885997772,
0.10144995152950287,
0.19741307199001312,
-0.9266394972801208,
0.007894694805145264,
-0.9312054514884949,
-0.17484210431575775,
-0.6947632431983948,
-0.4639807641506195,
0.6170094609260559,
0.5728527307510376,
-0.07114681601524353,
0.17972072958946228,
-0.13065361976623535,
0.3091280460357666,
0.4788040816783905,
-0.2520885467529297,
0.5721557140350342,
-0.09584350138902664,
-0.35112619400024414,
-0.2828735113143921,
-0.49547716975212097,
-0.8260390758514404,
1.136237621307373,
0.49937543272972107,
0.5067203640937805,
0.30721333622932434,
0.4290046989917755,
0.33835887908935547,
0.4653928577899933,
-0.9550748467445374,
0.052069418132305145,
-0.30656278133392334,
-0.8376796245574951,
-0.4741678237915039,
-0.8099616765975952,
-0.50440913438797,
0.6579830050468445,
-0.029617495834827423,
-0.4272061884403229,
0.028014415875077248,
0.012839439325034618,
-0.2959941625595093,
0.33448663353919983,
-0.5065913200378418,
1.062352180480957,
-0.2490641325712204,
0.07660815119743347,
-0.07305429875850677,
-0.6070321798324585,
0.45060694217681885,
-0.2733113467693329,
0.6523249745368958,
-0.6271139979362488,
-0.0006380929262377322,
0.8789939880371094,
-0.1114608496427536,
0.5044779181480408,
0.05783994123339653,
-0.03960058093070984,
0.05575938522815704,
0.4240196943283081,
0.13049572706222534,
-0.1281147450208664,
-0.3655191957950592,
0.3059316873550415,
0.599350094795227,
-0.6465133428573608,
-0.4130718410015106,
0.42467883229255676,
-0.869253933429718,
-0.0025014851707965136,
-0.4552997052669525,
-0.671491265296936,
-0.2716098129749298,
0.4315497577190399,
0.4047299027442932,
0.3976338505744934,
-0.3447414040565491,
0.13203218579292297,
0.22618965804576874,
-0.13096947968006134,
-0.06558452546596527,
0.6521732211112976,
-0.1303853988647461,
-0.6711329221725464,
0.7678530812263489,
0.21321776509284973,
0.6618106961250305,
0.4758165180683136,
0.2156827449798584,
-0.23000125586986542,
-0.5764350891113281,
-0.38760268688201904,
0.21736609935760498,
-0.8967904448509216,
-0.4586182236671448,
-0.2241031974554062,
-0.3018488585948944,
-0.408742219209671,
0.2745184600353241,
-0.62131267786026,
-0.3146137297153473,
-0.09425262361764908,
0.11346486210823059,
0.011269330978393555,
0.8345544934272766,
-0.159719780087471,
0.4283486306667328,
-1.26577889919281,
0.24697421491146088,
-0.2550659477710724,
0.3722417950630188,
-0.19819723069667816,
-0.7241569757461548,
-0.6120888590812683,
0.30005842447280884,
-0.599192202091217,
-0.8318477272987366,
0.6872854232788086,
0.014155035838484764,
0.5231958627700806,
0.1077369973063469,
-0.07906976342201233,
0.4604613184928894,
-0.4065740406513214,
0.707565426826477,
0.3066321611404419,
-1.1009747982025146,
0.24659192562103271,
0.02340202033519745,
0.3344424068927765,
0.3908863365650177,
0.4108124375343323,
-1.215086579322815,
-0.5673558115959167,
-0.06240696460008621,
-0.6141178011894226,
0.4978701174259186,
-0.17701934278011322,
0.030086638405919075,
0.39206090569496155,
0.24850055575370789,
0.2599131166934967,
0.19537334144115448,
-0.7389159798622131,
-0.330387145280838,
-0.10001744329929352,
-0.4434325098991394,
-0.485455721616745,
-0.34993976354599,
-0.17975565791130066,
-0.08588732033967972,
0.49255529046058655,
-0.19680717587471008,
0.18198631703853607,
0.04308605194091797,
-0.08693034946918488,
-0.5609850287437439,
0.42447611689567566,
0.7130515575408936,
0.9736964106559753,
-0.3079947531223297,
0.22484469413757324,
-0.1467592716217041,
-0.3032560646533966,
0.5533324480056763,
-0.19887079298496246,
0.02769336849451065,
0.01165164727717638,
0.27027201652526855,
0.30780836939811707,
0.05470046028494835,
-0.08786305785179138,
0.39836397767066956,
-0.03242797777056694,
-0.3923167884349823,
-0.29223209619522095,
-0.12921853363513947,
-0.2686645984649658,
-0.04313509166240692,
0.4205198884010315,
0.40151098370552063,
0.12529408931732178,
-0.3387811481952667,
0.2999012768268585,
0.11243021488189697,
-0.9166492223739624,
-0.31119516491889954,
0.6071223616600037,
-0.03265237808227539,
-0.03867600858211517,
0.5298272371292114,
-0.1654423624277115,
-0.43557509779930115,
0.46706724166870117,
0.22507335245609283,
0.4862295091152191,
-0.5021477341651917,
0.3300991654396057,
0.40148016810417175,
0.5780646800994873,
-0.1715443879365921,
0.23197516798973083,
0.44680124521255493,
-0.7904437780380249,
-0.45972785353660583,
-0.6899427175521851,
-0.5318889021873474,
-0.0807492733001709,
-0.8380762338638306,
0.022961122915148735,
-0.1035824567079544,
-0.10487767308950424,
0.08544081449508667,
0.04619773477315903,
-0.4654945135116577,
0.36274784803390503,
-0.20312373340129852,
0.7456876039505005,
-0.8501997590065002,
0.8296247720718384,
0.29131418466567993,
-0.5147795677185059,
-0.7100344896316528,
-0.14063379168510437,
0.4168802499771118,
-0.5857111215591431,
0.31962552666664124,
0.020720474421977997,
0.04843098297715187,
-0.0477282740175724,
-0.3272421956062317,
-0.9660648703575134,
0.96914142370224,
-0.22506415843963623,
-0.2244586944580078,
0.011512139812111855,
0.5702036619186401,
0.6252784729003906,
-0.44351842999458313,
0.19992287456989288,
0.7987974882125854,
0.48745009303092957,
-0.01630113087594509,
-0.882608950138092,
-0.07722228765487671,
-0.005535246338695288,
0.08760135620832443,
0.5902699828147888,
-0.5856981873512268,
0.958986222743988,
-0.009110087528824806,
0.07085607200860977,
0.5242146849632263,
0.39362213015556335,
0.24140237271785736,
0.2278793454170227,
0.17843568325042725,
0.3725828230381012,
0.4627086818218231,
-0.454068124294281,
0.9477088451385498,
-0.25254055857658386,
0.31593480706214905,
0.6182569861412048,
-0.08326532691717148,
0.8980814814567566,
0.518993079662323,
-0.5294394493103027,
-0.040742531418800354,
0.6317768096923828,
-0.19261424243450165,
0.2938646674156189,
0.3590362071990967,
0.02584952674806118,
-0.01293338742107153,
-0.06732622534036636,
-0.304159939289093,
0.43040692806243896,
0.40733176469802856,
-0.3019961416721344,
-0.06310586631298065,
0.028655806556344032,
-0.11547176539897919,
0.06081012636423111,
-0.33537423610687256,
0.7297340035438538,
0.2826371192932129,
-0.5398361086845398,
0.5626322627067566,
0.5499432682991028,
0.3626404404640198,
-0.6038990020751953,
0.11625304818153381,
-0.39679351449012756,
0.26486608386039734,
-0.11384284496307373,
-0.8540956377983093,
0.48476117849349976,
-0.30073386430740356,
-0.44021859765052795,
-0.15086686611175537,
0.09979850798845291,
-0.5095853805541992,
-0.6433493494987488,
0.4044245779514313,
0.7776527404785156,
0.3236393928527832,
-0.36164921522140503,
-0.4680235981941223,
0.029567673802375793,
-0.23431380093097687,
0.0630485936999321,
0.2937640845775604,
0.8341019153594971,
-0.1096317321062088,
0.37799182534217834,
0.6591455340385437,
0.2889164090156555,
0.3279544413089752,
0.07840382307767868,
0.262349009513855,
-0.9212395548820496,
-0.4497482180595398,
-0.6646435260772705,
0.44363781809806824,
0.35470297932624817,
-0.5548952221870422,
0.7352898120880127,
0.40906479954719543,
0.6927087903022766,
0.09998447448015213,
0.5711795091629028,
0.26318952441215515,
0.6744081974029541,
-0.4118657410144806,
0.5950973033905029,
-0.6624813079833984,
0.027476906776428223,
-0.17036733031272888,
-1.0761997699737549,
-0.6901363134384155,
0.14751319587230682,
-0.09005317836999893,
0.11435369402170181,
0.9218632578849792,
0.5090923309326172,
0.23884500563144684,
-0.05440797284245491,
0.762879490852356,
-0.1555606573820114,
0.5483084917068481,
0.5874478220939636,
0.949566662311554,
-0.8908718824386597,
1.0128930807113647,
-0.2082468420267105,
-0.2928197681903839,
-0.3266797959804535,
-0.5686130523681641,
-0.2812039852142334,
-0.4615745544433594,
-0.06984970718622208,
-0.49091285467147827,
-0.37434637546539307,
0.7445772290229797,
0.6558942198753357,
-0.9474743008613586,
-0.6485527157783508,
0.15170347690582275,
0.2280237078666687,
-0.5229977965354919,
-0.26481351256370544,
-0.03768894821405411,
-0.38922324776649475,
-0.5286200046539307,
0.10048841685056686,
0.425717294216156,
0.18159952759742737,
-0.28388112783432007,
-0.3208378255367279,
-0.0684414878487587,
0.05773613601922989,
0.4833306074142456,
0.04039987549185753,
-0.6782832145690918,
-0.07777471840381622,
-0.034956689924001694,
-0.5870147347450256,
0.41255661845207214,
0.5878849029541016,
0.05927710607647896,
0.42520976066589355,
0.3730328679084778,
0.15136075019836426,
0.124631367623806,
-0.0789676383137703,
0.849696695804596,
-0.4753502607345581,
-0.11733659356832504,
0.09521288424730301,
0.19246327877044678,
0.2771797776222229,
-0.016404330730438232,
0.41395050287246704,
0.2981644570827484,
-0.6943331956863403,
-0.6981725692749023,
0.3350723087787628,
-0.6751041412353516,
0.004612979479134083,
0.6320777535438538,
-0.07720260322093964,
-0.03845565766096115,
-0.00022657422232441604,
0.0416121706366539,
0.31162723898887634,
-0.2513294517993927,
0.7205412983894348,
1.0326658487319946,
-0.0060544381849467754,
-0.1941036581993103,
-1.0283524990081787,
0.5678950548171997,
0.320311963558197,
-0.8438009023666382,
-0.21310415863990784,
0.42326033115386963,
0.07340221852064133,
0.5050124526023865,
0.3393790125846863,
-0.642179012298584,
0.4671812653541565,
-0.05774683505296707,
0.20989689230918884,
0.4343430697917938,
-0.5016632676124573,
-0.46420109272003174,
0.2649240493774414,
0.33190858364105225,
-0.2251891940832138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16964v1
|
Exploring the LLM Journey from Cognition to Expression with Linear Representations
| 2024-05-27T08:57:04 | 2024-05-27T08:57:04 |
Yuzi Yan, Jialian Li, Yipin Zhang, Dong Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents an in-depth examination of the evolution and interplay of
cognitive and expressive capabilities in large language models (LLMs), with a
specific focus on Baichuan-7B and Baichuan-33B, an advanced bilingual (Chinese
and English) LLM series. We define and explore the model's cognitive and
expressive capabilities through linear representations across three critical
phases: Pretraining, Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT), and Reinforcement Learning
from Human Feedback (RLHF). Cognitive capability is defined as the quantity and
quality of information conveyed by the neuron output vectors within the
network, similar to the neural signal processing in human cognition. Expressive
capability is defined as the model's capability to produce word-level output.
Our findings unveil a sequential development pattern, where cognitive abilities
are largely established during Pretraining, whereas expressive abilities
predominantly advance during SFT and RLHF. Statistical analyses confirm a
significant correlation between the two capabilities, suggesting that cognitive
capacity may limit expressive potential. The paper also explores the
theoretical underpinnings of these divergent developmental trajectories and
their connection to the LLMs' architectural design. Moreover, we evaluate
various optimization-independent strategies, such as few-shot learning and
repeated sampling, which bridge the gap between cognitive and expressive
capabilities. This research reveals the potential connection between the hidden
space and the output space, contributing valuable insights into the
interpretability and controllability of their training processes.
|
[
-0.34561702609062195,
-0.6337195634841919,
0.6483709216117859,
0.31325480341911316,
0.13831062614917755,
0.2685703933238983,
-0.6852437853813171,
-0.540316641330719,
-0.030169496312737465,
0.44054797291755676,
-0.7278117537498474,
-0.08770684152841568,
-0.6905247569084167,
-0.03366152197122574,
-0.11563892662525177,
0.8318166732788086,
-0.15714186429977417,
-0.01854388602077961,
-0.08636754006147385,
-0.01629576086997986,
-0.7689069509506226,
-0.34505629539489746,
-0.5673317909240723,
-0.41733402013778687,
0.6960747241973877,
0.061026256531476974,
0.5837181210517883,
0.6089967489242554,
0.29044803977012634,
0.31416863203048706,
-0.055361222475767136,
0.2419643998146057,
-0.7244209051132202,
0.17729908227920532,
-0.08147615939378738,
-0.46804168820381165,
-0.47347331047058105,
0.12830032408237457,
0.6659582853317261,
0.7042462825775146,
-0.09820771217346191,
-0.008554437197744846,
0.47111812233924866,
0.5251924395561218,
-0.3657630681991577,
0.4685099720954895,
-0.6846352219581604,
-0.11400040984153748,
-0.29309916496276855,
0.04040658473968506,
-0.5160953998565674,
-0.15997546911239624,
0.06316645443439484,
-0.7659931182861328,
-0.22554214298725128,
-0.22803664207458496,
0.8854432106018066,
0.12706391513347626,
-0.4380640387535095,
-0.5539073944091797,
-0.7815465331077576,
0.8683806657791138,
-0.5654478073120117,
0.06952224671840668,
0.07476068288087845,
0.28760167956352234,
-0.08941321820020676,
-0.8566941022872925,
-0.4419063925743103,
-0.4481431841850281,
-0.11810711771249771,
0.30591925978660583,
0.023907754570245743,
0.149921253323555,
0.334740549325943,
0.30058446526527405,
-0.39939990639686584,
0.3976718783378601,
-0.6028215289115906,
-0.2957483232021332,
0.8219612240791321,
0.36391156911849976,
0.17301271855831146,
-0.006495446432381868,
-0.2920256555080414,
0.06394139677286148,
-0.6917566657066345,
0.2908170819282532,
0.09186141192913055,
0.3006274998188019,
-0.006152048707008362,
0.501815676689148,
0.07649137824773788,
0.581336498260498,
-0.11149976402521133,
0.06695166975259781,
-0.03877478092908859,
-0.19226457178592682,
-0.0101711330935359,
-0.30568647384643555,
0.9124795794487,
-0.1905507594347,
0.35619866847991943,
0.010410296730697155,
-0.5057438015937805,
0.11931087076663971,
0.37877345085144043,
-0.4141405522823334,
0.17144092917442322,
0.05537451058626175,
-0.5895035862922668,
-0.26222872734069824,
0.1057250127196312,
-0.3611520528793335,
-0.44376492500305176,
-0.46489232778549194,
0.3400537967681885,
-0.5481389760971069,
-0.3621962368488312,
0.09046632796525955,
0.2548728287220001,
0.44228601455688477,
0.4094049334526062,
-1.155403733253479,
0.39832261204719543,
0.7588577270507812,
0.614282488822937,
-0.3235878348350525,
-0.2939014136791229,
-0.053665414452552795,
-0.034563980996608734,
-0.5331084728240967,
0.3051009178161621,
-0.4746776223182678,
-0.15112099051475525,
0.18057046830654144,
-0.15098828077316284,
-0.1880888193845749,
-0.7089922428131104,
0.5218397378921509,
-0.6314178705215454,
-0.08636103570461273,
-0.24941180646419525,
-0.3523526191711426,
-0.38809844851493835,
-0.03202218562364578,
-0.7096700072288513,
0.9154484868049622,
0.24023379385471344,
-0.1785590648651123,
0.08839964121580124,
-0.5689330101013184,
-0.27606168389320374,
0.2156500220298767,
-0.5256514549255371,
0.011236299760639668,
0.5211978554725647,
-0.0285379346460104,
0.5136196613311768,
-0.4452284574508667,
0.2193848192691803,
-0.19012829661369324,
-0.22491729259490967,
0.40161049365997314,
-0.317080020904541,
0.6649168729782104,
0.1260080635547638,
-0.3013494312763214,
0.21422676742076874,
-0.7063642740249634,
0.08916720002889633,
0.2849159240722656,
-0.5725144147872925,
0.10106606781482697,
0.0033281734213232994,
-0.26371946930885315,
0.46642011404037476,
0.6524618268013,
-0.33181533217430115,
0.11345604807138443,
-0.26399120688438416,
0.592696487903595,
0.8716436624526978,
-0.28780096769332886,
0.44325125217437744,
-0.4687354266643524,
0.6660341024398804,
-0.02933160774409771,
0.033235810697078705,
-0.2805972993373871,
-0.4032272398471832,
-0.8872330784797668,
-0.05496586486697197,
0.09679201245307922,
0.6520960927009583,
-0.6129510998725891,
0.4515058100223541,
-0.36214518547058105,
-0.2809375524520874,
-0.5821581482887268,
0.4196915030479431,
0.35830700397491455,
0.1185227781534195,
0.06447397917509079,
-0.31339114904403687,
-0.2504865229129791,
-0.9418222308158875,
0.05814487487077713,
-0.09218083322048187,
0.024157507345080376,
0.33778518438339233,
0.3219417631626129,
-0.10877025872468948,
0.4500579237937927,
-0.2528223395347595,
-0.2865370213985443,
-0.40886035561561584,
0.07656777650117874,
0.5027069449424744,
0.3427356481552124,
0.49998173117637634,
-0.4375919997692108,
-0.26309558749198914,
0.2990804612636566,
-0.9179263114929199,
-0.2746816575527191,
-0.43335068225860596,
-0.18062752485275269,
0.051897622644901276,
0.5599179863929749,
-0.6863084435462952,
0.3467215299606323,
0.5831502079963684,
-0.04815487191081047,
0.6021715998649597,
-0.23183976113796234,
-0.23647049069404602,
-0.47930148243904114,
-0.28620949387550354,
-0.38378381729125977,
0.017546718940138817,
-0.6049109697341919,
0.3007810413837433,
0.09450293332338333,
-0.02252897247672081,
-0.19395171105861664,
0.2938668727874756,
-0.7486434578895569,
-0.040925126522779465,
-0.3482154905796051,
0.4895083010196686,
-0.15336045622825623,
0.6666192412376404,
0.02704818919301033,
0.5579059720039368,
0.568465530872345,
-0.5594782829284668,
0.46299874782562256,
-0.15067210793495178,
-0.31814444065093994,
0.13084305822849274,
-0.5327408313751221,
0.1268652081489563,
-0.12228575348854065,
0.0484435148537159,
-0.9336963295936584,
-0.07517211884260178,
0.026810679584741592,
-0.3783971965312958,
0.37758785486221313,
0.3632986843585968,
-0.41797563433647156,
-0.3746289014816284,
-0.1995077282190323,
0.27501606941223145,
0.5414353609085083,
-0.0488276481628418,
0.9886462688446045,
0.06561075150966644,
-0.2714727818965912,
-0.28222477436065674,
-0.8543773889541626,
-0.13126738369464874,
-0.09769242256879807,
-0.9837499260902405,
0.290082186460495,
0.02680826000869274,
-0.10540027916431427,
-0.24010591208934784,
0.17331640422344208,
0.3596457242965698,
0.18470565974712372,
0.24311111867427826,
0.42704805731773376,
-0.527111291885376,
0.14301535487174988,
0.04501568153500557,
0.04470690339803696,
0.20502275228500366,
-0.18679676949977875,
0.7434001564979553,
-0.3619178533554077,
-0.16806462407112122,
-0.30287542939186096,
0.12161948531866074,
0.47660431265830994,
-0.48269855976104736,
0.7962999939918518,
0.5929664969444275,
-0.31826502084732056,
-0.20744754374027252,
-0.22480042278766632,
0.13095641136169434,
-0.4644685387611389,
0.43436217308044434,
-0.43411099910736084,
-0.8173425793647766,
0.8427055478096008,
-0.1430875062942505,
0.2266223281621933,
0.4486706852912903,
0.8227362632751465,
-0.10191024094820023,
0.5694730281829834,
0.5301365256309509,
0.3922005295753479,
0.5903823971748352,
-0.40652719140052795,
-0.054641056805849075,
-1.1911561489105225,
-0.4157441258430481,
0.021512581035494804,
-0.46406289935112,
-0.6546192765235901,
-0.5780308246612549,
0.15714655816555023,
0.1987829953432083,
-0.41516414284706116,
0.2003001868724823,
-0.20518386363983154,
0.15172380208969116,
0.3739171028137207,
0.21326422691345215,
0.05104486271739006,
-0.30514588952064514,
-0.2812805473804474,
-0.1965898722410202,
-0.49943262338638306,
-0.6232894659042358,
1.1375561952590942,
0.5954737067222595,
0.7997596859931946,
0.40189316868782043,
0.6346062421798706,
0.029100408777594566,
0.41740015149116516,
-0.8701665997505188,
0.7254073619842529,
-0.29271209239959717,
-0.3949287533760071,
-0.22585807740688324,
-0.182656392455101,
-0.9969347715377808,
0.32487958669662476,
-0.43348804116249084,
-0.8116873502731323,
0.12332027405500412,
0.017656486481428146,
-0.4347652792930603,
0.014817789196968079,
-0.6374801397323608,
0.6495867371559143,
-0.650732159614563,
-0.7026490569114685,
-0.4518684446811676,
-0.5536918640136719,
0.5690511465072632,
-0.08756102621555328,
0.10665636509656906,
0.0406770296394825,
-0.23220841586589813,
0.4591532349586487,
-0.03544805571436882,
0.7537439465522766,
-0.021590352058410645,
-0.4583324193954468,
0.16626133024692535,
0.3392878472805023,
0.282135933637619,
-0.08386951684951782,
-0.188681960105896,
-0.05189768970012665,
-0.3208220303058624,
-0.40643319487571716,
-0.8053295612335205,
0.5624691843986511,
-0.8049587607383728,
-0.8975608944892883,
-0.24627022445201874,
-0.6626593470573425,
-0.30542075634002686,
0.3217461109161377,
0.03711274638772011,
0.28159773349761963,
-0.3468013405799866,
0.17495588958263397,
0.6851485371589661,
-0.39661601185798645,
0.4058281183242798,
0.19228193163871765,
-0.6347949504852295,
-0.1603698432445526,
0.7137351632118225,
0.17543400824069977,
0.633100152015686,
0.4627169072628021,
0.15461771190166473,
-0.15282902121543884,
-0.670042872428894,
-0.10377933830022812,
0.4161013662815094,
-0.7719935774803162,
0.17344504594802856,
-0.03774173930287361,
-0.578135073184967,
-0.3368825316429138,
-0.03741423413157463,
-0.18838909268379211,
-0.3061491847038269,
-0.44378358125686646,
-0.018534893169999123,
-0.15375781059265137,
1.2651269435882568,
-0.08517037332057953,
0.38404494524002075,
-0.41429540514945984,
0.19988301396369934,
0.3158404231071472,
0.07438047230243683,
0.41300493478775024,
-0.5952731370925903,
-0.400735080242157,
0.13126643002033234,
-0.8295659422874451,
-0.6543050408363342,
0.13533678650856018,
0.1760839968919754,
0.6300249099731445,
0.7023665308952332,
-0.33134523034095764,
0.44785621762275696,
-0.33203861117362976,
0.8751948475837708,
0.04259394854307175,
-0.8035680651664734,
0.2836958169937134,
-0.5309545397758484,
0.32767945528030396,
0.012812239117920399,
0.2568204402923584,
-0.45077505707740784,
-0.2866448760032654,
-0.37284940481185913,
-0.7117041945457458,
0.7829182744026184,
0.10786326229572296,
0.2583829164505005,
0.21572613716125488,
0.24223357439041138,
0.005598107818514109,
0.012369408272206783,
-0.9315352439880371,
-0.005482412409037352,
-0.22521500289440155,
-0.15495194494724274,
-0.09815418720245361,
-0.0760321393609047,
-0.23325560986995697,
-0.1958058774471283,
0.41397520899772644,
-0.09984017163515091,
0.34035006165504456,
-0.07082539051771164,
-0.20145773887634277,
0.34848278760910034,
0.14448301494121552,
0.7143430709838867,
0.5652044415473938,
0.1322396695613861,
-0.14039385318756104,
-0.1093570739030838,
-0.3492662012577057,
-0.07187969982624054,
-0.04552849382162094,
0.22097143530845642,
-0.47762179374694824,
0.7786791324615479,
1.1972928047180176,
-0.005350536201149225,
-0.6064242124557495,
0.39487314224243164,
0.12247209250926971,
-0.131071999669075,
-0.42002224922180176,
0.15487068891525269,
0.2921610176563263,
0.36754029989242554,
0.3218640387058258,
-0.009688682854175568,
-0.14552834630012512,
-0.7383956909179688,
-0.1704755276441574,
0.33538496494293213,
-0.34913888573646545,
-0.3389500081539154,
0.6778128147125244,
-0.009000713005661964,
-0.09307879954576492,
0.7956684231758118,
-0.055502962321043015,
-0.373300701379776,
0.4388975203037262,
0.4365755617618561,
0.8090806603431702,
0.00840108934789896,
0.14420710504055023,
0.1389961987733841,
0.4235862195491791,
0.2003031224012375,
0.07753584533929825,
-0.14453500509262085,
-1.022553563117981,
-0.29255542159080505,
-0.4926929771900177,
0.1519317477941513,
0.20324982702732086,
-0.7131821513175964,
0.14508062601089478,
-0.6667027473449707,
-0.3100159764289856,
0.009513449855148792,
-0.055887095630168915,
-0.707252025604248,
0.02195758745074272,
0.48402249813079834,
0.7621162533760071,
-0.5854246616363525,
0.7418197989463806,
0.5315904021263123,
-0.5841584801673889,
-1.0517843961715698,
-0.022043487057089806,
0.019742777571082115,
-1.1256510019302368,
1.0529104471206665,
0.06026408448815346,
-0.12626568973064423,
-0.1375446319580078,
-0.4518163800239563,
-0.6452263593673706,
1.2867395877838135,
0.4555264413356781,
-0.5229718685150146,
-0.24661564826965332,
0.21103264391422272,
0.7984447479248047,
-0.6295759677886963,
0.31741657853126526,
0.651357889175415,
0.3451681137084961,
-0.15501919388771057,
-0.8895267844200134,
0.1704384982585907,
-0.1799228936433792,
0.5046724081039429,
-0.054563969373703,
-0.8812892436981201,
0.9393699169158936,
-0.2537097632884979,
-0.42307624220848083,
0.5234702229499817,
0.8836340308189392,
0.325472891330719,
-0.19913695752620697,
0.18082799017429352,
0.3112497925758362,
0.5845109224319458,
-0.3380650579929352,
0.9752815365791321,
-0.2626418173313141,
0.08269603550434113,
0.707944393157959,
-0.22537745535373688,
0.8116434812545776,
0.49263396859169006,
-0.11086217314004898,
0.7563049793243408,
0.5167427062988281,
0.29372748732566833,
0.31602317094802856,
0.602911114692688,
-0.35952016711235046,
-0.2810567319393158,
-0.008937930688261986,
0.01680949330329895,
0.500923752784729,
0.7274430394172668,
-0.4609958231449127,
0.1192295253276825,
0.01706261932849884,
-0.10017503798007965,
0.28941965103149414,
-0.43314218521118164,
0.6731252670288086,
0.29252028465270996,
-0.8606514930725098,
0.7920143008232117,
-0.2361556589603424,
0.7617030739784241,
-0.891778290271759,
0.025116626173257828,
-0.18079091608524323,
0.11085417121648788,
-0.15775635838508606,
-1.1598767042160034,
0.1397906392812729,
-0.46716803312301636,
-0.07462596893310547,
-0.6178584098815918,
0.5956711173057556,
-0.3241913616657257,
-0.193587526679039,
0.673181414604187,
0.41213515400886536,
0.018992789089679718,
0.3597891330718994,
-0.6208904981613159,
0.3428970277309418,
-0.053033411502838135,
-0.282757431268692,
0.1359124779701233,
0.7340705990791321,
-0.29244670271873474,
0.7638901472091675,
0.4241369366645813,
0.5972564816474915,
0.35711172223091125,
0.0239819698035717,
0.7941105365753174,
-0.5747702121734619,
-0.19792379438877106,
-0.6152964234352112,
0.46104615926742554,
0.16064852476119995,
-0.30993062257766724,
0.2076399028301239,
0.27695587277412415,
0.8585648536682129,
-0.25323572754859924,
0.8057108521461487,
-0.3300716280937195,
0.10112843662500381,
-0.7991613745689392,
0.5630250573158264,
-0.39785706996917725,
0.429250031709671,
-0.04286817088723183,
-0.590107262134552,
-0.04889657720923424,
0.5743104815483093,
-0.42474544048309326,
0.21691720187664032,
0.6637598276138306,
0.7787086367607117,
0.07716702669858932,
-0.20752142369747162,
0.48737213015556335,
0.5089201331138611,
0.35995903611183167,
1.0829790830612183,
1.1439697742462158,
-0.2882572114467621,
0.43127501010894775,
0.023367369547486305,
-0.43400201201438904,
0.15700753033161163,
-0.5349330306053162,
-0.6592485904693604,
-0.7531368136405945,
0.16871872544288635,
-0.2920336425304413,
-0.3502095341682434,
0.6484673023223877,
0.5325674414634705,
-0.4855392277240753,
-0.6727058291435242,
0.010897701606154442,
-0.0653894692659378,
-0.22435104846954346,
-0.2586439251899719,
0.16772015392780304,
-0.3712080419063568,
-0.575835108757019,
0.14246554672718048,
0.3470565974712372,
-0.05036379024386406,
-0.6409549117088318,
-0.2801026701927185,
-0.08886375278234482,
0.13534055650234222,
0.7796218991279602,
0.3839184045791626,
-0.8771970868110657,
-0.08882863074541092,
0.08326146006584167,
-0.07684289664030075,
-0.04767359048128128,
0.9916741251945496,
-0.7200257778167725,
0.33260324597358704,
0.4112977087497711,
0.7488083839416504,
0.4827674627304077,
-0.2916366457939148,
0.8689977526664734,
-0.3053627014160156,
0.08707521110773087,
0.2147684246301651,
0.4869973361492157,
0.19223549962043762,
-0.07007728517055511,
0.22254106402397156,
0.14462660253047943,
-0.456981360912323,
-0.4302910566329956,
0.631053626537323,
-1.0291398763656616,
-0.13621214032173157,
0.9907497763633728,
-0.3042198419570923,
-0.05541060492396355,
0.1492694467306137,
-0.28933286666870117,
0.26142391562461853,
-0.24652981758117676,
0.6296423077583313,
1.0417770147323608,
-0.5589706897735596,
-0.3974519371986389,
-0.7087602019309998,
0.2955361008644104,
0.2605958878993988,
-0.6016526222229004,
0.10816862434148788,
0.29689136147499084,
0.009522393345832825,
0.3461257815361023,
0.6281115412712097,
-0.3240862786769867,
0.22663597762584686,
-0.20188403129577637,
-0.15699009597301483,
0.12021772563457489,
-0.19126512110233307,
-0.33329662680625916,
-0.11087056994438171,
0.3936610519886017,
0.0033249142579734325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16933v1
|
Empowering Large Language Models to Set up a Knowledge Retrieval Indexer via Self-Learning
| 2024-05-27T08:26:45 | 2024-05-27T08:26:45 |
Xun Liang, Simin Niu, Zhiyu li, Sensen Zhang, Shichao Song, Hanyu Wang, Jiawei Yang, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang, Chenyang Xi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) offers a cost-effective approach to
injecting real-time knowledge into large language models (LLMs). Nevertheless,
constructing and validating high-quality knowledge repositories require
considerable effort. We propose a pre-retrieval framework named Pseudo-Graph
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (PG-RAG), which conceptualizes LLMs as students
by providing them with abundant raw reading materials and encouraging them to
engage in autonomous reading to record factual information in their own words.
The resulting concise, well-organized mental indices are interconnected through
common topics or complementary facts to form a pseudo-graph database. During
the retrieval phase, PG-RAG mimics the human behavior in flipping through
notes, identifying fact paths and subsequently exploring the related contexts.
Adhering to the principle of the path taken by many is the best, it integrates
highly corroborated fact paths to provide a structured and refined sub-graph
assisting LLMs. We validated PG-RAG on three specialized question-answering
datasets. In single-document tasks, PG-RAG significantly outperformed the
current best baseline, KGP-LLaMA, across all key evaluation metrics, with an
average overall performance improvement of 11.6%. Specifically, its BLEU score
increased by approximately 14.3%, and the QE-F1 metric improved by 23.7%. In
multi-document scenarios, the average metrics of PG-RAG were at least 2.35%
higher than the best baseline. Notably, the BLEU score and QE-F1 metric showed
stable improvements of around 7.55% and 12.75%, respectively. Our code:
https://github.com/IAAR-Shanghai/PGRAG.
|
[
-0.41698041558265686,
-0.7496649622917175,
0.7122364044189453,
-0.2531677782535553,
-0.2278432697057724,
0.4731830060482025,
0.050920598208904266,
-0.32148438692092896,
0.3246118724346161,
0.40414926409721375,
-0.16141346096992493,
-0.3998105525970459,
-0.33924493193626404,
0.08310452848672867,
-0.3613823652267456,
1.1121842861175537,
0.04982315003871918,
-0.3276984691619873,
-0.34045106172561646,
0.002970093162730336,
-0.14860191941261292,
-0.5490946769714355,
-0.45494183897972107,
-0.33773720264434814,
0.6342768669128418,
0.2967885136604309,
0.597838819026947,
0.6967912912368774,
0.25895458459854126,
0.29280948638916016,
0.12540864944458008,
0.5526847839355469,
-0.9261979460716248,
0.09728699922561646,
-0.41345155239105225,
-0.3364734947681427,
-0.44249218702316284,
0.13512450456619263,
0.6683922410011292,
0.2384597361087799,
-0.11195746809244156,
0.3229338824748993,
0.14245878159999847,
0.7858903408050537,
-0.6691603660583496,
0.05093146488070488,
-0.5939863324165344,
-0.21417997777462006,
-0.43145859241485596,
-0.32434460520744324,
-0.31796279549598694,
-0.4091503620147705,
0.033766720443964005,
-0.8534504175186157,
0.18235987424850464,
0.412258505821228,
1.0932788848876953,
0.14116230607032776,
-0.29908835887908936,
-0.4259456396102905,
-0.37272530794143677,
0.5226612687110901,
-0.3175050914287567,
0.5854331851005554,
0.4801500737667084,
0.3920574486255646,
-0.11801347136497498,
-1.1934682130813599,
-0.8441557288169861,
0.0261120293289423,
-0.40701988339424133,
0.27510878443717957,
-0.066154345870018,
-0.0549030564725399,
0.15070900321006775,
0.509318470954895,
-0.7691433429718018,
-0.21164658665657043,
-0.25858622789382935,
-0.2898014783859253,
0.4898272156715393,
-0.008350090123713017,
0.357680082321167,
-0.5829285383224487,
-0.15561647713184357,
-0.13279888033866882,
-0.8149803280830383,
-0.13106779754161835,
0.4854671359062195,
0.2047627717256546,
0.3211323022842407,
0.7127370834350586,
-0.12881430983543396,
0.7564091086387634,
0.23119214177131653,
-0.33453643321990967,
0.4622375965118408,
-0.49064740538597107,
0.07855426520109177,
-0.09996297955513,
0.8713505864143372,
0.09979277104139328,
0.16071583330631256,
-0.3122781813144684,
-0.3301347494125366,
-0.24062012135982513,
0.31923767924308777,
-0.922451913356781,
-0.46322041749954224,
-0.03884444385766983,
-0.28766241669654846,
0.03836600482463837,
-0.16805493831634521,
-0.7720800042152405,
-0.36125925183296204,
-0.3708088994026184,
0.7343764305114746,
-0.389011412858963,
-0.3244340419769287,
-0.14069192111492157,
-0.09286157786846161,
0.23995861411094666,
0.22797122597694397,
-0.5510799288749695,
0.12194272130727768,
0.6581902503967285,
0.8604632019996643,
-0.10356966406106949,
-0.27882492542266846,
-0.5564604997634888,
0.11440081149339676,
-0.5576207041740417,
0.942456066608429,
-0.3786585032939911,
-0.5233849883079529,
-0.298489511013031,
-0.16560178995132446,
-0.19551397860050201,
-0.5574355125427246,
0.48153725266456604,
-0.8767464756965637,
0.4399299621582031,
-0.4445306360721588,
-0.5857251882553101,
-0.004739417694509029,
0.5242763757705688,
-0.34025534987449646,
1.3755824565887451,
0.38926583528518677,
-1.012292742729187,
0.2000858336687088,
-0.34331682324409485,
-0.30684056878089905,
0.27493736147880554,
-0.40605196356773376,
-0.34270694851875305,
-0.25832313299179077,
0.12110091745853424,
0.2901115119457245,
-0.5176386833190918,
0.2832973003387451,
-0.06407910585403442,
-0.4601171314716339,
-0.26756665110588074,
-0.14936037361621857,
0.4657615125179291,
0.29118603467941284,
-0.07488234341144562,
0.0012133095879107714,
-0.6971133351325989,
0.16809560358524323,
0.2113519012928009,
-0.3451622724533081,
-0.5322503447532654,
-0.1567741334438324,
-0.3736402690410614,
0.2858448028564453,
0.40501081943511963,
-0.5768455862998962,
0.2585684061050415,
-0.36682698130607605,
0.05335516110062599,
0.6262874603271484,
0.18280640244483948,
0.41801348328590393,
-0.40338584780693054,
0.5706221461296082,
-0.17364202439785004,
-0.009284022264182568,
-0.18756261467933655,
-0.2943732738494873,
-0.5321312546730042,
-0.42396673560142517,
0.33722764253616333,
0.6407128572463989,
-1.2889944314956665,
0.2744324505329132,
-0.3656199872493744,
-0.7172541618347168,
-0.6827795505523682,
0.4027782678604126,
0.5900132060050964,
1.1060028076171875,
0.4822520911693573,
-0.05501427501440048,
-0.4343651533126831,
-0.573279619216919,
-0.13007400929927826,
-0.34261515736579895,
-0.004567949566990137,
0.561410665512085,
0.28330275416374207,
-0.3494666516780853,
1.1690504550933838,
-0.5827412009239197,
-0.27363768219947815,
-0.20601797103881836,
0.3303925693035126,
0.4694070518016815,
0.21002358198165894,
0.4656028747558594,
-0.8023331761360168,
-0.6917573809623718,
-0.04624702036380768,
-0.6643511652946472,
-0.2609573006629944,
0.2784929871559143,
-0.4434581995010376,
0.12038106471300125,
0.5521807074546814,
-0.4718254804611206,
0.16207239031791687,
0.37702077627182007,
-0.1740553230047226,
0.6589996218681335,
-0.36164015531539917,
0.2609795033931732,
-1.1181243658065796,
0.3828161060810089,
-0.1897481232881546,
-0.4186415374279022,
-0.3064729571342468,
-0.026967590674757957,
0.1774330735206604,
-0.13412317633628845,
-0.14970827102661133,
0.7543980479240417,
-0.4784137010574341,
-0.17909517884254456,
-0.3282521367073059,
0.4443826675415039,
0.2584417462348938,
0.3218805491924286,
-0.16344527900218964,
1.2772730588912964,
0.2883128821849823,
-0.6110056638717651,
0.1609455794095993,
0.19429805874824524,
-0.36034008860588074,
0.4682893455028534,
-0.6101878881454468,
0.3289967477321625,
-0.4534370005130768,
0.2785140573978424,
-0.9071115851402283,
-0.049044474959373474,
0.18687517940998077,
-0.4629877209663391,
0.517063319683075,
-0.3316862881183624,
-0.7257848381996155,
-0.4546220004558563,
-0.18481630086898804,
0.3187294006347656,
0.5055011510848999,
-0.7318230867385864,
0.8787657022476196,
0.5968940854072571,
-0.08636365085840225,
-0.8749639987945557,
-0.07747825980186462,
0.03391644358634949,
0.046516966074705124,
-0.4969295263290405,
0.29291173815727234,
-0.07731025665998459,
-0.08914707601070404,
0.24607804417610168,
-0.04148239269852638,
0.250509649515152,
-0.08493704348802567,
-0.06000881269574165,
0.26894068717956543,
-0.16507470607757568,
0.36860984563827515,
0.009704293683171272,
-0.2950359284877777,
-0.26005667448043823,
-0.37764182686805725,
0.6302263140678406,
-0.07826723903417587,
-0.20557156205177307,
0.1821119785308838,
-0.082893505692482,
0.21330291032791138,
-0.5913243293762207,
0.565701961517334,
0.5533339381217957,
-0.020564734935760498,
-0.24611099064350128,
-0.5880988836288452,
-0.03822026774287224,
-0.5049891471862793,
0.28649523854255676,
-0.5864917635917664,
-1.0360585451126099,
0.38783809542655945,
-0.39786121249198914,
-0.028438247740268707,
0.5457305908203125,
0.35377001762390137,
-0.27759039402008057,
0.825168788433075,
0.38097211718559265,
-0.023417573422193527,
0.3370981216430664,
-0.4176257848739624,
0.45251166820526123,
-1.0062196254730225,
-0.11487134546041489,
-0.4846142530441284,
0.02822542004287243,
-0.7033674716949463,
-0.661748468875885,
0.6782545447349548,
0.45158651471138,
-0.23635141551494598,
0.056439224630594254,
-0.4957883358001709,
0.5429455637931824,
0.4597587585449219,
-0.0453057698905468,
0.2362985759973526,
-0.229958176612854,
-0.2745548486709595,
0.07581184059381485,
-0.7943311333656311,
-0.41701701283454895,
1.1542747020721436,
0.07630530744791031,
0.689867377281189,
0.15587182343006134,
0.9398561716079712,
0.23048292100429535,
0.5930566787719727,
-0.7357227802276611,
0.6463631987571716,
-0.2487042248249054,
-0.632556676864624,
-0.3167387545108795,
-0.7706498503684998,
-1.0381923913955688,
0.42326459288597107,
-0.29105275869369507,
-0.41588062047958374,
0.11462293565273285,
0.3600171208381653,
-0.0957777202129364,
0.16473475098609924,
-0.7232372164726257,
0.7998663783073425,
-0.38113516569137573,
-0.6342524290084839,
0.014348402619361877,
-0.5071876049041748,
0.27566206455230713,
-0.38866570591926575,
0.37268832325935364,
0.07668107002973557,
0.018743712455034256,
0.6112099289894104,
-0.30132535099983215,
0.4105817377567291,
-0.2888096570968628,
0.06534082442522049,
0.6586586236953735,
0.1649102121591568,
0.6209182739257812,
-0.07954524457454681,
-0.24368727207183838,
-0.10793789476156235,
0.04726606607437134,
-0.27593666315078735,
-0.8414666652679443,
0.6991093754768372,
-0.8239012360572815,
-0.8211303949356079,
-0.5455242991447449,
-0.40760812163352966,
-0.3358091711997986,
0.6098929047584534,
0.20413099229335785,
0.43019428849220276,
0.01769169792532921,
0.0872216448187828,
0.7693114280700684,
-0.15361906588077545,
-0.006367462687194347,
0.657201886177063,
-0.6848762631416321,
-0.47804170846939087,
1.307153582572937,
0.5365231037139893,
0.10527543723583221,
0.4983619153499603,
0.4416496753692627,
-0.7297095060348511,
-0.46095001697540283,
-0.6300303936004639,
0.6364299058914185,
-0.7337374091148376,
-0.28527265787124634,
-0.8120775818824768,
-0.159596249461174,
-0.6150685548782349,
0.17039872705936432,
-0.20833159983158112,
-0.24709764122962952,
-0.17981703579425812,
-0.20929422974586487,
0.2922303378582001,
0.6676018238067627,
-0.13754704594612122,
0.13786308467388153,
-0.8498925566673279,
0.5289334654808044,
0.37150460481643677,
0.3818260729312897,
0.017244895920157433,
-0.6206621527671814,
-0.3042706251144409,
-0.17911593616008759,
-0.15719982981681824,
-0.7348387241363525,
0.36082980036735535,
0.20023906230926514,
0.6714863181114197,
0.11096454411745071,
0.2233380824327469,
0.8411049246788025,
-0.678715169429779,
0.4293513298034668,
-0.14353600144386292,
-0.74402916431427,
0.3360089063644409,
-0.4261278212070465,
0.1039235070347786,
0.7650735378265381,
0.5671329498291016,
-0.44941800832748413,
-0.24422354996204376,
-0.5393086671829224,
-0.9845327138900757,
0.5686793923377991,
-0.1022636815905571,
0.04285523667931557,
-0.2193991243839264,
0.7004105448722839,
-0.14393827319145203,
0.2507269084453583,
-0.47432050108909607,
-0.2998514175415039,
-0.4797808527946472,
-0.3212778866291046,
-0.3273282051086426,
-0.40311896800994873,
0.060652948915958405,
-0.14609427750110626,
0.9327230453491211,
-0.3398483693599701,
-0.0025270862970501184,
0.4349871873855591,
-0.14799240231513977,
-0.04933799430727959,
0.05486301705241203,
0.044331084936857224,
0.8207385540008545,
-0.2486128956079483,
0.29189765453338623,
-0.09996847063302994,
-0.4619506001472473,
0.11559858918190002,
0.29694923758506775,
-0.2477198988199234,
-0.1826263815164566,
0.16181088984012604,
0.5330476760864258,
-0.014814070425927639,
-0.5883069634437561,
0.43895915150642395,
-0.07215705513954163,
0.05102900415658951,
-0.07489406317472458,
0.06363823264837265,
0.03218293935060501,
0.1210482120513916,
0.5796470642089844,
-0.4676632583141327,
0.17653696238994598,
-0.5627008080482483,
0.4366769790649414,
0.30431288480758667,
0.08006557077169418,
-0.1296451985836029,
0.3550476133823395,
0.02179405838251114,
-0.12330109626054764,
0.6435607075691223,
-0.7167816758155823,
-0.665393054485321,
0.14889638125896454,
0.676978588104248,
0.4465353190898895,
-0.21042880415916443,
0.2511310875415802,
0.5657323598861694,
0.2536564767360687,
-0.1358184963464737,
0.2666677236557007,
-0.18970438838005066,
-0.703429102897644,
-0.5361045598983765,
-0.8898468613624573,
-0.3391786217689514,
-0.09867724031209946,
-0.3180859684944153,
0.15368488430976868,
-0.3102448880672455,
-0.20449772477149963,
-0.3486851453781128,
0.3181290030479431,
-0.44979801774024963,
0.34301698207855225,
-0.24260713160037994,
0.6843730807304382,
-0.6012608408927917,
0.8654772043228149,
0.8416489958763123,
-0.5070713758468628,
-1.0552977323532104,
0.0188999455422163,
-0.26484742760658264,
-0.8123561143875122,
0.6159896850585938,
-0.13677208125591278,
-0.28158023953437805,
0.4890848398208618,
-0.14349417388439178,
-1.1166080236434937,
1.1364014148712158,
0.2658727467060089,
-0.6508980989456177,
-0.25215521454811096,
-0.14659368991851807,
0.7766598463058472,
0.0074864337220788,
0.32442519068717957,
0.2542526125907898,
0.33945542573928833,
0.3440421223640442,
-0.7361768484115601,
-0.1525219976902008,
-0.2507191002368927,
-0.23870038986206055,
0.519187331199646,
-0.7023782730102539,
0.8562844395637512,
0.010733426548540592,
-0.4017713963985443,
-0.24596334993839264,
0.7387542724609375,
0.5156254768371582,
0.42217889428138733,
0.5113885998725891,
0.7724243998527527,
1.022315263748169,
0.053007010370492935,
1.3203731775283813,
-0.6247702836990356,
0.3234390914440155,
1.2548620700836182,
-0.20692600309848785,
0.6991567611694336,
0.2598303556442261,
-0.0727374404668808,
0.49020084738731384,
0.47613325715065,
0.32789477705955505,
0.42443767189979553,
0.24669654667377472,
-0.09441782534122467,
-0.281491219997406,
-0.22434379160404205,
-0.22594915330410004,
0.31314414739608765,
0.3228122889995575,
-0.1737341284751892,
-0.29844725131988525,
-0.14723622798919678,
0.11929893493652344,
0.23748180270195007,
-0.3727087378501892,
0.7849169969558716,
0.058897409588098526,
-0.7481927275657654,
0.5002002716064453,
-0.16981738805770874,
0.5326409339904785,
-0.7467712163925171,
-0.1252415031194687,
-0.21703872084617615,
-0.0018081690650433302,
-0.21492120623588562,
-0.8926378488540649,
0.24752137064933777,
0.10642123967409134,
-0.18599656224250793,
-0.22203585505485535,
0.9999288320541382,
-0.35335198044776917,
-0.4713643491268158,
0.3618025481700897,
0.8396060466766357,
0.13959619402885437,
0.09082603454589844,
-0.7342373728752136,
-0.07892903685569763,
-0.19878660142421722,
-0.3961504399776459,
0.5698336362838745,
0.6039687395095825,
-0.12524618208408356,
0.525772213935852,
0.7767738103866577,
0.10847309231758118,
-0.017908982932567596,
0.1402713805437088,
0.9250547885894775,
-0.28518593311309814,
-0.47967156767845154,
-0.4947633445262909,
0.1454995572566986,
-0.029397111386060715,
-0.061608269810676575,
0.9770873188972473,
0.8508228659629822,
0.9164093732833862,
0.4564707279205322,
0.6191521286964417,
-0.12710732221603394,
0.9882352352142334,
-0.33315449953079224,
0.9269525408744812,
-0.7491238117218018,
0.06884302198886871,
-0.3189564049243927,
-0.9543362259864807,
-0.009372083470225334,
0.5203098058700562,
-0.5908370018005371,
0.12019925564527512,
0.42043131589889526,
0.8686650395393372,
0.00021958100842311978,
-0.4382851719856262,
0.3047616183757782,
0.22919948399066925,
0.5212302207946777,
0.048494789749383926,
0.780733048915863,
-0.2928332984447479,
0.6048644781112671,
-0.10867027193307877,
-0.21040989458560944,
0.1910577416419983,
-0.7146989703178406,
-0.7559024095535278,
-0.5692499279975891,
-0.03683391213417053,
-0.5082545876502991,
0.18227358162403107,
0.7929300665855408,
0.4704522490501404,
-0.3096145689487457,
-0.1558099240064621,
0.0824216976761818,
0.17872270941734314,
0.31057319045066833,
-0.26681944727897644,
0.6858659982681274,
-0.4914109408855438,
-0.5600460767745972,
0.382821649312973,
0.201494038105011,
-0.1544865220785141,
-0.16490021347999573,
-0.08347797393798828,
-0.4275921583175659,
0.09264618903398514,
0.634132444858551,
0.40330955386161804,
-0.2296268194913864,
-0.31111469864845276,
0.08908117562532425,
-0.2820071280002594,
0.04201045259833336,
0.7213078737258911,
-1.0334374904632568,
0.7139169573783875,
0.7408139109611511,
0.9290976524353027,
0.7227399945259094,
0.3745630085468292,
0.22167594730854034,
-0.5927684307098389,
-0.18458151817321777,
0.3371178209781647,
0.2353617399930954,
0.39285728335380554,
-0.4149132966995239,
0.5562857985496521,
0.38617071509361267,
-0.7508659958839417,
-0.8046838045120239,
0.04281964898109436,
-0.4601380527019501,
-0.14694218337535858,
0.8787049055099487,
-0.28187239170074463,
-0.45065340399742126,
-0.19261141121387482,
-0.2949690818786621,
0.35757169127464294,
-0.2759968936443329,
0.8145002722740173,
0.5014406442642212,
-0.1936093419790268,
-0.2928105294704437,
-0.2384825050830841,
0.5172103643417358,
0.1694777011871338,
-0.8148687481880188,
-0.07726471871137619,
0.5971799492835999,
0.28745314478874207,
0.37609976530075073,
1.0931881666183472,
-0.1891375482082367,
0.1554117053747177,
-0.2628966271877289,
0.0031675389036536217,
-0.3369868993759155,
-0.3895912170410156,
0.10755181312561035,
0.18627674877643585,
0.1218956932425499,
0.2531869113445282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16919v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16919v2
|
VoCoT: Unleashing Visually Grounded Multi-Step Reasoning in Large Multi-Modal Models
| 2024-05-27T08:12:00 | 2024-05-28T06:12:45 |
Zejun Li, Ruipu Luo, Jiwen Zhang, Minghui Qiu, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While large multi-modal models (LMMs) have exhibited impressive capabilities
across diverse tasks, their effectiveness in handling complex tasks has been
limited by the prevailing single-step reasoning paradigm. To this end, this
paper proposes VoCoT, a multi-step Visually grounded object-centric
Chain-of-Thought reasoning framework tailored for inference with LMMs. VoCoT is
characterized by two key features: (1) object-centric reasoning paths that
revolve around cross-modal shared object-level information, and (2) visually
grounded representation of object concepts in a multi-modal interleaved and
aligned manner, which effectively bridges the modality gap within LMMs during
long-term generation. Additionally, we construct an instruction dataset to
facilitate LMMs in adapting to reasoning with VoCoT. By introducing VoCoT into
the prevalent open-source LMM architecture, we introduce VolCano. With only 7B
parameters and limited input resolution, VolCano demonstrates excellent
performance across various scenarios, surpassing SOTA models, including GPT-4V,
in tasks requiring complex reasoning. Our code, data and model will be
available at https://github.com/RupertLuo/VoCoT.
|
[
-0.48493602871894836,
-0.954276442527771,
0.8591009974479675,
0.14186270534992218,
-0.3691652715206146,
-0.021047839894890785,
-0.051118154078722,
-0.2257208377122879,
-0.1741737574338913,
0.7485669851303101,
-0.6137183308601379,
-0.6261895895004272,
-0.2645007371902466,
-0.15608014166355133,
-0.2864327132701874,
0.5675584673881531,
0.15028683841228485,
-0.05205260589718819,
-0.6012510657310486,
0.13338783383369446,
-0.3904469311237335,
-0.5612604022026062,
-0.31107673048973083,
-0.18129035830497742,
0.7577467560768127,
0.5814117789268494,
0.66169673204422,
0.467136412858963,
0.18955183029174805,
0.23719333112239838,
-0.03742843493819237,
0.7187753915786743,
-0.41387614607810974,
0.24047574400901794,
-0.5240816473960876,
-0.3538723289966583,
-0.4884518086910248,
-0.4086277186870575,
0.2044975459575653,
0.46747368574142456,
-0.010913334786891937,
0.05849219858646393,
-0.17819204926490784,
0.4479278326034546,
-0.8274602890014648,
0.30072423815727234,
-0.8246004581451416,
0.039133187383413315,
0.009390324354171753,
-0.3328078091144562,
-0.8131712675094604,
0.19531495869159698,
-0.0979292020201683,
-0.7947898507118225,
0.15837743878364563,
0.2838679552078247,
0.4324997365474701,
0.27129217982292175,
-0.8555572032928467,
-0.024526726454496384,
-0.4967438280582428,
0.8136677145957947,
-0.3654674291610718,
0.7115126252174377,
0.1725199818611145,
0.3824615180492401,
-0.38005539774894714,
-0.8740414381027222,
-0.623609721660614,
-0.22374114394187927,
0.2140011042356491,
0.44546380639076233,
0.28774121403694153,
0.06910017877817154,
0.239290252327919,
0.14139805734157562,
-0.09244433045387268,
-0.08811761438846588,
-0.23157137632369995,
-0.08262596279382706,
0.116883784532547,
0.1307825893163681,
0.10064811259508133,
-0.43846648931503296,
-0.6502895355224609,
-0.05969252437353134,
-0.6624733209609985,
0.2328876554965973,
0.10314849764108658,
0.37004369497299194,
0.09786731749773026,
0.6718471646308899,
-0.14128383994102478,
0.7213835120201111,
-0.15203668177127838,
-0.09928739070892334,
-0.07927985489368439,
-0.27160418033599854,
-0.49102556705474854,
-0.01228319015353918,
0.7597259283065796,
0.47383248805999756,
-0.055097274482250214,
0.0871901586651802,
0.02009524218738079,
0.044483769685029984,
0.4961477816104889,
-1.0053824186325073,
-0.0895984023809433,
0.5223087668418884,
-0.22881513833999634,
-0.3390418589115143,
0.23161442577838898,
-0.9033485651016235,
-0.5026241540908813,
-0.43737322092056274,
0.35460662841796875,
-0.29659977555274963,
-0.39644721150398254,
0.4000184237957001,
-0.24363493919372559,
0.0184590145945549,
0.8772331476211548,
-0.3835617005825043,
0.16110073029994965,
0.9118661284446716,
0.6967449188232422,
-0.08380291610956192,
-0.3807208836078644,
-0.6840695738792419,
0.28428974747657776,
-0.4184061586856842,
0.7017610669136047,
-0.5766706466674805,
-0.35945454239845276,
-0.05759948864579201,
0.26234522461891174,
0.019579216837882996,
-0.2679378092288971,
0.593981146812439,
-0.4834701418876648,
0.19208505749702454,
-0.37881824374198914,
-0.1417684108018875,
-0.4861956536769867,
0.4720914661884308,
-0.5428041219711304,
0.9603186845779419,
-0.11572129279375076,
-0.8570155501365662,
0.46188706159591675,
-0.5085390210151672,
-0.39234933257102966,
-0.28322696685791016,
-0.37693044543266296,
-0.3945205509662628,
0.25263699889183044,
0.242999866604805,
0.536825954914093,
-0.7187206149101257,
0.3194217085838318,
-0.6329229474067688,
-0.11630379408597946,
0.056574586778879166,
-0.7417920827865601,
0.7832319736480713,
0.06159243360161781,
-0.48963290452957153,
0.425470232963562,
-0.7447024583816528,
0.20620188117027283,
-0.029716752469539642,
0.019440656527876854,
-0.1319662481546402,
0.04231967777013779,
-0.11233820021152496,
0.4316199719905853,
-0.0007458139443770051,
-0.3231678307056427,
0.3887205123901367,
0.33892956376075745,
0.549734354019165,
0.7324615716934204,
-0.01806844212114811,
0.03245843946933746,
0.07963559776544571,
0.26614078879356384,
0.4496604800224304,
0.5515974164009094,
-0.5650128722190857,
-0.5860540270805359,
-0.9091378450393677,
-0.6676934361457825,
-0.05005726218223572,
0.2574569284915924,
-0.9292566776275635,
0.15662100911140442,
-0.2024967074394226,
-0.4517068564891815,
-0.09588359296321869,
-0.24766682088375092,
0.27562960982322693,
0.6103506088256836,
0.6696538925170898,
-0.173762708902359,
-0.30475208163261414,
-0.756190836429596,
0.06439986824989319,
-0.021943386644124985,
0.06189097836613655,
0.33444055914878845,
0.5777779817581177,
-0.378705233335495,
0.723224401473999,
-0.4436616599559784,
-0.1344023495912552,
0.16634823381900787,
0.0805572122335434,
0.21658068895339966,
0.32191145420074463,
0.1500488668680191,
-0.9230625033378601,
-0.09549229592084885,
0.5668845772743225,
-0.7940064072608948,
0.22932763397693634,
-0.01633855327963829,
-0.43745678663253784,
-0.26924577355384827,
0.6608428955078125,
-0.9282316565513611,
0.6019716858863831,
0.4175654947757721,
-0.48400425910949707,
0.5742830634117126,
-0.2477710247039795,
0.4619801938533783,
-0.9464301466941833,
-0.07924589514732361,
-0.3814229965209961,
-0.5552604794502258,
-0.42854195833206177,
0.15052194893360138,
0.19918544590473175,
-0.131906658411026,
-0.6986204981803894,
0.36297619342803955,
-0.46632659435272217,
-0.06815190613269806,
-0.2130192220211029,
-0.22244571149349213,
0.6025251746177673,
0.6240999102592468,
0.0698341429233551,
0.6451111435890198,
0.899378776550293,
-0.7655584812164307,
0.3442682921886444,
-0.21872660517692566,
-0.14260515570640564,
0.8193057179450989,
-0.49007919430732727,
0.3001558184623718,
-0.26830384135246277,
0.28416335582733154,
-0.6290054321289062,
-0.35079091787338257,
0.1675020307302475,
0.06787630170583725,
-0.1187901422381401,
-0.28723523020744324,
-0.4067407548427582,
-0.4447285830974579,
-0.12958964705467224,
0.6581276059150696,
0.16268156468868256,
-0.7614580988883972,
1.1559637784957886,
0.07258353382349014,
0.46164536476135254,
-0.4550372064113617,
-0.3814762830734253,
0.02777683548629284,
-0.11245698481798172,
-0.43237537145614624,
0.27788102626800537,
-0.04583337530493736,
-0.10469315946102142,
-0.05473662540316582,
-0.30846211314201355,
-0.12371974438428879,
-0.1889919489622116,
0.5261725783348083,
0.0033967189956456423,
-0.24387289583683014,
0.25797298550605774,
0.22036196291446686,
0.07348529994487762,
0.04382104426622391,
-0.7787613868713379,
0.5138547420501709,
-0.29726967215538025,
-0.9281810522079468,
-0.3217763900756836,
0.36737799644470215,
1.3843432664871216,
-0.3557400107383728,
0.5838842391967773,
0.39997994899749756,
-0.3695348799228668,
-0.3688563406467438,
-0.333138644695282,
0.05061190202832222,
-0.4136130213737488,
0.18056251108646393,
-0.8329712748527527,
-0.5375004410743713,
0.3206791877746582,
-0.4657345712184906,
-0.05446842312812805,
0.36499977111816406,
0.536657989025116,
0.03287705034017563,
1.0246566534042358,
0.18177764117717743,
0.6977882981300354,
0.19018393754959106,
-0.44147372245788574,
0.17578519880771637,
-0.8249925971031189,
-0.7792209386825562,
-0.08986978232860565,
0.10527890175580978,
-0.025562074035406113,
-1.314879298210144,
0.33773162961006165,
0.44574567675590515,
-0.4212906062602997,
0.14122529327869415,
-0.5459190607070923,
0.44026508927345276,
0.6089481711387634,
0.3846559524536133,
0.5193708539009094,
-0.1564788669347763,
-0.40417346358299255,
0.252905935049057,
-0.7666333317756653,
-0.30351054668426514,
0.7520892024040222,
0.26795846223831177,
0.6663796305656433,
0.14903001487255096,
0.1788208931684494,
0.3562231659889221,
0.3135678172111511,
-0.9127729535102844,
0.5335900187492371,
0.13211801648139954,
-0.5146409869194031,
-0.21161417663097382,
-0.28391265869140625,
-0.6808345913887024,
0.7908722758293152,
-0.1063772439956665,
-0.36526721715927124,
0.2690225839614868,
0.24706555902957916,
-0.007688969373703003,
0.4262131154537201,
-0.7245892882347107,
1.0186764001846313,
-0.6573653817176819,
-0.7485783100128174,
-0.17096470296382904,
-0.2581561505794525,
0.5729557871818542,
-0.03323549032211304,
0.33871814608573914,
-0.19276465475559235,
-0.021912870928645134,
0.009765827096998692,
-0.8228791952133179,
0.9278164505958557,
-0.17190204560756683,
-0.11063934117555618,
0.6761096119880676,
0.24553239345550537,
0.4419978857040405,
0.30502450466156006,
-0.025979945436120033,
0.36717739701271057,
-0.09764986485242844,
-0.42786774039268494,
-0.8203609585762024,
0.7154772877693176,
-0.42820510268211365,
-0.7209717035293579,
-0.29408374428749084,
-0.31137722730636597,
-0.1593111902475357,
0.6023677587509155,
0.1838241070508957,
0.49185967445373535,
-0.05220688879489899,
0.5172598361968994,
0.5031462907791138,
0.043188780546188354,
0.068424291908741,
-0.08411905914545059,
-0.8172032237052917,
-0.663915753364563,
0.7553434371948242,
-0.09729868173599243,
0.46118953824043274,
0.4462546110153198,
0.30240964889526367,
-0.3679584562778473,
-0.1679345965385437,
-0.6502619385719299,
-0.24014298617839813,
-0.8151654005050659,
-0.21669521927833557,
-0.7801017165184021,
-0.05870989337563515,
0.1042230948805809,
-0.08111797273159027,
-0.6816630363464355,
-0.12469162046909332,
-0.12255582213401794,
-0.18257462978363037,
0.4378807246685028,
0.5937122702598572,
0.44757768511772156,
0.15157784521579742,
-0.23772495985031128,
0.6797841191291809,
0.7341158986091614,
0.2889312207698822,
0.23935623466968536,
-0.2074657678604126,
-0.0011873439652845263,
0.2376268208026886,
-0.2836897671222687,
-0.5586224794387817,
-0.10527162998914719,
-0.1731790155172348,
0.27662405371665955,
0.5366964936256409,
0.034707874059677124,
1.1407392024993896,
-0.6553077697753906,
0.5909414887428284,
0.7072169780731201,
-1.1557713747024536,
0.5707646012306213,
-0.40919172763824463,
0.24805667996406555,
0.23408985137939453,
0.14517845213413239,
-0.33526167273521423,
-0.10367859154939651,
-0.5674325823783875,
-0.8084897398948669,
0.2966550886631012,
0.15410146117210388,
-0.17228272557258606,
-0.16611860692501068,
-0.06197316199541092,
0.4217087924480438,
0.5006530284881592,
-0.6065336465835571,
0.16640961170196533,
-0.8423664569854736,
0.021189453080296516,
0.25674566626548767,
0.00004189720857539214,
-0.2929081618785858,
-0.5222672820091248,
0.1973607987165451,
-0.4939916431903839,
0.07007516175508499,
0.3697207570075989,
-0.11392619460821152,
0.13849389553070068,
0.09594807028770447,
0.6854873299598694,
0.778194010257721,
-0.009011047892272472,
0.8055224418640137,
0.11955522745847702,
-0.15013912320137024,
0.0819646492600441,
-0.43289169669151306,
0.004627860151231289,
-0.19011254608631134,
0.44430485367774963,
0.9932703971862793,
0.3231615126132965,
-0.6575050354003906,
0.7164929509162903,
0.0797991007566452,
-0.10885795205831528,
-0.2598749101161957,
0.11771249026060104,
0.2379830777645111,
0.2935999035835266,
0.1282525658607483,
0.4107554256916046,
-0.051437947899103165,
-0.7399832010269165,
0.23359474539756775,
0.30935725569725037,
-0.5483442544937134,
-0.3550110459327698,
0.9684479832649231,
0.20300079882144928,
-0.21724332869052887,
0.29502928256988525,
-0.00461910804733634,
-0.46468859910964966,
0.5133238434791565,
0.4329608678817749,
0.7494262456893921,
0.08303748071193695,
0.22797495126724243,
0.30121099948883057,
0.2008381336927414,
-0.26284515857696533,
0.2755584120750427,
-0.20496907830238342,
-0.47156664729118347,
-0.31441548466682434,
-0.34029093384742737,
-0.4274638593196869,
0.04060269147157669,
-0.46319133043289185,
0.5477302670478821,
-0.8623480200767517,
-0.34024834632873535,
-0.33161690831184387,
-0.7845190763473511,
-0.9382261037826538,
0.28828129172325134,
-0.025513188913464546,
0.7021172046661377,
-0.6395560503005981,
0.6118435263633728,
0.35471588373184204,
-0.46114638447761536,
-0.4912833869457245,
0.018265657126903534,
-0.04072706401348114,
-0.7865180969238281,
0.6365296840667725,
0.47574034333229065,
-0.7347272634506226,
-0.14678049087524414,
-0.41381415724754333,
-0.562303364276886,
1.1260583400726318,
0.34063389897346497,
-0.4608764052391052,
0.20084203779697418,
0.07848416268825531,
0.32657575607299805,
-0.5805773138999939,
0.5298663377761841,
0.06752515584230423,
0.4778750240802765,
0.3698878586292267,
-0.6122790575027466,
0.009938320145010948,
-0.0480802096426487,
-0.0370187908411026,
0.10243265330791473,
-0.9032579064369202,
1.083606243133545,
-0.2601771652698517,
-0.06533937156200409,
-0.35512956976890564,
0.6455067992210388,
0.4015063941478729,
0.39582884311676025,
0.7180147767066956,
0.5876274704933167,
0.9541171789169312,
0.038881346583366394,
0.9533442854881287,
-0.060530293732881546,
0.2259809970855713,
1.0725653171539307,
-0.2869012951850891,
0.7572150826454163,
0.6514864563941956,
0.11988040804862976,
0.7132770419120789,
0.40749871730804443,
0.36377474665641785,
0.3671894669532776,
0.1048348918557167,
-0.23705285787582397,
-0.7092686891555786,
-0.461167573928833,
-0.3267664313316345,
0.47618499398231506,
0.3446579575538635,
-0.20899012684822083,
-0.07591600716114044,
0.03814098984003067,
-0.005675052758306265,
-0.10952723026275635,
-0.5512219667434692,
0.30461379885673523,
0.11701972037553787,
-0.7280564904212952,
0.665571928024292,
-0.2814916968345642,
0.11777157336473465,
-0.25664910674095154,
-0.32729706168174744,
0.13059984147548676,
0.1065433919429779,
-0.3050866723060608,
-0.7847223281860352,
-0.24923118948936462,
-0.05800045654177666,
-0.3593766689300537,
-0.31105050444602966,
0.5072111487388611,
-0.2899375855922699,
-0.6969148516654968,
0.4370535612106323,
0.479440301656723,
-0.0624515600502491,
-0.4202003479003906,
-0.4245698153972626,
0.28088173270225525,
-0.1412295401096344,
-0.21135185658931732,
-0.1412462443113327,
1.1927281618118286,
-0.5084465146064758,
0.8460633158683777,
0.9814915657043457,
-0.20100818574428558,
0.22961586713790894,
0.46766921877861023,
0.9771235585212708,
-0.9055222272872925,
-0.3362700939178467,
-0.7985373735427856,
0.9790818095207214,
-0.3476547598838806,
-0.22603316605091095,
0.5662187337875366,
0.7163342237472534,
0.615670382976532,
-0.2897333800792694,
0.6692956686019897,
0.16190358996391296,
0.03829619288444519,
-0.7680790424346924,
0.11395033448934555,
-0.7525432705879211,
0.15569084882736206,
-0.05828438326716423,
-0.9873144030570984,
-0.1877874881029129,
0.3372317850589752,
-0.09784423559904099,
-0.004861276596784592,
0.9764017462730408,
0.5108564496040344,
-0.6348142623901367,
-0.13310672342777252,
0.5259807705879211,
0.1648084819316864,
0.6134383082389832,
0.314224511384964,
0.998469352722168,
-0.18928366899490356,
0.34971779584884644,
-0.1482398360967636,
-0.208549365401268,
-0.48896297812461853,
-1.1170244216918945,
-1.049781084060669,
-0.3629034459590912,
-0.1513512283563614,
-0.22464576363563538,
-0.26733243465423584,
0.7139172554016113,
0.8378293514251709,
-0.5620275139808655,
-0.05902182683348656,
-0.5327103137969971,
0.3550105094909668,
-0.40984004735946655,
-0.2070583552122116,
0.29068896174430847,
-0.02923058159649372,
-0.6953951120376587,
0.45975780487060547,
0.8803569674491882,
-0.24602819979190826,
-0.4488830864429474,
0.016781019046902657,
0.020435340702533722,
0.12168542295694351,
1.115301489830017,
0.03172798082232475,
-1.2030820846557617,
-0.5647833347320557,
0.09128879755735397,
-0.001599812530912459,
0.14544765651226044,
0.9939079880714417,
-0.6695941090583801,
0.894149124622345,
0.4252413809299469,
0.48052990436553955,
0.6285354495048523,
0.0971638634800911,
0.448410302400589,
-0.33626624941825867,
0.454151451587677,
0.19505693018436432,
0.4891045391559601,
0.14088822901248932,
-0.262475848197937,
0.2925695776939392,
0.32455044984817505,
-0.14911535382270813,
-0.8118967413902283,
0.5688873529434204,
-1.247079849243164,
-0.4608716368675232,
1.0543253421783447,
0.1958446502685547,
-0.5389257073402405,
-0.15333454310894012,
-0.5777448415756226,
0.07161219418048859,
-0.14163030683994293,
0.4582579731941223,
0.5703759789466858,
-0.16687029600143433,
-0.37972110509872437,
-0.572711169719696,
0.1618359386920929,
0.16197462379932404,
-1.0790263414382935,
0.31857436895370483,
0.44950348138809204,
-0.005544118583202362,
0.20223894715309143,
0.4782106876373291,
-0.0545419380068779,
0.17674461007118225,
0.2189365029335022,
0.19147919118404388,
-0.39996829628944397,
-0.953915536403656,
0.46229106187820435,
0.460931658744812,
0.0172077938914299,
-0.20914901793003082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16908v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16908v1
|
Can Large Language Models Faithfully Express Their Intrinsic Uncertainty in Words?
| 2024-05-27T07:56:23 | 2024-05-27T07:56:23 |
Gal Yona, Roee Aharoni, Mor Geva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We posit that large language models (LLMs) should be capable of expressing
their intrinsic uncertainty in natural language. For example, if the LLM is
equally likely to output two contradicting answers to the same question, then
its generated response should reflect this uncertainty by hedging its answer
(e.g., "I'm not sure, but I think..."). We formalize faithful response
uncertainty based on the gap between the model's intrinsic confidence in the
assertions it makes and the decisiveness by which they are conveyed. This
example-level metric reliably indicates whether the model reflects its
uncertainty, as it penalizes both excessive and insufficient hedging. We
evaluate a variety of aligned LLMs at faithfully communicating uncertainty on
several knowledge-intensive question answering tasks. Our results provide
strong evidence that modern LLMs are poor at faithfully conveying their
uncertainty, and that better alignment is necessary to improve their
trustworthiness.
|
[
-0.012785677798092365,
-0.9885503053665161,
0.984956681728363,
0.17221292853355408,
-0.15627184510231018,
0.21038728952407837,
-0.2030206024646759,
-0.7031590938568115,
-0.0959501713514328,
0.09681051969528198,
-0.5301880836486816,
-0.13503123819828033,
-0.9246367812156677,
-0.03462494909763336,
-0.47480085492134094,
0.49665889143943787,
-0.36173486709594727,
0.26137468218803406,
-0.17569606006145477,
-0.10034453123807907,
-0.3429277539253235,
-0.43673965334892273,
-0.5133544206619263,
-0.4590691030025482,
0.49149060249328613,
0.1580590158700943,
1.0230753421783447,
0.6620457768440247,
0.7287477254867554,
0.2883150279521942,
-0.06374180316925049,
-0.10063770413398743,
-0.35686352849006653,
0.35373443365097046,
-0.398751825094223,
-0.7685282230377197,
-0.3645835816860199,
0.007356081157922745,
0.7855936884880066,
0.7278279066085815,
-0.27218902111053467,
0.21360695362091064,
0.10778912901878357,
0.40639549493789673,
-0.4731552302837372,
0.049943964928388596,
-0.9843974709510803,
-0.22141149640083313,
-0.12921005487442017,
0.09819091111421585,
-0.3051910996437073,
-0.3386133015155792,
0.354949027299881,
-0.6330966353416443,
-0.34264615178108215,
0.341057151556015,
1.1861640214920044,
0.3586921989917755,
-0.19518911838531494,
-0.2988685071468353,
-0.8721463084220886,
0.7042732834815979,
-1.0463495254516602,
0.24277415871620178,
0.5180860757827759,
0.18705923855304718,
-0.1159023866057396,
-0.45499154925346375,
-0.5948579907417297,
-0.1088910922408104,
0.08687002956867218,
0.047902192920446396,
-0.13439196348190308,
0.07609035074710846,
0.09407135844230652,
0.524134635925293,
-0.40142667293548584,
0.1927764117717743,
-0.012008230201900005,
-0.38741469383239746,
0.5943702459335327,
0.23133639991283417,
0.009632758796215057,
0.20007434487342834,
-0.40170785784721375,
-0.04435311630368233,
-0.6744198203086853,
0.058856915682554245,
0.5672377347946167,
0.1739407479763031,
-0.010302667506039143,
0.8736470341682434,
-0.02711580879986286,
0.5288943648338318,
0.18514861166477203,
-0.05159350112080574,
-0.20307713747024536,
-0.2237958163022995,
-0.19509612023830414,
-0.11056539416313171,
0.835920512676239,
0.34240156412124634,
0.33365029096603394,
-0.12722355127334595,
-0.4706781804561615,
0.32417938113212585,
0.39974474906921387,
-0.4462273120880127,
0.20801205933094025,
0.40732598304748535,
-0.038781922310590744,
0.02478569932281971,
0.11426448076963425,
-0.39238613843917847,
-0.3426693379878998,
-0.12828969955444336,
0.6460762619972229,
-0.41931813955307007,
-0.10825235396623611,
0.33854490518569946,
0.022789161652326584,
0.2878989279270172,
0.35877591371536255,
-0.5703115463256836,
0.4119134247303009,
0.7863873243331909,
0.46638572216033936,
0.06563859432935715,
-0.20699629187583923,
-0.3785291314125061,
0.4112386107444763,
-0.7348906993865967,
0.546920657157898,
-0.6233755946159363,
-0.1371435970067978,
0.17738421261310577,
-0.15713712573051453,
0.01554393582046032,
-0.24627685546875,
0.7123736143112183,
-0.5521476864814758,
0.12513288855552673,
-0.44003018736839294,
-0.912487268447876,
0.07083536684513092,
0.4404326379299164,
-0.32773688435554504,
0.7959906458854675,
-0.04500477388501167,
-0.7959357500076294,
0.11658850312232971,
0.14198759198188782,
-0.06442014873027802,
-0.09814602136611938,
-0.22278471291065216,
-0.3760184645652771,
0.3818221092224121,
0.03325006738305092,
0.3741508424282074,
-0.2978341579437256,
0.3218649625778198,
-0.6012936234474182,
-0.23591862618923187,
0.9946455955505371,
-0.592395544052124,
0.23014143109321594,
0.053425006568431854,
-0.3293713629245758,
-0.08353734761476517,
-0.1817464828491211,
0.296207070350647,
-0.0886467918753624,
-0.2211073786020279,
-0.3699212670326233,
0.13729391992092133,
-0.3678814172744751,
0.1395913064479828,
0.596612274646759,
-0.5970166921615601,
0.2693156599998474,
-0.4214470088481903,
0.3823506236076355,
0.9382161498069763,
-0.0771956816315651,
0.4272018074989319,
-0.5960646867752075,
0.40311291813850403,
-0.010614822618663311,
-0.013406205922365189,
0.20014169812202454,
-0.5344909429550171,
-0.7052422165870667,
0.10894468426704407,
0.23715591430664062,
0.40642526745796204,
-0.3976233899593353,
0.3888797163963318,
-0.40820249915122986,
-0.35762789845466614,
-0.6212857961654663,
0.0686265230178833,
0.470654159784317,
0.5359972715377808,
0.06025242805480957,
-0.06811674684286118,
-0.28134238719940186,
-1.1316887140274048,
-0.45301663875579834,
-0.6383066773414612,
0.11911415308713913,
0.27657440304756165,
0.3872601389884949,
-0.03855787590146065,
0.8417955636978149,
-0.41171902418136597,
0.09473112970590591,
0.024492597207427025,
0.46718695759773254,
-0.048089649528265,
0.24956220388412476,
0.1902095526456833,
-0.5937408804893494,
-0.34857311844825745,
-0.10973671078681946,
-0.5513831973075867,
-0.021012237295508385,
-0.18652363121509552,
-0.25385257601737976,
0.29580530524253845,
0.31063777208328247,
-0.7466527223587036,
0.17285297811031342,
0.7153231501579285,
-0.24481262266635895,
0.4354155659675598,
-0.12761422991752625,
0.0664716362953186,
-1.1087746620178223,
-0.06993778795003891,
-0.11651627719402313,
-0.4227754473686218,
-0.33318305015563965,
0.21905376017093658,
0.15065406262874603,
0.5579475164413452,
-0.22006815671920776,
0.648420512676239,
-0.38562968373298645,
0.08382531255483627,
-0.2584246098995209,
0.1834249198436737,
-0.055881138890981674,
0.11276544630527496,
0.11054017394781113,
0.771113395690918,
0.6894058585166931,
-0.4121151268482208,
0.1577179878950119,
0.14923419058322906,
-0.2979259788990021,
0.724381148815155,
-0.7380843758583069,
0.03685425966978073,
-0.284050852060318,
0.24488802254199982,
-1.0036773681640625,
-0.542367696762085,
0.1807546466588974,
-0.6274948120117188,
0.49625176191329956,
0.05413246527314186,
-0.38436904549598694,
-0.4258357584476471,
-0.1986188143491745,
0.09230698645114899,
0.4744601249694824,
0.19433949887752533,
0.4632447361946106,
0.16971172392368317,
-0.31275710463523865,
-0.7402443885803223,
-0.9254258871078491,
0.08118933439254761,
-0.19301360845565796,
-0.5937805771827698,
0.06508207321166992,
-0.21300764381885529,
-0.5466127991676331,
0.2033209502696991,
-0.42693114280700684,
-0.3456096649169922,
0.23996806144714355,
0.3196987509727478,
0.2877812683582306,
-0.18002164363861084,
0.32985830307006836,
-0.21835532784461975,
0.10514935106039047,
0.21695688366889954,
-0.4312073588371277,
0.4800756871700287,
-0.3792877197265625,
-0.7096500992774963,
-0.42319491505622864,
0.32429003715515137,
0.657419741153717,
-0.07995544373989105,
0.8275812864303589,
0.5451297163963318,
-0.6935975551605225,
0.03398394212126732,
-0.6664748787879944,
-0.20734189450740814,
-0.4502967894077301,
0.08580164611339569,
-0.2433975487947464,
-1.1770612001419067,
0.7094330787658691,
0.333057701587677,
0.09796342253684998,
0.7699492573738098,
0.498311847448349,
-0.3946220576763153,
1.0468695163726807,
0.5398106575012207,
-0.1663118600845337,
-0.06365397572517395,
0.1717120110988617,
0.2217089980840683,
-0.7702717781066895,
-0.04038368910551071,
-0.7125126123428345,
-0.2855403423309326,
-0.4948369860649109,
-0.32792922854423523,
0.2136286497116089,
0.31607112288475037,
-0.2993623614311218,
0.00833112746477127,
-0.1991778314113617,
0.09999585896730423,
0.3794310688972473,
-0.09641421586275101,
0.1459471732378006,
-0.3196102976799011,
-0.04227450489997864,
-0.2689517140388489,
-0.4272487163543701,
-0.8668273091316223,
0.7806243896484375,
0.7012357711791992,
1.3784524202346802,
0.3053748309612274,
0.40087589621543884,
-0.14080187678337097,
0.3247968852519989,
-0.7530548572540283,
0.20380568504333496,
0.22678153216838837,
-0.8516066074371338,
-0.5198512077331543,
-0.5059972405433655,
-0.66604083776474,
-0.28221890330314636,
-0.38147464394569397,
-0.8401464819908142,
-0.029508640989661217,
0.2408600151538849,
-0.6061834096908569,
0.35515451431274414,
-0.32371804118156433,
0.48641347885131836,
-0.25987640023231506,
-0.4508759081363678,
0.006265153642743826,
-0.8054556250572205,
0.4325530230998993,
-0.25200867652893066,
0.02163897082209587,
-0.22248432040214539,
-0.29968175292015076,
0.5037680864334106,
-0.2779340445995331,
0.9491551518440247,
0.22274209558963776,
-0.4632833003997803,
0.6062865853309631,
0.32596391439437866,
0.8786441683769226,
0.2891094386577606,
-0.17964741587638855,
-0.048594798892736435,
0.03665350005030632,
-0.31998056173324585,
-0.5614004135131836,
0.5506007671356201,
-0.7164792418479919,
-0.8287650346755981,
-0.42854055762290955,
-0.7282850742340088,
-0.5375136733055115,
0.10479483753442764,
0.43674206733703613,
0.23027639091014862,
-0.08987248688936234,
0.19622734189033508,
0.9697514176368713,
-0.009569180198013783,
0.20721590518951416,
0.4107374846935272,
-0.10846201330423355,
-0.20608554780483246,
0.5009244680404663,
0.16771113872528076,
0.6620844006538391,
0.5274707078933716,
0.40428078174591064,
-0.5511237382888794,
-0.5858727097511292,
-0.39810872077941895,
0.20178787410259247,
-0.5312821269035339,
-0.299217164516449,
-0.45814642310142517,
-0.24968968331813812,
-0.4231753945350647,
-0.22141659259796143,
-0.455493688583374,
-0.3420923054218292,
-0.17664554715156555,
-0.26507842540740967,
0.36930036544799805,
0.9219818115234375,
0.1587008684873581,
0.44754618406295776,
-0.9078012108802795,
0.1719827950000763,
0.5163581967353821,
0.5895995497703552,
-0.2783898711204529,
-0.7131165266036987,
0.0383753627538681,
0.5574467778205872,
-0.026465628296136856,
-0.9207035303115845,
0.08515400439500809,
0.1854664832353592,
0.5786780118942261,
0.5236208438873291,
0.22999045252799988,
0.7159584164619446,
-0.43855053186416626,
0.905316174030304,
0.06322569400072098,
-1.0597084760665894,
0.12634985148906708,
-0.47034215927124023,
0.3120327293872833,
0.5551587343215942,
0.487035870552063,
-0.5645158886909485,
-0.9021570682525635,
-0.674415647983551,
-0.6106359362602234,
0.32746386528015137,
0.033189818263053894,
0.42696696519851685,
-0.10696305334568024,
0.4853949546813965,
0.025570910423994064,
0.46045559644699097,
-0.7967346906661987,
-0.14366258680820465,
0.04425600916147232,
-0.44860443472862244,
0.07609981298446655,
-0.4970357418060303,
-0.4906695783138275,
0.1785416454076767,
0.6185532212257385,
-0.19320577383041382,
0.4451906681060791,
0.3614649772644043,
0.010545306839048862,
-0.5537012219429016,
0.444718599319458,
0.6573920845985413,
0.7576774954795837,
-0.10357323288917542,
0.5155730247497559,
0.11764546483755112,
-0.2162337601184845,
0.15052476525306702,
-0.19629813730716705,
-0.08204267919063568,
-0.210703507065773,
0.5102296471595764,
0.5535527467727661,
-0.04992244020104408,
-0.6655609607696533,
0.7215750813484192,
-0.0760650709271431,
-0.20793788135051727,
-0.26727432012557983,
-0.17149794101715088,
0.4766333997249603,
0.2114104926586151,
0.3119298219680786,
-0.015462888404726982,
-0.18686933815479279,
-0.6165916919708252,
0.028979098424315453,
0.8484548926353455,
-0.6751566529273987,
-0.2965260446071625,
0.6490038633346558,
-0.18620502948760986,
-0.06974845379590988,
0.5218130946159363,
-0.15226468443870544,
-0.7127575874328613,
0.3230518102645874,
0.5299146175384521,
0.8050433993339539,
-0.22200670838356018,
0.028820998966693878,
0.203877791762352,
0.681667685508728,
-0.29999250173568726,
0.5241554975509644,
0.3987010419368744,
-0.7858768105506897,
-0.6063745021820068,
-0.6776065230369568,
-0.5008610486984253,
-0.055103953927755356,
-0.685565173625946,
-0.3054346740245819,
-0.48138606548309326,
-0.35256674885749817,
-0.3915863633155823,
-0.16799771785736084,
-0.409040629863739,
0.2242300659418106,
0.23446987569332123,
0.9173551797866821,
-0.7854836583137512,
0.5457291603088379,
0.7049609422683716,
-0.18058395385742188,
-1.1231549978256226,
0.17002715170383453,
-0.15843433141708374,
-0.7811155319213867,
0.37769582867622375,
-0.11442296206951141,
-0.2557515799999237,
-0.4303315579891205,
-0.9355418086051941,
-1.155846118927002,
0.8098540306091309,
0.427803099155426,
-0.5812183022499084,
0.012141299434006214,
0.4439205527305603,
0.6805931925773621,
-0.20765572786331177,
0.009109433740377426,
-0.004339889623224735,
0.7567180395126343,
0.20332181453704834,
-0.9562951326370239,
-0.027272719889879227,
0.0795019268989563,
-0.10055264830589294,
0.18808063864707947,
-0.6481688618659973,
1.0035181045532227,
-0.12047978490591049,
-0.4103389382362366,
0.373928964138031,
0.7979986071586609,
0.0009349235915578902,
0.05530161410570145,
0.21714307367801666,
0.6358200907707214,
0.9836753010749817,
-0.4428831934928894,
1.104354739189148,
-0.42317020893096924,
0.12679743766784668,
1.1345117092132568,
-0.4310888350009918,
1.068844199180603,
0.5852795243263245,
-0.11253070086240768,
0.30232569575309753,
0.6544553637504578,
0.4402448534965515,
0.053833846002817154,
0.30768486857414246,
-0.1782582849264145,
-0.7188754081726074,
-0.24292431771755219,
-0.22484366595745087,
0.16916923224925995,
0.60667484998703,
-0.1673341989517212,
0.14317715167999268,
-0.518342912197113,
0.06401477009057999,
0.20504483580589294,
-0.30539169907569885,
0.6087329983711243,
0.35854125022888184,
-0.7788609862327576,
0.3830084204673767,
0.08194153010845184,
0.6188607811927795,
-0.8002689480781555,
0.24369731545448303,
-0.04165932908654213,
0.029354028403759003,
-0.03558347746729851,
-1.2683762311935425,
0.40254315733909607,
-0.2912672162055969,
-0.07082261145114899,
-0.14251385629177094,
0.5076178312301636,
-0.518667995929718,
-0.5029265284538269,
-0.06275530159473419,
0.5905176401138306,
-0.1590557098388672,
0.0070206038653850555,
-0.5495444536209106,
0.06564702838659286,
-0.2874249219894409,
-0.23842115700244904,
0.006329395808279514,
0.5706835985183716,
-0.20098108053207397,
0.9710608720779419,
0.4007878303527832,
0.27824482321739197,
0.39838075637817383,
-0.3071730136871338,
0.523851752281189,
-0.24641969799995422,
-0.1539408266544342,
-0.7670271396636963,
0.37593263387680054,
-0.0570998415350914,
-0.3384025990962982,
0.8006057739257812,
0.2812774181365967,
0.5837101936340332,
0.1941079944372177,
0.7673050761222839,
0.18044176697731018,
0.3978610932826996,
-0.5218331813812256,
0.4364294707775116,
-0.39589419960975647,
0.11571382731199265,
-0.22590799629688263,
-0.8549817800521851,
-0.09921267628669739,
0.5796661376953125,
-0.2726830542087555,
-0.06192398816347122,
0.7087002992630005,
0.601742684841156,
0.10123151540756226,
-0.18057702481746674,
0.34421655535697937,
0.46559372544288635,
-0.043023452162742615,
0.5772577524185181,
1.1657072305679321,
-0.34839317202568054,
0.42350611090660095,
-0.06023078039288521,
0.14606915414333344,
0.11969640851020813,
-0.9149354100227356,
-0.35996586084365845,
-0.46534377336502075,
-0.32601118087768555,
-0.3535397946834564,
0.0540190115571022,
0.6968491673469543,
0.4786039888858795,
-0.4643254578113556,
-0.2090449035167694,
-0.05911748483777046,
0.15904182195663452,
-0.06930132955312729,
-0.1505390703678131,
0.13224373757839203,
-0.2263854742050171,
-0.747399628162384,
0.05969702824950218,
0.24845537543296814,
0.4255851209163666,
-0.45258474349975586,
-0.14793935418128967,
-0.16320092976093292,
0.6427963376045227,
0.13846296072006226,
0.02165708877146244,
-0.8001970052719116,
-0.8437346816062927,
0.29299190640449524,
-0.6557110548019409,
-0.1670801043510437,
0.4281906187534332,
-0.2608362138271332,
0.1885683834552765,
0.45902007818222046,
0.763988733291626,
0.006447502877563238,
0.19792583584785461,
0.7968510389328003,
-0.7377628087997437,
-0.27022913098335266,
0.429008424282074,
0.5151912569999695,
0.395691454410553,
-0.3843946158885956,
0.13400748372077942,
-0.09121054410934448,
-0.6119597554206848,
-0.5660967826843262,
0.4638174772262573,
-0.9325259923934937,
-0.2888162136077881,
1.3750056028366089,
-0.22073490917682648,
-0.3115119934082031,
-0.038401294499635696,
0.0285946037620306,
0.06533414125442505,
-0.27835920453071594,
0.5948888063430786,
1.2814257144927979,
0.1775892674922943,
0.03141838312149048,
-0.4169365465641022,
0.27035024762153625,
0.4908246099948883,
-0.6002912521362305,
0.3288296163082123,
0.5064812898635864,
0.2682001292705536,
0.22871443629264832,
0.3727506101131439,
0.0172383151948452,
-0.026541370898485184,
-0.03592711687088013,
-0.11329015344381332,
0.38697686791419983,
-0.13104470074176788,
-0.2816590964794159,
0.02551584504544735,
0.6985067129135132,
0.13871124386787415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16884v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16884v2
|
Match, Compare, or Select? An Investigation of Large Language Models for Entity Matching
| 2024-05-27T07:05:27 | 2024-06-23T13:42:02 |
Tianshu Wang, Xiaoyang Chen, Hongyu Lin, Xuanang Chen, Xianpei Han, Hao Wang, Zhenyu Zeng, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Entity matching (EM) is a critical step in entity resolution (ER). Recently,
entity matching based on large language models (LLMs) has shown great promise.
However, current LLM-based entity matching approaches typically follow a binary
matching paradigm that ignores the global consistency between record
relationships. In this paper, we investigate various methodologies for
LLM-based entity matching that incorporate record interactions from different
perspectives. Specifically, we comprehensively compare three representative
strategies: matching, comparing, and selecting, and analyze their respective
advantages and challenges in diverse scenarios. Based on our findings, we
further design a compound entity matching framework (ComEM) that leverages the
composition of multiple strategies and LLMs. ComEM benefits from the advantages
of different sides and achieves improvements in both effectiveness and
efficiency. Experimental results on 8 ER datasets and 9 LLMs verify the
superiority of incorporating record interactions through the selecting
strategy, as well as the further cost-effectiveness brought by ComEM.
|
[
-0.39274853467941284,
-0.5722212195396423,
0.7549867033958435,
0.33424314856529236,
-0.13300688564777374,
0.2908550202846527,
-0.5455220937728882,
-0.8976280689239502,
0.19324548542499542,
0.7614827752113342,
-0.2191232442855835,
-0.4952632188796997,
-0.0905400887131691,
0.41541069746017456,
-0.2273547202348709,
0.7793392539024353,
-0.42195022106170654,
0.1909433752298355,
-0.19096919894218445,
-0.25106552243232727,
-0.5687679052352905,
-0.5919108390808105,
-0.9470481872558594,
-0.46394482254981995,
0.5573247671127319,
0.19064919650554657,
0.569807767868042,
0.8228818774223328,
0.9787144064903259,
0.32903239130973816,
0.009450617246329784,
0.3612481653690338,
-0.4072011411190033,
0.454267293214798,
-0.35495254397392273,
-0.5450415015220642,
-0.3026599884033203,
-0.09799451380968094,
0.588183581829071,
0.779198944568634,
-0.26183250546455383,
-0.11106114089488983,
-0.35982993245124817,
0.5455728769302368,
-0.7067734003067017,
-0.053602855652570724,
-0.8852326273918152,
0.16271106898784637,
-0.30048802495002747,
-0.12093135714530945,
-0.6148041486740112,
-0.2323441207408905,
0.2710142135620117,
-0.5099532008171082,
0.3029804229736328,
0.56509929895401,
0.8365222215652466,
-0.07650451362133026,
-0.4990919530391693,
-0.5736432671546936,
-1.0881503820419312,
0.7297948002815247,
-0.6713567972183228,
0.7094653248786926,
-0.1389988362789154,
0.26317888498306274,
-0.20382855832576752,
-0.4276312291622162,
-0.5711623430252075,
-0.24242058396339417,
-0.24704527854919434,
0.02670406363904476,
0.07404215633869171,
0.23537284135818481,
0.3636587858200073,
0.7219914793968201,
-0.5114238262176514,
0.40367642045021057,
-0.003023920115083456,
-0.08717532455921173,
0.4314773976802826,
-0.012917760759592056,
0.5179346203804016,
0.1853986531496048,
-0.8324979543685913,
-0.18597181141376495,
-1.1145282983779907,
-0.4348398745059967,
0.3434843122959137,
0.6153886914253235,
0.10302995145320892,
0.6761083006858826,
0.011366339400410652,
0.9440717101097107,
0.13737283647060394,
-0.3416767418384552,
-0.03799978271126747,
-0.416006863117218,
-0.4237992465496063,
0.22677387297153473,
0.7387270331382751,
0.5982144474983215,
0.08215043693780899,
-0.5571669340133667,
-0.5428880453109741,
0.04820705205202103,
-0.11413080990314484,
-0.5377655625343323,
0.06243668869137764,
0.06524907797574997,
-0.5304912328720093,
0.14183270931243896,
-0.11663640290498734,
-0.7749831676483154,
-0.24274234473705292,
-0.7947033047676086,
0.5211829543113708,
-0.274349570274353,
-0.24168960750102997,
-0.056110892444849014,
0.0011934484355151653,
0.5152644515037537,
0.3609604835510254,
-0.8991681933403015,
0.6430162787437439,
0.9783972501754761,
0.8927163481712341,
-0.5513411164283752,
0.04419498145580292,
-0.7244769334793091,
0.3391726016998291,
-0.5960374474525452,
0.9471166729927063,
-0.5983803868293762,
-0.43140462040901184,
0.1692814975976944,
-0.3020956814289093,
-0.08879248052835464,
-1.1454721689224243,
0.6035218834877014,
-0.8015616536140442,
0.12835276126861572,
-0.45757612586021423,
-0.6327103972434998,
-0.10710454732179642,
0.20257185399532318,
-1.034456729888916,
0.8350903987884521,
-0.01388963870704174,
-0.4682042896747589,
0.7513121366500854,
-0.30798205733299255,
-0.31029701232910156,
0.09112047404050827,
-0.49506303668022156,
-0.2717019319534302,
-0.09718434512615204,
-0.08728209882974625,
0.3373437523841858,
-0.4867609441280365,
0.12105651944875717,
-0.4665558338165283,
-0.2428303211927414,
0.21210187673568726,
0.0009693285683169961,
0.3175576627254486,
0.28990408778190613,
-0.06755785644054413,
0.06998658925294876,
-0.6998112797737122,
-0.19873076677322388,
-0.033881597220897675,
-0.6025379300117493,
-0.5705255270004272,
0.13237853348255157,
-0.060890693217515945,
0.1894470602273941,
0.020695911720395088,
-0.3815588057041168,
0.027640005573630333,
-0.26493582129478455,
0.34489935636520386,
0.4968146085739136,
0.022658510133624077,
0.5946993231773376,
-0.6313828825950623,
0.2651420533657074,
0.2560974657535553,
-0.4513067305088043,
-0.01684827171266079,
0.09962046146392822,
-0.7153509855270386,
-0.541867733001709,
0.5887832045555115,
0.5367377996444702,
-0.5568593740463257,
0.197834774851799,
-0.40107426047325134,
-0.27561497688293457,
-0.5034217834472656,
0.13894902169704437,
0.4493040144443512,
0.406887024641037,
0.4822254478931427,
-0.3556356430053711,
-0.6567721962928772,
-0.9154216051101685,
-0.371074378490448,
-0.2890298068523407,
-0.06768222898244858,
0.6099660396575928,
0.16745266318321228,
0.3825324475765228,
0.7957849502563477,
-0.09083205461502075,
-0.4467828869819641,
0.01327295321971178,
-0.4870354235172272,
0.24195590615272522,
0.3283877670764923,
0.768658459186554,
-0.841752290725708,
-0.650897204875946,
0.3396018445491791,
-0.7347081899642944,
0.11231231689453125,
-0.21980173885822296,
-0.31851479411125183,
0.4043877422809601,
0.40227973461151123,
-0.6263116598129272,
-0.08691900223493576,
0.34928128123283386,
-0.025345230475068092,
0.03991348668932915,
-0.14898060262203217,
0.6040220260620117,
-0.9002874493598938,
-0.2867189049720764,
0.35560551285743713,
-0.41528722643852234,
-0.6866273283958435,
0.3666122555732727,
-0.015567810274660587,
-0.04531964659690857,
-0.6168645620346069,
0.432209312915802,
-0.9063963294029236,
-0.3807917833328247,
0.08949752897024155,
0.6231176853179932,
-0.10588781535625458,
0.1398283988237381,
0.2100820541381836,
0.9228402972221375,
0.4880702793598175,
-0.6560717821121216,
0.6001770496368408,
0.2402847707271576,
-0.16709843277931213,
1.0471789836883545,
-0.5516661405563354,
0.42821308970451355,
-0.029330821707844734,
0.19039294123649597,
-0.6874582171440125,
-0.13942134380340576,
0.23664571344852448,
-0.0467950776219368,
0.8879216313362122,
-0.20418652892112732,
-0.5852751731872559,
-0.048114653676748276,
-0.40595561265945435,
0.23031766712665558,
0.2127058357000351,
-0.8332597017288208,
1.1317025423049927,
0.20365986227989197,
-0.23874951899051666,
-0.5543850064277649,
-0.679938793182373,
0.3200399577617645,
-0.7131835222244263,
-0.5768550038337708,
0.8386147618293762,
-0.09196145832538605,
-0.6612249612808228,
0.08827727288007736,
-0.37580516934394836,
0.028294967487454414,
-0.08201050758361816,
-0.2003614604473114,
0.4379124045372009,
-0.4741934835910797,
-0.08798721432685852,
-0.14271153509616852,
0.10960447043180466,
-0.23341237008571625,
-0.1380259245634079,
0.31317150592803955,
0.20283496379852295,
-0.3264298439025879,
0.06342119723558426,
0.6987274885177612,
0.2861635088920593,
-0.27482831478118896,
0.7902095913887024,
-0.2565280795097351,
-0.4996245205402374,
-0.13663944602012634,
-0.9637699127197266,
0.025091949850320816,
-0.42717623710632324,
0.17392008006572723,
-0.7651710510253906,
-0.7795767784118652,
0.6222203373908997,
-0.04853824898600578,
0.34405598044395447,
0.03316734358668327,
0.6420817971229553,
0.14554032683372498,
0.43957778811454773,
0.25486692786216736,
-0.22353605926036835,
0.29457858204841614,
0.2872415781021118,
0.4636530578136444,
-0.9336405992507935,
-0.2851213216781616,
-0.9568461775779724,
-0.16955626010894775,
-0.760865330696106,
-0.2837481200695038,
-0.06252290308475494,
0.24836646020412445,
-0.165693998336792,
0.6692805290222168,
-0.3189666271209717,
0.4254642128944397,
0.367969810962677,
0.02138402685523033,
0.803264856338501,
-0.130635067820549,
0.056835610419511795,
-0.1780247837305069,
-0.416456013917923,
-0.6348713636398315,
1.0300449132919312,
0.12139514088630676,
0.7323731780052185,
0.7293712496757507,
0.7788125872612,
-0.13654428720474243,
0.5769529938697815,
-0.6814725399017334,
0.7923275232315063,
-0.20949435234069824,
-0.5641326308250427,
-0.07152858376502991,
-0.6424108743667603,
-1.0166467428207397,
0.5120408535003662,
-0.5984346866607666,
-0.6761540770530701,
0.16267913579940796,
0.01899525709450245,
-0.17435480654239655,
0.39410364627838135,
-0.7608453631401062,
0.417591392993927,
-0.26635828614234924,
-0.14611390233039856,
0.1693570911884308,
-0.29078197479248047,
0.23298199474811554,
-0.33624306321144104,
0.08065629750490189,
-0.07612874358892441,
-0.28520989418029785,
0.517300009727478,
-0.03456668555736542,
0.015228033065795898,
0.3438367545604706,
-0.4317975342273712,
0.03399323672056198,
0.2216198444366455,
0.46224793791770935,
-0.038001760840415955,
-0.23908673226833344,
0.005109773483127356,
-0.03231219947338104,
-0.02807832695543766,
-0.5943868160247803,
1.183707594871521,
-0.5118196606636047,
-0.7520111203193665,
-0.32444310188293457,
-0.3060435950756073,
-0.1674986481666565,
0.3330863118171692,
-0.07746231555938721,
0.22275196015834808,
-0.27346211671829224,
0.14837293326854706,
0.7908979654312134,
0.0014854836044833064,
0.5664386749267578,
0.8382882475852966,
-0.4144728481769562,
-0.2858388125896454,
0.7269876599311829,
0.10576372593641281,
0.4394668638706207,
0.6926734447479248,
-0.49581003189086914,
-0.452955037355423,
-0.4568832516670227,
-0.29115644097328186,
0.434772253036499,
-0.6399682760238647,
-0.40647462010383606,
-0.4922923743724823,
0.05879516899585724,
-0.2736242115497589,
0.23300151526927948,
-0.1448799967765808,
0.2775316834449768,
-0.1687997728586197,
-0.06613829731941223,
0.15399205684661865,
0.29977455735206604,
0.05284144729375839,
-0.21384821832180023,
-0.6181163191795349,
0.41289329528808594,
0.22655251622200012,
0.5304970145225525,
-0.1807870864868164,
-0.02925761230289936,
0.29030540585517883,
-0.306585431098938,
-0.17142926156520844,
-1.1304314136505127,
-0.18294402956962585,
0.24546198546886444,
0.6939857006072998,
0.1691591441631317,
0.02555348537862301,
0.6142919063568115,
-0.7441372871398926,
0.3732106685638428,
0.16561144590377808,
-0.7673365473747253,
0.27429747581481934,
-0.12948095798492432,
-0.6462175250053406,
0.49912819266319275,
0.49255385994911194,
-0.5262340307235718,
-0.25458839535713196,
-0.28176793456077576,
-0.8677703738212585,
0.5139437913894653,
0.3321612477302551,
-0.08394254744052887,
-0.2575826346874237,
0.503851056098938,
-0.15535858273506165,
0.27396199107170105,
-0.6501492261886597,
-0.3580706715583801,
0.7288603782653809,
-0.3405144512653351,
0.08146847039461136,
0.15308386087417603,
-0.20300963521003723,
0.4854663014411926,
0.528531551361084,
0.17613765597343445,
0.19601911306381226,
0.24499721825122833,
-0.1640608012676239,
-0.23352235555648804,
0.25437384843826294,
0.220554918050766,
0.7310864925384521,
-0.018066847696900368,
0.0691741332411766,
0.16266708076000214,
0.05146363377571106,
0.23449985682964325,
0.26348876953125,
-0.31041646003723145,
0.23866812884807587,
0.5020974278450012,
0.8087700605392456,
0.29165178537368774,
-0.6246973872184753,
0.15853454172611237,
-0.014128233306109905,
-0.20470204949378967,
-0.175166517496109,
0.31424838304519653,
0.21328450739383698,
0.3969467282295227,
0.16478806734085083,
-0.35362744331359863,
0.10421706736087799,
-0.8215075135231018,
-0.016552386805415154,
0.6914299130439758,
-0.014637798070907593,
0.12563134729862213,
0.6391258239746094,
0.1075325757265091,
-0.7865128517150879,
0.4914814829826355,
0.1024446114897728,
-0.2988555431365967,
0.4890609383583069,
0.5145744681358337,
0.26596421003341675,
-0.2265426069498062,
-0.14313571155071259,
0.05791005864739418,
0.0556875504553318,
-0.316691130399704,
0.09985077381134033,
0.1337708681821823,
-0.9493288397789001,
-0.8333327770233154,
-0.22398915886878967,
-0.5485586524009705,
0.2774750590324402,
-0.7941575646400452,
0.3977988064289093,
-0.17044079303741455,
-0.14201226830482483,
0.2858230173587799,
0.2783624231815338,
-0.8652397394180298,
-0.02009516954421997,
-0.005561648868024349,
0.8941331505775452,
-0.6230304837226868,
0.2612905204296112,
0.8925933241844177,
-0.5781976580619812,
-0.8759103417396545,
0.04596000537276268,
-0.04510878026485443,
-0.3374575674533844,
0.46073874831199646,
-0.008093520067632198,
0.19241318106651306,
0.05694763734936714,
-0.10838830471038818,
-0.612282395362854,
0.9780936241149902,
0.5141675472259521,
-0.9122950434684753,
-0.10231935977935791,
-0.13118420541286469,
0.4814164340496063,
-0.49051105976104736,
0.2897976338863373,
0.9722378849983215,
0.25614097714424133,
-0.013918437063694,
-0.9784746170043945,
0.15928438305854797,
0.4306167960166931,
0.30066773295402527,
0.6437466144561768,
-0.7375481128692627,
0.5214740633964539,
0.031095610931515694,
-0.5231664776802063,
0.22192086279392242,
0.8736734986305237,
0.5878374576568604,
0.27117806673049927,
0.7248865365982056,
0.6578386425971985,
0.6365579962730408,
-0.1374436765909195,
0.6179983615875244,
-0.3043849766254425,
0.5608165860176086,
1.2454750537872314,
-1.0889514684677124,
0.9297028183937073,
0.5760762095451355,
-0.7192967534065247,
0.2121020257472992,
0.7806243896484375,
-0.022305570542812347,
0.3638418912887573,
0.4069432020187378,
-0.5471593141555786,
-0.31085702776908875,
-0.13742974400520325,
-0.38732805848121643,
0.008875122293829918,
0.04000229388475418,
-0.12703710794448853,
-0.4067559838294983,
-0.2477845996618271,
-0.09531152248382568,
0.42137065529823303,
-0.13762933015823364,
0.9596470594406128,
0.13480806350708008,
-0.7365052700042725,
-0.11879359930753708,
0.022976670414209366,
0.5443816184997559,
-0.103001169860363,
-0.32695472240448,
-0.3815200924873352,
0.04195260629057884,
-0.034718457609415054,
-0.6931572556495667,
0.04353863745927811,
-0.17519186437129974,
-0.3112141489982605,
-0.010617290623486042,
0.7022473216056824,
-0.7791166305541992,
-0.04986566677689552,
0.7711279392242432,
0.4873958230018616,
0.028386013582348824,
0.22703208029270172,
-0.5160789489746094,
0.21255230903625488,
-0.36207523941993713,
0.004912562668323517,
0.520966112613678,
0.673829197883606,
-0.09257124364376068,
0.615367591381073,
0.7525489330291748,
0.37404197454452515,
-0.22488537430763245,
0.064927838742733,
0.6589879989624023,
-0.4693853557109833,
-0.09079015254974365,
-0.8306429982185364,
-0.0757158175110817,
-0.1304687112569809,
0.01661927066743374,
0.4297425448894501,
0.8264381289482117,
1.13758385181427,
0.14341212809085846,
0.43598002195358276,
0.09156103432178497,
0.8414398431777954,
-0.8069944977760315,
-0.0714755654335022,
-0.3037719130516052,
0.6102414727210999,
-0.24031095206737518,
-1.4881620407104492,
-0.239485502243042,
0.596156895160675,
-0.03213893994688988,
0.3087410032749176,
0.6497316360473633,
0.8363722562789917,
-0.18659788370132446,
-0.31577861309051514,
0.19150859117507935,
0.09457129240036011,
0.4259136915206909,
0.732253909111023,
0.6601464748382568,
-0.2663927972316742,
0.4451829195022583,
0.10859479010105133,
-0.12731614708900452,
-0.13876311480998993,
-0.975040853023529,
-0.813830554485321,
-0.3209891617298126,
-0.4744236171245575,
-0.5724497437477112,
0.15125423669815063,
1.2839741706848145,
0.43261194229125977,
-0.6505759954452515,
-0.0915055125951767,
0.2253580540418625,
0.2614879012107849,
0.0017936767544597387,
-0.1817958801984787,
0.16881169378757477,
-0.18219664692878723,
-0.9583966135978699,
0.4456782937049866,
0.4404553174972534,
0.1278042048215866,
-0.11424998939037323,
0.07177623361349106,
-0.17686770856380463,
0.07129284739494324,
0.3564894199371338,
0.28909292817115784,
-0.7420244812965393,
-0.37350383400917053,
0.15236879885196686,
-0.1630861461162567,
0.25979819893836975,
1.072970986366272,
-0.4509230852127075,
0.24774186313152313,
0.33762553334236145,
0.8919547200202942,
0.4067399799823761,
0.07304315268993378,
0.6046104431152344,
-0.42759907245635986,
-0.06711839884519577,
0.09493375569581985,
0.3722671866416931,
0.5654234290122986,
-0.39627164602279663,
0.7413971424102783,
-0.029709067195653915,
-0.5332325100898743,
-0.8435433506965637,
0.3191837966442108,
-1.074029564857483,
0.04253501817584038,
1.109612226486206,
-0.3836738169193268,
0.07962681353092194,
-0.0684220939874649,
-0.08957449346780777,
0.2185923308134079,
-0.2034623920917511,
0.2893311679363251,
0.9521715044975281,
0.0010495773749426007,
-0.08344558626413345,
-0.4977744221687317,
0.2318308800458908,
0.1910925805568695,
-0.7484403848648071,
-0.37248075008392334,
0.4664612412452698,
0.2620767056941986,
0.1200401782989502,
0.5612069368362427,
-0.10501539707183838,
-0.10716483741998672,
-0.5499817728996277,
-0.18755477666854858,
0.41806018352508545,
-0.28514614701271057,
-0.1358397752046585,
-0.13309887051582336,
0.23086415231227875,
-0.0205791387706995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16869v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16869v1
|
Mixture of Modality Knowledge Experts for Robust Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-05-27T06:36:17 | 2024-05-27T06:36:17 |
Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Yajing Xu, Binbin Hu, Ziqi Liu, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Multi-modal knowledge graph completion (MMKGC) aims to automatically discover
new knowledge triples in the given multi-modal knowledge graphs (MMKGs), which
is achieved by collaborative modeling the structural information concealed in
massive triples and the multi-modal features of the entities. Existing methods
tend to focus on crafting elegant entity-wise multi-modal fusion strategies,
yet they overlook the utilization of multi-perspective features concealed
within the modalities under diverse relational contexts. To address this issue,
we introduce a novel MMKGC framework with Mixture of Modality Knowledge experts
(MoMoK for short) to learn adaptive multi-modal embedding under intricate
relational contexts. We design relation-guided modality knowledge experts to
acquire relation-aware modality embeddings and integrate the predictions from
multi-modalities to achieve comprehensive decisions. Additionally, we
disentangle the experts by minimizing their mutual information. Experiments on
four public MMKG benchmarks demonstrate the outstanding performance of MoMoK
under complex scenarios.
|
[
-0.5866791605949402,
-0.7690421342849731,
0.5528373122215271,
-0.18695203959941864,
-0.3280578553676605,
0.6399133205413818,
-0.13601233065128326,
-0.44000044465065,
0.24858762323856354,
0.11442595720291138,
-0.5132973790168762,
-0.5448930263519287,
-0.24785886704921722,
0.025098398327827454,
0.5599861741065979,
0.5471575260162354,
0.05726014822721481,
0.04411432147026062,
-0.24496054649353027,
-0.28007006645202637,
-0.5960700511932373,
-0.03521554917097092,
-0.18906284868717194,
-0.3802177906036377,
0.4467566907405853,
0.3812987506389618,
0.6936410069465637,
0.39142149686813354,
-0.17903326451778412,
0.27832961082458496,
0.027504345402121544,
0.9243414402008057,
-0.3741239607334137,
0.2147241085767746,
0.05998823419213295,
-0.13479025661945343,
-0.7417147159576416,
-0.04771099239587784,
0.30824610590934753,
0.8614507913589478,
-0.15657272934913635,
-0.15458944439888,
0.04222556948661804,
0.4856407940387726,
-0.7107965350151062,
0.5341140031814575,
-0.6550766229629517,
0.09715314209461212,
0.11874712258577347,
-0.23740768432617188,
-0.5010000467300415,
0.07549673318862915,
0.20886820554733276,
-0.9442723393440247,
-0.2047315239906311,
0.3659360110759735,
0.20809829235076904,
0.32776927947998047,
-1.0866360664367676,
-0.005083405878394842,
-0.4518376588821411,
0.6536064743995667,
-0.44088947772979736,
0.7750555276870728,
0.44372686743736267,
0.4421829283237457,
-0.33293211460113525,
-0.1699804663658142,
-0.3035919964313507,
-0.13579891622066498,
-0.279937744140625,
0.32695406675338745,
0.22387781739234924,
0.25757861137390137,
-0.06527803838253021,
0.2764642834663391,
-0.38182583451271057,
-0.2736454904079437,
0.02325516566634178,
-0.45698606967926025,
0.28391680121421814,
0.16021299362182617,
-0.0875902995467186,
-0.6796941757202148,
-0.6422252655029297,
0.27722927927970886,
-0.4123426675796509,
0.028624381870031357,
0.2301349639892578,
0.1989331841468811,
-0.12881265580654144,
0.3058735430240631,
-0.37121379375457764,
1.0006542205810547,
0.4287532866001129,
-0.7496057748794556,
0.3753589987754822,
-0.652273952960968,
-0.16107453405857086,
-0.15686313807964325,
0.7466796040534973,
0.28233015537261963,
-0.30824190378189087,
-0.471116840839386,
0.0197504423558712,
-0.448547899723053,
0.031045563519001007,
-0.25413137674331665,
-0.44507884979248047,
-0.019069530069828033,
-0.4062515199184418,
-0.3899868130683899,
-0.11232232302427292,
-0.6136960983276367,
-0.583369255065918,
-0.4228731691837311,
0.4377952516078949,
-0.5940194129943848,
-0.7123977541923523,
-0.18790359795093536,
-0.12940530478954315,
-0.22803448140621185,
0.4850192964076996,
-0.5296861529350281,
-0.19847391545772552,
0.45008769631385803,
0.5672512650489807,
0.28515681624412537,
-0.34903207421302795,
-0.29181939363479614,
0.8298748135566711,
-0.028526905924081802,
0.6102625131607056,
-0.5801513195037842,
-0.31706690788269043,
-0.42673176527023315,
-0.2520807683467865,
-0.33809080719947815,
-0.2358718067407608,
0.2878415286540985,
-0.6898651719093323,
0.18576259911060333,
-0.5400316715240479,
-0.42865654826164246,
-0.5042865872383118,
0.5927518010139465,
-0.7196101546287537,
0.7763311862945557,
0.3928610682487488,
-0.8737764358520508,
0.8342656493186951,
-0.4014723300933838,
-0.367557168006897,
-0.040718115866184235,
-0.434110164642334,
-0.147480770945549,
-0.0280760508030653,
0.2923009693622589,
0.6726307272911072,
-0.0936371311545372,
0.1744391769170761,
-0.5808013081550598,
0.07599178701639175,
0.1581086814403534,
-0.09902314841747284,
0.521506130695343,
0.2352006435394287,
0.0016496378229930997,
0.26764464378356934,
-0.9731493592262268,
-0.1471381038427353,
-0.3451886773109436,
-0.5594437122344971,
-0.5549362897872925,
-0.04990360513329506,
-0.06914769858121872,
0.4820483922958374,
0.13024351000785828,
-0.23348183929920197,
0.2694481909275055,
-0.003669430036097765,
0.40053823590278625,
0.8758068680763245,
0.20690590143203735,
0.6042959094047546,
-0.4400152266025543,
0.39864441752433777,
0.3462795615196228,
0.21059206128120422,
-0.08140477538108826,
-0.6366892457008362,
-0.3028990626335144,
-0.6173477172851562,
0.21206456422805786,
0.1288892775774002,
-1.306552529335022,
0.5754989385604858,
-0.2525348663330078,
-0.356648713350296,
-0.25093910098075867,
0.3811090290546417,
0.21947860717773438,
0.8437694311141968,
0.2722872495651245,
-0.1800181120634079,
-0.2985726296901703,
-0.8200647234916687,
-0.15822650492191315,
-0.1636020988225937,
-0.07911305874586105,
0.6867163777351379,
0.25040775537490845,
-0.28507593274116516,
0.8983532190322876,
-0.3510238230228424,
-0.3302338123321533,
-0.03688790649175644,
0.19792355597019196,
-0.16937677562236786,
0.34182658791542053,
0.569912314414978,
-1.0146002769470215,
-0.4983595907688141,
0.2176830768585205,
-0.7801397442817688,
0.3748054504394531,
-0.13306446373462677,
-0.15886171162128448,
-0.11011305451393127,
0.2702277898788452,
-0.5617345571517944,
-0.18366296589374542,
0.3734080493450165,
-0.4556102156639099,
0.48245885968208313,
0.0562700517475605,
0.4747232496738434,
-1.5020146369934082,
-0.06193571165204048,
-0.17607785761356354,
-0.619350254535675,
-0.37607628107070923,
0.09689594060182571,
0.1842193454504013,
0.031618524342775345,
-0.062234003096818924,
0.2070854902267456,
-0.6673270463943481,
0.2292458564043045,
0.17489351332187653,
0.03766874969005585,
-0.0356704518198967,
0.7754270434379578,
-0.3907514214515686,
0.297218918800354,
0.49780696630477905,
-0.5089100003242493,
0.2774958610534668,
0.27242302894592285,
-0.09297824651002884,
0.8058264851570129,
0.00580237852409482,
0.1025761216878891,
0.10612248629331589,
0.26323747634887695,
-0.9930567741394043,
-0.6280704140663147,
0.41841575503349304,
-0.40873774886131287,
0.48263025283813477,
-0.6409010887145996,
-0.42850565910339355,
-0.16322924196720123,
-0.2926988899707794,
0.5601680874824524,
0.10490473359823227,
-0.1960441768169403,
1.2800195217132568,
0.4467773139476776,
0.27807196974754333,
-0.713370144367218,
-0.5184599757194519,
-0.08204204589128494,
-0.011342728510499,
-0.8382114768028259,
0.2646499276161194,
-0.14344747364521027,
0.12720489501953125,
0.1476764678955078,
-0.35900354385375977,
-0.18445277214050293,
0.13349252939224243,
0.3338564932346344,
0.0034508570097386837,
-0.14723291993141174,
0.2639729678630829,
0.2901853024959564,
-0.15218250453472137,
-0.17797628045082092,
-0.19025693833827972,
0.3338748514652252,
-0.08852129429578781,
-0.6300559639930725,
-0.09375523775815964,
0.4092106819152832,
0.920116126537323,
-0.2045648992061615,
0.7533046007156372,
0.908916175365448,
-0.4334593117237091,
0.0672042965888977,
-0.7873290181159973,
-0.1610763520002365,
-0.5023863315582275,
0.2815665304660797,
-0.5657433271408081,
-0.9944238662719727,
0.6619159579277039,
-0.22922617197036743,
-0.1119714304804802,
0.03148203343153,
0.4747147858142853,
0.1914023905992508,
1.0922538042068481,
0.6121810078620911,
-0.04302443563938141,
0.40339395403862,
-0.2319294810295105,
0.3321678042411804,
-0.7884316444396973,
-0.5706844925880432,
0.1650848090648651,
-0.31129229068756104,
-0.2968803644180298,
-0.4845474362373352,
0.7399284243583679,
0.3176089823246002,
-0.0449671596288681,
0.05151310935616493,
-0.3451923429965973,
0.424198180437088,
0.374022513628006,
0.6691666841506958,
0.6769643425941467,
-0.07746110111474991,
-0.43229448795318604,
0.017682421952486038,
-0.8883638381958008,
0.10348021984100342,
1.0562084913253784,
0.04559939727187157,
0.7439083456993103,
0.19663958251476288,
0.5300630927085876,
0.17383141815662384,
0.058764372020959854,
-0.9788858890533447,
0.3244090676307678,
0.4180280566215515,
-0.44687792658805847,
0.10426535457372665,
-0.7054029107093811,
-0.45307138562202454,
0.34227249026298523,
-0.5747208595275879,
-0.3024090826511383,
0.33466169238090515,
0.2311171442270279,
-0.5195246338844299,
0.3631027936935425,
-0.6687899231910706,
0.7454140782356262,
0.13505710661411285,
-0.23371635377407074,
-0.4819696843624115,
-0.8014228343963623,
0.6426833271980286,
-0.08978549391031265,
0.4864138662815094,
-0.08632322400808334,
-0.15203702449798584,
0.4778655767440796,
-0.14337322115898132,
0.7078108787536621,
-0.2649901509284973,
0.31433308124542236,
0.10807112604379654,
0.3443198800086975,
0.29121133685112,
0.25875124335289,
0.1425158977508545,
-0.24577336013317108,
-0.2810901999473572,
-0.4438744783401489,
-0.4607361853122711,
0.7252538800239563,
-0.8372814059257507,
-0.2814090847969055,
0.07022818922996521,
-0.8440672755241394,
-0.7306883335113525,
0.3991190791130066,
-0.06770551204681396,
0.6014732718467712,
0.0679563358426094,
0.3658912777900696,
0.5529290437698364,
0.2349052131175995,
0.28184738755226135,
0.34777823090553284,
0.17587924003601074,
-0.8618971705436707,
0.7568635940551758,
0.0732942596077919,
0.292296826839447,
0.2802199125289917,
0.27986711263656616,
-0.14049607515335083,
-0.4024049937725067,
-0.6092017889022827,
0.07211384922266006,
-0.709322988986969,
-0.4468700587749481,
-0.8522029519081116,
0.2161165028810501,
-0.25616654753685,
-0.2547627091407776,
-0.3168703615665436,
-0.3752989172935486,
-0.17007772624492645,
-0.12099214643239975,
0.3958069980144501,
0.5682678818702698,
-0.04115196317434311,
0.13079430162906647,
-0.7919648289680481,
0.2840026617050171,
0.7843720316886902,
0.31781449913978577,
0.258457213640213,
0.04975700378417969,
-0.430194228887558,
0.12382649630308151,
-0.42748087644577026,
-0.987332284450531,
-0.10517804324626923,
0.15004844963550568,
0.7702978849411011,
0.6515190005302429,
0.18112246692180634,
0.6565787196159363,
-0.03816135600209236,
0.5539942383766174,
0.4221387207508087,
-0.7096187472343445,
0.19466394186019897,
-0.9143694043159485,
0.03289654105901718,
0.5944908857345581,
0.4350161552429199,
-0.3347964882850647,
-0.27531665563583374,
-0.45438966155052185,
-0.7087293267250061,
0.48251664638519287,
-0.0710170716047287,
-0.350627601146698,
0.28968319296836853,
0.2227817326784134,
0.3282387852668762,
0.6523892879486084,
-0.6087743639945984,
-0.200031116604805,
-0.3674764931201935,
-0.3586752414703369,
0.3863953948020935,
-0.11815953254699707,
-0.58073890209198,
-0.39191746711730957,
0.3424270749092102,
-0.49756330251693726,
0.16879290342330933,
-0.001117769512347877,
-0.4030238687992096,
-0.35585615038871765,
0.19636259973049164,
0.491058886051178,
1.05503249168396,
-0.2378365695476532,
0.2271617203950882,
0.018675949424505234,
-0.187993586063385,
0.1472475677728653,
0.16126303374767303,
0.08059021830558777,
-0.3284182548522949,
0.3252880275249481,
0.4021701216697693,
0.6494799852371216,
-0.26148727536201477,
0.4958375096321106,
0.1167946308851242,
-0.1245175451040268,
0.01683760993182659,
-0.017704378813505173,
0.2220420390367508,
0.4229774475097656,
0.4589376151561737,
0.7355738878250122,
0.04374983161687851,
-0.46885985136032104,
0.2826577425003052,
0.27941054105758667,
-0.33848437666893005,
-0.4562179446220398,
0.6397178173065186,
0.3124188482761383,
0.16200315952301025,
0.15987153351306915,
-0.2546289265155792,
-0.6466100215911865,
0.13639163970947266,
0.021324411034584045,
0.6117411255836487,
-0.2868788242340088,
0.1466442048549652,
0.12258811295032501,
0.10577137768268585,
0.20315763354301453,
0.16198256611824036,
-0.35851970314979553,
-0.8040730357170105,
-0.48870694637298584,
-0.2820676267147064,
-0.2244599312543869,
-0.12690608203411102,
-0.387342631816864,
0.1750577986240387,
-0.45829421281814575,
-0.1439238339662552,
-0.14096862077713013,
-0.07888592779636383,
-0.750623345375061,
-0.31958523392677307,
-0.1499779224395752,
0.5325635671615601,
-0.9636457562446594,
0.6441569924354553,
0.8403705954551697,
-0.49567171931266785,
-0.9651896357536316,
-0.199813574552536,
0.1957278996706009,
-0.560089111328125,
0.10014548897743225,
-0.06796403229236603,
-0.1670418232679367,
-0.08053698390722275,
-0.13869324326515198,
-0.5838126540184021,
1.398664951324463,
0.35860198736190796,
0.04256649315357208,
-0.13959616422653198,
-0.13368214666843414,
0.11249144375324249,
-0.36765056848526,
0.24251718819141388,
0.13354480266571045,
0.6932174563407898,
0.1807623952627182,
-0.9204788208007812,
0.17955321073532104,
-0.08091329783201218,
-0.40272489190101624,
0.11630930751562119,
-0.8622972369194031,
0.910200834274292,
0.11167995631694794,
0.24743801355361938,
-0.46074753999710083,
0.5465735197067261,
0.2269655168056488,
0.3875870406627655,
0.823509693145752,
0.5629677176475525,
0.7503474354743958,
0.20867082476615906,
0.5694587826728821,
-0.4552463889122009,
0.30974942445755005,
0.9421942830085754,
0.21224962174892426,
0.3421168029308319,
0.2641832232475281,
0.0230519101023674,
0.5516802072525024,
0.8111425042152405,
0.2446843832731247,
0.705084502696991,
-0.7118675708770752,
-0.334697961807251,
-0.7562780380249023,
-0.10618188232183456,
-0.5459232926368713,
0.43833884596824646,
0.3814927041530609,
-0.19644050300121307,
-0.34472358226776123,
-0.011713649146258831,
-0.07656308263540268,
-0.26918652653694153,
-0.16292555630207062,
0.8399720788002014,
-0.10394517332315445,
-0.297908753156662,
0.47601819038391113,
-0.14247150719165802,
0.5948710441589355,
-0.5025746822357178,
-0.000686930725350976,
0.03642385080456734,
-0.08342935144901276,
-0.4018895626068115,
-0.3097616732120514,
-0.06352200359106064,
-0.917097270488739,
-0.40042728185653687,
-0.0344763919711113,
0.8626372814178467,
-0.746487557888031,
-0.2248392403125763,
0.21859069168567657,
1.0625966787338257,
-0.6137079000473022,
-0.21692349016666412,
-0.5786651372909546,
-0.41787123680114746,
-0.06474661082029343,
-0.1153714582324028,
0.27973654866218567,
0.5422073602676392,
0.258777916431427,
0.6440701484680176,
0.4601551294326782,
-0.2725876569747925,
0.17123129963874817,
-0.1334727257490158,
1.2181419134140015,
-0.28521767258644104,
-0.6236445307731628,
-0.6048208475112915,
0.5449178814888,
-0.13283564150333405,
-0.04188473895192146,
0.9054655432701111,
0.5413324236869812,
0.7543671131134033,
-0.13218021392822266,
0.5809033513069153,
-0.13365502655506134,
0.18196725845336914,
-0.44260355830192566,
0.8926598429679871,
-0.7319588661193848,
0.028778240084648132,
-0.44092804193496704,
-0.7001108527183533,
-0.07300516217947006,
0.4148200750350952,
-0.0284823440015316,
0.18386605381965637,
0.5253350138664246,
0.7392264604568481,
-0.5653060674667358,
-0.0024384097196161747,
0.4065052270889282,
0.22698622941970825,
0.384149432182312,
0.6201414465904236,
0.8358203768730164,
-0.12603740394115448,
0.5876151919364929,
-0.4714983105659485,
-0.3280595541000366,
-0.393500953912735,
-0.7322314977645874,
-0.9576631188392639,
-0.6736982464790344,
-0.23087620735168457,
-0.039973244071006775,
-0.48633742332458496,
1.2410995960235596,
1.0623170137405396,
-0.43961721658706665,
0.23014682531356812,
0.17097437381744385,
0.5556464791297913,
-0.2657025158405304,
-0.21868938207626343,
0.3759000599384308,
0.09095565974712372,
-0.1769949495792389,
0.6161220669746399,
0.3910894989967346,
-0.1692430078983307,
-0.4467189908027649,
-0.0693303570151329,
-0.22074498236179352,
-0.4397047162055969,
0.57724529504776,
-0.1749739795923233,
-0.7429597973823547,
-0.4694904088973999,
-0.08276424556970596,
0.14599424600601196,
0.18663114309310913,
1.0741071701049805,
-0.7894629240036011,
0.8401196599006653,
0.6807509064674377,
0.5345138907432556,
0.12065423280000687,
-0.04156234487891197,
0.5448929667472839,
-0.9740184545516968,
0.16306890547275543,
0.2858814001083374,
0.5252482891082764,
0.2469712644815445,
-0.3468833863735199,
0.37779417634010315,
0.7040241360664368,
-0.33212709426879883,
-0.5321316123008728,
0.3919300138950348,
-1.3608423471450806,
-0.2554111182689667,
0.8530515432357788,
-0.07597730308771133,
-0.09344179183244705,
-0.662431001663208,
-0.11020214110612869,
0.33917003870010376,
-0.602370023727417,
0.759950578212738,
0.5988906025886536,
-0.15958204865455627,
-0.22811968624591827,
-0.28867703676223755,
0.45313742756843567,
0.02229343168437481,
-0.38541364669799805,
-0.12889382243156433,
0.728058397769928,
0.3612922728061676,
0.30148571729660034,
0.458558052778244,
0.11692013591527939,
0.24765177071094513,
0.05310438945889473,
-0.30429089069366455,
-0.8627951145172119,
-0.3733334541320801,
0.2622254192829132,
0.4438602924346924,
0.19152389466762543,
0.17090867459774017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16856v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16856v1
|
Can We Trust LLMs? Mitigate Overconfidence Bias in LLMs through Knowledge Transfer
| 2024-05-27T06:06:36 | 2024-05-27T06:06:36 |
Haoyan Yang, Yixuan Wang, Xingyin Xu, Hanyuan Zhang, Yirong Bian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The study explores mitigating overconfidence bias in LLMs to improve their
reliability. We introduce a knowledge transfer (KT) method utilizing chain of
thoughts, where "big" LLMs impart knowledge to "small" LLMs via detailed,
sequential reasoning paths. This method uses advanced reasoning of larger
models to fine-tune smaller models, enabling them to produce more accurate
predictions with calibrated confidence. Experimental evaluation using
multiple-choice questions and sentiment analysis across diverse datasets
demonstrated the KT method's superiority over the vanilla and question-answer
pair (QA) fine-tuning methods. The most significant improvement in three key
metrics, where the KT method outperformed the vanilla and QA methods by an
average of 55.3% and 43.1%, respectively. These findings underscore the KT
method's potential in enhancing model trustworthiness and accuracy, offering
precise outputs with well-matched confidence levels across various contexts.
|
[
-0.3892447352409363,
-0.6114872097969055,
1.062731385231018,
-0.046720169484615326,
-0.36265790462493896,
0.4324635863304138,
0.03483796492218971,
-0.7188234329223633,
-0.0970052033662796,
0.33448830246925354,
-0.6556299924850464,
-0.18321014940738678,
-0.7263409495353699,
-0.15891890227794647,
-0.16904082894325256,
0.8262935280799866,
-0.2268538624048233,
0.3470400273799896,
-0.5711631178855896,
0.23287543654441833,
-0.404842734336853,
-0.46887946128845215,
-0.7094050049781799,
-0.7038772106170654,
0.46297481656074524,
0.4345158040523529,
0.7016557455062866,
0.24467585980892181,
0.749856173992157,
0.11527688056230545,
-0.16070379316806793,
0.3423009216785431,
-0.5571840405464172,
0.11573842912912369,
-0.5928425788879395,
-0.7751811742782593,
-0.4380667209625244,
0.1885896623134613,
0.26005610823631287,
0.4622860252857208,
-0.2216593474149704,
0.4067833721637726,
0.2012859284877777,
0.995171070098877,
-0.733735978603363,
0.05273863673210144,
-0.8941929936408997,
-0.13708075881004333,
0.17428536713123322,
-0.254037469625473,
-0.38310152292251587,
-0.9767876267433167,
0.4873447120189667,
-0.6425502300262451,
-0.40604931116104126,
0.202020525932312,
0.44258126616477966,
0.37282511591911316,
-0.6784104704856873,
-0.4331677258014679,
-0.8169876933097839,
0.7011592388153076,
-0.44837138056755066,
0.34890732169151306,
0.4995844066143036,
0.4712407886981964,
-0.10710319876670837,
-0.7434722185134888,
-0.3659135401248932,
-0.29873785376548767,
0.06618927419185638,
0.22877468168735504,
0.1463388055562973,
-0.06791223585605621,
0.3244483172893524,
0.18787290155887604,
-0.09274816513061523,
-0.14520218968391418,
-0.3507448434829712,
-0.2435499131679535,
0.7309824824333191,
-0.03978850692510605,
-0.10106896609067917,
0.13243858516216278,
-0.7320046424865723,
-0.12187357246875763,
-0.761130690574646,
0.16063636541366577,
0.11814918369054794,
-0.10629373788833618,
0.30671754479408264,
0.3871666193008423,
-0.180180162191391,
0.1450629085302353,
0.19858543574810028,
-0.28422415256500244,
-0.13622701168060303,
-0.41619622707366943,
-0.36069780588150024,
0.15860962867736816,
0.4531972110271454,
0.7941374182701111,
0.624289870262146,
-0.2907398045063019,
0.06152011826634407,
0.4335750937461853,
0.3580267131328583,
-0.6353432536125183,
-0.15500956773757935,
0.03995319828391075,
-0.4006378948688507,
-0.4911643862724304,
0.1205410361289978,
-0.6600082516670227,
-0.6046013832092285,
-0.2077392041683197,
0.8338087797164917,
-0.3782673478126526,
-0.24726475775241852,
0.21151898801326752,
-0.2212516814470291,
0.3028128147125244,
0.4874270558357239,
-0.4745926260948181,
0.48531678318977356,
0.4081118404865265,
0.6796943545341492,
-0.48358699679374695,
-0.06218373030424118,
-0.018897639587521553,
0.3465650975704193,
-0.5368041396141052,
0.6716781854629517,
-0.09919898211956024,
-0.5427966713905334,
-0.11238271743059158,
-0.2713516652584076,
-0.08874963968992233,
-0.3409123718738556,
0.5076017379760742,
-0.526958167552948,
-0.03732634708285332,
-0.8300815224647522,
-0.8585674166679382,
-0.1156700849533081,
0.5878706574440002,
-0.3164750933647156,
0.9282151460647583,
0.025138109922409058,
-0.8129302263259888,
0.32131922245025635,
-0.44570833444595337,
-0.2666437029838562,
-0.542336642742157,
-0.014133326709270477,
-0.16994978487491608,
-0.06111403927206993,
0.4022753834724426,
0.4370214641094208,
-0.41046059131622314,
0.03949034586548805,
-0.671739935874939,
-0.29006484150886536,
0.8598199486732483,
-0.49560806155204773,
0.537234902381897,
0.24795116484165192,
-0.2321295291185379,
-0.2682829201221466,
-0.6118541955947876,
0.38465210795402527,
-0.19291891157627106,
0.031014399603009224,
-0.512787401676178,
-0.4361279010772705,
-0.49689874053001404,
0.3834518492221832,
0.2702631950378418,
-0.5919363498687744,
0.31061455607414246,
-0.0925280749797821,
0.5039534568786621,
0.9746193885803223,
0.36413443088531494,
0.7017496228218079,
-0.8529930114746094,
0.4733894467353821,
0.23043854534626007,
0.3366788923740387,
0.28439050912857056,
-0.4397229850292206,
-0.8579626083374023,
0.18917006254196167,
0.12106751650571823,
0.6458806395530701,
-0.9082019329071045,
0.05316654592752457,
-0.16492301225662231,
-0.6142566800117493,
-0.515064537525177,
0.07575077563524246,
0.4850097894668579,
0.6977438926696777,
0.3333912789821625,
-0.5557013750076294,
-0.41832610964775085,
-0.866004467010498,
-0.3014202117919922,
-0.4058946669101715,
0.027113663032650948,
0.18504004180431366,
0.5862741470336914,
0.09776043146848679,
0.7103482484817505,
-0.5179824233055115,
-0.12162096798419952,
0.16029219329357147,
0.024901043623685837,
-0.11342020332813263,
0.582489550113678,
0.245650053024292,
-0.47098109126091003,
-0.6329102516174316,
-0.0025995990727096796,
-0.6361939311027527,
0.4372335374355316,
-0.07415687292814255,
-0.4676019251346588,
0.009075000882148743,
0.6075668931007385,
-0.824038565158844,
0.3693438470363617,
0.2989580035209656,
-0.3875490128993988,
0.6067354083061218,
0.03803841024637222,
0.4106403589248657,
-1.3198002576828003,
-0.14102524518966675,
-0.259781152009964,
-0.44468075037002563,
-0.20242871344089508,
-0.1354503631591797,
0.13753396272659302,
0.6287935972213745,
-0.3593050539493561,
0.2452303171157837,
-0.2512034773826599,
-0.08278615027666092,
-0.11359389871358871,
0.01659448631107807,
0.04561435431241989,
0.20782792568206787,
-0.3238678574562073,
0.7793435454368591,
0.6556681394577026,
-0.5578980445861816,
0.3849949538707733,
0.20998211205005646,
-0.45221418142318726,
1.2778531312942505,
-0.4459138810634613,
0.5304796099662781,
0.08816719800233841,
0.4138442873954773,
-1.1853309869766235,
0.02026602067053318,
0.2790737748146057,
-0.5838322043418884,
0.12708696722984314,
0.012572525069117546,
-0.3076821267604828,
-0.2531554102897644,
-0.45095300674438477,
0.17655819654464722,
0.7713448405265808,
-0.3175673186779022,
0.5193359851837158,
-0.14799495041370392,
-0.07634104788303375,
-0.6169980764389038,
-0.9635233283042908,
-0.24742600321769714,
-0.2074313461780548,
-0.673886775970459,
0.18741700053215027,
-0.3162217140197754,
-0.3616333603858948,
0.15104345977306366,
-0.51938396692276,
-0.2534378468990326,
0.10412043333053589,
0.25192826986312866,
0.379130482673645,
-0.07093499600887299,
0.1600363701581955,
0.015148792415857315,
-0.005741136148571968,
0.3454039394855499,
-0.5454691052436829,
0.04584947228431702,
-0.06221545487642288,
-0.5333746671676636,
-0.5345633625984192,
0.013887890614569187,
0.8153432011604309,
0.24814890325069427,
0.7440071105957031,
0.5465591549873352,
-0.2458043247461319,
-0.2819206118583679,
-0.8281475901603699,
-0.5309284925460815,
-0.43326932191848755,
0.047305669635534286,
-0.320722758769989,
-1.075531005859375,
0.5454795956611633,
-0.4170258939266205,
-0.12083455175161362,
0.17227451503276825,
0.4671310484409332,
-0.4158269762992859,
0.7935775518417358,
0.8575830459594727,
-0.4122997522354126,
0.06058567389845848,
-0.07246437668800354,
0.03911339491605759,
-0.846549928188324,
-0.282101035118103,
-0.24590755999088287,
-0.4487016499042511,
-0.5570508241653442,
-0.4549387991428375,
0.2754640281200409,
0.25067147612571716,
-0.370906263589859,
0.02119852788746357,
-0.28213557600975037,
0.5312057733535767,
0.7942674160003662,
0.642321765422821,
0.6645690202713013,
-0.2765437066555023,
-0.194407120347023,
0.00501333037391305,
-0.39350810647010803,
-0.3194923400878906,
1.4195665121078491,
0.4527803361415863,
0.9795870780944824,
0.04227478802204132,
0.5517712235450745,
0.36290332674980164,
0.3827784061431885,
-0.7756010293960571,
0.35007795691490173,
0.3232835531234741,
-0.7239205241203308,
-0.3737407326698303,
-0.3840041756629944,
-0.3021426200866699,
-0.021739386022090912,
-0.2383960783481598,
-0.8591347336769104,
0.12263495475053787,
0.1826915442943573,
-0.5593339800834656,
0.521043062210083,
-0.581632673740387,
0.18832284212112427,
-0.04288531094789505,
-0.37904947996139526,
-0.27888619899749756,
-0.7526529431343079,
0.6011407375335693,
-0.15481051802635193,
0.04350043088197708,
0.03783014044165611,
0.028132205829024315,
0.7324080467224121,
-0.17240920662879944,
0.8602897524833679,
0.16901226341724396,
-0.17648845911026,
0.35964760184288025,
0.24225428700447083,
0.9464814066886902,
0.11800915002822876,
-0.12555013597011566,
0.06320366263389587,
0.201484814286232,
-0.23449073731899261,
-1.0144215822219849,
0.5499446988105774,
-0.875874400138855,
-0.5955712199211121,
-0.3126709759235382,
-0.7897240519523621,
-0.714322566986084,
0.08416110277175903,
0.2463865727186203,
-0.19494010508060455,
0.006408485118299723,
0.3012169599533081,
0.9411264657974243,
0.3244546055793762,
0.1836341917514801,
0.33443644642829895,
-0.18047478795051575,
-0.5333199501037598,
0.3490956425666809,
0.23533101379871368,
0.7829800844192505,
0.18707455694675446,
0.27986595034599304,
-0.32336533069610596,
-0.4019702076911926,
-0.0978475883603096,
-0.019910762086510658,
-0.8826909065246582,
-0.41725894808769226,
-0.3332388699054718,
-0.5066869854927063,
-0.4570763111114502,
-0.2886340320110321,
-0.6747264266014099,
-0.6095921397209167,
0.14647714793682098,
-0.5919743776321411,
0.5717940330505371,
0.808196485042572,
0.06930113583803177,
0.41171878576278687,
-0.5843366384506226,
0.08803991228342056,
0.7511489391326904,
0.3824084401130676,
0.02343558333814144,
-0.5158555507659912,
0.0003173660079482943,
0.12466388195753098,
-0.45926448702812195,
-0.8515990376472473,
0.06072279438376427,
-0.27198755741119385,
0.4863895773887634,
0.18503731489181519,
0.3386819660663605,
0.7624449133872986,
-0.07289040833711624,
0.778358519077301,
0.34384414553642273,
-0.9431580305099487,
0.3829311728477478,
-0.2382468283176422,
-0.07153772562742233,
0.6288412809371948,
0.6370120644569397,
-0.20615419745445251,
-0.3604511320590973,
-0.8420097231864929,
-0.5041300654411316,
0.35989609360694885,
0.4188329875469208,
-0.3003120422363281,
0.4001486301422119,
0.6939631104469299,
-0.033795855939388275,
0.44142600893974304,
-0.5995988249778748,
-0.3423290252685547,
0.16194374859333038,
0.006084633991122246,
0.0011720320908352733,
-0.47460854053497314,
-0.43424874544143677,
-0.22811536490917206,
0.7667341828346252,
-0.07148563861846924,
0.21089409291744232,
0.6993368864059448,
-0.06442343443632126,
-0.43015018105506897,
0.4496617615222931,
0.5711319446563721,
1.026557445526123,
-0.3163316249847412,
0.4452786445617676,
0.7154214382171631,
-0.4829341173171997,
0.3199893534183502,
-0.3905286490917206,
-0.11273165792226791,
-0.4657934010028839,
0.15225131809711456,
0.38666826486587524,
0.008892776444554329,
-0.006618964020162821,
0.41727936267852783,
-0.03631911799311638,
-0.5561777353286743,
-0.1527048498392105,
-0.0855085551738739,
0.38232046365737915,
0.7005097270011902,
0.262584388256073,
0.43726736307144165,
0.12297944724559784,
-0.4871515929698944,
0.499138742685318,
0.4105004668235779,
-0.6722828149795532,
-0.1614890843629837,
0.49334901571273804,
0.07323464751243591,
0.08422984182834625,
0.48013123869895935,
0.14745298027992249,
-0.45915502309799194,
0.5386623740196228,
0.5874406099319458,
0.6781080365180969,
-0.1684950292110443,
0.13151748478412628,
0.20419806241989136,
0.5373609662055969,
-0.6637038588523865,
0.33413857221603394,
0.09013402462005615,
-0.9407800436019897,
-0.5323979258537292,
-0.38043808937072754,
-0.8097657561302185,
-0.04111681506037712,
-0.9480052590370178,
-0.18426774442195892,
-0.4976055920124054,
-0.43844151496887207,
-0.518756628036499,
0.12862640619277954,
-0.6609777212142944,
0.15953968465328217,
0.06921280175447464,
1.1117777824401855,
-0.9091365337371826,
1.0846065282821655,
0.5475233793258667,
-0.2514471411705017,
-1.1540603637695312,
-0.05501075088977814,
-0.009216944687068462,
-1.0613412857055664,
0.49089592695236206,
-0.09406937658786774,
-0.2861844003200531,
0.045496586710214615,
-0.7522414922714233,
-1.0099674463272095,
1.58854341506958,
0.4103405475616455,
-0.7170976996421814,
0.028282035142183304,
0.07328911125659943,
0.33268991112709045,
-0.24124620854854584,
0.2932911217212677,
0.6952769756317139,
0.48636800050735474,
0.5466489791870117,
-1.2021456956863403,
0.39717352390289307,
0.1948125809431076,
0.06747361272573471,
-0.1836562305688858,
-0.7511223554611206,
0.6435953974723816,
-0.3077928125858307,
0.2450145184993744,
0.07766616344451904,
0.6071875095367432,
0.47338584065437317,
0.40658625960350037,
0.5604660511016846,
0.5849552750587463,
1.1450556516647339,
0.17542549967765808,
0.8144251108169556,
-0.23192286491394043,
0.31394848227500916,
1.2204160690307617,
-0.34624359011650085,
0.8373526334762573,
0.9620530605316162,
-0.3034193515777588,
0.5605281591415405,
0.430743545293808,
0.3316412568092346,
0.6721810698509216,
0.346743106842041,
-0.04498651996254921,
-0.41116955876350403,
-0.12833018600940704,
-0.4666612148284912,
0.07809194922447205,
0.2959352433681488,
-0.3530341386795044,
0.08008024841547012,
-0.28506404161453247,
0.10075519233942032,
0.029255036264657974,
-0.454950749874115,
0.6040002703666687,
0.6390570998191833,
-0.67134690284729,
0.1443345546722412,
-0.6391504406929016,
0.8804317712783813,
-0.621623694896698,
-0.0011789010604843497,
-0.10356755554676056,
0.40437695384025574,
-0.18170496821403503,
-0.7724370956420898,
0.09050601720809937,
-0.4927927851676941,
-0.15251009166240692,
-0.4315711259841919,
1.1758387088775635,
-0.28939440846443176,
-0.5183568000793457,
0.18592141568660736,
0.8755935430526733,
-0.07261023670434952,
-0.3133533000946045,
-0.5949375629425049,
-0.22188116610050201,
-0.06953044980764389,
-0.2753256559371948,
0.3294522762298584,
0.5802571177482605,
-0.05171160399913788,
1.165806531906128,
0.8023807406425476,
0.41596871614456177,
0.04743002727627754,
-0.2768031060695648,
0.774677574634552,
-0.6140759587287903,
-0.3573315441608429,
-1.0808788537979126,
0.4617137312889099,
-0.20941764116287231,
0.017322221770882607,
0.9785280227661133,
0.03420877829194069,
0.9202495813369751,
-0.015567640773952007,
1.1149007081985474,
0.2998093068599701,
0.5520716905593872,
-0.5894718766212463,
0.7856040000915527,
-0.10511281341314316,
0.27364295721054077,
-0.3766222596168518,
-0.6962657570838928,
-0.12804745137691498,
0.6596962809562683,
-0.34681370854377747,
-0.0038594244979321957,
1.0715820789337158,
0.6230579614639282,
0.203290656208992,
0.05055057629942894,
0.4701639711856842,
0.2173561304807663,
0.16580164432525635,
0.8053398728370667,
1.0753358602523804,
-0.4776197373867035,
0.6898074746131897,
-0.6116703152656555,
-0.10181239992380142,
0.07356952875852585,
-1.044002652168274,
-0.996711015701294,
-0.06160151585936546,
-0.3823172152042389,
-0.5509628653526306,
0.3663168251514435,
0.8291313052177429,
0.708672046661377,
-0.6608611941337585,
-0.08232400566339493,
-0.2342843860387802,
0.3025490939617157,
-0.408973753452301,
-0.22102834284305573,
0.2856628894805908,
-0.20024706423282623,
-0.18149308860301971,
0.017545368522405624,
-0.0231718048453331,
0.16026541590690613,
-0.4507172405719757,
-0.03074362874031067,
-0.02292923629283905,
0.17367808520793915,
0.5224906206130981,
-0.2805528938770294,
-0.547681987285614,
-0.6929936408996582,
0.2815806269645691,
-0.2359992116689682,
-0.06762915849685669,
0.7831907868385315,
-0.6879584789276123,
0.10650908946990967,
0.43005964159965515,
0.6812048554420471,
0.292256236076355,
0.11349229514598846,
0.9308957457542419,
-0.4752183258533478,
-0.27690520882606506,
0.04781147465109825,
0.21924948692321777,
0.08591330796480179,
-0.7239956259727478,
0.6204527616500854,
0.16628357768058777,
-0.8706064820289612,
-0.6960282325744629,
0.25869446992874146,
-1.177627444267273,
-0.17668494582176208,
1.2060284614562988,
-0.36743709444999695,
-0.1932375282049179,
-0.1403045356273651,
-0.22460032999515533,
0.3696271479129791,
-0.4918515384197235,
1.0109392404556274,
0.9245519638061523,
-0.22704623639583588,
-0.14590182900428772,
-0.5703848600387573,
0.7464070320129395,
0.32832589745521545,
-0.8256725072860718,
-0.11373770236968994,
0.028827667236328125,
0.6188804507255554,
0.1802944839000702,
0.7328811883926392,
-0.17532560229301453,
0.22764775156974792,
-0.07811401039361954,
-0.1520613133907318,
-0.0637749508023262,
-0.18106596171855927,
0.06507249921560287,
0.01713150180876255,
0.38536593317985535,
-0.2756102383136749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16845v1
|
On Mesa-Optimization in Autoregressively Trained Transformers: Emergence and Capability
| 2024-05-27T05:41:06 | 2024-05-27T05:41:06 |
Chenyu Zheng, Wei Huang, Rongzhen Wang, Guoqiang Wu, Jun Zhu, Chongxuan Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Autoregressively trained transformers have brought a profound revolution to
the world, especially with their in-context learning (ICL) ability to address
downstream tasks. Recently, several studies suggest that transformers learn a
mesa-optimizer during autoregressive (AR) pretraining to implement ICL. Namely,
the forward pass of the trained transformer is equivalent to optimizing an
inner objective function in-context. However, whether the practical non-convex
training dynamics will converge to the ideal mesa-optimizer is still unclear.
Towards filling this gap, we investigate the non-convex dynamics of a one-layer
linear causal self-attention model autoregressively trained by gradient flow,
where the sequences are generated by an AR process $x_{t+1} = W x_t$. First,
under a certain condition of data distribution, we prove that an
autoregressively trained transformer learns $W$ by implementing one step of
gradient descent to minimize an ordinary least squares (OLS) problem
in-context. It then applies the learned $\widehat{W}$ for next-token
prediction, thereby verifying the mesa-optimization hypothesis. Next, under the
same data conditions, we explore the capability limitations of the obtained
mesa-optimizer. We show that a stronger assumption related to the moments of
data is the sufficient and necessary condition that the learned mesa-optimizer
recovers the distribution. Besides, we conduct exploratory analyses beyond the
first data condition and prove that generally, the trained transformer will not
perform vanilla gradient descent for the OLS problem. Finally, our simulation
results verify the theoretical results.
|
[
-0.6616106033325195,
-0.39859896898269653,
0.24586062133312225,
0.1646583080291748,
-0.04989216849207878,
-0.30125027894973755,
-0.18317674100399017,
-0.04424445331096649,
-0.09542660415172577,
0.534637451171875,
-0.9600169658660889,
0.015697872266173363,
-0.7715148329734802,
0.0005385641125030816,
-0.733357846736908,
1.168628454208374,
-0.03271770849823952,
-0.23068074882030487,
-0.10311422497034073,
-0.1430581957101822,
-0.180242657661438,
-0.11931949108839035,
-0.6823098659515381,
-0.0924372673034668,
0.12680792808532715,
0.24429857730865479,
0.12966062128543854,
0.645647406578064,
0.4898887574672699,
0.2900674641132355,
0.37728235125541687,
-0.22933292388916016,
-0.6027438640594482,
0.3256799578666687,
0.0454985611140728,
-0.32432183623313904,
0.07955767214298248,
0.1502300500869751,
0.8393933176994324,
0.6875821948051453,
-0.4195384085178375,
0.278545618057251,
0.5135066509246826,
0.5196325182914734,
-0.8954175710678101,
0.17825175821781158,
-0.5194262862205505,
0.4421670138835907,
-0.04709257185459137,
-0.1778167337179184,
-0.4696587324142456,
-0.10635090619325638,
0.2656039893627167,
-0.5953377485275269,
0.3802714943885803,
0.004240086767822504,
0.6825105547904968,
1.1239010095596313,
-0.454651415348053,
-0.060592349618673325,
-1.1171677112579346,
0.8827268481254578,
-0.3204786777496338,
0.4316158592700958,
0.08554384857416153,
0.5478549599647522,
0.05431462451815605,
-0.902854859828949,
-0.39985230565071106,
-0.19915823638439178,
0.028690874576568604,
0.2771284580230713,
-0.3983309864997864,
-0.07487411797046661,
0.399747371673584,
0.37612423300743103,
-0.44552600383758545,
0.26527777314186096,
-0.23458202183246613,
0.10362279415130615,
0.4046797752380371,
0.47013434767723083,
-0.30607306957244873,
-0.15833386778831482,
-0.7083510160446167,
-0.16897986829280853,
-0.20766831934452057,
0.6430363655090332,
-0.02579394541680813,
0.11441200226545334,
-0.13641990721225739,
0.19218987226486206,
-0.04320274665951729,
0.3011750280857086,
0.5142210721969604,
-0.046092674136161804,
0.22063301503658295,
-0.09386801719665527,
-0.29594168066978455,
-0.3083314001560211,
0.7730438709259033,
-0.22682806849479675,
-0.02480647899210453,
-0.35118183493614197,
-0.29147130250930786,
-0.24839457869529724,
0.6928292512893677,
-0.5762460231781006,
-0.22690056264400482,
-0.11025407910346985,
-0.47446712851524353,
-0.2125319391489029,
0.07385891675949097,
-0.744976282119751,
0.1666942536830902,
-0.27715063095092773,
0.5886902809143066,
-0.11844196915626526,
-0.0479310043156147,
-0.1812611073255539,
0.22148193418979645,
0.5072726607322693,
0.0963415578007698,
-0.972731351852417,
0.2840406000614166,
0.3486515283584595,
0.541765570640564,
-0.18562087416648865,
-0.25587257742881775,
-0.3987828195095062,
0.11605803668498993,
-0.36768636107444763,
0.5285432934761047,
-0.12514053285121918,
-0.29334065318107605,
-0.1912476122379303,
-0.035826705396175385,
-0.4668728709220886,
-0.21078795194625854,
0.5798125267028809,
-0.39099887013435364,
0.2269826978445053,
-0.16063444316387177,
-0.3396037817001343,
-0.06170743331313133,
0.054918576031923294,
-0.4550454914569855,
1.1074397563934326,
0.14876116812229156,
-0.5468499660491943,
0.5814024806022644,
-0.6827003359794617,
-0.40768933296203613,
-0.21606561541557312,
0.00022518700279761106,
-0.7302306890487671,
0.18884356319904327,
0.07656379789113998,
0.4170147478580475,
-0.35197487473487854,
-0.018959788605570793,
-0.27149730920791626,
0.029470983892679214,
-0.029846712946891785,
-0.59820556640625,
0.6392211318016052,
0.19178271293640137,
-0.741740882396698,
-0.2773188650608063,
-0.7322472929954529,
-0.1999622881412506,
0.1373007446527481,
0.19623616337776184,
0.05210644006729126,
0.14405974745750427,
-0.5002104640007019,
0.3758479952812195,
0.00605588685721159,
-0.47945746779441833,
0.14572106301784515,
-0.2978140413761139,
0.38935860991477966,
0.885249137878418,
0.2709749639034271,
0.7646245956420898,
0.1422988325357437,
0.6749494671821594,
-0.19485577940940857,
0.8883359432220459,
-0.046546582132577896,
-0.25014689564704895,
-1.1086970567703247,
-0.11409720778465271,
0.013456390239298344,
0.41994380950927734,
-0.3777056336402893,
0.4350195825099945,
-0.011259342543780804,
-0.41052180528640747,
-0.11951830983161926,
-0.01455268356949091,
0.23110057413578033,
1.0685384273529053,
0.5557721853256226,
-0.311628133058548,
-0.13200680911540985,
-1.091935396194458,
0.20391082763671875,
0.0678553432226181,
0.24468818306922913,
0.5005865693092346,
0.3859180510044098,
-0.04175542667508125,
1.000576138496399,
-0.4881177246570587,
-0.5507818460464478,
-0.010011487640440464,
0.34667783975601196,
0.27033090591430664,
0.5080738067626953,
0.6922777891159058,
-0.5204352140426636,
-0.5118452310562134,
-0.28761106729507446,
-0.7885957956314087,
-0.16290587186813354,
-0.08421836048364639,
-0.07365092635154724,
0.11446518450975418,
0.6840288043022156,
-0.27730709314346313,
0.5643591284751892,
0.2795344591140747,
0.14593015611171722,
0.14715109765529633,
-0.2439175397157669,
-0.26113420724868774,
-0.6539160013198853,
0.11331663280725479,
0.16961602866649628,
0.07698842138051987,
-0.586199939250946,
-0.24521316587924957,
-0.018906980752944946,
-0.149356409907341,
-0.25497910380363464,
0.24525173008441925,
-0.235228031873703,
-0.21215873956680298,
-0.4013670086860657,
-0.17594455182552338,
-0.1673170030117035,
0.7670702338218689,
-0.11058439314365387,
0.7129303812980652,
0.8862296342849731,
-0.9916043877601624,
-0.09423350542783737,
0.2761393189430237,
0.0005657268920913339,
0.4704212248325348,
-0.49165815114974976,
-0.22802792489528656,
-0.6010833382606506,
0.31077682971954346,
-0.9088119864463806,
0.1419495940208435,
0.3480292856693268,
-0.2116497904062271,
0.43590617179870605,
-0.12791785597801208,
-0.027495285496115685,
-0.6935962438583374,
0.06879308074712753,
0.36986398696899414,
0.6596997976303101,
-0.6634077429771423,
0.8023915886878967,
0.37180617451667786,
0.3980174958705902,
-1.1092804670333862,
-0.5059123039245605,
-0.23116546869277954,
-0.30783990025520325,
-0.4389420449733734,
0.03527434915304184,
0.09401273727416992,
0.1581016331911087,
-0.03209489956498146,
-0.10440827161073685,
-0.06700608134269714,
0.1809074580669403,
0.0589805506169796,
0.019625823944807053,
-0.10668181627988815,
-0.009902989491820335,
0.19121123850345612,
-0.6907423138618469,
0.356301486492157,
-0.5310779809951782,
0.3165457844734192,
-0.16310448944568634,
-0.5119284391403198,
-0.430751234292984,
0.15740162134170532,
0.32472771406173706,
-0.28962254524230957,
0.5475553274154663,
0.8225001096725464,
0.0012104498455300927,
-0.5687930583953857,
-0.447211354970932,
-0.35148105025291443,
-0.4873737394809723,
0.19439661502838135,
-0.3449576497077942,
-0.4360361695289612,
0.5838873982429504,
0.05902428552508354,
0.27262207865715027,
0.8734274506568909,
0.3514658212661743,
-0.2226255089044571,
0.7976071834564209,
0.7303749322891235,
0.1029830351471901,
0.39714282751083374,
-0.9432416558265686,
0.19141094386577606,
-0.994268536567688,
-0.402435839176178,
-0.38473519682884216,
-0.5483235716819763,
-0.44711750745773315,
-0.13909612596035004,
0.6958023905754089,
-0.14454464614391327,
-0.3189633786678314,
0.47297853231430054,
-0.5336264371871948,
0.20074863731861115,
0.5041357278823853,
-0.1558167040348053,
-0.041762832552194595,
-0.44221562147140503,
-0.06731511652469635,
-0.1636805236339569,
-1.021841287612915,
0.09012594074010849,
0.9287939667701721,
0.14759962260723114,
0.8480960130691528,
-0.27740052342414856,
0.49713292717933655,
0.21576324105262756,
0.36761990189552307,
-0.46454840898513794,
0.3577899932861328,
-0.14571578800678253,
-0.2399669736623764,
-0.36202001571655273,
-0.25158631801605225,
-1.106448769569397,
0.21249890327453613,
-0.3078233599662781,
-0.4755833148956299,
0.5173659324645996,
0.35825034976005554,
-0.405948281288147,
0.27217140793800354,
-0.3766269385814667,
0.9068478345870972,
-0.15614312887191772,
-0.2055579423904419,
-0.1043219119310379,
-0.8899461030960083,
0.1731533259153366,
-0.22471389174461365,
0.022340893745422363,
-0.013010929338634014,
-0.07430223375558853,
0.351035475730896,
-0.40762588381767273,
0.6034699082374573,
-0.40593957901000977,
0.012295957654714584,
0.26384520530700684,
-0.1207994669675827,
0.5263070464134216,
0.05957217141985893,
0.18283984065055847,
0.05873332545161247,
-0.594559371471405,
-0.2737804055213928,
-0.798542857170105,
0.516660749912262,
-0.8261745572090149,
-0.6575338244438171,
-0.2093704342842102,
-0.23814517259597778,
-0.07060997188091278,
-0.04264706373214722,
0.6767706274986267,
0.510932981967926,
-0.0764106884598732,
0.23712529242038727,
0.6371691823005676,
0.2824198007583618,
1.0472524166107178,
0.448253870010376,
0.21848534047603607,
-0.009930678643286228,
0.6489824056625366,
0.23203273117542267,
0.31302276253700256,
0.15449364483356476,
0.20704372227191925,
-0.28056472539901733,
-0.4703134000301361,
-0.5138079524040222,
0.10969580709934235,
-0.6799522638320923,
-0.11678075790405273,
-0.650601327419281,
-0.4023130238056183,
-0.017284609377384186,
-0.2787450850009918,
-0.6703668832778931,
-0.30535510182380676,
-0.34547585248947144,
0.3282696008682251,
-0.04492774233222008,
0.7471804618835449,
-0.368072509765625,
0.25005385279655457,
-0.5282344818115234,
-0.07354793697595596,
0.4371297359466553,
0.24647638201713562,
0.301763117313385,
-0.7049652934074402,
-0.4898666739463806,
-0.23630821704864502,
-0.453954815864563,
-0.34450310468673706,
0.3872329592704773,
0.286337673664093,
0.9991967082023621,
0.7617477774620056,
0.11438386142253876,
0.3869549632072449,
-0.5160976052284241,
0.5232167840003967,
-0.04441981390118599,
-0.7606642842292786,
0.40138351917266846,
-0.2536318302154541,
0.03051033429801464,
0.6328015923500061,
0.3635200560092926,
-0.07347402721643448,
-0.45661666989326477,
-0.7230784893035889,
-0.7332899570465088,
0.7979347705841064,
0.4384729862213135,
0.24370037019252777,
0.012008179910480976,
0.6586546897888184,
0.20595373213291168,
0.13213492929935455,
-0.7809333205223083,
-0.5510624051094055,
-0.5518794059753418,
0.26078131794929504,
-0.0316338837146759,
0.13103851675987244,
0.11257205158472061,
-0.27183133363723755,
0.7200250029563904,
-0.14122217893600464,
0.4781399071216583,
0.15890833735466003,
-0.1203540712594986,
-0.23919019103050232,
-0.21131950616836548,
0.4747312664985657,
0.32930493354797363,
0.08196671307086945,
-0.38186386227607727,
0.3513481318950653,
-0.38638192415237427,
0.26320332288742065,
0.07782839983701706,
-0.24368812143802643,
-0.4568290412425995,
-0.029675889760255814,
1.0864360332489014,
0.321117639541626,
-0.058306653052568436,
0.7946010231971741,
-0.17104798555374146,
-0.2850331664085388,
-0.81493079662323,
0.2970080077648163,
-0.7284879684448242,
0.5541402101516724,
0.8883213996887207,
0.5439184904098511,
0.27782171964645386,
0.15532557666301727,
0.3073696792125702,
0.8173546195030212,
-0.39737075567245483,
-0.1933206468820572,
1.0169942378997803,
0.0724564865231514,
-0.20066162943840027,
0.5985623598098755,
-0.17951859533786774,
-0.42987731099128723,
0.66541987657547,
0.3955138027667999,
1.0687628984451294,
-0.2634720504283905,
-0.13136577606201172,
0.5117829442024231,
0.36512404680252075,
0.12101323157548904,
-0.43510037660598755,
-0.45964935421943665,
-0.5322815775871277,
-0.6266054511070251,
-0.4479410648345947,
-0.22004836797714233,
-0.17678113281726837,
-0.9469660520553589,
0.4195617139339447,
-0.37650132179260254,
-0.20480047166347504,
-0.19272106885910034,
-0.28319233655929565,
-0.6056980490684509,
0.3999477028846741,
-0.013514646328985691,
0.44421228766441345,
-0.8299275636672974,
0.6978404521942139,
0.01992260105907917,
-0.07883453369140625,
-0.6806508302688599,
0.2893095314502716,
-0.29772496223449707,
-0.9780778884887695,
0.8000438213348389,
0.01606873981654644,
-0.23345060646533966,
0.42870089411735535,
-0.19301186501979828,
-1.3513472080230713,
1.226641058921814,
0.23694348335266113,
-0.21277253329753876,
-0.1721445918083191,
-0.013411475345492363,
0.43594175577163696,
-0.3625282347202301,
0.2848503291606903,
0.2600192427635193,
0.354438453912735,
0.21487963199615479,
-0.7798023223876953,
-0.3219890892505646,
-0.14303255081176758,
-0.0006025241455063224,
0.7211703062057495,
-0.9199228882789612,
0.8524631857872009,
-0.12524965405464172,
-0.04708551615476608,
-0.15360984206199646,
0.8753618597984314,
-0.4699305593967438,
-0.01452188566327095,
0.722977876663208,
0.8891275525093079,
0.3464011549949646,
-0.05251351743936539,
1.2264113426208496,
-0.5540392398834229,
0.7462958693504333,
0.5341290831565857,
0.20915675163269043,
0.42308276891708374,
0.1916918307542801,
-0.16207335889339447,
0.5533116459846497,
0.3697149455547333,
-0.16746766865253448,
0.7175499796867371,
-0.218073770403862,
-0.14507809281349182,
-0.2670840919017792,
0.23872117698192596,
-0.3479822278022766,
0.7405375242233276,
0.23210223019123077,
-0.469364196062088,
-0.44414862990379333,
0.5067769885063171,
-0.4075581729412079,
-0.26489928364753723,
-0.355156272649765,
0.6137704849243164,
-0.0750388503074646,
-0.7050776481628418,
0.5046833157539368,
-0.3201758861541748,
0.37746870517730713,
-0.49310389161109924,
0.45468878746032715,
-0.05473208427429199,
0.17677004635334015,
0.07577785849571228,
-0.5019737482070923,
0.4890316426753998,
-0.5753016471862793,
-0.15935060381889343,
-0.19127368927001953,
0.4510755240917206,
-0.09204277396202087,
-0.24278226494789124,
0.2498026341199875,
0.26665928959846497,
-0.13775227963924408,
0.2960415482521057,
-0.6262369155883789,
-0.44348078966140747,
-0.15289251506328583,
-0.4931190311908722,
0.16635499894618988,
0.09600448608398438,
0.13283616304397583,
0.9952254295349121,
0.385410338640213,
-0.37373560667037964,
0.27150964736938477,
-0.21005059778690338,
0.7358035445213318,
-0.15790726244449615,
-0.586259126663208,
-0.9202226996421814,
0.4663555324077606,
0.05136549100279808,
-0.5115158557891846,
0.7544713020324707,
0.36292561888694763,
0.4866752028465271,
0.1518867313861847,
0.4722593426704407,
0.06253565847873688,
0.33053308725357056,
-0.3917210102081299,
0.44490334391593933,
-0.6839516162872314,
-0.07791251689195633,
-0.26708313822746277,
-1.1355100870132446,
-0.09429654479026794,
0.7558274269104004,
-0.3838798701763153,
0.11954173445701599,
0.7583234906196594,
0.3599366545677185,
-0.2739108204841614,
0.0919840857386589,
0.0875656008720398,
0.04061044752597809,
0.009857906959950924,
0.6763526797294617,
0.4397524297237396,
-0.48286905884742737,
0.5801295638084412,
-0.5216851830482483,
-0.37358155846595764,
-0.06194870173931122,
-0.7619053721427917,
-0.7509748935699463,
-0.9190288782119751,
-0.10670414566993713,
-0.3285388946533203,
-0.29385802149772644,
0.6818894147872925,
0.8250343799591064,
-0.41298508644104004,
0.004045283421874046,
-0.46447354555130005,
-0.4301237463951111,
-0.08885641396045685,
-0.26960113644599915,
0.22466006875038147,
-0.7886010408401489,
-0.6467815637588501,
0.31537124514579773,
0.5501959323883057,
0.044512517750263214,
-0.6845830082893372,
-0.17295213043689728,
0.17689335346221924,
0.12271057814359665,
0.37798571586608887,
0.5742578506469727,
-0.31263336539268494,
-0.09007785469293594,
0.15433351695537567,
-0.045804712921381,
0.3793410062789917,
1.0225001573562622,
-0.9516006112098694,
0.3751886188983917,
0.011717676185071468,
0.6489357948303223,
1.1407431364059448,
-0.05717746913433075,
0.4312865138053894,
-0.6639845967292786,
0.30604180693626404,
0.2743743658065796,
0.4227166473865509,
-0.1568983793258667,
-0.36747369170188904,
0.33440545201301575,
0.19787585735321045,
-0.8513752222061157,
-0.4814155399799347,
0.3423655331134796,
-0.7210606932640076,
0.13615001738071442,
0.7823707461357117,
0.06159219518303871,
-0.11873704195022583,
-0.1516464203596115,
0.28115114569664,
0.2902403473854065,
-0.29629069566726685,
0.897243320941925,
0.2670931816101074,
-0.622397780418396,
-0.36333170533180237,
-0.39974337816238403,
0.6499195098876953,
0.588062047958374,
-0.5556952357292175,
-0.09964951127767563,
-0.03625355288386345,
0.1045987457036972,
0.08786629885435104,
0.4878121316432953,
0.14764554798603058,
0.2982839345932007,
-0.22106584906578064,
-0.3112456500530243,
-0.10403525084257126,
-0.2523905038833618,
-0.39532363414764404,
0.17329899966716766,
-0.2364278882741928,
-0.22885094583034515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16821v1
|
Perturbation-Restrained Sequential Model Editing
| 2024-05-27T04:40:56 | 2024-05-27T04:40:56 |
Jun-Yu Ma, Hong Wang, Hao-Xiang Xu, Zhen-Hua Ling, Jia-Chen Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Model editing is an emerging field that focuses on updating the knowledge
embedded within large language models (LLMs) without extensive retraining.
However, current model editing methods significantly compromise the general
abilities of LLMs as the number of edits increases, and this trade-off poses a
substantial challenge to the continual learning of LLMs. In this paper, we
first theoretically analyze that the factor affecting the general abilities in
sequential model editing lies in the condition number of the edited matrix. The
condition number of a matrix represents its numerical sensitivity, and
therefore can be used to indicate the extent to which the original knowledge
associations stored in LLMs are perturbed after editing. Subsequently,
statistical findings demonstrate that the value of this factor becomes larger
as the number of edits increases, thereby exacerbating the deterioration of
general abilities. To this end, a framework termed Perturbation Restraint on
Upper bouNd for Editing (PRUNE) is proposed, which applies the condition number
restraints in sequential editing. These restraints can lower the upper bound on
perturbation to edited models, thus preserving the general abilities.
Systematically, we conduct experiments employing three popular editing methods
on three LLMs across four representative downstream tasks. Evaluation results
show that PRUNE can preserve considerable general abilities while maintaining
the editing performance effectively in sequential model editing. The code and
data are available at https://github.com/mjy1111/PRUNE.
|
[
-0.25833791494369507,
-0.7796807289123535,
0.5979490280151367,
0.42448586225509644,
-0.2760647237300873,
-0.017433125525712967,
-0.3344484865665436,
-0.10129258781671524,
-0.13133126497268677,
0.6823474168777466,
-0.41036808490753174,
-0.48396772146224976,
-0.6209578514099121,
0.4212002754211426,
-0.355760395526886,
0.8278854489326477,
-0.14464882016181946,
-0.10494592785835266,
-0.15203611552715302,
0.0005672777770087123,
-0.5758927464485168,
-0.913232147693634,
-0.45278865098953247,
0.1789175420999527,
0.600774884223938,
0.3683280944824219,
0.9129554629325867,
0.7067254185676575,
0.6772042512893677,
0.44664281606674194,
-0.5984642505645752,
-0.014323730953037739,
-0.6228820085525513,
0.3004804253578186,
-0.3235137164592743,
-0.6612247824668884,
-0.7764664888381958,
-0.26118817925453186,
1.2121745347976685,
0.35933566093444824,
-0.02658994495868683,
-0.024017661809921265,
0.06863771378993988,
0.5979341268539429,
-0.5470725297927856,
-0.5180985331535339,
-0.7488839030265808,
-0.06532493978738785,
-0.3787190914154053,
-0.029858890920877457,
-0.5317090749740601,
0.04124774411320686,
-0.08921167254447937,
-0.7025495767593384,
0.0997157022356987,
-0.20922331511974335,
0.9542807936668396,
0.7385497689247131,
-0.07614342868328094,
0.36647188663482666,
-0.7112576365470886,
0.5468850135803223,
-0.8815344572067261,
0.25289854407310486,
0.3291440010070801,
-0.2715138792991638,
-0.3535394072532654,
-0.5917174816131592,
-0.5410401225090027,
0.005267512984573841,
0.02320861630141735,
-0.10416968911886215,
-0.14903445541858673,
0.49121949076652527,
0.7745206356048584,
0.2620196044445038,
-0.19608451426029205,
0.4352653920650482,
-0.3033544719219208,
-0.12160108238458633,
0.6104668378829956,
0.2920169532299042,
0.38567325472831726,
-0.2193932980298996,
-0.10278476774692535,
-0.11293330788612366,
-0.8957949876785278,
0.011050724424421787,
0.6279169917106628,
-0.23057007789611816,
0.2856737971305847,
0.6086718440055847,
-0.053064100444316864,
0.6798087954521179,
0.21700133383274078,
-0.10933829843997955,
0.06975973397493362,
-0.4486660063266754,
-0.5106218457221985,
-0.36573857069015503,
0.6852431893348694,
0.24318495392799377,
0.2827567160129547,
0.03856806084513664,
-0.30035004019737244,
-0.08252514898777008,
0.28945258259773254,
-0.7039890289306641,
-0.03268545866012573,
0.030782410874962807,
-0.2556256651878357,
-0.4341481924057007,
0.10948611050844193,
-0.4325616955757141,
-0.49545279145240784,
-0.25791871547698975,
0.17341545224189758,
-0.27573785185813904,
0.052303507924079895,
0.3111206889152527,
-0.09072007983922958,
-0.27734267711639404,
0.6135162711143494,
-0.6906377673149109,
0.22259201109409332,
0.5609340667724609,
0.7925238609313965,
0.07474890351295471,
-0.30030176043510437,
-0.20938430726528168,
0.20020785927772522,
-0.3531598448753357,
0.3672963082790375,
-0.7730457782745361,
-0.6536431312561035,
-0.4843789041042328,
0.026533538475632668,
-0.03867562115192413,
-0.5032684803009033,
0.45369458198547363,
-0.6898242235183716,
-0.18522246181964874,
-0.16652943193912506,
-0.3392782211303711,
-0.16120468080043793,
-0.1803407073020935,
-0.6777632832527161,
0.6031931638717651,
-0.12177431583404541,
-0.8634677529335022,
0.12943381071090698,
-0.2120639681816101,
-0.3881855309009552,
-0.46567443013191223,
0.01747516728937626,
-0.6202895641326904,
0.4721662700176239,
0.17853885889053345,
0.04489335045218468,
-0.10424152761697769,
0.3507022261619568,
-0.48851919174194336,
-0.3152017593383789,
0.46218636631965637,
-0.25713977217674255,
0.5395902991294861,
-0.10725309699773788,
0.26866379380226135,
0.6974023580551147,
-0.634617269039154,
-0.1942930519580841,
-0.1535966694355011,
-0.547360897064209,
-0.4026026725769043,
0.24265499413013458,
-0.6203590631484985,
0.35188883543014526,
-0.05851249396800995,
-0.4607275724411011,
0.8148482441902161,
-0.2839714288711548,
0.5415757894515991,
1.1105868816375732,
0.7404332756996155,
0.40811094641685486,
-0.4751204550266266,
0.7495235204696655,
-0.07181873917579651,
0.23257620632648468,
-0.1191156879067421,
-0.44494563341140747,
-0.8785882592201233,
-0.13781510293483734,
0.717789888381958,
0.7493010759353638,
-0.5433740019798279,
0.22083407640457153,
-0.09929543733596802,
-0.2654170095920563,
-0.6821696758270264,
0.38787099719047546,
0.40605536103248596,
0.27178341150283813,
0.322501003742218,
-0.4200279414653778,
-0.6778908371925354,
-0.9670456051826477,
-0.3915160894393921,
0.09656651318073273,
-0.11066720634698868,
-0.12176205217838287,
0.3481515645980835,
-0.027021367102861404,
0.6519681215286255,
-0.299565851688385,
-0.21826966106891632,
0.043490875512361526,
0.05772022157907486,
0.44362175464630127,
0.6863462328910828,
0.3694266080856323,
-0.5275475382804871,
-0.20591388642787933,
-0.2995298504829407,
-0.3554189205169678,
-0.4424305260181427,
-0.4577521085739136,
-0.32009631395339966,
0.23404443264007568,
0.5677043795585632,
-0.7085140943527222,
0.8112391233444214,
0.32304516434669495,
-0.2941504716873169,
0.7215284705162048,
-0.2617509961128235,
0.1282930076122284,
-0.4641808569431305,
-0.00674406485632062,
-0.09295301139354706,
0.02498745732009411,
-0.6778304576873779,
0.058607082813978195,
0.1294676512479782,
-0.013647275045514107,
-0.3524493873119354,
0.27176180481910706,
-0.5175870060920715,
-0.020972920581698418,
-0.13768617808818817,
-0.18068933486938477,
-0.1474800705909729,
0.45258867740631104,
0.06366696953773499,
0.5241059064865112,
0.2772233486175537,
-0.6744738817214966,
-0.16559968888759613,
0.46802961826324463,
-0.34504058957099915,
-0.0635945200920105,
-0.8343045711517334,
0.6210857033729553,
-0.22807301580905914,
0.20521730184555054,
-0.8121126890182495,
-0.03732163459062576,
0.08834365010261536,
-0.31866562366485596,
0.41304895281791687,
-0.40514492988586426,
-0.5237057209014893,
-0.17037594318389893,
-0.3583245575428009,
0.10182860493659973,
0.2288666069507599,
0.08353089541196823,
0.38865208625793457,
0.13528256118297577,
-0.5052053928375244,
-0.5838631987571716,
-0.7172052264213562,
0.12922663986682892,
-0.10963436216115952,
-0.9297208786010742,
0.6589352488517761,
-0.1816089153289795,
-0.49184903502464294,
0.10472549498081207,
-0.26766955852508545,
0.17787428200244904,
0.3610035181045532,
0.28186678886413574,
0.41909945011138916,
0.1326122134923935,
0.1550319641828537,
0.387780100107193,
-0.24965068697929382,
-0.20649957656860352,
0.02493659220635891,
0.18185599148273468,
0.2903846502304077,
-0.24834582209587097,
-0.5113269090652466,
0.02974945493042469,
0.6700649857521057,
-0.5823613405227661,
0.4984103739261627,
-0.02197491005063057,
-0.22109872102737427,
-0.09563171863555908,
-0.4470430016517639,
-0.17969898879528046,
-0.5042482018470764,
0.610312283039093,
-0.7033855319023132,
-0.8810742497444153,
0.5358589887619019,
0.14942581951618195,
0.21478118002414703,
0.411872923374176,
0.45622944831848145,
0.24637258052825928,
1.1724741458892822,
0.48645880818367004,
-0.038877494633197784,
0.6211276054382324,
-0.14231647551059723,
-0.09148934483528137,
-1.0524600744247437,
0.21233327686786652,
-0.5215228199958801,
-0.7070057988166809,
-0.3460708260536194,
-0.5642310976982117,
0.3217323124408722,
0.6261672377586365,
-0.4175911247730255,
0.05037139356136322,
-0.45543134212493896,
0.39826807379722595,
0.29845401644706726,
0.16085395216941833,
0.4187016487121582,
-0.23357993364334106,
-0.3034076392650604,
-0.27647536993026733,
-0.701147735118866,
-0.4440256357192993,
0.920055627822876,
0.4840112030506134,
0.7059121131896973,
0.40946078300476074,
0.5154100060462952,
0.1362205147743225,
0.37021487951278687,
-0.5144235491752625,
0.7089190483093262,
-0.31686487793922424,
-0.6452916264533997,
-0.40435296297073364,
-0.2299247533082962,
-0.5036042332649231,
0.43682706356048584,
-0.3684009313583374,
-0.8367409706115723,
0.5198860764503479,
0.46739575266838074,
-0.5462566614151001,
0.42614254355430603,
-0.5279476642608643,
0.6372959613800049,
-0.4193950295448303,
-0.8029381632804871,
-0.4898364245891571,
-0.5350415110588074,
0.4033934473991394,
-0.1587577909231186,
0.2000446617603302,
0.009404866956174374,
-0.30836501717567444,
0.6841315031051636,
-0.6173682808876038,
0.8367254734039307,
-0.27521535754203796,
0.16231903433799744,
0.10200191289186478,
0.4753389358520508,
0.8140713572502136,
0.06939136236906052,
-0.3707766830921173,
-0.12225152552127838,
-0.1915660798549652,
-0.036420874297618866,
-0.7559131383895874,
0.49490857124328613,
-0.6583855748176575,
-1.214081048965454,
-0.24447309970855713,
-0.3840780556201935,
-0.44481557607650757,
0.21836835145950317,
0.1840108335018158,
0.2862129509449005,
0.251117080450058,
0.3024005591869354,
0.48506107926368713,
-0.5902610421180725,
0.31853097677230835,
0.5648464560508728,
-0.5014488101005554,
-0.47491681575775146,
0.540605902671814,
0.6051976680755615,
0.5216556191444397,
0.2884161174297333,
0.17064282298088074,
0.13954296708106995,
-1.0829875469207764,
-0.11159589886665344,
0.21303334832191467,
-0.5829923748970032,
-0.13246577978134155,
-0.37090003490448,
0.005222797393798828,
-0.3126402199268341,
-0.2659696936607361,
0.04683613032102585,
-0.5793966054916382,
-0.33638566732406616,
-0.17534123361110687,
0.3561215400695801,
0.8815089464187622,
-0.1780678629875183,
0.28724589943885803,
-0.6672192811965942,
0.2987740635871887,
0.08613699674606323,
0.40010055899620056,
0.10396137833595276,
-0.9128496050834656,
0.0037535179872065783,
-0.20961833000183105,
-0.22628431022167206,
-1.1378370523452759,
0.3586886525154114,
0.07942251116037369,
0.41870251297950745,
0.36695536971092224,
0.016770897433161736,
0.870792031288147,
-0.3126380145549774,
0.3268624544143677,
-0.07864809781312943,
-1.077451467514038,
0.4153253436088562,
-0.40416210889816284,
0.6232872605323792,
0.4587939977645874,
0.30565524101257324,
-0.5824893712997437,
-0.5192735195159912,
-0.4947744905948639,
-0.8849390745162964,
0.7018252611160278,
-0.0697895884513855,
-0.06511618196964264,
0.2224137783050537,
0.4507063925266266,
-0.28582024574279785,
0.22145965695381165,
-0.37544751167297363,
0.09611256420612335,
-0.02616691216826439,
0.23733381927013397,
0.22494760155677795,
-0.7431827783584595,
0.18819531798362732,
-0.6247620582580566,
0.8611873388290405,
0.4246276319026947,
-0.045174162834882736,
0.4758204519748688,
-0.3988415598869324,
-0.2600719928741455,
0.40827804803848267,
0.762824535369873,
0.8052332997322083,
-0.25454920530319214,
-0.170430526137352,
0.40240833163261414,
-0.37972190976142883,
0.19115129113197327,
-0.10647950321435928,
-0.5750463008880615,
-0.36198705434799194,
0.3108392655849457,
1.0789258480072021,
0.6383330821990967,
-0.3094196319580078,
-0.028840716928243637,
0.046972110867500305,
-0.3239338994026184,
0.021832549944519997,
0.1746811866760254,
-0.013777414336800575,
-0.09446381032466888,
0.13778972625732422,
0.41209876537323,
-0.17776407301425934,
-0.0786111056804657,
0.23384307324886322,
-0.016112372279167175,
0.018993332982063293,
-0.3497592508792877,
0.7541163563728333,
0.18116211891174316,
-0.44681328535079956,
0.7925940752029419,
-0.06078420579433441,
-0.6909689903259277,
0.4397817552089691,
0.39912232756614685,
0.6473568081855774,
-0.4035120904445648,
-0.27835366129875183,
0.5021238327026367,
0.5294185876846313,
0.06225770339369774,
0.14134769141674042,
0.24039088189601898,
-0.8817979693412781,
-0.8200802206993103,
-0.5043920278549194,
-0.34220024943351746,
0.2595447897911072,
-0.3876248598098755,
0.4017426073551178,
-1.0315628051757812,
-0.5506276488304138,
0.08298207074403763,
-0.2569658160209656,
-0.3600032329559326,
-0.015366182662546635,
-0.059536416083574295,
0.9607656598091125,
-0.27892088890075684,
1.047187089920044,
0.7399849891662598,
-0.3475930988788605,
-0.7693937420845032,
-0.32272645831108093,
0.2925085723400116,
-0.25901269912719727,
0.405318021774292,
-0.21779514849185944,
0.09343049675226212,
0.17780524492263794,
-0.48606181144714355,
-0.973534107208252,
0.7057983875274658,
0.5536264777183533,
-1.1685082912445068,
-0.25030308961868286,
-0.3165208399295807,
0.4754795730113983,
0.21992887556552887,
-0.08284826576709747,
0.5694374442100525,
0.8643522262573242,
-0.08686642348766327,
-0.9534910917282104,
-0.007058111485093832,
-0.45241937041282654,
0.016506604850292206,
0.33010220527648926,
-0.49845150113105774,
0.9572946429252625,
-0.43279317021369934,
-0.22397944331169128,
0.296080082654953,
0.46565788984298706,
0.111650750041008,
-0.4833175241947174,
0.5218207836151123,
0.9207291603088379,
0.7032977938652039,
-0.05896703898906708,
1.1896671056747437,
-0.2183622121810913,
0.04953211918473244,
1.2809808254241943,
-0.2387252151966095,
0.8364059329032898,
0.34587642550468445,
-0.2569699287414551,
0.3356875777244568,
0.49679815769195557,
-0.14890635013580322,
0.1497110277414322,
0.5265613794326782,
-0.1844778060913086,
-0.30572062730789185,
0.2745116651058197,
-0.1473873257637024,
0.3409835398197174,
0.4162081480026245,
-0.46995770931243896,
0.35675203800201416,
-0.10027724504470825,
0.46221789717674255,
0.10947681963443756,
-0.4596713185310364,
0.5341636538505554,
0.008709194138646126,
-0.7848374843597412,
0.5441027283668518,
0.3462130129337311,
0.5310625433921814,
-0.6681933403015137,
-0.006986397318542004,
0.031352829188108444,
0.2934054136276245,
-0.343407541513443,
-0.7137461304664612,
0.23472781479358673,
0.06096279248595238,
-0.40132075548171997,
-0.34138399362564087,
0.943082332611084,
-0.28387001156806946,
-0.4648955166339874,
0.21692439913749695,
-0.006852985359728336,
-0.29347148537635803,
-0.07120884209871292,
-0.5063360929489136,
0.4832701086997986,
0.12367138266563416,
-0.5246497988700867,
0.39745309948921204,
0.1394507735967636,
-0.2634083926677704,
0.4854491651058197,
0.6430327892303467,
0.33036333322525024,
0.003121452871710062,
-0.020827874541282654,
0.8349672555923462,
-0.6063995361328125,
-0.40219202637672424,
-0.8958293795585632,
0.8009814023971558,
-0.029531577602028847,
-0.5543274283409119,
0.7731050252914429,
0.05915749445557594,
0.6487014293670654,
-0.05861951783299446,
0.9272666573524475,
-0.0001994791382458061,
0.375400573015213,
-0.6999913454055786,
0.630479633808136,
-0.11855517327785492,
0.38702794909477234,
-0.4385436475276947,
-0.6795737147331238,
-0.5914716720581055,
0.47266045212745667,
-0.8213779330253601,
-0.17171640694141388,
0.5357017517089844,
0.8239787220954895,
0.4052818715572357,
-0.17815349996089935,
0.3063889443874359,
0.8168202638626099,
0.0689084455370903,
0.4037694036960602,
0.8126946091651917,
0.13705086708068848,
0.00431791739538312,
-0.47402289509773254,
-0.1046341136097908,
0.050879959017038345,
-0.8189306855201721,
-0.6259254813194275,
-0.284267395734787,
-0.2048654407262802,
-0.24983739852905273,
0.3423272371292114,
0.6314842104911804,
0.5174646377563477,
-0.7023157477378845,
-0.18488973379135132,
-0.019877657294273376,
0.36962977051734924,
-0.12925182282924652,
-0.12342265993356705,
0.25706616044044495,
-0.0592079795897007,
-0.4191805124282837,
0.5224130153656006,
0.2366340160369873,
-0.010905183851718903,
-0.0933048352599144,
-0.07796484977006912,
-0.5517238974571228,
0.022372638806700706,
0.3850080966949463,
0.3872879445552826,
-0.4363504648208618,
-0.22994431853294373,
-0.08409543335437775,
0.3219481110572815,
-0.09036571532487869,
0.9844169616699219,
-0.629938542842865,
0.6062493920326233,
0.7384084463119507,
0.618971586227417,
0.40672916173934937,
0.41696667671203613,
0.7858659029006958,
-0.679918110370636,
0.347416490316391,
0.21685552597045898,
0.5315502285957336,
0.24272875487804413,
-0.17974638938903809,
0.3611193001270294,
0.3188481032848358,
-0.6434239149093628,
-0.8969528079032898,
0.09137821942567825,
-0.5857741832733154,
-0.31429314613342285,
1.0999670028686523,
-0.15772676467895508,
-0.021250074729323387,
0.07264538109302521,
-0.42308181524276733,
0.1642940640449524,
-0.27445051074028015,
0.3550613522529602,
0.7845641374588013,
-0.12278661876916885,
-0.2759075462818146,
-0.5537348985671997,
0.5044065713882446,
0.6229714751243591,
-0.38750794529914856,
0.02635844796895981,
0.6509230136871338,
0.14201416075229645,
-0.10934541374444962,
0.4643387794494629,
-0.20024576783180237,
0.43464240431785583,
-0.26478368043899536,
0.12554886937141418,
-0.476884126663208,
-0.47347795963287354,
-0.6550466418266296,
0.17679055035114288,
0.5905480980873108,
0.188445582985878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16810v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16810v2
|
Performance evaluation of Reddit Comments using Machine Learning and Natural Language Processing methods in Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-05-27T03:59:28 | 2024-05-28T14:28:49 |
Xiaoxia Zhang, Xiuyuan Qi, Zixin Teng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis, an increasingly vital field in both academia and
industry, plays a pivotal role in machine learning applications, particularly
on social media platforms like Reddit. However, the efficacy of sentiment
analysis models is hindered by the lack of expansive and fine-grained emotion
datasets. To address this gap, our study leverages the GoEmotions dataset,
comprising a diverse range of emotions, to evaluate sentiment analysis methods
across a substantial corpus of 58,000 comments. Distinguished from prior
studies by the Google team, which limited their analysis to only two models,
our research expands the scope by evaluating a diverse array of models. We
investigate the performance of traditional classifiers such as Naive Bayes and
Support Vector Machines (SVM), as well as state-of-the-art transformer-based
models including BERT, RoBERTa, and GPT. Furthermore, our evaluation criteria
extend beyond accuracy to encompass nuanced assessments, including hierarchical
classification based on varying levels of granularity in emotion
categorization. Additionally, considerations such as computational efficiency
are incorporated to provide a comprehensive evaluation framework. Our findings
reveal that the RoBERTa model consistently outperforms the baseline models,
demonstrating superior accuracy in fine-grained sentiment classification tasks.
This underscores the substantial potential and significance of the RoBERTa
model in advancing sentiment analysis capabilities.
|
[
-0.4458771347999573,
-0.7450207471847534,
0.424960732460022,
0.2632434666156769,
-0.39716821908950806,
-0.02461939863860607,
-0.4631412625312805,
-0.5962530970573425,
0.0676981508731842,
0.2023729532957077,
-0.621696949005127,
-0.6041793823242188,
-0.7745451927185059,
0.1802322268486023,
-0.3868996798992157,
1.3258683681488037,
0.10369332879781723,
0.15169937908649445,
-0.34997308254241943,
-0.23522579669952393,
-0.18999241292476654,
-0.5407360792160034,
-0.37050074338912964,
-0.275014728307724,
0.3695242404937744,
0.1543368250131607,
0.7178270220756531,
-0.01745622046291828,
1.0261213779449463,
0.2916465401649475,
-0.17091792821884155,
0.15357814729213715,
-0.49101969599723816,
0.12515103816986084,
0.06272998452186584,
-0.34838005900382996,
-0.4193655252456665,
0.08631306886672974,
0.2939015328884125,
0.36816591024398804,
-0.022614935413002968,
0.4583200514316559,
0.10852793604135513,
0.9296286702156067,
-0.6424217224121094,
0.22448047995567322,
-0.42039409279823303,
0.2769901156425476,
-0.0059390682727098465,
0.028551694005727768,
-0.5875557661056519,
-0.7667325735092163,
0.3529416024684906,
-0.2640179693698883,
0.24027712643146515,
-0.236125186085701,
0.8680068254470825,
0.3056930601596832,
-0.10360118746757507,
-0.2706381380558014,
-0.914747416973114,
1.1102406978607178,
-0.6615623831748962,
0.22380788624286652,
-0.05744054168462753,
0.42530491948127747,
0.0687842071056366,
-0.7630520462989807,
-0.4089650511741638,
-0.10679629445075989,
-0.1205769032239914,
0.41825318336486816,
-0.5842090845108032,
-0.14902879297733307,
0.17194421589374542,
0.4965716600418091,
-0.6757379770278931,
-0.16918937861919403,
-0.09677856415510178,
0.15193699300289154,
0.4339567720890045,
0.1909095197916031,
0.19512394070625305,
-0.42865076661109924,
-0.2467236965894699,
-0.1808401346206665,
-0.051359884440898895,
0.07234137505292892,
0.4069426655769348,
0.36831435561180115,
-0.11772506684064865,
0.41031983494758606,
-0.07339077442884445,
0.8064870834350586,
-0.17179688811302185,
0.3654279410839081,
0.2032114714384079,
-0.2674999535083771,
-0.40751913189888,
-0.754681408405304,
1.025065302848816,
0.715141773223877,
0.4034144878387451,
-0.11720594763755798,
-0.010389585047960281,
0.4303048551082611,
0.7608285546302795,
-0.68414705991745,
-0.28441011905670166,
0.178550586104393,
-0.8402777910232544,
-0.45915934443473816,
0.23340708017349243,
-1.2306385040283203,
-0.44168055057525635,
-0.3330790400505066,
0.03847174346446991,
-0.28634950518608093,
-0.21021027863025665,
-0.11223045736551285,
-0.3319734036922455,
0.06679821014404297,
0.3029348850250244,
-0.6294432878494263,
0.5164588689804077,
0.7664962410926819,
0.9139910340309143,
-0.19695915281772614,
0.08892032504081726,
-0.19296389818191528,
-0.5817497372627258,
-0.1832619160413742,
0.8817914128303528,
-1.1084816455841064,
-0.42331168055534363,
0.13598309457302094,
-0.25383949279785156,
-0.21570850908756256,
-0.6402895450592041,
0.8674150705337524,
-0.7604917883872986,
0.2966043949127197,
-0.006586646195501089,
-0.4813961386680603,
-0.5314299464225769,
0.25964346528053284,
-0.7028900980949402,
1.0365586280822754,
0.244532510638237,
-0.8540570735931396,
0.23277547955513,
-1.0625090599060059,
-0.43806192278862,
-0.17334158718585968,
0.07072117924690247,
-0.5917976498603821,
0.7036274671554565,
0.14149270951747894,
0.6408309936523438,
-0.381613165140152,
-0.07269947230815887,
-0.5720904469490051,
-0.32501938939094543,
0.5374743342399597,
-0.4803891181945801,
0.4075961709022522,
0.15507780015468597,
-0.34688758850097656,
0.23525163531303406,
-0.7344681024551392,
0.1838683784008026,
0.06812072545289993,
-0.10562296211719513,
-0.3540481925010681,
0.013398528099060059,
0.3111407160758972,
0.28705039620399475,
0.0257496889680624,
-0.5423892140388489,
-0.04090080037713051,
-0.3736378252506256,
0.6810997128486633,
0.6052622199058533,
0.10743193328380585,
0.38168999552726746,
-0.07116691768169403,
0.6019245386123657,
0.02838851884007454,
0.37212279438972473,
0.1334727555513382,
-0.6121447086334229,
-0.5721256136894226,
-0.20410753786563873,
0.35330361127853394,
0.3988400995731354,
-0.045077260583639145,
0.36049193143844604,
-0.38632434606552124,
-0.6845449805259705,
-0.7304041385650635,
-0.033692389726638794,
0.18966396152973175,
0.4413054585456848,
0.4819624125957489,
-0.2596825659275055,
-0.6323314309120178,
-0.9603917002677917,
-0.35663801431655884,
-0.20471911132335663,
-0.07875088602304459,
0.43605494499206543,
0.5263926982879639,
-0.46505385637283325,
0.973332405090332,
-0.43572068214416504,
-0.07694035023450851,
-0.05290679633617401,
0.7007126808166504,
0.06016683951020241,
0.09739819169044495,
0.3479355275630951,
-0.7955538630485535,
-0.566018283367157,
0.060302190482616425,
-0.8290796875953674,
0.10427393019199371,
0.155038520693779,
0.039784371852874756,
0.48161622881889343,
-0.008110006339848042,
-0.5945248007774353,
0.3715115189552307,
0.7361342310905457,
0.13343419134616852,
0.41194236278533936,
0.051581185311079025,
0.2919275760650635,
-0.8158252835273743,
0.1438874900341034,
0.2688097655773163,
-0.19806833565235138,
-0.46170172095298767,
-0.20049254596233368,
0.10675421357154846,
-0.0972452461719513,
-0.37468743324279785,
0.16864582896232605,
-0.1162271499633789,
-0.06144586578011513,
-0.1017865389585495,
0.2014942169189453,
-0.021486597135663033,
0.42038246989250183,
0.09205136448144913,
0.6203945875167847,
0.27033326029777527,
-0.4258679747581482,
0.3875780403614044,
-0.14381414651870728,
-0.25741344690322876,
0.6454432010650635,
-0.7108986973762512,
0.38070163130760193,
-0.0033763821702450514,
0.22440125048160553,
-1.3229565620422363,
-0.3853626847267151,
0.21490409970283508,
-0.7131406664848328,
0.05952280014753342,
-0.04085705056786537,
-0.41709306836128235,
-0.5939124822616577,
-0.7160053849220276,
-0.02255670726299286,
0.601885974407196,
-0.3243007957935333,
0.8442913293838501,
0.4384300708770752,
-0.30375945568084717,
-0.3547842800617218,
-0.5053331851959229,
0.11407114565372467,
-0.38279131054878235,
-0.6251123547554016,
-0.03521480783820152,
-0.003344114637002349,
-0.374133825302124,
0.17570540308952332,
0.06218462437391281,
-0.2707878649234772,
0.136880025267601,
0.5027028918266296,
0.33406031131744385,
0.14831525087356567,
0.2506261169910431,
-0.22366128861904144,
-0.1276944875717163,
0.25103405117988586,
0.008321484550833702,
0.522282063961029,
-0.4778027832508087,
-0.09680355340242386,
-0.566079318523407,
0.03708446025848389,
0.7419470548629761,
-0.2616656422615051,
0.5936247706413269,
0.6223909854888916,
-0.2238396853208542,
-0.28919175267219543,
-0.4289409816265106,
-0.031695954501628876,
-0.29537656903266907,
0.4316408336162567,
0.14232631027698517,
-0.9121212959289551,
0.5872904062271118,
-0.02110106684267521,
-0.035745665431022644,
0.5717796087265015,
0.6025843620300293,
-0.25173360109329224,
1.150412917137146,
0.5945481657981873,
-0.4580044746398926,
0.5371227860450745,
-0.18533867597579956,
0.3820398449897766,
-0.7735763788223267,
0.13828277587890625,
-0.6614362001419067,
-0.37623533606529236,
-0.7908293604850769,
-0.5194395184516907,
0.0960204154253006,
-0.4660557210445404,
0.10130578279495239,
0.05785524100065231,
-0.5731745958328247,
0.34459564089775085,
0.38267725706100464,
-0.046515628695487976,
0.09030579030513763,
0.09298752248287201,
0.3532961308956146,
-0.19084492325782776,
-0.462787389755249,
-0.9642073512077332,
1.3799748420715332,
0.5212711691856384,
0.6287345290184021,
-0.05972198396921158,
0.5405029058456421,
0.6402730941772461,
0.6646541357040405,
-0.7812206149101257,
0.5526588559150696,
-0.45739617943763733,
-0.3332022428512573,
-0.1394849568605423,
-0.46588513255119324,
-0.6055358648300171,
0.035671666264534,
-0.053478412330150604,
-0.5580176115036011,
-0.16769243776798248,
-0.012629075907170773,
-0.37160536646842957,
0.15424399077892303,
-0.8234561681747437,
0.9356829524040222,
0.06837330758571625,
-0.38486960530281067,
-0.3707093894481659,
-0.7619640827178955,
0.3230651319026947,
0.047181256115436554,
0.13097788393497467,
0.21679489314556122,
0.1446150243282318,
0.930934488773346,
-0.1979653537273407,
0.7824916839599609,
-0.24442613124847412,
0.08068470656871796,
0.3911501169204712,
-0.2590187191963196,
0.39318570494651794,
0.07481541484594345,
-0.14852046966552734,
0.44940051436424255,
-0.33229461312294006,
-0.08842460066080093,
-0.6705799102783203,
0.7198105454444885,
-0.7866773009300232,
0.08137891441583633,
-0.19749410450458527,
-0.22829851508140564,
-0.274991512298584,
-0.10708107054233551,
0.1598712056875229,
0.12372546643018723,
-0.4277264475822449,
0.34251853823661804,
0.6344823241233826,
0.039959363639354706,
0.4321649372577667,
0.18468697369098663,
-0.04995635524392128,
-0.570030689239502,
0.9487155675888062,
0.11208838224411011,
0.028860872611403465,
0.17918813228607178,
0.10972477495670319,
-0.3986590504646301,
-0.3405236601829529,
-0.3949834406375885,
0.10156546533107758,
-0.6615632176399231,
-0.2274627983570099,
-0.6144499182701111,
0.14263349771499634,
-0.298671156167984,
0.010373996570706367,
-0.4617297351360321,
-0.2855733633041382,
-0.21718409657478333,
-0.13167418539524078,
0.12181015312671661,
0.8712567687034607,
0.2769124507904053,
0.26323962211608887,
-0.9199313521385193,
0.30678823590278625,
0.4353480339050293,
0.5876544117927551,
0.009379943832755089,
-0.3853771984577179,
-0.29824286699295044,
-0.009027384221553802,
-0.28737950325012207,
-0.676805317401886,
0.30038172006607056,
-0.022513343021273613,
0.12954039871692657,
0.3534119725227356,
0.010740364901721478,
0.7156499624252319,
-0.17368623614311218,
0.9328888654708862,
-0.0435483418405056,
-0.8075017929077148,
0.5902921557426453,
-0.34976744651794434,
0.0846882238984108,
0.6135044693946838,
0.23088620603084564,
-0.3840193450450897,
-0.5445917844772339,
-0.6993952393531799,
-0.8488782048225403,
0.5546951293945312,
0.38512352108955383,
0.23143866658210754,
-0.19703660905361176,
0.14132651686668396,
0.09612671285867691,
0.333538293838501,
-0.7263223528862,
-0.002510964637622237,
-0.0432540625333786,
-0.4108837842941284,
-0.008884730748832226,
-0.3291984796524048,
-0.11400651931762695,
0.06739926338195801,
0.6616610288619995,
0.02016783505678177,
0.5186923742294312,
0.009696854278445244,
-0.2797520160675049,
-0.2879301905632019,
0.37413346767425537,
0.555295467376709,
0.4223978519439697,
-0.44126221537590027,
-0.16863195598125458,
0.06017856299877167,
-0.2938914895057678,
-0.2201855182647705,
0.05401945486664772,
-0.08829201757907867,
0.23844940960407257,
0.3300706148147583,
0.7310590744018555,
0.1835496872663498,
-0.6902963519096375,
0.41244104504585266,
-0.582765519618988,
0.025974150747060776,
-0.20850501954555511,
0.012046358548104763,
0.08152362704277039,
0.19408200681209564,
-0.02825998142361641,
0.42042407393455505,
0.3084172010421753,
-0.3890255391597748,
-0.08580023795366287,
0.49643880128860474,
-0.6862331628799438,
-0.5117670297622681,
0.29952487349510193,
0.195139080286026,
-0.18409688770771027,
0.5154211521148682,
-0.010816848836839199,
-0.47860780358314514,
0.48698270320892334,
0.13379549980163574,
1.337819218635559,
0.06761258840560913,
0.3055240511894226,
0.16198204457759857,
0.1407032012939453,
-0.0998784750699997,
0.16342481970787048,
-0.04560956731438637,
-0.34906384348869324,
-0.3900902569293976,
-0.73103266954422,
-0.7231959104537964,
-0.004010293632745743,
-0.9738781452178955,
0.04831814020872116,
-0.4821476340293884,
-0.6198254823684692,
-0.037342362105846405,
-0.034873414784669876,
-0.6696189045906067,
0.476937860250473,
0.21726639568805695,
0.7434426546096802,
-0.9861049056053162,
0.21694348752498627,
1.1671664714813232,
-0.27895981073379517,
-0.3767998218536377,
0.19914031028747559,
-0.0716763436794281,
-0.27928078174591064,
0.7299310564994812,
0.4529758095741272,
-0.5060821175575256,
-0.2408575713634491,
-0.4363791048526764,
-0.23913531005382538,
0.5303194522857666,
0.08125420659780502,
-0.38506343960762024,
0.4634639322757721,
0.08749706298112869,
1.1217947006225586,
-0.39287102222442627,
0.5704330801963806,
0.5175946354866028,
0.43448057770729065,
-0.20804592967033386,
-0.614034116268158,
-0.4975421130657196,
-0.5023350119590759,
0.23119938373565674,
0.19294235110282898,
-0.6046118140220642,
0.5704662799835205,
0.19360573589801788,
-0.12517370283603668,
-0.18856734037399292,
0.6676908731460571,
-0.07245559245347977,
0.2242613136768341,
0.4041217863559723,
0.8987254500389099,
0.8476325869560242,
-0.15404480695724487,
1.1262987852096558,
-0.3762102723121643,
0.7500202059745789,
1.0336154699325562,
-0.41773054003715515,
1.1475425958633423,
0.3099096715450287,
-0.5289267897605896,
0.8400857448577881,
0.45654547214508057,
0.08560007065534592,
0.3074142038822174,
0.12854932248592377,
-0.25787606835365295,
-0.12772078812122345,
-0.03751427307724953,
-0.14241649210453033,
0.37586939334869385,
0.09917362779378891,
-0.430969774723053,
-0.15134944021701813,
0.028675148263573647,
0.1565074473619461,
0.17260882258415222,
-0.28175121545791626,
1.0481075048446655,
-0.22910349071025848,
-0.6299583911895752,
0.12912245094776154,
-0.1248292401432991,
0.5988577008247375,
-0.550543487071991,
-0.0014426886336877942,
-0.19070814549922943,
0.42500439286231995,
-0.26754310727119446,
-0.7697413563728333,
0.495996356010437,
0.551341712474823,
-0.39869189262390137,
-0.15389762818813324,
0.9244790077209473,
0.14022740721702576,
-0.6828760504722595,
0.45985376834869385,
0.1642715036869049,
-0.04204238951206207,
-0.2117275595664978,
-0.6107142567634583,
0.20248985290527344,
-0.16541577875614166,
-0.6387394070625305,
0.3273705542087555,
0.4166842997074127,
0.053065236657857895,
0.5587261915206909,
0.5536009073257446,
-0.037167347967624664,
-0.05053963512182236,
0.1912398636341095,
0.9435116648674011,
-0.8153296113014221,
-0.3922572731971741,
-1.1568922996520996,
0.7162621021270752,
-0.3213578462600708,
-0.21475090086460114,
0.9748844504356384,
0.4934614896774292,
0.7745068669319153,
-0.33212602138519287,
1.0950170755386353,
0.06756671518087387,
0.8470786213874817,
-0.17315219342708588,
0.41384822130203247,
-0.34978756308555603,
-0.01869097910821438,
-0.636567234992981,
-0.868725597858429,
-0.6635070443153381,
0.9171231985092163,
-0.5923888087272644,
0.2839764654636383,
0.4613136053085327,
0.5439393520355225,
0.16727691888809204,
0.4790049195289612,
-0.05251036584377289,
0.1956261694431305,
0.32406818866729736,
0.3092662990093231,
0.9108524322509766,
-0.35668355226516724,
0.3560015559196472,
-0.36562538146972656,
-0.24995730817317963,
-0.47748664021492004,
-0.9229600429534912,
-0.8252917528152466,
-0.13867101073265076,
-0.2854918837547302,
-0.2665309011936188,
-0.004866031464189291,
0.7363580465316772,
0.5489863753318787,
-0.8465334177017212,
-0.2753087282180786,
-0.1370580643415451,
0.11912152171134949,
-0.292135089635849,
-0.3036111295223236,
0.23852799832820892,
-0.669104814529419,
-0.7688434720039368,
0.019960377365350723,
0.6267693042755127,
-0.3811693489551544,
-0.1752634197473526,
-0.08864819258451462,
0.11761606484651566,
0.0795067548751831,
0.773889422416687,
-0.030649177730083466,
-0.4826192855834961,
-0.3116878271102905,
0.1494375765323639,
-0.055766429752111435,
0.17227396368980408,
0.5394636988639832,
-0.6398352980613708,
0.5816596746444702,
0.6062079668045044,
0.6466612219810486,
0.1083168312907219,
0.44732922315597534,
0.24575412273406982,
-0.4427405595779419,
-0.2840127646923065,
0.28494396805763245,
0.14547276496887207,
0.3598301410675049,
0.07765809446573257,
0.5088116526603699,
0.1760067492723465,
-0.7944028377532959,
-0.8682079315185547,
-0.009797700680792332,
-0.9642343521118164,
-0.0431353822350502,
0.8058174252510071,
-0.30939605832099915,
-0.2552390694618225,
0.19858689606189728,
-0.22853562235832214,
0.17958548665046692,
-0.5105623006820679,
1.0060480833053589,
0.915364682674408,
-0.38641470670700073,
0.07139172405004501,
-0.6410681009292603,
0.24968770146369934,
0.4697856307029724,
-0.8964736461639404,
0.45413851737976074,
0.6963158845901489,
-0.03821500018239021,
0.3627719283103943,
0.3169863224029541,
-0.2331547737121582,
0.34083566069602966,
-0.4211902916431427,
0.05237638205289841,
0.2503117024898529,
-0.31453636288642883,
-0.7667989134788513,
0.7814563512802124,
-0.02987162582576275,
-0.19404105842113495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16806v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16806v2
|
Entity Alignment with Noisy Annotations from Large Language Models
| 2024-05-27T03:52:55 | 2024-05-28T07:50:18 |
Shengyuan Chen, Qinggang Zhang, Junnan Dong, Wen Hua, Qing Li, Xiao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity alignment (EA) aims to merge two knowledge graphs (KGs) by identifying
equivalent entity pairs. While existing methods heavily rely on human-generated
labels, it is prohibitively expensive to incorporate cross-domain experts for
annotation in real-world scenarios. The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs)
presents new avenues for automating EA with annotations, inspired by their
comprehensive capability to process semantic information. However, it is
nontrivial to directly apply LLMs for EA since the annotation space in
real-world KGs is large. LLMs could also generate noisy labels that may mislead
the alignment. To this end, we propose a unified framework, LLM4EA, to
effectively leverage LLMs for EA. Specifically, we design a novel active
learning policy to significantly reduce the annotation space by prioritizing
the most valuable entities based on the entire inter-KG and intra-KG structure.
Moreover, we introduce an unsupervised label refiner to continuously enhance
label accuracy through in-depth probabilistic reasoning. We iteratively
optimize the policy based on the feedback from a base EA model. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the advantages of LLM4EA on four benchmark datasets in
terms of effectiveness, robustness, and efficiency. Codes are available via
https://github.com/chensyCN/llm4ea_official.
|
[
-0.29610109329223633,
-0.5710636973381042,
0.6325690746307373,
0.06551574170589447,
-0.08981023728847504,
0.014437511563301086,
-0.44264549016952515,
-0.8413376212120056,
0.25636807084083557,
0.6799068450927734,
-0.3503588140010834,
-0.6928926110267639,
-0.34814831614494324,
0.0822826698422432,
-0.21939030289649963,
0.9046032428741455,
-0.3928077518939972,
-0.22853799164295197,
-0.13338734209537506,
-0.33954429626464844,
-0.22235415875911713,
-0.17616283893585205,
-0.5829633474349976,
-0.3044132888317108,
0.6127170324325562,
0.35543712973594666,
0.846817135810852,
0.8562421798706055,
0.3673262894153595,
0.32115837931632996,
0.05198069289326668,
0.4958459138870239,
-0.38420015573501587,
0.2721328139305115,
-0.17251421511173248,
-0.2380768060684204,
-0.7077640891075134,
-0.17284372448921204,
0.7299266457557678,
0.7339262366294861,
-0.12981586158275604,
0.05509397014975548,
0.013655449263751507,
0.21924054622650146,
-0.5215544104576111,
0.409828245639801,
-0.7791916728019714,
-0.24681246280670166,
-0.33747896552085876,
0.2183447927236557,
-0.3487466275691986,
-0.17388767004013062,
0.09956343472003937,
-0.9695600271224976,
-0.09459300339221954,
0.14822880923748016,
1.2794064283370972,
0.4492129683494568,
-0.43765437602996826,
-0.06237896904349327,
-0.6381972432136536,
0.751120924949646,
-0.6119822859764099,
0.7349570989608765,
0.22995533049106598,
-0.16538207232952118,
-0.2381594330072403,
-0.78704833984375,
-0.583411693572998,
0.21749959886074066,
0.06446662545204163,
-0.022309284657239914,
-0.3010421097278595,
0.21673254668712616,
-0.03402559086680412,
0.06495244055986404,
-0.24341990053653717,
0.6369217038154602,
-0.06640797108411789,
-0.46213969588279724,
0.6919962167739868,
-0.12176649272441864,
0.13527648150920868,
0.46827414631843567,
-0.5635590553283691,
0.23228806257247925,
-0.7803909778594971,
-0.2951180040836334,
0.5689378380775452,
0.27337029576301575,
0.34464776515960693,
0.5011636018753052,
-0.03279076889157295,
0.6682478785514832,
0.16451701521873474,
-0.3040885031223297,
0.5383492112159729,
-0.11056406050920486,
-0.09987157583236694,
0.19021758437156677,
0.8298721313476562,
0.3228580057621002,
0.17615097761154175,
-0.6347526907920837,
-0.424957811832428,
-0.052728015929460526,
0.35782045125961304,
-0.7736105918884277,
-0.31571516394615173,
0.2511501908302307,
-0.007209157571196556,
-0.24203677475452423,
-0.1013515293598175,
-0.6029396653175354,
-0.2512285113334656,
-0.5354609489440918,
0.35689350962638855,
-0.21424362063407898,
-0.22386997938156128,
-0.13556905090808868,
0.5302137136459351,
0.0029742950573563576,
0.4466187655925751,
-0.7817617654800415,
0.09463547170162201,
0.5906849503517151,
0.45041465759277344,
-0.35302218794822693,
-0.36528095602989197,
-0.3924453556537628,
0.7515040636062622,
-0.288534551858902,
0.7458986043930054,
-0.5608741641044617,
0.05299719050526619,
0.11619868129491806,
0.20881912112236023,
0.22051845490932465,
-0.5925700664520264,
0.5937168598175049,
-0.8558780550956726,
-0.12661917507648468,
-0.19117477536201477,
-0.7382850646972656,
-0.4178381860256195,
0.1333623230457306,
-0.8276687264442444,
1.031811237335205,
-0.1728850156068802,
-0.5223502516746521,
0.534795880317688,
-0.6209785342216492,
-0.38660573959350586,
0.12355230748653412,
-0.24076369404792786,
-0.8095456957817078,
-0.37479162216186523,
0.37369871139526367,
0.42441418766975403,
-0.15277992188930511,
0.5381021499633789,
-0.5328834056854248,
-0.1364426463842392,
0.18871548771858215,
-0.3764249086380005,
0.5226837992668152,
0.2259989231824875,
-0.4383542835712433,
0.21786987781524658,
-0.7839449644088745,
0.04178853705525398,
0.016827581450343132,
-0.4229462444782257,
-0.32436612248420715,
-0.15204136073589325,
-0.2587752640247345,
-0.05423133820295334,
0.5320841670036316,
-0.36256784200668335,
0.3983566164970398,
-0.23590290546417236,
0.1985371708869934,
0.7901726961135864,
0.09012676030397415,
0.7851854562759399,
0.1390313357114792,
0.32696276903152466,
0.008680732920765877,
-0.052461475133895874,
0.1627015322446823,
-0.47405776381492615,
-0.47444072365760803,
-0.6714765429496765,
0.6008538007736206,
0.4828903079032898,
-0.5782763957977295,
0.5696436166763306,
-0.40783610939979553,
-0.23569072782993317,
-0.8736355900764465,
0.636911153793335,
0.281646192073822,
0.5401824712753296,
0.5100401043891907,
-0.19679173827171326,
-0.2920844256877899,
-0.9800604581832886,
-0.05109112709760666,
-0.21225371956825256,
0.07506811618804932,
0.12485289573669434,
0.03288746625185013,
-0.3452214300632477,
0.7493571639060974,
-0.3271501362323761,
-0.5682286024093628,
0.03457652032375336,
0.06122224032878876,
-0.12441056966781616,
0.23313367366790771,
0.41803205013275146,
-0.7209904193878174,
-0.22149577736854553,
-0.08588995784521103,
-0.6354479789733887,
-0.5925654172897339,
-0.08533311635255814,
-0.5027406811714172,
0.25873515009880066,
0.5003941655158997,
-0.67275071144104,
0.12500512599945068,
0.5341041088104248,
-0.144404798746109,
-0.022487683221697807,
0.12383042275905609,
-0.09252502769231796,
-0.9301995038986206,
-0.03461310639977455,
0.041867610067129135,
-0.13591116666793823,
-0.3496372401714325,
-0.0069354563020169735,
0.0747326910495758,
0.10308356583118439,
-0.23711101710796356,
0.5138477683067322,
-0.9407715797424316,
-0.15967601537704468,
-0.07889591157436371,
0.41921254992485046,
0.22690263390541077,
0.5231106877326965,
0.10927240550518036,
0.5539137721061707,
0.4261857569217682,
-0.5154734253883362,
0.3158595561981201,
0.29870104789733887,
-0.18845409154891968,
0.40452641248703003,
-0.10986248403787613,
0.04123229160904884,
-0.040478140115737915,
0.40839940309524536,
-0.7150560021400452,
-0.0441129133105278,
0.23204217851161957,
-0.0681079551577568,
0.8104081749916077,
-0.1657732129096985,
-0.4707409739494324,
-0.17322976887226105,
-0.06850118190050125,
0.3681059181690216,
0.17651844024658203,
-0.7502405643463135,
0.7575691938400269,
0.773052990436554,
0.028383001685142517,
-0.815178394317627,
-0.6281736493110657,
0.19130659103393555,
-0.194915771484375,
-0.522971510887146,
0.5930660963058472,
0.08397943526506424,
-0.23784056305885315,
0.4830091893672943,
-0.34190818667411804,
-0.07740580290555954,
0.17205166816711426,
0.2878366708755493,
0.36181026697158813,
-0.2017347365617752,
0.1973983645439148,
-0.062125809490680695,
-0.12453454732894897,
-0.017670102417469025,
-0.5882185697555542,
-0.0043441904708743095,
0.06938181072473526,
-0.43863582611083984,
-0.4592028856277466,
-0.0025474759750068188,
0.4951362907886505,
-0.4169389009475708,
0.6655051708221436,
0.6432402729988098,
-0.5060072541236877,
-0.22353237867355347,
-0.7192487716674805,
-0.06723632663488388,
-0.42968684434890747,
0.5118547081947327,
-0.3576716184616089,
-0.7422645688056946,
0.4769452214241028,
-0.25249963998794556,
0.6574199199676514,
0.3541553020477295,
0.562609076499939,
-0.019076624885201454,
0.8779988884925842,
0.39898431301116943,
-0.17707550525665283,
0.4432508647441864,
-0.1814589947462082,
0.5382854342460632,
-0.7348030209541321,
-0.3267935514450073,
-0.3161744475364685,
-0.44772207736968994,
-0.3918811082839966,
-0.40272197127342224,
-0.07450071722269058,
0.25783392786979675,
-0.21388404071331024,
0.19019244611263275,
-0.4963269829750061,
0.4692077040672302,
0.2559203505516052,
-0.11865892261266708,
0.24523577094078064,
0.02374952845275402,
-0.09356985986232758,
-0.08851799368858337,
-0.5866414904594421,
-0.6244068741798401,
0.976516842842102,
0.4957684278488159,
0.7444547414779663,
0.4185188114643097,
0.9043552279472351,
-0.07695320248603821,
0.7786927223205566,
-0.697067379951477,
0.5222465395927429,
0.10446715354919434,
-0.529836893081665,
-0.5672351121902466,
-0.45320427417755127,
-1.1024914979934692,
0.19173042476177216,
-0.35515302419662476,
-0.7107243537902832,
0.09251691401004791,
0.21038860082626343,
-0.28875845670700073,
0.6380853652954102,
-0.6600282788276672,
0.7821788787841797,
-0.4188304841518402,
-0.6513100862503052,
0.35401222109794617,
-0.43899327516555786,
0.2928149104118347,
-0.36422455310821533,
0.32074758410453796,
-0.23352977633476257,
-0.42385295033454895,
0.6891419887542725,
-0.38267192244529724,
0.802854061126709,
-0.1765379011631012,
-0.47637027502059937,
0.5414908528327942,
-0.02025126852095127,
0.8870982527732849,
-0.03272775560617447,
-0.042659416794776917,
0.40173035860061646,
-0.495603084564209,
-0.336769700050354,
-0.4964347183704376,
0.9804425239562988,
-0.8288716673851013,
-0.49173691868782043,
-0.15003734827041626,
-0.5455876588821411,
-0.40772300958633423,
0.35641059279441833,
-0.023464582860469818,
0.10998848080635071,
0.07938089966773987,
-0.0939842164516449,
0.7389969229698181,
0.09449433535337448,
0.293460875749588,
0.7369003295898438,
-0.23815873265266418,
-0.47966697812080383,
0.8607760071754456,
0.41651496291160583,
0.07619518786668777,
0.3393304944038391,
-0.3271419107913971,
-0.5505241751670837,
-0.6981915235519409,
-0.5228700041770935,
0.34356123208999634,
-0.8164035677909851,
-0.5912985801696777,
-0.8343066573143005,
0.06435617804527283,
-0.47411859035491943,
-0.14991027116775513,
-0.4704764485359192,
-0.28566962480545044,
-0.3518929183483124,
-0.4335232973098755,
0.3583269417285919,
0.6250221133232117,
0.0922846794128418,
0.04362108185887337,
-0.6520619988441467,
0.12480996549129486,
0.2803063988685608,
0.4454999566078186,
-0.07070360332727432,
-0.39301425218582153,
-0.2270796000957489,
-0.08606710284948349,
-0.3340296149253845,
-0.9501550197601318,
0.1137213259935379,
0.1390935331583023,
0.7684106826782227,
0.5063363909721375,
0.13764235377311707,
0.7525606155395508,
-0.44494912028312683,
0.48461341857910156,
0.07556086033582687,
-0.7088751196861267,
0.06433679908514023,
-0.035724833607673645,
-0.04872302711009979,
0.6159854531288147,
0.3272762894630432,
0.06870201975107193,
-0.6210097670555115,
-0.735172688961029,
-1.4221665859222412,
0.4262789487838745,
0.047261156141757965,
-0.24452613294124603,
-0.03599155321717262,
0.47415339946746826,
-0.12469831109046936,
0.10900738090276718,
-0.7848909497261047,
-0.2543646991252899,
0.18208561837673187,
-0.5815230011940002,
0.20867490768432617,
-0.13017772138118744,
-0.19195252656936646,
0.044804155826568604,
1.253490924835205,
-0.19798342883586884,
-0.048985108733177185,
-0.05451623722910881,
-0.23686666786670685,
-0.4818198084831238,
0.09430529177188873,
0.13104495406150818,
0.5136923789978027,
0.0792599692940712,
0.23920796811580658,
0.38257932662963867,
-0.26772692799568176,
0.1421428918838501,
0.3084692358970642,
-0.3748583197593689,
-0.005412285216152668,
0.40362632274627686,
0.7321326732635498,
0.5688830614089966,
-0.3411612808704376,
0.5517054796218872,
0.22047297656536102,
-0.27281343936920166,
-0.3288241922855377,
-0.1439589411020279,
0.3944114148616791,
0.35396111011505127,
0.07434806227684021,
-0.16843944787979126,
-0.01803797297179699,
-0.2784769535064697,
0.30543145537376404,
0.39527565240859985,
-0.2675512135028839,
-0.2689531445503235,
0.9132491946220398,
0.4744929373264313,
-0.05453003942966461,
0.5868130326271057,
-0.3427319824695587,
-0.5851568579673767,
0.2891394793987274,
0.424060195684433,
0.6785197257995605,
-0.21788670122623444,
-0.1357327103614807,
0.2377297580242157,
0.4083101749420166,
-0.19995976984500885,
0.02411072328686714,
0.1221487745642662,
-0.9530726671218872,
-0.6819888353347778,
-0.7309406995773315,
-0.2768929600715637,
0.23067469894886017,
-0.5195301175117493,
0.461821973323822,
-0.11569388210773468,
-0.1996648609638214,
0.22057905793190002,
0.07863933593034744,
-0.7450389862060547,
0.011883489787578583,
0.3211275339126587,
0.5665391087532043,
-0.863739013671875,
0.9734775424003601,
0.9933633208274841,
-0.6279212832450867,
-1.151861310005188,
0.015692589804530144,
0.02639845386147499,
-0.837766170501709,
0.4560829699039459,
0.07365521043539047,
0.09039577841758728,
0.1690363734960556,
-0.45806676149368286,
-0.9932600259780884,
1.339791178703308,
0.45395466685295105,
-0.9588457345962524,
-0.10571548342704773,
-0.15036144852638245,
0.3361838459968567,
-0.3082863688468933,
-0.08615759760141373,
0.4092620015144348,
0.7598301768302917,
0.08518620580434799,
-0.7429628372192383,
0.12514306604862213,
0.1394413411617279,
-0.29296526312828064,
0.7728430032730103,
-0.7456042170524597,
0.21058684587478638,
-0.26599007844924927,
-0.12236692756414413,
-0.2714650332927704,
0.9904816150665283,
0.20727728307247162,
0.3095615804195404,
0.6717569231987,
0.9616644382476807,
1.0776385068893433,
-0.15814794600009918,
0.5900405049324036,
-0.4356887936592102,
0.13342739641666412,
1.14876127243042,
-0.7329252362251282,
0.5892131328582764,
0.48519155383110046,
-0.07634218782186508,
0.304064005613327,
0.5900132060050964,
-0.14130201935768127,
0.34681591391563416,
0.15388929843902588,
-0.23378194868564606,
-0.32860419154167175,
-0.0914052426815033,
0.10550663620233536,
0.30851972103118896,
0.2648817300796509,
-0.2944055199623108,
-0.11245714873075485,
-0.2895757257938385,
0.3733181059360504,
0.018098117783665657,
-0.23315013945102692,
0.9222960472106934,
-0.01941991038620472,
-0.6917785406112671,
0.287945032119751,
-0.12583404779434204,
0.4363453686237335,
-0.4652014970779419,
-0.1396482139825821,
0.02962430939078331,
0.09030165523290634,
-0.360597163438797,
-0.8233668804168701,
0.06340250372886658,
-0.08710768073797226,
-0.0906905010342598,
-0.27896928787231445,
0.5428566336631775,
-0.9697465896606445,
-0.2052682340145111,
0.5209289789199829,
0.24118022620677948,
0.2615586221218109,
0.2834315598011017,
-0.7895867824554443,
0.15709270536899567,
0.16575196385383606,
-0.47249966859817505,
0.3646981418132782,
0.9139604568481445,
-0.478487104177475,
0.4794706404209137,
0.6315368413925171,
0.2431531697511673,
0.012549493461847305,
0.21173648536205292,
0.73935866355896,
-0.26041358709335327,
-0.30319052934646606,
-0.5576202273368835,
0.24852138757705688,
-0.12441740185022354,
-0.035426490008831024,
0.4995766580104828,
0.6161710619926453,
0.8862547874450684,
0.5555530190467834,
0.5559800267219543,
0.2853028178215027,
0.25101515650749207,
-0.547648012638092,
0.4745439887046814,
-0.5812121629714966,
0.6395418643951416,
-0.2618521749973297,
-1.3682589530944824,
-0.41358792781829834,
0.48194676637649536,
-0.15810205042362213,
-0.02719583734869957,
0.4325580894947052,
0.7904955148696899,
-0.05459561198949814,
-0.25954657793045044,
0.2734522521495819,
0.4162481725215912,
0.39313656091690063,
0.3464987874031067,
0.38473236560821533,
-0.12237526476383209,
0.799934446811676,
-0.22820256650447845,
-0.18427999317646027,
0.018392052501440048,
-0.8929669857025146,
-0.5370205640792847,
-0.4479134678840637,
-0.7188578844070435,
-0.4605412185192108,
-0.00555450702086091,
0.9499919414520264,
0.42898085713386536,
-0.6431800723075867,
0.3019258379936218,
0.164886474609375,
0.05087120831012726,
-0.10030883550643921,
-0.22664791345596313,
0.5704226493835449,
-0.24718250334262848,
-0.8497249484062195,
0.37468358874320984,
0.2558092176914215,
0.14356961846351624,
-0.2052721381187439,
-0.16575756669044495,
-0.19038936495780945,
0.022800149396061897,
0.1749858409166336,
0.2669018805027008,
-0.9071523547172546,
-0.4050365388393402,
-0.33341214060783386,
-0.18358264863491058,
-0.12370800226926804,
0.4254627525806427,
-0.48629212379455566,
0.3401334285736084,
0.12336760759353638,
1.0108996629714966,
0.3613393306732178,
0.07016468793153763,
0.39803358912467957,
-0.7385599613189697,
0.04948176443576813,
0.27591627836227417,
0.5716608762741089,
0.48235055804252625,
-0.4388684034347534,
0.707343578338623,
0.106015644967556,
-0.7171596884727478,
-0.9363948702812195,
0.15768080949783325,
-0.859731912612915,
-0.19206352531909943,
1.3712708950042725,
-0.41229408979415894,
-0.33199483156204224,
-0.15866036713123322,
-0.04153572767972946,
0.4502933621406555,
-0.5851584076881409,
0.6200962662696838,
0.6526570320129395,
-0.04671384021639824,
0.09488986432552338,
-0.41890397667884827,
0.40494951605796814,
0.4279960095882416,
-0.6118477582931519,
0.19836421310901642,
0.6935941576957703,
0.37383976578712463,
0.24914905428886414,
0.5470843315124512,
-0.1255885809659958,
-0.144330695271492,
-0.32661548256874084,
0.6659663319587708,
-0.20884649455547333,
-0.37060531973838806,
-0.06410379707813263,
0.09575726836919785,
0.36809661984443665,
-0.0866636410355568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16802v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16802v3
|
AutoCV: Empowering Reasoning with Automated Process Labeling via Confidence Variation
| 2024-05-27T03:44:24 | 2024-05-29T01:47:35 |
Jianqiao Lu, Zhiyang Dou, Hongru Wang, Zeyu Cao, Jianbo Dai, Yingjia Wan, Yinya Huang, Zhijiang Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this work, we propose a novel method named \textbf{Auto}mated Process
Labeling via \textbf{C}onfidence \textbf{V}ariation (\textbf{\textsc{AutoCV}})
to enhance the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) by
automatically annotating the reasoning steps. Our approach begins by training a
verification model on the correctness of final answers, enabling it to generate
automatic process annotations. This verification model assigns a confidence
score to each reasoning step, indicating the probability of arriving at the
correct final answer from that point onward. We detect relative changes in the
verification's confidence scores across reasoning steps to automatically
annotate the reasoning process. This alleviates the need for numerous manual
annotations or the high computational costs associated with model-induced
annotation approaches. We experimentally validate that the confidence
variations learned by the verification model trained on the final answer
correctness can effectively identify errors in the reasoning steps.
Subsequently, we demonstrate that the process annotations generated by
\textsc{AutoCV} can improve the accuracy of the verification model in selecting
the correct answer from multiple outputs generated by LLMs. Notably, we achieve
substantial improvements across five datasets in mathematics and commonsense
reasoning. The source code of \textsc{AutoCV} is available at
\url{https://github.com/rookie-joe/AUTOCV}.
|
[
-0.28740689158439636,
-0.7633607983589172,
0.621315062046051,
0.08258763700723648,
-0.08989527076482773,
0.13342025876045227,
-0.06954210996627808,
-0.4488416612148285,
-0.045055877417325974,
0.4137071967124939,
-0.5130518078804016,
-0.5875831842422485,
-0.589776337146759,
0.210667684674263,
-0.09686688333749771,
0.5055248737335205,
-0.4245889186859131,
0.06594237685203552,
-0.6096223592758179,
0.05810001492500305,
-0.17777961492538452,
-0.6463121175765991,
-0.3406187891960144,
-0.38558700680732727,
0.22757017612457275,
0.46061453223228455,
0.6404072046279907,
1.1691066026687622,
0.5037158131599426,
0.3315039277076721,
0.12805692851543427,
0.5197885036468506,
-0.09498826414346695,
0.5988759398460388,
-0.06640630960464478,
-0.5234531164169312,
-0.4200047552585602,
-0.018853863701224327,
0.42473655939102173,
0.4111964702606201,
-0.1539686769247055,
0.140964075922966,
-0.04790664464235306,
0.47342878580093384,
-0.8508189916610718,
0.32438939809799194,
-0.6422790884971619,
-0.0567181333899498,
0.07552312314510345,
-0.2458856999874115,
-0.37899500131607056,
-0.1546206921339035,
-0.06629163771867752,
-0.6324285268783569,
-0.03824960067868233,
0.07921411097049713,
0.8006197214126587,
0.9926435351371765,
-0.19134578108787537,
-0.13371983170509338,
-0.9179264307022095,
0.703748881816864,
-0.5651422142982483,
0.212464839220047,
0.4617798328399658,
0.42940154671669006,
-0.12929685413837433,
-0.7238280177116394,
-0.5456746220588684,
-0.2544051706790924,
0.06406860053539276,
0.0777960792183876,
0.137222558259964,
0.12579530477523804,
0.46789345145225525,
0.4959496557712555,
-0.36345037817955017,
0.013866117224097252,
0.12213234603404999,
-0.501699686050415,
0.7947896718978882,
0.2357298880815506,
0.1656762659549713,
0.11603996902704239,
-0.008511660620570183,
-0.23617461323738098,
-0.4430277943611145,
0.08311386406421661,
0.42002972960472107,
-0.017639050260186195,
0.2023378312587738,
0.5927738547325134,
-0.5735639333724976,
0.7415390610694885,
0.18313442170619965,
0.11661487817764282,
0.32153648138046265,
-0.1767096370458603,
-0.5559127926826477,
-0.12891240417957306,
0.8498109579086304,
-0.03396252542734146,
0.1467672884464264,
0.16407594084739685,
-0.2176179438829422,
-0.029238183051347733,
0.10611981153488159,
-0.6047115325927734,
-0.4967840313911438,
0.20059528946876526,
-0.13668330013751984,
-0.28377798199653625,
0.10290267318487167,
-0.26204150915145874,
-0.28209829330444336,
-0.5330677628517151,
0.3399684727191925,
-0.3023258149623871,
0.11091046035289764,
-0.021553663536906242,
0.1168142706155777,
0.47397875785827637,
0.7019616961479187,
-0.7692314386367798,
0.029834553599357605,
0.6928837299346924,
0.4927609860897064,
-0.2936692535877228,
0.016181448474526405,
-0.6731772422790527,
-0.01063101552426815,
-0.32170337438583374,
0.8296308517456055,
-0.8546550869941711,
-0.19035395979881287,
-0.1695212423801422,
-0.0510576069355011,
0.13756534457206726,
-0.3383009433746338,
0.5075703263282776,
-0.30507418513298035,
-0.06502498686313629,
-0.2092430591583252,
-0.7576907873153687,
0.09514649212360382,
0.3292621076107025,
-0.5175741910934448,
1.4281065464019775,
-0.25886544585227966,
-0.7652738690376282,
0.3230248689651489,
-0.37545326352119446,
-0.23392386734485626,
0.08832146227359772,
-0.38741016387939453,
-0.5601024031639099,
-0.2299281805753708,
0.39669090509414673,
0.4642801284790039,
-0.13043925166130066,
-0.012073677964508533,
-0.6564995050430298,
-0.03023630380630493,
0.545264720916748,
-0.42613840103149414,
0.5884556770324707,
0.35113534331321716,
-0.4311973452568054,
0.19740065932273865,
-0.934684157371521,
0.12883280217647552,
-0.2049083709716797,
-0.06811700016260147,
-0.33642715215682983,
-0.09607990086078644,
-0.5020054578781128,
0.3435037136077881,
0.3798454999923706,
-0.4960257411003113,
0.34795650839805603,
-0.4221375584602356,
0.2287840098142624,
0.6246697306632996,
0.24801397323608398,
0.38403189182281494,
-0.11051841080188751,
0.44380253553390503,
0.018100472167134285,
0.4945737421512604,
-0.411704957485199,
-0.7008272409439087,
-1.118591547012329,
-0.323668897151947,
0.36755993962287903,
0.8808658719062805,
-0.798214316368103,
0.651312530040741,
0.32068386673927307,
-0.5325655937194824,
-0.6518493890762329,
0.20216509699821472,
0.36821457743644714,
0.5223435163497925,
0.39824724197387695,
-0.35849976539611816,
-0.5824722051620483,
-0.9148492813110352,
-0.21143922209739685,
-0.35852399468421936,
-0.020573416724801064,
0.23735156655311584,
0.5682343244552612,
-0.12131084501743317,
0.9720503091812134,
-0.5292428135871887,
0.019428318366408348,
0.3558492660522461,
0.5737292766571045,
-0.11887433379888535,
0.6116554141044617,
-0.15259598195552826,
-0.7365382313728333,
-0.5117735862731934,
-0.12505033612251282,
-0.7173792719841003,
-0.2739720940589905,
-0.22057990729808807,
-0.37113529443740845,
0.5680207014083862,
0.7540154457092285,
-0.011168990284204483,
0.6928973197937012,
0.26401838660240173,
0.026978934183716774,
0.6093516945838928,
-0.5590330362319946,
0.38669541478157043,
-0.8718600273132324,
-0.2297378033399582,
0.07268182933330536,
-0.3921687602996826,
-0.19590041041374207,
-0.20511777698993683,
0.027327585965394974,
0.3890315890312195,
-0.26587584614753723,
0.22202005982398987,
-0.5725197196006775,
0.05232562869787216,
-0.2095315009355545,
-0.22808286547660828,
-0.01449335552752018,
0.3072032034397125,
0.2809749245643616,
0.6233682036399841,
0.7699183225631714,
-0.47857993841171265,
0.67264324426651,
0.04809778183698654,
0.035579729825258255,
0.5213977098464966,
-0.5283289551734924,
0.3130093216896057,
0.0708276703953743,
0.3672836422920227,
-1.3439500331878662,
-0.4905415177345276,
0.40834125876426697,
-0.7836257219314575,
0.19562086462974548,
-0.20682105422019958,
-0.6833148002624512,
-0.34418511390686035,
0.009095996618270874,
0.13785026967525482,
0.5072221159934998,
-0.30768436193466187,
0.8222962617874146,
0.4072961211204529,
-0.04697955399751663,
-0.6064045429229736,
-0.9676277041435242,
-0.03522522374987602,
0.06122477725148201,
-0.5860127210617065,
-0.08933953195810318,
-0.4412972927093506,
-0.2622685432434082,
-0.19291415810585022,
-0.06720294058322906,
-0.48359784483909607,
0.16367027163505554,
0.4474656581878662,
0.5118645429611206,
0.055869340896606445,
0.3533952236175537,
0.23678378760814667,
-0.275607168674469,
0.12542423605918884,
-0.612774670124054,
-0.06515292823314667,
-0.37686458230018616,
-0.5943024754524231,
-0.5536466836929321,
0.26561376452445984,
0.4055210053920746,
-0.28015485405921936,
0.6449214816093445,
0.5299738645553589,
-0.5785727500915527,
-0.10022266209125519,
-0.6575163006782532,
-0.20275668799877167,
-0.4668729901313782,
-0.17866072058677673,
-0.425105482339859,
-0.9177244305610657,
0.5732613801956177,
-0.06788630783557892,
0.055473167449235916,
0.5996335744857788,
0.8421233892440796,
-0.25016751885414124,
1.129509687423706,
0.6023625135421753,
0.3509226441383362,
0.14860215783119202,
0.015204673632979393,
-0.054147977381944656,
-0.5367749333381653,
-0.4280834197998047,
-0.4618283212184906,
0.1611146628856659,
-0.5477451086044312,
-0.9332073926925659,
0.11974962055683136,
-0.11027228832244873,
-0.10461455583572388,
0.13671079277992249,
-0.9690011739730835,
0.5394039154052734,
0.5049527883529663,
-0.13381873071193695,
0.5346612334251404,
-0.2795136570930481,
-0.4300175607204437,
-0.2846938967704773,
-0.6005428433418274,
-0.6261375546455383,
1.0126535892486572,
0.3562421202659607,
0.8431662321090698,
-0.30840760469436646,
0.8852789998054504,
0.3717624545097351,
0.4319961965084076,
-0.763089656829834,
0.3647245764732361,
0.188664510846138,
-0.5047802925109863,
-0.47453755140304565,
-0.4091014862060547,
-0.48804861307144165,
-0.036675773561000824,
-0.3390921652317047,
-0.6972065567970276,
0.24333277344703674,
0.7127130627632141,
-0.5124074220657349,
0.12471548467874527,
-0.5906344652175903,
0.6701858639717102,
-0.2584797739982605,
-0.5111131072044373,
0.15390397608280182,
-0.8051799535751343,
0.3174927830696106,
-0.007394148502498865,
0.07131607830524445,
0.04744928330183029,
-0.09063459932804108,
0.3446120023727417,
-0.6606868505477905,
0.9818423986434937,
0.16083543002605438,
-0.32078060507774353,
0.47236156463623047,
0.10972265899181366,
0.7053612470626831,
0.17348165810108185,
-0.025122230872511864,
-0.06816280633211136,
-0.2608186900615692,
-0.17305037379264832,
-0.6766074895858765,
0.6552572846412659,
-0.608657956123352,
-0.4823843538761139,
-0.6289255619049072,
-0.5065343976020813,
-0.04198586195707321,
-0.0987197756767273,
0.276161253452301,
0.09389573335647583,
0.052903912961483,
-0.004362291190773249,
1.2004210948944092,
-0.14079928398132324,
0.2644076943397522,
0.18970640003681183,
0.10128732025623322,
-0.5942352414131165,
0.58094722032547,
0.09016873687505722,
0.39097511768341064,
0.4419670104980469,
-0.040909867733716965,
-0.36271366477012634,
-0.2776600420475006,
-0.4126051962375641,
0.09016470611095428,
-0.984387218952179,
-0.109588123857975,
-0.7894425392150879,
-0.153466135263443,
-0.6837829351425171,
-0.1692328006029129,
-0.6915550231933594,
-0.6878828406333923,
-0.29113543033599854,
0.04272543638944626,
0.43444424867630005,
0.4737180173397064,
-0.2921614348888397,
0.0045703100040555,
-0.41972875595092773,
0.16166788339614868,
0.6297725439071655,
0.31440702080726624,
-0.41488415002822876,
-0.6417401432991028,
-0.13626660406589508,
-0.04390319809317589,
-0.22499267756938934,
-0.7669477462768555,
0.22365567088127136,
-0.021316329017281532,
0.6145230531692505,
0.13112542033195496,
0.246303990483284,
0.4334779679775238,
-0.22625300288200378,
0.7836045026779175,
0.018723219633102417,
-1.13619065284729,
0.7843027710914612,
-0.1934540569782257,
0.32436269521713257,
0.5497113466262817,
0.39942941069602966,
-0.2951127588748932,
-0.7365559935569763,
-0.9322201013565063,
-1.2060954570770264,
0.3398965895175934,
0.3847096562385559,
-0.4466020464897156,
0.12876448035240173,
0.5582935810089111,
0.18276602029800415,
0.06054867431521416,
-0.48763567209243774,
-0.5702340006828308,
-0.37868532538414,
-0.30490440130233765,
0.38284456729888916,
-0.05515950173139572,
-0.15453824400901794,
-0.4002671241760254,
1.1041853427886963,
-0.3606177568435669,
0.14349260926246643,
0.6262866258621216,
-0.18801310658454895,
-0.032690975815057755,
0.08205509930849075,
0.3782491087913513,
0.47881823778152466,
0.012475864961743355,
0.21229565143585205,
0.3939659595489502,
-0.08057891577482224,
0.10426497459411621,
0.2957536578178406,
-0.20641998946666718,
-0.09155328571796417,
0.1708236187696457,
0.7401841282844543,
-0.2942965626716614,
-0.3663961887359619,
0.28016573190689087,
-0.27001431584358215,
-0.42790356278419495,
-0.632483959197998,
0.3941911458969116,
0.029666323214769363,
0.35050150752067566,
0.33213144540786743,
-0.012212592177093029,
0.3106482923030853,
-0.12414094060659409,
0.43215322494506836,
0.1723415106534958,
-0.4461579918861389,
0.1934482753276825,
0.7271832227706909,
0.1344962865114212,
-0.3125866651535034,
0.40326428413391113,
-0.43669357895851135,
-0.3596190810203552,
0.6454408764839172,
0.09842495620250702,
0.9565737843513489,
-0.4181177616119385,
0.17104065418243408,
0.5224184393882751,
0.2978894114494324,
-0.23283664882183075,
0.08896101266145706,
-0.30522727966308594,
-0.48183774948120117,
-0.8238713145256042,
-0.39437419176101685,
-0.9932029843330383,
-0.06825093179941177,
-0.6463854908943176,
0.2676907181739807,
-0.40963393449783325,
-0.013697365298867226,
-0.0736868754029274,
-0.2926613986492157,
-0.4954254627227783,
0.4321170747280121,
0.6476814150810242,
0.6870714426040649,
-0.9438768625259399,
0.9910455942153931,
0.7772815227508545,
-0.4432792663574219,
-0.8841104507446289,
0.03701579198241234,
-0.03958738595247269,
-0.6005420684814453,
0.5612018704414368,
0.0792248472571373,
-0.34827908873558044,
-0.10267718881368637,
-0.997768223285675,
-0.893750786781311,
0.9682544469833374,
0.19074875116348267,
-0.582097053527832,
0.5172449350357056,
0.15738028287887573,
0.5651831030845642,
-0.6534450650215149,
0.5468043684959412,
0.6749336123466492,
0.5480726957321167,
0.6923635601997375,
-0.7665925025939941,
0.18179424107074738,
-0.2922932505607605,
-0.023604808375239372,
-0.08418269455432892,
-0.3853021264076233,
0.5317161083221436,
-0.3053509294986725,
0.06022876501083374,
0.0726376473903656,
1.111024022102356,
0.4224853515625,
0.16324298083782196,
0.6047946810722351,
0.4856484532356262,
1.0571666955947876,
-0.29284006357192993,
0.7999653816223145,
-0.17549142241477966,
0.4594933092594147,
1.4665204286575317,
-0.15286222100257874,
0.6271358728408813,
0.43244466185569763,
0.12691864371299744,
0.6573115587234497,
0.8146570920944214,
-0.14499863982200623,
0.08080576360225677,
0.4945535659790039,
-0.1660952866077423,
-0.8975018262863159,
0.17191502451896667,
-0.07865805178880692,
0.2739867866039276,
0.4675194323062897,
-0.4154427945613861,
0.16633917391300201,
-0.17314676940441132,
0.006527447607368231,
0.11414723098278046,
-0.0817393884062767,
0.6310617327690125,
0.04091451317071915,
-0.8495087623596191,
0.6812855005264282,
-0.20843437314033508,
0.4529767632484436,
-0.46590691804885864,
-0.22749850153923035,
0.014525478705763817,
0.18279564380645752,
-0.13931624591350555,
-0.8403517007827759,
0.38926905393600464,
-0.021830031648278236,
-0.10224060714244843,
-0.28715795278549194,
0.7900476455688477,
-0.5732580423355103,
-0.528075098991394,
0.0507550910115242,
0.2625844478607178,
0.2735714912414551,
-0.003766655921936035,
-0.8683881759643555,
0.07860926538705826,
-0.00548161193728447,
-0.2655823826789856,
-0.1528538167476654,
0.6782466769218445,
-0.04505551606416702,
0.8913866877555847,
0.5912768840789795,
-0.035757508128881454,
0.06896786391735077,
0.05491203814744949,
0.7458739280700684,
-0.48029249906539917,
-0.43869248032569885,
-0.8336842656135559,
0.6232286691665649,
-0.40627747774124146,
-0.2763030230998993,
0.5882963538169861,
0.4044801592826843,
0.7918365001678467,
0.02256811037659645,
1.1364058256149292,
0.02174893394112587,
0.25936639308929443,
-0.4436787962913513,
0.36395710706710815,
-0.4075074791908264,
0.35357338190078735,
-0.19475917518138885,
-0.6153098940849304,
-0.6319292783737183,
0.8681272268295288,
-0.48258811235427856,
-0.06374470889568329,
0.8382917642593384,
0.86137855052948,
0.11171386390924454,
-0.12850598990917206,
0.2127639353275299,
0.24654746055603027,
0.31677716970443726,
0.5329835414886475,
0.742373526096344,
-0.269131600856781,
0.7635374069213867,
-0.2850046753883362,
-0.5148003697395325,
-0.21593554317951202,
-1.257056474685669,
-0.8291789293289185,
-0.5306593179702759,
-0.9104000329971313,
-0.5056930780410767,
0.15104183554649353,
1.0642420053482056,
0.6690061688423157,
-0.7338804006576538,
0.0338868610560894,
-0.2963706851005554,
-0.048753511160612106,
-0.2725960612297058,
-0.24279463291168213,
0.18796291947364807,
-0.5690775513648987,
-0.6380332112312317,
0.053979016840457916,
0.5514733195304871,
0.25541362166404724,
-0.4685503840446472,
-0.15811336040496826,
-0.26702967286109924,
0.367344468832016,
-0.037442732602357864,
0.4626631736755371,
-0.6828080415725708,
-0.2772143483161926,
-0.013701396994292736,
-0.1571931689977646,
0.28383007645606995,
0.7731943726539612,
-0.6958986520767212,
0.810004711151123,
0.6452358961105347,
0.7055676579475403,
0.6337560415267944,
-0.10783512890338898,
0.8074175715446472,
-0.6129653453826904,
-0.09027348458766937,
0.22534270584583282,
0.41791993379592896,
0.6088513135910034,
-0.6499792337417603,
0.3839391767978668,
0.3711702227592468,
-0.7920387983322144,
-0.5109593868255615,
0.41938501596450806,
-0.9010196924209595,
-0.046290796250104904,
1.2969067096710205,
-0.4779743254184723,
-0.4790980815887451,
-0.37400341033935547,
-0.04789329692721367,
0.726190447807312,
-0.45339876413345337,
0.9796068072319031,
0.9501355886459351,
-0.30074214935302734,
-0.050649236887693405,
-0.40412044525146484,
0.6159037351608276,
0.4596783518791199,
-0.9883158802986145,
0.20066460967063904,
0.46272486448287964,
0.23665578663349152,
0.13560448586940765,
0.3951391279697418,
-0.18055596947669983,
0.28092050552368164,
-0.22967305779457092,
0.3967578411102295,
-0.26940011978149414,
-0.17605403065681458,
-0.24548713862895966,
-0.09930752962827682,
0.08038178831338882,
-0.2531445622444153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16751v1
|
LLM-Based Cooperative Agents using Information Relevance and Plan Validation
| 2024-05-27T01:47:14 | 2024-05-27T01:47:14 |
SeungWon Seo, Junhyeok Lee, SeongRae Noh, HyeongYeop Kang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MA
|
We address the challenge of multi-agent cooperation, where agents achieve a
common goal by interacting with a 3D scene and cooperating with decentralized
agents under complex partial observations. This involves managing communication
costs and optimizing interaction trajectories in dynamic environments. Our
research focuses on three primary limitations of existing cooperative agent
systems. Firstly, current systems demonstrate inefficiency in managing acquired
information through observation, resulting in declining planning performance as
the environment becomes more complex with additional objects or goals.
Secondly, the neglect of false plans in partially observable settings leads to
suboptimal cooperative performance, as agents struggle to adapt to
environmental changes influenced by the unseen actions of other agents. Lastly,
the failure to incorporate spatial data into decision-making processes
restricts the agent's ability to construct optimized trajectories. To overcome
these limitations, we propose the RElevance and Validation-Enhanced Cooperative
Language Agent (REVECA), a novel cognitive architecture powered by GPT-3.5.
REVECA leverages relevance assessment, plan validation, and spatial information
to enhance the efficiency and robustness of agent cooperation in dynamic and
partially observable environments while minimizing continuous communication
costs and effectively managing irrelevant dummy objects. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate the superiority of REVECA over previous approaches,
including those driven by GPT-4.0. Additionally, a user study highlights
REVECA's potential for achieving trustworthy human-AI cooperation. We expect
that REVECA will have significant applications in gaming, XR applications,
educational tools, and humanoid robots, contributing to substantial economic,
commercial, and academic advancements.
|
[
-0.36965078115463257,
-0.7239770293235779,
0.898413896560669,
0.2571977972984314,
0.23378491401672363,
0.2597879469394684,
-0.13746750354766846,
-0.6346192955970764,
0.2291325479745865,
0.4540632665157318,
-0.6706508994102478,
-0.49688661098480225,
-0.22618407011032104,
0.043275799602270126,
0.04005393385887146,
0.6779036521911621,
0.022884583100676537,
-0.17777645587921143,
-0.5545013546943665,
-0.25078943371772766,
-0.5332992672920227,
-0.5339799523353577,
-0.7896261215209961,
-0.5562934875488281,
0.4929976165294647,
0.6146670579910278,
1.0090360641479492,
0.2864231765270233,
0.5247160792350769,
0.492866575717926,
0.1491747498512268,
0.41029930114746094,
-0.5899584889411926,
0.4103395342826843,
-0.3068954050540924,
-0.5381824970245361,
-0.7371489405632019,
0.23967233300209045,
0.411239355802536,
0.4193422794342041,
-0.29589933156967163,
-0.256307452917099,
-0.05074107646942139,
0.5456081628799438,
-0.6222256422042847,
0.4866546094417572,
-0.5634093284606934,
-0.0784047394990921,
0.176358163356781,
-0.1185363382101059,
-0.2817694842815399,
-0.22268623113632202,
0.1582263857126236,
-0.9939157962799072,
0.0754033550620079,
0.060242705047130585,
0.8167699575424194,
0.4228101372718811,
-0.193807914853096,
-0.36793792247772217,
-0.8401275277137756,
0.8854964375495911,
-0.27169257402420044,
0.28570783138275146,
0.47446009516716003,
0.5840962529182434,
-0.6848310828208923,
-0.7617064714431763,
-0.7293069362640381,
-0.26923829317092896,
0.128767728805542,
0.5622605085372925,
-0.25357842445373535,
0.204507514834404,
0.0301663801074028,
0.07231215387582779,
-0.3910179138183594,
-0.020124824717640877,
-0.07055923342704773,
-0.3599141538143158,
0.4066639542579651,
0.2879505455493927,
0.17450684309005737,
0.3832851052284241,
-0.5226675868034363,
-0.1964954137802124,
-0.5077123641967773,
0.13237084448337555,
0.3150954246520996,
0.05174199864268303,
-0.4098835289478302,
0.6708606481552124,
-0.3798232674598694,
0.3700879216194153,
0.026361403986811638,
0.024234598502516747,
0.20246632397174835,
-0.7186964154243469,
-0.10203875601291656,
-0.42601144313812256,
0.6499677896499634,
0.3714998662471771,
-0.02245626226067543,
-0.3671110272407532,
-0.2579485774040222,
0.3327139914035797,
0.31957510113716125,
-0.1876225471496582,
-0.11077932268381119,
0.26301050186157227,
-0.03690076991915703,
-0.2602092921733856,
0.048014577478170395,
-0.8477131724357605,
-0.14072845876216888,
-0.14626763761043549,
0.26936033368110657,
-0.23102909326553345,
-0.03649822250008583,
0.11070537567138672,
-0.14827211201190948,
0.3826313614845276,
0.8923155665397644,
-0.4250464141368866,
0.34282851219177246,
0.6993663907051086,
0.6436256766319275,
0.019962802529335022,
-0.7642238736152649,
-0.45770663022994995,
0.32268255949020386,
-0.18386639654636383,
0.8624880909919739,
-0.6176120638847351,
-0.3582327961921692,
-0.10965511947870255,
-0.1942593902349472,
0.05095936730504036,
-0.3613562285900116,
0.5464412569999695,
-0.7910109758377075,
0.28774866461753845,
-0.3417015075683594,
-0.19370929896831512,
-0.12242518365383148,
0.707728385925293,
-0.8015204668045044,
0.748826265335083,
0.3784829378128052,
-0.3985420763492584,
0.24488873779773712,
-0.5150469541549683,
-0.2746806740760803,
-0.10624244064092636,
-0.40197932720184326,
-0.23714575171470642,
-0.3019746243953705,
-0.11120021343231201,
0.09789202362298965,
-0.41658321022987366,
0.18217334151268005,
-0.26695364713668823,
-0.437156617641449,
0.17002202570438385,
-0.5342072248458862,
0.28191715478897095,
0.2617182433605194,
-0.15606284141540527,
0.3811793923377991,
-0.5078848600387573,
0.06347353011369705,
-0.049947675317525864,
-0.5060044527053833,
0.0406654067337513,
-0.14592640101909637,
-0.32479721307754517,
0.1622520089149475,
0.7326390743255615,
-0.3746112287044525,
0.29547828435897827,
-0.03542817756533623,
0.25249719619750977,
0.7482556700706482,
0.05039576441049576,
0.7139508724212646,
-0.8003082871437073,
0.5318993926048279,
-0.2413758933544159,
0.6385748982429504,
0.08250376582145691,
-0.7597651481628418,
-0.3974170386791229,
-0.4136635363101959,
-0.2203492671251297,
0.563389241695404,
-1.1454100608825684,
0.34844866394996643,
-0.1427997201681137,
-0.2974134385585785,
-0.13897164165973663,
-0.3016382157802582,
0.25816676020622253,
0.46076732873916626,
0.3881601095199585,
-0.22869499027729034,
-0.47940587997436523,
-0.7482710480690002,
0.24589957296848297,
-0.4042200744152069,
0.12015262991189957,
0.4659143388271332,
0.3614150285720825,
-0.5957979559898376,
0.9400643110275269,
-0.020420655608177185,
-0.251316100358963,
-0.2352699637413025,
-0.15345339477062225,
0.2388933002948761,
0.13195791840553284,
0.3187653422355652,
-0.9423367381095886,
-0.29694369435310364,
0.16602329909801483,
-0.8234724402427673,
0.06441222876310349,
-0.2189732939004898,
-0.16938164830207825,
0.006532393395900726,
0.09761060774326324,
-0.8424498438835144,
0.5839557647705078,
0.8347915410995483,
-0.318193644285202,
0.5493593215942383,
-0.6186946034431458,
0.3711627125740051,
-0.6656515598297119,
-0.11100000143051147,
-0.4620148241519928,
-0.350137323141098,
-0.4981556236743927,
0.008210328407585621,
-0.37065330147743225,
0.06623572111129761,
-0.28348731994628906,
0.47264841198921204,
-0.4830969274044037,
-0.3876461684703827,
-0.42072951793670654,
0.6386215090751648,
0.1471191644668579,
0.6852849721908569,
0.008014648221433163,
0.8267369270324707,
0.5283166170120239,
-0.7143641710281372,
0.5644817352294922,
0.17106513679027557,
0.15146854519844055,
0.5234950184822083,
-0.5616167187690735,
0.2131219506263733,
0.2502523362636566,
0.3828313946723938,
-0.6802663207054138,
-0.1602611541748047,
0.5193884968757629,
-0.5455577373504639,
0.014370627701282501,
0.12322552502155304,
-0.4506935179233551,
0.02393178828060627,
-0.440017431974411,
0.5829493999481201,
0.16144561767578125,
-0.41776198148727417,
0.9678146243095398,
0.5130104422569275,
0.4174474775791168,
-0.7972071170806885,
-0.47313007712364197,
0.1024538204073906,
0.0932658240199089,
-0.7252740263938904,
0.24076059460639954,
-0.05917203053832054,
-0.4998105466365814,
0.18229897320270538,
-0.0979343056678772,
0.01990307867527008,
0.055508650839328766,
0.3812176287174225,
0.38391658663749695,
0.2657984793186188,
-0.26559457182884216,
-0.1747310757637024,
-0.2216194123029709,
-0.02392844296991825,
-0.06025020033121109,
0.614831268787384,
-0.4337199926376343,
-0.47967100143432617,
-0.34369829297065735,
0.31019386649131775,
0.6554802656173706,
0.009851363487541676,
0.6962894201278687,
0.3388057053089142,
-0.3524523675441742,
0.03338971361517906,
-0.4774191081523895,
-0.10351480543613434,
-0.4831717908382416,
0.29956090450286865,
-0.41245678067207336,
-0.9878118634223938,
0.7820889353752136,
-0.3600843548774719,
0.09898974746465683,
0.004779897630214691,
0.38793161511421204,
-0.04518209770321846,
0.3912890553474426,
0.5544331669807434,
0.07718780636787415,
0.39162129163742065,
-0.20486611127853394,
-0.16072650253772736,
-0.9613461494445801,
-0.48345375061035156,
-0.563464879989624,
-0.18461471796035767,
-0.7400630116462708,
-0.8170457482337952,
0.37305304408073425,
-0.12636618316173553,
-0.2541157007217407,
0.40192911028862,
-0.3997952938079834,
0.3135046660900116,
0.5914559364318848,
0.14112727344036102,
0.47748640179634094,
-0.2992437481880188,
0.01838340051472187,
0.29426515102386475,
-0.7295674681663513,
-0.631276547908783,
1.0066701173782349,
0.1328132450580597,
0.7409653663635254,
0.41124704480171204,
0.6135699152946472,
0.43526917695999146,
0.40577197074890137,
-0.5997296571731567,
0.756138801574707,
0.5055794715881348,
-0.3779001235961914,
-0.6661444306373596,
-0.6173832416534424,
-1.302348256111145,
0.30692318081855774,
-0.33891022205352783,
-0.5986136198043823,
0.42117148637771606,
-0.0725172832608223,
-0.1512129157781601,
0.07555913925170898,
-0.5251895189285278,
0.4234960079193115,
-0.19515545666217804,
-0.7744881510734558,
-0.5194385051727295,
-0.6081858277320862,
-0.05210090056061745,
0.040358033031225204,
0.32808467745780945,
0.08951621502637863,
-0.5246557593345642,
0.21930280327796936,
-0.18971358239650726,
0.8095448017120361,
-0.014601383358240128,
-0.052476417273283005,
0.4806802272796631,
0.18114064633846283,
1.008004069328308,
0.3393085300922394,
-0.23104697465896606,
0.42948415875434875,
-0.24735812842845917,
-0.37726670503616333,
-0.5989947319030762,
0.889304518699646,
-1.0583511590957642,
-0.6948989629745483,
-0.5516506433486938,
-0.6719227433204651,
-0.31027117371559143,
0.3241646885871887,
0.05745014548301697,
-0.11950672417879105,
-0.3302188515663147,
0.13437622785568237,
0.20164178311824799,
-0.2181725800037384,
0.23667308688163757,
0.5888356566429138,
-0.12058898061513901,
-0.537471354007721,
0.5218088626861572,
-0.3439256250858307,
0.41825807094573975,
0.541038453578949,
-0.05728519707918167,
-0.27490901947021484,
-0.6058023571968079,
0.1519961804151535,
0.24533170461654663,
-0.5150933265686035,
-0.14067798852920532,
-0.2460392415523529,
0.10701142996549606,
-0.2181587517261505,
-0.33858224749565125,
-0.574347972869873,
-0.21793338656425476,
-0.06754700094461441,
0.1114448681473732,
-0.17253805696964264,
0.8437621593475342,
-0.33773618936538696,
0.11398036777973175,
-0.4843297302722931,
0.18796676397323608,
0.29198136925697327,
0.14927145838737488,
-0.28517889976501465,
-0.11925667524337769,
-0.1849452257156372,
0.31203097105026245,
-0.39632609486579895,
-0.6991500854492188,
0.1486646980047226,
-0.29160889983177185,
0.9390544295310974,
0.0022699853871017694,
0.17102310061454773,
0.47959497570991516,
-0.07014927268028259,
0.6446016430854797,
-0.046493977308273315,
-0.6695665717124939,
0.5815612077713013,
-0.4098517596721649,
-0.011682636104524136,
0.5139010548591614,
-0.057596515864133835,
-0.1489386260509491,
-0.4051573574542999,
-0.7021344304084778,
-0.6313136219978333,
0.6566837430000305,
0.621185839176178,
-0.27530163526535034,
0.02985380031168461,
0.6136825680732727,
-0.1916610151529312,
0.19834139943122864,
-0.4847353398799896,
-0.16382183134555817,
-0.17224866151809692,
0.13162147998809814,
0.11246944963932037,
0.030404862016439438,
-0.3243730664253235,
0.34054991602897644,
0.4611441493034363,
-0.11270371824502945,
0.34432321786880493,
0.5647820234298706,
0.30070480704307556,
-0.17053963243961334,
0.22033168375492096,
0.754838764667511,
0.5496745705604553,
-0.0608009397983551,
0.006534704938530922,
0.2196771800518036,
-0.5720770359039307,
0.08747608959674835,
-0.06751906126737595,
-0.10918237268924713,
-0.36592787504196167,
0.46236032247543335,
0.3524334728717804,
0.22650115191936493,
-0.5343570113182068,
0.48958009481430054,
-0.4912644922733307,
-0.13456061482429504,
-0.5540832281112671,
0.27842140197753906,
-0.20106130838394165,
0.7931659817695618,
0.05043561011552811,
0.6273651123046875,
0.012607412412762642,
-0.8515589237213135,
0.2541019916534424,
0.5678914189338684,
-0.37791240215301514,
-0.48671671748161316,
0.353380411863327,
0.17131011188030243,
-0.31977957487106323,
0.5993563532829285,
-0.3954421281814575,
-0.2822013199329376,
0.8163580298423767,
0.2821674942970276,
0.6293455958366394,
-0.19457009434700012,
0.17401105165481567,
0.15199777483940125,
0.43852347135543823,
-0.1414688676595688,
0.21046188473701477,
-0.2344246655702591,
-1.070802927017212,
-0.2406691163778305,
-0.0770338922739029,
-0.8333502411842346,
-0.0539269782602787,
-0.45293956995010376,
0.2283579558134079,
-0.42885515093803406,
-0.356607586145401,
-0.7066167593002319,
0.2768913507461548,
-0.7430853247642517,
-0.11410287767648697,
-0.26192525029182434,
0.6806958317756653,
-0.27211764454841614,
0.9290626645088196,
0.9005630016326904,
-0.2926951050758362,
-0.711776852607727,
-0.018479788675904274,
-0.09201335906982422,
-0.9128337502479553,
0.28651881217956543,
-0.1909346580505371,
-0.6389756202697754,
-0.1525985598564148,
-0.4949348568916321,
-0.7707610726356506,
1.752643346786499,
0.3148040771484375,
-0.5562536716461182,
-0.057877667248249054,
-0.041861072182655334,
0.7719112634658813,
-0.4247415363788605,
0.3815818727016449,
0.03654057905077934,
0.6879140138626099,
0.6101986765861511,
-0.8254088163375854,
0.0036568879149854183,
0.033262722194194794,
-0.33519190549850464,
-0.15251792967319489,
-0.9979546070098877,
0.905366063117981,
-0.5659388899803162,
-0.4009002149105072,
0.2535172402858734,
0.7483772039413452,
0.6916905641555786,
0.7334818243980408,
0.5390318632125854,
0.32017701864242554,
0.9274653792381287,
-0.11581851541996002,
0.9355918169021606,
-0.2716817855834961,
0.4362141788005829,
1.3214643001556396,
-0.6711540222167969,
0.5024468898773193,
0.4519943594932556,
-0.09876421093940735,
0.4092746376991272,
0.2707304358482361,
0.13551507890224457,
0.5733717083930969,
-0.16303583979606628,
-0.4394916892051697,
-0.26191216707229614,
-0.1754186898469925,
-0.1733781099319458,
0.4802274703979492,
0.45533767342567444,
0.15076479315757751,
-0.26382628083229065,
-0.19670404493808746,
-0.20923247933387756,
0.3282330334186554,
-0.0014162735315039754,
0.5984580516815186,
-0.15289367735385895,
-0.7418528199195862,
-0.09324409812688828,
-0.16770891845226288,
0.3807869255542755,
-0.6408480405807495,
-0.38801857829093933,
-0.39312946796417236,
0.2714385688304901,
-0.08811147511005402,
-0.8051024675369263,
0.1854947954416275,
-0.34513285756111145,
0.07741912454366684,
0.016077807173132896,
0.7035295367240906,
-0.21241328120231628,
0.3603326678276062,
0.5400562286376953,
0.6800485849380493,
-0.015623084269464016,
-0.030572718009352684,
-0.6012802124023438,
0.32079756259918213,
-0.09175721555948257,
-0.2067440003156662,
0.26750534772872925,
0.7556434869766235,
-0.07112064212560654,
1.0585501194000244,
0.7211735248565674,
0.17065565288066864,
-0.3854527771472931,
-0.09420496970415115,
1.0983401536941528,
-0.5808308124542236,
-0.302394300699234,
-0.5775633454322815,
0.09769312292337418,
-0.06907189637422562,
0.012158083729445934,
0.7468765377998352,
0.5596582293510437,
0.8019973039627075,
0.2772974669933319,
0.5882074236869812,
0.10232964903116226,
-0.04675890505313873,
-0.40445151925086975,
0.2996399998664856,
-0.24131716787815094,
0.7775866985321045,
0.03781752288341522,
-0.8729798197746277,
-0.12661296129226685,
0.6208136677742004,
-0.27849727869033813,
0.3495093882083893,
0.5753754377365112,
0.6859431266784668,
0.3005916476249695,
0.1023394986987114,
0.6924048066139221,
0.0560634545981884,
0.7132977247238159,
0.9525632262229919,
1.1544722318649292,
-0.346427857875824,
0.7010412812232971,
-0.26240554451942444,
-0.5338056087493896,
-0.02989947982132435,
-0.5670151114463806,
-0.7725185751914978,
-0.4841879904270172,
-0.18102006614208221,
-0.2846188247203827,
0.1518932282924652,
0.6096594929695129,
0.6334428191184998,
-0.26375484466552734,
-0.10730553418397903,
-0.3156517744064331,
0.4438440799713135,
-0.20066936314105988,
-0.27074578404426575,
0.01528342254459858,
-0.21006694436073303,
-0.598312497138977,
0.5016098022460938,
0.5938027501106262,
0.07865016162395477,
-0.3249319791793823,
-0.6096609234809875,
-0.18833784759044647,
0.039535023272037506,
0.3724862039089203,
0.43124130368232727,
-0.5671603083610535,
-0.4733874499797821,
0.0427410863339901,
-0.4044257402420044,
0.0421491414308548,
0.7357802987098694,
-0.8268495202064514,
0.3507588505744934,
0.3581192195415497,
0.2794418931007385,
0.36665695905685425,
0.10229641944169998,
0.4666939675807953,
-0.592271625995636,
0.12707123160362244,
0.3859531283378601,
0.28321167826652527,
0.14789216220378876,
-0.6266567707061768,
0.7877581119537354,
0.2143777757883072,
-1.0106914043426514,
-0.3364005982875824,
0.3141244053840637,
-1.28830087184906,
0.062434662133455276,
0.989256739616394,
-0.3885185718536377,
-0.43242987990379333,
-0.5186294317245483,
-0.3520371913909912,
0.2674350440502167,
-0.7657214999198914,
0.7977529168128967,
0.5600552558898926,
-0.508612334728241,
-0.05362046882510185,
-0.2662034332752228,
0.29405152797698975,
0.08247748762369156,
-1.0072946548461914,
0.06847981363534927,
0.6508422493934631,
-0.23303227126598358,
0.6078841090202332,
0.807608425617218,
-0.15596137940883636,
0.40376925468444824,
0.18913130462169647,
0.13331492245197296,
-0.3307686746120453,
-0.4752062261104584,
0.01457868330180645,
0.12987655401229858,
0.12723693251609802,
-0.26970237493515015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16720v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16720v2
|
Large Scale Knowledge Washing
| 2024-05-26T23:29:49 | 2024-05-28T15:48:12 |
Yu Wang, Ruihan Wu, Zexue He, Xiusi Chen, Julian McAuley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models show impressive abilities in memorizing world
knowledge, which leads to concerns regarding memorization of private
information, toxic or sensitive knowledge, and copyrighted content. We
introduce the problem of Large Scale Knowledge Washing, focusing on unlearning
an extensive amount of factual knowledge. Previous unlearning methods usually
define the reverse loss and update the model via backpropagation, which may
affect the model's fluency and reasoning ability or even destroy the model due
to extensive training with the reverse loss. Existing works introduce
additional data from downstream tasks to prevent the model from losing
capabilities, which requires downstream task awareness. Controlling the
tradeoff of unlearning and maintaining existing capabilities is also
challenging. To this end, we propose LAW (Large Scale Washing) to update the
MLP layers in decoder-only large language models to perform knowledge washing,
as inspired by model editing methods and based on the hypothesis that knowledge
and reasoning are disentanglable. We derive a new objective with the knowledge
to be unlearned to update the weights of certain MLP layers. Experimental
results demonstrate the effectiveness of LAW in forgetting target knowledge
while maintaining reasoning ability. The code will be open-sourced at
https://github.com/wangyu-ustc/LargeScaleWashing.
|
[
-0.018080728128552437,
-0.7033292651176453,
0.599524974822998,
0.08811336755752563,
-0.07636259496212006,
0.03661105036735535,
-0.44425350427627563,
-0.3451940417289734,
-0.21774017810821533,
1.0794973373413086,
-0.16904202103614807,
-0.007034215144813061,
-0.7183184623718262,
-0.6990921497344971,
-0.5645033717155457,
1.0084642171859741,
-0.10719197988510132,
-0.05524609237909317,
-0.08840443938970566,
-0.16949279606342316,
-0.3256857097148895,
-0.523513913154602,
-0.8950337767601013,
-0.7180484533309937,
0.5351912975311279,
0.5132415294647217,
0.5258216261863708,
0.7083374261856079,
0.17690624296665192,
0.30714213848114014,
-0.377055287361145,
0.14814302325248718,
-0.7911158204078674,
0.14175771176815033,
-0.7244892120361328,
-0.4986223876476288,
-0.2162158042192459,
0.021325604990124702,
0.6405789852142334,
0.7526478171348572,
-0.365678071975708,
0.17015327513217926,
0.27992936968803406,
1.0057653188705444,
-0.8497724533081055,
0.3031226694583893,
-0.5968524813652039,
0.005497557111084461,
0.26743724942207336,
-0.10989908128976822,
-0.57243812084198,
0.11818783730268478,
-0.074119932949543,
-0.5240140557289124,
0.06145601347088814,
0.08717995136976242,
0.6259012222290039,
0.329825758934021,
-0.40470007061958313,
-0.09832331538200378,
-0.9224452972412109,
0.9950499534606934,
-0.8162397742271423,
0.19714632630348206,
0.6418054103851318,
0.15232907235622406,
-0.14887793362140656,
-0.6685336828231812,
-0.49913960695266724,
-0.02401553839445114,
0.2097386121749878,
-0.0317373126745224,
-0.1893533319234848,
-0.2643316984176636,
0.45818617939949036,
0.2420673370361328,
-0.016157066449522972,
0.3944534361362457,
-0.5042974948883057,
-0.040968164801597595,
0.733213484287262,
-0.09480978548526764,
0.4310689866542816,
0.338811993598938,
-0.47976136207580566,
0.1061021015048027,
-0.724276065826416,
-0.012840877287089825,
0.17007037997245789,
0.2117536962032318,
0.24825245141983032,
0.6025585532188416,
-0.28088855743408203,
0.2757703959941864,
-0.19437214732170105,
-0.3923575282096863,
0.23285925388336182,
0.22703954577445984,
-0.3273707926273346,
0.2616756558418274,
0.5017253756523132,
0.4101089537143707,
0.3688478171825409,
-0.005170648451894522,
-0.39023199677467346,
-0.7017710208892822,
0.19238729774951935,
-0.7949470281600952,
-0.16998149454593658,
0.08920156210660934,
-0.5252233147621155,
-0.019109975546598434,
-0.06772369891405106,
-0.5167464017868042,
-1.1008026599884033,
-0.7128080725669861,
0.7281785011291504,
-0.5621057152748108,
-0.4890369474887848,
0.1250395029783249,
-0.4901001453399658,
0.22464212775230408,
0.3340533971786499,
-0.9290869235992432,
0.02732297033071518,
0.7705838084220886,
0.48626384139060974,
0.487971693277359,
-0.3905460238456726,
-0.3831369876861572,
0.3886876404285431,
-0.2979266941547394,
0.13922488689422607,
-0.311295747756958,
0.01812341809272766,
-0.06690831482410431,
-0.04643969610333443,
-0.11214272677898407,
-0.6524488925933838,
0.07794162631034851,
-0.8393536806106567,
-0.11665554344654083,
-0.32374733686447144,
-0.7498720288276672,
-0.5370561480522156,
0.11885271221399307,
-0.6426591873168945,
0.5068517923355103,
-0.010958020575344563,
-0.7937695384025574,
0.3098832666873932,
-0.4610195457935333,
-0.5791313648223877,
-0.16964276134967804,
0.4071385860443115,
-0.5174474120140076,
0.058250121772289276,
-0.027076907455921173,
0.7135793566703796,
-0.2231917530298233,
0.4031602144241333,
-0.39929160475730896,
-0.32667866349220276,
0.01850949227809906,
-0.37371912598609924,
0.9966412782669067,
0.30646851658821106,
-0.5228279829025269,
-0.015538583509624004,
-0.5846264362335205,
-0.17392408847808838,
0.27709364891052246,
-0.4099429249763489,
-0.6440086364746094,
0.17555198073387146,
-0.3791893720626831,
0.20355425775051117,
0.3964260220527649,
-0.4105507731437683,
0.15019793808460236,
0.07583391666412354,
0.7242496013641357,
0.9777881503105164,
0.10912884026765823,
0.4806392192840576,
-0.5058953166007996,
0.04943154379725456,
0.21575549244880676,
0.20975598692893982,
-0.09359056502580643,
-0.5843002200126648,
-0.7530267834663391,
-0.3481714725494385,
0.0880412682890892,
0.5040872693061829,
-0.7183418273925781,
0.36253273487091064,
-0.12873195111751556,
-0.45811668038368225,
-0.2588534653186798,
0.5333199501037598,
0.5183757543563843,
0.43162989616394043,
0.5817246437072754,
0.01894090510904789,
-0.40807604789733887,
-0.7276232242584229,
-0.44261667132377625,
0.04638385772705078,
-0.004770749714225531,
-0.0857311487197876,
0.6564745903015137,
-0.27462121844291687,
0.5742613673210144,
-0.4651051461696625,
-0.5055167078971863,
-0.44524645805358887,
0.22899229824543,
0.023866578936576843,
0.5458816289901733,
0.04179893434047699,
-0.8804463148117065,
-0.2611597180366516,
0.1995389610528946,
-0.6602737903594971,
0.2671268582344055,
0.025428634136915207,
0.13716402649879456,
0.32307735085487366,
0.9817569851875305,
-0.6340165138244629,
0.19600550830364227,
0.3952973783016205,
-0.3258860409259796,
0.565997302532196,
-0.7030795216560364,
0.05448542907834053,
-0.9788883328437805,
0.24716688692569733,
-0.08057321608066559,
-0.1987038403749466,
-0.5614842772483826,
0.4110877513885498,
0.03663492575287819,
0.028064526617527008,
-0.35136011242866516,
0.5006055235862732,
-0.43335971236228943,
0.13444148004055023,
-0.4476817846298218,
-0.016898270696401596,
0.010533436201512814,
0.5560489296913147,
-0.06444663554430008,
0.3314361870288849,
0.3013700842857361,
-0.6171332597732544,
0.46624326705932617,
-0.09734570980072021,
-0.48232656717300415,
0.018588731065392494,
-0.23449553549289703,
-0.025479193776845932,
-0.2898428440093994,
0.14139343798160553,
-0.6942846775054932,
-0.04375205188989639,
-0.19815534353256226,
-0.04112967848777771,
0.6643159985542297,
-0.2765350341796875,
-0.5858106017112732,
-0.3137643337249756,
-0.21194452047348022,
0.1556127667427063,
0.8677637577056885,
-0.722405195236206,
0.6694391965866089,
0.46957507729530334,
-0.07250148057937622,
-1.0066944360733032,
-0.6419967412948608,
-0.036449041217565536,
-0.28881850838661194,
-0.32915571331977844,
-0.10704518854618073,
0.23741643130779266,
-0.4193422496318817,
0.02331612817943096,
-0.27741605043411255,
-0.3225743770599365,
0.037018731236457825,
0.13934063911437988,
-0.15097470581531525,
-0.07064861059188843,
0.22002211213111877,
-0.023672979325056076,
0.07438017427921295,
0.3084595203399658,
-0.6684596538543701,
0.6977982521057129,
0.0938652977347374,
-0.2890860438346863,
-0.20886580646038055,
0.043445736169815063,
0.7952693700790405,
-0.374320387840271,
1.0033257007598877,
0.7228284478187561,
-0.40734168887138367,
-0.5262951850891113,
-0.6745916604995728,
0.050021130591630936,
-0.45630863308906555,
0.6350563168525696,
-0.18829065561294556,
-0.765357494354248,
0.5738303661346436,
-0.12762445211410522,
0.13777005672454834,
0.46011507511138916,
0.5469761490821838,
-0.22167837619781494,
0.9133139252662659,
0.801293671131134,
-0.5030867457389832,
0.3496323823928833,
-0.4691472351551056,
0.5359128713607788,
-0.7320992946624756,
-0.1584632843732834,
-0.2920307219028473,
-0.512560248374939,
-0.3505847752094269,
-0.4647587537765503,
-0.22296024858951569,
0.41836249828338623,
-0.6736520528793335,
0.2388852834701538,
-0.1808444857597351,
0.6241307854652405,
0.8013879060745239,
0.43881916999816895,
0.5706018209457397,
-0.16877207159996033,
0.04986084997653961,
0.34913599491119385,
-0.5675557851791382,
-0.23502467572689056,
1.0614317655563354,
0.4749760329723358,
0.7484064102172852,
-0.0886462926864624,
0.6028491854667664,
0.20541724562644958,
0.2665993571281433,
-0.7321908473968506,
0.5382598042488098,
-0.23639258742332458,
-0.6123194098472595,
-0.7856946587562561,
-0.8856959342956543,
-0.6485099196434021,
0.20701292157173157,
-0.013561117462813854,
-0.6720733046531677,
-0.2085794061422348,
0.19033874571323395,
-0.03664426878094673,
1.2639610767364502,
-0.6571768522262573,
0.648983359336853,
0.11394931375980377,
-0.21761652827262878,
-0.6463490128517151,
-0.40549513697624207,
0.6519040465354919,
-0.3554190993309021,
0.451406329870224,
-0.0024294485338032246,
0.1788903921842575,
0.793915331363678,
-0.5124847292900085,
1.0513361692428589,
-0.5897269248962402,
-0.47626641392707825,
0.31015849113464355,
0.093782939016819,
0.4806658923625946,
-0.2602587044239044,
0.3492262661457062,
-0.020843908190727234,
-0.12548649311065674,
-0.5969476103782654,
-0.517608642578125,
0.5573714971542358,
-0.6176043152809143,
-0.8443390130996704,
-0.0706901103258133,
-0.7762722373008728,
-0.1596519947052002,
0.4636131823062897,
0.11367236822843552,
0.23950596153736115,
0.22641895711421967,
0.251079797744751,
1.210543155670166,
-0.5514865517616272,
0.3189656138420105,
0.4629473388195038,
-0.3886706531047821,
0.018668238073587418,
1.1456893682479858,
0.23318488895893097,
0.346449077129364,
0.6395580172538757,
0.5057488679885864,
-0.11051328480243683,
-0.48992297053337097,
-0.056517068296670914,
0.37014347314834595,
-0.7393529415130615,
-0.07182542979717255,
-0.5146937966346741,
-0.4236358404159546,
-0.24389022588729858,
-0.12224110215902328,
-0.45107704401016235,
-0.4223395586013794,
0.03082212246954441,
0.08210907876491547,
0.3794938325881958,
0.662764847278595,
-0.17586489021778107,
0.07189230620861053,
-0.679192304611206,
0.48166343569755554,
0.5177410244941711,
0.4545624554157257,
0.27849262952804565,
-0.9066399931907654,
-0.4449480175971985,
0.22229230403900146,
-0.09922611713409424,
-0.04773642495274544,
0.2649453580379486,
0.0005087221506983042,
0.39266493916511536,
0.7909367680549622,
0.13929498195648193,
0.4187973141670227,
-0.4358117878437042,
0.3004538118839264,
0.48384734988212585,
-0.8447437286376953,
0.24630753695964813,
-0.3425516188144684,
0.370746910572052,
0.14632567763328552,
0.34320902824401855,
-0.5920799970626831,
-0.6820576190948486,
-0.6387203335762024,
-1.0002071857452393,
0.49699288606643677,
-0.5698238015174866,
0.24046443402767181,
0.4088268578052521,
0.24159081280231476,
-0.10591798275709152,
0.19053874909877777,
-0.3240351676940918,
0.04314044490456581,
-0.06763886660337448,
-0.053759485483169556,
-0.2441355139017105,
-0.3695075511932373,
-0.09145145863294601,
-0.35830995440483093,
1.1938021183013916,
0.15616746246814728,
-0.19575388729572296,
-0.07423697412014008,
-0.4287542998790741,
-0.1261642873287201,
0.35090315341949463,
0.4497155249118805,
0.8352939486503601,
0.16438902914524078,
0.12130749970674515,
0.205667644739151,
-0.7438967823982239,
0.09373608976602554,
-0.12616778910160065,
-0.20359733700752258,
-0.7274099588394165,
0.48766112327575684,
0.43166327476501465,
0.3178299367427826,
-0.8380630612373352,
0.6466577649116516,
0.29866522550582886,
-0.5559088587760925,
-0.37479227781295776,
0.1839292198419571,
0.49293404817581177,
0.3044171929359436,
0.3527422249317169,
0.2515784800052643,
-0.11932343244552612,
-0.7233721017837524,
0.2888362407684326,
0.1327885389328003,
-0.3724406063556671,
0.1581338793039322,
0.6704673171043396,
-0.13098278641700745,
0.2148130089044571,
0.9952234625816345,
-0.18845121562480927,
-0.5668880343437195,
0.4174315333366394,
0.41152501106262207,
0.3692476451396942,
-0.5189328193664551,
0.037562254816293716,
0.29131850600242615,
0.3787023425102234,
-0.6095775365829468,
-0.012582431547343731,
0.17555704712867737,
-0.9248001575469971,
-0.9376205801963806,
-0.3921900987625122,
-0.24967171251773834,
0.5310991406440735,
-0.5800682306289673,
-0.06643153727054596,
-0.9065801501274109,
0.1282537281513214,
-0.05463254451751709,
0.07124729454517365,
-0.32789507508277893,
0.2663614749908447,
0.12937206029891968,
0.8103165626525879,
-0.6805099844932556,
0.8458364009857178,
0.5199987888336182,
-0.4511379301548004,
-0.835881769657135,
-0.15164682269096375,
0.08917322009801865,
-1.0288364887237549,
0.6817225813865662,
0.2719651758670807,
0.022887352854013443,
-0.039282526820898056,
-0.5833255648612976,
-0.7382873296737671,
1.040972113609314,
0.3653189539909363,
-0.6860777735710144,
-0.029629774391651154,
-0.046410784125328064,
0.25665661692619324,
0.10966061800718307,
-0.3116890788078308,
0.7585244178771973,
0.5821171402931213,
0.09832613170146942,
-0.957787036895752,
0.16998620331287384,
-0.13360044360160828,
-0.3432132601737976,
0.48090189695358276,
-0.6352686882019043,
0.8043397665023804,
-0.7195225954055786,
0.1228904128074646,
-0.11630909889936447,
0.5094931125640869,
0.08438242226839066,
0.19056688249111176,
0.6865774393081665,
1.0084937810897827,
0.9330253601074219,
0.08234680444002151,
0.6761875152587891,
-0.039908722043037415,
0.2617606520652771,
1.1549084186553955,
-0.28454986214637756,
0.7545334100723267,
0.3049023449420929,
0.1278257817029953,
0.36242079734802246,
-0.1495523899793625,
-0.24742476642131805,
0.24068759381771088,
0.5120642781257629,
-0.19632954895496368,
-0.13143746554851532,
0.054694026708602905,
0.031150424852967262,
0.6647963523864746,
0.12143784761428833,
-0.486769437789917,
-0.10732318460941315,
0.2816723883152008,
0.5730977654457092,
0.12432534247636795,
-0.8902391791343689,
0.682292103767395,
0.22127889096736908,
-0.5344786047935486,
0.5913121104240417,
0.04209856316447258,
0.3274553418159485,
-0.37040603160858154,
-0.04560666158795357,
0.053035762161016464,
0.6499468684196472,
-0.2461531013250351,
-0.6529716849327087,
0.08189812302589417,
-0.17335183918476105,
-0.4041083753108978,
-0.4117670953273773,
0.6494118571281433,
-0.5500127077102661,
-0.17485396564006805,
0.5968351364135742,
0.3456205129623413,
0.05986330658197403,
-0.4940687119960785,
-0.5305662155151367,
-0.3619979918003082,
0.10453657805919647,
-0.5529478192329407,
0.6100996732711792,
0.5403767228126526,
-0.208504319190979,
1.026108741760254,
0.5585287809371948,
0.24580399692058563,
-0.022499922662973404,
0.38028836250305176,
0.7989515066146851,
-0.6867185831069946,
-0.29410287737846375,
-0.7129724025726318,
0.4131668210029602,
-0.198448047041893,
0.1481323391199112,
0.6331021189689636,
0.44636568427085876,
0.8219343423843384,
0.013514012098312378,
0.8260102868080139,
0.020180482417345047,
0.5127406120300293,
-0.654007613658905,
1.2083221673965454,
-0.40689173340797424,
-0.005647731013596058,
-0.08156385272741318,
-0.8560819625854492,
-0.11939336359500885,
0.1545027792453766,
-0.3010149896144867,
0.1169101744890213,
0.6684530377388,
0.4081701636314392,
-0.07034486532211304,
0.2089066207408905,
0.5888664126396179,
0.6025744676589966,
0.16743147373199463,
0.5828995704650879,
0.7556554079055786,
-0.16157737374305725,
0.5407479405403137,
-0.2965923547744751,
-0.5344111919403076,
-0.03204469755291939,
-0.7377451062202454,
-0.851861298084259,
-0.6363381147384644,
-0.22730474174022675,
-0.26864945888519287,
-0.10677047818899155,
0.490736722946167,
0.4215738773345947,
-0.7177987694740295,
-0.07244233787059784,
0.030575331300497055,
0.15465721487998962,
-0.6120193600654602,
-0.2332243174314499,
0.434889018535614,
-0.6858492493629456,
-0.45268285274505615,
0.24441668391227722,
0.08046381175518036,
-0.2823779582977295,
-0.10906928032636642,
0.14569851756095886,
-0.30450886487960815,
-0.14070920646190643,
0.801376461982727,
0.4508109390735626,
-0.29092469811439514,
-0.12604032456874847,
-0.602922260761261,
0.14297963678836823,
-0.3757498264312744,
1.040763258934021,
-0.35422348976135254,
0.17243951559066772,
0.3100936710834503,
0.7451828718185425,
0.7014347910881042,
-0.14464125037193298,
0.5454261302947998,
-0.5918201804161072,
-0.09795784950256348,
-0.05322816222906113,
0.8196240067481995,
0.27433523535728455,
-0.3026902675628662,
0.15073056519031525,
0.040377385914325714,
-0.6721463203430176,
-0.5986495018005371,
0.052464112639427185,
-0.48502814769744873,
-0.8532894849777222,
1.1524949073791504,
-0.3921206295490265,
-0.26240089535713196,
-0.18604759871959686,
-0.02318277396261692,
0.4249073565006256,
-0.22107598185539246,
0.8492638468742371,
0.6241428256034851,
0.3670974671840668,
-0.13333538174629211,
-0.6864221096038818,
0.33561500906944275,
0.14381307363510132,
-0.36597591638565063,
0.7741979360580444,
0.27922874689102173,
0.5561823844909668,
0.1259707510471344,
0.4461376368999481,
-0.22577673196792603,
-0.025293715298175812,
-0.023389538750052452,
0.31096866726875305,
-0.29750797152519226,
-0.4264678359031677,
-0.2704331874847412,
0.15175077319145203,
0.013038135133683681,
0.39415693283081055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16714v1
|
Crafting Interpretable Embeddings by Asking LLMs Questions
| 2024-05-26T22:30:29 | 2024-05-26T22:30:29 |
Vinamra Benara, Chandan Singh, John X. Morris, Richard Antonello, Ion Stoica, Alexander G. Huth, Jianfeng Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.NC
|
Large language models (LLMs) have rapidly improved text embeddings for a
growing array of natural-language processing tasks. However, their opaqueness
and proliferation into scientific domains such as neuroscience have created a
growing need for interpretability. Here, we ask whether we can obtain
interpretable embeddings through LLM prompting. We introduce question-answering
embeddings (QA-Emb), embeddings where each feature represents an answer to a
yes/no question asked to an LLM. Training QA-Emb reduces to selecting a set of
underlying questions rather than learning model weights.
We use QA-Emb to flexibly generate interpretable models for predicting fMRI
voxel responses to language stimuli. QA-Emb significantly outperforms an
established interpretable baseline, and does so while requiring very few
questions. This paves the way towards building flexible feature spaces that can
concretize and evaluate our understanding of semantic brain representations. We
additionally find that QA-Emb can be effectively approximated with an efficient
model, and we explore broader applications in simple NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.4526396095752716,
-0.9687513113021851,
1.1331477165222168,
0.19878201186656952,
-0.2927062213420868,
-0.26963284611701965,
-0.17908234894275665,
-0.373274564743042,
0.2535156011581421,
0.46217355132102966,
-0.7622367143630981,
-0.3920900225639343,
-0.6545687317848206,
0.14963552355766296,
-0.3216151297092438,
0.7784269452095032,
0.02890755422413349,
0.2583957016468048,
-0.7007570266723633,
-0.250240296125412,
-0.5239497423171997,
-0.2751941382884979,
-0.4985940456390381,
-0.34409239888191223,
0.5688053369522095,
0.1468627154827118,
0.8229386806488037,
0.5813130140304565,
-0.01775163598358631,
0.17687460780143738,
-0.41615626215934753,
0.07181166112422943,
-0.22649294137954712,
0.19024251401424408,
-0.09563014656305313,
-0.8772000074386597,
-0.19462327659130096,
-0.12422680854797363,
0.5520659685134888,
0.974307119846344,
-0.217081218957901,
0.11885128170251846,
0.1604582965373993,
0.13027989864349365,
-0.27457380294799805,
0.16527248919010162,
-0.7249818444252014,
0.005503898020833731,
0.2895304560661316,
-0.35012897849082947,
-0.5276079177856445,
-0.38764679431915283,
0.19038642942905426,
-0.44094112515449524,
-0.03332443907856941,
0.10172540694475174,
0.6175593733787537,
0.37173211574554443,
-0.32914140820503235,
-0.49150216579437256,
-0.2377488613128662,
0.6573805212974548,
-0.551270604133606,
0.5074641108512878,
0.602241575717926,
0.19598843157291412,
-0.14411146938800812,
-0.8422732353210449,
-0.655358076095581,
-0.1205279678106308,
-0.23629353940486908,
0.03309119865298271,
-0.19175511598587036,
0.012701423838734627,
0.24165277183055878,
0.14118258655071259,
-0.5549662709236145,
0.021455436944961548,
-0.14848525822162628,
-0.008973684161901474,
0.2502203583717346,
0.21267220377922058,
0.466838538646698,
-0.35956618189811707,
-0.26382166147232056,
-0.022271044552326202,
-0.7880222797393799,
-0.022458501160144806,
0.12830035388469696,
-0.030347386375069618,
-0.0433964766561985,
0.774200975894928,
0.2767714858055115,
0.613964855670929,
-0.0069627645425498486,
0.4647112190723419,
-0.12864883244037628,
0.03330320119857788,
-0.03704512119293213,
-0.20677734911441803,
0.24796617031097412,
0.27753686904907227,
0.14226840436458588,
-0.2768303453922272,
-0.1285172700881958,
-0.17364774644374847,
0.3747856914997101,
-0.7557022571563721,
-0.11354953050613403,
0.7048560380935669,
-0.4391571879386902,
-0.12586916983127594,
-0.10712094604969025,
-0.5339356660842896,
-0.46174731850624084,
-0.1228271871805191,
0.46763214468955994,
-0.5786097049713135,
-0.23477324843406677,
0.3978136479854584,
-0.18200545012950897,
0.7349315285682678,
0.4162181317806244,
-1.0233721733093262,
0.04506418853998184,
0.5934864282608032,
0.7187573313713074,
0.11912029981613159,
-0.06777361035346985,
-0.4340682625770569,
0.1068597137928009,
-0.21098420023918152,
0.8975836634635925,
-0.6661362051963806,
-0.4021177589893341,
-0.022540045902132988,
0.049496449530124664,
-0.07084523141384125,
-0.5354185700416565,
0.18361160159111023,
-0.8297640681266785,
0.24959750473499298,
-0.4750082194805145,
-0.749565064907074,
-0.35662588477134705,
0.4300692081451416,
-0.5182821750640869,
0.6033116579055786,
0.026701461523771286,
-0.7914987802505493,
0.14631910622119904,
-0.6411871314048767,
-0.13487885892391205,
0.09057006984949112,
-0.40434619784355164,
-0.0990491658449173,
0.43005549907684326,
0.6736470460891724,
0.7706255316734314,
-0.07144661247730255,
0.2548671364784241,
-0.53182053565979,
-0.13790364563465118,
0.7997393608093262,
-0.5088604092597961,
0.6113772392272949,
0.23035213351249695,
0.009671501815319061,
-0.09815599769353867,
-0.4698367714881897,
0.3604833781719208,
0.1520288735628128,
-0.39416614174842834,
-0.21676114201545715,
0.05584430322051048,
-0.10058716684579849,
-0.035533152520656586,
0.36875033378601074,
-0.5208013653755188,
-0.013996954075992107,
-0.4326919615268707,
0.7063818573951721,
0.7804576754570007,
0.04732357710599899,
0.3698735535144806,
-0.25513482093811035,
0.7152663469314575,
-0.03601251170039177,
-0.05429264158010483,
-0.21174795925617218,
-0.6758314371109009,
-0.505946695804596,
-0.32969120144844055,
0.23615066707134247,
0.32064586877822876,
-0.8846098780632019,
0.3276602327823639,
-0.17991210520267487,
-0.2533037066459656,
-0.9139117002487183,
-0.0068681747652590275,
0.06131786108016968,
0.3125542402267456,
0.49424368143081665,
0.10461422801017761,
-0.37161099910736084,
-0.9510555863380432,
-0.267925888299942,
-0.09208914637565613,
-0.35123002529144287,
0.4316222667694092,
0.39692214131355286,
-0.10226429253816605,
0.9137189984321594,
-0.7730244398117065,
0.16847321391105652,
-0.41020748019218445,
0.06536532938480377,
0.1627356857061386,
0.1262224316596985,
0.2500307261943817,
-0.6890043020248413,
-0.06689677387475967,
-0.22472718358039856,
-0.9620748162269592,
0.05228155478835106,
-0.2702646553516388,
0.10032904148101807,
-0.31899434328079224,
0.6522352695465088,
-0.6725960969924927,
0.04085922986268997,
0.6331615447998047,
-0.5104827284812927,
0.04985128343105316,
-0.2737734317779541,
-0.23237228393554688,
-1.1384302377700806,
0.0064929877407848835,
-0.3963100016117096,
-0.36380186676979065,
-0.5714521408081055,
0.07995995879173279,
0.16884127259254456,
-0.10958666354417801,
-0.5725014209747314,
0.6751081347465515,
-0.461948961019516,
-0.2941882312297821,
-0.05409552529454231,
0.24375464022159576,
0.33856824040412903,
0.3377053737640381,
0.11117325723171234,
0.6578665971755981,
0.5562856197357178,
-0.34253862500190735,
-0.20084497332572937,
0.5732181072235107,
-0.6039760708808899,
0.33385413885116577,
-0.7847356200218201,
0.3724460005760193,
-0.5960395336151123,
0.16667403280735016,
-1.0909979343414307,
-0.10242685675621033,
0.15748824179172516,
-0.49027228355407715,
0.2992953360080719,
0.012801864184439182,
-0.2430359423160553,
-0.02448227070271969,
-0.136702761054039,
0.41097959876060486,
0.5067844390869141,
-0.7673211097717285,
0.7356194853782654,
0.24250835180282593,
-0.26125314831733704,
-0.483931303024292,
-0.9602883458137512,
-0.03140001744031906,
-0.012765384279191494,
-0.5955559611320496,
0.1588301658630371,
-0.10096799582242966,
-0.002462259493768215,
0.27029186487197876,
0.0025241756811738014,
-0.017128583043813705,
0.24812418222427368,
0.3764704167842865,
0.20172876119613647,
-0.47658514976501465,
0.18912340700626373,
0.28785568475723267,
0.08474590629339218,
0.2947469651699066,
-0.1371251940727234,
0.46619582176208496,
-0.27645784616470337,
-0.40179580450057983,
-0.23771651089191437,
0.4812176823616028,
0.3919951021671295,
-0.12126617133617401,
0.8308663964271545,
0.5181423425674438,
-0.3879982829093933,
-0.3264819085597992,
-0.30585387349128723,
-0.5485644936561584,
-0.48811691999435425,
0.4158362150192261,
-0.4473252296447754,
-1.2747553586959839,
0.49725475907325745,
-0.11585355550050735,
-0.10342004150152206,
0.16223596036434174,
0.6314927935600281,
-0.5372440814971924,
1.2924264669418335,
0.46580228209495544,
0.522454023361206,
0.3422389328479767,
-0.23773407936096191,
0.10832338780164719,
-0.9774535894393921,
-0.33523833751678467,
-0.20661330223083496,
-0.3627780079841614,
-0.3137012720108032,
-0.7227790355682373,
0.4766468405723572,
0.01619296707212925,
0.31617215275764465,
0.07854094356298447,
-0.23085945844650269,
0.6276018023490906,
0.08507712185382843,
0.2569306492805481,
0.013289361260831356,
-0.12546446919441223,
-0.1556301862001419,
-0.045215312391519547,
-0.7889225482940674,
-0.6341457366943359,
0.90947425365448,
0.6706968545913696,
0.8474080562591553,
-0.20590226352214813,
0.4898845851421356,
-0.17650958895683289,
0.5347955822944641,
-0.9332470893859863,
0.4889181852340698,
0.14925868809223175,
-0.7508987188339233,
-0.25327539443969727,
-0.18938742578029633,
-1.0405529737472534,
0.4754704236984253,
-0.44936811923980713,
-0.607511043548584,
0.32923153042793274,
0.01920379512012005,
-0.5697818994522095,
0.3677302896976471,
-0.6939420104026794,
0.8022117018699646,
-0.21733956038951874,
0.1873505860567093,
-0.2589520812034607,
-0.38500455021858215,
0.19477489590644836,
0.20271797478199005,
0.07846689969301224,
-0.022987734526395798,
-0.3909755051136017,
0.48923757672309875,
0.10780546069145203,
0.7649868726730347,
-0.18477408587932587,
-0.014804719015955925,
0.29236823320388794,
0.05730721354484558,
0.20756278932094574,
0.4274947941303253,
-0.2918722629547119,
0.18401972949504852,
0.3029649257659912,
-0.40069907903671265,
-1.1138039827346802,
0.5053183436393738,
-0.7423900961875916,
-0.7741724848747253,
-0.25623640418052673,
-0.8523606657981873,
-0.3843129873275757,
-0.07392552495002747,
0.04343928024172783,
0.5160886645317078,
-0.16513389348983765,
0.38289085030555725,
0.9033889174461365,
-0.6270724534988403,
0.10433924198150635,
0.27292752265930176,
-0.4079405963420868,
-0.3380790948867798,
0.7196595668792725,
-0.07174717634916306,
0.1707429140806198,
0.4439191520214081,
0.20433515310287476,
-0.6974250078201294,
-0.8188542723655701,
-0.4688457250595093,
0.4496088922023773,
-0.8929476737976074,
0.08097094297409058,
-0.7868550419807434,
-0.12794625759124756,
-0.06501559913158417,
-0.11951900273561478,
-0.04265831410884857,
-0.4053993821144104,
-0.51897132396698,
-0.31406381726264954,
0.2456105351448059,
0.945636510848999,
0.22439032793045044,
0.11808403581380844,
-0.8468026518821716,
0.3202586770057678,
0.5072510838508606,
0.29457277059555054,
-0.1507899910211563,
-0.4911224842071533,
-0.2154470831155777,
0.16016629338264465,
-0.11872155964374542,
-1.0217859745025635,
0.23863744735717773,
0.2025502622127533,
0.5455487966537476,
0.3004259467124939,
-0.029652196913957596,
0.429091215133667,
-0.431800901889801,
0.7144024968147278,
-0.0011469246819615364,
-0.8096635937690735,
0.5104798674583435,
-0.1751830130815506,
0.3623373210430145,
0.3589935302734375,
0.7406260371208191,
-0.39203712344169617,
-0.5480217337608337,
-0.5478231310844421,
-0.6474871039390564,
0.4980534017086029,
0.06707672774791718,
0.5741563439369202,
-0.32382887601852417,
0.5998591780662537,
0.18488621711730957,
0.10565104335546494,
-0.5125475525856018,
-0.027243517339229584,
-0.17158496379852295,
-0.2587379515171051,
0.02528293989598751,
-0.3880460560321808,
-0.14368543028831482,
-0.04658845067024231,
0.16305406391620636,
-0.47365155816078186,
0.5740980505943298,
0.25906306505203247,
-0.2735784649848938,
0.12893612682819366,
0.43796220421791077,
0.3297683000564575,
0.7026645541191101,
-0.4141635596752167,
0.24718399345874786,
0.5185566544532776,
-0.22839604318141937,
-0.041195519268512726,
-0.18436415493488312,
-0.10180933773517609,
-0.1038992628455162,
0.28389349579811096,
0.861515998840332,
0.02584848925471306,
-0.8068960309028625,
0.5104373097419739,
-0.4487714469432831,
-0.36399218440055847,
-0.24256810545921326,
-0.033672649413347244,
0.6253949403762817,
0.4483647346496582,
0.009254026226699352,
-0.2576877176761627,
-0.010880564339458942,
-0.6327900290489197,
0.1966608166694641,
0.49545684456825256,
-0.6377484798431396,
-0.2617133557796478,
0.6013033986091614,
-0.18793238699436188,
-0.060660216957330704,
0.7162907123565674,
0.18255871534347534,
-0.34669792652130127,
0.47548073530197144,
0.6004846096038818,
0.808668315410614,
-0.018066558986902237,
0.30548524856567383,
0.07708897441625595,
0.28791317343711853,
0.25675085186958313,
0.8305978178977966,
0.016528937965631485,
-0.8844319581985474,
-0.41119658946990967,
-0.7205108404159546,
-0.62623131275177,
0.19409538805484772,
-0.9813998937606812,
0.06873556971549988,
-0.6503055095672607,
-0.11247648298740387,
0.1717514544725418,
-0.5408660173416138,
-0.5781204700469971,
0.3091519773006439,
0.2298683226108551,
0.9233263731002808,
-0.725952684879303,
0.9463043808937073,
0.9344865083694458,
-0.3560412526130676,
-0.7477582693099976,
0.03570357337594032,
-0.43720367550849915,
-1.0075287818908691,
0.36529818177223206,
0.21761879324913025,
0.18142856657505035,
0.1459742784500122,
-0.7891878485679626,
-0.7615219950675964,
1.1140140295028687,
0.5811914801597595,
-0.17720027267932892,
-0.059667740017175674,
0.13699573278427124,
0.5258281826972961,
-0.39922282099723816,
0.371608704328537,
0.5484653115272522,
0.4803347885608673,
-0.015188987366855145,
-0.120763398706913,
0.448757141828537,
-0.1217859536409378,
-0.07632578164339066,
-0.04843606427311897,
-0.19334763288497925,
0.6250815987586975,
-0.3456878066062927,
-0.26297691464424133,
0.01213184092193842,
0.8701392412185669,
0.24481429159641266,
0.09365697205066681,
0.6246654391288757,
0.34048792719841003,
0.885692298412323,
-0.03570010885596275,
1.2561701536178589,
-0.17772012948989868,
0.028483280912041664,
0.8479422330856323,
0.12190031260251999,
1.2216014862060547,
0.8981382250785828,
-0.11060457676649094,
0.5383861064910889,
0.7583211064338684,
0.01283964142203331,
0.42910608649253845,
0.28801119327545166,
-0.06767401099205017,
-0.6855182647705078,
-0.13641254603862762,
-0.15621639788150787,
0.48175159096717834,
0.7218747138977051,
-0.18035100400447845,
-0.20271947979927063,
0.11656836420297623,
-0.22862271964550018,
0.042057670652866364,
-0.01784394308924675,
0.7080056071281433,
0.6110410690307617,
-0.5864177942276001,
0.5682951211929321,
-0.04233163222670555,
0.5827709436416626,
-0.6993013620376587,
-0.16535988450050354,
-0.22171036899089813,
-0.16016411781311035,
-0.15609216690063477,
-1.1643258333206177,
0.5384312272071838,
-0.07694394141435623,
-0.18557268381118774,
-0.4476124048233032,
0.4179763197898865,
-0.5269289016723633,
-0.2946709096431732,
0.22928670048713684,
0.8589971661567688,
0.2901267111301422,
-0.09845345467329025,
-0.7597783803939819,
-0.15264910459518433,
-0.10541210323572159,
-0.46113350987434387,
0.556829571723938,
0.3129107654094696,
0.14036446809768677,
0.9287904500961304,
0.6926165819168091,
0.1123163253068924,
0.006969911511987448,
-0.03219565376639366,
0.9205494523048401,
-0.6769707202911377,
-0.4149477183818817,
-0.5681627988815308,
0.525874674320221,
0.347443163394928,
-0.15362267196178436,
0.3645237982273102,
-0.03963469713926315,
0.5173602104187012,
-0.09796258807182312,
0.6782114505767822,
-0.15720222890377045,
0.2815362215042114,
-0.8842229843139648,
0.8563308715820312,
-0.7967026233673096,
0.3679857552051544,
0.3239337205886841,
-0.7897453904151917,
-0.23924340307712555,
0.6498351097106934,
-0.3877094089984894,
-0.032346758991479874,
0.8952065110206604,
0.9836845993995667,
-0.018974656239151955,
0.4578862190246582,
0.6431560516357422,
0.37984684109687805,
0.17168332636356354,
0.5303879380226135,
1.3138350248336792,
-0.19159695506095886,
0.5910693407058716,
0.10938078165054321,
0.14635956287384033,
0.044344693422317505,
-0.9303549528121948,
-0.9156328439712524,
-0.35421159863471985,
-0.24878238141536713,
-0.44916507601737976,
-0.23292410373687744,
0.9532614350318909,
0.39334040880203247,
-0.9120340943336487,
0.02087230235338211,
0.24071291089057922,
0.3526625633239746,
-0.07508347183465958,
-0.17552435398101807,
0.5090885162353516,
-0.39473429322242737,
-0.6251634359359741,
0.49215245246887207,
0.20655283331871033,
0.10301040858030319,
-0.4447087347507477,
0.07708264142274857,
-0.1516820788383484,
0.2633572816848755,
0.47466176748275757,
-0.04989754408597946,
-0.7164186239242554,
-0.5858967304229736,
0.33234158158302307,
0.031870629638433456,
0.04202507063746452,
0.6617477536201477,
-0.5608038902282715,
0.4143809974193573,
0.6027758717536926,
1.1708711385726929,
0.47276440262794495,
-0.17284098267555237,
0.8378368020057678,
-0.5972562432289124,
-0.1291850060224533,
0.4013226330280304,
0.44862231612205505,
0.38817623257637024,
-0.4270075261592865,
0.2000489979982376,
-0.26286599040031433,
-0.3425731062889099,
-0.6792161464691162,
0.2052803635597229,
-1.0095432996749878,
-0.45790886878967285,
1.220700740814209,
-0.44292372465133667,
-0.46755385398864746,
-0.30901920795440674,
-0.12533259391784668,
-0.0196903757750988,
0.09172988682985306,
0.5016253590583801,
0.7892258763313293,
-0.15948599576950073,
-0.37368154525756836,
-0.6669575572013855,
0.46376165747642517,
0.8351090550422668,
-0.7044585347175598,
-0.09099052846431732,
0.23206906020641327,
0.4949750006198883,
-0.14603254199028015,
0.40702730417251587,
-0.2518448531627655,
0.2947945296764374,
-0.053982533514499664,
-0.1693125069141388,
-0.1133846715092659,
-0.12437227368354797,
-0.7559753656387329,
0.2613835036754608,
0.45174574851989746,
-0.06748779863119125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16712v1
|
Zamba: A Compact 7B SSM Hybrid Model
| 2024-05-26T22:23:02 | 2024-05-26T22:23:02 |
Paolo Glorioso, Quentin Anthony, Yury Tokpanov, James Whittington, Jonathan Pilault, Adam Ibrahim, Beren Millidge
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this technical report, we present Zamba, a novel 7B SSM-transformer hybrid
model which achieves competitive performance against leading open-weight models
at a comparable scale. Zamba is trained on 1T tokens from openly available
datasets and is the best non-transformer model at this scale. Zamba pioneers a
unique architecture combining a Mamba backbone with a single shared attention
module, thus obtaining the benefits of attention at minimal parameter cost. Due
to its architecture, Zamba is significantly faster at inference than comparable
transformer models and requires substantially less memory for generation of
long sequences. Zamba is pretrained in two phases: the first phase is based on
existing web datasets, while the second one consists of annealing the model
over high-quality instruct and synthetic datasets, and is characterized by a
rapid learning rate decay. We open-source the weights and all checkpoints for
Zamba, through both phase 1 and annealing phases.
|
[
-0.39129936695098877,
-0.31870853900909424,
0.16297735273838043,
0.24307359755039215,
-0.5873669385910034,
0.20694810152053833,
0.08996084332466125,
-0.1465827375650406,
0.3743768036365509,
0.4984379708766937,
-0.5276001691818237,
-0.17212603986263275,
-0.36047908663749695,
-0.0819302499294281,
-0.5284314155578613,
0.4841766655445099,
0.23831842839717865,
0.17172293365001678,
0.009923664852976799,
-0.22104103863239288,
-0.38286975026130676,
-0.45367443561553955,
-0.12265773862600327,
-0.69842928647995,
0.6098501086235046,
0.343034565448761,
0.7950983643531799,
0.4221755266189575,
0.33586350083351135,
0.2804429233074188,
-0.3901471495628357,
0.0075782667845487595,
-0.6060483455657959,
-0.2633926570415497,
-0.25960811972618103,
-0.8438000679016113,
-0.34589534997940063,
-0.13710404932498932,
0.6442608833312988,
0.7048445343971252,
-0.3151145875453949,
0.10779961198568344,
-0.308439701795578,
0.9654675722122192,
-0.7722845673561096,
-0.12984244525432587,
-0.5836175084114075,
0.05686899647116661,
-0.3116455674171448,
0.1968793123960495,
-0.7131177186965942,
-0.5446625351905823,
-0.2634887099266052,
-0.3269631564617157,
0.5286903381347656,
-0.028201604261994362,
0.7194212675094604,
0.389880508184433,
-0.5653742551803589,
0.14200550317764282,
-0.9397820234298706,
0.5811503529548645,
-0.4010466933250427,
0.376720666885376,
-0.012006092816591263,
1.0613036155700684,
-0.03087775409221649,
-0.6537009477615356,
-0.5638794302940369,
0.052831050008535385,
0.1785789281129837,
0.4544864594936371,
-0.14448441565036774,
0.010689587332308292,
0.06099306792020798,
0.6099509596824646,
-0.48798125982284546,
0.11266665160655975,
-0.8549357056617737,
0.10742805898189545,
0.5754638314247131,
0.15555596351623535,
0.05337845906615257,
-0.41625070571899414,
-0.6708218455314636,
-0.10731933265924454,
-0.552690863609314,
-0.0003554728755261749,
0.6022704839706421,
0.2423650175333023,
-0.26198458671569824,
0.46941885352134705,
-0.33960598707199097,
0.6841491460800171,
0.37595126032829285,
0.012888964265584946,
0.23889625072479248,
-0.26299387216567993,
-0.2944251298904419,
0.34797927737236023,
0.8300434350967407,
0.23020386695861816,
-0.21211150288581848,
-0.42409583926200867,
-0.06358877569437027,
0.33677300810813904,
0.6679350137710571,
-0.7168784141540527,
-0.24336443841457367,
0.15307487547397614,
-0.8810669183731079,
-0.08929404616355896,
0.17916296422481537,
-0.6648736596107483,
-0.5244945287704468,
-0.20740368962287903,
0.6675188541412354,
-0.6077073216438293,
-0.5035801529884338,
0.19639952480793,
-0.11272932589054108,
0.32627689838409424,
0.1645343005657196,
-0.6054072976112366,
0.14692148566246033,
0.07816506177186966,
0.9032089710235596,
0.017160996794700623,
0.13032911717891693,
-0.01293334923684597,
0.1981721818447113,
-0.5025165677070618,
1.0146379470825195,
-0.2904113829135895,
-0.7358331084251404,
-0.4491431713104248,
-0.13823959231376648,
-0.37510183453559875,
-0.8064401149749756,
0.4423375129699707,
-0.4117816090583801,
-0.10125220566987991,
-0.10360714793205261,
-0.279232382774353,
-0.4877221882343292,
-0.10386576503515244,
-0.9052677750587463,
1.1251956224441528,
0.6172383427619934,
-0.2685406804084778,
0.19860033690929413,
-0.7395060658454895,
-0.49855321645736694,
0.27895107865333557,
0.12374231964349747,
-0.5472274422645569,
0.1956186592578888,
-0.24265512824058533,
0.33450961112976074,
-0.6181380748748779,
0.1560564488172531,
-0.25564950704574585,
-0.6052284836769104,
0.17374207079410553,
0.3424414098262787,
0.37846970558166504,
0.3738044202327728,
-0.3462931215763092,
0.4822937250137329,
-1.2879538536071777,
-0.029558902606368065,
0.2877231240272522,
-0.11065244674682617,
0.016524266451597214,
-0.0029572092462331057,
-0.08192585408687592,
0.44945839047431946,
0.16597360372543335,
-0.5194638967514038,
-0.053857795894145966,
-0.29966938495635986,
0.527863085269928,
0.49709147214889526,
-0.22542749345302582,
0.5756374001502991,
-0.3089263141155243,
0.6849812865257263,
0.21675631403923035,
0.600348949432373,
-0.2692725956439972,
-0.09210701286792755,
-0.974428653717041,
-0.4738864302635193,
0.5330437421798706,
0.22214673459529877,
-0.8100724220275879,
0.8194327354431152,
-0.1028265431523323,
-1.1273040771484375,
-0.6904916763305664,
0.07197001576423645,
0.25198301672935486,
0.1968703418970108,
0.4719986617565155,
-0.2552972733974457,
-0.621185302734375,
-1.4767727851867676,
0.1664973348379135,
0.35155054926872253,
0.05196831375360489,
-0.035784851759672165,
0.38132116198539734,
-0.08759887516498566,
0.9499768018722534,
-0.1775076985359192,
-0.28437671065330505,
-1.0149747133255005,
0.16980195045471191,
0.26711371541023254,
0.3865102231502533,
0.7595955729484558,
-0.8097171783447266,
-0.36542758345603943,
0.08427701145410538,
-0.7119683027267456,
0.04322667792439461,
-0.20994600653648376,
-0.37719231843948364,
-0.18453648686408997,
0.10075969994068146,
-0.6319442391395569,
0.33933162689208984,
0.327711820602417,
0.042262014001607895,
0.05660463497042656,
-0.05698100104928017,
-0.039349623024463654,
-1.2633570432662964,
0.23478098213672638,
0.0037254616618156433,
0.045130565762519836,
-0.6217223405838013,
0.07347598671913147,
0.6376038193702698,
-0.11986003816127777,
-0.5420193076133728,
0.02971681021153927,
-0.6179323792457581,
-0.3008217513561249,
-0.5339667797088623,
-0.07103054970502853,
-0.2567630410194397,
0.6069517731666565,
-0.2545340657234192,
0.5120351314544678,
0.21093422174453735,
-0.6155845522880554,
0.3433227241039276,
0.22616642713546753,
-0.6704503893852234,
0.5656556487083435,
-0.6983082890510559,
0.28153952956199646,
-0.16759006679058075,
0.3521014153957367,
-0.6963667273521423,
-0.16894623637199402,
0.03886976093053818,
-0.4221157431602478,
0.1919940561056137,
-0.26782357692718506,
-0.7606312036514282,
-0.6989129185676575,
-0.19550353288650513,
-0.03315122053027153,
0.799350917339325,
-0.5286757946014404,
1.2041831016540527,
0.09091587364673615,
0.31408122181892395,
-0.017213791608810425,
-0.39640989899635315,
-0.20380474627017975,
-0.17859160900115967,
-0.657803475856781,
0.2522547245025635,
0.0028124258387833834,
0.20281939208507538,
-0.2022840827703476,
-0.35845378041267395,
0.006129527930170298,
0.28297656774520874,
0.65947026014328,
0.464633971452713,
-0.13285548985004425,
-0.31368088722229004,
0.26563119888305664,
-0.2484508454799652,
-0.18597695231437683,
0.24475832283496857,
0.8773553967475891,
0.1904216706752777,
-0.11350099742412567,
-0.5041913986206055,
0.40443751215934753,
0.5716970562934875,
-0.2511943280696869,
1.2877330780029297,
0.3420686423778534,
-0.38537654280662537,
-0.3813011646270752,
-0.42583319544792175,
0.3912909924983978,
-0.4977898895740509,
0.18447639048099518,
-0.5043002367019653,
-0.251353919506073,
0.7159181833267212,
-0.1981409341096878,
-0.19291669130325317,
0.5344846248626709,
0.7872522473335266,
0.13535338640213013,
1.0338962078094482,
0.6431558728218079,
0.25507932901382446,
0.5583929419517517,
-0.3481749892234802,
0.43077704310417175,
-0.7841309309005737,
-0.8826884031295776,
-0.7354879379272461,
-0.6898661851882935,
-0.05438776686787605,
-0.4099069833755493,
0.40853267908096313,
0.5152602195739746,
-0.20085111260414124,
0.529548168182373,
-0.4696257412433624,
0.5969832539558411,
0.6798362135887146,
0.3721996545791626,
0.03598563000559807,
-0.6040573716163635,
-0.15054695308208466,
0.3490641415119171,
-1.0242832899093628,
-0.31638848781585693,
0.9862099289894104,
-0.16287119686603546,
0.9401325583457947,
0.14328958094120026,
0.45014292001724243,
0.12715329229831696,
0.20252570509910583,
-0.6504396200180054,
0.568252444267273,
0.16272707283496857,
-0.6273160576820374,
0.3102615475654602,
-0.40522706508636475,
-0.7568543553352356,
0.47988370060920715,
-0.17309138178825378,
-0.42705729603767395,
0.20039962232112885,
0.08241453766822815,
-0.670160710811615,
0.42944881319999695,
-1.0698213577270508,
0.5980924963951111,
-0.18255844712257385,
-0.08003075420856476,
-0.23360836505889893,
-1.0534601211547852,
0.5940882563591003,
-0.21313203871250153,
0.013558708131313324,
-0.08629103004932404,
0.3220888674259186,
0.6645323038101196,
-0.22526274621486664,
0.7169696688652039,
-0.25751569867134094,
0.3656167984008789,
0.25958138704299927,
-0.11171601712703705,
0.20922991633415222,
-0.5698124766349792,
0.004894180689007044,
0.12707707285881042,
-0.32543861865997314,
-0.5350769758224487,
-0.5603724718093872,
0.4542267620563507,
-0.9538367986679077,
-0.25107744336128235,
-0.2563217878341675,
-0.6166537404060364,
-0.18682560324668884,
0.29224255681037903,
0.31032076478004456,
0.16197149455547333,
-0.0248863622546196,
0.7699151039123535,
0.7282007932662964,
-0.2442249357700348,
0.3354591727256775,
0.5071744918823242,
-0.04781310260295868,
-0.5002225041389465,
0.7282332181930542,
0.37754490971565247,
0.6169784069061279,
0.3999633193016052,
0.04157019034028053,
-0.29435718059539795,
-0.6410617828369141,
-0.4616223871707916,
0.18121394515037537,
-0.6084725856781006,
-0.4181530773639679,
-0.7338021993637085,
-0.4387906789779663,
-0.3607512414455414,
-0.2373855710029602,
-0.7771908044815063,
-0.47777676582336426,
-0.029606152325868607,
-0.31619489192962646,
0.17292112112045288,
0.8011906743049622,
-0.024966493248939514,
0.7938122749328613,
-0.8607916235923767,
0.602655827999115,
-0.14773857593536377,
0.2961937189102173,
0.16387920081615448,
-0.3039861023426056,
-0.6062094569206238,
-0.10084563493728638,
-0.5693982243537903,
-0.7976027131080627,
0.15499082207679749,
-0.06910881400108337,
0.8311494588851929,
0.5925332307815552,
0.3501329720020294,
0.4233871102333069,
-0.13644176721572876,
0.8526563048362732,
0.6378671526908875,
-0.7913364171981812,
0.7425669431686401,
-0.24337998032569885,
0.35905101895332336,
0.2527472674846649,
0.4596019387245178,
-0.13372202217578888,
0.02636169083416462,
-0.5570198893547058,
-0.763955295085907,
1.0113741159439087,
0.36026859283447266,
-0.30342403054237366,
0.32227054238319397,
0.22149346768856049,
0.5471746921539307,
0.3172377049922943,
-0.3787877559661865,
-0.4483998119831085,
-0.6516395807266235,
-0.32281434535980225,
-0.15446418523788452,
-0.15735848248004913,
-0.07911853492259979,
-0.18652808666229248,
0.669245183467865,
-0.12204476445913315,
0.3172528147697449,
-0.18428996205329895,
-0.419761061668396,
-0.21197335422039032,
0.17375405132770538,
0.539461612701416,
0.5356992483139038,
-0.2169319987297058,
-0.1971873641014099,
-0.027634209021925926,
-0.24085767567157745,
0.16454188525676727,
0.2646959722042084,
-0.27493417263031006,
-0.03780630603432655,
-0.1190696656703949,
0.9437261819839478,
0.6401835083961487,
-0.5675251483917236,
0.0659915953874588,
0.10160015523433685,
-0.4212598502635956,
0.013762874528765678,
0.5129677653312683,
0.28174522519111633,
0.4860028922557831,
0.5192810297012329,
0.15867328643798828,
0.014943179674446583,
-0.554940402507782,
-0.2913263738155365,
0.027674196287989616,
-0.1261749267578125,
-0.43922460079193115,
0.9647070169448853,
0.2952008545398712,
-0.22353611886501312,
0.2908514440059662,
0.29167360067367554,
-0.5749815702438354,
0.6845783591270447,
0.42149969935417175,
0.5680237412452698,
-0.5116758942604065,
0.2420319765806198,
0.3555819094181061,
0.2586819529533386,
-0.27941572666168213,
0.24570804834365845,
-0.2862752079963684,
-0.5479238033294678,
0.16357092559337616,
-0.6104103326797485,
-0.6233994960784912,
-0.16472077369689941,
-1.2508249282836914,
0.12148953229188919,
-0.7126986384391785,
-0.20732425153255463,
0.01972496137022972,
-0.08236707001924515,
-0.2959500849246979,
0.30560481548309326,
0.13100335001945496,
0.9878784418106079,
-0.6755879521369934,
1.0332458019256592,
0.4545300006866455,
-0.48998185992240906,
-0.6238383054733276,
-0.760722815990448,
-0.1256123185157776,
-0.6749906539916992,
0.08920523524284363,
0.44571244716644287,
-0.174373060464859,
0.02485531195998192,
-0.41008469462394714,
-0.6699205040931702,
1.4585318565368652,
0.46991753578186035,
-0.7258421182632446,
-0.25442996621131897,
0.13215982913970947,
0.10252808034420013,
-0.007652402389794588,
0.04429877921938896,
0.5824968814849854,
0.31190139055252075,
0.4534638226032257,
-0.6148912310600281,
-0.2957341969013214,
-0.40308043360710144,
0.21980470418930054,
0.6659096479415894,
-1.4201076030731201,
0.8786337971687317,
-0.10428965091705322,
-0.19563734531402588,
0.5269509553909302,
0.8849450945854187,
0.05780494585633278,
0.11171190440654755,
0.4110889434814453,
0.6060659885406494,
0.6949783563613892,
-0.29787760972976685,
1.0346834659576416,
-0.26127782464027405,
0.35123884677886963,
1.1291429996490479,
-0.7925543785095215,
0.4701082408428192,
0.249154195189476,
-0.12507875263690948,
0.528792142868042,
0.7997822761535645,
-0.1612464338541031,
0.7537748217582703,
-0.01971307024359703,
-0.10571978241205215,
-0.5622567534446716,
0.0007436166633851826,
-0.7290393710136414,
0.17253251373767853,
-0.02980630472302437,
-0.393250048160553,
-0.17545907199382782,
0.07352754473686218,
-0.39101243019104004,
0.02844509854912758,
-0.589128315448761,
0.46257007122039795,
0.0804804340004921,
-0.2814774811267853,
0.20268000662326813,
0.12514139711856842,
0.5967684388160706,
-1.1371666193008423,
0.3247475326061249,
-0.46421635150909424,
0.525592565536499,
-0.13520704209804535,
-0.24972936511039734,
0.20623859763145447,
-0.09069577604532242,
-0.4478740394115448,
-0.0426567941904068,
0.639406144618988,
-0.09513956308364868,
-0.5216078758239746,
0.41590431332588196,
0.2520609498023987,
-0.2563862204551697,
-0.14513103663921356,
-0.38741689920425415,
0.1584399789571762,
-0.38546204566955566,
-0.07336411625146866,
0.6182671785354614,
0.09596531093120575,
0.254963219165802,
0.8508672714233398,
0.6414838433265686,
-0.3879660367965698,
0.5574142932891846,
0.06235772371292114,
0.8541358113288879,
-1.0829038619995117,
-0.7874476313591003,
-0.2709730863571167,
0.4881833493709564,
-0.07679982483386993,
-0.05219123139977455,
0.7624067068099976,
0.7838464379310608,
0.5716657638549805,
-0.0909220278263092,
0.7827996015548706,
0.02433823235332966,
0.552803635597229,
-0.5444292426109314,
0.8102246522903442,
-0.3862327039241791,
-0.39762672781944275,
0.19693933427333832,
-0.8002208471298218,
0.07026910781860352,
0.5366293787956238,
0.05763353407382965,
0.1261899769306183,
0.7041467428207397,
0.5385812520980835,
0.0815286785364151,
0.46944430470466614,
0.4201379120349884,
0.22790640592575073,
-0.012155264616012573,
0.74892258644104,
0.7792048454284668,
-0.5966209173202515,
0.6275901794433594,
-0.38242149353027344,
0.008677225559949875,
-0.2947200834751129,
-0.30444109439849854,
-1.1479703187942505,
-0.31690388917922974,
-0.04229673370718956,
-0.24904148280620575,
-0.14181631803512573,
0.8342244029045105,
0.7927034497261047,
-0.4910142123699188,
-0.08665115386247635,
0.3228481113910675,
0.033397357910871506,
-0.32267430424690247,
-0.20158003270626068,
-0.013245392590761185,
0.26245155930519104,
-0.6175200343132019,
0.7286679148674011,
0.42322149872779846,
0.11002321541309357,
-0.30173459649086,
0.07963310182094574,
-0.35157510638237,
0.26940450072288513,
0.46977847814559937,
0.023247916251420975,
-0.4541782736778259,
0.1034456267952919,
-0.09227659553289413,
0.03366430103778839,
0.4327104985713959,
0.8815070390701294,
-0.7458471655845642,
0.2763381600379944,
0.22096963226795197,
0.4523812234401703,
0.7380384206771851,
-0.060540758073329926,
0.5995132327079773,
-0.2336319386959076,
0.31014159321784973,
0.06524558365345001,
0.5021833181381226,
0.3010479509830475,
-0.1566479355096817,
0.6579967141151428,
0.3550754487514496,
-0.0015555480495095253,
-0.8071374297142029,
-0.07753385603427887,
-1.5374940633773804,
-0.1956912726163864,
0.6948026418685913,
0.020552532747387886,
-0.45850443840026855,
0.19977782666683197,
-0.10960362106561661,
0.4063083529472351,
-0.27780881524086,
0.6029858589172363,
0.43974244594573975,
0.1144828200340271,
-0.16355901956558228,
-0.1301783174276352,
-0.31428274512290955,
0.10053372383117676,
-0.8066111207008362,
-0.5200018882751465,
0.24875508248806,
0.3448789417743683,
0.10130258649587631,
0.13070395588874817,
-0.19264212250709534,
0.4963426887989044,
0.32810017466545105,
0.3462072014808655,
-0.3437976837158203,
-0.562178909778595,
-0.10334467142820358,
0.5487129092216492,
-0.5676217079162598,
-0.348291277885437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01606v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01606v1
|
SymTax: Symbiotic Relationship and Taxonomy Fusion for Effective Citation Recommendation
| 2024-05-26T21:51:58 | 2024-05-26T21:51:58 |
Karan Goyal, Mayank Goel, Vikram Goyal, Mukesh Mohania
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Citing pertinent literature is pivotal to writing and reviewing a scientific
document. Existing techniques mainly focus on the local context or the global
context for recommending citations but fail to consider the actual human
citation behaviour. We propose SymTax, a three-stage recommendation
architecture that considers both the local and the global context, and
additionally the taxonomical representations of query-candidate tuples and the
Symbiosis prevailing amongst them. SymTax learns to embed the infused
taxonomies in the hyperbolic space and uses hyperbolic separation as a latent
feature to compute query-candidate similarity. We build a novel and large
dataset ArSyTa containing 8.27 million citation contexts and describe the
creation process in detail. We conduct extensive experiments and ablation
studies to demonstrate the effectiveness and design choice of each module in
our framework. Also, combinatorial analysis from our experiments shed light on
the choice of language models (LMs) and fusion embedding, and the inclusion of
section heading as a signal. Our proposed module that captures the symbiotic
relationship solely leads to performance gains of 26.66% and 39.25% in Recall@5
w.r.t. SOTA on ACL-200 and RefSeer datasets, respectively. The complete
framework yields a gain of 22.56% in Recall@5 wrt SOTA on our proposed dataset.
The code and dataset are available at https://github.com/goyalkaraniit/SymTax
|
[
-0.39693716168403625,
-0.4436052441596985,
0.6530415415763855,
0.25218209624290466,
-0.420439749956131,
-0.05637039616703987,
0.23348554968833923,
-0.5352165699005127,
0.5307033061981201,
0.39967456459999084,
-0.1201547160744667,
-0.3395736515522003,
-0.24051536619663239,
0.4325004816055298,
-0.21406389772891998,
1.0818685293197632,
0.026710977777838707,
-0.0014942738926038146,
-0.49736371636390686,
-0.46962854266166687,
-0.5273714661598206,
-0.5509456396102905,
-0.3055500388145447,
-0.6707490682601929,
0.9231513142585754,
-0.07802233099937439,
0.6300228238105774,
0.6799637079238892,
0.48775359988212585,
0.1819954663515091,
-0.2883373498916626,
0.26360613107681274,
-0.44890910387039185,
0.752685010433197,
-0.6703374981880188,
-0.2870282828807831,
-0.27409833669662476,
-0.2615269124507904,
0.7547156810760498,
0.44906988739967346,
-0.022337835282087326,
0.15110018849372864,
0.051098357886075974,
0.2139429748058319,
-0.6863934993743896,
0.1501922309398651,
-0.6643393635749817,
-0.30825933814048767,
-0.41128766536712646,
-0.4316633641719818,
-0.45671015977859497,
-0.36784911155700684,
0.15257185697555542,
-0.6158450245857239,
-0.2630198001861572,
0.36847424507141113,
0.7233347296714783,
0.011044781655073166,
-0.4880330562591553,
0.034931980073451996,
-0.65636146068573,
0.43757370114326477,
-0.18736450374126434,
0.2701672613620758,
0.5104446411132812,
0.12055838108062744,
-0.16370895504951477,
-0.780372679233551,
-0.3989870846271515,
0.14360684156417847,
-0.19866177439689636,
-0.08807355910539627,
-0.6182027459144592,
-0.15143156051635742,
0.10676753520965576,
0.05471591278910637,
-0.7851107716560364,
-0.39015328884124756,
-0.1808289885520935,
-0.21138593554496765,
0.30608105659484863,
0.10088925063610077,
0.10171937942504883,
-0.40953585505485535,
-0.4898001551628113,
-0.1296459287405014,
-0.8265951871871948,
-0.5441622138023376,
0.02555428259074688,
0.451474666595459,
0.22552204132080078,
0.3674538731575012,
0.19151562452316284,
0.5853312611579895,
-0.3120303153991699,
0.13448596000671387,
0.23125362396240234,
-0.5330919623374939,
-0.004410764202475548,
0.02565108612179756,
0.6875351071357727,
0.17862296104431152,
0.012891380116343498,
-0.21401943266391754,
-0.20774027705192566,
0.11568009853363037,
0.2625735402107239,
-0.4897233843803406,
-0.2754547894001007,
-0.008492117747664452,
-0.22964559495449066,
0.11042813211679459,
0.1723516583442688,
-0.6214155554771423,
-0.5413104295730591,
-0.36932137608528137,
0.7831366658210754,
-0.6953291296958923,
-0.3819843828678131,
-0.2376115918159485,
-0.31798696517944336,
-0.0692410096526146,
0.09535577893257141,
-0.3518869876861572,
0.2095249444246292,
0.523820161819458,
1.1511090993881226,
-0.053827546536922455,
-0.5202787518501282,
-0.3503477871417999,
0.6046275496482849,
0.14698904752731323,
1.2646770477294922,
-0.8792682886123657,
-0.6095224022865295,
-0.03128177672624588,
-0.11856022477149963,
-0.27632367610931396,
-0.5103060007095337,
0.2782493829727173,
-0.394620418548584,
-0.08170340955257416,
-0.3345080614089966,
-0.276189386844635,
-0.13605840504169464,
0.061609897762537,
-0.6825647950172424,
0.9223848581314087,
0.2402316778898239,
-0.8604907393455505,
0.2272132784128189,
-0.7099820971488953,
-0.4811100959777832,
0.23486150801181793,
0.053799089044332504,
-0.37835440039634705,
-0.25899553298950195,
-0.07151522487401962,
0.2505268454551697,
-0.26987871527671814,
0.3567937910556793,
-0.7199346423149109,
-0.30842041969299316,
0.20500867068767548,
0.26659098267555237,
0.56597501039505,
0.6397388577461243,
-0.06209372356534004,
0.4696608781814575,
-0.5257492065429688,
-0.403432160615921,
-0.11667259782552719,
0.20201943814754486,
-1.0759326219558716,
-0.026776950806379318,
0.30779922008514404,
0.11722709238529205,
-0.118666872382164,
-0.41446030139923096,
0.28807300329208374,
-0.22846919298171997,
0.7208127379417419,
0.6581606268882751,
0.3829420208930969,
0.17929619550704956,
-0.4950297176837921,
0.45766782760620117,
0.008022479712963104,
-0.08544036000967026,
-0.3433886170387268,
-0.24268010258674622,
-0.3117029666900635,
-0.25066983699798584,
0.14389273524284363,
-0.07911579310894012,
-0.8557915091514587,
0.11751976609230042,
-0.28689277172088623,
-0.6174342632293701,
-0.26845625042915344,
0.10487446933984756,
0.4719332754611969,
0.2654150128364563,
0.5094539523124695,
-0.23125264048576355,
-0.9160184264183044,
-0.6313562393188477,
-0.20035690069198608,
-0.4555665850639343,
0.2108452022075653,
0.16100260615348816,
0.6084485054016113,
-0.4178773760795593,
1.0606051683425903,
-0.527999997138977,
-0.3330989181995392,
-0.20815518498420715,
0.09318669140338898,
0.24086090922355652,
0.437215119600296,
0.6311476826667786,
-0.5096231698989868,
-0.14349393546581268,
-0.033072371035814285,
-0.6933661103248596,
-0.17332196235656738,
0.23537389934062958,
-0.5324013233184814,
0.029917987063527107,
0.248936727643013,
-0.6489944458007812,
0.029145164415240288,
0.13074760138988495,
-0.7634001970291138,
0.32933464646339417,
-0.14442211389541626,
-0.11015844345092773,
-1.4891759157180786,
0.6498908996582031,
0.24468396604061127,
-0.21078109741210938,
-0.29517805576324463,
0.26986679434776306,
-0.04126395285129547,
-0.21383219957351685,
-0.1949790120124817,
0.7063078284263611,
-0.24679628014564514,
0.09446971863508224,
-0.089076928794384,
0.046100717037916183,
-0.0934024229645729,
0.2722196877002716,
-0.02022886835038662,
0.46716931462287903,
0.22889886796474457,
-0.5135291218757629,
0.03146316856145859,
0.301796555519104,
0.06696202605962753,
0.9376464486122131,
-0.5314128994941711,
-0.08500275015830994,
0.02571941912174225,
0.712365984916687,
-1.0640398263931274,
-0.07159876823425293,
0.12447473406791687,
-0.15145480632781982,
-0.019503697752952576,
0.040045905858278275,
-0.6607793569564819,
-0.11441042274236679,
-0.2676541805267334,
0.6787023544311523,
-0.00028906509396620095,
-0.417973130941391,
0.6905337572097778,
0.6798003911972046,
-0.2964668869972229,
-0.08911499381065369,
-0.05940431356430054,
0.023391377180814743,
-0.35591384768486023,
-0.21258822083473206,
0.3964601755142212,
0.029808660969138145,
-0.30346331000328064,
0.014728059060871601,
-0.31291550397872925,
0.17160490155220032,
0.11096622049808502,
0.6813885569572449,
0.37267330288887024,
0.023088285699486732,
0.47483667731285095,
0.09687556326389313,
-0.22381795942783356,
-0.026782216504216194,
-0.6161542534828186,
0.7800696492195129,
-0.08802279084920883,
0.002699380973353982,
-0.25554779171943665,
0.32722383737564087,
0.6570551991462708,
-0.12859390676021576,
0.33514636754989624,
0.7540403008460999,
-0.3696586489677429,
0.2898882031440735,
-0.3160584270954132,
-0.23228292167186737,
-0.3283799886703491,
0.19669000804424286,
-0.4074384570121765,
-0.5996130108833313,
0.25793156027793884,
0.13866519927978516,
0.029574114829301834,
0.5655375123023987,
0.6447901725769043,
-0.015159612521529198,
0.7411043047904968,
0.42903053760528564,
-0.29542481899261475,
0.5384364724159241,
-0.26576563715934753,
-0.03414176031947136,
-0.7889811992645264,
-0.3255537450313568,
-0.9256719946861267,
-0.23238518834114075,
-0.4265163242816925,
-0.2437676638364792,
0.516488254070282,
-0.18754349648952484,
-0.451021283864975,
0.652638852596283,
-0.3571324348449707,
0.30707502365112305,
0.5611345171928406,
0.07643870264291763,
0.41003909707069397,
0.13517005741596222,
-0.5261544585227966,
0.16145962476730347,
-0.726008415222168,
-0.4588000476360321,
0.9845526814460754,
0.061312444508075714,
0.8350508809089661,
0.27645689249038696,
0.8006207346916199,
0.33190837502479553,
0.46348512172698975,
-0.4382767081260681,
0.5743494033813477,
0.3937479257583618,
-0.6380769610404968,
-0.025588806718587875,
-0.22423073649406433,
-1.4775205850601196,
0.4272298514842987,
-0.3923642635345459,
-0.7206569910049438,
0.25763770937919617,
0.051723264157772064,
-0.34019702672958374,
0.030397815629839897,
-0.48603805899620056,
0.5471417307853699,
0.33391204476356506,
-0.735741376876831,
-0.5203962922096252,
-0.9147472977638245,
0.06719208508729935,
0.05607558414340019,
0.09757377952337265,
0.11459516733884811,
0.20608660578727722,
0.8410664796829224,
-0.09883885085582733,
0.6058422923088074,
-0.1414613425731659,
0.11467429995536804,
0.09334081411361694,
0.38980916142463684,
0.19879275560379028,
0.2545478641986847,
-0.1908053308725357,
0.11444652080535889,
0.6137327551841736,
-0.209202840924263,
-0.3380069136619568,
0.9922797679901123,
-0.8626301288604736,
-0.5552080869674683,
-0.8757028579711914,
-0.7352702021598816,
-0.3113301396369934,
0.48886191844940186,
-0.15789681673049927,
0.3793111741542816,
0.10894787311553955,
0.3436436057090759,
0.3745425045490265,
0.27956458926200867,
0.4087941348552704,
0.35614892840385437,
-0.47066450119018555,
-0.8449720144271851,
1.1495260000228882,
-0.08014839142560959,
-0.09385957568883896,
0.45005351305007935,
0.10609431564807892,
-0.43970754742622375,
-0.13527308404445648,
0.014134945347905159,
0.6916695833206177,
-0.44698575139045715,
-0.566030740737915,
-0.7451722025871277,
0.039482418447732925,
-0.5077391862869263,
0.1490190625190735,
0.20669281482696533,
-0.37217703461647034,
-0.20618601143360138,
0.1938016712665558,
0.3233911395072937,
0.6976834535598755,
0.07162754237651825,
0.1634678691625595,
-0.5011152029037476,
-0.14967826008796692,
-0.061553262174129486,
0.27955636382102966,
0.0862732082605362,
-0.061732616275548935,
-0.3939761221408844,
-0.2693342864513397,
-0.7474340200424194,
-0.8190475106239319,
0.5006753206253052,
0.21896211802959442,
0.5594449639320374,
0.4924878478050232,
0.08757499605417252,
0.86127769947052,
-0.17554254829883575,
0.5315545797348022,
0.029353924095630646,
-0.6443700790405273,
0.650990903377533,
-0.6264978647232056,
0.4505378007888794,
0.4409678876399994,
0.6938371658325195,
-0.28861334919929504,
-0.5110862255096436,
-0.7241899371147156,
-0.902593195438385,
0.4366530776023865,
0.2605181336402893,
-0.3358434736728668,
-0.028943413868546486,
0.2340558022260666,
0.172793447971344,
0.06887500733137131,
-0.5691268444061279,
0.02061423473060131,
-0.0741211473941803,
-0.034337300807237625,
-0.3986484110355377,
-0.10591243952512741,
-0.625533401966095,
-0.23604339361190796,
0.6322891712188721,
-0.22258011996746063,
0.3139728009700775,
0.3259280025959015,
-0.229333758354187,
-0.1261940747499466,
0.07714059948921204,
0.6462689638137817,
0.766963005065918,
-0.4073406755924225,
0.5212031006813049,
-0.29917654395103455,
-0.5267016887664795,
0.0025609303265810013,
0.23424580693244934,
0.04722374305129051,
0.17174313962459564,
0.3310529291629791,
0.32678428292274475,
0.458771675825119,
-0.40345895290374756,
-0.09916079789400101,
0.10948178917169571,
-0.06735879182815552,
0.1269846111536026,
-0.06139911711215973,
0.01649150252342224,
0.31190648674964905,
0.4448101818561554,
0.17287690937519073,
0.025108758360147476,
-0.5465222597122192,
0.22950255870819092,
0.39774900674819946,
-0.3173190653324127,
-0.535837709903717,
0.5449927449226379,
0.296737402677536,
-0.09873441606760025,
0.20206819474697113,
0.19729647040367126,
-0.33034273982048035,
0.015047119930386543,
1.0113599300384521,
0.6884135007858276,
-0.18169622123241425,
0.14220726490020752,
0.32900699973106384,
-0.09774836897850037,
0.1370779573917389,
0.12046211212873459,
-0.44950708746910095,
-0.299643874168396,
0.20583157241344452,
-0.9567089676856995,
-0.320441871881485,
-0.266153484582901,
-0.5611942410469055,
0.3007318675518036,
-0.43085917830467224,
-0.42212700843811035,
0.13018803298473358,
0.21156148612499237,
-0.2651209533214569,
-0.20957817137241364,
-0.16161015629768372,
0.8044530153274536,
-0.9549925327301025,
1.0322834253311157,
1.0719053745269775,
-0.6487951278686523,
-0.6932005286216736,
-0.022146010771393776,
0.20977327227592468,
-0.4750591814517975,
0.41895022988319397,
-0.06515403836965561,
-0.16496147215366364,
0.13062988221645355,
-0.21158215403556824,
-1.0162776708602905,
1.3806078433990479,
0.5865697860717773,
-0.13798795640468597,
0.1668056696653366,
-0.5169398784637451,
0.6406447887420654,
-0.5505378842353821,
0.5083973407745361,
0.346912682056427,
0.33327850699424744,
0.5222111344337463,
-0.8201364874839783,
0.24826203286647797,
-0.49187785387039185,
0.28689876198768616,
0.2751443088054657,
-0.6137241125106812,
0.6220664978027344,
-0.017369737848639488,
-0.23111563920974731,
0.27987125515937805,
0.5617278218269348,
0.7337488532066345,
0.5367481708526611,
0.41568589210510254,
0.5215650200843811,
0.682986855506897,
-0.023932691663503647,
0.9062108993530273,
-0.41845494508743286,
0.30456697940826416,
0.8525179624557495,
-0.6237578988075256,
1.0291849374771118,
0.9371908903121948,
-0.30822598934173584,
0.9068540930747986,
0.8724313378334045,
0.1966925859451294,
0.3312446177005768,
-0.16688507795333862,
-0.09258195012807846,
-0.32316118478775024,
-0.5548923015594482,
-0.6899195909500122,
0.19990795850753784,
0.22660595178604126,
-0.45314517617225647,
-0.39529138803482056,
0.02895631641149521,
0.23159284889698029,
0.04279431700706482,
-0.08554279804229736,
0.6932271122932434,
0.10185819864273071,
-0.9001859426498413,
0.5435338616371155,
-0.3997316062450409,
0.20186254382133484,
-0.636678159236908,
-0.058934979140758514,
-0.3907448947429657,
0.1418636590242386,
-0.2745213210582733,
-0.5585810542106628,
0.213964581489563,
-0.41355520486831665,
-0.3224392533302307,
-0.09213174134492874,
0.6082308888435364,
-0.2731662094593048,
-0.17977802455425262,
0.15181635320186615,
0.311015784740448,
0.010456259362399578,
0.31927019357681274,
-0.18294692039489746,
0.18077360093593597,
-0.37295112013816833,
0.1567871868610382,
0.6666232347488403,
0.06524933874607086,
-0.23597675561904907,
0.7543545961380005,
0.787638247013092,
0.2586648464202881,
-0.5783076286315918,
-0.01599012315273285,
1.0374338626861572,
-0.6342268586158752,
-0.6408969759941101,
-0.8018176555633545,
0.009080418385565281,
-0.1157502681016922,
-0.34748443961143494,
0.8624253869056702,
0.640957236289978,
0.6195027232170105,
0.05540842562913895,
0.5238981246948242,
-0.018156971782445908,
0.16114604473114014,
-0.24182075262069702,
0.651057243347168,
-0.5339837670326233,
0.4333847463130951,
-0.7027794718742371,
-1.1961065530776978,
-0.6724803447723389,
0.585134744644165,
-0.16414330899715424,
-0.09743344038724899,
0.8778547048568726,
0.8330206274986267,
0.03895287960767746,
0.2602570354938507,
0.05560663342475891,
0.37144559621810913,
0.3614267110824585,
0.5604422688484192,
0.689050555229187,
-0.10896233469247818,
0.34187325835227966,
0.2852083444595337,
-0.1781061291694641,
-0.3644523024559021,
-0.6705024242401123,
-0.5635616183280945,
-0.9382396936416626,
-0.2657584547996521,
-0.801336407661438,
0.35512441396713257,
1.193168044090271,
0.5958414077758789,
-0.47775399684906006,
-0.538630485534668,
0.02739180624485016,
0.4668040871620178,
-0.46730026602745056,
-0.2090359628200531,
0.24899962544441223,
-0.263492226600647,
-0.4460792541503906,
-0.03387801721692085,
0.6993278861045837,
-0.2434462606906891,
-0.42340412735939026,
-0.055069878697395325,
-0.7406191825866699,
-0.11772067099809647,
0.7447754740715027,
0.36051711440086365,
-0.632610559463501,
-0.10226821899414062,
-0.22138142585754395,
-0.1324741393327713,
-0.21294249594211578,
1.0823949575424194,
-1.1141796112060547,
0.6133472323417664,
0.48604005575180054,
0.3772549629211426,
0.43153172731399536,
-0.19189980626106262,
0.7413266897201538,
-0.2927723526954651,
-0.12974990904331207,
0.2565789818763733,
0.4893287122249603,
0.02799927070736885,
0.07165118306875229,
0.5818162560462952,
0.7820560932159424,
-0.6032440662384033,
-1.2737442255020142,
-0.08168975263834,
-1.2399345636367798,
-0.18118587136268616,
1.3033546209335327,
-0.2139393836259842,
-0.27916771173477173,
-0.21355663239955902,
-0.3481706380844116,
0.07773641496896744,
-0.5097513198852539,
0.8279055953025818,
0.5696918964385986,
-0.31232956051826477,
0.1577458381652832,
0.2704842686653137,
0.07624177634716034,
0.417100727558136,
-0.5399433970451355,
-0.06372297555208206,
0.4590469002723694,
0.3234069049358368,
0.4323337972164154,
0.16537393629550934,
-0.04422036558389664,
0.4054639935493469,
-0.043704092502593994,
-0.24104611575603485,
-0.04952353239059448,
-0.30980384349823,
-0.3390679359436035,
0.4908321797847748,
0.19338606297969818,
0.2662201523780823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00034v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00034v1
|
Adaptive Activation Steering: A Tuning-Free LLM Truthfulness Improvement Method for Diverse Hallucinations Categories
| 2024-05-26T21:39:53 | 2024-05-26T21:39:53 |
Tianlong Wang, Xianfeng Jiao, Yifan He, Zhongzhi Chen, Yinghao Zhu, Xu Chu, Junyi Gao, Yasha Wang, Liantao Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent studies have indicated that Large Language Models (LLMs) harbor an
inherent understanding of truthfulness, yet often fail to express fully and
generate false statements. This gap between "knowing" and "telling" poses a
challenge for ensuring the truthfulness of generated content. To address this,
we introduce Adaptive Activation Steering (ACT), a tuning-free method that
adaptively shift LLM's activations in "truthful" direction during inference.
ACT addresses diverse categories of hallucinations by utilizing diverse
steering vectors and adjusting the steering intensity adaptively. Applied as an
add-on across various models, ACT significantly improves truthfulness in LLaMA
($\uparrow$ 142\%), LLaMA2 ($\uparrow$ 24\%), Alpaca ($\uparrow$ 36\%), Vicuna
($\uparrow$ 28\%), and LLaMA2-Chat ($\uparrow$ 19\%). Furthermore, we verify
ACT's scalability across larger models (13B, 33B, 65B), underscoring the
adaptability of ACT to large-scale language models.
|
[
-0.1111179068684578,
-0.8489810228347778,
0.6433981657028198,
0.5620667934417725,
-0.270693302154541,
-0.02674425207078457,
-0.3834228813648224,
-0.5436910390853882,
0.31230849027633667,
0.39879223704338074,
-0.6345395445823669,
-0.4382562041282654,
-0.7655863165855408,
0.016483580693602562,
-0.26508858799934387,
0.8606322407722473,
0.102537602186203,
0.14731866121292114,
0.0528830885887146,
-0.33639460802078247,
-0.688742458820343,
-0.1731191724538803,
-0.7242959141731262,
-0.32805153727531433,
0.42378947138786316,
0.23510411381721497,
0.8532934188842773,
0.582453191280365,
0.43991589546203613,
0.3593077063560486,
-0.11650051176548004,
0.39183861017227173,
-0.6350499987602234,
0.33664900064468384,
-0.28184959292411804,
-0.5341936349868774,
-0.5538911819458008,
-0.05004921182990074,
0.4411853849887848,
0.6469686627388,
-0.5632423162460327,
-0.18254417181015015,
-0.0562281496822834,
0.5929204225540161,
-0.8772813081741333,
-0.002477420959621668,
-1.0385260581970215,
-0.035858724266290665,
0.35015740990638733,
-0.4464110732078552,
-0.6598343849182129,
-0.4619835913181305,
0.0020074970088899136,
-0.9700441360473633,
0.22729064524173737,
0.1808348447084427,
0.46466395258903503,
0.8327912092208862,
-0.42619261145591736,
-0.5294986963272095,
-0.778830885887146,
0.6678006649017334,
-0.6846732497215271,
0.4834733307361603,
0.39869770407676697,
0.16144156455993652,
-0.379437118768692,
-0.583001434803009,
-0.7603690028190613,
-0.33081790804862976,
0.2060660570859909,
0.20295286178588867,
-0.3772071897983551,
0.17054535448551178,
0.3200758099555969,
0.15667232871055603,
-0.2235637903213501,
0.3209150433540344,
-0.16781233251094818,
-0.32156023383140564,
0.5959813594818115,
0.1777113527059555,
-0.016530882567167282,
0.2422509789466858,
-0.3382253050804138,
-0.2594590187072754,
-0.5959565043449402,
-0.11168555915355682,
0.3909395933151245,
0.21775366365909576,
-0.016440480947494507,
0.5228323340415955,
-0.21862100064754486,
0.6940087676048279,
0.5121433138847351,
-0.250132292509079,
0.3964400887489319,
0.09772281348705292,
-0.35403531789779663,
0.3975563943386078,
0.39068740606307983,
0.6184871792793274,
-0.17244696617126465,
-0.10613483935594559,
-0.3037458658218384,
0.1336756944656372,
0.6206623911857605,
-0.6019492149353027,
-0.15278713405132294,
0.3323220908641815,
-0.35525044798851013,
-0.3668249249458313,
-0.07804477959871292,
-0.7670285105705261,
-0.9979242086410522,
-0.34826841950416565,
0.7667264938354492,
-0.6047061681747437,
-0.5572025179862976,
0.44227758049964905,
0.10791335254907608,
0.5380827188491821,
0.4837547242641449,
-1.0614649057388306,
0.11446619778871536,
0.6532996892929077,
0.7140243053436279,
-0.5320206880569458,
-0.2641361653804779,
-0.8113783001899719,
-0.017988473176956177,
-0.6646322011947632,
0.8383511900901794,
-0.569588840007782,
-0.2437536120414734,
0.0077954307198524475,
-0.017559874802827835,
-0.2983543574810028,
-0.853672981262207,
0.7340857982635498,
-0.6596086025238037,
-0.13194291293621063,
-0.3826732337474823,
-0.5253610610961914,
-0.6195542216300964,
0.06969210505485535,
-0.6996835470199585,
0.9628894329071045,
-0.07754485309123993,
-0.3419478237628937,
0.32540661096572876,
-0.7534207701683044,
-0.48396503925323486,
-0.27819791436195374,
0.06691401451826096,
-0.2970609962940216,
0.586897075176239,
0.27475470304489136,
0.15235447883605957,
0.23465007543563843,
0.40229031443595886,
-0.1910283863544464,
-0.5234888195991516,
0.47027167677879333,
-0.5182800889015198,
0.7054290771484375,
-0.06937747448682785,
-0.686019778251648,
0.4906245172023773,
-0.9681104421615601,
-0.24080336093902588,
-0.12944985926151276,
-0.1774953156709671,
-0.17720161378383636,
0.13504578173160553,
-0.2901889383792877,
-0.011797716841101646,
0.01194012351334095,
-0.35307055711746216,
0.1132889911532402,
-0.468269407749176,
-0.04808719828724861,
0.979439914226532,
0.17883063852787018,
0.33650267124176025,
-0.5129641890525818,
0.3484232425689697,
0.4186742603778839,
0.10359681397676468,
0.2588909864425659,
-0.5491597056388855,
-1.170468807220459,
-0.15735764801502228,
0.010857908986508846,
0.5706881880760193,
-1.068031907081604,
0.6996007561683655,
-0.12929470837116241,
-0.3965296745300293,
-0.8503900766372681,
0.006500793620944023,
0.1426944136619568,
0.6401475667953491,
0.7047216296195984,
-0.28763547539711,
-0.39687711000442505,
-0.7399435639381409,
-0.22061094641685486,
-0.25715872645378113,
0.06768719106912613,
-0.01860547810792923,
0.4555521309375763,
-0.24328871071338654,
0.5804161429405212,
-0.34431591629981995,
-0.33105453848838806,
-0.06018894165754318,
0.3723248243331909,
-0.017163341864943504,
0.3822905123233795,
0.2884071171283722,
-0.7652090191841125,
-0.15743684768676758,
-0.14861464500427246,
-0.5965428948402405,
-0.35463666915893555,
-0.3638612627983093,
-0.14357393980026245,
0.41841983795166016,
0.23308910429477692,
-0.553303599357605,
0.6086682081222534,
0.7616243362426758,
-0.5493781566619873,
0.5630713701248169,
-0.2130175530910492,
0.1613491326570511,
-0.7046286463737488,
-0.2250860035419464,
-0.31289204955101013,
0.00005290329863782972,
-0.7876792550086975,
-0.07277869433164597,
0.055334631353616714,
0.43468520045280457,
-0.42753952741622925,
0.40069934725761414,
-0.279460608959198,
-0.03632745519280434,
-0.78147292137146,
0.1874610185623169,
-0.19723019003868103,
0.7217585444450378,
0.09669742733240128,
0.7868032455444336,
0.8228338360786438,
-0.7903091907501221,
0.38895368576049805,
0.2678656280040741,
-0.4609706401824951,
0.5704699158668518,
-0.16663001477718353,
0.28931277990341187,
-0.15691477060317993,
-0.05692627280950546,
-0.8396088480949402,
-0.16041941940784454,
0.45428335666656494,
-0.31806397438049316,
0.21749795973300934,
0.2634817361831665,
-0.10164571553468704,
0.18082170188426971,
-0.17625154554843903,
0.10987090319395065,
0.43146324157714844,
-0.8030366897583008,
1.16824209690094,
0.07584099471569061,
0.0719747543334961,
-0.7084489464759827,
-0.6077744364738464,
0.1724407970905304,
-0.18087098002433777,
-0.2913500666618347,
0.35785600543022156,
-0.35491418838500977,
-0.4166371524333954,
-0.050786349922418594,
-0.4516766369342804,
0.08141401410102844,
0.05333937332034111,
0.33463162183761597,
0.14654459059238434,
-0.1945067048072815,
0.24428696930408478,
0.36379340291023254,
-0.14774413406848907,
0.021018268540501595,
-0.10472468286752701,
0.4321483075618744,
-0.11880026757717133,
-0.5539946556091309,
-0.48193633556365967,
0.03940014913678169,
0.47254112362861633,
-0.14377647638320923,
0.9268064498901367,
0.7016056776046753,
-0.23775623738765717,
-0.3787117004394531,
-0.8823062181472778,
-0.3824666440486908,
-0.5687707662582397,
0.3120059072971344,
-0.2718476355075836,
-0.9301244020462036,
0.5926965475082397,
0.0048798066563904285,
0.07412047684192657,
0.24126556515693665,
0.8720292448997498,
0.2342580109834671,
0.8419554829597473,
0.8149929642677307,
0.14194343984127045,
0.46341636776924133,
0.012950248084962368,
0.24189630150794983,
-0.8421570658683777,
-0.3092346787452698,
-0.2522019147872925,
-0.4340750575065613,
-0.5069525837898254,
-0.70191490650177,
0.4192464053630829,
-0.09709405153989792,
-0.024782640859484673,
-0.05571453645825386,
-0.5500034689903259,
0.2842666804790497,
0.445865273475647,
0.3453900218009949,
0.6185864806175232,
0.09165468066930771,
0.0728815495967865,
-0.07440698146820068,
-0.4798746407032013,
-0.21385425329208374,
1.046484112739563,
0.10554928332567215,
0.8110770583152771,
0.20761367678642273,
0.3219822943210602,
0.27717265486717224,
0.6170494556427002,
-1.02195143699646,
0.7719311118125916,
0.09016367793083191,
-0.5702813863754272,
-0.3260824978351593,
-0.32883894443511963,
-0.7204759120941162,
0.4398522973060608,
-0.535390317440033,
-0.5701229572296143,
0.5006240010261536,
0.09094935655593872,
-0.4831068515777588,
0.4846271872520447,
-0.40667596459388733,
0.3183070421218872,
-0.34967103600502014,
-0.2929209768772125,
-0.5997421741485596,
-0.5190097689628601,
0.2781129479408264,
-0.3159537613391876,
-0.08847612142562866,
-0.32693418860435486,
-0.3665167987346649,
0.8097683787345886,
0.02381100505590439,
0.9612363576889038,
-0.43875542283058167,
-0.3069770932197571,
0.27594998478889465,
0.24493888020515442,
0.7417199015617371,
-0.17945678532123566,
-0.35630351305007935,
0.12410176545381546,
-0.46248534321784973,
-0.11144422739744186,
-0.9756496548652649,
0.4925379455089569,
-0.689035952091217,
-0.8184704780578613,
-0.30037543177604675,
-0.9403964877128601,
-0.4754505157470703,
0.017348844558000565,
0.08833638578653336,
0.193588986992836,
-0.11987796425819397,
0.335074245929718,
0.9936567544937134,
-0.13070063292980194,
0.5369539260864258,
0.8750124573707581,
-0.1791226714849472,
-0.6012724041938782,
0.7247965931892395,
-0.07136297971010208,
0.25607746839523315,
0.22309136390686035,
0.1390354484319687,
-0.3842616379261017,
-0.9436106085777283,
-0.12613409757614136,
0.21841570734977722,
-0.7999466061592102,
-0.2638564705848694,
-0.590006947517395,
-0.09954297542572021,
-0.18452924489974976,
-0.03859385475516319,
-0.3489037752151489,
-0.5385173559188843,
-0.24984073638916016,
-0.4960983097553253,
0.49739953875541687,
0.5049046874046326,
-0.22792306542396545,
0.5592672228813171,
-0.2837525010108948,
0.5145775675773621,
0.41868939995765686,
0.36406272649765015,
0.033557068556547165,
-0.867285430431366,
-0.0870991051197052,
0.11526947468519211,
-0.48328697681427,
-0.924584686756134,
0.3168765902519226,
0.21936507523059845,
0.6380722522735596,
0.5605001449584961,
0.3356005847454071,
0.8291671276092529,
-0.2751009464263916,
0.7845311164855957,
0.28487804532051086,
-0.9030155539512634,
0.297245055437088,
-0.021239187568426132,
-0.05241072177886963,
0.5759341716766357,
0.31718796491622925,
-0.33571431040763855,
-0.6782420873641968,
-0.41030845046043396,
-0.5136981010437012,
0.49637481570243835,
0.24542978405952454,
0.26462921500205994,
0.18491269648075104,
0.38816037774086,
0.31296199560165405,
0.2703637480735779,
-0.8405933976173401,
-0.21299298107624054,
-0.3205530345439911,
-0.3713526129722595,
0.13481523096561432,
-0.2930867075920105,
-0.46920323371887207,
-0.4037645161151886,
0.9618422389030457,
-0.5016553401947021,
0.3714378774166107,
0.3431374132633209,
-0.14809642732143402,
-0.43180781602859497,
0.14007166028022766,
0.8315371870994568,
0.8075894713401794,
-0.019247625023126602,
0.22145521640777588,
0.563532829284668,
-0.7452538013458252,
0.33217552304267883,
0.050331033766269684,
-0.401044636964798,
-0.17022287845611572,
0.49591630697250366,
1.3410440683364868,
0.07747083157300949,
-0.5344126224517822,
0.38791653513908386,
0.030459487810730934,
-0.2976994216442108,
0.025931060314178467,
0.5553693771362305,
-0.12336070835590363,
0.55930495262146,
0.5127108097076416,
0.2449488490819931,
0.005866594612598419,
-0.32662561535835266,
-0.009336681105196476,
0.39639222621917725,
-0.6770167946815491,
-0.3124925196170807,
0.7251805663108826,
0.07141982764005661,
-0.32109516859054565,
0.6622815132141113,
-0.16976723074913025,
-0.2670716941356659,
0.332061767578125,
0.7687263488769531,
1.2825772762298584,
-0.4441947042942047,
0.1539907306432724,
0.23013274371623993,
0.4385378658771515,
-0.0375475250184536,
0.36778971552848816,
0.1024441197514534,
-1.2084786891937256,
-0.5337891578674316,
-0.6202387809753418,
-0.5679410696029663,
0.2561594247817993,
-0.6885849833488464,
-0.01584051549434662,
-0.29027706384658813,
-0.2759424149990082,
-0.3087734580039978,
-0.14068587124347687,
-0.09181856364011765,
0.17459051311016083,
0.055440064519643784,
1.0388227701187134,
-0.7885693311691284,
0.8657070994377136,
0.6114171743392944,
-0.02454999089241028,
-0.7381866574287415,
0.41743165254592896,
0.028484463691711426,
-0.9204892516136169,
0.10593794286251068,
0.09540193527936935,
-0.42460963129997253,
0.09554743766784668,
-0.8012288212776184,
-0.7152026295661926,
1.2289044857025146,
0.46813488006591797,
-0.4152085781097412,
0.13935062289237976,
0.06297829747200012,
0.6585742235183716,
-0.6165948510169983,
-0.18483145534992218,
0.6751609444618225,
0.6573494672775269,
0.4002135396003723,
-0.7883828282356262,
0.1487233191728592,
-0.04189378395676613,
-0.15570811927318573,
-0.17342299222946167,
-0.564039945602417,
0.26096096634864807,
-0.41042667627334595,
-0.05974356085062027,
0.09104728698730469,
0.9500210881233215,
0.5695621967315674,
0.405345618724823,
0.929998517036438,
0.5662112236022949,
1.1333085298538208,
-0.16413787007331848,
0.569118082523346,
-0.4772651195526123,
0.03304380923509598,
1.2129117250442505,
-0.38081470131874084,
0.7695428133010864,
0.5621829628944397,
0.24533487856388092,
0.7383946776390076,
0.3376835584640503,
-0.02553861401975155,
0.6865178942680359,
-0.17702838778495789,
-0.4929468035697937,
-0.4271247088909149,
-0.023371700197458267,
-0.12917980551719666,
0.4119669497013092,
0.4609532356262207,
-0.06156027689576149,
0.07533825933933258,
0.3276406526565552,
-0.06268103420734406,
-0.026730554178357124,
-0.3652476668357849,
0.8815662264823914,
0.042562760412693024,
-0.9549235701560974,
0.7220130562782288,
-0.0830121859908104,
0.5394947528839111,
-0.6282998323440552,
-0.10168204456567764,
-0.2635970115661621,
0.15809783339500427,
-0.17603623867034912,
-0.6814983487129211,
0.26072603464126587,
-0.2037939727306366,
-0.04086339846253395,
0.03697816655039787,
0.7484312653541565,
-0.47619009017944336,
-0.3415089547634125,
0.47426116466522217,
0.4334816336631775,
-0.11936283856630325,
-0.09036161005496979,
-0.6291232705116272,
0.35049059987068176,
0.03813646733760834,
-0.4399253726005554,
-0.059287331998348236,
0.3599155843257904,
-0.07969790697097778,
0.9346602559089661,
0.6667378544807434,
0.268934041261673,
0.39639753103256226,
0.13003401458263397,
0.9102799296379089,
-0.6534683704376221,
-0.42513492703437805,
-0.6227920651435852,
0.579654335975647,
0.05269009247422218,
-0.12070401757955551,
0.6102384328842163,
0.3645420968532562,
0.4916689991950989,
-0.04887817054986954,
0.4487769305706024,
-0.12353329360485077,
0.2747005820274353,
-0.8075850009918213,
0.6244281530380249,
-0.5270105600357056,
0.24709603190422058,
0.15128739178180695,
-1.0272613763809204,
-0.32103851437568665,
0.6976627111434937,
-0.4271320700645447,
-0.06560680270195007,
0.8088527321815491,
1.3071449995040894,
0.04949832335114479,
0.18031226098537445,
0.41729995608329773,
0.7013340592384338,
0.19254456460475922,
0.3624182343482971,
1.014609694480896,
-0.22802573442459106,
0.44089803099632263,
-0.23088552057743073,
-0.4261152744293213,
-0.21028871834278107,
-0.9552821516990662,
-0.7821388840675354,
-0.45148965716362,
-0.40190422534942627,
-0.5227229595184326,
0.025803089141845703,
0.9014819264411926,
0.6320042014122009,
-1.0019603967666626,
-0.1310722827911377,
0.07173393666744232,
0.1938686966896057,
-0.7862440943717957,
-0.1767285019159317,
0.337606817483902,
-0.5070835947990417,
-0.574860155582428,
0.7662433981895447,
0.40087395906448364,
0.014914806932210922,
-0.1580537110567093,
-0.3857170641422272,
-0.09879352152347565,
0.3986370265483856,
0.4983481168746948,
0.014935468323528767,
-0.8054189682006836,
-0.6001917719841003,
0.033301107585430145,
0.04924144223332405,
0.3737013041973114,
0.7987091541290283,
-0.6842182278633118,
0.5399578213691711,
0.1440104842185974,
0.4550103545188904,
0.40452417731285095,
0.11551652103662491,
0.3531946539878845,
-0.5061210989952087,
0.2870631217956543,
0.2736884355545044,
0.12799426913261414,
0.32504263520240784,
-0.3519274890422821,
0.5468019247055054,
0.3297848701477051,
-0.47262024879455566,
-0.7659027576446533,
0.18532893061637878,
-1.3100357055664062,
-0.16069340705871582,
1.1374906301498413,
0.3013263940811157,
-0.14581513404846191,
-0.2007853239774704,
-0.33638474345207214,
0.36171939969062805,
-0.2204282283782959,
1.17726469039917,
0.5422340035438538,
-0.3815397024154663,
-0.11453928053379059,
-0.45188185572624207,
0.6428747773170471,
0.5045219659805298,
-0.7163904309272766,
0.223064586520195,
0.5623895525932312,
0.2762508988380432,
0.36820897459983826,
0.6058194041252136,
0.07844753563404083,
0.3591645061969757,
-0.06009088456630707,
0.06961113959550858,
-0.17459900677204132,
-0.6189001798629761,
-0.6207824349403381,
0.08341039717197418,
-0.014202776364982128,
-0.00041623052675276995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16702v1
|
Accurate and Nuanced Open-QA Evaluation Through Textual Entailment
| 2024-05-26T21:33:27 | 2024-05-26T21:33:27 |
Peiran Yao, Denilson Barbosa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open-domain question answering (Open-QA) is a common task for evaluating
large language models (LLMs). However, current Open-QA evaluations are
criticized for the ambiguity in questions and the lack of semantic
understanding in evaluators. Complex evaluators, powered by foundation models
or LLMs and pertaining to semantic equivalence, still deviate from human
judgments by a large margin. We propose to study the entailment relations of
answers to identify more informative and more general system answers, offering
a much closer evaluation to human judgment on both NaturalQuestions and
TriviaQA while being learning-free. The entailment-based evaluation we propose
allows the assignment of bonus or partial marks by quantifying the inference
gap between answers, enabling a nuanced ranking of answer correctness that has
higher AUC than current methods.
|
[
-0.2930084466934204,
-1.021241307258606,
0.6922746896743774,
0.04577495530247688,
-0.016800347715616226,
0.014101013541221619,
-0.33379384875297546,
-0.5148590207099915,
0.18169765174388885,
0.476255863904953,
-0.41574257612228394,
-0.4576154351234436,
-0.41560330986976624,
0.15174245834350586,
-0.1775754988193512,
0.7028820514678955,
-0.40430188179016113,
-0.12240833789110184,
-0.7724115252494812,
-0.2236543893814087,
-0.47457143664360046,
-0.30734264850616455,
-0.45962730050086975,
-0.2505224049091339,
0.22930586338043213,
0.355965256690979,
0.856143057346344,
0.24000611901283264,
0.6058357357978821,
0.24207711219787598,
0.011430739425122738,
0.31785452365875244,
-0.36071938276290894,
0.08114275336265564,
-0.30687248706817627,
-0.6537814736366272,
-0.35659024119377136,
-0.07935503870248795,
0.33577966690063477,
0.9252588152885437,
-0.05343271419405937,
0.5809746980667114,
0.06651182472705841,
0.8187447190284729,
-1.0122672319412231,
0.04665026813745499,
-0.312137633562088,
-0.09494835883378983,
0.12926989793777466,
-0.35081031918525696,
-0.43103131651878357,
-0.900957465171814,
0.5016257166862488,
-0.9548318982124329,
0.05475727841258049,
-0.06394756585359573,
1.0021544694900513,
0.5124841928482056,
-0.38117048144340515,
-0.6522064208984375,
-0.6910393834114075,
0.7753767371177673,
-0.5924177765846252,
0.3527664244174957,
0.44028544425964355,
0.5300140976905823,
-0.008427808992564678,
-0.4935779273509979,
-0.41465795040130615,
-0.25737982988357544,
-0.08256726711988449,
0.2889731824398041,
-0.12476816028356552,
0.11130795627832413,
0.03437797352671623,
0.6069232225418091,
-0.6427428126335144,
-0.21326562762260437,
-0.04711686074733734,
-0.0574728362262249,
0.4842260181903839,
0.10838375985622406,
0.47732776403427124,
0.0028509879484772682,
-0.2684876322746277,
0.13199087977409363,
-0.6453902721405029,
0.29280516505241394,
0.30210208892822266,
-0.05185556039214134,
0.06640416383743286,
0.9332528114318848,
-0.6295192241668701,
0.8910689353942871,
0.049053724855184555,
0.3447442650794983,
0.0730915293097496,
-0.29828357696533203,
-0.5137617588043213,
-0.09442740678787231,
0.42473000288009644,
0.44638487696647644,
0.6785807609558105,
-0.4909723699092865,
-0.11853104829788208,
0.12381120026111603,
0.27380073070526123,
-0.7464368939399719,
0.16330090165138245,
0.5879644155502319,
-0.3986395299434662,
-0.13630220293998718,
0.4429832100868225,
-0.6260999441146851,
-0.058820027858018875,
-0.4522113502025604,
0.8536693453788757,
-0.4440465569496155,
-0.06899258494377136,
0.610032320022583,
-0.1630842536687851,
0.5393475890159607,
0.578454852104187,
-0.3745260536670685,
0.5527655482292175,
0.6694681644439697,
0.5472508072853088,
0.03414089232683182,
0.03830700367689133,
-0.6694296598434448,
0.14459076523780823,
-0.38962024450302124,
0.6704576015472412,
-0.6843065023422241,
-0.04703894257545471,
0.053212039172649384,
0.017841875553131104,
-0.12899701297283173,
-0.673894464969635,
0.630365252494812,
-1.0149954557418823,
0.566768229007721,
-0.05460406839847565,
-0.7024565935134888,
-0.4619447886943817,
0.38106411695480347,
-0.6916090250015259,
0.9035426378250122,
0.20389211177825928,
-0.7041876316070557,
0.24729815125465393,
-0.8747524619102478,
-0.06890936195850372,
0.017930392175912857,
0.20927482843399048,
0.03295537456870079,
0.058329466730356216,
0.4177281856536865,
0.1385699063539505,
-0.5544487237930298,
0.3971051275730133,
-0.26173970103263855,
-0.5083985328674316,
0.49661633372306824,
-0.3535155951976776,
0.9142336249351501,
0.10056250542402267,
-0.22516965866088867,
0.22642332315444946,
-0.6428634524345398,
0.33352240920066833,
-0.17172962427139282,
-0.34269994497299194,
-0.6969267129898071,
-0.33187660574913025,
-0.5117958188056946,
0.012871955521404743,
0.4367031157016754,
-0.7289382815361023,
-0.10019640624523163,
-0.8888352513313293,
-0.06380102038383484,
0.6333529949188232,
0.31623053550720215,
0.5735217332839966,
-0.4063924252986908,
0.6161904335021973,
-0.20630981028079987,
0.23471860587596893,
0.2428683042526245,
-0.6124966144561768,
-0.7952104210853577,
-0.15111087262630463,
0.6503589153289795,
0.6312624216079712,
-0.9142661690711975,
0.3779613971710205,
-0.2941839098930359,
-0.38315674662590027,
-0.9070155024528503,
-0.07281102240085602,
0.6001699566841125,
0.17643103003501892,
0.26673758029937744,
-0.20196758210659027,
-0.2204044610261917,
-0.8066298365592957,
-0.6218401193618774,
-0.16125525534152985,
-0.47387588024139404,
0.2330847680568695,
0.56428062915802,
0.2620023190975189,
1.1176230907440186,
-0.7288191914558411,
0.07044297456741333,
0.36119532585144043,
-0.04118325933814049,
0.14791172742843628,
0.1548747420310974,
0.3611848056316376,
-0.6538975238800049,
-0.3430379331111908,
0.01674484647810459,
-0.8667759299278259,
-0.18478058278560638,
0.31978851556777954,
-0.5099924206733704,
-0.08962441235780716,
0.060207899659872055,
-0.772390604019165,
0.47261369228363037,
0.10405825823545456,
-0.5796316862106323,
0.3694429397583008,
0.03401811420917511,
0.5199567079544067,
-0.6544363498687744,
0.06747423112392426,
-0.13167160749435425,
-0.03275761008262634,
-0.5518626570701599,
0.4179535210132599,
0.07186882197856903,
0.21087375283241272,
-0.2720463275909424,
0.680331289768219,
-0.338102787733078,
-0.0181224774569273,
0.2657872140407562,
0.586889922618866,
0.37841159105300903,
0.30481594800949097,
-0.12822023034095764,
0.5235221982002258,
0.25681036710739136,
-0.7130829691886902,
0.33505743741989136,
0.36047980189323425,
-0.3700985610485077,
0.545987606048584,
-0.6640105247497559,
0.15902025997638702,
-0.19904445111751556,
-0.003964560106396675,
-0.908353865146637,
-0.34275496006011963,
0.24053369462490082,
-0.7874270081520081,
-0.0298512801527977,
0.17701564729213715,
-0.38873419165611267,
-0.06913740187883377,
-0.43381577730178833,
0.5754064321517944,
0.3433319926261902,
-0.6191494464874268,
0.4579251706600189,
0.13389940559864044,
-0.07205043733119965,
-0.6812110543251038,
-0.3051077127456665,
-0.2134353071451187,
-0.0831209197640419,
-0.9736140966415405,
0.1386324018239975,
-0.005913812201470137,
-0.6386741399765015,
0.26959648728370667,
-0.21939393877983093,
-0.36931368708610535,
0.3325498402118683,
0.06837008893489838,
0.23637406527996063,
-0.46291640400886536,
0.5279088616371155,
-0.009795363061130047,
0.16965773701667786,
0.3036372661590576,
-0.03712213411927223,
0.3451666533946991,
-0.3798941671848297,
-0.6087130308151245,
0.0016555823385715485,
0.2205146998167038,
0.4072672724723816,
-0.7447028160095215,
0.4600609540939331,
0.09079427272081375,
-0.7276393175125122,
-0.024137113243341446,
-0.33378326892852783,
-0.2355489581823349,
-0.3493589162826538,
0.029544781893491745,
-0.45793455839157104,
-1.0418094396591187,
0.4192241430282593,
0.16492539644241333,
0.13036774098873138,
0.6497169137001038,
0.35190755128860474,
0.10192492604255676,
0.7412724494934082,
0.1929619014263153,
0.6860105991363525,
-0.19460545480251312,
-0.07055554538965225,
0.18804879486560822,
-0.6687089800834656,
-0.44777828454971313,
-0.8443952798843384,
0.05310368165373802,
-0.25375592708587646,
-0.5153701901435852,
0.19264887273311615,
0.42691829800605774,
-0.30757904052734375,
-0.09354401379823685,
-0.3570655286312103,
0.4647233188152313,
0.3001110851764679,
0.15118251740932465,
0.6455665230751038,
-0.2522231340408325,
0.048580873757600784,
0.19397343695163727,
-0.2651856541633606,
-0.8828059434890747,
1.1377041339874268,
0.4547136723995209,
0.533233642578125,
0.5869273543357849,
0.528093695640564,
0.12223558127880096,
0.5333132147789001,
-0.8600391745567322,
0.371683269739151,
0.11662410944700241,
-0.6470001935958862,
-0.7089610695838928,
-0.42638394236564636,
-0.6801528930664062,
0.3380942940711975,
-0.18409985303878784,
-0.6255447268486023,
0.13601315021514893,
-0.3881620764732361,
-0.43150794506073,
-0.010131203569471836,
-0.7428480386734009,
0.6895918846130371,
-0.029145589098334312,
-0.23563037812709808,
0.003217479446902871,
-0.6164581179618835,
0.6177939772605896,
-0.16201356053352356,
0.08438436686992645,
-0.16296620666980743,
-0.24706599116325378,
0.8084559440612793,
-0.317525714635849,
0.5587674975395203,
-0.20742325484752655,
-0.30172380805015564,
0.5107504725456238,
0.16968634724617004,
-0.004894590470939875,
0.04952511563897133,
-0.3453157842159271,
-0.22687901556491852,
0.29724130034446716,
-0.3947821855545044,
-1.0858170986175537,
0.3895876109600067,
-0.7175378799438477,
-0.5858719944953918,
-0.18129348754882812,
-0.35517647862434387,
-0.5830981731414795,
-0.035854272544384,
-0.10344543308019638,
0.4706665873527527,
-0.43014073371887207,
0.17528019845485687,
0.9015202522277832,
-0.4389049708843231,
0.0612713098526001,
0.761932373046875,
-0.35558247566223145,
-0.20835687220096588,
0.5634465217590332,
-0.08888308703899384,
0.305341511964798,
0.7396062016487122,
0.17810620367527008,
-0.5097569823265076,
-0.19095025956630707,
-0.7826370000839233,
0.2976801097393036,
-0.831271231174469,
-0.28186631202697754,
-0.6065921783447266,
-0.10412777215242386,
-0.2951962947845459,
0.008006392046809196,
0.18006208539009094,
-0.6700098514556885,
-0.19717538356781006,
-0.1749119758605957,
0.39997705817222595,
0.7649646997451782,
0.5299368500709534,
0.039479147642850876,
-0.7951683402061462,
0.46702221035957336,
0.3174142837524414,
0.6699052453041077,
0.05629393085837364,
-0.6205925345420837,
-0.14916276931762695,
0.19606302678585052,
-0.2972470819950104,
-1.035785436630249,
-0.1685142070055008,
0.36020034551620483,
0.5518830418586731,
0.25680044293403625,
0.4658980071544647,
0.5660310983657837,
-0.1691274493932724,
0.8035562634468079,
0.0436781570315361,
-1.0471534729003906,
0.48451942205429077,
-0.02671932429075241,
0.3228726089000702,
0.573283314704895,
0.4221368134021759,
-0.29968342185020447,
-0.5115790963172913,
-0.4390092194080353,
-0.5715241432189941,
0.4546870291233063,
0.19887691736221313,
-0.1707811802625656,
-0.06210700049996376,
0.3426460325717926,
0.17037612199783325,
0.14971168339252472,
-0.4470730721950531,
0.02569151669740677,
-0.08177652209997177,
-0.31584152579307556,
0.23563005030155182,
-0.06175999715924263,
-0.13350196182727814,
0.06339950859546661,
0.7420704960823059,
-0.28989940881729126,
0.07074116170406342,
0.4041745960712433,
-0.2768156826496124,
-0.19257326424121857,
0.776298999786377,
0.2805041968822479,
0.8587840795516968,
-0.46654072403907776,
0.0772784873843193,
0.2844850718975067,
-0.26145219802856445,
0.3107043206691742,
-0.16804294288158417,
-0.21268664300441742,
0.024260960519313812,
0.46646326780319214,
0.5413151979446411,
0.15147161483764648,
-0.7929050922393799,
0.8994579315185547,
-0.20325936377048492,
-0.27147892117500305,
-0.07829039543867111,
-0.08260620385408401,
0.1533644199371338,
-0.0053148274309933186,
0.22877207398414612,
-0.19057078659534454,
0.43869584798812866,
-0.4279789626598358,
0.2823517322540283,
0.42212674021720886,
-0.7673235535621643,
-0.04902007058262825,
0.3551337420940399,
0.1750665307044983,
-0.20196254551410675,
0.38837048411369324,
0.17778125405311584,
-0.22310204803943634,
0.8427287936210632,
0.31201499700546265,
1.1161255836486816,
-0.43384748697280884,
0.4049346148967743,
0.3110719323158264,
0.42736202478408813,
0.2193145751953125,
0.5619877576828003,
0.039802394807338715,
-0.6022886633872986,
-0.639832615852356,
-0.9311544895172119,
-0.5301141738891602,
-0.25221526622772217,
-1.0610744953155518,
0.15372928977012634,
-0.19435612857341766,
0.10960639268159866,
-0.06811900436878204,
-0.048455409705638885,
-0.6187829971313477,
0.5279590487480164,
-0.4651590883731842,
1.1769317388534546,
-0.5950326919555664,
0.45864638686180115,
0.913508951663971,
-0.6338942050933838,
-0.7827964425086975,
0.11847813427448273,
-0.5722782611846924,
-0.4204156696796417,
0.5872083306312561,
0.25821033120155334,
-0.36632147431373596,
-0.21221749484539032,
-0.3639759123325348,
-0.6852351427078247,
0.9618854522705078,
0.4585745930671692,
-0.128538578748703,
-0.1187531054019928,
0.22800983488559723,
0.6876741051673889,
-0.3781907856464386,
0.6834867596626282,
0.5890774726867676,
0.5403156876564026,
-0.14411327242851257,
-0.973734974861145,
0.27954718470573425,
-0.22423572838306427,
-0.34453698992729187,
0.3410578668117523,
-0.3167419731616974,
0.4895981252193451,
-0.27809733152389526,
-0.474180668592453,
0.0910557210445404,
0.49367696046829224,
0.08727573603391647,
0.5105998516082764,
0.46490752696990967,
0.5241129994392395,
0.7737274765968323,
-0.22132231295108795,
0.9902711510658264,
-0.023635147139430046,
0.25827065110206604,
0.9793046712875366,
-0.29366999864578247,
0.9755299091339111,
0.4481015205383301,
-0.3224560618400574,
0.6078690886497498,
0.718883216381073,
0.5981202125549316,
0.31849703192710876,
0.5662080645561218,
-0.2985781729221344,
-0.3292999565601349,
-0.11449960619211197,
-0.2755379378795624,
0.4764364957809448,
0.266419380903244,
-0.03296414017677307,
-0.41319090127944946,
-0.2707853317260742,
-0.3121453821659088,
0.40144139528274536,
-0.4034179151058197,
0.9302560687065125,
0.08284521847963333,
-0.9367613196372986,
0.6434201598167419,
0.13991092145442963,
0.3031143546104431,
-0.45472022891044617,
-0.2784845530986786,
-0.02092139609158039,
-0.12228977680206299,
-0.40890178084373474,
-1.138474464416504,
0.4462687373161316,
0.22827725112438202,
-0.25528934597969055,
0.28536102175712585,
0.6115424036979675,
-0.42247700691223145,
-0.12668463587760925,
0.3964304029941559,
0.8289251923561096,
0.1660398542881012,
-0.2453734576702118,
-0.22432108223438263,
-0.6490058898925781,
-0.1537565290927887,
-0.1618971824645996,
-0.04058374464511871,
0.6576990485191345,
-0.2772744297981262,
0.512301504611969,
0.553618848323822,
-0.2682689428329468,
0.07096374779939651,
0.16533425450325012,
0.6877548098564148,
-0.5262709259986877,
-0.4533344805240631,
-0.5906036496162415,
0.4052193760871887,
-0.04529048502445221,
-0.2522529661655426,
0.7222453951835632,
0.6437708735466003,
0.7071255445480347,
-0.18556253612041473,
0.6326247453689575,
0.09408716857433319,
0.6397889852523804,
-0.6940951943397522,
0.4284285604953766,
-0.6025927662849426,
0.339476078748703,
-0.21098223328590393,
-0.995055615901947,
-0.23787346482276917,
0.22070102393627167,
-0.47425541281700134,
-0.18851810693740845,
0.777568519115448,
0.4841848611831665,
0.08185379207134247,
0.501165509223938,
0.3691660761833191,
-0.0664782002568245,
0.09643743187189102,
0.7136802077293396,
1.143896222114563,
-0.5027756690979004,
0.42303895950317383,
0.09773748368024826,
-0.5820506811141968,
-0.04895678535103798,
-0.6052638292312622,
-0.7362873554229736,
-0.3649729788303375,
-0.14183305203914642,
-0.44561222195625305,
0.1466161012649536,
0.791110098361969,
-0.07271023839712143,
-0.915494978427887,
-0.26665326952934265,
0.25685009360313416,
0.28656432032585144,
-0.21800750494003296,
-0.32956764101982117,
0.5371084809303284,
-0.2209234982728958,
-0.612708568572998,
0.059734418988227844,
0.2903960347175598,
-0.20571906864643097,
-0.27842390537261963,
-0.1904391199350357,
-0.13562311232089996,
0.48565277457237244,
0.636795163154602,
-0.12156321108341217,
-0.8820268511772156,
-0.5544285178184509,
0.33796530961990356,
0.03675786033272743,
-0.042092617601156235,
0.6345414519309998,
-0.7285904884338379,
0.4934396743774414,
0.5850736498832703,
0.9832074046134949,
0.07911146432161331,
0.24268867075443268,
0.6560935974121094,
-0.6029194593429565,
-0.4313725233078003,
0.29399850964546204,
-0.00833323784172535,
0.3156113922595978,
-0.29976025223731995,
0.6815798878669739,
-0.2549256980419159,
-0.43910250067710876,
-0.7476716637611389,
0.27539169788360596,
-0.846757173538208,
-0.28287220001220703,
1.107855200767517,
-0.3919496238231659,
-0.2869832515716553,
-0.35033079981803894,
-0.16129516065120697,
0.30188220739364624,
-0.17638465762138367,
0.4355686902999878,
0.8614574074745178,
-0.08168832212686539,
0.19738376140594482,
-0.5475961565971375,
0.35737746953964233,
0.34078240394592285,
-1.1265727281570435,
-0.009237382560968399,
0.5321736335754395,
0.35172489285469055,
0.26214393973350525,
0.591148853302002,
-0.36852505803108215,
0.4897976219654083,
-0.2892851233482361,
0.12940894067287445,
0.12058168649673462,
-0.2310311496257782,
-0.39768633246421814,
0.4995485544204712,
0.23475226759910583,
-0.33458834886550903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16700v1
|
Implicit Multimodal Alignment: On the Generalization of Frozen LLMs to Multimodal Inputs
| 2024-05-26T21:31:59 | 2024-05-26T21:31:59 |
Mustafa Shukor, Matthieu Cord
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance on
multimodal tasks, without any multimodal finetuning. They are the building
block for Large Multimodal Models, yet, we still lack a proper understanding of
their success. In this work, we expose frozen LLMs to image, video, audio and
text inputs and analyse their internal representation aiming to understand
their generalization beyond textual inputs.
Findings. Perceptual tokens (1) are easily distinguishable from textual ones
inside LLMs, with significantly different representations, and complete
translation to textual tokens does not exist. Yet, (2) both perceptual and
textual tokens activate similar LLM weights. Despite being different, (3)
perceptual and textual tokens are implicitly aligned inside LLMs, we call this
the implicit multimodal alignment (IMA), and argue that this is linked to
architectural design, helping LLMs to generalize. This provide more evidence to
believe that the generalization of LLMs to multimodal inputs is mainly due to
their architecture.
Implications. (1) We find a positive correlation between the implicit
alignment score and the task performance, suggesting that this could act as a
proxy metric for model evaluation and selection. (2) A negative correlation
exists regarding hallucinations, revealing that this problem is mainly due to
misalignment between the internal perceptual and textual representations. (3)
Perceptual tokens change slightly throughout the model, thus, we propose
different approaches to skip computations (e.g. in FFN layers), and
significantly reduce the inference cost. (4) Due to the slowly changing
embeddings across layers, and the high overlap between textual and multimodal
activated weights, we compress LLMs by keeping only 1 subnetwork that works
well across a wide range of multimodal tasks. Paper code:
https://github.com/mshukor/ima-lmms.
|
[
-0.3596680462360382,
-0.7219178080558777,
0.8374853730201721,
0.01409427635371685,
-0.1742185652256012,
0.02601875551044941,
-0.1562410444021225,
-0.5038578510284424,
0.16192986071109772,
0.07351306080818176,
-0.5777496099472046,
-0.5374090075492859,
-0.6779246926307678,
0.07755932211875916,
-0.43359214067459106,
0.5921981334686279,
-0.18251918256282806,
0.31191495060920715,
-0.5059928894042969,
-0.15454980731010437,
-0.4976115822792053,
-0.33049577474594116,
-0.4356967806816101,
-0.28241121768951416,
0.49133771657943726,
0.18744856119155884,
0.809045672416687,
0.6966608166694641,
0.4359062612056732,
0.44295454025268555,
0.06039411202073097,
0.14279405772686005,
-0.2627700865268707,
0.24508248269557953,
0.13732102513313293,
-0.2523648738861084,
-0.4257819652557373,
-0.16211864352226257,
0.7324867248535156,
0.41366612911224365,
0.10437265783548355,
0.12070398777723312,
0.26424092054367065,
0.34005972743034363,
-0.6183074116706848,
0.23737625777721405,
-0.49942800402641296,
0.13738594949245453,
-0.0811876505613327,
-0.08009029924869537,
-0.4216465353965759,
0.016338881105184555,
0.018713047727942467,
-0.6702022552490234,
0.03067462332546711,
0.1653786301612854,
0.7273783683776855,
0.5200459361076355,
-0.6094534993171692,
-0.39367273449897766,
-0.7246214747428894,
0.7181821465492249,
-0.620673418045044,
0.5904857516288757,
0.13661843538284302,
0.028794456273317337,
-0.12174684554338455,
-0.4911995232105255,
-0.6420922875404358,
-0.27367424964904785,
-0.17044585943222046,
0.13547037541866302,
-0.24892646074295044,
0.1863349974155426,
0.19633495807647705,
0.1511557698249817,
-0.6789392232894897,
0.3687102496623993,
-0.17598724365234375,
-0.37689724564552307,
0.3310028612613678,
0.3000040352344513,
0.5107672214508057,
-0.08243032544851303,
-0.6030019521713257,
0.0276977326720953,
-0.5186721682548523,
-0.04076950252056122,
0.3383386731147766,
0.10548218339681625,
-0.3431798219680786,
0.7776678204536438,
0.18160241842269897,
0.5783257484436035,
0.1147703304886818,
-0.3937697112560272,
0.31346696615219116,
-0.33005690574645996,
-0.2293105572462082,
0.21091434359550476,
0.8248579502105713,
0.42377766966819763,
0.2989233434200287,
-0.16441597044467926,
-0.10251946747303009,
0.2472439706325531,
0.3233546018600464,
-0.4266866147518158,
0.04843932390213013,
0.3542860448360443,
-0.3992263674736023,
0.03877142816781998,
-0.07915592193603516,
-0.6849603652954102,
-0.35298117995262146,
-0.5685514807701111,
0.3751252293586731,
-0.38564640283584595,
-0.12143479287624359,
-0.10677789896726608,
-0.007735217921435833,
0.2610473930835724,
0.44281959533691406,
-0.9293232560157776,
0.3761661648750305,
0.5669530034065247,
0.82674640417099,
-0.2680491805076599,
-0.4342464506626129,
-0.39684271812438965,
0.37274688482284546,
-0.4608742892742157,
0.7236860990524292,
-0.6316477060317993,
-0.02191806398332119,
0.12904731929302216,
0.05374513939023018,
-0.076211117208004,
-0.27803924679756165,
0.33247610926628113,
-0.5553298592567444,
0.21157659590244293,
0.05777335166931152,
-0.41805800795555115,
-0.20756150782108307,
0.1991991251707077,
-0.7743380665779114,
0.7723718285560608,
-0.3999022841453552,
-0.49898621439933777,
0.26267218589782715,
-0.4270723760128021,
-0.1571582555770874,
-0.217647984623909,
-0.36869969964027405,
-0.2066856175661087,
0.38733571767807007,
0.3730734586715698,
0.5217193365097046,
-0.3637482523918152,
0.2163417488336563,
-0.351519376039505,
-0.49292781949043274,
0.4219011068344116,
-0.4465717673301697,
0.2860802114009857,
0.17111067473888397,
-0.3661413788795471,
0.2509334981441498,
-0.557130753993988,
-0.0478755459189415,
-0.045183926820755005,
-0.3928937017917633,
-0.324594646692276,
0.03116733208298683,
0.05644627660512924,
0.2521251440048218,
0.2171870470046997,
-0.47988075017929077,
0.2904156744480133,
-0.0930832102894783,
0.3258199691772461,
1.0327630043029785,
-0.5044865012168884,
0.6252565383911133,
-0.21269755065441132,
0.4610633850097656,
0.21356256306171417,
-0.049678266048431396,
-0.3324252963066101,
-0.47214943170547485,
-0.5847524404525757,
-0.6059513092041016,
0.24990758299827576,
0.4987489879131317,
-0.6141408681869507,
-0.0746559351682663,
-0.40291497111320496,
0.022611059248447418,
-0.6515965461730957,
0.28569430112838745,
0.5116613507270813,
0.2644024193286896,
0.31534823775291443,
-0.08587293326854706,
-0.37793251872062683,
-1.159294843673706,
0.02216707356274128,
0.03696373850107193,
-0.049612801522016525,
0.14683669805526733,
0.45901384949684143,
-0.30202731490135193,
0.6295772194862366,
-0.39075344800949097,
-0.47907716035842896,
0.16804631054401398,
0.20448796451091766,
0.15958130359649658,
0.6859879493713379,
0.41580700874328613,
-0.762213945388794,
-0.218312606215477,
0.0006179534248076379,
-0.919981837272644,
0.006391941569745541,
-0.17464320361614227,
0.056222472339868546,
0.3779405355453491,
0.6844351291656494,
-0.9795593023300171,
0.19797541201114655,
0.7965778708457947,
-0.3197748064994812,
0.33890631794929504,
-0.16456475853919983,
0.255700945854187,
-1.0631295442581177,
-0.14303478598594666,
0.05189034342765808,
0.007266238797456026,
-0.5100437998771667,
0.05516420677304268,
0.15797683596611023,
0.010503852739930153,
-0.5063360333442688,
0.6185156106948853,
-0.9331446290016174,
-0.25890907645225525,
-0.05147843062877655,
0.23263131082057953,
-0.03265462815761566,
0.793083906173706,
-0.1480637788772583,
0.6240041255950928,
0.5771510601043701,
-0.3635176420211792,
0.3339119851589203,
0.030474575236439705,
-0.36883848905563354,
0.5595920085906982,
-0.45009833574295044,
0.36438918113708496,
-0.4244575798511505,
0.16877315938472748,
-1.3642230033874512,
-0.2614462375640869,
0.30423596501350403,
-0.2897590100765228,
0.6356420516967773,
-0.176396906375885,
-0.6024275422096252,
0.07248038798570633,
-0.310373991727829,
0.7513303756713867,
0.281525582075119,
-0.3696059584617615,
1.12544846534729,
0.23004111647605896,
-0.066039077937603,
-0.8130519986152649,
-0.7751047611236572,
0.14590150117874146,
-0.17468056082725525,
-0.6713099479675293,
0.4995436370372772,
-0.28845837712287903,
-0.4411739110946655,
0.2766697406768799,
-0.15082189440727234,
0.047787316143512726,
-0.17686085402965546,
0.5579293966293335,
0.300178587436676,
-0.6011490821838379,
0.2980698049068451,
0.0726693645119667,
-0.017824292182922363,
-0.09028948098421097,
-0.21757151186466217,
0.5816124677658081,
-0.0802234336733818,
-0.6502857804298401,
-0.5669168829917908,
0.45371365547180176,
0.9752287268638611,
0.030928876250982285,
0.7374729514122009,
0.5623064041137695,
-0.44343599677085876,
0.18906401097774506,
-0.7745294570922852,
0.01813196949660778,
-0.4491647183895111,
0.39154693484306335,
-0.5946844220161438,
-0.8186934590339661,
0.6813605427742004,
0.00002208868318120949,
-0.025087201967835426,
0.44320574402809143,
0.5434918403625488,
-0.31965139508247375,
1.1710309982299805,
0.5489596128463745,
0.1242259070277214,
0.360934853553772,
-0.07572410255670547,
-0.029902275651693344,
-1.077501654624939,
-0.43204250931739807,
-0.3625323474407196,
-0.5573151707649231,
-0.4360732436180115,
-0.4406939744949341,
0.3020879328250885,
-0.0915687158703804,
-0.22470428049564362,
-0.24065718054771423,
-0.26795557141304016,
0.48409512639045715,
0.2127823680639267,
0.03958128020167351,
0.19121091067790985,
0.06537063419818878,
-0.4433947503566742,
-0.2086966186761856,
-0.5553532242774963,
-0.5472057461738586,
0.916311502456665,
0.46308568120002747,
0.8658655881881714,
0.24405968189239502,
0.22838881611824036,
0.20298302173614502,
0.24952106177806854,
-0.7557424306869507,
0.4740859866142273,
-0.21525147557258606,
-0.45788368582725525,
-0.23298190534114838,
-0.16366145014762878,
-0.7635854482650757,
0.434854120016098,
-0.47422879934310913,
-0.7593410015106201,
0.20847861468791962,
0.11137140542268753,
-0.1769508570432663,
0.2852190434932709,
-0.8231599926948547,
0.6727252006530762,
-0.4133199155330658,
-0.5524355173110962,
-0.09866739809513092,
-0.45929089188575745,
0.5125769972801208,
-0.11667005717754364,
0.3669098913669586,
-0.06895893812179565,
-0.3028677701950073,
0.502192497253418,
-0.0034579008352011442,
0.9713385105133057,
0.10138177126646042,
-0.24365057051181793,
-0.07651243358850479,
0.16680017113685608,
0.4173896312713623,
-0.07239234447479248,
0.04797261208295822,
0.33917468786239624,
-0.09443602710962296,
-0.2635405659675598,
-0.6993057727813721,
0.9291691780090332,
-0.8858765363693237,
-0.6605240106582642,
-0.41762804985046387,
-0.8145483136177063,
-0.1323128193616867,
0.10584288835525513,
0.0985078364610672,
0.7671450972557068,
-0.07575418055057526,
0.21085606515407562,
0.746105432510376,
-0.09098787605762482,
0.44407713413238525,
0.3214293420314789,
-0.24474100768566132,
-0.44053375720977783,
0.5548471212387085,
0.18450042605400085,
0.11267413944005966,
0.6024492979049683,
-0.052722781896591187,
-0.31519702076911926,
-0.5563743710517883,
-0.552244246006012,
0.3015623390674591,
-0.9869604706764221,
-0.11528777331113815,
-0.7182429432868958,
-0.022642897441983223,
-0.5870700478553772,
-0.19058428704738617,
-0.24434536695480347,
-0.2986088693141937,
-0.528207540512085,
-0.18702447414398193,
0.04259072616696358,
0.8644809722900391,
0.01194576546549797,
0.2334475964307785,
-0.6786525249481201,
0.4876515865325928,
0.3110285699367523,
0.2879805266857147,
0.15168261528015137,
-0.4059360921382904,
-0.16405287384986877,
-0.02718353644013405,
-0.04072950407862663,
-0.7539083361625671,
0.2283305823802948,
0.11416470259428024,
0.7178387641906738,
0.5658759474754333,
-0.3068341910839081,
0.9029057025909424,
-0.5469616651535034,
0.7742982506752014,
0.39808690547943115,
-0.9089304804801941,
-0.012478455901145935,
-0.14672502875328064,
0.7659321427345276,
0.2036425620317459,
0.4915156960487366,
-0.3059140145778656,
-0.43700897693634033,
-0.0939047634601593,
-0.8071381449699402,
0.6007143259048462,
-0.03810117766261101,
0.32481998205184937,
0.18019992113113403,
0.3190290033817291,
0.11352866142988205,
0.10289518535137177,
-0.9112212061882019,
-0.1737491488456726,
-0.17515721917152405,
-0.4273488223552704,
-0.16510368883609772,
-0.6110441088676453,
-0.28777721524238586,
-0.0869017168879509,
0.3820018470287323,
-0.30021804571151733,
0.5176734328269958,
0.10398323833942413,
-0.24084828794002533,
-0.1360606551170349,
0.14372031390666962,
1.1079508066177368,
0.6420909762382507,
-0.07016630470752716,
0.5429803729057312,
0.11564920097589493,
-0.41151300072669983,
0.24173034727573395,
-0.1670808494091034,
0.14160031080245972,
-0.08159175515174866,
0.6672288775444031,
0.8080174326896667,
0.4966256618499756,
-0.46532514691352844,
0.2580435574054718,
-0.22257819771766663,
-0.20732341706752777,
-0.3713509440422058,
-0.22158657014369965,
0.159516841173172,
0.4928511381149292,
0.4974996745586395,
0.08392204344272614,
-0.1865409016609192,
-0.5971683859825134,
-0.005007633939385414,
0.6953976154327393,
-0.40754377841949463,
-0.37752676010131836,
0.6798136830329895,
-0.09222304821014404,
-0.2134881317615509,
0.7753264904022217,
0.3905563950538635,
-0.27673307061195374,
0.4395872950553894,
0.6291244029998779,
1.0416193008422852,
-0.06841715425252914,
-0.008013213984668255,
0.07652723789215088,
0.48448464274406433,
0.11332448571920395,
-0.01772492565214634,
-0.11172619462013245,
-0.9105163812637329,
-0.6091169118881226,
-0.6386296153068542,
-0.10396672040224075,
0.095450259745121,
-0.30605030059814453,
0.20224691927433014,
-0.32593128085136414,
-0.16820690035820007,
-0.16646386682987213,
-0.5671883821487427,
-0.6176389455795288,
0.17484380304813385,
0.46546199917793274,
0.6008161306381226,
-0.743880569934845,
0.810709536075592,
0.7411742806434631,
-0.20014816522598267,
-0.5689371824264526,
0.06993760168552399,
0.3672991991043091,
-0.7888501286506653,
0.8981468677520752,
0.05908900499343872,
-0.38607028126716614,
-0.25525644421577454,
-0.6264258027076721,
-1.220757246017456,
1.0942782163619995,
0.6526945233345032,
-0.48358938097953796,
-0.2856936454772949,
0.20699168741703033,
0.5057291984558105,
-0.6200089454650879,
0.24810011684894562,
-0.011930926702916622,
0.5172239542007446,
0.2732282876968384,
-0.8966488242149353,
0.22364801168441772,
-0.35064202547073364,
-0.004865856841206551,
0.20607149600982666,
-0.48248594999313354,
0.8659894466400146,
-0.09600495547056198,
-0.3368363380432129,
0.08113355189561844,
0.511390745639801,
0.06991485506296158,
0.2865833044052124,
0.3422708511352539,
0.661405086517334,
0.4482335150241852,
-0.1193983182311058,
1.013767957687378,
-0.2743445932865143,
-0.0473974384367466,
1.0617097616195679,
-0.20856523513793945,
0.6363034844398499,
0.7980048060417175,
0.23854289948940277,
0.42255696654319763,
0.4688141345977783,
0.21528993546962738,
0.5230986475944519,
0.06321362406015396,
0.02003168873488903,
-0.23256586492061615,
-0.07830148190259933,
-0.30823764204978943,
0.5454058647155762,
0.37701988220214844,
-0.40158194303512573,
-0.017983078956604004,
0.11556694656610489,
0.011097583919763565,
-0.21606700122356415,
-0.21056430041790009,
0.8276827335357666,
0.16779017448425293,
-0.6006014347076416,
0.5114548802375793,
-0.12799398601055145,
0.6061192750930786,
-0.7439520359039307,
-0.1865978091955185,
-0.1024860367178917,
0.07535424083471298,
-0.276425838470459,
-0.6974287033081055,
0.2176245003938675,
-0.29335781931877136,
-0.23506511747837067,
-0.40479233860969543,
0.4877761900424957,
-0.41341620683670044,
-0.385135293006897,
0.44405534863471985,
0.4378552734851837,
0.09656873345375061,
0.20505571365356445,
-0.5550429821014404,
0.5296310186386108,
-0.2206161469221115,
-0.29424211382865906,
0.4709860384464264,
0.4882688820362091,
-0.12093034386634827,
0.6107417345046997,
0.6395997405052185,
-0.0555957593023777,
0.21312710642814636,
-0.08287051320075989,
0.7683983445167542,
-0.5437102913856506,
-0.13568776845932007,
-1.055012583732605,
0.6435147523880005,
0.30424556136131287,
-0.27752065658569336,
0.6511570811271667,
0.4370320737361908,
0.7456148862838745,
-0.15948982536792755,
0.23297379910945892,
0.284915953874588,
-0.2602686583995819,
-1.1074414253234863,
0.5164283514022827,
-0.8271639943122864,
0.2426830381155014,
-0.4719572961330414,
-1.1258288621902466,
-0.3835287094116211,
0.3433177173137665,
-0.1404750794172287,
-0.18232661485671997,
0.8252394795417786,
0.7672199010848999,
-0.08891613781452179,
-0.20967964828014374,
0.5528085231781006,
0.4229457974433899,
0.13427004218101501,
0.36333519220352173,
1.049362301826477,
-0.24954453110694885,
0.44403713941574097,
0.0064003923907876015,
-0.052104830741882324,
-0.07644184678792953,
-0.9415017366409302,
-0.5895220041275024,
-0.8709207773208618,
-0.3162210285663605,
-0.11832468211650848,
-0.046200066804885864,
0.8155794739723206,
0.6982210278511047,
-0.6285338997840881,
-0.3500169813632965,
0.3274689018726349,
0.27971717715263367,
-0.19910627603530884,
-0.17927579581737518,
0.3218466341495514,
-0.12050087749958038,
-0.8454735279083252,
0.3826857805252075,
0.3959171772003174,
0.2647235691547394,
-0.4024416506290436,
-0.08019325882196426,
-0.3983994424343109,
0.13101184368133545,
0.6436523795127869,
-0.09901972860097885,
-1.0076075792312622,
-0.30301016569137573,
0.059147726744413376,
-0.22332847118377686,
0.27555835247039795,
0.700357973575592,
-0.6950603127479553,
0.4356813430786133,
0.4942968487739563,
0.44505348801612854,
0.567165732383728,
-0.12921397387981415,
0.6195687651634216,
-0.5102684497833252,
0.23776857554912567,
-0.016071045771241188,
0.5828185081481934,
0.23077808320522308,
-0.44030457735061646,
0.22346189618110657,
-0.05215277895331383,
-0.37044963240623474,
-0.8004908561706543,
0.17999468743801117,
-1.0836427211761475,
-0.4720917046070099,
1.0380303859710693,
0.10104982554912567,
-0.3381950855255127,
-0.019501661881804466,
-0.2714608609676361,
0.08715324848890305,
-0.41090255975723267,
0.7706423997879028,
0.9118497371673584,
-0.191744863986969,
-0.3807987570762634,
-0.5064166784286499,
0.31077811121940613,
0.3484455943107605,
-0.47655922174453735,
-0.25298601388931274,
0.7578030824661255,
0.13324777781963348,
0.5848464369773865,
0.5271036624908447,
-0.16955727338790894,
0.16415239870548248,
-0.18395763635635376,
0.0435909740626812,
-0.11920833587646484,
-0.5261749029159546,
-0.5367092490196228,
0.5670970678329468,
-0.1191454827785492,
-0.23856082558631897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16684v1
|
gzip Predicts Data-dependent Scaling Laws
| 2024-05-26T20:33:08 | 2024-05-26T20:33:08 |
Rohan Pandey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Past work has established scaling laws that predict the performance of a
neural language model (LM) as a function of its parameter count and the number
of tokens it's trained on, enabling optimal allocation of a fixed compute
budget. Are these scaling laws agnostic to training data as some prior work
suggests? We generate training datasets of varying complexities by modulating
the syntactic properties of a PCFG, finding that 1) scaling laws are sensitive
to differences in data complexity and that 2) gzip, a compression algorithm, is
an effective predictor of how data complexity impacts scaling properties. We
propose a new data-dependent scaling law for LM's that accounts for the
training data's gzip-compressibility; its compute-optimal frontier increases in
dataset size preference (over parameter count preference) as training data
becomes harder to compress.
|
[
-0.27984750270843506,
-0.5422902703285217,
0.24060048162937164,
0.40100058913230896,
0.007378359325230122,
-0.3348798155784607,
-0.33106252551078796,
-0.5357427000999451,
0.3803061544895172,
0.4128044843673706,
-0.4094367027282715,
0.31286728382110596,
-0.8655353784561157,
0.014932016842067242,
-0.33266037702560425,
0.6923327445983887,
0.23547545075416565,
0.24328984320163727,
-0.4502999484539032,
0.0283674206584692,
-0.3116396367549896,
-0.8921847343444824,
-0.160683274269104,
-0.4350779950618744,
0.2677256166934967,
0.1810872107744217,
1.0570509433746338,
1.156760573387146,
0.43609631061553955,
0.3236050307750702,
-0.1496749073266983,
-0.4460952579975128,
-0.18402715027332306,
-0.0032131504267454147,
0.11090393364429474,
-0.9572211503982544,
-0.10180527716875076,
-0.04082220792770386,
0.6344118118286133,
0.720512330532074,
-0.5210516452789307,
-0.03713871166110039,
0.09183508902788162,
0.7287371754646301,
-0.5768479108810425,
0.2580035924911499,
-0.7168605327606201,
0.10194795578718185,
-0.026360703632235527,
-0.39316970109939575,
-0.4933602809906006,
-0.10609281808137894,
-0.11074590682983398,
-0.25138360261917114,
0.6832329034805298,
0.045665185898542404,
0.6781986355781555,
0.5299461483955383,
-0.26313960552215576,
-0.40548521280288696,
-0.6432237029075623,
0.586708664894104,
-0.5733146071434021,
0.4137386679649353,
0.5243275165557861,
0.3392990529537201,
-0.19880221784114838,
-0.75644451379776,
-0.4924316108226776,
-0.1443636268377304,
-0.13712847232818604,
-0.3401305377483368,
-0.20219680666923523,
0.17298124730587006,
0.5102725028991699,
0.7929428815841675,
-0.5376697778701782,
0.2072591483592987,
-0.5763759613037109,
-0.10648617893457413,
0.3415192663669586,
0.292462557554245,
0.5029182434082031,
-0.06866932660341263,
-0.22165517508983612,
0.12027085572481155,
-0.7131938338279724,
0.07925865054130554,
0.39886125922203064,
0.6887297034263611,
-0.2235041856765747,
0.2620781362056732,
-0.3122776746749878,
0.7385076880455017,
0.2155965119600296,
-0.14011353254318237,
0.3976404070854187,
-0.10418596118688583,
-0.27743884921073914,
0.10933451354503632,
0.5880457758903503,
0.15623065829277039,
0.38140952587127686,
-0.47706836462020874,
-0.0650244876742363,
-0.07330024987459183,
0.40839746594429016,
-1.2046988010406494,
-0.2390589565038681,
-0.008217566646635532,
-0.3336278796195984,
-0.21922478079795837,
-0.01216103881597519,
-0.45521000027656555,
-0.6444393396377563,
-0.474643737077713,
0.4898364245891571,
-0.07815386354923248,
-0.02191479504108429,
0.4171997606754303,
0.027830714359879494,
-0.006120673846453428,
0.11391521245241165,
-1.5860881805419922,
0.5073680877685547,
0.594007670879364,
1.0427005290985107,
0.34989628195762634,
-0.45126715302467346,
-0.7256888747215271,
-0.15388455986976624,
-0.032324038445949554,
0.43819764256477356,
-0.5012680292129517,
-0.03599761426448822,
0.06736104190349579,
0.1264655590057373,
-0.023147255182266235,
-0.4660457968711853,
0.40885722637176514,
-0.4530905783176422,
-0.1592041403055191,
-0.3693181872367859,
-0.7107810378074646,
-0.015053640119731426,
-0.08829212933778763,
-0.8899233937263489,
0.42454129457473755,
0.31902164220809937,
-0.7807353138923645,
0.7680642008781433,
-0.15934672951698303,
-0.5131757855415344,
0.257040798664093,
-0.2172989547252655,
-0.4394937753677368,
0.3901067078113556,
0.13905669748783112,
0.4169037640094757,
-0.5720484256744385,
0.3002070188522339,
-0.6028737425804138,
-0.3792378306388855,
-0.07630826532840729,
-0.2576896846294403,
0.7312604784965515,
0.0671297162771225,
-0.059176988899707794,
-0.19657832384109497,
-0.8450298309326172,
0.22364866733551025,
0.03094230405986309,
-0.673466682434082,
0.1846507340669632,
0.3716433048248291,
-0.19986936450004578,
0.058011919260025024,
0.08048690855503082,
-0.5223947763442993,
0.6405701041221619,
-0.22929726541042328,
0.6695486903190613,
0.6669521331787109,
-0.03938918560743332,
0.5755760669708252,
-0.27631592750549316,
0.5895105600357056,
-0.3327168822288513,
0.2792695462703705,
0.10450480878353119,
-0.24368354678153992,
-0.38129690289497375,
-0.22542639076709747,
0.40625953674316406,
0.30312299728393555,
-0.3782368004322052,
0.18563006818294525,
-0.3723624348640442,
-0.5197727680206299,
-0.048792652785778046,
0.07914412021636963,
-0.16875673830509186,
0.26853206753730774,
0.4620782732963562,
-0.13876211643218994,
-0.5785086154937744,
-0.8516886830329895,
-0.15955635905265808,
-0.23688675463199615,
-0.2156120091676712,
0.338000625371933,
0.33669739961624146,
0.12835176289081573,
0.7030686140060425,
-0.4461238980293274,
-0.16444119811058044,
-0.33697158098220825,
0.2554047405719757,
0.3653554618358612,
0.4850062131881714,
0.8028992414474487,
-0.7558355927467346,
-0.48224127292633057,
-0.3165685534477234,
-0.35463955998420715,
-0.16912955045700073,
-0.022357938811182976,
0.5700421333312988,
-0.08553130179643631,
0.621607780456543,
-0.5730648636817932,
0.22440753877162933,
0.6270747780799866,
-0.3058733642101288,
0.6856201887130737,
-0.517760694026947,
-0.11802415549755096,
-0.5034668445587158,
-0.18256622552871704,
-0.1255563646554947,
0.02530113235116005,
-0.9028201699256897,
0.00647612614557147,
0.2628914713859558,
0.16751527786254883,
-0.3375089466571808,
0.037290532141923904,
-0.3837355077266693,
-0.1654958724975586,
-0.26707127690315247,
-0.8717052340507507,
-0.2390160858631134,
0.4706544280052185,
0.1575094759464264,
0.8259361386299133,
0.771806001663208,
-0.5026272535324097,
0.1377446949481964,
0.04534333571791649,
-0.3873077630996704,
0.1797838807106018,
-0.8098037838935852,
0.06704028695821762,
0.11601320654153824,
0.20282083749771118,
-0.4748813807964325,
-0.30630311369895935,
-0.06888751685619354,
-0.3924783170223236,
0.45863187313079834,
-0.6298705339431763,
-0.9334508776664734,
-0.06905490159988403,
-0.1654607504606247,
0.4207032024860382,
0.41502776741981506,
-0.6295140981674194,
0.5728323459625244,
0.2700454294681549,
-0.044804345816373825,
-0.4982408881187439,
-0.8086812496185303,
0.0027332601603120565,
-0.18859471380710602,
-0.543915331363678,
0.18842481076717377,
-0.3252606689929962,
-0.0004596419457811862,
-0.27197590470314026,
0.05841369181871414,
-0.3455655872821808,
0.1657343953847885,
0.594299852848053,
0.04574767127633095,
-0.18303100764751434,
0.02424309216439724,
-0.25527724623680115,
0.30121561884880066,
0.5076856017112732,
-0.5055668354034424,
0.7968733310699463,
-0.3249503970146179,
0.20315828919410706,
0.30719155073165894,
0.046588681638240814,
0.6105509400367737,
0.10293355584144592,
0.7308254837989807,
0.309129923582077,
-0.23515239357948303,
-0.3758540153503418,
-0.10878268629312515,
0.027267999947071075,
-0.5169606804847717,
0.2084227204322815,
-0.25416845083236694,
-0.681243360042572,
0.5665218830108643,
0.25865650177001953,
-0.3866432011127472,
0.395589679479599,
0.6369569897651672,
0.32556137442588806,
0.8673475384712219,
0.9273468852043152,
-0.4003136157989502,
0.535615086555481,
-0.09017018973827362,
-0.19016103446483612,
-0.32301896810531616,
0.25949016213417053,
-0.6425608396530151,
-0.5350064039230347,
-0.9288259148597717,
-0.11495205014944077,
0.13879290223121643,
0.1399402916431427,
-0.16894380748271942,
0.20968671143054962,
-0.3299437463283539,
0.9056111574172974,
0.37976714968681335,
0.11064217239618301,
-0.11548175662755966,
0.07839315384626389,
0.29984158277511597,
0.16430290043354034,
-0.8285149335861206,
0.22492095828056335,
1.3582353591918945,
0.2371593862771988,
0.6662245988845825,
0.034050486981868744,
0.41085395216941833,
0.48267099261283875,
-0.015762193128466606,
-0.8203855752944946,
0.32467788457870483,
-0.32521235942840576,
-0.5304390788078308,
-0.14453279972076416,
-0.7261341214179993,
-1.0125387907028198,
-0.05339799076318741,
-0.13415445387363434,
-1.0158697366714478,
0.3172793686389923,
-0.004322528839111328,
-0.2643565237522125,
0.42522016167640686,
-0.6360677480697632,
0.2663167715072632,
-0.08533904701471329,
-0.23404476046562195,
-0.3151090443134308,
-0.8294047117233276,
-0.09089258313179016,
0.0013573941541835666,
0.013416503556072712,
0.15394875407218933,
0.01689312420785427,
0.7047118544578552,
-0.8094792366027832,
0.6874485015869141,
-0.3531222939491272,
0.19796058535575867,
0.22932635247707367,
0.20445598661899567,
0.3972230553627014,
-0.11442537605762482,
0.08331543207168579,
0.2363254576921463,
-0.021755635738372803,
-0.4620046615600586,
-0.7926061749458313,
0.43816450238227844,
-0.7464897632598877,
-0.3766452670097351,
-0.2925434410572052,
-0.9598987102508545,
-0.28250882029533386,
0.2455228716135025,
0.5471726655960083,
0.47663137316703796,
0.30424773693084717,
0.3744644820690155,
0.38664987683296204,
0.015093679539859295,
0.40325766801834106,
0.5122638940811157,
-0.10171516984701157,
-0.45737406611442566,
1.064635157585144,
0.6711965203285217,
0.44761013984680176,
0.21959134936332703,
0.40182915329933167,
-0.0076472098007798195,
-0.795148491859436,
-0.32502269744873047,
-0.04960155487060547,
-0.6771705150604248,
-0.12848834693431854,
-0.2492925226688385,
-0.34999823570251465,
-0.0577392540872097,
-0.34053197503089905,
-0.17923738062381744,
-0.697348415851593,
-0.08326084911823273,
0.04905528202652931,
0.27913251519203186,
0.7111946940422058,
-0.38984060287475586,
0.33145591616630554,
-0.462739497423172,
0.060477811843156815,
0.17854030430316925,
0.5304858684539795,
-0.2831985652446747,
-0.6776735186576843,
-0.44791752099990845,
-0.15370076894760132,
0.030713172629475594,
-0.44992437958717346,
0.3260321021080017,
0.5401148200035095,
0.15052202343940735,
0.35863274335861206,
-0.15082357823848724,
0.07260297238826752,
-0.5022422671318054,
0.6250551342964172,
0.3576255440711975,
-0.7368762493133545,
0.1854877769947052,
-0.38728296756744385,
0.2735573649406433,
0.36772897839546204,
0.2094162255525589,
-0.26419565081596375,
-0.462112694978714,
-0.9119478464126587,
-0.8073975443840027,
0.6408655047416687,
-0.07969465851783752,
0.3832024335861206,
0.2846924960613251,
0.6883765459060669,
0.2971958816051483,
0.306311696767807,
-0.558107316493988,
-0.16107797622680664,
-0.09997736662626266,
0.13348229229450226,
0.026291968300938606,
-0.2817924916744232,
0.23947077989578247,
-0.31580302119255066,
0.24990041553974152,
-0.24335473775863647,
0.24772179126739502,
-0.1618386209011078,
0.08449864387512207,
-0.11608493328094482,
0.19561830163002014,
0.6620602607727051,
0.4845742881298065,
-0.4662451446056366,
0.15495584905147552,
-0.04630299657583237,
-1.0580531358718872,
0.29561522603034973,
0.058258868753910065,
-0.49644050002098083,
-0.15048950910568237,
0.35043299198150635,
0.6664664149284363,
-0.18735867738723755,
-0.24065496027469635,
0.44616973400115967,
-0.2468935251235962,
-0.5369403958320618,
-0.08288711309432983,
0.3894251585006714,
-0.10506514459848404,
0.16478131711483002,
0.22966234385967255,
0.21304315328598022,
0.16645346581935883,
-0.32784539461135864,
0.37108635902404785,
0.2042434811592102,
-0.23985834419727325,
-0.4374399483203888,
0.6991543173789978,
-0.1416558176279068,
-0.13833487033843994,
0.6745193004608154,
-0.02308814227581024,
-0.4475613534450531,
0.7996288537979126,
0.43540841341018677,
0.7692508697509766,
-0.2552686333656311,
-0.014816323295235634,
0.37239599227905273,
0.475408136844635,
-0.2783168852329254,
0.30087605118751526,
-0.20412667095661163,
-0.6301072835922241,
-0.304243266582489,
-0.4797598421573639,
-0.32111531496047974,
0.27835509181022644,
-0.8319404721260071,
0.37418296933174133,
-0.9799877405166626,
-0.1370430737733841,
0.2823410630226135,
0.08673272281885147,
-0.6677679419517517,
0.49953433871269226,
0.22692717611789703,
0.9751838445663452,
-0.6715825796127319,
0.8723324537277222,
0.06035811826586723,
-0.4075152575969696,
-0.7507709860801697,
0.12555959820747375,
0.056758005172014236,
-0.7211369872093201,
0.5118271708488464,
0.21047215163707733,
0.08795680105686188,
-0.22371923923492432,
-0.689202606678009,
-0.9605858325958252,
0.8996574878692627,
1.066813349723816,
-0.4574260711669922,
0.021604757755994797,
0.4894612431526184,
0.6300292611122131,
-0.3693682849407196,
0.16817693412303925,
0.45534977316856384,
0.10120636224746704,
0.027142813429236412,
-0.9349728226661682,
-0.10010168701410294,
-0.37476977705955505,
-0.32328835129737854,
0.49668094515800476,
-0.6875810623168945,
1.083672285079956,
-0.3333253860473633,
-0.17519056797027588,
-0.28250837326049805,
0.5649232864379883,
-0.47260913252830505,
-0.057849764823913574,
0.5879764556884766,
0.6804645657539368,
0.7088097929954529,
-0.00560448644682765,
1.3118096590042114,
-0.5566726922988892,
0.4564460813999176,
1.2701460123062134,
0.018601983785629272,
0.8177164793014526,
0.47396403551101685,
-0.320255309343338,
0.47868409752845764,
0.5127974152565002,
-0.5137815475463867,
0.422708660364151,
0.5522809624671936,
0.00022243402781896293,
0.02858761139214039,
-0.25202128291130066,
-0.3137866258621216,
0.454860121011734,
0.00047292487579397857,
-0.5837083458900452,
-0.1556830108165741,
-0.36410605907440186,
0.2010038048028946,
-0.3097141981124878,
-0.46916255354881287,
0.4232572615146637,
-0.2897944748401642,
-0.3003964126110077,
0.913912832736969,
-0.14293387532234192,
0.2901260554790497,
-0.6611311435699463,
0.3310372829437256,
-0.10830564051866531,
0.10406854748725891,
-0.2667674124240875,
-0.7141470909118652,
0.23087014257907867,
-0.2702665328979492,
-0.6340174078941345,
-0.13143283128738403,
0.6052235960960388,
-0.2192770391702652,
-0.38533589243888855,
0.18362930417060852,
0.19199766218662262,
-0.0005264298524707556,
-0.2250758707523346,
-0.4316742718219757,
-0.043546829372644424,
-0.10596399754285812,
-0.5310971140861511,
0.7688625454902649,
0.21456201374530792,
0.22071346640586853,
0.7727701663970947,
0.35020220279693604,
0.5254828333854675,
0.126170814037323,
0.09225545078516006,
0.8213539123535156,
-0.32667702436447144,
-0.7974925637245178,
-0.9256789684295654,
0.138625830411911,
0.19633284211158752,
-0.11793061345815659,
0.340425968170166,
0.5563229322433472,
0.6042916774749756,
0.14152419567108154,
0.8974283933639526,
-0.24764437973499298,
0.000823690090328455,
-0.5360819697380066,
0.6726081371307373,
-0.5011258125305176,
0.20545166730880737,
0.14724884927272797,
-0.686396598815918,
-0.24570973217487335,
0.032173041254282,
-0.28518903255462646,
-0.011810441501438618,
0.502365231513977,
0.8810426592826843,
-0.04860702529549599,
0.20325148105621338,
0.1450454294681549,
0.07553821802139282,
0.261420875787735,
0.6859036087989807,
0.2651301622390747,
-0.18198485672473907,
0.4560813307762146,
-0.39189520478248596,
-0.1253214329481125,
-0.028944699093699455,
-0.8440180420875549,
-0.5825697183609009,
-0.6981111764907837,
-0.2431628406047821,
-0.314848929643631,
-0.46274110674858093,
0.740261435508728,
0.7064394950866699,
-0.5076477527618408,
-0.28927385807037354,
-0.5418279767036438,
-0.23665033280849457,
-0.26458191871643066,
-0.17445379495620728,
0.23200297355651855,
-0.3446975350379944,
-0.26234185695648193,
0.2525426745414734,
0.24323341250419617,
0.2698603868484497,
-0.24259714782238007,
-0.2274315357208252,
0.20973992347717285,
0.4163620173931122,
0.1585419625043869,
0.495945543050766,
-0.3540990948677063,
-0.23455145955085754,
-0.24167251586914062,
-0.12941882014274597,
0.3439149856567383,
1.0681487321853638,
-0.5218953490257263,
0.593065083026886,
0.5929632782936096,
0.5466604828834534,
0.3835565149784088,
-0.2530727982521057,
0.6475182771682739,
-0.6937521696090698,
0.18212492763996124,
0.002942903432995081,
0.498538076877594,
0.025736292824149132,
-0.7227877974510193,
0.6119444966316223,
0.23810327053070068,
-0.8246620297431946,
-0.8102203011512756,
0.1423606127500534,
-0.6570382714271545,
-0.25276198983192444,
1.084501028060913,
-0.15899883210659027,
-0.27677851915359497,
0.3564348816871643,
0.10994869470596313,
-0.1361805647611618,
-0.12392313033342361,
0.8550007939338684,
0.8571467399597168,
-0.20223458111286163,
-0.3045700490474701,
-0.7008371353149414,
0.6906730532646179,
0.4744133949279785,
-0.6505735516548157,
0.4796419143676758,
0.3777536451816559,
0.13596144318580627,
0.08707280457019806,
0.34022703766822815,
0.2526102662086487,
0.17266307771205902,
0.31120333075523376,
-0.03019840270280838,
-0.2151157408952713,
-0.4287680983543396,
-0.5486716032028198,
0.5859147906303406,
-0.018156789243221283,
0.1195627823472023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16682v1
|
A Systematic Review of Federated Generative Models
| 2024-05-26T20:20:44 | 2024-05-26T20:20:44 |
Ashkan Vedadi Gargary, Emiliano De Cristofaro
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Federated Learning (FL) has emerged as a solution for distributed systems
that allow clients to train models on their data and only share models instead
of local data. Generative Models are designed to learn the distribution of a
dataset and generate new data samples that are similar to the original data.
Many prior works have tried proposing Federated Generative Models. Using
Federated Learning and Generative Models together can be susceptible to
attacks, and designing the optimal architecture remains challenging.
This survey covers the growing interest in the intersection of FL and
Generative Models by comprehensively reviewing research conducted from 2019 to
2024. We systematically compare nearly 100 papers, focusing on their FL and
Generative Model methods and privacy considerations. To make this field more
accessible to newcomers, we highlight the state-of-the-art advancements and
identify unresolved challenges, offering insights for future research in this
evolving field.
|
[
-0.4368159770965576,
-0.7252244353294373,
0.15737709403038025,
0.2285870611667633,
0.2408817559480667,
0.053216353058815,
0.1770308017730713,
-0.914786159992218,
-0.05054440721869469,
0.295432448387146,
-0.7936035990715027,
-0.2589957118034363,
-0.33520787954330444,
0.3511768877506256,
-0.7946411967277527,
0.8289491534233093,
0.10289068520069122,
0.17784421145915985,
-0.5920001268386841,
-0.1660887748003006,
0.02915683016180992,
-0.5586240887641907,
-0.28754565119743347,
-0.3838898539543152,
0.3512440323829651,
-0.10137124359607697,
0.6603856682777405,
0.06149721518158913,
0.9209516048431396,
0.34368571639060974,
-0.061326559633016586,
0.08117176592350006,
-0.6494637131690979,
0.36397191882133484,
-0.21335357427597046,
-0.39379677176475525,
-0.4620462656021118,
-0.010967652313411236,
0.4739767014980316,
1.0165921449661255,
-0.3500562310218811,
0.11843279749155045,
-0.3117738664150238,
0.9331197738647461,
-0.8597205877304077,
0.2862171232700348,
-0.23189370334148407,
0.555290699005127,
-0.2345806360244751,
0.1629755049943924,
-0.5644576549530029,
-0.6429752707481384,
0.4534427523612976,
-0.5794379115104675,
0.7311593294143677,
-0.03606424480676651,
0.4601270854473114,
-0.20778781175613403,
-0.15121319890022278,
-0.2303166389465332,
-1.0193426609039307,
0.4890505075454712,
0.04287504032254219,
0.4733714461326599,
-0.1403319388628006,
0.5546481609344482,
-0.09877410531044006,
-0.952399492263794,
-0.17536771297454834,
0.18460708856582642,
-0.14270469546318054,
0.10229872912168503,
-0.7386343479156494,
0.07181117683649063,
0.0001259690907318145,
0.9229044914245605,
-0.6108177304267883,
0.1144646480679512,
-0.2570173442363739,
0.0763992965221405,
1.026541829109192,
0.056670479476451874,
0.23456989228725433,
0.08745294064283371,
-0.8797215223312378,
-0.28702425956726074,
-0.6186047792434692,
-0.2334604114294052,
0.30562567710876465,
0.19030769169330597,
-0.1429266631603241,
0.30842241644859314,
-0.5031143426895142,
0.6656627655029297,
0.12509140372276306,
0.11293995380401611,
0.22734831273555756,
-0.18589892983436584,
-0.5900936126708984,
-0.4681934416294098,
0.965789258480072,
0.046190809458494186,
-0.18461570143699646,
-0.5455427169799805,
-0.7069242000579834,
-0.40640363097190857,
0.12968546152114868,
-0.4096923768520355,
-0.13329584896564484,
0.3211550712585449,
-0.47831255197525024,
-0.6577662229537964,
0.5731185078620911,
-0.905404806137085,
-0.4682646095752716,
-0.0321425199508667,
0.20551051199436188,
-0.1187364012002945,
-0.8417369723320007,
-0.043702736496925354,
-0.189738467335701,
-0.008204593323171139,
0.5003853440284729,
-0.9547079205513,
0.30684694647789,
1.190652847290039,
0.9588969349861145,
-0.007037327159196138,
-0.18632185459136963,
-0.18136315047740936,
-0.22917544841766357,
-0.3821336328983307,
0.5798156261444092,
-0.1366112232208252,
-0.5827128887176514,
0.47113245725631714,
-0.12043247371912003,
-0.18411630392074585,
-0.3086601197719574,
-0.05013003572821617,
-0.9502623081207275,
0.399476557970047,
-0.4118988811969757,
-0.6957226991653442,
-0.1455778032541275,
0.15661004185676575,
-0.7689831256866455,
0.20153795182704926,
0.43611079454421997,
-0.9275115132331848,
0.4672110378742218,
-0.6374061107635498,
-0.24628981947898865,
0.4093377888202667,
-0.25961270928382874,
-0.6430078744888306,
0.29692205786705017,
0.10801731795072556,
0.5907750725746155,
-0.3141716718673706,
0.44164010882377625,
-0.5478634238243103,
-0.16379636526107788,
0.20227676630020142,
-0.24393025040626526,
1.0405901670455933,
0.6999782919883728,
-0.31080910563468933,
0.2747592329978943,
-0.5383467674255371,
-0.10605815798044205,
0.33558768033981323,
0.11019164323806763,
-0.15070423483848572,
-0.08369337022304535,
0.07527165859937668,
-0.15846635401248932,
0.1331183910369873,
-0.4804084897041321,
0.01799924671649933,
-0.3819825053215027,
0.5607761144638062,
0.8027041554450989,
0.1555994600057602,
0.6741649508476257,
-0.7115898728370667,
0.7766551971435547,
0.02581409364938736,
0.7365986108779907,
-0.07401560992002487,
-0.22365055978298187,
-0.4226260185241699,
-0.16261787712574005,
0.09964315593242645,
0.007915394380688667,
-0.743705689907074,
0.18360063433647156,
-0.312195748090744,
-0.6606465578079224,
-0.2818829119205475,
-0.23608243465423584,
0.22939005494117737,
0.062154293060302734,
0.10560479760169983,
-0.12463628500699997,
-0.18847864866256714,
-0.5016950368881226,
0.12770220637321472,
-0.1451791524887085,
0.023790743201971054,
0.44655588269233704,
0.3838557302951813,
-0.398380845785141,
1.0005309581756592,
-0.454218327999115,
-0.37330496311187744,
-0.189217671751976,
0.08330884575843811,
-0.43536078929901123,
0.27753138542175293,
0.7986963391304016,
-0.9823498129844666,
-0.42423638701438904,
0.17483989894390106,
-1.0319781303405762,
0.5130933523178101,
0.04905391111969948,
0.07086178660392761,
0.10404730588197708,
-0.0013088276609778404,
-0.5714586973190308,
0.1358821541070938,
0.4740246534347534,
-0.07842672616243362,
0.46049949526786804,
-0.06423473358154297,
0.1659725159406662,
-0.7764559388160706,
0.1370939016342163,
-0.27909111976623535,
-0.07768741250038147,
-0.8580185770988464,
0.7697672843933105,
-0.05836618319153786,
-0.5284077525138855,
-0.14497175812721252,
0.10900577902793884,
-0.7575318813323975,
-0.30323538184165955,
-0.08076181262731552,
-0.3064376711845398,
-0.21662107110023499,
-0.030990304425358772,
-0.03823552280664444,
0.7136836051940918,
0.9127771258354187,
-0.22946149110794067,
0.6659311056137085,
0.40152889490127563,
-0.4227423369884491,
0.4635869562625885,
-0.422225683927536,
0.26269102096557617,
-0.2572271227836609,
0.4733332097530365,
-0.49517571926116943,
-0.6193985939025879,
0.180494487285614,
-0.2984565496444702,
0.1316174417734146,
0.2379751056432724,
-0.5039790868759155,
-0.4299636483192444,
-0.0649421215057373,
0.2572619318962097,
0.3617713153362274,
-0.8606428503990173,
0.46934622526168823,
0.2986429035663605,
0.23143218457698822,
-0.5987580418586731,
-0.6129222512245178,
-0.2698562443256378,
0.03652484714984894,
-0.8277279734611511,
0.0694441869854927,
0.35237398743629456,
-0.5068789720535278,
-0.09733466804027557,
-0.11786984652280807,
-0.1392962634563446,
0.3107442855834961,
0.43805304169654846,
-0.2122044563293457,
-0.31656768918037415,
0.11069346964359283,
-0.28823333978652954,
0.16199451684951782,
0.20425936579704285,
-0.17908726632595062,
0.43760842084884644,
-0.16752345860004425,
-0.4699454605579376,
-0.321042001247406,
0.652411699295044,
0.5059531331062317,
-0.514337956905365,
0.7705053091049194,
0.5228062868118286,
-0.23106800019741058,
-0.6311487555503845,
-0.4146815538406372,
-0.3630576431751251,
-0.48815008997917175,
-0.1412270963191986,
-0.2511531710624695,
-1.0146645307540894,
0.4243679642677307,
-0.03560063615441322,
0.49197688698768616,
0.21764199435710907,
0.30524688959121704,
-0.1527153104543686,
0.44945013523101807,
1.1303623914718628,
-0.0003086554352194071,
0.6579818725585938,
-0.4322147071361542,
0.44394969940185547,
-0.12732072174549103,
-0.4383224844932556,
-0.24302233755588531,
-0.17929863929748535,
-0.6483128070831299,
-0.194414421916008,
0.23161299526691437,
-0.17373067140579224,
0.13065025210380554,
0.04234609007835388,
-0.4829829931259155,
0.15896348655223846,
0.46056461334228516,
0.16433818638324738,
0.29526662826538086,
0.17228035628795624,
0.028107699006795883,
0.48182398080825806,
-0.6130219101905823,
0.11466971039772034,
1.1534072160720825,
0.441577672958374,
0.8357049822807312,
0.29298311471939087,
1.1040862798690796,
0.3876705467700958,
0.6887350678443909,
-0.2782568335533142,
0.2677890658378601,
0.1380607783794403,
-0.8950284719467163,
-0.2222621887922287,
-0.7844071388244629,
-0.8514149188995361,
0.3390290439128876,
-0.10582484304904938,
-0.27788448333740234,
0.7321712374687195,
0.007737670559436083,
-0.33567240834236145,
0.5390918254852295,
-0.5466276407241821,
0.37336915731430054,
-0.01750701293349266,
-0.23536410927772522,
-0.11948098987340927,
-0.6498135328292847,
0.799274742603302,
0.08699683099985123,
0.16178949177265167,
0.13777600228786469,
0.5588294863700867,
0.5391703844070435,
-0.6177365779876709,
0.7010310888290405,
-0.2679956257343292,
-0.04045436158776283,
0.2834821939468384,
-0.2125430703163147,
0.19376565515995026,
0.08898109942674637,
-0.014802047982811928,
0.24990278482437134,
0.02401828020811081,
-0.2991071343421936,
-0.3506096601486206,
0.6576686501502991,
-0.8604907393455505,
-0.6083254218101501,
-0.8958857655525208,
-0.20169611275196075,
-0.20101842284202576,
0.2079433798789978,
0.3499540686607361,
0.17351040244102478,
-0.6106298565864563,
0.32298994064331055,
0.7420650124549866,
0.20413918793201447,
0.39306920766830444,
0.5302521586418152,
-0.31115275621414185,
-0.5906493663787842,
0.6199010610580444,
0.02964671328663826,
0.4280926287174225,
0.5102171301841736,
0.03287801146507263,
0.00121009792201221,
-0.42219844460487366,
-0.07582411915063858,
0.12996427714824677,
-0.6014242768287659,
-0.3214738667011261,
-0.6067476272583008,
-0.5275287628173828,
-0.5916233062744141,
-0.24673530459403992,
-0.42403480410575867,
-0.07853525876998901,
-0.5402892827987671,
-0.3069632947444916,
0.3558385670185089,
0.9438291788101196,
-0.15024487674236298,
0.20587624609470367,
-0.4475962221622467,
0.003546458203345537,
0.21558263897895813,
0.5471423864364624,
0.3934584856033325,
0.41220346093177795,
0.09568632394075394,
0.09359420090913773,
-0.32090890407562256,
-0.8907755017280579,
0.10919035971164703,
0.15460701286792755,
0.33804619312286377,
0.9532140493392944,
0.4344761073589325,
0.5361219048500061,
-0.30952340364456177,
0.5741152167320251,
0.4443122446537018,
-0.4881814122200012,
0.500163197517395,
-0.2868189215660095,
-0.07621067762374878,
0.45035040378570557,
0.5987580418586731,
-0.2799503803253174,
-0.1324089914560318,
-0.8613019585609436,
-0.38178297877311707,
0.4749792516231537,
0.12031075358390808,
0.11426954716444016,
0.18921968340873718,
0.167291060090065,
0.33819422125816345,
0.30339503288269043,
-0.588317334651947,
-0.42931368947029114,
-0.06987040489912033,
0.12697148323059082,
0.06736601889133453,
-0.0609884113073349,
-0.49755197763442993,
-0.020660776644945145,
0.13843446969985962,
0.07644249498844147,
0.47392943501472473,
0.15373718738555908,
0.11334456503391266,
-0.5031066536903381,
0.1377107948064804,
0.20828679203987122,
0.6564531326293945,
-0.14116430282592773,
-0.21677806973457336,
-0.4390904903411865,
-0.37717851996421814,
0.29653921723365784,
0.3282414972782135,
-0.7480394244194031,
0.10142010450363159,
0.45716699957847595,
0.8299638628959656,
0.30533337593078613,
-0.42904505133628845,
0.8428155779838562,
-0.06631840020418167,
-0.7743036150932312,
-0.4989842474460602,
0.3122599124908447,
-0.257637619972229,
0.21087779104709625,
0.12918490171432495,
0.3695368766784668,
0.10484334081411362,
-0.5545235276222229,
0.28163251280784607,
0.6573694944381714,
-0.23722346127033234,
-0.5356884002685547,
0.6961418390274048,
0.3500080704689026,
-0.17022857069969177,
0.648915708065033,
0.09525622427463531,
-0.24392051994800568,
0.21945838630199432,
0.25889357924461365,
0.9903556704521179,
-0.30090785026550293,
0.6406545639038086,
0.06970066577196121,
0.12867775559425354,
-0.2713572084903717,
0.3066859543323517,
-0.754632830619812,
-0.6151646375656128,
0.4556015729904175,
-0.7264043092727661,
-0.6275708675384521,
-0.006943202577531338,
-1.0538818836212158,
-0.22564904391765594,
-0.6944051384925842,
-0.2484264373779297,
-0.07816259562969208,
0.1854734569787979,
-0.7665035128593445,
-0.07190220803022385,
-0.10134167969226837,
0.919668436050415,
-1.004193902015686,
0.5315275192260742,
0.5975516438484192,
-0.6500977277755737,
-0.2827615737915039,
-0.12377423048019409,
0.06341473758220673,
-0.4503724277019501,
0.2927539050579071,
0.03463970124721527,
0.21293587982654572,
-0.0940292477607727,
-0.39260944724082947,
-0.7657228708267212,
1.4099993705749512,
-0.041007015854120255,
-0.6464995741844177,
-0.2720527648925781,
0.4104556441307068,
0.6160529851913452,
-0.12021142989397049,
0.0029244648758322,
0.2655337154865265,
0.023829078301787376,
0.1874333769083023,
-0.4565272629261017,
-0.3727041184902191,
0.08723054081201553,
-0.07196991890668869,
-0.05832614749670029,
-1.0334582328796387,
0.941267728805542,
-0.24841974675655365,
-0.8118429183959961,
-0.04777897894382477,
1.0075552463531494,
0.0812034010887146,
0.6215687990188599,
0.4559134542942047,
0.5023306012153625,
0.7946842908859253,
-0.20186220109462738,
0.8945203423500061,
0.008304374292492867,
0.6548105478286743,
0.8713369965553284,
-0.4764174520969391,
0.7723090648651123,
0.20984691381454468,
-0.42879554629325867,
0.22052712738513947,
0.6818718314170837,
-0.22962291538715363,
0.647341251373291,
0.044822681695222855,
-0.6283359527587891,
0.13628605008125305,
0.3087872862815857,
-0.5306289196014404,
0.20829467475414276,
0.15612006187438965,
-0.5368058681488037,
-0.5278748273849487,
0.35966581106185913,
-0.24507761001586914,
0.07001369446516037,
0.022746354341506958,
1.2167694568634033,
0.0905468761920929,
-0.4117577373981476,
0.2264513522386551,
0.054059505462646484,
0.5151600241661072,
-0.5661516189575195,
0.39319756627082825,
-0.766053318977356,
0.1310071051120758,
-0.36669448018074036,
-0.34957218170166016,
0.3004498779773712,
0.2357615977525711,
-0.22015467286109924,
-0.5870473384857178,
0.3948863446712494,
-0.1354219764471054,
-0.2777843177318573,
0.39160650968551636,
0.5325559377670288,
-0.31869134306907654,
0.1880766600370407,
-0.6109941601753235,
0.16383549571037292,
-0.18914894759655,
-0.0907871350646019,
0.4774891138076782,
0.2591404616832733,
0.16205786168575287,
0.8389140963554382,
0.6151201725006104,
-0.055797334760427475,
0.20714804530143738,
0.10584134608507156,
0.8025695085525513,
-0.1262049823999405,
-0.6736000776290894,
-0.4140366315841675,
0.04370957240462303,
-0.17275470495224,
-0.27128762006759644,
0.7278341054916382,
0.35465753078460693,
1.091822624206543,
-0.2712468206882477,
0.708615243434906,
-0.14403289556503296,
0.28106385469436646,
-0.13560959696769714,
1.1437089443206787,
-0.5808796882629395,
-0.002421594923362136,
-0.040746476501226425,
-0.5572828054428101,
-0.1696850210428238,
0.4904223084449768,
-0.23996926844120026,
-0.13840532302856445,
0.25163209438323975,
0.5799574851989746,
-0.14001771807670593,
0.7210365533828735,
0.24586808681488037,
-0.11259667575359344,
0.628136932849884,
0.3671814501285553,
0.6331139206886292,
-0.45022550225257874,
-0.2401195466518402,
-0.8510698676109314,
-0.3066747784614563,
-0.4546137750148773,
-0.34347981214523315,
-0.6440836191177368,
-0.8191936016082764,
-0.3982812166213989,
0.2584001421928406,
0.15246276557445526,
0.5804547071456909,
0.8316203951835632,
-1.02690851688385,
-0.0074745179153978825,
-0.6983247995376587,
0.2804524004459381,
-0.6027700901031494,
-0.25861015915870667,
0.22471651434898376,
-0.3779495358467102,
-0.41076675057411194,
0.31982988119125366,
0.08971647173166275,
0.24149379134178162,
-0.7882387638092041,
0.21551309525966644,
-0.01271048840135336,
-0.21701084077358246,
0.4252920150756836,
0.3507708013057709,
-0.7250837087631226,
0.06600575894117355,
-0.1005924791097641,
-0.2753596007823944,
-0.27887454628944397,
0.8473256230354309,
-0.2787783741950989,
0.7638809084892273,
0.8133147954940796,
0.679679811000824,
0.1870546191930771,
0.30637842416763306,
0.6520131826400757,
-0.6443600058555603,
0.009611876681447029,
0.38216039538383484,
0.33000680804252625,
0.32713836431503296,
-0.5378403663635254,
0.5242595672607422,
0.3108817934989929,
-0.6123220324516296,
-1.2456426620483398,
0.2048846036195755,
-0.5703280568122864,
-0.18235884606838226,
0.5273125767707825,
-0.4611595571041107,
-0.07911040633916855,
0.3374364376068115,
0.7221723794937134,
-0.12818953394889832,
0.08374833315610886,
0.779962420463562,
0.5477561354637146,
-0.14823253452777863,
-0.28174057602882385,
-0.23415803909301758,
0.6620384454727173,
-0.01578281633555889,
-0.8190984725952148,
0.23519030213356018,
0.603105366230011,
0.288467139005661,
0.07195482403039932,
0.5320627093315125,
-0.17647188901901245,
0.3952297866344452,
0.20871613919734955,
-0.10613354295492172,
-0.13821221888065338,
-0.6728716492652893,
-0.6360905170440674,
0.6802340149879456,
-0.1878558248281479,
-0.06267102807760239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16681v1
|
Triple Preference Optimization: Achieving Better Alignment with Less Data in a Single Step Optimization
| 2024-05-26T20:18:11 | 2024-05-26T20:18:11 |
Amir Saeidi, Shivanshu Verma, Aswin RRV, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) perform well across diverse tasks, but aligning
them with human demonstrations is challenging. Recently, Reinforcement Learning
(RL)-free methods like Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) have emerged,
offering improved stability and scalability while retaining competitive
performance relative to RL-based methods. However, while RL-free methods
deliver satisfactory performance, they require significant data to develop a
robust Supervised Fine-Tuned (SFT) model and an additional step to fine-tune
this model on a preference dataset, which constrains their utility and
scalability. In this paper, we introduce Triple Preference Optimization (TPO),
a new preference learning method designed to align an LLM with three
preferences without requiring a separate SFT step and using considerably less
data. Through a combination of practical experiments and theoretical analysis,
we show the efficacy of TPO as a single-step alignment strategy. Specifically,
we fine-tuned the Phi-2 (2.7B) and Mistral (7B) models using TPO directly on
the UltraFeedback dataset, achieving superior results compared to models
aligned through other methods such as SFT, DPO, KTO, IPO, CPO, and ORPO.
Moreover, the performance of TPO without the SFT component led to notable
improvements in the MT-Bench score, with increases of +1.27 and +0.63 over SFT
and DPO, respectively. Additionally, TPO showed higher average accuracy,
surpassing DPO and SFT by 4.2% and 4.97% on the Open LLM Leaderboard
benchmarks. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/sahsaeedi/triple-preference-optimization .
|
[
-0.2390970140695572,
-0.43366146087646484,
0.5323854088783264,
0.16355106234550476,
-0.4019576609134674,
0.07904825359582901,
-0.34300974011421204,
-0.2141590714454651,
-0.053707871586084366,
0.596217691898346,
-0.6063416004180908,
-0.5656529664993286,
-0.44371891021728516,
-0.12188635021448135,
0.2769491374492645,
0.8136850595474243,
-0.29760730266571045,
-0.0038107053842395544,
0.12194052338600159,
-0.0437370166182518,
-0.4098820090293884,
-0.1715698093175888,
-0.71715247631073,
-0.547575056552887,
0.39293697476387024,
0.9717841744422913,
0.6123366355895996,
1.044446349143982,
0.23611414432525635,
0.1527668535709381,
0.07595549523830414,
0.4773019552230835,
-0.5668411254882812,
-0.0011837248457595706,
0.10683941841125488,
-0.1962803602218628,
-0.4752945899963379,
0.08423279225826263,
0.5026038885116577,
0.44515109062194824,
-0.12435317784547806,
0.02000078745186329,
0.23119133710861206,
1.118898868560791,
-0.6880122423171997,
0.13877616822719574,
-0.4693940281867981,
0.33391278982162476,
-0.121975377202034,
-0.3945031464099884,
-0.4177871346473694,
-0.8057664036750793,
0.2773265242576599,
-0.8808510899543762,
0.021272191777825356,
0.2266901135444641,
0.8595256209373474,
0.5263985991477966,
-0.4436330497264862,
0.26574957370758057,
-0.6255059242248535,
1.0700600147247314,
-0.5409033894538879,
0.2618536949157715,
0.2743154764175415,
0.19727760553359985,
-0.10668465495109558,
0.020344752818346024,
-0.44542357325553894,
-0.17097881436347961,
0.19588057696819305,
-0.03109610639512539,
0.023987317457795143,
0.21874235570430756,
-0.007400715257972479,
0.2568103075027466,
-0.41077089309692383,
0.4500371515750885,
-0.004950521048158407,
-0.0754828229546547,
0.4775547683238983,
-0.015471883118152618,
-0.06719257682561874,
-0.025904295966029167,
-0.5437749028205872,
-0.20330838859081268,
-0.5276445746421814,
0.15111282467842102,
0.4156501293182373,
0.6323193907737732,
-0.04564150795340538,
0.547848641872406,
-0.19196879863739014,
0.7846806049346924,
0.46685224771499634,
-0.43849727511405945,
0.3823530375957489,
-0.10499411076307297,
-0.0637977346777916,
0.10613333433866501,
0.957809567451477,
0.5917951464653015,
0.35425716638565063,
-0.027968350797891617,
-0.06231330335140228,
-0.1706930249929428,
0.13097207248210907,
-0.6331484913825989,
0.1046413853764534,
0.29976505041122437,
-0.30805104970932007,
-0.7447236776351929,
-0.09634722024202347,
-0.6943607330322266,
-0.38952893018722534,
-0.5086983442306519,
0.42130953073501587,
-0.42239153385162354,
-0.26251232624053955,
0.36988264322280884,
0.15988369286060333,
0.2843034565448761,
0.24802501499652863,
-1.4071763753890991,
0.3369767963886261,
0.9258138537406921,
0.8352776169776917,
-0.5835906267166138,
-0.41067326068878174,
-0.8313593864440918,
0.29408103227615356,
-0.5591777563095093,
0.5644954442977905,
-0.30144649744033813,
-0.18694084882736206,
-0.06622928380966187,
-0.36773669719696045,
-0.04163879528641701,
-0.3000296354293823,
0.6980853080749512,
-0.5326864123344421,
0.23984163999557495,
-0.0945897102355957,
-0.5017698407173157,
-0.10448183864355087,
0.2535611391067505,
-0.6397103667259216,
1.1073929071426392,
-0.10788930952548981,
-0.6118195652961731,
0.6315109133720398,
-0.754108726978302,
-0.33473455905914307,
-0.30859246850013733,
-0.15350401401519775,
-0.5482200980186462,
0.009508518502116203,
0.47899892926216125,
0.554747462272644,
-0.013894827105104923,
0.23049777746200562,
-0.738001823425293,
-0.5354874134063721,
-0.12630286812782288,
-0.08708523958921432,
0.5604720115661621,
-0.1688109040260315,
-0.44186004996299744,
0.3649151623249054,
-0.6988430023193359,
0.09105826914310455,
0.05252289026975632,
-0.3049663305282593,
-0.19170843064785004,
0.028744392096996307,
-0.3346378207206726,
0.28947949409484863,
0.2627943754196167,
-0.6612435579299927,
0.5401968955993652,
-0.6185035109519958,
0.28085601329803467,
1.1174861192703247,
-0.13609196245670319,
0.6021446585655212,
-0.30693066120147705,
0.35835084319114685,
-0.29860273003578186,
0.4045649766921997,
0.6666902899742126,
-0.21789896488189697,
-0.6680072546005249,
-0.18272310495376587,
0.1806088387966156,
0.4095754325389862,
-0.5159122943878174,
0.4818517565727234,
-0.4412406384944916,
-0.18689867854118347,
-0.5968440771102905,
0.22056250274181366,
0.4017079770565033,
0.8664286136627197,
0.4924818277359009,
0.24524658918380737,
-0.4416697919368744,
-1.1388263702392578,
-0.22181180119514465,
-0.08752918988466263,
-0.003416977124288678,
0.3217925727367401,
0.13921140134334564,
0.05362142249941826,
0.8651020526885986,
-0.7123281955718994,
-0.2709563076496124,
-0.09089453518390656,
-0.006686189211905003,
0.1328401267528534,
0.378689706325531,
0.36019623279571533,
-0.6505167484283447,
-0.6726331114768982,
0.22515027225017548,
-0.2830067574977875,
-0.049518924206495285,
0.31542226672172546,
-0.27164217829704285,
0.4881290793418884,
-0.03138207271695137,
-0.14729207754135132,
0.055265724658966064,
0.6335960030555725,
0.04998964071273804,
0.2742287516593933,
-0.11687032133340836,
0.15138034522533417,
-1.069510579109192,
-0.08309910446405411,
0.060539305210113525,
-0.12379613518714905,
-0.4950261116027832,
-0.2750209867954254,
0.42738741636276245,
-0.023732872679829597,
-0.49666115641593933,
0.6761962175369263,
-0.19544275104999542,
0.000023902568500488997,
-0.2788022458553314,
0.11383882164955139,
0.025706453248858452,
0.8564085364341736,
0.3685985803604126,
0.7358758449554443,
0.47439971566200256,
-0.7278304100036621,
0.031147805973887444,
0.2509792447090149,
-0.07677576690912247,
0.2568931579589844,
-0.3129905164241791,
0.36961114406585693,
0.14288358390331268,
0.01904829405248165,
-0.8263530135154724,
-0.26762625575065613,
0.3271898329257965,
-0.20786939561367035,
0.4367321729660034,
-0.293078750371933,
-0.34417930245399475,
-0.3026203513145447,
-0.7711511254310608,
0.34562548995018005,
0.2296498566865921,
-0.9621736407279968,
0.3900544047355652,
0.2010209858417511,
0.12097396701574326,
-1.08954656124115,
-0.37847664952278137,
-0.394686758518219,
-0.24677938222885132,
-0.5148749351501465,
0.5270889401435852,
-0.08298582583665848,
0.1718597412109375,
-0.4165593683719635,
-0.5274624228477478,
0.1270218938589096,
0.09420466423034668,
0.07922228425741196,
0.5615010857582092,
0.1170254796743393,
0.22619515657424927,
0.1272912323474884,
-0.45907172560691833,
-0.43004682660102844,
-0.5504529476165771,
0.49794480204582214,
-0.22831709682941437,
-0.07998641580343246,
-0.6818063855171204,
0.1554170548915863,
0.49016353487968445,
-0.0328267440199852,
0.43154793977737427,
0.45868247747421265,
-0.11308017373085022,
-0.1337060034275055,
-0.5757086277008057,
0.12836965918540955,
-0.4738180339336395,
-0.04167480394244194,
-0.4012290835380554,
-1.0578614473342896,
-0.1838557869195938,
0.12665997445583344,
0.2188534140586853,
0.22334378957748413,
0.32036346197128296,
0.08875840157270432,
1.251767873764038,
0.6810804605484009,
-0.2302488386631012,
0.6358890533447266,
0.05519471317529678,
0.15008527040481567,
-0.7953119874000549,
-0.1361505538225174,
-0.47828221321105957,
-0.2538289725780487,
-0.6879143714904785,
-0.20662760734558105,
0.3791799247264862,
0.11774464696645737,
-0.5951687693595886,
0.2286245971918106,
-0.5843563079833984,
0.555766761302948,
0.6457090377807617,
0.3524147570133209,
0.3973280191421509,
0.161581888794899,
-0.2978169918060303,
-0.09817351400852203,
-0.3907622992992401,
-0.6264961361885071,
1.3800058364868164,
0.23382054269313812,
0.642391562461853,
0.10216619074344635,
0.9669812917709351,
0.07633374631404877,
-0.007499205879867077,
-1.0627944469451904,
0.39069291949272156,
-0.26408806443214417,
-0.23191142082214355,
-0.35160768032073975,
-0.42891743779182434,
-0.6179634928703308,
0.2718351483345032,
-0.3220643997192383,
-0.790212869644165,
0.15145784616470337,
0.49055761098861694,
-0.7484433054924011,
0.2793106734752655,
-0.6912105083465576,
0.6793056726455688,
-0.48915842175483704,
-0.6925593018531799,
-0.12414898723363876,
-0.6070750951766968,
0.36473533511161804,
-0.1159990131855011,
-0.1335425227880478,
-0.3167485296726227,
-0.4637143611907959,
0.6747971773147583,
-0.20645587146282196,
0.40881654620170593,
-0.11226020753383636,
-0.10877488553524017,
-0.39252251386642456,
-0.0780293270945549,
0.5603540539741516,
-0.03813372179865837,
-0.39528658986091614,
-0.04788408800959587,
-0.14720650017261505,
-0.5397248864173889,
-0.5375946760177612,
0.8682755827903748,
-0.9935975670814514,
-0.6240023374557495,
-0.25367242097854614,
-0.3379320800304413,
-0.7226967811584473,
0.4654507040977478,
0.05907862260937691,
0.20295284688472748,
-0.1121562048792839,
0.11294298619031906,
0.7318816781044006,
0.06361200660467148,
0.4782625734806061,
0.556753933429718,
-0.24683231115341187,
-0.6491844058036804,
0.8149617314338684,
-0.33577921986579895,
0.3606218993663788,
0.7425395250320435,
0.6729964017868042,
-0.40018388628959656,
-0.6670156717300415,
-0.4288254380226135,
0.20537596940994263,
-0.2682958245277405,
-0.1400660276412964,
-0.6099112033843994,
0.35407283902168274,
-0.5019688606262207,
-0.30014827847480774,
-0.6050833463668823,
-0.5259057283401489,
-0.3814006745815277,
-0.13519719243049622,
0.11264519393444061,
0.4635775089263916,
-0.10570140928030014,
0.24419717490673065,
-0.4874165654182434,
0.5588154196739197,
0.5189806222915649,
0.6660366058349609,
-0.22295227646827698,
-0.2435425966978073,
-0.0635245069861412,
-0.06947051733732224,
-0.41861897706985474,
-0.5864821076393127,
0.24838314950466156,
-0.05311122164130211,
0.2883138954639435,
0.7265326976776123,
-0.003907774109393358,
0.758537769317627,
-0.33314013481140137,
0.5142754316329956,
0.13771440088748932,
-0.9981027245521545,
0.7695888876914978,
-0.4760185778141022,
0.05097318813204765,
0.9396187663078308,
0.4235541522502899,
-0.1705782264471054,
0.23659701645374298,
-0.3973155915737152,
-0.5333163142204285,
1.0659496784210205,
-0.07547256350517273,
-0.2112971544265747,
0.2351042628288269,
0.30740049481391907,
0.28377223014831543,
0.26472967863082886,
-0.7446097731590271,
-0.2847317159175873,
-0.09926305711269379,
-0.025694971904158592,
-0.03354407101869583,
-0.2454468458890915,
-0.22783876955509186,
-0.2205321192741394,
1.1141709089279175,
-0.40917980670928955,
-0.1631847620010376,
-0.204023078083992,
0.22500571608543396,
-0.3670734167098999,
0.3005567789077759,
0.6154481768608093,
0.36610448360443115,
-0.6463439464569092,
-0.3454543650150299,
-0.22161057591438293,
-0.12911157310009003,
0.31667500734329224,
0.24105660617351532,
-0.15894880890846252,
-0.4686806797981262,
-0.07075128704309464,
1.009405493736267,
0.26491034030914307,
-0.20233723521232605,
0.6434550285339355,
-0.11913302540779114,
-0.43436309695243835,
0.006955693010240793,
0.16560161113739014,
-0.16020330786705017,
0.14891989529132843,
0.20188090205192566,
0.23292310535907745,
-0.009752198122441769,
-0.11798243224620819,
-0.11280364543199539,
0.4516766369342804,
-0.4726095497608185,
0.06883669644594193,
0.4317514896392822,
0.2685015797615051,
-0.16383536159992218,
0.34431737661361694,
0.10929214954376221,
-0.36719900369644165,
0.20461085438728333,
0.5259205102920532,
0.960252583026886,
-0.1123809739947319,
0.3712965250015259,
0.3880182206630707,
0.1098499447107315,
-0.4292450249195099,
0.08170711249113083,
-0.2954363524913788,
-1.056865930557251,
-0.27180415391921997,
-0.5333318114280701,
-0.6036348938941956,
0.12701894342899323,
-0.8424592018127441,
0.511873722076416,
-0.5651099681854248,
0.018982291221618652,
-0.046682726591825485,
0.4685060977935791,
-0.43707194924354553,
-0.10562495142221451,
0.16824927926063538,
0.6031742095947266,
-0.7328570485115051,
0.9381095170974731,
0.5973409414291382,
-0.11948049068450928,
-0.9583808779716492,
0.26127928495407104,
0.23922330141067505,
-0.9720938801765442,
0.2569710612297058,
0.2463560700416565,
-0.49827975034713745,
0.11269248276948929,
-0.4452502131462097,
-1.0073554515838623,
1.0677698850631714,
0.526276707649231,
-0.559194803237915,
-0.058877136558294296,
-0.0940454825758934,
0.3356728255748749,
-0.4474155306816101,
-0.0013653533533215523,
0.7202602028846741,
0.5264692902565002,
0.050786618143320084,
-0.772259533405304,
-0.010027033276855946,
0.0448513925075531,
0.10925444960594177,
0.4702484905719757,
-0.9833599328994751,
0.36436811089515686,
-0.3099730312824249,
-0.0681576281785965,
-0.08263853192329407,
0.46542325615882874,
0.6152486801147461,
-0.023160124197602272,
0.5963037610054016,
0.5669345855712891,
0.8484281897544861,
0.002485583769157529,
0.9461543560028076,
-0.1887776255607605,
0.4051918685436249,
1.2395734786987305,
-0.3862789571285248,
0.825931191444397,
0.7934834361076355,
-0.004280520603060722,
0.30598050355911255,
0.812350332736969,
0.1782788783311844,
0.6208478212356567,
-0.0014106486923992634,
-0.14019525051116943,
-0.4999251365661621,
-0.07194653898477554,
-0.23602810502052307,
0.4365287721157074,
0.06489022821187973,
-0.13288605213165283,
0.055989090353250504,
-0.12169509381055832,
0.08919194340705872,
0.0995015949010849,
-0.14134438335895538,
0.8004100322723389,
-0.28228622674942017,
-0.8907468318939209,
0.7121499180793762,
-0.18966144323349,
0.7529721856117249,
-0.5526905059814453,
0.041336432099342346,
-0.2693822383880615,
0.2568025588989258,
-0.25345921516418457,
-0.573469340801239,
-0.18043318390846252,
-0.13778257369995117,
-0.22615459561347961,
-0.4283314049243927,
0.35346394777297974,
-0.35877469182014465,
-0.22730326652526855,
0.35993173718452454,
0.14577867090702057,
-0.31474748253822327,
0.08816884458065033,
-0.6432084441184998,
0.07927918434143066,
0.3385389745235443,
-0.32372185587882996,
0.23969951272010803,
-0.002413076814264059,
0.06203792616724968,
0.7432294487953186,
0.43651634454727173,
0.07028521597385406,
-0.37067466974258423,
0.13111159205436707,
0.6306621432304382,
-0.5667660236358643,
-0.4384405314922333,
-0.8723067045211792,
0.21012263000011444,
-0.170357808470726,
-0.4008534848690033,
0.4309195280075073,
0.6891303062438965,
0.8538153767585754,
0.04882782697677612,
0.7397372126579285,
0.3025020956993103,
0.7009572982788086,
-0.6659514307975769,
0.16414286196231842,
-0.7779355645179749,
0.29234468936920166,
-0.42199233174324036,
-0.888152003288269,
-0.4766866862773895,
0.3537571430206299,
-0.49402299523353577,
-0.1857832819223404,
0.7087532877922058,
0.8074551820755005,
-0.17702186107635498,
0.1698034703731537,
0.2144552320241928,
-0.18836979568004608,
0.16658015549182892,
0.7032938599586487,
0.528963029384613,
-0.2759074866771698,
0.655109703540802,
-0.5984779000282288,
-0.42215871810913086,
-0.2505606412887573,
-1.0335105657577515,
-0.7418727874755859,
-0.2802622616291046,
-0.2503299117088318,
-0.24002905189990997,
0.05894127115607262,
1.3330793380737305,
0.7314307689666748,
-0.7339726686477661,
-0.2847810685634613,
-0.05161496251821518,
0.2505672574043274,
-0.37426722049713135,
-0.21983563899993896,
0.4871212840080261,
-0.301595538854599,
-0.84787917137146,
0.5425677299499512,
0.38715630769729614,
0.09940238296985626,
0.12897925078868866,
-0.22714881598949432,
-0.18532273173332214,
-0.2186345010995865,
0.4781873822212219,
0.3328811824321747,
-0.8949388265609741,
-0.44893914461135864,
-0.04720156639814377,
-0.12558473646640778,
0.3492298126220703,
0.6581621170043945,
-0.5088715553283691,
0.5296355485916138,
0.35797378420829773,
0.6574428081512451,
0.6705269813537598,
0.2617732286453247,
0.8146109580993652,
-0.6589854955673218,
-0.1658393144607544,
0.20048591494560242,
0.20377393066883087,
0.2496286928653717,
-0.4089277684688568,
0.531147301197052,
-0.04768635705113411,
-0.5603161454200745,
-0.5242729187011719,
0.27733612060546875,
-1.2056598663330078,
-0.06347839534282684,
1.2020260095596313,
0.3285735845565796,
0.000870955060236156,
0.0835677906870842,
-0.21777048707008362,
0.3723035156726837,
-0.8898156881332397,
0.7516873478889465,
0.5450370907783508,
-0.5448252558708191,
-0.08007989078760147,
-0.3776113986968994,
0.792479395866394,
0.6529858112335205,
-0.5424963235855103,
0.10099995136260986,
0.613304615020752,
0.3333775997161865,
-0.1825043112039566,
0.7625484466552734,
-0.1186874583363533,
0.184900164604187,
-0.6077351570129395,
0.14365990459918976,
-0.2638755142688751,
-0.2850087583065033,
-0.6196447610855103,
0.32470789551734924,
0.1668395847082138,
-0.5307378172874451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16677v1
|
Crossmodal ASR Error Correction with Discrete Speech Units
| 2024-05-26T19:58:38 | 2024-05-26T19:58:38 |
Yuanchao Li, Pinzhen Chen, Peter Bell, Catherine Lai
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
ASR remains unsatisfactory in scenarios where the speaking style diverges
from that used to train ASR systems, resulting in erroneous transcripts. To
address this, ASR Error Correction (AEC), a post-ASR processing approach, is
required. In this work, we tackle an understudied issue: the Low-Resource
Out-of-Domain (LROOD) problem, by investigating crossmodal AEC on very limited
downstream data with 1-best hypothesis transcription. We explore pre-training
and fine-tuning strategies and uncover an ASR domain discrepancy phenomenon,
shedding light on appropriate training schemes for LROOD data. Moreover, we
propose the incorporation of discrete speech units to align with and enhance
the word embeddings for improving AEC quality. Results from multiple corpora
and several evaluation metrics demonstrate the feasibility and efficacy of our
proposed AEC approach on LROOD data, as well as its generalizability and
superiority on large-scale data. Finally, a study on speech emotion recognition
confirms that our model produces ASR error-robust transcripts suitable for
downstream applications.
|
[
-0.37022310495376587,
-0.6062000393867493,
0.19328416883945465,
-0.09821194410324097,
-0.18417085707187653,
0.3914204239845276,
-0.3170160949230194,
-0.4092846214771271,
0.3071821630001068,
0.22020824253559113,
-0.5647834539413452,
-0.4179196357727051,
-0.6949387192726135,
0.1479080617427826,
-0.2691437602043152,
0.6829612255096436,
-0.27481070160865784,
0.24577119946479797,
-0.4423583447933197,
-0.6256652474403381,
-0.40630000829696655,
-0.5279212594032288,
-0.7327539324760437,
-0.25540727376937866,
0.43720921874046326,
0.6991907358169556,
0.47056010365486145,
0.3333779275417328,
0.2897072434425354,
0.24816904962062836,
0.16484111547470093,
0.4435655176639557,
-0.4749968945980072,
-0.08114580810070038,
-0.19688083231449127,
-0.25444069504737854,
-0.7133711576461792,
-0.20462940633296967,
0.7627449035644531,
0.6562213897705078,
-0.36276084184646606,
0.0011085054138675332,
0.09701911360025406,
0.47849202156066895,
-0.658660352230072,
0.06628509610891342,
-0.5265535712242126,
-0.03811950609087944,
-0.42340558767318726,
-0.31131884455680847,
-0.25919488072395325,
-0.18224087357521057,
-0.11017368733882904,
-0.42011070251464844,
0.30403411388397217,
0.1253288984298706,
0.38597503304481506,
0.6587037444114685,
-0.19382025301456451,
-0.4110496938228607,
-1.0082135200500488,
0.7254820466041565,
-0.6966910362243652,
0.7686845064163208,
0.697235107421875,
-0.015451543033123016,
0.15524184703826904,
-0.6295480728149414,
-0.6472232341766357,
0.2133052945137024,
0.08867008239030838,
0.11818965524435043,
-0.6985001564025879,
0.19041277468204498,
0.22156016528606415,
0.14168483018875122,
-0.3900119364261627,
0.25658759474754333,
-0.3760526478290558,
-0.18433286249637604,
0.6019593477249146,
0.024208547547459602,
0.15645955502986908,
0.1399480700492859,
-0.11740738898515701,
-0.2523793578147888,
-0.7402116656303406,
0.2582831382751465,
0.3491189479827881,
0.30632540583610535,
-0.13443294167518616,
0.530096173286438,
-0.13418184220790863,
0.1827089935541153,
0.20342552661895752,
0.0605616457760334,
0.21413575112819672,
-0.14802320301532745,
-0.0527413971722126,
0.6561538577079773,
0.596670925617218,
0.0846889391541481,
0.03423894941806793,
0.048634421080350876,
-0.3744443655014038,
0.3206453025341034,
0.49269458651542664,
-0.5483667254447937,
-0.04169560968875885,
0.31813520193099976,
-0.248758926987648,
0.23621350526809692,
-0.11514744907617569,
-0.6233824491500854,
-0.14514608681201935,
-0.2512202560901642,
0.5420929789543152,
-0.47777509689331055,
-0.014208975248038769,
-0.13436409831047058,
0.30829501152038574,
-0.14229588210582733,
0.2640630304813385,
-0.8275777101516724,
0.44197794795036316,
0.2755238711833954,
0.6964468955993652,
-0.09896785020828247,
-0.12668536603450775,
-0.8593744039535522,
-0.012441433034837246,
-0.4013608992099762,
0.8531356453895569,
-0.6128479242324829,
-0.6936058402061462,
-0.09621359407901764,
-0.21952800452709198,
-0.12518328428268433,
-0.5809009075164795,
0.5246772170066833,
-0.40046027302742004,
-0.056410420686006546,
-0.16002260148525238,
-0.47053441405296326,
0.058188825845718384,
-0.28267812728881836,
-0.5596276521682739,
0.7970003485679626,
0.0808849036693573,
-0.7016698718070984,
0.16210053861141205,
-0.6314124464988708,
-0.53095543384552,
-0.08134957402944565,
-0.49102842807769775,
-0.30681103467941284,
0.2925594449043274,
0.32519611716270447,
0.070732481777668,
-0.34190037846565247,
0.008253520354628563,
-0.045857418328523636,
-0.20352043211460114,
0.3519909679889679,
-0.4145326316356659,
0.23408357799053192,
0.25746503472328186,
-0.3639371991157532,
0.3247058689594269,
-0.9161214232444763,
0.21111105382442474,
-0.2929043769836426,
-0.18331561982631683,
-0.4605480432510376,
0.1203942596912384,
-0.11325650662183762,
-0.001609194092452526,
-0.13686375319957733,
-0.6718109250068665,
-0.12481629103422165,
-0.004116419702768326,
0.5625624060630798,
0.6099995374679565,
-0.268255352973938,
0.5495941638946533,
-0.18613137304782867,
0.6517829298973083,
-0.06430817395448685,
0.05095040798187256,
0.18465955555438995,
-0.28058719635009766,
-0.6408674716949463,
-0.32441118359565735,
0.3416518568992615,
0.4539014995098114,
-1.0584815740585327,
0.23503342270851135,
-0.30513516068458557,
-0.3164277672767639,
-0.9037869572639465,
0.036959774792194366,
0.5108005404472351,
0.44463643431663513,
0.703008770942688,
-0.7188014984130859,
-0.6548713445663452,
-0.5143243670463562,
-0.07542373985052109,
-0.08964376896619797,
-0.002165106125175953,
0.41940516233444214,
0.23885400593280792,
-0.7489149570465088,
1.0857003927230835,
-0.05433327332139015,
-0.5020555257797241,
-0.2667815685272217,
0.4472189247608185,
-0.13314566016197205,
0.5050543546676636,
-0.07362259924411774,
-0.5194427967071533,
-0.15794655680656433,
0.05436382070183754,
-0.38813918828964233,
-0.27216413617134094,
-0.02938375622034073,
0.09304166585206985,
0.4037286937236786,
0.731660783290863,
-0.5357845425605774,
0.5444227457046509,
0.7497793436050415,
-0.12036636471748352,
0.1081962063908577,
-0.35646626353263855,
0.23184369504451752,
-0.6410258412361145,
-0.03999852389097214,
-0.26304712891578674,
-0.08618056029081345,
-0.7089911103248596,
-0.5595666170120239,
0.03521397337317467,
-0.045437637716531754,
-0.37452688813209534,
0.29672229290008545,
-0.4138438403606415,
-0.26030874252319336,
-0.29106056690216064,
-0.023331601172685623,
-0.09166828542947769,
0.3178955316543579,
0.15063758194446564,
0.6754591464996338,
0.284018874168396,
-0.35820120573043823,
0.33004799485206604,
0.476046085357666,
-0.18850257992744446,
0.5507094860076904,
-0.5598996877670288,
0.46438202261924744,
-0.3427373468875885,
0.5213903188705444,
-0.9131223559379578,
-0.34657734632492065,
0.1554388701915741,
-0.47741565108299255,
0.44327861070632935,
-0.07240582257509232,
-0.15430691838264465,
0.061426710337400436,
-0.10294388234615326,
0.9480471014976501,
0.6087422370910645,
-0.45594608783721924,
0.8462803363800049,
0.4555688798427582,
-0.420919269323349,
-0.5776274800300598,
-0.7238530516624451,
-0.27893882989883423,
0.06855128705501556,
-0.5295898914337158,
0.5529524683952332,
0.1017458438873291,
-0.1805618554353714,
0.01904071867465973,
-0.3042709529399872,
0.07217466831207275,
-0.5733094811439514,
0.45387202501296997,
-0.028668075799942017,
-0.2142154574394226,
-0.015739938244223595,
0.06007255241274834,
0.04476083070039749,
0.027174251154065132,
0.01705128140747547,
0.6072501540184021,
-0.009196261875331402,
-0.5977465510368347,
-0.45474040508270264,
0.48094233870506287,
0.5953854918479919,
-0.3024529218673706,
0.25461727380752563,
0.4924236834049225,
-0.5547135472297668,
-0.32300302386283875,
-0.4188847839832306,
-0.11440081149339676,
-0.43345803022384644,
0.266973614692688,
-0.10077697038650513,
-0.692253828048706,
0.5750373005867004,
0.05980526655912399,
-0.4118695557117462,
0.32980790734291077,
0.2547892928123474,
-0.15687823295593262,
0.7467865943908691,
0.5989810228347778,
0.08471762388944626,
0.5240951776504517,
-0.35119831562042236,
0.2610098123550415,
-0.8021647334098816,
-0.2740333676338196,
-0.47035273909568787,
-0.4044889211654663,
-0.5342572331428528,
-0.7363293170928955,
0.46424734592437744,
0.014039053581655025,
-0.12385399639606476,
0.15278267860412598,
0.09551096707582474,
0.23092293739318848,
0.595608651638031,
0.20947229862213135,
0.26113030314445496,
0.1838177740573883,
0.11766193062067032,
-0.1851835697889328,
-1.0180857181549072,
-0.14593595266342163,
0.668795645236969,
0.45317885279655457,
1.126253366470337,
-0.024517985060811043,
0.6567631363868713,
0.3238163888454437,
0.24563148617744446,
-0.7123205065727234,
0.18783071637153625,
-0.47627919912338257,
-0.2891842722892761,
-0.4889923632144928,
-0.5470568537712097,
-0.5670208930969238,
-0.07335521280765533,
-0.2206200659275055,
-0.4196217656135559,
0.7587221264839172,
0.34040340781211853,
-0.8803004026412964,
0.28414294123649597,
-0.5111033916473389,
0.8327252864837646,
-0.4476708471775055,
-0.3882227838039398,
-0.44330263137817383,
-0.7146613597869873,
-0.10415562987327576,
-0.21219059824943542,
0.3988644778728485,
-0.04817655310034752,
0.08939622342586517,
0.728797972202301,
-0.5117690563201904,
0.8526883125305176,
-0.17335668206214905,
-0.1269882619380951,
0.42283475399017334,
-0.12840381264686584,
0.5641515254974365,
-0.145629420876503,
0.19110658764839172,
0.45246195793151855,
-0.22732007503509521,
-0.21004024147987366,
-0.5030163526535034,
0.3649621903896332,
-0.9815042614936829,
0.00190576515160501,
-0.3983515501022339,
-0.430499792098999,
-0.5408112406730652,
-0.22635000944137573,
0.6940074563026428,
0.8047194480895996,
-0.300689160823822,
0.24633651971817017,
0.7435657382011414,
-0.4529222548007965,
0.38385656476020813,
0.41212138533592224,
0.18369317054748535,
-0.5939188003540039,
0.9067543148994446,
0.3930082321166992,
0.33132651448249817,
0.28683027625083923,
0.00835021585226059,
-0.5432931780815125,
-0.5017004609107971,
-0.453170508146286,
0.1252177208662033,
-0.7108006477355957,
-0.3634350597858429,
-0.560782253742218,
-0.22238817811012268,
-0.46491867303848267,
-0.12738199532032013,
-0.8683263659477234,
-0.09313748776912689,
-0.4217820167541504,
0.1149725466966629,
0.48184463381767273,
0.5156498551368713,
-0.35915109515190125,
0.5047074556350708,
-0.9791825413703918,
0.4425959885120392,
0.20353281497955322,
0.34446391463279724,
-0.25396135449409485,
-0.8641180992126465,
-0.18499769270420074,
0.3225683569908142,
0.11712443828582764,
-0.35759761929512024,
0.5865944027900696,
0.6255968809127808,
0.3147509694099426,
0.364729106426239,
0.25252845883369446,
0.9118202328681946,
-0.6660112142562866,
0.4494977593421936,
0.34353289008140564,
-1.2329723834991455,
0.6145792603492737,
-0.05066036805510521,
0.24525603652000427,
0.5768106579780579,
0.5629212260246277,
-0.6685283780097961,
-0.041538089513778687,
-0.6519852876663208,
-1.2254831790924072,
0.6612642407417297,
0.1687573790550232,
-0.15310576558113098,
0.1278352588415146,
-0.06072673946619034,
0.13758940994739532,
0.1951211392879486,
-0.14339235424995422,
0.0029103790875524282,
-0.33651742339134216,
-0.27851200103759766,
-0.42599084973335266,
-0.17385193705558777,
-0.3235061466693878,
-0.1458536684513092,
0.644736647605896,
-0.16269010305404663,
0.2750312089920044,
0.40702420473098755,
-0.2051015943288803,
-0.6755503416061401,
0.38221803307533264,
0.6778934597969055,
0.6313937306404114,
-0.16416822373867035,
0.21401411294937134,
0.34537574648857117,
-0.5316059589385986,
0.12906493246555328,
0.16964636743068695,
0.2257155179977417,
0.06871204078197479,
0.47040513157844543,
0.9463307857513428,
0.28971534967422485,
-0.8193579316139221,
0.48129183053970337,
-0.18212859332561493,
0.17511989176273346,
-0.32662433385849,
-0.2578878104686737,
-0.2684714198112488,
0.45112016797065735,
0.44694042205810547,
0.3648760914802551,
-0.029889339581131935,
-0.6697837710380554,
0.2873002886772156,
0.3066725730895996,
-0.32302552461624146,
-0.37578752636909485,
0.7711696028709412,
0.43212229013442993,
-0.22687652707099915,
0.5850310325622559,
0.07640300691127777,
-0.34158405661582947,
0.26865509152412415,
0.36448562145233154,
0.815017819404602,
-0.462885320186615,
0.08385877311229706,
-0.07269427925348282,
0.16413339972496033,
-0.2265346646308899,
0.32018789649009705,
-0.028904318809509277,
-0.9913788437843323,
-0.5024610161781311,
-0.565329372882843,
-0.6959612965583801,
-0.08962669968605042,
-0.7875983119010925,
0.08630948513746262,
-0.5509961843490601,
-0.2543455958366394,
-0.18441519141197205,
-0.39407879114151,
-0.6165645718574524,
0.3309459984302521,
0.3584040701389313,
0.44784849882125854,
-0.7216116189956665,
1.1257623434066772,
0.6807284355163574,
-0.2952061593532562,
-0.9057022929191589,
-0.09166158735752106,
0.027227837592363358,
-0.6832408905029297,
0.6122534871101379,
-0.17862410843372345,
-0.6404093503952026,
0.05207972601056099,
-0.3058578670024872,
-0.924258828163147,
0.9733737111091614,
0.2408832609653473,
-1.0160932540893555,
0.1794598549604416,
0.35578933358192444,
0.62795490026474,
-0.45823994278907776,
0.005807167384773493,
0.6095749139785767,
0.0860426053404808,
0.07565698772668839,
-1.106277346611023,
-0.12365846335887909,
-0.11718413978815079,
-0.039671435952186584,
0.03310638293623924,
-0.5360565185546875,
0.8066964149475098,
-0.1970597505569458,
-0.24508969485759735,
-0.321056991815567,
0.771712601184845,
0.1059393659234047,
0.6780533790588379,
0.6014384031295776,
0.5612843036651611,
0.7919341921806335,
0.011164091527462006,
0.8195745348930359,
-0.05148352310061455,
0.14977996051311493,
1.1436117887496948,
-0.4615626335144043,
1.1367253065109253,
0.6650593280792236,
-0.20380106568336487,
0.2072824090719223,
0.4880879521369934,
0.493653804063797,
0.7008585929870605,
-0.03713282197713852,
-0.4217412769794464,
-0.07875718921422958,
-0.2308749109506607,
-0.3487062454223633,
0.6734411716461182,
0.40960025787353516,
-0.09200357645750046,
0.12315990030765533,
0.3030148148536682,
-0.2694436013698578,
-0.00243968702852726,
-0.6829742193222046,
0.5298138856887817,
0.23341986536979675,
-0.21508163213729858,
0.6164836287498474,
-0.1438816636800766,
0.8611860275268555,
-0.5739759802818298,
-0.0001452398719266057,
-0.6022210121154785,
0.4259948432445526,
-0.4213651418685913,
-0.259767085313797,
0.40844064950942993,
0.2102462649345398,
-0.16013996303081512,
-0.4181564152240753,
0.6878922581672668,
-0.8835561871528625,
-0.19262854754924774,
0.34054288268089294,
0.48974624276161194,
0.025232654064893723,
-0.19673237204551697,
-0.12820199131965637,
0.478420615196228,
-0.01931309513747692,
0.2472718209028244,
0.2158936858177185,
0.46018320322036743,
-0.17705237865447998,
0.4059751033782959,
0.45077475905418396,
0.14219534397125244,
0.11023224890232086,
0.2589684724807739,
0.6983001828193665,
-0.5243937969207764,
-0.47657421231269836,
-0.5767317414283752,
0.5709569454193115,
0.2706742286682129,
-0.37209221720695496,
0.47000786662101746,
0.27068251371383667,
1.2039915323257446,
-0.12047230452299118,
0.779000461101532,
-0.08309668302536011,
0.5304867625236511,
-0.6259186267852783,
0.5778194665908813,
-0.4650464355945587,
0.2862459123134613,
-0.20445115864276886,
-0.7483640313148499,
-0.11139517277479172,
0.7441467642784119,
-0.1887487769126892,
-0.06942136585712433,
0.6988459825515747,
0.7446079850196838,
-0.15906378626823425,
0.1885536015033722,
0.3804073631763458,
0.25771674513816833,
0.06816518306732178,
0.327217698097229,
0.9092068076133728,
-0.573843777179718,
0.43317747116088867,
-0.23965057730674744,
-0.15392370522022247,
-0.272701621055603,
-0.4914001226425171,
-0.4191502630710602,
-0.4989274740219116,
-0.5263777375221252,
-0.3935369551181793,
0.23858574032783508,
1.281495451927185,
0.5069050788879395,
-1.0114654302597046,
-0.27606523036956787,
0.10146071761846542,
-0.17839942872524261,
-0.09444625675678253,
-0.08471570909023285,
0.11731845885515213,
-0.0518665537238121,
-0.6120380163192749,
0.7162209153175354,
0.0573994405567646,
0.08946377784013748,
0.09224992990493774,
-0.342451274394989,
0.1045984998345375,
0.1189119964838028,
0.661072313785553,
0.4818936288356781,
-0.5604754686355591,
-0.4518696367740631,
-0.14574719965457916,
0.00852866843342781,
0.21194849908351898,
1.2800060510635376,
-0.49883222579956055,
0.3091113269329071,
0.3024730384349823,
0.7437723278999329,
0.4842446446418762,
0.2186816781759262,
0.5715514421463013,
-1.0480834245681763,
-0.01886732317507267,
0.4905616343021393,
0.35035228729248047,
0.44331857562065125,
-0.18937641382217407,
0.32953834533691406,
0.1870032101869583,
-0.5696455240249634,
-0.8151445388793945,
0.08760534226894379,
-1.0907292366027832,
-0.07656262069940567,
1.0874743461608887,
-0.035042837262153625,
-0.0973481833934784,
-0.00043685862328857183,
-0.20990879833698273,
0.44323790073394775,
-0.5259220004081726,
0.593112587928772,
0.495501309633255,
-0.6367689967155457,
-0.26897647976875305,
-0.3984217047691345,
0.7343372106552124,
0.3942009508609772,
-0.8407784700393677,
0.22645393013954163,
0.6640653610229492,
0.1346879005432129,
0.18331710994243622,
0.7822853326797485,
0.009702450595796108,
0.2116081267595291,
0.3057859241962433,
0.3625125586986542,
0.2660554349422455,
-0.4285443425178528,
-0.65059894323349,
-0.09611503779888153,
0.0589229054749012,
-0.35061851143836975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16669v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16669v1
|
Low-resourced Languages and Online Knowledge Repositories: A Need-Finding Study
| 2024-05-26T19:20:26 | 2024-05-26T19:20:26 |
Hellina Hailu Nigatu, John Canny, Sarah E. Chasins
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Online Knowledge Repositories (OKRs) like Wikipedia offer communities a way
to share and preserve information about themselves and their ways of living.
However, for communities with low-resourced languages -- including most African
communities -- the quality and volume of content available are often
inadequate. One reason for this lack of adequate content could be that many
OKRs embody Western ways of knowledge preservation and sharing, requiring many
low-resourced language communities to adapt to new interactions. To understand
the challenges faced by low-resourced language contributors on the popular OKR
Wikipedia, we conducted (1) a thematic analysis of Wikipedia forum discussions
and (2) a contextual inquiry study with 14 novice contributors. We focused on
three Ethiopian languages: Afan Oromo, Amharic, and Tigrinya. Our analysis
revealed several recurring themes; for example, contributors struggle to find
resources to corroborate their articles in low-resourced languages, and
language technology support, like translation systems and spellcheck, result in
several errors that waste contributors' time. We hope our study will support
designers in making online knowledge repositories accessible to low-resourced
language speakers.
|
[
-0.9551977515220642,
-0.6598615646362305,
0.3812488615512848,
-0.05967298150062561,
-0.036350857466459274,
-0.09862426668405533,
-0.35429561138153076,
-0.689469575881958,
0.503374457359314,
0.4075179994106293,
-0.4377424418926239,
0.023120936006307602,
-0.6786358952522278,
0.34335654973983765,
-0.23631680011749268,
1.0617690086364746,
-0.47551241517066956,
-0.28182581067085266,
-0.16658605635166168,
-0.7998963594436646,
-0.4712216556072235,
-0.30825328826904297,
-0.8546358346939087,
-0.02296162210404873,
0.8279274106025696,
0.8406370282173157,
0.6339024901390076,
0.4257183372974396,
0.3106684684753418,
0.2315290868282318,
-0.2898658514022827,
0.11811474710702896,
-0.4549316167831421,
0.1537320464849472,
-0.2592524588108063,
-0.17722868919372559,
0.034467119723558426,
-0.4566727578639984,
0.062141645699739456,
1.0399330854415894,
-0.2818971574306488,
0.5485543012619019,
0.2356286644935608,
0.8265500664710999,
-0.953909158706665,
0.06123761832714081,
-0.22290171682834625,
-0.19737988710403442,
-0.5988979339599609,
0.25109565258026123,
0.1798124760389328,
-0.49096134305000305,
0.13235944509506226,
-0.6672253608703613,
0.3395727276802063,
-0.17292065918445587,
0.4950714707374573,
0.15318036079406738,
-0.3690374195575714,
-0.6985280513763428,
-0.6152219176292419,
0.48458632826805115,
-0.4419591426849365,
0.35678938031196594,
0.5849030017852783,
0.05410384386777878,
-0.004066378343850374,
-0.5435629487037659,
-0.8145127892494202,
0.21737846732139587,
-0.2881878912448883,
-0.4061286449432373,
-0.058144740760326385,
-0.2728153467178345,
0.24565519392490387,
0.4755464494228363,
0.01726439595222473,
-0.058898378163576126,
-0.3713368773460388,
-0.32736000418663025,
0.24101218581199646,
-0.05318466201424599,
0.576381504535675,
-0.3830179274082184,
0.17812427878379822,
0.1109243631362915,
-0.6581802368164062,
0.17064112424850464,
0.30593976378440857,
0.27969488501548767,
-0.1703132688999176,
0.5388418436050415,
-0.3404066264629364,
0.692040741443634,
-0.1317630112171173,
-0.13733720779418945,
0.08455009013414383,
-0.32332858443260193,
0.45196643471717834,
-0.06026368588209152,
0.5505088567733765,
-0.07260150462388992,
0.14789265394210815,
-0.011404674500226974,
-0.2461732178926468,
-0.44714418053627014,
0.16926848888397217,
-0.6012000441551208,
-0.2244880348443985,
-0.05199557915329933,
-0.70960932970047,
0.1495218575000763,
-0.11622887849807739,
-0.7586524486541748,
-0.5357252359390259,
0.08698559552431107,
0.3981172740459442,
-0.4346267879009247,
-0.15443237125873566,
-0.6029593348503113,
-0.2701680064201355,
-0.05182361602783203,
0.5849777460098267,
-1.2155064344406128,
0.466046541929245,
0.253005713224411,
1.0712366104125977,
0.03630194440484047,
-0.2396247684955597,
0.05031643435359001,
0.08183472603559494,
-0.09949202835559845,
0.5284289717674255,
-0.088935486972332,
-0.40509554743766785,
0.23335906863212585,
-0.11731812357902527,
0.31331050395965576,
-0.329468697309494,
0.7099931240081787,
-0.6812356114387512,
-0.22219139337539673,
-1.0616528987884521,
-0.2954781949520111,
-0.07972265779972076,
0.262470543384552,
-0.907435417175293,
0.7142258286476135,
0.5205250382423401,
-0.8883737325668335,
0.22277338802814484,
-0.6666938662528992,
-0.6697230935096741,
0.12142354995012283,
-0.1967773139476776,
0.2320874035358429,
0.504756510257721,
0.13321161270141602,
-0.01738840900361538,
-0.48789721727371216,
-0.4013745188713074,
0.015515606850385666,
-0.05951879173517227,
0.3203175365924835,
-0.20895357429981232,
1.0249494314193726,
0.4381077289581299,
-0.49696674942970276,
-0.645506739616394,
-0.7461102604866028,
-0.24152132868766785,
0.1616453230381012,
-0.4244590103626251,
-0.6471725702285767,
0.28357231616973877,
0.16405513882637024,
0.19474345445632935,
0.39214664697647095,
-0.5778014063835144,
0.09156110882759094,
-0.2955988347530365,
0.3842448592185974,
0.6177303791046143,
0.12526462972164154,
0.337537944316864,
-0.30281612277030945,
0.2132321447134018,
0.012011012062430382,
0.09483182430267334,
-0.020924851298332214,
-0.5227331519126892,
-1.3277699947357178,
0.3596378266811371,
0.23656406998634338,
0.23704609274864197,
-1.004597783088684,
-0.13051578402519226,
-0.04875019192695618,
-0.29605185985565186,
-0.8218094110488892,
0.5129090547561646,
0.1549198031425476,
0.6599056124687195,
0.4807753264904022,
-0.3728950619697571,
-0.23039016127586365,
-1.041800618171692,
0.1596933901309967,
-0.22198458015918732,
-0.22889678180217743,
0.496594101190567,
0.5140553116798401,
-0.2984846830368042,
0.9091522693634033,
-0.3401963412761688,
-0.5381346344947815,
-0.12936095893383026,
0.20303423702716827,
-0.1135503500699997,
0.21098071336746216,
0.6040976047515869,
-0.7182331681251526,
-0.6402881145477295,
0.22023455798625946,
-0.4746565520763397,
-0.17783722281455994,
0.47204941511154175,
0.18615899980068207,
0.45995625853538513,
0.22353580594062805,
-0.3752712309360504,
0.17309635877609253,
0.4654424488544464,
0.051542412489652634,
-0.11180005967617035,
-0.2637854814529419,
0.3322218060493469,
-0.8630529046058655,
0.2609997093677521,
-0.295928955078125,
0.3143267333507538,
-0.5546908974647522,
0.2839532196521759,
-0.04651501029729843,
-0.2774571180343628,
-0.23298265039920807,
0.5705952644348145,
-0.6112167239189148,
0.09798567742109299,
-0.30826762318611145,
0.37196895480155945,
-0.2647935748100281,
0.061536382883787155,
-0.028836607933044434,
0.7808861136436462,
0.0551675483584404,
-0.6648592948913574,
0.22377315163612366,
0.49236559867858887,
-0.6028103232383728,
0.7008885145187378,
-0.40781480073928833,
0.2345862239599228,
-0.10460023581981659,
-0.11281566321849823,
-0.6597548127174377,
-0.5334587097167969,
0.27265894412994385,
-0.2783730626106262,
0.25315579771995544,
-0.13462093472480774,
-0.3739006519317627,
-0.1360192596912384,
-0.053261540830135345,
0.5627525448799133,
0.2198488861322403,
-0.3358531594276428,
0.3356803357601166,
0.888428270816803,
-0.7309733629226685,
-0.680203914642334,
-0.7939915060997009,
0.08202915638685226,
0.18975819647312164,
-0.7139341831207275,
0.10618395358324051,
0.009648939594626427,
-0.48426368832588196,
0.42442211508750916,
0.05109967663884163,
-0.34824657440185547,
0.3425206243991852,
-0.08493036031723022,
-0.32934945821762085,
-0.3193705677986145,
0.14741365611553192,
-0.05360659584403038,
0.08176396042108536,
0.09386024624109268,
-0.1749379187822342,
0.5112268924713135,
-0.07400264590978622,
-0.4204351007938385,
-0.03706289082765579,
0.619554340839386,
0.2553255259990692,
-0.12185633927583694,
1.4573979377746582,
0.6100582480430603,
-0.5860497951507568,
-0.14125175774097443,
-0.9160082936286926,
0.04853253811597824,
-0.43130213022232056,
-0.11899150162935257,
-0.1428622007369995,
-1.0244171619415283,
0.9157597422599792,
0.2237250655889511,
-0.11100468784570694,
0.7112899422645569,
0.4852144718170166,
-0.3954562842845917,
0.22835448384284973,
0.9816162586212158,
-0.08745236694812775,
0.27265414595603943,
-0.19153466820716858,
0.23385265469551086,
-0.6247659921646118,
-0.35008519887924194,
-0.8157784938812256,
-0.549829363822937,
-0.74235999584198,
-0.22468484938144684,
0.3403254449367523,
0.03325970470905304,
0.0626009851694107,
0.24953773617744446,
-0.058179520070552826,
0.41687512397766113,
0.6565448045730591,
0.021901819854974747,
0.2492392361164093,
-0.17313739657402039,
-0.03481229394674301,
-0.02646958827972412,
-0.9172366261482239,
-0.5339868068695068,
0.7164109945297241,
-0.06816330552101135,
0.782110869884491,
0.5790016055107117,
0.7328885197639465,
0.3474368155002594,
0.44960811734199524,
-0.703952968120575,
0.03373438119888306,
0.2270432412624359,
-0.7799667716026306,
-0.517825722694397,
-0.5185415744781494,
-0.8463671803474426,
-0.1867857724428177,
-0.1421526074409485,
-0.5940820574760437,
0.5690053105354309,
0.159759521484375,
-0.138063445687294,
0.4154084622859955,
-0.47017914056777954,
0.9522711634635925,
-0.11728058755397797,
-0.17451460659503937,
-0.17090946435928345,
-0.7588543891906738,
0.16512618958950043,
-0.5229763388633728,
0.8390487432479858,
0.1488470733165741,
-0.15001817047595978,
0.6605778932571411,
-0.7347994446754456,
0.5587347149848938,
-0.1314297914505005,
-0.11678913235664368,
0.6926381587982178,
0.14073015749454498,
0.29565396904945374,
-0.03577437251806259,
-0.12394619733095169,
0.3330295979976654,
-0.09547531604766846,
-0.5849980711936951,
-0.28329992294311523,
0.9439076781272888,
-1.0572068691253662,
-0.6458144187927246,
-0.19455184042453766,
-0.20303967595100403,
-0.20425795018672943,
0.15771451592445374,
0.4152114987373352,
0.3202168941497803,
-0.3642866015434265,
0.2969725430011749,
0.7439698576927185,
-0.23770806193351746,
0.5591204166412354,
0.3006983697414398,
0.3962668180465698,
-0.292836993932724,
0.8714529275894165,
0.5760931968688965,
0.24806375801563263,
0.14602789282798767,
0.003212823299691081,
0.05911409482359886,
-0.5787659883499146,
-0.5533801317214966,
0.006153529975563288,
-0.8943398594856262,
-0.16451503336429596,
-0.4711275100708008,
-0.14974381029605865,
-0.32834234833717346,
-0.19078001379966736,
-0.20149679481983185,
-0.5934178233146667,
-0.4214143753051758,
0.258102148771286,
0.22047489881515503,
0.8012840747833252,
-0.28158894181251526,
0.29434478282928467,
-0.9001852869987488,
0.32636845111846924,
0.4290904104709625,
0.45642784237861633,
0.4028761684894562,
-0.4468750059604645,
-0.6394966244697571,
0.030937757343053818,
-0.2453065812587738,
-1.072653889656067,
-0.05061013996601105,
0.2074020951986313,
0.6731468439102173,
0.23061300814151764,
0.5038574934005737,
0.4022873342037201,
-0.5766956210136414,
0.6458685398101807,
-0.007423977833241224,
-0.8783354759216309,
0.5993784666061401,
-0.16349244117736816,
-0.010273663327097893,
0.9068190455436707,
0.7149178981781006,
-1.1041957139968872,
-0.32041382789611816,
-0.3488161265850067,
-0.8739525675773621,
0.9498003125190735,
0.36315467953681946,
0.42386287450790405,
-0.26770132780075073,
0.3619699478149414,
0.19432422518730164,
0.22640088200569153,
-0.6213060021400452,
-0.7137020230293274,
-0.41154980659484863,
0.07420983910560608,
0.13235841691493988,
-0.5999910235404968,
-0.1398862898349762,
0.19607990980148315,
0.6471567749977112,
0.05282582342624664,
-0.050262533128261566,
0.34751027822494507,
-0.4200931191444397,
-0.5052381753921509,
0.5657582879066467,
0.39479464292526245,
0.7020805478096008,
-0.0031925090588629246,
0.12033975124359131,
0.2845000922679901,
-0.4500036835670471,
0.2553153932094574,
0.013215074315667152,
-0.5701190829277039,
-0.025802260264754295,
0.22893449664115906,
0.7046900391578674,
0.18396811187267303,
-0.35908743739128113,
0.41036421060562134,
0.007001932244747877,
0.29402434825897217,
-0.21853557229042053,
-0.014225346967577934,
0.23618406057357788,
-0.0018499210709705949,
0.7016546130180359,
0.07034072279930115,
-0.10452389717102051,
-0.7756791114807129,
-0.25498005747795105,
0.338257372379303,
-0.28218531608581543,
-0.20066745579242706,
0.44052854180336,
0.6578150391578674,
-0.4229765832424164,
0.6475141048431396,
-0.1890762448310852,
-0.28533875942230225,
0.24387699365615845,
0.17380501329898834,
0.4857528507709503,
-0.09463226050138474,
0.08957100659608841,
0.2344520092010498,
0.6427823901176453,
0.16857954859733582,
0.17521271109580994,
-0.20923581719398499,
-0.8071455359458923,
-0.13268892467021942,
-0.7058184146881104,
-0.47582581639289856,
0.2602754831314087,
-0.6363574862480164,
0.17866897583007812,
-0.24786341190338135,
-0.33249926567077637,
0.04105125367641449,
0.012788093648850918,
-0.6833734512329102,
-0.15821266174316406,
0.006835375912487507,
0.8662592768669128,
-0.5900496244430542,
0.5592564940452576,
0.6596460342407227,
-0.7320657968521118,
-0.3390366733074188,
0.21791236102581024,
0.12752187252044678,
-0.5230534672737122,
0.6200706958770752,
-0.3987185060977936,
0.021195581182837486,
0.08645917475223541,
-0.13742798566818237,
-0.8885593414306641,
0.7348204255104065,
0.4472213089466095,
-0.18187148869037628,
0.06066836044192314,
0.1733059138059616,
0.6204479336738586,
0.1027919352054596,
-0.06915400922298431,
0.20437504351139069,
0.52357017993927,
-0.09567039459943771,
-1.023470401763916,
-0.10751207917928696,
-0.15365247428417206,
-0.07472911477088928,
0.5382534861564636,
-0.7772080898284912,
0.7985658645629883,
-0.3181918263435364,
-0.3545069396495819,
0.19425852596759796,
0.7097201943397522,
-0.20125965774059296,
0.06114828959107399,
0.26160889863967896,
0.4621240496635437,
0.6325680017471313,
-0.16894227266311646,
0.9881102442741394,
-0.477350652217865,
0.3012562096118927,
0.6987825632095337,
-0.002165371784940362,
0.8547007441520691,
0.7409701943397522,
-0.15341448783874512,
0.6922184824943542,
0.4379028081893921,
0.42034712433815,
0.3986756503582001,
0.06263118982315063,
-0.5185538530349731,
0.02567768469452858,
-0.41038978099823,
-0.4215451180934906,
0.10922455042600632,
0.45791640877723694,
0.03360646963119507,
-0.1671866476535797,
-0.0662015974521637,
-0.1480947881937027,
0.02130783721804619,
-0.5049799680709839,
0.7922974824905396,
0.14259673655033112,
-0.5138992667198181,
0.29550325870513916,
0.27527695894241333,
0.3698591887950897,
-0.46233808994293213,
0.14420168101787567,
-0.5016174912452698,
-0.09789849817752838,
-0.2341962605714798,
-0.735905647277832,
0.4479132294654846,
0.13824209570884705,
-0.19450382888317108,
0.03460094332695007,
0.9195281267166138,
-0.2810323238372803,
-0.18236751854419708,
0.2416992038488388,
0.9581848382949829,
-0.094874806702137,
0.2562626302242279,
-0.1806250512599945,
0.06642317771911621,
-0.3003920614719391,
-0.02304687909781933,
0.4710705876350403,
0.9344314336776733,
-0.1935303956270218,
0.5691823363304138,
0.41240203380584717,
0.19285893440246582,
-0.16599132120609283,
-0.14427624642848969,
0.7787925601005554,
-0.5144540667533875,
-0.21875928342342377,
-0.6412416696548462,
0.1433168351650238,
0.10355250537395477,
-0.3457965552806854,
0.9114751815795898,
0.39013299345970154,
1.219095230102539,
-0.15269403159618378,
0.7349523305892944,
-0.7219393849372864,
0.43817561864852905,
-0.3405654728412628,
1.1921669244766235,
-0.6222442388534546,
0.055284660309553146,
-0.19288364052772522,
-0.9344670176506042,
0.17720218002796173,
0.644067645072937,
0.220998615026474,
-0.0409761480987072,
0.557523250579834,
0.23754386603832245,
-0.12692086398601532,
-0.015683425590395927,
0.019231576472520828,
0.13664165139198303,
-0.18178169429302216,
0.13753990828990936,
0.9450552463531494,
-0.31275397539138794,
0.7526569962501526,
-0.7261230945587158,
-0.012576643377542496,
-0.38346460461616516,
-0.7235904932022095,
-0.7052208185195923,
-0.7020571231842041,
-0.1426686942577362,
-0.24082978069782257,
-0.16126765310764313,
1.0088235139846802,
0.08698264509439468,
-1.1633104085922241,
-0.3512636721134186,
0.23975104093551636,
0.4102541506290436,
0.14890708029270172,
-0.16430102288722992,
0.11406270414590836,
-0.3169628381729126,
-0.4821281433105469,
0.035255108028650284,
0.06802760809659958,
-0.014139268547296524,
-0.27621451020240784,
-0.1473022848367691,
-0.13436618447303772,
-0.16095778346061707,
0.47987568378448486,
0.6596437096595764,
-0.7829943299293518,
-0.5543995499610901,
0.01703963801264763,
-0.3738701641559601,
-0.12950202822685242,
0.9580656290054321,
-0.42858344316482544,
0.41395020484924316,
0.4858320951461792,
0.8444006443023682,
0.4900631010532379,
-0.3158800005912781,
0.3616738021373749,
-0.8761927485466003,
0.027438072487711906,
0.01709805615246296,
0.6010655760765076,
0.42803141474723816,
0.07903912663459778,
0.45355790853500366,
0.4272371828556061,
-0.4491789937019348,
-0.4195607304573059,
-0.029142137616872787,
-0.5878103375434875,
-0.03571593761444092,
0.77303546667099,
-0.17029160261154175,
-0.006402686238288879,
-0.47190096974372864,
-0.22435450553894043,
0.331376850605011,
-0.2987598776817322,
1.0942554473876953,
1.0908207893371582,
-0.03420618548989296,
-0.3324452042579651,
-0.6525022983551025,
0.6724737882614136,
-0.15198764204978943,
-0.7328348159790039,
-0.11573433130979538,
0.6516698002815247,
0.22830073535442352,
0.6454681158065796,
0.7833641171455383,
0.3745303153991699,
0.23391130566596985,
-0.016837434843182564,
-0.19193696975708008,
0.13817624747753143,
0.03068368509411812,
-0.022038044407963753,
0.2915341556072235,
0.3684391379356384,
0.31340742111206055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20775v1
|
Cross-Modality Jailbreak and Mismatched Attacks on Medical Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-05-26T19:11:21 | 2024-05-26T19:11:21 |
Xijie Huang, Xinyuan Wang, Hantao Zhang, Jiawen Xi, Jingkun An, Hao Wang, Chengwei Pan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Security concerns related to Large Language Models (LLMs) have been
extensively explored, yet the safety implications for Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs), particularly in medical contexts (MedMLLMs), remain
insufficiently studied. This paper delves into the underexplored security
vulnerabilities of MedMLLMs, especially when deployed in clinical environments
where the accuracy and relevance of question-and-answer interactions are
critically tested against complex medical challenges. By combining existing
clinical medical data with atypical natural phenomena, we redefine two types of
attacks: mismatched malicious attack (2M-attack) and optimized mismatched
malicious attack (O2M-attack). Using our own constructed voluminous 3MAD
dataset, which covers a wide range of medical image modalities and harmful
medical scenarios, we conduct a comprehensive analysis and propose the MCM
optimization method, which significantly enhances the attack success rate on
MedMLLMs. Evaluations with this dataset and novel attack methods, including
white-box attacks on LLaVA-Med and transfer attacks on four other
state-of-the-art models, indicate that even MedMLLMs designed with enhanced
security features are vulnerable to security breaches. Our work underscores the
urgent need for a concerted effort to implement robust security measures and
enhance the safety and efficacy of open-source MedMLLMs, particularly given the
potential severity of jailbreak attacks and other malicious or clinically
significant exploits in medical settings. For further research and replication,
anonymous access to our code is available at
https://github.com/dirtycomputer/O2M_attack. Warning: Medical large model
jailbreaking may generate content that includes unverified diagnoses and
treatment recommendations. Always consult professional medical advice.
|
[
-0.23581476509571075,
-1.0132848024368286,
0.6173948645591736,
-0.03664785623550415,
-0.3167791962623596,
-0.06746052205562592,
-0.032167959958314896,
-0.6716621518135071,
-0.11986052989959717,
0.8959116339683533,
-0.3011089861392975,
-0.35997965931892395,
-0.6966262459754944,
-0.06436919420957565,
0.06375940144062042,
0.8838458061218262,
-0.1484687179327011,
0.4204059839248657,
-0.17900657653808594,
-0.49541419744491577,
-0.7488800287246704,
-0.7981730103492737,
-0.28923261165618896,
0.1465333104133606,
0.5190424919128418,
0.055826686322689056,
0.8260295987129211,
0.29157963395118713,
0.9457395672798157,
0.20339830219745636,
0.27715814113616943,
0.23361359536647797,
-0.32555481791496277,
0.36837685108184814,
-0.1986672431230545,
-0.39924710988998413,
-0.5715765357017517,
-0.14331677556037903,
0.20736968517303467,
0.35832321643829346,
-0.18966370820999146,
0.09325192123651505,
-0.35283276438713074,
0.5539959073066711,
-0.8066755533218384,
-0.394382506608963,
-0.7522683143615723,
0.0670807883143425,
-0.4480844736099243,
-0.252259761095047,
-0.42781659960746765,
-0.19771502912044525,
-0.18776552379131317,
-0.07947591692209244,
-0.2582567632198334,
0.15270812809467316,
0.4260440468788147,
0.10742954164743423,
-0.5454769134521484,
-0.2990536391735077,
-0.5498495101928711,
0.5747403502464294,
-0.7244412302970886,
0.277521550655365,
0.6160755157470703,
0.568932831287384,
-0.4410362243652344,
-0.5550269484519958,
-0.2755458652973175,
-0.32450079917907715,
-0.0667903944849968,
-0.23229734599590302,
-0.3908478617668152,
0.10629281401634216,
0.23282314836978912,
0.025037327781319618,
-0.6795744299888611,
0.35289210081100464,
-0.5537307262420654,
-0.09313376992940903,
0.4782087504863739,
0.45161545276641846,
0.5632415413856506,
-0.12272005528211594,
-0.6629003882408142,
0.13327419757843018,
-0.9586273431777954,
-0.12632279098033905,
0.123775415122509,
0.115909643471241,
-0.4680400788784027,
0.7107013463973999,
0.40756261348724365,
0.5412929058074951,
-0.33529147505760193,
-0.4189792573451996,
0.1959204226732254,
-0.5948663353919983,
-0.2980360984802246,
-0.05700869485735893,
0.9346886873245239,
0.5169130563735962,
0.008694197982549667,
-0.2208910435438156,
-0.1782529652118683,
-0.03258226439356804,
0.4824087619781494,
-0.8102708458900452,
-0.1265096813440323,
0.5559552907943726,
-0.5321057438850403,
-0.5299693942070007,
0.06588808447122574,
-0.7171310186386108,
-0.6984897255897522,
0.28925779461860657,
0.2730313241481781,
-0.3396588861942291,
-0.2054651826620102,
0.06927507370710373,
0.21496786177158356,
-0.028345709666609764,
0.1806027889251709,
-0.6665264964103699,
0.15752959251403809,
0.475946843624115,
0.7873693108558655,
-0.06744237244129181,
-0.0463421456515789,
-0.4089697003364563,
0.33097144961357117,
-0.15779857337474823,
0.3664110600948334,
-0.21726281940937042,
-0.5397523641586304,
-0.04661561921238899,
0.020002584904432297,
-0.40832826495170593,
-0.5649797916412354,
0.273998886346817,
-0.5966701507568359,
-0.018485669046640396,
0.07083611935377121,
-0.17726029455661774,
0.04296059533953667,
0.4763469994068146,
-0.7708569765090942,
0.4561544954776764,
-0.1137969121336937,
-0.8600744605064392,
-0.031171932816505432,
-0.7193379402160645,
-0.40456315875053406,
-0.31315404176712036,
-0.24518096446990967,
-0.6206017732620239,
0.1946219652891159,
0.13572195172309875,
0.4352259635925293,
-0.34483328461647034,
0.3159598112106323,
-0.5651206970214844,
0.08806152641773224,
0.7545105814933777,
-0.49882635474205017,
0.6428245306015015,
0.5706793069839478,
-0.2754122316837311,
-0.022410107776522636,
-0.6652432084083557,
0.02389027364552021,
0.5117385983467102,
-0.17079472541809082,
-0.48323550820350647,
0.029924467206001282,
0.27629223465919495,
0.4091073274612427,
0.10944885015487671,
-0.5776380300521851,
0.2360212504863739,
-0.3704894483089447,
0.6000744700431824,
0.37434059381484985,
0.2395547777414322,
0.015560561791062355,
-0.3208245635032654,
0.5194162130355835,
0.07533761858940125,
0.7071644067764282,
-0.2717636823654175,
-0.3770926594734192,
0.12265327572822571,
-0.47519469261169434,
0.05273125693202019,
0.742193341255188,
-0.5609686970710754,
-0.06204841285943985,
0.22478635609149933,
-0.5031290054321289,
-0.5041658878326416,
0.10100444406270981,
0.624052882194519,
0.411548912525177,
0.46235883235931396,
-0.1432090401649475,
-0.36181551218032837,
-0.9514239430427551,
-0.35471856594085693,
-0.038931671530008316,
0.11588691920042038,
0.48023074865341187,
0.4866056442260742,
-0.6954877376556396,
0.5719533562660217,
-0.3479231297969818,
-0.45344796776771545,
-0.10940094292163849,
-0.3108283579349518,
0.007273871451616287,
0.8236342668533325,
0.7987223863601685,
-0.771239697933197,
-0.012000035494565964,
-0.04625779762864113,
-0.6848195195198059,
-0.04754926636815071,
-0.1420745849609375,
0.18728165328502655,
0.3095645606517792,
0.7181869745254517,
-0.6607750654220581,
0.4238670766353607,
0.7137592434883118,
-0.4347114861011505,
0.5761168599128723,
-0.36560821533203125,
0.15365754067897797,
-1.2498494386672974,
0.22548210620880127,
-0.2306879758834839,
-0.26261207461357117,
-0.7925023436546326,
0.6222708821296692,
0.1996210664510727,
-0.13001897931098938,
-0.7476582527160645,
0.367099791765213,
-0.4701792001724243,
0.13344183564186096,
-0.11768344044685364,
-0.1587253212928772,
-0.01864614337682724,
0.16937682032585144,
-0.35109949111938477,
0.45913997292518616,
0.4994482100009918,
0.05504816398024559,
0.2519303858280182,
-0.04771789535880089,
-0.2156430035829544,
0.49529770016670227,
-0.6213021874427795,
0.2911393940448761,
0.07617924362421036,
0.12628886103630066,
-0.830751359462738,
-0.36513280868530273,
0.4105129837989807,
-0.4073924720287323,
0.58375483751297,
-0.2046004831790924,
-0.671973466873169,
-0.03629252314567566,
-0.5082225799560547,
0.7688183784484863,
0.25984957814216614,
-0.22451132535934448,
0.34455394744873047,
0.5665091872215271,
-0.06864245980978012,
-0.5451439619064331,
-0.8133367896080017,
0.38435429334640503,
-0.3178744316101074,
-0.7318158149719238,
0.06575949490070343,
0.14628905057907104,
-0.46804872155189514,
-0.19841288030147552,
-0.03449263051152229,
-0.0829429030418396,
0.4193873107433319,
0.38895031809806824,
0.7040557861328125,
-0.17029786109924316,
-0.19167320430278778,
-0.13522113859653473,
0.041838306933641434,
0.269039511680603,
0.024673331528902054,
0.4297409951686859,
0.029965359717607498,
-0.8022529482841492,
-0.22682234644889832,
0.6380636096000671,
0.9915945529937744,
-0.30568164587020874,
0.9494534730911255,
0.40426105260849,
-0.47563672065734863,
0.2669491469860077,
-0.5637872219085693,
-0.19137823581695557,
-0.4041527509689331,
0.6132527589797974,
-0.17984622716903687,
-0.9365043044090271,
0.4444926977157593,
0.09760843217372894,
0.13878083229064941,
0.06111564114689827,
0.7187654376029968,
-0.21322335302829742,
1.1659674644470215,
0.22663721442222595,
-0.027454417198896408,
0.13255828619003296,
0.154412642121315,
0.22300338745117188,
-0.8159937858581543,
-0.6657452583312988,
-0.4369102120399475,
-0.04008294641971588,
-0.6317011713981628,
-0.6099963188171387,
0.5905922055244446,
-0.0034449822269380093,
-0.10844540596008301,
0.11283913254737854,
-0.007643035147339106,
0.28830060362815857,
0.0062964181415736675,
0.18188557028770447,
0.22010064125061035,
-0.07267764955759048,
-0.3784182071685791,
0.05445593222975731,
-0.5257242321968079,
-0.22548039257526398,
1.338144302368164,
0.6191104054450989,
1.2225241661071777,
0.5097989439964294,
0.37743812799453735,
0.2473364919424057,
0.12064335495233536,
-0.378037691116333,
0.20607788860797882,
-0.0009123400086537004,
-0.896579921245575,
0.11224717646837234,
-0.3709019124507904,
-1.0714360475540161,
0.4985470175743103,
-0.3825594186782837,
-0.8487808704376221,
0.018509341403841972,
0.1398066282272339,
-0.3134514391422272,
0.4471752345561981,
-0.740411102771759,
0.9574806690216064,
-0.4007987678050995,
-0.28528791666030884,
-0.22719788551330566,
-1.1289799213409424,
0.7117280960083008,
-0.5049615502357483,
0.6256925463676453,
0.03679148852825165,
-0.02543480694293976,
0.22368969023227692,
-0.6829196810722351,
0.7136785984039307,
-0.18596892058849335,
-0.09590021520853043,
-0.21050414443016052,
0.2501424551010132,
0.47616782784461975,
0.2790592610836029,
0.4432089328765869,
0.3646889925003052,
0.13504883646965027,
-0.39291590452194214,
-0.42040979862213135,
0.7591547966003418,
-0.641205370426178,
-0.6717702150344849,
-0.38305023312568665,
-0.48053935170173645,
-0.31497517228126526,
0.044794559478759766,
0.12472658604383469,
0.6348868608474731,
0.11286458373069763,
0.08762164413928986,
0.6577787399291992,
-0.41778722405433655,
0.26758724451065063,
0.5331323742866516,
-0.2872263491153717,
-0.7110819220542908,
0.6101760268211365,
-0.045049648731946945,
0.750973641872406,
0.013910890556871891,
0.007112512830644846,
-0.09647466987371445,
-0.8672491312026978,
-0.5233420729637146,
0.2850126326084137,
-0.5911147594451904,
-0.35076311230659485,
-0.6106958985328674,
-0.15822859108448029,
-0.4575786292552948,
-0.07479802519083023,
-0.29996833205223083,
-0.16994349658489227,
-0.10603819042444229,
0.16613487899303436,
0.2952515184879303,
0.423403263092041,
0.196115180850029,
0.0381181426346302,
-1.0658215284347534,
0.4468545913696289,
-0.13036410510540009,
0.25392040610313416,
-0.22915387153625488,
-0.20186573266983032,
-0.1678149253129959,
-0.1038796603679657,
-0.1912502646446228,
-1.049116611480713,
0.1571698933839798,
-0.16142086684703827,
0.5126842260360718,
0.4957559108734131,
-0.12155640870332718,
0.45005369186401367,
-0.6992565393447876,
0.5202628374099731,
0.46339723467826843,
-0.413237065076828,
0.5723412036895752,
-0.33440330624580383,
0.16362635791301727,
0.6849389672279358,
0.22600769996643066,
-0.4578956365585327,
-0.5285214781761169,
-0.4683743119239807,
-0.8808812499046326,
0.4933947026729584,
0.3448633551597595,
0.052773814648389816,
0.010776693001389503,
0.0919405072927475,
0.04017503187060356,
0.2400490790605545,
-0.6464799046516418,
-0.4458707571029663,
0.06207264959812164,
0.028708087280392647,
0.19291932880878448,
-0.27652668952941895,
-0.4743666350841522,
-0.18966986238956451,
0.3717139959335327,
0.06485413759946823,
0.057089291512966156,
0.24677395820617676,
-0.2661573886871338,
-0.08978229761123657,
0.3872933089733124,
0.9737077355384827,
0.4276224672794342,
-0.17888794839382172,
0.3859880268573761,
-0.0016822188626974821,
-0.9445151686668396,
0.16077440977096558,
0.20597846806049347,
0.14283199608325958,
-0.12406842410564423,
0.337932825088501,
0.7269157767295837,
0.12395806610584259,
-1.0470342636108398,
0.6476689577102661,
-0.09238174557685852,
0.06481552124023438,
-0.25064802169799805,
-0.06429531425237656,
-0.06035914644598961,
0.42293474078178406,
0.11125387251377106,
0.548522412776947,
-0.1266774833202362,
-0.5528857111930847,
0.09764302521944046,
0.7859964370727539,
-0.3571613132953644,
-0.2890113592147827,
0.771205484867096,
-0.10075299441814423,
-0.1381293088197708,
0.27883780002593994,
0.4467749297618866,
-0.33974719047546387,
0.6569076776504517,
0.8184061050415039,
0.6878186464309692,
-0.31677189469337463,
-0.2715418338775635,
-0.1834428906440735,
0.7332592606544495,
0.14849811792373657,
0.2420615404844284,
0.15897361934185028,
-0.4693151116371155,
-0.05924377217888832,
-0.25017425417900085,
-0.29044002294540405,
0.4059751629829407,
-0.5456653237342834,
0.30407384037971497,
-0.6424190402030945,
-0.3916209936141968,
-0.0795108824968338,
-0.4664728045463562,
-0.26366758346557617,
0.05359727144241333,
0.38273388147354126,
0.8681504130363464,
-0.5068598389625549,
0.9106839895248413,
0.7303321361541748,
0.04012942686676979,
-0.6221651434898376,
-0.2964981496334076,
0.3170323669910431,
-0.8722594976425171,
0.16675467789173126,
0.1427915096282959,
0.06832845509052277,
-0.5033671855926514,
-0.3107409179210663,
-0.7865470051765442,
0.9166336059570312,
0.4095747172832489,
-0.6090933680534363,
0.05606817454099655,
0.40160682797431946,
0.24652205407619476,
-0.2691551446914673,
0.005052118096500635,
0.5813042521476746,
0.31156203150749207,
-0.0824165940284729,
-1.0478755235671997,
0.26503631472587585,
-0.2662073075771332,
-0.10968857258558273,
0.508361279964447,
-0.2991946339607239,
0.7787919640541077,
-0.6183873414993286,
0.09710627049207687,
0.07821471989154816,
-0.14483122527599335,
0.5669699907302856,
0.4030849039554596,
0.27668270468711853,
0.6183246374130249,
0.48613807559013367,
0.08000784367322922,
1.2533221244812012,
-0.2338385134935379,
0.2118111103773117,
0.8654746413230896,
-0.31152305006980896,
0.6651321649551392,
0.8588751554489136,
-0.11369732022285461,
0.10254289954900742,
0.3052791953086853,
-0.21293842792510986,
0.530270516872406,
0.16744326055049896,
-0.2973535656929016,
0.05234820395708084,
0.1518029272556305,
-0.6998617649078369,
0.3142577111721039,
0.42210623621940613,
-0.6449427604675293,
-0.23819774389266968,
0.46362408995628357,
0.54840087890625,
-0.2823752164840698,
-0.2691468596458435,
0.7148708701133728,
0.25848692655563354,
-0.2337389886379242,
0.6305601596832275,
0.32355567812919617,
0.4589143693447113,
-0.7317413687705994,
0.19354978203773499,
-0.017719047144055367,
0.03853423893451691,
-0.3555966913700104,
-0.48168638348579407,
0.22581015527248383,
0.23537437617778778,
-0.03005773387849331,
0.1707897186279297,
0.7886878848075867,
-0.21469585597515106,
-0.3462907075881958,
0.31901249289512634,
0.2858525514602661,
0.05220832675695419,
0.07149126380681992,
-0.6492120027542114,
0.3518292307853699,
-0.23183399438858032,
-0.23410803079605103,
0.7400919795036316,
0.03141350671648979,
-0.23186855018138885,
0.602996289730072,
0.8685886859893799,
0.29330626130104065,
0.0636458769440651,
0.11446341127157211,
0.9900838136672974,
-0.5052815079689026,
-0.3268294632434845,
-1.4008280038833618,
0.4651593267917633,
0.03139365464448929,
-0.12144460529088974,
0.6721793413162231,
0.5145228505134583,
0.5612598061561584,
-0.03668097034096718,
0.604590117931366,
0.0805414542555809,
0.04441121220588684,
-0.7330462336540222,
1.0680317878723145,
-0.5337624549865723,
0.5013550519943237,
-0.4130576550960541,
-0.48938509821891785,
-0.5153164863586426,
0.11249998956918716,
-0.1434849351644516,
-0.15179385244846344,
0.7832418084144592,
0.871036946773529,
0.029157888144254684,
-0.04490213841199875,
0.36442241072654724,
0.25755709409713745,
0.3566758930683136,
0.6710888743400574,
0.7593492269515991,
-0.24188721179962158,
0.3206704556941986,
-0.03770214691758156,
-0.19197389483451843,
-0.28695064783096313,
-0.6699473261833191,
-1.0755505561828613,
-0.11411003768444061,
-0.12356659024953842,
-0.5916560888290405,
0.12952543795108795,
1.048797607421875,
0.43633386492729187,
-0.7583205699920654,
0.012401968240737915,
0.4416379928588867,
-0.05184614658355713,
0.15124137699604034,
-0.13705149292945862,
0.24911946058273315,
-0.05846793204545975,
-0.05896599963307381,
0.4286651611328125,
0.5229498147964478,
0.1226443499326706,
-0.43181899189949036,
0.12274853885173798,
-0.12555654346942902,
0.1577243208885193,
0.43751776218414307,
0.2511383593082428,
-0.7901361584663391,
-0.056655533611774445,
-0.03695671260356903,
-0.5302480459213257,
0.1514865607023239,
0.9361861348152161,
-0.42528221011161804,
0.5659789443016052,
0.017286714166402817,
0.740208089351654,
0.03617607429623604,
-0.1882658302783966,
0.2882632315158844,
-0.5481074452400208,
0.23708724975585938,
0.30426543951034546,
0.548287034034729,
0.07662317156791687,
-0.41148969531059265,
0.0909220278263092,
0.34985342621803284,
-0.25776830315589905,
-1.1863430738449097,
0.35349181294441223,
-0.9622710347175598,
-0.572958767414093,
1.0176026821136475,
-0.2336200773715973,
-0.20176979899406433,
-0.31195688247680664,
-0.346210777759552,
-0.22980321943759918,
-0.004820394795387983,
0.6272673010826111,
0.2961888015270233,
-0.0024572527036070824,
0.10526852309703827,
-0.959343671798706,
0.4456922113895416,
0.16512109339237213,
-0.8656893372535706,
-0.06014009565114975,
0.44372332096099854,
0.37318897247314453,
0.018578412011265755,
0.33214735984802246,
-0.8094222545623779,
0.502449095249176,
-0.2999321222305298,
-0.1875879317522049,
-0.48114028573036194,
-0.15041512250900269,
-0.4524279534816742,
0.4897069036960602,
-0.05149182304739952,
-0.2258061319589615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16662v1
|
Conjunctive categorial grammars and Lambek grammars with additives
| 2024-05-26T18:53:56 | 2024-05-26T18:53:56 |
Stepan L. Kuznetsov, Alexander Okhotin
|
cs.LO
|
cs.LO, cs.CL, math.LO, 03D05, F.4.2; F.4.1
|
A new family of categorial grammars is proposed, defined by enriching basic
categorial grammars with a conjunction operation. It is proved that the
formalism obtained in this way has the same expressive power as conjunctive
grammars, that is, context-free grammars enhanced with conjunction. It is also
shown that categorial grammars with conjunction can be naturally embedded into
the Lambek calculus with conjunction and disjunction operations. This further
implies that a certain NP-complete set can be defined in the Lambek calculus
with conjunction. We also show how to handle some subtle issues connected with
the empty string. Finally, we prove that a language generated by a conjunctive
grammar can be described by a Lambek grammar with disjunction (but without
conjunction).
|
[
-0.2473434954881668,
-0.840340793132782,
0.568280816078186,
0.6443237066268921,
-0.15483501553535461,
0.08557664602994919,
-0.21631699800491333,
-0.5333729386329651,
0.38739529252052307,
0.47716307640075684,
-0.2757994830608368,
0.13113966584205627,
-0.32721996307373047,
0.23171012103557587,
-0.34745895862579346,
0.9073197245597839,
0.12664537131786346,
0.005108237732201815,
-0.30649900436401367,
0.03698496147990227,
-0.35825681686401367,
-0.483096182346344,
-0.4209853410720825,
-0.24822132289409637,
0.5081856846809387,
0.45045796036720276,
0.7287400960922241,
0.5831514000892639,
0.5541302561759949,
0.4936009645462036,
-0.39350461959838867,
-0.2177763283252716,
0.29871076345443726,
0.2190612256526947,
-0.5414324998855591,
-0.3776012063026428,
-0.7040249109268188,
-0.22996529936790466,
0.6869176030158997,
0.8646142482757568,
-0.3817373514175415,
0.11262246966362,
-0.0754176527261734,
0.6204069256782532,
-0.8488485217094421,
0.19730815291404724,
-0.48180148005485535,
-0.1426803469657898,
-0.10233511030673981,
-0.2314571738243103,
-0.21298114955425262,
-0.3810712695121765,
0.24881286919116974,
-0.7711294889450073,
0.04092542454600334,
-0.19636519253253937,
0.32298681139945984,
0.40501871705055237,
-0.7059803009033203,
-0.6022534370422363,
-0.46602165699005127,
0.5670368075370789,
-0.377514123916626,
0.4690802991390228,
0.27154606580734253,
0.4886495769023895,
-0.4362833797931671,
-0.7843396663665771,
-0.895427405834198,
-0.5117575526237488,
-0.3902280330657959,
0.5167780518531799,
-0.4110497236251831,
0.30985674262046814,
0.1507391482591629,
0.8454427123069763,
-0.4385395348072052,
-0.029845306649804115,
-0.038244232535362244,
-0.1429828554391861,
0.3244853913784027,
0.06934108585119247,
0.1638389527797699,
-0.48676598072052,
-0.576587438583374,
0.025884412229061127,
-0.5171284675598145,
0.4506087899208069,
0.38675937056541443,
0.16359961032867432,
-0.2299659550189972,
0.8513339757919312,
-0.5221234560012817,
0.8804909586906433,
0.18074794113636017,
0.12146982550621033,
-0.04277908802032471,
-0.6645515561103821,
-0.5534814596176147,
0.2993037700653076,
0.37001314759254456,
-0.0070945187471807,
-0.045265842229127884,
-0.15328019857406616,
0.04696979373693466,
0.931504487991333,
-0.029288392513990402,
-0.4049772024154663,
0.030214501544833183,
0.051388271152973175,
-0.020954366773366928,
-0.42367714643478394,
0.035765089094638824,
-0.4961007535457611,
-0.27303197979927063,
-0.43525126576423645,
0.27978479862213135,
0.12321813404560089,
-0.3791794180870056,
0.7191115617752075,
-0.5161128044128418,
0.30271777510643005,
0.44013985991477966,
-0.9450801014900208,
0.6770981550216675,
0.9822583198547363,
-0.11798270791769028,
0.6070784330368042,
0.029974021017551422,
-0.7838571667671204,
0.158434197306633,
-0.521448016166687,
0.9334911704063416,
-0.8590155243873596,
-0.17238053679466248,
-0.002785363933071494,
0.27686846256256104,
0.2574092447757721,
-0.41751667857170105,
0.6671059727668762,
-0.21569764614105225,
0.2913499176502228,
-0.08822621405124664,
-0.5618752837181091,
-0.5510278344154358,
0.2218262404203415,
-0.5600563883781433,
0.7265063524246216,
0.49941250681877136,
-0.06133551523089409,
0.3226243853569031,
-0.250536173582077,
-0.6630322337150574,
0.5290965437889099,
-0.02945835329592228,
0.10603108257055283,
0.3747110962867737,
-0.34717392921447754,
0.32144325971603394,
-0.3879050612449646,
0.4387509822845459,
-0.35690751671791077,
0.10360325872898102,
0.3480864465236664,
0.04950655996799469,
1.004239559173584,
-0.021787479519844055,
-0.35399430990219116,
-0.018388062715530396,
-1.1350990533828735,
0.130408376455307,
-0.5076786279678345,
-0.4960690438747406,
-0.41385945677757263,
-0.04563659429550171,
-0.13924366235733032,
0.2676970660686493,
0.42525190114974976,
-0.7490800619125366,
0.16268721222877502,
-0.3696332573890686,
0.4351603090763092,
0.6248002648353577,
0.08070225268602371,
0.6595097184181213,
-0.11752820014953613,
0.3689778447151184,
0.011281169019639492,
0.3452693521976471,
-0.10913518816232681,
-0.4534934461116791,
-1.3166078329086304,
-0.11155423521995544,
0.22429870069026947,
0.5962179899215698,
-0.7462548613548279,
0.7227811813354492,
0.15225163102149963,
-0.31703805923461914,
-0.014900284819304943,
-0.030248915776610374,
0.6983755826950073,
0.48067086935043335,
0.235072523355484,
-0.12131225317716599,
-1.0993165969848633,
-1.1253042221069336,
0.1598745733499527,
-0.1577237993478775,
0.3803083598613739,
-0.10035955160856247,
0.13589003682136536,
-0.2826542854309082,
0.42768168449401855,
-0.1726142168045044,
0.0009471566881984472,
-0.18523818254470825,
-0.32114601135253906,
0.16143912076950073,
0.6040441393852234,
0.4881898760795593,
-0.7082364559173584,
-0.3926160931587219,
0.47754302620887756,
-0.5517266392707825,
0.08170128613710403,
0.11048561334609985,
-0.16609956324100494,
-0.04317374899983406,
0.36956220865249634,
-0.3563748300075531,
0.5926555395126343,
0.4541400372982025,
-0.7193391919136047,
0.3629084527492523,
0.06713001430034637,
-0.2732887864112854,
-0.9123842120170593,
-0.3823486566543579,
0.024456143379211426,
-0.5060237050056458,
-0.7592266798019409,
0.4134128987789154,
0.01923944614827633,
0.22031673789024353,
-0.5583322048187256,
0.6807326674461365,
-0.06780891865491867,
0.12524326145648956,
-0.1684199720621109,
0.006521007511764765,
0.09405210614204407,
0.5585667490959167,
0.09159334748983383,
0.48148202896118164,
0.8517014384269714,
-1.0496829748153687,
0.5844720005989075,
0.2727667987346649,
-0.2563598155975342,
0.6425864696502686,
-0.5242635607719421,
-0.7110978364944458,
-0.003758310340344906,
0.3224743902683258,
-0.7797930836677551,
-0.3981917202472687,
0.5420530438423157,
-0.29127708077430725,
-0.011327456682920456,
0.2132812887430191,
-0.4229729473590851,
-0.2044041007757187,
-0.10749722272157669,
0.4379212260246277,
0.5108644366264343,
-0.39899441599845886,
0.16319668292999268,
0.24641449749469757,
0.02423764020204544,
-0.5231714844703674,
-0.5376354455947876,
0.017772596329450607,
-0.10460025072097778,
-0.3014135956764221,
0.2968783378601074,
-0.04066779464483261,
-0.6184435486793518,
0.26867666840553284,
-0.11196678131818771,
-0.12819799780845642,
0.23674149811267853,
0.07976537942886353,
0.24396198987960815,
-0.32734057307243347,
0.19057559967041016,
0.07685661315917969,
-0.13607639074325562,
-0.3778821527957916,
-0.026630304753780365,
0.322075217962265,
-0.5273674726486206,
0.14030101895332336,
-0.5174813866615295,
0.49800732731819153,
0.14074473083019257,
0.001120115164667368,
-0.05836990475654602,
0.12646883726119995,
-0.42269396781921387,
-0.002516774460673332,
-0.5406608581542969,
0.17610925436019897,
-0.5386331081390381,
-0.21271635591983795,
-0.13668206334114075,
-1.1732292175292969,
0.4922008514404297,
0.20832602679729462,
-0.16418059170246124,
0.6026598811149597,
0.5502991080284119,
0.04043501242995262,
0.49265256524086,
0.8228753209114075,
0.7009744644165039,
0.6106576919555664,
0.07982486486434937,
-0.048257116228342056,
-1.1547733545303345,
-0.12304491549730301,
-0.6357465982437134,
-0.016049180179834366,
-1.2414591312408447,
-0.004914257675409317,
-0.1740688532590866,
0.28402072191238403,
-0.4656653106212616,
0.7239760160446167,
-0.528197169303894,
0.49874794483184814,
0.5613610148429871,
0.06283684074878693,
0.3198544979095459,
-0.2179013043642044,
-0.11978967487812042,
0.35952502489089966,
-0.6167680025100708,
-0.39506298303604126,
0.7771031260490417,
-0.16832983493804932,
0.4649384915828705,
0.5137506127357483,
0.6875795722007751,
0.11369385570287704,
0.2961200177669525,
-0.963128387928009,
0.6400452256202698,
-0.4701215922832489,
-0.5562209486961365,
0.1809890866279602,
-0.17069530487060547,
-0.9909225106239319,
0.24199113249778748,
-0.23648153245449066,
-0.7515780329704285,
0.8132321834564209,
0.06085900589823723,
-0.6299141049385071,
-0.23921366035938263,
-0.8731152415275574,
0.7197099328041077,
-0.1276550441980362,
-0.6774787902832031,
-0.11660909652709961,
-0.3446391224861145,
0.5723000764846802,
0.2561662495136261,
0.1430356204509735,
-0.08198168873786926,
-0.1941400021314621,
0.3159545361995697,
-0.4782138764858246,
0.788029134273529,
0.13090983033180237,
-0.4379214346408844,
0.6902788877487183,
0.31390535831451416,
0.47325438261032104,
0.3637374937534332,
-0.0016723222797736526,
-0.4022352993488312,
-0.02608506567776203,
-0.21133841574192047,
-1.0107091665267944,
0.5875959992408752,
-0.044770076870918274,
-0.6821147203445435,
-0.4728277325630188,
-0.10734046250581741,
-0.1911400854587555,
0.3340916335582733,
-0.17513659596443176,
0.7253150939941406,
-0.05202602595090866,
0.3865048289299011,
0.17347033321857452,
-0.11844942718744278,
0.60326087474823,
0.5170881748199463,
-0.23766805231571198,
-0.6360002756118774,
0.9557688236236572,
-0.2813915014266968,
0.2424604296684265,
0.6601393222808838,
0.4025208652019501,
-0.5404691100120544,
0.15073177218437195,
-0.06581942737102509,
0.0051414030604064465,
-0.628456175327301,
-0.22246026992797852,
-0.3969467282295227,
-0.08015432208776474,
-0.2535710632801056,
-0.3732810616493225,
-0.005723074544221163,
-1.196976661682129,
-0.04610247164964676,
0.08257842063903809,
0.31888720393180847,
0.82353276014328,
-0.2194826602935791,
0.6401109099388123,
-0.5280653238296509,
0.4157525599002838,
0.6473790407180786,
0.5780165791511536,
-0.02832905389368534,
0.1050276979804039,
-0.013625129126012325,
0.030193479731678963,
-0.5407214164733887,
-0.38893696665763855,
-0.31219491362571716,
0.20977076888084412,
0.44100695848464966,
0.47801628708839417,
-0.17774470150470734,
1.0348563194274902,
-0.5595437288284302,
0.6639907360076904,
0.6533834934234619,
-1.1835134029388428,
0.1654631495475769,
-0.6388856768608093,
-0.14287179708480835,
0.31699150800704956,
-0.27115756273269653,
-0.7031921744346619,
-0.7288389205932617,
-1.067683219909668,
-0.42360720038414,
0.3467801809310913,
0.20313207805156708,
0.21154096722602844,
-0.3554840385913849,
0.22610072791576385,
0.28488689661026,
0.5534101128578186,
-0.8548030257225037,
0.01702113263309002,
-0.4416621923446655,
-0.03175002336502075,
-0.17697083950042725,
-0.37595152854919434,
0.10412318259477615,
-0.6577421426773071,
0.3682875633239746,
0.42767056822776794,
-0.014105250127613544,
0.1335105001926422,
0.0317685604095459,
0.01994066871702671,
0.7467028498649597,
0.7525492310523987,
0.4247698187828064,
-0.001595789915882051,
0.6140065789222717,
-0.4287668764591217,
-0.1588440090417862,
0.3789741098880768,
-0.19220198690891266,
0.06163901835680008,
-0.1448962688446045,
0.31994524598121643,
0.6920264363288879,
0.9476901888847351,
-0.5766580700874329,
0.2712782919406891,
0.2544354498386383,
-0.22903676331043243,
-0.3628287613391876,
0.37642693519592285,
-0.07922773063182831,
0.4293404221534729,
-0.012457124888896942,
0.10474041849374771,
0.4553551971912384,
-0.8172826766967773,
0.3481910526752472,
0.514802098274231,
-0.2134687900543213,
-0.45068633556365967,
0.2985736131668091,
0.10079778730869293,
-0.27323704957962036,
-0.13530384004116058,
-0.4630667269229889,
-0.6446582674980164,
0.6454653143882751,
0.7476497292518616,
1.0394706726074219,
-0.149978369474411,
0.47299155592918396,
0.48267874121665955,
0.2688750922679901,
-0.09053162485361099,
0.34573549032211304,
-0.5833445191383362,
-0.5993039608001709,
-0.256024032831192,
-0.763207733631134,
-0.5151320695877075,
0.09072411060333252,
-0.6251751184463501,
0.252130925655365,
-0.5774430632591248,
0.050517551600933075,
0.2865580916404724,
-0.07730931043624878,
-0.47201845049858093,
0.14251330494880676,
-0.3020826280117035,
0.4721413850784302,
-0.20963245630264282,
0.3569146990776062,
0.9013826251029968,
-0.3039347529411316,
-0.6888082027435303,
-0.2834082245826721,
-0.43528521060943604,
-0.6013447642326355,
0.6384820938110352,
-0.0076621645130217075,
-0.03495311737060547,
0.22223827242851257,
-0.3421963155269623,
-0.9094486236572266,
0.4108688533306122,
0.07393698394298553,
-0.17483749985694885,
0.3237244486808777,
0.19374802708625793,
0.6745287179946899,
-0.022646216675639153,
-0.24847222864627838,
0.2724408209323883,
0.8647208213806152,
0.13745830953121185,
-0.8713164925575256,
0.1908164620399475,
-0.37461310625076294,
-0.12239908427000046,
0.4390706717967987,
-0.5925343036651611,
1.1025844812393188,
0.18392455577850342,
-0.5425112843513489,
0.325629860162735,
0.46378907561302185,
-0.3096601665019989,
0.08633090555667877,
0.09729623794555664,
0.8881021738052368,
0.38868221640586853,
0.017650749534368515,
1.1227678060531616,
0.24129530787467957,
0.3531661033630371,
1.164036512374878,
-0.12426862865686417,
0.5139790177345276,
0.38656219840049744,
-0.32643842697143555,
0.6870551109313965,
0.5898151993751526,
0.23377837240695953,
0.27776089310646057,
0.10962282121181488,
-0.6581752300262451,
-0.7012817859649658,
-0.20593573153018951,
-0.32702329754829407,
0.7628517150878906,
0.41068997979164124,
0.1103108674287796,
-0.9457308053970337,
-0.016716353595256805,
-0.15036271512508392,
0.18165573477745056,
-0.5212551951408386,
0.8414050340652466,
0.04392334818840027,
-0.9320338368415833,
0.8036779761314392,
-0.17575997114181519,
0.5305452942848206,
-0.479510098695755,
-0.2347097247838974,
-0.05772015452384949,
0.26090461015701294,
-0.4495149850845337,
-0.7130619287490845,
0.2593969702720642,
-0.2117999643087387,
0.0006902813911437988,
0.045809704810380936,
0.33555707335472107,
-0.4306437075138092,
-0.7555118203163147,
0.022351328283548355,
0.3960167467594147,
-0.1530195027589798,
0.5827907919883728,
-0.11943341046571732,
-0.5116680264472961,
-0.40430012345314026,
0.116525799036026,
-0.06557849049568176,
0.5501466989517212,
-0.31288960576057434,
0.4098668098449707,
0.7439762949943542,
-0.005572741851210594,
0.4628940522670746,
-0.4290699064731598,
0.7576096057891846,
-0.606609046459198,
-0.4838451147079468,
-0.8318096995353699,
0.49294766783714294,
0.28346043825149536,
-0.22277770936489105,
0.881568431854248,
0.6518384218215942,
0.7436095476150513,
-0.1396171748638153,
0.7177134156227112,
-0.3538948595523834,
-0.08100949972867966,
-0.31290698051452637,
0.10102920979261398,
-0.9617079496383667,
-0.3010478913784027,
-0.5312754511833191,
-0.9400534629821777,
-0.6410455703735352,
0.4991055130958557,
0.01792326383292675,
-0.43496742844581604,
0.8414806723594666,
0.4428536295890808,
-0.18460987508296967,
0.04465377703309059,
0.21438780426979065,
-0.23507973551750183,
0.14549371600151062,
0.694141685962677,
1.1553491353988647,
-0.41076669096946716,
-0.0922502651810646,
-0.3922531008720398,
-0.41870179772377014,
-0.2118154913187027,
-0.9383158087730408,
-0.4728756844997406,
-0.6785802841186523,
-0.12141026556491852,
-0.01138595025986433,
-0.2959165871143341,
0.4874582588672638,
0.03994423896074295,
-0.6317906379699707,
-0.35628700256347656,
-0.7913439869880676,
0.5955179929733276,
-0.2604145109653473,
-0.26939237117767334,
0.2049625813961029,
-0.6269448399543762,
-0.7738054990768433,
0.2972884774208069,
0.40024274587631226,
0.4036957919597626,
-0.026121987029910088,
0.10453653335571289,
-0.1295204758644104,
0.21816374361515045,
1.0456936359405518,
0.49575522541999817,
-0.6997432112693787,
-0.43479278683662415,
-0.02923048473894596,
0.16604608297348022,
-0.0441884845495224,
0.965346097946167,
-0.8849753141403198,
0.45325344800949097,
0.39393821358680725,
0.32722941040992737,
-0.005791251081973314,
-0.01445471029728651,
0.1100890263915062,
-0.5421361923217773,
0.7962719798088074,
0.21397225558757782,
0.3378089666366577,
-0.19865016639232635,
-0.27977272868156433,
0.2843731939792633,
0.18442611396312714,
-0.12049593776464462,
-0.8311401009559631,
0.596138596534729,
-1.5151697397232056,
0.01618235372006893,
1.1666964292526245,
0.5330126285552979,
-0.294147253036499,
-0.13376428186893463,
0.006843854673206806,
0.34099963307380676,
-0.18484161794185638,
0.43813392519950867,
0.7605851888656616,
-0.11063171178102493,
0.1272316575050354,
-0.20661629736423492,
0.5633123517036438,
0.38589048385620117,
-0.9289960265159607,
0.17878331243991852,
0.7133705019950867,
-0.06475013494491577,
0.39064908027648926,
0.32936909794807434,
-0.15554554760456085,
0.6708731055259705,
0.022816862910985947,
-0.04945700615644455,
-0.07633966952562332,
-0.2530146539211273,
-0.07564437389373779,
0.004348255693912506,
-0.295879602432251,
-0.23241502046585083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16661v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16661v1
|
RLSF: Reinforcement Learning via Symbolic Feedback
| 2024-05-26T18:49:59 | 2024-05-26T18:49:59 |
Piyush Jha, Prithwish Jana, Arnav Arora, Vijay Ganesh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.LO
|
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have had a dramatic impact on
various sub-fields of AI, most notably on natural language understanding tasks.
However, there is widespread agreement that the logical reasoning capabilities
of contemporary LLMs are, at best, fragmentary (i.e., may work well on some
problem instances but fail dramatically on others). While traditional LLM
fine-tuning approaches (e.g., those that use human feedback) do address this
problem to some degree, they suffer from many issues, including unsound
black-box reward models, difficulties in collecting preference data, and sparse
scalar reward values.
To address these challenges, we propose a new training/fine-tuning paradigm
we refer to as Reinforcement Learning via Symbolic Feedback (RLSF), which is
aimed at enhancing the reasoning capabilities of LLMs. In the RLSF setting, the
LLM that is being trained/fine-tuned is considered as the RL agent, while the
environment is allowed access to reasoning or domain knowledge tools (e.g.,
solvers, algebra systems). Crucially, in RLSF, these reasoning tools can
provide feedback to the LLMs via poly-sized certificates (e.g., proofs), that
characterize errors in the LLM-generated object with respect to some
correctness specification. The ability of RLSF-based training/fine-tuning to
leverage certificate-generating symbolic tools enables sound fine-grained
(token-level) reward signals to LLMs, and thus addresses the limitations of
traditional reward models mentioned above. Via extensive evaluations, we show
that our RLSF-based fine-tuning of LLMs outperforms traditional approaches on
two different applications, namely, program synthesis from natural language
pseudo-code to programming language (C++) and solving the Game of 24.
|
[
-0.2544066905975342,
-0.8247703909873962,
0.45231854915618896,
0.1441800743341446,
-0.3200850784778595,
0.22849935293197632,
-0.49172157049179077,
-0.4717807471752167,
0.0656386986374855,
0.48047029972076416,
-0.9334991574287415,
-0.40597474575042725,
-0.6515443921089172,
0.26821598410606384,
-0.0487031415104866,
1.1924643516540527,
-0.14213404059410095,
0.14559613168239594,
-0.13050846755504608,
-0.16698847711086273,
-0.593806803226471,
-0.5446769595146179,
-1.0135221481323242,
-0.7365155816078186,
0.6561378836631775,
0.24102139472961426,
0.592475950717926,
0.7829464673995972,
0.3599853813648224,
0.2963716983795166,
-0.11265310645103455,
0.6610379219055176,
-0.5718464851379395,
0.27643319964408875,
-0.2868405282497406,
-0.6069220900535583,
-0.1466490626335144,
-0.02865656465291977,
0.6786527633666992,
0.1958145648241043,
-0.32369711995124817,
0.1485675722360611,
-0.0768318772315979,
0.9484726190567017,
-0.602729856967926,
0.5289792418479919,
-0.519749641418457,
0.508023738861084,
0.21583504974842072,
-0.5409156084060669,
-0.711097240447998,
-0.4021166265010834,
-0.0985988974571228,
-0.8323542475700378,
-0.05358413606882095,
0.045747071504592896,
0.8032203316688538,
0.7225508689880371,
-0.21143773198127747,
-0.19862164556980133,
-0.9872607588768005,
0.8782112002372742,
-0.6350516676902771,
0.46194738149642944,
0.3321511149406433,
0.35251250863075256,
-0.3855833411216736,
-0.47231394052505493,
-0.23407278954982758,
-0.5540800094604492,
-0.2160220891237259,
-0.03045475296676159,
0.17720860242843628,
0.14263679087162018,
0.34574079513549805,
-0.0028527609538286924,
-0.2621776759624481,
0.024707205593585968,
-0.3532053232192993,
-0.19558213651180267,
0.7861295938491821,
0.3247752785682678,
0.01985039934515953,
0.2825413942337036,
-0.26702752709388733,
-0.33863306045532227,
-0.8659533262252808,
0.2778146266937256,
0.26290974020957947,
0.5021876692771912,
-0.07420551776885986,
0.40221914649009705,
-0.2825680673122406,
0.8376770615577698,
0.11792029440402985,
-0.37483885884284973,
-0.06872165203094482,
-0.10624433308839798,
-0.11208589375019073,
0.14720332622528076,
0.547849714756012,
0.08520233631134033,
0.462812215089798,
-0.1361420452594757,
-0.7505846619606018,
0.2794826328754425,
0.2784026265144348,
-0.737407922744751,
-0.1721203476190567,
0.047841813415288925,
-0.3893864154815674,
-0.3771152198314667,
0.14172932505607605,
-0.21373820304870605,
-0.4878612756729126,
-0.8369720578193665,
0.3403193950653076,
-0.4438495337963104,
-0.1250791698694229,
0.17952412366867065,
-0.10134477913379669,
0.10534849017858505,
0.5076093673706055,
-0.9073663949966431,
0.2995070219039917,
0.9706235527992249,
0.5086111426353455,
-0.17351028323173523,
-0.5207694172859192,
-1.0127313137054443,
0.0016378100262954831,
-0.3452755808830261,
0.8019943237304688,
-0.5715709328651428,
-0.31750261783599854,
0.025893880054354668,
-0.10595113039016724,
-0.10844090580940247,
-0.7376999855041504,
0.17937715351581573,
-0.453616201877594,
-0.1516723781824112,
-0.19912689924240112,
-0.3557684123516083,
0.04354437068104744,
0.44132205843925476,
-0.3963072597980499,
1.0050145387649536,
-0.08679088205099106,
-0.4136866331100464,
0.37907934188842773,
-0.4571670889854431,
-0.5995267033576965,
-0.04937468096613884,
-0.3678470849990845,
-0.46245092153549194,
0.02596883475780487,
0.18565621972084045,
0.31578385829925537,
-0.16819798946380615,
0.307295560836792,
-0.3601416051387787,
-0.631080150604248,
0.35687536001205444,
-0.2825431227684021,
0.18692520260810852,
0.24893620610237122,
-0.34154728055000305,
0.6308887600898743,
-0.6660757064819336,
0.06731268763542175,
0.25641870498657227,
-0.4687136709690094,
-0.03994087129831314,
0.29362624883651733,
-0.15686281025409698,
0.28145572543144226,
0.14854508638381958,
-0.35628384351730347,
0.0502304844558239,
-0.6084195971488953,
0.5766555666923523,
0.9270934462547302,
0.07015601545572281,
0.222548246383667,
-0.506328284740448,
0.5814331769943237,
0.08479493856430054,
0.2417469471693039,
0.12604257464408875,
-0.06032722815871239,
-0.8262746930122375,
-0.16398832201957703,
0.2235061526298523,
0.4413519501686096,
-0.7063038945198059,
0.3140023946762085,
0.07495253533124924,
-0.2970922291278839,
-0.4189170002937317,
0.3039456307888031,
0.6367183923721313,
0.10982239246368408,
0.29201045632362366,
-0.2601379156112671,
-0.38815978169441223,
-0.6415979862213135,
-0.21675072610378265,
-0.38153544068336487,
0.32675477862358093,
0.4194101095199585,
0.43318992853164673,
-0.025639144703745842,
0.7847968935966492,
-0.3975663483142853,
-0.4938908815383911,
-0.4537007808685303,
0.0737723708152771,
-0.09280909597873688,
0.2640678882598877,
0.0731046050786972,
-0.4410451650619507,
-0.08625185489654541,
-0.029839886352419853,
-0.682065486907959,
0.16026411950588226,
-0.35790494084358215,
0.14644263684749603,
0.36071714758872986,
0.6396940350532532,
-0.5698478817939758,
0.1561359316110611,
0.21202966570854187,
-0.5196386575698853,
0.575151264667511,
-0.6084533333778381,
-0.12140228599309921,
-0.3966294825077057,
-0.2671903371810913,
0.05462419614195824,
-0.3274608254432678,
-0.1909063309431076,
0.25430768728256226,
0.06692434847354889,
0.0465899296104908,
-0.5786339640617371,
0.5485239028930664,
-0.21851731836795807,
-0.12535615265369415,
-0.33357784152030945,
0.2186669111251831,
-0.2616117596626282,
0.8464184999465942,
0.2725602090358734,
0.7044363021850586,
0.20796121656894684,
-0.6472663879394531,
0.40105247497558594,
0.04473700374364853,
0.11203165352344513,
0.6473347544670105,
-0.6840267777442932,
-0.054645225405693054,
-0.18685773015022278,
0.5719947218894958,
-0.4491179287433624,
0.12463918328285217,
0.3028598427772522,
-0.25181812047958374,
0.19765165448188782,
0.03280824422836304,
-0.5020252466201782,
-0.0675918310880661,
-0.25067204236984253,
0.31160759925842285,
0.38518890738487244,
-0.5696814656257629,
0.5838878154754639,
0.16490884125232697,
0.2312232255935669,
-0.6166282296180725,
-0.2670738399028778,
-0.1527475267648697,
-0.05135640501976013,
-0.2753193974494934,
-0.08600527048110962,
-0.01799706555902958,
-0.07610853761434555,
0.018444186076521873,
-0.244597926735878,
0.2776991128921509,
0.2873811423778534,
0.4925376772880554,
0.2593618929386139,
-0.11159513145685196,
0.23167622089385986,
0.029475266113877296,
-0.4556482136249542,
0.287883996963501,
-0.40871018171310425,
0.2895515561103821,
-0.5780308842658997,
-0.5564560890197754,
-0.30477383732795715,
-0.1269383430480957,
0.4475170075893402,
-0.5986244678497314,
0.6301965713500977,
0.5334405899047852,
-0.20165786147117615,
-0.8362215161323547,
-0.2684655785560608,
-0.6696994304656982,
-0.4220101237297058,
0.3894130289554596,
-0.21295985579490662,
-1.2425533533096313,
0.1329914778470993,
-0.20282047986984253,
0.2519150972366333,
0.25198468565940857,
0.6536240577697754,
0.08375200629234314,
1.2136523723602295,
0.48687365651130676,
-0.038651999086141586,
0.3488221764564514,
-0.14541515707969666,
0.16956841945648193,
-0.3883034884929657,
-0.42574217915534973,
-0.42977362871170044,
-0.449120432138443,
-0.4067617952823639,
-0.1529540866613388,
0.23157380521297455,
0.0650041401386261,
-0.5550163388252258,
0.10210239887237549,
-0.572180986404419,
0.6230632066726685,
0.5805856585502625,
0.33576613664627075,
0.39399170875549316,
-0.1801278293132782,
-0.24382159113883972,
0.1386893093585968,
-0.7801917195320129,
-0.29100313782691956,
0.7009073495864868,
0.5746251940727234,
0.9691014885902405,
-0.12210919708013535,
0.9376627206802368,
0.3602277934551239,
0.1952342540025711,
-0.7682384848594666,
0.6270459294319153,
-0.027685746550559998,
-0.17556126415729523,
-0.4803272485733032,
-0.4312334954738617,
-0.7744115591049194,
0.2705531418323517,
-0.4500923156738281,
-0.4745188355445862,
-0.20256322622299194,
0.4403526186943054,
-0.4770457148551941,
0.2226306051015854,
-0.5159345865249634,
0.8338673114776611,
-0.3171308934688568,
-0.31493905186653137,
-0.619424045085907,
-0.7230214476585388,
0.32690876722335815,
0.16358542442321777,
0.16438768804073334,
-0.10431254655122757,
0.2577744126319885,
0.6701578497886658,
-0.5054506659507751,
1.0364394187927246,
-0.19158923625946045,
-0.22814948856830597,
0.07083313167095184,
0.29193735122680664,
0.8352662920951843,
0.3977595269680023,
0.3245134949684143,
-0.29050594568252563,
0.4385828375816345,
-0.17634457349777222,
-0.8947245478630066,
0.6405039429664612,
-1.086937427520752,
-0.5540190935134888,
-0.6448614001274109,
-0.7528070211410522,
-0.3738977909088135,
-0.02780470810830593,
-0.27009329199790955,
0.30102184414863586,
0.06475576758384705,
-0.06013156473636627,
0.9837150573730469,
-0.22545510530471802,
0.10089743137359619,
0.5480120778083801,
-0.3985365927219391,
-0.3218327462673187,
1.2608875036239624,
-0.3186396658420563,
0.19191670417785645,
0.36016884446144104,
0.2011876404285431,
-0.3897021412849426,
-0.2958366274833679,
-0.5091806054115295,
0.4487045705318451,
-0.7825241088867188,
-0.22994472086429596,
-0.18857012689113617,
-0.4262116849422455,
0.12959539890289307,
-0.0955120101571083,
-0.4754004180431366,
-0.3392575979232788,
-0.23228906095027924,
-0.12393904477357864,
0.475829154253006,
0.9598888754844666,
-0.0036647829692810774,
-0.05877742916345596,
-0.7300602793693542,
0.23217354714870453,
0.22550304234027863,
0.5382627248764038,
0.11268580704927444,
-0.40172135829925537,
-0.26820191740989685,
-0.0008676344295963645,
-0.18948052823543549,
-0.5269880294799805,
0.105742909014225,
-0.0013679752591997385,
0.3878166675567627,
0.22884660959243774,
0.12104431539773941,
0.5368481278419495,
-0.33335867524147034,
0.6219444870948792,
0.15171749889850616,
-0.6795539855957031,
0.5324907302856445,
-0.12641966342926025,
0.172730952501297,
0.41586047410964966,
-0.09154094010591507,
-0.5778254270553589,
-0.691290020942688,
-0.5936412215232849,
-0.47741809487342834,
1.0021804571151733,
-0.10155029594898224,
-0.11803867667913437,
-0.02086731791496277,
0.3676672875881195,
-0.11520508676767349,
0.11220791190862656,
-0.758973240852356,
-0.2627606987953186,
-0.11250483989715576,
-0.05221707373857498,
-0.151044562458992,
-0.02667599730193615,
-0.35164377093315125,
-0.2732580900192261,
1.0463348627090454,
-0.19544926285743713,
0.14182835817337036,
0.09708613902330399,
-0.16257517039775848,
-0.43970638513565063,
0.35291966795921326,
0.9033056497573853,
0.4564954340457916,
-0.13366900384426117,
0.34141796827316284,
0.2947971224784851,
-0.07718580961227417,
0.3403405547142029,
-0.026373185217380524,
-0.18731990456581116,
-0.30485638976097107,
0.22589270770549774,
1.0682036876678467,
0.222026526927948,
-0.9925049543380737,
0.1921495497226715,
-0.16462263464927673,
-0.4323951303958893,
-0.22618255019187927,
0.4523029625415802,
0.09492635726928711,
0.4929603636264801,
-0.00009298081567976624,
-0.031119249761104584,
-0.3791714906692505,
-0.3312763273715973,
0.35273438692092896,
0.6360458731651306,
-0.7847201228141785,
-0.11754913628101349,
0.49645599722862244,
0.09506871551275253,
-0.49098074436187744,
0.5371251106262207,
-0.28751876950263977,
-0.5063470005989075,
0.5839301943778992,
0.7080608010292053,
0.7479017376899719,
0.29923924803733826,
0.44965383410453796,
0.2655787467956543,
0.3416447639465332,
-0.27705392241477966,
0.13761626183986664,
-0.273623526096344,
-0.5566940307617188,
-0.5665274262428284,
-0.6996505856513977,
-0.47132426500320435,
0.07233060896396637,
-0.4147116243839264,
0.01114611979573965,
-0.945433497428894,
0.04167100042104721,
-0.31551122665405273,
-0.0030231184791773558,
-0.2228998839855194,
0.19646002352237701,
0.09712247550487518,
0.8621497750282288,
-0.6637224555015564,
0.8323482871055603,
0.8475305438041687,
-0.4655623435974121,
-1.1783374547958374,
-0.3045639097690582,
0.03147127106785774,
-0.7622149586677551,
0.9045186638832092,
-0.1187216192483902,
-0.3933905065059662,
-0.08800976723432541,
-0.33879926800727844,
-0.578098475933075,
0.950154185295105,
0.4833665192127228,
-0.4909045696258545,
0.054028674960136414,
0.360042542219162,
0.7012621760368347,
-0.15249253809452057,
0.11960047483444214,
0.7332397103309631,
0.49184268712997437,
0.10863848775625229,
-0.7518565058708191,
0.2286004275083542,
-0.1394762247800827,
0.08970722556114197,
0.4941183626651764,
-0.6081074476242065,
0.38048070669174194,
-0.2792072892189026,
0.05098329111933708,
-0.06694278120994568,
0.8519191145896912,
0.7265055179595947,
0.08517138659954071,
0.6144024729728699,
0.6645563840866089,
0.49799808859825134,
-0.1490318775177002,
0.951677143573761,
-0.37306010723114014,
0.4627925455570221,
0.9964035153388977,
-0.13567911088466644,
0.8548725843429565,
0.6459121108055115,
-0.14067000150680542,
0.37420541048049927,
0.7285131216049194,
0.09612977504730225,
0.4643068015575409,
0.5319426655769348,
-0.1908506602048874,
-0.6414216756820679,
-0.18049177527427673,
-0.2730420231819153,
-0.017843902111053467,
0.24294587969779968,
-0.0526246502995491,
-0.5163267254829407,
-0.1303330361843109,
-0.29588863253593445,
0.2617679238319397,
-0.23798993229866028,
0.825303316116333,
0.2836857736110687,
-0.8840837478637695,
0.7386904954910278,
0.31799814105033875,
0.5944809913635254,
-0.7418479919433594,
-0.28968489170074463,
-0.23829931020736694,
0.5303479433059692,
-0.2883983552455902,
-0.6222476363182068,
0.3443949818611145,
-0.2515810430049896,
0.04756072163581848,
-0.3060092628002167,
0.760530412197113,
-0.3415970206260681,
-0.17582309246063232,
0.31618183851242065,
0.30941441655158997,
-0.20265910029411316,
0.20863227546215057,
-0.9501581788063049,
0.16449889540672302,
-0.0992005467414856,
-0.06272416561841965,
0.6002823710441589,
0.3782752752304077,
-0.14655965566635132,
0.8684658408164978,
0.7256752252578735,
0.18332703411579132,
-0.18989352881908417,
0.10611870884895325,
0.583203911781311,
-0.6169562935829163,
-0.6545901894569397,
-0.7945448160171509,
0.057467568665742874,
0.39472705125808716,
-0.39000484347343445,
0.3969530463218689,
0.2675587832927704,
0.996911346912384,
-0.16798514127731323,
0.5497177839279175,
0.3254145681858063,
0.17410258948802948,
-0.6491020321846008,
0.49497130513191223,
-0.5478713512420654,
0.4078379273414612,
-0.01945941522717476,
-0.6237233877182007,
-0.39075785875320435,
0.7029043436050415,
-0.16609415411949158,
-0.06966342031955719,
0.6152420043945312,
0.9224578142166138,
0.05418192595243454,
0.2331392765045166,
0.23087583482265472,
0.009764106944203377,
0.29703405499458313,
0.8051723837852478,
1.0612306594848633,
0.033882249146699905,
0.4518301784992218,
-0.26170021295547485,
0.02424434758722782,
-0.15234094858169556,
-0.7226261496543884,
-0.9427738785743713,
-0.4356248676776886,
-0.2966620624065399,
-0.5872148275375366,
0.4332314729690552,
1.4056371450424194,
0.5286798477172852,
-0.8707504868507385,
-0.41023606061935425,
-0.3237189054489136,
0.40606871247291565,
-0.5964915752410889,
-0.14696896076202393,
0.2352364957332611,
-0.7426187992095947,
-0.2955839931964874,
0.29875504970550537,
0.5031377077102661,
-0.20656946301460266,
-0.5284339189529419,
-0.762524425983429,
-0.016158495098352432,
0.11462215334177017,
0.6605290174484253,
0.5589005351066589,
-0.9382872581481934,
-0.456651896238327,
-0.045341264456510544,
-0.05850128084421158,
-0.12071184068918228,
0.8678568601608276,
-0.9685678482055664,
0.04701612889766693,
0.29313236474990845,
1.0406670570373535,
0.47806626558303833,
-0.25548118352890015,
0.5085994005203247,
-0.7209579944610596,
0.059862155467271805,
0.05065055936574936,
0.27223992347717285,
-0.012572643347084522,
-0.25122955441474915,
0.41982412338256836,
0.34209349751472473,
-0.4237436056137085,
-0.7796528935432434,
0.40774545073509216,
-0.9576950073242188,
-0.4017816185951233,
1.1951314210891724,
0.07507506757974625,
-0.12988419830799103,
0.06686076521873474,
-0.42470091581344604,
0.25154319405555725,
-0.5351858139038086,
0.8650495409965515,
0.481216162443161,
-0.19831131398677826,
-0.23766808211803436,
-0.162491112947464,
0.7439350485801697,
0.8432271480560303,
-0.8007344007492065,
0.2583770453929901,
0.5496041178703308,
0.19261017441749573,
-0.098285973072052,
0.45831072330474854,
-0.06683757156133652,
0.5575074553489685,
-0.43290621042251587,
-0.26128461956977844,
-0.5107041001319885,
-0.5866360068321228,
-0.4302299916744232,
0.1617724895477295,
0.6204124689102173,
0.14011520147323608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16640v1
|
A Survey of Multimodal Large Language Model from A Data-centric Perspective
| 2024-05-26T17:31:21 | 2024-05-26T17:31:21 |
Tianyi Bai, Hao Liang, Binwang Wan, Ling Yang, Bozhou Li, Yifan Wang, Bin Cui, Conghui He, Binhang Yuan, Wentao Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
Human beings perceive the world through diverse senses such as sight, smell,
hearing, and touch. Similarly, multimodal large language models (MLLMs) enhance
the capabilities of traditional large language models by integrating and
processing data from multiple modalities including text, vision, audio, video,
and 3D environments. Data plays a pivotal role in the development and
refinement of these models. In this survey, we comprehensively review the
literature on MLLMs from a data-centric perspective. Specifically, we explore
methods for preparing multimodal data during the pretraining and adaptation
phases of MLLMs. Additionally, we analyze the evaluation methods for datasets
and review benchmarks for evaluating MLLMs. Our survey also outlines potential
future research directions. This work aims to provide researchers with a
detailed understanding of the data-driven aspects of MLLMs, fostering further
exploration and innovation in this field.
|
[
-0.6542371511459351,
-0.7029439210891724,
0.4512461721897125,
0.17385490238666534,
0.11847952753305435,
0.014096579514443874,
-0.5188034176826477,
-0.3902572691440582,
-0.11045430600643158,
0.5385051369667053,
-0.5040668249130249,
-0.46824491024017334,
-0.314243882894516,
-0.036607775837183,
-0.23561371862888336,
0.8255366683006287,
0.09771950542926788,
0.2634753882884979,
-0.26163995265960693,
-0.31658297777175903,
-0.3629070818424225,
-1.0036574602127075,
-0.27525490522384644,
-0.1821247935295105,
0.7656471729278564,
0.19500964879989624,
0.4989226460456848,
0.25394368171691895,
0.35457801818847656,
0.3217903673648834,
0.09883323311805725,
0.07615005970001221,
-0.3440457880496979,
0.18421679735183716,
-0.14834783971309662,
-0.31964078545570374,
-0.3262266218662262,
0.036529798060655594,
0.6487755179405212,
0.9526621699333191,
-0.11392239481210709,
0.2031911313533783,
0.10066511482000351,
0.7909949421882629,
-0.6109116077423096,
0.18269884586334229,
-0.3413240313529968,
0.1312563419342041,
-0.328067809343338,
-0.11825506389141083,
-0.6060675978660583,
-0.0364377424120903,
0.2803928554058075,
-0.38156116008758545,
0.13973064720630646,
0.11030392348766327,
0.1032465249300003,
-0.0905429869890213,
-0.804380476474762,
-0.26470494270324707,
-0.9046176671981812,
1.0685930252075195,
-0.6061925292015076,
1.125855565071106,
0.3102448284626007,
0.2690703570842743,
-0.06097129359841347,
-0.5543140769004822,
-0.7208001017570496,
-0.3313393294811249,
-0.01702790893614292,
-0.07678646594285965,
0.18245938420295715,
-0.2002377063035965,
0.22218751907348633,
0.2944052219390869,
-0.7662521004676819,
0.14786531031131744,
-0.22718824446201324,
-0.14029386639595032,
0.7981504797935486,
0.38172855973243713,
0.2405565232038498,
-0.05468255653977394,
-0.37439605593681335,
-0.3142407238483429,
-0.4883711636066437,
0.07762674242258072,
0.2991361916065216,
0.34026965498924255,
-0.159853994846344,
0.5504029393196106,
-0.17280909419059753,
1.0943782329559326,
-0.32204246520996094,
-0.4517291188240051,
0.6511856913566589,
-0.7422589659690857,
-0.28165268898010254,
-0.23722781240940094,
0.6760302782058716,
0.5605345964431763,
0.3166949152946472,
0.017189299687743187,
-0.2879660725593567,
-0.14763374626636505,
0.18062855303287506,
-0.6759011745452881,
-0.015555476769804955,
0.3478797674179077,
-0.5828119516372681,
-0.05980038642883301,
-0.22077858448028564,
-0.8635123372077942,
-0.6469029784202576,
-0.8938804864883423,
0.19369280338287354,
-0.38540783524513245,
-0.5673216581344604,
0.20843131840229034,
0.12062434107065201,
-0.021566305309534073,
0.43937453627586365,
-0.848003089427948,
-0.06293965876102448,
0.3576233983039856,
0.4895568788051605,
-0.23741203546524048,
-0.5428782105445862,
-0.16673481464385986,
0.08763400465250015,
-0.23773065209388733,
0.46243366599082947,
-0.5126099586486816,
-0.27561047673225403,
0.1646720916032791,
0.0014528799802064896,
-0.14330452680587769,
-0.34120532870292664,
0.2974962890148163,
-0.4857403337955475,
0.4481365382671356,
-0.23038364946842194,
-0.2471068650484085,
-0.33175528049468994,
0.6465654373168945,
-0.8091352581977844,
0.7390177845954895,
0.06256652623414993,
-0.8443028926849365,
0.5787835717201233,
-0.6185502409934998,
-0.3832651674747467,
-0.22928830981254578,
-0.1685533970594406,
-0.13549822568893433,
0.188558891415596,
0.2904834747314453,
0.5895625948905945,
-0.28615111112594604,
0.38420549035072327,
-0.29252123832702637,
0.13510701060295105,
0.6648624539375305,
-0.6961735486984253,
0.6210335493087769,
0.4166194200515747,
0.1114603728055954,
0.28745439648628235,
-1.0145354270935059,
0.1613970845937729,
-0.0065902662463486195,
-0.43925878405570984,
-0.30995646119117737,
0.11232484877109528,
0.5931437611579895,
0.5979200601577759,
0.2799478769302368,
-0.5823392271995544,
0.11630313843488693,
-0.06428861618041992,
0.31420543789863586,
0.6253458261489868,
-0.3478271961212158,
0.3826098144054413,
-0.061333101242780685,
0.36027243733406067,
0.3902556002140045,
0.5262726545333862,
-0.4454462230205536,
-0.10372074693441391,
-0.6142102479934692,
-0.12933826446533203,
0.13876330852508545,
0.2700337767601013,
-0.914841890335083,
0.1950622797012329,
-0.17090560495853424,
-0.5928076505661011,
-0.459561824798584,
0.2893613874912262,
0.10476750880479813,
0.1804884523153305,
0.154558002948761,
-0.16371499001979828,
-0.658808171749115,
-0.9118814468383789,
0.14243106544017792,
0.03318040072917938,
0.06774908304214478,
0.36684495210647583,
0.2640530467033386,
-0.44131338596343994,
0.8869898319244385,
-0.32478222250938416,
-0.12858842313289642,
-0.3757138252258301,
-0.11138381063938141,
0.13913200795650482,
0.4156225025653839,
0.8020905256271362,
-1.1009899377822876,
-0.3403407037258148,
0.18599608540534973,
-0.7755767107009888,
0.29339301586151123,
0.09159715473651886,
0.1909080445766449,
0.2185909003019333,
0.3179018199443817,
-0.5206926465034485,
0.1899457424879074,
1.0225516557693481,
-0.35478490591049194,
0.5429092645645142,
-0.1524665504693985,
0.24985428154468536,
-0.9399052262306213,
0.31380459666252136,
-0.0861937552690506,
-0.07294857501983643,
-0.9108673930168152,
-0.01943906769156456,
-0.010919403284788132,
-0.0948309451341629,
-0.4367186427116394,
0.517826497554779,
-0.5954388380050659,
-0.19131644070148468,
-0.15598326921463013,
-0.053514447063207626,
0.10512150824069977,
0.38973268866539,
0.2996268570423126,
0.485379695892334,
0.670850932598114,
-0.5728540420532227,
0.6618421077728271,
0.09234554320573807,
-0.6684190034866333,
0.47006478905677795,
-0.4570949673652649,
0.10857786983251572,
-0.49632352590560913,
0.22872474789619446,
-0.8980520963668823,
-0.10059120506048203,
0.05857786908745766,
-0.19116951525211334,
0.1001172885298729,
0.19950266182422638,
-0.7022333145141602,
-0.42337849736213684,
-0.17580682039260864,
0.5260313749313354,
-0.0766095221042633,
-0.30135318636894226,
0.5469850301742554,
0.4843621253967285,
-0.2814911901950836,
-0.4519074261188507,
-0.5451661944389343,
0.15015573799610138,
-0.17756302654743195,
-0.3638819754123688,
-0.1993178427219391,
-0.3456745445728302,
-0.36960846185684204,
-0.37671440839767456,
0.4013562500476837,
-0.011669855564832687,
-0.11810939013957977,
0.2553388178348541,
0.3025643825531006,
-0.24222488701343536,
0.22942481935024261,
-0.5962866544723511,
0.05365028977394104,
-0.10033275187015533,
-0.08690983057022095,
0.8520183563232422,
0.053281668573617935,
-0.5301409959793091,
-0.15905317664146423,
0.5297742486000061,
0.9053065776824951,
-0.613524854183197,
0.835050642490387,
0.8430977463722229,
-0.1209971234202385,
0.10370805114507675,
-0.6560065150260925,
-0.04372537136077881,
-0.3782528340816498,
0.5064967274665833,
-0.4160236716270447,
-0.8829659819602966,
0.2613380551338196,
0.13295476138591766,
0.1571507453918457,
0.07646043598651886,
0.8064852356910706,
0.03751508146524429,
1.0956358909606934,
0.7476829886436462,
-0.1287529319524765,
0.6323086023330688,
0.051934510469436646,
0.21398130059242249,
-0.8247555494308472,
-0.48426687717437744,
-0.38585788011550903,
-0.2934281826019287,
-0.4230285584926605,
-0.4339387118816376,
0.4334125518798828,
-0.2152879536151886,
-0.14760583639144897,
0.01523967832326889,
-0.23193344473838806,
-0.04285169020295143,
0.26129281520843506,
-0.0038630927447229624,
0.2759785056114197,
0.003615147201344371,
-0.040771789848804474,
-0.17377245426177979,
-0.5128456354141235,
-0.39907869696617126,
1.2314039468765259,
0.5980190634727478,
0.8743572235107422,
0.13572093844413757,
0.06188428774476051,
-0.041218604892492294,
0.23082666099071503,
-0.6372414827346802,
0.33657121658325195,
-0.006418534554541111,
-0.8683300614356995,
-0.4530918300151825,
-0.32194289565086365,
-0.8807389140129089,
0.5009042620658875,
-0.3264986276626587,
-0.5511415600776672,
0.21538078784942627,
-0.01762755960226059,
-0.052540700882673264,
0.13803334534168243,
-0.7758730053901672,
0.8211622834205627,
-0.5794104933738708,
-0.268814355134964,
-0.18495984375476837,
-0.5935404896736145,
0.38249650597572327,
-0.3368668854236603,
0.5735278725624084,
-0.07395487278699875,
0.08011309057474136,
0.6033790111541748,
-0.0904141217470169,
0.652113139629364,
-0.3692239820957184,
-0.4807884097099304,
0.12036623060703278,
-0.18399976193904877,
0.23808909952640533,
-0.19005469977855682,
-0.0754975974559784,
0.1320854276418686,
0.10329408198595047,
-0.17519035935401917,
-0.5615612268447876,
0.6135624647140503,
-0.5485753417015076,
-0.2271249145269394,
-0.11385275423526764,
-0.9199780821800232,
-0.6669676303863525,
0.20853368937969208,
-0.13542719185352325,
0.6454955339431763,
-0.22027766704559326,
0.3927757740020752,
0.5029473304748535,
-0.42208847403526306,
0.6061842441558838,
0.6343663930892944,
-0.9257585406303406,
-0.223250150680542,
0.8473160266876221,
0.1638302057981491,
0.26211175322532654,
0.325102835893631,
0.01656488887965679,
-0.43694961071014404,
-0.6319293975830078,
-0.5282001495361328,
0.02729722484946251,
-0.48565423488616943,
0.19403593242168427,
-0.7487120032310486,
-0.11258559674024582,
-0.46123987436294556,
0.2324487268924713,
-0.5038577318191528,
0.0001921141956700012,
0.11904433369636536,
-0.023348351940512657,
0.321327269077301,
0.8595797419548035,
0.13097693026065826,
0.12775827944278717,
-0.8281123638153076,
0.2477644979953766,
0.3248383700847626,
0.5163977146148682,
0.26888400316238403,
-0.08117233961820602,
-0.4533599615097046,
0.2952464818954468,
0.15056392550468445,
-0.3441203832626343,
0.4078153967857361,
-0.11761889606714249,
0.6772928833961487,
0.4476899802684784,
-0.32106128334999084,
0.5145187377929688,
-0.6037150621414185,
0.8393034934997559,
0.385174423456192,
-0.5651362538337708,
0.30308353900909424,
-0.31509485840797424,
0.36129263043403625,
0.3796127736568451,
0.43600282073020935,
-0.6604156494140625,
0.11319756507873535,
-0.08537983149290085,
-0.6615484356880188,
0.47326815128326416,
-0.04915490373969078,
0.23626616597175598,
0.31370577216148376,
-0.30559635162353516,
0.2824411392211914,
0.47506824135780334,
-0.6601423025131226,
-0.09956644475460052,
-0.3107324540615082,
-0.20895570516586304,
-0.589941680431366,
-0.27938976883888245,
-0.037689026445150375,
-0.3060634732246399,
0.07680422812700272,
-0.12498048692941666,
-0.03911536931991577,
-0.2829694151878357,
-0.30204710364341736,
0.24535438418388367,
0.49712637066841125,
0.7716785073280334,
0.9544186592102051,
-0.08503125607967377,
0.2962040901184082,
-0.11983028799295425,
-0.6177300214767456,
0.1760033816099167,
-0.056885745376348495,
0.23778755962848663,
0.010610075667500496,
0.36375218629837036,
0.8456985950469971,
0.02241840399801731,
-0.9898750185966492,
0.5556514859199524,
-0.12805548310279846,
0.10965912789106369,
-0.24345946311950684,
-0.2674511671066284,
0.08457052707672119,
0.18061895668506622,
0.37036582827568054,
-0.05375531688332558,
0.01748768240213394,
-0.7402582764625549,
0.07732316106557846,
0.3823404312133789,
-0.2534099221229553,
-0.5170812010765076,
0.26232367753982544,
0.10604608058929443,
0.23276236653327942,
0.5277317762374878,
0.35098060965538025,
-0.2973892390727997,
0.12592650949954987,
0.5205340385437012,
0.346216082572937,
-0.44275251030921936,
-0.012258872389793396,
0.27884745597839355,
0.15110169351100922,
0.225131556391716,
0.32290080189704895,
-0.030125731602311134,
-0.9216167330741882,
-0.4516793489456177,
-0.8910372853279114,
-0.03713713958859444,
0.31826862692832947,
-0.6360799670219421,
0.103487029671669,
-0.3636576235294342,
-0.18938753008842468,
0.1306745558977127,
-0.2442695051431656,
-0.9075095057487488,
0.5960267782211304,
0.5302107334136963,
0.7231519222259521,
-0.8020519018173218,
0.9816007018089294,
0.6913437247276306,
-0.20535263419151306,
-0.5060664415359497,
-0.40433698892593384,
-0.09583352506160736,
-0.74235600233078,
0.8779736161231995,
-0.03337857127189636,
-0.0421966090798378,
-0.11495909094810486,
-0.5427985787391663,
-0.8756822347640991,
0.7785773277282715,
0.11073456704616547,
-0.6895056962966919,
-0.058334480971097946,
0.3764726519584656,
0.6086350679397583,
-0.45545342564582825,
0.1491338461637497,
0.5063042640686035,
0.7004624009132385,
-0.022146301344037056,
-1.0270946025848389,
-0.38288429379463196,
-0.3246621787548065,
0.19952727854251862,
0.06600851565599442,
-0.4640364944934845,
1.109030842781067,
0.04740208759903908,
-0.030268970876932144,
-0.30260199308395386,
0.3899077773094177,
0.20317219197750092,
0.20347806811332703,
0.6346889734268188,
0.41886407136917114,
0.37254777550697327,
0.20736941695213318,
0.9803697466850281,
-0.2377392053604126,
0.1746816486120224,
0.9484321475028992,
-0.6114712357521057,
0.8794668912887573,
0.7157768607139587,
-0.3608008027076721,
0.29175126552581787,
0.33334484696388245,
0.15756332874298096,
0.3865606188774109,
0.1334083527326584,
-0.25170356035232544,
-0.17266517877578735,
-0.42969387769699097,
-0.5141829252243042,
0.846531867980957,
0.5600325465202332,
-0.3620831370353699,
-0.17434829473495483,
0.6262581944465637,
-0.1180945485830307,
-0.141567200422287,
-0.3177196979522705,
0.7907935380935669,
-0.1566695123910904,
-0.377348929643631,
0.3882954716682434,
-0.06571795791387558,
0.6356205344200134,
-0.6326070427894592,
0.12845388054847717,
-0.012464746832847595,
0.1465451717376709,
-0.251014769077301,
-0.996429979801178,
0.11871252954006195,
-0.014295532368123531,
-0.4359370768070221,
-0.4134383499622345,
0.5356272459030151,
-0.5677096247673035,
-0.4387124478816986,
0.17532557249069214,
0.7765652537345886,
0.0058015333488583565,
-0.11973483115434647,
-0.49330830574035645,
0.5910875797271729,
0.09307991713285446,
-0.45707836747169495,
0.3869085907936096,
0.4912221431732178,
-0.11835681647062302,
0.7178484201431274,
0.7977219223976135,
-0.07905320823192596,
0.21595166623592377,
0.30736956000328064,
0.8957086205482483,
-0.747586727142334,
-0.21272525191307068,
-0.7067531943321228,
0.6303579211235046,
0.12803499400615692,
-0.1764216423034668,
0.9636522531509399,
0.6923688054084778,
0.7795882821083069,
-0.2910727262496948,
0.9349760413169861,
-0.07080220431089401,
0.6387351155281067,
-0.626387357711792,
0.7999652624130249,
-0.49667951464653015,
-0.24370263516902924,
-0.28839385509490967,
-0.981565535068512,
-0.21140798926353455,
0.27758312225341797,
-0.3053937554359436,
0.17895367741584778,
0.4345313608646393,
0.5800108909606934,
-0.07452073693275452,
0.009700451046228409,
0.5305262207984924,
0.19601456820964813,
0.33895620703697205,
0.3922973573207855,
1.089985728263855,
-0.1785840094089508,
0.14298808574676514,
-0.12238460034132004,
-0.01850106567144394,
-0.15320922434329987,
-0.6696788668632507,
-0.8312678933143616,
-0.9156525135040283,
0.12752898037433624,
0.1113794818520546,
-0.5011054873466492,
0.8008171319961548,
0.7410446405410767,
-0.7277939319610596,
-0.3613380491733551,
0.36641737818717957,
-0.2736761271953583,
0.141044020652771,
-0.1841581016778946,
0.16516628861427307,
-0.1309545338153839,
-0.7926154732704163,
0.34395551681518555,
0.29250359535217285,
0.20522862672805786,
-0.7911871075630188,
-0.06200237199664116,
-0.2927267551422119,
-0.24740943312644958,
1.2221672534942627,
-0.01365638431161642,
-0.6052712202072144,
-0.18683646619319916,
0.02834239788353443,
-0.22121989727020264,
-0.10131260007619858,
0.9574713110923767,
-0.6629554033279419,
0.6932675838470459,
0.366727739572525,
0.4712328612804413,
0.3614179193973541,
-0.2188616245985031,
0.591785728931427,
-0.5247508883476257,
0.5038076043128967,
0.09951046854257584,
0.29547691345214844,
0.6432090997695923,
0.014799549244344234,
0.25093814730644226,
0.04048429802060127,
-0.3441026210784912,
-0.794743001461029,
0.19921216368675232,
-1.0378750562667847,
-0.18423128128051758,
1.064361333847046,
0.00365738058462739,
-0.05303945392370224,
-0.18226498365402222,
-0.3876549005508423,
-0.1236264556646347,
0.08074918389320374,
0.310345858335495,
0.9181428551673889,
-0.10888130217790604,
-0.3920283913612366,
-0.7510861754417419,
0.2033233344554901,
0.056913912296295166,
-0.8092442750930786,
0.2572091221809387,
0.8321813344955444,
0.19152198731899261,
0.22087372839450836,
0.429652601480484,
-0.16234302520751953,
-0.1990392804145813,
-0.034080781042575836,
0.20634609460830688,
0.030647512525320053,
-0.4372071921825409,
-0.2964450418949127,
0.29805728793144226,
0.13006260991096497,
-0.06749900430440903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16635v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16635v1
|
Compressing Lengthy Context With UltraGist
| 2024-05-26T17:23:56 | 2024-05-26T17:23:56 |
Peitian Zhang, Zheng Liu, Shitao Xiao, Ninglu Shao, Qiwei Ye, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compressing lengthy context is a critical but technically challenging
problem. In this paper, we propose a new method called UltraGist, which is
distinguished for its high-quality compression of lengthy context due to the
innovative design of the compression and learning algorithm. UltraGist brings
forth the following important benefits. Firstly, it notably contributes to the
flexibility of compression, as it can be effectively learned to support a broad
range of context lengths and compression ratios. Secondly, it helps to produce
fine-grained compression for the lengthy context, where each small segment of
the context is progressively processed on top of a tailored cross-attention
mechanism. Thirdly, it makes the training process sample-efficient and thus
maximizes the use of training data. Finally, it facilitates the efficient
running of compression for dynamic context, as the compression result can be
progressively generated and hence incrementally updated. UltraGist is evaluated
on a wide variety of tasks associated with lengthy context, such as document QA
and summarization, few-shot learning, multi-session conversation, et al. Whilst
the existing methods fail to handle these challenging scenarios, our approach
is able to preserve a near-lossless compression performance throughout all the
evaluations. Our data, model, and code have been released at
\url{https://github.com/namespace-Pt/UltraGist}.
|
[
-0.3138396143913269,
-0.47679123282432556,
0.5548322796821594,
0.07245685160160065,
-0.5169087052345276,
0.10012056678533554,
-0.7316679358482361,
-0.5578957796096802,
0.1565554291009903,
0.2164308726787567,
-0.5219592452049255,
-0.39450085163116455,
-0.33447474241256714,
0.051657672971487045,
-0.30293649435043335,
0.8800565600395203,
-0.1473861187696457,
-0.27884629368782043,
-0.17013539373874664,
-0.3193986415863037,
-0.5000016689300537,
-0.6427905559539795,
-0.6073831915855408,
-0.41495123505592346,
0.25467801094055176,
0.3215540051460266,
0.15336734056472778,
0.4917842447757721,
0.21518264710903168,
0.2896924912929535,
-0.38392356038093567,
0.14974237978458405,
-0.8084574341773987,
0.5783883333206177,
0.02569887600839138,
0.027600914239883423,
-0.1469390094280243,
-0.2507154643535614,
0.841144859790802,
0.6638637185096741,
-0.2010946124792099,
0.4920491576194763,
0.4146186113357544,
0.7574328780174255,
-0.7500956654548645,
0.10467589646577835,
-0.19428075850009918,
0.25518494844436646,
-0.13804566860198975,
-0.6468983292579651,
-0.36822080612182617,
0.16129186749458313,
0.0032653866801410913,
-0.6839849948883057,
0.1344836950302124,
-0.23008257150650024,
0.47783228754997253,
0.5629494190216064,
-0.5006884932518005,
0.19210223853588104,
-0.875917911529541,
0.6398739218711853,
-0.36887383460998535,
0.6001948714256287,
0.003786435117945075,
0.7366786003112793,
-0.025787534192204475,
-0.9873380064964294,
-0.5263111591339111,
0.2177082598209381,
0.1758279949426651,
0.2071169912815094,
-0.1652425080537796,
0.07363531738519669,
0.2709448039531708,
0.1717909574508667,
-0.48555323481559753,
0.2470078319311142,
-0.2590169310569763,
-0.3169645667076111,
0.15578992664813995,
0.2983885705471039,
-0.218291774392128,
-0.16535550355911255,
-0.7015957832336426,
-0.3500465452671051,
-0.4657612442970276,
0.19842974841594696,
0.16670624911785126,
0.09717230498790741,
-0.14469419419765472,
0.2481810748577118,
-0.7409011721611023,
0.6894283890724182,
-0.19706426560878754,
-0.13391506671905518,
0.2716834843158722,
0.03320838510990143,
-0.267559677362442,
0.10183265060186386,
0.7058244943618774,
0.6274055242538452,
-0.2653312087059021,
-0.07527224719524384,
-0.31596097350120544,
0.09910313040018082,
0.11916959285736084,
-0.8388127088546753,
-0.06300703436136246,
0.2978608012199402,
-0.5231069922447205,
-0.15171043574810028,
-0.20188386738300323,
-1.0711822509765625,
-0.2543517053127289,
-0.4780435562133789,
0.23676706850528717,
-0.2846720516681671,
0.2836090326309204,
0.3136724829673767,
0.003530177753418684,
-0.03126732259988785,
0.31576699018478394,
-0.7165029048919678,
-0.025581227615475655,
0.5086439847946167,
0.7478577494621277,
-0.1179281696677208,
-0.08424992859363556,
-0.7776634693145752,
0.3792382478713989,
-0.04367228224873543,
1.0547953844070435,
-0.5261043906211853,
-0.4245155155658722,
0.07085301727056503,
-0.1376497894525528,
0.33332303166389465,
-0.4116320013999939,
0.860640287399292,
-0.2908005118370056,
0.12526723742485046,
0.18004369735717773,
-0.5302747488021851,
0.01771937496960163,
0.35885295271873474,
-0.5732108354568481,
1.148636817932129,
0.3375437259674072,
-0.7071825265884399,
0.27507397532463074,
-0.6067168712615967,
-0.19481481611728668,
0.38807085156440735,
-0.19295255839824677,
-0.22403405606746674,
0.2314341962337494,
0.3103405833244324,
0.6408267617225647,
-0.16108739376068115,
0.0927124172449112,
-0.16411373019218445,
-0.546162486076355,
0.1197885200381279,
-0.45577725768089294,
0.3242012560367584,
0.1723068356513977,
-0.35348325967788696,
0.14619947969913483,
-0.5861766934394836,
0.048130620270967484,
-0.06393624097108841,
-0.8209701776504517,
-0.21126240491867065,
-0.3176291882991791,
0.5302548408508301,
0.3122287392616272,
0.208908811211586,
-0.6734893321990967,
0.4831494688987732,
-0.1374344527721405,
0.2624933123588562,
0.9043756723403931,
0.02630706876516342,
0.2348237931728363,
-0.0025575533509254456,
0.5815702676773071,
-0.45625054836273193,
0.4340337812900543,
-0.08544887602329254,
0.1173575296998024,
-0.7942541837692261,
-0.2664341926574707,
0.6593953371047974,
0.2759479582309723,
-0.802015483379364,
0.4863246977329254,
-0.7566882371902466,
-0.3117391765117645,
-0.09219726920127869,
0.07839560508728027,
0.43291133642196655,
0.6318145990371704,
0.5307294726371765,
-0.4373832046985626,
-0.7422221899032593,
-0.46656012535095215,
-0.02056635171175003,
0.12890373170375824,
-0.07229316979646683,
0.43138277530670166,
0.24061046540737152,
-0.6449928283691406,
0.7626817226409912,
-0.6907813549041748,
-0.4767392873764038,
-0.33042293787002563,
0.38393545150756836,
0.1590552031993866,
0.6047185063362122,
0.47548094391822815,
-0.7240303754806519,
-0.5025742053985596,
-0.30356448888778687,
-0.7072138786315918,
-0.08278772979974747,
-0.29627156257629395,
-0.26386430859565735,
0.2609138488769531,
0.5404150485992432,
-0.6633517146110535,
0.4721151888370514,
0.530545711517334,
-0.07921851426362991,
0.5697939991950989,
-0.24788030982017517,
-0.04726727679371834,
-1.2421596050262451,
0.20556175708770752,
-0.15426722168922424,
-0.4145725965499878,
-0.5449506044387817,
0.2732636332511902,
0.11595935374498367,
-0.2930825352668762,
-0.7273730635643005,
0.6699376106262207,
-0.49846041202545166,
0.1661607325077057,
-0.30544209480285645,
-0.32206299901008606,
-0.20864306390285492,
0.6047792434692383,
0.10363483428955078,
0.5368109345436096,
0.5071995258331299,
-0.5872514247894287,
0.41977620124816895,
0.2600952088832855,
-0.46492576599121094,
0.5529206395149231,
-0.45526883006095886,
0.29711058735847473,
-0.09328390657901764,
0.9581265449523926,
-0.558784008026123,
-0.3628877103328705,
-0.025521207600831985,
-0.3347989320755005,
0.6037479639053345,
-0.24816656112670898,
-0.6973356604576111,
-0.359285831451416,
-0.44858062267303467,
0.6233636736869812,
0.5769471526145935,
-0.7047876119613647,
0.42791786789894104,
0.29912450909614563,
0.20588348805904388,
-0.6066701412200928,
-0.5588265061378479,
0.22196900844573975,
-0.3543523848056793,
-0.020839672535657883,
0.5065945982933044,
-0.2931843400001526,
0.3810657858848572,
-0.20613087713718414,
-0.7008932828903198,
0.02684919536113739,
0.05066521465778351,
0.36323586106300354,
0.025994468480348587,
0.2219320833683014,
-0.020436985418200493,
0.11173222213983536,
-0.40696313977241516,
-0.19786308705806732,
-0.5618748664855957,
0.6616591811180115,
0.2565031945705414,
0.06054209545254707,
-0.4487393796443939,
0.5618276596069336,
0.4622781276702881,
-0.011874675750732422,
0.44922158122062683,
0.760525643825531,
-0.34898310899734497,
-0.35767030715942383,
-0.4158194363117218,
-0.052253350615501404,
-0.4935653805732727,
0.13554246723651886,
-0.23261970281600952,
-1.2807434797286987,
0.3257010281085968,
-0.48833340406417847,
-0.09133633226156235,
0.36129558086395264,
0.38166818022727966,
-0.025708207860589027,
0.9595146179199219,
1.0396251678466797,
-0.1910226196050644,
0.6373499631881714,
-0.6430087685585022,
0.03884386643767357,
-1.274444818496704,
-0.31340116262435913,
-0.5095775723457336,
-0.39453673362731934,
-0.2177540808916092,
-0.5485800504684448,
0.8545693755149841,
0.047489266842603683,
0.14844654500484467,
0.2871943414211273,
-0.7613974213600159,
0.6336190700531006,
0.35632598400115967,
0.18111227452754974,
-0.1326591670513153,
0.12081428617238998,
-0.07100403308868408,
0.31266796588897705,
-0.6568055152893066,
-0.34815770387649536,
1.0543195009231567,
0.15401387214660645,
0.882658064365387,
0.09993910044431686,
0.9962948560714722,
0.24536196887493134,
-0.05411523953080177,
-0.9104626178741455,
0.6560224294662476,
0.05369219183921814,
-0.22007718682289124,
-0.23734189569950104,
-0.6090488433837891,
-1.1622648239135742,
-0.06969697028398514,
-0.327006459236145,
-0.8831279277801514,
0.31331825256347656,
0.14019623398780823,
-0.7224304676055908,
0.08738621324300766,
-0.19381898641586304,
0.6550196409225464,
-0.10232046991586685,
-0.5181138515472412,
-0.16113102436065674,
-1.1392167806625366,
-0.03091588243842125,
-0.1766364425420761,
-0.10699973255395889,
-0.037572212517261505,
-0.14559005200862885,
0.9682934284210205,
-0.14267677068710327,
0.7960120439529419,
-0.14660486578941345,
0.1606517732143402,
-0.05198381096124649,
-0.040745582431554794,
0.18415968120098114,
0.31592461466789246,
0.11276167631149292,
-0.007197135593742132,
-0.00046549009857699275,
-0.3918740749359131,
-0.699827253818512,
0.617638111114502,
-0.42802876234054565,
-0.2164996862411499,
-0.4523279070854187,
-0.741143524646759,
-0.184074267745018,
0.4797911047935486,
0.3696071207523346,
0.8528409600257874,
-0.25303250551223755,
0.30408984422683716,
0.6583998203277588,
-0.0626322403550148,
0.6792586445808411,
0.3682989180088043,
0.3626698851585388,
-0.3561267554759979,
0.6793037056922913,
-0.2682991921901703,
-0.2609822452068329,
0.6534242630004883,
0.18436294794082642,
-0.34052300453186035,
-0.6322130560874939,
-0.3538246154785156,
-0.10175879299640656,
-0.9632881283760071,
-0.6009243726730347,
-0.6846886277198792,
0.04196649417281151,
-0.53891921043396,
-0.22902067005634308,
-0.3271641731262207,
-0.5696125626564026,
-0.2611093521118164,
0.2241758555173874,
-0.04574228450655937,
0.4656441807746887,
0.024614037945866585,
0.14602677524089813,
-1.1037155389785767,
0.4248913824558258,
0.4226062595844269,
0.3024021089076996,
-0.2151636779308319,
-0.3421540856361389,
-0.6118761897087097,
-0.22444619238376617,
-0.3045627474784851,
-0.6753755807876587,
0.30744314193725586,
0.48839855194091797,
0.6284566521644592,
0.46847763657569885,
0.4232051968574524,
0.8153724074363708,
-0.43345025181770325,
0.7540206909179688,
0.026813829317688942,
-0.7073796987533569,
0.33796772360801697,
-0.15996040403842926,
0.6851060390472412,
0.9997619390487671,
0.501828670501709,
-0.5442823171615601,
-0.05451630800962448,
-0.4973480701446533,
-1.2306891679763794,
0.3210376799106598,
0.05599023401737213,
0.19347791373729706,
0.18746107816696167,
0.5424541234970093,
0.03472288325428963,
0.12426243722438812,
-0.37392860651016235,
0.03440510109066963,
-0.08227741718292236,
-0.2693668603897095,
-0.30817294120788574,
-0.5220428705215454,
-0.39603137969970703,
-0.4902722239494324,
0.5555756688117981,
-0.5926100611686707,
0.4992481470108032,
0.2885850965976715,
-0.3376571238040924,
0.09360380470752716,
0.44979751110076904,
0.574701726436615,
0.5682225823402405,
-0.3068462014198303,
0.29204052686691284,
0.09890548884868622,
-0.23348554968833923,
0.1550644189119339,
0.5325440764427185,
0.19197779893875122,
-0.05332084745168686,
0.4431976079940796,
0.8276157379150391,
0.28266289830207825,
-0.9023405313491821,
0.5280759334564209,
-0.2898535132408142,
-0.06907645612955093,
-0.27053090929985046,
-0.21438290178775787,
-0.383401483297348,
0.3364696204662323,
0.3126203417778015,
-0.031841475516557693,
0.4793548583984375,
-0.4700554609298706,
0.09479235112667084,
0.18501892685890198,
-0.3885667622089386,
-0.05346201732754707,
0.601301372051239,
0.2062402367591858,
0.1940491646528244,
0.5164897441864014,
-0.11492175608873367,
-0.9000035524368286,
0.0842282846570015,
0.40403491258621216,
0.8189008235931396,
-0.0762193575501442,
-0.11291157454252243,
0.04558715224266052,
-0.1774599403142929,
-0.16883648931980133,
0.20794038474559784,
-0.8576353192329407,
-0.20665577054023743,
-0.5359613299369812,
-0.7887843251228333,
-0.4268101155757904,
-0.057534363120794296,
-0.6259440183639526,
0.0011497882660478354,
-0.10953422635793686,
-0.11944349855184555,
-0.14197471737861633,
0.08638427406549454,
-0.4753327965736389,
0.2922389805316925,
0.26058265566825867,
1.109399676322937,
-0.5994841456413269,
0.9297430515289307,
0.8246229887008667,
0.00657289382070303,
-0.8083385229110718,
0.23132754862308502,
0.06856224685907364,
-0.27984490990638733,
0.398776650428772,
0.6531484127044678,
-0.12134217470884323,
-0.10274638235569,
-0.3254047930240631,
-0.5432159304618835,
1.0372669696807861,
0.4072135388851166,
-0.5188368558883667,
-0.06151436269283295,
0.031604524701833725,
0.7157689929008484,
-0.16616031527519226,
0.044243741780519485,
0.3784710168838501,
0.3138652741909027,
0.04124876484274864,
-0.8033527135848999,
0.2676181197166443,
-0.4850975573062897,
0.23481673002243042,
0.5007482767105103,
-0.6148163676261902,
0.3521903157234192,
0.2156062126159668,
-0.22321471571922302,
0.3299655616283417,
0.6395547389984131,
-0.0669841542840004,
0.24346157908439636,
0.6328319311141968,
0.8211730122566223,
0.4630783200263977,
0.09888872504234314,
1.0017716884613037,
-0.6454932689666748,
0.7486445307731628,
1.1410361528396606,
-0.09486997872591019,
0.7467239499092102,
0.5771581530570984,
0.31838667392730713,
0.5423224568367004,
0.834714412689209,
0.07403259724378586,
0.5428562164306641,
0.15568794310092926,
-0.564620852470398,
-0.2630740702152252,
-0.3450110852718353,
-0.34035664796829224,
0.6056966781616211,
0.04248029738664627,
-0.1133425235748291,
-0.1495361477136612,
0.17297638952732086,
0.015289239585399628,
-0.21236556768417358,
-0.05458787456154823,
0.6678253412246704,
-0.0706116259098053,
-0.6021878719329834,
0.875294029712677,
-0.09917264431715012,
0.7837831974029541,
-0.4592161476612091,
0.006770578678697348,
-0.1287347823381424,
0.07456119358539581,
-0.2079000622034073,
-0.6604055762290955,
0.1558663696050644,
-0.16108380258083344,
0.1056264117360115,
-0.5508889555931091,
0.6709551215171814,
-0.33348849415779114,
-0.0636085644364357,
0.1015581488609314,
0.23698142170906067,
0.1312127560377121,
-0.14160209894180298,
-0.48947447538375854,
0.21190690994262695,
-0.3024917542934418,
-0.4550650119781494,
0.3710232675075531,
0.26632121205329895,
-0.0014961666893213987,
0.47134050726890564,
0.7383900880813599,
-0.06752298027276993,
-0.26156097650527954,
-0.07987874001264572,
1.2595391273498535,
-0.5808132886886597,
-0.7326979041099548,
-0.5237705707550049,
0.4769912362098694,
-0.1618620902299881,
-0.4026395082473755,
0.45094573497772217,
0.8223442435264587,
0.7680466771125793,
0.185593843460083,
0.444792777299881,
-0.03738236799836159,
0.1361248940229416,
-0.717629611492157,
0.6207420825958252,
-0.7689382433891296,
0.24704501032829285,
-0.1572650820016861,
-0.912375807762146,
-0.5389875173568726,
0.2366458773612976,
0.2930831015110016,
-0.12904812395572662,
0.9256367087364197,
0.3038742244243622,
-0.45665544271469116,
-0.3103780150413513,
0.09520410001277924,
-0.06484203785657883,
0.34628286957740784,
0.9330241680145264,
0.6589354276657104,
-0.0860753282904625,
0.7652217149734497,
-0.6514385938644409,
-0.39068639278411865,
-0.2618178725242615,
-0.8978581428527832,
-0.8023570775985718,
-0.6645203828811646,
-0.1496456414461136,
-0.23067964613437653,
0.03649211302399635,
0.9290423393249512,
1.2275274991989136,
-0.1727304309606552,
-0.10879567265510559,
0.17549481987953186,
-0.34980496764183044,
-0.3265499770641327,
-0.2043348103761673,
0.4058879613876343,
-0.06396698206663132,
-0.6581091284751892,
0.6677239537239075,
0.27798596024513245,
0.054737914353609085,
-0.05734497308731079,
-0.017653385177254677,
0.16325686872005463,
-0.1846148520708084,
0.7314244508743286,
0.41503268480300903,
-0.07697700709104538,
-0.30599507689476013,
-0.41959354281425476,
0.1558232456445694,
0.10173295438289642,
0.9907705187797546,
-1.1384217739105225,
0.5850533246994019,
0.6817065477371216,
0.6958615183830261,
0.8358334898948669,
-0.07400468736886978,
0.4284076988697052,
-0.9482058882713318,
0.44310876727104187,
0.3166731894016266,
0.4773871600627899,
0.37025246024131775,
-0.6066644787788391,
0.7615982890129089,
0.06447229534387589,
-0.7432903051376343,
-1.0712440013885498,
0.28439706563949585,
-1.4764807224273682,
-0.29645660519599915,
1.0670489072799683,
-0.22727039456367493,
-0.24201905727386475,
0.14029893279075623,
-0.22880332171916962,
0.6942150592803955,
-0.5811972618103027,
0.7816693782806396,
0.11287546157836914,
-0.5810455083847046,
-0.11908861249685287,
-0.5491475462913513,
0.45967423915863037,
0.4845501780509949,
-0.8074920177459717,
-0.06621406972408295,
0.5924185514450073,
0.06901675462722778,
0.17698338627815247,
0.3691151440143585,
0.06113617867231369,
0.45444828271865845,
-0.48970556259155273,
0.12189041823148727,
-0.1675543487071991,
-0.4751878082752228,
-0.711820125579834,
0.33643606305122375,
-0.27842044830322266,
-0.06312017142772675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16631v1
|
Let Silence Speak: Enhancing Fake News Detection with Generated Comments from Large Language Models
| 2024-05-26T17:09:23 | 2024-05-26T17:09:23 |
Qiong Nan, Qiang Sheng, Juan Cao, Beizhe Hu, Danding Wang, Jintao Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Fake news detection plays a crucial role in protecting social media users and
maintaining a healthy news ecosystem. Among existing works, comment-based fake
news detection methods are empirically shown as promising because comments
could reflect users' opinions, stances, and emotions and deepen models'
understanding of fake news. Unfortunately, due to exposure bias and users'
different willingness to comment, it is not easy to obtain diverse comments in
reality, especially for early detection scenarios. Without obtaining the
comments from the ``silent'' users, the perceived opinions may be incomplete,
subsequently affecting news veracity judgment. In this paper, we explore the
possibility of finding an alternative source of comments to guarantee the
availability of diverse comments, especially those from silent users.
Specifically, we propose to adopt large language models (LLMs) as a user
simulator and comment generator, and design GenFEND, a generated
feedback-enhanced detection framework, which generates comments by prompting
LLMs with diverse user profiles and aggregating generated comments from
multiple subpopulation groups. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of
GenFEND and further analysis shows that the generated comments cover more
diverse users and could even be more effective than actual comments.
|
[
-0.4985843598842621,
-0.8034371137619019,
0.7200732827186584,
0.2623165249824524,
-0.47292831540107727,
0.17796660959720612,
-0.3886210322380066,
-0.5234547853469849,
0.2913817763328552,
0.3489219844341278,
-0.6211779713630676,
-0.5987712144851685,
-0.39137503504753113,
0.07722524553537369,
-0.5088396072387695,
0.9428433775901794,
0.29544106125831604,
0.21495486795902252,
0.038651350885629654,
-0.021719705313444138,
-0.08285561949014664,
-0.46815335750579834,
-0.3121531009674072,
-0.0367930568754673,
0.4662189483642578,
0.31488311290740967,
0.5245294570922852,
0.19802679121494293,
-0.18162570893764496,
0.24730776250362396,
-0.06846879422664642,
0.1908094882965088,
-0.40526407957077026,
0.25520744919776917,
-0.3152634799480438,
-0.13718250393867493,
-0.21847788989543915,
-0.12628775835037231,
0.6386626958847046,
0.43145546317100525,
-0.06902078539133072,
0.03139983117580414,
0.22126059234142303,
-0.07611189782619476,
-0.4780239760875702,
-0.06473055481910706,
-0.4392605423927307,
0.08353429287672043,
-0.03628503903746605,
0.13609226047992706,
-0.41244402527809143,
-0.4887152910232544,
-0.042139798402786255,
-0.46625226736068726,
0.4312277138233185,
-0.16584986448287964,
0.7646967172622681,
-0.012971889227628708,
-0.20001129806041718,
-0.08928950130939484,
-0.9370841979980469,
0.7095158100128174,
-1.0361493825912476,
0.39953625202178955,
0.11978080868721008,
0.14713208377361298,
-0.11799901723861694,
-0.48557794094085693,
-0.845249593257904,
-0.5607380270957947,
-0.057140979915857315,
0.2844538688659668,
-0.3041559159755707,
-0.1135866716504097,
0.3591451346874237,
0.09199533611536026,
-0.2989913821220398,
0.04104112833738327,
-0.24437321722507477,
-0.30355533957481384,
0.6635554432868958,
-0.3093678057193756,
0.30146610736846924,
-0.3104744851589203,
-0.13420067727565765,
0.15926696360111237,
-0.46965205669403076,
-0.37414708733558655,
0.7320178151130676,
0.43649137020111084,
-0.31641271710395813,
0.3517756164073944,
-0.6017874479293823,
0.42905935645103455,
-0.014285906217992306,
-0.21557879447937012,
0.32757332921028137,
-0.1086200624704361,
-0.011875801719725132,
-0.23491810262203217,
0.8888457417488098,
0.20766085386276245,
0.25314053893089294,
0.03284989297389984,
-0.08217878639698029,
0.15234267711639404,
0.1477750688791275,
-1.1363532543182373,
-0.1685687005519867,
-0.10791488736867905,
-0.6652956604957581,
-0.7236436009407043,
0.35023415088653564,
-1.0885975360870361,
-0.8558534383773804,
-0.17179396748542786,
0.26009511947631836,
-0.14227332174777985,
-0.6860228180885315,
-0.19629661738872528,
-0.17150649428367615,
-0.14650894701480865,
0.6654744148254395,
-0.42038047313690186,
0.4242578148841858,
0.47407329082489014,
0.6898052096366882,
0.057500630617141724,
0.15172457695007324,
-0.8643128871917725,
-0.00699241179972887,
-0.58503258228302,
0.76815265417099,
-0.6935660243034363,
-0.398882657289505,
0.20293724536895752,
0.06970459967851639,
0.47511330246925354,
-0.5301976203918457,
0.785237193107605,
-0.3304058611392975,
0.19858789443969727,
-0.44939449429512024,
-0.20552176237106323,
-0.21999722719192505,
0.23068158328533173,
-0.5353715419769287,
0.6552506685256958,
0.1466851681470871,
-0.7143542170524597,
0.49206018447875977,
-0.4018646478652954,
-0.6068847179412842,
0.39983317255973816,
-0.24435199797153473,
-0.30044832825660706,
0.26225146651268005,
0.4766791760921478,
0.18368664383888245,
0.006155604496598244,
0.18127848207950592,
-0.6850267052650452,
-0.031631141901016235,
0.3687799870967865,
-0.5572500228881836,
0.6704353094100952,
0.35972359776496887,
-0.5260961055755615,
0.1968674510717392,
-0.4179046154022217,
-0.06089957058429718,
-0.16561757028102875,
-0.36152005195617676,
-0.1299646496772766,
-0.026557667180895805,
0.14805135130882263,
0.24084924161434174,
-0.25525352358818054,
-0.8572368025779724,
-0.06832925975322723,
-0.4318157136440277,
-0.09902440011501312,
0.7579817175865173,
0.197433203458786,
0.17742082476615906,
-0.2607124447822571,
0.6462485194206238,
0.18281273543834686,
0.31548434495925903,
-0.30883753299713135,
-0.37383899092674255,
-0.8132075667381287,
-0.4727656841278076,
0.36338332295417786,
0.35414138436317444,
-0.7894152998924255,
0.061620812863111496,
-0.11509721726179123,
-0.15195298194885254,
-0.7202427387237549,
0.4946090579032898,
0.2752494215965271,
0.22199608385562897,
-0.04489365965127945,
-0.14793264865875244,
-0.9590931534767151,
-0.8364796042442322,
-0.35407957434654236,
-0.2912418842315674,
-0.13828690350055695,
0.16015732288360596,
0.29957735538482666,
-0.23341862857341766,
0.8193274140357971,
-0.25342318415641785,
-0.16655191779136658,
-0.3288026750087738,
-0.06251455843448639,
-0.033306438475847244,
0.10366161167621613,
0.38811174035072327,
-0.6623550653457642,
-0.6869838833808899,
0.025959821417927742,
-0.8389185667037964,
-0.4706321954727173,
-0.14244282245635986,
-0.06808487325906754,
0.2769598960876465,
0.7695977091789246,
-0.712361216545105,
0.4401620328426361,
0.5867455005645752,
0.08862307667732239,
0.3529812693595886,
0.40261709690093994,
0.22695989906787872,
-1.0475090742111206,
-0.1258440911769867,
-0.003101987997069955,
-0.6405447125434875,
-0.5407376289367676,
0.11846937239170074,
-0.3225971758365631,
-0.16319499909877777,
-0.3381326496601105,
0.6537211537361145,
-0.5851863026618958,
0.2294367402791977,
-0.49830666184425354,
0.12577949464321136,
-0.042195964604616165,
0.09348830580711365,
-0.019738968461751938,
0.5059796571731567,
0.44831517338752747,
-0.3957701325416565,
0.321207731962204,
-0.0313585139811039,
-0.49453482031822205,
0.5231276750564575,
-0.638861894607544,
0.11001738160848618,
-0.14737635850906372,
0.6003546118736267,
-0.8022703528404236,
-0.6871916055679321,
0.4250091016292572,
-0.8311582803726196,
-0.06829090416431427,
-0.38748887181282043,
-0.8282026052474976,
-0.4574981927871704,
-0.5445078015327454,
-0.01815815083682537,
0.5689554810523987,
-0.4917815327644348,
0.6938521862030029,
0.5071573257446289,
-0.31372421979904175,
-0.2820627987384796,
-0.6315857768058777,
0.2664963901042938,
0.149696946144104,
-0.7025375962257385,
-0.16837885975837708,
-0.2455301433801651,
-0.6133931875228882,
0.1339699625968933,
0.013432496227324009,
0.24819904565811157,
-0.14537104964256287,
0.4686296880245209,
-0.02611619420349598,
-0.32580330967903137,
0.4147559106349945,
0.11533834040164948,
0.2931564748287201,
-0.16371947526931763,
-0.1561853289604187,
0.6731617450714111,
-0.11091289669275284,
-0.573962390422821,
-0.3616192638874054,
0.6794180274009705,
0.6927206516265869,
0.08288951218128204,
0.8089552521705627,
0.5301982760429382,
-0.39801934361457825,
-0.8427287936210632,
-0.7966128587722778,
-0.4738682806491852,
-0.471916139125824,
0.2610310912132263,
0.03557803854346275,
-1.1440688371658325,
0.44600537419319153,
-0.13150614500045776,
0.01028646994382143,
0.3417151868343353,
0.8122724890708923,
0.13773126900196075,
1.2072635889053345,
0.7054586410522461,
-0.06448592990636826,
0.4199642837047577,
0.2808627486228943,
0.3497207760810852,
-0.4026571214199066,
-0.2024494707584381,
-0.31417903304100037,
-0.04601442813873291,
-0.43916231393814087,
-0.4192567765712738,
0.2708055078983307,
-0.01955038495361805,
0.07528591901063919,
-0.06646645814180374,
-0.3768081068992615,
0.3668244183063507,
0.43997621536254883,
0.39090797305107117,
0.3191283047199249,
0.2809813320636749,
-0.08114618808031082,
-0.07354532182216644,
-0.5317594408988953,
-0.27799248695373535,
0.9086798429489136,
0.39464080333709717,
0.7061593532562256,
0.14904926717281342,
0.6398155093193054,
0.6089820861816406,
1.0118743181228638,
-0.6980082988739014,
0.615113377571106,
-0.004674315918236971,
-0.6922630667686462,
-0.05279340595006943,
-0.3640114367008209,
-0.44352880120277405,
0.5176923274993896,
-0.13817821443080902,
-0.6103708744049072,
0.22833268344402313,
0.16700482368469238,
-0.420156329870224,
0.493085652589798,
-0.6710083484649658,
0.39436250925064087,
0.12673811614513397,
-0.35191383957862854,
-0.26446422934532166,
-0.25576844811439514,
0.5934377312660217,
-0.14732278883457184,
0.4570489227771759,
-0.10319637507200241,
0.347868949174881,
0.48662710189819336,
-0.7505728006362915,
1.23546302318573,
-0.24217301607131958,
-0.23771265149116516,
0.47573935985565186,
-0.03773290663957596,
0.4258959889411926,
0.19280797243118286,
-0.15254294872283936,
0.12789946794509888,
-0.6625994443893433,
-0.04044481739401817,
-0.136060431599617,
0.9233749508857727,
-0.5998244285583496,
-0.8515539169311523,
-0.2023186832666397,
-0.39752817153930664,
-0.1677388697862625,
0.34519681334495544,
0.3076096475124359,
0.18930700421333313,
-0.5297284722328186,
0.24000464379787445,
0.6446701288223267,
-0.2309611737728119,
0.4661044180393219,
0.7483773231506348,
-0.43063753843307495,
-0.5892791748046875,
0.499468594789505,
0.22401121258735657,
0.10497532784938812,
-0.2132694125175476,
0.20219852030277252,
-0.2918282747268677,
-0.15138179063796997,
-0.49477705359458923,
0.3457487225532532,
-0.826696515083313,
-0.2880164682865143,
-0.7850428819656372,
-0.3471108376979828,
-0.6666563153266907,
0.05685265734791756,
-0.13230738043785095,
-0.15430836379528046,
-0.18514741957187653,
-0.3781742751598358,
0.3803744316101074,
0.5446963906288147,
-0.47180619835853577,
0.4246104955673218,
-0.49842286109924316,
0.6763826608657837,
0.5430478453636169,
0.46703702211380005,
0.18628565967082977,
-0.7145026326179504,
-0.19432778656482697,
0.2147156298160553,
-0.08716362714767456,
-1.069110631942749,
0.34468919038772583,
-0.07645773887634277,
0.4725775122642517,
0.512739360332489,
0.399921178817749,
0.2757558822631836,
-0.22631624341011047,
0.6201528906822205,
0.14324826002120972,
-0.8806545734405518,
0.6322652697563171,
-0.5301313996315002,
0.2227666974067688,
0.2471594512462616,
0.06467094272375107,
-0.40632492303848267,
-0.7673478722572327,
-0.5755022168159485,
-0.6011243462562561,
0.5316708087921143,
0.13592743873596191,
0.695802628993988,
0.027783051133155823,
-0.21861718595027924,
0.22134025394916534,
0.3417847454547882,
-1.0374315977096558,
0.18056689202785492,
-0.3108243942260742,
0.012846335768699646,
0.36084267497062683,
-0.558746874332428,
-0.25511059165000916,
-0.33207905292510986,
0.7315047979354858,
-0.008351550437510014,
-0.07383663207292557,
0.19405971467494965,
0.018338479101657867,
-0.39779871702194214,
0.4940406382083893,
0.5979852080345154,
0.4987350404262543,
0.024044370278716087,
0.23598262667655945,
0.12595708668231964,
-0.3530455529689789,
-0.09256840497255325,
0.0946352481842041,
-0.6795725226402283,
0.6091038584709167,
0.1630258560180664,
0.7556302547454834,
-0.07572227716445923,
-0.564031183719635,
0.7375014424324036,
0.2032662034034729,
-0.19942322373390198,
-0.47302666306495667,
0.05340816080570221,
0.2626197338104248,
0.26728445291519165,
0.438928484916687,
0.2129109501838684,
-0.04316597804427147,
-0.7991470694541931,
0.5279217958450317,
0.5580510497093201,
-0.5790150761604309,
-0.410006046295166,
0.6915160417556763,
0.3234434425830841,
-0.23516196012496948,
0.2519342601299286,
-0.1749030500650406,
-0.6575400829315186,
0.27930352091789246,
0.4924377501010895,
1.1910401582717896,
-0.5044361352920532,
0.6655067801475525,
0.20933082699775696,
0.5957375764846802,
-0.16514693200588226,
0.25828883051872253,
0.048734430223703384,
-0.7030170559883118,
-0.5699583888053894,
-0.7606196403503418,
-0.3477703332901001,
0.58780837059021,
-0.2812053859233856,
0.3612384498119354,
-0.9178571105003357,
-0.2989114820957184,
-0.0008028976735658944,
-0.24935348331928253,
-0.2669517397880554,
0.05322874337434769,
0.4415629804134369,
0.6098114848136902,
-1.0271499156951904,
0.5569968223571777,
0.30674830079078674,
-0.44443798065185547,
-0.5212932825088501,
0.5383914113044739,
0.19736574590206146,
-0.3342549204826355,
0.4073343575000763,
0.2333720177412033,
-0.20386701822280884,
-0.20062397420406342,
-1.1284334659576416,
-0.4099523425102234,
0.08196799457073212,
0.7318291664123535,
-0.6105750799179077,
0.7689948678016663,
-0.00950776506215334,
0.7352604269981384,
-0.26026758551597595,
0.03712618723511696,
0.04760802909731865,
0.47217586636543274,
0.11639145016670227,
-0.7457473278045654,
0.3011499047279358,
-0.4986228346824646,
-0.13886038959026337,
-0.19156676530838013,
-0.8211588859558105,
0.8974986672401428,
-0.3232417106628418,
-0.35749924182891846,
0.08302872627973557,
0.741310179233551,
0.3014950752258301,
0.3010084629058838,
0.6030113101005554,
0.31701093912124634,
0.4882400333881378,
0.22595073282718658,
1.1345694065093994,
0.01296574529260397,
0.08976631611585617,
1.0098735094070435,
-0.5540590286254883,
0.5625227093696594,
0.019274108111858368,
0.1573060005903244,
0.7689523100852966,
0.2356085628271103,
-0.2889752686023712,
0.32802191376686096,
0.4594355523586273,
-1.0143574476242065,
-0.43025439977645874,
-0.5987477898597717,
-0.3418424427509308,
0.01503913477063179,
0.23538392782211304,
-0.4236156940460205,
-0.24308356642723083,
0.05813531577587128,
0.504059374332428,
0.308294415473938,
-0.20315247774124146,
0.5032323598861694,
0.26424673199653625,
-0.6356765031814575,
0.3277945816516876,
0.23801074922084808,
0.7388615608215332,
-0.5998008251190186,
-0.2606274485588074,
-0.4978967308998108,
0.1734606921672821,
-0.34957626461982727,
-0.33346471190452576,
-0.06716791540384293,
0.32270556688308716,
-0.3992083966732025,
-0.12985242903232574,
0.8623063564300537,
-0.47886618971824646,
-0.619610607624054,
0.28360483050346375,
0.4489937722682953,
-0.10189642757177353,
-0.30333787202835083,
-0.21961262822151184,
0.2618025243282318,
0.19432368874549866,
-0.36613988876342773,
0.1424444019794464,
0.2079789638519287,
-0.22684793174266815,
0.5391658544540405,
1.1086921691894531,
0.25355762243270874,
0.1503058671951294,
0.4008377492427826,
1.1825172901153564,
-0.15316756069660187,
-0.5780356526374817,
-0.8912205100059509,
0.3250657021999359,
-0.7209312319755554,
-0.06331345438957214,
1.1562938690185547,
0.481344074010849,
0.7468037605285645,
-0.307859867811203,
1.3310545682907104,
0.005026574246585369,
1.0197559595108032,
-0.14336024224758148,
0.8672378063201904,
-0.3129783272743225,
0.2155735194683075,
-0.5267233848571777,
-0.7722535133361816,
-0.275350421667099,
0.5110622644424438,
0.11451596021652222,
0.19719308614730835,
0.4105510711669922,
1.0598652362823486,
-0.16100025177001953,
-0.17386822402477264,
0.48248976469039917,
0.6707053184509277,
0.4048805832862854,
-0.027510173618793488,
0.9953662157058716,
-0.23237624764442444,
0.7185861468315125,
0.1636681705713272,
-0.11053626239299774,
-0.33266153931617737,
-0.5627147555351257,
-1.107771873474121,
-0.03783617541193962,
-0.4474044740200043,
-0.6404218673706055,
0.12127762287855148,
0.44141626358032227,
0.8295414447784424,
-0.9891495704650879,
0.049406640231609344,
0.033852625638246536,
0.29979217052459717,
0.20568521320819855,
-0.3284020721912384,
0.27902886271476746,
0.08112578094005585,
-0.6903706192970276,
0.4837551414966583,
0.09710296243429184,
0.017947562038898468,
-0.4073961079120636,
-0.16189299523830414,
0.2502245604991913,
0.5249457359313965,
0.5634531378746033,
0.5361973643302917,
-0.8197808861732483,
-0.42207545042037964,
-0.12361308932304382,
0.03719417750835419,
-0.3854832649230957,
0.6964858770370483,
-0.9084095358848572,
0.451240211725235,
0.45948466658592224,
0.25149229168891907,
0.6802904009819031,
0.2915376126766205,
0.5235792994499207,
-0.9608570337295532,
0.7139319777488708,
0.09727909415960312,
0.09042464941740036,
0.5201191902160645,
-0.16269506514072418,
0.25466835498809814,
0.5342543721199036,
0.06409364938735962,
-1.1427898406982422,
0.4475756883621216,
-0.8786724209785461,
-0.49176323413848877,
1.6148755550384521,
-0.017201848328113556,
0.09789054840803146,
-0.20738865435123444,
-0.3576972782611847,
0.23417270183563232,
-0.7084476947784424,
0.7156002521514893,
0.553074300289154,
0.3365386426448822,
-0.4539014399051666,
-0.7788159251213074,
0.4922095835208893,
0.2350730001926422,
-0.9867616891860962,
-0.05819181725382805,
0.8013416528701782,
0.48823171854019165,
0.07595281302928925,
0.9521971940994263,
-0.19634565711021423,
0.2538292706012726,
0.21398040652275085,
0.0989750400185585,
0.02885015681385994,
-0.3355207145214081,
-0.03430695831775665,
0.41279199719429016,
-0.20317675173282623,
-0.1556272804737091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18842v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18842v2
|
The global landscape of academic guidelines for generative AI and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-26T15:28:24 | 2024-06-28T02:54:06 |
Junfeng Jiao, Saleh Afroogh, Kevin Chen, David Atkinson, Amit Dhurandhar
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The integration of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GAI) and Large
Language Models (LLMs) in academia has spurred a global discourse on their
potential pedagogical benefits and ethical considerations. Positive reactions
highlight some potential, such as collaborative creativity, increased access to
education, and empowerment of trainers and trainees. However, negative
reactions raise concerns about ethical complexities, balancing innovation and
academic integrity, unequal access, and misinformation risks. Through a
systematic survey and text-mining-based analysis of global and national
directives, insights from independent research, and eighty university-level
guidelines, this study provides a nuanced understanding of the opportunities
and challenges posed by GAI and LLMs in education. It emphasizes the importance
of balanced approaches that harness the benefits of these technologies while
addressing ethical considerations and ensuring equitable access and educational
outcomes. The paper concludes with recommendations for fostering responsible
innovation and ethical practices to guide the integration of GAI and LLMs in
academia.
|
[
-0.25768154859542847,
-0.6931945085525513,
0.7619923949241638,
-0.10395608842372894,
0.16499833762645721,
0.3168318271636963,
-0.2268866002559662,
-0.5668599009513855,
-0.25784993171691895,
0.2820226550102234,
-0.3540518581867218,
-0.23228798806667328,
-0.6696023941040039,
0.1257343590259552,
-0.4345090687274933,
1.0602723360061646,
-0.1475924700498581,
0.3936106860637665,
-0.6089065670967102,
-0.13042443990707397,
-0.21197760105133057,
-0.6612052321434021,
-0.5453495979309082,
-0.2978067100048065,
0.49441418051719666,
0.22249984741210938,
0.6136924624443054,
0.2789660692214966,
0.47733357548713684,
0.25202441215515137,
-0.1694217324256897,
0.07512731850147247,
-0.31444498896598816,
-0.051499009132385254,
-0.33512499928474426,
-0.29099005460739136,
-0.4800468981266022,
0.25137850642204285,
0.6182658672332764,
0.7690355777740479,
-0.2649966776371002,
0.14646141231060028,
0.39533108472824097,
0.36011847853660583,
-0.5534783601760864,
0.026961224153637886,
0.018049856647849083,
0.17290617525577545,
-0.18382398784160614,
-0.16625142097473145,
-0.22287794947624207,
-0.5755776166915894,
0.10548893362283707,
-0.5931490063667297,
0.03460918739438057,
-0.29737240076065063,
0.6261468529701233,
0.07208885252475739,
-0.2321104109287262,
-0.5935714244842529,
-0.7566481828689575,
1.0561245679855347,
-0.48131510615348816,
0.1756383329629898,
0.06031481549143791,
0.09470976889133453,
-0.21371616423130035,
-0.6584745049476624,
-0.537293553352356,
0.21159669756889343,
0.1476365029811859,
0.07848089188337326,
-0.09186495840549469,
0.2593863904476166,
0.04487479850649834,
0.5371014475822449,
-0.2103022187948227,
0.5383543372154236,
-0.4212663173675537,
0.011933702975511551,
0.6914815306663513,
0.09136953204870224,
0.703490138053894,
0.23034194111824036,
-0.039829328656196594,
0.16869960725307465,
-0.7969037294387817,
-0.125360369682312,
0.7937667965888977,
0.1777709275484085,
-0.3062492311000824,
0.43067535758018494,
0.1981944590806961,
0.4498237073421478,
-0.2488516867160797,
0.06840097159147263,
0.23292547464370728,
-0.7127885222434998,
-0.06159846484661102,
0.013689401559531689,
0.8764498829841614,
0.23275943100452423,
0.3643849194049835,
-0.4431031346321106,
0.08179127424955368,
0.2102658599615097,
0.39854204654693604,
-0.495031476020813,
0.2555742859840393,
0.3222620487213135,
-0.19432266056537628,
-0.263261079788208,
0.15899069607257843,
-0.870876133441925,
-0.4632699191570282,
-0.7583010196685791,
0.15667220950126648,
-0.21199645102024078,
-0.2697845995426178,
0.02271738275885582,
-0.2197602093219757,
0.4842321574687958,
0.38719412684440613,
-1.1348861455917358,
0.0335998460650444,
1.1314692497253418,
0.6919785737991333,
0.10504268854856491,
-0.16074176132678986,
-0.1673431247472763,
0.29266563057899475,
-0.21853628754615784,
0.19027993083000183,
-0.6800593137741089,
-0.8452516198158264,
0.28892818093299866,
-0.18522261083126068,
0.04949887469410896,
-0.18733473122119904,
0.6293668150901794,
-0.17796266078948975,
0.36209723353385925,
-0.28560370206832886,
-0.4553370177745819,
-0.21443894505500793,
0.15022005140781403,
-0.3434104323387146,
0.6086609363555908,
-0.031178567558526993,
-0.5539523363113403,
0.252430260181427,
-0.9092656970024109,
-0.5658392906188965,
0.35854896903038025,
-0.5992240309715271,
-0.2351503074169159,
-0.01720641739666462,
0.08044399321079254,
0.3867804706096649,
-0.5972208380699158,
0.7998292446136475,
-0.20901700854301453,
-0.27210134267807007,
-0.03654918819665909,
-0.5298539996147156,
1.2611490488052368,
0.1499357968568802,
-0.5406058430671692,
0.2965656816959381,
-0.5777634382247925,
0.17415842413902283,
-0.02361726388335228,
-0.2897275686264038,
-0.4146827757358551,
0.10737733542919159,
0.06156789883971214,
0.023766521364450455,
0.06592909246683121,
-0.3360339105129242,
0.19068527221679688,
-0.17956854403018951,
0.8972633481025696,
0.864425539970398,
-0.07607405632734299,
0.6944577693939209,
-0.3633195459842682,
0.5849546194076538,
-0.42360758781433105,
0.43853724002838135,
0.12100745737552643,
-0.49176254868507385,
-0.6020190715789795,
-0.17459912598133087,
-0.03326498717069626,
0.49584120512008667,
-0.4384281039237976,
0.6177927851676941,
-0.18495596945285797,
-0.5106943845748901,
-0.9601870179176331,
0.24263246357440948,
0.20759901404380798,
0.30628126859664917,
0.18040764331817627,
0.1022300124168396,
-0.5094314813613892,
-0.710304319858551,
-0.2653045952320099,
-0.11075470596551895,
-0.12744157016277313,
0.3810397982597351,
0.7113757729530334,
-0.39941975474357605,
0.7176259160041809,
0.22607775032520294,
-0.17213022708892822,
-0.05697474256157875,
0.30843570828437805,
0.014008915051817894,
0.506618320941925,
0.4849548041820526,
-0.9552492499351501,
-0.2561465799808502,
0.011932446621358395,
-1.2665709257125854,
0.04281727597117424,
-0.18575511872768402,
-0.21508516371250153,
-0.04391695186495781,
0.2993125021457672,
-0.5683628916740417,
0.12995262444019318,
0.34231746196746826,
-0.06858701258897781,
0.2989276051521301,
0.08691710978746414,
0.5297831892967224,
-0.9383733868598938,
0.12302590161561966,
0.2561061978340149,
0.25398629903793335,
-0.5615158081054688,
0.3708435595035553,
-0.16605162620544434,
0.10772204399108887,
-0.32614824175834656,
0.5607600808143616,
-0.3813064992427826,
0.19869330525398254,
0.04759420081973076,
0.31931549310684204,
-0.04337100684642792,
-0.21754390001296997,
-0.34365513920783997,
1.2226518392562866,
0.6471073627471924,
-0.6051308512687683,
0.3325017988681793,
0.5343828797340393,
-0.5511444807052612,
0.8471024036407471,
-0.6609904170036316,
0.06477954238653183,
-0.05112054944038391,
0.29711219668388367,
-0.15901829302310944,
-0.2911944091320038,
0.37699273228645325,
-0.3862379491329193,
0.11363618820905685,
0.11448204517364502,
-0.42994847893714905,
-0.34751203656196594,
-0.4721781313419342,
0.542174220085144,
0.5313456654548645,
-0.6817188262939453,
0.6369323134422302,
0.6948688626289368,
-0.31215354800224304,
-0.7879181504249573,
-0.7180498242378235,
0.39312222599983215,
-0.2073238343000412,
-0.5545740127563477,
0.45992982387542725,
0.004006294999271631,
-0.615410327911377,
0.06635241210460663,
0.29474082589149475,
0.2594897150993347,
0.3127196729183197,
0.30070939660072327,
0.4534798562526703,
-0.10332582890987396,
-0.2588602602481842,
-0.011993661522865295,
0.008782410994172096,
0.3731025457382202,
-0.3339328169822693,
0.306627482175827,
-0.31791451573371887,
-0.3355386555194855,
-0.3369466960430145,
0.5432646870613098,
0.7436240315437317,
-0.20473454892635345,
0.6595132350921631,
0.573052167892456,
-0.3056910037994385,
-0.09121382981538773,
-0.4945008158683777,
-0.05267222970724106,
-0.4190061390399933,
0.1558932512998581,
0.28897586464881897,
-0.9425005316734314,
0.2432696670293808,
0.11600317060947418,
0.24123485386371613,
0.36277446150779724,
0.6385493278503418,
-0.07971086353063583,
1.0448726415634155,
0.7564904093742371,
-0.13818834722042084,
0.38077691197395325,
-0.5324382781982422,
0.6389577984809875,
-1.1494340896606445,
-0.6269190311431885,
-0.6559749245643616,
-0.18204063177108765,
-0.4981337785720825,
-0.20567883551120758,
0.29318517446517944,
0.04350811243057251,
-0.3361800014972687,
-0.43693801760673523,
-0.6117146015167236,
0.4802424907684326,
0.7146866917610168,
-0.3346134126186371,
0.23853431642055511,
-0.0313897542655468,
-0.10971693694591522,
0.10747241228818893,
-0.6029614806175232,
-0.9073238372802734,
1.0095160007476807,
0.2688727080821991,
0.9252191185951233,
0.16981053352355957,
0.5567901134490967,
0.31590285897254944,
0.34836137294769287,
-0.7220922708511353,
0.5909439921379089,
-0.18103815615177155,
-0.525822639465332,
-0.19866812229156494,
-0.3409518003463745,
-0.6125009059906006,
0.034350864589214325,
-0.24140368402004242,
-0.7869287729263306,
0.1655070036649704,
-0.23408107459545135,
-0.16580820083618164,
0.5979331731796265,
-0.5491736531257629,
0.5486820340156555,
-0.4236283600330353,
-0.5613456964492798,
-0.2887899577617645,
-0.5208843946456909,
0.3555235266685486,
0.021820180118083954,
0.5067258477210999,
0.060328274965286255,
0.23777742683887482,
0.7336899042129517,
-0.04391106218099594,
0.9133583307266235,
0.06432536989450455,
-0.23265986144542694,
0.5542881488800049,
-0.5449858903884888,
0.12056239694356918,
-0.017237797379493713,
-0.023797908797860146,
0.6573510766029358,
-0.2601444125175476,
-0.15731967985630035,
-0.14081637561321259,
0.9117211103439331,
-1.1033045053482056,
-0.7770054936408997,
-0.5818654894828796,
-0.5133726000785828,
-0.13097019493579865,
0.1159464418888092,
0.28669601678848267,
-0.0015223564114421606,
-0.3071976900100708,
0.3230970799922943,
0.7995935678482056,
-0.2600906491279602,
0.20052814483642578,
0.2627793848514557,
0.12401799857616425,
-0.2764272391796112,
0.8405361175537109,
0.21868760883808136,
0.19188466668128967,
-0.0362512543797493,
0.03533486649394035,
-0.2935731112957001,
-0.47705262899398804,
-0.5729864239692688,
0.18736016750335693,
-0.7884286642074585,
0.07515985518693924,
-0.49252474308013916,
-0.643491268157959,
-0.46616676449775696,
-0.6463561654090881,
0.26812657713890076,
0.05486999824643135,
-0.7412896156311035,
-0.20644034445285797,
0.15981848537921906,
0.73734050989151,
-0.0785181000828743,
0.025675565004348755,
-0.6480672955513,
-0.012169155292212963,
0.17712749540805817,
0.30840569734573364,
0.11201431602239609,
-0.23570339381694794,
0.025402117520570755,
0.18644490838050842,
-0.33041420578956604,
-0.33162766695022583,
-0.057654332369565964,
0.09451667219400406,
0.8843080997467041,
0.3288916051387787,
-0.17218482494354248,
0.4007832109928131,
-0.6016663908958435,
0.831417977809906,
0.3482273817062378,
-0.7128782272338867,
0.3777483403682709,
-0.4575504660606384,
-0.024748021736741066,
0.2609707713127136,
0.7708117961883545,
-0.729977011680603,
-0.5731952786445618,
-0.5335999727249146,
-1.1257609128952026,
0.49064937233924866,
-0.0730285793542862,
0.5387759208679199,
0.07863783836364746,
0.24707680940628052,
0.27645373344421387,
0.3161280155181885,
-0.6155032515525818,
-0.11895804107189178,
-0.024748455733060837,
-0.5235347151756287,
0.11641567200422287,
-0.16305309534072876,
-0.7142621874809265,
-0.15828268229961395,
0.8870802521705627,
0.1720542013645172,
-0.016385052353143692,
-0.24015553295612335,
0.10293422639369965,
-0.13241024315357208,
0.7611624598503113,
0.25211942195892334,
0.7144069075584412,
0.23171831667423248,
-0.2578561305999756,
-0.12840428948402405,
-0.46895116567611694,
0.3441830277442932,
-0.023653902113437653,
-0.6245999336242676,
-0.47798916697502136,
0.20865978300571442,
0.4899543225765228,
-0.06226516515016556,
-0.6037476062774658,
0.23318718373775482,
0.0012277313508093357,
-0.4474290907382965,
-0.3712162971496582,
0.4134982228279114,
-0.07999353110790253,
0.12877309322357178,
0.32510054111480713,
-0.07998991012573242,
0.0484171137213707,
-0.6309886574745178,
-0.15275752544403076,
0.6050990223884583,
-0.04531913250684738,
-0.19244393706321716,
0.9227531552314758,
0.5257617235183716,
-0.26905474066734314,
0.7020000219345093,
0.1358860433101654,
-0.16222433745861053,
0.6640851497650146,
0.5184847712516785,
0.836197018623352,
-0.016978761181235313,
0.44829636812210083,
0.1324554830789566,
0.2733730673789978,
-0.2751229703426361,
0.2589104175567627,
0.1777704805135727,
-0.6125211119651794,
-0.23953227698802948,
-0.5501409769058228,
-0.5978135466575623,
0.2542930245399475,
-0.5723221302032471,
0.2366820126771927,
-0.6245315074920654,
-0.23120158910751343,
0.1929703950881958,
-0.407898485660553,
-0.5184038281440735,
0.01877264864742756,
0.254904180765152,
0.4791421592235565,
-0.782346785068512,
0.4981726408004761,
0.8178001642227173,
-0.6186559200286865,
-0.48378416895866394,
-0.18055322766304016,
0.37279409170150757,
-0.6279040575027466,
0.30533450841903687,
0.2394806444644928,
-0.2678419053554535,
0.06412247568368912,
-0.5741128325462341,
-0.4914719760417938,
0.9882732033729553,
0.22914187610149384,
-0.5179911255836487,
-0.3170376420021057,
0.16005195677280426,
0.4591482877731323,
-0.20884808897972107,
0.019213255494832993,
0.5095826387405396,
0.5098651051521301,
-0.06953524798154831,
-0.5713551044464111,
-0.3511163294315338,
-0.307120144367218,
-0.07459062337875366,
0.3514440953731537,
-0.5721984505653381,
0.6069143414497375,
-0.20106196403503418,
-0.33363521099090576,
0.03924352303147316,
0.31913650035858154,
0.020144158974289894,
0.35417795181274414,
-0.11265471577644348,
0.40701109170913696,
0.8556116223335266,
-0.4258507788181305,
0.9835867881774902,
-0.41865187883377075,
0.12323593348264694,
0.5222229361534119,
-0.21233569085597992,
0.41847461462020874,
0.41405558586120605,
-0.3190978169441223,
0.4410553574562073,
0.478154718875885,
-0.4928542375564575,
0.19292882084846497,
0.08499563485383987,
-0.6092636585235596,
0.08406378328800201,
-0.5521044731140137,
-0.5207056999206543,
0.2505791485309601,
0.7522061467170715,
-0.2443034052848816,
0.004562166053801775,
0.06741157919168472,
0.09590067714452744,
0.3131651282310486,
-0.5905450582504272,
0.5570494532585144,
0.14676544070243835,
-0.6255417466163635,
-0.05347901210188866,
0.030176499858498573,
0.8837774991989136,
-0.41508767008781433,
-0.04773076996207237,
0.08185359090566635,
-0.03336811810731888,
-0.32980385422706604,
-0.9341338872909546,
0.21928758919239044,
0.32467928528785706,
-0.16788652539253235,
-0.3465019166469574,
0.32242241501808167,
-0.29014936089515686,
-0.5656834840774536,
0.17943108081817627,
0.4577631950378418,
-0.22864441573619843,
0.6715842485427856,
-0.598476767539978,
-0.0594194158911705,
-0.17384320497512817,
0.2714916169643402,
0.46636542677879333,
0.34367382526397705,
-0.120440773665905,
0.8172856569290161,
0.582099437713623,
0.10060202330350876,
-0.08409937471151352,
0.3146399259567261,
0.5729426145553589,
-0.27916449308395386,
-0.42416828870773315,
-0.8815418481826782,
0.47913894057273865,
-0.07497407495975494,
-0.40674665570259094,
0.6519160866737366,
0.17664189636707306,
0.9897786378860474,
0.18763962388038635,
1.201130986213684,
-0.1809340864419937,
-0.0455472394824028,
-0.5186850428581238,
0.8422443270683289,
-0.45027264952659607,
0.34882086515426636,
-0.044788818806409836,
-0.6578471660614014,
-0.3165009617805481,
0.6210570931434631,
-0.44679805636405945,
0.46723276376724243,
0.19561241567134857,
0.25330570340156555,
0.29938799142837524,
0.2077151983976364,
-0.018220989033579826,
0.03059002384543419,
0.5421559810638428,
0.24686650931835175,
0.8882972598075867,
-0.08045651763677597,
0.27888384461402893,
0.145783931016922,
-0.14049899578094482,
-0.2004556953907013,
-0.7511131763458252,
-0.679696798324585,
-0.3406652510166168,
-0.3583374619483948,
-0.14868515729904175,
0.19674052298069,
0.7513720989227295,
0.3139205574989319,
-0.7999401092529297,
-0.22647354006767273,
-0.3186381161212921,
0.19593968987464905,
0.028762882575392723,
-0.26720285415649414,
0.17405371367931366,
-0.24453788995742798,
-0.9659505486488342,
0.1353202760219574,
0.39683011174201965,
0.23360835015773773,
-0.5787373781204224,
-0.15349826216697693,
-0.21232615411281586,
0.15508627891540527,
0.5087162256240845,
0.4686628580093384,
-0.8173903822898865,
-0.3422679305076599,
-0.25257551670074463,
-0.2792840600013733,
-0.14675839245319366,
0.6110537648200989,
-0.38153186440467834,
0.3698950409889221,
0.11818624287843704,
0.925392746925354,
-0.3930497467517853,
-0.14929914474487305,
0.7418293356895447,
-0.3588283658027649,
0.031931422650814056,
0.5555683970451355,
0.28374940156936646,
0.447315514087677,
-0.3483301103115082,
0.6976927518844604,
0.06365568935871124,
-0.7982124090194702,
-1.050445795059204,
0.15974624454975128,
-0.49497920274734497,
-0.15173186361789703,
1.0025790929794312,
-0.11705012619495392,
-0.09636489301919937,
-0.10195022821426392,
0.08339393138885498,
0.28635331988334656,
-0.04742009937763214,
0.9135144948959351,
0.8360673785209656,
-0.02475215122103691,
0.0677238404750824,
-0.9098585247993469,
0.3774451017379761,
0.15813499689102173,
-0.916212797164917,
-0.05175797641277313,
0.505977213382721,
0.026167096570134163,
0.15294179320335388,
0.26141682267189026,
-0.3803251385688782,
0.17994149029254913,
-0.09756738692522049,
0.13060258328914642,
0.007166916038841009,
-0.5987916588783264,
-0.37671932578086853,
-0.059044599533081055,
0.03521179035305977,
0.16745223104953766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16584v1
|
MentalManip: A Dataset For Fine-grained Analysis of Mental Manipulation in Conversations
| 2024-05-26T14:27:48 | 2024-05-26T14:27:48 |
Yuxin Wang, Ivory Yang, Saeed Hassanpour, Soroush Vosoughi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mental manipulation, a significant form of abuse in interpersonal
conversations, presents a challenge to identify due to its context-dependent
and often subtle nature. The detection of manipulative language is essential
for protecting potential victims, yet the field of Natural Language Processing
(NLP) currently faces a scarcity of resources and research on this topic. Our
study addresses this gap by introducing a new dataset, named ${\rm M{\small
ental}M{\small anip}}$, which consists of $4,000$ annotated movie dialogues.
This dataset enables a comprehensive analysis of mental manipulation,
pinpointing both the techniques utilized for manipulation and the
vulnerabilities targeted in victims. Our research further explores the
effectiveness of leading-edge models in recognizing manipulative dialogue and
its components through a series of experiments with various configurations. The
results demonstrate that these models inadequately identify and categorize
manipulative content. Attempts to improve their performance by fine-tuning with
existing datasets on mental health and toxicity have not overcome these
limitations. We anticipate that ${\rm M{\small ental}M{\small anip}}$ will
stimulate further research, leading to progress in both understanding and
mitigating the impact of mental manipulation in conversations.
|
[
-0.479705810546875,
-1.0003888607025146,
0.29720374941825867,
0.13927105069160461,
0.05908501148223877,
0.09211927652359009,
-0.07377883046865463,
-0.30630919337272644,
0.2905222177505493,
0.6814900040626526,
-0.8832864165306091,
-0.16986653208732605,
-0.9580516815185547,
0.16477946937084198,
-0.2528032064437866,
0.9611477255821228,
0.16682294011116028,
0.07954521477222443,
-0.1597135365009308,
-0.026990486308932304,
-0.6455877423286438,
-0.6865798830986023,
-0.3735780715942383,
-0.5306050181388855,
0.29229623079299927,
0.22920915484428406,
0.9560830593109131,
0.5151764750480652,
0.7729961276054382,
0.2964232265949249,
0.03165211156010628,
0.35273468494415283,
-0.39719879627227783,
0.04766630753874779,
-0.41058406233787537,
-0.38017353415489197,
-0.5871879458427429,
0.3269236087799072,
0.2657351791858673,
0.61485755443573,
-0.27994653582572937,
0.16775467991828918,
0.12571094930171967,
0.6636961102485657,
-0.8003726601600647,
0.17362189292907715,
-0.7109642028808594,
0.2887181043624878,
-0.4120640158653259,
-0.4877404570579529,
-0.37702301144599915,
0.07661284506320953,
-0.2259303778409958,
-0.26866939663887024,
-0.2707217335700989,
0.03299647942185402,
0.7985607385635376,
0.5044853687286377,
-0.11292117089033127,
-0.198260098695755,
-0.8957874774932861,
0.6354359984397888,
-0.4994896352291107,
-0.04347663000226021,
0.9461005926132202,
0.3137759864330292,
-0.1768866628408432,
-0.35187798738479614,
-0.5720977783203125,
-0.11227299273014069,
-0.19383715093135834,
-0.08797773718833923,
-0.6334220170974731,
0.24246779084205627,
0.5058435201644897,
0.14575697481632233,
-0.27267107367515564,
0.12401995807886124,
-0.45899105072021484,
-0.2768731713294983,
0.5086944699287415,
0.7358145713806152,
0.5258414149284363,
-0.3890964984893799,
-0.19428376853466034,
0.10037924349308014,
-0.31088683009147644,
-0.06710777431726456,
0.5894462466239929,
0.2789379358291626,
-0.15057802200317383,
1.1370714902877808,
-0.05365915969014168,
0.7511327862739563,
0.11964157968759537,
-0.2229921668767929,
-0.15352998673915863,
-0.3052852749824524,
-0.38308343291282654,
-0.10966279357671738,
0.8916575908660889,
0.9686592817306519,
0.5414147973060608,
0.06590422987937927,
0.07078278809785843,
0.1533728390932083,
0.610719621181488,
-0.8048418164253235,
-0.3692359924316406,
0.25756052136421204,
-0.4111780524253845,
-0.24710801243782043,
0.0335334837436676,
-0.7244200706481934,
-0.5739427804946899,
-0.5605515241622925,
0.2831999361515045,
-0.8495550155639648,
-0.2841687500476837,
0.2117205560207367,
-0.159107506275177,
-0.24483874440193176,
0.1624707579612732,
-0.8806824684143066,
0.5891326665878296,
0.7845588326454163,
1.083646535873413,
-0.0974557101726532,
-0.3817942440509796,
-0.3319184184074402,
0.2047656923532486,
-0.20613986253738403,
0.8759885430335999,
-0.9487910866737366,
-0.0905652716755867,
-0.26695799827575684,
-0.1217893436551094,
-0.2676777243614197,
-0.8772275447845459,
0.3436518907546997,
0.09913846105337143,
0.4572201669216156,
-0.15041384100914001,
-0.3407624363899231,
-0.2537461221218109,
0.39161795377731323,
-0.4108290672302246,
0.5683078169822693,
0.3199751079082489,
-1.1513162851333618,
0.13310816884040833,
-0.7316185235977173,
-0.008074923418462276,
-0.20242249965667725,
-0.17399735748767853,
-0.12829208374023438,
0.023091508075594902,
0.15348884463310242,
0.38208290934562683,
-0.30603817105293274,
0.42103105783462524,
-0.40000948309898376,
-0.4424853026866913,
0.3620929718017578,
-0.5950013399124146,
0.9495276808738708,
0.10379313677549362,
0.1813989132642746,
0.14494378864765167,
-0.5866031050682068,
-0.24268002808094025,
-0.025417212396860123,
0.08482019603252411,
-0.5105213522911072,
-0.12874217331409454,
-0.042162422090768814,
0.6715376973152161,
0.13601437211036682,
-0.6310103535652161,
0.2762638032436371,
-0.3350561559200287,
0.11687316000461578,
0.6083272099494934,
0.16150204837322235,
0.26834315061569214,
-0.5509001612663269,
0.6328102350234985,
0.06551094353199005,
0.29163500666618347,
0.14787696301937103,
-0.1491660624742508,
-0.2780361473560333,
-0.6374152898788452,
0.008368074893951416,
0.8402112126350403,
-0.837913990020752,
0.47676512598991394,
-0.16842155158519745,
-0.4501765966415405,
-0.6726464033126831,
-0.09829790145158768,
0.38677918910980225,
0.5515385866165161,
0.5668654441833496,
-0.40127426385879517,
-0.7106614708900452,
-1.3784500360488892,
-0.38007432222366333,
-0.09227973967790604,
-0.40975362062454224,
0.29176512360572815,
0.25085029006004333,
-0.25283822417259216,
1.1772669553756714,
-0.41792628169059753,
-0.7577358484268188,
-0.17852813005447388,
0.43321195244789124,
0.05950909107923508,
0.293980211019516,
0.45969876646995544,
-0.2953098714351654,
-0.39094483852386475,
-0.10671454668045044,
-0.9246031045913696,
-0.4483336806297302,
-0.18735413253307343,
-0.2726803123950958,
-0.3441571295261383,
0.39372196793556213,
-0.7076410055160522,
0.3251890540122986,
0.3958668112754822,
-0.5123142004013062,
0.6717514991760254,
0.0732373595237732,
0.2145886868238449,
-0.713513970375061,
-0.05510064959526062,
-0.06624409556388855,
0.06324566900730133,
-0.7629912495613098,
-0.25913816690444946,
-0.21519629657268524,
-0.03960943967103958,
-0.611487865447998,
0.1648314744234085,
-0.09912040084600449,
0.32704222202301025,
-0.4968269169330597,
-0.07718323171138763,
-0.3835698068141937,
0.5963122844696045,
-0.22266782820224762,
0.7247161865234375,
0.26070255041122437,
-0.19811801612377167,
0.29333317279815674,
0.24991479516029358,
0.07168582826852798,
0.9145134091377258,
-0.28693246841430664,
0.20361365377902985,
-0.281326562166214,
-0.06373602896928787,
-0.43125227093696594,
-0.3141447901725769,
0.6077253818511963,
-0.2512197494506836,
0.3344063460826874,
-0.2800285518169403,
-0.7104710936546326,
0.1253417283296585,
-0.38832899928092957,
0.09486754238605499,
-0.07659848779439926,
-0.06921911239624023,
0.3729487657546997,
0.8164248466491699,
-0.46926817297935486,
-0.45098891854286194,
-0.13109421730041504,
0.3679235577583313,
-0.4548162817955017,
-0.3775704503059387,
0.3133525848388672,
0.10168324410915375,
-0.6790669560432434,
-0.2836310863494873,
0.04119729623198509,
-0.0195000059902668,
-0.08472627401351929,
0.46429917216300964,
0.20200443267822266,
0.3561059236526489,
0.11210484057664871,
0.2519126832485199,
-0.37411677837371826,
0.45001423358917236,
0.5527476072311401,
0.988007664680481,
-0.025748053565621376,
-0.13786427676677704,
-0.43949657678604126,
0.4441539943218231,
0.6178362369537354,
-0.2196805477142334,
0.6837668418884277,
0.5636053681373596,
-0.6227279901504517,
0.31440961360931396,
-0.16129307448863983,
-0.1832556277513504,
-0.44304725527763367,
0.5316358804702759,
-0.3531775176525116,
-0.612095296382904,
0.18988415598869324,
-0.14853444695472717,
-0.14560401439666748,
0.125062957406044,
0.718984842300415,
-0.07628568261861801,
1.3332979679107666,
0.49938544631004333,
-0.38379210233688354,
0.5276098251342773,
-0.10041859745979309,
0.14430665969848633,
-0.8652383089065552,
-0.08085436373949051,
-0.15764281153678894,
-0.4541109502315521,
-0.3954027593135834,
-0.3756825029850006,
0.20816367864608765,
0.03162027522921562,
-0.2898487150669098,
0.40118446946144104,
-0.48042431473731995,
0.44340622425079346,
0.1288291960954666,
0.11230802536010742,
0.5119378566741943,
0.018239807337522507,
0.06998483091592789,
-0.6217708587646484,
-0.33311212062835693,
-0.8705353736877441,
0.9615035653114319,
0.4760807156562805,
0.6338379383087158,
0.1271335780620575,
0.16913975775241852,
0.32149645686149597,
0.4364137351512909,
-0.8126286864280701,
0.7378015518188477,
0.03385581448674202,
-0.5691686272621155,
-0.10188020765781403,
-0.2420176863670349,
-1.0127627849578857,
0.3430725038051605,
-0.40385475754737854,
-1.2800321578979492,
0.06186673417687416,
-0.19169700145721436,
-0.20494060218334198,
0.4450862407684326,
-0.6587734818458557,
0.5504348874092102,
0.08532781898975372,
-0.21291710436344147,
-0.4646800756454468,
-0.5645817518234253,
0.5632280707359314,
-0.08103100210428238,
0.15690794587135315,
-0.606855571269989,
0.2103353887796402,
0.666436493396759,
-0.4526959955692291,
0.7180068492889404,
-0.24584968388080597,
-0.06977035105228424,
0.04253862425684929,
0.5442849397659302,
0.051759567111730576,
0.05912281200289726,
-0.0008724561193957925,
0.22274646162986755,
0.123686783015728,
-0.157597154378891,
-0.8410084843635559,
0.2265487015247345,
-0.4227485656738281,
-0.4460395276546478,
-0.26876625418663025,
-1.002886414527893,
-0.3304629325866699,
0.04670904949307442,
0.21719110012054443,
0.27999261021614075,
0.1596054881811142,
0.0959990993142128,
0.08478615432977676,
-0.08829887956380844,
0.3028668463230133,
0.4357183873653412,
-0.39105871319770813,
-0.30152690410614014,
0.9893808364868164,
0.29485294222831726,
0.07272016257047653,
0.21191853284835815,
0.14270204305648804,
0.21492448449134827,
-0.39564231038093567,
-0.08710876107215881,
0.3328961133956909,
-0.18038369715213776,
-0.31392496824264526,
-0.7698809504508972,
-0.2129954695701599,
0.10864477604627609,
0.23689760267734528,
-0.5352510213851929,
-0.3778708279132843,
-0.1132410392165184,
-0.1762446165084839,
0.18389001488685608,
0.3488135039806366,
-0.1259588897228241,
0.4494781494140625,
-0.6006227731704712,
0.4284157454967499,
0.11228073388338089,
0.31317076086997986,
-0.19715280830860138,
-0.4151006042957306,
-0.29527929425239563,
0.17168420553207397,
-0.6474161148071289,
-1.1778037548065186,
0.8324927687644958,
0.1193220466375351,
0.1391695737838745,
0.503413736820221,
0.3572542071342468,
0.6973840594291687,
-0.47509852051734924,
0.48423266410827637,
-0.026130080223083496,
-0.7368380427360535,
0.8944591283798218,
-0.497683584690094,
0.07002662122249603,
0.5798338055610657,
0.6975887417793274,
-0.673798680305481,
-0.831640362739563,
-0.799354612827301,
-0.5592389702796936,
0.730597198009491,
0.2455822080373764,
0.18639810383319855,
-0.10805471241474152,
-0.05555444210767746,
0.2599056363105774,
0.5052622556686401,
-0.38349178433418274,
-0.2788303792476654,
0.24711638689041138,
-0.21515409648418427,
0.19702774286270142,
-0.04453741014003754,
-0.5451247096061707,
-0.5484365224838257,
0.34490346908569336,
-0.07405826449394226,
0.6219413876533508,
-0.005967287812381983,
-0.2641243040561676,
-0.21769143640995026,
0.15896856784820557,
0.2755507528781891,
0.5084109306335449,
-0.5936540961265564,
0.12746113538742065,
0.03622724488377571,
-0.78056401014328,
-0.010667163878679276,
0.1008235290646553,
0.11539185792207718,
-0.1389491707086563,
0.288847953081131,
0.6385118961334229,
-0.1379900574684143,
-1.027637243270874,
0.45690271258354187,
-0.046956617385149,
-0.02337726764380932,
-0.05040786787867546,
0.2339903563261032,
-0.527662992477417,
0.4123651683330536,
0.10451474785804749,
0.3283267319202423,
0.404410183429718,
-0.6798036694526672,
0.36759454011917114,
0.4426971673965454,
-0.4706023037433624,
-0.37372323870658875,
0.25943616032600403,
-0.31677767634391785,
-0.681656539440155,
0.8640137314796448,
-0.19330660998821259,
-0.3702174723148346,
-0.004331715404987335,
0.4381959140300751,
0.5372725129127502,
0.039651498198509216,
0.2448679804801941,
0.13691385090351105,
0.37743207812309265,
0.3799184560775757,
0.3439549207687378,
-0.010128943249583244,
-1.0279237031936646,
-0.3507864475250244,
-0.19537167251110077,
-0.7160593867301941,
0.3528406322002411,
-1.0359243154525757,
0.22291947901248932,
-0.7371141910552979,
-0.40208351612091064,
0.03169940412044525,
-0.06508410722017288,
-0.4517575800418854,
-0.10791364312171936,
0.14982980489730835,
0.6379726529121399,
-1.026648998260498,
0.7069914937019348,
0.5788503289222717,
-0.263813316822052,
-0.3262118995189667,
-0.06233930215239525,
0.2829296588897705,
-0.5829077363014221,
0.3170342445373535,
0.3119792938232422,
-0.05372055247426033,
-0.25466296076774597,
-0.7007876634597778,
-0.4434546232223511,
0.6474014520645142,
0.680450439453125,
-0.049165986478328705,
-0.042320359498262405,
0.13489669561386108,
0.5947862267494202,
-0.23720185458660126,
0.37331342697143555,
1.1387537717819214,
0.41671261191368103,
-0.358173668384552,
-1.0577805042266846,
0.05142999440431595,
-0.607825517654419,
-0.3528749644756317,
0.4608558118343353,
-0.5125210881233215,
0.5805233120918274,
0.010845808312296867,
-0.1600167453289032,
-0.3519345223903656,
0.25573721528053284,
0.44685134291648865,
0.2850814461708069,
0.40704432129859924,
0.412780225276947,
0.6389482617378235,
-0.15293850004673004,
0.8633084893226624,
-0.09937833249568939,
0.27837011218070984,
1.2167872190475464,
-0.032371506094932556,
0.9078865051269531,
0.7839170098304749,
-0.43273937702178955,
0.4276961386203766,
0.3685048818588257,
-0.12738046050071716,
0.39199063181877136,
0.08185465633869171,
-0.12338501960039139,
-0.1733444631099701,
-0.45381036400794983,
0.071929432451725,
0.8753916621208191,
0.8160313963890076,
-0.1675170361995697,
-0.1488969326019287,
0.3529012203216553,
0.2696455419063568,
-0.004178913775831461,
-0.12324868142604828,
0.7459825873374939,
-0.02324860543012619,
-0.3063802421092987,
0.322054922580719,
0.04688136279582977,
0.836382269859314,
-0.3936520218849182,
-0.055497653782367706,
0.06292758882045746,
0.004168190062046051,
-0.24690507352352142,
-0.8014060258865356,
0.7954276204109192,
-0.057193901389837265,
-0.0538669154047966,
-0.30119234323501587,
0.9226707220077515,
-0.2967621982097626,
-0.20761428773403168,
0.2190137356519699,
0.645836353302002,
0.23560602962970734,
-0.37977030873298645,
-0.7269400954246521,
-0.23584720492362976,
-0.16253474354743958,
-0.04340336471796036,
0.742611825466156,
0.43780145049095154,
0.07904514670372009,
0.8930176496505737,
0.5162132978439331,
0.256024569272995,
-0.17616328597068787,
-0.001740982523187995,
0.7131824493408203,
-0.6923596858978271,
-0.22106292843818665,
-0.9841739535331726,
0.5016364455223083,
-0.33171147108078003,
-0.44392356276512146,
0.7497713565826416,
0.4764867424964905,
0.7575002908706665,
-0.01704319939017296,
0.23205776512622833,
0.01805759035050869,
0.6039456725120544,
-0.36846765875816345,
0.5335338115692139,
-0.10015203803777695,
0.32472503185272217,
-0.5640789866447449,
-0.712430477142334,
-0.35215991735458374,
0.8504001498222351,
-0.411083847284317,
-0.26176413893699646,
0.5462769865989685,
0.8279891610145569,
-0.012070508673787117,
0.21768805384635925,
0.2990230917930603,
0.23505444824695587,
0.21223847568035126,
0.31315210461616516,
0.9933517575263977,
-0.2657453417778015,
0.29229262471199036,
-0.6960974335670471,
-0.2594251334667206,
0.04648681357502937,
-0.6974970698356628,
-0.8409199714660645,
-0.3481326997280121,
-0.2490455061197281,
-0.11989801377058029,
-0.061559077352285385,
1.291660189628601,
0.5070966482162476,
-0.4638327360153198,
-0.35690417885780334,
0.13443009555339813,
0.013937652111053467,
-0.5924017429351807,
-0.2891363501548767,
0.07042620331048965,
-0.16085554659366608,
-0.9238767623901367,
0.44140005111694336,
0.805925726890564,
-0.018788425251841545,
-0.15783852338790894,
0.20569033920764923,
-0.27636078000068665,
0.05729762092232704,
0.8553133606910706,
-0.0031183799728751183,
-0.48033607006073,
-0.13072428107261658,
-0.1276589035987854,
0.12255552411079407,
0.15435342490673065,
0.9242314696311951,
-0.6430940628051758,
0.5190821886062622,
0.2675565481185913,
0.4587520360946655,
0.11031976342201233,
0.1305912584066391,
0.7912209630012512,
-1.0535646677017212,
0.13227030634880066,
0.32497888803482056,
0.2770509123802185,
0.11827146261930466,
-0.426743745803833,
0.42985284328460693,
0.11373434215784073,
-0.24071745574474335,
-0.9486895203590393,
0.1427329033613205,
-0.8927352428436279,
-0.3474719226360321,
0.8880274295806885,
0.241032212972641,
0.03066400997340679,
-0.43081599473953247,
-0.839971661567688,
0.1494632512331009,
-0.28239962458610535,
0.9463430643081665,
0.9948654770851135,
-0.6397656798362732,
-0.27668964862823486,
-0.8007397651672363,
0.3480854034423828,
0.4149908423423767,
-0.8497850298881531,
0.42718806862831116,
0.38734573125839233,
-0.11564009636640549,
0.30407193303108215,
0.5209693908691406,
-0.31549057364463806,
-0.04497421905398369,
-0.01078385766595602,
-0.10482892394065857,
-0.2853360176086426,
-0.46851322054862976,
-0.3842499256134033,
0.3195457458496094,
-0.2932136356830597,
-0.08408831804990768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16579v1
|
Automatically Generating Numerous Context-Driven SFT Data for LLMs across Diverse Granularity
| 2024-05-26T14:14:18 | 2024-05-26T14:14:18 |
Shanghaoran Quan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Constructing high-quality query-response pairs from custom corpus is crucial
for supervised fine-tuning (SFT) large language models (LLMs) in many
applications, like creating domain-specific AI assistants or roleplaying
agents. However, sourcing this data through human annotation is costly, and
existing automated methods often fail to capture the diverse range of
contextual granularity and tend to produce homogeneous data. To tackle these
issues, we introduce a novel method named AugCon, capable of automatically
generating context-driven SFT data across multiple levels of granularity with
high diversity, quality and fidelity. AugCon begins by generating queries using
the Context-Split-Tree (CST), an innovative approach for recursively deriving
queries and splitting context to cover full granularity. Then, we train a
scorer through contrastive learning to collaborate with CST to rank and refine
queries. Finally, a synergistic integration of self-alignment and
self-improving is introduced to obtain high-fidelity responses.
Extensive experiments are conducted incorporating both human and automatic
evaluations, encompassing a test scenario and four widely-used benchmarks in
English and Chinese. The results highlight the significant advantages of AugCon
in producing high diversity, quality, and fidelity SFT data against several
state-of-the-art methods. All of our code, dataset, and fine-tuned model will
be available at: https://github.com/quanshr/AugCon.
|
[
-0.6891833543777466,
-1.0514367818832397,
0.14815787971019745,
0.2017209529876709,
0.026298588141798973,
0.008974315598607063,
-0.3843545615673065,
-0.4141048491001129,
0.2323925942182541,
0.4852101504802704,
-0.42980605363845825,
-0.5673925280570984,
-0.09173573553562164,
0.35645827651023865,
-0.5767273306846619,
0.9356291890144348,
-0.07204504311084747,
-0.20631937682628632,
-0.32696375250816345,
-0.1717461198568344,
-0.22328054904937744,
-0.43009695410728455,
-0.6794254779815674,
0.10882307589054108,
0.21874451637268066,
0.38136428594589233,
0.5561967492103577,
0.7184035181999207,
0.43157851696014404,
0.3628697395324707,
0.08218667656183243,
0.7064067721366882,
-0.5051805377006531,
0.258694589138031,
-0.07434146851301193,
-0.24241013824939728,
-0.2536461055278778,
-0.0642707422375679,
0.691387414932251,
0.6744728088378906,
-0.067779041826725,
-0.09513627737760544,
0.19385431706905365,
0.45540329813957214,
-0.44928520917892456,
0.013229514472186565,
-0.9146599173545837,
-0.1100461408495903,
-0.09329874068498611,
-0.4171372950077057,
-0.20174764096736908,
-0.16868776082992554,
-0.04655661806464195,
-0.6701636910438538,
0.3937930762767792,
0.10248202830553055,
0.7704331278800964,
0.5236786603927612,
-0.5662224888801575,
-0.18111400306224823,
-0.35133054852485657,
0.5184057950973511,
-0.710986852645874,
0.3191588819026947,
0.4382694959640503,
0.2086549997329712,
-0.3197903633117676,
-0.6927210092544556,
-0.3157320022583008,
-0.26601970195770264,
-0.4192551076412201,
0.13670994341373444,
0.39708226919174194,
-0.05916333943605423,
0.14707821607589722,
0.5863136053085327,
-0.44667455554008484,
0.09842964261770248,
-0.26257821917533875,
-0.28791460394859314,
0.9624902606010437,
0.32255950570106506,
0.156963050365448,
-0.21391046047210693,
-0.29284387826919556,
0.18888749182224274,
-0.604972779750824,
0.22262844443321228,
0.44245171546936035,
0.4600079655647278,
-0.004379570949822664,
0.38949722051620483,
-0.6836703419685364,
0.7666859030723572,
0.4090646803379059,
-0.10205697268247604,
0.2868994176387787,
-0.8587774038314819,
-0.04310071840882301,
-0.2283223420381546,
1.0797126293182373,
0.09220138192176819,
0.02215542644262314,
-0.3186805248260498,
-0.39875176548957825,
-0.2774657607078552,
0.23936080932617188,
-0.9978229403495789,
-0.29381486773490906,
0.23859326541423798,
-0.1022026464343071,
-0.301679402589798,
0.0493948832154274,
-0.45104843378067017,
-0.08820861577987671,
-0.5550480484962463,
0.14634466171264648,
-0.5794060826301575,
-0.0422428622841835,
-0.2670098841190338,
0.2667897343635559,
0.261810302734375,
0.45295894145965576,
-0.9362457990646362,
0.31119614839553833,
0.5356505513191223,
0.7656849026679993,
-0.5693225860595703,
-0.44893476366996765,
-0.8625478744506836,
-0.07056425511837006,
-0.5388636589050293,
0.7656479477882385,
-0.5246788859367371,
-0.33481934666633606,
-0.10644795745611191,
0.003571396227926016,
-0.045213352888822556,
-0.4472109079360962,
0.41965946555137634,
-0.2809296250343323,
0.3797547519207001,
-0.19129227101802826,
-0.3904149532318115,
0.19344422221183777,
0.4900442063808441,
-0.4550407826900482,
1.3100733757019043,
0.2523230016231537,
-0.8625842332839966,
0.32866236567497253,
-0.5692364573478699,
-0.7441444396972656,
0.17215131223201752,
-0.5481013655662537,
-0.11249303817749023,
0.14661017060279846,
0.6035753488540649,
0.3319169580936432,
-0.11768385767936707,
0.24591811001300812,
-0.1306474655866623,
-0.3216884732246399,
0.08573770523071289,
-0.3742048442363739,
0.5296267867088318,
0.20500782132148743,
-0.19074177742004395,
0.2495981901884079,
-0.7456993460655212,
-0.04347582906484604,
-0.04221545532345772,
-0.5094717741012573,
-0.3203638792037964,
0.007139549590647221,
0.02717452310025692,
0.3738328516483307,
0.39148974418640137,
-0.39576998353004456,
0.2619457244873047,
-0.6068605780601501,
0.5994055867195129,
0.5922231674194336,
0.006657200865447521,
0.3966507315635681,
-0.11014765501022339,
0.4234643876552582,
0.06800761818885803,
0.07903178781270981,
-0.6362616419792175,
-0.09177114814519882,
-0.5855870246887207,
-0.24339014291763306,
0.14142298698425293,
0.4067814350128174,
-0.7665795087814331,
0.5152704119682312,
-0.20564714074134827,
-0.23243364691734314,
-0.6035106778144836,
0.2155313789844513,
0.2023286670446396,
0.747462272644043,
0.3365112543106079,
-0.3957420289516449,
-0.30995264649391174,
-0.9526965618133545,
-0.03502523899078369,
0.03639310225844383,
0.0417221263051033,
0.7731695175170898,
0.4079102575778961,
-0.22967760264873505,
1.1975576877593994,
-0.4251954257488251,
-0.3886195719242096,
0.25901976227760315,
0.21637463569641113,
-0.07762382924556732,
0.5388805866241455,
0.5890206098556519,
-0.8686489462852478,
-0.4979551434516907,
0.37541699409484863,
-0.4713514745235443,
-0.4297311305999756,
-0.15889905393123627,
-0.46777844429016113,
0.2622224688529968,
0.6351820826530457,
-0.14724509418010712,
0.08237752318382263,
0.4957173764705658,
-0.30976587533950806,
0.6661961078643799,
-0.004893575794994831,
0.6067121028900146,
-1.388167142868042,
0.11337317526340485,
-0.10583607107400894,
-0.4106237590312958,
-0.30918750166893005,
0.15546272695064545,
-0.010180093348026276,
0.19662803411483765,
-0.42820411920547485,
0.42555826902389526,
-0.28138938546180725,
-0.025234520435333252,
-0.2922702729701996,
0.08697012811899185,
0.010736439377069473,
0.5399312973022461,
0.012222823686897755,
1.1757134199142456,
0.22359338402748108,
-0.5496352314949036,
0.37899357080459595,
0.479326069355011,
-0.1085440143942833,
0.7495654225349426,
-0.623255729675293,
-0.026517709717154503,
0.057232651859521866,
0.2351093590259552,
-1.0161370038986206,
-0.623950719833374,
-0.10320431739091873,
-0.4767465889453888,
0.04993995651602745,
-0.363873153924942,
-0.5772600173950195,
-0.10506849735975266,
-0.2697959840297699,
0.49742668867111206,
0.1492820382118225,
-0.7235241532325745,
0.47113046050071716,
0.34800833463668823,
-0.17705608904361725,
-0.4631114900112152,
-0.7969373464584351,
0.09749411791563034,
-0.19562813639640808,
-0.8028247356414795,
0.5386868119239807,
-0.3174036741256714,
0.04841228201985359,
-0.13535580039024353,
-0.10739119350910187,
-0.23626597225666046,
0.20342792570590973,
0.25384974479675293,
0.013211534358561039,
-0.1389491856098175,
0.04625941440463066,
0.3309016525745392,
0.13138674199581146,
-0.07665925472974777,
-0.3746328353881836,
0.5490726828575134,
-0.31651613116264343,
-0.49345463514328003,
-0.1984313279390335,
0.2883223593235016,
0.25634002685546875,
-0.5357311367988586,
0.34522008895874023,
0.7976810932159424,
-0.29884475469589233,
-0.30527904629707336,
-0.5410580635070801,
-0.17065471410751343,
-0.4808211624622345,
0.23003359138965607,
-0.5841899514198303,
-1.3120263814926147,
0.5952995419502258,
0.06471213698387146,
0.46400541067123413,
0.4126858413219452,
0.6847862005233765,
0.17990905046463013,
1.125306248664856,
0.43519631028175354,
-0.06521877646446228,
0.6234359741210938,
-0.10269223898649216,
-0.10379581898450851,
-0.7467920780181885,
0.05089607089757919,
-0.42928698658943176,
-0.18422499299049377,
-0.6440626978874207,
-0.32629305124282837,
0.40267154574394226,
0.06313157081604004,
-0.2583107650279999,
0.3362860679626465,
-0.6975435018539429,
0.6471781134605408,
0.4598751962184906,
-0.20820526778697968,
0.5846810340881348,
-0.027117930352687836,
-0.0033336065243929625,
0.018454987555742264,
-0.38300514221191406,
-0.20947480201721191,
0.9467338919639587,
0.06202547252178192,
0.7728801369667053,
-0.04465387389063835,
0.9831060171127319,
0.05220566317439079,
0.14948059618473053,
-0.7739850282669067,
0.28716984391212463,
-0.056218262761831284,
-0.45163899660110474,
-0.32575955986976624,
-0.7923282384872437,
-0.7454851269721985,
0.5056734681129456,
-0.0384615883231163,
-0.5489248037338257,
-0.021006029099225998,
0.17436783015727997,
-0.4746052026748657,
-0.15368618071079254,
-0.5990402698516846,
0.7893609404563904,
-0.44252604246139526,
-0.5933653712272644,
0.1288989782333374,
-0.6874756813049316,
0.5814777612686157,
-0.26642298698425293,
0.10667929798364639,
-0.10161596536636353,
-0.2084842026233673,
0.5829738974571228,
-0.3683463931083679,
0.6720167994499207,
0.13618981838226318,
-0.27084219455718994,
0.3263343274593353,
0.2238267958164215,
0.5274688005447388,
0.5104889869689941,
-0.0888514593243599,
-0.04984113946557045,
0.20912039279937744,
-0.3048434257507324,
-0.36739975214004517,
0.9525958299636841,
-0.596980094909668,
-0.4811440110206604,
-0.11457698047161102,
-0.8239158391952515,
-0.3059239983558655,
0.40957608819007874,
0.2887893617153168,
0.3578990697860718,
-0.18966875970363617,
0.22030232846736908,
0.44952476024627686,
-0.10411252826452255,
0.3854358494281769,
0.5595217943191528,
-0.25994589924812317,
-0.6884848475456238,
0.7523139715194702,
0.12581907212734222,
0.19229596853256226,
0.2668567895889282,
0.07423148304224014,
-0.08871352672576904,
-0.6712144017219543,
-0.46205928921699524,
-0.03280376270413399,
-0.36868816614151,
-0.2768479883670807,
-0.6013592481613159,
-0.32489433884620667,
-0.6285327076911926,
-0.26506680250167847,
-0.4530295729637146,
-0.26246681809425354,
-0.014383826404809952,
0.04317831993103027,
0.37865692377090454,
0.3294107913970947,
0.08385422080755234,
0.3698282837867737,
-0.6715922951698303,
0.23384828865528107,
0.25753793120384216,
0.3234439790248871,
-0.3055999279022217,
-0.4586482048034668,
-0.4063540995121002,
0.029635071754455566,
-0.2284315824508667,
-0.36432409286499023,
0.4781363606452942,
0.32759514451026917,
0.4427115321159363,
0.30054229497909546,
0.11956155300140381,
0.8571298122406006,
-0.43401262164115906,
0.8963367342948914,
-0.18964844942092896,
-0.7568954229354858,
0.586600124835968,
-0.5395499467849731,
0.2826288640499115,
1.068300724029541,
0.11455792188644409,
-0.5197033882141113,
-0.38139548897743225,
-0.5750951170921326,
-1.1784836053848267,
0.8674195408821106,
0.13361510634422302,
0.12738348543643951,
-0.1158827543258667,
0.3127528727054596,
0.385429322719574,
0.40744492411613464,
-0.5296977162361145,
-0.009332899935543537,
-0.07458649575710297,
-0.22093766927719116,
0.20610985159873962,
0.17801132798194885,
-0.36304616928100586,
-0.28136754035949707,
0.6110557913780212,
-0.6317919492721558,
-0.18795070052146912,
0.2901739776134491,
-0.3199339210987091,
-0.07840238511562347,
0.09967633336782455,
0.24311168491840363,
0.491934597492218,
0.09046406298875809,
0.09243786334991455,
0.3842804729938507,
-0.1969674527645111,
-0.2406243234872818,
0.34443095326423645,
-0.2433817982673645,
-0.24907048046588898,
0.36497482657432556,
0.6098873615264893,
0.1325751543045044,
-0.7203927040100098,
0.49400779604911804,
-0.12320787459611893,
-0.11118628084659576,
-0.3312376141548157,
0.1835549771785736,
-0.09233006089925766,
0.1339324712753296,
0.21611876785755157,
-0.167332261800766,
0.3023979365825653,
-0.23924145102500916,
0.5364965200424194,
0.5066350698471069,
-0.08484236896038055,
-0.2596410810947418,
0.7011886239051819,
0.47766852378845215,
0.10157712548971176,
0.5977509617805481,
-0.32295697927474976,
-0.38845115900039673,
0.44653403759002686,
0.3673960566520691,
0.6121071577072144,
-0.08514312654733658,
0.028698300942778587,
0.46131008863449097,
0.18947286903858185,
-0.04418318718671799,
-0.013491177000105381,
-0.5303267240524292,
-0.5334229469299316,
-0.588437557220459,
-0.8288540244102478,
-0.24625691771507263,
-0.019235266372561455,
-0.40885743498802185,
0.3337496519088745,
-0.36276498436927795,
0.11525911092758179,
-0.24155139923095703,
0.16090688109397888,
-0.6310617923736572,
0.08040663599967957,
0.24676579236984253,
0.8143655061721802,
-0.7699368000030518,
0.6772302985191345,
0.6956928372383118,
-0.7428873777389526,
-0.7576677203178406,
0.08896341174840927,
-0.17090442776679993,
-0.7177709341049194,
0.32899537682533264,
0.33642929792404175,
0.04807096719741821,
0.06695301830768585,
-0.6712150573730469,
-1.0102049112319946,
1.1978416442871094,
0.2808077335357666,
-0.5227007865905762,
-0.0446796752512455,
0.12115193158388138,
0.5798959732055664,
-0.6220858097076416,
0.47652509808540344,
0.8717654943466187,
0.3853316009044647,
0.11097489297389984,
-0.9926959872245789,
-0.022982267662882805,
-0.26651954650878906,
0.02578098699450493,
0.32160699367523193,
-0.8051896095275879,
0.7500138282775879,
0.0894365906715393,
-0.17522411048412323,
-0.06996750086545944,
0.7426490783691406,
0.1925714910030365,
0.187849223613739,
0.5318725109100342,
0.6188643574714661,
0.5766555070877075,
-0.12702897191047668,
0.6602314114570618,
-0.608353853225708,
0.2871699333190918,
1.2615793943405151,
-0.13323931396007538,
0.7223829030990601,
0.37052783370018005,
-0.15025900304317474,
0.2608347535133362,
0.8123011589050293,
0.002551656449213624,
0.22750817239284515,
0.01562395878136158,
-0.07785443961620331,
-0.3427176773548126,
-0.22816479206085205,
-0.25235190987586975,
0.4304574131965637,
0.40186968445777893,
-0.27620553970336914,
-0.1698223501443863,
-0.22425973415374756,
-0.11471054702997208,
0.18291029334068298,
-0.102262943983078,
0.9338331818580627,
-0.012255639769136906,
-0.7759995460510254,
0.5772010684013367,
-0.10049348324537277,
1.0929619073867798,
-0.5026348829269409,
0.180769145488739,
-0.4569340944290161,
-0.15338186919689178,
-0.6858532428741455,
-0.7156191468238831,
0.2875622808933258,
-0.04683724045753479,
0.01829969696700573,
0.0072101447731256485,
0.4529777467250824,
-0.7794755101203918,
-0.4275341331958771,
0.08836879581212997,
0.419875830411911,
0.10446533560752869,
-0.08749816566705704,
-0.6312280297279358,
-0.05316253378987312,
-0.023731980472803116,
-0.510205864906311,
0.3448246717453003,
0.6186807155609131,
-0.2490490823984146,
0.42479968070983887,
0.7559624314308167,
-0.07219916582107544,
0.14841555058956146,
0.10580191761255264,
0.8537588119506836,
-0.4605717957019806,
-0.546714723110199,
-0.6141158938407898,
0.5442107915878296,
-0.25111067295074463,
-0.4541594684123993,
0.6018423438072205,
0.7664400935173035,
1.0518783330917358,
0.3218587338924408,
0.9629459381103516,
-0.21878741681575775,
0.23741702735424042,
-0.2964004874229431,
0.521740198135376,
-0.677436888217926,
0.30229586362838745,
0.0468183234333992,
-0.8549555540084839,
-0.1147085651755333,
0.4364842176437378,
-0.2052452713251114,
0.14679844677448273,
0.516700029373169,
0.8803660273551941,
-0.3047553598880768,
-0.19659894704818726,
0.15933622419834137,
0.11414025723934174,
0.5744403600692749,
0.5175516605377197,
0.5937201976776123,
-0.3165070712566376,
0.6826990246772766,
-0.4792138338088989,
-0.23065690696239471,
-0.25046399235725403,
-0.5836429595947266,
-0.7891115546226501,
-0.6812732219696045,
-0.33784404397010803,
-0.3005915880203247,
-0.20038604736328125,
1.1393195390701294,
0.7605078816413879,
-0.8739953637123108,
-0.05815848708152771,
-0.1848563253879547,
-0.15948137640953064,
-0.0735209733247757,
-0.29898521304130554,
0.39715805649757385,
-0.7848103642463684,
-0.9651586413383484,
0.5150228142738342,
0.25638139247894287,
-0.15280765295028687,
-0.38350027799606323,
-0.08274949342012405,
0.07280327379703522,
-0.09784241020679474,
0.6466078758239746,
0.13516612350940704,
-0.6447764039039612,
-0.1871286928653717,
-0.10071362555027008,
-0.3076591193675995,
0.1528734266757965,
0.6397154331207275,
-1.0069892406463623,
0.33399903774261475,
0.7795472145080566,
0.9466125965118408,
0.25930944085121155,
0.4472631812095642,
0.5199512839317322,
-1.0149542093276978,
-0.01300881989300251,
0.33146369457244873,
0.3803924024105072,
0.5033073425292969,
-0.4752557575702667,
0.8145577907562256,
0.0004604957939591259,
-0.7004578113555908,
-0.7572739124298096,
0.3079852759838104,
-0.9906851053237915,
-0.17812807857990265,
1.2797459363937378,
0.09080196171998978,
-0.14220298826694489,
0.14829306304454803,
-0.4522363245487213,
0.0124262860044837,
-0.5877478122711182,
0.7829983830451965,
0.554638683795929,
-0.36955976486206055,
0.09167130291461945,
-0.3913923501968384,
0.4658468961715698,
0.26139357686042786,
-1.0538874864578247,
0.30100369453430176,
0.7690017223358154,
0.32409998774528503,
-0.03107898309826851,
0.5297864675521851,
-0.2063787430524826,
0.07168940454721451,
-0.1521410495042801,
-0.061081960797309875,
-0.3550962209701538,
-0.10713957250118256,
-0.1688700020313263,
0.3081750273704529,
0.06219073385000229,
0.07978583872318268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16571v1
|
A Preliminary Empirical Study on Prompt-based Unsupervised Keyphrase Extraction
| 2024-05-26T13:37:57 | 2024-05-26T13:37:57 |
Mingyang Song, Yi Feng, Liping Jing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained large language models can perform natural language processing
downstream tasks by conditioning on human-designed prompts. However, a
prompt-based approach often requires "prompt engineering" to design different
prompts, primarily hand-crafted through laborious trial and error, requiring
human intervention and expertise. It is a challenging problem when constructing
a prompt-based keyphrase extraction method. Therefore, we investigate and study
the effectiveness of different prompts on the keyphrase extraction task to
verify the impact of the cherry-picked prompts on the performance of extracting
keyphrases. Extensive experimental results on six benchmark keyphrase
extraction datasets and different pre-trained large language models demonstrate
that (1) designing complex prompts may not necessarily be more effective than
designing simple prompts; (2) individual keyword changes in the designed
prompts can affect the overall performance; (3) designing complex prompts
achieve better performance than designing simple prompts when facing long
documents.
|
[
-0.21334104239940643,
-0.7301801443099976,
0.7653099894523621,
0.3658554255962372,
-0.422027051448822,
0.29921600222587585,
-0.35671716928482056,
-0.1452544778585434,
-0.07313399761915207,
0.38825416564941406,
-0.6068729758262634,
-0.28495174646377563,
-0.5437604784965515,
0.5233895182609558,
0.030844613909721375,
0.6189454793930054,
0.12684711813926697,
0.013248894363641739,
0.10979650914669037,
0.35521751642227173,
-0.8203511238098145,
-0.4641759991645813,
-0.17984646558761597,
-0.017813298851251602,
0.587550699710846,
0.575416088104248,
0.5391369462013245,
0.30608057975769043,
0.6191892623901367,
0.26263558864593506,
-0.36275801062583923,
-0.15207144618034363,
0.02126169204711914,
0.5690352320671082,
-0.2484389692544937,
-0.35320138931274414,
0.2269165813922882,
0.4447203278541565,
0.16120560467243195,
0.5908608436584473,
0.23312824964523315,
-0.05336117371916771,
0.3000357449054718,
0.6019203662872314,
-0.7216075658798218,
0.1283896118402481,
-0.49887943267822266,
-0.08687030524015427,
-0.3705361485481262,
-0.2859702706336975,
-0.5191836953163147,
-0.4084089398384094,
0.4972933232784271,
-0.4901537299156189,
0.1107998862862587,
0.2421286404132843,
0.4845522344112396,
-0.0638854131102562,
-0.1489822268486023,
-0.8452877402305603,
-0.3759166896343231,
0.6686951518058777,
-0.7223473191261292,
0.2500148117542267,
-0.006103345192968845,
0.3565342426300049,
-0.41778290271759033,
-0.7908679842948914,
-0.14604096114635468,
-0.3601379990577698,
-0.05490616336464882,
0.041877299547195435,
0.1842755824327469,
0.31590792536735535,
0.6315717697143555,
0.20948076248168945,
-0.4796358048915863,
0.37843379378318787,
-0.3905196785926819,
-0.19744709134101868,
0.37409329414367676,
-0.06577605754137039,
0.4985862672328949,
-0.6377151012420654,
-0.09148082882165909,
-0.32063958048820496,
-0.7155453562736511,
0.7676637768745422,
0.1305803507566452,
0.7016139030456543,
0.183444544672966,
0.5684230923652649,
-0.5750787854194641,
0.3141774535179138,
0.0004529996949713677,
-0.09646739065647125,
0.1512776017189026,
-0.16622622311115265,
0.08261098712682724,
0.07651553303003311,
0.7687252163887024,
0.259465754032135,
0.46231788396835327,
-0.6974660158157349,
-0.3840700089931488,
-0.02153002843260765,
0.19808721542358398,
-0.9102308750152588,
-0.40933364629745483,
0.24412015080451965,
-0.6801815032958984,
-0.5009134411811829,
0.16464953124523163,
-1.1180237531661987,
-0.4865691363811493,
-0.22324925661087036,
0.5794307589530945,
-0.2559080719947815,
0.03461465239524841,
-0.12339313328266144,
-0.7401590943336487,
0.1407453715801239,
0.2085973620414734,
-0.7261476516723633,
0.012846976518630981,
0.6735042333602905,
0.8350560665130615,
-0.6518594026565552,
-0.08534256368875504,
-0.7459246516227722,
-0.5054594278335571,
-0.22283531725406647,
0.8282870650291443,
-0.898431122303009,
-0.7580171823501587,
0.018828127533197403,
0.021739836782217026,
-0.11157254129648209,
-0.5294681787490845,
0.913910984992981,
-0.6829501390457153,
0.3624936044216156,
-0.7837210893630981,
-0.5821506381034851,
0.028322968631982803,
-0.17950740456581116,
-0.6427792906761169,
0.5626462697982788,
-0.2036793977022171,
-0.5381103754043579,
0.404742956161499,
-0.8652351498603821,
-0.5992447137832642,
0.23697255551815033,
-0.2684515118598938,
0.0410303995013237,
0.4309793710708618,
0.546832263469696,
0.3296521306037903,
-0.58149254322052,
0.22274163365364075,
-0.1941889077425003,
-0.4155272841453552,
0.6070847511291504,
-0.4831356704235077,
1.043839454650879,
0.4030933380126953,
-0.5535672903060913,
-0.13641637563705444,
-0.6235796213150024,
0.08133311569690704,
-0.058590006083250046,
-0.2949371039867401,
-0.3778432607650757,
-0.11024734377861023,
0.0034223387483507395,
0.2668623924255371,
0.1464873105287552,
-0.66150963306427,
0.3723355233669281,
-0.47539404034614563,
0.3902188241481781,
0.7869215607643127,
0.284643292427063,
0.4701937437057495,
-0.10202046483755112,
0.7850825786590576,
-0.33870163559913635,
-0.041759248822927475,
-0.4610934257507324,
-0.5505293607711792,
-0.006600986234843731,
-0.4969621002674103,
0.4887261688709259,
0.42900413274765015,
-0.7546741366386414,
0.1295728236436844,
0.016982806846499443,
-0.44832828640937805,
-0.16026945412158966,
0.04908869415521622,
0.38989466428756714,
0.5960614681243896,
0.2059435397386551,
-0.11556419730186462,
-0.26809996366500854,
-0.5550795793533325,
-0.6704445481300354,
0.04999561607837677,
-0.12889225780963898,
0.12409436702728271,
0.3998633623123169,
0.20614275336265564,
1.2609494924545288,
-0.7359514832496643,
0.19325582683086395,
-0.23896752297878265,
0.5932903289794922,
0.5540148019790649,
0.3072824478149414,
0.364566445350647,
-0.7822492718696594,
-0.5414455533027649,
-0.4524219036102295,
-0.683014452457428,
-0.5125529766082764,
-0.23991253972053528,
0.024009494110941887,
-0.445529043674469,
0.5185573101043701,
-0.9960702657699585,
0.2830163538455963,
-0.12887948751449585,
-0.15359601378440857,
0.8688912987709045,
-0.12288106977939606,
0.367674857378006,
-0.733683705329895,
0.2934126555919647,
-0.09742558747529984,
0.44996950030326843,
-0.6543911695480347,
0.172336146235466,
0.35341423749923706,
-0.4524286389350891,
-0.6230180859565735,
0.5083750486373901,
-0.6601261496543884,
0.03091355971992016,
-0.41390126943588257,
-0.10020279884338379,
0.03558971732854843,
0.47180745005607605,
0.06723596155643463,
1.1149245500564575,
0.48136353492736816,
-0.7606812715530396,
0.1823190301656723,
0.1599375158548355,
-0.4094949960708618,
0.4249926805496216,
-1.0476775169372559,
0.20889239013195038,
-0.1656348556280136,
-0.14735792577266693,
-1.2525131702423096,
-0.04723278060555458,
0.12450908124446869,
-0.341557115316391,
0.2472638636827469,
0.001079790061339736,
-0.46363571286201477,
-0.406276673078537,
-0.45664453506469727,
0.10685956478118896,
0.6862455606460571,
-0.5374649167060852,
0.3912421762943268,
0.04830612987279892,
-0.6603633165359497,
-0.15676091611385345,
0.08459927141666412,
0.25578978657722473,
-0.47792646288871765,
-0.29441508650779724,
0.3183594346046448,
-0.11765468865633011,
-0.3336161971092224,
-0.43035459518432617,
-0.17568695545196533,
-0.001893044332973659,
0.5299288630485535,
0.5132103562355042,
0.2265237271785736,
0.1588541567325592,
0.19617772102355957,
0.06613738089799881,
-0.11436434090137482,
0.37988653779029846,
0.14222568273544312,
0.4116075932979584,
0.29657772183418274,
-0.28912830352783203,
-0.5466045141220093,
0.5033804774284363,
0.7964026927947998,
-0.5545221567153931,
0.1799398809671402,
-0.00846496969461441,
-0.23354558646678925,
0.09826108068227768,
-0.4601958692073822,
-0.530266523361206,
-0.5772086381912231,
0.14032234251499176,
-0.5229805111885071,
-0.4827730059623718,
0.30087971687316895,
-0.43715372681617737,
0.5252700448036194,
0.3315803110599518,
0.23019438982009888,
-0.43844377994537354,
1.1223286390304565,
0.31200993061065674,
-0.04691168665885925,
0.49154767394065857,
0.1487955003976822,
-0.017012128606438637,
-0.6894906163215637,
-0.03995942696928978,
-0.9808820486068726,
-0.2893902063369751,
-0.4337477684020996,
0.08265756070613861,
0.2927224934101105,
0.2571812868118286,
0.0716342180967331,
0.26516327261924744,
-0.4774710536003113,
0.2206263393163681,
0.7813892960548401,
0.08155740052461624,
0.12329202890396118,
-0.01888471655547619,
-0.3221973180770874,
-0.26490217447280884,
-0.41690441966056824,
-0.46360987424850464,
1.148383378982544,
0.05841301754117012,
0.7402692437171936,
-0.16023394465446472,
0.5728855729103088,
0.38811615109443665,
-0.04414498805999756,
-0.5708534121513367,
0.35369673371315,
0.14353731274604797,
-0.4634319543838501,
-0.298579603433609,
-0.23003198206424713,
-1.162095308303833,
0.2918538749217987,
-0.2112402319908142,
-0.7420064806938171,
0.2218007594347,
-0.21372739970684052,
-0.6137093901634216,
-0.3294414281845093,
-0.7505619525909424,
0.7907586097717285,
-0.3731738030910492,
0.09993991255760193,
0.1589052826166153,
-0.6722421050071716,
-0.11517272144556046,
-0.3208354413509369,
0.29890650510787964,
0.12451313436031342,
0.1911458969116211,
1.0851958990097046,
-0.43503469228744507,
0.6350429654121399,
-0.32691794633865356,
0.12859047949314117,
0.2856348156929016,
-0.06945446878671646,
0.9658417105674744,
-0.09784814715385437,
-0.16724492609500885,
-0.3226398229598999,
-0.18692892789840698,
-0.04791232571005821,
-0.7771310210227966,
0.21671225130558014,
-0.5025283098220825,
-0.7884768843650818,
-0.15054327249526978,
-0.3050745129585266,
-0.4303833544254303,
0.31472986936569214,
0.698610246181488,
0.6458980441093445,
-0.0932958647608757,
0.31454551219940186,
0.6609858274459839,
-0.26473554968833923,
0.8830956816673279,
0.49146562814712524,
0.007972128689289093,
-0.3081011176109314,
0.6070541143417358,
0.22380466759204865,
0.07343285530805588,
0.45656952261924744,
0.5386170148849487,
-0.4381084144115448,
-0.5300368666648865,
-0.29308950901031494,
-0.006914457306265831,
-0.5446573495864868,
0.10105129331350327,
-0.7969228029251099,
0.002540809102356434,
-0.787564754486084,
-0.1707184761762619,
-0.18396443128585815,
-0.3742336630821228,
-0.3813017010688782,
0.04743219166994095,
0.34196779131889343,
0.25811710953712463,
0.14313171803951263,
0.5531219840049744,
-0.9696068167686462,
0.3526779115200043,
0.5024043917655945,
-0.2748214304447174,
-0.18098291754722595,
-0.5641414523124695,
0.11666154116392136,
-0.003091852879151702,
-0.020899537950754166,
-1.2378790378570557,
0.203208327293396,
-0.07075662165880203,
0.726754903793335,
0.4100475311279297,
0.4558759033679962,
0.23525620996952057,
-0.4921160936355591,
0.853234052658081,
0.15004374086856842,
-0.5863990783691406,
0.701485812664032,
-0.1127769947052002,
0.5308749675750732,
0.852293848991394,
0.27815765142440796,
-0.3686990439891815,
-0.2459000200033188,
-0.47081685066223145,
-0.6476079821586609,
0.43294766545295715,
0.2468719780445099,
-0.12228389829397202,
-0.0656861886382103,
0.39086681604385376,
0.3501272201538086,
0.42282435297966003,
-0.1022326648235321,
-0.16716711223125458,
0.18566900491714478,
-0.07432444393634796,
-0.07997439056634903,
-0.367733359336853,
0.29668566584587097,
0.08975493907928467,
0.1555471122264862,
0.16076774895191193,
-0.06701397150754929,
0.14103448390960693,
-0.4470070004463196,
0.2501758635044098,
0.5334509015083313,
0.405340313911438,
0.35792428255081177,
-0.30693960189819336,
0.1108522042632103,
-0.14343145489692688,
-0.5804253220558167,
0.177615687251091,
0.05775577202439308,
-0.3950949013233185,
0.1550159901380539,
0.583067774772644,
0.47759756445884705,
0.3700152337551117,
-0.7366650700569153,
0.5033649206161499,
-0.11729773133993149,
0.025682006031274796,
0.3383699357509613,
0.1261797845363617,
-0.22299809753894806,
0.2416532337665558,
0.7378644347190857,
-0.08917059004306793,
0.4015040099620819,
-0.5299356579780579,
0.2793371081352234,
0.6517452001571655,
-0.20166249573230743,
-0.3064647614955902,
0.500831663608551,
0.37276843190193176,
-0.6750463843345642,
0.6283730864524841,
-0.09334369003772736,
-0.7200350165367126,
0.5978268384933472,
0.33496585488319397,
1.0423144102096558,
-0.08273011445999146,
0.308403879404068,
0.108180470764637,
0.1650761067867279,
-0.1588396579027176,
0.20779921114444733,
-0.3337719440460205,
-0.1788962036371231,
-0.3758896589279175,
-0.3948718309402466,
-0.3742360472679138,
-0.049669381231069565,
-0.54487544298172,
0.08852409571409225,
-0.18939271569252014,
-0.2995088994503021,
0.17260827124118805,
0.2308259904384613,
-0.7488207817077637,
0.2127484232187271,
-0.37551912665367126,
0.8467528820037842,
-0.8760676383972168,
0.2813889682292938,
0.6725331544876099,
-0.48864081501960754,
-0.8295482397079468,
0.006659696809947491,
-0.1415281742811203,
-0.554924488067627,
0.7592516541481018,
0.40952903032302856,
0.29488620162010193,
-0.12488014250993729,
-0.4068376421928406,
-0.7714975476264954,
0.787979006767273,
-0.025940794497728348,
-0.47697940468788147,
-0.35952243208885193,
0.15036539733409882,
0.2862248718738556,
-0.29528042674064636,
0.29009929299354553,
0.4016626477241516,
0.3330327272415161,
0.08995168656110764,
-0.8014624118804932,
0.1430371254682541,
-0.22055143117904663,
-0.03122635744512081,
-0.1002170518040657,
-0.05839727446436882,
1.0605356693267822,
-0.055909689515829086,
-0.4484231173992157,
0.09238085150718689,
0.5687682032585144,
0.43588510155677795,
0.17687664926052094,
0.5387786030769348,
0.012377909384667873,
0.810448169708252,
0.32366064190864563,
0.7525337934494019,
-0.31395503878593445,
-0.04204258322715759,
0.9335097074508667,
-0.29565665125846863,
0.544230580329895,
0.6134387850761414,
0.029147503897547722,
0.13725371658802032,
0.6678157448768616,
0.26245585083961487,
1.0794142484664917,
-0.07533030211925507,
0.01476468425244093,
-0.19714879989624023,
-0.07173758745193481,
-0.4363575279712677,
0.3000028133392334,
0.14459703862667084,
-0.5204091668128967,
-0.4526812732219696,
0.3324616253376007,
-0.062391497194767,
-0.19019687175750732,
-0.1552543044090271,
0.6135129332542419,
0.1604864001274109,
-0.9710161685943604,
0.1464512199163437,
-0.17092037200927734,
0.7143524885177612,
-0.1591596007347107,
0.042025648057460785,
-0.012266150675714016,
-0.2457006573677063,
0.17965255677700043,
-0.6605562567710876,
-0.3739900290966034,
0.2385493516921997,
-0.1108754575252533,
-0.31604301929473877,
0.8518733978271484,
0.060579635202884674,
-0.21165277063846588,
-0.26029273867607117,
0.6842781901359558,
0.15594299137592316,
-0.6653122901916504,
-0.5681553483009338,
-0.05677169933915138,
0.05184914544224739,
-0.5177747011184692,
0.23175032436847687,
0.5853998064994812,
0.08035188913345337,
0.3582698404788971,
0.8321230411529541,
0.1818987876176834,
-0.049228981137275696,
-0.1482573300600052,
0.7914417386054993,
-0.7134575843811035,
-0.6489444971084595,
-1.0243548154830933,
0.45857301354408264,
-0.3902362883090973,
-0.4398330748081207,
0.8011849522590637,
0.38822194933891296,
0.11293233931064606,
-0.20663337409496307,
0.8912681937217712,
0.12090300023555756,
0.6495395302772522,
-0.6610264182090759,
0.5001163482666016,
-0.2160196602344513,
0.2328823059797287,
-0.5648370385169983,
-1.0143522024154663,
0.16981945931911469,
0.37037622928619385,
-0.29395875334739685,
-0.07552093267440796,
0.7854375243186951,
0.7931084036827087,
0.35259613394737244,
0.2667464315891266,
0.010461628437042236,
-0.2798798978328705,
0.6424968242645264,
0.26236605644226074,
0.8808175325393677,
-0.13086505234241486,
0.29389074444770813,
-0.32378488779067993,
-0.3921176791191101,
-0.3827894926071167,
-0.7772857546806335,
-0.9380903244018555,
-0.5086885690689087,
-0.1930302083492279,
0.0190937127918005,
0.17648150026798248,
0.9416972994804382,
0.1865459382534027,
-0.5206339955329895,
0.10243767499923706,
-0.16044658422470093,
0.19638405740261078,
-0.1988261342048645,
-0.20525045692920685,
0.5551718473434448,
-0.6537030935287476,
-0.49136021733283997,
0.5737857818603516,
0.1444704383611679,
-0.06105794012546539,
0.15130892395973206,
0.16970707476139069,
0.15363143384456635,
0.006156740244477987,
0.43986204266548157,
0.39542055130004883,
-0.43076640367507935,
-0.3074784576892853,
0.5278644561767578,
-0.3743407428264618,
-0.13767996430397034,
1.0447922945022583,
-0.6641806960105896,
0.44750356674194336,
0.8241168856620789,
0.6988459825515747,
-0.08512970805168152,
0.20362617075443268,
0.7704228162765503,
-0.317295640707016,
-0.22829729318618774,
-0.001777912606485188,
0.20215395092964172,
0.025584526360034943,
-0.3700580894947052,
0.24847492575645447,
0.30161669850349426,
-0.4262370765209198,
-0.8029375076293945,
0.02145593985915184,
-0.7899376749992371,
-0.5756979584693909,
1.3866430521011353,
-0.03693395107984543,
-0.1797669529914856,
-0.2729847729206085,
-0.4819464683532715,
0.18438629806041718,
-0.5361835360527039,
0.8036215901374817,
0.7134532332420349,
0.05000711604952812,
-0.11470553278923035,
-0.31514301896095276,
0.5520581007003784,
0.4238027334213257,
-0.5449448823928833,
0.1526365429162979,
0.25549769401550293,
0.12906615436077118,
0.1795669049024582,
0.5248700976371765,
0.0357741117477417,
0.4298953115940094,
-0.2261531800031662,
-0.15242278575897217,
-0.1031474769115448,
-0.3486078977584839,
-0.32408180832862854,
0.6174840927124023,
0.10297612100839615,
-0.41579556465148926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16552v1
|
SED: Self-Evaluation Decoding Enhances Large Language Models for Better Generation
| 2024-05-26T12:43:18 | 2024-05-26T12:43:18 |
Ziqin Luo, Haixia Han, Haokun Zhao, Guochao Jiang, Chengyu Du, Tingyun Li, Jiaqing Liang, Deqing Yang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing Large Language Models (LLMs) generate text through unidirectional
autoregressive decoding methods to respond to various user queries. These
methods tend to consider token selection in a simple sequential manner, making
it easy to fall into suboptimal options when encountering uncertain tokens,
referred to as chaotic points in our work. Many chaotic points exist in texts
generated by LLMs, and they often significantly affect the quality of
subsequently generated tokens, which can interfere with LLMs' generation. This
paper proposes Self-Evaluation Decoding, SED, a decoding method for enhancing
model generation. Analogous to the human decision-making process, SED
integrates speculation and evaluation steps into the decoding process, allowing
LLMs to make more careful decisions and thus optimize token selection at
chaotic points. Experimental results across various tasks using different LLMs
demonstrate SED's effectiveness.
|
[
-0.25662583112716675,
-0.6600186228752136,
0.5189304351806641,
0.5258806943893433,
-0.5866455435752869,
0.15797127783298492,
-0.02522975206375122,
-0.24018120765686035,
0.19106251001358032,
0.4943993091583252,
-0.5590514540672302,
-0.4248983860015869,
-0.4447202980518341,
0.35126543045043945,
-0.484123557806015,
0.9211511611938477,
0.16568340361118317,
0.20665526390075684,
0.03999735042452812,
0.4068804085254669,
-0.16918842494487762,
-0.8452128767967224,
-0.8860819935798645,
-0.2172289937734604,
0.2108701467514038,
0.09257745742797852,
0.6565556526184082,
0.686695396900177,
0.41803160309791565,
0.3912513852119446,
-0.04736361652612686,
0.3313125967979431,
-0.6182476282119751,
0.6546121835708618,
-0.3502255976200104,
-0.2000071108341217,
-0.3785979449748993,
-0.3340570628643036,
0.47549957036972046,
0.5269781351089478,
-0.07036150991916656,
0.2500664293766022,
0.2099125236272812,
0.44106683135032654,
-0.614325761795044,
-0.022534508258104324,
-0.55356764793396,
0.0527503527700901,
-0.19592398405075073,
-0.5047246813774109,
-0.37536370754241943,
-0.24166339635849,
-0.1736604869365692,
-0.1517319530248642,
0.24454785883426666,
-0.09193754941225052,
0.5295848846435547,
0.33838412165641785,
-0.47274529933929443,
-0.30637940764427185,
-0.6432414054870605,
0.465588241815567,
-0.8470945954322815,
0.579963207244873,
0.3170110285282135,
-0.06751400977373123,
-0.49648481607437134,
-0.6150975823402405,
-0.48436856269836426,
0.12506407499313354,
0.36245426535606384,
0.15304486453533173,
-0.0013679048279300332,
0.1652190089225769,
0.010748048312962055,
0.3103785812854767,
-0.2804364264011383,
0.11993081122636795,
-0.1508590131998062,
-0.38694441318511963,
0.7468463182449341,
0.5243800282478333,
0.208095982670784,
-0.709547758102417,
-0.16926346719264984,
-0.3291757106781006,
-0.49949491024017334,
-0.14792117476463318,
0.6404596567153931,
0.35344579815864563,
0.14327800273895264,
0.5060317516326904,
-0.2602108418941498,
0.46694669127464294,
0.2577037513256073,
0.04329369589686394,
0.2041437178850174,
-0.4290105998516083,
-0.35029563307762146,
-0.32533136010169983,
0.8798609375953674,
0.41234514117240906,
-0.1804487556219101,
-0.06800363212823868,
-0.6660237312316895,
-0.11299736797809601,
0.19758248329162598,
-0.8267332911491394,
-0.2674718201160431,
0.1078222393989563,
-0.8758273720741272,
-0.60105961561203,
-0.09061223268508911,
-0.9792847037315369,
-0.38259637355804443,
-0.045138392597436905,
0.31560012698173523,
-0.4613690972328186,
-0.24315686523914337,
0.36744987964630127,
-0.19742752611637115,
-0.06057162210345268,
0.4317433536052704,
-1.050223708152771,
0.30543723702430725,
0.4429727792739868,
0.6217570304870605,
-0.1754862666130066,
-0.36817657947540283,
-0.3340594172477722,
-0.042108822613954544,
-0.59941166639328,
0.9729217886924744,
-0.5045168399810791,
-0.8118045330047607,
-0.2688532769680023,
-0.3661344051361084,
0.08077732473611832,
-0.47554171085357666,
0.7286940217018127,
-0.5865132212638855,
-0.01080548670142889,
-0.267832487821579,
-0.5151677131652832,
-0.06669759750366211,
-0.07657422870397568,
-0.4761972427368164,
1.1783661842346191,
0.0590929239988327,
-0.7054541110992432,
0.4689752757549286,
-0.49666669964790344,
-0.5857844352722168,
0.13314314186573029,
-0.15494956076145172,
-0.27120107412338257,
0.5636743903160095,
0.49104514718055725,
0.6653017401695251,
-0.22776281833648682,
0.22674329578876495,
-0.41809430718421936,
0.09162942320108414,
0.15928658843040466,
-0.7784976363182068,
0.6351116299629211,
0.8534026741981506,
-0.30822989344596863,
0.04671245440840721,
-0.7537271976470947,
0.38676583766937256,
0.3009110689163208,
-0.5710378885269165,
-0.4254438281059265,
0.20336149632930756,
0.037753425538539886,
0.22783932089805603,
0.246246337890625,
-0.18318764865398407,
0.16624736785888672,
-0.6659148335456848,
0.25727447867393494,
0.9985688328742981,
0.2900945544242859,
0.15030300617218018,
-0.02196621522307396,
0.604498028755188,
0.13387922942638397,
-0.09191548824310303,
-0.4134867489337921,
-0.1717958003282547,
-0.9503995180130005,
0.1112828403711319,
0.4282355010509491,
0.19776248931884766,
-0.676896333694458,
0.6995095014572144,
-0.03951244801282883,
-0.4220009744167328,
-0.5565798282623291,
0.2715010941028595,
0.34605059027671814,
0.07348817586898804,
0.17075224220752716,
-0.21786755323410034,
-0.6854526400566101,
-0.5762427449226379,
-0.2990970313549042,
-0.3196147680282593,
0.20343545079231262,
0.047082651406526566,
0.4706076979637146,
-0.46360522508621216,
0.6942938566207886,
-0.26298394799232483,
0.0930376648902893,
-0.4807973802089691,
0.3441908657550812,
-0.027026986703276634,
0.45691463351249695,
0.39516177773475647,
-0.23622862994670868,
-0.21924470365047455,
-0.17783205211162567,
-0.37862953543663025,
-0.33921104669570923,
-0.6403247714042664,
-0.21304628252983093,
0.29184380173683167,
0.6186586022377014,
-0.43419450521469116,
0.3427354395389557,
0.4529614746570587,
-0.6448819637298584,
0.6265366077423096,
-0.5136388540267944,
0.3453260660171509,
-1.026351809501648,
-0.04011224955320358,
-0.3924604058265686,
-0.4910471737384796,
-0.26435235142707825,
0.26264050602912903,
0.0814608708024025,
0.012231971137225628,
-0.07220600545406342,
0.49150002002716064,
-0.6376383304595947,
-0.29867997765541077,
-0.20719964802265167,
0.10172398388385773,
-0.04441487416625023,
0.14940784871578217,
-0.1856069564819336,
0.997738242149353,
0.4073057174682617,
-0.5125092267990112,
0.11851659417152405,
-0.044337399303913116,
-0.512111485004425,
0.06970638781785965,
-0.4431263506412506,
0.36260753870010376,
-0.18127989768981934,
-0.0838979035615921,
-1.0095685720443726,
-0.30658531188964844,
-0.0539260059595108,
-0.32311779260635376,
0.21085676550865173,
0.09574267268180847,
-0.5667986273765564,
-0.5170334577560425,
-0.3034760355949402,
0.5639938116073608,
0.3062087893486023,
-0.7648192644119263,
0.4004199802875519,
0.5459733605384827,
-0.12481667101383209,
-0.33218711614608765,
-0.5635014176368713,
0.376778244972229,
-0.007680585142225027,
-0.635199248790741,
-0.07764055579900742,
-0.2786146104335785,
-0.10114625841379166,
-0.1977061927318573,
-0.021565714851021767,
0.28081467747688293,
0.34343504905700684,
0.07655027508735657,
0.07117699086666107,
-0.18244414031505585,
0.07236427813768387,
0.25253957509994507,
-0.2409229874610901,
0.19198262691497803,
-0.16095203161239624,
0.8787668943405151,
-0.12229576706886292,
-0.5692573189735413,
-0.3721636235713959,
0.3904089331626892,
0.6111778020858765,
-0.2463557869195938,
0.2239583134651184,
0.23579631745815277,
-0.27298858761787415,
-0.588918924331665,
-0.5504977703094482,
-0.07045760750770569,
-0.5318945050239563,
0.5694103837013245,
-0.5514973998069763,
-0.6764259338378906,
0.6529698967933655,
-0.28428539633750916,
-0.2533867061138153,
0.721024215221405,
0.8223467469215393,
0.037784039974212646,
1.6159839630126953,
0.4833405911922455,
-0.04269783943891525,
0.30778300762176514,
-0.1898379921913147,
0.40624260902404785,
-0.7001491785049438,
-0.09308531880378723,
-0.5506153106689453,
-0.021522851660847664,
-0.27529579401016235,
-0.5930861830711365,
0.25136837363243103,
0.33413004875183105,
-0.12436605244874954,
-0.024823935702443123,
-0.5199815630912781,
0.6630169153213501,
0.3048493564128876,
-0.016509704291820526,
0.1915784627199173,
-0.018168888986110687,
-0.5512218475341797,
-0.1924680769443512,
-0.7017629742622375,
-0.6204033493995667,
1.0641330480575562,
0.47473475337028503,
1.249483346939087,
-0.04120456427335739,
1.1262084245681763,
0.4905025362968445,
-0.006791205145418644,
-0.6497447490692139,
0.5912865400314331,
-0.10054187476634979,
-0.39786553382873535,
-0.35193875432014465,
-0.4006870687007904,
-0.9842063784599304,
0.2781137228012085,
-0.3328065276145935,
-0.6951590776443481,
0.2823502719402313,
0.08689776808023453,
-0.5973007678985596,
0.18536147475242615,
-0.6978679299354553,
0.78664231300354,
-0.5265971422195435,
-0.012832808308303356,
-0.40246397256851196,
-0.15357215702533722,
0.27419739961624146,
-0.1790737807750702,
0.1437516212463379,
0.19992347061634064,
0.2435135692358017,
0.7566879987716675,
-0.5527439713478088,
0.7457058429718018,
-0.023230155929923058,
-0.1781601756811142,
0.2382926046848297,
0.5969891548156738,
0.751275360584259,
0.1310545951128006,
-0.4879395365715027,
-0.038817111402750015,
0.05957018584012985,
0.05671495571732521,
-0.5891357064247131,
0.6851299405097961,
-0.9322056770324707,
-0.669122576713562,
-0.3171161115169525,
-0.267271488904953,
-0.009651301428675652,
0.488089919090271,
0.5316319465637207,
0.6518886685371399,
-0.1856105774641037,
-0.07864933460950851,
0.15166085958480835,
-0.36193376779556274,
0.5099189877510071,
0.1493588089942932,
-0.5047087669372559,
-0.5725240707397461,
0.8158453702926636,
-0.04386988282203674,
0.19892960786819458,
-0.1243443638086319,
0.037794843316078186,
-0.6368522644042969,
-0.8042036294937134,
-0.3812471330165863,
0.10707125812768936,
-1.0864917039871216,
-0.5794439911842346,
-0.6573676466941833,
-0.43093863129615784,
-0.7176660299301147,
-0.23724637925624847,
-0.6574463248252869,
-0.37595313787460327,
-0.4605233073234558,
-0.4131097197532654,
-0.25867754220962524,
1.0433006286621094,
-0.32122617959976196,
0.1905512511730194,
-0.673818826675415,
0.2960723042488098,
0.20266319811344147,
0.4422243535518646,
0.11437838524580002,
-0.34310853481292725,
-0.19626301527023315,
0.06149507313966751,
-0.3021012544631958,
-1.0124008655548096,
0.7691967487335205,
0.039325837045907974,
0.6706635355949402,
0.6643999814987183,
0.24148055911064148,
1.0799179077148438,
-0.4186171293258667,
0.7864092588424683,
0.15777772665023804,
-1.2824112176895142,
0.609401285648346,
-0.2190781533718109,
0.27176418900489807,
0.40753623843193054,
-0.2023555338382721,
-0.5347667932510376,
-0.5783970952033997,
-0.5890709757804871,
-0.840474545955658,
0.7317527532577515,
0.1955246925354004,
0.41303226351737976,
-0.592058539390564,
0.35416415333747864,
0.22775277495384216,
-0.15374919772148132,
-0.8105209469795227,
-0.26668834686279297,
-0.3304680585861206,
-0.20399069786071777,
0.07743972539901733,
-0.7421256899833679,
0.1334226131439209,
-0.06697142869234085,
0.5892819762229919,
-0.023135880008339882,
0.4163777530193329,
0.4550405740737915,
-0.07162503153085709,
-0.5307843685150146,
0.33027976751327515,
0.4295860528945923,
0.3852492570877075,
0.06865205615758896,
0.327820360660553,
0.4010680615901947,
-0.18648135662078857,
-0.008043082430958748,
-0.30490756034851074,
-0.14785848557949066,
-0.15688595175743103,
0.2809423506259918,
0.8428894281387329,
0.0882745012640953,
-0.5912672281265259,
0.5344486236572266,
-0.32745984196662903,
0.004057725891470909,
-0.05227767676115036,
0.24829348921775818,
-0.20887434482574463,
0.46619218587875366,
0.3968537449836731,
0.19747412204742432,
0.5088226795196533,
-0.3517027497291565,
0.18415643274784088,
0.5461319088935852,
0.08299078047275543,
-0.367123544216156,
0.7171623110771179,
0.493293434381485,
-0.48502570390701294,
0.5060717463493347,
-0.5727810263633728,
-0.7347305417060852,
0.4810207784175873,
1.1174942255020142,
1.1615225076675415,
-0.3569781184196472,
0.3298172652721405,
0.42917537689208984,
0.23965662717819214,
-0.14324820041656494,
0.5479565858840942,
-0.07368211448192596,
-0.7605319619178772,
-0.40652701258659363,
-0.9329585433006287,
-0.02806273102760315,
0.2551153898239136,
-0.4451029300689697,
0.4203953444957733,
-0.5341322422027588,
-0.34759899973869324,
-0.40377277135849,
-0.19843804836273193,
-0.6281407475471497,
0.24635717272758484,
0.2826536297798157,
0.7496013641357422,
-0.3785141706466675,
0.6419873833656311,
0.38076168298721313,
0.06115131080150604,
-0.9003337025642395,
0.09942623227834702,
-0.13007274270057678,
-0.7327243685722351,
0.8325446248054504,
-0.0010972704039886594,
-0.4457133114337921,
0.21717362105846405,
-0.41257280111312866,
-1.0904194116592407,
0.7412048578262329,
0.4570918679237366,
-0.46173062920570374,
0.048123449087142944,
0.06709699332714081,
0.5945448279380798,
-0.4272642433643341,
0.5306642055511475,
0.5337212681770325,
0.31832021474838257,
0.17718535661697388,
-0.7479423880577087,
0.24743956327438354,
-0.3892521262168884,
0.13177542388439178,
0.25329163670539856,
-0.40085533261299133,
0.7919844388961792,
-0.654263436794281,
-0.7530699372291565,
0.2241559475660324,
0.6944693326950073,
-0.07683860510587692,
-0.02698606066405773,
0.4940062165260315,
0.37941449880599976,
0.8262521028518677,
0.21346122026443481,
1.0844545364379883,
-0.6326978206634521,
0.6023913025856018,
1.0525676012039185,
0.05675556883215904,
0.8806292414665222,
0.223336860537529,
-0.02739509381353855,
0.28867387771606445,
0.8274432420730591,
-0.05742510408163071,
0.6205584406852722,
0.012843956239521503,
-0.029751496389508247,
-0.8082978129386902,
0.3235909938812256,
-0.3748401701450348,
0.6176550388336182,
0.4411798417568207,
-0.39531126618385315,
-0.6136837005615234,
-0.3138155937194824,
-0.12767519056797028,
-0.027516093105077744,
-0.16756294667720795,
0.7410925626754761,
-0.13270483911037445,
-0.6342794299125671,
0.5167307257652283,
0.39116886258125305,
0.5008682608604431,
-0.37387746572494507,
0.16559405624866486,
-0.2539397180080414,
-0.008247562684118748,
-0.0804225504398346,
-0.772097110748291,
0.27034619450569153,
-0.0628657415509224,
0.05663265287876129,
-0.3698202073574066,
0.9251253604888916,
-0.3090919852256775,
-0.598564863204956,
0.4634774625301361,
0.5601747632026672,
0.12090631574392319,
0.08980628848075867,
-0.7853105068206787,
0.10498072952032089,
0.10711338371038437,
-0.4595552682876587,
0.056374456733465195,
0.8027898669242859,
0.11343017965555191,
0.8012194037437439,
0.9056520462036133,
0.1577337086200714,
0.04874006286263466,
0.2928236722946167,
0.9215386509895325,
-0.9907183051109314,
-0.9106712937355042,
-1.0228663682937622,
0.3871299922466278,
-0.014989704824984074,
-0.4824359714984894,
0.8081302642822266,
0.4502553641796112,
0.7798081636428833,
-0.09474697709083557,
0.8595457077026367,
0.14371463656425476,
0.3099389672279358,
-0.6530911922454834,
0.7187183499336243,
-0.4021751284599304,
0.5347307324409485,
-0.466632604598999,
-0.7752955555915833,
-0.35249951481819153,
0.9450649619102478,
-0.15623842179775238,
0.19420680403709412,
0.6315137147903442,
0.7877877354621887,
0.15409494936466217,
0.033996354788541794,
0.544998824596405,
0.3681239187717438,
0.36077624559402466,
0.18445034325122833,
1.137710452079773,
-0.3449725806713104,
0.3639691472053528,
-0.14103487133979797,
-0.019373074173927307,
-0.2419055998325348,
-0.8528286218643188,
-1.0689929723739624,
-0.6775514483451843,
-0.02845037914812565,
-0.2698409855365753,
-0.07253682613372803,
1.2620203495025635,
0.5607314705848694,
-0.6215283870697021,
-0.3414914011955261,
-0.09420784562826157,
0.235550194978714,
0.12338767200708389,
-0.20313042402267456,
0.21110031008720398,
-0.9446976184844971,
-0.6846669912338257,
0.448649525642395,
0.5032145380973816,
0.2930454909801483,
-0.3792196214199066,
-0.3258635103702545,
0.15498638153076172,
0.34788787364959717,
0.5698896646499634,
-0.09672164916992188,
-0.5982176661491394,
-0.3826002776622772,
-0.14940500259399414,
-0.33194243907928467,
-0.05422661080956459,
0.8713691830635071,
-0.7033100724220276,
0.6156551837921143,
0.6894721984863281,
0.6429190039634705,
0.3032801151275635,
0.1396053284406662,
0.7328448295593262,
-0.24492868781089783,
-0.18397589027881622,
0.11219439655542374,
0.49735164642333984,
0.1914948970079422,
-0.6516368985176086,
0.24087299406528473,
0.12634021043777466,
-0.7183709144592285,
-0.7533494830131531,
0.04381677880883217,
-0.6530069708824158,
-0.42411455512046814,
1.3526177406311035,
0.02302929386496544,
-0.26593074202537537,
-0.27854785323143005,
-0.38252413272857666,
0.07642922550439835,
-0.4763229787349701,
1.14670991897583,
0.6796062588691711,
-0.09378444403409958,
0.07735329866409302,
-0.09656310081481934,
0.7118346095085144,
0.59068363904953,
-0.7599914073944092,
0.3842464089393616,
0.6321097016334534,
0.22025883197784424,
-0.0625317171216011,
0.8084247708320618,
-0.16020403802394867,
0.18112996220588684,
0.0924300104379654,
0.004778378643095493,
0.1143726259469986,
-0.25325167179107666,
-0.4621542692184448,
0.004526522941887379,
0.32144197821617126,
0.20543690025806427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16546v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16546v2
|
Cocktail: A Comprehensive Information Retrieval Benchmark with LLM-Generated Documents Integration
| 2024-05-26T12:30:20 | 2024-07-02T12:23:37 |
Sunhao Dai, Weihao Liu, Yuqi Zhou, Liang Pang, Rongju Ruan, Gang Wang, Zhenhua Dong, Jun Xu, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to an influx of
AI-generated content (AIGC) on the internet, transforming the corpus of
Information Retrieval (IR) systems from solely human-written to a coexistence
with LLM-generated content. The impact of this surge in AIGC on IR systems
remains an open question, with the primary challenge being the lack of a
dedicated benchmark for researchers. In this paper, we introduce Cocktail, a
comprehensive benchmark tailored for evaluating IR models in this mixed-sourced
data landscape of the LLM era. Cocktail consists of 16 diverse datasets with
mixed human-written and LLM-generated corpora across various text retrieval
tasks and domains. Additionally, to avoid the potential bias from previously
included dataset information in LLMs, we also introduce an up-to-date dataset,
named NQ-UTD, with queries derived from recent events. Through conducting over
1,000 experiments to assess state-of-the-art retrieval models against the
benchmarked datasets in Cocktail, we uncover a clear trade-off between ranking
performance and source bias in neural retrieval models, highlighting the
necessity for a balanced approach in designing future IR systems. We hope
Cocktail can serve as a foundational resource for IR research in the LLM era,
with all data and code publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/KID-22/Cocktail}.
|
[
-0.14616286754608154,
-0.6317906379699707,
0.29099804162979126,
0.09350622445344925,
-0.05838845297694206,
0.48129481077194214,
-0.15280450880527496,
-0.5868593454360962,
0.29427123069763184,
0.5576257705688477,
-0.24990291893482208,
-0.6407968997955322,
-0.48107463121414185,
0.14539527893066406,
-0.5909309983253479,
0.9696843028068542,
0.09692054241895676,
0.2937766909599304,
-0.4123802185058594,
-0.22848127782344818,
-0.48697736859321594,
-0.5545969009399414,
-0.38742950558662415,
-0.5482528209686279,
0.5289779305458069,
0.20932985842227936,
0.37975260615348816,
0.46376797556877136,
0.8252851366996765,
0.08226806670427322,
-0.0754338726401329,
0.2886427640914917,
-0.7448561191558838,
0.5373551845550537,
-0.2635878622531891,
-0.6733742356300354,
-0.1654161661863327,
0.13383075594902039,
0.5084862112998962,
0.5589067339897156,
-0.2026333212852478,
0.1442873775959015,
0.2206643968820572,
0.6558759808540344,
-1.1922760009765625,
-0.11485438048839569,
-0.9277145862579346,
0.1513884961605072,
-0.5311116576194763,
-0.10105422139167786,
-0.4977010488510132,
-0.2220575213432312,
0.0005040637915953994,
-0.3852017819881439,
-0.057227905839681625,
0.2813760042190552,
0.5036775469779968,
0.22148822247982025,
-0.550349235534668,
-0.2095826119184494,
-0.6607052683830261,
0.6233764886856079,
-0.6410126090049744,
0.29984450340270996,
0.1896561086177826,
0.4067232608795166,
-0.5393760800361633,
-1.1087712049484253,
-0.5335572957992554,
-0.30806922912597656,
0.15866337716579437,
0.11624933034181595,
-0.2893371880054474,
-0.08445410430431366,
-0.1361188441514969,
0.2665471136569977,
-0.5266115069389343,
-0.0638263002038002,
-0.0034927004016935825,
0.0376247763633728,
0.5220164060592651,
0.3281131982803345,
0.239409402012825,
0.09063328057527542,
-0.3132452666759491,
-0.016147729009389877,
-0.8613346219062805,
-0.34911903738975525,
0.2125720977783203,
0.3160422146320343,
0.06956321746110916,
0.8973529934883118,
-0.2276148647069931,
0.5662309527397156,
-0.030526278540492058,
-0.0652175322175026,
0.03441321477293968,
-0.6666527986526489,
0.05248789116740227,
0.038804903626441956,
0.9708253741264343,
0.5493161678314209,
0.24123191833496094,
-0.31512150168418884,
-0.4168495237827301,
-0.20158499479293823,
0.20363178849220276,
-0.8050270080566406,
-0.29525622725486755,
-0.10596634447574615,
-0.46922317147254944,
-0.2263364940881729,
0.06592053920030594,
-0.7300989627838135,
-0.7083637118339539,
-0.06760377436876297,
0.3251812160015106,
-0.17281894385814667,
-0.10906735062599182,
-0.27001819014549255,
-0.48121944069862366,
0.3283751904964447,
0.061964210122823715,
-0.6590851545333862,
0.3932409882545471,
0.8637022972106934,
0.9394367337226868,
-0.7322746515274048,
0.043986521661281586,
-0.7587847113609314,
0.175384983420372,
-0.3621063828468323,
0.8917392492294312,
-0.7576956748962402,
-0.5037518739700317,
0.10559698194265366,
-0.47586020827293396,
0.17447908222675323,
-1.1090986728668213,
0.6341798305511475,
-0.7525091171264648,
-0.007292384281754494,
-0.08273162692785263,
-0.744145929813385,
0.2920956611633301,
0.27338871359825134,
-0.45853909850120544,
1.319833517074585,
-0.22001919150352478,
-0.8467772603034973,
0.5128450989723206,
-0.3647999167442322,
-0.49205178022384644,
0.11387933045625687,
-0.32069119811058044,
-0.07715553790330887,
0.07284245640039444,
0.0979245975613594,
0.1898244172334671,
-0.8531265258789062,
0.6263861656188965,
-0.726793646812439,
-0.5295363664627075,
0.34797802567481995,
-0.40733733773231506,
0.6674309372901917,
0.43820011615753174,
-0.11304837465286255,
-0.15678226947784424,
-0.8129856586456299,
-0.06585638970136642,
-0.05792360007762909,
-0.5615889430046082,
-0.4463638663291931,
0.21311195194721222,
0.31190627813339233,
-0.13395853340625763,
0.3810485899448395,
-0.4374964237213135,
0.35046622157096863,
-0.05929535627365112,
0.29964518547058105,
0.41540613770484924,
0.17242369055747986,
0.4324062764644623,
-0.33777353167533875,
0.3844413757324219,
-0.001099286717362702,
-0.15661107003688812,
-0.11818491667509079,
-0.2893469035625458,
-0.5830345749855042,
-0.36461341381073,
0.4238356947898865,
0.667469322681427,
-0.6811661124229431,
0.44984063506126404,
-0.20807108283042908,
-0.7088558673858643,
-0.618811309337616,
0.1017274260520935,
0.17210683226585388,
0.4734046161174774,
0.3922344446182251,
-0.2894867956638336,
-0.47186270356178284,
-0.8357000350952148,
-0.5783683657646179,
-0.1886376589536667,
-0.295377641916275,
0.531204104423523,
0.4886486828327179,
-0.21810196340084076,
0.9326597452163696,
-0.3266655206680298,
-0.31956321001052856,
-0.1215631514787674,
0.2843160927295685,
0.5260494947433472,
0.26541733741760254,
0.42616596817970276,
-0.45621004700660706,
-0.5738480687141418,
-0.020566456019878387,
-0.9252528548240662,
-0.5390344262123108,
0.060764532536268234,
-0.2852803170681,
-0.13881362974643707,
0.4482439458370209,
-0.4143312871456146,
0.3453020751476288,
0.04772769659757614,
-0.3497908413410187,
0.4964192807674408,
0.10806454718112946,
0.37016761302948,
-0.8821358680725098,
0.3922407329082489,
0.047535840421915054,
-0.19686155021190643,
-0.4237307608127594,
0.12552186846733093,
0.33864277601242065,
0.02525409124791622,
-0.261048287153244,
0.7615757584571838,
-0.36864492297172546,
-0.09727156907320023,
-0.39244621992111206,
0.13824111223220825,
0.23259316384792328,
-0.060881659388542175,
-0.35029470920562744,
1.018614411354065,
0.3638307750225067,
-0.2779604196548462,
0.24531209468841553,
-0.053850699216127396,
-0.3665825128555298,
0.925509512424469,
-0.6576627492904663,
0.16871242225170135,
-0.11015091091394424,
0.29122310876846313,
-0.8740895390510559,
-0.051691461354494095,
0.05163196474313736,
-0.3326350748538971,
0.367611825466156,
-0.22345760464668274,
-0.6867233514785767,
0.18477608263492584,
-0.39633962512016296,
0.41457659006118774,
0.11146460473537445,
-0.6019165515899658,
0.8249009847640991,
0.5476074814796448,
0.008094258606433868,
-1.0125958919525146,
-0.7846998572349548,
0.6514410376548767,
-0.38634389638900757,
-0.6750882863998413,
0.8530693650245667,
-0.2405860275030136,
-0.664027214050293,
0.07882633805274963,
-0.10660789161920547,
-0.07453431934118271,
0.05057626590132713,
0.02970481663942337,
0.4978075325489044,
-0.1749926060438156,
-0.10680830478668213,
-0.06436749547719955,
0.2842230796813965,
-0.09459944814443588,
-0.1868504136800766,
0.43300485610961914,
0.1504610776901245,
-0.13073456287384033,
-0.2767791748046875,
0.19066932797431946,
0.5202319025993347,
-0.11418163776397705,
0.6643074154853821,
0.2903084456920624,
-0.10069878399372101,
-0.16455423831939697,
-0.6632165312767029,
-0.11899387091398239,
-0.4367203116416931,
0.1582280546426773,
-0.25495755672454834,
-0.5959790349006653,
0.7626421451568604,
0.16849885880947113,
-0.03682704269886017,
0.32290467619895935,
0.35843926668167114,
-0.12264032661914825,
0.5672267079353333,
0.19714340567588806,
-0.44677889347076416,
0.6313537359237671,
-0.03868498653173447,
0.10999014973640442,
-0.8364375233650208,
-0.40419360995292664,
-0.7121576070785522,
-0.409628301858902,
-0.48656508326530457,
-0.2994644343852997,
0.5078045725822449,
0.2463928461074829,
-0.1815366894006729,
0.035799700766801834,
-0.20308275520801544,
0.5926512479782104,
0.7364192605018616,
-0.15062467753887177,
0.6035428643226624,
-0.3814409673213959,
-0.33436667919158936,
-0.004175553098320961,
-0.46460407972335815,
-0.17192132771015167,
1.5048713684082031,
-0.03194934129714966,
1.115632176399231,
0.12746183574199677,
0.9080830216407776,
0.8548367023468018,
0.33375829458236694,
-0.6670304536819458,
0.4825507402420044,
-0.07479982823133469,
-0.8779129981994629,
0.4140029549598694,
-0.47372451424598694,
-0.9556177258491516,
0.4192824065685272,
-0.5067015886306763,
-0.5573118925094604,
0.24313396215438843,
-0.2934209704399109,
0.0433528907597065,
-0.027750883251428604,
-0.5381906628608704,
0.5675443410873413,
-0.40289556980133057,
-0.9141599535942078,
-0.20548151433467865,
-0.5318994522094727,
0.42280158400535583,
-0.026277154684066772,
0.10263696312904358,
-0.3104114234447479,
-0.2625657320022583,
0.6315934658050537,
-0.14621412754058838,
0.31954994797706604,
-0.011387394741177559,
0.34943318367004395,
0.23452897369861603,
0.2526349127292633,
0.5749067068099976,
0.060804616659879684,
-0.3667512834072113,
0.31259840726852417,
0.0770113542675972,
-0.09930215775966644,
-0.49289193749427795,
0.9299172759056091,
-0.5113153457641602,
-0.4504128098487854,
-0.6181207895278931,
-0.32878464460372925,
0.12162762880325317,
0.38819220662117004,
0.17884281277656555,
0.22406230866909027,
-0.32914668321609497,
0.41317740082740784,
0.44584402441978455,
-0.14353732764720917,
0.4217502176761627,
0.6596347093582153,
-0.2718307375907898,
-0.5237888097763062,
0.5268296003341675,
0.09334651380777359,
-0.07767622172832489,
0.47315388917922974,
-0.2116757333278656,
-0.2626740336418152,
-0.8603402972221375,
-0.2766663730144501,
0.02309407666325569,
-0.7146501541137695,
-0.5583921670913696,
-0.49269360303878784,
-0.080344557762146,
-0.3672116696834564,
0.031939275562763214,
-0.4971950054168701,
-0.18418028950691223,
-0.6121576428413391,
0.13616563379764557,
0.09259797632694244,
0.7117971777915955,
0.09139466285705566,
-0.018224680796265602,
-0.6252996325492859,
0.243989497423172,
-0.25174981355667114,
0.39317479729652405,
-0.061704836785793304,
-0.45764437317848206,
-0.18752296268939972,
-0.22789008915424347,
-0.3812602162361145,
-0.8669238686561584,
0.4681403338909149,
0.4966002404689789,
0.7396218180656433,
0.30352070927619934,
0.24852101504802704,
0.535222053527832,
-0.3977161645889282,
0.8034659028053284,
0.0069561307318508625,
-0.5879639387130737,
0.3646715581417084,
-0.273444801568985,
0.26789039373397827,
0.9574649930000305,
0.21698683500289917,
-0.5528031587600708,
-0.2656884491443634,
-0.03856363892555237,
-1.0638285875320435,
0.41345107555389404,
0.01546377781778574,
-0.008458116091787815,
-0.22813372313976288,
0.3880857825279236,
0.09541545808315277,
0.24017392098903656,
-0.6946362257003784,
-0.42402616143226624,
0.32004839181900024,
-0.3163566589355469,
0.32034730911254883,
0.013139192014932632,
0.06231541559100151,
-0.10064652562141418,
0.590457022190094,
0.031426843255758286,
0.012462767772376537,
0.08176074922084808,
-0.07247371971607208,
0.1471242904663086,
-0.026026947423815727,
-0.05517062917351723,
0.39336809515953064,
-0.4315949082374573,
0.2844015061855316,
-0.1581905633211136,
-0.34857726097106934,
0.09130590409040451,
0.2552412748336792,
-0.25155940651893616,
-0.19335505366325378,
0.4492730498313904,
0.32120010256767273,
-0.014371593482792377,
-1.2020736932754517,
0.392654150724411,
-0.2848952114582062,
0.171205535531044,
-0.1953372359275818,
0.4349088668823242,
0.0030486872419714928,
0.5012495517730713,
0.8585943579673767,
-0.19375380873680115,
0.6737783551216125,
-0.8220717906951904,
0.3184071481227875,
0.8376930952072144,
-0.05993660166859627,
0.07191029191017151,
0.8694031834602356,
0.11021870374679565,
-0.3218997120857239,
0.7735610008239746,
0.09101348370313644,
0.12127060443162918,
0.21045653522014618,
0.355035662651062,
0.9158963561058044,
0.2060459703207016,
-0.2103584110736847,
0.29518061876296997,
0.04100741446018219,
0.06642520427703857,
0.07543820887804031,
-0.2668268382549286,
-0.6201991438865662,
-0.13445857167243958,
-0.6130721569061279,
-0.2972606122493744,
0.06192981079220772,
-0.5508834719657898,
0.429330438375473,
-0.2807580232620239,
-0.4074535667896271,
0.0994066596031189,
-0.0061064213514328,
-0.5614431500434875,
-0.35104480385780334,
0.03549373894929886,
1.113952875137329,
-0.5619491338729858,
0.8011782169342041,
0.3385488986968994,
-0.3702859580516815,
-0.01225067675113678,
0.18886874616146088,
0.1602509319782257,
-0.7046913504600525,
0.5214041471481323,
-0.06684304028749466,
-0.17797856032848358,
-0.21961912512779236,
-0.6369045972824097,
-0.8960809707641602,
1.1086276769638062,
0.38716381788253784,
-0.39154747128486633,
0.04642021656036377,
0.12791235744953156,
0.6452831625938416,
-0.5884292125701904,
0.5956002473831177,
0.8606979250907898,
0.28041574358940125,
0.17758962512016296,
-0.8522588014602661,
-0.2190207839012146,
-0.5515210628509521,
-0.0006123179337009788,
0.01735815405845642,
-0.304200142621994,
0.5210510492324829,
0.01870119385421276,
-0.271497517824173,
0.08630309253931046,
0.6363776326179504,
0.36299023032188416,
0.5168582797050476,
-0.07955542206764221,
0.5543811321258545,
0.6862253546714783,
-0.06726589798927307,
1.040164828300476,
-0.4227987229824066,
-0.0580466091632843,
1.345670223236084,
-0.6747052073478699,
1.1246082782745361,
0.7216910719871521,
-0.2617141604423523,
0.22994166612625122,
0.5650267004966736,
-0.10218469798564911,
0.9289110898971558,
0.3254031836986542,
-0.4904613196849823,
0.11847924441099167,
-0.43956613540649414,
-0.3022669553756714,
0.4119933247566223,
0.3562697172164917,
-0.5399817228317261,
-0.12424848973751068,
-0.29349589347839355,
-0.15675212442874908,
0.013282530941069126,
-0.02710818313062191,
1.1497796773910522,
0.0038042976520955563,
-0.9635991454124451,
0.6034516096115112,
0.04871075227856636,
1.0033985376358032,
-0.3434242010116577,
-0.02307545207440853,
-0.6718130707740784,
0.062149882316589355,
0.010358127765357494,
-0.9096760153770447,
0.07715962082147598,
0.1256636083126068,
-0.01893666572868824,
0.19084130227565765,
0.7965470552444458,
-0.3486354649066925,
-0.2734266519546509,
0.5458171367645264,
0.42769408226013184,
0.04727226123213768,
0.019340287894010544,
-0.6372619271278381,
0.24700695276260376,
-0.0820629820227623,
-0.28929710388183594,
0.47170817852020264,
0.3387596309185028,
0.4270555377006531,
0.6830584406852722,
0.44438034296035767,
0.025407949462532997,
0.1224454715847969,
-0.15220612287521362,
0.8285832405090332,
-0.5984960794448853,
-0.1781819611787796,
-0.9857059717178345,
0.28482335805892944,
-0.11151111125946045,
-0.22364436089992523,
0.5969035029411316,
0.927978515625,
0.8068051934242249,
0.19120803475379944,
0.9019879102706909,
-0.024231117218732834,
0.21093010902404785,
-0.4639340937137604,
0.7701691389083862,
-0.6899248361587524,
0.5944111943244934,
-0.054442014545202255,
-1.14755380153656,
-0.3996089994907379,
0.3469716012477875,
-0.023889565840363503,
0.06411731243133545,
0.25152263045310974,
0.9525679349899292,
-0.05149400979280472,
-0.1971312016248703,
0.11335382610559464,
-0.08271221071481705,
0.4321558475494385,
0.1829620897769928,
0.909656822681427,
-0.2597484290599823,
0.38516226410865784,
0.08673176914453506,
-0.017370790243148804,
-0.6322509050369263,
-0.8853347301483154,
-0.7081253528594971,
-0.4498441517353058,
-0.10893018543720245,
-0.4023783802986145,
0.36491063237190247,
1.1460469961166382,
0.5093755722045898,
-0.6822713613510132,
-0.4362630546092987,
0.04941515997052193,
0.06973423063755035,
0.1844853013753891,
-0.2593931555747986,
-0.030060335993766785,
-0.26714733242988586,
-0.6433686017990112,
0.7273634076118469,
0.40886202454566956,
-0.020499711856245995,
-0.1850890815258026,
0.02950548194348812,
-0.48370206356048584,
0.1741499900817871,
0.31363001465797424,
0.018904101103544235,
-0.470794677734375,
0.0369764044880867,
0.15227019786834717,
-0.2429926097393036,
0.43615883588790894,
0.7342254519462585,
-0.7853166460990906,
0.5618422031402588,
0.6058778762817383,
0.7868959903717041,
0.8492365479469299,
-0.2573223412036896,
0.7114625573158264,
-0.735406756401062,
-0.2575457990169525,
0.41686615347862244,
0.4660142660140991,
0.3819652795791626,
-0.2930747866630554,
0.7871780395507812,
0.16258399188518524,
-0.6565805673599243,
-0.9959610104560852,
-0.2015485018491745,
-0.7854209542274475,
-0.3013535439968109,
0.9833812117576599,
-0.0691874623298645,
0.040862057358026505,
-0.11848858743906021,
0.025294166058301926,
0.24971824884414673,
-0.6757730841636658,
0.9086822271347046,
0.699261486530304,
-0.32974711060523987,
0.06190778315067291,
-0.5309172868728638,
0.1435329169034958,
0.2185295671224594,
-0.7274796962738037,
0.16910727322101593,
0.7906136512756348,
0.20065414905548096,
-0.17596708238124847,
0.4708367586135864,
-0.11058250069618225,
-0.0693824514746666,
0.0015112377004697919,
0.202214315533638,
0.14291392266750336,
-0.4588765501976013,
-0.11276781558990479,
0.19854232668876648,
0.17096474766731262,
0.12761135399341583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16533v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16533v1
|
Chain of Tools: Large Language Model is an Automatic Multi-tool Learner
| 2024-05-26T11:40:58 | 2024-05-26T11:40:58 |
Zhengliang Shi, Shen Gao, Xiuyi Chen, Yue Feng, Lingyong Yan, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin, Zhumin Chen, Suzan Verberne, Zhaochun Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Augmenting large language models (LLMs) with external tools has emerged as a
promising approach to extend their utility, empowering them to solve practical
tasks. Existing work typically empowers LLMs as tool users with a manually
designed workflow, where the LLM plans a series of tools in a step-by-step
manner, and sequentially executes each tool to obtain intermediate results
until deriving the final answer. However, they suffer from two challenges in
realistic scenarios: (1) The handcrafted control flow is often ad-hoc and
constraints the LLM to local planning; (2) The LLM is instructed to use only
manually demonstrated tools or well-trained Python functions, which limits its
generalization to new tools. In this work, we first propose Automatic Tool
Chain (ATC), a framework that enables the LLM to act as a multi-tool user,
which directly utilizes a chain of tools through programming. To scale up the
scope of the tools, we next propose a black-box probing method. This further
empowers the LLM as a tool learner that can actively discover and document tool
usages, teaching themselves to properly master new tools. For a comprehensive
evaluation, we build a challenging benchmark named ToolFlow, which diverges
from previous benchmarks by its long-term planning scenarios and complex
toolset. Experiments on both existing datasets and ToolFlow illustrate the
superiority of our framework. Analysis on different settings also validates the
effectiveness and the utility of our black-box probing algorithm.
|
[
-0.37594854831695557,
-0.8672272562980652,
0.5118522644042969,
-0.13299870491027832,
-0.13502468168735504,
0.4876900315284729,
-0.26969611644744873,
-0.398250550031662,
-0.03647482767701149,
0.574857771396637,
-0.5747137069702148,
-0.2953683137893677,
-0.5161738395690918,
0.056502606719732285,
-0.5854664444923401,
0.7132245898246765,
-0.31258273124694824,
-0.25534650683403015,
0.15134432911872864,
-0.18450237810611725,
-0.31644144654273987,
-0.5075790286064148,
-0.8227065801620483,
-0.5773140788078308,
0.6261497139930725,
0.3003886938095093,
0.9466425776481628,
0.7801855206489563,
0.32871076464653015,
0.3865664303302765,
-0.008008113130927086,
0.15611480176448822,
-0.3456680178642273,
-0.02424013800919056,
-0.26066771149635315,
-0.4552799463272095,
-0.43490123748779297,
-0.23447369039058685,
0.5618451833724976,
0.7891085743904114,
-0.21751046180725098,
0.3467157185077667,
-0.03623669967055321,
0.2948688268661499,
-0.602005124092102,
-0.13079063594341278,
-0.7951861023902893,
-0.11924250423908234,
-0.10623569041490555,
-0.1434614062309265,
-0.2781235873699188,
-0.09266279637813568,
0.10411742329597473,
-0.33327460289001465,
-0.09547284990549088,
0.04726560413837433,
0.5163564085960388,
0.23970244824886322,
-0.7511420845985413,
-0.35926538705825806,
-0.816535234451294,
0.7701759338378906,
-0.7250872254371643,
0.32910242676734924,
0.24927668273448944,
0.5637912750244141,
-0.3308447003364563,
-0.6317470669746399,
-0.46568918228149414,
-0.10076522827148438,
0.15565292537212372,
-0.22609002888202667,
-0.033659979701042175,
-0.1488635390996933,
0.3860291838645935,
0.40002381801605225,
-0.44005459547042847,
0.44085702300071716,
-0.533135175704956,
-0.19703151285648346,
0.7951157093048096,
0.3493213951587677,
0.05862116441130638,
0.0805034190416336,
-0.14791375398635864,
-0.24215984344482422,
-0.827192485332489,
0.04215994477272034,
0.6382997632026672,
0.2670643925666809,
-0.11359753459692001,
0.6708354353904724,
0.1023733988404274,
0.7748165130615234,
-0.3529803454875946,
-0.18051835894584656,
0.20946091413497925,
-0.39685437083244324,
-0.2909933030605316,
-0.030721647664904594,
0.9192635416984558,
-0.04006336256861687,
0.36853474378585815,
-0.0646798238158226,
-0.39283180236816406,
-0.09699033200740814,
0.46121251583099365,
-0.6045721173286438,
-0.17427557706832886,
0.34040477871894836,
-0.1019069105386734,
-0.4197969436645508,
-0.13518744707107544,
-0.4969164729118347,
-0.4449104070663452,
-0.3108867108821869,
0.530167818069458,
0.007306375075131655,
-0.4534400701522827,
0.0879535973072052,
0.12141841650009155,
0.2810349762439728,
0.413722962141037,
-0.4627610146999359,
0.4201381802558899,
0.622746467590332,
1.107817530632019,
-0.1822146326303482,
-0.3081280291080475,
-0.6582676768302917,
0.1844457983970642,
-0.5326622724533081,
0.49677982926368713,
-0.3843047618865967,
-0.4918101131916046,
0.13715749979019165,
0.28162145614624023,
0.35996314883232117,
-0.45681115984916687,
0.012844683602452278,
-0.33558762073516846,
0.06429389119148254,
0.01808304898440838,
-0.2554466128349304,
-0.19566486775875092,
0.29156237840652466,
-0.6551424264907837,
1.0995014905929565,
0.12736675143241882,
-0.6005602478981018,
0.2237914800643921,
-0.5458770990371704,
-0.533210039138794,
-0.049832865595817566,
-0.22670958936214447,
-0.43775585293769836,
-0.013761373236775398,
0.17444980144500732,
0.6434767246246338,
-0.3954783082008362,
0.44519051909446716,
-0.7448226809501648,
-0.4321441650390625,
0.054724473506212234,
-0.3465251922607422,
0.9192000031471252,
0.16117911040782928,
-0.3761541247367859,
0.37374451756477356,
-0.7168620824813843,
-0.046706490218639374,
0.06863739341497421,
-0.2604800760746002,
-0.32171058654785156,
0.19238580763339996,
-0.12370868772268295,
0.5363582372665405,
-0.05675322934985161,
-0.4430467188358307,
0.5119352340698242,
-0.5958287119865417,
0.5909799933433533,
0.9458662271499634,
-0.14712387323379517,
0.3679538369178772,
-0.2081834077835083,
0.6730949878692627,
-0.19423779845237732,
0.03468489646911621,
-0.1644967943429947,
-0.21210257709026337,
-0.7973357439041138,
0.11851859837770462,
-0.03652120754122734,
0.6962531208992004,
-0.8486611843109131,
0.5628622174263,
-0.09254742413759232,
-0.6181111335754395,
-0.5358518958091736,
0.4395037591457367,
0.1903410702943802,
0.10011865198612213,
0.18291215598583221,
-0.550168514251709,
-0.38741275668144226,
-0.7847921848297119,
0.13923774659633636,
-0.13907988369464874,
-0.2097802311182022,
0.2689598798751831,
0.6837003827095032,
-0.24053922295570374,
0.7030678391456604,
-0.4995913505554199,
-0.10179739445447922,
-0.38233575224876404,
0.03590851649641991,
0.49327465891838074,
0.30555906891822815,
-0.02710886299610138,
-0.5166444778442383,
-0.34557268023490906,
0.3303069472312927,
-0.608607828617096,
0.04137803986668587,
-0.12873661518096924,
-0.03583526238799095,
0.05904828757047653,
0.6778383255004883,
-0.21573404967784882,
0.3992540240287781,
0.59904944896698,
-0.16272275149822235,
0.9007157683372498,
-0.3607715964317322,
-0.2515938878059387,
-1.1475151777267456,
0.24802909791469574,
0.008415378630161285,
-0.2715476155281067,
-0.5554404258728027,
0.13293275237083435,
0.17528019845485687,
-0.19841475784778595,
-0.5452577471733093,
0.8069508671760559,
-0.5587771534919739,
-0.2714059352874756,
-0.4284437298774719,
-0.07096131891012192,
-0.16117160022258759,
0.44315865635871887,
-0.022494688630104065,
0.9054258465766907,
0.7965281009674072,
-0.5646133422851562,
0.6509332060813904,
-0.12004026770591736,
-0.3157643973827362,
0.2957162857055664,
-0.8048948049545288,
0.24031855165958405,
0.22428441047668457,
0.2954116463661194,
-0.7691201567649841,
0.06793507933616638,
0.08934243768453598,
-0.02988595701754093,
0.30712535977363586,
-0.1611386090517044,
-1.0977531671524048,
-0.7078962326049805,
-0.32417911291122437,
0.11428797990083694,
0.47293007373809814,
-0.6113913059234619,
0.8613796234130859,
0.28188925981521606,
-0.012919902801513672,
-0.6624660491943359,
-0.45979318022727966,
0.08832933753728867,
-0.3711266815662384,
-0.5425994992256165,
-0.10452893376350403,
-0.15021808445453644,
-0.3525826334953308,
-0.49285832047462463,
-0.2775607407093048,
-0.0669550895690918,
0.23340041935443878,
0.24400438368320465,
0.23817016184329987,
-0.10966970026493073,
0.20549249649047852,
-0.11547832936048508,
0.18069623410701752,
0.3847257196903229,
-0.16966544091701508,
0.6464466452598572,
-0.05484594777226448,
-0.5315330028533936,
-0.1146313026547432,
0.1219501718878746,
0.6150404214859009,
-0.3620888888835907,
0.5764948725700378,
0.6783549785614014,
-0.22501468658447266,
-0.49218156933784485,
-0.7747868299484253,
-0.2751644551753998,
-0.6200090646743774,
0.33017003536224365,
-0.5305740237236023,
-0.6788404583930969,
0.839217483997345,
-0.4268452525138855,
0.3179090619087219,
0.02611970528960228,
0.6904881000518799,
0.2010658234357834,
1.0380443334579468,
0.7318413257598877,
-0.4307861328125,
0.23762643337249756,
-0.5257095098495483,
0.1679372489452362,
-0.9063014388084412,
0.08402782678604126,
-0.39748120307922363,
-0.19363513588905334,
-0.47411835193634033,
-0.4500206708908081,
0.31821495294570923,
0.017839867621660233,
-0.2547113597393036,
0.6350972056388855,
-0.38080495595932007,
0.4004633128643036,
0.4404814839363098,
-0.027754291892051697,
0.4204011857509613,
-0.1755959689617157,
-0.38744011521339417,
0.5795084238052368,
-0.7956467866897583,
-0.5173943638801575,
1.3698697090148926,
0.6240088939666748,
1.0501950979232788,
-0.060786448419094086,
0.6025208234786987,
-0.004432672634720802,
0.21436218917369843,
-0.8550809621810913,
0.5450668334960938,
0.1535017043352127,
-0.627577543258667,
-0.48142945766448975,
-0.3213140368461609,
-0.9494003653526306,
0.43535521626472473,
0.0012130968971177936,
-0.9541892409324646,
0.03016258217394352,
0.19440896809101105,
-0.2394907921552658,
0.6748344898223877,
-0.71795254945755,
0.731304407119751,
-0.39398276805877686,
-0.7537786960601807,
-0.1686735600233078,
-0.6815019845962524,
0.2511574923992157,
-0.4733957350254059,
0.41380879282951355,
0.1186264306306839,
-0.06397904455661774,
0.5094828009605408,
-0.4257732033729553,
0.8616948127746582,
0.1668056845664978,
-0.5597274303436279,
0.23870207369327545,
0.37473064661026,
0.9432745575904846,
-0.003439734224230051,
-0.07910341769456863,
-0.02989351376891136,
-0.12295664101839066,
-0.16191641986370087,
-0.5475515723228455,
0.7767077088356018,
-0.6736708283424377,
-0.6528228521347046,
-0.38831213116645813,
-0.6548464894294739,
-0.17248785495758057,
0.2636145353317261,
-0.3260197937488556,
0.6757774949073792,
0.1599610596895218,
0.06935372203588486,
0.29791325330734253,
-0.3225310742855072,
0.5275045037269592,
0.4753815531730652,
-0.2747080326080322,
-0.04780607670545578,
0.7285782098770142,
0.07972078770399094,
0.5765295624732971,
0.14534525573253632,
0.3643380403518677,
-0.21400241553783417,
-0.6021517515182495,
-0.45002856850624084,
0.3610761761665344,
-0.69979327917099,
-0.08895232528448105,
-0.5036842226982117,
-0.19310511648654938,
-0.16185292601585388,
-0.41088438034057617,
-0.37819865345954895,
-0.07160989195108414,
-0.07479522377252579,
0.0768509954214096,
0.24368248879909515,
0.823773205280304,
0.18374668061733246,
0.3850593864917755,
-0.44146135449409485,
0.051376763731241226,
0.31584709882736206,
0.43711888790130615,
0.1597405970096588,
-0.2781163156032562,
-0.25367239117622375,
-0.10904189944267273,
-0.5337334275245667,
-0.6502457857131958,
0.41881275177001953,
-0.10490800440311432,
0.42158424854278564,
0.39300286769866943,
0.0820808857679367,
0.7919749021530151,
-0.586914598941803,
0.4959450960159302,
0.017065906897187233,
-0.8592298030853271,
0.505045473575592,
-0.4046443998813629,
0.6606225967407227,
0.26935628056526184,
0.5794631838798523,
-0.43149426579475403,
-0.8633466362953186,
-0.6478284001350403,
-0.9700372815132141,
0.6299802660942078,
0.05671267583966255,
-0.07690797001123428,
0.33260589838027954,
0.20638947188854218,
0.14144712686538696,
0.3611740469932556,
-0.8617105484008789,
-0.17439541220664978,
0.03508065640926361,
0.05426304042339325,
-0.36636996269226074,
0.1074969545006752,
-0.1238764226436615,
-0.21210111677646637,
0.6084967255592346,
-0.3214057683944702,
-0.0652165561914444,
-0.17321819067001343,
-0.098804771900177,
-0.23657603561878204,
0.3170880079269409,
0.2183133214712143,
1.1461588144302368,
-0.18914224207401276,
0.3133603036403656,
0.4977981150150299,
-0.16132467985153198,
0.18828891217708588,
0.09236793220043182,
0.20315343141555786,
-0.2504023015499115,
0.5936821103096008,
0.6600930094718933,
0.10045813024044037,
-0.7732102274894714,
0.30864977836608887,
0.3629603981971741,
-0.2764410972595215,
-0.48124223947525024,
0.19379088282585144,
0.20023982226848602,
0.33685579895973206,
0.3033152222633362,
-0.34070807695388794,
0.16521990299224854,
-0.740530788898468,
0.2300303876399994,
0.5519720315933228,
-0.3378082513809204,
-0.2445823699235916,
0.299949586391449,
0.0919497013092041,
-0.49405452609062195,
0.49205949902534485,
-0.16928382217884064,
-0.508674681186676,
0.5469936728477478,
0.4379808306694031,
0.5029755234718323,
-0.21156045794487,
-0.11094217002391815,
0.270525187253952,
0.5537081360816956,
-0.19482186436653137,
0.10732998698949814,
-0.10026321560144424,
-0.5052198171615601,
-0.7772170305252075,
-0.33001285791397095,
-0.2919155955314636,
0.3427600860595703,
-0.4753757417201996,
0.6183017492294312,
-0.4131021797657013,
-0.015866760164499283,
-0.12073271721601486,
0.22946268320083618,
-0.7067428827285767,
-0.09288457036018372,
-0.13661709427833557,
1.0141199827194214,
-0.8130226731300354,
1.145468831062317,
0.6712886095046997,
-0.15654395520687103,
-0.946976900100708,
-0.3277493119239807,
0.31646835803985596,
-0.9309611916542053,
0.5311211347579956,
0.23390382528305054,
-0.25997915863990784,
-0.025449607521295547,
-0.2878783345222473,
-0.8189846873283386,
1.0969483852386475,
-0.07644668221473694,
-0.8312733769416809,
-0.09277929365634918,
-0.027180342003703117,
0.5029428601264954,
-0.28388506174087524,
0.3913343846797943,
0.3704254627227783,
0.4056326150894165,
0.22822265326976776,
-1.3772984743118286,
0.22648242115974426,
-0.0818532407283783,
-0.07502598315477371,
0.618449330329895,
-0.3108089566230774,
0.6544563174247742,
-0.2982730269432068,
-0.19091221690177917,
-0.15958291292190552,
0.2061205804347992,
0.12168863415718079,
0.03432098776102066,
0.7733125686645508,
0.3781389892101288,
0.2927864193916321,
0.10851216316223145,
0.9873170852661133,
-0.1334236115217209,
0.19582295417785645,
1.256266474723816,
-0.4167582094669342,
0.8833625316619873,
0.5691044926643372,
-0.30445265769958496,
0.37402600049972534,
0.4892091751098633,
-0.24444663524627686,
0.22073444724082947,
0.758918046951294,
-0.07963564991950989,
-0.2062346190214157,
0.06752491742372513,
-0.16166670620441437,
0.4238235354423523,
0.3170641362667084,
-0.25092655420303345,
-0.27759698033332825,
0.1699816882610321,
0.04383113607764244,
-0.14212103188037872,
-0.3888840973377228,
0.7724953293800354,
0.14905379712581635,
-0.5392062664031982,
0.5739192366600037,
-0.09001514315605164,
0.7784757614135742,
-0.9356765151023865,
0.04372437298297882,
0.19721589982509613,
0.4233410358428955,
0.0077545540407299995,
-0.9464174509048462,
0.27120351791381836,
-0.2911512553691864,
0.4206535518169403,
-0.21190495789051056,
0.6363734602928162,
-0.4230158030986786,
-0.6669794917106628,
0.5713953375816345,
0.6536791324615479,
0.03415367752313614,
-0.019390007480978966,
-0.7539048194885254,
0.21200212836265564,
-0.2101326733827591,
-0.194407656788826,
0.30089491605758667,
0.4118795692920685,
-0.20272064208984375,
1.2721904516220093,
0.7238574624061584,
0.42137131094932556,
-0.04055539518594742,
0.13116630911827087,
1.0279076099395752,
-0.4900231659412384,
-0.3847532272338867,
-0.9291708469390869,
0.5185929536819458,
-0.12259548902511597,
-0.2015712857246399,
0.727295994758606,
0.5489280819892883,
1.0752843618392944,
0.2010403275489807,
0.6432409882545471,
0.10409623384475708,
0.3427356481552124,
-0.3192872405052185,
0.5098592638969421,
-0.8117936849594116,
0.34727737307548523,
-0.3832576274871826,
-0.8161022067070007,
-0.1184593215584755,
0.5526303052902222,
-0.224934384226799,
-0.15627595782279968,
0.8261978626251221,
0.9090024828910828,
-0.311482697725296,
-0.3115732967853546,
0.14360786974430084,
0.010046444833278656,
0.6095180511474609,
0.5667614936828613,
0.6297715306282043,
-0.19394852221012115,
0.6576499938964844,
-0.46646547317504883,
-0.16374872624874115,
0.07174305617809296,
-0.9551458358764648,
-1.3256129026412964,
-0.53875333070755,
-0.1955508440732956,
-0.26435038447380066,
0.06303278356790543,
1.0247325897216797,
0.8381637930870056,
-0.538940966129303,
-0.9806768298149109,
-0.014523888006806374,
0.1794602870941162,
-0.3013540208339691,
-0.1675998717546463,
0.2567521035671234,
-0.1556961089372635,
-0.44987204670906067,
0.2983225882053375,
0.15788932144641876,
0.0888364315032959,
-0.8523592948913574,
-0.09017981588840485,
-0.3759766221046448,
-0.1791306734085083,
0.624848484992981,
0.17451535165309906,
-0.7885730862617493,
-0.20900790393352509,
-0.107123002409935,
0.3253284990787506,
-0.1357404589653015,
1.1031568050384521,
-0.7005342245101929,
0.6145552396774292,
0.12735013663768768,
0.6474488973617554,
0.5691539645195007,
-0.4474327862262726,
0.9916319847106934,
-0.7437756657600403,
0.12544405460357666,
0.0600164532661438,
0.379352331161499,
0.16521398723125458,
-0.23751583695411682,
0.571471631526947,
-0.23272062838077545,
-0.5082103610038757,
-1.0304195880889893,
0.35452863574028015,
-0.7869941592216492,
-0.42215168476104736,
1.1707870960235596,
0.07600618153810501,
-0.12555451691150665,
-0.38874173164367676,
-0.19084200263023376,
0.17792370915412903,
-0.4026232063770294,
0.6719553470611572,
0.826185941696167,
0.07306035608053207,
-0.21328504383563995,
-0.7861200571060181,
0.17308062314987183,
-0.052693042904138565,
-0.858626127243042,
0.25398993492126465,
0.2318657785654068,
0.32892727851867676,
0.17724496126174927,
0.43695300817489624,
0.1209769994020462,
-0.0006210962892509997,
-0.32442259788513184,
-0.04822296276688576,
-0.4344775676727295,
-0.4352724850177765,
-0.3014760911464691,
0.09854065626859665,
0.1468515843153,
0.2405463457107544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16528v1
|
LoQT: Low Rank Adapters for Quantized Training
| 2024-05-26T11:29:57 | 2024-05-26T11:29:57 |
Sebastian Loeschcke, Mads Toftrup, Michael J. Kastoryano, Serge Belongie, Vésteinn Snæbjarnarson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Training of large neural networks requires significant computational
resources. Despite advances using low-rank adapters and quantization,
pretraining of models such as LLMs on consumer hardware has not been possible
without model sharding, offloading during training, or per-layer gradient
updates. To address these limitations, we propose LoQT, a method for
efficiently training quantized models. LoQT uses gradient-based tensor
factorization to initialize low-rank trainable weight matrices that are
periodically merged into quantized full-rank weight matrices. Our approach is
suitable for both pretraining and fine-tuning of models, which we demonstrate
experimentally for language modeling and downstream task adaptation. We find
that LoQT enables efficient training of models up to 7B parameters on a
consumer-grade 24GB GPU. We also demonstrate the feasibility of training a 13B
parameter model using per-layer gradient updates on the same hardware.
|
[
-0.1822649985551834,
-0.6292344927787781,
0.3304891288280487,
0.28855961561203003,
-0.3990219831466675,
0.014365105889737606,
0.19812707602977753,
0.032725147902965546,
-0.08560536801815033,
0.43009617924690247,
-0.27243882417678833,
-0.09498584270477295,
-0.3524198830127716,
-0.3786313235759735,
-0.322625070810318,
1.0369889736175537,
0.03329262509942055,
0.20705969631671906,
-0.11446218937635422,
-0.17078560590744019,
-0.07455872744321823,
-0.6973459720611572,
-0.9840252995491028,
-0.2622887194156647,
0.6714670658111572,
-0.02309310995042324,
0.6425807476043701,
0.3744654953479767,
0.5022351145744324,
0.2803094685077667,
0.11249710619449615,
-0.17913788557052612,
-0.6662073135375977,
0.026687242090702057,
0.0043717664666473866,
-0.587118923664093,
-0.9071975350379944,
-0.04449186101555824,
0.6932128667831421,
0.7526893019676208,
-0.20404542982578278,
0.31080949306488037,
0.17152073979377747,
0.828715980052948,
-0.896664559841156,
-0.12866289913654327,
-0.47538891434669495,
0.28860023617744446,
0.17617598176002502,
-0.2638026773929596,
-0.1549706757068634,
-0.3041056990623474,
-0.06914627552032471,
-0.9179477691650391,
0.03241848573088646,
-0.11126324534416199,
0.37830430269241333,
0.6710755825042725,
-0.5844606161117554,
0.43817564845085144,
-0.8059868216514587,
0.7133038640022278,
-0.6263280510902405,
0.4987247884273529,
0.3611457943916321,
0.22236208617687225,
0.013436183333396912,
-0.9767340421676636,
-0.10871659219264984,
-0.10915414243936539,
0.19619320333003998,
0.24151884019374847,
-0.19688096642494202,
0.3916073441505432,
0.584283173084259,
0.48941388726234436,
-0.45973262190818787,
0.05237795040011406,
-0.1355351060628891,
0.18929986655712128,
0.36018258333206177,
0.031524427235126495,
-0.01538882963359356,
0.12067049741744995,
-0.5229971408843994,
0.05411878228187561,
-0.8323834538459778,
0.09316632151603699,
0.15546274185180664,
0.0709085538983345,
-0.0464835949242115,
0.3646411597728729,
-0.42831411957740784,
0.7111153602600098,
0.33298635482788086,
0.03589842841029167,
-0.2910648286342621,
-0.19684650003910065,
-0.511615514755249,
-0.045147333294153214,
0.5537094473838806,
-0.20648252964019775,
-0.03290153667330742,
-0.20610754191875458,
-0.5806472301483154,
-0.31724148988723755,
0.29024213552474976,
-1.24465811252594,
-0.4515492022037506,
0.12421885877847672,
-0.45302656292915344,
-0.4032370150089264,
-0.4385536015033722,
-0.21129558980464935,
-0.40270984172821045,
-0.28249692916870117,
0.9877132177352905,
-0.30755022168159485,
0.12780845165252686,
0.15369388461112976,
-0.028195146471261978,
0.13734136521816254,
0.4535538852214813,
-1.0185388326644897,
0.3794599175453186,
0.49555855989456177,
0.6984069347381592,
0.00400623120367527,
-0.041464246809482574,
-0.9404710531234741,
-0.044453516602516174,
-0.3061896562576294,
0.49285081028938293,
-0.1905377060174942,
-0.21620014309883118,
-0.2001693993806839,
-0.10189541429281235,
-0.12302890419960022,
-0.4022614359855652,
0.3630177676677704,
-0.8714341521263123,
-0.15265852212905884,
-0.25894203782081604,
-0.258871853351593,
0.0711202546954155,
0.2747739851474762,
-0.5671662092208862,
1.0947827100753784,
0.6381957530975342,
-0.5997245907783508,
0.12411744147539139,
-0.8332066535949707,
-0.2815272808074951,
0.15012498199939728,
0.14641374349594116,
-0.43943890929222107,
0.4847848415374756,
0.1564464420080185,
0.43906229734420776,
-0.371212363243103,
-0.018616605550050735,
-0.3452050983905792,
-0.7139262557029724,
0.36715036630630493,
-0.34735068678855896,
0.8408793807029724,
0.1326444447040558,
-0.16851434111595154,
0.17782987654209137,
-0.8760926127433777,
0.0854741632938385,
0.10476122051477432,
-0.7412165999412537,
-0.3353097140789032,
-0.025874614715576172,
-0.04386698082089424,
0.13857662677764893,
0.2200220674276352,
-0.2848755717277527,
0.5103964805603027,
-0.0406918078660965,
1.0966169834136963,
0.7829603552818298,
-0.21142540872097015,
0.4690488576889038,
-0.24746482074260712,
0.7572556734085083,
0.09661910682916641,
0.25222715735435486,
0.0841183215379715,
-0.0728650838136673,
-1.1427844762802124,
-0.43246346712112427,
0.7169072031974792,
0.41402649879455566,
-1.0760184526443481,
0.26031187176704407,
-0.48267850279808044,
-0.3066582977771759,
-0.407938152551651,
0.05486851558089256,
0.18808136880397797,
0.2754441499710083,
0.4102863669395447,
-0.10452084243297577,
-0.32867690920829773,
-0.7438123226165771,
-0.09825939685106277,
-0.036621689796447754,
-0.28132638335227966,
0.10778933763504028,
0.42374640703201294,
-0.07792553305625916,
0.6879881024360657,
-0.4449220597743988,
-0.12656840682029724,
0.18505646288394928,
0.1455129235982895,
0.04997219517827034,
0.7199355959892273,
0.46343761682510376,
-0.5226733088493347,
-0.34753304719924927,
-0.007798160891979933,
-0.6671756505966187,
0.36033186316490173,
0.09701289981603622,
-0.3094244599342346,
-0.1422003209590912,
0.8522012829780579,
-0.34181585907936096,
0.20575745403766632,
0.7701331973075867,
-0.1820378601551056,
-0.02524230256676674,
-0.1288154423236847,
0.008815694600343704,
-1.046150803565979,
0.043646279722452164,
-0.05017373710870743,
-0.6086805462837219,
-0.5717039704322815,
-0.006917678751051426,
-0.0009191494318656623,
-0.5439891815185547,
-0.5044770240783691,
0.5199037194252014,
-0.10563986003398895,
-0.1993376612663269,
-0.11185368150472641,
-0.15096911787986755,
0.1024174615740776,
0.7460379600524902,
-0.21041569113731384,
0.8815074563026428,
0.4555833041667938,
-0.5113433599472046,
0.3308740258216858,
0.08995985984802246,
-0.2653675377368927,
0.7375476360321045,
-0.7697343230247498,
0.29163241386413574,
0.01812015473842621,
0.2142086923122406,
-0.6844190955162048,
0.1697973757982254,
0.02816382609307766,
-0.0998968705534935,
-0.09768298268318176,
-0.7222990393638611,
-0.25958940386772156,
0.02338670939207077,
-0.3356917202472687,
0.9094943404197693,
0.6772379875183105,
-0.6948164701461792,
0.9044830799102783,
0.06048598140478134,
0.07352781295776367,
-0.4148976504802704,
-0.5729130506515503,
-0.4892260432243347,
-0.2797243893146515,
-0.4703744351863861,
0.34863054752349854,
-0.17592354118824005,
0.16188566386699677,
-0.11263212561607361,
-0.10225453972816467,
-0.1973365992307663,
0.6728203892707825,
0.2987930476665497,
0.15908238291740417,
-0.6836734414100647,
0.01819979026913643,
-0.03011498600244522,
-0.0712117999792099,
0.045654818415641785,
-0.7714297771453857,
0.3868488371372223,
-0.20647241175174713,
-0.22105129063129425,
-0.22839584946632385,
-0.04359213262796402,
0.30021578073501587,
-0.18106545507907867,
0.6642809510231018,
0.9748393893241882,
-0.48854780197143555,
-0.4176589250564575,
-0.20367218554019928,
-0.19536274671554565,
-0.5051529407501221,
0.6275864839553833,
-0.3660948872566223,
-0.9099000692367554,
0.28616848587989807,
-0.24464072287082672,
-0.20751968026161194,
0.2146848887205124,
0.30744630098342896,
-0.25434553623199463,
1.0200108289718628,
0.6054069399833679,
-0.04924770072102547,
0.8514978289604187,
-0.27030450105667114,
0.2795075476169586,
-1.0748416185379028,
0.4082711935043335,
-0.2844667434692383,
-0.6404335498809814,
-0.6441187858581543,
-0.5578268766403198,
0.5113492608070374,
0.5965064764022827,
-0.7499581575393677,
-0.06241810694336891,
-0.3220868408679962,
0.5097768306732178,
0.7794598340988159,
0.34758976101875305,
0.322121262550354,
0.1396675705909729,
0.3846580386161804,
0.33596718311309814,
-0.805122435092926,
0.06059124320745468,
1.1018869876861572,
0.3039626181125641,
0.9202960729598999,
0.11216685175895691,
0.5050014853477478,
0.3162330687046051,
0.31810587644577026,
-1.0330379009246826,
0.4654819071292877,
-0.5307722091674805,
-0.3717096745967865,
-0.432697057723999,
-0.4940529763698578,
-0.797437846660614,
0.3066392242908478,
-0.41881537437438965,
-0.49948322772979736,
0.4046304523944855,
0.4630535840988159,
-0.9524051547050476,
0.18272764980793,
-0.6099674701690674,
0.718413233757019,
-0.20513983070850372,
-0.41911789774894714,
-0.07245325297117233,
-0.07211964577436447,
0.48003506660461426,
-0.29708677530288696,
-0.21835073828697205,
-0.07338423281908035,
-0.03900841623544693,
1.0241303443908691,
-0.5128580927848816,
0.7026104927062988,
-0.3732461929321289,
-0.08151230961084366,
0.09857713431119919,
0.061082661151885986,
0.6428208351135254,
0.380006343126297,
-0.03682909905910492,
0.011175530031323433,
0.2543984353542328,
-0.8384329676628113,
-0.7149307131767273,
0.6510024070739746,
-1.0960203409194946,
-0.47819435596466064,
-0.24379126727581024,
-0.6756168603897095,
-0.7363157868385315,
0.1184803918004036,
0.15947067737579346,
0.4086844027042389,
-0.20927415788173676,
0.39797070622444153,
0.7845285534858704,
0.006894929800182581,
0.4086229205131531,
0.26205748319625854,
-0.28756147623062134,
-0.4890747368335724,
1.150697112083435,
0.060059115290641785,
0.338175892829895,
0.4591997563838959,
0.14312154054641724,
0.31828394532203674,
-0.7179788947105408,
-0.23145155608654022,
-0.024595050141215324,
-0.6084403991699219,
-0.43450161814689636,
-0.35830187797546387,
-0.6152961850166321,
0.032144270837306976,
-0.23183420300483704,
-0.6280316710472107,
-0.6850659847259521,
-0.24619533121585846,
0.27527204155921936,
0.3617294132709503,
0.4073958694934845,
0.1402548998594284,
0.976186215877533,
-0.5643894672393799,
0.5211023688316345,
0.903855562210083,
0.3392278850078583,
-0.052749186754226685,
-0.7145319581031799,
-0.6138389706611633,
0.06466308236122131,
-0.4041092097759247,
0.0029175998643040657,
0.14670820534229279,
0.2733969986438751,
0.12423031777143478,
0.369030237197876,
0.08291313797235489,
0.5869607925415039,
-0.18136224150657654,
0.5199422240257263,
0.11960943788290024,
-1.1496857404708862,
0.27606281638145447,
-0.5555098056793213,
0.3306196630001068,
0.4661683738231659,
0.534055233001709,
-0.3076874017715454,
0.4294138252735138,
-0.24342484772205353,
-0.5743603110313416,
0.7415763139724731,
-0.011974680237472057,
0.04831064119935036,
0.44949424266815186,
0.44841477274894714,
-0.31850293278694153,
0.19750165939331055,
-0.7438469529151917,
0.03938965126872063,
-0.484387069940567,
-0.09157824516296387,
-0.008816054090857506,
-0.2190588414669037,
-0.3305279612541199,
-0.3974437117576599,
0.7098340392112732,
-0.6195809841156006,
0.5420796275138855,
-0.025885606184601784,
-0.3444032669067383,
0.00664673512801528,
0.06494998186826706,
0.3777422308921814,
0.4643140137195587,
-0.39475783705711365,
0.19032177329063416,
0.26254692673683167,
-0.49448779225349426,
0.26294979453086853,
0.19811728596687317,
-0.17166122794151306,
-0.5604585409164429,
0.09187673032283783,
1.2725178003311157,
0.43943238258361816,
-0.22882042825222015,
0.5197744965553284,
-0.3773012161254883,
-0.46191805601119995,
-0.14483068883419037,
0.20299522578716278,
0.24797001481056213,
0.4189085066318512,
0.2387847751379013,
0.06317826360464096,
-0.04100541025400162,
-0.3550660014152527,
-0.3692714273929596,
0.656162440776825,
-0.5741433501243591,
-0.40864303708076477,
0.7039558291435242,
0.33597373962402344,
-0.13348476588726044,
0.9032955169677734,
-0.034946538507938385,
-0.24967755377292633,
0.38431036472320557,
0.41671204566955566,
0.7555499076843262,
-0.17182420194149017,
0.07745712995529175,
0.14937403798103333,
0.042612701654434204,
-0.16900534927845,
0.1671387255191803,
-0.06978190690279007,
-0.6913556456565857,
-0.586511492729187,
-0.8974916934967041,
-0.20389233529567719,
0.262037456035614,
-0.6844039559364319,
0.294238418340683,
-0.8060893416404724,
-0.42131489515304565,
-0.06934294104576111,
-0.10631775856018066,
-0.7307316064834595,
0.2381756454706192,
0.1624595820903778,
0.5922548174858093,
-0.6000532507896423,
1.1654179096221924,
0.6000869870185852,
-0.1751352697610855,
-0.566304087638855,
-0.2551439106464386,
-0.6348401308059692,
-1.0789178609848022,
0.7281176447868347,
-0.4905916750431061,
0.10664854198694229,
0.658582329750061,
-0.5252177715301514,
-0.996694028377533,
1.316043496131897,
0.6930184364318848,
-0.433270126581192,
-0.3883173167705536,
0.22214797139167786,
0.2866564095020294,
-0.050138767808675766,
0.28859734535217285,
0.4903913140296936,
0.1504383683204651,
-0.12370170652866364,
-0.4405803084373474,
0.0301078911870718,
-0.1512988805770874,
0.19483743607997894,
0.20148149132728577,
-0.8221355080604553,
1.2108519077301025,
0.11127635091543198,
0.1751052439212799,
0.11598006635904312,
0.6096672415733337,
0.09107549488544464,
-0.2115411013364792,
0.6399170160293579,
0.49736857414245605,
0.706562876701355,
-0.07375114411115646,
0.8869473934173584,
-0.3556225895881653,
0.4361657500267029,
0.8479068279266357,
-0.15149854123592377,
0.8799100518226624,
0.48414888978004456,
-0.37840744853019714,
0.17366713285446167,
0.5162776112556458,
-0.007322946097701788,
0.47223421931266785,
0.4557114541530609,
-0.3518223464488983,
-0.5325098633766174,
-0.05757388100028038,
-0.3550625145435333,
0.34498411417007446,
0.07968507707118988,
-0.16418109834194183,
0.1238788515329361,
0.2161242514848709,
-0.2732095718383789,
-0.6245304942131042,
-0.7439377307891846,
0.7383163571357727,
0.3018832206726074,
-0.4554678499698639,
1.086419939994812,
-0.062175169587135315,
0.6728150248527527,
-0.5510053038597107,
0.17279218137264252,
-0.49241751432418823,
0.22679145634174347,
-0.30280613899230957,
0.07454856485128403,
-0.21742545068264008,
-0.326067179441452,
-0.2616477310657501,
-0.18065576255321503,
0.44364356994628906,
-0.13687537610530853,
-0.6191825866699219,
0.04832756891846657,
0.5352399945259094,
-0.3259468972682953,
-0.4448327124118805,
-0.5334790945053101,
-0.06426376849412918,
-0.2444051206111908,
-0.5835881233215332,
0.9353128671646118,
0.35059821605682373,
-0.21725797653198242,
0.664277195930481,
0.6405543684959412,
-0.046093378216028214,
0.17359904944896698,
-0.14175786077976227,
1.0354886054992676,
-0.6895922422409058,
-0.3908543586730957,
-0.5077370405197144,
0.3483043611049652,
0.39967775344848633,
-0.16969610750675201,
0.16369010508060455,
0.36183077096939087,
0.6339060068130493,
-0.09405811876058578,
0.784112811088562,
0.3062112033367157,
-0.09671834856271744,
-0.8419799208641052,
0.7879840731620789,
-0.6842527985572815,
0.20201902091503143,
0.2739115059375763,
-1.1046310663223267,
-0.014651601202785969,
0.6195970177650452,
-0.2768746316432953,
0.28943464159965515,
0.8786770701408386,
0.45258358120918274,
-0.3417509198188782,
-0.04842638969421387,
0.637983500957489,
0.2901194095611572,
0.1258532702922821,
0.6441852450370789,
0.9199937582015991,
-0.8142092823982239,
0.40073657035827637,
-0.2973703145980835,
0.047847095876932144,
-0.30755260586738586,
-0.9463520050048828,
-1.0372285842895508,
-0.4056547284126282,
-0.6193783283233643,
-0.40222570300102234,
0.30892467498779297,
0.7544916272163391,
1.1187299489974976,
-0.5857633948326111,
-0.1278901845216751,
-0.05404117703437805,
-0.14771321415901184,
-0.13091935217380524,
-0.1137763187289238,
0.4220375120639801,
-0.22913697361946106,
-0.5657236576080322,
0.40136346220970154,
-0.04737599194049835,
0.08651013672351837,
-0.35554128885269165,
-0.04185987263917923,
0.05191585794091225,
0.19194716215133667,
0.8840099573135376,
0.20640432834625244,
-0.14267495274543762,
-0.08075536787509918,
-0.1279018074274063,
-0.19486036896705627,
0.25916099548339844,
1.0484097003936768,
-1.0377395153045654,
-0.2608332633972168,
0.45680686831474304,
0.8608260154724121,
0.7413768768310547,
0.19256335496902466,
0.4291292130947113,
-0.6898545622825623,
0.2396116554737091,
0.2585647404193878,
0.3817667067050934,
0.21896542608737946,
-0.28139814734458923,
0.4721349775791168,
0.17491565644741058,
-0.730676531791687,
-0.8793171048164368,
-0.02959580346941948,
-1.2793837785720825,
-0.07628852128982544,
1.0019303560256958,
-0.20508429408073425,
-0.4037092626094818,
0.2617252469062805,
0.09490767866373062,
0.10051438957452774,
-0.18778912723064423,
0.5711794495582581,
0.26283130049705505,
-0.0035082183312624693,
-0.19768141210079193,
-0.7082291841506958,
0.6565443277359009,
0.5224993824958801,
-0.984606146812439,
-0.05440646782517433,
-0.08645018935203552,
0.23941613733768463,
-0.22467875480651855,
0.6584358215332031,
0.19711528718471527,
0.21913249790668488,
-0.059463389217853546,
0.07764837145805359,
-0.14549143612384796,
0.17987757921218872,
-0.5703617334365845,
0.09648333489894867,
0.655751645565033,
-0.15006668865680695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16510v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16510v3
|
Meta-Task Planning for Language Agents
| 2024-05-26T10:33:17 | 2024-05-30T12:40:06 |
Cong Zhang, Derrick Goh Xin Deik, Dexun Li, Hao Zhang, Yong Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapid advancement of neural language models has sparked a new surge of
intelligent agent research. Unlike traditional agents, large language
model-based agents (LLM agents) have emerged as a promising paradigm for
achieving artificial general intelligence (AGI) due to their superior reasoning
and generalization capabilities. Effective planning is crucial for the success
of LLM agents in real-world tasks, making it a highly pursued topic in the
community. Current planning methods typically translate tasks into executable
action sequences. However, determining a feasible or optimal sequence for
complex tasks at fine granularity, which often requires compositing long chains
of heterogeneous actions, remains challenging. This paper introduces Meta-Task
Planning (MTP), a zero-shot methodology for collaborative LLM-based multi-agent
systems that simplifies complex task planning by decomposing it into a
hierarchy of subordinate tasks, or meta-tasks. Each meta-task is then mapped
into executable actions. MTP was assessed on two rigorous benchmarks,
TravelPlanner and API-Bank. Notably, MTP achieved an average $\sim40\%$ success
rate on TravelPlanner, significantly higher than the state-of-the-art (SOTA)
baseline ($2.92\%$), and outperforming $LLM_{api}$-4 with ReAct on API-Bank by
$\sim14\%$, showing the immense potential of integrating LLM with multi-agent
systems.
|
[
-0.4573076367378235,
-0.6012285351753235,
0.7983782887458801,
0.04276196286082268,
0.10029827058315277,
0.09455811232328415,
-0.17392732203006744,
-0.20303945243358612,
0.5061397552490234,
0.5875886082649231,
-0.8211674690246582,
-0.5871894359588623,
-0.3039165735244751,
-0.10210219770669937,
0.09456957131624222,
0.7192900776863098,
-0.026076287031173706,
-0.4535633325576782,
0.03322466462850571,
-0.23898036777973175,
-0.6915814280509949,
-0.4397525489330292,
-0.5730141997337341,
-0.5923312306404114,
0.6182522773742676,
0.6262235641479492,
0.8303270936012268,
0.5279396176338196,
0.3693448007106781,
0.35032016038894653,
0.2688485383987427,
0.4805704653263092,
-0.14106681942939758,
0.24398820102214813,
-0.3729391396045685,
-0.19349612295627594,
-0.9649111032485962,
-0.12385862320661545,
0.29304659366607666,
0.5117506384849548,
-0.3563753664493561,
0.39953041076660156,
-0.06681594252586365,
0.4494746923446655,
-0.8758046627044678,
0.33978018164634705,
-0.5211846232414246,
0.1590963453054428,
0.03911472111940384,
-0.3856032192707062,
-0.3330465853214264,
0.2977098524570465,
-0.05556217581033707,
-0.4825175404548645,
-0.022851603105664253,
-0.12684571743011475,
0.22644273936748505,
0.3213033080101013,
-0.19081291556358337,
-0.21896405518054962,
-1.1301826238632202,
0.7141262292861938,
-0.6006754040718079,
0.05556763336062431,
0.21070031821727753,
0.40792596340179443,
-0.1891397088766098,
-0.5926664471626282,
-0.6032313108444214,
-0.01215179543942213,
0.0626339465379715,
0.02047220803797245,
-0.2575039863586426,
0.25531455874443054,
0.19922225177288055,
-0.28539955615997314,
-0.9244627356529236,
-0.0025774247478693724,
0.17376352846622467,
0.16790513694286346,
0.5024945735931396,
0.4726179540157318,
0.18288329243659973,
0.1155073419213295,
-0.1340244710445404,
0.13879142701625824,
-0.5148122906684875,
0.03844738006591797,
0.04440438002347946,
0.6686140298843384,
0.09263104200363159,
0.6008076667785645,
-0.5389501452445984,
0.6435924768447876,
0.038193270564079285,
-0.24127139151096344,
0.08195386081933975,
-0.5973455309867859,
-0.4547826051712036,
-0.3754693865776062,
0.7881606817245483,
0.2793343961238861,
0.2539096474647522,
-0.368553102016449,
-0.27096784114837646,
-0.17616109549999237,
0.31736451387405396,
-0.6781287789344788,
0.3023128807544708,
0.561778724193573,
-0.10946212708950043,
0.030692778527736664,
-0.46355774998664856,
-0.5134205222129822,
0.05747918784618378,
-0.4740706980228424,
0.46165212988853455,
-0.41343018412590027,
-0.19364582002162933,
0.020324883982539177,
0.1519915610551834,
0.11611124128103256,
0.21309791505336761,
-0.9216253757476807,
0.20001330971717834,
0.7830033302307129,
0.6673625707626343,
0.21734736859798431,
-0.8276444673538208,
-0.7834732532501221,
0.6448948979377747,
-0.22895200550556183,
1.095197319984436,
-0.45852652192115784,
-0.4384472966194153,
0.1959395408630371,
-0.3763907849788666,
-0.29497694969177246,
-0.29764246940612793,
0.48866838216781616,
-0.3881586194038391,
-0.1455981433391571,
-0.35421809554100037,
-0.05995628237724304,
-0.2663930356502533,
0.8726797103881836,
-0.45606639981269836,
0.4575755298137665,
0.0012340409448370337,
-0.1789967268705368,
0.2816036641597748,
-0.9560811519622803,
-0.4328800439834595,
0.07047627121210098,
-0.1480623334646225,
-0.004024376627057791,
-0.2523050606250763,
0.181326761841774,
0.6574511528015137,
-0.21341776847839355,
0.44873061776161194,
-0.23268115520477295,
-0.380845844745636,
-0.05005895718932152,
-0.04148049280047417,
0.3489879071712494,
0.10835491865873337,
-0.5291796922683716,
0.42322829365730286,
-0.43625953793525696,
0.4195789694786072,
-0.07165133953094482,
-0.30912819504737854,
-0.10985284298658371,
0.1424199938774109,
-0.1295473277568817,
0.47940337657928467,
0.16945700347423553,
-0.23570621013641357,
0.6195734143257141,
-0.405391126871109,
0.3464011251926422,
0.6429587602615356,
-0.2715984582901001,
0.7904186844825745,
-0.4364755153656006,
0.5110053420066833,
-0.539495050907135,
0.40998777747154236,
-0.11764939874410629,
-0.31600072979927063,
-0.4497554898262024,
-0.2276884764432907,
-0.09083107113838196,
0.7479336261749268,
-0.964084267616272,
0.4617871940135956,
-0.433464378118515,
-0.4439493417739868,
0.04883473366498947,
-0.17052267491817474,
0.3923664093017578,
0.13728705048561096,
0.42064857482910156,
-0.01389043778181076,
-0.13724687695503235,
-0.7092605233192444,
-0.2407877892255783,
-0.10027425736188889,
0.15870195627212524,
0.22696515917778015,
0.504850447177887,
-0.4514463543891907,
0.858836829662323,
-0.5714882016181946,
-0.46278658509254456,
-0.6843165755271912,
0.4457085132598877,
0.23135170340538025,
0.18509669601917267,
0.5655801296234131,
-0.5920217037200928,
-0.6781140565872192,
-0.15930260717868805,
-0.4565080404281616,
-0.10048960149288177,
-0.18681947886943817,
-0.20919929444789886,
0.16421155631542206,
0.18755048513412476,
-1.0227577686309814,
0.3069489300251007,
0.6006094217300415,
-0.4686022102832794,
0.6793457865715027,
-0.2271849364042282,
0.10860740393400192,
-1.0735021829605103,
0.3332436680793762,
-0.438541054725647,
-0.3102397322654724,
-0.9676951169967651,
0.4121461808681488,
-0.2396891564130783,
-0.23397815227508545,
-0.336812287569046,
0.5474792122840881,
-0.4621722102165222,
-0.267669677734375,
-0.6786472201347351,
-0.17836153507232666,
-0.4610437750816345,
1.0619313716888428,
0.027224954217672348,
0.6615962386131287,
0.3511713445186615,
-0.5608891844749451,
0.2082766592502594,
0.1706922948360443,
0.36793023347854614,
0.6983031034469604,
-0.30701524019241333,
0.1661091148853302,
0.08425455540418625,
0.39661768078804016,
-0.6250169277191162,
0.024746375158429146,
0.37352144718170166,
-0.36736708879470825,
0.3354664444923401,
-0.07110066711902618,
-0.5661713480949402,
-0.2361004501581192,
-0.34219399094581604,
0.4836196005344391,
0.10054761916399002,
-0.13787931203842163,
1.362428069114685,
0.31112614274024963,
-0.2200426608324051,
-0.8887432813644409,
-0.4985051155090332,
0.3211666941642761,
0.22233320772647858,
-0.547573447227478,
0.42297810316085815,
-0.121614009141922,
-0.0924660786986351,
0.24670358002185822,
0.0370565764605999,
0.016293717548251152,
-0.22422142326831818,
0.5383387804031372,
0.15155500173568726,
0.09084407985210419,
-0.25759729743003845,
-0.29537704586982727,
-0.6269547343254089,
-0.20910711586475372,
-0.26286453008651733,
1.098591685295105,
-0.011376587674021721,
-0.5350353121757507,
-0.18640334904193878,
0.5595365166664124,
0.700552225112915,
-0.3160928189754486,
0.5548602342605591,
0.2810050845146179,
-0.16620081663131714,
-0.38401827216148376,
-0.46428415179252625,
0.2576920986175537,
-0.3982594311237335,
0.07293762266635895,
-0.4852336049079895,
-0.5908549427986145,
0.403038889169693,
-0.2157045304775238,
0.3588750660419464,
0.3306678831577301,
0.5451604723930359,
0.026556726545095444,
0.7777143120765686,
0.8217633366584778,
-0.11471575498580933,
0.4234958291053772,
-0.6661350727081299,
0.1394229382276535,
-0.6882634162902832,
-0.037042077630758286,
-0.393396258354187,
-0.6001863479614258,
-0.3499130606651306,
-0.8058246970176697,
0.3419983685016632,
-0.6323156952857971,
-0.17526346445083618,
0.6860830187797546,
-0.1256396621465683,
0.48606017231941223,
0.6946924328804016,
-0.4483649730682373,
0.29681622982025146,
-0.23435522615909576,
-0.11349192261695862,
0.5441970825195312,
-0.4987383782863617,
-0.43408170342445374,
1.2902262210845947,
-0.1473248451948166,
0.31401386857032776,
-0.0935884341597557,
0.7280632257461548,
0.24767284095287323,
0.1254141479730606,
-0.68328857421875,
0.9385014176368713,
-0.09024599939584732,
-0.4998073875904083,
-0.6892607808113098,
-0.2769356369972229,
-0.9477481245994568,
0.443852037191391,
-0.22630904614925385,
-0.6239677667617798,
0.2901932895183563,
0.0028844568878412247,
-0.5624927282333374,
0.420171856880188,
-0.4411344826221466,
0.669282853603363,
-0.1005057692527771,
-0.19567278027534485,
-0.4518551230430603,
-0.6817613840103149,
0.24454587697982788,
-0.06064382568001747,
0.2985045611858368,
-0.40089643001556396,
-0.11693866550922394,
0.11616449058055878,
-0.3290514051914215,
0.5638174414634705,
-0.27627018094062805,
0.18528622388839722,
0.34634774923324585,
0.27494922280311584,
0.7283647060394287,
-0.5387901067733765,
-0.03890989348292351,
0.22259151935577393,
-0.13647648692131042,
-0.42996853590011597,
-0.42604631185531616,
0.48246726393699646,
-0.4308042824268341,
-0.28532326221466064,
-0.37079909443855286,
-0.995157778263092,
-0.31196653842926025,
0.1300288289785385,
-0.10252181440591812,
0.3848783075809479,
-0.37701094150543213,
-0.36126309633255005,
0.11356029659509659,
-0.19642890989780426,
1.06630539894104,
1.0413453578948975,
-0.11471626907587051,
-0.5212462544441223,
0.8271932601928711,
0.390079528093338,
0.41467756032943726,
0.6677218079566956,
-0.11276042461395264,
-0.022313639521598816,
-0.6649842858314514,
-0.4409024119377136,
0.27726468443870544,
-0.3259211480617523,
-0.19557586312294006,
-0.642526388168335,
-0.17851217091083527,
-0.4542078971862793,
-0.4037942886352539,
-0.3818696141242981,
-0.3071615993976593,
0.23601692914962769,
0.18931110203266144,
-0.5459052324295044,
0.36380305886268616,
-0.41290509700775146,
0.38810575008392334,
-0.7218278050422668,
0.5373762845993042,
0.3931416869163513,
0.06690540909767151,
-0.087662473320961,
0.03810841217637062,
-0.2641012668609619,
-0.06840746849775314,
-0.49228206276893616,
-0.6319755911827087,
0.5946319699287415,
0.12893182039260864,
0.7869132161140442,
0.46588197350502014,
0.07888932526111603,
0.8078917264938354,
-0.8096365332603455,
0.5364418625831604,
0.05351066589355469,
-0.5619916319847107,
0.4790550172328949,
-0.4799644947052002,
0.504498302936554,
0.6499239206314087,
0.16736391186714172,
-0.6482037901878357,
-0.5863621830940247,
-0.6751646399497986,
-0.8271709084510803,
0.7039925456047058,
0.34945130348205566,
-0.09514429420232773,
0.23535120487213135,
0.09278642386198044,
-0.06774644553661346,
0.44185519218444824,
-0.6628240942955017,
-0.2766585052013397,
0.24641238152980804,
0.08521189540624619,
-0.37737786769866943,
-0.24215492606163025,
-0.20526009798049927,
-0.015471640974283218,
0.4267991781234741,
-0.3975505232810974,
0.45942366123199463,
-0.05495184287428856,
0.007203156128525734,
-0.33754438161849976,
0.4952930808067322,
0.9716292023658752,
0.8304630517959595,
-0.23081845045089722,
0.2667478024959564,
0.07959277927875519,
-0.43237337470054626,
0.2916528582572937,
0.2297053337097168,
-0.3322688341140747,
-0.2657843232154846,
0.5911511778831482,
0.2265581637620926,
-0.14755260944366455,
-0.7549694776535034,
0.48100775480270386,
0.08154166489839554,
-0.27548283338546753,
-0.21284162998199463,
0.12044688314199448,
-0.019558049738407135,
0.6710125207901001,
0.2871817350387573,
0.2260821908712387,
0.25268155336380005,
-0.8301695585250854,
-0.06355436146259308,
0.5486477613449097,
-0.07383318990468979,
-0.459825724363327,
0.2547253966331482,
0.38690385222435,
-0.5693850517272949,
0.30620041489601135,
-0.546309769153595,
-0.4369341731071472,
0.5021719932556152,
0.47708332538604736,
1.3232508897781372,
-0.4965636432170868,
0.4164280891418457,
0.23594531416893005,
0.5285074710845947,
-0.03294207155704498,
0.5966832637786865,
-0.055518943816423416,
-0.7155935764312744,
-0.8436317443847656,
-0.4980350136756897,
-0.3619168996810913,
-0.059510212391614914,
0.11494364589452744,
0.17732782661914825,
-0.32055312395095825,
-0.19098003208637238,
-0.3927057385444641,
0.008305473253130913,
-0.6793442368507385,
0.06227459758520126,
0.23540641367435455,
0.6792981028556824,
-0.7766364216804504,
0.6349886655807495,
0.5731122493743896,
-0.37638235092163086,
-0.9600253105163574,
0.2555631101131439,
0.07850007712841034,
-1.0417786836624146,
0.5313802361488342,
0.20549462735652924,
-0.22065499424934387,
-0.1583155393600464,
-0.26409074664115906,
-0.9530948400497437,
1.2524596452713013,
0.29538097977638245,
-0.5723745226860046,
-0.4531572461128235,
0.6111380457878113,
0.37278133630752563,
-0.2824597954750061,
0.3096408545970917,
0.39043205976486206,
0.51509028673172,
0.40888822078704834,
-1.0949496030807495,
0.15383388102054596,
-0.01936156116425991,
-0.2984979748725891,
0.5799392461776733,
-0.5522915124893188,
0.823688268661499,
-0.2716451585292816,
-0.13497452437877655,
-0.1570332646369934,
0.2606205642223358,
0.26383695006370544,
0.683628261089325,
0.694905698299408,
0.905838668346405,
0.43706661462783813,
0.1058717891573906,
0.837230384349823,
-0.3220004737377167,
0.11991158127784729,
1.1521008014678955,
-0.4812372028827667,
0.9675471186637878,
0.28475451469421387,
0.007372601423412561,
0.42244666814804077,
0.21531806886196136,
0.2338462918996811,
0.6828712224960327,
-0.05979529395699501,
-0.2793649137020111,
-0.2802956998348236,
-0.1505071222782135,
0.007080806884914637,
0.4340645670890808,
-0.030694277957081795,
0.06016697734594345,
-0.5343144536018372,
0.16678187251091003,
0.11658312380313873,
-0.31362512707710266,
-0.3242214024066925,
0.7053349614143372,
-0.1650223582983017,
-0.853752851486206,
0.1311710625886917,
0.039572183042764664,
0.42168065905570984,
-0.744186282157898,
0.00652145454660058,
-0.11108089238405228,
0.0986889898777008,
-0.08609689027070999,
-0.8019763827323914,
0.49068719148635864,
-0.02572697214782238,
-0.15593908727169037,
-0.6416929960250854,
0.810552716255188,
-0.3222024738788605,
-0.030749119818210602,
0.35923945903778076,
0.7280988097190857,
-0.03244764730334282,
-0.6177860498428345,
-0.5881822109222412,
-0.3828897178173065,
-0.33471396565437317,
-0.2702290415763855,
0.3713654577732086,
0.4001743197441101,
0.19441361725330353,
0.8871816992759705,
0.7456504106521606,
0.09319576621055603,
-0.26615291833877563,
-0.14575079083442688,
0.8447926044464111,
-0.8104798793792725,
-0.5498440861701965,
-1.046437382698059,
0.6899327039718628,
0.11810864508152008,
0.1060146614909172,
0.30495235323905945,
0.5905167460441589,
0.5297183394432068,
0.025496594607830048,
0.43076133728027344,
-0.1162327453494072,
0.3407925069332123,
-0.3392297029495239,
0.3265902101993561,
-0.49413707852363586,
0.14206020534038544,
-0.1984722912311554,
-1.017006516456604,
-0.12605521082878113,
0.1238865852355957,
-0.30741897225379944,
-0.172790065407753,
0.7829010486602783,
0.5433752536773682,
0.01863175444304943,
-0.573427677154541,
0.5845171809196472,
-0.3039863705635071,
0.5376602411270142,
0.9121707677841187,
0.7641186118125916,
0.17806793749332428,
0.824192464351654,
-0.025405436754226685,
-0.23604875802993774,
-0.3799589276313782,
-0.7497325539588928,
-0.8151372075080872,
-0.3717527687549591,
0.017219724133610725,
0.3223084509372711,
-0.06899351626634598,
1.140655755996704,
0.7626572251319885,
-0.3805910646915436,
-0.4887221157550812,
-0.08732594549655914,
0.13064414262771606,
-0.47207435965538025,
-0.11421003192663193,
0.06997165083885193,
-0.4695832431316376,
-0.6164475083351135,
0.4876875877380371,
0.6801552176475525,
-0.2165471911430359,
-0.21092990040779114,
-0.17338715493679047,
-0.23352354764938354,
0.3036555051803589,
0.6555117964744568,
0.42926841974258423,
-0.6814290881156921,
-0.13293029367923737,
0.11732235550880432,
-0.23195326328277588,
-0.19815632700920105,
0.8308989405632019,
-0.5315263271331787,
0.19099295139312744,
0.5071694254875183,
0.35215869545936584,
0.3716369867324829,
-0.005324831698089838,
0.6372909545898438,
-0.6974678635597229,
0.15579165518283844,
0.37104740738868713,
0.12843793630599976,
-0.3507285416126251,
-0.1560170203447342,
0.8519942760467529,
0.12924768030643463,
-0.950893759727478,
-0.6038660407066345,
0.2541816830635071,
-1.179788589477539,
-0.43081068992614746,
1.124253511428833,
0.1996537446975708,
-0.08809422701597214,
0.05869833007454872,
-0.33594608306884766,
0.12549538910388947,
-0.381595253944397,
0.47382670640945435,
0.4756613075733185,
-0.5720670223236084,
0.09155348688364029,
-0.6626563668251038,
0.1971600353717804,
0.018127907067537308,
-1.0395945310592651,
0.08879715204238892,
0.5194414258003235,
-0.012170047499239445,
0.6209112405776978,
1.2428500652313232,
0.5695725679397583,
0.06155006214976311,
-0.006647226866334677,
0.46490854024887085,
-0.36370691657066345,
-0.6735262274742126,
0.24504320323467255,
0.5281500816345215,
-0.11430461704730988,
-0.4397287368774414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16482v1
|
DarijaBanking: A New Resource for Overcoming Language Barriers in Banking Intent Detection for Moroccan Arabic Speakers
| 2024-05-26T08:33:28 | 2024-05-26T08:33:28 |
Abderrahman Skiredj, Ferdaous Azhari, Ismail Berrada, Saad Ezzini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Navigating the complexities of language diversity is a central challenge in
developing robust natural language processing systems, especially in
specialized domains like banking. The Moroccan Dialect (Darija) serves as the
common language that blends cultural complexities, historical impacts, and
regional differences. The complexities of Darija present a special set of
challenges for language models, as it differs from Modern Standard Arabic with
strong influence from French, Spanish, and Tamazight, it requires a specific
approach for effective communication. To tackle these challenges, this paper
introduces \textbf{DarijaBanking}, a novel Darija dataset aimed at enhancing
intent classification in the banking domain, addressing the critical need for
automatic banking systems (e.g., chatbots) that communicate in the native
language of Moroccan clients. DarijaBanking comprises over 1,800 parallel
high-quality queries in Darija, Modern Standard Arabic (MSA), English, and
French, organized into 24 intent classes. We experimented with various intent
classification methods, including full fine-tuning of monolingual and
multilingual models, zero-shot learning, retrieval-based approaches, and Large
Language Model prompting. One of the main contributions of this work is
BERTouch, our BERT-based language model for intent classification in Darija.
BERTouch achieved F1-scores of 0.98 for Darija and 0.96 for MSA on
DarijaBanking, outperforming the state-of-the-art alternatives including GPT-4
showcasing its effectiveness in the targeted application.
|
[
-0.40092572569847107,
-0.830004870891571,
0.34132739901542664,
0.5629117488861084,
-0.26564398407936096,
0.049524616450071335,
-0.20044024288654327,
-0.4644242823123932,
0.1604398936033249,
1.0120726823806763,
-0.3687755763530731,
-1.0394880771636963,
-0.7426860332489014,
-0.11975197494029999,
-0.2889857590198517,
1.3609073162078857,
-0.16997838020324707,
-0.12123346328735352,
0.3244594633579254,
-0.17292030155658722,
-0.6500158905982971,
-0.5784071683883667,
-1.0337755680084229,
0.09127886593341827,
0.38257262110710144,
0.4981909990310669,
0.5958131551742554,
0.03218593820929527,
0.46026480197906494,
0.31912586092948914,
-0.03824122995138168,
0.26485180854797363,
-0.21129290759563446,
0.4131944477558136,
-0.09700866043567657,
-0.38387539982795715,
-0.3196621239185333,
-0.3506705164909363,
0.348713755607605,
0.49544334411621094,
-0.17151032388210297,
0.18997424840927124,
-0.12389621138572693,
0.9865148067474365,
-0.5011273622512817,
0.27274686098098755,
-0.4163070321083069,
-0.42585280537605286,
-0.34137994050979614,
0.0388384684920311,
-0.3757522404193878,
-0.4798637926578522,
0.26241183280944824,
0.09756912291049957,
0.11868824809789658,
-0.2252674400806427,
0.7081854939460754,
0.16449013352394104,
-0.7673943042755127,
-0.9035937786102295,
-0.6342849135398865,
0.689166247844696,
-0.42615267634391785,
0.35850638151168823,
0.7650473117828369,
0.5975546836853027,
-0.2144414782524109,
-0.39697787165641785,
-0.39272207021713257,
-0.17368006706237793,
0.10490459948778152,
-0.4101421535015106,
-0.09122169017791748,
0.17176823318004608,
0.05860140174627304,
0.21167363226413727,
-0.42278724908828735,
-0.22249580919742584,
-0.09494607150554657,
-0.3105802834033966,
0.6553687453269958,
-0.18595737218856812,
0.18142035603523254,
-0.34723758697509766,
-0.29544252157211304,
-0.31467515230178833,
-0.3994041085243225,
0.5660193562507629,
0.728567898273468,
0.5409969687461853,
0.00865643098950386,
0.10757537186145782,
-0.17288152873516083,
0.7269434928894043,
-0.08587402105331421,
-0.2595745921134949,
0.17943701148033142,
-0.1942669153213501,
0.02029108628630638,
0.2889783978462219,
0.33627140522003174,
-0.013222520239651203,
-0.02129133604466915,
0.09774500876665115,
-0.5780968070030212,
-0.23220275342464447,
0.17752927541732788,
-0.6277143955230713,
-0.2382715493440628,
0.3695617616176605,
-0.5279067158699036,
-0.2434488981962204,
-0.14618709683418274,
-0.5000211596488953,
-0.28687530755996704,
0.026125190779566765,
0.37825706601142883,
-0.3546905219554901,
-0.06304645538330078,
0.24605140089988708,
0.15157338976860046,
0.12516902387142181,
0.3475979268550873,
-1.278610110282898,
0.5137316584587097,
0.5995368361473083,
0.7726171016693115,
0.07841619104146957,
0.38798636198043823,
-0.2823680341243744,
0.07566388696432114,
-0.04784339293837547,
0.6671434044837952,
-0.5255346894264221,
-0.47477543354034424,
0.06233685836195946,
-0.3823675215244293,
0.2221096307039261,
-0.2650824785232544,
1.27536940574646,
-0.7380059361457825,
-0.17875514924526215,
-0.09326273947954178,
-0.1835540235042572,
-0.8184541463851929,
0.31719106435775757,
-0.8571383953094482,
0.7850128412246704,
0.24656954407691956,
-0.24098363518714905,
0.3892061710357666,
-0.8068271279335022,
-0.5238980054855347,
0.13921058177947998,
-0.10999023169279099,
-0.5435972213745117,
0.09088733047246933,
0.33464232087135315,
0.22026480734348297,
-0.21274201571941376,
0.5633290410041809,
0.08912548422813416,
-0.12023142725229263,
0.4889377951622009,
-0.8419720530509949,
0.933247447013855,
0.26931527256965637,
-0.4532342851161957,
-0.08871354162693024,
-0.7828856110572815,
-0.20999516546726227,
-0.10703057050704956,
-0.08047877252101898,
-0.5536264777183533,
-0.01980612985789776,
0.17742730677127838,
0.3576483130455017,
0.642363429069519,
-0.6395083665847778,
0.21081720292568207,
-0.4590553045272827,
-0.10750649869441986,
0.8276217579841614,
-0.10611283779144287,
0.25655803084373474,
-0.35211995244026184,
0.5225397348403931,
-0.058002740144729614,
0.21030056476593018,
-0.020094243809580803,
-0.7604047656059265,
-0.6093427538871765,
-0.5562430024147034,
0.6371349096298218,
0.520209014415741,
-0.4883989095687866,
0.1425773799419403,
0.016555659472942352,
-0.37009796500205994,
-0.5269734859466553,
0.2526605427265167,
0.24981218576431274,
0.1548449695110321,
0.10476851463317871,
-0.5068519115447998,
-0.6442444920539856,
-0.9871442914009094,
-0.20349706709384918,
-0.17605377733707428,
0.32069623470306396,
0.7837297320365906,
0.2003956139087677,
-0.4174550771713257,
0.8683762550354004,
-0.3388700783252716,
-0.6056110262870789,
-0.5192171335220337,
0.3937145173549652,
1.0484859943389893,
0.26693716645240784,
1.005314588546753,
-1.2128313779830933,
-0.8830963373184204,
0.3260084092617035,
-0.2064761221408844,
-0.24321423470973969,
-0.1736629605293274,
0.07635165750980377,
0.49215492606163025,
0.0017269973177462816,
-0.26898905634880066,
0.7582700848579407,
0.8068366646766663,
-0.3878195881843567,
0.28774991631507874,
-0.28878623247146606,
0.30225077271461487,
-0.8171422481536865,
-0.16486942768096924,
-0.457521915435791,
-0.14453551173210144,
-0.8667897582054138,
-0.6250595450401306,
-0.10786378383636475,
0.1429189294576645,
-0.12074338644742966,
0.8845616579055786,
-0.13330522179603577,
0.024561932310461998,
-0.6028800010681152,
-0.16103167831897736,
-0.32082515954971313,
0.5685067176818848,
0.0913139060139656,
0.553297758102417,
0.6884356737136841,
-0.7389302253723145,
0.30942076444625854,
0.7200241088867188,
-0.5950217247009277,
0.3211323618888855,
-0.4822600483894348,
-0.02089359425008297,
0.028419680893421173,
0.18776185810565948,
-1.405093789100647,
-0.24147629737854004,
0.41651809215545654,
-0.6451703906059265,
0.14632830023765564,
-0.27518555521965027,
-0.26834073662757874,
-0.23981031775474548,
0.10505905002355576,
0.7448038458824158,
0.4584190845489502,
-0.6869702339172363,
0.9773004055023193,
0.26630204916000366,
-0.8155476450920105,
-1.0508114099502563,
-0.4131854474544525,
0.16304244101047516,
-0.13611461222171783,
-0.7909741401672363,
0.10568013042211533,
0.30660557746887207,
-0.08384314179420471,
-0.23275311291217804,
-0.1326812207698822,
-0.3833897113800049,
0.3907544016838074,
0.45572179555892944,
0.37852030992507935,
0.18239541351795197,
0.19440968334674835,
0.38054513931274414,
-0.10279654711484909,
0.19304627180099487,
-0.33365219831466675,
0.6933554410934448,
0.10296674817800522,
-0.3872009515762329,
-0.3578436076641083,
0.39350318908691406,
0.27184873819351196,
-0.2552061378955841,
0.9862442016601562,
0.4829261898994446,
-0.029709717258810997,
-0.42541831731796265,
-0.5920413136482239,
0.08321310579776764,
-0.5344444513320923,
0.021357210353016853,
-0.5836976766586304,
-0.8690441250801086,
0.6903539896011353,
-0.03687150403857231,
0.3391241431236267,
-0.031442660838365555,
0.7421582341194153,
0.09714564681053162,
0.9507021307945251,
0.8053218126296997,
-0.021072961390018463,
0.5954707860946655,
0.04417574033141136,
0.6767242550849915,
-0.22641535103321075,
-0.13329041004180908,
-0.589060366153717,
-0.4488174319267273,
-0.8736608028411865,
-0.2817090153694153,
0.2854561507701874,
-0.27850982546806335,
0.38702094554901123,
0.5793619155883789,
0.01389752421528101,
0.2620353102684021,
0.5466197729110718,
-0.012253989465534687,
0.20895230770111084,
0.030001947656273842,
-0.1261485069990158,
0.19275784492492676,
-0.3621614873409271,
-0.7179309129714966,
1.4644384384155273,
0.29285600781440735,
0.7455591559410095,
0.5459189414978027,
1.128531813621521,
0.605981171131134,
0.35792770981788635,
-0.505711019039154,
0.3649863302707672,
-0.255368173122406,
-0.9084675908088684,
-0.32610324025154114,
-0.44254428148269653,
-1.1098982095718384,
0.24031703174114227,
0.07406174391508102,
-0.8461732864379883,
0.4582042992115021,
0.17597198486328125,
-0.5379374623298645,
0.0514654703438282,
-0.5403954386711121,
0.9102501273155212,
-0.5093499422073364,
-0.2615368962287903,
-0.08697159588336945,
-0.5545447468757629,
0.366378515958786,
-0.3318173885345459,
0.48297637701034546,
-0.288339227437973,
0.19971540570259094,
0.6180680394172668,
-0.12165901064872742,
0.7556596994400024,
-0.38531795144081116,
-0.5835804343223572,
0.4955507218837738,
0.024847567081451416,
0.6243426203727722,
0.20603162050247192,
-0.06919371336698532,
0.3717707395553589,
-0.1795455366373062,
-0.49922847747802734,
-0.4745229482650757,
0.6130157709121704,
-0.5727465152740479,
-0.26859593391418457,
-0.5110095739364624,
-0.947291374206543,
-0.20788517594337463,
0.18609854578971863,
-0.25628185272216797,
0.29055240750312805,
-0.4664144515991211,
0.10630659013986588,
0.6610495448112488,
-0.24133989214897156,
0.27667874097824097,
0.7048280239105225,
-0.4596345126628876,
-0.18830621242523193,
1.0004318952560425,
-0.24994659423828125,
0.028059478849172592,
0.3938596248626709,
-0.2775353491306305,
-0.6369128823280334,
-0.7965331077575684,
-0.06440393626689911,
0.2076069861650467,
-0.6774750351905823,
-0.13336670398712158,
-0.7229805588722229,
0.017993086948990822,
-0.7694093585014343,
-0.1441851556301117,
-0.14052674174308777,
-0.4887530505657196,
0.24251914024353027,
0.043691206723451614,
0.2873111069202423,
0.6306890845298767,
-0.4260345697402954,
0.605586588382721,
-0.9817871451377869,
0.5402737855911255,
0.34180325269699097,
0.3946162164211273,
-0.36750316619873047,
-0.5999947190284729,
-0.2293674796819687,
0.09654711931943893,
-0.04401039332151413,
-0.7449976205825806,
0.6272768378257751,
0.09392047673463821,
0.6565847396850586,
0.6380849480628967,
0.022994862869381905,
0.11521296948194504,
-0.12598274648189545,
0.2697702944278717,
-0.2252196967601776,
-1.0133371353149414,
0.5742049813270569,
-0.3781374990940094,
-0.06853500753641129,
0.8421115875244141,
0.49038204550743103,
-0.9946659207344055,
-0.2364499717950821,
-0.5407527685165405,
-1.0419610738754272,
1.037169098854065,
0.49623194336891174,
0.11720149964094162,
-0.1751953363418579,
0.08349665254354477,
0.4344075620174408,
0.4584812819957733,
-0.8319020867347717,
-0.2437841147184372,
0.01684679463505745,
-0.457912802696228,
-0.04896598309278488,
-0.4247116446495056,
0.09756883978843689,
0.03408540040254593,
0.7790601253509521,
0.10423263907432556,
0.022434376180171967,
-0.20128586888313293,
-0.30248817801475525,
0.23525691032409668,
0.2521335184574127,
0.43033939599990845,
0.35782793164253235,
-0.48908960819244385,
-0.23010753095149994,
-0.22568586468696594,
-0.6826719045639038,
0.258107990026474,
0.2373598963022232,
-0.31619277596473694,
0.3500518500804901,
-0.12580789625644684,
0.8551842570304871,
0.08756138384342194,
-0.9814899563789368,
0.6065280437469482,
-0.36018106341362,
-0.17805008590221405,
-0.4676884710788727,
0.1330263465642929,
-0.2976793050765991,
0.2529389262199402,
0.27652275562286377,
0.028625892475247383,
0.4394054114818573,
-0.3917449116706848,
0.21457190811634064,
0.4937460422515869,
-0.3745993673801422,
0.059366218745708466,
0.05219206213951111,
0.5213712453842163,
-0.23169797658920288,
0.6203715205192566,
-0.46319472789764404,
-0.5757777690887451,
0.617486834526062,
0.42365744709968567,
1.0085331201553345,
-0.6869861483573914,
0.469180703163147,
0.4112066626548767,
0.22400611639022827,
0.05722767114639282,
0.5641893744468689,
-0.7067360877990723,
-0.7752323746681213,
-0.1772293746471405,
-0.8744775056838989,
-0.4603159725666046,
-0.26866716146469116,
-0.6912675499916077,
0.31038349866867065,
-0.422603964805603,
-0.13147291541099548,
-0.06575135141611099,
-0.11259564012289047,
-0.5155831575393677,
-0.030122829601168633,
0.446044385433197,
0.6455836296081543,
-0.8517065644264221,
0.896510124206543,
0.6031162142753601,
-0.02714345045387745,
-0.26469284296035767,
-0.3205454647541046,
-0.23738376796245575,
-0.8544790148735046,
1.0219286680221558,
0.3607509136199951,
-0.24572357535362244,
-0.17676159739494324,
-0.43218833208084106,
-0.9524211883544922,
0.6389987468719482,
-0.05870423465967178,
-0.49115076661109924,
0.18407274782657623,
0.3482191264629364,
0.3197246789932251,
-0.2027975469827652,
0.08311969041824341,
0.7784221172332764,
0.6028090119361877,
0.15180030465126038,
-0.7317866086959839,
-0.38559406995773315,
-0.06167261675000191,
-0.17803311347961426,
0.7593111991882324,
-0.359962522983551,
0.8559863567352295,
-0.09597448259592056,
-0.2498982548713684,
0.3154420256614685,
0.767741322517395,
0.009114690124988556,
0.4444279372692108,
0.60246342420578,
0.46526405215263367,
0.8169312477111816,
-0.2164098173379898,
0.7531697154045105,
-0.32976076006889343,
0.22551164031028748,
0.9921379089355469,
-0.38018929958343506,
0.4994523525238037,
0.2608259916305542,
-0.03866022825241089,
0.800552248954773,
0.3654361367225647,
0.31392601132392883,
0.6021968722343445,
0.05688101425766945,
-0.6889401078224182,
-0.20704567432403564,
-0.28113019466400146,
0.09242429584264755,
0.7539838552474976,
0.9175519347190857,
-0.2305358201265335,
-0.35189124941825867,
0.2999718487262726,
-0.2664536237716675,
0.021534213796257973,
-0.3016229271888733,
0.6495733261108398,
-0.07711523026227951,
-0.5455008149147034,
0.4234635829925537,
0.02127615548670292,
0.492609441280365,
-0.9628333449363708,
-0.13158077001571655,
-0.227145716547966,
0.2391723096370697,
0.019313964992761612,
-0.6215558052062988,
0.09555220603942871,
0.11301472783088684,
-0.20856891572475433,
-0.3836947977542877,
0.7534005641937256,
-0.5408148765563965,
-0.2971300184726715,
0.2925181984901428,
0.1751682311296463,
0.32449713349342346,
-0.07345675677061081,
-0.7059982419013977,
0.07141929119825363,
0.2458052933216095,
0.1970777064561844,
0.13121913373470306,
0.6631242036819458,
-0.2582707405090332,
0.6933835744857788,
0.7768658995628357,
-0.14153926074504852,
-0.08368002623319626,
0.19874300062656403,
0.5526105165481567,
-0.8304169774055481,
-0.7902318835258484,
-0.6265400648117065,
0.02747269906103611,
-0.07044311612844467,
-0.27773958444595337,
0.9729464650154114,
0.32859480381011963,
0.7714178562164307,
0.03539891913533211,
0.7485714554786682,
-0.13688136637210846,
0.5890516042709351,
-0.29943716526031494,
0.4075896739959717,
-0.19729465246200562,
0.2536700665950775,
-0.33680543303489685,
-0.915838360786438,
-0.044727642089128494,
0.7034395337104797,
-0.6278579235076904,
0.05700337514281273,
0.33069491386413574,
0.6533541083335876,
0.23528330028057098,
0.0469626821577549,
0.3551705777645111,
0.18962979316711426,
0.29016706347465515,
0.691411018371582,
0.7780569195747375,
-0.38265684247016907,
0.7606672048568726,
-0.19392205774784088,
-0.29326102137565613,
-0.6609768867492676,
-0.5174664258956909,
-1.0376189947128296,
-0.5124126672744751,
0.005904375109821558,
-0.06625672429800034,
0.061708904802799225,
0.9539011716842651,
0.22961047291755676,
-1.2200124263763428,
-0.4875028729438782,
-0.07252433151006699,
0.37918609380722046,
-0.27314627170562744,
-0.1252949833869934,
0.2472677379846573,
-0.5472347140312195,
-0.78653883934021,
0.13451837003231049,
0.5118881464004517,
0.2471242994070053,
0.00951421819627285,
-0.05310869961977005,
-0.39765992760658264,
0.28665539622306824,
0.46718108654022217,
0.3958245515823364,
-0.42477911710739136,
0.0969938188791275,
-0.16989831626415253,
-0.23979796469211578,
-0.11258494108915329,
0.7739441394805908,
-0.6605821251869202,
0.493069589138031,
0.46700069308280945,
0.9042319059371948,
0.3831685483455658,
0.11480776220560074,
0.3700038492679596,
-0.7743671536445618,
0.3301887810230255,
0.5937464237213135,
0.16641241312026978,
0.09307265281677246,
-0.39953020215034485,
0.23829372227191925,
-0.2888104319572449,
-0.6885461211204529,
-0.5109413862228394,
0.32432422041893005,
-1.1049867868423462,
-0.29714974761009216,
0.7503543496131897,
-0.05677544325590134,
-0.5446692109107971,
-0.7350218892097473,
-0.82552570104599,
-0.02714977227151394,
-0.841131329536438,
1.0232585668563843,
0.9296324253082275,
-0.07633921504020691,
0.20996887981891632,
-0.6652685403823853,
0.6033493280410767,
0.7576869130134583,
-0.5035002827644348,
0.09231311827898026,
0.436655730009079,
-0.18065190315246582,
0.2823120057582855,
0.6783364415168762,
0.11312463134527206,
0.7707139849662781,
-0.16918465495109558,
0.19332674145698547,
0.2035234421491623,
-0.38496503233909607,
-0.2676122188568115,
0.02543119341135025,
0.055820465087890625,
-0.21204420924186707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16473v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16473v1
|
M$^3$CoT: A Novel Benchmark for Multi-Domain Multi-step Multi-modal Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-05-26T07:56:30 | 2024-05-26T07:56:30 |
Qiguang Chen, Libo Qin, Jin Zhang, Zhi Chen, Xiao Xu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Multi-modal Chain-of-Thought (MCoT) requires models to leverage knowledge
from both textual and visual modalities for step-by-step reasoning, which gains
increasing attention. Nevertheless, the current MCoT benchmark still faces some
challenges: (1) absence of visual modal reasoning, (2) single-step visual modal
reasoning, and (3) Domain missing, thereby hindering the development of MCoT.
Motivated by this, we introduce a novel benchmark (M$^3$CoT) to address the
above challenges, advancing the multi-domain, multi-step, and multi-modal CoT.
Additionally, we conduct a thorough evaluation involving abundant MCoT
approaches on Vision Large Language Models (VLLMs). In addition, we highlight
that the current VLLMs still struggle to correctly reason in M$^3$CoT and there
remains a large gap between existing VLLMs and human performance in M$^3$CoT,
despite their superior results on previous MCoT benchmarks. To our knowledge,
we take the first meaningful step toward the multi-domain, multi-step, and
multi-modal scenario in MCoT. We hope that M$^3$CoT can serve as a valuable
resource, providing a pioneering foundation in multi-domain, multi-step,
multi-modal chain-of-thought research.
|
[
-0.6936696171760559,
-0.7234429717063904,
0.884757399559021,
0.134059876203537,
-0.405571311712265,
0.44881150126457214,
-0.06994578242301941,
-0.5480988025665283,
-0.10669146478176117,
0.41606900095939636,
-0.5128522515296936,
-0.3528669476509094,
-0.5670580863952637,
0.10504984855651855,
-0.01856025494635105,
0.5108715891838074,
-0.27698346972465515,
0.12518374621868134,
-0.13901741802692413,
-0.1515682488679886,
-0.4753968119621277,
-0.6985120177268982,
-0.47956526279449463,
0.03232000768184662,
0.6924577951431274,
0.43542978167533875,
0.6809200644493103,
0.3399304449558258,
0.5601137280464172,
0.1472172886133194,
0.141348198056221,
0.48224130272865295,
-0.2241937816143036,
-0.024160007014870644,
-0.12533147633075714,
-0.23364168405532837,
-0.7879666090011597,
0.16043028235435486,
0.6632205247879028,
0.5828768014907837,
0.04537435621023178,
-0.01448362972587347,
-0.24987897276878357,
0.9646517634391785,
-1.0677818059921265,
0.05863150954246521,
-0.7668598890304565,
-0.0041065942496061325,
-0.21427230536937714,
-0.16777493059635162,
-0.5484817028045654,
-0.029478320851922035,
-0.07274795323610306,
-0.47358185052871704,
0.16969896852970123,
0.38880857825279236,
0.40861713886260986,
-0.12480948865413666,
-0.7427922487258911,
0.01640225015580654,
-0.4336138367652893,
0.8473210334777832,
-0.2831752300262451,
0.8065914511680603,
0.30243849754333496,
0.5281869173049927,
-0.15305204689502716,
-0.6834434866905212,
-1.0106463432312012,
-0.40194064378738403,
0.40569791197776794,
-0.00033624889329075813,
0.09168670326471329,
-0.13634681701660156,
0.08321579545736313,
0.15633352100849152,
-0.25628891587257385,
-0.4868048131465912,
-0.427751749753952,
-0.1289832592010498,
0.28567367792129517,
0.2249707281589508,
-0.06357463449239731,
-0.13558922708034515,
-0.9495202898979187,
-0.22873541712760925,
-0.7042632699012756,
-0.2100234031677246,
0.0468570776283741,
0.09768333286046982,
-0.1460939645767212,
0.6497288942337036,
-0.3058920204639435,
0.6548140645027161,
-0.39984095096588135,
-0.17815668880939484,
0.43912163376808167,
-0.4720630347728729,
-0.2829258143901825,
-0.2502545118331909,
0.82198566198349,
0.42082467675209045,
0.22590576112270355,
0.12014676630496979,
-0.14216648042201996,
0.08221198618412018,
0.32287856936454773,
-0.6293565630912781,
-0.17596715688705444,
0.09531744569540024,
-0.22299599647521973,
-0.09958932548761368,
0.014846059493720531,
-0.8207904100418091,
-0.29634299874305725,
-0.3574255704879761,
0.35293787717819214,
-0.5426211953163147,
-0.3986946940422058,
0.14155545830726624,
0.06182103231549263,
0.11772211641073227,
0.6471570134162903,
-0.6782954931259155,
0.4449324607849121,
0.8082978129386902,
0.9563732147216797,
-0.31513869762420654,
-0.6625584959983826,
-0.3453685939311981,
0.2052394300699234,
-0.42205435037612915,
0.8395904302597046,
-0.7394998073577881,
-0.23134195804595947,
-0.4808007478713989,
-0.011155297048389912,
-0.35617613792419434,
-0.2768257260322571,
0.4697626531124115,
-0.3263513147830963,
-0.0916806012392044,
-0.299626886844635,
-0.21186208724975586,
-0.19438636302947998,
0.645526111125946,
-0.8369669914245605,
0.8723253011703491,
0.06291563808917999,
-0.5579686164855957,
0.48480501770973206,
-0.6399620771408081,
-0.1623837649822235,
-0.12258090078830719,
-0.6354975700378418,
-0.07282035797834396,
0.10616783052682877,
0.2229578197002411,
0.4156193435192108,
-0.905131995677948,
0.15211115777492523,
-0.5858515501022339,
-0.23505623638629913,
0.3729289174079895,
-0.718951940536499,
0.5749490857124329,
0.25210967659950256,
-0.41215479373931885,
-0.1597198247909546,
-0.9755392074584961,
0.2389921396970749,
0.026375828310847282,
-0.11868429183959961,
-0.17834985256195068,
-0.024471530690789223,
0.16421262919902802,
0.6864772439002991,
0.08295445889234543,
-0.5063014030456543,
0.20996718108654022,
0.2273605465888977,
0.24604906141757965,
0.848170816898346,
-0.09083931148052216,
-0.04696573689579964,
-0.17649871110916138,
0.46534496545791626,
0.41632094979286194,
0.32387158274650574,
-0.02970878593623638,
-0.6986998915672302,
-0.5530387759208679,
-0.6597605347633362,
0.1795145869255066,
0.1342260092496872,
-1.1077553033828735,
-0.1211511567234993,
-0.03695174679160118,
-0.4215156137943268,
-0.35826823115348816,
0.026239780709147453,
0.520248293876648,
0.24081075191497803,
0.5859764814376831,
-0.37157142162323,
-0.3626682460308075,
-0.8406806588172913,
-0.2539442479610443,
-0.18352627754211426,
0.11758943647146225,
0.23383282124996185,
0.5814578533172607,
-0.3890042006969452,
0.41432836651802063,
-0.29052960872650146,
-0.23236824572086334,
-0.09016157686710358,
0.23538880050182343,
-0.09358688443899155,
0.5879981517791748,
0.21137873828411102,
-0.8946584463119507,
-0.10350937396287918,
0.20799405872821808,
-0.5883795022964478,
0.2249058037996292,
-0.023099031299352646,
-0.35011690855026245,
0.18797507882118225,
0.5663871169090271,
-0.6235366463661194,
0.1958414763212204,
0.7365288138389587,
-0.5688427090644836,
0.6648204922676086,
-0.008435508236289024,
0.6337466239929199,
-0.9481747150421143,
0.12525980174541473,
-0.3778418004512787,
-0.2636966407299042,
-0.24368102848529816,
0.05850850045681,
0.4667554497718811,
0.04720087721943855,
-0.7006454467773438,
0.49842652678489685,
-0.5067888498306274,
0.08852831274271011,
-0.13422657549381256,
0.5486234426498413,
0.22092735767364502,
0.7441379427909851,
-0.09590990096330643,
0.8352417945861816,
0.496709942817688,
-0.6545781493186951,
0.09389158338308334,
0.04715781658887863,
-0.24613700807094574,
0.8744537234306335,
-0.2891123294830322,
0.21164658665657043,
0.2994353771209717,
0.24335260689258575,
-0.7575490474700928,
0.12122245877981186,
0.09958034008741379,
-0.27528926730155945,
0.025532789528369904,
0.1147838681936264,
-0.5922717452049255,
-0.4031452536582947,
-0.4465257525444031,
1.0128792524337769,
0.029201921075582504,
-0.59007728099823,
0.8342865705490112,
0.2646671235561371,
0.23742656409740448,
-0.7299883365631104,
-0.43295642733573914,
0.28866440057754517,
0.147477388381958,
-0.48856425285339355,
0.30629783868789673,
-0.1551205813884735,
0.009612549096345901,
-0.1308431774377823,
-0.31473636627197266,
-0.0008618731517344713,
-0.17657026648521423,
0.1286342889070511,
0.3439895212650299,
-0.4008326232433319,
0.018213842064142227,
-0.13293829560279846,
-0.2680644392967224,
0.04478165879845619,
-0.20515435934066772,
0.5060642957687378,
-0.5137110948562622,
-0.3592909574508667,
-0.09920812398195267,
0.3633030354976654,
1.0377094745635986,
-0.31998997926712036,
0.6970685720443726,
0.631525993347168,
-0.40606558322906494,
-0.12158005684614182,
-0.7980453968048096,
0.2611352801322937,
-0.3756784200668335,
0.24880185723304749,
-0.9149436354637146,
-0.8094821572303772,
0.07481155544519424,
-0.36433881521224976,
-0.4110187292098999,
0.5288407206535339,
0.672934889793396,
0.1527101844549179,
1.2610735893249512,
0.6892713308334351,
0.36769071221351624,
0.29634734988212585,
-0.26245343685150146,
0.22170722484588623,
-1.4551146030426025,
-0.4111112356185913,
-0.2483273595571518,
-0.06365363299846649,
-0.5135547518730164,
-1.0532724857330322,
0.3885209858417511,
0.3350278437137604,
-0.20410457253456116,
0.3300774097442627,
-0.16026674211025238,
0.5516895651817322,
0.49890926480293274,
0.20850954949855804,
0.5041249394416809,
-0.44359177350997925,
-0.8471953272819519,
0.3031022548675537,
-0.594327449798584,
-0.6892749071121216,
1.2383430004119873,
0.12566938996315002,
0.5756218433380127,
0.32784873247146606,
0.31371310353279114,
0.3508565127849579,
0.2025134116411209,
-0.5299554467201233,
0.721134603023529,
0.16907678544521332,
-0.6083272695541382,
0.0872751772403717,
-0.47495394945144653,
-0.7247364521026611,
0.7651011347770691,
-0.2781706750392914,
-0.8171635866165161,
0.2990292012691498,
0.15116462111473083,
0.057472191751003265,
0.5024393200874329,
-0.8419535160064697,
1.0788867473602295,
-0.2535456418991089,
-0.6840460896492004,
-0.4009144902229309,
-0.7030428647994995,
0.6791565418243408,
-0.18387050926685333,
0.3503369092941284,
-0.49101850390434265,
-0.2894376814365387,
0.604484498500824,
-0.45065218210220337,
0.40128985047340393,
-0.0433376207947731,
0.08863634616136551,
0.3753639757633209,
0.1417594701051712,
0.25204864144325256,
0.1673821061849594,
0.23797351121902466,
0.26039448380470276,
0.2724155783653259,
-0.5841534733772278,
-0.30813679099082947,
0.9502778053283691,
-0.6324044466018677,
-0.34882864356040955,
-0.602394700050354,
-0.4022490978240967,
-0.7268096804618835,
0.3202383816242218,
-0.2520066499710083,
0.4692452549934387,
-0.216953307390213,
0.32096797227859497,
0.3307667374610901,
0.23614536225795746,
0.4630621373653412,
0.4150306284427643,
-0.3134991526603699,
-0.8356605768203735,
0.7960624694824219,
-0.33245858550071716,
0.6082280874252319,
0.41112715005874634,
0.10116210579872131,
-0.250951886177063,
-0.3101027011871338,
-0.5315595865249634,
0.1510203778743744,
-0.8390132784843445,
-0.4415890574455261,
-0.9152024388313293,
0.09598881751298904,
0.03509466350078583,
-0.073668472468853,
-0.6609002351760864,
-0.5170525312423706,
0.1543792188167572,
0.11471381038427353,
0.11207432299852371,
0.6381986141204834,
0.05057336762547493,
-0.08806000649929047,
-0.6702731251716614,
0.8515763282775879,
0.405304491519928,
0.7478918433189392,
0.18873615562915802,
0.1490999460220337,
-0.34953299164772034,
0.006203450262546539,
-0.7012894749641418,
-0.5138784050941467,
-0.1707731932401657,
-0.1931513398885727,
0.49889394640922546,
0.3002164661884308,
-0.09609640389680862,
0.8173220753669739,
-0.681583046913147,
0.8503288626670837,
0.5779198408126831,
-1.1977847814559937,
0.3597630262374878,
-0.05332593619823456,
0.396637886762619,
0.7366478443145752,
0.21291318535804749,
-0.24536779522895813,
-0.4513460397720337,
-0.7485665678977966,
-0.7707618474960327,
0.5099021792411804,
0.3925711512565613,
-0.41408243775367737,
-0.45529061555862427,
-0.22242601215839386,
0.19314999878406525,
0.4085690379142761,
-0.6747730374336243,
0.018099436536431313,
-0.04230686277151108,
0.0068431817926466465,
-0.06964106112718582,
-0.09417299926280975,
-0.08335573971271515,
-0.3349274694919586,
0.5254981517791748,
-0.35482582449913025,
0.42118099331855774,
0.42401400208473206,
-0.19772782921791077,
-0.2007264494895935,
0.216134175658226,
0.9073265790939331,
0.979032039642334,
-0.40532925724983215,
0.7179192900657654,
0.17056478559970856,
-0.7172346711158752,
0.14965443313121796,
-0.22303710877895355,
0.48891615867614746,
-0.3184613585472107,
0.24782907962799072,
0.638281524181366,
0.27879390120506287,
-0.9229210615158081,
0.6596547365188599,
-0.276944100856781,
-0.23301148414611816,
0.00024739978834986687,
0.04014691337943077,
-0.033555082976818085,
0.48036086559295654,
0.30644869804382324,
0.7275745868682861,
0.054440148174762726,
-0.7407734990119934,
0.1973692774772644,
0.31785786151885986,
-0.49653851985931396,
-0.16433711349964142,
0.855471134185791,
0.19418390095233917,
-0.17069227993488312,
0.09756217896938324,
-0.0216081403195858,
-0.5142115354537964,
0.3395627737045288,
0.48779258131980896,
1.0503697395324707,
0.17793036997318268,
-0.07490122318267822,
0.2185869961977005,
0.5265486240386963,
-0.1876896172761917,
0.4692557752132416,
-0.2760973572731018,
-0.5283791422843933,
-0.19678395986557007,
-0.5578210353851318,
-0.6548105478286743,
-0.17091704905033112,
-0.421123206615448,
0.3515915274620056,
-0.5610187649726868,
-0.2247171700000763,
-0.17291106283664703,
-0.09014085680246353,
-0.9077379703521729,
0.48192429542541504,
0.3784906566143036,
0.9412894248962402,
-0.36758309602737427,
0.9676056504249573,
0.3065233826637268,
-0.40896478295326233,
-0.4445510804653168,
0.040617089718580246,
0.03182187303900719,
-0.7984745502471924,
0.21775087714195251,
0.3919454514980316,
-1.064079999923706,
-0.23018011450767517,
-0.4458593428134918,
-0.6731671094894409,
1.2775629758834839,
0.25309544801712036,
-0.6144788265228271,
0.3798234462738037,
-0.10787174105644226,
0.3109351694583893,
-0.8319689035415649,
0.18988382816314697,
0.6335183382034302,
0.2962491810321808,
0.1450054794549942,
-0.8549992442131042,
0.2626633644104004,
-0.3886539041996002,
0.09152209013700485,
0.4289012551307678,
-0.8252236843109131,
1.1766852140426636,
-0.45167210698127747,
-0.00997366476804018,
-0.04941394180059433,
0.5063391923904419,
0.5836197733879089,
0.5517973899841309,
0.5409987568855286,
0.40456250309944153,
0.6318734884262085,
0.009536070749163628,
1.0841816663742065,
-0.27101239562034607,
0.41265472769737244,
1.1109651327133179,
-0.3611926734447479,
1.3140193223953247,
0.7770978808403015,
-0.2284115105867386,
0.5975189805030823,
0.24537932872772217,
0.21759721636772156,
0.4758455455303192,
0.04926222562789917,
-0.32024145126342773,
-0.28013521432876587,
0.2417604774236679,
-0.6200012564659119,
0.35981908440589905,
0.32782208919525146,
-0.2510497570037842,
0.26871755719184875,
0.015414929017424583,
0.011111474595963955,
-0.15801207721233368,
-0.29655852913856506,
0.544156014919281,
0.047367557883262634,
-0.502927839756012,
0.9385354518890381,
-0.1420368254184723,
0.2993185520172119,
-0.4428199827671051,
-0.11429162323474884,
0.11412924528121948,
0.3400312662124634,
0.1775517463684082,
-0.5964181423187256,
-0.13713444769382477,
-0.07050242274999619,
-0.08368491381406784,
-0.060052771121263504,
0.22066201269626617,
-0.1673753708600998,
-0.6900789737701416,
0.4222567081451416,
0.7368249893188477,
-0.07655391842126846,
-0.32188451290130615,
-0.6126910448074341,
0.2626246213912964,
-0.30043426156044006,
-0.22027043998241425,
0.018685264512896538,
0.95515376329422,
-0.10386627167463303,
0.6654300689697266,
0.6375255584716797,
-0.2053113728761673,
0.13741055130958557,
0.2553062438964844,
0.9877417087554932,
-1.2830078601837158,
-0.3066142201423645,
-0.9325034022331238,
0.4392753541469574,
-0.1472487598657608,
-0.6043267846107483,
0.4248040020465851,
0.6529452800750732,
0.9066370725631714,
-0.10904069989919662,
0.571553647518158,
-0.179109588265419,
0.2533574402332306,
-0.8633576035499573,
0.4290045499801636,
-0.8753933906555176,
0.24376261234283447,
-0.6855027079582214,
-1.0537290573120117,
-0.33969220519065857,
0.40065816044807434,
-0.010572102852165699,
0.23057924211025238,
1.7665849924087524,
0.4674527049064636,
-0.20977652072906494,
0.3207874894142151,
0.6351334452629089,
0.09838012605905533,
0.38712188601493835,
0.7231469750404358,
0.96696537733078,
-0.634696900844574,
0.5232459306716919,
-0.14208325743675232,
-0.3064080774784088,
-0.18654543161392212,
-1.0057799816131592,
-0.9229068756103516,
-0.7009474039077759,
-0.14553934335708618,
-0.2738494575023651,
-0.07473442703485489,
1.1986348628997803,
0.699084460735321,
-0.6870918869972229,
-0.22042568027973175,
-0.257985919713974,
0.23727025091648102,
-0.5880335569381714,
-0.15707913041114807,
0.12048125267028809,
-0.22861044108867645,
-0.38231781125068665,
0.35712116956710815,
0.657357394695282,
-0.008320149034261703,
-0.289722204208374,
-0.09691136330366135,
-0.6862854957580566,
0.21771927177906036,
1.1287261247634888,
-0.14347344636917114,
-1.1270695924758911,
-0.3864138126373291,
-0.14476735889911652,
-0.14967207610607147,
0.2843509018421173,
1.1799290180206299,
-0.8527393341064453,
0.6450188159942627,
0.07491063326597214,
0.44789087772369385,
0.6678635478019714,
-0.25938233733177185,
0.6930597424507141,
-0.4442630112171173,
0.11577849090099335,
0.2664628028869629,
0.570016086101532,
0.27913689613342285,
0.05787501856684685,
0.660297155380249,
0.3697030246257782,
-0.4273946285247803,
-0.749469518661499,
0.22290147840976715,
-1.5106958150863647,
-0.14594115316867828,
0.9001572728157043,
0.19111838936805725,
-0.390113890171051,
-0.03559611737728119,
-0.5540273785591125,
-0.08217242360115051,
-0.30188068747520447,
0.6960694193840027,
0.7751374244689941,
-0.28005537390708923,
-0.4465238153934479,
-0.7066810131072998,
0.3159381151199341,
0.3655227720737457,
-0.9380583763122559,
0.2844853699207306,
0.44052261114120483,
-0.17891141772270203,
0.17120781540870667,
0.7811288833618164,
-0.21460731327533722,
0.46827802062034607,
0.43083515763282776,
0.003414473496377468,
0.015078606083989143,
-0.9189929366111755,
0.21655026078224182,
0.37933772802352905,
0.0945616140961647,
-0.3121867775917053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17505v1
|
Predicting Rental Price of Lane Houses in Shanghai with Machine Learning Methods and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-26T07:01:33 | 2024-05-26T07:01:33 |
Tingting Chen, Shijing Si
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Housing has emerged as a crucial concern among young individuals residing in
major cities, including Shanghai. Given the unprecedented surge in property
prices in this metropolis, young people have increasingly resorted to the
rental market to address their housing needs. This study utilizes five
traditional machine learning methods: multiple linear regression (MLR), ridge
regression (RR), lasso regression (LR), decision tree (DT), and random forest
(RF), along with a Large Language Model (LLM) approach using ChatGPT, for
predicting the rental prices of lane houses in Shanghai. It applies these
methods to examine a public data sample of about 2,609 lane house rental
transactions in 2021 in Shanghai, and then compares the results of these
methods. In terms of predictive power, RF has achieved the best performance
among the traditional methods. However, the LLM approach, particularly in the
10-shot scenario, shows promising results that surpass traditional methods in
terms of R-Squared value. The three performance metrics: mean squared error
(MSE), mean absolute error (MAE), and R-Squared, are used to evaluate the
models. Our conclusion is that while traditional machine learning models offer
robust techniques for rental price prediction, the integration of LLM such as
ChatGPT holds significant potential for enhancing predictive accuracy.
|
[
-0.05159715935587883,
-0.8401134610176086,
0.41448718309402466,
0.019156552851200104,
0.054683055728673935,
0.007069847080856562,
-0.04265894368290901,
-0.4447401463985443,
-0.2717601954936981,
0.19018805027008057,
-0.21695953607559204,
-0.6478123068809509,
-0.18310654163360596,
-0.3792538642883301,
-0.14166681468486786,
0.4822092652320862,
0.03135151043534279,
0.40505656599998474,
0.2777767777442932,
0.09933993220329285,
-0.5049675107002258,
-0.3663857579231262,
-0.5748147964477539,
0.05167236551642418,
0.2970198392868042,
0.009661913849413395,
0.9355447292327881,
0.9850595593452454,
0.5621107220649719,
0.1909019947052002,
0.20797477662563324,
0.08216827362775803,
-0.07508911937475204,
-0.13136854767799377,
0.3215494155883789,
-0.09468580782413483,
-0.2725169062614441,
-0.004646308720111847,
0.6343364715576172,
0.35091671347618103,
-0.21169067919254303,
0.1219182014465332,
0.08407925069332123,
0.6918465495109558,
-0.5680938959121704,
0.482497900724411,
-0.6876870393753052,
0.24144680798053741,
-0.3679816424846649,
-0.09137486666440964,
-0.48663270473480225,
-0.2572534382343292,
0.02776355855166912,
-0.2858031690120697,
0.33085572719573975,
0.4051368236541748,
0.9808748364448547,
0.22513413429260254,
-0.4178333580493927,
-0.180527463555336,
-0.7506070733070374,
0.7615256309509277,
-0.8239263296127319,
0.3679986298084259,
0.15503932535648346,
0.6570394039154053,
-0.23964297771453857,
-0.3610113859176636,
-0.26658394932746887,
-0.4871537983417511,
-0.054872892796993256,
0.4100230634212494,
-0.11055899411439896,
0.07818803936243057,
0.35931721329689026,
0.043955348432064056,
-0.7798582911491394,
0.1329287439584732,
-0.7985778450965881,
0.08833672106266022,
0.9017194509506226,
0.40278586745262146,
0.21742846071720123,
-0.5171782374382019,
-0.7555493116378784,
-0.16568173468112946,
-0.512209415435791,
0.46257248520851135,
0.4236027002334595,
0.6918254494667053,
0.19031581282615662,
0.42097410559654236,
-0.08465472608804703,
0.5200870633125305,
-0.28330808877944946,
-0.13033731281757355,
0.19630686938762665,
-0.2068614661693573,
-0.12864141166210175,
0.21460705995559692,
0.8631373047828674,
0.5214029550552368,
0.3534480929374695,
0.012922927737236023,
-0.2646845877170563,
-0.00514241773635149,
-0.09732086956501007,
-0.481207937002182,
-0.4036879539489746,
0.5009313821792603,
-0.5765873193740845,
-0.25830355286598206,
0.20911288261413574,
-0.7153884768486023,
-0.33602872490882874,
-0.022711660712957382,
0.012697682715952396,
-0.23090960085391998,
-0.2504574656486511,
0.02216901257634163,
-0.14515691995620728,
0.7118608355522156,
0.5243237614631653,
-0.5492058992385864,
0.1732853651046753,
0.28056538105010986,
0.9232128858566284,
-0.28330135345458984,
-0.4433436989784241,
-0.4353157579898834,
0.17667420208454132,
-0.36955615878105164,
1.0666459798812866,
-0.3040279746055603,
-0.2870665490627289,
0.18941061198711395,
-0.33659395575523376,
-0.27126604318618774,
-0.6707705855369568,
0.48235276341438293,
-0.24587561190128326,
0.0996721163392067,
0.498699426651001,
-0.2462601363658905,
-0.47399643063545227,
0.3650200068950653,
-0.7746902108192444,
1.1414846181869507,
0.23164035379886627,
-0.541876494884491,
0.3371463418006897,
-0.5448738932609558,
-0.23537179827690125,
0.20411038398742676,
0.19669416546821594,
-1.0273150205612183,
-0.08694522827863693,
0.28772255778312683,
0.8400934338569641,
0.03172994777560234,
0.6027576923370361,
-0.5093345046043396,
-0.3592526912689209,
0.27240225672721863,
-0.6741610169410706,
0.7410876750946045,
0.4821251928806305,
-0.15319201350212097,
0.44520261883735657,
-0.7892811298370361,
-0.14930382370948792,
0.09749672561883926,
0.15015241503715515,
0.09933632612228394,
0.25894954800605774,
0.22568073868751526,
0.4093286097049713,
0.37014660239219666,
-0.3377009332180023,
0.14357130229473114,
-0.09539207071065903,
0.25084325671195984,
0.7203463912010193,
-0.25844526290893555,
0.08427286148071289,
-0.5976043343544006,
0.642691433429718,
0.3073892593383789,
0.20023994147777557,
0.10423576086759567,
-0.52003014087677,
-0.37003588676452637,
-0.30193957686424255,
0.14167042076587677,
0.7443539500236511,
-0.008612284436821938,
-0.1637638807296753,
-0.023808779194951057,
-0.6932931542396545,
-0.5025591850280762,
-0.11585541069507599,
-0.18904738128185272,
0.048546742647886276,
0.3321889340877533,
0.527030885219574,
-0.694959282875061,
-0.2821100950241089,
-0.2393140345811844,
-0.1669253408908844,
0.12058348208665848,
0.5177885890007019,
0.3076906204223633,
-0.10727899521589279,
0.7904975414276123,
-0.6877894401550293,
-0.44569239020347595,
-0.6397197842597961,
-0.21161510050296783,
0.3402876555919647,
0.11715271323919296,
0.477389931678772,
-0.8142814040184021,
-0.8555354475975037,
0.09923259913921356,
-0.4395007789134979,
0.15733937919139862,
-0.08517824113368988,
0.3490297794342041,
0.4134885370731354,
0.3580898344516754,
-0.40439367294311523,
0.6462806463241577,
0.6536800265312195,
-0.013809353113174438,
0.7598203420639038,
-0.38602253794670105,
-0.24738739430904388,
-1.0684399604797363,
-0.2980403006076813,
0.4530114233493805,
-0.17166069149971008,
-0.28009819984436035,
-0.10053316503763199,
-0.20989824831485748,
-0.11702834814786911,
-0.6280319690704346,
0.5861210823059082,
-0.2099498063325882,
-0.1433507204055786,
-0.0693703219294548,
0.23693765699863434,
-0.4394305944442749,
0.6293352246284485,
0.26612070202827454,
0.8602886199951172,
0.23957516252994537,
-0.4517063498497009,
0.6721290946006775,
-0.11078351736068726,
-0.2339465618133545,
-0.35566678643226624,
-0.502957284450531,
-0.10720818489789963,
-0.1409377157688141,
0.28033509850502014,
-1.1446664333343506,
-0.0725717842578888,
0.21630355715751648,
-0.349877268075943,
-0.4171436131000519,
-0.29046082496643066,
-0.4553147554397583,
-0.4417465031147003,
-0.6265670657157898,
0.13426165282726288,
0.38585489988327026,
-0.3240913152694702,
0.4861716628074646,
0.25895652174949646,
0.07928063720464706,
-0.47368931770324707,
0.0035361777991056442,
-0.3915156424045563,
-0.6031860709190369,
-0.5615646243095398,
-0.07084675878286362,
0.15293505787849426,
-0.4278239607810974,
0.10139930248260498,
0.5038610696792603,
-0.2027197778224945,
0.3590899407863617,
0.4441172480583191,
0.7513779401779175,
-0.08182147890329361,
0.10521107912063599,
-0.5580081939697266,
-0.3831852376461029,
0.033607594668865204,
-0.35292884707450867,
0.5385576486587524,
-0.3663610816001892,
-0.022688766941428185,
-0.09367720037698746,
-0.2094378024339676,
0.2136945277452469,
-0.25027555227279663,
0.7838332653045654,
0.727936863899231,
-0.3795115649700165,
-0.3936292231082916,
-0.17084087431430817,
0.17931051552295685,
-0.32581499218940735,
0.5713675618171692,
-0.4336461126804352,
-0.5544395446777344,
0.6376181840896606,
-0.19743172824382782,
0.11524885147809982,
0.38656145334243774,
0.5166541934013367,
-0.49973198771476746,
1.158193588256836,
0.5917578339576721,
-0.12539264559745789,
0.7135031819343567,
-0.1838630586862564,
0.6459804177284241,
-0.5383331775665283,
-0.026266979053616524,
-0.6308935880661011,
-0.2634388208389282,
-1.1899300813674927,
-0.5058633685112,
0.31346583366394043,
0.06026620417833328,
-0.2630557417869568,
0.5170075297355652,
-0.3716208040714264,
0.19053398072719574,
0.6072252988815308,
0.2056063860654831,
0.5579279065132141,
-0.05274283513426781,
0.05597367137670517,
0.06299246102571487,
-0.7962968945503235,
-0.5081349611282349,
1.1708436012268066,
0.5087481141090393,
0.4963567554950714,
-0.05865682661533356,
0.2790535092353821,
0.3714151978492737,
0.20087046921253204,
-0.7651870846748352,
0.41194814443588257,
-0.4186953902244568,
-0.46856823563575745,
-0.6420467495918274,
-0.2811698913574219,
-1.0897495746612549,
0.555673360824585,
-0.08536390215158463,
-0.7047144174575806,
-0.23383277654647827,
-0.052818961441516876,
-0.5052857995033264,
0.5138633847236633,
-0.3182745575904846,
0.830051064491272,
-0.27165687084198,
-0.42732974886894226,
-0.2755683958530426,
-0.2939644455909729,
0.36097997426986694,
-0.24519257247447968,
0.4352070987224579,
-0.5250995755195618,
0.5654658675193787,
0.5098346471786499,
-0.130147323012352,
0.4328678846359253,
-0.19126901030540466,
0.2545962333679199,
0.4125209152698517,
-0.35961759090423584,
0.8153234124183655,
-0.21393358707427979,
-0.24934515357017517,
0.08838535845279694,
0.2545708417892456,
-0.5036320090293884,
-0.4503907561302185,
0.29503247141838074,
-0.9848871827125549,
-0.1727323681116104,
-0.5143953561782837,
-0.47558432817459106,
0.014490685425698757,
-0.03755534067749977,
0.2108803242444992,
0.211408793926239,
0.07054515928030014,
-0.044000811874866486,
0.26989123225212097,
-0.2679276466369629,
0.4492974877357483,
0.21877504885196686,
-0.6881808042526245,
-0.40842223167419434,
1.0725860595703125,
0.2605471909046173,
-0.09167178720235825,
0.19627472758293152,
0.6703892350196838,
-0.3680712878704071,
-0.5073234438896179,
-0.2983707785606384,
0.03445854038000107,
-0.33849671483039856,
-0.08819182962179184,
-0.5124465227127075,
-0.5019049644470215,
-0.4911973178386688,
-0.3894639015197754,
-0.4621754288673401,
-0.1111450269818306,
0.516258955001831,
-0.36998677253723145,
0.04369452968239784,
0.825851321220398,
-0.03343253210186958,
0.2857140600681305,
-0.8919641375541687,
0.05606721714138985,
0.010223384015262127,
0.04513746500015259,
-0.00910110678523779,
-0.29688704013824463,
-0.5524425506591797,
0.3440812826156616,
-0.3455764949321747,
-0.44816961884498596,
0.9495885968208313,
-0.46180465817451477,
0.3533259630203247,
0.4600794017314911,
0.4012978971004486,
0.7621137499809265,
-0.2560584843158722,
0.8407241106033325,
-0.1177341565489769,
-0.4652446210384369,
0.6787266731262207,
-0.48299553990364075,
-0.06858699023723602,
0.07322506606578827,
0.22335195541381836,
-0.4109639823436737,
-0.1774618923664093,
-0.7403379678726196,
-0.9161758422851562,
0.2699364721775055,
-0.29880210757255554,
-0.04200347885489464,
0.3179614543914795,
-0.13173091411590576,
-0.1559610664844513,
0.241193026304245,
-1.1587741374969482,
-0.05405670404434204,
0.17935816943645477,
-0.12728288769721985,
0.052388954907655716,
-0.12908935546875,
0.43004581332206726,
-0.4447193443775177,
0.7456951141357422,
-0.04905690252780914,
0.045867711305618286,
-0.25950413942337036,
-0.030264293774962425,
-0.22243177890777588,
0.16185712814331055,
0.5145987272262573,
0.44778627157211304,
-0.6712968945503235,
-0.20297285914421082,
0.2760837972164154,
-0.15244601666927338,
0.1933574676513672,
-0.13782460987567902,
-0.34536972641944885,
0.08690862357616425,
0.28557446599006653,
0.809889018535614,
-0.299030065536499,
-0.6891189813613892,
0.5289331674575806,
0.23156799376010895,
-0.31379711627960205,
-1.098934531211853,
-0.10236874222755432,
-0.3739689886569977,
0.20062664151191711,
0.1293058693408966,
-0.05460099130868912,
0.1760701835155487,
-0.42861974239349365,
0.039391785860061646,
0.2475496381521225,
-0.7232807278633118,
-0.11261191219091415,
0.6705921292304993,
0.004834397695958614,
-0.0007551206508651376,
1.1946139335632324,
0.1028115302324295,
-0.5769543051719666,
0.5695198178291321,
0.25099170207977295,
1.2370439767837524,
-0.12031084299087524,
0.25109240412712097,
0.6012174487113953,
0.037931401282548904,
-0.11172317713499069,
0.0031819851137697697,
0.1336890310049057,
-1.077290654182434,
-0.4782041609287262,
-0.4211941063404083,
-0.3530232906341553,
-0.08913181722164154,
-0.3798675239086151,
0.4899279773235321,
-0.32958582043647766,
-0.017646217718720436,
-0.5095369815826416,
0.7500960230827332,
-0.4112767279148102,
0.1369052231311798,
0.4763484001159668,
0.8717089891433716,
-0.8242911100387573,
1.0612812042236328,
0.7472323179244995,
-0.323369562625885,
-1.1276330947875977,
0.13851836323738098,
-0.19048500061035156,
-0.5734578967094421,
0.9219574928283691,
0.26966533064842224,
-0.3646335303783417,
0.027265015989542007,
-0.5609294176101685,
-0.4273218810558319,
1.0306165218353271,
-0.1673768311738968,
-0.7058964371681213,
-0.20236340165138245,
0.0988842025399208,
0.4585729241371155,
-0.15717875957489014,
0.30859658122062683,
0.3464980721473694,
0.5725906491279602,
0.07810478657484055,
-0.6264245510101318,
-0.32296842336654663,
0.12667544186115265,
0.0902354046702385,
0.25574323534965515,
-0.7151656150817871,
0.6334691643714905,
-0.4536372721195221,
-0.23553264141082764,
-0.0529797226190567,
0.6988608837127686,
0.5377696752548218,
0.7855369448661804,
0.3719882667064667,
0.25123873353004456,
0.749552309513092,
-0.05501115694642067,
0.785850465297699,
-0.7993156313896179,
0.49086758494377136,
0.634949803352356,
-0.49312132596969604,
1.5017372369766235,
0.06458085030317307,
-0.5847243666648865,
0.48594218492507935,
0.6519388556480408,
-0.38678762316703796,
0.4320943057537079,
0.537792980670929,
-0.019616292789578438,
-0.2789548933506012,
0.07118353247642517,
0.020827563479542732,
0.44903549551963806,
0.28301340341567993,
0.1708955615758896,
-0.1134684607386589,
0.11388612538576126,
-0.05067078396677971,
0.11467631161212921,
-0.18501637876033783,
0.828981876373291,
0.033576156944036484,
-0.2739553451538086,
-0.06662987917661667,
0.09787198901176453,
0.2871542274951935,
-0.5450781583786011,
-0.15300653874874115,
-0.20402559638023376,
0.44572198390960693,
-0.09145914763212204,
-0.7066429257392883,
0.19943933188915253,
-0.4855388104915619,
0.060620736330747604,
-0.4851474165916443,
0.7710065841674805,
-0.3657881021499634,
-0.9230369925498962,
0.4523468613624573,
0.4703194797039032,
0.20362304151058197,
-0.22312404215335846,
-0.6205441951751709,
-0.17781540751457214,
0.08778651803731918,
-0.02331859990954399,
0.2574155032634735,
0.3790035843849182,
-0.3479999303817749,
1.0255783796310425,
0.8414439558982849,
0.3362356424331665,
0.19213026762008667,
-0.2990090250968933,
0.46782252192497253,
-0.9986873269081116,
-0.2966943383216858,
-0.9458816051483154,
0.48530665040016174,
0.07127046585083008,
-0.20655325055122375,
0.823677659034729,
0.6308611631393433,
0.9564852118492126,
-0.03696298599243164,
0.7573630809783936,
0.5068715214729309,
0.5988895297050476,
-0.6202577948570251,
0.24987643957138062,
-0.11669531464576721,
0.3812911808490753,
-0.13087482750415802,
-1.067603588104248,
-0.367738276720047,
0.9921140074729919,
-0.6951301693916321,
-0.0862140953540802,
0.5181291699409485,
0.6457772254943848,
0.49583250284194946,
-0.013619253411889076,
0.6653313636779785,
-0.011228845454752445,
0.4919566512107849,
0.498259961605072,
1.0660942792892456,
-0.6279391646385193,
0.4312123656272888,
-0.5743364095687866,
0.20566779375076294,
-0.4814566373825073,
-0.5013314485549927,
-0.6317580342292786,
-0.42898476123809814,
-0.3589121103286743,
-0.5493804216384888,
0.4174121916294098,
1.085520625114441,
0.5260075926780701,
-0.9948961138725281,
-0.7824891805648804,
0.16073045134544373,
0.14955459535121918,
-0.7168889045715332,
-0.26254802942276,
0.7965970635414124,
-0.344230592250824,
-0.7742486000061035,
0.013585040345788002,
0.25383809208869934,
0.11646950989961624,
-0.5260184407234192,
-0.04930705577135086,
0.12660399079322815,
-0.2862931489944458,
0.4418785274028778,
-0.20140120387077332,
-0.6014741659164429,
-0.08517283201217651,
0.03641669079661369,
-0.5139749050140381,
0.20937246084213257,
0.6669747233390808,
-0.8787617087364197,
-0.141054168343544,
0.5410084128379822,
0.27278590202331543,
0.5496044158935547,
0.2368697077035904,
0.6938638687133789,
-0.09428209066390991,
0.0013816929422318935,
-0.07304120808839798,
0.31513988971710205,
0.00814388319849968,
-0.42374980449676514,
0.5238541960716248,
0.26323768496513367,
-0.38523873686790466,
-0.5339853167533875,
-0.020263615995645523,
-0.8100595474243164,
-0.48213306069374084,
0.792751669883728,
-0.047439780086278915,
-0.40650519728660583,
-0.2260713428258896,
-0.30765393376350403,
-0.0831642895936966,
-0.5801286697387695,
0.838416576385498,
0.653260350227356,
-0.04073098301887512,
-0.8013186454772949,
-1.2315633296966553,
0.20212753117084503,
0.008525886572897434,
-0.36668768525123596,
0.27334287762641907,
0.516526997089386,
-0.11030031740665436,
-0.3307015299797058,
0.3735523819923401,
0.018949978053569794,
0.16497713327407837,
0.1415671706199646,
-0.10030960291624069,
-0.23105183243751526,
-0.26379674673080444,
-0.06097687780857086,
0.40785902738571167,
0.10744200646877289,
-0.5430654287338257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16442v1
|
Development of an open education resources (OER) system: a comparative analysis and implementation approach
| 2024-05-26T05:58:45 | 2024-05-26T05:58:45 |
Nimol Thuon, Wangrui Zhang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Several institutions are collaborating on the development of a new web-based
Open Education Resources (OER) system designed exclusively for non-commercial
educational purposes. This initiative is underpinned by meticulous research
aimed at constructing an OER system that optimizes user experiences across
diverse user profiles. A significant emphasis is placed on utilizing
open-source tools, frameworks, and technologies. The project includes a
comparative analysis of the top five open-source Learning Management Systems
(LMS), providing critical insights to inform the development process. The
primary objective is to create a web-based system that facilitates the sharing
of educational resources for non-commercial users, leveraging information and
communication technologies. The project is structured around two key teams: a
research team and a development team. This comprehensive approach is intended
to establish a robust, user-centric OER system, informed by insights from
existing platforms and the latest advancements in open education resource
development.
|
[
-0.5593063235282898,
-0.3528626561164856,
0.23849639296531677,
-0.43026238679885864,
0.2196783423423767,
0.13457341492176056,
-0.31673476099967957,
-0.5116534233093262,
0.1035987064242363,
0.2702910900115967,
-0.23865841329097748,
-0.22105702757835388,
-0.1611957848072052,
0.08987858891487122,
-0.22370390594005585,
0.8111589550971985,
-0.3470713794231415,
0.18985101580619812,
-0.07656435668468475,
-0.5874098539352417,
-0.3115786910057068,
-0.1699080765247345,
-0.698399543762207,
-0.15185242891311646,
0.6265915632247925,
0.5213348865509033,
0.39812734723091125,
0.23493552207946777,
0.7218000292778015,
0.2111886739730835,
-0.028978176414966583,
-0.3264613449573517,
-0.9450934529304504,
-0.22469264268875122,
-0.6550245881080627,
-0.2733158767223358,
-0.39910775423049927,
0.006429684814065695,
0.5996219515800476,
0.515609085559845,
-0.36617258191108704,
0.5005092024803162,
0.3762699365615845,
0.7922571301460266,
-1.127591848373413,
-0.09900356829166412,
0.18674494326114655,
0.24134700000286102,
-0.28413236141204834,
0.05466807261109352,
-0.15969586372375488,
-0.6828168630599976,
0.39449629187583923,
-0.6429381966590881,
0.050992175936698914,
0.05202042683959007,
0.281864732503891,
-0.20270080864429474,
0.020184868946671486,
-0.33532410860061646,
-0.8247922658920288,
0.9252719879150391,
-0.41833943128585815,
0.7435920238494873,
-0.18482714891433716,
0.454738050699234,
-0.08896953612565994,
-0.5614352226257324,
-0.32930347323417664,
0.14003121852874756,
0.08389879763126373,
0.19615909457206726,
-0.07762516289949417,
-0.12987485527992249,
-0.23485447466373444,
0.7800452709197998,
-0.545971691608429,
0.18462853133678436,
-0.9438604712486267,
-0.040737688541412354,
0.2569410502910614,
0.022949617356061935,
0.16921767592430115,
0.3646705150604248,
-0.7384656667709351,
-0.12233743816614151,
-0.27920228242874146,
0.10308532416820526,
0.4902338683605194,
0.5059504508972168,
-0.07028438150882721,
0.9634931087493896,
-0.24257886409759521,
0.11497756838798523,
-0.1849343329668045,
-0.10354016721248627,
0.29422181844711304,
-0.2039608657360077,
-0.4463641047477722,
0.1594916433095932,
0.7395369410514832,
0.5257102251052856,
0.15904134511947632,
-0.2751416563987732,
-0.4055117070674896,
0.1835869550704956,
0.28061071038246155,
-0.6781721711158752,
-0.10128191113471985,
0.1788490116596222,
-0.8709760904312134,
-0.2991487979888916,
0.35505932569503784,
-0.8460600972175598,
-0.366290420293808,
-0.402259886264801,
0.4866377115249634,
-0.513442873954773,
-0.5855260491371155,
-0.14889661967754364,
-0.4393400549888611,
0.19022615253925323,
0.24331210553646088,
-0.34877198934555054,
0.5085306763648987,
0.2612965404987335,
0.945458710193634,
-0.12495694309473038,
-0.1044803336262703,
-0.16727860271930695,
-0.003219637321308255,
0.19198311865329742,
0.28228846192359924,
-0.5161335468292236,
-0.815911591053009,
0.24244444072246552,
-0.2802174687385559,
0.1951490044593811,
-0.4237496256828308,
0.5025953054428101,
-0.6870327591896057,
0.471813827753067,
-0.2536728084087372,
-0.496364563703537,
-0.010336484760046005,
0.06834030896425247,
-0.7788296937942505,
0.7850644588470459,
0.41704341769218445,
-0.6404075622558594,
0.17986585199832916,
-1.417952537536621,
0.33178290724754333,
0.2273252159357071,
-0.12663663923740387,
0.1325228363275528,
0.31741487979888916,
-0.41061022877693176,
-0.3402039110660553,
-0.3953327238559723,
-0.18424904346466064,
-0.06509921699762344,
-0.4581013321876526,
0.10224665701389313,
0.056851889938116074,
0.8422438502311707,
0.5110027194023132,
-0.17391279339790344,
0.1349467933177948,
-0.8242971897125244,
0.21009257435798645,
0.46301642060279846,
-0.590678870677948,
-0.45484042167663574,
-0.15596187114715576,
0.2758147120475769,
-0.11701472848653793,
0.6170167326927185,
-0.7063763737678528,
0.23732858896255493,
0.1356734186410904,
0.26862484216690063,
0.5600228309631348,
-0.285135418176651,
0.8561046719551086,
0.03808657452464104,
0.38921454548835754,
-0.29952991008758545,
0.6343542337417603,
-0.0212389063090086,
-0.2120809555053711,
-0.5830528736114502,
0.10207588970661163,
0.30270808935165405,
0.5098741054534912,
-0.46494513750076294,
-0.015424899756908417,
0.16496166586875916,
-0.1681704819202423,
-0.7069219350814819,
0.1763153225183487,
0.7058301568031311,
0.2816193401813507,
0.5149536728858948,
-0.961932361125946,
-0.495364248752594,
-0.3981591761112213,
-0.06022113561630249,
-0.11418834328651428,
0.08144790679216385,
0.18573100864887238,
0.5099658966064453,
0.12450950592756271,
0.9537251591682434,
-0.4743388891220093,
-0.6508944034576416,
0.1349683254957199,
-0.19302015006542206,
-0.05560779571533203,
0.3256032168865204,
0.6800360083580017,
-0.7099771499633789,
-0.5182011723518372,
0.01318979449570179,
-0.7276281714439392,
0.18152745068073273,
0.7216618061065674,
-0.39582252502441406,
0.2099757045507431,
0.16805413365364075,
0.12397146970033646,
0.45682045817375183,
0.30634304881095886,
-0.22815729677677155,
0.3254706859588623,
-0.05074597895145416,
0.15246449410915375,
-0.46303591132164,
0.4950830042362213,
-0.06552069634199142,
0.4278988242149353,
-0.3258545398712158,
0.2820574939250946,
-0.13221611082553864,
-0.2997868061065674,
-0.47361502051353455,
0.43248963356018066,
-0.37202686071395874,
-0.07315095514059067,
-0.2713775038719177,
0.6131207942962646,
-0.1151137575507164,
0.14982357621192932,
-0.045340344309806824,
0.8786600828170776,
0.27605587244033813,
-0.20923255383968353,
-0.004959349520504475,
0.4475516974925995,
-0.32373058795928955,
1.2471415996551514,
-0.4154585599899292,
0.0484912171959877,
0.11106511205434799,
-0.17501065135002136,
-0.1413497030735016,
-0.1965157389640808,
0.7378695607185364,
-0.45885926485061646,
-0.02566680870950222,
0.054923996329307556,
-0.09493525326251984,
-0.3344179391860962,
-0.38939327001571655,
0.31958553194999695,
0.5021889209747314,
-0.4734012484550476,
0.2548634707927704,
0.3953635096549988,
0.014271143823862076,
-0.7900316715240479,
-0.27590203285217285,
-0.17707808315753937,
0.10915134102106094,
-0.27440327405929565,
-0.13238179683685303,
0.020380543544888496,
-0.5888652801513672,
0.6838236451148987,
-0.2502959072589874,
-0.30535396933555603,
0.01577611081302166,
0.17959485948085785,
0.39064571261405945,
-0.7728506326675415,
-0.22569485008716583,
-0.43844151496887207,
0.07831494510173798,
0.01259402371942997,
-0.6838147640228271,
0.058750495314598083,
-0.05541030317544937,
-0.5098996758460999,
-0.5227044820785522,
0.37423092126846313,
0.452321857213974,
-0.5262285470962524,
1.1391836404800415,
0.18232488632202148,
-0.15858840942382812,
-0.13529865443706512,
-0.3308999538421631,
-0.014517996460199356,
-0.46061739325523376,
-0.2200896292924881,
0.022234518080949783,
-0.8311920166015625,
0.2763011157512665,
-0.07218527793884277,
0.5323334336280823,
0.2969281077384949,
0.10078012198209763,
-0.07441677153110504,
0.33444857597351074,
0.9714184999465942,
0.057802651077508926,
0.7148438096046448,
-0.5389267802238464,
0.24234910309314728,
-0.8685634136199951,
-0.7788268327713013,
-0.5314384698867798,
-0.5837210416793823,
-0.23553378880023956,
-0.3186221420764923,
0.16475394368171692,
0.45139139890670776,
-0.41577085852622986,
0.2268933355808258,
-0.5435839891433716,
0.5651852488517761,
0.7404140830039978,
-0.0945434719324112,
0.4530353248119354,
-0.05461535230278969,
-0.2532147765159607,
0.36556655168533325,
-0.3741748034954071,
-0.8343541026115417,
1.1188502311706543,
0.28531283140182495,
0.6428167819976807,
0.493918240070343,
0.7500176429748535,
0.23135614395141602,
0.37551212310791016,
-0.5569583773612976,
0.37452074885368347,
0.07370585948228836,
-0.7335880398750305,
-0.4945567846298218,
-0.3885047435760498,
-0.8328585028648376,
0.08741945028305054,
-0.3420105278491974,
-0.7770019769668579,
0.21411193907260895,
-0.10132061690092087,
-0.18894627690315247,
0.7495961785316467,
-0.5066672563552856,
0.6296475529670715,
-0.14011117815971375,
-0.7558759450912476,
-0.20915444195270538,
-0.5317077040672302,
0.16918416321277618,
-0.0878683552145958,
0.42379236221313477,
0.3733154833316803,
-0.001053200219757855,
0.7984952330589294,
-0.2767452299594879,
0.6015375852584839,
-0.5111556053161621,
-0.1556980311870575,
0.8050422072410583,
-0.2597351372241974,
-0.14529530704021454,
-0.5653358697891235,
-0.3599229156970978,
0.19530540704727173,
-0.3392321467399597,
-0.4257657825946808,
-0.1716967523097992,
0.8928213119506836,
-1.1033672094345093,
-0.17081356048583984,
-0.3840413987636566,
-0.2592175304889679,
0.10698775947093964,
0.3689556419849396,
-0.03180421516299248,
0.37616053223609924,
-0.8509534001350403,
0.17576465010643005,
0.6188304424285889,
-0.19448216259479523,
0.3331344723701477,
0.8259364366531372,
-0.40238597989082336,
-0.6472924947738647,
0.9090086817741394,
0.33228418231010437,
0.18018554151058197,
0.24517600238323212,
0.220488503575325,
-0.3131268322467804,
-0.6910167336463928,
-0.3920128047466278,
0.2259245216846466,
-0.7714317440986633,
0.12267456948757172,
-0.03279692679643631,
-0.27988260984420776,
-0.40842947363853455,
-0.26958993077278137,
-0.3041485846042633,
-0.11364106088876724,
-0.1328888237476349,
0.08451340347528458,
0.03591155260801315,
1.3205808401107788,
-0.18385662138462067,
0.5010260343551636,
-0.7621041536331177,
0.04613548517227173,
-0.03442457690834999,
0.9980903267860413,
0.11719797551631927,
-0.055771008133888245,
-0.5753172039985657,
-0.09771137684583664,
-0.7266709208488464,
-0.651314377784729,
-0.32613351941108704,
-0.04672954976558685,
0.674220085144043,
0.6791216135025024,
0.3270079493522644,
0.23272866010665894,
-0.23530949652194977,
0.6680914759635925,
0.6089203953742981,
-0.6597557663917542,
0.5693392753601074,
-0.17631809413433075,
-0.1929222047328949,
0.7876169085502625,
0.46517762541770935,
-0.21133029460906982,
-0.11262376606464386,
-0.5052970051765442,
-0.8619494438171387,
1.0230754613876343,
0.36691176891326904,
-0.30062100291252136,
0.49026307463645935,
0.08235783129930496,
0.33587098121643066,
0.3192799687385559,
-0.5621933937072754,
-0.49710947275161743,
-0.1648467779159546,
0.13516461849212646,
-0.19584521651268005,
-0.048312265425920486,
-0.29995831847190857,
0.4639829397201538,
0.7289364337921143,
0.35399481654167175,
-0.08287472277879715,
0.07513954490423203,
-0.025708049535751343,
-0.42714202404022217,
0.5629086494445801,
0.21246729791164398,
0.7914998531341553,
-0.4801773726940155,
-0.34690284729003906,
0.0065185679122805595,
-0.4705735445022583,
0.022202882915735245,
-0.35078898072242737,
-0.10518176853656769,
-0.1868606060743332,
-0.0181577131152153,
0.7548404335975647,
0.13487575948238373,
-0.6057778596878052,
0.35960298776626587,
-0.028085043653845787,
-0.26444122195243835,
-0.3289647400379181,
0.1904529184103012,
-0.2218429297208786,
0.578389585018158,
0.23728500306606293,
0.08982137590646744,
0.16789451241493225,
-0.519920289516449,
-0.16478291153907776,
0.15040259063243866,
-0.5783467888832092,
-0.30386868119239807,
0.5833001732826233,
0.7410475611686707,
-0.5683501362800598,
0.6236894726753235,
0.2526227533817291,
0.05408104136586189,
0.2729983329772949,
0.3955856263637543,
0.6965268850326538,
-0.3772314786911011,
0.06685811281204224,
0.37630537152290344,
0.07786961644887924,
-0.1491696983575821,
0.6883265972137451,
-0.198004350066185,
-0.14565999805927277,
0.06438175588846207,
-0.6483721137046814,
-0.7161567211151123,
0.15254178643226624,
-1.0960156917572021,
0.5938452482223511,
-0.3710104823112488,
-0.2614451050758362,
-0.26361995935440063,
-0.2560802400112152,
-0.465702623128891,
0.31940168142318726,
0.10775135457515717,
1.1218504905700684,
-0.6689392924308777,
0.45184075832366943,
1.1024513244628906,
-0.652182936668396,
-0.3692116439342499,
-0.18169264495372772,
0.10197421908378601,
-0.3876185417175293,
0.5586123466491699,
-0.02371426299214363,
-0.4295726716518402,
0.007565039675682783,
0.0930325835943222,
-0.6701598763465881,
1.0938481092453003,
0.18073619902133942,
-0.8268530964851379,
-0.3353990316390991,
0.06513945758342743,
0.32199862599372864,
0.10034958273172379,
0.3057197332382202,
0.02126132883131504,
0.4972288906574249,
0.05484131723642349,
-1.113930106163025,
-0.3708925247192383,
0.009611654095351696,
-0.3575018346309662,
0.844188392162323,
-0.5429975986480713,
0.7652313113212585,
-0.36331939697265625,
-0.3558898866176605,
0.2565714716911316,
0.5828560590744019,
-0.21771815419197083,
0.6216936707496643,
0.3316236138343811,
0.6775237917900085,
0.5370296239852905,
0.22152651846408844,
0.5840689539909363,
-0.49368974566459656,
0.45557674765586853,
1.0745919942855835,
-0.12301696091890335,
1.0324742794036865,
0.7108973860740662,
-0.4696412682533264,
0.43971896171569824,
0.03937859088182449,
0.10302234441041946,
0.47568798065185547,
0.20678915083408356,
-0.6191184520721436,
0.3974425196647644,
-0.41421830654144287,
-0.7645992040634155,
0.31540682911872864,
0.13297370076179504,
-0.4534884989261627,
-0.4435748755931854,
0.02957885153591633,
-0.2356998175382614,
0.2562522292137146,
-0.5767637491226196,
0.6122291684150696,
0.1758221983909607,
-0.36489760875701904,
-0.2056472897529602,
0.1684028059244156,
0.3548721969127655,
-0.5631758570671082,
0.20050321519374847,
0.174280047416687,
0.5190246105194092,
-0.4015445113182068,
-0.7586623430252075,
0.2909194827079773,
0.3354373276233673,
-0.1115468367934227,
-0.13112902641296387,
0.5650529265403748,
-0.10428524762392044,
0.15854652225971222,
0.585018515586853,
0.8739374279975891,
0.12476947158575058,
0.2883002460002899,
-0.11109881848096848,
0.30441558361053467,
-0.3603336215019226,
0.12274648249149323,
0.4723818302154541,
0.3945177495479584,
-0.11641223728656769,
0.23443932831287384,
0.5174199342727661,
0.06209353730082512,
-0.16143798828125,
0.12373757362365723,
0.7735478281974792,
-0.44162067770957947,
-0.24165765941143036,
-0.5414559841156006,
0.45165371894836426,
-0.054849639534950256,
-0.3098275661468506,
0.733698308467865,
0.8916163444519043,
1.2994669675827026,
-0.05682489648461342,
1.0260086059570312,
-0.4810577929019928,
0.26843875646591187,
-0.059595804661512375,
0.6117488741874695,
-0.6049104332923889,
-0.03346942737698555,
-0.06673102080821991,
-1.0830152034759521,
0.08907856792211533,
0.4673032760620117,
-0.06310747563838959,
-0.16861601173877716,
0.5738238096237183,
0.16849100589752197,
-0.21256123483181,
0.47191548347473145,
0.060916632413864136,
-0.2692565321922302,
-0.022334842011332512,
0.2473156601190567,
1.141875982284546,
-0.3800075650215149,
0.5753949880599976,
-0.29113754630088806,
-0.5044564604759216,
-0.461541086435318,
-0.6843754649162292,
-0.9427270889282227,
-0.40139028429985046,
-0.27111101150512695,
-0.1398448795080185,
0.20290544629096985,
0.9320331811904907,
0.13703005015850067,
-0.9736817479133606,
-0.6798540353775024,
0.12377074360847473,
-0.1633923202753067,
0.05778323486447334,
-0.26256048679351807,
-0.20460781455039978,
0.027817171066999435,
-0.6283974051475525,
0.3854166865348816,
0.10471446812152863,
-0.16578930616378784,
-0.6481115221977234,
-0.2503679096698761,
0.05562954023480415,
0.02393370494246483,
0.48853743076324463,
0.6019137501716614,
-0.4544849395751953,
-0.10160281509160995,
0.2793503701686859,
-0.08476176112890244,
0.01926255412399769,
1.012378215789795,
-0.6319235563278198,
0.5650486350059509,
0.49080100655555725,
0.32042738795280457,
-0.23835907876491547,
-0.31844639778137207,
0.29537203907966614,
-0.13093218207359314,
-0.28565514087677,
0.06132674217224121,
0.2447139322757721,
0.017963919788599014,
-0.02623797580599785,
0.6628655195236206,
0.04739836975932121,
-0.6215501427650452,
-0.919655442237854,
-0.022556990385055542,
-0.8403117656707764,
-0.10048599541187286,
0.4051196575164795,
-0.3924131393432617,
0.04693160206079483,
-0.0846855416893959,
-0.39661285281181335,
0.49620798230171204,
-0.791854202747345,
0.6553866863250732,
0.350126713514328,
-0.30889996886253357,
0.33098599314689636,
-0.34887897968292236,
-0.20284388959407806,
-0.3365909159183502,
-0.47648534178733826,
-0.4926319718360901,
0.4292146861553192,
0.28385084867477417,
0.5760970115661621,
0.5073458552360535,
-0.1322348266839981,
0.11384867876768112,
0.00978376530110836,
0.4961777329444885,
-0.17646846175193787,
-0.4597228467464447,
0.0018928070785477757,
0.7736008763313293,
0.13549798727035522,
-0.6108270287513733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16434v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16434v2
|
The Importance of Directional Feedback for LLM-based Optimizers
| 2024-05-26T05:22:35 | 2024-06-20T16:10:50 |
Allen Nie, Ching-An Cheng, Andrey Kolobov, Adith Swaminathan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
We study the potential of using large language models (LLMs) as an
interactive optimizer for solving maximization problems in a text space using
natural language and numerical feedback. Inspired by the classical optimization
literature, we classify the natural language feedback into directional and
non-directional, where the former is a generalization of the first-order
feedback to the natural language space. We find that LLMs are especially
capable of optimization when they are provided with {directional feedback}.
Based on this insight, we design a new LLM-based optimizer that synthesizes
directional feedback from the historical optimization trace to achieve reliable
improvement over iterations. Empirically, we show our LLM-based optimizer is
more stable and efficient in solving optimization problems, from maximizing
mathematical functions to optimizing prompts for writing poems, compared with
existing techniques.
|
[
-0.2549598515033722,
-0.905310869216919,
0.7925488948822021,
0.6265436410903931,
-0.25168439745903015,
-0.03268210589885712,
-0.5576381683349609,
-0.181717649102211,
0.33734649419784546,
0.4935568571090698,
-0.8571677803993225,
-0.5382430553436279,
-0.4122275114059448,
0.3652232587337494,
-0.3804647922515869,
0.8996902704238892,
-0.06268175691366196,
0.4591209590435028,
-0.42769330739974976,
-0.048989687114953995,
-0.27038630843162537,
-0.5933102965354919,
-1.045129656791687,
-0.4071248173713684,
0.9339436292648315,
0.15574072301387787,
0.5919076800346375,
0.6783908009529114,
0.6386864185333252,
0.3784572184085846,
-0.16568948328495026,
0.18553322553634644,
-0.7711238265037537,
0.32998788356781006,
0.0887645035982132,
-0.5210118889808655,
-0.14243102073669434,
-0.0670386403799057,
0.8804118633270264,
0.8301941156387329,
-0.19613710045814514,
-0.1692008674144745,
-0.07926488667726517,
1.0944468975067139,
-0.4288886487483978,
-0.00009461095760343596,
-0.31070074439048767,
0.23730994760990143,
0.09432961046695709,
-0.7653011679649353,
-0.40324825048446655,
-0.9868900179862976,
0.24319636821746826,
-0.592191755771637,
-0.3524729907512665,
-0.0482473187148571,
0.46610337495803833,
0.5486108660697937,
-0.24076619744300842,
-0.5788883566856384,
-1.058574914932251,
1.1539665460586548,
-0.7231871485710144,
0.4569392800331116,
0.041860051453113556,
0.200728178024292,
-0.43816834688186646,
-0.29407748579978943,
-0.27944624423980713,
-0.5881577134132385,
0.2774946689605713,
0.05999649688601494,
-0.08420423418283463,
0.1350284069776535,
0.10089153051376343,
-0.1216181218624115,
-0.12938682734966278,
0.3391661047935486,
-0.013559282757341862,
0.011376149952411652,
0.7633864879608154,
0.1970069706439972,
0.44471806287765503,
0.09871329367160797,
-0.15319156646728516,
0.049846477806568146,
-0.7941650748252869,
0.028068436309695244,
0.4252566993236542,
0.20513422787189484,
0.05767611414194107,
0.6729280948638916,
-0.12776459753513336,
0.8190398812294006,
0.09193897247314453,
-0.5941086411476135,
-0.14508649706840515,
-0.4152016043663025,
0.30551856756210327,
-0.15486806631088257,
0.5907261371612549,
0.6181957125663757,
0.21269072592258453,
-0.29975295066833496,
-0.3660598397254944,
-0.19358406960964203,
0.2041148990392685,
-0.7417511343955994,
0.009310588240623474,
0.03961324319243431,
-0.45155224204063416,
-0.4529550075531006,
-0.13974860310554504,
-0.7687383890151978,
-0.4481848478317261,
-0.8509806990623474,
0.3305876553058624,
-0.23700715601444244,
0.05551832914352417,
0.03891778364777565,
-0.08662476390600204,
0.4452705383300781,
0.5224099159240723,
-0.908583402633667,
0.10051718354225159,
0.8314626216888428,
0.9393178820610046,
-0.051103245466947556,
-0.07559658586978912,
-0.7568027973175049,
0.00983938854187727,
-0.4850788414478302,
0.7546102404594421,
-0.5209992527961731,
-0.5083017349243164,
0.2580559253692627,
-0.35601210594177246,
0.05534221604466438,
-0.506279706954956,
0.6413989663124084,
-0.4773443937301636,
0.19717799127101898,
-0.40328657627105713,
-0.5303352475166321,
-0.1442021131515503,
0.14340923726558685,
-0.6010741591453552,
0.9477060437202454,
-0.26118943095207214,
-0.6478593349456787,
-0.04387776553630829,
-0.6583295464515686,
-0.31960663199424744,
-0.03915781527757645,
-0.1448500156402588,
-0.39669138193130493,
0.3805694580078125,
0.06566661596298218,
0.08260861784219742,
-0.3997592628002167,
0.048611514270305634,
-0.2631834149360657,
-0.2616855502128601,
0.3432411551475525,
-0.2603621184825897,
0.5377570390701294,
-0.04439718276262283,
-0.409762978553772,
0.41097527742385864,
-0.8467727899551392,
0.10445871949195862,
0.15034012496471405,
-0.9671674966812134,
-0.2094389796257019,
0.4628513753414154,
-0.06632467359304428,
-0.3562919497489929,
0.5282718539237976,
-0.4638436436653137,
0.19513024389743805,
-0.446197509765625,
0.38369226455688477,
0.8268652558326721,
-0.08046381175518036,
0.6058767437934875,
-0.24447083473205566,
0.8934761881828308,
-0.7472285628318787,
-0.050512079149484634,
0.1363213211297989,
-0.21134896576404572,
-0.803943395614624,
-0.222885400056839,
0.15161728858947754,
0.47435063123703003,
-0.5494699478149414,
0.374325156211853,
-0.09356969594955444,
-0.4019886255264282,
-0.12542878091335297,
0.49551862478256226,
0.27488964796066284,
0.33521372079849243,
-0.1936047375202179,
0.020913902670145035,
-0.5883578658103943,
-0.660642683506012,
-0.2814966142177582,
-0.15695102512836456,
0.18435198068618774,
0.2057347595691681,
0.043347712606191635,
-0.3813673257827759,
0.8963714838027954,
-0.502784252166748,
-0.01638871431350708,
-0.4715684950351715,
-0.01852494291961193,
0.2519961893558502,
0.0038406646344810724,
0.5715332627296448,
-0.5231446027755737,
-0.6121786832809448,
0.04036390036344528,
-0.6608995199203491,
-0.5626952648162842,
-0.19926518201828003,
-0.40686386823654175,
0.40943461656570435,
0.6818114519119263,
-0.6700478196144104,
-0.050895873457193375,
0.6588688492774963,
-0.05020402744412422,
0.5229088664054871,
-0.2422018051147461,
-0.49286046624183655,
-0.5421367287635803,
0.003802866442129016,
0.23334351181983948,
-0.09515707194805145,
-0.6205412745475769,
0.07384073734283447,
-0.11398880183696747,
0.06707834452390671,
-0.17487896978855133,
0.4349175691604614,
-0.5624141097068787,
0.3256065845489502,
-0.44912293553352356,
0.3013652563095093,
-0.1875821202993393,
0.5664616227149963,
0.1007382795214653,
0.43988534808158875,
0.40368038415908813,
-0.42614835500717163,
0.44322720170021057,
0.042334575206041336,
-0.05499102175235748,
0.547011137008667,
-0.7464703321456909,
0.41167598962783813,
-0.5674848556518555,
0.04392741993069649,
-0.8657342791557312,
0.00026790384436026216,
0.02922036126255989,
-0.2889406085014343,
0.4300677180290222,
0.1055108979344368,
-0.4109775424003601,
-0.3652803897857666,
-0.8630375862121582,
0.08666636794805527,
0.32669660449028015,
-0.5729674696922302,
0.5913171768188477,
0.2619500160217285,
-0.20107778906822205,
-0.35873234272003174,
-0.30072057247161865,
-0.05753359943628311,
-0.10158614069223404,
-0.6923475861549377,
-0.08271549642086029,
-0.26331591606140137,
-0.42405185103416443,
-0.2297176867723465,
0.02894529141485691,
0.19927075505256653,
-0.018015891313552856,
0.10917509347200394,
0.3354454040527344,
-0.04767817631363869,
-0.04412481188774109,
-0.043532151728868484,
-0.24845823645591736,
0.31773966550827026,
-0.40944287180900574,
0.6088152527809143,
-0.11018487066030502,
-0.32180407643318176,
-0.4249297082424164,
0.44138652086257935,
0.601737380027771,
-0.057535916566848755,
0.6650686264038086,
0.3498963415622711,
-0.15010987222194672,
-0.343962699174881,
-0.57724928855896,
-0.16784001886844635,
-0.5315091013908386,
0.602821946144104,
-0.1307816058397293,
-0.8441916704177856,
0.1533648520708084,
-0.026852020993828773,
0.17436189949512482,
0.11013496667146683,
0.7638734579086304,
-0.01542060449719429,
1.2975952625274658,
0.8670971393585205,
-0.20242057740688324,
0.5534275770187378,
-0.22840550541877747,
0.39675256609916687,
-0.695423424243927,
-0.3216227889060974,
-0.7909945249557495,
-0.4325599670410156,
-0.5575323700904846,
-0.22798892855644226,
0.35947185754776,
0.14659936726093292,
-0.1485842764377594,
0.06228535249829292,
-0.5914083123207092,
0.5963603258132935,
0.8821085691452026,
-0.05524351820349693,
0.23677299916744232,
-0.017772717401385307,
-0.2720504403114319,
-0.3336316645145416,
-0.7545374631881714,
-0.48029592633247375,
1.0380455255508423,
0.47980043292045593,
1.059486746788025,
0.10315151512622833,
0.8616018295288086,
-0.30302324891090393,
0.33550092577934265,
-1.1545360088348389,
0.7072017788887024,
0.033421434462070465,
-0.14577199518680573,
-0.2713678479194641,
-0.5595648884773254,
-0.8585514426231384,
0.08350183069705963,
-0.10414397716522217,
-0.4230157136917114,
-0.2831062078475952,
-0.05183625593781471,
-0.2548083961009979,
0.19460536539554596,
-0.535847008228302,
0.5580474734306335,
-0.7023617625236511,
-0.46802452206611633,
-0.10457693040370941,
-0.38603270053863525,
-0.21922044456005096,
-0.10373729467391968,
0.22253787517547607,
0.14457640051841736,
-0.28024378418922424,
0.6698130965232849,
-0.8056506514549255,
0.9418025016784668,
-0.25957122445106506,
-0.33402326703071594,
0.2924230694770813,
0.06287628412246704,
0.5423787832260132,
-0.11372185498476028,
-0.024845240637660027,
-0.16889534890651703,
-0.160477876663208,
-0.05986129865050316,
-0.8230202198028564,
1.003954291343689,
-0.9546831250190735,
-0.8210970163345337,
-0.20385059714317322,
-0.5175140500068665,
-0.07827949523925781,
0.2995991110801697,
0.06685082614421844,
0.6088912487030029,
0.015778305009007454,
0.2730860412120819,
0.5064182877540588,
-0.3487139046192169,
0.6494073271751404,
0.5206124186515808,
-0.4501367211341858,
-0.6828859448432922,
0.813327968120575,
-0.027833295986056328,
0.04327377304434776,
0.8434084057807922,
0.4661896526813507,
-0.5074589252471924,
-0.8732820749282837,
-0.23397351801395416,
0.5783339738845825,
-0.7614807486534119,
-0.07907649874687195,
-0.321743369102478,
-0.18288175761699677,
0.20702315866947174,
-0.5171265006065369,
-0.18623271584510803,
-0.4107666015625,
-0.3208581805229187,
-0.10583069920539856,
0.26743805408477783,
1.006942629814148,
-0.16263031959533691,
0.04509298875927925,
-0.6536373496055603,
-0.023119309917092323,
0.14901144802570343,
0.3749883472919464,
0.0346367284655571,
-0.06959063559770584,
-0.22945168614387512,
-0.09706087410449982,
-0.41861453652381897,
-0.9660274982452393,
0.5183206796646118,
-0.03940253332257271,
0.5020062327384949,
0.3804921507835388,
-0.3344159424304962,
0.33794236183166504,
-0.6354334950447083,
0.46572819352149963,
0.3733401298522949,
-0.7454365491867065,
0.6165201663970947,
-0.5888648629188538,
0.5259450674057007,
0.5201405882835388,
0.37674838304519653,
-0.5323702692985535,
-0.3911086618900299,
0.20036670565605164,
-0.7204686999320984,
0.6025353074073792,
0.10551987588405609,
0.2618112564086914,
-0.13034123182296753,
0.6533283591270447,
0.019536178559064865,
0.39012113213539124,
-0.9419411420822144,
-0.20433229207992554,
0.1646772176027298,
-0.3951795995235443,
0.13609933853149414,
-0.4904521405696869,
-0.0837310329079628,
-0.42277440428733826,
0.6442092061042786,
-0.19713498651981354,
0.2874126136302948,
0.23687660694122314,
0.19690734148025513,
-0.5296087265014648,
-0.033627599477767944,
0.692847728729248,
0.7606593370437622,
-0.12730054557323456,
-0.021069061011075974,
0.016320504248142242,
-0.4106878638267517,
0.050315409898757935,
-0.23749978840351105,
-0.6528857350349426,
0.1828836351633072,
0.33238592743873596,
0.7199931144714355,
0.21881239116191864,
-0.6778329610824585,
0.27994516491889954,
0.1010347455739975,
-0.19293084740638733,
-0.37633198499679565,
-0.06020030006766319,
0.32384684681892395,
0.28206852078437805,
0.31649982929229736,
-0.014257158152759075,
0.06251218914985657,
-0.2508721649646759,
-0.2972469925880432,
1.0466327667236328,
-0.29902002215385437,
-0.24339118599891663,
0.7768638134002686,
0.4632461965084076,
-0.7715758681297302,
0.19726158678531647,
0.10161391645669937,
-0.7752021551132202,
0.5559644103050232,
0.4582159221172333,
1.0910627841949463,
0.1290075033903122,
0.2451421320438385,
0.33803290128707886,
0.2559089958667755,
0.10138025879859924,
0.26902449131011963,
-0.015183540061116219,
-0.36885836720466614,
-0.8097116947174072,
-0.9695107340812683,
-0.6782711744308472,
-0.25048214197158813,
-0.27768704295158386,
0.5228018760681152,
-0.9570501446723938,
-0.3380001485347748,
-0.0873388946056366,
0.19294816255569458,
-0.33200305700302124,
-0.21069572865962982,
0.18609265983104706,
0.7193735241889954,
-0.04603538662195206,
0.5082436203956604,
0.9568886160850525,
-0.15226960182189941,
-0.6893773078918457,
-0.19736699759960175,
0.13017792999744415,
-0.7168657183647156,
0.94683837890625,
0.3322916030883789,
-0.6621999740600586,
-0.07520875334739685,
-0.5806552767753601,
-0.9687206149101257,
0.9273454546928406,
0.4573233723640442,
-0.9050112962722778,
0.03208618983626366,
0.2504849433898926,
0.8586430549621582,
-0.2939862012863159,
0.25761258602142334,
0.08323761075735092,
0.5003060102462769,
0.2738817036151886,
-0.8363474011421204,
-0.11093111336231232,
-0.22107145190238953,
0.6037851572036743,
0.6547737717628479,
-0.9461690187454224,
0.2537625730037689,
-0.2397579699754715,
0.03069179691374302,
0.38029468059539795,
0.5132226943969727,
0.16498470306396484,
0.06492748111486435,
0.15532223880290985,
0.686054527759552,
0.5823156237602234,
-0.030669890344142914,
1.3824385404586792,
-0.4217667579650879,
0.23832732439041138,
0.6535765528678894,
-0.12728993594646454,
0.934477686882019,
0.7927029132843018,
-0.2283926159143448,
0.6396047472953796,
0.3378410041332245,
0.20654617249965668,
0.727861225605011,
0.4566294848918915,
-0.44732722640037537,
-0.015139640308916569,
0.0398196242749691,
-0.024290388450026512,
0.02980959601700306,
-0.009181748144328594,
-0.12888309359550476,
-0.09999101608991623,
-0.322388619184494,
0.29965874552726746,
0.2124262899160385,
-0.2314976155757904,
0.7648109197616577,
0.2182384878396988,
-0.7700712084770203,
0.6220632791519165,
0.4020310640335083,
0.6826603412628174,
-0.6823862791061401,
0.21182560920715332,
-0.3566364645957947,
0.431894987821579,
-0.2260499745607376,
-0.38483667373657227,
0.3328491747379303,
-0.1670154482126236,
-0.12314050644636154,
-0.2808152139186859,
0.7229251265525818,
-0.4147297143936157,
-0.6328859925270081,
0.4952927827835083,
0.326978474855423,
-0.2986604571342468,
0.17572997510433197,
-0.48686501383781433,
0.3743351995944977,
0.2391500324010849,
-0.34314197301864624,
0.14024268090724945,
0.3007707893848419,
0.20157653093338013,
0.9677556753158569,
0.8418662548065186,
0.22577756643295288,
0.2720150947570801,
0.1562654674053192,
0.7074277997016907,
-0.844615638256073,
-0.4073962867259979,
-1.150985598564148,
0.10920818895101547,
0.05305781587958336,
-0.12778176367282867,
0.8829947710037231,
0.2550960183143616,
0.3948970139026642,
0.006167306564748287,
0.7657514810562134,
0.3743874430656433,
0.44994962215423584,
-0.7201862931251526,
0.4506075084209442,
-0.46657541394233704,
0.4672738313674927,
-0.13314270973205566,
-1.4455193281173706,
-0.4859990179538727,
0.6943084001541138,
-0.4934307932853699,
0.1313450038433075,
0.7393994331359863,
0.7721078991889954,
0.39313653111457825,
0.2170582264661789,
-0.09699223190546036,
0.28550153970718384,
0.28453129529953003,
0.542643129825592,
0.9910317063331604,
0.0904424861073494,
0.5268966555595398,
-0.37258705496788025,
-0.4068944752216339,
-0.21022312343120575,
-0.9966058135032654,
-1.1721665859222412,
-0.2044614851474762,
-0.5565714836120605,
-0.16614143550395966,
0.008597929030656815,
0.9594541788101196,
0.4448325037956238,
-0.5639777779579163,
-0.5514497756958008,
-0.33628880977630615,
0.16885024309158325,
0.3627265393733978,
-0.28900834918022156,
0.17920203506946564,
-0.5832581520080566,
-0.8252355456352234,
0.336618572473526,
0.8121075630187988,
-0.013307665474712849,
-0.7321348190307617,
-0.4696343243122101,
0.005889417137950659,
0.31909382343292236,
0.8063268661499023,
0.2302836924791336,
-0.5891854166984558,
-0.09542975574731827,
0.4070380628108978,
-0.09133170545101166,
-0.00041091686580330133,
0.7741185426712036,
-0.3731040060520172,
0.43205803632736206,
0.5019412636756897,
0.9008930921554565,
0.40039297938346863,
-0.09334656596183777,
0.8838428854942322,
-0.40423324704170227,
0.03415030241012573,
0.13474364578723907,
0.23639410734176636,
0.5497912168502808,
-0.23839059472084045,
0.465920090675354,
0.23773221671581268,
-0.6727083325386047,
-0.5243510603904724,
0.11749371141195297,
-0.8689578175544739,
0.006401381455361843,
1.5497610569000244,
0.3642936944961548,
-0.4302613139152527,
0.3576453626155853,
-0.6048246622085571,
-0.24733369052410126,
-0.4680681824684143,
0.6024572253227234,
0.8517577052116394,
-0.41823065280914307,
-0.16836972534656525,
-0.39553186297416687,
0.4325014352798462,
0.9323700666427612,
-0.6716189980506897,
-0.42083075642585754,
0.7773210406303406,
0.09417989104986191,
0.22150392830371857,
0.6269605755805969,
-0.17163261771202087,
-0.08256637305021286,
-0.2942262291908264,
-0.32260647416114807,
0.2584182024002075,
-0.2128625065088272,
-0.4249269664287567,
0.09562458842992783,
0.6052960753440857,
0.012669765390455723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16433v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16433v3
|
CPsyCoun: A Report-based Multi-turn Dialogue Reconstruction and Evaluation Framework for Chinese Psychological Counseling
| 2024-05-26T05:18:00 | 2024-06-10T11:43:48 |
Chenhao Zhang, Renhao Li, Minghuan Tan, Min Yang, Jingwei Zhu, Di Yang, Jiahao Zhao, Guancheng Ye, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Using large language models (LLMs) to assist psychological counseling is a
significant but challenging task at present. Attempts have been made on
improving empathetic conversations or acting as effective assistants in the
treatment with LLMs. However, the existing datasets lack consulting knowledge,
resulting in LLMs lacking professional consulting competence. Moreover, how to
automatically evaluate multi-turn dialogues within the counseling process
remains an understudied area. To bridge the gap, we propose CPsyCoun, a
report-based multi-turn dialogue reconstruction and evaluation framework for
Chinese psychological counseling. To fully exploit psychological counseling
reports, a two-phase approach is devised to construct high-quality dialogues
while a comprehensive evaluation benchmark is developed for the effective
automatic evaluation of multi-turn psychological consultations. Competitive
experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed framework in
psychological counseling. We open-source the datasets and model for future
research at https://github.com/CAS-SIAT-XinHai/CPsyCoun
|
[
-0.18446731567382812,
-0.2683875560760498,
0.5025692582130432,
0.8544591069221497,
-0.3414401710033417,
0.12528157234191895,
-0.7312198281288147,
-0.30303385853767395,
0.2554525136947632,
0.3868376612663269,
-0.755886971950531,
-0.3627936840057373,
-0.5151800513267517,
0.19976338744163513,
-0.06265825778245926,
0.8367652297019958,
0.19262735545635223,
0.8442707061767578,
0.01251168455928564,
0.21810053288936615,
-0.3804287910461426,
-0.34750962257385254,
-0.9447184801101685,
-0.2548670470714569,
0.13093183934688568,
0.38036206364631653,
0.43041399121284485,
0.09555120766162872,
0.1585533767938614,
0.2602422535419464,
0.013415265828371048,
0.377439945936203,
-0.45385074615478516,
-0.06584477424621582,
0.12673112750053406,
-0.3630596399307251,
-0.757428765296936,
0.10187457501888275,
0.3986302614212036,
0.740129292011261,
-0.4746896028518677,
-0.02019941434264183,
0.5315401554107666,
0.20078088343143463,
-0.603384792804718,
0.2964078485965729,
-0.5332004427909851,
0.10671212524175644,
0.31113556027412415,
-0.11359785497188568,
-0.5462190508842468,
-0.38102272152900696,
0.33772310614585876,
-0.6734757423400879,
0.4404008984565735,
-0.028053758665919304,
0.23506712913513184,
-0.2219424843788147,
-0.508111834526062,
-0.45322760939598083,
-0.5919603705406189,
0.9102360010147095,
-0.9621633291244507,
0.2405734658241272,
0.48676759004592896,
0.31442007422447205,
-0.35542628169059753,
-0.6060715317726135,
-0.22187134623527527,
-0.3343116343021393,
-0.24651207029819489,
0.47252339124679565,
0.18204042315483093,
0.09604174643754959,
0.07617317885160446,
0.37416377663612366,
-0.22126156091690063,
-0.15955466032028198,
-0.12190324068069458,
-0.4879085123538971,
0.8176717758178711,
0.6254822015762329,
0.30029571056365967,
-0.1790405958890915,
-0.17179839313030243,
0.2017551213502884,
-0.32744300365448,
0.12834253907203674,
0.2737739086151123,
0.5053925514221191,
-0.1745680719614029,
0.16669665277004242,
0.0648135393857956,
0.5440885424613953,
0.33823198080062866,
-0.52323979139328,
-0.3437372148036957,
-0.5544112920761108,
-0.25123125314712524,
0.2952950596809387,
1.0737930536270142,
0.6964737176895142,
0.07391190528869629,
-0.11377908289432526,
0.21704263985157013,
-0.14628209173679352,
0.3727467954158783,
-0.6999401450157166,
-0.5191750526428223,
0.4507240056991577,
-0.5355043411254883,
-0.17003145813941956,
-0.019776180386543274,
-1.1249085664749146,
-0.5888446569442749,
-0.5387274622917175,
-0.30401715636253357,
-0.5300778746604919,
-0.5517818927764893,
0.014442311599850655,
0.20447057485580444,
0.37326961755752563,
0.6488881707191467,
-0.6360927224159241,
0.4635400176048279,
0.880872368812561,
0.9702630639076233,
-0.33802443742752075,
-0.47999462485313416,
-0.46811211109161377,
-0.0674077570438385,
-0.45361748337745667,
0.7265028357505798,
-0.35275977849960327,
-0.5361079573631287,
0.3138224482536316,
0.41116663813591003,
-0.05690578743815422,
-0.31187769770622253,
0.7122642993927002,
0.21116431057453156,
0.2694648802280426,
-0.4940280020236969,
-0.1606983244419098,
0.3451465368270874,
0.5358729958534241,
-0.5148301124572754,
0.6533840298652649,
0.012404982931911945,
-0.7238277792930603,
0.22021996974945068,
-0.2548266351222992,
-0.3119228184223175,
0.04933178424835205,
-0.15495088696479797,
-0.3326259255409241,
-0.15921567380428314,
0.3439616858959198,
0.2063901722431183,
-0.6296699643135071,
0.1906394064426422,
-0.5119168162345886,
-0.5145185589790344,
0.27714866399765015,
-0.26118528842926025,
1.0860151052474976,
0.07545065134763718,
0.029039764776825905,
0.20915386080741882,
-0.6946095824241638,
0.09440495073795319,
-0.043553099036216736,
-0.21447333693504333,
-0.2071589082479477,
-0.21875163912773132,
0.13833966851234436,
0.17627204954624176,
0.06698117405176163,
-0.9287163615226746,
0.2633036971092224,
-0.4326081871986389,
0.36881107091903687,
0.49956434965133667,
-0.056486863642930984,
0.25412246584892273,
-0.19244390726089478,
0.7061769962310791,
-0.033121854066848755,
0.36694633960723877,
-0.3798002302646637,
-0.18580415844917297,
-0.843522310256958,
-0.5091679096221924,
-0.2576504051685333,
0.4066440165042877,
-0.5888617634773254,
0.3827363848686218,
0.29915767908096313,
-0.7407830357551575,
-0.646558403968811,
0.0507315918803215,
0.4212847948074341,
0.3863368630409241,
0.279967337846756,
-0.15030494332313538,
-0.8210843801498413,
-0.6544404029846191,
-0.36927828192710876,
0.08830700814723969,
0.02225419506430626,
0.1747927963733673,
0.03383062034845352,
0.26588162779808044,
0.6274471282958984,
-0.4829760789871216,
-0.4669080674648285,
-0.5478494167327881,
0.20299838483333588,
0.18956591188907623,
0.3419972360134125,
0.3797065317630768,
-0.2689448893070221,
-0.6540419459342957,
-0.3862912058830261,
-0.49891361594200134,
-0.15061402320861816,
-0.4190809428691864,
-0.282819002866745,
0.187123104929924,
0.09109141677618027,
-0.26598697900772095,
0.324684202671051,
0.5831758975982666,
-0.24003759026527405,
1.1053054332733154,
-0.11547791957855225,
0.3043777048587799,
-0.9794726967811584,
-0.014079367741942406,
0.0470980629324913,
-0.17837919294834137,
-0.5971661806106567,
-0.3146456480026245,
0.07949022948741913,
-0.24713265895843506,
-0.47201693058013916,
0.02457675337791443,
-0.580371081829071,
0.0018015856621786952,
-0.30726829171180725,
0.41964951157569885,
-0.12062016874551773,
0.862683117389679,
0.07911667227745056,
0.633027195930481,
0.4205142557621002,
-0.4684024453163147,
0.793185830116272,
0.5913281440734863,
-0.33441656827926636,
0.9450061321258545,
-0.49387913942337036,
0.2475098967552185,
0.26340124011039734,
0.5909016728401184,
-1.0209540128707886,
-0.045689474791288376,
0.43314895033836365,
-0.08194386959075928,
0.12527035176753998,
-0.2834208011627197,
-0.2298489511013031,
-0.274564266204834,
-0.548774003982544,
0.49692684412002563,
-0.144627645611763,
-0.5457502007484436,
0.37029320001602173,
0.0968809649348259,
-0.4755958914756775,
-0.6033132076263428,
-0.451237291097641,
0.2713155448436737,
0.028351427987217903,
-0.43917110562324524,
0.3340252637863159,
-0.22287312150001526,
0.1078743264079094,
-0.3696322441101074,
0.00434528011828661,
0.014187149703502655,
-0.31150323152542114,
0.24902231991291046,
0.5524877905845642,
0.008176586590707302,
-0.29982930421829224,
0.0621463768184185,
-0.304463654756546,
0.3344481885433197,
0.043859414756298065,
0.7526692152023315,
-0.3138945996761322,
-0.514316976070404,
-0.5334060788154602,
0.23821642994880676,
0.4449138939380646,
-0.209503635764122,
0.5643638372421265,
0.42518025636672974,
-0.3058430850505829,
-0.17628969252109528,
-0.43933820724487305,
0.043802715837955475,
-0.40368589758872986,
0.42694857716560364,
-0.17017294466495514,
-0.5784475803375244,
0.18506298959255219,
-0.28448474407196045,
0.09296125173568726,
-0.007500598672777414,
0.8126252293586731,
0.010478929616510868,
1.1769037246704102,
0.5224370360374451,
0.11067353188991547,
0.3206520676612854,
-0.22699563205242157,
0.3314383327960968,
-1.1723253726959229,
-0.4189102053642273,
-0.3723984956741333,
0.029235703870654106,
-0.34075623750686646,
0.0003149784170091152,
0.3658798336982727,
0.11240284889936447,
-0.3315708637237549,
0.49295225739479065,
-0.5872701406478882,
-0.03195520490407944,
-0.04326457902789116,
0.2673846483230591,
0.5949499607086182,
-0.3194323778152466,
-0.1818654090166092,
-0.5562582612037659,
-0.5073806643486023,
-0.41361740231513977,
0.7341164350509644,
0.21762393414974213,
0.5874336361885071,
-0.15132322907447815,
0.343716025352478,
-0.07231511175632477,
0.6297088861465454,
-1.264192819595337,
0.4594796299934387,
0.09604190289974213,
-0.2314361184835434,
-0.29406800866127014,
-0.14704899489879608,
-0.7472289800643921,
0.5587135553359985,
-0.08860806375741959,
-0.8764167428016663,
0.16989505290985107,
0.0374147854745388,
-0.2518462836742401,
0.06630361825227737,
-0.23639708757400513,
0.6490777134895325,
-0.5856610536575317,
-0.28120189905166626,
-0.36270734667778015,
-0.2850072979927063,
0.7264939546585083,
-0.1977512240409851,
0.09746378660202026,
-0.2008393257856369,
0.21264615654945374,
0.6818851232528687,
-0.6570721864700317,
0.835039496421814,
-0.21523050963878632,
-0.3950394093990326,
0.15638747811317444,
0.3677176237106323,
0.3291851282119751,
0.29524943232536316,
-0.2868191599845886,
-0.08924254775047302,
0.8389548659324646,
-0.22446590662002563,
-0.7686392664909363,
0.5558103919029236,
-0.5710245370864868,
-0.3757508397102356,
-0.466340035200119,
-0.4928322732448578,
-0.5759648084640503,
0.21049955487251282,
0.2820519208908081,
0.29921141266822815,
-0.5639455914497375,
-0.1345483362674713,
-0.09319915622472763,
-0.5799562335014343,
0.17321136593818665,
0.629676342010498,
-0.31021809577941895,
-0.8678401112556458,
0.5621325373649597,
-0.05388745665550232,
0.020037995651364326,
-0.3664361238479614,
0.11881299316883087,
-0.03878011181950569,
0.0750303715467453,
-0.014023956842720509,
0.49376702308654785,
-0.644059419631958,
-0.19849266111850739,
-0.3080430328845978,
-0.17166006565093994,
-0.6960302591323853,
-0.021347174420952797,
-0.6524354815483093,
-0.22535055875778198,
0.15069612860679626,
0.08949626237154007,
0.029505807906389236,
0.32776907086372375,
-0.06999474763870239,
0.41587772965431213,
-0.5773554444313049,
0.22565944492816925,
-0.15659727156162262,
0.41359904408454895,
0.5036239624023438,
-0.32664960622787476,
-0.36183464527130127,
0.30692076683044434,
-0.5918923020362854,
-0.8668113350868225,
0.5065656304359436,
-0.0502622090280056,
0.500931441783905,
0.46516114473342896,
0.33488261699676514,
0.9817892909049988,
-0.107270248234272,
0.9359152317047119,
0.4966961145401001,
-1.0455418825149536,
0.5149686336517334,
-0.1541106253862381,
0.06390196084976196,
0.5615371465682983,
0.28246212005615234,
-0.969563901424408,
-0.4057413637638092,
-0.3839189410209656,
-0.6803485751152039,
1.146973729133606,
0.038364093750715256,
0.07238499820232391,
0.256740540266037,
0.32832083106040955,
0.06695904582738876,
0.2703579366207123,
-0.385385125875473,
0.005606675520539284,
-0.4573088586330414,
-0.12990272045135498,
0.1312812864780426,
-0.30552083253860474,
-0.48174819350242615,
-0.2705360949039459,
0.6513426303863525,
-0.10123313963413239,
0.5961407423019409,
0.3987495005130768,
0.029435044154524803,
-0.192084401845932,
0.3132348954677582,
0.2990112602710724,
0.5886345505714417,
-0.042322222143411636,
-0.1406659632921219,
0.431904673576355,
-0.5031367540359497,
-0.09086479246616364,
-0.06201768293976784,
0.41700127720832825,
-0.16909341514110565,
0.6402842402458191,
0.4749831259250641,
0.15916644036769867,
-0.48005762696266174,
0.7757298350334167,
-0.2907376289367676,
-0.1610352247953415,
-0.7915915846824646,
-0.14044219255447388,
0.024924127385020256,
0.11941860616207123,
0.1721026748418808,
-0.37754473090171814,
0.10269670933485031,
-0.6189245581626892,
0.10428416728973389,
0.1521035134792328,
-0.6058883666992188,
-0.28280511498451233,
0.2561531662940979,
0.19202052056789398,
-0.5112509727478027,
0.9278818368911743,
0.12220928072929382,
-0.6665228605270386,
0.4497084617614746,
0.8197152018547058,
0.7845694422721863,
-0.2417517900466919,
0.3601517379283905,
0.5705441832542419,
0.031142080202698708,
-0.22292457520961761,
0.3897182047367096,
-0.2479236125946045,
-0.596663773059845,
-0.5412665009498596,
-0.33897072076797485,
-0.7938080430030823,
0.32214072346687317,
-1.0158072710037231,
0.5543293356895447,
-0.71196448802948,
-0.10575306415557861,
-0.5455429553985596,
0.025753233581781387,
-0.4897705614566803,
-0.0361134372651577,
0.1029561385512352,
0.9870495200157166,
-0.45933905243873596,
0.6052766442298889,
0.56656813621521,
-0.33579275012016296,
-0.7806921005249023,
0.14988063275814056,
0.21085672080516815,
-0.6936332583427429,
0.037119586020708084,
0.13731417059898376,
-0.39788562059402466,
-0.2956291437149048,
-0.8527493476867676,
-0.32206621766090393,
1.2410633563995361,
0.6610817909240723,
-0.5763332843780518,
0.006110612768679857,
0.43998825550079346,
0.7282761931419373,
-0.6401380300521851,
0.5825693011283875,
0.8051896691322327,
0.45678359270095825,
0.13510024547576904,
-1.0648030042648315,
0.21397149562835693,
-0.25880128145217896,
-0.12034396827220917,
-0.2654329836368561,
-1.2123751640319824,
0.4417237639427185,
-0.03293794021010399,
-0.11249342560768127,
0.49467378854751587,
0.3361629545688629,
0.5958037376403809,
0.27990710735321045,
0.591667652130127,
-0.13371990621089935,
0.6611582040786743,
0.05923329293727875,
0.579206645488739,
-0.662316620349884,
0.4750138223171234,
1.5401926040649414,
-0.32914549112319946,
0.49659016728401184,
0.2610565721988678,
-0.17532610893249512,
0.3399786949157715,
0.5922058820724487,
-0.3368106782436371,
0.2558633089065552,
0.06520149856805801,
-0.07596021145582199,
-0.47689446806907654,
-0.4324692189693451,
-0.006139646749943495,
0.5173152685165405,
0.45560941100120544,
-0.15999063849449158,
-0.11820829659700394,
-0.11203142255544662,
0.142938494682312,
0.06819338351488113,
0.0020705084316432476,
0.6061527132987976,
0.5287871956825256,
-0.7088659405708313,
0.4496877193450928,
0.15532073378562927,
0.40407612919807434,
-0.521483838558197,
-0.2448255717754364,
-0.4033326804637909,
0.2865455746650696,
-0.5918305516242981,
-0.5986806750297546,
0.3655688762664795,
0.03189225494861603,
0.4402161240577698,
-0.215708926320076,
0.6021023392677307,
-0.6372925639152527,
-0.47017645835876465,
0.5349155068397522,
0.31479841470718384,
0.13365265727043152,
-0.07862017303705215,
-0.8456884026527405,
0.05976243317127228,
-0.1422443985939026,
-0.054343268275260925,
0.20964987576007843,
0.35352015495300293,
0.22089138627052307,
0.5862976908683777,
0.4799383878707886,
0.30477944016456604,
-0.5158675909042358,
0.3585869371891022,
0.7641677856445312,
-0.6487181782722473,
-0.5643911361694336,
-0.604549765586853,
0.4980599880218506,
-0.12816093862056732,
-0.33301791548728943,
0.7344741821289062,
0.5278903841972351,
0.46003350615501404,
0.2060621678829193,
0.9647458791732788,
0.05388695001602173,
0.4635029137134552,
-0.2669074237346649,
0.5868382453918457,
-0.3834313452243805,
0.2771328091621399,
-0.5745090246200562,
-0.9775179028511047,
-0.11904869228601456,
0.5319200754165649,
-0.35141822695732117,
-0.1753930151462555,
0.8016085624694824,
0.815268337726593,
-0.1696421205997467,
0.43798214197158813,
0.2526524066925049,
0.3284705579280853,
0.605607807636261,
0.6599912047386169,
1.1103707551956177,
-0.3876855671405792,
0.9320449233055115,
-0.4083418548107147,
-0.3438897430896759,
0.030122114345431328,
-0.821624755859375,
-0.7487921714782715,
-0.44780001044273376,
-0.11207468062639236,
-0.5714187622070312,
-0.21990305185317993,
1.2421973943710327,
0.45919281244277954,
-0.8368754386901855,
-0.6070406436920166,
0.17827577888965607,
-0.4325130581855774,
-0.47635674476623535,
-0.20351162552833557,
0.40561679005622864,
-0.32594770193099976,
-0.7657928466796875,
0.403400719165802,
0.24846325814723969,
-0.3978222906589508,
-0.574773371219635,
-0.30779993534088135,
0.182878315448761,
-0.1072797030210495,
0.4962007999420166,
-0.011845264583826065,
-0.6832565069198608,
0.06597964465618134,
-0.03534121438860893,
-0.18958652019500732,
0.24024687707424164,
1.4979599714279175,
-0.3448081910610199,
0.5764504075050354,
0.0794248878955841,
0.39986810088157654,
0.6114562153816223,
-0.004345956724137068,
1.0203169584274292,
-0.32297784090042114,
0.2872990667819977,
-0.022382207214832306,
0.5346318483352661,
0.37602919340133667,
-0.6481000185012817,
0.49660003185272217,
0.07692892849445343,
-0.3523327112197876,
-0.6781819462776184,
0.19091777503490448,
-1.0077826976776123,
-0.2722875773906708,
1.150390386581421,
-0.5427703261375427,
0.15713387727737427,
-0.3684600293636322,
-0.9420893788337708,
0.8254066109657288,
-0.40164095163345337,
0.9229366183280945,
0.9806737303733826,
-0.687349259853363,
-0.39125919342041016,
-0.13584867119789124,
0.451990008354187,
0.5139138698577881,
-0.5504043102264404,
0.4636307656764984,
0.36598989367485046,
0.3233197033405304,
0.08959200233221054,
0.7504381537437439,
-0.27462074160575867,
0.20253710448741913,
-0.10438548028469086,
-0.10576057434082031,
-0.15386518836021423,
-0.19590862095355988,
-0.24541500210762024,
-0.11590197682380676,
-0.0211296696215868,
0.2966182827949524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16422v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16422v1
|
AI-Generated Text Detection and Classification Based on BERT Deep Learning Algorithm
| 2024-05-26T04:26:07 | 2024-05-26T04:26:07 |
Hao Wang, Jianwei Li, Zhengyu Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
AI-generated text detection plays an increasingly important role in various
fields. In this study, we developed an efficient AI-generated text detection
model based on the BERT algorithm, which provides new ideas and methods for
solving related problems. In the data preprocessing stage, a series of steps
were taken to process the text, including operations such as converting to
lowercase, word splitting, removing stop words, stemming extraction, removing
digits, and eliminating redundant spaces, to ensure data quality and accuracy.
By dividing the dataset into a training set and a test set in the ratio of 60%
and 40%, and observing the changes in the accuracy and loss values during the
training process, we found that the model performed well during the training
process. The accuracy increases steadily from the initial 94.78% to 99.72%,
while the loss value decreases from 0.261 to 0.021 and converges gradually,
which indicates that the BERT model is able to detect AI-generated text with
high accuracy and the prediction results are gradually approaching the real
classification results. Further analysis of the results of the training and
test sets reveals that in terms of loss value, the average loss of the training
set is 0.0565, while the average loss of the test set is 0.0917, showing a
slightly higher loss value. As for the accuracy, the average accuracy of the
training set reaches 98.1%, while the average accuracy of the test set is
97.71%, which is not much different from each other, indicating that the model
has good generalisation ability. In conclusion, the AI-generated text detection
model based on the BERT algorithm proposed in this study shows high accuracy
and stability in experiments, providing an effective solution for related
fields.
|
[
-0.25839799642562866,
-0.9645189046859741,
0.5699526071548462,
0.03159976750612259,
-0.5062481760978699,
0.0700918659567833,
-0.19583407044410706,
-0.7762099504470825,
-0.21680539846420288,
0.3118574321269989,
-0.513629138469696,
-0.6638695001602173,
-0.8057767152786255,
0.1007273718714714,
-0.5937017202377319,
0.8992193937301636,
0.06710905581712723,
-0.027286725118756294,
0.08055706322193146,
0.21878869831562042,
-0.6515906453132629,
-0.480712890625,
-0.570675790309906,
-0.19259165227413177,
0.1089068353176117,
0.31092122197151184,
0.3286798894405365,
0.5324605107307434,
0.7035652995109558,
0.3536837697029114,
-0.15749461948871613,
0.36414971947669983,
-0.1173633262515068,
0.12090112268924713,
0.2092493176460266,
-0.3383404612541199,
-0.13807463645935059,
0.04926406592130661,
0.5537933707237244,
0.005222375970333815,
0.03578193113207817,
0.015461674891412258,
0.1241425946354866,
0.5359274744987488,
-0.17329812049865723,
-0.029032573103904724,
-0.9236825108528137,
0.03295708820223808,
-0.16617795825004578,
-0.1454939842224121,
-0.5613436102867126,
-0.45352014899253845,
0.2942218780517578,
-0.3514408767223358,
0.5241225957870483,
0.09572160989046097,
1.165757417678833,
0.008300120942294598,
-0.12387372553348541,
-0.775943398475647,
-0.5150759220123291,
0.8557692766189575,
-0.9295022487640381,
0.20045384764671326,
0.20415423810482025,
0.21087294816970825,
0.027907373383641243,
-0.6459071636199951,
-1.092940330505371,
-0.1475183516740799,
0.19434216618537903,
0.12894609570503235,
-0.10742446035146713,
0.010295972228050232,
-0.11067675054073334,
0.198094442486763,
-0.5149760842323303,
0.4258604049682617,
-0.10399171710014343,
-0.30666881799697876,
0.6776718497276306,
0.045155011117458344,
0.4829917848110199,
-0.18849602341651917,
-0.24126233160495758,
-0.22947677969932556,
-0.18985077738761902,
0.02161259576678276,
0.3343345522880554,
0.24360741674900055,
0.0981142595410347,
0.20557716488838196,
0.14777116477489471,
0.5780105590820312,
-0.17563676834106445,
-0.1748402863740921,
0.2904513478279114,
-0.2009737640619278,
-0.23941242694854736,
0.09588956832885742,
0.8398895859718323,
0.21659545600414276,
0.7220180034637451,
0.26261475682258606,
-0.2715962827205658,
0.06012846156954765,
0.3121867775917053,
-0.8439992070198059,
-0.0578925758600235,
-0.07490282505750656,
-0.9988108277320862,
-0.6899821162223816,
-0.13199667632579803,
-0.35503116250038147,
-0.25625863671302795,
-0.19613142311573029,
0.3654216527938843,
-0.8004221320152283,
0.011450416408479214,
-0.056491654366254807,
0.03684220835566521,
0.164836123585701,
0.6774755716323853,
-0.7493335008621216,
-0.03774335980415344,
0.48992428183555603,
0.8416325449943542,
-0.12790320813655853,
0.010126287117600441,
-0.15551897883415222,
-0.18339116871356964,
-0.3830871284008026,
0.9803767800331116,
-0.314017117023468,
-0.14440856873989105,
0.21811409294605255,
-0.3757753372192383,
-0.021124813705682755,
-0.25875672698020935,
0.7445290684700012,
-0.6908178329467773,
0.3083656430244446,
0.2575971782207489,
-0.9556049704551697,
-0.4650161862373352,
0.5519263744354248,
-0.6291038990020752,
0.9799546599388123,
-0.37532055377960205,
-0.6810339689254761,
0.48074957728385925,
-0.6207165122032166,
-0.6507578492164612,
0.37044864892959595,
-0.00527302548289299,
-0.977329671382904,
-0.07502474635839462,
0.5158140063285828,
0.691501259803772,
-0.05234775319695473,
0.32746797800064087,
0.00170482590328902,
-0.709748387336731,
0.2847059667110443,
-0.7517881393432617,
0.7272498607635498,
0.14687193930149078,
-0.4661068916320801,
0.07483741641044617,
-0.6903245449066162,
0.15121442079544067,
0.04479096457362175,
-0.5387945175170898,
-0.3379025459289551,
0.1716064065694809,
0.43511226773262024,
-0.07368815690279007,
0.22850824892520905,
-0.8277453184127808,
0.11236642301082611,
-0.5348265171051025,
-0.005593026522547007,
0.9660427570343018,
0.04647398740053177,
0.2033863067626953,
-0.06745854020118713,
0.10515257716178894,
-0.21191208064556122,
-0.027028555050492287,
-0.2162552922964096,
-0.8365547060966492,
-0.7994803190231323,
-0.29170656204223633,
0.7173592448234558,
0.7540227174758911,
-0.5737735629081726,
1.0189363956451416,
-0.05393148213624954,
-0.5365628600120544,
-0.43236613273620605,
-0.02949243038892746,
0.27001097798347473,
0.6704131960868835,
0.21078068017959595,
-0.08912720531225204,
-0.3219974935054779,
-0.7514234781265259,
-0.1261359304189682,
-0.2834532558917999,
-0.03332251310348511,
0.15994150936603546,
0.6020252108573914,
-0.5232322216033936,
0.9334618449211121,
-0.5625625848770142,
-0.6413495540618896,
-0.417630672454834,
0.6129075884819031,
0.4089595377445221,
0.5353110432624817,
0.7687155604362488,
-0.9110009670257568,
-0.7368332743644714,
-0.05220264941453934,
-0.7996476292610168,
-0.12209982424974442,
-0.27220430970191956,
0.1929146647453308,
0.5378199815750122,
0.23439587652683258,
-0.15742430090904236,
0.8252492547035217,
0.09112896025180817,
-0.1729755699634552,
0.6933130025863647,
-0.35378313064575195,
0.09587202966213226,
-1.0493091344833374,
-0.08169738203287125,
0.12757518887519836,
-0.24462959170341492,
-0.6133408546447754,
-0.12864363193511963,
0.18798550963401794,
-0.10230264067649841,
-0.11862561851739883,
0.33608072996139526,
-0.07374995946884155,
0.3165852129459381,
-0.6482869982719421,
-0.1994314193725586,
0.0908462181687355,
0.3795965015888214,
0.15688763558864594,
0.7661359310150146,
0.32599905133247375,
-0.6737142205238342,
0.29423609375953674,
0.2956833839416504,
-0.6542635560035706,
0.21960771083831787,
-0.4486877918243408,
0.06903035938739777,
-0.2339780628681183,
0.1581977754831314,
-1.0826878547668457,
0.17059627175331116,
0.3492376208305359,
-0.8302810788154602,
0.18787945806980133,
0.357697457075119,
-0.896182119846344,
-0.4419942796230316,
-0.2768819332122803,
-0.08430637419223785,
0.6802738904953003,
-0.6080604195594788,
0.6309597492218018,
0.00015158962924033403,
-0.4416990280151367,
-0.4872114360332489,
-0.7143706679344177,
-0.025136372074484825,
0.1888636350631714,
-0.6749627590179443,
0.5302291512489319,
-0.230647012591362,
0.03632853180170059,
-0.037202637642621994,
0.2876409590244293,
-0.4958036541938782,
0.08934508264064789,
0.018349427729845047,
0.27481594681739807,
0.008257895708084106,
0.723692774772644,
0.4081664979457855,
-0.04685678333044052,
-0.007535745855420828,
-0.02755449153482914,
0.6507183313369751,
0.16656294465065002,
-0.11011793464422226,
-1.100529432296753,
0.35906460881233215,
0.3642774224281311,
-0.33808633685112,
0.6645348072052002,
1.0391919612884521,
-0.5510636568069458,
-0.13674679398536682,
-0.46038755774497986,
-0.1902974247932434,
-0.4934810698032379,
0.43360209465026855,
-0.14514826238155365,
-0.4900703728199005,
0.40945038199424744,
0.12300843745470047,
0.0921018049120903,
0.604829728603363,
0.5300593972206116,
-0.6018487215042114,
1.0729700326919556,
0.8616476058959961,
-0.44505202770233154,
0.7363620400428772,
-0.17750969529151917,
0.3240627646446228,
-0.45789963006973267,
-0.23000751435756683,
-0.5368399024009705,
-0.3699186146259308,
-0.47165611386299133,
0.03287927061319351,
0.033811312168836594,
-0.15577201545238495,
-0.2497083693742752,
0.04955567419528961,
-0.8847558498382568,
0.13065263628959656,
0.9788750410079956,
0.49989423155784607,
0.19292853772640228,
0.23451559245586395,
0.04171117767691612,
-0.13902807235717773,
-0.18215018510818481,
-0.5613360404968262,
1.2060935497283936,
0.5423795580863953,
0.5514402985572815,
-0.18778309226036072,
0.8109549283981323,
0.888690710067749,
0.5510441064834595,
-0.7758511304855347,
0.4807986617088318,
-0.24901041388511658,
-0.5117512345314026,
-0.3543281853199005,
-0.1969616711139679,
-0.7017941474914551,
-0.08403510600328445,
-0.48267680406570435,
-0.4051498472690582,
0.04061932861804962,
-0.06571172177791595,
-0.11981038004159927,
0.37011194229125977,
-0.6431863903999329,
0.4795747995376587,
-0.4845048487186432,
0.18798774480819702,
-0.23660913109779358,
-0.5605946183204651,
0.11473974585533142,
-0.21925680339336395,
0.03297082707285881,
-0.1699143499135971,
0.38058674335479736,
1.023248553276062,
-0.391205757856369,
0.7692316770553589,
-0.29033467173576355,
-0.26627570390701294,
0.6120527386665344,
-0.31980082392692566,
0.5730481147766113,
-0.03601500391960144,
-0.17260953783988953,
0.17481909692287445,
-0.6553258895874023,
-0.10349122434854507,
-0.26923176646232605,
0.28207457065582275,
-0.7974016666412354,
-0.05525967851281166,
-0.6122838258743286,
-0.6400519609451294,
0.2817102074623108,
0.6366332173347473,
0.5879970788955688,
0.28075316548347473,
-0.13019850850105286,
-0.045754749327898026,
0.9436060190200806,
-0.49761539697647095,
0.7682400941848755,
0.4800003170967102,
-0.04467163607478142,
-0.47152647376060486,
0.9159987568855286,
-0.1701861172914505,
-0.23008579015731812,
0.3435598611831665,
0.02366716042160988,
-0.4074844717979431,
-0.9545966386795044,
-0.46757304668426514,
-0.14749328792095184,
-0.4911239445209503,
-0.5930708050727844,
-0.5805332660675049,
-0.4552890658378601,
-0.596104621887207,
-0.14126935601234436,
0.18429112434387207,
0.07796741276979446,
-0.7185905575752258,
0.11766014248132706,
0.3346084952354431,
0.4381961226463318,
0.39788082242012024,
0.7464708685874939,
-0.8759002089500427,
0.4492158889770508,
0.217030867934227,
0.3345329761505127,
0.06179093196988106,
-0.5242496132850647,
-0.17470400035381317,
-0.04900043085217476,
-0.42365342378616333,
-0.8204238414764404,
0.7551754713058472,
0.3947544991970062,
0.2634333074092865,
0.5621012449264526,
-0.043829042464494705,
0.22316841781139374,
-0.5719351172447205,
0.5073838233947754,
0.12023570388555527,
-1.0251305103302002,
0.6607842445373535,
-0.2856423854827881,
0.3084736168384552,
0.5392498970031738,
-0.020308485254645348,
-0.24656668305397034,
-0.3611312210559845,
-0.5096496343612671,
-0.49764665961265564,
0.6514039635658264,
0.4412272870540619,
0.20882058143615723,
0.335512638092041,
0.39762619137763977,
0.03799296170473099,
0.24246947467327118,
-0.9775774478912354,
-0.07766896486282349,
-0.010940947569906712,
-0.7124136090278625,
0.21543069183826447,
-0.3745082914829254,
0.5696828961372375,
-0.23243989050388336,
0.640548586845398,
0.015505527146160603,
0.6147691011428833,
0.051315389573574066,
-0.1879366934299469,
0.05839090049266815,
0.18683476746082306,
0.5145243406295776,
0.19537253677845,
-0.41584938764572144,
-0.3632856607437134,
0.09931416809558868,
-0.7976197600364685,
0.13494759798049927,
0.5105434060096741,
-0.3113432824611664,
0.3329910933971405,
0.6810744404792786,
0.46556559205055237,
-0.5418497920036316,
-0.8389301896095276,
0.6088224649429321,
-0.24025464057922363,
-0.2237207293510437,
-0.4221417307853699,
0.12492624670267105,
-0.31590497493743896,
0.1257169097661972,
0.902446985244751,
0.2571922838687897,
0.3483884930610657,
-0.27248552441596985,
0.2515105605125427,
0.5026938915252686,
-0.1620517522096634,
0.27036550641059875,
0.4387015998363495,
0.29019108414649963,
-0.48870453238487244,
1.0046287775039673,
-0.15535858273506165,
-0.9799787998199463,
1.0330580472946167,
0.5461698770523071,
0.8129197955131531,
-0.21022923290729523,
0.2103518396615982,
-0.004194413311779499,
0.43691033124923706,
0.32557034492492676,
0.33558210730552673,
-0.08210913091897964,
-1.0981744527816772,
-0.2655220031738281,
-0.7139633893966675,
-0.30385997891426086,
0.31473225355148315,
-0.3811633884906769,
0.18420816957950592,
-0.5373249650001526,
-0.165684774518013,
0.12471949309110641,
0.25843486189842224,
-0.5163137316703796,
0.8118021488189697,
0.3482995927333832,
0.9781840443611145,
-0.858521580696106,
0.8811951279640198,
0.4647372364997864,
-0.16482384502887726,
-0.4504587650299072,
0.3907901644706726,
-0.2652137875556946,
-0.7275742888450623,
0.7533127665519714,
0.8833523988723755,
0.09652506560087204,
0.08845904469490051,
-0.7200880646705627,
-0.45821094512939453,
0.8756361603736877,
-0.12928378582000732,
-0.6446192264556885,
0.08108336478471756,
0.08683215826749802,
0.7647364139556885,
-0.30669769644737244,
0.11438500136137009,
0.23815575242042542,
0.4951443076133728,
-0.14496922492980957,
-0.6756256222724915,
-0.22887153923511505,
-0.4784669876098633,
0.07601848244667053,
0.2039986401796341,
-0.34550103545188904,
0.8928039073944092,
0.088145412504673,
-0.12211944162845612,
0.42226895689964294,
0.8448575735092163,
0.15558001399040222,
0.49538907408714294,
0.4542990028858185,
0.5746615529060364,
0.6417070627212524,
-0.15755821764469147,
0.7224560976028442,
0.10320866107940674,
0.4357139468193054,
0.5985079407691956,
-0.25174644589424133,
0.6780767440795898,
-0.12259750813245773,
0.10210549831390381,
0.9224108457565308,
0.8006075620651245,
-0.37686315178871155,
0.668239951133728,
0.058846306055784225,
-0.33541974425315857,
-0.19251148402690887,
-0.10985076427459717,
-0.3282395899295807,
0.4999050498008728,
0.42334794998168945,
-0.87922203540802,
-0.0991639643907547,
0.35344114899635315,
-0.20084883272647858,
0.2477857768535614,
-0.304940789937973,
0.8218827247619629,
-0.412992388010025,
-0.38619884848594666,
0.23951338231563568,
0.2971862554550171,
1.005895972251892,
-0.5213121771812439,
-0.23461611568927765,
0.17279885709285736,
0.5085984468460083,
0.15930750966072083,
-0.87624591588974,
-0.03467617556452751,
0.05505219101905823,
-0.4129522740840912,
-0.3099856376647949,
1.4268200397491455,
-0.25437286496162415,
-0.8605342507362366,
-0.015588643960654736,
0.15966655313968658,
0.05270512402057648,
-0.2536558508872986,
-0.6433461308479309,
0.11702503263950348,
0.11248358339071274,
0.05504673346877098,
-0.06437452882528305,
0.4445435702800751,
0.13516387343406677,
0.4008251130580902,
0.7110335826873779,
-0.041221942752599716,
-0.0634719654917717,
-0.10208630561828613,
0.7217202186584473,
-0.5765479207038879,
-0.8179829716682434,
-0.814910888671875,
0.2436666041612625,
-0.45336371660232544,
-0.21288469433784485,
0.48185214400291443,
0.42714449763298035,
0.4693809449672699,
-0.258573055267334,
1.0309967994689941,
-0.024379752576351166,
0.728694498538971,
-0.4537312090396881,
1.2499949932098389,
-0.2737569510936737,
0.06229379400610924,
-0.49545156955718994,
-0.6802054047584534,
-0.5332504510879517,
0.8689156174659729,
-0.14228391647338867,
0.06621326506137848,
0.34569060802459717,
0.20007386803627014,
0.21414217352867126,
-0.0056159659288823605,
-0.005201739724725485,
-0.2601499557495117,
0.5628381371498108,
0.44025295972824097,
0.4667273759841919,
-0.6691732406616211,
0.6013265252113342,
-0.15161000192165375,
-0.3344770669937134,
-0.4907445013523102,
-0.7297698855400085,
-1.099647045135498,
-0.37234142422676086,
-0.18659017980098724,
0.016423888504505157,
0.09220925718545914,
0.4386571943759918,
0.6580750346183777,
-0.8346796035766602,
0.2184666395187378,
-0.4290333688259125,
0.07455382496118546,
-0.3074924647808075,
-0.3505209684371948,
0.6694202423095703,
-0.4460902512073517,
-0.9184715747833252,
0.13376103341579437,
-0.009772172197699547,
0.26540541648864746,
0.04845859482884407,
0.09674561023712158,
-0.6759786605834961,
0.054038483649492264,
0.6422172784805298,
-0.09974248707294464,
-0.4765591025352478,
-0.32008877396583557,
-0.08922608196735382,
-0.2189188003540039,
-0.1445271521806717,
0.3953738212585449,
-0.9002397060394287,
0.6380684971809387,
0.5632430911064148,
0.8652793765068054,
0.3314179480075836,
0.13184259831905365,
0.31924569606781006,
-0.8478891253471375,
0.13313351571559906,
0.43982744216918945,
0.1288859248161316,
0.227644681930542,
-0.6190701723098755,
0.22983229160308838,
0.2018398940563202,
-0.6280530095100403,
-0.7273926138877869,
0.028228390961885452,
-0.6221384406089783,
-0.4003892242908478,
0.5014670491218567,
-0.1150357648730278,
-0.11575726419687271,
-0.006384954322129488,
-0.5546218752861023,
0.607403576374054,
-0.5281246900558472,
1.0132399797439575,
0.5693272352218628,
-0.3666810691356659,
-0.30925890803337097,
0.010596321895718575,
0.2673337757587433,
0.42688754200935364,
-0.9995396733283997,
-0.4238608777523041,
0.4673667848110199,
0.05761722847819328,
0.47009456157684326,
0.4327082335948944,
0.36763831973075867,
0.3346779942512512,
-0.3236508369445801,
0.28592854738235474,
-0.05144766345620155,
-0.2992432713508606,
-0.11312055587768555,
0.16737040877342224,
-0.22177043557167053,
-0.663582980632782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16420v1
|
M-RAG: Reinforcing Large Language Model Performance through Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Multiple Partitions
| 2024-05-26T04:03:13 | 2024-05-26T04:03:13 |
Zheng Wang, Shu Xian Teo, Jieer Ouyang, Yongjun Xu, Wei Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) enhances Large Language Models (LLMs) by
retrieving relevant memories from an external database. However, existing RAG
methods typically organize all memories in a whole database, potentially
limiting focus on crucial memories and introducing noise. In this paper, we
introduce a multiple partition paradigm for RAG (called M-RAG), where each
database partition serves as a basic unit for RAG execution. Based on this
paradigm, we propose a novel framework that leverages LLMs with Multi-Agent
Reinforcement Learning to optimize different language generation tasks
explicitly. Through comprehensive experiments conducted on seven datasets,
spanning three language generation tasks and involving three distinct language
model architectures, we confirm that M-RAG consistently outperforms various
baseline methods, achieving improvements of 11%, 8%, and 12% for text
summarization, machine translation, and dialogue generation, respectively.
|
[
-0.5189490914344788,
-0.6275075674057007,
0.5668671131134033,
0.2901831269264221,
-0.06755902618169785,
0.5733465552330017,
-0.269418329000473,
0.04912322759628296,
0.4154987037181854,
0.6722555756568909,
-0.5941305756568909,
-0.12082564830780029,
-0.32546094059944153,
-0.0036313922610133886,
-0.0744282677769661,
1.1028847694396973,
0.1615382730960846,
0.0004166043072473258,
-0.20173625648021698,
-0.277776837348938,
-0.38751357793807983,
-0.45518743991851807,
-0.8184796571731567,
-0.31855127215385437,
0.889068603515625,
0.4966503083705902,
0.47891005873680115,
0.6314908266067505,
0.12039325386285782,
0.4313858449459076,
0.07121261954307556,
0.8025773763656616,
-0.493004709482193,
0.6423822045326233,
-0.021130528301000595,
-0.3234732747077942,
-0.4450652003288269,
-0.12479711323976517,
0.9979519844055176,
0.1555379033088684,
-0.4520344138145447,
0.06191040202975273,
-0.1964416354894638,
0.7630388736724854,
-0.9484626054763794,
-0.032107140868902206,
-0.6525946855545044,
-0.2817125916481018,
-0.17124755680561066,
-0.31600257754325867,
-0.8328022956848145,
-0.2237151712179184,
-0.17843031883239746,
-0.48184964060783386,
0.09638015925884247,
0.2812683880329132,
0.6099855303764343,
0.2220698446035385,
-0.625311553478241,
-0.15894083678722382,
-0.7326585650444031,
1.0375645160675049,
-0.4528134763240814,
0.40960413217544556,
0.12694686651229858,
0.5120826363563538,
-0.3084273934364319,
-0.4615932106971741,
-0.6949912309646606,
-0.2547348737716675,
0.035385023802518845,
-0.0679437518119812,
0.19412016868591309,
-0.06329025328159332,
0.1651782989501953,
0.15346793830394745,
-0.47496098279953003,
0.0006868201890029013,
-0.17706957459449768,
-0.015482024289667606,
0.6096286177635193,
0.384360671043396,
0.12820906937122345,
-0.1980658620595932,
-0.4854865074157715,
-0.4577803611755371,
-0.6970030665397644,
-0.23599644005298615,
0.3713606894016266,
0.5279932618141174,
0.2076452672481537,
0.4936876893043518,
0.033131130039691925,
0.6152122616767883,
-0.05766329541802406,
-0.7531092166900635,
0.4522281587123871,
-0.2763136327266693,
0.019183456897735596,
-0.10970218479633331,
0.7530020475387573,
0.00676534790545702,
-0.24717667698860168,
-0.15061426162719727,
-0.4660583436489105,
-0.10979529470205307,
0.6031182408332825,
-0.9320215582847595,
0.10209959745407104,
0.10193619877099991,
-0.25455668568611145,
-0.32348352670669556,
-0.30957096815109253,
-0.7674717903137207,
-0.47312548756599426,
-0.2794661521911621,
0.297135591506958,
-0.5062716007232666,
-0.5715198516845703,
-0.2509136497974396,
-0.26066839694976807,
0.2637515068054199,
0.241986945271492,
-0.8299775123596191,
0.3129577338695526,
0.7974662184715271,
0.6085917949676514,
-0.23599307239055634,
-0.5389347076416016,
-0.8401507139205933,
0.37998512387275696,
-0.5051229596138,
0.9644220471382141,
-0.5949392914772034,
-0.3533332347869873,
-0.08772075921297073,
-0.1211404874920845,
-0.17364501953125,
-0.6647666096687317,
0.3140787184238434,
-0.702945351600647,
0.16658243536949158,
-0.18396876752376556,
-0.3613331615924835,
-0.1363835334777832,
0.3555406332015991,
-0.8078376054763794,
1.0076156854629517,
0.14397697150707245,
-0.4336967170238495,
0.3865053057670593,
-0.3903457820415497,
-0.43297693133354187,
-0.18721996247768402,
-0.3192287087440491,
-0.6936744451522827,
0.2484416365623474,
0.19688451290130615,
0.29924726486206055,
-0.5840717554092407,
0.22156448662281036,
-0.17889352142810822,
-0.04093841463327408,
0.3593319058418274,
-0.37132394313812256,
0.34211188554763794,
0.3748818635940552,
0.07912933081388474,
0.16999666392803192,
-0.7800630331039429,
0.02212403528392315,
0.19234924018383026,
-0.7348387837409973,
-0.36000069975852966,
0.10123350471258163,
-0.07306314259767532,
0.3524453043937683,
0.13856491446495056,
-0.4685089588165283,
0.3371645510196686,
-0.3764185905456543,
-0.15150652825832367,
0.6927818059921265,
0.13321654498577118,
0.6947294473648071,
-0.6694677472114563,
0.6817770004272461,
0.19841551780700684,
-0.1864369958639145,
-0.5283851623535156,
-0.1663087010383606,
-0.6612653136253357,
-0.539219081401825,
0.24109183251857758,
0.34746214747428894,
-1.2367279529571533,
-0.19589543342590332,
-0.23316797614097595,
-0.2940217852592468,
-0.5959916710853577,
-0.000972687965258956,
0.7488665580749512,
0.2092622071504593,
0.3034813404083252,
-0.16524213552474976,
-0.5774033665657043,
-0.8109440803527832,
-0.19617420434951782,
-0.07983531802892685,
0.11296997219324112,
0.5994004607200623,
0.24476222693920135,
-0.3201225697994232,
0.6558552980422974,
-0.43914148211479187,
-0.09950901567935944,
-0.4095109701156616,
0.30273523926734924,
0.08761737495660782,
0.3722553849220276,
0.3292171061038971,
-0.8177152872085571,
-0.44905292987823486,
-0.10794416815042496,
-0.32636407017707825,
0.10922545194625854,
-0.1724783480167389,
-0.10924333333969116,
0.6877695322036743,
0.34782880544662476,
-0.555088222026825,
-0.02067193016409874,
0.723680317401886,
-0.1441153734922409,
0.8251411318778992,
-0.49607259035110474,
0.17741060256958008,
-1.3844422101974487,
-0.25377213954925537,
-0.28505271673202515,
-0.23965461552143097,
-0.6856364011764526,
0.15506620705127716,
0.08680402487516403,
0.041412353515625,
-0.4815237522125244,
0.7123042345046997,
-0.6473375558853149,
-0.3538886308670044,
-0.6957064867019653,
0.14654281735420227,
0.1090538501739502,
0.517365574836731,
-0.26880159974098206,
0.9772475361824036,
0.15134595334529877,
-0.7773982286453247,
0.03924749791622162,
0.06652954965829849,
-0.10833290964365005,
0.48478370904922485,
-0.08451786637306213,
0.21659177541732788,
-0.41620221734046936,
0.41162109375,
-0.816486120223999,
-0.19361889362335205,
-0.07776511460542679,
-0.5132766366004944,
0.7077508568763733,
-0.07692072540521622,
-0.48968377709388733,
-0.017464017495512962,
-0.3791034519672394,
0.45959845185279846,
0.4245922863483429,
-0.6523768305778503,
1.0242072343826294,
0.6525087952613831,
-0.06828517466783524,
-0.955890417098999,
-0.14594921469688416,
-0.049498870968818665,
-0.2753089666366577,
-0.6274418830871582,
0.2888696789741516,
0.12035589665174484,
-0.24031975865364075,
0.017591752111911774,
-0.028442759066820145,
0.018815988674759865,
-0.021181249991059303,
0.05740983039140701,
0.07009447365999222,
-0.24308983981609344,
0.39800915122032166,
0.0757841020822525,
-0.2278880476951599,
-0.3496426045894623,
-0.17029494047164917,
0.8705543279647827,
0.02330879122018814,
-0.04186348244547844,
0.4061608910560608,
0.37473589181900024,
0.3998332917690277,
-0.5564877986907959,
1.0225731134414673,
0.6698941588401794,
-0.0011735493317246437,
-0.6591022610664368,
-0.6015956401824951,
0.010526590049266815,
-0.47660696506500244,
0.38245323300361633,
-0.7231745719909668,
-1.0584169626235962,
0.32406875491142273,
-0.43876808881759644,
0.2621789276599884,
0.3982488811016083,
0.8702459931373596,
0.024546196684241295,
1.1414307355880737,
0.5162484645843506,
-0.06586810201406479,
0.4929603636264801,
-0.23452071845531464,
0.06871743500232697,
-1.1728800535202026,
-0.027167243883013725,
-0.5426928997039795,
-0.12838688492774963,
-0.8736916780471802,
-0.9605668187141418,
0.4581950306892395,
-0.05354179069399834,
-0.36100292205810547,
0.039268188178539276,
-0.14401444792747498,
0.5394344329833984,
0.6517268419265747,
-0.05930253863334656,
0.28183597326278687,
0.00007824835483916104,
-0.3139667510986328,
0.18748794496059418,
-0.7460275292396545,
-0.48059558868408203,
1.152358889579773,
0.1091868132352829,
0.694409966468811,
0.4010501801967621,
1.1236746311187744,
-0.022539297118782997,
0.4071275293827057,
-0.6190811395645142,
0.5112094879150391,
-0.2899714410305023,
-0.7224553823471069,
-0.4639953672885895,
-0.6678658127784729,
-1.2427623271942139,
0.8978231549263,
-0.3190111219882965,
-0.40085098147392273,
-0.07352055609226227,
-0.019450901076197624,
-0.1765059232711792,
0.1974973827600479,
-0.5136192440986633,
0.5560720562934875,
-0.22017528116703033,
-0.31635597348213196,
-0.5357272028923035,
-0.3000718951225281,
0.6977089047431946,
-0.22601214051246643,
0.4968893527984619,
-0.17718090116977692,
-0.3011506497859955,
0.5126469135284424,
-0.34926509857177734,
0.3657776117324829,
-0.2836966812610626,
0.03731529414653778,
0.25222936272621155,
0.162617027759552,
0.6439737677574158,
-0.18003006279468536,
0.07909780740737915,
-0.5626790523529053,
-0.307889461517334,
-0.3124931752681732,
-0.6014897227287292,
0.7081529498100281,
-0.6899210810661316,
-0.4471845030784607,
-0.35340821743011475,
-0.7971147298812866,
-0.257799357175827,
0.11632833629846573,
-0.3007110357284546,
0.46344003081321716,
-0.2700219750404358,
0.10677529126405716,
0.6978199481964111,
-0.6533097624778748,
0.4197808802127838,
0.7395113706588745,
-0.6296393275260925,
-0.6700139045715332,
1.4334163665771484,
-0.03883375599980354,
0.19920426607131958,
0.33871039748191833,
0.22302275896072388,
-0.297855943441391,
-0.27617979049682617,
-0.5955040454864502,
0.42013445496559143,
-0.4311898350715637,
-0.2635481059551239,
-0.8867767453193665,
0.013502024114131927,
-0.32359007000923157,
0.09827253967523575,
-0.6088559627532959,
-0.4375247061252594,
0.17273485660552979,
0.06172780692577362,
0.16794756054878235,
0.7181805372238159,
-0.26025718450546265,
0.4745827615261078,
-0.9001795053482056,
0.6824275851249695,
0.21904528141021729,
0.2699509561061859,
0.02914794161915779,
-0.2897833585739136,
-0.4830071032047272,
-0.1093972846865654,
-0.47960779070854187,
-0.8970409631729126,
0.5840904712677002,
0.21651895344257355,
0.5778676271438599,
0.0440332293510437,
-0.15093325078487396,
0.48847129940986633,
-1.0436891317367554,
0.4663906395435333,
0.09857477992773056,
-0.4616747498512268,
0.1399988830089569,
-0.361117422580719,
0.2557307183742523,
0.3658045530319214,
0.14740027487277985,
-0.3988945186138153,
-0.5737587213516235,
-0.7348333597183228,
-1.0074905157089233,
0.8141885995864868,
-0.18993030488491058,
0.00968489982187748,
-0.11716482043266296,
0.030208725482225418,
-0.028562067076563835,
0.38261812925338745,
-0.4810490310192108,
-0.34304162859916687,
0.2561973035335541,
0.06333929300308228,
-0.4424949586391449,
-0.36516791582107544,
-0.02119736559689045,
0.1778825968503952,
0.8744859099388123,
-0.17137117683887482,
0.2417251169681549,
-0.28133276104927063,
-0.16882260143756866,
-0.03349050506949425,
0.45057550072669983,
0.6821190118789673,
0.5175778865814209,
0.07262640446424484,
0.01467688474804163,
0.06483183056116104,
-0.17811746895313263,
0.5363622903823853,
0.029375426471233368,
-0.12688793241977692,
0.11082777380943298,
-0.011283495463430882,
0.9006316065788269,
0.2377309948205948,
-0.5774512887001038,
0.3315323293209076,
-0.18751944601535797,
-0.21455876529216766,
-0.3253139853477478,
0.09875930100679398,
0.18499471247196198,
0.6374945044517517,
0.46561485528945923,
-0.061830200254917145,
0.10832060128450394,
-0.44513222575187683,
0.47149914503097534,
0.5017389059066772,
0.23240412771701813,
0.05413700267672539,
0.5314072966575623,
-0.12146123498678207,
-0.24481201171875,
0.4391539990901947,
-0.54417884349823,
-0.4858429729938507,
0.4232160747051239,
0.6336373686790466,
0.9360975027084351,
-0.5033589601516724,
0.3808312714099884,
0.4582964777946472,
0.30621081590652466,
-0.2304774820804596,
0.3365110158920288,
0.034547802060842514,
-0.8463248014450073,
-0.9732145071029663,
-0.9848909378051758,
-0.6031097769737244,
-0.11547935009002686,
-0.3825322985649109,
-0.05452439934015274,
-0.2094172090291977,
-0.1668999046087265,
-0.11911995708942413,
0.12455478310585022,
-0.3851830065250397,
0.10308627039194107,
0.16977231204509735,
0.5187203884124756,
-0.6144903302192688,
1.041136384010315,
0.5684190392494202,
-0.4111206829547882,
-0.9422434568405151,
-0.09876993298530579,
0.06761550903320312,
-0.664340615272522,
0.5489798784255981,
-0.0090388935059309,
-0.20263740420341492,
-0.06471459567546844,
-0.17399029433727264,
-1.106799840927124,
0.894011914730072,
0.27804556488990784,
-0.26984938979148865,
0.08681640028953552,
-0.033990759402513504,
0.3937632143497467,
-0.5717903971672058,
0.22343659400939941,
0.5696750283241272,
0.4186660945415497,
0.2555776536464691,
-0.7019296884536743,
-0.10751914978027344,
0.01246578898280859,
0.19548752903938293,
0.6825218796730042,
-0.7128236889839172,
1.1534359455108643,
-0.2554766535758972,
-0.14155039191246033,
-0.03611472249031067,
0.7298163771629333,
1.0603715181350708,
0.16579607129096985,
0.5913823246955872,
0.7186810374259949,
0.7122522592544556,
0.09947211295366287,
1.1475505828857422,
-0.158950537443161,
0.023062091320753098,
1.3868498802185059,
-0.22441525757312775,
0.9835805892944336,
0.330227792263031,
-0.03212469816207886,
0.5443645715713501,
0.15529730916023254,
0.4001001715660095,
0.5272118449211121,
0.32478880882263184,
-0.4542495012283325,
-0.06298026442527771,
-0.15893778204917908,
-0.17154057323932648,
0.5084081888198853,
0.44817879796028137,
-0.226119726896286,
-0.2602396011352539,
0.1039155051112175,
0.15631398558616638,
-0.03515690565109253,
-0.08634211868047714,
1.1498068571090698,
0.004240209702402353,
-0.8531212210655212,
0.5894349813461304,
0.23502172529697418,
0.5738266110420227,
-0.4672921299934387,
-0.22414487600326538,
-0.2709389328956604,
0.3546656668186188,
0.0826072245836258,
-0.29752692580223083,
0.1876574456691742,
-0.0305776409804821,
-0.37905022501945496,
-0.4038236737251282,
0.7929860949516296,
-0.6686690449714661,
-0.35183000564575195,
0.1875683069229126,
0.8444820642471313,
0.1675892472267151,
-0.0030350838787853718,
-0.5437746047973633,
0.19193804264068604,
-0.149677574634552,
-0.5325935482978821,
0.7061337232589722,
0.7242083549499512,
-0.00014660322631243616,
0.6946343183517456,
0.6546555161476135,
0.12349250167608261,
0.37400022149086,
0.07908660173416138,
0.955601155757904,
-0.6536664366722107,
-0.4419674873352051,
-0.7221812009811401,
0.5333344340324402,
-0.06998065114021301,
0.0967511460185051,
0.7862125039100647,
0.7072285413742065,
0.7866884469985962,
0.04460093379020691,
0.6415969729423523,
-0.05378048121929169,
1.0046573877334595,
-0.3961527347564697,
0.5015300512313843,
-0.733587384223938,
0.13904309272766113,
-0.20263665914535522,
-1.0110443830490112,
-0.022342026233673096,
0.35884371399879456,
-0.01869087852537632,
0.09582004696130753,
0.641339123249054,
0.8917104601860046,
0.2851286828517914,
-0.37008386850357056,
0.4185176491737366,
0.10169195383787155,
0.5461874008178711,
0.3856699764728546,
1.0259507894515991,
-0.27912312746047974,
0.5068073868751526,
-0.10242535918951035,
-0.054550204426050186,
-0.032391507178545,
-0.6240320205688477,
-0.6582044959068298,
-0.7679151892662048,
0.12412548810243607,
-0.37715426087379456,
-0.0450495220720768,
0.9446179270744324,
0.5043880939483643,
-0.45479080080986023,
-0.5176485776901245,
0.4179507791996002,
0.19875192642211914,
-0.046558912843465805,
-0.16093237698078156,
0.15800155699253082,
-0.9736503958702087,
-0.7491158843040466,
0.770355761051178,
0.2143835723400116,
-0.3156014680862427,
-0.39001786708831787,
-0.48001164197921753,
-0.42148929834365845,
0.12026791274547577,
0.8191958665847778,
0.21224334836006165,
-0.5204945206642151,
0.13393856585025787,
-0.22499868273735046,
-0.22260381281375885,
0.05238776654005051,
0.9024680852890015,
-0.8970034718513489,
0.4534590244293213,
0.44999924302101135,
0.9664376378059387,
0.8662986159324646,
0.1003221943974495,
0.6817516684532166,
-1.0570861101150513,
0.24680043756961823,
0.2912016808986664,
0.2573193907737732,
0.19991104304790497,
0.0933111310005188,
0.46301373839378357,
-0.2516297996044159,
-0.7998314499855042,
-0.9064359664916992,
0.23105627298355103,
-0.48078277707099915,
-0.5076361298561096,
1.1409969329833984,
0.14164681732654572,
-0.3881889879703522,
0.07887601107358932,
-0.2173922061920166,
0.3027363717556,
-0.5601744055747986,
0.3940443694591522,
0.3716067373752594,
-0.08754829317331314,
-0.39977365732192993,
-0.7352285385131836,
0.6485036015510559,
0.3092712461948395,
-0.7145640850067139,
0.021680250763893127,
0.8992270827293396,
-0.15835827589035034,
0.25598838925361633,
0.9539898633956909,
-0.008770790882408619,
0.19877703487873077,
0.11698619276285172,
0.21871720254421234,
0.006475691683590412,
-0.7686598300933838,
-0.19186626374721527,
0.1947341412305832,
0.2741258442401886,
-0.14634472131729126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17503v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17503v2
|
Code Repair with LLMs gives an Exploration-Exploitation Tradeoff
| 2024-05-26T04:00:30 | 2024-05-30T15:20:19 |
Hao Tang, Keya Hu, Jin Peng Zhou, Sicheng Zhong, Wei-Long Zheng, Xujie Si, Kevin Ellis
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Iteratively improving and repairing source code with large language models
(LLMs), known as refinement, has emerged as a popular way of generating
programs that would be too complex to construct in one shot. Given a bank of
test cases, together with a candidate program, an LLM can improve that program
by being prompted with failed test cases. But it remains an open question how
to best iteratively refine code, with prior work employing simple greedy or
breadth-first strategies. We show here that refinement exposes an
explore-exploit tradeoff: exploit by refining the program that passes the most
test cases, or explore by refining a lesser considered program. We frame this
as an arm-acquiring bandit problem, which we solve with Thompson Sampling. The
resulting LLM-based program synthesis algorithm is broadly applicable: Across
loop invariant synthesis, visual reasoning puzzles, and competition programming
problems, we find that our new method can solve more problems using fewer
language model calls.
|
[
-0.16113004088401794,
-0.4305132329463959,
0.6688550710678101,
-0.1895275115966797,
-0.05148790031671524,
0.5238903164863586,
-0.2270916849374771,
-0.4413753151893616,
0.3449915647506714,
0.9696434140205383,
-0.7072551846504211,
-0.37486666440963745,
-0.521464467048645,
-0.03948768600821495,
-0.3890467882156372,
1.018093228340149,
-0.4431122839450836,
-0.3934918940067291,
0.17193402349948883,
-0.07113337516784668,
-0.40545570850372314,
-0.13709524273872375,
-0.8133590817451477,
-0.10909414291381836,
0.3442704677581787,
0.687069296836853,
0.45017001032829285,
0.6552061438560486,
0.5534300804138184,
0.33673274517059326,
0.11812946200370789,
0.15635214745998383,
-0.9678122997283936,
0.12074945867061615,
0.06269984692335129,
-0.8425624966621399,
0.08687791228294373,
-0.0646500512957573,
0.2048071026802063,
0.40505269169807434,
-0.1802966147661209,
0.09235790371894836,
-0.15719746053218842,
0.9690518379211426,
-0.6721940040588379,
-0.14774584770202637,
-0.8911251425743103,
-0.15908628702163696,
-0.06894507259130478,
-0.5732950568199158,
-0.4126357436180115,
-0.4494369924068451,
-0.00012008536577923223,
-0.3624382019042969,
0.24991799890995026,
-0.10505982488393784,
0.7221855521202087,
0.42327266931533813,
-0.061551984399557114,
-0.03682040423154831,
-0.8123296499252319,
1.036523461341858,
-0.6738056540489197,
-0.17988726496696472,
0.0983271524310112,
0.3480721116065979,
-0.45666688680648804,
-0.6242201328277588,
-0.10230924189090729,
-0.4456506073474884,
0.010083111934363842,
-0.1504898965358734,
-0.42590269446372986,
0.012257593683898449,
0.46552401781082153,
0.3892928659915924,
-0.27642783522605896,
0.029739702120423317,
-1.0420869588851929,
-0.322106271982193,
0.8559272885322571,
0.10734838992357254,
0.25553831458091736,
0.1003570631146431,
-0.5777581334114075,
-0.050714947283267975,
-1.3555235862731934,
0.11370893567800522,
0.5083608031272888,
0.2430613487958908,
0.403624564409256,
0.6966695189476013,
-0.07891310751438141,
0.8457026481628418,
-0.3532406687736511,
-0.09936333447694778,
-0.03927059471607208,
-0.11853833496570587,
-0.4452913701534271,
-0.09163931757211685,
0.021726880222558975,
0.37844619154930115,
0.3071784973144531,
-0.16294045746326447,
-0.5469222068786621,
0.02293313480913639,
0.7766821384429932,
-0.40075457096099854,
-0.2313060611486435,
0.4797646999359131,
-0.4161899983882904,
-0.2792721390724182,
0.014500766061246395,
-0.29527124762535095,
-0.2066918909549713,
-0.3360665440559387,
0.3377332091331482,
-0.3459555506706238,
-0.20999804139137268,
0.21546387672424316,
-0.4663878083229065,
0.4471021294593811,
0.2666632831096649,
-0.4626636505126953,
-0.16324245929718018,
0.6864963173866272,
0.578594446182251,
0.15417633950710297,
-0.33217644691467285,
-0.7484416365623474,
0.1259928196668625,
-0.5314900279045105,
0.9502735733985901,
-0.43627849221229553,
-0.5940690040588379,
0.07725338637828827,
-0.07528822124004364,
0.2312362939119339,
-0.9594451785087585,
0.3553055226802826,
-0.6405749320983887,
-0.07061316817998886,
-0.30230987071990967,
-0.44447365403175354,
-0.06441070139408112,
0.4601620137691498,
-0.752900242805481,
0.8264777064323425,
0.3915443420410156,
-0.6143563389778137,
0.2518535554409027,
-0.47896885871887207,
-0.39532071352005005,
-0.25299543142318726,
0.0661713033914566,
-0.4594670832157135,
0.3408844470977783,
0.20807220041751862,
0.12674270570278168,
-0.16338060796260834,
-0.12724216282367706,
-0.31888461112976074,
-0.9057379961013794,
0.3711215555667877,
0.10198163241147995,
0.5818966627120972,
0.292125403881073,
-0.26810598373413086,
0.15702810883522034,
-0.469804972410202,
0.15907728672027588,
0.1850622594356537,
-0.668157160282135,
-0.24358081817626953,
0.05305655673146248,
-0.36921870708465576,
-0.20995724201202393,
0.0828915387392044,
-0.4287113547325134,
0.48298779129981995,
-0.7004151940345764,
0.5724815130233765,
0.9522683024406433,
-0.04857267439365387,
0.4335891306400299,
-0.7534228563308716,
0.8407583236694336,
-0.32286500930786133,
-0.04969820752739906,
-0.5890676975250244,
-0.034179896116256714,
-1.050009846687317,
-0.4616645872592926,
0.15335305035114288,
0.4999421238899231,
-0.982842743396759,
-0.0927884504199028,
-0.03586696460843086,
-0.40590888261795044,
-0.7794601321220398,
0.17447036504745483,
0.35047754645347595,
0.1657383143901825,
0.30832552909851074,
-0.33764347434043884,
-0.7071335911750793,
-0.98238605260849,
-0.7179423570632935,
-0.12761898338794708,
-0.1547045260667801,
0.21120329201221466,
0.0052445377223193645,
-0.5866797566413879,
0.7330981492996216,
-0.6649985313415527,
-0.2863585352897644,
-0.3939194679260254,
-0.08525487780570984,
0.35984233021736145,
0.3407585322856903,
0.27342942357063293,
-0.1519346386194229,
-0.32179293036460876,
-0.2932742238044739,
-0.19315873086452484,
-0.16229088604450226,
-0.31208229064941406,
-0.075741246342659,
0.3139198124408722,
0.9342724680900574,
-0.2271692305803299,
0.3829365074634552,
0.4830990433692932,
0.11831603199243546,
0.3882664442062378,
-0.24099168181419373,
0.14645269513130188,
-0.6919716000556946,
0.1491592824459076,
-0.27397990226745605,
-0.2657775580883026,
-0.31658899784088135,
0.7059348225593567,
-0.13725070655345917,
-0.08911911398172379,
-0.3638518750667572,
0.3167164921760559,
-0.6488977670669556,
-0.10206188261508942,
-0.5480029582977295,
0.20875589549541473,
-0.2948008179664612,
0.23161742091178894,
-0.17764140665531158,
0.6845199465751648,
0.5214438438415527,
-0.37787577509880066,
0.3542059063911438,
-0.3773738443851471,
-0.21136146783828735,
0.1373547911643982,
-0.6772125363349915,
0.36590129137039185,
-0.23016904294490814,
0.03476829081773758,
-1.3508857488632202,
-0.03664090856909752,
0.032087624073028564,
-0.29273706674575806,
0.5132386088371277,
-0.3895867168903351,
0.03528132662177086,
-0.35690101981163025,
-0.8351787328720093,
0.23790879547595978,
0.6731331944465637,
-0.7106680274009705,
0.46498581767082214,
0.22828471660614014,
-0.1372392475605011,
-0.7918457388877869,
-0.7187075614929199,
0.11369232088327408,
-0.343657523393631,
-0.8057974576950073,
0.3536805510520935,
0.02554064430296421,
-0.3723035752773285,
0.012668369337916374,
-0.3112388551235199,
0.04552002251148224,
0.22208528220653534,
0.11226484179496765,
0.4154893457889557,
0.061859454959630966,
-0.1763450801372528,
0.034645311534404755,
-0.49518364667892456,
0.07018475979566574,
-0.21091538667678833,
0.3925275206565857,
0.21298329532146454,
-0.5373439192771912,
0.3188892900943756,
0.311475932598114,
0.3412654399871826,
-0.22003935277462006,
-0.13872627913951874,
0.1105676218867302,
-0.04388951510190964,
-0.5604231953620911,
-0.6269955039024353,
-0.24160006642341614,
-0.4811514616012573,
0.3104214072227478,
-0.2605322003364563,
-1.1753162145614624,
0.3940702974796295,
-0.4558304250240326,
0.4672970175743103,
0.3359471559524536,
0.38776522874832153,
0.01768381893634796,
0.5327571630477905,
0.9078690409660339,
-0.31930282711982727,
0.4211845099925995,
-0.4023304283618927,
0.3859226405620575,
-0.7229585647583008,
0.04394645616412163,
-0.5296808481216431,
-0.6059770584106445,
-0.5338228344917297,
-0.45507845282554626,
0.4157247841358185,
-0.11713547259569168,
-0.03790163993835449,
0.6556475758552551,
-0.6304037570953369,
0.891761302947998,
0.9437873959541321,
0.2677582800388336,
0.3666931688785553,
0.28197282552719116,
0.06571327149868011,
-0.1525096893310547,
-0.5759271383285522,
-0.41960400342941284,
1.3682223558425903,
0.2933466136455536,
0.9522473216056824,
0.15367400646209717,
1.3395216464996338,
0.07112232595682144,
0.7220416069030762,
-0.7064993381500244,
0.4028414189815521,
0.06532585620880127,
-0.47456520795822144,
-0.19090603291988373,
-0.391951322555542,
-1.1410913467407227,
-0.19253909587860107,
0.05756015703082085,
-0.6372026205062866,
-0.1319345384836197,
0.3072098195552826,
-0.6083979606628418,
0.15656018257141113,
-0.8092116713523865,
0.557568371295929,
0.03647273778915405,
-0.35768383741378784,
-0.4561362862586975,
-0.4929893910884857,
0.8461389541625977,
-0.0012532253749668598,
0.18093152344226837,
0.18569038808345795,
0.052319079637527466,
0.32655200362205505,
-0.5881214737892151,
0.5806732773780823,
-0.07061801105737686,
-0.24183334410190582,
0.621644914150238,
0.5223737955093384,
0.6382465958595276,
0.03200497850775719,
0.18926627933979034,
-0.29986414313316345,
-0.06637851893901825,
-0.5640835762023926,
-0.3719785511493683,
0.7877770066261292,
-0.4920160174369812,
-0.9083433151245117,
-0.3271736204624176,
-0.36134400963783264,
-0.12047166377305984,
-0.13563773036003113,
0.14580407738685608,
0.034682031720876694,
-0.06400128453969955,
-0.2466888576745987,
0.624226987361908,
-0.4453059136867523,
0.5243672132492065,
0.44894829392433167,
-0.32576820254325867,
-0.16109047830104828,
0.7079950571060181,
-0.27668100595474243,
0.35656264424324036,
0.19600573182106018,
-0.15793123841285706,
0.15516512095928192,
-0.62760329246521,
-0.19595561921596527,
0.2893422544002533,
-0.5731375217437744,
-0.5599496364593506,
-0.09239430725574493,
-0.24513311684131622,
0.1872449368238449,
-0.6093417406082153,
-0.36453136801719666,
-0.24234609305858612,
0.01232486218214035,
-0.09087150543928146,
0.34479182958602905,
0.5327931642532349,
-0.21701864898204803,
0.26354238390922546,
-1.0465713739395142,
0.2359035611152649,
0.40971213579177856,
0.3700414299964905,
-0.23600749671459198,
-0.519547164440155,
-0.20043903589248657,
-0.07639344036579132,
-0.30261939764022827,
-0.7131099104881287,
0.3722178637981415,
-0.3617854714393616,
0.43682605028152466,
0.11036841571331024,
-0.14132241904735565,
0.6662278175354004,
-0.46051356196403503,
0.6748161315917969,
0.14375199377536774,
-0.8244279026985168,
0.6375066041946411,
-0.15483103692531586,
0.23228400945663452,
0.5925591588020325,
0.1548951119184494,
-0.4390363097190857,
-0.4949021339416504,
-0.7007192373275757,
-1.024827003479004,
0.5898561477661133,
-0.055806223303079605,
0.16062961518764496,
0.15354546904563904,
0.5129880309104919,
-0.07904649525880814,
0.000985031365416944,
-0.6750863194465637,
0.029584303498268127,
0.35805195569992065,
0.18213142454624176,
0.041839659214019775,
-0.34023407101631165,
-0.5252244472503662,
0.15233390033245087,
0.6691957712173462,
-0.11473030596971512,
0.38027483224868774,
0.13616685569286346,
-0.11609407514333725,
-0.31380677223205566,
0.34473657608032227,
0.43064257502555847,
0.6596611142158508,
-0.19018247723579407,
0.09299032390117645,
-0.15551647543907166,
-0.039347801357507706,
0.04287261515855789,
0.2850731611251831,
-0.12887541949748993,
-0.2456730753183365,
0.5147473216056824,
0.30811795592308044,
0.03374006226658821,
-1.3426077365875244,
0.2994847893714905,
0.11276798695325851,
-0.09598568081855774,
-0.16911694407463074,
0.4465148150920868,
0.0788557156920433,
0.5951589941978455,
0.378347247838974,
0.27087289094924927,
0.26011011004447937,
-0.7470806837081909,
0.28387650847435,
0.6183249950408936,
-0.10372286289930344,
0.19317202270030975,
0.3584698736667633,
0.1154475063085556,
-0.26666656136512756,
0.79603111743927,
-0.14590109884738922,
-0.5766207575798035,
0.754558801651001,
0.2184448093175888,
0.9062116146087646,
-0.0967002734541893,
0.07088879495859146,
0.4509333074092865,
0.6724521517753601,
-0.136001318693161,
0.6005153059959412,
0.23544557392597198,
-0.5544207692146301,
-0.8144528269767761,
-0.1769436150789261,
-0.3430648446083069,
-0.12763333320617676,
-0.3166140019893646,
0.41798728704452515,
-0.507215678691864,
0.08976663649082184,
-0.4104567766189575,
-0.09845083206892014,
-0.381182461977005,
-0.05703028291463852,
-0.1374870240688324,
0.9358943700790405,
-0.4247857332229614,
0.5484485030174255,
0.5147616267204285,
-0.19610343873500824,
-0.8540327548980713,
-0.013326156884431839,
-0.054472822695970535,
-1.0661535263061523,
0.47071802616119385,
0.10585861653089523,
0.04970286786556244,
-0.13394656777381897,
-0.7885964512825012,
-0.9706286787986755,
0.9351824522018433,
0.5452371835708618,
-0.867789089679718,
0.29961511492729187,
-0.1961389183998108,
0.29266786575317383,
-0.08732279390096664,
0.11275710165500641,
0.8424308896064758,
0.40992435812950134,
0.2325717657804489,
-0.7721109986305237,
0.048274364322423935,
-0.030778776854276657,
0.14602820575237274,
0.5402058959007263,
-0.509053111076355,
0.5922502279281616,
-0.9063066244125366,
-0.21278493106365204,
0.22996719181537628,
0.28214552998542786,
0.6860931515693665,
0.12102707475423813,
0.4678991138935089,
0.761239230632782,
0.5686174631118774,
-0.24633033573627472,
1.301559329032898,
-0.23611369729042053,
0.2843804955482483,
0.9557563662528992,
-0.18292030692100525,
0.7315114736557007,
0.5958468317985535,
-0.45709702372550964,
0.4052121937274933,
0.7116535305976868,
0.05454517900943756,
0.6389899849891663,
0.8795121908187866,
-0.15134671330451965,
-0.11040692031383514,
0.42852118611335754,
-0.2423342913389206,
0.40329408645629883,
0.03907497599720955,
-0.5004844069480896,
-0.3784868121147156,
-0.39374491572380066,
0.2158452570438385,
0.01621798612177372,
-0.30248957872390747,
0.5505349040031433,
0.06807571649551392,
-0.9698957204818726,
0.6636962294578552,
0.4949774444103241,
0.6141351461410522,
-0.5194677114486694,
-0.014319084584712982,
-0.6012195944786072,
0.36889511346817017,
-0.25749316811561584,
-0.48325127363204956,
0.6403935551643372,
-0.10216835141181946,
0.08705034106969833,
-0.11826834827661514,
0.881545901298523,
-0.47446751594543457,
-0.21829335391521454,
0.2026197612285614,
0.46568992733955383,
-0.09027339518070221,
-0.28426462411880493,
-0.3774077594280243,
0.422344446182251,
0.4900994598865509,
-0.23797324299812317,
0.3136822283267975,
0.1386263519525528,
0.26838889718055725,
0.6717022061347961,
0.6593421101570129,
0.15122923254966736,
0.13364112377166748,
-0.29609987139701843,
1.1733548641204834,
-0.8837751746177673,
0.0017408551648259163,
-0.9033358097076416,
0.7144725918769836,
0.016036760061979294,
0.0025768077466636896,
0.57768315076828,
0.5049441456794739,
1.014524221420288,
-0.1491096317768097,
0.9627820253372192,
0.16276073455810547,
0.5689834356307983,
-0.7128807902336121,
0.11022866517305374,
-0.4521227478981018,
0.8513815402984619,
-0.14438891410827637,
-0.9111964106559753,
-0.3771265745162964,
0.5947501063346863,
-0.10666561871767044,
0.030608966946601868,
0.5046316385269165,
1.1256284713745117,
0.050835996866226196,
-0.2205653339624405,
-0.0027303441893309355,
0.15629102289676666,
0.323702335357666,
1.0850976705551147,
0.9462853074073792,
-0.3364452123641968,
0.605322003364563,
-0.02363433502614498,
-0.5049076676368713,
-0.14935839176177979,
-0.9698045253753662,
-0.5731896758079529,
-0.02845669724047184,
-0.37153196334838867,
-0.6381352543830872,
0.0044565582647919655,
0.7984179258346558,
0.3505576550960541,
-0.297181099653244,
-0.3928646445274353,
-0.00793226808309555,
0.3413882851600647,
-0.3353951871395111,
-0.21276609599590302,
0.09887154400348663,
-0.6456924080848694,
-0.7455691695213318,
0.5868017673492432,
0.458652526140213,
-0.2773590087890625,
-0.4170873165130615,
-0.032846301794052124,
0.17523245513439178,
0.21003592014312744,
0.4849877953529358,
0.5734871625900269,
-0.5527803897857666,
-0.22709934413433075,
0.31793636083602905,
0.23874375224113464,
0.052565980702638626,
1.4035226106643677,
-0.9676164388656616,
0.6767538785934448,
0.18146678805351257,
1.0014643669128418,
0.7122451066970825,
-0.3366125524044037,
0.7631346583366394,
-0.8608706593513489,
0.05978317931294441,
0.04251859337091446,
0.5006397366523743,
0.20430244505405426,
-0.23748041689395905,
0.6570174694061279,
0.009049184620380402,
-0.5114777088165283,
-0.839393675327301,
0.46034690737724304,
-0.7058076858520508,
-0.6424767374992371,
1.1323965787887573,
-0.10526033490896225,
-0.07146535813808441,
0.19931678473949432,
-0.6583817601203918,
-0.1728246957063675,
-0.16642561554908752,
1.1577954292297363,
0.5786418318748474,
-0.1044871062040329,
-0.19896726310253143,
-0.18672728538513184,
0.5465970635414124,
0.30926820635795593,
-0.7249956727027893,
0.10293368250131607,
0.618260383605957,
0.4050494134426117,
0.1054241806268692,
0.7841962575912476,
-0.21588116884231567,
0.23487119376659393,
-0.11738191545009613,
-0.02464727871119976,
-0.01821848377585411,
-0.21753066778182983,
-0.3200257122516632,
0.06828802078962326,
0.4550243318080902,
-0.009439395740628242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16413v1
|
Augmented Risk Prediction for the Onset of Alzheimer's Disease from Electronic Health Records with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-26T03:05:10 | 2024-05-26T03:05:10 |
Jiankun Wang, Sumyeong Ahn, Taykhoom Dalal, Xiaodan Zhang, Weishen Pan, Qiannan Zhang, Bin Chen, Hiroko H. Dodge, Fei Wang, Jiayu Zhou
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.AP
|
Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the fifth-leading cause of death among Americans
aged 65 and older. Screening and early detection of AD and related dementias
(ADRD) are critical for timely intervention and for identifying clinical trial
participants. The widespread adoption of electronic health records (EHRs)
offers an important resource for developing ADRD screening tools such as
machine learning based predictive models. Recent advancements in large language
models (LLMs) demonstrate their unprecedented capability of encoding knowledge
and performing reasoning, which offers them strong potential for enhancing risk
prediction. This paper proposes a novel pipeline that augments risk prediction
by leveraging the few-shot inference power of LLMs to make predictions on cases
where traditional supervised learning methods (SLs) may not excel.
Specifically, we develop a collaborative pipeline that combines SLs and LLMs
via a confidence-driven decision-making mechanism, leveraging the strengths of
SLs in clear-cut cases and LLMs in more complex scenarios. We evaluate this
pipeline using a real-world EHR data warehouse from Oregon Health \& Science
University (OHSU) Hospital, encompassing EHRs from over 2.5 million patients
and more than 20 million patient encounters. Our results show that our proposed
approach effectively combines the power of SLs and LLMs, offering significant
improvements in predictive performance. This advancement holds promise for
revolutionizing ADRD screening and early detection practices, with potential
implications for better strategies of patient management and thus improving
healthcare.
|
[
0.0021037757396698,
-0.7943603992462158,
1.080154538154602,
-0.7148900032043457,
-0.11487927287817001,
-0.14755070209503174,
0.026266809552907944,
-0.7661136388778687,
0.2535540759563446,
0.5772766470909119,
-0.4455261826515198,
-0.6744202971458435,
-0.837266743183136,
-0.3657984137535095,
0.04693814739584923,
1.1208434104919434,
0.07078509032726288,
0.33805051445961,
-0.055089931935071945,
0.19049279391765594,
-0.19899998605251312,
-0.3799474835395813,
-0.8413079380989075,
-0.26703140139579773,
0.4655342102050781,
0.38619792461395264,
0.5109414458274841,
0.6638039946556091,
0.5104838609695435,
0.17904704809188843,
-0.11796998232603073,
0.26691949367523193,
-0.18077243864536285,
0.22010935842990875,
0.40774351358413696,
-0.4771936535835266,
-0.99600750207901,
-0.22035004198551178,
0.23329833149909973,
0.5628530383110046,
-0.22821547091007233,
0.16031135618686676,
0.013139527291059494,
0.6185479760169983,
-0.6755427718162537,
0.24784450232982635,
-0.6377602815628052,
0.14234189689159393,
-0.3963603377342224,
-0.17749950289726257,
-0.46342381834983826,
-0.04195476323366165,
0.40667757391929626,
-0.43380409479141235,
-0.02967895194888115,
0.10625237971544266,
0.5400031805038452,
0.15822690725326538,
-0.4357980787754059,
-0.21987371146678925,
-0.652895987033844,
0.6822419762611389,
-0.5184748768806458,
0.2987036406993866,
0.7204529047012329,
0.6412420272827148,
-0.22856999933719635,
-0.7212840914726257,
-0.17191658914089203,
-0.16508692502975464,
0.08353250473737717,
-0.1368550956249237,
-0.2535470426082611,
0.33314216136932373,
0.15710017085075378,
0.3169191777706146,
-0.5953865051269531,
0.45883646607398987,
-0.5879489779472351,
-0.4907987713813782,
0.5657395720481873,
0.24993449449539185,
0.2730353772640228,
0.01756293885409832,
-0.2830464243888855,
0.07147481292486191,
-0.5586662888526917,
-0.10953798145055771,
-0.05351818725466728,
0.41469964385032654,
-0.07298967242240906,
0.6453522443771362,
-0.14449918270111084,
0.5400111675262451,
0.08982441574335098,
-0.20869006216526031,
0.44900357723236084,
0.019170036539435387,
-0.23965057730674744,
0.6870855093002319,
0.4188697040081024,
0.3671734631061554,
-0.018161101266741753,
0.14593617618083954,
0.019529376178979874,
0.44090816378593445,
-0.050946321338415146,
-0.5487035512924194,
-0.4419414699077606,
0.6458112001419067,
-0.4091198146343231,
-0.06373199075460434,
-0.1659000664949417,
-0.7126139402389526,
-0.5843105316162109,
-0.08718908578157425,
0.3814932405948639,
-0.6215600967407227,
0.10737699270248413,
0.29078587889671326,
0.12975378334522247,
-0.15947028994560242,
0.38254669308662415,
-0.5292530059814453,
0.2575235068798065,
0.7079564332962036,
0.685476541519165,
-0.43328866362571716,
-0.07792741805315018,
-1.202139973640442,
0.34450486302375793,
-0.15248988568782806,
0.7530762553215027,
-0.12074402719736099,
-0.2151702493429184,
0.07728475332260132,
-0.3635914623737335,
0.2029038369655609,
-0.32616126537323,
0.5869092345237732,
-0.5808085799217224,
-0.016228489577770233,
0.5032027363777161,
-0.5190658569335938,
0.03147529065608978,
0.22174815833568573,
-0.9865944981575012,
0.6773022413253784,
0.035631902515888214,
-0.6802762746810913,
0.741918683052063,
-0.39517226815223694,
-0.45674771070480347,
0.4564065635204315,
-0.1794111132621765,
-0.7795500159263611,
-0.24424046277999878,
0.508199155330658,
0.5450992584228516,
-0.1472029983997345,
0.2235722541809082,
-0.4477394223213196,
-0.03521642088890076,
-0.04737911745905876,
-0.35095688700675964,
0.5179110169410706,
0.23134367167949677,
0.0433071032166481,
0.15329580008983612,
-0.6695374250411987,
0.22771893441677094,
-0.13413923978805542,
-0.2914162874221802,
-0.52238929271698,
-0.07877091318368912,
-0.15697327256202698,
0.2549842596054077,
0.2815679609775543,
-0.4319458603858948,
-0.12451233714818954,
-0.18745937943458557,
0.106282539665699,
0.7552474141120911,
0.12509854137897491,
0.3548375368118286,
-0.4452368915081024,
0.5256597995758057,
0.15810424089431763,
0.4230799674987793,
-0.3504791259765625,
-0.6966899633407593,
-0.22176361083984375,
-0.5879039168357849,
0.12369789928197861,
0.6700274348258972,
-0.4541538655757904,
0.5309624075889587,
-0.4073616564273834,
-0.31996169686317444,
-0.7050173878669739,
0.029877960681915283,
0.2696775496006012,
0.3424786925315857,
0.4837055802345276,
-0.29638218879699707,
-0.6920225024223328,
-0.46972906589508057,
-0.0698966532945633,
-0.4361177682876587,
-0.24604715406894684,
0.43931764364242554,
-0.04363512247800827,
-0.41252097487449646,
0.5527184009552002,
-0.9432366490364075,
-0.7991974949836731,
-0.3884444832801819,
0.0015257219783961773,
0.17905409634113312,
0.2586038410663605,
-0.06694655865430832,
-0.5338621735572815,
-0.25431105494499207,
0.05446354299783707,
-0.7366204261779785,
0.20572102069854736,
0.3601078391075134,
-0.04190823435783386,
0.13731403648853302,
0.5171685814857483,
-0.5617053508758545,
0.4982945919036865,
0.811787486076355,
-0.25081804394721985,
0.37599977850914,
-0.41369545459747314,
-0.055526867508888245,
-0.8370848298072815,
-0.5004696249961853,
0.24240630865097046,
-0.011408204212784767,
-0.5362802147865295,
-0.3482705354690552,
-0.36724498867988586,
-0.15991069376468658,
-0.3722688555717468,
0.3997228145599365,
-0.4905257523059845,
0.1243819072842598,
0.008326306939125061,
-0.18942898511886597,
-0.0947636291384697,
-0.14979222416877747,
0.011096184141933918,
0.19987808167934418,
0.8854387402534485,
-0.6654812097549438,
-0.003559056669473648,
0.18530377745628357,
-0.6333500146865845,
0.3305926024913788,
-0.43543827533721924,
0.03220361843705177,
-0.2563032805919647,
0.38593345880508423,
-0.7150168418884277,
-0.220101997256279,
-0.0216202512383461,
-0.4411066770553589,
0.3240644335746765,
-0.259145051240921,
-0.16499313712120056,
-0.5050126314163208,
-0.29029780626296997,
0.2895366847515106,
0.5049607157707214,
-0.21574869751930237,
0.9698891043663025,
0.7992110252380371,
-0.43298664689064026,
-0.4243440628051758,
-0.8935363292694092,
0.03813588246703148,
-0.2831699252128601,
-0.7589209079742432,
0.3137566149234772,
0.02484978921711445,
-0.26936739683151245,
0.19095130264759064,
0.16269177198410034,
-0.21749524772167206,
-0.18237048387527466,
0.3631822466850281,
0.7192699313163757,
-0.2687162458896637,
0.2805510461330414,
-0.052816156297922134,
-0.3435100317001343,
-0.15560269355773926,
-0.5279117226600647,
0.30988797545433044,
-0.02655707113444805,
-0.5086495280265808,
-0.37439975142478943,
0.30691787600517273,
0.6986940503120422,
-0.16884386539459229,
0.5937889218330383,
0.4120507538318634,
-0.5937946438789368,
-0.1584741324186325,
-0.6178427338600159,
-0.512180745601654,
-0.4045857787132263,
0.3547292947769165,
-0.08445979654788971,
-0.8888266086578369,
0.3177616000175476,
-0.19509389996528625,
-0.0851050540804863,
0.2911824882030487,
0.4663325548171997,
-0.05453452467918396,
1.1647002696990967,
0.5201535224914551,
-0.1420871764421463,
0.3204842209815979,
-0.21462389826774597,
0.16950848698616028,
-0.9267047047615051,
-0.32651373744010925,
-0.10265576094388962,
0.000045426284486893564,
-0.6974557638168335,
-0.5675690770149231,
0.8963394165039062,
-0.40451207756996155,
-0.28133493661880493,
-0.05360559746623039,
-0.1976930946111679,
0.045639537274837494,
0.28472501039505005,
0.6288009285926819,
0.560443103313446,
-0.03289825841784477,
-0.16034238040447235,
-0.06638503819704056,
-0.67078697681427,
-0.4927579164505005,
1.6361656188964844,
0.45730024576187134,
0.8979798555374146,
-0.05647115409374237,
0.7974016070365906,
0.5494096279144287,
0.3157346844673157,
-0.8961328268051147,
0.2382500022649765,
-0.333434522151947,
-0.6397093534469604,
-0.4996896982192993,
-0.24535611271858215,
-1.041143536567688,
-0.09153388440608978,
-0.49258196353912354,
-0.7513914108276367,
0.026800120249390602,
0.44291678071022034,
-0.751289963722229,
0.4078978896141052,
-0.5412746667861938,
0.6298942565917969,
-0.6315792202949524,
-0.2577917277812958,
-0.22617577016353607,
-0.6512866616249084,
0.39132067561149597,
-0.17848648130893707,
0.5005189180374146,
-0.12006261944770813,
-0.022802840918302536,
0.5262975692749023,
-0.4183862805366516,
0.696770966053009,
0.2732776999473572,
0.08635593950748444,
0.4245907664299011,
0.114817313849926,
0.7039839625358582,
-0.04596053808927536,
-0.3897312581539154,
0.2335597723722458,
-0.3438252806663513,
-0.21387548744678497,
-0.1857994943857193,
0.8134338855743408,
-0.4683440923690796,
-0.35731059312820435,
-0.6862318515777588,
-0.4599933326244354,
-0.19769532978534698,
0.24318760633468628,
0.08487925678491592,
0.3499566614627838,
-0.18447057902812958,
-0.29206910729408264,
0.5574398636817932,
0.08492821455001831,
0.03373515605926514,
0.4285000264644623,
-0.04246463626623154,
-0.396770179271698,
0.6344780325889587,
0.10075651109218597,
0.20740260183811188,
0.12593227624893188,
0.5111107230186462,
-0.18013127148151398,
-0.6614744663238525,
-0.25683802366256714,
0.0890544205904007,
-0.6841822266578674,
-0.1688898205757141,
-0.6075623631477356,
-0.088847316801548,
-0.4170083701610565,
-0.07442422211170197,
-0.1203060895204544,
-0.002752568107098341,
-0.3133957087993622,
-0.45359477400779724,
0.6277444362640381,
0.5568735003471375,
-0.045067474246025085,
0.11515980958938599,
-0.9554553627967834,
0.2745775580406189,
0.43046537041664124,
0.27862128615379333,
-0.09522579610347748,
-0.3658302128314972,
-0.25620102882385254,
-0.16182951629161835,
-0.1631258875131607,
-0.6013001799583435,
0.5240679383277893,
0.28367137908935547,
0.6882162690162659,
0.6030604839324951,
0.08262385427951813,
0.47016608715057373,
-0.7382925748825073,
0.6222708225250244,
0.2567213773727417,
-0.46038320660591125,
0.7115322351455688,
-0.1638181209564209,
-0.14971023797988892,
0.6326475739479065,
0.5628491044044495,
-0.12354554980993271,
0.15909747779369354,
-0.7866480350494385,
-1.030829906463623,
0.5393880605697632,
-0.30248594284057617,
-0.26671910285949707,
-0.04308206960558891,
0.0028498410247266293,
0.07780496776103973,
-0.08898190408945084,
-0.15265710651874542,
-0.33871695399284363,
0.3733552098274231,
-0.22304636240005493,
-0.2952357530593872,
-0.1794867366552353,
-0.11446941643953323,
-0.058921802788972855,
0.7223663926124573,
-0.12931479513645172,
0.12955377995967865,
0.21594658493995667,
0.009603844955563545,
-0.5762580037117004,
0.15770527720451355,
-0.022603066638112068,
0.3407551646232605,
-0.4555169939994812,
0.3050415813922882,
0.2130657583475113,
-0.6293390393257141,
-0.0962139293551445,
0.24107122421264648,
-0.12689529359340668,
-0.0587477907538414,
0.30302736163139343,
0.8903043866157532,
0.05332358926534653,
-0.963015615940094,
0.4311842620372772,
0.14942191541194916,
0.20959915220737457,
-0.5989176034927368,
-0.16466182470321655,
-0.12231749296188354,
0.14678987860679626,
0.5034787058830261,
-0.05667756497859955,
0.3601459562778473,
-0.5714181065559387,
0.7573027014732361,
0.47542881965637207,
-0.7309162020683289,
-0.037798382341861725,
0.6291808485984802,
-0.03278931975364685,
-0.08760816603899002,
0.4499846398830414,
-0.016422109678387642,
-0.315080851316452,
0.48024818301200867,
0.33457279205322266,
0.7430170774459839,
-0.4212276041507721,
-0.029494047164916992,
0.2566782534122467,
0.18666869401931763,
-0.3340860605239868,
0.0528138130903244,
0.6414020657539368,
-0.6853584051132202,
-0.608344554901123,
-0.32000967860221863,
-0.3607233762741089,
0.33634692430496216,
-0.5796129703521729,
0.7146888375282288,
-0.2813374400138855,
-0.48775428533554077,
0.13374993205070496,
-0.06667914241552353,
-0.5808972716331482,
0.27351322770118713,
0.6093120574951172,
0.635220468044281,
-1.1185452938079834,
0.6235033869743347,
0.7747364640235901,
-0.16119162738323212,
-0.6103837490081787,
0.22465640306472778,
0.3880018889904022,
-0.8077261447906494,
0.6157568693161011,
0.1632152795791626,
0.053493089973926544,
-0.043797142803668976,
-0.2035934180021286,
-0.902250349521637,
1.300590991973877,
0.19649049639701843,
-0.42254436016082764,
-0.14035682380199432,
-0.2574140727519989,
0.40047338604927063,
-0.5334563255310059,
0.21845810115337372,
0.5186392664909363,
0.2904699742794037,
0.3014345169067383,
-0.8704904317855835,
-0.024847567081451416,
0.15881705284118652,
-0.275640606880188,
0.31363022327423096,
0.06126216799020767,
0.9865592122077942,
-0.8134597539901733,
-0.05716456100344658,
-0.269872784614563,
0.6599768400192261,
0.6380955576896667,
0.7366093993186951,
0.28649574518203735,
0.8659122586250305,
0.9751248955726624,
0.24571792781352997,
1.3487221002578735,
-0.20533806085586548,
0.0032936499919742346,
1.0468679666519165,
-0.5334901213645935,
0.9377091526985168,
0.3222948908805847,
-0.3495207726955414,
0.6544756293296814,
0.36764243245124817,
0.3873445987701416,
0.518682599067688,
0.12525616586208344,
-0.5183166265487671,
-0.44568416476249695,
-0.30251801013946533,
-0.0328400693833828,
0.3132569193840027,
0.8993366360664368,
-0.46028944849967957,
-0.13072817027568817,
0.04622869938611984,
-0.12005529552698135,
-0.029493875801563263,
-0.5224840641021729,
0.6699860095977783,
0.23092737793922424,
-0.3885044753551483,
0.28687331080436707,
-0.2295716404914856,
0.7387410402297974,
-0.6461077332496643,
-0.30220556259155273,
0.4448590874671936,
0.36470842361450195,
-0.13413214683532715,
-0.7641001343727112,
-0.12050296366214752,
-0.18442830443382263,
-0.07331935316324234,
0.30524617433547974,
0.8003901243209839,
-0.5059510469436646,
-0.5735874176025391,
0.4113208055496216,
0.5460795760154724,
0.3031879961490631,
0.028076820075511932,
-0.49854689836502075,
0.15416739881038666,
-0.3892706334590912,
0.04561803489923477,
0.48524010181427,
0.37431609630584717,
-0.4041420519351959,
0.7966872453689575,
0.8607015609741211,
0.6646071076393127,
-0.07060519605875015,
-0.24165818095207214,
0.7325800657272339,
0.01365726999938488,
-0.5103456377983093,
-0.811408519744873,
0.36150646209716797,
0.1343543529510498,
-0.08454128354787827,
0.323819637298584,
0.4412091374397278,
0.3935014307498932,
0.04411392658948898,
1.0190844535827637,
0.21435609459877014,
0.5725233554840088,
-0.6138405799865723,
0.48122507333755493,
-0.25852644443511963,
0.2919011414051056,
-0.08446098864078522,
-0.35801392793655396,
-0.36714011430740356,
0.435436874628067,
-0.5630333423614502,
-0.014068757183849812,
0.6802750825881958,
0.5220032930374146,
0.11119430512189865,
-0.4448462426662445,
0.2597529888153076,
0.3208443820476532,
0.2034468799829483,
0.9239524006843567,
0.09645431488752365,
-0.489459753036499,
0.46004772186279297,
-0.1131393313407898,
-0.5212493538856506,
-0.5830557942390442,
-1.1642545461654663,
-0.49143117666244507,
-0.308851420879364,
-0.3962573707103729,
-0.6207274198532104,
0.2904492914676666,
1.0330407619476318,
0.6080204248428345,
-0.8508102893829346,
0.24673224985599518,
0.039368096739053726,
-0.00857185572385788,
-0.32186391949653625,
-0.10538424551486969,
0.8064351677894592,
0.2011953741312027,
-0.47170722484588623,
0.37108397483825684,
0.18043828010559082,
0.22700998187065125,
-0.1741415560245514,
-0.19149941205978394,
-0.1789105385541916,
-0.18398752808570862,
0.6306359171867371,
0.31207433342933655,
-0.5718735456466675,
-0.08820716291666031,
0.00882328487932682,
-0.21712319552898407,
-0.13533717393875122,
0.48198428750038147,
-0.9865887761116028,
0.49258384108543396,
0.380329430103302,
0.528586745262146,
0.5067371726036072,
0.08873060345649719,
0.44441676139831543,
-0.21249626576900482,
0.03196459636092186,
0.5208849310874939,
0.42460525035858154,
0.38462960720062256,
-0.9140399694442749,
0.18293339014053345,
-0.07288220524787903,
-0.38921016454696655,
-0.5611878633499146,
0.2373846024274826,
-0.9743627309799194,
-0.05756644904613495,
1.1160508394241333,
-0.09582202881574631,
-0.19057446718215942,
-0.43290969729423523,
-0.06393987685441971,
0.31227463483810425,
-0.6348127722740173,
0.7825390100479126,
0.2594396770000458,
-0.48783499002456665,
0.09156446158885956,
-0.8296547532081604,
0.5087248682975769,
0.27794358134269714,
-0.735715389251709,
0.06331407278776169,
0.7262861728668213,
0.08103334903717041,
0.05932619422674179,
0.6804669499397278,
-0.3635480999946594,
0.3794323801994324,
-0.3441532552242279,
0.12846516072750092,
-0.14013202488422394,
-0.44356006383895874,
-0.4351522624492645,
-0.13019242882728577,
0.28020012378692627,
-0.20268338918685913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16412v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16412v2
|
KG-FIT: Knowledge Graph Fine-Tuning Upon Open-World Knowledge
| 2024-05-26T03:04:26 | 2024-06-04T07:35:32 |
Pengcheng Jiang, Lang Cao, Cao Xiao, Parminder Bhatia, Jimeng Sun, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE) techniques are crucial in learning compact
representations of entities and relations within a knowledge graph,
facilitating efficient reasoning and knowledge discovery. While existing
methods typically focus either on training KGE models solely based on graph
structure or fine-tuning pre-trained language models with classification data
in KG, KG-FIT leverages LLM-guided refinement to construct a semantically
coherent hierarchical structure of entity clusters. By incorporating this
hierarchical knowledge along with textual information during the fine-tuning
process, KG-FIT effectively captures both global semantics from the LLM and
local semantics from the KG. Extensive experiments on the benchmark datasets
FB15K-237, YAGO3-10, and PrimeKG demonstrate the superiority of KG-FIT over
state-of-the-art pre-trained language model-based methods, achieving
improvements of 14.4%, 13.5%, and 11.9% in the Hits@10 metric for the link
prediction task, respectively. Furthermore, KG-FIT yields substantial
performance gains of 12.6%, 6.7%, and 17.7% compared to the structure-based
base models upon which it is built. These results highlight the effectiveness
of KG-FIT in incorporating open-world knowledge from LLMs to significantly
enhance the expressiveness and informativeness of KG embeddings.
|
[
-0.7297208309173584,
-0.7595087289810181,
0.6467136144638062,
-0.3444564938545227,
-0.15291818976402283,
-0.08733002841472626,
-0.1077970489859581,
-0.3698999583721161,
0.19604644179344177,
0.43219253420829773,
-0.5607328414916992,
-0.9088518619537354,
-0.5807342529296875,
-0.10355135798454285,
0.09919742494821548,
0.7218062877655029,
-0.37331560254096985,
-0.04354942589998245,
-0.3704058825969696,
-0.22221721708774567,
-0.47076132893562317,
0.08368758857250214,
-0.4695001244544983,
-0.596130907535553,
0.68295818567276,
0.41079407930374146,
0.9287475347518921,
0.8428175449371338,
0.18928378820419312,
0.15159796178340912,
-0.19494491815567017,
0.35303008556365967,
-0.8143457770347595,
0.12942518293857574,
-0.16080990433692932,
-0.4813292920589447,
-0.43048936128616333,
-0.018124544993042946,
0.5643371939659119,
0.888946533203125,
-0.1953134685754776,
0.22739599645137787,
0.13723212480545044,
0.7610369324684143,
-0.8524665236473083,
0.5019950270652771,
-0.6081163883209229,
0.13161468505859375,
-0.052397508174180984,
0.05382668599486351,
-0.4524696469306946,
-0.5046262741088867,
0.16163475811481476,
-0.9852908253669739,
-0.10338256508111954,
0.3485576808452606,
0.8276193141937256,
0.5357210040092468,
-0.5852475166320801,
-0.3877890408039093,
-0.3509007394313812,
0.373594731092453,
-0.5597408413887024,
1.1061058044433594,
0.48503541946411133,
0.4780448377132416,
-0.4848921298980713,
-0.8728955388069153,
-0.37136217951774597,
-0.21846750378608704,
-0.35173097252845764,
0.050750743597745895,
0.0018294269684702158,
0.20215728878974915,
0.15896311402320862,
0.29435455799102783,
-0.2377534955739975,
0.22883903980255127,
-0.1339411586523056,
-0.2847105860710144,
0.4100099503993988,
0.016793277114629745,
0.18868879973888397,
-0.03572484850883484,
-0.07584225386381149,
-0.14750121533870697,
-0.8727273941040039,
-0.1942577064037323,
0.4440464377403259,
0.24240083992481232,
0.1512361615896225,
0.6713605523109436,
-0.697803795337677,
0.8885210752487183,
-0.03788066282868385,
-0.3926084339618683,
0.08365222811698914,
-0.08671026676893234,
-0.36297348141670227,
0.040104418992996216,
0.6298068761825562,
0.37738165259361267,
0.4399762749671936,
-0.7486769556999207,
0.08368860185146332,
-0.044337619096040726,
0.18114730715751648,
-0.9333182573318481,
-0.5124148726463318,
-0.0933951586484909,
-0.5008320808410645,
-0.27166563272476196,
0.02565200813114643,
-0.5213665962219238,
-0.21372276544570923,
-0.5547665357589722,
0.45981118083000183,
-0.5788601636886597,
-0.025917084887623787,
0.1757555902004242,
-0.1922934204339981,
-0.011227669194340706,
0.29679206013679504,
-0.6778538227081299,
0.1765834242105484,
0.503423273563385,
0.6006713509559631,
0.10912836343050003,
-0.09075244516134262,
-0.25685518980026245,
0.600429117679596,
-0.40266233682632446,
0.7052728533744812,
-0.5218705534934998,
-0.262235164642334,
-0.004150494001805782,
-0.005386808421462774,
-0.052729781717061996,
-0.5603136420249939,
0.5761075615882874,
-0.8107813596725464,
-0.05738436058163643,
-0.4067314565181732,
-0.8907479047775269,
-0.3119787871837616,
0.5405282378196716,
-0.5344162583351135,
1.1096543073654175,
0.3295844495296478,
-0.7826559543609619,
0.6277710795402527,
-0.6976746320724487,
-0.2078857123851776,
-0.25065934658050537,
-0.04269373044371605,
-0.4861961305141449,
-0.08666298538446426,
0.46104317903518677,
0.7329177260398865,
-0.17142653465270996,
-0.1062941774725914,
-0.7456377744674683,
-0.0861024409532547,
-0.2971700429916382,
0.13251449167728424,
0.27182838320732117,
0.2110612839460373,
0.11950604617595673,
-0.20756052434444427,
-0.7862550616264343,
0.48335209488868713,
0.12009254097938538,
-0.3744993805885315,
-0.447429895401001,
0.08815494179725647,
-0.4589807987213135,
-0.12959237396717072,
0.1617116779088974,
-0.6240140795707703,
0.48952269554138184,
-0.45495790243148804,
0.1608077883720398,
0.574634313583374,
0.11046169698238373,
0.46814125776290894,
-0.2578584849834442,
0.41080841422080994,
-0.06360773742198944,
0.06665538251399994,
0.07120900601148605,
-0.6787276864051819,
-0.2930997610092163,
-0.21264097094535828,
0.5931758284568787,
0.3713919520378113,
-0.6542180180549622,
0.34833118319511414,
-0.4728381633758545,
-0.8698310256004333,
-0.5334338545799255,
0.1263289600610733,
0.23683135211467743,
0.6542643904685974,
0.4242519438266754,
-0.10726667940616608,
-0.2668442726135254,
-0.8625905513763428,
-0.3714383542537689,
0.03516123443841934,
-0.038590893149375916,
0.6710217595100403,
0.3851120173931122,
-0.5580121278762817,
1.1894584894180298,
-1.0478805303573608,
-0.19729411602020264,
0.1771474927663803,
-0.20044374465942383,
0.017010902985930443,
0.2716417908668518,
0.5389760732650757,
-0.8068975806236267,
-0.8707753419876099,
0.43602868914604187,
-0.7181129455566406,
-0.11600986123085022,
0.5813981294631958,
-0.3597479462623596,
-0.25477704405784607,
0.5425324440002441,
-0.4570019841194153,
0.3941575288772583,
0.4644875228404999,
-0.48959654569625854,
0.3721340000629425,
-0.131486177444458,
0.22597412765026093,
-1.3945258855819702,
-0.12561658024787903,
-0.20286139845848083,
-0.19591090083122253,
-0.332040399312973,
0.10310207307338715,
0.18496085703372955,
-0.02215265855193138,
-0.12760750949382782,
0.5372483134269714,
-0.3947746157646179,
-0.048691052943468094,
0.030431149527430534,
0.3684338629245758,
-0.21646517515182495,
0.38899660110473633,
-0.43973782658576965,
0.46572884917259216,
0.47828689217567444,
-0.7306666970252991,
0.2932114601135254,
0.5129330158233643,
-0.5152428150177002,
0.4640955626964569,
-0.3767803907394409,
0.24691326916217804,
-0.27750369906425476,
0.1221848726272583,
-0.9057085514068604,
-0.5742185711860657,
0.2228347808122635,
-0.42274847626686096,
0.5871729850769043,
-0.4957018196582794,
-0.6629105806350708,
-0.2419622391462326,
-0.13358326256275177,
0.3554264008998871,
0.5310999751091003,
-0.7180517911911011,
0.7980556488037109,
0.44428715109825134,
0.2768191695213318,
-0.5829529166221619,
-0.3555655777454376,
-0.3914755880832672,
-0.14319051802158356,
-0.920650064945221,
0.573676586151123,
0.06341692060232162,
0.16711242496967316,
0.46822354197502136,
-0.30760282278060913,
-0.08986259996891022,
0.20609252154827118,
0.24790069460868835,
-0.09954483807086945,
-0.29682570695877075,
0.07000355422496796,
0.2416526973247528,
-0.25652047991752625,
-0.19432389736175537,
-0.6271976232528687,
0.5476287603378296,
0.15178367495536804,
-0.48102903366088867,
-0.33922937512397766,
-0.15115053951740265,
0.6483930945396423,
-0.07220650464296341,
0.9595003724098206,
0.6077758073806763,
-0.4198339879512787,
-0.28329768776893616,
-0.45267432928085327,
-0.09612555056810379,
-0.46481722593307495,
0.4759952425956726,
-0.43397057056427,
-1.222504734992981,
0.5762411952018738,
-0.6847893595695496,
-0.2006780058145523,
0.4228597581386566,
0.3601210117340088,
-0.1496247947216034,
1.0576887130737305,
0.7848328948020935,
-0.20080168545246124,
0.3335902690887451,
-0.14273937046527863,
0.30206871032714844,
-0.9582145810127258,
-0.532041609287262,
-0.5466545224189758,
-0.48117634654045105,
-0.837950587272644,
-0.300216406583786,
0.5255863070487976,
0.7692686915397644,
-0.3924613296985626,
0.3988136053085327,
-0.3861505687236786,
0.757500410079956,
0.3454168438911438,
0.16799022257328033,
0.07296131551265717,
0.08705149590969086,
-0.5477331876754761,
-0.04900088533759117,
-0.9046366214752197,
-0.2719084620475769,
1.1598480939865112,
0.26748907566070557,
0.9617369771003723,
0.16161437332630157,
0.6729207038879395,
-0.051198091357946396,
0.48072823882102966,
-1.0056463479995728,
0.3907814025878906,
-0.0875738188624382,
-0.23962128162384033,
-0.19944153726100922,
-0.6631416082382202,
-0.9974148869514465,
0.12221945822238922,
-0.20792903006076813,
-0.9153508543968201,
-0.22012518346309662,
0.3210603892803192,
0.08713170886039734,
0.5450425744056702,
-0.7119572162628174,
0.9798596501350403,
0.27635011076927185,
0.2044648826122284,
-0.2144812047481537,
-0.2792786955833435,
0.1936599314212799,
-0.06351391226053238,
0.08854573220014572,
-0.23136328160762787,
0.0403876006603241,
0.5913477540016174,
-0.29713547229766846,
0.7231713533401489,
-0.19063284993171692,
-0.09445803612470627,
0.2749554514884949,
0.13803565502166748,
0.8624312281608582,
0.012225717306137085,
0.04517434164881706,
0.07010574638843536,
-0.017760474234819412,
-0.3931891918182373,
-0.988081693649292,
0.704196035861969,
-0.9413818120956421,
-0.29759523272514343,
0.4516453146934509,
-0.592496931552887,
-0.6645200848579407,
0.3933519124984741,
0.10734881460666656,
0.39289507269859314,
-0.10794719308614731,
0.4777311682701111,
0.7868306040763855,
-0.09757900983095169,
-0.12272021919488907,
0.38376620411872864,
-0.4020664393901825,
-0.8665927648544312,
0.6257128715515137,
0.25881853699684143,
0.3509514629840851,
0.5923974514007568,
0.3741667568683624,
-0.3898743689060211,
-0.5029571056365967,
-0.24441559612751007,
0.2660871744155884,
-1.0005208253860474,
-0.4348737299442291,
-0.5092984437942505,
-0.0895269587635994,
-0.5052741169929504,
-0.3390144407749176,
-0.35961318016052246,
-0.33181875944137573,
0.17625692486763,
-0.09699584543704987,
0.32533904910087585,
1.0360039472579956,
0.1389733850955963,
0.4034934937953949,
-0.877781867980957,
0.10770780593156815,
0.22081653773784637,
0.7583643794059753,
-0.04303118586540222,
-0.07016375660896301,
-0.5069994926452637,
-0.02024652436375618,
-0.26789239048957825,
-0.9692326784133911,
-0.18157032132148743,
0.13244375586509705,
0.8688845634460449,
0.24610942602157593,
-0.04116253927350044,
0.7676099538803101,
-0.4757622182369232,
0.4668368995189667,
0.13079506158828735,
-0.5599828958511353,
0.6956010460853577,
-0.41707420349121094,
0.21336376667022705,
0.4983333349227905,
0.8045771718025208,
-0.5737230181694031,
-0.14920856058597565,
-0.5449621081352234,
-0.5804339051246643,
0.5862234830856323,
0.1802881509065628,
-0.3050304651260376,
0.025160979479551315,
0.9252310991287231,
-0.08133131265640259,
0.14922930300235748,
-0.5368438959121704,
-0.38458070158958435,
0.14547480642795563,
-0.5575770735740662,
0.26828864216804504,
-0.15652842819690704,
-0.11361849308013916,
-0.31500253081321716,
0.8394185900688171,
-0.5965767502784729,
0.32662954926490784,
0.05800309404730797,
-0.03379838913679123,
-0.19110171496868134,
-0.12368468195199966,
0.059145379811525345,
0.5696007609367371,
-0.050815317779779434,
-0.0049273669719696045,
0.4818804860115051,
-0.48445263504981995,
-0.04780147224664688,
0.0635019838809967,
-0.3355463743209839,
-0.23345156013965607,
0.34433799982070923,
0.7849409580230713,
0.3749189078807831,
-0.34854307770729065,
0.2109329253435135,
0.21358869969844818,
-0.1947273463010788,
0.2586977183818817,
0.3287701904773712,
0.2635717988014221,
0.44525405764579773,
-0.24930347502231598,
0.10684007406234741,
-0.10635070502758026,
-0.35696256160736084,
0.14557166397571564,
0.480741024017334,
-0.4472968578338623,
-0.18703562021255493,
0.6863775253295898,
-0.1635676622390747,
0.033148039132356644,
0.6459019780158997,
-0.24395368993282318,
-0.5725753307342529,
0.49696749448776245,
0.558836042881012,
0.6371983289718628,
-0.16255542635917664,
-0.033757299184799194,
0.5560347437858582,
0.1891639530658722,
0.019145702943205833,
0.07521579414606094,
-0.19834646582603455,
-1.094399094581604,
-0.6040900349617004,
-0.8539323210716248,
-0.17390143871307373,
-0.247184619307518,
-0.6476842761039734,
0.4101274609565735,
-0.14529943466186523,
-0.028794825077056885,
-0.19922152161598206,
0.042210426181554794,
-0.7840996980667114,
0.23587529361248016,
0.02533665858209133,
1.1936322450637817,
-0.6015037894248962,
0.890592098236084,
0.9381623864173889,
-0.14365516602993011,
-1.0648432970046997,
0.04368472471833229,
-0.1582440882921219,
-1.016813039779663,
0.70904541015625,
0.16275130212306976,
-0.04790448024868965,
0.361529678106308,
-0.4452955722808838,
-1.2985156774520874,
1.692240834236145,
0.5474940538406372,
-0.3940120339393616,
0.04454309493303299,
0.24858684837818146,
0.15050503611564636,
-0.27244833111763,
0.027163878083229065,
0.39932942390441895,
0.4723220467567444,
0.31837621331214905,
-1.1433727741241455,
-0.0620575025677681,
0.30331069231033325,
0.05375611409544945,
0.8806867003440857,
-0.6021974086761475,
0.280756413936615,
-0.057723596692085266,
-0.08330181241035461,
-0.18551617860794067,
0.5747429728507996,
0.13963326811790466,
0.3128034770488739,
0.5195869207382202,
1.3722103834152222,
1.1736571788787842,
-0.20494574308395386,
1.0318838357925415,
-0.5092697739601135,
0.640515923500061,
0.7871164083480835,
0.018530817702412605,
0.7819110751152039,
0.04363406449556351,
-0.2417025864124298,
0.6215498447418213,
0.6701313257217407,
0.22934219241142273,
0.8303061723709106,
-0.045946333557367325,
-0.0349494144320488,
-0.269254207611084,
0.038298770785331726,
-0.4094312787055969,
0.27815866470336914,
0.4376603960990906,
-0.2583347260951996,
-0.4388763904571533,
-0.23288455605506897,
0.222805917263031,
-0.27133145928382874,
-0.5234646797180176,
0.7817783951759338,
0.06613229960203171,
-0.5978360176086426,
0.29537346959114075,
-0.024507636204361916,
0.3188602030277252,
-0.8929547667503357,
0.16590426862239838,
0.16724836826324463,
0.2664189040660858,
-0.25010108947753906,
-0.8486576676368713,
0.30778393149375916,
-0.4630144536495209,
-0.281735897064209,
-0.1404179483652115,
1.0906238555908203,
-0.3785623610019684,
-0.10033541172742844,
0.4248226583003998,
0.402892529964447,
-0.15121956169605255,
-0.07918181270360947,
-0.45398736000061035,
-0.23222632706165314,
0.1684907227754593,
-0.31298330426216125,
0.4843374490737915,
0.6958247423171997,
0.13387730717658997,
0.7213590741157532,
0.615045964717865,
-0.2385735660791397,
0.10787005722522736,
-0.17131301760673523,
0.9968447089195251,
-0.42461153864860535,
-0.42278510332107544,
-0.7541608214378357,
0.3738878667354584,
-0.07058049738407135,
-0.2713715434074402,
0.7207410931587219,
0.6141746640205383,
1.1462395191192627,
0.1131298616528511,
0.5460089445114136,
-0.18876561522483826,
0.144632950425148,
-0.850238561630249,
0.8252062201499939,
-0.5813148021697998,
-0.15765687823295593,
-0.09107953310012817,
-1.075547456741333,
-0.26878833770751953,
0.5322819948196411,
-0.3504558801651001,
0.18477129936218262,
0.571082353591919,
0.8224425315856934,
-0.3126736283302307,
0.0563683919608593,
0.34593474864959717,
0.3196657598018646,
0.29689720273017883,
0.31845536828041077,
0.5699042677879333,
-0.40282583236694336,
0.48335152864456177,
-0.25696122646331787,
-0.05331145226955414,
-0.011489242315292358,
-0.9402233958244324,
-0.940922200679779,
-0.3514370024204254,
-0.3916832506656647,
-0.39123955368995667,
-0.1854160577058792,
0.7774425148963928,
0.89005446434021,
-0.5340730547904968,
0.26193931698799133,
-0.13997390866279602,
0.06177891790866852,
0.10124023258686066,
-0.18580691516399384,
0.3738064765930176,
-0.49663448333740234,
-0.41839703917503357,
0.5737597346305847,
0.26890501379966736,
0.024865727871656418,
-0.03542156144976616,
-0.380622535943985,
0.12504789233207703,
-0.21908046305179596,
0.666652262210846,
-0.09141460061073303,
-0.6125932931900024,
-0.5867691040039062,
-0.04575808346271515,
0.24363979697227478,
-0.16934455931186676,
0.7040990591049194,
-0.8624149560928345,
0.5482743382453918,
0.48483607172966003,
0.9697842597961426,
0.7055841684341431,
-0.15419964492321014,
0.5594751238822937,
-0.9225602746009827,
-0.15304403007030487,
0.06334682554006577,
0.6200159192085266,
0.08008100092411041,
-0.329523503780365,
0.7760920524597168,
0.385040283203125,
-0.7579299211502075,
-0.5910373330116272,
0.5333518981933594,
-0.8163485527038574,
-0.24826975166797638,
0.9785329103469849,
-0.17677325010299683,
-0.25597691535949707,
0.08018312603235245,
-0.11709652841091156,
0.47052091360092163,
0.06543958932161331,
0.5256231427192688,
0.9459896683692932,
-0.20677345991134644,
0.1951117366552353,
-0.6867562532424927,
0.4359824061393738,
0.13078069686889648,
-0.7541024684906006,
-0.29903051257133484,
0.29547199606895447,
0.4853442311286926,
0.2052415907382965,
0.3133021891117096,
0.14342831075191498,
0.0035742162726819515,
-0.06056638062000275,
-0.2671056389808655,
-0.2768801748752594,
-0.22934216260910034,
0.4783579707145691,
0.40689605474472046,
0.13549694418907166,
0.06621754169464111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16411v1
|
Tensor Attention Training: Provably Efficient Learning of Higher-order Transformers
| 2024-05-26T02:59:13 | 2024-05-26T02:59:13 |
Jiuxiang Gu, Yingyu Liang, Zhenmei Shi, Zhao Song, Yufa Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Tensor Attention, a multi-view attention that is able to capture high-order
correlations among multiple modalities, can overcome the representational
limitations of classical matrix attention. However, the $\Omega(n^3)$ time
complexity of tensor attention poses a significant obstacle to its practical
implementation in transformers, where $n$ is the input sequence length. In this
work, we prove that the backward gradient of tensor attention training can be
computed in almost linear $n^{1+o(1)}$ time, the same complexity as its forward
computation under a bounded entries assumption. We provide a closed-form
solution for the gradient and propose a fast computation method utilizing
polynomial approximation methods and tensor algebraic tricks. Furthermore, we
prove the necessity and tightness of our assumption through hardness analysis,
showing that slightly weakening it renders the gradient problem unsolvable in
truly subcubic time. Our theoretical results establish the feasibility of
efficient higher-order transformer training and may facilitate practical
applications of tensor attention architectures.
|
[
-0.48420318961143494,
-0.5196307897567749,
0.3868314325809479,
0.5678396821022034,
-0.06652849912643433,
0.11545012891292572,
-0.23391976952552795,
-0.3109414577484131,
0.27296438813209534,
-0.12150882184505463,
-0.7393778562545776,
-0.04589780420064926,
-0.8699229955673218,
-0.04884699359536171,
-0.23780056834220886,
0.7620016932487488,
-0.17790834605693817,
0.14426033198833466,
0.22253283858299255,
-0.3107862174510956,
-0.2710987329483032,
-0.2386924773454666,
-0.6075761914253235,
-0.07864223420619965,
0.7340070605278015,
0.13588552176952362,
0.441651314496994,
0.39957818388938904,
0.9957489371299744,
0.3347136974334717,
-0.0921199768781662,
0.06630208343267441,
-0.9675487279891968,
0.00873368326574564,
0.012601551599800587,
-0.4935435354709625,
-0.450188010931015,
0.1629851758480072,
0.667563796043396,
0.4322025179862976,
0.14941942691802979,
0.4371758997440338,
-0.05774366110563278,
0.8452142477035522,
-0.9523081183433533,
0.12306148558855057,
-0.2573412358760834,
0.5655338764190674,
0.05089237168431282,
-0.19524462521076202,
-0.61986243724823,
-0.23425422608852386,
0.12234780937433243,
-0.6929888725280762,
0.595263659954071,
-0.1482761949300766,
0.8078688979148865,
0.5153693556785583,
0.03268274664878845,
0.3470451235771179,
-0.9140574336051941,
0.986745297908783,
0.008033473044633865,
1.0764641761779785,
0.20906947553157806,
0.5725243091583252,
0.09452002495527267,
-0.88527512550354,
-0.32772743701934814,
0.0012556790607050061,
-0.10373968631029129,
0.4980953633785248,
-0.17340247333049774,
0.055622927844524384,
0.45666542649269104,
0.5573883056640625,
-0.2412160485982895,
-0.026002075523138046,
-0.2948678731918335,
0.02461078204214573,
0.09885095804929733,
0.23669645190238953,
-0.3596764802932739,
0.13950438797473907,
-0.5334314703941345,
-0.17699408531188965,
-0.4494427740573883,
0.009437719359993935,
0.16774994134902954,
-0.2938365638256073,
-0.1135801300406456,
0.24683021008968353,
-0.06368858367204666,
0.34813013672828674,
0.48647862672805786,
-0.04234019294381142,
-0.04942186921834946,
-0.057940881699323654,
-0.38519129157066345,
-0.24252572655677795,
0.48283153772354126,
0.010922929272055626,
0.12847912311553955,
-0.5727823972702026,
-0.04497862607240677,
-0.04214777052402496,
0.5733679533004761,
-0.683394730091095,
0.20165684819221497,
0.2791077494621277,
-0.41411304473876953,
0.10461321473121643,
-0.08810677379369736,
-0.7823380827903748,
-0.06851576268672943,
-0.13590940833091736,
0.41314342617988586,
-0.2820355296134949,
-0.08934692293405533,
0.028317593038082123,
0.17885057628154755,
0.4560771882534027,
0.33524155616760254,
-0.908589243888855,
0.16086140275001526,
0.9219818711280823,
0.9599997401237488,
0.006223598495125771,
-0.24331115186214447,
-0.821641206741333,
-0.027509160339832306,
-0.246581569314003,
0.4203284680843353,
-0.4065345823764801,
-0.019889621064066887,
-0.1733749657869339,
-0.35408398509025574,
-0.34484410285949707,
-0.20560523867607117,
0.52082759141922,
-1.0130890607833862,
0.1832931637763977,
0.2945294976234436,
-0.258633017539978,
0.018742313608527184,
0.30567601323127747,
-0.5975660681724548,
0.6878311634063721,
0.4195202887058258,
-0.7280119061470032,
0.038392260670661926,
-0.6988500952720642,
-0.5659720301628113,
-0.1298828274011612,
0.03465768322348595,
-0.8176224231719971,
0.25943559408187866,
0.28560054302215576,
0.6125767230987549,
-0.34237417578697205,
-0.001976911211386323,
-0.2942699193954468,
-0.506270706653595,
0.13077613711357117,
-0.4807191789150238,
0.49071940779685974,
0.20967072248458862,
-0.5570359826087952,
0.05266997963190079,
-0.5680915713310242,
-0.1651116907596588,
0.12858730554580688,
-0.45597392320632935,
0.0929584875702858,
-0.43647274374961853,
0.06278574466705322,
-0.01377299427986145,
0.06759769469499588,
-0.6553282737731934,
0.2760707139968872,
-0.2866533696651459,
0.42538806796073914,
0.8183866143226624,
-0.3383657932281494,
0.6266161799430847,
0.23605044186115265,
0.5684564113616943,
0.027781672775745392,
0.5725283622741699,
-0.11235301941633224,
-0.30935412645339966,
-0.9736855626106262,
-0.5744553804397583,
0.5095400810241699,
0.20986972749233246,
-0.4877752661705017,
0.07332190871238708,
-0.5626306533813477,
-0.5512721538543701,
-0.48230692744255066,
-0.07596704363822937,
0.6986603736877441,
0.49770572781562805,
0.5695093274116516,
-0.2980862855911255,
-0.5856637358665466,
-0.7177762985229492,
-0.19643686711788177,
-0.022109583020210266,
-0.08454224467277527,
0.198100283741951,
0.35097628831863403,
-0.13943630456924438,
0.5907474160194397,
-0.721631646156311,
-0.5531266331672668,
-0.056490208953619,
0.2307026982307434,
0.29095789790153503,
0.43593326210975647,
0.253457635641098,
-0.7480252981185913,
-0.23834197223186493,
-0.11576469987630844,
-0.6938232779502869,
0.6332382559776306,
-0.020312586799263954,
-0.19126051664352417,
-0.06019151955842972,
0.6042587161064148,
-0.7687281966209412,
0.567732572555542,
0.16133318841457367,
0.1605769246816635,
-0.012225454673171043,
-0.07010357826948166,
-0.15999099612236023,
-0.8992555737495422,
0.10281788557767868,
0.27679046988487244,
-0.06613795459270477,
-0.7763445377349854,
0.11580783128738403,
0.26608169078826904,
-0.10080138593912125,
-0.38378196954727173,
0.3651983439922333,
-0.4100019037723541,
-0.045807380229234695,
0.07302436977624893,
-0.1317543387413025,
-0.20749929547309875,
1.042142391204834,
0.23188365995883942,
0.15183070302009583,
0.29387298226356506,
-0.6195888519287109,
0.17591814696788788,
0.3541222810745239,
-0.11972709745168686,
0.8130331039428711,
-0.5445845127105713,
0.2760908603668213,
-0.3841705322265625,
0.279666930437088,
-0.817173182964325,
-0.07908325642347336,
0.2679623067378998,
-0.5772926211357117,
0.5544581413269043,
-0.33872148394584656,
-0.07505684345960617,
-0.33097606897354126,
-0.28015729784965515,
0.7521376013755798,
0.4308677315711975,
-0.818228542804718,
0.8826318383216858,
-0.10758436471223831,
0.32884925603866577,
-1.2839205265045166,
-0.4592643678188324,
-0.24577151238918304,
-0.10156957060098648,
-0.43811938166618347,
0.2823801040649414,
0.17975150048732758,
-0.08139500021934509,
-0.18092890083789825,
-0.15501928329467773,
0.020440509542822838,
0.2698201835155487,
-0.05686744302511215,
0.03654708340764046,
-0.4504908621311188,
-0.033202167600393295,
-0.3950066566467285,
-0.40783363580703735,
-0.015523940324783325,
-0.3484959006309509,
0.6228825449943542,
-0.09003546833992004,
-0.2948508858680725,
-0.5467022061347961,
0.4212072193622589,
0.7624132037162781,
-0.41793155670166016,
0.3893747925758362,
1.1016807556152344,
-0.5609506964683533,
0.11312402039766312,
-0.582359254360199,
-0.3695162236690521,
-0.4388320744037628,
0.6180214881896973,
-0.3208097517490387,
-0.4993199110031128,
0.41548776626586914,
0.365048885345459,
0.2341206669807434,
0.384443074464798,
0.7022911906242371,
0.086232028901577,
1.0178529024124146,
0.6459916234016418,
-0.2314465492963791,
0.7550184726715088,
-0.5959979295730591,
0.47390055656433105,
-0.9311699867248535,
-0.4186538755893707,
-0.2838643193244934,
-0.8048778176307678,
-0.4981323182582855,
-0.10475769639015198,
0.428092360496521,
-0.20309065282344818,
-0.2825513482093811,
0.27313947677612305,
-0.1971331387758255,
0.5169309973716736,
0.6631121039390564,
0.3212962746620178,
0.020557276904582977,
-0.05412299931049347,
0.1632416695356369,
-0.07945609092712402,
-0.6820127964019775,
0.39746588468551636,
0.7103953957557678,
0.6777963042259216,
1.0445808172225952,
0.23088689148426056,
0.5481843948364258,
-0.11974606662988663,
0.44490134716033936,
-1.256745457649231,
0.24963197112083435,
0.11639053374528885,
-0.4079005718231201,
-0.2772074341773987,
-0.45204275846481323,
-0.8147900700569153,
0.15682131052017212,
0.012388285249471664,
-0.47575831413269043,
0.5427055358886719,
0.1674087643623352,
-0.41515424847602844,
0.2505754828453064,
-1.028552532196045,
0.5246484875679016,
-0.004971702583134174,
-0.7505524158477783,
-0.20912912487983704,
-0.916343092918396,
0.23864151537418365,
0.05293092876672745,
-0.1384681612253189,
0.18021321296691895,
0.1471693217754364,
0.7709948420524597,
-0.3779427111148834,
0.6168845891952515,
-0.3199479281902313,
-0.03359471261501312,
-0.10922212898731232,
0.04462413117289543,
0.26643994450569153,
0.3939618766307831,
0.5665136575698853,
0.004135947208851576,
-0.785656750202179,
-0.5727506875991821,
-0.8185555934906006,
0.4438437223434448,
-0.6826440691947937,
-0.6966831684112549,
-0.33588501811027527,
-0.5859168171882629,
-0.5037345290184021,
0.2598153054714203,
0.2725895047187805,
0.6277956962585449,
0.29532501101493835,
0.24332047998905182,
0.9422546029090881,
0.3869481086730957,
0.7495303153991699,
0.12580007314682007,
0.285025954246521,
-0.5314481258392334,
0.838610053062439,
0.1499669849872589,
0.02367679588496685,
0.839818000793457,
0.1119331419467926,
-0.2958420515060425,
-0.3148541748523712,
-0.4182208180427551,
0.32071173191070557,
-0.7625390291213989,
-0.3275340497493744,
-0.6925575733184814,
-0.1569201648235321,
-0.30597782135009766,
-0.13238020241260529,
-0.5656930804252625,
-0.4682857096195221,
-0.2493387758731842,
0.1055474802851677,
0.30254900455474854,
0.5449900031089783,
-0.001467163790948689,
0.283059686422348,
-0.7676812410354614,
0.6221709251403809,
0.47291234135627747,
0.8058911561965942,
0.29762890934944153,
-0.45533791184425354,
-0.4957888722419739,
-0.4313090443611145,
-0.37521106004714966,
-0.38029927015304565,
0.12637291848659515,
0.12209900468587875,
0.4922127425670624,
0.6239944100379944,
-0.1677825003862381,
0.649553656578064,
-0.5616995692253113,
0.30050861835479736,
0.3884217441082001,
-0.7414663434028625,
0.10342611372470856,
-0.06408532708883286,
0.3210791349411011,
0.27222612500190735,
0.6018131971359253,
-0.27985525131225586,
-0.19332259893417358,
-0.6660341620445251,
-0.7524844408035278,
0.8829683661460876,
0.5335206985473633,
0.02136223576962948,
0.282363623380661,
0.3619222640991211,
-0.19386687874794006,
-0.0958251804113388,
-0.3632868826389313,
-0.41612499952316284,
-0.5029061436653137,
-0.23964259028434753,
-0.31087741255760193,
-0.11032333970069885,
-0.07355448603630066,
-0.27466627955436707,
0.5417709350585938,
-0.17954684793949127,
0.9229610562324524,
0.3506731688976288,
-0.30628281831741333,
0.008376258425414562,
0.11649127304553986,
0.9204046130180359,
0.4205341339111328,
-0.31207090616226196,
0.2935331165790558,
0.09869234263896942,
-0.8969094753265381,
0.09095217287540436,
0.18971921503543854,
0.1708063781261444,
-0.16897478699684143,
0.19228313863277435,
0.8076780438423157,
0.11818249523639679,
-0.08830352127552032,
0.569986879825592,
-0.5513471364974976,
-0.025907911360263824,
-0.06957680732011795,
-0.25132450461387634,
-0.08549939841032028,
0.4783370792865753,
0.5372974872589111,
0.3117172420024872,
0.03570196405053139,
0.049104198813438416,
-0.049749333411455154,
0.32191213965415955,
-0.8899127244949341,
-0.30828455090522766,
0.9400237202644348,
0.11586200445890427,
-0.43120601773262024,
0.6302587985992432,
0.2796209454536438,
-0.5647428035736084,
0.5251709222793579,
0.3781559467315674,
1.0411008596420288,
-0.2148766666650772,
-0.16419275104999542,
0.26117148995399475,
0.14161524176597595,
0.1121763288974762,
0.06485218554735184,
-0.38035717606544495,
-0.3846060037612915,
-0.6032528877258301,
-0.3684726357460022,
-0.4420318603515625,
0.12409653514623642,
-0.6847400069236755,
0.230817511677742,
-0.7078894376754761,
-0.15233804285526276,
0.15170849859714508,
-0.5281014442443848,
-0.7180113792419434,
0.27576616406440735,
-0.09068385511636734,
0.6643556952476501,
-0.3016803562641144,
0.35065242648124695,
0.42585116624832153,
-0.2398337870836258,
-0.36240705847740173,
0.024588046595454216,
-0.5943505167961121,
-0.9704942107200623,
0.8012111186981201,
0.47195670008659363,
-0.5143045783042908,
0.30825984477996826,
-0.37325069308280945,
-0.4677225351333618,
0.7103187441825867,
0.5521236062049866,
-0.33038556575775146,
-0.17257536947727203,
0.07002311944961548,
0.5155086517333984,
0.11683693528175354,
0.5146485567092896,
0.43730345368385315,
0.20865017175674438,
-0.1695621758699417,
-0.5175713300704956,
-0.17478050291538239,
-0.40142369270324707,
-0.07516692578792572,
0.38905835151672363,
-1.0908424854278564,
0.7283025979995728,
-0.31061744689941406,
-0.11030823737382889,
-0.11523603647947311,
1.0502794981002808,
-0.3689284324645996,
0.11018600314855576,
0.3927738666534424,
0.6405693888664246,
0.25902485847473145,
-0.29945358633995056,
0.9823085069656372,
-0.13875767588615417,
0.8308324217796326,
0.4493255913257599,
0.14423012733459473,
0.4542941153049469,
0.740474283695221,
-0.14888551831245422,
0.18042239546775818,
0.4654923379421234,
0.06107575073838234,
0.614710807800293,
0.027952194213867188,
-0.1073123887181282,
-0.19621215760707855,
-0.04039619863033295,
-0.40988555550575256,
0.37762320041656494,
0.19932998716831207,
-0.5214458107948303,
-0.0024060129653662443,
0.01791980303823948,
-0.023041177541017532,
-0.22279110550880432,
-0.5301818251609802,
0.6551323533058167,
0.05675842985510826,
-0.7611532211303711,
0.9423074722290039,
-0.2127530872821808,
0.5227614641189575,
-0.32128989696502686,
-0.021454207599163055,
-0.3645005524158478,
0.7710371613502502,
-0.17403171956539154,
-0.3763943910598755,
-0.06996318697929382,
-0.2478436976671219,
-0.1642216444015503,
-0.24734985828399658,
0.31105905771255493,
-0.011116916313767433,
-0.3646557033061981,
-0.02364542707800865,
0.14043845236301422,
-0.38625773787498474,
0.1588829606771469,
-0.10505294054746628,
-0.4469795823097229,
-0.4216172397136688,
-0.38271281123161316,
0.10375040024518967,
-0.0962899923324585,
0.18774937093257904,
0.5894898772239685,
0.16968005895614624,
-0.487113893032074,
0.3404170274734497,
-0.150271475315094,
0.5157185196876526,
-0.3756504952907562,
-0.6355211734771729,
-0.8370932936668396,
0.25901806354522705,
0.0011248048394918442,
-0.456790953874588,
0.4199824035167694,
0.4332890510559082,
0.9025066494941711,
-0.45419493317604065,
0.4628876745700836,
0.20023098587989807,
0.18279631435871124,
-0.6421465873718262,
0.40886232256889343,
-0.3854037821292877,
-0.10128255933523178,
-0.15658283233642578,
-0.8989579677581787,
-0.6689041256904602,
0.5883038640022278,
-0.2507797181606293,
0.2299153059720993,
0.8787222504615784,
0.323426216840744,
-0.3825308680534363,
0.24188101291656494,
0.1842297464609146,
0.014582142233848572,
0.3079768419265747,
0.805099368095398,
0.9708369374275208,
-0.531816840171814,
0.5294978618621826,
-0.5127219557762146,
-0.047064460813999176,
-0.2947530448436737,
-0.64104825258255,
-0.8938325643539429,
-0.4259662926197052,
-0.16537220776081085,
-0.6436869502067566,
-0.09169455617666245,
0.6897149682044983,
0.7049328088760376,
-0.6208444833755493,
0.16046904027462006,
-0.07780474424362183,
0.136625275015831,
-0.5100475549697876,
-0.18138696253299713,
0.7592552304267883,
-0.22273442149162292,
-0.967402458190918,
-0.06692954152822495,
0.20398014783859253,
-0.007501192856580019,
-0.5863385796546936,
-0.0981624498963356,
-0.11520823836326599,
-0.17367763817310333,
0.7000461220741272,
0.451808363199234,
-0.40321072936058044,
-0.26919025182724,
0.6814385056495667,
-0.07387571036815643,
0.528186023235321,
1.1216881275177002,
-0.7149305939674377,
0.35283076763153076,
0.5438048243522644,
1.0691317319869995,
0.8729293942451477,
-0.26244744658470154,
0.29986926913261414,
-0.9560357332229614,
0.22990567982196808,
0.1114194393157959,
0.4670661985874176,
0.30609288811683655,
-0.5212472677230835,
0.5444770455360413,
0.39575836062431335,
-0.19252438843250275,
-0.6474795937538147,
0.4127502143383026,
-1.070473313331604,
0.4211035668849945,
0.9986947178840637,
-0.25676971673965454,
-0.5610781908035278,
-0.14456243813037872,
-0.15929755568504333,
0.46222060918807983,
-0.2704409062862396,
0.9120249152183533,
0.24029669165611267,
-0.3349781334400177,
-0.0859227180480957,
-0.06872902810573578,
0.35021403431892395,
0.6642041802406311,
-0.4438767433166504,
-0.022562997415661812,
-0.11831626296043396,
-0.12439234554767609,
0.6908572316169739,
0.2271287888288498,
-0.1671907901763916,
0.6872772574424744,
-0.222691148519516,
-0.43070200085639954,
-0.05108770355582237,
-0.46347296237945557,
-0.3924976885318756,
0.4644790589809418,
-0.23296451568603516,
-0.4553789496421814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16406v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16406v2
|
SpinQuant: LLM quantization with learned rotations
| 2024-05-26T02:15:49 | 2024-05-28T18:14:15 |
Zechun Liu, Changsheng Zhao, Igor Fedorov, Bilge Soran, Dhruv Choudhary, Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi, Vikas Chandra, Yuandong Tian, Tijmen Blankevoort
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Post-training quantization (PTQ) techniques applied to weights, activations,
and the KV cache greatly reduce memory usage, latency, and power consumption of
Large Language Models (LLMs), but may lead to large quantization errors when
outliers are present. Recent findings suggest that rotating activation or
weight matrices helps remove outliers and benefits quantization. In this work,
we identify a collection of applicable rotation parameterizations that lead to
identical outputs in full-precision Transformer architectures, and find that
some random rotations lead to much better quantization than others, with an up
to 13 points difference in downstream zero-shot reasoning performance. As a
result, we propose SpinQuant that optimizes (or learns) the rotation matrices
with Cayley optimization on a small validation set. With 4-bit quantization of
weight, activation, and KV-cache, SpinQuant narrows the accuracy gap on
zero-shot reasoning tasks with full precision to merely 2.9 points on the
LLaMA-2 7B model, surpassing LLM-QAT by 19.1 points and SmoothQuant by 25.0
points. SpinQuant also outperforms concurrent work QuaRot, which applies random
rotations to remove outliers. In particular, for LLaMA-2 7B/LLaMA-3 8B models
that are hard to quantize, SpinQuant reduces the gap to full precision by
30.2%/34.1% relative to QuaRot.
|
[
-0.23340140283107758,
-0.614713728427887,
0.7083145380020142,
0.02853294089436531,
-0.34255221486091614,
0.3502975106239319,
-0.3047751188278198,
-0.07835650444030762,
0.10358775407075882,
0.2538217306137085,
-0.38992926478385925,
-0.29985329508781433,
-0.5410000681877136,
-0.22101925313472748,
-0.4653798043727875,
0.9876571893692017,
-0.04566939175128937,
0.3542807996273041,
-0.2568219304084778,
-0.12577775120735168,
-0.05559141933917999,
-0.4193566143512726,
-0.5619459748268127,
-0.7809144258499146,
0.322593629360199,
0.46828389167785645,
1.0203216075897217,
0.40953561663627625,
0.621124804019928,
0.18168051540851593,
-0.21606023609638214,
-0.043849095702171326,
-0.45475178956985474,
0.33412688970565796,
-0.06311864405870438,
-0.9336413145065308,
-0.404548704624176,
-0.17450672388076782,
0.48512086272239685,
0.6174214482307434,
-0.34363865852355957,
0.3194461762905121,
-0.3683583736419678,
1.0200212001800537,
-0.7671850323677063,
0.17415615916252136,
-0.5557252764701843,
0.28937968611717224,
-0.2814827263355255,
-0.07347583770751953,
-0.22642730176448822,
-0.3951503336429596,
-0.04770281910896301,
-0.8710911273956299,
0.3844219446182251,
0.03623316064476967,
0.9275280833244324,
0.3695008456707001,
-0.2889598309993744,
-0.009900807403028011,
-0.9070957899093628,
1.0356109142303467,
-0.45722928643226624,
0.34508800506591797,
0.16201408207416534,
0.27083492279052734,
-0.08959099650382996,
-0.6394969820976257,
-0.7276419401168823,
-0.16370680928230286,
0.42984890937805176,
0.4087351858615875,
-0.32914721965789795,
0.0911954790353775,
0.4117073118686676,
0.6023561954498291,
-0.5372044444084167,
-0.0996803343296051,
-0.45359691977500916,
-0.015531390905380249,
0.350533127784729,
0.020202575251460075,
-0.14096103608608246,
-0.008377457968890667,
-0.08637311309576035,
-0.7686547040939331,
-0.9823053479194641,
0.04609840363264084,
0.4779284596443176,
-0.2737501561641693,
0.20280061662197113,
0.8997461199760437,
-0.3903278112411499,
0.4965377449989319,
0.5609371066093445,
-0.16723671555519104,
0.10759512335062027,
0.12110528349876404,
-0.22312477231025696,
-0.03502202406525612,
0.6786215901374817,
0.009910873137414455,
0.3294605314731598,
-0.2485879808664322,
-0.18292443454265594,
-0.09335891157388687,
0.3245830535888672,
-0.7363643050193787,
-0.42873069643974304,
0.2691218852996826,
-0.34316733479499817,
-0.4154975712299347,
0.04861387610435486,
-0.32153043150901794,
-0.3808475434780121,
-0.5689846873283386,
0.7855483293533325,
-0.5899956822395325,
-0.212279811501503,
0.34460002183914185,
-0.2152496874332428,
0.5937960743904114,
0.44535017013549805,
-0.5091734528541565,
-0.059511225670576096,
0.8170679807662964,
0.5463687181472778,
-0.3880542516708374,
-0.009054887108504772,
-0.2618013620376587,
0.017203956842422485,
-0.5943062901496887,
0.7384582161903381,
-0.1652841418981552,
-0.1449318677186966,
-0.2540636658668518,
-0.5063309669494629,
-0.005168806295841932,
-0.5959070324897766,
0.38799506425857544,
-0.9517987370491028,
0.17261825501918793,
-0.3132731318473816,
-0.3683297634124756,
-0.4016770124435425,
0.2302449643611908,
-0.7104645371437073,
1.0639808177947998,
0.2131624072790146,
-0.5699476599693298,
0.24398748576641083,
-0.4386464059352875,
-0.3616943061351776,
-0.07458963245153427,
0.027701007202267647,
-0.6310967803001404,
0.5376920104026794,
0.1323196440935135,
0.16214913129806519,
-0.7087352275848389,
0.36957788467407227,
-0.28339266777038574,
-0.46772709488868713,
0.5198677778244019,
-0.4883294701576233,
0.8763061165809631,
0.23801396787166595,
-0.35534587502479553,
0.1922752559185028,
-0.7568822503089905,
0.2906651496887207,
0.2262854278087616,
-0.057653944939374924,
0.023178378120064735,
-0.27743303775787354,
-0.45012110471725464,
0.039396386593580246,
0.2242100089788437,
-0.2972407639026642,
-0.02761959098279476,
-0.35775601863861084,
0.24512478709220886,
0.5191680788993835,
-0.1956184357404709,
0.7300781607627869,
-0.4436083436012268,
0.7880011796951294,
0.2632404863834381,
0.14677782356739044,
0.06531409174203873,
-0.4629228115081787,
-1.2657976150512695,
-0.3447595238685608,
0.33881139755249023,
0.7660331130027771,
-1.0734736919403076,
0.42233017086982727,
-0.4045988917350769,
-0.6069161295890808,
-0.3652826249599457,
0.026575326919555664,
0.4029437005519867,
0.37386569380760193,
0.37782686948776245,
-0.18141233921051025,
-0.3116929531097412,
-0.7021316289901733,
-0.2756839990615845,
-0.2066834568977356,
-0.24802598357200623,
-0.3565713167190552,
0.39422133564949036,
0.1604187935590744,
0.9798581004142761,
-0.49356502294540405,
-0.1873054951429367,
-0.23026026785373688,
0.41989845037460327,
0.40332505106925964,
0.19623099267482758,
0.19397200644016266,
-0.49720948934555054,
-0.5989691615104675,
-0.06088469177484512,
-0.6917182207107544,
-0.01120828464627266,
-0.03482887148857117,
-0.12048453837633133,
0.20834612846374512,
0.4298665225505829,
-1.1176481246948242,
0.4991668462753296,
0.41997289657592773,
0.15453210473060608,
0.6170685291290283,
-0.18984705209732056,
-0.0019032121635973454,
-0.8529418110847473,
-0.16575796902179718,
-0.15751023590564728,
-0.24467173218727112,
-0.5934478640556335,
0.13956275582313538,
0.2241974174976349,
-0.048293694853782654,
-0.3157810866832733,
0.16690239310264587,
-0.2645373046398163,
-0.06082477793097496,
-0.20979976654052734,
0.020270299166440964,
0.15551285445690155,
0.5107185244560242,
0.05581000819802284,
0.929564893245697,
0.3572081923484802,
-0.2536770701408386,
0.28444746136665344,
-0.14242540299892426,
-0.15835174918174744,
0.7197594046592712,
-0.701368510723114,
0.2474973201751709,
-0.32446733117103577,
0.1381828337907791,
-0.9464979767799377,
0.1869472861289978,
0.22650159895420074,
-0.5429391264915466,
0.3546956777572632,
-0.023453695699572563,
-0.5268241167068481,
-0.12242081016302109,
-0.6324554085731506,
0.4673795700073242,
0.4830934405326843,
-0.4676241874694824,
0.5883464813232422,
0.10245474427938461,
0.3245602548122406,
-0.7301737070083618,
-0.43905898928642273,
-0.2843099534511566,
-0.24168580770492554,
-0.43712276220321655,
0.4436843693256378,
0.14240078628063202,
-0.28385481238365173,
-0.13654431700706482,
-0.3936940133571625,
-0.001959826797246933,
-0.11564158648252487,
0.06221160292625427,
0.17940518260002136,
-0.25245314836502075,
0.24114994704723358,
0.11670791357755661,
-0.4271763265132904,
0.09596739709377289,
-0.4063796401023865,
0.7991158366203308,
-0.4860513210296631,
-0.49480965733528137,
-0.1961597353219986,
-0.013259232975542545,
0.5347248911857605,
-0.1854870468378067,
0.7495627403259277,
0.9791128039360046,
-0.1632215976715088,
0.014095866121351719,
-0.6810922622680664,
-0.24728073179721832,
-0.48630768060684204,
0.30054959654808044,
-0.43488097190856934,
-1.084088683128357,
0.33902567625045776,
0.07671334594488144,
-0.29225361347198486,
0.5605164170265198,
0.5817052721977234,
-0.31148943305015564,
0.957033097743988,
0.3706238865852356,
0.05082976445555687,
0.46155402064323425,
-0.5075520277023315,
0.6059452295303345,
-0.8482992649078369,
0.059234991669654846,
-0.418374627828598,
-0.2394685298204422,
-0.5637291073799133,
-0.9405651092529297,
0.6366948485374451,
0.5607674717903137,
-0.5226660966873169,
0.30657073855400085,
-0.4711135923862457,
0.574837863445282,
0.8375959992408752,
0.10939522087574005,
0.3688605725765228,
0.3260946273803711,
-0.09750187397003174,
-0.1550712138414383,
-0.6185436248779297,
-0.14075404405593872,
1.3732936382293701,
0.08117731660604477,
0.8346542119979858,
-0.016357379034161568,
0.6276975274085999,
-0.008010215125977993,
0.32253360748291016,
-1.0676906108856201,
0.3815757930278778,
0.019038746133446693,
-0.42853450775146484,
-0.3576676547527313,
-0.41995447874069214,
-0.6979907155036926,
0.3227632939815521,
-0.2449551820755005,
-0.3330903649330139,
-0.03773841634392738,
0.036922041326761246,
-0.43743303418159485,
0.43352946639060974,
-0.5245822668075562,
0.3442041575908661,
-0.15716174244880676,
-0.15216970443725586,
-0.5210856199264526,
-0.39125919342041016,
0.38922321796417236,
-0.08783864974975586,
-0.17514891922473907,
-0.09905322641134262,
0.13011719286441803,
0.5799093842506409,
-0.38381314277648926,
0.559032142162323,
0.044993843883275986,
0.031387172639369965,
0.45822733640670776,
0.3227602243423462,
0.5826709270477295,
0.11268611997365952,
0.10883212834596634,
0.46731048822402954,
0.08003149926662445,
-0.20238491892814636,
-0.6535447239875793,
0.356378436088562,
-0.9693024754524231,
-0.6889001727104187,
-0.6261661648750305,
-0.7457742691040039,
-0.22737476229667664,
0.10339745879173279,
0.31019270420074463,
-0.017478900030255318,
0.2915555238723755,
0.4643142819404602,
1.1874456405639648,
-0.18564268946647644,
0.36498939990997314,
0.4359517991542816,
-0.06883926689624786,
-0.7596604824066162,
0.8500139117240906,
0.04343615472316742,
0.32992276549339294,
0.7180693745613098,
0.2986733615398407,
-0.17268262803554535,
-0.3708459436893463,
-0.21710056066513062,
0.40545454621315,
-0.7738038897514343,
-0.866229772567749,
-0.43340224027633667,
-0.4881424009799957,
-0.2450718730688095,
-0.13457974791526794,
-0.6213676929473877,
-1.2394753694534302,
-0.19717592000961304,
-0.0025894923601299524,
0.5837039947509766,
0.31838151812553406,
-0.1952800154685974,
0.84323650598526,
-0.4671938419342041,
0.47683748602867126,
0.4792129397392273,
0.01131227146834135,
0.041934289038181305,
-0.686951220035553,
-0.19611166417598724,
0.09699960052967072,
-0.7575203776359558,
-0.6293830871582031,
0.3705357611179352,
0.08137323707342148,
0.2655795216560364,
0.547214686870575,
-0.14678460359573364,
0.8779091238975525,
-0.21525737643241882,
0.5216021537780762,
0.4727339446544647,
-1.1964408159255981,
0.1516609638929367,
-0.12702617049217224,
0.4510997235774994,
0.3801356852054596,
0.3932279944419861,
-0.5357568264007568,
-0.32422125339508057,
-0.6186833381652832,
-0.7907730340957642,
0.5120499730110168,
0.24169068038463593,
-0.1264224499464035,
0.1268111914396286,
0.5599246025085449,
-0.29462531208992004,
0.3232508897781372,
-0.7322185635566711,
-0.3317529261112213,
-0.08989004790782928,
-0.35382428765296936,
0.2680686414241791,
-0.30895522236824036,
-0.14348725974559784,
-0.376910001039505,
0.6823683977127075,
-0.2405300885438919,
0.4600410461425781,
0.10388415306806564,
-0.5284268260002136,
-0.39861199259757996,
0.16255366802215576,
0.6064234972000122,
0.8161541223526001,
-0.04739004746079445,
0.12196414917707443,
0.45692986249923706,
-0.6265222430229187,
0.19650067389011383,
-0.1262074112892151,
-0.45039716362953186,
-0.23349057137966156,
0.07830285280942917,
0.5511983633041382,
-0.04827247932553291,
-0.36726081371307373,
0.6021929383277893,
0.027235524728894234,
-0.07508407533168793,
-0.5567550659179688,
0.1090538501739502,
0.0989413857460022,
0.4716942608356476,
0.4708542823791504,
0.08434124290943146,
0.06250318884849548,
-0.003661156864836812,
-0.0750170573592186,
0.7253013849258423,
-0.41986048221588135,
-0.36420097947120667,
0.5885131359100342,
-0.4592517018318176,
-0.06565344333648682,
0.5330350399017334,
-0.3540610074996948,
-0.5810369849205017,
0.5068345069885254,
0.4790237247943878,
0.8666567206382751,
-0.20681822299957275,
0.34624603390693665,
0.44318416714668274,
0.32716360688209534,
-0.21155819296836853,
0.35960832238197327,
-0.20220114290714264,
-0.9867048859596252,
-0.7620053291320801,
-0.5664609670639038,
-0.6539080142974854,
-0.16310694813728333,
-0.8322166800498962,
0.32851722836494446,
-0.5928280353546143,
-0.254092276096344,
-0.24496260285377502,
0.22664226591587067,
-0.6047577261924744,
0.03682009503245354,
0.03310267999768257,
0.5259973406791687,
-0.5217205286026001,
1.0819416046142578,
0.5944940447807312,
-0.2892073690891266,
-0.7284560203552246,
-0.3205144703388214,
-0.1030932292342186,
-1.0072704553604126,
0.6094338297843933,
-0.11428449302911758,
-0.3194621503353119,
0.021569080650806427,
-0.48152461647987366,
-1.1351349353790283,
1.3352882862091064,
0.45105406641960144,
-0.49339210987091064,
0.11831135302782059,
0.5785892605781555,
0.549225926399231,
0.04412216320633888,
0.5608780384063721,
0.659701943397522,
0.240477055311203,
0.41269853711128235,
-0.7044711112976074,
-0.1362704485654831,
0.23696792125701904,
0.21983036398887634,
0.4068969786167145,
-0.7027077078819275,
0.9698293209075928,
-0.18587075173854828,
0.032987408339977264,
0.015107978135347366,
0.9070593118667603,
0.6645190715789795,
0.03027430921792984,
0.3477310240268707,
0.956739068031311,
0.8010950684547424,
-0.3350914716720581,
0.6714058518409729,
-0.3610142767429352,
0.48226669430732727,
0.9402074217796326,
-0.32863670587539673,
0.6943118572235107,
0.7560098171234131,
-0.48330748081207275,
0.42366260290145874,
0.1807413548231125,
0.2179396152496338,
0.35264819860458374,
0.36313536763191223,
-0.37089428305625916,
-0.40796416997909546,
0.3189692497253418,
-0.3025975227355957,
0.3846083879470825,
0.4623439610004425,
0.12186625599861145,
-0.19673794507980347,
-0.11552798002958298,
0.4734570384025574,
-0.3431391417980194,
-0.060034673660993576,
0.3886934816837311,
0.2364097535610199,
-0.655834436416626,
0.480985552072525,
0.20700035989284515,
0.6002218127250671,
-0.5405920743942261,
0.051155101507902145,
-0.3288130462169647,
0.4843609929084778,
-0.027655262500047684,
-0.6158617734909058,
0.39729824662208557,
-0.4549401104450226,
-0.2853570580482483,
-0.32741519808769226,
0.6832990646362305,
-0.3057805597782135,
-0.6968974471092224,
-0.1506744921207428,
0.4678381681442261,
-0.16164454817771912,
-0.5092007517814636,
-0.6202943325042725,
-0.11585808545351028,
-0.057760488241910934,
-0.34714508056640625,
0.32578784227371216,
0.6047506928443909,
-0.27010008692741394,
0.7479106187820435,
0.8389503955841064,
0.20428165793418884,
0.22082236409187317,
-0.022347547113895416,
0.8010353446006775,
-0.6770991086959839,
0.020971307530999184,
-0.5753145813941956,
0.22072343528270721,
0.02183627150952816,
-0.31961506605148315,
0.6113568544387817,
0.4509458541870117,
0.8433333039283752,
-0.10686657577753067,
0.26181745529174805,
-0.01988675631582737,
0.4584410488605499,
-0.43311354517936707,
0.753806471824646,
-0.2503144145011902,
0.19480399787425995,
0.1922711730003357,
-1.0342981815338135,
-0.6235406994819641,
1.077848196029663,
-0.3701663315296173,
-0.07304125279188156,
0.8845551609992981,
0.8865436315536499,
0.06918147951364517,
-0.003406420350074768,
0.4212389588356018,
-0.034326352179050446,
0.43734458088874817,
0.5741033554077148,
0.9950613379478455,
-0.7997584939002991,
0.6721594333648682,
-0.6261982321739197,
-0.05467527359724045,
-0.030218597501516342,
-0.9879987239837646,
-0.8057140707969666,
-0.3060290813446045,
-0.5675474405288696,
-0.4078025817871094,
-0.10241895169019699,
0.7744196653366089,
0.598113477230072,
-0.9985208511352539,
-0.4922713041305542,
-0.10939411073923111,
0.3467590808868408,
-0.3446674644947052,
-0.32032254338264465,
0.4210696816444397,
-0.5615936517715454,
-0.4672814607620239,
0.1216396912932396,
0.38816308975219727,
-0.11905504018068314,
-0.25415274500846863,
-0.08363790065050125,
0.21315841376781464,
-0.006812984123826027,
0.7310364246368408,
0.11327376961708069,
-0.566515326499939,
-0.14154517650604248,
0.3919484317302704,
0.09140271693468094,
0.21755744516849518,
0.9897522330284119,
-0.8338944911956787,
0.29261884093284607,
0.5361738204956055,
0.2926185429096222,
0.9769853949546814,
-0.23343396186828613,
0.5464556813240051,
-0.41640886664390564,
0.34238937497138977,
0.3456915318965912,
0.12013036757707596,
0.13292288780212402,
-0.2421644926071167,
0.5185545086860657,
0.3126276731491089,
-0.5702093839645386,
-0.6182426810264587,
0.038598377257585526,
-0.9703077077865601,
0.11681419610977173,
1.1078749895095825,
-0.01820683665573597,
-0.42715319991111755,
0.20230577886104584,
0.09307259321212769,
0.42797166109085083,
-0.15657366812229156,
0.8994736075401306,
0.6702207326889038,
-0.16010339558124542,
-0.3582771122455597,
-0.41816720366477966,
0.4866800606250763,
0.7852332592010498,
-0.48182329535484314,
-0.42766648530960083,
0.1900283694267273,
0.2955370545387268,
0.25196802616119385,
0.23749200999736786,
-0.47197863459587097,
0.4156681001186371,
-0.2958672344684601,
0.31019356846809387,
0.11535883694887161,
-0.2905842363834381,
-0.5294294953346252,
-0.005775755271315575,
0.21586103737354279,
0.059989284723997116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16402v1
|
Assessing Empathy in Large Language Models with Real-World Physician-Patient Interactions
| 2024-05-26T01:58:57 | 2024-05-26T01:58:57 |
Man Luo, Christopher J. Warren, Lu Cheng, Haidar M. Abdul-Muhsin, Imon Banerjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into the healthcare domain
has the potential to significantly enhance patient care and support through the
development of empathetic, patient-facing chatbots. This study investigates an
intriguing question Can ChatGPT respond with a greater degree of empathy than
those typically offered by physicians? To answer this question, we collect a
de-identified dataset of patient messages and physician responses from Mayo
Clinic and generate alternative replies using ChatGPT. Our analyses incorporate
novel empathy ranking evaluation (EMRank) involving both automated metrics and
human assessments to gauge the empathy level of responses. Our findings
indicate that LLM-powered chatbots have the potential to surpass human
physicians in delivering empathetic communication, suggesting a promising
avenue for enhancing patient care and reducing professional burnout. The study
not only highlights the importance of empathy in patient interactions but also
proposes a set of effective automatic empathy ranking metrics, paving the way
for the broader adoption of LLMs in healthcare.
|
[
-0.37720856070518494,
-0.7856841683387756,
0.8502053022384644,
-0.0031192658934742212,
-0.08525268733501434,
-0.02877907268702984,
-0.31182345747947693,
-0.5975362062454224,
0.30700260400772095,
0.2576580047607422,
-0.46259233355522156,
-0.3018598258495331,
-1.0548076629638672,
0.0762917622923851,
-0.17595639824867249,
0.6919512748718262,
0.18621826171875,
0.356221079826355,
-0.18413791060447693,
-0.11036184430122375,
-0.0034337174147367477,
-0.7548973560333252,
-0.9159864783287048,
-0.5050125122070312,
0.8078192472457886,
0.28053879737854004,
0.840946614742279,
0.23084914684295654,
0.835546612739563,
0.3280469477176666,
0.018586179241538048,
0.030083976686000824,
-0.4871141016483307,
-0.011513386853039265,
0.17183540761470795,
-0.1898607760667801,
-0.9645273089408875,
0.26234859228134155,
0.20102237164974213,
0.6876499056816101,
-0.245508074760437,
0.06996767967939377,
0.09216900169849396,
0.4219309389591217,
-0.15340150892734528,
0.02284220978617668,
-0.23867322504520416,
0.42751479148864746,
0.3751816153526306,
-0.37985026836395264,
-0.40958788990974426,
-0.4770624041557312,
0.2513403594493866,
-0.1869107186794281,
-0.12270016223192215,
0.11271100491285324,
0.5123389959335327,
0.2549891173839569,
-0.46436768770217896,
-0.267760306596756,
-0.47264859080314636,
0.7014411687850952,
-0.8168893456459045,
0.269765704870224,
0.2809399664402008,
0.25183776021003723,
0.07069206982851028,
-0.5318148732185364,
-0.5113663673400879,
-0.41761401295661926,
-0.031064337119460106,
0.4687083959579468,
-0.425300657749176,
0.317141592502594,
0.3910297155380249,
0.46659451723098755,
-0.4089491069316864,
0.3938564658164978,
-0.008592961356043816,
0.20897994935512543,
0.6814255714416504,
0.45264551043510437,
0.6213095188140869,
-0.04508199542760849,
-0.10496722161769867,
-0.038702525198459625,
-0.3165573179721832,
-0.1020168885588646,
0.1948060393333435,
-0.00013726894394494593,
-0.4087633788585663,
0.7639046311378479,
0.2532043755054474,
0.4664155840873718,
-0.24990983307361603,
0.10003280639648438,
-0.0035098190419375896,
0.28604504466056824,
-0.36364421248435974,
0.08642983436584473,
0.9758172631263733,
0.9726861715316772,
0.7418203353881836,
-0.052083294838666916,
0.2067946344614029,
0.10150742530822754,
0.6098164916038513,
-0.9094015955924988,
-0.3121815323829651,
0.6238529086112976,
-0.734569787979126,
-0.4084472060203552,
-0.06854847073554993,
-0.8612107038497925,
-0.6529799103736877,
-0.059848565608263016,
0.12707656621932983,
-0.17494040727615356,
-0.4429120719432831,
0.18073947727680206,
-0.10316035151481628,
0.46966227889060974,
0.427285760641098,
-0.8312898278236389,
0.3569883108139038,
0.9676742553710938,
0.8581897616386414,
0.026177702471613884,
-0.22807273268699646,
-0.5639690160751343,
-0.2793389558792114,
-0.4598865211009979,
0.78909832239151,
-0.8362898826599121,
-0.65352863073349,
0.12247245013713837,
-0.13173538446426392,
-0.01722034439444542,
-0.36585015058517456,
0.5730128288269043,
-0.0337146520614624,
0.1813560575246811,
-0.1372055858373642,
-0.6943261623382568,
0.2203075885772705,
0.5619608163833618,
-0.20668768882751465,
0.5660365223884583,
0.3982143998146057,
-0.7457443475723267,
0.1403958797454834,
-0.7557243704795837,
-0.40619149804115295,
-0.036380887031555176,
-0.015095147304236889,
-0.32554709911346436,
0.4322044551372528,
0.12311507761478424,
0.8286659717559814,
-0.5510894060134888,
0.03172557055950165,
-0.5156741738319397,
-0.23352226614952087,
0.48809030652046204,
-0.5020423531532288,
0.36493635177612305,
0.13172096014022827,
0.0389401875436306,
-0.035570159554481506,
-0.3148137331008911,
0.024416420608758926,
0.15915532410144806,
-0.14412029087543488,
-0.17049334943294525,
-0.033938292413949966,
0.11713410913944244,
0.29716506600379944,
-0.0416751503944397,
-0.7495113611221313,
0.21355804800987244,
-0.5337809920310974,
0.386039137840271,
0.8283883333206177,
0.08695920556783676,
0.45502132177352905,
-0.3962650001049042,
0.8056167960166931,
-0.2353687882423401,
0.4883301556110382,
-0.1348370909690857,
-0.7311303019523621,
-0.6315011978149414,
-0.5764321088790894,
-0.2171339988708496,
0.3839583098888397,
0.07219582051038742,
0.5297055244445801,
-0.3747177720069885,
-0.8200902342796326,
-0.8688177466392517,
-0.22828617691993713,
0.48808902502059937,
0.6233316659927368,
0.26342901587486267,
-0.4596339762210846,
-0.06179175525903702,
-0.8570311069488525,
-0.6662144660949707,
-0.049405623227357864,
-0.2285790592432022,
0.9184359908103943,
0.020052922889590263,
-0.3225131034851074,
0.46955162286758423,
-0.5484218001365662,
-0.14003652334213257,
-0.42082974314689636,
-0.2157687544822693,
0.1360408365726471,
0.226496160030365,
0.3042716681957245,
-0.6922635436058044,
-0.7648701071739197,
0.1629110425710678,
-0.7053784728050232,
-0.13714860379695892,
-0.01997830532491207,
-0.016924049705266953,
-0.20163953304290771,
0.40881776809692383,
-0.6520742177963257,
0.4048236906528473,
0.7454122304916382,
-0.44505760073661804,
0.0709998607635498,
-0.22376422584056854,
0.45330485701560974,
-1.1891109943389893,
0.10614190250635147,
0.06103193759918213,
-0.10625402629375458,
-0.8333950042724609,
-0.23083995282649994,
-0.07997851818799973,
-0.023593751713633537,
-0.5266336798667908,
0.9103480577468872,
-0.03872115537524223,
-0.0440339632332325,
-0.10495275259017944,
0.20922380685806274,
-0.20403052866458893,
0.08772904425859451,
0.07364246249198914,
0.43161630630493164,
0.6199554800987244,
-0.20654061436653137,
0.531649112701416,
0.5622381567955017,
-0.08544938266277313,
0.8951204419136047,
-0.8445749282836914,
0.08621668815612793,
0.13650472462177277,
0.33516398072242737,
-1.0080770254135132,
-0.5169462561607361,
0.3484759032726288,
-0.7706537842750549,
0.14735938608646393,
-0.26967653632164,
-0.5334575772285461,
-0.3766021132469177,
-0.09993141144514084,
0.20442955195903778,
0.8980979323387146,
-0.43385836482048035,
0.654292643070221,
0.46886301040649414,
-0.5245897173881531,
-0.03375714644789696,
-0.6708781719207764,
0.2554652988910675,
-0.3344956636428833,
-0.5469865202903748,
-0.18041981756687164,
-0.08800970017910004,
-0.5874179005622864,
-0.4411272406578064,
0.23965448141098022,
-0.09581984579563141,
0.08158161491155624,
0.4650956392288208,
0.11854682117700577,
0.150495246052742,
0.22952085733413696,
0.06149544194340706,
-0.20507551729679108,
0.28768327832221985,
0.3429056406021118,
0.8002943992614746,
-0.08440995216369629,
-0.7762924432754517,
-0.6731306314468384,
0.40352532267570496,
0.7125586867332458,
-0.059604462236166,
0.6492792367935181,
0.4793853759765625,
-0.1714131236076355,
0.31767258048057556,
-0.6202458739280701,
-0.5103800296783447,
-0.423395574092865,
0.3335176408290863,
-0.12499265372753143,
-0.9087536334991455,
0.3935329020023346,
-0.1036037728190422,
0.07799092680215836,
0.06412316113710403,
0.8179377913475037,
-0.03450017049908638,
1.4168503284454346,
0.2797680199146271,
-0.20149312913417816,
0.21115124225616455,
0.06723768264055252,
0.6925852298736572,
-0.9998677372932434,
-0.27221378684043884,
-0.3084394931793213,
-0.35753998160362244,
-0.8493295311927795,
-0.21882887184619904,
0.45230191946029663,
-0.6196255683898926,
-0.22306786477565765,
-0.06709015369415283,
-0.5091678500175476,
0.1086224764585495,
0.20162315666675568,
0.3665848970413208,
0.10044477880001068,
-0.28416991233825684,
0.38206496834754944,
-0.07586552947759628,
-0.537473201751709,
-0.5197194814682007,
0.807415783405304,
0.6702593564987183,
0.8554146885871887,
0.12797702848911285,
0.7785927653312683,
0.2707033157348633,
0.6474986672401428,
-1.1397842168807983,
0.46047669649124146,
-0.047465741634368896,
-0.1907496452331543,
-0.2994978129863739,
-0.4480072855949402,
-1.0058318376541138,
0.16011840105056763,
-0.09070168435573578,
-0.7857205867767334,
-0.28760388493537903,
0.25138401985168457,
-0.318052738904953,
0.1819458305835724,
-0.903653085231781,
0.7304087281227112,
-0.2156141698360443,
-0.15520693361759186,
-0.21745207905769348,
-0.630971372127533,
-0.08724294602870941,
-0.10441870242357254,
0.22797226905822754,
-0.30974844098091125,
-0.07419777661561966,
0.3814065754413605,
-0.3580443263053894,
0.8659831285476685,
-0.10030900686979294,
-0.3358311951160431,
-0.16743029654026031,
0.34012770652770996,
0.20107579231262207,
0.06749612838029861,
-0.18706610798835754,
0.18575569987297058,
-0.18945464491844177,
-0.4904589056968689,
-0.6545296311378479,
0.8440741896629333,
-0.6712567806243896,
-0.5889437198638916,
-0.4180242121219635,
-0.512295663356781,
-0.45175430178642273,
-0.018056748434901237,
-0.03364728018641472,
0.17144709825515747,
-0.4404860734939575,
0.00565565237775445,
0.34646350145339966,
-0.6216633319854736,
0.1439291536808014,
0.4180057644844055,
-0.016110900789499283,
-0.018874147906899452,
0.5824396014213562,
-0.296700119972229,
0.4094575047492981,
0.3583995997905731,
0.5558128356933594,
-0.09628108888864517,
0.04595373198390007,
-0.15191876888275146,
0.35032787919044495,
-0.4095239043235779,
-0.030148621648550034,
-0.9174339771270752,
-0.1320790946483612,
-0.4670040011405945,
-0.6719120144844055,
-0.3859655559062958,
-0.05657239258289337,
-0.19796107709407806,
-0.12157268077135086,
0.5283056497573853,
0.7735201120376587,
0.13162006437778473,
0.2920140027999878,
-1.0588409900665283,
0.14572614431381226,
0.22859661281108856,
0.4464464485645294,
0.14074936509132385,
-0.5430591702461243,
0.14248265326023102,
-0.07498591393232346,
-0.06577485799789429,
-0.766007125377655,
0.7323997020721436,
0.09327322244644165,
0.3494091331958771,
0.6758229732513428,
-0.10402675718069077,
0.5210413932800293,
-0.6949392557144165,
0.8218964338302612,
0.42879390716552734,
-0.7893002033233643,
0.2952960133552551,
-0.5385490655899048,
0.2052668333053589,
0.04246455058455467,
0.49913981556892395,
-0.9346775412559509,
-0.53271484375,
-0.8132306337356567,
-0.6126554012298584,
0.3978537917137146,
-0.08422770351171494,
0.7360879778862,
-0.2705661356449127,
0.21511833369731903,
-0.027139337733387947,
-0.11396890878677368,
-0.2877003848552704,
0.01702081225812435,
0.2093997597694397,
-0.39994606375694275,
-0.3725162446498871,
-0.2804153263568878,
-0.2886594533920288,
0.14028117060661316,
-0.08241281658411026,
0.05865144729614258,
0.5276349186897278,
0.23425285518169403,
0.32659199833869934,
-0.21457593142986298,
0.2700406610965729,
0.15163329243659973,
0.2606266736984253,
-0.014528689906001091,
0.02589806169271469,
0.2559746503829956,
-0.34799808263778687,
-0.2008509784936905,
-0.09441487491130829,
0.7639999985694885,
-0.333682656288147,
0.6004282832145691,
0.20627737045288086,
0.31245124340057373,
-0.9618774056434631,
0.8655287623405457,
-0.2016683667898178,
-0.11745037883520126,
-0.1917678862810135,
0.09020905196666718,
0.2660035192966461,
0.37652915716171265,
-0.08779297024011612,
-0.3103962242603302,
0.26278451085090637,
-0.40828803181648254,
0.13405941426753998,
0.5953177809715271,
-0.6781707406044006,
-0.19350123405456543,
0.32858678698539734,
0.28917744755744934,
-0.7106186151504517,
0.8184479475021362,
0.6911091804504395,
-0.6363353133201599,
0.5860636830329895,
0.3446756601333618,
0.7850582599639893,
-0.3778313994407654,
0.15912707149982452,
0.12599508464336395,
0.009836699813604355,
0.0578489825129509,
0.22008205950260162,
0.05551771819591522,
-0.6479836106300354,
-0.13786344230175018,
-0.3412553071975708,
-0.9360424876213074,
-0.39144736528396606,
-0.8892659544944763,
0.011184563860297203,
-0.4693478047847748,
-0.2788067162036896,
0.029221773147583008,
-0.17898860573768616,
-0.747632622718811,
0.28070318698883057,
0.008639336563646793,
0.725002110004425,
-0.8535842299461365,
0.5277085304260254,
0.573451817035675,
-0.18602289259433746,
-0.5899641513824463,
0.17147685587406158,
-0.04706635698676109,
-1.240071177482605,
0.4661966860294342,
0.2716601490974426,
-0.008521541953086853,
0.05007553845643997,
-0.4004773795604706,
-0.11696343123912811,
0.870290219783783,
0.28978821635246277,
-0.2838955521583557,
0.10215453803539276,
0.1148066371679306,
0.8753955960273743,
-0.3608306348323822,
0.6165006160736084,
0.42802631855010986,
0.3996102809906006,
-0.25101208686828613,
-1.0523056983947754,
-0.06356915086507797,
-0.33875054121017456,
-0.2988625764846802,
0.2070527821779251,
-0.9492587447166443,
0.514710545539856,
-0.38480815291404724,
0.10105686634778976,
0.08930660784244537,
-0.10442683845758438,
0.03148389980196953,
0.29821211099624634,
0.2898236811161041,
0.5648995637893677,
0.5098557472229004,
-0.04047076404094696,
1.4779607057571411,
-0.3546602725982666,
0.2873970866203308,
0.7451356649398804,
-0.45615652203559875,
0.9476979374885559,
0.7106333374977112,
-0.19874152541160583,
0.08998508751392365,
0.5630108714103699,
-0.13181942701339722,
0.026469772681593895,
0.17599140107631683,
-0.514080286026001,
-0.3961964249610901,
-0.4263300895690918,
-0.24168507754802704,
0.469757080078125,
0.2147134393453598,
-0.6976621150970459,
0.1385660469532013,
0.03366217389702797,
0.35236290097236633,
0.04574896767735481,
-0.15387463569641113,
0.8821942806243896,
0.4789924919605255,
-0.5398473739624023,
0.18908710777759552,
-0.35226771235466003,
0.35689347982406616,
-0.3566587269306183,
-0.1897926926612854,
-0.22343701124191284,
0.13782672584056854,
-0.21440830826759338,
-1.0199847221374512,
-0.01358170248568058,
0.29272404313087463,
0.20752426981925964,
-0.4328538179397583,
0.5163149833679199,
-0.11654841899871826,
-0.31239616870880127,
0.6524298787117004,
0.7903659343719482,
0.48851925134658813,
-0.05267047882080078,
-0.6850324869155884,
0.11147377640008926,
-0.29002827405929565,
-0.6333884000778198,
0.6167387962341309,
0.33385220170021057,
0.4788314998149872,
1.0037949085235596,
0.7136732339859009,
0.18578413128852844,
-0.2892748713493347,
0.4097798466682434,
0.9419999718666077,
-0.5368996262550354,
-0.09872356057167053,
-1.0430607795715332,
0.3688928186893463,
-0.210036039352417,
-0.1943047195672989,
0.7732906937599182,
0.3668356239795685,
0.35759106278419495,
-0.10041213780641556,
0.9032220840454102,
-0.07039761543273926,
0.7857756018638611,
-0.22951100766658783,
0.8072172999382019,
-0.7558284997940063,
-0.03053068183362484,
-0.5675921440124512,
-0.6126822829246521,
-0.5770595073699951,
0.6553796529769897,
-0.5417382717132568,
0.28202107548713684,
0.3013671040534973,
0.8270986080169678,
-0.04474392160773277,
-0.10946756601333618,
0.8688668012619019,
0.2702040672302246,
0.5152711868286133,
0.5680349469184875,
1.0205968618392944,
-0.025825191289186478,
0.2152881771326065,
0.12825296819210052,
-0.4360560476779938,
-0.38764724135398865,
-0.8103359341621399,
-0.9937011003494263,
-0.09526842087507248,
-0.02883007749915123,
-0.30639535188674927,
-0.024546634405851364,
1.1839452981948853,
0.3538467288017273,
-0.44836995005607605,
-0.018132751807570457,
0.1789906769990921,
-0.24920406937599182,
0.04499800503253937,
-0.20103660225868225,
0.4263806641101837,
-0.13310298323631287,
-1.071287751197815,
0.022172370925545692,
0.5959023237228394,
0.03527989611029625,
-0.10692555457353592,
-0.3004554808139801,
0.4335039556026459,
0.25494447350502014,
0.6522688865661621,
0.08720385283231735,
-0.6520333886146545,
-0.3350815176963806,
0.30622896552085876,
-0.19092999398708344,
0.19365294277668,
0.801445722579956,
-0.21636562049388885,
0.5797610878944397,
0.19903627038002014,
0.6677020788192749,
-0.16694505512714386,
0.22331202030181885,
0.6638147830963135,
-0.016310933977365494,
-0.033744387328624725,
0.49293315410614014,
0.36519500613212585,
0.27045974135398865,
-0.4548628628253937,
0.35967332124710083,
-0.2794834077358246,
-0.8330464363098145,
-0.8798657655715942,
0.34310203790664673,
-1.1844713687896729,
0.1688123643398285,
1.356191873550415,
-0.3901687562465668,
0.1911124587059021,
0.005875138565897942,
-0.5906907320022583,
0.21304115653038025,
-0.5556932687759399,
0.9545450806617737,
0.39198777079582214,
-0.5814473628997803,
-0.40613943338394165,
-0.5194491744041443,
0.3495559096336365,
0.358937531709671,
-0.9242891669273376,
0.20854629576206207,
0.3473834693431854,
0.02963525988161564,
-0.2488589882850647,
0.7247024774551392,
-0.3062053620815277,
0.16503389179706573,
-0.10350137948989868,
0.038154032081365585,
0.3162723183631897,
0.22127562761306763,
-0.19616006314754486,
-0.021070722490549088,
0.2619568407535553,
0.15589539706707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16388v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16388v1
|
Multi-Reference Preference Optimization for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-26T00:29:04 | 2024-05-26T00:29:04 |
Hung Le, Quan Tran, Dung Nguyen, Kien Do, Saloni Mittal, Kelechi Ogueji, Svetha Venkatesh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
How can Large Language Models (LLMs) be aligned with human intentions and
values? A typical solution is to gather human preference on model outputs and
finetune the LLMs accordingly while ensuring that updates do not deviate too
far from a reference model. Recent approaches, such as direct preference
optimization (DPO), have eliminated the need for unstable and sluggish
reinforcement learning optimization by introducing close-formed supervised
losses. However, a significant limitation of the current approach is its design
for a single reference model only, neglecting to leverage the collective power
of numerous pretrained LLMs. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a novel
closed-form formulation for direct preference optimization using multiple
reference models. The resulting algorithm, Multi-Reference Preference
Optimization (MRPO), leverages broader prior knowledge from diverse reference
models, substantially enhancing preference learning capabilities compared to
the single-reference DPO. Our experiments demonstrate that LLMs finetuned with
MRPO generalize better in various preference data, regardless of data scarcity
or abundance. Furthermore, MRPO effectively finetunes LLMs to exhibit superior
performance in several downstream natural language processing tasks such as
GSM8K and TruthfulQA.
|
[
-0.45397889614105225,
-0.2123287320137024,
0.6794497966766357,
0.028167234733700752,
-0.30561363697052,
-0.16006572544574738,
-0.7682322859764099,
-0.19408361613750458,
-0.030556686222553253,
0.6476839184761047,
-0.7568952441215515,
-0.27173006534576416,
-0.4611615240573883,
0.18393519520759583,
0.3724331557750702,
0.8515692949295044,
0.019520040601491928,
0.09809394925832748,
-0.35932889580726624,
-0.23241139948368073,
-0.2700886130332947,
-0.696605384349823,
-0.543925404548645,
-0.7653454542160034,
0.7663401365280151,
0.7196668386459351,
0.608532726764679,
0.49759477376937866,
0.403199166059494,
0.24038201570510864,
0.0219583660364151,
0.5141714215278625,
-0.5244730710983276,
0.18117928504943848,
-0.16863633692264557,
-0.3149159252643585,
-0.2953832447528839,
0.22340567409992218,
0.6014279127120972,
0.6214522123336792,
-0.18230335414409637,
0.020233293995261192,
0.07526817172765732,
1.0330920219421387,
-0.7835195064544678,
-0.02419005148112774,
-0.678408145904541,
0.028042757883667946,
-0.058663394302129745,
-0.262062668800354,
-0.5614821910858154,
-0.47991496324539185,
0.2763795852661133,
-0.5529415011405945,
0.06318382918834686,
-0.006264504976570606,
0.6159148812294006,
0.4299646019935608,
-0.3570539355278015,
-0.06871256977319717,
-0.8201603889465332,
1.111272931098938,
-0.5954082608222961,
0.5844590663909912,
0.4038892984390259,
0.17420366406440735,
-0.17913569509983063,
-0.23944877088069916,
-0.4024962782859802,
-0.48696932196617126,
0.05655110627412796,
0.03420672565698624,
0.11809900403022766,
0.14591561257839203,
-0.02642524242401123,
0.1278521567583084,
-0.38522398471832275,
0.13405470550060272,
-0.18286864459514618,
-0.0364062637090683,
0.39571627974510193,
-0.12470276653766632,
-0.23103268444538116,
-0.06976443529129028,
-0.44418835639953613,
-0.10779426246881485,
-0.6804370880126953,
-0.0020243998151272535,
0.5201646685600281,
0.622299075126648,
0.08530480414628983,
0.3464238941669464,
-0.34762823581695557,
0.6875825524330139,
0.2828953266143799,
-0.2886051833629608,
0.2937532961368561,
-0.3178817331790924,
-0.04596136137843132,
-0.00758980680257082,
0.9265533089637756,
0.19148509204387665,
0.45823797583580017,
-0.19569648802280426,
0.009929513558745384,
-0.23887622356414795,
0.3525979816913605,
-0.7852631211280823,
0.0620274655520916,
0.12599538266658783,
-0.4368703067302704,
-0.3122938275337219,
-0.10852821171283722,
-0.6275960803031921,
-0.2866978049278259,
-0.7214850783348083,
-0.06298288702964783,
-0.18561215698719025,
-0.26598331332206726,
0.3511027693748474,
0.14640633761882782,
-0.25917911529541016,
0.19735796749591827,
-1.2510485649108887,
0.2762910723686218,
0.4386177957057953,
0.6134399771690369,
-0.1000673696398735,
-0.23076073825359344,
-0.6026777625083923,
0.37319156527519226,
-0.12606465816497803,
0.7809122204780579,
-0.8343755602836609,
-0.2920287549495697,
-0.19409044086933136,
-0.4690283536911011,
0.016308221966028214,
-0.5546349287033081,
0.9118509888648987,
-0.575458288192749,
0.23511424660682678,
-0.24605342745780945,
-0.24900873005390167,
-0.0076074921526014805,
0.272599458694458,
-0.6071068644523621,
0.8647611141204834,
-0.20508749783039093,
-0.5855711698532104,
0.27650272846221924,
-0.6060778498649597,
-0.23173080384731293,
-0.5004153847694397,
-0.2539220154285431,
-0.4055491089820862,
0.2375594675540924,
0.16734813153743744,
0.5031614303588867,
-0.4238527715206146,
0.4711858630180359,
-0.6621927618980408,
-0.0765034407377243,
0.09439361840486526,
-0.33660072088241577,
0.3131493031978607,
0.3350774347782135,
0.08764038980007172,
0.5244547724723816,
-0.5281991362571716,
0.00582721596583724,
0.1494559943675995,
-0.5353565216064453,
-0.7043666243553162,
0.23492440581321716,
-0.3196216821670532,
0.36765527725219727,
0.3570215404033661,
-0.2799760699272156,
0.4043912887573242,
-0.322500616312027,
0.323251873254776,
1.0555506944656372,
-0.2582574784755707,
0.658841609954834,
-0.21789218485355377,
0.34336957335472107,
-0.042917780578136444,
0.2773439586162567,
0.2512455880641937,
-0.09399105608463287,
-0.6692312359809875,
-0.13522158563137054,
0.1521044820547104,
0.15761658549308777,
-0.29252585768699646,
0.5245771408081055,
-0.3812459111213684,
-0.282943993806839,
-0.26244571805000305,
0.2811222970485687,
0.26077336072921753,
0.46958091855049133,
0.378641277551651,
-0.13275131583213806,
-0.5143131017684937,
-1.1256122589111328,
0.011409453116357327,
-0.10115781426429749,
0.018996626138687134,
0.5845895409584045,
-0.06612201780080795,
-0.3147295415401459,
0.938737690448761,
-0.8122546076774597,
-0.13895010948181152,
-0.16259680688381195,
-0.20671875774860382,
0.32520028948783875,
0.2199942022562027,
0.456399530172348,
-0.8268119096755981,
-0.336771696805954,
0.024633852764964104,
-0.27611038088798523,
-0.17064055800437927,
0.0022187018766999245,
-0.2707779109477997,
0.0009888404747471213,
0.2588559091091156,
-0.32126060128211975,
-0.4323631823062897,
0.7916350960731506,
0.12441295385360718,
0.6371076107025146,
-0.30633822083473206,
-0.011224404908716679,
-1.0462894439697266,
0.053365934640169144,
0.07255706191062927,
-0.10289855301380157,
-0.5093492865562439,
-0.17295263707637787,
0.07272931188344955,
-0.024168910458683968,
-0.22676028311252594,
0.5990216135978699,
-0.4504382610321045,
0.11066919565200806,
-0.3393898904323578,
0.24377520382404327,
0.05641878396272659,
0.6618712544441223,
0.3448922634124756,
0.7292478084564209,
0.23728199303150177,
-0.799741268157959,
0.38004106283187866,
0.23350179195404053,
0.1574348658323288,
0.17847110331058502,
-0.422122985124588,
0.42924562096595764,
-0.20329944789409637,
0.1316377818584442,
-0.8211371898651123,
0.003939616959542036,
0.17907002568244934,
-0.26014652848243713,
0.30265554785728455,
-0.24525780975818634,
-0.2833799719810486,
-0.1397295743227005,
-0.4520939588546753,
0.42345550656318665,
0.05525026097893715,
-0.5766072869300842,
0.4414442479610443,
0.29512327909469604,
-0.2185308188199997,
-0.9067600965499878,
-0.17048117518424988,
-0.23695942759513855,
-0.2969466745853424,
-0.5008683204650879,
0.34454190731048584,
-0.2639467716217041,
-0.07926777750253677,
-0.26879337430000305,
-0.26976093649864197,
-0.05915990471839905,
-0.07282672077417374,
0.014320217072963715,
0.35640329122543335,
-0.0006405973108485341,
0.4461231231689453,
-0.07511020451784134,
-0.3165998160839081,
-0.24798229336738586,
-0.43148547410964966,
0.7664311528205872,
-0.14087939262390137,
-0.20512621104717255,
0.0872078537940979,
0.2727311849594116,
0.5164755582809448,
-0.35447958111763,
0.523875892162323,
0.396686851978302,
-0.08836104720830917,
-0.17513053119182587,
-0.6420451402664185,
-0.2796880006790161,
-0.47094759345054626,
0.2983989119529724,
-0.6936501264572144,
-0.8134886622428894,
0.1454811990261078,
-0.28091681003570557,
0.02842693403363228,
0.2121039479970932,
0.5879158973693848,
0.37473127245903015,
0.7545777559280396,
0.6744071841239929,
-0.4486091434955597,
0.7786548137664795,
0.11539030820131302,
0.0829964131116867,
-0.9354490637779236,
0.0018676382023841143,
-0.7239019274711609,
-0.08552123606204987,
-0.5244235992431641,
-0.29091212153434753,
0.26986151933670044,
0.16361230611801147,
-0.2629756033420563,
0.1598900854587555,
-0.4149702489376068,
0.3884738087654114,
0.7906705141067505,
0.25563958287239075,
0.5256075859069824,
0.08863906562328339,
-0.5498287081718445,
-0.11458040773868561,
-0.74560546875,
-0.8305287957191467,
1.2933622598648071,
0.2666482627391815,
0.9183638095855713,
0.12464118003845215,
0.7475776672363281,
-0.09630580991506577,
0.3122870922088623,
-0.8561188578605652,
0.3306558132171631,
-0.33690106868743896,
-0.5351535081863403,
-0.3487805724143982,
-0.5505340695381165,
-0.8068171739578247,
0.419038861989975,
-0.3437148630619049,
-0.4508620500564575,
0.15014265477657318,
0.3375898599624634,
-0.36689433455467224,
0.1392112672328949,
-0.7726564407348633,
0.7995890974998474,
-0.2270311564207077,
-0.624013364315033,
-0.48596835136413574,
-0.5279610753059387,
0.47190120816230774,
-0.1074235737323761,
0.11360305547714233,
-0.3669882118701935,
-0.06231300160288811,
0.5063571929931641,
-0.03523461893200874,
0.5831671357154846,
0.07791302353143692,
-0.037309639155864716,
-0.0632181316614151,
-0.31649670004844666,
0.5008208155632019,
0.08081872016191483,
-0.38383370637893677,
0.04551240801811218,
-0.32896095514297485,
-0.1977330446243286,
-0.42056870460510254,
0.8532284498214722,
-0.9101258516311646,
-0.4930492639541626,
-0.30585405230522156,
-0.3847702741622925,
-0.5397862792015076,
0.3854055404663086,
-0.0068871681578457355,
0.3213152289390564,
-0.30639421939849854,
0.05809502676129341,
0.6421821713447571,
-0.18156930804252625,
0.2452421337366104,
0.4459455609321594,
-0.05244288221001625,
-0.4636193811893463,
0.6113772988319397,
-0.23019185662269592,
0.5735341310501099,
0.509829044342041,
0.6094103455543518,
-0.4596653878688812,
-0.6478618383407593,
-0.3001742362976074,
0.4512908458709717,
-0.49561384320259094,
0.015399710275232792,
-0.41994476318359375,
0.2057047188282013,
-0.4355945587158203,
0.0026936265639960766,
-0.6241593956947327,
-0.19875438511371613,
-0.25068399310112,
0.12130934745073318,
0.09081956744194031,
0.4315698742866516,
-0.05640443041920662,
0.07867557555437088,
-0.8592827320098877,
0.5204923152923584,
0.5270538926124573,
0.7152347564697266,
-0.17868857085704803,
-0.351774126291275,
-0.21783266961574554,
0.06207806617021561,
-0.4446130692958832,
-0.5823434591293335,
0.19143539667129517,
0.025079917162656784,
0.6969858407974243,
0.6873906254768372,
0.30989518761634827,
0.6484658718109131,
-0.8019945621490479,
0.17955240607261658,
0.27397024631500244,
-0.6137293577194214,
0.4778631329536438,
-0.4207839071750641,
0.2804051339626312,
0.7399757504463196,
0.47922858595848083,
-0.7820078730583191,
-0.007340100593864918,
-0.408357709646225,
-0.5144743323326111,
0.7692252993583679,
-0.02350328490138054,
0.1894933581352234,
0.05937676504254341,
0.3872227370738983,
0.10503466427326202,
0.3525383770465851,
-0.6540119647979736,
-0.48703864216804504,
-0.0035908883437514305,
-0.07557523250579834,
-0.26536741852760315,
-0.4187242388725281,
-0.27437835931777954,
0.02832290343940258,
0.7717904448509216,
-0.3306230902671814,
0.154219388961792,
0.05498887971043587,
0.20642878115177155,
-0.2208683341741562,
0.5081043243408203,
0.8347144722938538,
0.6485610604286194,
-0.43694332242012024,
0.11380476504564285,
-0.1539023220539093,
-0.3670670688152313,
0.20177701115608215,
0.2097470909357071,
-0.10430501401424408,
-0.17004598677158356,
-0.07151871919631958,
0.8708500862121582,
0.10675964504480362,
-0.5124822854995728,
0.1224675327539444,
-0.14729228615760803,
-0.04499303922057152,
-0.17804531753063202,
0.07631909102201462,
0.1825256198644638,
0.06761004030704498,
0.3443666994571686,
0.32296690344810486,
0.05033409968018532,
-0.4395008683204651,
0.05270715057849884,
0.5662672519683838,
-0.36511605978012085,
-0.1103326603770256,
0.40448784828186035,
0.4363201856613159,
0.006335425190627575,
0.282058984041214,
0.07642042636871338,
-0.4496209919452667,
0.275273859500885,
0.41970205307006836,
0.8462185859680176,
-0.2457272708415985,
-0.025957925245165825,
0.4529248774051666,
0.22171737253665924,
-0.22793380916118622,
-0.22630327939987183,
-0.04317278414964676,
-1.282421588897705,
-0.49212199449539185,
-0.49524998664855957,
-0.7754522562026978,
0.25942909717559814,
-0.5405718088150024,
0.37285107374191284,
-0.42770370841026306,
-0.1917703002691269,
0.009280226193368435,
0.19165478646755219,
-0.42473599314689636,
0.0805610939860344,
0.24704356491565704,
0.46751463413238525,
-0.5544308423995972,
1.0896344184875488,
0.6711066961288452,
-0.17765766382217407,
-0.5838860273361206,
0.025949206203222275,
-0.05951286852359772,
-0.5981917977333069,
0.6140899658203125,
0.09306882321834564,
-0.43513840436935425,
-0.015715688467025757,
-0.30909475684165955,
-0.8443217277526855,
0.6464266180992126,
0.5736268758773804,
-0.6238349676132202,
0.060386475175619125,
-0.10265845060348511,
0.17001014947891235,
-0.3964558243751526,
0.19940589368343353,
0.44549262523651123,
0.5658395290374756,
0.10501513630151749,
-0.9547343850135803,
-0.09149789810180664,
0.09332223981618881,
-0.19461975991725922,
0.5309549570083618,
-0.9261934757232666,
0.4584703743457794,
-0.38108929991722107,
0.01752893067896366,
-0.38496679067611694,
0.5811808109283447,
0.5717600584030151,
-0.13871607184410095,
0.5767110586166382,
0.36137261986732483,
0.7455546259880066,
0.1591259241104126,
0.9217256903648376,
-0.2237108051776886,
0.33570152521133423,
1.2275984287261963,
-0.33663231134414673,
0.8637892007827759,
0.7576566338539124,
-0.28369855880737305,
0.12596580386161804,
0.620505690574646,
0.3808867037296295,
0.697690486907959,
0.1087353453040123,
-0.4508676528930664,
-0.5251042246818542,
-0.17916935682296753,
-0.2136574536561966,
0.3306463360786438,
0.060804449021816254,
-0.18578407168388367,
-0.13287630677223206,
-0.16976989805698395,
0.0034922813065350056,
0.35075944662094116,
-0.11365438997745514,
0.681891918182373,
0.03486495092511177,
-0.7335594892501831,
0.6043313145637512,
0.11813464760780334,
0.877557635307312,
-0.8723366260528564,
0.1618058979511261,
-0.11548038572072983,
0.40891483426094055,
0.012442161329090595,
-0.31981658935546875,
0.1727224439382553,
-0.22836291790008545,
-0.5771945118904114,
-0.3521260917186737,
0.6844304800033569,
-0.5848716497421265,
-0.23894982039928436,
0.26263856887817383,
0.2972027361392975,
-0.1467895805835724,
-0.3224332332611084,
-0.643006443977356,
-0.021396851167082787,
0.11136633902788162,
-0.38609203696250916,
0.36981871724128723,
0.23342426121234894,
0.06459967792034149,
0.9097028970718384,
0.7641502022743225,
0.21147359907627106,
-0.19130191206932068,
0.1839941293001175,
0.8978960514068604,
-0.6061140298843384,
-0.3361492455005646,
-0.9347910284996033,
0.13122440874576569,
-0.14104066789150238,
-0.3276796340942383,
0.5423951745033264,
0.5813338160514832,
0.8911959528923035,
-0.20053741335868835,
0.8408005237579346,
0.39782047271728516,
0.5028471350669861,
-0.7287473678588867,
0.23175343871116638,
-0.38649821281433105,
0.1258677840232849,
-0.2716507017612457,
-1.0331884622573853,
-0.2567835748195648,
0.674010694026947,
-0.49576523900032043,
0.09381116181612015,
0.7623832821846008,
0.603654146194458,
-0.15392954647541046,
-0.2733137309551239,
0.3722313642501831,
-0.2460463047027588,
0.24918226897716522,
0.7610532641410828,
0.5588948726654053,
-0.07305649667978287,
0.6131747961044312,
-0.3188939094543457,
-0.1586267352104187,
-0.17307846248149872,
-0.989585280418396,
-0.8756893277168274,
-0.4127882719039917,
-0.06728027760982513,
0.101224884390831,
-0.03363385051488876,
1.3579567670822144,
0.9132631421089172,
-0.6430636048316956,
-0.36028817296028137,
0.15858444571495056,
0.3280884623527527,
0.020137447863817215,
-0.1593921184539795,
0.11662282794713974,
-0.5725770592689514,
-1.0358188152313232,
0.4220339059829712,
0.2495991587638855,
0.01710791140794754,
-0.22303102910518646,
-0.4024389684200287,
-0.3328551948070526,
-0.02145462855696678,
0.6455203294754028,
0.12654165923595428,
-0.6520509123802185,
-0.32834532856941223,
0.02680763602256775,
-0.27253100275993347,
0.27766546607017517,
0.9856448173522949,
-0.6034432649612427,
0.4899837374687195,
0.4019303321838379,
0.5864201188087463,
0.5247352719306946,
0.1643560379743576,
0.8365222811698914,
-0.7904317378997803,
0.2983921468257904,
0.20239949226379395,
0.3656170666217804,
0.25256264209747314,
-0.257494181394577,
0.40998899936676025,
0.06743493676185608,
-0.6476788520812988,
-0.4004470705986023,
0.49012306332588196,
-1.1045230627059937,
-0.29749658703804016,
1.369828224182129,
0.1028420478105545,
0.2205970585346222,
-0.013378382660448551,
-0.2970533072948456,
0.09810521453619003,
-0.8521839380264282,
0.6182927489280701,
0.7828466296195984,
-0.20376893877983093,
-0.15790578722953796,
-0.5896799564361572,
0.5763660073280334,
0.4875202178955078,
-0.6763308644294739,
0.33522945642471313,
0.7882737517356873,
0.21425317227840424,
0.16366636753082275,
0.6535513401031494,
0.11865834146738052,
-0.09351874142885208,
-0.5112074613571167,
0.29310640692710876,
-0.3238626718521118,
-0.31741979718208313,
-0.34801140427589417,
0.19968163967132568,
0.446371465921402,
-0.29294198751449585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16376v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16376v2
|
STRIDE: A Tool-Assisted LLM Agent Framework for Strategic and Interactive Decision-Making
| 2024-05-25T23:25:10 | 2024-05-28T01:21:19 |
Chuanhao Li, Runhan Yang, Tiankai Li, Milad Bafarassat, Kourosh Sharifi, Dirk Bergemann, Zhuoran Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.GT
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 have revolutionized natural language
processing, showing remarkable linguistic proficiency and reasoning
capabilities. However, their application in strategic multi-agent
decision-making environments is hampered by significant limitations including
poor mathematical reasoning, difficulty in following instructions, and a
tendency to generate incorrect information. These deficiencies hinder their
performance in strategic and interactive tasks that demand adherence to nuanced
game rules, long-term planning, exploration in unknown environments, and
anticipation of opponents' moves. To overcome these obstacles, this paper
presents a novel LLM agent framework equipped with memory and specialized tools
to enhance their strategic decision-making capabilities. We deploy the tools in
a number of economically important environments, in particular bilateral
bargaining and multi-agent and dynamic mechanism design. We employ quantitative
metrics to assess the framework's performance in various strategic
decision-making problems. Our findings establish that our enhanced framework
significantly improves the strategic decision-making capability of LLMs. While
we highlight the inherent limitations of current LLM models, we demonstrate the
improvements through targeted enhancements, suggesting a promising direction
for future developments in LLM applications for interactive environments.
|
[
-0.33869412541389465,
-0.9657531976699829,
1.0862594842910767,
0.35320809483528137,
-0.06292632967233658,
0.5857002139091492,
-0.35613709688186646,
-0.248407244682312,
0.17553047835826874,
0.3926474452018738,
-0.41040825843811035,
-0.5709714293479919,
-0.5570560693740845,
-0.14177502691745758,
0.17224401235580444,
0.6684122681617737,
-0.21295078098773956,
0.09391076117753983,
0.05604724958539009,
-0.4496239721775055,
-0.6555315852165222,
-0.3817763328552246,
-1.208821415901184,
-0.516976535320282,
0.3729824125766754,
0.2812741994857788,
1.0565975904464722,
0.5651261210441589,
0.6399807929992676,
0.506193220615387,
0.10597651451826096,
0.14824622869491577,
-0.3950805366039276,
0.4748819172382355,
-0.3361401855945587,
-0.4322461187839508,
-0.9048354029655457,
0.0219016894698143,
0.8008160591125488,
0.1307770013809204,
-0.22617177665233612,
-0.11678659170866013,
-0.1158171147108078,
0.47794654965400696,
-0.4420567452907562,
0.42955484986305237,
-0.644406259059906,
-0.029554175212979317,
-0.09771548956632614,
-0.16122271120548248,
-0.14878450334072113,
0.005555121228098869,
0.03763386607170105,
-0.8400614857673645,
-0.4152311682701111,
-0.01893029920756817,
0.6606306433677673,
0.34499433636665344,
-0.29488545656204224,
-0.46661263704299927,
-0.9230769872665405,
0.6295372247695923,
-0.5200687646865845,
0.4202730655670166,
0.08402785658836365,
0.5691261887550354,
-0.2655763626098633,
-0.7436072826385498,
-0.08644497394561768,
-0.30345624685287476,
0.2614712417125702,
0.2140188366174698,
-0.3071270287036896,
0.33737772703170776,
0.24306482076644897,
-0.28722718358039856,
-0.22752240300178528,
0.13076336681842804,
-0.01597006246447563,
-0.11927749216556549,
0.5123789310455322,
0.47189387679100037,
0.1359347254037857,
0.1641875058412552,
-0.45542028546333313,
-0.07644733041524887,
-0.5012491941452026,
0.14058129489421844,
0.30694305896759033,
0.2154562771320343,
-0.05758165568113327,
0.3632013201713562,
0.04374045878648758,
0.4681406319141388,
0.17485669255256653,
-0.32514017820358276,
-0.07152232527732849,
-0.2597070038318634,
-0.15075913071632385,
-0.04669567570090294,
0.5843181014060974,
0.31209301948547363,
0.03822311758995056,
-0.20272350311279297,
-0.4736619293689728,
-0.04945758357644081,
0.118584543466568,
-0.579409122467041,
-0.06223900243639946,
0.2723289132118225,
-0.15252411365509033,
-0.13741342723369598,
-0.18350574374198914,
-0.8861096501350403,
-0.43749839067459106,
-0.14296400547027588,
0.41160663962364197,
-0.6365770101547241,
-0.08763500303030014,
0.1550639569759369,
-0.32472434639930725,
0.4768628478050232,
0.45134422183036804,
-0.6917862296104431,
0.24317137897014618,
0.6454015970230103,
0.9691922068595886,
-0.16568267345428467,
-0.38982123136520386,
-0.6513838768005371,
0.48558342456817627,
-0.42483004927635193,
0.831500768661499,
-0.9529305100440979,
-0.6294651031494141,
-0.2317483127117157,
-0.38547447323799133,
0.05730048567056656,
-0.5478104948997498,
0.4787569046020508,
-0.4854981601238251,
-0.18552112579345703,
-0.44751521944999695,
-0.13274100422859192,
-0.23929135501384735,
0.7255042791366577,
-0.9150371551513672,
0.839844286441803,
0.12145798653364182,
-0.21849201619625092,
0.6164195537567139,
-0.8809128999710083,
-0.4019325077533722,
0.3636336326599121,
-0.4465070068836212,
-0.2215326577425003,
-0.20522241294384003,
0.2070736140012741,
0.2686801552772522,
-0.4360799491405487,
0.24827270209789276,
-0.23927965760231018,
-0.3312600553035736,
0.18686550855636597,
-0.4692228436470032,
0.37882277369499207,
0.0382419154047966,
-0.4618614614009857,
0.5264130234718323,
-0.5129801630973816,
0.07302408665418625,
0.16311004757881165,
-0.8320115208625793,
-0.014270634390413761,
0.1531526893377304,
-0.28866663575172424,
0.2634516954421997,
0.4350762665271759,
-0.025588061660528183,
0.34506940841674805,
-0.15259651839733124,
0.3188580870628357,
0.9792211055755615,
0.0024237162433564663,
0.7688801884651184,
-0.47383853793144226,
0.8433834910392761,
-0.12282303720712662,
0.06682877987623215,
-0.009654583409428596,
-0.4182782769203186,
-0.8037279844284058,
-0.4462276101112366,
0.007352789398282766,
0.569985568523407,
-0.9074980616569519,
-0.004656883887946606,
-0.29082632064819336,
-0.3588123321533203,
-0.424175888299942,
0.0758177787065506,
0.07927356660366058,
0.0820181593298912,
0.1496468335390091,
-0.08859682083129883,
-0.6320515275001526,
-0.4991353154182434,
-0.31617480516433716,
-0.276766836643219,
0.23367618024349213,
0.4727747142314911,
0.3358003497123718,
-0.3219727873802185,
0.875826358795166,
-0.07565291225910187,
-0.2460385262966156,
-0.47744226455688477,
-0.015039562247693539,
0.1140708327293396,
0.06263481080532074,
0.3661588132381439,
-0.6788300275802612,
-0.4471256136894226,
0.047952357679605484,
-0.6260308623313904,
0.07019146531820297,
-0.6377959847450256,
-0.2846466302871704,
0.14457210898399353,
0.30944904685020447,
-0.9558440446853638,
0.11269229650497437,
0.2098838835954666,
-0.49179500341415405,
0.5464117527008057,
-0.4811634421348572,
0.1816515475511551,
-0.6181193590164185,
-0.11928138136863708,
-0.06622599810361862,
-0.21253952383995056,
-0.5265474915504456,
0.23280368745326996,
-0.15876543521881104,
0.15375526249408722,
-0.31274381279945374,
0.7221360802650452,
-0.5961030125617981,
-0.1783127784729004,
-0.1711561679840088,
0.39204469323158264,
-0.11890129745006561,
0.41071879863739014,
0.19184580445289612,
0.9368069767951965,
0.5464215874671936,
-0.6266229152679443,
0.4961562156677246,
0.11858467757701874,
-0.016670631244778633,
0.7367430329322815,
-0.4200543761253357,
0.04840560629963875,
-0.041457146406173706,
0.17203490436077118,
-0.5799159407615662,
0.020694037899374962,
0.2366763800382614,
-0.07280083000659943,
0.2504383325576782,
-0.04759354144334793,
-0.3674120008945465,
-0.005723014008253813,
-0.3626384139060974,
0.13749155402183533,
0.4744638204574585,
-0.24285370111465454,
1.2027531862258911,
0.4206896424293518,
-0.07742692530155182,
-0.39797914028167725,
-0.42179104685783386,
0.3667687177658081,
-0.5802618265151978,
-0.5881806015968323,
0.2650182843208313,
-0.12104091048240662,
-0.6299033761024475,
-0.18543559312820435,
-0.02785887010395527,
0.18010587990283966,
-0.03202490136027336,
0.1195034459233284,
0.2532614469528198,
-0.282376229763031,
0.006797959562391043,
-0.3329707384109497,
-0.27587589621543884,
0.1892257183790207,
-0.34032776951789856,
0.5252295732498169,
-0.4058348834514618,
-0.4221811592578888,
0.3323586881160736,
0.1489304006099701,
0.7924795746803284,
-0.46423575282096863,
0.4256054162979126,
0.5798178911209106,
-0.0290446225553751,
-0.3887532651424408,
-0.5646777153015137,
0.024172045290470123,
-0.5785211324691772,
0.6119415760040283,
-0.38311487436294556,
-0.7237021923065186,
0.5375890135765076,
-0.7541431784629822,
0.22992712259292603,
0.12299574911594391,
0.6300662159919739,
0.16922815144062042,
0.9029273390769958,
0.39168694615364075,
-0.10492808371782303,
0.29002735018730164,
-0.18760448694229126,
0.18890391290187836,
-0.7033458948135376,
-0.34664419293403625,
-0.06230853125452995,
-0.49682143330574036,
-0.48718884587287903,
-0.7850048542022705,
0.660164475440979,
-0.2366587221622467,
-0.5170924067497253,
-0.08759001642465591,
-0.1532667726278305,
0.4769881069660187,
0.33144062757492065,
-0.12468962371349335,
0.1767982691526413,
-0.314320832490921,
-0.4154466688632965,
-0.034112825989723206,
-0.778347909450531,
-0.6751879453659058,
0.8250049352645874,
0.4452493190765381,
0.6023630499839783,
0.42217159271240234,
0.6184592843055725,
0.22944426536560059,
0.09634346514940262,
-0.846352756023407,
0.8737475275993347,
0.27779027819633484,
-0.46705788373947144,
-0.5279573798179626,
-0.21910205483436584,
-0.9134164452552795,
0.3659985065460205,
-0.3958841562271118,
-0.6243632435798645,
-0.0991714671254158,
-0.12172893434762955,
-0.5855894088745117,
0.4975227117538452,
-0.43144145607948303,
0.5930708646774292,
-0.8571215271949768,
-0.781602144241333,
-0.2809997797012329,
-0.21157854795455933,
0.04826287552714348,
-0.16782481968402863,
0.2456880360841751,
-0.15090136229991913,
-0.757158100605011,
0.5054485201835632,
0.07813222706317902,
0.5711861848831177,
-0.15622760355472565,
0.041174184530973434,
0.36176443099975586,
0.3375885486602783,
0.9603692889213562,
0.003838692558929324,
-0.4044221341609955,
-0.07378310710191727,
-0.3318988084793091,
-0.12079153209924698,
-0.5907665491104126,
0.6533734798431396,
-0.42286092042922974,
-0.8867055773735046,
-0.5519915819168091,
-0.6561184525489807,
-0.4803915023803711,
0.2716864049434662,
-0.1866040974855423,
-0.0485212504863739,
-0.6066204309463501,
0.028702838346362114,
0.3948286175727844,
-0.17141953110694885,
0.7087650299072266,
0.7621042132377625,
-0.12186034023761749,
-0.2514181435108185,
0.6950573325157166,
0.1719987690448761,
0.14179857075214386,
0.08044003695249557,
0.0759294331073761,
-0.4082600176334381,
-0.7529468536376953,
-0.296743243932724,
-0.0015133671695366502,
-0.852135956287384,
-0.14264288544654846,
-0.24247276782989502,
-0.05062325298786163,
0.10276634246110916,
-0.433636337518692,
-0.15915054082870483,
-0.09318443387746811,
0.048640791326761246,
-0.2879900634288788,
0.24005915224552155,
0.9107665419578552,
-0.11661181598901749,
0.3191526532173157,
-0.5617241263389587,
0.05222387984395027,
0.14720942080020905,
0.3487498462200165,
0.008288213983178139,
-0.063186876475811,
-0.22808387875556946,
-0.08624988049268723,
-0.4181666970252991,
-0.8761032819747925,
0.4520885646343231,
0.02251260168850422,
0.7852784395217896,
0.32682543992996216,
-0.23083966970443726,
0.6440301537513733,
-0.5696204304695129,
0.6119351387023926,
-0.10001079738140106,
-0.6793935894966125,
0.2609235644340515,
-0.6626211404800415,
0.4617379903793335,
0.2445625513792038,
0.1579352617263794,
-0.14920422434806824,
-0.24873332679271698,
-0.6018857359886169,
-0.890535295009613,
0.6378870010375977,
0.20923224091529846,
-0.19121719896793365,
0.04348926991224289,
0.15896469354629517,
-0.2808596193790436,
0.17968985438346863,
-0.3862840533256531,
-0.009746399708092213,
0.21300381422042847,
0.17211762070655823,
-0.16142819821834564,
-0.15583661198616028,
-0.047549646347761154,
-0.09689170867204666,
0.6993459463119507,
-0.11072930693626404,
0.10196425020694733,
-0.09672226011753082,
0.1264721304178238,
-0.07562339305877686,
0.4022402763366699,
0.2548765540122986,
0.6028337478637695,
0.03933276981115341,
-0.05543948709964752,
0.6840165257453918,
-0.3057556450366974,
0.3741486072540283,
0.09889024496078491,
-0.0033887200988829136,
-0.22784583270549774,
0.3367796838283539,
0.5457263588905334,
0.4165123403072357,
-0.8126842379570007,
0.0876743495464325,
0.09854304045438766,
-0.12428860366344452,
-0.3034232258796692,
0.12726490199565887,
0.4349345564842224,
0.8635476231575012,
0.0560462586581707,
0.056058209389448166,
0.1462484747171402,
-0.59555983543396,
0.19626981019973755,
0.7843543887138367,
-0.16873164474964142,
0.010025719180703163,
0.48087307810783386,
0.32296618819236755,
-0.5140554308891296,
0.427499383687973,
-0.3662508726119995,
-0.47430941462516785,
0.5625709295272827,
0.46599721908569336,
0.8574168086051941,
-0.19055262207984924,
0.3277224004268646,
0.05172252655029297,
0.43954941630363464,
-0.03635066747665405,
0.25720855593681335,
0.00859902985394001,
-0.6720284223556519,
-0.1802615076303482,
-0.42680463194847107,
-0.3691340684890747,
0.07725142687559128,
-0.10236872732639313,
0.2552913725376129,
-0.9118762612342834,
-0.6081405282020569,
-0.304140567779541,
0.3027467727661133,
-0.7171967029571533,
-0.10559751093387604,
0.12306348979473114,
0.7627277970314026,
-0.17887523770332336,
0.7364727854728699,
0.7618089318275452,
-0.29034295678138733,
-0.8012107610702515,
-0.02719205431640148,
0.3075353503227234,
-0.8034557700157166,
0.5607991814613342,
-0.08453937619924545,
-0.6294869780540466,
-0.12980881333351135,
-0.18473447859287262,
-0.9270244240760803,
1.4637852907180786,
0.6280813813209534,
-0.5107242465019226,
-0.15276330709457397,
0.2620006501674652,
0.45058536529541016,
-0.3607490062713623,
0.2760019302368164,
0.888622522354126,
0.9633329510688782,
0.3485792577266693,
-0.6892107129096985,
0.08284001052379608,
0.005353944841772318,
-0.17270515859127045,
0.44373393058776855,
-0.9021222591400146,
0.8958837389945984,
-0.41302230954170227,
-0.20542457699775696,
-0.02781263366341591,
0.4013436734676361,
0.6030047535896301,
0.2029993087053299,
0.3122881352901459,
0.3764001429080963,
0.8398198485374451,
-0.13748931884765625,
0.7263821363449097,
-0.41619887948036194,
-0.05968235433101654,
0.895906388759613,
-0.6410700082778931,
0.7438495755195618,
0.24992252886295319,
0.03542303666472435,
0.563940167427063,
0.28565943241119385,
0.010822559706866741,
0.16967527568340302,
-0.012706393375992775,
-0.53587806224823,
-0.5113093256950378,
0.009254368022084236,
0.17318212985992432,
0.7648099064826965,
0.6060308218002319,
-0.052712392061948776,
-0.39729949831962585,
-0.33941495418548584,
0.1735081523656845,
0.055566489696502686,
-0.27301228046417236,
0.7393296957015991,
0.02548048086464405,
-0.5850108861923218,
0.08411543816328049,
0.26041579246520996,
0.6122390031814575,
-0.9585604667663574,
-0.318641722202301,
0.02030220814049244,
0.36854398250579834,
0.08942042291164398,
-0.8871316313743591,
0.12495498359203339,
-0.12862657010555267,
0.2579749524593353,
-0.40366095304489136,
0.8482983708381653,
-0.1835196316242218,
-0.26305001974105835,
0.5597902536392212,
0.7882590293884277,
-0.1418883055448532,
-0.039957839995622635,
-1.0782041549682617,
0.34503597021102905,
-0.23896443843841553,
-0.24326607584953308,
0.2648249566555023,
0.751036524772644,
-0.11929461359977722,
0.8977726101875305,
0.45913758873939514,
0.24680517613887787,
-0.376508891582489,
-0.22228844463825226,
0.7353242635726929,
-0.6811981797218323,
-0.655500590801239,
-1.05388605594635,
0.32877233624458313,
-0.18983830511569977,
0.004248984158039093,
0.807991623878479,
0.5287715196609497,
0.4110642969608307,
0.2710290253162384,
0.7945579886436462,
0.16557127237319946,
-0.23889251053333282,
-0.657280445098877,
0.6716838479042053,
-0.1037558764219284,
0.5495965480804443,
0.04739867523312569,
-0.7443652153015137,
-0.08112069219350815,
0.5623131394386292,
-0.4735667109489441,
0.5209246873855591,
0.5294649600982666,
0.6926544904708862,
-0.07778904587030411,
-0.3258405327796936,
0.5318032503128052,
0.21738244593143463,
0.5055835843086243,
0.8114387392997742,
0.7002178430557251,
0.21866413950920105,
0.6409476399421692,
0.2962692379951477,
-0.14957590401172638,
0.09117311239242554,
-0.9683374166488647,
-0.9912002086639404,
-0.4325384497642517,
0.05970323830842972,
-0.11370404809713364,
0.3367372751235962,
0.9880431294441223,
0.7273942828178406,
-0.20518375933170319,
-0.469968318939209,
0.03414318338036537,
0.17317301034927368,
-0.1025879830121994,
-0.14687883853912354,
0.011470397002995014,
-0.3785113990306854,
-0.41341596841812134,
0.5650699138641357,
0.7150949835777283,
0.1939004808664322,
-0.3874227702617645,
-0.6524263620376587,
-0.3144029974937439,
0.6197365522384644,
0.5277823805809021,
0.232650026679039,
-0.6805147528648376,
-0.13673517107963562,
-0.05203160271048546,
0.1565057784318924,
0.25267672538757324,
0.8374633193016052,
-0.8570243716239929,
0.3943231403827667,
0.11033719033002853,
0.5422383546829224,
0.214943528175354,
-0.08579441159963608,
0.713001012802124,
-0.39784255623817444,
0.27470964193344116,
0.44414398074150085,
0.38380879163742065,
0.3170636296272278,
-0.36332547664642334,
0.3627060651779175,
-0.19243314862251282,
-0.46523216366767883,
-0.120923712849617,
0.28182291984558105,
-0.6752013564109802,
-0.30006036162376404,
1.3544803857803345,
-0.059256214648485184,
-0.1608603149652481,
-0.09356742352247238,
-0.5589380860328674,
-0.0014401930384337902,
-0.6900458335876465,
0.37491464614868164,
0.9091472625732422,
-0.1458594799041748,
-0.14955078065395355,
-0.49741363525390625,
0.6622878313064575,
0.21299763023853302,
-0.7977355122566223,
0.00011739930050680414,
0.7283830642700195,
-0.04401670768857002,
-0.00010520142677705735,
0.7872962951660156,
0.05667150393128395,
0.2056771218776703,
0.31006062030792236,
-0.4040944278240204,
-0.24095618724822998,
-0.46758517622947693,
-0.3082959055900574,
0.12054236978292465,
0.5076749920845032,
0.03910939767956734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16337v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16337v2
|
Learning to Reason via Program Generation, Emulation, and Search
| 2024-05-25T19:40:50 | 2024-05-28T23:28:52 |
Nathaniel Weir, Muhammad Khalifa, Linlu Qiu, Orion Weller, Peter Clark
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Program synthesis with language models (LMs) has unlocked a large set of
reasoning abilities; code-tuned LMs have proven adept at generating programs
that solve a wide variety of algorithmic symbolic manipulation tasks (e.g. word
concatenation). However, not all reasoning tasks are easily expressible as
code, e.g. tasks involving commonsense reasoning, moral decision-making, and
sarcasm understanding. Our goal is to extend an LM's program synthesis skills
to such tasks and evaluate the results via pseudo-programs, namely Python
programs where some leaf function calls are left undefined. To that end, we
propose, Code Generation and Emulated EXecution (CoGEX). CoGEX works by (1)
training LMs to generate their own pseudo-programs, (2) teaching them to
emulate their generated program's execution, including those leaf functions,
allowing the LM's knowledge to fill in the execution gaps; and (3) using them
to search over many programs to find an optimal one. To adapt the CoGEX model
to a new task, we introduce a method for performing program search to find a
single program whose pseudo-execution yields optimal performance when applied
to all the instances of a given dataset. We show that our approach yields large
improvements compared to standard in-context learning approaches on a battery
of tasks, both algorithmic and soft reasoning. This result thus demonstrates
that code synthesis can be applied to a much broader class of problems than
previously considered. Our released dataset, fine-tuned models, and
implementation can be found at \url{https://github.com/nweir127/CoGEX}.
|
[
-0.35279691219329834,
-0.7808853387832642,
0.9134509563446045,
-0.11530554294586182,
0.0909525528550148,
0.012586647644639015,
-0.23655438423156738,
-0.020919373258948326,
0.012358787469565868,
0.48524075746536255,
-0.790456235408783,
-0.5321751832962036,
-0.07616856694221497,
-0.03632659837603569,
-0.31175997853279114,
0.8140021562576294,
0.06331345438957214,
-0.2543198764324188,
-0.13528721034526825,
0.03696466609835625,
-0.34970101714134216,
-0.5125454068183899,
-0.4710700213909149,
-0.5056973099708557,
0.15912523865699768,
0.4959414303302765,
0.5802850127220154,
0.3998008668422699,
0.08363852649927139,
0.2663268446922302,
0.47646966576576233,
0.10283177345991135,
-0.6374387741088867,
-0.15118186175823212,
-0.30650100111961365,
-0.6354202032089233,
-0.04700522869825363,
0.1821109801530838,
0.1302696019411087,
0.49133583903312683,
-0.0793301984667778,
0.03935945779085159,
-0.2326088547706604,
0.3806111216545105,
-0.5897901058197021,
0.09783900529146194,
-0.8069130778312683,
0.23875240981578827,
0.4030689597129822,
-0.5346465110778809,
-0.570553183555603,
-0.5821859836578369,
0.020933251827955246,
-0.9212799668312073,
0.2347465455532074,
0.20400914549827576,
0.576263964176178,
0.3312445878982544,
0.014906497672200203,
-0.663007378578186,
-0.5955297350883484,
1.1067341566085815,
-0.7389716506004333,
0.15945641696453094,
0.12995003163814545,
0.2687007188796997,
-0.4861256778240204,
-0.964779257774353,
-0.4936947226524353,
-0.3907085955142975,
0.0937035009264946,
0.16539697349071503,
-0.23518376052379608,
0.3142811059951782,
0.6877870559692383,
0.18700584769248962,
-0.48721373081207275,
-0.2843802273273468,
-0.2634125351905823,
-0.15096555650234222,
0.6672206521034241,
0.11522386223077774,
0.7275696396827698,
0.13843774795532227,
-0.007017066236585379,
-0.23522698879241943,
-0.7495169639587402,
0.18137696385383606,
0.3727039396762848,
0.09212735295295715,
0.027499970048666,
0.6079398393630981,
-0.10189758986234665,
0.8385998010635376,
0.005453050602227449,
0.07769622653722763,
-0.12424378842115402,
-0.05737714841961861,
-0.36175525188446045,
0.13911697268486023,
0.4847710132598877,
0.2898465096950531,
0.17264537513256073,
-0.09286867827177048,
-0.307232528924942,
0.4367126524448395,
0.3656010031700134,
-0.7489764094352722,
-0.6105104088783264,
0.3442087769508362,
-0.4712200164794922,
-0.15053020417690277,
-0.1918531209230423,
-0.51002436876297,
0.047568947076797485,
-0.7890811562538147,
0.5425388216972351,
-0.5618390440940857,
-0.07203605771064758,
0.253879576921463,
-0.4714677631855011,
0.273847371339798,
0.3100871741771698,
-0.5640309453010559,
0.4136485755443573,
0.8851242065429688,
0.6960345506668091,
0.19027960300445557,
-0.30051806569099426,
-0.9247819781303406,
-0.09856078773736954,
-0.6796002984046936,
0.34741273522377014,
-0.7708909511566162,
-0.09846363216638565,
-0.1262933313846588,
-0.2231016308069229,
0.031446672976017,
-0.47094398736953735,
0.17296268045902252,
-0.35782474279403687,
0.06517772376537323,
-0.2550451159477234,
-0.6494571566581726,
-0.334092915058136,
0.09095645695924759,
-0.39667630195617676,
0.8374252319335938,
0.3640832304954529,
-0.4675552248954773,
0.14752309024333954,
-0.7865504026412964,
-0.5050985813140869,
-0.06601449847221375,
-0.38344141840934753,
-0.3197925090789795,
0.42528119683265686,
0.13120967149734497,
0.2116653025150299,
-0.23715101182460785,
0.20050157606601715,
-0.4644400179386139,
-0.6993130445480347,
0.16526757180690765,
-0.013449070043861866,
0.6975495219230652,
0.34231144189834595,
-0.4830799996852875,
0.1878020465373993,
-0.5239188075065613,
0.6005328893661499,
0.013397574424743652,
-0.07509048283100128,
-0.45109885931015015,
0.2744995653629303,
-0.24638217687606812,
0.2316436618566513,
-0.018983233720064163,
-0.3257175087928772,
0.18754827976226807,
-0.6059001684188843,
0.6693195104598999,
0.3264482319355011,
-0.03949248790740967,
0.4659983217716217,
-0.33644840121269226,
0.5393355488777161,
-0.3847868740558624,
0.24925130605697632,
-0.2215273082256317,
-0.3524342179298401,
-0.8671454787254333,
-0.05864354223012924,
-0.18179357051849365,
0.44136467576026917,
-1.0207411050796509,
0.42803269624710083,
0.14381588995456696,
-0.41861265897750854,
-0.44965922832489014,
0.1639433056116104,
0.3410627245903015,
0.199341282248497,
0.5312837362289429,
-0.1551501303911209,
-0.6087892651557922,
-0.6784651279449463,
-0.3965369760990143,
0.025756102055311203,
0.12777580320835114,
0.34981855750083923,
0.45071783661842346,
-0.24097171425819397,
1.0116429328918457,
-0.634317934513092,
0.2158747762441635,
-0.5257844924926758,
0.2383449375629425,
0.5352905988693237,
0.44858843088150024,
0.3444772958755493,
-0.52680504322052,
-0.2336898148059845,
0.013420835137367249,
-0.6175351738929749,
-0.4209989011287689,
-0.44927605986595154,
-0.06867404282093048,
-0.025683272629976273,
0.6474296450614929,
-0.20388883352279663,
0.2866387367248535,
0.6065284609794617,
-0.09899074584245682,
0.5662120580673218,
-0.5257397890090942,
0.13194158673286438,
-0.7826067805290222,
0.26846325397491455,
-0.11544360220432281,
-0.30100804567337036,
-0.5340714454650879,
0.4943169057369232,
-0.0891985073685646,
-0.5157700181007385,
-0.5160727500915527,
0.26317206025123596,
-0.5980686545372009,
-0.2043110579252243,
-0.4397663176059723,
-0.1278040111064911,
-0.04523039981722832,
0.459512323141098,
0.1879892349243164,
0.8071337938308716,
0.6503053307533264,
-0.7232756018638611,
0.36598366498947144,
-0.18077033758163452,
-0.44317033886909485,
-0.003010479500517249,
-0.7404016256332397,
0.49326908588409424,
-0.008211305364966393,
-0.018079090863466263,
-0.5421428680419922,
-0.10051736980676651,
0.16159233450889587,
-0.1518193930387497,
0.08656004071235657,
-0.42129096388816833,
-0.12639480829238892,
-0.34765592217445374,
-0.2578381896018982,
0.2778468728065491,
0.8291730880737305,
-0.8436338901519775,
0.3519652783870697,
0.3525368273258209,
0.18819302320480347,
-0.2862277626991272,
-0.5733718276023865,
0.053478918969631195,
-0.0869491696357727,
-0.4267607033252716,
0.21638408303260803,
-0.14803345501422882,
-0.3155234158039093,
0.04683096706867218,
-0.04272075742483139,
0.040737979114055634,
0.23268769681453705,
0.18162918090820312,
0.013607899658381939,
-0.07999496161937714,
-0.12132825702428818,
0.39944928884506226,
-0.10437601059675217,
-0.01139949169009924,
-0.5163497924804688,
0.5625326037406921,
-0.3161042630672455,
-0.42229363322257996,
-0.08003266900777817,
0.3243944048881531,
0.33703795075416565,
-0.15720416605472565,
0.18722905218601227,
0.24815066158771515,
-0.339319109916687,
-0.9895431399345398,
-0.10679221898317337,
-0.3556407392024994,
-0.48761695623397827,
0.2991636097431183,
-0.45453155040740967,
-0.8459468483924866,
0.10118678212165833,
-0.46743544936180115,
0.04339097440242767,
-0.05641336366534233,
0.4854099750518799,
0.034196797758340836,
1.118849515914917,
0.4478636085987091,
0.24067120254039764,
0.31288227438926697,
-0.43817296624183655,
0.5444491505622864,
-0.5505684614181519,
0.01825973019003868,
-0.2927972674369812,
-0.20558564364910126,
-0.6571905612945557,
-0.8223893642425537,
0.47954508662223816,
0.07811937481164932,
-0.15100859105587006,
0.36624905467033386,
-0.8150797486305237,
0.7755504846572876,
0.6887787580490112,
0.10376494377851486,
-0.09877722710371017,
0.040114711970090866,
-0.25301915407180786,
0.08865891396999359,
-1.0437768697738647,
-0.4478631317615509,
0.9503425359725952,
0.09757933020591736,
0.9748244285583496,
-0.3160482943058014,
1.1012681722640991,
0.4428333640098572,
0.3364377021789551,
-0.8428762555122375,
0.6367153525352478,
-0.22555096447467804,
-0.26900944113731384,
-0.08900762349367142,
-0.5345328450202942,
-0.7947577834129333,
0.034383624792099,
-0.08005665987730026,
-0.6098237633705139,
-0.10367242246866226,
0.3442889451980591,
-0.36830613017082214,
0.008167405612766743,
-0.9576663374900818,
0.9756084680557251,
-0.4737485349178314,
-0.6688172221183777,
-0.624277651309967,
-0.341775119304657,
0.45783546566963196,
0.2130894511938095,
0.18989543616771698,
0.13694347441196442,
0.25410744547843933,
0.35866546630859375,
-0.59589684009552,
0.7374048829078674,
-0.21536530554294586,
0.09969338029623032,
0.7117336988449097,
0.353930801153183,
0.4014213979244232,
0.11428962647914886,
-0.07308019697666168,
-0.0853814035654068,
0.3262810707092285,
-0.16985322535037994,
-0.6253281235694885,
0.9811939597129822,
-0.6623750925064087,
-0.7984834313392639,
-0.49440819025039673,
-0.5740729570388794,
0.18009817600250244,
0.15832751989364624,
0.01309956330806017,
0.46550390124320984,
-0.26851749420166016,
-0.0035186237655580044,
0.5415029525756836,
-0.6733182072639465,
0.4507044553756714,
0.22279368340969086,
-0.42695075273513794,
-0.30536171793937683,
1.0819300413131714,
-0.0026513575576245785,
0.10351046174764633,
0.32442507147789,
0.32491716742515564,
-0.22039413452148438,
-0.20880821347236633,
-0.3837616741657257,
-0.14909663796424866,
-0.7039251923561096,
-0.005905501078814268,
-0.38660866022109985,
-0.08121680468320847,
-0.07582256197929382,
-0.5046188831329346,
-0.26162657141685486,
-0.2339859902858734,
-0.11040281504392624,
0.29409629106521606,
0.1155170202255249,
0.6364700198173523,
-0.01533812191337347,
0.1402241736650467,
-0.6421651244163513,
0.35555359721183777,
0.30802154541015625,
0.1323796808719635,
-0.10920076072216034,
-0.0756424069404602,
-0.125437393784523,
0.15834978222846985,
-0.4256729185581207,
-0.9763154983520508,
0.47564536333084106,
0.14035557210445404,
0.5714450478553772,
0.10840892791748047,
0.015996934846043587,
0.48901697993278503,
-0.42666658759117126,
0.5592151880264282,
0.3297286927700043,
-1.3331451416015625,
0.7969936728477478,
-0.14441132545471191,
0.14501364529132843,
0.4015752971172333,
0.15373435616493225,
-0.42413339018821716,
-0.26536551117897034,
-0.6067246198654175,
-0.5242096781730652,
0.7746384739875793,
0.26157355308532715,
0.0263206884264946,
-0.046305101364851,
0.4893662631511688,
0.2146589457988739,
0.10773679614067078,
-0.507965087890625,
0.09392271935939789,
-0.3218419849872589,
-0.36618801951408386,
-0.01656321808695793,
0.20536412298679352,
-0.11688823997974396,
-0.3525448143482208,
0.579238772392273,
-0.5923218727111816,
0.3653915524482727,
0.28820738196372986,
-0.1452288031578064,
-0.012968778610229492,
0.24185873568058014,
0.3976927101612091,
0.5860284566879272,
-0.01848733238875866,
0.4045884907245636,
-0.04659073054790497,
0.04739969223737717,
0.10423605889081955,
-0.12628449499607086,
-0.41517701745033264,
-0.20116280019283295,
0.14742054045200348,
0.8304165601730347,
0.05314135178923607,
-0.8977442979812622,
0.30859434604644775,
0.013782435096800327,
-0.08348646014928818,
-0.22003398835659027,
0.7452660202980042,
0.18088270723819733,
0.19424156844615936,
0.04919169843196869,
0.16344653069972992,
0.33305516839027405,
-0.9010616540908813,
0.3141920566558838,
0.52336585521698,
-0.0585329569876194,
-0.37652114033699036,
0.5312589406967163,
0.09160348773002625,
-0.4157255291938782,
0.6766258478164673,
-0.47828203439712524,
-0.7884055376052856,
0.8475621342658997,
0.8223503232002258,
0.8853855729103088,
0.14894571900367737,
0.35154300928115845,
0.5740746259689331,
0.3839813768863678,
-0.21684123575687408,
0.6731694340705872,
-0.16996733844280243,
-0.5265920162200928,
-0.6194905042648315,
-0.5102739930152893,
-0.441169410943985,
0.24359416961669922,
-0.25829121470451355,
0.38887813687324524,
-0.7019614577293396,
-0.04600946232676506,
-0.4202840030193329,
-0.03573981299996376,
-0.6644095778465271,
0.44256681203842163,
0.19153007864952087,
0.7941761612892151,
-0.9567816257476807,
0.8707960247993469,
0.8103932738304138,
-0.3576841652393341,
-0.8846657872200012,
0.12632130086421967,
-0.3518197238445282,
-0.6013543009757996,
0.29561951756477356,
0.3812812268733978,
-0.05944199487566948,
0.12595413625240326,
-0.7859628200531006,
-0.6070197820663452,
0.6914634704589844,
0.5953407883644104,
-0.7601780295372009,
0.15973907709121704,
0.13625560700893402,
0.5963716506958008,
-0.3669625222682953,
0.405243843793869,
0.5855795741081238,
0.3765611946582794,
-0.07045910507440567,
-0.41806232929229736,
0.1029847264289856,
-0.13137000799179077,
-0.07562433928251266,
0.15988479554653168,
-0.4897894263267517,
0.6591471433639526,
-0.5781447887420654,
-0.11544204503297806,
0.013349175453186035,
0.45443928241729736,
0.5408856868743896,
0.6394453048706055,
0.28461015224456787,
0.6521676182746887,
0.738618016242981,
-0.15649686753749847,
1.2012064456939697,
-0.3967505097389221,
0.40839946269989014,
1.0447958707809448,
-0.2576836347579956,
0.5595666766166687,
0.7117739319801331,
-0.07910096645355225,
0.34190627932548523,
0.5322391390800476,
-0.017983172088861465,
0.6220588088035583,
0.6339591145515442,
-0.0638241097331047,
-0.6247897148132324,
0.16920924186706543,
-0.01805143430829048,
0.2059384286403656,
0.4964737892150879,
-0.35399654507637024,
-0.20432408154010773,
-0.2624945044517517,
-0.279805451631546,
0.190712571144104,
-0.3480188548564911,
0.4947586953639984,
0.3810287415981293,
-1.1617010831832886,
0.588106632232666,
0.20528502762317657,
0.35171547532081604,
-0.6383108496665955,
-0.46533191204071045,
-0.0027970049995929003,
0.37521621584892273,
-0.2751848101615906,
-0.7632761001586914,
0.47242116928100586,
-0.19112391769886017,
0.03388338163495064,
-0.17840981483459473,
0.8951281309127808,
-0.4414534270763397,
-0.4318631589412689,
0.4449336528778076,
0.4173499643802643,
0.19410398602485657,
0.09278473258018494,
-0.885939359664917,
0.21862347424030304,
0.2916524112224579,
-0.08751646429300308,
0.14961308240890503,
0.24066276848316193,
-0.06297816336154938,
0.5708305239677429,
0.8757123947143555,
0.11774416267871857,
0.23392772674560547,
0.04393273591995239,
0.7164375185966492,
-0.44506463408470154,
-0.5272339582443237,
-0.77840256690979,
0.05042186379432678,
0.00411900132894516,
-0.066041499376297,
0.5333715081214905,
0.7195548415184021,
0.9786505103111267,
-0.37615033984184265,
1.279916763305664,
-0.36020219326019287,
-0.0007560120429843664,
-0.7127089500427246,
0.4724450707435608,
-0.6760318279266357,
0.17108604311943054,
-0.16355380415916443,
-0.9133567214012146,
-0.11160190403461456,
0.8237695693969727,
-0.559389591217041,
0.026869045570492744,
0.6684892773628235,
1.074080467224121,
-0.38178592920303345,
0.0690697655081749,
0.5171090960502625,
-0.08069002628326416,
0.37430092692375183,
1.0969717502593994,
0.9904759526252747,
-0.2988393008708954,
0.12864625453948975,
-0.27514979243278503,
-0.40023261308670044,
-0.12909077107906342,
-1.0278081893920898,
-0.9053009152412415,
-0.3479243814945221,
-0.4000886380672455,
-0.4425727427005768,
0.21478790044784546,
1.205081820487976,
0.6522385478019714,
-0.8343738317489624,
-0.3380315899848938,
-0.6948330402374268,
0.237391859292984,
-0.4695470929145813,
-0.1910324990749359,
0.23650233447551727,
-0.5915035009384155,
-0.768918514251709,
0.6795034408569336,
0.37101051211357117,
-0.45429423451423645,
0.017330698668956757,
-0.53464674949646,
0.013052616268396378,
0.3057980537414551,
0.4368036985397339,
0.48062413930892944,
-0.4813591539859772,
-0.2939900755882263,
0.10071663558483124,
0.11577878892421722,
-0.11817759275436401,
1.1978862285614014,
-0.7110975384712219,
0.6773945093154907,
0.7366921305656433,
0.671282947063446,
0.46781376004219055,
-0.10348612815141678,
0.74659663438797,
-0.43072009086608887,
-0.048894379287958145,
0.23528875410556793,
0.3555084764957428,
0.24683088064193726,
-0.16994373500347137,
0.34689420461654663,
0.23100827634334564,
-0.4506990313529968,
-0.6591452956199646,
0.2766853868961334,
-0.7021313309669495,
-0.5295629501342773,
1.2444615364074707,
-0.208331897854805,
-0.3783682584762573,
-0.12818485498428345,
-0.4308241605758667,
0.510780394077301,
-0.23458607494831085,
0.7853444218635559,
0.3174341022968292,
-0.2618580162525177,
-0.12201377749443054,
-0.30774587392807007,
0.5221027135848999,
0.4837804138660431,
-0.9090069532394409,
-0.03676338866353035,
0.5140883326530457,
0.5274611711502075,
0.02627030946314335,
0.3594413697719574,
0.14620524644851685,
0.5734217166900635,
0.010157336480915546,
0.29274147748947144,
-0.07810637354850769,
-0.35873985290527344,
-0.05441926419734955,
0.24711643159389496,
0.14757667481899261,
0.10046075284481049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16295v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16295v3
|
Comparative Analysis of Open-Source Language Models in Summarizing Medical Text Data
| 2024-05-25T16:16:22 | 2024-05-29T20:40:32 |
Yuhao Chen, Zhimu Wang, Bo Wen, Farhana Zulkernine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Unstructured text in medical notes and dialogues contains rich information.
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior
performance in question answering and summarization tasks on unstructured text
data, outperforming traditional text analysis approaches. However, there is a
lack of scientific studies in the literature that methodically evaluate and
report on the performance of different LLMs, specifically for domain-specific
data such as medical chart notes. We propose an evaluation approach to analyze
the performance of open-source LLMs such as Llama2 and Mistral for medical
summarization tasks, using GPT-4 as an assessor. Our innovative approach to
quantitative evaluation of LLMs can enable quality control, support the
selection of effective LLMs for specific tasks, and advance knowledge discovery
in digital health.
|
[
0.08444570749998093,
-0.7501661777496338,
0.8712772130966187,
0.1329757273197174,
-0.419717013835907,
0.010319739580154419,
-0.31875741481781006,
-0.4656527638435364,
0.18639805912971497,
0.507053792476654,
-0.08634871989488602,
-0.8605943322181702,
-0.7087275981903076,
0.3190821707248688,
-0.4825432598590851,
1.2208057641983032,
-0.26591530442237854,
0.3721166253089905,
-0.6199402213096619,
-0.23455312848091125,
-0.17142456769943237,
-0.5748637914657593,
-0.4756794571876526,
-0.39060041308403015,
0.27365174889564514,
0.014246244914829731,
0.5523773431777954,
0.4004501402378082,
1.0505517721176147,
0.36541008949279785,
-0.19537894427776337,
-0.015155225992202759,
-0.43830832839012146,
0.14848357439041138,
-0.05663454905152321,
-0.3891561031341553,
-0.7942149043083191,
-0.08726341277360916,
0.5624716877937317,
0.6287221908569336,
-0.11304087936878204,
0.29164132475852966,
-0.07884416729211807,
0.7660055160522461,
-0.22469425201416016,
0.440032422542572,
-0.22979533672332764,
-0.056528013199567795,
-0.09154126793146133,
-0.3262409567832947,
-0.07087066024541855,
-0.8028294444084167,
0.233387291431427,
-0.4989108443260193,
0.10746381431818008,
-0.2942731976509094,
0.6141794919967651,
0.26504895091056824,
-0.26487788558006287,
-0.6321903467178345,
-0.6711077094078064,
0.5576155185699463,
-1.15017569065094,
0.2991950213909149,
0.28212857246398926,
0.36708828806877136,
0.01252899132668972,
-1.099122405052185,
-0.3288687765598297,
-0.30351173877716064,
-0.06320919841527939,
0.3246103823184967,
-0.4491948187351227,
0.08150996267795563,
-0.18687132000923157,
0.7226800322532654,
-0.7623775601387024,
0.11372258514165878,
-0.5036048293113708,
-0.09117840975522995,
0.5404272675514221,
0.3316722512245178,
0.5370027422904968,
-0.09419669955968857,
-0.11081739515066147,
0.27425843477249146,
-0.6430785655975342,
-0.19873356819152832,
-0.15937425196170807,
0.06931675970554352,
-0.3367578089237213,
0.8645599484443665,
-0.2120153158903122,
0.5582807064056396,
-0.3352111279964447,
-0.4738174080848694,
0.4128793478012085,
-0.625207781791687,
-0.2829763889312744,
-0.21882791817188263,
1.0940595865249634,
0.6880145072937012,
0.27376192808151245,
-0.28689852356910706,
-0.14322279393672943,
-0.06258603185415268,
0.07189548015594482,
-0.9723609089851379,
-0.2922095060348511,
0.5322377681732178,
-0.7854079008102417,
-0.3032093942165375,
-0.20532739162445068,
-0.7510563135147095,
-0.4962773621082306,
-0.28975802659988403,
0.2762853801250458,
-0.22526267170906067,
-0.1627340465784073,
0.08256715536117554,
-0.12298658490180969,
-0.2754702568054199,
0.448983758687973,
-0.5765702128410339,
0.6112346649169922,
0.7664674520492554,
1.2553050518035889,
-0.4137534499168396,
0.017386475577950478,
-0.2563626766204834,
-0.07254968583583832,
-0.35469850897789,
0.9509732723236084,
-0.38082823157310486,
-0.5360279679298401,
-0.1062290221452713,
-0.17426717281341553,
-0.029998930171132088,
-0.8040435314178467,
0.6204590201377869,
-0.32504233717918396,
0.3671199679374695,
-0.2490570992231369,
-0.6579068899154663,
-0.11943177133798599,
0.11260515451431274,
-0.8415139317512512,
0.8822278380393982,
0.4860099256038666,
-1.1264294385910034,
0.1970546990633011,
-0.739572286605835,
-0.3315991461277008,
0.13177739083766937,
-0.49284008145332336,
-0.5474996566772461,
0.10952161252498627,
0.3618201017379761,
0.5445512533187866,
-0.6482757329940796,
0.3303010165691376,
-0.11593574285507202,
-0.47010132670402527,
0.3946976959705353,
-0.029942285269498825,
0.6421251893043518,
0.13327926397323608,
-0.10319264233112335,
0.41827037930488586,
-0.5799984931945801,
-0.09586179256439209,
0.22458060085773468,
-0.49281615018844604,
-0.5354766249656677,
0.09858264029026031,
-0.0055744885466992855,
0.04046284779906273,
0.18927954137325287,
-0.40164461731910706,
0.21543574333190918,
-0.4412398040294647,
0.4798485040664673,
0.34641599655151367,
0.15183013677597046,
0.17263489961624146,
-0.38810157775878906,
0.7188641428947449,
-0.23877224326133728,
0.13670553267002106,
-0.17200741171836853,
-0.5811444520950317,
-0.26102444529533386,
-0.5097583532333374,
0.4273272454738617,
0.5642074346542358,
-0.6701729893684387,
0.07980063557624817,
-0.5525735020637512,
-0.511684238910675,
-0.7764483690261841,
0.06213429570198059,
0.4657217562198639,
0.6378527283668518,
0.3840949535369873,
-0.436563640832901,
-0.3810405731201172,
-0.7919822335243225,
-0.18076063692569733,
-0.304043173789978,
-0.33292120695114136,
0.3316991925239563,
0.40464749932289124,
-0.3294580280780792,
0.777234673500061,
-0.4759845733642578,
-0.17573373019695282,
-0.39817219972610474,
0.16183261573314667,
0.1852722316980362,
-0.020062826573848724,
0.6871559023857117,
-0.44203677773475647,
-0.31536510586738586,
0.10858357697725296,
-0.8966225385665894,
-0.5022330284118652,
0.30034345388412476,
0.28811877965927124,
0.006317553576081991,
0.4290640354156494,
-0.5064745545387268,
0.21157073974609375,
0.7554985880851746,
-0.2182563692331314,
0.467556893825531,
-0.27344828844070435,
0.4162154197692871,
-1.003675937652588,
0.3932642936706543,
0.007953975349664688,
-0.2028592973947525,
-0.732322633266449,
-0.06673938035964966,
0.1732468605041504,
-0.025153739377856255,
-0.19559071958065033,
0.547113299369812,
-0.418137788772583,
-0.2839456796646118,
-0.22668763995170593,
0.36608409881591797,
-0.13701927661895752,
0.14055632054805756,
0.07694888114929199,
0.7821747064590454,
0.23620346188545227,
-0.333504855632782,
0.23031243681907654,
0.3560650944709778,
-0.548201858997345,
0.35977986454963684,
-1.0311033725738525,
-0.11413320153951645,
-0.12864266335964203,
0.1964314877986908,
-1.0157592296600342,
-0.15596164762973785,
0.07144699990749359,
-0.5902386903762817,
0.15881246328353882,
0.040552735328674316,
-0.4669880270957947,
-0.35679155588150024,
-0.6063263416290283,
0.36045897006988525,
0.45561137795448303,
-0.06584632396697998,
0.28002429008483887,
0.6344703435897827,
-0.8950722813606262,
-0.350016713142395,
-0.5604212880134583,
0.08466532081365585,
-0.14268499612808228,
-0.46719521284103394,
0.15370413661003113,
-0.08953506499528885,
-0.614966869354248,
0.1944739669561386,
-0.20425985753536224,
-0.2455044984817505,
0.030115898698568344,
0.14558297395706177,
0.47419503331184387,
-0.383248895406723,
0.09738817811012268,
0.12430667132139206,
-0.11155775189399719,
0.0811690166592598,
-0.043315015733242035,
0.24518407881259918,
0.06905066221952438,
-0.36089691519737244,
-0.22535058856010437,
0.25112470984458923,
0.581088125705719,
-0.37938687205314636,
0.35149839520454407,
0.18472865223884583,
-0.3064696490764618,
0.1257680207490921,
-0.4070478081703186,
0.13733358681201935,
-0.38265353441238403,
0.5005351305007935,
0.1284993588924408,
-0.9806779026985168,
0.34506726264953613,
-0.06671471893787384,
0.2271295040845871,
0.5996904373168945,
0.9489026069641113,
-0.06434483826160431,
0.6830965280532837,
0.4807010889053345,
-0.2035987377166748,
0.049684371799230576,
0.018620779737830162,
0.048126790672540665,
-0.5933718085289001,
-0.25249162316322327,
-0.6522724032402039,
0.12099991738796234,
-0.3084733486175537,
-0.5597774982452393,
0.821887195110321,
-0.007856049574911594,
0.029393812641501427,
-0.06643699109554291,
-0.4425998628139496,
0.3474968373775482,
0.05966823175549507,
-0.10751678794622421,
0.8140090107917786,
-0.10294420272111893,
-0.05599413812160492,
0.04592093080282211,
-0.42216747999191284,
-0.8267333507537842,
1.4298774003982544,
0.5013813376426697,
0.6553501486778259,
0.15512177348136902,
0.41222190856933594,
0.2669662833213806,
0.650401771068573,
-0.7324485182762146,
0.34301307797431946,
-0.33887356519699097,
-0.2787635028362274,
-0.3200080096721649,
-0.6108020544052124,
-0.9995284080505371,
0.3666697144508362,
-0.06698981672525406,
-0.6463868618011475,
-0.4306665062904358,
-0.06881590932607651,
-0.35934630036354065,
0.19800515472888947,
-0.5483587384223938,
0.6899906992912292,
-0.29824206233024597,
0.2675229012966156,
-0.0954638198018074,
-0.44379544258117676,
0.5531743764877319,
-0.32617607712745667,
0.4742051362991333,
-0.14266979694366455,
-0.35382819175720215,
0.8568602800369263,
-0.4465337097644806,
0.6085963845252991,
-0.04526294767856598,
-0.3864732086658478,
0.2314782738685608,
0.0019024208886548877,
0.11700622737407684,
-0.01381774339824915,
0.0011733276769518852,
0.4220605492591858,
0.22585046291351318,
-0.06771301478147507,
-0.6307805776596069,
0.7776912450790405,
-0.6346948742866516,
-0.18160325288772583,
-0.31792065501213074,
-0.4059290289878845,
-0.23348718881607056,
0.2226324826478958,
0.2467179298400879,
0.4513159394264221,
-0.3883958160877228,
-0.059432726353406906,
0.32703015208244324,
-0.369331955909729,
0.3258541226387024,
0.7580610513687134,
-0.366435170173645,
-0.5891761779785156,
0.6827548146247864,
0.1385342925786972,
0.1978548765182495,
0.5058378577232361,
0.3543408215045929,
-0.29104816913604736,
-0.9113763570785522,
-0.392848402261734,
0.47636982798576355,
-0.6824524402618408,
-0.055608369410037994,
-0.7889837622642517,
-0.10605288296937943,
-0.3744739592075348,
0.1388816237449646,
-0.11880340427160263,
-0.5914799571037292,
-0.10083627700805664,
-0.20571015775203705,
0.4208202064037323,
1.1242622137069702,
0.25529569387435913,
0.1694788783788681,
-0.913098931312561,
0.4155423939228058,
0.026792610064148903,
0.5523403286933899,
-0.03515348210930824,
-0.23616383969783783,
-0.27035000920295715,
-0.3235386610031128,
-0.2741144001483917,
-0.9667671918869019,
0.2696681320667267,
-0.08107651770114899,
0.6078365445137024,
0.34070929884910583,
-0.24711498618125916,
0.3971148729324341,
-0.5450038313865662,
0.8009411692619324,
0.22942881286144257,
-0.8150227665901184,
0.43979495763778687,
-0.38261160254478455,
0.2601894438266754,
0.5203222036361694,
0.45019111037254333,
-0.5696631669998169,
-0.5093795657157898,
-0.3175950348377228,
-0.8414338827133179,
0.41285625100135803,
0.37421730160713196,
-0.3553438186645508,
0.1743037849664688,
0.2328481674194336,
0.24818648397922516,
0.2831600308418274,
-0.4393003284931183,
-0.12102002650499344,
-0.02613564021885395,
-0.5036792159080505,
-0.3306795060634613,
-0.28054022789001465,
-0.15604111552238464,
-0.12074927985668182,
0.3096274435520172,
-0.027957826852798462,
0.2621159553527832,
0.33292606472969055,
-0.08008774369955063,
-0.0020950143225491047,
0.35114485025405884,
0.6597438454627991,
0.8272801041603088,
-0.15442073345184326,
0.057844482362270355,
0.09485301375389099,
-0.8170696496963501,
-0.002468803199008107,
0.18572092056274414,
-0.21614797413349152,
0.3212326169013977,
0.8470481634140015,
0.4955507218837738,
0.2693096697330475,
-0.9288057088851929,
0.7255184054374695,
-0.2608982026576996,
-0.16412554681301117,
-0.11682217568159103,
-0.19974558055400848,
0.2862578332424164,
0.15829581022262573,
0.06079017370939255,
-0.3942693769931793,
0.4858507513999939,
-0.3332739472389221,
0.10484624654054642,
0.1732741743326187,
-0.28693678975105286,
-0.47037819027900696,
0.5761856436729431,
0.19105751812458038,
-0.07037876546382904,
0.3236740231513977,
0.265118807554245,
-0.13784487545490265,
0.5769653916358948,
0.4365779757499695,
0.706177830696106,
-0.388322651386261,
0.18111982941627502,
0.25966373085975647,
0.26376619935035706,
-0.07006377726793289,
0.5574549436569214,
0.07633230835199356,
-0.18496018648147583,
-0.7667235732078552,
-0.36040666699409485,
-0.5129579901695251,
0.29439806938171387,
-0.5021106600761414,
0.060375798493623734,
-0.2116321176290512,
-0.2738282382488251,
0.19186557829380035,
-0.12667444348335266,
-0.459145724773407,
0.061316799372434616,
-0.2470085620880127,
0.775506854057312,
-0.7196891903877258,
0.6114649176597595,
0.6149386167526245,
-0.46099576354026794,
-0.42569413781166077,
-0.07437766343355179,
0.1619631052017212,
-0.6914873719215393,
0.44734326004981995,
-0.15672166645526886,
0.059290047734975815,
-0.4304266571998596,
-0.24235111474990845,
-0.6646778583526611,
1.134266972541809,
0.32900625467300415,
-0.5966394543647766,
-0.2672221064567566,
0.22701852023601532,
0.8952115774154663,
-0.0831216350197792,
0.7285445332527161,
0.614097535610199,
0.29230278730392456,
-0.10713058710098267,
-1.3461912870407104,
0.002345265354961157,
-0.3949891924858093,
-0.21472860872745514,
0.3671495318412781,
-0.4161370098590851,
0.8547672629356384,
-0.29682233929634094,
-0.3263886570930481,
0.1792117953300476,
0.33707720041275024,
0.12949344515800476,
0.5489944815635681,
0.03408592566847801,
0.3164413273334503,
0.8172951936721802,
-0.0036700766067951918,
1.227329134941101,
-0.2228090465068817,
0.42007535696029663,
1.1723151206970215,
-0.3609214425086975,
0.8252220153808594,
0.16620977222919464,
-0.5058044791221619,
0.28489720821380615,
0.36647042632102966,
0.11329072713851929,
0.279201477766037,
0.4313792884349823,
-0.1954137086868286,
0.37850818037986755,
0.12771093845367432,
-0.39352577924728394,
0.21378210186958313,
0.3136681318283081,
-0.5036170482635498,
-0.4027383327484131,
-0.18973545730113983,
0.2757020890712738,
0.10354825854301453,
-0.3303307294845581,
1.097827434539795,
0.14619652926921844,
-0.4030460715293884,
0.5277719497680664,
0.13576973974704742,
0.32498544454574585,
-0.5830397009849548,
-0.12753716111183167,
-0.3627440333366394,
0.04509984701871872,
-0.3806729018688202,
-0.7427241802215576,
0.3309067487716675,
0.4544563591480255,
0.03629845008254051,
0.2667582631111145,
0.6554220914840698,
-0.28255951404571533,
-0.45457378029823303,
0.2764226794242859,
0.6058331727981567,
0.4136464595794678,
0.0511966310441494,
-0.4193623661994934,
-0.009663131088018417,
-0.21221691370010376,
-0.24520044028759003,
0.2903769612312317,
0.4413374066352844,
-0.2643772065639496,
0.7245011329650879,
0.4926372468471527,
0.4497778117656708,
-0.2523338794708252,
0.27630725502967834,
0.9963626861572266,
-0.6429782509803772,
-0.38685232400894165,
-0.975592315196991,
0.4030584692955017,
-0.10139449685811996,
-0.20737172663211823,
0.7343443036079407,
0.8027604818344116,
0.5407530069351196,
-0.03092559240758419,
1.1211210489273071,
0.2777913510799408,
0.9485116004943848,
-0.5761096477508545,
0.8482784032821655,
-0.3892543315887451,
0.2529444694519043,
-0.6048237085342407,
-0.5945543646812439,
-0.41380754113197327,
0.23687423765659332,
-0.19355571269989014,
-0.06705466657876968,
0.881951093673706,
0.4151347577571869,
0.03847439959645271,
0.06889218091964722,
0.12130597233772278,
0.2765231132507324,
0.3645595610141754,
0.45490387082099915,
0.7515972256660461,
-0.08229392766952515,
0.4035535454750061,
0.059695616364479065,
-0.5476971864700317,
-0.09020142257213593,
-0.7657008171081543,
-1.0647962093353271,
-0.5424607396125793,
-0.15126438438892365,
-0.1075163334608078,
-0.02183397114276886,
0.7358738780021667,
0.26192981004714966,
-0.8297611474990845,
-0.19011978805065155,
0.26401612162590027,
-0.200790673494339,
-0.11840179562568665,
-0.14461909234523773,
0.7373858094215393,
0.03850901499390602,
-0.4446098506450653,
0.41227713227272034,
0.5543843507766724,
0.09938209503889084,
-0.22114317119121552,
-0.05647160857915878,
0.31530189514160156,
0.11653674393892288,
0.7257207632064819,
0.06555049866437912,
-0.736222505569458,
0.32511940598487854,
0.0290727149695158,
-0.17701752483844757,
0.15764954686164856,
1.189965009689331,
-0.4651382565498352,
0.43404707312583923,
0.5486698150634766,
0.6400176882743835,
0.3112773895263672,
0.224042147397995,
0.5184734463691711,
-0.18545415997505188,
-0.33090609312057495,
0.38742125034332275,
0.3125803470611572,
0.2865963578224182,
-0.1905314177274704,
0.646538257598877,
-0.05083129554986954,
-0.6701707243919373,
-0.6662448644638062,
-0.24675969779491425,
-0.923635721206665,
-0.471828818321228,
1.189969778060913,
-0.3025464415550232,
0.0210981797426939,
-0.2125871777534485,
-0.43433311581611633,
0.28393855690956116,
-0.2858768701553345,
0.7768849730491638,
0.5640956163406372,
-0.21435725688934326,
0.11152064800262451,
-0.8721957802772522,
0.4672399163246155,
0.0059258174151182175,
-1.2076091766357422,
0.04483562707901001,
0.6015569567680359,
0.4644794464111328,
-0.06634719669818878,
1.3020398616790771,
-0.7360882759094238,
0.15759901702404022,
-0.34102246165275574,
0.05794604867696762,
-0.12511518597602844,
-0.07241649180650711,
-0.633126437664032,
0.21530960500240326,
0.20650450885295868,
0.0722566545009613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16284v1
|
Generating clickbait spoilers with an ensemble of large language models
| 2024-05-25T15:49:08 | 2024-05-25T15:49:08 |
Mateusz Woźny, Mateusz Lango
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Clickbait posts are a widespread problem in the webspace. The generation of
spoilers, i.e. short texts that neutralize clickbait by providing information
that satisfies the curiosity induced by it, is one of the proposed solutions to
the problem. Current state-of-the-art methods are based on passage retrieval or
question answering approaches and are limited to generating spoilers only in
the form of a phrase or a passage. In this work, we propose an ensemble of
fine-tuned large language models for clickbait spoiler generation. Our approach
is not limited to phrase or passage spoilers, but is also able to generate
multipart spoilers that refer to several non-consecutive parts of text.
Experimental evaluation demonstrates that the proposed ensemble model
outperforms the baselines in terms of BLEU, METEOR and BERTScore metrics.
|
[
-0.6010245680809021,
-0.8200399875640869,
0.762457549571991,
0.2545084059238434,
-0.48424264788627625,
-0.3241475522518158,
-0.28612402081489563,
-0.3688637912273407,
0.5556039810180664,
0.6208739280700684,
-0.61899334192276,
-0.2253170758485794,
-0.48987877368927,
0.38065454363822937,
-0.5612925887107849,
1.416086196899414,
0.313679963350296,
-0.20043881237506866,
-0.3946220576763153,
0.2524349093437195,
-0.45441362261772156,
-0.17999006807804108,
-0.6412870287895203,
0.10605473071336746,
0.8284635543823242,
0.19020302593708038,
0.5720110535621643,
0.5136721134185791,
0.2916491627693176,
0.23836344480514526,
-0.11490846425294876,
0.2550128400325775,
-0.7037399411201477,
0.3132198750972748,
-0.39785099029541016,
-0.23943881690502167,
-0.022174512967467308,
-0.07337192445993423,
0.7060208916664124,
0.6597224473953247,
-0.016873549669981003,
0.10001837462186813,
0.07140397280454636,
0.2648151218891144,
-0.6546220779418945,
-0.009021763689815998,
-0.7783849835395813,
-0.2556387484073639,
-0.13475726544857025,
-0.4531864821910858,
-0.6941456198692322,
-0.6686771512031555,
0.03542690351605415,
-0.48138317465782166,
0.29037803411483765,
0.25396719574928284,
0.5040422081947327,
0.30066221952438354,
-0.41581737995147705,
-0.20587287843227386,
-0.7629085183143616,
1.0916008949279785,
-0.8572589755058289,
0.10858004540205002,
0.154429093003273,
0.08313068002462387,
-0.23618954420089722,
-0.34653839468955994,
-0.5069443583488464,
-0.2355085015296936,
-0.11096508055925369,
0.04846425727009773,
-0.053325265645980835,
-0.30962371826171875,
0.08975937217473984,
-0.05879129469394684,
-0.813040554523468,
0.2722999155521393,
-0.4105721414089203,
-0.18942202627658844,
0.8385418057441711,
0.2715506851673126,
0.26294296979904175,
-0.46913227438926697,
-0.5666906237602234,
0.0023782216012477875,
-0.6130500435829163,
-0.17443746328353882,
0.6219102740287781,
0.2556300461292267,
0.20155668258666992,
0.3512769043445587,
-0.28519877791404724,
0.6212149262428284,
0.31014055013656616,
-0.10915712267160416,
-0.12540850043296814,
-0.2244325876235962,
0.09465747326612473,
0.10116409510374069,
0.9633529782295227,
0.6995055079460144,
0.32785138487815857,
-0.2641630470752716,
-0.013981283642351627,
-0.025467822328209877,
0.38260218501091003,
-0.9768698215484619,
-0.29308322072029114,
0.4964931309223175,
-0.4570038616657257,
-0.7522476315498352,
0.07976023107767105,
-1.0654467344284058,
-0.37287166714668274,
-0.13682277500629425,
0.39175185561180115,
-0.5410405993461609,
-0.0002901572734117508,
-0.14587819576263428,
-0.30249956250190735,
-0.019311023876070976,
0.3817204236984253,
-0.6665815711021423,
0.04517025128006935,
0.37634027004241943,
0.3300083577632904,
-0.33422747254371643,
-0.5933895707130432,
-0.7734782099723816,
0.2640668749809265,
-0.2833736836910248,
1.0373355150222778,
-0.8052391409873962,
-0.3715815544128418,
0.1646357774734497,
0.04531784728169441,
-0.1758912354707718,
-0.30008789896965027,
0.5464348196983337,
-0.9891579747200012,
0.3917558491230011,
-0.11135225743055344,
-0.7403748631477356,
-0.42401501536369324,
0.3918430805206299,
-0.842139720916748,
0.5647534728050232,
-0.6803414821624756,
-0.7099514603614807,
0.43970856070518494,
-0.6108496189117432,
-0.5630539655685425,
0.11443600058555603,
0.11226800829172134,
-0.30907711386680603,
0.1669764518737793,
0.39683997631073,
0.3853123188018799,
-0.3344383239746094,
0.4349544048309326,
-0.10387793928384781,
-0.3529939651489258,
0.6148527264595032,
-0.46524593234062195,
-0.008306161500513554,
0.02896585501730442,
-0.12897124886512756,
0.035688575357198715,
-0.30632925033569336,
-0.19698800146579742,
0.15311037003993988,
-0.726018488407135,
-0.48256275057792664,
0.2781473994255066,
0.08580896258354187,
0.09695011377334595,
0.37684500217437744,
-0.29440438747406006,
0.10577873140573502,
-0.32188141345977783,
0.09229802340269089,
0.5432367324829102,
0.40504559874534607,
0.3843047618865967,
-0.4378567636013031,
0.5796205997467041,
0.3056831359863281,
0.20877975225448608,
-0.6884772181510925,
-0.49447154998779297,
-0.6169210076332092,
0.0716642513871193,
0.5542077422142029,
0.2975495457649231,
-0.8438596725463867,
0.42146173119544983,
-0.3255065977573395,
-0.38381460309028625,
-0.18162018060684204,
0.003707822412252426,
0.4179488718509674,
0.16430488228797913,
0.3687056601047516,
0.0257288608700037,
-0.10500244051218033,
-0.7032099366188049,
-0.3699946105480194,
0.16775745153427124,
0.0015732813626527786,
0.15417300164699554,
0.6055503487586975,
0.1568424254655838,
0.8289487957954407,
-0.7027466297149658,
-0.10441824793815613,
-0.1456030309200287,
0.3692587912082672,
0.08608005195856094,
0.43326273560523987,
0.6206416487693787,
-1.1677579879760742,
-0.4653843343257904,
-0.41878393292427063,
-0.560852587223053,
0.1815764307975769,
-0.0575217604637146,
0.10844162851572037,
0.061213236302137375,
0.5755312442779541,
-0.6049909591674805,
0.0626249834895134,
0.37132903933525085,
-0.060376767069101334,
0.8634887337684631,
0.06489157676696777,
0.23151499032974243,
-1.2357512712478638,
0.17724376916885376,
0.17625713348388672,
-0.18588443100452423,
-0.6391626596450806,
0.18365339934825897,
-0.16739624738693237,
-0.2316729575395584,
-0.7334632873535156,
0.6857057213783264,
-0.30773571133613586,
0.5088339447975159,
-0.5276613235473633,
0.2926446795463562,
-0.0038865050300955772,
0.545701801776886,
0.18482975661754608,
0.4335693120956421,
0.3969026803970337,
-0.8182653784751892,
0.17065925896167755,
0.20020876824855804,
0.010148082859814167,
0.39164602756500244,
-0.6073182225227356,
0.012033913284540176,
-0.47165343165397644,
0.6131952404975891,
-0.8944650292396545,
-0.6323784589767456,
0.10660044103860855,
-0.3508639335632324,
0.10993241518735886,
-0.5194569230079651,
-0.6872214674949646,
-0.316098153591156,
-0.5969317555427551,
0.6349462270736694,
0.5127857327461243,
-0.2894251346588135,
0.2391035407781601,
0.16312240064144135,
-0.5480766296386719,
-0.43962302803993225,
-0.17423386871814728,
0.020144376903772354,
-0.4524277448654175,
-0.5259841084480286,
0.09563671797513962,
-0.31384456157684326,
0.06238937005400658,
0.00011423478281358257,
0.2562214434146881,
0.1346941888332367,
-0.2174704670906067,
-0.13934989273548126,
-0.010914046317338943,
-0.12010028213262558,
0.4042919874191284,
0.23597334325313568,
-0.03913263604044914,
-0.07336900383234024,
-0.5142395496368408,
0.8262248039245605,
0.293758362531662,
-0.24964375793933868,
-0.2174924612045288,
0.5718449950218201,
0.616333544254303,
-0.5976904630661011,
0.8940236568450928,
0.6300228238105774,
-0.22920984029769897,
-0.4600980281829834,
-0.5933942198753357,
-0.4116232395172119,
-0.43111464381217957,
0.11216843128204346,
0.09831150621175766,
-0.7480769157409668,
0.5506142973899841,
-0.1764112263917923,
-0.19220685958862305,
0.5414823293685913,
0.350660115480423,
0.02243674360215664,
1.1449567079544067,
0.6370986104011536,
-0.07450265437364578,
0.3125118911266327,
-0.04623608663678169,
0.20943410694599152,
-0.5426471829414368,
-0.0911559984087944,
-0.3843974173069,
-0.377304345369339,
-0.7801204323768616,
-0.38272640109062195,
0.5620976090431213,
0.1750384122133255,
0.054798707365989685,
0.2802587151527405,
-0.3264675438404083,
0.7906046509742737,
0.7233934998512268,
0.05594601109623909,
0.21279287338256836,
-0.10716915130615234,
0.027440935373306274,
0.16750405728816986,
-0.5475530028343201,
-0.6364012956619263,
0.9602040648460388,
0.04124267399311066,
0.9023399353027344,
0.2832692563533783,
0.8336383700370789,
0.30979323387145996,
-0.11218705773353577,
-0.668189525604248,
0.5415546894073486,
-0.3543969690799713,
-0.7628352642059326,
-0.4491300880908966,
-0.32956114411354065,
-1.0090831518173218,
0.0966368019580841,
-0.15524081885814667,
-0.9219939708709717,
0.022092344239354134,
0.11572351306676865,
-0.5829043984413147,
0.2489895224571228,
-0.3907450735569,
0.8604412078857422,
-0.015714650973677635,
-0.44382035732269287,
-0.2886708676815033,
-0.6386622190475464,
0.5486460328102112,
-0.34291520714759827,
0.15093214809894562,
0.036239948123693466,
0.15168257057666779,
0.938116729259491,
-0.31843164563179016,
0.9943570494651794,
-0.10199519991874695,
-0.03666353598237038,
0.5905687212944031,
0.4254026412963867,
0.6446108222007751,
0.25221771001815796,
0.017648713663220406,
-0.19191497564315796,
-0.14232176542282104,
-0.40942999720573425,
-0.19310669600963593,
0.7176496386528015,
-0.24616311490535736,
-0.3190656900405884,
-0.16757391393184662,
-0.5236148238182068,
-0.011499670334160328,
0.5777321457862854,
0.5071768164634705,
0.6978359818458557,
-0.2804624140262604,
-0.008113820105791092,
0.7394599914550781,
-0.3302416503429413,
0.9129227995872498,
0.5813132524490356,
-0.1692839115858078,
-0.3192075192928314,
1.1044224500656128,
-0.31182679533958435,
0.02194385789334774,
0.4491210877895355,
0.1475774198770523,
-0.4707281291484833,
-0.6621464490890503,
-0.4358431398868561,
0.459763765335083,
-0.540918231010437,
-0.3394525945186615,
-0.6466004252433777,
-0.10543490201234818,
-0.39231428503990173,
-0.1745920032262802,
0.09340771287679672,
-0.07412999123334885,
-0.3078741431236267,
0.041244976222515106,
0.45755505561828613,
1.0618568658828735,
0.11568687111139297,
0.41896581649780273,
-1.2814764976501465,
0.10498347133398056,
0.3240315616130829,
0.07383605092763901,
0.18644647300243378,
-0.18009264767169952,
-0.42502322793006897,
-0.04878172278404236,
-0.4909304082393646,
-0.8718870282173157,
0.2920369803905487,
-0.13382945954799652,
0.2872696816921234,
0.6274865865707397,
0.3181554079055786,
0.16178275644779205,
-0.721264123916626,
1.0752851963043213,
0.20963741838932037,
-0.6118059754371643,
0.6651200652122498,
-0.9278256893157959,
0.20846474170684814,
0.4645845890045166,
0.5307062268257141,
-0.4338732659816742,
-0.6503716707229614,
-0.6540672183036804,
-0.8829130530357361,
0.6096926331520081,
0.33747735619544983,
0.29936012625694275,
-0.34062251448631287,
-0.12308577448129654,
0.4053161144256592,
0.6703804135322571,
-0.7450577616691589,
0.17358873784542084,
0.15380461513996124,
-0.043131157755851746,
-0.1772850900888443,
-0.34909936785697937,
-0.024009136483073235,
0.4229094982147217,
0.7450132966041565,
-0.18349218368530273,
-0.08163578063249588,
-0.1697578877210617,
-0.38372400403022766,
-0.16877590119838715,
0.4484880268573761,
0.6486547589302063,
0.5512742400169373,
-0.21699820458889008,
-0.05234541371464729,
-0.19446633756160736,
-0.12057625502347946,
-0.08178254216909409,
0.36410531401634216,
-0.3109839856624603,
0.08608370274305344,
0.27875447273254395,
0.6567552089691162,
0.2611818015575409,
-0.6908330917358398,
0.6838021278381348,
0.13942140340805054,
0.15753032267093658,
-0.347049742937088,
-0.14043991267681122,
0.06975925713777542,
0.05919700860977173,
0.316965252161026,
0.11908313632011414,
0.256553053855896,
-0.5158244967460632,
0.33997300267219543,
0.18838739395141602,
-0.07446539402008057,
-0.3857369124889374,
0.8871451020240784,
0.642045795917511,
-0.0012885145843029022,
0.44301465153694153,
-0.513828694820404,
-0.5852630734443665,
0.5153469443321228,
0.3402296006679535,
0.7935509085655212,
-0.28288453817367554,
0.3908891975879669,
0.23070470988750458,
0.27534234523773193,
-0.018823174759745598,
0.10633630305528641,
0.005751974880695343,
-0.6198229193687439,
-0.7168424725532532,
-1.0407321453094482,
-0.24900923669338226,
0.2955624759197235,
-0.37126514315605164,
0.3765198290348053,
-0.018945081159472466,
-0.018615664914250374,
0.10637784004211426,
-0.30695000290870667,
-0.5040475726127625,
0.2785574495792389,
0.4678800106048584,
0.8218817710876465,
-1.073921799659729,
0.34424009919166565,
0.9124781489372253,
-0.7572762370109558,
-0.5713326930999756,
0.7167589068412781,
-0.271672785282135,
-0.31932371854782104,
0.2859313189983368,
0.21414293348789215,
0.07233686745166779,
0.07697612792253494,
-0.5796189904212952,
-0.8247559666633606,
0.5593392848968506,
-0.05307498574256897,
-0.34805524349212646,
-0.32977190613746643,
0.20501838624477386,
0.5644977688789368,
-0.12454435974359512,
0.11850828677415848,
0.307618647813797,
0.6194167733192444,
-0.013289373368024826,
-0.9065472483634949,
0.20483560860157013,
-0.042567964643239975,
-0.06490804255008698,
0.4787229299545288,
-0.8349286913871765,
0.7834739089012146,
-0.052729081362485886,
0.0912785455584526,
0.43205657601356506,
0.32643648982048035,
0.17195700109004974,
0.3041253089904785,
0.5493388772010803,
0.5649279356002808,
0.36385655403137207,
-0.041334375739097595,
1.0100290775299072,
-0.3013168275356293,
0.47053053975105286,
1.0324307680130005,
-0.24024271965026855,
0.7855460047721863,
0.3150567412376404,
0.13081495463848114,
0.4951118528842926,
0.6325202584266663,
-0.11704113334417343,
0.5908252596855164,
0.20649279654026031,
-0.14345772564411163,
-0.5813613533973694,
-0.19908154010772705,
-0.039327699691057205,
0.5086954236030579,
0.3149404227733612,
-0.4154694378376007,
-0.4431827962398529,
0.18722029030323029,
0.3849658966064453,
0.10271111130714417,
-0.337481826543808,
1.0001531839370728,
0.008650089614093304,
-0.9959618449211121,
0.26888540387153625,
0.027436474338173866,
0.7025957107543945,
-0.42668890953063965,
0.07020477205514908,
-0.05459415912628174,
0.008997921831905842,
-0.15305127203464508,
-0.6867475509643555,
-0.14356546103954315,
0.047610778361558914,
-0.3715527355670929,
0.05317940190434456,
0.7372003197669983,
-0.7114114165306091,
-0.632225513458252,
0.032385315746068954,
0.45981767773628235,
0.42941394448280334,
-0.3095133304595947,
-0.20582033693790436,
-0.13801676034927368,
-0.16328851878643036,
-0.15865354239940643,
0.1511341631412506,
0.28068122267723083,
-0.09952103346586227,
0.23840756714344025,
0.5910442471504211,
-0.13555292785167694,
0.18899302184581757,
0.0662350282073021,
0.7895475029945374,
-0.6873447895050049,
-0.948370635509491,
-0.6046374440193176,
0.7958607077598572,
-0.1989736109972,
-0.09462537616491318,
0.7324232459068298,
0.5497444272041321,
0.4762727916240692,
-0.41315555572509766,
1.0404865741729736,
-0.03675524890422821,
0.6274400353431702,
-0.621716320514679,
0.8280616402626038,
-0.7749573588371277,
-0.007258898112922907,
-0.36674976348876953,
-1.095191478729248,
-0.05983980372548103,
-0.32637470960617065,
-0.34352627396583557,
0.22932372987270355,
0.6744763255119324,
0.4163743257522583,
-0.30300939083099365,
0.06518886238336563,
0.2904782295227051,
0.26331090927124023,
0.18251603841781616,
0.3578861653804779,
1.0020357370376587,
-0.30885955691337585,
0.7045822143554688,
-0.08028140664100647,
0.0820767730474472,
-0.7324509024620056,
-0.9147253036499023,
-0.9660990834236145,
-0.5509727001190186,
-0.2754000425338745,
-0.014406959526240826,
-0.003603128017857671,
0.4751802384853363,
0.5501270890235901,
-0.7811741232872009,
0.10274425148963928,
0.26034268736839294,
0.017768200486898422,
0.04054660722613335,
-0.2897259294986725,
0.3301675617694855,
-0.40663811564445496,
-1.0414806604385376,
0.6125168204307556,
-0.04860226437449455,
-0.06984201818704605,
-0.23879331350326538,
0.23445318639278412,
-0.15602470934391022,
0.393764466047287,
0.5808049440383911,
0.09825166314840317,
-0.558704674243927,
-0.44471392035484314,
-0.084031842648983,
0.35998204350471497,
-0.35828909277915955,
0.6782857775688171,
-0.772259533405304,
0.13288255035877228,
0.6258315443992615,
0.09613490104675293,
0.2935998737812042,
0.40372785925865173,
0.5314250588417053,
-1.082471251487732,
0.012886054813861847,
0.38992777466773987,
0.39995941519737244,
0.2752407193183899,
-0.3528597056865692,
-0.002595889149233699,
-0.0853261649608612,
-0.6166663765907288,
-0.6906161904335022,
0.3427332639694214,
-0.852456271648407,
-0.46326974034309387,
1.2266631126403809,
0.25703689455986023,
-0.12925300002098083,
0.2693732976913452,
0.01052473857998848,
0.15810491144657135,
-0.7075019478797913,
0.7401881217956543,
0.4856579005718231,
0.03373415768146515,
0.3104861378669739,
-0.2218395620584488,
0.45873430371284485,
0.23553715646266937,
-0.8644895553588867,
-0.1449957937002182,
0.6485975384712219,
0.5510432124137878,
0.7164161205291748,
0.17721538245677948,
-0.003229757770895958,
0.36837396025657654,
-0.15220174193382263,
0.00951562449336052,
0.22427578270435333,
-0.7359337210655212,
-0.24715381860733032,
0.30988171696662903,
-0.0928577184677124,
-0.29948386549949646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16282v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16282v5
|
Confidence Under the Hood: An Investigation into the Confidence-Probability Alignment in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-25T15:42:04 | 2024-06-15T22:18:06 |
Abhishek Kumar, Robert Morabito, Sanzhar Umbet, Jad Kabbara, Ali Emami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) becomes more widespread,
understanding their self-evaluation of confidence in generated responses
becomes increasingly important as it is integral to the reliability of the
output of these models. We introduce the concept of Confidence-Probability
Alignment, that connects an LLM's internal confidence, quantified by token
probabilities, to the confidence conveyed in the model's response when
explicitly asked about its certainty. Using various datasets and prompting
techniques that encourage model introspection, we probe the alignment between
models' internal and expressed confidence. These techniques encompass using
structured evaluation scales to rate confidence, including answer options when
prompting, and eliciting the model's confidence level for outputs it does not
recognize as its own. Notably, among the models analyzed, OpenAI's GPT-4 showed
the strongest confidence-probability alignment, with an average Spearman's
$\hat{\rho}$ of 0.42, across a wide range of tasks. Our work contributes to the
ongoing efforts to facilitate risk assessment in the application of LLMs and to
further our understanding of model trustworthiness.
|
[
-0.047113560140132904,
-0.36023998260498047,
0.7388540506362915,
0.00504692317917943,
0.16168706119060516,
-0.003799149766564369,
-0.16722175478935242,
-0.5675318241119385,
-0.11517318338155746,
0.03900643065571785,
-0.48954182863235474,
-0.41736435890197754,
-0.5720514059066772,
-0.21859674155712128,
-0.5486260652542114,
0.7622188925743103,
-0.021880054846405983,
0.20368941128253937,
-0.28251880407333374,
0.4391983151435852,
-0.3843384087085724,
-0.5069377422332764,
-0.7166717648506165,
-0.314601868391037,
0.6834505796432495,
0.1352250874042511,
0.8061403632164001,
0.5190776586532593,
0.9032591581344604,
0.3250933885574341,
0.3478691875934601,
-0.2759343087673187,
-0.2882295548915863,
0.20290648937225342,
-0.2722107470035553,
-0.4723004996776581,
-0.6910272836685181,
0.11529882997274399,
0.7177177667617798,
0.47498619556427,
-0.15145787596702576,
0.23538297414779663,
0.3110635280609131,
0.24997587502002716,
-0.7915043234825134,
0.04248485341668129,
-0.8118529915809631,
-0.2974368929862976,
-0.33752429485321045,
-0.17019852995872498,
-0.3336697220802307,
-0.305965781211853,
-0.020719021558761597,
-0.37301987409591675,
-0.22051939368247986,
0.05213411897420883,
0.7026639580726624,
0.2109992951154709,
-0.4399069547653198,
-0.11717025190591812,
-0.6661965847015381,
0.8386514782905579,
-0.6866416931152344,
0.14056171476840973,
0.33455905318260193,
0.297033429145813,
-0.38704952597618103,
-0.4934972822666168,
-0.7122102379798889,
0.0765705481171608,
0.07636594027280807,
0.22625556588172913,
-0.20237815380096436,
0.18738313019275665,
-0.28532087802886963,
0.5454117655754089,
-0.6235411167144775,
0.36366140842437744,
-0.15957234799861908,
-0.2522641718387604,
0.7618404626846313,
0.01905876211822033,
0.16940484941005707,
0.11843688786029816,
-0.37170785665512085,
-0.2909475266933441,
-0.6379327774047852,
-0.025093073025345802,
0.8292874693870544,
0.425272136926651,
0.08750702440738678,
0.8852808475494385,
-0.08235544711351395,
0.545145571231842,
0.029234634712338448,
-0.31133538484573364,
0.18839217722415924,
-0.3998388350009918,
-0.4482923150062561,
0.1517908126115799,
0.9731209874153137,
0.543461263179779,
0.7025822401046753,
0.0668179988861084,
-0.3021441698074341,
0.20386457443237305,
0.5923689603805542,
-0.4632856547832489,
-0.036098580807447433,
0.6060194969177246,
-0.2149878293275833,
-0.6084620356559753,
0.5032873749732971,
-0.3709937036037445,
-0.2705901563167572,
-0.04907021299004555,
0.6970266103744507,
-0.24234440922737122,
-0.3316306173801422,
-0.07937125116586685,
0.10732301324605942,
0.4934253990650177,
0.1898314654827118,
-0.6651329398155212,
0.2749039828777313,
0.9505579471588135,
0.6863972544670105,
-0.3512877821922302,
-0.19642487168312073,
-0.5018678307533264,
0.3792795240879059,
-0.5927765965461731,
0.40062132477760315,
-0.3869156837463379,
-0.1163189560174942,
0.11983128637075424,
0.07988439500331879,
-0.16851872205734253,
-0.10015091300010681,
0.5985994935035706,
-0.3984975516796112,
0.08281990140676498,
0.04212286323308945,
-0.7444248795509338,
0.12133816629648209,
0.28250595927238464,
-0.32400140166282654,
1.0557016134262085,
0.042252153158187866,
-0.883537769317627,
0.28967607021331787,
-0.2663247585296631,
-0.18310129642486572,
-0.09114916622638702,
-0.3698230981826782,
-0.1445430964231491,
0.27176812291145325,
0.01162929181009531,
0.5006414651870728,
-0.21528826653957367,
0.28653275966644287,
-0.6122928857803345,
-0.3542613983154297,
0.9805368781089783,
-0.5565260052680969,
0.7003459930419922,
0.09744412451982498,
-0.1606847494840622,
0.3403976559638977,
-0.5441111326217651,
0.29102763533592224,
-0.19906072318553925,
0.3145066499710083,
-0.3653661012649536,
-0.2858022153377533,
-0.3117787539958954,
0.2935888171195984,
0.4375772178173065,
-0.5620725750923157,
0.2061985433101654,
-0.26527538895606995,
0.2028326690196991,
1.0135990381240845,
0.1448357105255127,
0.3758852779865265,
-0.33478108048439026,
0.5524905920028687,
0.006819481961429119,
0.39581841230392456,
0.12437018752098083,
-0.6594560742378235,
-0.3730124831199646,
-0.20859502255916595,
0.46288198232650757,
0.6388068795204163,
-0.13228580355644226,
0.48605549335479736,
-0.3168869912624359,
-0.696912944316864,
-0.6859898567199707,
0.11152704805135727,
0.45993009209632874,
0.40994980931282043,
-0.0035081147216260433,
-0.49610769748687744,
-0.2639029324054718,
-1.0086274147033691,
-0.23711945116519928,
-0.5312020182609558,
-0.38270533084869385,
-0.14203716814517975,
0.4196643531322479,
-0.07463347911834717,
0.975033700466156,
-0.6472859978675842,
-0.1582047939300537,
0.0995713621377945,
0.021401207894086838,
0.19744648039340973,
0.6635670065879822,
0.40207555890083313,
-0.5275329351425171,
-0.31353959441185,
-0.025850100442767143,
-0.6666647791862488,
-0.1191626638174057,
0.2344667613506317,
-0.30497878789901733,
0.239369735121727,
0.47829169034957886,
-0.9440800547599792,
0.5798750519752502,
0.777763843536377,
0.0812426432967186,
0.5509661436080933,
-0.0954013243317604,
0.2611943483352661,
-1.1968811750411987,
-0.0611734464764595,
0.1281483769416809,
-0.07544463127851486,
-0.6176692843437195,
0.14710095524787903,
-0.006276456639170647,
0.35957983136177063,
-0.10157433897256851,
0.5296227931976318,
-0.5208357572555542,
-0.29881832003593445,
-0.16718871891498566,
0.21523576974868774,
-0.25995564460754395,
0.005161207634955645,
-0.04426971450448036,
0.8792243599891663,
0.6589910984039307,
-0.4087557792663574,
0.22863832116127014,
0.1213807612657547,
-0.48677653074264526,
0.7745847702026367,
-0.597458004951477,
0.30486059188842773,
0.2032865434885025,
0.061974216252565384,
-1.4566787481307983,
-0.6360859870910645,
0.2088969349861145,
-0.5799536108970642,
0.5933212637901306,
-0.284074068069458,
-0.4781738519668579,
-0.3016956150531769,
-0.2757163345813751,
0.3606374263763428,
0.48356297612190247,
-0.12275109440088272,
0.4593525230884552,
0.45049503445625305,
-0.3649924099445343,
-1.0052894353866577,
-0.9279733896255493,
-0.06580519676208496,
-0.40221890807151794,
-0.6805063486099243,
0.20232056081295013,
-0.25962716341018677,
-0.7827927470207214,
-0.2728157341480255,
-0.26806288957595825,
-0.09645375609397888,
0.17343899607658386,
0.5007538199424744,
0.40693843364715576,
-0.1930055320262909,
0.15499334037303925,
-0.1729033887386322,
0.011701155453920364,
0.10451051592826843,
-0.48701047897338867,
0.44955140352249146,
-0.05467929318547249,
-0.6273752450942993,
-0.4711887836456299,
-0.017379725351929665,
0.2747523784637451,
0.07278518378734589,
0.9195730686187744,
0.4315064549446106,
-0.5413261651992798,
0.30209776759147644,
-0.502755343914032,
-0.21429774165153503,
-0.45652130246162415,
0.0390709787607193,
-0.5252108573913574,
-0.7259343862533569,
0.5457847714424133,
0.3457091748714447,
-0.22051964700222015,
0.6248854398727417,
0.6234031319618225,
-0.4032900333404541,
0.9188032746315002,
0.7641105651855469,
-0.11754650622606277,
0.2057640105485916,
0.43630528450012207,
0.36654603481292725,
-0.6165690422058105,
-0.10306140780448914,
-0.48101556301116943,
-0.2383982092142105,
-0.6558058261871338,
-0.5393771529197693,
0.2613261342048645,
0.13115864992141724,
-0.39264675974845886,
0.280770480632782,
-0.25491592288017273,
0.19706496596336365,
0.46621668338775635,
-0.1412060707807541,
0.45151641964912415,
-0.23229196667671204,
-0.050841037184000015,
-0.00016112442244775593,
-0.4422107934951782,
-0.6199242472648621,
1.2013614177703857,
0.702433705329895,
1.0243844985961914,
0.3846411406993866,
0.6551779508590698,
-0.010502677410840988,
0.5102248191833496,
-0.781792402267456,
0.35833391547203064,
0.27588745951652527,
-0.7411648035049438,
-0.6239022016525269,
-0.4272841811180115,
-0.6996420621871948,
-0.1380784809589386,
-0.18854458630084991,
-1.1347359418869019,
0.18413841724395752,
0.19129955768585205,
-0.4473101794719696,
0.07825683802366257,
-0.5014009475708008,
0.8406836986541748,
-0.3319411277770996,
-0.16203053295612335,
0.12831911444664001,
-0.8527055978775024,
0.6822211742401123,
-0.4169312119483948,
0.25973355770111084,
-0.05589102953672409,
-0.1440810114145279,
0.30549633502960205,
-0.1883840411901474,
0.9534447193145752,
0.2166200429201126,
-0.7221523523330688,
0.31201669573783875,
0.13831454515457153,
0.43348070979118347,
0.006934074684977531,
-0.1285361647605896,
0.18163271248340607,
0.16937679052352905,
-0.08694034069776535,
-0.6446573138237,
0.7020339369773865,
-0.6607843637466431,
-0.48969322443008423,
-0.5559288263320923,
-0.669843316078186,
-0.3674107789993286,
0.054763928055763245,
0.3591534197330475,
0.22272080183029175,
-0.28903064131736755,
0.18246033787727356,
0.6333954930305481,
-0.09664144366979599,
0.16439807415008545,
0.07807452976703644,
-0.3758312463760376,
-0.29783886671066284,
0.5032737851142883,
0.16358229517936707,
0.6911389231681824,
0.39626064896583557,
0.07302334904670715,
-0.41679954528808594,
-0.4025258421897888,
-0.12670494616031647,
-0.04176514968276024,
-0.7979241609573364,
-0.5764757394790649,
-0.3443745970726013,
-0.5493000149726868,
-0.7381019592285156,
-0.057737018913030624,
-0.31085726618766785,
-0.6123032569885254,
0.031835947185754776,
-0.25135281682014465,
0.24481387436389923,
0.7467111945152283,
0.057508353143930435,
0.597044050693512,
-0.5035857558250427,
-0.23841191828250885,
0.2445768415927887,
0.38551580905914307,
-0.22627851366996765,
-0.6326290369033813,
-0.03138955682516098,
0.008768399246037006,
-0.10912363976240158,
-0.9612404108047485,
0.2345218062400818,
0.060994088649749756,
0.5198455452919006,
0.6323364973068237,
0.1812150776386261,
0.6236587166786194,
-0.2840590476989746,
0.7114781737327576,
0.1963261067867279,
-0.950450599193573,
0.21500305831432343,
-0.48145729303359985,
0.06548146158456802,
0.5448241829872131,
0.5510116219520569,
-0.2067134529352188,
-0.6836570501327515,
-0.6825310587882996,
-0.6233221888542175,
0.13733674585819244,
0.3258723020553589,
0.011052142828702927,
-0.06147266924381256,
0.38214170932769775,
-0.06660212576389313,
0.4347812831401825,
-0.6915909647941589,
0.014931832440197468,
-0.0641263797879219,
-0.7309601306915283,
-0.270372599363327,
-0.29769888520240784,
-0.5336829423904419,
0.0021544082555919886,
0.7507913708686829,
-0.36997708678245544,
0.29491129517555237,
0.11809015274047852,
-0.032279834151268005,
-0.2690246105194092,
0.4011204242706299,
0.6045889854431152,
0.8612996339797974,
-0.3267368972301483,
0.29862579703330994,
-0.03967519477009773,
-0.3350546658039093,
0.12611402571201324,
-0.049126412719488144,
0.09382717311382294,
-0.3897947669029236,
0.4284135401248932,
0.28776347637176514,
0.23773284256458282,
-0.3644719421863556,
0.856863260269165,
0.0518513023853302,
-0.025176087394356728,
-0.6206870079040527,
0.11093737185001373,
0.06870818883180618,
0.2511105537414551,
0.5524997711181641,
-0.27359825372695923,
-0.03854944184422493,
-0.7925419807434082,
0.19545167684555054,
0.7591652274131775,
-0.4886333644390106,
-0.2796224057674408,
0.44699040055274963,
-0.2630726099014282,
-0.14231857657432556,
0.5783156752586365,
0.04964904859662056,
-0.3617096245288849,
0.34883058071136475,
0.5354957580566406,
0.9902536869049072,
-0.4351670444011688,
0.07879304885864258,
0.3331047594547272,
0.6330747008323669,
-0.14275042712688446,
0.18063770234584808,
0.48199209570884705,
-1.0752489566802979,
-0.6641027927398682,
-0.8137450814247131,
-0.4409284293651581,
0.15741191804409027,
-0.7029404640197754,
-0.03241009637713432,
-0.1320883184671402,
-0.5236504673957825,
-0.2490168660879135,
-0.03328350558876991,
-0.4191499948501587,
0.3617056906223297,
0.010219215415418148,
1.0167845487594604,
-0.908079206943512,
0.942706823348999,
0.2802530527114868,
-0.38154077529907227,
-1.008047103881836,
0.49533817172050476,
0.20678851008415222,
-0.8776993751525879,
0.6027922034263611,
0.22996854782104492,
-0.29360127449035645,
-0.15629912912845612,
-0.7783592343330383,
-1.065254807472229,
1.1768594980239868,
0.4661409854888916,
-0.5595815777778625,
0.019582197070121765,
0.010442441329360008,
0.5251019597053528,
-0.6282644271850586,
0.2799902856349945,
0.5158631801605225,
0.6555848121643066,
0.21198956668376923,
-1.0714877843856812,
0.07594393938779831,
0.012642847374081612,
-0.06074343994259834,
0.13587543368339539,
-0.40615415573120117,
0.7634262442588806,
-0.2109834849834442,
-0.11663628369569778,
0.46403616666793823,
0.9658265113830566,
0.31870201230049133,
0.13011716306209564,
0.3965708911418915,
0.4200489819049835,
0.8930295705795288,
-0.26552170515060425,
1.092307448387146,
-0.41207703948020935,
0.04761232063174248,
1.3528780937194824,
-0.3632463216781616,
1.0947299003601074,
0.6699944734573364,
-0.15684044361114502,
0.5921608805656433,
0.6514125466346741,
0.14472831785678864,
0.1364859640598297,
0.30667564272880554,
-0.10722321271896362,
-0.11039493978023529,
0.06805653125047684,
-0.17664290964603424,
0.626297116279602,
0.24824093282222748,
-0.28226789832115173,
0.45035988092422485,
-0.5473883748054504,
-0.17851455509662628,
-0.17694364488124847,
-0.40403079986572266,
0.6245917677879333,
0.3539489209651947,
-0.69943767786026,
-0.043284785002470016,
-0.23035794496536255,
0.4555690884590149,
-0.8035343885421753,
0.31466037034988403,
0.00418702932074666,
0.3125108778476715,
-0.3326953947544098,
-1.3215252161026,
0.26694053411483765,
-0.2026660144329071,
0.03977493569254875,
0.018284933641552925,
0.7687823176383972,
-0.5640964508056641,
-0.46498414874076843,
0.17869900166988373,
0.34416335821151733,
0.34232452511787415,
-0.2683027386665344,
-0.38476628065109253,
0.14188452064990997,
-0.505854606628418,
-0.28806254267692566,
0.523499608039856,
0.48859596252441406,
-0.09999226033687592,
0.6568876504898071,
0.5075498819351196,
0.06060619652271271,
-0.03235286474227905,
0.046474259346723557,
0.3887646198272705,
-0.28187111020088196,
-0.09679358452558517,
-0.8700292706489563,
0.5035249590873718,
-0.22771424055099487,
-0.23753945529460907,
1.0603950023651123,
0.35845208168029785,
0.7993133068084717,
-0.08001028746366501,
0.7339208126068115,
0.19928768277168274,
0.13532207906246185,
-0.5780704021453857,
0.5708863735198975,
-0.421098917722702,
0.02579096332192421,
-0.7572943568229675,
-0.9408988952636719,
-0.22513478994369507,
0.7481604218482971,
-0.35299623012542725,
0.21816259622573853,
0.6455918550491333,
0.8137730956077576,
0.08617530018091202,
-0.3431399464607239,
0.3895874619483948,
0.22380207479000092,
0.012045064009726048,
0.349228173494339,
0.7564257383346558,
-0.2729574143886566,
0.42729583382606506,
-0.04126395285129547,
-0.3343832790851593,
0.1280955672264099,
-1.3271973133087158,
-0.4836842715740204,
-0.6025339961051941,
-0.3649740517139435,
-0.5185292363166809,
-0.15833477675914764,
0.7066183090209961,
0.4326792061328888,
-0.7383209466934204,
-0.4732551872730255,
0.0308661051094532,
-0.14258845150470734,
-0.3426291048526764,
-0.23865003883838654,
0.15163934230804443,
-0.28979191184043884,
-0.6456479430198669,
0.31645989418029785,
0.38964956998825073,
0.38119199872016907,
-0.47866207361221313,
0.005014523398131132,
-0.054372552782297134,
0.369687020778656,
0.131130650639534,
0.04197797179222107,
-0.6432989239692688,
-0.5655292868614197,
-0.04865296930074692,
-0.33682551980018616,
-0.03430849313735962,
0.5401563048362732,
-0.23108074069023132,
0.1288520246744156,
0.2598808705806732,
0.6068016290664673,
0.2201555073261261,
0.22444270551204681,
1.2082304954528809,
-0.9495840072631836,
-0.16536249220371246,
-0.1698097139596939,
0.35846590995788574,
0.5225452184677124,
-0.5541878938674927,
0.7421644926071167,
-0.1552961766719818,
-0.7576727271080017,
-0.9888997077941895,
0.4387374520301819,
-1.057468056678772,
-0.04766125977039337,
1.0755620002746582,
-0.03589208424091339,
-0.15057849884033203,
0.13576145470142365,
0.1076522246003151,
0.2941160798072815,
-0.11384423077106476,
0.503341794013977,
1.074753999710083,
0.0009118769667111337,
-0.12925371527671814,
-0.7269755601882935,
0.6151187419891357,
0.07523954659700394,
-0.6093882322311401,
0.11426366120576859,
0.22015975415706635,
0.42907077074050903,
0.3627336919307709,
0.6394848823547363,
-0.17849476635456085,
-0.13498131930828094,
-0.2017756849527359,
0.11423251032829285,
0.49737611413002014,
-0.4178079068660736,
-0.5056123733520508,
0.2587520480155945,
0.3461202383041382,
0.019096458330750465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00033v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00033v1
|
Retrieval-Augmented Conversational Recommendation with Prompt-based Semi-Structured Natural Language State Tracking
| 2024-05-25T15:41:26 | 2024-05-25T15:41:26 |
Sara Kemper, Justin Cui, Kai Dicarlantonio, Kathy Lin, Danjie Tang, Anton Korikov, Scott Sanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Conversational recommendation (ConvRec) systems must understand rich and
diverse natural language (NL) expressions of user preferences and intents,
often communicated in an indirect manner (e.g., "I'm watching my weight"). Such
complex utterances make retrieving relevant items challenging, especially if
only using often incomplete or out-of-date metadata. Fortunately, many domains
feature rich item reviews that cover standard metadata categories and offer
complex opinions that might match a user's interests (e.g., "classy joint for a
date"). However, only recently have large language models (LLMs) let us unlock
the commonsense connections between user preference utterances and complex
language in user-generated reviews. Further, LLMs enable novel paradigms for
semi-structured dialogue state tracking, complex intent and preference
understanding, and generating recommendations, explanations, and question
answers. We thus introduce a novel technology RA-Rec, a Retrieval-Augmented,
LLM-driven dialogue state tracking system for ConvRec, showcased with a video,
open source GitHub repository, and interactive Google Colab notebook.
|
[
-0.41528943181037903,
-0.9336962699890137,
0.537709653377533,
0.0018401396228000522,
-0.12243051081895828,
0.30448973178863525,
-0.08583332598209381,
-0.4499662518501282,
0.4959217607975006,
0.5629448890686035,
-0.8061040043830872,
-0.5510724782943726,
-0.12124869227409363,
0.19444985687732697,
-0.2539306879043579,
1.1864862442016602,
0.23835887014865875,
0.08317068219184875,
-0.16754120588302612,
-0.2410428375005722,
-0.8760701417922974,
-0.459330677986145,
-0.40000882744789124,
-0.5769878029823303,
0.34013351798057556,
0.6731440424919128,
0.7018855214118958,
-0.10682018846273422,
0.289581298828125,
0.19615793228149414,
-0.13956308364868164,
0.3760022819042206,
-0.5137014389038086,
0.4659365117549896,
-0.19782191514968872,
-0.3096410632133484,
-0.27878835797309875,
-0.16741180419921875,
0.4084065556526184,
0.7638264298439026,
-0.4084160029888153,
0.057426467537879944,
0.07830491662025452,
0.8115575909614563,
-0.5694535374641418,
0.19135358929634094,
-0.28339990973472595,
-0.13094691932201385,
0.1375257521867752,
-0.44451287388801575,
-0.4900948703289032,
-0.4701246917247772,
0.7487348914146423,
-0.5455405712127686,
0.1508556753396988,
0.5512099862098694,
0.5050407648086548,
-0.09237264841794968,
-0.4051196873188019,
-0.5936270356178284,
-0.9902318716049194,
0.8535822629928589,
-0.2408369779586792,
0.42857038974761963,
0.5696724057197571,
0.5512101650238037,
-0.2925879657268524,
-0.5756096243858337,
-0.4323512315750122,
-0.6437075734138489,
-0.05742236226797104,
-0.01129017025232315,
-0.2990259528160095,
0.1727721393108368,
0.20818288624286652,
0.5566941499710083,
-0.4732324779033661,
-0.23441293835639954,
-0.15521876513957977,
-0.36245667934417725,
0.46671760082244873,
0.30188900232315063,
0.32809701561927795,
-0.26593017578125,
-0.5911694765090942,
0.1641274392604828,
-0.7680164575576782,
0.12441397458314896,
0.19775427877902985,
0.22280384600162506,
-0.22011585533618927,
0.829113245010376,
-0.4972469210624695,
0.9108447432518005,
0.17630082368850708,
0.19576133787631989,
0.16629460453987122,
-0.5804154276847839,
-0.251027911901474,
0.3999665379524231,
0.6640715599060059,
0.4907066524028778,
0.17835605144500732,
-0.06549511104822159,
-0.2297997772693634,
-0.09780608117580414,
0.05508080869913101,
-0.5958017110824585,
-0.35564711689949036,
0.049610983580350876,
-0.3889152407646179,
-0.14839483797550201,
-0.041174065321683884,
-0.5867781639099121,
-0.5738064646720886,
-0.36698025465011597,
0.34687450528144836,
-0.3058169186115265,
-0.05939066410064697,
0.4261550009250641,
0.08695490658283234,
0.031158046796917915,
0.5515414476394653,
-1.0017709732055664,
0.4448809325695038,
0.5338517427444458,
0.858443021774292,
-0.10516168922185898,
0.2970040440559387,
-0.8738088011741638,
-0.028574351221323013,
-0.09546440094709396,
1.0153743028640747,
-1.0229493379592896,
-0.5558032989501953,
0.34840357303619385,
0.1580255627632141,
0.36036884784698486,
-0.5644858479499817,
0.5036813616752625,
-0.6399322152137756,
0.3087170422077179,
-0.4393986463546753,
-0.563518226146698,
-0.33914420008659363,
0.5917870998382568,
-0.5981199741363525,
1.1498730182647705,
-0.05783535912632942,
-0.6382109522819519,
0.21102605760097504,
-0.4326925575733185,
-0.4349091351032257,
0.27897927165031433,
-0.07736457139253616,
-0.041052188724279404,
-0.1462353616952896,
0.16694074869155884,
0.45957115292549133,
-0.439907431602478,
0.45389074087142944,
-0.44974178075790405,
-0.44476965069770813,
0.2732963263988495,
-0.44577276706695557,
0.34104305505752563,
0.45359209179878235,
0.1310187727212906,
0.30209633708000183,
-0.6869542598724365,
-0.3458876311779022,
-0.18988186120986938,
-0.4183078110218048,
-0.44257256388664246,
0.014753518626093864,
0.05280565842986107,
-0.15066424012184143,
0.4892216920852661,
-0.6832180023193359,
0.25698521733283997,
-0.418697327375412,
0.38164564967155457,
0.454682856798172,
0.290862500667572,
0.6320812106132507,
-0.39986932277679443,
0.5807082056999207,
-0.3150821030139923,
0.015930568799376488,
-0.3506655991077423,
-0.3356500566005707,
-0.4895871877670288,
-0.09310358762741089,
-0.05866937339305878,
0.5128715634346008,
-0.7782930135726929,
0.3368922173976898,
-0.002888299059122801,
-0.3028748333454132,
-0.44493845105171204,
0.011325646191835403,
0.3026302456855774,
0.5443956255912781,
0.34061408042907715,
-0.08958427608013153,
-0.513498842716217,
-0.7971910834312439,
-0.19198636710643768,
-0.2208377569913864,
-0.1376103162765503,
0.7181032299995422,
0.18986213207244873,
-0.049909841269254684,
1.0022528171539307,
-0.6499467492103577,
-0.42886650562286377,
-0.6300281286239624,
0.1584809124469757,
0.20363140106201172,
0.25323161482810974,
0.14516794681549072,
-0.7318171858787537,
-0.3324917256832123,
-0.04666198417544365,
-0.44933614134788513,
-0.1290009468793869,
-0.0843186303973198,
0.009161826223134995,
0.041582971811294556,
0.3391367197036743,
-0.4890769422054291,
0.23310907185077667,
0.5086510181427002,
-0.29194602370262146,
0.5362616181373596,
-0.39342936873435974,
0.23642580211162567,
-1.1414235830307007,
0.10027728229761124,
0.3350988030433655,
-0.47819700837135315,
-0.4494360387325287,
-0.5245552659034729,
-0.4133082330226898,
-0.1470455825328827,
-0.3258260488510132,
0.7870280146598816,
-0.3321409821510315,
-0.02553727850317955,
-0.18444454669952393,
0.33265313506126404,
0.0575857013463974,
0.5401944518089294,
0.1009615957736969,
0.6883180737495422,
0.3777293562889099,
-0.6905862092971802,
0.5733694434165955,
0.3510689437389374,
-0.6636139750480652,
0.7282178997993469,
-0.6074970364570618,
0.13157644867897034,
0.0698438435792923,
0.5511434674263,
-1.1143889427185059,
-0.16397178173065186,
0.23352929949760437,
-0.2607972323894501,
0.18422599136829376,
-0.38595104217529297,
-0.28538277745246887,
0.07481834292411804,
-0.3797512352466583,
0.39380601048469543,
0.1589815467596054,
-0.5150564312934875,
0.754285991191864,
0.5868414044380188,
-0.20864537358283997,
-0.6724202036857605,
-0.3722049295902252,
0.22537626326084137,
0.18304796516895294,
-0.34371012449264526,
0.16441354155540466,
-0.2549416422843933,
-0.21554724872112274,
-0.1758507788181305,
-0.20129531621932983,
0.23972783982753754,
0.06172240525484085,
0.19774462282657623,
0.5441790223121643,
0.24039719998836517,
0.30060872435569763,
-0.03944755345582962,
-0.09772244095802307,
-0.07765679806470871,
-0.3617251217365265,
0.6516304016113281,
-0.41459396481513977,
-0.17148122191429138,
-0.5701457858085632,
0.35697534680366516,
0.4841761291027069,
-0.15808136761188507,
0.3012749254703522,
0.4406295418739319,
-0.306160032749176,
-0.11704500764608383,
-0.7586647272109985,
-0.3314782977104187,
-0.45853251218795776,
0.32719653844833374,
-0.23173169791698456,
-1.2260212898254395,
0.3248785138130188,
-0.16780023276805878,
0.012158781290054321,
0.08583344519138336,
0.7209906578063965,
-0.40193647146224976,
1.2133057117462158,
0.524329423904419,
-0.15364035964012146,
0.8008769750595093,
-0.2228885442018509,
0.22822727262973785,
-0.8194873332977295,
-0.6352605223655701,
-0.6072075963020325,
-0.34665513038635254,
-0.6913498044013977,
-0.04227437078952789,
0.3364644944667816,
-0.1733788549900055,
-0.21053510904312134,
0.029303450137376785,
-0.43071815371513367,
0.19007623195648193,
0.6822113990783691,
0.15389667451381683,
0.5330564379692078,
-0.09651678055524826,
-0.06610081344842911,
0.027874289080500603,
-0.45934274792671204,
-0.4539083242416382,
0.7093579173088074,
0.12821349501609802,
1.3705480098724365,
0.003150444244965911,
0.30962657928466797,
0.9564248323440552,
0.11696998029947281,
-1.0645755529403687,
0.7629989385604858,
-0.0798778310418129,
-0.5513225197792053,
-0.050781819969415665,
-0.2758634686470032,
-0.8641336560249329,
-0.19907154142856598,
-0.5960066914558411,
-0.7691320776939392,
0.16440488398075104,
0.43177157640457153,
-0.373158723115921,
0.1792268455028534,
-0.6075249314308167,
0.7268583178520203,
-0.026695355772972107,
-0.2859838604927063,
-0.566137433052063,
-0.6093202829360962,
0.07636208832263947,
0.3961222767829895,
-0.13090716302394867,
-0.20541533827781677,
0.2524682283401489,
0.582798182964325,
-0.3987853527069092,
0.7677973508834839,
-0.3314732611179352,
0.07352638989686966,
0.4966384172439575,
0.6588242650032043,
0.685121476650238,
0.2281186282634735,
0.17109350860118866,
-0.13263241946697235,
0.11473765224218369,
-0.053962741047143936,
-0.6510987877845764,
0.8560110926628113,
-0.3522854447364807,
-0.5721705555915833,
-0.4980018436908722,
-0.5375676155090332,
-0.236994668841362,
0.1120123416185379,
-0.1854049116373062,
0.7436217665672302,
-0.34335091710090637,
0.37029650807380676,
0.8533340692520142,
-0.29020780324935913,
0.054231248795986176,
0.7511539459228516,
-0.3383467197418213,
-0.3383706510066986,
0.9038580656051636,
-0.2102007418870926,
0.06052890419960022,
0.8579967617988586,
0.2207595854997635,
-0.5248080492019653,
-0.4114486873149872,
-0.40713489055633545,
0.12488481402397156,
-0.419506698846817,
-0.23094776272773743,
-0.7288519144058228,
0.30215945839881897,
-0.07241179794073105,
-0.14073902368545532,
-0.10163253545761108,
-0.3972308337688446,
-0.2555329501628876,
-0.30497172474861145,
0.5011388063430786,
0.8411335945129395,
0.2907770276069641,
0.05696284398436546,
-0.7350500226020813,
0.3376788794994354,
0.3012479543685913,
0.48938390612602234,
-0.19377152621746063,
-0.41459667682647705,
-0.3494989275932312,
0.1337423026561737,
-0.09165123850107193,
-0.6483138203620911,
0.32957419753074646,
0.008504033088684082,
0.22714950144290924,
0.21061372756958008,
0.2479531615972519,
0.3249306380748749,
-0.3415021002292633,
0.9126213788986206,
0.2321014255285263,
-0.6394878029823303,
0.5938034057617188,
-0.31428587436676025,
0.46611759066581726,
0.5248268246650696,
0.1350986510515213,
-0.8075833916664124,
-0.22804836928844452,
-0.09864684194326401,
-0.561150312423706,
0.7332407832145691,
-0.147832453250885,
0.2270243912935257,
-0.1612349897623062,
0.15881367027759552,
0.11533311009407043,
0.1960112452507019,
-0.3338998556137085,
-0.09907551109790802,
-0.015861187130212784,
-0.2780151665210724,
0.07457563281059265,
-0.5943154096603394,
-0.1112515851855278,
0.13134583830833435,
0.6927449107170105,
-0.24287517368793488,
0.09030519425868988,
0.43908917903900146,
-0.20618169009685516,
-0.03933039680123329,
0.4837976396083832,
0.5030490159988403,
0.279000461101532,
-0.7404747009277344,
-0.07810362428426743,
0.1175982654094696,
-0.45022863149642944,
-0.03551632538437843,
0.0642281249165535,
-0.2475273311138153,
-0.018351173028349876,
-0.14286372065544128,
0.7821495532989502,
0.45158708095550537,
-0.8520898222923279,
0.4212128221988678,
-0.2519201636314392,
0.11714651435613632,
-0.4469310939311981,
-0.0659191906452179,
-0.11833064258098602,
0.20768903195858002,
0.4658239781856537,
0.373025119304657,
0.48196113109588623,
-0.6927478313446045,
0.07254914939403534,
0.6319682002067566,
-0.7775089144706726,
-0.41218477487564087,
0.46419885754585266,
0.6247066855430603,
-0.43254250288009644,
0.5504946112632751,
-0.006152092479169369,
-0.19237400591373444,
0.017583245411515236,
0.364793598651886,
1.0577539205551147,
0.07583285868167877,
0.2879624664783478,
0.3663885295391083,
-0.043125227093696594,
-0.23700574040412903,
0.25176432728767395,
-0.49734240770339966,
-0.6584659218788147,
-0.3819698393344879,
-0.5339406132698059,
-0.6896549463272095,
-0.20922838151454926,
-0.8348222374916077,
0.3149265944957733,
-0.3822353780269623,
-0.32176271080970764,
-0.15129917860031128,
0.23940393328666687,
-0.6229004859924316,
0.06538718193769455,
0.22214795649051666,
0.9809882640838623,
-0.6834708452224731,
0.680072546005249,
0.7149798274040222,
-0.3434714078903198,
-0.6146550178527832,
-0.2594413757324219,
0.032270658761262894,
-0.6305117607116699,
0.40353286266326904,
0.06807873398065567,
-0.7500065565109253,
-0.14565888047218323,
-0.6169167757034302,
-0.515059769153595,
0.9419333934783936,
0.40198636054992676,
-0.6773108839988708,
0.06582437455654144,
-0.3303416669368744,
0.6566141843795776,
-0.31522315740585327,
0.34253183007240295,
0.44091373682022095,
0.2477051019668579,
0.3728238046169281,
-0.837815523147583,
-0.04511958733201027,
-0.1453426331281662,
-0.21818551421165466,
0.3430155813694,
-0.5351550579071045,
0.1269349604845047,
-0.4063555896282196,
-0.30366504192352295,
0.08164189755916595,
0.6610106825828552,
0.24281780421733856,
0.5255751013755798,
0.5523568391799927,
0.2768586277961731,
0.6374378204345703,
0.015756556764245033,
1.187293529510498,
-0.23776766657829285,
0.39335501194000244,
1.316969633102417,
-0.5097517967224121,
0.8086817264556885,
0.3488537073135376,
0.10472583770751953,
0.7501240968704224,
0.666521430015564,
-0.009476331062614918,
0.5066794753074646,
-0.03315070644021034,
-0.4396878778934479,
-0.42043444514274597,
-0.817841112613678,
-0.0008769775158725679,
0.21129557490348816,
0.3528977930545807,
-0.03209403529763222,
-0.09274416416883469,
0.09823357313871384,
-0.13121579587459564,
0.15445749461650848,
-0.2863941192626953,
1.0638092756271362,
0.140703484416008,
-0.9785497784614563,
0.4603888988494873,
-0.26999640464782715,
0.67682284116745,
-0.8103872537612915,
-0.5035305619239807,
-0.3566224277019501,
-0.07496872544288635,
-0.3043080270290375,
-1.0778589248657227,
-0.16932794451713562,
0.2019755095243454,
-0.4060051441192627,
-0.23845720291137695,
0.702256441116333,
-0.5765963792800903,
-0.1993260383605957,
0.35249435901641846,
0.35140106081962585,
0.08536157011985779,
0.19888706505298615,
-0.57583087682724,
-0.08180176466703415,
0.10957647860050201,
-0.2064877450466156,
0.19307036697864532,
0.12815488874912262,
-0.14604243636131287,
1.212754249572754,
0.7072821855545044,
0.041176583617925644,
-0.3058103621006012,
0.40852025151252747,
0.6725606322288513,
-0.559812605381012,
-0.4814077615737915,
-0.5698421597480774,
0.14040547609329224,
0.2239786982536316,
-0.019393187016248703,
0.5126466155052185,
0.6766548752784729,
0.9151118397712708,
0.10931962728500366,
0.5618098378181458,
-0.11635169386863708,
0.6033382415771484,
-0.48230454325675964,
0.27701908349990845,
-0.4407697021961212,
0.6874068975448608,
-0.11254117637872696,
-0.9103119373321533,
-0.1696617305278778,
0.20458029210567474,
-0.2847194969654083,
0.01116685476154089,
0.5281346440315247,
0.8866538405418396,
0.18832892179489136,
0.20713654160499573,
0.1446591466665268,
0.1119234710931778,
0.45342010259628296,
0.3899001479148865,
0.9311892986297607,
-0.05716569349169731,
0.7356051206588745,
0.12780943512916565,
-0.04167059808969498,
-0.44845134019851685,
-0.6809661388397217,
-0.652737021446228,
-0.6091132164001465,
-0.20522469282150269,
-0.5258886218070984,
0.0030467931646853685,
1.4346562623977661,
0.5191872715950012,
-0.8974128365516663,
-0.3739463686943054,
0.07248824834823608,
0.1502888947725296,
-0.08459595590829849,
-0.24607795476913452,
0.28456607460975647,
-0.1308990865945816,
-0.8310128450393677,
0.6076120734214783,
0.51316237449646,
-0.05613362044095993,
-0.3423594832420349,
-0.19173471629619598,
-0.5143576264381409,
-0.0807105004787445,
0.5009669065475464,
0.349025696516037,
-0.7188770174980164,
-0.4256207048892975,
0.09117981046438217,
-0.1708054393529892,
0.029193462803959846,
0.9739848375320435,
-1.0219249725341797,
1.1105602979660034,
0.6426175236701965,
0.44788360595703125,
0.5982917547225952,
0.1786198914051056,
0.7927864789962769,
-0.638444185256958,
-0.10839591175317764,
0.3742019534111023,
0.38722020387649536,
0.468982994556427,
-0.22504262626171112,
0.2697691023349762,
0.17704898118972778,
-0.5788301229476929,
-0.8274112343788147,
0.24551965296268463,
-1.3624238967895508,
0.07356163114309311,
0.9549452662467957,
-0.03179696947336197,
0.08525100350379944,
-0.27311527729034424,
-0.6463066339492798,
0.09553615003824234,
-0.9577336311340332,
0.7551760673522949,
0.6004342436790466,
-0.1121070608496666,
0.0612698532640934,
-0.5276950001716614,
0.5407865643501282,
0.3898421823978424,
-0.4458034336566925,
0.28016898036003113,
0.741581380367279,
0.30278080701828003,
-0.09641086310148239,
0.5990298390388489,
0.1328231543302536,
0.24170903861522675,
-0.5482831597328186,
-0.017685504630208015,
-0.06396414339542389,
-0.30278655886650085,
-0.37911319732666016,
-0.004323617089539766,
0.03159624710679054,
-0.22232338786125183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16281v1
|
ConStat: Performance-Based Contamination Detection in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-25T15:36:37 | 2024-05-25T15:36:37 |
Jasper Dekoninck, Mark Niklas Müller, Martin Vechev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Public benchmarks play an essential role in the evaluation of large language
models. However, data contamination can lead to inflated performance, rendering
them unreliable for model comparison. It is therefore crucial to detect
contamination and estimate its impact on measured performance. Unfortunately,
existing detection methods can be easily evaded and fail to quantify
contamination. To overcome these limitations, we propose a novel definition of
contamination as artificially inflated and non-generalizing benchmark
performance instead of the inclusion of benchmark samples in the training data.
This perspective enables us to detect any model with inflated performance,
i.e., performance that does not generalize to rephrased samples, synthetic
samples from the same distribution, or different benchmarks for the same task.
Based on this insight, we develop ConStat, a statistical method that reliably
detects and quantifies contamination by comparing performance between a primary
and reference benchmark relative to a set of reference models. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of ConStat in an extensive evaluation of diverse model
architectures, benchmarks, and contamination scenarios and find high levels of
contamination in multiple popular models including Mistral, Llama, Yi, and the
top-3 Open LLM Leaderboard models.
|
[
-0.2887222170829773,
-1.0582987070083618,
0.5349955558776855,
-0.0014816127950325608,
-0.22763323783874512,
0.1293162852525711,
-0.060486216098070145,
-0.6805329322814941,
-0.02203449420630932,
0.720585286617279,
-0.23185262084007263,
-0.6196628212928772,
-0.818330705165863,
-0.20363983511924744,
-0.745534360408783,
0.8743172287940979,
-0.1001478061079979,
-0.22412672638893127,
-0.49033257365226746,
-0.0008355443133041263,
-0.36104676127433777,
-0.6951968669891357,
-0.5413228273391724,
-0.35450467467308044,
0.23579753935337067,
0.2893882095813751,
0.5711536407470703,
0.5494206547737122,
0.6048495769500732,
0.38763830065727234,
-0.2432333379983902,
0.4267426133155823,
-0.5396872162818909,
0.3739650547504425,
-0.4233825206756592,
-0.4872051179409027,
-0.1663484275341034,
-0.19581037759780884,
0.6320070624351501,
0.43999868631362915,
-0.19420957565307617,
0.24535562098026276,
0.3836066722869873,
0.46749594807624817,
-1.1079455614089966,
0.3347618281841278,
-0.7019602656364441,
-0.28341567516326904,
-0.5879853367805481,
-0.1427374929189682,
-0.40441805124282837,
-0.4376981258392334,
-0.12168414890766144,
-0.7737918496131897,
0.2636858820915222,
-0.12076742947101593,
0.6559345126152039,
0.6049502491950989,
-0.3269537687301636,
-0.019184811040759087,
-0.9323561191558838,
0.7414886355400085,
-0.6932156085968018,
0.2893003523349762,
0.46060487627983093,
0.411749005317688,
-0.3549504280090332,
-0.7783558964729309,
-0.6907224059104919,
-0.24851544201374054,
-0.04620077461004257,
-0.12931998074054718,
-0.21315790712833405,
-0.03233424201607704,
0.07561593502759933,
0.25873398780822754,
-0.6603703498840332,
0.073480524122715,
-0.07296017557382584,
-0.338407427072525,
0.43585243821144104,
0.08325736969709396,
0.3899936378002167,
0.1522069126367569,
-0.6239790320396423,
-0.26857298612594604,
-0.8400770425796509,
0.017687901854515076,
0.28777334094047546,
0.34202510118484497,
-0.1111333891749382,
0.3331526815891266,
-0.29736047983169556,
0.4020322263240814,
-0.29941895604133606,
-0.04947788640856743,
0.18568938970565796,
-0.32935619354248047,
-0.38972577452659607,
0.04461480677127838,
0.7344611287117004,
-0.10531775653362274,
0.33582496643066406,
0.02343865856528282,
-0.3341453969478607,
0.2608725130558014,
0.17786428332328796,
-0.9569156169891357,
-0.5413057208061218,
0.15195009112358093,
-0.01138807088136673,
-0.4582501947879791,
-0.010196820832788944,
-0.6117154359817505,
-0.6884551644325256,
-0.3170287013053894,
0.7866579294204712,
-0.32073473930358887,
-0.5748065710067749,
0.3556835353374481,
-0.016403600573539734,
-0.6766095161437988,
0.15836593508720398,
-0.8291381001472473,
0.46213510632514954,
1.3316537141799927,
0.6079897284507751,
-0.16563425958156586,
-0.07355508953332901,
-0.6335784792900085,
0.06467567384243011,
-0.44459301233291626,
1.0654253959655762,
-0.6326934695243835,
-0.2478511482477188,
0.18645067512989044,
-0.3253912627696991,
-0.004815282300114632,
-1.1541651487350464,
0.6761642098426819,
-0.3418690264225006,
-0.15933778882026672,
-0.10256894677877426,
-0.7652433514595032,
-0.25918659567832947,
0.2702352702617645,
-0.771912157535553,
1.2082359790802002,
0.08549386262893677,
-0.9358328580856323,
0.5490633249282837,
-0.33939334750175476,
-0.17626270651817322,
0.4238710403442383,
-0.21725034713745117,
-0.4340464174747467,
0.1055920198559761,
-0.07166379690170288,
0.2335965782403946,
-0.12731710076332092,
0.42265310883522034,
-0.4990230202674866,
-0.6986941695213318,
0.24755044281482697,
-0.6391105651855469,
0.46495500206947327,
0.07295942306518555,
-0.12679962813854218,
-0.011500075459480286,
-0.8834211230278015,
0.17269405722618103,
-0.34731173515319824,
-0.2668018341064453,
-0.7075253129005432,
0.08715251088142395,
0.18889454007148743,
0.041843295097351074,
0.17789986729621887,
-0.4428570568561554,
-0.07476305961608887,
-0.1369793862104416,
-0.025549929589033127,
0.6621066331863403,
0.35202446579933167,
-0.17450524866580963,
-0.5408559441566467,
0.4720436632633209,
0.17298680543899536,
0.12375868111848831,
0.0028054993599653244,
-0.32562732696533203,
-0.673751950263977,
-0.6719303727149963,
0.29655230045318604,
0.39200717210769653,
-0.7301035523414612,
0.48569726943969727,
-0.440586119890213,
-0.8374679088592529,
-0.3837183713912964,
-0.037448104470968246,
0.5066484808921814,
0.5373563170433044,
0.46902912855148315,
-0.1708425134420395,
-0.38400617241859436,
-0.9764165878295898,
-0.5963486433029175,
-0.2073553055524826,
-0.06138131394982338,
0.055108264088630676,
0.6682521104812622,
-0.15330590307712555,
0.7508653998374939,
-0.486672580242157,
-0.22837722301483154,
0.23731321096420288,
0.317403107881546,
0.2883334755897522,
0.7087357044219971,
0.2988125681877136,
-0.4371095597743988,
-0.5398296117782593,
0.0860646516084671,
-0.7213894128799438,
-0.196468323469162,
0.2379804253578186,
-0.13429732620716095,
-0.3165711760520935,
0.7061126232147217,
-0.41209718585014343,
0.20373322069644928,
0.7874170541763306,
-0.20601540803909302,
0.7511836886405945,
-0.29041406512260437,
0.21789640188217163,
-0.6573730111122131,
0.3563474416732788,
0.1682547926902771,
-0.3694298267364502,
-0.7351782321929932,
0.18481706082820892,
0.22436237335205078,
0.23248451948165894,
-0.7430515289306641,
0.3883490562438965,
0.16966645419597626,
0.28693562746047974,
-0.28069451451301575,
0.0729023814201355,
0.34976959228515625,
0.03714220970869064,
-0.1512773483991623,
1.0060720443725586,
0.23884712159633636,
-0.49707654118537903,
0.24477162957191467,
0.20095767080783844,
-1.0148749351501465,
0.5678035616874695,
-0.6471219062805176,
-0.09240511804819107,
0.22239474952220917,
0.4309752285480499,
-1.0957685708999634,
-0.06147531419992447,
0.16260908544063568,
-0.16054412722587585,
0.269112229347229,
-0.2892073690891266,
-0.8619867563247681,
0.18739080429077148,
0.02873878926038742,
0.6678550243377686,
0.05584568902850151,
-0.6065737009048462,
-0.029069947078824043,
0.40612348914146423,
0.01952829584479332,
-0.5960695147514343,
-0.609618067741394,
-0.27593299746513367,
-0.37491244077682495,
-0.6150291562080383,
0.2005770057439804,
0.10314997285604477,
-0.29850947856903076,
-0.0754263773560524,
-0.40882888436317444,
-0.3801501393318176,
0.4938243627548218,
0.09939278662204742,
0.05221688374876976,
-0.2513491213321686,
0.3018578290939331,
0.04792587831616402,
-0.0793774202466011,
0.03608603775501251,
-0.07384698837995529,
0.678195059299469,
0.23736299574375153,
-0.5738984942436218,
-0.7044389843940735,
0.003144546877592802,
0.740409255027771,
-0.4098822772502899,
0.7471393942832947,
0.26715946197509766,
-0.6326014995574951,
-0.37594354152679443,
-0.4410014748573303,
0.00967124942690134,
-0.5568394660949707,
0.548758864402771,
-0.3707045912742615,
-0.4382467269897461,
0.4759623408317566,
-0.17976896464824677,
-0.25641483068466187,
0.386679083108902,
0.27531272172927856,
0.020481541752815247,
0.7564460635185242,
0.5360316038131714,
0.05328679084777832,
0.47748205065727234,
-0.2538977265357971,
0.1798299103975296,
-0.651414155960083,
-0.18027791380882263,
-0.6998900175094604,
-0.2373896986246109,
-0.7859167456626892,
-0.4250745475292206,
0.4421136975288391,
0.009430534206330776,
-0.5680034160614014,
0.18919064104557037,
-0.3757108151912689,
0.6890604496002197,
0.36352893710136414,
0.03655588626861572,
0.6534587144851685,
-0.271352618932724,
-0.28194791078567505,
-0.025175292044878006,
-0.24875593185424805,
-0.5083572864532471,
0.9298999905586243,
0.34418222308158875,
0.6866043210029602,
0.09007235616445541,
0.7874880433082581,
0.3939356505870819,
0.5340394377708435,
-0.287781298160553,
0.1928224116563797,
-0.4491503834724426,
-0.8550719022750854,
-0.11161066591739655,
-0.44802534580230713,
-0.8881910443305969,
0.4953664243221283,
-0.1954759657382965,
-0.8673322200775146,
0.40094098448753357,
-0.012399038299918175,
-0.4229898452758789,
0.4331665635108948,
-0.5449161529541016,
1.0591785907745361,
-0.09383338689804077,
-0.43466466665267944,
-0.1667356640100479,
0.027510076761245728,
0.7035828828811646,
-0.4473751187324524,
0.3224726915359497,
-0.35654187202453613,
-0.022943314164876938,
0.4960452616214752,
-0.4032095670700073,
0.5320351123809814,
-0.0932815670967102,
-0.27052783966064453,
0.12850229442119598,
0.5890476703643799,
0.6497007608413696,
-0.10045310109853745,
-0.05283911153674126,
0.3492261469364166,
0.44561609625816345,
-0.26301494240760803,
-0.4836956858634949,
0.630914568901062,
-0.5551906228065491,
-0.3276090621948242,
-0.5295878052711487,
-0.5338985323905945,
-0.36231791973114014,
0.22242151200771332,
0.3165035545825958,
0.3146774470806122,
-0.15846283733844757,
0.5106775164604187,
0.5575008988380432,
-0.2449219524860382,
0.07065681368112564,
0.5535112023353577,
-0.1999555230140686,
-0.11108189821243286,
0.9916401505470276,
0.12681640684604645,
0.37856581807136536,
0.4747464656829834,
0.24661190807819366,
-0.4047974944114685,
-0.7064248323440552,
-0.04721946641802788,
0.16034653782844543,
-0.3637301027774811,
-0.3242199718952179,
-0.47416195273399353,
-0.15585117042064667,
-0.08299103379249573,
0.39592134952545166,
-0.6993656158447266,
-0.13848473131656647,
-0.011038830503821373,
-0.05882014334201813,
0.1024053692817688,
0.7200915217399597,
0.004783873911947012,
0.6153138279914856,
-0.6335061192512512,
0.15192000567913055,
-0.0694420337677002,
0.6165381073951721,
-0.12043853849172592,
-0.433977335691452,
-0.3774760961532593,
0.17103539407253265,
-0.5139539241790771,
-0.524604320526123,
0.5437487363815308,
0.11570311337709427,
0.595605194568634,
0.7855168581008911,
0.16082744300365448,
0.5415008068084717,
-0.19096140563488007,
0.6775521039962769,
-0.10146584361791611,
-1.152130126953125,
0.27802330255508423,
-0.5143575072288513,
-0.1616644263267517,
0.6854574680328369,
0.2097335308790207,
-0.8423696756362915,
-0.8400008678436279,
-0.6823320388793945,
-0.8806537389755249,
0.39575982093811035,
0.06972134113311768,
-0.10285627841949463,
-0.08872056007385254,
0.10853830724954605,
0.15043483674526215,
0.36720192432403564,
-0.29601430892944336,
-0.048493459820747375,
0.1418171375989914,
-0.19518974423408508,
-0.24100631475448608,
-0.2851454019546509,
-0.06940735131502151,
0.07239562273025513,
0.7279606461524963,
0.2393103539943695,
-0.41626039147377014,
-0.20328296720981598,
-0.32860293984413147,
-0.0532015785574913,
-0.011512024328112602,
0.446376770734787,
0.687467634677887,
-0.3095160126686096,
0.286722868680954,
-0.06703110039234161,
-0.5515506863594055,
0.21076847612857819,
-0.06018516793847084,
-0.19317950308322906,
-0.042082998901605606,
0.4909244179725647,
0.19164250791072845,
0.5688925981521606,
-0.7991665005683899,
0.6111354827880859,
0.007878976874053478,
0.13672694563865662,
-0.3748510479927063,
0.30104324221611023,
-0.009949322789907455,
0.17957863211631775,
0.21776819229125977,
0.1255340576171875,
0.32125088572502136,
-0.5935342907905579,
0.7899783253669739,
0.311303049325943,
-0.33357325196266174,
-0.09911245107650757,
0.7030143737792969,
0.07672996073961258,
0.0724913477897644,
0.46677836775779724,
-0.006978563964366913,
-0.3891112208366394,
0.6859077215194702,
0.30549031496047974,
0.6838555932044983,
-0.36983537673950195,
0.042016852647066116,
0.2979408800601959,
0.22480040788650513,
-0.24991807341575623,
0.009244786575436592,
0.2443583905696869,
-0.9280284643173218,
-0.5778266191482544,
-0.4848178029060364,
-0.4083854556083679,
0.8056272864341736,
-0.7193997502326965,
0.23805178701877594,
-0.4638163149356842,
-0.038994625210762024,
0.22237233817577362,
0.2719420790672302,
-0.4689812958240509,
0.16091318428516388,
0.24987082183361053,
0.9839933514595032,
-1.453285574913025,
0.7561967968940735,
0.17240603268146515,
-0.3477405607700348,
-0.47970741987228394,
0.20291830599308014,
0.10761033743619919,
-0.500758945941925,
0.42463934421539307,
0.2571452558040619,
0.017425497993826866,
-0.36967578530311584,
-0.20247572660446167,
-0.989220380783081,
0.6694695949554443,
0.6243300437927246,
-0.3248436450958252,
0.36220425367355347,
0.15642277896404266,
0.6804633736610413,
0.049879543483257294,
0.3992082476615906,
0.9268683195114136,
0.5561611652374268,
-0.2764737606048584,
-0.9154558777809143,
0.04794173687696457,
-0.16755862534046173,
-0.12303813546895981,
0.3028302490711212,
-0.6791361570358276,
0.9199044108390808,
0.4812934994697571,
-0.4120345413684845,
0.26787230372428894,
0.3949962854385376,
0.42331942915916443,
0.4711322486400604,
0.4607858657836914,
0.7164426445960999,
1.079110860824585,
-0.22796063125133514,
0.8866846561431885,
-0.4271453320980072,
0.6667748093605042,
1.346069097518921,
-0.3133079409599304,
1.0700950622558594,
0.11779537796974182,
-0.2661910653114319,
0.4254387617111206,
0.7049506902694702,
0.04073571413755417,
0.5703725218772888,
0.47711992263793945,
-0.6446765065193176,
-0.278958261013031,
-0.26981091499328613,
-0.4414035677909851,
0.6225442886352539,
0.46960610151290894,
-0.03408195450901985,
-0.5209485292434692,
-0.2783318758010864,
0.13180461525917053,
0.3731636703014374,
0.018084177747368813,
0.6072633266448975,
-0.16006548702716827,
-0.7777489423751831,
0.82233726978302,
-0.12819162011146545,
0.5979961156845093,
-0.3769903779029846,
-0.07008114457130432,
-0.3633638620376587,
0.5949206352233887,
-0.21783095598220825,
-0.6580325961112976,
0.36538562178611755,
-0.19267538189888,
0.08136764913797379,
-0.05999855324625969,
0.452200323343277,
-0.5924313068389893,
-0.3823082745075226,
0.3905070126056671,
0.6442872881889343,
0.3259376287460327,
-0.5627207159996033,
-0.24136927723884583,
0.15530437231063843,
-0.3707005977630615,
0.05217256024479866,
0.3603614270687103,
0.607128918170929,
-0.13254351913928986,
0.781369686126709,
0.8943514823913574,
0.26752981543540955,
-0.003970691934227943,
0.008001076057553291,
0.5786150097846985,
-0.04174933210015297,
-0.4019971489906311,
-0.9406059980392456,
0.4269649386405945,
0.07189066708087921,
-0.1486039012670517,
0.3779659569263458,
1.0485635995864868,
0.8311547636985779,
0.17781898379325867,
0.7716589570045471,
0.6164138317108154,
0.6260919570922852,
-0.26396074891090393,
0.9353156089782715,
-0.4116193354129791,
0.36104851961135864,
-0.1931484192609787,
-0.7358474135398865,
-0.15292420983314514,
0.3487730622291565,
-0.2656378149986267,
-0.24040614068508148,
0.6982596516609192,
0.8070852756500244,
-0.40213626623153687,
-0.011315882205963135,
0.47761934995651245,
0.43077024817466736,
0.8048014640808105,
0.4143083393573761,
0.8191540837287903,
-0.24710485339164734,
0.5235507488250732,
-0.32835355401039124,
-0.37358903884887695,
-0.3132084310054779,
-0.8702644109725952,
-0.37106895446777344,
-0.49136027693748474,
-0.36337578296661377,
-0.3415621519088745,
0.06456044316291809,
0.49437466263771057,
0.614348292350769,
-1.0160220861434937,
-0.11433176696300507,
-0.0686674565076828,
0.2196788638830185,
-0.5772675275802612,
-0.2047824114561081,
0.512337863445282,
-0.4320535659790039,
-1.006956696510315,
0.4491671323776245,
-0.19475775957107544,
-0.12592168152332306,
-0.24172650277614594,
0.5831359028816223,
-0.03650436922907829,
0.25242123007774353,
0.382994681596756,
0.14386509358882904,
-0.3070802688598633,
-0.5776544213294983,
-0.48905378580093384,
-0.14599771797657013,
-0.046270761638879776,
0.5609635710716248,
-0.6733105182647705,
0.45117849111557007,
0.6924800872802734,
0.5867815017700195,
0.6459286212921143,
0.25292351841926575,
0.3244433104991913,
-1.0402791500091553,
0.21650880575180054,
0.23633573949337006,
0.3144950270652771,
0.36140912771224976,
-0.4751966893672943,
0.4771866500377655,
0.30326026678085327,
-0.47739729285240173,
-1.0941740274429321,
0.16285450756549835,
-0.7024325132369995,
-0.20212078094482422,
1.1168614625930786,
-0.2582523226737976,
-0.06916067749261856,
-0.23233792185783386,
0.2699829936027527,
0.21335309743881226,
-0.30215325951576233,
1.0287448167800903,
0.8753429055213928,
-0.010137815959751606,
0.33079588413238525,
-0.9919614195823669,
0.5506484508514404,
0.051011405885219574,
-0.8665213584899902,
0.2878599464893341,
0.2958945333957672,
0.7680432796478271,
0.1410338580608368,
0.3518884778022766,
-0.3008791208267212,
0.13115189969539642,
0.03595868498086929,
-0.006620319094508886,
-0.0838521271944046,
-0.1866355687379837,
-0.14584340155124664,
0.17962604761123657,
-0.16212883591651917,
-0.5020385384559631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16277v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16277v3
|
Picturing Ambiguity: A Visual Twist on the Winograd Schema Challenge
| 2024-05-25T15:28:22 | 2024-06-03T16:42:55 |
Brendan Park, Madeline Janecek, Naser Ezzati-Jivan, Yifeng Li, Ali Emami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable success in tasks
like the Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC), showcasing advanced textual
common-sense reasoning. However, applying this reasoning to multimodal domains,
where understanding text and images together is essential, remains a
substantial challenge. To address this, we introduce WinoVis, a novel dataset
specifically designed to probe text-to-image models on pronoun disambiguation
within multimodal contexts. Utilizing GPT-4 for prompt generation and Diffusion
Attentive Attribution Maps (DAAM) for heatmap analysis, we propose a novel
evaluation framework that isolates the models' ability in pronoun
disambiguation from other visual processing challenges. Evaluation of
successive model versions reveals that, despite incremental advancements,
Stable Diffusion 2.0 achieves a precision of 56.7% on WinoVis, only marginally
surpassing random guessing. Further error analysis identifies important areas
for future research aimed at advancing text-to-image models in their ability to
interpret and interact with the complex visual world.
|
[
-0.14418047666549683,
-0.7478039264678955,
0.9223431944847107,
0.15993672609329224,
-0.32180994749069214,
0.08396641910076141,
-0.2764494717121124,
-0.48961734771728516,
-0.4202284812927246,
0.10209302604198456,
-0.5438417196273804,
-0.5346434712409973,
-1.0808453559875488,
0.009032639674842358,
-0.15278446674346924,
0.3858717381954193,
-0.3642250597476959,
-0.07857079058885574,
-0.3909895718097687,
-0.18909502029418945,
-0.44022491574287415,
0.15185390412807465,
-0.13351817429065704,
0.02745620533823967,
0.5474086999893188,
0.5027251839637756,
1.2051630020141602,
0.28955480456352234,
0.8755608797073364,
0.3719392716884613,
-0.12043721228837967,
0.3384486734867096,
-0.088820680975914,
0.4618799388408661,
-0.061227817088365555,
-0.24940040707588196,
-0.08682870864868164,
0.055135875940322876,
0.6172093749046326,
0.7823176980018616,
-0.3322991132736206,
0.14399069547653198,
-0.32440826296806335,
0.5336247682571411,
-0.8209063410758972,
0.07301419228315353,
-0.6203632354736328,
-0.0005941028939560056,
-0.4166009724140167,
0.05007065832614899,
-0.3971371054649353,
-0.11650828272104263,
0.18373094499111176,
-0.9545249342918396,
0.14960359036922455,
0.2602875232696533,
1.04771888256073,
0.2171361744403839,
-0.7779034376144409,
-0.24793808162212372,
-0.64735347032547,
0.7791177034378052,
-0.37248751521110535,
0.37255027890205383,
0.09613297134637833,
0.42146748304367065,
-0.40480589866638184,
-0.5823570489883423,
-0.8982137441635132,
0.3067837059497833,
0.005509186536073685,
0.02867506816983223,
-0.6454842686653137,
-0.1873762458562851,
0.2183665782213211,
0.15888555347919464,
-0.6247204542160034,
-0.1850387305021286,
-0.39364388585090637,
-0.09511332958936691,
0.26481661200523376,
0.058637943118810654,
0.2640005052089691,
-0.3456142544746399,
-0.5065822005271912,
-0.031828638166189194,
-0.4510188400745392,
-0.046704910695552826,
0.26745250821113586,
0.1409485787153244,
-0.0661967545747757,
0.6767512559890747,
0.18392865359783173,
0.9450909495353699,
-0.22444888949394226,
0.03549342229962349,
0.4680864214897156,
-0.17888066172599792,
-0.35907167196273804,
-0.562923789024353,
0.9128177762031555,
0.5593701004981995,
0.18024593591690063,
-0.00860357005149126,
0.0949506163597107,
0.41058802604675293,
-0.019075924530625343,
-0.4829100966453552,
-0.09305162727832794,
0.04378105327486992,
-0.3891153633594513,
-0.27235889434814453,
-0.207777202129364,
-0.6411973237991333,
-0.3109513521194458,
-0.2806110680103302,
0.6188126802444458,
-0.5328858494758606,
-0.3932681679725647,
0.34658733010292053,
-0.42909368872642517,
0.13203975558280945,
0.5149785280227661,
-0.599837601184845,
0.1658359169960022,
0.2633979618549347,
0.8039442896842957,
-0.05331455543637276,
-0.3434525430202484,
-0.34935665130615234,
0.29000553488731384,
-0.6289546489715576,
1.0725162029266357,
-1.0602260828018188,
-0.35821229219436646,
-0.2807621359825134,
0.019189899787306786,
-0.17350655794143677,
-0.5462403893470764,
0.06436016410589218,
-0.3802736699581146,
0.5026208162307739,
-0.31704747676849365,
-0.30082058906555176,
-0.06382099539041519,
0.1172027587890625,
-0.538336992263794,
1.098801851272583,
0.1453908234834671,
-1.0341674089431763,
0.4531285762786865,
-0.5900938510894775,
-0.173366978764534,
0.2154444456100464,
-0.33416756987571716,
-0.25058266520500183,
0.16181503236293793,
0.22920666635036469,
0.4934723675251007,
-0.34824639558792114,
0.6620023250579834,
-0.2265336811542511,
-0.2709503769874573,
0.14445120096206665,
-0.2847728133201599,
0.4814760982990265,
0.25142234563827515,
-0.247312530875206,
0.3049200773239136,
-0.6485863924026489,
-0.14568397402763367,
0.4125151038169861,
0.13040785491466522,
-0.5968424677848816,
-0.046067699790000916,
-0.044875528663396835,
0.3275049328804016,
-0.02119322121143341,
-0.447796493768692,
0.35739609599113464,
0.006370438262820244,
0.28868788480758667,
0.6151530742645264,
-0.21792541444301605,
0.5362669825553894,
-0.035453107208013535,
0.6402617692947388,
0.4355265498161316,
0.26427382230758667,
-0.2863193154335022,
-0.8217963576316833,
-0.4646258056163788,
-0.5671105980873108,
0.10538724064826965,
0.6853682994842529,
-1.1322158575057983,
-0.35804516077041626,
-0.15633715689182281,
-0.5099743008613586,
-0.6752877831459045,
0.002910636132583022,
0.24102075397968292,
0.5281063318252563,
0.3899892270565033,
-0.05787726119160652,
-0.15890783071517944,
-1.0557610988616943,
-0.11426308006048203,
-0.018948769196867943,
-0.11234736442565918,
0.18067118525505066,
0.6313797235488892,
-0.26355743408203125,
0.7466222643852234,
-0.43115147948265076,
-0.1951586753129959,
0.010413982905447483,
0.424041211605072,
0.10033998638391495,
0.2373591661453247,
0.5405765771865845,
-0.9598108530044556,
-0.1318022608757019,
-0.2274380922317505,
-0.8129616975784302,
0.2063654363155365,
-0.07115544378757477,
-0.30965662002563477,
-0.149831622838974,
0.3530850112438202,
-0.7986627221107483,
0.5466708540916443,
0.6811608672142029,
-0.5680861473083496,
0.5011584758758545,
-0.3528864085674286,
0.5357085466384888,
-1.0982011556625366,
0.042810071259737015,
0.23910722136497498,
-0.17338570952415466,
-0.47315722703933716,
-0.026934439316391945,
0.15009069442749023,
-0.10131923854351044,
-0.5318831205368042,
0.49766433238983154,
-0.7882876396179199,
-0.11338780075311661,
0.18647326529026031,
0.4045425355434418,
0.08814699947834015,
0.10903749614953995,
0.12236590683460236,
0.5950555801391602,
1.0976170301437378,
-0.29066333174705505,
0.5498897433280945,
0.2754228711128235,
-0.5869924426078796,
0.8578550815582275,
-0.5246179103851318,
-0.04815466329455376,
-0.3779122233390808,
0.0603172592818737,
-1.2863463163375854,
-0.30088362097740173,
0.4637211859226227,
-0.11555834859609604,
0.33056584000587463,
0.026538241654634476,
-0.5919752717018127,
-0.34399235248565674,
-0.17297589778900146,
0.8510756492614746,
0.22149065136909485,
-0.38221272826194763,
0.45286330580711365,
0.2259283810853958,
-0.20311309397220612,
-0.7204968929290771,
-0.3360385596752167,
0.36413851380348206,
-0.2713525593280792,
-0.809024453163147,
0.3868250548839569,
-0.1529872566461563,
-0.4685589373111725,
-0.060460735112428665,
0.22661952674388885,
-0.004469653591513634,
-0.10853223502635956,
0.4431600868701935,
0.45662885904312134,
0.020313218235969543,
0.31600505113601685,
0.0702349990606308,
-0.06075248494744301,
-0.23925606906414032,
-0.03983509540557861,
-0.05231958627700806,
-0.3175539970397949,
-0.48614969849586487,
-0.44045108556747437,
0.629961371421814,
0.548975944519043,
-0.1620381623506546,
0.5040918588638306,
0.519891083240509,
-0.42012977600097656,
0.12203622609376907,
-0.3356747627258301,
0.19991634786128998,
-0.4637329578399658,
0.1301201432943344,
-0.6236035227775574,
-0.6979895830154419,
0.5549609065055847,
-0.3056968152523041,
-0.09300993382930756,
0.5155240893363953,
0.2979944050312042,
-0.40268680453300476,
0.9681137800216675,
0.46146160364151,
0.6366214752197266,
0.19258831441402435,
-0.117349773645401,
0.1088298037648201,
-0.6569617986679077,
-0.6054765582084656,
-0.24747341871261597,
-0.4922783374786377,
-0.2588743269443512,
-0.8994619846343994,
0.23805595934391022,
-0.1586182415485382,
0.022644367069005966,
0.09655503928661346,
-0.34197473526000977,
0.641913890838623,
0.26934096217155457,
0.1024022176861763,
0.3308526277542114,
0.14563803374767303,
-0.193433478474617,
-0.5221709609031677,
-0.5984595417976379,
-0.36853766441345215,
0.7263392806053162,
0.3390931189060211,
0.7505699992179871,
0.4120255410671234,
0.2536464333534241,
0.2960580587387085,
0.19252647459506989,
-0.4444226920604706,
0.5721298456192017,
-0.16529631614685059,
-0.45058152079582214,
-0.0954609364271164,
-0.3130156695842743,
-1.0070241689682007,
0.4418223798274994,
-0.30766943097114563,
-0.6504469513893127,
0.4173869490623474,
0.2284376174211502,
-0.1550496220588684,
0.26613858342170715,
-0.7048848271369934,
1.0876843929290771,
-0.044530510902404785,
-0.4458453357219696,
0.15120135247707367,
-0.8324439525604248,
0.2929474711418152,
0.3088604211807251,
0.7289913892745972,
-0.32074403762817383,
-0.20808392763137817,
0.4367745816707611,
0.0032200205605477095,
0.7422230839729309,
-0.18942321836948395,
-0.42913755774497986,
0.22458770871162415,
0.4979235529899597,
0.1532401591539383,
-0.24401885271072388,
-0.0003618639602791518,
0.38687849044799805,
-0.006249559577554464,
-0.5341928601264954,
-0.49516162276268005,
0.4834122061729431,
-0.3220992684364319,
-0.34610041975975037,
-0.5319757461547852,
-0.6824802756309509,
-0.19224660098552704,
0.05286262556910515,
0.40274688601493835,
0.4469318389892578,
-0.06694091856479645,
-0.11151506751775742,
0.6609675288200378,
-0.15868587791919708,
0.2301214039325714,
0.17666880786418915,
-0.3786349296569824,
-0.010031028650701046,
0.87028968334198,
-0.25035661458969116,
0.2993791103363037,
0.0634869858622551,
0.08118017762899399,
-0.2578703761100769,
-0.5493928790092468,
-0.6422392129898071,
0.323432981967926,
-1.0128452777862549,
-0.2876241207122803,
-0.312919944524765,
0.282539039850235,
-0.24081137776374817,
-0.14289696514606476,
-0.37192806601524353,
-0.288235068321228,
-0.573472261428833,
0.017986880615353584,
0.25282320380210876,
0.843396782875061,
-0.09379744529724121,
0.462632954120636,
-0.3458508253097534,
0.5364944338798523,
0.16714221239089966,
0.3718055486679077,
-0.5396959781646729,
-0.7051001191139221,
0.19297553598880768,
-0.0937390923500061,
-0.20051617920398712,
-1.3535898923873901,
0.2706438899040222,
0.4413933753967285,
0.5133553743362427,
0.32896339893341064,
-0.22930908203125,
0.7559178471565247,
-0.4622350037097931,
0.7947962880134583,
0.40887725353240967,
-0.9650360345840454,
0.804677426815033,
-0.5200538635253906,
0.4822719693183899,
0.1661846935749054,
0.4960631728172302,
-0.5162067413330078,
-0.5873682498931885,
-0.7046793103218079,
-1.018686294555664,
0.3112804889678955,
0.28452497720718384,
-0.05515741929411888,
-0.2835286259651184,
0.5032756924629211,
0.2500944435596466,
0.2413775622844696,
-0.5731022953987122,
-0.06546279042959213,
0.04601600021123886,
-0.47199320793151855,
-0.04898973926901817,
-0.2682666480541229,
-0.19626295566558838,
-0.1355285942554474,
0.27539658546447754,
-0.19695055484771729,
0.2344430685043335,
0.11225825548171997,
-0.3927457332611084,
-0.11067842692136765,
0.44455084204673767,
0.7284940481185913,
0.7036823630332947,
-0.012550623156130314,
0.5493257641792297,
-0.02997458539903164,
-0.2423655390739441,
0.0892563909292221,
-0.05793169140815735,
0.17387136816978455,
0.24077636003494263,
0.4963556230068207,
0.9827410578727722,
0.3733983337879181,
-0.6775158047676086,
0.8737336993217468,
-0.32791322469711304,
-0.5101131200790405,
0.13982179760932922,
-0.16961683332920074,
0.14570185542106628,
0.4531274437904358,
0.4042426645755768,
0.49911344051361084,
0.13315477967262268,
-0.40144386887550354,
0.03734719753265381,
0.67152339220047,
-0.2560824155807495,
-0.25782766938209534,
0.6090636849403381,
0.017040574923157692,
0.02623732015490532,
0.4713177978992462,
-0.2166343480348587,
-0.3309911787509918,
0.48938918113708496,
0.3624807298183441,
0.3212108612060547,
-0.4093151092529297,
0.5328369736671448,
0.1030687689781189,
0.33904725313186646,
-0.1681649386882782,
0.6660832762718201,
-0.0160711370408535,
-0.584748387336731,
-0.16686929762363434,
-0.2490949183702469,
-0.22294537723064423,
-0.2931266725063324,
-0.6586982011795044,
0.14314787089824677,
-0.09730885177850723,
-0.3811410367488861,
0.24804697930812836,
-0.7095621824264526,
-0.8088198900222778,
0.23569412529468536,
0.3947478234767914,
0.6708047986030579,
-1.113147258758545,
0.519879937171936,
0.5528204441070557,
0.06488396972417831,
-0.37238895893096924,
-0.2992839217185974,
0.08737904578447342,
-0.5969029068946838,
0.8253288865089417,
0.1320641189813614,
-0.4677456319332123,
-0.143833726644516,
-0.7131987810134888,
-0.5826419591903687,
1.06210458278656,
0.6735902428627014,
-0.8129640221595764,
0.05619017779827118,
-0.1786666363477707,
0.35496756434440613,
-0.6021325588226318,
0.3161958158016205,
0.3631606996059418,
0.4714968204498291,
0.4206070899963379,
-0.895469605922699,
-0.006493972614407539,
-0.4288674294948578,
0.19358119368553162,
0.1404912769794464,
-0.24600662291049957,
0.7479167580604553,
-0.9753922820091248,
-0.3957724869251251,
-0.19610853493213654,
0.5834447145462036,
-0.05536217615008354,
0.4700621962547302,
0.6706383228302002,
0.4026074707508087,
0.9063929319381714,
-0.30788230895996094,
0.8882094621658325,
0.35896816849708557,
0.2703806161880493,
1.158799648284912,
-0.24219398200511932,
1.0358688831329346,
0.9664958715438843,
-0.13409356772899628,
0.7354401350021362,
0.9375130534172058,
0.01796831004321575,
0.6104983687400818,
0.15840362012386322,
-0.2798115909099579,
-0.5118579864501953,
0.0402427539229393,
-0.35810062289237976,
0.3731116056442261,
0.5639464259147644,
-0.15447913110256195,
-0.25949999690055847,
0.48348209261894226,
-0.14797842502593994,
0.1556289792060852,
0.15811793506145477,
0.5986117124557495,
-0.3194381594657898,
-0.3564680516719818,
0.38068896532058716,
-0.13468490540981293,
0.6422774791717529,
-0.5022851228713989,
-0.014922496862709522,
-0.03053268790245056,
-0.04889126121997833,
0.00886328611522913,
-1.002729058265686,
0.27127546072006226,
-0.1488320380449295,
-0.2005586326122284,
-0.16740523278713226,
0.5300068855285645,
-0.7318370938301086,
-0.7926782965660095,
0.2470475286245346,
0.4209741950035095,
0.20886248350143433,
0.03148694708943367,
-0.6763566136360168,
0.33028730750083923,
-0.1524992436170578,
-0.3232850134372711,
0.023637590929865837,
0.49955233931541443,
-0.10818035155534744,
0.6773579120635986,
0.3272583782672882,
-0.10077889263629913,
0.07534844428300858,
0.127373605966568,
0.7614211440086365,
-0.5315417647361755,
-0.10281475633382797,
-0.8552573323249817,
0.6620319485664368,
0.05442006140947342,
-0.2974717617034912,
0.4280979037284851,
0.35128289461135864,
0.4609296917915344,
-0.10913719236850739,
0.6567087769508362,
0.06650294363498688,
0.138945534825325,
-0.47367924451828003,
0.34120386838912964,
-0.9653379321098328,
0.10353132337331772,
-0.6031104326248169,
-0.6052963137626648,
-0.6400426030158997,
0.7646597623825073,
-0.41853296756744385,
-0.16050325334072113,
0.6019493937492371,
0.6985964775085449,
-0.18060974776744843,
-0.13794659078121185,
0.3101625144481659,
0.013934738002717495,
0.15048103034496307,
0.6517356038093567,
0.9976771473884583,
-0.6691104769706726,
0.5072141289710999,
-0.08216580748558044,
-0.4421609938144684,
0.04689439758658409,
-1.2086541652679443,
-0.5099537372589111,
-0.9569929242134094,
-0.6933380365371704,
-0.1442422866821289,
0.14419490098953247,
0.47606852650642395,
0.6767584681510925,
-0.31633132696151733,
0.03094584122300148,
0.261664479970932,
0.08923406898975372,
-0.22157908976078033,
-0.10186728835105896,
0.2839197814464569,
-0.040378157049417496,
-0.6098570823669434,
0.4286288619041443,
0.527600109577179,
0.4245151877403259,
-0.030605370178818703,
-0.09789832681417465,
-0.36022111773490906,
0.14209550619125366,
0.4984658360481262,
-0.17104129493236542,
-0.8902807235717773,
-0.1143823191523552,
0.13027597963809967,
-0.018607966601848602,
0.07399459928274155,
0.7250543832778931,
-0.592889130115509,
0.7990737557411194,
0.3224402964115143,
0.07796462625265121,
0.3345133662223816,
-0.10412268340587616,
0.3798058032989502,
-0.7716841101646423,
0.4078144431114197,
-0.0699438527226448,
0.33148008584976196,
0.6925358772277832,
-0.29367324709892273,
0.008997072465717793,
0.4911799728870392,
-0.19167067110538483,
-0.846145749092102,
0.41581490635871887,
-1.0505681037902832,
-0.5800500512123108,
1.0504308938980103,
-0.10388561338186264,
-0.24801643192768097,
0.057294007390737534,
-0.3775629997253418,
0.06574254482984543,
-0.13654319941997528,
0.5661469101905823,
0.8991156220436096,
-0.029376816004514694,
-0.5876010656356812,
-0.5836995244026184,
0.4072132110595703,
0.40842676162719727,
-0.7078025341033936,
0.2448311150074005,
0.8118845820426941,
0.32992470264434814,
0.09289874881505966,
0.5638179183006287,
0.07262593507766724,
0.3080803453922272,
0.028261957690119743,
0.013773055747151375,
-0.10051463544368744,
-0.6487686038017273,
-0.1323055773973465,
0.27864372730255127,
-0.05780224874615669,
-0.3978031277656555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16247v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16247v1
|
AutoManual: Generating Instruction Manuals by LLM Agents via Interactive Environmental Learning
| 2024-05-25T14:11:44 | 2024-05-25T14:11:44 |
Minghao Chen, Yihang Li, Yanting Yang, Shiyu Yu, Binbin Lin, Xiaofei He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLM) based agents have shown promise in autonomously
completing tasks across various domains, e.g., robotics, games, and web
navigation. However, these agents typically require elaborate design and expert
prompts to solve tasks in specific domains, which limits their adaptability. We
introduce AutoManual, a framework enabling LLM agents to autonomously build
their understanding through interaction and adapt to new environments.
AutoManual categorizes environmental knowledge into diverse rules and optimizes
them in an online fashion by two agents: 1) The Planner codes actionable plans
based on current rules for interacting with the environment. 2) The Builder
updates the rules through a well-structured rule system that facilitates online
rule management and essential detail retention. To mitigate hallucinations in
managing rules, we introduce \textit{case-conditioned prompting} strategy for
the Builder. Finally, the Formulator agent compiles these rules into a
comprehensive manual. The self-generated manual can not only improve the
adaptability but also guide the planning of smaller LLMs while being
human-readable. Given only one simple demonstration, AutoManual significantly
improves task success rates, achieving 97.4\% with GPT-4-turbo and 86.2\% with
GPT-3.5-turbo on ALFWorld benchmark tasks. The source code will be available
soon.
|
[
-0.4019232988357544,
-0.9034550189971924,
0.6863729953765869,
0.308798223733902,
0.21150308847427368,
-0.047921665012836456,
-0.17795628309249878,
-0.4314139485359192,
-0.0298574510961771,
0.42123445868492126,
-0.7181258201599121,
-0.5229739546775818,
-0.2874740958213806,
0.1730760782957077,
-0.1897825449705124,
0.6456359028816223,
-0.3588671386241913,
-0.3491443395614624,
-0.4104440212249756,
-0.026796037331223488,
-0.36201342940330505,
-0.3342357575893402,
-0.6034948825836182,
-0.24737197160720825,
0.4002365171909332,
0.4183657467365265,
0.7072712779045105,
1.018839716911316,
0.27626070380210876,
0.5007662177085876,
0.4206486642360687,
0.44047683477401733,
-0.12200189381837845,
0.6254512667655945,
-0.20682841539382935,
-0.201080322265625,
-0.49640557169914246,
-0.17619600892066956,
0.32557427883148193,
0.3091197907924652,
-0.41182228922843933,
0.11563480645418167,
0.12196528911590576,
0.6859099268913269,
-0.4718259871006012,
0.7504695057868958,
-0.43764886260032654,
0.23361793160438538,
0.4363384544849396,
-0.5530035495758057,
-0.18131916224956512,
0.06480377912521362,
-0.08624761551618576,
-1.0371623039245605,
-0.11958570778369904,
0.1544973999261856,
0.3886284828186035,
0.7977442145347595,
-0.43678706884384155,
-0.7684913277626038,
-0.8654158711433411,
0.35825982689857483,
-0.4701126217842102,
0.43843477964401245,
0.34629112482070923,
0.3779209852218628,
-0.33083340525627136,
-0.6306573152542114,
-0.46538305282592773,
-0.3313100039958954,
-0.09239111095666885,
0.3494379222393036,
-0.2852545976638794,
0.11927992105484009,
0.11859186738729477,
0.029258370399475098,
-0.39718127250671387,
0.0285370834171772,
-0.09039002656936646,
0.054564911872148514,
0.711685061454773,
0.35792890191078186,
0.5552574396133423,
-0.05478841811418533,
-0.19448013603687286,
-0.15264178812503815,
-0.6437652707099915,
0.0009364651050418615,
0.38989779353141785,
0.23843802511692047,
0.12734109163284302,
0.4698027968406677,
-0.21126951277256012,
0.6479102373123169,
0.2646646797657013,
-0.2202700674533844,
-0.15705254673957825,
-0.2801955044269562,
-0.21225707232952118,
-0.051587287336587906,
0.4368473291397095,
0.23359934985637665,
0.07309096306562424,
-0.09342766553163528,
-0.635949969291687,
-0.5506646633148193,
0.4871184825897217,
-0.6282808184623718,
-0.4336501955986023,
-0.10378763824701309,
-0.34076738357543945,
-0.019274406135082245,
-0.008286075666546822,
-0.394390344619751,
-0.23475295305252075,
-0.943540632724762,
0.5809641480445862,
-0.30759143829345703,
-0.18996833264827728,
-0.18584759533405304,
0.05817721411585808,
0.3293887674808502,
0.6701381802558899,
-0.8575724363327026,
0.3663274347782135,
0.27725136280059814,
0.6212009191513062,
0.04401254281401634,
-0.5110613107681274,
-0.5057199001312256,
0.5255224108695984,
-0.2543686032295227,
0.923162579536438,
-0.21637818217277527,
-0.4305900037288666,
-0.025123514235019684,
0.09819035232067108,
-0.2753124535083771,
-0.5239882469177246,
-0.39716818928718567,
-0.4555531442165375,
0.22954340279102325,
-0.036648526787757874,
-0.43644535541534424,
-0.31634849309921265,
0.20281867682933807,
-0.4653654098510742,
0.8673298954963684,
0.23919638991355896,
0.015545650385320187,
0.19819357991218567,
-1.0114705562591553,
-0.46454551815986633,
0.09188906848430634,
-0.18217389285564423,
-0.02761995606124401,
-0.19211366772651672,
0.10979030281305313,
0.21080848574638367,
0.0776401162147522,
0.11477161943912506,
-0.09719327092170715,
-0.015440210700035095,
-0.07222488522529602,
-0.26575717329978943,
0.5639199614524841,
0.27893346548080444,
-0.7729926705360413,
0.33685556054115295,
-0.3505191206932068,
-0.048990122973918915,
0.10587425529956818,
-0.5588833689689636,
-0.12481848895549774,
0.1288805902004242,
-0.1567998081445694,
0.3979164958000183,
0.33923789858818054,
-0.026454661041498184,
0.33359676599502563,
-0.16668660938739777,
0.20726418495178223,
0.9785206317901611,
0.09160955995321274,
0.5191785097122192,
-0.6042301058769226,
0.6887624263763428,
-0.2132108360528946,
0.22184936702251434,
-0.5121344327926636,
-0.2293139547109604,
-1.0643032789230347,
-0.2935031056404114,
-0.3073783218860626,
0.7575874328613281,
-0.9050354957580566,
0.5307489037513733,
0.07464583963155746,
-0.444343239068985,
-0.11879861354827881,
0.7487478852272034,
0.3730219602584839,
0.16065213084220886,
0.3617819547653198,
-0.0593484602868557,
-0.3847692608833313,
-0.6778221130371094,
-0.07012223452329636,
-0.23999632894992828,
0.010597752407193184,
0.5660005211830139,
0.6472556591033936,
-0.575631320476532,
1.1058692932128906,
-0.48152482509613037,
-0.5427209138870239,
-0.16951711475849152,
0.17810693383216858,
-0.1619693636894226,
0.4005066752433777,
0.44803041219711304,
-0.4878070652484894,
-0.6935526132583618,
-0.027745533734560013,
-1.116083025932312,
-0.2775426506996155,
-0.17182785272598267,
-0.11513295769691467,
0.4949856698513031,
0.8894011378288269,
-0.5949634313583374,
0.2650793194770813,
0.13662053644657135,
-0.3342728912830353,
0.28160586953163147,
-0.7738534212112427,
-0.11053789407014847,
-0.8251035809516907,
-0.17566508054733276,
-0.046774156391620636,
-0.44135552644729614,
-0.3355470299720764,
0.280670166015625,
-0.06045249104499817,
0.017772221937775612,
-0.4020887613296509,
0.7669345736503601,
-0.7404028177261353,
-0.11022967100143433,
-0.4491935968399048,
0.07021839171648026,
-0.22910091280937195,
0.6929662227630615,
0.05988364666700363,
0.774777889251709,
0.2932344079017639,
-0.8865237832069397,
0.6351451873779297,
0.3073376715183258,
0.16135597229003906,
0.5940055847167969,
-0.4604800343513489,
0.21015065908432007,
-0.313679963350296,
0.42191264033317566,
-0.6949900388717651,
-0.40156280994415283,
0.40968218445777893,
-0.05222306028008461,
0.2266700714826584,
0.05609310790896416,
-0.7478699088096619,
-0.0953216627240181,
-0.039834365248680115,
-0.16375824809074402,
0.5725488662719727,
-0.6272292733192444,
1.124568223953247,
0.3330911099910736,
-0.4029213786125183,
-0.08087810128927231,
-0.3051411211490631,
0.10943922400474548,
-0.0601082369685173,
-0.3116288185119629,
-0.0027901383582502604,
-0.5005971789360046,
-0.594962477684021,
0.26706376671791077,
-0.18138624727725983,
0.02673775888979435,
0.2606872618198395,
0.5518115758895874,
0.07857821881771088,
-0.13808275759220123,
0.17900530993938446,
0.1445278376340866,
-0.038958679884672165,
0.4993586242198944,
-0.5530176162719727,
0.17339657247066498,
-0.284313440322876,
-0.45158886909484863,
-0.18584954738616943,
0.3112524449825287,
0.5437808632850647,
0.0032208047341555357,
0.4826450049877167,
0.3394250273704529,
-0.4300795793533325,
-0.5047553181648254,
-0.2533999979496002,
-0.15316496789455414,
-0.6070736050605774,
0.13587632775306702,
-0.379787802696228,
-0.37393462657928467,
0.17051400244235992,
-0.1961987316608429,
0.42795825004577637,
0.48334020376205444,
0.6128645539283752,
-0.3245882987976074,
0.9097027778625488,
0.760941207408905,
0.26550185680389404,
0.6060577034950256,
-0.25620222091674805,
-0.10754530131816864,
-0.4775964617729187,
-0.4510464370250702,
0.013784084469079971,
-0.15242666006088257,
-0.3289797008037567,
-0.48412492871284485,
0.3497444987297058,
-0.3081556260585785,
-0.44336459040641785,
0.3920610249042511,
-0.36375004053115845,
0.4987148940563202,
0.7939426302909851,
0.2223907709121704,
0.38232529163360596,
-0.10559415072202682,
-0.15004269778728485,
0.23371829092502594,
-0.8154408931732178,
-0.6786103248596191,
0.9103784561157227,
0.19543050229549408,
0.7648338079452515,
0.2871728539466858,
0.7768179178237915,
0.6458502411842346,
0.633384644985199,
-0.7021518349647522,
0.6733439564704895,
0.342050164937973,
-0.5966207385063171,
-0.5481386184692383,
-0.2826724946498871,
-0.9045757055282593,
0.1895037591457367,
-0.13808222115039825,
-0.1978853940963745,
-0.017177283763885498,
0.3145309090614319,
-0.39571934938430786,
0.11098793148994446,
-0.6573494076728821,
0.6353995203971863,
-0.631858766078949,
-0.3559132218360901,
-0.2125263661146164,
-0.467776894569397,
-0.004336169920861721,
-0.37301358580589294,
0.32402652502059937,
-0.10805950313806534,
-0.49537596106529236,
0.4054645597934723,
-0.45667845010757446,
1.0213271379470825,
-0.34840428829193115,
-0.46880388259887695,
0.3026571273803711,
0.2148934006690979,
0.609128475189209,
-0.076583132147789,
0.12186861783266068,
-0.28226566314697266,
-0.21344079077243805,
-0.23127450048923492,
-0.7458212971687317,
0.6362284421920776,
-0.8918167352676392,
-0.818202018737793,
-0.4069453179836273,
-0.7324172258377075,
0.07079911231994629,
0.24324633181095123,
-0.04573354870080948,
0.4271019399166107,
-0.2718643248081207,
-0.08024123311042786,
0.7331944108009338,
-0.3932390809059143,
0.6960868835449219,
0.9720198512077332,
-0.18614667654037476,
-0.35057398676872253,
0.8813165426254272,
0.2198995053768158,
0.1471712440252304,
0.4042445123195648,
-0.0303345937281847,
-0.28940778970718384,
-0.26055365800857544,
-0.4766336977481842,
-0.00904125813394785,
-1.1752512454986572,
-0.20613634586334229,
-0.8416392207145691,
-0.3472413122653961,
-0.2322094738483429,
-0.3814387023448944,
-0.058257538825273514,
-0.09871643036603928,
-0.3889532685279846,
-0.07247961312532425,
0.3386703431606293,
1.2839059829711914,
-0.29705822467803955,
0.21075546741485596,
-0.6201539039611816,
0.2647077441215515,
0.779560923576355,
-0.04058649390935898,
-0.05738550052046776,
-0.35352036356925964,
-0.2619000971317291,
0.0015898436540737748,
-0.4923127293586731,
-0.7868350744247437,
0.6011298894882202,
0.43228602409362793,
0.847209095954895,
0.3664381802082062,
0.284799724817276,
0.5377174019813538,
-0.5318460464477539,
0.3371538519859314,
-0.25195586681365967,
-0.9332514405250549,
0.6548510193824768,
-0.5071729421615601,
0.4128355383872986,
0.47059518098831177,
0.3747852146625519,
-0.256149560213089,
-0.7741462588310242,
-0.6664853096008301,
-1.0130386352539062,
0.5234793424606323,
0.13412262499332428,
0.18478602170944214,
0.07264627516269684,
0.26331284642219543,
0.23047670722007751,
0.27017053961753845,
-0.7199780941009521,
-0.2929414212703705,
-0.32135772705078125,
-0.39086011052131653,
-0.11645369976758957,
0.03792832791805267,
-0.11557038873434067,
-0.3765396177768707,
0.7714222073554993,
-0.3716205060482025,
0.45583319664001465,
0.3463943302631378,
-0.7033860087394714,
-0.17306508123874664,
-0.04466329887509346,
0.6777734756469727,
0.7221932411193848,
-0.08004434406757355,
0.30229586362838745,
0.3993881344795227,
-0.27493736147880554,
0.43078815937042236,
0.27936744689941406,
-0.020738640800118446,
-0.24320784211158752,
0.5123510360717773,
0.5339735746383667,
0.3562626242637634,
-0.7019053101539612,
0.19195207953453064,
-0.16519968211650848,
-0.321380078792572,
-0.7932873964309692,
0.4955717921257019,
0.06589040160179138,
0.416849285364151,
0.4206009805202484,
0.00045295862946659327,
0.09028547257184982,
-0.4924924075603485,
0.3596811592578888,
0.20651495456695557,
-0.2400168925523758,
-0.1953306496143341,
0.8169873356819153,
0.5662546157836914,
-0.4567664861679077,
0.5283303260803223,
-0.5850070714950562,
-0.39944952726364136,
0.8783295750617981,
0.5624898672103882,
0.881877601146698,
-0.23362836241722107,
0.05529075860977173,
0.2908839285373688,
0.48259809613227844,
0.11301852017641068,
0.08050303906202316,
-0.4348974823951721,
-0.47993797063827515,
-0.05284024402499199,
-0.32194748520851135,
-0.665658175945282,
-0.15524059534072876,
-0.19255664944648743,
-0.07381686568260193,
-0.6992445588111877,
0.27022913098335266,
-0.3228359818458557,
0.005228763446211815,
-0.7471796274185181,
0.11586377769708633,
0.1721816211938858,
0.7481133937835693,
-0.7506518363952637,
0.5472279191017151,
0.9538792371749878,
-0.33980271220207214,
-0.6559438109397888,
0.057123299688100815,
0.29952889680862427,
-0.8322069048881531,
0.7991933226585388,
0.2951599061489105,
-0.28238925337791443,
0.2975925803184509,
-0.40489867329597473,
-0.9383364319801331,
1.4669796228408813,
0.28660303354263306,
-0.4267900586128235,
-0.00028554891468957067,
-0.027248889207839966,
0.47173383831977844,
-0.5948349833488464,
0.3018990457057953,
0.2297346144914627,
0.8079376220703125,
-0.1795244812965393,
-0.7082740664482117,
0.2685164213180542,
-0.5160971283912659,
-0.15785452723503113,
0.08702854812145233,
-0.6070583462715149,
0.49955612421035767,
-0.3115399479866028,
-0.1561422049999237,
-0.04091475531458855,
0.6833136081695557,
0.12969070672988892,
0.3525075614452362,
0.7712222933769226,
0.22816622257232666,
0.8200837969779968,
0.1276775300502777,
0.8917246460914612,
-0.7054587006568909,
-0.02479218877851963,
1.1203469038009644,
-0.23583877086639404,
0.5039017796516418,
0.05750386416912079,
0.1022074744105339,
0.6368551254272461,
0.7072531580924988,
-0.040890343487262726,
0.44636300206184387,
0.051428284496068954,
-0.523663341999054,
-0.3014674782752991,
-0.004038266837596893,
-0.1192653626203537,
0.47783708572387695,
0.3006729483604431,
-0.20141322910785675,
-0.24683882296085358,
0.33429938554763794,
-0.03146066144108772,
0.07446584105491638,
-0.18522702157497406,
1.0734044313430786,
0.0037113032303750515,
-0.7845290303230286,
0.18919268250465393,
-0.12773476541042328,
0.4296964704990387,
-0.5155438780784607,
-0.22892417013645172,
-0.29388999938964844,
0.21307849884033203,
-0.1894690990447998,
-0.4577811360359192,
0.31682977080345154,
-0.14584395289421082,
-0.07947083562612534,
-0.7878015041351318,
0.7058184742927551,
-0.5989788770675659,
-0.24437221884727478,
0.3178103268146515,
0.8823994398117065,
0.045341458171606064,
-0.05213893949985504,
-0.736169159412384,
-0.3862718939781189,
-0.19679418206214905,
-0.40730541944503784,
0.18349044024944305,
0.600696325302124,
0.07254879176616669,
1.0767897367477417,
0.6421443819999695,
-0.2332252860069275,
-0.09120038151741028,
-0.4682602882385254,
0.8094015121459961,
-0.7248967885971069,
-0.3989469110965729,
-0.7708712816238403,
0.18337202072143555,
0.11413266509771347,
-0.007625410798937082,
0.8932808637619019,
0.5803490877151489,
0.6756759881973267,
-0.2148243635892868,
0.7999013662338257,
-0.08189435303211212,
-0.20799487829208374,
-0.5503970980644226,
0.8385965824127197,
-0.5865627527236938,
0.28233715891838074,
0.07381036877632141,
-0.9771721363067627,
0.018202215433120728,
0.6010938882827759,
-0.1306493878364563,
0.20749610662460327,
0.7638483643531799,
0.7569364905357361,
0.004460495430976152,
-0.3328416645526886,
0.21782459318637848,
0.02917536348104477,
0.3396774232387543,
0.4768123924732208,
0.9110183715820312,
0.07154960930347443,
0.5850383043289185,
-0.19145826995372772,
-0.23745058476924896,
-0.2367895096540451,
-1.0353888273239136,
-0.9046732783317566,
-0.6115014553070068,
-0.42595237493515015,
0.034032080322504044,
0.2748211622238159,
1.3820574283599854,
0.847722053527832,
-0.3642156720161438,
-0.3450154662132263,
-0.40989193320274353,
0.24608199298381805,
-0.24499419331550598,
-0.21595822274684906,
-0.055040206760168076,
-0.6483398675918579,
-0.6371971368789673,
0.5919249653816223,
0.4008827209472656,
0.36262211203575134,
-0.42749693989753723,
-0.4526102840900421,
0.002465528901666403,
0.2774669826030731,
0.5780389308929443,
0.5085434913635254,
-0.47595715522766113,
0.03565066307783127,
-0.004052124917507172,
-0.261191189289093,
-0.007508611306548119,
0.5794152021408081,
-0.7977322936058044,
0.4182065725326538,
0.1427040547132492,
0.4977489411830902,
0.33679988980293274,
-0.2544838488101959,
0.8330495953559875,
-0.4573662281036377,
-0.08593466877937317,
-0.04747757688164711,
0.32499027252197266,
0.3407922089099884,
-0.5904008150100708,
0.5699453949928284,
0.17977653443813324,
-0.6722261905670166,
-0.2942780554294586,
0.16749577224254608,
-0.5740975737571716,
-0.5168464779853821,
1.2781314849853516,
-0.164561465382576,
-0.35722339153289795,
-0.24919256567955017,
-0.3454652726650238,
0.22618220746517181,
-0.45088082551956177,
0.8946487307548523,
0.48843440413475037,
-0.35378116369247437,
-0.156431183218956,
-0.66765958070755,
0.5018028020858765,
0.07725559175014496,
-1.428717017173767,
-0.03146222606301308,
0.6851252317428589,
0.391265869140625,
-0.04418143630027771,
0.6205323934555054,
0.519264817237854,
0.3397740125656128,
-0.03093715012073517,
0.20843295753002167,
-0.6442892551422119,
-0.49836868047714233,
-0.17719797790050507,
-0.1596733033657074,
0.1538114845752716,
0.0828440859913826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16229v1
|
No Two Devils Alike: Unveiling Distinct Mechanisms of Fine-tuning Attacks
| 2024-05-25T13:38:40 | 2024-05-25T13:38:40 |
Chak Tou Leong, Yi Cheng, Kaishuai Xu, Jian Wang, Hanlin Wang, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The existing safety alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) is found
fragile and could be easily attacked through different strategies, such as
through fine-tuning on a few harmful examples or manipulating the prefix of the
generation results. However, the attack mechanisms of these strategies are
still underexplored. In this paper, we ask the following question:
\textit{while these approaches can all significantly compromise safety, do
their attack mechanisms exhibit strong similarities?} To answer this question,
we break down the safeguarding process of an LLM when encountered with harmful
instructions into three stages: (1) recognizing harmful instructions, (2)
generating an initial refusing tone, and (3) completing the refusal response.
Accordingly, we investigate whether and how different attack strategies could
influence each stage of this safeguarding process. We utilize techniques such
as logit lens and activation patching to identify model components that drive
specific behavior, and we apply cross-model probing to examine representation
shifts after an attack. In particular, we analyze the two most representative
types of attack approaches: Explicit Harmful Attack (EHA) and Identity-Shifting
Attack (ISA). Surprisingly, we find that their attack mechanisms diverge
dramatically. Unlike ISA, EHA tends to aggressively target the harmful
recognition stage. While both EHA and ISA disrupt the latter two stages, the
extent and mechanisms of their attacks differ significantly. Our findings
underscore the importance of understanding LLMs' internal safeguarding process
and suggest that diverse defense mechanisms are required to effectively cope
with various types of attacks.
|
[
-0.3574783205986023,
-1.0243000984191895,
0.5259365439414978,
-0.27144184708595276,
-0.230347141623497,
0.20088273286819458,
0.18864431977272034,
-0.6986241936683655,
-0.14567634463310242,
0.6519044041633606,
-0.8208194375038147,
-0.16302372515201569,
-0.724389374256134,
0.18620720505714417,
-0.29028037190437317,
1.1432642936706543,
0.0727853775024414,
0.12063801288604736,
0.3711200952529907,
-0.007779648061841726,
-0.5784807205200195,
-0.4429570734500885,
-0.8706757426261902,
-0.3201385736465454,
0.7518712878227234,
0.02901705726981163,
0.6605908274650574,
0.5694792866706848,
0.7958024740219116,
0.2705681324005127,
-0.17316699028015137,
-0.1411188542842865,
-0.593860924243927,
0.26341742277145386,
-0.36486881971359253,
-0.5858283042907715,
-0.18131251633167267,
-0.20184208452701569,
0.4882126450538635,
0.3426680266857147,
0.1975492686033249,
0.03124408982694149,
0.2634948790073395,
0.57804274559021,
-0.6542289853096008,
-0.41593194007873535,
-1.1775089502334595,
-0.2625200152397156,
-0.6050873398780823,
-0.2374539077281952,
-0.4860285520553589,
-0.22249044477939606,
-0.07979411631822586,
-0.1574610024690628,
-0.09686043113470078,
-0.07954811304807663,
0.8820255994796753,
0.2514876425266266,
-0.5194613933563232,
-0.23935186862945557,
-0.4298573136329651,
0.8756116628646851,
-0.6306091547012329,
-0.10869141668081284,
0.14276742935180664,
0.08226246386766434,
-0.2745770514011383,
-0.37934377789497375,
-0.2219289243221283,
-0.09388606250286102,
-0.1180780902504921,
-0.31439274549484253,
-0.4473699629306793,
0.2856824994087219,
0.3859620690345764,
-0.05034417286515236,
-0.3529854714870453,
0.626935601234436,
-0.5778728127479553,
-0.3121541440486908,
0.6241887807846069,
0.29539060592651367,
0.4845373332500458,
-0.15985910594463348,
-0.6631486415863037,
-0.2921600639820099,
-1.1892882585525513,
0.035518284887075424,
0.6328830718994141,
0.36001887917518616,
-0.17185479402542114,
0.2769797742366791,
0.2006409466266632,
0.4705793559551239,
0.120267853140831,
-0.06302586942911148,
-0.27448469400405884,
-0.2135675847530365,
-0.33104243874549866,
0.27460893988609314,
0.7959859371185303,
0.5048096776008606,
0.297617107629776,
-0.2332354187965393,
-0.3669544458389282,
0.2192462831735611,
0.7330472469329834,
-0.6664817333221436,
-0.018759820610284805,
0.19084005057811737,
-0.42476320266723633,
-0.6585332751274109,
0.24137063324451447,
-0.5733247399330139,
-0.5161813497543335,
-0.12918365001678467,
0.4866775870323181,
-0.3981327414512634,
-0.15525367856025696,
-0.029779352247714996,
0.09990087151527405,
0.7490296363830566,
-0.06350398063659668,
-0.9249094128608704,
0.4558230936527252,
1.220174789428711,
0.6130093932151794,
-0.4174173176288605,
-0.16274873912334442,
-0.521285891532898,
0.2901729941368103,
-0.4779660701751709,
0.6728959083557129,
-0.6135416626930237,
-0.42572611570358276,
0.04829111695289612,
-0.06439477950334549,
-0.09413530677556992,
-0.5281251072883606,
0.7045772671699524,
-0.8024452328681946,
-0.2279268205165863,
-0.40157225728034973,
-0.42096149921417236,
-0.3292526304721832,
0.31896257400512695,
-0.7304314374923706,
0.6472275257110596,
-0.2934533357620239,
-1.01334547996521,
0.1743420511484146,
-0.5815513134002686,
-0.44793111085891724,
-0.30531319975852966,
-0.1320578157901764,
-0.49680399894714355,
0.3462134301662445,
-0.10177542269229889,
0.5330119729042053,
-0.20733454823493958,
-0.15521658957004547,
-0.659437894821167,
-0.2676757276058197,
0.5957199335098267,
-0.48803529143333435,
0.8968835473060608,
0.2764565050601959,
-0.31031379103660583,
0.17443130910396576,
-0.5793096423149109,
0.09940992295742035,
0.3012908399105072,
-0.05486493185162544,
-0.5472760200500488,
-0.06835523247718811,
-0.2837834358215332,
0.22908753156661987,
0.3174176514148712,
-0.5268245935440063,
0.13267257809638977,
-0.4747188687324524,
0.5183535814285278,
1.044622540473938,
0.40122535824775696,
0.3207303285598755,
-0.46529722213745117,
0.3468315899372101,
0.08277630060911179,
0.5371314883232117,
-0.1337500959634781,
-0.20058202743530273,
-0.5410968065261841,
0.12069279700517654,
-0.07669489830732346,
0.5503938794136047,
-0.24292530119419098,
0.06850859522819519,
-0.0023117796517908573,
-0.3790261149406433,
-0.5598189234733582,
0.08129458874464035,
0.9390401244163513,
-0.06087344139814377,
0.21983858942985535,
-0.42993417382240295,
-0.4373733401298523,
-1.0504859685897827,
-0.6595341563224792,
-0.28229331970214844,
0.2011093646287918,
-0.15052230656147003,
0.35980600118637085,
-0.1354764997959137,
0.5076146721839905,
-0.29438093304634094,
-0.06632433831691742,
0.14029163122177124,
-0.08578462153673172,
-0.004455776885151863,
0.577878475189209,
0.8237214684486389,
-0.5938374996185303,
-0.5301685333251953,
0.11407259851694107,
-0.6386654376983643,
-0.07699805498123169,
-0.10593318194150925,
-0.16048981249332428,
0.34692713618278503,
0.9500938653945923,
-0.39261993765830994,
0.25786566734313965,
0.34188970923423767,
-0.14731590449810028,
0.39771124720573425,
0.17432482540607452,
0.059357497841119766,
-1.0000015497207642,
-0.1587768793106079,
-0.3491070866584778,
0.07163865864276886,
-1.1193636655807495,
0.6832566261291504,
0.08413276076316833,
0.27439025044441223,
-0.7189688682556152,
0.3893711268901825,
-0.44950708746910095,
0.10114124417304993,
-0.24861636757850647,
-0.12976288795471191,
-0.14593148231506348,
0.3430730104446411,
-0.520531952381134,
0.5398349761962891,
0.8305302858352661,
-0.6972351670265198,
-0.09257712960243225,
-0.09175514429807663,
-0.1286037564277649,
0.763820230960846,
-0.7606947422027588,
0.6535778045654297,
0.010372644290328026,
-0.2786939740180969,
-1.021507740020752,
0.02151493914425373,
0.4552804231643677,
-0.2263057380914688,
0.6751646995544434,
-0.21440468728542328,
-0.37992578744888306,
-0.05141506344079971,
-0.5776154398918152,
0.2334647923707962,
0.3696603775024414,
-0.49974364042282104,
0.6340667009353638,
0.41047051548957825,
-0.2592546045780182,
-0.8573644757270813,
-0.6063192486763,
0.18538415431976318,
-0.6844387650489807,
-0.5203707814216614,
0.3404022455215454,
-0.09041332453489304,
-0.7696391940116882,
-0.2720654606819153,
-0.37093913555145264,
0.033418647944927216,
0.592863142490387,
0.517714262008667,
0.24858130514621735,
0.05071748420596123,
-0.2783445715904236,
0.09372936189174652,
-0.16536615788936615,
0.4270951449871063,
-0.15257267653942108,
0.43041104078292847,
0.16070586442947388,
-0.5684557557106018,
-0.7052421569824219,
0.5172529816627502,
0.6725510358810425,
-0.22411826252937317,
0.7086076736450195,
0.30394256114959717,
-0.3206952214241028,
0.06734809279441833,
-0.565497100353241,
-0.47231003642082214,
-0.515568196773529,
0.34773901104927063,
-0.6203793287277222,
-0.8141865134239197,
0.548915445804596,
0.1535862386226654,
0.5778636336326599,
0.34898966550827026,
0.4712972342967987,
-0.059189509600400925,
0.9442930817604065,
0.6145767569541931,
-0.2240677773952484,
0.31699880957603455,
0.17123070359230042,
0.2703627645969391,
-0.6924867033958435,
-0.19925259053707123,
-0.5970586538314819,
-0.36872807145118713,
-0.6496899724006653,
-0.04294570907950401,
0.22483213245868683,
0.15473471581935883,
-0.28949591517448425,
0.3579593598842621,
-0.4501743018627167,
0.748494029045105,
0.23119616508483887,
0.04822622984647751,
0.1928970068693161,
0.13708868622779846,
-0.1975790411233902,
0.016277750954031944,
-0.361319363117218,
-0.6827678084373474,
1.0964910984039307,
0.5445887446403503,
1.00668203830719,
0.3854580223560333,
0.9277663230895996,
0.10416081547737122,
0.2451259195804596,
-0.42066285014152527,
0.6773765087127686,
-0.14366070926189423,
-0.7146701216697693,
-0.068454809486866,
-0.21781446039676666,
-1.178122878074646,
0.22967246174812317,
-0.3228621184825897,
-0.8456532955169678,
-0.007854095660150051,
-0.041474442929029465,
-0.48990482091903687,
0.6055818200111389,
-0.7408997416496277,
0.6554891467094421,
-0.3701159656047821,
-0.29425522685050964,
-0.2975517809391022,
-0.8416162729263306,
0.46496638655662537,
-0.415483683347702,
0.10048417001962662,
0.0016767802881076932,
0.08490001410245895,
0.7180107235908508,
0.09976271539926529,
1.0889945030212402,
0.054115213453769684,
-0.5314018130302429,
0.13232813775539398,
0.5291751623153687,
0.5576050877571106,
-0.1448991745710373,
0.10347972810268402,
0.22164113819599152,
0.21200282871723175,
-0.2878059446811676,
-0.5103476643562317,
0.7819989323616028,
-0.6757922172546387,
-0.9555995464324951,
-0.32151105999946594,
-0.4072028696537018,
0.04759148880839348,
0.23081928491592407,
0.20365086197853088,
0.2518196403980255,
-0.41672182083129883,
0.042285602539777756,
0.9158620834350586,
-0.02310148999094963,
0.5870562791824341,
0.6361355185508728,
-0.00986461527645588,
-0.1559784710407257,
0.6234428286552429,
0.022095391526818275,
0.8271070718765259,
0.5197155475616455,
-0.017981790006160736,
-0.048959482461214066,
-0.8101810216903687,
0.01887781172990799,
0.2752745449542999,
-0.6365900039672852,
-0.355997234582901,
-0.5671175122261047,
-0.12450846284627914,
-0.3695286512374878,
-0.015358255244791508,
-0.14393579959869385,
-0.08028770983219147,
-0.1452735960483551,
-0.20098422467708588,
0.33295848965644836,
1.0302045345306396,
0.011318007484078407,
0.3445897102355957,
-0.720206081867218,
0.19535693526268005,
0.44791388511657715,
0.07448364049196243,
-0.005642248783260584,
-0.4381903409957886,
0.004753864835947752,
-0.06937063485383987,
-0.5032358765602112,
-1.1588494777679443,
-0.06249217689037323,
-0.023286214098334312,
0.4168873429298401,
0.7897045612335205,
0.0517033115029335,
0.38407662510871887,
-0.584644615650177,
0.5211876630783081,
0.22597816586494446,
-0.666839063167572,
0.3426150381565094,
-0.24478669464588165,
-0.013762968592345715,
0.6054744720458984,
0.3574090003967285,
-0.33276137709617615,
-0.37579604983329773,
-0.6202434301376343,
-0.5776249766349792,
0.5929797291755676,
0.07635947316884995,
0.21817269921302795,
0.014588013291358948,
0.47787633538246155,
0.1213419958949089,
-0.20323826372623444,
-0.809515655040741,
-0.35828226804733276,
0.22807106375694275,
0.1549818515777588,
0.2810435891151428,
-0.4028652608394623,
-0.7751638293266296,
0.3210656940937042,
0.5143062472343445,
0.03861425444483757,
0.02266824245452881,
-0.09932128340005875,
-0.01922016404569149,
-0.12215760350227356,
0.4822556674480438,
0.5742574334144592,
0.26141470670700073,
0.1124797984957695,
0.26651531457901,
0.329338401556015,
-0.42812296748161316,
0.2014467716217041,
-0.12651591002941132,
-0.2607881426811218,
-0.3599594831466675,
0.4518049657344818,
0.8432945013046265,
0.31249505281448364,
-0.3663228750228882,
0.27317896485328674,
-0.10467233508825302,
-0.1280495524406433,
-0.011197325773537159,
0.42651045322418213,
-0.2296740561723709,
0.31172993779182434,
0.1706896424293518,
0.10607883334159851,
-0.1191846951842308,
-0.7540634274482727,
0.2115124613046646,
0.8900758624076843,
-0.34370487928390503,
-0.4069269597530365,
0.5179817080497742,
-0.09099584817886353,
-0.5095843076705933,
0.14497224986553192,
-0.13246458768844604,
-0.5655947923660278,
0.5909132957458496,
0.45708927512168884,
1.0802173614501953,
-0.5541400909423828,
-0.04323608800768852,
0.15771280229091644,
0.7249227166175842,
0.1085662692785263,
0.034786298871040344,
0.1923043131828308,
-0.5877928733825684,
-0.19060568511486053,
-0.5091991424560547,
-0.22086358070373535,
0.13544735312461853,
-0.9289961457252502,
0.09861086308956146,
-0.7983251214027405,
-0.10876190662384033,
0.02344522625207901,
-0.14354881644248962,
-0.4137880206108093,
-0.058536939322948456,
0.29249072074890137,
0.6329310536384583,
-0.8464710116386414,
0.5457585453987122,
0.5203685760498047,
-0.14820760488510132,
-0.7823033332824707,
0.25533413887023926,
0.36324217915534973,
-0.853663980960846,
0.5155361294746399,
0.20062613487243652,
-0.16937574744224548,
-0.20678527653217316,
-0.5357235670089722,
-0.8183414936065674,
0.6978549361228943,
0.49383071064949036,
-0.8389718532562256,
-0.1295667141675949,
0.2012484073638916,
0.22695162892341614,
-0.12334679812192917,
-0.14051789045333862,
0.9515935182571411,
0.47437992691993713,
-0.3227593004703522,
-0.9045723080635071,
0.3116092383861542,
0.09558770060539246,
-0.09330286830663681,
0.5201265215873718,
-0.49509915709495544,
0.7326506972312927,
-0.37446779012680054,
-0.5482837557792664,
0.1995510756969452,
0.38155797123908997,
0.2597696781158447,
0.13192006945610046,
0.5184595584869385,
0.7619110941886902,
0.5418689250946045,
-0.10635410994291306,
1.0339611768722534,
-0.38365936279296875,
-0.03719453886151314,
0.869622528553009,
-0.23765544593334198,
0.8484858274459839,
0.5974578857421875,
-0.20724228024482727,
0.3490580916404724,
0.5511070489883423,
0.03188667818903923,
0.5594924688339233,
0.1877126693725586,
-0.17879919707775116,
-0.11819985508918762,
0.11061394214630127,
-0.36298248171806335,
0.35556572675704956,
0.2989215552806854,
-0.1338111311197281,
-0.29224884510040283,
-0.024864627048373222,
0.38109034299850464,
0.029339436441659927,
-0.45280155539512634,
1.0512245893478394,
0.30593234300613403,
-0.7065989375114441,
0.6936784386634827,
0.04846770688891411,
0.7115150094032288,
-0.8186873197555542,
0.23170064389705658,
0.05542036145925522,
0.03470189496874809,
-0.23102279007434845,
-0.8751389384269714,
0.2743934690952301,
-0.008122324012219906,
-0.16839037835597992,
-0.053436074405908585,
0.702154278755188,
-0.19415335357189178,
-0.08781605213880539,
0.548102080821991,
0.06875208020210266,
0.017153985798358917,
0.043963003903627396,
-0.8491501808166504,
0.44483914971351624,
0.09942791610956192,
-0.004319998435676098,
0.6601477861404419,
0.2952531576156616,
-0.19861523807048798,
0.5371977090835571,
0.5761569142341614,
0.020925572142004967,
0.36513060331344604,
0.19312691688537598,
0.7154539823532104,
-0.4877227246761322,
-0.337054044008255,
-1.255190372467041,
0.27483490109443665,
0.0000841485962155275,
-0.07690080255270004,
0.811542272567749,
0.16914822161197662,
0.9276528358459473,
0.06374780833721161,
0.5397324562072754,
0.31818851828575134,
0.2583555579185486,
-0.8339310884475708,
0.684083878993988,
-0.30872437357902527,
0.39935213327407837,
-0.4775691628456116,
-1.0516316890716553,
-0.34367507696151733,
0.20209822058677673,
-0.05310945585370064,
-0.04452158510684967,
0.8820383548736572,
1.2160165309906006,
0.13500794768333435,
-0.05697161331772804,
0.24102307856082916,
0.5208309888839722,
0.4972493052482605,
0.6448724865913391,
0.8688372373580933,
-0.42643046379089355,
0.5738967061042786,
0.05083691328763962,
0.04500005394220352,
-0.06466846913099289,
-0.8005653023719788,
-1.1324877738952637,
-0.42226818203926086,
-0.3941073715686798,
-0.3197048306465149,
0.2942204177379608,
0.5782326459884644,
0.592066764831543,
-0.7420923113822937,
0.00971879344433546,
0.07254151999950409,
0.11555694788694382,
-0.25033703446388245,
-0.1341300904750824,
0.191036656498909,
-0.26731371879577637,
-0.46240806579589844,
0.4006863832473755,
0.39712122082710266,
0.17415887117385864,
-0.4006265699863434,
0.08523987978696823,
-0.016363250091671944,
0.3186192810535431,
0.32076263427734375,
0.4595150947570801,
-0.9098154306411743,
-0.4698009490966797,
-0.21627463400363922,
-0.3027726113796234,
-0.020958416163921356,
0.8700796365737915,
-0.2622787356376648,
0.1910826414823532,
0.3718053102493286,
0.7784356474876404,
-0.10845893621444702,
-0.2599266469478607,
0.3536718487739563,
-0.6929170489311218,
-0.08882227540016174,
-0.0036214757710695267,
0.265848308801651,
0.3181339502334595,
-0.4514717757701874,
0.33774039149284363,
-0.09934211522340775,
-0.5366272330284119,
-1.0453786849975586,
0.7153387665748596,
-0.868743896484375,
-0.5627946853637695,
1.0197887420654297,
0.09939610213041306,
-0.2778344452381134,
-0.08809290081262589,
-0.29694992303848267,
0.05706463009119034,
-0.07666827738285065,
0.8600665926933289,
0.6057698726654053,
0.06759298592805862,
0.06973686069250107,
-0.3703380525112152,
0.6780223846435547,
0.42917028069496155,
-0.6590580344200134,
0.18345622718334198,
0.10281854122877121,
0.44629940390586853,
0.2985839247703552,
0.08087769150733948,
-0.441611647605896,
0.23517432808876038,
-0.21603909134864807,
-0.3634444773197174,
0.07955334335565567,
-0.4405101537704468,
-0.6552907824516296,
0.3289378583431244,
0.21121267974376678,
-0.17181721329689026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12881v1
|
Towards Unlocking Insights from Logbooks Using AI
| 2024-05-25T13:38:15 | 2024-05-25T13:38:15 |
Antonin Sulc, Alex Bien, Annika Eichler, Daniel Ratner, Florian Rehm, Frank Mayet, Gregor Hartmann, Hayden Hoschouer, Henrik Tuennermann, Jan Kaiser, Jason St. John, Jennefer Maldonado, Kyle Hazelwood, Raimund Kammering, Thorsten Hellert, Tim Wilksen, Verena Kain, Wan-Lin Hu
|
physics.acc-ph
|
physics.acc-ph, cs.CL
|
Electronic logbooks contain valuable information about activities and events
concerning their associated particle accelerator facilities. However, the
highly technical nature of logbook entries can hinder their usability and
automation. As natural language processing (NLP) continues advancing, it offers
opportunities to address various challenges that logbooks present. This work
explores jointly testing a tailored Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) model
for enhancing the usability of particle accelerator logbooks at institutes like
DESY, BESSY, Fermilab, BNL, SLAC, LBNL, and CERN. The RAG model uses a corpus
built on logbook contributions and aims to unlock insights from these logbooks
by leveraging retrieval over facility datasets, including discussion about
potential multimodal sources. Our goals are to increase the FAIR-ness
(findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reusability) of logbooks by
exploiting their information content to streamline everyday use, enable
macro-analysis for root cause analysis, and facilitate problem-solving
automation.
|
[
-0.22156426310539246,
-0.7573699355125427,
0.34100455045700073,
-0.31171032786369324,
-0.115577332675457,
0.305480033159256,
0.23461668193340302,
-0.7473755478858948,
-0.010628589428961277,
0.4695762097835541,
-0.4827815592288971,
-0.11213847994804382,
-0.4111260175704956,
0.3072713613510132,
-0.3927094042301178,
1.2257423400878906,
0.24913911521434784,
-0.17826911807060242,
-0.5214883089065552,
-0.08875875920057297,
-0.6276798844337463,
-0.6702301502227783,
-0.8214532136917114,
-0.39006781578063965,
0.22791750729084015,
0.10711155086755753,
0.8256837129592896,
0.19094327092170715,
0.6926223039627075,
0.3151111602783203,
-0.11961545795202255,
0.4285299479961395,
-0.10158033668994904,
-0.03399180248379707,
-0.203174889087677,
-0.35352829098701477,
-0.735225260257721,
-0.37786316871643066,
0.6955376863479614,
0.48847657442092896,
-0.23112796247005463,
0.2911628186702728,
0.15176813304424286,
0.7085216045379639,
-0.7109808921813965,
0.1422528624534607,
-0.6730287075042725,
0.09076951444149017,
-0.24390871822834015,
-0.2612430155277252,
-0.7497411370277405,
0.03692181780934334,
-0.15922386944293976,
-0.6344025135040283,
0.691548228263855,
0.26032280921936035,
0.948745608329773,
0.2639193832874298,
-0.3635614216327667,
-0.4941859543323517,
-0.7224164605140686,
0.8753128051757812,
-0.5023696422576904,
0.5740165114402771,
0.602775514125824,
0.3885347247123718,
-0.31577184796333313,
-0.8411242365837097,
-0.4206489622592926,
-0.15221025049686432,
-0.7138490080833435,
-0.15449196100234985,
-0.23860540986061096,
-0.1204250156879425,
0.1291876584291458,
0.24264585971832275,
-0.6131608486175537,
-0.17220014333724976,
-0.19132164120674133,
-0.13065481185913086,
0.7371310591697693,
0.25605472922325134,
0.48338615894317627,
-0.26812005043029785,
-0.01188694778829813,
-0.46391090750694275,
0.011259120889008045,
0.15086184442043304,
0.07928408682346344,
0.40002235770225525,
0.24587707221508026,
0.46218642592430115,
-0.13943517208099365,
0.768714427947998,
-0.19629620015621185,
-0.1654115617275238,
0.4739081561565399,
-0.6919684410095215,
-0.26094892621040344,
0.05986654385924339,
0.31215545535087585,
0.07602981477975845,
-0.2602599561214447,
-0.1189793199300766,
-0.4522511661052704,
-0.3524644076824188,
0.5163733959197998,
-0.6810348629951477,
-0.019905945286154747,
0.1377187818288803,
-0.4698319733142853,
-0.30852583050727844,
0.025406289845705032,
-1.0782274007797241,
-0.5738973021507263,
-0.22015544772148132,
0.4567028284072876,
-0.3502727150917053,
-0.1759343147277832,
-0.13377249240875244,
-0.5277888178825378,
0.3375176787376404,
0.3037632405757904,
-1.1256524324417114,
0.2763199806213379,
0.8082261085510254,
0.697983980178833,
0.170700803399086,
-0.019672516733407974,
-0.9811170101165771,
0.24647843837738037,
-0.03732983395457268,
0.7348015904426575,
-0.7110922932624817,
-0.6129453182220459,
-0.05614342913031578,
-0.12771740555763245,
-0.19788463413715363,
-0.5495736002922058,
0.6420943737030029,
-0.6552609801292419,
0.007885384373366833,
0.33220845460891724,
-0.5172569155693054,
-0.033329591155052185,
0.3063853085041046,
-0.7367770671844482,
0.9872546792030334,
0.09658165276050568,
-0.5630043148994446,
0.32152095437049866,
-0.5954399108886719,
-0.2696550786495209,
0.26097938418388367,
-0.5356903076171875,
-0.6366545557975769,
0.26827943325042725,
0.33249571919441223,
0.18393678963184357,
-0.22208565473556519,
0.5823367834091187,
0.07974714040756226,
-0.007252177223563194,
0.23971185088157654,
-0.49850696325302124,
0.7687755823135376,
0.2678680717945099,
-0.04009845852851868,
-0.1571953147649765,
-0.9506347179412842,
-0.1509995460510254,
0.160241961479187,
-0.2465135008096695,
-0.46658188104629517,
-0.07342406362295151,
0.02889304608106613,
-0.27006396651268005,
0.46988826990127563,
-0.4893247187137604,
0.18101222813129425,
-0.24317587912082672,
-0.3711007535457611,
0.6542662978172302,
-0.0867396667599678,
0.21567562222480774,
-0.38700032234191895,
0.7196342349052429,
-0.2583467960357666,
0.3005227744579315,
-0.4148515462875366,
-0.6922070384025574,
-0.29447492957115173,
-0.2888616621494293,
0.21675212681293488,
0.4959457218647003,
-0.5531378388404846,
0.04260185733437538,
0.1207861378788948,
-0.3250660300254822,
-0.5611377358436584,
0.3539644181728363,
0.5610669255256653,
0.8672114610671997,
0.3477991223335266,
-0.4495355486869812,
-0.295147567987442,
-0.8185904026031494,
-0.5854743719100952,
-0.10325584560632706,
-0.29263007640838623,
0.7353401184082031,
0.2578284740447998,
-0.4708549380302429,
0.7683618068695068,
-0.4731287658214569,
-0.2082480639219284,
-0.2509922385215759,
0.2555573880672455,
0.5324611067771912,
0.3514277935028076,
0.26651644706726074,
-1.3216743469238281,
-0.37794584035873413,
0.363477498292923,
-0.7687656879425049,
0.08677130192518234,
-0.21123568713665009,
-0.06685822457075119,
0.4773895740509033,
0.4396345317363739,
-0.4483143091201782,
0.993966281414032,
0.3720945119857788,
-0.9003853797912598,
0.3886612057685852,
-0.4092361629009247,
0.35344281792640686,
-0.7609740495681763,
0.4079839289188385,
-0.4006464183330536,
-0.29896894097328186,
-0.6245141625404358,
0.16425977647304535,
0.11373260617256165,
-0.33383604884147644,
-0.19648921489715576,
0.8248282074928284,
-0.19216372072696686,
-0.439489483833313,
-0.24359498918056488,
0.244877427816391,
0.5379668474197388,
0.1249479427933693,
-0.23479987680912018,
0.6892348527908325,
0.14762566983699799,
-0.6879841685295105,
0.2050074338912964,
0.6416445970535278,
-0.18368281424045563,
0.36185720562934875,
-0.3848140835762024,
0.23805323243141174,
-0.2690107822418213,
0.2537527084350586,
-0.6020333170890808,
-0.4136873483657837,
-0.10237622261047363,
-0.6199538111686707,
0.5131921768188477,
0.022722065448760986,
-0.7076041102409363,
0.07126674801111221,
-0.05771033093333244,
0.6299301981925964,
0.5629355907440186,
-0.8409377336502075,
1.1159675121307373,
0.5456140637397766,
-0.13226041197776794,
-0.7286679148674011,
-0.18029934167861938,
-0.018721889704465866,
0.05075233429670334,
-0.6118245124816895,
0.3829556107521057,
-0.10742772370576859,
-0.459686815738678,
0.15445072948932648,
0.03802706301212311,
-0.19884075224399567,
0.36033496260643005,
0.08012650907039642,
0.6165897846221924,
0.02239389345049858,
0.48492372035980225,
-0.1079365611076355,
-0.1659320592880249,
-0.18623997271060944,
-0.0893121063709259,
0.44682586193084717,
-0.2907721698284149,
-0.25045666098594666,
-0.3842918872833252,
0.31956303119659424,
-0.0195827167481184,
-0.48255184292793274,
0.8931523561477661,
0.8045132756233215,
-0.5241714715957642,
-0.025317300111055374,
-0.2895360589027405,
-0.1529608964920044,
-0.5539081692695618,
0.27694305777549744,
-0.22430165112018585,
-0.6815949082374573,
0.21084672212600708,
-0.06161683425307274,
0.4269670248031616,
0.4328307807445526,
0.5101737976074219,
0.12055984884500504,
0.9581328630447388,
0.7563461661338806,
0.16409733891487122,
0.4200834333896637,
-0.016143545508384705,
0.3242112696170807,
-0.7401137948036194,
-0.5887234210968018,
-0.8976754546165466,
-0.07668796926736832,
-0.4538136124610901,
-0.33110862970352173,
0.43809622526168823,
0.2809509038925171,
0.27920424938201904,
0.05853495001792908,
-0.42149120569229126,
0.6781838536262512,
0.5021042227745056,
-0.12220440059900284,
0.6699362397193909,
-0.16569283604621887,
0.028104767203330994,
0.27891016006469727,
-0.6397267580032349,
-0.5371426343917847,
0.9320929050445557,
0.10721319168806076,
0.3899608552455902,
0.25872671604156494,
0.8181842565536499,
0.44134432077407837,
0.3166978359222412,
-0.44720324873924255,
0.3385753929615021,
-0.38335341215133667,
-0.9380894303321838,
-0.4273124635219574,
-0.4000874161720276,
-1.2423678636550903,
0.09279222786426544,
-0.09092991799116135,
-0.9327239394187927,
-0.024180389940738678,
0.34538501501083374,
-0.30288997292518616,
0.2975793778896332,
-0.5215629935264587,
0.938641369342804,
-0.09456804394721985,
-0.16204707324504852,
-0.47024214267730713,
-0.4920656979084015,
0.18541274964809418,
-0.36961036920547485,
0.7951804399490356,
-0.024821687489748,
0.30073806643486023,
0.6951189637184143,
-0.22751423716545105,
0.5857264995574951,
-0.01334208995103836,
0.025394948199391365,
0.4506422281265259,
0.09318165481090546,
0.3977290689945221,
0.39122775197029114,
-0.3193264305591583,
-0.004499503877013922,
0.06841260939836502,
-0.32683315873146057,
-0.7486739158630371,
0.5513193607330322,
-0.5984315276145935,
-0.5785580277442932,
-0.3623078167438507,
-0.6892388463020325,
-0.254812091588974,
0.27366700768470764,
-0.31022489070892334,
0.8548089265823364,
-0.10837357491254807,
0.1474177986383438,
0.5274021625518799,
-0.4728018045425415,
0.41791412234306335,
0.35151755809783936,
-0.5318573713302612,
0.005779326427727938,
0.9038475751876831,
-0.40598559379577637,
0.13644498586654663,
0.5749337673187256,
0.3422452211380005,
-0.19269885122776031,
-0.16265849769115448,
-0.49201780557632446,
0.07178172469139099,
-0.6870819926261902,
-0.43174099922180176,
-0.5062648057937622,
-0.12578143179416656,
-0.7228005528450012,
-0.24906693398952484,
-0.2497849315404892,
-0.7050063610076904,
-0.44265007972717285,
-0.15276184678077698,
0.3740401566028595,
0.7858880162239075,
-0.2724023461341858,
0.034093525260686874,
-1.24693763256073,
0.5405893921852112,
0.3255757987499237,
0.28099551796913147,
0.011973338201642036,
-0.6257321238517761,
-0.4344709515571594,
-0.29930779337882996,
-0.5543562173843384,
-0.4929969608783722,
0.665649950504303,
0.38297486305236816,
0.4620835483074188,
-0.00652408879250288,
-0.049918193370103836,
0.39309385418891907,
-0.6895732879638672,
0.6483269333839417,
-0.1071220114827156,
-0.7456440925598145,
0.7605608701705933,
-0.15040236711502075,
0.08562733232975006,
0.5819531083106995,
0.34011098742485046,
-0.24529841542243958,
-0.47967779636383057,
-1.0401607751846313,
-0.9767009615898132,
0.6954447627067566,
0.20730899274349213,
0.10184206813573837,
0.16967198252677917,
0.5086309313774109,
0.22165338695049286,
0.13540767133235931,
-0.31064772605895996,
-0.16502057015895844,
-0.1768827736377716,
-0.32830995321273804,
-0.2662089765071869,
0.06671521067619324,
-0.11834176629781723,
0.105344258248806,
0.860177755355835,
-0.028870657086372375,
-0.0324721559882164,
0.18436317145824432,
0.11630798876285553,
-0.07012669742107391,
0.20394571125507355,
0.2197170853614807,
0.7290953993797302,
-0.47219565510749817,
-0.004621218424290419,
0.09530520439147949,
-0.49853023886680603,
-0.17762750387191772,
0.2698744535446167,
-0.09202442318201065,
0.40702760219573975,
0.394756942987442,
0.6617581248283386,
0.013130332343280315,
-1.1102042198181152,
0.11722863465547562,
-0.5263934135437012,
0.2433680146932602,
-0.37999752163887024,
0.19834110140800476,
-0.16933487355709076,
0.321879506111145,
0.4893299341201782,
-0.10699545592069626,
0.424223393201828,
-0.6171605587005615,
0.6785596013069153,
0.5960277915000916,
-0.01590508222579956,
-0.07641663402318954,
0.6073620915412903,
0.17138716578483582,
-0.9093636274337769,
0.861008882522583,
-0.39157626032829285,
-0.13896848261356354,
0.6922187209129333,
0.6049121022224426,
0.7312158942222595,
-0.1102011576294899,
0.3071666955947876,
0.5218288898468018,
0.15977613627910614,
0.4306749403476715,
-0.1488032042980194,
-0.008082527667284012,
-0.6691308617591858,
-0.3011445701122284,
-0.9522795081138611,
-0.5935264825820923,
-0.015752116218209267,
-0.9638969898223877,
0.309367299079895,
-0.3600757122039795,
-0.09012109786272049,
0.05315295234322548,
-0.0034175703767687082,
-0.8753489255905151,
0.23558998107910156,
0.1521475613117218,
0.6466650366783142,
-0.5176621675491333,
0.6462209224700928,
0.5101839900016785,
-0.15585441887378693,
-0.7147098183631897,
-0.19622519612312317,
-0.09047245979309082,
-0.8678122758865356,
0.8486793041229248,
0.23262931406497955,
0.06903634965419769,
-0.09718621522188187,
-0.22620226442813873,
-0.8068748116493225,
1.1959573030471802,
0.021152900531888008,
-0.593908429145813,
0.02889711782336235,
0.011351032182574272,
0.43519866466522217,
-0.030789034441113472,
0.19680233299732208,
0.7693361639976501,
0.2853226363658905,
-0.1308751404285431,
-1.033506989479065,
-0.11294946819543839,
-0.3092007339000702,
-0.2817398011684418,
0.5104644894599915,
-0.4189119040966034,
0.610388457775116,
-0.14107131958007812,
0.03248179703950882,
-0.18783248960971832,
0.637789785861969,
0.5844777822494507,
0.9890235662460327,
0.5244694352149963,
0.5205277800559998,
1.1472364664077759,
0.5577221512794495,
1.49154531955719,
-0.008272815495729446,
0.40777385234832764,
1.060518741607666,
-0.037462376058101654,
0.7370060682296753,
0.5819724202156067,
-0.09452091157436371,
0.5813801884651184,
-0.027395548298954964,
0.12617993354797363,
0.3835393786430359,
-0.042472321540117264,
-0.6002686619758606,
-0.1355707347393036,
-0.603271484375,
-0.1029563844203949,
0.2799642086029053,
0.5054225921630859,
-0.09402308613061905,
-0.23973111808300018,
-0.030001940205693245,
-0.23931090533733368,
0.12803684175014496,
-0.3192291557788849,
0.7756099104881287,
0.1641126275062561,
-0.42764052748680115,
0.26543375849723816,
0.1439073085784912,
0.12703262269496918,
-0.42759203910827637,
-0.3308004140853882,
-0.33734366297721863,
0.21698789298534393,
-0.1795577108860016,
-0.41167470812797546,
0.5908253192901611,
0.35943713784217834,
-0.056869905441999435,
-0.15948179364204407,
0.9981101155281067,
0.11873277276754379,
-0.835739016532898,
0.16313914954662323,
0.2863359749317169,
0.142701655626297,
0.39350101351737976,
-0.5258402824401855,
0.11967907100915909,
0.11723299324512482,
-0.24803823232650757,
0.7314714789390564,
0.5188712477684021,
0.09121742844581604,
0.6290280818939209,
0.5510557889938354,
-0.2920195162296295,
0.0023559730034321547,
0.09658144414424896,
0.7551642060279846,
-0.6199641823768616,
-0.18604138493537903,
-0.7717875838279724,
0.6352756023406982,
-0.12362854927778244,
-0.28133729100227356,
0.5575109124183655,
0.4344271421432495,
0.9599789381027222,
0.12079578638076782,
0.624291718006134,
-0.16007556021213531,
0.5180370807647705,
-0.6112933158874512,
0.4988096356391907,
-0.7406749129295349,
0.2497939169406891,
-0.16695529222488403,
-0.38404005765914917,
-0.32790908217430115,
0.5694870352745056,
0.21650205552577972,
-0.18007272481918335,
0.43281662464141846,
0.602199912071228,
-0.011550771072506905,
0.14649075269699097,
0.3998819887638092,
-0.05551523342728615,
0.7304880619049072,
0.40688642859458923,
0.5098471641540527,
-0.4907362461090088,
0.6322452425956726,
-0.36091387271881104,
-0.45937129855155945,
-0.26847463846206665,
-0.955585241317749,
-0.9386357665061951,
-0.5593265891075134,
-0.3732409179210663,
-0.22511203587055206,
0.056957703083753586,
0.6492518186569214,
0.08176050335168839,
-0.7146286368370056,
-0.1781558096408844,
-0.11031712591648102,
0.20845991373062134,
0.1613621860742569,
-0.2820734679698944,
0.46862658858299255,
-0.8231568336486816,
-0.6624619960784912,
0.6062812209129333,
-0.01999089866876602,
-0.17086714506149292,
0.048351019620895386,
-0.016634156927466393,
-0.07733739167451859,
0.02366989105939865,
0.3915477693080902,
0.3671872615814209,
-0.17572438716888428,
-0.1944277584552765,
-0.04489285126328468,
0.2175743132829666,
-0.25209879875183105,
0.7836148142814636,
-1.047832727432251,
0.5926038026809692,
0.3732328712940216,
1.3188894987106323,
0.4062824547290802,
0.11142197996377945,
0.4752700924873352,
-1.0362592935562134,
0.19027179479599,
0.5002303719520569,
0.23653024435043335,
0.2894723415374756,
-0.6005527973175049,
0.6048833131790161,
0.07288245856761932,
-0.9119009375572205,
-1.0771533250808716,
0.16951560974121094,
-0.6400931477546692,
-0.3978712260723114,
0.7572508454322815,
-0.037515465170145035,
-0.18117088079452515,
-0.04054272174835205,
-0.14148621261119843,
0.3600427806377411,
-0.33061912655830383,
0.9614190459251404,
0.4964958429336548,
-0.5835775136947632,
0.1160617545247078,
-0.8783103823661804,
0.6231468319892883,
0.581786036491394,
-0.9189791679382324,
0.05132284387946129,
0.38301894068717957,
-0.24740993976593018,
0.5763781070709229,
0.7288733720779419,
-0.13159117102622986,
0.28344404697418213,
-0.128870889544487,
-0.06887964904308319,
-0.023145437240600586,
-0.60920649766922,
-0.4569292366504669,
-0.08750840276479721,
0.18949778378009796,
0.04209096357226372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16205v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16205v1
|
GeneAgent: Self-verification Language Agent for Gene Set Knowledge Discovery using Domain Databases
| 2024-05-25T12:35:15 | 2024-05-25T12:35:15 |
Zhizheng Wang, Qiao Jin, Chih-Hsuan Wei, Shubo Tian, Po-Ting Lai, Qingqing Zhu, Chi-Ping Day, Christina Ross, Zhiyong Lu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Gene set knowledge discovery is essential for advancing human functional
genomics. Recent studies have shown promising performance by harnessing the
power of Large Language Models (LLMs) on this task. Nonetheless, their results
are subject to several limitations common in LLMs such as hallucinations. In
response, we present GeneAgent, a first-of-its-kind language agent featuring
self-verification capability. It autonomously interacts with various biological
databases and leverages relevant domain knowledge to improve accuracy and
reduce hallucination occurrences. Benchmarking on 1,106 gene sets from
different sources, GeneAgent consistently outperforms standard GPT-4 by a
significant margin. Moreover, a detailed manual review confirms the
effectiveness of the self-verification module in minimizing hallucinations and
generating more reliable analytical narratives. To demonstrate its practical
utility, we apply GeneAgent to seven novel gene sets derived from mouse B2905
melanoma cell lines, with expert evaluations showing that GeneAgent offers
novel insights into gene functions and subsequently expedites knowledge
discovery.
|
[
-0.4373648464679718,
-0.5347340703010559,
0.5513676404953003,
0.0701165422797203,
-0.045424602925777435,
0.3746170103549957,
-0.15393203496932983,
-0.4751451909542084,
0.37811827659606934,
0.693328857421875,
-0.4317138195037842,
-0.5185270309448242,
-0.4758245050907135,
0.43779247999191284,
-0.5473299026489258,
0.5568676590919495,
0.1257759928703308,
-0.030189044773578644,
-0.3787049949169159,
-0.16322073340415955,
-0.16522841155529022,
-0.5761117339134216,
-0.40199965238571167,
-0.5292722582817078,
0.6308504939079285,
0.2734617590904236,
0.627265214920044,
0.65758216381073,
0.5770167112350464,
0.40035659074783325,
0.37623581290245056,
0.3852904140949249,
-0.3609884977340698,
0.21776005625724792,
-0.35551634430885315,
-0.3907458782196045,
-0.3088914453983307,
-0.13288907706737518,
0.20656414330005646,
0.555098295211792,
-0.021493244916200638,
-0.06842843443155289,
-0.10935068875551224,
0.5890703797340393,
-0.36732980608940125,
0.07689045369625092,
-0.5877372026443481,
0.2834337651729584,
-0.21164773404598236,
-0.36170801520347595,
-0.06589411199092865,
-0.5193522572517395,
0.19233302772045135,
-0.4616374969482422,
0.524963915348053,
-0.09730144590139389,
0.634800374507904,
0.5235593318939209,
-0.34132298827171326,
-0.07917682826519012,
-0.7438228130340576,
0.3269541561603546,
-0.4671568274497986,
0.07425931841135025,
0.43370962142944336,
0.4765651226043701,
-0.43752676248550415,
-0.6959126591682434,
-0.6670176982879639,
-0.6721005439758301,
-0.2282722443342209,
-0.17068691551685333,
-0.03565090894699097,
0.005165671929717064,
0.25292259454727173,
0.3323008120059967,
-0.8110575079917908,
-0.14587824046611786,
-0.3757660686969757,
-0.5333089828491211,
0.43789955973625183,
-0.1685631275177002,
0.49359598755836487,
-0.2202371507883072,
-0.25881466269493103,
-0.10342495888471603,
-0.44518420100212097,
-0.37538716197013855,
0.1496628224849701,
-0.051386889070272446,
0.5343238115310669,
0.6502753496170044,
-0.10806266963481903,
0.3653047978878021,
-0.12391845136880875,
0.18423689901828766,
0.339476078748703,
0.044906966388225555,
0.021997569128870964,
0.28872838616371155,
0.8122134208679199,
0.01015674788504839,
0.17119775712490082,
-0.26767510175704956,
-0.1713263839483261,
0.1678548902273178,
0.4034775197505951,
-0.7321661114692688,
-0.6750749349594116,
0.37677183747291565,
-0.2677673101425171,
-0.3455794155597687,
0.012692321091890335,
-0.9821078777313232,
-0.8741501569747925,
0.10294204205274582,
0.6914467811584473,
-0.7475722432136536,
-0.2928335666656494,
0.06819497048854828,
-0.17120279371738434,
0.2708157002925873,
0.13931499421596527,
-0.5295004844665527,
0.05946528539061546,
0.4908550977706909,
0.7362691164016724,
-0.3449176549911499,
-0.4250759482383728,
-0.4806501865386963,
0.18236581981182098,
-0.3069297969341278,
0.893052339553833,
-0.3610706031322479,
-0.44243741035461426,
-0.35916855931282043,
0.22791346907615662,
-0.03714407980442047,
-0.647020697593689,
0.19845861196517944,
-0.2738228440284729,
-0.21672271192073822,
-0.3672381043434143,
-0.7762323021888733,
-0.17633569240570068,
0.028527691960334778,
-0.6651427745819092,
0.8375352621078491,
0.15777133405208588,
-0.4271899461746216,
0.24078109860420227,
-0.6861836314201355,
-0.6608541011810303,
0.6230645179748535,
-0.6328518986701965,
-0.34528037905693054,
-0.16578537225723267,
0.027541857212781906,
0.5431612730026245,
0.07825148105621338,
0.08765911310911179,
-0.21792683005332947,
-0.13101232051849365,
0.5162972807884216,
-0.09754648059606552,
0.4614947736263275,
0.12417123466730118,
-0.7563719153404236,
0.03740588575601578,
-0.8828330636024475,
-0.13485755026340485,
0.3824843764305115,
0.11013346910476685,
-0.3306046426296234,
-0.03472889959812164,
-0.5620626211166382,
0.02571650967001915,
0.27674251794815063,
-0.6766980290412903,
0.2921365201473236,
-0.33144086599349976,
0.10719352215528488,
0.7166844606399536,
-0.011074787937104702,
-0.031104017049074173,
-0.3039152920246124,
0.5919530391693115,
-0.07260412722826004,
0.0065973359160125256,
0.005279214587062597,
-0.569256067276001,
-0.6598544716835022,
-0.06514418125152588,
0.09743806719779968,
0.6015450358390808,
-0.8784041404724121,
0.7079377770423889,
-0.09835716336965561,
-0.49783673882484436,
-0.31661808490753174,
0.14514602720737457,
0.24888700246810913,
0.42917028069496155,
0.5383562445640564,
-0.15073110163211823,
-0.4594724476337433,
-0.8407912254333496,
-0.06429488956928253,
-0.033370524644851685,
-0.1325182318687439,
0.28384295105934143,
0.5807037949562073,
-0.6776313185691833,
0.9344660639762878,
-0.4673108160495758,
-0.5199154615402222,
-0.2797878086566925,
0.2242465615272522,
-0.08257120847702026,
0.5962550044059753,
0.4409843683242798,
-0.466220498085022,
-0.07872296124696732,
0.4550389349460602,
-0.942156970500946,
-0.2763293981552124,
-0.014560313895344734,
-0.20079462230205536,
0.19703400135040283,
0.5304262042045593,
-0.4037964344024658,
0.3840911388397217,
0.6624364256858826,
-0.4333653151988983,
0.3964511454105377,
-0.41791319847106934,
0.3979925513267517,
-0.8293030858039856,
0.29727503657341003,
-0.1745297759771347,
-0.3965958058834076,
-0.6630948185920715,
-0.20274394750595093,
-0.012116022408008575,
0.19050057232379913,
0.08724108338356018,
0.42357563972473145,
-0.30656856298446655,
-0.22522933781147003,
-0.44521790742874146,
0.2176457643508911,
-0.0686081275343895,
0.31226831674575806,
-0.14712150394916534,
0.97840416431427,
0.4507933557033539,
-0.5410533547401428,
0.47062888741493225,
0.48525387048721313,
-0.21889036893844604,
0.26540136337280273,
-0.47796830534935,
0.29560524225234985,
-0.16557514667510986,
0.04415300115942955,
-0.7002900242805481,
-0.2218121886253357,
0.36731845140457153,
-0.4847687780857086,
0.2312881052494049,
-0.08780352771282196,
-0.352855384349823,
-0.3824719190597534,
0.02712436020374298,
-0.004363108891993761,
0.5117036700248718,
-0.7142683863639832,
0.8312502503395081,
0.46114814281463623,
0.007771783508360386,
-0.507820188999176,
-0.7460585236549377,
0.2161591798067093,
0.13105541467666626,
-0.5152258276939392,
0.2267245650291443,
-0.21783466637134552,
-0.10511629283428192,
-0.06406783312559128,
-0.36261799931526184,
-0.009652289561927319,
-0.10471851378679276,
0.23409785330295563,
0.09873045235872269,
-0.11001643538475037,
0.3816300928592682,
-0.015457291156053543,
-0.11569917947053909,
0.09423579275608063,
-0.4213167726993561,
0.300311803817749,
-0.17567075788974762,
-0.32838621735572815,
0.2526582181453705,
0.2869439721107483,
0.4643974006175995,
-0.395635187625885,
0.4767354428768158,
0.6564292311668396,
-0.4230242371559143,
-0.4525575339794159,
-0.6690564155578613,
-0.34559255838394165,
-0.4882522225379944,
0.32378631830215454,
-0.47383731603622437,
-0.950289249420166,
0.5459681153297424,
-0.24976597726345062,
-0.391625314950943,
0.4972597360610962,
0.3795665502548218,
0.29166898131370544,
0.7999125123023987,
0.43974435329437256,
0.04923507943749428,
0.01676185615360737,
-0.1006309911608696,
0.06409892439842224,
-0.41199061274528503,
-0.42371824383735657,
-0.5192537903785706,
-0.009992041625082493,
-0.4265390932559967,
-0.6949943900108337,
0.5145769715309143,
-0.36159032583236694,
0.17768463492393494,
0.24524345993995667,
-0.6849882006645203,
0.7193352580070496,
0.4413096606731415,
0.19963885843753815,
0.2718087434768677,
-0.184829443693161,
-0.28486204147338867,
0.48348692059516907,
-0.5473945736885071,
-0.6491618156433105,
0.9073876738548279,
0.11232474446296692,
0.7771866321563721,
0.10729093849658966,
0.749553382396698,
0.42713698744773865,
0.35334962606430054,
-0.5585347414016724,
0.8115785717964172,
-0.37371504306793213,
-0.7532473802566528,
-0.4636077880859375,
-0.6916032433509827,
-1.1040210723876953,
0.15329819917678833,
-0.068104587495327,
-0.7395197749137878,
0.32628166675567627,
0.19486257433891296,
-0.41600263118743896,
0.3087141513824463,
-0.3375091552734375,
0.9590655565261841,
-0.44399386644363403,
-0.1600581556558609,
-0.08735577017068863,
-0.6692343354225159,
0.33029448986053467,
-0.2500089406967163,
-0.13228604197502136,
-0.324849009513855,
0.0036850660108029842,
0.5868258476257324,
-0.5908660292625427,
0.6576606631278992,
-0.1889907270669937,
-0.09896188974380493,
0.07613649219274521,
0.40126532316207886,
0.49366188049316406,
-0.009762037545442581,
0.12272205948829651,
0.2718117833137512,
0.22162792086601257,
-0.1849166750907898,
-0.42792078852653503,
0.7985748052597046,
-0.6817147135734558,
-0.5572410821914673,
-0.33676910400390625,
-0.11933261901140213,
-0.3486798107624054,
0.33185791969299316,
0.3733139932155609,
0.17971402406692505,
-0.19831930100917816,
0.10635248571634293,
1.182887315750122,
-0.431295245885849,
0.14072129130363464,
0.37972381711006165,
-0.46551892161369324,
-0.25644800066947937,
1.0442466735839844,
-0.11396509408950806,
0.09045301377773285,
0.35312408208847046,
0.4334689974784851,
-0.17305023968219757,
-0.3464317321777344,
-0.3174465596675873,
0.07606571912765503,
-0.8157088756561279,
-0.28425106406211853,
-1.0547938346862793,
-0.2740001976490021,
-0.4380347728729248,
0.05600668489933014,
-0.27994275093078613,
-0.3309178650379181,
-0.023078614845871925,
-0.2140776813030243,
0.5220431685447693,
0.8326363563537598,
-0.22012189030647278,
-0.11334286630153656,
-0.8472676873207092,
0.577536940574646,
0.6012038588523865,
0.4312148094177246,
-0.4936395287513733,
-0.062226999551057816,
-0.16481153666973114,
-0.25772446393966675,
0.1804947704076767,
-1.3242064714431763,
0.38359495997428894,
0.22874483466148376,
0.8612572550773621,
0.20147527754306793,
-0.1873566061258316,
0.12892009317874908,
-0.2683977484703064,
0.5296996235847473,
-0.32976022362709045,
-0.7140180468559265,
0.6146856546401978,
-0.22330868244171143,
0.09756206721067429,
0.4544738233089447,
0.2138315886259079,
-0.39917463064193726,
-0.6082494258880615,
-0.5383616089820862,
-0.5577787160873413,
0.1966947764158249,
0.4530266523361206,
-0.25886091589927673,
-0.048540178686380386,
0.44758424162864685,
0.37403905391693115,
0.1362994909286499,
-0.41663193702697754,
-0.4305230379104614,
-0.4423121511936188,
-0.12182080745697021,
-0.21715141832828522,
-0.0805266946554184,
-0.31721487641334534,
-0.09637990593910217,
0.8274182677268982,
-0.5022754073143005,
0.37103381752967834,
0.6868764162063599,
-0.3032074570655823,
-0.29858332872390747,
0.17402654886245728,
0.6654391288757324,
0.47863665223121643,
-0.20593523979187012,
0.3924084007740021,
0.09074908494949341,
-0.6066305041313171,
0.15322229266166687,
0.544443666934967,
0.022355331107974052,
0.06933564692735672,
0.11348344385623932,
0.1813538819551468,
-0.23649272322654724,
-0.7056823372840881,
0.5066125392913818,
-0.16483575105667114,
-0.20614895224571228,
-0.24204878509044647,
0.19802318513393402,
-0.11411546170711517,
0.3588683605194092,
0.48541706800460815,
0.1398056000471115,
0.47035524249076843,
-0.134695902466774,
0.5577278733253479,
0.29023438692092896,
-0.27438366413116455,
-0.0010457549942657351,
0.5899643898010254,
0.1650640368461609,
0.15631449222564697,
0.2125120460987091,
-0.4382116496562958,
-0.5982137322425842,
0.7553771734237671,
0.27206581830978394,
1.1452304124832153,
-0.5396496653556824,
0.3427093029022217,
0.0914895161986351,
0.566970705986023,
-0.08668764680624008,
0.32031023502349854,
0.30428293347358704,
-0.9210190176963806,
-0.27115675806999207,
-0.5210142135620117,
-0.47250205278396606,
0.20963934063911438,
-0.10008314996957779,
-0.15666408836841583,
-0.3223424553871155,
-0.11187036335468292,
0.19460131227970123,
-0.028103133663535118,
-0.4773896336555481,
0.03144824132323265,
0.0800744891166687,
0.673454225063324,
-0.6468542814254761,
0.9346320629119873,
0.6652351021766663,
-0.3445549011230469,
-0.7838551998138428,
-0.059418268501758575,
0.09428821504116058,
-0.8046256899833679,
0.30874884128570557,
0.18931026756763458,
-0.37329962849617004,
0.09075882285833359,
-0.5813645720481873,
-0.6941179037094116,
1.1581480503082275,
0.2521778643131256,
-0.608874499797821,
0.4536224603652954,
0.07041672617197037,
0.6545161008834839,
-0.39133650064468384,
-0.2732035219669342,
0.6287785172462463,
0.6538918614387512,
0.31284549832344055,
-0.4822719097137451,
0.3534899353981018,
-0.24379315972328186,
-0.16246598958969116,
0.1460951417684555,
-0.22507628798484802,
0.4428996443748474,
-0.2290751039981842,
-0.034960441291332245,
0.1611328274011612,
0.6347619891166687,
0.20783576369285583,
0.2882431745529175,
0.3802056610584259,
0.13696308434009552,
1.036934494972229,
-0.04685252159833908,
0.9073423743247986,
-0.5846440196037292,
0.10431622713804245,
0.9367932677268982,
-0.392082542181015,
0.2871265411376953,
0.21708251535892487,
-0.12553739547729492,
0.4798600971698761,
0.22939200699329376,
-0.3627214729785919,
0.09162482619285583,
0.438773512840271,
-0.4371457099914551,
-0.3293861746788025,
0.08938894420862198,
-0.3180732727050781,
0.19727341830730438,
0.3243812024593353,
-0.29035693407058716,
0.22906674444675446,
0.16706226766109467,
-0.10685961693525314,
0.05266936495900154,
-0.12526588141918182,
0.6931872963905334,
-0.12102489173412323,
-0.6086179614067078,
0.08027654886245728,
-0.25014883279800415,
0.3760139048099518,
-0.6370219588279724,
-0.19299791753292084,
-0.46803635358810425,
0.2509979009628296,
-0.1711244434118271,
-0.6209573149681091,
-0.03733163699507713,
-0.2668481171131134,
0.18701046705245972,
0.26464471220970154,
1.1790403127670288,
-0.618021547794342,
-0.4440923035144806,
0.30247634649276733,
0.7778345942497253,
0.2529022693634033,
-0.1447218358516693,
-0.46286189556121826,
-0.20927566289901733,
-0.14316323399543762,
-0.13727650046348572,
-0.0403834767639637,
0.6134278178215027,
0.24165283143520355,
0.9077087044715881,
0.5851535201072693,
0.12376715242862701,
0.08644411712884903,
0.13260625302791595,
0.7175301313400269,
-0.7538004517555237,
-0.049251146614551544,
-0.7483479380607605,
0.07558716833591461,
-0.2116299271583557,
0.06961758434772491,
0.6197031736373901,
0.491973876953125,
0.6278956532478333,
-0.2075633704662323,
1.1429731845855713,
-0.1252073049545288,
0.5446598529815674,
-0.3162638247013092,
0.857343316078186,
-0.25988948345184326,
0.29505273699760437,
-0.10496562719345093,
-0.6001666188240051,
-0.5161272287368774,
0.825175404548645,
-0.08780419081449509,
0.4530795216560364,
0.9199020266532898,
1.148269534111023,
0.2961958944797516,
-0.01869348995387554,
0.6741930842399597,
0.40064072608947754,
0.4310169517993927,
0.27633655071258545,
0.7831107378005981,
-0.09956590086221695,
0.6467593312263489,
-0.23517534136772156,
-0.43132033944129944,
-0.17621318995952606,
-0.7879126071929932,
-1.166168451309204,
-0.5218575596809387,
-0.4273970425128937,
-0.5654162764549255,
0.38955962657928467,
1.1378183364868164,
0.6452505588531494,
-0.7304878830909729,
-0.09437020123004913,
-0.01364891231060028,
0.06383447349071503,
-0.20755179226398468,
-0.16210991144180298,
0.1392335295677185,
-0.29433441162109375,
-0.22779437899589539,
0.7353357672691345,
0.535190761089325,
0.29835763573646545,
-0.6582784056663513,
-0.08570970594882965,
-0.10961848497390747,
0.2556971311569214,
0.3623318672180176,
0.5681503415107727,
-0.5018407702445984,
-0.3413616418838501,
-0.03711758926510811,
-0.41507163643836975,
0.08980195969343185,
1.0419291257858276,
-0.959318220615387,
0.5574394464492798,
0.19627048075199127,
0.6499716639518738,
0.18874125182628632,
-0.2925378978252411,
0.6838725209236145,
-0.6835653781890869,
-0.4840399920940399,
0.30733522772789,
0.389535516500473,
0.32942473888397217,
-0.7950311303138733,
0.7645504474639893,
0.28534919023513794,
-0.8814408779144287,
-0.3353705108165741,
0.2034732550382614,
-1.0070031881332397,
-0.2790575921535492,
1.1633931398391724,
-0.008894631639122963,
-0.3155116140842438,
-0.23075279593467712,
-0.33339282870292664,
0.15128006041049957,
-0.1993836611509323,
1.0272951126098633,
0.2809860110282898,
-0.23698921501636505,
-0.2018837183713913,
-0.30408769845962524,
0.9044074416160583,
0.34240490198135376,
-1.163048267364502,
0.15548233687877655,
0.5385894775390625,
0.2420753538608551,
0.12667004764080048,
0.5429967641830444,
-0.026280637830495834,
0.17256712913513184,
-0.10222431272268295,
0.4263765811920166,
-0.007795637007802725,
-0.35317981243133545,
-0.361415833234787,
0.13590170443058014,
-0.011906622909009457,
-0.005801987834274769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16897v1
|
InstructPatentGPT: Training patent language models to follow instructions with human feedback
| 2024-05-25T11:48:50 | 2024-05-25T11:48:50 |
Jieh-Sheng Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this research, patent prosecution is conceptualized as a system of
reinforcement learning from human feedback. The objective of the system is to
increase the likelihood for a language model to generate patent claims that
have a higher chance of being granted. To showcase the controllability of the
language model, the system learns from granted patents and pre-grant
applications with different rewards. The status of "granted" and "pre-grant"
are perceived as labeled human feedback implicitly. In addition, specific to
patent drafting, the experiments in this research demonstrate the model's
capability to learn from adjusting claim length and inclusion of limiting terms
for narrowing claim scope. As proof of concept, the experiments focus on claim
ones only and the training data originates from a patent dataset tailored
specifically for artificial intelligence. Although the available human feedback
in patent prosecution are limited and the quality of generated patent text
requires improvement, the experiments following the 3-stage reinforcement
learning from human feedback have demonstrated that generative language models
are capable of reflecting the human feedback or intent in patent prosecution.
To enhance the usability of language models, the implementation in this
research utilizes modern techniques that enable execution on a single
consumer-grade GPU. The demonstrated proof of concept, which reduces hardware
requirements, will prove valuable in the future as more human feedback in
patent prosecution become available for broader use, either within patent
offices or in the public domain.
|
[
0.0023709628731012344,
-0.4607691764831543,
0.41682326793670654,
0.5541009306907654,
-0.2191178798675537,
0.22574295103549957,
-0.1547248214483261,
-0.3853796124458313,
-0.2218298614025116,
0.5385539531707764,
-0.192896768450737,
-0.40571191906929016,
-0.44518807530403137,
-0.20528128743171692,
-0.20051155984401703,
1.0694100856781006,
-0.09574844688177109,
0.26079297065734863,
-0.10632696747779846,
0.4505208730697632,
-0.42342764139175415,
-0.6126869320869446,
-0.7864366769790649,
-0.6623924970626831,
0.08877180516719818,
0.4185192883014679,
0.18367964029312134,
0.3791970908641815,
0.10129409283399582,
0.26023614406585693,
0.06893981248140335,
-0.2999386787414551,
-0.11518140882253647,
-0.09458722174167633,
-0.18289463222026825,
-0.48957157135009766,
-0.12847118079662323,
0.3012404441833496,
0.3917427957057953,
0.4252281188964844,
-0.6619402170181274,
-0.03493678197264671,
0.3360682427883148,
0.2817363440990448,
-0.4554874897003174,
0.44739386439323425,
-0.5672950744628906,
0.0941416472196579,
0.04889518767595291,
-0.19401872158050537,
-0.8166863322257996,
-0.45854315161705017,
0.27154916524887085,
-0.6566765308380127,
0.5746407508850098,
0.269963800907135,
0.8025754690170288,
-0.008699541911482811,
0.0004086606786586344,
-0.3240177631378174,
-0.6301618218421936,
0.39006587862968445,
-0.8150522708892822,
0.03596971929073334,
0.40400370955467224,
0.16155825555324554,
-0.4650048017501831,
-0.9904343485832214,
-0.6199826002120972,
-0.9077483415603638,
0.10569029301404953,
-0.03291242569684982,
-0.13665124773979187,
0.37139105796813965,
0.37429964542388916,
0.01949203759431839,
-0.5698138475418091,
0.2557097375392914,
-0.5174515247344971,
-0.37291380763053894,
0.449042946100235,
-0.2801477313041687,
0.44409143924713135,
-0.03068871609866619,
-0.5119497179985046,
-0.31879401206970215,
-0.9741374254226685,
0.1667429804801941,
0.5282400250434875,
0.2567729353904724,
0.12163767218589783,
0.5407311320304871,
-0.3111013174057007,
0.6288245320320129,
0.13904209434986115,
0.14462126791477203,
-0.006524518597871065,
-0.06976351886987686,
-0.29740869998931885,
0.3771965801715851,
0.7668259143829346,
-0.13428309559822083,
0.05807514861226082,
-0.34457001090049744,
-0.43244245648384094,
-0.09002571552991867,
0.48433277010917664,
-0.8829494714736938,
-0.4609137773513794,
-0.0941503643989563,
-0.6006787419319153,
-0.3341788053512573,
0.21870972216129303,
-0.6574842929840088,
-0.5626868009567261,
-0.4336608350276947,
0.5881038308143616,
-0.4076016843318939,
-0.26868313550949097,
0.3287634253501892,
-0.4539484679698944,
0.23573718965053558,
0.24845115840435028,
-1.3318760395050049,
0.5027620196342468,
0.8746790885925293,
0.4968566298484802,
0.04606145620346069,
-0.4523346722126007,
-0.5471203923225403,
0.12246182560920715,
-0.2720620632171631,
0.7411381602287292,
-0.49188467860221863,
-0.6996440887451172,
-0.2464098185300827,
-0.02158033475279808,
-0.3291334807872772,
-0.7912912368774414,
0.5570896863937378,
-0.6516778469085693,
0.3324633240699768,
0.17813298106193542,
-0.5840469002723694,
-0.07338816672563553,
0.09842774271965027,
-0.17482542991638184,
0.47717157006263733,
-0.01863604038953781,
-0.5506638884544373,
0.7807469964027405,
-0.9922705292701721,
-0.489958792924881,
0.31042376160621643,
-0.3849155604839325,
-0.4590730369091034,
0.1375064104795456,
0.15533128380775452,
0.26094046235084534,
-0.22880926728248596,
0.27718451619148254,
-0.09836474061012268,
-0.1232575923204422,
0.11997455358505249,
-0.2969611585140228,
0.8434649705886841,
0.1907222419977188,
-0.8099508881568909,
0.3907029926776886,
-0.6233439445495605,
0.004532502498477697,
0.11708709597587585,
-0.6243264079093933,
-0.09291791170835495,
0.033474624156951904,
-0.1822216510772705,
-0.08287525177001953,
-0.04289322346448898,
-0.9010807275772095,
0.4254147410392761,
-0.47124576568603516,
0.5481202602386475,
0.8162933588027954,
0.09148827195167542,
0.25457772612571716,
0.013372290879487991,
0.808168888092041,
-0.37222281098365784,
0.30451589822769165,
0.012166857719421387,
-0.6373424530029297,
-0.6117801070213318,
-0.09033069014549255,
0.3721426725387573,
0.544624924659729,
-0.7553666234016418,
0.058942802250385284,
-0.14691013097763062,
-0.1369180977344513,
-0.3900345265865326,
0.16132347285747528,
0.6549030542373657,
0.6871769428253174,
0.027584346011281013,
-0.6089062094688416,
-0.40139415860176086,
-0.7297263741493225,
-0.22166571021080017,
-0.5335378050804138,
-0.24504466354846954,
0.11224319040775299,
0.5512583255767822,
0.11597906053066254,
0.7606523036956787,
-0.4672592580318451,
-0.09981196373701096,
-0.318939208984375,
0.8660492300987244,
0.17281699180603027,
0.6074849963188171,
0.33468374609947205,
-0.5840067863464355,
-0.4071328639984131,
0.22078914940357208,
-0.5130859017372131,
0.06728402525186539,
-0.05288873612880707,
0.2145814150571823,
0.10389149188995361,
0.5423218011856079,
-0.6896213889122009,
0.6149088144302368,
0.13270078599452972,
-0.4948582649230957,
0.8442479372024536,
-0.70247483253479,
-0.007374448701739311,
-0.853334367275238,
-0.02042667381465435,
-0.04410947114229202,
-0.02138330228626728,
-0.2785626947879791,
-0.08809040486812592,
0.051026202738285065,
-0.39076173305511475,
-0.4633693993091583,
0.40668392181396484,
-0.3969068229198456,
0.20953789353370667,
-0.4353981018066406,
-0.2562909424304962,
-0.19628675282001495,
0.3897736072540283,
-0.012617264874279499,
1.1496360301971436,
0.4790400266647339,
-0.7543545365333557,
0.5661561489105225,
0.15471504628658295,
-0.5738387107849121,
0.3465513586997986,
-0.9284901022911072,
0.21895205974578857,
-0.10383018851280212,
-0.011317932046949863,
-0.7570938467979431,
-0.32406139373779297,
0.3628746569156647,
-0.497998982667923,
0.49476203322410583,
-0.28307655453681946,
-0.618882954120636,
-0.5659242272377014,
0.0029110973700881004,
-0.23622511327266693,
0.47687092423439026,
-0.8526872992515564,
0.3023824989795685,
0.3762919306755066,
-0.3475242257118225,
-0.47923344373703003,
-0.4994090795516968,
0.2346559762954712,
-0.17949897050857544,
-0.3618965148925781,
0.5198314189910889,
0.0974307581782341,
0.0331694595515728,
0.06223108246922493,
0.403749018907547,
-0.13356822729110718,
0.04614933207631111,
0.2926587164402008,
0.2626875936985016,
-0.03453054651618004,
0.20164792239665985,
-0.11867791414260864,
-0.2234916090965271,
0.3714327812194824,
-0.6868086457252502,
0.4046381115913391,
0.009571258910000324,
-0.486948698759079,
-0.6634819507598877,
-0.008140024729073048,
0.2623516619205475,
-0.09960708022117615,
0.26593610644340515,
0.26424553990364075,
-0.2470155954360962,
-0.4053299129009247,
-0.2954370379447937,
-0.17311613261699677,
-0.5133242607116699,
0.3412008285522461,
-0.35619112849235535,
-0.7466816306114197,
0.09254954010248184,
-0.22172333300113678,
-0.11054524779319763,
0.2541022002696991,
0.616296648979187,
0.20331159234046936,
1.0159642696380615,
0.9151163101196289,
-0.28760889172554016,
0.5835084319114685,
-0.3164796829223633,
0.297886461019516,
-0.6659258008003235,
-0.4153207540512085,
-0.5925121307373047,
0.11239118129014969,
-0.28425025939941406,
-0.10403835028409958,
0.10033732652664185,
0.20856203138828278,
-0.32171937823295593,
0.4364725649356842,
-0.8087456226348877,
0.5839203000068665,
1.1088734865188599,
0.2732398509979248,
0.12902064621448517,
0.23543286323547363,
-0.5499696731567383,
-0.02324730157852173,
-0.721336305141449,
-0.5529855489730835,
1.2543390989303589,
0.2680531144142151,
1.1175692081451416,
-0.10551872104406357,
0.6448202133178711,
0.4204714894294739,
0.668347954750061,
-0.6009464859962463,
0.40973344445228577,
0.03559214621782303,
-0.3785296082496643,
-0.19294726848602295,
-0.2774527072906494,
-0.8349217772483826,
0.08189456164836884,
0.11389850825071335,
-0.9785900115966797,
0.19809624552726746,
0.41753774881362915,
-0.5509068965911865,
0.22083233296871185,
-1.1100964546203613,
0.9933799505233765,
-0.6267390251159668,
-0.3780410587787628,
-0.531646192073822,
-0.49669840931892395,
0.2259986251592636,
0.21452903747558594,
-0.417672723531723,
0.18969881534576416,
0.43624329566955566,
0.8227612972259521,
-0.5911693572998047,
1.2126349210739136,
-0.499432235956192,
0.0032097932416945696,
0.21454903483390808,
-0.20793722569942474,
0.5154531002044678,
0.056229569017887115,
0.13498753309249878,
-0.6354309916496277,
-0.22203703224658966,
-0.13874903321266174,
-0.5965296030044556,
0.41397953033447266,
-0.5942447781562805,
-0.8051081895828247,
-0.4165714681148529,
-0.2347160428762436,
-0.1875676065683365,
0.20601074397563934,
0.4254119098186493,
0.21462669968605042,
-0.4531182050704956,
-0.05892163887619972,
0.6604488492012024,
-0.392973929643631,
0.4187110364437103,
0.3891521990299225,
-0.214954674243927,
-0.4557185173034668,
0.9827395081520081,
-0.27381032705307007,
0.0833074152469635,
0.27341675758361816,
0.17020046710968018,
-0.5870415568351746,
-0.7344090342521667,
-0.5694944262504578,
0.17542725801467896,
-0.6281483173370361,
0.02837849035859108,
-0.31535735726356506,
-0.18044456839561462,
-0.48732441663742065,
0.3736800253391266,
-0.14112190902233124,
-0.4379718005657196,
-0.3366454541683197,
-0.13596923649311066,
0.17631933093070984,
1.0801762342453003,
0.08309799432754517,
0.37697693705558777,
-0.5213241577148438,
0.12929585576057434,
0.7373441457748413,
0.6585273742675781,
0.05409470573067665,
-0.5416148900985718,
-0.17993007600307465,
0.05169730633497238,
-0.818583071231842,
-0.40197160840034485,
0.31895196437835693,
0.19219551980495453,
0.7985469698905945,
0.4763616621494293,
-0.1502782106399536,
0.3488549590110779,
-0.5276309251785278,
0.602147102355957,
0.2692183256149292,
-0.929100751876831,
0.85004061460495,
-0.1326855719089508,
-0.08561969548463821,
0.27519944310188293,
0.18776008486747742,
-0.34002119302749634,
-0.18697451055049896,
-0.5895649194717407,
-0.5783345103263855,
0.7649117112159729,
-0.1110316812992096,
0.22979594767093658,
0.23013046383857727,
0.5240836143493652,
-0.005091843660920858,
0.29324638843536377,
-0.5984284281730652,
0.28094926476478577,
-0.22216925024986267,
-0.0432233102619648,
0.23780612647533417,
-0.19670738279819489,
-0.3201916813850403,
-0.3727997839450836,
0.7861148118972778,
-0.054131750017404556,
0.28616058826446533,
0.07999329268932343,
-0.09387258440256119,
0.31548094749450684,
0.4292276203632355,
0.9132382273674011,
0.8537715673446655,
-0.04440751671791077,
-0.06737582385540009,
-0.30873793363571167,
-0.643066942691803,
0.30550074577331543,
0.4343388080596924,
-0.2991756200790405,
-0.14013870060443878,
0.06177910044789314,
1.1581881046295166,
-0.14545944333076477,
-0.6696561574935913,
0.5130192041397095,
-0.24648071825504303,
-0.40792208909988403,
-0.15804068744182587,
0.11110448092222214,
-0.1126074343919754,
0.38554689288139343,
0.25822484493255615,
0.1177026778459549,
0.18427708745002747,
-0.3236415982246399,
0.3308309316635132,
0.3511559069156647,
-0.42006635665893555,
-0.4987896680831909,
1.0433290004730225,
0.23601719737052917,
-0.3421558141708374,
0.7269912362098694,
-0.4230256676673889,
-0.6475615501403809,
0.7064939141273499,
0.8386824727058411,
1.0830522775650024,
-0.11269176006317139,
0.5786529779434204,
0.1794777512550354,
0.2589177191257477,
-0.41599076986312866,
0.053129956126213074,
-0.2689419984817505,
-0.6563634276390076,
-0.411609023809433,
-0.2542703151702881,
-0.6359642148017883,
-0.0018359527457505465,
-0.34198951721191406,
-0.016398372128605843,
-0.6253105401992798,
-0.19713237881660461,
-0.11740687489509583,
-0.2815244495868683,
-0.3273633122444153,
-0.072966568171978,
-0.056926973164081573,
0.7448300719261169,
-0.6477720737457275,
1.0922954082489014,
0.5679886937141418,
-0.7513843774795532,
-0.9031108021736145,
0.07951713353395462,
-0.1083424985408783,
-0.6546540856361389,
1.3493611812591553,
0.06362973153591156,
-0.13901636004447937,
0.09292782098054886,
-0.8187569379806519,
-0.32474657893180847,
0.8823021054267883,
0.5980260372161865,
-0.11961489170789719,
0.026677705347537994,
0.04308350384235382,
0.47957736253738403,
-0.4033365547657013,
-0.15441052615642548,
0.40658819675445557,
0.1434001326560974,
0.047782931476831436,
-0.9706165790557861,
-0.06682895869016647,
-0.28006377816200256,
0.1965535283088684,
-0.09979915618896484,
-0.2092646360397339,
0.6369753479957581,
-0.45356282591819763,
-0.24429668486118317,
0.20786266028881073,
0.6700435280799866,
0.43148255348205566,
0.0888938456773758,
0.3801115155220032,
0.7642787098884583,
0.7514780759811401,
-0.09866750240325928,
1.2664403915405273,
-0.23992224037647247,
0.2925155460834503,
1.2362064123153687,
-0.16735811531543732,
0.8954135775566101,
0.45857059955596924,
-0.28240054845809937,
0.4160892367362976,
0.5866670608520508,
-0.0686611607670784,
0.7020266056060791,
0.6541113257408142,
-0.5775349140167236,
0.11882290244102478,
-0.26962026953697205,
-0.1894140988588333,
0.1572352796792984,
0.34276729822158813,
-0.48358771204948425,
-0.02566327340900898,
0.28216052055358887,
0.02157065086066723,
0.03594391420483589,
-0.028346488252282143,
0.8625209927558899,
-0.0008425697451457381,
-0.9037545323371887,
0.5739519000053406,
0.022297892719507217,
0.6797394156455994,
-0.5937862396240234,
-0.35500437021255493,
0.007784962188452482,
0.5238801836967468,
-0.009613950736820698,
-0.5206047296524048,
-0.11941302567720413,
0.06112363934516907,
-0.19739127159118652,
-0.34175169467926025,
0.4472964107990265,
-0.33486294746398926,
-0.3240608274936676,
0.13665828108787537,
-0.15445832908153534,
0.021015170961618423,
-0.0007794409175403416,
-0.6166662573814392,
-0.2861446142196655,
0.06603024154901505,
-0.07381253689527512,
0.14289870858192444,
0.26597023010253906,
-0.10840088874101639,
0.9615692496299744,
0.5729416608810425,
0.5663069486618042,
0.435519278049469,
0.3563845753669739,
0.8654146790504456,
-0.3611159026622772,
-0.5983087420463562,
-0.5252090692520142,
0.23319827020168304,
-0.3498736321926117,
-0.2560739815235138,
0.5646829009056091,
0.5587093234062195,
0.9230450391769409,
-0.36754921078681946,
1.1255581378936768,
-0.1226767972111702,
0.4630237817764282,
-0.6557459235191345,
0.7726237773895264,
0.02817610464990139,
0.37149709463119507,
-0.021706577390432358,
-0.44082286953926086,
-0.40428027510643005,
0.5355399250984192,
-0.3627477288246155,
0.03508016839623451,
0.5028611421585083,
0.9400320053100586,
-0.06916160136461258,
-0.02161862701177597,
-0.06636853516101837,
-0.03969419375061989,
0.7328576445579529,
0.3391663432121277,
0.9090401530265808,
-0.21230870485305786,
0.4872274100780487,
-0.3419552147388458,
-0.2812976837158203,
-0.10319807380437851,
-0.7563914656639099,
-0.6255254745483398,
-0.3035100996494293,
-0.2679012715816498,
-0.3056083023548126,
0.21949289739131927,
0.8309510350227356,
0.8888952732086182,
-0.9204741716384888,
-0.46303489804267883,
-0.5864593386650085,
-0.053863462060689926,
-0.09715750813484192,
-0.25357887148857117,
0.44290634989738464,
-0.7265066504478455,
-0.5098960399627686,
0.47051241993904114,
0.3438524007797241,
0.23281878232955933,
-0.23290568590164185,
-0.3281175494194031,
-0.03645363822579384,
-0.41787126660346985,
0.5093569159507751,
0.8100053668022156,
-0.7212501764297485,
-0.21986907720565796,
-0.16991084814071655,
0.0016603261465206742,
0.014070711098611355,
1.3397479057312012,
-0.7118391394615173,
0.9313505291938782,
0.6103374361991882,
0.9087018966674805,
0.5400367379188538,
0.018341995775699615,
1.0171122550964355,
-0.7615882754325867,
0.53783118724823,
0.22912220656871796,
0.3209775388240814,
0.28159087896347046,
-0.3168523907661438,
0.336739182472229,
0.300296813249588,
-0.6439391374588013,
-0.41741228103637695,
0.17480197548866272,
-0.45351696014404297,
-0.15595269203186035,
0.652639627456665,
-0.3992709219455719,
-0.04701613262295723,
-0.15016856789588928,
-0.448042631149292,
0.03606083244085312,
-0.5084546804428101,
1.079502820968628,
0.6626538634300232,
-0.3761864900588989,
-0.3655858337879181,
-0.6184515953063965,
0.697968602180481,
0.2872920632362366,
-0.8679230213165283,
-0.027043653652071953,
0.20103034377098083,
0.27617570757865906,
-0.007422746624797583,
0.8177888989448547,
-0.2642385959625244,
0.3294931650161743,
-0.07674787193536758,
0.5223769545555115,
0.040197983384132385,
-0.23322105407714844,
-0.4678136706352234,
0.09786339104175568,
0.6888092160224915,
-0.5603428483009338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16178v1
|
Accelerating Inference of Retrieval-Augmented Generation via Sparse Context Selection
| 2024-05-25T11:10:04 | 2024-05-25T11:10:04 |
Yun Zhu, Jia-Chen Gu, Caitlin Sikora, Ho Ko, Yinxiao Liu, Chu-Cheng Lin, Lei Shu, Liangchen Luo, Lei Meng, Bang Liu, Jindong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) augmented with retrieval exhibit robust
performance and extensive versatility by incorporating external contexts.
However, the input length grows linearly in the number of retrieved documents,
causing a dramatic increase in latency. In this paper, we propose a novel
paradigm named Sparse RAG, which seeks to cut computation costs through
sparsity. Specifically, Sparse RAG encodes retrieved documents in parallel,
which eliminates latency introduced by long-range attention of retrieved
documents. Then, LLMs selectively decode the output by only attending to highly
relevant caches auto-regressively, which are chosen via prompting LLMs with
special control tokens. It is notable that Sparse RAG combines the assessment
of each individual document and the generation of the response into a single
process. The designed sparse mechanism in a RAG system can facilitate the
reduction of the number of documents loaded during decoding for accelerating
the inference of the RAG system. Additionally, filtering out undesirable
contexts enhances the model's focus on relevant context, inherently improving
its generation quality. Evaluation results of two datasets show that Sparse RAG
can strike an optimal balance between generation quality and computational
efficiency, demonstrating its generalizability across both short- and long-form
generation tasks.
|
[
-0.5075914263725281,
-0.737789511680603,
0.5995509028434753,
0.3503495752811432,
-0.29416853189468384,
0.012171301059424877,
-0.3529760539531708,
-0.4200792908668518,
0.5155173540115356,
0.4685301184654236,
-0.5624446272850037,
0.04480261355638504,
-0.5585445761680603,
0.26053252816200256,
-0.4345528483390808,
1.038867712020874,
0.1899387389421463,
-0.2351660281419754,
-0.32673153281211853,
-0.07507459074258804,
-0.505195677280426,
-0.13839998841285706,
-0.7245227694511414,
-0.22584377229213715,
0.652511477470398,
0.19303908944129944,
0.593468964099884,
0.8613554239273071,
0.17138142883777618,
0.32456734776496887,
-0.1847120076417923,
0.3680185079574585,
-0.8827781677246094,
0.5516439080238342,
-0.07503235340118408,
-0.1376044601202011,
-0.3476833999156952,
-0.235618457198143,
0.9269203543663025,
0.7652574181556702,
-0.005453913472592831,
0.28935539722442627,
0.44021016359329224,
0.5305101275444031,
-0.9008803367614746,
-0.2548157870769501,
-0.8463370203971863,
-0.314567893743515,
-0.29050973057746887,
-0.34756991267204285,
-0.5151568055152893,
0.0438886322081089,
-0.2767547070980072,
-0.6562602519989014,
0.43695971369743347,
0.03880229964852333,
0.7771078944206238,
0.6393156051635742,
0.0562589094042778,
-0.18459992110729218,
-0.6560546159744263,
0.8755115270614624,
-0.32107284665107727,
0.43439266085624695,
0.4212747812271118,
0.13173174858093262,
-0.4165213108062744,
-0.8199895024299622,
-0.27667251229286194,
-0.07207871973514557,
-0.13302159309387207,
0.146581768989563,
0.03544312343001366,
-0.03755054995417595,
0.40281927585601807,
0.1889253705739975,
-0.6081843376159668,
0.0045633683912456036,
-0.18424078822135925,
-0.00638217106461525,
0.33574989438056946,
0.16825035214424133,
-0.18579046428203583,
-0.35125452280044556,
-0.2365371733903885,
0.07390499114990234,
-0.6180478930473328,
-0.30120792984962463,
0.13675592839717865,
0.28358080983161926,
0.12704706192016602,
0.45158299803733826,
-0.22059297561645508,
0.8021191954612732,
0.1612115502357483,
-0.17240437865257263,
-0.07957044243812561,
-0.11079565435647964,
-0.27219000458717346,
-0.2511935532093048,
0.563999593257904,
-0.02270374447107315,
-0.2051904797554016,
-0.2698633074760437,
-0.5249996781349182,
0.05112818628549576,
0.31087031960487366,
-0.8991120457649231,
0.309684157371521,
0.13406524062156677,
-0.4033806025981903,
-0.13541705906391144,
-0.267123818397522,
-1.058167815208435,
-0.3543579876422882,
-0.21696506440639496,
0.23030778765678406,
-0.12193364650011063,
0.10065716505050659,
-0.10572618991136551,
-0.12946289777755737,
-0.04944999888539314,
0.30184802412986755,
-0.8299469947814941,
0.5653855800628662,
0.6602532267570496,
0.8674947619438171,
-0.3128374516963959,
0.006749708205461502,
-1.0633554458618164,
0.3056129813194275,
-0.39851099252700806,
1.0231271982192993,
-0.6740784049034119,
-0.4478501081466675,
-0.28144803643226624,
-0.15406852960586548,
0.07926144450902939,
-0.5234953165054321,
0.6982707381248474,
-0.7306702136993408,
-0.01073936466127634,
-0.0672701820731163,
-0.32053595781326294,
0.4107116162776947,
-0.15610788762569427,
-0.8415841460227966,
1.3353424072265625,
0.25613388419151306,
-0.7221847176551819,
0.4141119122505188,
-0.12026415765285492,
-0.42252129316329956,
0.2573372423648834,
-0.29627466201782227,
-0.38184061646461487,
0.3687790632247925,
0.2066468894481659,
0.40621429681777954,
-0.690017580986023,
0.43388068675994873,
-0.3500903248786926,
-0.7201040983200073,
-0.05672731250524521,
-0.4299543797969818,
0.43895602226257324,
0.5715417265892029,
-0.3061762750148773,
-0.14323057234287262,
-0.7353171110153198,
-0.17864976823329926,
0.17639853060245514,
-0.5932897329330444,
-0.5362735390663147,
0.14984020590782166,
0.0314292348921299,
-0.08081242442131042,
0.2049982249736786,
-0.4724409878253937,
0.05997972562909126,
-0.5391301512718201,
-0.04394212365150452,
0.7430359125137329,
-0.03772812709212303,
0.6539033651351929,
-0.46596667170524597,
0.40889641642570496,
-0.5496562123298645,
-0.17204967141151428,
-0.18049319088459015,
-0.22517740726470947,
-0.6725082397460938,
-0.6404441595077515,
0.35922300815582275,
0.3369918465614319,
-0.6812212467193604,
0.18009890615940094,
-0.3918536305427551,
-0.010915788821876049,
-0.4358047544956207,
0.23937711119651794,
0.432543009519577,
0.5374964475631714,
0.2356732189655304,
-0.07374580949544907,
-0.44037410616874695,
-0.5994651913642883,
-0.2905668020248413,
0.24756164848804474,
-0.09749957919120789,
0.6385301947593689,
0.14719711244106293,
-0.09448198974132538,
0.8476818203926086,
-0.5307479500770569,
0.015289371833205223,
-0.19510261714458466,
0.20150180160999298,
0.32712075114250183,
0.4881168603897095,
0.4527151882648468,
-0.8242189288139343,
-0.45868098735809326,
-0.09347181022167206,
-0.3893383741378784,
-0.5585454106330872,
-0.37421512603759766,
-0.31884849071502686,
0.3941548764705658,
0.5753327012062073,
-0.6240605115890503,
0.41912901401519775,
0.31759896874427795,
-0.030503245070576668,
0.3447512686252594,
-0.33084914088249207,
-0.056854087859392166,
-0.9944615960121155,
0.22130508720874786,
-0.18118228018283844,
-0.23876041173934937,
-0.35174110531806946,
0.05718201771378517,
0.0711607038974762,
-0.09706756472587585,
0.09900631010532379,
0.9366151094436646,
-0.7849133014678955,
-0.5445588231086731,
-0.572676956653595,
0.16624577343463898,
0.2305557280778885,
0.41596823930740356,
0.020876727998256683,
0.9928799867630005,
0.08952126652002335,
-0.5029149055480957,
-0.1898815780878067,
0.03976891562342644,
-0.057627949863672256,
0.1737106889486313,
-0.5514270067214966,
0.052019983530044556,
-0.3949953615665436,
0.3908035159111023,
-0.969546914100647,
-0.4143545925617218,
-0.1497792750597,
-0.5378261804580688,
0.7286387085914612,
-0.18655352294445038,
-0.5482428073883057,
-0.19985347986221313,
-0.13604465126991272,
0.38091281056404114,
0.599079430103302,
-0.5676311254501343,
0.5987451076507568,
0.41066497564315796,
-0.2803214192390442,
-0.903523325920105,
-0.3658410310745239,
0.05348963290452957,
-0.17361819744110107,
-0.4440116882324219,
0.36967185139656067,
-0.034450922161340714,
-0.1838172823190689,
0.03759012743830681,
-0.3030070662498474,
-0.11867330968379974,
0.15350289642810822,
0.10512669384479523,
0.2866345942020416,
-0.18349944055080414,
0.08281215280294418,
0.5025193691253662,
-0.14664176106452942,
-0.1500818133354187,
-0.3117484748363495,
0.4397604167461395,
0.33586585521698,
-0.00031926677911542356,
0.1297716647386551,
0.6693366169929504,
0.4100871682167053,
-0.13803702592849731,
0.6584845185279846,
0.47522881627082825,
-0.2955373525619507,
-0.6820666193962097,
-0.7812632322311401,
-0.11821924149990082,
-0.5050475597381592,
0.26726919412612915,
-0.466713547706604,
-0.9903793334960938,
0.34382164478302,
-0.22853900492191315,
0.11857486516237259,
0.331976979970932,
0.5451174974441528,
0.2289617508649826,
0.9347121119499207,
0.4318505525588989,
-0.003023919416591525,
0.4557366371154785,
-0.22803737223148346,
-0.12541241943836212,
-0.8706488609313965,
0.16605353355407715,
-0.7868882417678833,
-0.00019680654804687947,
-0.5600621700286865,
-0.8066298961639404,
0.45936959981918335,
0.15515613555908203,
-0.18138687312602997,
0.003560643410310149,
-0.591980516910553,
0.4965818524360657,
0.31629523634910583,
-0.010609700344502926,
0.10240349918603897,
0.3125927746295929,
-0.29554736614227295,
-0.00581846060231328,
-0.873113214969635,
-0.30477046966552734,
0.8710816502571106,
0.076569102704525,
0.8431905508041382,
0.021002985537052155,
0.8434938788414001,
0.26130595803260803,
0.4243665337562561,
-0.5284754633903503,
0.5523524284362793,
-0.3211623430252075,
-0.3836207091808319,
-0.19689854979515076,
-0.6270789504051208,
-1.2083232402801514,
0.49405989050865173,
-0.26221147179603577,
-0.5656319856643677,
0.217400923371315,
0.030684906989336014,
-0.33840158581733704,
-0.007334132678806782,
-0.5177100300788879,
0.48802900314331055,
0.051326777786016464,
-1.0758692026138306,
-0.29188305139541626,
-0.5521109104156494,
0.42097973823547363,
-0.3916485905647278,
0.24833713471889496,
0.019375765696167946,
-0.33720698952674866,
0.4706648588180542,
-0.2828320264816284,
0.607903242111206,
-0.16439370810985565,
0.14329279959201813,
0.23059740662574768,
0.2690490186214447,
0.7435700297355652,
0.11264485120773315,
-0.2259344756603241,
-0.24443727731704712,
-0.4425429403781891,
-0.408413827419281,
-0.5429844856262207,
1.0124967098236084,
-0.413733571767807,
-0.6589270830154419,
-0.31603094935417175,
-0.8577067255973816,
-0.2621690332889557,
0.3461225628852844,
0.2467634379863739,
0.6544432044029236,
-0.04039940983057022,
-0.02791600115597248,
0.7439743280410767,
-0.46397170424461365,
0.2717309594154358,
0.35354334115982056,
0.10401954501867294,
-0.450100302696228,
1.0267499685287476,
0.11867102980613708,
0.2592093348503113,
0.3336026966571808,
0.15206964313983917,
-0.3237961530685425,
-0.517692506313324,
-0.5034480690956116,
0.5118257999420166,
-0.6026344895362854,
-0.34803587198257446,
-0.8273519277572632,
-0.053452201187610626,
-0.5285654067993164,
-0.40086740255355835,
-0.16338111460208893,
-0.3994152843952179,
-0.3947176933288574,
0.33474433422088623,
0.18147502839565277,
0.74123215675354,
-0.19226659834384918,
0.19540967047214508,
-0.7353833913803101,
0.7384962439537048,
0.0855834111571312,
0.36645692586898804,
0.0816725641489029,
-0.6689204573631287,
-0.3183221220970154,
-0.3403310775756836,
-0.10908867418766022,
-0.6246357560157776,
0.5634697675704956,
0.18163152039051056,
0.5743773579597473,
0.10229220241308212,
0.1258939802646637,
0.9461081624031067,
-0.7781779170036316,
0.3652110695838928,
-0.24329903721809387,
-0.6288632154464722,
0.2145489603281021,
-0.4853369891643524,
0.2559078633785248,
0.33586767315864563,
0.22520464658737183,
-0.10686703771352768,
-0.562102735042572,
-0.5143609046936035,
-1.0732370615005493,
0.7735864520072937,
0.09416236728429794,
0.03932730108499527,
-0.3280976414680481,
0.5449473857879639,
0.07166071236133575,
-0.030678439885377884,
-0.34303584694862366,
-0.03948897123336792,
0.072870172560215,
0.011980235576629639,
0.1035698801279068,
-0.5456017851829529,
0.008839230984449387,
0.12763100862503052,
0.5496663451194763,
-0.24674129486083984,
0.31871452927589417,
0.2700238823890686,
-0.034277863800525665,
-0.34724369645118713,
0.1465655416250229,
0.5889065861701965,
0.39370056986808777,
-0.17044533789157867,
-0.007036315277218819,
0.18858076632022858,
-0.4646056890487671,
0.06580992043018341,
0.30033472180366516,
-0.31445440649986267,
0.18357209861278534,
0.20327481627464294,
0.6684038639068604,
0.2917637228965759,
-0.6506537795066833,
0.29230329394340515,
-0.16590778529644012,
0.0482170544564724,
-0.13835038244724274,
-0.03991416096687317,
-0.04491855949163437,
0.21426153182983398,
0.5531643629074097,
-0.020668450742959976,
0.36728301644325256,
0.0761295035481453,
0.326799601316452,
0.6645352840423584,
0.294675350189209,
0.09756586700677872,
0.9255984425544739,
0.05501272529363632,
0.03214258700609207,
0.12155483663082123,
-0.16950039565563202,
0.024924589321017265,
0.5147485733032227,
0.6795559525489807,
0.9515690803527832,
-0.008648701943457127,
-0.14509862661361694,
0.5767350792884827,
0.1869320273399353,
-0.19100531935691833,
-0.0031407221686095,
-0.5073563456535339,
-0.3356539309024811,
-0.8905498385429382,
-1.2516822814941406,
-0.187967449426651,
0.19275186955928802,
-0.6625515818595886,
-0.020585479214787483,
-0.26011207699775696,
-0.13251586258411407,
-0.09235426783561707,
0.05616948381066322,
-0.25645095109939575,
0.06859397143125534,
0.14860981702804565,
0.8709726929664612,
-0.5769446492195129,
0.8329320549964905,
0.3039800822734833,
-0.047765541821718216,
-0.5744242072105408,
0.20994533598423004,
-0.12894770503044128,
-0.6159074306488037,
0.8593124151229858,
0.15291240811347961,
-0.4455418586730957,
0.004042061045765877,
-0.3854910731315613,
-1.1766189336776733,
0.8201273083686829,
0.5841261148452759,
-0.428035706281662,
-0.006278587505221367,
-0.19351468980312347,
0.4038161635398865,
-0.3110269606113434,
0.15695945918560028,
0.5743189454078674,
0.2709962725639343,
0.2884565591812134,
-0.703770637512207,
0.1659529209136963,
-0.20265041291713715,
0.33042001724243164,
0.4240776598453522,
-0.44577112793922424,
0.8712141513824463,
-0.02797478809952736,
-0.49984610080718994,
0.5151805877685547,
0.7593767046928406,
0.5552748441696167,
0.15284542739391327,
0.40761277079582214,
0.5981858372688293,
0.5628600120544434,
0.17050591111183167,
1.236925721168518,
-0.3883289694786072,
0.14594987034797668,
1.19076669216156,
-0.41557714343070984,
0.7410681247711182,
0.47232434153556824,
0.11072034388780594,
0.2470361888408661,
0.42412808537483215,
0.3539055585861206,
0.38143765926361084,
0.15290306508541107,
-0.5500490665435791,
-0.18330740928649902,
-0.3415001928806305,
-0.08202925324440002,
0.13624343276023865,
0.6694952845573425,
-0.20511099696159363,
-0.43954092264175415,
-0.12830370664596558,
0.032131377607584,
0.1862989366054535,
-0.23826149106025696,
0.7957686185836792,
-0.08954554051160812,
-1.1124602556228638,
1.0953874588012695,
-0.06403196603059769,
0.6515138149261475,
-0.6095091700553894,
-0.2549421489238739,
-0.4242655634880066,
0.08779454976320267,
-0.13364820182323456,
-0.4476330876350403,
0.4254433810710907,
0.21667474508285522,
-0.33335888385772705,
-0.3600896894931793,
1.0578571557998657,
-0.31811580061912537,
-0.24934819340705872,
0.4310372769832611,
0.4364314675331116,
0.22999654710292816,
0.16420693695545197,
-0.591769814491272,
0.40883010625839233,
-0.2515577971935272,
-0.5114800930023193,
0.7320764660835266,
0.6825140118598938,
-0.18485629558563232,
0.3850291073322296,
0.7862196564674377,
0.3631645739078522,
0.10413568466901779,
-0.0917382538318634,
1.2196944952011108,
-0.3215304911136627,
-0.45091521739959717,
-0.40648406744003296,
0.23708024621009827,
-0.1279764622449875,
0.04536200314760208,
0.6834197044372559,
0.48963692784309387,
0.5651417970657349,
0.11332538723945618,
0.6109296083450317,
-0.15833990275859833,
0.8215581178665161,
-0.46808499097824097,
0.5695391297340393,
-0.7987234592437744,
0.38417673110961914,
-0.18162685632705688,
-0.8126009702682495,
-0.1930449903011322,
0.5293183922767639,
-0.1257181614637375,
0.07241477817296982,
0.46626585721969604,
1.0357779264450073,
-0.14052022993564606,
-0.5036362409591675,
0.4676697254180908,
0.20441478490829468,
-0.034231532365083694,
0.30254504084587097,
0.42632266879081726,
-0.15391185879707336,
0.5405087471008301,
-0.08430033177137375,
-0.3241461515426636,
-0.08479300886392593,
-0.7727411389350891,
-0.6885564923286438,
-0.4577363133430481,
0.3863691985607147,
-0.476720929145813,
0.11255189776420593,
0.6870907545089722,
0.6084161996841431,
-0.4056689441204071,
-0.41768524050712585,
-0.13598230481147766,
0.041568394750356674,
0.059510488063097,
-0.2982032895088196,
0.3023017942905426,
-0.9145143032073975,
-0.7995063066482544,
0.6561922430992126,
0.3277204632759094,
-0.26151320338249207,
-0.10804201662540436,
-0.17292006313800812,
-0.21690115332603455,
0.2233601063489914,
0.5415340065956116,
0.4207773208618164,
-0.6525424122810364,
0.08647632598876953,
-0.03410579636693001,
-0.2326994240283966,
-0.11440087854862213,
0.890488862991333,
-1.050987958908081,
0.4124476909637451,
0.6310714483261108,
1.120394229888916,
0.695775032043457,
0.09414376318454742,
0.4573802947998047,
-0.9339921474456787,
0.5334289073944092,
0.3300969898700714,
0.3776196241378784,
0.17483524978160858,
-0.6055948138237,
0.48243656754493713,
0.31154152750968933,
-0.8282846212387085,
-1.0579109191894531,
0.07028590142726898,
-0.8591921329498291,
-0.5819083452224731,
1.2522834539413452,
-0.04151793569326401,
-0.5491483807563782,
-0.13222627341747284,
-0.09291407465934753,
0.2172263264656067,
-0.542474091053009,
0.4788760542869568,
0.17852701246738434,
-0.10734743624925613,
-0.04635988175868988,
-0.7951161861419678,
0.5863062739372253,
0.6855584979057312,
-0.5732926726341248,
0.34491539001464844,
0.9117752909660339,
0.032506782561540604,
0.059249505400657654,
0.8011822700500488,
0.06064574047923088,
0.4104454815387726,
0.18856583535671234,
-0.15543077886104584,
0.12435448169708252,
-0.46604791283607483,
-0.4110059440135956,
0.3109712302684784,
0.05396018177270889,
0.24891556799411774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16176v1
|
Bi-reachability in Petri nets with data
| 2024-05-25T11:00:44 | 2024-05-25T11:00:44 |
Łukasz Kamiński, Sławomir Lasota
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LO
|
We investigate Petri nets with data, an extension of plain Petri nets where
tokens carry values from an infinite data domain, and executability of
transitions is conditioned by equalities between data values. We provide a
decision procedure for the bi-reachability problem: given a Petri net and its
two configurations, we ask if each of the configurations is reachable from the
other. This pushes forward the decidability borderline, as the bi-reachability
problem subsumes the coverability problem (which is known to be decidable) and
is subsumed by the reachability problem (whose decidability status is unknown).
|
[
-0.5276179313659668,
-0.6059495806694031,
0.725244402885437,
0.18782761693000793,
-0.27996793389320374,
0.2838933765888214,
0.06989990174770355,
-0.7756056189537048,
0.170071542263031,
0.7020367980003357,
-0.4667314887046814,
-0.05585779622197151,
-0.34531402587890625,
-0.1132943257689476,
-0.08157331496477127,
1.119737148284912,
-0.2523557245731354,
-0.15869608521461487,
-0.34086981415748596,
-0.2583611309528351,
-0.39612293243408203,
-0.7624036073684692,
-0.3948996961116791,
-0.4907107353210449,
0.28198498487472534,
0.5441656112670898,
0.9096338748931885,
0.521629810333252,
0.7486512660980225,
0.25848618149757385,
-0.3206639587879181,
0.19316837191581726,
-0.24860641360282898,
0.20341365039348602,
-0.5629424452781677,
-0.7136716246604919,
-0.4743524193763733,
0.16841691732406616,
0.7807161808013916,
1.6813875436782837,
0.3475285768508911,
-0.06696148216724396,
-0.16371960937976837,
1.052001714706421,
-0.4687401354312897,
-0.130438432097435,
-0.3404161036014557,
0.4616713225841522,
-0.37267592549324036,
-0.2844676077365875,
-0.46999213099479675,
-0.10218559205532074,
0.28032514452934265,
-0.4733143746852875,
0.17980869114398956,
0.4227532148361206,
0.9456068873405457,
-0.06366199254989624,
-0.6287002563476562,
0.13751955330371857,
-1.1969223022460938,
0.435004323720932,
-0.3241020739078522,
0.49298107624053955,
0.6975269913673401,
0.5738393664360046,
-0.358581006526947,
-0.790249764919281,
-0.4817693531513214,
-0.24534378945827484,
-0.1210700124502182,
0.17948272824287415,
-0.0260063074529171,
0.32729023694992065,
0.6539259552955627,
0.6225039958953857,
-0.8004159331321716,
-0.2174864411354065,
-0.7381817698478699,
0.17727822065353394,
0.21705187857151031,
0.2730380594730377,
0.19381757080554962,
0.27598556876182556,
-0.5055779814720154,
0.13411591947078705,
-0.5861927270889282,
0.25231999158859253,
0.39514246582984924,
0.35800468921661377,
-0.2547686994075775,
0.49351319670677185,
-0.34365734457969666,
0.8632420897483826,
0.015875186771154404,
0.7610837817192078,
0.39248234033584595,
-0.46484771370887756,
-0.09264613687992096,
-0.23635520040988922,
-0.03803926333785057,
0.18513338267803192,
0.18677003681659698,
-0.4842117428779602,
0.0962015688419342,
-0.40001434087753296,
0.404926598072052,
-0.652908444404602,
-0.329898864030838,
0.6126291751861572,
-0.6411190629005432,
0.1577080339193344,
0.17984218895435333,
-0.22643862664699554,
-0.31985950469970703,
-0.4512239098548889,
0.462133526802063,
-0.2029651254415512,
-0.4952184557914734,
0.051927268505096436,
-0.40613850951194763,
0.4136612117290497,
-0.003304065205156803,
-0.7134384512901306,
0.6514215469360352,
0.9812847971916199,
1.0886082649230957,
-0.11040666699409485,
-0.24545849859714508,
-0.38641712069511414,
0.18022039532661438,
-0.6756982803344727,
0.5099816918373108,
-0.5459151864051819,
-0.3535253405570984,
-0.3702740967273712,
0.18018463253974915,
-0.26527124643325806,
-0.272097110748291,
0.3440297544002533,
-0.909476101398468,
-0.06655426323413849,
-0.31034454703330994,
-0.6633520722389221,
-0.49913713335990906,
0.18149986863136292,
-0.8279218673706055,
0.3438069224357605,
0.1989012211561203,
-1.0562572479248047,
0.4225527048110962,
-0.7324263453483582,
-0.4240369200706482,
0.1549321562051773,
0.20933330059051514,
-0.3892723023891449,
-0.06569576263427734,
-0.7857832908630371,
-0.03028111904859543,
-0.04475465416908264,
-0.10302694886922836,
-0.7247333526611328,
-0.32917147874832153,
0.19154635071754456,
-0.24070046842098236,
0.9293910264968872,
0.30169492959976196,
-0.10501877218484879,
-0.23674695193767548,
-0.8504869937896729,
0.367743581533432,
-0.2811121940612793,
-0.5123850107192993,
-0.5011425018310547,
0.2974429130554199,
-0.13363026082515717,
0.13575850427150726,
0.23429039120674133,
-0.8961435556411743,
0.45176011323928833,
-0.5820567607879639,
0.4254278242588043,
0.439785361289978,
0.21614550054073334,
0.4945054352283478,
-0.5068499445915222,
0.1038796529173851,
0.22648249566555023,
0.4361819922924042,
0.3345663547515869,
-0.5442014932632446,
-1.1132997274398804,
0.18802852928638458,
0.49804484844207764,
0.7485689520835876,
-0.5087622404098511,
0.3853476941585541,
-0.029581328853964806,
-0.4807564318180084,
0.15731942653656006,
-0.42701467871665955,
0.44116294384002686,
0.4174356460571289,
0.08895813673734665,
-0.3822709619998932,
-0.7010812163352966,
-1.123334527015686,
0.2887181341648102,
-0.33954885601997375,
0.19471141695976257,
0.2741183042526245,
0.5463221669197083,
-0.0032046909909695387,
0.9838589429855347,
-0.2605680227279663,
0.31467363238334656,
0.04701284319162369,
0.33806297183036804,
0.9128777384757996,
0.8855070471763611,
0.2769820988178253,
-1.360493779182434,
-0.5822555422782898,
0.16069650650024414,
-0.6178908944129944,
-0.11477489024400711,
-0.21918053925037384,
-0.449331670999527,
-0.10116001963615417,
0.4095059931278229,
-0.3193892240524292,
0.731779158115387,
0.16761565208435059,
-0.6053523421287537,
0.5698786973953247,
-0.47127020359039307,
0.1209445595741272,
-0.814634382724762,
0.44290024042129517,
-0.7971605062484741,
-0.7107771039009094,
-1.1140390634536743,
-0.05521111935377121,
-0.027554688975214958,
-0.17857712507247925,
-0.23183611035346985,
0.08380398899316788,
-0.48954465985298157,
-0.47574546933174133,
-0.42071279883384705,
-0.24056249856948853,
0.14020150899887085,
0.3579683303833008,
0.4260309934616089,
0.523284912109375,
0.7565860152244568,
-0.9087127447128296,
0.31401270627975464,
0.3806217908859253,
-0.0488034188747406,
0.9201366305351257,
-0.8481394052505493,
0.14600950479507446,
-0.1794406622648239,
0.4154156744480133,
-0.9795498847961426,
0.17860586941242218,
0.5882623791694641,
-0.4911019802093506,
0.25333696603775024,
-0.39702752232551575,
0.06480155885219574,
-0.3087059259414673,
-0.015044916421175003,
0.5661585927009583,
0.09833846986293793,
-0.47406429052352905,
0.2923988699913025,
0.2331516593694687,
-0.03130772337317467,
-0.3785973787307739,
-0.8624594211578369,
0.2628987431526184,
-0.04326469451189041,
-0.570886492729187,
0.3751243054866791,
-0.5539697408676147,
-0.1364668309688568,
0.17484602332115173,
0.03696618601679802,
-0.4711968004703522,
0.10569678992033005,
0.645399272441864,
0.2973979413509369,
0.15702807903289795,
-0.06253870576620102,
-0.10972508788108826,
-0.37016674876213074,
0.06491781771183014,
-0.22037804126739502,
0.36457356810569763,
-0.38254839181900024,
-0.6442506909370422,
0.17298860847949982,
0.8415977954864502,
0.5314947962760925,
-0.06849465519189835,
0.5816940665245056,
-0.11313934624195099,
-0.5161541104316711,
-0.1992134153842926,
-0.011011622846126556,
0.20678411424160004,
-0.4537452161312103,
-0.044529300183057785,
-1.043968677520752,
-0.4173828661441803,
1.0758713483810425,
-0.022778255864977837,
0.4139736592769623,
0.20263469219207764,
0.2943167984485626,
-0.05647891014814377,
0.8474286794662476,
0.6111598610877991,
0.447665274143219,
0.24329595267772675,
-0.36938345432281494,
0.15868252515792847,
-0.9543548822402954,
-0.36643335223197937,
-0.5280685424804688,
-0.5063670873641968,
-0.8497856259346008,
-0.23701845109462738,
0.5996958017349243,
0.30704963207244873,
-0.4879261553287506,
0.5667071342468262,
-0.42479845881462097,
0.53050297498703,
0.7107267379760742,
0.3733985722064972,
0.23276814818382263,
-0.428918719291687,
-0.5364559888839722,
0.3265424072742462,
-0.6581047177314758,
0.04329400882124901,
0.5491460561752319,
0.16139626502990723,
0.06702325493097305,
0.27750372886657715,
0.2985144555568695,
0.6005605459213257,
-0.23865270614624023,
-0.39689213037490845,
0.2641180455684662,
-0.04852569103240967,
-1.0981942415237427,
-0.22576211392879486,
-0.4805036187171936,
-1.1046448945999146,
0.20920991897583008,
-0.04428894817829132,
-0.854144811630249,
0.8944061398506165,
-0.15383478999137878,
-0.2707853317260742,
0.5436075925827026,
-0.48823583126068115,
0.5842061042785645,
-0.3079870045185089,
-0.15262873470783234,
-0.14098995923995972,
-1.1986721754074097,
0.25958454608917236,
-0.15653501451015472,
-0.012986965477466583,
-0.1482643336057663,
-0.30695396661758423,
0.578440248966217,
-0.9399377703666687,
0.7145400643348694,
-0.14510361850261688,
0.439511239528656,
0.08704680949449539,
0.1516837179660797,
0.3321671187877655,
-0.1404576152563095,
-0.31731128692626953,
0.2215835303068161,
0.42344725131988525,
-0.6133102774620056,
-0.6216139793395996,
0.007857928983867168,
-0.5496637225151062,
-0.25410789251327515,
-0.5671789050102234,
-0.11437655240297318,
-0.5732653737068176,
0.24447263777256012,
0.2400343120098114,
0.3010641038417816,
-0.04602891951799393,
0.20246797800064087,
0.45550569891929626,
0.18031078577041626,
0.5624040365219116,
1.0648356676101685,
-0.013667410239577293,
-0.30004337430000305,
0.8769344091415405,
0.44738179445266724,
0.44787314534187317,
0.35945001244544983,
-0.10300273448228836,
-0.18505984544754028,
-0.4901077449321747,
-0.7397499680519104,
-0.1845797747373581,
-0.45569437742233276,
0.007452563848346472,
-0.13625186681747437,
-0.9830078482627869,
0.32555991411209106,
-0.27796974778175354,
-0.3860395848751068,
-0.617241621017456,
0.025104038417339325,
-0.06598704308271408,
0.368530809879303,
0.42078474164009094,
-0.9197809100151062,
-0.002503720112144947,
-0.6739141345024109,
0.27916133403778076,
0.1009763851761818,
0.8724800944328308,
-0.39908528327941895,
-0.6947341561317444,
-0.33779582381248474,
0.05770919844508171,
0.11432796716690063,
-0.9900912046432495,
-0.1374412626028061,
0.27859196066856384,
0.38426539301872253,
0.5202599167823792,
0.4067328870296478,
0.36224865913391113,
-0.5622244477272034,
0.5065100789070129,
0.22324714064598083,
-0.9835193753242493,
0.3271740674972534,
-0.3558073937892914,
-0.10894200950860977,
0.8151810765266418,
0.6042966842651367,
-0.7570963501930237,
0.1284104585647583,
-0.6767301559448242,
-0.8635695576667786,
0.5777364373207092,
0.3828919231891632,
0.0026603895239531994,
0.4407491683959961,
0.4512801468372345,
0.242865651845932,
0.14164724946022034,
-0.2878941297531128,
-0.34904736280441284,
-0.0422549769282341,
0.6477022767066956,
0.4139613211154938,
-0.20571169257164001,
0.052074313163757324,
-0.16467665135860443,
0.5853281021118164,
0.1986839771270752,
0.24133062362670898,
0.051253870129585266,
0.5324950814247131,
-0.17811164259910583,
0.12278485298156738,
0.08389024436473846,
1.209396481513977,
-0.5941707491874695,
0.35497528314590454,
0.0925489217042923,
-0.4583648145198822,
0.37186187505722046,
0.1590104103088379,
-0.4223098158836365,
-0.11965443193912506,
-0.00043309744796715677,
1.0495558977127075,
-0.27490368485450745,
-0.28063786029815674,
0.4463721513748169,
0.12417720258235931,
-0.360822856426239,
-0.3625485897064209,
0.0071288724429905415,
-0.24039888381958008,
0.49394136667251587,
0.021415770053863525,
0.02150852419435978,
0.5011482834815979,
-0.42764928936958313,
0.5472452640533447,
0.32464152574539185,
-0.3294193744659424,
-0.16669122874736786,
0.5840235352516174,
0.2555479407310486,
-0.45476359128952026,
0.7355625629425049,
-0.26880741119384766,
-0.6221755146980286,
0.7188464999198914,
0.5733724236488342,
0.7403937578201294,
0.062055282294750214,
0.24403919279575348,
0.003923596348613501,
0.2572076618671417,
0.3799917995929718,
0.495561420917511,
-0.40394845604896545,
-0.7982876300811768,
-0.47286105155944824,
-0.36272597312927246,
-1.227419137954712,
0.1795918494462967,
-0.7473993301391602,
0.13769900798797607,
-0.46796751022338867,
-0.17043763399124146,
0.4638737142086029,
0.11342528462409973,
-0.31397172808647156,
0.4287506937980652,
0.0352185033261776,
0.932894766330719,
-0.9185248613357544,
0.4056722819805145,
0.6619611978530884,
-0.49040937423706055,
-0.36694395542144775,
-0.40557166934013367,
-0.5764899253845215,
-0.32950565218925476,
0.6454151272773743,
-0.14875952899456024,
0.05121240392327309,
-0.39905938506126404,
-0.4107638895511627,
-0.9888057112693787,
0.49506711959838867,
0.23302271962165833,
-0.21479849517345428,
0.03334926441311836,
0.6846648454666138,
0.2951515316963196,
0.1936143934726715,
0.5549259781837463,
0.5361500382423401,
0.8583595752716064,
0.34008273482322693,
-1.0809991359710693,
-0.18205244839191437,
-0.7284163236618042,
-0.20537565648555756,
0.1846100389957428,
-0.9585731029510498,
0.8623777031898499,
0.08185876160860062,
-0.07128355652093887,
-0.2499963492155075,
0.5290533900260925,
0.03604574874043465,
0.5600178241729736,
0.962276816368103,
0.6610739827156067,
0.812462329864502,
0.030019838362932205,
0.5442302823066711,
-0.19069264829158783,
0.27860915660858154,
0.928491473197937,
-0.10627604275941849,
0.7750635743141174,
0.10036937147378922,
-0.6162438988685608,
0.48025187849998474,
1.1186515092849731,
0.12341183423995972,
0.3015170395374298,
0.394940048456192,
-0.2541205883026123,
-0.5741063356399536,
-0.05286049470305443,
-0.4982232451438904,
0.5680218935012817,
0.4149075150489807,
-0.16225707530975342,
-0.40618428587913513,
0.10267268121242523,
-0.13749000430107117,
-0.4305737018585205,
-0.19714921712875366,
0.5276643633842468,
-0.008130514062941074,
-0.43807950615882874,
0.633544385433197,
-0.018321478739380836,
-0.1112886443734169,
-0.5716760158538818,
-0.19191725552082062,
-0.27187928557395935,
-0.10597304999828339,
-0.41057297587394714,
-1.0131365060806274,
0.7646304965019226,
-0.09745962172746658,
-0.9284369349479675,
-0.13693879544734955,
0.7409577369689941,
-0.1331796795129776,
-0.2353268414735794,
0.07212334871292114,
0.43600112199783325,
0.8088133931159973,
0.20368091762065887,
-0.48456668853759766,
-0.2263297438621521,
-0.2728383541107178,
-0.49488818645477295,
0.13031402230262756,
0.23851005733013153,
-0.18443144857883453,
0.7826066017150879,
0.4863644540309906,
0.24986915290355682,
0.26705998182296753,
-0.3263292610645294,
1.094789743423462,
-0.4307771325111389,
-0.7053847908973694,
-0.4641515612602234,
0.26238834857940674,
-0.2609502971172333,
-0.0482332780957222,
0.43402430415153503,
0.8678004145622253,
0.6080082654953003,
0.2004304975271225,
0.9598013758659363,
-0.43118345737457275,
0.8303030133247375,
-0.3284357190132141,
0.5246684551239014,
-0.39724400639533997,
-0.09369290620088577,
0.11850554496049881,
-0.7745556235313416,
-0.12950678169727325,
0.47032713890075684,
-0.3893406093120575,
0.015251603908836842,
0.5596231818199158,
0.4381140470504761,
-0.3868318200111389,
0.1326323002576828,
0.3509976267814636,
-0.17488433420658112,
0.11181039363145828,
1.0164358615875244,
0.6688668727874756,
-0.029602639377117157,
0.29823169112205505,
-0.15135906636714935,
-0.4813106954097748,
-0.0450998991727829,
-0.9496811032295227,
-0.5931023955345154,
-0.8824486136436462,
-0.1625586450099945,
-0.4752448499202728,
0.3626503050327301,
0.4261145293712616,
1.2126116752624512,
-1.0623691082000732,
-0.05467144399881363,
-0.5088571906089783,
0.347873330116272,
-0.15438686311244965,
-0.15368366241455078,
0.520663321018219,
-0.22790540754795074,
-0.7320913076400757,
0.3870970606803894,
0.16409575939178467,
-0.010489314794540405,
-0.17061910033226013,
0.10909635573625565,
-0.1720711886882782,
0.46642962098121643,
0.1061379536986351,
1.031248688697815,
0.2552775740623474,
-0.33836600184440613,
-0.372368186712265,
0.22003275156021118,
0.004151628352701664,
0.8367269039154053,
-0.6126362085342407,
0.8108255863189697,
1.1351873874664307,
0.7711172699928284,
0.7353211045265198,
0.32093313336372375,
0.4473475515842438,
-0.5230846405029297,
0.10888470709323883,
0.18192628026008606,
0.3327607214450836,
-0.07491485029459,
-0.25334468483924866,
0.8869702219963074,
0.4627627432346344,
-0.8126432299613953,
-0.4427008330821991,
0.5491660833358765,
-1.2935981750488281,
-0.2269735187292099,
0.8954603672027588,
-0.3716667890548706,
-0.09833163768053055,
-0.6277291178703308,
-0.12477883696556091,
0.270856648683548,
0.31290218234062195,
0.3032197952270508,
0.4668070077896118,
-0.6552905440330505,
0.23448653519153595,
-0.5413676500320435,
0.29772743582725525,
0.39343756437301636,
-0.7795018553733826,
0.040001921355724335,
0.37670886516571045,
0.19391632080078125,
0.18619680404663086,
0.4830682873725891,
0.1621730774641037,
0.1699647754430771,
0.17866522073745728,
-0.2685634195804596,
-0.37836843729019165,
-0.48875558376312256,
0.09922903776168823,
0.07071799039840698,
-0.09903733432292938,
-0.8462293148040771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.16155v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.16155v2
|
Improving Multi-lingual Alignment Through Soft Contrastive Learning
| 2024-05-25T09:46:07 | 2024-05-28T04:51:35 |
Minsu Park, Seyeon Choi, Chanyeol Choi, Jun-Seong Kim, Jy-yong Sohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Making decent multi-lingual sentence representations is critical to achieve
high performances in cross-lingual downstream tasks. In this work, we propose a
novel method to align multi-lingual embeddings based on the similarity of
sentences measured by a pre-trained mono-lingual embedding model. Given
translation sentence pairs, we train a multi-lingual model in a way that the
similarity between cross-lingual embeddings follows the similarity of sentences
measured at the mono-lingual teacher model. Our method can be considered as
contrastive learning with soft labels defined as the similarity between
sentences. Our experimental results on five languages show that our contrastive
loss with soft labels far outperforms conventional contrastive loss with hard
labels in various benchmarks for bitext mining tasks and STS tasks. In
addition, our method outperforms existing multi-lingual embeddings including
LaBSE, for Tatoeba dataset. The code is available at
https://github.com/YAI12xLinq-B/IMASCL
|
[
-0.1995173841714859,
-0.33873143792152405,
0.2047828733921051,
-0.05325520038604736,
-0.42456743121147156,
0.08359625935554504,
-0.4272253215312958,
-0.21208354830741882,
0.451892226934433,
0.19347898662090302,
-0.5347471237182617,
-0.5948702692985535,
-0.3343116343021393,
0.06332655251026154,
0.11615116149187088,
1.0613644123077393,
-0.22136573493480682,
0.39409443736076355,
-0.0031129505950957537,
-0.6704145669937134,
-0.5112436413764954,
-0.2059042751789093,
-0.17611928284168243,
-0.40324681997299194,
0.6796117424964905,
0.4324478805065155,
0.7225064635276794,
0.36300206184387207,
0.31103515625,
0.3726521134376526,
0.013022252358496189,
0.2722678482532501,
-0.4784720242023468,
-0.05205810070037842,
-0.3352331817150116,
-0.33376532793045044,
-0.09326440095901489,
-0.1745988130569458,
0.6429644227027893,
0.8443030118942261,
-0.048755425959825516,
-0.2295224666595459,
0.35425257682800293,
0.37475475668907166,
-0.39026108384132385,
-0.024472439661622047,
-0.3412507474422455,
0.38270267844200134,
-0.17589735984802246,
-0.03956835716962814,
-0.40307629108428955,
-0.37118807435035706,
0.19033178687095642,
-0.7041727304458618,
0.12617544829845428,
0.08246257901191711,
1.0900697708129883,
0.07483118027448654,
-0.6116047501564026,
-0.27410709857940674,
-0.07009246945381165,
0.9115092158317566,
-0.6721330285072327,
0.5540449023246765,
-0.32958951592445374,
0.03128134086728096,
0.3125021755695343,
-0.3738716244697571,
-0.38208937644958496,
0.09240968525409698,
-0.3609614670276642,
0.26185280084609985,
0.3508051633834839,
-0.15598595142364502,
-0.41832709312438965,
0.37314292788505554,
-0.6635341644287109,
0.27129408717155457,
-0.12677083909511566,
-0.40826645493507385,
0.14204607903957367,
-0.028800906613469124,
0.3662949502468109,
0.010295707732439041,
-0.9808993339538574,
-0.29610496759414673,
-0.5936954021453857,
-0.18750803172588348,
0.40299150347709656,
0.7457090020179749,
-0.38996899127960205,
0.3812074661254883,
0.2517978250980377,
0.4509184956550598,
-0.0250437892973423,
-0.1089363619685173,
0.8238970041275024,
-0.6963997483253479,
0.10007178038358688,
0.48491066694259644,
0.7952298521995544,
0.4885348081588745,
0.4966556429862976,
-0.35323193669319153,
-0.2352062314748764,
-0.07891126722097397,
0.051369402557611465,
-0.7949455380439758,
-0.15253899991512299,
-0.24691887199878693,
-0.3142656087875366,
-0.16224803030490875,
0.042604535818099976,
-0.6082664728164673,
-0.35260170698165894,
-0.3122422993183136,
0.5984017848968506,
-0.6198955774307251,
-0.46713289618492126,
0.05358186736702919,
-0.02021840214729309,
0.2843937277793884,
-0.21768134832382202,
-0.8023979663848877,
0.28299885988235474,
0.6927863359451294,
0.9087420105934143,
0.035692572593688965,
-0.6644472479820251,
-0.5533775091171265,
0.21041633188724518,
-0.49228543043136597,
0.5373083353042603,
-0.3080194294452667,
0.0910174623131752,
0.2894013822078705,
0.09321437776088715,
-0.3478763997554779,
-0.41236668825149536,
0.21006692945957184,
-0.36697274446487427,
0.3150724470615387,
0.13904081284999847,
-0.6065487265586853,
-0.26191049814224243,
0.5427300333976746,
-0.6775570511817932,
0.7386817932128906,
0.09289470314979553,
-0.9064146280288696,
0.3445053696632385,
-0.2838051915168762,
-0.5804434418678284,
-0.15403829514980316,
-0.13955339789390564,
-0.6793075799942017,
-0.04921235516667366,
0.16590753197669983,
0.5897179841995239,
0.09416118264198303,
0.3779180943965912,
-0.3589196801185608,
-0.4508160650730133,
0.23211516439914703,
-0.15548111498355865,
0.7576847076416016,
0.18055571615695953,
-0.4825347661972046,
0.20274390280246735,
-0.3991537392139435,
0.1260034292936325,
0.04166414961218834,
-0.12614774703979492,
-0.7330124974250793,
-0.41083624958992004,
0.309620201587677,
0.284379780292511,
0.2825029492378235,
-0.6369614601135254,
0.14419561624526978,
-0.6586417555809021,
0.21773697435855865,
0.9937245845794678,
-0.4439116418361664,
0.5596974492073059,
-0.16116008162498474,
0.3550865054130554,
0.41587379574775696,
-0.2174905389547348,
-0.3603156805038452,
-0.005985579453408718,
-0.42641758918762207,
-0.1548968404531479,
0.9129457473754883,
0.656974196434021,
-0.8347621560096741,
0.3510512709617615,
-0.6865261197090149,
-0.36555215716362,
-0.8804242610931396,
0.5270835161209106,
0.9346088767051697,
0.5656905174255371,
0.4793332517147064,
-0.3791607618331909,
-0.38501131534576416,
-1.0238100290298462,
-0.1481628566980362,
0.37298843264579773,
0.1193380281329155,
0.20404385030269623,
0.2989589273929596,
-0.333103209733963,
0.4742565453052521,
-0.48606574535369873,
-0.5580332279205322,
-0.16104376316070557,
0.33055534958839417,
0.10123618692159653,
0.8170555233955383,
0.5686185359954834,
-1.0180115699768066,
-0.6259338855743408,
0.30905860662460327,
-0.6348636150360107,
-0.10318012535572052,
0.012796586379408836,
-0.27958279848098755,
0.3953675627708435,
0.5826881527900696,
-0.12437114119529724,
-0.2053162008523941,
0.7155044078826904,
-0.49980244040489197,
0.2909983992576599,
-0.21444764733314514,
0.3805104196071625,
-1.3716000318527222,
-0.040711771696805954,
0.1582106202840805,
-0.2714232802391052,
-0.33830884099006653,
0.08121593296527863,
0.3445023000240326,
-0.07954291254281998,
-0.8202593922615051,
0.5077589154243469,
-0.6359774470329285,
0.07754596322774887,
-0.04391312226653099,
0.43129557371139526,
0.1818486452102661,
0.7345389723777771,
0.1297299563884735,
0.6970354914665222,
0.6003157496452332,
-0.5153153538703918,
0.0877375602722168,
0.38958537578582764,
-0.5680968761444092,
0.811694860458374,
-0.35387665033340454,
0.05739102512598038,
-0.028008868917822838,
0.09829548746347427,
-1.096676230430603,
0.21811334788799286,
0.1759810596704483,
-0.22462432086467743,
0.6176241636276245,
-0.07535692304372787,
-0.39076346158981323,
0.12852318584918976,
-0.5950131416320801,
0.7409469485282898,
0.1490863412618637,
-0.6942371726036072,
0.610579252243042,
0.22712254524230957,
-0.2757405936717987,
-0.7531111836433411,
-0.9550358653068542,
-0.09640201181173325,
-0.3287258446216583,
-0.5869147181510925,
0.8223185539245605,
-0.09793005138635635,
0.07278043776750565,
0.26035526394844055,
-0.002224864438176155,
0.0024959687143564224,
-0.07718559354543686,
-0.06240110471844673,
0.28292831778526306,
-0.656112790107727,
0.41995036602020264,
0.048313289880752563,
-0.2913665175437927,
-0.36170944571495056,
-0.24777553975582123,
0.5639868378639221,
-0.3439071774482727,
-0.12658646702766418,
-0.08001979440450668,
0.43982958793640137,
0.11279051005840302,
-0.21235765516757965,
0.7709411978721619,
1.0367693901062012,
-0.27799826860427856,
0.08517152816057205,
-0.394398957490921,
-0.015480819158256054,
-0.47867122292518616,
0.29368340969085693,
-0.6560022830963135,
-0.7673392295837402,
0.35818734765052795,
-0.18607549369335175,
-0.0073671950958669186,
0.22222064435482025,
0.22255869209766388,
0.10620047897100449,
1.0533469915390015,
0.8185715675354004,
-0.14443102478981018,
0.3701651692390442,
-0.03149991109967232,
0.21963970363140106,
-0.6657548546791077,
-0.308282732963562,
-0.37432733178138733,
-0.48929065465927124,
-0.9066575765609741,
-0.20143817365169525,
0.09818989783525467,
-0.1368013620376587,
-0.3048093020915985,
0.37504783272743225,
-0.4562308192253113,
0.4413895308971405,
0.4966992437839508,
0.2629150450229645,
-0.22840231657028198,
-0.10972858220338821,
-0.4002062678337097,
-0.33077895641326904,
-0.7045505046844482,
-0.3252984881401062,
0.6521591544151306,
-0.014966718852519989,
0.8662239909172058,
0.2635975480079651,
1.0229722261428833,
0.009894018992781639,
0.27394944429397583,
-0.6264995336532593,
0.33280161023139954,
-0.502966046333313,
-0.2475883513689041,
-0.04762660339474678,
-0.5780901312828064,
-1.0780737400054932,
0.5130057334899902,
-0.24506396055221558,
-0.4054485857486725,
-0.049779560416936874,
0.022682689130306244,
-0.15975424647331238,
0.300841748714447,
-1.1825282573699951,
1.3490772247314453,
-0.39977508783340454,
-0.5645137429237366,
0.03699508309364319,
-0.7399430871009827,
0.14741122722625732,
0.14405065774917603,
0.29994794726371765,
0.06290965527296066,
-0.2749352753162384,
0.9582972526550293,
-0.39024287462234497,
0.8581164479255676,
-0.25819432735443115,
-0.17057660222053528,
0.0801173597574234,
-0.026936285197734833,
0.09360294044017792,
-0.29045334458351135,
-0.046385735273361206,
0.07183390110731125,
-0.10460145771503448,
-0.6421270966529846,
-0.4441641569137573,
1.092082142829895,
-0.5561822652816772,
-0.2021857649087906,
-0.4334935247898102,
-0.5049373507499695,
-0.2393750697374344,
0.3777446150779724,
0.14955468475818634,
0.6176643371582031,
-0.22250525653362274,
0.08882738649845123,
0.7091369032859802,
-0.21551154553890228,
0.25649383664131165,
0.4436090588569641,
0.04406438022851944,
-0.608683705329895,
1.2403898239135742,
0.07432973384857178,
0.011347215622663498,
0.7552909255027771,
0.379159539937973,
-0.6071175336837769,
-0.2863108217716217,
-0.423378050327301,
0.3385029733181,
-0.6453015804290771,
-0.5041866898536682,
-0.4988063871860504,
0.23326656222343445,
-0.7022610306739807,
-0.5412037968635559,
-0.3067982792854309,
-0.10686284303665161,
-0.12974813580513,
-0.11356111615896225,
0.022556154057383537,
0.4647696614265442,
-0.225931778550148,
0.22659742832183838,
-0.8566968441009521,
0.2167542427778244,
0.08405251055955887,
0.5487281680107117,
-0.24149079620838165,
-0.3909686505794525,
-0.3448532521724701,
-0.0864032730460167,
-0.21291519701480865,
-0.8046972155570984,
0.30702483654022217,
0.3247731924057007,
0.4893653988838196,
0.4580899775028229,
-0.026308169588446617,
0.80226731300354,
-0.6696814894676208,
0.48343849182128906,
0.5670342445373535,
-1.1696966886520386,
0.3897262513637543,
0.0524364672601223,
0.5541304349899292,
0.8616158366203308,
0.5596516728401184,
-0.5069730877876282,
-0.11525600403547287,
-0.4530653655529022,
-1.0592894554138184,
0.5609133243560791,
-0.2124951034784317,
0.2673276662826538,
0.030614539980888367,
-0.06311040371656418,
0.42427748441696167,
0.05582086369395256,
-1.0598232746124268,
-0.2418101280927658,
-0.32378876209259033,
-0.7963888645172119,
-0.36192435026168823,
-0.11210063099861145,
0.03153743967413902,
0.07624287903308868,
0.8389794230461121,
-0.3270170986652374,
-0.06535640358924866,
-0.05894596129655838,
-0.42826464772224426,
0.18366120755672455,
0.4247109591960907,
0.33873751759529114,
0.3467864990234375,
-0.05199325084686279,
0.5664064884185791,
0.3035215437412262,
-0.08412125706672668,
0.1953672170639038,
0.412863165140152,
0.0838550254702568,
0.06349291652441025,
0.28841766715049744,
0.49108925461769104,
0.9518903493881226,
-0.8406941890716553,
0.6596649289131165,
0.14049944281578064,
-0.12494800239801407,
0.08073975145816803,
-0.30771833658218384,
0.17497147619724274,
0.14790043234825134,
-0.17784467339515686,
-0.13039425015449524,
0.12953750789165497,
-0.5329436659812927,
0.2699248492717743,
0.3059632480144501,
-0.6880003809928894,
-0.1282382607460022,
0.3628949224948883,
0.28175345063209534,
-0.17035606503486633,
0.7722997069358826,
-0.13653495907783508,
-0.9096171259880066,
0.37191373109817505,
0.7460722327232361,
0.4426461458206177,
-0.5295529961585999,
0.24083690345287323,
0.4740276634693146,
0.17563003301620483,
0.19830390810966492,
0.014312535524368286,
-0.028760667890310287,
-0.7154768705368042,
-0.4235137403011322,
-0.3512411415576935,
-0.41177064180374146,
-0.10883628576993942,
-0.6380487084388733,
0.3027419149875641,
0.15544742345809937,
0.31954166293144226,
0.05237575247883797,
0.13658982515335083,
-0.7011129260063171,
0.2511211335659027,
0.3737523853778839,
0.5717595219612122,
-1.017802119255066,
0.6284263134002686,
0.7118558883666992,
-0.36674219369888306,
-0.7671281695365906,
-0.22081789374351501,
-0.10580707341432571,
-0.797190248966217,
0.408995121717453,
0.7973375916481018,
-0.32215097546577454,
-0.2570960819721222,
-0.29050251841545105,
-0.6222903728485107,
0.9367026686668396,
0.4485592544078827,
-0.6053422689437866,
0.2891974151134491,
0.06511855125427246,
0.4040188491344452,
-0.38686856627464294,
0.21534302830696106,
0.1517147570848465,
0.5193784832954407,
-0.22779975831508636,
-0.6034902930259705,
0.2166726291179657,
-0.5660470724105835,
-0.08536595851182938,
0.5607107877731323,
-0.5563262701034546,
0.5863098502159119,
-0.24393297731876373,
-0.3016079366207123,
-0.08391116559505463,
0.7905650734901428,
0.15356048941612244,
0.3732984960079193,
0.7408288717269897,
0.5739734768867493,
0.6510403156280518,
-0.14177341759204865,
0.7685853242874146,
-0.1813039481639862,
0.21897077560424805,
1.2096812725067139,
-0.36056479811668396,
0.737960696220398,
0.6270835995674133,
0.2977120578289032,
0.7473310828208923,
0.5863893032073975,
-0.10573431849479675,
0.8330243825912476,
0.2705478072166443,
-0.006917422637343407,
-0.2521265745162964,
-0.26746314764022827,
-0.33693987131118774,
0.1503857970237732,
0.2059015929698944,
-0.16586138308048248,
-0.21525122225284576,
0.3067783713340759,
0.15140679478645325,
0.48845648765563965,
-0.3425913453102112,
0.7568061351776123,
0.008566743694245815,
-0.8438376784324646,
0.593690037727356,
-0.07799412310123444,
1.303381323814392,
-0.6812412142753601,
-0.04598226025700569,
-0.21510779857635498,
0.473432719707489,
-0.1377820521593094,
-0.8442041873931885,
0.19919122755527496,
-0.22922520339488983,
0.10575661063194275,
-0.41733628511428833,
0.4780530035495758,
-0.9844086170196533,
-0.32283392548561096,
0.5718809962272644,
0.42148515582084656,
0.1263616979122162,
0.31508737802505493,
-0.8754045963287354,
-0.08175045251846313,
-0.020177669823169708,
-0.14205017685890198,
0.44642171263694763,
0.4767487049102783,
0.16912224888801575,
0.3364882469177246,
0.08436374366283417,
-0.2673940658569336,
-0.04489423707127571,
0.40036892890930176,
0.6272733807563782,
-0.787369430065155,
-0.7367138266563416,
-0.6976091861724854,
0.3721938133239746,
-0.005578800104558468,
-0.4382779896259308,
0.49119454622268677,
0.8106869459152222,
1.142116665840149,
-0.1589026004076004,
0.3402998447418213,
0.06064532697200775,
0.5014916062355042,
-0.8469052910804749,
0.374897837638855,
-0.8440831303596497,
-0.14933207631111145,
-0.2085275650024414,
-0.8494808077812195,
-0.2297998070716858,
0.45489975810050964,
-0.048351164907217026,
0.03531812131404877,
0.9292048215866089,
0.9015061259269714,
-0.5564030408859253,
-0.2952635884284973,
0.2136155366897583,
0.12116514146327972,
0.03433114290237427,
0.8453789353370667,
0.518181324005127,
-0.5843527317047119,
1.0835391283035278,
-0.4568442404270172,
0.02873993292450905,
-0.058870818465948105,
-0.8566250205039978,
-0.6848459243774414,
-0.7920684814453125,
-0.70582515001297,
-0.34092625975608826,
0.13536188006401062,
0.7529377937316895,
0.5767511129379272,
-0.8241074085235596,
-0.09482313692569733,
0.15729869902133942,
0.29477232694625854,
-0.5363661646842957,
-0.2799008786678314,
0.6225941181182861,
-0.6061162948608398,
-0.9816418886184692,
0.3422949016094208,
-0.037306737154722214,
0.22750581800937653,
0.03092350997030735,
-0.25542762875556946,
-0.60997474193573,
-0.15700264275074005,
0.3147243559360504,
0.034416526556015015,
-0.45124849677085876,
-0.22156009078025818,
-0.1684318333864212,
-0.4024605453014374,
0.25033682584762573,
0.726731538772583,
-0.7113313674926758,
0.3715844452381134,
0.43627890944480896,
0.6984338164329529,
0.5048238039016724,
-0.11862147599458694,
0.4435884654521942,
-1.068516731262207,
0.1097530722618103,
0.11061111092567444,
0.654233992099762,
0.8416902422904968,
-0.032461024820804596,
0.6562061905860901,
-0.10797221958637238,
-0.22346049547195435,
-0.6957781314849854,
0.04902079328894615,
-1.2123932838439941,
-0.4351780414581299,
0.9024801254272461,
-0.4169376790523529,
-0.2969248592853546,
0.01148528978228569,
-0.2932088375091553,
0.4274473190307617,
-0.12407432496547699,
0.5926035046577454,
0.533434271812439,
0.3647715449333191,
-0.09614954888820648,
0.15880711376667023,
0.04327927157282829,
0.7622392773628235,
-0.5565071105957031,
-0.24767938256263733,
0.24899308383464813,
0.3010028302669525,
0.5715160965919495,
0.3214816749095917,
-0.04203224182128906,
0.23206250369548798,
0.0491652749478817,
0.20829544961452484,
-0.017753878608345985,
-0.12737639248371124,
-0.39725199341773987,
0.33003637194633484,
-0.33378511667251587,
-0.48829880356788635
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.