id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14982v1
|
In-context Time Series Predictor
| 2024-05-23T18:37:00 | 2024-05-23T18:37:00 |
Jiecheng Lu, Yan Sun, Shihao Yang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Recent Transformer-based large language models (LLMs) demonstrate in-context
learning ability to perform various functions based solely on the provided
context, without updating model parameters. To fully utilize the in-context
capabilities in time series forecasting (TSF) problems, unlike previous
Transformer-based or LLM-based time series forecasting methods, we reformulate
"time series forecasting tasks" as input tokens by constructing a series of
(lookback, future) pairs within the tokens. This method aligns more closely
with the inherent in-context mechanisms, and is more parameter-efficient
without the need of using pre-trained LLM parameters. Furthermore, it addresses
issues such as overfitting in existing Transformer-based TSF models,
consistently achieving better performance across full-data, few-shot, and
zero-shot settings compared to previous architectures.
|
[
-0.19253437221050262,
-0.29484936594963074,
0.4398757517337799,
0.18204213678836823,
-0.41189661622047424,
0.23556900024414062,
-0.05313283950090408,
-0.29780465364456177,
0.10686961561441422,
0.42985332012176514,
-0.9318533539772034,
-0.06868186593055725,
-0.5605068802833557,
0.12184371054172516,
-0.583901047706604,
0.8750604391098022,
-0.23312602937221527,
0.10115659981966019,
-0.09759441018104553,
0.057391513139009476,
-0.40206483006477356,
-0.5477031469345093,
-0.5081567764282227,
-0.6490551829338074,
0.3813023567199707,
0.4856007397174835,
0.4537525475025177,
0.5243986248970032,
0.41261395812034607,
0.2505265474319458,
0.04582025483250618,
0.10326889902353287,
-0.34421950578689575,
0.3046571910381317,
0.2511483132839203,
-0.2968102991580963,
-0.2670879662036896,
-0.22839945554733276,
0.6926305294036865,
0.6792414784431458,
-0.15180383622646332,
0.3618049621582031,
0.10573089867830276,
0.18421302735805511,
-0.4128739833831787,
0.3903560936450958,
-0.4734635055065155,
0.21480637788772583,
-0.07311777025461197,
-0.5979238152503967,
-0.5166574120521545,
-0.05988376587629318,
0.33031588792800903,
-0.381522536277771,
0.2544821798801422,
0.20331288874149323,
0.5545162558555603,
0.48552411794662476,
-0.6071147322654724,
0.35397687554359436,
-1.0867958068847656,
0.9889419078826904,
-0.9591398239135742,
0.4129995107650757,
0.06654874980449677,
0.6303452253341675,
-0.1266685277223587,
-0.8284093737602234,
-0.3311340808868408,
0.15616467595100403,
-0.2503977119922638,
0.049446795135736465,
0.11998994648456573,
-0.2706886827945709,
0.37992042303085327,
0.2036779224872589,
-0.24317339062690735,
0.030455920845270157,
-0.2535945475101471,
0.14609678089618683,
0.20482796430587769,
0.5281674265861511,
-0.2936156094074249,
-0.08696509152650833,
-0.5594888925552368,
0.09949319809675217,
-0.7482165694236755,
0.03184125944972038,
-0.19168560206890106,
0.5753667950630188,
-0.28037595748901367,
0.416655033826828,
-0.03720071166753769,
0.47042596340179443,
0.1119656041264534,
-0.4529491662979126,
0.11769638955593109,
-0.10868631303310394,
-0.5681589245796204,
0.07890431582927704,
0.299699068069458,
0.3305928111076355,
0.011837505735456944,
-0.45292574167251587,
-0.19531895220279694,
-0.36214712262153625,
0.005091882776468992,
-1.1076580286026,
0.2636851966381073,
0.16789314150810242,
-0.3376114070415497,
-0.5678688883781433,
0.07223707437515259,
-0.6941642165184021,
-0.20152853429317474,
-0.5558698773384094,
0.29709160327911377,
-0.23182491958141327,
0.056506454944610596,
-0.34358230233192444,
-0.1364610493183136,
0.5507472157478333,
0.13917088508605957,
-0.7554839253425598,
0.4592778980731964,
0.5745772123336792,
0.9725999236106873,
-0.3759750723838806,
-0.2786123752593994,
-0.8140686750411987,
0.49325019121170044,
-0.11756711453199387,
0.6451019644737244,
-0.5510002970695496,
-0.7980596423149109,
0.032366763800382614,
0.22617611289024353,
0.12977419793605804,
-0.30514663457870483,
0.19644951820373535,
-0.6264020800590515,
0.2722020745277405,
-0.29956310987472534,
-0.557502031326294,
-0.1709021031856537,
0.28544726967811584,
-0.5016345977783203,
1.2088927030563354,
0.2814476191997528,
-0.5464159846305847,
0.5836036205291748,
-0.8382326364517212,
-0.5280749201774597,
0.0062441457994282246,
0.15515395998954773,
-0.2947272062301636,
-0.1879042387008667,
0.6199227571487427,
0.9517732858657837,
-0.4316464960575104,
0.6356237530708313,
-0.3948354125022888,
-0.4219924509525299,
-0.006023978814482689,
-0.63966965675354,
0.42950788140296936,
0.10907809436321259,
-0.37314996123313904,
0.2894250750541687,
-0.5655583143234253,
-0.20022504031658173,
0.045124601572752,
-0.0601331889629364,
-0.00970488041639328,
0.29309025406837463,
0.26380935311317444,
0.17782260477542877,
0.016747504472732544,
-0.6195250749588013,
0.07182901352643967,
-0.6756565570831299,
0.8374975323677063,
0.7942138910293579,
0.00850206520408392,
0.4267457127571106,
-0.3969442546367645,
0.7755947709083557,
0.17592547833919525,
0.1685847043991089,
-0.6290205121040344,
-0.2803775370121002,
-0.6173964142799377,
-0.14339664578437805,
-0.14660130441188812,
0.520617663860321,
-0.5969206094741821,
0.2151772677898407,
-0.5713547468185425,
-0.5662016868591309,
0.4301765561103821,
-0.0862395316362381,
0.15374985337257385,
0.8455026745796204,
0.46210068464279175,
0.25947654247283936,
-0.7789670825004578,
-0.4337831735610962,
-0.04522322490811348,
0.21252329647541046,
0.0358998067677021,
0.2936488687992096,
0.429848313331604,
-0.12970492243766785,
1.1441912651062012,
-0.6337388753890991,
-0.01272421795874834,
-0.5372752547264099,
-0.16641466319561005,
0.45166146755218506,
0.11071423441171646,
0.502501368522644,
-0.6342287063598633,
-0.5370523929595947,
-0.15783724188804626,
-0.530785083770752,
0.06463134288787842,
0.13526208698749542,
0.2651996612548828,
0.3072131276130676,
0.9778794646263123,
-0.23776249587535858,
0.35661303997039795,
0.5350369811058044,
-0.5001600980758667,
0.29648759961128235,
0.12668122351169586,
-0.17330743372440338,
-1.5177814960479736,
0.06447483599185944,
0.17621247470378876,
-0.4567931890487671,
-0.6070443987846375,
-0.2986450493335724,
0.03010791353881359,
-0.38019493222236633,
-0.643589198589325,
1.050601601600647,
-0.07444773614406586,
-0.06550054997205734,
-0.08912517875432968,
-0.24822762608528137,
0.07375071942806244,
0.4165918529033661,
0.004792942199856043,
0.8218334913253784,
0.4148610830307007,
-0.6424154043197632,
0.34311819076538086,
-0.01754089631140232,
-0.3453625738620758,
0.2644403576850891,
-0.6721466779708862,
-0.08882460743188858,
-0.273009717464447,
0.34500017762184143,
-0.862825334072113,
-0.12696237862110138,
0.035401832312345505,
-0.019160162657499313,
0.5573479533195496,
-0.024348121136426926,
-0.3038195073604584,
-0.4455120861530304,
-0.13109341263771057,
0.5317733287811279,
0.3133369982242584,
-1.034407377243042,
0.8411561846733093,
-0.03191625699400902,
0.03102654591202736,
-0.7405449151992798,
-0.7688649892807007,
-0.1037253811955452,
-0.6627668142318726,
-0.27139711380004883,
0.6493771076202393,
-0.06718205660581589,
-0.11123698949813843,
-0.21582083404064178,
-0.12939448654651642,
0.1792621612548828,
0.13054102659225464,
0.2987782657146454,
0.6740208268165588,
-0.24073809385299683,
0.10833790153265,
-0.2252555638551712,
-0.29849714040756226,
-0.1418168544769287,
-0.5497847199440002,
0.5523288249969482,
-0.10550538450479507,
-0.1575728952884674,
-0.1431576907634735,
0.2350188046693802,
0.501754879951477,
-0.1335826963186264,
0.5901644825935364,
0.49109819531440735,
-0.41780799627304077,
-0.3681736886501312,
-0.4632318317890167,
-0.25307798385620117,
-0.5463122129440308,
0.5010544657707214,
-0.21621988713741302,
-0.9853631854057312,
0.4426973760128021,
0.06676841527223587,
0.16817879676818848,
0.41614606976509094,
0.3753642141819,
-0.01823202148079872,
0.7373632788658142,
0.5873535871505737,
-0.4639403522014618,
0.7114570140838623,
-0.3448065221309662,
0.34230953454971313,
-0.7979381680488586,
-0.3001335561275482,
-0.19038833677768707,
-0.46721941232681274,
-0.24992293119430542,
-0.1658352017402649,
0.48142385482788086,
-0.32818514108657837,
-0.8817119002342224,
0.5485721230506897,
-0.30995261669158936,
0.42584511637687683,
0.5582259297370911,
0.006104753818362951,
0.16376981139183044,
-0.02685249038040638,
0.2219432294368744,
0.024369997903704643,
-0.4836162030696869,
-0.2503758668899536,
1.4869978427886963,
0.28857070207595825,
0.7224175333976746,
-0.047976214438676834,
0.4506186246871948,
0.303809255361557,
0.6041701436042786,
-0.9470721483230591,
0.384998083114624,
-0.2922714650630951,
-0.3562430441379547,
-0.3527446389198303,
-0.10762055218219757,
-0.5766780376434326,
0.0011304885847494006,
0.07181801646947861,
-0.8499241471290588,
0.052199769765138626,
0.056922197341918945,
-0.48649775981903076,
0.6348128318786621,
-0.5671873092651367,
0.6722053289413452,
-0.07728756964206696,
-0.04505147412419319,
0.07641496509313583,
-0.3780770003795624,
0.034399259835481644,
0.008813478983938694,
-0.07426299154758453,
-0.04324493929743767,
-0.2413879930973053,
0.611941397190094,
-0.5024933218955994,
1.0295413732528687,
-0.28530701994895935,
0.08282404392957687,
0.15694166719913483,
-0.011142856441438198,
0.5344824194908142,
0.08507281541824341,
-0.3267764747142792,
0.0571032278239727,
0.2679785490036011,
-0.23929645121097565,
-0.680506706237793,
0.6460302472114563,
-0.6982259750366211,
-0.6487321853637695,
-0.522445023059845,
-0.5719342827796936,
-0.5058140158653259,
0.2543051540851593,
0.3217334747314453,
1.1047437191009521,
-0.29689493775367737,
0.33548054099082947,
0.22549675405025482,
0.28483662009239197,
1.2112524509429932,
0.31186750531196594,
-0.26737990975379944,
-0.3853641152381897,
0.5909424424171448,
-0.02305525727570057,
0.13237912952899933,
0.8712330460548401,
0.3737567067146301,
-0.4628651738166809,
-0.2790084481239319,
-0.23598216474056244,
0.017273005098104477,
-0.7504746317863464,
-0.49560385942459106,
-0.18427401781082153,
-0.20913754403591156,
-0.3156708776950836,
-0.35356399416923523,
-0.040728889405727386,
-0.2654384672641754,
-0.43292349576950073,
-0.16629286110401154,
0.37671998143196106,
0.7189300060272217,
0.6015520095825195,
0.6943494081497192,
-0.7469435930252075,
0.10684198141098022,
0.19600200653076172,
0.6182793974876404,
0.1155933290719986,
-0.7341708540916443,
-0.22581788897514343,
-0.23899947106838226,
-0.575605034828186,
-0.5736650228500366,
0.7633908987045288,
0.315416157245636,
0.29974570870399475,
0.5314388871192932,
-0.13582828640937805,
0.8574831485748291,
-0.6050747632980347,
0.8980967998504639,
0.013136912137269974,
-1.0468018054962158,
0.27343761920928955,
-0.39931440353393555,
0.4270990788936615,
-0.09700879454612732,
0.13565437495708466,
-0.6126238107681274,
0.059990521520376205,
-0.40632137656211853,
-0.637721598148346,
1.0447258949279785,
-0.18027363717556,
0.15016137063503265,
0.027540065348148346,
0.561319887638092,
0.19871118664741516,
0.266677588224411,
-0.6185251474380493,
-0.3870352506637573,
-0.5541967749595642,
-0.11169416457414627,
-0.7398045063018799,
-0.3299855589866638,
0.09402796626091003,
-0.36172476410865784,
0.6633800268173218,
-0.4127165675163269,
0.35688894987106323,
0.1949048787355423,
0.21946978569030762,
-0.39277467131614685,
0.14075303077697754,
0.5137771368026733,
0.6682342886924744,
-0.3120620846748352,
-0.24908557534217834,
0.6046359539031982,
-0.14270062744617462,
0.07432645559310913,
0.17332306504249573,
-0.20187832415103912,
-0.11447802931070328,
0.29011332988739014,
0.9654696583747864,
0.5091941356658936,
-0.5262268781661987,
0.3604642152786255,
0.22486934065818787,
-0.004910991992801428,
-0.8210588097572327,
-0.1469097137451172,
-0.03133935108780861,
0.558803915977478,
0.5371753573417664,
0.18152184784412384,
0.012894976884126663,
-0.3940017521381378,
-0.003670877544209361,
0.4380156695842743,
-0.5176194906234741,
-0.27932748198509216,
0.7530598640441895,
0.03917267546057701,
-0.33690813183784485,
0.34345659613609314,
0.1602783054113388,
-0.4414018988609314,
0.7970479726791382,
0.9968664050102234,
1.0206451416015625,
-0.2572515308856964,
-0.012782411649823189,
0.23996172845363617,
-0.1578441709280014,
-0.2850545048713684,
0.2936367392539978,
0.0010082268854603171,
-0.6556977033615112,
-0.6202194690704346,
-0.5674243569374084,
-0.47508251667022705,
0.34560754895210266,
-0.5561438798904419,
0.6635388731956482,
-0.47584232687950134,
-0.1962250918149948,
-0.1111706793308258,
-0.013516304083168507,
-0.6963108777999878,
0.44696956872940063,
0.20875197649002075,
1.0584570169448853,
-0.5239903330802917,
0.9620505571365356,
0.5126916766166687,
0.08815898001194,
-0.7391897439956665,
0.14588101208209991,
-0.05141986533999443,
-0.7163999080657959,
0.6572118997573853,
0.34635278582572937,
-0.25130778551101685,
0.08592532575130463,
-0.4152900278568268,
-1.3257136344909668,
1.551975965499878,
0.3290170133113861,
-0.27101701498031616,
-0.38837334513664246,
0.20647378265857697,
0.28651493787765503,
-0.5692598223686218,
0.2028883695602417,
0.3556658625602722,
0.35093310475349426,
0.2610297203063965,
-0.7290321588516235,
0.11460427939891815,
-0.18167747557163239,
0.20492692291736603,
0.6042800545692444,
-0.6824780106544495,
0.5948994159698486,
-0.18986433744430542,
-0.07094366103410721,
0.11417440325021744,
0.9286433458328247,
-0.27189236879348755,
0.3793630301952362,
0.3801083564758301,
0.1525695025920868,
0.3798880875110626,
-0.31860628724098206,
1.0805330276489258,
-0.4329317808151245,
0.21968884766101837,
1.2312105894088745,
-0.22772590816020966,
0.9623024463653564,
0.7244507670402527,
-0.2393997460603714,
0.6029532551765442,
0.4306989908218384,
-0.20994633436203003,
0.5662189722061157,
-0.25617876648902893,
0.025159258395433426,
-0.3781255781650543,
0.020721182227134705,
-0.11267925053834915,
0.3949495255947113,
0.41058313846588135,
-0.18942707777023315,
-0.28368693590164185,
0.01820388436317444,
-0.02451339364051819,
-0.14505323767662048,
-0.4217071533203125,
0.3772364556789398,
0.22364598512649536,
-0.7185166478157043,
0.26289302110671997,
0.026862209662795067,
0.8195378184318542,
-0.6301107406616211,
0.25860685110092163,
-0.0061052278615534306,
0.18703852593898773,
-0.14281105995178223,
-0.6412203311920166,
0.5708546042442322,
-0.180467888712883,
-0.13875120878219604,
-0.32721441984176636,
0.40214279294013977,
-0.1901690512895584,
-0.6836069822311401,
0.2935420572757721,
0.2810249328613281,
-0.42625901103019714,
0.11282923072576523,
-0.20183001458644867,
-0.37879830598831177,
-0.27255502343177795,
-0.4629579782485962,
0.020901408046483994,
0.02355092391371727,
-0.03063390590250492,
0.9795576930046082,
0.31807026267051697,
-0.046867795288562775,
-0.09087200462818146,
0.19407077133655548,
0.5991353988647461,
-0.9377867579460144,
-0.49914786219596863,
-0.9033039212226868,
0.4412268400192261,
0.2559480369091034,
-0.25484609603881836,
0.42767661809921265,
0.4055505394935608,
0.5950526595115662,
-0.11186235398054123,
0.8563205003738403,
0.22885215282440186,
0.7152246236801147,
-0.3197263479232788,
0.2235569804906845,
-0.756339967250824,
0.3450636863708496,
-0.17108485102653503,
-0.9716283082962036,
-0.4166848063468933,
-0.19331249594688416,
-0.479705810546875,
0.21693256497383118,
0.5995494723320007,
0.4217953681945801,
-0.20730488002300262,
0.4148235619068146,
0.2703419625759125,
-0.0025078204926103354,
0.38084402680397034,
0.3186377286911011,
0.48810601234436035,
-0.3540588617324829,
0.6890499591827393,
-0.5298978686332703,
0.051266707479953766,
-0.14680655300617218,
-1.1965752840042114,
-1.153361201286316,
-0.585824191570282,
0.005397140514105558,
-0.2147406041622162,
-0.23617754876613617,
1.2445284128189087,
0.646636962890625,
-1.0948799848556519,
-0.3455469608306885,
0.006845229305326939,
-0.2970196008682251,
-0.2786945700645447,
-0.2337293177843094,
0.4862734079360962,
-0.3965981602668762,
-0.9213975667953491,
0.5548220872879028,
0.16618868708610535,
0.12877345085144043,
-0.3592517077922821,
-0.05215201526880264,
0.4781600534915924,
0.044273849576711655,
0.8234542608261108,
0.1175001934170723,
-0.8106673955917358,
-0.35048380494117737,
0.3744719922542572,
0.3935958743095398,
0.1935073733329773,
0.8218603730201721,
-1.019819974899292,
0.20019295811653137,
0.2725667655467987,
0.44049566984176636,
0.7078291177749634,
0.007385606411844492,
0.8276405334472656,
-0.7462576031684875,
0.16604581475257874,
0.06121917441487312,
0.8052811026573181,
0.3405829966068268,
-0.49379855394363403,
0.22730059921741486,
0.17323549091815948,
-0.3922954201698303,
-0.6695951223373413,
0.13314925134181976,
-0.8907573223114014,
-0.0523696206510067,
1.1340126991271973,
0.19797374308109283,
0.03020021691918373,
-0.022432783618569374,
0.06363136321306229,
0.38863179087638855,
-0.5509676933288574,
0.6170838475227356,
0.4820345342159271,
-0.02831057831645012,
-0.01589996926486492,
-0.3027120530605316,
0.40142855048179626,
0.11231882870197296,
-0.5151843428611755,
0.0012641755165532231,
-0.13195829093456268,
0.3307952284812927,
-0.28109464049339294,
0.17713093757629395,
-0.08774014562368393,
-0.1047765463590622,
-0.5024448037147522,
-0.46102210879325867,
-0.4323221445083618,
-0.4175494611263275,
-0.2456531673669815,
0.0936201959848404,
-0.0766419991850853,
0.06436658650636673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14974v1
|
LOVA3: Learning to Visual Question Answering, Asking and Assessment
| 2024-05-23T18:21:59 | 2024-05-23T18:21:59 |
Henry Hengyuan Zhao, Pan Zhou, Difei Gao, Mike Zheng Shou
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Question answering, asking, and assessment are three innate human traits
crucial for understanding the world and acquiring knowledge. By enhancing these
capabilities, humans can more effectively utilize data, leading to better
comprehension and learning outcomes. However, current Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) primarily focus on question answering, often neglecting the full
potential of questioning and assessment skills. In this study, we introduce
LOVA3, an innovative framework named ``Learning tO Visual Question Answering,
Asking and Assessment,'' designed to equip MLLMs with these additional
capabilities. Our approach involves the creation of two supplementary training
tasks GenQA and EvalQA, aiming at fostering the skills of asking and assessing
questions in the context of images. To develop the questioning ability, we
compile a comprehensive set of multimodal foundational tasks. For assessment,
we introduce a new benchmark called EvalQABench, comprising 64,000 training
samples (split evenly between positive and negative samples) and 5,000 testing
samples. We posit that enhancing MLLMs with the capabilities to answer, ask,
and assess questions will improve their multimodal comprehension and lead to
better performance. We validate our hypothesis by training an MLLM using the
LOVA3 framework and testing it on 10 multimodal benchmarks. The results
demonstrate consistent performance improvements, thereby confirming the
efficacy of our approach.
|
[
-0.7026084661483765,
-1.176897644996643,
0.4653809666633606,
-0.02166145294904709,
-0.029937973245978355,
0.010793077759444714,
0.1703907549381256,
-0.5417932271957397,
-0.16631966829299927,
0.6574561595916748,
-0.5477070212364197,
-0.27695709466934204,
-0.35077276825904846,
0.06012968719005585,
-0.22863228619098663,
0.3881506025791168,
-0.367067813873291,
0.31063708662986755,
-0.5547292828559875,
-0.4877205789089203,
-0.6445235013961792,
-0.07881567627191544,
-0.6195732355117798,
0.1782831996679306,
0.7967275977134705,
0.5456653237342834,
0.42297786474227905,
0.14783388376235962,
0.6181317567825317,
0.36474746465682983,
0.20809271931648254,
0.3106420040130615,
-0.4002237021923065,
0.20847627520561218,
-0.01399819552898407,
-0.7634825110435486,
-0.2909562885761261,
-0.039543379098176956,
0.566041111946106,
0.4473794996738434,
-0.012805231846868992,
0.4545947015285492,
-0.13217663764953613,
0.7570697665214539,
-0.8895146250724792,
-0.016139838844537735,
-0.5366269946098328,
0.14690756797790527,
0.3281252980232239,
-0.41140928864479065,
-0.15607595443725586,
-0.36974263191223145,
0.09404255449771881,
-0.6560322642326355,
0.19473886489868164,
-0.12256743758916855,
0.7207760214805603,
0.39984193444252014,
-0.5543808937072754,
0.21005810797214508,
-0.38170215487480164,
0.46686646342277527,
-0.21308207511901855,
0.3665620684623718,
0.4826297163963318,
0.6808744668960571,
0.3120734989643097,
-0.7861253619194031,
-0.7509348392486572,
0.18784868717193604,
0.426628977060318,
0.2581889033317566,
-0.14492076635360718,
-0.23873315751552582,
0.4840628206729889,
0.1545134037733078,
-0.7625036239624023,
-0.10881444811820984,
-0.6184836030006409,
-0.04680429771542549,
0.4340827465057373,
0.20748022198677063,
0.30867451429367065,
-0.3630988299846649,
-0.6708372831344604,
-0.3225650191307068,
-0.664681613445282,
0.5388891100883484,
0.22202236950397491,
-0.010319420136511326,
0.03566926345229149,
0.7707459330558777,
-0.3062773048877716,
0.7800447344779968,
-0.49184784293174744,
-0.1823536604642868,
0.2877073585987091,
-0.36679521203041077,
-0.27093666791915894,
-0.5091566443443298,
0.5273134112358093,
0.7321153879165649,
0.1992204338312149,
0.4717654287815094,
-0.049495160579681396,
-0.04719585180282593,
0.38001567125320435,
-0.655921220779419,
0.15740856528282166,
0.2737172245979309,
-0.3505212962627411,
-0.293843537569046,
-0.08429846912622452,
-0.9932728409767151,
-0.5139195919036865,
-0.2932770848274231,
0.7917558550834656,
-0.5235170722007751,
-0.08049240708351135,
0.0965157151222229,
-0.35685470700263977,
0.7298709750175476,
0.802695095539093,
-0.765075147151947,
0.17247553169727325,
0.29718291759490967,
0.35678112506866455,
-0.12631551921367645,
-0.6136149168014526,
-0.9921361804008484,
-0.02249634638428688,
-0.3558398485183716,
0.9338827133178711,
-0.4386567175388336,
-0.14634069800376892,
0.016250688582658768,
0.0757656991481781,
0.006004180293530226,
-0.4874730110168457,
-0.03076944500207901,
-0.6687482595443726,
0.2950035333633423,
-0.47459566593170166,
-0.08068893849849701,
-0.4838067591190338,
0.788910984992981,
-0.8331813216209412,
1.0895092487335205,
0.41170504689216614,
-0.5512925386428833,
0.3533705174922943,
-0.6943700313568115,
-0.0908866599202156,
0.23772522807121277,
-0.3744715750217438,
-0.14286619424819946,
-0.017643751576542854,
0.8084725737571716,
0.586091160774231,
-0.329410582780838,
-0.25022855401039124,
-0.26450154185295105,
-0.5093522071838379,
0.3369487226009369,
-0.42887768149375916,
0.5951852798461914,
-0.024966660887002945,
-0.4039483368396759,
0.21163992583751678,
-0.7532714009284973,
0.45643487572669983,
0.28469589352607727,
-0.3180800676345825,
-0.03284492716193199,
-0.32478782534599304,
0.03457086905837059,
0.09904567152261734,
-0.09238928556442261,
-0.39561185240745544,
0.10841825604438782,
-0.16084203124046326,
0.23722118139266968,
0.641493022441864,
0.2392689436674118,
0.08223613351583481,
-0.22574029862880707,
0.9915651679039001,
-0.1400410234928131,
0.46463918685913086,
-0.16580043733119965,
-0.6679413318634033,
-0.8159324526786804,
-0.22812111675739288,
-0.020605040714144707,
0.6565968990325928,
-1.3849914073944092,
-0.27777203917503357,
-0.16907283663749695,
-0.4818955361843109,
-0.6024416089057922,
0.5454253554344177,
0.30457884073257446,
0.5457609295845032,
0.5110885500907898,
-0.28002452850341797,
-0.44050711393356323,
-0.7902208566665649,
0.09054740518331528,
-0.4231475591659546,
0.07209829241037369,
0.32173874974250793,
0.867071807384491,
-0.06473477929830551,
0.6395274996757507,
-0.4733459949493408,
-0.17090214788913727,
-0.3872513771057129,
0.15373662114143372,
-0.29070109128952026,
0.12636017799377441,
0.5092116594314575,
-1.2623454332351685,
-0.2646588683128357,
-0.006323678884655237,
-0.8707021474838257,
0.3079354763031006,
0.16662859916687012,
-0.034477878361940384,
0.012487195432186127,
0.6837549209594727,
-0.3333214819431305,
0.4390273094177246,
0.4854738414287567,
-0.2992195785045624,
0.40485575795173645,
-0.01624971441924572,
0.4811898171901703,
-0.8579347729682922,
0.09508723020553589,
-0.4221547245979309,
-0.3802028298377991,
-0.404462069272995,
0.34703710675239563,
0.1867985725402832,
-0.3505920469760895,
-1.0538874864578247,
0.8346095681190491,
-0.23233827948570251,
-0.16688409447669983,
0.032522667199373245,
0.2661009132862091,
0.46667608618736267,
0.6978033185005188,
-0.20063094794750214,
0.7757828235626221,
0.7528074383735657,
-0.4302378296852112,
0.7878954410552979,
0.4355700612068176,
-0.7505099773406982,
1.022361397743225,
-0.678274393081665,
0.019795306026935577,
-0.3987244665622711,
-0.03254308924078941,
-1.0831220149993896,
-0.30788928270339966,
-0.07076316326856613,
-0.541947603225708,
-0.07621414214372635,
0.02103014849126339,
-0.4184173345565796,
-0.5777350664138794,
-0.42229709029197693,
0.288336843252182,
0.47045373916625977,
-0.6215730905532837,
1.0007154941558838,
0.10676679760217667,
-0.17449511587619781,
-0.8014135956764221,
-0.6463379859924316,
-0.12015605717897415,
-0.32924312353134155,
-0.6459901928901672,
-0.3141663670539856,
-0.20663590729236603,
-0.14801304042339325,
-0.039454393088817596,
0.27931246161460876,
-0.1455230712890625,
0.23875582218170166,
0.17657050490379333,
0.4450764060020447,
-0.34355345368385315,
0.24637582898139954,
-0.48725253343582153,
0.10963728278875351,
0.04635431244969368,
0.18629947304725647,
0.33326682448387146,
-0.45510321855545044,
-0.6624442338943481,
-0.27533814311027527,
0.5440618991851807,
0.622700572013855,
-0.7722291946411133,
0.25410428643226624,
1.0252634286880493,
-0.1434824913740158,
-0.06022007390856743,
-0.7889543175697327,
0.10477568954229355,
-0.43993306159973145,
0.5072438716888428,
-0.4956111013889313,
-0.8448015451431274,
0.2883930504322052,
0.2439797818660736,
-0.05330699309706688,
0.13869869709014893,
0.5698320269584656,
-0.6039767861366272,
1.1270374059677124,
0.6112083196640015,
0.5781259536743164,
0.3300642669200897,
-0.42934006452560425,
-0.15961280465126038,
-1.024971604347229,
-0.4306040108203888,
-0.10374005138874054,
-0.29398226737976074,
-0.19619469344615936,
-0.9813476800918579,
0.6000284552574158,
-0.013397843576967716,
-0.170063316822052,
-0.03073323704302311,
-0.013026906177401543,
0.603201687335968,
0.4958629608154297,
0.13511566817760468,
0.2774975299835205,
0.10370016098022461,
0.0117794806137681,
0.06950199604034424,
-0.5061356425285339,
-0.3625357747077942,
1.0849424600601196,
0.3733888268470764,
0.8001052141189575,
0.27465128898620605,
0.3512454628944397,
-0.131094828248024,
0.2893497943878174,
-0.8217846155166626,
0.7487009167671204,
0.31561478972435,
-0.7290083169937134,
-0.4381658732891083,
-0.23325206339359283,
-0.7831359505653381,
0.5497555732727051,
-0.3289051949977875,
-0.6232151985168457,
0.23456475138664246,
0.132663756608963,
-0.463577538728714,
0.2744256258010864,
-0.7573457956314087,
0.8668338656425476,
-0.5749975442886353,
-0.598796010017395,
0.02564259245991707,
-0.6611733436584473,
0.3343152701854706,
0.07614734768867493,
0.05495894327759743,
0.008847185410559177,
-0.22672508656978607,
0.5938541293144226,
0.1272755116224289,
0.7592133283615112,
-0.3066863417625427,
-0.062283799052238464,
0.5324628949165344,
-0.021191760897636414,
0.2754133939743042,
0.20815631747245789,
0.23502978682518005,
-0.2513466775417328,
0.2709721624851227,
-0.6114084124565125,
-1.1157417297363281,
0.42581799626350403,
-0.691496729850769,
-0.6281041502952576,
-0.12332259118556976,
-0.3985065817832947,
-0.8109510540962219,
0.15246471762657166,
-0.1301850527524948,
0.5868963003158569,
-0.38521409034729004,
0.4914492666721344,
0.8546238541603088,
-0.3497820794582367,
0.14631883800029755,
0.4006751775741577,
-0.5370607972145081,
-0.6070882081985474,
0.8727307915687561,
-0.3321312963962555,
0.6430085301399231,
0.4025236666202545,
0.05233294889330864,
-0.3511402904987335,
-0.2756240963935852,
-0.5262523293495178,
0.12873539328575134,
-1.1870503425598145,
-0.15677987039089203,
-0.665754497051239,
0.011738236993551254,
-0.29984524846076965,
-0.09430306404829025,
-0.1933528333902359,
-0.16453810036182404,
-0.12252487987279892,
-0.12370061874389648,
0.2980104088783264,
0.599112868309021,
0.19307377934455872,
-0.03230933099985123,
-0.5797414779663086,
0.68636155128479,
1.1500948667526245,
0.271042138338089,
-0.14718984067440033,
-0.20278435945510864,
0.09206461906433105,
0.005065334960818291,
-0.4340458810329437,
-0.5690998435020447,
0.051349788904190063,
0.08009360730648041,
0.5340542793273926,
0.2853206992149353,
-0.45528143644332886,
0.8682346940040588,
-0.4858226776123047,
0.8977590203285217,
0.4155650734901428,
-0.6602867841720581,
0.7567289471626282,
-0.34710848331451416,
0.4334300756454468,
0.7706817984580994,
0.4992428421974182,
-0.36437761783599854,
0.1016877070069313,
-0.5263179540634155,
-0.48464974761009216,
0.25350961089134216,
0.049275971949100494,
0.19696536660194397,
0.22075390815734863,
-0.03512017801403999,
0.03878837078809738,
0.2087964564561844,
-0.7694417834281921,
0.10530374944210052,
-0.5114542245864868,
0.04721841961145401,
-0.1300860345363617,
-0.05206632614135742,
-0.5204048156738281,
-0.45378127694129944,
0.31185898184776306,
-0.6734127998352051,
0.24483075737953186,
0.2451592981815338,
-0.11835744976997375,
0.04547454044222832,
0.3289843499660492,
0.40132761001586914,
0.7894476652145386,
-0.1933041363954544,
0.2190944254398346,
0.46735846996307373,
-0.3563879728317261,
0.09345050901174545,
-0.07537014782428741,
0.3249126076698303,
-0.4269368350505829,
0.6342745423316956,
1.0763797760009766,
-0.03371451795101166,
-1.2764627933502197,
0.9135725498199463,
-0.47597989439964294,
-0.6256282925605774,
-0.24303051829338074,
0.2701786458492279,
0.17357227206230164,
0.38451167941093445,
0.06646940112113953,
-0.04969523474574089,
0.003936619497835636,
-0.8012641072273254,
0.007890786975622177,
0.3990688621997833,
-0.7094179391860962,
0.10858364403247833,
0.42143791913986206,
0.17935757339000702,
0.09740977734327316,
0.4586779475212097,
0.2715402841567993,
-0.4276646673679352,
0.6454675793647766,
0.2579042911529541,
0.3602604269981384,
-0.04673286899924278,
0.5496628880500793,
0.3177604675292969,
0.42172735929489136,
0.12810736894607544,
1.0894947052001953,
-0.1849747598171234,
-0.5387576818466187,
-0.17974185943603516,
-0.4183695912361145,
-0.42241621017456055,
0.27944931387901306,
-0.8563303351402283,
0.3149976432323456,
-0.2960396707057953,
0.05985571816563606,
-0.1294524222612381,
-0.1816602498292923,
-0.9969045519828796,
0.446634441614151,
0.26016244292259216,
0.8600367903709412,
-0.6712921857833862,
0.37668377161026,
0.7730886340141296,
-0.6303461194038391,
-0.7293188571929932,
-0.4402617812156677,
-0.0016662204870954156,
-1.0867725610733032,
0.8579893112182617,
0.23607560992240906,
-0.1003919169306755,
-0.05287915840744972,
-0.8121157288551331,
-0.9314523935317993,
1.2476365566253662,
0.17439094185829163,
-0.0001228822220582515,
-0.029823921620845795,
0.019003024324774742,
0.5183447003364563,
-0.33330652117729187,
0.2656577229499817,
0.25479796528816223,
0.45367440581321716,
0.2874002754688263,
-0.49103546142578125,
-0.23987403512001038,
-0.6024991869926453,
0.0521356537938118,
-0.12153618037700653,
-0.3162217140197754,
0.6878118515014648,
-0.6273312568664551,
-0.07688339054584503,
0.2136007398366928,
0.5053285956382751,
0.22426863014698029,
-0.08716122061014175,
0.5992304682731628,
0.38542795181274414,
0.6946663856506348,
-0.14747436344623566,
1.1960960626602173,
0.40141725540161133,
-0.04248880594968796,
1.099085807800293,
-0.3561883866786957,
1.2996089458465576,
0.728600025177002,
0.05020427703857422,
0.5747605562210083,
0.46176987886428833,
-0.23004493117332458,
0.2328910380601883,
0.10815431922674179,
-0.14054659008979797,
-0.4381537437438965,
-0.04752139747142792,
-0.3497237265110016,
0.8153492212295532,
0.2739848792552948,
-0.03719610348343849,
-0.10358717292547226,
0.5227169394493103,
-0.5810613632202148,
0.01693541556596756,
-0.2139938771724701,
0.6246740221977234,
-0.19021451473236084,
-0.7706371545791626,
0.7974914312362671,
-0.461105078458786,
0.11449133604764938,
-0.734251081943512,
-0.22964590787887573,
-0.09400685876607895,
-0.0052347504533827305,
0.09379462897777557,
-1.025420904159546,
-0.22530053555965424,
-0.013449414633214474,
0.11418800055980682,
-0.2596084475517273,
0.37187719345092773,
-0.32679250836372375,
-0.6370250582695007,
0.16750943660736084,
0.7772046327590942,
0.03283694386482239,
0.0976119264960289,
-0.6714442372322083,
0.05171015486121178,
-0.18506500124931335,
-0.2848966419696808,
0.03542369604110718,
0.3018372058868408,
-0.11986688524484634,
0.9864481091499329,
0.5234047174453735,
0.009075396694242954,
-0.03714974969625473,
0.3317788243293762,
0.8465538620948792,
-0.6011742353439331,
-0.3259182870388031,
-0.46259555220603943,
0.7226004004478455,
-0.04248088225722313,
-0.44357752799987793,
0.5368006825447083,
0.273508220911026,
0.6896928548812866,
-0.1443442851305008,
0.7671485543251038,
0.0028106344398111105,
0.4057038426399231,
-0.8321698307991028,
0.43210723996162415,
-1.0956039428710938,
-0.1070738285779953,
-0.3309307098388672,
-0.8657373189926147,
-0.29569417238235474,
0.47415584325790405,
-0.19367094337940216,
-0.03745286539196968,
1.017874002456665,
0.8749881386756897,
0.17568126320838928,
0.04687880352139473,
0.5939458608627319,
-0.05521584674715996,
0.3988467752933502,
0.6614621877670288,
1.3804752826690674,
-0.6571123003959656,
0.5743177533149719,
-0.1527995765209198,
-0.13228954374790192,
-0.024494268000125885,
-0.5528457164764404,
-1.190447449684143,
-0.8055173754692078,
-0.05282129719853401,
-0.13511115312576294,
-0.14530669152736664,
0.6227388381958008,
0.5018208622932434,
-0.28458288311958313,
-0.03009251318871975,
0.30614787340164185,
-0.06091760843992233,
-0.26045867800712585,
-0.14128223061561584,
0.2897065281867981,
-0.0911007672548294,
-0.5531291365623474,
0.35371989011764526,
0.4080502390861511,
0.23131978511810303,
-0.6188810467720032,
0.10368921607732773,
-0.4201471507549286,
-0.09448076784610748,
0.8740518093109131,
0.22405214607715607,
-0.7314199805259705,
-0.23523634672164917,
0.22686852514743805,
0.00906289555132389,
0.13528859615325928,
0.6638262867927551,
-0.913057804107666,
0.8017595410346985,
0.5690743327140808,
0.8632494807243347,
0.4486995339393616,
0.10548197478055954,
0.404386043548584,
-0.433405339717865,
0.01750752329826355,
0.279887855052948,
0.41396626830101013,
0.6413422226905823,
-0.056232232600450516,
0.5305453538894653,
0.03963514417409897,
-0.08854453265666962,
-0.7046382427215576,
0.287606418132782,
-0.9347264170646667,
-0.1715829074382782,
1.2615725994110107,
0.14453129470348358,
-0.4384344518184662,
-0.1372305303812027,
-0.5973507165908813,
-0.32336685061454773,
0.24102380871772766,
0.23849642276763916,
0.6380366086959839,
-0.16489127278327942,
-0.5170387625694275,
-1.0374176502227783,
0.2713514566421509,
0.4481107294559479,
-1.283111572265625,
-0.19825442135334015,
0.46205633878707886,
0.36600860953330994,
0.10121581703424454,
0.6049636602401733,
-0.2676081657409668,
0.7681522369384766,
-0.22454491257667542,
0.16625943779945374,
-0.004441129043698311,
-0.4336210787296295,
-0.24533823132514954,
0.43487435579299927,
0.04400795325636864,
-0.0834408849477768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14962v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14962v1
|
Data Augmentation Method Utilizing Template Sentences for Variable Definition Extraction
| 2024-05-23T18:14:05 | 2024-05-23T18:14:05 |
Kotaro Nagayama, Shota Kato, Manabu Kano
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The extraction of variable definitions from scientific and technical papers
is essential for understanding these documents. However, the characteristics of
variable definitions, such as the length and the words that make up the
definition, differ among fields, which leads to differences in the performance
of existing extraction methods across fields. Although preparing training data
specific to each field can improve the performance of the methods, it is costly
to create high-quality training data. To address this challenge, this study
proposes a new method that generates new definition sentences from template
sentences and variable-definition pairs in the training data. The proposed
method has been tested on papers about chemical processes, and the results show
that the model trained with the definition sentences generated by the proposed
method achieved a higher accuracy of 89.6%, surpassing existing models.
|
[
-0.24974995851516724,
-0.7321972846984863,
0.584768533706665,
0.03120274841785431,
-0.41649386286735535,
0.15619808435440063,
-0.24563106894493103,
-0.32810550928115845,
0.37924715876579285,
0.35832634568214417,
-0.49704715609550476,
-0.372392863035202,
-0.47391775250434875,
0.47599679231643677,
-0.2473694533109665,
0.9862216114997864,
-0.34041035175323486,
0.03615438938140869,
-0.4513885974884033,
0.0485512912273407,
-0.5376548171043396,
-0.26219072937965393,
0.025825712829828262,
-0.17272968590259552,
0.3368529975414276,
0.17796289920806885,
0.3247217833995819,
1.025916337966919,
0.7152501940727234,
0.39198634028434753,
-0.1660131961107254,
0.4549402892589569,
-0.07457343488931656,
0.2516150176525116,
-0.17986363172531128,
-0.49434295296669006,
-0.4063711166381836,
0.46109744906425476,
0.6156735420227051,
0.5748931169509888,
0.19343632459640503,
0.06204590946435928,
-0.05968121439218521,
0.5660120248794556,
-0.5448548793792725,
0.5021784901618958,
-0.7056742310523987,
0.2838534712791443,
-0.09457432478666306,
-0.6832228899002075,
-0.05562319979071617,
-0.4247194230556488,
0.05520740896463394,
-0.7451105713844299,
0.7211968302726746,
-0.4227142930030823,
1.045681357383728,
-0.1875278800725937,
-0.2137870043516159,
-0.3306524455547333,
-0.6378125548362732,
0.4874919652938843,
-0.46275052428245544,
0.18442252278327942,
0.06704492121934891,
0.12077608704566956,
-0.02184866927564144,
-0.9189370274543762,
-0.9197907447814941,
-0.21448588371276855,
-0.15029479563236237,
0.2877625524997711,
0.3376670479774475,
0.06980878114700317,
0.47295644879341125,
0.503799319267273,
-0.3028999865055084,
-0.19307079911231995,
-0.9384980201721191,
-0.029773086309432983,
0.6790828704833984,
0.2775764465332031,
-0.22149032354354858,
-0.3687507212162018,
-0.4066202640533447,
-0.2674359679222107,
-0.3970870077610016,
-0.12701109051704407,
0.37485644221305847,
0.49303385615348816,
0.12161862850189209,
1.0540436506271362,
-0.21870765089988708,
0.4638652503490448,
-0.16179154813289642,
-0.19116008281707764,
0.7494134306907654,
-0.5706888437271118,
-0.4550001621246338,
-0.16216261684894562,
0.3853803873062134,
0.2102511078119278,
-0.23400799930095673,
-0.32568493485450745,
-0.28806909918785095,
0.10390418767929077,
0.2377612143754959,
-0.7115826606750488,
-0.15611134469509125,
0.01617116667330265,
-0.36643439531326294,
-0.6061885356903076,
0.42524364590644836,
-0.7721976637840271,
-0.1950264871120453,
-0.6397811770439148,
0.3345230221748352,
-0.6115000247955322,
0.02329067699611187,
-0.1062113344669342,
-0.6733245253562927,
0.08932758122682571,
0.13981416821479797,
-0.7005614042282104,
-0.009068494662642479,
0.6356695294380188,
1.0895214080810547,
-0.0056684548035264015,
0.0824560821056366,
-0.6461053490638733,
0.05594230070710182,
-0.40111008286476135,
0.7332468032836914,
-0.6825276017189026,
-0.4459114968776703,
-0.06715374439954758,
-0.1642981469631195,
0.11101891845464706,
-0.4793524742126465,
0.36336550116539,
-0.261341392993927,
0.5003311634063721,
-0.019008485600352287,
-0.8579626679420471,
-0.004819612018764019,
-0.01041756197810173,
-0.5292790532112122,
1.0361173152923584,
0.6215230822563171,
-0.5781078338623047,
0.5859375,
-0.8930619359016418,
-0.4198456406593323,
0.4087916612625122,
-0.4938903748989105,
-0.38906797766685486,
0.4336707293987274,
0.19067418575286865,
0.533275306224823,
-0.4399908483028412,
0.2769814133644104,
-0.14431850612163544,
-0.022241562604904175,
0.4759595990180969,
-0.07437268644571304,
0.6305341124534607,
0.22656184434890747,
0.020592741668224335,
-0.18278466165065765,
-1.079127311706543,
0.29345616698265076,
-0.29778972268104553,
-0.7228370904922485,
-0.24449224770069122,
-0.12800514698028564,
0.09878728538751602,
0.35324567556381226,
0.0677340105175972,
-0.7036800384521484,
0.36197224259376526,
-0.6214130520820618,
0.10177955776453018,
0.7246716022491455,
0.3243594765663147,
0.320054829120636,
-0.2519633173942566,
0.47751688957214355,
-0.0060555944219231606,
-0.20560623705387115,
-0.4942830801010132,
-0.01843695156276226,
-0.7612648606300354,
-0.5280327796936035,
0.5256868004798889,
0.34451261162757874,
-0.8583561778068542,
1.0427873134613037,
-0.39476191997528076,
-0.5217013955116272,
-0.45152345299720764,
0.31386762857437134,
0.28809598088264465,
0.8717296123504639,
0.5227302312850952,
-0.14704841375350952,
-0.9189469218254089,
-0.8512523174285889,
-0.18271537125110626,
-0.013831914402544498,
-0.27470460534095764,
-0.006174328736960888,
0.4995931386947632,
-0.09466453641653061,
1.0686824321746826,
-0.7986052632331848,
-0.15925654768943787,
-0.05639750137925148,
0.5448591709136963,
0.317496657371521,
0.3580018877983093,
0.5020241737365723,
-0.7970649003982544,
-0.5553252100944519,
0.02041308395564556,
-0.8481107950210571,
-0.23049621284008026,
-0.26156920194625854,
0.03869563713669777,
0.1852734237909317,
0.5233549475669861,
-0.36451244354248047,
0.4938232898712158,
0.021122479811310768,
-0.16197799146175385,
0.5413910746574402,
-0.2820771038532257,
0.09059977531433105,
-1.3321993350982666,
0.1998242735862732,
0.5482317805290222,
-0.12307710945606232,
-0.6445697546005249,
0.16142883896827698,
0.07947446405887604,
0.04162955284118652,
-0.6180461049079895,
0.22149334847927094,
-0.5626311302185059,
0.3326667249202728,
-0.2575209140777588,
-0.007669406943023205,
0.35594117641448975,
0.03986011818051338,
0.08391378074884415,
0.7752644419670105,
0.5415094494819641,
-0.5554445385932922,
0.6703510880470276,
0.3434242904186249,
-0.35887402296066284,
0.5764937996864319,
-0.3918472230434418,
-0.056145403534173965,
-0.26616284251213074,
0.052345797419548035,
-0.7517619132995605,
-0.007317763287574053,
0.002280347514897585,
-0.2808421552181244,
0.27402377128601074,
0.2767547369003296,
-0.5678980946540833,
-0.4144422113895416,
-0.2959020137786865,
-0.22831423580646515,
0.4264271855354309,
-0.23150360584259033,
0.5160825848579407,
0.20986977219581604,
-0.1568976789712906,
-0.1604919135570526,
-0.5573177337646484,
-0.0584314689040184,
-0.6214973330497742,
-0.36345481872558594,
0.6957769989967346,
0.003670991165563464,
-0.13766086101531982,
-0.25845301151275635,
-0.3041630983352661,
-0.16517265141010284,
-0.10074498504400253,
0.050938207656145096,
0.5862142443656921,
-0.16929008066654205,
0.6207494139671326,
-0.012288127094507217,
0.044803980737924576,
0.11951708048582077,
-0.152288019657135,
0.4975440204143524,
0.26043325662612915,
0.4324013590812683,
-0.48578304052352905,
0.4769461154937744,
0.27856677770614624,
-0.15345948934555054,
0.7661921977996826,
0.6741113066673279,
-0.2383723258972168,
0.10673049837350845,
-0.40655094385147095,
-0.11571449786424637,
-0.5172370672225952,
0.2834693491458893,
-0.4441867470741272,
-0.25598636269569397,
0.31833890080451965,
-0.10366834700107574,
-0.13507404923439026,
0.6079006791114807,
0.32185521721839905,
-0.2754160165786743,
0.5484737753868103,
0.6991089582443237,
0.1930132657289505,
0.6933111548423767,
-0.3396354615688324,
0.20273616909980774,
-0.879817008972168,
-0.41612616181373596,
-0.5769720673561096,
-0.0956340879201889,
-0.6693824529647827,
-0.7129835486412048,
0.5559183359146118,
-0.09684913605451584,
0.06723623722791672,
0.35099127888679504,
-0.37495046854019165,
0.2700454592704773,
0.39291849732398987,
0.285176545381546,
0.12489919364452362,
0.48004984855651855,
-0.20750068128108978,
-0.22126902639865875,
-0.27257779240608215,
-0.435300350189209,
1.2535139322280884,
0.1251486986875534,
0.5106322765350342,
-0.12643152475357056,
0.7674809098243713,
0.28804856538772583,
0.16794651746749878,
-0.6655063629150391,
0.3241383135318756,
-0.16391102969646454,
-0.2562902271747589,
-0.09581819176673889,
-0.46697574853897095,
-0.7199561595916748,
0.024390026926994324,
-0.7434571981430054,
-0.7695051431655884,
0.19408349692821503,
-0.0963626429438591,
-0.10944519937038422,
-0.049968864768743515,
-0.4435563087463379,
0.23590007424354553,
-0.2511523365974426,
-0.3770378530025482,
0.11512985080480576,
-0.4995100200176239,
0.1271955668926239,
-0.5072911381721497,
-0.16769079864025116,
0.09231019765138626,
-0.06234145909547806,
0.9269566535949707,
-0.6025813221931458,
0.3248485326766968,
-0.12090190500020981,
-0.059162963181734085,
0.3364015519618988,
-0.4450405240058899,
0.5308329463005066,
0.044040780514478683,
-0.3282369375228882,
-0.126836895942688,
-0.09441539645195007,
-0.2502143979072571,
-0.9199098348617554,
0.23509927093982697,
-0.3652556538581848,
-0.3985729515552521,
-0.3548508584499359,
-0.642049252986908,
-0.01727149821817875,
0.2904598116874695,
0.2822900116443634,
0.19030341506004333,
-0.0756634846329689,
0.3637433350086212,
0.48398929834365845,
-0.3092176616191864,
0.36925792694091797,
0.5371373891830444,
0.13884347677230835,
-0.5031158924102783,
0.7882976531982422,
0.19313360750675201,
0.06186104565858841,
0.5254887342453003,
0.22299788892269135,
-0.38780832290649414,
-0.42139631509780884,
0.1703002005815506,
-0.04910479858517647,
-0.47191861271858215,
-0.5041475892066956,
-0.6689855456352234,
-0.3900674283504486,
-0.8008956909179688,
-0.06328604370355606,
-0.19758695363998413,
-0.6893287897109985,
-0.30792295932769775,
-0.25344595313072205,
0.5385951995849609,
0.32065215706825256,
-0.15196697413921356,
0.5127686858177185,
-0.8058537244796753,
0.5253027081489563,
-0.058864861726760864,
0.16532209515571594,
-0.6782581210136414,
-0.1666887253522873,
-0.3278689980506897,
0.2531769573688507,
-0.48903587460517883,
-0.9412185549736023,
0.716079831123352,
0.3350108563899994,
0.618125855922699,
0.23137934505939484,
-0.24178491532802582,
0.8788647651672363,
-0.23170813918113708,
0.6099133491516113,
0.42469581961631775,
-0.9551716446876526,
0.9379116296768188,
-0.36343270540237427,
0.05116323009133339,
0.4579266309738159,
0.363583505153656,
-0.3112691640853882,
-0.22032733261585236,
-0.9075947403907776,
-1.161534070968628,
0.36746299266815186,
0.3621158003807068,
0.1922515630722046,
-0.0343807227909565,
0.841319739818573,
0.3465525805950165,
0.43075111508369446,
-0.42694467306137085,
-0.235951229929924,
0.07227341085672379,
-0.27211612462997437,
-0.19617746770381927,
0.08438864350318909,
-0.17118538916110992,
-0.46276623010635376,
0.7172214984893799,
-0.17601069808006287,
0.45227763056755066,
0.09495305269956589,
-0.09643516689538956,
-0.05192304402589798,
0.07840006053447723,
0.3626832962036133,
0.7483086585998535,
-0.33012884855270386,
-0.03239021822810173,
0.027904128655791283,
-0.5048313736915588,
0.23714779317378998,
0.30768296122550964,
0.005944756790995598,
0.19739346206188202,
0.29135993123054504,
0.6341835856437683,
-0.5396941304206848,
-0.45378023386001587,
0.32501381635665894,
-0.00310329906642437,
-0.41003167629241943,
-0.18655632436275482,
0.4289257824420929,
-0.3614993095397949,
0.32055893540382385,
0.45542454719543457,
0.1506516933441162,
0.1629759669303894,
-0.5799053311347961,
0.4963342547416687,
0.29391801357269287,
-0.10550567507743835,
0.03887201100587845,
0.2832181453704834,
-0.0780656635761261,
-0.2893340289592743,
0.7220339775085449,
-0.015328732319176197,
-0.18939821422100067,
0.6781431436538696,
0.6896283626556396,
0.630466103553772,
-0.02179710753262043,
0.36192628741264343,
0.305864155292511,
-0.08045107871294022,
0.11553540080785751,
0.47645533084869385,
-0.005163666792213917,
-0.5514229536056519,
-0.2243165373802185,
-0.5899819135665894,
-0.007251064293086529,
0.6485324501991272,
-0.873645007610321,
0.5977473258972168,
-0.32033273577690125,
-0.13251344859600067,
0.5687747001647949,
0.3111712336540222,
-0.9595010280609131,
0.3516988158226013,
-0.23761340975761414,
0.9146499633789062,
-1.2181485891342163,
0.6896995306015015,
0.6229478120803833,
-0.7449455261230469,
-0.552157461643219,
-0.06936028599739075,
-0.18095523118972778,
-0.15860216319561005,
0.7592059969902039,
0.08210337162017822,
0.3164072036743164,
-0.3077688217163086,
-0.32888418436050415,
-0.8239840269088745,
1.1373144388198853,
0.3108264207839966,
-0.3425348997116089,
0.035159509629011154,
0.18007095158100128,
0.763090968132019,
-0.641000509262085,
0.10672774910926819,
0.5645361542701721,
0.47908908128738403,
-0.06445683538913727,
-0.598021924495697,
0.10331369191408157,
-0.6072384715080261,
0.3015119433403015,
-0.03871389478445053,
-0.17901556193828583,
0.7852156758308411,
0.18007312715053558,
-0.3128474950790405,
-0.028534211218357086,
0.888512134552002,
0.11419351398944855,
0.06411638855934143,
0.19036726653575897,
0.16911587119102478,
0.9906882643699646,
-0.036934640258550644,
0.7384660840034485,
-0.10391510277986526,
0.4304843544960022,
1.1014050245285034,
-0.24361339211463928,
0.5219774842262268,
0.64561527967453,
-0.22777704894542694,
0.47859323024749756,
0.5461933016777039,
-0.5402613878250122,
0.5845934748649597,
0.27390486001968384,
-0.4914315640926361,
0.19102180004119873,
0.027768367901444435,
-0.35300567746162415,
0.6567086577415466,
0.6648139953613281,
-0.9639910459518433,
-0.14917466044425964,
0.11029034852981567,
-0.11016794294118881,
0.12050864100456238,
-0.08072745054960251,
0.7578411102294922,
-0.38694435358047485,
-0.7753233313560486,
0.5185819864273071,
0.2930331230163574,
0.3562297224998474,
-0.33089447021484375,
-0.22240781784057617,
-0.11901400983333588,
0.07027756422758102,
-0.19483207166194916,
-0.5909408926963806,
0.3599546551704407,
0.1587694138288498,
-0.15475988388061523,
-0.07511670887470245,
0.4517615735530853,
-0.4403618276119232,
-0.8389182686805725,
-0.3344173729419708,
0.5876192450523376,
0.005108536221086979,
0.3219100832939148,
-0.4618145525455475,
-0.3157675564289093,
-0.14652971923351288,
0.058011431246995926,
-0.036852918565273285,
0.22288376092910767,
0.1445365846157074,
0.12631380558013916,
0.5562814474105835,
0.45260778069496155,
0.06816492974758148,
-0.28597182035446167,
1.1152493953704834,
-0.5979195237159729,
-0.558220624923706,
-0.8024120330810547,
0.6214237809181213,
-0.5742878913879395,
-0.23373615741729736,
0.48471754789352417,
1.0060521364212036,
0.8383142948150635,
-0.26121312379837036,
1.3398354053497314,
-0.40921446681022644,
0.38778552412986755,
-0.8530086874961853,
0.13370612263679504,
-0.10795062780380249,
0.3706851899623871,
-0.21094073355197906,
-0.9683771729469299,
-0.4014776647090912,
0.9599449634552002,
-0.05252927914261818,
0.11299456655979156,
0.9624241590499878,
0.826751708984375,
-0.24421142041683197,
-0.07541569322347641,
-0.1892670840024948,
0.08054517954587936,
0.6724274158477783,
0.04623907804489136,
0.2955365478992462,
-0.49331575632095337,
-0.13153380155563354,
-0.39631158113479614,
-0.14836576581001282,
-0.031174521893262863,
-1.0076091289520264,
-0.6681105494499207,
-0.7912567257881165,
-0.5242976546287537,
-0.5229008793830872,
0.21123433113098145,
0.9813422560691833,
0.5782278180122375,
-0.4763459265232086,
-0.0195058211684227,
-0.45197686553001404,
-0.18961448967456818,
-0.4212038815021515,
-0.33358234167099,
0.5559208393096924,
-0.5467666387557983,
-0.7847262024879456,
0.5058615803718567,
0.10595383495092392,
0.16657516360282898,
-0.12929445505142212,
0.245338574051857,
-0.4696243405342102,
0.16506043076515198,
0.3991459012031555,
0.10298436135053635,
-0.2954779863357544,
-0.36714503169059753,
-0.283513605594635,
0.15289577841758728,
0.4840242862701416,
1.0966973304748535,
-0.8702222108840942,
0.7882935404777527,
0.7703824043273926,
0.24976269900798798,
0.6473070383071899,
0.20808349549770355,
0.9549427628517151,
-1.299623966217041,
0.08593783527612686,
-0.07622278481721878,
0.13086484372615814,
0.3050858974456787,
-0.622069776058197,
0.5836310982704163,
0.43957287073135376,
-0.027916552498936653,
-0.6230813264846802,
0.015580510720610619,
-0.8779886364936829,
-0.2558457851409912,
0.9815360307693481,
-0.152771458029747,
-0.23316089808940887,
0.1973910629749298,
-0.09264656156301498,
0.9390361905097961,
-0.23556722700595856,
1.163059115409851,
0.34814000129699707,
-0.4913484454154968,
0.07274723798036575,
-0.3219086527824402,
0.46466904878616333,
-0.1647932082414627,
-0.9417271614074707,
-0.05852050334215164,
0.4835605323314667,
0.26435866951942444,
0.337012380361557,
0.23520803451538086,
-0.22822023928165436,
0.0634678527712822,
-0.015016211196780205,
0.06896227598190308,
-0.43850386142730713,
-0.20934443175792694,
-0.2556769549846649,
0.21414557099342346,
-0.44242414832115173,
-0.18459287285804749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00020v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00020v2
|
Harmful Speech Detection by Language Models Exhibits Gender-Queer Dialect Bias
| 2024-05-23T18:07:28 | 2024-06-21T18:01:06 |
Rebecca Dorn, Lee Kezar, Fred Morstatter, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Content moderation on social media platforms shapes the dynamics of online
discourse, influencing whose voices are amplified and whose are suppressed.
Recent studies have raised concerns about the fairness of content moderation
practices, particularly for aggressively flagging posts from transgender and
non-binary individuals as toxic. In this study, we investigate the presence of
bias in harmful speech classification of gender-queer dialect online, focusing
specifically on the treatment of reclaimed slurs. We introduce a novel dataset,
QueerReclaimLex, based on 109 curated templates exemplifying non-derogatory
uses of LGBTQ+ slurs. Dataset instances are scored by gender-queer annotators
for potential harm depending on additional context about speaker identity. We
systematically evaluate the performance of five off-the-shelf language models
in assessing the harm of these texts and explore the effectiveness of
chain-of-thought prompting to teach large language models (LLMs) to leverage
author identity context. We reveal a tendency for these models to inaccurately
flag texts authored by gender-queer individuals as harmful. Strikingly, across
all LLMs the performance is poorest for texts that show signs of being written
by individuals targeted by the featured slur (F1 <= 0.24). We highlight an
urgent need for fairness and inclusivity in content moderation systems. By
uncovering these biases, this work aims to inform the development of more
equitable content moderation practices and contribute to the creation of
inclusive online spaces for all users.
|
[
-0.16606104373931885,
-0.7412420511245728,
0.32127493619918823,
-0.13280273973941803,
-0.1550007164478302,
-0.09383223205804825,
-0.05868137255311012,
-0.49823638796806335,
0.02950246073305607,
0.8691216111183167,
-0.5300530195236206,
-0.23847801983356476,
-0.6261869072914124,
0.13580088317394257,
-0.7150223255157471,
1.2040573358535767,
0.507584810256958,
0.17969827353954315,
0.11017509549856186,
-0.05071542412042618,
-0.7230185866355896,
-0.3245192766189575,
-0.3777852952480316,
0.038584135472774506,
0.5583358407020569,
-0.0716475248336792,
0.7140150666236877,
0.4513310194015503,
-0.03786441683769226,
0.23794318735599518,
-0.33822041749954224,
-0.03130264952778816,
-0.78651362657547,
0.42112794518470764,
-0.4907492995262146,
-0.38954460620880127,
-0.34633713960647583,
0.0502457432448864,
0.5295746326446533,
0.5791577100753784,
-0.09207182377576828,
0.2768930494785309,
0.11553025245666504,
0.4805658459663391,
-0.7006926536560059,
-0.30650806427001953,
-1.0526456832885742,
0.050350774079561234,
-0.41618067026138306,
0.10909522324800491,
-0.4046059250831604,
-0.46245381236076355,
-0.09861747920513153,
-0.3611922562122345,
0.26403379440307617,
0.1199706569314003,
0.5559183359146118,
-0.008236302994191647,
-0.5522658824920654,
-0.3647957742214203,
-0.7758497595787048,
0.8206609487533569,
-0.7262934446334839,
0.7296344637870789,
0.6280746459960938,
0.10188433527946472,
0.0937185287475586,
-0.4928222894668579,
-0.6187041997909546,
0.154572531580925,
-0.013995807617902756,
-0.22955267131328583,
-0.3855842351913452,
-0.12839825451374054,
0.41209807991981506,
0.0918145626783371,
-0.5467134118080139,
0.2331693172454834,
-0.6255922913551331,
-0.3605706989765167,
0.8396264314651489,
0.10471423715353012,
0.2379915565252304,
-0.34508657455444336,
-0.3500775098800659,
0.2157815396785736,
-0.6659048199653625,
-0.2543879747390747,
0.8197742700576782,
0.6699082255363464,
0.14563138782978058,
0.37009066343307495,
0.37522652745246887,
0.29617249965667725,
0.113624706864357,
0.003909275401383638,
0.3509848713874817,
-0.10111260414123535,
-0.1206701248884201,
0.11756021529436111,
0.6367359161376953,
0.4413580596446991,
0.3181910812854767,
0.0007559619261883199,
-0.36393511295318604,
-0.13601255416870117,
0.4585791528224945,
-0.3147401213645935,
0.03544800356030464,
-0.047392282634973526,
-0.40171846747398376,
0.007014055270701647,
-0.0675530880689621,
-0.7758418917655945,
-1.0824226140975952,
-0.02840355411171913,
0.3897992968559265,
-0.13552497327327728,
-0.6003890037536621,
0.09172987937927246,
-0.3157568871974945,
-0.09885261952877045,
0.19856484234333038,
-0.6789088249206543,
0.1510372906923294,
0.8590498566627502,
0.39563873410224915,
-0.09462949633598328,
0.1890937238931656,
-0.7560744285583496,
-0.02675120159983635,
-0.3089566230773926,
0.444439560174942,
-0.4735334515571594,
-0.2488393932580948,
0.26830366253852844,
0.23052901029586792,
0.11444241553544998,
-0.6808894276618958,
1.0096515417099,
-0.39891746640205383,
0.2977088689804077,
-0.5399602651596069,
-0.5148959755897522,
-0.16629914939403534,
-0.1611165702342987,
-0.8545480370521545,
0.7757185101509094,
0.12969423830509186,
-0.8625994324684143,
0.5957018136978149,
-0.29838117957115173,
-0.1716427356004715,
0.3439154624938965,
-0.08237065374851227,
-0.3864001929759979,
-0.02197706326842308,
-0.19107425212860107,
0.47693461179733276,
-0.11700178682804108,
0.5809416174888611,
-0.3246499001979828,
-0.3931088149547577,
0.2777850329875946,
-0.3709975481033325,
0.8112280964851379,
0.2956768870353699,
-0.7085731625556946,
0.30100059509277344,
-0.29336681962013245,
-0.2001011073589325,
-0.03677063807845116,
-0.01419877726584673,
-0.6500059366226196,
0.1232111006975174,
0.42015132308006287,
0.3139563798904419,
-0.3942258954048157,
-0.6431379318237305,
-0.6655861139297485,
-0.3536938428878784,
0.4823227822780609,
0.9997485280036926,
-0.4086897671222687,
0.23442742228507996,
-0.5744561553001404,
0.4293924570083618,
-0.07838626205921173,
0.23341582715511322,
0.06121258810162544,
-0.6383504867553711,
-0.39565715193748474,
-0.2735840976238251,
0.009501676075160503,
0.1944299340248108,
-0.6548690795898438,
0.5515776872634888,
-0.3052901327610016,
-0.3237510025501251,
-0.5018936991691589,
0.07447647303342819,
0.43060302734375,
0.3471335470676422,
0.25858360528945923,
-0.1836208701133728,
-0.46701836585998535,
-1.2730530500411987,
-0.7050442695617676,
-0.44531217217445374,
0.039728760719299316,
0.2733776867389679,
0.32057705521583557,
-0.26353156566619873,
0.7062153816223145,
-0.08275386691093445,
-0.18429504334926605,
-0.13079959154129028,
0.07841507345438004,
0.01561433169990778,
0.201477512717247,
0.5675348043441772,
-0.9366939663887024,
-0.39257103204727173,
-0.5140171051025391,
-0.17850278317928314,
-0.5942884087562561,
0.03563154861330986,
-0.09227693825960159,
0.03429105132818222,
0.22096411883831024,
-0.11914335191249847,
0.3241940438747406,
0.3875272274017334,
-0.7957144379615784,
0.7270150780677795,
0.6167898774147034,
0.13107085227966309,
-0.6054120659828186,
0.04708223044872284,
0.21314698457717896,
-0.6070078611373901,
-0.7916616797447205,
0.10612178593873978,
-0.1151537373661995,
0.10369738936424255,
-0.7162666320800781,
0.5903330445289612,
-0.17835745215415955,
0.296353816986084,
-0.20104321837425232,
0.17787224054336548,
0.0744551494717598,
0.07884202152490616,
-0.020973121747374535,
0.5663264989852905,
0.19327673316001892,
-0.3799048066139221,
-0.014924957416951656,
0.2460469901561737,
-0.22487835586071014,
0.5605593323707581,
-0.2495272010564804,
0.19688183069229126,
-0.5137537717819214,
0.15454742312431335,
-0.9821427464485168,
0.14748753607273102,
0.5194021463394165,
-0.2593417167663574,
0.11521907150745392,
-0.021716192364692688,
-0.44021421670913696,
-0.2462051659822464,
-0.5034292340278625,
0.5450873374938965,
0.09713979065418243,
-0.3422037959098816,
0.2573471665382385,
0.9726352691650391,
-0.26525482535362244,
-0.5770710110664368,
-0.7956953644752502,
0.022617029026150703,
-0.41933777928352356,
-0.2450026571750641,
0.07825534790754318,
-0.08755999058485031,
-0.5009137988090515,
-0.15709975361824036,
-0.06624092906713486,
-0.17415104806423187,
0.2144302874803543,
0.3606196641921997,
-0.01886930875480175,
0.20228685438632965,
0.5386896729469299,
0.21741259098052979,
0.3909243941307068,
0.3309842050075531,
0.11959834396839142,
0.5596396923065186,
-0.07123137265443802,
-0.1586567461490631,
-0.11056921631097794,
0.7390323281288147,
0.44228726625442505,
0.0557018518447876,
0.6341762542724609,
0.8639631867408752,
-0.563900887966156,
-0.38028615713119507,
-0.6665182113647461,
-0.2471345067024231,
-0.4634344279766083,
0.35225632786750793,
0.19663311541080475,
-1.2793011665344238,
0.36085689067840576,
0.4228588938713074,
0.226385697722435,
0.36271584033966064,
0.2865649461746216,
0.010944138281047344,
0.8794417381286621,
0.3981916308403015,
0.07397099584341049,
0.49009665846824646,
0.03992908075451851,
0.17973501980304718,
-0.5331524610519409,
-0.14806051552295685,
-0.639248788356781,
-0.21791677176952362,
-0.7242968678474426,
-0.4275527596473694,
0.13032060861587524,
-0.33611026406288147,
-0.49586859345436096,
0.27714627981185913,
-0.5268911719322205,
0.316523015499115,
0.27786239981651306,
0.175114706158638,
0.2102413922548294,
0.05289587751030922,
0.030477801337838173,
-0.5910261273384094,
-0.4836783707141876,
-0.6123025417327881,
0.9171615839004517,
0.7143866419792175,
0.7005189061164856,
0.28602415323257446,
0.2540196478366852,
1.0541572570800781,
0.40656593441963196,
-0.666053295135498,
0.4726663827896118,
-0.24574045836925507,
-1.2344948053359985,
-0.0710623487830162,
-0.5033227205276489,
-0.8214279413223267,
0.24309517443180084,
-0.35933369398117065,
-0.8723974227905273,
0.35148704051971436,
0.07073502987623215,
-0.19931752979755402,
0.7551552057266235,
-0.4168488681316376,
0.45236289501190186,
-0.20635122060775757,
-0.7536149024963379,
-0.15401385724544525,
-0.4460615813732147,
0.5836476683616638,
-0.43174025416374207,
0.7234284281730652,
-0.3729473948478699,
0.010567354038357735,
0.7331737875938416,
-0.09615373611450195,
1.0000566244125366,
-0.17200949788093567,
-0.5233024954795837,
0.16157904267311096,
0.3073444068431854,
0.10162080824375153,
-0.14048674702644348,
-0.561385452747345,
0.4180697798728943,
-0.0814368724822998,
-0.019332200288772583,
0.004822678864002228,
0.6923923492431641,
-0.47798725962638855,
-0.6204267144203186,
-0.2832997143268585,
-0.25984930992126465,
-0.11558845639228821,
0.21332702040672302,
0.025706451386213303,
0.2368282824754715,
-0.07804113626480103,
0.11024681478738785,
0.7351964712142944,
-0.5574923157691956,
0.22049131989479065,
0.3191739618778229,
-0.4404536485671997,
-0.3576524555683136,
0.8060120940208435,
-0.03797105327248573,
0.2054518759250641,
-0.056345123797655106,
0.1722189486026764,
-0.5632216930389404,
-0.24121110141277313,
-0.27619102597236633,
0.3289211690425873,
-0.7636430263519287,
-0.2992449700832367,
-0.7123733758926392,
-0.1687447875738144,
-0.5495935678482056,
0.0637650191783905,
-0.31168171763420105,
-0.3383220136165619,
-0.2992451786994934,
-0.06458191573619843,
-0.04098154976963997,
0.7194579839706421,
-0.03906221687793732,
0.23694494366645813,
-0.7625669836997986,
0.10573381185531616,
0.3938595652580261,
0.3254778981208801,
-0.08273196220397949,
-0.650164783000946,
0.10506252944469452,
0.21524593234062195,
-0.3418024778366089,
-1.1796625852584839,
0.40169838070869446,
0.3237057626247406,
0.6592944264411926,
0.41310593485832214,
0.2733123302459717,
0.17368461191654205,
-0.32113996148109436,
0.9722371101379395,
0.20034286379814148,
-1.0531015396118164,
0.3901161551475525,
-0.47154539823532104,
-0.079536572098732,
0.45340457558631897,
0.46195414662361145,
-0.9355378150939941,
-0.6095333099365234,
-0.29294681549072266,
-0.9245352149009705,
0.6296078562736511,
0.1473437398672104,
0.5139806866645813,
-0.34476688504219055,
0.2571696937084198,
0.6849460601806641,
0.5953931212425232,
-1.2113734483718872,
-0.45593178272247314,
-0.18100017309188843,
0.07709237933158875,
0.231292724609375,
-0.47676700353622437,
-0.19514086842536926,
-0.24398577213287354,
0.651189386844635,
-0.11200054734945297,
0.2968476116657257,
-0.06767522543668747,
-0.24262353777885437,
-0.4345274865627289,
0.5088337063789368,
0.44681480526924133,
0.575939953327179,
0.07911137491464615,
0.19628393650054932,
-0.10768385976552963,
-0.4164235591888428,
0.01930852420628071,
-0.23183204233646393,
-0.44761207699775696,
0.11715114116668701,
0.28315913677215576,
0.8934358954429626,
0.10245494544506073,
-0.8324285745620728,
0.6277403831481934,
-0.1622273474931717,
0.055794376879930496,
-0.1573965847492218,
0.1542113721370697,
-0.08899077028036118,
0.15580712258815765,
0.4158746302127838,
-0.022381680086255074,
0.47620561718940735,
-0.5031673312187195,
0.22437931597232819,
0.49679267406463623,
-0.703800618648529,
-0.34949663281440735,
0.944400429725647,
0.28842949867248535,
-0.3156203627586365,
0.30206501483917236,
-0.15162484347820282,
-0.7000907063484192,
0.1839413195848465,
0.5533100962638855,
1.0657124519348145,
-0.20080871880054474,
0.533854603767395,
0.5196300745010376,
0.39162173867225647,
0.26444920897483826,
0.41843467950820923,
0.13724201917648315,
-0.7704660296440125,
-0.04510683938860893,
-0.7087578177452087,
0.10476351529359818,
0.4249603748321533,
-0.449503630399704,
0.2664787173271179,
-0.6419900059700012,
-0.5846880674362183,
-0.015285884030163288,
-0.26983991265296936,
-0.4689186215400696,
-0.03204406425356865,
0.7543339729309082,
0.6286415457725525,
-1.253377079963684,
0.22266671061515808,
0.5437306761741638,
0.15764975547790527,
-0.4169171452522278,
0.10394205152988434,
0.5646072626113892,
-0.3302052617073059,
0.4248887598514557,
0.29894301295280457,
-0.17042392492294312,
-0.2217206060886383,
-0.49015650153160095,
-0.38233092427253723,
0.4802978038787842,
0.5457695722579956,
-0.7039706110954285,
0.22541551291942596,
0.43839046359062195,
0.5842731595039368,
-0.15422798693180084,
0.3862862288951874,
0.19534751772880554,
0.3818574845790863,
-0.2095113843679428,
-1.3113586902618408,
0.2771059572696686,
-0.23455928266048431,
-0.008159204386174679,
0.18356579542160034,
-0.4726914167404175,
1.0179848670959473,
0.1470741629600525,
-0.572058379650116,
-0.21325869858264923,
0.3373391032218933,
0.13522139191627502,
0.27241766452789307,
0.9839429259300232,
0.2529357671737671,
0.8551362156867981,
-0.042623408138751984,
0.5103439092636108,
0.3725436329841614,
0.1562391072511673,
1.0775245428085327,
-0.25242161750793457,
0.5691667199134827,
0.23818114399909973,
-0.10366564244031906,
0.5098050832748413,
0.47408798336982727,
0.12988732755184174,
0.27661722898483276,
0.39018699526786804,
-0.46696192026138306,
-0.35474371910095215,
-0.6970071792602539,
-0.3860057294368744,
0.35302868485450745,
0.6026157736778259,
-0.6213970184326172,
-0.14816302061080933,
0.21003155410289764,
0.2020931988954544,
0.5611821413040161,
-0.39220917224884033,
0.5498040318489075,
0.027454080060124397,
-0.45556601881980896,
0.5132518410682678,
0.026756292209029198,
0.9586419463157654,
-0.445599228143692,
0.08783669769763947,
-0.054295673966407776,
-0.09179630875587463,
-0.2782030701637268,
-0.8814161419868469,
0.3984684944152832,
-0.010435134172439575,
-0.23672980070114136,
-0.3439244329929352,
0.9056013226509094,
-0.6253772974014282,
-0.31850892305374146,
0.49864205718040466,
0.6195588111877441,
0.03462928533554077,
-0.19582119584083557,
-0.8349037766456604,
0.26948899030685425,
0.009455801919102669,
0.2697075605392456,
0.18817760050296783,
-0.007906705141067505,
-0.31076157093048096,
0.7191928029060364,
0.4241795539855957,
0.16299723088741302,
0.2826777398586273,
0.2170628160238266,
0.8289055228233337,
-0.49684974551200867,
-0.5008861422538757,
-0.7051482796669006,
0.5046863555908203,
0.034123558551073074,
-0.2849036753177643,
0.7160280346870422,
0.6216441988945007,
0.9221359491348267,
0.15934093296527863,
0.6859081387519836,
-0.04308058321475983,
0.6451429724693298,
-0.139778733253479,
1.0912747383117676,
-0.6476380825042725,
0.4350068271160126,
-0.5647510886192322,
-0.696286141872406,
-0.24171370267868042,
0.3018510043621063,
-0.12771403789520264,
0.12233732640743256,
0.28069236874580383,
0.8813442587852478,
0.08029071241617203,
0.355258971452713,
0.39952120184898376,
0.32837405800819397,
0.46031057834625244,
0.08684104681015015,
1.0580543279647827,
-0.38277527689933777,
0.23464304208755493,
-0.0919032171368599,
0.013336658477783203,
-0.06020693853497505,
-0.821473240852356,
-0.8780490756034851,
-0.793064534664154,
-0.4133530557155609,
-0.5628010034561157,
0.14523223042488098,
1.1146899461746216,
0.6424163579940796,
-0.7210474014282227,
-0.19975951313972473,
0.4581565260887146,
0.33325913548469543,
-0.024801619350910187,
-0.3106188178062439,
-0.09015069156885147,
0.1332755833864212,
-0.8272049427032471,
0.13215188682079315,
-0.11444130539894104,
-0.4272349774837494,
-0.45858532190322876,
-0.019775236025452614,
-0.3082910180091858,
-0.07275214046239853,
0.617271900177002,
0.05783925950527191,
-0.7962281107902527,
-0.33483195304870605,
-0.032530322670936584,
-0.13064506649971008,
-0.24862521886825562,
0.782719612121582,
-0.5240532755851746,
0.6439123749732971,
0.6119591593742371,
0.2244804948568344,
0.09210195392370224,
-0.01284454483538866,
0.5285884737968445,
-0.9049903750419617,
-0.1740478128194809,
0.551629900932312,
0.29385435581207275,
0.5036104917526245,
-0.5604724884033203,
0.10671146214008331,
0.5165942311286926,
-0.3980564773082733,
-1.006710410118103,
0.10604691505432129,
-0.4873271882534027,
-0.3888861835002899,
1.3742011785507202,
-0.013368516229093075,
-0.11764825880527496,
-0.4799165427684784,
-0.3113422989845276,
0.1982925683259964,
-0.44450485706329346,
0.8515514731407166,
0.4556114971637726,
0.18627895414829254,
-0.1879037767648697,
-0.7343347072601318,
0.5871922373771667,
0.2915782332420349,
-0.4095812439918518,
0.4353939890861511,
0.8606802821159363,
0.3993869125843048,
0.05751343443989754,
0.4490172564983368,
-0.17703749239444733,
0.19419707357883453,
-0.28951090574264526,
0.05499428138136864,
0.110675148665905,
-0.21171514689922333,
-0.4666399359703064,
0.11919315159320831,
-0.17909017205238342,
0.24204383790493011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14863v1
|
A Nurse is Blue and Elephant is Rugby: Cross Domain Alignment in Large Language Models Reveal Human-like Patterns
| 2024-05-23T17:59:26 | 2024-05-23T17:59:26 |
Asaf Yehudai, Taelin Karidi, Gabriel Stanovsky, Ariel Goldstein, Omri Abend
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Cross-domain alignment refers to the task of mapping a concept from one
domain to another. For example, ``If a \textit{doctor} were a \textit{color},
what color would it be?''. This seemingly peculiar task is designed to
investigate how people represent concrete and abstract concepts through their
mappings between categories and their reasoning processes over those mappings.
In this paper, we adapt this task from cognitive science to evaluate the
conceptualization and reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs)
through a behavioral study. We examine several LLMs by prompting them with a
cross-domain mapping task and analyzing their responses at both the population
and individual levels. Additionally, we assess the models' ability to reason
about their predictions by analyzing and categorizing their explanations for
these mappings. The results reveal several similarities between humans' and
models' mappings and explanations, suggesting that models represent concepts
similarly to humans. This similarity is evident not only in the model
representation but also in their behavior. Furthermore, the models mostly
provide valid explanations and deploy reasoning paths that are similar to those
of humans.
|
[
-0.314059317111969,
-0.7430822253227234,
0.742854118347168,
0.19963526725769043,
-0.05725483596324921,
0.12982192635536194,
-0.376865029335022,
-0.7095242142677307,
-0.07914730906486511,
0.45105311274528503,
-0.5468683838844299,
-0.4532715976238251,
-0.567690372467041,
0.05862812325358391,
-0.26927492022514343,
0.75944584608078,
-0.18689113855361938,
0.22999393939971924,
-0.30009618401527405,
-0.13409334421157837,
-0.7998474836349487,
-0.5392628908157349,
-0.7168629765510559,
-0.7784932851791382,
0.46269986033439636,
-0.0576133206486702,
0.9704850316047668,
0.6719037890434265,
0.48911988735198975,
0.33373427391052246,
0.10917605459690094,
0.13495661318302155,
-0.5234984159469604,
-0.05521831288933754,
-0.7710216641426086,
-0.4852449595928192,
-0.4810514748096466,
0.2553110718727112,
0.269566148519516,
1.0604780912399292,
0.04705853387713432,
0.017672188580036163,
0.04372801259160042,
0.33878234028816223,
-0.2901967465877533,
0.18750238418579102,
-0.5597334504127502,
-0.07020967453718185,
0.01959731988608837,
-0.2745814621448517,
-0.37579163908958435,
-0.15755023062229156,
0.4312310516834259,
-0.8727341294288635,
0.11978944391012192,
0.4233149588108063,
1.1192268133163452,
0.03532722592353821,
-0.7118876576423645,
-0.2905438244342804,
-0.8280163407325745,
0.9355095028877258,
-0.5521573424339294,
0.48597121238708496,
0.41842854022979736,
0.1829499751329422,
-0.2671957015991211,
-0.30851510167121887,
-0.8766584992408752,
-0.19489911198616028,
-0.3653179705142975,
-0.026186194270849228,
-0.17747685313224792,
-0.03305482119321823,
0.1589851975440979,
0.04516831040382385,
-0.7461614012718201,
0.12353290617465973,
-0.2671041786670685,
-0.1557495892047882,
0.9078614115715027,
0.3015782833099365,
0.8044803142547607,
0.19922499358654022,
-0.35134464502334595,
0.06902111321687698,
-0.5349894762039185,
-0.03096097707748413,
0.06643327325582504,
0.34371867775917053,
-0.19255180656909943,
0.7490803599357605,
-0.09526637196540833,
0.9758106470108032,
0.11626896262168884,
-0.2666226327419281,
0.0346238873898983,
-0.33783257007598877,
-0.2295197993516922,
0.12587286531925201,
0.46883338689804077,
0.6368324160575867,
0.8480368852615356,
-0.27166223526000977,
-0.10952148586511612,
0.45883798599243164,
0.4569290578365326,
-0.21780550479888916,
-0.1657603681087494,
0.18797245621681213,
-0.7036080956459045,
0.10639774054288864,
-0.2641848921775818,
-0.22592587769031525,
-0.35175028443336487,
-0.8300938606262207,
0.3707561790943146,
-0.4896981418132782,
-0.4850787818431854,
0.47526654601097107,
-0.057374559342861176,
0.3408969044685364,
0.38276517391204834,
-1.0481168031692505,
0.3997889757156372,
1.1338218450546265,
0.5046479105949402,
-0.472695529460907,
-0.5152508616447449,
0.2278297245502472,
0.3027608096599579,
-0.37519481778144836,
0.8571928143501282,
-0.7915266752243042,
-0.25866997241973877,
-0.0822659283876419,
0.07336804270744324,
-0.25341862440109253,
-0.5312230587005615,
0.28781694173812866,
-0.5129329562187195,
-0.0458856038749218,
-0.4536396563053131,
-0.6493180394172668,
-0.46863898634910583,
0.4636615514755249,
-0.4761221706867218,
0.7771288156509399,
-0.0025633573532104492,
-0.593311071395874,
0.527315080165863,
-0.6351943016052246,
-0.34820759296417236,
-0.05039243400096893,
-0.42143696546554565,
-0.05219157412648201,
-0.05837943032383919,
-0.09261512011289597,
0.5674323439598083,
-0.5299347639083862,
0.24137546122074127,
-0.4295693337917328,
-0.14700905978679657,
0.6940026879310608,
0.22814758121967316,
0.9420440196990967,
0.022111674770712852,
-0.18260999023914337,
-0.04094894230365753,
-0.4477955996990204,
0.14614814519882202,
0.40655189752578735,
-0.18612729012966156,
-0.8427994847297668,
0.095680370926857,
-0.35165804624557495,
0.47832486033439636,
-0.0013866907684132457,
-0.456556111574173,
0.3791229724884033,
-0.024472801014780998,
0.5042585730552673,
0.4054344594478607,
-0.14480562508106232,
0.5331756472587585,
-0.7657085657119751,
0.6080042719841003,
0.0012905874755233526,
-0.009163053706288338,
0.21891431510448456,
-0.6886605024337769,
-0.555827260017395,
-0.4087446331977844,
0.34445318579673767,
0.4611154794692993,
-0.32941293716430664,
0.22231528162956238,
-0.5392782688140869,
-0.46624210476875305,
-0.6197304725646973,
-0.08800327777862549,
0.41268810629844666,
0.4941878616809845,
0.23200778663158417,
-0.31776973605155945,
-0.4774410128593445,
-0.8287826776504517,
-0.45722848176956177,
-0.2393597513437271,
0.18335597217082977,
0.38410484790802,
0.7543808817863464,
-0.3616493046283722,
0.9430269598960876,
-0.33684831857681274,
0.06693796068429947,
-0.037785377353429794,
0.1707996129989624,
-0.09862163662910461,
0.49811163544654846,
0.4756971001625061,
-0.6957541704177856,
-0.1586400866508484,
0.2505689561367035,
-0.873323380947113,
-0.09903956949710846,
-0.22336597740650177,
-0.5343358516693115,
0.09512652456760406,
0.4534521698951721,
-0.7261037826538086,
0.45355483889579773,
0.48523539304733276,
-0.5401212573051453,
0.560066282749176,
-0.05265143886208534,
0.13231463730335236,
-0.5618560314178467,
0.09342470020055771,
0.24261854588985443,
0.04010794684290886,
-0.6400982141494751,
0.08918493241071701,
-0.2282816469669342,
0.04025944322347641,
-0.1380123347043991,
0.7400678396224976,
-0.6352702975273132,
-0.3961034417152405,
-0.12531936168670654,
0.29579252004623413,
0.143007293343544,
0.33218562602996826,
0.5428513288497925,
0.36739492416381836,
0.405342161655426,
-0.7364729642868042,
0.22176890075206757,
0.2872501015663147,
-0.3711185157299042,
0.7247165441513062,
-0.5861658453941345,
0.12706203758716583,
0.012589532881975174,
0.28311124444007874,
-1.1202237606048584,
0.019494039937853813,
0.047500964254140854,
-0.43007534742355347,
0.08102649450302124,
-0.07617221772670746,
-0.3479604721069336,
-0.17181597650051117,
0.18450604379177094,
0.8339595794677734,
0.3144446015357971,
-0.2727646231651306,
0.7339354157447815,
0.48346570134162903,
-0.1647297441959381,
-0.41170743107795715,
-0.7864882946014404,
-0.12867696583271027,
-0.2790907919406891,
-0.8289595246315002,
0.475877583026886,
0.08940720558166504,
-0.6174667477607727,
0.05162909999489784,
-0.016702190041542053,
-0.09874355792999268,
0.0766267478466034,
0.1856682002544403,
0.6483352184295654,
-0.5923845767974854,
0.06583189964294434,
-0.28577595949172974,
0.1544613093137741,
0.2593854069709778,
-0.3051435947418213,
0.5161505341529846,
0.25959599018096924,
-0.44935622811317444,
-0.27352625131607056,
0.29731565713882446,
0.47932732105255127,
-0.23562312126159668,
0.6447574496269226,
0.09924030303955078,
-0.4657075107097626,
-0.2704586088657379,
-0.37158310413360596,
-0.08918871730566025,
-0.39892783761024475,
0.34200960397720337,
-0.4791579842567444,
-0.7451721429824829,
0.49150243401527405,
-0.07704290747642517,
0.02386772446334362,
0.2792750597000122,
0.7103273868560791,
-0.2709833085536957,
1.113090991973877,
0.5064602494239807,
0.21021360158920288,
0.007087562698870897,
-0.14648646116256714,
0.5152643322944641,
-0.9470809698104858,
-0.5779244303703308,
-0.5242079496383667,
-0.5398548245429993,
-0.5209316611289978,
-0.6040189266204834,
-0.08815420418977737,
-0.08058609068393707,
-0.47260722517967224,
0.268299400806427,
-0.6386102437973022,
0.3654255270957947,
0.17907115817070007,
-0.15227380394935608,
0.28089314699172974,
-0.11286921799182892,
-0.1904815286397934,
-0.05051662027835846,
-0.46745917201042175,
-0.7013072371482849,
0.9938281774520874,
0.33000004291534424,
0.8568616509437561,
0.11552097648382187,
0.41246405243873596,
0.22554533183574677,
0.37409234046936035,
-1.0141208171844482,
0.6640325784683228,
-0.06026775389909744,
-0.8460871577262878,
-0.4073401689529419,
-0.15113280713558197,
-1.3103801012039185,
0.5328941941261292,
-0.5125042796134949,
-0.8725107312202454,
0.2760399281978607,
0.09045218676328659,
-0.2881656587123871,
0.10511693358421326,
-0.48631954193115234,
0.8320809006690979,
-0.5839132070541382,
0.08275720477104187,
-0.2793852984905243,
-0.38611018657684326,
0.6302326917648315,
-0.13835731148719788,
0.21270297467708588,
-0.10908057540655136,
-0.15024921298027039,
0.6666065454483032,
-0.15856188535690308,
0.8212075233459473,
0.1892857551574707,
-0.4327501058578491,
0.1419834941625595,
0.3268950879573822,
0.10048358887434006,
-0.5180705189704895,
-0.09548579901456833,
0.34172558784484863,
0.039457354694604874,
-0.5178778171539307,
-0.7961203455924988,
0.4365004897117615,
-0.8375785946846008,
-0.7456138134002686,
-0.5065363049507141,
-0.7256165742874146,
-0.3450591564178467,
0.018678931519389153,
-0.10692800581455231,
0.05787014588713646,
-0.2915741205215454,
-0.37329012155532837,
0.6022107005119324,
-0.267354816198349,
-0.10953614860773087,
0.7422061562538147,
-0.40926867723464966,
0.2365625500679016,
0.8074214458465576,
-0.007380386348813772,
0.4331834018230438,
0.4296474754810333,
0.09933649748563766,
-0.34176722168922424,
-0.6204286813735962,
-0.23075369000434875,
0.666187584400177,
-0.6723188757896423,
0.13457538187503815,
-0.537691056728363,
-0.1417127102613449,
-0.327786922454834,
-0.24803191423416138,
0.05896127223968506,
-0.3174291253089905,
-0.08658671379089355,
0.01986023411154747,
0.14513441920280457,
0.8539133071899414,
0.33402585983276367,
0.11190871894359589,
-0.5661719441413879,
0.3490259647369385,
0.4657166004180908,
-0.05467906966805458,
0.3044095039367676,
-0.5651193857192993,
0.010541122406721115,
0.13279308378696442,
-0.2914694845676422,
-0.7753036618232727,
0.17997422814369202,
-0.024184733629226685,
0.6947586536407471,
0.4578746259212494,
-0.16425465047359467,
0.8077003955841064,
-0.5935508608818054,
0.6884027719497681,
0.20638562738895416,
-1.0158244371414185,
0.27575260400772095,
-0.3319203853607178,
-0.01269551832228899,
0.08346644788980484,
0.6911588907241821,
-0.6863216161727905,
-0.3483413755893707,
-0.3715765178203583,
-0.4652073383331299,
0.5867146849632263,
0.023853376507759094,
-0.0011350312270224094,
-0.07128206640481949,
0.4224952757358551,
0.007677428890019655,
-0.1419634371995926,
-0.45900681614875793,
-0.08732949942350388,
-0.138349711894989,
-0.22381681203842163,
-0.01504801120609045,
0.11912600696086884,
-0.3941546082496643,
-0.28493213653564453,
0.5595701336860657,
-0.17992548644542694,
0.4297162592411041,
-0.012906341813504696,
-0.19480431079864502,
-0.2308352291584015,
0.1600591540336609,
0.7539676427841187,
0.871469259262085,
0.15806423127651215,
0.14146439731121063,
0.05476432666182518,
-0.15764255821704865,
0.26088249683380127,
-0.09096673130989075,
0.13791659474372864,
-0.21187736093997955,
0.7978873252868652,
0.6105493307113647,
0.17371907830238342,
-0.7142684459686279,
0.431864470243454,
-0.0682016909122467,
-0.08865179121494293,
0.002349184127524495,
0.1437983214855194,
0.5097259283065796,
0.3637206554412842,
0.016479168087244034,
-0.16897077858448029,
0.06312978267669678,
-1.0507291555404663,
-0.15977005660533905,
0.7121412754058838,
-0.014572967775166035,
-0.5439003109931946,
0.4552474319934845,
0.1820322424173355,
-0.4612961709499359,
0.7519667744636536,
0.002907045651227236,
-0.6947874426841736,
0.7538845539093018,
0.7938447594642639,
0.5921061635017395,
-0.14672508835792542,
0.143238365650177,
0.11607880145311356,
0.26649290323257446,
-0.14126582443714142,
0.3796474039554596,
0.1857706904411316,
-1.2866333723068237,
-0.6293186545372009,
-0.47796881198883057,
-0.25728026032447815,
0.09332337230443954,
-0.7568107843399048,
0.13479387760162354,
-0.21548040211200714,
-0.3142874538898468,
0.5842552781105042,
-0.18670569360256195,
-0.8538722395896912,
0.5635592937469482,
0.35869327187538147,
0.8217365741729736,
-1.0481505393981934,
0.8805860877037048,
1.1899311542510986,
-0.335197776556015,
-1.0050508975982666,
0.11056066304445267,
0.05432293191552162,
-1.3077903985977173,
1.132435917854309,
-0.14951401948928833,
-0.13351328670978546,
-0.44795048236846924,
-0.3496270179748535,
-0.8763773441314697,
0.9908662438392639,
0.3420480489730835,
-0.5592644810676575,
-0.17460069060325623,
0.34069082140922546,
0.734869122505188,
-0.8017861843109131,
0.19887559115886688,
0.9397689700126648,
0.5574437379837036,
-0.2029111087322235,
-1.2162646055221558,
0.34892451763153076,
-0.1068631261587143,
0.2006986439228058,
0.071418896317482,
-0.6061577796936035,
0.9556220173835754,
-0.3183841109275818,
-0.11085209995508194,
-0.065531425178051,
0.6067277193069458,
0.5706202387809753,
0.29554277658462524,
0.7387985587120056,
0.42183855175971985,
0.8943371772766113,
-0.025273796170949936,
1.1272584199905396,
-0.19757385551929474,
0.22210562229156494,
1.0076639652252197,
-0.6596811413764954,
0.5394175052642822,
0.4559718072414398,
-0.20852351188659668,
0.8275446891784668,
0.49598827958106995,
0.10134696215391159,
0.36370351910591125,
0.5216189026832581,
0.08283012360334396,
-0.5575709342956543,
-0.18530681729316711,
-0.10084233433008194,
0.6506276726722717,
0.4907599091529846,
-0.32338234782218933,
0.07381701469421387,
-0.20636826753616333,
-0.026150064542889595,
0.12331977486610413,
-0.4227618873119354,
0.7081881761550903,
0.277127742767334,
-0.980487585067749,
0.7433812022209167,
-0.09912177175283432,
0.39391961693763733,
-0.3677731454372406,
-0.15280131995677948,
0.1388547569513321,
0.16078096628189087,
-0.26867568492889404,
-0.9758971929550171,
0.21135738492012024,
-0.21618333458900452,
-0.3090156316757202,
-0.17914584279060364,
0.4975056052207947,
-0.4960050582885742,
-0.1558445692062378,
0.553205668926239,
0.46003249287605286,
0.34090152382850647,
0.35886985063552856,
-0.9904648065567017,
0.17163494229316711,
-0.0639941617846489,
-0.007976778782904148,
0.44034069776535034,
0.7185498476028442,
-0.6557055711746216,
0.8222556114196777,
0.4949108958244324,
0.3356025516986847,
0.014990972355008125,
0.03370172157883644,
0.5496221780776978,
-0.7785847187042236,
-0.2850116789340973,
-0.8291758894920349,
0.31039896607398987,
0.06290076673030853,
-0.4100510776042938,
0.5302232503890991,
0.36223864555358887,
1.0253913402557373,
-0.09726332128047943,
0.7920441627502441,
0.20063315331935883,
0.4045526087284088,
-0.5717268586158752,
0.4012316167354584,
-0.6055741310119629,
0.11061862111091614,
-0.21691332757472992,
-0.7370182275772095,
-0.02591228298842907,
0.8576995134353638,
-0.5915108323097229,
0.12543155252933502,
0.9177883267402649,
0.7070003747940063,
-0.37943539023399353,
0.19688571989536285,
0.3078469932079315,
0.19678981602191925,
0.020464187487959862,
0.4804302752017975,
1.2081084251403809,
0.11629526317119598,
0.2477959394454956,
0.050185538828372955,
-0.13910061120986938,
-0.1906876564025879,
-0.809229850769043,
-1.0436371564865112,
-0.45768794417381287,
-0.5903893709182739,
-0.45208027958869934,
0.043476004153490067,
0.9186816215515137,
0.8958736658096313,
-0.8553740382194519,
-0.42165204882621765,
0.3489953279495239,
0.050880447030067444,
-0.4555127024650574,
-0.21478836238384247,
0.35974791646003723,
-0.03215321898460388,
-0.6392955780029297,
0.051295846700668335,
0.12885117530822754,
-0.017906464636325836,
-0.29861459136009216,
-0.20799508690834045,
-0.3334571421146393,
0.553885281085968,
0.6097674369812012,
0.28098636865615845,
-1.128497838973999,
-0.3944200873374939,
-0.05343466252088547,
-0.34811654686927795,
0.026194166392087936,
1.1348884105682373,
-0.6057912111282349,
0.2353615164756775,
0.33280032873153687,
0.7155373096466064,
0.28858882188796997,
0.06887385249137878,
0.7225809097290039,
-0.28022685647010803,
-0.09663078188896179,
0.3379667103290558,
0.5901429653167725,
0.4289402663707733,
-0.30171817541122437,
0.5694494843482971,
0.08107685297727585,
-0.6475732922554016,
-0.7489334344863892,
0.2851225733757019,
-1.2023122310638428,
-0.4546729028224945,
1.1156268119812012,
-0.31130486726760864,
-0.2729972004890442,
-0.3307671546936035,
-0.30624067783355713,
0.33056214451789856,
-0.2411540150642395,
0.881329357624054,
0.9183939099311829,
-0.4458594024181366,
0.16187693178653717,
-0.587825357913971,
0.37203389406204224,
0.6348075270652771,
-0.7580165863037109,
-0.024951312690973282,
0.14514406025409698,
0.5976768136024475,
0.2608111798763275,
0.685383677482605,
0.011610033921897411,
0.28767988085746765,
-0.4024078845977783,
0.18430688977241516,
0.31459468603134155,
0.09183792769908905,
-0.18367400765419006,
-0.33956238627433777,
0.018598129972815514,
-0.13384994864463806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14862v1
|
Bitune: Bidirectional Instruction-Tuning
| 2024-05-23T17:59:22 | 2024-05-23T17:59:22 |
Dawid J. Kopiczko, Tijmen Blankevoort, Yuki M. Asano
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Bitune, a method that improves instruction-tuning of pretrained
decoder-only large language models, leading to consistent gains on downstream
tasks. Bitune applies both causal and bidirectional attention to the prompt, to
obtain a better representation of the query or instruction. We realize this by
introducing two sets of parameters, for which we apply parameter-efficient
finetuning techniques. These causal and bidirectional features are then
combined into a weighted average with trainable coefficients, which is
subsequently used to generate new tokens. We demonstrate significant
improvements in zero-shot performance on commonsense reasoning, arithmetic, and
language understanding tasks, while extensive ablation studies validate the
role of each component and demonstrate the method's agnosticism to different
PEFT techniques.
|
[
-0.23832635581493378,
-0.8961560726165771,
0.3711537718772888,
0.32117998600006104,
-0.42311331629753113,
-0.3506268262863159,
-0.4056567847728729,
-0.1608884036540985,
0.13132122159004211,
0.5848841667175293,
-0.5801587700843811,
-0.22737888991832733,
-0.4666423797607422,
0.03847283497452736,
-0.26075485348701477,
1.0119621753692627,
0.2893473207950592,
-0.016757499426603317,
0.0025327191688120365,
-0.04450777545571327,
-0.8038825988769531,
-0.16675424575805664,
-0.9278731346130371,
-0.21429193019866943,
0.734335720539093,
0.8541087508201599,
0.7548378109931946,
0.7522139549255371,
0.5041012167930603,
0.24499593675136566,
0.12908144295215607,
0.018351741135120392,
-0.6477221250534058,
0.06314241141080856,
-0.46526509523391724,
-0.7036962509155273,
-0.41468191146850586,
0.0706763043999672,
0.6593142151832581,
0.9558968544006348,
-0.1194995865225792,
0.06446269154548645,
-0.07506314665079117,
0.7966855764389038,
-0.7784208655357361,
-0.14755992591381073,
-0.5116103887557983,
-0.215189129114151,
-0.22584933042526245,
-0.5550225973129272,
-0.44430965185165405,
-0.4072147011756897,
-0.0165465846657753,
-0.6591010689735413,
0.47873684763908386,
0.13939136266708374,
0.7945757508277893,
0.4931252896785736,
-0.42496493458747864,
0.07179848104715347,
-0.6287295818328857,
1.071507453918457,
-0.5765002369880676,
0.5526062250137329,
0.4854878783226013,
0.07585648447275162,
-0.007213180419057608,
-0.45686545968055725,
-0.26451408863067627,
-0.0007848201203159988,
-0.10722676664590836,
0.10491827130317688,
-0.0390339121222496,
0.5408959984779358,
0.3847922086715698,
0.44648608565330505,
-0.5397061705589294,
0.2381332367658615,
-0.4632003605365753,
-0.14548462629318237,
0.743278980255127,
-0.07488928735256195,
0.048678793013095856,
0.0014638202264904976,
-0.2380927950143814,
-0.2305300086736679,
-1.0438330173492432,
-0.18644405901432037,
0.44844576716423035,
0.21163420379161835,
-0.035462718456983566,
0.4285370707511902,
-0.29883816838264465,
1.0884648561477661,
0.45555374026298523,
0.09198727458715439,
0.01807989738881588,
-0.186112180352211,
-0.4096702039241791,
0.6898372769355774,
0.577046275138855,
0.359281450510025,
0.11204086989164352,
-0.2736070454120636,
-0.039120547473430634,
-0.061228469014167786,
0.27739405632019043,
-1.126604437828064,
-0.5332038998603821,
0.27005916833877563,
-0.28552117943763733,
-0.5098487138748169,
-0.23175787925720215,
-0.44747182726860046,
-0.1167626827955246,
-0.6547768712043762,
0.6253733038902283,
-0.6017630696296692,
-0.19148196280002594,
0.17698326706886292,
-0.2414834350347519,
0.4353879392147064,
0.4508882164955139,
-1.023786187171936,
-0.07715599238872528,
0.9774543046951294,
0.6605919003486633,
0.1677292138338089,
-0.43043598532676697,
-1.1099900007247925,
0.12214791029691696,
-0.6344172358512878,
0.817470908164978,
-0.7569449543952942,
-0.07748078554868698,
-0.29682278633117676,
0.06348638981580734,
-0.20751020312309265,
-0.43655550479888916,
0.27588826417922974,
-0.6388201117515564,
0.19999951124191284,
-0.45374441146850586,
-0.473262220621109,
-0.39927205443382263,
0.21419772505760193,
-0.4679466784000397,
0.8552525639533997,
0.19531789422035217,
-0.7437311410903931,
0.28185155987739563,
-0.7373139262199402,
-0.8113685250282288,
0.13905753195285797,
-0.05512530729174614,
-0.11626770347356796,
0.58427894115448,
0.10405829548835754,
0.4043765962123871,
-0.3938668370246887,
0.4108085334300995,
-0.07341911643743515,
-0.6804736256599426,
0.019380493089556694,
-0.7540225982666016,
0.8545189499855042,
0.09667941182851791,
-0.44629567861557007,
0.32000505924224854,
-0.6691237092018127,
-0.049581944942474365,
-0.07861042767763138,
-0.10936003923416138,
-0.5760758519172668,
0.009939052164554596,
-0.26734694838523865,
-0.06346788257360458,
0.27879828214645386,
-0.5636276602745056,
0.30078452825546265,
-0.7996718287467957,
0.3877941370010376,
0.7463173270225525,
0.09577454626560211,
0.42344799637794495,
-0.24227973818778992,
0.3277536928653717,
0.21700391173362732,
0.09251325577497482,
-0.427746057510376,
-0.1791699379682541,
-0.981375515460968,
-0.08980152755975723,
0.5859593749046326,
0.5607037544250488,
-1.0428097248077393,
0.3447154760360718,
-0.12323901802301407,
-0.2076610028743744,
-0.7436383962631226,
0.14252594113349915,
0.46099603176116943,
0.524312436580658,
0.2696869671344757,
-0.20122872292995453,
-0.27648627758026123,
-0.8400833606719971,
-0.1277652084827423,
0.005773742217570543,
-0.07501108944416046,
0.2541009783744812,
0.04944548010826111,
0.11535052210092545,
0.40245863795280457,
-0.5017569065093994,
0.2733263671398163,
-0.14854080975055695,
0.5342631340026855,
0.2937350571155548,
0.5632646083831787,
0.3317528963088989,
-0.7172319889068604,
-0.46776193380355835,
0.003341593546792865,
-0.4065926969051361,
-0.17799659073352814,
-0.3634694814682007,
-0.5266873836517334,
0.17857274413108826,
0.6698969006538391,
-0.27647915482521057,
0.14947590231895447,
0.3994225859642029,
-0.5784284472465515,
0.5414605736732483,
-0.27655908465385437,
0.40696319937705994,
-1.0190443992614746,
0.024166980758309364,
-0.12552373111248016,
-0.3892275393009186,
-0.5695651173591614,
0.19635190069675446,
0.2957090437412262,
-0.10090716183185577,
-0.51325523853302,
0.19283930957317352,
-0.4254932403564453,
0.10250118374824524,
-0.4940773546695709,
0.07699575275182724,
0.0397302508354187,
0.5190278887748718,
0.21687544882297516,
1.0562574863433838,
0.7004324793815613,
-0.7033830285072327,
0.6207355260848999,
-0.053553685545921326,
-0.06341928243637085,
0.8760755062103271,
-1.0231702327728271,
0.22839327156543732,
-0.2698709964752197,
-0.48414862155914307,
-0.899761438369751,
-0.10367711633443832,
0.13552872836589813,
-0.2669445872306824,
0.8024314045906067,
-0.28455737233161926,
-0.37442097067832947,
-0.10427793860435486,
-0.4951315224170685,
0.40077120065689087,
0.36341217160224915,
-0.4716207981109619,
0.2478751689195633,
-0.18789179623126984,
-0.26043233275413513,
-0.3632230758666992,
-0.3372075855731964,
-0.13762037456035614,
-0.10868161916732788,
-0.35328927636146545,
0.34787923097610474,
0.03906577080488205,
0.06170591711997986,
-0.14427511394023895,
0.03163669630885124,
0.15457171201705933,
0.19016598165035248,
0.065311498939991,
0.38278016448020935,
-0.5435247421264648,
0.30510929226875305,
0.5091434717178345,
-0.39477968215942383,
-0.10147945582866669,
-0.43462109565734863,
0.5126054883003235,
-0.06662498414516449,
-0.2304079383611679,
-0.31584668159484863,
0.300108402967453,
0.4194192588329315,
-0.4587666094303131,
0.6981991529464722,
0.6808992028236389,
0.057489946484565735,
0.14869146049022675,
-0.6008120775222778,
-0.45478352904319763,
-0.5156348347663879,
0.26800549030303955,
-0.2091335952281952,
-0.8907636404037476,
-0.1709652990102768,
-0.23947757482528687,
0.3500487804412842,
0.20902979373931885,
0.32627880573272705,
-0.18247653543949127,
1.0290342569351196,
0.8726510405540466,
-0.17436957359313965,
0.7287694215774536,
-0.31412273645401,
0.2430906742811203,
-0.9815059304237366,
0.20992107689380646,
-0.5288962721824646,
-0.6335321068763733,
-0.6614829897880554,
-0.3705902695655823,
0.360449880361557,
0.4530390799045563,
-0.5253433585166931,
0.42699339985847473,
-0.6039511561393738,
0.6785057783126831,
0.9608162045478821,
0.17992690205574036,
0.022065741941332817,
-0.06713979691267014,
0.21504215896129608,
0.1400359570980072,
-0.9283550977706909,
-0.16314435005187988,
1.112630009651184,
-0.09552152454853058,
0.7405323386192322,
0.03405189514160156,
0.7788509130477905,
0.057442259043455124,
0.18245410919189453,
-0.8513227105140686,
0.5117936134338379,
-0.1807066947221756,
-0.668515682220459,
-0.46397972106933594,
-0.616887092590332,
-0.9742307662963867,
0.15222322940826416,
-0.12941864132881165,
-0.7387266755104065,
0.26832398772239685,
0.4330720007419586,
-0.6150871515274048,
-0.04649493470788002,
-0.8604044914245605,
1.2162147760391235,
-0.41749805212020874,
-0.8620907068252563,
-0.5003137588500977,
-0.6473322510719299,
0.12881255149841309,
0.2550845742225647,
-0.3102206885814667,
-0.07249350845813751,
0.030907772481441498,
0.811943531036377,
-0.18939614295959473,
0.80963134765625,
-0.24158741533756256,
0.062182795256376266,
0.09498006105422974,
0.25232240557670593,
0.4149816930294037,
-0.07144565880298615,
-0.09668631106615067,
0.11252908408641815,
0.21779094636440277,
-0.6665059328079224,
-0.565027117729187,
0.8061962723731995,
-0.782203733921051,
-0.6890937685966492,
-0.22788004577159882,
-0.6165385842323303,
-0.16204524040222168,
0.40222641825675964,
0.25436273217201233,
0.7417044639587402,
-0.006290148012340069,
0.30632463097572327,
1.052504539489746,
-0.21299973130226135,
0.4541977643966675,
0.7023456692695618,
0.10468543320894241,
-0.2756497263908386,
1.2201473712921143,
-0.12988515198230743,
0.2658337354660034,
0.728937566280365,
0.24376800656318665,
-0.14115680754184723,
-0.3441230058670044,
-0.6861899495124817,
0.5029165148735046,
-0.237955242395401,
-0.4306630492210388,
-0.2628926932811737,
0.005965708289295435,
-0.27028781175613403,
-0.36068278551101685,
-0.4568230211734772,
-0.4967968165874481,
-0.3715783655643463,
0.0855255052447319,
0.40403619408607483,
0.2947036623954773,
0.009757076390087605,
0.5473060011863708,
-0.9128563404083252,
0.2823559641838074,
0.3858541250228882,
0.38518014550209045,
-0.1175198033452034,
-0.620769202709198,
-0.28973835706710815,
0.20699888467788696,
-0.48394352197647095,
-0.9344561696052551,
0.036332715302705765,
0.3595118522644043,
0.24372339248657227,
0.818959653377533,
0.190109521150589,
0.7403591275215149,
-0.5238144397735596,
0.6151722073554993,
0.2913901209831238,
-0.8833602070808411,
0.9503645896911621,
-0.19689008593559265,
0.3694915175437927,
0.6738913655281067,
0.5756312012672424,
-0.5066089034080505,
-0.12998853623867035,
-0.5578522086143494,
-0.5692473649978638,
1.118987798690796,
0.0633234903216362,
0.16908706724643707,
-0.028807589784264565,
0.287309855222702,
-0.0250362828373909,
0.40424472093582153,
-0.12328406423330307,
-0.19759687781333923,
-0.17037354409694672,
-0.4046086072921753,
-0.2921375632286072,
-0.47298896312713623,
-0.08542182296514511,
-0.4556407332420349,
0.9083387851715088,
-0.20652438700199127,
0.29084911942481995,
0.039416614919900894,
-0.18271329998970032,
-0.31766584515571594,
0.33297762274742126,
0.5061975121498108,
0.6718790531158447,
-0.12731346487998962,
0.18339961767196655,
-0.08911547809839249,
-0.4304196536540985,
0.055158380419015884,
0.4002022445201874,
-0.4438837468624115,
-0.1905149668455124,
0.354430615901947,
1.0752061605453491,
0.5738710761070251,
-0.48489299416542053,
0.539203941822052,
0.06092551723122597,
-0.13270631432533264,
0.31332889199256897,
0.39426618814468384,
-0.035645678639411926,
0.23360002040863037,
-0.19619643688201904,
-0.14184291660785675,
0.36555227637290955,
-0.5726732611656189,
-0.10808312147855759,
0.27878352999687195,
-0.49894043803215027,
-0.4203836917877197,
0.5451200604438782,
0.5014150738716125,
-0.24931785464286804,
1.0097260475158691,
-0.267179012298584,
-0.4322122037410736,
0.41145333647727966,
0.7621921300888062,
0.9139413237571716,
-0.4032963514328003,
0.3111266791820526,
0.2962237000465393,
0.4210764169692993,
0.21202069520950317,
0.43525391817092896,
-0.618864119052887,
-0.6388970017433167,
-0.7085211873054504,
-0.7587373852729797,
-0.3062325417995453,
-0.03585426136851311,
-0.7673851251602173,
0.2649424374103546,
-0.2637167274951935,
0.16711480915546417,
0.27615460753440857,
0.08269151300191879,
-0.49471962451934814,
-0.028350744396448135,
0.04847637936472893,
0.855713427066803,
-0.9045354723930359,
0.837685227394104,
1.0795918703079224,
-0.2744074761867523,
-0.8823989033699036,
-0.028037941083312035,
-0.37289655208587646,
-0.6579411625862122,
0.34800511598587036,
0.10433267056941986,
0.058980826288461685,
0.318914532661438,
-0.4712274968624115,
-0.6914159655570984,
0.8400337100028992,
0.4162020683288574,
-1.0406333208084106,
-0.049152933061122894,
-0.07304351031780243,
0.12055942416191101,
0.22750593721866608,
0.34419548511505127,
0.943264901638031,
0.2512790858745575,
0.37857335805892944,
-0.8099303841590881,
-0.07479386776685715,
-0.12357459962368011,
0.08020715415477753,
0.8444629907608032,
-0.7099420428276062,
0.6287044286727905,
-0.25705182552337646,
0.014737571589648724,
-0.39133912324905396,
0.6752755045890808,
0.018717529252171516,
0.4055713713169098,
0.37895092368125916,
0.5418270230293274,
0.7192463278770447,
-0.19062171876430511,
0.8800800442695618,
-0.6717391014099121,
0.15908998250961304,
1.1440273523330688,
-0.0577177070081234,
0.6707727313041687,
0.5032578110694885,
-0.18492358922958374,
0.2525988221168518,
0.4760904610157013,
0.341505765914917,
0.6927067041397095,
-0.33344247937202454,
-0.276200532913208,
-0.47410905361175537,
0.07203291356563568,
-0.1806880384683609,
0.36047670245170593,
0.38570407032966614,
-0.17658153176307678,
-0.2949345111846924,
0.21757638454437256,
0.1121571958065033,
-0.23627333343029022,
-0.6498587727546692,
0.9851536154747009,
0.03633761778473854,
-0.8584861755371094,
0.8622380495071411,
0.1999630182981491,
0.566016674041748,
-0.5676174163818359,
-0.31583911180496216,
-0.30102676153182983,
0.1406874805688858,
-0.08634233474731445,
-0.5333865880966187,
0.29037055373191833,
-0.05591513589024544,
-0.10011430084705353,
-0.04214940592646599,
0.7908005714416504,
-0.6040937900543213,
-0.567970335483551,
-0.26616159081459045,
-0.025800874456763268,
0.24626867473125458,
-0.35602492094039917,
-0.6516386866569519,
0.06624125689268112,
0.1581207662820816,
-0.06696121394634247,
0.0877736434340477,
0.6724621653556824,
0.06527777016162872,
0.17925381660461426,
0.45377853512763977,
0.14438892900943756,
-0.037806250154972076,
0.1830202043056488,
0.8217504620552063,
-0.8158937692642212,
-0.5138955116271973,
-0.7950186133384705,
0.2365482896566391,
-0.11130508035421371,
-0.21309730410575867,
0.7425152659416199,
0.5849785804748535,
0.8630200028419495,
0.13674776256084442,
0.4069760739803314,
-0.06797152757644653,
0.2873709797859192,
-0.6391461491584778,
0.4413456916809082,
-0.5178620219230652,
0.10142355412244797,
-0.08372438699007034,
-0.9586413502693176,
-0.11314921081066132,
0.6281102895736694,
-0.7694677114486694,
-0.013253720477223396,
0.5997441411018372,
0.9030320048332214,
-0.40990760922431946,
0.19882875680923462,
0.5264329314231873,
0.19682559370994568,
-0.016015222296118736,
0.722891628742218,
0.603091835975647,
-0.44058674573898315,
0.13960161805152893,
-0.5490971803665161,
-0.4720127582550049,
-0.5662040114402771,
-0.7880697846412659,
-0.9396821856498718,
-0.2505359649658203,
-0.48771238327026367,
0.07146986573934555,
0.31871575117111206,
0.9122880101203918,
0.8852684497833252,
-0.8759663701057434,
-0.10816700011491776,
-0.2807468771934509,
0.24187497794628143,
-0.3774544298648834,
-0.25076279044151306,
0.3611656427383423,
-0.6490942239761353,
-0.5724198818206787,
0.2521641254425049,
0.6036578416824341,
-0.23483490943908691,
-0.036009110510349274,
0.0415341779589653,
-0.049218982458114624,
0.2908686697483063,
0.9048996567726135,
0.1298801600933075,
-0.2876931428909302,
-0.1797628104686737,
-0.08326765894889832,
0.1706211268901825,
-0.025251159444451332,
0.9203758239746094,
-0.6368846893310547,
0.5145202279090881,
0.3989533483982086,
0.46789199113845825,
0.5227003693580627,
0.18071869015693665,
0.4795065224170685,
-0.8038547039031982,
0.4543589949607849,
0.28820866346359253,
0.0794941857457161,
0.2800540328025818,
-0.5199652314186096,
0.17062748968601227,
0.17225559055805206,
-0.543499767780304,
-0.6123244166374207,
0.16331550478935242,
-0.7600609064102173,
-0.2785828709602356,
0.8572186231613159,
0.04361860826611519,
-0.48081842064857483,
0.19030900299549103,
-0.30714651942253113,
0.19839195907115936,
-0.25850820541381836,
0.5429437160491943,
0.34876278042793274,
-0.13678331673145294,
-0.3173539936542511,
-0.361568421125412,
0.19488270580768585,
0.5505171418190002,
-0.6039741039276123,
0.1793026477098465,
0.7473194003105164,
0.29385504126548767,
-0.1417696624994278,
0.4897170066833496,
-0.0010570642771199346,
0.7598602771759033,
0.04735099896788597,
-0.03838469460606575,
-0.18559929728507996,
-0.8293291330337524,
-0.37042754888534546,
-0.20166189968585968,
0.39453190565109253,
-0.4490562081336975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14839v1
|
A Textbook Remedy for Domain Shifts: Knowledge Priors for Medical Image Analysis
| 2024-05-23T17:55:02 | 2024-05-23T17:55:02 |
Yue Yang, Mona Gandhi, Yufei Wang, Yifan Wu, Michael S. Yao, Chris Callison-Burch, James C. Gee, Mark Yatskar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
While deep networks have achieved broad success in analyzing natural images,
when applied to medical scans, they often fail in unexcepted situations. We
investigate this challenge and focus on model sensitivity to domain shifts,
such as data sampled from different hospitals or data confounded by demographic
variables such as sex, race, etc, in the context of chest X-rays and skin
lesion images. A key finding we show empirically is that existing visual
backbones lack an appropriate prior from the architecture for reliable
generalization in these settings. Taking inspiration from medical training, we
propose giving deep networks a prior grounded in explicit medical knowledge
communicated in natural language. To this end, we introduce Knowledge-enhanced
Bottlenecks (KnoBo), a class of concept bottleneck models that incorporates
knowledge priors that constrain it to reason with clinically relevant factors
found in medical textbooks or PubMed. KnoBo uses retrieval-augmented language
models to design an appropriate concept space paired with an automatic training
procedure for recognizing the concept. We evaluate different resources of
knowledge and recognition architectures on a broad range of domain shifts
across 20 datasets. In our comprehensive evaluation with two imaging
modalities, KnoBo outperforms fine-tuned models on confounded datasets by 32.4%
on average. Finally, evaluations reveal that PubMed is a promising resource for
making medical models less sensitive to domain shift, outperforming other
resources on both diversity of information and final prediction performance.
|
[
-0.35776177048683167,
-0.3777313232421875,
0.48188674449920654,
-0.32053840160369873,
-0.223997563123703,
-0.20976632833480835,
-0.057251278311014175,
-0.5158290863037109,
-0.4377160370349884,
0.8190358281135559,
-0.5859194397926331,
-0.2955661714076996,
-0.8496756553649902,
-0.0365779735147953,
0.014371092431247234,
0.7912515997886658,
0.00424876157194376,
0.15729357302188873,
-0.507613480091095,
-0.21945911645889282,
-0.6045909523963928,
-0.2289690226316452,
-0.6089138984680176,
-0.5838770866394043,
0.12924017012119293,
0.0077032241970300674,
0.930739164352417,
0.4312180280685425,
1.0317206382751465,
0.226182222366333,
0.22699277102947235,
0.4708324074745178,
-0.27525192499160767,
0.0724104717373848,
-0.34898751974105835,
-0.5538386702537537,
-0.32837504148483276,
-0.3783317506313324,
0.32690104842185974,
1.0221493244171143,
0.12309233844280243,
-0.19163012504577637,
-0.4704979360103607,
1.068647861480713,
-0.5999150276184082,
0.026835693046450615,
-0.8924769759178162,
0.14496806263923645,
-0.15048615634441376,
-0.20472441613674164,
-0.07533276081085205,
-0.11845844984054565,
0.5823626518249512,
-0.9543979167938232,
0.6137359142303467,
-0.15241916477680206,
1.103440284729004,
0.8070070743560791,
-0.4293036460876465,
-0.2840591371059418,
-0.5298991203308105,
0.4407898783683777,
-0.518435001373291,
0.568880021572113,
0.3152112662792206,
0.3580661416053772,
-0.09152239561080933,
-0.9405560493469238,
-0.3060387670993805,
-0.020565807819366455,
0.006378443446010351,
-0.054319582879543304,
-0.3259701132774353,
-0.13323962688446045,
0.3100796639919281,
0.36435842514038086,
-0.4383653402328491,
0.13229022920131683,
-0.74407559633255,
-0.1395166516304016,
0.5740622282028198,
0.28893405199050903,
0.32558679580688477,
0.3988089859485626,
-0.36615410447120667,
-0.14599722623825073,
-1.0226924419403076,
-0.0994805172085762,
-0.265575110912323,
0.043414972722530365,
-0.05939873680472374,
0.28063493967056274,
0.041273098438978195,
0.891210675239563,
0.3995108902454376,
0.07527267187833786,
0.40453040599823,
-0.05365529656410217,
-0.46618178486824036,
-0.2762395441532135,
0.4239374101161957,
0.5815975069999695,
0.47401729226112366,
0.005736281163990498,
0.09788650274276733,
0.1374419629573822,
0.7660595178604126,
-0.7949612140655518,
-0.7201611995697021,
0.09876305609941483,
-0.4475380480289459,
-0.21902528405189514,
-0.24996277689933777,
-0.3604464530944824,
-0.7997926473617554,
-0.5205908417701721,
-0.04538876563310623,
-0.46497416496276855,
-0.34143462777137756,
0.4435219466686249,
-0.15237656235694885,
0.0006642477819696069,
0.287086546421051,
-0.4363643527030945,
0.28411757946014404,
0.45264577865600586,
0.7653296589851379,
-0.3088594675064087,
0.21261774003505707,
0.1754361391067505,
0.020018117502331734,
-0.552056610584259,
0.721557080745697,
-0.5955361723899841,
-0.5848057270050049,
0.017047684639692307,
0.17253965139389038,
-0.2815883159637451,
-0.9653822183609009,
0.4481222927570343,
-0.6149401068687439,
-0.10563910007476807,
-0.23223435878753662,
-0.6667296290397644,
0.14625270664691925,
-0.09212604910135269,
-0.6590257883071899,
0.4941945970058441,
0.10305418074131012,
-0.6009770631790161,
0.5550355911254883,
-0.6034059524536133,
-0.7248725295066833,
-0.12215493619441986,
-0.3035764694213867,
-0.7557182312011719,
0.3280504643917084,
0.5483397245407104,
0.5079240798950195,
-0.1538936346769333,
0.333137184381485,
-0.14597076177597046,
0.1147046685218811,
0.47443705797195435,
-0.02801286056637764,
0.7050246596336365,
0.3292005956172943,
-0.07232702523469925,
-0.28882455825805664,
-0.575458824634552,
0.04555147886276245,
0.2023904174566269,
0.1407410353422165,
-0.756801426410675,
-0.06694189459085464,
-0.32222625613212585,
0.23039039969444275,
-0.16754183173179626,
-0.14999885857105255,
0.45276638865470886,
-0.417827844619751,
0.3089725971221924,
0.4308701753616333,
0.1440306156873703,
0.4718751311302185,
-0.3518482446670532,
0.3603154420852661,
0.34293851256370544,
0.19346123933792114,
0.16030848026275635,
-0.7014135718345642,
-0.6392949223518372,
-0.16529099643230438,
0.057402972131967545,
0.2985401749610901,
-0.9650496244430542,
-0.05353303998708725,
-0.4754364490509033,
-0.1323409080505371,
-0.6010431051254272,
-0.04878271371126175,
0.3706654906272888,
0.8610424995422363,
0.3931922912597656,
-0.5909919142723083,
-0.4440026581287384,
-0.9004824757575989,
-0.2504615783691406,
0.20095814764499664,
-0.13198991119861603,
0.559555172920227,
0.3299712538719177,
-0.4560508728027344,
0.5045968890190125,
-0.892846941947937,
-0.2895609140396118,
0.4302622079849243,
0.23147176206111908,
0.21891610324382782,
0.653495728969574,
0.4347579777240753,
-1.1304396390914917,
-0.33392560482025146,
0.18008728325366974,
-0.6627333760261536,
-0.046380795538425446,
-0.27279284596443176,
-0.18460240960121155,
-0.05049322918057442,
0.6711620092391968,
-0.4967416822910309,
0.39716607332229614,
0.24726852774620056,
-0.0575198233127594,
0.36397093534469604,
-0.0012383158318698406,
0.008795041590929031,
-0.841156005859375,
0.02252027578651905,
0.23137526214122772,
-0.13672922551631927,
-0.781164824962616,
0.0830988734960556,
0.011206528171896935,
-0.0637577623128891,
-0.05377314239740372,
0.6107349991798401,
-0.6300202012062073,
0.15296603739261627,
-0.23712483048439026,
-0.38829633593559265,
0.13519105315208435,
0.13708673417568207,
0.523438036441803,
0.6437482237815857,
0.5269274115562439,
-0.8254600167274475,
-0.16078098118305206,
0.3216051757335663,
-0.21272467076778412,
1.0102636814117432,
-0.6323212385177612,
0.5468881726264954,
0.053391773253679276,
-0.11389898508787155,
-0.6298292279243469,
-0.043410323560237885,
0.13946497440338135,
-0.5507505536079407,
0.917221188545227,
-0.45607542991638184,
0.24654391407966614,
-0.6204357147216797,
0.11378345638513565,
0.5136067867279053,
0.41890162229537964,
-0.24196569621562958,
0.07700406759977341,
0.567367434501648,
-0.09843815863132477,
-0.6622553467750549,
-0.5495120286941528,
-0.01921853795647621,
-0.023320186883211136,
-0.3666123151779175,
0.43954965472221375,
-0.026666248217225075,
-0.2772909104824066,
0.1697062849998474,
-0.3123169541358948,
-0.7753545641899109,
-0.00326692801900208,
0.3564404845237732,
0.32779279351234436,
-0.3944726288318634,
0.5240793228149414,
-0.04465359449386597,
0.05756506696343422,
0.08613234013319016,
-0.7348800301551819,
-0.02584002912044525,
0.10045639425516129,
-0.15038736164569855,
0.06014735624194145,
0.029404031112790108,
0.4785632789134979,
-0.006630532909184694,
0.14459222555160522,
0.3924413323402405,
-0.56998211145401,
-0.04646256938576698,
-0.4508160650730133,
-0.0217574555426836,
-0.42779433727264404,
0.5062176585197449,
-0.4248873293399811,
-0.8720943331718445,
0.2480802983045578,
-0.4714564383029938,
-0.20678456127643585,
0.5253210663795471,
0.6828001141548157,
-0.27450889348983765,
0.44099587202072144,
0.6469870209693909,
-0.0008238179143518209,
0.18341246247291565,
-0.38560572266578674,
0.023548001423478127,
-0.9387133121490479,
-0.01855585351586342,
-0.29203322529792786,
-0.13427141308784485,
-0.4501793384552002,
-0.6445057988166809,
0.5518112182617188,
-0.2057591825723648,
-0.15832434594631195,
0.07184385508298874,
-0.7917203903198242,
0.34694960713386536,
0.3000653088092804,
0.3738178014755249,
0.1669672131538391,
0.125070258975029,
0.01781134493649006,
-0.27692586183547974,
-0.8763874173164368,
-0.015060214325785637,
1.5679270029067993,
0.27766698598861694,
0.7270700335502625,
-0.35086315870285034,
0.2311011403799057,
0.3791700005531311,
0.4469974935054779,
-0.594012975692749,
-0.11581281572580338,
-0.40730512142181396,
-0.8693543672561646,
-0.42513126134872437,
-0.3196616768836975,
-1.1837693452835083,
0.04281768947839737,
-0.1605837643146515,
-0.33780109882354736,
0.882455587387085,
0.3315870463848114,
-0.39537540078163147,
0.20012502372264862,
-0.4260818362236023,
0.6391580700874329,
-0.11896663904190063,
-0.45674657821655273,
0.011570851318538189,
-0.7453489303588867,
0.47019368410110474,
-0.03561622276902199,
0.31367236375808716,
-0.04444611072540283,
-0.11134997010231018,
0.252492755651474,
-0.5950081944465637,
1.0238041877746582,
-0.23448549211025238,
0.0646703839302063,
0.22800295054912567,
0.09314929693937302,
0.24726223945617676,
-0.04066804423928261,
0.28000760078430176,
0.4316912591457367,
-0.08208777010440826,
-0.27663519978523254,
-0.7193536162376404,
0.44692111015319824,
-0.758335530757904,
-0.41809552907943726,
-0.06329011172056198,
-0.6288419961929321,
-0.5382858514785767,
0.08363969624042511,
0.5772042274475098,
0.3422258198261261,
-0.04298348352313042,
-0.0036288578994572163,
0.9389830827713013,
-0.015065469779074192,
-0.23127681016921997,
0.47905927896499634,
0.38943833112716675,
-0.2255673110485077,
0.6897096037864685,
0.27023035287857056,
0.16462108492851257,
0.4057711660861969,
0.19459956884384155,
-0.18207383155822754,
-0.8944191336631775,
-0.4396086633205414,
-0.10079145431518555,
-0.5999653339385986,
-0.4824138879776001,
-0.4043087959289551,
-0.15773658454418182,
-0.37182480096817017,
-0.28037142753601074,
-0.4099213182926178,
-0.41093623638153076,
-0.13145077228546143,
0.1826588660478592,
0.2772033214569092,
0.3885190188884735,
-0.00017607287736609578,
0.269631028175354,
-0.5213712453842163,
0.4622083306312561,
0.23814810812473297,
0.3374171257019043,
-0.2730243504047394,
-0.5941300988197327,
-0.43544694781303406,
-0.11481225490570068,
-0.19193311035633087,
-0.5552963018417358,
0.41888025403022766,
0.3841513395309448,
0.5130548477172852,
0.5445085167884827,
0.09129684418439865,
0.5843204855918884,
-0.5048260688781738,
0.3504420518875122,
0.38431087136268616,
-0.5667247176170349,
0.41735637187957764,
-0.20233745872974396,
0.2944565713405609,
0.6420611143112183,
0.6852720975875854,
-0.23778463900089264,
-0.18210701644420624,
-0.6037895083427429,
-0.742238461971283,
-0.03311639651656151,
0.05811120942234993,
0.06046890839934349,
0.06616400182247162,
0.6505895256996155,
0.2649122178554535,
0.4397543668746948,
-0.3284158408641815,
-0.2796196937561035,
-0.23167087137699127,
-0.03121035359799862,
0.1559842973947525,
0.11936382949352264,
-0.37891966104507446,
-0.5097397565841675,
0.3777272403240204,
-0.33995023369789124,
0.36669865250587463,
0.6449757218360901,
-0.3275090754032135,
-0.07245197892189026,
-0.15004684031009674,
0.5530828833580017,
0.7244980335235596,
-0.10090749710798264,
0.21037018299102783,
-0.054908085614442825,
-0.7984299063682556,
0.03987180441617966,
0.0010179852833971381,
-0.04763993248343468,
0.13548435270786285,
0.5850223302841187,
0.7914630770683289,
0.20689712464809418,
-0.21272921562194824,
0.48133718967437744,
0.026116399094462395,
-0.20954078435897827,
0.029107093811035156,
-0.07432227581739426,
-0.11446478962898254,
0.1243470087647438,
0.2773844599723816,
0.5983749032020569,
0.5171695351600647,
-0.19208265841007233,
0.46450474858283997,
0.3581559956073761,
-0.5691511631011963,
-0.16995441913604736,
0.5292702317237854,
0.2514738440513611,
0.1710633635520935,
0.6638752818107605,
0.1512729972600937,
-0.24902398884296417,
0.8429438471794128,
0.2933691143989563,
0.7555308938026428,
-0.30214276909828186,
0.02745330147445202,
0.30123597383499146,
0.3628898859024048,
0.08084385842084885,
-0.044200483709573746,
0.05424362048506737,
-1.1550549268722534,
-0.26277658343315125,
0.04010371118783951,
-0.18296079337596893,
0.16283658146858215,
-0.6535131931304932,
-0.0005574407987296581,
-0.4152255058288574,
-0.7279850244522095,
0.3584994375705719,
-0.15678098797798157,
-1.204294204711914,
0.6450088024139404,
0.17264418303966522,
0.699817419052124,
-0.7323963642120361,
0.8598933219909668,
0.8342277407646179,
-0.20045118033885956,
-0.3930811583995819,
-0.05274806544184685,
-0.057290274649858475,
-1.1611087322235107,
0.668850302696228,
-0.3160124719142914,
0.11112921684980392,
-0.3088796138763428,
-0.668189287185669,
-0.6462683081626892,
0.7117998600006104,
0.23150859773159027,
-0.8257367014884949,
-0.03610146418213844,
0.05637924373149872,
0.5769259929656982,
-0.4898647665977478,
-0.04159365966916084,
0.5568694472312927,
0.17233549058437347,
0.13881804049015045,
-0.7635921835899353,
0.25747233629226685,
-0.23568160831928253,
0.027985475957393646,
0.06908684223890305,
-0.2112925946712494,
0.8228294849395752,
-0.6053838133811951,
-0.13872143626213074,
-0.22056981921195984,
0.08552911132574081,
-0.2379642128944397,
0.6469506025314331,
0.3488515317440033,
0.6634548902511597,
1.0821574926376343,
-0.1189383938908577,
1.478209137916565,
-0.26150473952293396,
0.13626554608345032,
1.16477632522583,
-0.32650601863861084,
0.3694097399711609,
0.4615526497364044,
-0.4036688804626465,
0.3796131908893585,
0.45761838555336,
-0.07604535669088364,
0.795852780342102,
0.2378850281238556,
0.0595962218940258,
-0.4222734868526459,
0.08710840344429016,
-0.7912813425064087,
0.06763111054897308,
0.6463133692741394,
-0.513493001461029,
0.10491526871919632,
0.04129794239997864,
-0.053562019020318985,
-0.14285220205783844,
-0.4669477641582489,
0.7618637084960938,
0.4582468569278717,
-0.3184216320514679,
0.9740567803382874,
-0.6097937822341919,
0.4094695448875427,
-0.5030864477157593,
0.005399753805249929,
-0.22462548315525055,
0.2731052339076996,
-0.18887712061405182,
-0.5658506155014038,
0.36908772587776184,
-0.6364966034889221,
-0.41971591114997864,
0.2906818091869354,
1.1760607957839966,
-0.04506866633892059,
-0.7330960035324097,
-0.15957553684711456,
0.6043215990066528,
0.07492061704397202,
-0.21200595796108246,
-0.8137296438217163,
-0.0451912060379982,
-0.08282813429832458,
0.07280901074409485,
0.28643280267715454,
0.6286060214042664,
-0.402904748916626,
0.5877575874328613,
0.5576656460762024,
0.17293483018875122,
-0.09499724954366684,
0.046865276992321014,
1.029001235961914,
-0.14014650881290436,
-0.06610875576734543,
-0.4562172591686249,
0.3455221652984619,
-0.31196099519729614,
-0.5557383894920349,
0.2833508849143982,
0.3347054719924927,
0.8289793133735657,
-0.5330999493598938,
0.9252873659133911,
0.3613804876804352,
0.18315277993679047,
-0.662746012210846,
0.6534059643745422,
-0.5346589088439941,
0.15812894701957703,
-0.1767120361328125,
-0.21177808940410614,
-0.5182717442512512,
0.5556727051734924,
-0.6937090158462524,
-0.20986180007457733,
0.6358509659767151,
0.6084573268890381,
-0.0017038678051903844,
-0.2986728250980377,
0.441334068775177,
0.19537004828453064,
-0.07933240383863449,
0.7530606985092163,
0.5004900693893433,
-0.31227394938468933,
-0.01378768589347601,
-0.09481468051671982,
-0.1398342102766037,
-0.28262150287628174,
-0.7554013133049011,
-0.970170259475708,
-0.5622135996818542,
-0.788388729095459,
-0.2695513665676117,
0.57070392370224,
0.34147369861602783,
1.297441005706787,
-0.8496403694152832,
0.19589397311210632,
-0.10724519938230515,
0.2651959955692291,
-0.38530153036117554,
-0.15940356254577637,
0.49640947580337524,
-0.50069260597229,
-0.33642667531967163,
0.17601151764392853,
0.12551194429397583,
0.028172221034765244,
0.151946559548378,
0.1560216248035431,
0.19074101746082306,
0.009324030950665474,
0.3567098379135132,
0.48245078325271606,
-0.3982353210449219,
-0.06841013580560684,
0.036799874156713486,
-0.05129772424697876,
0.29720339179039,
1.478171467781067,
-0.8216174840927124,
0.7362619042396545,
0.026196103543043137,
0.8261812925338745,
0.5505362153053284,
-0.18226200342178345,
0.8365890383720398,
-0.7581304311752319,
0.22500237822532654,
0.3288780152797699,
0.21922999620437622,
0.4686591327190399,
-0.8189698457717896,
0.712451696395874,
0.5028287172317505,
-0.40859514474868774,
-0.5743104219436646,
0.17935636639595032,
-0.6171575784683228,
-0.7535197734832764,
0.6882120966911316,
-0.2148212492465973,
-0.0971081331372261,
-0.3505995571613312,
0.025852082297205925,
0.022932512685656548,
-0.0590873658657074,
0.8222978711128235,
0.3819635808467865,
-0.24279773235321045,
-0.1392051726579666,
-0.6838719248771667,
0.8689091801643372,
0.33115655183792114,
-0.5814319252967834,
-0.18209797143936157,
0.45625725388526917,
0.45731714367866516,
0.22416949272155762,
0.683782696723938,
-0.31043264269828796,
0.4217514395713806,
0.027025582268834114,
0.19998788833618164,
-0.2654545307159424,
-0.2370016872882843,
-0.3388318121433258,
-0.025674238801002502,
-0.07047347724437714,
-0.27932628989219666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14838v1
|
From Explicit CoT to Implicit CoT: Learning to Internalize CoT Step by Step
| 2024-05-23T17:54:14 | 2024-05-23T17:54:14 |
Yuntian Deng, Yejin Choi, Stuart Shieber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
When leveraging language models for reasoning tasks, generating explicit
chain-of-thought (CoT) steps often proves essential for achieving high accuracy
in final outputs. In this paper, we investigate if models can be taught to
internalize these CoT steps. To this end, we propose a simple yet effective
method for internalizing CoT steps: starting with a model trained for explicit
CoT reasoning, we gradually remove the intermediate steps and finetune the
model. This process allows the model to internalize the intermediate reasoning
steps, thus simplifying the reasoning process while maintaining high
performance. Our approach enables a GPT-2 Small model to solve 9-by-9
multiplication with up to 99% accuracy, whereas standard training cannot solve
beyond 4-by-4 multiplication. Furthermore, our method proves effective on
larger language models, such as Mistral 7B, achieving over 50% accuracy on
GSM8K without producing any intermediate steps.
|
[
-0.2702612280845642,
-0.679506242275238,
0.9192798733711243,
0.0509965755045414,
-0.37646210193634033,
0.10139366239309311,
-0.5318977236747742,
-0.5289731621742249,
-0.7733196020126343,
0.43649691343307495,
-0.34970709681510925,
-0.36207640171051025,
-0.6770374774932861,
-0.11171157658100128,
-0.335511714220047,
0.9755567908287048,
-0.589558482170105,
0.2539854943752289,
0.17506706714630127,
0.16017061471939087,
-0.23525510728359222,
-0.6320841908454895,
-0.8786591291427612,
-0.4158860146999359,
0.3371284008026123,
0.4211136996746063,
0.512908399105072,
0.32614898681640625,
0.1083771362900734,
0.2497914433479309,
-0.3474483788013458,
0.5171647071838379,
-0.5898047089576721,
-0.11899644881486893,
-0.25342923402786255,
-0.612172544002533,
-0.3440498411655426,
-0.0632837638258934,
0.5642831921577454,
0.5033043026924133,
0.019110089167952538,
0.073580801486969,
0.1526244431734085,
0.6273834705352783,
-0.5279165506362915,
0.4361329674720764,
-0.7434030175209045,
-0.21185941994190216,
0.37374231219291687,
0.08186805993318558,
-0.7614080309867859,
-0.418570876121521,
-0.06649702787399292,
-0.39653968811035156,
0.3270079791545868,
-0.2570344805717468,
0.43300747871398926,
0.013961562886834145,
-0.6044614315032959,
-0.5773204565048218,
-1.0177656412124634,
0.3974795937538147,
-0.559630811214447,
0.33274519443511963,
0.43652069568634033,
0.23009181022644043,
-0.10132011771202087,
-0.7944372296333313,
-0.487130731344223,
-0.595912754535675,
-0.25800180435180664,
-0.23322060704231262,
0.2001221477985382,
0.3205043077468872,
0.40361639857292175,
0.2171734869480133,
-0.23383061587810516,
-0.4248475432395935,
-0.6501548886299133,
0.2267034351825714,
0.6229634284973145,
-0.13581319153308868,
0.28827863931655884,
0.3180612623691559,
-0.42098209261894226,
-0.021292151883244514,
-0.9524049162864685,
0.071696937084198,
0.18330173194408417,
0.46181756258010864,
-0.14448116719722748,
0.6493573784828186,
-0.11486531049013138,
0.359113872051239,
0.5619896054267883,
0.061142098158597946,
-0.14750471711158752,
-0.39325276017189026,
-0.2286568284034729,
0.16587506234645844,
0.2893396317958832,
-0.43881985545158386,
0.34664198756217957,
-0.29109880328178406,
-0.5421523451805115,
0.11331718415021896,
0.5466582179069519,
-0.6260331869125366,
-0.2621265947818756,
0.26201948523521423,
0.00046165785170160234,
-0.16309869289398193,
-0.01399068720638752,
-0.13200989365577698,
-0.16255034506320953,
-0.731711208820343,
0.6190934777259827,
-0.5509175062179565,
-0.20695531368255615,
-0.0511845126748085,
0.2651037573814392,
0.29814934730529785,
0.5305317640304565,
-0.7749847769737244,
0.7511370182037354,
0.7902114987373352,
0.7973048090934753,
0.27984610199928284,
-0.07550603151321411,
-0.6023935675621033,
0.3354964554309845,
-0.790691077709198,
0.6628322005271912,
-0.544342577457428,
-0.40853047370910645,
-0.23636825382709503,
-0.14263196289539337,
-0.1418384313583374,
-0.1031043604016304,
0.3931364417076111,
-0.2439020425081253,
-0.04338008910417557,
-0.3321981132030487,
-0.5915042161941528,
-0.12641166150569916,
0.27334797382354736,
-0.2991081178188324,
1.0585721731185913,
0.11106418818235397,
-0.37390682101249695,
0.07149557024240494,
-0.6220241189002991,
-0.06072467938065529,
-0.36454522609710693,
-0.2978378236293793,
-0.040107086300849915,
0.45053261518478394,
0.4732975959777832,
0.27726948261260986,
-0.10377861559391022,
0.05883466824889183,
-0.03404134884476662,
-0.638276219367981,
-0.16416367888450623,
-0.21132101118564606,
0.6380093097686768,
0.039032500237226486,
-0.7500704526901245,
0.19807089865207672,
-0.4241834282875061,
0.2262895554304123,
0.03111366741359234,
0.06286267191171646,
-0.18441267311573029,
-0.32656624913215637,
-0.5425041913986206,
0.4232683777809143,
-0.02623004838824272,
-0.3430958688259125,
0.4637954533100128,
-0.5575570464134216,
-0.014593870379030704,
0.9946246147155762,
-0.09778329730033875,
0.8441200256347656,
0.00036679295590147376,
0.29050323367118835,
0.11923809349536896,
0.2692708373069763,
0.046920690685510635,
-0.6205407977104187,
-0.9089624285697937,
-0.19412222504615784,
0.24821965396404266,
0.10721007734537125,
-0.7827226519584656,
-0.013770448043942451,
0.01279291883111,
-0.5522679686546326,
-0.3676513731479645,
0.2951907515525818,
0.7329273819923401,
0.40303871035575867,
0.4285750389099121,
-0.09210205078125,
-0.20045404136180878,
-0.49746033549308777,
-0.23745456337928772,
-0.13369040191173553,
0.15798452496528625,
-0.031151827424764633,
0.4836962819099426,
-0.13675980269908905,
0.4693225920200348,
-0.4362037181854248,
-0.10280575603246689,
-0.3760572075843811,
0.5571308732032776,
0.014918196015059948,
0.691365122795105,
0.2132255882024765,
-0.6943621039390564,
-0.627552330493927,
0.4265221655368805,
-0.7310409545898438,
0.1211545318365097,
-0.07732833176851273,
-0.43172526359558105,
0.3345224857330322,
0.5522075295448303,
-0.6135918498039246,
0.7662227153778076,
0.12732136249542236,
-0.4258994162082672,
0.5830594897270203,
-0.48256081342697144,
0.03834476321935654,
-0.6978992223739624,
-0.16405266523361206,
-0.053126078099012375,
-0.3731664717197418,
-0.6744188070297241,
0.44821417331695557,
0.3045302629470825,
0.010637238621711731,
-0.4695371687412262,
0.6176373958587646,
-0.9262962937355042,
-0.011631237342953682,
-0.4177705645561218,
-0.05555431544780731,
-0.14051227271556854,
0.7257704734802246,
0.1504826545715332,
0.9315569400787354,
0.2754279375076294,
-0.6885400414466858,
0.032468847930431366,
0.038661882281303406,
-0.1231137067079544,
-0.054940082132816315,
-0.6633565425872803,
0.58299720287323,
-0.3680780827999115,
0.5603874921798706,
-0.885863184928894,
0.1379029005765915,
0.23245468735694885,
-0.24246415495872498,
0.4044496417045593,
-0.5950505137443542,
-0.45193907618522644,
-0.12865401804447174,
-0.17967289686203003,
0.568526029586792,
0.6783610582351685,
-0.8036267161369324,
0.837854266166687,
0.020503824576735497,
-0.10130684077739716,
-0.5620225071907043,
-0.2789745330810547,
-0.317672997713089,
0.22424089908599854,
-0.38310956954956055,
0.2766738831996918,
0.047054506838321686,
-0.17273733019828796,
-0.050632886588573456,
-0.30302688479423523,
-0.12464787811040878,
-0.27492934465408325,
0.17743821442127228,
0.19370828568935394,
-0.19099025428295135,
0.20760013163089752,
0.13851748406887054,
-0.1891903579235077,
0.0579889677464962,
-0.5409602522850037,
0.6196045875549316,
-0.5464276075363159,
-0.32567816972732544,
-0.21147006750106812,
0.3773288428783417,
0.31894651055336,
-0.18564730882644653,
0.7442233562469482,
0.6773765683174133,
-0.621170163154602,
-0.5209441184997559,
-0.38324669003486633,
-0.1259177178144455,
-0.4577158987522125,
0.03454219922423363,
-0.8031148910522461,
-0.3236539959907532,
0.4519973695278168,
-0.2493126392364502,
0.04099857062101364,
0.3153366446495056,
0.5636978149414062,
0.03888929262757301,
1.471498727798462,
0.8831027150154114,
0.44546717405319214,
0.3198172152042389,
-0.7697148323059082,
0.48336321115493774,
-1.1683732271194458,
-0.3210900127887726,
-0.381179541349411,
0.10417066514492035,
-0.4737943112850189,
-0.7747218012809753,
0.4101852774620056,
0.41123199462890625,
-0.5739029049873352,
0.35851404070854187,
-0.45541056990623474,
0.7901593446731567,
0.42493048310279846,
0.5993276238441467,
0.2936263382434845,
-0.1728747934103012,
-0.43391332030296326,
0.4839678406715393,
-0.6076822876930237,
-0.6454911828041077,
1.202879786491394,
0.25760939717292786,
0.8006897568702698,
0.0748455598950386,
0.8003085255622864,
-0.008392902091145515,
0.6175715327262878,
-0.4665577709674835,
0.3900604248046875,
-0.15931810438632965,
-0.2971601188182831,
-0.26684659719467163,
-0.4388022720813751,
-0.3367566764354706,
0.37008577585220337,
0.06985586136579514,
-0.850035548210144,
0.27071377635002136,
0.23328964412212372,
-0.07220287621021271,
0.4509873390197754,
-1.072754979133606,
0.5006111860275269,
-0.21405896544456482,
-0.6043810248374939,
-0.3300977647304535,
-0.4411810636520386,
0.7199970483779907,
0.12670989334583282,
0.09100693464279175,
-0.04412071406841278,
-0.05711578205227852,
0.11600953340530396,
-0.7368635535240173,
0.9812115430831909,
-0.18853294849395752,
-0.39112383127212524,
0.5494781136512756,
0.2872399389743805,
0.983525276184082,
0.07200556993484497,
0.06086680293083191,
-0.18248558044433594,
-0.09290281683206558,
-0.5996445417404175,
-0.9598867893218994,
0.7153111696243286,
-0.7982394695281982,
-0.6023382544517517,
-0.49625787138938904,
-0.3086882531642914,
-0.4173412322998047,
-0.06966683268547058,
0.12007307261228561,
0.624075710773468,
0.045044202357530594,
-0.3334802985191345,
0.6896119713783264,
0.36770278215408325,
0.23207028210163116,
0.11572778970003128,
-0.2998654842376709,
-0.38524332642555237,
0.5908136367797852,
0.09422162920236588,
0.5869147181510925,
0.11655115336179733,
0.2921544015407562,
-0.6293157935142517,
-0.3193471431732178,
-0.38418683409690857,
0.300386518239975,
-1.0885636806488037,
0.010119984857738018,
-0.6364563703536987,
-0.44300180673599243,
-0.35429224371910095,
-0.32574328780174255,
-0.5974155068397522,
-0.4841536283493042,
0.14438150823116302,
-0.2048892080783844,
0.05598454922437668,
1.116674780845642,
0.07683984190225601,
0.3602714240550995,
-0.4484463036060333,
0.6831008195877075,
0.4520028531551361,
0.45627227425575256,
0.22344011068344116,
-0.4373960793018341,
-0.18794947862625122,
0.4636751413345337,
-0.31742435693740845,
-0.6550227999687195,
0.17997346818447113,
0.020024636760354042,
0.5110809803009033,
0.10614216327667236,
-0.012512542307376862,
1.0805606842041016,
-0.5553873181343079,
0.6917688846588135,
0.15422192215919495,
-1.3709779977798462,
0.6235094666481018,
-0.09948430955410004,
0.31036025285720825,
0.44107893109321594,
0.4788694679737091,
-0.019232403486967087,
-0.48349708318710327,
-0.8758070468902588,
-0.8411142826080322,
0.5350623726844788,
0.4585304260253906,
0.015505914576351643,
0.04700009897351265,
0.4438041150569916,
0.23784495890140533,
-0.049169838428497314,
-0.754315197467804,
0.12753935158252716,
0.10368909686803818,
-0.27819550037384033,
-0.049003567546606064,
-0.21096085011959076,
-0.12105544656515121,
-0.6056593656539917,
0.9828352928161621,
-0.3899175226688385,
0.45589298009872437,
0.43915364146232605,
-0.482257217168808,
-0.13353389501571655,
0.10369975864887238,
0.665067732334137,
0.9918450713157654,
-0.1591915488243103,
0.3533806800842285,
0.31696486473083496,
-0.4213654100894928,
0.37897956371307373,
-0.42457708716392517,
-0.03015158139169216,
-0.09273794293403625,
0.29296156764030457,
0.576404869556427,
0.3740910291671753,
-0.4466208517551422,
0.5100230574607849,
-0.15983764827251434,
-0.019829435274004936,
-0.40089166164398193,
0.16126257181167603,
-0.014908626675605774,
0.24098093807697296,
0.11657622456550598,
0.1275518238544464,
0.007694851141422987,
-0.7686102390289307,
0.2189408838748932,
0.1479950100183487,
-0.48290541768074036,
-0.3235315680503845,
0.5054263472557068,
0.19310782849788666,
0.05120323598384857,
0.5301553606987,
-0.14189304411411285,
-0.5695825815200806,
0.66060471534729,
0.847473680973053,
1.1973134279251099,
-0.10121726989746094,
0.1416623592376709,
0.5141998529434204,
0.4749614894390106,
-0.4832506775856018,
0.18439361453056335,
-0.4366438686847687,
-0.5642359256744385,
-0.5531116127967834,
-0.22802071273326874,
-0.5444937944412231,
-0.19964680075645447,
-0.4582403302192688,
0.4309632480144501,
-0.6782791018486023,
0.1200992614030838,
-0.13293208181858063,
0.06878652423620224,
-0.6833035945892334,
0.4544505774974823,
0.3900051414966583,
0.781607449054718,
-0.6134201288223267,
1.0633987188339233,
0.44435834884643555,
-0.5848713517189026,
-1.1024831533432007,
0.1106748953461647,
-0.22163201868534088,
-0.6461614966392517,
0.5214517116546631,
0.22311335802078247,
-0.5099667310714722,
-0.22327744960784912,
-0.8200172185897827,
-0.8193065524101257,
0.9253329038619995,
0.3603130877017975,
-0.5001457929611206,
-0.19493575394153595,
-0.1210889220237732,
0.5543951392173767,
-0.7213642597198486,
0.6610997319221497,
0.4711008369922638,
0.17981956899166107,
0.24297215044498444,
-0.8081681728363037,
0.2280357927083969,
-0.22482983767986298,
0.09666930139064789,
0.20978742837905884,
-0.4949329197406769,
1.0089446306228638,
-0.5821265578269958,
-0.06330712884664536,
-0.1222500428557396,
0.735541045665741,
0.31392788887023926,
0.2764444053173065,
0.5352915525436401,
0.1562918722629547,
0.85001140832901,
0.05511944741010666,
1.102994441986084,
-0.17207615077495575,
0.3114628791809082,
1.5955275297164917,
-0.22955168783664703,
0.8329800367355347,
0.25183314085006714,
0.08903820067644119,
0.593055248260498,
0.2959632873535156,
0.6805775165557861,
0.4142889082431793,
0.09050416201353073,
-0.47022315859794617,
-0.24390588700771332,
0.4279533922672272,
-0.3040074408054352,
0.33890780806541443,
0.49095016717910767,
-0.3250819444656372,
-0.20753984153270721,
-0.15552560985088348,
0.10667699575424194,
0.2033294290304184,
-0.6254104375839233,
1.0035357475280762,
0.2544820308685303,
-0.6228605508804321,
0.8243313431739807,
-0.1097702607512474,
0.2468791902065277,
-0.699532151222229,
-0.27988311648368835,
-0.12707124650478363,
0.32189950346946716,
-0.06497520208358765,
-0.6614829301834106,
0.39553549885749817,
0.3256324827671051,
0.022643329575657845,
-0.23227553069591522,
0.656687319278717,
-0.6711970567703247,
-0.8434146046638489,
0.2994842827320099,
0.37043339014053345,
-0.01237515453249216,
-0.2144477516412735,
-0.38393983244895935,
-0.16016040742397308,
-0.06457317620515823,
-0.1573643982410431,
0.18051573634147644,
0.5926414728164673,
-0.4124288856983185,
0.7835707664489746,
0.6725379228591919,
0.1652328222990036,
0.3090757727622986,
0.05089780315756798,
1.0964784622192383,
-0.8041840195655823,
-0.5430493950843811,
-0.694296658039093,
0.6673657894134521,
-0.2672274112701416,
-0.19136802852153778,
0.20997744798660278,
0.39592495560646057,
1.019625186920166,
-0.1887170523405075,
0.7732030749320984,
0.14658214151859283,
-0.006067272275686264,
-0.7359308004379272,
0.4072587490081787,
-0.1736132800579071,
0.4029868245124817,
-0.15804457664489746,
-0.8388151526451111,
0.0746215432882309,
0.6232866048812866,
-0.4495832920074463,
0.07425478100776672,
1.1359796524047852,
0.6935523748397827,
-0.26607346534729004,
0.19317422807216644,
0.30754104256629944,
0.3786160349845886,
0.418634295463562,
0.5801032781600952,
0.7223011255264282,
-0.6276261806488037,
0.35555151104927063,
-0.7585048079490662,
-0.3149401843547821,
0.21364812552928925,
-0.7468713521957397,
-0.924090564250946,
-0.5408613085746765,
-0.2247137874364853,
-0.3749676048755646,
0.39898931980133057,
1.2675676345825195,
0.7498590350151062,
-0.7247413992881775,
-0.24240121245384216,
-0.5487073063850403,
0.27588310837745667,
-0.4737147092819214,
-0.13458652794361115,
0.40416473150253296,
-0.8437651991844177,
-0.6654398441314697,
0.31874585151672363,
0.06622136384248734,
0.09615081548690796,
-0.02851150929927826,
-0.08413884788751602,
-0.26339659094810486,
0.4165210425853729,
0.8132951259613037,
-0.05907959118485451,
-0.8802328705787659,
-0.4827217757701874,
-0.35846665501594543,
-0.1638791263103485,
-0.003242172533646226,
1.1704747676849365,
-0.9669714570045471,
0.4310813248157501,
0.3614523410797119,
0.15038125216960907,
0.9993951320648193,
0.19901885092258453,
0.9989572167396545,
-0.8076731562614441,
0.40578919649124146,
0.21938519179821014,
0.3173644244670868,
0.06322533637285233,
-0.7134509086608887,
0.8797038793563843,
-0.20839428901672363,
-0.3053125739097595,
-0.8625304102897644,
0.10513544082641602,
-0.9348053932189941,
-0.34381821751594543,
1.1846954822540283,
-0.1970343291759491,
-0.5548987984657288,
0.020830649882555008,
-0.6416841149330139,
0.3810020089149475,
-0.20802059769630432,
0.7117990851402283,
0.3853239417076111,
-0.2792697846889496,
-0.2638702392578125,
-0.2452685832977295,
0.7504826784133911,
0.03475498408079147,
-0.7668439745903015,
0.17537382245063782,
0.10241137444972992,
0.3160051107406616,
-0.1744924634695053,
0.8079549074172974,
-0.3888385593891144,
0.379300981760025,
0.3265744149684906,
-0.034919753670692444,
-0.11324002593755722,
-0.547784149646759,
-0.177514910697937,
0.12945440411567688,
0.11311828345060349,
0.0010171170579269528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14831v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14831v1
|
HippoRAG: Neurobiologically Inspired Long-Term Memory for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T17:47:55 | 2024-05-23T17:47:55 |
Bernal Jiménez Gutiérrez, Yiheng Shu, Yu Gu, Michihiro Yasunaga, Yu Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In order to thrive in hostile and ever-changing natural environments,
mammalian brains evolved to store large amounts of knowledge about the world
and continually integrate new information while avoiding catastrophic
forgetting. Despite the impressive accomplishments, large language models
(LLMs), even with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), still struggle to
efficiently and effectively integrate a large amount of new experiences after
pre-training. In this work, we introduce HippoRAG, a novel retrieval framework
inspired by the hippocampal indexing theory of human long-term memory to enable
deeper and more efficient knowledge integration over new experiences. HippoRAG
synergistically orchestrates LLMs, knowledge graphs, and the Personalized
PageRank algorithm to mimic the different roles of neocortex and hippocampus in
human memory. We compare HippoRAG with existing RAG methods on multi-hop
question answering and show that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art
methods remarkably, by up to 20%. Single-step retrieval with HippoRAG achieves
comparable or better performance than iterative retrieval like IRCoT while
being 10-30 times cheaper and 6-13 times faster, and integrating HippoRAG into
IRCoT brings further substantial gains. Finally, we show that our method can
tackle new types of scenarios that are out of reach of existing methods. Code
and data are available at https://github.com/OSU-NLP-Group/HippoRAG.
|
[
-0.1373000293970108,
-1.1610184907913208,
0.6435046195983887,
0.20129139721393585,
-0.06843061000108719,
0.3517672121524811,
-0.29316246509552,
-0.6879730224609375,
0.43126413226127625,
0.4182347357273102,
-0.1263277232646942,
-0.4223342537879944,
-0.2827463150024414,
-0.38988998532295227,
0.027069494128227234,
0.8060088753700256,
-0.041113756597042084,
-0.0633620172739029,
-0.400160014629364,
-0.280361145734787,
-0.2540726065635681,
-0.6634740233421326,
-0.27169159054756165,
-0.6081892848014832,
0.8269632458686829,
0.12379220128059387,
0.31785932183265686,
0.4551428556442261,
0.43121203780174255,
0.12675517797470093,
-0.28070691227912903,
0.27598562836647034,
-0.6066772937774658,
0.30102822184562683,
-0.3089313507080078,
-0.3791823983192444,
-0.33914217352867126,
-0.29910165071487427,
0.7139328122138977,
0.869053304195404,
-0.2783817648887634,
0.10626760870218277,
-0.02807183749973774,
0.5995321869850159,
-0.9311186671257019,
-0.21208234131336212,
-0.6419343948364258,
0.011000788770616055,
-0.158969447016716,
-0.5537216663360596,
-0.44212716817855835,
-0.13086462020874023,
0.24695752561092377,
-0.5157493352890015,
-0.02485661394894123,
0.18967118859291077,
0.5855758786201477,
0.13798511028289795,
-0.10346248000860214,
-0.1213589683175087,
-0.7312083840370178,
0.8194149136543274,
-0.5204183459281921,
0.4254428744316101,
0.5419433116912842,
0.09780620783567429,
-0.4741505980491638,
-0.6060121655464172,
-0.35259193181991577,
-0.29376742243766785,
0.1301015168428421,
-0.17159517109394073,
0.1081567332148552,
0.057580895721912384,
0.06292938441038132,
0.13553005456924438,
-0.7102009654045105,
-0.0005133586819283664,
-0.19461651146411896,
-0.2768775522708893,
0.15696407854557037,
0.09072163701057434,
0.04636326804757118,
-0.11382930725812912,
-0.6934514045715332,
0.16100071370601654,
-0.3889249265193939,
0.025158431380987167,
0.06482113897800446,
0.1286115050315857,
0.4986603558063507,
0.3580576479434967,
-0.20017792284488678,
0.5984774231910706,
-0.25858238339424133,
-0.3282599151134491,
0.47039470076560974,
-0.01630236580967903,
0.09924273937940598,
-0.15246979892253876,
0.7897517085075378,
0.10096237063407898,
-0.12881743907928467,
-0.5438092350959778,
-0.11591324955224991,
-0.16078127920627594,
0.22408470511436462,
-0.7975167036056519,
-0.3090653717517853,
0.25696903467178345,
-0.5181830525398254,
-0.01689530722796917,
-0.37442606687545776,
-1.0255085229873657,
-0.4714513421058655,
0.12017706781625748,
0.9455009698867798,
-0.8805260062217712,
-0.10291215777397156,
0.4325309991836548,
-0.43167662620544434,
0.4346204996109009,
0.3012846112251282,
-0.5805758833885193,
0.39033883810043335,
0.8028411865234375,
0.8292124271392822,
-0.40729641914367676,
-0.5666515231132507,
-0.6861370801925659,
0.2074534147977829,
-0.3219500780105591,
0.849193274974823,
-0.7326284050941467,
-0.21508270502090454,
-0.12489763647317886,
-0.16905473172664642,
0.032345518469810486,
-0.6850848197937012,
0.28416967391967773,
-0.7651904821395874,
0.16940005123615265,
-0.28736454248428345,
-0.6208049654960632,
-0.012555726803839207,
0.22633999586105347,
-0.3297463059425354,
0.980343222618103,
-0.037979211658239365,
-0.8840040564537048,
0.14523695409297943,
-0.550298810005188,
-0.3354083299636841,
0.4038064777851105,
-0.07567641884088516,
-0.24953629076480865,
-0.04755124822258949,
-0.22659172117710114,
0.20568808913230896,
-0.38408395648002625,
0.2402919977903366,
-0.4232622981071472,
-0.4517207145690918,
0.01731587015092373,
-0.024855155497789383,
0.6807504296302795,
0.02491133287549019,
-0.13268311321735382,
-0.16624942421913147,
-0.677590012550354,
0.0915120467543602,
0.26210200786590576,
-0.4487626254558563,
-0.9528273940086365,
-0.1555715650320053,
-0.18333373963832855,
-0.002471976215019822,
0.6844402551651001,
-0.7547604441642761,
0.2520356774330139,
0.06682412326335907,
0.48046261072158813,
0.4921276569366455,
0.30629831552505493,
0.47605976462364197,
-0.34174802899360657,
0.3819511830806732,
0.06159597635269165,
0.052197448909282684,
-0.51223224401474,
-0.4362049698829651,
-0.3796505331993103,
-0.19532588124275208,
0.18090663850307465,
0.42687714099884033,
-0.5312836766242981,
0.41441771388053894,
-0.1816275715827942,
-0.5053386092185974,
-0.4483644366264343,
0.24437187612056732,
0.1490730494260788,
0.6320186853408813,
0.6385630965232849,
-0.4915631413459778,
-0.40650931000709534,
-0.6923867464065552,
-0.08164059370756149,
-0.18996869027614594,
0.04187643527984619,
0.492084801197052,
0.392045259475708,
-0.5848168730735779,
0.7536411881446838,
-0.5681329965591431,
-0.07063275575637817,
0.062052834779024124,
0.29577285051345825,
0.19454653561115265,
0.407371461391449,
0.44921112060546875,
-0.5359630584716797,
-0.06795983016490936,
-0.15296779572963715,
-0.3540821969509125,
0.1494169384241104,
-0.06357745081186295,
-0.48091572523117065,
0.06834924221038818,
0.3385586440563202,
-1.090383768081665,
0.17331399023532867,
0.35747072100639343,
-0.4932059943675995,
0.74784916639328,
-0.514006495475769,
0.03854283690452576,
-0.985363245010376,
0.4153878688812256,
-0.36025822162628174,
-0.1818445771932602,
-0.4867550730705261,
-0.0013766199117526412,
0.30210599303245544,
-0.08216773718595505,
-0.10907463729381561,
0.7045724987983704,
-0.3313906490802765,
0.04601268097758293,
-0.4087469279766083,
0.24007660150527954,
0.23623868823051453,
0.47209393978118896,
-0.12172485142946243,
0.6062237024307251,
0.5433011054992676,
-0.6789567470550537,
0.20426075160503387,
0.3440842032432556,
-0.4707212746143341,
0.11675713211297989,
-0.5234255194664001,
0.19773387908935547,
-0.4268205165863037,
0.5101564526557922,
-1.0399158000946045,
0.05071256309747696,
0.04344085603952408,
-0.406508207321167,
0.3847227096557617,
0.025923563167452812,
-0.38569310307502747,
-0.331061989068985,
-0.16594566404819489,
0.5044994950294495,
0.7354221940040588,
-0.648221492767334,
0.6836404800415039,
0.547237753868103,
-0.2007087916135788,
-0.8474693298339844,
-0.3682524561882019,
0.14362852275371552,
-0.3250258266925812,
-0.2137131541967392,
0.5691182613372803,
-0.2558281421661377,
0.005243457388132811,
-0.07071185857057571,
-0.22077536582946777,
-0.08275119960308075,
-0.04620742425322533,
-0.11214030534029007,
0.2880849540233612,
-0.10925491899251938,
0.6484900712966919,
-0.3584739863872528,
0.0770326629281044,
0.03858783468604088,
-0.4272851049900055,
0.9991687536239624,
0.003173715667799115,
-0.01220722310245037,
-0.1208946630358696,
0.5009046792984009,
0.6268633008003235,
-0.5937814712524414,
0.7289641499519348,
0.8275365233421326,
-0.30619990825653076,
-0.42624056339263916,
-0.6080843210220337,
-0.24439232051372528,
-0.4235024154186249,
0.5848357677459717,
-0.26068851351737976,
-0.8930281400680542,
0.4733140170574188,
-0.35769298672676086,
0.03361662104725838,
0.06268680095672607,
0.38415196537971497,
-0.22050298750400543,
0.39918848872184753,
0.6446476578712463,
-0.16930349171161652,
0.5807854533195496,
-0.12581025063991547,
0.19523820281028748,
-1.1994997262954712,
-0.3409249186515808,
-0.4664388597011566,
-0.3891994059085846,
-0.5519837737083435,
-0.9315627813339233,
0.09021176397800446,
0.2510438859462738,
-0.08999022841453552,
0.25511395931243896,
-0.3457299470901489,
0.4816115200519562,
0.4949086010456085,
0.18767796456813812,
0.14969657361507416,
-0.21065686643123627,
-0.2673790752887726,
0.153567835688591,
-0.7488563060760498,
-0.14994826912879944,
0.9795492887496948,
0.4585520327091217,
1.0644266605377197,
-0.2600037157535553,
0.933836817741394,
0.0652516782283783,
-0.0037108848337084055,
-1.015934944152832,
0.5847923755645752,
-0.01171103399246931,
-0.5606634616851807,
-0.32663577795028687,
-0.5266308784484863,
-1.2395299673080444,
0.361798495054245,
-0.2436937540769577,
-0.9725103974342346,
0.2186962515115738,
0.05495859682559967,
-0.6021642684936523,
0.4178171157836914,
-0.567018985748291,
0.6492987871170044,
-0.46464428305625916,
-0.722651481628418,
-0.5093581080436707,
-0.650431752204895,
0.12992757558822632,
0.055471260100603104,
-0.07223530113697052,
-0.15557056665420532,
-0.42825302481651306,
0.8608098030090332,
0.07714205235242844,
0.5049037337303162,
-0.2593396306037903,
0.014911993406713009,
0.33091917634010315,
0.0829668864607811,
0.32127368450164795,
-0.009322511963546276,
-0.11799675226211548,
0.18589210510253906,
0.055711738765239716,
-0.5678722262382507,
-0.3942350447177887,
0.9373331069946289,
-0.7673854231834412,
-0.5070754289627075,
-0.41948944330215454,
-0.7462206482887268,
-0.45279717445373535,
0.3891147971153259,
-0.1416790783405304,
0.2768137753009796,
-0.24206897616386414,
0.48940911889076233,
0.9840441942214966,
-0.5998977422714233,
0.3329075872898102,
0.516645610332489,
-0.5112380981445312,
-0.5462056994438171,
0.7898631691932678,
-0.018085243180394173,
0.1442733108997345,
0.667930006980896,
0.49624332785606384,
-0.020343830808997154,
-0.4866194725036621,
0.1681482046842575,
0.677443265914917,
-0.4439657926559448,
-0.27624720335006714,
-1.0658468008041382,
-0.09258779138326645,
-0.3263545036315918,
0.11723598837852478,
-0.3198050260543823,
-0.39466631412506104,
0.038728851824998856,
0.2108212411403656,
0.41902583837509155,
0.3782447576522827,
-0.12846943736076355,
-0.06531920284032822,
-0.7160773873329163,
0.6731358170509338,
0.3454747796058655,
0.6005482077598572,
-0.06300235539674759,
-0.47713392972946167,
-0.3138837516307831,
-0.07965200394392014,
-0.3057438135147095,
-0.7756168246269226,
0.4105145037174225,
0.24413296580314636,
0.684066653251648,
0.09319386631250381,
-0.07263551652431488,
0.845091700553894,
-0.804838240146637,
0.4115917384624481,
0.05090612173080444,
-0.40686509013175964,
0.26130515336990356,
-0.25246211886405945,
0.526270866394043,
0.4524027407169342,
0.6532914042472839,
-0.6939519047737122,
-0.015996795147657394,
-0.5427627563476562,
-1.0701898336410522,
0.2293282300233841,
-0.3829769790172577,
0.10316982120275497,
-0.17505361139774323,
0.5500965714454651,
0.3225880265235901,
0.16405364871025085,
-0.06763001531362534,
0.007570923306047916,
0.1928597241640091,
0.3082730174064636,
-0.3129366338253021,
-0.3261708617210388,
-0.0557778924703598,
-0.28724533319473267,
0.5772414207458496,
-0.14133810997009277,
0.47884446382522583,
0.2443394511938095,
0.1262974739074707,
-0.1718238890171051,
0.2208554744720459,
0.18811962008476257,
0.7803115248680115,
-0.5437984466552734,
0.08464302122592926,
0.07375882565975189,
-0.4258638918399811,
-0.10711986571550369,
0.16885240375995636,
-0.053171396255493164,
0.22780287265777588,
0.07319100946187973,
0.4616785943508148,
0.1490660309791565,
-0.8988621830940247,
0.31095585227012634,
-0.02583339624106884,
-0.008296511135995388,
-0.4039630889892578,
0.0618009977042675,
0.4505270719528198,
0.2792750597000122,
0.6187485456466675,
0.004545337520539761,
0.17203117907047272,
-0.7379066944122314,
0.4625810384750366,
0.6891864538192749,
-0.14072394371032715,
-0.14040672779083252,
0.3920126259326935,
-0.09308411180973053,
-0.6065574288368225,
0.46191924810409546,
-0.0705905631184578,
-0.32728686928749084,
0.10314610600471497,
0.7744469046592712,
0.7091189622879028,
-0.3359999358654022,
0.29778555035591125,
0.4538877606391907,
-0.08129390329122543,
-0.0403665192425251,
0.23611178994178772,
-0.2792999744415283,
-0.6632505059242249,
-0.5099197626113892,
-1.090820550918579,
-0.32677075266838074,
0.3476182818412781,
-0.48179706931114197,
0.04176439344882965,
-0.44982603192329407,
-0.3026775121688843,
-0.06478067487478256,
0.17184452712535858,
-0.40766292810440063,
-0.10420960187911987,
0.24118821322917938,
1.0397828817367554,
-0.4892136752605438,
1.037192702293396,
0.7016493082046509,
0.10980596393346786,
-0.17967140674591064,
0.20630377531051636,
-0.5591469407081604,
-0.7038407921791077,
0.2971457540988922,
0.1538405567407608,
-0.1678265482187271,
-0.18013456463813782,
-0.5007074475288391,
-0.9704756736755371,
1.1585280895233154,
0.1052948608994484,
-0.4323136508464813,
-0.5163024067878723,
-0.3548981845378876,
0.7456235289573669,
-0.28211021423339844,
-0.023641042411327362,
0.6505917906761169,
0.048366397619247437,
0.24201686680316925,
-0.7360197901725769,
-0.29081040620803833,
-0.17408782243728638,
-0.08151554316282272,
0.5869830250740051,
-0.865700900554657,
0.7111395001411438,
-0.42500948905944824,
0.08289901912212372,
0.10223809629678726,
0.4660922884941101,
0.45415663719177246,
0.22006992995738983,
0.26926347613334656,
0.690635621547699,
0.9125707745552063,
0.20472712814807892,
0.8453609347343445,
-0.25207433104515076,
0.1675727218389511,
1.4401434659957886,
-0.08023017644882202,
1.1711550951004028,
0.8626708984375,
0.09020411223173141,
0.7404228448867798,
0.12323687970638275,
0.3878515362739563,
0.572791337966919,
0.050949811935424805,
-0.17743127048015594,
-0.445850670337677,
-0.22822263836860657,
-0.16715162992477417,
0.5727155804634094,
0.4975722134113312,
-0.1939544826745987,
-0.22436858713626862,
0.040844615548849106,
-0.07384535670280457,
0.056384969502687454,
-0.05773642659187317,
0.7297325134277344,
0.2023269087076187,
-0.569037675857544,
0.7515303492546082,
-0.3267509341239929,
0.7337056994438171,
-0.7680373787879944,
-0.19282856583595276,
-0.03924928233027458,
0.2740182876586914,
0.20898281037807465,
-0.6628832817077637,
-0.02723945491015911,
-0.334729939699173,
0.13332630693912506,
-0.2418157160282135,
0.649620532989502,
-0.6705667972564697,
-0.005733121186494827,
0.5177929997444153,
0.4948924779891968,
-0.07526607811450958,
0.15825852751731873,
-0.6661801934242249,
-0.029238764196634293,
-0.243535116314888,
-0.397838830947876,
0.4817013144493103,
0.5071505904197693,
0.13965177536010742,
0.8359988331794739,
0.4532660245895386,
0.2704008221626282,
-0.030857082456350327,
-0.2220357060432434,
0.7528671622276306,
-0.9231773614883423,
-0.5065065026283264,
-0.5487763285636902,
0.1949908584356308,
-0.03308345377445221,
-0.1319284290075302,
0.5832473635673523,
0.6146096587181091,
0.5544624328613281,
0.02309427224099636,
0.6287644505500793,
-0.15672865509986877,
0.7704744935035706,
-0.07842056453227997,
0.6293885707855225,
-0.47704023122787476,
-0.08403057605028152,
-0.14207836985588074,
-0.881040632724762,
-0.137990802526474,
0.5409901738166809,
-0.4144010841846466,
-0.12233170121908188,
0.8193783760070801,
0.6361276507377625,
0.034148264676332474,
-0.3506663143634796,
0.5786831974983215,
0.39045873284339905,
0.41774576902389526,
0.9233077764511108,
0.7867875695228577,
-0.3113628923892975,
0.5329891443252563,
-0.3209424316883087,
-0.3476259708404541,
-0.22469346225261688,
-0.6087160706520081,
-0.7488571405410767,
-0.5974692106246948,
-0.14750376343727112,
-0.28140848875045776,
0.13281838595867157,
0.9255490899085999,
0.46820494532585144,
-0.42341718077659607,
-0.2169421911239624,
0.17381323873996735,
-0.16433550417423248,
-0.021706748753786087,
-0.20264022052288055,
0.20931747555732727,
-0.7082164287567139,
-0.35398757457733154,
0.48667097091674805,
0.5548652410507202,
-0.1427960842847824,
-0.2511085569858551,
-0.00545021565631032,
-0.5834643840789795,
0.06370573490858078,
0.5453794002532959,
0.44131943583488464,
-0.40525588393211365,
-0.22413356602191925,
0.24075911939144135,
-0.15388061106204987,
0.34825488924980164,
0.7909215092658997,
-1.081653118133545,
0.6160224676132202,
0.7863271236419678,
0.9526534080505371,
0.6220948100090027,
0.08591622114181519,
0.32008153200149536,
-0.050690993666648865,
0.1493569165468216,
0.663515031337738,
0.38819143176078796,
0.38145098090171814,
-0.26787951588630676,
0.11008381098508835,
0.011606195010244846,
-0.9339690804481506,
-0.5757036805152893,
0.1764736920595169,
-0.8700342774391174,
-0.4345369040966034,
1.2425436973571777,
0.021642375737428665,
-0.6746777892112732,
-0.045174941420555115,
-0.12436848878860474,
-0.010118127800524235,
-0.3001587986946106,
1.153550386428833,
0.5415053367614746,
-0.21426288783550262,
-0.05493137240409851,
-0.46558964252471924,
0.39656922221183777,
0.5772475004196167,
-0.7097086906433105,
0.2703452408313751,
0.6602143049240112,
0.3973175287246704,
0.4833671450614929,
0.6152825355529785,
-0.23869088292121887,
0.388835608959198,
0.023105688393115997,
0.019762072712183,
0.2595176100730896,
-0.5856226682662964,
-0.16757231950759888,
0.35511577129364014,
0.24146513640880585,
-0.07016408443450928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20347v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20347v1
|
Small Language Models for Application Interactions: A Case Study
| 2024-05-23T17:33:32 | 2024-05-23T17:33:32 |
Beibin Li, Yi Zhang, Sébastien Bubeck, Jeevan Pathuri, Ishai Menache
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We study the efficacy of Small Language Models (SLMs) in facilitating
application usage through natural language interactions. Our focus here is on a
particular internal application used in Microsoft for cloud supply chain
fulfilment. Our experiments show that small models can outperform much larger
ones in terms of both accuracy and running time, even when fine-tuned on small
datasets. Alongside these results, we also highlight SLM-based system design
considerations.
|
[
-0.24408094584941864,
-0.6301131248474121,
0.6724417209625244,
0.008107234723865986,
-0.16395536065101624,
-0.06172681227326393,
-0.4238913059234619,
-0.8882727026939392,
0.0370735302567482,
0.5201077461242676,
-0.6336864829063416,
-0.18509164452552795,
0.146399587392807,
0.06716766208410263,
-0.544601559638977,
0.7052255272865295,
-0.011836839839816093,
-0.04806539788842201,
-0.47475412487983704,
-0.11809729784727097,
-0.7425052523612976,
-0.7574976682662964,
-0.9813647270202637,
-0.7083501219749451,
0.3528415858745575,
0.7094504833221436,
1.2890368700027466,
0.46435728669166565,
0.8036524057388306,
0.32474321126937866,
-0.14948713779449463,
0.010759192518889904,
-0.2754559814929962,
-0.02788802981376648,
-0.3082900643348694,
-0.615096926689148,
-0.1812896579504013,
-0.15755201876163483,
0.3640598654747009,
0.6883713603019714,
-0.6647032499313354,
0.33170682191848755,
0.12368189543485641,
0.7128252983093262,
-0.4962632358074188,
-0.08782268315553665,
-0.6460089683532715,
0.0931444987654686,
-0.0036591042298823595,
0.3451210558414459,
-0.43821442127227783,
-0.1463364213705063,
0.2828451097011566,
-0.2907727062702179,
0.35601726174354553,
0.3710640072822571,
0.775539219379425,
-0.11201683431863785,
-0.24806343019008636,
-0.8754235506057739,
-1.0791045427322388,
1.0514070987701416,
-1.1650702953338623,
0.15254651010036469,
0.5959970951080322,
0.3386828601360321,
-0.2506791949272156,
-0.9146662354469299,
-0.4620538055896759,
-0.42981916666030884,
-0.7144272327423096,
-0.4817065894603729,
-0.47465869784355164,
0.21958981454372406,
0.18261538445949554,
0.5437176823616028,
-0.44170862436294556,
0.27096298336982727,
-0.5355691909790039,
0.22251269221305847,
0.6711347103118896,
0.7344201803207397,
0.431105375289917,
0.001725394744426012,
-0.22368232905864716,
0.3780926465988159,
-0.6296371817588806,
0.13473109900951385,
-0.010604573413729668,
0.8245010375976562,
-0.2044014036655426,
0.6523213982582092,
0.051108118146657944,
1.1284801959991455,
-0.263379842042923,
0.04365452006459236,
-0.4139908254146576,
-0.5745139122009277,
-0.7685774564743042,
0.027089470997452736,
0.6522067189216614,
0.12669074535369873,
0.007795429788529873,
-0.1826540231704712,
-0.3908509314060211,
0.21485215425491333,
0.7017737030982971,
-0.6358323097229004,
-0.15585365891456604,
0.2504937946796417,
-0.5483512878417969,
-0.33090317249298096,
0.01887998729944229,
-0.6222633719444275,
-0.49922114610671997,
-0.5653756260871887,
0.33523377776145935,
-0.05701623857021332,
0.08641881495714188,
-0.023236004635691643,
0.11105089634656906,
0.06338141113519669,
0.10247872024774551,
-0.8044558763504028,
1.0508490800857544,
0.7867105603218079,
1.1036865711212158,
-0.28228560090065,
-0.17197853326797485,
-0.5901988744735718,
0.33989620208740234,
-0.4136001467704773,
0.4878848195075989,
-0.4130592346191406,
-0.2645050287246704,
0.19571472704410553,
0.037203945219516754,
-0.01648079790174961,
-0.941314160823822,
0.29166895151138306,
-0.3564261794090271,
-0.07662546634674072,
-0.15117181837558746,
-0.6042127013206482,
0.09529148042201996,
0.13479934632778168,
-0.5826594233512878,
0.8145978450775146,
-0.0052413418889045715,
-0.2907197177410126,
0.1690872311592102,
-0.7377368211746216,
-0.5728752017021179,
0.27999553084373474,
-0.19113001227378845,
-0.24686706066131592,
0.6814952492713928,
-0.39476504921913147,
0.3778053820133209,
-0.3702586591243744,
-0.13615721464157104,
-0.3671965003013611,
-0.41445866227149963,
0.14428728818893433,
0.2400793731212616,
0.3579373061656952,
0.4104687571525574,
-0.1043444573879242,
0.061651330441236496,
-0.5468703508377075,
0.1993623524904251,
0.1220882385969162,
0.031858135014772415,
-0.5922299027442932,
0.12094839662313461,
0.10039874911308289,
0.41757383942604065,
0.10456568747758865,
-0.2515084445476532,
0.2944195866584778,
-0.5234388113021851,
0.7784935832023621,
0.2675650417804718,
-0.04586813598871231,
0.8292394876480103,
-0.288929283618927,
0.8529314994812012,
-0.06425122171640396,
0.2972075939178467,
0.0955616906285286,
-0.5357957482337952,
-0.8265941739082336,
0.01845022290945053,
0.24287885427474976,
0.19818450510501862,
-0.8190410733222961,
-0.22358721494674683,
0.1548791080713272,
-0.5288633108139038,
-0.38418900966644287,
0.6195688843727112,
0.09814051538705826,
0.16569821536540985,
-0.04064156115055084,
-0.18689027428627014,
-0.6051369905471802,
-1.1819491386413574,
-0.33750513195991516,
-0.2783496081829071,
-0.026138942688703537,
0.5201225876808167,
0.3475439250469208,
-0.5167174339294434,
1.4599050283432007,
-0.5226023197174072,
-0.45787563920021057,
-0.4231550991535187,
0.1757325530052185,
0.25368326902389526,
0.29950234293937683,
0.6844902634620667,
-0.6341351270675659,
-0.6363971829414368,
0.2278083860874176,
-0.593416690826416,
-0.0028463236521929502,
-0.0923122838139534,
-0.04730577394366264,
0.3844964802265167,
0.13178618252277374,
-0.644967257976532,
0.677412211894989,
0.5606722831726074,
-0.2965272068977356,
0.2345999926328659,
-0.5949345827102661,
-0.31426334381103516,
-0.7742927074432373,
-0.2339792102575302,
0.24430403113365173,
-0.386113703250885,
-1.1117312908172607,
0.06559675931930542,
0.12868691980838776,
-0.4623069167137146,
-0.8836352229118347,
0.4912460148334503,
-0.5911353230476379,
-0.3988915979862213,
-0.5080700516700745,
0.24112534523010254,
0.012461967766284943,
-0.0055792550556361675,
0.20635056495666504,
0.8904041051864624,
0.12451113760471344,
-0.8050202131271362,
0.10860428959131241,
0.06673558801412582,
-0.3740675151348114,
0.6469849348068237,
-0.8680022954940796,
0.12480185180902481,
0.013889593072235584,
-0.35145097970962524,
-0.8088506460189819,
0.01697630062699318,
-0.20479758083820343,
0.25308284163475037,
-0.10647006332874298,
-0.14844080805778503,
-0.8377188444137573,
-0.7226256132125854,
-0.05253036692738533,
-0.15218377113342285,
0.42037859559059143,
-0.5246265530586243,
0.5330080389976501,
0.397047221660614,
-0.054437123239040375,
0.38512349128723145,
-1.062493920326233,
0.18258939683437347,
-0.33486154675483704,
-0.7329220771789551,
0.046284452080726624,
-0.26830407977104187,
-0.5679636001586914,
-0.1868819147348404,
0.15075252950191498,
-0.4005107581615448,
0.16687814891338348,
0.37205401062965393,
0.160987988114357,
-0.2875252962112427,
0.15126994252204895,
-0.4750903844833374,
0.1449999213218689,
-0.12273415178060532,
0.1547672152519226,
0.34680798649787903,
-0.582063615322113,
-0.20477394759655,
-0.5167977213859558,
0.608728289604187,
0.6207122206687927,
0.3604971170425415,
1.1109099388122559,
0.09543080627918243,
-0.7870064377784729,
-0.2187989205121994,
-0.2363407164812088,
-0.38490697741508484,
-0.5993340611457825,
-0.15690171718597412,
-0.2993640601634979,
-0.5674306154251099,
0.5148671865463257,
0.2996043562889099,
-0.1971571445465088,
0.17851801216602325,
0.4636814296245575,
-0.2692756950855255,
1.1182547807693481,
1.0916630029678345,
-0.16985833644866943,
0.5095569491386414,
-0.16806282103061676,
0.5705022811889648,
-0.5266587138175964,
-0.0021946313790977,
-0.5815047025680542,
-0.3340928554534912,
-0.245832622051239,
-0.10575873404741287,
-0.00963614508509636,
0.66279137134552,
-0.160434752702713,
0.6068729162216187,
-0.31495770812034607,
0.38725215196609497,
0.22287438809871674,
-0.36113032698631287,
0.3601486086845398,
0.04148062318563461,
-0.003955969586968422,
-0.33282750844955444,
-1.1242482662200928,
-0.9794371724128723,
0.1583097279071808,
0.5034708380699158,
1.0987106561660767,
0.40462034940719604,
0.3997088670730591,
0.5767810940742493,
0.5720415115356445,
-0.7215657830238342,
0.4563434422016144,
-0.24558785557746887,
-0.39719608426094055,
0.04265217483043671,
-0.26615816354751587,
-1.129710078239441,
0.1189332902431488,
-0.03634067624807358,
-1.1251420974731445,
0.16953936219215393,
0.41626420617103577,
-0.43324559926986694,
0.06222154200077057,
-1.4099303483963013,
0.9741561412811279,
-0.44168198108673096,
-0.37323352694511414,
-0.04058361053466797,
-0.23904572427272797,
0.11772845685482025,
0.18535451591014862,
0.553522527217865,
0.24985651671886444,
-0.1872836947441101,
0.4381965100765228,
-1.00301992893219,
1.0097988843917847,
0.09308688342571259,
-0.2268650233745575,
0.42293110489845276,
0.16988669335842133,
0.8748571276664734,
-0.22248129546642303,
-0.13667818903923035,
0.08002002537250519,
0.247754767537117,
-0.21600234508514404,
-0.576187789440155,
1.0198503732681274,
-0.42537519335746765,
-0.2816798686981201,
-0.5627695918083191,
-0.40990903973579407,
-0.2952425479888916,
0.1968923807144165,
-0.15840765833854675,
0.07355061173439026,
-0.05123570188879967,
0.2688881456851959,
0.054018519818782806,
0.10615817457437515,
0.7650164365768433,
0.9385064840316772,
-0.5017362236976624,
-0.06300465762615204,
0.6125580668449402,
0.2764814496040344,
0.5475183129310608,
-0.08375008404254913,
0.41162464022636414,
-0.12390200048685074,
-0.2995327413082123,
-0.39792370796203613,
0.1379723846912384,
-0.5975428223609924,
-0.2951350212097168,
-0.3458367884159088,
-0.13999545574188232,
-0.06958916038274765,
-0.35285478830337524,
-0.4306190013885498,
-0.1222158670425415,
-0.46857258677482605,
0.08354701846837997,
0.46863892674446106,
1.3422647714614868,
0.37318935990333557,
0.8938808441162109,
-0.8280776143074036,
0.12514296174049377,
0.2784334719181061,
0.6075119972229004,
0.20720817148685455,
-0.04239272326231003,
-0.661208987236023,
0.3438465893268585,
-0.2211504876613617,
-0.9532437324523926,
0.5085678696632385,
0.2621753215789795,
0.5824766159057617,
0.28269898891448975,
-0.09914862364530563,
0.8168843388557434,
-0.48094335198402405,
1.3021323680877686,
0.14789457619190216,
-1.0365147590637207,
0.5735916495323181,
-0.2016376405954361,
0.43609389662742615,
0.4043255150318146,
0.14989590644836426,
-0.6508410573005676,
-0.3106360137462616,
-0.7811669707298279,
-0.8190270066261292,
1.0241472721099854,
0.5169320106506348,
-0.12271694839000702,
0.097227081656456,
0.4323694109916687,
-0.13115225732326508,
0.7301074862480164,
-0.42481371760368347,
-0.4896363914012909,
0.5828500390052795,
-0.2621282637119293,
-0.3754459023475647,
-0.39992523193359375,
0.029596757143735886,
-0.19624365866184235,
0.7456504106521606,
-0.17358803749084473,
0.0845380648970604,
-0.2924286425113678,
-0.13581351935863495,
-0.21753761172294617,
0.18939146399497986,
0.8730587363243103,
0.8719834089279175,
0.03985576331615448,
0.2801873981952667,
0.29366910457611084,
-0.3883347511291504,
-0.13700243830680847,
-0.445780485868454,
-0.2802959382534027,
0.1798797845840454,
-0.0848597064614296,
0.6514257788658142,
0.23813951015472412,
-0.7898064851760864,
0.27975994348526,
-0.3699253797531128,
0.3950163424015045,
-0.28311535716056824,
-0.12579669058322906,
0.2790893316268921,
0.19287936389446259,
0.15158121287822723,
-0.204396054148674,
0.1580779254436493,
-0.7064225077629089,
0.0988169014453888,
0.6544211506843567,
-0.5206795334815979,
-0.08956944197416306,
0.3250356912612915,
-0.08509600162506104,
-0.8920800685882568,
0.4177856743335724,
-0.0020489159505814314,
-0.39282336831092834,
0.6751177906990051,
0.8366491198539734,
0.6884732246398926,
-0.003049793653190136,
0.18569819629192352,
-0.20302651822566986,
0.7591406106948853,
-0.30408981442451477,
0.30161044001579285,
0.06417565792798996,
-0.392302542924881,
0.013553915545344353,
-0.46206584572792053,
-0.7118079662322998,
0.28602156043052673,
-0.7064475417137146,
0.38390564918518066,
-0.27544376254081726,
-0.3749038875102997,
0.03709468990564346,
0.2562088966369629,
-0.9242629408836365,
0.1969134360551834,
0.12114472687244415,
0.8638779520988464,
-0.8657525777816772,
0.9302260279655457,
1.0499138832092285,
-0.35647180676460266,
-0.6850007176399231,
-0.5504921674728394,
-0.04600326716899872,
-0.30681130290031433,
0.4535663425922394,
-0.1278456151485443,
-0.17520685493946075,
-0.4866936206817627,
-0.3092970848083496,
-0.7922842502593994,
0.9325950145721436,
0.3791554868221283,
-0.7671849727630615,
0.3740079998970032,
0.6530803442001343,
0.9870327115058899,
-0.8817709684371948,
0.07331535965204239,
0.8326835036277771,
0.09265900403261185,
-0.2055383324623108,
-0.8080969452857971,
-0.18410451710224152,
-0.19290176033973694,
0.7498816251754761,
0.19181932508945465,
-0.5961025953292847,
0.7302942872047424,
0.09264053404331207,
-0.14050956070423126,
0.30891838669776917,
0.6670044660568237,
0.1361299753189087,
0.6243764758110046,
0.4534594714641571,
0.21544931828975677,
0.8517178893089294,
0.15984296798706055,
1.2961900234222412,
-0.37422680854797363,
0.5842245817184448,
1.508366584777832,
-0.6591803431510925,
1.1354122161865234,
1.0069804191589355,
-0.30270916223526,
0.5133023858070374,
0.5398633480072021,
0.330662339925766,
0.4396804869174957,
0.30764317512512207,
-0.1495511531829834,
0.12098836153745651,
-0.25550225377082825,
-0.15154345333576202,
-0.11126889288425446,
0.4910717308521271,
-0.3452308475971222,
0.008852328173816204,
0.17156800627708435,
-0.2433323860168457,
0.137719064950943,
-0.572763979434967,
0.8244670629501343,
0.43703216314315796,
-0.20293088257312775,
0.33362457156181335,
0.16320890188217163,
0.41467586159706116,
-0.5408132672309875,
0.09168198704719543,
-0.032503314316272736,
0.4902664124965668,
-0.38294708728790283,
-0.7065801620483398,
0.7747536897659302,
0.03030768409371376,
-0.5381773710250854,
-0.21873976290225983,
1.0900604724884033,
-0.5239324569702148,
-0.6088378429412842,
0.19304797053337097,
0.23432214558124542,
-0.12337242811918259,
0.07735255360603333,
-0.5565529465675354,
0.4231991171836853,
-0.5325865745544434,
-0.012534093111753464,
0.478885293006897,
0.08567894995212555,
-0.1405850648880005,
0.8233428597450256,
0.4001713693141937,
0.15545424818992615,
0.21424849331378937,
0.027251731604337692,
0.38262102007865906,
-0.5736690759658813,
-0.8972733616828918,
-0.8747401833534241,
0.35189783573150635,
-0.2942478358745575,
0.23515969514846802,
1.1377383470535278,
0.7128801345825195,
0.5664137601852417,
-0.33743008971214294,
0.4999903440475464,
0.16659781336784363,
0.3966594934463501,
-0.21853800117969513,
0.5833808183670044,
-0.47230198979377747,
0.6450183391571045,
-0.21657654643058777,
-0.5656754374504089,
0.05356709286570549,
0.6697216033935547,
-0.3948599100112915,
-0.036352191120386124,
0.6003677845001221,
0.6459882259368896,
-0.2585752010345459,
0.5927082896232605,
0.34666091203689575,
0.17943456768989563,
0.20242060720920563,
0.5136748552322388,
0.8495230674743652,
-0.5075330138206482,
0.16470955312252045,
-0.6876357197761536,
0.2282707393169403,
-0.27385619282722473,
-1.1830695867538452,
-0.8429253697395325,
-0.24579176306724548,
-0.3956596851348877,
-0.37883031368255615,
-0.06709747761487961,
1.0933796167373657,
0.9527850151062012,
-0.9533493518829346,
-0.8772547245025635,
-0.24345092475414276,
0.24502798914909363,
-0.44081196188926697,
-0.24347302317619324,
-0.281586229801178,
-0.27312955260276794,
-0.3879825174808502,
0.3497692942619324,
0.23257216811180115,
0.25292208790779114,
-0.42068615555763245,
-0.273218035697937,
-0.18751516938209534,
0.31700974702835083,
0.8132991790771484,
0.3346540331840515,
-0.5613312721252441,
-0.20758795738220215,
-0.2607845366001129,
-0.3072933852672577,
-0.15798582136631012,
1.2993290424346924,
-0.7201087474822998,
0.25393205881118774,
0.28812605142593384,
0.4908629357814789,
0.4973887801170349,
-0.11924146115779877,
0.7406429648399353,
-0.9349772334098816,
0.28721559047698975,
-0.005201159045100212,
0.35863983631134033,
0.38459834456443787,
-0.654238224029541,
0.5439611077308655,
-0.017782727256417274,
-0.4236859083175659,
-1.0853387117385864,
0.2576134204864502,
-0.734868586063385,
-0.08830336481332779,
1.232048749923706,
0.2268199920654297,
-0.23508283495903015,
-0.005704123061150312,
-0.249380961060524,
-0.45612338185310364,
-0.24270868301391602,
0.43089404702186584,
0.8409253358840942,
-0.24052970111370087,
-0.16494719684123993,
-0.8825856447219849,
0.6456368565559387,
0.23324495553970337,
-0.9442102313041687,
-0.021015416830778122,
0.2925964295864105,
0.10700806975364685,
0.1682787984609604,
0.4863685965538025,
0.47790029644966125,
-0.09519001841545105,
-0.44130924344062805,
-0.36093658208847046,
0.18694746494293213,
-0.30365121364593506,
-0.7360396385192871,
0.23320668935775757,
0.37625062465667725,
0.017709633335471153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14808v1
|
Implicit Personalization in Language Models: A Systematic Study
| 2024-05-23T17:18:46 | 2024-05-23T17:18:46 |
Zhijing Jin, Nils Heil, Jiarui Liu, Shehzaad Dhuliawala, Yahang Qi, Bernhard Schölkopf, Rada Mihalcea, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Implicit Personalization (IP) is a phenomenon of language models inferring a
user's background from the implicit cues in the input prompts and tailoring the
response based on this inference. While previous work has touched upon various
instances of this problem, there lacks a unified framework to study this
behavior. This work systematically studies IP through a rigorous mathematical
formulation, a multi-perspective moral reasoning framework, and a set of case
studies. Our theoretical foundation for IP relies on a structural causal model
and introduces a novel method, indirect intervention, to estimate the causal
effect of a mediator variable that cannot be directly intervened upon. Beyond
the technical approach, we also introduce a set of moral reasoning principles
based on three schools of moral philosophy to study when IP may or may not be
ethically appropriate. Equipped with both mathematical and ethical insights, we
present three diverse case studies illustrating the varied nature of the IP
problem and offer recommendations for future research. Our code and data are at
https://github.com/jiarui-liu/IP.
|
[
-0.19974827766418457,
-0.930683970451355,
0.8343692421913147,
0.5022090077400208,
0.11864485591650009,
-0.09990517795085907,
0.10749828815460205,
-0.382066547870636,
-0.24629290401935577,
0.3890243172645569,
-0.5011749267578125,
-0.3746303617954254,
-0.47802549600601196,
-0.003810037625953555,
-0.18540029227733612,
1.2206801176071167,
0.044745512306690216,
0.20641116797924042,
0.031054366379976273,
-0.25562962889671326,
-0.6572038531303406,
-0.5098277926445007,
-1.1288950443267822,
-0.0921611413359642,
0.660918116569519,
0.41350874304771423,
0.2424239218235016,
0.7752634286880493,
0.38231202960014343,
0.3623183071613312,
-0.1681412160396576,
-0.3618954122066498,
-0.6373704671859741,
0.3041938841342926,
-0.5040280222892761,
-0.4394585192203522,
-0.09932007640600204,
0.21105767786502838,
0.7707085013389587,
0.7920689582824707,
0.18456952273845673,
0.223318412899971,
0.015062636695802212,
0.6868254542350769,
-0.7484998106956482,
-0.029386896640062332,
-0.3523928225040436,
0.15527068078517914,
-0.06654662638902664,
-0.06197226047515869,
-0.47077512741088867,
-0.6602860689163208,
0.404331237077713,
-0.5069553256034851,
0.0832396000623703,
0.2193463146686554,
0.5109630227088928,
0.12205098569393158,
-0.6699610948562622,
-0.18240413069725037,
-1.1363476514816284,
0.8376615643501282,
-0.36773303151130676,
0.043387770652770996,
0.5586100816726685,
0.017501717433333397,
0.07426553219556808,
-0.6651697158813477,
-0.4767303466796875,
-0.28212541341781616,
-0.22786596417427063,
0.05927077308297157,
-0.27602118253707886,
0.21598544716835022,
0.3978550434112549,
0.12557746469974518,
-0.10664644092321396,
-0.004217811860144138,
-0.3770247995853424,
0.10229653865098953,
0.446010559797287,
0.14451207220554352,
0.780975341796875,
0.13681186735630035,
-0.2929137051105499,
0.23276980221271515,
-0.9377337098121643,
0.5843654274940491,
0.8758911490440369,
0.006993574555963278,
-0.27670323848724365,
0.6074401140213013,
-0.10477114468812943,
0.494618684053421,
0.4262400269508362,
0.06327389180660248,
-0.07106943428516388,
-0.34372422099113464,
0.03310825675725937,
0.41531166434288025,
0.6789575219154358,
0.1187957152724266,
0.5730175375938416,
0.19488093256950378,
0.1059524342417717,
-0.33946293592453003,
0.12740857899188995,
-0.8011979460716248,
0.10345147550106049,
0.4178946614265442,
-0.4700184762477875,
-0.49653035402297974,
0.21556447446346283,
-0.2586061358451843,
-0.3457252085208893,
-0.39313963055610657,
-0.07442386448383331,
-0.3517644703388214,
-0.23046645522117615,
-0.11542753130197525,
-0.09695464372634888,
0.0833493322134018,
0.1838112622499466,
-0.7464984655380249,
0.28087878227233887,
0.6403598189353943,
0.7601646780967712,
0.003970046062022448,
-0.4437733292579651,
-0.650651752948761,
0.6601018309593201,
-0.25243279337882996,
0.658094048500061,
-0.8809319734573364,
-0.5044999718666077,
0.09419121593236923,
-0.0899428203701973,
0.06443873792886734,
-0.046980760991573334,
0.6767827272415161,
-0.3918384611606598,
0.590364933013916,
-0.39960989356040955,
-0.3552682399749756,
-0.2756039798259735,
-0.10517941415309906,
-0.471596896648407,
0.5315237641334534,
-0.3655361533164978,
-0.96207195520401,
0.27142152190208435,
-0.9839656949043274,
-0.3575224280357361,
0.03254440426826477,
-0.13866600394248962,
-0.28887149691581726,
0.38050898909568787,
-0.2244059145450592,
0.33109408617019653,
-0.2750576138496399,
0.697516143321991,
-0.5726098418235779,
-0.5381706357002258,
0.28096872568130493,
-0.43127042055130005,
0.9261735677719116,
0.06105663999915123,
-0.5109452605247498,
0.24801714718341827,
-0.6896468997001648,
-0.09290914982557297,
0.2645520269870758,
-0.040138475596904755,
-0.8051213622093201,
0.33145812153816223,
-0.12604011595249176,
0.1492101103067398,
0.21736587584018707,
-0.6316620111465454,
0.011887503787875175,
-0.49122974276542664,
0.23240652680397034,
1.2355996370315552,
-0.0033084324095398188,
0.5608924627304077,
-0.16994626820087433,
0.20743337273597717,
0.016300180926918983,
0.2687102258205414,
-0.2961285710334778,
-0.5051018595695496,
-0.4893004894256592,
-0.40221738815307617,
0.047910597175359726,
0.5887112021446228,
-0.22297702729701996,
0.06084376573562622,
-0.10957236588001251,
0.2915324866771698,
-0.22987833619117737,
-0.17119593918323517,
0.8228688836097717,
0.6129617691040039,
0.11210323870182037,
-0.060575611889362335,
-0.18286177515983582,
-1.2332878112792969,
-0.5667769312858582,
-0.5398882627487183,
-0.06637360155582428,
0.8123779892921448,
0.45255357027053833,
0.08405431360006332,
1.0645860433578491,
-0.5735940933227539,
-0.3020046055316925,
-0.01545440312474966,
0.4820316433906555,
0.10734596103429794,
0.7647226452827454,
0.5104939341545105,
-0.9504231810569763,
-0.7289381623268127,
0.07370895892381668,
-0.8775531649589539,
-0.4502589702606201,
-0.14317774772644043,
-0.0516945980489254,
-0.31406477093696594,
0.5108970999717712,
-0.0727524682879448,
0.5139579176902771,
0.4525114893913269,
-0.6058796048164368,
0.40965965390205383,
-0.23226900398731232,
0.14070285856723785,
-1.0246793031692505,
0.2819252014160156,
0.138462632894516,
0.11449626833200455,
-0.8576781153678894,
-0.05000855773687363,
-0.2583709955215454,
-0.07504547387361526,
-0.6936829686164856,
0.9881571531295776,
-0.2582395672798157,
0.21516093611717224,
-0.33444857597351074,
-0.23070035874843597,
-0.09839888662099838,
0.6017739176750183,
-0.08155173063278198,
0.9248400926589966,
0.39321771264076233,
-0.5012728571891785,
0.10945888608694077,
0.036927323788404465,
0.16282321512699127,
0.9870214462280273,
-1.1326299905776978,
0.4016014635562897,
-0.5392457246780396,
0.14689385890960693,
-0.8961047530174255,
-0.23174946010112762,
0.7301896810531616,
-0.21007351577281952,
-0.018671078607439995,
-0.5863443613052368,
-0.2826497554779053,
0.27538400888442993,
-0.46627670526504517,
0.7721007466316223,
0.2542073428630829,
-0.534269392490387,
0.6795564889907837,
0.23396722972393036,
-0.5330967307090759,
-0.6683861613273621,
-0.30283525586128235,
-0.033784572035074234,
-0.42925143241882324,
-0.5682612657546997,
0.5524423122406006,
-0.4322243332862854,
-0.6118678450584412,
0.2637206017971039,
0.11257986724376678,
-0.4244740903377533,
0.23607544600963593,
0.3099218010902405,
-0.05164635181427002,
-0.17235006392002106,
-0.03762759640812874,
0.46303287148475647,
-0.30177807807922363,
0.2476784884929657,
-0.24537862837314606,
0.25064975023269653,
-0.5288899540901184,
-0.5464111566543579,
-0.6932264566421509,
0.8680853247642517,
0.21262143552303314,
-0.2238621711730957,
0.8262205719947815,
0.3020206391811371,
-0.3492472469806671,
0.08368618041276932,
-0.5494356155395508,
0.08062545210123062,
-0.500679612159729,
0.09362883120775223,
-0.473708838224411,
-0.7364764213562012,
0.5127741694450378,
-0.25119146704673767,
-0.2636236250400543,
0.09060007333755493,
0.322713702917099,
-0.2741757333278656,
1.4839493036270142,
0.9849568009376526,
0.0428900383412838,
0.6826356649398804,
0.04364735633134842,
0.18454596400260925,
-1.0576421022415161,
-0.35561150312423706,
-0.4900175929069519,
-0.16046524047851562,
-0.7758792638778687,
0.24631890654563904,
0.30233630537986755,
0.2565724849700928,
-0.7129372358322144,
-0.24974916875362396,
-0.30514082312583923,
0.7567241787910461,
0.7250076532363892,
0.06989142298698425,
0.384024441242218,
-0.15006978809833527,
-0.4017212688922882,
-0.06805843859910965,
-0.2966933846473694,
-0.5637896656990051,
0.8170153498649597,
0.2589746415615082,
0.6177815198898315,
0.45631763339042664,
0.37548020482063293,
0.3826161026954651,
0.4618516266345978,
-0.5019043684005737,
0.4257965087890625,
0.019076675176620483,
-0.8031076192855835,
-0.24094505608081818,
-0.2064865082502365,
-1.043550729751587,
0.12234659492969513,
0.006151452660560608,
-1.1589027643203735,
0.47481945157051086,
0.3023178279399872,
-0.18524537980556488,
0.05623000115156174,
-0.8966355919837952,
0.6197699308395386,
-0.40040549635887146,
-0.9891709089279175,
-0.14570358395576477,
-0.6389493942260742,
0.493264377117157,
-0.2566586136817932,
0.020545167848467827,
-0.25540292263031006,
-0.038015253841876984,
0.2965990900993347,
-0.19762663543224335,
1.2482298612594604,
-0.24039147794246674,
0.0851878896355629,
-0.08942680805921555,
0.10416688770055771,
0.7045393586158752,
0.42237743735313416,
0.10153696686029434,
0.28486761450767517,
-0.16926148533821106,
-0.3227919638156891,
-0.5593486428260803,
0.9442769885063171,
-0.7251591682434082,
-1.0185388326644897,
-0.6744561195373535,
-0.41153717041015625,
-0.1219864934682846,
0.5583276152610779,
0.024532202631235123,
0.16893136501312256,
-0.42946141958236694,
0.2916785776615143,
0.8806905746459961,
-0.6171974539756775,
0.356540709733963,
0.7703691124916077,
-0.06890513002872467,
-0.2824477255344391,
0.8880505561828613,
-0.2147490680217743,
-0.044863421469926834,
0.3025716245174408,
0.74455326795578,
-0.1864021122455597,
-0.42731520533561707,
-0.2486058473587036,
0.33059170842170715,
-0.7675734758377075,
0.3016906678676605,
-0.6886753439903259,
-0.06583871692419052,
-0.009954972192645073,
-0.382367342710495,
-0.21503125131130219,
0.0712023675441742,
-0.30060428380966187,
0.08529196679592133,
0.03961799666285515,
0.8176626563072205,
-0.03142564371228218,
0.3472967743873596,
-0.3658353388309479,
0.1954336315393448,
0.40676242113113403,
0.6118051409721375,
-0.2718929350376129,
-0.18656733632087708,
0.14382271468639374,
0.1692771166563034,
-0.09507099539041519,
-0.7789641618728638,
0.09378911554813385,
0.12274045497179031,
0.6455335021018982,
0.6390210390090942,
-0.053625933825969696,
0.5829216837882996,
-1.003788709640503,
0.5683098435401917,
0.18112461268901825,
-1.3325265645980835,
0.7157744765281677,
-0.49646052718162537,
0.08839740604162216,
0.5088215470314026,
0.6350187659263611,
-0.6412625908851624,
-0.345104455947876,
-0.5832234621047974,
-0.8278608322143555,
0.8384075164794922,
0.3923485279083252,
0.5534542202949524,
0.19434842467308044,
0.5670788288116455,
-0.08300714939832687,
0.3070695102214813,
-1.0160812139511108,
-0.5341253876686096,
-0.11882045120000839,
-0.2624383866786957,
0.28030359745025635,
-0.4740777909755707,
-0.40351900458335876,
-0.10868008434772491,
0.542646050453186,
-0.1660861223936081,
0.2648150324821472,
0.042604394257068634,
0.00024053400557022542,
-0.06973118335008621,
0.05608921870589256,
0.8010760545730591,
0.6812785267829895,
-0.10990852862596512,
0.019694359973073006,
-0.10131540149450302,
-0.22307392954826355,
0.36847618222236633,
0.06957938522100449,
-0.47095760703086853,
-0.2853403091430664,
0.17696864902973175,
0.8252889513969421,
0.15046463906764984,
-0.28270262479782104,
0.7440429329872131,
-0.38116881251335144,
0.2025631219148636,
-0.49866583943367004,
-0.06047438457608223,
-0.2965638339519501,
0.18929697573184967,
0.20210742950439453,
0.014327052049338818,
0.395248144865036,
-0.3744542598724365,
-0.12471289187669754,
0.46198898553848267,
-0.5151920914649963,
-0.7043364644050598,
0.9568408727645874,
0.3770575523376465,
-0.4721083641052246,
0.4865235388278961,
0.19202765822410583,
-0.2198120802640915,
0.5938358306884766,
0.5910536050796509,
1.3115761280059814,
-0.43259865045547485,
0.37569236755371094,
0.20871366560459137,
0.12641480565071106,
0.21542508900165558,
-0.05692412331700325,
-0.09601805359125137,
-0.992864727973938,
-0.570741593837738,
-0.09605218470096588,
-0.4861471354961395,
0.17106392979621887,
-0.4780491888523102,
0.17075058817863464,
-0.6494935154914856,
-0.018216904252767563,
0.04024941846728325,
-0.4514387547969818,
-0.5023475289344788,
0.03618067502975464,
0.016151627525687218,
0.2291705459356308,
-0.7931185364723206,
0.7091168761253357,
0.726126492023468,
-0.5193593502044678,
-0.3407517075538635,
0.45609182119369507,
0.1448068916797638,
-0.8347296118736267,
1.268857717514038,
0.038152191787958145,
-0.5705317258834839,
0.021391432732343674,
-0.7384161353111267,
-0.9430509805679321,
0.6618168950080872,
0.5480181574821472,
-0.029502710327506065,
0.1370912790298462,
0.16890700161457062,
0.5961114764213562,
-0.4105832576751709,
0.288592666387558,
0.1293775886297226,
0.4519125521183014,
-0.1312505602836609,
-0.3041364252567291,
0.12705405056476593,
-0.5145429968833923,
0.4267244338989258,
-0.0954241082072258,
-0.6767708659172058,
0.5556327104568481,
-0.2608197033405304,
-0.22080449759960175,
-0.14512266218662262,
0.4289483428001404,
0.3289088308811188,
0.2904965579509735,
0.3591112196445465,
-0.120577871799469,
0.5083522200584412,
-0.011374139226973057,
1.3014496564865112,
-0.6224291920661926,
0.08162269741296768,
1.1615418195724487,
-0.4267566502094269,
0.20947034657001495,
0.583419919013977,
0.22293922305107117,
0.5533711314201355,
0.36953020095825195,
0.21986673772335052,
0.6467642188072205,
0.18279001116752625,
-0.5416536331176758,
0.2509707510471344,
-0.7232971787452698,
-0.26850688457489014,
0.3166780471801758,
0.22526825964450836,
-0.45684128999710083,
0.25389328598976135,
-0.09727396816015244,
0.3340965211391449,
-0.040815506130456924,
-0.004887685179710388,
0.8603190779685974,
-0.06535565108060837,
-0.5180385708808899,
-0.037675779312849045,
0.4032110869884491,
0.2854878008365631,
-0.6675897836685181,
-0.3797256350517273,
-0.46350687742233276,
-0.0008760414202697575,
-0.005801045801490545,
-0.6932472586631775,
0.2693026661872864,
0.14051365852355957,
-0.23805376887321472,
-0.6965493559837341,
0.6605516076087952,
-0.1868564784526825,
-0.43617191910743713,
0.19739361107349396,
0.4623757302761078,
-0.18907037377357483,
0.15747196972370148,
-0.8279924988746643,
-0.1490408331155777,
-0.11223192512989044,
-0.2983929514884949,
0.17634734511375427,
0.4781230092048645,
-0.24206173419952393,
0.8299474716186523,
1.059218406677246,
0.1199539452791214,
-0.21578828990459442,
0.061230678111314774,
0.666628897190094,
-0.6764360070228577,
-0.5281867384910583,
-1.0917428731918335,
0.6869152188301086,
-0.1869215965270996,
-0.4928286373615265,
0.5917081832885742,
0.35156160593032837,
0.8529473543167114,
-0.022198738530278206,
0.8939642906188965,
0.13211867213249207,
0.08242063224315643,
-0.5143952965736389,
0.46189194917678833,
-0.38623887300491333,
0.5050956606864929,
-0.47965946793556213,
-0.8408435583114624,
-0.2783167362213135,
0.5133216977119446,
-0.4763775169849396,
0.15826566517353058,
0.7599257230758667,
0.34332290291786194,
-0.025520561262965202,
-0.05295770242810249,
0.3261766731739044,
0.24823887646198273,
0.40396299958229065,
0.12356805801391602,
1.1487005949020386,
0.05185984820127487,
0.18422086536884308,
-0.39182284474372864,
-0.25994399189949036,
0.09171320497989655,
-1.147579312324524,
-0.7966108322143555,
-0.6474594473838806,
-0.29725173115730286,
-0.19245615601539612,
0.34775882959365845,
0.7707667946815491,
0.6973183751106262,
-0.7995631098747253,
-0.3253103792667389,
-0.3184417188167572,
0.5201935172080994,
-0.12518177926540375,
-0.2613010108470917,
0.36030063033103943,
-0.04548349231481552,
-1.1682289838790894,
0.22584395110607147,
0.4596867859363556,
0.1434905081987381,
-0.2355649769306183,
0.12305223941802979,
-0.18566925823688507,
0.3113294541835785,
0.7095575928688049,
0.3719162940979004,
-0.6284428238868713,
-0.5124719142913818,
-0.14354565739631653,
0.12506258487701416,
0.15892329812049866,
1.1311687231063843,
-0.41130542755126953,
0.5456081628799438,
0.3114660680294037,
0.6164005398750305,
0.2771727740764618,
0.12778951227664948,
0.9987653493881226,
-0.7800174355506897,
0.3312673568725586,
0.23847754299640656,
0.36527374386787415,
0.024419086053967476,
-0.7714203000068665,
0.40766504406929016,
0.3576447069644928,
-0.2304050624370575,
-0.8381198644638062,
0.5474509596824646,
-0.4464209973812103,
-0.34549564123153687,
1.1869451999664307,
-0.3100159764289856,
-0.042617205530405045,
-0.3441944718360901,
-0.3665982782840729,
-0.16068044304847717,
-0.5748199224472046,
0.7328304052352905,
0.6907714605331421,
-0.2883480191230774,
0.05460890009999275,
-0.4873690903186798,
0.4750441908836365,
0.3798007369041443,
-0.843816339969635,
-0.31515198945999146,
0.5294686555862427,
0.4760916829109192,
-0.03629523515701294,
0.7230391502380371,
0.06657528132200241,
0.045450590550899506,
-0.39211732149124146,
-0.02951807901263237,
-0.10583429783582687,
-0.4489954113960266,
-0.49041908979415894,
0.1730233132839203,
-0.09342258423566818,
0.013847174122929573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14804v1
|
Can LLMs Solve longer Math Word Problems Better?
| 2024-05-23T17:13:50 | 2024-05-23T17:13:50 |
Xin Xu, Tong Xiao, Zitong Chao, Zhenya Huang, Can Yang, Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Math Word Problems (MWPs) are crucial for evaluating the capability of Large
Language Models (LLMs), with current research primarily focusing on questions
with concise contexts. However, as real-world math problems often involve
complex circumstances, LLMs' ability to solve long MWPs is vital for their
applications in these scenarios, yet remains under-explored. This study
pioneers the exploration of Context Length Generalizability (CoLeG), the
ability of LLMs to solve long MWPs. We introduce Extended Grade-School Math
(E-GSM), a collection of MWPs with lengthy narratives. Two novel metrics are
proposed to assess the efficacy and resilience of LLMs in solving these
problems. Our examination of existing zero-shot prompting techniques and both
proprietary and open-source LLMs reveals a general deficiency in CoLeG. To
alleviate these challenges, we propose distinct approaches for different
categories of LLMs. For proprietary LLMs, a new instructional prompt is
proposed to mitigate the influence of long context. For open-source LLMs, a new
data augmentation task is developed to improve CoLeG. Our comprehensive results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed methods, showing not only
improved performance on E-GSM but also generalizability across several other
MWP benchmarks. Our findings pave the way for future research in employing LLMs
for complex, real-world applications, offering practical solutions to current
limitations and opening avenues for further exploration of model
generalizability and training methodologies.
|
[
-0.2782823443412781,
-1.080496907234192,
0.9791430830955505,
0.43234220147132874,
-0.3213104009628296,
0.28839945793151855,
-0.629472553730011,
-0.4868505895137787,
0.033505529165267944,
0.016480760648846626,
-0.6213663816452026,
-0.6242687106132507,
-0.712040364742279,
0.21143071353435516,
-0.17070595920085907,
0.630588173866272,
-0.4118788540363312,
0.01277276873588562,
-0.7197818756103516,
-0.25058457255363464,
-0.5915795564651489,
-0.7003749012947083,
-0.5479370951652527,
-0.3355022370815277,
0.5648565888404846,
0.32923606038093567,
0.6956193447113037,
0.4622839391231537,
0.7842334508895874,
0.21205607056617737,
-0.205339714884758,
0.24310177564620972,
-0.4747203290462494,
0.12611280381679535,
0.137655109167099,
-0.4831945598125458,
-0.4995582699775696,
0.040402162820100784,
0.6081768274307251,
1.121647596359253,
-0.1578739434480667,
0.18083493411540985,
0.019294695928692818,
0.8334373831748962,
-0.42176172137260437,
0.13470576703548431,
-0.39678242802619934,
0.27846163511276245,
-0.02141278237104416,
-0.2450161725282669,
-0.27169543504714966,
-0.18847668170928955,
0.2747648060321808,
-0.7942572236061096,
-0.11568575352430344,
0.025260960683226585,
0.6383243799209595,
0.0421212837100029,
-0.47414329648017883,
-0.7726521492004395,
-0.8874500393867493,
1.1172055006027222,
-0.613981306552887,
0.3870474398136139,
0.20222610235214233,
0.33656740188598633,
-0.39038971066474915,
-0.500748336315155,
-0.2233951836824417,
-0.3110714554786682,
0.18687587976455688,
0.2701050341129303,
-0.2699821889400482,
0.1492297202348709,
0.5259131193161011,
0.22700896859169006,
-0.5078670382499695,
0.23383817076683044,
-0.40472733974456787,
-0.16592766344547272,
0.3876791000366211,
0.43451938033103943,
0.37866318225860596,
0.038723837584257126,
-0.29814523458480835,
0.2620517909526825,
-0.9208305478096008,
0.2926108241081238,
0.255058228969574,
0.07160531729459763,
-0.19572728872299194,
0.5627673864364624,
-0.04913705959916115,
0.8878804445266724,
-0.6309821009635925,
-0.35166478157043457,
-0.015275286510586739,
0.023038364946842194,
-0.27041095495224,
-0.2872590720653534,
0.24750050902366638,
0.36198076605796814,
0.5154365301132202,
-0.2103339284658432,
-0.04314520210027695,
0.04091883450746536,
-0.22370582818984985,
-0.7026187777519226,
0.317758172750473,
0.07251297682523727,
-0.11667138338088989,
0.07609707862138748,
-0.26645535230636597,
-0.35193899273872375,
0.020840417593717575,
-0.6486735939979553,
0.30419400334358215,
-0.44505774974823,
0.1971454620361328,
0.340259313583374,
0.00012391051859594882,
0.17823055386543274,
0.2722565829753876,
-0.6260308623313904,
0.12494772672653198,
0.952511191368103,
1.1357643604278564,
-0.22995799779891968,
-0.13695277273654938,
-0.4806305468082428,
0.1878884881734848,
-0.5469471216201782,
0.5025717616081238,
-0.651375412940979,
-0.709646999835968,
0.06839077174663544,
-0.14419691264629364,
0.0075010317377746105,
-0.6179248690605164,
0.7226129174232483,
-0.39849263429641724,
0.371000736951828,
-0.2035299390554428,
-0.8061944246292114,
0.22564758360385895,
0.5461989045143127,
-0.3203529417514801,
0.8173713088035583,
0.14542430639266968,
-0.37948212027549744,
0.019543852657079697,
-0.6155359745025635,
-0.17073452472686768,
0.1362518072128296,
-0.2478594034910202,
-0.2875419855117798,
0.5840032696723938,
0.27511265873908997,
0.3926220238208771,
-0.3840954601764679,
0.3794265389442444,
-0.35387730598449707,
-0.5701375603675842,
-0.0680776834487915,
-0.5157400965690613,
0.47495174407958984,
0.12808826565742493,
0.06430116295814514,
-0.11885713040828705,
-0.6065845489501953,
0.32998132705688477,
0.3160076141357422,
-0.4693675935268402,
-0.4684099555015564,
0.0839722752571106,
-0.4511248469352722,
0.02491743303835392,
0.23796077072620392,
-0.6045120358467102,
0.26297080516815186,
-0.35857275128364563,
0.4745761454105377,
0.7795169949531555,
-0.40477386116981506,
0.506163477897644,
-0.3891717195510864,
0.739791989326477,
-0.30401942133903503,
-0.06550886482000351,
-0.5623679757118225,
-0.3622976541519165,
-0.7518817186355591,
-0.31136786937713623,
0.25131481885910034,
0.5358784198760986,
-0.6848753690719604,
0.15748125314712524,
-0.6013370752334595,
-0.17548412084579468,
0.1433815062046051,
0.1315823197364807,
0.40812379121780396,
0.6620620489120483,
0.4744414687156677,
-0.07685337215662003,
-0.36575424671173096,
-0.8090715408325195,
-0.6075841188430786,
0.17662625014781952,
-0.48161083459854126,
0.5105772614479065,
0.2793777585029602,
-0.2702471613883972,
1.305771827697754,
-0.7653380036354065,
-0.3549196422100067,
-0.11136562377214432,
0.08758721500635147,
0.18533220887184143,
-0.02130659855902195,
0.4555610120296478,
-0.29679998755455017,
-0.41344335675239563,
-0.4382704794406891,
-0.7966300845146179,
-0.36041849851608276,
0.05250389873981476,
0.17632395029067993,
0.17115990817546844,
0.39632755517959595,
-0.3628230392932892,
0.372080534696579,
0.6047346591949463,
-0.21711458265781403,
0.684198796749115,
-0.37802058458328247,
-0.36545222997665405,
-0.9148597121238708,
-0.34766846895217896,
0.26377418637275696,
-0.22048595547676086,
-0.5940918922424316,
0.13491734862327576,
0.24897092580795288,
-0.45820268988609314,
-0.4287036061286926,
0.5972433686256409,
-0.6997626423835754,
-0.1850437968969345,
-0.31758278608322144,
0.2959310710430145,
-0.07168552279472351,
0.3377878963947296,
-0.18931138515472412,
0.8063490986824036,
0.3788846433162689,
-0.5833039283752441,
0.5088793635368347,
-0.22709277272224426,
-0.3131881058216095,
0.5950887203216553,
-0.7143375277519226,
0.14403270184993744,
-0.3525456190109253,
0.488256573677063,
-0.767008364200592,
-0.12808282673358917,
-0.14903447031974792,
-0.39271196722984314,
0.13089539110660553,
-0.018457923084497452,
-0.48334938287734985,
-0.5921151638031006,
-0.3300129175186157,
0.4584721326828003,
0.6521340608596802,
-0.6714668869972229,
0.39624345302581787,
-0.09710879623889923,
-0.36281818151474,
-0.4227267801761627,
-0.4985073506832123,
0.3178742527961731,
-0.36026135087013245,
-0.8905329704284668,
0.36900594830513,
-0.3493109345436096,
-0.3745540380477905,
-0.1890305131673813,
-0.28924575448036194,
-0.02322877198457718,
0.12652230262756348,
-0.019983038306236267,
0.4162670075893402,
-0.10641158372163773,
0.37798812985420227,
0.07460697740316391,
-0.18870466947555542,
0.24138201773166656,
-0.06564230471849442,
0.5929610133171082,
-0.22507940232753754,
-0.44735750555992126,
0.0332452617585659,
0.40853795409202576,
0.19656707346439362,
0.061213795095682144,
0.3371891379356384,
0.3368132412433624,
-0.43977248668670654,
-0.39118149876594543,
-0.4081319570541382,
0.044703882187604904,
-0.551798403263092,
0.346825510263443,
-0.3175221085548401,
-1.4022865295410156,
0.4969155490398407,
-0.4964098334312439,
0.08905383944511414,
0.012124487198889256,
0.18356700241565704,
-0.12552517652511597,
1.0139729976654053,
0.6917884945869446,
-0.04634721204638481,
0.3490180969238281,
-0.10404098778963089,
0.2971220910549164,
-1.0117006301879883,
-0.30185389518737793,
-0.06184159219264984,
-0.3331642746925354,
-0.1937149316072464,
-0.48633909225463867,
0.5739378333091736,
0.29027101397514343,
0.07458387315273285,
0.023030323907732964,
-0.3613768517971039,
0.8727871179580688,
-0.06107890605926514,
-0.18754836916923523,
0.3384135365486145,
0.23577740788459778,
-0.316867470741272,
-0.38497018814086914,
-0.41026610136032104,
-0.39870741963386536,
0.990919291973114,
0.4481816291809082,
0.7242323756217957,
0.21623529493808746,
0.6113945841789246,
0.028580447658896446,
0.38621240854263306,
-1.262149453163147,
0.5995798110961914,
0.02108985371887684,
-0.3789192736148834,
-0.44361206889152527,
-0.5280241370201111,
-1.0485472679138184,
0.19507303833961487,
0.11752617359161377,
-0.6852849721908569,
-0.3173362910747528,
-0.11713353544473648,
-0.23938775062561035,
0.24962842464447021,
-0.6001453399658203,
0.18598222732543945,
-0.36560893058776855,
-0.25959569215774536,
0.09041960537433624,
-0.3026704788208008,
0.3470616936683655,
-0.1615421026945114,
0.6527647376060486,
-0.51133793592453,
-0.3779309093952179,
0.6654279828071594,
-0.5681146383285522,
0.5148898363113403,
0.032094430178403854,
-0.5197243690490723,
0.36592692136764526,
0.003114754566922784,
0.5217800140380859,
0.038516514003276825,
0.17536821961402893,
0.1574191004037857,
-0.24538755416870117,
-0.477893590927124,
-0.8724608421325684,
0.9844850897789001,
-0.4346821904182434,
-0.9052097797393799,
-0.3991536498069763,
-0.7725880146026611,
-0.5169986486434937,
0.033709943294525146,
0.02904125675559044,
0.6449047327041626,
0.02444896288216114,
0.39580386877059937,
0.5960595011711121,
-0.2181367576122284,
0.8987478613853455,
0.6017515063285828,
-0.3157726228237152,
-0.3869873285293579,
0.9636256694793701,
0.4066057801246643,
0.27745354175567627,
0.03912637382745743,
0.4867464005947113,
-0.22002200782299042,
-0.44214901328086853,
-0.43222615122795105,
0.12007047981023788,
-0.6930479407310486,
-0.18349449336528778,
-0.2994745373725891,
-0.2791377604007721,
-0.0873369500041008,
-0.5855205655097961,
0.04174978658556938,
-0.4695229232311249,
-0.3499317765235901,
-0.05579081550240517,
0.28868094086647034,
0.33420246839523315,
-0.08486014604568481,
0.29537448287010193,
-0.823092520236969,
0.3249801993370056,
0.481414258480072,
0.5494540929794312,
-0.03485708683729172,
-0.6240572333335876,
-0.10561108589172363,
0.027631735429167747,
-0.3398626446723938,
-0.6272345781326294,
0.3250373303890228,
0.25608471035957336,
0.28109726309776306,
0.21842139959335327,
-0.18209552764892578,
1.0307426452636719,
-0.7835953831672668,
0.7953662276268005,
0.5159892439842224,
-1.0512092113494873,
0.24641099572181702,
-0.541756272315979,
0.44086867570877075,
0.10022928565740585,
0.5182836055755615,
-0.6836053133010864,
-0.1321384161710739,
-0.2780013382434845,
-1.024810791015625,
0.40879586338996887,
0.25561007857322693,
0.5210282206535339,
-0.07488560676574707,
0.6740024089813232,
-0.16908925771713257,
-0.05693399906158447,
-0.4186825752258301,
-0.2496747076511383,
0.13265632092952728,
-0.17741452157497406,
-0.15367454290390015,
-0.381668359041214,
-0.1367083638906479,
-0.3803161382675171,
0.19921623170375824,
-0.16729450225830078,
0.198432058095932,
0.17071662843227386,
-0.15671025216579437,
0.0634685680270195,
0.7341861724853516,
0.9495914578437805,
1.0785261392593384,
-0.10519220679998398,
0.029215160757303238,
0.5806589722633362,
-0.4632808268070221,
0.29644984006881714,
-0.11619450896978378,
0.040430277585983276,
0.05280512943863869,
0.38497665524482727,
0.45138993859291077,
0.21594950556755066,
-0.8430330157279968,
0.5832577347755432,
-0.03960273414850235,
-0.3883321285247803,
-0.7061560153961182,
-0.06279116123914719,
0.2998795211315155,
-0.11866990476846695,
0.7138237357139587,
-0.5693678259849548,
-0.05242922157049179,
-0.6160995960235596,
-0.10445114225149155,
0.6863829493522644,
-0.3299788534641266,
-0.17667244374752045,
0.35285866260528564,
0.12837202847003937,
-0.678058385848999,
0.36532101035118103,
-0.03808867186307907,
-0.44056999683380127,
1.0812084674835205,
0.9478411078453064,
0.4497365951538086,
0.00035150142502970994,
0.0584038607776165,
0.16658353805541992,
0.15110938251018524,
-0.1163930743932724,
0.16473014652729034,
0.004512165207415819,
-0.5470793843269348,
-0.6001685261726379,
-0.48704755306243896,
-0.6250191330909729,
0.27907776832580566,
-0.5889222621917725,
0.328898549079895,
-0.7259923219680786,
-0.13207118213176727,
-0.4130699932575226,
0.09754148870706558,
-0.5534518957138062,
0.3515518605709076,
0.2984357178211212,
0.790398120880127,
-0.42173469066619873,
0.5166886448860168,
0.5253406763076782,
0.35462823510169983,
-0.8246847987174988,
-0.21856887638568878,
0.009577786549925804,
-0.8422855138778687,
0.5635766386985779,
0.4422030448913574,
-0.2098572850227356,
0.04643140360713005,
-0.6454440951347351,
-0.7846657037734985,
1.377651333808899,
0.33359286189079285,
-0.899992048740387,
-0.19901405274868011,
0.4848354160785675,
0.6425538659095764,
-0.33646294474601746,
0.3117218017578125,
0.4834724962711334,
0.32350730895996094,
0.25390902161598206,
-0.7820040583610535,
-0.12260155379772186,
0.10611487179994583,
0.21998915076255798,
0.40053969621658325,
-0.7014887928962708,
0.6321786642074585,
-0.30406633019447327,
-0.2784336805343628,
0.12797321379184723,
0.6863316297531128,
0.4965931475162506,
0.6908951997756958,
0.2774870693683624,
0.8293659687042236,
0.7223087549209595,
-0.20146983861923218,
0.9165767431259155,
-0.25040724873542786,
0.5977209806442261,
1.1494662761688232,
-0.1348261833190918,
0.5547448396682739,
0.33940765261650085,
-0.2135898768901825,
0.41020095348358154,
0.4258662760257721,
0.048893239349126816,
0.07054441422224045,
0.7846022844314575,
-0.5194481015205383,
-0.27960166335105896,
-0.016633329913020134,
-0.5879330039024353,
0.2435178905725479,
0.5881819128990173,
-0.21939538419246674,
-0.5632410645484924,
0.1500062495470047,
0.3238523602485657,
0.12980103492736816,
-0.5130794644355774,
0.29742899537086487,
0.5018484592437744,
-0.28476837277412415,
0.47839418053627014,
0.34375622868537903,
1.0446083545684814,
-0.716098964214325,
0.19236218929290771,
-0.3456880748271942,
-0.09402868896722794,
-0.16868601739406586,
-0.5164408683776855,
0.2970506250858307,
0.15188533067703247,
-0.04961781948804855,
-0.1823856681585312,
0.7647355198860168,
-0.39736923575401306,
-0.6873759627342224,
0.2668173015117645,
0.6220014691352844,
-0.06440936774015427,
0.2158619910478592,
-0.39099010825157166,
0.06210264191031456,
-0.41421422362327576,
-0.10647184401750565,
0.42206504940986633,
0.2872007489204407,
-0.12191823124885559,
0.9867071509361267,
0.7942039370536804,
0.0005455492646433413,
0.12784996628761292,
-0.02388121746480465,
0.8882907032966614,
-0.782497763633728,
-0.17354221642017365,
-1.1535732746124268,
0.06306444108486176,
-0.050823599100112915,
-0.1820688098669052,
0.9399247765541077,
0.6723424196243286,
0.8496236801147461,
0.06703606247901917,
0.5641464591026306,
0.4850848317146301,
0.3866923749446869,
-0.527691662311554,
0.2556326687335968,
-0.5217452049255371,
0.46506181359291077,
-0.09443918615579605,
-1.1021853685379028,
-0.562148928642273,
0.30334994196891785,
-0.5834961533546448,
-0.11100105196237564,
0.7764140367507935,
0.2795184552669525,
-0.0735974833369255,
-0.08886824548244476,
0.6588532328605652,
-0.4389728605747223,
0.5178208947181702,
0.8598212003707886,
0.9989585280418396,
-0.09027066081762314,
0.7518924474716187,
-0.0554228238761425,
-0.2056894600391388,
-0.08496156334877014,
-0.987442135810852,
-1.043670654296875,
-0.04001127555966377,
-0.07078349590301514,
0.05404704809188843,
-0.027892792597413063,
0.845547080039978,
0.3025978207588196,
-0.2187398374080658,
-0.07724389433860779,
-0.03185483440756798,
0.2067604959011078,
0.3730385899543762,
-0.26227959990501404,
0.1970258355140686,
-0.4775853753089905,
-0.717786431312561,
0.505364716053009,
0.4282580018043518,
0.29840755462646484,
-0.03904082626104355,
-0.03844018280506134,
0.49578240513801575,
0.5527002811431885,
1.0205625295639038,
0.30901071429252625,
-0.6851581931114197,
-0.4650285840034485,
0.22067178785800934,
-0.018219586461782455,
0.06390304118394852,
1.1067370176315308,
-0.6261892914772034,
0.39230120182037354,
0.32590174674987793,
0.6079902052879333,
0.16057045757770538,
0.13987098634243011,
0.31587111949920654,
-0.8016764521598816,
0.10977295786142349,
0.2931584119796753,
0.44845396280288696,
0.16682760417461395,
-0.2431795597076416,
0.45911484956741333,
0.3108617663383484,
-0.4147799611091614,
-0.7552934885025024,
0.5821357369422913,
-0.7653570771217346,
-0.31938496232032776,
1.43747079372406,
-0.36373284459114075,
-0.21812786161899567,
0.14352655410766602,
0.0013550006551668048,
-0.18323031067848206,
-0.19334115087985992,
0.6711556911468506,
1.1589395999908447,
-0.15406498312950134,
0.0623476542532444,
-0.4300920069217682,
0.19285409152507782,
0.6702655553817749,
-0.8744605183601379,
-0.2122541218996048,
0.5979338884353638,
0.420488178730011,
0.06930460780858994,
0.5612069368362427,
-0.15696629881858826,
-0.09970377385616302,
-0.51622474193573,
-0.468193382024765,
-0.5078136324882507,
-0.43714702129364014,
-0.53495854139328,
0.12390576303005219,
-0.13430561125278473,
0.15757037699222565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14782v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14782v2
|
Lessons from the Trenches on Reproducible Evaluation of Language Models
| 2024-05-23T16:50:49 | 2024-05-29T17:15:53 |
Stella Biderman, Hailey Schoelkopf, Lintang Sutawika, Leo Gao, Jonathan Tow, Baber Abbasi, Alham Fikri Aji, Pawan Sasanka Ammanamanchi, Sidney Black, Jordan Clive, Anthony DiPofi, Julen Etxaniz, Benjamin Fattori, Jessica Zosa Forde, Charles Foster, Jeffrey Hsu, Mimansa Jaiswal, Wilson Y. Lee, Haonan Li, Charles Lovering, Niklas Muennighoff, Ellie Pavlick, Jason Phang, Aviya Skowron, Samson Tan, Xiangru Tang, Kevin A. Wang, Genta Indra Winata, François Yvon, Andy Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effective evaluation of language models remains an open challenge in NLP.
Researchers and engineers face methodological issues such as the sensitivity of
models to evaluation setup, difficulty of proper comparisons across methods,
and the lack of reproducibility and transparency. In this paper we draw on
three years of experience in evaluating large language models to provide
guidance and lessons for researchers. First, we provide an overview of common
challenges faced in language model evaluation. Second, we delineate best
practices for addressing or lessening the impact of these challenges on
research. Third, we present the Language Model Evaluation Harness (lm-eval): an
open source library for independent, reproducible, and extensible evaluation of
language models that seeks to address these issues. We describe the features of
the library as well as case studies in which the library has been used to
alleviate these methodological concerns.
|
[
-0.22191385924816132,
-0.7598046660423279,
0.5019345283508301,
0.519426703453064,
0.20556554198265076,
0.12656372785568237,
-0.3632737696170807,
-0.47446924448013306,
-0.34351345896720886,
0.5457456111907959,
-0.25821563601493835,
-0.29586777091026306,
-0.431561142206192,
0.08978491276502609,
-0.5664724707603455,
0.9366363883018494,
-0.41974687576293945,
0.07773559540510178,
-0.156781867146492,
-0.3266216218471527,
-0.43285873532295227,
-0.6872587203979492,
-0.5286234617233276,
-0.46302327513694763,
0.4401448965072632,
0.041473813354969025,
0.7095641493797302,
0.43282705545425415,
0.6453657746315002,
0.21706555783748627,
-0.2576110064983368,
-0.21114632487297058,
-0.4916260540485382,
0.26774388551712036,
-0.29859352111816406,
-0.11964679509401321,
-0.17138352990150452,
0.07497508823871613,
0.7584390044212341,
0.9211331009864807,
-0.32922762632369995,
0.1899273693561554,
0.14398732781410217,
0.66897052526474,
-0.7788280248641968,
0.20905126631259918,
-0.4306936264038086,
0.005081270355731249,
-0.07000967115163803,
-0.0651707872748375,
-0.7040384411811829,
-0.40438729524612427,
0.1910947859287262,
-0.31599941849708557,
0.09397775679826736,
-0.10336978733539581,
0.7865389585494995,
-0.06857402622699738,
-0.2237733006477356,
-0.39379456639289856,
-0.9401538372039795,
0.966962456703186,
-0.853537917137146,
0.5658330321311951,
0.4602111876010895,
0.5762887597084045,
-0.13272903859615326,
-0.8748583793640137,
-0.20901651680469513,
-0.42796897888183594,
0.10637380927801132,
-0.20835532248020172,
-0.33343034982681274,
-0.2578614354133606,
0.12666171789169312,
0.3540753722190857,
-0.5599210858345032,
0.299434095621109,
-0.5336575508117676,
-0.023769399151206017,
0.67181396484375,
0.027861937880516052,
0.22701449692249298,
-0.08453565090894699,
-0.18240079283714294,
-0.09471198916435242,
-0.7069965600967407,
-0.22621528804302216,
0.554430365562439,
0.3283834159374237,
-0.010968508198857307,
0.5776349306106567,
-0.11310970783233643,
0.5905289649963379,
-0.5135478973388672,
0.11807931959629059,
0.4849013388156891,
-0.1732434779405594,
-0.06267332285642624,
-0.5589442849159241,
0.6004606485366821,
0.18052220344543457,
0.18692992627620697,
-0.4376707375049591,
-0.6271817684173584,
-0.22240373492240906,
0.47687357664108276,
-0.427348792552948,
-0.1951148360967636,
0.3258892893791199,
-0.5675076842308044,
-0.3226621150970459,
-0.3241628408432007,
-0.7699882984161377,
-0.3559325933456421,
-0.16302497684955597,
0.5941347479820251,
-0.26122355461120605,
-0.5660423636436462,
0.10527446866035461,
-0.27119189500808716,
0.22308585047721863,
0.24638719856739044,
-0.7457956075668335,
0.5623346567153931,
0.9553472995758057,
0.9482778906822205,
-0.15885134041309357,
-0.42443856596946716,
-0.3837542235851288,
-0.40761813521385193,
-0.2963480055332184,
0.5021873712539673,
-0.31019070744514465,
-0.35472267866134644,
0.21287976205348969,
0.01777438446879387,
-0.06567586958408356,
-0.542741596698761,
0.7777745723724365,
-0.40874871611595154,
0.23157013952732086,
0.14099591970443726,
-0.7231309413909912,
0.004124701488763094,
0.06629382818937302,
-0.6776198744773865,
0.9979332089424133,
0.42851266264915466,
-0.8874626159667969,
-0.17882737517356873,
-0.6734831929206848,
0.022254005074501038,
0.0719609335064888,
-0.07570227980613708,
-0.38095077872276306,
0.36880502104759216,
-0.05662890151143074,
0.186817929148674,
-0.174691841006279,
0.37545689940452576,
-0.21750546991825104,
-0.09198212623596191,
0.15264490246772766,
-0.3887994587421417,
1.072285771369934,
0.3193950057029724,
-0.23254650831222534,
0.23684170842170715,
-0.8278413414955139,
0.11132405698299408,
0.25759389996528625,
-0.1027350202202797,
-0.5062185525894165,
0.09821544587612152,
0.2809966206550598,
-0.01889985427260399,
-0.059860099107027054,
-0.3435349464416504,
0.1207863837480545,
-0.47217315435409546,
0.46695494651794434,
0.6963207125663757,
-0.2583034932613373,
0.3849112093448639,
-0.2508062720298767,
0.7750735282897949,
-0.6179941296577454,
0.2535223066806793,
-0.3211641013622284,
-0.36580631136894226,
-0.5657697916030884,
0.10968486964702606,
0.4911295175552368,
0.31989431381225586,
-0.6127102971076965,
0.14412634074687958,
0.03097110241651535,
-0.9120814204216003,
-0.7649767994880676,
0.10902411490678787,
0.33283308148384094,
0.5376898646354675,
0.2551780939102173,
-0.3133563995361328,
-0.5206230282783508,
-1.0756969451904297,
-0.2920498549938202,
-0.21241889894008636,
-0.14466501772403717,
0.2130025327205658,
0.8653948903083801,
-0.02369673177599907,
0.8746659755706787,
-0.24694660305976868,
0.19077493250370026,
-0.22432537376880646,
0.5338127017021179,
0.034210704267024994,
0.5952321290969849,
0.4197635352611542,
-0.6027961373329163,
-0.10604593902826309,
0.0644306093454361,
-0.8333374857902527,
-0.34266671538352966,
0.18606115877628326,
0.05999279022216797,
0.17606201767921448,
0.5227271914482117,
-0.3938327431678772,
0.16520999372005463,
0.7972993850708008,
-0.17792171239852905,
0.9651154279708862,
-0.04287275671958923,
0.08785737305879593,
-0.505532443523407,
0.3692007064819336,
-0.08095864951610565,
-0.17240625619888306,
-0.6805556416511536,
0.602362334728241,
0.24433206021785736,
-0.26681044697761536,
-0.5441620349884033,
0.7162648439407349,
-0.3572479486465454,
-0.09020131081342697,
-0.19711944460868835,
0.2702789604663849,
0.21793001890182495,
-0.0777064636349678,
0.1515268087387085,
0.5791482925415039,
0.3186034858226776,
-0.29752317070961,
0.2554944157600403,
0.04917927831411362,
-0.8252112865447998,
0.22457018494606018,
-0.9111828207969666,
0.4312800467014313,
0.11888954043388367,
-0.0026151644997298717,
-0.4873645305633545,
0.22156323492527008,
0.17615772783756256,
-0.23530425131320953,
0.4097530245780945,
-0.22428517043590546,
-0.35446053743362427,
-0.2947176694869995,
-0.40779387950897217,
0.32227545976638794,
0.42391330003738403,
-0.38083991408348083,
0.31124347448349,
0.46032628417015076,
-0.4370972812175751,
-0.8025928735733032,
-0.4489186108112335,
0.012512747198343277,
-0.1804063469171524,
-0.6101782917976379,
0.023338153958320618,
-0.14497984945774078,
-0.6601300239562988,
0.11104872077703476,
0.013945694081485271,
-0.2567422389984131,
0.4601890742778778,
0.03270360827445984,
0.0028208757285028696,
-0.38082757592201233,
0.21090304851531982,
-0.4227655231952667,
-0.03038184717297554,
0.17181344330310822,
0.18277139961719513,
0.3471634089946747,
-0.24694618582725525,
-0.5799657106399536,
0.02765653468668461,
0.479792982339859,
0.15075060725212097,
-0.24770161509513855,
0.6832062602043152,
0.3326447606086731,
-0.38216668367385864,
-0.43220803141593933,
-0.6024113893508911,
-0.0880739688873291,
-0.38874760270118713,
0.5987324118614197,
-0.17146512866020203,
-0.8540276885032654,
0.43491092324256897,
-0.13139405846595764,
0.2793193757534027,
0.43316569924354553,
0.49347037076950073,
0.018077747896313667,
0.7633390426635742,
0.9607328176498413,
0.11518668383359909,
0.20748166739940643,
-0.0660991370677948,
0.2036265879869461,
-0.9206697940826416,
-0.15376107394695282,
-1.0673801898956299,
0.17909668385982513,
-0.20204003155231476,
-0.4921821355819702,
0.08370483666658401,
0.4968617260456085,
-0.10750669986009598,
0.2600935399532318,
-0.2694157660007477,
0.49595701694488525,
0.227211594581604,
-0.2124790996313095,
0.4267134666442871,
-0.23361611366271973,
-0.011655543930828571,
-0.14057594537734985,
-0.8960679769515991,
-0.861363410949707,
1.0086230039596558,
0.8701072931289673,
0.9079703092575073,
-0.01794898323714733,
0.523685097694397,
0.20152771472930908,
0.5899165868759155,
-0.6941083073616028,
0.24019472301006317,
0.26321783661842346,
-0.6196011304855347,
-0.36066576838493347,
-0.5402427315711975,
-0.9670220017433167,
0.38124045729637146,
-0.13020774722099304,
-0.8521289825439453,
-0.07198074460029602,
0.014830595813691616,
0.02935643680393696,
0.12146134674549103,
-0.7489468455314636,
1.0354154109954834,
-0.2993399202823639,
-0.27549684047698975,
0.07623749226331711,
-0.43029138445854187,
0.5485048294067383,
-0.1673993021249771,
0.6565073132514954,
0.05170172452926636,
0.23400439321994781,
0.6057042479515076,
-0.39111948013305664,
0.5930103063583374,
0.039480093866586685,
-0.35464170575141907,
0.183096781373024,
0.19849972426891327,
0.44457903504371643,
-0.35498976707458496,
-0.34592047333717346,
0.2290676236152649,
0.07726026326417923,
-0.27428147196769714,
-0.6671769022941589,
0.808347225189209,
-0.6403570771217346,
-0.6569932103157043,
-0.26109737157821655,
-0.4575011134147644,
-0.1771828681230545,
-0.002375560812652111,
-0.0363309271633625,
0.46639472246170044,
-0.4275319278240204,
0.28973907232284546,
0.39412760734558105,
-0.7447906136512756,
0.4073072373867035,
0.5184955596923828,
-0.8793680667877197,
-0.2616537809371948,
0.636867344379425,
0.19249719381332397,
0.5492908358573914,
-0.025793766602873802,
0.30664700269699097,
-0.12834961712360382,
-0.6337642669677734,
-0.5558852553367615,
0.08439882844686508,
-0.9382551312446594,
0.02595597878098488,
-0.5779076814651489,
-0.32466402649879456,
-0.33712121844291687,
-0.05879464000463486,
-0.6637527942657471,
-0.5717304348945618,
0.03678026422858238,
-0.06545541435480118,
0.10704530030488968,
0.9810248017311096,
-0.05703507736325264,
0.05068253353238106,
-0.6803866028785706,
0.14789988100528717,
-0.034810349345207214,
0.6185265183448792,
0.18592804670333862,
-0.5243836045265198,
-0.489689439535141,
-0.149106964468956,
-0.2390187382698059,
-0.8440040349960327,
0.52509605884552,
-0.027394456788897514,
0.7071850895881653,
-0.10566201061010361,
0.04623741656541824,
0.27991753816604614,
-0.614981472492218,
0.8823073506355286,
-0.08169040083885193,
-1.0489822626113892,
0.5635330677032471,
-0.2775738835334778,
0.16058629751205444,
0.36762815713882446,
0.49509280920028687,
-0.4079297184944153,
-0.45267537236213684,
-0.5475738048553467,
-1.131455659866333,
0.4212270975112915,
0.40045660734176636,
0.04197497293353081,
0.13379032909870148,
0.03756232187151909,
0.3782462775707245,
0.22397403419017792,
-0.9318172335624695,
-0.10530553758144379,
-0.06977495551109314,
0.08312369883060455,
-0.15701544284820557,
-0.35417670011520386,
-0.254352867603302,
0.027507390826940536,
0.6637958884239197,
0.1820644587278366,
-0.18719330430030823,
0.07121460884809494,
-0.37760892510414124,
-0.02857695333659649,
0.5072721838951111,
0.6101267337799072,
1.2263154983520508,
-0.40699487924575806,
0.12568606436252594,
0.052914269268512726,
-0.018963107839226723,
-0.015916870906949043,
0.0587104968726635,
-0.25338053703308105,
0.3366171419620514,
0.6409851312637329,
0.6504458785057068,
0.4081152081489563,
-0.8236050605773926,
0.5975255370140076,
-0.010830995626747608,
-0.061113905161619186,
-0.33202043175697327,
-0.4025510251522064,
0.25692570209503174,
0.1322111040353775,
0.3510677218437195,
-0.22095336019992828,
0.1805027723312378,
-0.4389338493347168,
0.18038414418697357,
0.2922782599925995,
-0.27605658769607544,
-0.21862798929214478,
0.2744993567466736,
0.21087917685508728,
-0.6165726184844971,
0.4412994682788849,
0.01230546273291111,
-0.3962404727935791,
0.4434446096420288,
0.5740724205970764,
0.862623393535614,
-0.4454732835292816,
0.22935162484645844,
0.13091035187244415,
0.6838787794113159,
-0.38392478227615356,
0.05790618434548378,
0.2776658833026886,
-0.5650286078453064,
-0.6223446726799011,
-0.7230315804481506,
-0.6939197182655334,
0.4379980266094208,
-0.7642359137535095,
0.3716820478439331,
-0.13264337182044983,
0.0635838657617569,
0.09103379398584366,
-0.3312778174877167,
-0.6010069847106934,
-0.21732449531555176,
-0.04182837903499603,
1.1786261796951294,
-1.0180273056030273,
0.6210440993309021,
0.42007359862327576,
-0.46876266598701477,
-0.6812191605567932,
-0.6039613485336304,
-0.06806770712137222,
-0.4867073893547058,
0.7324810028076172,
0.003974794875830412,
-0.08580871671438217,
-0.24439282715320587,
-0.5193459987640381,
-0.43738028407096863,
0.5927029848098755,
0.45916104316711426,
-0.6515305042266846,
0.24995404481887817,
-0.09405788034200668,
0.7110557556152344,
-0.39948052167892456,
0.49416905641555786,
0.4457075595855713,
0.3846870958805084,
-0.47957178950309753,
-1.3827961683273315,
-0.259909451007843,
-0.3908706605434418,
0.01631784625351429,
0.012895070016384125,
-0.20361396670341492,
0.8605630397796631,
0.06381630152463913,
-0.2262810468673706,
0.26478371024131775,
0.4045710563659668,
0.3139052987098694,
0.47879770398139954,
0.36907345056533813,
0.3924314081668854,
0.5065613389015198,
0.009174727834761143,
1.2614071369171143,
-0.10641655325889587,
0.6579126119613647,
1.4000773429870605,
-0.3960956037044525,
1.0607562065124512,
0.6021231412887573,
-0.3377782106399536,
0.3743743598461151,
0.3307570815086365,
0.05887187272310257,
0.28425830602645874,
0.6589930653572083,
-0.12870411574840546,
0.13545145094394684,
-0.16766345500946045,
-0.5895590782165527,
0.26580923795700073,
0.12441544234752655,
-0.6073662638664246,
-0.48082947731018066,
0.11099446564912796,
-0.06946566700935364,
0.28667786717414856,
-0.23190635442733765,
0.5051562190055847,
0.10788276791572571,
-0.3144446313381195,
0.5974969267845154,
0.0668134018778801,
0.41142159700393677,
-0.5631702542304993,
-0.311305969953537,
-0.08511164784431458,
0.05202891677618027,
-0.11797628551721573,
-0.6531473398208618,
0.5378424525260925,
0.2704905867576599,
-0.04544644057750702,
-0.3696190118789673,
0.8425283432006836,
-0.29130133986473083,
-0.4120882451534271,
0.5378108024597168,
0.7696000337600708,
0.3142351806163788,
-0.026537472382187843,
-0.6115207672119141,
0.5574080944061279,
-0.3673144578933716,
-0.620861291885376,
0.4333098232746124,
0.36188849806785583,
0.053040191531181335,
0.970385730266571,
0.3767954111099243,
0.24641776084899902,
-0.08360115438699722,
0.3932020664215088,
0.7007753849029541,
-0.7164315581321716,
-0.013431541621685028,
-0.7829142212867737,
0.5864980220794678,
0.10928463190793991,
-0.26432543992996216,
0.7876087427139282,
0.5467155575752258,
0.8554868102073669,
-0.251038134098053,
0.8975991606712341,
0.03273773565888405,
0.6220174431800842,
-0.4653075933456421,
0.7266829013824463,
-0.26507875323295593,
0.48010554909706116,
-0.3441225290298462,
-0.8696341514587402,
-0.3056311011314392,
0.7256097197532654,
-0.06856578588485718,
0.11168509721755981,
0.6982003450393677,
0.6863849759101868,
0.027219558134675026,
0.03002532571554184,
0.2675657570362091,
0.26589104533195496,
0.34115809202194214,
0.09161398559808731,
1.3118400573730469,
-0.3789862096309662,
0.2520218789577484,
-0.4826553761959076,
-0.2546914219856262,
-0.10741110146045685,
-1.292534589767456,
-0.5707976222038269,
-0.5959147214889526,
-0.3907948434352875,
-0.43326419591903687,
0.28203216195106506,
0.8501967787742615,
0.5447218418121338,
-0.746623158454895,
-0.5798174738883972,
0.07374715805053711,
0.39003533124923706,
-0.27962031960487366,
-0.2815931737422943,
0.35147103667259216,
-0.3405560851097107,
-0.5909539461135864,
0.6830821633338928,
0.3257756531238556,
-0.25182443857192993,
-0.6829547882080078,
0.0295072253793478,
-0.2155056744813919,
-0.14973437786102295,
0.6597040891647339,
0.42894959449768066,
-0.6414445638656616,
-0.568740725517273,
-0.13285738229751587,
-0.029460277408361435,
-0.19130201637744904,
0.8854408264160156,
-0.6633340716362,
0.535351574420929,
0.3329726755619049,
0.7866703271865845,
0.24509942531585693,
-0.23343077301979065,
1.0269055366516113,
-0.7010435461997986,
-0.06000131741166115,
0.4720480442047119,
0.3688357174396515,
0.6133324503898621,
0.20869551599025726,
0.9359976649284363,
-0.07314697653055191,
-0.8346484899520874,
-1.3520342111587524,
0.09164544194936752,
-0.6767683029174805,
-0.35656529664993286,
1.1176931858062744,
-0.6293395161628723,
0.033484991639852524,
-0.3287612795829773,
-0.0706465020775795,
0.00020282805780880153,
0.1950346827507019,
0.8454047441482544,
1.1065900325775146,
-0.04329647496342659,
-0.4801032543182373,
-1.075032353401184,
0.3744218349456787,
0.27449584007263184,
-0.6392035484313965,
0.2730378210544586,
0.35215288400650024,
0.3210521340370178,
0.08118530362844467,
0.37440991401672363,
-0.27076274156570435,
-0.023741018027067184,
0.22300243377685547,
0.26902514696121216,
-0.02775369957089424,
-0.256099671125412,
-0.7557757496833801,
0.22937485575675964,
0.499056339263916,
0.39637547731399536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14779v1
|
Smart Bilingual Focused Crawling of Parallel Documents
| 2024-05-23T16:45:59 | 2024-05-23T16:45:59 |
Cristian García-Romero, Miquel Esplà-Gomis, Felipe Sánchez-Martínez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Crawling parallel texts $\unicode{x2014}$texts that are mutual
translations$\unicode{x2014}$ from the Internet is usually done following a
brute-force approach: documents are massively downloaded in an unguided
process, and only a fraction of them end up leading to actual parallel content.
In this work we propose a smart crawling method that guides the crawl towards
finding parallel content more rapidly. Our approach builds on two different
models: one that infers the language of a document from its URL, and another
that infers whether a pair of URLs link to parallel documents. We evaluate both
models in isolation and their integration into a crawling tool. The results
demonstrate the individual effectiveness of both models and highlight that
their combination enables the early discovery of parallel content during
crawling, leading to a reduction in the amount of downloaded documents deemed
useless, and yielding a greater quantity of parallel documents compared to
conventional crawling approaches.
|
[
-0.58697110414505,
-0.5306185483932495,
0.6962558627128601,
0.6373649835586548,
-0.42142289876937866,
0.28407344222068787,
-0.19433851540088654,
-0.5721966028213501,
0.6468154191970825,
0.42629894614219666,
-0.5644146800041199,
-0.49162518978118896,
-0.540657639503479,
0.4059954583644867,
-0.8422616720199585,
0.868629515171051,
-0.026793915778398514,
0.1080138310790062,
-0.3716707229614258,
-0.2938368022441864,
-0.09443407505750656,
-0.30984222888946533,
-0.18176794052124023,
-0.05454155430197716,
0.7431593537330627,
0.33318662643432617,
0.9052499532699585,
1.0338455438613892,
0.8789939284324646,
0.4181947708129883,
-0.011803441680967808,
0.10503337532281876,
-0.3915805220603943,
0.06530822813510895,
-0.7993535995483398,
-0.5255603194236755,
-0.27384111285209656,
-0.08312402665615082,
0.6654310822486877,
0.787478506565094,
0.12237013876438141,
0.16375266015529633,
-0.0497908741235733,
0.7314595580101013,
-0.38314712047576904,
-0.01855379343032837,
-0.5112478137016296,
-0.07690012454986572,
-0.7510566115379333,
-0.30071914196014404,
-0.22901833057403564,
-0.1487058401107788,
0.015443441458046436,
-0.5320764780044556,
0.5485786199569702,
0.17651963233947754,
0.7768443822860718,
-0.1306886523962021,
-0.4657129645347595,
-0.3698998689651489,
-0.4334876835346222,
1.0295321941375732,
-0.36306461691856384,
0.674524188041687,
0.2906375229358673,
0.20838822424411774,
0.0039134579710662365,
-1.0394654273986816,
-0.741269052028656,
0.07721270620822906,
0.019765708595514297,
0.05152496322989464,
0.06664345413446426,
-0.35341858863830566,
0.20444324612617493,
0.40208134055137634,
-0.6915819048881531,
0.035753414034843445,
-0.32540616393089294,
-0.16513298451900482,
0.6822888255119324,
0.27405640482902527,
0.7721878886222839,
-0.34027084708213806,
-0.5827476978302002,
-0.28756141662597656,
-0.5622676610946655,
-0.1146676167845726,
0.7250781059265137,
0.4436247944831848,
-0.06869515776634216,
0.5732784867286682,
-0.25114044547080994,
0.4437767565250397,
-0.1013021469116211,
-0.3493795692920685,
0.361391544342041,
-0.6102033853530884,
0.3801528215408325,
-0.0960666760802269,
0.8380629420280457,
0.46112704277038574,
0.4812857508659363,
-0.44074854254722595,
-0.4392569065093994,
-0.1471090018749237,
0.33522310853004456,
-0.6252197623252869,
0.05699358507990837,
0.1456650048494339,
-0.5811389684677124,
0.02057345025241375,
0.15842294692993164,
-0.6944506168365479,
-0.22249867022037506,
-0.33695510029792786,
0.13122305274009705,
-0.4792488217353821,
-0.11021991819143295,
0.08301717787981033,
-0.394175261259079,
-0.1308802217245102,
0.13683301210403442,
-0.6844471096992493,
0.4192556142807007,
0.8539815545082092,
1.1008155345916748,
-0.22081682085990906,
-0.7335402369499207,
-0.5132467150688171,
0.3546742796897888,
0.008408443070948124,
1.0906139612197876,
-0.4451824128627777,
-0.5510358214378357,
-0.06208239495754242,
0.3616024851799011,
-0.2779929041862488,
-0.5648476481437683,
0.8277712464332581,
-0.8095018863677979,
-0.09887926280498505,
-0.4032422602176666,
-0.2464580088853836,
-0.5492731928825378,
0.3626919388771057,
-1.061159610748291,
0.7627337574958801,
0.12110338360071182,
-1.1921416521072388,
-0.15307869017124176,
-0.37715795636177063,
-0.7904084920883179,
0.09746509045362473,
0.037157852202653885,
0.0075075458735227585,
0.012172650545835495,
0.1877681016921997,
0.10681474953889847,
-0.5158625245094299,
0.12017068266868591,
-0.4006699323654175,
-0.33478352427482605,
-0.10340669751167297,
0.07338278740644455,
0.9486865401268005,
0.051217641681432724,
-0.2898194491863251,
-0.16967232525348663,
-0.45264407992362976,
-0.3399105370044708,
0.5387972593307495,
-0.3122321665287018,
-0.6392657160758972,
0.36536699533462524,
0.205267071723938,
0.05475463718175888,
0.686364471912384,
-0.6903441548347473,
0.264773964881897,
-0.27126967906951904,
-0.0776720941066742,
0.5325871109962463,
-0.2526974678039551,
0.37923404574394226,
-0.5600062012672424,
0.44029495120048523,
-0.08196458220481873,
0.03784438967704773,
-0.4075959026813507,
-0.62110435962677,
-0.6043432354927063,
-0.22637303173542023,
0.34334197640419006,
0.5945904850959778,
-0.4958338141441345,
-0.02300766482949257,
-0.5711119174957275,
-0.5085368156433105,
-0.5169652700424194,
0.38149142265319824,
0.5845924019813538,
0.5251569747924805,
0.5170717239379883,
-0.5241386890411377,
-0.4521319568157196,
-0.6394749879837036,
-0.7049368023872375,
0.00617486797273159,
0.14814326167106628,
0.3685041069984436,
0.3293793499469757,
-0.4940248727798462,
0.6725197434425354,
-0.23133614659309387,
-0.397691011428833,
-0.3496038317680359,
0.28229060769081116,
0.18942791223526,
0.42474812269210815,
0.7679359912872314,
-1.405091404914856,
-1.0426615476608276,
0.10285023599863052,
-0.7006414532661438,
-0.10957563668489456,
0.08745891600847244,
0.06524647772312164,
0.08992162346839905,
0.5008768439292908,
-0.5654498934745789,
0.180257186293602,
0.45043033361434937,
0.08414078503847122,
0.47116023302078247,
-0.25853490829467773,
0.026832852512598038,
-0.7592462301254272,
0.04667346552014351,
0.12443269789218903,
-0.3639451563358307,
-0.3346996605396271,
0.8311883211135864,
0.3797796964645386,
0.14610832929611206,
-0.5213487148284912,
0.5594249963760376,
-0.5183722376823425,
0.04607589915394783,
-0.27516210079193115,
0.16639631986618042,
-0.02431383915245533,
0.27726057171821594,
-0.1836257129907608,
0.765217125415802,
0.41324180364608765,
-0.15171197056770325,
0.3547942340373993,
0.1408698409795761,
0.019931089133024216,
0.12547406554222107,
-0.5677400231361389,
0.3467296361923218,
-0.1529523879289627,
0.4134402275085449,
-0.5352147817611694,
-0.1962747871875763,
-0.029398104175925255,
-0.36885154247283936,
0.15530042350292206,
-0.308962345123291,
-1.0334309339523315,
-0.4251132011413574,
-0.587392270565033,
0.7346938252449036,
0.3599562644958496,
-0.5778236985206604,
0.5188297629356384,
0.4909583330154419,
-0.5652616620063782,
-0.2392691969871521,
-0.4861285984516144,
0.2258259803056717,
0.027909474447369576,
-0.9175851345062256,
0.4720302224159241,
-0.11681806296110153,
-0.34209010004997253,
0.07302487641572952,
-0.010051615536212921,
-0.18051132559776306,
-0.2126556783914566,
0.027616098523139954,
0.01297532208263874,
-0.14823400974273682,
-0.40036338567733765,
0.05210041627287865,
-0.2140505015850067,
-0.054201897233724594,
-0.45301637053489685,
0.8303871750831604,
-0.18960967659950256,
-0.4426492154598236,
-0.3414139151573181,
0.980497419834137,
0.8517690300941467,
-0.5594736933708191,
0.7052593231201172,
0.6675707101821899,
-0.2504553496837616,
0.07764612883329391,
-0.6170307397842407,
0.12123626470565796,
-0.5285199284553528,
0.0705878958106041,
-0.3418520987033844,
-0.4957580864429474,
0.7359558343887329,
-0.1398889422416687,
-0.2545514404773712,
0.5412776470184326,
0.5057474970817566,
-0.1503312885761261,
1.4340062141418457,
0.9403470158576965,
-0.09930167347192764,
0.11785820126533508,
-0.26065415143966675,
0.43263664841651917,
-0.5229489803314209,
-0.6085165739059448,
-0.8254765272140503,
-0.3599259853363037,
-0.8776740431785583,
-0.45532914996147156,
0.20684947073459625,
0.14750994741916656,
0.20352138578891754,
0.6364952921867371,
-0.12080221623182297,
0.4164418578147888,
0.9553248286247253,
0.2182113230228424,
0.5235742330551147,
-0.016253070905804634,
-0.5445178151130676,
-0.12462203949689865,
-0.5085877180099487,
-0.24984781444072723,
1.0482726097106934,
-0.050928860902786255,
0.2569129467010498,
0.01610574871301651,
0.9076698422431946,
0.15231016278266907,
-0.07160893082618713,
-0.7139771580696106,
0.7909603714942932,
-0.4555530846118927,
-0.5463190078735352,
-0.04829791188240051,
-0.31711554527282715,
-0.9922299385070801,
0.04987913742661476,
0.16387991607189178,
-0.5119326114654541,
0.05371762439608574,
-0.2971436679363251,
0.2224409580230713,
0.5267345309257507,
-0.5936529040336609,
0.5622158050537109,
-0.3716735541820526,
-0.3727809190750122,
-0.6982068419456482,
-0.682156503200531,
0.08418287336826324,
-0.6186860799789429,
0.6111009120941162,
-0.09199049323797226,
-0.3390812873840332,
0.5438521504402161,
-0.586916983127594,
0.2955314815044403,
-0.0017943879356607795,
0.09600867331027985,
0.2652193307876587,
0.2702564001083374,
0.7559133768081665,
-0.08435239642858505,
-0.09952542930841446,
0.36477622389793396,
-0.17004315555095673,
-0.8034846782684326,
-0.4230544865131378,
0.9167243242263794,
-0.4178639352321625,
-0.7464280724525452,
-0.23626714944839478,
-1.0006828308105469,
0.08454786986112595,
0.8872866630554199,
0.047371406108140945,
0.26054057478904724,
0.1722252517938614,
0.09488880634307861,
0.5787731409072876,
-0.011129355058073997,
0.6436609625816345,
0.6190708875656128,
-0.15604844689369202,
-0.08328977972269058,
1.2478821277618408,
0.24011683464050293,
-0.3149492144584656,
0.587225615978241,
0.1493542641401291,
-0.4029655158519745,
-0.9203389286994934,
-0.2723517417907715,
0.532998263835907,
-0.4533844292163849,
-0.018421713262796402,
-1.1162208318710327,
0.09810762852430344,
-0.6733627319335938,
-0.3199491500854492,
-0.4038808047771454,
-0.27762600779533386,
-0.14831122756004333,
0.22723761200904846,
0.11153190582990646,
0.5195062756538391,
-0.2545255422592163,
0.05752817913889885,
-1.3754152059555054,
0.7499549388885498,
0.13308225572109222,
0.2584439516067505,
-0.106905996799469,
-0.04569371044635773,
-0.3819192945957184,
-0.017603347077965736,
-0.11604053527116776,
-1.0375306606292725,
0.5294466018676758,
-0.12384798377752304,
0.47691845893859863,
0.5482828617095947,
0.23758481442928314,
0.4943520128726959,
-0.6792952418327332,
0.37192302942276,
0.16798554360866547,
-0.7088099122047424,
0.25070950388908386,
-0.9890868067741394,
0.21390804648399353,
0.5577786564826965,
1.0275853872299194,
-0.2673156261444092,
-0.359737753868103,
-0.3607840836048126,
-1.0540015697479248,
0.427904337644577,
0.07129146158695221,
0.16012531518936157,
-0.12843501567840576,
-0.26436948776245117,
0.2743591368198395,
0.04675878956913948,
-0.3565361797809601,
0.11905302107334137,
-0.10085194557905197,
-0.0834876149892807,
0.01235827337950468,
-0.15904861688613892,
-0.031596578657627106,
-0.3799722492694855,
0.32734283804893494,
-0.12978558242321014,
-0.11131292581558228,
0.06857846677303314,
-0.5401890873908997,
-0.0826273262500763,
-0.19957534968852997,
0.06387219578027725,
0.5728465914726257,
-0.3091878294944763,
0.1055772602558136,
-0.13519634306430817,
-0.6659103035926819,
-0.11928790807723999,
0.31492942571640015,
-0.18222059309482574,
0.2862006723880768,
0.265904039144516,
0.17669261991977692,
0.25481128692626953,
-1.0234851837158203,
0.7934756875038147,
0.011564955115318298,
0.013119148090481758,
-0.025846023112535477,
-0.1563987135887146,
0.28498008847236633,
0.5047397613525391,
0.40248754620552063,
0.09008530527353287,
0.31978049874305725,
-0.435322642326355,
0.09386556595563889,
0.18584343791007996,
-0.06515982747077942,
-0.46082016825675964,
0.6376503109931946,
0.2965167164802551,
-0.6261955499649048,
0.7532085180282593,
-0.32377901673316956,
-0.8391106128692627,
0.5877487659454346,
0.5650768876075745,
1.0503919124603271,
0.13517972826957703,
0.09260525554418564,
0.18226505815982819,
0.2605424225330353,
-0.2734706997871399,
0.3649953603744507,
-0.36459681391716003,
-0.30913829803466797,
-0.3441225588321686,
-0.7609784603118896,
-0.4465992748737335,
-0.5035726428031921,
-0.7569513320922852,
0.3277214467525482,
-0.18297044932842255,
0.24421468377113342,
-0.1023501455783844,
0.07464747130870819,
-0.7090480327606201,
0.17885693907737732,
0.027934296056628227,
1.2651337385177612,
-0.5417532324790955,
0.7796788811683655,
0.8787965178489685,
-0.41738757491111755,
-0.4386351704597473,
0.4062260091304779,
-0.029150351881980896,
-0.7768847346305847,
0.395029753446579,
0.22801515460014343,
-0.19822297990322113,
0.2186417430639267,
-0.3741700053215027,
-0.8986989855766296,
0.8195275068283081,
0.2913314998149872,
-0.6065438985824585,
-0.3700422942638397,
0.3740876317024231,
0.4379238486289978,
0.1658189296722412,
0.13500338792800903,
0.18287156522274017,
0.619683027267456,
-0.39484795928001404,
-1.0425584316253662,
0.22305184602737427,
-0.5036801099777222,
-0.20785796642303467,
0.2571050226688385,
-0.8896614909172058,
0.965903103351593,
-0.2777811288833618,
-0.32618841528892517,
0.3151692748069763,
0.5703551769256592,
0.11934053897857666,
0.6136951446533203,
0.6257705092430115,
0.8377640247344971,
0.5712752342224121,
0.20517775416374207,
1.2025789022445679,
-0.6189746856689453,
0.3441191017627716,
0.7544859051704407,
-0.21536578238010406,
0.9153324365615845,
0.6746284365653992,
-0.14758040010929108,
0.743766725063324,
0.35963213443756104,
0.07364025712013245,
0.5621206760406494,
-0.20573048293590546,
-0.34585556387901306,
-0.11437036842107773,
-0.45097798109054565,
-0.36394643783569336,
0.39072534441947937,
0.15186196565628052,
-0.10532674938440323,
-0.653567910194397,
-0.013421631418168545,
0.19597910344600677,
0.39600253105163574,
-0.2351931780576706,
0.5083773136138916,
0.0006769330357201397,
-0.8467485904693604,
0.2648526728153229,
0.37170255184173584,
0.54132479429245,
-0.45919880270957947,
0.29914188385009766,
-0.4501098096370697,
0.18153323233127594,
-0.16712574660778046,
-0.6767812371253967,
0.38783004879951477,
0.29718396067619324,
-0.6576356887817383,
-0.5712265968322754,
0.7227205038070679,
-0.14322973787784576,
-0.37784382700920105,
0.84203040599823,
0.5016739964485168,
0.1953732967376709,
-0.436443030834198,
-0.5649422407150269,
-0.04718344286084175,
-0.08318822830915451,
-0.2385464906692505,
0.6208149194717407,
0.4198054373264313,
-0.3780496418476105,
0.5199510455131531,
1.0296043157577515,
-0.07200125604867935,
0.3939017951488495,
-0.19961358606815338,
1.0751675367355347,
-0.8032850027084351,
-0.7386569380760193,
-0.6070498824119568,
0.3246096968650818,
0.12819108366966248,
0.2302553653717041,
1.168074369430542,
0.7720316648483276,
1.2599371671676636,
0.10642344504594803,
0.7415890097618103,
0.10275351256132126,
0.6762317419052124,
-0.0948939248919487,
0.774759829044342,
-0.8411800265312195,
-0.12209443002939224,
-0.20696771144866943,
-0.8941419720649719,
-0.09466871619224548,
-0.08678758889436722,
0.055053673684597015,
-0.403719037771225,
0.9489270448684692,
0.7800682187080383,
-0.5368236303329468,
-0.0050738356076180935,
-0.09066067636013031,
-0.08001293241977692,
-0.055153436958789825,
0.29104718565940857,
0.6168293356895447,
-0.24446840584278107,
0.7653751373291016,
-0.5828940868377686,
-0.1295500099658966,
-0.34120801091194153,
-0.8280526995658875,
-0.6247446537017822,
-0.4291008412837982,
0.052834928035736084,
-0.2659660577774048,
0.12172380834817886,
0.32788607478141785,
0.47434520721435547,
-0.6244456171989441,
-0.23592916131019592,
-0.3351583778858185,
0.27047455310821533,
0.09269306063652039,
-0.12491973489522934,
0.12682001292705536,
-0.4650524854660034,
-1.1520506143569946,
0.6229259371757507,
0.5514962077140808,
-0.02909795008599758,
-0.24547478556632996,
-0.1594754457473755,
-0.49275729060173035,
0.22117264568805695,
0.13311068713665009,
0.4907272160053253,
-0.2684558033943176,
0.3569180369377136,
0.26407772302627563,
-0.24447818100452423,
-0.07685071974992752,
1.0095021724700928,
-0.8449201583862305,
0.5660840272903442,
1.2264305353164673,
0.6301389932632446,
0.5319902300834656,
-0.057085491716861725,
0.43050605058670044,
-0.3176076412200928,
0.44832614064216614,
0.24112872779369354,
0.4613701403141022,
0.2975231409072876,
-0.023606933653354645,
0.22700679302215576,
0.7428786754608154,
-0.2365456074476242,
-0.9623249769210815,
-0.022995760664343834,
-1.0108623504638672,
-0.34200921654701233,
0.9558225870132446,
-0.39535945653915405,
-0.34281018376350403,
-0.0931292250752449,
0.05978928133845329,
0.23422472178936005,
-0.042453616857528687,
0.7020425796508789,
0.29148179292678833,
0.29167553782463074,
0.3706860840320587,
-0.369877427816391,
-0.1865902692079544,
0.5918703675270081,
-0.36575886607170105,
-0.6115767955780029,
0.03274986520409584,
0.0687585100531578,
0.41443368792533875,
0.40810778737068176,
-0.17840926349163055,
0.328612357378006,
0.11696778982877731,
-0.23156124353408813,
0.04403575882315636,
-0.7662692666053772,
0.10183496028184891,
0.4652298390865326,
-0.5210506319999695,
-0.18402992188930511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14769v1
|
Pragmatic Feature Preferences: Learning Reward-Relevant Preferences from Human Input
| 2024-05-23T16:36:16 | 2024-05-23T16:36:16 |
Andi Peng, Yuying Sun, Tianmin Shu, David Abel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Humans use social context to specify preferences over behaviors, i.e. their
reward functions. Yet, algorithms for inferring reward models from preference
data do not take this social learning view into account. Inspired by pragmatic
human communication, we study how to extract fine-grained data regarding why an
example is preferred that is useful for learning more accurate reward models.
We propose to enrich binary preference queries to ask both (1) which features
of a given example are preferable in addition to (2) comparisons between
examples themselves. We derive an approach for learning from these
feature-level preferences, both for cases where users specify which features
are reward-relevant, and when users do not. We evaluate our approach on linear
bandit settings in both vision- and language-based domains. Results support the
efficiency of our approach in quickly converging to accurate rewards with fewer
comparisons vs. example-only labels. Finally, we validate the real-world
applicability with a behavioral experiment on a mushroom foraging task. Our
findings suggest that incorporating pragmatic feature preferences is a
promising approach for more efficient user-aligned reward learning.
|
[
-0.41012123227119446,
-0.6003637313842773,
0.4568849205970764,
-0.05004939064383507,
-0.2573355436325073,
-0.08351299911737442,
-0.5498406887054443,
-0.4781394600868225,
0.689568817615509,
0.47415804862976074,
-0.4449447691440582,
-0.561171293258667,
-0.5840688943862915,
-0.20875585079193115,
0.02122635580599308,
1.133878231048584,
0.15948863327503204,
-0.22923672199249268,
-0.3371966779232025,
-0.1625988632440567,
-0.4367469549179077,
-0.9260725378990173,
-0.6059707403182983,
-0.3458694517612457,
1.1435084342956543,
0.6088509559631348,
0.6033279299736023,
0.5000513792037964,
0.3353172242641449,
0.2415580302476883,
-0.05223406106233597,
0.33536750078201294,
-0.629425048828125,
0.009938379749655724,
-0.4766252040863037,
-0.6020988821983337,
0.1860622763633728,
0.2287103235721588,
-0.022093916311860085,
0.5518582463264465,
-0.11617626249790192,
0.10002843290567398,
0.08506899327039719,
0.4729557931423187,
-0.6973079442977905,
0.4832852780818939,
-0.6341069340705872,
0.05500571429729462,
-0.17806574702262878,
-0.24994324147701263,
-0.16491760313510895,
-0.6675493121147156,
0.44225603342056274,
-0.5752259492874146,
0.27046191692352295,
-0.24180574715137482,
1.0358330011367798,
0.050453364849090576,
-0.18160052597522736,
-0.5004810690879822,
-0.34598737955093384,
0.8866337537765503,
-0.30322369933128357,
-0.05748123303055763,
0.7924161553382874,
0.44858935475349426,
0.018061554059386253,
-0.6100366115570068,
-0.2859979569911957,
-0.19966822862625122,
-0.5954762697219849,
-0.20707273483276367,
0.27205905318260193,
0.07456634938716888,
0.035188592970371246,
0.04512565955519676,
-0.26400893926620483,
-0.05710680037736893,
-0.203586608171463,
-0.32680270075798035,
0.8133693337440491,
-0.0325259231030941,
-0.08839375525712967,
-0.45240890979766846,
-0.34636837244033813,
-0.48524755239486694,
-0.5759868025779724,
0.8861744403839111,
0.5421609878540039,
0.3763698935508728,
0.05025802552700043,
0.46070611476898193,
-0.17406031489372253,
0.8611221313476562,
0.08273246139287949,
-0.08516782522201538,
0.34164905548095703,
-0.039968010038137436,
0.26801422238349915,
-0.02903505228459835,
0.40785476565361023,
0.48290762305259705,
0.3482937514781952,
-0.1978442668914795,
-0.3054899573326111,
0.30588212609291077,
0.4757077395915985,
-0.6157334446907043,
-0.4525587856769562,
0.06507907062768936,
-0.4076431393623352,
-0.5944421291351318,
0.3137733042240143,
-0.5243918895721436,
-0.5041845440864563,
-0.2764653265476227,
0.40240374207496643,
-0.3268885314464569,
-0.15777264535427094,
0.15423166751861572,
-0.5810405611991882,
0.3415278494358063,
0.3555125892162323,
-1.25157630443573,
-0.05936097353696823,
1.0335538387298584,
0.6595537066459656,
-0.11632733792066574,
-0.3647967576980591,
-0.6017354130744934,
-0.0902690589427948,
-0.12421616911888123,
1.0567989349365234,
-1.028265118598938,
-0.3758160471916199,
-0.1800706535577774,
0.1798473447561264,
0.09655889868736267,
-0.8035560250282288,
0.557265043258667,
-0.2664913535118103,
0.13805922865867615,
-0.7306057810783386,
-0.29651033878326416,
-0.29424843192100525,
0.254475861787796,
-0.3420286476612091,
0.6507564187049866,
0.2908666729927063,
-0.6224027276039124,
1.007187008857727,
-0.7145540118217468,
-0.5427641272544861,
0.2108641415834427,
-0.36934593319892883,
-0.30652058124542236,
0.2864524722099304,
-0.12574754655361176,
0.5625746250152588,
0.275684654712677,
0.5150264501571655,
-0.5275679230690002,
-0.5602893233299255,
0.4471667408943176,
-0.12760812044143677,
0.48100778460502625,
0.22698761522769928,
-0.26011544466018677,
0.29732340574264526,
-0.23878730833530426,
-0.07081108540296555,
0.27181559801101685,
-0.21996399760246277,
-0.5559167265892029,
0.5348557233810425,
-0.19763930141925812,
-0.09431881457567215,
0.37469616532325745,
-0.41906899213790894,
0.035354021936655045,
-0.3829735815525055,
0.6897050142288208,
1.0425132513046265,
-0.011028565466403961,
0.38025161623954773,
-0.5070503950119019,
0.15229080617427826,
0.015255973674356937,
0.2372928112745285,
0.14305688440799713,
-0.38260069489479065,
-0.33922305703163147,
-0.4629703760147095,
0.4612583816051483,
0.2892454266548157,
-0.5655056238174438,
0.5847063660621643,
0.06081326678395271,
-0.3974163830280304,
-0.4202660024166107,
0.1114327535033226,
0.32850199937820435,
0.40139973163604736,
0.1440926492214203,
-0.7634993195533752,
-0.21026626229286194,
-1.118369460105896,
-0.4651373326778412,
-0.33295294642448425,
-0.36154624819755554,
1.0064764022827148,
0.23731602728366852,
0.04615176096558571,
1.097303032875061,
-0.8192735314369202,
0.008318610489368439,
-0.2539007365703583,
0.21566057205200195,
0.16119317710399628,
0.16856980323791504,
0.6645417809486389,
-1.2539024353027344,
-0.21702086925506592,
0.009155284613370895,
-0.524196207523346,
0.2526662051677704,
0.08741437643766403,
-0.24695880711078644,
-0.1864238679409027,
-0.3218260705471039,
-0.3842427134513855,
0.5185030698776245,
0.14355619251728058,
-0.3971812427043915,
0.047659724950790405,
-0.1337762326002121,
0.196734219789505,
-0.5304117798805237,
-0.0160024706274271,
0.3664427399635315,
-0.3339824378490448,
-0.37298059463500977,
-0.17137500643730164,
0.022029083222150803,
0.053397051990032196,
-0.4994605481624603,
0.5804612636566162,
0.1259119212627411,
-0.367702454328537,
-0.10360895097255707,
-0.04716278612613678,
0.043443288654088974,
0.6524598598480225,
0.6938688158988953,
0.5459364056587219,
0.37680184841156006,
-0.633414626121521,
0.32058170437812805,
0.25747352838516235,
-0.292495459318161,
0.5361447334289551,
-0.6055329442024231,
0.10173748433589935,
-0.303393691778183,
-0.05095334351062775,
-0.8646841049194336,
-0.5164988040924072,
0.32186055183410645,
-0.7735657095909119,
0.16268350183963776,
-0.32604169845581055,
-0.20069186389446259,
-0.05146355181932449,
-0.5926279425621033,
-0.05168010666966438,
0.6541818380355835,
-0.7226398587226868,
0.16545824706554413,
0.6464515328407288,
-0.13259756565093994,
-0.5496975183486938,
-0.3120914697647095,
-0.2378624826669693,
-0.5571402907371521,
-0.4022287428379059,
0.296810120344162,
0.22094619274139404,
-0.14233310520648956,
-0.14011085033416748,
-0.1486831158399582,
0.05989837273955345,
0.43042442202568054,
0.3266333341598511,
0.17344234883785248,
0.18835143744945526,
0.08597234636545181,
-0.2361631542444229,
-0.14343228936195374,
-0.21518225967884064,
-0.20835824310779572,
0.43834900856018066,
-0.16932454705238342,
-0.12313497811555862,
0.09424097090959549,
0.28075122833251953,
0.023914184421300888,
-0.3742600679397583,
0.5399088263511658,
0.5805988311767578,
-0.14121676981449127,
-0.16673216223716736,
-0.2811219394207001,
-0.6054587364196777,
-0.5048328042030334,
0.19977712631225586,
-0.1735396832227707,
-1.1211421489715576,
0.26046422123908997,
0.04972486197948456,
0.20200736820697784,
0.028344906866550446,
0.3268490731716156,
-0.455078125,
0.8888651132583618,
0.5615243315696716,
0.11909770220518112,
0.8788883090019226,
-0.08761869370937347,
0.1388477385044098,
-0.4819645285606384,
-0.5087995529174805,
-0.5711228847503662,
-0.7062289714813232,
-0.5915982723236084,
-0.22901873290538788,
0.31996333599090576,
-0.08656822890043259,
-0.06567694991827011,
0.4564170837402344,
-0.7610873579978943,
0.39605098962783813,
0.6256716847419739,
0.47840195894241333,
-0.28133293986320496,
0.2769029140472412,
0.15898855030536652,
-0.17140232026576996,
-0.533123254776001,
-0.5151848196983337,
0.704343318939209,
0.16295947134494781,
0.8590660691261292,
-0.03894789144396782,
0.8675611615180969,
0.36769166588783264,
0.27767208218574524,
-0.8558737635612488,
0.33093562722206116,
-0.3650668263435364,
-0.5309668183326721,
-0.34543102979660034,
-0.3980543613433838,
-1.1367149353027344,
0.19279654324054718,
-0.2966708540916443,
-0.853966474533081,
0.5526068210601807,
0.36833977699279785,
-0.35360386967658997,
-0.1065513864159584,
-1.1799192428588867,
1.1006677150726318,
-0.7184083461761475,
-0.6041058897972107,
-0.14635856449604034,
-0.7829796671867371,
0.006169424392282963,
0.3190782070159912,
-0.04506528005003929,
-0.23559094965457916,
-0.06189388781785965,
0.6138479113578796,
-0.17174780368804932,
1.0425130128860474,
-0.5313628315925598,
0.48510539531707764,
0.15287639200687408,
-0.01209007203578949,
0.3694658577442169,
0.26888468861579895,
0.05369190126657486,
0.146952286362648,
-0.12959697842597961,
-0.5573990345001221,
-0.7327589988708496,
0.6082407236099243,
-0.7748933434486389,
-0.6663785576820374,
-0.31350985169410706,
-0.20177830755710602,
-0.22974582016468048,
-0.07162795215845108,
-0.005103813484311104,
0.25816941261291504,
0.050463780760765076,
0.34763815999031067,
0.8544194102287292,
-0.24749748408794403,
0.19498753547668457,
0.23060117661952972,
0.04223672300577164,
-0.023091858252882957,
1.2447421550750732,
-0.010078657418489456,
0.10602730512619019,
0.5223159193992615,
0.41191792488098145,
-0.45525264739990234,
-0.3740929961204529,
-0.3253058195114136,
0.1753547340631485,
-0.5956981778144836,
-0.011213625781238079,
-0.5449413061141968,
0.07934509962797165,
-0.05135034769773483,
-0.6566997170448303,
-0.10083319246768951,
-0.308121919631958,
-0.26564764976501465,
-0.10349465906620026,
0.5906406044960022,
0.6235150098800659,
0.09803229570388794,
0.11067422479391098,
-0.4818897843360901,
0.30366355180740356,
0.7230418920516968,
0.43895411491394043,
-0.24515600502490997,
-0.29058241844177246,
-0.11740253865718842,
0.16980840265750885,
-0.2853512465953827,
-0.7630201578140259,
0.5417314767837524,
0.093558169901371,
0.9147956371307373,
0.3899742662906647,
0.05239859223365784,
0.490130215883255,
0.03046908602118492,
0.7161422371864319,
0.13883723318576813,
-0.5473516583442688,
0.7253350615501404,
-0.08981228619813919,
-0.23711620271205902,
0.8148419260978699,
0.6362042427062988,
-0.5299248099327087,
0.16640222072601318,
-0.7403726577758789,
-0.8157681226730347,
0.8144089579582214,
-0.0868917927145958,
0.07886357605457306,
-0.07291513681411743,
0.6162849068641663,
0.28224390745162964,
0.5521159768104553,
-0.5350020527839661,
-0.06949160248041153,
-0.6184435486793518,
-0.2598106861114502,
-0.45800936222076416,
-0.1717950999736786,
-0.27831247448921204,
-0.17227385938167572,
0.0886973887681961,
-0.2788746654987335,
0.14200341701507568,
0.03294758126139641,
-0.14440980553627014,
0.2482629418373108,
0.2240247130393982,
0.27962997555732727,
0.8507323861122131,
-0.45186737179756165,
0.22286315262317657,
-0.10535865277051926,
-0.2735522389411926,
0.08117648214101791,
-0.026602623984217644,
-0.1865488439798355,
-0.11915018409490585,
-0.10050734877586365,
0.8760879039764404,
0.44607001543045044,
-0.7956675291061401,
0.7477073073387146,
-0.24064379930496216,
-0.22116665542125702,
-0.04203291982412338,
0.5108749270439148,
0.28240054845809937,
0.17346200346946716,
0.10478240251541138,
0.0686948299407959,
0.30936259031295776,
-0.8238970637321472,
0.31286266446113586,
0.7391546368598938,
-0.5607463717460632,
-0.1650906652212143,
0.0505269356071949,
0.3161856234073639,
-0.4698837101459503,
0.3240574896335602,
-0.2720794081687927,
-0.5501123070716858,
0.5496265292167664,
0.1197889968752861,
0.757700502872467,
0.1148761436343193,
0.5443984270095825,
0.26010701060295105,
0.004953064955770969,
-0.0481734536588192,
0.11847835034132004,
-0.5757101774215698,
-0.7185074687004089,
-0.0590781532227993,
-0.7522154450416565,
-0.4681941568851471,
-0.40121427178382874,
-0.7156956195831299,
0.5181506276130676,
-0.5080922245979309,
-0.17386583983898163,
0.3054492175579071,
-0.02856213040649891,
-0.6545501947402954,
-0.04440877214074135,
0.12610159814357758,
0.5837048292160034,
-0.7888733148574829,
0.7507433295249939,
1.0133885145187378,
-0.3034948706626892,
-0.6026705503463745,
-0.2243010401725769,
-0.12676778435707092,
-1.0828125476837158,
0.47973307967185974,
0.06832634657621384,
0.034689925611019135,
-0.4705645442008972,
-0.7772138714790344,
-0.4300585687160492,
1.0674771070480347,
0.22311237454414368,
-0.3696286678314209,
-0.054368700832128525,
-0.3136349320411682,
0.33659350872039795,
-0.5311936140060425,
0.3357427418231964,
0.6693652272224426,
0.4942483901977539,
0.4268396198749542,
-0.5738442540168762,
-0.3414115011692047,
0.03394709900021553,
0.12430261820554733,
0.34890344738960266,
-0.7986053228378296,
0.6176193356513977,
-0.2843592166900635,
-0.006121364422142506,
-0.5645154118537903,
0.4071464240550995,
0.47150781750679016,
0.500124454498291,
0.6965272426605225,
0.1641223430633545,
0.7595812678337097,
-0.07983052730560303,
1.0460999011993408,
0.06342733651399612,
0.42015576362609863,
0.7245973348617554,
-0.29989713430404663,
0.87007075548172,
0.45675432682037354,
-0.2817856967449188,
0.5492949485778809,
1.2485798597335815,
0.22220441699028015,
0.8461958169937134,
0.139849454164505,
-0.11391838639974594,
-0.4912906885147095,
-0.1840945929288864,
-0.0822637528181076,
0.4856564402580261,
0.5246921181678772,
-0.24587763845920563,
-0.2176700234413147,
-0.34031209349632263,
-0.28091397881507874,
0.0852108895778656,
-0.31992852687835693,
1.0304585695266724,
-0.1860411912202835,
-0.7966252565383911,
0.49398213624954224,
-0.017311902716755867,
1.0335603952407837,
-0.867168128490448,
-0.308292955160141,
-0.23324033617973328,
-0.03322332724928856,
-0.4209592938423157,
-0.9555056095123291,
0.19670763611793518,
0.08407886326313019,
-0.1227097436785698,
-0.1238684430718422,
0.8295861482620239,
-0.34059208631515503,
-0.0868048220872879,
-0.023042336106300354,
0.0779075026512146,
0.31081947684288025,
0.007257295772433281,
-0.7776066660881042,
-0.1513579934835434,
0.23217225074768066,
-0.06314586102962494,
0.7249278426170349,
0.30513060092926025,
-0.12760981917381287,
0.45383983850479126,
0.685655415058136,
0.18316882848739624,
-0.33130452036857605,
-0.34786075353622437,
0.8501645922660828,
-0.821678102016449,
-0.6978540420532227,
-0.7201159596443176,
0.48211443424224854,
-0.2994937598705292,
-0.23052699863910675,
0.6182461977005005,
0.4294929504394531,
1.0809777975082397,
0.12581326067447662,
0.8430627584457397,
-0.18590709567070007,
0.45905691385269165,
-0.38023605942726135,
0.32511064410209656,
-0.4643494486808777,
0.2387743443250656,
0.0277219470590353,
-0.7390711307525635,
0.17361193895339966,
1.0446096658706665,
-0.6343570351600647,
0.07794076204299927,
0.3937055766582489,
0.8617017269134521,
0.007773555815219879,
-0.0421815887093544,
0.3936409056186676,
-0.34761616587638855,
0.054523974657058716,
0.7772772908210754,
0.9271426200866699,
0.46416226029396057,
0.18594926595687866,
-0.44146209955215454,
-0.44943225383758545,
-0.5192967653274536,
-0.8043892979621887,
-0.7825106978416443,
-0.5323394536972046,
-0.006170412991195917,
-0.26077941060066223,
0.17980776727199554,
1.129459261894226,
0.9812411069869995,
-0.6553112864494324,
-0.3277798295021057,
0.29685261845588684,
0.6323118209838867,
-0.2701025903224945,
-0.23309579491615295,
0.12496258318424225,
-0.39037245512008667,
-0.4135253131389618,
-0.034903787076473236,
0.4217165410518646,
-0.2278733104467392,
-0.27024224400520325,
-0.24951833486557007,
0.06128838285803795,
-0.022372785955667496,
0.4468892216682434,
0.46204087138175964,
-0.6522607803344727,
-0.555667519569397,
0.04986639693379402,
0.09255096316337585,
0.24425441026687622,
1.1708009243011475,
-0.9514134526252747,
0.5200498104095459,
0.4637071192264557,
0.6174715757369995,
0.6842474937438965,
0.23134620487689972,
0.32237508893013,
-0.6926547884941101,
0.3119173049926758,
0.33747103810310364,
0.1416991800069809,
0.3746449053287506,
-0.5713452696800232,
0.23295891284942627,
0.41273877024650574,
-0.45963796973228455,
-0.6280284523963928,
0.29819729924201965,
-0.8443303108215332,
-0.4082457423210144,
1.1328216791152954,
-0.4300600588321686,
-0.6665155291557312,
-0.1481657773256302,
-0.2707382142543793,
-0.29835984110832214,
-0.6425679326057434,
0.7406280636787415,
0.5504672527313232,
-0.31156042218208313,
-0.13173627853393555,
-0.31152793765068054,
0.7322754263877869,
0.2262546867132187,
-0.6291270852088928,
0.16638585925102234,
0.5409798622131348,
0.38081297278404236,
-0.01801331713795662,
0.4712788462638855,
-0.08133228868246078,
0.5316420793533325,
-0.1852475255727768,
0.05833552032709122,
-0.05755149945616722,
-0.46091121435165405,
-0.3728579580783844,
0.27889394760131836,
0.5822619199752808,
-0.1550598293542862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14768v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14768v1
|
WISE: Rethinking the Knowledge Memory for Lifelong Model Editing of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T16:35:52 | 2024-05-23T16:35:52 |
Peng Wang, Zexi Li, Ningyu Zhang, Ziwen Xu, Yunzhi Yao, Yong Jiang, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) need knowledge updates to meet the ever-growing
world facts and correct the hallucinated responses, facilitating the methods of
lifelong model editing. Where the updated knowledge resides in memories is a
fundamental question for model editing. In this paper, we find that editing
either long-term memory (direct model parameters) or working memory
(non-parametric knowledge of neural network activations/representations by
retrieval) will result in an impossible triangle -- reliability,
generalization, and locality can not be realized together in the lifelong
editing settings. For long-term memory, directly editing the parameters will
cause conflicts with irrelevant pretrained knowledge or previous edits (poor
reliability and locality). For working memory, retrieval-based activations can
hardly make the model understand the edits and generalize (poor
generalization). Therefore, we propose WISE to bridge the gap between memories.
In WISE, we design a dual parametric memory scheme, which consists of the main
memory for the pretrained knowledge and a side memory for the edited knowledge.
We only edit the knowledge in the side memory and train a router to decide
which memory to go through when given a query. For continual editing, we devise
a knowledge-sharding mechanism where different sets of edits reside in distinct
subspaces of parameters, and are subsequently merged into a shared memory
without conflicts. Extensive experiments show that WISE can outperform previous
model editing methods and overcome the impossible triangle under lifelong model
editing of question answering, hallucination, and out-of-distribution settings
across trending LLM architectures, e.g., GPT, LLaMA, and Mistral. Code will be
released at https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyEdit.
|
[
-0.07095687836408615,
-1.0780974626541138,
0.7441226243972778,
0.01924968510866165,
-0.18957139551639557,
-0.1544644832611084,
-0.4009494185447693,
-0.41838985681533813,
0.11361883580684662,
0.6773063540458679,
-0.2433360368013382,
-0.34408020973205566,
-0.303149551153183,
-0.21573367714881897,
-0.2545124888420105,
0.841711163520813,
-0.0748758539557457,
0.10554518550634384,
-0.38750579953193665,
-0.5226331353187561,
-0.6663176417350769,
-0.5781086683273315,
-0.9164384007453918,
-0.23305270075798035,
0.5831084251403809,
0.1472485065460205,
0.9822216629981995,
0.6995232701301575,
0.3123936355113983,
0.31776317954063416,
-0.3614273965358734,
0.24472233653068542,
-0.6582044959068298,
0.2016383707523346,
-0.2955581545829773,
-0.39709851145744324,
-0.8807398676872253,
-0.28617802262306213,
0.6055513024330139,
0.5835050344467163,
-0.18267694115638733,
-0.08405947685241699,
0.15219664573669434,
0.880479633808136,
-0.4153009057044983,
-0.10056203603744507,
-0.8825774192810059,
-0.15400776267051697,
-0.1788320243358612,
-0.11214368045330048,
-0.1884617805480957,
-0.23991398513317108,
-0.13094325363636017,
-0.5143496990203857,
0.03160502761602402,
-0.03846973180770874,
0.43308308720588684,
0.36310461163520813,
-0.2506551742553711,
-0.12297747284173965,
-0.6816806197166443,
0.5841686725616455,
-0.7819634675979614,
0.6539548635482788,
0.30175626277923584,
0.05444912984967232,
-0.24576812982559204,
-0.560543417930603,
-0.46777498722076416,
-0.13835668563842773,
0.3217453360557556,
-0.09816109389066696,
-0.05239243060350418,
0.2616531252861023,
0.17107604444026947,
0.2617945969104767,
-0.28050655126571655,
-0.08110293745994568,
-0.48185205459594727,
-0.21527275443077087,
0.629569411277771,
0.16070258617401123,
0.2856556177139282,
-0.07971405237913132,
-0.24585530161857605,
0.3026793897151947,
-0.8599343299865723,
-0.1612413078546524,
0.301429808139801,
-0.007836682721972466,
0.3338558077812195,
0.5769364237785339,
-0.2625402510166168,
1.0917049646377563,
0.19959065318107605,
-0.08218617737293243,
-0.023973366245627403,
-0.24130472540855408,
-0.2671305239200592,
-0.12412639707326889,
0.7642718553543091,
0.5200937986373901,
0.31456032395362854,
-0.42204487323760986,
-0.38964515924453735,
-0.540856122970581,
0.20934472978115082,
-0.5039544701576233,
-0.35981881618499756,
0.14079709351062775,
-0.2569894790649414,
-0.13032476603984833,
-0.3769359886646271,
-0.5828003287315369,
-0.3940395712852478,
-0.34480568766593933,
0.6457074284553528,
-0.6018047332763672,
-0.09531547129154205,
0.4718184173107147,
-0.00013837490405421704,
-0.20047616958618164,
0.2920514643192291,
-0.7258632779121399,
0.001690961653366685,
0.6495737433433533,
0.7174651026725769,
0.10716528445482254,
-0.565962016582489,
-0.28839534521102905,
0.5065555572509766,
-0.30479374527931213,
0.7011427879333496,
-0.6683632135391235,
-0.25270411372184753,
-0.26595979928970337,
-0.35830047726631165,
0.013048366643488407,
-0.5527785420417786,
0.15024450421333313,
-1.0511726140975952,
0.11453129351139069,
-0.37192434072494507,
-0.6834998726844788,
-0.12500928342342377,
0.20646405220031738,
-0.7267612814903259,
0.9934367537498474,
-0.10494276136159897,
-0.8099883794784546,
0.07172361761331558,
-0.501750648021698,
-0.28599822521209717,
-0.22586442530155182,
0.1220100149512291,
-0.3018483817577362,
0.13467639684677124,
0.15790432691574097,
0.29981037974357605,
-0.03702480345964432,
0.8261439800262451,
-0.45573747158050537,
-0.3086143732070923,
0.30626142024993896,
-0.33739331364631653,
0.6878620386123657,
-0.03403819724917412,
0.12042135000228882,
0.2732663154602051,
-0.7522777318954468,
-0.05377931147813797,
-0.012870585545897484,
-0.46277302503585815,
-0.5535483360290527,
-0.10653970390558243,
-0.31778112053871155,
0.28216779232025146,
0.6718829870223999,
-0.3574961721897125,
0.46267810463905334,
-0.22491610050201416,
0.6412745714187622,
0.9383823871612549,
0.3321109414100647,
0.5409095287322998,
-0.5676631927490234,
0.30123862624168396,
0.08670780062675476,
0.2987000048160553,
0.30044251680374146,
-0.44877734780311584,
-0.930334746837616,
0.23917271196842194,
0.24524031579494476,
0.5226128101348877,
-0.7960448861122131,
0.09803278744220734,
-0.33722150325775146,
-0.3577457070350647,
-0.3549603223800659,
0.49182257056236267,
0.35035011172294617,
0.5740191340446472,
0.5266730189323425,
-0.016520103439688683,
-0.6076516509056091,
-0.8403385877609253,
-0.6656026840209961,
-0.17155756056308746,
0.10949438065290451,
0.11914084106683731,
0.3240874707698822,
-0.21615764498710632,
0.8763843774795532,
-0.38855618238449097,
-0.047896482050418854,
-0.20604804158210754,
-0.21466408669948578,
-0.011661093682050705,
0.36348703503608704,
0.0867336168885231,
-0.5929323434829712,
-0.26577937602996826,
-0.35238194465637207,
-0.6996417045593262,
0.12269654124975204,
-0.2847428321838379,
-0.25102493166923523,
0.03900738060474396,
0.7647891640663147,
-0.7954831719398499,
0.2315531224012375,
0.28784048557281494,
-0.14278756082057953,
0.6153995394706726,
-0.49672019481658936,
0.06769604235887527,
-1.009304165840149,
-0.14541028439998627,
-0.28443676233291626,
-0.17757995426654816,
-0.6441799998283386,
0.19950860738754272,
0.322000116109848,
0.0163173396140337,
-0.34406545758247375,
0.6796079874038696,
-0.5218784809112549,
0.18614381551742554,
-0.1815066635608673,
0.2147824764251709,
-0.08733828365802765,
0.6654748916625977,
-0.16906145215034485,
0.6592037677764893,
0.49982118606567383,
-0.6481650471687317,
0.4770311713218689,
0.2028009444475174,
-0.27362900972366333,
0.5427618026733398,
-0.5536859035491943,
0.48945680260658264,
-0.2197321653366089,
0.2030802071094513,
-0.591848611831665,
0.04363444074988365,
0.213588148355484,
-0.2433158904314041,
0.17576450109481812,
-0.022241732105612755,
-0.5514752268791199,
-0.05429701507091522,
-0.3032805025577545,
0.5809020400047302,
0.15056505799293518,
-0.4243519902229309,
0.6710574626922607,
0.38146349787712097,
-0.1861410290002823,
-0.5125985741615295,
-0.7436215281486511,
0.4856771230697632,
-0.2211838811635971,
-0.9253090620040894,
0.38289880752563477,
-0.29637548327445984,
-0.4011651575565338,
0.21342125535011292,
-0.18202757835388184,
-0.2166794240474701,
-0.23042431473731995,
-0.06314001977443695,
0.23886001110076904,
-0.15104344487190247,
0.44204583764076233,
0.1668960601091385,
-0.21730419993400574,
-0.06029374152421951,
-0.38165736198425293,
0.40434950590133667,
-0.15299031138420105,
-0.32803767919540405,
-0.3026423454284668,
0.23335057497024536,
0.6326559782028198,
-0.4128025472164154,
0.787022590637207,
0.18759869039058685,
-0.44793251156806946,
-0.08002246916294098,
-0.920346200466156,
-0.022784031927585602,
-0.462216317653656,
0.5382449626922607,
-0.49009671807289124,
-1.0571471452713013,
0.58013916015625,
0.07862038910388947,
0.1839289665222168,
0.3368467688560486,
0.2703695297241211,
-0.031219566240906715,
0.6284717321395874,
0.6733614206314087,
-0.16229601204395294,
0.31636565923690796,
-0.036832429468631744,
0.35692107677459717,
-1.1821413040161133,
-0.09187168627977371,
0.019306929782032967,
-0.4894142746925354,
-0.1828937530517578,
-0.580075740814209,
0.3502483665943146,
0.47527334094047546,
-0.33036771416664124,
0.061176709830760956,
-0.22589422762393951,
0.6446565985679626,
0.43289098143577576,
0.393151193857193,
0.6415325999259949,
-0.32000190019607544,
-0.004470349755138159,
-0.06527760624885559,
-0.7871541380882263,
-0.2281569093465805,
1.3274171352386475,
0.12889166176319122,
0.6814908981323242,
0.08614654839038849,
0.7748074531555176,
-0.04467826336622238,
0.04638996720314026,
-0.4889610707759857,
0.8596624732017517,
-0.01459234207868576,
-0.538844645023346,
-0.3942684531211853,
-0.3999820947647095,
-0.5051922798156738,
0.058880921453237534,
-0.009736217558383942,
-0.6058752536773682,
0.08663657307624817,
0.3835720419883728,
-0.5426422953605652,
0.9003707766532898,
-0.43301406502723694,
0.6985102295875549,
-0.43006083369255066,
-0.5222788453102112,
-0.5257697105407715,
-0.5604772567749023,
0.5118600726127625,
-0.17867998778820038,
0.16642023622989655,
0.39108195900917053,
-0.2308749556541443,
0.9026654362678528,
-0.4556792378425598,
0.7174003720283508,
-0.1644926816225052,
0.054546892642974854,
0.25990307331085205,
0.3591642379760742,
0.6395926475524902,
0.2876494824886322,
-0.24051553010940552,
0.06028314679861069,
-0.05542944371700287,
-0.30230438709259033,
-0.7470766305923462,
0.7146469354629517,
-0.5538285970687866,
-0.9006586670875549,
-0.2180815190076828,
-0.9510740041732788,
-0.6316313147544861,
0.21275201439857483,
-0.04957287758588791,
0.410489559173584,
-0.12727484107017517,
0.1428120881319046,
0.9469060897827148,
-0.25453072786331177,
0.19212523102760315,
0.3754015564918518,
-0.5186537504196167,
-0.42515137791633606,
0.8401675820350647,
0.3487694263458252,
0.4683546721935272,
0.29544153809547424,
0.2515122592449188,
-0.07628705352544785,
-0.8464470505714417,
-0.23089033365249634,
0.3287561237812042,
-0.772537887096405,
-0.13866399228572845,
-0.7951037287712097,
-0.48313629627227783,
-0.2513740062713623,
-0.20471084117889404,
-0.37961071729660034,
-0.4093489944934845,
-0.1514623463153839,
-0.11606265604496002,
0.5847494006156921,
0.8019000291824341,
-0.5343323945999146,
0.12171199917793274,
-0.707332193851471,
0.6014378666877747,
0.6341185569763184,
0.4191397726535797,
0.29301875829696655,
-0.516374945640564,
-0.2371080219745636,
0.26690980792045593,
-0.03939666226506233,
-0.8788886666297913,
0.11108123511075974,
0.08410061150789261,
0.32886892557144165,
0.2610475718975067,
-0.15337616205215454,
1.0560799837112427,
-0.4539467692375183,
0.4848705232143402,
-0.01915280893445015,
-0.898801326751709,
0.2134505957365036,
-0.47843316197395325,
0.35829076170921326,
0.7667285203933716,
-0.013037300668656826,
-0.9732204675674438,
-0.509308934211731,
-0.5616306662559509,
-0.6512534022331238,
0.3198169767856598,
-0.421524316072464,
0.08309390395879745,
0.03990297019481659,
0.6711040139198303,
0.05268419161438942,
0.16662412881851196,
-0.6782424449920654,
-0.0024641624186187983,
-0.04594026133418083,
0.024561496451497078,
0.17337337136268616,
-0.555142879486084,
0.06354646384716034,
-0.6180384159088135,
0.7967894077301025,
0.28208228945732117,
0.11260880529880524,
0.09177499264478683,
-0.24582616984844208,
-0.08527131378650665,
0.3837398886680603,
0.4777106046676636,
1.0830557346343994,
-0.22661349177360535,
0.019987449049949646,
0.4952339231967926,
-0.2670027017593384,
-0.12347009032964706,
-0.28539952635765076,
-0.35431721806526184,
-0.23608948290348053,
0.17959825694561005,
0.7312674522399902,
0.5204746127128601,
-0.3849826455116272,
0.1850045919418335,
-0.02342963218688965,
-0.16110141575336456,
-0.09626282006502151,
0.18007072806358337,
0.6785754561424255,
0.2880157232284546,
0.03997747600078583,
0.34696897864341736,
-0.183121457695961,
-0.4023052752017975,
0.24149014055728912,
0.4582425653934479,
-0.30051490664482117,
-0.16651399433612823,
0.622883677482605,
0.03405873849987984,
-0.5022657513618469,
0.8299415707588196,
-0.3924276530742645,
-0.5744832158088684,
0.14189507067203522,
0.5321525931358337,
0.6346906423568726,
-0.17699231207370758,
-0.006131545640528202,
0.35765740275382996,
0.30708712339401245,
-0.20155519247055054,
0.19412238895893097,
0.05143992602825165,
-0.7650380730628967,
-0.37651756405830383,
-0.4729343056678772,
-0.22831451892852783,
0.3559708893299103,
-0.5490553975105286,
0.0871662124991417,
-0.6231015920639038,
0.08312173187732697,
-0.5803627967834473,
-0.17719115316867828,
-0.49778300523757935,
0.12204456329345703,
-0.25668859481811523,
0.8844668865203857,
-0.44443076848983765,
1.1921401023864746,
0.3369821608066559,
-0.2004234790802002,
-0.7514019012451172,
-0.042425431311130524,
0.04444991797208786,
-0.9025507569313049,
0.24509842693805695,
-0.1080588772892952,
-0.0972365066409111,
0.07008569687604904,
-0.5043020844459534,
-0.8427672386169434,
1.008895754814148,
0.3137396574020386,
-0.8079365491867065,
-0.3992367684841156,
0.06824831664562225,
0.42750123143196106,
0.1000264585018158,
-0.2388383001089096,
0.5501726269721985,
0.5984922647476196,
0.09156797081232071,
-0.7008142471313477,
-0.01593746617436409,
-0.1428748220205307,
-0.07321488112211227,
0.2892323136329651,
-0.7807215452194214,
0.9529094099998474,
-0.39518705010414124,
-0.07917963713407516,
0.23658783733844757,
0.7963107228279114,
0.2560311257839203,
0.04983679950237274,
0.3821530342102051,
1.0408718585968018,
0.9084799885749817,
0.2652488648891449,
0.6381999254226685,
-0.5262827277183533,
0.1238088309764862,
1.340889811515808,
-0.1282593011856079,
0.9120962023735046,
0.6242043375968933,
0.006908576004207134,
0.30584871768951416,
0.37676241993904114,
0.22117267549037933,
0.3864699602127075,
0.041358429938554764,
-0.36343511939048767,
-0.37395378947257996,
0.372715562582016,
-0.4377201199531555,
0.2717917859554291,
0.1925712525844574,
0.06387083232402802,
-0.17738354206085205,
0.0016576602356508374,
0.3748515248298645,
-0.0817185714840889,
-0.3745366632938385,
0.7356384992599487,
0.1918153464794159,
-0.6261811852455139,
0.44429370760917664,
0.21525335311889648,
0.8082633018493652,
-0.6579768657684326,
0.19531314074993134,
-0.23582570254802704,
0.07981585711240768,
-0.11796551942825317,
-0.8082248568534851,
0.5638097524642944,
0.0171400997787714,
-0.10833130776882172,
-0.3774562180042267,
0.7645503282546997,
-0.6152533292770386,
-0.5730332732200623,
0.3025549352169037,
0.6134824156761169,
-0.13316334784030914,
-0.36398419737815857,
-0.9100372195243835,
0.03734733909368515,
0.1320696622133255,
-0.2815934121608734,
0.4292433559894562,
0.5709137916564941,
0.014958563260734081,
0.7789230346679688,
0.6376522183418274,
0.3502303659915924,
0.16088418662548065,
-0.10935988277196884,
0.8044745326042175,
-0.957142174243927,
-0.4834066331386566,
-0.9595188498497009,
0.47240278124809265,
0.0534454807639122,
-0.34905481338500977,
0.5932436585426331,
0.5122693777084351,
0.6809831261634827,
0.15214143693447113,
0.6099523901939392,
0.05040017515420914,
0.20921343564987183,
-0.7083755135536194,
1.0464842319488525,
-0.5033804178237915,
0.2534543573856354,
-0.038930222392082214,
-0.9706900715827942,
-0.31345075368881226,
0.3882790207862854,
-0.6383870244026184,
0.05616958811879158,
0.7885810732841492,
1.0243806838989258,
-0.1266518533229828,
0.08001210540533066,
0.2476666271686554,
0.6157428026199341,
0.24869340658187866,
1.0728200674057007,
0.7710399031639099,
-0.2651485800743103,
0.4660711884498596,
-0.35271361470222473,
0.014906490221619606,
0.06917556375265121,
-0.7675837278366089,
-0.8443405628204346,
-0.6792848110198975,
-0.15630362927913666,
-0.21080701053142548,
0.4484419524669647,
0.504460871219635,
0.248649463057518,
-0.33883020281791687,
-0.1377859264612198,
-0.12947840988636017,
0.29925015568733215,
-0.08703317493200302,
-0.15477557480335236,
0.491950660943985,
-0.08268599212169647,
-0.20017009973526,
0.5253766179084778,
0.5145784020423889,
-0.24042779207229614,
-0.3072766661643982,
-0.12125565856695175,
-0.3640722632408142,
0.10534118860960007,
0.3523585796356201,
0.29779937863349915,
-0.5410839319229126,
-0.4607451558113098,
-0.054023828357458115,
-0.0804930180311203,
0.19371578097343445,
0.665077269077301,
-0.7184970378875732,
0.5232115387916565,
0.4548616409301758,
0.7998406887054443,
0.21943645179271698,
-0.23140949010849,
0.5056931972503662,
-0.2620784640312195,
-0.005804206244647503,
0.21647189557552338,
0.443938285112381,
0.4355778396129608,
-0.31290990114212036,
0.013035139068961143,
0.17522284388542175,
-0.7375693321228027,
-0.6000247001647949,
0.18851666152477264,
-0.9354645013809204,
-0.3259759843349457,
1.095036506652832,
0.23878365755081177,
-0.36109012365341187,
-0.1576562523841858,
-0.21720784902572632,
0.3265397250652313,
-0.09662796556949615,
0.953296959400177,
0.8351296782493591,
-0.13179288804531097,
-0.07635873556137085,
-0.6463472843170166,
0.34037378430366516,
0.45996883511543274,
-0.5340183973312378,
0.2782957851886749,
0.7115500569343567,
0.5120734572410583,
-0.27845606207847595,
0.7097480297088623,
-0.11969082057476044,
0.3889477550983429,
-0.14225782454013824,
-0.0386156290769577,
-0.5471498966217041,
-0.5192292332649231,
-0.41482895612716675,
0.1287114918231964,
0.12592515349388123,
0.21324913203716278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14767v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14767v2
|
FinRobot: An Open-Source AI Agent Platform for Financial Applications using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T16:35:20 | 2024-05-27T12:43:42 |
Hongyang Yang, Boyu Zhang, Neng Wang, Cheng Guo, Xiaoli Zhang, Likun Lin, Junlin Wang, Tianyu Zhou, Mao Guan, Runjia Zhang, Christina Dan Wang
|
q-fin.ST
|
q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.TR
|
As financial institutions and professionals increasingly incorporate Large
Language Models (LLMs) into their workflows, substantial barriers, including
proprietary data and specialized knowledge, persist between the finance sector
and the AI community. These challenges impede the AI community's ability to
enhance financial tasks effectively. Acknowledging financial analysis's
critical role, we aim to devise financial-specialized LLM-based toolchains and
democratize access to them through open-source initiatives, promoting wider AI
adoption in financial decision-making. In this paper, we introduce FinRobot, a
novel open-source AI agent platform supporting multiple financially specialized
AI agents, each powered by LLM. Specifically, the platform consists of four
major layers: 1) the Financial AI Agents layer that formulates Financial
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) by breaking sophisticated financial problems down into
logical sequences; 2) the Financial LLM Algorithms layer dynamically configures
appropriate model application strategies for specific tasks; 3) the LLMOps and
DataOps layer produces accurate models by applying training/fine-tuning
techniques and using task-relevant data; 4) the Multi-source LLM Foundation
Models layer that integrates various LLMs and enables the above layers to
access them directly. Finally, FinRobot provides hands-on for both
professional-grade analysts and laypersons to utilize powerful AI techniques
for advanced financial analysis. We open-source FinRobot at
\url{https://github.com/AI4Finance-Foundation/FinRobot}.
|
[
-0.1179845854640007,
-0.7779995799064636,
0.3819834291934967,
0.2628282308578491,
-0.05398137494921684,
0.6475924849510193,
-0.26860785484313965,
-0.6853907108306885,
0.0734538808465004,
0.8974466919898987,
-0.21168097853660583,
-0.7215551137924194,
-0.3862643837928772,
-0.16441960632801056,
-0.18245939910411835,
1.0388214588165283,
-0.019912488758563995,
0.14436395466327667,
-0.1838819831609726,
0.028259506449103355,
-0.16751332581043243,
-0.3093281090259552,
-1.0443886518478394,
-0.42987024784088135,
0.35822510719299316,
0.39945289492607117,
0.7942920327186584,
0.464325875043869,
0.7845068573951721,
0.500500500202179,
0.5525087714195251,
-0.183465376496315,
-0.08006784319877625,
-0.034463319927453995,
-0.3500185012817383,
-0.5705865621566772,
-0.8381124138832092,
0.12796780467033386,
0.21819289028644562,
0.22661080956459045,
-0.23559264838695526,
0.24862392246723175,
-0.27500689029693604,
0.7223387360572815,
-0.5309200882911682,
0.6936371326446533,
-0.49052274227142334,
-0.2812957465648651,
-0.24797800183296204,
0.0695883259177208,
-0.38506537675857544,
-0.21433863043785095,
0.09956596791744232,
-0.5801936984062195,
-0.07927894592285156,
-0.07012807577848434,
0.4535752236843109,
0.38347628712654114,
-0.15391969680786133,
-0.2534138858318329,
-0.8116189241409302,
0.5249927043914795,
-0.59127277135849,
0.31414175033569336,
0.3706775903701782,
0.7697649598121643,
0.10178506374359131,
-0.644004762172699,
-0.37222886085510254,
-0.3837319016456604,
0.17069923877716064,
0.02469305321574211,
-0.4464806318283081,
0.0442575104534626,
-0.2085200548171997,
0.0597689114511013,
-0.224600687623024,
0.32971325516700745,
-0.4712243676185608,
-0.21381902694702148,
0.6098107695579529,
0.03166978433728218,
-0.03579365462064743,
0.3823646605014801,
-0.6379606127738953,
-0.27874043583869934,
-0.27490997314453125,
0.07787898927927017,
0.6669891476631165,
0.5563883185386658,
-0.2415233701467514,
0.44665050506591797,
-0.00410069664940238,
0.5675013065338135,
-0.2126280814409256,
-0.3844519853591919,
0.3948623836040497,
0.07141882926225662,
-0.2487361580133438,
0.2451552450656891,
0.8445008993148804,
0.017689649015665054,
0.2971976697444916,
0.022147759795188904,
-0.513416588306427,
-0.3578806519508362,
0.2941133379936218,
-0.13550631701946259,
-0.02278941310942173,
0.621386706829071,
-0.2612401247024536,
-0.5060501098632812,
0.15127550065517426,
-0.8701443076133728,
-0.5269255638122559,
-0.23201946914196014,
0.29647719860076904,
-0.2330169677734375,
-0.07774081081151962,
0.17551545798778534,
-0.3594832718372345,
0.40524861216545105,
0.405082643032074,
-0.6636714339256287,
0.5204378366470337,
1.1000287532806396,
0.7502862811088562,
0.18279293179512024,
-0.29665613174438477,
-0.7758524417877197,
0.4250339865684509,
-0.19490128755569458,
0.8624671101570129,
-0.58315509557724,
-0.04096679762005806,
-0.16915826499462128,
-0.28544744849205017,
0.027776330709457397,
-0.3571931719779968,
0.10828664153814316,
-0.5316052436828613,
-0.1824871450662613,
0.4434851109981537,
-0.33832383155822754,
-0.2620212733745575,
0.2428160458803177,
-0.8641697764396667,
0.5820474028587341,
0.4008353352546692,
-0.4864825904369354,
0.05486973747611046,
-0.9986141920089722,
-0.32515496015548706,
0.3883272707462311,
-0.23344072699546814,
-0.2529512345790863,
-0.3609659671783447,
0.035600773990154266,
0.38672468066215515,
-0.7935910224914551,
0.3370217978954315,
-0.4255165159702301,
-0.31636205315589905,
0.41109585762023926,
-0.35537657141685486,
0.5383874177932739,
0.07143641263246536,
-0.5802838802337646,
0.6531637907028198,
-0.6728578209877014,
-0.3965700566768646,
0.29840514063835144,
0.19105371832847595,
-0.3659568130970001,
-0.03492176905274391,
0.22812983393669128,
-0.0163659006357193,
0.6560786366462708,
-0.5568339228630066,
0.14606866240501404,
-0.4250901937484741,
0.7858297228813171,
1.138549566268921,
-0.49187174439430237,
0.28034329414367676,
-0.4043318033218384,
0.7078102231025696,
-0.35797056555747986,
0.3052932918071747,
0.007890330627560616,
-0.21554149687290192,
-0.27446621656417847,
-0.6520150899887085,
0.22012104094028473,
0.807762622833252,
-0.5327357649803162,
0.4848627746105194,
0.0418015792965889,
-0.8317654132843018,
-0.5802003145217896,
0.22592613101005554,
0.06935594230890274,
0.3803972899913788,
0.11832462251186371,
0.08257090300321579,
-0.19915178418159485,
-1.0879271030426025,
-0.0032050840090960264,
-0.3449348509311676,
-0.1008746400475502,
0.24118542671203613,
0.5371193885803223,
-0.322503000497818,
0.7803699374198914,
-0.5044945478439331,
-0.5653952360153198,
-0.4310818016529083,
-0.054475829005241394,
0.2913857102394104,
0.4522342085838318,
0.8427558541297913,
-0.8171235918998718,
-0.1533733755350113,
0.47990623116493225,
-0.4029291570186615,
0.08250977843999863,
-0.339441180229187,
-0.21279661357402802,
0.2241334617137909,
0.4425491392612457,
-0.6301264762878418,
0.30651798844337463,
0.5217733979225159,
-0.3785649538040161,
0.3575931191444397,
-0.3286362290382385,
-0.262055903673172,
-0.8998256921768188,
0.43372541666030884,
-0.005027046427130699,
-0.24883206188678741,
-0.30547288060188293,
0.24761845171451569,
-0.26175323128700256,
-0.10658613592386246,
-0.14267732203006744,
0.9187625050544739,
0.1352805644273758,
-0.4157547950744629,
-0.3951224386692047,
0.45994430780410767,
-0.03396269679069519,
0.400619238615036,
-0.12418092042207718,
0.797515332698822,
0.6236171722412109,
-0.0777587965130806,
0.7413152456283569,
0.1377478390932083,
-0.050958313047885895,
0.38869738578796387,
-0.810767650604248,
0.10781801491975784,
0.19549866020679474,
0.24711087346076965,
-0.8131044507026672,
-0.2610236406326294,
0.6757160425186157,
-0.18176522850990295,
-0.09095025062561035,
0.20055663585662842,
-0.44925132393836975,
-0.37627556920051575,
-0.3469378352165222,
0.28568965196609497,
0.12931615114212036,
-0.3140767216682434,
1.0107866525650024,
0.5144238471984863,
-0.5294370651245117,
-0.8400115966796875,
-0.399215430021286,
0.1093442440032959,
-0.028268082067370415,
-0.5933067798614502,
0.13136982917785645,
0.08105470985174179,
-0.7318676114082336,
0.11964422464370728,
-0.07368320226669312,
-0.0087759830057621,
0.25156328082084656,
0.21872460842132568,
0.6729698777198792,
-0.15939900279045105,
0.13993212580680847,
-0.012747248634696007,
-0.3466148376464844,
0.06048824265599251,
-0.5238409638404846,
0.6163203120231628,
-0.4464341104030609,
-0.34285902976989746,
-0.38198989629745483,
0.006148424465209246,
0.8725938200950623,
-0.7015565633773804,
0.7162268757820129,
0.5154886841773987,
-0.162856325507164,
-0.3056192994117737,
-0.5188788175582886,
0.2788821756839752,
-0.5358652472496033,
0.06403061002492905,
-0.31820228695869446,
-1.0290523767471313,
0.8272811770439148,
-0.07421093434095383,
0.34727248549461365,
0.6908133625984192,
0.6606013178825378,
0.15344619750976562,
0.48535215854644775,
0.762039065361023,
-0.44223251938819885,
0.5262371897697449,
-0.1847754269838333,
0.03325442224740982,
-0.23522397875785828,
-0.4236430823802948,
-0.6262614130973816,
-0.27652257680892944,
-0.3521368205547333,
-0.5341677069664001,
0.23717854917049408,
-0.08610403537750244,
-0.4053471088409424,
0.124612957239151,
-0.20952509343624115,
0.4495890140533447,
0.6661632657051086,
-0.0318254791200161,
0.1696138083934784,
-0.14726048707962036,
0.03628169372677803,
0.7280940413475037,
-0.42090269923210144,
-0.5611346960067749,
1.089359164237976,
0.6380090117454529,
0.8207632899284363,
-0.12279871106147766,
0.49527204036712646,
0.6954760551452637,
0.34447333216667175,
-0.7562863230705261,
0.40371254086494446,
-0.18827280402183533,
-0.4130566716194153,
-0.5086317658424377,
-0.46848735213279724,
-0.7163335680961609,
-0.10114119201898575,
0.005729402415454388,
-0.4953785240650177,
0.05056697130203247,
-0.17435191571712494,
-0.46617281436920166,
0.42582210898399353,
-0.20848175883293152,
0.8846952319145203,
-0.4805503785610199,
-0.21017372608184814,
-0.3986406922340393,
-0.5531360507011414,
0.30204853415489197,
-0.5823615193367004,
0.5059289336204529,
-0.30179035663604736,
-0.3575935363769531,
0.43138912320137024,
-0.6876147985458374,
0.949587881565094,
-0.13602003455162048,
-0.43320271372795105,
0.6702369451522827,
-0.11102248728275299,
0.6158319115638733,
0.07544593513011932,
-0.23167936503887177,
0.42674779891967773,
-0.25182563066482544,
-0.5342749357223511,
-0.5251819491386414,
0.5539586544036865,
-0.7949641346931458,
-0.4999822974205017,
-0.4015011191368103,
-0.5941502451896667,
-0.10664907842874527,
0.2978529930114746,
-0.5088381171226501,
0.021645348519086838,
-0.11958138644695282,
0.02979191020131111,
-0.14116570353507996,
-0.24871528148651123,
0.2996000051498413,
0.4578341841697693,
-0.21611151099205017,
-0.6315931677818298,
0.7881645560264587,
-0.404285192489624,
0.09152370691299438,
0.38283392786979675,
0.2530227601528168,
-0.19185495376586914,
-0.3784984350204468,
-0.3717228174209595,
0.2824253737926483,
-0.6391966938972473,
-0.3691002130508423,
-0.22738516330718994,
-0.13995420932769775,
-0.6261988282203674,
-0.48402267694473267,
-0.42225122451782227,
-0.2947128117084503,
0.02505509741604328,
-0.32963716983795166,
0.8992758989334106,
0.7109104990959167,
-0.308001309633255,
0.27798497676849365,
-0.9360949993133545,
0.28625407814979553,
0.16535288095474243,
0.6354654431343079,
0.043011344969272614,
0.10535015165805817,
-0.31879594922065735,
-0.09926293045282364,
0.2166908234357834,
-0.44123101234436035,
0.24418768286705017,
-0.07213550060987473,
0.6518827676773071,
0.6925130486488342,
0.011191862635314465,
0.3119795322418213,
-0.016076894477009773,
0.324074387550354,
0.07723528891801834,
-1.0546748638153076,
0.43668973445892334,
-0.527975857257843,
0.14660143852233887,
0.5473534464836121,
0.250719279050827,
-0.3693767786026001,
-0.7246003150939941,
-0.3827497959136963,
-0.8834713697433472,
0.7800633311271667,
0.03431403636932373,
-0.11450815945863724,
0.18228353559970856,
0.3787344992160797,
0.5220850110054016,
0.5715110301971436,
-0.4149114787578583,
0.049707118421792984,
-0.18983548879623413,
-0.21137821674346924,
-0.2622028589248657,
0.28707703948020935,
-0.2305857390165329,
0.04870779067277908,
0.5937783122062683,
-0.37879204750061035,
-0.05734989419579506,
-0.018150843679904938,
0.27624547481536865,
-0.16293016076087952,
-0.006835226435214281,
0.5091913938522339,
0.7458695769309998,
-0.3136540949344635,
-0.09250609576702118,
-0.3190429210662842,
-0.46773561835289,
-0.04307405650615692,
0.48401591181755066,
-0.08330496400594711,
-0.30673474073410034,
0.6169145107269287,
0.6080606579780579,
0.26246997714042664,
-1.321502923965454,
0.34394949674606323,
0.15829981863498688,
-0.19487881660461426,
-0.7766667604446411,
0.2118602842092514,
-0.049245402216911316,
0.97789067029953,
0.58094322681427,
0.38861700892448425,
-0.05174119397997856,
-0.6437878608703613,
0.31924816966056824,
0.2824067771434784,
-0.3579956293106079,
-0.10682827234268188,
0.7843214273452759,
0.3798198103904724,
-0.34700632095336914,
0.7697241902351379,
0.21135380864143372,
-0.46301084756851196,
0.9127553105354309,
0.2548618018627167,
1.141932725906372,
-0.024095145985484123,
0.4810556471347809,
-0.21272967755794525,
0.30009299516677856,
-0.1630357950925827,
0.35968855023384094,
-0.09464498609304428,
-0.6664307117462158,
-0.5261525511741638,
-0.6506711840629578,
-0.7108082175254822,
-0.14980705082416534,
-0.44572633504867554,
0.21835078299045563,
-0.900425910949707,
-0.24756889045238495,
0.0952162817120552,
-0.17848744988441467,
-0.4547995924949646,
-0.21739289164543152,
0.2763581871986389,
1.080399990081787,
-0.3505091071128845,
0.6671557426452637,
0.6561246514320374,
-0.46563997864723206,
-0.3514719605445862,
-0.24905367195606232,
-0.0030583501793444157,
-0.8319051265716553,
0.5002927184104919,
0.03117922693490982,
-0.5036905407905579,
-0.13919241726398468,
-0.6294320225715637,
-0.7541182041168213,
1.1293858289718628,
0.5537353157997131,
-0.6360195279121399,
-0.13089768588542938,
0.3231791853904724,
0.5150051116943359,
-0.6084488034248352,
-0.026384789496660233,
0.4292725622653961,
0.8432803750038147,
0.2237042784690857,
-0.8461211919784546,
-0.18682442605495453,
-0.24936778843402863,
-0.5783768892288208,
0.3698467016220093,
-0.9944371581077576,
0.902225911617279,
-0.23701637983322144,
0.337952196598053,
0.07704527676105499,
0.494985967874527,
0.3267197012901306,
0.7053494453430176,
0.552649974822998,
0.07890424132347107,
0.793576180934906,
0.11132505536079407,
0.9921647906303406,
-0.6285319328308105,
0.1321191042661667,
0.9516711831092834,
-0.507542610168457,
0.862974226474762,
0.11664462834596634,
-0.041819363832473755,
0.5508453845977783,
0.3397988975048065,
-0.43601199984550476,
0.005566991865634918,
0.08788041770458221,
-0.18614009022712708,
-0.38791903853416443,
-0.036642953753471375,
-0.034705668687820435,
0.9031313061714172,
0.2326163351535797,
-0.23237572610378265,
0.039452873170375824,
0.24257974326610565,
-0.19298489391803741,
0.10738097876310349,
-0.5252678990364075,
0.45284709334373474,
0.046706825494766235,
-0.13329799473285675,
-0.21155378222465515,
0.26347795128822327,
0.27311450242996216,
-0.9888829588890076,
-0.09297915548086166,
-0.044439371675252914,
0.24837149679660797,
0.10735568404197693,
-0.6458616852760315,
0.2484268695116043,
0.1021229699254036,
0.14565248787403107,
-0.25592610239982605,
0.8668302893638611,
-0.037162598222494125,
-0.6726087927818298,
0.6272598505020142,
0.5433244705200195,
0.07990775257349014,
-0.18701928853988647,
-0.7805472016334534,
-0.03961148113012314,
-0.3659377098083496,
-0.15297625958919525,
0.1883508712053299,
0.44050300121307373,
-0.28804242610931396,
0.9186328053474426,
0.9160478711128235,
-0.006692072842270136,
-0.5062766075134277,
0.03254477307200432,
0.8500203490257263,
-0.9328485727310181,
-0.5591601729393005,
-0.8772798180580139,
0.27116817235946655,
0.06682168692350388,
-0.19264519214630127,
0.5054288506507874,
0.7173175811767578,
0.8705648183822632,
-0.058691829442977905,
0.7109104990959167,
0.22705891728401184,
0.09398935735225677,
-0.3497580885887146,
0.7612784504890442,
-0.40387997031211853,
0.29561078548431396,
-0.4627690613269806,
-0.7523608207702637,
-0.3040425777435303,
0.4017511308193207,
-0.29828086495399475,
-0.11214148253202438,
0.12849941849708557,
0.2493589222431183,
0.23832277953624725,
0.0765380784869194,
0.11485138535499573,
0.06786047667264938,
0.1706714779138565,
0.25504204630851746,
0.4976649582386017,
0.08385318517684937,
0.5939819812774658,
-0.16611725091934204,
-0.1861959993839264,
-0.3238658308982849,
-0.47190237045288086,
-0.8234527111053467,
-0.29957303404808044,
-0.23285891115665436,
0.03978259116411209,
-0.05379996821284294,
1.0689873695373535,
0.21100397408008575,
-0.5986633896827698,
-0.7124415040016174,
0.19551590085029602,
0.3101591467857361,
-0.46126630902290344,
-0.18492169678211212,
0.3413914144039154,
-0.15960267186164856,
-0.6838558316230774,
0.6313480138778687,
0.6338662505149841,
-0.05386855825781822,
-0.6558246612548828,
0.00325224781408906,
0.06271945685148239,
0.25322866439819336,
0.529462993144989,
0.21352382004261017,
-0.3823457956314087,
-0.21448788046836853,
-0.015185505151748657,
-0.04030492529273033,
-0.03716030716896057,
0.9367331266403198,
-0.5025976896286011,
0.20990291237831116,
0.40138888359069824,
0.7582744359970093,
0.12195616960525513,
0.10421667993068695,
0.7531273365020752,
-0.1278531700372696,
0.36451420187950134,
0.2738502025604248,
0.15698902308940887,
-0.24187879264354706,
-0.4470842778682709,
0.692762017250061,
0.08464272320270538,
-0.2866862714290619,
-0.6019216775894165,
-0.18188539147377014,
-1.0252777338027954,
-0.6442737579345703,
0.5915422439575195,
-0.06156367436051369,
-0.5713726282119751,
0.009322629310190678,
-0.20348607003688812,
0.05607224628329277,
-0.7549591064453125,
0.4443630576133728,
0.4820755124092102,
-0.11582200229167938,
0.029844708740711212,
-0.6328639984130859,
0.15952926874160767,
-0.22077301144599915,
-0.758776068687439,
0.14979128539562225,
0.45786184072494507,
0.046212565153837204,
0.2708827257156372,
0.6644007563591003,
0.01688987948000431,
0.3044172525405884,
0.32975584268569946,
0.3587130010128021,
-0.597632884979248,
-0.5167897343635559,
-0.19648198783397675,
0.3501664996147156,
-0.061617396771907806,
0.06603482365608215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14766v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models for Public Health Classification and Extraction Tasks
| 2024-05-23T16:33:18 | 2024-05-23T16:33:18 |
Joshua Harris, Timothy Laurence, Leo Loman, Fan Grayson, Toby Nonnenmacher, Harry Long, Loes WalsGriffith, Amy Douglas, Holly Fountain, Stelios Georgiou, Jo Hardstaff, Kathryn Hopkins, Y-Ling Chi, Galena Kuyumdzhieva, Lesley Larkin, Samuel Collins, Hamish Mohammed, Thomas Finnie, Luke Hounsome, Steven Riley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50
|
Advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have led to significant interest in
their potential to support human experts across a range of domains, including
public health. In this work we present automated evaluations of LLMs for public
health tasks involving the classification and extraction of free text. We
combine six externally annotated datasets with seven new internally annotated
datasets to evaluate LLMs for processing text related to: health burden,
epidemiological risk factors, and public health interventions. We initially
evaluate five open-weight LLMs (7-70 billion parameters) across all tasks using
zero-shot in-context learning. We find that Llama-3-70B-Instruct is the highest
performing model, achieving the best results on 15/17 tasks (using micro-F1
scores). We see significant variation across tasks with all open-weight LLMs
scoring below 60% micro-F1 on some challenging tasks, such as Contact
Classification, while all LLMs achieve greater than 80% micro-F1 on others,
such as GI Illness Classification. For a subset of 12 tasks, we also evaluate
GPT-4 and find comparable results to Llama-3-70B-Instruct, which scores equally
or outperforms GPT-4 on 6 of the 12 tasks. Overall, based on these initial
results we find promising signs that LLMs may be useful tools for public health
experts to extract information from a wide variety of free text sources, and
support public health surveillance, research, and interventions.
|
[
0.12841571867465973,
-0.619760274887085,
0.9487603902816772,
0.07621670514345169,
-0.11320628225803375,
-0.24076931178569794,
-0.5596874356269836,
-0.6560594439506531,
0.1554223597049713,
0.5348172187805176,
-0.0252215676009655,
-0.8523476123809814,
-1.0965036153793335,
0.5363136529922485,
-0.4920419752597809,
1.1874823570251465,
-0.04193707928061485,
0.09549195319414139,
-0.25138235092163086,
0.3022887408733368,
-0.32380345463752747,
-0.5448395609855652,
-0.4533495306968689,
-0.3364180624485016,
0.8031336665153503,
0.6226197481155396,
0.47179603576660156,
0.5918748378753662,
0.6993493437767029,
0.20110401511192322,
-0.23191066086292267,
0.08470790088176727,
-0.4811483323574066,
-0.05320684239268303,
-0.443704217672348,
-0.07760617882013321,
-0.44286048412323,
0.20099720358848572,
0.4168209433555603,
0.4866856038570404,
0.020289765670895576,
0.5672872066497803,
0.03212467208504677,
0.4314142167568207,
-0.5417386293411255,
0.38762426376342773,
-0.5413005352020264,
-0.23100538551807404,
-0.19436801970005035,
-0.12826569378376007,
-0.38049155473709106,
-0.12437357008457184,
0.4667910039424896,
-0.4293938875198364,
-0.3756435513496399,
-0.17310775816440582,
0.6347394585609436,
0.2499527484178543,
-0.7951933145523071,
-0.44336065649986267,
-0.4469735324382782,
0.7928420305252075,
-0.6849644184112549,
0.2309977114200592,
0.5643537044525146,
0.12960141897201538,
-0.2530101537704468,
-0.651057243347168,
-0.3008447587490082,
-0.30669182538986206,
0.007170875556766987,
0.05958917364478111,
-0.4503798484802246,
0.15713149309158325,
0.23649248480796814,
0.31960922479629517,
-0.4743914008140564,
0.37205907702445984,
-0.3849853575229645,
-0.08613058179616928,
0.8969031572341919,
0.13154710829257965,
0.40718987584114075,
-0.6363318562507629,
-0.1629548817873001,
0.17546290159225464,
-0.6866426467895508,
-0.01218828372657299,
-0.13651196658611298,
0.4108729362487793,
-0.31057652831077576,
0.5682620406150818,
-0.307305246591568,
0.47558632493019104,
-0.3246006667613983,
-0.6585162878036499,
0.37637603282928467,
-0.1488104611635208,
-0.4075676500797272,
-0.18936315178871155,
0.8230359554290771,
0.40549880266189575,
0.21194811165332794,
-0.24599480628967285,
-0.24283258616924286,
-0.49922728538513184,
0.21145938336849213,
-0.8203238844871521,
-0.2928076982498169,
0.1806226372718811,
-0.6818581819534302,
-0.27639245986938477,
-0.054056499153375626,
-0.9379708170890808,
-0.5882708430290222,
-0.4851871132850647,
0.4347743093967438,
-0.16342461109161377,
-0.2047921121120453,
0.15185587108135223,
0.10834608972072601,
-0.19585683941841125,
0.5164124965667725,
-0.5891861319541931,
0.4110797047615051,
0.8348181247711182,
0.9398127794265747,
-0.5565996766090393,
0.1577441543340683,
-0.5840842723846436,
0.05428484082221985,
-0.0931553989648819,
0.7853782176971436,
-0.5880433320999146,
-0.28537991642951965,
-0.07369228452444077,
0.16091389954090118,
-0.23103976249694824,
-0.7809206247329712,
0.766218364238739,
-0.17694319784641266,
0.03901170566678047,
-0.37863650918006897,
-0.5151252150535583,
-0.2195570170879364,
0.2163744568824768,
-0.6235617995262146,
0.8215402364730835,
0.020493431016802788,
-0.86725252866745,
0.267346054315567,
-0.6637029051780701,
-0.605516791343689,
0.2850695252418518,
-0.12584233283996582,
-0.2916960120201111,
0.030149340629577637,
0.48385336995124817,
0.8021460175514221,
-0.7703022360801697,
0.33446159958839417,
-0.3226073086261749,
-0.22880250215530396,
0.24822334945201874,
-0.3591534197330475,
0.8185109496116638,
0.016282757744193077,
-0.3357451260089874,
0.5068677663803101,
-0.6788682341575623,
-0.12111971527338028,
0.18128421902656555,
-0.6822107434272766,
-0.39059755206108093,
0.24389824271202087,
0.24067413806915283,
0.14545372128486633,
0.1516125351190567,
-0.6339985728263855,
0.13352437317371368,
-0.4567670226097107,
0.5246458649635315,
0.6040430665016174,
0.4158441722393036,
-0.039415501058101654,
-0.41256192326545715,
0.34809499979019165,
-0.3943263590335846,
0.21939978003501892,
-0.01266148965805769,
-0.8718250393867493,
-0.2243163287639618,
-0.6996379494667053,
0.22359181940555573,
0.7763175368309021,
-0.5724195837974548,
0.6299118399620056,
-0.6635754704475403,
-0.5847507119178772,
-0.3751019835472107,
0.15255041420459747,
0.3557646572589874,
0.4743727743625641,
0.4838479459285736,
-0.12116190791130066,
-0.31613415479660034,
-0.7543278932571411,
-0.06096649914979935,
-0.06623361259698868,
-0.2815644145011902,
0.3028411269187927,
0.8684138059616089,
-0.32239124178886414,
0.7509083151817322,
-0.5646981596946716,
-0.21506395936012268,
-0.2516540288925171,
0.30763596296310425,
0.1108260452747345,
0.13830672204494476,
0.3620980679988861,
-0.6137298941612244,
-0.31720131635665894,
0.2470199465751648,
-0.6498486995697021,
-0.42606884241104126,
0.4079027473926544,
0.1996535062789917,
-0.07701905071735382,
-0.02374226041138172,
-0.4703824520111084,
0.41793009638786316,
0.601419985294342,
0.0538635328412056,
0.529029130935669,
-0.08774374425411224,
0.025654751807451248,
-0.8475971817970276,
0.3384395241737366,
0.35550642013549805,
-0.23592504858970642,
-0.7375434041023254,
0.04380521923303604,
0.053315795958042145,
-0.05457134544849396,
-0.5512552261352539,
0.7623701095581055,
-0.23445498943328857,
0.03977172076702118,
-0.27718812227249146,
-0.04319749027490616,
-0.21580974757671356,
0.10834718495607376,
0.040254294872283936,
0.4909675121307373,
0.32783687114715576,
-0.3781280517578125,
0.3881513178348541,
-0.09554947912693024,
-0.6806373596191406,
0.08494527637958527,
-0.555348813533783,
0.16484999656677246,
-0.13403774797916412,
0.24477273225784302,
-0.7456509470939636,
-0.5710253715515137,
0.3619379997253418,
-0.12258069962263107,
-0.07857407629489899,
0.03101770393550396,
-0.825882077217102,
-0.45204779505729675,
-0.19775313138961792,
0.0517837218940258,
0.31379538774490356,
-0.2951434254646301,
0.1467738002538681,
0.8142234683036804,
-0.37004515528678894,
-0.24213570356369019,
-0.5088867545127869,
0.03433714434504509,
-0.2825652062892914,
-0.2172536849975586,
-0.020334729924798012,
0.08602964878082275,
-0.4848954677581787,
-0.01418936625123024,
-0.09715104103088379,
-0.1631091833114624,
0.35593071579933167,
0.36655765771865845,
0.12101610749959946,
0.08646414428949356,
0.3061658442020416,
0.028071384876966476,
0.12029166519641876,
0.046749457716941833,
-0.09530123323202133,
0.1467212587594986,
0.11731898784637451,
-0.39325642585754395,
-0.5024517178535461,
0.30918100476264954,
0.6621472835540771,
-0.3808675706386566,
0.5426400899887085,
0.28346604108810425,
-0.7267290353775024,
0.22162097692489624,
-0.44029155373573303,
0.18964488804340363,
-0.3043951094150543,
0.5068899393081665,
0.028967637568712234,
-0.8194735646247864,
0.1176084578037262,
0.02939387783408165,
0.15905418992042542,
0.446956992149353,
0.6965754628181458,
0.15324507653713226,
0.8601345419883728,
0.3828422427177429,
-0.4326508939266205,
0.12511032819747925,
-0.05969272181391716,
-0.06231621280312538,
-0.5413866639137268,
-0.31763312220573425,
-0.5494784712791443,
0.003376549109816551,
-0.35990357398986816,
-0.6715999245643616,
0.7370425462722778,
-0.05145677179098129,
-0.19605492055416107,
0.10740377008914948,
-0.5283619165420532,
0.2994866371154785,
0.22432801127433777,
0.4238482713699341,
0.38855838775634766,
-0.10168439149856567,
0.12968091666698456,
0.1573689579963684,
-0.41123124957084656,
-0.75119549036026,
1.3369524478912354,
0.668296754360199,
0.5957012176513672,
0.08341968804597855,
0.7262201905250549,
0.3257048428058624,
0.9646105766296387,
-0.992929220199585,
0.5323684215545654,
-0.5595322251319885,
-0.47790786623954773,
-0.47753462195396423,
-0.4682251214981079,
-1.0076278448104858,
0.20151494443416595,
-0.4020772874355316,
-1.135319709777832,
-0.15416738390922546,
-0.1491859406232834,
-0.40393373370170593,
0.17829273641109467,
-0.5319825410842896,
0.5612174272537231,
-0.5173946022987366,
-0.006001039873808622,
-0.27084434032440186,
-0.4823213219642639,
0.37162449955940247,
-0.32414886355400085,
0.5662253499031067,
-0.5895636677742004,
-0.15613985061645508,
0.8292763233184814,
-0.033348146826028824,
0.9156830310821533,
-0.0006893250974826515,
-0.47143682837486267,
0.10204630345106125,
-0.32384172081947327,
0.15473338961601257,
0.06880728155374527,
-0.4669828712940216,
0.3384550213813782,
0.1541861742734909,
-0.1235676184296608,
-0.3404638171195984,
0.5258893370628357,
-0.6815540790557861,
-0.6428942084312439,
-0.28127872943878174,
-0.4400442838668823,
-0.026447787880897522,
0.4346684515476227,
0.018897920846939087,
0.501994252204895,
-0.16443634033203125,
0.18458832800388336,
0.3171131908893585,
-0.5005730390548706,
0.15124700963497162,
0.5489016175270081,
-0.2175218164920807,
-0.6356511116027832,
0.8875083327293396,
0.1855209320783615,
0.10931183397769928,
0.7816632390022278,
0.6514424681663513,
-0.21183514595031738,
-0.6867392659187317,
-0.23216047883033752,
0.15448203682899475,
-0.7042531371116638,
-0.44283056259155273,
-0.6101871132850647,
-0.27390503883361816,
-0.6361417770385742,
0.3399656116962433,
0.15226858854293823,
-0.03631224110722542,
-0.4104612469673157,
-0.20566073060035706,
0.44090473651885986,
1.2612119913101196,
-0.007018329109996557,
0.11563829332590103,
-1.0291625261306763,
0.25770264863967896,
0.19029991328716278,
0.15290920436382294,
0.20042474567890167,
-0.2968718111515045,
-0.37036028504371643,
-0.12039851397275925,
-0.2383306920528412,
-1.2999006509780884,
0.46022066473960876,
0.04500441625714302,
0.7544711828231812,
0.5031546950340271,
-0.002236669883131981,
0.5276499390602112,
-0.46943044662475586,
0.7236263751983643,
0.07828138768672943,
-0.8847407102584839,
0.3853992521762848,
-0.387348473072052,
0.28657883405685425,
0.48596447706222534,
0.7218745350837708,
-0.60235995054245,
-0.3359143137931824,
-0.03433527424931526,
-0.787936270236969,
0.6030163764953613,
0.061416201293468475,
-0.2700470983982086,
-0.36599352955818176,
0.24525956809520721,
0.16415072977542877,
0.06984376907348633,
-0.6646493673324585,
0.033250533044338226,
0.24799147248268127,
-0.368360310792923,
-0.04597633704543114,
-0.40715378522872925,
-0.1876237988471985,
-0.4003872275352478,
0.3821622431278229,
-0.036971792578697205,
0.048676300793886185,
0.3877353370189667,
-0.2482222616672516,
-0.1788780689239502,
0.6388125419616699,
0.5160074830055237,
0.6086779832839966,
-0.1435980498790741,
0.27574050426483154,
0.25209710001945496,
-0.3855435252189636,
0.1021258533000946,
0.22839203476905823,
-0.024061519652605057,
-0.24830274283885956,
0.8269416093826294,
0.4788161516189575,
0.6812335848808289,
-0.9986514449119568,
0.6315912008285522,
0.1297566294670105,
-0.14894011616706848,
0.0053792679682374,
-0.0989549532532692,
-0.05411209538578987,
0.12422109395265579,
0.40569064021110535,
-0.5250445604324341,
0.3437899053096771,
-0.3820928633213043,
0.3009994626045227,
0.29419830441474915,
-0.07011530548334122,
-0.37122079730033875,
0.3619721829891205,
0.38984590768814087,
-0.12728628516197205,
0.4003147482872009,
-0.22919929027557373,
-0.33071383833885193,
0.5057746171951294,
0.4453793168067932,
0.663553774356842,
-0.2533475160598755,
0.02402087114751339,
0.4015440046787262,
0.3389853835105896,
-0.17108388245105743,
0.2128472626209259,
0.20227856934070587,
-0.43266087770462036,
-0.8746318221092224,
-0.7245787382125854,
-0.44092053174972534,
0.6269440054893494,
-0.6783080697059631,
0.24933592975139618,
-0.21539977192878723,
-0.12194129824638367,
0.19239428639411926,
0.12402978539466858,
-0.6520946621894836,
0.28469061851501465,
0.4656866192817688,
1.0133918523788452,
-0.9689973592758179,
0.8465262651443481,
0.7938270568847656,
-0.2574598491191864,
-0.764472246170044,
0.39897558093070984,
0.28923219442367554,
-0.6117779016494751,
0.7432904243469238,
0.4727398753166199,
0.1136174201965332,
-0.23664332926273346,
-0.4796256422996521,
-1.1338855028152466,
0.9002018570899963,
0.3226516842842102,
-0.6436331272125244,
-0.23049050569534302,
0.17626847326755524,
0.5054928660392761,
-0.33298370242118835,
0.4282876253128052,
0.5440515279769897,
0.6819432973861694,
-0.23568259179592133,
-1.434954285621643,
0.2175622284412384,
-0.0845833271741867,
-0.18775193393230438,
0.010313691571354866,
-0.33361902832984924,
0.7518211007118225,
-0.0922929048538208,
-0.3658561110496521,
0.2039480209350586,
0.48720309138298035,
0.09031343460083008,
0.3063214123249054,
0.5594729781150818,
0.4185912311077118,
0.9810664057731628,
0.18573543429374695,
0.9751726984977722,
-0.16167433559894562,
0.28709879517555237,
1.0566061735153198,
-0.4826604723930359,
1.009721279144287,
0.021699270233511925,
-0.1491299718618393,
0.34584152698516846,
0.5555310249328613,
0.09626005589962006,
0.3403470814228058,
0.357575923204422,
-0.2150111198425293,
-0.0708877220749855,
-0.2295031100511551,
-0.016233354806900024,
0.6030873656272888,
0.5758384466171265,
-0.5214750170707703,
-0.41107603907585144,
0.3279261291027069,
0.15498840808868408,
-0.011593061499297619,
-0.49950674176216125,
0.7901367545127869,
0.10932309925556183,
-0.5339290499687195,
0.3200313150882721,
0.15492622554302216,
0.5374315977096558,
-0.3178914189338684,
-0.1842079907655716,
0.34300827980041504,
-0.11482607573270798,
-0.3877214789390564,
-0.9555618762969971,
0.31974878907203674,
0.3357278108596802,
-0.2490086555480957,
-0.20093002915382385,
0.8942583203315735,
-0.34616395831108093,
-0.4805299639701843,
0.5166072249412537,
0.398769348859787,
0.5200516581535339,
-0.1930888146162033,
-0.4448149800300598,
0.04083752632141113,
-0.16720493137836456,
-0.3552228808403015,
0.2786635458469391,
0.25691601634025574,
-0.21174943447113037,
0.5886088013648987,
0.5897767543792725,
0.486827552318573,
-0.25412246584892273,
0.008138716220855713,
0.6547989249229431,
-0.47515830397605896,
-0.1262991577386856,
-0.892347514629364,
0.19660738110542297,
-0.03431981801986694,
-0.18988238275051117,
0.6387016773223877,
0.585222601890564,
0.6558240652084351,
0.095741406083107,
0.9473950862884521,
0.06354275345802307,
0.8004685044288635,
-0.459654301404953,
0.7612971067428589,
-0.5539565682411194,
0.04653562977910042,
-0.2265070527791977,
-0.34008923172950745,
-0.32272425293922424,
0.3077046871185303,
-0.8509309887886047,
-0.4482685923576355,
0.6286004185676575,
0.3585122525691986,
0.2689865827560425,
0.0009347829618491232,
0.26358678936958313,
0.08884404599666595,
0.5301522016525269,
0.5567982792854309,
0.554236114025116,
0.16275812685489655,
0.2561660706996918,
-0.20793360471725464,
-0.5066037178039551,
-0.1861400306224823,
-1.0231568813323975,
-0.8573905229568481,
-0.40440985560417175,
-0.06968369334936142,
0.0682736411690712,
0.21386396884918213,
1.3577216863632202,
0.8044589161872864,
-0.750097930431366,
-0.08223173767328262,
0.39912110567092896,
0.02612675540149212,
-0.14056934416294098,
-0.24858911335468292,
0.39993205666542053,
0.04264027625322342,
-0.6381149888038635,
0.5578914880752563,
0.35744428634643555,
-0.18377438187599182,
-0.07036472111940384,
0.34131407737731934,
-0.19729545712471008,
-0.19993335008621216,
0.9128584861755371,
0.23524333536624908,
-0.9676648378372192,
-0.4226681590080261,
-0.30623936653137207,
-0.23835337162017822,
-0.03790222108364105,
0.6492078304290771,
-0.5092041492462158,
0.21903838217258453,
0.3479343056678772,
0.7992509007453918,
0.07261399924755096,
-0.061694614589214325,
0.33999302983283997,
-0.5159466862678528,
-0.1319848895072937,
0.29342925548553467,
0.37668395042419434,
0.331148624420166,
-0.4104599058628082,
0.4426913857460022,
0.05683920159935951,
-0.6622816920280457,
-0.772619366645813,
-0.015616078861057758,
-0.8148223757743835,
-0.3072965741157532,
1.5798133611679077,
-0.2804505228996277,
-0.2573027014732361,
-0.24788087606430054,
-0.15562918782234192,
0.386953204870224,
-0.5062591433525085,
0.6490106582641602,
0.638300895690918,
-0.20727410912513733,
0.00966187845915556,
-0.875507116317749,
0.3072401285171509,
-0.04656783491373062,
-1.2953996658325195,
0.14280608296394348,
0.2052026093006134,
0.5271485447883606,
0.04979057237505913,
0.932281494140625,
-0.16671091318130493,
0.03385980799794197,
-0.6790062785148621,
0.11454276740550995,
0.12196044623851776,
-0.3755906820297241,
-0.4278644025325775,
0.07978581637144089,
0.026835838332772255,
0.1277041882276535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14917v1
|
SliM-LLM: Salience-Driven Mixed-Precision Quantization for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T16:21:48 | 2024-05-23T16:21:48 |
Wei Huang, Haotong Qin, Yangdong Liu, Yawei Li, Xianglong Liu, Luca Benini, Michele Magno, Xiaojuan Qi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) achieve remarkable performance in natural
language understanding but require substantial computation and memory
resources. Post-training quantization (PTQ) is a powerful compression technique
extensively investigated in LLMs. However, existing PTQ methods are still not
ideal in terms of accuracy and efficiency, especially with below 4 bit-widths.
Standard PTQ methods using group-wise quantization suffer difficulties in
quantizing LLMs accurately to such low-bit, but advanced methods remaining
high-precision weights element-wisely are hard to realize their theoretical
hardware efficiency. This paper presents a Salience-Driven Mixed-Precision
Quantization scheme for LLMs, namely SliM-LLM. The scheme exploits the salience
distribution of weights to determine optimal bit-width and quantizers for
accurate LLM quantization, while aligning bit-width partition to groups for
compact memory usage and fast integer inference. Specifically, the proposed
SliM-LLM mainly relies on two novel techniques: (1) Salience-Determined Bit
Allocation utilizes the clustering characteristics of salience distribution to
allocate the bit-widths of each group, increasing the accuracy of quantized
LLMs and maintaining the inference efficiency; (2) Salience-Weighted Quantizer
Calibration optimizes the parameters of the quantizer by considering the
element-wise salience within the group, balancing the maintenance of salient
information and minimization of errors. Comprehensive experiments show that
SliM-LLM significantly improves the accuracy of LLMs at ultra-low bits, e.g.,
2-bit LLaMA-7B achieves a 5.5-times memory-saving than original model on NVIDIA
A800 GPUs, and 48% decrease of perplexity compared to the state-of-the-art
gradient-free PTQ method. Moreover, SliM-LLM+, which is integrated from the
extension of SliM-LLM with gradient-based quantizers, further reduces
perplexity by 35.1%.
|
[
-0.2267109453678131,
-0.5531874895095825,
0.6969351768493652,
0.0241087656468153,
-0.6396987438201904,
0.0861850380897522,
-0.4464430510997772,
-0.03710118681192398,
0.3177896738052368,
0.16405242681503296,
-0.5000630617141724,
-0.5035874247550964,
-0.49660229682922363,
-0.004159775096923113,
0.002439188538119197,
0.8340247273445129,
0.12067320942878723,
0.17303460836410522,
-0.11342307180166245,
-0.06824418157339096,
-0.07382382452487946,
-0.6009722352027893,
-0.26971718668937683,
-0.006948591209948063,
0.5370693206787109,
0.2378769814968109,
0.906300961971283,
0.793534517288208,
0.5271410942077637,
0.22756776213645935,
-0.416399747133255,
0.1839921474456787,
-0.6105625629425049,
0.04792502894997597,
0.11294655501842499,
-0.690653920173645,
-0.7236583232879639,
-0.15956152975559235,
0.7338206768035889,
0.6393374800682068,
-0.29712018370628357,
0.12630479037761688,
-0.20705392956733704,
0.7137880325317383,
-1.023735523223877,
-0.07398364692926407,
-0.5127122402191162,
0.18165060877799988,
-0.48329782485961914,
-0.08210049569606781,
-0.0744570717215538,
-0.5643792152404785,
-0.20560747385025024,
-0.6277487277984619,
0.14016340672969818,
0.10039474815130234,
0.6154674291610718,
0.6477131843566895,
-0.21967105567455292,
0.022033212706446648,
-0.42344197630882263,
1.2176249027252197,
-1.0279473066329956,
0.659975528717041,
0.1046936884522438,
-0.02955871820449829,
0.04827744513750076,
-0.36299580335617065,
-0.46525809168815613,
0.06422877311706543,
-0.023803070187568665,
0.2614244818687439,
0.0762166678905487,
0.3341319262981415,
0.312333345413208,
0.7498963475227356,
-0.6028714776039124,
0.19361679255962372,
-0.33372387290000916,
-0.191133514046669,
0.6106844544410706,
0.11220463365316391,
-0.1789836585521698,
-0.2309451848268509,
-0.23517681658267975,
0.05424055829644203,
-0.7611171007156372,
-0.24740701913833618,
0.4612714648246765,
0.1748662292957306,
-0.15435180068016052,
0.6298698782920837,
-0.2597031593322754,
0.6225929856300354,
0.20606820285320282,
-0.7561293244361877,
0.10044892132282257,
-0.27072232961654663,
-0.3805050849914551,
0.19258959591388702,
0.9201644659042358,
0.19868849217891693,
0.21588632464408875,
0.0007599738892167807,
-0.4690159857273102,
0.014423897489905357,
-0.2252824753522873,
-1.0943603515625,
-0.29608601331710815,
0.33321136236190796,
-0.456687331199646,
-0.0004170518077444285,
-0.13316799700260162,
-0.7030150294303894,
-0.29598984122276306,
-0.24926155805587769,
0.34014633297920227,
-0.6794140934944153,
-0.027101019397377968,
0.31455284357070923,
0.07134230434894562,
0.084201879799366,
0.5175658464431763,
-1.017211675643921,
0.3972715139389038,
0.7348450422286987,
0.8550628423690796,
-0.34737494587898254,
0.24118687212467194,
-0.5947489738464355,
0.3470211625099182,
-0.004992201924324036,
0.5129695534706116,
-0.34194228053092957,
-0.2962771952152252,
-0.4684957265853882,
-0.4926159977912903,
0.15639585256576538,
-0.7028970122337341,
0.4704245626926422,
-0.30586743354797363,
0.22825224697589874,
-0.1211283728480339,
-0.5652305483818054,
0.018437808379530907,
0.06210961565375328,
-0.5172739028930664,
1.0748331546783447,
0.20289012789726257,
-0.840343177318573,
0.26210471987724304,
-0.3245018720626831,
-0.2043977826833725,
0.1742096245288849,
0.019278056919574738,
-0.4806533753871918,
0.6804676651954651,
0.20776748657226562,
0.4114058315753937,
-0.34337055683135986,
0.2060006558895111,
-0.37341198325157166,
-0.8199750185012817,
0.36256855726242065,
-0.4468052387237549,
0.5171900391578674,
0.2363176792860031,
0.03403022512793541,
0.19234305620193481,
-0.6232452988624573,
0.20296448469161987,
0.008337731473147869,
-0.2256375253200531,
-0.41840213537216187,
-0.2275398224592209,
-0.30365127325057983,
-0.03412606194615364,
0.5161635875701904,
-0.3396395444869995,
0.1518545299768448,
-0.4832947254180908,
0.3424522280693054,
0.8665351867675781,
-0.2064773142337799,
0.4274848699569702,
-0.16831393539905548,
0.41056621074676514,
-0.21245171129703522,
0.3715391755104065,
0.01726219430565834,
-0.26809245347976685,
-0.6886071562767029,
-0.9148818850517273,
0.48621541261672974,
0.6485604047775269,
-0.3558799922466278,
0.6295603513717651,
-0.3229489326477051,
-0.022367795929312706,
-0.49480003118515015,
-0.00901896320283413,
0.342166006565094,
0.1681213080883026,
0.1928965300321579,
-0.5136801600456238,
-0.26810479164123535,
-0.8733540177345276,
-0.05909743905067444,
-0.2299034148454666,
-0.40944188833236694,
0.26632970571517944,
0.14796078205108643,
-0.052999597042798996,
0.6929032802581787,
-0.6906845569610596,
0.12618610262870789,
0.12305670231580734,
-0.12903989851474762,
0.3978865146636963,
0.26129764318466187,
0.23797959089279175,
-0.520745575428009,
-0.3391600251197815,
-0.21460486948490143,
-0.3705693781375885,
-0.4235418736934662,
0.2226259559392929,
-0.04420122131705284,
0.08496600389480591,
-0.051101457327604294,
-0.8152280449867249,
0.30762600898742676,
0.5292993783950806,
-0.03851272165775299,
0.8052611947059631,
0.09463806450366974,
0.1090782880783081,
-0.9418857097625732,
-0.0765739232301712,
0.04653095453977585,
-0.49471357464790344,
-0.39494454860687256,
0.06919047981500626,
0.23060542345046997,
0.1546519249677658,
-0.5628196597099304,
0.45828309655189514,
-0.43906357884407043,
-0.1561853140592575,
-0.2534159719944,
0.10270347446203232,
0.02148207649588585,
0.5050560832023621,
-0.06416186690330505,
0.9337807297706604,
0.43806779384613037,
-0.4674723744392395,
0.5175706148147583,
-0.1204477921128273,
0.10017453134059906,
0.9750872850418091,
-0.5505353212356567,
0.04768020659685135,
-0.12362655252218246,
-0.1497296541929245,
-0.6457171440124512,
-0.20116069912910461,
0.2508210837841034,
-0.22407396137714386,
0.363017737865448,
-0.05036276951432228,
-0.8722357749938965,
-0.16565948724746704,
-0.6095354557037354,
0.5684013962745667,
0.8140544295310974,
-0.2411259412765503,
0.5352774858474731,
0.16750511527061462,
-0.32464003562927246,
-0.3973264694213867,
-0.7733520865440369,
-0.2397104650735855,
-0.521095335483551,
-0.5505425930023193,
0.3546179533004761,
-0.27481719851493835,
-0.44073283672332764,
-0.19506804645061493,
-0.3763568103313446,
-0.011070005595684052,
0.03870809078216553,
0.11725761741399765,
0.23070800304412842,
-0.08712153881788254,
0.14852207899093628,
0.07924286276102066,
-0.07448452711105347,
-0.13303862512111664,
-0.3891311585903168,
0.6378911733627319,
-0.26201802492141724,
-0.31879377365112305,
-0.48265013098716736,
0.22318752110004425,
0.2701084613800049,
-0.15325425565242767,
0.6789013147354126,
0.6148029565811157,
-0.22489874064922333,
-0.03120063804090023,
-0.609890878200531,
-0.5045086741447449,
-0.5008352398872375,
0.39207422733306885,
-0.2238643765449524,
-1.221358299255371,
0.3956484794616699,
-0.3211717903614044,
-0.040691036731004715,
0.08326245099306107,
0.7429972887039185,
-0.03166642412543297,
0.7999324798583984,
0.5774516463279724,
-0.007774228695780039,
0.41734886169433594,
0.05633832514286041,
0.3083026111125946,
-0.7260940670967102,
-0.03276767581701279,
-0.10135135054588318,
-0.4708831012248993,
-0.3527308702468872,
-0.6472059488296509,
0.578140139579773,
0.41539859771728516,
-0.2732151448726654,
-0.23859255015850067,
-0.46546316146850586,
0.418651282787323,
0.6080479025840759,
0.20094306766986847,
0.4401022791862488,
0.16881701350212097,
-0.12688839435577393,
-0.34480908513069153,
-0.6005994081497192,
-0.23063193261623383,
0.9047728180885315,
0.18571753799915314,
1.0481762886047363,
0.21917323768138885,
0.731248140335083,
0.03420853987336159,
0.273556649684906,
-1.1141949892044067,
0.7008892893791199,
-0.28571945428848267,
-0.01892189122736454,
-0.17861564457416534,
-0.850119411945343,
-0.40350955724716187,
0.3202880024909973,
-0.11609426885843277,
-0.746486246585846,
-0.08655546605587006,
0.24702110886573792,
-0.582485556602478,
0.44486621022224426,
-0.6872079372406006,
0.4852917194366455,
-0.42319443821907043,
-0.5087031722068787,
-0.17628608644008636,
-0.6504075527191162,
0.7739455103874207,
-0.22845220565795898,
0.08294826745986938,
-0.23250560462474823,
-0.3991732597351074,
0.6381640434265137,
-0.6182345151901245,
0.5872675180435181,
0.12379825115203857,
-0.33122071623802185,
-0.029182858765125275,
0.09986523538827896,
0.5938220024108887,
0.17523235082626343,
-0.17939424514770508,
0.15915317833423615,
-0.12946465611457825,
-0.49780961871147156,
-0.6296878457069397,
0.6275345087051392,
-0.6216534376144409,
-0.6430560946464539,
-0.3572770953178406,
-1.0469666719436646,
-0.21723982691764832,
0.10538826137781143,
-0.034143682569265366,
0.07201837748289108,
0.2522442936897278,
-0.010064027272164822,
1.091809630393982,
-0.20084476470947266,
0.4038535952568054,
0.5513585805892944,
-0.007571586407721043,
-0.7856729626655579,
0.7715256214141846,
-0.1603163480758667,
0.4944723844528198,
0.5185337066650391,
0.21411237120628357,
-0.23748724162578583,
-0.6848676204681396,
-0.26333364844322205,
0.6204510927200317,
-0.25111061334609985,
-0.39543667435646057,
-0.36937201023101807,
-0.0034775668755173683,
-0.2455660104751587,
-0.03244351968169212,
-0.6706031560897827,
-0.6867381930351257,
-0.33511149883270264,
0.08051909506320953,
0.5588316321372986,
0.1495472639799118,
-0.10572981089353561,
0.8346133232116699,
-0.6935354471206665,
0.23716683685779572,
0.2772536873817444,
0.4675769805908203,
-0.2817422151565552,
-0.5304592847824097,
-0.26662781834602356,
0.006742642726749182,
-0.27423426508903503,
-0.906545102596283,
0.5608961582183838,
0.10056506842374802,
0.05674419552087784,
0.6516790390014648,
-0.0688512995839119,
0.8889930844306946,
-0.27501657605171204,
0.6354432702064514,
0.38863328099250793,
-1.0356417894363403,
0.3002155125141144,
-0.13432271778583527,
0.3441590368747711,
0.39791786670684814,
0.21472975611686707,
-0.42711448669433594,
-0.2543739378452301,
-0.4475824236869812,
-0.8009632229804993,
0.5464572906494141,
0.07137587666511536,
-0.19958186149597168,
0.38575980067253113,
0.5086091160774231,
0.11788694560527802,
0.675071656703949,
-0.6438422203063965,
-0.48738566040992737,
0.01951685920357704,
-0.48125699162483215,
0.24109873175621033,
-0.35024863481521606,
-0.13514603674411774,
-0.1314610242843628,
0.5731625556945801,
-0.3288857042789459,
0.1558077186346054,
-0.08773542940616608,
-0.0310773067176342,
-0.16808108985424042,
0.408824622631073,
0.31009507179260254,
0.5636532306671143,
-0.44744426012039185,
0.2802233397960663,
0.25658363103866577,
-0.5251441597938538,
0.18891817331314087,
0.38255050778388977,
-0.3422100841999054,
-0.09704189002513885,
-0.0920686274766922,
0.7946318984031677,
0.2162405401468277,
-0.858195424079895,
0.4137132167816162,
0.020626084879040718,
-0.1304926574230194,
0.13434118032455444,
0.1379069685935974,
-0.011150902137160301,
0.23445014655590057,
0.4049530625343323,
-0.15369825065135956,
0.16568829119205475,
-0.24800848960876465,
-0.01507529802620411,
0.715201735496521,
-0.03308507055044174,
-0.40649619698524475,
0.5763540267944336,
-0.21080926060676575,
0.08414607495069504,
0.4916965067386627,
-0.45652252435684204,
-0.49111998081207275,
0.10026688128709793,
0.3991939127445221,
0.5942471027374268,
-0.35136616230010986,
0.059869181364774704,
0.1015639379620552,
0.1715707629919052,
-0.17802707850933075,
0.5456518530845642,
-0.10259081423282623,
-0.5174955725669861,
-0.744719922542572,
-0.8452258706092834,
-0.5412093997001648,
0.03740749508142471,
-0.4594949185848236,
0.09072303771972656,
-0.5724297165870667,
-0.14513884484767914,
-0.46602049469947815,
0.28701886534690857,
-0.35617387294769287,
0.17179100215435028,
0.30571213364601135,
0.5160573124885559,
-0.5893979668617249,
0.6169605851173401,
0.49627581238746643,
0.20851558446884155,
-0.7898504734039307,
0.011628251522779465,
-0.00857409369200468,
-0.671654224395752,
0.3253456652164459,
-0.0379377044737339,
0.1787012219429016,
0.08469328284263611,
-0.5974276661872864,
-1.0780725479125977,
1.1524543762207031,
0.7045300602912903,
-0.8450435996055603,
0.1674385368824005,
0.20299497246742249,
0.229005366563797,
0.21200788021087646,
0.4135168790817261,
0.4839157164096832,
0.4142068326473236,
0.4733997583389282,
-1.0434037446975708,
0.2716984152793884,
0.032979585230350494,
-0.012394456192851067,
0.5141192674636841,
-1.055382490158081,
1.093941569328308,
-0.32134512066841125,
-0.2791835367679596,
0.17250923812389374,
0.9281045794487,
1.0700751543045044,
0.06910600513219833,
0.367870032787323,
0.9288293719291687,
1.1268422603607178,
-0.21930663287639618,
0.7737061381340027,
-0.3538016378879547,
0.3055065870285034,
0.6479296684265137,
-0.34307602047920227,
0.4750851094722748,
0.768168568611145,
-0.5128556489944458,
0.1486804187297821,
0.6570101380348206,
0.1293618083000183,
0.49402984976768494,
0.5668300986289978,
-0.6143190860748291,
-0.21215461194515228,
-0.26388615369796753,
-0.25869664549827576,
-0.06561559438705444,
0.4927467703819275,
-0.02168506197631359,
-0.04966406524181366,
-0.2472621649503708,
0.14694702625274658,
-0.3422982692718506,
-0.5929452776908875,
0.4984710216522217,
0.3227219879627228,
-0.21817532181739807,
0.6472095251083374,
0.29329198598861694,
1.1910537481307983,
-0.7011657953262329,
0.18051934242248535,
-0.38359999656677246,
0.11418147385120392,
-0.27292439341545105,
-0.5570135116577148,
0.07417215406894684,
-0.04641270637512207,
-0.23952434957027435,
-0.1753804087638855,
0.6474587917327881,
-0.4472726881504059,
-0.5565541386604309,
-0.2866707444190979,
0.5721265077590942,
0.31850960850715637,
-0.2992803752422333,
-0.5864682197570801,
0.2522009015083313,
-0.0887729674577713,
-0.20122551918029785,
0.38760676980018616,
0.7182307243347168,
0.011056873947381973,
0.6014989018440247,
0.5427113771438599,
0.4733485281467438,
0.21736714243888855,
0.038672804832458496,
0.91975337266922,
-0.7069210410118103,
-0.5700197219848633,
-1.0107877254486084,
0.22059747576713562,
0.09868257492780685,
0.020192865282297134,
0.8747352361679077,
0.767061710357666,
0.5381643176078796,
0.07321667671203613,
0.6261841058731079,
0.15145628154277802,
0.19352880120277405,
-0.718356192111969,
0.16828641295433044,
-0.6228876709938049,
0.3590109348297119,
-0.09773799031972885,
-0.9764782786369324,
-0.516828715801239,
0.6011219024658203,
-0.27670401334762573,
0.16429546475410461,
0.6467815637588501,
0.7983832359313965,
-0.22202886641025543,
-0.16228193044662476,
0.34685638546943665,
0.2316247820854187,
-0.039157066494226456,
0.9213883876800537,
0.6526488065719604,
-0.148830845952034,
0.29785895347595215,
-0.40079888701438904,
-0.2988228499889374,
-0.15781517326831818,
-0.7567043900489807,
-0.8055152297019958,
0.14028173685073853,
-0.40480369329452515,
-0.11059993505477905,
0.20902666449546814,
0.7613860964775085,
0.8611147999763489,
-0.6932578086853027,
-0.07418842613697052,
0.1101691722869873,
0.19331789016723633,
0.043595850467681885,
-0.3279593884944916,
0.4790235161781311,
-0.04510869085788727,
-0.8009952306747437,
0.08122309297323227,
0.5240463018417358,
0.22957324981689453,
-0.39866217970848083,
-0.2171909660100937,
0.21490031480789185,
0.020351771265268326,
0.44976234436035156,
-0.005946115590631962,
-0.6989699602127075,
0.04613770544528961,
0.04505567625164986,
-0.07742324471473694,
0.1771295666694641,
0.7741143107414246,
-0.8022258281707764,
-0.09116596728563309,
0.3494586646556854,
0.3410903811454773,
0.45657995343208313,
0.24276454746723175,
0.33914753794670105,
-1.031282901763916,
0.45516374707221985,
0.3963058590888977,
0.30228984355926514,
0.5439922213554382,
-0.5219821929931641,
0.32973670959472656,
0.5711640119552612,
-0.44948405027389526,
-0.8150570392608643,
0.20633359253406525,
-1.0431890487670898,
-0.16403761506080627,
1.1059417724609375,
0.011304758489131927,
-0.4772754907608032,
0.44163569808006287,
-0.11216428130865097,
0.2728751599788666,
-0.6308407187461853,
0.6800799369812012,
0.37577784061431885,
-0.14619383215904236,
-0.5355920195579529,
-0.375006765127182,
0.3850823938846588,
0.6123901009559631,
-0.709555447101593,
-0.0424087718129158,
0.658282458782196,
0.214907705783844,
-0.10953696817159653,
0.4607754945755005,
-0.031904663890600204,
0.0506100058555603,
-0.40212148427963257,
0.18778271973133087,
-0.05658649280667305,
0.035906869918107986,
-0.25126728415489197,
0.160663440823555,
-0.1321272999048233,
0.13104864954948425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14734v1
|
SimPO: Simple Preference Optimization with a Reference-Free Reward
| 2024-05-23T16:01:46 | 2024-05-23T16:01:46 |
Yu Meng, Mengzhou Xia, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) is a widely used offline preference
optimization algorithm that reparameterizes reward functions in reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) to enhance simplicity and training
stability. In this work, we propose SimPO, a simpler yet more effective
approach. The effectiveness of SimPO is attributed to a key design: using the
average log probability of a sequence as the implicit reward. This reward
formulation better aligns with model generation and eliminates the need for a
reference model, making it more compute and memory efficient. Additionally, we
introduce a target reward margin to the Bradley-Terry objective to encourage a
larger margin between the winning and losing responses, further enhancing the
algorithm's performance. We compare SimPO to DPO and its latest variants across
various state-of-the-art training setups, including both base and
instruction-tuned models like Mistral and Llama3. We evaluated on extensive
instruction-following benchmarks, including AlpacaEval 2, MT-Bench, and the
recent challenging Arena-Hard benchmark. Our results demonstrate that SimPO
consistently and significantly outperforms existing approaches without
substantially increasing response length. Specifically, SimPO outperforms DPO
by up to 6.4 points on AlpacaEval 2 and by up to 7.5 points on Arena-Hard. Our
top-performing model, built on Llama3-8B-Instruct, achieves a remarkable 44.7
length-controlled win rate on AlpacaEval 2 -- surpassing Claude 3 Opus on the
leaderboard, and a 33.8 win rate on Arena-Hard -- making it the strongest 8B
open-source model.
|
[
-0.29185810685157776,
-0.029230520129203796,
0.5577152371406555,
0.3304263651371002,
-0.5792075991630554,
-0.2126760631799698,
-0.29446926712989807,
-0.30809274315834045,
0.09294324368238449,
0.18137551844120026,
-0.7898547649383545,
0.023202044889330864,
-0.6021615266799927,
0.2071082890033722,
0.45501944422721863,
0.8485143184661865,
-0.1991351693868637,
0.12419543415307999,
-0.4080326557159424,
0.12783829867839813,
-0.22141309082508087,
-0.37286603450775146,
-0.5662804245948792,
-0.6627659797668457,
0.4819943308830261,
0.7360705137252808,
0.5856972336769104,
0.9183709025382996,
0.41749492287635803,
0.22088700532913208,
-0.12343940138816833,
0.5119535326957703,
-0.7985832095146179,
-0.15739503502845764,
0.13923002779483795,
-0.5484505891799927,
-0.4148152470588684,
0.12136731296777725,
0.09391801059246063,
0.14497771859169006,
-0.4212299585342407,
-0.08151973783969879,
0.054740846157073975,
1.0292956829071045,
-0.8558095097541809,
0.2520439028739929,
-0.5380658507347107,
0.2222404032945633,
0.16713297367095947,
-0.7463803291320801,
-0.532813310623169,
-0.659033477306366,
-0.01889396272599697,
-0.943840742111206,
-0.1676906943321228,
0.10667448490858078,
0.7066887021064758,
0.5982169508934021,
-0.359063059091568,
-0.38117286562919617,
-0.7331470847129822,
0.944358766078949,
-0.24480172991752625,
0.2725337743759155,
0.3008517026901245,
0.4430670142173767,
-0.3547983169555664,
-0.3070802688598633,
-0.1618051379919052,
-0.5554132461547852,
0.1937151700258255,
0.3814207911491394,
0.02081955596804619,
0.1756986528635025,
0.1415136456489563,
0.17133335769176483,
-0.09678986668586731,
-0.10544642060995102,
-0.06272929161787033,
0.14902333915233612,
0.6677355766296387,
0.047393493354320526,
-0.2990497648715973,
-0.22374886274337769,
-0.8178457021713257,
-0.4075911343097687,
-0.5846194624900818,
0.6177355647087097,
0.5465916395187378,
0.08591382950544357,
0.10874669253826141,
0.20441259443759918,
-0.519005537033081,
0.593761682510376,
0.36326864361763,
-0.5942949652671814,
0.042421676218509674,
0.25186794996261597,
-0.0648685097694397,
0.19563283026218414,
0.6744770407676697,
0.4950764775276184,
0.2303248643875122,
-0.1505672186613083,
-0.027548898011446,
-0.21456366777420044,
0.18129907548427582,
-0.7502962350845337,
0.12555795907974243,
0.2384473830461502,
-0.4744871258735657,
-0.7597434520721436,
0.20641492307186127,
-0.5899748802185059,
-0.266630619764328,
-0.5991538763046265,
0.2388765513896942,
-0.5412290096282959,
0.06261945515871048,
0.09646755456924438,
-0.19748555123806,
0.1828608512878418,
0.6299542188644409,
-1.1073839664459229,
0.5960132479667664,
0.8081380724906921,
0.6367361545562744,
-0.3991992771625519,
-0.2307824194431305,
-0.7173184752464294,
0.31565409898757935,
-0.3197861909866333,
0.7118578553199768,
-0.5878137946128845,
-0.5903497934341431,
-0.25377529859542847,
-0.45256492495536804,
0.2640061676502228,
-0.6601741909980774,
0.8734838962554932,
-0.2934950590133667,
-0.2088944911956787,
-0.5092794299125671,
-0.6386836767196655,
0.11927464604377747,
0.21747246384620667,
-0.5962108373641968,
1.0025436878204346,
-0.33169758319854736,
-0.5738608241081238,
0.3522971570491791,
-0.6193616390228271,
0.20347346365451813,
-0.2129031866788864,
-0.16348226368427277,
-0.25624826550483704,
0.2640264332294464,
0.07983759790658951,
0.04110517352819443,
-0.4643266201019287,
0.06681473553180695,
-0.612303614616394,
-0.9088723659515381,
0.05024086311459541,
-0.148715078830719,
0.528099000453949,
0.17964768409729004,
-0.421739399433136,
0.08893687278032303,
-0.7534341812133789,
0.3212445378303528,
0.4393206834793091,
-0.2806673049926758,
-0.48189982771873474,
0.24306505918502808,
-0.4892202317714691,
0.19794832170009613,
0.04876498505473137,
-0.5188746452331543,
0.6160078644752502,
-0.0933636873960495,
-0.06182442978024483,
0.9397906064987183,
-0.24511532485485077,
0.4333118200302124,
-0.3419604003429413,
0.440640389919281,
-0.2037239968776703,
0.7676960825920105,
0.3503476679325104,
-0.3675769865512848,
-0.4830501079559326,
-0.4988482594490051,
0.3818504214286804,
0.4988727271556854,
-0.5750946998596191,
0.2657793462276459,
-0.24507953226566315,
-0.4219861328601837,
-0.3119368255138397,
0.25192081928253174,
0.24418875575065613,
0.49086281657218933,
0.2327907234430313,
-0.11339740455150604,
-0.34993186593055725,
-0.9145757555961609,
-0.08051644265651703,
-0.31718918681144714,
0.057053785771131516,
0.7675772905349731,
0.07217860221862793,
0.029638221487402916,
0.9775324463844299,
-1.0113047361373901,
-0.23528268933296204,
-0.21746984124183655,
0.044220875948667526,
0.08907067775726318,
0.12268538028001785,
0.6932103633880615,
-0.8244648575782776,
-0.41586774587631226,
-0.18892894685268402,
-0.5495728850364685,
-0.14981524646282196,
0.25712546706199646,
-0.30047595500946045,
-0.19634687900543213,
0.01275439653545618,
-0.4807046055793762,
0.23532812297344208,
0.32056379318237305,
0.14419756829738617,
0.31214115023612976,
-0.25083255767822266,
0.32021379470825195,
-0.6216864585876465,
0.10288791358470917,
-0.45250222086906433,
-0.11318541318178177,
-0.4178348481655121,
-0.1372726708650589,
0.188185915350914,
-0.22644385695457458,
-0.6268588304519653,
0.4857674837112427,
-0.08493909239768982,
0.0008031196775846183,
-0.4559268653392792,
-0.2515715956687927,
-0.17274856567382812,
0.8115517497062683,
0.33933237195014954,
0.37278932332992554,
0.057667169719934464,
-0.7804428339004517,
0.49082574248313904,
0.08457738161087036,
-0.028094902634620667,
0.22931337356567383,
-0.6904516220092773,
0.3718698024749756,
-0.14043371379375458,
0.41698887944221497,
-0.7505772709846497,
-0.1481183022260666,
0.4272531270980835,
-0.2731534540653229,
0.12235409766435623,
-0.19997812807559967,
-0.19366596639156342,
-0.23389068245887756,
-0.8645479679107666,
0.49368366599082947,
0.5110755562782288,
-0.7189044952392578,
0.1872117966413498,
-0.08863327652215958,
0.1740877330303192,
-0.9493486881256104,
0.01406543143093586,
-0.522555410861969,
0.01945166289806366,
-0.37723979353904724,
0.36637118458747864,
-0.38547229766845703,
-0.13574711978435516,
-0.3156825006008148,
-0.3468177318572998,
0.04393036291003227,
0.1695498526096344,
0.42112788558006287,
0.24923212826251984,
0.38110271096229553,
0.08121810108423233,
0.029780937358736992,
-0.4381782114505768,
-0.2720440924167633,
0.10089312493801117,
0.5706664323806763,
-0.06506966799497604,
-0.18065553903579712,
-0.3383106589317322,
0.30437812209129333,
0.2842240631580353,
0.21297933161258698,
0.2818480134010315,
0.0355018712580204,
-0.02204860933125019,
-0.40385258197784424,
-0.19139039516448975,
-0.13006260991096497,
-0.4566895067691803,
-0.1223706305027008,
-0.5817779898643494,
-0.4075115919113159,
-0.006420585326850414,
-0.5137349963188171,
0.012275632470846176,
0.13303881883621216,
0.4062616527080536,
0.050636377185583115,
0.988159716129303,
0.6045197248458862,
0.1148030236363411,
0.5736615657806396,
-0.20120331645011902,
-0.32853662967681885,
-0.5704068541526794,
-0.44804301857948303,
-0.34901365637779236,
-0.33059370517730713,
-0.5115544199943542,
-0.35223981738090515,
0.18049801886081696,
0.18853922188282013,
-0.051623616367578506,
0.10797297209501266,
-0.3845747709274292,
0.4536116421222687,
0.6984812021255493,
0.36691489815711975,
0.4748327136039734,
-0.032201044261455536,
-0.3195984959602356,
-0.2656773626804352,
-0.7338042259216309,
-0.2048601359128952,
1.1059901714324951,
0.2529078423976898,
1.052294135093689,
-0.09065347164869308,
1.185401439666748,
0.39117178320884705,
0.2466956526041031,
-1.0500140190124512,
0.37529927492141724,
0.061399608850479126,
-0.33307528495788574,
-0.17074277997016907,
-0.46589064598083496,
-0.6805390119552612,
0.2798821032047272,
-0.13069963455200195,
-0.3971668481826782,
0.4455075263977051,
0.5608828067779541,
-0.4664013385772705,
0.15806379914283752,
-0.5117159485816956,
0.4965028762817383,
-0.47809353470802307,
-0.5706795454025269,
-0.17760848999023438,
-0.4692515730857849,
0.5347024202346802,
0.1995779126882553,
-0.13589467108249664,
-0.35606247186660767,
-0.4598383903503418,
0.3545937240123749,
-0.6286865472793579,
0.21691007912158966,
-0.12746186554431915,
0.1301308125257492,
0.14380787312984467,
-0.0001595596258994192,
0.6074085235595703,
0.18343870341777802,
-0.2445969581604004,
0.052321407943964005,
-0.1952509731054306,
-0.3633805215358734,
-0.7114078402519226,
0.8799460530281067,
-1.2245479822158813,
-0.48988550901412964,
-0.7523773908615112,
-0.3201982378959656,
-0.2959236204624176,
-0.07439097762107849,
0.24882853031158447,
0.09789440780878067,
-0.30142924189567566,
0.18731336295604706,
0.6615581512451172,
-0.015915852040052414,
0.3952817916870117,
0.44568225741386414,
-0.04621689394116402,
-0.7408838272094727,
0.5374003052711487,
-0.2666129767894745,
0.2497456818819046,
0.5759775638580322,
0.5770823955535889,
-0.31405535340309143,
-0.07970326393842697,
-0.5187286734580994,
0.19640985131263733,
-0.42569485306739807,
-0.2329493910074234,
-0.2723753750324249,
0.21617981791496277,
-0.18122060596942902,
-0.13260573148727417,
-0.713951051235199,
-0.40244823694229126,
0.12690964341163635,
0.18799889087677002,
0.14025750756263733,
0.6507924199104309,
-0.24183416366577148,
0.2336743026971817,
-0.28343573212623596,
0.4130868911743164,
0.8343216180801392,
0.5208061933517456,
-0.1722899079322815,
-0.2574557065963745,
0.2321637123823166,
0.0027582510374486446,
-0.3391418159008026,
-1.0055540800094604,
0.10830280929803848,
-0.03810267150402069,
0.506107747554779,
0.5411460995674133,
0.34261763095855713,
0.7982533574104309,
-0.5252472162246704,
0.20293055474758148,
0.3150014579296112,
-0.7909082174301147,
0.787853479385376,
-0.20387139916419983,
0.15674714744091034,
0.9126203060150146,
0.7250974178314209,
-0.2062976062297821,
0.4570747911930084,
-0.6982250213623047,
-0.46169254183769226,
1.2727147340774536,
0.3070867359638214,
-0.3328222632408142,
0.23286285996437073,
0.626735270023346,
0.2729208171367645,
0.5195155143737793,
-0.6907879114151001,
-0.4835175573825836,
-0.27421656250953674,
0.1943793147802353,
0.13084478676319122,
-0.46714311838150024,
-0.3683626055717468,
-0.10278814285993576,
0.8053116798400879,
-0.19552701711654663,
0.4000741243362427,
0.1626550853252411,
0.1854272484779358,
-0.36410394310951233,
0.11110569536685944,
0.6925331354141235,
0.5815439820289612,
-0.8922741413116455,
-0.16028669476509094,
0.11876942217350006,
-0.1825008988380432,
0.47176969051361084,
-0.0947064682841301,
-0.4256085455417633,
0.010528848506510258,
-0.07745099812746048,
0.9404355883598328,
0.4054446220397949,
-0.5778816938400269,
0.6522756218910217,
-0.3609079122543335,
-0.2733173668384552,
-0.07658237963914871,
0.2185288965702057,
-0.18871836364269257,
-0.16842561960220337,
0.3748520314693451,
0.16869458556175232,
0.38319501280784607,
-0.603298544883728,
0.1299062967300415,
0.25644275546073914,
-0.6269610524177551,
-0.01948385499417782,
0.4537196159362793,
0.4964199662208557,
-0.13587789237499237,
0.03897915780544281,
-0.22412820160388947,
-0.275114506483078,
0.6302649974822998,
0.5282357335090637,
0.7299849390983582,
-0.36019665002822876,
0.33450114727020264,
0.4069201350212097,
0.016654808074235916,
-0.44024598598480225,
0.16731570661067963,
-0.3771756589412689,
-0.4384826421737671,
-0.1899310052394867,
-0.4942649304866791,
-0.8910616636276245,
-0.020223800092935562,
-0.8458765149116516,
0.6948738694190979,
-0.7666888236999512,
0.010471558198332787,
-0.08805935829877853,
0.2775496244430542,
-0.49266669154167175,
0.10145635157823563,
0.36653271317481995,
0.9705407619476318,
-0.6839182376861572,
0.863903284072876,
0.8167446851730347,
-0.07585712522268295,
-0.6952641606330872,
-0.03684419393539429,
0.21804462373256683,
-0.9296531081199646,
0.803600013256073,
0.03717838227748871,
-0.45343899726867676,
-0.2687259912490845,
-0.46754154562950134,
-0.8875206112861633,
1.3279571533203125,
0.7190026640892029,
-0.5646727085113525,
0.07089389860630035,
0.052029434591531754,
0.1736588180065155,
-0.40688556432724,
0.5993726253509521,
0.343858540058136,
0.2556939721107483,
0.5673723220825195,
-0.6602025032043457,
-0.10134478658437729,
-0.06438662111759186,
0.15274551510810852,
0.11737744510173798,
-1.2175986766815186,
0.566741943359375,
-0.14704835414886475,
0.2655257284641266,
0.03160629794001579,
0.5528622269630432,
0.7157454490661621,
0.26188740134239197,
0.7341909408569336,
0.5974522233009338,
0.5550720691680908,
-0.14522522687911987,
1.3852183818817139,
-0.18433701992034912,
0.3968696892261505,
0.9184519052505493,
-0.2710234522819519,
0.8632042407989502,
0.5966203212738037,
-0.12946933507919312,
0.45752063393592834,
0.7248543500900269,
0.5314427018165588,
0.9954139590263367,
0.18539689481258392,
-0.11718593537807465,
-0.5190441608428955,
-0.32475370168685913,
-0.39527207612991333,
0.5341513752937317,
-0.3855140209197998,
-0.06547702848911285,
-0.07343390583992004,
-0.4153299331665039,
0.05605349317193031,
-0.09795445948839188,
-0.3751382827758789,
0.7374873757362366,
0.08851905912160873,
-0.8755505084991455,
0.48972392082214355,
-0.03862221911549568,
0.5526601672172546,
-1.1517071723937988,
-0.09887003153562546,
-0.5244707465171814,
0.5513623952865601,
-0.038109470158815384,
-0.08110527694225311,
-0.2812875807285309,
-0.09124310314655304,
-0.08016456663608551,
-0.14908328652381897,
0.5956125259399414,
-0.21688714623451233,
-0.20137560367584229,
0.41524678468704224,
0.23922093212604523,
-0.1671314388513565,
0.046928770840168,
-0.8574979901313782,
0.32783791422843933,
0.1308148354291916,
-0.30257323384284973,
0.3732832968235016,
0.20325787365436554,
0.12248975783586502,
0.8174710273742676,
0.4988456964492798,
0.06575479358434677,
-0.21831557154655457,
-0.13593897223472595,
0.6853798627853394,
-0.649692177772522,
-0.6800989508628845,
-0.8113760948181152,
0.11445986479520798,
-0.3480195105075836,
-0.4966197609901428,
0.43541768193244934,
0.6265727877616882,
0.552248477935791,
-0.20310094952583313,
0.4817264974117279,
0.04424874112010002,
0.19581884145736694,
-0.3678704500198364,
-0.15810087323188782,
-0.8353484272956848,
0.13159137964248657,
-0.38017338514328003,
-1.0406367778778076,
0.07204890996217728,
0.3459663689136505,
-0.11471325904130936,
-0.12548598647117615,
0.5598300695419312,
0.3834496736526489,
-0.1492704600095749,
-0.1973406821489334,
0.4230785667896271,
-0.4506289064884186,
-0.0015793060883879662,
0.9040128588676453,
0.8894563913345337,
-0.35630902647972107,
0.9653846621513367,
-0.721901535987854,
-0.6340699791908264,
-0.6534078121185303,
-1.1339225769042969,
-0.62548828125,
-0.009254241362214088,
-0.08926213532686234,
0.03512989729642868,
0.22515849769115448,
1.3579645156860352,
0.8068358898162842,
-0.6596943736076355,
-0.49620121717453003,
0.2785082757472992,
0.17509421706199646,
-0.4956806004047394,
-0.1327182650566101,
0.15479005873203278,
-0.27515482902526855,
-0.9996550679206848,
0.3449552655220032,
0.46114200353622437,
-0.013352581299841404,
0.25617626309394836,
-0.598071813583374,
-0.1277507096529007,
0.3404610753059387,
0.504828929901123,
0.4114203155040741,
-0.7282777428627014,
-0.32094937562942505,
0.1873871088027954,
-0.19356225430965424,
0.026753317564725876,
1.0020999908447266,
-0.606890082359314,
0.6245153546333313,
0.5972678661346436,
0.5137171149253845,
0.671412467956543,
0.48539111018180847,
0.7240455150604248,
-0.6399272680282593,
0.539367139339447,
0.1461513638496399,
0.36743029952049255,
0.009771321900188923,
-0.3602917194366455,
0.8140164613723755,
0.45635950565338135,
-0.35547542572021484,
-0.5731825828552246,
0.24236340820789337,
-1.414613962173462,
-0.23226547241210938,
1.313302755355835,
0.033485446125268936,
-0.2731172442436218,
0.4122779071331024,
-0.5283089280128479,
0.07921379059553146,
-0.7048074007034302,
1.0617595911026,
0.4908580183982849,
-0.6682515740394592,
0.0806090235710144,
-0.2860141694545746,
1.107796549797058,
0.6913439035415649,
-0.7563259601593018,
-0.09652252495288849,
0.35493049025535583,
0.3017657995223999,
0.025050194934010506,
0.8658483028411865,
0.05692075937986374,
0.6131955981254578,
-0.03545482084155083,
0.23089413344860077,
-0.5856274366378784,
-0.3589917719364166,
-0.3262209892272949,
0.3815186619758606,
0.3436061441898346,
-0.4916701018810272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14722v1
|
CAPE: Context-Adaptive Positional Encoding for Length Extrapolation
| 2024-05-23T15:51:24 | 2024-05-23T15:51:24 |
Chuanyang Zheng, Yihang Gao, Han Shi, Minbin Huang, Jingyao Li, Jing Xiong, Xiaozhe Ren, Michael Ng, Xin Jiang, Zhenguo Li, Yu Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Positional encoding plays a crucial role in transformers, significantly
impacting model performance and length generalization. Prior research has
introduced absolute positional encoding (APE) and relative positional encoding
(RPE) to distinguish token positions in given sequences. However, both APE and
RPE remain fixed after model training regardless of input data, limiting their
adaptability and flexibility. Hence, we expect that the desired positional
encoding should be context-adaptive and can be dynamically adjusted with the
given attention. In this paper, we propose a Context-Adaptive Positional
Encoding (CAPE) method, which dynamically and semantically adjusts based on
input context and learned fixed priors. Experimental validation on real-world
datasets (Arxiv, Books3, and CHE) demonstrates that CAPE enhances model
performances in terms of trained length and length generalization, where the
improvements are statistically significant. The model visualization suggests
that our model can keep both local and anti-local information. Finally, we
successfully train the model on sequence length 128 and achieve better
performance at evaluation sequence length 8192, compared with other static
positional encoding methods, revealing the benefit of the adaptive positional
encoding method.
|
[
-0.40250444412231445,
-0.5741103887557983,
0.3113577365875244,
0.2567445635795593,
-0.4000145196914673,
-0.025078659877181053,
-0.327983021736145,
-0.5428560376167297,
0.4200543165206909,
0.09180504083633423,
-0.40532568097114563,
-0.12928317487239838,
-0.8332631587982178,
0.1604432612657547,
-0.27295780181884766,
0.5780465602874756,
-0.10698701441287994,
-0.15949369966983795,
0.07324012368917465,
-0.24919195473194122,
-0.8488690257072449,
-0.7855122089385986,
-0.29119130969047546,
0.12250437587499619,
0.3955288231372833,
0.4645318388938904,
1.021871566772461,
0.8483839631080627,
0.4204097092151642,
0.27652010321617126,
-0.12223648279905319,
0.3159097135066986,
-0.277213454246521,
0.10878095775842667,
-0.2616713345050812,
-0.3939650356769562,
-0.6437901258468628,
-0.3576548993587494,
0.9168491959571838,
0.5999464392662048,
-0.18387523293495178,
0.16794976592063904,
-0.05293533578515053,
0.6967347264289856,
-0.7800085544586182,
-0.08587533235549927,
-0.7821435332298279,
0.12819528579711914,
0.13462984561920166,
-0.44868847727775574,
-0.49286651611328125,
0.135551318526268,
0.16023923456668854,
-0.8571944832801819,
0.47347721457481384,
-0.10831364244222641,
0.9080886244773865,
0.21057549118995667,
-0.4830980598926544,
0.013751190155744553,
-0.7382028102874756,
0.8298436999320984,
-0.646004855632782,
0.7654424905776978,
0.3336254358291626,
0.4851917028427124,
-0.04683394357562065,
-0.6039682626724243,
-0.6077095866203308,
0.0056533291935920715,
-0.24916334450244904,
0.2060556858778,
0.0378623902797699,
-0.2788563072681427,
0.34793150424957275,
0.21308083832263947,
-0.2995522916316986,
0.04181902855634689,
-0.4219626784324646,
-0.17987903952598572,
0.7535905241966248,
-0.023007165640592575,
0.12018831074237823,
-0.05167052149772644,
-0.6268443465232849,
-0.4595130383968353,
-0.6285803318023682,
0.16827699542045593,
0.27853479981422424,
0.26438912749290466,
-0.5235804319381714,
0.35541462898254395,
-0.12102069705724716,
0.867012619972229,
0.2781241536140442,
0.1181497648358345,
0.44826561212539673,
0.21333612501621246,
-0.04141578823328018,
0.2121632993221283,
0.3161184787750244,
0.4050385057926178,
-0.050428055226802826,
0.05914721637964249,
-0.18597745895385742,
-0.2053573727607727,
0.5465323328971863,
-0.4848020076751709,
-0.039238955825567245,
-0.04294830933213234,
-0.32750964164733887,
0.0565749853849411,
0.2529882788658142,
-0.7830101251602173,
-0.23085317015647888,
-0.48710986971855164,
0.4393273591995239,
-0.40487390756607056,
0.03607628494501114,
-0.06625860184431076,
-0.08128726482391357,
0.3569371700286865,
0.08455119282007217,
-1.3391451835632324,
-0.03880883380770683,
0.3859001398086548,
0.9351873993873596,
-0.26284852623939514,
-0.44189155101776123,
-0.5647285580635071,
0.4511340260505676,
-0.3576427698135376,
0.6768358945846558,
-0.6319375038146973,
-0.48172706365585327,
0.06332892924547195,
0.22732795774936676,
-0.16470485925674438,
-0.34893664717674255,
0.45117881894111633,
-0.9069639444351196,
-0.019874854013323784,
-0.3971896767616272,
-0.38891851902008057,
-0.3511052429676056,
0.11401404440402985,
-0.645761251449585,
0.8413271307945251,
0.3623235523700714,
-0.40792766213417053,
0.6225695610046387,
-0.9115014672279358,
-0.61917644739151,
-0.1791536509990692,
-0.04748949408531189,
-0.3047892451286316,
0.3167939782142639,
0.809542715549469,
0.37148749828338623,
0.029421236366033554,
0.07049916684627533,
-0.007821481674909592,
-0.6800194382667542,
0.2654833495616913,
-0.7284083962440491,
0.1833840012550354,
0.07266474515199661,
-0.21283021569252014,
0.4438036382198334,
-0.8991117477416992,
-0.1360688954591751,
0.02887994796037674,
-0.26592764258384705,
0.020244643092155457,
0.10829604417085648,
-0.21024107933044434,
0.13721606135368347,
0.15610353648662567,
-0.3810410499572754,
0.35818812251091003,
-0.5259612798690796,
0.3690810203552246,
0.770880937576294,
-0.046754494309425354,
0.7178318500518799,
-0.019474007189273834,
0.6109911203384399,
-0.12882591784000397,
0.19048133492469788,
-0.34003713726997375,
-0.24640528857707977,
-0.6463900208473206,
-0.10328049957752228,
0.5335691571235657,
0.468306303024292,
-0.7173474431037903,
0.5131190419197083,
-0.47171005606651306,
-0.3945252299308777,
0.01634787954390049,
-0.4192565977573395,
-0.06169573962688446,
0.6553933620452881,
0.8643955588340759,
-0.5351590514183044,
-0.5899331569671631,
-0.693866491317749,
-0.18273910880088806,
0.11172594130039215,
-0.3387134373188019,
0.25034084916114807,
0.1754569411277771,
-0.2178446352481842,
1.192833662033081,
-0.682603120803833,
-0.13441382348537445,
-0.0838228240609169,
0.14775680005550385,
0.3632706105709076,
0.4749511480331421,
0.6631703972816467,
-0.9511035084724426,
-0.2602386474609375,
-0.20218074321746826,
-0.6470186710357666,
-0.08255861699581146,
-0.27528902888298035,
-0.06931234896183014,
-0.011586026288568974,
0.17010557651519775,
-0.20385558903217316,
0.6349808573722839,
0.653389036655426,
-0.32223403453826904,
0.5308288931846619,
-0.5532007813453674,
0.13070136308670044,
-0.8573507070541382,
-0.06415244191884995,
-0.2376077026128769,
-0.3694027066230774,
-0.533208966255188,
0.06212347745895386,
0.278173565864563,
-0.29929712414741516,
-0.5901455879211426,
0.34950488805770874,
-0.5862285494804382,
-0.41836732625961304,
-0.6071166396141052,
0.015461583621799946,
0.13596542179584503,
0.7524958848953247,
0.5240872502326965,
0.9230527877807617,
0.5431113839149475,
-0.8640673160552979,
0.39565402269363403,
0.474042683839798,
-0.37051862478256226,
0.33192089200019836,
-0.54642653465271,
0.2527698576450348,
0.06940446048974991,
0.5454555749893188,
-0.7092347145080566,
-0.2675088942050934,
0.0911114364862442,
-0.2936573028564453,
0.4741314649581909,
-0.24424609541893005,
0.010023729875683784,
-0.2579389214515686,
-0.07294215261936188,
0.7375046610832214,
0.4184093177318573,
-0.7411340475082397,
0.8192318677902222,
0.23970112204551697,
-0.11334244161844254,
-0.8835843205451965,
-0.625556230545044,
-0.006845137104392052,
-0.2057412564754486,
-0.491068959236145,
0.8772467374801636,
0.1297730952501297,
0.3918963670730591,
-0.5188152194023132,
-0.4072429835796356,
-0.13230262696743011,
-0.2141338735818863,
0.2380383461713791,
0.1801963895559311,
-0.18314418196678162,
-0.09835461527109146,
0.25448107719421387,
-0.2792007625102997,
-0.11909490823745728,
-0.1367974579334259,
0.6941121220588684,
-0.044341083616018295,
-0.24025218188762665,
-0.4043709337711334,
0.3580663800239563,
0.49311256408691406,
-0.0803089588880539,
0.8230032324790955,
0.6639091372489929,
-0.2769838273525238,
-0.20383870601654053,
-0.2370915561914444,
-0.25737622380256653,
-0.5567362904548645,
0.5009297132492065,
-0.4441806375980377,
-0.6059570908546448,
0.6937717199325562,
-0.046711429953575134,
-0.18934501707553864,
0.3183284401893616,
0.36061471700668335,
-0.06648606806993484,
0.9433467984199524,
0.9888390302658081,
0.14347118139266968,
0.6045395731925964,
-0.38715213537216187,
0.16983547806739807,
-1.0335205793380737,
-0.11922767013311386,
0.05206352472305298,
-0.6947171688079834,
-0.11732608824968338,
-0.45965009927749634,
0.44757822155952454,
0.37806037068367004,
-0.3558008670806885,
0.7484806776046753,
-0.6471336483955383,
0.5123209357261658,
0.4043377935886383,
0.29106467962265015,
-0.2135012447834015,
-0.043479904532432556,
-0.06533296406269073,
-0.14551368355751038,
-0.8713110089302063,
-0.37433138489723206,
0.8070749640464783,
0.41665685176849365,
0.5090935826301575,
0.17646116018295288,
-0.019359929487109184,
0.7642303109169006,
0.05889035761356354,
-0.6893601417541504,
0.40454667806625366,
0.046167921274900436,
-0.1264318972826004,
-0.3757816553115845,
-0.14224863052368164,
-0.6786776185035706,
0.13542380928993225,
-0.14135074615478516,
-0.6927492022514343,
0.8485580682754517,
0.524755597114563,
-0.5494612455368042,
0.31927016377449036,
-0.4555608034133911,
0.7300968170166016,
-0.3694379925727844,
-0.19939696788787842,
-0.06745383143424988,
-0.8746673464775085,
-0.2044413834810257,
-0.18959541618824005,
0.07220012694597244,
0.023880228400230408,
-0.05708189308643341,
0.8630226254463196,
-0.6499891877174377,
0.7243327498435974,
-0.3271656930446625,
-0.2930713891983032,
0.31693169474601746,
0.06489019095897675,
0.6377689242362976,
0.12910592555999756,
-0.16054679453372955,
0.5544854998588562,
0.04427675902843475,
-0.5743147134780884,
-0.7231811881065369,
0.40614575147628784,
-0.8135502338409424,
-0.5547505617141724,
-0.3199772834777832,
-0.8629898428916931,
-0.45428237318992615,
-0.045373640954494476,
0.6581091284751892,
0.4935283660888672,
0.05664575472474098,
0.16487658023834229,
0.164128839969635,
-0.4358910918235779,
0.6889490485191345,
0.3397473096847534,
0.13381923735141754,
-0.39878809452056885,
0.6608322262763977,
-0.02829006128013134,
0.2303859144449234,
0.6793227791786194,
0.13005444407463074,
-0.5453042387962341,
-0.44329917430877686,
-0.6943231225013733,
-0.20567430555820465,
-0.9724084734916687,
-0.37680670619010925,
-0.26332610845565796,
-0.001645230338908732,
-0.3275466561317444,
-0.6185625791549683,
-0.3816556930541992,
-0.6285192370414734,
-0.0642334520816803,
-0.07360503077507019,
0.49747079610824585,
0.46446192264556885,
-0.3909795582294464,
0.8617941737174988,
-0.9671237468719482,
0.4264528155326843,
0.33931782841682434,
0.38950079679489136,
0.05579806864261627,
-1.053955078125,
-0.28260159492492676,
0.2202199548482895,
-0.20363405346870422,
-0.9036301970481873,
0.5269215106964111,
0.32831186056137085,
0.25517845153808594,
0.2401466965675354,
-0.0012674443423748016,
0.8898146152496338,
-0.7861371636390686,
1.0473847389221191,
0.19990737736225128,
-1.1139156818389893,
0.3631708323955536,
-0.19563251733779907,
0.33232882618904114,
0.3524024188518524,
0.25812986493110657,
-0.5747566223144531,
0.5425595045089722,
-0.23625752329826355,
-1.2228000164031982,
0.7898673415184021,
0.15298029780387878,
0.37499645352363586,
-0.01422713790088892,
0.5816576480865479,
0.17913506925106049,
-0.14081187546253204,
-0.42848721146583557,
0.007601005956530571,
-0.5334814190864563,
-0.035148922353982925,
0.19438304007053375,
-0.4598233997821808,
-0.017899340018630028,
-0.2732402980327606,
0.8391435146331787,
-0.33278733491897583,
0.7606562376022339,
0.37529876828193665,
-0.5252386331558228,
0.03905141353607178,
0.03311014547944069,
0.9330173134803772,
1.1271929740905762,
-0.09823694825172424,
-0.17897163331508636,
0.7247368693351746,
-0.5652563571929932,
0.2527925670146942,
-0.06828644871711731,
0.11895537376403809,
0.06849311292171478,
0.3808373510837555,
0.9430035948753357,
0.2105303853750229,
-0.44789788126945496,
0.740303099155426,
0.1143173798918724,
0.2657760679721832,
-0.4709273874759674,
0.02944883331656456,
-0.3559034466743469,
0.12412133067846298,
0.5604034662246704,
0.2712610065937042,
-0.1548837423324585,
-0.30972081422805786,
0.45454421639442444,
-0.06773752719163895,
-0.6409985423088074,
-0.39475899934768677,
0.8374071717262268,
0.17928087711334229,
-0.3576430678367615,
0.44921231269836426,
0.29180970788002014,
-0.5818341970443726,
0.6581980586051941,
0.7007681727409363,
0.5210294127464294,
-0.38125625252723694,
-0.14447414875030518,
0.3099921643733978,
-0.10395660251379013,
0.029468383640050888,
0.14271655678749084,
-0.3598240613937378,
-0.8604683876037598,
-0.6298922300338745,
-0.6665685176849365,
-0.4113287925720215,
-0.02531767264008522,
-0.8309312462806702,
0.4665551781654358,
-0.3621632754802704,
-0.10988559573888779,
-0.3735557794570923,
-0.6872007250785828,
-0.572187066078186,
0.5652375817298889,
0.1963670700788498,
1.1640585660934448,
-0.6246341466903687,
0.8137620687484741,
0.5805627703666687,
-0.08083757758140564,
-0.8076071739196777,
0.07664443552494049,
-0.4261365532875061,
-0.7655349373817444,
0.4574812650680542,
0.2791764736175537,
-0.3087069094181061,
-0.15946927666664124,
-0.31754136085510254,
-1.1725363731384277,
1.1349421739578247,
0.3054139018058777,
-0.8830060958862305,
-0.051110800355672836,
0.447202205657959,
0.3671141564846039,
-0.4199221432209015,
0.21221031248569489,
0.3036169707775116,
0.2653675079345703,
0.033626485615968704,
-0.7543684840202332,
-0.023064952343702316,
-0.14393439888954163,
0.20739956200122833,
0.028949987143278122,
-0.5663461089134216,
0.3498588502407074,
0.017886994406580925,
-0.011461080983281136,
0.2467086762189865,
1.1240133047103882,
0.19970548152923584,
-0.0477910190820694,
0.6272168159484863,
0.21085283160209656,
0.5300028324127197,
-0.07755905389785767,
1.0621074438095093,
-0.5995562076568604,
0.4206419885158539,
1.2196427583694458,
-0.3509249985218048,
0.7567705512046814,
0.22970859706401825,
-0.01737639680504799,
0.6812766194343567,
0.5523566007614136,
-0.08867527544498444,
0.7091590166091919,
-0.06514036655426025,
-0.07358020544052124,
-0.1297260969877243,
0.34795212745666504,
-0.6759285926818848,
0.6187360882759094,
0.45476239919662476,
-0.6729249954223633,
0.1852036416530609,
0.2877993881702423,
-0.3383757770061493,
0.2051500529050827,
-0.3956208825111389,
0.3515506088733673,
-0.13093458116054535,
-0.48231059312820435,
0.9095821380615234,
0.2499738335609436,
0.7023890018463135,
-0.7724144458770752,
-0.12933216989040375,
0.0006369925104081631,
0.16549552977085114,
-0.07329436391592026,
-0.5181871652603149,
0.5001545548439026,
-0.07490132749080658,
-0.457294225692749,
-0.14703722298145294,
0.6732854247093201,
-0.10128185153007507,
-0.3725273609161377,
0.20242656767368317,
-0.08322088420391083,
0.018993549048900604,
-0.08562470972537994,
-0.5580025911331177,
0.14472785592079163,
-0.27574339509010315,
-0.26851147413253784,
0.11979611963033676,
0.04184569790959358,
-0.40998491644859314,
0.318268746137619,
0.7539820075035095,
-0.1644880771636963,
0.09791559725999832,
0.08609192073345184,
0.587343156337738,
-0.8462474942207336,
-0.8935270309448242,
-0.7336479425430298,
0.4033133387565613,
-0.07671000808477402,
-0.29962843656539917,
0.43502768874168396,
0.40938788652420044,
0.8251575231552124,
-0.33945319056510925,
0.35478782653808594,
-0.07745353877544403,
0.28682926297187805,
-0.4228213429450989,
0.6483728289604187,
-0.2557539641857147,
0.30752328038215637,
-0.16091324388980865,
-1.3058773279190063,
-0.4483393430709839,
0.8089693188667297,
-0.5108636021614075,
0.1207534521818161,
0.4381011128425598,
0.5363261699676514,
-0.41408172249794006,
0.12122613191604614,
0.285921573638916,
0.09215446561574936,
0.19266971945762634,
0.5059859156608582,
0.7402780652046204,
-0.6682838201522827,
0.3116043210029602,
-0.2646370530128479,
-0.20874984562397003,
-0.13187210261821747,
-1.1979649066925049,
-0.3907683491706848,
-0.4389180839061737,
-0.1705760359764099,
-0.0812034085392952,
-0.009434795938432217,
0.7430534958839417,
1.1234453916549683,
-0.9174889326095581,
0.0595509335398674,
0.017716187983751297,
-0.31328195333480835,
-0.7635300159454346,
-0.20570650696754456,
0.7753912806510925,
0.046812742948532104,
-0.627439558506012,
1.0978238582611084,
0.2398325800895691,
-0.10830242931842804,
0.30880674719810486,
-0.14570094645023346,
-0.17572863399982452,
0.18404456973075867,
0.7929661870002747,
0.5089734196662903,
-0.5247567892074585,
-0.7907994389533997,
-0.24002374708652496,
0.37707215547561646,
0.4468485713005066,
0.8494359254837036,
-0.9496536254882812,
0.3599889576435089,
0.5886421203613281,
0.4409707486629486,
0.39928045868873596,
0.4345000386238098,
0.9877109527587891,
-1.2503031492233276,
0.4874504804611206,
0.07118423283100128,
0.6608312726020813,
0.406572550535202,
-0.6704224348068237,
0.5781346559524536,
0.10981442779302597,
-0.4525785446166992,
-0.6867159008979797,
0.4112308919429779,
-1.1087777614593506,
-0.33135369420051575,
0.9424524307250977,
-0.2516689598560333,
-0.09354878962039948,
0.11917978525161743,
-0.2584877908229828,
0.5469178557395935,
-0.19409097731113434,
0.8305420875549316,
0.33788228034973145,
-0.15269197523593903,
0.04078397527337074,
-0.15272685885429382,
0.34922313690185547,
0.556637704372406,
-0.24773980677127838,
-0.03448805585503578,
0.2158128023147583,
0.21741200983524323,
0.42893290519714355,
0.0263734869658947,
-0.06282299011945724,
0.5105912685394287,
-0.23283308744430542,
-0.048436664044857025,
-0.29224294424057007,
-0.5568689107894897,
-0.5597445964813232,
0.22106780111789703,
-0.2605774700641632,
-0.3233834207057953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14696v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14696v2
|
A Declarative System for Optimizing AI Workloads
| 2024-05-23T15:31:18 | 2024-05-29T15:27:07 |
Chunwei Liu, Matthew Russo, Michael Cafarella, Lei Cao, Peter Baille Chen, Zui Chen, Michael Franklin, Tim Kraska, Samuel Madden, Gerardo Vitagliano
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, H.2.3; I.2.5
|
A long-standing goal of data management systems has been to build systems
which can compute quantitative insights over large corpora of unstructured data
in a cost-effective manner. Until recently, it was difficult and expensive to
extract facts from company documents, data from scientific papers, or metrics
from image and video corpora. Today's models can accomplish these tasks with
high accuracy. However, a programmer who wants to answer a substantive
AI-powered query must orchestrate large numbers of models, prompts, and data
operations. For even a single query, the programmer has to make a vast number
of decisions such as the choice of model, the right inference method, the most
cost-effective inference hardware, the ideal prompt design, and so on. The
optimal set of decisions can change as the query changes and as the
rapidly-evolving technical landscape shifts. In this paper we present
Palimpzest, a system that enables anyone to process AI-powered analytical
queries simply by defining them in a declarative language. The system uses its
cost optimization framework to implement the query plan with the best
trade-offs between runtime, financial cost, and output data quality. We
describe the workload of AI-powered analytics tasks, the optimization methods
that Palimpzest uses, and the prototype system itself. We evaluate Palimpzest
on tasks in Legal Discovery, Real Estate Search, and Medical Schema Matching.
We show that even our simple prototype offers a range of appealing plans,
including one that is 3.3x faster and 2.9x cheaper than the baseline method,
while also offering better data quality. With parallelism enabled, Palimpzest
can produce plans with up to a 90.3x speedup at 9.1x lower cost relative to a
single-threaded GPT-4 baseline, while obtaining an F1-score within 83.5% of the
baseline. These require no additional work by the user.
|
[
-0.1575225591659546,
-0.405752956867218,
0.5939224362373352,
0.3939579129219055,
-0.3460533916950226,
0.11143086850643158,
-0.05825027823448181,
-0.2348637729883194,
0.2606687843799591,
0.4640499949455261,
-0.5148194432258606,
-0.5210914015769958,
-0.20778797566890717,
0.02969074249267578,
-0.4183614253997803,
0.8762049674987793,
0.14412960410118103,
0.015678536146879196,
-0.3641131520271301,
-0.20390503108501434,
-0.31521546840667725,
-0.3141610324382782,
-0.662387490272522,
-0.011125168763101101,
0.03095124661922455,
0.2778950035572052,
0.9232813715934753,
0.8395684957504272,
0.8322703242301941,
0.34957462549209595,
0.2958238124847412,
0.2828756272792816,
-0.35664528608322144,
0.6463157534599304,
-0.15407155454158783,
-0.6415265202522278,
-0.2856746315956116,
-0.10032592713832855,
0.3394568860530853,
0.7034346461296082,
-0.48301705718040466,
0.3354260325431824,
-0.27419811487197876,
0.8151230812072754,
-0.6719503402709961,
0.6557582020759583,
-0.4799993634223938,
0.04770262911915779,
-0.27843818068504333,
-0.22468110918998718,
-0.21441295742988586,
-0.5413612723350525,
-0.013240826316177845,
-0.7954557538032532,
0.09213124960660934,
0.28460222482681274,
0.5944514274597168,
0.9291719794273376,
0.05697530508041382,
-0.24545793235301971,
-0.7732536196708679,
0.5607179403305054,
-0.47183024883270264,
0.28320348262786865,
0.384098619222641,
0.4935764968395233,
0.09178991615772247,
-0.7540165185928345,
-0.23240748047828674,
-0.3406146168708801,
-0.16744239628314972,
0.19442299008369446,
-0.4290381669998169,
0.16341835260391235,
0.3288109600543976,
0.3036001920700073,
-0.9103038907051086,
0.07383213937282562,
-0.5875091552734375,
-0.01851479336619377,
0.6669000387191772,
0.6930155754089355,
0.14359870553016663,
0.10631047934293747,
-0.14862117171287537,
0.08240193873643875,
-0.6278220415115356,
-0.28763261437416077,
0.162536159157753,
0.1492052972316742,
0.19815026223659515,
0.6170732975006104,
-0.5435495972633362,
0.7132686376571655,
-0.0922735258936882,
0.09088072925806046,
-0.15480005741119385,
-0.2633947432041168,
-0.32284754514694214,
0.11041605472564697,
0.6814963221549988,
0.20040182769298553,
0.004609991330653429,
-0.37778282165527344,
-0.29966121912002563,
0.2281760424375534,
0.4168013334274292,
-1.0352344512939453,
-0.5481261610984802,
0.26518794894218445,
-0.3563169240951538,
-0.2742391526699066,
-0.06331503391265869,
-0.8807790279388428,
-0.36693865060806274,
-0.5406177043914795,
0.18880483508110046,
-0.6178745031356812,
0.07315627485513687,
-0.1233290508389473,
-0.06481216102838516,
0.16714103519916534,
0.3590705096721649,
-0.7337896227836609,
0.40192869305610657,
0.7708417177200317,
1.020618200302124,
-0.1700506955385208,
-0.04943552240729332,
-0.6943243145942688,
-0.04917372390627861,
-0.6959574222564697,
0.6986498832702637,
-0.5664821863174438,
-0.3781740963459015,
-0.35111042857170105,
-0.457544207572937,
-0.03632885217666626,
-0.5460733771324158,
0.42519447207450867,
-0.7696569561958313,
0.10182642191648483,
-0.23287193477153778,
-0.5120623707771301,
0.037600450217723846,
0.2509409487247467,
-0.7300147414207458,
0.8692755699157715,
-0.06279696524143219,
-0.4994945824146271,
0.42011645436286926,
-0.979055643081665,
-0.42734670639038086,
0.44708991050720215,
-0.2422545999288559,
-0.19027327001094818,
0.19581516087055206,
0.2003541886806488,
0.051280613988637924,
-0.6749652028083801,
0.3091229200363159,
0.18134981393814087,
-0.3679397702217102,
-0.1895294040441513,
-0.403251051902771,
0.7558619976043701,
0.3298671543598175,
-0.4339156746864319,
0.025727132335305214,
-0.8969520926475525,
-0.04329213872551918,
0.1601831614971161,
-0.6181004643440247,
-0.18483982980251312,
0.3016532361507416,
-0.41157516837120056,
-0.32673439383506775,
0.3264826834201813,
-0.39023008942604065,
0.12634989619255066,
-0.47721901535987854,
0.45232877135276794,
0.7153579592704773,
-0.32591429352760315,
0.3870406746864319,
-0.17407631874084473,
0.7882551550865173,
-0.5489370822906494,
0.23571620881557465,
-0.21279282867908478,
-0.2953666150569916,
-0.5831421613693237,
-0.5137969255447388,
0.15351524949073792,
0.6856058835983276,
-0.5540457963943481,
0.3309573829174042,
-0.2982002794742584,
-0.5875148177146912,
-0.8465980291366577,
-0.12172089517116547,
0.13492262363433838,
0.5775430798530579,
0.4419172406196594,
-0.02274296246469021,
-0.2822478711605072,
-1.0236817598342896,
-0.2103271484375,
-0.3704339265823364,
-0.07268745452165604,
0.225070059299469,
0.19778846204280853,
0.20835921168327332,
0.832628071308136,
-0.8588321208953857,
0.0849493220448494,
0.03795255348086357,
0.37174397706985474,
0.28506332635879517,
0.2905580997467041,
0.13498538732528687,
-0.9536170363426208,
-0.4849209487438202,
-0.012653960846364498,
-0.72176593542099,
-0.3657236695289612,
-0.26163241267204285,
-0.1439736783504486,
0.015976563096046448,
0.33614131808280945,
-1.0093324184417725,
0.4293956458568573,
0.035305023193359375,
-0.11175931990146637,
0.7221922278404236,
-0.32635927200317383,
-0.03737398609519005,
-0.6921087503433228,
0.3105120062828064,
-0.25018781423568726,
-0.10147422552108765,
-0.46967944502830505,
0.11349944770336151,
-0.07547193765640259,
-0.4635566174983978,
-0.022348299622535706,
0.1862611621618271,
-0.36084067821502686,
-0.21815606951713562,
-0.19895105063915253,
-0.08425425738096237,
0.10517002642154694,
0.511893093585968,
-0.27179914712905884,
1.1402876377105713,
0.5852298140525818,
-0.46297308802604675,
0.817469596862793,
0.3740611970424652,
-0.2304682582616806,
0.9105247855186462,
-0.7188354730606079,
0.07853943854570389,
-0.3227553963661194,
0.044509921222925186,
-0.743230938911438,
-0.22655142843723297,
0.1296325922012329,
-0.29673126339912415,
0.11023274809122086,
-0.046596135944128036,
-0.6982682943344116,
-0.2136085033416748,
-0.23415927588939667,
0.18527814745903015,
0.46152442693710327,
-0.6943812370300293,
0.5620118975639343,
0.2484302520751953,
-0.28597110509872437,
-0.39850372076034546,
-0.5680573582649231,
0.3814365267753601,
-0.17537668347358704,
-0.5807929039001465,
0.3668271005153656,
0.10454258322715759,
-0.44018134474754333,
0.23574459552764893,
-0.2922515571117401,
-0.05127178132534027,
-0.10167745500802994,
0.23795154690742493,
0.38574638962745667,
-0.1431153118610382,
0.2527179718017578,
0.19628304243087769,
-0.28706955909729004,
0.13038578629493713,
-0.41690123081207275,
0.5645923018455505,
-0.24374139308929443,
-0.6216346025466919,
-0.506619930267334,
0.3213637173175812,
0.9670253992080688,
-0.6549230813980103,
0.512338399887085,
0.35977551341056824,
-0.21492204070091248,
-0.2118178904056549,
-0.4637831747531891,
-0.04762309789657593,
-0.45686423778533936,
0.2815344035625458,
-0.3469949960708618,
-0.30945897102355957,
0.3380340039730072,
-0.08182606101036072,
0.2812373638153076,
0.5731923580169678,
0.5429508090019226,
0.02724902331829071,
1.1428645849227905,
0.27355116605758667,
-0.22589242458343506,
0.15764625370502472,
-0.2550806403160095,
0.21844658255577087,
-0.27920520305633545,
-0.42120981216430664,
-0.5786089301109314,
-0.3654734194278717,
-0.7310107350349426,
-0.2431674301624298,
0.716641902923584,
-0.2781435549259186,
-0.520114541053772,
0.2597390115261078,
-0.8349830508232117,
0.4958588480949402,
0.967705249786377,
-0.02405896782875061,
0.4494025707244873,
-0.24135078489780426,
0.4298117458820343,
0.0762638971209526,
-0.58962482213974,
-0.2583804726600647,
1.0036073923110962,
-0.17985403537750244,
0.8666331171989441,
0.08783791214227676,
0.5791544318199158,
0.4349629282951355,
0.080357626080513,
-0.6257212162017822,
0.6458829045295715,
-0.18762195110321045,
-0.5377375483512878,
-0.35354912281036377,
-0.4682694375514984,
-0.9304569959640503,
0.439749151468277,
0.22808179259300232,
-0.4902333617210388,
0.3739461302757263,
-0.019299844279885292,
-0.4743816554546356,
0.18202413618564606,
-0.5756340026855469,
0.6414898037910461,
-0.44510331749916077,
-0.41700953245162964,
-0.5559558272361755,
-0.6835805773735046,
0.15274307131767273,
-0.20665669441223145,
-0.16317464411258698,
-0.2613883912563324,
-0.31937354803085327,
0.6905044317245483,
-0.6983316540718079,
0.5727220177650452,
-0.17026716470718384,
0.4824669659137726,
0.12822668254375458,
0.3092378079891205,
0.5082769393920898,
-0.019217059016227722,
-0.36376142501831055,
-0.0953868106007576,
0.25645339488983154,
-0.4474610984325409,
-0.5986440777778625,
0.5283836126327515,
-0.3756271302700043,
-0.7973277568817139,
-0.4482945203781128,
-0.6360024809837341,
-0.06129530444741249,
0.23251944780349731,
0.04186481609940529,
0.28056666254997253,
-0.26068469882011414,
0.13775981962680817,
0.27535000443458557,
-0.05577661469578743,
0.28850463032722473,
0.33901476860046387,
0.26551347970962524,
-0.17041434347629547,
1.0190125703811646,
0.017383964732289314,
-0.010290023870766163,
0.33034953474998474,
0.2730414569377899,
-0.25611746311187744,
-0.4649334251880646,
-0.5106959342956543,
0.11486918479204178,
-0.3902183175086975,
-0.6327416896820068,
-0.3049521744251251,
0.02113933674991131,
-0.12102369219064713,
-0.11785959452390671,
-0.39886534214019775,
-0.5012259483337402,
-0.23495939373970032,
-0.004320667125284672,
0.22061030566692352,
0.3644544184207916,
-0.3006923794746399,
0.16826671361923218,
-0.5564452409744263,
0.15573012828826904,
0.26960358023643494,
0.14867836236953735,
-0.29435208439826965,
0.040232498198747635,
-0.19070953130722046,
-0.229070246219635,
-0.3428940176963806,
-0.8213785290718079,
0.7132859230041504,
0.23090499639511108,
0.43267208337783813,
0.5010964870452881,
0.21523475646972656,
0.49648037552833557,
-0.3069743812084198,
0.5173214077949524,
-0.10744620114564896,
-0.7770952582359314,
0.6887666583061218,
-0.06904212385416031,
0.1394004225730896,
0.9632797241210938,
0.5368764400482178,
-0.22219964861869812,
-0.07142263650894165,
-0.4326649010181427,
-0.6474284529685974,
0.9049612283706665,
0.28235286474227905,
-0.030543705448508263,
0.1421264111995697,
0.34848111867904663,
0.10371889919042587,
0.6076467633247375,
0.0652812272310257,
0.031288087368011475,
-0.16718177497386932,
-0.20251192152500153,
0.2926298975944519,
0.24596068263053894,
-0.25794509053230286,
-0.2938300371170044,
0.44473057985305786,
-0.18769314885139465,
0.02980159781873226,
0.002110546687617898,
0.019654760137200356,
0.24188365042209625,
-0.06785191595554352,
0.09088647365570068,
0.8726969957351685,
-0.24461275339126587,
0.15288227796554565,
-0.052348848432302475,
-0.4027724862098694,
-0.06306815892457962,
0.5532643795013428,
-0.3041052520275116,
0.06138591095805168,
0.1357811987400055,
0.8152881860733032,
-0.19732575118541718,
-0.994848370552063,
0.2547135651111603,
0.21962592005729675,
0.004570928402245045,
0.00973313208669424,
0.09337663650512695,
-0.08490283042192459,
0.48869502544403076,
0.2153896987438202,
0.07368502765893936,
0.51926189661026,
-0.3668559193611145,
-0.06455009430646896,
0.5336334109306335,
0.18708428740501404,
-0.2680530250072479,
0.7747566103935242,
0.02463844045996666,
-0.4546077251434326,
1.1099671125411987,
-0.26070186495780945,
-0.4336782693862915,
0.7575309872627258,
0.1379585862159729,
0.7660906314849854,
-0.4278310239315033,
0.3459988832473755,
0.0706755742430687,
0.3567635416984558,
-0.09945829212665558,
0.21618236601352692,
-0.4979337751865387,
-0.33832383155822754,
-0.3008597791194916,
-0.7788588404655457,
-0.6828956604003906,
-0.17986507713794708,
-0.50370854139328,
0.11028187721967697,
-0.556057870388031,
0.02934092842042446,
0.230979323387146,
0.07030532509088516,
-0.643944263458252,
0.07970219105482101,
-0.17228077352046967,
0.8011530041694641,
-0.4201809763908386,
0.3422166109085083,
0.4464173913002014,
-0.6513046622276306,
-0.3594881594181061,
-0.26492127776145935,
0.02004276029765606,
-1.0841659307479858,
0.610818088054657,
-0.04074827954173088,
0.02107987180352211,
-0.01594039425253868,
-0.4729192852973938,
-0.7857875227928162,
1.1160833835601807,
0.613592803478241,
-0.37993770837783813,
-0.287692129611969,
0.22708620131015778,
0.6834477186203003,
-0.14300036430358887,
0.054759521037340164,
0.9811457991600037,
0.6021192669868469,
0.11861585825681686,
-0.6702209115028381,
0.12860891222953796,
-0.010085835121572018,
-0.19222965836524963,
0.44114556908607483,
-0.5344796180725098,
0.7487668991088867,
-0.10857303440570831,
-0.26480960845947266,
-0.03724108636379242,
0.3092306852340698,
0.07767951488494873,
0.49440041184425354,
0.33772629499435425,
0.7114903330802917,
1.0408920049667358,
0.06571123749017715,
0.9622442126274109,
-0.526531457901001,
0.08458001166582108,
0.8280404806137085,
-0.246709406375885,
0.6083247065544128,
0.2455834597349167,
-0.5341404676437378,
0.2790592312812805,
0.6302762627601624,
-0.37487250566482544,
0.523213803768158,
0.4032542407512665,
-0.41885054111480713,
-0.17561575770378113,
-0.10025013983249664,
-0.024722304195165634,
0.6273525357246399,
0.36080819368362427,
-0.09729382395744324,
-0.41201287508010864,
-0.12313035130500793,
-0.017837975174188614,
-0.12056787312030792,
-0.04617103934288025,
0.8569932579994202,
-0.13755197823047638,
-0.7293313145637512,
0.3331005871295929,
-0.08729780465364456,
0.22325436770915985,
-0.412566602230072,
0.1279085874557495,
-0.5525326728820801,
0.03451824560761452,
-0.17860744893550873,
-0.5924323797225952,
0.5978122353553772,
-0.0028222447726875544,
0.0851115956902504,
-0.10960632562637329,
0.4984836280345917,
-0.07307535409927368,
-0.6142057776451111,
-0.15417486429214478,
0.5602731704711914,
0.41674673557281494,
-0.43495723605155945,
-0.7201099991798401,
0.08656194806098938,
-0.1568685621023178,
-0.21159611642360687,
0.10539716482162476,
0.2376307100057602,
-0.1469462662935257,
0.6668718457221985,
0.7234036326408386,
0.331447571516037,
-0.1394573152065277,
-0.14025427401065826,
1.0323582887649536,
-0.40165621042251587,
-0.5863605737686157,
-0.8346248865127563,
0.1386478990316391,
-0.27432766556739807,
0.02027401700615883,
0.3535509407520294,
0.8208412528038025,
0.30898573994636536,
0.43370938301086426,
0.6413116455078125,
-0.06026172265410423,
0.15133881568908691,
-0.3044819235801697,
0.5087464451789856,
-0.5684080123901367,
0.32235923409461975,
0.3601781725883484,
-0.994274377822876,
-0.30859407782554626,
0.2820516526699066,
-0.4647531807422638,
-0.2943245768547058,
0.4173066318035126,
0.9210041761398315,
-0.02296893671154976,
0.27249762415885925,
0.14180834591388702,
-0.017696795985102654,
0.5008945465087891,
0.2755085527896881,
0.5435002446174622,
0.06263463944196701,
0.7029199600219727,
-0.21844998002052307,
-0.5032580494880676,
-0.17903314530849457,
-0.28263717889785767,
-0.4147414267063141,
-0.6294280886650085,
-0.18346567451953888,
-0.014494587667286396,
0.41708841919898987,
0.6520981192588806,
0.7405428290367126,
-0.5470756888389587,
-0.19125893712043762,
-0.3365517556667328,
-0.08558926731348038,
-0.1372668445110321,
-0.20397567749023438,
0.7970049977302551,
-0.8070368766784668,
-0.7442524433135986,
0.6254242658615112,
0.5597952604293823,
-0.5609574913978577,
-0.32024437189102173,
0.1451243758201599,
0.11367204785346985,
0.26496800780296326,
0.44738271832466125,
0.4442514181137085,
-0.2075774222612381,
0.20410282909870148,
0.1454544961452484,
-0.023520417511463165,
0.16105671226978302,
0.801789402961731,
-0.6353049278259277,
0.5382642149925232,
0.6196361780166626,
1.059322476387024,
0.8947543501853943,
0.3288278877735138,
0.426777184009552,
-0.3561042845249176,
-0.08181791007518768,
0.5937068462371826,
0.1283111423254013,
0.2077411413192749,
-0.6006723642349243,
0.7260439395904541,
0.28462502360343933,
-0.6712071299552917,
-0.7384617924690247,
-0.060183264315128326,
-0.6494678258895874,
-0.38496366143226624,
0.6340614557266235,
0.25739333033561707,
-0.18210512399673462,
0.06944301724433899,
-0.16149325668811798,
0.018835950642824173,
-0.5115271806716919,
0.8562222719192505,
0.3630606234073639,
-0.8221103549003601,
0.15215322375297546,
-0.5478957891464233,
0.5181984901428223,
0.6587263941764832,
-1.0042444467544556,
0.12036895751953125,
0.8153486251831055,
-0.15897734463214874,
0.2717445194721222,
0.5339351892471313,
-0.08082996308803558,
0.14309318363666534,
0.24363094568252563,
-0.14928573369979858,
-0.23237860202789307,
-0.2525741457939148,
-0.09440469741821289,
0.48711955547332764,
-0.18345429003238678,
-0.7244911789894104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14660v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14660v1
|
Implicit In-context Learning
| 2024-05-23T14:57:52 | 2024-05-23T14:57:52 |
Zhuowei Li, Zihao Xu, Ligong Han, Yunhe Gao, Song Wen, Di Liu, Hao Wang, Dimitris N. Metaxas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In-context Learning (ICL) empowers large language models (LLMs) to adapt to
unseen tasks during inference by prefixing a few demonstration examples prior
to test queries. Despite its versatility, ICL incurs substantial computational
and memory overheads compared to zero-shot learning and is susceptible to the
selection and order of demonstration examples. In this work, we introduce
Implicit In-context Learning (I2CL), an innovative paradigm that addresses the
challenges associated with traditional ICL by absorbing demonstration examples
within the activation space. I2CL first generates a condensed vector
representation, namely a context vector, from the demonstration examples. It
then integrates the context vector during inference by injecting a linear
combination of the context vector and query activations into the model's
residual streams. Empirical evaluation on nine real-world tasks across three
model architectures demonstrates that I2CL achieves few-shot performance with
zero-shot cost and exhibits robustness against the variation of demonstration
examples. Furthermore, I2CL facilitates a novel representation of "task-ids",
enhancing task similarity detection and enabling effective transfer learning.
We provide a comprehensive analysis of I2CL, offering deeper insights into its
mechanisms and broader implications for ICL. The source code is available at:
https://github.com/LzVv123456/I2CL.
|
[
-0.09561023861169815,
-0.6173427104949951,
0.6220311522483826,
0.31497615575790405,
-0.15398848056793213,
0.06871763616800308,
-0.16338832676410675,
-0.5543212294578552,
-0.8425681591033936,
0.12210565060377121,
-0.5668280124664307,
-0.5341158509254456,
-0.4608318507671356,
-0.15035602450370789,
-0.5526769161224365,
1.0228188037872314,
-0.0753803700208664,
0.15781456232070923,
-0.5805511474609375,
-0.17280763387680054,
-0.3004508316516876,
-0.30236586928367615,
-0.7081777453422546,
-0.4316744804382324,
0.16529454290866852,
0.8223668336868286,
-0.18534226715564728,
0.44081640243530273,
-0.062479086220264435,
0.04914199188351631,
0.17771373689174652,
0.15557891130447388,
-0.7344439029693604,
0.11497785151004791,
-0.2623175382614136,
-0.42502373456954956,
0.1738927811384201,
-0.04455815255641937,
0.6641140580177307,
0.7193356156349182,
0.32168468832969666,
0.26135140657424927,
0.5274791717529297,
0.411044716835022,
-0.8841779232025146,
0.36603978276252747,
-0.8708450794219971,
-0.16961272060871124,
-0.015429960563778877,
-0.013975802809000015,
-0.5907912850379944,
0.08529482036828995,
0.3515922725200653,
-0.48446983098983765,
-0.03143860399723053,
-0.00024596022558398545,
0.4227507412433624,
0.3381599187850952,
-0.5572105646133423,
-0.49043506383895874,
-0.7349216938018799,
0.5934760570526123,
-0.4238172471523285,
0.263911634683609,
0.16184955835342407,
0.2399994283914566,
-0.09246930480003357,
-0.8505669832229614,
-0.5563929080963135,
-0.2779116928577423,
-0.2720996141433716,
-0.003232075134292245,
-0.18605148792266846,
-0.11817333102226257,
0.32014381885528564,
-0.29081401228904724,
-0.5068743228912354,
0.2250988781452179,
-0.38634032011032104,
0.19056032598018646,
0.16856977343559265,
-0.024288568645715714,
0.21220964193344116,
0.21584725379943848,
-0.8351481556892395,
0.08359022438526154,
-1.1563360691070557,
0.3231711983680725,
-0.13567060232162476,
0.33327600359916687,
-0.274076908826828,
0.1246374174952507,
-0.23639127612113953,
0.3758186101913452,
0.1828928291797638,
-0.06558366864919662,
-0.03118027001619339,
-0.04622405022382736,
-0.09460286051034927,
0.47090741991996765,
0.2891453802585602,
-0.04289013519883156,
-0.11728957295417786,
-0.1796966791152954,
0.015768952667713165,
-0.12438992410898209,
0.02959960699081421,
-0.9627858400344849,
0.05241488665342331,
0.1435602754354477,
0.005165968555957079,
0.07958288490772247,
0.007582643069326878,
-0.21695832908153534,
-0.18432001769542694,
-0.41072702407836914,
0.5411548018455505,
-0.5631502866744995,
-0.08293212205171585,
-0.12770333886146545,
0.035905830562114716,
0.4045759439468384,
0.3755824863910675,
-0.6592324376106262,
0.5690082907676697,
0.9606391191482544,
0.6790372133255005,
-0.4563104808330536,
-0.21524029970169067,
-0.8226189017295837,
0.4653021991252899,
-0.21036680042743683,
0.753981351852417,
-0.38979578018188477,
-0.3499072790145874,
0.14488178491592407,
-0.11954033374786377,
0.045034363865852356,
-0.5553860068321228,
0.21495525538921356,
-0.46971288323402405,
0.03832414746284485,
-0.11578822135925293,
-0.6293743252754211,
-0.34279999136924744,
0.32028505206108093,
-0.1799485683441162,
1.2838867902755737,
0.08226758986711502,
-0.40962085127830505,
0.42176884412765503,
-0.7101936340332031,
-0.451418936252594,
0.27998894453048706,
-0.37905704975128174,
-0.20213788747787476,
0.1267649531364441,
-0.20202554762363434,
0.5412790775299072,
-0.24207332730293274,
0.06537967920303345,
-0.28605735301971436,
-0.815161943435669,
0.0027067570481449366,
-0.1270642876625061,
0.7112907767295837,
0.006591386161744595,
-0.8521170616149902,
0.14992719888687134,
-0.5566883683204651,
-0.03191959112882614,
-0.12183508276939392,
-0.1828482449054718,
-0.5038273334503174,
-0.09761752188205719,
-0.08494412899017334,
0.4670330584049225,
-0.046320971101522446,
-0.4272063970565796,
0.20212937891483307,
-0.48503583669662476,
0.2643367350101471,
0.6735454797744751,
-0.1898108273744583,
0.7668221592903137,
0.11145099252462387,
0.18843555450439453,
0.18843790888786316,
0.013393286615610123,
-0.21926680207252502,
-0.16490238904953003,
-0.74464350938797,
-0.3994962275028229,
0.09474945068359375,
0.47673341631889343,
-0.7694621682167053,
-0.11973831057548523,
-0.36749064922332764,
-0.1511271595954895,
-0.19066521525382996,
0.23621398210525513,
0.7850397825241089,
0.8880285024642944,
0.32880595326423645,
0.14755213260650635,
-0.2068195343017578,
-0.8624579906463623,
-0.2138320803642273,
-0.2745424807071686,
0.068755604326725,
0.4516565501689911,
0.6547768712043762,
-0.08568920195102692,
0.8839972615242004,
-0.1365577131509781,
-0.3451515734195709,
-0.33841946721076965,
0.26801180839538574,
-0.09277614951133728,
0.6403403282165527,
0.48287445306777954,
-0.6949586868286133,
-0.8604992628097534,
-0.059939973056316376,
-0.7526640892028809,
-0.12248720228672028,
-0.07422696053981781,
-0.10930773615837097,
0.2705874443054199,
0.9716163277626038,
-0.17200936377048492,
0.41708847880363464,
0.4042445123195648,
-0.32995593547821045,
0.19451294839382172,
-0.31098243594169617,
-0.2872668504714966,
-0.72369384765625,
0.017808228731155396,
-0.08696642518043518,
-0.28970569372177124,
-0.5623454451560974,
0.03143690153956413,
0.5008261203765869,
0.12343963235616684,
-0.9605674743652344,
1.022996425628662,
-0.5118752121925354,
-0.2788577675819397,
-0.3613561689853668,
0.010698395781219006,
-0.1279325932264328,
0.6389282941818237,
-0.17155541479587555,
1.0251878499984741,
0.5552613139152527,
-0.7128097414970398,
-0.34152132272720337,
0.12705571949481964,
-0.4029240906238556,
0.4389837384223938,
-0.3330552577972412,
0.2986922562122345,
-0.43660208582878113,
0.43906456232070923,
-1.3031177520751953,
-0.04393358528614044,
0.40712544322013855,
-0.05357949808239937,
0.5059230923652649,
-0.28419020771980286,
-0.4887480139732361,
0.24314819276332855,
-0.12392857670783997,
0.7123211026191711,
0.683849573135376,
-0.9305304288864136,
0.4415794610977173,
-0.0045767892152071,
0.12247838079929352,
-0.6263633370399475,
-0.5830540657043457,
-0.04969969391822815,
-0.20738720893859863,
-0.14019709825515747,
0.6572085618972778,
-0.21095328032970428,
-0.32287314534187317,
0.21221138536930084,
-0.10760042071342468,
-0.08931014686822891,
0.2796894907951355,
0.5561647415161133,
0.05111012980341911,
-0.11129263043403625,
0.3669189214706421,
0.4394921064376831,
-0.18492010235786438,
-0.1564093977212906,
-0.5807791948318481,
0.24329911172389984,
-0.20668405294418335,
-0.5365727543830872,
-0.4359756410121918,
0.5232799649238586,
0.47242647409439087,
-0.006094915792346001,
0.4940054714679718,
0.37718549370765686,
-0.36613932251930237,
-0.6853736042976379,
-0.3008827865123749,
-0.276923805475235,
-0.41522273421287537,
0.3488606810569763,
-0.4695378839969635,
-0.9550073146820068,
0.05503465607762337,
-0.6596972346305847,
0.004619786981493235,
0.12633511424064636,
0.3921170234680176,
-0.30578890442848206,
0.9715069532394409,
0.6796857714653015,
0.21895506978034973,
0.52921462059021,
-0.4138035476207733,
0.08519119769334793,
-1.0123629570007324,
-0.36262914538383484,
-0.22730323672294617,
-0.27750957012176514,
0.021725445985794067,
-0.592759370803833,
0.676672101020813,
0.33306586742401123,
-0.47998297214508057,
-0.043858837336301804,
-0.11286082863807678,
0.6110365986824036,
0.507595956325531,
0.2273985594511032,
0.21435017883777618,
0.07308761775493622,
-0.17663106322288513,
0.07224678248167038,
-0.6152980327606201,
-0.4404776692390442,
0.8952057957649231,
0.04988214001059532,
0.36621564626693726,
0.13931971788406372,
0.405959814786911,
0.41257208585739136,
0.5627962946891785,
-0.7223225831985474,
0.5423066020011902,
-0.16741162538528442,
-0.4850205183029175,
-0.034255802631378174,
0.21732282638549805,
-0.6854375004768372,
0.3273433446884155,
-0.13665257394313812,
-0.69168621301651,
0.09007136523723602,
0.21579159796237946,
-0.2911345958709717,
0.012899196706712246,
-0.5201935768127441,
0.7084556221961975,
-0.4384770691394806,
-0.9430111646652222,
-0.3361824154853821,
-0.7120400071144104,
0.4395016133785248,
0.1677112728357315,
0.0888424962759018,
-0.18122176826000214,
-0.28595924377441406,
0.11604280024766922,
-0.017759643495082855,
1.0256447792053223,
-0.25233301520347595,
0.0810294896364212,
0.18385615944862366,
0.21360643208026886,
0.6797481775283813,
0.17784544825553894,
-0.11683215200901031,
0.025041386485099792,
-0.3320055902004242,
-0.377401202917099,
-0.6630373001098633,
0.913655161857605,
-0.43909701704978943,
-0.4797777533531189,
-0.356914758682251,
-0.562417209148407,
-0.3647521734237671,
0.02942519634962082,
0.1183444932103157,
0.615510106086731,
-0.14461903274059296,
0.2359674721956253,
0.8745677471160889,
-0.11288321018218994,
0.5324547290802002,
0.6099905371665955,
0.06653401255607605,
0.15432369709014893,
0.6943948864936829,
-0.030516143888235092,
0.3473900258541107,
0.39179015159606934,
0.03742646053433418,
-0.39846888184547424,
-0.6559796929359436,
-0.5421813130378723,
0.15798278152942657,
-1.0954375267028809,
0.040743518620729446,
-0.7671315670013428,
0.03317948058247566,
-0.06130458787083626,
-0.28548818826675415,
-0.20826104283332825,
-0.12857812643051147,
-0.5310524106025696,
-0.10392308980226517,
0.05124356597661972,
0.6879170536994934,
0.14243559539318085,
0.2559218108654022,
-0.26675379276275635,
0.08408316224813461,
0.41988590359687805,
0.23944884538650513,
0.10514312982559204,
-0.4682825803756714,
-0.12392057478427887,
-0.12792974710464478,
-0.07968470454216003,
-0.49359363317489624,
0.17814791202545166,
0.4374766945838928,
0.5564157962799072,
0.3273247480392456,
0.0800432488322258,
0.7596544027328491,
-0.6126077175140381,
0.7472694516181946,
-0.07861530035734177,
-1.0325459241867065,
0.2697405517101288,
-0.04107891395688057,
0.33562010526657104,
0.6832258701324463,
0.6043066382408142,
-0.2195354849100113,
-0.17245672643184662,
-0.45152077078819275,
-0.9195318222045898,
0.780925989151001,
-0.15263481438159943,
0.19924919307231903,
0.12789739668369293,
0.6401128768920898,
0.342215895652771,
0.028235210105776787,
-0.6996209025382996,
-0.2295055091381073,
0.14608296751976013,
-0.3167407512664795,
0.09688106179237366,
-0.4913954734802246,
-0.08857652544975281,
-0.42031750082969666,
0.7792534828186035,
-0.5852348804473877,
0.12538394331932068,
0.2541375756263733,
-0.6385163068771362,
0.24165137112140656,
0.08890249580144882,
0.7902308106422424,
0.648698091506958,
0.02329096570611,
0.4080348312854767,
0.4516051113605499,
0.13278941810131073,
0.20283283293247223,
-0.14754228293895721,
-0.2713681161403656,
-0.19799256324768066,
0.30422133207321167,
0.9249869585037231,
0.7252723574638367,
-0.9446255564689636,
0.7128722667694092,
-0.0998615249991417,
-0.16187366843223572,
-0.5282744765281677,
0.03316928818821907,
0.01115601696074009,
0.5549929738044739,
0.4949551820755005,
-0.11052387207746506,
0.39591875672340393,
-0.7169077396392822,
0.3707103133201599,
0.5435532927513123,
-0.9241750240325928,
-0.3324531316757202,
0.7110183238983154,
-0.008322326466441154,
-0.042010191828012466,
0.5263564586639404,
-0.32115480303764343,
-0.4125971496105194,
0.45950454473495483,
0.9603337049484253,
0.9157114028930664,
0.2672322392463684,
0.0016856563743203878,
0.3409987688064575,
-0.09052551537752151,
-0.03099287860095501,
0.13018782436847687,
-0.4963771104812622,
-0.3474390506744385,
-0.3134872019290924,
-0.22614353895187378,
-0.2853814363479614,
-0.074099600315094,
-0.29615524411201477,
0.3458804488182068,
-0.49900469183921814,
0.45495209097862244,
-0.4280071258544922,
-0.306483656167984,
-0.6092700362205505,
-0.11171404272317886,
0.5027709603309631,
0.8339072465896606,
-0.7131764888763428,
1.1970032453536987,
0.5507557392120361,
-0.10230211913585663,
-0.48922669887542725,
0.2198953628540039,
0.07670041173696518,
-0.7178049087524414,
1.3008630275726318,
0.3520980477333069,
-0.3479098677635193,
0.24700920283794403,
-0.7807133197784424,
-0.821234941482544,
1.2482346296310425,
0.6238337755203247,
-0.22518260776996613,
0.11176607012748718,
0.09823581576347351,
0.32451334595680237,
-0.688539445400238,
0.26026350259780884,
0.3490403890609741,
0.19904746115207672,
0.2187163531780243,
-0.45433828234672546,
0.23895154893398285,
-0.021929988637566566,
-0.008534335531294346,
-0.16350489854812622,
-0.5196179151535034,
0.8330495357513428,
-0.17955711483955383,
-0.440433144569397,
0.02081518992781639,
0.6646689772605896,
0.4497467279434204,
0.4565192759037018,
0.5599419474601746,
0.1948849856853485,
0.4583033323287964,
-0.09694576263427734,
1.2133831977844238,
-0.21751326322555542,
0.017902083694934845,
1.3626960515975952,
-0.46506521105766296,
0.8748816251754761,
0.5881407260894775,
0.27302438020706177,
0.6838961839675903,
0.3280016779899597,
0.4615704119205475,
0.7482089996337891,
0.19240421056747437,
-0.6650072932243347,
-0.20838060975074768,
-0.4438675045967102,
-0.0736645832657814,
0.4424729645252228,
0.6915434002876282,
-0.16039685904979706,
-0.4923882484436035,
0.2911989390850067,
0.08851955831050873,
0.05461878329515457,
-0.20476111769676208,
0.962515115737915,
0.06164713203907013,
-0.6410045027732849,
0.5235854983329773,
-0.3510007858276367,
0.5580632090568542,
-0.6170473098754883,
-0.562042236328125,
-0.10809721052646637,
0.32682424783706665,
-0.018414385616779327,
-0.45427143573760986,
0.09127936512231827,
-0.1773945391178131,
-0.1782756894826889,
-0.49459531903266907,
0.6408449411392212,
-0.5830318927764893,
-0.16681811213493347,
0.5351284742355347,
0.315136581659317,
-0.016840673983097076,
-0.1246194988489151,
-0.5865124464035034,
0.03137196600437164,
-0.25397706031799316,
0.04089202359318733,
0.6774237155914307,
0.3192981779575348,
-0.3428066372871399,
0.5913394689559937,
0.5413954257965088,
-0.34718507528305054,
0.05985574051737785,
-0.2867031395435333,
0.7615944743156433,
-0.20406848192214966,
-0.4241805374622345,
-0.8769144415855408,
0.7664581537246704,
0.025760091841220856,
-0.21320714056491852,
0.6568558812141418,
0.660852313041687,
1.1084418296813965,
-0.10060933977365494,
0.8910436630249023,
0.10286630690097809,
0.3642365634441376,
-0.4618193209171295,
0.4305066764354706,
-0.7157092690467834,
0.2951233386993408,
0.1108323261141777,
-0.47979408502578735,
-0.35479217767715454,
0.2414190024137497,
-0.2216784805059433,
-0.5142728090286255,
0.6291724443435669,
0.5928884148597717,
-0.33364948630332947,
-0.41947469115257263,
0.2841874361038208,
0.17165058851242065,
0.46916070580482483,
0.5806962251663208,
0.8569357395172119,
-0.4240014851093292,
0.4070349931716919,
-0.331622451543808,
-0.10662176460027695,
-0.3607475757598877,
-1.0531725883483887,
-0.7242108583450317,
-0.7744655013084412,
-0.3517395257949829,
-0.2174270898103714,
0.2216767966747284,
1.2786130905151367,
0.961157500743866,
-0.6581624746322632,
-0.40305137634277344,
-0.18124334514141083,
0.16838349401950836,
-0.34766000509262085,
-0.19248464703559875,
0.4035331904888153,
-0.5425727367401123,
-0.929366409778595,
0.7316760420799255,
0.492194801568985,
0.012294196523725986,
-0.057487744837999344,
-0.12554597854614258,
-0.29300418496131897,
-0.17775225639343262,
0.9452938437461853,
0.4287258982658386,
-0.8069716095924377,
-0.2990988790988922,
-0.2978834807872772,
-0.2564884126186371,
-0.05110364779829979,
0.8441093564033508,
-1.1556991338729858,
0.3976503312587738,
0.38386261463165283,
0.8647061586380005,
0.7925117611885071,
-0.0941571593284607,
0.3930410146713257,
-0.9424612522125244,
0.5886503458023071,
0.1734352558851242,
0.08291886746883392,
0.05511661618947983,
-0.4027332067489624,
0.5005663633346558,
0.11579162627458572,
-0.054511383175849915,
-0.9074215292930603,
0.22835493087768555,
-0.8326718807220459,
-0.6474183797836304,
1.2674119472503662,
-0.18072688579559326,
-0.22829794883728027,
-0.1599421501159668,
-0.229179248213768,
0.1326165795326233,
-0.3407629728317261,
0.5339513421058655,
0.23931413888931274,
-0.3615275025367737,
-0.08669981360435486,
-0.7390613555908203,
0.6694822907447815,
0.3648519814014435,
-0.6660836338996887,
-0.08531468361616135,
0.3424789309501648,
0.37927713990211487,
-0.3114628195762634,
0.432891845703125,
0.04308269917964935,
0.1824183166027069,
-0.40678563714027405,
-0.07131323218345642,
-0.2078281044960022,
-0.4762045443058014,
-0.5085718035697937,
0.3769010603427887,
0.053634896874427795,
-0.03813144937157631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14654v1
|
Efficient Medical Question Answering with Knowledge-Augmented Question Generation
| 2024-05-23T14:53:52 | 2024-05-23T14:53:52 |
Julien Khlaut, Corentin Dancette, Elodie Ferreres, Alaedine Bennani, Paul Hérent, Pierre Manceron
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the expanding field of language model applications, medical knowledge
representation remains a significant challenge due to the specialized nature of
the domain. Large language models, such as GPT-4, obtain reasonable scores on
medical question answering tasks, but smaller models are far behind. In this
work, we introduce a method to improve the proficiency of a small language
model in the medical domain by employing a two-fold approach. We first
fine-tune the model on a corpus of medical textbooks. Then, we use GPT-4 to
generate questions similar to the downstream task, prompted with textbook
knowledge, and use them to fine-tune the model. Additionally, we introduce
ECN-QA, a novel medical question answering dataset containing ``progressive
questions'' composed of related sequential questions. We show the benefits of
our training strategy on this dataset. The study's findings highlight the
potential of small language models in the medical domain when appropriately
fine-tuned. The code and weights are available at
https://github.com/raidium-med/MQG.
|
[
-0.31855371594429016,
-1.008298635482788,
0.8990827798843384,
-0.5716736912727356,
-0.22329911589622498,
-0.025709034875035286,
-0.10692230612039566,
-0.43180474638938904,
0.0718262642621994,
0.5120508670806885,
-0.4978010952472687,
-0.3834337890148163,
-0.424277663230896,
0.20361587405204773,
-0.0038051786832511425,
1.0044851303100586,
0.03425251692533493,
0.5145679116249084,
-0.3735330402851105,
-0.26795223355293274,
-0.41537728905677795,
-0.48194950819015503,
-0.9936938881874084,
-0.31097841262817383,
0.6072064638137817,
0.46080684661865234,
0.5700353384017944,
0.6380941271781921,
0.4554375410079956,
0.15964266657829285,
-0.025247450917959213,
0.29635295271873474,
-0.1942051500082016,
0.15083514153957367,
-0.0905088484287262,
-0.5837175846099854,
-0.4297557771205902,
-0.24988704919815063,
0.5381659269332886,
0.969143271446228,
-0.16199418902397156,
0.10385347902774811,
-0.16602247953414917,
0.6768555045127869,
-0.0999390184879303,
-0.061213310807943344,
-0.38976600766181946,
-0.2621971368789673,
-0.0598180890083313,
-0.17198200523853302,
-0.14770333468914032,
-0.3387010395526886,
0.2289114147424698,
-0.660232663154602,
0.3571436107158661,
0.004966077394783497,
0.7666603326797485,
0.25962910056114197,
-0.501738965511322,
-0.4249158501625061,
-0.6148951053619385,
0.4513498842716217,
-0.7464451789855957,
0.3599781095981598,
0.4377409815788269,
0.30627137422561646,
0.1930251568555832,
-0.9560664892196655,
-0.5684121251106262,
-0.124502032995224,
0.021590430289506912,
0.15588316321372986,
0.11590689420700073,
0.13384824991226196,
0.29972541332244873,
0.41662395000457764,
-0.7460330724716187,
-0.02646362967789173,
-0.4974258244037628,
0.04035286232829094,
0.29412180185317993,
0.2412734031677246,
0.5619920492172241,
-0.04430398344993591,
-0.11228779703378677,
0.1336030811071396,
-0.8718513250350952,
-0.06090959161520004,
0.07840986549854279,
-0.01122103538364172,
0.2642565667629242,
0.6945621371269226,
-0.20463760197162628,
0.9511066675186157,
0.1593211442232132,
-0.0663328617811203,
0.1921878457069397,
-0.482476145029068,
-0.03398056700825691,
-0.3371730446815491,
0.32311946153640747,
0.37471044063568115,
0.05345100536942482,
0.05960315465927124,
-0.11188995838165283,
-0.05621444433927536,
0.3878522217273712,
-0.8247420787811279,
-0.4889303147792816,
0.504420280456543,
-0.29536348581314087,
-0.21460621058940887,
-0.31405341625213623,
-0.5817694067955017,
-0.2956904172897339,
-0.2984769940376282,
0.5055153965950012,
-0.5771669149398804,
-0.1854434758424759,
0.21377910673618317,
0.04234444350004196,
0.2079148292541504,
0.3828217387199402,
-0.8823431730270386,
0.31527289748191833,
0.5699297785758972,
0.4801414906978607,
0.17498132586479187,
0.18820682168006897,
-0.5520457029342651,
0.05878674238920212,
-0.3575277030467987,
0.8567810654640198,
-0.5383742451667786,
-0.2867720425128937,
-0.022105654701590538,
-0.032032910734415054,
-0.10844322293996811,
-0.7590712904930115,
0.32272621989250183,
-0.7623956799507141,
0.391112357378006,
-0.29577356576919556,
-0.904812753200531,
-0.10821615159511566,
0.5293737649917603,
-0.46400028467178345,
0.7867917418479919,
0.2689726948738098,
-0.7284220457077026,
0.08512663096189499,
-0.5809497833251953,
-0.3329640030860901,
0.17872311174869537,
-0.31478771567344666,
-0.394488126039505,
0.030959295108914375,
0.5452799797058105,
0.19534730911254883,
-0.23094742000102997,
0.013430535793304443,
-0.002367687178775668,
0.11354558169841766,
0.16271346807479858,
-0.15511159598827362,
0.32971346378326416,
0.05961144343018532,
0.1158519983291626,
-0.156581312417984,
-0.6846978664398193,
0.26967287063598633,
0.06394805014133453,
-0.365112841129303,
-0.5306690335273743,
-0.20826415717601776,
-0.47344353795051575,
0.15012137591838837,
0.3671259880065918,
-0.5847947001457214,
0.42500802874565125,
-0.7227134108543396,
0.3221191167831421,
0.21739564836025238,
0.5921790599822998,
0.4630069136619568,
-0.5767420530319214,
0.75474613904953,
0.027696508914232254,
0.21082884073257446,
-0.08498682081699371,
-0.8596109747886658,
-0.5608845949172974,
-0.07701003551483154,
0.6145777106285095,
0.551205039024353,
-1.3586353063583374,
-0.14128407835960388,
-0.16943593323230743,
-0.4252401888370514,
-0.7239462733268738,
0.07252746820449829,
0.2722000181674957,
0.9086486101150513,
0.5974140167236328,
-0.1208127811551094,
-0.2396104335784912,
-0.690617561340332,
-0.3035712242126465,
-0.3118548095226288,
-0.23769664764404297,
0.5944063663482666,
0.3824225962162018,
-0.2342812865972519,
0.6052103042602539,
-0.7980559468269348,
-0.05298493057489395,
-0.1902167946100235,
0.20199429988861084,
0.05915255472064018,
0.447927862405777,
0.3468910753726959,
-0.9017998576164246,
-0.505752444267273,
0.026928013190627098,
-0.525485634803772,
-0.08643030375242233,
-0.005901317577809095,
-0.11432819813489914,
-0.06435076892375946,
0.5082647204399109,
-0.5003209114074707,
-0.030143361538648605,
0.5236297845840454,
-0.3451599180698395,
0.4824945628643036,
-0.4457497298717499,
0.33075255155563354,
-1.1843239068984985,
0.09730547666549683,
-0.2917149066925049,
-0.378238707780838,
-1.0016343593597412,
0.22339382767677307,
0.3273824155330658,
-0.18680113554000854,
-0.4247027635574341,
0.660601019859314,
-0.33006542921066284,
0.4475393295288086,
-0.3553897440433502,
0.14926905930042267,
0.13526879251003265,
0.38600581884384155,
-0.018243657425045967,
0.6367669701576233,
0.31546515226364136,
-0.5326499342918396,
0.1626824587583542,
0.38241997361183167,
-0.09864410012960434,
0.49998289346694946,
-0.7201017141342163,
0.41396480798721313,
-0.1811068058013916,
-0.1729428768157959,
-0.7877241373062134,
-0.4391595125198364,
0.04191311076283455,
-0.5061389803886414,
0.5933116674423218,
-0.2991638779640198,
-0.4880927503108978,
-0.5407587885856628,
-0.12716388702392578,
0.6856439709663391,
0.7149330377578735,
-0.31380072236061096,
0.43999576568603516,
0.3600890338420868,
-0.6247410178184509,
-0.2925504446029663,
-0.4576551020145416,
-0.30279016494750977,
0.07680640369653702,
-0.6520065665245056,
0.22906871140003204,
-0.13751955330371857,
-0.0035216889809817076,
-0.021130068227648735,
-0.10621852427721024,
-0.2651613652706146,
-0.19714437425136566,
-0.2250901609659195,
0.11641909182071686,
-0.31352874636650085,
0.5375750064849854,
0.4609850347042084,
0.05865940824151039,
-0.056576333940029144,
-0.48093119263648987,
0.44923877716064453,
0.0129149304702878,
-0.26002031564712524,
-0.06944269686937332,
0.46533629298210144,
0.38314157724380493,
-0.28446221351623535,
0.5482923984527588,
0.2108800709247589,
-0.615315318107605,
0.05799908563494682,
-0.46029746532440186,
-0.5635213255882263,
-0.40131253004074097,
0.46691858768463135,
-0.35161304473876953,
-1.0052999258041382,
0.4223691523075104,
-0.14830483496189117,
0.04734969139099121,
0.5404266715049744,
0.942257821559906,
-0.2487742155790329,
1.1708639860153198,
0.5332474708557129,
0.4379483461380005,
0.15972210466861725,
-0.09215400367975235,
-0.12448105216026306,
-0.8086035847663879,
-0.08821388334035873,
-0.27609583735466003,
-0.000017079439203371294,
-0.3065374195575714,
-0.5625222325325012,
0.8235993385314941,
0.12041784077882767,
-0.12793773412704468,
-0.04026143252849579,
-0.46678081154823303,
0.30757418274879456,
0.49050235748291016,
0.5278816819190979,
0.438001811504364,
-0.2549646496772766,
-0.20046977698802948,
0.1613335758447647,
-0.9869886636734009,
-0.4243842363357544,
1.3313432931900024,
0.3757404088973999,
0.5542661547660828,
0.03713047131896019,
0.6767418384552002,
-0.13786627352237701,
0.4889049232006073,
-0.5871583819389343,
0.21282021701335907,
-0.17879074811935425,
-0.7754746079444885,
-0.4306381046772003,
-0.5830599069595337,
-0.9418880343437195,
0.02432275004684925,
-0.1221599131822586,
-0.22909018397331238,
0.07748990505933762,
0.3822483420372009,
-0.8895432949066162,
0.11819368600845337,
-0.7569848895072937,
0.8653901219367981,
-0.12245859950780869,
-0.10153147578239441,
0.06475615501403809,
-0.7034425139427185,
0.2647037208080292,
-0.24378187954425812,
0.2039288729429245,
0.11853091418743134,
-0.2462807297706604,
0.7325296998023987,
-0.6898508667945862,
0.6225916147232056,
-0.3296375572681427,
-0.11803264170885086,
0.4957934021949768,
-0.11318986862897873,
0.4569030702114105,
0.39127981662750244,
0.12358095496892929,
-0.17772597074508667,
0.3732045590877533,
-0.5676575899124146,
-0.7598863840103149,
0.44037601351737976,
-0.619500458240509,
-0.6070874333381653,
-0.17392513155937195,
-0.5952849388122559,
-0.6260390281677246,
0.2410089522600174,
0.29364633560180664,
0.6405202746391296,
-0.06302428990602493,
-0.1361054629087448,
0.7892637252807617,
-0.38708600401878357,
-0.11670824140310287,
0.5119474530220032,
-0.16919809579849243,
-0.46190714836120605,
0.5498244762420654,
0.271369069814682,
0.516020655632019,
0.43221744894981384,
0.20787999033927917,
-0.4869060814380646,
-0.5450494289398193,
-0.7763911485671997,
0.4757959246635437,
-0.6557245254516602,
-0.30408552289009094,
-0.7913706302642822,
-0.21803788840770721,
-0.36099210381507874,
0.20502974092960358,
-0.19153693318367004,
-0.5118890404701233,
-0.21960148215293884,
0.06294676661491394,
0.47507768869400024,
0.6666263341903687,
0.2717030346393585,
0.08269114047288895,
-0.9618305563926697,
0.5358680486679077,
0.713655948638916,
0.31658244132995605,
-0.3667190968990326,
-0.6271912455558777,
-0.3384556770324707,
0.17957888543605804,
-0.1733410656452179,
-0.9510409235954285,
0.1870575100183487,
0.23917415738105774,
0.28393468260765076,
0.08245454728603363,
0.041009869426488876,
0.31605803966522217,
-0.9455254673957825,
0.7704573273658752,
0.1008206233382225,
-0.36335471272468567,
0.6222401261329651,
-0.45826372504234314,
0.3842748701572418,
0.6429451107978821,
0.4027249217033386,
-0.36639246344566345,
-0.584819495677948,
-0.7525102496147156,
-0.6891192197799683,
0.1582092046737671,
0.15128177404403687,
0.16550546884536743,
-0.14958272874355316,
0.6943174004554749,
0.14363117516040802,
0.2521262466907501,
-0.27547091245651245,
-0.1400751769542694,
-0.03308923542499542,
-0.5183650851249695,
0.08392488956451416,
-0.2842796742916107,
-0.3047902286052704,
-0.34359869360923767,
0.6388179659843445,
-0.38142937421798706,
0.29456502199172974,
0.39365965127944946,
-0.060860637575387955,
-0.010966718196868896,
0.31150543689727783,
0.5843365788459778,
0.5987645387649536,
-0.01077183149755001,
0.0641956552863121,
0.2844700217247009,
-0.7780476808547974,
0.14990156888961792,
0.22321061789989471,
-0.3049132227897644,
-0.04204470291733742,
0.018198352307081223,
0.30337512493133545,
-0.12592363357543945,
-0.6740939021110535,
0.557377815246582,
-0.13886293768882751,
-0.29228320717811584,
-0.08077201247215271,
-0.020005930215120316,
0.24454046785831451,
0.20276068150997162,
0.16191250085830688,
0.035884395241737366,
0.1632964164018631,
-0.35376420617103577,
0.4276603162288666,
0.16982519626617432,
-0.24057766795158386,
-0.17869038879871368,
0.8165324926376343,
0.19057528674602509,
-0.091091088950634,
0.5219418406486511,
-0.10552983731031418,
-0.41927483677864075,
0.5655898451805115,
0.41903021931648254,
0.33353281021118164,
-0.2146274745464325,
0.1478542536497116,
0.40786537528038025,
0.2104462832212448,
-0.17882344126701355,
0.770419716835022,
0.2960001528263092,
-0.687075138092041,
-0.5768974423408508,
-0.42810770869255066,
-0.6282712817192078,
0.06046081334352493,
-0.5323843955993652,
0.13328930735588074,
-0.30074602365493774,
-0.25729548931121826,
0.01345911342650652,
-0.001156048383563757,
-0.7502214908599854,
0.4568937420845032,
-0.036760322749614716,
0.7953782081604004,
-0.4358995854854584,
1.0221977233886719,
1.0065982341766357,
-0.5465561747550964,
-0.9108349680900574,
0.06192178279161453,
-0.47016170620918274,
-0.6998888254165649,
0.1955854296684265,
-0.1422034651041031,
0.3682542145252228,
0.34100255370140076,
-0.39870649576187134,
-0.5577629208564758,
0.9751574397087097,
0.15936610102653503,
-0.5842186808586121,
-0.17390227317810059,
0.11079426854848862,
0.7693065404891968,
-0.292864590883255,
0.047076430171728134,
0.5320878028869629,
0.19467930495738983,
-0.21835902333259583,
-0.7559624314308167,
0.06915577501058578,
-0.2629419267177582,
-0.19196248054504395,
0.17719285190105438,
-0.3000994026660919,
0.815584123134613,
-0.4805409908294678,
-0.003172355704009533,
0.4165417551994324,
0.4167279899120331,
0.36269134283065796,
0.3468680679798126,
0.44241392612457275,
0.48529672622680664,
1.0508662462234497,
-0.15986785292625427,
1.278748631477356,
-0.5724051594734192,
0.42370983958244324,
0.856704831123352,
-0.008395715616643429,
0.7846495509147644,
0.44954511523246765,
-0.0030985400080680847,
0.4616676867008209,
0.652265191078186,
0.20308087766170502,
0.49635833501815796,
0.06759941577911377,
-0.4401320219039917,
-0.3096272945404053,
0.22103062272071838,
-0.4554443061351776,
0.012586821801960468,
0.38778620958328247,
-0.3785276412963867,
-0.008113237097859383,
0.33303022384643555,
-0.09804999083280563,
0.051090266555547714,
-0.5427328944206238,
1.0088133811950684,
0.2636357545852661,
-0.6546075344085693,
0.6436924934387207,
-0.07833810150623322,
0.19465455412864685,
-0.450363427400589,
-0.10923561453819275,
-0.2721599042415619,
0.016009895130991936,
0.0849166139960289,
-0.6012945175170898,
0.10072281211614609,
-0.04025426134467125,
-0.33897966146469116,
0.13276544213294983,
0.7502476572990417,
-0.8351568579673767,
-0.6197202205657959,
-0.2963015139102936,
0.9365858435630798,
0.08083110302686691,
-0.11154565960168839,
-0.6034246683120728,
-0.5715793371200562,
-0.16475076973438263,
-0.19879962503910065,
0.17905621230602264,
0.6712124943733215,
0.0016081645153462887,
0.6242104768753052,
0.5741792917251587,
0.2453819364309311,
0.024210764095187187,
0.21269914507865906,
0.9560126662254333,
-0.49811220169067383,
-0.4919252395629883,
-0.5098955631256104,
0.4574529230594635,
0.03736529126763344,
-0.2208215296268463,
0.3651182949542999,
0.41967254877090454,
0.5517359972000122,
-0.3168259263038635,
0.6974876523017883,
0.07375966012477875,
1.0688014030456543,
-0.6403687000274658,
0.8042455911636353,
-0.7104614973068237,
0.2899188697338104,
-0.036030419170856476,
-0.4261617660522461,
-0.4805692732334137,
0.18826180696487427,
-0.41051265597343445,
0.21182763576507568,
0.8265724778175354,
0.8296549916267395,
0.059632256627082825,
-0.04165450483560562,
0.5278722047805786,
0.3094731867313385,
0.17597515881061554,
0.6347319483757019,
0.6558176875114441,
-0.5233928561210632,
0.4787044823169708,
-0.266056627035141,
-0.28998544812202454,
-0.01830831728875637,
-0.31377169489860535,
-0.8307684063911438,
-0.44408151507377625,
-0.40382081270217896,
-0.5132158994674683,
0.17907267808914185,
0.7361772060394287,
0.536302924156189,
-0.7303355932235718,
0.47361546754837036,
-0.05236584693193436,
-0.08180542290210724,
-0.3270505368709564,
-0.13172756135463715,
0.5898873209953308,
-0.4470270872116089,
-0.5964475870132446,
0.21939225494861603,
0.0346694216132164,
0.12023595720529556,
0.02070860005915165,
0.05147618427872658,
-0.03430310636758804,
0.17439348995685577,
0.5446099638938904,
0.32603639364242554,
-0.3019745647907257,
-0.4187995195388794,
0.32967114448547363,
-0.18701624870300293,
0.13049399852752686,
0.9114127159118652,
-0.7456878423690796,
0.5230862498283386,
0.34396249055862427,
0.9205838441848755,
0.39589208364486694,
0.2760296165943146,
0.5979650616645813,
-0.8421944379806519,
-0.3221127986907959,
0.5640669465065002,
0.26362118124961853,
0.419156551361084,
-0.48398226499557495,
0.40658122301101685,
0.2556569576263428,
-0.7362201809883118,
-0.5379170775413513,
0.26035723090171814,
-0.8167614340782166,
-0.3407677412033081,
1.2836428880691528,
-0.05473503842949867,
-0.02405843883752823,
-0.40532952547073364,
-0.38724735379219055,
0.22514581680297852,
0.014947968535125256,
0.6765620112419128,
0.4839032292366028,
-0.37701350450515747,
-0.23242215812206268,
-0.8437116742134094,
0.7301905751228333,
0.5316089987754822,
-0.9444856643676758,
-0.2121923267841339,
0.30706721544265747,
0.5883625745773315,
-0.07959533482789993,
0.9117494225502014,
-0.40296268463134766,
0.5783767104148865,
-0.10844728350639343,
-0.004519741050899029,
0.03413312882184982,
-0.13398593664169312,
-0.2824530601501465,
0.27417895197868347,
0.26572152972221375,
-0.1885836273431778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14646v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14646v1
|
Unveiling the Achilles' Heel of NLG Evaluators: A Unified Adversarial Framework Driven by Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T14:48:15 | 2024-05-23T14:48:15 |
Yiming Chen, Chen Zhang, Danqing Luo, Luis Fernando D'Haro, Robby T. Tan, Haizhou Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The automatic evaluation of natural language generation (NLG) systems
presents a long-lasting challenge. Recent studies have highlighted various
neural metrics that align well with human evaluations. Yet, the robustness of
these evaluators against adversarial perturbations remains largely
under-explored due to the unique challenges in obtaining adversarial data for
different NLG evaluation tasks. To address the problem, we introduce AdvEval, a
novel black-box adversarial framework against NLG evaluators. AdvEval is
specially tailored to generate data that yield strong disagreements between
human and victim evaluators. Specifically, inspired by the recent success of
large language models (LLMs) in text generation and evaluation, we adopt strong
LLMs as both the data generator and gold evaluator. Adversarial data are
automatically optimized with feedback from the gold and victim evaluator. We
conduct experiments on 12 victim evaluators and 11 NLG datasets, spanning tasks
including dialogue, summarization, and question evaluation. The results show
that AdvEval can lead to significant performance degradation of various victim
metrics, thereby validating its efficacy.
|
[
-0.4107152223587036,
-0.9949743747711182,
0.26949286460876465,
-0.1393623799085617,
-0.09654970467090607,
0.13601572811603546,
-0.21757489442825317,
-0.24484065175056458,
-0.27049916982650757,
0.5095357298851013,
-0.3634619414806366,
-0.33504775166511536,
-0.6492282152175903,
0.16584111750125885,
-0.47283604741096497,
1.4298006296157837,
0.22176216542720795,
-0.10938692092895508,
-0.1836114227771759,
-0.36563175916671753,
-0.5177547931671143,
-0.5997068285942078,
-0.9277870059013367,
-0.5340884327888489,
0.322990357875824,
-0.15190556645393372,
1.0322898626327515,
0.3615283668041229,
0.3816325068473816,
0.31541797518730164,
-0.118376225233078,
0.27611425518989563,
-0.5011523365974426,
0.3285902142524719,
-0.018038040027022362,
-0.4251039922237396,
-0.33938807249069214,
0.0374470129609108,
0.29697707295417786,
0.35344234108924866,
-0.20872274041175842,
0.019508397206664085,
0.02264392375946045,
0.6884374618530273,
-0.7735448479652405,
-0.3129221498966217,
-0.991269588470459,
0.12067127227783203,
-0.06006377562880516,
-0.19851627945899963,
-0.3965523838996887,
-0.5563756227493286,
0.15275467932224274,
-0.3649486005306244,
0.472201406955719,
-0.2326633334159851,
0.765807032585144,
0.6099029779434204,
-0.26038670539855957,
-0.5192738175392151,
-0.6913845539093018,
0.5608828067779541,
-0.5765594840049744,
-0.1989838182926178,
0.09643737971782684,
0.33692601323127747,
-0.3697834312915802,
-0.3858630955219269,
-0.4538964629173279,
-0.4161338210105896,
0.05016303434967995,
0.05658593401312828,
-0.7611803412437439,
-0.06753914058208466,
0.021793890744447708,
0.3881851136684418,
-0.8857319355010986,
0.12796922028064728,
-0.280836284160614,
-0.1158350259065628,
0.7359216213226318,
0.25732913613319397,
0.31142109632492065,
-0.29885372519493103,
-0.5574000477790833,
-0.2842939794063568,
-0.6783038377761841,
0.028865033760666847,
0.7384502291679382,
0.297528475522995,
0.47218650579452515,
0.25022801756858826,
0.2927357852458954,
0.8200273513793945,
0.012170747853815556,
0.1460014432668686,
0.03160804510116577,
-0.053499795496463776,
-0.32628437876701355,
0.30240628123283386,
1.2744531631469727,
0.2633206248283386,
0.2572506368160248,
-0.2846914529800415,
-0.36068496108055115,
0.6174908876419067,
1.0234986543655396,
-0.5439977645874023,
-0.3959087133407593,
0.18389752507209778,
0.01569967344403267,
-0.9799848794937134,
-0.0724790021777153,
-0.9196852445602417,
-0.7604926228523254,
0.15538865327835083,
0.5256879925727844,
-0.3367730975151062,
0.021192966029047966,
0.1361543834209442,
-0.007958780974149704,
-0.03961028531193733,
0.1347380429506302,
-0.4531673789024353,
0.40348687767982483,
0.6692032814025879,
0.4077405035495758,
-0.1288948804140091,
-0.23861302435398102,
-0.8733344674110413,
-0.36484581232070923,
-0.5232647657394409,
0.794734537601471,
-0.31358468532562256,
-0.23538519442081451,
0.00543466629460454,
-0.22330811619758606,
0.12085725367069244,
-0.6414494514465332,
0.8783106207847595,
-0.4306734502315521,
0.3007656931877136,
0.1406773328781128,
-0.05570710822939873,
-0.1399947702884674,
0.32917627692222595,
-0.6836090087890625,
1.0084811449050903,
-0.050717778503894806,
-0.8281402587890625,
0.3929869532585144,
-0.6040207743644714,
-0.5624118447303772,
0.23352715373039246,
-0.22707639634609222,
-0.7365387082099915,
0.18294158577919006,
0.3940974771976471,
0.38790184259414673,
-0.7223047018051147,
0.40667226910591125,
-0.30829086899757385,
-0.38743922114372253,
0.2582074999809265,
-0.9342816472053528,
0.9169458150863647,
0.14527931809425354,
-0.4395088255405426,
0.020942168310284615,
-0.9665459394454956,
-0.07026521116495132,
0.4665672183036804,
-0.4018922746181488,
-0.44751060009002686,
-0.17199943959712982,
-0.1800418496131897,
0.012528175488114357,
-0.17687185108661652,
-0.539088249206543,
0.1740095317363739,
-0.6316604018211365,
0.20406724512577057,
0.9247626662254333,
0.004655906930565834,
0.11673904955387115,
-0.1720924973487854,
0.9073343873023987,
-0.4092700481414795,
-0.07523929327726364,
-0.1286739557981491,
-0.22801384329795837,
-0.5339756608009338,
0.09730582684278488,
0.40286919474601746,
0.4597765803337097,
-0.9333854913711548,
0.5063661336898804,
-0.20307189226150513,
-0.6537710428237915,
-0.794887125492096,
0.3008982539176941,
0.7649534344673157,
0.38166266679763794,
0.18024596571922302,
-0.07437563687562943,
-0.41539743542671204,
-0.7555547952651978,
-0.286790132522583,
-0.47249120473861694,
-0.1691194623708725,
0.27589625120162964,
0.4777062237262726,
-0.20287972688674927,
0.7942706942558289,
-0.3342459797859192,
-0.06899812817573547,
-0.23815949261188507,
0.3871275782585144,
-0.1552518904209137,
0.10641269385814667,
0.6412448287010193,
-0.7257474064826965,
0.0033093190286308527,
-0.12642787396907806,
-0.7962218523025513,
-0.21420428156852722,
-0.25660794973373413,
-0.040545910596847534,
0.1583426594734192,
0.06713201105594635,
-0.3539274334907532,
0.3261833190917969,
0.7255228757858276,
-0.569807767868042,
0.8311989307403564,
-0.08947871625423431,
0.0014333565486595035,
-0.7989336252212524,
0.13581326603889465,
0.023385480046272278,
-0.09983420372009277,
-0.5901361107826233,
0.1013278067111969,
-0.11739815771579742,
-0.21961432695388794,
-0.4190079867839813,
0.5441021919250488,
0.004144652746617794,
0.263525128364563,
-0.19071103632450104,
0.4014788269996643,
0.27119889855384827,
0.3335250914096832,
-0.36383867263793945,
0.5869864821434021,
0.3693045973777771,
-0.6965168118476868,
0.9614887237548828,
0.33638420701026917,
-0.22769486904144287,
0.6705633401870728,
-0.9544876217842102,
0.29267069697380066,
-0.06059303507208824,
0.1830436736345291,
-0.9246123433113098,
0.03523597866296768,
0.12879762053489685,
-0.6993072628974915,
0.40085533261299133,
-0.2053980678319931,
-0.3559333384037018,
-0.5307736992835999,
-0.44391930103302,
0.17051410675048828,
0.18664699792861938,
-0.7448958158493042,
0.3063293993473053,
0.3326762616634369,
-0.15651240944862366,
-0.8925259113311768,
-0.821766197681427,
0.5367071628570557,
-0.5073705911636353,
-0.6575608849525452,
-0.03556767851114273,
-0.0034819492138922215,
-0.3373749554157257,
0.028641359880566597,
0.10302359610795975,
0.19822806119918823,
0.38763704895973206,
0.11857198178768158,
0.180056631565094,
-0.17971527576446533,
0.20713700354099274,
-0.36646994948387146,
-0.2591187059879303,
0.3292194604873657,
-0.2284241020679474,
0.28906747698783875,
-0.3823024332523346,
-0.3942796587944031,
0.20730842649936676,
0.055921707302331924,
0.646216630935669,
-0.3702319264411926,
0.5159287452697754,
0.7165393233299255,
-0.2624240517616272,
-0.47212138772010803,
-0.47601091861724854,
0.11823048442602158,
-0.4219883978366852,
0.5280774831771851,
-0.23558148741722107,
-0.5142607092857361,
0.2622748017311096,
0.21267220377922058,
0.16634328663349152,
0.41664162278175354,
0.5331103205680847,
0.43913114070892334,
1.108447790145874,
0.15334682166576385,
-0.1576654613018036,
-0.052746329456567764,
-0.3038528263568878,
0.1359814703464508,
-0.8117615580558777,
0.08705426007509232,
-0.3507221043109894,
-0.23172539472579956,
-0.28110432624816895,
-0.0054391310550272465,
0.3424797058105469,
0.1759166121482849,
-0.06030949950218201,
0.4479496479034424,
-0.694203794002533,
0.2519274353981018,
0.18723855912685394,
-0.1308160424232483,
0.11187924444675446,
-0.013383876532316208,
-0.28623053431510925,
-0.05200255662202835,
-0.8868339657783508,
-0.7542288303375244,
1.1851747035980225,
0.4108670949935913,
0.8212896585464478,
0.10033464431762695,
0.4962829351425171,
0.45611587166786194,
0.3982143998146057,
-0.7923720479011536,
0.404604434967041,
-0.2882789075374603,
-0.3868696689605713,
-0.24316547811031342,
-0.6364088654518127,
-1.1969395875930786,
0.5434969067573547,
-0.21188320219516754,
-0.5747715830802917,
0.03806935250759125,
0.13311995565891266,
-0.6428809762001038,
0.39416441321372986,
-0.5939009785652161,
1.014460563659668,
-0.3781242370605469,
-0.33572855591773987,
0.23493634164333344,
-0.2598307430744171,
0.5000579953193665,
-0.2495054453611374,
0.14738261699676514,
0.16045495867729187,
0.23781181871891022,
0.7597251534461975,
-0.44703149795532227,
0.6021841168403625,
-0.22238567471504211,
-0.29850900173187256,
0.5060633420944214,
0.4673541784286499,
0.6773689389228821,
0.05575874075293541,
-0.21329277753829956,
-0.19368278980255127,
-0.5579427480697632,
-0.23276717960834503,
-0.7458416819572449,
0.7264345288276672,
-0.45173966884613037,
-0.4247080087661743,
-0.4631062150001526,
-0.18032577633857727,
-0.2860792577266693,
-0.2005016952753067,
0.46991828083992004,
0.598602294921875,
-0.6221383810043335,
0.45468592643737793,
0.5305020213127136,
-0.43901050090789795,
0.43797367811203003,
0.3509175479412079,
0.19140644371509552,
-0.6200039386749268,
1.0101597309112549,
-0.3088970184326172,
0.2301200032234192,
-0.2655662000179291,
0.28213199973106384,
-0.241644024848938,
-0.5403969287872314,
-0.7898679375648499,
-0.13524451851844788,
-0.5455261468887329,
-0.44680604338645935,
-0.59831702709198,
-0.22531834244728088,
-0.15688155591487885,
-0.23868893086910248,
-0.6174156069755554,
-0.139384925365448,
-0.020029164850711823,
-0.13944999873638153,
0.24868382513523102,
1.0458858013153076,
0.18519549071788788,
-0.012281997129321098,
-0.6625776886940002,
0.27000996470451355,
0.6184746026992798,
0.07639186829328537,
0.02444806508719921,
-0.5690433979034424,
-0.12400548160076141,
0.039935994893312454,
-0.5008926391601562,
-0.7060564756393433,
0.38706737756729126,
0.024563513696193695,
0.44546249508857727,
0.36554327607154846,
0.3327553868293762,
0.4714156687259674,
-0.38580945134162903,
0.940781831741333,
0.2832386791706085,
-0.6416788697242737,
0.5682867169380188,
-0.2922547161579132,
0.21590754389762878,
0.5283576846122742,
0.01717827469110489,
-0.36925163865089417,
-0.6691927313804626,
-0.950476348400116,
-1.0574532747268677,
0.6226648092269897,
0.46587517857551575,
-0.0806780457496643,
0.019885875284671783,
0.13661815226078033,
0.06250923126935959,
0.22915761172771454,
-0.714850127696991,
-0.2909224033355713,
-0.19054242968559265,
-0.05924588441848755,
-0.23049183189868927,
-0.1311522275209427,
-0.3913196325302124,
0.29115501046180725,
0.486600786447525,
-0.1323825716972351,
-0.12560904026031494,
0.10603872686624527,
-0.11923234909772873,
-0.25050902366638184,
0.4441964328289032,
0.2970755994319916,
0.47749629616737366,
0.05107573792338371,
0.09335628151893616,
0.23131506145000458,
-0.2625603973865509,
0.3852914571762085,
0.32315704226493835,
-0.2692404091358185,
-0.013074507005512714,
0.6502280831336975,
0.9356412291526794,
0.10772477835416794,
-0.7263343930244446,
0.820637583732605,
-0.49511945247650146,
-0.37153303623199463,
-0.2867816388607025,
0.10338795185089111,
-0.28748854994773865,
0.02841254323720932,
0.5000429749488831,
0.2818172872066498,
0.011384828016161919,
-0.2675289809703827,
0.38248464465141296,
0.5666984915733337,
-0.5536947250366211,
-0.20212510228157043,
0.7272642850875854,
0.22794854640960693,
-0.38852250576019287,
0.1359885334968567,
-0.4067680537700653,
-0.7805413007736206,
0.5885667204856873,
0.3454132378101349,
1.1197044849395752,
-0.32787299156188965,
0.3178602457046509,
0.1169898509979248,
0.372036337852478,
0.060138292610645294,
-0.20383967459201813,
0.1840304732322693,
-0.489170640707016,
-0.26863712072372437,
-0.8328232765197754,
-0.17955408990383148,
0.6095849871635437,
-0.7560610175132751,
0.052160777151584625,
-0.3171054720878601,
-0.1242133229970932,
0.08500973135232925,
0.009500074200332165,
-0.6255584955215454,
0.369632363319397,
0.17499852180480957,
0.3067975640296936,
-0.7832068800926208,
0.2835318148136139,
0.8016116619110107,
-0.10043186694383621,
-0.33618611097335815,
0.13963919878005981,
0.21100515127182007,
-0.6035915017127991,
0.4935010075569153,
-0.0954134464263916,
-0.318203866481781,
-0.4577156901359558,
-0.16238653659820557,
-0.3364270329475403,
0.6884081959724426,
0.554438591003418,
-0.21010443568229675,
0.025051355361938477,
-0.14800067245960236,
0.8617327809333801,
-0.2492109090089798,
0.168237566947937,
0.652968168258667,
0.40209007263183594,
-0.0033735528122633696,
-0.7632995843887329,
0.14625152945518494,
-0.5072924494743347,
-0.0757715031504631,
0.23640625178813934,
-0.5319982767105103,
0.5360217094421387,
-0.13684432208538055,
-0.1856076419353485,
-0.12979818880558014,
0.21853449940681458,
0.12711983919143677,
-0.04060665890574455,
0.7068203687667847,
0.6704344153404236,
0.6292800903320312,
-0.12173119932413101,
1.2868973016738892,
-0.07180537283420563,
0.08515731990337372,
0.9998324513435364,
0.07551518082618713,
0.5409501194953918,
-0.08499635010957718,
-0.2201610952615738,
0.17602351307868958,
0.18523086607456207,
-0.2971535921096802,
0.16552959382534027,
0.45770880579948425,
-0.11974462121725082,
-0.09178965538740158,
0.08708056807518005,
-0.1300346553325653,
0.7512013912200928,
0.2280784696340561,
-0.25127482414245605,
-0.26142117381095886,
0.04953812062740326,
0.12129512429237366,
0.3540925085544586,
-0.06316672265529633,
0.8710644841194153,
-0.11201170086860657,
-0.7674343585968018,
1.1740270853042603,
-0.038294170051813126,
0.5579444766044617,
-0.6349380612373352,
0.02487945556640625,
0.20386408269405365,
0.42660897970199585,
-0.10011104494333267,
-0.5411523580551147,
0.2873348295688629,
0.42832517623901367,
0.28200140595436096,
-0.03651653602719307,
0.7444692850112915,
-0.30743011832237244,
-0.4036909341812134,
0.5523393750190735,
0.13966546952724457,
-0.09361463785171509,
-0.29842960834503174,
-0.8316266536712646,
-0.04235725477337837,
0.12165727466344833,
-0.6254549026489258,
0.30778440833091736,
0.47049978375434875,
0.264249712228775,
0.6241689920425415,
0.6707477569580078,
0.4879666566848755,
-0.131047785282135,
0.08462585508823395,
0.8798829913139343,
-0.516312837600708,
-0.27718397974967957,
-1.0777745246887207,
0.518172562122345,
0.01976664364337921,
-0.5676649212837219,
0.6984098553657532,
0.3913995921611786,
0.6195544004440308,
0.4332180619239807,
0.9929448962211609,
0.21436965465545654,
0.42551153898239136,
-0.33628442883491516,
0.855801522731781,
-0.5976414084434509,
0.29632338881492615,
-0.47114866971969604,
-0.7098180055618286,
-0.16420878469944,
0.470020055770874,
-0.12142335623502731,
-0.06931731849908829,
0.5723580121994019,
0.5840404033660889,
0.21306383609771729,
-0.04707111790776253,
0.40520185232162476,
0.2049548178911209,
0.6449391841888428,
0.745062530040741,
0.7666124701499939,
-0.7007248997688293,
1.2488389015197754,
0.025234052911400795,
-0.22701746225357056,
-0.15982989966869354,
-0.7104495763778687,
-1.0568921566009521,
-0.20483259856700897,
-0.21759432554244995,
-0.5685437321662903,
0.2932938039302826,
0.7151553630828857,
0.3966349959373474,
-0.7319377064704895,
0.07649226486682892,
-0.06291741132736206,
-0.08992169052362442,
-0.007645744364708662,
-0.25273987650871277,
0.46955448389053345,
-0.2684813141822815,
-0.6003158092498779,
0.742800772190094,
0.1693127304315567,
-0.09072275459766388,
-0.6780142784118652,
-0.1572907567024231,
0.1438007354736328,
0.09136988967657089,
0.2899594306945801,
0.22299443185329437,
-0.8110645413398743,
-0.12945450842380524,
-0.5594714879989624,
-0.26557496190071106,
-0.14497850835323334,
0.8941230773925781,
-0.9078530669212341,
0.7314803004264832,
0.13841581344604492,
1.0838940143585205,
-0.04627104848623276,
0.22823113203048706,
1.0502538681030273,
-0.9619086384773254,
0.04527433589100838,
0.5728484392166138,
0.19067083299160004,
0.47313377261161804,
-0.5329462289810181,
0.4729013442993164,
0.013582727871835232,
-0.5148427486419678,
-1.1091982126235962,
0.07248196750879288,
-0.212111696600914,
-0.3639105558395386,
1.1624335050582886,
-0.2695733308792114,
-0.19623206555843353,
-0.0016611083410680294,
-0.12664927542209625,
0.025508007034659386,
-0.4078293740749359,
0.938422679901123,
0.7844363451004028,
0.13364417850971222,
0.3190615773200989,
-0.541957437992096,
0.7583935260772705,
0.4595205783843994,
-0.5550165176391602,
0.420962929725647,
0.348574161529541,
-0.11763068288564682,
0.3598400950431824,
0.1813514232635498,
-0.12168005108833313,
0.3366791009902954,
0.3075108230113983,
0.014977632090449333,
-0.31927546858787537,
-0.37206095457077026,
-0.7497548460960388,
0.39361295104026794,
-0.1787898987531662,
-0.01609872467815876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14622v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14622v3
|
Calibrated Self-Rewarding Vision Language Models
| 2024-05-23T14:30:33 | 2024-05-31T16:37:53 |
Yiyang Zhou, Zhiyuan Fan, Dongjie Cheng, Sihan Yang, Zhaorun Chen, Chenhang Cui, Xiyao Wang, Yun Li, Linjun Zhang, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have made substantial progress by
integrating pre-trained large language models (LLMs) and vision models through
instruction tuning. Despite these advancements, LVLMs often exhibit the
hallucination phenomenon, where generated text responses appear linguistically
plausible but contradict the input image, indicating a misalignment between
image and text pairs. This misalignment arises because the model tends to
prioritize textual information over visual input, even when both the language
model and visual representations are of high quality. Existing methods leverage
additional models or human annotations to curate preference data and enhance
modality alignment through preference optimization. These approaches may not
effectively reflect the target LVLM's preferences, making the curated
preferences easily distinguishable. Our work addresses these challenges by
proposing the Calibrated Self-Rewarding (CSR) approach, which enables the model
to self-improve by iteratively generating candidate responses, evaluating the
reward for each response, and curating preference data for fine-tuning. In the
reward modeling, we employ a step-wise strategy and incorporate visual
constraints into the self-rewarding process to place greater emphasis on visual
input. Empirical results demonstrate that CSR enhances performance and reduces
hallucinations across ten benchmarks and tasks, achieving substantial
improvements over existing methods by 7.62%. Our empirical results are further
supported by rigorous theoretical analysis, under mild assumptions, verifying
the effectiveness of introducing visual constraints into the self-rewarding
paradigm. Additionally, CSR shows compatibility with different vision-language
models and the ability to incrementally improve performance through iterative
fine-tuning. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/YiyangZhou/CSR.
|
[
-0.20101793110370636,
-0.31521177291870117,
0.5621068477630615,
0.1555822491645813,
-0.2804253101348877,
-0.22433142364025116,
-0.34612447023391724,
-0.39200785756111145,
0.35998204350471497,
0.8246207237243652,
-0.5014967918395996,
-0.23106878995895386,
-0.4439009130001068,
0.06635602563619614,
-0.063031405210495,
0.8877255916595459,
0.09430897235870361,
0.3135937452316284,
-0.2851674258708954,
-0.0902492105960846,
-0.8453656435012817,
-0.6694215536117554,
-0.28959065675735474,
-0.35987284779548645,
0.7707303762435913,
0.2886684834957123,
0.5777140259742737,
0.9399492740631104,
0.6758018136024475,
0.27509498596191406,
0.19600437581539154,
0.20042316615581512,
-0.6506536602973938,
0.10208341479301453,
-0.31916406750679016,
-0.1914844661951065,
-0.09390642493963242,
-0.13537898659706116,
0.12423597276210785,
0.2632175087928772,
-0.3151201009750366,
0.13990984857082367,
0.3323221206665039,
0.960598349571228,
-0.915730893611908,
0.12974901497364044,
-0.6125677824020386,
0.1563752144575119,
-0.008197315968573093,
-0.6970921158790588,
-0.342655211687088,
-0.31641027331352234,
0.12244066596031189,
-0.5282653570175171,
0.16045987606048584,
0.014435476623475552,
0.6643517017364502,
0.7126692533493042,
-0.06908930093050003,
-0.3041064739227295,
-0.5538090467453003,
0.7766989469528198,
-0.601397693157196,
0.5036282539367676,
0.5304732322692871,
0.2819408178329468,
0.14299459755420685,
-0.3755321204662323,
-0.3441801369190216,
-0.27903804183006287,
-0.1549379825592041,
0.1671496033668518,
0.21174132823944092,
-0.06477511674165726,
0.11786962300539017,
0.38452574610710144,
-0.6629379987716675,
0.1239781305193901,
-0.4462912678718567,
-0.21009229123592377,
0.6092304587364197,
0.3668249845504761,
0.037883732467889786,
-0.2723081409931183,
-0.35813191533088684,
-0.5606010556221008,
-0.4307538866996765,
0.350739985704422,
0.2595801055431366,
0.45627763867378235,
0.10290461033582687,
0.7296711206436157,
-0.41220852732658386,
0.9519473314285278,
0.3443179726600647,
-0.0811321958899498,
0.39095133543014526,
-0.25729238986968994,
-0.2820075452327728,
0.16404977440834045,
0.5891355276107788,
0.7090418934822083,
0.2905672788619995,
-0.10636541992425919,
-0.43497079610824585,
0.3078780770301819,
0.5103501081466675,
-0.8012679219245911,
-0.4328663945198059,
0.09999348223209381,
-0.5581412315368652,
-0.6311672925949097,
-0.13723701238632202,
-0.707118570804596,
-0.6699488759040833,
-0.6150664687156677,
0.6912832260131836,
-0.27608567476272583,
-0.10173734277486801,
0.37481072545051575,
0.01403078343719244,
0.3043974041938782,
0.4628225564956665,
-1.2218245267868042,
-0.08627969026565552,
0.45774680376052856,
0.6523127555847168,
-0.6101169586181641,
-0.2855067849159241,
-0.639083981513977,
0.03627672791481018,
-0.3036338984966278,
0.7349340319633484,
-0.4649936854839325,
-0.2847265899181366,
0.03593803197145462,
0.05337841436266899,
0.12759147584438324,
-0.684733510017395,
0.3581189513206482,
-0.35440143942832947,
0.15303419530391693,
-0.5412015318870544,
-0.3372407853603363,
-0.043264154344797134,
0.3672819137573242,
-0.6321471929550171,
0.9107828140258789,
-0.005669767502695322,
-0.5795438885688782,
0.4462752044200897,
-0.40756353735923767,
-0.1415637582540512,
0.33646178245544434,
-0.5845205783843994,
-0.2250680774450302,
0.2765507698059082,
0.33681225776672363,
0.4803902208805084,
-0.0024078486021608114,
0.31061357259750366,
-0.16037866473197937,
-0.4596783518791199,
0.1375100165605545,
-0.3205941617488861,
0.44913414120674133,
0.26933255791664124,
-0.5223010778427124,
0.37503325939178467,
-0.6357542872428894,
0.1237252801656723,
0.18205446004867554,
-0.10668608546257019,
-0.36714741587638855,
0.185601606965065,
0.10092785954475403,
0.22508788108825684,
0.4157981872558594,
-0.30658212304115295,
0.19688859581947327,
-0.5227460861206055,
0.18949386477470398,
1.0573011636734009,
-0.4024806320667267,
0.45240870118141174,
-0.24153460562229156,
0.3225114941596985,
0.02792341262102127,
0.2778623104095459,
-0.16912733018398285,
0.034549590200185776,
-0.9107298851013184,
-0.1835130751132965,
-0.07668779790401459,
0.5733417868614197,
-0.7945545315742493,
0.490116149187088,
-0.19501623511314392,
-0.31768736243247986,
-0.53861004114151,
0.19930453598499298,
0.33449769020080566,
0.5100248456001282,
0.5422016382217407,
-0.4059400260448456,
-0.3614540100097656,
-1.0122828483581543,
-0.07419123500585556,
0.013557656668126583,
0.11687847971916199,
0.4298148453235626,
0.2772909700870514,
-0.11641980707645416,
0.7451011538505554,
-0.5298120975494385,
-0.8223227858543396,
0.03290454298257828,
-0.03451380506157875,
0.04444501921534538,
0.5101284980773926,
0.3030482530593872,
-0.6986479759216309,
-0.32807430624961853,
0.08356600254774094,
-0.7769652009010315,
-0.058736227452754974,
-0.0777561217546463,
0.1098746508359909,
0.37474676966667175,
0.36378607153892517,
0.02468240261077881,
0.7263578176498413,
0.594495415687561,
-0.337424099445343,
0.5779721140861511,
-0.34098705649375916,
0.4211445748806,
-0.6847753524780273,
-0.06289009004831314,
-0.03218599781394005,
-0.2953220009803772,
-0.3969706594944,
0.015004709362983704,
0.1762901097536087,
0.17506788671016693,
-0.3751244843006134,
0.4645707309246063,
-0.3326590359210968,
0.12647680938243866,
-0.6380983591079712,
-0.0694349855184555,
-0.09189161658287048,
0.5823206901550293,
0.4473726451396942,
0.7464643716812134,
0.5200057625770569,
-0.5670204758644104,
0.3868602514266968,
0.16862241923809052,
-0.44068455696105957,
0.5903923511505127,
-0.6831199526786804,
0.023295078426599503,
-0.2326638400554657,
-0.1354956477880478,
-0.8771213293075562,
-0.23375970125198364,
0.29923245310783386,
-0.2822646200656891,
0.11421746015548706,
0.22214317321777344,
-0.2234514206647873,
-0.27238181233406067,
-0.301128625869751,
0.7195909023284912,
0.28623437881469727,
-0.8912356495857239,
0.6180515885353088,
0.1671019047498703,
0.27466002106666565,
-0.7030665874481201,
-0.7433533668518066,
0.13545309007167816,
-0.18549193441867828,
-0.37598344683647156,
0.46855878829956055,
-0.3390216529369354,
0.15821866691112518,
-0.15601688623428345,
-0.010848402976989746,
0.3498954176902771,
-0.26028409600257874,
0.3459407091140747,
0.3769384026527405,
-0.05085025355219841,
0.10790467262268066,
-0.3452925980091095,
-0.18032728135585785,
-0.0955449640750885,
-0.14566858112812042,
0.7259503602981567,
-0.28693687915802,
-0.3751555383205414,
-0.492008239030838,
0.12216845154762268,
0.2715584933757782,
-0.42935073375701904,
0.47182533144950867,
0.5357677340507507,
-0.2106407880783081,
-0.04846440255641937,
-0.9820394515991211,
-0.49516382813453674,
-0.5552401542663574,
0.3060767352581024,
-0.5252618789672852,
-1.0317327976226807,
0.21839609742164612,
0.27286022901535034,
-0.15130895376205444,
0.19647882878780365,
0.7746344208717346,
0.000978462165221572,
1.1205146312713623,
0.7147367596626282,
0.042916253209114075,
0.5860310196876526,
-0.06855413317680359,
0.2269604504108429,
-0.7714359164237976,
-0.45893892645835876,
-0.25276851654052734,
-0.2748100459575653,
-0.4585230052471161,
-0.38931605219841003,
0.2576022744178772,
-0.22485043108463287,
-0.16401340067386627,
0.22461074590682983,
-1.186416745185852,
0.599373996257782,
0.624280571937561,
0.23462730646133423,
0.1487616002559662,
0.20184507966041565,
-0.09810999780893326,
-0.4130105972290039,
-0.4869161546230316,
-0.3772662878036499,
0.7834610939025879,
0.11932644993066788,
1.2235740423202515,
-0.23643758893013,
0.7438374757766724,
0.305611252784729,
0.02718876302242279,
-0.7183352708816528,
0.5037750005722046,
-0.22644813358783722,
-0.2794824540615082,
-0.4707399904727936,
-0.33062228560447693,
-0.744083821773529,
0.24366271495819092,
-0.3292399048805237,
-1.0335198640823364,
0.4827623963356018,
0.48475950956344604,
-0.401081919670105,
0.02310592494904995,
-0.4164235591888428,
1.105698823928833,
-0.7084019780158997,
-0.6902846097946167,
-0.20909371972084045,
-0.61165851354599,
0.2262302041053772,
-0.020661914721131325,
-0.08947193622589111,
0.03614949807524681,
0.2878314256668091,
0.42761728167533875,
-0.12718011438846588,
0.7550408840179443,
0.04031543433666229,
-0.13641169667243958,
-0.193204864859581,
0.25124332308769226,
0.5374845266342163,
-0.1490020602941513,
-0.10105133801698685,
0.1432693600654602,
0.23411692678928375,
-0.17836590111255646,
-0.6540551781654358,
0.8721932172775269,
-0.6739596128463745,
-0.7183600664138794,
-0.6684597730636597,
-0.6927686333656311,
0.053867027163505554,
0.05070292204618454,
0.3786827623844147,
0.33875054121017456,
-0.00855050329118967,
0.251789391040802,
0.5811300277709961,
-0.37143924832344055,
0.3276106119155884,
0.30887386202812195,
-0.5855614542961121,
-0.617117702960968,
1.1395546197891235,
-0.04557301849126816,
0.28436627984046936,
0.2792067229747772,
0.1838829070329666,
-0.4660953879356384,
-0.21425174176692963,
-0.3792084753513336,
0.17697188258171082,
-0.7383394837379456,
-0.13075563311576843,
-0.45837467908859253,
-0.28880903124809265,
-0.5186284184455872,
-0.4651632308959961,
-0.5497113466262817,
-0.13929547369480133,
-0.4018400013446808,
0.18254391849040985,
0.12006470561027527,
0.5508042573928833,
-0.1703081578016281,
0.1642650067806244,
-0.29365667700767517,
0.3356095254421234,
0.4329633414745331,
0.5047245621681213,
0.08236318081617355,
-0.5799601674079895,
-0.35320115089416504,
0.030875300988554955,
-0.2977871298789978,
-0.6887041926383972,
0.713856041431427,
-0.1853341907262802,
0.44395390152931213,
0.4229482412338257,
0.027916913852095604,
1.0634664297103882,
-0.421474426984787,
0.7969024777412415,
0.5052977204322815,
-0.765018880367279,
0.6896884441375732,
-0.04101322218775749,
0.3672228157520294,
0.7655534744262695,
-0.06216813623905182,
-0.4295543134212494,
-0.16335150599479675,
-0.06467738747596741,
-0.6809356808662415,
0.5341160297393799,
0.05913654714822769,
0.177533358335495,
0.09526374936103821,
0.40777525305747986,
0.023833829909563065,
0.056765127927064896,
-1.2372980117797852,
-0.20619356632232666,
-0.7010931968688965,
-0.302433043718338,
-0.24392810463905334,
-0.23566995561122894,
-0.19957047700881958,
-0.4665290415287018,
0.6545970439910889,
-0.32775571942329407,
0.07647751271724701,
0.4034007787704468,
-0.10415291786193848,
-0.19147491455078125,
0.03317561000585556,
0.68668133020401,
0.6230834722518921,
-0.22494933009147644,
0.2865942120552063,
0.010028383694589138,
-0.18850700557231903,
0.15379159152507782,
-0.13326133787631989,
-0.250883549451828,
-0.32777002453804016,
-0.1869710087776184,
0.9228641390800476,
-0.04725147783756256,
-0.6746701598167419,
0.6629981398582458,
-0.15827001631259918,
-0.1903465837240219,
-0.3116939961910248,
0.25375035405158997,
-0.19158796966075897,
0.27268916368484497,
0.29908332228660583,
-0.11159967631101608,
0.3735424876213074,
-0.279420405626297,
0.0027966960333287716,
0.7705864906311035,
-0.7219634056091309,
0.048140496015548706,
0.8077207803726196,
-0.09261810034513474,
-0.3869386613368988,
0.42159196734428406,
-0.04724879935383797,
-0.48253315687179565,
0.3532995581626892,
0.6851785182952881,
0.8467104434967041,
-0.2508084177970886,
0.3059031069278717,
0.5397682785987854,
0.39851996302604675,
-0.26954707503318787,
0.13498403131961823,
-0.1649208813905716,
-0.7203357815742493,
-0.25848254561424255,
-0.7141381502151489,
-0.16655674576759338,
0.2570461630821228,
-0.6155956387519836,
0.4281657040119171,
-0.10331311821937561,
-0.11316488683223724,
-0.07634269446134567,
-0.33918464183807373,
-0.7340700030326843,
0.3833359181880951,
0.24682343006134033,
0.4769119918346405,
-0.6493614912033081,
0.8069425225257874,
0.4318358302116394,
-0.45872583985328674,
-0.7662205696105957,
-0.15571455657482147,
-0.17218643426895142,
-0.9139305353164673,
0.8266096115112305,
0.4604821801185608,
-0.42627260088920593,
-0.0385623462498188,
-0.6046285033226013,
-0.843279242515564,
1.0332509279251099,
0.21124126017093658,
-0.7539150714874268,
0.029265528544783592,
0.41118407249450684,
0.48723408579826355,
-0.5476340651512146,
0.020093005150556564,
0.2703932821750641,
0.29379868507385254,
0.30210843682289124,
-0.8006040453910828,
0.12038496136665344,
-0.1865968406200409,
0.34862786531448364,
0.1092328131198883,
-0.5169756412506104,
0.40810325741767883,
-0.2745315432548523,
-0.03283876180648804,
0.07654464989900589,
0.6210216879844666,
0.48644962906837463,
0.3624245822429657,
0.6753796339035034,
0.48928117752075195,
0.46326419711112976,
0.01706312783062458,
0.7017338871955872,
-0.49140262603759766,
0.329345703125,
1.1921051740646362,
-0.3083069920539856,
0.8508785963058472,
0.8829683065414429,
0.30301377177238464,
0.3929557800292969,
0.6032986640930176,
-0.21744920313358307,
0.884604275226593,
0.22542807459831238,
0.05910108983516693,
-0.6210905313491821,
-0.25622987747192383,
-0.4871727228164673,
0.6143456697463989,
0.018785515800118446,
-0.47012075781822205,
0.07418250292539597,
0.17079800367355347,
-0.6337722539901733,
0.18548370897769928,
-0.26878246665000916,
0.6593737006187439,
-0.013941613957285881,
-0.947437584400177,
0.6096624135971069,
-0.2077852338552475,
0.8082719445228577,
-0.4874117076396942,
-0.09055926650762558,
-0.048219747841358185,
0.25641751289367676,
-0.24416010081768036,
-0.6932045817375183,
0.06658923625946045,
-0.13092590868473053,
-0.17419347167015076,
-0.34826064109802246,
0.743886411190033,
-0.516475260257721,
-0.6237450838088989,
0.2853430509567261,
0.28961312770843506,
0.07552357017993927,
-0.11114796251058578,
-0.5615890026092529,
0.24811889231204987,
0.1063595861196518,
-0.22085313498973846,
0.30176854133605957,
0.10992050170898438,
0.07751525193452835,
0.6807074546813965,
0.5851656198501587,
0.09589608013629913,
-0.11797115951776505,
0.23604226112365723,
0.7175508141517639,
-0.8001424074172974,
-0.6425660848617554,
-1.0074665546417236,
0.4867161512374878,
-0.026018835604190826,
-0.180352583527565,
0.5838450789451599,
0.6934079527854919,
0.852618396282196,
-0.32916685938835144,
0.32508385181427,
0.2388496696949005,
0.14176636934280396,
-0.5108397006988525,
0.5675724744796753,
-0.9581915140151978,
0.26501235365867615,
-0.34172889590263367,
-0.911511242389679,
-0.3852352201938629,
1.0142993927001953,
-0.3124629855155945,
0.059197258204221725,
0.5158215165138245,
1.1055476665496826,
0.07288455963134766,
-0.3002716898918152,
0.6425608396530151,
-0.14840534329414368,
0.06467707455158234,
0.5756134986877441,
0.9072797298431396,
-0.16525331139564514,
0.4009428024291992,
-0.526677668094635,
-0.2502920925617218,
-0.35300877690315247,
-0.9601350426673889,
-0.8236106634140015,
-0.7884753942489624,
-0.33323580026626587,
-0.48030540347099304,
0.07714678347110748,
0.9375157952308655,
0.8067888021469116,
-0.7222453951835632,
-0.4894058108329773,
-0.061676956713199615,
-0.2104477882385254,
-0.19378460943698883,
-0.23412324488162994,
0.28315359354019165,
-0.4380549490451813,
-0.4600975811481476,
0.1427975594997406,
0.6343795657157898,
0.13097630441188812,
-0.5679052472114563,
-0.3878818452358246,
0.2255670726299286,
0.1090996265411377,
0.6637171506881714,
0.1428561955690384,
-1.2041006088256836,
-0.5021471381187439,
0.43814119696617126,
-0.37303391098976135,
0.3112192749977112,
0.6233071088790894,
-0.9922529458999634,
0.8043039441108704,
0.28948017954826355,
0.5641795992851257,
0.6865798830986023,
0.02921091578900814,
0.35578832030296326,
-0.2670029103755951,
-0.06214291229844093,
0.08614479005336761,
0.23913009464740753,
0.5278300046920776,
-0.614648163318634,
0.6168016791343689,
-0.039481110870838165,
-0.7960315346717834,
-0.8564353585243225,
0.21457810699939728,
-1.3783750534057617,
-0.1994500607252121,
1.1377006769180298,
0.43915826082229614,
-0.21216852962970734,
0.3445923924446106,
-0.5412765145301819,
0.08044249564409256,
-0.11393512040376663,
1.3982676267623901,
0.7014443278312683,
-0.09543244540691376,
-0.31893470883369446,
-0.30009421706199646,
0.6014754176139832,
0.765185534954071,
-0.7010502815246582,
0.17151258885860443,
0.7026351690292358,
0.18533968925476074,
0.1063239574432373,
0.6685346961021423,
-0.1035352572798729,
0.468532532453537,
-0.5385456085205078,
0.37201040983200073,
0.01031132135540247,
-0.3654407858848572,
-0.6114537119865417,
0.08115475624799728,
0.05104732885956764,
-0.17634905874729156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14604v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14604v1
|
A Watermark for Low-entropy and Unbiased Generation in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T14:17:29 | 2024-05-23T14:17:29 |
Minjia Mao, Dongjun Wei, Zeyu Chen, Xiao Fang, Michael Chau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have highlighted the risk
of misuse, raising concerns about accurately detecting LLM-generated content. A
viable solution for the detection problem is to inject imperceptible
identifiers into LLMs, known as watermarks. Previous work demonstrates that
unbiased watermarks ensure unforgeability and preserve text quality by
maintaining the expectation of the LLM output probability distribution.
However, previous unbiased watermarking methods are impractical for local
deployment because they rely on accesses to white-box LLMs and input prompts
during detection. Moreover, these methods fail to provide statistical
guarantees for the type II error of watermark detection. This study proposes
the Sampling One Then Accepting (STA-1) method, an unbiased watermark that does
not require access to LLMs nor prompts during detection and has statistical
guarantees for the type II error. Moreover, we propose a novel tradeoff between
watermark strength and text quality in unbiased watermarks. We show that in
low-entropy scenarios, unbiased watermarks face a tradeoff between watermark
strength and the risk of unsatisfactory outputs. Experimental results on
low-entropy and high-entropy datasets demonstrate that STA-1 achieves text
quality and watermark strength comparable to existing unbiased watermarks, with
a low risk of unsatisfactory outputs. Implementation codes for this study are
available online.
|
[
-0.07471273839473724,
-0.5717902183532715,
0.5898465514183044,
0.23179036378860474,
-0.8018961548805237,
0.07001867145299911,
-0.18409180641174316,
-0.3291165232658386,
0.2585398554801941,
0.5537346005439758,
-0.16374966502189636,
-0.43521368503570557,
-0.8774888515472412,
-0.16646727919578552,
-0.46472927927970886,
0.7067476511001587,
-0.14009594917297363,
-0.0437711738049984,
-0.37434181571006775,
-0.18914854526519775,
-0.0047965156845748425,
-0.604389488697052,
-0.6525607705116272,
-0.4280562996864319,
0.2861851155757904,
0.328116774559021,
0.6358904242515564,
0.6784936189651489,
0.49601924419403076,
0.15189029276371002,
-0.14353196322917938,
0.3175337612628937,
-0.32465171813964844,
0.2353789210319519,
-0.0895424336194992,
-0.37653928995132446,
-0.09669346362352371,
-0.02726391889154911,
0.6913655996322632,
0.32139793038368225,
0.037572551518678665,
0.3572368323802948,
0.2827056050300598,
0.558283269405365,
-0.8248984217643738,
-0.001703329966403544,
-0.7906663417816162,
-0.00672901002690196,
-0.6528857350349426,
-0.4430319666862488,
-0.515674889087677,
-0.3850732743740082,
-0.25096482038497925,
-0.30510830879211426,
-0.11874596774578094,
0.161706805229187,
0.9874331951141357,
0.3791533410549164,
-0.1588905155658722,
-0.19724948704242706,
-0.6953691840171814,
0.909132719039917,
-1.0951253175735474,
-0.024758178740739822,
0.6377679705619812,
0.019973719492554665,
-0.3931145966053009,
-0.42572927474975586,
-0.6568203568458557,
0.12485167384147644,
0.3032352328300476,
0.11879188567399979,
-0.44281136989593506,
-0.3397502601146698,
-0.043097782880067825,
0.2816094756126404,
-0.2811168134212494,
0.23434020578861237,
-0.11138235032558441,
-0.10001576691865921,
0.56573086977005,
-0.062227435410022736,
0.2113237828016281,
0.17680928111076355,
-0.41766074299812317,
-0.2618587911128998,
-0.9677565693855286,
0.10363124310970306,
0.7105869054794312,
0.4137813448905945,
-0.19347137212753296,
0.5200701951980591,
-0.026877962052822113,
0.37469255924224854,
-0.172084242105484,
-0.17014257609844208,
0.06995387375354767,
-0.1197323352098465,
-0.16208843886852264,
0.05310223996639252,
1.0363707542419434,
0.036321815103292465,
0.4127826988697052,
-0.035631630569696426,
-0.4322301745414734,
-0.14297044277191162,
-0.06907143443822861,
-0.7437952160835266,
-0.02701311744749546,
0.0556703545153141,
-0.48904138803482056,
-0.44198930263519287,
0.15793433785438538,
-0.8450303673744202,
-0.4837416410446167,
0.003430992364883423,
0.538587212562561,
-0.16345034539699554,
-0.28744053840637207,
0.06891044229269028,
-0.275476336479187,
-0.30048438906669617,
0.11300691962242126,
-0.7016005516052246,
0.032708194106817245,
0.27184370160102844,
0.6842955946922302,
-0.4508066773414612,
-0.055248506367206573,
-0.4667971730232239,
0.19280865788459778,
-0.46266236901283264,
1.010616421699524,
-0.7153325080871582,
-0.16292314231395721,
0.15954986214637756,
-0.3228875398635864,
0.4102766811847687,
-0.702813446521759,
0.2713070809841156,
-0.6259998679161072,
-0.0232837051153183,
-0.10322681814432144,
-0.7242870926856995,
0.089719258248806,
-0.2170872539281845,
-0.6317728757858276,
1.1221288442611694,
0.23386327922344208,
-0.9245852828025818,
0.563866376876831,
-0.2649136483669281,
-0.4666425585746765,
-0.009175396524369717,
-0.11565878242254257,
-0.65708327293396,
0.2465142160654068,
0.0010593878105282784,
0.22643983364105225,
-0.332337349653244,
0.1927109956741333,
-0.573092520236969,
-0.29518646001815796,
0.4527483880519867,
-0.8005236387252808,
0.47691580653190613,
0.0654725432395935,
-0.35476061701774597,
-0.09050901234149933,
-0.8128718733787537,
0.38310936093330383,
0.3514116704463959,
-0.6588443517684937,
-0.6623018383979797,
0.07001877576112747,
0.06136362999677658,
-0.07797873020172119,
0.45661237835884094,
-0.46181580424308777,
-0.022390227764844894,
-0.04706577956676483,
0.19016827642917633,
0.8894146084785461,
0.18430407345294952,
0.3478444814682007,
-0.2554219365119934,
0.4563051462173462,
0.3982029855251312,
0.012811240740120411,
0.17037126421928406,
-0.5826500654220581,
-0.6666496992111206,
-0.5625887513160706,
0.4650903046131134,
0.4581771492958069,
-1.0389342308044434,
0.5531899929046631,
-0.2020019143819809,
-0.6051346063613892,
-0.480406790971756,
0.55643230676651,
0.5460384488105774,
0.05722818896174431,
0.31297653913497925,
-0.21783162653446198,
-0.3823471665382385,
-0.932629406452179,
-0.4585684835910797,
-0.2001233994960785,
-0.25276467204093933,
0.07891982793807983,
0.3602369725704193,
-0.05372016876935959,
0.9986115097999573,
-0.38254159688949585,
-0.1873428374528885,
-0.23159348964691162,
0.45913758873939514,
0.2025696188211441,
0.5432472229003906,
0.32387804985046387,
-0.4203402101993561,
-0.36816492676734924,
-0.2853965759277344,
-0.6451054811477661,
-0.3737615644931793,
0.06923770159482956,
-0.11159049719572067,
0.18793722987174988,
0.2588197886943817,
-0.3502717614173889,
0.5999107956886292,
0.7477494478225708,
-0.36519280076026917,
0.133154034614563,
-0.37296828627586365,
0.12996892631053925,
-1.0179972648620605,
-0.04788580909371376,
0.11329308897256851,
-0.1321655809879303,
-0.5414988398551941,
-0.16304688155651093,
0.06961394101381302,
0.16051152348518372,
-0.37017664313316345,
0.7348806858062744,
-0.16182708740234375,
0.06313273310661316,
-0.5254396796226501,
-0.1423041969537735,
0.05614978075027466,
0.2444884479045868,
-0.00007883306534495205,
0.8557658195495605,
0.2946033775806427,
-0.4844565987586975,
-0.037798456847667694,
-0.03513434901833534,
-0.5606445670127869,
0.4409911334514618,
-0.6869176626205444,
0.24066612124443054,
-0.3908501863479614,
0.005247519351541996,
-0.9390740394592285,
0.08186311274766922,
0.20313216745853424,
-0.260149210691452,
0.43231523036956787,
-0.12868377566337585,
-0.8288170099258423,
0.02345210313796997,
-0.33261770009994507,
0.3611205816268921,
0.55078125,
-0.5819382667541504,
0.04862038791179657,
0.4076223373413086,
-0.2013903558254242,
-0.3748224675655365,
-0.8445268869400024,
0.015329972840845585,
-0.24838045239448547,
-0.46901822090148926,
0.18903718888759613,
-0.003311175387352705,
-0.2865223288536072,
-0.026185128837823868,
-0.16804632544517517,
-0.24200990796089172,
0.12879309058189392,
0.3188537061214447,
0.2546444833278656,
-0.09106499701738358,
-0.1226402297616005,
0.22863206267356873,
-0.23111455142498016,
-0.25922757387161255,
-0.2503998279571533,
0.2851121723651886,
0.3383490741252899,
-0.537549614906311,
-0.4379064440727234,
0.4247247874736786,
0.5160606503486633,
-0.12711961567401886,
0.5147663354873657,
0.20672607421875,
-0.6731750965118408,
-0.47664809226989746,
-0.4018198847770691,
-0.18269389867782593,
-0.46744808554649353,
0.043885525315999985,
0.053098153322935104,
-0.6937448382377625,
0.3507295250892639,
0.19043324887752533,
0.10032503306865692,
0.3346690237522125,
0.41277819871902466,
-0.2114373743534088,
0.6880751848220825,
0.37762215733528137,
-0.185263529419899,
0.561708390712738,
0.181203693151474,
0.39494776725769043,
-0.6284079551696777,
0.07907464355230331,
-0.7851302623748779,
-0.29422828555107117,
-0.25236645340919495,
-0.5152266621589661,
0.20705531537532806,
0.3396773338317871,
-0.2315664142370224,
0.3166673183441162,
-0.5065011978149414,
0.3616936504840851,
1.0394444465637207,
0.09451323747634888,
0.37296774983406067,
0.5111832618713379,
0.020054899156093597,
-0.284730464220047,
-0.393216997385025,
-0.8141356110572815,
1.0507365465164185,
0.29109811782836914,
1.1366806030273438,
0.13941802084445953,
0.7791420221328735,
0.5545706748962402,
0.514900803565979,
-0.2997564673423767,
0.30586299300193787,
-0.31442785263061523,
-0.6613206267356873,
-0.4587317109107971,
-0.5070937871932983,
-0.7591286301612854,
0.10325515270233154,
-0.23732048273086548,
-0.8274151086807251,
0.26896700263023376,
0.23733267188072205,
-0.24845467507839203,
0.5630916953086853,
-0.4458363950252533,
0.6048767566680908,
-0.13765372335910797,
-0.5483812689781189,
0.0528983511030674,
0.005080129951238632,
0.16016802191734314,
-0.34009677171707153,
0.20551396906375885,
-0.24604369699954987,
0.08327578008174896,
0.8111807107925415,
-0.3038650155067444,
0.7008197903633118,
-0.45855119824409485,
-0.4873647689819336,
0.512518584728241,
0.24611054360866547,
0.9482839703559875,
0.007694132160395384,
-0.182350754737854,
0.27543216943740845,
-0.049692146480083466,
-0.32807615399360657,
-0.22081123292446136,
0.47246283292770386,
-0.5755701065063477,
-0.4326998293399811,
-0.40999653935432434,
-0.25670987367630005,
-0.27427050471305847,
0.18879909813404083,
0.6801667213439941,
0.2625919282436371,
0.23938697576522827,
0.1721295565366745,
0.634324312210083,
-0.3496510684490204,
0.5194690823554993,
0.5500274300575256,
0.15496474504470825,
-0.45829513669013977,
0.9905152916908264,
0.28977346420288086,
0.2811613976955414,
0.2740733325481415,
0.2737324833869934,
-0.35752782225608826,
-0.923738420009613,
-0.4713298976421356,
-0.14142964780330658,
-0.7773126363754272,
-0.4670545756816864,
-0.27933406829833984,
-0.20182083547115326,
-0.03427252545952797,
-0.07553800940513611,
-0.580980658531189,
-0.12387987226247787,
-0.4109475314617157,
0.09049058705568314,
0.2996044158935547,
0.5965494513511658,
-0.06902927905321121,
0.2822131812572479,
-0.5701043605804443,
0.270346999168396,
0.35039666295051575,
0.4773271381855011,
-0.057958878576755524,
-0.7895492315292358,
-0.07894466072320938,
0.2557985484600067,
-0.23661938309669495,
-0.5615947842597961,
0.2036941945552826,
0.05579059198498726,
0.35396406054496765,
0.7119826078414917,
0.2835228741168976,
0.4382703900337219,
-0.3399418890476227,
0.7351449728012085,
0.25399506092071533,
-0.9053305983543396,
0.5100106596946716,
-0.1899009793996811,
0.19961975514888763,
0.7197757959365845,
-0.053933463990688324,
-0.14968056976795197,
-0.847450315952301,
-0.44358694553375244,
-0.9039117693901062,
0.3731040060520172,
0.1984724998474121,
0.3353596329689026,
-0.14563913643360138,
0.1699213683605194,
0.2509133517742157,
0.28400951623916626,
-0.7654041647911072,
-0.27163490653038025,
-0.1866437941789627,
-0.3125223219394684,
0.1591867208480835,
-0.6080579161643982,
0.06781166791915894,
0.23744267225265503,
1.0561671257019043,
-0.12893372774124146,
0.17586272954940796,
0.16903693974018097,
0.016774816438555717,
-0.3665827810764313,
0.4733685553073883,
0.616961658000946,
0.4160630404949188,
-0.16602633893489838,
0.5658034086227417,
-0.042558301240205765,
-0.3127690255641937,
0.42726901173591614,
-0.24348440766334534,
-0.6505360007286072,
0.20254074037075043,
0.448773592710495,
0.5988308191299438,
0.1849823296070099,
-0.659765899181366,
0.6165992617607117,
0.029490383341908455,
0.043073125183582306,
-0.16834312677383423,
-0.04082784429192543,
0.0842081755399704,
0.09493870288133621,
0.6171517968177795,
-0.10727676004171371,
-0.15740425884723663,
-0.2546427249908447,
0.18268761038780212,
0.7281900644302368,
-0.27746158838272095,
-0.21819673478603363,
0.7472853064537048,
-0.01478671282529831,
-0.12970666587352753,
0.18847647309303284,
-0.42774757742881775,
-0.13256575167179108,
0.5621832013130188,
0.7357146739959717,
0.7300188541412354,
-0.1295938640832901,
0.063584104180336,
0.3094853162765503,
0.4830247163772583,
-0.31190192699432373,
0.48157012462615967,
0.2791074514389038,
-0.9254462122917175,
0.027924230322241783,
-0.7971169948577881,
-0.4509306252002716,
0.40868833661079407,
-0.5067926049232483,
-0.029645264148712158,
-0.549380898475647,
-0.265745609998703,
-0.011405998840928078,
-0.3419458270072937,
-0.5015947222709656,
0.16048672795295715,
0.36798080801963806,
0.863934338092804,
-0.749424397945404,
0.8289083242416382,
0.5230252742767334,
-0.09669958800077438,
-0.5054337382316589,
0.01506217010319233,
-0.045517563819885254,
-0.8406002521514893,
0.3103330135345459,
-0.11674535274505615,
-0.09784916043281555,
-0.14019815623760223,
-0.7135185599327087,
-0.9474901556968689,
0.8018784523010254,
0.6457653641700745,
-0.47944584488868713,
0.4692322015762329,
0.43759459257125854,
0.3824845552444458,
-0.23554684221744537,
-0.08190614730119705,
0.30268099904060364,
0.6495323777198792,
-0.206549733877182,
-0.47075092792510986,
0.38362428545951843,
-0.27774015069007874,
0.21563012897968292,
0.0492548942565918,
-0.6287072896957397,
0.5973441004753113,
-0.059385526925325394,
-0.4742264747619629,
0.14286763966083527,
0.5583202838897705,
0.453965425491333,
0.273877888917923,
0.4327564537525177,
0.5911716222763062,
0.7510532140731812,
-0.1808883398771286,
0.9174085259437561,
-0.3142138719558716,
0.3456447124481201,
1.1790772676467896,
-0.42979079484939575,
1.055004358291626,
0.8822264075279236,
-0.4336870014667511,
0.20730140805244446,
0.530073881149292,
-0.17855903506278992,
0.7933294773101807,
0.5088563561439514,
-0.44726991653442383,
-0.4076886475086212,
-0.39111700654029846,
-0.30848273634910583,
0.1995030790567398,
-0.018371563404798508,
-0.43096643686294556,
-0.17572256922721863,
-0.22353136539459229,
0.25231873989105225,
0.01831910014152527,
-0.153544619679451,
0.6695778369903564,
0.23060694336891174,
-0.5705273747444153,
0.4548637270927429,
0.19698812067508698,
0.9741150140762329,
-0.6060929894447327,
0.1638820320367813,
-0.44263947010040283,
0.2115841507911682,
-0.15392906963825226,
-0.843000054359436,
0.03709077835083008,
0.13503551483154297,
-0.2674623131752014,
-0.1820261925458908,
0.7532130479812622,
-0.5590053796768188,
-0.5288970470428467,
0.361817866563797,
0.3216453194618225,
0.12175167351961136,
-0.1314142793416977,
-0.08807011693716049,
0.07906682044267654,
-0.0588412843644619,
-0.45049893856048584,
0.45589113235473633,
0.40671348571777344,
-0.004276329651474953,
0.5979238748550415,
0.8185673356056213,
0.29937928915023804,
0.06342986971139908,
0.11627267301082611,
0.45387715101242065,
-0.41869696974754333,
-0.4013983905315399,
-1.0339038372039795,
0.30014052987098694,
-0.07760800421237946,
-0.3549095690250397,
0.6668623089790344,
0.48219987750053406,
0.527355968952179,
-0.12771986424922943,
1.1953316926956177,
0.13873107731342316,
0.08375037461519241,
-0.5271944403648376,
0.8482218384742737,
-0.6161982417106628,
0.1370103657245636,
-0.22200340032577515,
-0.7768122553825378,
-0.24703094363212585,
0.33236029744148254,
0.11258436739444733,
-0.202589213848114,
0.5792402625083923,
0.791272759437561,
-0.014681358821690083,
-0.12334790825843811,
0.3746322989463806,
-0.2403610646724701,
0.24222321808338165,
0.5182763934135437,
0.6834436058998108,
-0.45282959938049316,
0.391018271446228,
-0.20499736070632935,
-0.31781163811683655,
-0.06342629343271255,
-0.9692107439041138,
-0.8478971123695374,
-0.5141631364822388,
-0.47980305552482605,
-0.6651026010513306,
-0.04494236409664154,
0.8914198875427246,
0.6515833139419556,
-1.0825210809707642,
0.16014552116394043,
0.16249962151050568,
0.24538542330265045,
-0.1888071596622467,
-0.2072405368089676,
0.342868447303772,
-0.07682910561561584,
-0.6262733340263367,
0.35732927918434143,
0.4731428027153015,
0.5397680401802063,
-0.27159062027931213,
-0.14089623093605042,
0.13959719240665436,
0.5695328116416931,
0.2304215282201767,
0.202695831656456,
-0.3583921790122986,
-0.5003800988197327,
-0.4092378318309784,
-0.31864503026008606,
0.05877995863556862,
0.6141161322593689,
-0.22772420942783356,
0.17695318162441254,
0.5363022685050964,
0.6671555638313293,
0.22619600594043732,
-0.08170749247074127,
0.24463775753974915,
-0.9167511463165283,
0.21465688943862915,
-0.095313161611557,
0.6091826558113098,
0.4204505383968353,
-0.28062260150909424,
0.3572266101837158,
0.2828614115715027,
-0.19711044430732727,
-1.0015918016433716,
-0.004114706069231033,
-0.6471428275108337,
-0.07121846079826355,
1.4462026357650757,
-0.3663696050643921,
-0.17042341828346252,
-0.08809665590524673,
0.16038168966770172,
0.08082259446382523,
-0.525976300239563,
0.9862707257270813,
0.9485583305358887,
0.4901447594165802,
0.01982695609331131,
-0.45359715819358826,
0.4950914978981018,
0.2382914125919342,
-1.1080925464630127,
0.23124030232429504,
0.03786562383174896,
0.45768308639526367,
0.16915357112884521,
0.5694707036018372,
-0.17153367400169373,
0.06199216842651367,
0.06072201952338219,
0.3404698073863983,
0.03157731890678406,
-0.062274619936943054,
-0.17578846216201782,
0.1528456062078476,
0.16335827112197876,
-0.1929684430360794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14601v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14601v1
|
A FAIR and Free Prompt-based Research Assistant
| 2024-05-23T14:16:46 | 2024-05-23T14:16:46 |
Mahsa Shamsabadi, Jennifer D'Souza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This demo will present the Research Assistant (RA) tool developed to assist
with six main types of research tasks defined as standardized instruction
templates, instantiated with user input, applied finally as prompts to
well-known--for their sophisticated natural language processing abilities--AI
tools, such as ChatGPT (https://chat.openai.com/) and Gemini
(https://gemini.google.com/app). The six research tasks addressed by RA are:
creating FAIR research comparisons, ideating research topics, drafting grant
applications, writing scientific blogs, aiding preliminary peer reviews, and
formulating enhanced literature search queries. RA's reliance on generative AI
tools like ChatGPT or Gemini means the same research task assistance can be
offered in any scientific discipline. We demonstrate its versatility by sharing
RA outputs in Computer Science, Virology, and Climate Science, where the output
with the RA tool assistance mirrored that from a domain expert who performed
the same research task.
|
[
-0.14646722376346588,
-0.7866405844688416,
0.5677719712257385,
0.45165902376174927,
0.07695508003234863,
-0.017020585015416145,
0.018805328756570816,
-0.3665587902069092,
0.3408656716346741,
0.18097005784511566,
-0.6018186211585999,
-0.20638303458690643,
-0.5073341727256775,
0.4076990783214569,
-0.39716947078704834,
1.1291041374206543,
0.1472768932580948,
0.2266288697719574,
-0.3748267590999603,
-0.13380537927150726,
-0.7197601795196533,
0.026907529681921005,
-1.0109785795211792,
-0.31814098358154297,
0.8063700795173645,
0.8214401602745056,
0.8475173115730286,
0.11407992243766785,
0.894756555557251,
0.2727285623550415,
0.23786719143390656,
-0.04347124323248863,
-0.13864082098007202,
0.4340916574001312,
-0.34102946519851685,
-0.49030449986457825,
-0.5789680480957031,
0.42936888337135315,
-0.08090312033891678,
0.48316895961761475,
-0.13639332354068756,
0.24543221294879913,
0.16398005187511444,
0.6852112412452698,
-0.6636546850204468,
0.1954960972070694,
-0.22946284711360931,
-0.14061768352985382,
-0.27345898747444153,
-0.1967378556728363,
-0.3820163905620575,
-0.5602114200592041,
0.010892624966800213,
-1.1785974502563477,
0.5262381434440613,
0.031943246722221375,
0.528693437576294,
0.3562000095844269,
-0.04205363243818283,
-0.484701007604599,
-0.5509086847305298,
0.8197649717330933,
-0.3879924714565277,
-0.18651029467582703,
0.3045777380466461,
0.7366420030593872,
-0.2491719275712967,
-0.7458030581474304,
-0.7824125289916992,
-0.29698696732521057,
-0.050147365778684616,
0.21755461394786835,
-0.45345208048820496,
0.23988351225852966,
0.16492705047130585,
0.34979087114334106,
-0.631132185459137,
-0.35968804359436035,
-0.3266374468803406,
-0.14682388305664062,
0.42100876569747925,
0.0933443009853363,
0.5785977840423584,
-0.13674534857273102,
0.12491704523563385,
-0.374003142118454,
-0.4032730162143707,
0.164850115776062,
0.1611582338809967,
0.4208372235298157,
-0.1997920572757721,
0.8655246496200562,
-0.1982509195804596,
0.6110023856163025,
-0.0018772336188703775,
0.08366570621728897,
0.21855607628822327,
-0.32770347595214844,
-0.24579651653766632,
-0.17831896245479584,
0.7209166288375854,
0.08401855081319809,
0.058803487569093704,
-0.13739345967769623,
-0.04850350320339203,
0.3322569727897644,
0.05301905795931816,
-0.4482291042804718,
-0.3074204921722412,
0.08216515183448792,
-0.5050920248031616,
-0.2267436534166336,
-0.09278693795204163,
-0.7314140200614929,
-0.5855275988578796,
-0.09237746894359589,
0.7383302450180054,
-0.2522360384464264,
-0.18775109946727753,
0.2033461034297943,
-0.6595261693000793,
0.29441124200820923,
0.5214536190032959,
-0.37884148955345154,
0.48134756088256836,
0.4419727027416229,
0.9865037798881531,
-0.21078334748744965,
0.010564553551375866,
-0.6425575017929077,
-0.2635343372821808,
0.06579574197530746,
0.6940352916717529,
-0.9731054306030273,
-0.90852290391922,
-0.3188672661781311,
-0.23076726496219635,
-0.23237933218479156,
-0.24820615351200104,
0.5443347692489624,
-0.38043421506881714,
0.8621811866760254,
-0.33727145195007324,
-0.042748212814331055,
-0.24006354808807373,
0.12059219926595688,
-0.7519128322601318,
1.1257489919662476,
0.165352463722229,
-1.0290740728378296,
0.04411356896162033,
-1.5481209754943848,
-0.25013771653175354,
0.09204757213592529,
-0.358151912689209,
-0.04666340351104736,
-0.25227466225624084,
0.33944404125213623,
0.19228680431842804,
-0.4728069305419922,
0.15119904279708862,
-0.21533727645874023,
-0.15721328556537628,
0.3283471465110779,
-0.39488524198532104,
0.9446715116500854,
0.4942798316478729,
-0.49177297949790955,
0.6389658451080322,
-0.8107541799545288,
-0.27846670150756836,
0.05438860505819321,
0.044605791568756104,
-0.18784213066101074,
-0.3988202214241028,
0.3686056137084961,
-0.2069307416677475,
0.23089349269866943,
-0.6524091958999634,
0.45626139640808105,
-0.042426176369190216,
0.09619048982858658,
0.6283202171325684,
-0.13234741985797882,
0.4181281626224518,
-0.4470598101615906,
0.916600227355957,
-0.1986478865146637,
0.1443849503993988,
0.06289071589708328,
-1.0595693588256836,
-0.7273724675178528,
-0.3783729076385498,
0.34470558166503906,
0.8520554900169373,
-0.9083828926086426,
0.1423531025648117,
0.15734072029590607,
-0.43953290581703186,
-0.8805593848228455,
-0.18177370727062225,
0.24228587746620178,
0.6235020160675049,
0.25824108719825745,
-0.18403896689414978,
-0.4860013723373413,
-0.8211409449577332,
-0.29609784483909607,
0.33219093084335327,
-0.06302311271429062,
0.05051591992378235,
0.47552603483200073,
-0.042071785777807236,
1.274670124053955,
-0.381977915763855,
-0.41098615527153015,
-0.38346800208091736,
0.6934686899185181,
0.16335853934288025,
0.36893540620803833,
0.5292364954948425,
-0.8179223537445068,
-0.5060353875160217,
-0.0216920617967844,
-0.7164306044578552,
-0.2583863437175751,
0.19588005542755127,
0.08412721008062363,
-0.11004175245761871,
0.24326056241989136,
-0.7106117010116577,
0.5579177737236023,
0.4603544771671295,
-0.6698378324508667,
0.3020451068878174,
-0.2515017092227936,
0.5175750851631165,
-1.1063035726547241,
0.6570446491241455,
-0.09827985614538193,
-0.14363250136375427,
-0.5780067443847656,
0.07857103645801544,
-0.33615657687187195,
-0.5036318302154541,
-0.14711196720600128,
0.9561982154846191,
-0.37324345111846924,
-0.1323879510164261,
-0.768671989440918,
0.03527911752462387,
-0.06801190227270126,
0.0056632026098668575,
-0.16474232077598572,
1.3227168321609497,
0.5386466383934021,
-0.3816571533679962,
0.017167823389172554,
0.23746028542518616,
-0.0688006803393364,
0.1652158796787262,
-0.9428877234458923,
0.4737056791782379,
-0.4222172796726227,
0.12679624557495117,
-0.7593799829483032,
-0.16680751740932465,
0.7749179005622864,
-0.9226233959197998,
-0.2478751540184021,
0.30015382170677185,
-0.2327248901128769,
-0.04177219420671463,
-0.35562026500701904,
0.5006353259086609,
0.5591663122177124,
-0.17531244456768036,
0.8069591522216797,
0.12354356795549393,
-0.5010340213775635,
-1.055334448814392,
-0.2517443895339966,
-0.05599404126405716,
-0.07363206148147583,
-0.4627845287322998,
0.20424066483974457,
-0.3924310505390167,
-0.6385230422019958,
0.3431403338909149,
0.2778942286968231,
-0.2506766617298126,
0.017326369881629944,
0.5020028948783875,
0.3213595747947693,
-0.03247595578432083,
-0.3729267418384552,
-0.02165238931775093,
-0.18255825340747833,
-0.11056983470916748,
0.30410513281822205,
0.31979605555534363,
-0.05501589551568031,
-0.3577400743961334,
-0.49785786867141724,
0.510199248790741,
0.606241762638092,
-0.1783619076013565,
0.29139599204063416,
0.6420865654945374,
-0.31681180000305176,
0.18403398990631104,
-0.31604456901550293,
-0.11578218638896942,
-0.5037353038787842,
-0.1758682280778885,
-0.368569552898407,
-0.8242905735969543,
0.5591424703598022,
0.5864633917808533,
0.46351563930511475,
0.5186053514480591,
0.2436884492635727,
0.2833106815814972,
0.906950056552887,
0.8535678386688232,
-0.15149043500423431,
0.4079020321369171,
-0.09110096096992493,
0.19538137316703796,
-0.38279086351394653,
-0.2566643953323364,
-1.0468432903289795,
-0.3482982814311981,
-0.11404842883348465,
-0.7040877342224121,
0.3813914358615875,
-0.20744620263576508,
-0.13143056631088257,
-0.07483871281147003,
-0.8472550511360168,
0.2543809413909912,
1.075320839881897,
-0.09740880131721497,
0.23670072853565216,
-0.18789148330688477,
0.2755688428878784,
0.03487040475010872,
-0.6393491625785828,
-0.4663599729537964,
0.9643497467041016,
0.10075397044420242,
0.9402815699577332,
-0.23132358491420746,
0.5342801809310913,
0.8665210604667664,
0.42084622383117676,
-0.7142561078071594,
0.6319111585617065,
0.13015055656433105,
-0.5533703565597534,
-0.2357005923986435,
-0.22351379692554474,
-1.0634238719940186,
-0.1123541072010994,
-0.13605783879756927,
-0.43948274850845337,
0.3118366301059723,
0.4258421063423157,
-0.31216537952423096,
-0.05068376287817955,
-0.5843638181686401,
0.693328857421875,
0.14048196375370026,
-0.06245710700750351,
-0.502720057964325,
-0.48817840218544006,
0.11006753891706467,
0.5810893177986145,
0.296007364988327,
-0.2604660093784332,
0.312341570854187,
0.903652548789978,
0.1685144454240799,
0.8036186695098877,
-0.6372618675231934,
0.5991284847259521,
0.3429354727268219,
0.23804691433906555,
0.30602434277534485,
0.047111812978982925,
-0.041716039180755615,
-0.3539564311504364,
-0.019149720668792725,
-0.40188777446746826,
-0.46343937516212463,
0.5581392645835876,
-0.8033592700958252,
-0.6055999994277954,
-0.7890880703926086,
-0.9112983345985413,
0.020721109583973885,
0.10609446465969086,
0.1314782351255417,
0.16162849962711334,
-0.308197021484375,
0.06590201705694199,
0.6862252950668335,
-0.360819548368454,
0.16143587231636047,
0.46512889862060547,
-0.19716888666152954,
-0.09430883824825287,
0.8893470168113708,
-0.48008856177330017,
-0.17052419483661652,
0.605026125907898,
0.293703556060791,
-0.16413673758506775,
-0.38534030318260193,
-0.17200174927711487,
-0.13600297272205353,
-0.6001538634300232,
-0.40086397528648376,
-0.77724689245224,
-0.0434877872467041,
-0.8062773942947388,
-0.26451393961906433,
-0.005856103729456663,
-0.7971609234809875,
-0.2670931816101074,
-0.05721108987927437,
0.8166733384132385,
0.795720100402832,
-0.29083240032196045,
0.4198935627937317,
-0.4509558379650116,
0.5660223960876465,
0.2505529820919037,
-0.05317138135433197,
-0.26863521337509155,
-0.04363643750548363,
0.11189905554056168,
-0.11866359412670135,
-0.4013017416000366,
-0.677467942237854,
0.34924954175949097,
0.1073567122220993,
0.4983574450016022,
0.2539602816104889,
-0.13580197095870972,
0.29363176226615906,
-0.20136785507202148,
0.9781743288040161,
0.3316706717014313,
-0.717982292175293,
0.6196198463439941,
-0.35606253147125244,
0.09852178394794464,
0.5426612496376038,
0.28445538878440857,
-0.6228309869766235,
-0.4294329285621643,
-0.4799739420413971,
-0.674863338470459,
0.5715611577033997,
0.26816606521606445,
-0.2187557965517044,
-0.04801175370812416,
0.11533568799495697,
0.5202950239181519,
0.015747468918561935,
-0.6913970112800598,
-0.1448856145143509,
-0.5167418122291565,
-0.28447994589805603,
0.13281559944152832,
0.051166974008083344,
-0.40214017033576965,
0.050836339592933655,
0.7067797780036926,
-0.21974541246891022,
0.41631245613098145,
0.5187111496925354,
0.06787817180156708,
0.11372078210115433,
0.6356163024902344,
0.45825672149658203,
0.5177155137062073,
-0.2982562482357025,
-0.18617881834506989,
-0.29016393423080444,
-0.4552193880081177,
-0.047219280153512955,
0.5009681582450867,
-0.35428157448768616,
0.1704937070608139,
-0.1411108672618866,
0.5217408537864685,
-0.18013924360275269,
-0.698756217956543,
0.4445078670978546,
-0.5944306254386902,
-0.2527279853820801,
-0.20480726659297943,
0.46786201000213623,
-0.1499026119709015,
-0.0009132119012065232,
0.38874581456184387,
0.2912169098854065,
0.672177255153656,
-0.387520968914032,
-0.03411006182432175,
0.4851049482822418,
-0.13630910217761993,
-0.3655850291252136,
1.0267117023468018,
0.3974602520465851,
-0.49045902490615845,
0.5995551347732544,
-0.18244662880897522,
0.1610729843378067,
0.5325607657432556,
0.2542676031589508,
0.9568923115730286,
-0.04070837423205376,
0.4520619511604309,
0.03877617418766022,
-0.04160540550947189,
-0.14541472494602203,
0.7637429237365723,
0.044534288346767426,
-0.4884050190448761,
-0.31195175647735596,
-0.35148176550865173,
-0.7463396191596985,
0.0023446157574653625,
-0.697802722454071,
0.1703510731458664,
-0.3207096755504608,
-0.10403186082839966,
0.38703539967536926,
-0.14263880252838135,
-0.9045210480690002,
-0.004301493521779776,
-0.48820000886917114,
1.2479016780853271,
-0.6915280222892761,
0.7470096349716187,
0.8759956955909729,
-0.5722392201423645,
-0.5915382504463196,
-0.45163920521736145,
0.16729465126991272,
-0.6889753341674805,
0.5150509476661682,
0.1363467127084732,
-0.3949347138404846,
-0.2863331139087677,
-0.6108609437942505,
-0.5023413300514221,
1.0938774347305298,
0.32277995347976685,
-0.2554444372653961,
-0.41411399841308594,
-0.16899214684963226,
0.252089262008667,
-0.1837027221918106,
0.6206932663917542,
0.20087982714176178,
0.6116986870765686,
-0.08233378082513809,
-1.090368628501892,
-0.16590365767478943,
-0.6759101152420044,
-0.41886913776397705,
-0.18189509212970734,
-0.2652146518230438,
0.7851974964141846,
-0.12475035339593887,
-0.10137992352247238,
0.4785074293613434,
0.7965682148933411,
0.309771329164505,
0.7310160994529724,
0.4895331859588623,
0.2873428165912628,
0.7955701947212219,
-0.04018610715866089,
0.9187688231468201,
-0.35167035460472107,
-0.07039099186658859,
0.9051361680030823,
-0.2439410537481308,
0.3610181212425232,
0.584257960319519,
0.11672838032245636,
0.43916264176368713,
0.32227519154548645,
0.16113317012786865,
0.5027191042900085,
-0.16529147326946259,
-0.6367001533508301,
0.2726587653160095,
-0.3365168869495392,
-0.4266456663608551,
0.09627500176429749,
0.4999862611293793,
0.003090551821514964,
-0.2563784718513489,
0.39528924226760864,
0.0005968628684058785,
0.24207089841365814,
-0.24858839809894562,
0.47230324149131775,
0.04930173605680466,
-0.7842830419540405,
-0.35153499245643616,
0.1929434984922409,
0.8523874878883362,
-0.9899578094482422,
-0.26645970344543457,
-0.2512127757072449,
0.06506544351577759,
-0.14437241852283478,
-0.8359165191650391,
0.36257511377334595,
0.11056317389011383,
-0.4820624887943268,
-0.35981664061546326,
0.86094069480896,
-0.0009050338994711637,
-0.26154178380966187,
-0.04945087060332298,
0.7130036354064941,
0.26495131850242615,
0.030509188771247864,
-0.8630140423774719,
-0.001627109246328473,
-0.0586840994656086,
-0.2768769860267639,
0.16149349510669708,
0.2110951840877533,
-0.07061024755239487,
0.9323424100875854,
0.5096946954727173,
0.16849492490291595,
-0.01419279258698225,
0.17935803532600403,
0.6539995074272156,
-0.7793105840682983,
-0.3941971957683563,
-0.18541204929351807,
0.26597654819488525,
-0.016798481345176697,
-0.45219311118125916,
0.6518202424049377,
0.5660042762756348,
0.45491060614585876,
-0.22548694908618927,
1.1154028177261353,
-0.6711800694465637,
0.9225963950157166,
-0.19178402423858643,
0.4362908899784088,
-0.20751702785491943,
-0.1758999079465866,
-0.019631974399089813,
-0.6189069151878357,
-0.25250545144081116,
0.6455994844436646,
-0.14142131805419922,
-0.0001700921857263893,
0.5322040915489197,
0.8940635919570923,
-0.15864145755767822,
0.14242251217365265,
0.014615506865084171,
-0.3497544825077057,
0.6491854190826416,
0.05053485184907913,
0.6486287713050842,
0.0134430518373847,
0.512467086315155,
-0.07725285738706589,
-0.4373866021633148,
0.0174176674336195,
-0.5982857346534729,
-0.8481251001358032,
-0.39609768986701965,
-0.0741252675652504,
-0.42883390188217163,
0.4918901026248932,
1.159617304801941,
0.4049597382545471,
-0.7530623078346252,
-0.2922784090042114,
-0.14533403515815735,
-0.09357094019651413,
-0.27827751636505127,
-0.3913070559501648,
0.422210156917572,
-0.43573257327079773,
-0.8281112313270569,
0.5635361671447754,
0.1414499431848526,
-0.14570434391498566,
-0.07062002271413803,
-0.0034950750414282084,
0.10940954834222794,
-0.08153142035007477,
0.24851486086845398,
0.698383092880249,
-0.45802196860313416,
-0.19947555661201477,
0.3195239305496216,
-0.09412466734647751,
0.10590919852256775,
1.154691457748413,
-0.9042983055114746,
0.46306678652763367,
0.572105348110199,
0.8013346791267395,
0.027430571615695953,
-0.14983397722244263,
0.8851247429847717,
-0.5332522988319397,
0.32595768570899963,
0.4467909634113312,
0.30432912707328796,
0.47290870547294617,
-0.42506662011146545,
0.5516948103904724,
0.03299862518906593,
-0.7311474680900574,
-0.5362194180488586,
-0.06230170652270317,
-1.3656758069992065,
-0.32668429613113403,
0.9033063054084778,
0.007097355555742979,
0.004729623440653086,
-0.2340218722820282,
-0.7288252711296082,
0.3265104293823242,
-0.9825108051300049,
1.0647130012512207,
0.4616166353225708,
-0.5898867249488831,
-0.1874540150165558,
-0.6391772031784058,
0.7487632632255554,
0.43832531571388245,
-0.9247059226036072,
-0.07701155543327332,
0.43129968643188477,
0.3712724447250366,
0.1421859711408615,
1.2078689336776733,
-0.08369752019643784,
0.6052751541137695,
-0.138865664601326,
0.34341633319854736,
-0.15863068401813507,
-0.37633106112480164,
-0.16007792949676514,
0.075007364153862,
0.4411576986312866,
-0.47318199276924133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14594v1
|
Data Augmentation Techniques for Process Extraction from Scientific Publications
| 2024-05-23T14:09:02 | 2024-05-23T14:09:02 |
Yuni Susanti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
We present data augmentation techniques for process extraction tasks in
scientific publications. We cast the process extraction task as a sequence
labeling task where we identify all the entities in a sentence and label them
according to their process-specific roles. The proposed method attempts to
create meaningful augmented sentences by utilizing (1) process-specific
information from the original sentence, (2) role label similarity, and (3)
sentence similarity. We demonstrate that the proposed methods substantially
improve the performance of the process extraction model trained on chemistry
domain datasets, up to 12.3 points improvement in performance accuracy
(F-score). The proposed methods could potentially reduce overfitting as well,
especially when training on small datasets or in a low-resource setting such as
in chemistry and other scientific domains.
|
[
-0.10476090013980865,
-0.6869141459465027,
0.7199410796165466,
-0.04862792044878006,
-0.06772858649492264,
0.22365766763687134,
-0.1293075978755951,
-0.7482910752296448,
0.2884873151779175,
0.8279815316200256,
-0.5494444966316223,
-0.23489220440387726,
-0.5029774308204651,
0.4834117591381073,
-0.07234835624694824,
1.0197478532791138,
-0.20640955865383148,
0.19916865229606628,
-0.516730785369873,
0.41487857699394226,
-0.26944512128829956,
-0.3948547840118408,
-0.21077273786067963,
-0.3621295392513275,
0.3492797911167145,
0.5209243893623352,
0.49187612533569336,
0.8813542127609253,
0.648600161075592,
0.30857324600219727,
-0.06621264666318893,
0.44104456901550293,
-0.12293979525566101,
0.4506599009037018,
-0.3245928883552551,
-0.3227047026157379,
-0.49571725726127625,
0.33964043855667114,
0.6081969738006592,
1.0908621549606323,
0.3527468740940094,
0.2908424139022827,
-0.012594969011843204,
0.6012158393859863,
-0.6053370237350464,
0.4500986635684967,
-0.39619606733322144,
0.14507907629013062,
-0.13686132431030273,
-0.4234965443611145,
-0.4004214406013489,
-0.25290924310684204,
0.21956844627857208,
-0.9018038511276245,
0.5248040556907654,
0.16367745399475098,
0.6994580030441284,
0.07013320177793503,
-0.19042986631393433,
-0.34613487124443054,
-0.7827936410903931,
0.7565298676490784,
-0.5140671133995056,
0.26477867364883423,
0.13026751577854156,
-0.034530721604824066,
-0.22418738901615143,
-1.0334981679916382,
-0.5238266587257385,
-0.3274235725402832,
-0.24288253486156464,
0.08597223460674286,
0.09713350236415863,
0.1769127994775772,
0.7257073521614075,
0.5707470774650574,
-0.5377981662750244,
-0.30243775248527527,
-0.7656028270721436,
-0.22910857200622559,
0.7345283031463623,
-0.020788753405213356,
0.15102618932724,
-0.107460618019104,
-0.276014119386673,
-0.11620936542749405,
-0.4497678577899933,
-0.2616614103317261,
0.3743203580379486,
0.4711281657218933,
0.7743555903434753,
1.1005359888076782,
-0.3712271749973297,
0.6054471135139465,
-0.086479552090168,
0.21575245261192322,
0.5856075882911682,
-0.4234827756881714,
-0.3832418620586395,
0.5322283506393433,
0.34891635179519653,
0.01856205053627491,
0.08343210071325302,
-0.4468241035938263,
-0.061458948999643326,
0.06393614411354065,
0.3833731710910797,
-0.9053745865821838,
-0.38716253638267517,
0.12021619081497192,
-0.2835714519023895,
-0.07582435756921768,
0.37021276354789734,
-0.7646024823188782,
-0.4083946645259857,
-0.5519761443138123,
0.3535294532775879,
-0.3998517692089081,
0.08898366242647171,
-0.2593628764152527,
-0.7232573628425598,
-0.11506684869527817,
0.18448126316070557,
-0.7372668385505676,
0.46867796778678894,
0.748360276222229,
1.0101559162139893,
-0.4774133861064911,
0.12799717485904694,
-0.8082544803619385,
0.20189329981803894,
-0.1220957487821579,
0.7036031484603882,
-1.0610958337783813,
-0.5319840908050537,
-0.3072878420352936,
0.27980589866638184,
-0.050745006650686264,
-0.7787351608276367,
0.6800866723060608,
-0.7438327074050903,
0.0382569283246994,
-0.3038265109062195,
-0.9264230132102966,
-0.07842058688402176,
-0.024657368659973145,
-0.8787126541137695,
1.130028486251831,
0.22052107751369476,
-0.3868616819381714,
0.39530283212661743,
-0.9847288727760315,
-0.5770471096038818,
0.017193472012877464,
0.2723824381828308,
-0.23728321492671967,
0.09167838841676712,
0.3204842805862427,
0.37936946749687195,
-0.1389860212802887,
-0.07928662747144699,
-0.36069637537002563,
0.036781277507543564,
0.5074820518493652,
-0.032171882688999176,
0.6001134514808655,
0.3718208074569702,
0.08218202739953995,
0.094600148499012,
-1.0932108163833618,
0.1753709465265274,
-0.4501262903213501,
-0.33646950125694275,
-0.3900885581970215,
-0.2780537009239197,
-0.018744582310318947,
0.14370205998420715,
0.10664656013250351,
-0.8842644095420837,
0.6176301836967468,
-0.562039315700531,
0.283242791891098,
0.36965885758399963,
0.5923951268196106,
0.675845742225647,
-0.13521932065486908,
0.5839337110519409,
-0.07333977520465851,
-0.17746436595916748,
-0.3730830252170563,
-0.5030750632286072,
-0.5714705586433411,
-0.552850067615509,
0.5195954442024231,
0.7192786931991577,
-0.8334693312644958,
0.6517570614814758,
-0.3080805540084839,
-0.5601215958595276,
-0.5838316679000854,
0.3018481433391571,
0.10655727982521057,
0.8419919610023499,
0.597136914730072,
-0.48324766755104065,
-0.8427118062973022,
-0.7621025443077087,
-0.47759637236595154,
0.07309907674789429,
-0.02611597813665867,
-0.10136052221059799,
0.5067703127861023,
-0.01966063864529133,
1.100644588470459,
-0.9451793432235718,
-0.10160993039608002,
0.17352153360843658,
0.5066190361976624,
0.29171276092529297,
0.5920931696891785,
-0.02104618214070797,
-0.8889176249504089,
-0.3858521580696106,
0.014597523957490921,
-0.6767783761024475,
-0.3643997013568878,
-0.12607893347740173,
-0.018637312576174736,
0.28034743666648865,
0.6240774393081665,
-0.7032110095024109,
0.2787865400314331,
-0.14623180031776428,
-0.1577305942773819,
0.5273346304893494,
-0.2326832264661789,
0.5720745921134949,
-0.8016887307167053,
0.2619278132915497,
0.3799629211425781,
-0.2168094515800476,
-0.9536570310592651,
-0.1785746067762375,
-0.15945662558078766,
-0.21063286066055298,
-0.5239726901054382,
0.3473585247993469,
-0.8461739420890808,
-0.1328882873058319,
-0.41112029552459717,
-0.2074170708656311,
0.315155565738678,
0.1661999672651291,
0.3913613259792328,
0.8298290967941284,
0.47830963134765625,
-0.4140152633190155,
0.410629540681839,
0.21523208916187286,
-0.5116777420043945,
0.15559759736061096,
-0.3286672532558441,
0.16039182245731354,
-0.18102611601352692,
0.11131716519594193,
-1.2048667669296265,
-0.24721430242061615,
0.4069463610649109,
-0.2108764499425888,
0.472018301486969,
-0.02861734852194786,
-0.7108596563339233,
-0.20574168860912323,
-0.22377413511276245,
-0.016486193984746933,
0.41391026973724365,
-0.264819473028183,
0.4357340633869171,
0.25550463795661926,
-0.42469552159309387,
-0.3335466682910919,
-0.7931687831878662,
-0.15388573706150055,
-0.45175209641456604,
-0.4402100443840027,
0.8149348497390747,
0.08660939335823059,
-0.0661967322230339,
0.02677038125693798,
-0.28640320897102356,
-0.34485408663749695,
-0.0856502577662468,
0.22410133481025696,
0.422213613986969,
0.035603445023298264,
0.2361801266670227,
0.09877422451972961,
-0.12757229804992676,
0.045364633202552795,
-0.1073298379778862,
0.13059227168560028,
0.33008283376693726,
0.09974227845668793,
-0.37167805433273315,
0.5268123149871826,
0.31154993176460266,
-0.013564408756792545,
0.5903230309486389,
0.7295752167701721,
-0.3843492865562439,
0.1934225857257843,
-0.27009108662605286,
-0.4824545085430145,
-0.48178261518478394,
0.18321263790130615,
-0.31608593463897705,
-0.6365489363670349,
0.4741883873939514,
-0.4123302698135376,
-0.11321096867322922,
0.4565979838371277,
0.13169576227664948,
-0.20210932195186615,
0.8724040389060974,
0.44480979442596436,
0.2444312572479248,
0.5380180478096008,
-0.2176007777452469,
0.42187535762786865,
-0.937714159488678,
-0.2518581449985504,
-0.551402747631073,
-0.13193275034427643,
-0.3086864650249481,
-0.683903694152832,
0.4627702534198761,
0.43405652046203613,
0.09539978951215744,
0.45754650235176086,
-0.7473062872886658,
0.2739850580692291,
0.5127509832382202,
0.08158335834741592,
0.5289930701255798,
0.35179945826530457,
0.38290539383888245,
-0.3060978949069977,
-0.5178197622299194,
-0.5842177271842957,
0.9890273213386536,
0.09508489072322845,
0.5064609050750732,
-0.108265221118927,
0.710159420967102,
0.6785003542900085,
0.26509591937065125,
-0.7421397566795349,
0.42504531145095825,
0.06233708932995796,
-0.5484020709991455,
-0.30172401666641235,
-0.2638757526874542,
-0.8095462918281555,
0.08734522014856339,
-0.4694950580596924,
-0.8855851888656616,
0.3257291615009308,
-0.019076621159911156,
-0.3249034583568573,
-0.34139886498451233,
-0.9375238418579102,
0.7454359531402588,
-0.09625706821680069,
-0.3905279040336609,
0.0750192403793335,
-0.7041143774986267,
0.176921084523201,
-0.12321226298809052,
0.010395839810371399,
0.13974370062351227,
-0.14317907392978668,
0.9640769958496094,
-0.7281757593154907,
0.6855616569519043,
-0.19789817929267883,
0.05879148095846176,
0.4706518054008484,
-0.4218941628932953,
0.5940645337104797,
-0.19109567999839783,
-0.40058696269989014,
-0.10308263450860977,
0.17648214101791382,
-0.154458150267601,
-0.9304215908050537,
0.5701555609703064,
-0.21927064657211304,
-0.6228001117706299,
-0.7057211399078369,
-0.5234306454658508,
-0.252959668636322,
0.20928065478801727,
0.021353840827941895,
0.0013376300921663642,
0.015231399796903133,
-0.08157079666852951,
0.5619414448738098,
0.12325715273618698,
0.5033751726150513,
0.26012375950813293,
0.22462968528270721,
-0.5723327994346619,
0.8063051104545593,
0.2585117518901825,
0.19259798526763916,
0.45306193828582764,
-0.175112783908844,
-0.49878638982772827,
-0.3414478003978729,
-0.2791651487350464,
-0.13972415030002594,
-0.7007856369018555,
-0.30081912875175476,
-0.7532942891120911,
-0.04052317142486572,
-1.026153802871704,
0.06915926933288574,
-0.09749773889780045,
-0.961637020111084,
-0.6072731018066406,
-0.14689908921718597,
0.6762758493423462,
0.22537340223789215,
-0.18921779096126556,
0.45301344990730286,
-1.138803482055664,
0.36453676223754883,
-0.06750171631574631,
-0.0902516320347786,
-0.3855837881565094,
-0.37007033824920654,
-0.27868396043777466,
-0.01859113574028015,
-0.3806988000869751,
-1.123128890991211,
0.5631846189498901,
0.6059005260467529,
0.803342878818512,
0.11455461382865906,
0.016673246398568153,
0.9232967495918274,
-0.6122329831123352,
0.9453948140144348,
0.024457044899463654,
-0.9021536111831665,
0.7926996946334839,
0.01315678097307682,
-0.08016332238912582,
0.49064525961875916,
0.7560588717460632,
-0.0926610603928566,
0.01701604202389717,
-0.6564581394195557,
-1.1633692979812622,
0.6706095933914185,
0.3214638829231262,
-0.2097364217042923,
-0.05278164893388748,
0.7654017210006714,
0.26978135108947754,
0.28843051195144653,
-0.30602604150772095,
-0.27410927414894104,
0.13944227993488312,
-0.1822381615638733,
0.030126037076115608,
0.02279643714427948,
-0.07271099835634232,
-0.40516865253448486,
1.0574421882629395,
-0.09825997799634933,
0.14467167854309082,
0.7136688828468323,
-0.39059337973594666,
-0.10378614813089371,
0.2827844023704529,
0.3527688682079315,
0.5452407598495483,
-0.3120378255844116,
0.03502846881747246,
-0.0072788395918905735,
-0.5536631345748901,
0.0613328292965889,
0.5441861748695374,
0.10405358672142029,
0.03622513264417648,
0.4882889986038208,
0.5617672204971313,
-0.25667428970336914,
-0.7213142514228821,
0.03954659402370453,
0.5334303379058838,
0.013284788466989994,
0.05583130940794945,
0.4130833148956299,
-0.3087227940559387,
0.6201484799385071,
0.5698779821395874,
0.16748586297035217,
0.8893743753433228,
-0.8755955100059509,
0.4925704002380371,
0.1685580462217331,
-0.28093448281288147,
-0.051200732588768005,
0.4194384813308716,
-0.1585427224636078,
-0.17937597632408142,
0.3826972246170044,
-0.2007446140050888,
-0.30555805563926697,
0.4828559160232544,
0.6819378733634949,
0.5576534867286682,
-0.2533407509326935,
0.3676622211933136,
0.4311639964580536,
-0.10609769821166992,
-0.2880076467990875,
0.29252180457115173,
-0.20709769427776337,
-0.4910893440246582,
-0.741096019744873,
-0.5479974150657654,
-0.35458067059516907,
-0.030096156522631645,
-0.7326465249061584,
0.12170396000146866,
-0.20338530838489532,
-0.31369084119796753,
0.8057435750961304,
0.3779630959033966,
-0.3789767920970917,
0.20781102776527405,
-0.06766416877508163,
0.704782247543335,
-1.0979068279266357,
0.7368964552879333,
0.8714806437492371,
-0.5478543043136597,
-0.1394050121307373,
-0.4414360225200653,
-0.18173591792583466,
-0.16761739552021027,
0.8810945749282837,
0.08831378817558289,
0.1427639126777649,
-0.05302516743540764,
-0.39496996998786926,
-0.9325774312019348,
0.9390754699707031,
0.2896557152271271,
-0.46243950724601746,
0.11079184710979462,
0.22323650121688843,
0.7249675989151001,
-0.6033924221992493,
0.13933010399341583,
0.8207826018333435,
0.6129246354103088,
0.3096984028816223,
-0.6201096177101135,
0.3420048654079437,
-0.4966067969799042,
0.0006443005404435098,
0.05648970976471901,
0.06758962571620941,
0.4490461051464081,
0.021734291687607765,
-0.27273884415626526,
0.18633615970611572,
0.8664329051971436,
0.42081376910209656,
0.46633437275886536,
0.4300258457660675,
0.3169923424720764,
1.0939949750900269,
-0.028009919449687004,
0.8100547790527344,
0.06967122107744217,
0.18143559992313385,
1.1663157939910889,
-0.556857705116272,
0.5016069412231445,
0.652114748954773,
-0.05195925012230873,
0.3963385224342346,
0.8038551211357117,
-0.3800226151943207,
0.7455167770385742,
0.21279606223106384,
-0.31200796365737915,
-0.13010729849338531,
-0.242306649684906,
-0.16481682658195496,
0.045200418680906296,
0.6175671219825745,
-0.7688725590705872,
-0.03260678052902222,
0.34427523612976074,
-0.1014094352722168,
-0.06352788209915161,
-0.23592114448547363,
0.7770676612854004,
-0.06343643367290497,
-0.8662152886390686,
0.3021184206008911,
-0.16678625345230103,
0.19739164412021637,
-0.127517431974411,
-0.5670710206031799,
0.4573825001716614,
0.08795249462127686,
-0.41306477785110474,
-0.9873372316360474,
0.5385345816612244,
0.009369212202727795,
-0.5471136569976807,
-0.3785386085510254,
0.9613344073295593,
-0.5934938192367554,
-0.6719330549240112,
-0.20110243558883667,
0.28406086564064026,
0.4733113944530487,
-0.14092673361301422,
-0.551749050617218,
-0.04785729572176933,
-0.016723155975341797,
-0.23901861906051636,
-0.055066630244255066,
0.20751789212226868,
-0.21895736455917358,
0.24042315781116486,
0.8425572514533997,
0.3318682610988617,
0.05404329299926758,
-0.12949047982692719,
0.8383429646492004,
-0.6609066724777222,
-0.24319180846214294,
-0.6684632301330566,
0.547422468662262,
-0.6660895943641663,
-0.11065063625574112,
0.6914637684822083,
0.8913881182670593,
0.6671319007873535,
-0.37851330637931824,
0.9694442749023438,
-0.08674666285514832,
0.5149044990539551,
-0.7172713875770569,
0.1323258876800537,
-0.14444158971309662,
0.34116947650909424,
-0.34449103474617004,
-1.2373242378234863,
-0.49577024579048157,
0.6187896132469177,
-0.4203701913356781,
-0.1343393474817276,
0.7624718546867371,
0.9148930311203003,
-0.1450394093990326,
0.2415965348482132,
-0.23226843774318695,
0.053558893501758575,
0.4030078947544098,
-0.05297541618347168,
0.44002512097358704,
-0.5436927080154419,
0.05606145039200783,
-0.37886476516723633,
-0.19869276881217957,
-0.06122365593910217,
-0.9566614627838135,
-0.5404166579246521,
-0.5800170302391052,
-0.879633367061615,
-0.42282721400260925,
0.12663468718528748,
0.9271138906478882,
0.7695136070251465,
-0.8606163859367371,
0.2074931114912033,
-0.23762720823287964,
-0.1635352224111557,
-0.5008578300476074,
-0.3469778895378113,
0.4663982391357422,
-0.497662216424942,
-0.7852898240089417,
0.7667677402496338,
0.11840808391571045,
-0.09591305255889893,
0.09978330880403519,
0.28851526975631714,
-0.4550464451313019,
-0.16315360367298126,
0.49899911880493164,
0.42811229825019836,
-0.3804756999015808,
-0.34468361735343933,
0.07234340161085129,
0.4770350456237793,
0.3089461028575897,
1.0171549320220947,
-0.7188908457756042,
0.6936509609222412,
0.9068225622177124,
0.45064541697502136,
0.8962936401367188,
0.41631489992141724,
0.637866199016571,
-1.089133381843567,
-0.007735819090157747,
0.21561473608016968,
0.11142770946025848,
0.4433874189853668,
-0.7815757393836975,
0.772055983543396,
0.29888632893562317,
-0.5359581708908081,
-0.7710999846458435,
-0.02697993628680706,
-1.3511093854904175,
-0.3247906565666199,
1.047483205795288,
-0.1708752065896988,
-0.4106725752353668,
-0.19734901189804077,
-0.30195701122283936,
0.79803866147995,
-0.521584689617157,
0.6633157730102539,
0.6653459072113037,
-0.721608579158783,
0.012295819818973541,
-0.46096381545066833,
0.6359671950340271,
0.03321194276213646,
-0.8830119371414185,
0.06913017481565475,
0.7192732691764832,
0.2037222683429718,
0.667830228805542,
0.2060951441526413,
-0.15705054998397827,
0.005021171644330025,
-0.18962982296943665,
0.15541860461235046,
-0.2122294008731842,
-0.28964266180992126,
-0.1619112491607666,
0.2961532771587372,
-0.38186556100845337,
-0.2643849849700928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14591v1
|
Base of RoPE Bounds Context Length
| 2024-05-23T14:03:31 | 2024-05-23T14:03:31 |
Xin Men, Mingyu Xu, Bingning Wang, Qingyu Zhang, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Weipeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Position embedding is a core component of current Large Language Models
(LLMs). Rotary position embedding (RoPE), a technique that encodes the position
information with a rotation matrix, has been the de facto choice for position
embedding in many LLMs, such as the Llama series. RoPE has been further
utilized to extend long context capability, which is roughly based on adjusting
the \textit{base} parameter of RoPE to mitigate out-of-distribution (OOD)
problems in position embedding. However, in this paper, we find that LLMs may
obtain a superficial long-context ability based on the OOD theory. We revisit
the role of RoPE in LLMs and propose a novel property of long-term decay, we
derive that the \textit{base of RoPE bounds context length}: there is an
absolute lower bound for the base value to obtain certain context length
capability. Our work reveals the relationship between context length and RoPE
base both theoretically and empirically, which may shed light on future long
context training.
|
[
-0.37739598751068115,
-0.8919355869293213,
0.5732957720756531,
-0.00838492251932621,
-0.5078614354133606,
-0.05553531274199486,
-0.37456902861595154,
-0.5849733352661133,
0.3735645115375519,
0.4924056828022003,
-0.12375392019748688,
-0.46323099732398987,
-0.5691325068473816,
-0.21057896316051483,
-0.45305928587913513,
0.9036551117897034,
-0.11367201805114746,
-0.3632659912109375,
-0.24529674649238586,
-0.6980219483375549,
-0.6288292407989502,
-0.8532870411872864,
-0.11243293434381485,
-0.31304651498794556,
0.5561931729316711,
0.4131774604320526,
0.761729896068573,
0.7991812229156494,
0.3428348898887634,
0.13753139972686768,
-0.2441079467535019,
-0.23097634315490723,
-0.5317125916481018,
0.316356360912323,
-0.14054657518863678,
-0.6278300285339355,
-0.6200066208839417,
-0.1698586642742157,
0.8090169429779053,
1.0020191669464111,
-0.17841221392154694,
-0.15783478319644928,
-0.1370394378900528,
0.9005641341209412,
-0.592110812664032,
-0.29187241196632385,
-0.39451977610588074,
0.02880246751010418,
-0.5091955065727234,
-0.24753087759017944,
-0.3806847333908081,
0.1360391229391098,
0.21444344520568848,
-0.1732645332813263,
0.03894142806529999,
0.07300940901041031,
0.7249220013618469,
0.1830889880657196,
-0.8029573559761047,
-0.42981240153312683,
-0.5223564505577087,
0.9603057503700256,
-0.7022292017936707,
0.5438327789306641,
0.5535142421722412,
0.2835446298122406,
-0.19141288101673126,
-0.3148537278175354,
-0.38137292861938477,
-0.3663850426673889,
0.0831892192363739,
-0.2346583604812622,
0.4494898021221161,
0.136223703622818,
0.28910309076309204,
0.3474096655845642,
-0.13426299393177032,
0.2671251595020294,
-0.4641754925251007,
0.3282161056995392,
0.6134498119354248,
-0.032825592905282974,
0.3403500020503998,
-0.07707131654024124,
-0.44941583275794983,
-0.01958453841507435,
-1.2128554582595825,
0.28069326281547546,
0.25893527269363403,
0.02339751273393631,
-0.19012345373630524,
0.9388943314552307,
0.039045047014951706,
0.8848865628242493,
0.08483535796403885,
-0.4808257818222046,
0.12009996175765991,
0.1783062368631363,
-0.11499080806970596,
0.43786394596099854,
0.21065649390220642,
0.40646418929100037,
0.3174569606781006,
-0.08961450308561325,
-0.22699612379074097,
-0.21805691719055176,
0.15504878759384155,
-0.532878577709198,
0.4194600284099579,
0.03226643428206444,
-0.31011679768562317,
-0.05346629023551941,
0.3289047181606293,
-0.19309554994106293,
-0.22110585868358612,
-0.17934992909431458,
0.04560590535402298,
-0.4815720319747925,
-0.11642545461654663,
0.36995264887809753,
-0.21942521631717682,
0.41497093439102173,
0.06422832608222961,
-0.9105506539344788,
0.16061139106750488,
0.7367885708808899,
0.9246909618377686,
-0.3450876772403717,
-0.20357103645801544,
-0.5945649743080139,
0.4630090594291687,
-0.3241800367832184,
0.2548759877681732,
-0.49841636419296265,
-0.470919132232666,
0.23944978415966034,
0.006150135770440102,
0.28921249508857727,
-0.2494010478258133,
0.27672892808914185,
-0.8764463663101196,
-0.09388283640146255,
0.022308191284537315,
-0.5032494068145752,
-0.20601364970207214,
0.015778936445713043,
-0.559168815612793,
0.9454050064086914,
0.24159201979637146,
-0.6153658032417297,
0.3208814263343811,
-0.27015063166618347,
-0.5903471112251282,
-0.3099064528942108,
-0.16388030350208282,
-0.24172617495059967,
0.40023431181907654,
-0.10989495366811752,
0.3398139476776123,
-0.20953863859176636,
0.174094095826149,
-0.5206655263900757,
-0.5705901384353638,
0.40433570742607117,
-0.2836364209651947,
0.6564902067184448,
-0.09835811704397202,
-0.2825062870979309,
-0.33828818798065186,
-0.4842756390571594,
-0.07503476738929749,
-0.1036561131477356,
-0.637791097164154,
-0.7532645463943481,
0.27748870849609375,
-0.26385924220085144,
0.11828812211751938,
0.15135729312896729,
-0.3593396544456482,
0.4487136900424957,
-0.6178904175758362,
0.6896857023239136,
0.7248943448066711,
-0.0070607615634799,
0.716054379940033,
-0.2230800986289978,
0.5341067910194397,
-0.15183182060718536,
-0.198686882853508,
-0.27008000016212463,
-0.4469304084777832,
-0.7454640865325928,
-0.0784178152680397,
0.25448915362358093,
0.33246996998786926,
-0.3870808780193329,
0.6873177886009216,
-0.45511454343795776,
-0.13719989359378815,
0.11682763695716858,
0.1298879235982895,
0.17937767505645752,
0.3354235291481018,
0.4671704173088074,
-0.43733835220336914,
-0.46397116780281067,
-0.8115546703338623,
0.10566391795873642,
0.003453170880675316,
-0.10276781767606735,
0.0806259959936142,
0.4930257797241211,
-0.26872408390045166,
1.38494074344635,
-0.4789530038833618,
-0.3590136468410492,
-0.1778227537870407,
-0.33134323358535767,
0.65646892786026,
0.5004276037216187,
0.640473484992981,
-0.7159239053726196,
-0.3929276466369629,
-0.02305324748158455,
-0.8229247331619263,
0.177063450217247,
-0.058913473039865494,
-0.0927763357758522,
0.34189480543136597,
0.44893738627433777,
-0.6532723307609558,
0.6559589505195618,
0.7931998372077942,
-0.22861547768115997,
0.30207958817481995,
-0.27757877111434937,
-0.4157850742340088,
-0.7014008164405823,
-0.10735983401536942,
-0.2130996733903885,
-0.3045318126678467,
-0.44265204668045044,
0.06848900020122528,
0.24276293814182281,
0.06794363260269165,
-0.3612768352031708,
0.5150241255760193,
-0.6249334216117859,
-0.22364524006843567,
-0.3680044114589691,
0.4393359124660492,
-0.11683163046836853,
0.4409165382385254,
0.02779010310769081,
0.5209882259368896,
0.483183354139328,
-0.929699718952179,
0.08540757745504379,
0.16351597011089325,
-0.27553388476371765,
0.7583087682723999,
-0.8103179335594177,
0.20214927196502686,
-0.1817273199558258,
0.6404502391815186,
-0.9569559097290039,
-0.12718024849891663,
-0.012340818531811237,
-0.2620728313922882,
0.5390973091125488,
-0.48877426981925964,
0.07103057950735092,
-0.3287142515182495,
-0.6518547534942627,
0.7741571068763733,
0.6053065061569214,
-0.46580666303634644,
0.15564630925655365,
0.41391521692276,
0.13818509876728058,
-1.1515971422195435,
-0.9203174710273743,
0.09956289082765579,
-0.562448263168335,
-0.862269937992096,
0.803562343120575,
0.01042221114039421,
-0.2913469970226288,
-0.13336141407489777,
-0.38964614272117615,
-0.01568104512989521,
-0.08115722239017487,
0.2795705497264862,
-0.14906668663024902,
-0.541720449924469,
0.3952278792858124,
0.21011564135551453,
-0.08024395257234573,
0.0628272145986557,
-0.3273983299732208,
0.6194286346435547,
-0.2154940813779831,
-0.5592831373214722,
0.13759228587150574,
0.3707484006881714,
0.6449808478355408,
-0.11070061475038528,
0.7567082047462463,
0.008845857344567776,
-0.2676262855529785,
-0.33641716837882996,
-0.4159153699874878,
0.15388421714305878,
-0.5901614427566528,
0.25348106026649475,
-0.24337349832057953,
-0.8517662882804871,
0.468869686126709,
0.09587889164686203,
-0.2652931809425354,
0.38891518115997314,
0.18438991904258728,
-0.2969622313976288,
0.776145875453949,
0.8186330795288086,
-0.134144127368927,
0.6504291892051697,
-0.5632289052009583,
0.21325884759426117,
-1.264037013053894,
0.1301817148923874,
-0.24980853497982025,
-0.4924698770046234,
-0.47802144289016724,
-0.6191040873527527,
0.4123299717903137,
0.9584860801696777,
-0.49910038709640503,
0.35350924730300903,
-0.1909087747335434,
0.4343414306640625,
0.39548876881599426,
0.005647224839776754,
0.08455618470907211,
-0.1199689656496048,
-0.21898698806762695,
-0.04509158805012703,
-0.6420887112617493,
-0.5061364769935608,
0.836408793926239,
0.5134657025337219,
0.9665182828903198,
0.30559179186820984,
0.6089377403259277,
0.3490157723426819,
0.29279953241348267,
-1.012642502784729,
0.2877052128314972,
0.14347931742668152,
-0.4681718349456787,
-0.5554957389831543,
0.18705175817012787,
-1.0805087089538574,
-0.0894438624382019,
0.2936544716358185,
-0.7528191208839417,
0.1673165112733841,
0.06189941614866257,
0.025659609586000443,
0.34582698345184326,
-0.1955840289592743,
0.405865877866745,
-0.4903563857078552,
-0.26053586602211,
-0.18363413214683533,
-0.7995504140853882,
0.14252428710460663,
0.20150192081928253,
0.13955307006835938,
-0.13155891001224518,
-0.29781216382980347,
0.7971116900444031,
-0.5763037204742432,
0.9333609938621521,
-0.1474163979291916,
-0.46076083183288574,
0.508208155632019,
-0.028433071449398994,
0.734486997127533,
0.2718663513660431,
-0.08101329952478409,
0.16636763513088226,
-0.3580727279186249,
-0.4274914562702179,
-0.5811781883239746,
0.8043411374092102,
-0.6103283166885376,
-0.8655084371566772,
-0.44245225191116333,
-0.10884977877140045,
-0.2047937512397766,
0.09560420364141464,
0.19561921060085297,
0.5209951400756836,
-0.09356334060430527,
0.7568404078483582,
0.6182036399841309,
-0.34135702252388,
0.82481449842453,
0.14494863152503967,
-0.21983833611011505,
-0.4682445824146271,
0.472196102142334,
0.3415856957435608,
0.345442533493042,
0.3632311522960663,
0.1949242800474167,
-0.39487123489379883,
-0.5207230448722839,
-0.5187215209007263,
0.43785980343818665,
-1.0566866397857666,
-0.2581873834133148,
-0.15123194456100464,
-0.18533705174922943,
0.17975029349327087,
-0.8447978496551514,
-0.30253729224205017,
-0.5611674785614014,
-0.023267267271876335,
-0.35475656390190125,
0.439266562461853,
0.9020147919654846,
0.08358169347047806,
0.3703998029232025,
-0.7493022084236145,
0.08764132112264633,
0.2066413015127182,
0.4126274287700653,
0.14364111423492432,
-0.4994543492794037,
-0.5043947696685791,
0.30396419763565063,
-0.31320473551750183,
-0.9680848717689514,
0.2937108874320984,
0.29033154249191284,
0.6653029918670654,
0.5437092781066895,
0.13253723084926605,
0.6700024008750916,
-0.6491093039512634,
0.9562746286392212,
0.39479461312294006,
-1.061592698097229,
0.40574321150779724,
-0.4890816807746887,
0.26786237955093384,
0.12256920337677002,
0.40330350399017334,
-0.8395275473594666,
-0.21987396478652954,
-0.47356313467025757,
-1.1295835971832275,
0.4783490002155304,
0.04817423224449158,
0.5619244575500488,
-0.3195628821849823,
0.43312200903892517,
-0.05582659691572189,
0.1108064204454422,
-0.631868302822113,
-0.2460559457540512,
-0.15818153321743011,
0.05202583223581314,
-0.09743919223546982,
-0.560746431350708,
-0.19629593193531036,
-0.17725247144699097,
0.1807006448507309,
-0.21977859735488892,
0.5331111550331116,
0.1840590089559555,
-0.5637285113334656,
-0.17860528826713562,
0.07308296859264374,
1.0033496618270874,
1.2116974592208862,
-0.2601042091846466,
0.3085547983646393,
0.691609263420105,
-0.3274879455566406,
0.4082942306995392,
-0.6846914887428284,
0.061229407787323,
-0.006310358177870512,
0.6710854768753052,
0.5610727071762085,
0.3362610936164856,
-0.510886013507843,
0.4865925908088684,
0.6072215437889099,
0.2498897910118103,
-0.6647836565971375,
0.12560346722602844,
0.21399083733558655,
-0.032715123146772385,
0.8144282698631287,
-0.1636761873960495,
-0.21149848401546478,
-0.557911217212677,
0.3424539268016815,
0.32706543803215027,
-0.6261729001998901,
-0.40382206439971924,
0.4634738564491272,
0.17364412546157837,
-0.7268157005310059,
0.49694082140922546,
0.2597992718219757,
-0.4713188707828522,
0.7595399022102356,
0.6750237345695496,
0.39512428641319275,
-0.26567432284355164,
-0.07237225770950317,
0.26345881819725037,
-0.042495544999837875,
0.03294031694531441,
-0.11940009146928787,
-0.02566055953502655,
-0.7065261602401733,
-0.45804521441459656,
-0.5618460774421692,
-0.10100897401571274,
-0.13279308378696442,
-0.7299467921257019,
0.4123871624469757,
-0.37615716457366943,
-0.14531731605529785,
-0.6399582624435425,
-0.24719224870204926,
-0.32993730902671814,
0.16594788432121277,
0.15312933921813965,
0.757416307926178,
-0.09477976709604263,
1.2227529287338257,
0.441152960062027,
-0.11293623596429825,
-0.2233506739139557,
-0.06059833616018295,
-0.2755449712276459,
-0.6317311525344849,
1.1491241455078125,
0.6127684116363525,
-0.5914367437362671,
-0.289542555809021,
-0.45440107583999634,
-1.154530644416809,
1.3298308849334717,
0.2592368423938751,
-0.4121286869049072,
-0.12508705258369446,
0.2984316945075989,
0.607890784740448,
-0.515359103679657,
-0.058641593903303146,
0.13292460143566132,
0.2134360522031784,
-0.23411370813846588,
-0.9003830552101135,
0.04262905940413475,
0.2400256246328354,
0.3632674515247345,
0.2827259600162506,
-0.6492953300476074,
0.9095808863639832,
-0.1667034924030304,
-0.1726163625717163,
-0.058441370725631714,
0.7559241056442261,
0.3052813410758972,
0.05742810294032097,
0.541800320148468,
0.4028320908546448,
0.5587064027786255,
0.3093257248401642,
1.2253940105438232,
-0.4662548899650574,
0.6500456929206848,
0.8698221445083618,
-0.1396876871585846,
1.0956896543502808,
0.6749871373176575,
-0.0768645778298378,
0.8123790621757507,
0.3530561327934265,
0.6324387788772583,
0.6108790040016174,
0.5712342858314514,
-0.13451412320137024,
-0.0766267329454422,
0.10583870857954025,
-0.850458562374115,
0.40639206767082214,
0.6322197914123535,
-0.556424081325531,
-0.06260883063077927,
0.020847994834184647,
0.21485762298107147,
-0.022888856008648872,
-0.15509676933288574,
0.10885118693113327,
0.45197150111198425,
-0.5305914282798767,
1.1161813735961914,
0.2804783880710602,
0.8999210596084595,
-0.7036464810371399,
-0.04210629686713219,
-0.27397748827934265,
0.32892873883247375,
0.0680508241057396,
-0.9594526886940002,
0.40741756558418274,
-0.3889477849006653,
0.011543589644134045,
-0.3502764105796814,
0.576388418674469,
-0.2918827533721924,
0.010397670790553093,
0.5232723951339722,
0.16984570026397705,
-0.28348931670188904,
0.21086983382701874,
-0.27510377764701843,
0.05719307065010071,
-0.44364410638809204,
-0.7145395278930664,
0.29307326674461365,
0.5261756181716919,
-0.287565678358078,
0.7710716724395752,
0.39771077036857605,
-0.3337404727935791,
0.03892047330737114,
-0.447331964969635,
0.9037072658538818,
-0.9762064218521118,
-0.47819820046424866,
-0.9556670188903809,
0.5361724495887756,
-0.05159517750144005,
-0.5352970361709595,
0.624552845954895,
0.21847698092460632,
0.8366640210151672,
-0.22434814274311066,
0.4653574228286743,
-0.3511418402194977,
-0.03629510477185249,
-0.7830860614776611,
0.5550631284713745,
-0.4764879643917084,
0.3104040026664734,
-0.1259632259607315,
-1.06535804271698,
-0.34245139360427856,
0.9466829299926758,
-0.4502578377723694,
0.07364337146282196,
0.8548312783241272,
0.5204092860221863,
-0.20530767738819122,
-0.49658817052841187,
0.45085224509239197,
0.003918319474905729,
0.4051815867424011,
0.6545321941375732,
1.032883882522583,
-0.3202624022960663,
0.1878788322210312,
-0.23745134472846985,
0.11455260962247849,
-0.7084057331085205,
-1.0665764808654785,
-1.041569471359253,
-0.5980600714683533,
0.03195742517709732,
-0.3491266071796417,
0.085298091173172,
0.860062301158905,
0.9639737010002136,
-0.6785743236541748,
-0.5632622241973877,
-0.10867632925510406,
0.31923604011535645,
-0.17556872963905334,
-0.1913524568080902,
0.4666615426540375,
-0.06406247615814209,
-0.406355619430542,
0.6862896084785461,
0.4257561266422272,
0.04772072285413742,
-0.3051808476448059,
-0.5620311498641968,
-0.4402190148830414,
-0.02873978763818741,
0.9073300361633301,
0.3344530463218689,
-0.7329115271568298,
-0.8540217876434326,
0.025811240077018738,
-0.1828259378671646,
0.4015640318393707,
0.8462052345275879,
-0.6919521689414978,
0.02520304173231125,
0.6178067922592163,
0.48832419514656067,
0.6163150668144226,
0.0888044536113739,
0.9528468251228333,
-1.1877167224884033,
0.5156435966491699,
0.23226182162761688,
0.458266019821167,
0.25437143445014954,
-0.36184632778167725,
0.7379584908485413,
0.151291161775589,
-0.30646541714668274,
-0.8296124339103699,
0.5315710306167603,
-1.1548336744308472,
-0.20326653122901917,
1.3889081478118896,
-0.22018635272979736,
-0.2798951268196106,
-0.1484355479478836,
-0.3779701292514801,
0.09727546572685242,
-0.12741932272911072,
0.545476496219635,
0.7248091697692871,
-0.10663487762212753,
-0.0648997500538826,
-0.5278069972991943,
0.4119502604007721,
0.3347969651222229,
-0.23052331805229187,
-0.1745995581150055,
0.1988622099161148,
0.3466455340385437,
0.34002840518951416,
0.3810608386993408,
0.27474379539489746,
0.1019924208521843,
-0.32665079832077026,
-0.2373611330986023,
-0.092064268887043,
-0.4410203695297241,
-0.2511593997478485,
0.292936772108078,
0.3469371497631073,
0.06211875006556511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14577v1
|
Representation noising effectively prevents harmful fine-tuning on LLMs
| 2024-05-23T13:51:55 | 2024-05-23T13:51:55 |
Domenic Rosati, Jan Wehner, Kai Williams, Łukasz Bartoszcze, David Atanasov, Robie Gonzales, Subhabrata Majumdar, Carsten Maple, Hassan Sajjad, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Releasing open-source large language models (LLMs) presents a dual-use risk
since bad actors can easily fine-tune these models for harmful purposes. Even
without the open release of weights, weight stealing and fine-tuning APIs make
closed models vulnerable to harmful fine-tuning attacks (HFAs). While safety
measures like preventing jailbreaks and improving safety guardrails are
important, such measures can easily be reversed through fine-tuning. In this
work, we propose Representation Noising (RepNoise), a defence mechanism that is
effective even when attackers have access to the weights and the defender no
longer has any control. RepNoise works by removing information about harmful
representations such that it is difficult to recover them during fine-tuning.
Importantly, our defence is also able to generalize across different subsets of
harm that have not been seen during the defence process. Our method does not
degrade the general capability of LLMs and retains the ability to train the
model on harmless tasks. We provide empirical evidence that the effectiveness
of our defence lies in its "depth": the degree to which information about
harmful representations is removed across all layers of the LLM.
|
[
-0.3503744602203369,
-0.3363822400569916,
0.17744021117687225,
-0.14469501376152039,
-0.44420790672302246,
-0.003933700267225504,
-0.39138221740722656,
-0.4842154383659363,
0.0695309266448021,
0.9719802737236023,
-0.2560475170612335,
-0.6859743595123291,
-0.676345705986023,
-0.034288208931684494,
-0.36690494418144226,
0.980811357498169,
-0.08031504601240158,
0.010427333414554596,
-0.15097948908805847,
-0.37030094861984253,
-0.47575029730796814,
-0.6639924049377441,
-0.7895344495773315,
-0.2718042731285095,
0.7234985828399658,
0.4080379903316498,
0.5215039849281311,
0.6369436383247375,
0.5398777723312378,
0.2729202210903168,
0.02189107984304428,
-0.055777426809072495,
-0.865411102771759,
0.5291850566864014,
-0.2887609601020813,
-0.7646434903144836,
-0.2971836030483246,
0.01324990764260292,
0.7071608304977417,
0.43660596013069153,
-0.003949304111301899,
-0.01803634501993656,
0.03269955515861511,
0.7744864821434021,
-0.9640016555786133,
-0.1219564899802208,
-0.9946441650390625,
-0.00530375586822629,
-0.2094772607088089,
-0.05292756110429764,
-0.6900388598442078,
-0.0026201927103102207,
-0.4859488308429718,
-0.6563263535499573,
-0.0795779600739479,
-0.15947923064231873,
0.9016557335853577,
0.5279710292816162,
-0.15629255771636963,
0.208140566945076,
-0.6495206952095032,
0.8577983379364014,
-0.8914621472358704,
0.1608021855354309,
0.38185426592826843,
0.37373751401901245,
-0.28274452686309814,
-0.22159402072429657,
-0.12895002961158752,
-0.4639594852924347,
-0.08739624917507172,
-0.12980543076992035,
-0.454917848110199,
0.3030361533164978,
0.5350925922393799,
0.05204348638653755,
-0.26022008061408997,
0.447216272354126,
-0.2947652339935303,
-0.5485889315605164,
0.6486870646476746,
-0.09024273604154587,
0.5868686437606812,
-0.08735670894384384,
-0.38655105233192444,
-0.1882079839706421,
-1.1779273748397827,
-0.2768573760986328,
0.6007694005966187,
0.48098501563072205,
-0.1170421615242958,
0.6953725218772888,
-0.07137192785739899,
0.42494380474090576,
0.04618401452898979,
0.10371054708957672,
-0.05120186135172844,
0.05804002657532692,
-0.2808276116847992,
0.11995470523834229,
0.7601610422134399,
0.4312967360019684,
0.5185407996177673,
-0.46768054366111755,
-0.4499223232269287,
0.318303644657135,
0.5634925961494446,
-0.8191461563110352,
0.05308637395501137,
0.10451813787221909,
-0.1934102475643158,
-0.45570406317710876,
0.010360528714954853,
-0.6784916520118713,
-0.7224397659301758,
-0.033451274037361145,
0.45693057775497437,
-0.48956552147865295,
-0.46046286821365356,
0.22218790650367737,
-0.1875011920928955,
0.17240014672279358,
0.12253511697053909,
-0.8471757173538208,
0.46438848972320557,
0.8502421379089355,
0.674475908279419,
0.0861244797706604,
0.011839753948152065,
-0.7351740002632141,
0.37662458419799805,
-0.5689717531204224,
0.4867021441459656,
-0.384182333946228,
-0.3573703169822693,
-0.17495892941951752,
-0.018191877752542496,
0.2544804811477661,
-0.7983832359313965,
0.5243365168571472,
-0.5305279493331909,
-0.1906990259885788,
-0.21616406738758087,
-0.3666749894618988,
0.0959855169057846,
0.35343605279922485,
-0.8336858749389648,
0.5453661680221558,
0.050884444266557693,
-0.7034256458282471,
0.33831092715263367,
-0.236028254032135,
-0.4638371467590332,
-0.28721755743026733,
-0.28560692071914673,
-0.6660722494125366,
0.37498486042022705,
0.12420135736465454,
0.3436518907546997,
0.16511499881744385,
-0.002581261331215501,
-0.5479027628898621,
-0.382307231426239,
-0.12711201608181,
-0.2007649838924408,
0.5291683673858643,
0.26357677578926086,
-0.2754662036895752,
0.37185385823249817,
-0.5675808787345886,
-0.1989457905292511,
0.16633747518062592,
-0.17915977537631989,
-0.7113708257675171,
-0.2373349964618683,
-0.5413379073143005,
0.101024329662323,
0.3058170676231384,
-0.8151467442512512,
0.348222017288208,
-0.7562755942344666,
0.4895528554916382,
0.9427675604820251,
0.14353208243846893,
0.7651697397232056,
-0.35058292746543884,
0.5631716847419739,
-0.08582010865211487,
0.06844080239534378,
-0.04933999478816986,
-0.27079030871391296,
-0.4632109999656677,
-0.3593285381793976,
0.393489271402359,
0.25283369421958923,
-0.8315908312797546,
0.11708086729049683,
-0.11185533553361893,
-0.4758106768131256,
-0.5523026585578918,
0.15607815980911255,
0.6650965809822083,
0.23719920217990875,
0.21620047092437744,
-0.17955368757247925,
-0.6646246910095215,
-1.0310828685760498,
-0.6425004005432129,
-0.13452500104904175,
0.016975749284029007,
0.06462322175502777,
0.43415001034736633,
-0.14146791398525238,
0.45009860396385193,
-0.2076234221458435,
-0.23387642204761505,
-0.03439164534211159,
0.15590578317642212,
-0.14387039840221405,
0.5926317572593689,
0.775795042514801,
-0.48215043544769287,
-0.29259994626045227,
0.029371848329901695,
-0.8340389132499695,
-0.2278890460729599,
-0.20671041309833527,
-0.17528940737247467,
0.32581642270088196,
0.5229410529136658,
-0.7285882234573364,
0.5211085677146912,
0.350288063287735,
-0.12916775047779083,
0.6428742408752441,
-0.1564214527606964,
-0.17705535888671875,
-0.7445840835571289,
0.050693873316049576,
-0.09132690727710724,
-0.4164202809333801,
-0.4991350769996643,
0.5827974677085876,
0.1384855955839157,
-0.39175137877464294,
-0.4306432902812958,
0.6907919049263,
-0.34089213609695435,
0.1150413528084755,
-0.2922702431678772,
0.07536563277244568,
0.10270702838897705,
0.3275201916694641,
-0.19146102666854858,
0.6671648025512695,
0.5293391346931458,
-0.5392009019851685,
-0.10861904174089432,
-0.17124834656715393,
-0.24665187299251556,
0.4831484258174896,
-0.7048598527908325,
0.11799084395170212,
-0.12907348573207855,
-0.2614549696445465,
-0.9475865364074707,
-0.08543354272842407,
0.5763872265815735,
-0.389320969581604,
0.7120000123977661,
-0.4848547875881195,
-0.36533957719802856,
-0.18909043073654175,
-0.47752121090888977,
0.20193414390087128,
0.2974631190299988,
-0.3944254517555237,
0.4091232717037201,
0.4445361793041229,
0.11578930914402008,
-0.8662300705909729,
-0.9961535930633545,
0.30373403429985046,
-0.394203782081604,
-0.544188380241394,
0.3838040232658386,
0.11525829881429672,
-0.3018271028995514,
0.07969335466623306,
-0.5849603414535522,
0.17376786470413208,
0.45523613691329956,
0.33213484287261963,
0.004123235587030649,
-0.0732182115316391,
0.19788363575935364,
-0.00938014592975378,
-0.3581605553627014,
0.1885293424129486,
-0.2052025943994522,
0.47640785574913025,
0.22637295722961426,
-0.7113097310066223,
-0.502617597579956,
0.2770281136035919,
0.7365114688873291,
-0.21446345746517181,
0.8370286226272583,
0.31823375821113586,
-0.37819185853004456,
-0.24565881490707397,
-0.4602143466472626,
-0.39807555079460144,
-0.4855912923812866,
0.40210890769958496,
-0.17159922420978546,
-1.1560547351837158,
0.46381980180740356,
-0.10183164477348328,
0.18768875300884247,
0.30124354362487793,
0.30611997842788696,
0.05324864387512207,
0.912121593952179,
0.644788384437561,
-0.37357017397880554,
0.6942800283432007,
-0.2442854940891266,
0.17514492571353912,
-0.7622031569480896,
-0.08300016075372696,
-0.5459806323051453,
-0.531254768371582,
-0.5570144653320312,
-0.09407078474760056,
0.14317190647125244,
0.48856186866760254,
-0.35629531741142273,
0.5941779017448425,
-0.6697709560394287,
0.5007421374320984,
0.33629971742630005,
0.19778645038604736,
0.16137151420116425,
0.2724774479866028,
-0.11354148387908936,
-0.10725366324186325,
-0.33389273285865784,
-0.6165983080863953,
1.2784532308578491,
0.4135204553604126,
0.9818945527076721,
0.2517628073692322,
1.2457603216171265,
0.21731111407279968,
0.2528701424598694,
-0.7841333150863647,
0.6463976502418518,
-0.1762169450521469,
-0.5175328254699707,
-0.3896106779575348,
-0.7806782126426697,
-1.057243824005127,
0.26870590448379517,
-0.18231432139873505,
-0.7750130295753479,
0.2455737292766571,
0.1821761429309845,
-0.3247573673725128,
0.6925734281539917,
-0.7026692628860474,
0.7317261695861816,
-0.092086561024189,
-0.43712282180786133,
-0.4303237795829773,
-0.26418647170066833,
0.3931903839111328,
0.13505905866622925,
0.17302264273166656,
-0.07889237254858017,
-0.1650332808494568,
0.8275467157363892,
-0.08871868997812271,
1.2378227710723877,
-0.4569203853607178,
-0.3344491422176361,
0.22769393026828766,
0.5483695864677429,
0.6349112391471863,
0.0748789981007576,
-0.14727739989757538,
0.22493577003479004,
0.01265980489552021,
-0.47737929224967957,
-0.8260750770568848,
0.7616689801216125,
-0.8001527190208435,
-1.064234972000122,
-0.2746438682079315,
-0.4149329960346222,
0.059036049991846085,
0.5914766788482666,
0.108070008456707,
0.16505981981754303,
-0.28646358847618103,
0.18898524343967438,
0.7551867365837097,
-0.2930952310562134,
0.305585116147995,
0.6855190992355347,
-0.1964125782251358,
-0.6254189014434814,
0.9757919907569885,
0.29667380452156067,
0.5411642789840698,
0.23808932304382324,
0.129254549741745,
-0.034434154629707336,
-0.7269190549850464,
-0.042407505214214325,
0.3038792312145233,
-0.4561298191547394,
-0.4945314824581146,
-0.30846893787384033,
-0.1408008486032486,
-0.43549177050590515,
0.09687507897615433,
-0.4159446060657501,
-0.7417435050010681,
-0.045305896550416946,
-0.18864479660987854,
0.208505317568779,
0.925391435623169,
-0.49778124690055847,
0.2818445563316345,
-0.3675472140312195,
0.4247640371322632,
0.23502704501152039,
0.4635402262210846,
0.002616734243929386,
-0.5717073678970337,
-0.25740304589271545,
0.14242231845855713,
-0.4208483397960663,
-0.6059013605117798,
0.26146796345710754,
-0.07899200171232224,
0.6673202514648438,
0.5101562142372131,
0.32582607865333557,
0.3714454472064972,
-0.40665924549102783,
0.42315229773521423,
0.24995626509189606,
-0.6848609447479248,
0.3127339482307434,
-0.3752184808254242,
0.171404168009758,
0.49225103855133057,
0.2021511048078537,
-0.6154547333717346,
-0.496577650308609,
-0.4601254165172577,
-0.8355631828308105,
0.5713256597518921,
-0.009346410632133484,
0.3542861342430115,
-0.14617213606834412,
0.6105750799179077,
-0.11411256343126297,
0.36890852451324463,
-0.712415874004364,
-0.02150609716773033,
-0.2742503583431244,
0.1585463434457779,
0.044857192784547806,
-0.4150697886943817,
-0.36492833495140076,
-0.1975480616092682,
0.6186239123344421,
0.13272687792778015,
0.06297179311513901,
0.10490583628416061,
-0.14044155180454254,
-0.3408019542694092,
0.4397919178009033,
0.5911304950714111,
0.1199963241815567,
-0.20383356511592865,
0.3856908977031708,
-0.07916269451379776,
-0.2634955644607544,
0.38078057765960693,
-0.31725814938545227,
-0.28886592388153076,
-0.3624601662158966,
0.6436127424240112,
0.6427561640739441,
0.46302348375320435,
-0.5169472098350525,
0.4164200723171234,
-0.0013523271773010492,
-0.2506452798843384,
0.060793060809373856,
0.27071288228034973,
0.014767239801585674,
-0.07576213032007217,
-0.093488909304142,
0.5014785528182983,
-0.24382330477237701,
-0.5026941895484924,
0.4822463393211365,
0.6450596451759338,
-0.529351532459259,
-0.2825733423233032,
0.4636608362197876,
-0.0774705708026886,
-0.24199527502059937,
0.23111629486083984,
-0.26413410902023315,
-0.3251417875289917,
0.6193884015083313,
0.5365650653839111,
0.795184314250946,
-0.34005582332611084,
0.16007834672927856,
0.4564431309700012,
0.7212973237037659,
-0.1718704253435135,
0.11856088042259216,
0.22480285167694092,
-0.7450401782989502,
-0.491110235452652,
-0.40348660945892334,
-0.22454802691936493,
0.3027922511100769,
-0.7943716049194336,
-0.01729162596166134,
-1.0208457708358765,
-0.23761413991451263,
-0.38445138931274414,
-0.13222293555736542,
-0.23483937978744507,
-0.23174794018268585,
0.34764784574508667,
0.9185462594032288,
-0.6762639284133911,
0.6773451566696167,
0.4485752284526825,
-0.5497618317604065,
-0.5033774971961975,
-0.05146109685301781,
-0.023104360327124596,
-0.7191840410232544,
0.4816770851612091,
0.18006442487239838,
-0.16952534019947052,
-0.24918608367443085,
-0.8638975024223328,
-0.8601154685020447,
0.6017399430274963,
1.2652872800827026,
-0.7674803137779236,
0.08821403980255127,
0.3009576201438904,
0.5313451886177063,
-0.1328350454568863,
-0.26050087809562683,
0.4409102499485016,
0.5970747470855713,
-0.1448553204536438,
-0.5928664207458496,
0.30284997820854187,
-0.09034869819879532,
-0.1977345198392868,
0.34625181555747986,
-0.6384721398353577,
0.8603928685188293,
-0.25789645314216614,
-0.6988617777824402,
0.21758684515953064,
0.3127783536911011,
0.07179857790470123,
-0.09995359182357788,
0.414736270904541,
1.0171658992767334,
0.8600807785987854,
-0.06978895515203476,
1.1071257591247559,
-0.22416895627975464,
0.08622940629720688,
1.3716869354248047,
-0.3040340542793274,
0.8251350522041321,
0.49127691984176636,
0.18397000432014465,
0.40617167949676514,
0.2297506034374237,
-0.019564496353268623,
0.770343542098999,
0.5338510870933533,
-0.08962959051132202,
-0.4025510251522064,
-0.14188729226589203,
-0.2884575426578522,
0.2569952607154846,
0.19530744850635529,
-0.1891104280948639,
-0.5790264010429382,
0.01707358844578266,
0.2439441829919815,
0.49335992336273193,
-0.4126630425453186,
0.9943605065345764,
0.40058770775794983,
-0.328794926404953,
1.0055210590362549,
-0.0789625272154808,
0.5878272652626038,
-0.5828658938407898,
-0.0467381589114666,
-0.10920711606740952,
0.10378574579954147,
-0.29149144887924194,
-0.6058303117752075,
0.5898972749710083,
-0.20974388718605042,
-0.16400884091854095,
-0.0938149020075798,
0.8946014046669006,
-0.2997632622718811,
-0.2115240842103958,
0.8177666664123535,
0.1487579196691513,
-0.19786418974399567,
-0.485563725233078,
-0.6630937457084656,
0.23353691399097443,
-0.16718660295009613,
-0.022095588967204094,
0.7003045678138733,
0.6139256954193115,
-0.18280555307865143,
0.7967585921287537,
0.4368218779563904,
0.33705905079841614,
-0.03568829968571663,
0.19553442299365997,
1.1614031791687012,
-0.5131072998046875,
-0.13995647430419922,
-1.169025182723999,
0.36123839020729065,
-0.19949199259281158,
0.17382775247097015,
0.951468288898468,
0.41485607624053955,
0.9215893149375916,
0.1726362407207489,
0.7929861545562744,
0.3837904930114746,
0.14373737573623657,
-0.4179903566837311,
1.09326171875,
-0.5376590490341187,
0.38065457344055176,
-0.29689911007881165,
-0.4836815893650055,
-0.4678049683570862,
0.36453941464424133,
-0.6547001600265503,
-0.30457618832588196,
0.3563250005245209,
0.9961662888526917,
-0.06265415251255035,
-0.30202245712280273,
0.6277242302894592,
0.45356738567352295,
0.3903788924217224,
0.49990731477737427,
0.7299727201461792,
-0.39374300837516785,
0.6659423112869263,
-0.32804322242736816,
-0.16790926456451416,
0.025552738457918167,
-0.8441537618637085,
-1.2979625463485718,
-0.14487487077713013,
-0.102103091776371,
-0.4244157671928406,
0.22801557183265686,
0.5003993511199951,
0.8422152996063232,
-0.9491117000579834,
-0.16450199484825134,
0.04705103859305382,
0.3602662980556488,
-0.20851314067840576,
-0.15267524123191833,
0.057508233934640884,
-0.5440785884857178,
-0.027385437861084938,
0.5082180500030518,
0.32823699712753296,
-0.024026278406381607,
-0.4875407814979553,
-0.07443799078464508,
-0.05495995283126831,
-0.009763887152075768,
0.4006496071815491,
0.48422035574913025,
-0.6900124549865723,
-0.5411641597747803,
-0.4152943789958954,
-0.16362915933132172,
0.19110871851444244,
0.7984528541564941,
-0.6288687586784363,
0.5024538040161133,
0.3774312138557434,
0.8091554641723633,
0.20602089166641235,
-0.26502811908721924,
0.7523730993270874,
-1.0330489873886108,
0.5095837116241455,
0.1917894184589386,
0.4504598379135132,
0.3968394696712494,
-0.624261200428009,
0.4952183663845062,
0.04927333816885948,
-0.25590142607688904,
-0.9904116988182068,
0.4202835261821747,
-0.46638134121894836,
-0.4308752119541168,
0.8789228200912476,
-0.28355222940444946,
-0.5494551062583923,
0.02346179634332657,
-0.3356610834598541,
0.29318496584892273,
-0.7070484757423401,
1.0091804265975952,
0.5670369267463684,
0.4137614071369171,
-0.13926850259304047,
-0.417925626039505,
0.5539906620979309,
0.3734931945800781,
-0.4872380793094635,
0.45750609040260315,
0.17464882135391235,
0.4113563299179077,
0.21661841869354248,
0.2889319360256195,
-0.3935557007789612,
0.009509383700788021,
-0.09309626370668411,
0.16135776042938232,
-0.42788165807724,
-0.4377862811088562,
-0.5919181704521179,
0.27790504693984985,
0.22184988856315613,
-0.0710049420595169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14555v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14555v4
|
Subtle Biases Need Subtler Measures: Dual Metrics for Evaluating Representative and Affinity Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T13:35:34 | 2024-06-03T16:43:16 |
Abhishek Kumar, Sarfaroz Yunusov, Ali Emami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Research on Large Language Models (LLMs) has often neglected subtle biases
that, although less apparent, can significantly influence the models' outputs
toward particular social narratives. This study addresses two such biases
within LLMs: representative bias, which denotes a tendency of LLMs to generate
outputs that mirror the experiences of certain identity groups, and affinity
bias, reflecting the models' evaluative preferences for specific narratives or
viewpoints. We introduce two novel metrics to measure these biases: the
Representative Bias Score (RBS) and the Affinity Bias Score (ABS), and present
the Creativity-Oriented Generation Suite (CoGS), a collection of open-ended
tasks such as short story writing and poetry composition, designed with
customized rubrics to detect these subtle biases. Our analysis uncovers marked
representative biases in prominent LLMs, with a preference for identities
associated with being white, straight, and men. Furthermore, our investigation
of affinity bias reveals distinctive evaluative patterns within each model,
akin to `bias fingerprints'. This trend is also seen in human evaluators,
highlighting a complex interplay between human and machine bias perceptions.
|
[
-0.6144852638244629,
-0.4153203070163727,
0.5635231733322144,
0.05867679417133331,
-0.16649781167507172,
0.386588454246521,
-0.5272464156150818,
-0.4272451400756836,
0.3223375976085663,
0.40709930658340454,
-0.5717694163322449,
-0.47293511033058167,
-0.4794548749923706,
-0.12266319990158081,
-0.2146688550710678,
1.0695061683654785,
-0.04573657363653183,
0.14113624393939972,
-0.23094618320465088,
-0.39837539196014404,
-0.34712710976600647,
-0.12119371443986893,
-0.31986507773399353,
-0.43647444248199463,
1.0596250295639038,
0.2695663869380951,
0.6739057302474976,
0.45374879240989685,
0.39042845368385315,
0.10497808456420898,
0.085683174431324,
0.10650883615016937,
-0.44211333990097046,
0.10557279735803604,
-0.4073929786682129,
-0.4385600984096527,
-0.3020019233226776,
0.4382314682006836,
0.618463397026062,
0.8058825731277466,
0.5847828984260559,
0.763169527053833,
0.3038022220134735,
0.818641722202301,
-0.7021161317825317,
-0.12238264083862305,
-0.5017674565315247,
0.028827432543039322,
-0.4194638729095459,
0.07205916941165924,
-0.2289806753396988,
-0.520786702632904,
0.2261812686920166,
0.020226823166012764,
0.46128779649734497,
0.19465197622776031,
0.6243253350257874,
0.04677077382802963,
-0.45387667417526245,
-0.36101868748664856,
-0.6092215776443481,
1.1403276920318604,
-0.5854508280754089,
0.07547906786203384,
-0.14677757024765015,
0.23994366824626923,
0.17322227358818054,
-0.3953668475151062,
-0.3463132381439209,
-0.2782384753227234,
0.03519895672798157,
-0.00282673561014235,
-0.08386281877756119,
-0.26283538341522217,
0.2912599444389343,
0.39086052775382996,
-0.4709397256374359,
0.3713853061199188,
-0.06518707424402237,
-0.22598321735858917,
1.0139480829238892,
0.3304242193698883,
0.2842126488685608,
0.013948171399533749,
-0.2708907127380371,
0.03583143651485443,
-0.887877345085144,
0.23358294367790222,
1.0109527111053467,
0.34946170449256897,
-0.34667491912841797,
0.6102798581123352,
-0.072308748960495,
0.524341881275177,
0.14789056777954102,
0.023084647953510284,
0.10013886541128159,
-0.2672105133533478,
0.2994074821472168,
0.04813627526164055,
0.9658005833625793,
0.2774432897567749,
0.46869418025016785,
-0.13606320321559906,
-0.298308789730072,
0.30018147826194763,
0.1677824705839157,
-0.5520418286323547,
0.022261185571551323,
0.13961289823055267,
-0.5748172402381897,
-0.3826271891593933,
0.26290571689605713,
-0.917330265045166,
-0.7832570672035217,
-0.3219434916973114,
0.1501968502998352,
0.09885630756616592,
-0.3250446319580078,
-0.29018276929855347,
-0.5098218321800232,
0.27972185611724854,
0.06201644241809845,
-0.7816234230995178,
0.16736026108264923,
0.8263483643531799,
0.6048187613487244,
-0.5265451073646545,
-0.144502192735672,
-0.46852266788482666,
-0.07793573290109634,
-0.42762452363967896,
0.6370154023170471,
-0.7329378724098206,
-0.05730981379747391,
-0.020755434408783913,
-0.43689340353012085,
0.30061590671539307,
-0.5447996258735657,
0.5266551375389099,
-0.21067486703395844,
0.23479335010051727,
-0.6613187193870544,
-0.39703068137168884,
0.05796376243233681,
-0.004929645918309689,
-0.7102680206298828,
0.9000471830368042,
0.31957703828811646,
-0.9799311757087708,
0.664930522441864,
-0.3893434703350067,
-0.13477350771427155,
-0.04237359017133713,
-0.6409810185432434,
-0.39911726117134094,
0.5454098582267761,
-0.014648842625319958,
0.38957610726356506,
-0.6294994950294495,
0.45087507367134094,
-0.5586360096931458,
-0.5058557391166687,
0.5555214285850525,
-0.325121134519577,
0.6332060694694519,
0.10206222534179688,
-0.6169751882553101,
0.2708704173564911,
-0.7347249984741211,
-0.09900917857885361,
0.17264486849308014,
-0.2106713056564331,
-0.38539180159568787,
-0.04717132821679115,
-0.17566098272800446,
0.058556124567985535,
0.4203563630580902,
-0.4114348292350769,
-0.030883198603987694,
-0.16799615323543549,
0.04531775787472725,
0.9065538644790649,
-0.12412940710783005,
0.7530942559242249,
-0.5312293767929077,
0.5757278203964233,
-0.02714039757847786,
-0.14958979189395905,
0.05911274999380112,
-0.3631548583507538,
-0.740933358669281,
-0.29750683903694153,
0.13558562099933624,
-0.02212122268974781,
-0.3203992247581482,
0.7196305990219116,
-0.25736650824546814,
-0.7813289761543274,
-0.7241495251655579,
0.3214821517467499,
0.35769152641296387,
0.13262686133384705,
-0.08387868851423264,
-0.5920369029045105,
-0.2845512330532074,
-1.0968542098999023,
-1.1550339460372925,
-0.008569051511585712,
-0.340236634016037,
0.5550923347473145,
0.3737941384315491,
-0.12606129050254822,
1.1101714372634888,
-0.3154512643814087,
-0.26578289270401,
-0.5616235136985779,
0.27382296323776245,
0.15719085931777954,
0.03154516965150833,
0.6227794885635376,
-0.4392988979816437,
-0.5801754593849182,
-0.27585458755493164,
-0.33140161633491516,
-0.7287331223487854,
-0.09559265524148941,
0.05991821736097336,
-0.006001447327435017,
-0.06531622260808945,
-0.32941189408302307,
0.22810125350952148,
0.661229133605957,
-0.598589301109314,
0.8353047966957092,
0.5111678242683411,
-0.20835624635219574,
-0.6145066618919373,
0.09463876485824585,
0.37321579456329346,
0.1480255126953125,
-0.2671082615852356,
-0.034843429923057556,
-0.055117443203926086,
0.369881272315979,
-0.3228352665901184,
0.9599801898002625,
-0.7889595031738281,
-0.27410343289375305,
-0.04052688553929329,
0.25488969683647156,
0.32037147879600525,
0.26459425687789917,
-0.1251281499862671,
0.5097828507423401,
0.23968124389648438,
-0.23114581406116486,
0.41771209239959717,
-0.2671339213848114,
-0.5817812085151672,
0.41120645403862,
-0.40517377853393555,
0.4498167634010315,
-0.15800423920154572,
0.056376006454229355,
-1.1275231838226318,
-0.1806967854499817,
0.043850596994161606,
-0.3913101851940155,
0.32039567828178406,
0.17865322530269623,
-0.2614969313144684,
-0.4099339246749878,
-0.7446866631507874,
0.3260433077812195,
0.5525916814804077,
-0.3999221622943878,
0.5326454639434814,
0.3504343032836914,
-0.20162703096866608,
-0.5902593731880188,
-0.6500839591026306,
-0.12593156099319458,
-0.5808758735656738,
-0.5987875461578369,
0.057334013283252716,
0.11071952432394028,
-0.6652669906616211,
-0.0710168182849884,
-0.07855673134326935,
0.17406117916107178,
-0.0797552838921547,
0.25340375304222107,
0.09475516527891159,
-0.14069445431232452,
-0.12474020570516586,
0.09521565586328506,
0.05933479964733124,
0.18628522753715515,
-0.07059077173471451,
0.7025987505912781,
-0.09909169375896454,
-0.5029088854789734,
-0.1307392418384552,
0.17213894426822662,
0.5151238441467285,
-0.3266828954219818,
0.5393226146697998,
0.9068205952644348,
0.11779291927814484,
-0.4644293189048767,
-0.949476420879364,
-0.3635551333427429,
-0.4080977141857147,
0.3405712842941284,
-0.12984922528266907,
-1.013351559638977,
0.773410975933075,
0.11108250170946121,
-0.04344753548502922,
0.429813027381897,
0.7616332173347473,
0.24157200753688812,
1.0375242233276367,
0.37605831027030945,
-0.2790338397026062,
0.4790983498096466,
-0.02661789022386074,
0.4911836087703705,
-1.1880826950073242,
0.018253089860081673,
-0.5400691032409668,
-0.7505918741226196,
-0.4567021429538727,
-0.2345760613679886,
0.27810409665107727,
-0.19520936906337738,
-0.24168947339057922,
-0.15030981600284576,
-0.6079055666923523,
0.35931089520454407,
0.6032569408416748,
-0.14701953530311584,
-0.01949205994606018,
-0.1229906901717186,
-0.2873741388320923,
-0.3625209927558899,
-0.49855300784111023,
-0.9776613712310791,
1.253275990486145,
0.6234558820724487,
0.8614886403083801,
-0.1653672605752945,
0.7290002703666687,
0.17524033784866333,
0.5945156812667847,
-0.7081717252731323,
0.5829254984855652,
-0.009506240487098694,
-0.61739182472229,
-0.3063124716281891,
-0.38322144746780396,
-0.6842801570892334,
0.12429637461900711,
0.06296356767416,
-0.7907995581626892,
0.1838977038860321,
0.10990998893976212,
-0.34252727031707764,
0.24804691970348358,
-0.5531533360481262,
0.8652183413505554,
-0.36328014731407166,
-0.8368416428565979,
0.0026915185153484344,
-0.43840959668159485,
0.5611196756362915,
-0.12312247604131699,
0.1271241158246994,
-0.36318862438201904,
-0.056311700493097305,
0.7191426753997803,
0.08826792985200882,
0.937218964099884,
-0.16241173446178436,
-0.14121541380882263,
0.40705984830856323,
0.2940930724143982,
0.47237929701805115,
-0.06336650252342224,
-0.22331516444683075,
0.2962871789932251,
-0.4062473773956299,
-0.15532267093658447,
-0.3659486770629883,
0.6981248259544373,
-0.6176037788391113,
-0.5500916838645935,
-0.33199986815452576,
-0.6465680599212646,
-0.10781824588775635,
0.04781777039170265,
0.3345089852809906,
0.0814228281378746,
-0.3979862630367279,
0.0540023073554039,
0.37915247678756714,
-0.4702751338481903,
0.1860491782426834,
0.42751345038414,
-0.1124076098203659,
-0.026815004646778107,
0.7582418918609619,
0.28198620676994324,
0.44049352407455444,
-0.00995483249425888,
0.5209565162658691,
-0.2571280598640442,
-0.40790119767189026,
-0.29273635149002075,
0.4576110541820526,
-0.34085312485694885,
-0.025767160579562187,
-0.4447762072086334,
-0.10614708811044693,
-0.36697614192962646,
-0.20349560678005219,
-0.3197683095932007,
-0.22039401531219482,
-0.33628907799720764,
0.01384972594678402,
-0.10793320834636688,
0.5977895259857178,
0.10105334967374802,
0.07234471291303635,
-0.4541461169719696,
0.3415907323360443,
0.3292219042778015,
0.3223345875740051,
0.24852660298347473,
-0.6021476984024048,
-0.2522985339164734,
0.007110606878995895,
-0.43937674164772034,
-0.7934756875038147,
0.33572202920913696,
-0.015169357880949974,
0.3642376959323883,
0.7756233811378479,
-0.045932576060295105,
0.21785429120063782,
-0.3833326995372772,
1.0389487743377686,
0.16435562074184418,
-0.8529987931251526,
0.2626120150089264,
-0.46864205598831177,
0.35706377029418945,
0.5360585451126099,
0.11858008056879044,
-0.5202080607414246,
-0.8433265686035156,
-0.5249248147010803,
-0.5228815078735352,
0.5702939629554749,
-0.2158987820148468,
0.355042040348053,
-0.056457825005054474,
0.1828874796628952,
0.44375404715538025,
0.3839735686779022,
-0.8053463697433472,
-0.14364919066429138,
0.3308543264865875,
-0.394971638917923,
0.16283299028873444,
-0.5531449913978577,
-0.2035813182592392,
-0.0730559229850769,
0.3851223289966583,
-0.20172302424907684,
-0.026301605626940727,
-0.04755537584424019,
0.192024827003479,
-0.37154823541641235,
0.4052508771419525,
0.2241600900888443,
0.6033534407615662,
-0.05757374316453934,
0.40805456042289734,
-0.045213066041469574,
-0.3732568323612213,
0.09730102866888046,
-0.37712565064430237,
-0.28123170137405396,
0.09837817400693893,
0.4582105576992035,
0.7329262495040894,
-0.20716804265975952,
-0.6341038942337036,
0.6565279960632324,
0.1341361403465271,
0.2331027388572693,
-0.31399407982826233,
0.3756406307220459,
0.21126297116279602,
0.2610304355621338,
0.22554710507392883,
0.02196752466261387,
0.10705098509788513,
-0.7341839671134949,
-0.27915582060813904,
0.7840529680252075,
-0.674609363079071,
-0.5944316387176514,
0.47424039244651794,
0.16791914403438568,
-0.264151006937027,
0.2224946916103363,
-0.36398836970329285,
-0.42246752977371216,
0.64767986536026,
0.2576446533203125,
1.2818641662597656,
-0.21515053510665894,
0.1594022512435913,
0.14227956533432007,
0.3091985285282135,
0.045530758798122406,
0.1494872272014618,
0.02192085050046444,
-0.8375179767608643,
-0.11565762758255005,
-0.8074142932891846,
-0.16381914913654327,
0.11078336834907532,
-0.7022686004638672,
0.5036962032318115,
-0.24693076312541962,
-0.21250927448272705,
0.1124047338962555,
0.002268893178552389,
-0.9249110817909241,
-0.04301265999674797,
0.4062332808971405,
0.7098891139030457,
-1.0187103748321533,
0.4192081093788147,
0.6221967339515686,
-0.11677676439285278,
-0.726590096950531,
0.052214425057172775,
0.19364216923713684,
-0.6399064660072327,
0.6854283809661865,
0.29847535490989685,
0.03001140058040619,
-0.3057226538658142,
-0.40781307220458984,
-0.6371157765388489,
0.8478834629058838,
0.4175560772418976,
-0.7429037094116211,
-0.03851849585771561,
0.479278564453125,
0.6280711889266968,
-0.6698386669158936,
0.3168617784976959,
1.0059010982513428,
0.5933213829994202,
-0.34814637899398804,
-0.7525503635406494,
0.035445790737867355,
0.11117356270551682,
-0.0006645333487540483,
0.12319125235080719,
-0.9347805976867676,
0.732810378074646,
-0.2627578675746918,
-0.18218232691287994,
-0.10403206199407578,
0.3032275438308716,
0.5116493701934814,
0.5282289385795593,
0.26682397723197937,
0.47266918420791626,
0.5320149660110474,
-0.2666967213153839,
1.05726158618927,
-0.23803219199180603,
0.13314825296401978,
1.023787021636963,
-0.6540016531944275,
0.2663221061229706,
0.7164896726608276,
-0.16195514798164368,
0.488722562789917,
0.4704165756702423,
-0.0002928289759438485,
0.3978041112422943,
0.638589084148407,
-0.45898833870887756,
-0.01926407217979431,
-0.37469422817230225,
-0.04625954106450081,
0.449970006942749,
0.22922179102897644,
-0.6124224662780762,
0.019764065742492676,
-0.2973179519176483,
0.05052372068166733,
0.19668559730052948,
-0.2511163055896759,
0.7991103529930115,
0.34856685996055603,
-0.7229065895080566,
-0.031846802681684494,
-0.119996078312397,
0.6925382018089294,
-0.5374454259872437,
0.22857792675495148,
-0.22594451904296875,
0.13090601563453674,
-0.3078993260860443,
-0.9476562142372131,
0.09360554069280624,
0.10303615033626556,
-0.27625295519828796,
-0.08946754038333893,
0.784949541091919,
-0.5382423996925354,
-0.49483534693717957,
0.36772286891937256,
0.6037600636482239,
-0.018982160836458206,
-0.198232963681221,
-0.48299968242645264,
0.34441155195236206,
0.0843089297413826,
-0.5192086100578308,
0.332825630903244,
0.47647973895072937,
-0.16734768450260162,
0.355450302362442,
0.4115596115589142,
0.5780653357505798,
0.15260133147239685,
0.4868520498275757,
0.696330189704895,
-0.6129242181777954,
-0.3582635819911957,
-1.0562313795089722,
0.5346679091453552,
-0.15176457166671753,
-0.2517620921134949,
0.9879293441772461,
0.7308461666107178,
0.6954215168952942,
-0.02147931046783924,
0.9987404942512512,
0.19875749945640564,
0.7334877252578735,
-0.1475147306919098,
0.7351632714271545,
-0.359713613986969,
0.35973942279815674,
-0.4063069522380829,
-1.377663254737854,
0.009194186888635159,
0.3391592800617218,
-0.6195212006568909,
0.22186359763145447,
0.42853668332099915,
0.6987711787223816,
0.022131409496068954,
-0.2339249551296234,
0.08770181238651276,
-0.014610149897634983,
0.3663063943386078,
0.44454866647720337,
1.1742738485336304,
0.011586728505790234,
-0.11083966493606567,
-0.007551661692559719,
-0.39072051644325256,
-0.24992875754833221,
-0.8100743293762207,
-1.1231399774551392,
-0.1598115861415863,
-0.3409811854362488,
-0.24547813832759857,
-0.37386754155158997,
0.7817754745483398,
0.31539425253868103,
-0.6102530360221863,
-0.35970011353492737,
0.2194952517747879,
0.3701421916484833,
0.005842776037752628,
-0.33207225799560547,
0.2443343698978424,
-0.3226366639137268,
-0.7289576530456543,
-0.11319068819284439,
0.5505343079566956,
-0.1662573367357254,
-0.8378121256828308,
-0.13070763647556305,
0.48025423288345337,
0.34154212474823,
0.28009024262428284,
-0.12801209092140198,
-0.8909971714019775,
-0.4776151180267334,
-0.13662533462047577,
-0.2932051420211792,
-0.017612144351005554,
0.9988520741462708,
-0.5305633544921875,
0.5161378979682922,
0.5742647051811218,
0.25645560026168823,
0.11735458672046661,
-0.012935529462993145,
0.48610562086105347,
-0.9634032845497131,
0.18829943239688873,
0.5405391454696655,
0.2730322778224945,
0.4024870693683624,
-0.26336342096328735,
0.3606298565864563,
0.06767699122428894,
-0.4724075198173523,
-0.962460458278656,
0.4527661204338074,
-0.8381785154342651,
-0.051052290946245193,
1.3424646854400635,
0.06692883372306824,
-0.15856331586837769,
0.13503336906433105,
-0.21876682341098785,
0.18641620874404907,
-0.2900235652923584,
1.0288809537887573,
0.8701473474502563,
-0.13336080312728882,
0.010799355804920197,
-0.4362353980541229,
0.5141512155532837,
0.3279418349266052,
-0.40739893913269043,
0.10052450746297836,
0.5388486385345459,
0.2242087572813034,
0.3975893557071686,
0.4053645730018616,
-0.2889080345630646,
0.04947248846292496,
-0.09041878581047058,
0.2543064057826996,
0.12744824588298798,
-0.14334405958652496,
-0.33253562450408936,
0.07813259214162827,
0.2828996479511261,
0.31079593300819397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14535v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14535v1
|
Exploring Alignment in Shared Cross-lingual Spaces
| 2024-05-23T13:20:24 | 2024-05-23T13:20:24 |
Basel Mousi, Nadir Durrani, Fahim Dalvi, Majd Hawasly, Ahmed Abdelali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite their remarkable ability to capture linguistic nuances across diverse
languages, questions persist regarding the degree of alignment between
languages in multilingual embeddings. Drawing inspiration from research on
high-dimensional representations in neural language models, we employ
clustering to uncover latent concepts within multilingual models. Our analysis
focuses on quantifying the \textit{alignment} and \textit{overlap} of these
concepts across various languages within the latent space. To this end, we
introduce two metrics \CA{} and \CO{} aimed at quantifying these aspects,
enabling a deeper exploration of multilingual embeddings. Our study encompasses
three multilingual models (\texttt{mT5}, \texttt{mBERT}, and \texttt{XLM-R})
and three downstream tasks (Machine Translation, Named Entity Recognition, and
Sentiment Analysis). Key findings from our analysis include: i) deeper layers
in the network demonstrate increased cross-lingual \textit{alignment} due to
the presence of language-agnostic concepts, ii) fine-tuning of the models
enhances \textit{alignment} within the latent space, and iii) such
task-specific calibration helps in explaining the emergence of zero-shot
capabilities in the models.\footnote{The code is available at
\url{https://github.com/baselmousi/multilingual-latent-concepts}}
|
[
-0.33846667408943176,
-0.7015417218208313,
0.43254607915878296,
0.16762675344944,
0.041698794811964035,
0.51669842004776,
-0.18432848155498505,
-0.39777418971061707,
0.5067367553710938,
0.030441608279943466,
-0.3221067786216736,
-0.593756377696991,
-0.4002264440059662,
-0.2490680068731308,
-0.14715108275413513,
0.795224666595459,
-0.3463079035282135,
0.15855635702610016,
-0.26599550247192383,
-0.4402676522731781,
-0.7163885235786438,
-0.426839679479599,
-0.3253230154514313,
-0.24625781178474426,
0.9661734104156494,
0.2591013014316559,
0.6987009048461914,
0.6243147850036621,
0.6188930869102478,
0.20951248705387115,
0.017220670357346535,
0.03574971854686737,
-0.38987353444099426,
-0.043311186134815216,
-0.20944228768348694,
-0.5097455978393555,
-0.5807015299797058,
-0.048235613852739334,
0.7571936845779419,
1.049745798110962,
-0.06514903903007507,
-0.056877315044403076,
0.013456161133944988,
0.14546692371368408,
-0.6092795133590698,
-0.04963591694831848,
-0.5228995084762573,
0.24944539368152618,
-0.2395191639661789,
-0.07947319746017456,
-0.06503482162952423,
-0.10871525853872299,
0.21412774920463562,
-0.7171510457992554,
0.13239923119544983,
0.019159749150276184,
1.0276482105255127,
0.3311654329299927,
-0.4247341752052307,
-0.10395488142967224,
-0.4415059983730316,
0.9932806491851807,
-0.4665258824825287,
0.5991347432136536,
-0.02268729917705059,
0.15833435952663422,
0.20572227239608765,
-0.2975273132324219,
-0.6613137722015381,
0.3718471825122833,
-0.24071016907691956,
0.18585416674613953,
-0.2519287168979645,
-0.3047143518924713,
-0.15292881429195404,
0.4700961410999298,
-0.8736903667449951,
0.39595210552215576,
-0.06108805537223816,
-0.29062795639038086,
0.49336257576942444,
0.004563745576888323,
0.6240981221199036,
0.044803086668252945,
-0.3994700610637665,
-0.1391564905643463,
-0.7932947874069214,
-0.017294205725193024,
0.4756636619567871,
0.509549081325531,
-0.5852605700492859,
0.681198000907898,
0.2703200876712799,
0.6436717510223389,
0.13907873630523682,
0.27622851729393005,
0.2941170930862427,
-0.6544162631034851,
0.10834420472383499,
0.28402766585350037,
0.7558055520057678,
0.2171853929758072,
0.10436684638261795,
-0.3726913630962372,
0.1607896387577057,
0.19658565521240234,
0.18305906653404236,
-0.3938155174255371,
-0.02383345365524292,
0.10927937924861908,
-0.13311615586280823,
-0.14912763237953186,
0.14246352016925812,
-0.3659074008464813,
-0.1664440929889679,
-0.4062618315219879,
0.2854727506637573,
-0.27155977487564087,
-0.5405750870704651,
0.04572398588061333,
0.04709507152438164,
0.31411248445510864,
0.0807047113776207,
-0.7944676280021667,
0.1032276451587677,
0.9655730128288269,
0.9751172661781311,
-0.4784834086894989,
-0.6323257684707642,
-0.20393356680870056,
0.24950537085533142,
-0.6714644432067871,
0.6248785257339478,
-0.7112410068511963,
-0.06734045594930649,
-0.03370334953069687,
0.21148334443569183,
-0.3894957900047302,
-0.28552114963531494,
0.14320799708366394,
-0.5671502947807312,
0.29013535380363464,
-0.5127191543579102,
-0.6526932120323181,
-0.2537567913532257,
0.46368274092674255,
-0.7454902529716492,
0.9765740633010864,
-0.2615553140640259,
-0.8589528799057007,
0.3891957700252533,
-0.6030499935150146,
-0.1946336030960083,
-0.15177884697914124,
-0.5873753428459167,
-0.25562232732772827,
0.26160287857055664,
0.07302220165729523,
0.5606868267059326,
-0.1772027164697647,
0.36732345819473267,
-0.3558019995689392,
-0.22650642693042755,
0.3614538908004761,
-0.22328773140907288,
0.6099787950515747,
0.2018452286720276,
-0.2687152624130249,
0.002557402476668358,
-0.4756965637207031,
0.013297095894813538,
-0.01105690561234951,
0.19307056069374084,
-0.5890102386474609,
-0.2825947403907776,
-0.10276524722576141,
0.2742949426174164,
0.6327740550041199,
-0.5790875554084778,
0.042196765542030334,
-0.3442186117172241,
0.226536363363266,
0.4037938117980957,
-0.0945155993103981,
0.7299938201904297,
-0.160152867436409,
0.5172621607780457,
0.3965902328491211,
-0.27622729539871216,
-0.16929766535758972,
-0.29558366537094116,
-0.5760868787765503,
-0.002664262894541025,
0.49008795619010925,
0.5771955847740173,
-0.4586763083934784,
0.5517378449440002,
-0.6847354769706726,
-0.5151603817939758,
-0.6036714315414429,
0.03165024146437645,
0.5118135809898376,
0.2227555811405182,
0.31329843401908875,
-0.415043443441391,
-0.15126433968544006,
-0.9803768396377563,
-0.000460623181425035,
0.05894717946648598,
0.4490937888622284,
0.22280918061733246,
0.41426408290863037,
-0.1648343801498413,
0.8693828582763672,
-0.5383710861206055,
-0.07415231317281723,
0.12439561635255814,
0.2880653738975525,
-0.01025569811463356,
0.6808610558509827,
0.634441077709198,
-0.8470800518989563,
-0.816008448600769,
0.7050568461418152,
-0.9419935941696167,
-0.04202951863408089,
0.05791144445538521,
-0.17819559574127197,
0.17120301723480225,
0.549425482749939,
-0.25667083263397217,
0.22328265011310577,
0.8830090165138245,
-0.2864297926425934,
0.1679803729057312,
-0.07011514902114868,
0.2545369565486908,
-1.3516067266464233,
0.2934320569038391,
-0.14848780632019043,
0.01414776872843504,
-0.5837427377700806,
0.21722599864006042,
-0.00020357411995064467,
-0.07338029891252518,
-0.41719135642051697,
0.6406295895576477,
-0.6644963026046753,
-0.40152621269226074,
-0.08640296757221222,
0.4096966087818146,
0.19087237119674683,
0.43721118569374084,
0.33874744176864624,
0.8166682124137878,
0.6126937866210938,
-0.3284247815608978,
0.03355161100625992,
0.18256863951683044,
-0.23784565925598145,
0.7606667876243591,
-0.7494533061981201,
0.08925826102495193,
0.2556663155555725,
-0.08533242344856262,
-1.003138780593872,
-0.019761620089411736,
0.04338640347123146,
-0.5816426873207092,
0.4398139417171478,
0.05446097254753113,
-0.45699429512023926,
0.07935900241136551,
-0.053786471486091614,
0.9713910818099976,
-0.06456907093524933,
-0.3085237145423889,
0.3859950006008148,
0.6406239867210388,
-0.21058544516563416,
-1.0338020324707031,
-0.785581111907959,
0.04027555137872696,
-0.3560499846935272,
-0.6323437690734863,
0.5744694471359253,
0.009898718446493149,
-0.22900202870368958,
0.18694663047790527,
-0.07070963829755783,
-0.18426914513111115,
-0.01692844368517399,
0.0481681190431118,
0.11893880367279053,
-0.46322035789489746,
0.0781332403421402,
0.17515942454338074,
-0.1286565214395523,
-0.3642834722995758,
-0.5607083439826965,
0.701855480670929,
-0.29688793420791626,
-0.6735129356384277,
-0.21019111573696136,
0.46249881386756897,
0.32885655760765076,
-0.3297904133796692,
0.7760291695594788,
0.8860238790512085,
-0.5386031866073608,
0.35325339436531067,
-0.4934987425804138,
0.10459420084953308,
-0.3499281704425812,
0.23946784436702728,
-0.48671725392341614,
-1.2077480554580688,
0.9926501512527466,
0.28104907274246216,
-0.0155674759298563,
0.5332573056221008,
0.5695180892944336,
-0.04339691624045372,
0.8976854681968689,
0.9021307229995728,
-0.06860478967428207,
0.23609283566474915,
-0.255999356508255,
0.5085047483444214,
-0.7848478555679321,
-0.1573483943939209,
-0.45009663701057434,
-0.4316069185733795,
-0.7209523916244507,
-0.8798837065696716,
0.2171991616487503,
0.22108177840709686,
0.019322924315929413,
0.5448941588401794,
-0.2282213270664215,
0.5668919086456299,
0.12880492210388184,
-0.42477285861968994,
0.08637040108442307,
0.1595563441514969,
-0.48269158601760864,
-0.44668689370155334,
-0.7695890069007874,
-0.3681223392486572,
0.7533994913101196,
0.3289584219455719,
0.5503606200218201,
0.35765546560287476,
0.6868339776992798,
-0.028892677277326584,
-0.11218048632144928,
-0.7388857007026672,
0.13609328866004944,
-0.38216403126716614,
-0.6625922918319702,
-0.2709783613681793,
-0.38834571838378906,
-1.122107982635498,
0.27573707699775696,
-0.09132730960845947,
-0.7627754807472229,
0.4580095410346985,
-0.0165785513818264,
-0.4846937358379364,
0.2816920876502991,
-0.5291664004325867,
1.1833164691925049,
-0.47433769702911377,
-0.5581884980201721,
-0.4134284555912018,
-0.6139294505119324,
0.06251015514135361,
-0.3034946918487549,
0.1422850638628006,
0.04044048488140106,
-0.16225455701351166,
0.5698881149291992,
-0.13150988519191742,
0.9540311098098755,
0.06125607341527939,
-0.6333601474761963,
0.2032518833875656,
0.08685104548931122,
-0.10874941200017929,
-0.25461843609809875,
0.1260359287261963,
0.5775722861289978,
0.2512453496456146,
-0.6154491305351257,
-0.5748468041419983,
1.0398566722869873,
-0.8678271174430847,
-0.10187879204750061,
-0.4103314280509949,
-0.8279885649681091,
-0.16721969842910767,
0.3030444383621216,
0.0840432420372963,
0.2330186516046524,
-0.5667702555656433,
0.21222476661205292,
0.6170668005943298,
-0.4675096571445465,
0.303494393825531,
0.4484017491340637,
-0.3314075767993927,
-0.2448781430721283,
1.2213512659072876,
0.2610158324241638,
0.3042842149734497,
0.9336811900138855,
-0.02444462664425373,
-0.4800601899623871,
-0.20615331828594208,
-0.36946743726730347,
0.3778674304485321,
-0.5411525368690491,
-0.08135637640953064,
-0.7924808263778687,
-0.0158595759421587,
-0.6235595941543579,
-0.30004677176475525,
-0.4095378518104553,
-0.5971766710281372,
-0.20060713589191437,
-0.10306084901094437,
-0.09358465671539307,
0.5998432636260986,
-0.31327810883522034,
0.5969640612602234,
-0.9174880981445312,
-0.11000925302505493,
0.01573566533625126,
0.32127633690834045,
0.07575096935033798,
-0.23889820277690887,
-0.5647441148757935,
0.12485324591398239,
-0.24857409298419952,
-0.6347031593322754,
0.3080351948738098,
0.14946867525577545,
0.6616232395172119,
0.5222069025039673,
-0.45147398114204407,
0.9151489734649658,
-0.45126405358314514,
0.808769166469574,
0.38166120648384094,
-1.001136302947998,
0.14017736911773682,
-0.48388671875,
0.394732803106308,
0.5551354289054871,
0.5380075573921204,
-0.8958613276481628,
-0.12806980311870575,
-0.5475242733955383,
-0.6191964745521545,
0.38957199454307556,
0.01445988193154335,
0.1166398897767067,
0.039104923605918884,
0.23335891962051392,
0.1346263587474823,
0.23933196067810059,
-0.7406714558601379,
-0.13045713305473328,
0.03324694558978081,
-0.39878392219543457,
-0.3419874310493469,
0.10303272306919098,
-0.22702185809612274,
-0.10044863075017929,
0.40298640727996826,
-0.34277501702308655,
0.29070866107940674,
-0.22087323665618896,
-0.3260527551174164,
-0.18796510994434357,
0.07281281054019928,
0.6143532991409302,
0.572106659412384,
0.1277439147233963,
0.3079887926578522,
0.06880699098110199,
-0.1606721729040146,
0.09808271378278732,
0.09512273967266083,
0.040160391479730606,
-0.05563006177544594,
0.44855785369873047,
0.7885316014289856,
0.4060197174549103,
-0.26797035336494446,
0.5708284378051758,
-0.056048743426799774,
0.05519723892211914,
-0.17717336118221283,
-0.20306074619293213,
0.3207973539829254,
0.23202842473983765,
-0.14637838304042816,
-0.030678803101181984,
-0.13600799441337585,
-0.42311471700668335,
0.24185247719287872,
0.6065971851348877,
-0.6829149723052979,
-0.7199525237083435,
0.3988223969936371,
-0.06177108734846115,
-0.002512885257601738,
0.25853052735328674,
-0.08201413601636887,
-0.5581904649734497,
0.5711204409599304,
0.4072939455509186,
0.7171384692192078,
-0.16535204648971558,
0.21727944910526276,
0.3785612881183624,
0.15680214762687683,
0.17250017821788788,
0.16979268193244934,
0.03559736907482147,
-1.1658215522766113,
-0.697285532951355,
-0.661653459072113,
-0.14172035455703735,
-0.19662992656230927,
-0.7066214084625244,
0.2541349232196808,
0.010538763366639614,
-0.02593657188117504,
0.13731451332569122,
0.06435184180736542,
-0.5712779760360718,
0.011421271599829197,
0.2551068663597107,
0.5999411344528198,
-1.1620166301727295,
0.8544672727584839,
0.9057372808456421,
-0.33825987577438354,
-0.9063254594802856,
-0.011393113061785698,
0.19768856465816498,
-0.8736353516578674,
0.6095510721206665,
0.15328435599803925,
-0.1830621063709259,
-0.039479050785303116,
-0.2806423306465149,
-1.122528314590454,
1.065675139427185,
0.23652195930480957,
-0.60696941614151,
0.015024309977889061,
0.43858855962753296,
0.7409829497337341,
-0.6703343987464905,
0.020739564672112465,
0.3068392872810364,
0.4074345529079437,
0.04422254115343094,
-0.9981064796447754,
-0.21091516315937042,
-0.3388577699661255,
-0.1697111427783966,
0.41298630833625793,
-0.5353670120239258,
0.8809149265289307,
0.0037530784029513597,
-0.25504499673843384,
-0.039306510239839554,
0.5906844735145569,
0.07833737134933472,
0.32579365372657776,
0.4163885712623596,
1.013121247291565,
0.7580885887145996,
-0.13842393457889557,
0.8169646263122559,
-0.5051159858703613,
0.3520885705947876,
1.1720086336135864,
-0.37991875410079956,
0.844719648361206,
0.6715632081031799,
0.010783171281218529,
0.5412027835845947,
0.6819772720336914,
0.05533750355243683,
0.41679123044013977,
-0.06137804687023163,
0.04683438688516617,
-0.15230144560337067,
-0.5160128474235535,
-0.39611026644706726,
0.5487804412841797,
0.48908731341362,
0.026940081268548965,
-0.13015230000019073,
-0.24936076998710632,
0.0026405812241137028,
0.1444922536611557,
-0.03203696012496948,
0.7281396985054016,
0.23229554295539856,
-0.7828487753868103,
0.38734960556030273,
-0.187208890914917,
0.6471464037895203,
-0.3643025755882263,
0.12532052397727966,
-0.0646941065788269,
0.11022354662418365,
-0.1698082983493805,
-0.8229852318763733,
0.5089743733406067,
-0.17930661141872406,
-0.1418171375989914,
-0.25857070088386536,
0.467804491519928,
-0.8828322291374207,
-0.35297685861587524,
0.6313191652297974,
1.0169087648391724,
0.321694552898407,
0.27849850058555603,
-0.8834879398345947,
0.09338666498661041,
-0.09187927842140198,
0.3720703423023224,
0.27415403723716736,
0.5658801198005676,
-0.2720700204372406,
0.048505086451768875,
0.46677905321121216,
0.17248371243476868,
0.16350170969963074,
0.37659648060798645,
0.43377169966697693,
-0.4776654541492462,
-0.5228046774864197,
-0.7876884937286377,
0.4208115041255951,
0.004355267621576786,
-0.24912148714065552,
0.7992062568664551,
0.7458269000053406,
1.1790357828140259,
0.19587434828281403,
0.49401596188545227,
-0.1713002622127533,
0.383933424949646,
-0.3419778645038605,
0.608130931854248,
-1.062389612197876,
0.0036198964808136225,
-0.41859856247901917,
-1.0379499197006226,
-0.4361620545387268,
0.6782180070877075,
-0.43095341324806213,
-0.20826061069965363,
0.7375432252883911,
0.812066376209259,
-0.45351672172546387,
-0.20313896238803864,
0.29877969622612,
-0.05576220899820328,
0.14798705279827118,
0.4160923957824707,
0.9582307934761047,
-0.39330124855041504,
0.19472914934158325,
-0.23085390031337738,
0.017587989568710327,
0.0662958100438118,
-0.8911962509155273,
-0.6494604349136353,
-0.7016676068305969,
-0.48547863960266113,
0.008133575320243835,
-0.27800944447517395,
0.5582643151283264,
0.644679069519043,
-1.002937912940979,
-0.5467638373374939,
-0.059714801609516144,
0.09951402992010117,
-0.19294314086437225,
-0.2369469553232193,
0.3843855559825897,
-0.31696075201034546,
-0.8130707144737244,
0.21358270943164825,
0.37188079953193665,
0.21894831955432892,
-0.3914340138435364,
-0.1515478640794754,
-0.5535914301872253,
-0.17081491649150848,
0.3411429524421692,
0.13939926028251648,
-0.7124590277671814,
-0.2563808560371399,
0.515861988067627,
-0.186421200633049,
0.11750435084104538,
0.9052297472953796,
-0.1655275672674179,
0.3917114734649658,
0.5887172222137451,
0.9076874256134033,
0.2164658010005951,
-0.10462337732315063,
0.8791024684906006,
-1.1226874589920044,
0.17851124703884125,
0.0824773907661438,
0.4328899681568146,
0.5749815702438354,
-0.26739659905433655,
0.5397844314575195,
0.10995557904243469,
-0.43799909949302673,
-0.8027263879776001,
0.32128700613975525,
-0.9916636943817139,
-0.2630152702331543,
0.7224617600440979,
-0.32618725299835205,
-0.09528223425149918,
0.09604920446872711,
0.2211962640285492,
0.5440936088562012,
-0.06280834227800369,
0.5765584111213684,
1.0457700490951538,
0.008042638190090656,
-0.0989106073975563,
-0.35635870695114136,
0.09029296040534973,
0.7904837131500244,
-0.6543980836868286,
-0.205408975481987,
0.4388050436973572,
0.10572636872529984,
0.9070327877998352,
0.24146048724651337,
-0.2916850447654724,
0.05203690379858017,
-0.20737387239933014,
0.1655558943748474,
0.48756399750709534,
-0.46722716093063354,
-0.5712075233459473,
-0.013524635694921017,
-0.1125650629401207,
-0.07814200222492218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14522v1
|
Explaining Black-box Model Predictions via Two-level Nested Feature Attributions with Consistency Property
| 2024-05-23T13:03:26 | 2024-05-23T13:03:26 |
Yuya Yoshikawa, Masanari Kimura, Ryotaro Shimizu, Yuki Saito
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML
|
Techniques that explain the predictions of black-box machine learning models
are crucial to make the models transparent, thereby increasing trust in AI
systems. The input features to the models often have a nested structure that
consists of high- and low-level features, and each high-level feature is
decomposed into multiple low-level features. For such inputs, both high-level
feature attributions (HiFAs) and low-level feature attributions (LoFAs) are
important for better understanding the model's decision. In this paper, we
propose a model-agnostic local explanation method that effectively exploits the
nested structure of the input to estimate the two-level feature attributions
simultaneously. A key idea of the proposed method is to introduce the
consistency property that should exist between the HiFAs and LoFAs, thereby
bridging the separate optimization problems for estimating them. Thanks to this
consistency property, the proposed method can produce HiFAs and LoFAs that are
both faithful to the black-box models and consistent with each other, using a
smaller number of queries to the models. In experiments on image classification
in multiple instance learning and text classification using language models, we
demonstrate that the HiFAs and LoFAs estimated by the proposed method are
accurate, faithful to the behaviors of the black-box models, and provide
consistent explanations.
|
[
-0.13524848222732544,
-0.9774482846260071,
0.6710329651832581,
-0.1409110724925995,
-0.14840273559093475,
-0.043369174003601074,
-0.07138564437627792,
-0.6326571106910706,
-0.06444855034351349,
0.46837618947029114,
-0.36964309215545654,
-0.35664355754852295,
-0.5049663186073303,
-0.1842208355665207,
-0.3083227276802063,
0.8260064125061035,
-0.3581910729408264,
-0.4105701744556427,
-0.4696541726589203,
-0.19870524108409882,
-0.49941885471343994,
-0.38945481181144714,
-0.5600601434707642,
-0.5343403220176697,
0.5089319944381714,
0.1815905123949051,
0.9741657376289368,
0.8931882977485657,
0.17088837921619415,
0.2263677567243576,
-0.11880314350128174,
0.19882814586162567,
-0.3326391875743866,
0.08241769671440125,
-0.1954805999994278,
-0.7218785881996155,
-0.36977091431617737,
-0.08687125891447067,
0.6446278095245361,
0.35357972979545593,
-0.05597745627164841,
0.13208898901939392,
0.20292632281780243,
0.09777125716209412,
-0.9359045028686523,
0.19963136315345764,
-0.8318623304367065,
0.1058630421757698,
0.21337279677391052,
-0.032020773738622665,
-0.4608933627605438,
-0.23745054006576538,
0.033313605934381485,
-0.6022201180458069,
0.4094279408454895,
-0.19243066012859344,
1.243179440498352,
0.3932795226573944,
-0.41415324807167053,
0.17625154554843903,
-0.8099665641784668,
0.9883196949958801,
-0.7715355157852173,
0.25482621788978577,
0.5538735389709473,
0.5508867502212524,
0.0789223164319992,
-0.16903285682201385,
-0.6117808222770691,
-0.09297367930412292,
-0.47166043519973755,
0.04853853955864906,
-0.22959940135478973,
-0.29065653681755066,
-0.11100640147924423,
0.2570894956588745,
-0.19645655155181885,
0.47617778182029724,
-0.11435579508543015,
-0.3031459152698517,
0.5989612936973572,
-0.11115577816963196,
-0.2548561096191406,
-0.2427600771188736,
-0.48131829500198364,
0.14413899183273315,
-0.7745888829231262,
0.26947930455207825,
0.19871391355991364,
0.33404457569122314,
-0.42460811138153076,
0.5282077193260193,
0.1664508581161499,
0.4426611661911011,
0.1631266474723816,
-0.40897852182388306,
0.2376847118139267,
-0.5513646602630615,
-0.16100484132766724,
0.04256252944469452,
0.7686563730239868,
0.10918194055557251,
0.13211368024349213,
-0.36595937609672546,
-0.19913740456104279,
0.5182886123657227,
0.3033601641654968,
-0.6747692823410034,
0.23363922536373138,
0.3696461617946625,
-0.564847469329834,
-0.6896522045135498,
-0.016384897753596306,
-0.7525271773338318,
-0.38834714889526367,
-0.11947065591812134,
0.6321800351142883,
0.1493503600358963,
-0.3260919153690338,
0.02091255970299244,
0.08950071781873703,
-0.016106873750686646,
0.41830626130104065,
-0.7959679961204529,
0.3098198175430298,
0.6378253698348999,
0.8488323092460632,
-0.16096967458724976,
-0.38056978583335876,
-0.6477088928222656,
0.4923766553401947,
-0.2880036532878876,
0.7474396824836731,
-0.600943922996521,
0.06629685312509537,
0.08671507984399796,
0.006661917548626661,
0.08131197839975357,
-0.5201230645179749,
0.03645990043878555,
-0.12074947357177734,
0.22245098650455475,
0.09784848242998123,
-0.2612728774547577,
-0.2649523615837097,
0.382097989320755,
-0.4097267985343933,
1.1493932008743286,
-0.04047800227999687,
-0.6191938519477844,
0.46041935682296753,
-0.7126868367195129,
-0.3926784098148346,
-0.37051063776016235,
-0.3863510489463806,
-1.1192045211791992,
0.1821356862783432,
0.42725104093551636,
0.6126576662063599,
-0.03976360335946083,
0.27862975001335144,
-0.7151342034339905,
-0.37489476799964905,
0.13430412113666534,
-0.391163170337677,
0.9023503661155701,
0.0009025742765516043,
-0.6582832932472229,
0.1426537185907364,
-0.7191495895385742,
-0.18497537076473236,
0.36762478947639465,
-0.08238505572080612,
-0.12850645184516907,
0.21056678891181946,
-0.654211699962616,
0.08383043110370636,
0.5341159105300903,
-0.5461763143539429,
0.21688519418239594,
-0.18889784812927246,
0.509926438331604,
0.6266378164291382,
0.17541205883026123,
0.5241742730140686,
-0.2577782869338989,
0.5444517135620117,
0.524399995803833,
0.13257402181625366,
-0.34990400075912476,
-0.5871552228927612,
-0.343606561422348,
-0.3494536876678467,
0.044654738157987595,
0.4178955554962158,
-0.09523677825927734,
0.5266560912132263,
0.0015523284673690796,
-0.22191542387008667,
-0.6554791331291199,
0.1292036920785904,
0.5114330649375916,
0.571252167224884,
0.4271955192089081,
-0.14955943822860718,
-0.26179057359695435,
-1.0251951217651367,
0.021795740351080894,
-0.24675732851028442,
-0.011691632680594921,
0.3678561747074127,
0.5951915383338928,
-0.3887018859386444,
0.8599833250045776,
-0.45165130496025085,
-0.2527830898761749,
0.21947357058525085,
0.45820173621177673,
-0.04525602236390114,
0.5020534992218018,
0.6352052688598633,
-0.6088401079177856,
-0.296933114528656,
0.23282891511917114,
-0.7472286820411682,
0.22040057182312012,
-0.05235619470477104,
-0.1900748908519745,
0.1784629374742508,
0.2332996129989624,
-0.4787852168083191,
0.8072454929351807,
0.3762902617454529,
-0.26209428906440735,
0.6088548302650452,
-0.2624260187149048,
0.042687736451625824,
-1.0749925374984741,
-0.292733371257782,
0.27237093448638916,
-0.29327499866485596,
-0.3317459225654602,
0.12161918729543686,
0.03774040564894676,
-0.018424371257424355,
-0.01586848311126232,
0.7053840160369873,
-0.4511933922767639,
-0.3980858325958252,
-0.07603943347930908,
0.015939893200993538,
0.45340362191200256,
0.6074389815330505,
0.023661118000745773,
0.5139558911323547,
0.8801535964012146,
-0.1442052125930786,
0.2936815023422241,
0.33703169226646423,
-0.0980037972331047,
0.42203739285469055,
-0.6270925402641296,
0.2229420393705368,
-0.1115882620215416,
0.13071885704994202,
-1.0591729879379272,
-0.026880571618676186,
0.1417544186115265,
-0.55448979139328,
0.05509493499994278,
-0.4548965096473694,
-0.48263269662857056,
-0.13481226563453674,
-0.06486796587705612,
0.4080238342285156,
0.5470812320709229,
-0.6871022582054138,
0.8274530172348022,
0.14236043393611908,
0.08345843106508255,
-0.7935607433319092,
-0.7225643992424011,
-0.27068597078323364,
-0.4074837267398834,
-0.6238101720809937,
0.4110284149646759,
0.0807148665189743,
-0.057604268193244934,
0.2253899723291397,
-0.29015061259269714,
-0.40190383791923523,
0.3735940456390381,
0.43314430117607117,
0.41421768069267273,
-0.5848610997200012,
-0.19861668348312378,
-0.08070527017116547,
0.08493220806121826,
0.028488874435424805,
-0.20278824865818024,
-0.03957582265138626,
-0.21789801120758057,
-0.32135045528411865,
-0.5199493765830994,
0.2863197326660156,
0.4477670192718506,
-0.5176343321800232,
0.9462890625,
0.6790938377380371,
-0.8079313635826111,
-0.3625619113445282,
-0.337090402841568,
-0.37745562195777893,
-0.4015957713127136,
0.1885737031698227,
-0.5789461731910706,
-0.7469232082366943,
1.0513763427734375,
0.3490464389324188,
0.10773803293704987,
0.4195578694343567,
0.6052742600440979,
-0.061745304614305496,
1.3331273794174194,
0.8146460652351379,
0.009489397518336773,
0.327858567237854,
-0.2776325047016144,
0.32236573100090027,
-0.3651967942714691,
-0.3735083341598511,
-0.8354076743125916,
-0.22068697214126587,
-0.23068447411060333,
-0.15501372516155243,
0.2906099855899811,
0.37037143111228943,
-0.2690448462963104,
0.24640397727489471,
-0.4422644078731537,
0.4720768630504608,
0.5647238492965698,
0.33874183893203735,
0.2910401225090027,
0.39325428009033203,
0.005225772503763437,
0.22131524980068207,
-0.5697171688079834,
-0.3584989309310913,
0.8140621185302734,
0.6688992381095886,
0.8015849590301514,
0.135885551571846,
0.8451629281044006,
0.21648932993412018,
0.12878593802452087,
-0.8500018119812012,
0.1324509084224701,
-0.12644092738628387,
-0.62814861536026,
-0.44697004556655884,
-0.4722042977809906,
-1.0273957252502441,
0.13779303431510925,
-0.4994180500507355,
-1.1892260313034058,
0.4619992971420288,
0.5097706913948059,
-0.3620130121707916,
0.13601696491241455,
-0.729667067527771,
1.2642617225646973,
-0.07252607494592667,
-0.5064396858215332,
-0.3273954689502716,
-0.4430932104587555,
0.37554556131362915,
-0.20184960961341858,
0.11469991505146027,
0.06569946557283401,
0.13912975788116455,
0.483888179063797,
-0.34476611018180847,
0.830356776714325,
-0.2672426998615265,
-0.30261144042015076,
0.18738707900047302,
0.18536311388015747,
0.676204264163971,
0.07807003706693649,
-0.06066110357642174,
0.28903213143348694,
-0.12284666299819946,
-0.5161600708961487,
-1.0333794355392456,
0.499443918466568,
-0.8855153322219849,
-0.45374515652656555,
-0.01554668415337801,
-0.48951685428619385,
-0.11426553875207901,
0.3181682527065277,
0.09495892375707626,
0.7315844893455505,
0.45493724942207336,
0.2676141560077667,
0.5403802394866943,
0.2320351004600525,
0.010610011406242847,
0.17785832285881042,
0.025043508037924767,
-0.030358649790287018,
0.8630911111831665,
-0.039140984416007996,
0.28255540132522583,
0.39711493253707886,
0.46308860182762146,
-0.4087607264518738,
-0.8763038516044617,
-0.36477553844451904,
0.24903671443462372,
-0.6399387121200562,
-0.23778747022151947,
-0.23984554409980774,
-0.1917084902524948,
-0.37367919087409973,
-0.4961564838886261,
-0.4291173219680786,
-0.19608952105045319,
-0.22957518696784973,
-0.06961061805486679,
-0.0008552614017389715,
0.77598637342453,
0.2814106047153473,
0.2829441428184509,
-0.49481120705604553,
0.8200924396514893,
0.24058732390403748,
0.45241624116897583,
0.12150812894105911,
-0.6284318566322327,
-0.5983371138572693,
0.3238423466682434,
-0.3342910408973694,
-0.9466465711593628,
-0.09276045858860016,
0.18682365119457245,
0.751691460609436,
0.5762415528297424,
-0.15385772287845612,
0.7243218421936035,
-0.26718878746032715,
0.648160457611084,
0.22306931018829346,
-0.8622100353240967,
0.7110342979431152,
-0.21583439409732819,
0.08152344077825546,
0.21624362468719482,
0.23260611295700073,
0.20468400418758392,
-0.7089161276817322,
-0.8584129214286804,
-0.41151565313339233,
0.6755269765853882,
0.18346185982227325,
-0.2448606640100479,
0.33722883462905884,
0.45775106549263,
0.2343650758266449,
0.16619697213172913,
-0.9972046613693237,
-0.3266257345676422,
-0.5345931649208069,
-0.47008615732192993,
-0.02447594702243805,
-0.18195466697216034,
-0.41363999247550964,
-0.017378807067871094,
0.6801893711090088,
-0.2839321494102478,
0.38202014565467834,
-0.14372611045837402,
-0.04721314460039139,
-0.45079079270362854,
0.30493199825286865,
0.49410614371299744,
1.0125528573989868,
-0.49653270840644836,
0.40230122208595276,
-0.24191159009933472,
-0.16755260527133942,
0.3623470366001129,
0.25738897919654846,
-0.47148701548576355,
-0.06172138825058937,
0.48218709230422974,
0.8013860583305359,
0.12143778800964355,
-0.05594388768076897,
0.5566304922103882,
0.32285594940185547,
-0.2907838523387909,
-0.0255727656185627,
0.1063384860754013,
-0.025997383520007133,
0.539928138256073,
0.2335958331823349,
0.26712262630462646,
-0.03712797909975052,
-0.7567924857139587,
0.19109955430030823,
0.6830403804779053,
-0.2797754406929016,
-0.17670424282550812,
0.8172063827514648,
-0.2078482061624527,
-0.043997228145599365,
0.22606290876865387,
0.0012116034049540758,
-0.5486325025558472,
0.7689816951751709,
0.6050295829772949,
0.9602054953575134,
-0.010209412313997746,
0.4343116581439972,
0.3110595643520355,
0.23277099430561066,
-0.23313318192958832,
-0.19974422454833984,
-0.07472299784421921,
-1.082222580909729,
-0.39898306131362915,
-0.6447035670280457,
-0.4269646406173706,
0.27555495500564575,
-0.8722513318061829,
0.16958357393741608,
-0.3555217683315277,
-0.002080876613035798,
0.5974779725074768,
0.0046441154554486275,
-0.46025171875953674,
0.19097717106342316,
0.2546411454677582,
0.5391321182250977,
-0.8771717548370361,
0.7937883138656616,
0.624636173248291,
-0.42136019468307495,
-0.8163397908210754,
-0.06267613917589188,
-0.03534366562962532,
-0.9756258726119995,
0.19790612161159515,
0.13507802784442902,
-0.22365064918994904,
-0.24636703729629517,
-0.6287985444068909,
-0.6937984228134155,
0.965512752532959,
0.57823246717453,
-0.2518991529941559,
-0.23647478222846985,
-0.06586790829896927,
0.26016733050346375,
-0.8322834968566895,
-0.0007251708302646875,
0.4307664632797241,
0.5101182460784912,
0.04107137769460678,
-0.8455058336257935,
0.2057022899389267,
-0.11294546723365784,
-0.13118866086006165,
0.07650016248226166,
-0.11160705983638763,
0.5874956846237183,
-0.5140640735626221,
-0.09072931110858917,
-0.13622644543647766,
0.7819962501525879,
0.5884690880775452,
0.397991806268692,
0.718049168586731,
0.4579048156738281,
0.6789848208427429,
-0.03319357708096504,
0.8418970108032227,
0.05050757899880409,
0.6379927396774292,
1.048570156097412,
0.004991177469491959,
0.9031456112861633,
0.20153026282787323,
-0.1953214854001999,
0.87239009141922,
0.6200743913650513,
-0.407674640417099,
0.4509257376194,
-0.16643162071704865,
0.020695040002465248,
-0.23340308666229248,
0.025330642238259315,
-0.11450088024139404,
0.5005444884300232,
0.09511203318834305,
-0.34112635254859924,
-0.28260886669158936,
-0.0674423798918724,
0.011250327341258526,
0.07332518696784973,
-0.4074900448322296,
0.6924089193344116,
-0.1567329466342926,
-0.6360185146331787,
1.0123517513275146,
-0.06845199316740036,
0.476948618888855,
-0.5379294753074646,
-0.16949205100536346,
-0.1453835517168045,
0.29138222336769104,
-0.288099080324173,
-0.6774507164955139,
0.2069557011127472,
-0.11623427271842957,
-0.6394500732421875,
0.04032417759299278,
0.7229307889938354,
-0.7604424357414246,
-0.5939368009567261,
0.19608506560325623,
0.2481827586889267,
0.08561227470636368,
-0.10142875462770462,
-0.8436169028282166,
-0.0037318714894354343,
-0.09558598697185516,
-0.0486966110765934,
0.03446667641401291,
0.4326118230819702,
-0.3276982307434082,
0.5968741178512573,
0.35605841875076294,
0.21897758543491364,
0.10196149349212646,
-0.020436767488718033,
0.364871084690094,
-0.44943103194236755,
-0.7659780979156494,
-0.6278197169303894,
0.7352267503738403,
0.06001473590731621,
0.05148245021700859,
0.5540958642959595,
0.4228007197380066,
0.7070504426956177,
0.18312257528305054,
0.8484622240066528,
0.331900030374527,
0.3453829884529114,
-0.56639164686203,
0.31410518288612366,
-0.9363991618156433,
0.135812908411026,
-0.06221600994467735,
-1.014340877532959,
-0.07706406712532043,
0.7707058191299438,
-0.15119686722755432,
0.17520858347415924,
0.6896491050720215,
0.7720580101013184,
-0.4860498011112213,
-0.2362690418958664,
0.19654662907123566,
0.6021799445152283,
0.20372994244098663,
0.426734060049057,
0.5073895454406738,
-0.28303366899490356,
0.46441224217414856,
-0.45303115248680115,
-0.34311652183532715,
-0.28272026777267456,
-1.0023635625839233,
-0.8290661573410034,
-0.3998333513736725,
-0.6251559257507324,
-0.5453256368637085,
-0.018765278160572052,
0.1981714963912964,
1.0513631105422974,
-0.947930634021759,
-0.04297001659870148,
0.03405081480741501,
0.43572527170181274,
-0.6303308010101318,
-0.28608348965644836,
0.4651027023792267,
-0.06925910711288452,
-0.43784064054489136,
0.21254774928092957,
0.22585144639015198,
0.2086631953716278,
-0.6076121926307678,
-0.228989377617836,
-0.04674834758043289,
0.06171216443181038,
0.30337584018707275,
0.24544832110404968,
-1.0339901447296143,
-0.4769509732723236,
-0.3648258447647095,
-0.08912055939435959,
0.3887793719768524,
0.5613426566123962,
-0.7632996439933777,
0.26855677366256714,
0.15335126221179962,
0.5388197898864746,
0.7191080451011658,
0.2598329782485962,
0.6095350980758667,
-0.8854674100875854,
0.22600777447223663,
-0.07998668402433395,
0.4915696382522583,
0.35578614473342896,
-0.7129306197166443,
0.3325498402118683,
0.16183388233184814,
-0.3399800956249237,
-0.998651921749115,
0.34540221095085144,
-1.110105037689209,
-0.36336052417755127,
0.7722013592720032,
-0.4829239547252655,
-0.25836116075515747,
-0.05033913254737854,
0.27475327253341675,
0.35144469141960144,
-0.28001669049263,
0.8910805583000183,
0.5257255434989929,
0.014624517410993576,
-0.5976344347000122,
-0.439899742603302,
0.39814022183418274,
0.3983418345451355,
-0.8130017518997192,
0.1888599395751953,
0.4767003357410431,
0.1036510020494461,
0.4879956841468811,
0.22688573598861694,
-0.09919769316911697,
0.2715960741043091,
0.11802484840154648,
-0.2020861953496933,
-0.3778393268585205,
-0.7615514993667603,
-0.24589428305625916,
0.23754237592220306,
-0.06694678962230682,
-0.24732698500156403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14521v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14521v1
|
Synthetic Data Generation for Intersectional Fairness by Leveraging Hierarchical Group Structure
| 2024-05-23T13:03:23 | 2024-05-23T13:03:23 |
Gaurav Maheshwari, Aurélien Bellet, Pascal Denis, Mikaela Keller
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a data augmentation approach specifically
tailored to enhance intersectional fairness in classification tasks. Our method
capitalizes on the hierarchical structure inherent to intersectionality, by
viewing groups as intersections of their parent categories. This perspective
allows us to augment data for smaller groups by learning a transformation
function that combines data from these parent groups. Our empirical analysis,
conducted on four diverse datasets including both text and images, reveals that
classifiers trained with this data augmentation approach achieve superior
intersectional fairness and are more robust to ``leveling down'' when compared
to methods optimizing traditional group fairness metrics.
|
[
-0.46626582741737366,
-0.6294344663619995,
0.5616750121116638,
-0.01873880811035633,
0.16690731048583984,
0.46915993094444275,
0.30168449878692627,
-0.7542939186096191,
0.11934254318475723,
0.35228949785232544,
-0.507039487361908,
-0.25666841864585876,
-0.5486139059066772,
0.030882997438311577,
-0.5069589614868164,
0.9712671637535095,
0.33631518483161926,
0.2144770473241806,
-0.4084826111793518,
-0.19560883939266205,
-0.388060063123703,
-0.7361235022544861,
-0.57710862159729,
-0.3223491907119751,
0.37751084566116333,
0.5738924741744995,
1.0205020904541016,
1.0864983797073364,
0.315630704164505,
0.4364810585975647,
0.19705788791179657,
0.15965703129768372,
-0.580963671207428,
-0.3854931592941284,
-0.38900911808013916,
-0.5667592287063599,
-0.4414210319519043,
-0.024720922112464905,
0.7151703834533691,
1.5104906558990479,
-0.13961488008499146,
-0.09846744686365128,
0.008108529262244701,
0.6460427641868591,
-0.7142323851585388,
-0.06894683092832565,
-0.9565110802650452,
0.5280851721763611,
-0.36470532417297363,
-0.5242517590522766,
-0.08267620950937271,
-0.7465510368347168,
-0.1891973465681076,
-0.8212446570396423,
0.6768794059753418,
0.5057722926139832,
0.5431252121925354,
0.2926764488220215,
-0.5128387808799744,
0.22342929244041443,
-0.6307686567306519,
0.7541706562042236,
-0.20777961611747742,
0.10088043659925461,
0.2949143052101135,
0.7261977195739746,
-0.2696642279624939,
-0.7588239312171936,
-0.9792218208312988,
0.3871883749961853,
-0.3782206177711487,
0.19134235382080078,
-0.017670033499598503,
0.3307287096977234,
0.3341856002807617,
0.7914407253265381,
-0.390569269657135,
0.23263050615787506,
-0.802317202091217,
0.14090706408023834,
0.8913710117340088,
0.4540920853614807,
0.49589022994041443,
-0.24225729703903198,
-0.3128117024898529,
-0.07439684867858887,
-0.6760926246643066,
0.3318181335926056,
0.7089588642120361,
0.4445164203643799,
0.07283221185207367,
0.5888194441795349,
-0.5029052495956421,
0.5736504197120667,
0.46684229373931885,
0.19418051838874817,
0.7045555114746094,
-0.558750569820404,
-0.10134649276733398,
0.34967276453971863,
0.4562402069568634,
0.8842254877090454,
0.07860540598630905,
-0.41815871000289917,
-0.3283587694168091,
0.23755043745040894,
0.2878284752368927,
-0.5955801606178284,
-0.23067203164100647,
0.09241688996553421,
-0.4810522198677063,
-0.5583246350288391,
0.3510863184928894,
-0.8070139288902283,
-0.34962743520736694,
-0.6554121971130371,
0.3546397387981415,
0.009283916093409061,
0.009609846398234367,
0.13809269666671753,
-0.27834153175354004,
0.15465542674064636,
0.2272527515888214,
-1.061811923980713,
0.5425170660018921,
0.8190122246742249,
0.5617142915725708,
-0.3777196705341339,
-0.10204245150089264,
-0.7828711271286011,
0.3268473744392395,
-0.2758505642414093,
0.7027866244316101,
-0.7707610726356506,
-0.28719276189804077,
-0.19164058566093445,
0.0722883865237236,
-0.07731031626462936,
-0.7707831263542175,
0.3260681629180908,
-0.2132078856229782,
0.39776143431663513,
-0.0035789296962320805,
-0.30480918288230896,
-0.17228206992149353,
0.11427755653858185,
-0.6922266483306885,
0.8802819848060608,
0.41458287835121155,
-0.713136613368988,
1.0748991966247559,
-0.6787453293800354,
-0.5878497958183289,
0.37939053773880005,
-0.5700879693031311,
-0.5692049264907837,
0.13660895824432373,
0.5593932867050171,
0.16120792925357819,
0.29564228653907776,
0.30513066053390503,
-0.3823621869087219,
-0.41126778721809387,
-0.04921439290046692,
0.04621227830648422,
0.6150192618370056,
0.025617223232984543,
-0.1954358071088791,
0.22468067705631256,
-0.8180034756660461,
-0.010113958269357681,
-0.0543622262775898,
-0.0275772325694561,
-0.3627277910709381,
0.14358501136302948,
0.10648646950721741,
0.3956807851791382,
-0.09017879515886307,
-0.7694450616836548,
-0.12087297439575195,
-0.6118144392967224,
-0.04004952684044838,
1.1827993392944336,
-0.17939141392707825,
0.6720004081726074,
-0.7405553460121155,
0.37037062644958496,
0.07294505834579468,
0.42208582162857056,
0.3992491364479065,
-0.4778245985507965,
-0.6106072664260864,
-0.24096737802028656,
0.4322049021720886,
0.4136451780796051,
-1.14885413646698,
0.7810779809951782,
-0.5351672768592834,
-0.00816505029797554,
-0.7240103483200073,
-0.22915157675743103,
0.049858950078487396,
0.559516191482544,
0.45932844281196594,
-0.4751400649547577,
-0.7653825879096985,
-1.0309569835662842,
-0.08209338039159775,
0.06034991890192032,
-0.051389459520578384,
0.21576926112174988,
0.2635364830493927,
-0.08812684565782547,
1.213079810142517,
-0.22912532091140747,
-0.18319165706634521,
-0.0907370075583458,
0.07061267644166946,
0.08430568128824234,
0.7859582901000977,
0.6042019724845886,
-1.1367372274398804,
-0.24470046162605286,
0.2882368862628937,
-0.5287594795227051,
-0.4133286476135254,
0.01386004127562046,
-0.18324565887451172,
-0.08531960099935532,
0.48994240164756775,
0.2263028919696808,
0.7382490038871765,
0.3378233313560486,
-0.366115003824234,
0.19322320818901062,
0.26010653376579285,
0.5439107418060303,
-0.9386976361274719,
-0.14500266313552856,
-0.23720668256282806,
-0.5416366457939148,
-0.748980700969696,
0.05592259392142296,
-0.40026867389678955,
0.21081356704235077,
-0.4254949986934662,
0.34261512756347656,
0.05597620829939842,
-0.48015767335891724,
-0.5069180130958557,
-0.07119101285934448,
-0.22818216681480408,
0.4226597249507904,
-0.06668847054243088,
0.6215967535972595,
0.41022950410842896,
-0.6190236806869507,
0.16216817498207092,
0.2532642185688019,
-0.24602895975112915,
1.0430798530578613,
-0.5953795313835144,
-0.12204216420650482,
-0.5233436226844788,
0.22849620878696442,
-0.8415942192077637,
-0.49207189679145813,
0.21468482911586761,
-0.5016171336174011,
-0.29879751801490784,
-0.32330071926116943,
-0.6736573576927185,
-0.23030979931354523,
-0.32888084650039673,
1.1527448892593384,
0.6173064708709717,
-1.0124726295471191,
0.5330707430839539,
0.7713584899902344,
-0.21206307411193848,
-0.20939315855503082,
-0.8810096979141235,
-0.15769892930984497,
-0.5694056749343872,
-0.8525559902191162,
0.852638304233551,
0.21167230606079102,
-0.284030556678772,
-0.04490251466631889,
0.21670447289943695,
-0.09147444367408752,
-0.254032164812088,
0.36447495222091675,
0.19391535222530365,
0.25719207525253296,
0.11164207756519318,
0.38696515560150146,
-0.17335179448127747,
-0.07850725203752518,
0.1410004198551178,
0.4907257556915283,
0.29390114545822144,
-0.3386966288089752,
-0.24679160118103027,
0.5156877636909485,
0.050917573273181915,
0.1041409820318222,
0.417020708322525,
0.5608127117156982,
-0.6950666904449463,
-0.07017715275287628,
-0.32667985558509827,
-0.13264484703540802,
-0.594930112361908,
0.15266291797161102,
-0.36802437901496887,
-1.072481632232666,
0.5536805391311646,
0.24949000775814056,
0.08318445086479187,
0.3774834871292114,
0.33968207240104675,
0.27860134840011597,
1.5725146532058716,
0.5629143118858337,
0.15393027663230896,
0.4677307605743408,
0.13287073373794556,
0.26542428135871887,
-0.6295881867408752,
-0.5085605382919312,
-0.46569302678108215,
-0.6317154169082642,
-0.9968063831329346,
-0.46720123291015625,
0.7413765788078308,
-0.0034447554498910904,
-0.20907923579216003,
-0.11708039790391922,
-0.7576117515563965,
0.54190593957901,
0.6421076655387878,
0.3196522295475006,
0.62751305103302,
0.387806236743927,
0.4086814820766449,
-0.2948460876941681,
-0.7509588003158569,
-0.1366751492023468,
1.139724850654602,
0.2715253233909607,
0.511975884437561,
-0.05557113513350487,
0.7414646744728088,
0.2926871180534363,
0.2807801365852356,
-0.5928643345832825,
0.5290966033935547,
-0.2762974202632904,
-0.39287856221199036,
-0.056199751794338226,
-0.9881336092948914,
-1.247231364250183,
0.4230504631996155,
-0.46749553084373474,
-0.7481694221496582,
0.6297293305397034,
0.09549479186534882,
-0.26005446910858154,
0.4011951982975006,
-0.48077625036239624,
0.5222645401954651,
-0.1060979813337326,
-0.12157054990530014,
-0.28143858909606934,
-0.5954098701477051,
0.5700748562812805,
-0.2601114809513092,
0.39897844195365906,
0.10148583352565765,
0.046550389379262924,
0.7106292843818665,
-0.7453427910804749,
0.44838398694992065,
-0.1892170011997223,
0.26305893063545227,
-0.04735441505908966,
-0.3305109441280365,
0.17360006272792816,
-0.15943798422813416,
0.09278624504804611,
0.1932520866394043,
-0.42926928400993347,
-0.5445206165313721,
-0.7589294910430908,
0.518290638923645,
-0.37849438190460205,
-0.3051178455352783,
-0.2993313670158386,
-0.9359722137451172,
-0.319261372089386,
-0.10127424448728561,
0.0014253270346671343,
0.16179387271404266,
0.31152668595314026,
0.0774163082242012,
0.03233000263571739,
-0.048221405595541,
0.2882617115974426,
0.1722724586725235,
-0.4016914963722229,
-0.4996998608112335,
0.8758583068847656,
-0.00964259821921587,
0.5042062401771545,
0.025954801589250565,
-0.0403401255607605,
-0.45387235283851624,
-0.6360754370689392,
-0.3576279878616333,
-0.34313416481018066,
-0.3395549952983856,
-0.03214116767048836,
-0.628971517086029,
-0.39212891459465027,
-0.48132097721099854,
-0.3538423180580139,
0.03964652121067047,
-1.0650055408477783,
0.3867740333080292,
-0.3598756492137909,
0.244362011551857,
0.724329948425293,
-0.5555258393287659,
0.5883718729019165,
-0.3015952408313751,
0.5868653655052185,
0.40836936235427856,
0.23010225594043732,
-0.12292183190584183,
-0.25104275345802307,
0.13478782773017883,
0.19456544518470764,
-0.3462745249271393,
-0.28060802817344666,
0.07236061990261078,
-0.16369889676570892,
0.5642556548118591,
0.18218505382537842,
0.03271026536822319,
0.8906757235527039,
-0.5616275668144226,
0.45671406388282776,
0.5119886994361877,
-0.793096661567688,
0.4162026345729828,
-0.2441132366657257,
-0.2718879282474518,
0.6281076073646545,
0.06769907474517822,
-0.15807750821113586,
-0.4657295346260071,
-0.7616007924079895,
-1.0782285928726196,
0.8297383785247803,
0.7225490808486938,
-0.12712515890598297,
0.2636549770832062,
0.19162194430828094,
0.20910011231899261,
0.3269626498222351,
-0.9084975719451904,
-0.19209828972816467,
-0.12186098843812943,
-0.5196447968482971,
0.42678704857826233,
0.4524688124656677,
-0.2057057023048401,
-0.6468636989593506,
0.16796688735485077,
-0.15392063558101654,
-0.0690581426024437,
-0.008364265784621239,
0.3115159571170807,
-0.22100196778774261,
0.03932897001504898,
0.002113976515829563,
0.7349375486373901,
0.005196280311793089,
-0.014246641658246517,
0.19536611437797546,
-0.1898987889289856,
0.08000601828098297,
0.5629390478134155,
-0.2646881341934204,
-0.31996163725852966,
0.1281346082687378,
0.44177961349487305,
-0.3780166506767273,
-0.42793020606040955,
0.3640556037425995,
0.05666448175907135,
-0.2850339710712433,
0.015372944064438343,
0.33251282572746277,
-0.7987999320030212,
0.27047109603881836,
0.6463973522186279,
0.0238749161362648,
0.7887405157089233,
-0.7980854511260986,
0.5982970595359802,
0.4739798605442047,
-0.19203011691570282,
0.08673631399869919,
0.6515254378318787,
0.07878345251083374,
-0.06863249093294144,
0.1159672811627388,
-0.35275229811668396,
-0.6763505935668945,
0.5737358331680298,
0.39903995394706726,
0.4904087483882904,
-0.24862471222877502,
0.09622365236282349,
0.3444933593273163,
0.20128591358661652,
0.22282327711582184,
0.029918881133198738,
0.01335294358432293,
-0.6708259582519531,
-0.39671456813812256,
-0.5938761830329895,
-0.3121388554573059,
0.006004687864333391,
-0.5567899346351624,
-0.0007686757016927004,
-0.44877076148986816,
-0.023874854668974876,
-0.02045009844005108,
-0.2677745521068573,
-0.4539773762226105,
0.599599301815033,
0.0023660599254071712,
0.17068445682525635,
-0.8063554763793945,
0.02667582593858242,
0.5361542105674744,
-0.2465786337852478,
-0.3902963697910309,
0.06110212951898575,
-0.2993035614490509,
-0.9462502598762512,
0.44261837005615234,
0.40123116970062256,
0.051889434456825256,
-0.1271487921476364,
-0.6340151429176331,
-0.4459582567214966,
0.8963111639022827,
-0.02981475368142128,
-0.36921945214271545,
-0.11299755424261093,
0.9165481925010681,
0.39743706583976746,
-0.5843064188957214,
0.03538280352950096,
0.6346038579940796,
0.46409985423088074,
0.23895040154457092,
-1.0459829568862915,
0.21608585119247437,
-0.33775439858436584,
0.35300159454345703,
0.1045413464307785,
-0.16781768202781677,
0.8019688129425049,
0.005217765923589468,
-0.41167691349983215,
-0.09782713651657104,
0.41272327303886414,
0.6107712984085083,
0.605951189994812,
1.0767751932144165,
0.7971200942993164,
0.5983977913856506,
-0.5299617648124695,
0.9813414216041565,
0.1215319111943245,
-0.03633612021803856,
0.8943219184875488,
0.01720123551785946,
0.11439445614814758,
0.5054506063461304,
-0.2798100709915161,
0.35334983468055725,
0.5371019840240479,
0.11185020953416824,
0.5184414386749268,
0.4799569547176361,
-0.2038719803094864,
-0.33441540598869324,
-0.4652198553085327,
-0.4453652799129486,
0.3690902590751648,
0.313014954328537,
-0.14217880368232727,
-0.24131722748279572,
0.04459865018725395,
-0.3206842243671417,
0.3963128328323364,
-0.8669146299362183,
0.7351722717285156,
-0.18072262406349182,
-0.3525082468986511,
0.16649813950061798,
0.08061719685792923,
0.7300146818161011,
0.1233552098274231,
-0.41240835189819336,
-0.016004065051674843,
0.15449723601341248,
-0.647115170955658,
-1.0829576253890991,
0.35220640897750854,
-0.2974623143672943,
-0.2131708413362503,
-0.006496883928775787,
0.49666085839271545,
-0.5874554514884949,
-0.716938853263855,
0.15179960429668427,
0.32941269874572754,
-0.050732553005218506,
0.1802571415901184,
-0.5516754388809204,
-0.13362514972686768,
-0.15027855336666107,
0.5158401131629944,
0.024706944823265076,
0.46542537212371826,
-0.2769213020801544,
0.4309825599193573,
0.9204246997833252,
0.07588575035333633,
0.4110443592071533,
0.20475131273269653,
0.9641183614730835,
-0.7034887075424194,
-0.775307297706604,
-0.5609339475631714,
0.8626118302345276,
-0.6320509314537048,
0.03329337760806084,
0.48036956787109375,
0.7871032953262329,
1.1506381034851074,
0.3275618851184845,
0.9208167791366577,
-0.20801003277301788,
0.7178455591201782,
-0.7091575860977173,
0.4504860043525696,
-0.6806538105010986,
0.04650874808430672,
-0.3382960557937622,
-0.7906081676483154,
-0.41586488485336304,
0.5964331030845642,
-0.5177964568138123,
0.5666257739067078,
0.30508124828338623,
0.8751774430274963,
-0.48686206340789795,
0.19301916658878326,
0.08574880659580231,
-0.233136385679245,
0.43163391947746277,
0.7802067995071411,
1.0619573593139648,
-0.5874764919281006,
0.32074636220932007,
-0.359424889087677,
-0.47637319564819336,
-0.09819184988737106,
-0.36776718497276306,
-0.826755702495575,
-0.368474543094635,
-0.1932186335325241,
-0.2401738166809082,
0.22373762726783752,
0.5215181708335876,
1.047755479812622,
-0.7742684483528137,
0.05879727005958557,
-0.44270387291908264,
0.27346205711364746,
0.26505351066589355,
-0.47447025775909424,
0.19188101589679718,
-0.454761266708374,
-1.065455436706543,
0.18843911588191986,
0.07814662158489227,
0.17556032538414001,
0.08709513396024704,
-0.08690901100635529,
0.19235359132289886,
-0.11691077798604965,
0.5724965929985046,
0.013229402713477612,
-0.14938615262508392,
-0.44512292742729187,
-0.6054201126098633,
0.13932590186595917,
0.2894817590713501,
0.7354723215103149,
-1.0118602514266968,
0.372381329536438,
0.3409636616706848,
0.7158123850822449,
0.21985957026481628,
0.7041621208190918,
0.7520752549171448,
-0.8930971622467041,
0.21074418723583221,
0.32569172978401184,
0.26953524351119995,
0.4686095118522644,
-0.47268545627593994,
0.8198325037956238,
0.3411976397037506,
-0.5300213098526001,
-0.9002480506896973,
0.31529608368873596,
-0.912284255027771,
0.08258242905139923,
0.7610925436019897,
0.5255671143531799,
-0.1090557724237442,
-0.4481583833694458,
-0.08724828064441681,
0.16023248434066772,
-0.2708963453769684,
1.0618329048156738,
0.036204993724823,
-0.4021463990211487,
0.06601247191429138,
-0.17095379531383514,
0.5427542924880981,
0.4066220819950104,
-1.408489465713501,
-0.3669928312301636,
0.7908315658569336,
-0.08614659309387207,
0.2402096390724182,
0.6329522728919983,
-0.49662184715270996,
0.4831751883029938,
-0.21215438842773438,
-0.07752733677625656,
0.1035098284482956,
-0.3310609757900238,
-0.1296183466911316,
0.27296435832977295,
-0.6176654696464539,
-0.4557530879974365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14507v1
|
Unchosen Experts Can Contribute Too: Unleashing MoE Models' Power by Self-Contrast
| 2024-05-23T12:45:29 | 2024-05-23T12:45:29 |
Chufan Shi, Cheng Yang, Xinyu Zhu, Jiahao Wang, Taiqiang Wu, Siheng Li, Deng Cai, Yujiu Yang, Yu Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) has emerged as a prominent architecture for scaling
model size while maintaining computational efficiency. In MoE, each token in
the input sequence activates a different subset of experts determined by a
routing mechanism. However, the unchosen experts in MoE models do not
contribute to the output, potentially leading to underutilization of the
model's capacity. In this work, we first conduct exploratory studies to
demonstrate that increasing the number of activated experts does not
necessarily improve and can even degrade the output quality. Then, we show that
output distributions from an MoE model using different routing strategies
substantially differ, indicating that different experts do not always act
synergistically. Motivated by these findings, we propose Self-Contrast
Mixture-of-Experts (SCMoE), a training-free strategy that utilizes unchosen
experts in a self-contrast manner during inference. In SCMoE, the next-token
probabilities are determined by contrasting the outputs from strong and weak
activation using the same MoE model. Our method is conceptually simple and
computationally lightweight, as it incurs minimal latency compared to greedy
decoding. Experiments on several benchmarks (GSM8K, StrategyQA, MBPP and
HumanEval) demonstrate that SCMoE can consistently enhance Mixtral 8x7B's
reasoning capability across various domains. For example, it improves the
accuracy on GSM8K from 61.79 to 66.94. Moreover, combining SCMoE with
self-consistency yields additional gains, increasing major@20 accuracy from
75.59 to 78.31.
|
[
-0.5554593205451965,
-0.15491609275341034,
0.4723701477050781,
0.3068538308143616,
-0.5420511960983276,
0.05704621598124504,
-0.30392780900001526,
-0.4170370101928711,
0.4095976948738098,
0.6029961705207825,
-0.22675637900829315,
-0.017026610672473907,
-0.7636585235595703,
0.14730830490589142,
-0.18528687953948975,
0.8131295442581177,
0.3237549662590027,
0.15045280754566193,
-0.2596420645713806,
-0.13950574398040771,
-0.4114933907985687,
-0.1033487319946289,
-0.43961748480796814,
-0.4472917914390564,
0.2169191688299179,
0.4025275707244873,
0.35785651206970215,
0.6385859251022339,
0.2638174891471863,
0.38108861446380615,
0.0757862851023674,
0.36609771847724915,
-0.5086597204208374,
0.36377906799316406,
-0.5218807458877563,
-0.36666229367256165,
-0.352385938167572,
-0.20423740148544312,
0.15040309727191925,
0.5026598572731018,
-0.32861217856407166,
-0.16956833004951477,
0.2176217883825302,
0.6378629207611084,
-0.8933994770050049,
-0.029084235429763794,
-0.9875653386116028,
-0.26986145973205566,
-0.13249804079532623,
-0.420706182718277,
-0.5473471879959106,
0.43380701541900635,
0.040997691452503204,
-0.5374880433082581,
0.2443321794271469,
0.04561425372958183,
0.35013896226882935,
0.6509861350059509,
-0.7210556864738464,
-0.20289203524589539,
-0.5466755628585815,
0.880183756351471,
-1.1615039110183716,
0.0702376440167427,
0.23193359375,
0.18420690298080444,
-0.2634979486465454,
-0.24293671548366547,
-0.29281410574913025,
0.20673823356628418,
0.04071834683418274,
0.6246102452278137,
-0.15441635251045227,
0.12226837128400803,
-0.24406391382217407,
0.35474416613578796,
-0.003091915277764201,
0.2839874029159546,
-0.7678805589675903,
-0.13166402280330658,
1.074133038520813,
0.17964912950992584,
-0.14140048623085022,
-0.2765587568283081,
-0.4895823001861572,
0.08731807768344879,
-0.36745908856391907,
-0.18526163697242737,
0.29600465297698975,
-0.06689270585775375,
0.2844647169113159,
0.29431474208831787,
-0.4259084165096283,
0.39853471517562866,
0.6277937889099121,
0.028443828225135803,
0.073801189661026,
-0.08071072399616241,
-0.18811053037643433,
0.16436901688575745,
1.0251762866973877,
0.38794395327568054,
-0.042975980788469315,
-0.3070581257343292,
-0.33067476749420166,
-0.17656680941581726,
0.4864331781864166,
-0.767795979976654,
-0.7002776861190796,
0.09792950004339218,
-0.43209174275398254,
-0.32684755325317383,
0.18339566886425018,
-0.9360456466674805,
-0.4210485517978668,
-0.06609676778316498,
0.696901261806488,
-0.24304239451885223,
-0.5604627728462219,
0.19903722405433655,
-0.2653522491455078,
-0.18206654489040375,
0.2712309956550598,
-1.0936492681503296,
0.2355847805738449,
0.27867361903190613,
0.47288307547569275,
-0.2657816708087921,
-0.21627205610275269,
-0.12531961500644684,
0.24952642619609833,
-0.5474982857704163,
0.8822832107543945,
-0.4103032052516937,
-0.7998530864715576,
-0.5388251543045044,
-0.5467875599861145,
-0.22034519910812378,
-0.704486608505249,
0.33167147636413574,
-0.43104732036590576,
0.06074013188481331,
-0.27519288659095764,
-0.6799052357673645,
-0.19326166808605194,
-0.3391694128513336,
-0.2602774202823639,
1.091598629951477,
-0.06787904351949692,
-0.7703544497489929,
0.21489675343036652,
-0.5979965925216675,
-0.3722265362739563,
-0.18487660586833954,
-0.4824795722961426,
-0.10919362306594849,
0.7136509418487549,
0.3698364198207855,
0.6719914674758911,
-0.11608576774597168,
0.09461656212806702,
-0.415292352437973,
-0.2978268563747406,
0.27941298484802246,
-0.535286545753479,
0.7722797393798828,
0.3798789083957672,
-0.4683944284915924,
0.013250963762402534,
-1.020891785621643,
0.06746382266283035,
-0.008757616393268108,
-0.34402838349342346,
-0.5973175764083862,
-0.0015186700038611889,
-0.49256473779678345,
0.3599725067615509,
0.06686951220035553,
-0.5254368782043457,
0.23963101208209991,
-0.15274500846862793,
0.5098069310188293,
1.1403539180755615,
0.16778549551963806,
0.6863654851913452,
-0.16241507232189178,
0.1759791374206543,
0.40958648920059204,
0.059017110615968704,
-0.1781938076019287,
-0.5319017767906189,
-0.8579221367835999,
-0.5317675471305847,
0.540686845779419,
0.232879638671875,
-0.7888393998146057,
0.46595585346221924,
-0.34406206011772156,
-0.5880188941955566,
-0.9476253390312195,
0.5228597521781921,
0.3046260178089142,
0.6850148439407349,
0.48224902153015137,
-0.4447126090526581,
-0.23027533292770386,
-1.1006015539169312,
-0.2875487506389618,
0.13355745375156403,
-0.1962769627571106,
0.08345697075128555,
0.28553512692451477,
0.050665318965911865,
0.8125274181365967,
-0.29460448026657104,
-0.17035922408103943,
-0.04174774885177612,
0.4175567924976349,
-0.01702730543911457,
0.644916832447052,
0.42199885845184326,
-0.5331060290336609,
-0.5663483738899231,
0.0019963013473898172,
-0.811260998249054,
-0.369727224111557,
-0.11334577202796936,
-0.26385024189949036,
-0.13023363053798676,
0.477355420589447,
-0.39648446440696716,
0.34484928846359253,
0.46340492367744446,
-0.15781280398368835,
0.3800720274448395,
-0.5205000042915344,
0.28447213768959045,
-0.9342616200447083,
-0.4571360945701599,
-0.10940426588058472,
0.09124407172203064,
-0.5213907957077026,
0.13281847536563873,
0.03780480474233627,
0.2020954042673111,
-0.13810767233371735,
0.4855737090110779,
-0.528688907623291,
-0.11635714769363403,
-0.39285722374916077,
-0.09600015729665756,
0.035426065325737,
0.6626070141792297,
-0.20187078416347504,
0.8724150061607361,
0.6454862952232361,
-0.673617959022522,
0.045233361423015594,
-0.13393634557724,
-0.26554104685783386,
0.5725744962692261,
-0.6763646602630615,
0.14454036951065063,
0.10646775364875793,
0.03467680886387825,
-1.0461293458938599,
-0.18254727125167847,
0.14211435616016388,
-0.5049657225608826,
0.3584327697753906,
-0.05156474560499191,
-0.4178900718688965,
-0.22335511445999146,
-0.22733238339424133,
0.44303396344184875,
0.7792153358459473,
-0.3634077310562134,
1.1641671657562256,
0.03545388579368591,
-0.021655607968568802,
-0.4034503996372223,
-0.8617684841156006,
-0.11712442338466644,
-0.16068978607654572,
-0.7384034991264343,
0.18695156276226044,
-0.14666679501533508,
-0.10205550491809845,
0.07982659339904785,
-0.49224361777305603,
-0.08224557340145111,
0.12188002467155457,
0.28502747416496277,
-0.10416878759860992,
-0.20304107666015625,
0.05076851323246956,
0.5578054189682007,
-0.22355227172374725,
0.1703217327594757,
-0.27541065216064453,
0.20272821187973022,
0.15186749398708344,
-0.5857127904891968,
-0.5647416710853577,
0.6533931493759155,
0.5243174433708191,
-0.339216411113739,
0.5022346377372742,
0.43655478954315186,
0.25046107172966003,
-0.20126847922801971,
-0.793964147567749,
-0.388947457075119,
-0.5221814513206482,
0.12936756014823914,
-0.3715992569923401,
-0.46480971574783325,
0.680176854133606,
-0.16648834943771362,
0.19666174054145813,
0.6825360655784607,
0.4089403450489044,
-0.2628064751625061,
1.1950486898422241,
0.40059179067611694,
0.21625477075576782,
0.2883923351764679,
-0.2641630470752716,
0.20853044092655182,
-0.9880778193473816,
-0.3067711293697357,
-0.2803230583667755,
-0.3701511323451996,
-0.4488484859466553,
-0.2849067747592926,
0.45522192120552063,
0.23999735713005066,
-0.10494386404752731,
0.00767049053683877,
-0.5670605897903442,
0.41080793738365173,
0.7902704477310181,
0.28057435154914856,
0.3174441158771515,
0.23106786608695984,
-0.08951504528522491,
0.09780171513557434,
-1.3040169477462769,
-0.050255537033081055,
1.330458402633667,
0.0037248360458761454,
1.0027024745941162,
-0.17909759283065796,
0.9777661561965942,
0.46592432260513306,
0.23893482983112335,
-0.42452290654182434,
0.6561903953552246,
-0.1361762136220932,
-0.6447144746780396,
-0.2568502724170685,
-0.5642239451408386,
-0.728329062461853,
0.6348426342010498,
-0.3745953440666199,
-0.4371955394744873,
0.7187812924385071,
0.40193971991539,
-0.34995579719543457,
0.48953887820243835,
-0.683575451374054,
0.3246482312679291,
-0.19054943323135376,
-0.41632553935050964,
-0.4875466823577881,
-0.6143043637275696,
0.2247544825077057,
-0.13672588765621185,
0.1883833408355713,
-0.0472981333732605,
0.09588588029146194,
0.9346556067466736,
-0.42051437497138977,
0.8559220433235168,
0.04771775007247925,
-0.07115226984024048,
0.4045117199420929,
0.32212600111961365,
0.31705859303474426,
-0.2741716802120209,
-0.24224117398262024,
0.4737401008605957,
-0.4541285037994385,
-0.9809786677360535,
-0.8205751180648804,
0.6859270930290222,
-0.9346336126327515,
-0.8551903963088989,
-0.12464851886034012,
-0.53193598985672,
-0.19625619053840637,
0.4804091155529022,
0.6136893033981323,
0.5216062664985657,
0.37236660718917847,
0.41994741559028625,
0.781751811504364,
0.47172147035598755,
0.32399553060531616,
0.4206346273422241,
0.17709395289421082,
-0.6059184670448303,
0.9405587315559387,
0.2927512526512146,
0.4979065954685211,
-0.03876739740371704,
0.27669569849967957,
-0.2159905731678009,
-0.6976692080497742,
-0.6404507756233215,
0.05610651895403862,
-0.786281168460846,
-0.2352409064769745,
-0.6133601665496826,
0.07772891968488693,
-0.33203062415122986,
-0.39257460832595825,
-0.6871019601821899,
-0.47050076723098755,
-0.17519822716712952,
-0.046508997678756714,
0.13314561545848846,
0.8145620822906494,
-0.30880045890808105,
0.633057177066803,
-0.4568789303302765,
-0.048462748527526855,
0.6240198016166687,
0.04643520340323448,
0.4245448410511017,
-0.6170497536659241,
-0.323911190032959,
0.13932833075523376,
-0.4798353910446167,
-0.9108640551567078,
0.03616015613079071,
-0.08006253838539124,
0.8876639008522034,
0.99495929479599,
0.31586953997612,
0.7111874222755432,
-0.10751664638519287,
0.6020836234092712,
0.42264652252197266,
-1.0121511220932007,
0.1994616538286209,
-0.3905521333217621,
-0.04802953451871872,
0.5133953094482422,
0.132951557636261,
0.24954275786876678,
-0.544579029083252,
-0.88388991355896,
-0.7393265962600708,
0.44722315669059753,
0.3293372690677643,
0.14064158499240875,
0.04078303277492523,
0.18575984239578247,
0.23158778250217438,
0.5014095902442932,
-0.3370288610458374,
-0.14614756405353546,
-0.5493557453155518,
-0.2264549881219864,
0.07935157418251038,
-0.3458293378353119,
-0.27002453804016113,
-0.19731834530830383,
0.6009576320648193,
0.10540568083524704,
0.2965458035469055,
0.31750407814979553,
0.08250994235277176,
-0.09903116524219513,
0.35294651985168457,
0.3589847683906555,
0.8555390238761902,
-0.12955737113952637,
0.2621753513813019,
0.2264014184474945,
0.04304046556353569,
0.04233293607831001,
-0.2306094467639923,
-0.1946815848350525,
-0.10184527933597565,
0.5636611580848694,
0.6524361968040466,
0.6036505103111267,
-0.2058078795671463,
0.34154263138771057,
0.4460063874721527,
-0.5508967041969299,
0.33690693974494934,
0.5266872048377991,
0.03154539689421654,
0.2925451397895813,
0.7223855257034302,
0.42165279388427734,
0.25823599100112915,
-0.3293271064758301,
-0.11087562888860703,
0.22347600758075714,
-0.012636201456189156,
-0.16907180845737457,
0.7306180596351624,
0.6522445678710938,
-0.1044873371720314,
0.5207913517951965,
-0.17068585753440857,
-0.3650805354118347,
0.6975966691970825,
0.4664551615715027,
0.49030742049217224,
-0.5494219660758972,
-0.07304439693689346,
-0.07315347343683243,
0.10571401566267014,
-0.18787144124507904,
-0.08165214210748672,
-0.26921558380126953,
-0.6510478258132935,
-0.2933565378189087,
0.005193383898586035,
-0.08378610759973526,
-0.30297574400901794,
-1.0647863149642944,
-0.14482465386390686,
-0.33419349789619446,
-0.061859071254730225,
-0.06768607348203659,
-0.05125594511628151,
-0.6067786812782288,
0.20775727927684784,
-0.3817991018295288,
0.7712348103523254,
-0.9318407773971558,
0.5607351660728455,
0.6014069318771362,
-0.2494492381811142,
-0.6137378811836243,
-0.12341807782649994,
-0.34256765246391296,
-0.9017531275749207,
0.4304862320423126,
-0.06314372271299362,
-0.20897513628005981,
0.07623426616191864,
-0.6078416705131531,
-0.41863977909088135,
1.1466832160949707,
-0.018094416707754135,
-0.4326576292514801,
0.08578569442033768,
-0.35777145624160767,
0.4481754004955292,
-0.54323810338974,
0.5033942461013794,
-0.03263217955827713,
0.2477102130651474,
0.08077071607112885,
-0.7877252697944641,
-0.03265701234340668,
-0.13265326619148254,
-0.024958869442343712,
0.1834341436624527,
-0.9425266981124878,
1.0305256843566895,
-0.24928034842014313,
0.07589731365442276,
-0.209030881524086,
1.1152360439300537,
0.14339721202850342,
0.33919185400009155,
0.7538325786590576,
0.42732545733451843,
0.5819652080535889,
0.47211092710494995,
0.7276934385299683,
-0.3401454985141754,
0.3411366939544678,
1.0147743225097656,
0.00301183364354074,
0.6825858354568481,
0.5408621430397034,
0.0013035793090239167,
0.6204854249954224,
0.4999437928199768,
0.0006806761375628412,
0.75008624792099,
-0.2056853175163269,
-0.14581750333309174,
-1.0605037212371826,
0.38128700852394104,
-0.4448395073413849,
0.38222140073776245,
0.2853514850139618,
-0.3654363453388214,
-0.4272819459438324,
-0.08355545997619629,
-0.07539842277765274,
0.1386956423521042,
-0.5246097445487976,
0.6375847458839417,
0.09754820913076401,
-0.5066300630569458,
0.3381763994693756,
-0.22533820569515228,
0.7679182887077332,
-0.5718646049499512,
0.10462908446788788,
-0.40874412655830383,
0.05115813389420509,
-0.2649613320827484,
-0.6604896187782288,
-0.1101946085691452,
-0.46145039796829224,
-0.3043729364871979,
0.12374235689640045,
0.6520801782608032,
-0.3584021329879761,
-0.5085981488227844,
0.3968718647956848,
0.6189020872116089,
0.26286235451698303,
-0.05061929672956467,
-0.6226076483726501,
-0.2796264886856079,
0.10620845854282379,
-0.2744544446468353,
0.6002994775772095,
0.760301947593689,
0.03730121627449989,
1.0354520082473755,
0.5907085537910461,
0.07861127704381943,
0.3533726632595062,
-0.432343065738678,
1.054815411567688,
-0.331560879945755,
-0.692706823348999,
-0.6760478019714355,
0.5189064145088196,
-0.3451835811138153,
-0.30372825264930725,
0.9723504781723022,
0.21510523557662964,
0.8785008192062378,
-0.1736285537481308,
0.7061727046966553,
0.2635768949985504,
0.17154590785503387,
-0.5808587074279785,
0.4795219898223877,
-0.883725643157959,
0.29067280888557434,
0.005693963263183832,
-0.37560907006263733,
0.29611071944236755,
0.5768743753433228,
-0.2879602909088135,
0.18745259940624237,
0.3513144552707672,
0.6792158484458923,
-0.40358635783195496,
-0.23526115715503693,
0.44164028763771057,
0.38770943880081177,
0.12947526574134827,
0.38477662205696106,
0.5051884055137634,
-0.17107583582401276,
0.5386812686920166,
-0.4351637661457062,
-0.2809413969516754,
-0.6284127831459045,
-0.8199031949043274,
-1.1688846349716187,
-0.3450121283531189,
-0.23589135706424713,
-0.13117410242557526,
0.08918295055627823,
0.7845218181610107,
1.0130040645599365,
-0.6161531805992126,
0.040126651525497437,
0.0770287960767746,
0.10378085821866989,
-0.413772851228714,
-0.16489030420780182,
0.22939541935920715,
-0.1165446937084198,
-0.4937237501144409,
0.4931686818599701,
0.45012080669403076,
-0.17975333333015442,
-0.3990926742553711,
-0.01977635733783245,
0.24546052515506744,
0.5463928580284119,
0.3822805881500244,
0.131279855966568,
-0.762361466884613,
0.08132762461900711,
-0.18247029185295105,
0.11902646720409393,
0.10603713244199753,
0.9589633345603943,
-0.614692747592926,
0.6878620982170105,
0.5409555435180664,
0.6518054008483887,
0.18519887328147888,
0.23167076706886292,
0.5085651278495789,
-0.30803120136260986,
-0.04756547510623932,
-0.002211265731602907,
0.5268515348434448,
0.02522609755396843,
-0.5668783783912659,
0.34457552433013916,
0.3191172778606415,
-0.7982038855552673,
-0.582108199596405,
0.09103495627641678,
-1.0484291315078735,
-0.5191237330436707,
1.0187283754348755,
-0.13599784672260284,
-0.15804120898246765,
-0.164117693901062,
-0.1881158947944641,
-0.013572052121162415,
-0.8038254380226135,
1.116400122642517,
0.7868494987487793,
-0.4468033015727997,
-0.10981937497854233,
-0.4537859261035919,
0.02942928671836853,
0.8831015825271606,
-0.369978666305542,
-0.15074728429317474,
0.18808472156524658,
0.6433971524238586,
0.17799317836761475,
0.8548848032951355,
0.16721917688846588,
0.12144400924444199,
0.3190097510814667,
0.05170659348368645,
-0.5900393128395081,
-0.3247442841529846,
-0.2274743765592575,
0.004161807242780924,
-0.16670523583889008,
-0.25500065088272095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14505v1
|
Explainable automatic industrial carbon footprint estimation from bank transaction classification using natural language processing
| 2024-05-23T12:43:06 | 2024-05-23T12:43:06 |
Jaime González-González, Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Francisco J. González-Castaño, Óscar Barba-Seara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.LG
|
Concerns about the effect of greenhouse gases have motivated the development
of certification protocols to quantify the industrial carbon footprint (CF).
These protocols are manual, work-intensive, and expensive. All of the above
have led to a shift towards automatic data-driven approaches to estimate the
CF, including Machine Learning (ML) solutions. Unfortunately, the
decision-making processes involved in these solutions lack transparency from
the end user's point of view, who must blindly trust their outcomes compared to
intelligible traditional manual approaches. In this research, manual and
automatic methodologies for CF estimation were reviewed, taking into account
their transparency limitations. This analysis led to the proposal of a new
explainable ML solution for automatic CF calculations through bank transaction
classification. Consideration should be given to the fact that no previous
research has considered the explainability of bank transaction classification
for this purpose. For classification, different ML models have been employed
based on their promising performance in the literature, such as Support Vector
Machine, Random Forest, and Recursive Neural Networks. The results obtained
were in the 90 % range for accuracy, precision, and recall evaluation metrics.
From their decision paths, the proposed solution estimates the CO2 emissions
associated with bank transactions. The explainability methodology is based on
an agnostic evaluation of the influence of the input terms extracted from the
descriptions of transactions using locally interpretable models. The
explainability terms were automatically validated using a similarity metric
over the descriptions of the target categories. Conclusively, the explanation
performance is satisfactory in terms of the proximity of the explanations to
the associated activity sector descriptions.
|
[
-0.5049585103988647,
-0.6827207803726196,
0.6473401188850403,
-0.13110628724098206,
-0.1578424870967865,
0.08191583305597305,
0.09988683462142944,
-0.9627920389175415,
-0.07598159462213516,
0.6818734407424927,
-0.2970740795135498,
-0.4365312159061432,
-0.5703882575035095,
-0.07635322213172913,
-0.4815472960472107,
0.9919552206993103,
-0.18708312511444092,
0.007937092334032059,
-0.17140275239944458,
-0.016824867576360703,
-0.31217268109321594,
-0.37949663400650024,
-0.9076117277145386,
-0.22914528846740723,
0.2539258897304535,
-0.047007232904434204,
0.6089082360267639,
0.6309555172920227,
0.38210731744766235,
0.38760486245155334,
-0.1491745561361313,
0.08661209046840668,
0.11278510093688965,
-0.6707624793052673,
-0.06399832665920258,
-0.1954897940158844,
-0.2566559910774231,
-0.04916055127978325,
0.5121302008628845,
0.9394010305404663,
-0.08418312668800354,
0.24063219130039215,
0.28358444571495056,
0.7241637110710144,
-0.6843883991241455,
0.4491056501865387,
-0.5062212347984314,
0.12564195692539215,
0.46536824107170105,
-0.07929230481386185,
-0.3692759871482849,
-0.2547592520713806,
0.2537645399570465,
-0.1727074533700943,
0.6239592432975769,
0.23126734793186188,
0.7258808612823486,
0.24107006192207336,
-0.33033379912376404,
-0.8624812364578247,
-0.9778408408164978,
0.6818310022354126,
-0.6504673361778259,
0.4160363972187042,
0.20873118937015533,
0.5112501382827759,
0.13251258432865143,
-0.4987243711948395,
-0.41928383708000183,
-0.2695491313934326,
-0.769797146320343,
0.07479839026927948,
-0.2866925001144409,
0.31388184428215027,
0.16445383429527283,
0.32820138335227966,
-0.47375789284706116,
0.15170921385288239,
-0.27831968665122986,
-0.6628060340881348,
0.6245546340942383,
0.10523253679275513,
-0.26253101229667664,
-0.04306329786777496,
-0.5011775493621826,
-0.024055592715740204,
0.016228418797254562,
0.3398706614971161,
0.5536727905273438,
0.24131132662296295,
-0.25991758704185486,
0.08621197938919067,
-0.14271089434623718,
0.8994898796081543,
-0.02571863681077957,
-0.08653681725263596,
-0.2128855288028717,
-0.4024251103401184,
-0.6290239691734314,
0.25783026218414307,
0.5402316451072693,
0.09387220442295074,
-0.34692737460136414,
-0.32541072368621826,
-0.1008562445640564,
-0.014449210837483406,
0.0858544334769249,
-0.6862510442733765,
-0.22952356934547424,
0.3147734999656677,
-0.3730607330799103,
-0.39179086685180664,
0.4831062853336334,
-0.8402199745178223,
-0.29044675827026367,
-0.45684805512428284,
0.1445499211549759,
0.18383148312568665,
-0.2226167619228363,
0.06575977057218552,
-0.25881507992744446,
0.22999145090579987,
0.4849463999271393,
-0.7563786506652832,
0.2791176438331604,
0.6106006503105164,
0.8520146012306213,
0.06911970674991608,
0.40241020917892456,
-0.1588374525308609,
0.23085840046405792,
-0.17311574518680573,
0.7270125150680542,
-0.39488378167152405,
-0.35806804895401,
-0.24639803171157837,
0.1956363022327423,
-0.023916900157928467,
-0.43418869376182556,
0.3282206952571869,
-0.39778798818588257,
0.28700539469718933,
0.05807717144489288,
-0.37416747212409973,
-0.8140688538551331,
0.32129326462745667,
-0.6808916926383972,
0.7070344090461731,
0.2938303053379059,
-0.7678062319755554,
0.4832233488559723,
-0.6967929601669312,
-0.26157334446907043,
0.04910819232463837,
0.11683827638626099,
-0.7362844944000244,
-0.11854669451713562,
-0.06778734177350998,
0.5851740837097168,
-0.2119370400905609,
0.5157608389854431,
-0.29387959837913513,
-0.2080553025007248,
0.18837162852287292,
-0.7538362145423889,
1.1642931699752808,
0.37622106075286865,
-0.524852454662323,
0.1629715859889984,
-0.9256743788719177,
-0.04008922725915909,
-0.3985442519187927,
-0.19938404858112335,
0.09335067123174667,
-0.19545909762382507,
-0.04122871160507202,
-0.060687217861413956,
0.3021111488342285,
-0.4842512011528015,
-0.41141387820243835,
-0.36976107954978943,
0.41977202892303467,
0.7038639187812805,
0.14981591701507568,
0.23632356524467468,
-0.20134860277175903,
0.4393899142742157,
-0.10076169669628143,
0.35485199093818665,
-0.011938189156353474,
-0.3087170422077179,
-0.6246168613433838,
-0.30878451466560364,
0.20810642838478088,
0.5068857073783875,
0.12755151093006134,
0.6734448075294495,
-0.010710366070270538,
-0.7813861966133118,
-0.01438186876475811,
0.11367745697498322,
0.18846257030963898,
0.7944968938827515,
0.1575489044189453,
-0.505196213722229,
-0.504205048084259,
-1.0236581563949585,
-0.23501892387866974,
-0.4560776352882385,
-0.10546571761369705,
0.430564820766449,
0.46147724986076355,
-0.39386850595474243,
1.004152774810791,
-0.46437814831733704,
-0.04491901770234108,
0.2226848304271698,
0.5165226459503174,
0.252279669046402,
0.5671991109848022,
0.4282796382904053,
-0.9040856957435608,
-0.3808784484863281,
0.26359137892723083,
-0.3636211156845093,
0.26476630568504333,
-0.6621523499488831,
-0.17543217539787292,
0.4506121277809143,
0.4795374572277069,
-0.21985599398612976,
0.7519559264183044,
0.5071995258331299,
-0.3774312734603882,
0.5675647258758545,
-0.559785008430481,
0.0011965865269303322,
-0.4048769474029541,
0.4666769802570343,
0.1285807490348816,
-0.3823604881763458,
-0.4392577111721039,
-0.14984355866909027,
-0.09687936305999756,
-0.03560343384742737,
-0.1751812994480133,
0.41908887028694153,
-0.28549104928970337,
-0.4266287386417389,
-0.3071364760398865,
-0.2602287828922272,
0.44326457381248474,
0.7305970788002014,
0.08925861865282059,
0.23571330308914185,
0.37788498401641846,
-0.844900906085968,
0.1629810780286789,
-0.05364201217889786,
-0.2526286542415619,
0.18315930664539337,
-0.3272522985935211,
0.15227003395557404,
0.00811976008117199,
0.5224433541297913,
-1.302018404006958,
0.006224055774509907,
0.4935588836669922,
-0.4452439546585083,
0.35428014397621155,
-0.24962784349918365,
-0.31465065479278564,
-0.34567680954933167,
0.19694583117961884,
-0.03253159672021866,
0.4085792303085327,
-0.5948232412338257,
0.9822977781295776,
-0.03917459398508072,
0.37123143672943115,
-0.2337360382080078,
-0.8141859173774719,
0.02599884197115898,
-0.5092003345489502,
-0.4037555158138275,
0.03609627112746239,
-0.24783433973789215,
-0.2352815717458725,
-0.1604759395122528,
-0.5868434309959412,
-0.3962048888206482,
0.6224997639656067,
0.21766939759254456,
0.21674591302871704,
0.193034365773201,
-0.13227708637714386,
-0.28957197070121765,
-0.3497312366962433,
0.6380258202552795,
-0.35818085074424744,
0.16813427209854126,
-0.0898304358124733,
-0.013290254399180412,
-0.7205697894096375,
0.0951746255159378,
0.6371046304702759,
-0.04871321842074394,
0.9744771122932434,
0.5953693389892578,
-0.5138604640960693,
0.09242942929267883,
-0.39654091000556946,
0.11684195697307587,
-0.5086349248886108,
-0.023775272071361542,
0.09415855258703232,
-0.4768497347831726,
0.8084871768951416,
-0.19863957166671753,
0.23815612494945526,
0.6774787902832031,
0.24394914507865906,
-0.14855657517910004,
0.8777101635932922,
0.6081750392913818,
0.3031246066093445,
0.28642112016677856,
-0.3635082244873047,
0.6243209838867188,
-0.3725242018699646,
-0.551812469959259,
-0.8690779209136963,
0.01077942457050085,
-0.7234506011009216,
-0.29423120617866516,
0.21059861779212952,
0.2653094530105591,
-0.34957802295684814,
0.36152422428131104,
-0.5761551260948181,
0.25676384568214417,
0.18808546662330627,
0.06246575340628624,
0.3208889961242676,
-0.07423679530620575,
0.028701411560177803,
0.5324912667274475,
-0.4946080446243286,
-0.5282999873161316,
0.4740762412548065,
0.37428179383277893,
0.17963607609272003,
0.05474139377474785,
0.5314330458641052,
0.5558918714523315,
0.5214589834213257,
-0.589523196220398,
0.22909846901893616,
0.05792519822716713,
-0.7695952653884888,
-0.3685091435909271,
-0.4090328514575958,
-0.8975350856781006,
0.11769682168960571,
-0.08316902816295624,
-0.677888035774231,
0.16301369667053223,
0.4694761335849762,
-0.4644629657268524,
0.42796146869659424,
-0.9027203321456909,
0.9121336340904236,
-0.5550142526626587,
-0.45361465215682983,
-0.12837383151054382,
-0.5330541133880615,
0.33002200722694397,
-0.25427672266960144,
0.5989817380905151,
0.16044403612613678,
0.06125476211309433,
0.8115038275718689,
-0.6925610303878784,
1.0416096448898315,
-0.5963060855865479,
-0.3609004020690918,
0.47558316588401794,
-0.06654955446720123,
0.7653613686561584,
-0.18308250606060028,
-0.17460407316684723,
0.659589409828186,
0.023364122956991196,
-0.41428399085998535,
-0.67476886510849,
0.36710450053215027,
-0.2102501094341278,
-0.3842833936214447,
-0.47388583421707153,
-0.18791641294956207,
-0.2617111802101135,
0.19369223713874817,
0.1287795752286911,
-0.015405073761940002,
-0.08730335533618927,
-0.0808814987540245,
0.31593888998031616,
-0.3159721791744232,
0.6193122863769531,
0.6616019606590271,
0.0392473004758358,
-0.21568310260772705,
0.6156381964683533,
0.18850155174732208,
0.17090097069740295,
0.42221733927726746,
0.48989203572273254,
-0.3771255612373352,
-0.7478726506233215,
-0.39659228920936584,
-0.14805328845977783,
-0.7055145502090454,
-0.11481710523366928,
-0.6579420566558838,
-0.10613257437944412,
-0.3571167588233948,
-0.623405933380127,
-0.04664212092757225,
-0.3628230392932892,
-0.21090267598628998,
-0.5095688700675964,
0.21177545189857483,
0.6346411108970642,
-0.14214755594730377,
0.5280666947364807,
-0.7579994201660156,
0.20635239779949188,
0.047439802438020706,
0.6797541975975037,
0.2121639847755432,
-0.2164558470249176,
-0.7362661361694336,
0.17180834710597992,
-0.1410067230463028,
-0.8080584406852722,
0.41850873827934265,
-0.19883577525615692,
0.5463889241218567,
0.8295721411705017,
0.03511931747198105,
0.6466646790504456,
0.26004260778427124,
0.5764356255531311,
0.37973085045814514,
-1.1883931159973145,
0.3006661534309387,
-0.13129650056362152,
0.08615157008171082,
0.470459908246994,
0.3771314024925232,
-0.329542875289917,
-0.452105313539505,
-0.8433132171630859,
-1.031593680381775,
0.6953714489936829,
0.2713204026222229,
-0.2684948742389679,
0.3070468604564667,
0.3206978738307953,
0.5443403124809265,
0.13650056719779968,
-0.7088871002197266,
-0.1749284714460373,
-0.15255233645439148,
0.09851386398077011,
-0.11264421045780182,
0.13530893623828888,
0.006969822105020285,
-0.36434081196784973,
0.9034685492515564,
-0.10671725869178772,
0.33337244391441345,
0.1631333976984024,
0.07679903507232666,
-0.04205251857638359,
0.056229934096336365,
0.46349087357521057,
0.9381603002548218,
-0.4490174353122711,
-0.03181951120495796,
0.2613813281059265,
-0.3344871997833252,
-0.13768044114112854,
-0.06811780482530594,
-0.26034191250801086,
0.05688939616084099,
0.44074416160583496,
0.7270487546920776,
-0.16863933205604553,
-0.5711641907691956,
0.043372444808483124,
-0.07328283786773682,
-0.47086939215660095,
-0.9707530736923218,
0.10919497907161713,
0.06388229131698608,
0.06827439367771149,
0.07579895853996277,
0.769342839717865,
0.6025691628456116,
-0.44337767362594604,
-0.028178511187434196,
0.4269965887069702,
-0.7451838254928589,
0.06669482588768005,
0.7514334917068481,
0.26471376419067383,
-0.03361358493566513,
0.5684216618537903,
-0.11865564435720444,
-0.5691697597503662,
1.1975922584533691,
0.07552247494459152,
1.1061891317367554,
0.21924711763858795,
0.16722680628299713,
0.7337722182273865,
0.4234716594219208,
0.10332603007555008,
-0.36216557025909424,
-0.4123663604259491,
-0.5527433753013611,
-0.23756572604179382,
-0.6767327785491943,
-0.5044360756874084,
0.23598414659500122,
-0.9353145956993103,
0.2169238179922104,
-0.9803060293197632,
0.19461378455162048,
0.15854692459106445,
0.08308207988739014,
-0.872839093208313,
0.4988722503185272,
0.2524828016757965,
0.7078971266746521,
-0.9894534945487976,
0.4711765646934509,
0.1558300405740738,
-0.1652834117412567,
-0.760115385055542,
-0.12435949593782425,
-0.08825074136257172,
-0.8171740174293518,
0.26422688364982605,
0.5363633036613464,
-0.35564857721328735,
-0.2294774353504181,
-0.40462636947631836,
-0.6611729860305786,
1.0665866136550903,
0.31082481145858765,
-0.8324876427650452,
0.26847320795059204,
0.2374485284090042,
0.6318650245666504,
-0.20209269225597382,
0.2942675054073334,
0.6620447635650635,
0.9665656685829163,
0.07471585273742676,
-0.4963022768497467,
0.021362030878663063,
0.05473758652806282,
-0.28783291578292847,
0.2718108296394348,
-0.6573322415351868,
0.06567195802927017,
-0.10609319806098938,
-0.24284586310386658,
-0.1933594048023224,
0.4889824688434601,
-0.15637698769569397,
0.8453550338745117,
0.9133069515228271,
0.4085867404937744,
1.0922518968582153,
0.015213250182569027,
1.0446523427963257,
-0.2521582841873169,
0.4475626051425934,
0.7735292315483093,
0.03139841556549072,
0.3996039927005768,
0.3089029788970947,
-0.2966977059841156,
0.775060772895813,
0.8835604190826416,
-0.27119770646095276,
0.16425754129886627,
0.4592667818069458,
-0.24271996319293976,
-0.08956804126501083,
-0.02083466947078705,
0.16006432473659515,
0.5398510098457336,
0.26622462272644043,
-0.6294657588005066,
-0.05542686954140663,
-0.15734967589378357,
-0.16367603838443756,
-0.004847608972340822,
-0.40958988666534424,
0.8193234801292419,
-0.28928259015083313,
-0.5079565048217773,
0.30058321356773376,
0.2664116322994232,
0.5278552174568176,
-0.702889621257782,
-0.11555303633213043,
-0.07635270059108734,
-0.031901657581329346,
-0.581509530544281,
-0.395744264125824,
0.8045758008956909,
0.1137881800532341,
-0.2353331595659256,
-0.7185430526733398,
0.3985024094581604,
-0.12198265641927719,
-0.7993724346160889,
0.303810179233551,
0.028598768636584282,
0.22913527488708496,
-0.10632722824811935,
-0.6187583208084106,
-0.19826120138168335,
0.39762645959854126,
0.08288181573152542,
0.058652885258197784,
0.28003543615341187,
-0.25829368829727173,
0.3884517252445221,
0.6668605208396912,
-0.36993008852005005,
-0.234529048204422,
-0.39630696177482605,
0.38871556520462036,
-0.7047635912895203,
-0.8230661749839783,
-0.7138247489929199,
0.47806400060653687,
0.033010710030794144,
0.2234106957912445,
0.5629182457923889,
0.8916711807250977,
0.8534061312675476,
0.03160537779331207,
1.0538817644119263,
-0.043906256556510925,
0.25543439388275146,
-0.6334534287452698,
0.552905261516571,
-0.22711797058582306,
0.6301591396331787,
-0.03578891232609749,
-0.9103500247001648,
-0.0937606617808342,
0.6696913242340088,
-0.21089455485343933,
0.27958786487579346,
0.6874660849571228,
0.6217387318611145,
0.0404612235724926,
0.24028761684894562,
0.11116985231637955,
0.28480997681617737,
0.23572643101215363,
0.17121991515159607,
0.21627755463123322,
-0.1720045804977417,
0.7298247814178467,
-0.580740749835968,
-0.04204493761062622,
-0.26154381036758423,
-1.1936380863189697,
-0.40903425216674805,
-0.3193846642971039,
-0.7841280102729797,
-0.4343571364879608,
-0.4915330708026886,
0.4287886321544647,
0.7300274968147278,
-1.0173543691635132,
-0.250818133354187,
-0.6571060419082642,
0.25791609287261963,
-0.5540564060211182,
-0.24960774183273315,
0.7091271877288818,
0.11350259184837341,
-0.6362140774726868,
0.010900667868554592,
0.07756654173135757,
0.2257108837366104,
-0.40056684613227844,
-0.18993878364562988,
0.17313425242900848,
0.06912855803966522,
0.1675378531217575,
0.36278221011161804,
-0.6050522923469543,
-0.36614474654197693,
-0.32806092500686646,
0.255309522151947,
0.07220236212015152,
0.8261733055114746,
-0.6899176239967346,
0.47014597058296204,
0.49040085077285767,
0.540177047252655,
0.6132044792175293,
-0.025766147300601006,
0.40430980920791626,
-0.47073492407798767,
0.012531952001154423,
0.17468386888504028,
0.34183377027511597,
0.37719327211380005,
-1.022800326347351,
0.526107132434845,
0.24233083426952362,
-0.3558553159236908,
-0.46267279982566833,
-0.022208893671631813,
-1.2121808528900146,
-0.5189357399940491,
0.5861910581588745,
-0.2654115557670593,
-0.3442617952823639,
-0.5270853638648987,
-0.1227177083492279,
0.35115671157836914,
-0.15271665155887604,
0.8727152943611145,
0.83018559217453,
-0.535399854183197,
0.14718902111053467,
-0.37400156259536743,
0.19709345698356628,
0.1980513334274292,
-0.7006661295890808,
0.43700671195983887,
0.6807788610458374,
0.1914239227771759,
0.2497376799583435,
0.378242552280426,
-0.05958266928792,
0.08033135533332825,
0.08681522309780121,
0.09192027896642685,
-0.3245891034603119,
-0.1494898945093155,
-0.4044072926044464,
0.05220450088381767,
-0.09852276742458344,
0.011349685490131378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14490v1
|
Impact of Non-Standard Unicode Characters on Security and Comprehension in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T12:24:38 | 2024-05-23T12:24:38 |
Johan S Daniel, Anand Pal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advancement of large language models has significantly improved natural
language processing. However, challenges such as jailbreaks (prompt injections
that cause an LLM to follow instructions contrary to its intended use),
hallucinations (generating incorrect or misleading information), and
comprehension errors remain prevalent. In this report, we present a comparative
analysis of the performance of fifteen distinct models, with each model
undergoing a standardized test comprising 38 queries across three key metrics:
jailbreaks, hallucinations, and comprehension errors. The models are assessed
based on the total occurrences of jailbreaks, hallucinations, and comprehension
errors. Our work exposes these models' inherent vulnerabilities and challenges
the notion of human-level language comprehension of these models. We have
empirically analysed the impact of non-standard Unicode characters on LLMs and
their safeguarding mechanisms on the best-performing LLMs, including GPT-4,
Gemini 1.5 Pro, LlaMA-3-70B, and Claude 3 Opus. By incorporating alphanumeric
symbols from Unicode outside the standard Latin block and variants of
characters in other languages, we observed a reduction in the efficacy of
guardrails implemented through Reinforcement Learning Human Feedback (RLHF).
Consequently, these models exhibit heightened vulnerability to content policy
breaches and prompt leakage. Our study also suggests a need to incorporate
non-standard Unicode text in LLM training data to enhance the capabilities of
these models.
|
[
-0.2401287853717804,
-0.829992413520813,
0.5097336769104004,
0.08993404358625412,
-0.2073005735874176,
0.11902442574501038,
-0.15360379219055176,
-0.827526330947876,
0.043515000492334366,
0.8527852296829224,
-0.4107595682144165,
-0.5247659087181091,
-0.5590626001358032,
0.631393551826477,
-0.2072543054819107,
0.6725942492485046,
-0.07239682227373123,
-0.01908157952129841,
0.09642987698316574,
-0.08326464891433716,
-0.743026852607727,
-1.0960952043533325,
-0.34140270948410034,
-0.018371662124991417,
0.3907017707824707,
0.0686710998415947,
0.7415850162506104,
0.27033329010009766,
0.6757425665855408,
0.2190021425485611,
-0.08165466785430908,
0.1305220127105713,
-0.48120617866516113,
0.13858966529369354,
-0.18292292952537537,
-0.4506775140762329,
-0.2627902030944824,
-0.1183265969157219,
0.5504341125488281,
0.41573837399482727,
-0.04948905482888222,
-0.2706521153450012,
-0.023690855130553246,
0.6414380669593811,
-0.5108915567398071,
0.13151249289512634,
-0.7388120889663696,
-0.09566948562860489,
-0.18382175266742706,
-0.08438637852668762,
-0.6881871223449707,
-0.28516462445259094,
-0.12060539424419403,
-0.5383641123771667,
-0.13124704360961914,
0.36193838715553284,
0.7509442567825317,
0.11942160874605179,
-0.41791313886642456,
-0.45773252844810486,
-0.4547210931777954,
0.6728845238685608,
-0.6284372806549072,
0.6000277996063232,
0.4509706199169159,
0.11235050112009048,
-0.2721060812473297,
-0.3921041190624237,
-0.18127025663852692,
-0.5830376148223877,
-0.042391665279865265,
-0.11802411079406738,
-0.28390392661094666,
0.3280071020126343,
0.4049387574195862,
0.0979435071349144,
-0.6726447939872742,
0.6300578117370605,
-0.432000070810318,
-0.3516472280025482,
0.7193213701248169,
0.2695651948451996,
0.6449418663978577,
-0.31810206174850464,
-0.18086791038513184,
-0.2643907070159912,
-1.019923448562622,
0.043051984161138535,
0.6281983852386475,
0.4486629068851471,
0.003957861103117466,
0.5121551752090454,
-0.03388649597764015,
0.48963597416877747,
-0.3863171339035034,
-0.11891793459653854,
-0.0567980632185936,
-0.1327293962240219,
-0.1888677328824997,
-0.13776125013828278,
0.8139265179634094,
0.28412529826164246,
0.5579559803009033,
-0.5471316576004028,
-0.3618745803833008,
-0.10234455019235611,
0.3059222996234894,
-0.8298662304878235,
-0.032729558646678925,
0.03773494437336922,
-0.480773389339447,
-0.1544950008392334,
0.15616808831691742,
-0.6676209568977356,
-0.6848737597465515,
-0.05985156446695328,
0.34600114822387695,
-0.7145732641220093,
-0.1570134460926056,
-0.03221593052148819,
-0.12204558402299881,
0.2109479010105133,
0.26937925815582275,
-0.9687665700912476,
0.23194168508052826,
0.6925127506256104,
0.8592248558998108,
-0.27475476264953613,
-0.15759722888469696,
-0.26379063725471497,
-0.19765837490558624,
-0.3552401065826416,
0.5754173994064331,
-0.42469289898872375,
-0.7279016375541687,
0.05801321566104889,
-0.026094911620020866,
-0.36893877387046814,
-0.5400736331939697,
0.459160715341568,
-0.5756419897079468,
-0.3507428765296936,
-0.3550221920013428,
-0.5634160041809082,
-0.15680332481861115,
0.22884982824325562,
-0.836817741394043,
0.45608219504356384,
0.08359869569540024,
-0.7222920060157776,
0.18965643644332886,
-0.38661718368530273,
-0.5222000479698181,
0.10798265039920807,
-0.09787869453430176,
-0.29604169726371765,
0.24797077476978302,
0.30774515867233276,
0.23661646246910095,
-0.035900939255952835,
0.07690910249948502,
-0.3692658543586731,
-0.6613565683364868,
0.6441648602485657,
-0.585482120513916,
0.6189438700675964,
0.28588518500328064,
-0.1251499354839325,
0.013165396638214588,
-0.515132486820221,
-0.08950173854827881,
0.15061353147029877,
-0.09438456594944,
-0.3689306676387787,
-0.1590857356786728,
0.1852080374956131,
0.10198277235031128,
0.04195228964090347,
-0.3534916043281555,
0.14904528856277466,
-0.4388527274131775,
0.6016388535499573,
0.7644354701042175,
0.23929239809513092,
0.27816706895828247,
-0.26701998710632324,
0.7307745218276978,
-0.03688207268714905,
0.297384649515152,
-0.2423194944858551,
-0.5245506763458252,
-0.3241954743862152,
-0.1742047816514969,
0.25669747591018677,
0.550534725189209,
-0.6663645505905151,
0.06523273140192032,
-0.02284233644604683,
-0.4034487307071686,
-0.34946751594543457,
0.09077361226081848,
0.38119634985923767,
0.16939480602741241,
0.22601743042469025,
-0.2754669189453125,
-0.49300050735473633,
-0.8238264918327332,
-0.48386600613594055,
-0.575484573841095,
0.09417795389890671,
0.3272010385990143,
0.7204561233520508,
-0.2793615758419037,
0.6287841200828552,
-0.09440264850854874,
-0.19574527442455292,
-0.4979320764541626,
-0.09055490046739578,
-0.07092208415269852,
0.2907410264015198,
0.4241906702518463,
-0.4113880693912506,
-0.18873289227485657,
-0.2243250161409378,
-0.703722357749939,
0.027348773553967476,
-0.09380954504013062,
0.18512535095214844,
0.5490236878395081,
0.41849008202552795,
-0.418605774641037,
0.3693592846393585,
0.4728577733039856,
-0.39476513862609863,
0.8288042545318604,
-0.23403720557689667,
0.2194432020187378,
-0.8022579550743103,
0.05488919839262962,
0.017020246013998985,
0.01811455562710762,
-0.7574304938316345,
0.41209280490875244,
0.4567684829235077,
-0.17628203332424164,
-0.5955079197883606,
0.5471834540367126,
-0.4792165458202362,
-0.11761094629764557,
0.06028047204017639,
0.06416736543178558,
0.07234446704387665,
0.26588675379753113,
0.13508881628513336,
1.0470962524414062,
0.30014029145240784,
-0.4016733765602112,
0.08813155442476273,
0.14949430525302887,
-0.6430469751358032,
0.4050896167755127,
-0.6843931078910828,
0.2352430373430252,
-0.043501224368810654,
0.17059403657913208,
-0.6440860629081726,
-0.23928925395011902,
0.04990772530436516,
-0.4199448823928833,
0.3237534165382385,
-0.17979775369167328,
-0.7913792729377747,
-0.19183488190174103,
-0.32968223094940186,
0.010011807084083557,
0.5360965132713318,
-0.3321244716644287,
0.11122506856918335,
0.2713033854961395,
0.033490728586912155,
-0.46483975648880005,
-0.7624945044517517,
0.5222464799880981,
-0.4369441866874695,
-0.8239138722419739,
-0.02089671976864338,
0.06626532971858978,
-0.4873864948749542,
-0.35227400064468384,
0.020070629194378853,
0.07310929149389267,
0.6601550579071045,
0.23368245363235474,
0.3828240931034088,
-0.09375544637441635,
-0.015791436657309532,
-0.11865928769111633,
0.22165140509605408,
0.13128544390201569,
0.046750668436288834,
0.4872923195362091,
-0.18824981153011322,
-0.38046756386756897,
-0.47091367840766907,
0.2963608205318451,
0.5154343843460083,
-0.34290948510169983,
1.0720371007919312,
0.12054962664842606,
-0.27344828844070435,
-0.11023591458797455,
-0.5099232792854309,
-0.4243124723434448,
-0.4484713077545166,
0.42905622720718384,
-0.4667320251464844,
-0.9979484677314758,
0.7371997833251953,
0.4636920392513275,
-0.004955958109349012,
0.2798062860965729,
0.2648642659187317,
0.07901929318904877,
1.0987128019332886,
0.5077233910560608,
-0.16415154933929443,
0.48191380500793457,
-0.026209073141217232,
0.18484607338905334,
-0.7891576886177063,
-0.34770718216896057,
-0.5737188458442688,
-0.008303611539304256,
-0.844810426235199,
-0.22238363325595856,
0.04863624647259712,
0.1695045679807663,
-0.05481056496500969,
0.3934318423271179,
-0.05769486352801323,
0.4166509509086609,
0.1996350735425949,
-0.06508855521678925,
0.47849172353744507,
0.0018781450344249606,
-0.1562214493751526,
-0.06913183629512787,
-0.3770706057548523,
-0.7595475912094116,
1.2465572357177734,
0.5718762874603271,
1.1564102172851562,
0.26219436526298523,
0.7802282571792603,
0.29317978024482727,
0.19542552530765533,
-0.585151731967926,
0.48901239037513733,
-0.06924229115247726,
-0.6696276664733887,
-0.09769801050424576,
-0.6137027144432068,
-1.0371596813201904,
0.3498787581920624,
-0.11388920992612839,
-1.1710598468780518,
0.09010240435600281,
-0.24507026374340057,
-0.2790519893169403,
0.34752359986305237,
-0.740837037563324,
0.7321732044219971,
-0.2817952334880829,
-0.07670120894908905,
0.05100027844309807,
-0.3619992136955261,
0.6230748891830444,
-0.16107191145420074,
0.30900320410728455,
-0.02805592305958271,
0.0719023048877716,
0.6705230474472046,
-0.22023120522499084,
0.7637834548950195,
-0.10230452567338943,
-0.192601278424263,
0.1523696780204773,
0.2387728989124298,
0.8022350072860718,
0.29532966017723083,
-0.20325569808483124,
0.34306642413139343,
0.05926267430186272,
-0.1759432703256607,
-0.43247702717781067,
0.6104443669319153,
-1.0458046197891235,
-0.8045327663421631,
-0.38549676537513733,
-0.6454000473022461,
-0.3383274972438812,
0.00009318281809100881,
0.36086106300354004,
0.3506663739681244,
-0.31112945079803467,
0.18848708271980286,
0.8392056822776794,
-0.4415678083896637,
0.4090985655784607,
0.5654821395874023,
-0.3533948063850403,
-0.41946372389793396,
0.771112322807312,
0.33897390961647034,
0.37816956639289856,
0.19863609969615936,
-0.13704785704612732,
-0.4868328869342804,
-0.8519624471664429,
-0.5051992535591125,
0.3013899028301239,
-0.7057933807373047,
-0.06071915104985237,
-0.6881937384605408,
-0.3798534870147705,
-0.6636215448379517,
0.005028003826737404,
0.014539319090545177,
-0.295104444026947,
-0.46570613980293274,
-0.19069088995456696,
0.31471189856529236,
0.7107861042022705,
0.15927785634994507,
0.2477799504995346,
-0.8057152628898621,
0.07199881225824356,
-0.04520122706890106,
0.3147827386856079,
-0.007881526835262775,
-0.6831200122833252,
-0.27555158734321594,
-0.01740988902747631,
-0.2870559096336365,
-1.242453694343567,
0.4291989803314209,
-0.047537270933389664,
0.5944291949272156,
0.4070219099521637,
0.1466037631034851,
0.5983479022979736,
-0.24342384934425354,
0.7425652146339417,
-0.049374405294656754,
-0.8693806529045105,
0.3350852131843567,
-0.3122015595436096,
0.128105029463768,
0.5732027888298035,
0.0640038549900055,
-0.8889983892440796,
-0.7351289987564087,
-0.3593671917915344,
-0.708253026008606,
0.7870013117790222,
0.47581812739372253,
0.1040521115064621,
-0.1145143210887909,
0.3455720841884613,
0.11952105909585953,
-0.06787317991256714,
-0.7414140701293945,
0.026021994650363922,
-0.08345069736242294,
0.03247788920998573,
-0.09247635304927826,
-0.1899428516626358,
0.34787437319755554,
0.21320098638534546,
0.48783430457115173,
0.07763821631669998,
0.026195669546723366,
0.06878612190485,
-0.7196366786956787,
0.1351127028465271,
0.4854212701320648,
0.6925617456436157,
0.5519456267356873,
-0.15576986968517303,
0.020399026572704315,
0.23703578114509583,
-0.5824846625328064,
0.07758396863937378,
-0.07520683854818344,
-0.18864527344703674,
-0.173936665058136,
0.5089625120162964,
0.8996730446815491,
-0.07814853638410568,
-0.8182204365730286,
0.09782866388559341,
-0.33293211460113525,
-0.028938299044966698,
-0.14444617927074432,
0.24153293669223785,
-0.16660082340240479,
0.07930704206228256,
0.2916359603404999,
-0.1920483559370041,
0.08463331311941147,
-0.6720089912414551,
0.11571373790502548,
0.4677025079727173,
-0.43203550577163696,
-0.37671589851379395,
0.5784585475921631,
0.14074206352233887,
-0.30788862705230713,
0.8111979961395264,
-0.014539243653416634,
-0.45739418268203735,
0.814915657043457,
0.6986784934997559,
0.7969328761100769,
-0.11714588105678558,
0.25912216305732727,
0.18264853954315186,
0.9410269856452942,
-0.11350725591182709,
0.20624251663684845,
0.17935238778591156,
-0.5291522741317749,
-0.2649633586406708,
-0.6114888191223145,
-0.5926351547241211,
0.24342569708824158,
-0.6073608994483948,
0.07315929979085922,
-0.637267529964447,
-0.1704809069633484,
-0.49365654587745667,
0.2040259689092636,
-0.539537787437439,
0.02532443404197693,
0.37681490182876587,
1.0536460876464844,
-0.8738310933113098,
0.7055860161781311,
0.4752740263938904,
-0.5870237946510315,
-0.7796019911766052,
0.03614766150712967,
-0.10002727061510086,
-0.7936869859695435,
0.4793570637702942,
0.5685126185417175,
0.3115277886390686,
-0.1571502685546875,
-0.08308187872171402,
-0.7293816208839417,
0.7699269652366638,
0.39365100860595703,
-0.8236775994300842,
-0.08316099643707275,
0.6118378043174744,
0.5875961184501648,
-0.11919084936380386,
0.4314741790294647,
0.8129318356513977,
0.4627973139286041,
-0.20928636193275452,
-0.8446836471557617,
0.20550882816314697,
-0.055159877985715866,
0.2871817350387573,
0.24705861508846283,
-0.5594344735145569,
0.6778301000595093,
-0.2540804445743561,
-0.3300170302391052,
0.2802732586860657,
0.49470284581184387,
0.5407990217208862,
0.03812382370233536,
0.28803887963294983,
0.5620355606079102,
0.7986074686050415,
-0.17196545004844666,
1.1536294221878052,
-0.24259105324745178,
0.031011288985610008,
0.7655082941055298,
-0.4136398434638977,
0.82177734375,
0.4320695400238037,
-0.02882774919271469,
0.43816885352134705,
0.8394551277160645,
-0.04420279711484909,
0.3936063051223755,
0.40339282155036926,
0.026864688843488693,
-0.114516481757164,
0.08096184581518173,
-0.33631470799446106,
0.27480360865592957,
0.449068158864975,
-0.25685054063796997,
-0.14845648407936096,
0.24564741551876068,
0.14535260200500488,
-0.15548287332057953,
-0.35745564103126526,
0.8193017244338989,
0.30679288506507874,
-0.7493554353713989,
0.5406377911567688,
0.3333449065685272,
0.5809541940689087,
-0.4246232807636261,
0.3376324474811554,
-0.6369816064834595,
0.05812245234847069,
-0.13995018601417542,
-0.7027566432952881,
0.33759430050849915,
0.4216941297054291,
0.19989840686321259,
-0.16990414261817932,
0.5941823720932007,
-0.016289662569761276,
-0.3862883150577545,
0.3128580152988434,
0.1584368348121643,
0.2380446195602417,
-0.4319489300251007,
-0.6100158095359802,
0.3413921296596527,
-0.23470847308635712,
-0.2256634682416916,
0.5277093052864075,
0.2747771143913269,
-0.36677315831184387,
0.6365540623664856,
0.6120816469192505,
-0.0320027656853199,
0.21717534959316254,
0.19425305724143982,
0.5385671854019165,
-0.7284622192382812,
-0.5623233914375305,
-1.073673963546753,
0.2520017921924591,
-0.0038228267803788185,
-0.09312587976455688,
0.9675098061561584,
0.3922017216682434,
0.515300989151001,
0.15073846280574799,
0.837242841720581,
0.3257427215576172,
-0.11362261325120926,
-0.6652873754501343,
1.037941813468933,
-0.3433295786380768,
0.5293281078338623,
-0.2692966163158417,
-0.9232212901115417,
-0.202418714761734,
0.2488328516483307,
-0.38386595249176025,
0.05813818797469139,
0.6972164511680603,
0.7946857810020447,
0.29716095328330994,
0.06019515544176102,
0.6977389454841614,
0.19005072116851807,
0.5308263897895813,
0.5815681219100952,
0.9784762263298035,
-0.39243370294570923,
0.6098067164421082,
0.05658595263957977,
0.04005805775523186,
-0.43650129437446594,
-0.44716235995292664,
-1.2127692699432373,
-0.28012409806251526,
-0.143416628241539,
-0.37321752309799194,
0.27502304315567017,
0.6133100390434265,
0.4411981701850891,
-0.7144596576690674,
-0.16871309280395508,
-0.1385459303855896,
0.4438827633857727,
0.18089038133621216,
-0.18789799511432648,
0.15364955365657806,
-0.45280754566192627,
-0.44752657413482666,
0.45804068446159363,
0.3560905456542969,
0.16649027168750763,
-0.41048964858055115,
-0.2386699765920639,
0.28886598348617554,
0.50457763671875,
0.47114041447639465,
0.2107667326927185,
-0.8594053387641907,
-0.17263463139533997,
0.3255632817745209,
-0.29501450061798096,
-0.055085618048906326,
0.5810090899467468,
-0.5510267019271851,
0.2122693806886673,
0.43013498187065125,
0.4616968333721161,
0.13032317161560059,
-0.17483945190906525,
0.4216759502887726,
-0.4812433421611786,
-0.05742722004652023,
0.18046027421951294,
0.5625032782554626,
0.3715118169784546,
-0.38567298650741577,
0.21571752429008484,
0.21868808567523956,
-0.49106746912002563,
-0.9609965085983276,
0.400563508272171,
-0.5505883693695068,
-0.42870742082595825,
1.329067587852478,
-0.2350294142961502,
-0.356876403093338,
-0.24336744844913483,
-0.08194590359926224,
-0.05086713656783104,
-0.4566247761249542,
0.8609174489974976,
0.7544138431549072,
0.1654956340789795,
-0.2915661633014679,
-0.5392577052116394,
0.3091208040714264,
0.21076950430870056,
-0.9595174789428711,
0.1905113011598587,
0.39618757367134094,
0.24322544038295746,
-0.3046732246875763,
0.2791827917098999,
-0.3228876292705536,
0.14919543266296387,
-0.1110590398311615,
-0.08709415048360825,
-0.17494967579841614,
-0.3106533885002136,
-0.4795975983142853,
0.12194246798753738,
0.24218827486038208,
0.25982967019081116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14488v1
|
MoGU: A Framework for Enhancing Safety of Open-Sourced LLMs While Preserving Their Usability
| 2024-05-23T12:19:59 | 2024-05-23T12:19:59 |
Yanrui Du, Sendong Zhao, Danyang Zhao, Ming Ma, Yuhan Chen, Liangyu Huo, Qing Yang, Dongliang Xu, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in various
applications. As their usage grows, concerns regarding their safety are rising,
especially in maintaining harmless responses when faced with malicious
instructions. Many defense strategies have been developed to enhance the safety
of LLMs. However, our research finds that existing defense strategies lead LLMs
to predominantly adopt a rejection-oriented stance, thereby diminishing the
usability of their responses to benign instructions. To solve this problem, we
introduce the MoGU framework, designed to enhance LLMs' safety while preserving
their usability. Our MoGU framework transforms the base LLM into two variants:
the usable LLM and the safe LLM, and further employs dynamic routing to balance
their contribution. When encountering malicious instructions, the router will
assign a higher weight to the safe LLM to ensure that responses are harmless.
Conversely, for benign instructions, the router prioritizes the usable LLM,
facilitating usable and helpful responses. On various open-sourced LLMs, we
compare multiple defense strategies to verify the superiority of our MoGU
framework. Besides, our analysis provides key insights into the effectiveness
of MoGU and verifies that our designed routing mechanism can effectively
balance the contribution of each variant by assigning weights. Our work
released the safer Llama2, Vicuna, Falcon, Dolphin, and Baichuan2.
|
[
-0.06682924181222916,
-0.8906059861183167,
0.406563401222229,
0.11180148273706436,
-0.40992745757102966,
0.06209954619407654,
-0.23430918157100677,
-0.3689515292644501,
-0.07477043569087982,
0.6588565111160278,
-0.21022184193134308,
-0.6251901984214783,
-0.459455281496048,
-0.17384184896945953,
-0.16557982563972473,
0.9452330470085144,
0.23469185829162598,
-0.036055225878953934,
-0.37255316972732544,
-0.3584854006767273,
-0.32579872012138367,
-0.4621520936489105,
-0.7959283590316772,
-0.3723737895488739,
0.685915470123291,
0.28446853160858154,
0.7733833193778992,
0.8209983706474304,
0.7426549792289734,
0.28751567006111145,
-0.1477201282978058,
-0.03690124303102493,
-0.42869850993156433,
0.3276710510253906,
-0.2685600817203522,
-0.5891964435577393,
-0.8971372246742249,
-0.27215075492858887,
0.45950618386268616,
0.4140540361404419,
-0.49806156754493713,
-0.15976862609386444,
0.09951364248991013,
0.5996413230895996,
-0.6486312747001648,
-0.2198483794927597,
-0.7772887945175171,
0.10403721779584885,
-0.5660654306411743,
-0.3379703760147095,
-0.5531889796257019,
-0.45795851945877075,
0.0269307903945446,
-0.5463796854019165,
-0.35775232315063477,
-0.05318562313914299,
0.5864546895027161,
0.11808858066797256,
-0.6263934373855591,
-0.20378683507442474,
-0.535248339176178,
0.6496566534042358,
-0.8121511936187744,
0.11562289297580719,
0.2021164745092392,
0.41625750064849854,
-0.730821967124939,
-0.3517546057701111,
-0.30246198177337646,
-0.45903894305229187,
0.17041197419166565,
0.09169309586286545,
-0.4761204719543457,
0.188510924577713,
0.13352355360984802,
0.26829931139945984,
-0.7282620668411255,
0.3761084973812103,
0.024798516184091568,
-0.3924037218093872,
0.38231605291366577,
0.08438992500305176,
0.586555004119873,
0.01765536516904831,
-0.6581935882568359,
0.00537477433681488,
-1.204520583152771,
-0.0234313253313303,
0.6261073350906372,
0.19252672791481018,
-0.03878549113869667,
0.5914116501808167,
-0.22559374570846558,
0.5802775025367737,
-0.129958376288414,
-0.6105708479881287,
0.22923643887043,
0.030293473973870277,
-0.16142632067203522,
-0.06790953874588013,
0.9098080396652222,
0.3443952202796936,
0.06190358102321625,
-0.19954077899456024,
-0.2228097915649414,
0.08921082317829132,
0.627606213092804,
-0.6834253072738647,
-0.10275786370038986,
0.01561897061765194,
-0.6908050179481506,
-0.6880240440368652,
0.035921696573495865,
-0.8730793595314026,
-0.690902829170227,
0.21799124777317047,
0.4407442808151245,
-0.5295016765594482,
-0.4465080201625824,
0.20083226263523102,
0.10233116894960403,
0.13149620592594147,
0.4191933870315552,
-0.7624760270118713,
0.28598451614379883,
0.8219935297966003,
0.6282101273536682,
-0.38152968883514404,
0.036611057817935944,
-0.9686034321784973,
0.6397266387939453,
-0.08752806484699249,
0.5574422478675842,
-0.43081173300743103,
-0.6937660574913025,
0.05154074355959892,
-0.12503544986248016,
0.19277095794677734,
-0.5155976414680481,
0.7599107027053833,
-0.605736494064331,
-0.041244618594646454,
-0.1374315619468689,
-0.21560263633728027,
-0.3362754285335541,
0.35688456892967224,
-0.5332693457603455,
0.520666241645813,
-0.06811219453811646,
-0.7284531593322754,
-0.038192588835954666,
-0.6750960946083069,
-0.8649751543998718,
-0.11076036840677261,
-0.024181753396987915,
-0.3052786588668823,
0.2293759435415268,
-0.1301162987947464,
0.17657721042633057,
-0.2714881896972656,
-0.1408155858516693,
-0.5473807454109192,
-0.20433826744556427,
0.25324109196662903,
-0.5101738572120667,
0.961883544921875,
0.4286280870437622,
-0.33390456438064575,
0.3099955916404724,
-0.9267758131027222,
0.018108271062374115,
0.2124488204717636,
-0.7996498346328735,
-0.7265517711639404,
0.23174433410167694,
-0.5587248206138611,
-0.0804988443851471,
0.13561557233333588,
-0.5288682579994202,
0.16003906726837158,
-0.23510289192199707,
0.3644023835659027,
1.0868154764175415,
-0.20231510698795319,
0.5062652230262756,
-0.14388900995254517,
0.5630323886871338,
-0.09700632095336914,
0.3112350106239319,
-0.13590659201145172,
-0.4518660604953766,
-0.7756659388542175,
-0.20758023858070374,
0.02861364372074604,
0.7190200090408325,
-0.6467766165733337,
0.3216990828514099,
-0.1605561524629593,
-0.4110642373561859,
-0.012880365364253521,
0.27174055576324463,
0.5727088451385498,
0.5798524618148804,
0.0759819969534874,
-0.22802825272083282,
-0.4056868255138397,
-0.7234002351760864,
-0.05789998546242714,
-0.5806032419204712,
-0.11142301559448242,
0.15342319011688232,
-0.03503673896193504,
-0.40955448150634766,
0.4623284339904785,
-0.444968581199646,
-0.07886266708374023,
-0.11508955806493759,
-0.08161251246929169,
-0.14014728367328644,
0.544140100479126,
0.7453855276107788,
-0.5771599411964417,
-0.12692514061927795,
0.05297486111521721,
-0.8553534746170044,
-0.3048297166824341,
0.21753334999084473,
-0.5934433341026306,
0.18363520503044128,
0.3509150743484497,
-0.5226853489875793,
0.2125074416399002,
0.5907944440841675,
-0.29183655977249146,
0.32222992181777954,
-0.017518477514386177,
0.0371725931763649,
-1.1112273931503296,
-0.09412790089845657,
-0.053375620394945145,
-0.26956039667129517,
-0.5207670331001282,
0.5940741300582886,
-0.026871100068092346,
-0.07299425452947617,
-0.568055272102356,
0.4249087870121002,
-0.09372393786907196,
0.14926302433013916,
-0.3282269239425659,
-0.07172982394695282,
-0.0688774511218071,
0.20615588128566742,
-0.3288944959640503,
0.7273182272911072,
0.6049911379814148,
-0.7299336791038513,
0.5194446444511414,
-0.07481305301189423,
-0.17296136915683746,
0.8310337066650391,
-0.8161265254020691,
0.3236444592475891,
0.18956923484802246,
0.13464386761188507,
-0.7769040465354919,
-0.2220049351453781,
0.5969371199607849,
-0.2149716317653656,
0.28335410356521606,
-0.4630216956138611,
-0.43829479813575745,
-0.3193545937538147,
-0.42267027497291565,
0.12493138760328293,
0.6512593030929565,
-0.5194178819656372,
0.6936959624290466,
0.5279011130332947,
-0.05581040307879448,
-0.5909104943275452,
-0.6663185358047485,
0.08728758990764618,
-0.6370579600334167,
-0.7795482277870178,
0.1854778677225113,
-0.4169664978981018,
-0.4438565969467163,
-0.06378168612718582,
-0.18254689872264862,
0.04727780446410179,
0.5854662656784058,
0.4854906499385834,
0.33249473571777344,
-0.30435189604759216,
-0.13116638362407684,
-0.03043493814766407,
-0.3959159255027771,
0.18277834355831146,
-0.514035165309906,
0.4153865873813629,
-0.028380749747157097,
-0.6907715201377869,
-0.20671764016151428,
0.2286582887172699,
0.6641520857810974,
-0.26267239451408386,
0.6298248171806335,
0.5221815705299377,
-0.20432281494140625,
-0.013482384383678436,
-0.36695438623428345,
0.12339798361063004,
-0.6044145226478577,
0.03388909623026848,
-0.31385254859924316,
-1.076486587524414,
0.26003435254096985,
-0.11870650202035904,
0.34212878346443176,
0.10167177021503448,
0.4766525626182556,
-0.17101828753948212,
0.8694847226142883,
0.7249076962471008,
-0.12396980077028275,
0.44589704275131226,
0.22125785052776337,
0.1505645513534546,
-0.73929363489151,
-0.46413081884384155,
-0.5581076145172119,
-0.17249983549118042,
-0.4115962088108063,
-0.2761128842830658,
0.46968141198158264,
0.08410347253084183,
-0.011979063041508198,
0.39027833938598633,
-0.26366713643074036,
0.4652223289012909,
0.5332962274551392,
0.014413471333682537,
0.3337034583091736,
0.238132044672966,
-0.40253889560699463,
0.1035706028342247,
-0.3842177093029022,
-0.679872453212738,
1.0045676231384277,
0.5057507753372192,
1.4155503511428833,
0.686507523059845,
0.6042525768280029,
0.37124714255332947,
0.1548869013786316,
-0.697815477848053,
1.0873901844024658,
-0.11992140859365463,
-0.3144324719905853,
-0.15794388949871063,
-0.7256618738174438,
-0.9972460865974426,
0.4463207721710205,
-0.14687246084213257,
-0.6355815529823303,
-0.36132752895355225,
0.26563048362731934,
-0.3560963273048401,
0.5673571825027466,
-0.4510382115840912,
0.45245102047920227,
-0.5417007207870483,
-0.433076411485672,
-0.29656511545181274,
-0.39626696705818176,
0.5998721122741699,
0.06962127983570099,
-0.048873934894800186,
-0.27267032861709595,
-0.2641028165817261,
0.45108336210250854,
-0.39989519119262695,
0.6846659779548645,
-0.06542495638132095,
-0.5915623307228088,
0.25708791613578796,
0.441587895154953,
0.6284396052360535,
0.22206805646419525,
-0.4186963140964508,
0.17246297001838684,
-0.48270314931869507,
-0.3864196836948395,
-0.4935174584388733,
0.9774805307388306,
-0.47105884552001953,
-1.0431922674179077,
-0.23464684188365936,
-0.4389593005180359,
-0.055290836840867996,
0.4286005198955536,
0.1344059556722641,
0.39807596802711487,
-0.21994145214557648,
0.4394894242286682,
1.0995608568191528,
-0.39473628997802734,
0.5011080503463745,
0.7631626725196838,
-0.21212531626224518,
-0.5121656060218811,
0.7802172899246216,
-0.17028343677520752,
0.5238774418830872,
0.3959629237651825,
0.34686005115509033,
-0.11890232563018799,
-0.9558185935020447,
-0.6478472948074341,
-0.1911284476518631,
-0.5483429431915283,
-0.3277178108692169,
-0.5730897784233093,
-0.11618225276470184,
-0.22472582757472992,
-0.024130908772349358,
-0.19031478464603424,
-0.3544425964355469,
-0.02592279575765133,
-0.22244231402873993,
0.3332667350769043,
0.47670117020606995,
-0.048066396266222,
0.18769703805446625,
-0.760570228099823,
0.2335629016160965,
0.3984386622905731,
0.48194876313209534,
0.03270174562931061,
-0.38063812255859375,
-0.001132531906478107,
0.08076929301023483,
-0.36178824305534363,
-0.6705368161201477,
-0.005723482929170132,
-0.214248389005661,
0.8441580533981323,
0.7283598184585571,
0.29401805996894836,
0.45277222990989685,
-0.6312577724456787,
0.6371570825576782,
0.39075106382369995,
-0.6302986145019531,
0.8209819197654724,
-0.6800878047943115,
0.10157185047864914,
0.3149547278881073,
0.05231579765677452,
-0.19510683417320251,
-0.345140665769577,
-0.28215429186820984,
-0.6777941584587097,
0.30065467953681946,
0.27115315198898315,
0.4450434148311615,
-0.12386232614517212,
0.22476829588413239,
0.28103160858154297,
0.1778726577758789,
-0.8024519681930542,
-0.2734503149986267,
-0.07541046291589737,
0.12191563099622726,
0.40570759773254395,
-0.5072832107543945,
-0.5343035459518433,
0.1840261071920395,
0.5455839037895203,
-0.0032534776255488396,
0.2946247160434723,
-0.3552151918411255,
-0.13587252795696259,
-0.23430752754211426,
0.35783395171165466,
0.7250611782073975,
0.40410372614860535,
-0.10929570347070694,
0.5529712438583374,
0.1625010371208191,
-0.5539055466651917,
0.4941583275794983,
-0.2685500383377075,
-0.5263901948928833,
-0.27645552158355713,
0.2655290961265564,
0.5519262552261353,
0.1083376556634903,
-0.6741450428962708,
0.33297908306121826,
-0.03958470746874809,
0.05372035130858421,
-0.07268218696117401,
0.7422884702682495,
-0.056435078382492065,
0.051582518965005875,
0.15724456310272217,
0.1883082389831543,
-0.10555262118577957,
-0.5958433747291565,
0.0897710844874382,
0.5791065692901611,
-0.17519819736480713,
-0.275829941034317,
0.6204989552497864,
0.6320494413375854,
-0.4593481421470642,
0.17728018760681152,
-0.21019819378852844,
-0.3495759069919586,
0.4933914840221405,
0.8132896423339844,
0.8989783525466919,
-0.21584495902061462,
0.14600171148777008,
0.0923193022608757,
0.46191462874412537,
0.04595930874347687,
0.10227441042661667,
0.30440476536750793,
-0.4290821850299835,
0.13263358175754547,
-0.5189306139945984,
-0.33145228028297424,
0.2492847740650177,
-0.4586682915687561,
0.062112096697092056,
-0.8814586400985718,
-0.21135051548480988,
-0.617940366268158,
-0.3212185204029083,
-0.032205864787101746,
-0.10673017054796219,
0.27261844277381897,
0.9915051460266113,
-0.32665327191352844,
0.9074807167053223,
0.9526515007019043,
-0.18448807299137115,
-0.5105565786361694,
0.2955698072910309,
0.5735991597175598,
-0.5934948921203613,
0.17448832094669342,
-0.0051950374618172646,
-0.5303664207458496,
-0.3114413619041443,
-0.24602004885673523,
-0.8816408514976501,
1.1107980012893677,
0.5011184811592102,
-0.4228091537952423,
0.27975985407829285,
0.04239199310541153,
0.32267481088638306,
-0.1278405338525772,
-0.2190515100955963,
-0.0482952781021595,
0.3159187138080597,
0.14208118617534637,
-0.6202638745307922,
0.34243035316467285,
-0.23182380199432373,
0.10380811989307404,
0.2337261587381363,
-0.8787535429000854,
0.6176126003265381,
-0.3441377878189087,
-0.1776096522808075,
0.39836353063583374,
0.6636695265769958,
0.4728098213672638,
0.33005887269973755,
0.6150646805763245,
0.7491278052330017,
0.9129915833473206,
-0.11739625781774521,
1.051430344581604,
0.12474071979522705,
-0.30683058500289917,
0.8937618136405945,
-0.45085594058036804,
0.8585185408592224,
0.2927839756011963,
-0.043884728103876114,
0.6608304977416992,
0.3041248917579651,
0.17057035863399506,
0.7665108442306519,
0.37832891941070557,
-0.51004958152771,
-0.15895254909992218,
-0.07731729000806808,
-0.5327314734458923,
0.3313533663749695,
0.11476815491914749,
-0.09217294305562973,
-0.21104221045970917,
0.11799938231706619,
0.47065678238868713,
0.03101268969476223,
-0.34051504731178284,
0.5437254309654236,
0.16758939623832703,
-0.41851723194122314,
0.3282819092273712,
0.28428053855895996,
0.8355388045310974,
-0.900255024433136,
0.1737358719110489,
-0.41882339119911194,
0.22670985758304596,
-0.15393199026584625,
-0.7138729095458984,
0.2359936684370041,
0.2241814285516739,
-0.25776976346969604,
-0.002579385181888938,
1.0329097509384155,
-0.12187279015779495,
-0.19674119353294373,
0.4410880506038666,
0.07829564809799194,
-0.08090776950120926,
0.30351951718330383,
-0.6296291947364807,
0.4684963524341583,
-0.019487328827381134,
-0.2540992498397827,
0.7882286906242371,
0.5503429174423218,
-0.12170517444610596,
1.1229941844940186,
0.9065858125686646,
-0.03179033100605011,
0.1316615492105484,
0.07507863640785217,
0.8761821985244751,
-0.4048161506652832,
-0.45750293135643005,
-1.0298140048980713,
0.4949195086956024,
-0.11238231509923935,
0.056269384920597076,
1.0110599994659424,
0.3402419984340668,
0.6314550042152405,
0.029491612687706947,
0.7799531817436218,
-0.0976238027215004,
0.10043107718229294,
-0.76839679479599,
0.8959319591522217,
-0.5527926087379456,
0.7216930985450745,
-0.3185596168041229,
-0.9105124473571777,
-0.22177861630916595,
0.5550650954246521,
0.1573830395936966,
-0.13037775456905365,
0.3402160406112671,
0.9367270469665527,
-0.09475619345903397,
-0.2159285694360733,
0.39270251989364624,
0.07939768582582474,
0.56397944688797,
0.7368451356887817,
0.9117992520332336,
-0.07831243425607681,
0.9919415712356567,
-0.12199749797582626,
-0.26459458470344543,
-0.4062548577785492,
-1.3312499523162842,
-1.0840824842453003,
0.18212826550006866,
-0.3109174072742462,
-0.5481750965118408,
0.3423611521720886,
0.6394171118736267,
0.8139130473136902,
-0.6076185703277588,
-0.20521223545074463,
0.0008974398369900882,
0.3852895200252533,
-0.05291777104139328,
-0.15712706744670868,
-0.14060276746749878,
-0.048879481852054596,
-0.3555496335029602,
0.6583652496337891,
0.658987283706665,
0.23692472279071808,
-0.21824045479297638,
-0.48211008310317993,
0.029730312526226044,
0.26135018467903137,
0.7001034617424011,
0.3896681070327759,
-0.8621867299079895,
-0.49490469694137573,
-0.04923626407980919,
-0.5576543211936951,
-0.10667132586240768,
0.6445388793945312,
-0.44775909185409546,
0.33002907037734985,
0.6149216890335083,
0.7800083160400391,
-0.3411068618297577,
-0.1254023313522339,
0.7847715020179749,
-0.3993476331233978,
0.13431552052497864,
-0.09678484499454498,
0.5310013890266418,
0.24268850684165955,
-0.47154974937438965,
0.8324471712112427,
0.2966512441635132,
-0.23945604264736176,
-0.8783823847770691,
0.46659091114997864,
-1.2061570882797241,
-0.1267949342727661,
1.4683529138565063,
-0.5011069178581238,
-0.14567933976650238,
0.07134310901165009,
-0.28468021750450134,
0.014677906408905983,
-0.3974953293800354,
0.6765207648277283,
0.47629302740097046,
0.1940261870622635,
-0.07939028739929199,
-0.49573034048080444,
0.22713281214237213,
0.34276482462882996,
-0.9816808700561523,
-0.026375632733106613,
0.5008083581924438,
0.48659539222717285,
0.0759185329079628,
0.47975221276283264,
-0.3689568042755127,
0.2829456329345703,
-0.18984557688236237,
-0.1878148466348648,
-0.43628036975860596,
-0.39757096767425537,
-0.16495786607265472,
0.18394623696804047,
0.13548335433006287,
-0.3863121569156647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14486v1
|
RefChecker: Reference-based Fine-grained Hallucination Checker and Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T12:18:11 | 2024-05-23T12:18:11 |
Xiangkun Hu, Dongyu Ru, Lin Qiu, Qipeng Guo, Tianhang Zhang, Yang Xu, Yun Luo, Pengfei Liu, Yue Zhang, Zheng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities but also a
concerning tendency to hallucinate. This paper presents RefChecker, a framework
that introduces claim-triplets to represent claims in LLM responses, aiming to
detect fine-grained hallucinations. In RefChecker, an extractor generates
claim-triplets from a response, which are then evaluated by a checker against a
reference. We delineate three task settings: Zero, Noisy and Accurate Context,
to reflect various real-world use cases. We curated a benchmark spanning
various NLP tasks and annotated 11k claim-triplets from 2.1k responses by seven
LLMs. RefChecker supports both proprietary and open-source models as the
extractor and checker. Experiments demonstrate that claim-triplets enable
superior hallucination detection, compared to other granularities such as
response, sentence and sub-sentence level claims. RefChecker outperforms prior
methods by 6.8 to 26.1 points on our benchmark and the checking results of
RefChecker are strongly aligned with human judgments. This work is open sourced
at https://github.com/amazon-science/RefChecker
|
[
-0.29670363664627075,
-0.49457868933677673,
0.703616201877594,
0.1432109773159027,
0.09682085365056992,
-0.31623274087905884,
-0.22443851828575134,
-0.8822081685066223,
0.2028786689043045,
0.7569602131843567,
-0.2518763840198517,
-0.2994983196258545,
-0.38544347882270813,
0.4485798180103302,
-0.5569833517074585,
0.8301792740821838,
-0.12859642505645752,
-0.07772797346115112,
-0.27016428112983704,
0.17184503376483917,
-0.5177789926528931,
-0.3355872631072998,
-0.5996648669242859,
-0.6871344447135925,
0.5512464642524719,
0.3232945501804352,
0.5564265847206116,
0.12415774166584015,
0.5004051923751831,
0.26370418071746826,
0.0714397206902504,
0.3584076464176178,
-0.3002989888191223,
0.1693827360868454,
-0.37028753757476807,
-0.5365763306617737,
-0.39670878648757935,
-0.17699353396892548,
0.27543875575065613,
0.2982231676578522,
-0.10075745731592178,
0.2780020534992218,
0.005901929456740618,
0.6865583658218384,
-0.9746706485748291,
0.14369098842144012,
-0.9706963300704956,
0.09027077257633209,
-0.16090302169322968,
-0.21651646494865417,
-0.5744407773017883,
-0.6185266375541687,
-0.060713279992341995,
-0.08871114253997803,
0.5602925419807434,
0.10183998942375183,
0.9282581210136414,
0.5597941875457764,
-0.20901785790920258,
-0.21220026910305023,
-0.6726958155632019,
0.5525774955749512,
-0.63905930519104,
0.5540609955787659,
0.7600568532943726,
0.5025316476821899,
-0.20268286764621735,
-0.7619457840919495,
-0.8727259635925293,
-0.40556463599205017,
-0.29512733221054077,
-0.27693766355514526,
-0.3187718093395233,
-0.035320624709129333,
0.44832929968833923,
0.7124908566474915,
-0.541486382484436,
-0.001426777453161776,
-0.19086521863937378,
-0.5392988920211792,
0.4497884213924408,
0.00756832817569375,
0.05193066596984863,
-0.1973903924226761,
-0.15349717438220978,
-0.016734417527914047,
-0.6632519960403442,
-0.34158602356910706,
0.24278226494789124,
0.24411219358444214,
0.13871625065803528,
0.6712183952331543,
-0.48991894721984863,
0.8095578551292419,
0.14444580674171448,
0.026944736018776894,
0.435688316822052,
-0.23503082990646362,
-0.3458603322505951,
0.2085130214691162,
0.7009230852127075,
0.2738227844238281,
0.3368152678012848,
-0.5402130484580994,
-0.45145168900489807,
0.08217956870794296,
0.37618160247802734,
-0.9094054102897644,
-0.4164064824581146,
0.3693908154964447,
-0.31511715054512024,
-0.3264060616493225,
0.11580897867679596,
-0.9512187242507935,
-0.8047417998313904,
-0.24186651408672333,
0.31019270420074463,
-0.3029318153858185,
-0.2323380559682846,
0.6355026364326477,
0.18084369599819183,
0.22201161086559296,
0.07316989451646805,
-0.7788550853729248,
0.340909868478775,
0.697930634021759,
0.6582324504852295,
-0.2776361405849457,
-0.41628700494766235,
-1.0086277723312378,
0.04010045528411865,
-0.22298847138881683,
1.2565139532089233,
-0.3213866353034973,
0.07526936382055283,
0.27963921427726746,
0.22439709305763245,
0.3022381067276001,
-1.0580449104309082,
0.9122905135154724,
-0.42498883605003357,
-0.1620320826768875,
-0.2933500409126282,
-0.2476622462272644,
-0.2583076059818268,
0.3805391788482666,
-0.8820147514343262,
1.2053436040878296,
-0.03824874013662338,
-0.6577946543693542,
0.3643415868282318,
-0.23817260563373566,
-0.36045703291893005,
0.16263562440872192,
-0.3243548274040222,
-0.3402615189552307,
0.36001160740852356,
0.05017544701695442,
0.481802374124527,
-0.44503745436668396,
0.3785129487514496,
-0.38643282651901245,
-0.5183518528938293,
0.27408653497695923,
-0.24343600869178772,
0.467762291431427,
0.034534186124801636,
-0.5602390766143799,
0.18818622827529907,
-1.0559126138687134,
0.03438746556639671,
0.03742657229304314,
-0.16530586779117584,
-0.19779737293720245,
-0.021907461807131767,
0.12239937484264374,
0.09084612131118774,
0.1133291944861412,
-0.5988364815711975,
0.07993174344301224,
-0.1589459627866745,
0.1637880653142929,
0.5597754716873169,
-0.29171857237815857,
-0.35277336835861206,
-0.5267097353935242,
0.19726170599460602,
-0.11405956000089645,
-0.41351136565208435,
-0.04127698764204979,
0.025865374132990837,
-1.046583652496338,
-0.30676835775375366,
0.2720000147819519,
0.3582720160484314,
-0.5875132083892822,
0.9264315366744995,
-0.23009882867336273,
-0.2456812858581543,
-0.593027651309967,
0.04093147814273834,
0.2638259530067444,
0.33177363872528076,
0.5027644038200378,
0.12329738587141037,
-0.6678970456123352,
-1.1951192617416382,
-0.28538137674331665,
-0.25229188799858093,
-0.5410671234130859,
0.09965100884437561,
0.5857622623443604,
-0.5846655964851379,
0.8031787276268005,
-0.6167508959770203,
-0.5381863713264465,
0.18183858692646027,
0.3513168394565582,
-0.04822274670004845,
0.16791555285453796,
0.2754167318344116,
-0.2949376702308655,
-0.18852314352989197,
-0.03639991208910942,
-0.7697725296020508,
-0.520988941192627,
-0.15374185144901276,
0.18255141377449036,
0.36887088418006897,
0.6512724757194519,
-0.5208658576011658,
0.2508341372013092,
0.5692588686943054,
-0.3443354666233063,
0.9215468168258667,
-0.045665133744478226,
0.01663512922823429,
-0.9582676291465759,
0.21830153465270996,
-0.25643742084503174,
-0.47499746084213257,
-0.2672792077064514,
0.1522940695285797,
0.07630891352891922,
0.43584948778152466,
-0.07476035505533218,
0.3242858350276947,
-0.2773933708667755,
-0.0882953628897667,
-0.5528695583343506,
0.26568323373794556,
-0.14096561074256897,
0.1867835372686386,
0.1416587084531784,
0.7061675190925598,
0.3230106830596924,
-0.4750266373157501,
0.5516026020050049,
0.0024756051134318113,
-0.5454573035240173,
0.6481655836105347,
-0.6835665702819824,
0.4679401218891144,
0.22833141684532166,
0.3731926679611206,
-0.9577665328979492,
-0.2305375039577484,
0.1111668199300766,
-0.21584656834602356,
-0.07716075330972672,
0.3110329806804657,
-0.9281595945358276,
-0.509783148765564,
-0.4005991518497467,
0.27185720205307007,
-0.05110006034374237,
-0.9871141314506531,
0.7074949741363525,
0.23587319254875183,
0.13800573348999023,
-0.46213847398757935,
-0.8228659629821777,
0.16785480082035065,
0.0886196494102478,
-0.4046611189842224,
0.35667988657951355,
-0.0862656906247139,
-0.27697449922561646,
-0.11379790306091309,
-0.5639908313751221,
0.01912999525666237,
-0.1871231645345688,
0.3701733648777008,
0.1531045138835907,
-0.14828889071941376,
0.12003134936094284,
-0.3557218909263611,
-0.30913791060447693,
0.20184026658535004,
-0.12305085361003876,
0.7836623787879944,
-0.6831861138343811,
-0.3869358003139496,
-0.4132670760154724,
0.03657341003417969,
0.6109952926635742,
0.04469442367553711,
0.3004942238330841,
0.7244620323181152,
-0.7488694787025452,
-0.19342201948165894,
-1.2568086385726929,
-0.4544757604598999,
-0.4449913799762726,
0.2639833092689514,
-0.6645218133926392,
-0.9477760791778564,
0.5172907114028931,
0.07228070497512817,
0.016825998201966286,
0.3831457197666168,
0.6931313276290894,
0.3287142813205719,
0.5648865699768066,
0.44018933176994324,
0.013613393530249596,
-0.02771044336259365,
0.22425933182239532,
0.4241059422492981,
-0.824734628200531,
-0.2573494613170624,
-0.7763285040855408,
-0.21181511878967285,
-0.4687868356704712,
-0.5271463990211487,
-0.2838551700115204,
0.09121949970722198,
-0.09858537465333939,
0.3064897358417511,
-0.6034051775932312,
0.8623090982437134,
0.20020881295204163,
-0.05245935544371605,
0.7459225058555603,
-0.0442587286233902,
-0.09662652760744095,
-0.06285805255174637,
0.06187957897782326,
-0.6871541738510132,
0.8463009595870972,
0.2892879843711853,
0.6880000233650208,
0.13360595703125,
0.7129173278808594,
0.26131191849708557,
0.3950788974761963,
-0.9588956236839294,
0.7425158619880676,
0.12799179553985596,
-0.5922115445137024,
-0.002546735340729356,
-0.3899496793746948,
-0.7616097331047058,
0.3366435468196869,
-0.2637006640434265,
-1.0232183933258057,
0.2134076952934265,
0.11640523374080658,
-0.5774322152137756,
0.42026638984680176,
-0.3614654242992401,
0.5136857032775879,
-0.02579628862440586,
-0.45948415994644165,
-0.22746284306049347,
-0.1828421801328659,
0.6997237801551819,
-0.3190721273422241,
-0.21766050159931183,
-0.19017651677131653,
0.2502247393131256,
0.6050688624382019,
-0.22750099003314972,
0.8226398229598999,
0.21465887129306793,
-0.47474393248558044,
0.025579476729035378,
0.494927316904068,
0.8070370554924011,
0.11153056472539902,
-0.08634691685438156,
0.38458096981048584,
0.21026144921779633,
0.06174244359135628,
-0.26211822032928467,
0.932713508605957,
-0.4153018593788147,
-0.539513349533081,
-0.6575623750686646,
-0.6376731991767883,
-0.35060662031173706,
0.4554308354854584,
-0.03255728259682655,
-0.05830991640686989,
-0.13454827666282654,
0.42694613337516785,
0.6282558441162109,
-0.19701090455055237,
0.14757223427295685,
0.9010957479476929,
-0.65714430809021,
-0.3465099036693573,
0.799954891204834,
-0.42420944571495056,
0.11025824397802353,
0.18738314509391785,
0.2152767777442932,
-0.0515790618956089,
-0.48219427466392517,
0.1799326390028,
0.36861562728881836,
-0.5305206179618835,
-0.4371030628681183,
-0.7282329201698303,
-0.24794058501720428,
-0.3527379035949707,
0.05531180277466774,
-0.5922224521636963,
0.01638738624751568,
0.20695029199123383,
-0.1517278552055359,
0.1991584599018097,
0.6358654499053955,
-0.1922399401664734,
-0.021559691056609154,
-0.5140407085418701,
0.9050266742706299,
0.5935615301132202,
0.6843860745429993,
-0.17295396327972412,
-0.28647640347480774,
0.03622816503047943,
-0.15360350906848907,
-0.3507344722747803,
-0.5033912062644958,
0.1105976328253746,
-0.3302587866783142,
0.3360621929168701,
0.5436319708824158,
0.09127737581729889,
0.8741483092308044,
-0.49981895089149475,
0.7052152156829834,
0.05592253431677818,
-0.8711069226264954,
0.157855823636055,
0.09060157090425491,
0.22858917713165283,
0.9255030155181885,
0.04027169570326805,
-0.6098533868789673,
-0.4097890853881836,
-0.30001309514045715,
-0.5716524124145508,
0.6609494090080261,
0.12573398649692535,
-0.2833428978919983,
-0.10846643149852753,
0.2945807874202728,
0.3084377944469452,
0.02721344865858555,
-0.8429049253463745,
-0.029208175837993622,
0.17787951231002808,
0.09214597195386887,
0.04142359644174576,
-0.5122027397155762,
-0.1897752732038498,
-0.04230479896068573,
0.5801337957382202,
-0.23416739702224731,
0.15430031716823578,
0.26753634214401245,
-0.11543511599302292,
-0.30562567710876465,
0.22874660789966583,
0.6267214417457581,
0.41556134819984436,
-0.6308537125587463,
0.6193931698799133,
0.12429268658161163,
-0.5456513166427612,
-0.06978856772184372,
0.23687447607517242,
-0.11876506358385086,
0.17380855977535248,
0.29589471220970154,
0.4209054708480835,
0.23851782083511353,
-0.7315642833709717,
0.29788121581077576,
-0.27482616901397705,
-0.18783199787139893,
-0.4694933593273163,
-0.15310491621494293,
0.012891799211502075,
0.24894118309020996,
0.08510776609182358,
0.14330796897411346,
0.36880168318748474,
-0.357782244682312,
0.4658558666706085,
0.35986414551734924,
-0.2577682435512543,
-0.32010796666145325,
0.6568620204925537,
0.10191114246845245,
-0.4527527987957001,
0.6247153282165527,
-0.22962215542793274,
-0.36050480604171753,
0.23833294212818146,
0.7645284533500671,
1.3536092042922974,
-0.1370907574892044,
0.00650063157081604,
0.3989247977733612,
0.5465731024742126,
-0.4180638790130615,
0.247079998254776,
-0.03957584500312805,
-0.8838071227073669,
-0.31328481435775757,
-0.6504270434379578,
-0.3460216224193573,
0.874220609664917,
-0.7393144369125366,
0.4338247776031494,
-0.12526333332061768,
-0.08038728684186935,
0.19514214992523193,
-0.06652799248695374,
-0.7048335075378418,
-0.29150331020355225,
0.366021066904068,
0.7746984958648682,
-0.7358627915382385,
0.8475930690765381,
0.3158493936061859,
-0.2734743356704712,
-0.33178025484085083,
0.6222257018089294,
0.2238035500049591,
-0.7583798766136169,
0.7577406167984009,
0.5671379566192627,
-0.7602199912071228,
-0.27013465762138367,
-0.5080682635307312,
-0.617723822593689,
0.7751085758209229,
0.5051397681236267,
-0.777275562286377,
0.01532270759344101,
0.14522936940193176,
0.44519251585006714,
-0.13086223602294922,
0.1202843114733696,
0.9072922468185425,
0.4968055188655853,
0.19000133872032166,
-0.9794222712516785,
0.39228126406669617,
-0.05427159368991852,
-0.0996909961104393,
0.1303541213274002,
-0.4093815088272095,
0.5068871378898621,
-0.21364335715770721,
-0.15040554106235504,
0.1614616960287094,
0.7133305668830872,
0.7966968417167664,
0.18624389171600342,
0.6234437227249146,
0.627040684223175,
0.9334450364112854,
-0.09656631201505661,
0.9392309784889221,
-0.3708072602748871,
0.329404354095459,
1.7147786617279053,
-0.6158397197723389,
1.085323452949524,
0.6284956336021423,
-0.13133475184440613,
0.44537094235420227,
0.3672053813934326,
-0.3053390383720398,
0.2725070118904114,
0.5505604147911072,
-0.24301022291183472,
-0.2789463400840759,
-0.13883475959300995,
-0.40305274724960327,
0.26657745242118835,
0.2259197235107422,
-0.11927158385515213,
-0.26687413454055786,
-0.30085092782974243,
-0.06577637791633606,
-0.08557365089654922,
0.12398187816143036,
0.5652593374252319,
0.04188663512468338,
-0.8647820353507996,
0.887596070766449,
-0.2416285276412964,
0.7354612946510315,
-0.36496278643608093,
-0.21346771717071533,
-0.10773047059774399,
0.6892396807670593,
-0.43472543358802795,
-0.640822172164917,
0.39514660835266113,
-0.0023825776297599077,
-0.15219806134700775,
0.07021228224039078,
0.6074309349060059,
-0.5066004991531372,
-0.27931585907936096,
0.4023281931877136,
0.08245168626308441,
0.33715128898620605,
-0.3760288655757904,
-0.42204105854034424,
0.29553529620170593,
-0.00694003701210022,
-0.12589511275291443,
-0.048902448266744614,
0.3829202353954315,
0.05593082681298256,
0.6329277157783508,
0.48519614338874817,
0.1373671144247055,
-0.2370598316192627,
0.27919459342956543,
0.5949891805648804,
-0.660573422908783,
0.08973408490419388,
-0.8629583716392517,
0.16176638007164001,
-0.1001095399260521,
-0.14441314339637756,
0.6779853701591492,
0.8676862716674805,
0.9528820514678955,
-0.11556984484195709,
0.5845127105712891,
0.0870928019285202,
0.3410542905330658,
-0.4481441080570221,
0.5127413272857666,
-0.436759889125824,
0.2699108421802521,
-0.18090112507343292,
-0.9750233292579651,
-0.6077145338058472,
0.839550256729126,
-0.260201096534729,
-0.1863602250814438,
1.1598663330078125,
1.05400812625885,
0.023041680455207825,
0.15675118565559387,
0.36032941937446594,
0.4086955487728119,
0.4680190086364746,
0.6216145753860474,
0.7375288605690002,
-0.4280301034450531,
0.4765370190143585,
-0.20903123915195465,
-0.13869045674800873,
-0.4297519624233246,
-1.0148450136184692,
-1.161719560623169,
-0.47662532329559326,
-0.449969619512558,
-0.7486253380775452,
-0.3782980740070343,
0.8057463765144348,
0.39254337549209595,
-1.2025352716445923,
-0.19461432099342346,
-0.09212439507246017,
0.025439249351620674,
-0.31166213750839233,
-0.2545410692691803,
0.28981319069862366,
-0.4827401041984558,
-0.5762349963188171,
0.3153981566429138,
0.21081247925758362,
-0.1870332956314087,
-0.4542100727558136,
0.12532608211040497,
-0.0598665215075016,
0.11456272751092911,
0.6811444759368896,
0.25104403495788574,
-1.1518735885620117,
-0.5751280188560486,
-0.15558794140815735,
-0.26259201765060425,
-0.025145919993519783,
0.9260666370391846,
-0.8710442185401917,
0.5363410115242004,
0.43352261185646057,
0.6942870020866394,
0.6328058838844299,
-0.3786757290363312,
0.348070353269577,
-0.4700508117675781,
0.08236447721719742,
0.130319744348526,
0.5370678901672363,
0.21510747075080872,
-0.26424869894981384,
0.7348272800445557,
0.13785098493099213,
-0.5996881127357483,
-1.1892424821853638,
0.18603666126728058,
-1.0838743448257446,
-0.14101944863796234,
1.2947837114334106,
0.2949163615703583,
-0.07809313386678696,
-0.17074190080165863,
-0.24080269038677216,
-0.02571007050573826,
-0.23151224851608276,
1.447503924369812,
1.0071965456008911,
0.06362284719944,
0.19904129207134247,
-0.7463040351867676,
0.6334928870201111,
0.4307415783405304,
-0.9714954495429993,
0.7304554581642151,
0.6584122180938721,
0.24393843114376068,
0.639000654220581,
0.44452399015426636,
-0.28954020142555237,
0.17640259861946106,
-0.1555292308330536,
0.5965157151222229,
-0.01945328712463379,
-0.3483600318431854,
-0.4295402765274048,
0.17142215371131897,
-0.07988223433494568,
-0.18154314160346985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14470v1
|
Which Information Matters? Dissecting Human-written Multi-document Summaries with Partial Information Decomposition
| 2024-05-23T11:56:54 | 2024-05-23T11:56:54 |
Laura Mascarell, Yan L'Homme, Majed El Helou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the nature of high-quality summaries is crucial to further
improve the performance of multi-document summarization. We propose an approach
to characterize human-written summaries using partial information
decomposition, which decomposes the mutual information provided by all source
documents into union, redundancy, synergy, and unique information. Our
empirical analysis on different MDS datasets shows that there is a direct
dependency between the number of sources and their contribution to the summary.
|
[
-0.43889620900154114,
-0.4423774480819702,
0.4700191617012024,
0.05270787701010704,
-0.14609307050704956,
0.2635704576969147,
0.011656861752271652,
-0.21720458567142487,
0.6540393829345703,
0.29898691177368164,
-0.4480096995830536,
-0.12309841811656952,
-0.6910231113433838,
0.3209820091724396,
-0.33381757140159607,
0.9795669913291931,
0.0922282263636589,
0.04966409504413605,
-0.5210042595863342,
-0.30156654119491577,
0.05184554681181908,
-0.7378548383712769,
-0.3052833676338196,
-0.2816734313964844,
0.754690408706665,
0.39323514699935913,
0.46268460154533386,
0.8161647319793701,
0.7206878066062927,
0.3233010172843933,
-0.3733985722064972,
0.19385066628456116,
-0.48263320326805115,
0.16299013793468475,
-0.3303062617778778,
-0.6643329858779907,
-0.46804556250572205,
0.27069178223609924,
0.8821607232093811,
0.9295042157173157,
-0.13606393337249756,
0.3054710030555725,
0.2203933745622635,
0.9002072215080261,
-0.6730021238327026,
0.26489534974098206,
0.09505390375852585,
0.0533580482006073,
-0.44404760003089905,
-0.5231927037239075,
-0.2948237657546997,
-0.23155619204044342,
0.16877225041389465,
-0.5215519070625305,
0.636235773563385,
-0.17999330163002014,
0.6416652798652649,
0.1050984114408493,
-0.8172702789306641,
-0.23036451637744904,
-0.9408196210861206,
0.6511711478233337,
-0.31215700507164,
0.08964788168668747,
0.4425409436225891,
0.18952803313732147,
0.09850992262363434,
-0.6372531652450562,
-0.44490206241607666,
0.40676259994506836,
-0.466815710067749,
0.41042134165763855,
-0.13934071362018585,
0.23285958170890808,
0.10314612090587616,
0.7622858285903931,
-0.238973006606102,
-0.24071073532104492,
-0.8002027273178101,
-0.4569826126098633,
0.6194466948509216,
0.3114622235298157,
0.3975895643234253,
-0.18886472284793854,
-0.06052614003419876,
-0.21007408201694489,
-0.5376394987106323,
-0.16643546521663666,
0.5406822562217712,
-0.10482792556285858,
-0.1636764258146286,
0.7503709197044373,
-0.31301310658454895,
0.6133771538734436,
-0.0037589510902762413,
-0.5337242484092712,
0.21570459008216858,
-1.0274379253387451,
-0.2098529189825058,
0.10012602806091309,
0.6232476234436035,
0.4946228265762329,
-0.4793725907802582,
-0.11863060295581818,
0.058630138635635376,
-0.024387210607528687,
0.06574085354804993,
-0.5421422123908997,
-0.26727545261383057,
0.10489357262849808,
-0.7823596000671387,
-0.17249760031700134,
0.400424987077713,
-0.6407573819160461,
-0.7751137614250183,
-0.8743966817855835,
0.013622753322124481,
-0.13781172037124634,
-0.471303790807724,
-0.24622337520122528,
-0.9621661305427551,
-0.06981519609689713,
0.5726636052131653,
-0.7413569688796997,
0.18829400837421417,
0.2288699597120285,
0.7503892779350281,
-0.040451981127262115,
-0.5049787759780884,
-0.2550128102302551,
0.4863865077495575,
-0.14708663523197174,
0.9051135778427124,
-0.18020793795585632,
-0.21589653193950653,
-0.27982595562934875,
-0.2067718356847763,
-0.02335616573691368,
-0.6398899555206299,
0.4864843189716339,
-0.21003808081150055,
0.4004565477371216,
-0.9608352184295654,
-0.5044269561767578,
-0.2463592290878296,
-0.1548873782157898,
-1.1016104221343994,
0.4882536828517914,
0.2406795620918274,
-1.4262759685516357,
0.3940322995185852,
-0.7924579977989197,
-0.8499456644058228,
-0.4178462326526642,
-0.0683470219373703,
-0.18936240673065186,
0.4402679204940796,
0.04368402063846588,
0.5683618187904358,
-0.23099763691425323,
0.18407811224460602,
-0.04901106655597687,
-0.22085602581501007,
0.26853930950164795,
-0.256994366645813,
0.5206840634346008,
0.4008792042732239,
0.1715908646583557,
0.11459830403327942,
-0.8427482843399048,
-0.6689100861549377,
0.19001971185207367,
-0.7557984590530396,
-0.2952236235141754,
0.332705020904541,
-0.08192040026187897,
0.11563068628311157,
0.3386085033416748,
-0.1812567263841629,
0.026329752057790756,
-0.023991389200091362,
0.3461863696575165,
0.6479234099388123,
0.40239691734313965,
0.7550142407417297,
-0.7061654925346375,
0.632175087928772,
0.3436185121536255,
0.07577992230653763,
-0.46643728017807007,
-0.20667818188667297,
-0.6429454684257507,
-0.40138283371925354,
0.49279382824897766,
0.3199761211872101,
-0.5282529592514038,
0.306095689535141,
-0.08499399572610855,
-0.14726509153842926,
-0.6498163342475891,
-0.1045663133263588,
0.29359757900238037,
0.656844437122345,
0.17165227234363556,
-0.20035387575626373,
-0.9296079874038696,
-1.1815696954727173,
-0.30181238055229187,
-0.08265316486358643,
-0.157509446144104,
-0.25583022832870483,
0.19329309463500977,
-0.0558687224984169,
0.8779667615890503,
-0.6462820172309875,
-0.09922811388969421,
-0.7094210386276245,
0.41498011350631714,
-0.024652596563100815,
-0.08995849639177322,
0.5623079538345337,
-0.8259527683258057,
-0.06987810879945755,
-0.39171186089515686,
-0.8163266181945801,
-0.08623408526182175,
-0.19100640714168549,
-0.2254713773727417,
-0.0894399955868721,
0.19308112561702728,
-0.4512632489204407,
0.5545053482055664,
0.2861377000808716,
-0.37598878145217896,
0.37774211168289185,
-0.5960439443588257,
0.40178704261779785,
-1.1581499576568604,
0.2657880187034607,
0.09979967027902603,
-0.13125735521316528,
-0.4993540346622467,
-0.08064000308513641,
0.05201219394803047,
0.09264670312404633,
-0.005552159622311592,
0.24482309818267822,
-0.7238010764122009,
-0.3245897889137268,
-0.149888813495636,
0.16450949013233185,
0.2693737745285034,
0.35194599628448486,
-0.0921117514371872,
0.5401788353919983,
0.18866367638111115,
-0.5867699980735779,
0.4246787130832672,
0.2981901466846466,
-0.23083852231502533,
0.7440105676651001,
-0.34659287333488464,
-0.17842882871627808,
-0.719346821308136,
0.41282930970191956,
-1.0059711933135986,
-0.6494253277778625,
-0.0017754696309566498,
-0.42478305101394653,
0.3761131465435028,
-0.12712234258651733,
-0.7584508657455444,
-0.03738494962453842,
-0.6414369940757751,
-0.03198664262890816,
0.027054695412516594,
-0.2381983995437622,
0.8449913859367371,
1.0444430112838745,
-0.48717913031578064,
-0.523177981376648,
-0.6016091704368591,
0.18532592058181763,
-0.12815482914447784,
-0.5088106989860535,
0.18481582403182983,
-0.13535581529140472,
-0.674458920955658,
0.015516349114477634,
-0.3091426193714142,
-0.2719711661338806,
0.08919151872396469,
0.4399872124195099,
0.06878563016653061,
0.11329115927219391,
0.0211164727807045,
0.4192770719528198,
-0.14394626021385193,
0.0013259185943752527,
0.26031264662742615,
0.38502681255340576,
0.3438705503940582,
-0.0315704420208931,
-0.7289773225784302,
0.941804051399231,
0.8409742116928101,
-0.2433079332113266,
0.889514148235321,
0.31811171770095825,
-0.2840014100074768,
0.19576521217823029,
-0.3651788830757141,
0.14471770823001862,
-0.3491858243942261,
0.2194899469614029,
-0.2968668043613434,
-0.20666854083538055,
0.6388303637504578,
0.1753987967967987,
0.07077533006668091,
0.7532373666763306,
0.38077259063720703,
-0.49113729596138,
0.8029754161834717,
0.7315325736999512,
-0.3881758749485016,
0.5831542015075684,
-0.32946011424064636,
-0.1562006026506424,
-0.7008998990058899,
-0.4280468821525574,
-0.5661284327507019,
-0.32075533270835876,
0.13644833862781525,
0.06280342489480972,
0.36028897762298584,
0.19857318699359894,
0.15192772448062897,
0.13646994531154633,
-0.3592216670513153,
0.7646667957305908,
0.7047305703163147,
0.22287149727344513,
0.5623201727867126,
-0.003373746993020177,
0.12702833116054535,
0.19849969446659088,
-0.6166726350784302,
-0.37312284111976624,
1.1360944509506226,
0.16842149198055267,
0.7693583965301514,
0.43255355954170227,
0.6720715165138245,
0.5292277336120605,
-0.01768854819238186,
-0.37952739000320435,
0.3027336597442627,
0.21383795142173767,
-0.48950624465942383,
-0.11404312402009964,
-0.8078802227973938,
-1.0819228887557983,
0.29788681864738464,
-0.12337098270654678,
-0.2566767930984497,
0.15691505372524261,
0.08042523264884949,
-0.23588666319847107,
0.15203382074832916,
-1.221116304397583,
0.33723071217536926,
0.10114836692810059,
0.23684413731098175,
-0.4780395030975342,
-0.7993417978286743,
0.38632822036743164,
0.06254447251558304,
0.2904733121395111,
0.04490385949611664,
-0.041196029633283615,
1.3269734382629395,
-0.41071370244026184,
0.6898799538612366,
-0.09261182695627213,
0.05572037771344185,
0.33720821142196655,
0.09868738800287247,
0.16092373430728912,
0.12693926692008972,
0.10523124039173126,
0.15234807133674622,
0.14274121820926666,
-0.5390661358833313,
-0.541412353515625,
0.42326971888542175,
-0.8783249258995056,
-0.3667892515659332,
-0.5590541362762451,
-0.4248722791671753,
0.1917492300271988,
0.2551807761192322,
0.6058467030525208,
0.6414526700973511,
-0.04896465316414833,
-0.12342901527881622,
0.441768616437912,
0.13399194180965424,
0.4015510678291321,
0.30888015031814575,
0.21125732362270355,
-0.5721157193183899,
0.6364144086837769,
0.5854699015617371,
0.15551990270614624,
0.576705813407898,
0.039194341748952866,
-0.4152996242046356,
-0.5954310894012451,
-0.16859544813632965,
0.546669602394104,
-0.9340552687644958,
-0.11505001038312912,
-0.5187696814537048,
-0.14087386429309845,
-0.3570583164691925,
-0.15968498587608337,
-0.06171752139925957,
-0.5428866744041443,
-0.6139044761657715,
-0.3805006742477417,
-0.17528648674488068,
1.186094880104065,
-0.21987533569335938,
0.03612089902162552,
-0.8885337114334106,
0.9253804087638855,
0.26638081669807434,
0.18725605309009552,
-0.1578523963689804,
-0.2501324713230133,
-0.3279912769794464,
0.029322991147637367,
-0.22865620255470276,
-1.2055147886276245,
-0.09500566869974136,
-0.051717206835746765,
0.8134366869926453,
0.4589758515357971,
0.30588725209236145,
0.5519545078277588,
0.19906973838806152,
0.5990305542945862,
0.504662811756134,
-0.9009535312652588,
0.6553303599357605,
-0.3962012231349945,
0.38059836626052856,
0.6074177026748657,
0.19187627732753754,
-0.48074033856391907,
-0.2650997042655945,
-0.7538580298423767,
-0.7581664323806763,
0.9760639667510986,
0.3171026110649109,
-0.49102941155433655,
0.2519567012786865,
0.2193547934293747,
-0.020245030522346497,
0.15122531354427338,
-0.19875207543373108,
-0.4397924244403839,
0.0112034035846591,
-0.2614831030368805,
-0.14273756742477417,
-0.5858372449874878,
-0.5066410899162292,
-0.165757417678833,
0.18020068109035492,
0.24665196239948273,
0.24644166231155396,
0.40618056058883667,
-0.2890673875808716,
-0.08533606678247452,
0.14546681940555573,
0.7703589797019958,
1.1656852960586548,
-0.3265175223350525,
0.44881385564804077,
-0.05117199569940567,
-0.6150208115577698,
0.46031951904296875,
-0.1988164186477661,
0.13735739886760712,
0.1122947409749031,
0.7634365558624268,
0.42830386757850647,
-0.18231196701526642,
-0.2740463614463806,
0.5308720469474792,
-0.44118714332580566,
-0.06060168519616127,
0.046054642647504807,
0.08711661398410797,
0.10617538541555405,
0.020792579278349876,
0.5139332413673401,
0.6207879781723022,
0.27476945519447327,
-0.8055947422981262,
0.09590239077806473,
-0.30050212144851685,
0.13356226682662964,
-0.6147928833961487,
0.3750319182872772,
0.5365575551986694,
0.13415543735027313,
0.42882490158081055,
-0.20573560893535614,
-0.16173867881298065,
0.5246659517288208,
0.08334681391716003,
0.5468430519104004,
-0.29518136382102966,
0.29686376452445984,
0.3522864282131195,
0.151326984167099,
-0.2747948169708252,
0.20663264393806458,
-0.28061097860336304,
-0.3529452085494995,
-0.6125484704971313,
-0.20517177879810333,
-0.5689892172813416,
-0.10169737040996552,
-0.9036309719085693,
0.022997930645942688,
-0.40006107091903687,
-0.1583956778049469,
0.4535897970199585,
-0.07174918055534363,
-0.4712629020214081,
0.12758851051330566,
-0.0902748554944992,
0.7061610221862793,
-0.7827135324478149,
0.43694618344306946,
0.47659963369369507,
-0.6502721905708313,
-0.36553263664245605,
-0.039695464074611664,
0.2926367521286011,
-0.14030908048152924,
0.5161817669868469,
-0.26974916458129883,
-0.142924502491951,
-0.27222833037376404,
-0.15215176343917847,
-0.9469609260559082,
1.1493395566940308,
0.8221346139907837,
-0.25612297654151917,
-0.23299768567085266,
-0.2358625829219818,
0.196602463722229,
0.0947483703494072,
0.37097546458244324,
0.6719750165939331,
0.5438322424888611,
0.06877027451992035,
-0.9115595817565918,
-0.1653342843055725,
-0.34882888197898865,
-0.26544898748397827,
0.42536285519599915,
-0.6297119855880737,
0.7308250069618225,
-0.37025895714759827,
-0.7879202961921692,
-0.47683167457580566,
0.4058435261249542,
-0.21450722217559814,
0.31195881962776184,
0.14295652508735657,
0.43713074922561646,
1.1454702615737915,
-0.08025291562080383,
1.22971510887146,
-0.0261510219424963,
0.18954341113567352,
1.1609848737716675,
0.12263278663158417,
0.45022380352020264,
0.23028025031089783,
-0.43456822633743286,
0.06304267048835754,
0.5609204173088074,
0.38482341170310974,
0.41089969873428345,
0.11626604199409485,
-0.20684213936328888,
0.25643330812454224,
0.05518374964594841,
-0.4408620297908783,
0.5081520676612854,
0.2010604739189148,
-0.5071767568588257,
-0.33277130126953125,
-0.28058579564094543,
0.12988024950027466,
-0.22750896215438843,
-0.16235917806625366,
1.16379714012146,
-0.3534305691719055,
-0.6852815747261047,
0.3004654049873352,
0.21203863620758057,
0.325300395488739,
-0.641753077507019,
-0.023544378578662872,
-0.5194443464279175,
-0.009114283137023449,
-0.5558953285217285,
-0.895661473274231,
0.6003094911575317,
-0.1346864551305771,
-0.8415884375572205,
-0.23438309133052826,
0.628691554069519,
-0.3246850371360779,
-0.11354637891054153,
0.10936367511749268,
0.2895459532737732,
-0.029311547055840492,
-0.28892114758491516,
-0.09330436587333679,
-0.03305885195732117,
0.059820860624313354,
-0.1946486532688141,
0.5599589943885803,
0.45246946811676025,
0.37893491983413696,
0.5157561898231506,
0.7419319748878479,
0.19956612586975098,
-0.1486796885728836,
-0.019603855907917023,
0.9146164655685425,
-0.9499343633651733,
-0.7316357493400574,
-0.8476696014404297,
0.6266885995864868,
-0.6246080994606018,
-0.3241860270500183,
0.9337829351425171,
0.9497676491737366,
0.456932008266449,
0.05421360582113266,
1.1538774967193604,
0.15921521186828613,
0.7257695198059082,
-0.48275187611579895,
0.9955496191978455,
-0.15325886011123657,
0.21315225958824158,
-0.27072674036026,
-0.8207427859306335,
-0.26325342059135437,
0.3399599492549896,
0.11609826236963272,
-0.44065526127815247,
0.606545090675354,
0.3085255026817322,
-0.030131235718727112,
-0.14386507868766785,
0.04301423951983452,
0.020929209887981415,
0.10116859525442123,
0.23923605680465698,
0.981354832649231,
-0.1599607616662979,
0.44986310601234436,
-0.14732308685779572,
-0.4608926773071289,
-0.29303568601608276,
-0.4416571259498596,
-0.740649938583374,
-1.1239553689956665,
-0.5248762369155884,
-0.2549785077571869,
-0.5087119936943054,
0.43041756749153137,
0.7524014711380005,
-0.430921345949173,
-0.1394883394241333,
0.23849667608737946,
0.4737681448459625,
-0.043785642832517624,
-0.24015115201473236,
0.5274466276168823,
-0.007121004164218903,
-0.36355048418045044,
0.36167123913764954,
0.6879558563232422,
0.4135764241218567,
-0.1473424732685089,
-0.06409013271331787,
0.08506777882575989,
0.34149718284606934,
0.6492226719856262,
0.15824085474014282,
-0.44561129808425903,
0.351270467042923,
-0.3807618319988251,
-0.1666620373725891,
0.2681881785392761,
1.2024428844451904,
-0.3471965491771698,
0.6452104449272156,
0.9513593912124634,
0.3316345810890198,
0.4766077399253845,
0.21057964861392975,
0.7008534669876099,
-0.9715210199356079,
0.1502346694469452,
-0.07806152105331421,
0.7149335145950317,
0.17256218194961548,
-0.5177552700042725,
0.48897236585617065,
0.3814241290092468,
-0.4134710431098938,
-0.6300969123840332,
0.1468898057937622,
-1.1453543901443481,
-0.4468882083892822,
0.9718422293663025,
-0.16102124750614166,
-0.26425406336784363,
-0.37127813696861267,
-0.525673508644104,
0.33121973276138306,
-0.40976637601852417,
0.6186622977256775,
0.8783180117607117,
-0.3450039029121399,
-0.20259639620780945,
0.0322389230132103,
0.29819849133491516,
-0.33019888401031494,
-1.1150226593017578,
0.16805464029312134,
0.8610735535621643,
0.27761250734329224,
0.36763235926628113,
0.9287061095237732,
-0.13525989651679993,
-0.021260233595967293,
0.24355636537075043,
-0.018674040213227272,
-0.1550203263759613,
-0.5276061296463013,
-0.2616913318634033,
0.5105286240577698,
-0.22696705162525177,
-0.27207300066947937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14446v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14446v2
|
Worldwide Federated Training of Language Models
| 2024-05-23T11:25:19 | 2024-05-27T10:59:22 |
Alex Iacob, Lorenzo Sani, Bill Marino, Preslav Aleksandrov, William F. Shen, Nicholas Donald Lane
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC, I.2.7
|
The reliance of language model training on massive amounts of computation and
vast datasets scraped from potentially low-quality, copyrighted, or sensitive
data has come into question practically, legally, and ethically. Federated
learning provides a plausible alternative by enabling previously untapped data
to be voluntarily gathered from collaborating organizations. However, when
scaled globally, federated learning requires collaboration across heterogeneous
legal, security, and privacy regimes while accounting for the inherent locality
of language data; this further exacerbates the established challenge of
federated statistical heterogeneity. We propose a Worldwide Federated Language
Model Training~(WorldLM) system based on federations of federations, where each
federation has the autonomy to account for factors such as its industry,
operating jurisdiction, or competitive environment. WorldLM enables such
autonomy in the presence of statistical heterogeneity via partial model
localization by allowing sub-federations to attentively aggregate key layers
from their constituents. Furthermore, it can adaptively share information
across federations via residual layer embeddings. Evaluations of language
modeling on naturally heterogeneous datasets show that WorldLM outperforms
standard federations by up to $1.91\times$, approaches the personalized
performance of fully local models, and maintains these advantages under
privacy-enhancing techniques.
|
[
-0.03955283388495445,
-0.695925772190094,
0.3010638654232025,
0.451138436794281,
0.22534003853797913,
0.2183159589767456,
-0.23682640492916107,
-0.6656280755996704,
-0.17020845413208008,
0.4517592787742615,
-0.4671463072299957,
-0.38296544551849365,
-0.14652229845523834,
0.0887293890118599,
-0.15758945047855377,
0.8713929653167725,
0.14845089614391327,
0.34222182631492615,
-0.38736245036125183,
-0.43329334259033203,
0.10819213837385178,
-0.8933743834495544,
-0.164530947804451,
-0.43275704979896545,
0.36893385648727417,
0.3943614065647125,
0.76316899061203,
0.6617596745491028,
0.5171202421188354,
0.3139497637748718,
0.13773930072784424,
-0.08002417534589767,
-0.6422074437141418,
0.1350017935037613,
-0.28387054800987244,
-0.48216426372528076,
-0.4237840175628662,
0.24585364758968353,
0.8582426905632019,
0.9712851047515869,
-0.4569913446903229,
0.17814841866493225,
-0.1456579566001892,
0.41935715079307556,
-0.5466548204421997,
0.3895227611064911,
-0.5090062618255615,
0.44671279191970825,
0.04209063574671745,
0.17237237095832825,
-0.41826725006103516,
-0.45622140169143677,
0.32605984807014465,
-0.5546326637268066,
0.3674546778202057,
0.22110123932361603,
0.6634122729301453,
-0.009039320051670074,
-0.24676166474819183,
0.18135786056518555,
-0.8856863379478455,
0.771729052066803,
-0.4536101222038269,
0.7105532288551331,
0.4789298474788666,
0.43778321146965027,
0.13340379297733307,
-0.6508909463882446,
-0.21408696472644806,
0.012671367265284061,
-0.058756642043590546,
-0.16510403156280518,
-0.3416263461112976,
-0.13495291769504547,
-0.018913067877292633,
0.5500027537345886,
-0.46822088956832886,
0.38432151079177856,
-0.16851453483104706,
-0.4297029376029968,
0.7518669962882996,
0.14746278524398804,
0.2271837741136551,
0.3682939410209656,
-0.40478941798210144,
0.06793613731861115,
-0.7137047052383423,
-0.02040296047925949,
0.5096592903137207,
0.8135635852813721,
-0.4808064103126526,
0.1554260551929474,
-0.6296155452728271,
0.6396520733833313,
-0.1751164197921753,
-0.31672370433807373,
0.4213680922985077,
-0.10885585099458694,
-0.4332510828971863,
-0.2743683159351349,
0.9028923511505127,
-0.14540442824363708,
-0.0741434097290039,
-0.7112917900085449,
-0.3552258014678955,
-0.2664819657802582,
-0.060816727578639984,
-0.5253897905349731,
-0.03293800354003906,
0.24372519552707672,
-0.245668426156044,
-0.4396059811115265,
0.08787467330694199,
-0.6117038130760193,
-0.2008461356163025,
-0.6161479353904724,
0.2703065574169159,
-0.022276809439063072,
-0.3533368408679962,
-0.0868389755487442,
0.22081388533115387,
-0.054997146129608154,
-0.07976734638214111,
-1.2610230445861816,
0.40874114632606506,
0.8368710875511169,
0.8698847889900208,
0.09763328731060028,
-0.5344041585922241,
-0.7179445624351501,
0.07503820210695267,
-0.06814330816268921,
0.5009521245956421,
-0.6193621754646301,
-0.04261079430580139,
0.3561449646949768,
0.2136038839817047,
-0.04087835177779198,
-0.32125818729400635,
0.05994031950831413,
-0.6684974431991577,
0.6856817603111267,
-0.198823019862175,
-0.6218717098236084,
0.06876563280820847,
0.3001314699649811,
-0.6461420655250549,
0.6559069156646729,
0.16733554005622864,
-0.8144305944442749,
0.2880769670009613,
-0.5729556679725647,
-0.23476895689964294,
0.0956408753991127,
-0.14038613438606262,
-0.5527144074440002,
-0.02763625979423523,
0.23124364018440247,
0.7198745012283325,
-0.372167706489563,
0.6625120043754578,
-0.5938577651977539,
-0.37443801760673523,
-0.032439038157463074,
-0.5107149481773376,
1.229258418083191,
0.1903543472290039,
-0.23093704879283905,
-0.019716361537575722,
-0.8169454336166382,
0.040441203862428665,
0.21480415761470795,
-0.4997284412384033,
-0.4615356922149658,
-0.34524598717689514,
-0.005453135352581739,
0.18123015761375427,
0.22953546047210693,
-0.8221756815910339,
-0.000749472645111382,
-0.5073051452636719,
0.26776739954948425,
0.8061290383338928,
-0.14082413911819458,
0.7824355363845825,
-0.3124898374080658,
0.524537980556488,
-0.2591870427131653,
0.5193421840667725,
0.3237679898738861,
-0.29045262932777405,
-0.49968281388282776,
-0.3626551032066345,
0.2766493856906891,
0.4820442497730255,
-0.5021480321884155,
0.21361203491687775,
-0.5950648188591003,
-0.44384387135505676,
-0.30063921213150024,
0.024247808381915092,
0.45277339220046997,
0.24853955209255219,
0.050549641251564026,
0.052824802696704865,
-0.5530744194984436,
-0.8781031370162964,
0.045613449066877365,
-0.09556681662797928,
-0.08867162466049194,
0.1688859760761261,
0.4321131706237793,
-0.09671997278928757,
1.1750577688217163,
-0.1576276421546936,
-0.32002919912338257,
-0.093344546854496,
-0.11976712942123413,
-0.20390978455543518,
0.4009174704551697,
0.23063088953495026,
-0.9580156207084656,
-0.674842357635498,
0.287364661693573,
-0.9554197788238525,
0.026617955416440964,
0.18865929543972015,
-0.08926616609096527,
0.3823683261871338,
0.18110954761505127,
-0.10128474980592728,
-0.02531302161514759,
1.050328016281128,
-0.2821013629436493,
0.42710399627685547,
-0.3072088360786438,
-0.30767422914505005,
-0.9372950792312622,
0.2640807330608368,
-0.35199645161628723,
-0.38550445437431335,
-0.7784864902496338,
0.45847824215888977,
0.04087400808930397,
-0.2186620682477951,
-0.39997825026512146,
0.5813744068145752,
-0.5491204261779785,
-0.3515101671218872,
0.08776020258665085,
-0.010142908431589603,
-0.15522313117980957,
0.53825443983078,
0.04017338156700134,
0.6344426870346069,
0.8246713280677795,
-0.29569894075393677,
0.5592071413993835,
0.40886780619621277,
-0.2473365068435669,
0.6064057946205139,
-0.094815194606781,
0.108882375061512,
0.09819629788398743,
0.3241238296031952,
-0.1727171391248703,
-0.5368324518203735,
-0.012531055137515068,
-0.14490073919296265,
-0.004938526079058647,
-0.06911014765501022,
-0.4317668676376343,
-0.04774409905076027,
0.1333608329296112,
0.016980020329356194,
0.439952552318573,
-0.8777206540107727,
0.46919354796409607,
0.6774738430976868,
0.08191081881523132,
-0.9083274006843567,
-0.8474377989768982,
-0.10777110606431961,
-0.08492902666330338,
-0.6353986859321594,
-0.021741969510912895,
0.20683957636356354,
-0.3568626344203949,
-0.0738968625664711,
0.02381453663110733,
-0.33947232365608215,
0.3058204650878906,
0.38904502987861633,
0.06548811495304108,
-0.3242752254009247,
0.1619279384613037,
-0.18231110274791718,
-0.018832745030522346,
0.09051360934972763,
-0.5118635296821594,
0.49226948618888855,
-0.3258202075958252,
-0.44007402658462524,
-0.2920876443386078,
0.4217376112937927,
0.4336743950843811,
-0.41451749205589294,
1.1289358139038086,
0.36768653988838196,
-0.5668342709541321,
-0.45581933856010437,
-0.4929637014865875,
-0.08273815363645554,
-0.48437169194221497,
0.09227224439382553,
-0.06345611810684204,
-1.1631029844284058,
0.6484441757202148,
0.1299738734960556,
0.2991487979888916,
-0.022207938134670258,
0.6212978959083557,
0.17935200035572052,
0.7730099558830261,
1.2345691919326782,
-0.4755704700946808,
0.49935054779052734,
-0.12258418649435043,
0.28760847449302673,
-0.23442906141281128,
-0.4814404249191284,
-0.3655342161655426,
-0.028474386781454086,
-0.5298874974250793,
-0.4061347544193268,
0.13161630928516388,
-0.24108588695526123,
-0.4754776060581207,
0.00559809897094965,
-0.11219354718923569,
0.7538255453109741,
0.477478563785553,
0.03510913625359535,
0.5147790312767029,
0.5452716946601868,
-0.5179851651191711,
0.1053989976644516,
-0.8599087595939636,
-0.3321754038333893,
1.020250678062439,
0.5251146554946899,
0.8011837601661682,
0.2766202390193939,
0.8020755052566528,
0.14717884361743927,
0.6547826528549194,
-0.32832399010658264,
0.26130473613739014,
-0.06240769475698471,
-0.8069816827774048,
-0.46181735396385193,
-0.742718517780304,
-0.5865762233734131,
0.4588821828365326,
-0.1558254212141037,
-0.8593501448631287,
0.3430229127407074,
0.08790752291679382,
-0.3080565333366394,
0.6403080821037292,
-0.4955119490623474,
0.655660092830658,
0.09678342938423157,
-0.6397250890731812,
0.12792496383190155,
-0.7962733507156372,
0.4208414852619171,
-0.2977115213871002,
0.5383366942405701,
-0.10626811534166336,
0.2567121684551239,
0.5123550295829773,
-0.4198669195175171,
1.0580685138702393,
-0.38087019324302673,
-0.27176570892333984,
-0.12247913330793381,
-0.049988579005002975,
0.3717391788959503,
0.12005719542503357,
-0.17300157248973846,
0.31346720457077026,
-0.285240113735199,
-0.4482212960720062,
-0.33668479323387146,
0.7964965105056763,
-0.7994321584701538,
-0.39548012614250183,
-0.35704517364501953,
-0.6486606001853943,
-0.7075622081756592,
0.11881493777036667,
0.022252963855862617,
0.473682701587677,
-0.5675861239433289,
0.24383151531219482,
0.5381337404251099,
0.05910743027925491,
0.3777763247489929,
0.8700266480445862,
-0.2125825434923172,
-0.19261953234672546,
1.106160044670105,
-0.1403379738330841,
0.5790075063705444,
0.5023547410964966,
0.24786509573459625,
-0.3190847933292389,
-0.1016865074634552,
-0.18418368697166443,
0.2296726107597351,
-0.7921532988548279,
-0.2643962800502777,
-0.7080146074295044,
-0.2194645255804062,
-0.2842903435230255,
-0.19022464752197266,
-0.4342174530029297,
-0.331234872341156,
-0.041058216243982315,
-0.22741463780403137,
0.23156368732452393,
0.5562416315078735,
-0.5328887701034546,
0.1664857268333435,
-0.749019980430603,
-0.24403856694698334,
0.3891713619232178,
0.8296086192131042,
-0.0043579405173659325,
-0.3259274363517761,
-0.54203861951828,
0.3007780909538269,
0.1544625163078308,
-0.28759726881980896,
0.3098401129245758,
0.3387830853462219,
0.6244753003120422,
0.20072364807128906,
0.0009692436433397233,
0.4777076244354248,
-0.6524033546447754,
0.5700907707214355,
0.015067926608026028,
-0.8832194209098816,
0.05377331003546715,
-0.34957900643348694,
0.07425839453935623,
0.3312593698501587,
0.5153716206550598,
-0.7861560583114624,
-0.9314749836921692,
-0.6840521097183228,
-0.3416178822517395,
0.9616793990135193,
0.07474584132432938,
0.3720778822898865,
0.45282846689224243,
0.10915359854698181,
0.23027127981185913,
-0.008315177634358406,
-0.9896432757377625,
-0.12511925399303436,
-0.07123420387506485,
-0.24276915192604065,
0.057525038719177246,
0.18780431151390076,
-0.5060016512870789,
-0.15314513444900513,
0.8128834366798401,
-0.2632761299610138,
0.28930023312568665,
-0.013829788193106651,
-0.05284783989191055,
-0.256655752658844,
0.28241634368896484,
0.0927714928984642,
0.6937224268913269,
-0.08317937701940536,
0.027465468272566795,
-0.03637318313121796,
-0.3471549153327942,
0.43080464005470276,
0.21232254803180695,
-0.2126924991607666,
-0.16289593279361725,
0.461832731962204,
0.8323872685432434,
0.12144368141889572,
-0.6391462683677673,
0.5930786728858948,
-0.2636112570762634,
-0.32361167669296265,
-0.044016845524311066,
0.06197047606110573,
0.20352767407894135,
0.33397600054740906,
0.19689132273197174,
0.0195951946079731,
-0.26141953468322754,
-0.39288827776908875,
0.2863404154777527,
0.4331197738647461,
-0.3981808125972748,
-0.466526061296463,
0.6061460971832275,
0.18748608231544495,
-0.18903030455112457,
0.4649849832057953,
0.013064331375062466,
-0.5919501185417175,
0.27488455176353455,
0.7864897847175598,
0.47829505801200867,
-0.4893578886985779,
0.5235865712165833,
0.17386451363563538,
0.2625427842140198,
-0.364826500415802,
0.12951001524925232,
-0.053282227367162704,
-0.7951167225837708,
-0.1352851539850235,
-0.7581634521484375,
-0.660585880279541,
0.12122845649719238,
-0.6424118876457214,
-0.23404142260551453,
-0.6712826490402222,
0.25632601976394653,
-0.2754529118537903,
-0.00989980436861515,
-0.6786298155784607,
0.3117268979549408,
0.3098955452442169,
0.6593623161315918,
-1.1908785104751587,
0.9378373026847839,
0.4900500774383545,
-0.37852156162261963,
-0.8395844101905823,
0.003038472030311823,
0.0993044525384903,
-0.7176679372787476,
0.4400002062320709,
0.07452534884214401,
0.1425473541021347,
-0.10306324064731598,
-0.6678512692451477,
-0.9860512018203735,
1.0226589441299438,
0.5657056570053101,
-0.4956400692462921,
-0.061377670615911484,
0.5510061383247375,
0.7889922857284546,
-0.4633824825286865,
-0.40836435556411743,
0.523802638053894,
-0.037984997034072876,
-0.3250858187675476,
-0.9089312553405762,
-0.008211461827158928,
-0.051277149468660355,
-0.08923494070768356,
-0.08540065586566925,
-0.8260209560394287,
0.9363533854484558,
0.010669738054275513,
-0.3390122354030609,
-0.2724834978580475,
0.5657735466957092,
-0.0735233798623085,
-0.01135196816176176,
0.4379866123199463,
0.27458521723747253,
1.1546844244003296,
0.005030719563364983,
0.9125261902809143,
-0.17106492817401886,
0.7789861559867859,
1.2325857877731323,
-0.5212971568107605,
0.8192996382713318,
0.18511657416820526,
-0.13576453924179077,
0.3323352336883545,
0.305876761674881,
0.02280944213271141,
0.6315945386886597,
-0.11188331246376038,
-0.49652740359306335,
-0.24319297075271606,
-0.046458471566438675,
-0.16265486180782318,
0.5440650582313538,
0.11682336777448654,
-0.28914716839790344,
-0.38775935769081116,
0.41073843836784363,
-0.14962950348854065,
0.22958658635616302,
0.13900859653949738,
0.6800491213798523,
-0.07633057981729507,
-0.2885182201862335,
0.5345633029937744,
0.15170469880104065,
0.5583412051200867,
-0.613893985748291,
0.31883591413497925,
-0.646004319190979,
0.14840736985206604,
-0.20064489543437958,
-0.25239139795303345,
0.35506629943847656,
0.29832667112350464,
-0.1911812573671341,
-0.4585495889186859,
0.330768883228302,
-0.5874612927436829,
-0.47794774174690247,
0.3814550042152405,
0.601572573184967,
-0.0446268655359745,
0.1582118421792984,
-0.5828555822372437,
0.03699424862861633,
-0.026325911283493042,
-0.17925108969211578,
0.5629816055297852,
0.450185090303421,
-0.1490720510482788,
0.8758074045181274,
0.6562427282333374,
-0.06681593507528305,
0.05752338096499443,
0.12960749864578247,
0.7983623147010803,
-0.1330578625202179,
-0.8891084790229797,
-0.5985342264175415,
0.21024233102798462,
-0.15444956719875336,
-0.11286861449480057,
0.8245123028755188,
0.5340946912765503,
1.0006338357925415,
0.10451463609933853,
0.8414636254310608,
-0.12687554955482483,
0.43494167923927307,
-0.4649674594402313,
1.0595508813858032,
-0.6535669565200806,
0.26134827733039856,
0.10125651210546494,
-0.8290705680847168,
-0.5161588788032532,
0.5186144113540649,
-0.2523737847805023,
-0.3833933174610138,
0.49924972653388977,
0.7452618479728699,
-0.481977641582489,
0.5171178579330444,
0.4241437315940857,
0.11550067365169525,
0.4295428991317749,
0.3168015778064728,
0.48528358340263367,
-0.2069394439458847,
0.20486946403980255,
-0.7315875291824341,
-0.14896003901958466,
-0.05821811780333519,
-0.6506514549255371,
-0.7876420021057129,
-0.6655606031417847,
-0.17261581122875214,
0.023789167404174805,
-0.0290103517472744,
1.050437092781067,
0.8075358271598816,
-0.9558029174804688,
-0.26799091696739197,
-0.0010551506420597434,
0.03741146996617317,
-0.10579703748226166,
-0.20286314189434052,
0.2487134337425232,
-0.2015123814344406,
-0.5907362699508667,
0.5266059041023254,
0.10634966939687729,
0.13649524748325348,
-0.7301945090293884,
-0.11409708112478256,
-0.2169511318206787,
-0.1512313038110733,
0.34279677271842957,
0.34522712230682373,
-0.6393633484840393,
-0.35819581151008606,
-0.19628672301769257,
-0.43015187978744507,
0.014688072726130486,
0.6922423839569092,
-0.6019594669342041,
0.43079251050949097,
0.19013938307762146,
0.7729198336601257,
-0.027062101289629936,
-0.1417410522699356,
0.800624668598175,
-1.304984211921692,
0.6877714395523071,
0.2718488872051239,
0.25633561611175537,
0.6821706891059875,
-0.5116460919380188,
0.5447613596916199,
0.2813778519630432,
-0.5989512205123901,
-1.0288811922073364,
-0.106376513838768,
-0.3230579197406769,
-0.152100071310997,
0.9156918525695801,
-0.6424849629402161,
-0.3128930926322937,
-0.21842902898788452,
0.40950584411621094,
0.12871558964252472,
-0.178472101688385,
0.5550604462623596,
0.581609308719635,
0.2440626174211502,
0.22047366201877594,
-0.45780694484710693,
0.4406176805496216,
0.14217551052570343,
-0.9446150660514832,
0.5284147262573242,
0.6895666122436523,
0.5781012773513794,
0.143455371260643,
0.7197927832603455,
0.021881021559238434,
-0.009289775975048542,
0.18151231110095978,
-0.0351078063249588,
-0.12062764912843704,
-0.3900051414966583,
-0.757578432559967,
0.33977144956588745,
-0.36188191175460815,
0.09382458031177521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14445v1
|
Exploring the use of a Large Language Model for data extraction in systematic reviews: a rapid feasibility study
| 2024-05-23T11:24:23 | 2024-05-23T11:24:23 |
Lena Schmidt, Kaitlyn Hair, Sergio Graziozi, Fiona Campbell, Claudia Kapp, Alireza Khanteymoori, Dawn Craig, Mark Engelbert, James Thomas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper describes a rapid feasibility study of using GPT-4, a large
language model (LLM), to (semi)automate data extraction in systematic reviews.
Despite the recent surge of interest in LLMs there is still a lack of
understanding of how to design LLM-based automation tools and how to robustly
evaluate their performance. During the 2023 Evidence Synthesis Hackathon we
conducted two feasibility studies. Firstly, to automatically extract study
characteristics from human clinical, animal, and social science domain studies.
We used two studies from each category for prompt-development; and ten for
evaluation. Secondly, we used the LLM to predict Participants, Interventions,
Controls and Outcomes (PICOs) labelled within 100 abstracts in the EBM-NLP
dataset. Overall, results indicated an accuracy of around 80%, with some
variability between domains (82% for human clinical, 80% for animal, and 72%
for studies of human social sciences). Causal inference methods and study
design were the data extraction items with the most errors. In the PICO study,
participants and intervention/control showed high accuracy (>80%), outcomes
were more challenging. Evaluation was done manually; scoring methods such as
BLEU and ROUGE showed limited value. We observed variability in the LLMs
predictions and changes in response quality. This paper presents a template for
future evaluations of LLMs in the context of data extraction for systematic
review automation. Our results show that there might be value in using LLMs,
for example as second or third reviewers. However, caution is advised when
integrating models such as GPT-4 into tools. Further research on stability and
reliability in practical settings is warranted for each type of data that is
processed by the LLM.
|
[
-0.28123795986175537,
-0.8037189245223999,
0.8242638111114502,
0.18311990797519684,
-0.287951797246933,
-0.09489750117063522,
-0.39626115560531616,
-0.5247540473937988,
0.13359525799751282,
0.4955417215824127,
-0.2648841440677643,
-0.594422459602356,
-0.6850770115852356,
0.5937391519546509,
-0.696129322052002,
0.9313421249389648,
-0.291579008102417,
0.4277770221233368,
0.37692245841026306,
0.18040496110916138,
-0.38874393701553345,
-0.3712080121040344,
-0.33297866582870483,
-0.14863340556621552,
0.6374857425689697,
0.4195569157600403,
0.5000081062316895,
0.5461483001708984,
0.8686012625694275,
0.29407650232315063,
0.22569270431995392,
-0.2365584671497345,
-0.269370973110199,
0.05005620792508125,
-0.09775634855031967,
-0.29422029852867126,
-0.6139255166053772,
0.3076404631137848,
0.63779616355896,
0.628835141658783,
-0.307129830121994,
-0.02807827666401863,
0.09164982289075851,
0.31864112615585327,
-0.160658061504364,
0.30855900049209595,
-0.5888602137565613,
-0.00004864438233198598,
-0.11902596056461334,
-0.11115283519029617,
-0.18847215175628662,
-0.6036543250083923,
0.46408963203430176,
-0.42081549763679504,
0.1330403834581375,
0.15564054250717163,
0.935637354850769,
-0.04552897810935974,
-0.3721030652523041,
-0.6412768363952637,
-0.8234912157058716,
0.8373529314994812,
-0.9581900238990784,
0.16265356540679932,
0.28955569863319397,
0.41063714027404785,
-0.38204777240753174,
-0.8518640995025635,
-0.6532740592956543,
-0.3689330220222473,
0.018284421414136887,
0.12754733860492706,
0.21444712579250336,
0.11900582164525986,
0.4103154242038727,
0.4904429614543915,
-0.34859851002693176,
0.0584932304918766,
-0.434120237827301,
-0.35262808203697205,
0.679057240486145,
0.3047902286052704,
0.42938944697380066,
-0.3552769720554352,
-0.28260886669158936,
0.2043653130531311,
-0.7514041066169739,
-0.0390273816883564,
0.02855953387916088,
0.12363497167825699,
0.16465121507644653,
0.8683622479438782,
-0.1292356252670288,
0.4022615849971771,
-0.26657959818840027,
-0.3659570813179016,
0.20500069856643677,
-0.694556474685669,
-0.27604901790618896,
-0.3152809739112854,
1.096276044845581,
0.20415624976158142,
0.0025647685397416353,
-0.11686587333679199,
-0.536946713924408,
-0.026618678122758865,
0.1896454244852066,
-0.8114956021308899,
-0.25063154101371765,
0.4035220444202423,
-0.5369243025779724,
-0.469973623752594,
-0.027692627161741257,
-0.7888694405555725,
-0.16751143336296082,
-0.34334906935691833,
0.3775985538959503,
-0.2614649534225464,
-0.34003475308418274,
0.32867997884750366,
-0.08040403574705124,
0.5045759081840515,
0.5466492772102356,
-0.607171893119812,
0.4738476276397705,
0.4411699175834656,
0.8255218267440796,
-0.6327797174453735,
-0.2115294337272644,
-0.1922958791255951,
0.0022894993890076876,
-0.5111948251724243,
0.6933653354644775,
-0.26255282759666443,
-0.49262896180152893,
-0.019898444414138794,
0.23391695320606232,
0.05009160190820694,
-0.3682728409767151,
0.6203056573867798,
-0.5382171869277954,
0.34528252482414246,
-0.1764083206653595,
-0.5116957426071167,
0.008534622378647327,
0.3571462333202362,
-0.9485139846801758,
0.5637312531471252,
0.06702174246311188,
-0.6850115656852722,
0.516913890838623,
-0.6086283326148987,
-0.4377383291721344,
0.04646862670779228,
-0.28969255089759827,
-0.46772632002830505,
-0.03462764620780945,
0.24793510138988495,
0.3200313448905945,
-0.6826238632202148,
0.716741681098938,
-0.512768566608429,
-0.2235701084136963,
0.35058146715164185,
-0.25214099884033203,
0.7062321901321411,
0.24150854349136353,
-0.5192222595214844,
0.028400572016835213,
-0.454079806804657,
-0.09465432912111282,
0.19793766736984253,
-0.47822433710098267,
0.006632660049945116,
-0.09135308861732483,
-0.0018600616604089737,
0.4416934847831726,
-0.02424338459968567,
-0.5683164596557617,
0.29326552152633667,
-0.2677355110645294,
0.3232124149799347,
0.623930811882019,
0.2769683301448822,
0.39651691913604736,
-0.09152483195066452,
0.7595540881156921,
-0.4651664197444916,
0.313627690076828,
0.0978391245007515,
-0.39220088720321655,
-0.4888545274734497,
-0.35732609033584595,
0.7745901942253113,
0.22182153165340424,
-0.7444068789482117,
0.4668828845024109,
-0.14234471321105957,
-0.1452544927597046,
-0.2643599510192871,
0.13369528949260712,
0.13584202527999878,
0.3992128074169159,
0.04938681051135063,
-0.5837772488594055,
-0.5365468859672546,
-0.9423317909240723,
-0.07914064824581146,
-0.26672127842903137,
-0.06868267059326172,
0.16005156934261322,
0.7272523045539856,
-0.3403974175453186,
1.0126601457595825,
-0.3953857719898224,
-0.23399174213409424,
-0.6036020517349243,
0.21960745751857758,
0.24185258150100708,
0.14493149518966675,
-0.072034552693367,
-0.6314797401428223,
-0.17567384243011475,
-0.034307487308979034,
-0.9830638766288757,
-0.2949681878089905,
0.06146558001637459,
-0.09780596941709518,
0.036746151745319366,
0.29724135994911194,
-0.7305722832679749,
0.40633562207221985,
0.3681564927101135,
0.2977815866470337,
0.6584990620613098,
0.1305588334798813,
0.1778527796268463,
-0.8184698820114136,
0.28779464960098267,
0.15909872949123383,
0.02230696566402912,
-0.5582171678543091,
-0.2569124698638916,
0.11654537171125412,
-0.01512252725660801,
-0.28892552852630615,
0.5169219374656677,
-0.6719628572463989,
-0.09231626242399216,
-0.18837577104568481,
0.1024879664182663,
-0.10741268843412399,
0.07655022293329239,
0.31182724237442017,
0.4944920241832733,
0.31457820534706116,
-0.4413714110851288,
0.11394531279802322,
0.17899955809116364,
-0.45999884605407715,
0.039237380027770996,
-0.8733867406845093,
0.03518093749880791,
0.23292185366153717,
0.4323200285434723,
-0.879946768283844,
-0.622686505317688,
0.250885546207428,
-0.3020203411579132,
0.40632784366607666,
-0.15863436460494995,
-0.5075696706771851,
-0.5932024121284485,
-0.3955187201499939,
0.07412026822566986,
0.46102091670036316,
-0.08573406934738159,
0.43216434121131897,
0.8215734958648682,
-0.8302457928657532,
-0.2731923758983612,
-0.20993737876415253,
0.3653758466243744,
-0.3027474582195282,
-0.3885570168495178,
-0.11749615520238876,
0.02871731109917164,
-0.38260042667388916,
-0.3354591727256775,
-0.008162195794284344,
0.007398148067295551,
-0.017337437719106674,
0.003354868618771434,
0.5687636733055115,
0.11604958772659302,
0.07300042361021042,
-0.008301599882543087,
-0.01034452859312296,
0.4464395046234131,
0.1544457972049713,
0.2875942289829254,
0.04089944809675217,
-0.31908485293388367,
-0.4616605341434479,
0.22916243970394135,
0.47461646795272827,
0.08317502588033676,
-0.08804874867200851,
0.3742189407348633,
-0.33992335200309753,
-0.15379557013511658,
-0.6863958239555359,
-0.5390636324882507,
-0.3639221489429474,
0.4511663317680359,
-0.21552637219429016,
-0.6482675671577454,
0.24429956078529358,
-0.3195754587650299,
0.29099979996681213,
0.47380948066711426,
0.7166634798049927,
-0.10501638799905777,
1.0490498542785645,
0.7325399518013,
-0.09531783312559128,
0.38205721974372864,
-0.15496696531772614,
0.15252701938152313,
-0.7812967300415039,
-0.08592842519283295,
-0.5170765519142151,
-0.026411915197968483,
-0.47726956009864807,
-0.3657008409500122,
0.5898553729057312,
-0.08105593174695969,
0.15788863599300385,
-0.05076848715543747,
-0.15831516683101654,
0.1307704746723175,
-0.010126370936632156,
0.07372202724218369,
0.4892946779727936,
0.0038178404793143272,
0.044861990958452225,
-0.09023711830377579,
-0.5763522982597351,
-0.7691056132316589,
1.6079561710357666,
0.6025413274765015,
0.7736168503761292,
-0.12110350281000137,
0.7153775095939636,
0.17212092876434326,
0.8379579782485962,
-0.8430893421173096,
0.533578634262085,
0.46208077669143677,
-0.8144446015357971,
-0.4851243793964386,
-0.34465569257736206,
-0.9773906469345093,
0.34691762924194336,
-0.11860694736242294,
-0.32666483521461487,
-0.014144309796392918,
-0.184452086687088,
-0.27461379766464233,
-0.21467076241970062,
-0.6079725623130798,
0.3886987268924713,
-0.49171707034111023,
-0.28647109866142273,
0.044610850512981415,
-0.859656810760498,
0.7304295301437378,
-0.4467089772224426,
0.42122703790664673,
-0.1462852954864502,
-0.12165237218141556,
0.9058290719985962,
-0.42639100551605225,
0.7279244661331177,
-0.02232428267598152,
-0.2236776053905487,
0.2738313674926758,
0.12502194941043854,
0.6537656784057617,
0.30555418133735657,
-0.09130403399467468,
0.2951063811779022,
-0.1913885474205017,
-0.13629686832427979,
-0.5045703649520874,
0.5120955109596252,
-0.5834836363792419,
-0.6861030459403992,
-0.6029520034790039,
-0.5280576348304749,
-0.2915859818458557,
0.4002296030521393,
-0.08618848770856857,
0.26253756880760193,
-0.31899547576904297,
-0.13641752302646637,
0.4329066574573517,
-0.14522525668144226,
0.3260444700717926,
0.709499180316925,
-0.44211307168006897,
-0.5339364409446716,
0.5574204325675964,
-0.0021554208360612392,
0.28571274876594543,
-0.14232096076011658,
0.39748406410217285,
-0.35901713371276855,
-0.9813717603683472,
-0.39190226793289185,
0.3694520592689514,
-0.505832850933075,
0.081617072224617,
-0.7911834120750427,
-0.12266021966934204,
-0.2994183897972107,
0.27116280794143677,
-0.150436669588089,
-0.2723221480846405,
0.10544953495264053,
-0.11441566795110703,
0.08395399153232574,
1.1610093116760254,
-0.0030543392058461905,
-0.014922354370355606,
-0.6253194808959961,
0.4293913245201111,
0.06895972043275833,
0.03132203221321106,
-0.21218347549438477,
-0.44207093119621277,
-0.2036145031452179,
-0.2605038583278656,
-0.10807334631681442,
-0.8690595030784607,
0.7112368941307068,
-0.1284889429807663,
0.5357236266136169,
0.06426416337490082,
-0.19205303490161896,
0.5965825915336609,
-0.47832605242729187,
0.713670015335083,
0.24373990297317505,
-0.6957709789276123,
0.5027924180030823,
-0.5202005505561829,
0.06520117074251175,
0.6334323883056641,
0.6643032431602478,
-0.1703469455242157,
-0.4338356554508209,
-0.46716272830963135,
-0.9228588938713074,
0.6866593360900879,
0.18165422976016998,
-0.3565659523010254,
0.1185566782951355,
0.323557585477829,
0.5235631465911865,
0.2997913956642151,
-0.664257824420929,
0.19536669552326202,
0.4004019498825073,
0.06260798871517181,
-0.1311662495136261,
-0.2940158545970917,
-0.4576186239719391,
-0.27834823727607727,
0.44449958205223083,
-0.179239422082901,
0.2542741000652313,
0.4046678841114044,
-0.202772319316864,
-0.0825272873044014,
0.28921031951904297,
0.1708395630121231,
0.9227222204208374,
-0.2852104604244232,
-0.10239436477422714,
0.04947690665721893,
-0.6165117025375366,
0.06124238669872284,
0.18426083028316498,
-0.18062520027160645,
0.04300351068377495,
0.47344210743904114,
0.01832066848874092,
0.1119682714343071,
-0.48396390676498413,
0.5307574272155762,
-0.3516176640987396,
-0.27327775955200195,
-0.3560751974582672,
-0.3052298426628113,
-0.140144944190979,
-0.04225987195968628,
0.2820412218570709,
-0.27637606859207153,
0.5421789288520813,
-0.4545060992240906,
0.3452160954475403,
0.4794764816761017,
-0.16076892614364624,
-0.42379456758499146,
0.31158849596977234,
0.29050615429878235,
0.07540679723024368,
0.4590151011943817,
-0.04244551435112953,
-0.29082173109054565,
0.5628193616867065,
0.3373926281929016,
0.8691121935844421,
-0.020975260064005852,
0.09771332889795303,
0.33449801802635193,
0.3143133223056793,
-0.4163369834423065,
0.47258472442626953,
0.22514338791370392,
-0.46861493587493896,
-0.5875091552734375,
-0.6054291129112244,
-0.635836660861969,
0.14757491648197174,
-0.5159087181091309,
0.510015070438385,
-0.44185176491737366,
-0.3169451653957367,
0.006268097087740898,
0.12511350214481354,
-0.6366660594940186,
0.0333208329975605,
-0.1386890858411789,
0.5799956321716309,
-0.8486642241477966,
0.9343359470367432,
0.3137072026729584,
-0.48647400736808777,
-1.1811579465866089,
0.0064033749513328075,
0.3696085512638092,
-0.624169111251831,
0.4459150731563568,
-0.015389936044812202,
-0.06075858697295189,
-0.1741250604391098,
-0.6766049265861511,
-0.8575388193130493,
1.2205818891525269,
-0.029095418751239777,
-0.8522031307220459,
-0.1343083679676056,
-0.04323381930589676,
0.608536958694458,
-0.3904801309108734,
0.4719310700893402,
0.8209554553031921,
0.5389962792396545,
0.009377245791256428,
-1.0779259204864502,
0.1903400421142578,
-0.1371338814496994,
-0.14106062054634094,
-0.003008391009643674,
-0.22847172617912292,
0.8024433851242065,
-0.24398966133594513,
-0.23150211572647095,
0.27249622344970703,
0.26865455508232117,
0.29094743728637695,
0.21583321690559387,
0.22621339559555054,
0.20642133057117462,
0.6398575305938721,
-0.14026890695095062,
1.2203863859176636,
-0.2650737166404724,
0.40538927912712097,
0.7846533060073853,
-0.7729324698448181,
0.6164016723632812,
0.6385582089424133,
-0.299733430147171,
0.3209063410758972,
0.6570879817008972,
0.17144852876663208,
0.3349843919277191,
0.2884541451931,
-0.025107640773057938,
0.04559380188584328,
0.08556679636240005,
-0.32959073781967163,
0.16662105917930603,
0.4176483452320099,
-0.6128880381584167,
0.0038957749493420124,
-0.29104605317115784,
0.021486401557922363,
-0.5512502789497375,
-0.12066533416509628,
0.9190354943275452,
0.22650966048240662,
-0.7460383176803589,
0.48333463072776794,
-0.054708484560251236,
0.3828611671924591,
-0.8436974287033081,
-0.24218815565109253,
-0.11644667387008667,
0.0026236495468765497,
-0.23534956574440002,
-0.704961359500885,
0.026069996878504753,
-0.040452826768159866,
0.10485789179801941,
-0.09578904509544373,
0.7313769459724426,
-0.2421005517244339,
-0.6128449440002441,
0.24331870675086975,
0.8217309713363647,
0.3893336057662964,
0.21253778040409088,
-0.6900131702423096,
0.39139553904533386,
0.03767969831824303,
-0.6353566646575928,
0.4650019109249115,
0.5244466662406921,
-0.3089205324649811,
0.5120664238929749,
0.8994796276092529,
0.6615117788314819,
-0.18471655249595642,
0.2774989902973175,
1.0130938291549683,
-0.8964810371398926,
-0.08118008077144623,
-0.8689572215080261,
0.3247331976890564,
-0.14218176901340485,
-0.1932336837053299,
0.896312415599823,
0.4266449511051178,
0.3756759464740753,
0.021495003253221512,
1.1513025760650635,
-0.20240989327430725,
0.3888312876224518,
-0.5728568434715271,
0.42958781123161316,
-0.2410314381122589,
0.42662474513053894,
-0.5330011248588562,
-0.8948295712471008,
-0.42587339878082275,
0.287698358297348,
-0.5686841011047363,
0.0010518392082303762,
1.1061720848083496,
0.800950825214386,
0.3148103356361389,
0.1909422129392624,
0.14687480032444,
0.3409798741340637,
0.7230245471000671,
0.30286526679992676,
0.8796594142913818,
-0.2761680483818054,
0.34829387068748474,
-0.09244596213102341,
-0.5293620824813843,
0.05805419757962227,
-0.7328502535820007,
-0.6907714009284973,
-0.19775572419166565,
-0.04954705759882927,
-0.5146154761314392,
0.11589211225509644,
0.7574275732040405,
0.4715949594974518,
-0.6400334239006042,
-0.39703238010406494,
0.0547603964805603,
0.05260714888572693,
0.08928658068180084,
-0.22661522030830383,
0.35349416732788086,
-0.21531595289707184,
-0.5961167216300964,
0.2276545763015747,
0.4426444470882416,
-0.14259493350982666,
-0.3929462432861328,
-0.1234334409236908,
-0.17764823138713837,
-0.19001120328903198,
0.4694777727127075,
0.27838265895843506,
-0.7630946636199951,
-0.0486268624663353,
0.0750359520316124,
-0.2505719065666199,
-0.06304696947336197,
1.0258947610855103,
-0.46286848187446594,
0.5360538363456726,
0.3128502070903778,
0.4111696481704712,
0.48311811685562134,
0.08373504877090454,
1.0302075147628784,
0.08464573323726654,
-0.2685868740081787,
0.5306846499443054,
0.5493760704994202,
0.14720898866653442,
-0.09651198238134384,
0.638809859752655,
0.20363663136959076,
-0.8811478614807129,
-0.7341088652610779,
0.10636208206415176,
-0.9049482345581055,
0.01515909843146801,
1.5842187404632568,
-0.040754251182079315,
-0.31766626238822937,
-0.5837610363960266,
-0.4240734875202179,
-0.040593016892671585,
-0.4389195442199707,
1.044966697692871,
0.8194430470466614,
-0.3540796637535095,
0.06796389073133469,
-0.9278027415275574,
0.4978884756565094,
0.15328307449817657,
-0.9715792536735535,
-0.05152545124292374,
0.6358875036239624,
0.5366970300674438,
-0.11172579973936081,
0.9284479022026062,
-0.7706663608551025,
0.2860061526298523,
-0.33290669322013855,
0.40612393617630005,
0.3733173906803131,
-0.24777139723300934,
-0.6795727610588074,
0.10538916289806366,
0.3118319511413574,
0.2981995940208435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14437v1
|
Combining Denoising Autoencoders with Contrastive Learning to fine-tune Transformer Models
| 2024-05-23T11:08:35 | 2024-05-23T11:08:35 |
Alejo Lopez-Avila, Víctor Suárez-Paniagua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Recently, using large pretrained Transformer models for transfer learning
tasks has evolved to the point where they have become one of the flagship
trends in the Natural Language Processing (NLP) community, giving rise to
various outlooks such as prompt-based, adapters or combinations with
unsupervised approaches, among many others. This work proposes a 3 Phase
technique to adjust a base model for a classification task. First, we adapt the
model's signal to the data distribution by performing further training with a
Denoising Autoencoder (DAE). Second, we adjust the representation space of the
output to the corresponding classes by clustering through a Contrastive
Learning (CL) method. In addition, we introduce a new data augmentation
approach for Supervised Contrastive Learning to correct the unbalanced
datasets. Third, we apply fine-tuning to delimit the predefined categories.
These different phases provide relevant and complementary knowledge to the
model to learn the final task. We supply extensive experimental results on
several datasets to demonstrate these claims. Moreover, we include an ablation
study and compare the proposed method against other ways of combining these
techniques.
|
[
-0.5813990831375122,
-0.41537022590637207,
-0.12340199202299118,
-0.067989282310009,
-0.3307397663593292,
-0.009667803533375263,
-0.24466292560100555,
-0.40714672207832336,
-0.16792188584804535,
0.6702904105186462,
-0.37252092361450195,
-0.31346696615219116,
-0.9097532629966736,
0.2552686929702759,
-0.5154997110366821,
0.9964322447776794,
-0.05880604311823845,
-0.07315859943628311,
0.19144698977470398,
-0.09262995421886444,
-0.8370126485824585,
-0.3557395339012146,
-0.8222604990005493,
-0.648354709148407,
0.14570169150829315,
0.4505469799041748,
0.558678925037384,
0.5714421272277832,
0.6036264300346375,
0.3286744952201843,
-0.09799163788557053,
0.11496682465076447,
-0.3965504467487335,
0.021997932344675064,
-0.46707066893577576,
-0.6614986658096313,
-0.18804161250591278,
-0.08508230000734329,
0.39071017503738403,
1.0136830806732178,
-0.09523419290781021,
-0.2146930694580078,
0.5450595617294312,
0.7491617798805237,
-0.6500084400177002,
0.23016130924224854,
-0.7799034118652344,
0.12337318062782288,
0.47853514552116394,
-0.2195882797241211,
-0.3982551395893097,
-0.07547098398208618,
0.216319739818573,
-0.3478328585624695,
0.7352522611618042,
-0.18089458346366882,
0.7403841614723206,
0.6695451736450195,
-0.49890580773353577,
-0.16997334361076355,
-0.9589950442314148,
0.8843977451324463,
-0.6266818046569824,
0.31204017996788025,
0.16976559162139893,
0.11290697008371353,
0.2013106793165207,
-0.7093251943588257,
-0.6257094144821167,
0.07862334698438644,
-0.5916834473609924,
0.11465716361999512,
-0.3332025706768036,
0.04573047533631325,
0.05763077735900879,
0.7547345161437988,
-0.3639523983001709,
0.3511504530906677,
-0.4124365746974945,
0.12138666957616806,
0.32422786951065063,
0.08633046597242355,
0.05196504294872284,
-0.05731114000082016,
-0.3167250156402588,
-0.3624975085258484,
-0.22174832224845886,
-0.21413327753543854,
-0.02663089707493782,
0.4834401607513428,
-0.24651800096035004,
0.4120342433452606,
-0.25685563683509827,
0.7870675325393677,
0.7100130319595337,
0.3030065596103668,
0.39973771572113037,
-0.3104466199874878,
-0.3979673683643341,
-0.17001654207706451,
0.4917108118534088,
0.5786893367767334,
0.1955806016921997,
-0.06258916854858398,
-0.33386871218681335,
0.2818862795829773,
0.6172885298728943,
-0.839072048664093,
-0.5459439754486084,
0.07715122401714325,
-0.5055325031280518,
-0.5469043254852295,
-0.1473643034696579,
-0.7626999616622925,
-0.3477770984172821,
-0.8444061875343323,
0.5555795431137085,
-0.256788045167923,
-0.07227801531553268,
0.3014511466026306,
0.1231587827205658,
0.18071605265140533,
0.1835111528635025,
-1.2224717140197754,
0.6115057468414307,
0.33004459738731384,
0.5818787813186646,
-0.44738438725471497,
-0.2528083622455597,
-0.2514900863170624,
0.01721482165157795,
-0.15562745928764343,
0.6284853219985962,
-0.488765150308609,
-0.3098237216472626,
-0.009331243112683296,
0.25264614820480347,
-0.24197261035442352,
-0.7251780033111572,
0.4637416899204254,
-0.48591288924217224,
0.2578302323818207,
0.10580519586801529,
-0.4388691782951355,
-0.40911006927490234,
0.2698189318180084,
-0.7682583332061768,
0.9681885242462158,
0.4051368236541748,
-0.7274219989776611,
0.2772178053855896,
-0.6648902297019958,
-0.5752786993980408,
-0.11120490729808807,
0.27788570523262024,
-0.3648849427700043,
0.0847153291106224,
0.5554599165916443,
0.6391377449035645,
-0.12647412717342377,
0.1440788209438324,
0.18864575028419495,
-0.2574724853038788,
-0.08955815434455872,
-0.3278503119945526,
0.49294355511665344,
0.29191169142723083,
-0.568768322467804,
0.12169370800256729,
-0.8397504687309265,
-0.46230241656303406,
-0.04681389033794403,
-0.19796067476272583,
-0.2883278727531433,
-0.22084227204322815,
-0.12228690832853317,
0.22833015024662018,
0.0864061787724495,
-0.24522851407527924,
0.11164266616106033,
-0.6733928322792053,
0.27327755093574524,
0.38243743777275085,
0.09211764484643936,
0.8494812250137329,
-0.4826042056083679,
0.19781708717346191,
0.3681095242500305,
0.1751103699207306,
-0.2282247543334961,
0.016857774928212166,
-1.351065993309021,
0.08080081641674042,
0.3820308446884155,
0.6362386345863342,
-0.8755407929420471,
0.9502635598182678,
-0.22995436191558838,
-0.43438249826431274,
-0.5872986912727356,
0.14161688089370728,
0.006548760458827019,
0.8198854327201843,
0.964593231678009,
-0.2888781428337097,
-0.6980909109115601,
-0.7693434357643127,
0.012536738999187946,
0.27325439453125,
-0.23330020904541016,
-0.014867272228002548,
0.43242087960243225,
-0.4904271364212036,
0.7592484354972839,
-0.6095622777938843,
-0.6491667032241821,
-0.2435244619846344,
0.49875408411026,
0.25847136974334717,
0.863572895526886,
0.422482430934906,
-0.8514920473098755,
-0.48777467012405396,
0.1339908391237259,
-0.4487806260585785,
-0.14492781460285187,
-0.08281080424785614,
0.13117392361164093,
0.008418885059654713,
0.695353090763092,
-0.06625943630933762,
0.225870743393898,
0.6565934419631958,
-0.11875211447477341,
0.040455322712659836,
-0.2669373154640198,
0.230056032538414,
-1.1710551977157593,
-0.17454956471920013,
0.08437523245811462,
-0.1766337752342224,
-0.9756354093551636,
-0.08137726783752441,
0.010915346443653107,
0.10361456125974655,
-0.2593073546886444,
0.4101676046848297,
-0.3465137183666229,
0.3078227937221527,
-0.812781035900116,
-0.06931746006011963,
0.10815373808145523,
0.5559436678886414,
0.11896590143442154,
0.41460803151130676,
0.6884045600891113,
-0.8346681594848633,
0.18687355518341064,
0.4367418885231018,
0.05863639712333679,
0.6010188460350037,
-0.5385231971740723,
0.11950671672821045,
-0.36046016216278076,
0.18381020426750183,
-1.097792625427246,
0.11708533018827438,
0.24944430589675903,
-0.1414380520582199,
0.46471142768859863,
-0.186947301030159,
-0.1790691763162613,
-0.24571286141872406,
0.005902657750993967,
0.40911972522735596,
0.6745253205299377,
-0.7762110233306885,
0.8868511319160461,
0.12681131064891815,
-0.174108624458313,
-0.40702420473098755,
-0.6450335383415222,
-0.20757907629013062,
-0.33666685223579407,
-0.14697661995887756,
0.7900739908218384,
0.020265264436602592,
0.12109135091304779,
0.030729446560144424,
-0.08035723119974136,
-0.20225894451141357,
0.19403086602687836,
0.12917056679725647,
0.37780219316482544,
0.022743837907910347,
-0.1859503537416458,
0.12494447082281113,
-0.2653472423553467,
-0.14114858210086823,
-0.16896194219589233,
0.5899685621261597,
0.0004328357463236898,
-0.13655568659305573,
-0.36249542236328125,
0.07402467727661133,
0.2516130805015564,
-0.1373925358057022,
0.6091626286506653,
0.8593162894248962,
-0.43394914269447327,
-0.30962347984313965,
-0.5899088382720947,
-0.46967554092407227,
-0.5149220824241638,
0.17712977528572083,
-0.19738495349884033,
-0.9448621273040771,
0.29846441745758057,
-0.19458939135074615,
0.18413923680782318,
0.5979422926902771,
0.5209992527961731,
-0.0010588724398985505,
0.8982470035552979,
0.932916522026062,
-0.2249976545572281,
0.5988004803657532,
-0.4056795537471771,
0.22815844416618347,
-0.796754777431488,
-0.14838828146457672,
-0.6215606331825256,
-0.4968748688697815,
-0.5546888113021851,
-0.4902576804161072,
0.08436396718025208,
0.2249080240726471,
-0.12366000562906265,
0.5579365491867065,
-0.6577290296554565,
0.4524477422237396,
0.3279323875904083,
0.26188525557518005,
0.2655544579029083,
0.10097920149564743,
0.14778868854045868,
0.03910597413778305,
-0.5301329493522644,
-0.13322466611862183,
0.9305173754692078,
0.19521789252758026,
0.5902596116065979,
-0.1936986744403839,
0.5301605463027954,
0.34614408016204834,
0.3727639317512512,
-0.7191265225410461,
0.15149323642253876,
-0.748826801776886,
-0.08132022619247437,
-0.30211302638053894,
-0.21821939945220947,
-1.1862843036651611,
0.4719649851322174,
-0.4635114371776581,
-0.27446672320365906,
0.6433894038200378,
0.2437109798192978,
-0.2406609058380127,
0.1754787564277649,
-0.5564653277397156,
0.6260194182395935,
0.1046113446354866,
0.006986929569393396,
-0.23259450495243073,
-0.7475517392158508,
0.16952316462993622,
-0.08032020926475525,
0.2070237547159195,
0.10348064452409744,
0.23640404641628265,
0.6150805354118347,
-0.03779253736138344,
1.1081207990646362,
-0.19668562710285187,
-0.18261246383190155,
-0.02435772493481636,
0.018591614440083504,
0.5781112909317017,
-0.44924163818359375,
-0.0509612001478672,
-0.03738061338663101,
-0.2096027135848999,
-0.2835288345813751,
-0.7356407046318054,
0.49112218618392944,
-0.7035289406776428,
-0.23823422193527222,
-0.023707138374447823,
-0.5971723198890686,
-0.33376896381378174,
0.10708047449588776,
0.2458880990743637,
0.3728753328323364,
-0.07658162713050842,
0.23919567465782166,
0.6010333299636841,
0.12579551339149475,
0.41573265194892883,
0.5052456259727478,
0.18869847059249878,
-0.35325175523757935,
0.8878306150436401,
-0.29337140917778015,
0.2627861201763153,
0.5498568415641785,
0.109601691365242,
-0.17919723689556122,
-0.8620849251747131,
0.07687954604625702,
0.14755649864673615,
-0.8805115818977356,
-0.25672537088394165,
-0.7324484586715698,
-0.3149537146091461,
-0.4201015532016754,
-0.4011058807373047,
-0.3079904615879059,
-0.12831954658031464,
-0.6637182831764221,
-0.012326535768806934,
0.03828410431742668,
0.616906464099884,
0.013645702041685581,
0.7160963416099548,
-0.8714073300361633,
0.7509631514549255,
0.4175431728363037,
0.31875699758529663,
-0.11985307186841965,
-0.9831990003585815,
-0.20043842494487762,
-0.004562218673527241,
-0.1952628344297409,
-0.5442259311676025,
0.6211889386177063,
0.1473744809627533,
0.544264018535614,
0.07437717169523239,
0.1820218563079834,
0.4652695953845978,
-0.3619135916233063,
0.5782051086425781,
0.3812819719314575,
-0.9281741380691528,
0.5575880408287048,
-0.012746977619826794,
0.2175138145685196,
0.8213186860084534,
0.375349760055542,
-0.3645871579647064,
-0.22219699621200562,
-0.5836986899375916,
-0.8571909070014954,
0.6243849396705627,
0.22903110086917877,
0.1520487666130066,
0.055393654853105545,
0.40716296434402466,
0.2592095732688904,
0.033537719398736954,
-0.8051574230194092,
-0.47491732239723206,
-0.45118317008018494,
-0.46102479100227356,
-0.2622602581977844,
-0.1625751554965973,
-0.009009088389575481,
-0.38927367329597473,
0.6256628036499023,
-0.28794512152671814,
-0.0657677873969078,
0.1127956435084343,
-0.4005942940711975,
-0.013533570803701878,
0.44595253467559814,
0.29057130217552185,
0.29844343662261963,
-0.16222380101680756,
0.2502051889896393,
0.4735746383666992,
-0.41980236768722534,
0.1816934496164322,
0.31392160058021545,
-0.13258123397827148,
-0.0562174990773201,
0.09147360175848007,
1.0455248355865479,
0.3252662420272827,
-0.09017110615968704,
0.4405246675014496,
-0.0073931519873440266,
-0.512826681137085,
0.11328255385160446,
0.22656181454658508,
-0.29794397950172424,
0.2340884953737259,
0.2590230107307434,
0.38013508915901184,
0.4337426722049713,
-0.12012991309165955,
0.24349190294742584,
0.18694855272769928,
-0.5958573222160339,
-0.2764209508895874,
0.5164200663566589,
0.4639987349510193,
-0.09650105237960815,
0.3793901205062866,
0.08414337038993835,
-0.4722193479537964,
0.46211057901382446,
0.6866798400878906,
0.9281399250030518,
-0.5362849235534668,
0.09245021641254425,
0.5345215201377869,
0.3963029682636261,
-0.3002645969390869,
-0.09401578456163406,
0.06673417240381241,
-0.9948919415473938,
-0.5758363008499146,
-0.6616464257240295,
-0.36195436120033264,
0.3376174569129944,
-0.8022549748420715,
0.4368959069252014,
-0.09828117489814758,
0.2020454704761505,
0.016564441844820976,
-0.16184420883655548,
-0.8428170680999756,
0.6348339915275574,
0.11198775470256805,
0.5274927616119385,
-1.2211947441101074,
0.7331850528717041,
0.4476337432861328,
-0.03441016748547554,
-0.600062906742096,
-0.03365403786301613,
-0.5138275623321533,
-0.4981823265552521,
0.6179033517837524,
0.05548720434308052,
-0.10332434624433517,
0.3802478611469269,
-0.29264089465141296,
-0.7351395487785339,
0.8791888356208801,
0.08650702238082886,
-0.7393818497657776,
0.00031225461862049997,
0.14412091672420502,
0.5878862738609314,
-0.4812014400959015,
0.09268070757389069,
0.8970013856887817,
0.3882465958595276,
0.24503417313098907,
-0.8086236715316772,
0.004722184967249632,
-0.20985047519207,
0.03076985850930214,
0.16729922592639923,
-0.1496250331401825,
0.74481201171875,
0.09130612760782242,
-0.1458638310432434,
-0.25180783867836,
0.6564422845840454,
-0.13868160545825958,
-0.13670866191387177,
1.0192406177520752,
0.4679976999759674,
0.5309791564941406,
-0.012797975912690163,
0.7759280204772949,
-0.36414453387260437,
0.42495760321617126,
1.1590690612792969,
-0.14593461155891418,
0.5740357041358948,
0.3630656898021698,
-0.15358522534370422,
0.5090590715408325,
0.23418766260147095,
-0.43633484840393066,
0.6739879250526428,
0.032536644488573074,
-0.09644710272550583,
-0.1017267107963562,
-0.03176179155707359,
-0.19166740775108337,
0.4341065585613251,
0.35940539836883545,
-0.41129305958747864,
-0.4596736431121826,
0.3680279850959778,
-0.38678330183029175,
0.19508600234985352,
-0.36686673760414124,
0.9927822351455688,
-0.07499590516090393,
-0.715640127658844,
0.7345802783966064,
0.04767902195453644,
0.9683950543403625,
-0.19070647656917572,
-0.24373622238636017,
-0.22496244311332703,
0.21924254298210144,
-0.34994664788246155,
-0.5883960127830505,
0.5157668590545654,
-0.3148559629917145,
-0.3269023597240448,
-0.2977110743522644,
0.7945939898490906,
-0.6062156558036804,
-0.3699275255203247,
0.26985499262809753,
0.2821638286113739,
-0.16991381347179413,
0.01801207661628723,
-0.6467661261558533,
-0.24016425013542175,
0.12125103175640106,
0.02637004479765892,
0.21779108047485352,
0.19648392498493195,
0.20166665315628052,
0.3868355453014374,
0.5834278464317322,
-0.029069365933537483,
-0.01918386109173298,
0.4285259246826172,
0.9678975343704224,
-0.5274585485458374,
-0.42063629627227783,
-0.7255051136016846,
0.4949392080307007,
0.08428869396448135,
0.04754072055220604,
0.4077920615673065,
0.3265347182750702,
0.781312882900238,
-0.2554846405982971,
0.8062562942504883,
0.035742033272981644,
0.6834448575973511,
-0.6347090005874634,
0.14420266449451447,
-0.3476397395133972,
0.33942747116088867,
-0.11338938772678375,
-1.0089858770370483,
-0.5569012761116028,
0.4973842203617096,
-0.08530881255865097,
0.06459113210439682,
0.7745445966720581,
0.6707846522331238,
-0.20873546600341797,
0.08305423706769943,
0.315287709236145,
0.19937558472156525,
0.18537282943725586,
0.33818086981773376,
0.7251428961753845,
-0.6342412829399109,
0.5041690468788147,
-0.7812538146972656,
-0.1725034862756729,
-0.18763698637485504,
-0.8058462738990784,
-1.0944451093673706,
-0.6014387011528015,
-0.5054708123207092,
-0.07575853914022446,
-0.17205524444580078,
0.6424583196640015,
0.6202834248542786,
-1.0526933670043945,
-0.0789661556482315,
-0.40062665939331055,
-0.19067580997943878,
-0.3393803536891937,
-0.2497110366821289,
0.3832385838031769,
-0.7094793915748596,
-1.003056287765503,
0.41837403178215027,
-0.08702149242162704,
0.41459330916404724,
0.12197617441415787,
0.25788867473602295,
0.045167285948991776,
-0.21555690467357635,
0.6288702487945557,
-0.026408547535538673,
-0.47968658804893494,
-0.184867262840271,
-0.15833716094493866,
0.036349933594465256,
0.2768602967262268,
0.7953348159790039,
-0.8669462203979492,
0.23798881471157074,
0.40158510208129883,
0.6718231439590454,
0.6224913001060486,
0.25446510314941406,
0.5842301249504089,
-0.783906102180481,
0.04338362440466881,
0.15337757766246796,
0.38393327593803406,
0.5221889615058899,
-0.3955874443054199,
0.559074342250824,
-0.009957957081496716,
-0.5266572833061218,
-0.43727773427963257,
0.1563437432050705,
-1.0291152000427246,
-0.43629321455955505,
0.9710357785224915,
0.22340266406536102,
0.15284404158592224,
-0.47012820839881897,
-0.2563208043575287,
0.5203713178634644,
0.007254511117935181,
0.8362499475479126,
0.4393235146999359,
-0.04097466915845871,
-0.29622790217399597,
-0.17513157427310944,
0.5571614503860474,
0.575361430644989,
-0.969882071018219,
0.17870771884918213,
0.3698135018348694,
0.31664302945137024,
0.2488105446100235,
0.18756937980651855,
0.10167393088340759,
-0.009397424757480621,
-0.2622098922729492,
0.2183241993188858,
0.1027492880821228,
-0.3011251389980316,
-0.9137129187583923,
0.23377206921577454,
-0.07789865136146545,
-0.2404639571905136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14431v1
|
RaFe: Ranking Feedback Improves Query Rewriting for RAG
| 2024-05-23T11:00:19 | 2024-05-23T11:00:19 |
Shengyu Mao, Yong Jiang, Boli Chen, Xiao Li, Peng Wang, Xinyu Wang, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) and Retrieval Augmentation Generation (RAG)
techniques have evolved, query rewriting has been widely incorporated into the
RAG system for downstream tasks like open-domain QA. Many works have attempted
to utilize small models with reinforcement learning rather than costly LLMs to
improve query rewriting. However, current methods require annotations (e.g.,
labeled relevant documents or downstream answers) or predesigned rewards for
feedback, which lack generalization, and fail to utilize signals tailored for
query rewriting. In this paper, we propose ours, a framework for training query
rewriting models free of annotations. By leveraging a publicly available
reranker, ours~provides feedback aligned well with the rewriting objectives.
Experimental results demonstrate that ours~can obtain better performance than
baselines.
|
[
-0.15431398153305054,
-0.3501136898994446,
0.4545367658138275,
0.11971791833639145,
-0.17547690868377686,
-0.028125165030360222,
-0.17761282622814178,
-0.1966496855020523,
0.6453274488449097,
0.8935340046882629,
-0.6370834112167358,
-0.5417361855506897,
-0.3228955864906311,
0.11771111190319061,
-0.23507800698280334,
1.6091772317886353,
0.252349853515625,
0.12464367598295212,
-0.4362884759902954,
-0.21886514127254486,
-0.2710922658443451,
-0.5564842224121094,
-1.0808110237121582,
-0.15348605811595917,
1.1843317747116089,
0.29198986291885376,
0.5313692092895508,
0.2297924906015396,
0.4670138657093048,
0.3362802267074585,
0.027078907936811447,
0.5945355296134949,
-0.8931912779808044,
0.6962217092514038,
-0.4622124135494232,
-0.8807287812232971,
-0.5634434819221497,
0.2558973431587219,
0.7278969287872314,
0.710286021232605,
-0.30280083417892456,
0.3776244819164276,
-0.043817102909088135,
1.0152783393859863,
-0.7275309562683105,
-0.045186590403318405,
-0.8435442447662354,
-0.2557973861694336,
0.03612861782312393,
-0.4427439570426941,
-0.7660559415817261,
-0.8073123693466187,
-0.03730680048465729,
-0.8729064464569092,
0.47650885581970215,
0.5136985182762146,
0.7917292714118958,
0.6784232258796692,
-0.3551819622516632,
-0.2046569287776947,
-0.5959287881851196,
0.6694965362548828,
-0.4070090055465698,
0.47263050079345703,
0.503989577293396,
0.6333274841308594,
-0.3912292718887329,
-0.8687999844551086,
-0.10771100223064423,
-0.5898051261901855,
-0.19753515720367432,
0.20506176352500916,
0.21954040229320526,
-0.03967874124646187,
0.13948200643062592,
0.435176283121109,
-0.1205768808722496,
-0.05369299650192261,
-0.41022664308547974,
0.10908640176057816,
0.785484254360199,
0.13481199741363525,
-0.2870756983757019,
0.023045634850859642,
-0.18067969381809235,
0.06802592426538467,
-0.7488952875137329,
0.1841515451669693,
0.18157139420509338,
0.3122497498989105,
0.5075451135635376,
0.40128836035728455,
-0.4715978801250458,
0.7113779783248901,
0.17019888758659363,
0.13778088986873627,
0.05468546226620674,
0.0035584219731390476,
-0.10074571520090103,
-0.4304646849632263,
0.192633718252182,
0.3568766415119171,
0.12373025715351105,
-0.6130263209342957,
-0.45089712738990784,
-0.4602349102497101,
0.7773233652114868,
-0.8478949666023254,
-0.1628943681716919,
0.03072374500334263,
-0.4743998348712921,
-0.5495455265045166,
0.11925514042377472,
-0.412801593542099,
-0.5401396155357361,
-0.3416580557823181,
0.4256703853607178,
-0.06496872007846832,
-0.054074570536613464,
-0.24601370096206665,
-0.28487518429756165,
0.2889525592327118,
0.6453579664230347,
-0.8503544330596924,
0.299014151096344,
0.9090288877487183,
0.42816397547721863,
-0.09266576915979385,
-0.18037576973438263,
-1.1084086894989014,
0.22924457490444183,
-0.4800053834915161,
1.0633885860443115,
-0.7611264586448669,
-0.3527238667011261,
-0.11248482018709183,
0.2784971296787262,
-0.13702312111854553,
-0.6609506011009216,
0.5749351382255554,
-1.041141390800476,
0.2636725604534149,
-0.16756343841552734,
-0.691135048866272,
-0.057162169367074966,
0.3275592029094696,
-0.6663113832473755,
0.9717947840690613,
0.21635757386684418,
-0.611536979675293,
0.46144092082977295,
-0.4002978205680847,
-0.07444571703672409,
0.10979855805635452,
0.04685655236244202,
-0.5145654678344727,
0.4789265990257263,
0.4382641315460205,
-0.03038298338651657,
-0.2018907070159912,
0.024497555568814278,
-0.13330943882465363,
-0.5774591565132141,
0.13330155611038208,
-0.013924150727689266,
0.25219905376434326,
0.06709706038236618,
-0.12981128692626953,
0.6398517489433289,
-0.5878723859786987,
0.3473598062992096,
-0.0746234580874443,
-0.6946334838867188,
-0.39230242371559143,
-0.07932358980178833,
-0.22132563591003418,
-0.24075312912464142,
-0.09583763778209686,
-0.4027881622314453,
0.5192743539810181,
-0.6398609280586243,
0.04473895952105522,
0.709872841835022,
0.3420664668083191,
0.5625950694084167,
-0.6289568543434143,
0.8358768820762634,
-0.5063201189041138,
0.040468327701091766,
0.16923744976520538,
-0.4979960322380066,
-0.9255026578903198,
-0.23204416036605835,
0.7369226217269897,
0.1851527988910675,
-0.8442661166191101,
-0.27580589056015015,
-0.3807741403579712,
-0.5468779802322388,
-0.971216082572937,
0.16324833035469055,
0.5986813902854919,
0.14807572960853577,
0.3516409993171692,
-0.2633342742919922,
-0.44219401478767395,
-0.6374823451042175,
-0.47129616141319275,
-0.1593656986951828,
-0.19060924649238586,
0.43801790475845337,
0.14668460190296173,
-0.07436253130435944,
0.726901650428772,
-0.5573181509971619,
-0.48774951696395874,
-0.3059285283088684,
0.15654180943965912,
0.023438194766640663,
0.2811996638774872,
0.2039065957069397,
-0.6393983960151672,
-0.31880414485931396,
-0.35804328322410583,
-0.30252107977867126,
-0.23180989921092987,
0.1264534294605255,
-0.49005988240242004,
0.31777411699295044,
0.6772707104682922,
-0.11651189625263214,
0.36079856753349304,
0.26757845282554626,
-0.021161004900932312,
0.3396534025669098,
-0.17249563336372375,
0.33042284846305847,
-0.8799740076065063,
-0.07764765620231628,
-0.22469112277030945,
-0.4201257526874542,
-0.09899545460939407,
0.2772822678089142,
0.0021229705307632685,
-0.14295558631420135,
-0.21298450231552124,
0.5261319279670715,
-0.37944817543029785,
-0.11690761148929596,
-0.5530194044113159,
0.1674223393201828,
0.10459709912538528,
0.703441321849823,
0.07886171340942383,
0.7902258038520813,
-0.25039517879486084,
-0.6175298690795898,
0.17980515956878662,
0.2689746916294098,
0.06324502825737,
0.6635411977767944,
-0.7060779333114624,
0.2254423350095749,
-0.3319337069988251,
0.6529761552810669,
-0.8370888829231262,
-0.39786776900291443,
0.03376751393079758,
-0.6813945174217224,
0.3520335555076599,
-0.6885599493980408,
-0.03528854250907898,
-0.12136533111333847,
-0.6964788436889648,
0.16863778233528137,
0.39657989144325256,
-0.6852049231529236,
0.3324234187602997,
0.3304794728755951,
-0.011919485405087471,
-0.55089271068573,
-0.24177351593971252,
-0.1893065720796585,
0.08313977718353271,
-0.4391915798187256,
0.37643054127693176,
0.12655578553676605,
0.11407613754272461,
0.04911264777183533,
0.0020583432633429766,
-0.23527708649635315,
0.08884476125240326,
0.4348967373371124,
-0.10028217732906342,
-0.16613472998142242,
0.49441617727279663,
0.0014604106545448303,
-0.29862409830093384,
0.061279717832803726,
-0.4725624620914459,
0.13755327463150024,
0.051510877907276154,
-0.38108938932418823,
-0.3068046569824219,
0.1903804987668991,
0.4550299346446991,
-0.6499503254890442,
0.7668259739875793,
0.5270704627037048,
0.06476957350969315,
-0.6717561483383179,
-0.4689789116382599,
-0.36709725856781006,
-0.43226125836372375,
0.18623122572898865,
-0.15124556422233582,
-1.2184474468231201,
0.07727519422769547,
-0.24213415384292603,
0.17268206179141998,
0.35683444142341614,
0.5319086313247681,
-0.04497265815734863,
0.969913899898529,
0.8203865885734558,
0.02195727825164795,
0.4626736342906952,
-0.19856685400009155,
0.07465542107820511,
-0.9957268834114075,
-0.22715672850608826,
-0.6672472953796387,
-0.4198925793170929,
-0.7719583511352539,
-0.46273311972618103,
0.39246314764022827,
0.17155370116233826,
-0.2117544561624527,
-0.16671155393123627,
-0.7202825546264648,
0.6016746759414673,
0.9003960490226746,
0.08374056965112686,
0.20920205116271973,
0.01660289615392685,
-0.05401544272899628,
-0.19046345353126526,
-0.5862024426460266,
-0.2532600164413452,
1.3378022909164429,
0.11229836195707321,
0.8534085750579834,
0.2771831154823303,
0.9389322400093079,
0.1185503676533699,
0.9403737783432007,
-0.5830029249191284,
0.25708773732185364,
-0.06947504729032516,
-0.6389341950416565,
-0.334334135055542,
-0.43379437923431396,
-0.9743446707725525,
0.4441797733306885,
-0.22427479922771454,
-0.3434138894081116,
-0.02132466807961464,
0.2943321764469147,
-0.34468913078308105,
0.12514163553714752,
-0.5446404814720154,
0.5114762187004089,
0.08473916351795197,
-0.5962762236595154,
-0.12187696248292923,
-0.34602317214012146,
0.2471972107887268,
0.21387846767902374,
-0.03685392439365387,
0.0221781674772501,
-0.09655346721410751,
0.7025370001792908,
-0.7331234216690063,
0.8250740766525269,
-0.3979063928127289,
0.11017709970474243,
0.21243785321712494,
-0.12005547434091568,
0.47275564074516296,
0.41200706362724304,
-0.23226159811019897,
-0.7065852880477905,
-0.1730756163597107,
-0.31351417303085327,
-0.8785600066184998,
0.701583206653595,
-0.4850628972053528,
-0.8396114706993103,
-0.2559979557991028,
-0.3890240490436554,
-0.5682684779167175,
-0.02935715951025486,
0.07305633276700974,
0.3244801163673401,
0.13618740439414978,
0.35642391443252563,
0.6245050430297852,
-0.05905265361070633,
-0.1624419391155243,
0.7399119734764099,
-0.6991235613822937,
-0.7353971600532532,
0.9252998232841492,
-0.05988014489412308,
0.0075820619240403175,
0.3890584409236908,
-0.08345457911491394,
-0.3367035686969757,
-0.5182453393936157,
-0.3754342794418335,
0.4645758271217346,
-0.5433838367462158,
-0.4156486690044403,
-0.44934508204460144,
-0.2887403666973114,
-0.5621560215950012,
-0.08394094556570053,
-0.27522480487823486,
-0.7158290147781372,
0.30332151055336,
-0.13514089584350586,
0.495575487613678,
0.9441030025482178,
0.11366124451160431,
0.1816132664680481,
-0.6883568167686462,
0.2171388417482376,
0.462306410074234,
0.6835286021232605,
0.2393423616886139,
-0.5757153034210205,
-0.3799503445625305,
-0.16537222266197205,
-0.35259878635406494,
-0.6050227284431458,
0.24786275625228882,
0.2828516662120819,
0.6710364818572998,
-0.104972705245018,
0.3130352199077606,
0.4254218637943268,
-0.533247172832489,
0.6819331049919128,
-0.5115426182746887,
-0.42604848742485046,
0.6605841517448425,
-0.26013731956481934,
0.12357152253389359,
0.8629887104034424,
0.5306657552719116,
-0.42471590638160706,
-0.6670231223106384,
-0.41463884711265564,
-0.8869777321815491,
0.5820725560188293,
0.07556561380624771,
-0.10314133018255234,
-0.08958318829536438,
0.7359958291053772,
-0.05263936147093773,
0.47215837240219116,
-0.5178151726722717,
-0.020530283451080322,
0.028764909133315086,
0.07711787521839142,
0.06591906398534775,
-0.5956394076347351,
-0.0434098057448864,
-0.32986071705818176,
0.9338592886924744,
-0.03078046813607216,
0.15048770606517792,
0.22793127596378326,
-0.14141342043876648,
-0.18521031737327576,
0.21326890587806702,
0.38191652297973633,
0.46679261326789856,
-0.4418874979019165,
-0.269924521446228,
0.0689810961484909,
-0.16759143769741058,
0.06128322333097458,
-0.10530120134353638,
-0.27382153272628784,
0.08555537462234497,
0.1890716701745987,
0.47369495034217834,
0.5130809545516968,
-0.21605753898620605,
0.40338054299354553,
-0.3263266980648041,
-0.29116585850715637,
-0.1736305207014084,
0.29411208629608154,
0.1861308366060257,
0.2416275143623352,
0.15959198772907257,
-0.3131820857524872,
0.18568868935108185,
-0.06443411111831665,
0.34910064935684204,
0.3314156234264374,
-0.6189282536506653,
0.0225419532507658,
0.9302787780761719,
0.44050270318984985,
-0.305229514837265,
0.6609264016151428,
-0.2988337278366089,
-0.48410600423812866,
0.17603667080402374,
0.4340485632419586,
0.7121431231498718,
-0.25216418504714966,
0.35655996203422546,
0.4629892110824585,
0.2418576180934906,
0.02113637700676918,
0.1110059842467308,
-0.23083336651325226,
-0.11056193709373474,
-0.5310314297676086,
-0.9707151055335999,
-0.8127071261405945,
-0.16357259452342987,
-0.7777028679847717,
0.06620485335588455,
-0.5823523998260498,
-0.09826919436454773,
0.05784986913204193,
0.0936490073800087,
-0.33338361978530884,
0.32892775535583496,
-0.3340475261211395,
0.7860506772994995,
-0.25837406516075134,
0.6676318049430847,
0.962560772895813,
-0.9994631409645081,
-0.9298511147499084,
-0.004704730119556189,
-0.22871173918247223,
-0.574836254119873,
0.8196972608566284,
0.2749985158443451,
-0.3846885859966278,
0.09735564887523651,
-0.5591105818748474,
-0.8397504091262817,
0.9139418005943298,
0.3343469798564911,
-0.056366678327322006,
-0.13176585733890533,
-0.12510377168655396,
0.7142374515533447,
-0.4381811320781708,
0.4315165877342224,
0.18559299409389496,
0.18028777837753296,
0.09415572881698608,
-0.8425402641296387,
-0.13651292026042938,
-0.33732786774635315,
0.1376989632844925,
0.3317505419254303,
-0.5904936194419861,
0.502092182636261,
-0.12244387716054916,
0.11499984562397003,
0.268905371427536,
0.840351402759552,
0.14740151166915894,
0.42483440041542053,
0.35736340284347534,
0.7933162450790405,
0.7356671094894409,
0.0234628114849329,
1.378892421722412,
-0.003291636472567916,
0.2383081167936325,
1.4614746570587158,
-0.17313994467258453,
1.2085448503494263,
0.15152966976165771,
-0.0626167356967926,
0.6687174439430237,
0.47784993052482605,
0.2844478487968445,
0.5652663111686707,
0.7069938778877258,
-0.09557772427797318,
-0.3629000186920166,
-0.3267120122909546,
-0.3772365152835846,
0.4001212418079376,
0.09387005865573883,
-0.42891639471054077,
-0.3246798515319824,
-0.2035679668188095,
-0.055249910801649094,
0.3316940665245056,
-0.4442219138145447,
0.9376921057701111,
0.005464671645313501,
-1.0238473415374756,
0.7948603630065918,
0.08179551362991333,
0.6052924990653992,
-0.4649631977081299,
-0.23998183012008667,
-0.6170837879180908,
0.28772473335266113,
-0.3992786705493927,
-0.2590041160583496,
0.4090343415737152,
-0.022111017256975174,
-0.4616207778453827,
-0.1405937820672989,
0.4554908573627472,
-0.3545822203159332,
-0.2836286127567291,
0.11841079592704773,
0.28451424837112427,
0.24701979756355286,
-0.3835887908935547,
-0.45105358958244324,
-0.23010188341140747,
0.0857103168964386,
-0.36054137349128723,
0.4155717194080353,
0.4284394681453705,
-0.3332887887954712,
0.6710024476051331,
0.769209623336792,
-0.08158459514379501,
0.14608234167099,
0.418727308511734,
1.0098779201507568,
-0.6143426895141602,
-0.5101786851882935,
-0.026534628123044968,
0.3439244329929352,
-0.3437345623970032,
-0.18941305577754974,
0.8422475457191467,
0.4237413704395294,
0.955878496170044,
0.029392065480351448,
0.44384825229644775,
0.4997972846031189,
1.1880606412887573,
-0.3207184970378876,
0.9413056969642639,
-0.7981225848197937,
0.40576285123825073,
0.14225035905838013,
-1.08528470993042,
-0.35496407747268677,
0.2997203767299652,
-0.5960875749588013,
0.15466561913490295,
0.4827197194099426,
0.9538724422454834,
0.21032537519931793,
-0.025193754583597183,
0.17063239216804504,
-0.051572784781455994,
0.3720966577529907,
0.2652103006839752,
0.7755909562110901,
-0.172836571931839,
0.5394838452339172,
-0.053322382271289825,
-0.22474417090415955,
-0.44060027599334717,
-0.48267728090286255,
-0.8240551948547363,
-0.36017751693725586,
-0.2706603705883026,
-0.558673620223999,
0.47197842597961426,
0.7952651381492615,
0.6699122786521912,
-0.8224436640739441,
0.005396466236561537,
0.21363332867622375,
0.31346073746681213,
-0.09920952469110489,
-0.18789458274841309,
0.3498297333717346,
-1.0094341039657593,
-0.5787330269813538,
0.4202252924442291,
0.21163377165794373,
-0.5262377262115479,
-0.028138574212789536,
-0.11350730806589127,
-0.17934337258338928,
0.1572839617729187,
0.346970796585083,
0.23949667811393738,
-0.665596067905426,
-0.19672392308712006,
-0.04046659916639328,
-0.1168937236070633,
-0.12441986799240112,
0.9018147587776184,
-1.0686631202697754,
0.36995023488998413,
0.40479469299316406,
1.0238229036331177,
0.406154066324234,
0.3226974904537201,
0.6585074067115784,
-0.9436051845550537,
-0.11791396886110306,
0.32589486241340637,
0.007981664501130581,
0.3250773251056671,
-0.21835605800151825,
0.8519736528396606,
0.050093598663806915,
-0.9535227417945862,
-0.7609810829162598,
0.25964856147766113,
-0.5995121598243713,
-0.07318665087223053,
1.0328543186187744,
-0.18574413657188416,
-0.40805870294570923,
0.06526613235473633,
-0.3233214318752289,
0.042956214398145676,
-0.313848078250885,
0.7359936833381653,
0.20369018614292145,
-0.040859658271074295,
-0.003244098275899887,
-0.4234738349914551,
0.7902557849884033,
0.6162838339805603,
-0.6369035840034485,
0.03448694944381714,
0.6138860583305359,
0.30941474437713623,
-0.0662086084485054,
0.9250997304916382,
-0.12241913378238678,
0.478314071893692,
-0.1988099217414856,
-0.1996384561061859,
-0.3130228519439697,
-0.3298383951187134,
-0.2339240163564682,
0.3834778070449829,
0.6323099136352539,
-0.21196213364601135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14428v1
|
Mitigating Quantization Errors Due to Activation Spikes in GLU-Based LLMs
| 2024-05-23T10:54:14 | 2024-05-23T10:54:14 |
Jaewoo Yang, Hayun Kim, Younghoon Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Modern large language models (LLMs) have established state-of-the-art
performance through architectural improvements, but still require significant
computational cost for inference. In an effort to reduce the inference cost,
post-training quantization (PTQ) has become a popular approach, quantizing
weights and activations to lower precision, such as INT8. In this paper, we
reveal the challenges of activation quantization in GLU variants, which are
widely used in feed-forward network (FFN) of modern LLMs, such as LLaMA family.
The problem is that severe local quantization errors, caused by excessive
magnitudes of activation in GLU variants, significantly degrade the performance
of the quantized LLM. We denote these activations as activation spikes. Our
further observations provide a systematic pattern of activation spikes: 1) The
activation spikes occur in the FFN of specific layers, particularly in the
early and late layers, 2) The activation spikes are dedicated to a couple of
tokens, rather than being shared across a sequence. Based on our observations,
we propose two empirical methods, Quantization-free Module (QFeM) and
Quantization-free Prefix (QFeP), to isolate the activation spikes during
quantization. Our extensive experiments validate the effectiveness of the
proposed methods for the activation quantization, especially with
coarse-grained scheme, of latest LLMs with GLU variants, including LLaMA-2/3,
Mistral, Mixtral, SOLAR, and Gemma. In particular, our methods enhance the
current alleviation techniques (e.g., SmoothQuant) that fail to control the
activation spikes. Code is available at
https://github.com/onnoo/activation-spikes.
|
[
0.10924148559570312,
-0.7855529189109802,
0.2568702697753906,
0.5025362372398376,
-0.2752196192741394,
0.2142956554889679,
0.03465842828154564,
-0.3803502917289734,
0.15197902917861938,
0.2464730441570282,
-0.18846796452999115,
-0.3927467167377472,
-0.6489880084991455,
0.02577814646065235,
-0.3276117444038391,
0.5493276119232178,
-0.39267289638519287,
0.08121003210544586,
-0.308619886636734,
-0.2584879696369171,
0.024353312328457832,
-0.7115278244018555,
-1.0188705921173096,
-0.4873056411743164,
0.512937605381012,
-0.12320584058761597,
0.5351462364196777,
0.5633684396743774,
0.2688468396663666,
0.1924644410610199,
-0.47519397735595703,
0.12569813430309296,
-0.5143038034439087,
0.026881814002990723,
0.5583310723304749,
-0.6227715611457825,
-0.6812579035758972,
-0.32280927896499634,
0.875328004360199,
0.5931897759437561,
-0.08337919414043427,
0.0010050339624285698,
0.3047856390476227,
0.5743507146835327,
-0.9478259682655334,
0.010063624940812588,
-0.568848729133606,
0.2712828516960144,
-0.19288593530654907,
-0.46180686354637146,
-0.4154851734638214,
-0.2929447889328003,
-0.326312780380249,
-0.6179768443107605,
0.10805670917034149,
-0.2599020004272461,
0.7763298749923706,
0.35017913579940796,
-0.3715232014656067,
0.18716630339622498,
-0.7484000325202942,
0.7902771830558777,
-1.0037273168563843,
0.05726645514369011,
0.43330490589141846,
-0.04087015986442566,
-0.46476808190345764,
-0.6528226733207703,
-0.043550342321395874,
-0.21684451401233673,
-0.1590813547372818,
-0.02590673789381981,
-0.21421191096305847,
0.19244138896465302,
0.4964185059070587,
0.4294755160808563,
-0.3819392919540405,
0.28824007511138916,
0.013911874033510685,
-0.12755121290683746,
0.25460085272789,
0.19640538096427917,
0.016001058742403984,
0.1976768970489502,
-0.5847201943397522,
0.19767975807189941,
-1.3029396533966064,
0.4507386088371277,
0.6351413130760193,
-0.1227593719959259,
-0.12004150450229645,
0.37915855646133423,
-0.4450524151325226,
0.3617542088031769,
0.23322522640228271,
0.23668015003204346,
0.4523506462574005,
-0.36080992221832275,
-0.4450766146183014,
-0.021952319890260696,
0.9031074047088623,
-0.1101546511054039,
0.1853099912405014,
-0.17127421498298645,
-0.37389394640922546,
-0.10770945250988007,
-0.03918424993753433,
-0.9976515173912048,
-0.03380934149026871,
0.6487837433815002,
-0.15481199324131012,
-0.484598845243454,
-0.31855806708335876,
-0.3994099497795105,
-0.2869662642478943,
0.1506231129169464,
0.7806662917137146,
-0.30459877848625183,
-0.3626980185508728,
0.13649237155914307,
0.1346054971218109,
0.25775665044784546,
0.15701191127300262,
-1.1322205066680908,
0.15660427510738373,
0.4420866072177887,
0.7966384887695312,
0.02301063947379589,
-0.21399809420108795,
-0.6960410475730896,
0.15413959324359894,
-0.33497846126556396,
0.6488988995552063,
-0.24505123496055603,
-0.17981456220149994,
0.09460556507110596,
-0.08768552541732788,
-0.1319124549627304,
-0.6608476638793945,
0.3546697795391083,
-0.6185413002967834,
-0.24572281539440155,
-0.13075019419193268,
-0.46131011843681335,
-0.05220925062894821,
0.014120582491159439,
-0.8595067262649536,
1.176055669784546,
-0.020989345386624336,
-0.7750344276428223,
0.20058003067970276,
-0.45608240365982056,
-0.3018164038658142,
0.16610990464687347,
-0.09923931956291199,
-0.5754473209381104,
0.3738565742969513,
0.37849822640419006,
0.34739574790000916,
-0.060966067016124725,
0.2829053997993469,
-0.14070773124694824,
-0.7536965012550354,
0.18526096642017365,
-0.48589587211608887,
0.7793644070625305,
-0.2154262363910675,
-0.6958172917366028,
0.4264468550682068,
-0.8195335268974304,
0.1103372573852539,
0.23556943237781525,
-0.31017908453941345,
-0.1905294507741928,
0.22393208742141724,
-0.40129730105400085,
-0.08310157060623169,
-0.032817840576171875,
-0.033407967537641525,
0.24103522300720215,
-0.52480149269104,
0.5608482956886292,
0.6502891778945923,
0.2519642412662506,
0.48881298303604126,
-0.245253324508667,
0.6498283743858337,
0.5082796812057495,
0.2718436121940613,
-0.2904827892780304,
-0.6109957695007324,
-0.6228963732719421,
-0.37605273723602295,
0.31427326798439026,
0.4236229956150055,
-0.8082462549209595,
0.4363894760608673,
-0.24009403586387634,
-0.25069954991340637,
-0.49233075976371765,
0.25035861134529114,
0.305721253156662,
0.348795622587204,
0.2762887477874756,
-0.13674961030483246,
-0.11827021092176437,
-0.6103373169898987,
-0.13219811022281647,
0.18124084174633026,
-0.16087323427200317,
-0.07865161448717117,
0.2152988165616989,
-0.17016933858394623,
1.0373867750167847,
0.028916241601109505,
0.08033077418804169,
0.15319636464118958,
0.3576357662677765,
0.1494947373867035,
0.5804515480995178,
0.323813259601593,
-0.5962220430374146,
-0.18063488602638245,
-0.058384787291288376,
-0.35014215111732483,
-0.3542099893093109,
-0.25409233570098877,
-0.03737968951463699,
0.04153278097510338,
0.38285884261131287,
-0.5931981801986694,
0.5821528434753418,
0.45195186138153076,
0.020744070410728455,
0.7538947463035583,
0.014108625240623951,
0.1260255128145218,
-0.6278188228607178,
0.24117988348007202,
0.046105120331048965,
-0.3535325825214386,
-0.9371748566627502,
-0.08118780702352524,
0.2670760452747345,
0.2581235468387604,
-0.8380467891693115,
0.45544418692588806,
-0.26703178882598877,
-0.06676854938268661,
-0.19138066470623016,
-0.24695135653018951,
0.3014439344406128,
0.9448525905609131,
-0.3688945472240448,
0.924142599105835,
0.5014535188674927,
-0.4753818213939667,
0.2484818547964096,
-0.10435032099485397,
-0.3770458698272705,
-0.047472771257162094,
-0.772377610206604,
-0.007312967907637358,
-0.13799194991588593,
0.29499489068984985,
-0.8696956634521484,
0.08566851913928986,
0.6510872840881348,
-0.1367538720369339,
0.2495797723531723,
-0.3902115821838379,
-0.4910879135131836,
0.04055212065577507,
-0.8151034116744995,
0.8750348091125488,
0.3237464725971222,
-0.4989522695541382,
0.3285403847694397,
-0.13248904049396515,
0.22330474853515625,
-0.828654408454895,
-0.356057733297348,
-0.13886357843875885,
-0.5337302088737488,
-0.6092276573181152,
0.3120936155319214,
-0.0693606361746788,
-0.05749983713030815,
-0.11874262988567352,
-0.20622001588344574,
0.21215038001537323,
0.5101401805877686,
0.29020974040031433,
-0.045845359563827515,
-0.3585526943206787,
-0.0007786899222992361,
0.20533229410648346,
-0.18581785261631012,
0.1204264834523201,
-0.28194960951805115,
0.7093079686164856,
-0.05289345234632492,
-0.3339889645576477,
-0.2984797954559326,
0.33709588646888733,
0.4647350609302521,
-0.3532838523387909,
0.640800416469574,
0.8128036856651306,
-0.47867724299430847,
-0.13902580738067627,
-0.24613933265209198,
-0.10390560328960419,
-0.4961104094982147,
0.2038336843252182,
-0.22525839507579803,
-1.012869954109192,
0.8073707222938538,
-0.34239518642425537,
-0.17507386207580566,
0.19473187625408173,
0.7152760624885559,
0.02129155397415161,
0.9289969205856323,
0.1024952083826065,
0.048958081752061844,
0.5800957083702087,
-0.4799763560295105,
0.23027484118938446,
-1.1753454208374023,
0.12922179698944092,
-0.19588766992092133,
-0.46857622265815735,
-0.1970985382795334,
-0.49603983759880066,
0.3641960620880127,
0.6167701482772827,
-0.0977165549993515,
0.10019851475954056,
-0.1025160476565361,
0.43035247921943665,
0.3992929458618164,
-0.04400942847132683,
0.2234584242105484,
0.4529768228530884,
-0.12243333458900452,
0.25878626108169556,
-0.6486846804618835,
-0.18380112946033478,
1.0568327903747559,
0.4358573257923126,
0.6812755465507507,
-0.13436606526374817,
0.5497824549674988,
0.31961122155189514,
0.1959831863641739,
-0.885281503200531,
0.3396749198436737,
0.08268923312425613,
-0.09647367149591446,
-0.17813260853290558,
-0.6354448199272156,
-1.105840802192688,
0.34645071625709534,
-0.19379755854606628,
-0.9176673889160156,
0.37188634276390076,
0.35928094387054443,
-0.5741234421730042,
0.29890531301498413,
-0.6195558905601501,
0.8654894828796387,
-0.1238899827003479,
-0.505788266658783,
-0.0659935474395752,
-0.38639312982559204,
0.3695223033428192,
-0.17480456829071045,
0.03678584471344948,
-0.17721232771873474,
-0.08952872455120087,
0.5438313484191895,
-0.3474012017250061,
1.007731318473816,
-0.03228989988565445,
-0.5406873226165771,
0.4283168315887451,
-0.1576375812292099,
1.0417938232421875,
-0.018385836854577065,
0.07961132377386093,
0.3722095191478729,
-0.33055543899536133,
-0.5436035990715027,
-0.5797353982925415,
0.6120911836624146,
-0.7416061758995056,
-0.573259174823761,
0.029843976721167564,
-0.28329533338546753,
-0.31052467226982117,
-0.2585199177265167,
0.4920537769794464,
0.723147451877594,
0.26454609632492065,
0.03804294392466545,
0.41662800312042236,
-0.038864195346832275,
0.5324147343635559,
0.013429864309728146,
-0.23786745965480804,
-0.675063967704773,
0.9238480925559998,
0.1386924684047699,
0.6274537444114685,
0.24002207815647125,
0.1599041074514389,
-0.06335455179214478,
-0.9202156066894531,
-0.3675449788570404,
0.2015150636434555,
-0.6539067029953003,
-0.3206038773059845,
-0.49172553420066833,
-0.24355705082416534,
-0.3424823582172394,
0.11488017439842224,
-0.04175673797726631,
-0.4500598907470703,
-0.5566836595535278,
-0.17996595799922943,
0.2968367636203766,
0.14569684863090515,
0.18136903643608093,
0.7912296652793884,
-0.7930126786231995,
0.21312996745109558,
0.17292174696922302,
0.27557435631752014,
0.17674115300178528,
-0.4646323323249817,
-0.6559656858444214,
0.08819253742694855,
-0.3780238926410675,
-0.9300386309623718,
0.21713955700397491,
0.2925599217414856,
0.3289461135864258,
0.5860828161239624,
-0.20575816929340363,
0.6400201916694641,
-0.4094036817550659,
0.7284830212593079,
0.12769155204296112,
-0.9522882699966431,
0.34701433777809143,
-0.36378213763237,
0.1689106971025467,
0.05377691611647606,
0.4698732793331146,
-0.3154737949371338,
-0.5408329963684082,
-0.48805636167526245,
-1.343252420425415,
0.3802461624145508,
0.23500120639801025,
0.14761778712272644,
0.015759669244289398,
0.5212735533714294,
-0.001944380928762257,
0.42838507890701294,
-0.9127722978591919,
-0.34349024295806885,
0.08117503672838211,
0.10710787028074265,
0.31926360726356506,
-0.5414705276489258,
-0.12406332790851593,
-0.09030692279338837,
0.5592763423919678,
-0.363162100315094,
0.2102731317281723,
0.1616562157869339,
-0.129160538315773,
-0.5806036591529846,
0.18356341123580933,
0.6715739369392395,
0.6505499482154846,
-0.11492268741130829,
0.047401636838912964,
0.12373781949281693,
-0.46244391798973083,
0.35338807106018066,
-0.218595489859581,
-0.4255582392215729,
-0.13012021780014038,
0.21912246942520142,
1.1401256322860718,
0.3857525587081909,
-0.32454851269721985,
0.4107823669910431,
0.20403696596622467,
-0.10269026458263397,
-0.19259275496006012,
0.18089787662029266,
-0.05808747559785843,
0.2908370792865753,
0.6085003614425659,
-0.12543323636054993,
-0.08729803562164307,
-0.06061773747205734,
-0.06586624681949615,
0.5982022881507874,
-0.09086523950099945,
-0.48317158222198486,
0.6081042289733887,
0.21025259792804718,
-0.11037526279687881,
0.18243348598480225,
-0.3950617015361786,
-0.4226500988006592,
0.6951332688331604,
0.6632912158966064,
1.1520289182662964,
-0.14319705963134766,
0.24233190715312958,
0.19449482858181,
0.20843973755836487,
-0.06269607692956924,
0.11872155964374542,
-0.091619573533535,
-0.8032961487770081,
-1.0943559408187866,
-0.7050495743751526,
-0.20201849937438965,
0.39588671922683716,
-0.39427241683006287,
0.2626281678676605,
-0.5707348585128784,
-0.38848263025283813,
-0.36653369665145874,
-0.12507255375385284,
-0.24035999178886414,
-0.09640565514564514,
0.3266303837299347,
0.6690914630889893,
-0.9203399419784546,
1.045535922050476,
0.5465137362480164,
0.08600138127803802,
-0.5974962115287781,
-0.0002359253994654864,
-0.2940272390842438,
-0.72030109167099,
0.581514835357666,
0.08382757753133774,
0.05139826983213425,
0.35365304350852966,
-0.38902029395103455,
-0.8376821279525757,
1.149074912071228,
0.3169580101966858,
-0.5140302181243896,
-0.045608360320329666,
0.3998551368713379,
0.26105108857154846,
-0.09462416172027588,
0.4263227880001068,
0.631052553653717,
0.33338987827301025,
0.15836969017982483,
-0.4636487662792206,
0.11256474256515503,
-0.15756632387638092,
0.03532325476408005,
0.5092763304710388,
-0.5022709965705872,
0.7767902612686157,
0.10794857889413834,
-0.33807963132858276,
0.16301102936267853,
0.5238522887229919,
0.19774776697158813,
0.040879398584365845,
0.40260571241378784,
0.7446072101593018,
0.5778793096542358,
-0.10594500601291656,
0.7865900993347168,
-0.24881917238235474,
0.46154364943504333,
0.7417146563529968,
-0.26885786652565,
0.7564418911933899,
0.7810632586479187,
-0.3277909457683563,
0.1175946593284607,
0.5639440417289734,
-0.12944884598255157,
0.330571711063385,
0.5359604954719543,
-0.6642245054244995,
-0.18894700706005096,
0.034124162048101425,
-0.3411474823951721,
-0.027200423181056976,
0.5297890305519104,
0.04386899992823601,
-0.20601774752140045,
-0.0497330017387867,
0.140370711684227,
-0.5687307715415955,
-0.4722227156162262,
0.4768950939178467,
0.16944873332977295,
-0.1209486797451973,
0.9563789367675781,
-0.14056891202926636,
0.7656142711639404,
-0.72797691822052,
0.19267645478248596,
-0.5927321910858154,
-0.09838950634002686,
-0.3640826344490051,
-0.14853237569332123,
0.16169074177742004,
-0.15984000265598297,
-0.004428924061357975,
-0.06426350772380829,
0.6107678413391113,
-0.37937480211257935,
-0.277322381734848,
0.35567620396614075,
0.2700015902519226,
-0.12298882007598877,
-0.35154277086257935,
-0.3020002543926239,
0.2653084099292755,
-0.11746849864721298,
-0.6288185715675354,
0.6248526573181152,
0.2929879128932953,
-0.24344442784786224,
0.43211036920547485,
0.7339907288551331,
0.30841735005378723,
0.514921247959137,
0.11189842969179153,
0.8722413778305054,
-0.5143289566040039,
-0.288640558719635,
-0.8987339735031128,
0.6919808387756348,
0.2607612609863281,
-0.1350758969783783,
0.37693318724632263,
0.3353039622306824,
0.48247283697128296,
-0.035740651190280914,
0.33371394872665405,
0.38366422057151794,
-0.3725507855415344,
-0.8295435309410095,
0.6369903087615967,
-0.6705644726753235,
0.44639986753463745,
0.1285078376531601,
-1.0350643396377563,
-0.416519433259964,
0.18533915281295776,
-0.18541213870048523,
-0.15057192742824554,
0.5803050398826599,
0.8095724582672119,
0.21680761873722076,
-0.26328161358833313,
0.4395180344581604,
0.3100379705429077,
0.4567319452762604,
0.7662010192871094,
0.9511831402778625,
-0.6260214447975159,
0.5261566042900085,
-0.2132992297410965,
-0.245562344789505,
-0.45385733246803284,
-0.9436830282211304,
-0.5079819560050964,
-0.2251303791999817,
-0.6519875526428223,
-0.2864280641078949,
-0.002776622772216797,
0.8121991753578186,
0.3958265483379364,
-0.8415406942367554,
-0.14098821580410004,
0.012139162048697472,
0.14027433097362518,
-0.42148828506469727,
-0.18563014268875122,
0.45434629917144775,
-0.7312334179878235,
-0.7066242694854736,
0.4836013615131378,
0.4592575132846832,
0.2971056401729584,
-0.08426212519407272,
-0.043420638889074326,
0.036870382726192474,
-0.036134470254182816,
0.5077188611030579,
0.3903031349182129,
-0.6189541816711426,
-0.23162323236465454,
-0.15745563805103302,
-0.1957588940858841,
0.4925573170185089,
1.0238701105117798,
-0.9685409069061279,
-0.04266054555773735,
0.44488397240638733,
0.6762193441390991,
0.3130861222743988,
0.09470482170581818,
0.33136722445487976,
-1.1014312505722046,
0.2991061508655548,
0.16313287615776062,
0.5251208543777466,
0.13996243476867676,
-0.34332555532455444,
0.3179871141910553,
0.44958019256591797,
-0.548652708530426,
-0.8612403273582458,
0.16515496373176575,
-0.9474542140960693,
0.1743793487548828,
1.2413989305496216,
-0.29821473360061646,
-0.4831456243991852,
0.1196727603673935,
0.10262278467416763,
0.1131579726934433,
-0.11194168776273727,
0.6698781251907349,
0.5751065611839294,
0.04471307620406151,
-0.07575348764657974,
-0.5899397730827332,
0.7815580368041992,
0.7135916352272034,
-0.7159587740898132,
0.19352640211582184,
0.22140328586101532,
0.026485029608011246,
0.10067211836576462,
0.5156953930854797,
-0.14734159409999847,
0.31151115894317627,
-0.2288513034582138,
0.096520334482193,
-0.03921392932534218,
-0.1602734625339508,
-0.8081043362617493,
0.23220959305763245,
0.08357884734869003,
-0.3719044327735901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14394v1
|
Instruction Tuning With Loss Over Instructions
| 2024-05-23T10:12:03 | 2024-05-23T10:12:03 |
Zhengyan Shi, Adam X. Yang, Bin Wu, Laurence Aitchison, Emine Yilmaz, Aldo Lipani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction tuning plays a crucial role in shaping the outputs of language
models (LMs) to desired styles. In this work, we propose a simple yet effective
method, Instruction Modelling (IM), which trains LMs by applying a loss
function to the instruction and prompt part rather than solely to the output
part. Through experiments across 21 diverse benchmarks, we show that, in many
scenarios, IM can effectively improve the LM performance on both NLP tasks
(e.g., MMLU, TruthfulQA, and HumanEval) and open-ended generation benchmarks
(e.g., MT-Bench and AlpacaEval). Remarkably, in the most advantageous case, IM
boosts model performance on AlpacaEval 1.0 by over 100%. We identify two key
factors influencing the effectiveness of IM: (1) The ratio between instruction
length and output length in the training data; and (2) The number of training
examples. We observe that IM is especially beneficial when trained on datasets
with lengthy instructions paired with brief outputs, or under the Superficial
Alignment Hypothesis (SAH) where a small amount of training examples are used
for instruction tuning. Further analysis substantiates our hypothesis that the
improvement can be attributed to reduced overfitting to instruction tuning
datasets. Our work provides practical guidance for instruction tuning LMs,
especially in low-resource scenarios.
|
[
-0.3048660457134247,
-0.6495834589004517,
0.299535870552063,
-0.006972876377403736,
-0.2484486997127533,
-0.2868049442768097,
-0.5452909469604492,
-0.01763865351676941,
-0.2086929976940155,
0.6122307777404785,
-0.864431619644165,
-0.5001789331436157,
-0.611652672290802,
-0.2791755795478821,
-0.4506227672100067,
0.9111468195915222,
-0.026618316769599915,
0.2843520939350128,
-0.2015170007944107,
-0.13334369659423828,
-0.595452070236206,
-0.2735685706138611,
-0.8761047720909119,
-0.4945802092552185,
0.49211981892585754,
0.5760770440101624,
0.5919836163520813,
1.172624111175537,
0.1512022167444229,
0.18642041087150574,
0.022999271750450134,
0.46450838446617126,
-0.6629194021224976,
-0.08748191595077515,
0.08427809178829193,
-0.6641438603401184,
-0.08318337053060532,
0.10650365799665451,
0.6291323900222778,
0.7307408452033997,
-0.5656024813652039,
0.19201146066188812,
0.2738214433193207,
0.8861680626869202,
-0.7913492321968079,
0.21160902082920074,
-0.7180813550949097,
0.026151370257139206,
-0.19151324033737183,
-0.6438765525817871,
-0.7752307057380676,
-0.3282427191734314,
-0.15116098523139954,
-0.34600546956062317,
0.2624267339706421,
0.14071005582809448,
0.7671974897384644,
0.5791229605674744,
-0.2068263292312622,
-0.39303091168403625,
-0.7649521827697754,
0.9394822716712952,
-1.080074429512024,
0.51360023021698,
0.4226251542568207,
0.19469965994358063,
-0.11679910868406296,
-0.15721657872200012,
-0.22700612246990204,
-0.19269904494285583,
-0.14924980700016022,
0.09056318551301956,
0.019399622455239296,
0.20060674846172333,
0.3896580636501312,
0.3335776627063751,
-0.33406755328178406,
0.4479243755340576,
-0.4142773151397705,
-0.008034531958401203,
0.4280446767807007,
0.19105543196201324,
0.19553007185459137,
0.17786149680614471,
-0.08439308404922485,
-0.265659898519516,
-1.0459216833114624,
0.14963094890117645,
0.6915860176086426,
0.4911078214645386,
-0.08793118596076965,
0.5125927329063416,
-0.01909767836332321,
1.0465362071990967,
0.03037853166460991,
-0.3283567428588867,
-0.15983422100543976,
-0.09351396560668945,
0.014813331887125969,
0.2940663993358612,
0.462653785943985,
0.52244633436203,
0.3143666684627533,
-0.11770863831043243,
-0.3072658181190491,
-0.13879536092281342,
0.3646877110004425,
-1.0521942377090454,
-0.08530524373054504,
-0.3003958463668823,
-0.38052141666412354,
0.050315871834754944,
-0.14472106099128723,
-0.45348095893859863,
-0.2543991804122925,
-0.6077356934547424,
0.4483189582824707,
-0.7077244520187378,
0.1944345384836197,
0.3497444689273834,
0.03486121445894241,
0.4378123879432678,
0.09270060062408447,
-1.2761777639389038,
0.5174784660339355,
0.8084526658058167,
0.7980676293373108,
-0.020051250234246254,
-0.10066688060760498,
-0.8608441352844238,
0.009531818330287933,
-0.4830000400543213,
0.44954410195350647,
-0.5645296573638916,
-0.4077501595020294,
0.16322438418865204,
-0.11160961538553238,
-0.4916113317012787,
-0.360408216714859,
0.4914546012878418,
-0.3338879644870758,
0.44637271761894226,
-0.041972797363996506,
-0.9753397107124329,
-0.16424746811389923,
-0.11366419494152069,
-0.6241461038589478,
0.8822766542434692,
-0.005363590084016323,
-0.38485801219940186,
0.2182384431362152,
-0.6083216667175293,
-0.6530123353004456,
-0.35677018761634827,
0.009539212100207806,
-0.4185904860496521,
0.35722681879997253,
0.2297501266002655,
0.32551833987236023,
-0.3899560570716858,
-0.29189354181289673,
0.05750037729740143,
-0.7416346073150635,
0.14911620318889618,
-0.653301477432251,
0.4435279965400696,
-0.0939726009964943,
-0.46361976861953735,
-0.1139049232006073,
-0.8449537754058838,
0.37606313824653625,
-0.14673687517642975,
-0.4942944049835205,
-0.45377323031425476,
0.21543996036052704,
-0.43708503246307373,
-0.1382707953453064,
-0.1671716421842575,
-0.4952040910720825,
0.34682026505470276,
-0.781606137752533,
0.4738628566265106,
0.5776166915893555,
-0.06331666558980942,
0.5067344903945923,
-0.3196770250797272,
0.656147301197052,
-0.33922457695007324,
0.12883101403713226,
-0.41443926095962524,
-0.4138711392879486,
-1.0359305143356323,
-0.047947194427251816,
0.567653238773346,
0.5018989443778992,
-0.6632090210914612,
0.30028897523880005,
-0.03466150164604187,
-0.3494805693626404,
-1.1308338642120361,
0.14513082802295685,
0.702793538570404,
0.6200233697891235,
0.45842209458351135,
-0.2247520387172699,
-0.3437034487724304,
-0.8105660080909729,
-0.2381380945444107,
0.013195712119340897,
-0.09922369569540024,
0.35955601930618286,
-0.042136795818805695,
0.05041186511516571,
0.5695393085479736,
-0.5186337232589722,
-0.07652537524700165,
-0.19638679921627045,
0.3084721863269806,
0.27623382210731506,
0.4941538870334625,
0.4327751696109772,
-0.39239680767059326,
-0.37006428837776184,
-0.080415740609169,
-0.15654657781124115,
-0.281868040561676,
-0.27701520919799805,
-0.20147888362407684,
0.536615252494812,
0.5445281863212585,
-0.4589007794857025,
0.5528737902641296,
0.4766367971897125,
-0.04882095381617546,
0.3523114323616028,
-0.31737884879112244,
0.28848958015441895,
-0.8005722165107727,
-0.26370781660079956,
0.026545094326138496,
-0.07215756177902222,
-0.4269064962863922,
-0.017899127677083015,
0.282612144947052,
-0.06933411955833435,
-0.40374457836151123,
0.42926040291786194,
-0.45795121788978577,
0.0456746369600296,
-0.41532057523727417,
-0.11122068762779236,
0.17062580585479736,
0.7523133754730225,
-0.12466847151517868,
0.9304317235946655,
0.34024757146835327,
-0.6649451851844788,
0.02980990894138813,
-0.009923678822815418,
-0.6132679581642151,
0.1155472844839096,
-0.8188859224319458,
0.0828879103064537,
-0.23149427771568298,
-0.06227242574095726,
-0.7023735642433167,
0.08911173045635223,
0.3543858230113983,
-0.12897145748138428,
0.872179388999939,
-0.3150795102119446,
-0.35074880719184875,
-0.20324771106243134,
-0.32205575704574585,
-0.019515343010425568,
0.7226769328117371,
-0.5207721590995789,
0.4709206819534302,
-0.06969699263572693,
0.043682318180799484,
-0.6324588656425476,
-0.5774418115615845,
-0.31970444321632385,
-0.30813607573509216,
-0.3223540186882019,
0.628762423992157,
-0.1572881042957306,
0.12197289615869522,
-0.043963752686977386,
-0.25587937235832214,
0.1128155067563057,
0.1678665578365326,
0.2333739548921585,
0.0475783534348011,
-0.5156861543655396,
0.3493192195892334,
0.2842564582824707,
-0.08934672176837921,
0.002285407856106758,
-0.0930071696639061,
0.7226711511611938,
0.021091820672154427,
-0.530959963798523,
-0.5266748070716858,
0.43304768204689026,
0.31449222564697266,
-0.36183449625968933,
1.2014074325561523,
0.5701144933700562,
-0.12634681165218353,
-0.7548182606697083,
-0.40679797530174255,
-0.35438162088394165,
-0.4462151825428009,
0.50140380859375,
-0.15034858882427216,
-0.46173524856567383,
0.29966217279434204,
-0.01626734621822834,
0.2925577461719513,
0.1806730479001999,
0.33733922243118286,
-0.08513028174638748,
1.2726372480392456,
0.9536289572715759,
-0.01676173321902752,
0.7358437776565552,
-0.4415948987007141,
0.22477596998214722,
-0.8487415313720703,
-0.19415771961212158,
-0.6230829954147339,
-0.3447456359863281,
-0.46414241194725037,
-0.34056103229522705,
0.29833516478538513,
0.29660412669181824,
-0.1737271249294281,
0.3267607092857361,
-0.44022634625434875,
0.7502333521842957,
0.8900026082992554,
0.32361021637916565,
-0.08126000314950943,
-0.051281705498695374,
0.23783253133296967,
-0.1675463765859604,
-1.119795560836792,
-0.6105327010154724,
0.940926730632782,
0.2721472382545471,
1.1565202474594116,
-0.03894166648387909,
0.7472428679466248,
0.14330053329467773,
0.23495320975780487,
-0.9501883387565613,
0.3807685971260071,
-0.49529731273651123,
-0.15129804611206055,
-0.4382188022136688,
-0.5812507271766663,
-0.7133998274803162,
-0.10055944323539734,
-0.13663823902606964,
-0.4020690321922302,
-0.16154518723487854,
0.6076172590255737,
-0.37524935603141785,
0.23445844650268555,
-0.9853326678276062,
0.9686047434806824,
-0.34201687574386597,
-0.243573859333992,
-0.33242887258529663,
-0.48055794835090637,
0.24594999849796295,
0.1870812028646469,
-0.054651856422424316,
-0.019726388156414032,
-0.020521465688943863,
0.7168390154838562,
-0.6254710555076599,
0.9210554361343384,
-0.0777476578950882,
-0.15138857066631317,
0.21582229435443878,
-0.0621737502515316,
0.30820363759994507,
-0.26297077536582947,
-0.27624160051345825,
-0.09682738780975342,
-0.17380543053150177,
-0.28759896755218506,
-0.9775000810623169,
0.8317342400550842,
-0.7859652042388916,
-0.6940851211547852,
0.11144301295280457,
-0.5999628305435181,
-0.17677977681159973,
-0.017436562106013298,
0.36941903829574585,
0.9156871438026428,
0.07581041753292084,
0.3256131410598755,
0.9344357252120972,
-0.29286059737205505,
0.3896215260028839,
0.6566145420074463,
0.23607896268367767,
-0.00674064178019762,
0.8988296389579773,
0.3278099000453949,
0.4957803189754486,
0.5089994072914124,
0.3724803924560547,
-0.36093735694885254,
-0.37278351187705994,
-0.8828020691871643,
0.13324332237243652,
-0.8348797559738159,
-0.3364042639732361,
-0.24519680440425873,
-0.30839136242866516,
-0.10126958042383194,
0.0658903419971466,
-0.4758172333240509,
-0.5109432935714722,
-0.3042641878128052,
0.12685279548168182,
0.3931726813316345,
0.408719539642334,
0.26907479763031006,
0.8067073822021484,
-0.6597685217857361,
-0.06453192234039307,
0.17488993704319,
0.5559840202331543,
0.12533140182495117,
-0.8433046936988831,
-0.49605387449264526,
0.37576591968536377,
-0.36628711223602295,
-0.8644397854804993,
0.25251469016075134,
0.8215592503547668,
0.6001977324485779,
0.4731915593147278,
0.06714808195829391,
0.8421393632888794,
-0.9270954132080078,
0.4499042332172394,
-0.03618844598531723,
-0.935763418674469,
0.5240485668182373,
0.07500435411930084,
0.4538857936859131,
0.3823973834514618,
0.5171293020248413,
-0.4341091215610504,
-0.25395286083221436,
-0.2677080035209656,
-0.7593433260917664,
0.9821125268936157,
0.014384250156581402,
0.3910476863384247,
0.02712813951075077,
0.4412235617637634,
0.24711349606513977,
0.1618778109550476,
-0.527309238910675,
-0.38015517592430115,
-0.167691171169281,
-0.4626712501049042,
0.010692132636904716,
-0.28955206274986267,
-0.2347235232591629,
-0.08677184581756592,
1.2017608880996704,
-0.11855728924274445,
0.0881287157535553,
-0.32743507623672485,
-0.0015685436083003879,
-0.3807035982608795,
0.30233776569366455,
0.7573343515396118,
0.5940491557121277,
-0.1917594075202942,
0.026790471747517586,
0.025588877499103546,
0.042598482221364975,
-0.04256302863359451,
0.06796813011169434,
-0.3912498354911804,
0.09977457672357559,
0.5629205703735352,
1.2218174934387207,
0.5056543350219727,
-0.4936930537223816,
0.28653883934020996,
-0.13211019337177277,
0.09420861303806305,
0.1627054065465927,
0.5455197095870972,
0.10398904234170914,
-0.05913904309272766,
0.06666901707649231,
0.11757578700780869,
0.11603797227144241,
-0.5347700715065002,
0.06840045005083084,
0.37171655893325806,
-0.31389880180358887,
-0.03326692432165146,
0.596062421798706,
0.08072857558727264,
-0.5456554889678955,
0.6288068294525146,
-0.10525991767644882,
-0.3889150023460388,
0.6675429940223694,
0.7674005031585693,
0.6141499876976013,
-0.29235154390335083,
0.17007875442504883,
0.4149976968765259,
0.43177005648612976,
-0.1423487663269043,
-0.10083015263080597,
-0.17084357142448425,
-0.3541204035282135,
-0.663757860660553,
-0.7301574349403381,
-0.3784601092338562,
0.19565138220787048,
-0.9356200098991394,
0.34172412753105164,
-0.19210441410541534,
0.07333451509475708,
0.17005735635757446,
-0.16379861533641815,
-0.5183873772621155,
0.09900254011154175,
0.18461494147777557,
0.9523154497146606,
-0.8127727508544922,
0.6809946298599243,
0.3716545104980469,
-0.12654657661914825,
-0.8803271055221558,
-0.08006124198436737,
-0.21881313621997833,
-0.986649215221405,
0.2644248306751251,
0.3678099811077118,
-0.2546840310096741,
-0.02776295877993107,
-0.5155590176582336,
-0.7837697863578796,
0.7476367950439453,
0.6221831440925598,
-0.905221164226532,
-0.012023888528347015,
0.10965413600206375,
0.5160579085350037,
-0.4387366473674774,
0.12142327427864075,
0.5852990746498108,
0.11609585583209991,
0.11197676509618759,
-0.6037782430648804,
-0.22292406857013702,
-0.11519097536802292,
0.10388592630624771,
0.6132458448410034,
-0.508965253829956,
0.7224782705307007,
-0.2516215741634369,
-0.37872985005378723,
0.24138902127742767,
0.5902047753334045,
-0.07395630329847336,
0.2126760482788086,
0.4222322106361389,
0.5251787900924683,
0.4277585446834564,
-0.28079041838645935,
1.1707706451416016,
-0.5998741984367371,
0.09965778142213821,
1.2305303812026978,
0.07746405154466629,
0.6760704517364502,
0.33745846152305603,
0.11931440234184265,
0.3396322429180145,
0.5630775094032288,
0.1510801911354065,
0.7468441724777222,
0.4050021171569824,
0.026501407846808434,
-0.23875118792057037,
-0.12127292156219482,
-0.39757615327835083,
0.43335145711898804,
0.33962541818618774,
-0.3999132812023163,
-0.08589331060647964,
0.12265939265489578,
0.17154879868030548,
0.45315128564834595,
-0.5230481624603271,
0.6909130811691284,
-0.001293621608056128,
-0.7859062552452087,
0.9060158729553223,
0.27400699257850647,
0.4637385904788971,
-0.7907288670539856,
-0.3196620047092438,
-0.3365764617919922,
0.2649131119251251,
-0.0420774482190609,
-0.449012815952301,
0.23668622970581055,
-0.08754102140665054,
-0.3928629457950592,
-0.3532458543777466,
0.4004935622215271,
-0.9172720909118652,
-0.5836564898490906,
0.012568452395498753,
0.16784065961837769,
-0.012134959921240807,
0.305696576833725,
-0.6148593425750732,
0.18033085763454437,
0.015976520255208015,
-0.31180447340011597,
0.21053317189216614,
0.34633323550224304,
0.0510115772485733,
0.7854399681091309,
0.23991738259792328,
0.19393301010131836,
0.2160634845495224,
0.30169054865837097,
0.7787594795227051,
-0.44729718565940857,
-0.27705660462379456,
-0.9269874095916748,
0.32194089889526367,
-0.009889612905681133,
-0.45783117413520813,
0.7364429235458374,
0.4205143451690674,
0.9151812791824341,
-0.20005539059638977,
0.3317990005016327,
0.22350327670574188,
0.5804318189620972,
-1.1013622283935547,
0.5447298884391785,
-0.5522263050079346,
0.38325709104537964,
0.12241179496049881,
-0.8323788642883301,
0.05399487540125847,
0.4737170934677124,
-0.2366294264793396,
0.056141436100006104,
0.3498764932155609,
1.0052919387817383,
-0.12098782509565353,
-0.024691306054592133,
0.33736175298690796,
-0.015604632906615734,
0.09475976973772049,
0.5358110070228577,
0.7000362277030945,
-0.5721800327301025,
0.42171213030815125,
-0.6101576089859009,
-0.15483392775058746,
-0.17766351997852325,
-0.8086548447608948,
-1.0106923580169678,
-0.3320392966270447,
-0.35145118832588196,
0.004382550250738859,
0.3264254927635193,
0.9055755734443665,
0.9711663126945496,
-0.7665095329284668,
-0.2299197018146515,
0.15501172840595245,
0.08999910205602646,
-0.48388671875,
-0.17943793535232544,
0.41054773330688477,
-0.45430195331573486,
-0.7757666707038879,
0.632382869720459,
0.07436968386173248,
0.014481906779110432,
-0.06881028413772583,
-0.3088417649269104,
-0.08692281693220139,
0.3173607885837555,
0.5090376734733582,
0.22278694808483124,
-0.7042285203933716,
-0.2330625355243683,
0.04915574565529823,
-0.04266822710633278,
-0.1768629252910614,
0.8120198845863342,
-0.640198290348053,
0.4678242802619934,
0.09619054198265076,
0.7150270342826843,
0.4861687421798706,
0.07117543369531631,
0.7270770072937012,
-1.2314989566802979,
0.11953847855329514,
0.16882021725177765,
0.3871319890022278,
0.43715032935142517,
-0.2957431972026825,
0.5336225628852844,
-0.3552418649196625,
-0.53355473279953,
-0.8732187747955322,
0.16348086297512054,
-0.6201610565185547,
-0.16194744408130646,
0.9215533137321472,
-0.11881935596466064,
-0.30119165778160095,
0.6115023493766785,
-0.27727288007736206,
0.4465390145778656,
-0.3994789123535156,
0.9977841377258301,
0.6114827394485474,
-0.05805685743689537,
-0.3302868902683258,
-0.6007182002067566,
0.6468715667724609,
0.6472568511962891,
-0.5753341317176819,
0.13089124858379364,
0.48624879121780396,
-0.06301721185445786,
-0.021139929071068764,
0.06248884275555611,
0.24938535690307617,
0.39517199993133545,
-0.24232041835784912,
0.041985634714365005,
-0.3347405195236206,
-0.4580042064189911,
-0.24590586125850677,
-0.12282081693410873,
0.08887305110692978,
-0.4450371563434601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14391v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14391v2
|
Explainable Few-shot Knowledge Tracing
| 2024-05-23T10:07:21 | 2024-05-26T03:43:33 |
Haoxuan Li, Jifan Yu, Yuanxin Ouyang, Zhuang Liu, Wenge Rong, Juanzi Li, Zhang Xiong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Knowledge tracing (KT), aiming to mine students' mastery of knowledge by
their exercise records and predict their performance on future test questions,
is a critical task in educational assessment. While researchers achieved
tremendous success with the rapid development of deep learning techniques,
current knowledge tracing tasks fall into the cracks from real-world teaching
scenarios. Relying heavily on extensive student data and solely predicting
numerical performances differs from the settings where teachers assess
students' knowledge state from limited practices and provide explanatory
feedback. To fill this gap, we explore a new task formulation: Explainable
Few-shot Knowledge Tracing. By leveraging the powerful reasoning and generation
abilities of large language models (LLMs), we then propose a cognition-guided
framework that can track the student knowledge from a few student records while
providing natural language explanations. Experimental results from three widely
used datasets show that LLMs can perform comparable or superior to competitive
deep knowledge tracing methods. We also discuss potential directions and call
for future improvements in relevant topics.
|
[
-0.3478771150112152,
-0.8724172115325928,
0.8803783059120178,
-0.36181560158729553,
-0.03532244637608528,
0.24658305943012238,
-0.2177298665046692,
-0.2996333837509155,
-0.19271668791770935,
0.5926982760429382,
-0.7728520631790161,
-0.5454865097999573,
-0.4352348744869232,
-0.4003658592700958,
-0.5107985138893127,
0.9328322410583496,
-0.05678355321288109,
-0.049512363970279694,
-0.34852802753448486,
0.011505174450576305,
-0.7582096457481384,
-0.2382914423942566,
-0.5377354025840759,
-0.7293084263801575,
0.40804269909858704,
0.7682219743728638,
0.2409280687570572,
0.45379528403282166,
0.4288676679134369,
0.16783717274665833,
0.1839069128036499,
0.06928718835115433,
-0.6681000590324402,
-0.0010308952769264579,
-0.149051696062088,
-0.6933097243309021,
-0.3243425190448761,
-0.2410329133272171,
0.7218915224075317,
0.9169374704360962,
0.12425848096609116,
0.27246618270874023,
0.20409922301769257,
0.6524138450622559,
-0.5854587554931641,
0.18582035601139069,
-0.37155598402023315,
-0.04370925948023796,
-0.1774701476097107,
-0.17659993469715118,
-0.3781433701515198,
-0.42234864830970764,
0.48915597796440125,
-0.6980197429656982,
0.23979979753494263,
-0.19580841064453125,
0.5363287925720215,
0.11814463138580322,
-0.5223004817962646,
-0.22952167689800262,
-0.7967453002929688,
0.7298726439476013,
-0.4692635238170624,
0.1711793690919876,
0.623806893825531,
0.8451159596443176,
0.014699885621666908,
-0.7252744436264038,
-0.42217397689819336,
-0.01990405097603798,
-0.005312422290444374,
0.3175238072872162,
0.1368080973625183,
-0.10130777955055237,
0.35164177417755127,
0.16050246357917786,
-0.39536646008491516,
0.17772887647151947,
-0.39626842737197876,
-0.13559184968471527,
0.7083454728126526,
0.4350791573524475,
0.16895583271980286,
-0.06420518457889557,
-0.40850120782852173,
0.14929434657096863,
-0.7993679046630859,
0.16126307845115662,
0.10960592329502106,
0.46032029390335083,
-0.1845264583826065,
0.5494807362556458,
-0.24186348915100098,
0.9047099351882935,
-0.3240032494068146,
-0.3152145743370056,
-0.4088955819606781,
-0.174515500664711,
-0.10927262157201767,
0.1787458211183548,
0.5050777792930603,
0.30346086621284485,
0.3798544108867645,
-0.23753680288791656,
0.05843062698841095,
0.1985638439655304,
0.03975442424416542,
-1.0447803735733032,
-0.5202039480209351,
-0.17315571010112762,
-0.13629847764968872,
-0.07000285387039185,
-0.34735435247421265,
-1.007190227508545,
-0.6864275932312012,
-0.3451143503189087,
0.604555606842041,
-0.6320350170135498,
-0.24273167550563812,
0.0995834469795227,
0.033787716180086136,
0.23297789692878723,
0.588187038898468,
-0.858993411064148,
0.29270997643470764,
0.7690476775169373,
0.659702479839325,
-0.20173874497413635,
-0.20987766981124878,
-0.2536138892173767,
0.23886661231517792,
-0.36795464158058167,
0.7885718941688538,
-0.6190400719642639,
-0.011821724474430084,
-0.08467750251293182,
-0.3207125663757324,
-0.007020157761871815,
-0.2678861618041992,
0.10276325047016144,
-0.4172431230545044,
0.22145435214042664,
-0.5383965373039246,
-1.1198076009750366,
-0.5600341558456421,
0.47945353388786316,
-0.34830570220947266,
0.9992858171463013,
0.06632750481367111,
-0.6495000123977661,
0.4766525328159332,
-0.5307971239089966,
-0.14362864196300507,
0.2086896449327469,
-0.16983364522457123,
-0.06616160273551941,
-0.11153008788824081,
0.14225170016288757,
0.6323270797729492,
-0.3354872465133667,
0.12465708702802658,
-0.20971986651420593,
-0.5516924262046814,
0.10481631010770798,
-0.3334754705429077,
0.7619175314903259,
-0.07891903817653656,
-0.2559162378311157,
-0.40446707606315613,
-0.8930097222328186,
0.08562328666448593,
0.10132158547639847,
-0.34234818816185,
-0.3941328823566437,
-0.06294214725494385,
-0.6073001623153687,
0.03700103238224983,
-0.017838967964053154,
-0.3137093782424927,
0.3033832311630249,
-0.31085026264190674,
0.1772196888923645,
0.6946544647216797,
0.16761615872383118,
0.568484365940094,
-0.2344546914100647,
0.9639019966125488,
-0.1520499736070633,
-0.20030154287815094,
-0.5376922488212585,
-0.45018139481544495,
-0.5734037756919861,
-0.1386243849992752,
0.16025730967521667,
0.3287123143672943,
-0.5177405476570129,
-0.47046196460723877,
-0.36611998081207275,
-0.5453633069992065,
-0.5040097832679749,
0.4465641677379608,
0.33197715878486633,
0.897222638130188,
0.24542313814163208,
-0.04646695405244827,
-0.41818803548812866,
-0.5418432950973511,
-0.6261053681373596,
-0.15554969012737274,
0.05899633839726448,
0.4326050281524658,
0.57801753282547,
0.1965312957763672,
0.9958372116088867,
-0.61617511510849,
-0.3138335347175598,
-0.5008439421653748,
0.05334296077489853,
0.001691094134002924,
0.3903963267803192,
0.32186469435691833,
-0.341817170381546,
-0.3608608841896057,
0.011033175513148308,
-0.7625218629837036,
0.2061224728822708,
-0.30027535557746887,
-0.4447658360004425,
-0.23271401226520538,
0.4632825255393982,
-0.3943796455860138,
0.29379498958587646,
0.12657183408737183,
-0.45265212655067444,
0.4698122441768646,
0.17161519825458527,
-0.09848026931285858,
-0.697859525680542,
-0.10476214438676834,
-0.08562198281288147,
-0.18389731645584106,
-0.2991448938846588,
0.05251630023121834,
-0.1611408293247223,
-0.00023214987595565617,
-0.3724057078361511,
0.754169762134552,
-0.31334903836250305,
-0.16317610442638397,
-0.20497563481330872,
0.424223393201828,
0.04004594311118126,
0.37172362208366394,
-0.19541656970977783,
0.31668901443481445,
0.8546929955482483,
-0.6703418493270874,
0.37633195519447327,
0.031966038048267365,
-0.47049230337142944,
0.7044127583503723,
-0.21473801136016846,
0.19882655143737793,
-0.19206063449382782,
0.2604934871196747,
-1.2245349884033203,
-0.3148704469203949,
-0.3041731119155884,
-0.6887108087539673,
0.16589544713497162,
-0.6700977087020874,
-0.3080223798751831,
-0.4435195326805115,
-0.05371415615081787,
0.2585281431674957,
0.7154308557510376,
-0.5876702070236206,
0.7346864342689514,
0.004595709964632988,
0.1662629097700119,
-0.46444156765937805,
-0.6949923634529114,
-0.24655941128730774,
-0.462470144033432,
-0.6471086144447327,
0.015568366274237633,
-0.0044618938118219376,
-0.22810158133506775,
-0.004444541409611702,
-0.31817150115966797,
-0.48221349716186523,
0.40443357825279236,
0.3695570230484009,
0.3704666495323181,
-0.6126285195350647,
0.43276268243789673,
-0.2429462969303131,
-0.11860319972038269,
0.3393227458000183,
-0.3125593960285187,
0.2446671426296234,
0.029670225456357002,
-0.3063355088233948,
-0.3959232568740845,
0.07806260138750076,
0.4220491349697113,
0.06097692251205444,
0.5193018913269043,
0.6755609512329102,
-0.5096529722213745,
-0.5558817982673645,
-0.4913647472858429,
-0.4517749547958374,
-0.4018632173538208,
0.22018775343894958,
-0.4326546788215637,
-0.8001446723937988,
0.5179300308227539,
-0.31427156925201416,
0.14099766314029694,
0.3749944865703583,
0.4543974995613098,
-0.38346344232559204,
1.011467456817627,
0.7854161858558655,
0.018719607964158058,
0.17648416757583618,
-0.5259259343147278,
0.17720289528369904,
-0.5003044009208679,
-0.38666266202926636,
-0.29600828886032104,
-0.4195445477962494,
-0.38994836807250977,
-0.16089677810668945,
0.1630917191505432,
0.3283191919326782,
-0.21657754480838776,
0.04708538576960564,
-0.3250902593135834,
0.8953306674957275,
0.6314021348953247,
0.05266977846622467,
0.31693586707115173,
-0.1660861223936081,
-0.20617002248764038,
-0.04557240754365921,
-0.8774003386497498,
-0.5414184331893921,
1.3236488103866577,
0.20717738568782806,
0.8633701205253601,
-0.054588768631219864,
0.9217403531074524,
-0.16647610068321228,
0.3923507332801819,
-1.0673165321350098,
0.572716474533081,
-0.05766355246305466,
-1.0087162256240845,
-0.3667431175708771,
-0.19824591279029846,
-0.6562620401382446,
0.22783732414245605,
-0.1440858393907547,
-0.7700391411781311,
-0.5249292850494385,
0.4555164575576782,
-0.6719775199890137,
0.3634868860244751,
-0.8585672974586487,
0.8472141027450562,
-0.20920003950595856,
-0.7263628840446472,
-0.16661323606967926,
-0.4559725522994995,
0.7555536031723022,
0.027799751609563828,
0.20431259274482727,
-0.12867328524589539,
0.21403108537197113,
1.081932783126831,
-0.441677987575531,
1.084267497062683,
-0.4717024564743042,
0.17280049622058868,
0.704538881778717,
0.3515341281890869,
0.48354634642601013,
-0.18279388546943665,
0.008968007750809193,
-0.45551538467407227,
0.1072096899151802,
-0.4524594247341156,
-0.7153406143188477,
0.7527561187744141,
-0.3088335394859314,
-0.5119141936302185,
-0.05363278463482857,
-0.5702111721038818,
-0.39699801802635193,
0.15593811869621277,
0.20757727324962616,
0.3090254068374634,
-0.0389341339468956,
0.03609760105609894,
0.7299990653991699,
-0.011234222911298275,
0.4773596525192261,
0.692516028881073,
-0.15807273983955383,
0.2226337045431137,
1.1198588609695435,
0.5011304020881653,
0.10655108094215393,
0.2107267677783966,
0.5338022112846375,
-0.3238459527492523,
-0.5097262859344482,
-0.37974852323532104,
0.24100519716739655,
-0.919559895992279,
-0.1626499891281128,
-0.40146368741989136,
0.17497794330120087,
-0.2460712492465973,
-0.5629495978355408,
-0.43039366602897644,
-0.43465396761894226,
-0.21601901948451996,
-0.3441261649131775,
0.3695363402366638,
0.8580123782157898,
0.1547621339559555,
0.5617190003395081,
-0.4199346601963043,
0.523819088935852,
0.8189600706100464,
0.3469042479991913,
0.280254989862442,
-0.5942678451538086,
-0.29005926847457886,
-0.05934286117553711,
-0.3198082745075226,
-0.8686625957489014,
0.13171160221099854,
0.07064312696456909,
0.41945400834083557,
0.3958427906036377,
0.04231875389814377,
0.951079785823822,
-0.15364840626716614,
0.9113829135894775,
0.20940819382667542,
-0.8326774835586548,
0.7280611395835876,
-0.29104194045066833,
0.401879221200943,
0.5140392780303955,
0.2705432176589966,
-0.1962861269712448,
-0.3558214008808136,
-0.7130604386329651,
-0.759567379951477,
0.749346137046814,
-0.20593179762363434,
0.006995094940066338,
0.21702562272548676,
0.3248152732849121,
0.26107969880104065,
-0.2745495140552521,
-0.4052988588809967,
-0.03768298774957657,
-0.12275427579879761,
-0.1956416517496109,
-0.05342255160212517,
-0.3132511079311371,
-0.20602525770664215,
-0.23715339601039886,
0.6024813652038574,
-0.37615665793418884,
0.10782719403505325,
-0.0389309823513031,
-0.3787519931793213,
0.06351258605718613,
0.32645493745803833,
0.48592013120651245,
0.9639772772789001,
-0.029314963147044182,
0.4447307884693146,
0.41197648644447327,
-0.34825611114501953,
-0.08138337731361389,
-0.08987884223461151,
-0.19418321549892426,
-0.12391672283411026,
0.6342246532440186,
0.6159964203834534,
0.20104506611824036,
-0.6565382480621338,
0.6648339629173279,
0.31428462266921997,
-0.23153312504291534,
-0.44919025897979736,
0.1815759539604187,
0.45297491550445557,
0.3320181667804718,
0.44987818598747253,
-0.3005061149597168,
0.09804891049861908,
-0.4183832108974457,
0.14845718443393707,
0.3070068657398224,
-0.5657137632369995,
-0.5317205190658569,
0.542317807674408,
0.08413132280111313,
0.043976087123155594,
0.5910149812698364,
0.05873342603445053,
-0.5536107420921326,
0.8732447028160095,
0.5480597019195557,
0.595845639705658,
-0.0017176179680973291,
0.2733336389064789,
0.6021842360496521,
0.2954115867614746,
-0.3083387613296509,
0.23997880518436432,
-0.3507448434829712,
-0.3996463716030121,
-0.5935623645782471,
-0.3215760588645935,
-0.4547981917858124,
0.05219218507409096,
-0.8055922985076904,
0.20335406064987183,
-0.5323799848556519,
0.0705508217215538,
0.3528286814689636,
0.06656277179718018,
-1.0706520080566406,
0.47613805532455444,
0.39549189805984497,
0.661067008972168,
-1.0580430030822754,
0.7482326030731201,
0.5373682379722595,
-0.313273549079895,
-1.0223674774169922,
-0.25195783376693726,
0.22320081293582916,
-1.284742832183838,
0.826054036617279,
0.1106276586651802,
-0.06694591790437698,
0.029949422925710678,
-0.6106842756271362,
-0.45629701018333435,
1.1672111749649048,
0.5602626800537109,
-0.4307146370410919,
-0.13562273979187012,
0.020082244649529457,
0.48899826407432556,
-0.2061166614294052,
0.27284687757492065,
0.8795965313911438,
0.5139319896697998,
0.1147092804312706,
-0.42439618706703186,
0.005995815619826317,
0.30165839195251465,
-0.4641323387622833,
0.10544739663600922,
-0.4153422713279724,
0.4375259280204773,
-0.6859835386276245,
-0.06814900040626526,
-0.31121861934661865,
0.5298872590065002,
0.19607006013393402,
0.7648670673370361,
0.03154793754220009,
0.6344686150550842,
0.969526469707489,
-0.13756845891475677,
1.2196582555770874,
0.18235349655151367,
0.2478230744600296,
1.4353835582733154,
0.09915617853403091,
0.697913408279419,
0.49693334102630615,
-0.23321017622947693,
0.573975682258606,
0.4431915283203125,
0.10075569897890091,
0.27767714858055115,
0.3917171061038971,
-0.30501237511634827,
-0.7467738389968872,
-0.0629667192697525,
-0.11033036559820175,
0.7051118612289429,
0.3743029236793518,
-0.4068998098373413,
-0.3632195293903351,
0.07182320207357407,
0.024741867557168007,
-0.01214541681110859,
-0.536796510219574,
0.692357063293457,
0.03589453175663948,
-0.9104064702987671,
0.6686455607414246,
-0.518031656742096,
0.3992023169994354,
-0.5350500345230103,
-0.2989467680454254,
-0.45739927887916565,
0.20395489037036896,
-0.35281556844711304,
-0.8962215781211853,
-0.05812220275402069,
0.14411726593971252,
-0.06940293312072754,
-0.2340259552001953,
0.6784064769744873,
-0.4088742434978485,
-0.49007469415664673,
0.12191319465637207,
0.6181185841560364,
0.36150825023651123,
0.02782554365694523,
-0.4178740978240967,
-0.3055325746536255,
0.0623040646314621,
-0.2614983022212982,
0.3020698130130768,
0.5204301476478577,
-0.05665862560272217,
0.9987085461616516,
0.34384316205978394,
-0.07201672345399857,
0.4542572796344757,
-0.08257673680782318,
0.5089216828346252,
-0.7743768095970154,
-0.3404664397239685,
-0.9410285353660583,
0.5214357972145081,
0.2220817357301712,
-0.3605722188949585,
0.7653889060020447,
0.5629777908325195,
0.5667416453361511,
0.11360923945903778,
0.909171998500824,
0.21471033990383148,
0.7634584903717041,
-0.5368732213973999,
0.5757529735565186,
-0.3025709390640259,
0.321614146232605,
-0.22993819415569305,
-0.5118088722229004,
-0.17472192645072937,
0.4407770037651062,
-0.27477583289146423,
-0.1538219153881073,
0.7197981476783752,
0.45804473757743835,
-0.1304645538330078,
-0.025426657870411873,
0.34897714853286743,
0.3193546533584595,
0.3548779785633087,
0.932370126247406,
0.9440987706184387,
-0.32386502623558044,
0.8312612175941467,
-0.5201191902160645,
-0.07170470803976059,
-0.19354122877120972,
-0.8252804279327393,
-1.0200011730194092,
-0.34546542167663574,
-0.7163254022598267,
-0.1835177093744278,
-0.028920574113726616,
0.18472133576869965,
0.8233066201210022,
-0.5498051047325134,
-0.0862434059381485,
-0.19220836460590363,
0.3737533986568451,
-0.17721645534038544,
-0.2786608338356018,
0.5421709418296814,
-0.17545510828495026,
-0.4567417800426483,
0.5137383937835693,
-0.12555046379566193,
0.22911584377288818,
-0.2136239856481552,
-0.06889577209949493,
0.125383198261261,
-0.07964813709259033,
0.586171567440033,
0.48205453157424927,
-0.7658390402793884,
-0.30943071842193604,
0.09228752553462982,
0.08817543089389801,
-0.31928420066833496,
0.8985989689826965,
-1.1339915990829468,
0.7943995594978333,
0.5427016019821167,
0.725430428981781,
0.8298293352127075,
-0.1547899842262268,
0.3123632073402405,
-0.6070225238800049,
-0.23346154391765594,
0.38219815492630005,
0.07580927759408951,
0.3220502436161041,
-0.18326279520988464,
0.5922121405601501,
0.16032832860946655,
-0.33989134430885315,
-0.9428949952125549,
-0.030238119885325432,
-1.0352011919021606,
-0.22620083391666412,
0.97764652967453,
-0.47675907611846924,
0.05573538690805435,
-0.0809430330991745,
0.032808661460876465,
0.19246350228786469,
-0.07250964641571045,
0.6706470847129822,
0.9717614054679871,
-0.3216525912284851,
-0.21028666198253632,
-0.9917494058609009,
0.4604542553424835,
0.47530806064605713,
-0.7314826846122742,
0.1730795055627823,
0.6142627596855164,
0.5138938426971436,
-0.13390915095806122,
0.7175211310386658,
0.047559820115566254,
0.3261263966560364,
0.05465167388319969,
-0.31510674953460693,
-0.13064336776733398,
-0.3374743163585663,
-0.15024563670158386,
0.5187932848930359,
0.04271305724978447,
-0.32262319326400757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14388v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14388v1
|
Evaluation of the Programming Skills of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T10:04:36 | 2024-05-23T10:04:36 |
Luc Bryan Heitz, Joun Chamas, Christopher Scherb
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLM) has revolutionized the efficiency
and speed with which tasks are completed, marking a significant leap in
productivity through technological innovation. As these chatbots tackle
increasingly complex tasks, the challenge of assessing the quality of their
outputs has become paramount. This paper critically examines the output quality
of two leading LLMs, OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's Gemini AI, by comparing the
quality of programming code generated in both their free versions. Through the
lens of a real-world example coupled with a systematic dataset, we investigate
the code quality produced by these LLMs. Given their notable proficiency in
code generation, this aspect of chatbot capability presents a particularly
compelling area for analysis. Furthermore, the complexity of programming code
often escalates to levels where its verification becomes a formidable task,
underscoring the importance of our study. This research aims to shed light on
the efficacy and reliability of LLMs in generating high-quality programming
code, an endeavor that has significant implications for the field of software
development and beyond.
|
[
-0.10543882846832275,
-0.4789149761199951,
0.40957239270210266,
0.25111210346221924,
0.1503419429063797,
0.16686388850212097,
-0.3835617005825043,
-0.43662214279174805,
-0.1296890825033188,
0.5287796258926392,
-0.24715100228786469,
-0.6388683915138245,
-0.7850425839424133,
-0.07283996790647507,
-0.6814156174659729,
1.0674817562103271,
0.11757072061300278,
-0.09661359339952469,
-0.491942822933197,
0.1939098984003067,
-0.35451459884643555,
-0.5239216089248657,
-0.575657844543457,
-0.35401949286460876,
0.17526231706142426,
0.2759259045124054,
0.9885899424552917,
0.3354188799858093,
0.7952753901481628,
0.33264756202697754,
0.044313911348581314,
0.07064748555421829,
-0.9099244475364685,
0.07454543560743332,
0.11889831721782684,
-0.533191442489624,
-0.40685510635375977,
0.07829230278730392,
0.46479424834251404,
0.43238306045532227,
0.007645764388144016,
0.3736584782600403,
0.1863858848810196,
0.5908112525939941,
-0.23812486231327057,
0.4457817077636719,
-0.7545931935310364,
-0.2787155508995056,
0.011002819053828716,
-0.1018657311797142,
-0.40170714259147644,
-0.6666942834854126,
-0.3228756785392761,
-0.25545167922973633,
-0.11015976220369339,
-0.022452371194958687,
0.9571129679679871,
0.3601800799369812,
-0.2020435482263565,
-0.8018454313278198,
-0.913533091545105,
0.7453230619430542,
-0.928976833820343,
-0.002768418285995722,
0.09256153553724289,
0.359790176153183,
-0.44120141863822937,
-0.6261888742446899,
-0.6119011044502258,
-0.7505083680152893,
0.19225724041461945,
0.22224512696266174,
-0.06940997391939163,
-0.2637203633785248,
0.2373713105916977,
0.690282940864563,
-0.5721856951713562,
0.43665164709091187,
-0.5721156001091003,
-0.10879570990800858,
0.7213863134384155,
0.12387768924236298,
0.623027503490448,
-0.17217347025871277,
0.24266023933887482,
-0.09276948124170303,
-0.9324488639831543,
0.22221718728542328,
0.7786392569541931,
0.13061657547950745,
-0.14892949163913727,
0.9027709364891052,
-0.09826810657978058,
0.4299284517765045,
-0.524821937084198,
-0.45044317841529846,
0.011305819265544415,
-0.2994726300239563,
-0.2010193020105362,
-0.5086743235588074,
1.0079429149627686,
0.30275651812553406,
0.5752357840538025,
-0.1339271068572998,
-0.34693726897239685,
0.18097056448459625,
0.321527898311615,
-0.6927469968795776,
-0.18253210186958313,
0.48241615295410156,
-0.5790877342224121,
-0.24240757524967194,
0.1451902687549591,
-0.24966977536678314,
-0.31893059611320496,
-0.13042502105236053,
0.3626862168312073,
-0.28682926297187805,
-0.3851780891418457,
-0.02712181769311428,
0.009115492925047874,
0.2489367425441742,
0.13521531224250793,
-0.6562017202377319,
-0.13137398660182953,
1.2043510675430298,
0.7569933533668518,
-0.15772846341133118,
-0.2056068480014801,
-0.5401689410209656,
-0.39432111382484436,
-0.7238062620162964,
0.3361833691596985,
-0.41853517293930054,
-0.4097718894481659,
0.07165057212114334,
-0.5102335810661316,
0.26861757040023804,
-0.6823786497116089,
0.37220141291618347,
-0.4750099778175354,
0.07793513685464859,
0.27511337399482727,
-0.5590608716011047,
0.18940369784832,
0.2140437811613083,
-0.3004585802555084,
1.0166890621185303,
0.40342849493026733,
-0.45887836813926697,
0.3417019546031952,
-0.5296043753623962,
-0.13355016708374023,
0.18484283983707428,
-0.37233003973960876,
-0.3311593532562256,
0.17315949499607086,
-0.024832511320710182,
0.6291951537132263,
-0.4477686285972595,
0.28148025274276733,
-0.2782508134841919,
-0.5324040055274963,
0.7825198173522949,
-0.44203728437423706,
0.5034657716751099,
0.07692186534404755,
-0.07140009105205536,
0.22405417263507843,
-0.825466513633728,
0.2598065435886383,
0.21709294617176056,
-0.7388431429862976,
0.09823938459157944,
0.021059108898043633,
-0.32279688119888306,
0.4151057302951813,
0.20406119525432587,
-0.5172228813171387,
0.09098230302333832,
-0.5404448509216309,
0.5547116994857788,
0.6001293063163757,
-0.1865164041519165,
0.0899432897567749,
-0.1921447217464447,
0.5427623391151428,
-0.37820249795913696,
0.3518577516078949,
-0.2396131008863449,
-0.7347965836524963,
-0.8659728765487671,
-0.25376632809638977,
0.3841245472431183,
0.3769569396972656,
-0.6846501231193542,
0.42880764603614807,
-0.4491468369960785,
-0.8944907188415527,
-0.6826093792915344,
0.4427492916584015,
0.6423812508583069,
0.040012456476688385,
-0.08193974941968918,
-0.45255351066589355,
-0.11318863928318024,
-0.7325966954231262,
-0.15094950795173645,
-0.3326878249645233,
-0.45746397972106934,
0.47952911257743835,
0.5648200511932373,
-0.36425474286079407,
0.7463341355323792,
-0.25125938653945923,
0.14647634327411652,
-0.37331128120422363,
0.00743112713098526,
0.5905551314353943,
0.4947962462902069,
0.522729218006134,
-0.219868466258049,
-0.307056725025177,
0.010837881825864315,
-0.8620662093162537,
-0.13176396489143372,
-0.18423748016357422,
-0.2017737179994583,
0.19430674612522125,
0.3596218526363373,
-0.4472559094429016,
0.18609455227851868,
1.0559611320495605,
-0.18254564702510834,
0.8132653832435608,
-0.31806111335754395,
0.2996361553668976,
-0.7733510732650757,
0.2199598103761673,
-0.2535671591758728,
-0.04190611466765404,
-0.42568597197532654,
0.2531307339668274,
0.030222387984395027,
-0.3556739389896393,
-0.3384110927581787,
0.28152990341186523,
-0.3807101547718048,
-0.5947059988975525,
-0.20958101749420166,
0.2775748670101166,
-0.37945467233657837,
0.3576290011405945,
-0.30218586325645447,
0.9870352149009705,
0.40677541494369507,
-0.46691733598709106,
0.5757098197937012,
0.02948344312608242,
-0.8448524475097656,
0.17944848537445068,
-0.9276953935623169,
0.2955887019634247,
0.05783385410904884,
-0.07388486713171005,
-1.3456891775131226,
-0.39369359612464905,
-0.001458329032175243,
-0.9320248961448669,
0.1309574991464615,
-0.24913491308689117,
-0.7144970893859863,
-0.7467572093009949,
-0.08742410689592361,
-0.10938750952482224,
1.0021231174468994,
-0.35213834047317505,
0.0711410865187645,
0.12766310572624207,
-0.15924568474292755,
-0.5839236974716187,
-0.6021804809570312,
0.11049500852823257,
0.22136296331882477,
-0.7945348024368286,
-0.1683560311794281,
0.10198897868394852,
-0.35118958353996277,
-0.12734869122505188,
-0.14166496694087982,
0.15417997539043427,
0.3289392590522766,
0.5999045968055725,
0.47133612632751465,
-0.3551727831363678,
-0.21908800303936005,
-0.17454585433006287,
-0.3523588180541992,
0.1815466582775116,
-0.13369308412075043,
0.7485596537590027,
-0.009025792591273785,
-0.8576441407203674,
-0.39544764161109924,
-0.04236329346895218,
0.7875986099243164,
-0.2776075303554535,
0.9049607515335083,
0.4875209629535675,
0.040174104273319244,
-0.13687537610530853,
-0.4615879952907562,
0.17354707419872284,
-0.4743216633796692,
0.405803918838501,
-0.10809201747179031,
-0.9418936371803284,
0.462881475687027,
0.09221228212118149,
0.37101271748542786,
0.4510471522808075,
0.6720641851425171,
0.026738127693533897,
0.9238777160644531,
0.50557941198349,
-0.11974965035915375,
0.3473861515522003,
-0.2288588583469391,
0.46465739607810974,
-0.6048601865768433,
-0.3638140857219696,
-0.8433089852333069,
0.0359637513756752,
-0.5588720440864563,
-0.5667160749435425,
0.41576480865478516,
0.23953282833099365,
-0.5087854266166687,
0.1825050562620163,
-0.5665546655654907,
0.5530115962028503,
0.8292521238327026,
-0.07103178650140762,
0.39370328187942505,
-0.13175667822360992,
0.18584056198596954,
0.23945359885692596,
-0.5591508150100708,
-0.9724138975143433,
1.3301124572753906,
0.4772646725177765,
0.8187893629074097,
0.14390544593334198,
0.6117076277732849,
0.40318068861961365,
0.5276997685432434,
-0.6884728074073792,
0.528595507144928,
-0.09570153802633286,
-0.3927447497844696,
-0.3098362982273102,
-0.7086047530174255,
-0.8457764983177185,
-0.003273693611845374,
-0.18396414816379547,
-0.6227580904960632,
-0.5618644952774048,
0.1862712949514389,
-0.21413640677928925,
0.15822184085845947,
-0.6299229860305786,
0.811884343624115,
-0.4139474034309387,
-0.22776083648204803,
-0.36605194211006165,
-0.3090982735157013,
0.5698294043540955,
0.005557653959840536,
0.13718774914741516,
-0.29974862933158875,
0.07108225673437119,
0.5879126191139221,
-0.3005664050579071,
0.6246605515480042,
0.06112660840153694,
-0.42588409781455994,
0.48848894238471985,
0.3702104687690735,
0.3294198513031006,
0.08925829082727432,
-0.1955682933330536,
0.3343956768512726,
-0.17321547865867615,
-0.3682064116001129,
-0.40724149346351624,
0.9035765528678894,
-1.081513524055481,
-0.4804159998893738,
0.048408787697553635,
-0.3404724597930908,
-0.09504733234643936,
0.011693860404193401,
0.009820418432354927,
0.44083264470100403,
-0.13411137461662292,
0.19675025343894958,
0.3298923075199127,
-0.9598684906959534,
0.3658997416496277,
0.20146678388118744,
-0.4351849853992462,
-0.31693142652511597,
0.9478162527084351,
-0.028680210933089256,
0.5884040594100952,
0.11799299716949463,
-0.17386436462402344,
-0.0057448274455964565,
-0.6405462026596069,
-0.5738686323165894,
0.24655403196811676,
-0.7780293226242065,
-0.17089414596557617,
-0.3079376816749573,
-0.6021590828895569,
-0.3833748698234558,
-0.19736912846565247,
-0.5739116668701172,
-0.2907352149486542,
-0.021725628525018692,
0.33382731676101685,
0.09901853650808334,
1.0603569746017456,
0.30876392126083374,
0.08167706429958344,
-1.0348303318023682,
0.2069370001554489,
0.21280808746814728,
0.4048297107219696,
0.11309802532196045,
-0.30882754921913147,
-0.29121118783950806,
0.035034649074077606,
-0.4227766692638397,
-0.47603553533554077,
0.2978866994380951,
-0.15285058319568634,
0.699093222618103,
0.3452436029911041,
-0.3626774847507477,
0.2774811089038849,
0.04777267947793007,
1.2873517274856567,
0.33925825357437134,
-0.9582682847976685,
0.4806971251964569,
-0.39772939682006836,
0.2209533452987671,
0.03161687031388283,
0.30117067694664,
-0.6592299342155457,
-0.7241629362106323,
-0.5729148983955383,
-0.6773761510848999,
0.5349149107933044,
0.628670334815979,
0.4248161017894745,
-0.0038802598137408495,
0.32416775822639465,
0.23726332187652588,
0.3143632709980011,
-0.5741662979125977,
-0.07002168148756027,
-0.21366991102695465,
-0.15042395889759064,
-0.17644120752811432,
-0.34328269958496094,
0.2644718587398529,
0.22487671673297882,
0.5518239140510559,
-0.036469392478466034,
0.4082484543323517,
-0.272732675075531,
-0.02441488206386566,
0.19283287227153778,
0.3431602418422699,
0.47851279377937317,
0.8765185475349426,
0.057368744164705276,
-0.2671978175640106,
-0.29859867691993713,
-0.26350730657577515,
-0.11851219087839127,
-0.5869763493537903,
0.0022681073751300573,
-0.17575989663600922,
0.689845621585846,
0.49110931158065796,
-0.24035052955150604,
-0.9778749346733093,
0.643149197101593,
0.19356600940227509,
-0.01949257031083107,
-0.15085555613040924,
0.6545907258987427,
0.18506398797035217,
0.13580314815044403,
0.25576576590538025,
0.03787703067064285,
-0.2322050780057907,
-0.785784900188446,
-0.20314069092273712,
0.4100153148174286,
-0.08156634122133255,
-0.18906378746032715,
0.48803430795669556,
0.46175217628479004,
-0.4265151619911194,
1.194264531135559,
-0.13641557097434998,
-0.3963261544704437,
0.8800703883171082,
0.48384952545166016,
0.5447158217430115,
0.15981541574001312,
-0.0074324458837509155,
0.4987013041973114,
0.4169420301914215,
0.03574661538004875,
0.24170970916748047,
0.12933249771595,
-0.6493180990219116,
-0.8261861801147461,
-0.6518407464027405,
-0.6474522352218628,
0.013278127647936344,
-0.3616153597831726,
0.029181063175201416,
-0.38890013098716736,
-0.09847978502511978,
-0.3142094314098358,
-0.11206738650798798,
-0.6732384562492371,
0.006551739294081926,
0.3776647448539734,
0.7153855562210083,
-0.6174691319465637,
0.5608403086662292,
0.4426872134208679,
-0.4574420154094696,
-0.7575930953025818,
-0.10724448412656784,
-0.22726799547672272,
-1.0566059350967407,
0.7895799875259399,
0.11431240290403366,
-0.04452013224363327,
-0.23074916005134583,
-0.6206740140914917,
-0.7818199396133423,
0.8369282484054565,
0.39641714096069336,
-0.6120940446853638,
0.07668647915124893,
0.39934608340263367,
0.7426983714103699,
-0.21747902035713196,
0.6159814596176147,
0.5133604407310486,
0.3019222915172577,
0.09487979114055634,
-1.3137394189834595,
-0.21235904097557068,
-0.27251437306404114,
0.27519869804382324,
0.16663606464862823,
-0.6213665008544922,
0.628034234046936,
-0.374756395816803,
-0.1829242706298828,
0.2796782851219177,
0.6829912066459656,
0.24188601970672607,
0.100529246032238,
-0.025449145585298538,
0.1438448131084442,
0.7271994948387146,
-0.33755040168762207,
1.1309864521026611,
-0.572813093662262,
0.3382696509361267,
0.8220164179801941,
-0.17648877203464508,
0.9918729066848755,
0.11550144851207733,
-0.4395911991596222,
0.3783110976219177,
0.2681798040866852,
-0.20212695002555847,
0.00824218150228262,
0.6511564254760742,
0.21535982191562653,
-0.19151915609836578,
0.27325573563575745,
-0.13752998411655426,
0.4934047758579254,
0.3545534610748291,
-0.47596505284309387,
0.16564109921455383,
-0.06488848477602005,
0.12148773670196533,
0.043598975986242294,
-0.3354228138923645,
0.8055410981178284,
0.0066449916921556,
-1.0168460607528687,
0.6705206632614136,
-0.018080275505781174,
0.8709201812744141,
-0.42545124888420105,
0.1134386733174324,
-0.31278228759765625,
0.318162202835083,
-0.31834885478019714,
-1.1574259996414185,
0.43466001749038696,
0.3334941864013672,
0.19189171493053436,
-0.06837975978851318,
0.5158518552780151,
0.0672532394528389,
-0.3633396327495575,
0.1301833838224411,
0.70879727602005,
0.5744892358779907,
-0.03133378550410271,
-0.559447705745697,
0.2744942903518677,
0.032285213470458984,
-0.14380085468292236,
0.22468911111354828,
0.32080313563346863,
0.30473122000694275,
1.0194246768951416,
0.8579845428466797,
0.20120538771152496,
0.16346263885498047,
0.00953120831400156,
0.7810536026954651,
-0.4155929386615753,
-0.03066144697368145,
-0.921977162361145,
0.39309021830558777,
-0.0689953938126564,
-0.4834767282009125,
0.9078216552734375,
0.6209169030189514,
0.9981139302253723,
-0.1655779629945755,
0.7401872277259827,
-0.2274995893239975,
0.22884400188922882,
-0.5354889035224915,
0.7927204966545105,
-0.28054913878440857,
0.3977624773979187,
-0.2653116285800934,
-0.9642540812492371,
-0.21847891807556152,
0.3802940845489502,
-0.2983090877532959,
0.1564112901687622,
0.4206202030181885,
0.9961276650428772,
0.02356341853737831,
-0.2835004925727844,
0.6481404900550842,
0.15567468106746674,
0.5896316766738892,
0.820449948310852,
1.2039906978607178,
-0.36733779311180115,
0.8915141224861145,
0.05667639151215553,
-0.263251930475235,
-0.2403959035873413,
-0.7507238984107971,
-0.9982093572616577,
-0.42474302649497986,
-0.36288756132125854,
-0.6575016379356384,
-0.11550669372081757,
0.8391844630241394,
0.5018266439437866,
-0.5281713604927063,
-0.25229790806770325,
0.05578158423304558,
0.010952110402286053,
-0.2396136075258255,
-0.16494856774806976,
0.21720995008945465,
-0.40035733580589294,
-0.7196570038795471,
0.10901632159948349,
0.3865141272544861,
-0.031392425298690796,
-0.507136344909668,
-0.3590116500854492,
0.5903685688972473,
0.20553958415985107,
0.6979546546936035,
0.05988303944468498,
-0.715070366859436,
-0.1189316138625145,
-0.06225578859448433,
-0.47557753324508667,
0.028967799618840218,
0.7769584655761719,
-0.4846213161945343,
0.07169074565172195,
0.7505760192871094,
0.6286345720291138,
0.18536260724067688,
-0.12158484756946564,
0.436166912317276,
-0.3588617146015167,
-0.33100584149360657,
0.10936165601015091,
0.35599276423454285,
0.3471112847328186,
-0.04939823970198631,
0.579226016998291,
-0.24948875606060028,
-1.0184212923049927,
-0.7463074922561646,
0.047357942909002304,
-0.7800159454345703,
-0.12502425909042358,
1.4239495992660522,
-0.5699672102928162,
-0.1302299201488495,
0.10253090411424637,
-0.3599051833152771,
0.2107580155134201,
-0.34985703229904175,
0.9157745242118835,
0.7630553841590881,
-0.11977212131023407,
0.09065549075603485,
-0.7681632041931152,
0.17526279389858246,
0.18522357940673828,
-0.8803008198738098,
0.10959931463003159,
0.5573146343231201,
0.3402916491031647,
0.254462331533432,
0.5353319048881531,
-0.35380563139915466,
0.34984084963798523,
0.24480688571929932,
0.3518853187561035,
-0.2215915471315384,
-0.17515647411346436,
-0.07524184882640839,
0.37716642022132874,
0.661434531211853,
0.09359955042600632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14385v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14385v1
|
Emotion Identification for French in Written Texts: Considering their Modes of Expression as a Step Towards Text Complexity Analysis
| 2024-05-23T10:02:13 | 2024-05-23T10:02:13 |
Aline Étienne, Delphine Battistelli, Gwénolé Lecorvé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The objective of this paper is to predict (A) whether a sentence in a written
text expresses an emotion, (B) the mode(s) in which it is expressed, (C)
whether it is basic or complex, and (D) its emotional category.
One of our major contributions, through a dataset and a model, is to
integrate the fact that an emotion can be expressed in different modes: from a
direct mode, essentially lexicalized, to a more indirect mode, where emotions
will only be suggested, a mode that NLP approaches generally don't take into
account.
Another originality is that the scope is on written texts, as opposed usual
work focusing on conversational (often multi-modal) data. In this context,
modes of expression are seen as a factor towards the automatic analysis of
complexity in texts.
Experiments on French texts show acceptable results compared to the human
annotators' agreement, and outperforming results compared to using a large
language model with in-context learning (i.e. no fine-tuning).
|
[
-0.16344736516475677,
-0.8509416580200195,
0.6972924470901489,
0.6131154298782349,
-0.23053397238254547,
-0.017527300864458084,
-0.40765655040740967,
-0.6194741129875183,
0.09703025221824646,
0.36057281494140625,
-0.37908613681793213,
-0.46651437878608704,
-0.9635940790176392,
0.5287249088287354,
-0.5676050782203674,
0.7818690538406372,
-0.49832993745803833,
-0.025397758930921555,
-0.21194428205490112,
-0.15952585637569427,
-0.08785907179117203,
-0.8065335154533386,
-0.6614346504211426,
-0.20602843165397644,
0.7044021487236023,
0.2276318073272705,
0.2762255370616913,
0.13621118664741516,
0.5606368780136108,
0.44397392868995667,
-0.03525802493095398,
0.06498610228300095,
-0.37290987372398376,
0.3032820522785187,
0.2049284130334854,
-0.3419695198535919,
-0.42151883244514465,
0.13055406510829926,
0.4276154637336731,
0.3147667944431305,
0.21499530971050262,
-0.31344643235206604,
0.13525570929050446,
1.1796867847442627,
-0.5859391689300537,
0.5216131210327148,
-0.17610858380794525,
0.3340710997581482,
0.001963819842785597,
-0.35531938076019287,
-0.5176624655723572,
-0.26977774500846863,
0.4735134243965149,
-0.0772581472992897,
-0.0578790120780468,
0.0250242929905653,
0.82201087474823,
0.01173376850783825,
-0.8947879672050476,
-0.7378218770027161,
-0.7290168404579163,
0.6250060796737671,
-0.3444052040576935,
0.22406524419784546,
0.09988599270582199,
-0.09851563721895218,
0.14720381796360016,
-0.4960241913795471,
-0.7340185046195984,
-0.17447113990783691,
-0.21290789544582367,
0.4560769498348236,
-0.311496376991272,
0.2672281861305237,
0.4649962782859802,
0.4886970818042755,
-0.5403004288673401,
-0.18412788212299347,
-0.3036966919898987,
0.04905778914690018,
0.8494535684585571,
0.10510421544313431,
0.5949068069458008,
-0.39243894815444946,
-0.36961638927459717,
0.1022699624300003,
-0.21433612704277039,
0.3520161807537079,
0.49917247891426086,
0.10885556042194366,
-0.4561603367328644,
0.7146666049957275,
-0.22682586312294006,
0.48801755905151367,
-0.22000473737716675,
0.14127536118030548,
0.3079714775085449,
-0.0713110938668251,
-0.3554614782333374,
0.03950759023427963,
1.0872875452041626,
0.6355463862419128,
0.5144789814949036,
-0.024738255888223648,
-0.6458092927932739,
0.15396550297737122,
0.1936597377061844,
-0.6864875555038452,
-0.11415847390890121,
0.2932112514972687,
-0.5319404602050781,
-0.2816806435585022,
0.1692793369293213,
-1.071824073791504,
-0.40821778774261475,
-0.382639616727829,
0.5742706060409546,
-0.3503619134426117,
-0.15209397673606873,
0.11304106563329697,
-0.1550542265176773,
0.1312166154384613,
0.4694578945636749,
-0.9023957848548889,
0.5015458464622498,
0.36742329597473145,
0.7835546731948853,
-0.15217286348342896,
-0.031751397997140884,
-0.13813064992427826,
-0.41280704736709595,
-0.15080858767032623,
0.6040337085723877,
-0.6938300728797913,
-0.6365317702293396,
0.16847717761993408,
0.219709113240242,
-0.4221208691596985,
0.048626385629177094,
0.9631906151771545,
-0.2237839251756668,
0.5800589323043823,
-0.43827590346336365,
-0.5369601249694824,
-0.38965994119644165,
0.014567567966878414,
-0.9488746523857117,
1.3020654916763306,
0.27266359329223633,
-0.654285728931427,
0.05280696228146553,
-0.7616196870803833,
-0.4943450689315796,
-0.06189965456724167,
-0.10924909263849258,
-0.17902693152427673,
0.5054095983505249,
-0.06242140755057335,
0.5595217943191528,
-0.5219332575798035,
0.005244712345302105,
0.12780404090881348,
-0.06124500185251236,
0.3927322030067444,
-0.35131916403770447,
0.41287681460380554,
0.045033521950244904,
-0.5983728766441345,
0.13702522218227386,
-0.5866590142250061,
-0.1271916925907135,
0.09326272457838058,
-0.3183090388774872,
-0.4087553918361664,
0.270429790019989,
0.5018333792686462,
0.23223520815372467,
0.3423543870449066,
-0.7076880931854248,
0.2745074927806854,
-0.4761161208152771,
0.2766093313694,
0.6400170922279358,
0.18569056689739227,
0.5889652967453003,
-0.145863875746727,
0.6645523905754089,
-0.13408467173576355,
-0.09432864934206009,
-0.07687334716320038,
-0.616866946220398,
-0.7657344937324524,
-0.09792590886354446,
0.2794986367225647,
0.8283663392066956,
-0.23488828539848328,
0.5225091576576233,
0.029977502301335335,
-0.3667682409286499,
-0.15360738337039948,
-0.04459341987967491,
0.48383575677871704,
0.6421656012535095,
0.1999834179878235,
-0.30782076716423035,
-0.37001603841781616,
-0.849480926990509,
-0.33732011914253235,
-0.19524745643138885,
0.19525428116321564,
0.5195519328117371,
0.4736306369304657,
-0.2558824121952057,
0.6788923740386963,
-0.371660977602005,
0.06736767292022705,
-0.3742501735687256,
0.546760618686676,
-0.26911279559135437,
0.4474152624607086,
0.6316068768501282,
-1.2477054595947266,
-0.6952932476997375,
0.17655205726623535,
-0.8538803458213806,
-0.2870422601699829,
-0.20201298594474792,
0.04020988196134567,
0.4063197076320648,
0.4852493405342102,
-0.3888600468635559,
0.4895404279232025,
0.602541446685791,
-0.34485924243927,
0.2426041066646576,
-0.15289521217346191,
0.5392308831214905,
-0.7353585958480835,
-0.1450212299823761,
0.5516830682754517,
0.027222098782658577,
-0.7638706564903259,
-0.3554602563381195,
0.17183208465576172,
-0.14182505011558533,
-0.24546770751476288,
0.7182885408401489,
-0.25471875071525574,
0.5868905186653137,
-0.0841030478477478,
0.17232133448123932,
0.20047146081924438,
0.4208292067050934,
0.3924548625946045,
0.30653151869773865,
0.4844764769077301,
-0.36680638790130615,
0.21847878396511078,
-0.1262550950050354,
-0.26932263374328613,
0.4953280985355377,
-0.5533561110496521,
-0.050517309457063675,
-0.5119659900665283,
0.08044975250959396,
-1.19273841381073,
-0.4990452826023102,
0.3828819692134857,
-0.2877657115459442,
0.4053195118904114,
0.10294845700263977,
-0.19158653914928436,
-0.058129314333200455,
0.016044655814766884,
0.39585772156715393,
0.43129920959472656,
-0.034914929419755936,
1.1071761846542358,
0.0991382822394371,
-0.2851180136203766,
-0.45848751068115234,
-0.5473164319992065,
0.15554594993591309,
-0.34495121240615845,
-0.5493122339248657,
0.23595397174358368,
-0.12042141705751419,
-0.4164719581604004,
-0.1131107285618782,
-0.10440227389335632,
-0.2487950623035431,
0.1278478354215622,
0.64979088306427,
0.06392741203308105,
-0.05558181554079056,
0.5000584125518799,
0.39022424817085266,
0.03237806633114815,
0.29246893525123596,
0.43766549229621887,
0.21570372581481934,
-0.4033810794353485,
-0.0298748929053545,
-0.39264115691185,
0.8431591987609863,
0.5782932639122009,
-0.3045203983783722,
0.5673768520355225,
0.6295349597930908,
-0.6410708427429199,
-0.1401585042476654,
-0.3779536783695221,
0.1609518975019455,
-0.41659852862358093,
0.27350831031799316,
-0.5291891098022461,
-0.8129974603652954,
0.4980849325656891,
-0.21247322857379913,
-0.41286519169807434,
0.8706886768341064,
0.6287218928337097,
-0.23382535576820374,
0.9945141673088074,
0.8929618000984192,
-0.04504590854048729,
0.35639065504074097,
-0.04785604774951935,
0.34347644448280334,
-0.5826836228370667,
-0.28339627385139465,
-0.7575717568397522,
-0.4006541073322296,
-0.7899248003959656,
-0.12754838168621063,
0.1824934184551239,
0.2421308159828186,
0.04572344943881035,
-0.012533120810985565,
-0.5474997162818909,
0.4814728796482086,
0.14362646639347076,
0.15692968666553497,
-0.10655058175325394,
-0.23486588895320892,
0.1477992832660675,
-0.10797637701034546,
-0.41733014583587646,
-0.8675957918167114,
0.8855272531509399,
0.3825629949569702,
0.36442533135414124,
0.28900402784347534,
0.8692659139633179,
0.19137470424175262,
0.5412553548812866,
-1.1562600135803223,
0.44689619541168213,
-0.1894311010837555,
-0.34994685649871826,
-0.22829453647136688,
-0.32991087436676025,
-0.7364976406097412,
-0.04896748811006546,
-0.5426452159881592,
-1.2372262477874756,
0.4364989101886749,
-0.0335984081029892,
-0.06569255143404007,
0.05453234910964966,
-0.9525356888771057,
1.2083837985992432,
-0.2300151288509369,
-0.14207230508327484,
0.18820467591285706,
-0.6517101526260376,
0.28989875316619873,
-0.15611234307289124,
0.2800902724266052,
-0.12100869417190552,
-0.18185371160507202,
0.8645093441009521,
-0.231195330619812,
0.8748301267623901,
0.014870124869048595,
-0.09687836468219757,
0.4184185266494751,
0.22261247038841248,
0.4165813624858856,
0.01229434460401535,
-0.2927120327949524,
-0.1444496214389801,
-0.02713409811258316,
-0.23518888652324677,
-0.7472876906394958,
0.5720434188842773,
-0.6550269722938538,
-0.39683279395103455,
-0.44796350598335266,
-0.4077328145503998,
-0.0995102971792221,
0.006940630730241537,
0.4805386960506439,
0.8187851309776306,
-0.36011621356010437,
0.2072608917951584,
0.6481808423995972,
-0.15888454020023346,
0.6340386271476746,
0.16176624596118927,
0.009976575151085854,
0.1196824312210083,
0.8761632442474365,
-0.05596081539988518,
0.16688935458660126,
0.7020679712295532,
0.515998899936676,
-0.24463403224945068,
-0.20785410702228546,
-0.3082767426967621,
-0.13852277398109436,
-0.8788179159164429,
0.09360051900148392,
-0.9238852858543396,
-0.043308012187480927,
0.0013265066081658006,
-0.5263551473617554,
-0.20863637328147888,
-0.351791650056839,
-0.481117308139801,
-0.028241341933608055,
0.49186497926712036,
0.8074544668197632,
0.18836121261119843,
0.26148730516433716,
-1.0044808387756348,
0.15988455712795258,
0.23263520002365112,
0.2167394608259201,
-0.30751386284828186,
-0.26863953471183777,
-0.08477387577295303,
-0.3011001944541931,
-0.05085795745253563,
-1.2708203792572021,
0.592467725276947,
0.3855780363082886,
0.027189796790480614,
0.37479135394096375,
0.18101775646209717,
-0.07569243758916855,
-0.3293716013431549,
0.8633078336715698,
0.11910875141620636,
-1.31559157371521,
0.4326503574848175,
-0.3390662968158722,
0.15106293559074402,
0.3859599232673645,
0.7995348572731018,
-0.6727909445762634,
-0.27961066365242004,
-0.5095943808555603,
-0.8474839925765991,
0.3383069634437561,
0.15888333320617676,
0.4035351574420929,
-0.23430119454860687,
0.6778692007064819,
-0.21017277240753174,
0.2238360345363617,
-1.0452710390090942,
-0.3016137182712555,
0.005767452996224165,
-0.8375706076622009,
-0.3031529486179352,
-0.5535325407981873,
-0.2182035893201828,
-0.0776376947760582,
0.18168924748897552,
-0.05018039420247078,
0.636337161064148,
0.566173255443573,
-0.1501920074224472,
-0.4357651472091675,
0.3123840093612671,
0.7594561576843262,
0.4402402341365814,
-0.3124462068080902,
0.20376749336719513,
-0.04502517729997635,
-0.36059850454330444,
0.1930001676082611,
-0.043418098241090775,
0.15329045057296753,
-0.05804256722331047,
0.6815536022186279,
0.8465293049812317,
0.17020390927791595,
-0.6720920205116272,
0.799636721611023,
-0.12799866497516632,
-0.3439096510410309,
0.034851863980293274,
-0.036352284252643585,
-0.1084088459610939,
0.40383943915367126,
0.19664226472377777,
0.09843727201223373,
0.43701568245887756,
-0.5273430943489075,
0.03522873297333717,
0.26575660705566406,
-0.9613283276557922,
-0.3469063937664032,
0.43467995524406433,
0.3715227246284485,
-0.4706675708293915,
0.25223401188850403,
-0.4170074164867401,
-0.9994195103645325,
0.7598737478256226,
0.23078784346580505,
1.3785487413406372,
-0.23426975309848785,
0.10843592137098312,
0.42772918939590454,
0.4953962564468384,
-0.050267294049263,
0.7288489937782288,
0.18309468030929565,
-0.6984207630157471,
-0.37324464321136475,
-0.718546450138092,
-0.39882102608680725,
-0.2216855138540268,
-0.6917470097541809,
0.07528584450483322,
-0.19033730030059814,
0.031090183183550835,
0.06659451127052307,
-0.18294355273246765,
-0.6690033674240112,
0.7791242003440857,
0.1851862370967865,
0.7498229146003723,
-1.2735289335250854,
0.6858084201812744,
0.5732956528663635,
-0.24156272411346436,
-0.7331075072288513,
-0.039568524807691574,
0.286878764629364,
-0.11827217042446136,
0.9778944849967957,
0.39365044236183167,
-0.4383963644504547,
-0.03888404741883278,
-0.5486505627632141,
-0.3259194493293762,
0.5242101550102234,
-0.2594144344329834,
-0.6474183797836304,
0.17982928454875946,
-0.1679956316947937,
0.833876371383667,
-0.6711336374282837,
0.2776239514350891,
0.20394466817378998,
0.5816158652305603,
-0.2835298180580139,
-0.646162211894989,
0.09688282757997513,
-0.5115399956703186,
-0.17015022039413452,
0.41002923250198364,
-0.482939749956131,
0.9953632354736328,
0.18007051944732666,
-0.4432414770126343,
-0.19643284380435944,
0.7023467421531677,
-0.7875008583068848,
0.19660234451293945,
0.6116341352462769,
0.23913733661174774,
0.6882054209709167,
-0.46216657757759094,
1.1993244886398315,
-0.48650386929512024,
0.2883693277835846,
0.6568368673324585,
-0.11214747279882431,
0.7949408888816833,
0.23274707794189453,
-0.03502151370048523,
0.7148360013961792,
0.6274715065956116,
0.3073309361934662,
0.031170401722192764,
0.25466689467430115,
-0.5877344608306885,
-0.14612755179405212,
0.16360385715961456,
-0.07415905594825745,
0.5928705334663391,
0.5445891618728638,
-0.4878993332386017,
0.15532487630844116,
0.12472378462553024,
-0.03229334577918053,
0.30748146772384644,
-0.2524740993976593,
0.6577562093734741,
-0.06359407305717468,
-0.3364647328853607,
0.18120430409908295,
0.15400567650794983,
0.3052886724472046,
-0.4725906252861023,
0.03169633448123932,
-0.002891194075345993,
-0.2871657609939575,
-0.34890973567962646,
-0.7662993669509888,
0.23318475484848022,
0.055531833320856094,
-0.37450188398361206,
-0.21760404109954834,
0.693303644657135,
-0.5673629641532898,
-0.5023283958435059,
0.21474185585975647,
0.49581804871559143,
0.014819526113569736,
-0.3077057898044586,
-0.6257886290550232,
0.1604519486427307,
-0.05379648879170418,
-0.7216510772705078,
0.13130587339401245,
0.922008216381073,
0.0633731335401535,
0.37464800477027893,
-0.0005726637318730354,
-0.3016960322856903,
-0.2818537950515747,
-0.04075796529650688,
0.657799243927002,
-0.745281457901001,
-0.06568173319101334,
-0.9485586881637573,
0.823959231376648,
0.04039241746068001,
-0.4497719705104828,
0.5097293257713318,
0.5107793807983398,
0.18760105967521667,
-0.09641844779253006,
0.9343459010124207,
-0.27768078446388245,
0.18942146003246307,
-0.5621078610420227,
0.4399474859237671,
-0.7522306442260742,
-0.11786340177059174,
-0.8783632516860962,
-0.8382682800292969,
-0.3324829041957855,
0.77549809217453,
-0.3003915846347809,
0.0005336316535249352,
0.9736320972442627,
0.5189192891120911,
0.11612696200609207,
0.197865292429924,
0.11394278705120087,
0.10671978443861008,
0.054006144404411316,
0.6112014055252075,
0.7200364470481873,
-0.4473113715648651,
-0.026472201570868492,
-0.5041821599006653,
-0.5089311599731445,
-0.19801297783851624,
-1.2451525926589966,
-0.693673849105835,
-1.0861499309539795,
-0.5966805219650269,
-0.5452283024787903,
-0.2832125127315521,
0.8112749457359314,
-0.11818350106477737,
-0.5355731248855591,
-0.2167423814535141,
0.0038702248129993677,
0.2003549486398697,
0.04564591869711876,
-0.20237062871456146,
0.37543216347694397,
-0.292888343334198,
-1.1614500284194946,
0.1270175576210022,
0.6367549300193787,
0.186628058552742,
-0.06216321885585785,
-0.004511475097388029,
-0.060839831829071045,
0.6383585929870605,
0.9102845788002014,
0.2936510443687439,
-0.5655384659767151,
-0.6543656587600708,
-0.10541671514511108,
-0.3967165946960449,
-0.022028744220733643,
0.8137057423591614,
-0.21005025506019592,
0.8841615915298462,
0.5749737024307251,
0.33183449506759644,
0.3602682948112488,
-0.11465106904506683,
0.6603030562400818,
-0.5153316855430603,
0.20505592226982117,
0.29797762632369995,
0.4048076272010803,
0.06736026704311371,
-0.42995327711105347,
0.3657594919204712,
0.12909112870693207,
-0.6117146015167236,
-0.6792269945144653,
0.3028528094291687,
-1.5356049537658691,
-0.05788514390587807,
1.1217029094696045,
-0.1515154242515564,
-0.24528835713863373,
0.11950376629829407,
-0.5538068413734436,
0.15339845418930054,
-0.32449519634246826,
0.6246424317359924,
0.9676588177680969,
-0.21340332925319672,
-0.23857897520065308,
-0.6459206938743591,
0.9844851493835449,
0.2604171931743622,
-0.8094534277915955,
0.03772691637277603,
0.5762559771537781,
-0.3529500663280487,
0.08562882989645004,
0.6189765334129333,
0.06430862098932266,
0.025810111314058304,
-0.06557181477546692,
0.23899997770786285,
0.6076356768608093,
-0.36831358075141907,
-0.3689296841621399,
0.3779444694519043,
-0.1351441591978073,
0.3445911109447479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14383v1
|
Perception of Knowledge Boundary for Large Language Models through Semi-open-ended Question Answering
| 2024-05-23T10:00:14 | 2024-05-23T10:00:14 |
Zhihua Wen, Zhiliang Tian, Zexin Jian, Zhen Huang, Pei Ke, Yifu Gao, Minlie Huang, Dongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used for knowledge-seeking yet suffer
from hallucinations. The knowledge boundary (KB) of an LLM limits its factual
understanding, beyond which it may begin to hallucinate. Investigating the
perception of LLMs' KB is crucial for detecting hallucinations and LLMs'
reliable generation. Current studies perceive LLMs' KB on questions with a
concrete answer (close-ended questions) while paying limited attention to
semi-open-ended questions (SoeQ) that correspond to many potential answers.
Some researchers achieve it by judging whether the question is answerable or
not. However, this paradigm is unsuitable for SoeQ, which are usually partially
answerable, containing both answerable and ambiguous (unanswerable) answers.
Ambiguous answers are essential for knowledge-seeking, but they may go beyond
the KB of LLMs. In this paper, we perceive the LLMs' KB with SoeQ by
discovering more ambiguous answers. First, we apply an LLM-based approach to
construct SoeQ and obtain answers from a target LLM. Unfortunately, the output
probabilities of mainstream black-box LLMs are inaccessible to sample for
low-probability ambiguous answers. Therefore, we apply an open-sourced
auxiliary model to explore ambiguous answers for the target LLM. We calculate
the nearest semantic representation for existing answers to estimate their
probabilities, with which we reduce the generation probability of
high-probability answers to achieve a more effective generation. Finally, we
compare the results from the RAG-based evaluation and LLM self-evaluation to
categorize four types of ambiguous answers that are beyond the KB of the target
LLM. Following our method, we construct a dataset to perceive the KB for GPT-4.
We find that GPT-4 performs poorly on SoeQ and is often unaware of its KB.
Besides, our auxiliary model, LLaMA-2-13B, is effective in discovering more
ambiguous answers.
|
[
-0.5788236260414124,
-0.9247846603393555,
1.09428071975708,
0.011495248414576054,
-0.15536756813526154,
0.000688475847709924,
-0.3405824899673462,
-0.6949183940887451,
-0.00853806734085083,
0.5798946022987366,
-0.7321581840515137,
-0.4970347285270691,
-0.5708754658699036,
0.11557206511497498,
-0.15165206789970398,
0.7491079568862915,
-0.08918808400630951,
-0.18147990107536316,
-0.41688862442970276,
0.049229126423597336,
-0.5311473608016968,
-0.5540485978126526,
-0.3889947831630707,
-0.3003740906715393,
0.3417225778102875,
0.20566868782043457,
0.5567446947097778,
0.3262421190738678,
0.32839009165763855,
0.19394166767597198,
-0.23331768810749054,
0.10778120905160904,
-0.6509789228439331,
-0.07471443712711334,
-0.33337339758872986,
-0.5751148462295532,
-0.11500117927789688,
-0.2208951860666275,
0.5920316576957703,
0.9301512241363525,
-0.02530934289097786,
0.2305581271648407,
0.030332433059811592,
0.4725480377674103,
-0.5325400233268738,
0.022740310057997704,
-0.7660531401634216,
0.22899998724460602,
-0.28442633152008057,
-0.23867428302764893,
-0.358059287071228,
-0.1471686065196991,
0.24168041348457336,
-0.5425119400024414,
0.04812775179743767,
-0.010354853235185146,
0.6938295364379883,
0.2560293674468994,
-0.5041384100914001,
-0.3481144905090332,
-0.9106606245040894,
0.7676317691802979,
-0.615351140499115,
0.6979048848152161,
0.24152016639709473,
0.31921684741973877,
-0.44971519708633423,
-0.5031081438064575,
-0.6977635025978088,
-0.1336735188961029,
0.013942052610218525,
0.23614326119422913,
-0.2587265372276306,
0.09459720551967621,
0.32131943106651306,
0.2512575387954712,
-0.6552644371986389,
0.08846000581979752,
-0.3629308342933655,
-0.4881700575351715,
0.49045422673225403,
0.18277235329151154,
0.09347723424434662,
-0.27458658814430237,
-0.5526940822601318,
0.2461090087890625,
-0.7300007939338684,
0.07816758751869202,
0.38486436009407043,
-0.0005638956208713353,
0.13058412075042725,
0.7590224742889404,
-0.15576758980751038,
0.996380090713501,
0.06313349306583405,
-0.1419975906610489,
0.1467273086309433,
-0.06940917670726776,
-0.08684132248163223,
-0.0963371992111206,
0.5932332277297974,
0.33444780111312866,
0.1594906449317932,
-0.2449062168598175,
-0.22792549431324005,
-0.01872980035841465,
0.20239926874637604,
-0.43486160039901733,
0.07423534244298935,
0.19086533784866333,
-0.4055369794368744,
0.057508714497089386,
-0.13273702561855316,
-0.8382203578948975,
-0.4651622772216797,
-0.23715263605117798,
0.5528038144111633,
-0.3243502378463745,
-0.26953139901161194,
0.2022586166858673,
0.015376405790448189,
0.3716180622577667,
0.4412890076637268,
-0.48122677206993103,
0.2609066963195801,
0.4188421964645386,
0.5882558226585388,
-0.23225724697113037,
-0.13831262290477753,
-0.35861286520957947,
0.2123951017856598,
-0.33409878611564636,
0.7939919233322144,
-0.6499235033988953,
-0.22953379154205322,
-0.15100905299186707,
-0.12223554402589798,
0.1041114553809166,
-0.7720869779586792,
0.4120863378047943,
-0.9001977443695068,
0.16267511248588562,
-0.29878664016723633,
-0.5975615978240967,
-0.33173680305480957,
0.2974962592124939,
-0.5726672410964966,
0.9379832148551941,
0.15496942400932312,
-0.7731748819351196,
0.11412274092435837,
-0.49077796936035156,
-0.22443747520446777,
0.015777749940752983,
-0.4930257797241211,
-0.027863437309861183,
0.2640289068222046,
0.09377020597457886,
0.43660295009613037,
-0.41769838333129883,
0.3336111307144165,
-0.23681215941905975,
-0.21048596501350403,
0.3970372676849365,
-0.25872549414634705,
0.45682868361473083,
0.24688249826431274,
-0.2796432673931122,
-0.013056793250143528,
-0.7713693976402283,
0.0041173845529556274,
0.13633915781974792,
-0.2041226178407669,
-0.43974700570106506,
-0.22497983276844025,
-0.37983110547065735,
0.37842485308647156,
0.48158544301986694,
-0.6811670064926147,
-0.06837479025125504,
-0.41596904397010803,
0.14299000799655914,
1.0458154678344727,
0.23760762810707092,
0.29613229632377625,
-0.21868883073329926,
0.6229504942893982,
0.16041474044322968,
0.12271366268396378,
0.33536383509635925,
-0.6703404188156128,
-0.5445094108581543,
0.17633332312107086,
0.058338627219200134,
0.3742322027683258,
-0.8165578842163086,
0.3360195457935333,
0.07270477712154388,
-0.4600561261177063,
-0.518680989742279,
0.04037899523973465,
0.2320767194032669,
0.6608821749687195,
0.37022319436073303,
0.050745535641908646,
-0.5027461647987366,
-1.0731054544448853,
-0.30723750591278076,
-0.1560012549161911,
-0.1328222006559372,
0.5619011521339417,
0.4610106348991394,
-0.12328501790761948,
0.9266183376312256,
-0.8044561147689819,
-0.20946954190731049,
-0.11922028660774231,
-0.17940716445446014,
0.3875657021999359,
0.016602514311671257,
0.05843906104564667,
-0.9729345440864563,
-0.20279745757579803,
-0.022841641679406166,
-0.9785820245742798,
-0.11027450114488602,
0.014396227896213531,
-0.053429022431373596,
0.07312888652086258,
0.3348051607608795,
-0.6280279159545898,
0.33955416083335876,
0.5117412805557251,
-0.270903080701828,
0.6247715950012207,
-0.012039550580084324,
-0.09638901799917221,
-0.8530086278915405,
-0.024674415588378906,
-0.0957757979631424,
-0.036797456443309784,
-0.7913941740989685,
0.12777598202228546,
0.0332922525703907,
0.18837668001651764,
-0.4241872727870941,
0.7202128171920776,
-0.5426062345504761,
-0.33458298444747925,
-0.18553777039051056,
0.26560842990875244,
-0.12023144960403442,
0.5554381608963013,
0.3080810010433197,
0.5830065011978149,
0.5383282899856567,
-0.5474793314933777,
0.3373122811317444,
0.17035910487174988,
-0.4835579991340637,
0.22536760568618774,
-0.4175185263156891,
0.308377742767334,
-0.3522548973560333,
0.07172707468271255,
-0.9093366265296936,
-0.10636783391237259,
0.19449906051158905,
-0.4173542559146881,
0.13833792507648468,
0.06641418486833572,
-0.3664839565753937,
-0.4083665907382965,
-0.03423464298248291,
0.6269716620445251,
0.49135708808898926,
-0.5285409688949585,
0.685167133808136,
0.45072025060653687,
-0.21222852170467377,
-0.673955500125885,
-0.5024286508560181,
-0.14274466037750244,
-0.1529957503080368,
-0.6727948784828186,
0.14438779652118683,
-0.08236826956272125,
-0.291939914226532,
0.025916920974850655,
-0.4571402072906494,
0.19109266996383667,
-0.06024669110774994,
0.17285265028476715,
0.35363152623176575,
-0.07995685935020447,
0.16425643861293793,
0.0032266511116176844,
0.025124968960881233,
0.29648327827453613,
-0.49855899810791016,
0.7386850714683533,
-0.1667303591966629,
-0.4210664629936218,
0.2500937283039093,
0.23293179273605347,
0.32939329743385315,
-0.3379015028476715,
0.6092619895935059,
0.3003310263156891,
-0.7480444312095642,
-0.14447584748268127,
-0.7339498400688171,
-0.34089335799217224,
-0.43747958540916443,
0.384124755859375,
-0.7374930381774902,
-1.255100131034851,
1.0212070941925049,
-0.006241886876523495,
-0.27240297198295593,
0.5177250504493713,
0.8517608046531677,
-0.0684770718216896,
0.9034693241119385,
0.46759873628616333,
0.35419583320617676,
-0.07736571878194809,
-0.16263113915920258,
0.3381001055240631,
-0.9674559235572815,
-0.665375292301178,
-0.2830485701560974,
-0.1795022189617157,
-0.5521004796028137,
-0.4519709646701813,
0.7236136794090271,
0.21405674517154694,
0.04662911966443062,
-0.07321936637163162,
-0.41884860396385193,
0.37461864948272705,
0.4747004806995392,
0.33331099152565,
0.45786869525909424,
-0.3302786946296692,
-0.23453326523303986,
0.019974125549197197,
-0.6544649004936218,
-0.4310283064842224,
1.1189044713974,
0.5522081851959229,
0.919749915599823,
0.18689657747745514,
0.6379038095474243,
0.10232502222061157,
0.051953185349702835,
-0.6059644222259521,
0.7199392914772034,
0.27499842643737793,
-0.8797077536582947,
-0.6178109645843506,
-0.6062352657318115,
-0.8048524856567383,
0.14628759026527405,
-0.17280492186546326,
-1.0265460014343262,
0.21101094782352448,
-0.17947493493556976,
-0.426812082529068,
0.3492337167263031,
-0.42839452624320984,
0.8426545858383179,
-0.15908773243427277,
-0.3985746502876282,
0.15426313877105713,
-0.7540682554244995,
0.638491690158844,
-0.4192454218864441,
0.23676051199436188,
0.03259000927209854,
-0.030071120709180832,
0.9103273153305054,
-0.19630500674247742,
0.760105550289154,
-0.26555201411247253,
-0.4844990670681,
0.44034385681152344,
0.0553453229367733,
0.6637934446334839,
0.040839459747076035,
0.04563228040933609,
0.2553112804889679,
-0.11389093846082687,
-0.28404733538627625,
-0.8370780348777771,
0.6669107675552368,
-0.8538913130760193,
-0.9632142186164856,
-0.340469092130661,
-0.6966676712036133,
-0.3757934868335724,
0.3121287524700165,
0.434963196516037,
0.18870344758033752,
0.12038298696279526,
-0.2671078145503998,
0.9055014252662659,
-0.48329225182533264,
-0.051706552505493164,
0.48396414518356323,
-0.5095548629760742,
0.059684690088033676,
0.6263478398323059,
0.34294939041137695,
0.31432753801345825,
0.3765302300453186,
0.29077374935150146,
-0.6677399277687073,
-0.7679548263549805,
-0.39030730724334717,
0.30801311135292053,
-0.8124555349349976,
-0.11893773078918457,
-0.7963827848434448,
-0.5189900398254395,
-0.2598053514957428,
0.17630091309547424,
-0.07289323955774307,
-0.1883765310049057,
-0.14201873540878296,
-0.2586424648761749,
0.24143612384796143,
0.7833811640739441,
-0.09120262414216995,
0.0011471298057585955,
-0.6128365397453308,
0.5127579569816589,
0.3683280646800995,
0.533065676689148,
0.035515036433935165,
-0.6546509861946106,
-0.07620389759540558,
0.12641242146492004,
-0.12071232497692108,
-1.303625226020813,
-0.06683272868394852,
-0.29616281390190125,
0.7018359899520874,
0.33527126908302307,
0.3949734568595886,
0.526512622833252,
-0.5216134190559387,
0.5946964621543884,
0.03906147554516792,
-0.710690438747406,
0.45999813079833984,
-0.31674331426620483,
0.168895423412323,
0.2436491847038269,
0.5554094314575195,
-0.39517685770988464,
-0.7598795890808105,
-0.6350177526473999,
-0.5553120374679565,
0.6401673555374146,
0.17227180302143097,
-0.06670825183391571,
0.06385590136051178,
0.4393497109413147,
0.30404090881347656,
0.16911070048809052,
-0.9377840161323547,
-0.30438846349716187,
0.02636033296585083,
0.07658632844686508,
-0.03086293488740921,
-0.23624451458454132,
-0.13827161490917206,
-0.07987146079540253,
0.5045451521873474,
-0.02861141599714756,
0.44042736291885376,
0.25037580728530884,
0.005451530683785677,
-0.3117635250091553,
0.449218213558197,
0.5148837566375732,
0.7345850467681885,
-0.43016505241394043,
0.3804256021976471,
0.38796213269233704,
-0.27539145946502686,
0.19946426153182983,
0.19353210926055908,
-0.2483445256948471,
-0.1960839182138443,
0.3790283799171448,
0.8071811199188232,
-0.3259658217430115,
-0.7527283430099487,
0.4897913336753845,
0.12351194024085999,
-0.24227789044380188,
-0.4403500258922577,
-0.0040640500374138355,
0.19280500710010529,
0.4234454333782196,
0.46439358592033386,
0.01209814939647913,
0.3225060999393463,
-0.7401190400123596,
0.18765155971050262,
0.5726509094238281,
-0.3608648180961609,
-0.22011412680149078,
0.6403689980506897,
-0.1882244497537613,
-0.16905201971530914,
0.4307246208190918,
-0.1877526342868805,
-0.7793861627578735,
0.4951976537704468,
0.6870068907737732,
0.537369430065155,
-0.2178354561328888,
0.05269840732216835,
0.08723519742488861,
0.46866917610168457,
0.30923694372177124,
0.5461261868476868,
0.04126235842704773,
-1.0113117694854736,
-0.556682288646698,
-0.796349287033081,
-0.26327863335609436,
0.5523688197135925,
-0.7419213056564331,
0.14665953814983368,
-0.24363145232200623,
-0.056857481598854065,
-0.08348274976015091,
-0.16791608929634094,
-0.6150768399238586,
0.33897069096565247,
0.12879277765750885,
0.9906445741653442,
-0.9213313460350037,
0.5655681490898132,
0.7884180545806885,
-0.15295784175395966,
-0.8504114747047424,
0.17373867332935333,
-0.26475194096565247,
-0.9525271058082581,
0.47413286566734314,
0.05554528161883354,
0.0020174516830593348,
0.07423330098390579,
-0.39667069911956787,
-0.7708032727241516,
0.8590346574783325,
0.31058600544929504,
-0.6146502494812012,
-0.19807234406471252,
0.4215530455112457,
0.5744057297706604,
-0.15503619611263275,
0.20594610273838043,
0.6328333616256714,
0.6405821442604065,
0.2743418514728546,
-0.8027061223983765,
0.2709842920303345,
-0.010400441475212574,
-0.19500227272510529,
0.4954960346221924,
-0.6600996851921082,
0.6590144038200378,
-0.4197736978530884,
-0.14071635901927948,
-0.15064963698387146,
0.5942573547363281,
0.5606895089149475,
0.49932563304901123,
0.5597091913223267,
0.5494665503501892,
0.7327814698219299,
-0.044137969613075256,
0.7855672836303711,
0.01576710119843483,
0.26474273204803467,
1.0703697204589844,
-0.32206830382347107,
0.7606860995292664,
0.6975526809692383,
-0.20004498958587646,
0.3149195909500122,
0.8434160947799683,
0.11836176365613937,
0.6192237138748169,
0.6050087213516235,
-0.2558751106262207,
-0.4348873496055603,
-0.10591750591993332,
-0.4412546157836914,
0.45362362265586853,
0.33029457926750183,
-0.06285391747951508,
-0.30202716588974,
0.29232096672058105,
-0.20720446109771729,
0.20742318034172058,
-0.28779029846191406,
0.8397521376609802,
0.2149008959531784,
-0.6320974230766296,
0.5523873567581177,
0.041520945727825165,
0.28075411915779114,
-0.5374646186828613,
-0.1729070097208023,
-0.16528171300888062,
-0.1379307359457016,
-0.29732993245124817,
-1.227858066558838,
0.277235209941864,
0.07889692485332489,
-0.2664605379104614,
0.1771668791770935,
1.0060292482376099,
-0.4066805839538574,
-0.42213892936706543,
0.5233061909675598,
0.7695446610450745,
0.4006187319755554,
-0.1618361622095108,
-0.3562769591808319,
-0.01042445283383131,
0.21572507917881012,
-0.35897156596183777,
0.30037832260131836,
0.7404065132141113,
-0.20324648916721344,
0.7586695551872253,
0.5910095572471619,
0.10434224456548691,
0.3837493658065796,
-0.22396941483020782,
1.082129955291748,
-0.5318006277084351,
-0.4895552694797516,
-0.8094124794006348,
0.30469152331352234,
0.19437117874622345,
-0.06326934695243835,
0.6572574377059937,
0.6291940808296204,
0.9555413126945496,
-0.05864168331027031,
0.9875361919403076,
-0.034270208328962326,
0.6271573901176453,
-0.7526916265487671,
0.36562350392341614,
-0.6884783506393433,
0.5197116732597351,
-0.2907872200012207,
-1.16505765914917,
-0.21321958303451538,
0.5067270398139954,
-0.6549350619316101,
0.13586845993995667,
0.5781239867210388,
0.7536081671714783,
-0.02727654203772545,
0.15766336023807526,
0.6146669387817383,
0.5759807825088501,
0.05239631608128548,
0.9314467310905457,
1.3896222114562988,
-0.09179217368364334,
0.624098002910614,
-0.17055955529212952,
-0.4851934015750885,
0.04045247659087181,
-0.6193763613700867,
-0.9664486646652222,
-0.6482120156288147,
0.1015845388174057,
-0.3397701680660248,
-0.02728891186416149,
0.5848709940910339,
0.2965739965438843,
-0.6426726579666138,
-0.1100473627448082,
-0.00776145001873374,
0.19273826479911804,
0.021721528843045235,
-0.2742503881454468,
0.4477521777153015,
-0.04707302898168564,
-0.4275757670402527,
0.22460736334323883,
0.2558880150318146,
0.006770611274987459,
-0.36896052956581116,
-0.18789973855018616,
-0.15684977173805237,
-0.0057642520405352116,
0.4727678894996643,
0.09002294391393661,
-0.8551560640335083,
-0.5116831660270691,
0.40028712153434753,
0.1847929209470749,
-0.048221323639154434,
0.45706796646118164,
-0.6972017884254456,
0.4496723711490631,
0.22487953305244446,
0.7504992485046387,
0.7046075463294983,
-0.11860232800245285,
0.5492656826972961,
-0.6360405683517456,
-0.15703216195106506,
0.40230053663253784,
0.1887011080980301,
0.031632985919713974,
-0.5782739520072937,
0.4516980051994324,
0.19279541075229645,
-0.4586153030395508,
-0.792594850063324,
0.5158286094665527,
-0.932509183883667,
-0.356475293636322,
1.2803280353546143,
0.04808756709098816,
-0.13176146149635315,
-0.25382936000823975,
-0.18728066980838776,
0.191471666097641,
-0.20402070879936218,
0.6772903800010681,
0.8717020750045776,
-0.38139107823371887,
-0.2614758014678955,
-0.6545278429985046,
0.32586655020713806,
0.40638047456741333,
-0.7673895955085754,
0.025380708277225494,
0.44418907165527344,
0.17865493893623352,
0.26302868127822876,
0.6680808663368225,
-0.047593019902706146,
0.21533535420894623,
-0.2311592847108841,
0.08670870214700699,
0.0021889703348279,
-0.5372515320777893,
-0.16496756672859192,
0.2519093155860901,
0.24991847574710846,
-0.07547251135110855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14379v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14379v1
|
Can Large Language Models Create New Knowledge for Spatial Reasoning Tasks?
| 2024-05-23T09:54:54 | 2024-05-23T09:54:54 |
Thomas Greatrix, Roger Whitaker, Liam Turner, Walter Colombo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The potential for Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate new information
offers a potential step change for research and innovation. This is challenging
to assert as it can be difficult to determine what an LLM has previously seen
during training, making "newness" difficult to substantiate. In this paper we
observe that LLMs are able to perform sophisticated reasoning on problems with
a spatial dimension, that they are unlikely to have previously directly
encountered. While not perfect, this points to a significant level of
understanding that state-of-the-art LLMs can now achieve, supporting the
proposition that LLMs are able to yield significant emergent properties. In
particular, Claude 3 is found to perform well in this regard.
|
[
-0.5145891308784485,
-0.8920801281929016,
1.5096461772918701,
0.1772312968969345,
0.1680757999420166,
-0.10875509679317474,
-0.4672554135322571,
-0.8612807989120483,
0.09044203162193298,
0.6510610580444336,
-0.1349276453256607,
-0.4289625287055969,
-0.8641528487205505,
-0.03940671309828758,
-0.6060555577278137,
0.24171923100948334,
-0.22828689217567444,
-0.09671510756015778,
-0.16015128791332245,
-0.011701328679919243,
-0.3841884434223175,
-0.5962755680084229,
-0.6957317590713501,
-0.5384540557861328,
0.7605713605880737,
0.42581185698509216,
0.8266435265541077,
0.46755287051200867,
0.4921815097332001,
0.33499741554260254,
-0.33700698614120483,
0.34798455238342285,
-0.3095042109489441,
0.2211233377456665,
-0.23226799070835114,
-0.5714840888977051,
-0.36310166120529175,
-0.019826961681246758,
0.932272732257843,
1.0703433752059937,
0.18292756378650665,
-0.41897016763687134,
-0.12187211960554123,
0.7047373652458191,
-0.2488395869731903,
0.2739676237106323,
-0.957579493522644,
0.10527695715427399,
-0.01535265427082777,
-0.2362053394317627,
-0.34669622778892517,
-0.18393760919570923,
0.3750556409358978,
-0.7395296692848206,
0.03108370117843151,
0.016665715724229813,
0.890548050403595,
-0.053253721445798874,
-0.5353959798812866,
-0.21037708222866058,
-1.1780720949172974,
0.608390212059021,
-0.6272093653678894,
0.4384731650352478,
0.19340810179710388,
0.5964528322219849,
-0.3611879050731659,
-0.564548909664154,
-0.7279748320579529,
-0.16922986507415771,
0.18399931490421295,
-0.29550620913505554,
-0.2152157723903656,
-0.5182319283485413,
0.5197510123252869,
-0.0058367447927594185,
-0.11676961183547974,
0.3696054518222809,
-0.40258553624153137,
0.014048486016690731,
0.6930629014968872,
0.18529494106769562,
0.22475987672805786,
-0.1906033158302307,
-0.2863820493221283,
0.07178019732236862,
-1.013623833656311,
0.062492672353982925,
0.20252566039562225,
0.30025574564933777,
0.00807404424995184,
0.6621890068054199,
-0.12725381553173065,
0.5897289514541626,
-0.22794105112552643,
-0.12681958079338074,
0.22319982945919037,
-0.021004650741815567,
0.047044992446899414,
-0.25136539340019226,
0.607554018497467,
0.13286615908145905,
0.4803053140640259,
0.08920067548751831,
-0.3605283796787262,
-0.3253979980945587,
-0.038520339876413345,
-0.37930968403816223,
-0.4132351279258728,
0.21141092479228973,
-0.15965202450752258,
0.021437006071209908,
0.13718870282173157,
-0.34191736578941345,
-0.7587798833847046,
-0.6396104097366333,
0.23809625208377838,
-0.6188181042671204,
-0.6129410266876221,
0.4250957667827606,
-0.030623193830251694,
0.576964259147644,
0.9625643491744995,
-0.9195946455001831,
0.11477731913328171,
0.9049824476242065,
0.6504822969436646,
-0.12035365402698517,
-0.5342509150505066,
-0.2563799023628235,
0.1749507039785385,
-0.5994791984558105,
1.0578559637069702,
-0.6758112907409668,
-0.1746421456336975,
0.09411198645830154,
0.12026210874319077,
0.09855670481920242,
-0.7392707467079163,
0.1280643492937088,
-0.6839156746864319,
-0.16073256731033325,
-0.6437482833862305,
-0.28786343336105347,
-0.2779388725757599,
0.4598517119884491,
-0.7417932152748108,
0.9774338603019714,
0.2598835825920105,
-0.6263732314109802,
0.49523046612739563,
-0.4350321888923645,
-0.4471484422683716,
0.2747895121574402,
-0.2533145546913147,
-0.16548855602741241,
0.26358962059020996,
0.3792095482349396,
0.4307871460914612,
-0.25541409850120544,
0.22529947757720947,
-0.5963315367698669,
-0.1698971688747406,
0.6322499513626099,
-0.16003192961215973,
0.6136012077331543,
0.2490600198507309,
-0.25939705967903137,
-0.022549010813236237,
-0.6476872563362122,
0.0697278305888176,
0.282611221075058,
-0.4898228645324707,
-0.22307603061199188,
0.13665634393692017,
-0.34733107686042786,
0.24579156935214996,
0.4496234059333801,
-0.609469473361969,
0.3576209247112274,
-0.2543914020061493,
0.4843154549598694,
0.5250317454338074,
-0.05957164242863655,
0.6899204850196838,
-0.17106413841247559,
0.41931939125061035,
0.08669113367795944,
-0.11786425858736038,
-0.06045440956950188,
-0.5930750370025635,
-0.9263091683387756,
-0.21960964798927307,
0.01613033376634121,
0.4239853322505951,
-0.8403810858726501,
0.1059814915060997,
-0.3337060809135437,
-0.4909161329269409,
0.06786920130252838,
0.21964393556118011,
-0.16616463661193848,
0.10421264916658401,
0.030916478484869003,
0.20568598806858063,
-0.7267718315124512,
-0.7373853325843811,
-0.12748482823371887,
0.11867637187242508,
-0.03763357922434807,
0.6121420860290527,
0.7006787657737732,
-0.24161729216575623,
0.842067301273346,
-0.5836271047592163,
0.10951883345842361,
-0.5443475842475891,
0.004848712123930454,
0.20792816579341888,
0.17174804210662842,
0.5799167156219482,
-0.5940876007080078,
-0.2206040918827057,
0.30979466438293457,
-1.063951015472412,
-0.05990856513381004,
0.18932810425758362,
-0.07039880007505417,
0.1004657968878746,
0.7958319187164307,
-0.7843657732009888,
0.008957202546298504,
0.44104671478271484,
-0.28686627745628357,
0.499385803937912,
-0.598054826259613,
-0.028202150017023087,
-0.8082210421562195,
-0.358271986246109,
0.10142534971237183,
-0.09075374901294708,
-0.5424427390098572,
0.035978011786937714,
0.014792157337069511,
-0.22987931966781616,
-0.6107200980186462,
0.7475574612617493,
-0.6641457080841064,
-0.37523046135902405,
-0.3523954153060913,
0.564321756362915,
-0.03676842898130417,
0.10818581283092499,
0.2565535008907318,
0.3149521052837372,
0.7838743925094604,
-0.6905778646469116,
0.4024527966976166,
0.07324426621198654,
-0.8258162140846252,
0.15502022206783295,
-0.5099221467971802,
-0.05550311505794525,
-0.32394710183143616,
0.15694357454776764,
-0.886234700679779,
-0.49066680669784546,
-0.16753210127353668,
-0.3817627429962158,
0.15029318630695343,
-0.1261892318725586,
-0.8855095505714417,
-0.7408020496368408,
0.24384252727031708,
0.3609768748283386,
0.3129173517227173,
-0.6749444007873535,
0.4514455795288086,
0.6235682368278503,
-0.21674102544784546,
0.03443864360451698,
-0.7213664054870605,
0.07180371135473251,
-0.38321197032928467,
-0.7861070036888123,
-0.3398607075214386,
0.26514124870300293,
-0.5349730849266052,
-0.16994331777095795,
0.2681211829185486,
-0.25925445556640625,
0.16730165481567383,
-0.06976411491632462,
0.0730542540550232,
-0.11698839068412781,
0.10654730349779129,
-0.33077406883239746,
-0.14465615153312683,
0.5215809941291809,
-0.6986304521560669,
0.39675450325012207,
-0.14633411169052124,
-0.5327373147010803,
-0.10747230798006058,
0.2912059426307678,
0.9084849953651428,
-0.3609107732772827,
0.6143627762794495,
0.5058730840682983,
-0.5794365406036377,
-0.3191414475440979,
-0.5477213263511658,
-0.08364848047494888,
-0.45264938473701477,
0.5050492882728577,
-0.4281570613384247,
-1.2905561923980713,
0.595720112323761,
-0.3010120391845703,
-0.17941030859947205,
0.336947500705719,
0.5545028448104858,
-0.32127439975738525,
0.9898926615715027,
0.595579206943512,
0.4458363354206085,
0.3786514699459076,
-0.3721264600753784,
0.6204751133918762,
-0.9220632910728455,
-0.6465651988983154,
-0.4911819100379944,
-0.30727648735046387,
-0.5828993320465088,
-0.8128147721290588,
0.6192942261695862,
0.01752636767923832,
-0.2511236071586609,
0.1512649804353714,
-0.1256016194820404,
0.5353642106056213,
0.5136858224868774,
-0.015249869786202908,
0.07054848223924637,
0.1512516885995865,
-0.10387131571769714,
-0.18382570147514343,
-0.8541214466094971,
-0.6226103901863098,
0.9640466570854187,
0.4912753403186798,
0.9124267101287842,
0.4084688127040863,
0.3937143087387085,
-0.18895745277404785,
0.1590770184993744,
-0.6342108249664307,
0.8216384649276733,
0.07304288446903229,
-0.4394058585166931,
-0.5350980758666992,
-0.5430870652198792,
-1.2784298658370972,
0.31078943610191345,
-0.4759361743927002,
-0.8705025911331177,
0.08226797729730606,
0.011440522037446499,
-0.2650185525417328,
0.7141734957695007,
-0.5969642400741577,
0.5015614628791809,
-0.559510350227356,
-0.49874061346054077,
-0.02812741883099079,
-0.21545489132404327,
0.5267284512519836,
-0.2408071756362915,
0.4167170524597168,
-0.4004472494125366,
0.17536090314388275,
0.5097905397415161,
-0.24965578317642212,
0.7016845941543579,
-0.3343248963356018,
-0.6856346130371094,
0.608343243598938,
0.460110604763031,
0.5044042468070984,
0.14867421984672546,
0.14116138219833374,
0.057066407054662704,
-0.26443764567375183,
-0.3690773844718933,
-0.9037553071975708,
0.9437872171401978,
-0.7616466879844666,
-0.794186532497406,
-0.2080746591091156,
-1.0124592781066895,
-0.3247681260108948,
0.2051977515220642,
0.009790077805519104,
0.37262779474258423,
0.09737611562013626,
0.1364767998456955,
1.1043081283569336,
-0.40798935294151306,
0.310689777135849,
0.8157563805580139,
-0.5186419486999512,
-0.12638111412525177,
0.7319468259811401,
0.2054653763771057,
0.07142225652933121,
0.6242409348487854,
0.19436076283454895,
-0.4522927701473236,
-0.7407503128051758,
0.07601211965084076,
0.36625149846076965,
-0.717286229133606,
0.06722883880138397,
-0.6021946668624878,
-0.3574886918067932,
-0.18655088543891907,
-0.27729398012161255,
-0.36560800671577454,
-0.6255773305892944,
0.12801869213581085,
-0.1311764121055603,
0.1886855661869049,
1.364400029182434,
-0.1777370423078537,
0.011852063238620758,
-0.8539636731147766,
-0.11256382614374161,
0.4334448575973511,
0.17202028632164001,
0.007293659262359142,
-0.5647815465927124,
-0.45591995120048523,
0.01651124283671379,
-0.19637447595596313,
-0.7063133120536804,
0.35439613461494446,
-0.5273737907409668,
0.606777012348175,
0.4961321949958801,
-0.3648569583892822,
0.2871633470058441,
-0.6847060322761536,
0.7976659536361694,
0.11057234555482864,
-0.7044157385826111,
0.668415367603302,
-0.8797367215156555,
0.5070616602897644,
-0.15965880453586578,
0.3876328468322754,
-0.037595249712467194,
-0.41246235370635986,
-0.6110063195228577,
-0.7444664239883423,
0.21216784417629242,
-0.05287930369377136,
0.13532216846942902,
-0.1220012977719307,
0.4482477903366089,
-0.07405436038970947,
0.10915733128786087,
-0.9057014584541321,
0.140506312251091,
0.2531246840953827,
0.40072521567344666,
-0.12874117493629456,
-0.6462174654006958,
-0.12899045646190643,
-0.621674656867981,
0.4084491729736328,
0.06211608275771141,
0.3309426009654999,
0.1599622219800949,
0.21579721570014954,
0.03097211755812168,
0.4761369228363037,
0.7210757732391357,
1.0160071849822998,
0.1318310648202896,
0.5565245151519775,
0.36910176277160645,
0.057788148522377014,
0.23148483037948608,
-0.038700610399246216,
-0.07882426679134369,
-0.25217965245246887,
0.6867374181747437,
0.6836730241775513,
0.3188471794128418,
-0.6842098236083984,
0.5450962781906128,
0.22142013907432556,
-0.8262140154838562,
-0.5458277463912964,
0.016709519550204277,
0.2604493498802185,
0.5998967289924622,
0.13665063679218292,
0.021019430831074715,
-0.29558879137039185,
-0.5340794324874878,
-0.0012964700581505895,
0.486792653799057,
-0.1795019656419754,
-0.34257495403289795,
0.6439608931541443,
0.1744544953107834,
-0.07403523474931717,
0.6683343052864075,
-0.445909321308136,
-0.5735079646110535,
0.41919684410095215,
0.6063174605369568,
0.5054106116294861,
-0.028586452826857567,
0.07917873561382294,
0.5008383989334106,
0.5392225980758667,
0.022343311458826065,
0.4805515706539154,
0.2131119668483734,
-1.3291465044021606,
-0.6221643686294556,
-0.45382383465766907,
-0.37695708870887756,
0.36269769072532654,
-0.3768678605556488,
0.08044788241386414,
-0.5374745726585388,
-0.04696626216173172,
-0.21865923702716827,
-0.16322273015975952,
-0.627815306186676,
-0.027333049103617668,
0.3235819935798645,
0.9834063053131104,
-0.9492811560630798,
0.7786504626274109,
1.0073201656341553,
0.03511175885796547,
-0.9740018844604492,
-0.21354658901691437,
-0.13613800704479218,
-0.8063227534294128,
1.0223811864852905,
-0.041715629398822784,
-0.03184840828180313,
-0.31304797530174255,
-0.786785900592804,
-1.2404366731643677,
0.9672796130180359,
0.557102620601654,
-0.6932662129402161,
-0.07911785691976547,
0.32539841532707214,
0.5808534026145935,
-0.4826933741569519,
-0.06390659511089325,
0.5579465627670288,
0.777323842048645,
0.24832235276699066,
-0.757858157157898,
-0.07037001103162766,
-0.11791398376226425,
0.1114039272069931,
0.302448034286499,
-0.48451241850852966,
1.123253345489502,
-0.8286315202713013,
-0.06390076875686646,
-0.09514354914426804,
0.7180495858192444,
0.4062318503856659,
0.006393323186784983,
0.44709452986717224,
0.7212095260620117,
1.056877613067627,
-0.43156135082244873,
1.2076679468154907,
-0.28830233216285706,
0.15236836671829224,
1.1206008195877075,
-0.6099368333816528,
0.9875315427780151,
0.3032926023006439,
-0.09591664373874664,
0.7392867803573608,
0.4019208550453186,
-0.011123104952275753,
0.15097491443157196,
0.38150423765182495,
-0.3682323396205902,
-0.7058206796646118,
0.17314109206199646,
-0.13088856637477875,
0.7077597975730896,
0.6040859818458557,
-0.1312597095966339,
-0.25804248452186584,
0.019535589963197708,
0.10091114789247513,
0.27814725041389465,
-0.26183438301086426,
0.5612444281578064,
0.17891675233840942,
-0.6738860011100769,
0.5011036992073059,
-0.07926888763904572,
0.008449344895780087,
-0.5934617519378662,
-0.12467511743307114,
-0.014851328916847706,
0.2674541175365448,
-0.1935783475637436,
-1.21905517578125,
0.22780059278011322,
-0.2707699239253998,
-0.30012431740760803,
-0.4310036897659302,
0.664795458316803,
-0.33906039595603943,
-0.45983320474624634,
0.3646772801876068,
0.8909748196601868,
0.2780167758464813,
-0.04258041828870773,
-0.22778339684009552,
0.3352307379245758,
-0.04145747795701027,
0.029668744653463364,
0.1983586698770523,
1.2397364377975464,
-0.06098173186182976,
1.009796380996704,
0.4922255575656891,
0.41214942932128906,
0.0771147683262825,
0.08575969934463501,
0.831716001033783,
-0.8084686994552612,
-0.31939393281936646,
-0.5982775688171387,
0.19030562043190002,
-0.04532575234770775,
0.03817262127995491,
0.8839408755302429,
0.588485062122345,
0.7378507256507874,
-0.061555832624435425,
0.9948233366012573,
0.10131675004959106,
0.46900105476379395,
-0.8939600586891174,
0.4024048447608948,
-0.3459559977054596,
0.7014837861061096,
-0.11150352656841278,
-0.982253909111023,
-0.21891707181930542,
0.7772195339202881,
-0.7592010498046875,
0.12260796874761581,
1.108959674835205,
0.7252946496009827,
-0.01265503279864788,
-0.053176771849393845,
0.5293706655502319,
0.6512026786804199,
0.5788993835449219,
0.9573136568069458,
1.391086220741272,
0.050458602607250214,
0.41197669506073,
0.1630389243364334,
-0.20980559289455414,
0.19097217917442322,
-0.8612637519836426,
-0.9868634343147278,
-0.6349193453788757,
-0.08861727267503738,
-0.28859850764274597,
-0.20083440840244293,
0.414472758769989,
0.8455688953399658,
-0.500565767288208,
-0.12456117570400238,
-0.3351448178291321,
0.14484021067619324,
0.14056351780891418,
-0.25336191058158875,
0.06708753108978271,
-0.2852324843406677,
-0.7270843982696533,
0.5965940952301025,
0.34420785307884216,
0.3961322009563446,
-0.4899495542049408,
-0.10311679542064667,
-0.020955350250005722,
0.03987684100866318,
0.9579023718833923,
0.1828387975692749,
-0.7347093224525452,
-0.5876910090446472,
-0.19284017384052277,
0.010978443548083305,
-0.006473137065768242,
1.0640512704849243,
-0.7204576134681702,
0.14665868878364563,
0.38587692379951477,
0.6125451922416687,
0.6868225932121277,
-0.4714456796646118,
0.7083041071891785,
-0.5254403352737427,
0.22015711665153503,
-0.012780020013451576,
0.9438586831092834,
0.6211462616920471,
-0.12596043944358826,
0.3144174814224243,
0.24394463002681732,
-0.622374415397644,
-0.37323224544525146,
0.6236099600791931,
-0.7620894908905029,
-0.3045986592769623,
1.6382203102111816,
0.08924597501754761,
-0.24338343739509583,
-0.005715376231819391,
-0.18800242245197296,
-0.3366333842277527,
-0.03183521330356598,
0.5873488187789917,
0.8493462204933167,
-0.30376750230789185,
-0.37559133768081665,
-0.7363916039466858,
0.20213523507118225,
0.2374182939529419,
-0.949237585067749,
0.16514404118061066,
0.5833886861801147,
0.433956116437912,
0.26790109276771545,
0.7372880578041077,
-0.19680967926979065,
0.06478476524353027,
-0.060685060918331146,
-0.20008306205272675,
-0.09217753261327744,
-0.7095333933830261,
-0.027496563270688057,
0.23333539068698883,
0.4964672923088074,
0.41676104068756104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14908v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14908v1
|
Data Mixing Made Efficient: A Bivariate Scaling Law for Language Model Pretraining
| 2024-05-23T09:44:02 | 2024-05-23T09:44:02 |
Ce Ge, Zhijian Ma, Daoyuan Chen, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models exhibit exceptional generalization capabilities,
primarily attributed to the utilization of diversely sourced data. However,
conventional practices in integrating this diverse data heavily rely on
heuristic schemes, lacking theoretical guidance. This research tackles these
limitations by investigating strategies based on low-cost proxies for data
mixtures, with the aim of streamlining data curation to enhance training
efficiency. Specifically, we propose a unified scaling law, termed BiMix, which
accurately models the bivariate scaling behaviors of both data quantity and
mixing proportions. We conduct systematic experiments and provide empirical
evidence for the predictive power and fundamental principles of BiMix. Notably,
our findings reveal that entropy-driven training-free data mixtures can achieve
comparable or even better performance than more resource-intensive methods. We
hope that our quantitative insights can shed light on further judicious
research and development in cost-effective language modeling.
|
[
-0.23032280802726746,
-0.38138777017593384,
0.3121444880962372,
0.6225066184997559,
-0.2634373903274536,
0.11553000658750534,
-0.3274378478527069,
-0.20121072232723236,
-0.1946103423833847,
0.5124735236167908,
-0.1852561980485916,
-0.08384163677692413,
-0.665147602558136,
-0.3179470896720886,
-0.46037089824676514,
0.8550123572349548,
-0.01300279051065445,
0.3445603549480438,
-0.2656477093696594,
-0.20657162368297577,
-0.30475687980651855,
-0.5684837102890015,
-0.11508078128099442,
-0.5094912052154541,
0.6444915533065796,
0.5137283802032471,
0.9456458687782288,
1.0086857080459595,
0.3441925048828125,
0.220379039645195,
0.0028237346559762955,
-0.08677773177623749,
-0.6961321234703064,
0.042891230434179306,
-0.16862544417381287,
-0.7297480702400208,
-0.3571496605873108,
0.30824458599090576,
0.7626398205757141,
1.4018564224243164,
-0.525999128818512,
0.0946139246225357,
0.36452817916870117,
0.6204732060432434,
-1.0191526412963867,
0.0025381590239703655,
-0.6421807408332825,
-0.04866532236337662,
-0.3491586744785309,
-0.021015679463744164,
-0.4032863676548004,
-0.19694948196411133,
-0.11141548305749893,
-0.6154260039329529,
0.24404895305633545,
0.20675882697105408,
0.6946685314178467,
0.11686117947101593,
-0.2667938470840454,
-0.07162033021450043,
-1.0255900621414185,
0.959639310836792,
-0.6614111661911011,
0.6571019291877747,
0.45486980676651,
0.25418516993522644,
-0.03199475258588791,
-0.6483972668647766,
-0.6337825059890747,
0.1909857541322708,
0.09139720350503922,
-0.10388194024562836,
-0.40539830923080444,
-0.046000588685274124,
0.08481603860855103,
0.5016599297523499,
-0.5901267528533936,
0.1513538807630539,
-0.4245974123477936,
0.027572399005293846,
0.41382163763046265,
0.2362496703863144,
0.3538202941417694,
0.6270648241043091,
0.009212501347064972,
-0.3718482255935669,
-0.5529177188873291,
-0.06403835117816925,
0.6208356618881226,
0.7237038612365723,
-0.3704393208026886,
0.6329609155654907,
-0.21488724648952484,
0.4636210799217224,
-0.017439357936382294,
0.10121932625770569,
0.22554200887680054,
-0.79410320520401,
-0.23415809869766235,
-0.20102371275424957,
0.6879380941390991,
0.23246662318706512,
0.36630621552467346,
-0.5740790963172913,
-0.2488962560892105,
0.013726047240197659,
0.23985810577869415,
-1.0803098678588867,
-0.4739743173122406,
0.053521204739809036,
-0.38341420888900757,
-0.16732802987098694,
-0.17005474865436554,
-0.7622447609901428,
-0.2685702443122864,
-0.6788144707679749,
0.4218365252017975,
-0.31079399585723877,
-0.5246087312698364,
0.35340768098831177,
-0.1659686118364334,
0.06958307325839996,
0.070454902946949,
-1.2255662679672241,
0.42936474084854126,
0.744179368019104,
0.7239252924919128,
0.1342313289642334,
-0.24137842655181885,
-0.7821147441864014,
-0.08714011311531067,
-0.5320675373077393,
0.5122354030609131,
-0.6926699280738831,
-0.5368332266807556,
-0.10585858672857285,
-0.4169800877571106,
0.08445359021425247,
-0.7939764261245728,
-0.03541295975446701,
-0.4170798659324646,
0.07491717487573624,
-0.2661270201206207,
-0.3908269703388214,
0.23590342700481415,
-0.25073176622390747,
-0.6150602102279663,
1.031362771987915,
0.5121234059333801,
-0.7761955261230469,
0.7872748970985413,
-0.2045755535364151,
-0.5373753905296326,
0.07513011246919632,
-0.014688557013869286,
-0.45167139172554016,
0.28901949524879456,
-0.07853654026985168,
0.3091960847377777,
-0.7181804180145264,
0.2900902330875397,
-0.6311296820640564,
-0.2138632833957672,
-0.010807116515934467,
-0.25644737482070923,
0.9985285401344299,
0.5217316746711731,
-0.12853817641735077,
-0.0912969633936882,
-0.8753595948219299,
-0.01263196300715208,
-0.02217201143503189,
-0.4834991991519928,
-0.7250741124153137,
-0.09101174026727676,
0.09233325719833374,
-0.010344302281737328,
-0.06453125178813934,
-0.3323659598827362,
0.14143775403499603,
-0.09360736608505249,
-0.0905168429017067,
0.3978271186351776,
-0.3919430375099182,
1.0446335077285767,
-0.11743175238370895,
0.32013753056526184,
0.22341233491897583,
0.2535303831100464,
0.19573155045509338,
-0.35535889863967896,
-0.6335915923118591,
-0.5325860381126404,
0.5070251822471619,
0.5398203730583191,
-0.5704254508018494,
0.4255458116531372,
-0.28007158637046814,
-0.6828580498695374,
-0.6105454564094543,
0.7192510962486267,
0.3583724796772003,
0.24270550906658173,
0.4515601396560669,
-0.29620590806007385,
-0.640802264213562,
-0.8094574213027954,
-0.37054288387298584,
-0.007957328110933304,
-0.3836696147918701,
-0.18537992238998413,
0.15332238376140594,
-0.3135206401348114,
0.9238582849502563,
-0.10609353333711624,
0.34490302205085754,
-0.36217930912971497,
0.6959378123283386,
0.1901501715183258,
0.7372455596923828,
0.6649250984191895,
-0.5674132704734802,
-0.7298393249511719,
0.05027637258172035,
-0.5764424800872803,
-0.29140934348106384,
0.03450074419379234,
-0.3255990147590637,
-0.33170026540756226,
0.37949180603027344,
-0.23425506055355072,
0.30347657203674316,
0.5184900164604187,
-0.25034958124160767,
0.2662672996520996,
-0.494782418012619,
-0.2139178067445755,
-0.8573575019836426,
-0.04070441052317619,
0.06882026791572571,
-0.10470642894506454,
-1.0237246751785278,
-0.07981986552476883,
0.38154834508895874,
0.12882691621780396,
-0.2132118046283722,
0.30439290404319763,
-0.5318241715431213,
0.11337921768426895,
-0.37149491906166077,
-0.3994843065738678,
-0.06641938537359238,
0.3251948058605194,
-0.15365871787071228,
0.7790569067001343,
0.688818097114563,
-0.7538424730300903,
0.16908130049705505,
-0.2648636996746063,
-0.2982410490512848,
0.6415619254112244,
-0.6116529107093811,
-0.09807779639959335,
-0.20955941081047058,
-0.05662129446864128,
-0.9083025455474854,
0.10855799168348312,
-0.13141001760959625,
-0.1325799971818924,
0.42844223976135254,
-0.21829460561275482,
-0.8076680302619934,
-0.046697501093149185,
-0.17725200951099396,
0.5407808423042297,
0.6439697742462158,
-0.5995672941207886,
0.6689754724502563,
0.3578987717628479,
-0.21176151931285858,
-0.3513639569282532,
-0.7620226144790649,
-0.06041381508111954,
-0.2865169942378998,
-0.4665782153606415,
0.06634832173585892,
-0.36700916290283203,
-0.5419238805770874,
-0.2260971963405609,
-0.05556277558207512,
-0.2517279386520386,
0.21868854761123657,
-0.059002507477998734,
0.45915424823760986,
-0.21613286435604095,
-0.19973470270633698,
-0.01078890822827816,
0.11813660711050034,
0.08231009542942047,
-0.32032015919685364,
0.6180992126464844,
0.15537627041339874,
0.030128614977002144,
-0.17854449152946472,
0.5620971918106079,
0.5867890119552612,
-0.032015129923820496,
0.8486686944961548,
0.5978648066520691,
-0.2759283781051636,
-0.15836618840694427,
-0.35770171880722046,
-0.045821838080883026,
-0.44233939051628113,
0.2029394507408142,
-0.2039819359779358,
-0.546306848526001,
0.505247175693512,
0.0008636731072328985,
0.31585273146629333,
0.01799807883799076,
0.6567348837852478,
-0.07285867631435394,
1.216711163520813,
0.6888574361801147,
-0.16504612565040588,
0.6638076305389404,
-0.15411385893821716,
0.32663533091545105,
-0.4167860150337219,
-0.014271927997469902,
-0.8163851499557495,
-0.3519379794597626,
-0.7471105456352234,
-0.6727818250656128,
0.08284308761358261,
0.3153139650821686,
-0.383543998003006,
0.22064119577407837,
0.026549018919467926,
0.5572643280029297,
0.7946364879608154,
-0.24166657030582428,
0.07594411820173264,
0.26047971844673157,
-0.25424543023109436,
0.12002125382423401,
-0.7741362452507019,
-0.105058953166008,
1.4594337940216064,
0.1490074098110199,
1.089864730834961,
0.10281878709793091,
0.5419689416885376,
-0.021474724635481834,
0.5345129370689392,
-0.4242371618747711,
0.18603341281414032,
-0.23026277124881744,
-0.6083836555480957,
-0.30250075459480286,
-0.9199894666671753,
-0.9882199168205261,
0.511242687702179,
-0.45768263936042786,
-0.5054818391799927,
0.5811022520065308,
0.2269476354122162,
-0.22134822607040405,
0.42071494460105896,
-0.8793216347694397,
0.48960062861442566,
-0.22690746188163757,
-0.6842043995857239,
-0.16451771557331085,
-0.6414811015129089,
0.18664687871932983,
-0.2848207354545593,
0.49207237362861633,
-0.037950482219457626,
0.08648175001144409,
0.6533281207084656,
-0.8523574471473694,
0.6064929962158203,
-0.29203134775161743,
-0.08275428414344788,
0.14161725342273712,
0.004592066630721092,
0.3950915038585663,
-0.24495342373847961,
0.18701037764549255,
0.24630634486675262,
-0.02896040678024292,
-0.8951101899147034,
-0.640960693359375,
0.229941263794899,
-0.9160958528518677,
-0.10004712641239166,
0.07663983851671219,
-0.8202576637268066,
-0.6483611464500427,
0.14052940905094147,
0.3510417342185974,
0.15709292888641357,
0.16274911165237427,
0.5758384466171265,
0.7462942600250244,
0.12290582805871964,
0.17048248648643494,
0.607184112071991,
-0.3010025918483734,
-0.4575064480304718,
1.0872094631195068,
0.22277359664440155,
0.36098843812942505,
0.32679203152656555,
0.3675082325935364,
-0.056007035076618195,
-0.4687395989894867,
-0.23849910497665405,
0.23365704715251923,
-0.2634468078613281,
-0.010457088239490986,
-0.5860714912414551,
0.10170049220323563,
-0.636675238609314,
-0.08855874091386795,
-0.6883763670921326,
-0.32002148032188416,
-0.054037220776081085,
-0.08301245421171188,
-0.016726674512028694,
0.34039968252182007,
-0.4269990026950836,
0.6599088311195374,
-0.6182597279548645,
0.20361122488975525,
0.5355746746063232,
0.5195130109786987,
-0.07604105770587921,
-0.37172314524650574,
-0.5261648893356323,
0.24993805587291718,
-0.09043259918689728,
-0.4488065838813782,
0.26345348358154297,
0.03764130547642708,
0.7085012793540955,
0.5777454972267151,
-0.12009509652853012,
0.5947669744491577,
-0.3539997637271881,
0.3892527222633362,
0.6670817732810974,
-0.8349456787109375,
0.1630505919456482,
-0.19840887188911438,
0.15048867464065552,
0.612339198589325,
0.28779399394989014,
-0.3736409842967987,
-0.4800148904323578,
-0.4379581809043884,
-1.0108217000961304,
0.5686621069908142,
0.3203808665275574,
0.2919345200061798,
0.4578951597213745,
0.20886409282684326,
0.25678643584251404,
0.2957088351249695,
-0.4792156219482422,
-0.31341108679771423,
-0.35920450091362,
-0.36784693598747253,
-0.3037374019622803,
-0.12038564682006836,
-0.1020580306649208,
-0.59676593542099,
0.48691168427467346,
0.10453963279724121,
-0.040489476174116135,
-0.4837809205055237,
-0.12652550637722015,
-0.12378809601068497,
0.24626515805721283,
0.39321714639663696,
0.4488846957683563,
-0.2778822183609009,
0.3337024748325348,
-0.12996205687522888,
-0.679085373878479,
0.31551483273506165,
0.16450637578964233,
-0.09158738702535629,
-0.1369047611951828,
0.1770879030227661,
0.8538401126861572,
0.1463100165128708,
-0.6624355912208557,
0.35756129026412964,
-0.2561972439289093,
-0.5753726363182068,
0.3607482612133026,
0.267151802778244,
0.21675047278404236,
0.28101304173469543,
0.2321515828371048,
-0.10418395698070526,
0.10616403818130493,
-0.635250985622406,
0.0313367061316967,
0.31253769993782043,
-0.065984807908535,
-0.4626348614692688,
0.7661639451980591,
0.0035368080716580153,
0.040931664407253265,
0.7829435467720032,
-0.06471935659646988,
0.02451796643435955,
0.27422329783439636,
0.45128345489501953,
0.5205297470092773,
-0.5195854306221008,
0.0165414996445179,
0.09890387207269669,
0.3534519076347351,
-0.3013971447944641,
0.373928964138031,
-0.334359347820282,
-0.8026813864707947,
-0.1109318807721138,
-0.5763799548149109,
-0.4883054792881012,
0.05647102743387222,
-0.6720084547996521,
0.1193416565656662,
-0.5838526487350464,
-0.057083144783973694,
0.10095347464084625,
-0.10114786773920059,
-1.0037877559661865,
0.2605879604816437,
0.2866987884044647,
0.7565061450004578,
-0.9951606392860413,
0.7933021783828735,
0.5445155501365662,
-0.4213293790817261,
-0.9081006646156311,
-0.1944810450077057,
-0.01199917308986187,
-0.7061631083488464,
0.5145267248153687,
-0.19414830207824707,
0.08481418341398239,
-0.2097897082567215,
-0.7290291786193848,
-0.7275673151016235,
0.6766483187675476,
0.6839852929115295,
-0.5722795724868774,
-0.11738954484462738,
0.5548899173736572,
0.41530418395996094,
-0.4538726806640625,
0.08856988698244095,
0.7029205560684204,
0.4874628484249115,
0.30169424414634705,
-0.6444311141967773,
-0.2488100826740265,
-0.5668209195137024,
0.047561489045619965,
0.07555043697357178,
-0.21803870797157288,
1.147042155265808,
0.01582922786474228,
-0.18586143851280212,
-0.3066876530647278,
0.7178378105163574,
0.032686516642570496,
0.42184096574783325,
0.6561287641525269,
0.7237086296081543,
0.9780152440071106,
0.11540039628744125,
1.0296862125396729,
-0.4325126111507416,
0.16920754313468933,
1.2463698387145996,
-0.5314165353775024,
0.6156802773475647,
0.5210465788841248,
-0.5527520179748535,
0.38693416118621826,
0.5186262726783752,
0.2355189174413681,
0.6752524971961975,
0.29825401306152344,
-0.3037041127681732,
-0.41320541501045227,
0.04519585147500038,
-0.14199165999889374,
0.2428014725446701,
0.17182783782482147,
-0.1976144015789032,
-0.30764803290367126,
0.05477891489863396,
0.23534663021564484,
-0.09031584858894348,
-0.17734411358833313,
0.8094469308853149,
-0.18579348921775818,
-0.45673805475234985,
0.5869507193565369,
-0.15096978843212128,
0.6061354279518127,
-0.6021133065223694,
0.37898337841033936,
-0.5012484788894653,
0.08510850369930267,
0.08986913412809372,
-0.49164897203445435,
0.17622193694114685,
0.05674658343195915,
-0.31078413128852844,
-0.2677077353000641,
0.22373858094215393,
-0.7401891946792603,
-0.5358227491378784,
0.3200649321079254,
0.6133537292480469,
0.062402743846178055,
-0.11689762771129608,
-0.28845903277397156,
-0.0680151879787445,
-0.19686128199100494,
-0.08551161736249924,
0.6481070518493652,
0.589146077632904,
0.10095938295125961,
0.3761545717716217,
0.7051162123680115,
0.41222909092903137,
0.3148547112941742,
0.20315192639827728,
0.9236076474189758,
-0.23608694970607758,
-0.6489304304122925,
-0.6481452584266663,
0.5443468689918518,
-0.19088473916053772,
0.05433026701211929,
0.470197468996048,
0.9182342290878296,
0.8052173852920532,
0.24399155378341675,
0.9467741847038269,
0.38355377316474915,
0.41176676750183105,
-0.22852468490600586,
0.5869157910346985,
-0.7094323635101318,
0.11603210121393204,
-0.013340947218239307,
-0.9648545384407043,
-0.2892075479030609,
0.3072873651981354,
-0.15680909156799316,
0.16073481738567352,
0.34678134322166443,
0.8442211747169495,
-0.42678314447402954,
0.16250298917293549,
0.4402901828289032,
0.023447105661034584,
0.2399200201034546,
0.09887555241584778,
0.3732006847858429,
-0.04502243176102638,
0.4124644696712494,
-0.39388900995254517,
-0.5309571027755737,
-0.4154393970966339,
-0.5173601508140564,
-0.6976928114891052,
-0.5920388698577881,
-0.25019514560699463,
-0.19164708256721497,
-0.16463440656661987,
0.8766266703605652,
1.0750648975372314,
-0.6832794547080994,
-0.57942134141922,
-0.26807767152786255,
-0.09109482914209366,
-0.3573535978794098,
-0.16913263499736786,
-0.17500443756580353,
-0.5896235108375549,
-0.6644425392150879,
0.19986535608768463,
0.3048524558544159,
0.16752827167510986,
-0.1992948204278946,
-0.20694229006767273,
-0.1149376928806305,
0.6772095561027527,
0.5813782215118408,
0.2477826476097107,
-0.07764074951410294,
0.16388572752475739,
-0.26972365379333496,
-0.3472309410572052,
0.08641719073057175,
1.2425838708877563,
-0.2927262485027313,
0.6998759508132935,
0.7013499140739441,
0.6908320188522339,
0.3476582169532776,
-0.2022559493780136,
0.7539463043212891,
-0.8075206875801086,
0.16317491233348846,
-0.05685477331280708,
0.4545169174671173,
0.36971160769462585,
-0.19910980761051178,
0.47491127252578735,
0.33618953824043274,
-0.3222828209400177,
-0.9299516081809998,
-0.10207563638687134,
-0.8528584241867065,
-0.2982475757598877,
0.97900390625,
-0.04758477956056595,
-0.23494896292686462,
-0.13529454171657562,
0.20949582755565643,
0.48582786321640015,
-0.20548781752586365,
0.5668704509735107,
0.7130753993988037,
-0.015807192772626877,
-0.11119561642408371,
-0.5268303155899048,
0.17473547160625458,
0.5408656001091003,
-0.790789008140564,
0.5134186744689941,
0.4046838581562042,
0.3458992540836334,
-0.00443284772336483,
0.4090633988380432,
-0.01394796371459961,
0.06153016537427902,
0.36822137236595154,
0.19811616837978363,
0.2656782865524292,
-0.2113289088010788,
-0.16070568561553955,
0.07972549647092819,
-0.0704551637172699,
0.04300732910633087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14366v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14366v1
|
MiniCache: KV Cache Compression in Depth Dimension for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T09:43:52 | 2024-05-23T09:43:52 |
Akide Liu, Jing Liu, Zizheng Pan, Yefei He, Gholamreza Haffari, Bohan Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A critical approach for efficiently deploying computationally demanding large
language models (LLMs) is Key-Value (KV) caching. The KV cache stores key-value
states of previously generated tokens, significantly reducing the need for
repetitive computations and thereby lowering latency in autoregressive
generation. However, the size of the KV cache grows linearly with sequence
length, posing challenges for applications requiring long context input and
extensive sequence generation. In this paper, we present a simple yet effective
approach, called MiniCache, to compress the KV cache across layers from a novel
depth perspective, significantly reducing the memory footprint for LLM
inference. Our approach is based on the observation that KV cache states
exhibit high similarity between the adjacent layers in the middle-to-deep
portion of LLMs. To facilitate merging, we propose disentangling the states
into the magnitude and direction components, interpolating the directions of
the state vectors while preserving their lengths unchanged. Furthermore, we
introduce a token retention strategy to keep highly distinct state pairs
unmerged, thus preserving the information with minimal additional storage
overhead. Our MiniCache is training-free and general, complementing existing KV
cache compression strategies, such as quantization and sparsity. We conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of MiniCache utilizing various models including
LLaMA-2, LLaMA-3, Phi-3, Mistral, and Mixtral across multiple benchmarks,
demonstrating its exceptional performance in achieving superior compression
ratios and high throughput. On the ShareGPT dataset, LLaMA-2-7B with 4-bit
MiniCache achieves a remarkable compression ratio of up to 5.02x, enhances
inference throughput by approximately 5x, and reduces the memory footprint by
41% compared to the FP16 full cache baseline, all while maintaining
near-lossless performance.
|
[
-0.3673633337020874,
-0.4996323883533478,
0.4569273293018341,
0.09601026773452759,
-0.4948064982891083,
0.2097175270318985,
-0.22920076549053192,
-0.46970829367637634,
0.40862199664115906,
0.19725582003593445,
-0.5566678047180176,
-0.5684398412704468,
-0.5746630430221558,
-0.38293060660362244,
-0.5012457966804504,
0.37813621759414673,
0.1294066309928894,
-0.30810239911079407,
-0.2612927258014679,
0.07214589416980743,
-0.38854342699050903,
-0.28676608204841614,
-0.6623220443725586,
-0.16592937707901,
0.3757144510746002,
0.6503015756607056,
0.5490531921386719,
0.7705972790718079,
0.15155483782291412,
0.3022574484348297,
-0.2172105461359024,
0.3024774491786957,
-0.6490261554718018,
0.3064466416835785,
0.2317420393228531,
-0.41927582025527954,
-0.36613860726356506,
-0.3019472658634186,
0.5167552828788757,
0.4072447121143341,
-0.2957846224308014,
0.16694122552871704,
-0.010106513276696205,
0.652873158454895,
-0.9242711663246155,
0.3010384440422058,
-0.6224746108055115,
0.01779840514063835,
-0.19019266963005066,
0.04214779660105705,
-0.3910072445869446,
-0.26078784465789795,
0.005775631871074438,
-0.35031241178512573,
0.36936476826667786,
-0.13323432207107544,
0.6473734974861145,
0.5438564419746399,
-0.3110538721084595,
0.003407132113352418,
-0.6166130900382996,
0.5896210670471191,
-0.6740166544914246,
0.3289789855480194,
0.2784632444381714,
0.32693955302238464,
-0.15653403103351593,
-0.8110995888710022,
-0.8061130046844482,
0.057157497853040695,
0.02180812507867813,
0.01477562915533781,
-0.08145426213741302,
0.09090191125869751,
0.109909288585186,
0.7187800407409668,
-0.4566918909549713,
0.37819093465805054,
-0.19661659002304077,
-0.4261731803417206,
0.3278040885925293,
0.40598177909851074,
0.21660472452640533,
-0.014048700220882893,
-0.17503958940505981,
-0.6066362261772156,
-1.121512770652771,
0.2671433985233307,
0.35056960582733154,
0.4252927303314209,
-0.17421133816242218,
0.24262069165706635,
-0.46598467230796814,
0.3219394087791443,
-0.18769106268882751,
-0.17441105842590332,
-0.10052242130041122,
-0.4607900381088257,
-0.2712329626083374,
0.19236253201961517,
0.5965874195098877,
0.1604369431734085,
-0.2533283531665802,
0.055244721472263336,
0.006842671427875757,
0.2800323963165283,
0.06857259571552277,
-1.1802101135253906,
-0.5805176496505737,
0.08829814940690994,
-0.4065413177013397,
-0.46251216530799866,
-0.12029444426298141,
-0.9442459940910339,
-0.43089473247528076,
-0.1280074119567871,
0.2487633228302002,
0.03977047652006149,
-0.053364597260951996,
0.27715951204299927,
0.20438942313194275,
0.22795264422893524,
0.4190615713596344,
-0.9656374454498291,
0.6636099815368652,
0.5158724784851074,
1.0040411949157715,
-0.13484741747379303,
0.08584563434123993,
-0.5352027416229248,
0.10972011089324951,
-0.17910926043987274,
0.5462040901184082,
-0.39911431074142456,
-0.5864818096160889,
-0.023471422493457794,
-0.10790105164051056,
0.49262699484825134,
-0.4794147312641144,
0.313336044549942,
-0.6491305828094482,
-0.4554803967475891,
-0.6873832941055298,
-0.23147551715373993,
0.08367467671632767,
0.11066389083862305,
-1.0360510349273682,
1.2486162185668945,
-0.1988467276096344,
-0.5524743795394897,
0.24645143747329712,
-0.16086366772651672,
-0.41033199429512024,
-0.20708055794239044,
-0.24860690534114838,
-0.3584407567977905,
0.36806583404541016,
0.49889469146728516,
0.25650110840797424,
-0.6193510890007019,
-0.23551952838897705,
-0.279506117105484,
-0.41735461354255676,
-0.18473859131336212,
-0.3377537727355957,
0.6052118539810181,
0.020946349948644638,
-0.27226144075393677,
-0.12046795338392258,
-0.5630026459693909,
0.0488351434469223,
0.17071622610092163,
-0.49790847301483154,
-0.29827243089675903,
-0.1540616899728775,
-0.17207881808280945,
0.43920332193374634,
0.33310505747795105,
-0.56031334400177,
0.6026747822761536,
-0.40284186601638794,
0.47111889719963074,
0.8018789291381836,
-0.0432320237159729,
0.6116568446159363,
0.040122244507074356,
0.33760887384414673,
0.30867698788642883,
0.14461030066013336,
-0.03537363559007645,
-0.26700374484062195,
-1.2012338638305664,
-0.37607643008232117,
0.481792688369751,
0.29797226190567017,
-0.6538020968437195,
0.22596469521522522,
-0.7019326686859131,
-0.5699111819267273,
-0.7564840316772461,
0.1594148576259613,
0.36741119623184204,
0.4166581928730011,
0.40594103932380676,
-0.4180043041706085,
-0.3535974323749542,
-1.0139455795288086,
0.10062314569950104,
-0.22116659581661224,
0.18880437314510345,
0.34856128692626953,
0.3537156283855438,
-0.15763846039772034,
0.8532285690307617,
-0.5580999851226807,
-0.13476084172725677,
0.013660523109138012,
0.16546599566936493,
0.0805661752820015,
0.5318533182144165,
0.08306948840618134,
-0.4095174968242645,
-0.4141869843006134,
-0.23454712331295013,
-0.13910774886608124,
-0.18802540004253387,
0.19204871356487274,
-0.07504811137914658,
0.20786111056804657,
0.44632333517074585,
-0.9216880798339844,
0.6833061575889587,
0.6767348051071167,
0.06716267764568329,
0.2962392568588257,
-0.21009540557861328,
0.002734082518145442,
-0.8708773255348206,
0.0065936315804719925,
-0.6404314637184143,
-0.34010469913482666,
-0.3980882465839386,
0.06425777822732925,
0.22575753927230835,
-0.01967765763401985,
-0.4932903051376343,
0.5936892032623291,
-0.5319884419441223,
-0.21197879314422607,
-0.41082268953323364,
-0.035107970237731934,
0.0278355460613966,
0.34405335783958435,
-0.1736002117395401,
0.8305760025978088,
0.3020226061344147,
-0.5879688262939453,
0.22555457055568695,
0.034315913915634155,
-0.48085346817970276,
-0.13964033126831055,
-0.47531643509864807,
0.5336910486221313,
0.13239918649196625,
0.6924572587013245,
-1.1161975860595703,
0.11194098740816116,
-0.1568627953529358,
-0.14658348262310028,
0.45097118616104126,
-0.2794443964958191,
-1.1102256774902344,
-0.23773592710494995,
-0.4567689001560211,
0.7392697334289551,
0.6640015244483948,
-0.7381170392036438,
0.5470054149627686,
0.3427533507347107,
-0.010877984575927258,
-0.7526326179504395,
-0.9085034728050232,
0.17996029555797577,
-0.05572302266955376,
-0.668799102306366,
0.6503654718399048,
-0.129336416721344,
0.16686740517616272,
-0.04885295033454895,
-0.5288258194923401,
0.11258284747600555,
-0.19079965353012085,
0.3500213623046875,
0.03749781474471092,
-0.1795760989189148,
0.16378672420978546,
0.5501564741134644,
-0.27571868896484375,
-0.255359023809433,
-0.38681790232658386,
0.8938330411911011,
-0.4520057141780853,
-0.34270957112312317,
-0.2758626937866211,
0.3570529520511627,
0.4856175184249878,
0.06015975400805473,
0.7691287398338318,
0.3782427906990051,
-0.4402492046356201,
-0.3929789960384369,
-0.5260355472564697,
-0.4151769280433655,
-0.5168362259864807,
-0.05908800661563873,
-0.5050521492958069,
-1.1197706460952759,
0.890881359577179,
-0.2759567201137543,
-0.11021187156438828,
0.3984474241733551,
0.8124867677688599,
0.049109652638435364,
0.6878044009208679,
0.57079017162323,
-0.4932588040828705,
0.09783004224300385,
-0.6983555555343628,
0.3995395302772522,
-0.5050345063209534,
-0.07142142206430435,
-0.4174913763999939,
-0.6307892799377441,
-0.4323655366897583,
-0.7714740633964539,
0.281885027885437,
0.11034215241670609,
-0.10972505807876587,
0.1861521154642105,
-0.28605106472969055,
0.7425078749656677,
0.2929643988609314,
0.16247311234474182,
0.39111995697021484,
-0.03688953444361687,
-0.4531448185443878,
-0.0641704574227333,
-0.6775411367416382,
-0.10861865431070328,
0.6658720374107361,
0.20466600358486176,
0.8510878682136536,
0.3399517238140106,
0.8250144720077515,
0.11689067631959915,
-0.07007052004337311,
-0.8215311765670776,
0.6369576454162598,
-0.07585752755403519,
-0.36118972301483154,
-0.25257205963134766,
-0.23429353535175323,
-0.781248927116394,
0.36389872431755066,
0.10553566366434097,
-0.7038382291793823,
0.2970272898674011,
0.27277514338493347,
-0.4614690840244293,
0.2995973825454712,
-0.31874850392341614,
0.5695902705192566,
0.06978879868984222,
-0.31802013516426086,
-0.48150262236595154,
-0.8122597932815552,
0.45186999440193176,
0.0791352167725563,
-0.09854776412248611,
0.12560604512691498,
-0.3478303849697113,
0.4323810935020447,
-0.8259819746017456,
1.0377676486968994,
-0.16509588062763214,
-0.14161744713783264,
0.17106911540031433,
0.44090208411216736,
0.7861610054969788,
0.08186808228492737,
0.2893403470516205,
0.20652717351913452,
0.07318344712257385,
-0.4131358563899994,
-0.6602490544319153,
1.0858982801437378,
-0.7250182628631592,
-0.480218768119812,
-0.132477268576622,
-0.5280771255493164,
-0.18872489035129547,
0.2061508744955063,
0.22445271909236908,
0.3096719980239868,
0.03626461327075958,
0.14433936774730682,
0.8950203657150269,
-0.24105195701122284,
0.4763248562812805,
0.31075748801231384,
-0.05787471681833267,
-0.09465314447879791,
0.8030226826667786,
0.0547945536673069,
0.24949650466442108,
0.5587814450263977,
0.32536596059799194,
-0.34958213567733765,
-0.4863458573818207,
-0.3299338221549988,
0.2642628252506256,
-0.9603477716445923,
-0.48685234785079956,
-0.6166335344314575,
-0.3073868453502655,
-0.29398471117019653,
-0.1350499540567398,
-0.854519784450531,
-0.603477418422699,
-0.14066803455352783,
-0.11361861228942871,
0.35548797249794006,
0.35956746339797974,
-0.18334819376468658,
0.6305647492408752,
-0.7314459085464478,
0.15451160073280334,
0.34722498059272766,
0.08058415353298187,
0.32608962059020996,
-0.35327520966529846,
-0.3197575807571411,
-0.15272662043571472,
-0.09442134946584702,
-0.5524248480796814,
0.3789421021938324,
0.13325946033000946,
0.10604163259267807,
0.3550575375556946,
0.15327751636505127,
1.1098930835723877,
-0.3370848000049591,
0.8378610610961914,
-0.028948476538062096,
-1.1052824258804321,
0.36075037717819214,
0.006762064062058926,
0.40602561831474304,
0.835141658782959,
0.007017324212938547,
-0.444715678691864,
-0.14714975655078888,
-0.6327463388442993,
-1.093207597732544,
0.343612402677536,
-0.01918545365333557,
0.15871278941631317,
0.06208955869078636,
0.2880566120147705,
0.13723744451999664,
0.16188691556453705,
-0.5334659218788147,
-0.22749562561511993,
0.07449433207511902,
-0.25934600830078125,
0.1447809338569641,
-0.3646145761013031,
0.00017325527733191848,
-0.40201297402381897,
0.3712146580219269,
-0.09190154075622559,
0.40678855776786804,
-0.04389989376068115,
-0.2793061435222626,
0.10945162177085876,
-0.02112457901239395,
0.5535953640937805,
0.22254498302936554,
-0.03833799436688423,
0.6477864980697632,
0.3001675605773926,
-0.58009272813797,
0.2860194146633148,
-0.20376236736774445,
0.11987059563398361,
-0.13886113464832306,
0.13130496442317963,
0.4513031244277954,
0.38695862889289856,
-0.4737928509712219,
0.6339149475097656,
-0.30174773931503296,
0.10626205056905746,
-0.047584135085344315,
-0.05148664489388466,
0.29832834005355835,
0.23282743990421295,
-0.08724083751440048,
-0.30331218242645264,
0.19784416258335114,
-0.2972332835197449,
-0.05070743337273598,
0.21516449749469757,
-0.035503651946783066,
-0.2656610906124115,
0.30762162804603577,
0.09692742675542831,
0.3286489248275757,
0.9083590507507324,
0.06301965564489365,
-0.4342426657676697,
0.43919894099235535,
0.3646792769432068,
0.7493224143981934,
-0.19785185158252716,
-0.32461827993392944,
0.29736948013305664,
0.5183647274971008,
-0.07431265711784363,
0.19294849038124084,
-0.6253235936164856,
-0.5865679979324341,
-0.48380476236343384,
-0.576790452003479,
-0.1290813833475113,
0.34066450595855713,
-0.4816480875015259,
0.15872356295585632,
-0.5159596800804138,
0.11441495269536972,
-0.37773722410202026,
0.35950952768325806,
-0.853126049041748,
-0.0058612399734556675,
0.0011028517037630081,
1.1749939918518066,
-0.9327619671821594,
1.304885745048523,
-0.09008804708719254,
-0.3002036511898041,
-0.6859719753265381,
-0.14087961614131927,
0.3609718382358551,
-0.8445456027984619,
0.7197204232215881,
0.1804617941379547,
-0.4289698004722595,
-0.13244988024234772,
-0.4519409239292145,
-0.988077700138092,
1.2979214191436768,
0.4461666941642761,
-0.6212822198867798,
-0.06394222378730774,
0.2071681171655655,
0.4131159782409668,
-0.2644824683666229,
-0.1681315302848816,
0.8072478175163269,
0.3444907069206238,
0.28027501702308655,
-0.7006412148475647,
0.3518279790878296,
-0.2591668665409088,
0.28809094429016113,
0.3768766522407532,
-0.6335507035255432,
0.7091236114501953,
0.037123486399650574,
-0.35485732555389404,
0.27378255128860474,
0.7212231755256653,
0.2683800160884857,
-0.2001415193080902,
0.5927414298057556,
1.057755947113037,
0.7790654301643372,
0.04062069579958916,
0.9373125433921814,
-0.3065008819103241,
0.2158397138118744,
1.0927186012268066,
0.007127224467694759,
0.92568039894104,
0.6428331732749939,
-0.000984341953881085,
0.4840579330921173,
0.7626166343688965,
0.4761698842048645,
0.8792746067047119,
0.35982978343963623,
-0.4361533522605896,
-0.22143037617206573,
0.04450495168566704,
-0.3716159462928772,
0.3392126262187958,
0.4384297728538513,
-0.20815153419971466,
-0.19998687505722046,
-0.45739179849624634,
0.0484752431511879,
-0.5569765567779541,
-0.09957045316696167,
0.5773131847381592,
0.22767557203769684,
-0.33342742919921875,
0.461325079202652,
0.058052945882081985,
0.3836425840854645,
-0.3742304742336273,
0.015481875278055668,
-0.371123731136322,
0.11683661490678787,
-0.04604653641581535,
-0.43710917234420776,
0.07597629725933075,
-0.18340900540351868,
-0.34634941816329956,
-0.23159798979759216,
0.8371108174324036,
-0.4768391251564026,
-0.09061464667320251,
0.22892890870571136,
0.2370373159646988,
0.12490858137607574,
0.14356651902198792,
-0.35611093044281006,
0.5024677515029907,
-0.41329097747802734,
-0.22147007286548615,
0.5401399731636047,
0.23678259551525116,
0.03260398656129837,
0.4928300678730011,
0.7236036062240601,
0.3528398275375366,
0.34502488374710083,
0.116111621260643,
1.237085223197937,
-0.47980883717536926,
-0.7141637802124023,
-0.9093620181083679,
0.5316460132598877,
-0.0735892578959465,
-0.005663351155817509,
0.4602779746055603,
0.5542610883712769,
0.7503041625022888,
0.08345834165811539,
0.499182790517807,
0.1965010166168213,
-0.009964200668036938,
-0.7167810201644897,
0.6540985107421875,
-0.5630141496658325,
0.321162611246109,
-0.04717691242694855,
-0.8294392824172974,
-0.11191714555025101,
0.44627073407173157,
-0.03801542520523071,
0.0002673313720151782,
0.6513983011245728,
0.9479668140411377,
-0.27998265624046326,
-0.15357306599617004,
0.18287786841392517,
0.2312278151512146,
0.6225247979164124,
0.7368531227111816,
0.7276349663734436,
-0.44370847940444946,
0.4991588294506073,
-0.40851274132728577,
-0.10304339975118637,
-0.4236397445201874,
-1.0421556234359741,
-0.5671325325965881,
-0.642395555973053,
-0.02000655047595501,
-0.27011632919311523,
-0.36186733841896057,
0.5920030474662781,
0.930370032787323,
-0.501107394695282,
-0.15204650163650513,
-0.12452206015586853,
-0.15181128680706024,
0.08058473467826843,
-0.18406036496162415,
0.5962402820587158,
-0.09252377599477768,
-0.5001628398895264,
0.522316038608551,
0.545732855796814,
0.041608210653066635,
-0.5568000078201294,
-0.09619154036045074,
0.18531587719917297,
0.23101896047592163,
0.5775799751281738,
0.3103027641773224,
-0.9084919095039368,
-0.28458213806152344,
-0.2732541561126709,
-0.24155977368354797,
-0.0634075328707695,
1.0713059902191162,
-0.8785761594772339,
0.6278210282325745,
0.6744138598442078,
0.943494439125061,
1.1874642372131348,
-0.404574990272522,
0.28060591220855713,
-0.8875905871391296,
0.36591413617134094,
0.12413933128118515,
0.49678826332092285,
0.175916850566864,
-0.26467424631118774,
0.2701224088668823,
0.06391502171754837,
-0.47418421506881714,
-0.8882715106010437,
0.31463852524757385,
-1.2384141683578491,
-0.21087497472763062,
0.8630821704864502,
0.03215748071670532,
-0.19444939494132996,
0.22263510525226593,
0.007966728881001472,
0.34955787658691406,
-0.4111059308052063,
0.8659237027168274,
0.8122979998588562,
0.040775150060653687,
-0.34565046429634094,
-0.48185357451438904,
0.661124587059021,
0.37579813599586487,
-0.6825917959213257,
0.18461163341999054,
0.3397122323513031,
0.07767629623413086,
-0.04399511218070984,
0.6650658845901489,
-0.15940889716148376,
0.1726173311471939,
0.19139385223388672,
-0.08404906839132309,
-0.07217042148113251,
-0.5888120532035828,
-0.3720254600048065,
-0.01111587043851614,
-0.04503287002444267,
-0.08523061871528625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14365v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14365v1
|
JiuZhang3.0: Efficiently Improving Mathematical Reasoning by Training Small Data Synthesis Models
| 2024-05-23T09:43:19 | 2024-05-23T09:43:19 |
Kun Zhou, Beichen Zhang, Jiapeng Wang, Zhipeng Chen, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jing Sha, Zhichao Sheng, Shijin Wang, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mathematical reasoning is an important capability of large language
models~(LLMs) for real-world applications. To enhance this capability, existing
work either collects large-scale math-related texts for pre-training, or relies
on stronger LLMs (\eg GPT-4) to synthesize massive math problems. Both types of
work generally lead to large costs in training or synthesis. To reduce the
cost, based on open-source available texts, we propose an efficient way that
trains a small LLM for math problem synthesis, to efficiently generate
sufficient high-quality pre-training data. To achieve it, we create a dataset
using GPT-4 to distill its data synthesis capability into the small LLM.
Concretely, we craft a set of prompts based on human education stages to guide
GPT-4, to synthesize problems covering diverse math knowledge and difficulty
levels. Besides, we adopt the gradient-based influence estimation method to
select the most valuable math-related texts. The both are fed into GPT-4 for
creating the knowledge distillation dataset to train the small LLM. We leverage
it to synthesize 6 million math problems for pre-training our JiuZhang3.0
model, which only needs to invoke GPT-4 API 9.3k times and pre-train on 4.6B
data. Experimental results have shown that JiuZhang3.0 achieves
state-of-the-art performance on several mathematical reasoning datasets, under
both natural language reasoning and tool manipulation settings. Our code and
data will be publicly released in
\url{https://github.com/RUCAIBox/JiuZhang3.0}.
|
[
-0.37415075302124023,
-0.7178253531455994,
0.6301272511482239,
0.21399737894535065,
-0.1881980150938034,
-0.10538957267999649,
-0.23932109773159027,
-0.11055365949869156,
-0.11770498007535934,
0.26010775566101074,
-0.6148440837860107,
-0.38688433170318604,
-0.14830702543258667,
-0.14031068980693817,
-0.1010436937212944,
1.1689938306808472,
-0.20313124358654022,
0.3282216191291809,
-0.3025982081890106,
0.21649092435836792,
-0.24178054928779602,
-0.3189868628978729,
-0.5551901459693909,
-0.5057604908943176,
0.3041900396347046,
0.5134769082069397,
0.6756181120872498,
0.29048728942871094,
0.44644060730934143,
0.19551338255405426,
0.23232680559158325,
0.02808302827179432,
-0.5812733173370361,
-0.0038091198075562716,
-0.04377519339323044,
-0.7911233901977539,
-0.46345463395118713,
0.1041073277592659,
0.4384581446647644,
0.599007248878479,
-0.409566193819046,
0.21643204987049103,
0.022728273645043373,
0.9493019580841064,
-0.44128888845443726,
0.4906660318374634,
-0.709382176399231,
0.18291562795639038,
-0.6179365515708923,
0.15203621983528137,
-0.2932245433330536,
-0.7832435369491577,
-0.0269271619617939,
-0.950117826461792,
0.11477821320295334,
-0.09617109596729279,
0.6609805822372437,
0.3121771812438965,
-0.01014573872089386,
-0.21474023163318634,
-0.41760650277137756,
0.853847324848175,
-0.8192369341850281,
0.010321483947336674,
0.4915940761566162,
0.7166287302970886,
-0.33861446380615234,
-0.8671912550926208,
-0.596294641494751,
0.2860255539417267,
0.008436616510152817,
0.2727929353713989,
-0.039298735558986664,
-0.25498315691947937,
0.6877444386482239,
0.4081653952598572,
-0.5167723894119263,
-0.44659727811813354,
-0.46975305676460266,
-0.17871995270252228,
0.5383556485176086,
0.3283093273639679,
0.14868587255477905,
-0.2779563069343567,
0.011000552214682102,
0.06235542520880699,
-0.8874285221099854,
-0.16775502264499664,
0.5634453892707825,
0.08789584040641785,
0.04521442949771881,
0.4662822484970093,
-0.15527816116809845,
0.5847922563552856,
-0.011270309798419476,
-0.3261326551437378,
0.1991186887025833,
-0.2705219089984894,
-0.09382380545139313,
-0.16543684899806976,
0.7439299821853638,
-0.05212065577507019,
0.2883559763431549,
0.32742464542388916,
-0.1767139881849289,
0.1923423856496811,
0.10573258250951767,
-1.2061102390289307,
-0.6344329118728638,
-0.17783097922801971,
-0.1761578470468521,
-0.514671266078949,
-0.18490785360336304,
-0.6566634774208069,
-0.25707024335861206,
-0.47782209515571594,
0.6085348725318909,
-0.6253639459609985,
-0.08481323719024658,
0.19340389966964722,
0.22377265989780426,
-0.003988655284047127,
0.534895658493042,
-0.8906638026237488,
0.28052008152008057,
0.5173987746238708,
0.7182693481445312,
0.054459333419799805,
0.012207728810608387,
-0.5504157543182373,
0.14082898199558258,
-0.47742000222206116,
0.5537688136100769,
-0.3695189356803894,
-0.18889588117599487,
-0.3672977685928345,
-0.4487050175666809,
0.06642331182956696,
-0.3998340964317322,
0.5846049785614014,
-0.3787720799446106,
0.5638603568077087,
-0.05207088217139244,
-0.5127662420272827,
-0.31073471903800964,
0.153191938996315,
-0.6037412881851196,
0.8964770436286926,
0.36488062143325806,
-0.9256982207298279,
-0.02628355100750923,
-0.9763338565826416,
-0.4239310324192047,
0.12454106658697128,
-0.28696730732917786,
-0.7005717754364014,
0.03906090557575226,
0.5838411450386047,
0.2431209236383438,
-0.643208920955658,
0.30991119146347046,
-0.3263654410839081,
-0.5767278671264648,
0.18978404998779297,
-0.35554033517837524,
0.8175129890441895,
0.47023335099220276,
-0.22724495828151703,
-0.05046990513801575,
-0.5789873003959656,
0.3094082772731781,
0.359005868434906,
0.09131597727537155,
-0.3336101770401001,
-0.09853755682706833,
-0.48100486397743225,
-0.015312783420085907,
0.20676089823246002,
-0.17793935537338257,
0.3355558216571808,
-0.6701317429542542,
0.3578093647956848,
0.7390296459197998,
0.1072554811835289,
0.444644033908844,
-0.2653653919696808,
0.7492727637290955,
0.18986347317695618,
0.16083365678787231,
-0.04540374502539635,
-0.6150782704353333,
-0.5396108627319336,
-0.17405521869659424,
0.6722567081451416,
0.2868442237377167,
-1.2862303256988525,
0.03517957776784897,
-0.23288366198539734,
-0.6628496050834656,
-0.41238272190093994,
0.11250582337379456,
0.13648764789104462,
0.5296679735183716,
0.2768114507198334,
0.18556685745716095,
-0.4201502799987793,
-0.8223547339439392,
-0.44160300493240356,
0.2537354528903961,
-0.3403532803058624,
-0.09129641950130463,
0.5400896668434143,
0.017372433096170425,
0.9185441732406616,
-0.9433931112289429,
-0.5096534490585327,
-0.3221966624259949,
0.11759426444768906,
0.6254163980484009,
0.40192848443984985,
0.55038982629776,
-0.5706450343132019,
-0.9902994632720947,
-0.0652778297662735,
-0.7103503346443176,
-0.12214906513690948,
0.03588806837797165,
-0.3984207808971405,
0.1064862310886383,
0.1805272400379181,
-0.5502992272377014,
0.5726491212844849,
0.39640012383461,
0.07397136092185974,
0.3022959530353546,
0.1125088557600975,
-0.08209343254566193,
-1.117565393447876,
-0.032131634652614594,
-0.03360041230916977,
-0.07786545157432556,
-0.5396953225135803,
-0.05029130354523659,
0.06531277298927307,
-0.3674475848674774,
-0.20374687016010284,
0.31423959136009216,
-0.40119674801826477,
0.03686020150780678,
0.007621339056640863,
0.18069766461849213,
-0.16297373175621033,
0.7683619856834412,
-0.2384314388036728,
0.8396676182746887,
0.6140236258506775,
-0.4417673349380493,
0.3130424916744232,
0.23064017295837402,
-0.6934837698936462,
0.5241141319274902,
-0.6215308904647827,
0.12139765918254852,
0.16481831669807434,
0.3457198143005371,
-0.5909149646759033,
-0.48664993047714233,
0.6686179041862488,
-0.4393295645713806,
0.029536034911870956,
-0.5338578820228577,
-0.6900181174278259,
-0.29373985528945923,
-0.36893388628959656,
0.40509033203125,
0.9253422617912292,
-0.6405968070030212,
0.7802472114562988,
0.3892933428287506,
-0.4203914999961853,
-0.19478774070739746,
-0.6231086254119873,
-0.37142157554626465,
-0.34899622201919556,
-0.60332852602005,
0.09940733760595322,
-0.3435971140861511,
-0.11756658554077148,
-0.016313308849930763,
-0.20088420808315277,
-0.19940708577632904,
-0.03780629113316536,
0.043588969856500626,
0.37735414505004883,
0.06082884222269058,
0.10320964455604553,
0.4686996042728424,
-0.453186571598053,
0.271555095911026,
-0.4550703465938568,
0.26518023014068604,
-0.25681886076927185,
-0.3127155005931854,
-0.21604785323143005,
-0.10757028311491013,
0.18001961708068848,
-0.10788586735725403,
0.45353463292121887,
0.6902912855148315,
-0.5167754888534546,
-0.44594305753707886,
-0.04218742623925209,
-0.16573596000671387,
-0.49930059909820557,
0.06642976403236389,
-0.6127195358276367,
-0.5692880749702454,
0.19366301596164703,
-0.17097152769565582,
0.1937631219625473,
0.36290547251701355,
0.6994889378547668,
0.13713154196739197,
1.2032229900360107,
-0.11596830189228058,
0.11932334303855896,
0.30098679661750793,
-0.2496134638786316,
0.29003027081489563,
-0.6069709062576294,
0.12969937920570374,
-0.21148483455181122,
-0.24399909377098083,
-0.45508867502212524,
-0.5656815767288208,
0.7529348134994507,
-0.031148413196206093,
-0.03981870040297508,
0.07319501787424088,
-0.48519495129585266,
0.8702939748764038,
0.3402809500694275,
0.14965148270130157,
0.24486002326011658,
0.2856537699699402,
-0.13294637203216553,
-0.42946526408195496,
-0.6830903887748718,
-0.2271268665790558,
1.2792823314666748,
0.10210195183753967,
0.9679747223854065,
0.22664497792720795,
0.7674803137779236,
-0.13163289427757263,
0.5440157651901245,
-0.7515656352043152,
0.663322389125824,
0.1861746609210968,
-0.6681041121482849,
-0.19678635895252228,
-1.0963977575302124,
-0.779513418674469,
0.4076482355594635,
-0.16959063708782196,
-0.2542378604412079,
-0.5272552967071533,
0.29959097504615784,
-0.16199913620948792,
0.27712205052375793,
-0.8702043294906616,
0.7087135314941406,
-0.09203056246042252,
-0.6193408370018005,
-0.28417107462882996,
-0.5231463313102722,
0.723163366317749,
-0.4167253077030182,
0.36094170808792114,
-0.1280457079410553,
0.3329538106918335,
0.6117465496063232,
-0.6382754445075989,
0.6110329627990723,
-0.5207456946372986,
-0.27346071600914,
0.5625916123390198,
0.30493035912513733,
0.45657315850257874,
0.3945530354976654,
-0.09375954419374466,
0.2031942754983902,
-0.025428645312786102,
-0.4697721004486084,
-0.9158956408500671,
0.7867881059646606,
-0.6804502606391907,
-0.599549412727356,
-0.4965200126171112,
-0.6622698903083801,
-0.45671170949935913,
0.3178226053714752,
0.21499304473400116,
0.5609036087989807,
0.2126350849866867,
0.07811706513166428,
0.5867531299591064,
0.17972400784492493,
0.17667153477668762,
0.18805037438869476,
-0.5232048630714417,
-0.6476200222969055,
1.1645216941833496,
0.17313459515571594,
0.07481465488672256,
0.21155962347984314,
0.5404736399650574,
-0.19516755640506744,
-0.4166707396507263,
-0.4136507213115692,
0.17776989936828613,
-0.7562870979309082,
-0.5843071341514587,
-0.13646790385246277,
-0.27937301993370056,
-0.15552090108394623,
-0.014781901612877846,
-0.3392050266265869,
-0.7761662006378174,
-0.031718041747808456,
0.20619693398475647,
0.4471176266670227,
0.6663929224014282,
-0.26108789443969727,
0.20972537994384766,
-0.6667752265930176,
0.5478441715240479,
0.3375113606452942,
0.5352118611335754,
-0.06641974300146103,
-0.5284573435783386,
-0.5038469433784485,
0.38413822650909424,
-0.4731694161891937,
-0.5328579545021057,
0.2746398448944092,
-0.07881157100200653,
0.26476824283599854,
0.22680199146270752,
0.12007404118776321,
0.6624914407730103,
-0.5147612690925598,
0.5736754536628723,
0.32873809337615967,
-1.2220251560211182,
0.6019256711006165,
-0.499028742313385,
0.39254245162010193,
0.38634344935417175,
0.4269656240940094,
0.10200387984514236,
-0.10497031360864639,
-0.6664757132530212,
-0.3450281620025635,
0.8983238935470581,
0.717885434627533,
-0.2565433382987976,
0.1839732676744461,
0.4268595576286316,
0.3099648058414459,
0.1989632099866867,
-0.7854533791542053,
-0.0792296975851059,
-0.3423321545124054,
-0.5474283695220947,
0.27729952335357666,
0.06454137712717056,
-0.1549869030714035,
-0.6165269017219543,
0.9918719530105591,
-0.37324243783950806,
0.20110338926315308,
-0.3142600655555725,
-0.05624127760529518,
-0.03248054161667824,
0.059073153883218765,
0.5019732117652893,
0.7369387745857239,
0.05555238202214241,
-0.04893943667411804,
0.25621849298477173,
-0.6065047383308411,
0.12586168944835663,
0.2132829874753952,
-0.31517183780670166,
-0.011717017740011215,
-0.16165277361869812,
0.53354811668396,
0.06659726798534393,
-0.2913282811641693,
0.4813596308231354,
-0.24072770774364471,
-0.597087025642395,
-0.5581274032592773,
0.3074752986431122,
0.23915895819664001,
-0.02047714963555336,
0.11736864596605301,
0.16301369667053223,
0.13467596471309662,
-0.20446912944316864,
-0.16425658762454987,
0.08297466486692429,
0.15114596486091614,
-0.430564284324646,
0.5673044323921204,
0.20372048020362854,
0.21653255820274353,
0.6017313003540039,
-0.363869845867157,
-0.4587191343307495,
0.09368208795785904,
0.47075942158699036,
0.4972705543041229,
-0.16680464148521423,
0.12466449290513992,
0.7114579081535339,
0.05636558681726456,
-0.14747457206249237,
0.2740691006183624,
-0.0014482628321275115,
-0.48400306701660156,
-0.604335606098175,
-0.3550136685371399,
-0.588533341884613,
0.09185554832220078,
-0.6872537732124329,
0.5133571028709412,
-0.5819208025932312,
-0.01782635599374771,
-0.20108482241630554,
0.13620497286319733,
-0.5655073523521423,
0.10036612302064896,
-0.16826818883419037,
0.37130120396614075,
-0.4345095753669739,
0.8503526449203491,
0.6193878650665283,
-0.3620156943798065,
-0.9527287483215332,
-0.04125255346298218,
-0.00797552801668644,
-0.7009347081184387,
0.3816474676132202,
0.1664401888847351,
-0.11705224215984344,
0.2607056796550751,
-0.885855495929718,
-0.705987811088562,
0.9728905558586121,
0.4781423807144165,
-0.5396530628204346,
0.015194692648947239,
0.08256229758262634,
0.4338320791721344,
-0.16129067540168762,
0.15896224975585938,
0.4282287359237671,
0.5656675696372986,
0.2604064643383026,
-0.4967275559902191,
0.028622912243008614,
-0.3673744201660156,
0.07147499918937683,
0.5553470253944397,
-0.4041937589645386,
0.7611593008041382,
-0.3511393964290619,
-0.22072921693325043,
0.15877887606620789,
0.7780668139457703,
0.5122057199478149,
0.2909700572490692,
0.49673470854759216,
0.6715441942214966,
0.7372617721557617,
-0.3547077178955078,
0.8643368482589722,
-0.07502755522727966,
0.3846952021121979,
1.1279844045639038,
-0.2687097191810608,
0.5264065265655518,
0.43312013149261475,
-0.4096904397010803,
0.7044702172279358,
0.37013521790504456,
0.03060035966336727,
0.5673940777778625,
0.5560846328735352,
-0.22970490157604218,
-0.3633139133453369,
0.5339527726173401,
-0.5771389603614807,
0.20755930244922638,
0.6045478582382202,
0.2342003732919693,
-0.17578326165676117,
-0.10674665123224258,
0.24142275750637054,
0.04659178853034973,
-0.04904535412788391,
0.5128415822982788,
0.19431020319461823,
-0.5780606269836426,
0.5636609792709351,
-0.08021767437458038,
0.29567980766296387,
-0.8955458998680115,
-0.24637173116207123,
-0.3301199674606323,
0.4023853838443756,
-0.2592047154903412,
-0.6689356565475464,
0.2063930183649063,
0.03223147988319397,
0.04349604994058609,
0.004957829602062702,
0.6143096685409546,
-0.43710124492645264,
-0.6183182001113892,
-0.4334331154823303,
0.4523434042930603,
0.21465827524662018,
-0.1342150717973709,
-0.6289235949516296,
0.034277476370334625,
0.27669256925582886,
-0.3420250713825226,
0.4456765651702881,
0.8353574872016907,
-0.05363313853740692,
0.5805202126502991,
0.9655110239982605,
0.1547665148973465,
-0.30944883823394775,
0.1864696592092514,
0.9899561405181885,
-0.5965902209281921,
-0.642979085445404,
-0.6152403950691223,
0.349414587020874,
-0.14503107964992523,
-0.017466789111495018,
0.7941492795944214,
0.3833593726158142,
0.7343188524246216,
-0.25870481133461,
0.9890811443328857,
-0.06251346319913864,
0.7244930863380432,
-0.6871100664138794,
0.659355878829956,
-0.4301445186138153,
0.43574199080467224,
-0.3904528021812439,
-0.9806505441665649,
-0.35352823138237,
1.0949301719665527,
-0.47169941663742065,
0.08169633895158768,
0.7558251023292542,
0.5777790546417236,
-0.14884209632873535,
0.3571741282939911,
0.20634427666664124,
0.15048149228096008,
0.5049246549606323,
0.8407833576202393,
0.9523631930351257,
-0.61407470703125,
0.7964991927146912,
-0.31131085753440857,
-0.2993374764919281,
0.013160880655050278,
-0.891291618347168,
-1.1765379905700684,
-0.2856815457344055,
-0.3405301570892334,
-0.264463871717453,
-0.3910520076751709,
0.8074070811271667,
0.37766167521476746,
-0.4878472685813904,
-0.055935088545084,
-0.37270310521125793,
0.20577409863471985,
-0.10068189352750778,
-0.31461095809936523,
0.21333934366703033,
-0.31964200735092163,
-0.6852986216545105,
0.25329819321632385,
-0.000217346430872567,
0.044681861996650696,
-0.2079000324010849,
-0.07764829695224762,
0.24132800102233887,
0.03017459250986576,
0.5142389535903931,
-0.01546718180179596,
-0.3599267899990082,
-0.04660017415881157,
-0.20319418609142303,
0.027489284053444862,
0.048148248344659805,
0.767440140247345,
-0.6879295110702515,
0.35028454661369324,
0.43212124705314636,
0.5570820569992065,
0.8062185645103455,
-0.13434454798698425,
0.5990744829177856,
-0.4551889896392822,
0.09231657534837723,
0.13777053356170654,
0.42685049772262573,
0.3192189335823059,
-0.12573528289794922,
0.9852644205093384,
0.4241609275341034,
-0.42730477452278137,
-0.6942611336708069,
0.3111707270145416,
-0.647861659526825,
-0.1107996478676796,
0.8352066278457642,
-0.12773403525352478,
-0.15579847991466522,
0.21532754600048065,
-0.4569530785083771,
-0.09008780121803284,
-0.33223387598991394,
0.7354393005371094,
0.7057706117630005,
-0.20546984672546387,
0.0747956931591034,
-0.6262749433517456,
0.5572104454040527,
0.45139190554618835,
-1.1338618993759155,
0.0008881142712198198,
0.5990476608276367,
0.35075056552886963,
-0.006893274839967489,
0.5165122151374817,
-0.487978994846344,
0.41947075724601746,
0.20657502114772797,
-0.04237823560833931,
-0.32134830951690674,
-0.2481716275215149,
0.10517439246177673,
0.017697324976325035,
-0.14393241703510284,
0.19135290384292603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14314v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14314v2
|
Towards Efficient LLM Grounding for Embodied Multi-Agent Collaboration
| 2024-05-23T08:33:19 | 2024-05-26T02:31:15 |
Yang Zhang, Shixin Yang, Chenjia Bai, Fei Wu, Xiu Li, Zhen Wang, Xuelong Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MA, cs.RO
|
Grounding the reasoning ability of large language models (LLMs) for embodied
tasks is challenging due to the complexity of the physical world. Especially,
LLM planning for multi-agent collaboration requires communication of agents or
credit assignment as the feedback to re-adjust the proposed plans and achieve
effective coordination. However, existing methods that overly rely on physical
verification or self-reflection suffer from excessive and inefficient querying
of LLMs. In this paper, we propose a novel framework for multi-agent
collaboration that introduces Reinforced Advantage feedback (ReAd) for
efficient self-refinement of plans. Specifically, we perform critic regression
to learn a sequential advantage function from LLM-planned data, and then treat
the LLM planner as an optimizer to generate actions that maximize the advantage
function. It endows the LLM with the foresight to discern whether the action
contributes to accomplishing the final task. We provide theoretical analysis by
extending advantage-weighted regression in reinforcement learning to
multi-agent systems. Experiments on Overcooked-AI and a difficult variant of
RoCoBench show that ReAd surpasses baselines in success rate, and also
significantly decreases the interaction steps of agents and query rounds of
LLMs, demonstrating its high efficiency for grounding LLMs. More results are
given at https://read-llm.github.io/.
|
[
-0.3187221884727478,
-0.49495670199394226,
0.6413282752037048,
0.3089435398578644,
0.0060708471573889256,
0.1127796471118927,
-0.4509221911430359,
-0.24969176948070526,
0.4306129217147827,
0.6315407752990723,
-0.7352049946784973,
-0.5387059450149536,
-0.24048267304897308,
0.1450660228729248,
0.22399766743183136,
0.7474784851074219,
-0.26445674896240234,
0.08894102275371552,
-0.36306285858154297,
-0.3758922219276428,
-0.4733095169067383,
-0.5399506092071533,
-0.3935060501098633,
-0.8255956172943115,
0.4871378242969513,
0.5203196406364441,
0.42948076128959656,
0.3879258334636688,
0.2205260843038559,
0.4679722785949707,
0.1358790397644043,
0.8222938179969788,
-0.6176420450210571,
0.3636115491390228,
-0.334353506565094,
-0.42472782731056213,
-0.7091808319091797,
-0.12879887223243713,
0.5662611722946167,
0.46516183018684387,
-0.2588929533958435,
-0.22595781087875366,
0.2689442038536072,
0.6225220561027527,
-0.8791856169700623,
0.3150133192539215,
-0.34544751048088074,
-0.041827067732810974,
0.5336627960205078,
-0.4280606508255005,
-0.8056795597076416,
0.0361911915242672,
-0.30002275109291077,
-0.7341797351837158,
-0.054664067924022675,
-0.05680666118860245,
0.4663722515106201,
0.548486590385437,
-0.2517023980617523,
-0.0529189258813858,
-0.560939371585846,
0.6855759024620056,
-0.3894655406475067,
0.3266548812389374,
0.3200102150440216,
0.15286390483379364,
-0.35442399978637695,
-0.4857863783836365,
-0.558914303779602,
-0.4480125606060028,
-0.0650724545121193,
0.44808605313301086,
-0.028545942157506943,
0.4548938572406769,
0.05195293575525284,
-0.05428895354270935,
-0.10814914852380753,
0.04883712902665138,
0.07822003215551376,
0.04594142362475395,
0.7422662973403931,
0.06503576040267944,
0.08793125301599503,
0.11375366896390915,
-0.6344730854034424,
-0.2594517767429352,
-0.5668864250183105,
-0.10758916288614273,
0.11259448528289795,
0.41891998052597046,
-0.03786046430468559,
0.6392141580581665,
-0.35560211539268494,
0.21421803534030914,
0.2631682753562927,
-0.07230507582426071,
0.3631070852279663,
-0.2260589897632599,
-0.1316879838705063,
-0.11112053692340851,
0.4464942216873169,
0.3481876850128174,
0.08457653969526291,
-0.5260739326477051,
-0.3585894703865051,
-0.11347054690122604,
0.523845374584198,
-0.5323227047920227,
0.1510332226753235,
0.20023362338542938,
-0.21463976800441742,
-0.046864308416843414,
-0.05204054340720177,
-0.3714836835861206,
-0.4275733232498169,
-0.48131367564201355,
0.5220504403114319,
-0.23860512673854828,
-0.442900151014328,
0.23871228098869324,
-0.10763119906187057,
0.32848113775253296,
0.6145413517951965,
-0.7070381045341492,
0.5314391255378723,
0.7513046264648438,
0.6855648756027222,
0.09940634667873383,
-0.6940144300460815,
-0.5665603876113892,
0.3924272060394287,
-0.35052967071533203,
0.812345564365387,
-0.07392752915620804,
-0.31990286707878113,
-0.08165653795003891,
-0.03319351375102997,
-0.052694011479616165,
-0.3613671362400055,
0.4511061906814575,
-0.27764856815338135,
-0.3153889775276184,
-0.48084717988967896,
-0.43268659710884094,
-0.13307245075702667,
0.5854735970497131,
-0.6796189546585083,
0.8826550841331482,
-0.11974286288022995,
-0.6026299595832825,
0.41177332401275635,
-0.40079250931739807,
-0.34518611431121826,
-0.06671006232500076,
-0.410406231880188,
-0.35301825404167175,
-0.004891108255833387,
0.33930858969688416,
0.4624992311000824,
-0.1505187749862671,
0.2942618727684021,
-0.5486859679222107,
-0.3578161597251892,
0.01829984039068222,
-0.039292942732572556,
0.2860236167907715,
0.06372147798538208,
-0.7751806974411011,
0.6128489375114441,
-0.5056282877922058,
0.4041774272918701,
-0.07932056486606598,
-0.28293460607528687,
-0.25946810841560364,
0.15432041883468628,
-0.42083585262298584,
0.14681220054626465,
0.04279206693172455,
-0.09941572695970535,
0.5365031957626343,
-0.16125957667827606,
-0.03915676847100258,
0.8558913469314575,
-0.20296208560466766,
0.6627698540687561,
-0.6341584920883179,
0.4697484076023102,
-0.551932692527771,
-0.006740655284374952,
-0.13142509758472443,
0.058972496539354324,
-0.7766782641410828,
-0.5636178255081177,
-0.28924718499183655,
0.34354883432388306,
-1.027464747428894,
0.5051324367523193,
-0.18961483240127563,
-0.48661187291145325,
-0.4490039646625519,
0.15204861760139465,
0.7033758759498596,
0.1566856950521469,
0.4850342571735382,
-0.04970213398337364,
-0.2989380657672882,
-0.5905746221542358,
-0.08275553584098816,
-0.3212565779685974,
0.2925845980644226,
0.48128530383110046,
0.37450847029685974,
-0.16782955825328827,
0.8561584949493408,
-0.34334126114845276,
-0.27377748489379883,
-0.6100231409072876,
0.215244859457016,
0.04794079810380936,
0.5556302070617676,
0.38078269362449646,
-0.5839727520942688,
-0.2625676691532135,
-0.11357295513153076,
-0.83875572681427,
-0.22767677903175354,
-0.2861391305923462,
-0.39596793055534363,
0.010637530125677586,
0.4848186671733856,
-0.7689541578292847,
0.2603837847709656,
0.35017451643943787,
-0.41393691301345825,
0.6070789694786072,
-0.42910051345825195,
0.20747846364974976,
-0.8772652745246887,
0.05473029613494873,
-0.2381114661693573,
-0.33042338490486145,
-0.4914916455745697,
0.33063817024230957,
-0.013662632554769516,
0.2646621763706207,
-0.11435145884752274,
0.5431672930717468,
-0.9651566743850708,
-0.21440625190734863,
-0.5121119022369385,
0.11531854420900345,
0.0606146901845932,
0.8588380217552185,
0.27040013670921326,
0.6149696111679077,
0.3352217674255371,
-0.6105527281761169,
0.27610543370246887,
0.1438034623861313,
0.19858583807945251,
0.5267648696899414,
-0.5848641395568848,
0.41186025738716125,
-0.11853717267513275,
0.6676819920539856,
-0.8457724452018738,
0.06561668962240219,
0.28935861587524414,
-0.507114052772522,
0.28569167852401733,
-0.006755149457603693,
-0.3067149221897125,
-0.10811002552509308,
-0.5491988062858582,
0.2560051381587982,
-0.11426408588886261,
-0.8945671916007996,
1.1376979351043701,
0.2921178340911865,
0.2441651076078415,
-1.103692650794983,
-0.6347805261611938,
-0.14186044037342072,
-0.002966089639812708,
-0.7634475827217102,
0.36319467425346375,
0.022152921184897423,
-0.34831514954566956,
0.05532253533601761,
-0.1688022017478943,
0.12158820033073425,
0.15786176919937134,
0.49247387051582336,
-0.1296616494655609,
0.11382497847080231,
0.3378486633300781,
-0.042666248977184296,
-0.24229329824447632,
-0.01356694009155035,
-0.3062056303024292,
0.5047810673713684,
-0.2795690894126892,
-0.5044646859169006,
-0.1403600424528122,
0.42490270733833313,
0.525452733039856,
-0.15160861611366272,
0.810043215751648,
0.3949761986732483,
-0.2581116557121277,
-0.688549816608429,
-0.7423014640808105,
-0.46381112933158875,
-0.46858692169189453,
0.175864577293396,
-0.580211341381073,
-0.7411438226699829,
0.5190345644950867,
-0.29381436109542847,
0.07383255660533905,
0.23257456719875336,
0.6090799570083618,
0.2745957672595978,
0.7601232528686523,
0.7307071685791016,
0.0003291188913863152,
0.27131497859954834,
-0.571963906288147,
-0.2553824186325073,
-0.8128014802932739,
-0.4678303003311157,
-0.464468389749527,
-0.1848268061876297,
-0.22378955781459808,
-0.6337131857872009,
0.31115734577178955,
0.10910962522029877,
-0.18729855120182037,
0.09818287193775177,
-0.33424288034439087,
0.3182140588760376,
0.587826669216156,
0.32826754450798035,
0.32130196690559387,
-0.24749135971069336,
-0.534844696521759,
0.1269502192735672,
-0.6197452545166016,
-0.34530380368232727,
0.7303745150566101,
0.13591834902763367,
1.0741201639175415,
0.15975655615329742,
0.8379785418510437,
0.2682175040245056,
0.34456780552864075,
-0.675868809223175,
0.5448429584503174,
0.33020034432411194,
-0.37811797857284546,
-0.4574485719203949,
-0.39303112030029297,
-0.7863431572914124,
0.7610045075416565,
-0.42128169536590576,
-0.4094366729259491,
0.18517795205116272,
0.14927837252616882,
-0.04945406690239906,
0.3695296347141266,
-0.652039647102356,
0.5278077125549316,
-0.35570353269577026,
-0.958566427230835,
-0.6277117133140564,
-0.547799825668335,
0.04029706120491028,
0.4078558683395386,
0.17547103762626648,
0.019566167145967484,
-0.04231959953904152,
0.2904331684112549,
-0.48681432008743286,
1.0401586294174194,
-0.2677328288555145,
-0.11414308100938797,
0.3536086976528168,
-0.05660049244761467,
0.8375958204269409,
0.16707101464271545,
-0.25207576155662537,
-0.28871017694473267,
-0.5404950380325317,
-0.26035574078559875,
-0.7742984294891357,
0.533759355545044,
-0.9555405974388123,
-0.5523809194564819,
-0.24244940280914307,
-0.443901002407074,
-0.3088377118110657,
0.20997528731822968,
-0.02396782673895359,
0.36276668310165405,
-0.14261610805988312,
0.19449898600578308,
0.16097860038280487,
-0.025710906833410263,
0.32141005992889404,
0.7857968807220459,
-0.010332567617297173,
-0.6186332106590271,
0.5186879634857178,
0.029658522456884384,
0.24797013401985168,
0.5063967108726501,
0.0783277228474617,
-0.3563746213912964,
-0.3932509124279022,
-0.21537216007709503,
0.3641529381275177,
-0.8150492906570435,
-0.24037960171699524,
-0.6922748684883118,
0.05027763918042183,
-0.3825387954711914,
-0.46853214502334595,
-0.6217066645622253,
-0.08848469704389572,
-0.0912647619843483,
-0.447600781917572,
-0.06936202198266983,
0.7208400368690491,
-0.4688059091567993,
0.19125138223171234,
-0.4199923276901245,
0.23123490810394287,
0.16166488826274872,
0.27904215455055237,
0.17038194835186005,
0.038615476340055466,
-0.24871057271957397,
-0.11482752114534378,
-0.4538798928260803,
-0.84248286485672,
0.3966866433620453,
-0.0902741327881813,
0.9765665531158447,
0.19445917010307312,
0.42170068621635437,
0.6968413591384888,
-0.21007215976715088,
0.3645133972167969,
0.16170014441013336,
-0.9118609428405762,
0.21141944825649261,
-0.14365048706531525,
0.0999145582318306,
0.6278886795043945,
0.13046056032180786,
-0.22712232172489166,
-0.4250849783420563,
-0.6151627898216248,
-1.0095831155776978,
0.6497063040733337,
0.118010014295578,
-0.04771623760461807,
-0.05975596606731415,
0.4327825903892517,
-0.08676707744598389,
0.19793155789375305,
-0.8446455597877502,
-0.17177653312683105,
0.005911907181143761,
0.23516745865345,
-0.07480368763208389,
-0.3279407024383545,
-0.2293175458908081,
-0.19362591207027435,
0.5882296562194824,
-0.6698704361915588,
0.23998752236366272,
0.5989101529121399,
-0.14183752238750458,
-0.15767601132392883,
0.3976002335548401,
0.562006413936615,
0.4491631090641022,
-0.0690910592675209,
0.41610652208328247,
0.5324681997299194,
-0.032913267612457275,
0.35273677110671997,
-0.1362874060869217,
0.2952750325202942,
-0.3560841977596283,
0.7938278317451477,
0.680103063583374,
0.22938215732574463,
-0.45017895102500916,
0.5182549357414246,
-0.05488308146595955,
-0.41582053899765015,
-0.3200415074825287,
-0.03153621405363083,
-0.09407494962215424,
0.6587079167366028,
0.3454050123691559,
-0.08468734472990036,
0.1336577832698822,
-0.4374340772628784,
0.3827831745147705,
0.41680991649627686,
-0.3934667110443115,
-0.2406633496284485,
0.2432895302772522,
0.3921673595905304,
0.0880221277475357,
0.4643558859825134,
-0.2276344895362854,
-0.7006880640983582,
0.665794849395752,
0.6187574863433838,
0.9713727235794067,
-0.19592846930027008,
0.1966061294078827,
0.37393829226493835,
0.3597663342952728,
-0.2302878201007843,
0.25019243359565735,
-0.3708150386810303,
-0.9614024758338928,
-0.5778436064720154,
-0.04355285316705704,
-0.6034804582595825,
-0.2262391895055771,
-0.5181914567947388,
0.3155357241630554,
-0.3227338492870331,
-0.19695693254470825,
-0.5112767219543457,
0.27239373326301575,
-0.34992408752441406,
0.10936865955591202,
-0.03645132854580879,
0.5459811687469482,
-0.6629881262779236,
0.5717228055000305,
0.7669786214828491,
-0.40321120619773865,
-1.16327702999115,
-0.199774831533432,
0.07177406549453735,
-0.7683910727500916,
0.5880294442176819,
0.3953041732311249,
-0.866194486618042,
-0.12935149669647217,
-0.5762094855308533,
-0.7172486186027527,
1.2692561149597168,
0.5703651309013367,
-0.44138628244400024,
-0.21958032250404358,
-0.39067551493644714,
0.5459019541740417,
-0.4640284478664398,
0.7477610111236572,
0.15020404756069183,
0.48654186725616455,
0.27709636092185974,
-0.844278872013092,
0.3437321186065674,
-0.30922776460647583,
-0.4788273274898529,
0.027601445093750954,
-1.102242112159729,
0.7374333143234253,
-0.6220825910568237,
-0.14435569941997528,
-0.1052456945180893,
0.6843870878219604,
0.5044783353805542,
0.3940608501434326,
0.6491743326187134,
0.660006582736969,
0.7297992706298828,
0.14288398623466492,
0.9751029014587402,
-0.1853426992893219,
0.45282211899757385,
1.2087249755859375,
-0.3935682773590088,
0.6368414759635925,
0.34405675530433655,
0.25067147612571716,
0.36255842447280884,
0.0017794386949390173,
0.19503994286060333,
0.5477826595306396,
0.45041510462760925,
-0.1678898185491562,
-0.4660501480102539,
-0.17286477982997894,
-0.31908342242240906,
0.4702460467815399,
0.18872182071208954,
-0.11728082597255707,
-0.23247899115085602,
-0.11116825044155121,
0.15109696984291077,
0.33398303389549255,
-0.1310523897409439,
1.0083941221237183,
0.11577723920345306,
-0.9182830452919006,
0.5244527459144592,
-0.10415193438529968,
0.5986135601997375,
-0.4660060405731201,
-0.26383230090141296,
-0.19847455620765686,
0.5703765749931335,
-0.2748681306838989,
-0.530495285987854,
0.17108796536922455,
-0.3070884346961975,
-0.10731671005487442,
-0.35320767760276794,
0.7357392907142639,
-0.4201231598854065,
0.18994304537773132,
0.9551084041595459,
0.6654199361801147,
-0.17779333889484406,
-0.13417480885982513,
-0.46216312050819397,
0.06304027140140533,
-0.28701674938201904,
-0.3055574595928192,
0.016796113923192024,
0.4835616946220398,
-0.0279100239276886,
0.9883936047554016,
0.44015806913375854,
0.10755361616611481,
-0.2586289048194885,
0.20599406957626343,
1.1654462814331055,
-0.6675764918327332,
-0.7538871765136719,
-0.8376783728599548,
0.5087475180625916,
-0.12153974175453186,
-0.01701389066874981,
0.6105892062187195,
0.35598576068878174,
0.5928447246551514,
0.21848584711551666,
0.6404443979263306,
0.20695534348487854,
0.13368219137191772,
-0.6982740163803101,
0.592957079410553,
-0.7091055512428284,
0.2764284312725067,
-0.3538314700126648,
-0.6622657179832458,
-0.14306463301181793,
0.6037744879722595,
-0.20207257568836212,
0.21170981228351593,
0.7330981492996216,
0.5630270838737488,
0.2583810091018677,
-0.2464946061372757,
0.2794439494609833,
-0.04720721393823624,
0.5723463892936707,
0.5977401733398438,
0.9657003283500671,
0.10755506157875061,
0.3337574601173401,
-0.20601095259189606,
-0.47178781032562256,
-0.192695751786232,
-0.8998481035232544,
-0.965847909450531,
-0.4788132905960083,
-0.06889284402132034,
-0.42064380645751953,
0.31473878026008606,
1.2839683294296265,
1.0118300914764404,
-0.3628729283809662,
-0.3422555923461914,
-0.2117651253938675,
0.22140343487262726,
-0.47022920846939087,
-0.14801926910877228,
0.34156960248947144,
-0.644668459892273,
-0.4203702211380005,
0.569116473197937,
0.1646464318037033,
-0.264502614736557,
-0.18504278361797333,
-0.5502768754959106,
-0.18175946176052094,
0.032162413001060486,
0.46674200892448425,
0.23364336788654327,
-0.6478243470191956,
-0.18497127294540405,
0.013584611006081104,
-0.32984107732772827,
-0.056527093052864075,
0.8790469169616699,
-0.7669428586959839,
0.5658832788467407,
0.3438422679901123,
0.7875726819038391,
0.6300438642501831,
0.2763982117176056,
0.7875664830207825,
-0.7842097282409668,
0.2573446035385132,
0.20278288424015045,
0.40990597009658813,
0.19361430406570435,
-0.5002527832984924,
0.825596034526825,
0.13812334835529327,
-0.6545714139938354,
-0.5429383516311646,
-0.09662611037492752,
-1.043700933456421,
-0.2294781357049942,
1.2973532676696777,
-0.27385929226875305,
-0.1931064873933792,
0.1245269626379013,
-0.48626765608787537,
0.4507824182510376,
-0.5386489629745483,
0.7306545972824097,
0.5488808751106262,
-0.17682969570159912,
-0.29380232095718384,
-0.026363352313637733,
0.4240361154079437,
0.6804409027099609,
-1.0184518098831177,
0.09823240339756012,
0.6567732691764832,
-0.007101499941200018,
0.2110813409090042,
1.0618189573287964,
0.23225298523902893,
0.2686139643192291,
0.13209304213523865,
0.5541471838951111,
-0.46020835638046265,
-0.7435176968574524,
-0.15637093782424927,
0.17538365721702576,
0.2708747684955597,
-0.15936759114265442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14312v1
|
Improving Gloss-free Sign Language Translation by Reducing Representation Density
| 2024-05-23T08:32:58 | 2024-05-23T08:32:58 |
Jinhui Ye, Xing Wang, Wenxiang Jiao, Junwei Liang, Hui Xiong
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Gloss-free sign language translation (SLT) aims to develop well-performing
SLT systems with no requirement for the costly gloss annotations, but currently
still lags behind gloss-based approaches significantly. In this paper, we
identify a representation density problem that could be a bottleneck in
restricting the performance of gloss-free SLT. Specifically, the representation
density problem describes that the visual representations of semantically
distinct sign gestures tend to be closely packed together in feature space,
which makes gloss-free methods struggle with distinguishing different sign
gestures and suffer from a sharp performance drop. To address the
representation density problem, we introduce a simple but effective contrastive
learning strategy, namely SignCL, which encourages gloss-free models to learn
more discriminative feature representation in a self-supervised manner. Our
experiments demonstrate that the proposed SignCL can significantly reduce the
representation density and improve performance across various translation
frameworks. Specifically, SignCL achieves a significant improvement in BLEU
score for the Sign Language Transformer and GFSLT-VLP on the CSL-Daily dataset
by 39% and 46%, respectively, without any increase of model parameters.
Compared to Sign2GPT, a state-of-the-art method based on large-scale
pre-trained vision and language models, SignCL achieves better performance with
only 35% of its parameters. Implementation and Checkpoints are available at
https://github.com/JinhuiYE/SignCL.
|
[
-0.36363649368286133,
0.06834585964679718,
0.4987383782863617,
0.34580695629119873,
-0.7918021082878113,
0.015248707495629787,
-0.1719191074371338,
-0.7553091645240784,
0.33107611536979675,
0.6258253455162048,
-0.2962031364440918,
-0.700803816318512,
-0.9478909969329834,
-0.19133572280406952,
-0.29377099871635437,
1.0318080186843872,
-0.2060379683971405,
0.09501374512910843,
0.045776668936014175,
-0.3796598017215729,
-0.146037757396698,
-0.2281142920255661,
-0.7873315215110779,
-0.34697023034095764,
0.07808069884777069,
0.1904074102640152,
0.8478714227676392,
0.3832089304924011,
0.4554780423641205,
0.10478820651769638,
-0.15290066599845886,
0.1013251319527626,
-0.5673800706863403,
0.13062679767608643,
0.39273801445961,
-0.0875634178519249,
-0.32991358637809753,
-0.046048350632190704,
0.6153079867362976,
0.7707780003547668,
-0.015622211620211601,
-0.1569247841835022,
0.012862865813076496,
0.7459744215011597,
-0.45778194069862366,
0.2575836181640625,
-0.3983529508113861,
-0.022290008142590523,
-0.19856029748916626,
0.4110317528247833,
-0.3666680157184601,
-0.11420552432537079,
-0.06177552416920662,
-0.8383888006210327,
0.44762277603149414,
0.20702466368675232,
0.6638118624687195,
0.43485498428344727,
-0.48252224922180176,
-0.28081318736076355,
-0.665368378162384,
0.6379583477973938,
-0.6470016837120056,
0.7944341897964478,
0.41818568110466003,
0.173175647854805,
0.23066633939743042,
-0.09833516925573349,
-0.2378619760274887,
-0.41575559973716736,
-0.16501717269420624,
0.29691892862319946,
0.08355855196714401,
0.128022238612175,
0.28375765681266785,
0.2977120280265808,
-0.8852198719978333,
0.03789231926202774,
-0.4083860218524933,
-0.4312782287597656,
0.6993392705917358,
-0.1475035548210144,
0.03751305490732193,
0.14115889370441437,
-0.6893496513366699,
-0.47316908836364746,
-0.6580044031143188,
-0.0625942274928093,
-0.10906969010829926,
0.42934319376945496,
-0.31647783517837524,
0.17881251871585846,
0.0626043751835823,
0.4909965395927429,
-0.03953593596816063,
0.2441992312669754,
0.4254540801048279,
-0.20217633247375488,
0.056525737047195435,
0.04737171158194542,
0.666253924369812,
0.31281042098999023,
0.24045054614543915,
0.10877973586320877,
-0.5901513695716858,
-0.12182629108428955,
-0.26182347536087036,
-0.7858037352561951,
-0.45346683263778687,
0.06197755038738251,
-0.20877563953399658,
0.274183988571167,
0.20564764738082886,
-0.4304773211479187,
-0.700600266456604,
-0.03585955873131752,
0.2787920832633972,
-0.4863579273223877,
-0.540055513381958,
0.1642434448003769,
0.03221119940280914,
0.1800917536020279,
0.6104070544242859,
-0.9337336421012878,
0.5170364379882812,
0.28368157148361206,
0.9714035987854004,
-0.5862865447998047,
0.2992144525051117,
-0.4156586527824402,
0.3233630359172821,
-0.44752225279808044,
0.3407130241394043,
-0.10417800396680832,
-0.6168453693389893,
-0.21592068672180176,
-0.3981441557407379,
-0.13483202457427979,
-0.6509104371070862,
0.3256113827228546,
-0.3474051356315613,
-0.05620616674423218,
-0.20313945412635803,
-0.5293235778808594,
-0.022151699289679527,
-0.1013953685760498,
-0.922174870967865,
0.8656637668609619,
0.10946372151374817,
-0.2502433657646179,
0.3851070702075958,
-0.5325632691383362,
-0.5872344374656677,
0.3535548448562622,
-0.09723421186208725,
-0.564048171043396,
0.3729802668094635,
0.3016464114189148,
0.3285394012928009,
-0.0036219037137925625,
-0.17985086143016815,
0.07215255498886108,
-0.43898358941078186,
-0.03859557583928108,
0.05361013859510422,
0.5968146324157715,
0.37087810039520264,
-0.49818822741508484,
0.10050230473279953,
-0.613088071346283,
-0.12236147373914719,
0.17631959915161133,
0.05726209282875061,
-0.6977991461753845,
-0.315824419260025,
0.08385330438613892,
0.29680201411247253,
0.4102496802806854,
-0.398711621761322,
-0.052310798317193985,
-0.4712260961532593,
-0.1476423293352127,
0.44128844141960144,
-0.0734875500202179,
0.563377857208252,
0.23982958495616913,
0.36700519919395447,
0.3546980023384094,
0.29317963123321533,
0.26474136114120483,
-0.6992300152778625,
-0.8939692378044128,
-0.21263083815574646,
0.016748731955885887,
0.3797752261161804,
-0.6731042265892029,
0.038394466042518616,
-0.11784682422876358,
-0.2760704457759857,
-0.6579750776290894,
0.5236557126045227,
0.7986583113670349,
0.1394558548927307,
0.7565950751304626,
-0.7279632687568665,
-0.07023998349905014,
-0.7221890091896057,
-0.08332836627960205,
-0.15946616232395172,
0.08318191021680832,
-0.1438496857881546,
0.434317946434021,
0.250930517911911,
0.32225701212882996,
-0.5721946954727173,
-0.6002943515777588,
-0.21288764476776123,
0.06423531472682953,
0.10355032980442047,
0.5771453380584717,
0.4303135871887207,
-1.080651044845581,
-0.7406038641929626,
0.14414604008197784,
-0.31388092041015625,
-0.16413867473602295,
-0.1504494994878769,
0.24389587342739105,
0.35427165031433105,
0.52336186170578,
-0.4830353260040283,
0.494381844997406,
0.8372024893760681,
-0.5572599172592163,
0.4597941040992737,
-0.2560648024082184,
-0.05969005078077316,
-0.504751443862915,
0.0217468049377203,
0.0450233519077301,
-0.31533128023147583,
-0.8908817172050476,
0.05821695551276207,
0.28101563453674316,
-0.3879551589488983,
-0.6520068645477295,
0.6834040284156799,
-0.750514030456543,
-0.1940954327583313,
-0.19005592167377472,
0.56512051820755,
-0.05794667452573776,
0.39674243330955505,
0.15978902578353882,
0.7933405041694641,
0.418912798166275,
-0.6123441457748413,
-0.25905171036720276,
0.2845044732093811,
-0.1488061398267746,
0.4291698634624481,
-0.5873470306396484,
-0.06479677557945251,
0.011351536959409714,
-0.09067609161138535,
-1.1590262651443481,
0.21136532723903656,
0.3816733658313751,
-0.12650054693222046,
0.5805901885032654,
0.048749517649412155,
-0.26617491245269775,
-0.17630738019943237,
-0.12693925201892853,
0.3658837378025055,
0.7029680609703064,
-0.5097678303718567,
0.26186320185661316,
-0.0753350555896759,
0.23740185797214508,
-0.2921581268310547,
-0.8427330255508423,
-0.17424841225147247,
0.07739236205816269,
-0.5348600149154663,
0.34390026330947876,
-0.1558540314435959,
-0.012717822566628456,
-0.21761156618595123,
-0.4800255596637726,
0.22847189009189606,
0.008824802935123444,
0.0747009739279747,
-0.20609867572784424,
0.06420762836933136,
0.2408369481563568,
0.03507765382528305,
-0.4370829164981842,
-0.2569238245487213,
-0.3797065317630768,
0.43747103214263916,
-0.2314140647649765,
-0.5449030995368958,
-0.4936049282550812,
0.30737626552581787,
0.4477224051952362,
-0.2848343551158905,
0.6073782444000244,
0.6567074656486511,
0.05560538172721863,
-0.3544921576976776,
-0.25585225224494934,
-0.18254287540912628,
-0.4506637454032898,
0.13806426525115967,
-0.3314129412174225,
-0.9328862428665161,
0.6692109704017639,
-0.00519547238945961,
-0.044465940445661545,
0.3444000780582428,
0.21184435486793518,
-0.05422617495059967,
0.9888480305671692,
0.5511853694915771,
0.33948808908462524,
0.6245524287223816,
-0.2514079809188843,
0.08183731138706207,
-0.7696020007133484,
-0.10090967267751694,
-0.007705153431743383,
-0.17800122499465942,
-0.3178822994232178,
-0.7307945489883423,
0.4204084575176239,
0.26700359582901,
-0.023069830611348152,
0.6219083070755005,
-0.637649416923523,
0.18721628189086914,
0.24137616157531738,
0.11814277619123459,
0.4028385579586029,
0.017397496849298477,
-0.26394397020339966,
-0.1719965785741806,
-0.37287473678588867,
-0.18074829876422882,
0.7575204968452454,
0.09595741331577301,
0.43602052330970764,
0.28073251247406006,
1.0899865627288818,
0.23025444149971008,
0.26854076981544495,
-0.23528870940208435,
0.7465676665306091,
-0.6169611811637878,
-0.32811427116394043,
-0.24542848765850067,
-0.5617612600326538,
-0.8726294040679932,
0.6855860352516174,
-0.28231754899024963,
-0.3267977237701416,
0.3024890422821045,
0.387154221534729,
0.22139523923397064,
0.21099966764450073,
-0.7871617078781128,
0.9439290165901184,
-0.5773655772209167,
-0.1018652394413948,
-0.24316217005252838,
-0.728584885597229,
0.28659436106681824,
-0.03535795211791992,
0.26670730113983154,
-0.25819131731987,
-0.12880608439445496,
0.5327479243278503,
-0.4623176157474518,
0.9016175270080566,
-0.5605411529541016,
-0.5576103925704956,
0.15607231855392456,
0.3612480163574219,
0.5841155648231506,
-0.27994105219841003,
-0.10599260032176971,
0.1525554358959198,
-0.1808507889509201,
-0.6762000918388367,
-0.741334080696106,
0.46385595202445984,
-0.6771796941757202,
-0.4956994950771332,
-0.3119930326938629,
-0.5182569622993469,
-0.11106017231941223,
0.18313348293304443,
0.23077121376991272,
0.021062767133116722,
-0.26883724331855774,
-0.3789066970348358,
0.7435917258262634,
0.12237999588251114,
0.3411354124546051,
0.29388925433158875,
-0.3958769738674164,
-0.3632306456565857,
1.1912260055541992,
0.01656499318778515,
0.7666659951210022,
0.23807393014431,
0.24589170515537262,
-0.47152724862098694,
-0.9871999621391296,
-0.2837212085723877,
0.6261559128761292,
-0.8434240818023682,
0.04650061950087547,
-0.048897601664066315,
0.15774448215961456,
-0.43356820940971375,
-0.1627826690673828,
-0.4090692400932312,
-0.8318554162979126,
-0.22905592620372772,
0.06686148047447205,
0.2433699518442154,
0.5644225478172302,
-0.06234327703714371,
0.6207852959632874,
-0.25521960854530334,
0.35266822576522827,
0.09871106594800949,
0.3831036388874054,
-0.08634419739246368,
-0.36234164237976074,
-0.2801533043384552,
-0.1343698352575302,
-0.22375573217868805,
-0.7638359069824219,
0.28051719069480896,
0.42303597927093506,
0.36520954966545105,
0.5319386124610901,
0.21741953492164612,
0.6352816820144653,
-0.043178725987672806,
0.7359498739242554,
0.6404829621315002,
-1.021477222442627,
0.5674043893814087,
-0.07259032875299454,
0.6056479811668396,
0.593744695186615,
0.29630380868911743,
-0.5732946991920471,
-0.7463843822479248,
-0.5085867047309875,
-0.9638199210166931,
0.29804056882858276,
0.4434792101383209,
-0.043962955474853516,
0.00511624151840806,
0.23111186921596527,
0.0649193674325943,
0.25278013944625854,
-0.9164272546768188,
-0.25237295031547546,
-0.5212631225585938,
-0.22501370310783386,
-0.3567163944244385,
0.05977867543697357,
0.06378667056560516,
-0.2093529850244522,
0.6580686569213867,
-0.12038034200668335,
-0.017110833898186684,
0.2417292296886444,
-0.5238888263702393,
-0.0019805273041129112,
0.11272510141134262,
0.9622965455055237,
0.2521587610244751,
0.007649258244782686,
0.3998866379261017,
0.17086324095726013,
-0.6162417531013489,
0.041588012129068375,
-0.04111455753445625,
-0.569169819355011,
0.0807882621884346,
0.28144770860671997,
0.9582025408744812,
0.22362414002418518,
-0.4954531192779541,
0.6302944421768188,
0.2894113063812256,
-0.2863931357860565,
-0.04275348782539368,
0.11541744321584702,
-0.009285283274948597,
0.10634339600801468,
0.3892282247543335,
-0.0010845320066437125,
-0.09234805405139923,
0.08852862566709518,
0.17969468235969543,
0.4222278296947479,
-0.7310011386871338,
-0.19461867213249207,
0.7659916281700134,
0.23183366656303406,
-0.03294150531291962,
0.5031540989875793,
-0.43376684188842773,
-0.5006198883056641,
0.2954295575618744,
0.7599855661392212,
0.7424496412277222,
-0.5070276856422424,
0.40428683161735535,
0.3636437654495239,
0.3183925449848175,
-0.2582911550998688,
0.2805781662464142,
-0.3013882339000702,
-0.4823962152004242,
-0.2788645327091217,
-0.44568148255348206,
-0.5094225406646729,
-0.33706921339035034,
-0.37586215138435364,
0.07839705049991608,
-0.634300708770752,
0.0032241791486740112,
-0.6151912212371826,
0.0923326388001442,
-0.3998180031776428,
0.22248999774456024,
0.38059738278388977,
0.5248130559921265,
-1.0480215549468994,
0.777449905872345,
0.43467625975608826,
-0.5827434659004211,
-0.36807700991630554,
-0.25053638219833374,
-0.08510123193264008,
-0.7410286068916321,
0.6232888102531433,
0.17188620567321777,
-0.37620383501052856,
0.16404320299625397,
-0.5275468826293945,
-0.8702016472816467,
0.9759124517440796,
0.5165261626243591,
-0.6711582541465759,
0.2916789948940277,
0.36505112051963806,
0.7325518727302551,
-0.4884628653526306,
-0.17813384532928467,
0.3489294648170471,
0.7012772560119629,
0.17659269273281097,
-0.7646945714950562,
0.5299714207649231,
-0.027028925716876984,
0.2630322575569153,
0.5048360824584961,
-0.5672318339347839,
0.48637041449546814,
-0.25035014748573303,
-0.6110243201255798,
-0.03839217126369476,
0.8519359827041626,
0.3583522439002991,
0.36350980401039124,
0.5749146938323975,
0.5676140785217285,
0.9168146848678589,
-0.1507112830877304,
0.8077849745750427,
-0.22243376076221466,
0.4100184440612793,
0.6864533424377441,
-0.30783507227897644,
0.7527822256088257,
0.7141963243484497,
0.045765895396471024,
0.3488936126232147,
0.19847285747528076,
-0.1375121772289276,
0.4880039691925049,
0.32221078872680664,
-0.34751757979393005,
-0.5452070236206055,
0.18439236283302307,
-0.24441784620285034,
0.052333176136016846,
0.5262421369552612,
-0.21845901012420654,
-0.4462429881095886,
0.2814779579639435,
-0.08063440769910812,
0.44583314657211304,
-0.31311148405075073,
0.47435688972473145,
0.35913488268852234,
-0.2233753800392151,
0.9923795461654663,
-0.4896204471588135,
0.5843366384506226,
-0.7105064988136292,
-0.029518824070692062,
-0.3080024719238281,
-0.009949461556971073,
-0.22903794050216675,
-0.6848419904708862,
0.22305062413215637,
-0.5664229393005371,
0.056162115186452866,
-0.5992766618728638,
0.579274594783783,
-0.7338280081748962,
-0.36102086305618286,
0.6205649971961975,
0.45510804653167725,
0.5728129148483276,
0.05803246796131134,
-0.7990136742591858,
0.23798002302646637,
-0.10598690807819366,
-0.023178258910775185,
0.3231959342956543,
0.12130380421876907,
-0.3658505976200104,
0.6039221286773682,
0.5586745738983154,
0.2692389488220215,
0.06266370415687561,
0.22690720856189728,
0.5503088235855103,
-0.6175054907798767,
-0.4685634970664978,
-0.3377353847026825,
0.3966037929058075,
-0.1214437186717987,
-0.4142347574234009,
0.6154797673225403,
0.47632431983947754,
0.7479314208030701,
-0.20476838946342468,
0.38890349864959717,
0.022234931588172913,
0.06567014008760452,
-0.6079586744308472,
0.828203558921814,
-0.5996756553649902,
0.2192961424589157,
-0.3068380355834961,
-0.8875219821929932,
-0.9789817929267883,
0.7009056210517883,
-0.33811047673225403,
0.06375714391469955,
0.6965512037277222,
0.6531563401222229,
-0.05354920029640198,
-0.33606696128845215,
0.7987318634986877,
0.06728564202785492,
0.4097510874271393,
0.8263819813728333,
0.3321218192577362,
-0.7143444418907166,
0.8741531372070312,
-0.10751208662986755,
0.028868665918707848,
-0.3113274574279785,
-0.8186908960342407,
-0.6976282596588135,
-0.7908813953399658,
-0.6633751392364502,
-0.2649797797203064,
0.17513319849967957,
0.48225969076156616,
0.6841654181480408,
-0.8963416814804077,
-0.4197264611721039,
-0.11210831254720688,
0.20306873321533203,
-0.7430650591850281,
-0.13508599996566772,
0.6413394212722778,
-0.35026997327804565,
-0.3510071337223053,
0.514460563659668,
0.11222787201404572,
0.40205052495002747,
-0.09883562475442886,
-0.5949695110321045,
0.10160660743713379,
-0.40071240067481995,
0.5592976808547974,
0.6242272257804871,
-0.7073071002960205,
-0.4481135904788971,
-0.18414190411567688,
-0.1753804236650467,
0.1968035101890564,
0.833789050579071,
-0.5344771146774292,
0.5077143311500549,
0.24271760880947113,
0.18719811737537384,
1.1680198907852173,
0.06623237580060959,
0.25040534138679504,
-1.0046696662902832,
0.19368518888950348,
0.11324089765548706,
0.11318609863519669,
0.6522688269615173,
-0.15815815329551697,
0.39041221141815186,
0.2532311677932739,
-0.1581679880619049,
-0.33772775530815125,
0.6822007894515991,
-1.4160653352737427,
-0.2420303374528885,
0.976481020450592,
0.1483248472213745,
-0.1165178120136261,
-0.30883732438087463,
-0.14460238814353943,
0.14202480018138885,
-0.48467880487442017,
0.4044671952724457,
0.2953494191169739,
-0.4562242925167084,
-0.5999847650527954,
-0.389728307723999,
0.7532660365104675,
0.6426156163215637,
-0.21253839135169983,
0.3169872760772705,
0.4497716426849365,
0.14904451370239258,
0.46483114361763,
0.8061515092849731,
-0.23013952374458313,
0.32834017276763916,
-0.15700596570968628,
0.4136355519294739,
-0.2092255800962448,
-0.14397922158241272,
-0.5073345899581909,
0.2410677969455719,
0.27360764145851135,
0.028654903173446655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14277v1
|
Improving Language Models Trained with Translated Data via Continual Pre-Training and Dictionary Learning Analysis
| 2024-05-23T07:53:04 | 2024-05-23T07:53:04 |
Sabri Boughorbel, MD Rizwan Parvez, Majd Hawasly
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training LLMs in low resources languages usually utilizes data augmentation
with machine translation (MT) from English language. However, translation
brings a number of challenges: there are large costs attached to translating
and curating huge amounts of content with high-end machine translation
solutions, the translated content carries over cultural biases, and if the
translation is not faithful and accurate, the quality of the data degrades
causing issues in the trained model. In this work we investigate the role of
translation and synthetic data in training language models. We translate
TinyStories, a dataset of 2.2M short stories for 3-4 year old children, from
English to Arabic using the free NLLB-3B MT model. We train a number of story
generation models of sizes 1M-33M parameters using this data. We identify a
number of quality and task-specific issues in the resulting models. To rectify
these issues, we further pre-train the models with a small dataset of
synthesized high-quality stories, representing 1\% of the original training
data, using a capable LLM in Arabic. We show using GPT-4 as a judge and
dictionary learning analysis from mechanistic interpretability that the
suggested approach is a practical means to resolve some of the translation
pitfalls. We illustrate the improvement through case studies of linguistic
issues and cultural bias.
|
[
-0.14373961091041565,
-0.605963408946991,
0.48910221457481384,
0.11702127009630203,
-0.4117850959300995,
0.131557896733284,
-0.3008708357810974,
-0.5289397835731506,
0.071632981300354,
0.5062053799629211,
-0.5835379362106323,
-0.3098612129688263,
-0.580428421497345,
0.2352495640516281,
-0.425507515668869,
1.1173511743545532,
-0.5414610505104065,
0.2117994874715805,
-0.10317432135343552,
-0.25700366497039795,
-0.5533285737037659,
-0.6423149108886719,
-0.624895453453064,
-0.19089393317699432,
0.2452850639820099,
0.4928564429283142,
0.787265956401825,
0.682829737663269,
0.2704838514328003,
0.20550769567489624,
0.17724381387233734,
0.413119375705719,
-0.5599572658538818,
0.04116194322705269,
-0.02452898398041725,
-0.5107850432395935,
-0.30924421548843384,
0.25546994805336,
0.5821124911308289,
0.8730120062828064,
0.020836148411035538,
0.17274747788906097,
0.36570724844932556,
0.6357693076133728,
-0.20085468888282776,
0.19719016551971436,
-0.570141613483429,
0.19806402921676636,
-0.3485371470451355,
-0.03946581110358238,
-0.17417407035827637,
-0.31333792209625244,
0.09062875062227249,
-0.6036983132362366,
0.40892285108566284,
0.03683393821120262,
0.768007218837738,
0.2246866524219513,
-0.44249317049980164,
-0.6020928621292114,
-0.6294093728065491,
1.054305076599121,
-0.8176204562187195,
0.43515560030937195,
0.5145889520645142,
0.13555504381656647,
-0.23347312211990356,
-0.593644917011261,
-0.695796012878418,
-0.24278534948825836,
-0.24172343313694,
-0.022488994523882866,
-0.002041596919298172,
-0.35544389486312866,
0.12537088990211487,
0.257938951253891,
-0.5568938851356506,
0.06931803375482559,
-0.3317650556564331,
-0.29004842042922974,
0.5327781438827515,
0.3370228409767151,
0.30091625452041626,
-0.2583223283290863,
-0.048518240451812744,
-0.21353475749492645,
-0.9610021710395813,
-0.03878502920269966,
0.4607454836368561,
0.2807605564594269,
-0.20879939198493958,
0.40052223205566406,
-0.19315944612026215,
0.6199117302894592,
-0.04570924490690231,
-0.17956946790218353,
0.40242800116539,
-0.6988199353218079,
0.12337873876094818,
-0.09473012387752533,
0.679119348526001,
0.3277369439601898,
0.5070472359657288,
-0.26954230666160583,
-0.4248374104499817,
-0.14785189926624298,
0.195928156375885,
-0.8332158923149109,
-0.06102683022618294,
0.15593868494033813,
-0.45514917373657227,
-0.43172016739845276,
-0.4728552997112274,
-0.5571205019950867,
-0.1354132890701294,
-0.3827708959579468,
0.2222764939069748,
-0.5368276238441467,
-0.1361997276544571,
-0.01526143029332161,
0.3820660710334778,
-0.05010242760181427,
0.24039651453495026,
-1.0175105333328247,
0.20676864683628082,
0.27265802025794983,
0.9086451530456543,
-0.3318274915218353,
-0.2522132992744446,
-0.43918362259864807,
0.1791865974664688,
-0.6700868606567383,
0.5785108208656311,
-0.20199435949325562,
-0.47540730237960815,
0.023834271356463432,
-0.07441385835409164,
-0.07984313368797302,
-0.8053904175758362,
0.5334731936454773,
-0.37609216570854187,
0.3084122836589813,
-0.030699528753757477,
-0.29181987047195435,
0.06379105150699615,
0.46598851680755615,
-0.6796783208847046,
0.8930855989456177,
0.3537669777870178,
-0.43568864464759827,
0.41450923681259155,
-0.44573938846588135,
-0.47772669792175293,
0.03745788708329201,
-0.01950901746749878,
-0.33531734347343445,
0.3741348087787628,
0.6036646962165833,
0.41129806637763977,
-0.2698756754398346,
0.30207738280296326,
0.012006200850009918,
-0.18778029084205627,
0.1734514832496643,
-0.6324122548103333,
0.4163949489593506,
0.46545112133026123,
-0.052914198487997055,
-0.1250848025083542,
-0.7297235131263733,
0.011558882892131805,
0.18097393214702606,
-0.3538876473903656,
-0.22239026427268982,
0.07177126407623291,
0.09401153773069382,
0.47018370032310486,
0.3591884970664978,
-0.2904095947742462,
0.28710177540779114,
-0.6624568104743958,
0.3249785006046295,
0.5416350960731506,
0.009107631631195545,
0.5191803574562073,
-0.3241366147994995,
0.6578140258789062,
0.37957578897476196,
0.22143958508968353,
-0.010143009014427662,
-0.37046971917152405,
-0.6975550651550293,
0.04525173455476761,
0.4569619297981262,
0.3620118498802185,
-1.333980679512024,
-0.01956433616578579,
-0.6329022645950317,
-0.2457234263420105,
-0.7074425220489502,
0.4913580119609833,
0.1950206756591797,
0.5079656839370728,
0.5572134256362915,
-0.41286036372184753,
-0.49317505955696106,
-0.7220823764801025,
-0.26355838775634766,
-0.09847145527601242,
-0.20432956516742706,
0.009723961353302002,
0.39331918954849243,
-0.47566336393356323,
0.9613191485404968,
0.020223557949066162,
-0.316848486661911,
-0.4546140134334564,
0.22586606442928314,
0.3999221920967102,
0.6638697385787964,
0.6022371053695679,
-0.637435257434845,
-0.6935506463050842,
0.08490250259637833,
-0.6158890128135681,
-0.21789178252220154,
-0.32969164848327637,
0.011927656829357147,
0.4586450755596161,
0.31619134545326233,
-0.644961416721344,
0.3051121234893799,
0.729383647441864,
-0.030914921313524246,
0.5969717502593994,
-0.24855560064315796,
0.048847947269678116,
-1.1910645961761475,
-0.21879731118679047,
-0.21868391335010529,
-0.3152935206890106,
-0.7223550081253052,
-0.03853868320584297,
0.07268572598695755,
-0.046759672462940216,
-0.5221630930900574,
0.7043924927711487,
-0.3909156322479248,
0.13129448890686035,
-0.24567009508609772,
0.020750563591718674,
-0.06535109132528305,
0.2450670599937439,
0.08042638748884201,
0.8796818852424622,
0.12036864459514618,
-0.4557631015777588,
0.34861382842063904,
0.2098044455051422,
-0.45154595375061035,
0.43523386120796204,
-0.3962880074977875,
0.20803508162498474,
0.18449881672859192,
-0.008648715913295746,
-0.6644672751426697,
-0.1895931363105774,
0.3517974615097046,
-0.5012261867523193,
0.44496411085128784,
-0.17901360988616943,
-0.92446368932724,
-0.29838332533836365,
-0.19779598712921143,
0.2701835632324219,
0.4300837218761444,
-0.6137570142745972,
0.5289671421051025,
-0.0027797750663012266,
-0.3037673532962799,
-0.41609326004981995,
-0.5723981261253357,
0.10237781703472137,
-0.2444995939731598,
-0.5625194907188416,
0.17189626395702362,
-0.10527040809392929,
-0.07654200494289398,
0.19096685945987701,
-0.40255314111709595,
-0.22143062949180603,
0.1007319763302803,
-0.21023279428482056,
0.20785439014434814,
-0.18072780966758728,
0.0870303139090538,
0.14196844398975372,
-0.16553880274295807,
0.060001522302627563,
-0.3962312638759613,
0.5571215748786926,
-0.11077193170785904,
0.03010512888431549,
-0.1147402971982956,
0.20006927847862244,
0.3540673553943634,
-0.07462572306394577,
1.0690609216690063,
0.5803394317626953,
-0.2556993365287781,
-0.282042533159256,
-0.4535138010978699,
-0.0506240651011467,
-0.457304447889328,
0.3472920060157776,
-0.6000458598136902,
-0.6087871789932251,
0.4782346785068512,
0.028849627822637558,
-0.09352981299161911,
0.4881976246833801,
0.5101925730705261,
-0.4730679392814636,
1.275941014289856,
0.573914647102356,
-0.2512870132923126,
0.4171048700809479,
-0.2734018862247467,
0.16021715104579926,
-0.5377888679504395,
0.04808581620454788,
-0.23513981699943542,
-0.2666422128677368,
-0.6293554306030273,
-0.3269897699356079,
0.40928226709365845,
0.35249757766723633,
0.0903308093547821,
0.3067208528518677,
-0.049133822321891785,
0.511394739151001,
0.299331396818161,
-0.048055071383714676,
0.3069939613342285,
0.2572081387042999,
-0.15099000930786133,
-0.2658000886440277,
-0.81089848279953,
-0.6915180087089539,
1.3300700187683105,
0.31810441613197327,
0.6145073175430298,
0.2108984738588333,
0.8611549139022827,
-0.013213610276579857,
0.6122298240661621,
-0.7587946057319641,
0.2512008547782898,
-0.18116827309131622,
-0.4826122224330902,
-0.10916348546743393,
-0.738167405128479,
-0.9052894711494446,
0.2387925535440445,
-0.19715061783790588,
-0.43975168466567993,
0.018839452415704727,
0.1982751339673996,
-0.1821146309375763,
0.04203931242227554,
-0.8036008477210999,
0.8903568983078003,
-0.5713585019111633,
-0.37387335300445557,
-0.26089873909950256,
-0.49984297156333923,
0.2399730533361435,
-0.7222076654434204,
0.3919975161552429,
0.17502279579639435,
0.07123550772666931,
0.8023937344551086,
-0.533540666103363,
0.6889815330505371,
-0.09241877496242523,
-0.19698598980903625,
0.13967137038707733,
0.30419260263442993,
0.6068122386932373,
-0.010787789709866047,
-0.011906551197171211,
0.32609114050865173,
0.37245818972587585,
-0.6294519901275635,
-0.6612833738327026,
0.4973274767398834,
-0.8590964674949646,
-0.6102456450462341,
-0.37861183285713196,
-0.9021310806274414,
-0.6114376187324524,
0.1451205462217331,
0.22131124138832092,
0.1834677755832672,
0.08936557918787003,
0.18758676946163177,
0.37354618310928345,
-0.1993720680475235,
0.3340376615524292,
0.7334172129631042,
-0.16241726279258728,
-0.27219358086586,
0.9111695885658264,
0.30844372510910034,
0.4207591414451599,
-0.11575407534837723,
0.0712999626994133,
-0.3260563611984253,
-0.9327713251113892,
-0.6018092036247253,
0.29906561970710754,
-0.5488295555114746,
-0.15025952458381653,
-0.2703097462654114,
-0.1019112765789032,
-0.43037909269332886,
-0.01432795263826847,
-0.3767963647842407,
-0.38534021377563477,
-0.34067201614379883,
-0.10801880806684494,
0.011317145079374313,
0.6057757139205933,
-0.13854193687438965,
0.5986742377281189,
-1.1236674785614014,
0.3072395324707031,
-0.0643426775932312,
0.16391050815582275,
-0.16091835498809814,
-0.7969128489494324,
-0.730894148349762,
0.3025471866130829,
-0.4183056056499481,
-0.7442131042480469,
0.8109813928604126,
0.1380215883255005,
0.46181297302246094,
0.22905825078487396,
-0.3012644648551941,
0.7907976508140564,
-0.8085399270057678,
0.7227815389633179,
0.030761543661355972,
-0.8727586269378662,
0.4912289083003998,
-0.2512108385562897,
0.14579173922538757,
0.4760288596153259,
0.5098942518234253,
-0.6436643600463867,
-0.19165927171707153,
-0.6116748452186584,
-0.6577601432800293,
0.7643935084342957,
0.2781325876712799,
0.40280166268348694,
0.03222643584012985,
0.36910349130630493,
0.1596250981092453,
0.2889513373374939,
-0.7057626247406006,
0.10074159502983093,
-0.27017566561698914,
-0.5183576345443726,
-0.3357662260532379,
-0.3384346067905426,
0.0909683033823967,
-0.3461785614490509,
0.7999813556671143,
-0.1364717036485672,
-0.14359991252422333,
-0.27217379212379456,
-0.5515690445899963,
-0.053096938878297806,
0.11907689273357391,
0.335455983877182,
0.596684455871582,
-0.18085657060146332,
-0.1126224547624588,
0.24937376379966736,
-0.6150513887405396,
0.3507753908634186,
0.13596247136592865,
-0.11351703107357025,
0.0157431922852993,
0.5565171837806702,
0.6543382406234741,
-0.07432407140731812,
-0.6529473662376404,
0.42078500986099243,
0.031779929995536804,
0.08541139215230942,
-0.22479680180549622,
-0.07711073756217957,
-0.030801206827163696,
0.11544682830572128,
0.20321378111839294,
-0.16516241431236267,
-0.08872780203819275,
-0.6142992377281189,
0.10646560043096542,
0.17205317318439484,
-0.13891203701496124,
-0.409664124250412,
0.45808765292167664,
0.1756344884634018,
0.07410144060850143,
0.8949094414710999,
-0.20387409627437592,
-0.4878234267234802,
0.39326199889183044,
0.6236807107925415,
0.5101320147514343,
-0.398121178150177,
0.23979981243610382,
0.14186353981494904,
0.6323525309562683,
-0.18618759512901306,
0.11255813390016556,
-0.0069540515542030334,
-1.033866286277771,
-0.6042008996009827,
-0.7729644179344177,
-0.3169698119163513,
0.2739875614643097,
-0.5472308397293091,
0.07299536466598511,
-0.04025447741150856,
0.17900416254997253,
-0.5256962180137634,
0.21600790321826935,
-0.8752323985099792,
0.30146732926368713,
0.06935858726501465,
0.7332350015640259,
-0.9363884329795837,
1.2819103002548218,
0.4503369629383087,
-0.5927748680114746,
-0.8038994073867798,
0.06783658266067505,
-0.23372995853424072,
-0.734877347946167,
0.9665358662605286,
0.05966595932841301,
0.08970225602388382,
0.27902892231941223,
-0.5388473272323608,
-0.8396179676055908,
0.6772381663322449,
0.3268105685710907,
-0.6119576692581177,
-0.014275566674768925,
0.6468023061752319,
0.8051948547363281,
-0.28876593708992004,
-0.10696469992399216,
0.9062905311584473,
0.23073570430278778,
-0.11275669932365417,
-0.8158419132232666,
-0.2379327416419983,
-0.18237541615962982,
0.11534548550844193,
0.001331169856712222,
-0.046502046287059784,
0.6941027045249939,
0.020073041319847107,
-0.2529125213623047,
0.2839816212654114,
0.5494347214698792,
0.16568341851234436,
0.16987477242946625,
0.34075412154197693,
0.48903748393058777,
0.5772397518157959,
-0.17105799913406372,
1.2194854021072388,
-0.27216973900794983,
0.33533400297164917,
1.144980549812317,
-0.2400275021791458,
0.7193259000778198,
0.7011611461639404,
-0.15198495984077454,
0.23180612921714783,
0.8384211659431458,
0.10148335248231888,
0.7546593546867371,
0.17453894019126892,
-0.19819970428943634,
-0.05490516498684883,
0.004646343644708395,
-0.3164968490600586,
0.1731516271829605,
0.6245751976966858,
-0.22959540784358978,
-0.23922573029994965,
0.35194405913352966,
0.10387811809778214,
-0.06814315915107727,
-0.2192697823047638,
0.6520911455154419,
0.10185553133487701,
-0.358603298664093,
0.8153191804885864,
0.07160315662622452,
0.5656357407569885,
-0.6038638949394226,
0.02622057870030403,
-0.6755479574203491,
0.12701548635959625,
-0.06312216073274612,
-0.4750818908214569,
0.38488298654556274,
0.17708036303520203,
-0.20991195738315582,
-0.4853023886680603,
0.39148953557014465,
-0.5898270606994629,
-0.6514344811439514,
0.020020857453346252,
0.765733540058136,
0.26200002431869507,
-0.014245333150029182,
-0.6863552331924438,
0.08177261799573898,
-0.022945893928408623,
-0.24567709863185883,
0.30526289343833923,
0.5114505290985107,
-0.26837030053138733,
0.5437657833099365,
0.7463467121124268,
0.6018540263175964,
0.04956253618001938,
-0.011833755299448967,
0.6867190599441528,
-0.47212374210357666,
-0.37559235095977783,
-0.772770345211029,
0.29879871010780334,
0.07083997875452042,
-0.05243458226323128,
0.7562549114227295,
0.4577719569206238,
1.160900592803955,
-0.19755905866622925,
0.6889896392822266,
0.1915254145860672,
0.6217598915100098,
-0.7793009877204895,
0.8438391089439392,
-0.5492217540740967,
0.3212134540081024,
0.07758472859859467,
-1.0470622777938843,
-0.1337396502494812,
0.6708036661148071,
-0.5185087323188782,
-0.0381133109331131,
0.8459972739219666,
0.7002393007278442,
-0.19661356508731842,
-0.19221945106983185,
0.3428400158882141,
0.4408808946609497,
0.48639410734176636,
0.5932234525680542,
0.9801153540611267,
-0.5260176062583923,
0.5722357034683228,
-0.3281024396419525,
0.06272213160991669,
0.023228995501995087,
-0.6991479992866516,
-0.7620804309844971,
-0.4583745300769806,
-0.08811274915933609,
-0.3145540654659271,
-0.0663294568657875,
0.8577836155891418,
0.5804530382156372,
-1.0576789379119873,
-0.22779658436775208,
-0.022849349305033684,
-0.03935398533940315,
-0.12071165442466736,
-0.17993547022342682,
0.3602558374404907,
-0.645472526550293,
-0.8310333490371704,
0.598698079586029,
-0.2119373083114624,
0.2348814606666565,
-0.1274355947971344,
-0.23879145085811615,
0.18171261250972748,
0.0633191168308258,
0.646327018737793,
0.03347568213939667,
-0.4818512201309204,
-0.4180249571800232,
-0.2833252251148224,
-0.18050293624401093,
-0.042367056012153625,
0.667110800743103,
-0.8409833908081055,
0.5531259775161743,
0.06482379138469696,
0.8227437138557434,
0.5948700904846191,
-0.21280542016029358,
0.6463778614997864,
-1.0358253717422485,
0.3510580360889435,
0.2073623239994049,
0.40844014286994934,
0.4383338689804077,
-0.2268066704273224,
0.6922000646591187,
0.35799968242645264,
-0.2129134088754654,
-0.817681610584259,
0.14635853469371796,
-0.37434396147727966,
-0.14367017149925232,
0.9740722179412842,
-0.16377593576908112,
-0.15566785633563995,
-0.024486476555466652,
-0.18001078069210052,
0.3034198582172394,
0.16679558157920837,
0.8046353459358215,
1.132656455039978,
0.10381411015987396,
-0.12726709246635437,
-0.9919095039367676,
0.5868792533874512,
0.5148261785507202,
-0.7817971110343933,
-0.17265933752059937,
0.5731541514396667,
0.32608434557914734,
0.006137121934443712,
0.41890430450439453,
-0.19857679307460785,
0.1485557109117508,
-0.2015329748392105,
-0.035017114132642746,
-0.03876407444477081,
-0.35041144490242004,
-0.3978663682937622,
-0.19807158410549164,
0.04087420180439949,
-0.09341979026794434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14259v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14259v3
|
Let's Fuse Step by Step: A Generative Fusion Decoding Algorithm with LLMs for Multi-modal Text Recognition
| 2024-05-23T07:39:42 | 2024-06-02T16:30:00 |
Chan-Jan Hsu, Yi-Chang Chen, Feng-Ting Liao, Pei-Chen Ho, Yu-Hsiang Wang, Po-Chun Hsu, Da-shan Shiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce "Generative Fusion Decoding" (GFD), a novel shallow fusion
framework, utilized to integrate Large Language Models (LLMs) into multi-modal
text recognition systems such as automatic speech recognition (ASR) and optical
character recognition (OCR). We derive the formulas necessary to enable GFD to
operate across mismatched token spaces of different models by mapping text
token space to byte token space, enabling seamless fusion during the decoding
process. The framework is plug-and-play, compatible with various
auto-regressive models, and does not require re-training for feature alignment,
thus overcoming limitations of previous fusion techniques. We highlight three
main advantages of GFD: First, by simplifying the complexity of aligning
different model sample spaces, GFD allows LLMs to correct errors in tandem with
the recognition model, reducing computation latencies. Second, the in-context
learning ability of LLMs is fully capitalized by GFD, increasing robustness in
long-form speech recognition and instruction aware speech recognition. Third,
GFD enables fusing recognition models deficient in Chinese text recognition
with LLMs extensively trained on Chinese. Our evaluation demonstrates that GFD
significantly improves performance in ASR and OCR tasks, with ASR reaching
state-of-the-art in the NTUML2021 benchmark. GFD provides a significant step
forward in model integration, offering a unified solution that could be widely
applicable to leveraging existing pre-trained models through step by step
fusion.
|
[
-0.09666058421134949,
-0.39525705575942993,
0.46126338839530945,
0.07614380866289139,
-0.4669027030467987,
0.2261122614145279,
0.08430863916873932,
-0.5746473073959351,
-0.2443636804819107,
0.5191885232925415,
-0.6578643321990967,
-0.6226876974105835,
-0.545045793056488,
0.26342085003852844,
-0.6733417510986328,
0.6393698453903198,
0.01698722317814827,
0.3755943775177002,
-0.3794029951095581,
0.11469998210668564,
-0.3793465495109558,
-0.33959245681762695,
-0.33769655227661133,
-0.4703986942768097,
0.2873326539993286,
0.31387826800346375,
0.5909119248390198,
0.7362057566642761,
0.5875383615493774,
0.38132983446121216,
-0.035004209727048874,
0.20851276814937592,
-0.23568211495876312,
0.036381933838129044,
0.19850200414657593,
-0.23086267709732056,
-0.19369012117385864,
-0.18168357014656067,
0.7351155877113342,
0.7483026385307312,
0.03066156432032585,
-0.4341934621334076,
0.12209209054708481,
0.3934924602508545,
-0.4273624122142792,
0.011243443004786968,
-0.47970446944236755,
0.025401199236512184,
-0.08047811686992645,
-0.1732989251613617,
-0.3528018891811371,
-0.320109486579895,
0.054337285459041595,
-0.33545541763305664,
0.34688329696655273,
0.06759050488471985,
0.5875547528266907,
0.27633073925971985,
-0.7375858426094055,
-0.22800086438655853,
-0.8177152872085571,
0.6983884572982788,
-0.46029606461524963,
0.9652889370918274,
0.2770291268825531,
0.3043566942214966,
-0.28802919387817383,
-0.6842620372772217,
-0.8851603865623474,
-0.052361201494932175,
-0.1772994101047516,
0.1037667766213417,
0.06891757994890213,
0.31864219903945923,
0.11232072114944458,
0.8958876729011536,
-0.6954376101493835,
0.1895413100719452,
-0.3812771141529083,
-0.4073110520839691,
0.6230488419532776,
0.09607840329408646,
0.3955516517162323,
-0.1988760083913803,
-0.791907548904419,
-0.32623326778411865,
-0.5930270552635193,
-0.10286515206098557,
-0.14257051050662994,
0.4545430839061737,
-0.4656834304332733,
0.457918643951416,
0.033939216285943985,
0.8982033729553223,
0.06357449293136597,
-0.407313734292984,
0.15091048181056976,
-0.8075220584869385,
-0.49694716930389404,
0.22551044821739197,
0.9767479300498962,
0.0016870839754119515,
-0.3555169999599457,
-0.3062238395214081,
-0.1605207771062851,
0.28074944019317627,
-0.18892638385295868,
-0.5292041897773743,
0.013324791565537453,
0.20095044374465942,
-0.4723120331764221,
-0.0623079352080822,
0.05435139685869217,
-0.6704806089401245,
-0.6438035368919373,
-0.1990550309419632,
0.5221781730651855,
-0.6383508443832397,
-0.13777196407318115,
0.48006948828697205,
-0.2491164356470108,
0.5553445816040039,
0.3125881254673004,
-0.9484549164772034,
0.16472561657428741,
0.7302629947662354,
0.8221455812454224,
-0.22116529941558838,
-0.4033953547477722,
-0.4658394753932953,
0.25126487016677856,
-0.13934274017810822,
0.6945299506187439,
-0.4851531982421875,
-0.9073818325996399,
0.021330470219254494,
-0.25407058000564575,
-0.166589617729187,
-0.32709968090057373,
0.6619642972946167,
-0.4301469624042511,
0.3950745761394501,
-0.29455238580703735,
-0.5300671458244324,
-0.18393002450466156,
0.05991465598344803,
-0.8498340249061584,
0.7383750081062317,
0.060116641223430634,
-0.6778927445411682,
0.3081915080547333,
-0.46517616510391235,
-0.757207989692688,
0.09826673567295074,
-0.32127270102500916,
-0.25989070534706116,
0.0667102113366127,
0.39340153336524963,
0.4955351650714874,
-0.5756778120994568,
-0.18205632269382477,
-0.15612846612930298,
-0.32075226306915283,
-0.05128656327724457,
-0.6753992438316345,
0.9303556680679321,
0.20859958231449127,
-0.058371953666210175,
0.4320394694805145,
-0.80130535364151,
-0.25055697560310364,
-0.025898588821291924,
-0.49258044362068176,
-0.2782377302646637,
-0.06322605907917023,
0.22158753871917725,
0.13271790742874146,
0.1670837253332138,
-0.5837673544883728,
0.34028083086013794,
-0.6176643371582031,
0.4115651249885559,
0.556229829788208,
-0.12488119304180145,
0.6966040134429932,
-0.14687210321426392,
0.2839611768722534,
0.10403712838888168,
0.010883755050599575,
-0.5956962704658508,
-0.2451777309179306,
-0.7910684943199158,
-0.4217679798603058,
0.38759949803352356,
0.7181439995765686,
-1.1324419975280762,
0.8167646527290344,
-0.352165549993515,
-0.563270628452301,
-0.597386360168457,
0.27339601516723633,
0.3910285532474518,
0.5302571654319763,
0.266043484210968,
-0.36657971143722534,
-0.48021200299263,
-0.5789706110954285,
0.21416735649108887,
-0.21093164384365082,
-0.07405455410480499,
-0.015720997005701065,
0.21376219391822815,
-0.40659961104393005,
0.7992682456970215,
-0.26717251539230347,
-0.7509551048278809,
-0.38508471846580505,
0.04654785618185997,
0.09309171885251999,
0.5998885631561279,
0.1398870050907135,
-1.0858750343322754,
-0.3525554835796356,
0.3856760859489441,
-0.7463424205780029,
0.31276509165763855,
-0.16872482001781464,
0.022223593667149544,
0.12472239136695862,
0.7059571146965027,
-0.5664299726486206,
0.08756081759929657,
0.7931520938873291,
-0.48298805952072144,
0.230976864695549,
-0.21696622669696808,
0.4049322307109833,
-1.3332051038742065,
-0.13951261341571808,
-0.12820109724998474,
-0.204111248254776,
-0.8137145042419434,
0.14428728818893433,
0.05373165383934975,
-0.33145245909690857,
-0.44920048117637634,
0.29600250720977783,
-0.6076034307479858,
-0.18661367893218994,
-0.15863633155822754,
-0.0001799157471396029,
-0.02773040160536766,
0.17365092039108276,
0.08230965584516525,
0.8374635577201843,
0.6988365054130554,
-0.5055468082427979,
0.5016546845436096,
0.3026983141899109,
-0.32350704073905945,
0.5569833517074585,
-0.40508508682250977,
0.13784727454185486,
-0.18355023860931396,
0.31003350019454956,
-1.3239619731903076,
-0.3020981550216675,
0.13526539504528046,
-0.1990969479084015,
0.39382654428482056,
0.2713233232498169,
-0.5328958034515381,
-0.2923196852207184,
-0.238960400223732,
0.7039734721183777,
0.5007175803184509,
-0.8483585715293884,
1.3691399097442627,
0.20136116445064545,
0.08144163340330124,
-0.21916770935058594,
-0.7040407657623291,
-0.08432581275701523,
0.1262829601764679,
-0.9412159323692322,
0.8767262101173401,
-0.1485593318939209,
0.2096950113773346,
-0.09449231624603271,
-0.057906560599803925,
-0.1383371353149414,
-0.06386487185955048,
0.24650655686855316,
0.3208544850349426,
-0.15565848350524902,
-0.027687866240739822,
0.13713137805461884,
-0.35374516248703003,
-0.4040473997592926,
-0.10509634763002396,
0.8161270022392273,
-0.015560053288936615,
-0.674964964389801,
-0.4541519582271576,
0.5925066471099854,
0.7134155631065369,
-0.4056159555912018,
0.4176390469074249,
0.8555814027786255,
-0.4283701777458191,
-0.01139803510159254,
-0.5274048447608948,
-0.1225166842341423,
-0.5500209927558899,
0.25174805521965027,
-0.27362143993377686,
-1.0724818706512451,
0.40505725145339966,
0.029733901843428612,
0.1094612330198288,
0.5007719993591309,
0.38793811202049255,
-0.04790288954973221,
0.9343141913414001,
0.9930909872055054,
-0.48340925574302673,
0.443740576505661,
-0.017047666013240814,
0.2620809078216553,
-0.6462891101837158,
-0.5013875961303711,
-0.5377776622772217,
-0.19905270636081696,
-0.20946857333183289,
-0.6681394577026367,
0.5178363919258118,
0.20841899514198303,
0.2105693370103836,
0.10068273544311523,
-0.5362321734428406,
0.6609798669815063,
0.37699806690216064,
0.14880408346652985,
0.5809237360954285,
-0.036442358046770096,
0.0338108167052269,
0.05874740332365036,
-0.6337109208106995,
0.16498368978500366,
0.7500505447387695,
0.16294072568416595,
0.9843989610671997,
0.0036857356317341328,
0.9859968423843384,
0.2993014454841614,
0.06104344129562378,
-0.9080663323402405,
0.6406753659248352,
-0.3585989475250244,
0.0022927301470190287,
-0.21578019857406616,
-0.28620123863220215,
-0.725854754447937,
0.38862645626068115,
-0.34122759103775024,
-0.3650735020637512,
0.2691477835178375,
0.21572554111480713,
-0.3246563673019409,
0.22860750555992126,
-0.7094671726226807,
0.6329273581504822,
-0.28868621587753296,
0.1414349526166916,
-0.17040741443634033,
-0.5973506569862366,
0.7399245500564575,
0.12210004031658173,
0.13041190803050995,
0.28184258937835693,
-0.025496138259768486,
0.475308358669281,
-0.11961235851049423,
0.6726163625717163,
0.14271560311317444,
-0.39367541670799255,
-0.06528062373399734,
-0.21798460185527802,
0.39554277062416077,
-0.4328160881996155,
0.036899127066135406,
0.26688718795776367,
-0.11910688877105713,
0.02481013722717762,
-0.5207645893096924,
0.7609142661094666,
-0.4934527277946472,
-0.41506466269493103,
-0.5078120827674866,
-0.5178271532058716,
-0.08773212879896164,
0.22975827753543854,
0.36601826548576355,
0.47316041588783264,
-0.21646207571029663,
0.20627394318580627,
0.8637378811836243,
0.0039911880157887936,
0.5408754348754883,
0.18966065347194672,
-0.2995325028896332,
-0.6264352798461914,
1.1434682607650757,
-0.29419007897377014,
0.3553078770637512,
0.6210947036743164,
-0.013334459625184536,
-0.43401333689689636,
-0.33753323554992676,
-0.6118648648262024,
0.10252771526575089,
-0.8350359201431274,
-0.34874653816223145,
-0.596645176410675,
-0.4705498218536377,
-0.5245943069458008,
-0.36004751920700073,
-0.13149219751358032,
0.09325111657381058,
-0.5017651319503784,
0.05257565528154373,
0.17492802441120148,
0.4079422056674957,
0.10543359816074371,
0.3060464560985565,
-0.9880409836769104,
0.7543560266494751,
0.4538874626159668,
0.20156283676624298,
-0.09891383349895477,
-0.2382814735174179,
-0.0887923464179039,
-0.23302055895328522,
-0.06022985652089119,
-0.9803824424743652,
0.2140762209892273,
0.3693046271800995,
0.4104510545730591,
0.4735149145126343,
-0.05268478021025658,
0.7842763662338257,
-0.545932948589325,
0.8832746744155884,
0.4890934228897095,
-1.1337043046951294,
0.30737069249153137,
-0.17845730483531952,
0.5357822775840759,
0.2814393937587738,
0.30248117446899414,
-0.5708215236663818,
-0.07457588613033295,
-0.10930125415325165,
-0.7315693497657776,
0.7403238415718079,
-0.1753263622522354,
0.04110540449619293,
0.218476802110672,
0.09854944050312042,
0.04206796735525131,
-0.04012710228562355,
-0.705033540725708,
-0.24012312293052673,
-0.1471266895532608,
-0.4436887800693512,
-0.18764172494411469,
-0.26664265990257263,
-0.1194402351975441,
-0.30654025077819824,
0.3324923813343048,
-0.2062281221151352,
0.42976269125938416,
0.09121821820735931,
-0.1833886206150055,
0.021511990576982498,
0.30268314480781555,
0.5892680883407593,
-0.10948346555233002,
0.18745362758636475,
0.17598485946655273,
0.18949046730995178,
-0.33703774213790894,
0.12772150337696075,
0.41873347759246826,
0.013799520209431648,
-0.07789536565542221,
0.5181494355201721,
0.7051311135292053,
0.4860161244869232,
-0.5567471981048584,
0.49179837107658386,
-0.06602153182029724,
-0.32599061727523804,
0.054372966289520264,
0.18760903179645538,
-0.006010915152728558,
0.4219515025615692,
0.5371896028518677,
0.10737462341785431,
0.2695389986038208,
-0.5036033987998962,
0.1669905185699463,
0.6805592179298401,
-0.3876163959503174,
-0.19767503440380096,
0.5194656252861023,
0.3083101212978363,
-0.2816929221153259,
0.5260199904441833,
0.11318179965019226,
-0.6819210648536682,
0.24039949476718903,
0.8419871926307678,
1.033379077911377,
-0.47092998027801514,
0.11531896144151688,
0.19606167078018188,
0.14348509907722473,
-0.16200898587703705,
0.39551907777786255,
-0.3696971833705902,
-0.8011411428451538,
-0.343258798122406,
-0.9055646657943726,
-0.3430267572402954,
-0.05027145519852638,
-0.4331703186035156,
0.270063191652298,
-0.5428330898284912,
0.20562568306922913,
-0.15445742011070251,
-0.3661816418170929,
-0.5524900555610657,
0.21944458782672882,
0.16198104619979858,
0.915000319480896,
-0.9612541198730469,
0.813470721244812,
0.09355735033750534,
-0.2546834647655487,
-0.6311079263687134,
-0.011994628235697746,
0.2278185337781906,
-0.7556833624839783,
0.2599339783191681,
0.24301666021347046,
-0.2606751322746277,
0.22601990401744843,
-0.34192532300949097,
-0.9194496273994446,
1.2688307762145996,
0.3453741669654846,
-0.36802539229393005,
-0.16624894738197327,
0.11657074093818665,
0.20762281119823456,
-0.33620667457580566,
-0.19678768515586853,
0.6887714266777039,
0.29438892006874084,
0.5685600638389587,
-0.9939142465591431,
0.07456707209348679,
-0.15957780182361603,
0.11626966297626495,
0.2095954418182373,
-0.26329559087753296,
0.83516925573349,
-0.29703205823898315,
-0.6624518632888794,
0.2062748372554779,
0.9519702792167664,
0.09423723071813583,
-0.11582336574792862,
0.4629904627799988,
0.3777572214603424,
0.5730796456336975,
-0.2532697021961212,
1.1853960752487183,
-0.2619093358516693,
0.012905478477478027,
0.6246993541717529,
-0.24553999304771423,
1.0533337593078613,
0.35598132014274597,
-0.17930811643600464,
0.4666975140571594,
0.36343809962272644,
-0.13040682673454285,
0.8316667079925537,
-0.309739351272583,
-0.6584009528160095,
-0.4744528532028198,
-0.1366293728351593,
-0.5705150365829468,
0.4551900327205658,
0.3147924244403839,
-0.3155234456062317,
-0.46827200055122375,
0.30734169483184814,
-0.3995603621006012,
0.08608897030353546,
-0.40638935565948486,
0.9998059868812561,
0.13044597208499908,
-0.3061673939228058,
0.5037755966186523,
0.23329193890094757,
1.116594672203064,
-0.9029179215431213,
-0.09264715015888214,
0.08875284343957901,
0.15680840611457825,
-0.3820849657058716,
-0.6209850907325745,
0.1384439617395401,
-0.34698814153671265,
-0.4592772126197815,
-0.3539075553417206,
1.0351223945617676,
-0.8842375874519348,
-0.5709577202796936,
0.2386738806962967,
0.2329152524471283,
-0.16400717198848724,
0.13373737037181854,
-0.5359926223754883,
0.6331287026405334,
0.13394595682621002,
0.4077201783657074,
0.4642450511455536,
-0.0018730968004092574,
0.28160014748573303,
0.5814636945724487,
0.9811172485351562,
-0.25277477502822876,
0.020113898441195488,
0.11359302699565887,
0.9195585250854492,
-0.6565719246864319,
-0.5970758199691772,
-0.8546715378761292,
0.6554393172264099,
0.15857720375061035,
-0.08088691532611847,
0.7963761687278748,
0.3262650668621063,
0.797697901725769,
-0.09255818277597427,
0.766577959060669,
0.05816672742366791,
0.1868995577096939,
-0.8989250659942627,
0.7039945125579834,
-0.7162995338439941,
0.19559215009212494,
-0.2934654951095581,
-0.81805819272995,
-0.5919681787490845,
0.6586077213287354,
0.11960122734308243,
0.06685427576303482,
0.530481219291687,
0.7838121652603149,
-0.04167070984840393,
0.1562715619802475,
0.42603349685668945,
-0.12786008417606354,
0.558388352394104,
0.5366426706314087,
0.48935815691947937,
-0.6458737850189209,
0.5216720700263977,
-0.07028251141309738,
-0.17799963057041168,
-0.15239985287189484,
-0.6892333030700684,
-0.7569563984870911,
-0.8219302892684937,
-0.016240635886788368,
-0.3215252757072449,
-0.3104763329029083,
0.860103189945221,
0.476422518491745,
-0.6564264297485352,
-0.2122887670993805,
-0.021777233108878136,
0.3726091682910919,
-0.22344566881656647,
-0.20817556977272034,
0.3377549946308136,
-0.20082183182239532,
-0.7983619570732117,
0.7194698452949524,
0.5587131977081299,
0.33411261439323425,
-0.44463005661964417,
-0.2534356713294983,
-0.14711476862430573,
-0.14127115905284882,
0.7493110299110413,
0.4707406163215637,
-0.8873192667961121,
-0.14263896644115448,
-0.03953603655099869,
-0.377381294965744,
-0.11173790693283081,
0.7332475185394287,
-0.7490821480751038,
0.534360945224762,
0.6666867136955261,
0.8933007717132568,
0.1912127435207367,
-0.0790553018450737,
0.7527967095375061,
-0.6633572578430176,
0.13740481436252594,
0.04641653597354889,
0.3794727027416229,
0.5333710312843323,
-0.21973134577274323,
0.0998772457242012,
0.253237247467041,
-0.2645310163497925,
-0.900897741317749,
0.43206652998924255,
-1.3297348022460938,
0.01753169484436512,
0.9528900980949402,
0.13208812475204468,
-0.148530974984169,
-0.06661740690469742,
-0.37360942363739014,
-0.00782881397753954,
-0.20909900963306427,
0.5336056351661682,
0.3611278533935547,
-0.09695944935083389,
-0.3995201587677002,
0.46396055817604065,
0.7075856328010559,
0.14394444227218628,
-0.7364945411682129,
0.08744846284389496,
0.7628629803657532,
0.04415722191333771,
0.368775874376297,
0.8227673768997192,
-0.05175323411822319,
0.4786669611930847,
0.2770480811595917,
-0.13342243432998657,
-0.2793200612068176,
-0.44677433371543884,
-0.6964136362075806,
0.3107355833053589,
-0.22073650360107422,
-0.1588020771741867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14247v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14247v1
|
Text-Based Correlation Matrix in Multi-Asset Allocation
| 2024-05-23T07:25:51 | 2024-05-23T07:25:51 |
Yasuhiro Nakayama, Tomochika Sawaki, Issei Furuya, Shunsuke Tamura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The purpose of this study is to estimate the correlation structure between
multiple assets using financial text analysis. In recent years, as the
background of elevating inflation in the global economy and monetary policy
tightening by central banks, the correlation structure between assets,
especially interest rate sensitivity and inflation sensitivity, has changed
dramatically, increasing the impact on the performance of investors'
portfolios. Therefore, the importance of estimating a robust correlation
structure in portfolio management has increased. On the other hand, the
correlation coefficient using only the historical price data observed in the
financial market is accompanied by a certain degree of time lag, and also has
the aspect that prediction errors can occur due to the nonstationarity of
financial time series data, and that the interpretability from the viewpoint of
fundamentals is a little poor when a phase change occurs. In this study, we
performed natural language processing on news text and central bank text to
verify the prediction accuracy of future correlation coefficient changes. As a
result, it was suggested that this method is useful in comparison with the
prediction from ordinary time series data.
|
[
-0.10515662282705307,
-1.0361864566802979,
0.12350281327962875,
0.42578125,
-0.08162833005189896,
0.22688764333724976,
-0.02970791421830654,
-0.5653895735740662,
0.4822435975074768,
0.28798747062683105,
-0.1736234724521637,
-0.33279770612716675,
-0.5456811785697937,
-0.10001523792743683,
-0.35046079754829407,
1.2932077646255493,
-0.040214527398347855,
-0.0844152644276619,
-0.16487915813922882,
-0.060840487480163574,
-0.49462270736694336,
-0.5529319047927856,
-0.3989405632019043,
-0.23454582691192627,
0.22552186250686646,
0.1796981245279312,
0.7650039196014404,
0.5500695705413818,
1.0247828960418701,
0.3052486777305603,
-0.18154855072498322,
0.09212016314268112,
-0.12093666940927505,
0.01248094905167818,
0.04196798428893089,
-0.3435207009315491,
-0.7980695962905884,
-0.14235037565231323,
0.8041471242904663,
0.3827025890350342,
-0.003334479173645377,
0.24646709859371185,
0.03805136680603027,
0.8628713488578796,
-0.7312589287757874,
0.38083821535110474,
-0.41022059321403503,
-0.10791099816560745,
-0.3776688575744629,
-0.5878621339797974,
-0.31710466742515564,
-0.19927941262722015,
0.732608437538147,
-0.5166042447090149,
0.3664078116416931,
0.14194364845752716,
0.9646946787834167,
0.06586244702339172,
-0.44077038764953613,
-0.5855039358139038,
-0.7408645153045654,
1.1437355279922485,
-0.4314885139465332,
0.1830429881811142,
0.4916576147079468,
0.2747667729854584,
-0.007996958680450916,
-0.34501808881759644,
-0.30191725492477417,
0.11230184882879257,
-0.24055205285549164,
0.13214755058288574,
0.0723876804113388,
-0.44843539595603943,
-0.20524238049983978,
0.5239999294281006,
-0.3820981979370117,
-0.3582952916622162,
-0.35398542881011963,
-0.30456599593162537,
0.39797478914260864,
0.09504307061433792,
0.08104358613491058,
-0.1804140955209732,
-0.9253438711166382,
-0.3293280601501465,
-0.08558060228824615,
0.03287258744239807,
0.45562607049942017,
0.4866501986980438,
-0.6209874749183655,
0.5220546722412109,
0.26518693566322327,
0.33798032999038696,
0.1398213654756546,
-0.6396113038063049,
0.35418909788131714,
-0.641242504119873,
-0.1340002864599228,
0.2644607424736023,
0.5131108164787292,
0.3937411606311798,
0.07983331382274628,
-0.0004891548305749893,
0.302396684885025,
0.06281416118144989,
0.04868892580270767,
-0.5063516497612,
-0.08448846638202667,
0.09018340706825256,
-0.6984925270080566,
-0.3921203911304474,
0.09480908513069153,
-1.3367356061935425,
0.048743851482868195,
-0.2688554525375366,
0.19021855294704437,
-0.4624457359313965,
-0.09028416126966476,
0.09444860368967056,
-0.1460440307855606,
0.3493601977825165,
0.08084874600172043,
-0.8643592596054077,
0.3505585193634033,
0.43742209672927856,
0.9583899974822998,
-0.22128455340862274,
0.04005781561136246,
-0.26631784439086914,
0.6596072316169739,
-0.04903246834874153,
1.1534721851348877,
-0.48507845401763916,
-0.5793346762657166,
-0.02939913608133793,
-0.4299592673778534,
-0.3597581088542938,
-0.08632899075746536,
0.5892539620399475,
-0.5637364983558655,
0.3365493416786194,
-0.08338159322738647,
-0.23987989127635956,
-0.09010586887598038,
0.34093159437179565,
-0.8793050050735474,
0.8527620434761047,
-0.03525606170296669,
-1.2904969453811646,
0.30980604887008667,
-0.794417679309845,
-0.35757720470428467,
-0.636237621307373,
0.3314082622528076,
-1.2112443447113037,
-0.5290469527244568,
0.7027251720428467,
0.12450233101844788,
-0.4610418975353241,
0.39494428038597107,
-0.5763688683509827,
-0.04194879159331322,
0.7266347408294678,
-0.4915187656879425,
0.3062961995601654,
0.28885605931282043,
-0.06167474761605263,
-0.1374332308769226,
-1.1175341606140137,
-0.12142820656299591,
-0.3027612566947937,
-0.052046999335289,
-0.42191147804260254,
0.3621068596839905,
0.25196805596351624,
-0.14764797687530518,
0.5740751624107361,
-0.12324611097574234,
0.13559699058532715,
-0.19900162518024445,
0.03797592595219612,
0.7699158787727356,
0.22846005856990814,
0.5558306574821472,
-0.5252798795700073,
0.4863376021385193,
0.3791036307811737,
0.14008675515651703,
-0.2027376890182495,
-0.3241364657878876,
-0.5360077619552612,
-0.44953152537345886,
0.19240371882915497,
0.7036254405975342,
-0.015341393649578094,
0.3531883656978607,
-0.14151552319526672,
-0.361199289560318,
0.07347878068685532,
-0.021052230149507523,
0.2765929400920868,
0.7128060460090637,
0.6339972615242004,
-0.16895270347595215,
-0.7883660197257996,
-0.8816738724708557,
-0.2086930274963379,
-0.3428659439086914,
0.4246937036514282,
0.0023062562104314566,
0.170452281832695,
-0.14599652588367462,
1.051123857498169,
-0.8187171816825867,
-0.516649067401886,
0.12318934500217438,
0.5666688084602356,
0.2209567278623581,
0.3652585744857788,
0.6988469362258911,
-0.7159596085548401,
-0.5526780486106873,
0.08170562237501144,
-0.38845089077949524,
-0.12743791937828064,
-0.2844187617301941,
-0.2415182739496231,
0.1345140039920807,
0.3764194846153259,
0.008660150691866875,
0.5420470237731934,
0.5969752073287964,
-0.2821377217769623,
0.3896619379520416,
-0.2853761315345764,
0.05014127865433693,
-1.337020754814148,
0.4223212003707886,
0.2183016538619995,
0.14607596397399902,
-0.4934554100036621,
-0.45901453495025635,
0.03137243911623955,
0.12183476239442825,
-0.019800180569291115,
0.4604737162590027,
-0.3568025827407837,
-0.15918710827827454,
-0.046265505254268646,
0.1713339388370514,
-0.014140435494482517,
0.4055233299732208,
-0.23532408475875854,
0.9607077836990356,
0.39134231209754944,
-0.47374260425567627,
-0.20800477266311646,
0.40055787563323975,
-0.29391971230506897,
0.6633580327033997,
-0.3178860545158386,
-0.13416919112205505,
-0.2504615783691406,
0.20652525126934052,
-0.9715809226036072,
0.22629468142986298,
0.029842117801308632,
-0.34958308935165405,
0.3467727601528168,
0.4384939670562744,
-0.19960638880729675,
-0.1499507874250412,
-0.49458685517311096,
0.36355677247047424,
-0.4199523329734802,
-0.26305752992630005,
0.4665350914001465,
0.3634299039840698,
-0.031464964151382446,
-1.0334386825561523,
-0.6916251182556152,
-0.10754851251840591,
-0.3853284418582916,
-0.7000886797904968,
0.368472158908844,
-0.44521433115005493,
-0.4094671607017517,
0.05092182755470276,
-0.04940704628825188,
-0.48735272884368896,
0.2616236209869385,
-0.009693179279565811,
0.7302908897399902,
-0.2565630078315735,
0.14853216707706451,
-0.1438824087381363,
-0.44862884283065796,
-0.18960757553577423,
0.05908181518316269,
0.26876315474510193,
-0.18814407289028168,
0.06730438768863678,
-0.4674714207649231,
0.18406027555465698,
0.40376016497612,
-0.4083103537559509,
0.9120367765426636,
0.609842836856842,
0.0371411070227623,
0.29969698190689087,
-0.3599401116371155,
0.3802429735660553,
-0.42824339866638184,
0.1903078705072403,
-0.143573597073555,
-0.6169761419296265,
0.9516311883926392,
0.32087019085884094,
-0.12116236984729767,
0.698307454586029,
0.773492693901062,
0.3363076150417328,
0.598205029964447,
0.5986350774765015,
-0.36860665678977966,
0.7114057540893555,
-0.12745387852191925,
0.3251824676990509,
-0.7425412535667419,
-0.3829643726348877,
-0.7620269060134888,
-0.46705329418182373,
-0.6224545836448669,
-0.15546272695064545,
0.2892470359802246,
0.0565410740673542,
-0.09782145917415619,
0.19220532476902008,
-0.2990429103374481,
0.15679942071437836,
0.20821049809455872,
-0.19292302429676056,
0.45508408546447754,
0.048336293548345566,
-0.34398096799850464,
-0.05868047848343849,
-0.017109444364905357,
-0.46173959970474243,
1.3745652437210083,
0.3534090220928192,
0.9147055745124817,
0.26318034529685974,
0.15139232575893402,
0.39275476336479187,
0.4033147692680359,
-0.35844865441322327,
-0.09943892061710358,
-0.06456106901168823,
-0.735351026058197,
-0.04194142296910286,
-0.23137211799621582,
-0.8644564747810364,
0.11369776725769043,
-0.4450063705444336,
-0.6164982914924622,
0.5466486215591431,
0.08297524601221085,
-0.38950279355049133,
0.23840975761413574,
-0.7893280982971191,
0.4391688406467438,
0.022486303001642227,
-0.21907256543636322,
-0.17898350954055786,
-0.480148583650589,
0.3755500316619873,
-0.32323482632637024,
0.36074766516685486,
-0.22252288460731506,
-0.15059596300125122,
0.5954806804656982,
-0.2146722674369812,
0.5736254453659058,
0.3429011404514313,
-0.0728740319609642,
0.48035162687301636,
-0.24587345123291016,
0.35395780205726624,
0.19822539389133453,
-0.43466487526893616,
-0.001472302246838808,
0.23917244374752045,
-0.6436108350753784,
-0.29601430892944336,
0.703414797782898,
-1.123806118965149,
-0.10203460603952408,
-0.6984466910362244,
-0.8557407259941101,
-0.1462889164686203,
0.025610776618123055,
-0.17002485692501068,
0.39926987886428833,
-0.357479989528656,
0.3002811670303345,
0.07344178855419159,
-0.21806024014949799,
0.7798488736152649,
0.5848058462142944,
-0.03715306520462036,
-0.7975593209266663,
0.5100037455558777,
-0.02025523968040943,
0.16242022812366486,
0.9536885023117065,
0.4220871329307556,
-0.286422461271286,
-0.23135261237621307,
0.16408281028270721,
0.04272402450442314,
-0.29504910111427307,
-0.34996724128723145,
-0.5390770435333252,
0.0220062043517828,
-0.6073125600814819,
-0.3188226521015167,
-0.1777602881193161,
-0.2226133644580841,
-0.615753173828125,
-0.035893913358449936,
0.43283867835998535,
0.3266701400279999,
-0.19805163145065308,
0.6421870589256287,
-0.6610044240951538,
0.26414892077445984,
0.10019248723983765,
0.3839122951030731,
0.1260550171136856,
0.00502919452264905,
-0.722405195236206,
-0.009051205590367317,
-0.8041975498199463,
-0.8489611148834229,
0.6773820519447327,
0.24988362193107605,
0.21845117211341858,
0.6567701697349548,
-0.12594878673553467,
1.1021782159805298,
-0.14314775168895721,
0.4893748462200165,
0.07068908214569092,
-0.8261808156967163,
0.20408549904823303,
-0.4766485393047333,
0.22033971548080444,
0.3827928304672241,
-0.19272764027118683,
-0.33977651596069336,
-0.46952903270721436,
-0.5777297616004944,
-0.6390381455421448,
0.7685068845748901,
0.2638302743434906,
-0.20790959894657135,
-0.06238684803247452,
0.2884249985218048,
-0.06386226415634155,
0.23664069175720215,
-0.5760245323181152,
-0.6295179724693298,
-0.1876927614212036,
-0.13642928004264832,
-0.0011241409229114652,
-0.39627933502197266,
0.1661740094423294,
0.03523838520050049,
0.5401632785797119,
-0.14917097985744476,
0.47150614857673645,
0.33019793033599854,
0.0859675481915474,
-0.6418136358261108,
0.2812733054161072,
0.8345191478729248,
0.914941668510437,
-0.6825799942016602,
0.05981461703777313,
0.15622729063034058,
-0.465998113155365,
-0.10041466355323792,
0.12438465654850006,
0.10782279074192047,
-0.09582092612981796,
0.37589314579963684,
0.5462291836738586,
0.4566074013710022,
-0.4532812833786011,
0.4237632155418396,
-0.1342121958732605,
-0.0728650689125061,
-0.5846529603004456,
-0.40678542852401733,
-0.22285865247249603,
0.21667928993701935,
0.5448891520500183,
0.42476990818977356,
-0.00183311034925282,
-0.47731465101242065,
0.4334619641304016,
0.38591548800468445,
-0.21002228558063507,
-0.47249045968055725,
0.7415217757225037,
-0.21537290513515472,
0.15523330867290497,
0.06508979201316833,
0.3427833616733551,
-0.36653438210487366,
0.6379280090332031,
0.7264561653137207,
0.7929922342300415,
-0.3333180844783783,
0.26266852021217346,
0.3951658010482788,
0.1220322698354721,
-0.048447269946336746,
0.17955371737480164,
0.22675581276416779,
-0.6903409957885742,
-0.6347991824150085,
-0.5893006324768066,
-0.3550930321216583,
0.11916376650333405,
-0.6279590129852295,
0.5261218547821045,
-0.507856547832489,
-0.38960886001586914,
0.20276500284671783,
0.427911639213562,
-0.3657214045524597,
0.05618567019701004,
-0.012933101505041122,
0.4455749988555908,
-0.8204959630966187,
0.7512561678886414,
0.4736311733722687,
-0.2773999273777008,
-0.3518161475658417,
-0.027902204543352127,
0.05831489339470863,
-0.6301773190498352,
0.5859860181808472,
-0.07474633306264877,
0.2758571207523346,
-0.4835275411605835,
-0.31489789485931396,
-1.3596761226654053,
1.101705551147461,
0.16868509352207184,
-0.00610483530908823,
-0.0728200227022171,
0.018998658284544945,
0.5690135359764099,
-0.2793232500553131,
0.3321883976459503,
0.11148392409086227,
0.6573863625526428,
0.11033083498477936,
-0.7230504751205444,
-0.5437125563621521,
-0.11506383866071701,
-0.15636564791202545,
0.717586100101471,
-1.0370606184005737,
1.2923150062561035,
0.22405804693698883,
-0.19253145158290863,
0.19310013949871063,
0.9300538897514343,
0.0528329573571682,
0.5119411945343018,
0.21908897161483765,
0.56290602684021,
0.6516653895378113,
0.28011593222618103,
0.9373342394828796,
-0.7069489359855652,
0.7034822106361389,
0.9675912261009216,
-0.12321063131093979,
0.9312450289726257,
0.5321890711784363,
-0.4241326153278351,
0.9547869563102722,
0.21745873987674713,
-0.17750342190265656,
0.4757709503173828,
-0.41605690121650696,
-0.14540992677211761,
0.011316448450088501,
-0.07750150561332703,
-0.37034106254577637,
0.46883952617645264,
0.37113291025161743,
-0.4531366527080536,
-0.4247084856033325,
-0.4415580630302429,
0.12493792176246643,
0.2159346342086792,
-0.1420874297618866,
0.44091466069221497,
0.06552733480930328,
-0.44909319281578064,
-0.051569126546382904,
0.20991183817386627,
0.6284241080284119,
-0.6099190711975098,
0.3492560088634491,
0.24700535833835602,
0.5611708760261536,
-0.008498095907270908,
-0.35453030467033386,
0.5758959650993347,
-0.18885383009910583,
-0.464974582195282,
-0.248235285282135,
0.7903464436531067,
-0.3292502462863922,
-0.7812449336051941,
0.26330482959747314,
0.3951742351055145,
-0.45825546979904175,
0.5298018455505371,
-0.5305464863777161,
-0.3203130066394806,
-0.07294374704360962,
-0.08590380102396011,
0.2111939638853073,
0.3810052275657654,
-0.10974817723035812,
0.4818006753921509,
1.0852091312408447,
-0.03963179886341095,
0.015279828570783138,
-0.48761993646621704,
0.4505722224712372,
-0.7803044319152832,
-0.7774918079376221,
-0.8609418869018555,
0.18357501924037933,
-0.019281448796391487,
-0.4940016567707062,
0.5683600902557373,
0.7288517951965332,
0.28719887137413025,
0.23879574239253998,
0.38705724477767944,
0.2976648211479187,
0.8314421772956848,
-0.3201723098754883,
0.430436909198761,
-0.2264821082353592,
0.2756447494029999,
-0.558646023273468,
-0.9114120602607727,
-0.5562298893928528,
0.6643272638320923,
-0.5265451073646545,
-0.3136884570121765,
0.9579862356185913,
0.570403516292572,
0.15488237142562866,
0.316814661026001,
-0.1344176083803177,
0.035595040768384933,
0.37799710035324097,
0.19903962314128876,
0.06599068641662598,
-0.45634347200393677,
0.6143755316734314,
-0.23643729090690613,
0.15254774689674377,
-0.45218607783317566,
-1.0944225788116455,
-0.8139120936393738,
-0.4398311376571655,
-0.28468406200408936,
-0.2924902141094208,
-0.19201725721359253,
0.640694260597229,
0.1482888013124466,
-0.913025438785553,
-0.561475396156311,
0.21962103247642517,
0.23715922236442566,
-0.25775599479675293,
-0.2749791443347931,
0.9328234195709229,
-0.34621551632881165,
-0.5913844108581543,
0.06649017333984375,
0.3733481168746948,
0.26752641797065735,
-0.2860109508037567,
0.0998811200261116,
-0.6286231875419617,
0.17907224595546722,
0.44056597352027893,
0.1886785626411438,
-0.0881427526473999,
-0.3648541569709778,
0.07755590230226517,
-0.17727644741535187,
0.3074185252189636,
0.9235997200012207,
-0.5615957379341125,
0.5451273918151855,
0.6905148029327393,
0.3710777759552002,
0.44653189182281494,
0.29393237829208374,
0.5289281010627747,
-0.7100964784622192,
0.37543562054634094,
-0.3669251501560211,
0.19858182966709137,
0.19046273827552795,
-0.34923139214515686,
0.07787928730249405,
0.23034211993217468,
-0.8269068598747253,
-0.34708160161972046,
-0.3660189211368561,
-1.2730753421783447,
0.004766548052430153,
0.8024609684944153,
0.2483646273612976,
-0.48521220684051514,
-0.24097035825252533,
-0.11560987681150436,
0.3765469491481781,
-0.7465940117835999,
0.9656293988227844,
0.9684398770332336,
-0.0506943054497242,
0.03025916777551174,
-0.5192295908927917,
0.14864280819892883,
0.39468204975128174,
-0.6010090708732605,
-0.13411954045295715,
0.08157364279031754,
-0.11763910949230194,
0.4919373095035553,
0.43494755029678345,
-0.3291567862033844,
0.0009053333778865635,
-0.19760213792324066,
-0.20333638787269592,
0.2896425426006317,
0.08834764361381531,
0.09754382073879242,
0.2991066873073578,
-0.21426701545715332,
-0.26258718967437744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00019v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00019v1
|
EHR-SeqSQL : A Sequential Text-to-SQL Dataset For Interactively Exploring Electronic Health Records
| 2024-05-23T07:14:21 | 2024-05-23T07:14:21 |
Jaehee Ryu, Seonhee Cho, Gyubok Lee, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR
|
In this paper, we introduce EHR-SeqSQL, a novel sequential text-to-SQL
dataset for Electronic Health Record (EHR) databases. EHR-SeqSQL is designed to
address critical yet underexplored aspects in text-to-SQL parsing:
interactivity, compositionality, and efficiency. To the best of our knowledge,
EHR-SeqSQL is not only the largest but also the first medical text-to-SQL
dataset benchmark to include sequential and contextual questions. We provide a
data split and the new test set designed to assess compositional generalization
ability. Our experiments demonstrate the superiority of a multi-turn approach
over a single-turn approach in learning compositionality. Additionally, our
dataset integrates specially crafted tokens into SQL queries to improve
execution efficiency. With EHR-SeqSQL, we aim to bridge the gap between
practical needs and academic research in the text-to-SQL domain.
|
[
-0.09537583589553833,
-1.0511164665222168,
0.8313705325126648,
0.050712645053863525,
-0.44787588715553284,
-0.015651250258088112,
0.04100053384900093,
-0.21295581758022308,
0.40916362404823303,
0.49827703833580017,
-0.5057455897331238,
-0.7828167080879211,
-0.23821806907653809,
0.1793561428785324,
-0.28117620944976807,
1.041382074356079,
0.2669900059700012,
0.04902234673500061,
-0.45518958568573,
-0.5056029558181763,
-0.32460078597068787,
-0.8077912330627441,
-0.4035907983779907,
-0.1263829618692398,
0.5997924208641052,
0.3655290901660919,
0.46689751744270325,
0.8018969893455505,
0.5950158834457397,
0.16081896424293518,
0.16374598443508148,
0.08926354348659515,
-0.3414258360862732,
0.6933556795120239,
-0.22625060379505157,
-0.35434794425964355,
-0.35269808769226074,
-0.960462212562561,
0.6187253594398499,
0.8343765139579773,
-0.48580580949783325,
0.16283205151557922,
-0.32594749331474304,
1.1011103391647339,
-0.5460347533226013,
-0.02776525728404522,
-0.4128458797931671,
0.19317303597927094,
-0.5229135751724243,
-0.23525986075401306,
-0.5437310338020325,
-0.22412852942943573,
0.20191141963005066,
-0.4040674567222595,
-0.1375628411769867,
0.16966336965560913,
0.44462698698043823,
0.3555314540863037,
-0.9591829180717468,
-0.0288726594299078,
-0.6800809502601624,
0.3937360644340515,
-0.37301182746887207,
0.6966404914855957,
0.05722711980342865,
0.3356497287750244,
0.21826691925525665,
-0.9625983834266663,
-0.3987641930580139,
0.3558766841888428,
-0.229282408952713,
0.09968604147434235,
0.2621239125728607,
-0.027978016063570976,
0.19532909989356995,
0.4687483608722687,
-0.8059645891189575,
-0.24084891378879547,
-0.08108048886060715,
0.3039126992225647,
0.6931684613227844,
0.544301450252533,
0.5945818424224854,
-0.1848619133234024,
-0.20411419868469238,
0.02965305931866169,
-0.4802711308002472,
0.025175122544169426,
-0.3067876994609833,
0.18866822123527527,
-0.016036400571465492,
0.7272310853004456,
-0.35982903838157654,
0.6100078225135803,
0.1674765944480896,
0.36618027091026306,
0.6564699411392212,
-0.3860301673412323,
-0.3131283223628998,
0.2523038387298584,
0.8539941310882568,
0.2816002368927002,
-0.4280889332294464,
-0.10319247841835022,
-0.15675070881843567,
-0.028679797425866127,
0.3549518883228302,
-0.705633819103241,
-0.3143857717514038,
0.8067173361778259,
-0.5231961011886597,
-0.06626211851835251,
0.08424215018749237,
-0.8046067953109741,
-0.31958624720573425,
-0.5729233622550964,
0.47321179509162903,
-0.47920170426368713,
0.017046138644218445,
0.11936423927545547,
0.06470915675163269,
0.37144187092781067,
0.1406693458557129,
-0.9707571268081665,
0.7998225688934326,
1.0081537961959839,
0.5836111307144165,
-0.6968459486961365,
-0.03644518181681633,
-0.38013237714767456,
0.15502811968326569,
-0.04253300651907921,
0.7204528450965881,
-0.4741891622543335,
-0.57047438621521,
-0.12215272337198257,
0.13357946276664734,
-0.26911047101020813,
-0.6435890793800354,
0.5588116645812988,
-0.5709337592124939,
0.24493128061294556,
-0.46605122089385986,
-0.7519538998603821,
0.22597330808639526,
0.28092747926712036,
-0.8326800465583801,
1.03516685962677,
-0.09339985996484756,
-0.7334946990013123,
0.3795648515224457,
-0.5206406116485596,
-0.8965756297111511,
0.19178809225559235,
-0.7787668704986572,
-0.7006293535232544,
-0.010220365598797798,
0.24421906471252441,
0.2916775643825531,
-0.2663097083568573,
0.3950647711753845,
-0.02163868211209774,
-0.17012982070446014,
0.19593030214309692,
0.2665797770023346,
0.6517385244369507,
0.2257261425256729,
-0.11749207228422165,
0.06998969614505768,
-0.7681813836097717,
0.3438033163547516,
0.1484016478061676,
-0.3432982265949249,
-0.43893924355506897,
0.32721593976020813,
0.05023098737001419,
0.11407928168773651,
0.22897882759571075,
-0.2726278305053711,
-0.18269585072994232,
-0.3298790156841278,
0.16366071999073029,
0.2661608159542084,
0.4007679224014282,
0.27786147594451904,
-0.6303297877311707,
0.21180012822151184,
0.20622555911540985,
0.15114746987819672,
-0.6055436134338379,
-0.20508930087089539,
-0.5687893033027649,
-0.13788051903247833,
0.2980343997478485,
0.6886075735092163,
-0.43716803193092346,
0.8298977017402649,
-0.4211777150630951,
-0.26204439997673035,
-0.3846491873264313,
-0.48828554153442383,
0.19830352067947388,
0.5613569617271423,
0.6984745264053345,
-0.45283666253089905,
-0.5109909772872925,
-0.8843607306480408,
-0.44902533292770386,
0.0351412333548069,
-0.12656037509441376,
0.49682340025901794,
0.399131178855896,
-0.15578524768352509,
0.5963539481163025,
-0.5408168435096741,
-0.2478385716676712,
0.024337075650691986,
-0.06640893220901489,
0.17544572055339813,
0.5049343705177307,
0.049056798219680786,
-0.7732694149017334,
-0.7399064302444458,
0.18882215023040771,
-0.9343131184577942,
0.1435917615890503,
0.08858822286128998,
-0.23077097535133362,
-0.05506391078233719,
0.3016929626464844,
-0.347979873418808,
-0.017339013516902924,
0.17755043506622314,
-0.49522942304611206,
0.1773853451013565,
-0.04591202363371849,
0.48893991112709045,
-0.948875904083252,
0.3309362232685089,
-0.26859354972839355,
-0.17091111838817596,
-0.7725324630737305,
-0.0039467900060117245,
0.12437734007835388,
-0.04834653437137604,
-0.2923508286476135,
0.15858273208141327,
-0.2993769645690918,
-0.02597818709909916,
0.43819716572761536,
-0.39254555106163025,
0.16670601069927216,
0.23512613773345947,
0.05292201787233353,
0.40656355023384094,
0.3421647846698761,
-0.3154106140136719,
0.09525343775749207,
0.74088054895401,
-0.1096419245004654,
1.0100406408309937,
-0.8436815738677979,
0.4204643666744232,
-0.32791027426719666,
0.038833919912576675,
-0.7136979103088379,
-0.43533390760421753,
-0.05860864371061325,
-0.1943201869726181,
0.24057598412036896,
-0.06135733798146248,
-0.19991041719913483,
-0.15368255972862244,
-0.32324111461639404,
0.5229771137237549,
0.5303462147712708,
-0.26948481798171997,
0.7579509615898132,
0.6007182002067566,
-0.3613702356815338,
-0.4195081293582916,
-0.8075323104858398,
-0.169343963265419,
-0.1380889117717743,
-0.6057947278022766,
0.7703189849853516,
0.029389185830950737,
-0.18917670845985413,
-0.009950493462383747,
-0.056019142270088196,
-0.46322396397590637,
-0.33767780661582947,
0.1053549125790596,
0.2551889419555664,
-0.2400738000869751,
0.4181870222091675,
0.3255992829799652,
0.18745866417884827,
0.3418605625629425,
-0.07526285946369171,
0.3520705997943878,
0.059502728283405304,
-0.6446642279624939,
-0.3285633623600006,
0.8184289336204529,
0.3332590162754059,
-0.32688456773757935,
0.5050492882728577,
-0.21150000393390656,
-0.561299204826355,
-0.034475892782211304,
-0.5112236142158508,
-0.09862398356199265,
-0.3856019675731659,
0.33915063738822937,
-0.2930994927883148,
-0.8234148025512695,
0.2869226932525635,
-0.04396522417664528,
0.11756443977355957,
0.4642185866832733,
0.4788280725479126,
-0.15316620469093323,
0.7933436632156372,
-0.03887297958135605,
0.3091907799243927,
0.2583087980747223,
0.097885362803936,
-0.2035621553659439,
-0.6992707252502441,
-0.7404119968414307,
-0.5707647800445557,
-0.09143733978271484,
-0.43183714151382446,
-0.39937278628349304,
0.6059697866439819,
-0.5481497645378113,
-0.5997939705848694,
-0.12000136077404022,
-0.5017454624176025,
0.622585117816925,
-0.033742859959602356,
0.7048525810241699,
0.6347326040267944,
-0.17142103612422943,
-0.24240288138389587,
-0.21371939778327942,
-0.23201633989810944,
-0.23779642581939697,
1.1470696926116943,
-0.003540365258231759,
0.5742208957672119,
0.3239961564540863,
0.968876838684082,
0.22982890903949738,
-0.13991419970989227,
-0.718313992023468,
0.2845032215118408,
-0.3179430365562439,
-0.5438498854637146,
-0.4842473268508911,
-0.2337404042482376,
-1.0546672344207764,
0.4493902027606964,
-0.2177136391401291,
-0.34146085381507874,
0.14450624585151672,
0.2598189115524292,
-0.41865605115890503,
-0.09751308709383011,
-0.5399871468544006,
1.0242918729782104,
-0.5598767995834351,
-0.5692145824432373,
0.2258473038673401,
-1.1422277688980103,
0.11202430725097656,
-0.14058098196983337,
0.22757495939731598,
0.05101805180311203,
-0.2577005922794342,
0.5925657749176025,
-0.664543867111206,
0.3144933879375458,
0.03199511021375656,
0.38596490025520325,
0.09740310907363892,
-0.100131094455719,
0.41069111227989197,
-0.053629640489816666,
-0.05307371914386749,
-0.23532450199127197,
0.331124871969223,
-0.3249858021736145,
-0.5930626392364502,
0.5573641657829285,
-0.4876865744590759,
-0.21836692094802856,
-0.5963740348815918,
0.2655072808265686,
-0.48084211349487305,
0.43470528721809387,
0.08888735622167587,
0.4661467969417572,
-0.6417930126190186,
0.3769816756248474,
0.9924811720848083,
-0.16766448318958282,
-0.12658479809761047,
0.382262259721756,
-0.18533848226070404,
-0.4229489862918854,
0.5761464238166809,
-0.015254240483045578,
0.06315655261278152,
0.7643442153930664,
0.15424159169197083,
-0.6673946976661682,
-0.3319193124771118,
-0.5789265036582947,
0.1268952488899231,
-0.4832749366760254,
-0.05190674588084221,
-1.0410066843032837,
-0.11500263959169388,
-0.1041683703660965,
0.12310521304607391,
-0.14028331637382507,
-0.32982727885246277,
-0.41796940565109253,
-0.16162259876728058,
0.21221674978733063,
0.5721179842948914,
0.3830015957355499,
-0.12047917395830154,
-0.9683142900466919,
0.4494694173336029,
0.45350322127342224,
0.37421101331710815,
-0.2310621738433838,
-0.22000539302825928,
0.08234325796365738,
-0.44613760709762573,
-0.28659147024154663,
-1.172290563583374,
0.044342171400785446,
0.4788736402988434,
0.48824045062065125,
0.16564175486564636,
0.1673024296760559,
0.44112083315849304,
-1.0256972312927246,
0.7818965911865234,
0.129376620054245,
-0.9093267321586609,
0.6869707703590393,
-0.4949386715888977,
0.24697868525981903,
1.131408929824829,
0.4826313257217407,
-0.6880276203155518,
0.20583464205265045,
-0.6661771535873413,
-1.1825358867645264,
0.17959283292293549,
-0.04783553257584572,
-0.19710023701190948,
-0.1708013266324997,
0.20057110488414764,
0.2559780776500702,
0.32507768273353577,
-0.22971756756305695,
-0.6263260841369629,
-0.164443701505661,
-0.5844442844390869,
0.09899365156888962,
-0.2955795228481293,
-0.06571821868419647,
-0.3485282063484192,
0.22191734611988068,
-0.02281811647117138,
0.340989351272583,
0.47467583417892456,
-0.12812013924121857,
0.006391298957169056,
0.8456239104270935,
-0.01486358605325222,
0.5177565813064575,
-0.1102268323302269,
0.28175294399261475,
0.18086768686771393,
-0.3835870325565338,
0.2827560305595398,
0.24801041185855865,
-0.19671092927455902,
-0.07347606867551804,
-0.06629139930009842,
0.6062034964561462,
0.0859842374920845,
-0.7338787913322449,
0.7282783389091492,
-0.06255808472633362,
-0.14749300479888916,
-0.24062933027744293,
-0.2395326793193817,
0.2199418842792511,
-0.17184841632843018,
0.32385867834091187,
-0.34531646966934204,
0.7635558247566223,
-0.3498592972755432,
0.6320292949676514,
0.05379203334450722,
-0.3823305368423462,
-0.2514258027076721,
0.8193733096122742,
0.25489532947540283,
-0.0832359716296196,
0.5569671988487244,
0.2476101964712143,
-0.13629886507987976,
0.49726131558418274,
0.3935490548610687,
0.48349663615226746,
-0.4937061071395874,
0.03389379009604454,
0.3556193709373474,
-0.06235982105135918,
-0.30581134557724,
1.0347299575805664,
0.13882586359977722,
-0.4861542284488678,
-0.32582584023475647,
-0.13246282935142517,
-0.6013318300247192,
-0.08842729032039642,
-1.0285552740097046,
0.2948451638221741,
-0.336209774017334,
-0.16325704753398895,
0.08952278643846512,
-0.3252454698085785,
-0.7613601088523865,
0.35625311732292175,
-0.3891601264476776,
0.4985795021057129,
-0.7822763323783875,
0.47137171030044556,
0.9033211469650269,
-0.22886541485786438,
-0.6131234169006348,
-0.22242118418216705,
0.14283566176891327,
-0.35460755228996277,
0.11359678208827972,
0.07264168560504913,
0.4804948568344116,
0.16593457758426666,
-0.1621144562959671,
-0.36381855607032776,
1.126070499420166,
0.01833547092974186,
-0.6565062403678894,
-0.0159101951867342,
0.4181777834892273,
0.5651520490646362,
-0.13236713409423828,
0.12128286808729172,
0.8719378113746643,
0.28691595792770386,
-0.01712636463344097,
-0.6936076283454895,
0.3162256181240082,
-0.35813337564468384,
-0.1490061730146408,
0.5867469906806946,
-0.574667751789093,
0.8899878263473511,
-0.23123672604560852,
-0.28552550077438354,
-0.1639220267534256,
0.4297749996185303,
0.216544508934021,
0.6570979356765747,
0.3064385950565338,
0.7487151026725769,
0.8805415630340576,
-0.19019098579883575,
0.889033317565918,
-0.017292823642492294,
0.3403996527194977,
1.460852861404419,
-0.7195034623146057,
0.973807156085968,
0.5637236833572388,
-0.5072751641273499,
0.6201844215393066,
0.4334656596183777,
0.16926755011081696,
0.6252975463867188,
0.21419480443000793,
-0.5910967588424683,
-0.13368947803974152,
-0.1628212034702301,
-0.7180005311965942,
-0.017737239599227905,
0.5168833136558533,
-0.47901713848114014,
0.16865743696689606,
-0.20357966423034668,
-0.232728973031044,
0.19380901753902435,
0.17844241857528687,
1.1576216220855713,
0.09907211363315582,
-0.3768662214279175,
-0.02215004153549671,
-0.3955541253089905,
0.24627390503883362,
-0.38774573802948,
-0.03505049645900726,
-0.00007721807196503505,
-0.20178894698619843,
-0.38061320781707764,
-0.7349721789360046,
0.3868795335292816,
-0.4060834050178528,
-0.03366447240114212,
0.20548245310783386,
0.8352895379066467,
-0.4131324887275696,
-0.10681770741939545,
-0.14304332435131073,
0.8440057635307312,
-0.002655602991580963,
0.060401350259780884,
-0.5482941269874573,
0.0549699030816555,
-0.33180299401283264,
-0.066922128200531,
0.22021810710430145,
0.7980378866195679,
0.21840180456638336,
0.09885150194168091,
0.49932438135147095,
-0.03607537969946861,
-0.07598141580820084,
0.09128317981958389,
0.8288438320159912,
-0.9851189255714417,
-0.7871756553649902,
-0.6947499513626099,
0.70122891664505,
-0.2499196082353592,
-0.14010202884674072,
0.27209046483039856,
0.9979373812675476,
0.6829788088798523,
-0.19330419600009918,
0.980377197265625,
-0.17517751455307007,
0.9928228259086609,
-0.5306606292724609,
0.4775847792625427,
-0.4065681993961334,
0.11252229660749435,
0.039418745785951614,
-0.35912013053894043,
-0.4592460095882416,
0.36340317130088806,
-0.006204909645020962,
0.041959382593631744,
1.1291766166687012,
0.3251477777957916,
0.19757890701293945,
0.2581309378147125,
0.3131825625896454,
-0.04534153267741203,
0.17175766825675964,
0.5329394340515137,
0.7527537941932678,
-0.579509437084198,
-0.03401939198374748,
-0.2596506178379059,
-0.07754526287317276,
-0.23270297050476074,
-0.795065701007843,
-0.6568881869316101,
-0.5316893458366394,
-0.2666887044906616,
-0.35557761788368225,
0.41495832800865173,
1.2574448585510254,
0.30508121848106384,
-1.0581295490264893,
-0.030688637867569923,
-0.028087204322218895,
-0.1892821043729782,
-0.20850752294063568,
-0.19477848708629608,
0.5515397787094116,
-0.10614223778247833,
-0.19446639716625214,
0.2576824724674225,
0.2425646185874939,
0.10045390576124191,
0.2398364543914795,
0.29638671875,
-0.10669498145580292,
-0.02975606918334961,
0.6879559755325317,
0.5714324712753296,
-0.2557014226913452,
0.07538150250911713,
0.26206734776496887,
-0.2475670725107193,
0.5315649509429932,
1.094045639038086,
-0.545988142490387,
0.474035382270813,
0.6577187180519104,
0.9479160308837891,
0.6059743165969849,
0.3678470849990845,
0.26392078399658203,
-0.7646127939224243,
-0.4079050123691559,
0.5422322750091553,
0.21925444900989532,
0.32504910230636597,
-0.6916669011116028,
0.41609957814216614,
-0.00022748902847524732,
-0.7678114771842957,
-0.40410229563713074,
-0.02601741813123226,
-1.1562811136245728,
0.07374293357133865,
0.9960349202156067,
0.296196311712265,
-0.12298567593097687,
-0.5474516153335571,
-0.1515922248363495,
0.05753330513834953,
-0.5791255831718445,
0.4301677644252777,
0.2484697550535202,
-0.6170003414154053,
0.061905402690172195,
-0.40075066685676575,
0.4324563145637512,
0.4620259404182434,
-1.5573790073394775,
-0.15618716180324554,
0.7375796437263489,
0.30855295062065125,
-0.41050028800964355,
1.1744723320007324,
-0.5055539608001709,
0.23992575705051422,
-0.3383399546146393,
-0.2736947536468506,
0.3410448133945465,
-0.223623126745224,
-0.4975912570953369,
0.2059144675731659,
0.012888290919363499,
-0.1725604087114334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14233v1
|
Language processing in humans and computers
| 2024-05-23T07:08:57 | 2024-05-23T07:08:57 |
Dusko Pavlovic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO, 68T07, 68T50, I.2.7; I.2.6; H.3.1; H.3.3
|
Machine-learned language models have transformed everyday life: they steer us
when we study, drive, manage money. They have the potential to transform our
civilization. But they hallucinate. Their realities are virtual. This note
provides a high-level overview of language models and outlines a low-level
model of learning machines. It turns out that, after they become capable of
recognizing hallucinations and dreaming safely, as humans tend to be, the
language-learning machines proceed to generate broader systems of false beliefs
and self-confirming theories, as humans tend to do.
|
[
-0.3836291432380676,
-1.043544054031372,
0.6755337119102478,
-0.13029612600803375,
0.1934243142604828,
0.2047313153743744,
-0.16517159342765808,
-0.9637282490730286,
-0.06474245339632034,
0.8478283286094666,
-0.5012727379798889,
-0.0010329863289371133,
-0.5010032057762146,
0.1317288726568222,
-0.6000816822052002,
0.5872370004653931,
0.36115559935569763,
0.08354366570711136,
0.036102861166000366,
0.2776884436607361,
-0.27068960666656494,
-1.0381832122802734,
-0.7732947468757629,
-0.5945210456848145,
0.11491192132234573,
0.12311917543411255,
1.0088775157928467,
0.5672078132629395,
0.3509667217731476,
0.44196778535842896,
0.12400917708873749,
-0.08315779268741608,
-0.29702574014663696,
0.3560374081134796,
-0.17245091497898102,
-0.6648977398872375,
-0.23896990716457367,
0.15615394711494446,
0.21096907556056976,
1.1919078826904297,
-0.09671356528997421,
-0.06068863347172737,
0.05456322431564331,
0.828637421131134,
-0.32550570368766785,
0.21390846371650696,
-0.6624436974525452,
0.2530358135700226,
0.2007192224264145,
-0.13460110127925873,
-0.5924042463302612,
-0.5068385601043701,
0.1260879933834076,
-0.3214283287525177,
0.5373216867446899,
0.029318159446120262,
0.6885595321655273,
0.2676616609096527,
-0.18446215987205505,
-0.4017640948295593,
-1.1970539093017578,
0.7549399733543396,
-0.3041765093803406,
0.6996849179267883,
0.6637396216392517,
0.41788050532341003,
-0.2818303108215332,
-0.6767963171005249,
-0.6023988127708435,
-0.49098441004753113,
-0.15721005201339722,
-0.34214282035827637,
-0.1113273948431015,
0.30669480562210083,
0.5305602550506592,
0.19081473350524902,
-0.5706090331077576,
0.03329870477318764,
-0.7959755063056946,
-0.4771629571914673,
0.5653819441795349,
0.3346194922924042,
0.6985868811607361,
-0.09603899717330933,
0.12556889653205872,
-0.1659221649169922,
-0.3769870698451996,
-0.11234872043132782,
0.12800446152687073,
0.19672885537147522,
0.32827651500701904,
0.3756430447101593,
-0.17284099757671356,
0.935079038143158,
-0.25204986333847046,
-0.25245603919029236,
0.10451614111661911,
0.2597772479057312,
-0.6711820363998413,
0.11448410153388977,
0.5183629989624023,
0.18638530373573303,
0.6704068779945374,
-0.262484073638916,
-0.24781256914138794,
0.6693626642227173,
0.6495060920715332,
-0.5203946232795715,
-0.3367695212364197,
-0.025581400841474533,
-0.5919232964515686,
-0.3289114236831665,
-0.1093517318367958,
-0.588097095489502,
-0.6777089834213257,
-0.7005656957626343,
0.3373259902000427,
-0.32276859879493713,
-0.2203228622674942,
0.4368020296096802,
-0.04268908500671387,
0.007760671433061361,
0.416943222284317,
-1.0680662393569946,
0.7953637838363647,
0.6583244800567627,
0.5378285646438599,
-0.04914713650941849,
-0.34294337034225464,
-0.04412063583731651,
-0.1664339303970337,
-0.3124745786190033,
0.8836967349052429,
-0.5554845333099365,
-0.5512263774871826,
-0.011791547760367393,
0.07926399260759354,
-0.1203102171421051,
-0.9089266657829285,
0.41440343856811523,
-0.25020045042037964,
0.35563477873802185,
-0.17217686772346497,
-0.32341304421424866,
-0.4061817526817322,
0.14290562272071838,
-0.7073588371276855,
0.8708323836326599,
0.06497804075479507,
-0.41101694107055664,
0.09546825289726257,
-0.9684228897094727,
-0.5295879244804382,
0.09123248606920242,
-0.08129212260246277,
-0.19757069647312164,
0.36853447556495667,
-0.05727789178490639,
0.5111726522445679,
-0.252886563539505,
0.12653055787086487,
0.05140852928161621,
-0.34866541624069214,
0.5410560369491577,
-0.44870615005493164,
0.8488861322402954,
0.6292387247085571,
-0.2751469612121582,
0.16384543478488922,
-0.8344073295593262,
-0.2028687447309494,
0.09761326760053635,
-0.36047250032424927,
-0.2567203938961029,
0.38965651392936707,
0.11551965773105621,
0.4090113043785095,
0.06104734539985657,
-0.4789671301841736,
0.16139593720436096,
-0.5812888145446777,
0.6317023038864136,
0.5566707849502563,
-0.18480172753334045,
0.3756727874279022,
-0.44146522879600525,
0.4955781102180481,
0.10888195037841797,
0.08917133510112762,
0.00975903682410717,
-0.5425878167152405,
-0.9665582180023193,
0.1717955619096756,
-0.28568702936172485,
0.6516326665878296,
-0.4656485617160797,
0.19429194927215576,
-0.05078885704278946,
-0.24359987676143646,
-0.7652919292449951,
0.02359967865049839,
-0.011218416504561901,
0.32141849398612976,
0.31261494755744934,
-0.11534996330738068,
-0.8907959461212158,
-0.8236274719238281,
-0.39785367250442505,
-0.32475295662879944,
-0.21854804456233978,
-0.03607002645730972,
0.39062756299972534,
-0.5853053331375122,
0.5831332802772522,
-0.5527055859565735,
0.08478736132383347,
-0.4777998924255371,
0.22345580160617828,
-0.06295157968997955,
0.3194228410720825,
0.27672407031059265,
-0.9453476667404175,
-0.26812222599983215,
0.07531924545764923,
-0.9263471364974976,
0.09652020782232285,
-0.4452291429042816,
0.15421132743358612,
0.4435633718967438,
0.6363260746002197,
-0.3927671015262604,
0.5318918228149414,
0.2683108448982239,
-0.6292335987091064,
0.2707805633544922,
-0.37431642413139343,
0.12817838788032532,
-0.8357821106910706,
-0.22419443726539612,
-0.17788280546665192,
-0.41747310757637024,
-0.7904062867164612,
-0.2337638884782791,
-0.27352797985076904,
-0.20281167328357697,
-0.21525444090366364,
0.3764953017234802,
-0.434636652469635,
-0.39768821001052856,
-0.6117663383483887,
0.12083442509174347,
-0.2503322660923004,
0.2161346971988678,
0.2492693066596985,
0.3736455738544464,
0.7260260581970215,
-0.7623459696769714,
0.23273351788520813,
-0.2630191743373871,
-0.4254046678543091,
0.24046054482460022,
-0.29641786217689514,
0.2678925693035126,
-0.39891862869262695,
-0.2749084532260895,
-0.6822944283485413,
-0.4688965082168579,
0.1112089455127716,
-0.6010399460792542,
0.034651778638362885,
0.491588830947876,
-0.5563504099845886,
-0.23540610074996948,
0.175233393907547,
0.06732189655303955,
0.7116337418556213,
-0.14310608804225922,
0.5751535892486572,
0.7327889204025269,
0.04706054925918579,
-0.07599958032369614,
-0.8305822610855103,
0.3254345953464508,
0.04508909583091736,
-0.33666762709617615,
0.14486518502235413,
-0.20257295668125153,
-0.8841730952262878,
-0.03230831027030945,
0.1907912641763687,
-0.27234503626823425,
0.4743106961250305,
0.7020300030708313,
0.35296863317489624,
-0.1380234956741333,
0.23642294108867645,
-0.13098806142807007,
-0.07920307666063309,
0.260737806558609,
-0.28295227885246277,
0.7923158407211304,
-0.11057962477207184,
-0.1462569683790207,
-0.4341229498386383,
0.40425652265548706,
0.7949367761611938,
0.26909559965133667,
0.8479132652282715,
0.2545175552368164,
-0.8280307650566101,
-0.06110125035047531,
-0.5168813467025757,
-0.25489041209220886,
-0.4499901235103607,
0.45966026186943054,
-0.6114644408226013,
-1.0316402912139893,
0.24725297093391418,
0.1287567913532257,
-0.20382238924503326,
0.5209516286849976,
0.740968644618988,
-0.14711473882198334,
1.1787527799606323,
0.9707404971122742,
-0.1395542323589325,
0.4324841797351837,
0.06523018330335617,
0.23963549733161926,
-0.3154277503490448,
-0.23317068815231323,
-0.5978307127952576,
-0.06621687859296799,
-0.7885276675224304,
-0.16173842549324036,
0.25000229477882385,
0.13477960228919983,
-0.16188567876815796,
0.39492908120155334,
-0.7181736826896667,
0.7330809235572815,
0.40037161111831665,
-0.18157964944839478,
0.2556596100330353,
0.14923293888568878,
-0.08643575757741928,
-0.04326208680868149,
-0.26561880111694336,
-0.8461573719978333,
0.9334197640419006,
0.4145640432834625,
0.7413830161094666,
-0.3259192705154419,
0.6241822242736816,
0.5931858420372009,
0.40705499053001404,
-0.6695177555084229,
0.633546769618988,
0.09808310866355896,
-0.7121171951293945,
-0.29609328508377075,
-0.18643996119499207,
-1.1043212413787842,
0.29675963521003723,
-0.28903600573539734,
-1.0972648859024048,
-0.013901440426707268,
0.007188799791038036,
-0.09142372012138367,
0.4297315180301666,
-0.6193970441818237,
0.6014539003372192,
-0.25902050733566284,
0.07306663691997528,
-0.6095405220985413,
-0.4057154953479767,
0.348342627286911,
0.01887330412864685,
0.5655126571655273,
-0.01777002401649952,
0.3218193054199219,
0.6740757822990417,
-0.10316541790962219,
1.0149080753326416,
-0.04310997575521469,
-0.07873490452766418,
0.23578795790672302,
0.5541436076164246,
-0.061433013528585434,
-0.3876836895942688,
-0.3033754527568817,
0.04557844251394272,
-0.08320759981870651,
-0.23188689351081848,
-0.41828277707099915,
0.4624733626842499,
-0.9474075436592102,
-0.5987818241119385,
-0.4666720926761627,
-0.5930083394050598,
0.1020229384303093,
0.05814057216048241,
0.1881309598684311,
-0.012667479924857616,
-0.5038763880729675,
-0.20302709937095642,
0.4457669258117676,
-0.18356715142726898,
0.3989875912666321,
0.4434882700443268,
-0.7027801871299744,
-0.047133561223745346,
0.8593953847885132,
0.11699267476797104,
0.33725211024284363,
0.44709864258766174,
0.08448421210050583,
-0.025759432464838028,
-0.24899685382843018,
-0.12856616079807281,
0.19720229506492615,
-1.0219796895980835,
0.38833633065223694,
-0.9429028630256653,
-0.43786153197288513,
-0.6411958932876587,
-0.16930517554283142,
-0.15596824884414673,
-0.5156750082969666,
-0.36263152956962585,
-0.3040725886821747,
-0.13119664788246155,
1.322697639465332,
-0.19854721426963806,
0.1646733582019806,
-0.7207556366920471,
0.5774000883102417,
0.4890613853931427,
-0.036555539816617966,
-0.09888352453708649,
-0.4054768979549408,
-0.3207014203071594,
0.09970378875732422,
-0.46632885932922363,
-0.760482668876648,
0.6999889612197876,
0.09490174055099487,
0.5145373940467834,
0.2919342517852783,
-0.26207831501960754,
0.48428091406822205,
-0.4280717670917511,
0.7676264047622681,
0.018300175666809082,
-1.0842318534851074,
0.5482103824615479,
0.16951018571853638,
0.07286962121725082,
0.2147056609392166,
0.5174418687820435,
-0.954188883304596,
-0.24189886450767517,
-0.5610489845275879,
-0.25769802927970886,
0.5713688135147095,
0.09727051109075546,
0.12811723351478577,
-0.11391817778348923,
0.40916913747787476,
0.2575888931751251,
0.004658443853259087,
-0.9160561561584473,
-0.29263022541999817,
-0.26492321491241455,
0.07970421016216278,
-0.10978800058364868,
-0.19535508751869202,
0.345098078250885,
-0.608715295791626,
0.22688712179660797,
0.005212292540818453,
0.4764242470264435,
-0.0007378712762147188,
-0.21314342319965363,
-0.4237556457519531,
0.2446289360523224,
0.5917267203330994,
0.5693809390068054,
0.019012194126844406,
0.3673880398273468,
0.07914312183856964,
-0.500605046749115,
0.2133781760931015,
-0.3952697515487671,
-0.0023439722135663033,
-0.08664225786924362,
0.29064735770225525,
0.8429504036903381,
0.07372234761714935,
-0.7839518785476685,
-0.07178863883018494,
-0.2731454074382782,
-0.19045929610729218,
-0.49193617701530457,
0.5045325756072998,
0.18357427418231964,
0.11489297449588776,
0.2500551640987396,
0.4670792818069458,
0.3290576636791229,
-1.1823145151138306,
-0.06828982383012772,
0.18811233341693878,
-0.444009393453598,
-0.7057452201843262,
0.7379424571990967,
-0.1350797712802887,
-1.0272990465164185,
0.6591919660568237,
-0.09379790723323822,
-0.7666664123535156,
0.3578287959098816,
0.9096879959106445,
1.245241403579712,
-0.4007013142108917,
0.2254285365343094,
0.4203360080718994,
0.31978148221969604,
-0.32929062843322754,
0.48490646481513977,
-0.30226045846939087,
-1.0620173215866089,
-0.2997351288795471,
-1.0409457683563232,
-0.41764259338378906,
0.22637495398521423,
-0.5798330307006836,
0.19802603125572205,
-0.3840741515159607,
-0.11482614278793335,
0.38813579082489014,
-0.22266019880771637,
-0.6412098407745361,
0.5137125253677368,
0.6115627884864807,
0.47309839725494385,
-0.9167701601982117,
1.2251737117767334,
0.8112949132919312,
-0.3445156514644623,
-0.25518909096717834,
0.029877260327339172,
-0.14342497289180756,
-0.6728702187538147,
1.0030189752578735,
0.3088352680206299,
-0.36919108033180237,
-0.03522737696766853,
-0.873119592666626,
-0.7012814283370972,
0.4015895128250122,
0.40388697385787964,
-0.3717421889305115,
-0.29082369804382324,
0.521134078502655,
0.8054187297821045,
-0.4526946544647217,
0.04638088494539261,
0.7604629993438721,
0.32655957341194153,
-0.2522014379501343,
-1.006765365600586,
-0.16186416149139404,
-0.18242210149765015,
-0.041695572435855865,
0.1827860325574875,
0.08386971801519394,
1.1276378631591797,
-0.23419390618801117,
-0.5587306618690491,
-0.22991885244846344,
0.4660470187664032,
-0.03765092045068741,
0.0698724091053009,
0.4773617386817932,
0.1778947114944458,
0.759581983089447,
0.08523120731115341,
0.9916328191757202,
-0.23606260120868683,
0.1491737961769104,
0.760365903377533,
-0.14982560276985168,
0.7487679123878479,
0.3774236738681793,
-0.3647783398628235,
0.7993127703666687,
0.41909098625183105,
0.351684033870697,
0.04609101638197899,
0.23610912263393402,
-0.08527204394340515,
-0.5981299877166748,
0.08714097738265991,
0.10445967316627502,
0.47091081738471985,
0.8504820466041565,
-0.5634605288505554,
0.14894592761993408,
0.4340920150279999,
-0.14672131836414337,
0.37838467955589294,
-0.1191898062825203,
0.9949570298194885,
0.21796585619449615,
-0.8086733818054199,
0.7413888573646545,
0.0554162822663784,
0.4514297544956207,
-0.1096813976764679,
-0.20383547246456146,
0.2805854380130768,
0.3192818760871887,
-0.21640054881572723,
-0.5708848237991333,
0.7749344706535339,
-0.04052669554948807,
-0.272478312253952,
-0.49750205874443054,
0.950867772102356,
-0.0873703882098198,
-0.5051664113998413,
0.5293328166007996,
0.48893553018569946,
0.5288370847702026,
-0.17179831862449646,
-0.6312280297279358,
0.16378790140151978,
0.17545172572135925,
-0.1703532338142395,
0.44420093297958374,
0.14614218473434448,
-0.3444848656654358,
0.9244075417518616,
0.47955548763275146,
0.37913522124290466,
0.3107750713825226,
0.07227181643247604,
0.6362745761871338,
-1.2117607593536377,
-0.3375179171562195,
-1.046104073524475,
0.17813672125339508,
0.12371505796909332,
0.0937097892165184,
0.5212541222572327,
0.4898199439048767,
1.123732328414917,
-0.26698899269104004,
0.9904406666755676,
-0.029422441497445107,
0.5743908882141113,
-0.2941325306892395,
0.8984367847442627,
-0.3945249915122986,
0.09718574583530426,
-0.09188481420278549,
-0.8759167194366455,
-0.4565012753009796,
0.9015551805496216,
-0.2771707773208618,
-0.23475120961666107,
0.7036141157150269,
0.6189611554145813,
0.21091215312480927,
0.21504788100719452,
0.8634325861930847,
0.3616899251937866,
0.28031474351882935,
0.2719815969467163,
0.8284044861793518,
-0.3380610942840576,
0.15494215488433838,
-0.4109609127044678,
0.15706363320350647,
-0.13112442195415497,
-0.33323371410369873,
-0.9450016617774963,
-0.9128402471542358,
-0.2696740925312042,
-0.29309818148612976,
-0.03781219571828842,
1.0792170763015747,
0.7379745244979858,
-0.9634034633636475,
-0.7247463464736938,
-0.30884140729904175,
0.0946994498372078,
-0.2079286426305771,
-0.27282795310020447,
-0.039395201951265335,
-0.6207769513130188,
-0.923810601234436,
0.44178372621536255,
0.4444532096385956,
0.2635755240917206,
-0.6864043474197388,
-0.10915009677410126,
0.09351997077465057,
0.08838536590337753,
0.7569389939308167,
0.33373507857322693,
-0.9537827372550964,
-0.29171210527420044,
0.1852869838476181,
-0.2888750433921814,
0.19677986204624176,
0.9390171766281128,
-1.1493457555770874,
0.6370790004730225,
0.5196822285652161,
0.22908301651477814,
0.3296205699443817,
-0.3630690574645996,
0.5856893062591553,
-0.04819568991661072,
0.2904253304004669,
0.34591802954673767,
0.3327999711036682,
0.46802231669425964,
-0.40384361147880554,
0.44618645310401917,
0.3985879421234131,
-0.7014990448951721,
-0.865650475025177,
0.35533463954925537,
-0.49041885137557983,
-0.5645588040351868,
0.6592485904693604,
0.25226208567619324,
-0.48183223605155945,
-0.47254544496536255,
-0.4624302089214325,
0.3461553752422333,
0.07741021364927292,
1.1742939949035645,
0.5765074491500854,
-0.4534359872341156,
-0.12321609258651733,
-0.8593737483024597,
0.8247043490409851,
0.09958821535110474,
-0.9522892832756042,
0.041018545627593994,
0.41426199674606323,
0.19308826327323914,
0.3663041889667511,
0.5019482374191284,
-0.04577396810054779,
0.1581009477376938,
0.09200774878263474,
0.32388168573379517,
0.40913063287734985,
-0.3665754497051239,
-0.3073081374168396,
0.34748780727386475,
0.2252982258796692,
-0.01446517463773489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14231v1
|
From Role-Play to Drama-Interaction: An LLM Solution
| 2024-05-23T07:03:56 | 2024-05-23T07:03:56 |
Weiqi Wu, Hongqiu Wu, Lai Jiang, Xingyuan Liu, Jiale Hong, Hai Zhao, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Drama is a form of storytelling inspired by human creativity, proceeding with
a predefined storyline, carrying emotions and thoughts. This paper introduces
\emph{LLM-based interactive drama}, which endows traditional drama with an
unprecedented immersion, where a person is allowed to walk into it and interact
with the characters and scenes. We define this new artistic genre by 6
essential elements-plot, character, thought, diction, spectacle and
interaction-and study the entire pipeline to forge a backbone \emph{drama LLM}
to drive the playing process, which is challenged by limited drama resources,
uncontrollable narrative development, and complicated instruction following. We
propose \emph{Narrative Chain} to offer finer control over the narrative
progression during interaction with players; \emph{Auto-Drama} to synthesize
drama scripts given arbitrary stories; \emph{Sparse Instruction Tuning} to
allow the model to follow sophisticated instructions. We manually craft 3
scripts, \emph{Detective Conan}, \emph{Harry Potter}, \emph{Romeo and Juliet},
and design a 5-dimension principle to evaluate the drama LLM comprehensively.
|
[
-0.297212153673172,
-0.823564350605011,
0.6875143051147461,
0.5060092210769653,
-0.05676697567105293,
0.7519556283950806,
0.07779529690742493,
-0.5046567916870117,
0.7279191613197327,
0.8452311158180237,
-0.8939903378486633,
-0.2996255159378052,
-0.20805935561656952,
-0.0925600454211235,
-0.0318310521543026,
0.9313294887542725,
-0.2684799134731293,
-0.09263938665390015,
-0.2949644923210144,
-0.014148830436170101,
-0.35474684834480286,
-0.18732872605323792,
-0.5023088455200195,
-0.2722699046134949,
0.9204118847846985,
0.3182626962661743,
0.5108355283737183,
0.8088321089744568,
0.6145181059837341,
0.47125980257987976,
0.1973813772201538,
0.5233812928199768,
-0.8029542565345764,
0.35476306080818176,
-0.12522083520889282,
-0.6212524175643921,
-0.6710660457611084,
0.4014964997768402,
0.3981325030326843,
0.37773552536964417,
-0.006551436614245176,
0.11362850666046143,
0.0782678946852684,
0.48823031783103943,
-0.4512396454811096,
0.018122028559446335,
0.052178263664245605,
0.4082641005516052,
-0.10200173407793045,
-0.5307360887527466,
-0.3318999111652374,
-0.2742350101470947,
-0.12037820369005203,
-0.9811561703681946,
-0.2560790479183197,
0.2417922466993332,
0.5087241530418396,
0.006470819469541311,
-0.5006644129753113,
-0.31764423847198486,
-1.2799980640411377,
0.4488818347454071,
-0.4559394419193268,
-0.4201594293117523,
0.19154764711856842,
0.41331055760383606,
-0.09990032762289047,
-0.7374200820922852,
-0.26700595021247864,
-0.45648694038391113,
0.1162576898932457,
0.5376522541046143,
0.23821169137954712,
0.3867014944553375,
0.219826340675354,
0.5907512903213501,
-0.29870307445526123,
0.12022020667791367,
-0.10591048002243042,
0.11586134135723114,
0.8280905485153198,
0.8368391990661621,
0.6222911477088928,
0.07465559989213943,
-0.6653304696083069,
0.42454755306243896,
-0.5648582577705383,
0.34793582558631897,
0.6379047632217407,
-0.2993600070476532,
-0.2686028480529785,
0.6084792613983154,
0.04507782682776451,
0.18610073626041412,
0.40633031725883484,
-0.3587087094783783,
-0.5257344245910645,
0.0622502826154232,
-0.2909267544746399,
-0.014844905585050583,
0.7096635103225708,
0.6332131624221802,
0.08415520936250687,
-0.040411707013845444,
0.05379564315080643,
0.09254124760627747,
0.4705716371536255,
-0.5463137030601501,
-0.2576434314250946,
0.08054222911596298,
-0.2027462273836136,
-0.7145770192146301,
-0.03641384840011597,
-0.5202053189277649,
-0.8067255616188049,
-0.2940167784690857,
0.8187186121940613,
-0.3592115640640259,
0.012298829853534698,
-0.1964126080274582,
0.010592822916805744,
0.2577591836452484,
0.44243746995925903,
-1.0322984457015991,
0.5003757476806641,
0.34257471561431885,
0.6731434464454651,
-0.4639730751514435,
-0.30856412649154663,
-0.42811205983161926,
0.6255377531051636,
-0.47913217544555664,
0.8008133172988892,
-0.21750371158123016,
-0.3298090696334839,
-0.13470691442489624,
-0.14342345297336578,
0.07521706819534302,
-0.260852187871933,
0.1322367638349533,
-0.22809530794620514,
0.33338358998298645,
0.14647042751312256,
-0.5623892545700073,
-0.10519174486398697,
0.40577247738838196,
-1.009322166442871,
0.6092216968536377,
-0.06796804070472717,
-0.4060269296169281,
0.15171723067760468,
-0.6717264652252197,
-0.36321333050727844,
0.31644967198371887,
-0.12038414180278778,
0.153692364692688,
0.23438139259815216,
-0.04532894492149353,
-0.1988539695739746,
-0.2406686246395111,
0.27650442719459534,
-0.1246388703584671,
-0.8150663375854492,
0.4246043264865875,
-0.46999987959861755,
0.23798102140426636,
-0.020084939897060394,
-0.07748671621084213,
0.27079200744628906,
-0.7369427680969238,
-0.13636595010757446,
-0.09126759320497513,
-0.39206627011299133,
0.025364598259329796,
0.10795389860868454,
-0.0897291973233223,
0.28381383419036865,
0.3583509027957916,
-0.21663442254066467,
0.33127349615097046,
-0.4073188006877899,
0.11542277038097382,
0.6772276163101196,
0.1221875324845314,
0.6467640399932861,
-0.826870322227478,
0.9687976241111755,
-0.2478361874818802,
0.28686922788619995,
-0.44416093826293945,
-0.10150280594825745,
-1.0232230424880981,
-0.3594813346862793,
0.026496505364775658,
0.6456850171089172,
-0.610438883304596,
0.07923921942710876,
0.3048189580440521,
-0.10764370113611221,
-0.7004309296607971,
-0.06641469150781631,
0.08896077424287796,
0.12045667320489883,
0.10285422950983047,
-0.4008503556251526,
-0.7306715846061707,
-0.5336890816688538,
-0.09867055714130402,
-0.3027263581752777,
-0.05866769701242447,
0.4281758666038513,
-0.13673530519008636,
0.13610441982746124,
0.8987560868263245,
-0.31822702288627625,
-0.38674890995025635,
-0.694942057132721,
0.18345555663108826,
0.1991046667098999,
0.38504087924957275,
0.013987760059535503,
-0.40590280294418335,
-0.6308268308639526,
0.08152623474597931,
-1.0713915824890137,
-0.3324366509914398,
-0.343850314617157,
-0.05269907787442207,
0.13890062272548676,
0.5949686169624329,
-0.6026816368103027,
0.5644423365592957,
0.28530576825141907,
-0.19227071106433868,
0.5667155981063843,
-0.43896785378456116,
0.4341340959072113,
-0.7925054430961609,
-0.009859216399490833,
-0.40755802392959595,
-0.14111235737800598,
-0.6623047590255737,
0.23728732764720917,
-0.4641066789627075,
-0.0500960573554039,
-0.51703280210495,
0.5394799113273621,
-0.5194197297096252,
0.05168157443404198,
-0.4223679304122925,
0.45658984780311584,
0.1438441276550293,
0.8007952570915222,
0.010164999403059483,
-0.03319631144404411,
0.5533967018127441,
-0.5206615924835205,
0.9015849828720093,
0.08645999431610107,
-0.2621684968471527,
0.5778369903564453,
-0.18829746544361115,
0.12161903083324432,
0.07456191629171371,
0.10871991515159607,
-0.9372206926345825,
-0.40609702467918396,
0.4245505630970001,
0.05751516669988632,
0.34311649203300476,
-0.28951188921928406,
-0.44610801339149475,
-0.16963455080986023,
-0.23397764563560486,
0.2669652998447418,
0.4387631118297577,
-0.09411468356847763,
0.9169059991836548,
0.35211002826690674,
-0.26365599036216736,
-0.35735654830932617,
-0.5168648958206177,
0.31072887778282166,
-0.7088389992713928,
-0.7066975831985474,
0.531151294708252,
-0.5532025098800659,
-0.24744784832000732,
-0.2558766305446625,
-0.044594358652830124,
-0.2719114124774933,
-0.13427679240703583,
0.28251081705093384,
0.17029662430286407,
-0.20495373010635376,
-0.28658756613731384,
0.1973581612110138,
-0.1693778783082962,
0.046500008553266525,
0.30483174324035645,
0.35808491706848145,
0.20721009373664856,
-0.4461148977279663,
-0.5642932653427124,
0.5914684534072876,
0.7606364488601685,
0.07923474907875061,
0.06135491281747818,
0.5310609936714172,
0.14390642940998077,
-0.12511752545833588,
-0.26842883229255676,
0.110126793384552,
-0.5328748226165771,
-0.008146887645125389,
-0.15826673805713654,
-0.8826770186424255,
0.7802318930625916,
-0.5022764205932617,
-0.02419239655137062,
0.11766870319843292,
0.435143381357193,
-0.6054619550704956,
0.8258228898048401,
0.7640262246131897,
0.25994861125946045,
0.34878700971603394,
-0.10989644378423691,
0.022425755858421326,
-0.7934859395027161,
-0.39061224460601807,
0.41006189584732056,
-0.9218316674232483,
-0.7305072546005249,
-0.34225302934646606,
0.463470458984375,
0.30597469210624695,
-0.2041679173707962,
0.06628113985061646,
0.13394460082054138,
0.667866051197052,
0.1980568915605545,
0.002750244690105319,
0.6092044711112976,
-0.522445023059845,
-0.5163366794586182,
-0.1694193184375763,
-0.6824657320976257,
-0.4766084551811218,
0.5614122748374939,
0.5960448980331421,
1.1664494276046753,
0.6294623017311096,
0.9640156030654907,
0.33334171772003174,
0.26286011934280396,
-0.8843116760253906,
0.7957521080970764,
0.13139913976192474,
-0.400574266910553,
-0.542630672454834,
-0.027122193947434425,
-0.7654409408569336,
0.07901705801486969,
-0.5189000368118286,
-0.9974038004875183,
-0.03768612816929817,
-0.010486639104783535,
-0.5390050411224365,
0.2815372049808502,
-0.2908655107021332,
0.6061925292015076,
-0.3291870057582855,
-0.8953572511672974,
-0.15027016401290894,
-0.6545330286026001,
0.7652475833892822,
0.15726202726364136,
0.2345736175775528,
0.025804806500673294,
0.005761411972343922,
0.1489710509777069,
-0.34322303533554077,
1.0493055582046509,
0.2770425081253052,
-0.23853851854801178,
0.7095977663993835,
0.8879265189170837,
0.39715299010276794,
0.19382423162460327,
0.36106958985328674,
-0.5173923373222351,
-0.18993689119815826,
0.017713667824864388,
-0.7165238857269287,
0.6501176953315735,
-0.47747233510017395,
-0.9039262533187866,
-0.5373085141181946,
-1.044927954673767,
-0.05267760530114174,
-0.08363939821720123,
0.03033287078142166,
0.4415777921676636,
-0.7897205948829651,
-0.019387777894735336,
0.674549400806427,
-0.1821547895669937,
0.9030502438545227,
0.6023609042167664,
-0.6756311058998108,
-0.508438766002655,
0.6437878608703613,
-0.050793539732694626,
0.2552518844604492,
0.571517288684845,
0.11473210155963898,
-0.21652448177337646,
-0.18856365978717804,
-0.45444580912590027,
0.0034910705871880054,
-0.29391592741012573,
0.07906191796064377,
-0.5343846082687378,
-0.4598633944988251,
0.24773009121418,
-0.30678319931030273,
-0.07985083013772964,
-0.1947142332792282,
-0.45048314332962036,
-0.3452316224575043,
0.24856771528720856,
0.9633215069770813,
-0.378397136926651,
0.46892431378364563,
-0.6353489756584167,
0.3305133581161499,
0.4228663444519043,
0.5047346353530884,
-0.18870656192302704,
-0.38035574555397034,
-0.49249011278152466,
-0.4735576808452606,
-0.7042587399482727,
-0.828048825263977,
0.41288793087005615,
0.11889762431383133,
0.642657458782196,
0.7544258236885071,
-0.1192709431052208,
0.5023443698883057,
-0.7450701594352722,
0.8627594113349915,
0.1692979335784912,
-0.7914091348648071,
0.34751662611961365,
-0.6236688494682312,
0.10688027739524841,
0.25529783964157104,
0.315440833568573,
-0.6734249591827393,
-0.5213648080825806,
-0.7290049195289612,
-0.7915677428245544,
0.7678745985031128,
0.2139677256345749,
0.1232018768787384,
0.1590002477169037,
0.21728801727294922,
0.0963529497385025,
0.5121241807937622,
-0.971725583076477,
-0.05746394023299217,
0.06360901892185211,
-0.04056333005428314,
-0.023214606568217278,
-0.14521606266498566,
-0.1998801827430725,
-0.0195098128169775,
0.18055009841918945,
0.10553554445505142,
0.0633164495229721,
-0.0758894681930542,
-0.08625984191894531,
-0.5892639756202698,
-0.02852698229253292,
0.3935146629810333,
0.5633576512336731,
-0.18821321427822113,
0.18298842012882233,
-0.005220321472734213,
-0.3939533233642578,
0.3156454563140869,
-0.352408230304718,
0.16266131401062012,
-0.4080359637737274,
0.4571872353553772,
0.7369436025619507,
0.39042797684669495,
-0.561672031879425,
0.23991207778453827,
0.30980339646339417,
-0.22183144092559814,
-0.25855472683906555,
0.48339805006980896,
0.250002920627594,
0.7616258859634399,
0.19650773704051971,
-0.16982145607471466,
0.12085126340389252,
-0.9979491233825684,
0.3880433738231659,
0.02610320784151554,
-0.7234660983085632,
-0.07831629365682602,
0.5114380717277527,
0.3862052261829376,
-0.6306347250938416,
0.1164591908454895,
-0.016688810661435127,
0.006395190954208374,
0.624734103679657,
0.7266747951507568,
0.8635368943214417,
-0.3780510723590851,
0.7208881974220276,
-0.1633692979812622,
0.29841348528862,
0.016788307577371597,
0.2822895050048828,
0.30017226934432983,
-0.48424240946769714,
-0.8816956877708435,
-0.4585639536380768,
-0.5729766488075256,
0.44129759073257446,
-0.43058130145072937,
0.4425002336502075,
-0.6356548070907593,
0.3392127454280853,
-0.5355364084243774,
0.1360408067703247,
0.014552525244653225,
0.0448601134121418,
0.31807348132133484,
0.6946162581443787,
-0.6871354579925537,
0.48685380816459656,
0.42336729168891907,
-0.5153321027755737,
-0.43420353531837463,
0.10202656686306,
0.09803865104913712,
-0.2477540820837021,
0.23794153332710266,
0.060489166527986526,
-0.04552453011274338,
0.34901970624923706,
-0.5878504514694214,
-0.6429013013839722,
1.420034408569336,
0.15125836431980133,
-0.30517446994781494,
-0.031118471175432205,
0.07362987846136093,
0.7931663393974304,
-1.1025868654251099,
0.3023744821548462,
0.4442492723464966,
0.3283194601535797,
0.567306637763977,
-0.5105628371238708,
-0.273773193359375,
-0.26076725125312805,
-0.1252712905406952,
0.11866400390863419,
-0.8595013618469238,
0.6853147149085999,
-0.267639696598053,
-0.18012207746505737,
0.6850878000259399,
0.7208083868026733,
0.45511364936828613,
0.5707850456237793,
0.2230263501405716,
0.20963144302368164,
0.33031168580055237,
0.0925382599234581,
0.7547869682312012,
-0.19898943603038788,
0.07985122501850128,
1.1213070154190063,
-0.5056055188179016,
0.20493929088115692,
0.298939973115921,
-0.0021208145190030336,
0.7645949721336365,
0.8169697523117065,
0.01606411673128605,
0.5539112091064453,
0.8333398699760437,
-0.6067626476287842,
-0.4218885898590088,
-0.2256321758031845,
0.27267345786094666,
0.5251929759979248,
0.3600127696990967,
-0.17442548274993896,
-0.12408196181058884,
-0.15415580570697784,
-0.259685754776001,
0.3935668468475342,
-0.5166898369789124,
0.897477924823761,
0.19909100234508514,
-0.34058666229248047,
-0.22282977402210236,
-0.16566862165927887,
0.25087645649909973,
-0.8132537603378296,
-0.3438819348812103,
-0.3808700442314148,
-0.44582149386405945,
-0.035615261644124985,
-0.734354555606842,
-0.028246449306607246,
-0.16551215946674347,
0.00878371112048626,
-0.057911958545446396,
0.7680432200431824,
-0.7199615836143494,
-0.3346205949783325,
0.13360653817653656,
0.8020093441009521,
0.3966060280799866,
0.3137330114841461,
-0.3248555064201355,
-0.041438642889261246,
-0.24372032284736633,
-0.09150365740060806,
0.43870145082473755,
0.9079813361167908,
-0.10794125497341156,
0.6410395503044128,
0.2032177746295929,
-0.09085500240325928,
-0.31619882583618164,
0.14274488389492035,
0.6512239575386047,
-0.8062165379524231,
-0.8116599321365356,
-0.7003591060638428,
0.940659761428833,
0.07063838839530945,
-0.09341634809970856,
0.2587865889072418,
0.38929426670074463,
0.0651894137263298,
-0.09531896561384201,
0.6911818981170654,
-0.11490215361118317,
0.007666928227990866,
-0.6557788848876953,
0.6687467098236084,
-0.27810409665107727,
0.4640395939350128,
-0.39428243041038513,
-0.9947085380554199,
-0.06905745714902878,
0.36501768231391907,
0.15336154401302338,
0.09207733720541,
0.8537492752075195,
0.3572405278682709,
-0.18703988194465637,
-0.19581419229507446,
0.8066039681434631,
0.25998011231422424,
-0.11468052864074707,
0.5100446939468384,
1.3812488317489624,
-0.023553477600216866,
0.4798274636268616,
0.20760858058929443,
-0.4958273768424988,
-0.437335342168808,
-1.222170352935791,
-0.9843456149101257,
-0.21063640713691711,
-0.2886057496070862,
-0.21244798600673676,
-0.16408464312553406,
0.7985967993736267,
0.28183192014694214,
-0.1075291633605957,
-0.8497267961502075,
-0.06718903034925461,
0.2412949651479721,
-0.5244705080986023,
-0.2417578101158142,
-0.05863626301288605,
-0.15487010776996613,
-0.8135747313499451,
0.7266138792037964,
0.653235673904419,
0.029807543382048607,
-0.8252692222595215,
-0.054985012859106064,
-0.21090669929981232,
0.643352210521698,
0.6969181895256042,
0.24262955784797668,
-0.5378285050392151,
-0.08546193689107895,
0.044607631862163544,
-0.14690212905406952,
0.11263996362686157,
1.0183608531951904,
-0.5509437322616577,
0.4610816240310669,
0.26279833912849426,
0.08584515005350113,
0.8274387121200562,
-0.0915488749742508,
0.9598150849342346,
-0.5998373031616211,
-0.182792067527771,
0.15801209211349487,
-0.12437025457620621,
-0.05509765446186066,
-0.7007848620414734,
0.4472997188568115,
0.43561193346977234,
-0.31696099042892456,
-0.3063898980617523,
0.668515145778656,
-1.3232868909835815,
-0.011305754072964191,
0.9044502973556519,
-0.26828980445861816,
-0.14207255840301514,
-0.022123165428638458,
-0.468116819858551,
0.2789788246154785,
-0.220407634973526,
0.7931492328643799,
0.786785900592804,
-0.740889310836792,
-0.590221107006073,
-0.5240340828895569,
0.6897371411323547,
-0.22525806725025177,
-0.7918292284011841,
-0.2751350700855255,
0.5820382833480835,
0.0019408244406804442,
0.1024220809340477,
0.51545250415802,
-0.30846115946769714,
0.007062960881739855,
-0.24368734657764435,
0.3357444703578949,
-0.19869396090507507,
-0.7705886960029602,
-0.07145325094461441,
0.37156784534454346,
-0.21307910978794098,
0.04827331751585007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14230v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14230v1
|
Boosting Medical Image-based Cancer Detection via Text-guided Supervision from Reports
| 2024-05-23T07:03:38 | 2024-05-23T07:03:38 |
Guangyu Guo, Jiawen Yao, Yingda Xia, Tony C. W. Mok, Zhilin Zheng, Junwei Han, Le Lu, Dingwen Zhang, Jian Zhou, Ling Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The absence of adequately sufficient expert-level tumor annotations hinders
the effectiveness of supervised learning based opportunistic cancer screening
on medical imaging. Clinical reports (that are rich in descriptive textual
details) can offer a "free lunch'' supervision information and provide tumor
location as a type of weak label to cope with screening tasks, thus saving
human labeling workloads, if properly leveraged. However, predicting cancer
only using such weak labels can be very changeling since tumors are usually
presented in small anatomical regions compared to the whole 3D medical scans.
Weakly semi-supervised learning (WSSL) utilizes a limited set of voxel-level
tumor annotations and incorporates alongside a substantial number of medical
images that have only off-the-shelf clinical reports, which may strike a good
balance between minimizing expert annotation workload and optimizing screening
efficacy. In this paper, we propose a novel text-guided learning method to
achieve highly accurate cancer detection results. Through integrating
diagnostic and tumor location text prompts into the text encoder of a
vision-language model (VLM), optimization of weakly supervised learning can be
effectively performed in the latent space of VLM, thereby enhancing the
stability of training. Our approach can leverage clinical knowledge by
large-scale pre-trained VLM to enhance generalization ability, and produce
reliable pseudo tumor masks to improve cancer detection. Our extensive
quantitative experimental results on a large-scale cancer dataset, including
1,651 unique patients, validate that our approach can reduce human annotation
efforts by at least 70% while maintaining comparable cancer detection accuracy
to competing fully supervised methods (AUC value 0.961 versus 0.966).
|
[
0.06235010549426079,
-0.5807280540466309,
0.8559653162956238,
-0.15151908993721008,
-0.6158649325370789,
-0.3397674560546875,
-0.03161689266562462,
-0.5949543714523315,
0.266530305147171,
0.7240027189254761,
-0.2975989878177643,
-1.0228532552719116,
-0.7344184517860413,
0.07368224859237671,
-0.265941321849823,
1.2966660261154175,
0.21671971678733826,
0.1990872025489807,
-0.4087499976158142,
-0.1368093192577362,
-0.05792916566133499,
-0.06020905822515488,
-0.7606936693191528,
-0.033886365592479706,
0.6773741841316223,
0.3522515892982483,
0.5401601791381836,
0.9216500520706177,
0.6261446475982666,
0.22179722785949707,
-0.3046230971813202,
0.5724336504936218,
-0.36010733246803284,
0.06753703951835632,
0.0926266759634018,
-0.622204065322876,
-0.09232863038778305,
-0.2464580535888672,
0.011596087366342545,
0.6384129524230957,
-0.011065847240388393,
-0.23326116800308228,
0.0793883427977562,
0.3764490783214569,
-0.6986490488052368,
0.1382175087928772,
-0.3832125961780548,
0.24975983798503876,
-0.3383517861366272,
-0.4153420627117157,
-0.34907183051109314,
-0.5095030665397644,
0.24870043992996216,
-0.5492716431617737,
0.22085359692573547,
-0.2950242757797241,
0.7856708765029907,
0.4703117311000824,
-0.5313873887062073,
-0.4553210139274597,
-0.483982115983963,
0.7140940427780151,
-0.6118937730789185,
-0.1737516075372696,
0.7689930200576782,
0.3867351710796356,
0.06047801673412323,
-0.885769784450531,
0.27141985297203064,
-0.11426670104265213,
-0.3783453106880188,
0.44301077723503113,
0.09939248114824295,
0.30795231461524963,
0.2271653264760971,
0.43178024888038635,
-0.38801997900009155,
0.2626764178276062,
-0.3763555884361267,
-0.6351631283760071,
0.5091098546981812,
0.15150049328804016,
0.2286900281906128,
-0.04540271684527397,
-0.4194188416004181,
0.08526669442653656,
-0.5461621880531311,
0.005305746104568243,
-0.3275488317012787,
0.2928507924079895,
-0.10129440575838089,
0.42233675718307495,
-0.23475702106952667,
0.8833739161491394,
0.0020814635790884495,
-0.44252675771713257,
0.30032485723495483,
-0.4964643120765686,
-0.022031040862202644,
0.3072245419025421,
0.967049241065979,
0.30352523922920227,
-0.11432060599327087,
0.20949074625968933,
-0.06541716307401657,
0.20516487956047058,
0.17922163009643555,
-0.8983558416366577,
-0.4686376452445984,
0.0180862657725811,
-0.7232131958007812,
-0.7123439908027649,
-0.03498890623450279,
-0.8825706839561462,
-0.6992990970611572,
0.2906210720539093,
0.46039706468582153,
-0.07897108048200607,
0.32237303256988525,
0.17436321079730988,
0.06988773494958878,
-0.42534443736076355,
0.2303263247013092,
-0.6599809527397156,
-0.165533646941185,
0.05983002111315727,
0.9007961750030518,
0.1757693737745285,
0.251097172498703,
-1.1112205982208252,
0.2330707311630249,
-0.30978938937187195,
0.8887916803359985,
-0.6332026720046997,
-0.4712398946285248,
0.13841421902179718,
0.2617950737476349,
0.0759897381067276,
-0.3859109580516815,
0.8209463357925415,
0.012474529445171356,
0.5613400936126709,
-0.13323312997817993,
-0.2753220498561859,
-0.07545946538448334,
0.231505885720253,
-0.4416484236717224,
0.9237698316574097,
0.12324399501085281,
-0.7236840128898621,
0.6012843251228333,
-0.3204680383205414,
-0.5834059119224548,
0.23806880414485931,
-0.33551642298698425,
-0.9061802625656128,
-0.1236947774887085,
0.7301846146583557,
0.7806903123855591,
-0.0476592555642128,
0.097060926258564,
-0.2133825123310089,
-0.5386870503425598,
-0.3062282204627991,
-0.1343035101890564,
0.5486662983894348,
0.08654049783945084,
-0.5024243593215942,
0.13741378486156464,
-0.6094502806663513,
-0.09197863936424255,
0.27703386545181274,
-0.0683189406991005,
-0.6463702917098999,
0.14305028319358826,
-0.4434472918510437,
0.09616933763027191,
0.3355279862880707,
-0.6575868129730225,
0.08672970533370972,
-0.68038409948349,
-0.23045462369918823,
0.39604640007019043,
0.2399986982345581,
0.18289384245872498,
-0.2274908572435379,
0.38272303342819214,
0.1384413093328476,
0.4407802224159241,
-0.3148740828037262,
-0.906455397605896,
-0.280830442905426,
-0.5662127733230591,
0.1874995231628418,
0.5819503664970398,
-1.066004753112793,
0.335275262594223,
0.2006700187921524,
-0.5715222954750061,
-0.4327522814273834,
0.22822508215904236,
0.5823331475257874,
0.9448039531707764,
0.6152899861335754,
-0.25669559836387634,
-0.6360201239585876,
-0.9668815732002258,
-0.22480136156082153,
-0.07176733762025833,
-0.25208643078804016,
0.4407538175582886,
-0.013773496262729168,
-0.1755620241165161,
0.5756017565727234,
-1.0240877866744995,
-0.9929091930389404,
-0.18734793365001678,
0.11471474915742874,
0.43469035625457764,
0.06563612073659897,
0.44275879859924316,
-0.9777060747146606,
-0.5545440316200256,
0.15654124319553375,
-1.0313787460327148,
-0.5811086297035217,
-0.1659712791442871,
0.16783732175827026,
-0.12826602160930634,
0.577789306640625,
-0.05696142092347145,
0.9275745749473572,
0.39062970876693726,
-0.24547351896762848,
0.017397617921233177,
-0.5816417932510376,
0.21353138983249664,
-0.952735960483551,
-0.24274088442325592,
0.5625590085983276,
-0.4716404378414154,
-0.34925174713134766,
-0.5919687747955322,
0.09034370630979538,
0.12847556173801422,
-0.23679250478744507,
0.165690615773201,
-0.3789820373058319,
0.16057392954826355,
-0.40430793166160583,
-0.14525486528873444,
0.09165863692760468,
0.2954891622066498,
0.3829825222492218,
0.3517933189868927,
0.5804354548454285,
-0.6123850345611572,
-0.07034803926944733,
0.12057708948850632,
-0.3159511089324951,
0.36037880182266235,
-0.45983368158340454,
-0.09488708525896072,
-0.22229307889938354,
0.24863217771053314,
-0.8133330345153809,
-0.27883559465408325,
0.10802531987428665,
-0.30001962184906006,
0.2036656141281128,
-0.39641857147216797,
-0.42976856231689453,
-0.5945167541503906,
-0.20051367580890656,
0.21500840783119202,
0.6534335613250732,
-0.5564243197441101,
0.33740147948265076,
0.5301671028137207,
0.06355082243680954,
-0.3871711492538452,
-1.0346357822418213,
-0.18726015090942383,
-0.018494291231036186,
-0.29771363735198975,
0.28892725706100464,
0.3103734254837036,
0.2085123360157013,
0.001079108682461083,
-0.01660357229411602,
-0.16553400456905365,
-0.05412198230624199,
0.31124556064605713,
0.3767073154449463,
-0.05866820365190506,
0.07548241317272186,
0.14757539331912994,
-0.24970334768295288,
-0.17561805248260498,
-0.3798366189002991,
-0.18340662121772766,
0.18270368874073029,
-0.43360427021980286,
-0.4986812472343445,
0.09397145360708237,
0.4233274459838867,
-0.1782262772321701,
0.6443385481834412,
0.8005842566490173,
-0.5893316864967346,
-0.20191583037376404,
-0.1684778779745102,
-0.401780903339386,
-0.4204394221305847,
0.43003013730049133,
0.233938068151474,
-0.9386544823646545,
0.20038965344429016,
-0.19072742760181427,
0.0216479804366827,
0.5260821580886841,
0.7056256532669067,
-0.3410547971725464,
1.3186590671539307,
0.5249616503715515,
0.02641337178647518,
0.33334338665008545,
-0.025633709505200386,
0.10686323046684265,
-0.36770138144493103,
-0.5611269474029541,
-0.4355945885181427,
-0.17113427817821503,
-0.3806823790073395,
-0.543765127658844,
0.8122055530548096,
-0.42922335863113403,
0.3418963551521301,
0.10092990845441818,
-1.1630849838256836,
0.5244923830032349,
0.21707943081855774,
0.573035717010498,
0.1511978954076767,
-0.06801148504018784,
-0.1694408804178238,
-0.355348140001297,
-0.7572910189628601,
-0.26658329367637634,
1.3497827053070068,
0.03519592806696892,
0.6031667590141296,
-0.21987919509410858,
0.6758796572685242,
0.4331543445587158,
0.2079520970582962,
-0.46073782444000244,
0.33039578795433044,
-0.7230987548828125,
-0.39893096685409546,
-0.1275758594274521,
-0.4901043474674225,
-0.7259436249732971,
0.15347187221050262,
-0.36790990829467773,
-0.5738280415534973,
0.09429594874382019,
0.27903303503990173,
-0.48346686363220215,
0.4240511357784271,
-0.7893688678741455,
0.8278548717498779,
-0.3849228620529175,
-0.5567526817321777,
0.3640023469924927,
-0.7653083205223083,
0.19375799596309662,
-0.022238725796341896,
0.4260973334312439,
0.1764514148235321,
-0.07612814754247665,
0.5435656309127808,
-0.5631493926048279,
1.0171841382980347,
-0.6364448666572571,
0.014958745799958706,
0.27972084283828735,
-0.22962234914302826,
0.6258963942527771,
-0.0005480562103912234,
0.2635595202445984,
-0.1336584985256195,
-0.024967581033706665,
-0.6088973879814148,
-0.10088253766298294,
0.5028588175773621,
-0.2073928862810135,
-0.03332925960421562,
-0.23642803728580475,
-0.36957603693008423,
-0.346069872379303,
0.27761921286582947,
0.6210589408874512,
0.46657806634902954,
0.1707148402929306,
0.30929601192474365,
0.9810503721237183,
-0.5099117159843445,
-0.03023875504732132,
0.1770251989364624,
-0.10946159809827805,
-0.2178562730550766,
1.0070658922195435,
-0.030821284279227257,
-0.16891609132289886,
0.6112249493598938,
0.4951985478401184,
-0.3949921429157257,
-0.7515367865562439,
-0.05940834432840347,
-0.030156651511788368,
-0.4986402094364166,
-0.32516998052597046,
-0.7622957229614258,
0.16616305708885193,
-0.06840483099222183,
-0.2694704532623291,
-0.44959425926208496,
0.18336327373981476,
-0.3659323751926422,
0.06580448150634766,
0.36036762595176697,
0.4902469515800476,
-0.07070975005626678,
0.3393503725528717,
-0.5052329897880554,
0.32004114985466003,
0.19643333554267883,
0.1366586536169052,
-0.5043458938598633,
-0.6022308468818665,
-0.5244924426078796,
-0.009049809537827969,
0.06010805442929268,
-0.6450920701026917,
0.30297616124153137,
0.14214551448822021,
0.38890302181243896,
0.6202055215835571,
0.35168230533599854,
0.5116527080535889,
0.10805158317089081,
0.6263052821159363,
0.22054898738861084,
-0.3707939386367798,
0.9258853793144226,
-0.4178768992424011,
0.5542218089103699,
0.7675486207008362,
0.2076544463634491,
-0.05481419339776039,
-0.5355403423309326,
-0.2915104329586029,
-0.7465459704399109,
0.7632862329483032,
0.16654863953590393,
-0.25263458490371704,
-0.007316295988857746,
0.22322116792201996,
0.07970426976680756,
-0.09704781323671341,
-0.6454657912254333,
-0.2067645639181137,
-0.15421722829341888,
-0.726824939250946,
-0.18093548715114594,
-0.31138288974761963,
-0.24679715931415558,
-0.2085244506597519,
0.6858298182487488,
-0.425281286239624,
0.24493610858917236,
0.4875147342681885,
-0.009334603324532509,
0.12516842782497406,
-0.1306581348180771,
0.5839011073112488,
0.014780908823013306,
-0.421233594417572,
0.32444292306900024,
0.19620241224765778,
-0.7675696015357971,
-0.27541711926460266,
0.0383976511657238,
-0.0044603506103158,
0.25767430663108826,
0.592852771282196,
0.4795040190219879,
0.23127740621566772,
-0.5659011006355286,
0.8633783459663391,
-0.20959675312042236,
-0.49676042795181274,
0.19977320730686188,
-0.021586434915661812,
0.01694510690867901,
0.07076266407966614,
0.5480295419692993,
0.28882578015327454,
0.417350172996521,
-0.04497786983847618,
0.44360777735710144,
0.2700771987438202,
-1.0736290216445923,
0.08658839017152786,
0.7154009342193604,
0.07065004110336304,
0.3675982356071472,
0.09590156376361847,
-0.026066826656460762,
-0.43876975774765015,
0.7628759145736694,
0.42957237362861633,
0.3172409236431122,
-0.039397500455379486,
0.2599695324897766,
0.3433244824409485,
0.48317697644233704,
-0.22448863089084625,
0.035704925656318665,
-0.04346825182437897,
-0.24450838565826416,
-0.35829365253448486,
-0.17748843133449554,
-0.2847192883491516,
0.12801161408424377,
-0.44708508253097534,
0.3501718044281006,
-0.5728985071182251,
-0.245119109749794,
0.12918442487716675,
0.02400766685605049,
-0.12133440375328064,
0.7872475385665894,
0.2799784541130066,
0.5797827243804932,
-0.8766058683395386,
0.6550310254096985,
0.770763635635376,
-0.15447843074798584,
-0.6742314100265503,
0.044857051223516464,
0.22943544387817383,
-0.5761233568191528,
0.21043148636817932,
0.6147380471229553,
0.010722530074417591,
-0.3571016490459442,
-0.5798136591911316,
-0.25764286518096924,
1.1023019552230835,
0.2593570351600647,
-0.4005892276763916,
0.14590118825435638,
-0.24199068546295166,
0.7506176233291626,
-0.3816097378730774,
0.3322303295135498,
-0.06362710893154144,
0.15460330247879028,
0.46964117884635925,
-0.5475757122039795,
-0.023764338344335556,
-0.06833842396736145,
-0.17893478274345398,
0.36726072430610657,
-0.22799642384052277,
0.3444652855396271,
-0.2710554897785187,
-0.12671351432800293,
0.006344066001474857,
0.33070892095565796,
-0.006322053726762533,
0.9257532358169556,
0.5057904720306396,
0.4604915678501129,
0.7149654626846313,
-0.12045285850763321,
1.1852983236312866,
0.03146713972091675,
0.362002432346344,
0.6600469946861267,
0.04827108979225159,
0.2044856995344162,
0.36727532744407654,
-0.0019904703367501497,
0.4318230450153351,
0.8030130863189697,
-0.09220971912145615,
0.9020553231239319,
-0.22336141765117645,
-0.24008095264434814,
-0.5622343420982361,
-0.4669603705406189,
-0.3295753300189972,
0.20539836585521698,
0.5126129984855652,
-0.8494561910629272,
-0.34169915318489075,
0.2737073302268982,
-0.06552550196647644,
0.20835572481155396,
-0.49049267172813416,
0.7416478991508484,
0.10864511132240295,
-0.3482569456100464,
0.47850146889686584,
-0.18308962881565094,
1.0425723791122437,
-0.696377694606781,
0.05225188285112381,
-0.21193715929985046,
0.34423619508743286,
-0.6374427080154419,
-0.6492779850959778,
0.305781751871109,
0.14216850697994232,
0.10248441994190216,
0.08893771469593048,
1.1048918962478638,
-0.4301426112651825,
-0.6180029511451721,
0.3085249960422516,
0.25967738032341003,
0.20092082023620605,
0.08492090553045273,
-0.48639804124832153,
-0.20285898447036743,
0.30862733721733093,
0.05250900983810425,
0.4460403621196747,
0.3567443788051605,
-0.02612179145216942,
0.31566405296325684,
0.6637142300605774,
0.09917695075273514,
-0.5829713940620422,
-0.24560154974460602,
0.7061748504638672,
-0.18457408249378204,
-0.6012359857559204,
-0.6219925284385681,
0.2769611179828644,
-0.3381863236427307,
-0.28414738178253174,
0.5442951321601868,
0.462350457906723,
0.5348484516143799,
0.08095565438270569,
0.5562788844108582,
0.19426831603050232,
0.6404250264167786,
-0.5580716729164124,
0.8584064841270447,
-0.9462442994117737,
0.3098199963569641,
-0.36953845620155334,
-0.3245941698551178,
-0.612804651260376,
0.5377830862998962,
-0.6534724235534668,
0.22005832195281982,
0.6563471555709839,
0.8219134211540222,
-0.08595805615186691,
-0.14403489232063293,
0.5137154459953308,
0.17131385207176208,
-0.04422593489289284,
0.67703777551651,
0.27718526124954224,
-0.25530171394348145,
0.7425916790962219,
-0.397286593914032,
-0.4871215522289276,
-0.4736233055591583,
-0.6053722500801086,
-1.0929620265960693,
-0.45431217551231384,
-0.5566741824150085,
-0.2683526873588562,
-0.03268328681588173,
0.31584468483924866,
0.9442612528800964,
-0.6412895321846008,
0.4706195890903473,
0.10267636179924011,
0.0931287407875061,
-0.051008328795433044,
-0.1494014859199524,
0.621916651725769,
-0.08989503979682922,
-0.5228554010391235,
0.5600095391273499,
0.6708932518959045,
-0.07008243352174759,
0.17887304723262787,
0.07442254573106766,
-0.35388413071632385,
-0.3664221167564392,
0.33545157313346863,
0.41810691356658936,
-0.07672613114118576,
0.23192837834358215,
-0.20042265951633453,
-0.5038933157920837,
-0.0515112467110157,
0.48716363310813904,
-1.0008476972579956,
0.8831024169921875,
0.05569950491189957,
0.6913249492645264,
0.6041199564933777,
-0.06925111263990402,
0.14014533162117004,
-0.9165785908699036,
0.3362424969673157,
0.4736422896385193,
0.04969758167862892,
0.44196856021881104,
-0.9718961715698242,
0.45395147800445557,
0.5127822756767273,
-0.4576255977153778,
-0.7962239980697632,
0.09514541178941727,
-0.8643299341201782,
-0.4275687038898468,
0.9919909834861755,
-0.18456010520458221,
-0.5660603046417236,
-0.42877456545829773,
-0.28426796197891235,
0.2665649652481079,
-0.44270387291908264,
0.6240975260734558,
-0.09767124801874161,
-0.2481861114501953,
-0.23840105533599854,
-0.29333916306495667,
0.715334951877594,
0.6328275203704834,
-0.7056839466094971,
-0.5752123594284058,
0.44283193349838257,
0.13763809204101562,
-0.029701611027121544,
0.7897840142250061,
-0.34296542406082153,
0.5935946702957153,
-0.20636217296123505,
-0.10393699258565903,
-0.3217169940471649,
-0.05710654705762863,
-0.13085323572158813,
0.27014800906181335,
-0.17355069518089294,
-0.5844801664352417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14225v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14225v1
|
ReactXT: Understanding Molecular "Reaction-ship" via Reaction-Contextualized Molecule-Text Pretraining
| 2024-05-23T06:55:59 | 2024-05-23T06:55:59 |
Zhiyuan Liu, Yaorui Shi, An Zhang, Sihang Li, Enzhi Zhang, Xiang Wang, Kenji Kawaguchi, Tat-Seng Chua
|
q-bio.QM
|
q-bio.QM, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Molecule-text modeling, which aims to facilitate molecule-relevant tasks with
a textual interface and textual knowledge, is an emerging research direction.
Beyond single molecules, studying reaction-text modeling holds promise for
helping the synthesis of new materials and drugs. However, previous works
mostly neglect reaction-text modeling: they primarily focus on modeling
individual molecule-text pairs or learning chemical reactions without texts in
context. Additionally, one key task of reaction-text modeling -- experimental
procedure prediction -- is less explored due to the absence of an open-source
dataset. The task is to predict step-by-step actions of conducting chemical
experiments and is crucial to automating chemical synthesis. To resolve the
challenges above, we propose a new pretraining method, ReactXT, for
reaction-text modeling, and a new dataset, OpenExp, for experimental procedure
prediction. Specifically, ReactXT features three types of input contexts to
incrementally pretrain LMs. Each of the three input contexts corresponds to a
pretraining task to improve the text-based understanding of either reactions or
single molecules. ReactXT demonstrates consistent improvements in experimental
procedure prediction and molecule captioning and offers competitive results in
retrosynthesis. Our code is available at https://github.com/syr-cn/ReactXT.
|
[
-0.27643823623657227,
-0.5714944005012512,
0.7820475697517395,
0.16471125185489655,
-0.18472431600093842,
0.11413412541151047,
-0.16330471634864807,
-0.16346034407615662,
0.04859704151749611,
0.4350268840789795,
-0.786089301109314,
-0.5465497970581055,
-0.21126466989517212,
0.2942432463169098,
-0.2421649992465973,
1.0974938869476318,
-0.501940906047821,
0.2581038475036621,
-0.5437358617782593,
0.05998968333005905,
-0.2892320156097412,
-0.24995136260986328,
-0.4875641465187073,
-0.3155245780944824,
0.6517676711082458,
0.46217668056488037,
0.1603788286447525,
0.4631902873516083,
0.5499284863471985,
0.2825537323951721,
0.002287135925143957,
-0.4415209889411926,
-0.3654203414916992,
0.22588637471199036,
-0.2399548441171646,
-0.5897557735443115,
-0.5244280099868774,
0.21672500669956207,
0.295000821352005,
0.5689284205436707,
-0.03930659219622612,
-0.061684079468250275,
-0.3069149851799011,
0.55058354139328,
-0.729447603225708,
0.09035427868366241,
-0.3019042909145355,
0.35965991020202637,
0.010380825959146023,
-0.26405659317970276,
-0.581561803817749,
-0.10015954077243805,
0.36182093620300293,
-0.8959922194480896,
0.2732953429222107,
0.07385005801916122,
0.2873016595840454,
0.04588138312101364,
-0.5973097681999207,
-0.022981220856308937,
-0.5668150782585144,
0.3813360631465912,
-0.5369961857795715,
0.3459663987159729,
-0.26105424761772156,
0.5016036033630371,
-0.373623251914978,
-1.0990275144577026,
-0.552997887134552,
-0.31631430983543396,
-0.02802409417927265,
0.5062645673751831,
0.1911621242761612,
0.20758450031280518,
0.008253635838627815,
0.38128119707107544,
-0.8725501894950867,
-0.17987504601478577,
-0.13257651031017303,
-0.06724071502685547,
0.26605871319770813,
0.12719839811325073,
0.2552888095378876,
0.10057001560926437,
-0.955990731716156,
-0.3835359215736389,
-0.6777589321136475,
-0.34130534529685974,
-0.15950991213321686,
0.6826359629631042,
-0.22588512301445007,
0.6259233355522156,
-0.29244035482406616,
0.48737430572509766,
-0.30461257696151733,
0.5999780893325806,
0.24656234681606293,
-0.5060728788375854,
-0.34618058800697327,
0.37810295820236206,
0.8365495800971985,
0.07529262453317642,
0.08739188313484192,
0.05791448801755905,
-0.0704205110669136,
0.16258089244365692,
0.2986772358417511,
-1.1146260499954224,
-0.3217427730560303,
0.5212432742118835,
-0.3495253622531891,
-0.2787942588329315,
-0.11026577651500702,
-1.0034217834472656,
-0.32837894558906555,
-0.3732449412345886,
0.7866987586021423,
-0.15615643560886383,
-0.1564653217792511,
0.07944657653570175,
-0.5444498658180237,
-0.2297123223543167,
0.4750349521636963,
-0.3668338656425476,
0.3953738808631897,
0.3311249315738678,
0.765661358833313,
-0.5689476728439331,
-0.23424886167049408,
-0.6516092419624329,
-0.04602576419711113,
-0.12262619286775589,
0.7387763261795044,
-0.47508004307746887,
-0.5139573812484741,
-0.1965106725692749,
0.0005850515444763005,
0.15420521795749664,
-0.3368769586086273,
0.19287794828414917,
-0.4634014964103699,
0.2052551954984665,
0.012852413579821587,
-0.6955071091651917,
0.11720868200063705,
0.056953418999910355,
-0.6458113789558411,
0.5949001312255859,
0.10007645189762115,
-0.5200917720794678,
0.2010125070810318,
-0.8849518299102783,
-0.4728972017765045,
-0.1505662202835083,
-0.16234645247459412,
-0.2795829772949219,
0.18969562649726868,
-0.048089634627103806,
0.38591378927230835,
-0.05022807419300079,
-0.11033280193805695,
-0.48759904503822327,
-0.12192042917013168,
0.21705566346645355,
0.19340097904205322,
0.45850110054016113,
0.33035239577293396,
-0.3109067678451538,
0.41827836632728577,
-1.020691990852356,
0.01213244441896677,
-0.15176130831241608,
-0.31602320075035095,
-0.19442589581012726,
-0.222349151968956,
0.22554531693458557,
0.38111308217048645,
-0.024211019277572632,
-0.5835955739021301,
0.25636026263237,
-0.45910608768463135,
0.27628272771835327,
0.6937548518180847,
0.022167522460222244,
0.6075945496559143,
0.3283287584781647,
0.5587601661682129,
0.27811840176582336,
-0.06343012303113937,
-0.660161018371582,
-0.43149906396865845,
-0.41784846782684326,
0.27331870794296265,
0.20936819911003113,
0.33867812156677246,
-0.743896484375,
-0.2567395567893982,
-0.06278491765260696,
-0.45696166157722473,
0.3618028461933136,
-0.2648620307445526,
0.5698909759521484,
0.6989953517913818,
0.7007825374603271,
-0.26992660760879517,
-0.885445773601532,
-0.45628881454467773,
-0.45799344778060913,
-0.12934575974941254,
0.027699774131178856,
0.045980844646692276,
0.7786628603935242,
-0.3446911871433258,
0.898699164390564,
-0.7759553790092468,
-0.27271661162376404,
-0.07984203845262527,
0.6380894780158997,
0.0806979387998581,
0.6520779132843018,
0.06822091341018677,
-0.9449642300605774,
-0.5599720478057861,
0.1927674263715744,
-0.27630990743637085,
0.10481145977973938,
0.10985558480024338,
-0.32041043043136597,
0.2562582492828369,
0.9617558717727661,
-0.5391141176223755,
0.43930742144584656,
0.37001654505729675,
-0.34966903924942017,
0.46300867199897766,
-0.11085902154445648,
0.026973454281687737,
-1.2467578649520874,
0.16685090959072113,
0.09224899858236313,
-0.15882135927677155,
-0.7021860480308533,
-0.026695331558585167,
0.16383211314678192,
-0.3814547657966614,
-0.9393150210380554,
0.8448907136917114,
-0.37116238474845886,
-0.08775067329406738,
-0.22001735866069794,
0.01908978819847107,
-0.14864394068717957,
0.3988017141819,
0.8034263849258423,
0.725832998752594,
0.14122600853443146,
-0.5117623805999756,
0.02011183090507984,
0.3812180459499359,
-0.11685875803232193,
0.2709515392780304,
-0.5788806676864624,
0.10820852965116501,
-0.035566240549087524,
0.4780782163143158,
-1.2765268087387085,
-0.49411702156066895,
0.14694002270698547,
-0.5915979146957397,
0.36210373044013977,
0.0011779050109907985,
0.05914224684238434,
-0.41090065240859985,
-0.20258945226669312,
0.4996086359024048,
0.289065957069397,
-0.3233235776424408,
0.816493809223175,
0.04591485857963562,
-0.11029770225286484,
-0.5985420346260071,
-0.5694921016693115,
-0.2711186110973358,
-0.02362985908985138,
0.06084219366312027,
0.5743009448051453,
-0.406562864780426,
0.0994785726070404,
-0.1634823977947235,
-0.5108363628387451,
-0.3287656605243683,
-0.21419240534305573,
0.2811698615550995,
0.35570651292800903,
-0.06215696409344673,
0.16192704439163208,
-0.13485971093177795,
-0.22584494948387146,
0.1672240048646927,
-0.24444374442100525,
0.2641310691833496,
0.15867701172828674,
0.3162786662578583,
-0.10661705583333969,
0.2005770057439804,
0.5264074206352234,
-0.04141815006732941,
0.49222490191459656,
0.3177831768989563,
-0.10442447662353516,
-0.37718018889427185,
0.07467710971832275,
-0.5880183577537537,
-0.4257296323776245,
0.3684837222099304,
-0.2904275357723236,
-0.6884177923202515,
0.24185021221637726,
-0.44181135296821594,
-0.20106644928455353,
0.1302209198474884,
0.482234925031662,
-0.19752460718154907,
0.8235489726066589,
0.7413914799690247,
0.3990572690963745,
0.3001478910446167,
0.1590050756931305,
0.02011505886912346,
-0.6375626921653748,
-0.11177004128694534,
-0.6311543583869934,
-0.2018674910068512,
-0.4341195523738861,
-0.6255864500999451,
0.5351094007492065,
-0.3922422230243683,
-0.5410963296890259,
0.6520820260047913,
-0.3648119568824768,
0.4191225469112396,
0.2467854917049408,
0.05852141231298447,
0.1581796258687973,
0.15893010795116425,
-0.36339887976646423,
0.13492810726165771,
-0.5837392210960388,
-0.09457932412624359,
1.4777307510375977,
0.022583387792110443,
0.9903091788291931,
-0.3351130187511444,
0.7270926237106323,
0.08297969400882721,
0.4804375469684601,
-0.6292949318885803,
0.6559686064720154,
0.06692579388618469,
-0.7099842429161072,
-0.027537301182746887,
-0.690352737903595,
-0.9552010297775269,
0.010685866698622704,
-0.2637835443019867,
-0.4255374073982239,
0.03130393102765083,
0.35368964076042175,
-0.42914915084838867,
-0.2138739377260208,
-0.7815232872962952,
1.179653286933899,
0.03772233799099922,
-0.43863362073898315,
0.03221546486020088,
-1.1359530687332153,
0.24428676068782806,
-0.05829577520489693,
0.2316150814294815,
0.22134695947170258,
-0.18516069650650024,
0.5290281772613525,
-0.5433083772659302,
0.649010956287384,
0.05576194450259209,
-0.17499829828739166,
0.14199206233024597,
0.23756827414035797,
0.32832708954811096,
-0.0013343465980142355,
0.3561496138572693,
-0.27957603335380554,
-0.008826244622468948,
-0.051624469459056854,
-0.6598517298698425,
0.6488234400749207,
-0.4879246652126312,
-0.2997185289859772,
-0.42639949917793274,
-0.31512629985809326,
-0.26242074370384216,
0.4399186968803406,
0.5122568607330322,
0.3791508674621582,
-0.3726648986339569,
-0.08354459702968597,
0.7199407815933228,
-0.2964906096458435,
0.4421962797641754,
0.7335774302482605,
-0.4515927731990814,
-0.5266907811164856,
0.8641985654830933,
-0.21350747346878052,
0.3576582074165344,
1.071584701538086,
0.02620381861925125,
-0.4255838692188263,
-0.21250930428504944,
-0.03980795294046402,
-0.0057004643604159355,
-0.7850270867347717,
-0.18270640075206757,
-0.3461018204689026,
0.1918325126171112,
-0.21887405216693878,
-0.11690202355384827,
-0.7336379885673523,
-0.5466567873954773,
-0.19850067794322968,
-0.09950331598520279,
0.05317263677716255,
0.40454018115997314,
-0.00953553058207035,
0.17111513018608093,
-0.8409203886985779,
0.5420237183570862,
0.31789329648017883,
0.44409361481666565,
-0.3207516074180603,
-0.023453211411833763,
-0.1920575350522995,
-0.09868736565113068,
-0.23068606853485107,
-0.9256023168563843,
0.1994117945432663,
-0.001922327559441328,
0.1992693394422531,
0.010989034548401833,
0.07853198796510696,
0.4001050293445587,
-0.8261838555335999,
0.6231392621994019,
0.29680436849594116,
-0.8849006295204163,
1.072717547416687,
-0.34114426374435425,
0.44174885749816895,
0.40195533633232117,
0.7720054388046265,
-0.3933195173740387,
-0.16068077087402344,
-0.38080543279647827,
-0.9583324790000916,
0.8119283318519592,
0.38603225350379944,
-0.18906225264072418,
-0.1123746931552887,
0.3705461919307709,
0.1885373890399933,
0.4347377419471741,
-0.8981427550315857,
-0.3716081976890564,
-0.14323300123214722,
-0.2964927852153778,
-0.3955588638782501,
0.18352998793125153,
-0.14438961446285248,
-0.26452410221099854,
0.7462778091430664,
-0.2135159820318222,
0.5006517767906189,
0.349989652633667,
-0.12174438685178757,
-0.19032815098762512,
0.2334679663181305,
0.7376867532730103,
0.42902693152427673,
-0.6441512703895569,
0.29098474979400635,
-0.20299716293811798,
-0.6723514199256897,
0.5924781560897827,
0.16323082149028778,
0.3556409180164337,
0.015417061746120453,
0.12132717669010162,
0.6419220566749573,
0.27612295746803284,
-0.8002666234970093,
0.447936087846756,
-0.2634951174259186,
-0.20585015416145325,
-0.04741659387946129,
0.1166897565126419,
-0.011416209861636162,
0.15319092571735382,
0.07407683879137039,
0.31302502751350403,
0.36071088910102844,
-0.5626322031021118,
0.1921389400959015,
0.12803377211093903,
-0.6491878032684326,
-0.2880342900753021,
1.033556342124939,
0.46952909231185913,
0.05528973415493965,
0.30424222350120544,
0.15822578966617584,
-0.14532192051410675,
0.7477753162384033,
0.5935720801353455,
0.964572012424469,
-0.5757946372032166,
0.1494048684835434,
0.5504905581474304,
-0.18804988265037537,
-0.10217844694852829,
0.38621243834495544,
-0.1759159117937088,
-0.4870641529560089,
-0.2440340220928192,
-0.38049423694610596,
-0.425391286611557,
0.05299626290798187,
-0.5196877121925354,
0.4668453633785248,
-0.2815439701080322,
-0.057060644030570984,
0.0719980001449585,
-0.2816401720046997,
-0.3481023609638214,
0.5176149606704712,
0.19292806088924408,
1.1900131702423096,
-0.7071803212165833,
0.5131126046180725,
0.9574376940727234,
-0.2890990674495697,
-0.3863913416862488,
-0.1018267348408699,
0.07919333875179291,
-0.20357419550418854,
0.8829794526100159,
0.41223713755607605,
0.0901627466082573,
0.21532297134399414,
-0.5709630250930786,
-0.6583282947540283,
0.7998590469360352,
0.22843313217163086,
-0.5682841539382935,
0.06905661523342133,
0.1982765793800354,
0.46844467520713806,
-0.3393215537071228,
0.5092639327049255,
0.3935653567314148,
0.4316073954105377,
0.08169978857040405,
-0.5215691924095154,
0.23179253935813904,
-0.30948320031166077,
0.09102566540241241,
0.17601460218429565,
-0.3044199049472809,
1.0371185541152954,
-0.1929863542318344,
-0.178421750664711,
0.1314324587583542,
0.6042733788490295,
0.35892432928085327,
0.39514437317848206,
0.1811557114124298,
0.6455872058868408,
0.12229011952877045,
-0.17396414279937744,
1.0103569030761719,
-0.0001545668492326513,
0.3564684987068176,
1.3428431749343872,
-0.37695568799972534,
1.1531678438186646,
0.5839804410934448,
-0.39637506008148193,
0.5730416178703308,
0.571887731552124,
0.34290653467178345,
0.6773393154144287,
0.3141918182373047,
-0.36298996210098267,
-0.1011795625090599,
0.4027506411075592,
-0.34268954396247864,
0.20221289992332458,
0.25239241123199463,
-0.26576316356658936,
-0.2927105724811554,
0.27324676513671875,
0.009046236053109169,
-0.06699080765247345,
-0.3948132395744324,
0.6540984511375427,
-0.0026183954905718565,
-0.9259868264198303,
0.35875391960144043,
-0.2335459291934967,
0.16616381704807281,
-0.6998040676116943,
-0.33533504605293274,
-0.2321849763393402,
0.33549007773399353,
0.08031707257032394,
-0.8024284839630127,
-0.0359485000371933,
-0.3960025906562805,
-0.08500261604785919,
-0.2389671355485916,
0.6241469979286194,
-0.49698469042778015,
0.0012829864863306284,
0.253505140542984,
0.3298220932483673,
-0.01563376933336258,
-0.27332979440689087,
-0.4058779180049896,
0.1174359917640686,
-0.030941927805542946,
-0.5643728375434875,
0.4100980758666992,
0.2070438265800476,
0.12578710913658142,
0.4809582829475403,
0.46851813793182373,
-0.46573564410209656,
-0.23676460981369019,
-0.22362522780895233,
0.9013929963111877,
-0.7435621619224548,
-0.4733239412307739,
-0.774954080581665,
0.7106214165687561,
0.14651532471179962,
-0.25910916924476624,
0.6122308373451233,
0.7273882627487183,
0.8973373174667358,
-0.7460821866989136,
0.7791553139686584,
0.18409204483032227,
0.3393808901309967,
-0.5905422568321228,
0.5388199090957642,
-0.6563067436218262,
-0.17118869721889496,
-0.4773705303668976,
-1.0017060041427612,
-0.2637663781642914,
0.38581380248069763,
0.10424499958753586,
0.17815522849559784,
1.0863738059997559,
0.639625608921051,
-0.15651094913482666,
0.21382445096969604,
-0.21074029803276062,
0.4698556065559387,
0.2891257703304291,
0.6529669165611267,
0.7873473167419434,
-0.45313963294029236,
0.40625709295272827,
-0.1903412640094757,
-0.04975977540016174,
-0.2790635824203491,
-1.2149217128753662,
-0.9195329546928406,
-0.645937979221344,
-0.37540751695632935,
-0.26670169830322266,
-0.12983427941799164,
0.8844360709190369,
0.7077053189277649,
-0.7453008890151978,
-0.5422382950782776,
-1.0766133069992065,
-0.04781913012266159,
-0.009546534158289433,
-0.231687992811203,
0.03377675265073776,
-0.5187550783157349,
-0.6670351028442383,
0.6203943490982056,
0.3899398744106293,
0.528252124786377,
0.13035553693771362,
-0.028580643236637115,
-0.2768060266971588,
0.04744889587163925,
0.6188222169876099,
0.5596083402633667,
-0.35155677795410156,
0.21469078958034515,
-0.011711878702044487,
0.1207793802022934,
0.21547628939151764,
0.9904711246490479,
-1.092047095298767,
0.8373039960861206,
0.6338411569595337,
0.35381320118904114,
0.8922412991523743,
-0.15058821439743042,
0.9674450159072876,
-0.915584921836853,
0.08826650679111481,
0.11953913420438766,
0.04074551537632942,
-0.03310665115714073,
-0.3001418113708496,
0.7003015875816345,
0.305576890707016,
-0.4743202328681946,
-0.820195734500885,
0.05917849764227867,
-1.045436143875122,
-0.7435975670814514,
0.7236728072166443,
-0.07699741423130035,
-0.5417555570602417,
0.29708319902420044,
-0.36224645376205444,
0.5439693331718445,
-0.4672916531562805,
0.3810674548149109,
0.4836667478084564,
-0.252332866191864,
-0.14392144978046417,
-0.5378701090812683,
0.87140953540802,
0.5267525315284729,
-1.2048888206481934,
0.19458122551441193,
0.5589510798454285,
-0.015601042658090591,
0.3120771646499634,
0.5200210213661194,
0.012549380771815777,
0.45060423016548157,
-0.10559248179197311,
0.19313816726207733,
0.04172777757048607,
-0.6437947750091553,
-0.05843786895275116,
0.02685602195560932,
-0.5236470699310303,
-0.01852327212691307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00018v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00018v1
|
Large Language Models' Detection of Political Orientation in Newspapers
| 2024-05-23T06:18:03 | 2024-05-23T06:18:03 |
Alessio Buscemi, Daniele Proverbio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Democratic opinion-forming may be manipulated if newspapers' alignment to
political or economical orientation is ambiguous. Various methods have been
developed to better understand newspapers' positioning. Recently, the advent of
Large Language Models (LLM), and particularly the pre-trained LLM chatbots like
ChatGPT or Gemini, hold disruptive potential to assist researchers and citizens
alike. However, little is know on whether LLM assessment is trustworthy: do
single LLM agrees with experts' assessment, and do different LLMs answer
consistently with one another? In this paper, we address specifically the
second challenge. We compare how four widely employed LLMs rate the positioning
of newspapers, and compare if their answers align with one another. We observe
that this is not the case. Over a woldwide dataset, articles in newspapers are
positioned strikingly differently by single LLMs, hinting to inconsistent
training or excessive randomness in the algorithms. We thus raise a warning
when deciding which tools to use, and we call for better training and algorithm
development, to cover such significant gap in a highly sensitive matter for
democracy and societies worldwide. We also call for community engagement in
benchmark evaluation, through our open initiative navai.pro.
|
[
-0.2595982849597931,
-0.6474288702011108,
0.8576456308364868,
0.14454129338264465,
-0.23685093224048615,
0.28032419085502625,
-0.47443050146102905,
-0.323741614818573,
0.2567507326602936,
0.3095799684524536,
-0.3503539562225342,
-0.2995736598968506,
-0.9775979518890381,
-0.012984352186322212,
-0.39711347222328186,
0.7800427079200745,
0.07088994234800339,
0.33801451325416565,
-0.1423853039741516,
-0.2561987042427063,
-0.02738947980105877,
-0.6991233229637146,
-0.5219352841377258,
-0.4039945602416992,
0.41116008162498474,
0.18387146294116974,
0.8190411925315857,
0.35156330466270447,
0.5763442516326904,
0.323621541261673,
-0.18984317779541016,
0.04836384579539299,
-0.5624314546585083,
-0.027081137523055077,
-0.1947343945503235,
-0.5506761074066162,
-0.19608618319034576,
0.37274113297462463,
0.43577563762664795,
0.5558832883834839,
-0.033151932060718536,
0.25995755195617676,
0.061464790254831314,
0.9380373954772949,
-0.48460277915000916,
0.0959918275475502,
-0.7730959057807922,
-0.11461906135082245,
-0.2537674307823181,
0.02615627646446228,
-0.3612591624259949,
-0.5366781949996948,
0.19636735320091248,
-0.14387664198875427,
-0.016185065731406212,
-0.15085014700889587,
0.9131865501403809,
-0.00749913789331913,
-0.7689061760902405,
-0.4717668294906616,
-0.6839208006858826,
0.7331258058547974,
-0.7068849802017212,
0.27541154623031616,
0.09689364582300186,
0.2338075190782547,
-0.34027358889579773,
-0.20633579790592194,
-0.6994443535804749,
-0.06518734991550446,
0.3259344696998596,
0.3101448118686676,
0.011162719689309597,
-0.1779930293560028,
-0.008811073377728462,
0.20013684034347534,
-0.3819873332977295,
0.3030531406402588,
-0.15828540921211243,
-0.12186985462903976,
0.5900639891624451,
-0.026158204302191734,
-0.10548427700996399,
-0.4898862838745117,
-0.32571572065353394,
-0.09422194212675095,
-0.6917996406555176,
0.06908977031707764,
0.9721125364303589,
0.3521849513053894,
-0.1041073352098465,
0.8238427042961121,
-0.10643570125102997,
0.5825232267379761,
0.39034348726272583,
-0.1780991107225418,
0.25354278087615967,
-0.18331222236156464,
-0.1310248225927353,
0.0008368233684450388,
1.0033971071243286,
0.5362281799316406,
0.2979765236377716,
0.2590419352054596,
-0.3446492552757263,
0.18132135272026062,
0.17562325298786163,
-0.45476341247558594,
0.046261776238679886,
0.2787667512893677,
-0.45546022057533264,
-0.4407843053340912,
0.4057452380657196,
-0.5836561322212219,
-0.8454436659812927,
-0.3193250596523285,
0.20613569021224976,
0.12606610357761383,
-0.3866473138332367,
0.204141303896904,
0.11534760892391205,
0.38810282945632935,
0.5310662984848022,
-0.8073982000350952,
-0.11775260418653488,
1.2321901321411133,
0.7458436489105225,
-0.19437932968139648,
0.09249124675989151,
-0.31260615587234497,
-0.1554756909608841,
-0.44739624857902527,
0.7557530403137207,
-0.586660623550415,
-0.11574523895978928,
0.3202289640903473,
-0.056132011115550995,
0.10121647268533707,
-0.5025761723518372,
0.43064117431640625,
-0.5857959389686584,
0.6845765113830566,
-0.3396155834197998,
-0.6010228395462036,
-0.06158198043704033,
0.6372460722923279,
-0.7324011921882629,
1.0367026329040527,
0.21021726727485657,
-0.8533934354782104,
0.5019747614860535,
-0.24624621868133545,
0.007314738817512989,
-0.46532177925109863,
-0.39722195267677307,
-0.4064173996448517,
0.16555346548557281,
0.3538336455821991,
0.33830952644348145,
-0.027705810964107513,
0.49278831481933594,
-0.3670818507671356,
-0.0864267349243164,
0.5168555378913879,
-0.5626229643821716,
0.9232349395751953,
-0.030517948791384697,
-0.3171892464160919,
0.21036329865455627,
-0.5279596447944641,
-0.3384149968624115,
-0.13137602806091309,
-0.42201077938079834,
-0.25615233182907104,
0.031139567494392395,
0.11326618492603302,
0.32765305042266846,
0.38740840554237366,
-0.6009434461593628,
0.38815581798553467,
-0.40968331694602966,
0.3631950318813324,
0.9584716558456421,
-0.16661067306995392,
0.5090144276618958,
-0.3891732096672058,
0.5657902359962463,
0.05963893234729767,
0.22724321484565735,
0.20038536190986633,
-0.4664689302444458,
-0.6366340517997742,
0.06455057114362717,
0.37936893105506897,
0.5721765160560608,
-0.43257859349250793,
0.42456552386283875,
-0.2987469732761383,
-0.5260634422302246,
-0.5094852447509766,
0.015837162733078003,
0.119545578956604,
0.2989352345466614,
-0.21940657496452332,
-0.2996700704097748,
-0.43854865431785583,
-0.8247021436691284,
-0.380742609500885,
-0.49021586775779724,
0.07122612744569778,
0.08028731495141983,
0.3603961765766144,
-0.024987375363707542,
0.8624398708343506,
0.034056443721055984,
-0.006617595907300711,
-0.12061920017004013,
0.11968926340341568,
0.4459289014339447,
-0.09772936254739761,
0.319650799036026,
-0.9861811399459839,
-0.4677477478981018,
-0.0932600200176239,
-0.47344139218330383,
-0.16251277923583984,
-0.16751517355442047,
0.32780784368515015,
0.6064930558204651,
0.4361061155796051,
-0.6902726888656616,
0.19607700407505035,
0.9930880069732666,
-0.14558668434619904,
0.4307560622692108,
-0.01914226822555065,
0.31463947892189026,
-1.1087868213653564,
-0.20539629459381104,
0.11006671190261841,
-0.4222964942455292,
-0.5250908136367798,
-0.14537963271141052,
0.033872537314891815,
0.17148001492023468,
-0.5507171750068665,
0.49927350878715515,
-0.4746049642562866,
-0.08736882358789444,
-0.36311131715774536,
0.4800998568534851,
-0.09298980981111526,
-0.020075049251317978,
0.03177999332547188,
0.6149172782897949,
0.2952287197113037,
-0.05539381504058838,
0.31756067276000977,
0.0066102035343647,
-0.8725180625915527,
0.49778681993484497,
-0.33407726883888245,
0.3646376430988312,
-0.2962080240249634,
0.2907731831073761,
-1.268871784210205,
-0.21326513588428497,
0.21854077279567719,
-0.43830546736717224,
0.09851726144552231,
-0.09234501421451569,
-0.5835630893707275,
-0.2602250277996063,
-0.29395946860313416,
0.0715908631682396,
0.2648361325263977,
-0.40523242950439453,
0.4120079576969147,
0.6407673954963684,
-0.20005330443382263,
-0.8983113765716553,
-0.41726335883140564,
0.16359193623065948,
-0.2565767467021942,
-0.6074033975601196,
-0.18986326456069946,
0.332133024930954,
-0.526676595211029,
-0.0721093937754631,
-0.3254147171974182,
0.037114497274160385,
0.006559721194207668,
0.26179420948028564,
0.12673410773277283,
-0.29610899090766907,
0.1448957473039627,
-0.46814045310020447,
-0.15911173820495605,
0.07815194875001907,
0.004610889591276646,
0.6844987869262695,
-0.1227690652012825,
-0.540232241153717,
-0.44932475686073303,
0.2073058784008026,
0.8682622313499451,
-0.2448902726173401,
0.6996354460716248,
0.41985374689102173,
-0.07757967710494995,
0.1714707911014557,
-0.8343133330345154,
-0.03055242821574211,
-0.4690842628479004,
0.42349478602409363,
0.015466006472706795,
-0.9257345199584961,
0.4885573089122772,
-0.03586871922016144,
0.07023577392101288,
0.3647344410419464,
0.9060834050178528,
-0.02102595381438732,
1.0113661289215088,
0.6983141899108887,
-0.5535219311714172,
0.47743430733680725,
0.16926322877407074,
0.433799684047699,
-0.30182668566703796,
-0.2730603814125061,
-0.8066100478172302,
-0.35075250267982483,
-0.6848952770233154,
-0.2881045341491699,
0.41065841913223267,
-0.22018980979919434,
-0.2007751315832138,
-0.06143093481659889,
-0.5315059423446655,
0.5350723266601562,
0.17227891087532043,
-0.12879057228565216,
0.3249508738517761,
-0.03764171153306961,
0.45619165897369385,
-0.07190754264593124,
-0.47823575139045715,
-0.8581485152244568,
0.9507399201393127,
0.40509453415870667,
0.8745190501213074,
-0.01562982238829136,
0.6175763607025146,
-0.027503184974193573,
0.6223287582397461,
-0.8792937994003296,
0.411081999540329,
-0.09986428171396255,
-0.730204164981842,
-0.3099704086780548,
-0.2978692650794983,
-0.7780452966690063,
0.22850683331489563,
-0.33198800683021545,
-0.5977202653884888,
0.1741274744272232,
-0.2381201535463333,
-0.07272162288427353,
0.46586155891418457,
-0.41700151562690735,
0.5560094714164734,
-0.32779449224472046,
-0.03651631250977516,
-0.06398988515138626,
-0.47722750902175903,
0.20187832415103912,
-0.11206460744142532,
0.49077126383781433,
-0.31696340441703796,
-0.15421907603740692,
0.640282392501831,
-0.017170902341604233,
0.7998957633972168,
-0.20012784004211426,
-0.4398428201675415,
0.12534472346305847,
-0.2082500010728836,
0.28656721115112305,
0.017340581864118576,
-0.34580639004707336,
0.16417624056339264,
-0.07762417197227478,
-0.2060960829257965,
-0.47529101371765137,
0.6290499567985535,
-0.9948867559432983,
-0.9388969540596008,
-0.569030225276947,
-0.5666319727897644,
-0.16300572454929352,
0.12780678272247314,
0.3241865038871765,
0.21464323997497559,
-0.2847263813018799,
0.4237958788871765,
0.5510206818580627,
0.1362948715686798,
0.25572332739830017,
0.2829298675060272,
-0.47979840636253357,
-0.15945512056350708,
0.3343421518802643,
0.2185831516981125,
0.21199271082878113,
0.42797189950942993,
0.3090416491031647,
-0.35159578919410706,
-0.4834921061992645,
-0.29336491227149963,
0.09213525056838989,
-0.650739312171936,
-0.08304465562105179,
-0.3888818919658661,
-0.00975728128105402,
-0.34615465998649597,
-0.20137085020542145,
-0.6092892289161682,
-0.4882800877094269,
-0.06671499460935593,
0.01410539448261261,
0.17777319252490997,
0.7421802878379822,
0.1141572818160057,
0.3934067189693451,
-0.47251272201538086,
0.19729268550872803,
0.1303524225950241,
0.23816260695457458,
-0.35604387521743774,
-0.4273475110530853,
-0.03481851890683174,
0.17675979435443878,
-0.28834015130996704,
-1.0937694311141968,
0.0753624439239502,
-0.28268375992774963,
0.4812343716621399,
0.5830236077308655,
0.016941960901021957,
0.24892762303352356,
-0.4386199116706848,
0.8785632252693176,
0.08823559433221817,
-0.7374517321586609,
0.2248101532459259,
-0.553882896900177,
0.11691052466630936,
0.7722890973091125,
0.6645073890686035,
-0.5129130482673645,
-0.7911715507507324,
-0.5037612915039062,
-0.5651581287384033,
0.3437228500843048,
-0.1732277274131775,
0.42085763812065125,
-0.07890935242176056,
0.42038092017173767,
0.18089185655117035,
0.2920345664024353,
-0.9462366700172424,
0.021528128534555435,
-0.09486697614192963,
-0.27902981638908386,
-0.15647532045841217,
-0.2826979160308838,
-0.2915004789829254,
-0.01896662451326847,
0.4738309979438782,
0.0016734976088628173,
0.10788256675004959,
0.19701890647411346,
0.13231642544269562,
-0.32370075583457947,
0.41372957825660706,
0.47419023513793945,
1.050700068473816,
-0.15531006455421448,
0.11552022397518158,
-0.344996839761734,
-0.33663102984428406,
0.37654176354408264,
-0.2922500967979431,
-0.18243525922298431,
0.1923844963312149,
0.2513236999511719,
0.4247535467147827,
-0.07294946163892746,
-0.3211931586265564,
0.9077333807945251,
-0.022680215537548065,
-0.22886598110198975,
-0.45417097210884094,
-0.11372167617082596,
0.34542733430862427,
0.30970409512519836,
0.24435999989509583,
-0.08868039399385452,
-0.22060289978981018,
-0.934004545211792,
-0.13693246245384216,
0.8192104697227478,
-0.3630240559577942,
-0.1927189826965332,
0.3913593590259552,
0.24580280482769012,
-0.5496269464492798,
0.4812941253185272,
-0.06235526502132416,
-0.8361032605171204,
0.6645426750183105,
0.2642366886138916,
0.680546224117279,
-0.2928254306316376,
0.35328173637390137,
-0.03473665937781334,
0.5244497656822205,
-0.30104249715805054,
0.2558479309082031,
0.42802894115448,
-0.8843594193458557,
-0.41384556889533997,
-0.19854089617729187,
-0.6186875104904175,
0.22034680843353271,
-0.6660693287849426,
0.35606297850608826,
-0.467041939496994,
-0.40757250785827637,
0.036644574254751205,
0.41905608773231506,
-0.4044167399406433,
-0.1256350874900818,
0.3232699930667877,
0.8903538584709167,
-1.046366810798645,
0.7457598447799683,
0.6987142562866211,
0.21726468205451965,
-0.4515152871608734,
0.23675474524497986,
0.405526340007782,
-0.6686767339706421,
0.36105844378471375,
0.3788323700428009,
-0.16051560640335083,
-0.54798823595047,
-0.7503817677497864,
-0.5128944516181946,
0.6623170375823975,
0.37738168239593506,
-0.8190036416053772,
0.0423893928527832,
0.2722993791103363,
0.487541139125824,
-0.4122871160507202,
0.3099404275417328,
0.32257944345474243,
0.6541478633880615,
-0.3148235082626343,
-1.0143309831619263,
-0.25146520137786865,
0.16114197671413422,
-0.2032044380903244,
0.34697839617729187,
-1.028586745262146,
0.9181941151618958,
0.04016341269016266,
-0.21497909724712372,
0.03343873843550682,
0.519589364528656,
0.020414188504219055,
0.36734044551849365,
0.6221305727958679,
0.28879445791244507,
0.870668888092041,
-0.09829682111740112,
1.0484397411346436,
-0.26192453503608704,
0.4768863618373871,
0.7995593547821045,
-0.3884199857711792,
0.8648926615715027,
0.6177670359611511,
0.027676252648234367,
0.3989945650100708,
0.6132461428642273,
0.005305406171828508,
0.48397183418273926,
0.14650467038154602,
-0.25780171155929565,
-0.17253725230693817,
0.14542533457279205,
-0.16432437300682068,
0.6788279414176941,
0.4098697900772095,
-0.0967954620718956,
-0.29562366008758545,
-0.036944787949323654,
0.23895709216594696,
0.476295530796051,
-0.3023953139781952,
0.5287976861000061,
0.055440738797187805,
-0.6884526610374451,
0.09629485011100769,
0.11327061802148819,
0.7375226020812988,
-0.3938119113445282,
0.3853103816509247,
-0.22192895412445068,
0.06017718464136124,
-0.23955608904361725,
-1.087231993675232,
0.18290461599826813,
-0.06393115222454071,
-0.17226450145244598,
-0.20822979509830475,
0.5768516063690186,
-0.31017836928367615,
-0.4175354838371277,
0.12581497430801392,
0.8201441764831543,
-0.04035016894340515,
-0.029330691322684288,
-0.6503548622131348,
0.33179259300231934,
-0.04760242626070976,
-0.6031935214996338,
0.35690513253211975,
0.6056368350982666,
-0.12506017088890076,
0.48526981472969055,
0.5215462446212769,
0.07232131063938141,
-0.15772122144699097,
0.004970235284417868,
0.7593603134155273,
-0.33894082903862,
-0.3802289664745331,
-0.8962985277175903,
0.05238337442278862,
-0.09193336963653564,
-0.3615686297416687,
0.8315407633781433,
0.5664681792259216,
0.9096842408180237,
0.0817895457148552,
0.6495325565338135,
0.1092875674366951,
0.4195271134376526,
-0.6006209850311279,
0.769356906414032,
-0.2643979787826538,
0.06131570041179657,
-0.1834142655134201,
-1.1390643119812012,
-0.3191564083099365,
0.7324418425559998,
-0.6503075957298279,
0.044951144605875015,
0.47960901260375977,
0.9066972732543945,
-0.07062770426273346,
-0.00424550985917449,
-0.0036814550403505564,
0.13552631437778473,
0.39511439204216003,
0.5131999254226685,
1.2014646530151367,
-0.04000062495470047,
0.3582310378551483,
-0.22236374020576477,
-0.15745705366134644,
-0.13343553245067596,
-1.118963599205017,
-0.9452275633811951,
-0.5843406319618225,
-0.28867286443710327,
-0.4741765856742859,
0.025816427543759346,
0.8329899311065674,
0.6753852367401123,
-0.4741400480270386,
-0.3845560550689697,
0.332560658454895,
0.15874116122722626,
0.0779077559709549,
-0.17576833069324493,
0.4849961996078491,
0.0026010042056441307,
-0.8991037011146545,
-0.005202630069106817,
0.27037519216537476,
-0.20404037833213806,
-0.6427331566810608,
0.22663769125938416,
-0.21685044467449188,
0.1625729650259018,
0.43902626633644104,
0.1938522458076477,
-0.8349190950393677,
-0.7177965641021729,
0.002256335224956274,
-0.48240604996681213,
0.3908487558364868,
0.9386203289031982,
-0.5883476734161377,
0.3550434410572052,
0.5634799599647522,
0.5998216271400452,
0.2863523066043854,
0.1730518639087677,
0.25020837783813477,
-0.5165772438049316,
0.37146252393722534,
0.2635812759399414,
0.10698947310447693,
0.630867600440979,
-0.3222530484199524,
0.31010475754737854,
-0.10010586678981781,
-0.7330605387687683,
-0.7054789662361145,
0.1854323148727417,
-1.1522963047027588,
-0.13323824107646942,
1.3776192665100098,
0.17370140552520752,
-0.34131020307540894,
-0.04788399115204811,
-0.18491709232330322,
0.07888258993625641,
-0.3275345265865326,
0.9965181350708008,
1.0334525108337402,
-0.004405476152896881,
-0.202065110206604,
-0.7668446898460388,
0.1865074634552002,
0.2559748589992523,
-0.576513409614563,
-0.0021036292891949415,
0.4171850383281708,
0.3250870406627655,
0.2695585787296295,
0.8164864778518677,
-0.2947160303592682,
0.03737936168909073,
-0.3003876805305481,
-0.28875213861465454,
0.155723437666893,
-0.29865169525146484,
-0.6226875185966492,
0.1331527978181839,
0.08428220450878143,
0.04732593148946762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14213v1
|
From Text to Pixel: Advancing Long-Context Understanding in MLLMs
| 2024-05-23T06:17:23 | 2024-05-23T06:17:23 |
Yujie Lu, Xiujun Li, Tsu-Jui Fu, Miguel Eckstein, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The rapid progress in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has
significantly advanced their ability to process and understand complex visual
and textual information. However, the integration of multiple images and
extensive textual contexts remains a challenge due to the inherent limitation
of the models' capacity to handle long input sequences efficiently. In this
paper, we introduce SEEKER, a multimodal large language model designed to
tackle this issue. SEEKER aims to optimize the compact encoding of long text by
compressing the text sequence into the visual pixel space via images, enabling
the model to handle long text within a fixed token-length budget efficiently.
Our empirical experiments on six long-context multimodal tasks demonstrate that
SEEKER can leverage fewer image tokens to convey the same amount of textual
information compared with the OCR-based approach, and is more efficient in
understanding long-form multimodal input and generating long-form textual
output, outperforming all existing proprietary and open-source MLLMs by large
margins.
|
[
-0.3978608250617981,
-0.7476373314857483,
0.9264653921127319,
0.13303512334823608,
-0.20727217197418213,
-0.17027941346168518,
-0.47758930921554565,
-0.4850272536277771,
0.06763622909784317,
0.3371005654335022,
-0.5682592988014221,
-0.3834082782268524,
-0.8789093494415283,
-0.023860106244683266,
-0.5419453382492065,
0.6964208483695984,
-0.12584523856639862,
-0.35296866297721863,
0.05396398901939392,
-0.13795426487922668,
-0.567359209060669,
-0.6081651449203491,
-0.4404957592487335,
0.16139847040176392,
0.9932010769844055,
0.12025944888591766,
0.8136543035507202,
0.4157451391220093,
0.6028216481208801,
0.29918232560157776,
0.03782326728105545,
0.32384273409843445,
-0.6189161539077759,
0.2408338189125061,
-0.3727491796016693,
-0.12382450699806213,
-0.17142976820468903,
-0.30059921741485596,
0.9880049228668213,
0.4544416666030884,
0.06504268199205399,
0.1832742542028427,
-0.020006893202662468,
0.5551905035972595,
-0.8907497525215149,
-0.0005347367841750383,
-0.3779377341270447,
0.02337368205189705,
-0.28857871890068054,
-0.3895677924156189,
-0.8314148783683777,
0.2077576071023941,
0.035557109862565994,
-0.48520779609680176,
0.15923553705215454,
0.06612823903560638,
0.5892210602760315,
0.1145021840929985,
-0.8776528835296631,
-0.37952178716659546,
-0.5334343910217285,
1.048137903213501,
-0.1830199509859085,
0.5762273669242859,
0.4091842472553253,
0.5154318809509277,
-0.22924543917179108,
-0.9401721358299255,
-0.7324838042259216,
0.23163823783397675,
-0.15012076497077942,
-0.11232096701860428,
-0.05581198260188103,
-0.04468943178653717,
0.08568311482667923,
0.06379038840532303,
-0.5956044793128967,
-0.008894288912415504,
-0.31304898858070374,
-0.19003191590309143,
0.49852094054222107,
0.06818922609090805,
0.3160563111305237,
-0.4191091060638428,
-0.6787907481193542,
-0.12876668572425842,
-0.35699114203453064,
0.07181250303983688,
-0.2870407998561859,
0.44332176446914673,
-0.04786597564816475,
0.78838050365448,
0.11924637109041214,
0.7680431008338928,
-0.2957094609737396,
-0.06864653527736664,
-0.009534759446978569,
-0.577847421169281,
-0.20185978710651398,
-0.08607789129018784,
0.6380852460861206,
0.67408686876297,
-0.14669284224510193,
-0.04979546740651131,
-0.3376716077327728,
-0.05312860384583473,
0.1810332089662552,
-1.1160379648208618,
0.30797088146209717,
0.27934494614601135,
-0.8363307118415833,
0.26494118571281433,
-0.09259139746427536,
-1.1231622695922852,
-0.6112978458404541,
-0.26901209354400635,
0.49999353289604187,
-0.35877248644828796,
-0.16328755021095276,
0.2806631028652191,
-0.2675076127052307,
0.39182960987091064,
0.527216911315918,
-0.777845025062561,
-0.22273646295070648,
0.5727941393852234,
1.1262352466583252,
-0.06669563055038452,
-0.45673608779907227,
-0.9991058111190796,
0.198179230093956,
-0.33520424365997314,
0.6195438504219055,
-0.6327997446060181,
-0.4815566837787628,
0.26046404242515564,
0.015947967767715454,
-0.13461026549339294,
-0.035258714109659195,
0.5844376683235168,
-0.750382661819458,
0.21672050654888153,
-0.047942835837602615,
-0.39371734857559204,
-0.10764992237091064,
0.40167349576950073,
-0.7530436515808105,
0.897247314453125,
0.04967355728149414,
-0.486554354429245,
0.489732563495636,
-0.8570736646652222,
-0.2001114785671234,
0.10515861213207245,
-0.18937790393829346,
-0.12325941026210785,
0.3262588679790497,
0.5558112263679504,
0.7889875769615173,
-0.15004530549049377,
0.39034363627433777,
-0.15174145996570587,
-0.7103714346885681,
0.34495270252227783,
-0.5160210132598877,
0.31242889165878296,
0.3508230745792389,
-0.1961575150489807,
0.31003230810165405,
-0.4257253110408783,
0.05283771827816963,
0.1628579944372177,
-0.5587789416313171,
-0.15474483370780945,
0.2592799961566925,
0.6716717481613159,
0.22768379747867584,
0.2700027823448181,
-0.49502885341644287,
0.27051591873168945,
0.07461240887641907,
0.5211198925971985,
0.7358676195144653,
-0.4300510585308075,
0.6165370345115662,
-0.03185971453785896,
0.3200724124908447,
-0.09151504933834076,
0.15471792221069336,
-0.9972677230834961,
-0.3316434919834137,
-0.6379715800285339,
-0.6349418759346008,
0.07023400068283081,
0.03151702508330345,
-1.0849007368087769,
0.249312624335289,
-0.7144647836685181,
-0.15953336656093597,
-0.4608411192893982,
0.07486005127429962,
0.18167644739151,
0.177276149392128,
0.4568593204021454,
-0.1647842973470688,
-0.3219441771507263,
-0.6652610301971436,
-0.1815793812274933,
0.2704550623893738,
0.011415463872253895,
0.4263814389705658,
0.6324329376220703,
-0.7484133839607239,
1.036794900894165,
-0.5586527585983276,
-0.3650299906730652,
-0.29897210001945496,
0.14332394301891327,
0.2884063720703125,
0.3267506957054138,
0.620821475982666,
-1.1649738550186157,
-0.48466771841049194,
0.12726891040802002,
-0.558095395565033,
0.505952775478363,
-0.27263355255126953,
-0.22742488980293274,
0.3553195595741272,
0.5740681886672974,
-0.8088896870613098,
0.767436146736145,
0.6871953010559082,
-0.8361733555793762,
0.2741037905216217,
-0.22850647568702698,
0.24975092709064484,
-1.074772834777832,
0.2742227017879486,
0.09044096618890762,
-0.538341760635376,
-0.5905765891075134,
0.600020706653595,
0.5300940275192261,
-0.44666486978530884,
-0.5080991387367249,
0.9245315790176392,
-0.48015254735946655,
-0.033427923917770386,
-0.39876487851142883,
0.32374444603919983,
0.33132511377334595,
0.36026161909103394,
0.25723952054977417,
0.9248284101486206,
0.5173941850662231,
-0.40246373414993286,
0.5303950905799866,
0.24122647941112518,
-0.7172690033912659,
0.5428303480148315,
-0.37527498602867126,
0.12484467029571533,
-0.6376522183418274,
0.5444583296775818,
-0.9714677333831787,
-0.4356669485569,
-0.04029599577188492,
-0.4054659307003021,
0.4176948666572571,
-0.2097359448671341,
-0.7437954545021057,
-0.344744473695755,
-0.29532966017723083,
0.8744148015975952,
0.35341864824295044,
-0.9144687056541443,
0.8068994879722595,
-0.010347828269004822,
-0.05080089718103409,
-0.6767048835754395,
-0.6181095838546753,
0.5567998886108398,
0.030964339151978493,
-0.5232633948326111,
0.3184487223625183,
-0.032194819301366806,
0.13220162689685822,
-0.2471376657485962,
0.3769224286079407,
-0.08782899379730225,
-0.18529149889945984,
0.0502762608230114,
0.1822933405637741,
-0.2202116698026657,
0.7189737558364868,
-0.16450822353363037,
-0.12928332388401031,
-0.16642822325229645,
-0.14843350648880005,
0.8644907474517822,
-0.0367005318403244,
-0.4290328323841095,
-0.400145560503006,
0.9066265225410461,
0.7270162105560303,
-0.41075655817985535,
0.9773587584495544,
0.8487042784690857,
-0.28155654668807983,
-0.1748552769422531,
-0.38509002327919006,
0.1086355671286583,
-0.4663802683353424,
0.8578530550003052,
-0.5576868057250977,
-0.7138267755508423,
0.16584257781505585,
-0.01737828738987446,
0.03502878546714783,
0.33827707171440125,
0.3907507658004761,
-0.17306679487228394,
1.0277984142303467,
0.9173434376716614,
0.04764599725604057,
0.48256075382232666,
-0.13102929294109344,
0.28714635968208313,
-0.8829878568649292,
-0.3908746838569641,
-0.38494572043418884,
-0.3956390619277954,
-0.17194679379463196,
-1.012197732925415,
0.22796998918056488,
-0.09092526137828827,
-0.17382028698921204,
0.13855989277362823,
-0.45474517345428467,
0.5685738921165466,
0.4430682063102722,
0.3398541808128357,
0.07521963864564896,
0.011711101047694683,
0.2506150007247925,
-0.07123731076717377,
-0.46612146496772766,
-0.45057570934295654,
0.9771966338157654,
0.5119714736938477,
0.7803625464439392,
0.4466949999332428,
0.37115591764450073,
0.10623239725828171,
0.18841108679771423,
-1.1100727319717407,
0.5431740880012512,
-0.15833835303783417,
-0.6865829825401306,
-0.2077590376138687,
-0.2287251055240631,
-0.9908050298690796,
0.42540937662124634,
-0.25496408343315125,
-0.7551386952400208,
0.22230079770088196,
-0.1930381953716278,
-0.19294840097427368,
0.3640827238559723,
-0.7198895215988159,
0.8505892157554626,
-0.28667041659355164,
-0.5554438829421997,
-0.19200627505779266,
-0.5721938610076904,
0.09944935142993927,
-0.2815690338611603,
0.427252858877182,
0.05094136670231819,
-0.3481100797653198,
0.46575790643692017,
-0.08089161664247513,
0.7521993517875671,
-0.18286843597888947,
-0.2759874761104584,
0.15289805829524994,
0.029763419181108475,
0.37917160987854004,
-0.22412361204624176,
-0.2142234891653061,
-0.14699885249137878,
0.08310023695230484,
-0.7058383822441101,
-0.6046470403671265,
0.5571469664573669,
-0.43100443482398987,
-0.17603330314159393,
-0.3327822983264923,
-0.6424708366394043,
0.07421299070119858,
0.3111621141433716,
0.1447879523038864,
0.7867729067802429,
-0.0021723012905567884,
0.47182247042655945,
0.4443799555301666,
-0.5941874384880066,
0.905570924282074,
-0.1085745096206665,
-0.8468500375747681,
-0.3266001045703888,
0.6440669298171997,
-0.29145848751068115,
0.06662505120038986,
0.40137574076652527,
-0.09201490879058838,
-0.7367694973945618,
-0.318874716758728,
-0.6275879740715027,
0.1587790697813034,
-1.0173213481903076,
-0.19302521646022797,
-0.5237960815429688,
-0.0672900453209877,
-0.2256823033094406,
-0.38060465455055237,
-0.1760253608226776,
0.14818060398101807,
-0.3438647985458374,
0.3155706524848938,
0.16088153421878815,
0.5698010325431824,
0.48528623580932617,
0.5162255167961121,
-1.0134048461914062,
0.4290819466114044,
0.2388346642255783,
0.6004435420036316,
0.1599016636610031,
-0.5550445318222046,
-0.3464581072330475,
0.16684070229530334,
-0.04721314460039139,
-0.6722708344459534,
0.4657520353794098,
0.42591625452041626,
0.14993233978748322,
0.5137667059898376,
-0.14780309796333313,
1.1518248319625854,
-0.6190698146820068,
0.9276220798492432,
0.6148785948753357,
-1.0368727445602417,
0.5681598782539368,
-0.41987329721450806,
0.6347796320915222,
0.23933377861976624,
0.2134208083152771,
-0.7978271842002869,
0.294575959444046,
0.21240955591201782,
-0.729119062423706,
0.4993683397769928,
0.04630088433623314,
0.5547627210617065,
-0.08350707590579987,
0.2753496766090393,
0.07564468681812286,
0.0948692113161087,
-1.0485529899597168,
0.2977277338504791,
-0.13079644739627838,
-0.4342513382434845,
-0.5796690583229065,
-0.5689621567726135,
-0.106270432472229,
-0.12842851877212524,
0.1262301653623581,
-0.45369866490364075,
0.37360379099845886,
0.3028339147567749,
-0.53990238904953,
0.17398996651172638,
0.34664469957351685,
0.6127516627311707,
0.6365073919296265,
-0.12921617925167084,
0.32701098918914795,
-0.26323258876800537,
-0.3725228011608124,
-0.13001912832260132,
-0.036502353847026825,
0.30276763439178467,
0.11055786162614822,
0.5730993151664734,
0.7691501379013062,
0.08891592174768448,
-1.0354032516479492,
0.8959487080574036,
-0.1623408943414688,
-0.15381398797035217,
-0.07693271338939667,
-0.32734981179237366,
-0.18616947531700134,
0.3796679377555847,
0.6605952382087708,
-0.0509561225771904,
0.11140456050634384,
-0.8257284164428711,
0.1668342649936676,
0.5823020935058594,
-0.31821489334106445,
-0.06747093796730042,
0.44149184226989746,
0.28561165928840637,
-0.29766255617141724,
0.7441762685775757,
0.11902660131454468,
-0.46066805720329285,
0.30825573205947876,
0.7485856413841248,
0.4881049394607544,
0.20729532837867737,
0.1457577645778656,
0.28342121839523315,
0.0038036631885915995,
-0.00996523816138506,
0.07916227728128433,
-0.302542507648468,
-0.34793075919151306,
-0.7423701286315918,
-0.750407338142395,
0.058606382459402084,
-0.24809184670448303,
-0.3832610845565796,
0.31133395433425903,
-0.1502687633037567,
-0.4279598295688629,
-0.11152739822864532,
-0.19134317338466644,
-0.6720253229141235,
0.10210419446229935,
0.3672831356525421,
0.9651070237159729,
-0.31587252020835876,
0.701846182346344,
0.35648205876350403,
-0.04592930153012276,
-0.40258508920669556,
-0.1563461869955063,
-0.1898553967475891,
-0.7952299118041992,
0.8718478083610535,
0.8409645557403564,
-0.242950901389122,
-0.0741601213812828,
-0.5411601066589355,
-0.8397591710090637,
1.0179243087768555,
0.01922544836997986,
-0.6550498604774475,
-0.10090113431215286,
0.08966609835624695,
0.32821956276893616,
-0.19001911580562592,
0.2280474454164505,
0.11797884851694107,
0.523220956325531,
0.23265142738819122,
-0.9602541923522949,
-0.03178177401423454,
-0.26653194427490234,
0.14912953972816467,
0.6381370425224304,
-0.3033468723297119,
0.71415776014328,
-0.2741234004497528,
-0.4968832731246948,
0.47784870862960815,
0.42814919352531433,
-0.05449177697300911,
0.49828723073005676,
0.3499186038970947,
0.2774737477302551,
0.5570945143699646,
-0.06494127959012985,
1.1006687879562378,
0.0755191445350647,
0.5091448426246643,
0.9883660078048706,
-0.2607858180999756,
1.2504616975784302,
0.7505248188972473,
0.1065187007188797,
0.4229634702205658,
0.5398078560829163,
0.08807391673326492,
0.4893202781677246,
-0.014608439989387989,
-0.5113851428031921,
-0.22448591887950897,
-0.11050943285226822,
-0.287543922662735,
0.5957501530647278,
0.3657781481742859,
-0.5872951149940491,
-0.3030787706375122,
0.4304578900337219,
-0.24107077717781067,
0.22896839678287506,
-0.5970679521560669,
0.6143879294395447,
-0.11687655001878738,
-0.7646135687828064,
0.48834869265556335,
0.1489090919494629,
0.9460319876670837,
-0.5402352809906006,
0.07481047511100769,
0.15904444456100464,
0.40482765436172485,
-0.07550612837076187,
-1.0697253942489624,
0.17604440450668335,
0.032882243394851685,
-0.1935020387172699,
-0.5458385944366455,
0.7233765125274658,
-0.48014670610427856,
-0.6139730215072632,
0.4078886806964874,
0.30608299374580383,
0.01591576263308525,
-0.3567892611026764,
-0.383345365524292,
0.3617134094238281,
-0.2656315863132477,
-0.1674816757440567,
0.25035518407821655,
0.4139270484447479,
0.18049101531505585,
0.6905816197395325,
0.6376424431800842,
-0.2183225303888321,
0.17545770108699799,
-0.12665198743343353,
0.7733055353164673,
-0.9079775214195251,
-0.35581454634666443,
-1.1092277765274048,
0.7640994191169739,
-0.13147129118442535,
-0.10933859646320343,
0.5450542569160461,
0.5614781975746155,
0.3275153338909149,
-0.16402293741703033,
0.39861050248146057,
0.05561642348766327,
0.1424919068813324,
-0.7217086553573608,
0.8045727014541626,
-0.8618898987770081,
-0.23247851431369781,
-0.08476211875677109,
-0.9150818586349487,
-0.534776508808136,
0.5072460770606995,
-0.12062711268663406,
-0.0825553685426712,
0.5568636059761047,
0.5979627966880798,
-0.22433294355869293,
-0.328840970993042,
0.41162991523742676,
-0.19982366263866425,
0.5040445923805237,
0.7569326758384705,
1.0653064250946045,
-0.4921562969684601,
0.5735641717910767,
0.27414005994796753,
-0.15081439912319183,
-0.27817657589912415,
-1.0190448760986328,
-1.0171668529510498,
-0.8282919526100159,
0.2791295051574707,
-0.13720479607582092,
-0.21848036348819733,
0.8391844034194946,
0.9318125247955322,
-0.125626340508461,
-0.07434677332639694,
0.24684354662895203,
-0.06685338169336319,
0.3292609453201294,
-0.2000875324010849,
0.5177857875823975,
-0.4079062342643738,
-0.9165335893630981,
0.2745456099510193,
0.3834727704524994,
0.11828945577144623,
-0.15706515312194824,
-0.14876648783683777,
-0.2860212028026581,
0.07413826882839203,
1.2290703058242798,
-0.0541297048330307,
-0.751642644405365,
-0.3469008803367615,
0.11223125457763672,
-0.19826902449131012,
0.1258537620306015,
0.7404253482818604,
-0.8272131681442261,
0.849449872970581,
0.13182392716407776,
0.7477573156356812,
0.5347837805747986,
-0.1415652334690094,
0.47758719325065613,
-0.7470005750656128,
0.42113497853279114,
0.07511425763368607,
0.51775062084198,
0.2588101923465729,
-0.23880456387996674,
0.23472578823566437,
-0.32261088490486145,
-0.42802897095680237,
-0.9152527451515198,
0.35753026604652405,
-1.163361668586731,
-0.710348904132843,
1.2088040113449097,
-0.0006477792048826814,
-0.2571617364883423,
0.17509891092777252,
-0.6302939057350159,
-0.06606382131576538,
-0.2015122026205063,
0.5688557624816895,
0.7195082306861877,
0.3307912051677704,
-0.4645317494869232,
-0.4486997723579407,
0.09933767467737198,
0.3053762912750244,
-0.6770198941230774,
0.1109478771686554,
0.7116378545761108,
-0.2875213027000427,
0.3265672028064728,
0.605360209941864,
0.030482377856969833,
0.24521766602993011,
-0.17490947246551514,
-0.17279769480228424,
0.19211214780807495,
-0.4660227298736572,
-0.36631274223327637,
0.33669817447662354,
-0.010783396661281586,
-0.2614883780479431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14212v1
|
Federated Domain-Specific Knowledge Transfer on Large Language Models Using Synthetic Data
| 2024-05-23T06:14:35 | 2024-05-23T06:14:35 |
Haoran Li, Xinyuan Zhao, Dadi Guo, Hanlin Gu, Ziqian Zeng, Yuxing Han, Yangqiu Song, Lixin Fan, Qiang Yang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
As large language models (LLMs) demonstrate unparalleled performance and
generalization ability, LLMs are widely used and integrated into various
applications. When it comes to sensitive domains, as commonly described in
federated learning scenarios, directly using external LLMs on private data is
strictly prohibited by stringent data security and privacy regulations. For
local clients, the utilization of LLMs to improve the domain-specific small
language models (SLMs), characterized by limited computational resources and
domain-specific data, has attracted considerable research attention. By
observing that LLMs can empower domain-specific SLMs, existing methods
predominantly concentrate on leveraging the public data or LLMs to generate
more data to transfer knowledge from LLMs to SLMs. However, due to the
discrepancies between LLMs' generated data and clients' domain-specific data,
these methods cannot yield substantial improvements in the domain-specific
tasks. In this paper, we introduce a Federated Domain-specific Knowledge
Transfer (FDKT) framework, which enables domain-specific knowledge transfer
from LLMs to SLMs while preserving clients' data privacy. The core insight is
to leverage LLMs to augment data based on domain-specific few-shot
demonstrations, which are synthesized from private domain data using
differential privacy. Such synthetic samples share similar data distribution
with clients' private data and allow the server LLM to generate particular
knowledge to improve clients' SLMs. The extensive experimental results
demonstrate that the proposed FDKT framework consistently and greatly improves
SLMs' task performance by around 5\% with a privacy budget of less than 10,
compared to local training on private data.
|
[
-0.23951244354248047,
-0.7195637226104736,
0.6355500221252441,
0.2675279378890991,
-0.050387654453516006,
0.3500581979751587,
-0.49131104350090027,
-0.6222116947174072,
-0.022512953728437424,
0.6674811244010925,
-0.5354511737823486,
-0.7807019352912903,
-0.32931235432624817,
0.09329848736524582,
-0.3578859567642212,
0.971166729927063,
-0.17886538803577423,
-0.1421196311712265,
-0.447954386472702,
-0.03518969193100929,
-0.04545760899782181,
-0.6153309345245361,
-0.23765268921852112,
-0.3977150022983551,
0.29800230264663696,
0.3830949664115906,
0.5279675126075745,
0.5384425520896912,
0.5875751972198486,
0.2644091546535492,
0.1655876338481903,
0.28441259264945984,
-0.7852301597595215,
0.0065398793667554855,
-0.44425442814826965,
-0.5792554020881653,
-0.6093576550483704,
-0.07994034141302109,
0.7633865475654602,
0.7522459626197815,
-0.0003123696951661259,
0.1311844289302826,
-0.060037314891815186,
0.6435671448707581,
-0.5136423110961914,
0.5507462620735168,
-0.6629614233970642,
0.26090601086616516,
-0.2654336094856262,
0.051802970468997955,
-0.4152902662754059,
-0.4241096079349518,
0.32193148136138916,
-0.5844603180885315,
0.32862338423728943,
-0.06038378179073334,
0.38350197672843933,
0.02786499448120594,
-0.24423207342624664,
0.18774786591529846,
-0.9173890948295593,
0.6847032308578491,
-0.6070055365562439,
0.49335169792175293,
0.495495468378067,
0.3455860912799835,
-0.13804954290390015,
-0.8620216250419617,
-0.5422913432121277,
0.0023472378961741924,
-0.37964004278182983,
-0.2955823838710785,
-0.2899531424045563,
0.035209208726882935,
0.25578054785728455,
0.44314390420913696,
-0.4592389166355133,
0.2502213716506958,
-0.1749241054058075,
-0.25613319873809814,
0.8869404196739197,
0.2742554843425751,
-0.16049879789352417,
0.2845584750175476,
-0.660451352596283,
-0.01652451418340206,
-0.9643339514732361,
0.07531451433897018,
0.2569682002067566,
0.5723598003387451,
-0.2249038964509964,
0.35486915707588196,
-0.6155003309249878,
0.592127799987793,
0.2738650143146515,
-0.4047432243824005,
0.2789750397205353,
-0.41846054792404175,
-0.35527321696281433,
-0.19119291007518768,
0.4863276481628418,
0.1010814979672432,
0.008582605980336666,
-0.5841360688209534,
-0.37455135583877563,
-0.20541676878929138,
-0.03698882833123207,
-0.8411604166030884,
-0.1448144018650055,
0.09641150385141373,
-0.2646966278553009,
-0.2914177477359772,
-0.02092691697180271,
-0.8347640037536621,
-0.43227073550224304,
-0.4126410186290741,
0.3187372386455536,
-0.20470866560935974,
-0.34076443314552307,
-0.027014147490262985,
0.31207460165023804,
0.021073127165436745,
0.41556477546691895,
-0.8058843016624451,
0.5601442456245422,
0.9532181620597839,
0.855190634727478,
-0.5593593120574951,
-0.18726560473442078,
-0.6626455783843994,
0.33281344175338745,
-0.01178719662129879,
0.5817685127258301,
-0.43537598848342896,
-0.2623029351234436,
0.3333369195461273,
0.2378067523241043,
-0.06330089271068573,
-0.4708711504936218,
0.043188899755477905,
-0.75444495677948,
0.03358400985598564,
-0.1611683964729309,
-0.8093583583831787,
-0.03335898369550705,
0.2069142907857895,
-0.43608441948890686,
0.4390118420124054,
0.14786700904369354,
-0.6241248846054077,
0.10532266646623611,
-0.6039568185806274,
-0.5970298647880554,
0.2713109850883484,
-0.2561456859111786,
-0.36465784907341003,
-0.0929860770702362,
0.12732695043087006,
0.8305903673171997,
-0.22706331312656403,
0.17384850978851318,
-0.4539887011051178,
-0.2680695950984955,
0.35953694581985474,
-0.04039037972688675,
0.6266714334487915,
0.12934114038944244,
-0.39448031783103943,
-0.04050256311893463,
-0.723490834236145,
0.0395108163356781,
0.1911597102880478,
-0.2780184745788574,
-0.4445885121822357,
-0.5070984959602356,
-0.326448529958725,
0.11536111682653427,
0.32241585850715637,
-0.6287791132926941,
0.26087555289268494,
-0.6443678736686707,
0.14860393106937408,
0.9454301595687866,
0.0019387592328712344,
0.989256739616394,
-0.6020007729530334,
0.6686421632766724,
0.05240481346845627,
0.09869993478059769,
0.1839599907398224,
-0.3451298475265503,
-0.3601433038711548,
-0.47318920493125916,
0.23766914010047913,
0.27693289518356323,
-1.0750181674957275,
0.11569101363420486,
-0.5580285787582397,
-0.4165334105491638,
-0.33120694756507874,
0.30606329441070557,
0.34501612186431885,
0.4256953001022339,
0.12078540772199631,
-0.2692762613296509,
-0.21488700807094574,
-0.7758254408836365,
-0.09656189382076263,
0.18952396512031555,
-0.04078010097146034,
0.5042832493782043,
0.35425522923469543,
-0.2571784555912018,
0.9892056584358215,
-0.5400170683860779,
-0.7779533863067627,
-0.16581018269062042,
-0.1642126888036728,
-0.011449948884546757,
0.47313347458839417,
0.6603590250015259,
-0.6797035336494446,
-0.6974648833274841,
0.11840471625328064,
-0.5145464539527893,
-0.0020869204308837652,
0.044784460216760635,
-0.14867031574249268,
0.43749672174453735,
0.004651973489671946,
-0.6490848660469055,
0.315593957901001,
0.7942054867744446,
-0.3154126703739166,
0.5585342049598694,
-0.07449626177549362,
-0.04875526949763298,
-0.8364619612693787,
0.0031957419123500586,
-0.32158780097961426,
-0.5546509027481079,
-0.803219199180603,
0.13808368146419525,
-0.0789627805352211,
-0.09055940061807632,
-0.5915775895118713,
0.8279202580451965,
-0.3689662218093872,
-0.28654301166534424,
-0.3446483910083771,
0.15015916526317596,
-0.1520112007856369,
0.620306134223938,
0.07725551724433899,
0.7844964861869812,
0.648990273475647,
-0.48083990812301636,
0.5281651616096497,
0.47813504934310913,
-0.1990845948457718,
0.5873457789421082,
-0.11682144552469254,
0.46660423278808594,
0.2998383641242981,
0.2079613357782364,
-0.5008686780929565,
-0.32446029782295227,
0.2211446613073349,
-0.09610942006111145,
0.2832692563533783,
-0.19052357971668243,
-0.65103679895401,
-0.0167244840413332,
-0.19046828150749207,
0.19830068945884705,
0.5416809916496277,
-0.7793691754341125,
0.5502133965492249,
0.4347052276134491,
-0.21612437069416046,
-0.6162424087524414,
-0.9211698174476624,
-0.12320171296596527,
-0.09383700788021088,
-0.8748149275779724,
0.5478577017784119,
-0.06920362263917923,
-0.27402982115745544,
0.0868830606341362,
-0.16740263998508453,
-0.27951717376708984,
-0.04912814125418663,
0.42401546239852905,
0.020678697153925896,
-0.3054085671901703,
0.10349802672863007,
0.14413903653621674,
0.08363689482212067,
0.1806228756904602,
-0.5109451413154602,
0.30481553077697754,
-0.1577579230070114,
-0.3119294345378876,
-0.4194079637527466,
0.30322495102882385,
0.3034549951553345,
-0.11084213852882385,
1.0897036790847778,
0.5330935120582581,
-0.38212651014328003,
-0.8090295791625977,
-0.5205609798431396,
-0.506931483745575,
-0.5385046601295471,
-0.08871287852525711,
-0.39744648337364197,
-1.368812084197998,
0.6076172590255737,
-0.3205156624317169,
0.12093318998813629,
-0.026017826050519943,
0.6148393154144287,
0.1724519431591034,
0.7091443538665771,
0.8787784576416016,
-0.13197553157806396,
0.4903196096420288,
-0.3118806481361389,
0.1883678138256073,
-0.4541165232658386,
-0.10293173044919968,
-0.15070942044258118,
-0.29468727111816406,
-0.44101613759994507,
-0.5385326743125916,
0.12000299990177155,
-0.3279505968093872,
-0.08079497516155243,
0.18508027493953705,
-0.1429651975631714,
0.4793785810470581,
0.39951831102371216,
0.2845427989959717,
0.6816725134849548,
0.38651543855667114,
-0.21644142270088196,
0.014290605671703815,
-0.730297327041626,
-0.21536333858966827,
1.1627897024154663,
0.41523587703704834,
0.8592495918273926,
0.24646520614624023,
0.8388261795043945,
0.5559371113777161,
0.5704299807548523,
-0.4860886037349701,
0.7411943674087524,
-0.316234290599823,
-0.3874378502368927,
-0.18607403337955475,
-0.742367684841156,
-0.6167909502983093,
0.0029681266751140356,
-0.12109876424074173,
-0.6979074478149414,
0.36950474977493286,
0.002652264665812254,
-0.3227939307689667,
0.38209035992622375,
-0.5330178141593933,
0.5622365474700928,
0.0025265009608119726,
-0.7429553866386414,
-0.06324416399002075,
-0.5225812196731567,
0.5646666884422302,
-0.49066999554634094,
0.20924992859363556,
-0.009492024779319763,
0.21930599212646484,
0.6673564314842224,
-0.4420217275619507,
1.1091629266738892,
-0.486572265625,
-0.28855353593826294,
0.03136693686246872,
0.3666526973247528,
0.8281496167182922,
0.23820702731609344,
0.05407485365867615,
0.3581603765487671,
-0.17225076258182526,
-0.18865254521369934,
-0.713431715965271,
1.007238745689392,
-0.7258831858634949,
-0.7635030746459961,
-0.17855551838874817,
-0.7513964176177979,
-0.5528489947319031,
0.2123471349477768,
-0.25508913397789,
0.1315969079732895,
-0.008242446929216385,
0.3019368052482605,
0.5322237014770508,
-0.029662109911441803,
0.1148378774523735,
1.0506702661514282,
-0.28374120593070984,
-0.2220006287097931,
0.8105398416519165,
0.02511180005967617,
0.4983718991279602,
0.3288637697696686,
0.017361663281917572,
-0.47224748134613037,
-0.6173371076583862,
-0.04014477878808975,
0.43444812297821045,
-0.7898763418197632,
-0.6009775400161743,
-0.5093379616737366,
-0.3212265372276306,
-0.5324255228042603,
-0.2911517322063446,
-0.5064812898635864,
-0.5530998706817627,
-0.23318986594676971,
-0.33524975180625916,
0.6035251617431641,
0.43731576204299927,
-0.312200129032135,
0.3185409903526306,
-0.9186540842056274,
0.12244243174791336,
0.3116127848625183,
0.5577685832977295,
-0.11466251313686371,
-0.4427605867385864,
-0.27833008766174316,
0.26190993189811707,
0.05345730483531952,
-0.39758798480033875,
0.4403943121433258,
0.21453918516635895,
0.4796619713306427,
0.27281785011291504,
0.5055544376373291,
0.5277109146118164,
-0.3426364064216614,
0.6406359672546387,
-0.09725106507539749,
-0.876861572265625,
0.2378978431224823,
-0.32117241621017456,
-0.07405202835798264,
0.35965868830680847,
0.2524906098842621,
-0.20244981348514557,
-0.6339609622955322,
-0.6970301866531372,
-0.5401570200920105,
1.0392423868179321,
0.35976940393447876,
0.1556430608034134,
0.5448275804519653,
0.522441029548645,
0.38372644782066345,
0.30723175406455994,
-0.5479410290718079,
-0.2670135200023651,
0.20396924018859863,
-0.06701727956533432,
0.07188870012760162,
0.20167164504528046,
-0.4777818024158478,
-0.10552509874105453,
0.6716839671134949,
-0.28520068526268005,
0.4458850026130676,
0.12019941210746765,
-0.15627014636993408,
-0.2855154275894165,
0.18513061106204987,
0.5363771319389343,
0.6341637372970581,
0.018182776868343353,
0.3156757354736328,
0.22670909762382507,
-0.3681226372718811,
0.2755098342895508,
0.4889948070049286,
-0.3149482309818268,
-0.12211289256811142,
0.1045384407043457,
0.5811995267868042,
0.08991389721632004,
-0.5903354287147522,
0.6174257397651672,
-0.05805015563964844,
-0.36676138639450073,
-0.21483224630355835,
0.2640131711959839,
0.03347399830818176,
0.682622492313385,
0.15307530760765076,
-0.052296824753284454,
-0.2910884916782379,
-0.22559061646461487,
0.4259374141693115,
0.33103734254837036,
0.13405394554138184,
-0.6122022271156311,
0.5238630175590515,
0.27816200256347656,
-0.11957135796546936,
0.3418169915676117,
-0.07033062726259232,
-0.35849955677986145,
0.2617996037006378,
0.6351802349090576,
0.7130167484283447,
-0.3190667927265167,
0.4022640585899353,
-0.17866919934749603,
-0.023894591256976128,
-0.09042317420244217,
0.1417410671710968,
-0.3756621181964874,
-0.938957691192627,
-0.36109694838523865,
-0.6459903717041016,
-0.49159932136535645,
0.27503159642219543,
-0.5071037411689758,
-0.06317537277936935,
-0.6652547121047974,
-0.06656508147716522,
-0.20348022878170013,
0.3223855197429657,
-0.9428123235702515,
-0.18288059532642365,
0.10521405935287476,
0.8208445310592651,
-0.7462259531021118,
1.208594799041748,
0.5457051992416382,
-0.21181629598140717,
-0.7067343592643738,
-0.1485477238893509,
-0.029211286455392838,
-0.8313983082771301,
0.8289029598236084,
-0.2715950310230255,
-0.0558752715587616,
0.03934426233172417,
-0.4423331618309021,
-0.7141139507293701,
1.243869423866272,
0.5381912589073181,
-0.7355697751045227,
-0.020102031528949738,
0.8275996446609497,
0.7487918138504028,
-0.612817645072937,
-0.6599898338317871,
0.5153639316558838,
0.3997481167316437,
0.04178778827190399,
-0.930289626121521,
0.4105561673641205,
0.24777427315711975,
-0.12652580440044403,
-0.14064854383468628,
-0.6435966491699219,
0.6347917914390564,
-0.14867593348026276,
-0.3080888092517853,
-0.09765661507844925,
0.7030906677246094,
0.11699257791042328,
0.5215734839439392,
0.33926013112068176,
0.2627198398113251,
0.8276817798614502,
0.10883147269487381,
0.9114698171615601,
-0.3085139989852905,
0.5192546844482422,
1.1821907758712769,
-0.7727699875831604,
0.6656250953674316,
0.3988141119480133,
-0.16729852557182312,
0.12195514142513275,
0.05971406772732735,
0.024020515382289886,
0.7545788884162903,
0.03549664095044136,
-0.5515044927597046,
-0.06812174618244171,
-0.1505197137594223,
-0.31067410111427307,
0.4488944709300995,
0.3134148418903351,
-0.5298728346824646,
-0.20369967818260193,
0.23575446009635925,
0.0010546604171395302,
0.06508505344390869,
-0.09512163698673248,
1.0046783685684204,
0.2840617597103119,
-0.2619784474372864,
0.5453267693519592,
0.21291787922382355,
0.5479446649551392,
-0.6338142156600952,
0.12666459381580353,
-0.47111421823501587,
0.5822231769561768,
-0.29637548327445984,
-0.6713374257087708,
0.51552814245224,
0.18752124905586243,
-0.15551507472991943,
-0.6823961138725281,
1.070330262184143,
-0.6869742274284363,
-0.13565044105052948,
0.3080848753452301,
0.7323443293571472,
-0.02663561701774597,
-0.06696212291717529,
-0.5395216941833496,
-0.07171785086393356,
-0.04160837084054947,
-0.1690954566001892,
0.8125370740890503,
0.41265445947647095,
0.0767461508512497,
0.5214253067970276,
0.8753816485404968,
0.2909761667251587,
-0.01515250001102686,
0.006134749855846167,
1.1505223512649536,
-0.2753443717956543,
-0.6410415172576904,
-0.5359546542167664,
0.16076631844043732,
-0.03313017636537552,
0.20236097276210785,
0.8693055510520935,
0.2538888156414032,
1.115749478340149,
-0.26421648263931274,
0.7811974287033081,
0.13796456158161163,
0.6441202163696289,
-0.5407348871231079,
0.9889914393424988,
-0.2761244475841522,
0.38941025733947754,
0.035996779799461365,
-0.7618498802185059,
-0.3441774547100067,
0.5421696901321411,
-0.5125411152839661,
-0.33280694484710693,
0.38409918546676636,
0.9058002829551697,
-0.17792044579982758,
0.2299763709306717,
0.45990487933158875,
0.38661542534828186,
0.4616736173629761,
0.486102432012558,
0.6946948170661926,
-0.11502260714769363,
0.2946048676967621,
-0.8232088685035706,
-0.03636762127280235,
-0.11561837792396545,
-0.6987968683242798,
-1.0014152526855469,
-0.5573340058326721,
-0.47394222021102905,
-0.10906854271888733,
0.16697834432125092,
0.8841269016265869,
0.8268906474113464,
-0.8273323178291321,
-0.0013534458121284842,
-0.03747832030057907,
0.24582985043525696,
-0.14759722352027893,
-0.33142831921577454,
0.3877870440483093,
-0.038770321756601334,
-0.5417168736457825,
0.5352217555046082,
0.018992876634001732,
0.13944290578365326,
-0.40167510509490967,
-0.05490821227431297,
0.09245777130126953,
-0.2291068136692047,
0.6010552644729614,
0.15563993155956268,
-0.5413183569908142,
-0.47502401471138,
0.05221594125032425,
-0.06883798539638519,
-0.12071896344423294,
1.0204789638519287,
-0.8278385400772095,
0.2206796407699585,
0.4121569097042084,
0.9511180520057678,
0.4813153147697449,
0.08273480087518692,
0.619708240032196,
-1.3413076400756836,
0.27234983444213867,
0.35010096430778503,
0.13484375178813934,
0.28048697113990784,
-0.6688879728317261,
0.37725692987442017,
0.44717398285865784,
-0.5644211769104004,
-0.9319573640823364,
0.000593240896705538,
-0.7795870304107666,
-0.060383763164281845,
1.282086730003357,
-0.71941077709198,
-0.2163843959569931,
-0.09666397422552109,
0.2574383318424225,
-0.015997175127267838,
-0.4881261885166168,
0.7664651870727539,
0.3504543900489807,
-0.06794716417789459,
-0.04435030370950699,
-0.28338322043418884,
0.8551573753356934,
0.05181913450360298,
-0.9647761583328247,
0.4152470529079437,
0.4878581464290619,
0.5223520398139954,
-0.10367575287818909,
0.6088844537734985,
-0.04040173441171646,
-0.0016278917901217937,
-0.27808046340942383,
-0.34578612446784973,
-0.43142247200012207,
-0.4357396960258484,
-0.4004038870334625,
0.361008882522583,
-0.31621596217155457,
-0.06193475052714348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14211v1
|
ChronosLex: Time-aware Incremental Training for Temporal Generalization of Legal Classification Tasks
| 2024-05-23T06:09:16 | 2024-05-23T06:09:16 |
T. Y. S. S Santosh, Tuan-Quang Vuong, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study investigates the challenges posed by the dynamic nature of legal
multi-label text classification tasks, where legal concepts evolve over time.
Existing models often overlook the temporal dimension in their training
process, leading to suboptimal performance of those models over time, as they
treat training data as a single homogeneous block. To address this, we
introduce ChronosLex, an incremental training paradigm that trains models on
chronological splits, preserving the temporal order of the data. However, this
incremental approach raises concerns about overfitting to recent data,
prompting an assessment of mitigation strategies using continual learning and
temporal invariant methods. Our experimental results over six legal multi-label
text classification datasets reveal that continual learning methods prove
effective in preventing overfitting thereby enhancing temporal
generalizability, while temporal invariant methods struggle to capture these
dynamics of temporal shifts.
|
[
0.07928472757339478,
-0.5133240222930908,
0.5818814635276794,
0.12360472977161407,
-0.4207809269428253,
0.4378148913383484,
0.12829101085662842,
-0.7681400179862976,
-0.296802818775177,
0.2121126651763916,
-0.6134438514709473,
-0.3925912380218506,
-0.7634604573249817,
-0.10024388879537582,
-0.47185245156288147,
1.099265456199646,
-0.17724555730819702,
0.07476550340652466,
0.07506193965673447,
-0.6484517455101013,
-0.28444305062294006,
-0.9176353812217712,
-0.836428165435791,
-0.5386186242103577,
0.5948846340179443,
0.11902592331171036,
0.48231831192970276,
0.8810264468193054,
-0.07404625415802002,
0.25232213735580444,
-0.03194405138492584,
-0.44627565145492554,
-0.05118294060230255,
0.3309110105037689,
-0.3120788335800171,
-0.42413267493247986,
-0.30193111300468445,
0.177062526345253,
0.9945473670959473,
0.6557425856590271,
-0.5160484313964844,
0.1197461485862732,
-0.10189023613929749,
0.6104003190994263,
-0.8632994294166565,
0.08677351474761963,
-0.4566775858402252,
0.7225678563117981,
-0.152119442820549,
-0.5946441292762756,
-0.17027191817760468,
-0.6190991997718811,
0.23939663171768188,
-0.7781345844268799,
0.38190487027168274,
-0.0771811231970787,
0.6259342432022095,
0.4049476981163025,
-0.7761227488517761,
-0.49428650736808777,
-0.8306518793106079,
0.7057119607925415,
-0.4347993731498718,
0.75753253698349,
0.1912953406572342,
0.5195430517196655,
0.2809241712093353,
-0.9172595739364624,
-0.4032127559185028,
-0.38483142852783203,
0.1797756403684616,
0.2775585651397705,
0.15929055213928223,
-0.13529382646083832,
0.4980732202529907,
-0.017033513635396957,
-0.6623471975326538,
0.2527717351913452,
-0.03193854168057442,
-0.23884403705596924,
0.26901915669441223,
0.35695144534111023,
0.2648165822029114,
0.4010533094406128,
-0.36267757415771484,
-0.067886583507061,
-0.35381078720092773,
0.3561372756958008,
0.3932901620864868,
0.0343647263944149,
-0.13247911632061005,
0.2933928668498993,
-0.07670184969902039,
0.43634507060050964,
0.1263047754764557,
-0.21750862896442413,
0.2851632535457611,
-0.3984702229499817,
-0.261648565530777,
0.6945319771766663,
0.5271444916725159,
-0.2719641327857971,
0.08185745775699615,
-0.2771506905555725,
0.11875712126493454,
0.17095676064491272,
0.24021659791469574,
-0.8710952401161194,
-0.019996831193566322,
0.4372117817401886,
-0.04286547377705574,
-0.30676206946372986,
-0.06332996487617493,
-0.566504716873169,
-0.32023993134498596,
-0.9196332097053528,
0.04457958787679672,
-0.4711434245109558,
0.16625581681728363,
0.05920245498418808,
-0.257653146982193,
-0.03271213546395302,
0.5691798329353333,
-0.6833312511444092,
0.16523464024066925,
0.7327655553817749,
0.5952116847038269,
0.26288923621177673,
-0.3734361529350281,
-0.9773530960083008,
0.4302661120891571,
-0.5278326272964478,
0.54630047082901,
-0.7857152819633484,
-0.3964638113975525,
-0.07298985123634338,
0.36177000403404236,
-0.22917544841766357,
-0.16835705935955048,
0.22059988975524902,
-0.8206617832183838,
0.2944514751434326,
0.2055477797985077,
-0.48725971579551697,
0.08218144625425339,
0.5014066696166992,
-0.17836695909500122,
0.702477216720581,
0.1581164300441742,
-0.570913553237915,
1.1025025844573975,
-0.2880118489265442,
-0.3936447501182556,
0.24433690309524536,
-0.30477604269981384,
-0.935584306716919,
-0.3095569908618927,
-0.08227971941232681,
0.18052777647972107,
0.06674877554178238,
0.47124624252319336,
-0.3522662818431854,
0.1225760281085968,
0.2412186563014984,
-0.24143020808696747,
0.8132519125938416,
0.3842083215713501,
-0.3295324444770813,
0.060822635889053345,
-0.8497099280357361,
0.07148652523756027,
-0.1566501408815384,
-0.7954325675964355,
-0.4832266867160797,
0.28560346364974976,
-0.2333982288837433,
0.43588536977767944,
0.054044317454099655,
-0.788417637348175,
0.35247448086738586,
-0.08036444336175919,
0.6298459768295288,
0.8716639280319214,
0.10008816421031952,
0.5785956382751465,
-0.4138686954975128,
0.5496008396148682,
0.033552512526512146,
0.5837332010269165,
-0.19339291751384735,
-0.03513229265809059,
-0.5106755495071411,
-0.03390917554497719,
0.37348461151123047,
0.8593378067016602,
-0.6898643970489502,
0.031034065410494804,
-0.6345372796058655,
-0.5472592711448669,
0.235556498169899,
0.22772341966629028,
0.3312549889087677,
0.12652772665023804,
0.32980775833129883,
-0.23445084691047668,
-0.1457463800907135,
-0.3855089545249939,
-0.2437150478363037,
0.2016225904226303,
0.23446036875247955,
0.11654012650251389,
0.6695951223373413,
-0.42059311270713806,
0.6367520093917847,
-0.09965426474809647,
-0.09498704969882965,
0.20164652168750763,
0.7551424503326416,
-0.24941951036453247,
0.5348461270332336,
0.6639790534973145,
-0.8047003746032715,
-0.44469061493873596,
0.5167692303657532,
-0.7982583045959473,
0.11170259118080139,
-0.6829984188079834,
0.398271381855011,
0.5134236812591553,
0.8017957210540771,
0.044186219573020935,
0.2817070782184601,
0.21756742894649506,
-0.4874054789543152,
0.5251213908195496,
-0.4089297354221344,
0.35675546526908875,
-0.6429591178894043,
-0.19235457479953766,
-0.09285314381122589,
-0.40919244289398193,
-0.37504643201828003,
-0.13109564781188965,
0.4571264982223511,
-0.3083641231060028,
-0.6225001811981201,
0.5880818367004395,
-0.5895815491676331,
0.08748038113117218,
-0.17753607034683228,
-0.10121852904558182,
-0.30940505862236023,
0.499721884727478,
0.06044400483369827,
0.3628859221935272,
0.4527810215950012,
-1.0685160160064697,
0.27044662833213806,
-0.16343483328819275,
-0.15652558207511902,
0.9872852563858032,
-0.32181859016418457,
0.303960382938385,
-0.265950083732605,
0.2554019093513489,
-0.2919006943702698,
0.010358317755162716,
0.42469528317451477,
-0.2764587104320526,
0.7047917246818542,
-0.5400950312614441,
-0.5121163129806519,
-0.40461981296539307,
-0.2963721454143524,
0.6678681969642639,
0.0852384939789772,
-0.5306581258773804,
0.8315107822418213,
0.046675942838191986,
0.03744538128376007,
-0.7707882523536682,
-0.6421675682067871,
-0.02844083681702614,
-0.41463419795036316,
-0.08048035949468613,
0.223805770277977,
-0.0982319787144661,
-0.021524857729673386,
0.10280879586935043,
-0.5440044403076172,
-0.31977590918540955,
-0.03994815796613693,
0.36132967472076416,
-0.2134043127298355,
0.20560069382190704,
0.39973941445350647,
0.18935735523700714,
-0.2567301094532013,
-0.03647903725504875,
-0.8411312103271484,
0.3871605694293976,
0.35228830575942993,
-0.1709350049495697,
-0.6343461871147156,
0.22261019051074982,
0.5801166892051697,
-0.055743634700775146,
0.4065737724304199,
0.3075368404388428,
-0.18968120217323303,
-0.4038316011428833,
-0.523215651512146,
0.21464188396930695,
-0.4307367205619812,
0.11361467093229294,
-0.1925538331270218,
-1.1124658584594727,
0.222734734416008,
-0.09194011986255646,
0.3279827833175659,
0.3669317960739136,
0.27514249086380005,
-0.13235308229923248,
0.6598992943763733,
0.7422351241111755,
-0.08381882309913635,
1.0367029905319214,
-0.14084988832473755,
-0.42814454436302185,
-0.44010114669799805,
-0.3488876521587372,
-0.6301651000976562,
-0.0956302285194397,
-0.43014925718307495,
-0.0534566231071949,
0.2637912929058075,
-0.08702576160430908,
-0.6653862595558167,
0.3876366913318634,
-0.47029775381088257,
0.4213109016418457,
0.418900728225708,
0.20870725810527802,
0.24958236515522003,
0.21425548195838928,
0.04889781028032303,
0.041223712265491486,
-0.8297992944717407,
0.10826384276151657,
0.9797702431678772,
0.204001322388649,
0.5305697321891785,
-0.10508482158184052,
0.4692133367061615,
0.6123469471931458,
0.1786416918039322,
-0.5340816378593445,
0.22037333250045776,
-0.2781062424182892,
-0.529533326625824,
-0.3670211136341095,
-0.704203724861145,
-1.2935129404067993,
-0.026815157383680344,
-0.27004486322402954,
-0.5682409405708313,
0.629694938659668,
0.3129819929599762,
-0.3590962588787079,
0.32342728972435,
-0.1606607884168625,
0.7112837433815002,
-0.6477053165435791,
-0.5629174113273621,
-0.587112307548523,
-0.7433797121047974,
0.001631330931559205,
-0.4646857976913452,
0.4362860321998596,
-0.09443467855453491,
-0.02443697676062584,
0.7568641304969788,
-0.676846444606781,
1.0168602466583252,
-0.11271464079618454,
-0.0658869668841362,
0.2660520076751709,
0.16860440373420715,
0.5502914786338806,
0.1190335601568222,
0.43293148279190063,
-0.005574802402406931,
0.4734468162059784,
-0.5659124255180359,
-0.5912573933601379,
0.42191827297210693,
-0.5824781656265259,
-0.009544065222144127,
-1.1176482439041138,
-0.4598429501056671,
-0.04559538513422012,
0.04673049971461296,
0.18816301226615906,
0.7334411144256592,
-0.02669251151382923,
0.1093478724360466,
0.6282777786254883,
-0.21904176473617554,
0.4951208829879761,
0.7683855295181274,
0.16061514616012573,
-0.691557765007019,
0.8015899062156677,
0.5045182704925537,
0.243438720703125,
0.4787784218788147,
0.28184792399406433,
-0.27976953983306885,
-0.45320969820022583,
0.020160868763923645,
0.22945398092269897,
-0.8023337125778198,
0.13088412582874298,
-0.7794061303138733,
-0.12842793762683868,
-0.4954383969306946,
-0.24861405789852142,
-0.232870414853096,
-0.6882061958312988,
-0.061322979629039764,
0.20527036488056183,
0.34532439708709717,
0.3983058035373688,
-0.12167393416166306,
0.4370170831680298,
-1.0669664144515991,
0.229888454079628,
0.68809974193573,
0.3706120252609253,
-0.4304489493370056,
-0.6446112394332886,
-0.287432461977005,
-0.22698411345481873,
-0.31071895360946655,
-0.5650911927223206,
0.08602182567119598,
0.211138516664505,
0.7471749186515808,
0.37264105677604675,
-0.18991811573505402,
0.47575467824935913,
-0.6321409344673157,
0.5642890334129333,
0.28105759620666504,
-0.8373154401779175,
0.653511106967926,
-0.31723296642303467,
0.46997830271720886,
0.3261007070541382,
0.5162124037742615,
-0.7830524444580078,
-0.3231646716594696,
-0.608037531375885,
-0.9105990529060364,
0.734214723110199,
0.10610739141702652,
0.05338670313358307,
0.3431817889213562,
0.6855373382568359,
0.13067065179347992,
0.3442055284976959,
-0.6972951889038086,
0.1862681657075882,
-0.32228225469589233,
0.21486946940422058,
-0.07471679896116257,
-0.33239853382110596,
-0.13967956602573395,
-0.2868231534957886,
0.6263130903244019,
0.10397566109895706,
-0.0893104076385498,
0.1856096237897873,
-0.3546297550201416,
0.1012822836637497,
0.6784529089927673,
0.8112661838531494,
0.7249763607978821,
-0.07034523040056229,
-0.01624741405248642,
0.2939181327819824,
-0.7237933874130249,
0.5146833062171936,
0.22908827662467957,
-0.05152786150574684,
-0.17688067257404327,
0.5025377869606018,
0.5794939994812012,
0.2831350266933441,
-0.26262912154197693,
-0.04536287859082222,
0.06874597817659378,
-0.511058509349823,
-0.693022608757019,
0.09849750995635986,
-0.5465623736381531,
0.5462095141410828,
0.2616528272628784,
0.043299078941345215,
-0.0833420678973198,
-0.821319580078125,
0.2699713706970215,
0.09792894124984741,
-0.6943750381469727,
-0.12452428042888641,
0.9033755660057068,
-0.2735145390033722,
-0.14007218182086945,
0.47658461332321167,
-0.20058241486549377,
-0.533947229385376,
0.8321091532707214,
0.03993288055062294,
0.9010773301124573,
-0.43723544478416443,
0.09031970053911209,
0.5741118788719177,
0.3789357542991638,
-0.4176367521286011,
0.008043317124247551,
-0.6704520583152771,
-0.4720965325832367,
-0.1573842465877533,
-0.37547826766967773,
-0.32511770725250244,
-0.27180764079093933,
-0.4288904666900635,
-0.10763458907604218,
-0.7636761665344238,
-0.45013463497161865,
-0.10626079887151718,
-0.34695884585380554,
-0.5375170707702637,
0.34993410110473633,
-0.08629187196493149,
0.6261420845985413,
-0.5004985928535461,
1.0984549522399902,
0.513573169708252,
-0.22275114059448242,
-0.23744088411331177,
-0.15597856044769287,
0.380215048789978,
-0.20089475810527802,
0.9177101254463196,
-0.10308200865983963,
-0.27082526683807373,
-0.030742043629288673,
-0.6936854124069214,
-0.42576441168785095,
1.2813401222229004,
0.10212036222219467,
-0.8972011804580688,
0.006322676315903664,
0.24110129475593567,
0.5080798268318176,
-0.032296113669872284,
-0.39876309037208557,
0.4440464377403259,
0.3307614326477051,
0.10965459048748016,
-0.7693755626678467,
-0.2694410979747772,
-0.3095341920852661,
-0.13779722154140472,
0.4146213233470917,
-0.3030570447444916,
0.7573058009147644,
0.052122510969638824,
-0.6088525056838989,
-0.17398083209991455,
0.24273596704006195,
0.2069949209690094,
0.8106239438056946,
0.6309899091720581,
0.8123053312301636,
0.8201857805252075,
-0.2999345362186432,
1.2185046672821045,
-0.23149001598358154,
0.40384647250175476,
1.5834659337997437,
-0.20245717465877533,
0.2571541666984558,
0.2078620195388794,
-0.08075249940156937,
0.26214393973350525,
0.7057424783706665,
-0.32028794288635254,
0.38899141550064087,
0.08583357185125351,
-0.2685421109199524,
-0.5006536245346069,
0.10315553843975067,
-0.5509293079376221,
-0.16090625524520874,
0.32577475905418396,
-0.1917666643857956,
-0.5117313265800476,
0.39636141061782837,
0.09842980653047562,
0.06544291973114014,
-0.4619304835796356,
0.7193110585212708,
-0.04106682538986206,
-0.2250952124595642,
0.14992457628250122,
-0.2490251064300537,
0.45062652230262756,
-0.9762046933174133,
0.007896439172327518,
-0.12063048779964447,
0.46226683259010315,
-0.03006271831691265,
-0.7026901841163635,
0.1447000652551651,
-0.35179969668388367,
-0.024113621562719345,
-0.33217355608940125,
0.07886136323213577,
-0.30814072489738464,
-0.4851454794406891,
0.523945152759552,
-0.050107743591070175,
-0.10534598678350449,
0.04830231890082359,
-0.8357527256011963,
-0.14377082884311676,
-0.4342150390148163,
0.027906326577067375,
0.27611804008483887,
0.7977520823478699,
-0.32810449600219727,
0.9575408101081848,
0.5407654047012329,
-0.1056668609380722,
0.39159706234931946,
0.015867361798882484,
0.594974935054779,
-0.7180442214012146,
-0.821492075920105,
-0.7457962036132812,
0.41102853417396545,
-0.006179968360811472,
-0.334011971950531,
0.6694352030754089,
0.6497579216957092,
0.8801642656326294,
0.14159247279167175,
0.5756774544715881,
0.15282148122787476,
0.39669761061668396,
-0.9916468262672424,
0.5736594200134277,
-0.6579623818397522,
0.2273975908756256,
-0.025461215525865555,
-0.7374699711799622,
-0.289553165435791,
0.05052574723958969,
-0.35304588079452515,
-0.024410733953118324,
0.8840478658676147,
0.18171823024749756,
-0.09718933701515198,
-0.0575965978205204,
0.16124659776687622,
-0.017119361087679863,
0.40338462591171265,
0.718567967414856,
0.9776443839073181,
-0.16283375024795532,
0.534981369972229,
-0.5176393389701843,
-0.02233912982046604,
0.22507129609584808,
-0.8635964393615723,
-0.775758683681488,
-0.5286740064620972,
-0.776678204536438,
-0.41855815052986145,
0.4661554992198944,
0.6916483640670776,
0.7692421674728394,
-0.91927170753479,
-0.21887081861495972,
-0.16790492832660675,
-0.22520774602890015,
-0.34177640080451965,
-0.15807032585144043,
0.3321549892425537,
-0.6988676190376282,
-0.5370863080024719,
0.23173609375953674,
0.23662415146827698,
0.43798643350601196,
0.27073419094085693,
0.056796737015247345,
-0.1799977570772171,
-0.2700428366661072,
0.8266449570655823,
0.858092188835144,
-0.1585431694984436,
-0.3117399215698242,
-0.43304380774497986,
-0.0746084451675415,
0.21946373581886292,
1.392418622970581,
-0.6871249079704285,
0.7409653067588806,
0.4023762345314026,
0.5055487155914307,
0.9343722462654114,
-0.014267112128436565,
0.30180907249450684,
-0.6550559401512146,
0.5654551386833191,
0.2285996973514557,
0.33810749650001526,
-0.14920607209205627,
-0.4342647194862366,
0.7141245603561401,
0.459964781999588,
-0.7219764590263367,
-0.38497546315193176,
0.27112439274787903,
-0.934133768081665,
-0.8950097560882568,
0.691550076007843,
0.043337851762771606,
0.026786580681800842,
-0.5992174744606018,
0.17398998141288757,
0.3854028582572937,
-0.3625190854072571,
0.8333621621131897,
0.6611680388450623,
0.014619972556829453,
-0.2753284275531769,
-0.9744741320610046,
0.4859555959701538,
0.015702253207564354,
-0.7976191639900208,
0.033230677247047424,
0.7666602730751038,
0.5374975800514221,
0.4555889368057251,
0.6186915636062622,
-0.3621557652950287,
0.5390949845314026,
0.06298201531171799,
-0.1216573491692543,
-0.13251535594463348,
-0.6552526354789734,
-0.562303364276886,
0.34765034914016724,
-0.4359739422798157,
-0.04176784306764603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14205v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14205v1
|
Agent Planning with World Knowledge Model
| 2024-05-23T06:03:19 | 2024-05-23T06:03:19 |
Shuofei Qiao, Runnan Fang, Ningyu Zhang, Yuqi Zhu, Xiang Chen, Shumin Deng, Yong Jiang, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
Recent endeavors towards directly using large language models (LLMs) as agent
models to execute interactive planning tasks have shown commendable results.
Despite their achievements, however, they still struggle with brainless
trial-and-error in global planning and generating hallucinatory actions in
local planning due to their poor understanding of the ''real'' physical world.
Imitating humans' mental world knowledge model which provides global prior
knowledge before the task and maintains local dynamic knowledge during the
task, in this paper, we introduce parametric World Knowledge Model (WKM) to
facilitate agent planning. Concretely, we steer the agent model to
self-synthesize knowledge from both expert and sampled trajectories. Then we
develop WKM, providing prior task knowledge to guide the global planning and
dynamic state knowledge to assist the local planning. Experimental results on
three complex real-world simulated datasets with three state-of-the-art
open-source LLMs, Mistral-7B, Gemma-7B, and Llama-3-8B, demonstrate that our
method can achieve superior performance compared to various strong baselines.
Besides, we analyze to illustrate that our WKM can effectively alleviate the
blind trial-and-error and hallucinatory action issues, providing strong support
for the agent's understanding of the world. Other interesting findings include:
1) our instance-level task knowledge can generalize better to unseen tasks, 2)
weak WKM can guide strong agent model planning, and 3) unified WKM training has
promising potential for further development. Code will be available at
https://github.com/zjunlp/WKM.
|
[
-0.41724449396133423,
-0.6627233624458313,
0.8891832828521729,
-0.100051149725914,
0.08068884164094925,
-0.17637093365192413,
-0.09613432735204697,
-0.6504576206207275,
0.20299802720546722,
0.7216081619262695,
-0.6512181758880615,
-0.6382046341896057,
-0.26754385232925415,
-0.2591789960861206,
0.11574278771877289,
0.5321497321128845,
-0.15403880178928375,
-0.04383597895503044,
-0.1064976379275322,
-0.1087694764137268,
-0.23339557647705078,
-0.32464736700057983,
-0.5197606682777405,
-0.6754364967346191,
0.5937526226043701,
0.4762780964374542,
0.8006716966629028,
0.3048628866672516,
0.2025904357433319,
0.274999737739563,
-0.06125315651297569,
0.5239890813827515,
-0.12489815056324005,
0.26104292273521423,
-0.3270415961742401,
-0.1106468141078949,
-0.7475508451461792,
-0.11020871996879578,
0.09496859461069107,
0.5767217874526978,
-0.2322644740343094,
0.12006867676973343,
-0.1038847491145134,
0.38059574365615845,
-0.5656300187110901,
0.5034019947052002,
-0.714965283870697,
0.35052570700645447,
0.5526455640792847,
-0.04114952310919762,
-0.0009522534674033523,
0.17760998010635376,
0.269695520401001,
-0.8138009905815125,
0.24965614080429077,
-0.03979180008172989,
0.32520976662635803,
0.3387959599494934,
-0.4950297772884369,
-0.06516870856285095,
-1.0786104202270508,
0.4045097827911377,
-0.7042521238327026,
0.3090120553970337,
0.5434668064117432,
0.6345293521881104,
-0.6578156352043152,
-0.4880469739437103,
-0.649747908115387,
-0.38397419452667236,
0.16268478333950043,
0.12641870975494385,
0.1283925175666809,
0.29804909229278564,
0.34404420852661133,
-0.22657541930675507,
-0.4648391604423523,
0.04395464435219765,
-0.23683801293373108,
-0.37420666217803955,
0.7030720710754395,
0.4425298869609833,
-0.10042113065719604,
-0.03564172238111496,
-0.5673743486404419,
-0.05146144703030586,
-0.6336786150932312,
0.21482466161251068,
0.1879594773054123,
0.34402430057525635,
-0.06923618167638779,
0.4057527780532837,
-0.8100247979164124,
0.7806021571159363,
-0.268535315990448,
-0.4151487946510315,
-0.2982856333255768,
-0.06606587767601013,
-0.22008147835731506,
-0.31698518991470337,
0.49983566999435425,
0.29815542697906494,
0.19221681356430054,
-0.4415638744831085,
-0.4042545258998871,
0.03154877945780754,
0.2770874500274658,
-0.5586535334587097,
0.02550087310373783,
0.21501168608665466,
-0.21294532716274261,
0.042638637125492096,
-0.2536022961139679,
-0.6334053874015808,
-0.584795355796814,
-0.5645768642425537,
0.5320299863815308,
-0.35805049538612366,
-0.3273603916168213,
0.2845015227794647,
-0.0219861026853323,
0.2190702110528946,
0.4515956938266754,
-0.5012642741203308,
0.3042328357696533,
0.35879477858543396,
0.47132644057273865,
0.23758503794670105,
-0.8514178395271301,
-0.2532810866832733,
0.7498834133148193,
-0.3977014124393463,
1.0818268060684204,
-0.20071083307266235,
-0.1889910101890564,
0.1444905698299408,
-0.20596247911453247,
0.22934198379516602,
-0.3180544078350067,
0.20332220196723938,
-0.47698044776916504,
-0.2602309286594391,
-0.5592053532600403,
-0.21415860950946808,
-0.39110076427459717,
0.6443874835968018,
-0.5466508865356445,
0.7572818994522095,
0.027674168348312378,
-0.39585041999816895,
0.5347669124603271,
-0.5513662695884705,
-0.15410374104976654,
0.02822069451212883,
-0.07714547961950302,
0.09088084846735,
-0.11503511667251587,
0.2537878751754761,
0.7810973525047302,
-0.29925569891929626,
0.4636451005935669,
-0.2875916063785553,
-0.35108304023742676,
-0.08672209084033966,
0.006945745088160038,
0.3877054452896118,
0.22263872623443604,
-0.3716685175895691,
0.24050341546535492,
-0.7798345685005188,
0.04830560460686684,
0.254209041595459,
-0.09391673654317856,
-0.12543605268001556,
0.2822864055633545,
-0.22686240077018738,
0.5584288239479065,
0.24845494329929352,
-0.38455644249916077,
0.3847079277038574,
-0.17662200331687927,
0.16755802929401398,
0.619938313961029,
0.2911338806152344,
0.5864603519439697,
-0.502183198928833,
0.6651001572608948,
-0.28592339158058167,
0.3843819499015808,
0.5055755376815796,
-0.5285782217979431,
-0.6465317606925964,
0.24132400751113892,
-0.08771625906229019,
0.325840026140213,
-1.0606306791305542,
0.27101579308509827,
-0.2027754783630371,
-0.7045540809631348,
0.28398603200912476,
-0.03619229421019554,
0.14990074932575226,
0.38718876242637634,
0.26089829206466675,
0.08537986874580383,
-0.30771878361701965,
-0.6351280212402344,
-0.07946041971445084,
-0.3045734167098999,
-0.00716500636190176,
0.044680412858724594,
0.4267069101333618,
-0.22274620831012726,
0.9628334641456604,
-0.523802638053894,
-0.47877824306488037,
-0.5798346400260925,
-0.060482073575258255,
-0.27021345496177673,
0.06376833468675613,
0.22741584479808807,
-0.6842548847198486,
-0.27219992876052856,
-0.10459931939840317,
-0.8132421970367432,
0.1631740778684616,
-0.10414139181375504,
-0.6729806661605835,
-0.1726197749376297,
0.2215566486120224,
-0.914253294467926,
0.5562353134155273,
0.3370792865753174,
-0.6102265119552612,
0.5524459481239319,
-0.5154752135276794,
-0.10336988419294357,
-0.9806104302406311,
-0.16953232884407043,
0.03904152289032936,
-0.1652519851922989,
-0.7340575456619263,
0.36056438088417053,
0.030815135687589645,
-0.09991106390953064,
-0.5562558174133301,
0.7813630104064941,
-0.6320074200630188,
-0.17573988437652588,
-0.416766494512558,
0.1346365213394165,
-0.19694338738918304,
0.9727903008460999,
0.2082238346338272,
0.48029622435569763,
0.4660916328430176,
-0.8204281330108643,
0.48177218437194824,
0.3077268600463867,
-0.18939103186130524,
0.21380393207073212,
-0.1760200709104538,
0.11713306605815887,
-0.020115535706281662,
0.2661379873752594,
-0.38525116443634033,
-0.2836209833621979,
0.3172857463359833,
-0.18058940768241882,
0.058220624923706055,
-0.15354037284851074,
-0.5179499983787537,
-0.3798089027404785,
-0.021968364715576172,
0.037327155470848083,
0.46437567472457886,
-0.25050175189971924,
0.8471773266792297,
0.592615008354187,
0.07407785207033157,
-0.3575814664363861,
-0.39277124404907227,
0.043766796588897705,
-0.07070468366146088,
-0.5443212985992432,
0.3711033761501312,
-0.029791560024023056,
-0.3592076301574707,
-0.06461646407842636,
-0.2512206733226776,
-0.2110954076051712,
-0.2948168218135834,
0.2549155354499817,
-0.1004907563328743,
0.21597422659397125,
-0.05689917504787445,
-0.07540228217840195,
-0.2611018717288971,
0.13387469947338104,
-0.41772451996803284,
0.528988242149353,
0.26909342408180237,
-0.36302560567855835,
-0.18205292522907257,
0.1906873732805252,
0.7169390320777893,
-0.23528124392032623,
0.6984018087387085,
0.2236582338809967,
-0.6335245370864868,
-0.4849875867366791,
-0.5079712867736816,
-0.12416433542966843,
-0.396286278963089,
0.3278285264968872,
-0.442110151052475,
-0.3436032235622406,
0.6319884657859802,
-0.2686263620853424,
0.1210750937461853,
0.1694132536649704,
0.5319378972053528,
0.0794881209731102,
0.8691772222518921,
0.8470872044563293,
0.06872132420539856,
0.27597811818122864,
-0.5971761345863342,
-0.01953364722430706,
-0.5949434041976929,
-0.397585928440094,
-0.09502100199460983,
-0.5271822810173035,
-0.1324678361415863,
-0.7166540026664734,
0.4009042978286743,
-0.14856424927711487,
-0.17388184368610382,
0.22977924346923828,
-0.22769294679164886,
0.3043966293334961,
0.4693075716495514,
0.2742064297199249,
0.26731163263320923,
0.04954665154218674,
-0.35860374569892883,
0.2287621647119522,
-0.6338894963264465,
-0.6155873537063599,
1.0845428705215454,
-0.03150630742311478,
0.6669066548347473,
-0.27655619382858276,
0.6431052088737488,
0.24944578111171722,
-0.13230858743190765,
-0.4874209463596344,
0.9371770024299622,
0.5538485050201416,
-0.3678898811340332,
-0.6618919372558594,
-0.23329424858093262,
-0.8645623922348022,
0.3896338939666748,
-0.22003811597824097,
-0.5540849566459656,
0.2748321294784546,
0.23125426471233368,
-0.31851139664649963,
0.574102520942688,
-0.5443053245544434,
0.7138566970825195,
-0.13522623479366302,
-0.21953321993350983,
-0.3492535948753357,
-0.47836488485336304,
0.12052767723798752,
0.020344145596027374,
0.1448051929473877,
-0.6331926584243774,
-0.25642159581184387,
0.5552406311035156,
-0.4059799313545227,
0.7135491371154785,
-0.8008825778961182,
-0.12917695939540863,
0.566952645778656,
0.19789688289165497,
1.0314671993255615,
-0.012340804561972618,
-0.11995481699705124,
-0.018095869570970535,
-0.2482350766658783,
-0.47656938433647156,
-0.6498981714248657,
0.6083289980888367,
-0.6430057883262634,
-0.6388224959373474,
-0.2146463543176651,
-1.1740400791168213,
-0.56572425365448,
-0.04116930440068245,
0.031925808638334274,
0.32577335834503174,
-0.32023513317108154,
-0.4028048515319824,
0.37349873781204224,
0.03205745294690132,
0.49122849106788635,
0.9013742208480835,
-0.19375215470790863,
-0.05421792343258858,
0.6943944096565247,
0.3463441729545593,
0.1300571709871292,
0.3692387640476227,
0.2209300398826599,
-0.1317633092403412,
-0.6911771893501282,
-0.3009277880191803,
0.08688589185476303,
-0.6613599061965942,
-0.3008636236190796,
-0.6079731583595276,
-0.26813486218452454,
-0.4333079755306244,
-0.13138800859451294,
-0.19263625144958496,
-0.39543622732162476,
0.5264160633087158,
-0.15246251225471497,
0.2798559367656708,
1.015122652053833,
-0.15658098459243774,
0.09862497448921204,
-0.4557369351387024,
0.46074867248535156,
0.5122483968734741,
0.011703180149197578,
0.14531879127025604,
-0.0554271824657917,
-0.5309531688690186,
0.24122315645217896,
-0.5024408102035522,
-1.1004639863967896,
0.5865433216094971,
-0.08247844874858856,
0.9146561026573181,
0.3757321238517761,
0.48168179392814636,
0.6795933842658997,
-0.4689953625202179,
0.5458263754844666,
-0.3762005865573883,
-0.3852697014808655,
0.5446917414665222,
-0.5144942402839661,
0.46860337257385254,
0.33675357699394226,
0.39726522564888,
-0.44134312868118286,
-0.8356606960296631,
-0.6437548398971558,
-0.6482250690460205,
0.6709135174751282,
0.20900455117225647,
-0.09435849636793137,
0.3863408863544464,
0.3868434727191925,
0.1862921267747879,
0.18562616407871246,
-0.7769147157669067,
-0.031127607449889183,
0.08016166090965271,
0.0780167207121849,
-0.18911045789718628,
-0.31968897581100464,
-0.14082589745521545,
-0.4654582440853119,
0.6586292386054993,
-0.23318053781986237,
0.5492525696754456,
0.21790046989917755,
-0.24146918952465057,
-0.20325833559036255,
0.09282427281141281,
0.6469623446464539,
1.1367294788360596,
-0.07006122916936874,
0.27521371841430664,
0.407118558883667,
-0.38909921050071716,
0.3518245816230774,
0.20107829570770264,
-0.23078583180904388,
-0.4899996221065521,
0.2752563953399658,
0.3307647407054901,
0.13183051347732544,
-0.7144642472267151,
0.09527360647916794,
-0.031285982578992844,
-0.33504194021224976,
-0.2928660809993744,
0.20235072076320648,
0.2163793295621872,
0.6636237502098083,
0.33938926458358765,
0.05069875344634056,
0.08660704642534256,
-0.2903801500797272,
-0.2428853064775467,
0.27128866314888,
-0.17337411642074585,
-0.31605279445648193,
0.521259069442749,
-0.020932713523507118,
-0.33042576909065247,
0.12110356241464615,
-0.6329264640808105,
-0.5969605445861816,
0.7634533047676086,
0.5600755214691162,
0.6715823411941528,
-0.20219871401786804,
0.344613254070282,
0.09777172654867172,
0.3706604242324829,
0.030134515836834908,
0.6534132957458496,
-0.29542386531829834,
-0.8182648420333862,
-0.19765324890613556,
-0.5612943768501282,
-0.44339412450790405,
0.10200187563896179,
-0.1849406510591507,
0.12365228682756424,
-0.4726576507091522,
0.07600613683462143,
-0.6493215560913086,
0.23925115168094635,
-0.8772704005241394,
0.18793527781963348,
-0.06566159427165985,
0.8582276701927185,
-0.7579678297042847,
0.9790711402893066,
1.0599099397659302,
-0.2605303227901459,
-0.8493037819862366,
0.49446308612823486,
-0.13290993869304657,
-0.8483707904815674,
0.345357209444046,
0.0180152989923954,
-0.15313167870044708,
-0.12243176251649857,
-0.3311185836791992,
-1.0505083799362183,
1.3475712537765503,
0.3286578357219696,
-0.26857030391693115,
-0.39315927028656006,
0.28086620569229126,
0.5310729146003723,
-0.2144506573677063,
-0.20230689644813538,
0.2818290591239929,
0.42984238266944885,
0.24853447079658508,
-0.5785409808158875,
0.17820213735103607,
0.04665699973702431,
0.035221975296735764,
0.367782860994339,
-0.6528697609901428,
0.5443583726882935,
-0.24324798583984375,
0.13380277156829834,
-0.09518620371818542,
0.9090592265129089,
0.24660435318946838,
0.4196541905403137,
0.6162484884262085,
0.5003120303153992,
0.5962101221084595,
0.3591635525226593,
0.6707355380058289,
-0.5662041902542114,
0.03370881453156471,
0.7330769896507263,
-0.3288138806819916,
0.8501513600349426,
0.14441493153572083,
-0.14436626434326172,
0.357374370098114,
0.5557222366333008,
0.3731939196586609,
0.7664635181427002,
-0.17802825570106506,
-0.35366174578666687,
-0.49972084164619446,
0.1415608525276184,
-0.12032715231180191,
0.6185893416404724,
0.11265136301517487,
0.3537575900554657,
-0.42747625708580017,
0.2912483215332031,
-0.14653779566287994,
-0.05866243690252304,
-0.4050140082836151,
0.6191450953483582,
-0.06621581315994263,
-0.7701287269592285,
0.40006428956985474,
0.1626894325017929,
0.3772168457508087,
-0.7694411277770996,
-0.11400268971920013,
-0.3221122920513153,
0.14328888058662415,
0.10243412852287292,
-0.47444337606430054,
0.285819411277771,
-0.2017209678888321,
-0.10895248502492905,
-0.26665258407592773,
1.0392152070999146,
-0.39434510469436646,
-0.3309476971626282,
0.5313425064086914,
0.676493227481842,
0.0848681852221489,
-0.4468269944190979,
-0.4494515061378479,
-0.5116147994995117,
-0.14794856309890747,
-0.2879144251346588,
0.5095406770706177,
0.6348681449890137,
-0.28466519713401794,
0.9439716935157776,
0.4513055384159088,
0.33218321204185486,
0.08639983087778091,
-0.27389276027679443,
0.7920877933502197,
-0.8587837815284729,
-0.6739155054092407,
-0.40257033705711365,
0.26572948694229126,
0.06584373861551285,
0.040937382727861404,
0.5725939869880676,
0.3667675852775574,
0.7023217678070068,
-0.0020615579560399055,
0.41660457849502563,
0.04574841260910034,
0.22177670896053314,
-0.6317732930183411,
0.7850139141082764,
-0.5706859230995178,
0.04761766269803047,
-0.15236419439315796,
-1.000778079032898,
0.012149226851761341,
0.4260346591472626,
-0.4332503080368042,
-0.08063682913780212,
0.5189484357833862,
0.7358995079994202,
0.10842711478471756,
-0.23729433119297028,
0.8194246888160706,
0.07233160734176636,
0.22592765092849731,
0.867705762386322,
1.0040088891983032,
0.060441672801971436,
0.597997784614563,
-0.6653361320495605,
-0.17505043745040894,
0.08566699177026749,
-0.5926554203033447,
-0.9927493333816528,
-0.6761481761932373,
0.12181994318962097,
0.05016932263970375,
0.1541861891746521,
1.0011584758758545,
0.8432700037956238,
-0.2756441533565521,
-0.35808083415031433,
-0.17319999635219574,
0.14444252848625183,
-0.3425756096839905,
-0.09051474928855896,
0.15940257906913757,
-0.3011168837547302,
-0.48528310656547546,
0.5579174160957336,
0.039597321301698685,
0.18050053715705872,
-0.5196323990821838,
-0.5126913189888,
-0.08117975294589996,
-0.009732984937727451,
0.4693622887134552,
0.2796616852283478,
-0.8254179954528809,
-0.06127071753144264,
-0.16041766107082367,
-0.0831100344657898,
-0.21209992468357086,
0.8773669004440308,
-1.0819631814956665,
0.23479048907756805,
0.19921447336673737,
0.028472160920500755,
0.5575647354125977,
-0.33113130927085876,
0.7121118903160095,
-0.517423152923584,
0.6607322692871094,
0.19565562903881073,
0.45899698138237,
-0.08439493924379349,
-0.6365082859992981,
0.49977371096611023,
0.07889895141124725,
-0.7245859503746033,
-0.3981727957725525,
0.1551499366760254,
-0.6996130347251892,
-0.306715726852417,
1.126857042312622,
0.005603749770671129,
-0.17318063974380493,
-0.15140429139137268,
-0.34197455644607544,
0.3356489837169647,
-0.2997455894947052,
0.8711685538291931,
0.4741179943084717,
-0.45370978116989136,
0.020643027499318123,
-0.6574424505233765,
0.6083807349205017,
-0.07320186495780945,
-0.8810647130012512,
0.08940628916025162,
0.6625339388847351,
0.12128199636936188,
-0.14478152990341187,
0.8621454238891602,
0.4336315989494324,
0.24531912803649902,
0.27417564392089844,
0.5287601351737976,
-0.4390864670276642,
-0.7789087891578674,
0.13946552574634552,
0.26482006907463074,
0.29223158955574036,
-0.011609810404479504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14191v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14191v3
|
S-Eval: Automatic and Adaptive Test Generation for Benchmarking Safety Evaluation of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T05:34:31 | 2024-05-28T11:31:31 |
Xiaohan Yuan, Jinfeng Li, Dongxia Wang, Yuefeng Chen, Xiaofeng Mao, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue, Wenhai Wang, Kui Ren, Jingyi Wang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models have gained considerable attention for their
revolutionary capabilities. However, there is also growing concern on their
safety implications, making a comprehensive safety evaluation for LLMs urgently
needed before model deployment. In this work, we propose S-Eval, a new
comprehensive, multi-dimensional and open-ended safety evaluation benchmark. At
the core of S-Eval is a novel LLM-based automatic test prompt generation and
selection framework, which trains an expert testing LLM Mt combined with a
range of test selection strategies to automatically construct a high-quality
test suite for the safety evaluation. The key to the automation of this process
is a novel expert safety-critique LLM Mc able to quantify the riskiness score
of an LLM's response, and additionally produce risk tags and explanations.
Besides, the generation process is also guided by a carefully designed risk
taxonomy with four different levels, covering comprehensive and
multi-dimensional safety risks of concern. Based on these, we systematically
construct a new and large-scale safety evaluation benchmark for LLMs consisting
of 220,000 evaluation prompts, including 20,000 base risk prompts (10,000 in
Chinese and 10,000 in English) and 200,000 corresponding attack prompts derived
from 10 popular adversarial instruction attacks against LLMs. Moreover,
considering the rapid evolution of LLMs and accompanied safety threats, S-Eval
can be flexibly configured and adapted to include new risks, attacks and
models. S-Eval is extensively evaluated on 20 popular and representative LLMs.
The results confirm that S-Eval can better reflect and inform the safety risks
of LLMs compared to existing benchmarks. We also explore the impacts of
parameter scales, language environments, and decoding parameters on the
evaluation, providing a systematic methodology for evaluating the safety of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.2624778747558594,
-0.9156163930892944,
0.5723385214805603,
0.21766279637813568,
0.07036518305540085,
0.21021604537963867,
-0.2415471374988556,
-0.21165063977241516,
-0.260877788066864,
0.4580270051956177,
-0.40640661120414734,
-0.6080596446990967,
-0.4881078898906708,
0.2828650176525116,
-0.4009290933609009,
1.0675302743911743,
-0.20068909227848053,
0.03269768878817558,
-0.20118416845798492,
0.16712327301502228,
-0.10287263244390488,
-0.4006492793560028,
-0.7829137444496155,
0.3552192151546478,
0.6112954020500183,
0.08105579763650894,
0.38923320174217224,
0.6061503887176514,
0.4901125431060791,
0.3417593240737915,
-0.07721324265003204,
0.11605122685432434,
-0.15071383118629456,
0.327178031206131,
-0.033590566366910934,
-0.22494502365589142,
-0.6434119343757629,
-0.27807506918907166,
0.8250011205673218,
0.3715852200984955,
-0.18676453828811646,
0.28904879093170166,
0.2649489641189575,
0.5500720143318176,
-0.8428705930709839,
-0.00480200070887804,
-0.6949530243873596,
-0.048285968601703644,
0.02840312384068966,
-0.21728746592998505,
-0.6655417680740356,
-0.7686681151390076,
-0.18398797512054443,
-0.07566462457180023,
-0.29964932799339294,
0.25248971581459045,
0.569522500038147,
0.3068087697029114,
-0.6767178773880005,
-0.15889842808246613,
-0.3101731240749359,
0.7330548763275146,
-0.5848459005355835,
0.39580869674682617,
-0.00433778902515769,
0.8313865065574646,
-0.2515033185482025,
-0.48746392130851746,
-0.2563476860523224,
-0.6698822975158691,
0.2998197376728058,
0.02729647047817707,
-0.21269842982292175,
-0.08573094010353088,
0.23934203386306763,
-0.06028786674141884,
-0.7525742650032043,
0.2588743567466736,
-0.19986023008823395,
-0.12383519858121872,
1.0956878662109375,
0.48060721158981323,
0.4109936058521271,
-0.022575166076421738,
-0.7045756578445435,
-0.19228124618530273,
-1.1374566555023193,
-0.13455171883106232,
0.49594882130622864,
0.24022413790225983,
-0.019715862348675728,
0.20083512365818024,
-0.1895471215248108,
0.49228861927986145,
-0.28530749678611755,
-0.16370166838169098,
0.3857071101665497,
-0.2666158378124237,
-0.19414234161376953,
0.07540781050920486,
1.0692942142486572,
0.7400963306427002,
0.1957237273454666,
0.13080339133739471,
-0.42991307377815247,
-0.09962399303913116,
0.34599384665489197,
-0.7175427079200745,
0.14938291907310486,
0.036300260573625565,
-0.251512736082077,
-0.6512148976325989,
-0.27479854226112366,
-0.9506122469902039,
-0.5506044030189514,
-0.043414127081632614,
0.41706714034080505,
-0.42480987310409546,
-0.1528378427028656,
0.07945512235164642,
0.3754718005657196,
0.14384295046329498,
0.2902873754501343,
-0.43547168374061584,
0.16077208518981934,
0.4752563238143921,
0.45916569232940674,
-0.41581451892852783,
-0.5289814472198486,
-0.7757493257522583,
-0.01381915807723999,
-0.49139294028282166,
0.9553862810134888,
-0.23107829689979553,
-0.3550645411014557,
0.16676369309425354,
-0.04467492550611496,
-0.22602680325508118,
-0.32829320430755615,
0.405476450920105,
-0.41012728214263916,
-0.13022290170192719,
-0.025317147374153137,
-0.47971072793006897,
0.06033026799559593,
0.46225810050964355,
-0.41920965909957886,
1.1919233798980713,
-0.007224475499242544,
-0.606482982635498,
0.14857369661331177,
-0.4738275110721588,
-0.3571382462978363,
0.022634999826550484,
-0.3118899166584015,
-0.3950156271457672,
-0.18793614208698273,
0.09778351336717606,
0.4382994771003723,
-0.5653761625289917,
0.32061314582824707,
-0.3584919273853302,
-0.16911335289478302,
0.47597047686576843,
-0.7456914186477661,
0.5801898837089539,
0.22031794488430023,
-0.31537631154060364,
0.4717644155025482,
-0.8203979730606079,
0.3291114866733551,
0.061077240854501724,
-0.40401896834373474,
-0.008532146923244,
0.0008216099231503904,
0.06777772307395935,
0.2322535216808319,
0.4281258285045624,
-0.2887657582759857,
-0.1502760499715805,
-0.20014788210391998,
0.12503209710121155,
0.9224311709403992,
0.15973201394081116,
0.0068226102739572525,
-0.18915268778800964,
0.7854440808296204,
-0.36486363410949707,
0.4908928871154785,
-0.3673379123210907,
-0.05613139644265175,
-0.6653490662574768,
-0.18509624898433685,
0.14557965099811554,
0.7211104035377502,
-0.6242256760597229,
0.9946408271789551,
-0.2825070023536682,
-0.6853389739990234,
-0.3182032108306885,
0.030506959185004234,
0.7639038562774658,
0.2863742709159851,
0.15518806874752045,
0.10594993084669113,
-0.3424827754497528,
-0.9108753800392151,
-0.306119829416275,
-0.28623396158218384,
-0.11395449191331863,
0.2636518180370331,
0.43316495418548584,
-0.2909793257713318,
0.45600271224975586,
-0.5225692987442017,
0.2105356603860855,
-0.44759902358055115,
-0.20088399946689606,
-0.20448057353496552,
0.2505286633968353,
0.6262648701667786,
-0.18254467844963074,
-0.6123534440994263,
-0.041017260402441025,
-0.6459723114967346,
-0.29707595705986023,
-0.05760493502020836,
-0.2145964652299881,
0.40868449211120605,
0.6322270631790161,
-0.2933724820613861,
0.17124849557876587,
0.5572836995124817,
-0.2047174572944641,
0.9346224665641785,
-0.23498503863811493,
0.18609650433063507,
-1.1518993377685547,
0.00028272540657781065,
0.02529234066605568,
0.05412549152970314,
-0.5451056957244873,
0.3672774136066437,
0.4859900176525116,
0.03802638128399849,
-0.9150727987289429,
0.5706035494804382,
-0.09171755611896515,
-0.08430707454681396,
-0.1280263066291809,
0.30214783549308777,
-0.017469650134444237,
0.1625528335571289,
-0.2282344549894333,
0.8410547971725464,
0.6493812799453735,
-0.5874046683311462,
0.2820073962211609,
-0.04138965159654617,
-0.4797755181789398,
0.5976371765136719,
-0.5164478421211243,
0.12093375623226166,
0.20583966374397278,
0.18357649445533752,
-0.8170377016067505,
-0.024339070543646812,
-0.03840905427932739,
-0.06146137788891792,
0.20137853920459747,
0.1234055757522583,
-0.47691619396209717,
-0.20046882331371307,
-0.543025016784668,
0.2817661762237549,
0.5297055244445801,
-0.4567885994911194,
0.5907824039459229,
0.292034775018692,
-0.48075729608535767,
-0.4639904201030731,
-0.341974139213562,
0.2653108239173889,
-0.34718990325927734,
-0.7302510142326355,
-0.1849694401025772,
-0.4914771020412445,
-0.24262535572052002,
-0.33095812797546387,
-0.10963061451911926,
0.1327551156282425,
0.40776053071022034,
0.1908155232667923,
0.4589880406856537,
-0.16837139427661896,
-0.11291685700416565,
0.11379210650920868,
-0.3402019143104553,
0.22605501115322113,
0.3407151401042938,
0.47139817476272583,
-0.4939185380935669,
-0.5754874348640442,
-0.24741649627685547,
0.2897945046424866,
0.43312498927116394,
-0.227672278881073,
0.24445569515228271,
0.22896429896354675,
-0.25053369998931885,
-0.4544507563114166,
-0.47478002309799194,
-0.01639449968934059,
-0.5582861304283142,
0.5689461827278137,
-0.2625240683555603,
-0.527293860912323,
0.17477506399154663,
-0.22637370228767395,
0.14321275055408478,
0.31696629524230957,
0.4848003685474396,
0.12028209120035172,
1.1439603567123413,
0.1998542696237564,
-0.08225221186876297,
0.10620144754648209,
0.10775157809257507,
0.13085110485553741,
-0.7598223686218262,
-0.1534094214439392,
-0.5739344954490662,
0.1767871379852295,
-0.4259825348854065,
-0.3149126172065735,
0.6930171847343445,
-0.1831437647342682,
-0.5875256657600403,
0.30021169781684875,
-0.21105560660362244,
0.5279309749603271,
0.17904075980186462,
-0.12728722393512726,
0.11230696737766266,
-0.22450047731399536,
-0.28042739629745483,
0.08277050405740738,
-0.2753480076789856,
-0.8603787422180176,
1.1937878131866455,
0.45596548914909363,
0.9078584313392639,
-0.006114208605140448,
0.7366943359375,
0.22252649068832397,
0.48146122694015503,
-0.4947408437728882,
0.9545285105705261,
-0.06703855097293854,
-0.2647280991077423,
-0.2233262062072754,
-0.38940030336380005,
-0.8448455929756165,
0.24200718104839325,
-0.19251196086406708,
-0.7554333806037903,
-0.5790987014770508,
-0.08601582050323486,
-0.6421509385108948,
0.20053017139434814,
-0.5190412402153015,
0.7481826543807983,
-0.9072296619415283,
-0.18728700280189514,
-0.002784004667773843,
-0.47182586789131165,
0.5623566508293152,
-0.41212302446365356,
0.35590776801109314,
-0.29611366987228394,
-0.12865257263183594,
0.5020155310630798,
-0.07260797917842865,
0.6528698205947876,
0.06596849858760834,
-0.34399476647377014,
-0.009979315102100372,
0.3773971498012543,
0.6668302416801453,
-0.077505923807621,
-0.4204883873462677,
0.10604382306337357,
0.01766110584139824,
0.057319704443216324,
-0.5874629020690918,
0.8791102170944214,
-0.5336030721664429,
-0.7381359338760376,
-0.47649675607681274,
-0.4318434000015259,
-0.26080527901649475,
0.23631690442562103,
-0.11250729858875275,
0.16424933075904846,
-0.3039478659629822,
0.1343870759010315,
0.496195524930954,
-0.748755156993866,
0.39835667610168457,
0.7827950716018677,
-0.2802714407444,
-0.6323004364967346,
0.9006018042564392,
-0.14333969354629517,
0.42787760496139526,
0.02714010328054428,
0.15217112004756927,
-0.4561024606227875,
-0.6530387997627258,
-0.6758942604064941,
-0.16513539850711823,
-0.8749415278434753,
-0.39045843482017517,
-0.552180826663971,
-0.5818824768066406,
-0.15934161841869354,
-0.37391528487205505,
-0.39873960614204407,
0.07038043439388275,
0.08696521818637848,
-0.25915637612342834,
0.2872440218925476,
0.6200128197669983,
0.2921202778816223,
0.025915570557117462,
-0.8239471316337585,
-0.020739680156111717,
0.10997813194990158,
0.28566646575927734,
-0.14593416452407837,
-0.25210312008857727,
-0.11303076893091202,
-0.2867072522640228,
-0.374244749546051,
-0.7261372804641724,
0.2954567074775696,
0.007307864725589752,
0.7886245846748352,
0.44426748156547546,
0.39524906873703003,
0.33893588185310364,
-0.9015387296676636,
1.006277322769165,
0.24872688949108124,
-0.8440638184547424,
0.6374092102050781,
-0.24120363593101501,
-0.24654968082904816,
0.4968024492263794,
0.14788372814655304,
-0.3959521949291229,
-0.4090449810028076,
-0.572376549243927,
-1.1189937591552734,
0.41462090611457825,
-0.05099473521113396,
0.015020872466266155,
-0.24262015521526337,
-0.06869472563266754,
0.3020111918449402,
0.058482442051172256,
-0.5313943028450012,
-0.2506484091281891,
0.20963874459266663,
-0.27804186940193176,
-0.15135200321674347,
-0.30306476354599,
-0.3312128186225891,
0.22867368161678314,
0.5750296711921692,
-0.24339552223682404,
-0.05173372104763985,
-0.34156909584999084,
-0.10573136061429977,
-0.09148655831813812,
0.4815463125705719,
0.5278112292289734,
0.32238033413887024,
-0.09202691167593002,
0.32375890016555786,
0.8074524998664856,
-0.12714044749736786,
0.37220868468284607,
0.17857517302036285,
-0.17771469056606293,
-0.33556824922561646,
0.39210084080696106,
0.7755774259567261,
0.508777379989624,
-1.0926591157913208,
0.6088554859161377,
-0.06936867535114288,
-0.21504728496074677,
-0.3779427707195282,
0.5203464031219482,
-0.0027319269720464945,
0.1909734159708023,
0.28128597140312195,
-0.005607031751424074,
0.0611921064555645,
-0.22710873186588287,
0.3843271732330322,
0.3285194933414459,
-0.07826386392116547,
-0.12324513494968414,
0.6213803887367249,
0.34067076444625854,
-0.3738189935684204,
-0.011537661775946617,
-0.16419075429439545,
-0.40177738666534424,
0.7131759524345398,
0.4293593764305115,
1.1391420364379883,
-0.5858047604560852,
0.12295110523700714,
0.30232366919517517,
0.4480063319206238,
-0.014609861187636852,
0.41727253794670105,
0.40063637495040894,
-0.39053651690483093,
-0.13027645647525787,
-0.7531062960624695,
-0.4869154989719391,
0.3206741511821747,
-0.5875145196914673,
0.27360546588897705,
-0.6262307167053223,
0.06840814650058746,
-0.2707175612449646,
-0.07791323959827423,
-0.6004580855369568,
0.25519445538520813,
0.11987961083650589,
1.0995681285858154,
-0.8867886662483215,
0.5079441666603088,
0.5633137822151184,
-0.18277832865715027,
-0.7243248224258423,
0.17527714371681213,
0.14379361271858215,
-0.8798494338989258,
0.5838768482208252,
0.3454950749874115,
-0.20446394383907318,
-0.23321616649627686,
0.011731186881661415,
-0.9326379299163818,
1.1929436922073364,
0.6631863117218018,
-0.7074699401855469,
0.37962067127227783,
0.35061001777648926,
0.5057764649391174,
-0.5059413909912109,
0.536838710308075,
0.6602936387062073,
0.48737236857414246,
-0.2646542191505432,
-0.918105959892273,
0.500621497631073,
-0.30983394384384155,
0.28262901306152344,
-0.05705295875668526,
-0.6913527846336365,
0.6840908527374268,
-0.09124112129211426,
-0.18860593438148499,
0.2096928358078003,
0.1390412151813507,
0.8262140154838562,
0.44926995038986206,
0.7075092196464539,
0.21215781569480896,
0.535854697227478,
0.03470563888549805,
1.1120927333831787,
-0.7139587998390198,
0.06938918679952621,
1.010012149810791,
-0.745179295539856,
1.1690459251403809,
0.27740272879600525,
-0.33490830659866333,
0.24134404957294464,
0.6766470670700073,
0.03913953900337219,
0.348016619682312,
0.5274219512939453,
-0.415283203125,
-0.27863195538520813,
0.047946155071258545,
-0.40031424164772034,
0.13659875094890594,
0.2574102580547333,
-0.463205486536026,
-0.45709869265556335,
-0.033440593630075455,
-0.08649590611457825,
-0.02844640426337719,
-0.09271101653575897,
0.6828875541687012,
0.018637679517269135,
-0.4975501596927643,
0.5541887879371643,
-0.13076737523078918,
0.4416716992855072,
-0.626555323600769,
0.23440875113010406,
-0.18687887489795685,
0.14847198128700256,
0.0647149458527565,
-0.8618764877319336,
-0.05062418058514595,
0.3231027126312256,
0.4575978219509125,
-0.21091358363628387,
0.6625704765319824,
-0.3007836937904358,
-0.595651388168335,
0.4881642460823059,
0.40674811601638794,
0.26032260060310364,
0.1034252792596817,
-0.7326741218566895,
0.37359103560447693,
-0.08887775242328644,
-0.5214709639549255,
0.5475830435752869,
0.28341400623321533,
-0.15836657583713531,
0.8839015364646912,
0.6643406748771667,
0.11331596970558167,
0.06176770478487015,
0.15397688746452332,
0.8474058508872986,
-0.662784993648529,
-0.45505037903785706,
-0.8572107553482056,
0.7009463310241699,
0.017517877742648125,
-0.26992711424827576,
0.7780254483222961,
0.5342553853988647,
0.5244369506835938,
-0.11544572561979294,
1.2048401832580566,
0.25502389669418335,
0.17591768503189087,
-0.6028238534927368,
0.9400596618652344,
-0.5072438716888428,
0.5510156750679016,
-0.3158039450645447,
-0.7524378895759583,
-0.3486930727958679,
0.3524514436721802,
-0.2553618550300598,
0.13953562080860138,
0.7985224723815918,
1.026474118232727,
0.3070933222770691,
-0.11489659547805786,
0.47775229811668396,
0.08313470333814621,
0.4844697117805481,
0.6662679314613342,
1.1373835802078247,
-0.45978397130966187,
0.7476086020469666,
0.009750429540872574,
-0.24497374892234802,
-0.41661232709884644,
-1.236130952835083,
-0.8136273622512817,
-0.43137213587760925,
-0.5236936807632446,
-0.37448760867118835,
0.23528505861759186,
1.0897051095962524,
0.343172550201416,
-0.7008606195449829,
-0.08861323446035385,
0.07310634851455688,
-0.0010152168106287718,
-0.23976105451583862,
-0.2027614861726761,
0.6223787665367126,
-0.4806223511695862,
-0.5896642208099365,
0.8653098344802856,
0.5372781157493591,
0.03220381587743759,
-0.43404027819633484,
-0.3286762237548828,
0.2812751531600952,
0.23829473555088043,
0.559572696685791,
-0.013447876088321209,
-0.6460776329040527,
-0.5959509611129761,
-0.03164593502879143,
-0.21088865399360657,
-0.34269383549690247,
0.3555929958820343,
-0.14674390852451324,
0.2064746618270874,
0.34537747502326965,
0.8534715175628662,
-0.07041170448064804,
-0.4158109128475189,
0.6107561588287354,
-0.7054440975189209,
-0.21502147614955902,
0.056748129427433014,
0.5425023436546326,
0.26940563321113586,
-0.35730916261672974,
0.4220687448978424,
-0.21276605129241943,
-0.5717008709907532,
-1.2104898691177368,
0.2736130654811859,
-0.8518185615539551,
-0.03897435590624809,
1.5908939838409424,
-0.3437647223472595,
-0.2736448347568512,
0.052096422761678696,
-0.36255931854248047,
0.07924751937389374,
-0.28712257742881775,
1.0537526607513428,
0.40777289867401123,
-0.05495854467153549,
-0.11821569502353668,
-0.5600571036338806,
0.47390294075012207,
0.2616862952709198,
-1.2131586074829102,
0.32202741503715515,
0.3250925540924072,
0.552347719669342,
-0.10227356851100922,
0.2653266191482544,
-0.027241133153438568,
0.37364622950553894,
-0.018946455791592598,
0.14393052458763123,
-0.19113510847091675,
-0.36468130350112915,
-0.40061354637145996,
0.08784139156341553,
0.13021321594715118,
-0.08373066037893295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14189v1
|
Semantic-guided Prompt Organization for Universal Goal Hijacking against LLMs
| 2024-05-23T05:31:41 | 2024-05-23T05:31:41 |
Yihao Huang, Chong Wang, Xiaojun Jia, Qing Guo, Felix Juefei-Xu, Jian Zhang, Geguang Pu, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
With the rising popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), assessing their
trustworthiness through security tasks has gained critical importance.
Regarding the new task of universal goal hijacking, previous efforts have
concentrated solely on optimization algorithms, overlooking the crucial role of
the prompt. To fill this gap, we propose a universal goal hijacking method
called POUGH that incorporates semantic-guided prompt processing strategies.
Specifically, the method starts with a sampling strategy to select
representative prompts from a candidate pool, followed by a ranking strategy
that prioritizes the prompts. Once the prompts are organized sequentially, the
method employs an iterative optimization algorithm to generate the universal
fixed suffix for the prompts. Experiments conducted on four popular LLMs and
ten types of target responses verified the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.14795780181884766,
-1.0662846565246582,
0.9298865795135498,
0.15181928873062134,
-0.30355527997016907,
-0.003973448183387518,
0.1549428552389145,
-0.22325198352336884,
0.14519821107387543,
0.863209068775177,
-0.9259523153305054,
-1.0161347389221191,
-0.6037582159042358,
0.12879036366939545,
-0.08463530242443085,
1.0104931592941284,
0.25456002354621887,
-0.14644458889961243,
-0.029685351997613907,
0.27144894003868103,
-0.902653694152832,
-0.5108506083488464,
-0.6979483962059021,
0.07678630203008652,
0.6191200017929077,
0.6944562196731567,
0.745497465133667,
0.7659033536911011,
0.6843594908714294,
0.25158795714378357,
-0.25547555088996887,
0.12986022233963013,
-0.44447559118270874,
0.3996780812740326,
-0.29227444529533386,
-0.28672555088996887,
-0.48355671763420105,
0.14207512140274048,
0.5798903107643127,
0.6538739800453186,
-0.12834987044334412,
0.1305379420518875,
0.17865176498889923,
0.2574586570262909,
-0.7997865080833435,
-0.1529528796672821,
-1.0293059349060059,
-0.017089655622839928,
-0.09090336412191391,
-0.47150883078575134,
-0.3824199140071869,
-0.38063979148864746,
0.23610880970954895,
-0.7760245203971863,
-0.047901030629873276,
0.5038355588912964,
0.7211320996284485,
0.13476429879665375,
-0.029014386236667633,
-0.37463873624801636,
-0.3385339379310608,
0.9803130626678467,
-0.4057213366031647,
-0.07525046169757843,
0.3177553713321686,
0.22338037192821503,
-0.7726853489875793,
-0.38808345794677734,
-0.16221114993095398,
-0.3182019293308258,
0.20298181474208832,
-0.029113028198480606,
-0.13286513090133667,
0.45546141266822815,
0.33672627806663513,
-0.14223384857177734,
-0.6679511070251465,
0.17251107096672058,
-0.06522412598133087,
-0.7103980183601379,
0.42990201711654663,
0.26162171363830566,
0.5116419196128845,
-0.22333259880542755,
-0.8865603804588318,
-0.12022288888692856,
-0.673002302646637,
0.32636481523513794,
0.3395164906978607,
0.5731148719787598,
0.4373430907726288,
0.6596826910972595,
-0.5381371378898621,
0.8392241597175598,
0.09678656607866287,
-0.3207934498786926,
-0.20566514134407043,
-0.28651171922683716,
-0.1646249145269394,
0.4147498905658722,
0.5133466720581055,
0.5958293080329895,
0.27115917205810547,
-0.1961032599210739,
-0.2298249751329422,
0.14992724359035492,
0.2558140754699707,
-0.7016707062721252,
0.29534199833869934,
0.36337897181510925,
-0.3234836757183075,
-0.3516271412372589,
0.34206852316856384,
-0.9580170512199402,
-0.3947463929653168,
-0.22553645074367523,
0.5431955456733704,
-0.5234894752502441,
0.1741604208946228,
0.42301297187805176,
-0.31106460094451904,
0.34247562289237976,
0.4191012680530548,
-0.4773034453392029,
0.12725462019443512,
0.9555187225341797,
0.792820155620575,
-0.10712379217147827,
-0.5019122958183289,
-1.4651826620101929,
0.31938785314559937,
-0.21060609817504883,
0.6760686635971069,
-0.9678744077682495,
-0.6797003746032715,
0.23612363636493683,
-0.23623062670230865,
0.08380327373743057,
-0.18228061497211456,
0.7070978283882141,
-0.6684224009513855,
0.28551092743873596,
-0.4395500719547272,
-0.5910527110099792,
0.0025735243689268827,
0.4645613431930542,
-0.3800431489944458,
0.8158079385757446,
-0.24433965981006622,
-0.6242820024490356,
0.29811596870422363,
-0.6295375227928162,
-0.2344742715358734,
0.1615184098482132,
-0.025901589542627335,
-0.13499942421913147,
0.17396745085716248,
0.2216179221868515,
0.6127357482910156,
-0.4318736493587494,
0.2712809145450592,
-0.15744446218013763,
-0.44573473930358887,
-0.11918584257364273,
-0.012435469776391983,
0.9266526103019714,
0.19327367842197418,
-0.29115942120552063,
0.4429519474506378,
-0.6538875699043274,
-0.06044969707727432,
0.09615400433540344,
-0.2533216178417206,
-0.5786300301551819,
-0.17860664427280426,
-0.5190706849098206,
-0.09183282405138016,
0.6108065843582153,
-0.8280552625656128,
0.25549477338790894,
-0.4191686809062958,
-0.01525656133890152,
0.9714255332946777,
0.4513271749019623,
0.5511064529418945,
-0.2005029171705246,
0.4532913863658905,
-0.11702381074428558,
0.6442808508872986,
-0.32220256328582764,
-0.8566020131111145,
-0.09832565486431122,
-0.5026183724403381,
-0.15350276231765747,
0.667981743812561,
-0.460619181394577,
0.720358669757843,
0.12809133529663086,
-0.31427308917045593,
-0.4271392822265625,
0.1597035676240921,
0.42020881175994873,
0.7243740558624268,
0.35930848121643066,
0.043806109577417374,
-0.18172310292720795,
-0.8006688356399536,
-0.5786416530609131,
-0.2719547748565674,
-0.32220807671546936,
-0.27418142557144165,
0.2973819673061371,
-0.2217932641506195,
1.068649411201477,
-0.6455109715461731,
-0.586312472820282,
0.12851817905902863,
0.1676301509141922,
0.3289836347103119,
0.3664115071296692,
0.42154809832572937,
-0.8039429187774658,
-0.34070608019828796,
-0.45369216799736023,
-0.5237894654273987,
-0.17911137640476227,
-0.06834027171134949,
-0.5607297420501709,
-0.09888079017400742,
0.5756665468215942,
-0.6691465973854065,
0.5855169296264648,
0.14365290105342865,
-0.6183063387870789,
0.7864155173301697,
-0.06300723552703857,
0.16755864024162292,
-0.9518892168998718,
-0.20178504288196564,
-0.3933820426464081,
0.07324563711881638,
-0.6544325947761536,
0.26354727149009705,
-0.16608504951000214,
-0.2224792242050171,
-0.4936089515686035,
0.6434515118598938,
-0.6872926354408264,
0.19262000918388367,
-0.07667386531829834,
0.42053085565567017,
-0.11279299855232239,
0.397065669298172,
-0.23556330800056458,
0.3462297022342682,
0.9835832715034485,
-0.773212730884552,
0.6356629133224487,
0.3410086929798126,
-0.24743710458278656,
0.8747178316116333,
-0.7876507639884949,
0.18323032557964325,
-0.3431742489337921,
-0.06505301594734192,
-1.4766716957092285,
-0.2951657772064209,
0.4056365489959717,
-0.529818058013916,
0.10282830148935318,
0.028241397812962532,
-0.4019852578639984,
-0.18413248658180237,
-0.7239056825637817,
0.11740679293870926,
0.48907792568206787,
-0.5208219885826111,
0.6396900415420532,
0.17494092881679535,
0.15706807374954224,
-0.5638855695724487,
-0.2822822630405426,
0.0724678784608841,
-0.3871217370033264,
-0.597156822681427,
0.36420750617980957,
-0.11360076069831848,
-0.3910136818885803,
-0.029963059350848198,
-0.2748880982398987,
0.40540674328804016,
0.4321258068084717,
0.3168335258960724,
0.5213150978088379,
-0.01131198275834322,
-0.1849333792924881,
-0.14932914078235626,
-0.3709704875946045,
0.0032051794696599245,
-0.7048999667167664,
0.3877614438533783,
0.1987065225839615,
-0.49332648515701294,
-0.5586051344871521,
0.5777817368507385,
0.5334740877151489,
-0.44103512167930603,
0.7799345254898071,
0.36406147480010986,
-0.3667662441730499,
-0.34652137756347656,
-0.5423393845558167,
-0.3608005940914154,
-0.5249820947647095,
0.19006353616714478,
-0.5076143145561218,
-1.1137927770614624,
0.4231876730918884,
-0.1055554449558258,
0.4300890862941742,
0.09909236431121826,
0.2683038115501404,
0.05958636477589607,
1.073852300643921,
0.6516295671463013,
-0.27443239092826843,
0.5768837928771973,
0.26781147718429565,
0.10809638351202011,
-0.5090102553367615,
-0.08631492406129837,
-0.8366644978523254,
-0.12318232655525208,
-0.3519231975078583,
-0.27102530002593994,
0.6845015287399292,
0.3696543872356415,
-0.24658945202827454,
0.4497336149215698,
-0.8783107399940491,
0.6258036494255066,
0.6432042717933655,
-0.14031490683555603,
0.37250134348869324,
0.3428473472595215,
-0.5293529629707336,
0.12594003975391388,
-0.4976847469806671,
-0.661329984664917,
0.8116748929023743,
0.13483919203281403,
0.7401561141014099,
0.04711860045790672,
0.9493697881698608,
0.3309589624404907,
-0.11261794716119766,
-0.7084852457046509,
1.0304183959960938,
0.28969019651412964,
-0.42494136095046997,
-0.7476931810379028,
-0.37399840354919434,
-1.2573601007461548,
0.2420734316110611,
-0.005080960225313902,
-1.365118145942688,
-0.13688813149929047,
-0.05376843735575676,
-0.5258275866508484,
0.27768275141716003,
-0.3779938817024231,
0.7449783682823181,
-0.0681287944316864,
-0.21150259673595428,
-0.12733504176139832,
-0.7886595726013184,
0.16679562628269196,
0.14890742301940918,
0.14727874100208282,
-0.5389960408210754,
-0.3630337417125702,
0.7369927763938904,
-0.40699562430381775,
0.8033429980278015,
-0.5725529789924622,
-0.21639834344387054,
0.45303452014923096,
0.30489882826805115,
0.838711678981781,
-0.02181769162416458,
-0.2670852243900299,
0.12099804729223251,
-0.05414588749408722,
-0.499124675989151,
-0.560025691986084,
0.5944978594779968,
-0.3823317587375641,
-0.9968329668045044,
-0.31657952070236206,
-0.21814867854118347,
-0.4436112642288208,
0.2880605161190033,
0.4547801613807678,
0.5571204423904419,
-0.2952025532722473,
0.026621300727128983,
0.5959149599075317,
-0.13734784722328186,
0.4557395875453949,
0.5885127782821655,
-0.1608378142118454,
-0.29152846336364746,
0.7106485962867737,
-0.10795249789953232,
0.32171106338500977,
0.7357492446899414,
0.44996681809425354,
-0.261138379573822,
-0.5895398259162903,
-0.23751699924468994,
0.2125251740217209,
-0.615159273147583,
-0.29252249002456665,
-0.3931082487106323,
0.11141704767942429,
-0.4698473811149597,
-0.4490968883037567,
0.034305233508348465,
0.007663275580853224,
-0.2003045231103897,
-0.05805365741252899,
0.2636929452419281,
0.49601516127586365,
0.2097497433423996,
0.45562291145324707,
-0.8744714856147766,
0.3353860378265381,
0.3180514872074127,
0.209553524851799,
-0.07178876549005508,
-0.3811505436897278,
0.17534664273262024,
-0.09876569360494614,
-0.07352260500192642,
-1.1487759351730347,
-0.028072413057088852,
-0.03234216943383217,
0.867184579372406,
0.4625912308692932,
0.448650598526001,
0.43830281496047974,
-0.48446324467658997,
0.8159710764884949,
0.3387717604637146,
-0.832268238067627,
0.9560638070106506,
-0.3865654766559601,
0.34933343529701233,
0.6018847823143005,
0.4624633491039276,
-0.49925196170806885,
-0.538956344127655,
-0.3778338134288788,
-0.7917464971542358,
0.5997145771980286,
0.14653845131397247,
0.042315416038036346,
-0.12157168984413147,
0.42911162972450256,
0.006442151963710785,
0.3024856448173523,
-0.0019472410203889012,
-0.07805880159139633,
0.15026943385601044,
-0.1276879608631134,
0.22971686720848083,
-0.4932834506034851,
-0.17435628175735474,
0.26150932908058167,
0.5364379286766052,
-0.2480456531047821,
0.09843676537275314,
0.4176446497440338,
0.05107459798455238,
0.012985415756702423,
0.3648010194301605,
0.1324365735054016,
0.34197357296943665,
-0.2008192390203476,
-0.044115081429481506,
-0.13082705438137054,
-0.5970531702041626,
0.21222227811813354,
-0.1940484493970871,
-0.5300857424736023,
-0.03383007273077965,
0.3945595324039459,
0.539382815361023,
0.2181750386953354,
-0.6050159335136414,
0.500643253326416,
-0.032075077295303345,
-0.2613326609134674,
0.12703387439250946,
0.4775424301624298,
-0.3694634437561035,
0.09882248193025589,
0.5239329934120178,
-0.20099759101867676,
0.1594410091638565,
-0.6194085478782654,
0.24329246580600739,
0.6976318955421448,
-0.2288253754377365,
-0.28638339042663574,
0.5402096509933472,
0.08440139144659042,
-0.5690073370933533,
0.4303434491157532,
-0.15628524124622345,
-0.567596435546875,
0.35547906160354614,
0.3746075928211212,
1.1162080764770508,
-0.5491464138031006,
0.35535645484924316,
0.4575484097003937,
0.4491691291332245,
-0.10500828921794891,
0.38789260387420654,
-0.2219114750623703,
-0.6892113089561462,
-0.19017179310321808,
-0.943385660648346,
-0.5929961800575256,
-0.06706240773200989,
-0.625440239906311,
0.3163036108016968,
-0.6000369191169739,
-0.19245277345180511,
-0.11287571489810944,
-0.02997651882469654,
-0.5460278987884521,
0.05706669017672539,
-0.0593072772026062,
0.9165081977844238,
-0.35383468866348267,
0.5010861158370972,
0.825205385684967,
-0.3147345781326294,
-0.6702369451522827,
0.2224499136209488,
0.36283332109451294,
-0.976580798625946,
0.3661729693412781,
0.31294870376586914,
-0.4394682049751282,
0.09508459270000458,
-0.8680717945098877,
-0.9014497995376587,
0.8016607165336609,
0.2816745638847351,
-0.5558886528015137,
-0.3837548792362213,
0.23600126802921295,
0.060337815433740616,
-0.3673217296600342,
-0.2868257761001587,
0.6279693841934204,
0.7848284244537354,
0.3432317078113556,
-0.5934855341911316,
0.26923906803131104,
0.16503854095935822,
-0.013605996035039425,
0.09319616109132767,
-0.343740850687027,
0.6596538424491882,
-0.18222978711128235,
-0.38907915353775024,
0.22650869190692902,
0.4992123246192932,
0.4520173966884613,
0.12271605432033539,
0.7484140992164612,
0.16017811000347137,
1.1355153322219849,
-0.06148238107562065,
0.8805446028709412,
-0.15593120455741882,
0.015619315207004547,
0.8841601610183716,
-0.4796777069568634,
0.6281605362892151,
0.5343865752220154,
0.13046301901340485,
0.24857215583324432,
0.4091775417327881,
0.07104916125535965,
0.47814369201660156,
0.3389691412448883,
-0.15302197635173798,
-0.3898167014122009,
-0.32482728362083435,
0.03955923020839691,
0.5030445456504822,
0.345645934343338,
0.22479397058486938,
-0.5094897747039795,
0.2044501155614853,
0.23259802162647247,
0.0867619439959526,
-0.49257948994636536,
0.9715218544006348,
-0.03392629697918892,
-0.981839656829834,
0.4960387349128723,
0.05251463130116463,
0.7426360249519348,
-0.9829562902450562,
0.06314929574728012,
-0.03152477741241455,
0.05211314931511879,
-0.02576253190636635,
-0.6014411449432373,
0.10519011318683624,
0.08633102476596832,
-0.16864198446273804,
-0.24489155411720276,
0.9705218076705933,
-0.36965274810791016,
-0.11088750511407852,
0.5518835186958313,
0.3208959698677063,
0.15555354952812195,
-0.6090545058250427,
-0.5297790169715881,
0.09236150234937668,
-0.013084673322737217,
-0.296319842338562,
0.4215031862258911,
0.609015703201294,
-0.26760950684547424,
0.4037284553050995,
0.7889770865440369,
0.1869872808456421,
-0.029934346675872803,
-0.2034163624048233,
0.7092292308807373,
-0.7647805213928223,
-0.8408048152923584,
-1.0789108276367188,
0.4201270639896393,
-0.2281341552734375,
-0.21337836980819702,
1.1854774951934814,
0.22757302224636078,
0.6541094183921814,
0.12654440104961395,
0.5378071069717407,
0.28974229097366333,
0.5149343609809875,
-0.7356876730918884,
0.3499464690685272,
-0.5612639784812927,
0.2602538764476776,
-0.41086918115615845,
-1.1596013307571411,
-0.44476598501205444,
0.2898896336555481,
-0.342538058757782,
-0.3626774549484253,
0.5573864579200745,
1.0696073770523071,
0.3635503947734833,
0.2379329949617386,
0.6182522177696228,
0.049685269594192505,
0.42714402079582214,
0.48143476247787476,
0.9479499459266663,
0.08497187495231628,
0.6015770435333252,
0.07833172380924225,
-0.5499659180641174,
-0.4486020505428314,
-1.0561600923538208,
-1.0010161399841309,
-0.37038394808769226,
-0.25051334500312805,
-0.332364022731781,
0.20080427825450897,
1.0504145622253418,
0.6032971143722534,
-0.8362170457839966,
-0.08183103054761887,
0.022531740367412567,
0.39012858271598816,
-0.15836161375045776,
-0.19547292590141296,
0.3721686899662018,
-0.7179362177848816,
-0.41170570254325867,
0.5566822290420532,
0.48528674244880676,
-0.20229464769363403,
-0.18241563439369202,
0.03313145786523819,
-0.08743476867675781,
0.27645811438560486,
0.4500969350337982,
0.02203097939491272,
-0.7310468554496765,
-0.4084949791431427,
0.23069776594638824,
-0.2213944047689438,
-0.27764078974723816,
0.8860394358634949,
-0.45551320910453796,
0.31615909934043884,
0.5612434148788452,
0.7805479168891907,
-0.1691598892211914,
0.29730623960494995,
0.41089680790901184,
-0.8500849604606628,
0.001759697450324893,
0.19559860229492188,
0.3093571364879608,
0.14721065759658813,
-0.5768546462059021,
0.23532593250274658,
0.3634847104549408,
-0.432295024394989,
-0.7542705535888672,
0.26032137870788574,
-0.7854281663894653,
-0.549298107624054,
1.2447408437728882,
-0.09234892576932907,
-0.6796908974647522,
-0.2383458912372589,
-0.623237133026123,
-0.022757580503821373,
-0.7082956433296204,
0.5409029126167297,
0.7500882744789124,
0.13583365082740784,
0.5723487138748169,
-0.252249538898468,
0.6140925288200378,
0.34076693654060364,
-0.5152549147605896,
0.03833991289138794,
0.7534233331680298,
0.07523185759782791,
0.44344380497932434,
0.636481523513794,
-0.107256218791008,
0.1897539645433426,
-0.05503226816654205,
-0.2722635865211487,
-0.17233429849147797,
-0.796712338924408,
-0.32505345344543457,
0.5865437388420105,
-0.18157519400119781,
-0.5987573862075806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14179v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14179v2
|
UzMorphAnalyser: A Morphological Analysis Model for the Uzbek Language Using Inflectional Endings
| 2024-05-23T05:06:55 | 2024-06-12T09:16:46 |
Ulugbek Salaev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Uzbek language is agglutinative, has many morphological features which
words formed by combining root and affixes. Affixes play an important role in
the morphological analysis of words, by adding additional meanings and
grammatical functions to words. Inflectional endings are utilized to express
various morphological features within the language. This feature introduces
numerous possibilities for word endings, thereby significantly expanding the
word vocabulary and exacerbating issues related to data sparsity in statistical
models. This paper present modeling of the morphological analysis of Uzbek
words, including stemming, lemmatizing, and the extraction of morphological
information while considering morpho-phonetic exceptions. Main steps of the
model involve developing a complete set of word-ending with assigned
morphological information, and additional datasets for morphological analysis.
The proposed model was evaluated using a curated test set comprising 5.3K
words. Through manual verification of stemming, lemmatizing, and morphological
feature corrections carried out by linguistic specialists, it obtained a
word-level accuracy of over 91%. The developed tool based on the proposed model
is available as a web-based application and an open-source Python library.
|
[
-0.2094670832157135,
-0.8467773795127869,
0.06438238173723221,
0.2659279704093933,
-0.7885959148406982,
-0.07060801237821579,
0.026032811030745506,
-0.23411902785301208,
-0.08366642147302628,
0.48943084478378296,
-0.8530597686767578,
-0.4651010036468506,
-0.3934018313884735,
0.3103017210960388,
-0.46914178133010864,
0.60128253698349,
0.12536892294883728,
0.5575090646743774,
0.10830717533826828,
-0.1325521469116211,
-0.20696794986724854,
-0.5991441607475281,
0.02477688528597355,
-0.577548086643219,
-0.14550714194774628,
0.26162269711494446,
0.859967052936554,
0.9083316922187805,
0.3233286440372467,
0.2769778370857239,
-0.19643430411815643,
-0.19719994068145752,
0.10284384340047836,
0.5185234546661377,
0.07202158868312836,
-0.18611477315425873,
0.05496310070157051,
-0.2126532793045044,
0.4284461736679077,
0.7467488050460815,
-0.4881518483161926,
-0.0073884702287614346,
-0.17198075354099274,
0.4108371138572693,
-0.17474545538425446,
-0.23271702229976654,
-0.5542047619819641,
0.08278930932283401,
-0.6267898678779602,
-0.1111859381198883,
-0.17561617493629456,
-0.1602495163679123,
-0.051378048956394196,
0.008595773950219154,
0.103236123919487,
-0.2537684142589569,
0.8330402374267578,
0.0845814123749733,
-0.11661721765995026,
-0.4679105877876282,
-0.33979693055152893,
0.6131507754325867,
-1.0344749689102173,
0.8019747734069824,
0.05050855875015259,
0.163598895072937,
-0.9874427914619446,
-0.4170771539211273,
-0.6518796682357788,
-0.42213448882102966,
0.04767598956823349,
0.08837529271841049,
-0.2830222249031067,
0.26585653424263,
-0.2615894079208374,
0.4774641990661621,
-0.7773340344429016,
-0.09282936900854111,
-0.28869298100471497,
-0.0938124731183052,
0.31768113374710083,
0.49472811818122864,
0.9285563826560974,
-0.6166906356811523,
-0.2341964840888977,
0.10308332741260529,
-0.4808949828147888,
0.2641592025756836,
0.8366094827651978,
0.6677322387695312,
0.18434087932109833,
1.1987627744674683,
-0.4346201419830322,
0.7926774621009827,
-0.012664509937167168,
-0.22019562125205994,
0.13274222612380981,
-0.3688059449195862,
-0.315354585647583,
-0.43110597133636475,
0.8243653178215027,
0.049598921090364456,
0.3041404187679291,
-0.3317232131958008,
-0.14770643413066864,
-0.18469475209712982,
0.13096989691257477,
-0.6244802474975586,
-0.4108562767505646,
0.36581650376319885,
-0.4831545650959015,
-0.06874450296163559,
0.14216898381710052,
-0.9101585149765015,
-0.18166998028755188,
-0.09036406874656677,
0.314500093460083,
-1.0730777978897095,
-0.3169626295566559,
0.3815213739871979,
-0.26187849044799805,
0.10290855169296265,
0.0645575076341629,
-0.9584596753120422,
0.5358095169067383,
0.45564186573028564,
1.086643099784851,
-0.35093364119529724,
-0.2705637514591217,
-0.15835058689117432,
-0.1833290308713913,
0.027944155037403107,
0.9674960970878601,
-0.7833159565925598,
-0.6434243321418762,
0.13778409361839294,
0.08749417215585709,
-0.09570404887199402,
-0.2589128315448761,
0.5061529874801636,
-0.28495728969573975,
0.028664395213127136,
0.684057354927063,
-0.753399670124054,
-0.3784235715866089,
-0.10986223816871643,
-0.39530447125434875,
1.1051360368728638,
0.40779441595077515,
-0.4446277320384979,
0.2525629699230194,
-0.6650895476341248,
-0.209163099527359,
0.446088969707489,
-0.0018771564355120063,
-0.2723831832408905,
0.39377787709236145,
-0.003223907668143511,
0.3681717813014984,
-0.14865149557590485,
0.009351522661745548,
0.11331801116466522,
-0.05772607773542404,
0.26425597071647644,
-0.05091845989227295,
1.1628494262695312,
0.07938183099031448,
-0.031465187668800354,
0.29963821172714233,
-0.8973203301429749,
0.3247964680194855,
-0.09154713898897171,
-0.506080150604248,
-0.5150173306465149,
0.006441768258810043,
0.3664100170135498,
0.004832777660340071,
-0.078178271651268,
-0.7001200914382935,
0.5608961582183838,
-0.5471146702766418,
0.11967059969902039,
0.5578505396842957,
0.07092422991991043,
0.2426316738128662,
0.3587859869003296,
0.641516923904419,
-0.10909842699766159,
0.4954105615615845,
-0.06264538317918777,
-0.8398816585540771,
-0.5764064788818359,
-0.9031749963760376,
0.41615259647369385,
0.3070303797721863,
-0.5340031385421753,
0.4897124469280243,
-0.025998223572969437,
-0.676089346408844,
-0.24733678996562958,
0.02850572019815445,
0.21749281883239746,
0.2629489600658417,
0.15882548689842224,
-0.07755882292985916,
-0.6041144728660583,
-0.7731851935386658,
-0.38455620408058167,
-0.05553869158029556,
-0.31803449988365173,
-0.45768481492996216,
0.6834760904312134,
-0.3185861110687256,
0.9147226810455322,
-0.3690292239189148,
-0.4805411696434021,
-0.6229372620582581,
0.2628348171710968,
0.5888628959655762,
0.25302159786224365,
0.4093504846096039,
-0.6797356605529785,
-0.5557663440704346,
0.1457049697637558,
-0.10975689440965652,
-0.33318406343460083,
0.2414907068014145,
0.014800325967371464,
0.20720776915550232,
0.0032467294950038195,
-0.8724558353424072,
0.5582732558250427,
0.5286232233047485,
-0.7039604783058167,
0.7270344495773315,
-0.294232577085495,
0.24053436517715454,
-0.9133110642433167,
-0.25814005732536316,
0.10004664212465286,
0.12181872129440308,
-1.099162220954895,
0.41408777236938477,
0.005508421920239925,
0.17240557074546814,
-0.37606149911880493,
0.475488543510437,
-0.5183514356613159,
0.10280600190162659,
-0.2767408788204193,
-0.12401188910007477,
-0.27667397260665894,
0.3599214255809784,
-0.12405600398778915,
0.8625958561897278,
0.3284224271774292,
-0.5695413947105408,
0.8862603306770325,
0.39950886368751526,
-0.24571119248867035,
0.0034591893199831247,
-0.4997156858444214,
-0.09656593203544617,
0.18122966587543488,
-0.45028868317604065,
-1.231661319732666,
-0.5359843969345093,
0.6792832016944885,
-0.84677654504776,
0.07469292730093002,
-0.6049354672431946,
-0.7129946947097778,
-0.3100365996360779,
-0.5191279649734497,
0.16779160499572754,
0.4294488728046417,
-0.4075356125831604,
0.8055292367935181,
0.48338782787323,
-0.22863160073757172,
-0.0926959440112114,
-0.46008923649787903,
-0.041414983570575714,
-0.34700635075569153,
-0.6516961455345154,
0.053263310343027115,
0.1444280445575714,
-0.5136496424674988,
-0.01358603686094284,
0.11584653705358505,
-0.6582035422325134,
-0.07820752263069153,
0.1983867883682251,
0.47528165578842163,
0.12881475687026978,
0.1573127955198288,
0.19020606577396393,
-0.01667521707713604,
-0.21350590884685516,
-0.23704251646995544,
0.976270854473114,
0.14750848710536957,
-0.2139802724123001,
-0.4899723529815674,
0.2730819582939148,
0.6003880500793457,
-0.0370882973074913,
0.7012564539909363,
0.16437548398971558,
-0.6156085133552551,
0.21468695998191833,
-0.2907140851020813,
0.23713289201259613,
-0.38319429755210876,
0.3523966670036316,
-0.5466991066932678,
-0.23438820242881775,
0.8284894824028015,
0.029894234612584114,
-0.07119494676589966,
0.6952453255653381,
0.8088149428367615,
-0.11137589812278748,
1.1299052238464355,
0.8077706694602966,
0.08053646236658096,
0.4094669818878174,
-0.043440237641334534,
0.14482508599758148,
-0.7778017520904541,
-0.6909685730934143,
-0.7042087316513062,
0.6357766389846802,
-0.4396013915538788,
-0.20479102432727814,
0.17324121296405792,
-0.005745698697865009,
0.3888903856277466,
0.5019142627716064,
-0.40787240862846375,
0.19607368111610413,
0.24784789979457855,
-0.41191166639328003,
0.29326966404914856,
0.3452351689338684,
-0.36299026012420654,
-0.3606722950935364,
-0.19613191485404968,
-0.4982426166534424,
0.6943244338035583,
0.12390481680631638,
0.8970218896865845,
0.2815258800983429,
0.11072730273008347,
0.7149019241333008,
-0.2834751009941101,
-1.1171954870224,
0.2807447016239166,
-0.14991870522499084,
-0.3235306739807129,
-0.743983268737793,
-0.08149842172861099,
-0.5985310673713684,
0.6168511509895325,
-0.10507474094629288,
-1.1093677282333374,
-0.012477296404540539,
-0.17198117077350616,
-0.009869729168713093,
0.08406208455562592,
-0.21950368583202362,
0.6576862335205078,
0.019301097840070724,
0.1653316169977188,
-0.12311356514692307,
-0.27389952540397644,
0.3081264793872833,
0.1115385890007019,
-0.005394104868173599,
-0.2502959966659546,
0.040923669934272766,
0.683836817741394,
-0.7124600410461426,
0.29649147391319275,
-0.04465274140238762,
0.17723888158798218,
0.16695670783519745,
0.09946458041667938,
0.17742739617824554,
-0.2504744827747345,
-0.18404804170131683,
0.4434910714626312,
0.12440062314271927,
-0.16029982268810272,
-0.6528087854385376,
0.34184515476226807,
-0.4755614399909973,
-0.33535802364349365,
-0.6131870150566101,
-0.44555675983428955,
-0.03779315948486328,
0.12929289042949677,
0.3825119435787201,
0.7889019846916199,
-0.19357053935527802,
-0.23707932233810425,
0.4109346568584442,
0.1448650360107422,
0.1734423041343689,
0.3485713601112366,
-0.28141316771507263,
-0.42932888865470886,
0.6101539731025696,
0.28236421942710876,
-0.10782711952924728,
-0.2306785136461258,
0.47672757506370544,
-0.558920681476593,
-1.1068423986434937,
-1.0331069231033325,
0.3037390410900116,
-0.6197470426559448,
-0.2582535147666931,
-0.6178739666938782,
-0.30460238456726074,
-0.6171903610229492,
0.28208521008491516,
-0.177696093916893,
-0.6116823554039001,
-0.12334670126438141,
0.22266116738319397,
0.6878882050514221,
0.8993969559669495,
0.027439342811703682,
0.6178176999092102,
-0.9078711271286011,
0.3403235077857971,
-0.19280460476875305,
0.14365626871585846,
-0.3071691393852234,
-0.9046798944473267,
-0.25842347741127014,
0.10144693404436111,
-0.24894355237483978,
-1.1654210090637207,
0.7865913510322571,
0.27194899320602417,
0.7808640599250793,
0.6270697116851807,
-0.21272136270999908,
0.9580718874931335,
-0.5396044254302979,
0.7663131356239319,
0.18339505791664124,
-1.0802897214889526,
0.4266136884689331,
-0.5035858154296875,
0.15291035175323486,
0.34169015288352966,
0.32744312286376953,
-0.7765290141105652,
-0.8107789158821106,
-0.10530926287174225,
-0.9269585013389587,
0.5283257961273193,
0.33493271470069885,
0.2769518792629242,
-0.17215190827846527,
0.661104679107666,
0.5337608456611633,
0.017318693920969963,
-0.35696497559547424,
-0.22673359513282776,
-0.27444133162498474,
-0.363582968711853,
0.6533511281013489,
-0.5804116129875183,
0.38888171315193176,
-0.6525430679321289,
0.7996597290039062,
0.028597785159945488,
-0.03326664865016937,
-0.10111254453659058,
-0.4655807614326477,
0.067753367125988,
0.3101363778114319,
0.6876223087310791,
0.4376257359981537,
0.002740514697507024,
-0.24977023899555206,
0.06981618702411652,
-0.9125717878341675,
0.26456812024116516,
-0.13400807976722717,
-0.2123999148607254,
0.26858893036842346,
0.3101451098918915,
0.10379596799612045,
-0.11172071844339371,
-0.7106967568397522,
0.4013942778110504,
-0.13696859776973724,
0.11319319903850555,
-0.40839463472366333,
0.014799746684730053,
-0.17469611763954163,
0.1562560796737671,
0.7856718897819519,
-0.34143534302711487,
0.7973060011863708,
-0.5866231322288513,
0.1495344489812851,
0.5785267949104309,
-0.2295609712600708,
-0.5789862871170044,
-0.0731775239109993,
-0.062069348990917206,
-0.48594608902931213,
0.8467361927032471,
0.01805894635617733,
-0.9611220359802246,
0.43097448348999023,
0.6006194949150085,
0.5984349250793457,
-0.8532130122184753,
0.2512461841106415,
0.20954543352127075,
-0.0026865846011787653,
0.1585228443145752,
0.44084417819976807,
-0.04516270384192467,
-0.4598084092140198,
-0.12283975630998611,
-0.8354573845863342,
-0.22591349482536316,
0.15852327644824982,
-0.6457315683364868,
0.2717185914516449,
-0.23008641600608826,
-0.15407857298851013,
-0.05542060732841492,
-0.002559182234108448,
0.08891306817531586,
0.3741998076438904,
-0.40903759002685547,
0.927623450756073,
-0.8870947957038879,
0.7988316416740417,
0.6026076078414917,
-0.3833112418651581,
-0.37856772541999817,
0.1628875434398651,
0.11386312544345856,
-0.6468432545661926,
0.689044713973999,
0.09563495963811874,
-0.5755898356437683,
-0.13951091468334198,
-0.18903110921382904,
-0.8162676692008972,
0.427775502204895,
0.11672084778547287,
0.03218569979071617,
0.02311604656279087,
0.41257548332214355,
0.7537564635276794,
-0.3221035301685333,
0.25219646096229553,
0.6224460601806641,
0.5731247067451477,
0.2757370173931122,
-0.5712860226631165,
-0.09051872044801712,
-0.3672644793987274,
0.08674906939268112,
0.39426425099372864,
-0.09672302007675171,
1.1058999300003052,
-0.017602290958166122,
-0.6855685114860535,
0.7465831637382507,
0.7134669423103333,
-0.19862741231918335,
-0.5063151717185974,
0.2417328655719757,
0.07768388837575912,
0.3495854139328003,
-0.07747065275907516,
0.6689391136169434,
-0.15852463245391846,
0.43491578102111816,
0.5273488759994507,
0.1788579225540161,
0.6537310481071472,
0.7717068195343018,
-0.2808801829814911,
0.34043648838996887,
0.8476547598838806,
-0.29730919003486633,
0.7802037596702576,
0.3205033242702484,
-0.23398520052433014,
-0.1912013739347458,
-0.15363499522209167,
-0.06979557126760483,
0.9164573550224304,
0.3811684250831604,
0.15503233671188354,
-0.3416971266269684,
0.10629834234714508,
-0.019357308745384216,
0.06728863716125488,
-0.22912314534187317,
0.5174960494041443,
-0.2881280779838562,
-0.09858241677284241,
0.16333246231079102,
0.2494928389787674,
0.5648142099380493,
-0.828666627407074,
-0.33121258020401,
-0.16425155103206635,
0.20872966945171356,
-0.23169901967048645,
-0.8413033485412598,
0.4946492612361908,
0.03452466055750847,
0.016435004770755768,
0.37352973222732544,
0.43916213512420654,
-0.4180355370044708,
-0.7173337936401367,
0.4432740807533264,
0.33008381724357605,
0.30801650881767273,
0.1268516331911087,
-0.40318503975868225,
0.08457563817501068,
-0.2020314335823059,
-0.5600541234016418,
0.20014770328998566,
0.25880417227745056,
-0.16493187844753265,
1.0618258714675903,
0.7251179814338684,
0.46133533120155334,
0.2961421310901642,
0.34038978815078735,
0.9113572835922241,
-0.6313621401786804,
-0.40741249918937683,
-1.1190961599349976,
0.7195206880569458,
-0.0917612761259079,
-0.24679769575595856,
0.9031570553779602,
0.43596193194389343,
0.5178803205490112,
-0.17903965711593628,
0.6222583055496216,
0.024300651624798775,
0.3103136718273163,
-0.6358106732368469,
0.9572358131408691,
-0.5586643815040588,
-0.39586079120635986,
-0.21904149651527405,
-0.6038357019424438,
-0.5468167662620544,
0.80983567237854,
0.3173452615737915,
-0.22512571513652802,
0.3992377519607544,
0.32649263739585876,
-0.05048257112503052,
-0.06869865953922272,
0.7274101972579956,
0.14339511096477509,
0.21014879643917084,
-0.2222878634929657,
0.7883753776550293,
-0.2528257668018341,
0.2594853937625885,
-0.16128025949001312,
-0.3426298499107361,
-0.3770546317100525,
-0.41764596104621887,
-1.1386622190475464,
-0.841314971446991,
0.2636565864086151,
-0.0902421846985817,
0.1857312172651291,
1.0924991369247437,
0.14917296171188354,
-0.6650160551071167,
-0.3930281698703766,
0.0916551798582077,
-0.03398623317480087,
0.0028498386964201927,
-0.20432232320308685,
0.3083745539188385,
-0.21848632395267487,
-0.6053658127784729,
0.268535852432251,
0.5299744606018066,
0.3107343316078186,
-0.3740628957748413,
0.05237901955842972,
-0.18939435482025146,
0.2937681972980499,
0.23459699749946594,
0.13947345316410065,
-0.9787411689758301,
-0.3114924132823944,
0.20999020338058472,
-0.0029459400102496147,
0.19856779277324677,
0.8245744705200195,
-0.4249478876590729,
0.401338666677475,
0.452592670917511,
-0.03417060896754265,
-0.01646103337407112,
0.017593590542674065,
0.6127439737319946,
-0.028036989271640778,
0.2848869264125824,
-0.14476309716701508,
0.6219038963317871,
0.39169880747795105,
-0.45969119668006897,
0.29471275210380554,
0.1849185675382614,
-0.062565878033638,
-0.777023196220398,
0.4031418561935425,
-0.582477867603302,
-0.11581543833017349,
0.8603171110153198,
-0.3273453414440155,
-0.46598976850509644,
-0.7031782865524292,
-0.247499018907547,
0.5441041588783264,
-0.34023532271385193,
0.9597259759902954,
0.8652305603027344,
-0.48311612010002136,
-0.11499486118555069,
-0.06783954799175262,
0.3958359658718109,
-0.2591472864151001,
-0.5369202494621277,
0.2930930554866791,
0.37699607014656067,
0.58873051404953,
0.13519492745399475,
0.45593464374542236,
-0.23047807812690735,
0.4627561867237091,
0.06216730177402496,
0.29536160826683044,
-0.24821814894676208,
-0.35124796628952026,
-0.6193409562110901,
-0.08251992613077164,
0.030931586399674416,
-0.2525523006916046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14170v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14170v1
|
Large Language Models-guided Dynamic Adaptation for Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning
| 2024-05-23T04:54:37 | 2024-05-23T04:54:37 |
Jiapu Wang, Kai Sun, Linhao Luo, Wei Wei, Yongli Hu, Alan Wee-Chung Liew, Shirui Pan, Baocai Yin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning (TKGR) is the process of utilizing
temporal information to capture complex relations within a Temporal Knowledge
Graph (TKG) to infer new knowledge. Conventional methods in TKGR typically
depend on deep learning algorithms or temporal logical rules. However, deep
learning-based TKGRs often lack interpretability, whereas rule-based TKGRs
struggle to effectively learn temporal rules that capture temporal patterns.
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated extensive knowledge
and remarkable proficiency in temporal reasoning. Consequently, the employment
of LLMs for Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning (TKGR) has sparked increasing
interest among researchers. Nonetheless, LLMs are known to function as black
boxes, making it challenging to comprehend their reasoning process.
Additionally, due to the resource-intensive nature of fine-tuning, promptly
updating LLMs to integrate evolving knowledge within TKGs for reasoning is
impractical. To address these challenges, in this paper, we propose a Large
Language Models-guided Dynamic Adaptation (LLM-DA) method for reasoning on
TKGs. Specifically, LLM-DA harnesses the capabilities of LLMs to analyze
historical data and extract temporal logical rules. These rules unveil temporal
patterns and facilitate interpretable reasoning. To account for the evolving
nature of TKGs, a dynamic adaptation strategy is proposed to update the
LLM-generated rules with the latest events. This ensures that the extracted
rules always incorporate the most recent knowledge and better generalize to the
predictions on future events. Experimental results show that without the need
of fine-tuning, LLM-DA significantly improves the accuracy of reasoning over
several common datasets, providing a robust framework for TKGR tasks.
|
[
0.14560137689113617,
-1.06620454788208,
0.898790717124939,
0.046229176223278046,
-0.4344427287578583,
0.5406734943389893,
-0.3519197702407837,
-0.4186793863773346,
-0.36261820793151855,
0.47357311844825745,
-0.6145666241645813,
-0.7996148467063904,
-0.4718007743358612,
-0.08786368370056152,
0.13346631824970245,
0.6055481433868408,
-0.4016910791397095,
-0.37160420417785645,
0.09112787246704102,
0.06407930701971054,
-0.5592525601387024,
-0.141239196062088,
-0.7486352920532227,
-0.6403417587280273,
0.437168151140213,
0.29373881220817566,
0.49201130867004395,
0.7766148447990417,
0.013936849310994148,
0.23076461255550385,
-0.32071784138679504,
0.5025834441184998,
-0.4755946099758148,
0.36594316363334656,
-0.3293907344341278,
-0.34770774841308594,
-0.6344506144523621,
-0.4077039659023285,
0.6556931734085083,
0.6484212875366211,
-0.19104139506816864,
0.09479159861803055,
-0.1165904775261879,
0.3072209656238556,
-0.47458019852638245,
0.7602807879447937,
-0.7589947581291199,
0.2921905219554901,
-0.07047057896852493,
-0.5166749954223633,
-0.5157143473625183,
-0.45053088665008545,
0.13683728873729706,
-0.8464983701705933,
-0.27237293124198914,
0.0007711299695074558,
0.6288445591926575,
0.4304064214229584,
-0.6829749941825867,
-0.09273238480091095,
-0.7713518738746643,
0.7750317454338074,
-1.0260977745056152,
0.5701084136962891,
0.08683734387159348,
0.6388521194458008,
-0.5382986068725586,
-0.8313819766044617,
-0.6247566342353821,
-0.3786599636077881,
0.036906227469444275,
-0.10124453902244568,
-0.017579535022377968,
0.054014723747968674,
0.47023865580558777,
-0.2146645188331604,
-0.3169558048248291,
0.27333030104637146,
0.09274398535490036,
-0.008260988630354404,
0.490103155374527,
0.3740796148777008,
0.09524602442979813,
-0.1151307001709938,
0.0330185741186142,
0.03736118599772453,
-0.5240100026130676,
-0.09953261911869049,
0.07869035005569458,
0.13881069421768188,
-0.2897084355354309,
0.3597092628479004,
-0.2849525809288025,
0.9138380885124207,
0.36099058389663696,
-0.6277146935462952,
0.16692306101322174,
-0.24226674437522888,
-0.16802369058132172,
0.11170592904090881,
0.5650121569633484,
0.49724438786506653,
0.5616837739944458,
-0.41541588306427,
-0.03757490590214729,
-0.17646504938602448,
-0.03100099042057991,
-0.7220343351364136,
-0.13976900279521942,
0.05105888471007347,
-0.524921178817749,
-0.456712543964386,
-0.5359529852867126,
-0.9946292638778687,
-0.4985194802284241,
-0.4077821969985962,
0.47790905833244324,
-0.41421520709991455,
-0.3210345208644867,
0.25115662813186646,
-0.037360068410634995,
0.24183490872383118,
0.7635520100593567,
-0.6213120818138123,
-0.06068442389369011,
0.6483619809150696,
0.6518641710281372,
-0.012714001350104809,
-0.1250365823507309,
-0.7191692590713501,
0.7626731991767883,
-0.3463938236236572,
0.723724365234375,
-0.7870739698410034,
-0.14910873770713806,
-0.09662345796823502,
0.1716446727514267,
-0.06634408235549927,
-0.3091081976890564,
0.3673707842826843,
-0.8334789872169495,
-0.03623402491211891,
-0.15091882646083832,
-0.5824707746505737,
-0.3765488862991333,
0.3834896981716156,
-0.18029308319091797,
0.7298927903175354,
0.15422113239765167,
-0.4417671859264374,
0.59443598985672,
-0.674217939376831,
-0.3762061893939972,
0.27285051345825195,
-0.009037376381456852,
-0.3582373261451721,
-0.18168659508228302,
0.4316781461238861,
0.4585297405719757,
-0.08522574603557587,
0.5542387366294861,
-0.8656466007232666,
-0.004529847763478756,
0.03345928341150284,
-0.13256271183490753,
0.7463671565055847,
0.350652277469635,
-0.2404470294713974,
0.032544780522584915,
-0.7594501376152039,
0.10916808247566223,
0.1857258677482605,
-0.4533858299255371,
-0.09254004806280136,
0.45008689165115356,
-0.4420744478702545,
0.10512541979551315,
0.1359928399324417,
-0.35310599207878113,
0.7555908560752869,
-0.2050608992576599,
0.6798478960990906,
0.9073917865753174,
0.3225131332874298,
0.4077780842781067,
-0.20597510039806366,
0.4183195233345032,
-0.007264537736773491,
0.08102454245090485,
-0.06877898424863815,
-0.21663707494735718,
-0.48959729075431824,
0.08383636921644211,
0.28509819507598877,
0.6441222429275513,
-1.0443203449249268,
0.4940252900123596,
-0.593309223651886,
-0.37444254755973816,
-0.03679783269762993,
0.09357450157403946,
-0.07257052510976791,
0.7274394035339355,
0.2138349860906601,
0.21459956467151642,
-0.47162488102912903,
-0.3651610314846039,
-0.20624633133411407,
-0.3966715335845947,
0.1624765843153,
0.5081364512443542,
0.4616762101650238,
-0.2581952214241028,
0.5919796228408813,
-0.6189237833023071,
0.055734675377607346,
-0.19042357802391052,
0.13781510293483734,
0.28132396936416626,
0.09346990287303925,
0.6157767176628113,
-0.5038387179374695,
-0.5254331827163696,
0.32013973593711853,
-0.8451040983200073,
-0.5994173884391785,
-0.25259265303611755,
-0.09983301162719727,
0.2028413563966751,
0.7843285799026489,
-0.460842102766037,
0.23529398441314697,
0.5157814025878906,
-0.6936785578727722,
0.5853153467178345,
-0.2081003338098526,
0.015609870664775372,
-0.9912565350532532,
-0.19956539571285248,
-0.2782593071460724,
-0.3986596465110779,
-0.41788268089294434,
-0.0716271921992302,
0.0765518993139267,
0.023385509848594666,
-0.07506746053695679,
1.1050149202346802,
-0.4233611822128296,
0.15898339450359344,
-0.2934536039829254,
-0.07177498191595078,
0.0172530859708786,
0.44641274213790894,
-0.11987818777561188,
0.32428303360939026,
0.5520435571670532,
-0.6970313191413879,
0.74509197473526,
0.16158080101013184,
-0.5081647038459778,
0.19879662990570068,
-0.26063087582588196,
0.23086142539978027,
-0.08684277534484863,
0.424988329410553,
-0.5484198331832886,
-0.1486968696117401,
0.2970055341720581,
-0.1889847218990326,
0.6079634428024292,
-0.5825093984603882,
-0.6693834662437439,
-0.3209359049797058,
0.15689881145954132,
0.3806828558444977,
0.5111250281333923,
-0.7353920936584473,
1.2246164083480835,
0.1513439565896988,
-0.20180287957191467,
-0.47255048155784607,
-0.5686282515525818,
0.23501169681549072,
-0.20902281999588013,
-0.6781402230262756,
0.29169929027557373,
-0.04405118525028229,
-0.3809533417224884,
0.2949296832084656,
-0.2990138530731201,
0.18945202231407166,
0.18608185648918152,
-0.0637899711728096,
0.0010021404596045613,
-0.3013264238834381,
0.22919881343841553,
0.15049615502357483,
-0.022772004827857018,
-0.056387823075056076,
-0.6852960586547852,
0.44909003376960754,
0.21679750084877014,
-0.313564658164978,
-0.26135796308517456,
-0.08649447560310364,
0.7876489162445068,
-0.12655258178710938,
0.8725093007087708,
0.5723569989204407,
-0.24021124839782715,
-0.4858926236629486,
-0.6987159848213196,
-0.07982667535543442,
-0.4829213321208954,
0.4519727826118469,
-0.44771772623062134,
-0.9374393820762634,
0.5983851552009583,
-0.4325654208660126,
-0.025210369378328323,
0.264482706785202,
0.7073313593864441,
-0.166305810213089,
0.9190846085548401,
0.27681872248649597,
0.13851647078990936,
0.7000604867935181,
0.01794770359992981,
0.19793234765529633,
-0.5836263298988342,
-0.5616706013679504,
-0.1462981104850769,
-0.2981421649456024,
-0.6525432467460632,
-0.3839399516582489,
0.3589629828929901,
0.13082298636436462,
-0.46854186058044434,
-0.2350303679704666,
-0.16808481514453888,
0.3280777931213379,
0.1402866542339325,
0.24010132253170013,
0.3101995587348938,
-0.0439087450504303,
-0.26511186361312866,
0.18005125224590302,
-0.6819964647293091,
-0.2792145311832428,
0.9455185532569885,
0.30204907059669495,
0.9083775281906128,
0.22464537620544434,
0.18554645776748657,
0.4420904517173767,
0.024362511932849884,
-0.8332769870758057,
0.6687401533126831,
-0.2746635973453522,
-0.13749246299266815,
-0.30311229825019836,
-0.7439045906066895,
-0.8413421511650085,
-0.04052872955799103,
-0.3131502568721771,
-0.8554348349571228,
0.1349608302116394,
0.1717715859413147,
-0.23347005248069763,
0.7100354433059692,
-0.7660573124885559,
0.7763983011245728,
-0.42401471734046936,
-0.26657214760780334,
-0.20617161691188812,
-0.2992188632488251,
0.19640903174877167,
-0.3701634705066681,
0.14234429597854614,
-0.292692631483078,
-0.09480439126491547,
0.5803444385528564,
-0.2175084501504898,
0.9201995134353638,
-0.43490150570869446,
-0.02504716068506241,
0.19698818027973175,
0.3852074444293976,
1.073165774345398,
-0.18749725818634033,
-0.1834869384765625,
0.06536414474248886,
0.12261532247066498,
-0.41122734546661377,
-0.8156599998474121,
0.581537127494812,
-0.7450793385505676,
-0.853626549243927,
-0.2604295015335083,
-0.9740083813667297,
-0.2690061628818512,
0.2580287754535675,
-0.48715904355049133,
0.30612292885780334,
0.10936813801527023,
0.1804061383008957,
0.48547932505607605,
-0.5011814832687378,
0.40193673968315125,
0.7403333187103271,
-0.3375917375087738,
-0.3113901615142822,
0.48612791299819946,
0.23669371008872986,
0.3155321478843689,
0.6692035794258118,
0.5882846713066101,
-0.3823067247867584,
-0.9510384798049927,
-0.3481522798538208,
0.4386206269264221,
-0.7184849381446838,
-0.049584195017814636,
-0.7678808569908142,
-0.1681223064661026,
-0.5247676372528076,
-0.05993718281388283,
0.14750728011131287,
-0.4521544575691223,
-0.1708497405052185,
0.03476927429437637,
0.6752851009368896,
0.47368955612182617,
0.14608663320541382,
0.20358338952064514,
-0.8686231970787048,
0.3374177813529968,
0.5585808157920837,
0.3962266743183136,
0.173995241522789,
-0.757455587387085,
0.003236501943320036,
-0.2218884378671646,
-0.26361092925071716,
-0.8225913643836975,
0.2036425620317459,
0.12841083109378815,
0.7689126133918762,
0.33716481924057007,
0.06898897886276245,
0.7598440051078796,
-0.6621974110603333,
0.5184474587440491,
-0.2043124884366989,
-0.7715793251991272,
0.44429340958595276,
-0.8503700494766235,
0.5821546316146851,
-0.10373443365097046,
-0.08735766261816025,
-0.6001606583595276,
-0.11422908306121826,
-0.39630210399627686,
-0.4950588643550873,
0.7752053141593933,
-0.1655893623828888,
-0.2017909288406372,
0.308764785528183,
0.7245038151741028,
-0.007195309270173311,
0.08949081599712372,
-0.5030252933502197,
0.16258418560028076,
-0.14712144434452057,
-0.36746472120285034,
0.06508427858352661,
-0.32757219672203064,
0.03813197836279869,
-0.2641826272010803,
0.42843231558799744,
-0.35492902994155884,
0.13816829025745392,
-0.40754008293151855,
-0.031996358186006546,
-0.3478447496891022,
0.41034647822380066,
0.4618721604347229,
0.9247626066207886,
-0.3512919247150421,
0.05256516858935356,
0.676409125328064,
-0.27794694900512695,
0.10240903496742249,
0.2784455716609955,
-0.21793119609355927,
-0.3203584551811218,
0.6433427333831787,
0.920017659664154,
0.019755695015192032,
-0.5475545525550842,
0.2631934881210327,
0.16207154095172882,
-0.2261003702878952,
-0.2835921347141266,
0.24684025347232819,
0.20725275576114655,
0.8435590267181396,
0.3450169563293457,
-0.29036521911621094,
-0.6382483243942261,
-0.5911362171173096,
-0.10988973826169968,
0.24596451222896576,
0.09378374367952347,
-0.27345582842826843,
0.5746670961380005,
-0.010823950171470642,
-0.32136964797973633,
0.5135003328323364,
-0.2755974531173706,
-0.6325445175170898,
0.5115863084793091,
0.4889453947544098,
0.8160093426704407,
-0.25505003333091736,
-0.012234300374984741,
0.32538801431655884,
0.12731705605983734,
-0.0675170049071312,
0.24290086328983307,
-0.02836008183658123,
-0.7626810073852539,
-0.9585584998130798,
-0.7209699153900146,
-0.2743169665336609,
0.38077598810195923,
-0.05842946469783783,
0.40750566124916077,
-0.49683183431625366,
0.01701098307967186,
0.022929098457098007,
0.06453581899404526,
-0.5266903042793274,
0.037494491785764694,
0.26415762305259705,
1.0355154275894165,
-0.7452459335327148,
0.9708032011985779,
0.5659781694412231,
0.11646978557109833,
-0.7381435632705688,
0.12513947486877441,
0.13153894245624542,
-0.8612691760063171,
0.8188771605491638,
-0.4947374761104584,
0.10115247964859009,
-0.045274075120687485,
-0.5713015198707581,
-0.9601350426673889,
1.297899842262268,
0.5898211002349854,
-0.7489387392997742,
-0.2824193835258484,
-0.12255452573299408,
0.5856662392616272,
-0.2932579219341278,
-0.10033538192510605,
0.5031816959381104,
0.774049699306488,
0.46620288491249084,
-0.9703519940376282,
0.1799779087305069,
0.10219790041446686,
-0.30742180347442627,
0.48772427439689636,
-0.600391685962677,
0.5708182454109192,
-0.3542974889278412,
-0.12451618909835815,
-0.2058783322572708,
0.4676254391670227,
0.4604593813419342,
0.3593083620071411,
0.6786248087882996,
0.5922380685806274,
0.8898913860321045,
-0.15914757549762726,
0.9484707117080688,
-0.08505633473396301,
0.13563546538352966,
1.1531529426574707,
-0.28897374868392944,
0.40214917063713074,
0.16758015751838684,
-0.0408870168030262,
0.6654963493347168,
0.6293144226074219,
-0.3300066292285919,
0.6167652010917664,
0.10321708768606186,
-0.26955047249794006,
-0.621825098991394,
-0.22488851845264435,
-0.2496281862258911,
0.38786834478378296,
0.5531729459762573,
-0.304487019777298,
-0.45679810643196106,
-0.11682525277137756,
0.19041945040225983,
-0.23948664963245392,
-0.5068140029907227,
0.7749810218811035,
0.10094062983989716,
-0.5759833455085754,
0.47760406136512756,
-0.06612448394298553,
0.1425890177488327,
-0.6596642732620239,
-0.24100780487060547,
0.061495956033468246,
0.36357536911964417,
-0.13457541167736053,
-0.9186878800392151,
0.12004145979881287,
0.010231511667370796,
-0.0952669084072113,
-0.3018978238105774,
0.8391013741493225,
-0.33523911237716675,
-0.5437586903572083,
0.4880581498146057,
0.5321757793426514,
-0.13993550837039948,
0.3648258149623871,
-0.7549993991851807,
0.06647811084985733,
0.1289994865655899,
-0.25830668210983276,
0.2535739243030548,
1.0465213060379028,
-0.3005225360393524,
1.0005571842193604,
0.6486814022064209,
0.4545809030532837,
0.07241521030664444,
0.21398097276687622,
0.9342228174209595,
-0.752137303352356,
-0.5730092525482178,
-0.9413382411003113,
0.21695150434970856,
0.09862062335014343,
0.3393654525279999,
0.4668084979057312,
0.10663680732250214,
0.6351091265678406,
0.1876189112663269,
0.7883817553520203,
-0.00422846432775259,
0.4395526349544525,
-0.8174145221710205,
0.5958876013755798,
-0.7100659608840942,
0.36049649119377136,
-0.09842781722545624,
-0.745449423789978,
-0.2962190508842468,
0.2803057134151459,
-0.7278413772583008,
0.19122371077537537,
0.5957443714141846,
0.7142006754875183,
-0.2148674875497818,
-0.17899993062019348,
0.31404897570610046,
0.7956902384757996,
0.6415175795555115,
0.8879583477973938,
0.9111015200614929,
0.16489450633525848,
0.8247728943824768,
0.11839179694652557,
-0.19954916834831238,
-0.2051817774772644,
-1.4884309768676758,
-1.039325475692749,
-0.3013821244239807,
-0.5272452235221863,
-0.5099697709083557,
0.38493114709854126,
1.0032919645309448,
0.6073474884033203,
-0.6990600228309631,
0.10412618517875671,
0.1632583737373352,
0.2077648788690567,
-0.1518181413412094,
-0.23042398691177368,
0.6237697005271912,
-0.1171932965517044,
-0.5219459533691406,
0.47722452878952026,
0.24487599730491638,
0.16386757791042328,
0.10442502051591873,
-0.12499810010194778,
-0.1505579799413681,
-0.1994830220937729,
0.6230465173721313,
0.26533833146095276,
-0.686794102191925,
-0.6733348965644836,
-0.24885950982570648,
0.30227285623550415,
0.027605507522821426,
0.5916436910629272,
-0.715711236000061,
0.7141519784927368,
0.7339085340499878,
0.687381386756897,
0.9350276589393616,
-0.32101839780807495,
0.5382565855979919,
-0.45329058170318604,
0.07493851333856583,
0.20492447912693024,
0.2925325632095337,
0.1873282790184021,
-0.26027533411979675,
0.35543712973594666,
0.4216119050979614,
-0.6348114013671875,
-0.9113001823425293,
0.3437705636024475,
-1.097725510597229,
-0.5061097145080566,
1.5250602960586548,
-0.042410265654325485,
-0.33125364780426025,
-0.37134554982185364,
0.08110533654689789,
0.6233174800872803,
-0.3934641182422638,
1.0193028450012207,
0.8176929354667664,
-0.1416313797235489,
-0.5837572813034058,
-0.6579721570014954,
0.3315877616405487,
-0.09482965618371964,
-0.8382977843284607,
0.21461546421051025,
0.32423409819602966,
0.5416624546051025,
-0.23644842207431793,
0.27716565132141113,
-0.06551128625869751,
0.16607992351055145,
-0.12772402167320251,
-0.2220579981803894,
-0.5526462197303772,
-0.06093476340174675,
-0.12060801684856415,
0.1597440242767334,
0.12126482278108597,
0.16523581743240356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14161v1
|
Self-Taught Recognizer: Toward Unsupervised Adaptation for Speech Foundation Models
| 2024-05-23T04:27:11 | 2024-05-23T04:27:11 |
Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Chengwei Qin, Pin-Yu Chen, Eng Siong Chng, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We propose an unsupervised adaptation framework, Self-TAught Recognizer
(STAR), which leverages unlabeled data to enhance the robustness of automatic
speech recognition (ASR) systems in diverse target domains, such as noise and
accents. STAR is developed for prevalent speech foundation models based on
Transformer-related architecture with auto-regressive decoding (e.g., Whisper,
Canary). Specifically, we propose a novel indicator that empirically integrates
step-wise information during decoding to assess the token-level quality of
pseudo labels without ground truth, thereby guiding model updates for effective
unsupervised adaptation. Experimental results show that STAR achieves an
average of 13.5% relative reduction in word error rate across 14 target
domains, and it sometimes even approaches the upper-bound performance of
supervised adaptation. Surprisingly, we also observe that STAR prevents the
adapted model from the common catastrophic forgetting problem without recalling
source-domain data. Furthermore, STAR exhibits high data efficiency that only
requires less than one-hour unlabeled data, and seamless generality to
alternative large speech models and speech translation tasks. Our code aims to
open source to the research communities.
|
[
-0.004330533090978861,
-0.2013905942440033,
-0.05317045748233795,
0.16645130515098572,
-0.006591801531612873,
0.21172118186950684,
-0.1879982352256775,
-0.2771241068840027,
0.04039240628480911,
0.4709005355834961,
-0.21592140197753906,
-0.3380204439163208,
-0.6494418978691101,
-0.09996690601110458,
-0.7285127639770508,
0.7446503043174744,
0.3059600293636322,
0.07725388556718826,
-0.00018659901979845017,
-0.06487695127725601,
-0.35644978284835815,
-0.509618878364563,
-0.4153233468532562,
-0.28950411081314087,
-0.19388380646705627,
0.573047935962677,
0.23366184532642365,
0.6295233368873596,
0.31635618209838867,
0.32395175099372864,
0.2687569558620453,
-0.23291490972042084,
-0.3602479100227356,
-0.14185731112957,
-0.37361961603164673,
-0.1904306709766388,
-0.3610217273235321,
-0.16203898191452026,
0.6761681437492371,
0.9044816493988037,
-0.245081827044487,
0.2262800633907318,
0.3726450800895691,
0.8009361028671265,
-0.6804519891738892,
0.40367743372917175,
-0.6655024290084839,
-0.09846287220716476,
-0.11516771465539932,
0.046713512390851974,
-0.2648885250091553,
0.09337805211544037,
0.20168720185756683,
-0.549755871295929,
0.4534544348716736,
-0.28516530990600586,
0.10627033561468124,
0.5708337426185608,
-0.18695805966854095,
-0.3661174774169922,
-0.9897122383117676,
0.44630593061447144,
-0.40083086490631104,
0.9451501965522766,
0.3402797281742096,
0.4824889004230499,
-0.21120664477348328,
-0.7842463850975037,
-0.47529110312461853,
0.11664433032274246,
0.14730186760425568,
0.2521286606788635,
-0.8555912375450134,
-0.01889674924314022,
-0.22861336171627045,
0.5640121698379517,
-0.5675226449966431,
0.09666155278682709,
-0.33099159598350525,
-0.6056814789772034,
0.4470943212509155,
-0.31790459156036377,
-0.09760532528162003,
-0.04205384850502014,
-0.15498696267604828,
-0.2653803527355194,
-0.38001927733421326,
0.36694371700286865,
-0.07042725384235382,
0.4656737148761749,
-0.10902820527553558,
0.14654554426670074,
-0.3108440637588501,
0.47374483942985535,
0.435544490814209,
0.011384895071387291,
0.3043571412563324,
-0.05663880705833435,
-0.1805780529975891,
0.3284675180912018,
0.727992832660675,
0.12755149602890015,
0.2537865936756134,
-0.29222995042800903,
-0.4214558005332947,
0.3364907503128052,
-0.01178355049341917,
-0.6313631534576416,
-0.9497864842414856,
-0.18557359278202057,
-0.4077024757862091,
-0.06391666829586029,
-0.11626140773296356,
-0.7671888470649719,
-0.3461155891418457,
-0.14047929644584656,
0.7117874026298523,
-0.1278402954339981,
-0.30416613817214966,
0.30858394503593445,
0.08557220548391342,
0.015310133807361126,
0.14853543043136597,
-0.6762767434120178,
0.5663052201271057,
0.18379035592079163,
0.48740488290786743,
-0.22492918372154236,
-0.30756375193595886,
-0.6580731868743896,
0.0011139956768602133,
-0.33929336071014404,
0.7220008373260498,
-0.3395184874534607,
-0.6517395973205566,
-0.2802329361438751,
-0.04824334383010864,
-0.31974175572395325,
-0.5039770603179932,
0.5084078907966614,
-0.3101435899734497,
0.07960116863250732,
-0.15590792894363403,
-0.6457926630973816,
-0.1577456295490265,
-0.35762202739715576,
-0.39563682675361633,
0.9253025650978088,
0.14044509828090668,
-0.24148547649383545,
0.2440493106842041,
-0.8014695048332214,
-0.34129297733306885,
-0.011666655540466309,
-0.12811550498008728,
-0.35096463561058044,
0.27218538522720337,
0.4313848912715912,
0.4458634853363037,
-0.13629327714443207,
0.20691461861133575,
-0.12270689010620117,
-0.22866946458816528,
0.2675979435443878,
-0.5376023054122925,
0.5224539041519165,
0.29802727699279785,
-0.3587283790111542,
0.1345343291759491,
-1.0886942148208618,
-0.20313043892383575,
0.07964184880256653,
-0.2256016731262207,
-0.2361786663532257,
0.001281379023566842,
0.19223695993423462,
-0.04101947695016861,
0.0539134256541729,
-0.5969886183738708,
-0.05725976452231407,
-0.25721555948257446,
0.5109977126121521,
0.655605673789978,
-0.07251067459583282,
0.4668223559856415,
-0.059622641652822495,
0.185040682554245,
0.22718068957328796,
-0.00697174109518528,
-0.17669953405857086,
-0.09135149419307709,
-1.2586594820022583,
-0.29341328144073486,
0.5345771312713623,
0.36841991543769836,
-0.4640021324157715,
0.6810461282730103,
-0.19720208644866943,
-0.4620262086391449,
-0.5847601890563965,
0.31932559609413147,
0.6045840382575989,
0.7912960648536682,
0.7012168169021606,
-0.3721296191215515,
-0.6389048099517822,
-0.5175872445106506,
-0.25446420907974243,
-0.19820038974285126,
-0.04709303751587868,
0.05522098392248154,
0.4213447868824005,
-0.5143187642097473,
1.060201644897461,
-0.24238792061805725,
-0.6648086309432983,
-0.011913631111383438,
0.07694603502750397,
0.0295102596282959,
0.6569206714630127,
0.5240532755851746,
-0.5615228414535522,
-0.33977991342544556,
-0.23965011537075043,
-0.47806301712989807,
-0.020333483815193176,
-0.045218586921691895,
0.2441970705986023,
0.047951385378837585,
0.5275936126708984,
-0.11766139417886734,
0.47179606556892395,
0.6292234063148499,
-0.44608020782470703,
0.3462439775466919,
-0.28726717829704285,
0.025345345959067345,
-0.8768495917320251,
0.022677820175886154,
-0.11428050696849823,
-0.1642061322927475,
-0.9090826511383057,
-0.5492446422576904,
0.21757349371910095,
-0.3052498698234558,
-0.10318237543106079,
0.480018675327301,
-0.5883451104164124,
-0.4067688584327698,
-0.4310121536254883,
-0.2391490936279297,
-0.28909942507743835,
0.26708394289016724,
0.280769020318985,
1.084993839263916,
0.9676297307014465,
-0.8910430669784546,
-0.043937500566244125,
0.3441165089607239,
-0.21343353390693665,
0.4319888651371002,
-0.6181210279464722,
0.27942007780075073,
0.016922157257795334,
0.15887947380542755,
-0.9098222255706787,
-0.11747536063194275,
0.28053775429725647,
-0.6177696585655212,
0.4004126489162445,
-0.25071048736572266,
-0.002019151346758008,
-0.48030778765678406,
0.2483142763376236,
0.15808169543743134,
0.673649251461029,
-0.9564095735549927,
0.6728461384773254,
0.556450605392456,
0.043260782957077026,
-0.5428475141525269,
-0.48797687888145447,
0.07455216348171234,
0.026500120759010315,
-0.09472917765378952,
0.2934652864933014,
-0.1613868772983551,
0.21189941465854645,
0.03684794157743454,
-0.5470993518829346,
-0.2021571844816208,
0.09951237589120865,
0.27431920170783997,
-0.15997979044914246,
-0.45748016238212585,
0.033291637897491455,
-0.07701170444488525,
-0.31735020875930786,
0.143840029835701,
-0.6679350137710571,
0.013297426514327526,
-0.4602230489253998,
-0.36010023951530457,
-0.49040529131889343,
-0.007938574999570847,
0.5967888236045837,
-0.2924952507019043,
0.0721222534775734,
0.527045488357544,
-0.5121790766716003,
-0.3646976053714752,
-0.49466562271118164,
-0.24256420135498047,
-0.5305719971656799,
0.323180615901947,
-0.4953191578388214,
-0.8491893410682678,
0.5024178624153137,
-0.14833718538284302,
-0.24791628122329712,
0.4887279272079468,
0.27724963426589966,
-0.08876438438892365,
0.4200880825519562,
0.8612101078033447,
-0.4245223104953766,
0.25893792510032654,
-0.20693042874336243,
0.02976851351559162,
-0.6993135809898376,
-0.1085568219423294,
-0.43903636932373047,
-0.020653970539569855,
-0.21075917780399323,
-0.5582031607627869,
0.32637467980384827,
0.20991216599941254,
-0.006996395997703075,
0.4376921057701111,
-0.6917763948440552,
0.37011387944221497,
0.4451330900192261,
-0.03458196297287941,
0.19199398159980774,
-0.12777864933013916,
0.15482763946056366,
-0.06736375391483307,
-0.7998265624046326,
-0.09719099849462509,
1.2695825099945068,
0.37508606910705566,
0.8084098100662231,
-0.02914700098335743,
0.5071101188659668,
0.7456763982772827,
0.10500229895114899,
-0.6898070573806763,
0.26590999960899353,
-0.4240902066230774,
-0.3649221658706665,
-0.3086065948009491,
-0.3477381467819214,
-0.8226786851882935,
0.041557107120752335,
-0.23352466523647308,
-0.507483959197998,
0.6482006907463074,
0.5611268281936646,
-0.367313027381897,
0.16076552867889404,
-0.4672972857952118,
0.8405406475067139,
-0.2146001160144806,
0.2944073975086212,
-0.06883831322193146,
-0.46661868691444397,
0.03514983505010605,
-0.5411076545715332,
0.20877157151699066,
0.03472030535340309,
0.39756348729133606,
1.1477121114730835,
-0.04918742552399635,
1.0970091819763184,
-0.5907792448997498,
0.25831010937690735,
0.4733368158340454,
0.12638677656650543,
0.3769921064376831,
-0.3554363548755646,
0.07402805984020233,
0.4423014223575592,
0.06868135184049606,
-0.19263674318790436,
-0.6126607656478882,
0.4893141984939575,
-0.9963334798812866,
-0.40600502490997314,
-0.3843967616558075,
-0.4450203776359558,
-0.44599300622940063,
0.23501747846603394,
0.20496535301208496,
0.46924203634262085,
-0.5125073790550232,
0.3943381607532501,
0.671833872795105,
0.1672167032957077,
0.434355765581131,
0.9146589636802673,
-0.013490737415850163,
-0.5222520232200623,
1.1146348714828491,
0.09296491742134094,
0.03817958012223244,
0.2822524607181549,
0.49668049812316895,
-0.5961846709251404,
-0.8543936014175415,
-0.49839144945144653,
0.008405102416872978,
-0.9106401801109314,
-0.2870239019393921,
-0.7361878156661987,
-0.402321994304657,
-0.670596182346344,
-0.12436895072460175,
-0.8826976418495178,
-0.47175315022468567,
-0.5620682835578918,
0.03329538181424141,
0.45705682039260864,
0.7055205702781677,
-0.4916059970855713,
0.6087525486946106,
-0.514158308506012,
0.2286740392446518,
0.43684741854667664,
0.2356564849615097,
-0.2793620228767395,
-1.078925609588623,
-0.17887313663959503,
-0.04032817855477333,
0.12085442245006561,
-0.6075042486190796,
0.3996976912021637,
0.7797970175743103,
0.7950204014778137,
0.5301966071128845,
0.4004516005516052,
0.6118009686470032,
-0.4130849838256836,
0.41108614206314087,
0.28358596563339233,
-1.200514793395996,
0.5332972407341003,
-0.11374034732580185,
0.13937349617481232,
0.4839431345462799,
0.20393283665180206,
-0.32474660873413086,
-0.037017665803432465,
-0.4024827480316162,
-0.2216828167438507,
0.4353407919406891,
0.05526913329958916,
0.08771573007106781,
0.18902446329593658,
0.31615108251571655,
0.17778104543685913,
-0.03928757831454277,
-0.4647234380245209,
-0.43593737483024597,
-0.9958323240280151,
-0.21950216591358185,
-0.6054483652114868,
-0.25612056255340576,
-0.0056982808746397495,
-0.33393099904060364,
0.5860044360160828,
-0.38641953468322754,
0.3696309030056,
0.26077890396118164,
-0.5334450006484985,
-0.10890668630599976,
0.3307119905948639,
0.38072386384010315,
0.2795005738735199,
-0.13090559840202332,
0.28687840700149536,
0.19402165710926056,
-0.6483992338180542,
0.2046678364276886,
0.3715272843837738,
-0.06809469312429428,
-0.11775447428226471,
0.2145497053861618,
0.728909432888031,
0.6409437656402588,
-0.20378103852272034,
0.5896148085594177,
-0.014407656155526638,
-0.1004657968878746,
-0.3452439606189728,
0.2638856768608093,
-0.16256947815418243,
0.29279306530952454,
0.5914239287376404,
0.33990269899368286,
0.32287073135375977,
-0.2591852843761444,
0.5828452110290527,
0.25585439801216125,
-0.6679744720458984,
-0.5935159921646118,
0.7509998083114624,
0.4751772880554199,
-0.3350728154182434,
0.36583107709884644,
-0.07712803035974503,
-0.5650019645690918,
0.23752591013908386,
0.8837934136390686,
0.9431818127632141,
-0.7213103771209717,
-0.007786183152347803,
0.2829057276248932,
0.12398711591959,
-0.1164894625544548,
-0.021405385807156563,
-0.30380937457084656,
-0.955095648765564,
0.031957365572452545,
-0.7135697603225708,
-0.23186878859996796,
0.22839239239692688,
-0.7823600769042969,
0.04396027326583862,
-0.4469398856163025,
0.1090235710144043,
0.0701151043176651,
-0.28039810061454773,
-0.5567188262939453,
0.4109049439430237,
0.030768677592277527,
0.7623830437660217,
-1.0505259037017822,
1.119935154914856,
0.5380771160125732,
0.01597667671740055,
-0.5772116184234619,
-0.06461875140666962,
0.23723821341991425,
-0.886444628238678,
0.41039127111434937,
0.06288664788007736,
-0.5794699788093567,
0.4759243428707123,
0.030578453093767166,
-1.084104061126709,
1.007326364517212,
0.2994629442691803,
-0.6348167061805725,
0.2563246190547943,
0.07140248268842697,
0.4727349877357483,
-0.5711014866828918,
-0.15104132890701294,
0.6315761804580688,
-0.014565967954695225,
0.24167941510677338,
-1.1131316423416138,
-0.22029495239257812,
-0.196395605802536,
-0.18629400432109833,
-0.1394357830286026,
-0.2614021599292755,
0.40648001432418823,
-0.3214062452316284,
-0.15641315281391144,
-0.13957343995571136,
1.0791102647781372,
-0.13920336961746216,
0.37356218695640564,
0.6446307897567749,
0.16655616462230682,
0.873711347579956,
0.15259906649589539,
0.4350633919239044,
-0.44530850648880005,
0.29271039366722107,
1.0448026657104492,
0.06681016087532043,
0.7655661702156067,
0.17065207660198212,
-0.1884864866733551,
0.2977105975151062,
0.327844500541687,
-0.07185427099466324,
0.7596679329872131,
-0.17775924503803253,
-0.11305463314056396,
-0.3687262237071991,
0.07192113995552063,
-0.4804024398326874,
0.9552916288375854,
0.48990732431411743,
-0.3150199055671692,
-0.1954444795846939,
0.22044327855110168,
-0.33683136105537415,
0.17318813502788544,
-0.4378368556499481,
0.7138569951057434,
0.1253633052110672,
-0.144418403506279,
0.6875247955322266,
-0.24790234863758087,
0.6493639945983887,
-0.4666827321052551,
0.18765795230865479,
-0.09259607642889023,
0.5535522103309631,
-0.14634981751441956,
-0.5551707148551941,
0.31286290287971497,
-0.02573714591562748,
-0.4497709274291992,
-0.13480958342552185,
0.9834599494934082,
-0.40334105491638184,
-0.6141009330749512,
0.3470309376716614,
0.4926377236843109,
0.29323944449424744,
-0.13451893627643585,
-0.8564407825469971,
0.2024463564157486,
-0.02188916876912117,
-0.0015082694590091705,
0.21649247407913208,
0.20086543262004852,
0.035536929965019226,
0.7230550050735474,
0.8508041501045227,
-0.19441697001457214,
0.023338083177804947,
0.05903499573469162,
0.8423123955726624,
-0.4614710509777069,
-0.5984197854995728,
-0.31092119216918945,
0.3518507778644562,
0.35976889729499817,
-0.20845365524291992,
0.7828428149223328,
0.5380862355232239,
0.8331528306007385,
-0.2395332306623459,
0.6991511583328247,
0.2524460256099701,
0.6625673770904541,
-0.38165581226348877,
0.9452434778213501,
-0.27788591384887695,
0.25293436646461487,
-0.31854408979415894,
-0.6061804890632629,
-0.25356075167655945,
0.7903518080711365,
-0.17517153918743134,
0.006724012549966574,
0.31464582681655884,
0.8206942677497864,
-0.28315645456314087,
0.019561195746064186,
0.5724706649780273,
0.1228196769952774,
0.13066214323043823,
0.40828412771224976,
0.6750953793525696,
-0.6205119490623474,
0.5624973177909851,
-0.32281365990638733,
-0.4628911316394806,
-0.06293308734893799,
-0.6322838068008423,
-1.0214745998382568,
-0.8188462257385254,
-0.6802711486816406,
-0.14196635782718658,
0.20409102737903595,
0.8022894263267517,
0.9209002256393433,
-1.174656629562378,
-0.33771806955337524,
-0.1793203502893448,
-0.30109792947769165,
-0.255342036485672,
-0.13366159796714783,
0.5725435018539429,
-0.012458889745175838,
-0.3520640730857849,
1.0676467418670654,
0.12989500164985657,
0.23100997507572174,
-0.0548105351626873,
-0.36232367157936096,
0.40060925483703613,
-0.026183106005191803,
0.3189747631549835,
0.8187263607978821,
-0.7324017286300659,
-0.36381039023399353,
0.025005612522363663,
0.24397851526737213,
0.1563216596841812,
0.6442266702651978,
-0.9093809723854065,
0.8398851752281189,
-0.10005278140306473,
0.7858816385269165,
0.46621644496917725,
-0.018495582044124603,
0.35176903009414673,
-0.45936182141304016,
-0.02129376120865345,
0.0986306369304657,
0.3077597916126251,
0.5559024810791016,
-0.3843684494495392,
0.24878434836864471,
0.520212709903717,
-0.5016446709632874,
-0.8175698518753052,
0.09313066303730011,
-0.7939297556877136,
-0.07093345373868942,
0.9412822127342224,
-0.19018450379371643,
-0.08407074958086014,
-0.29126718640327454,
0.28475549817085266,
0.27866849303245544,
-0.43665003776550293,
0.820939302444458,
0.19904734194278717,
-0.3481118381023407,
-0.3540266752243042,
0.020099401473999023,
0.6707516312599182,
0.16291502118110657,
-0.5944782495498657,
0.39015644788742065,
0.5747819542884827,
0.7758380174636841,
0.12367167323827744,
0.8742124438285828,
0.11162977665662766,
0.4892984926700592,
0.16117875277996063,
0.27127113938331604,
-0.34157928824424744,
-0.6852768659591675,
-0.8151814937591553,
-0.16662104427814484,
0.06844055652618408,
-0.41313597559928894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14159v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14159v2
|
Super Tiny Language Models
| 2024-05-23T04:12:49 | 2024-06-26T08:41:06 |
Dylan Hillier, Leon Guertler, Cheston Tan, Palaash Agrawal, Chen Ruirui, Bobby Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has led to significant
improvements in natural language processing but also poses challenges due to
their high computational and energy demands. This paper introduces a series of
research efforts focused on Super Tiny Language Models (STLMs), which aim to
deliver high performance with significantly reduced parameter counts. We
explore innovative techniques such as byte-level tokenization with a pooling
mechanism, weight tying, and efficient training strategies. These methods aim
to significantly reduce reduce the parameter count compared to traditional
models -- in future works, we aim to build on these in a way that maintains and
improves upon the performance of base transformer models. This series of papers
will explore into various subproblems, including tokenizer-free models,
self-play based training, and alternative training objectives. We will target
models with 10M, 50M, and 100M parameters. Our ultimate goal is to make
high-performance language models more accessible and practical for a wide range
of applications.
|
[
-0.43021637201309204,
-0.49726104736328125,
0.2983378469944,
-0.06699894368648529,
-0.34761232137680054,
0.0240411888808012,
-0.2240077704191208,
-0.4696611762046814,
0.14683350920677185,
0.6491260528564453,
-0.38201504945755005,
-0.03312161937355995,
-0.5724689960479736,
-0.013826936483383179,
-0.45118412375450134,
0.8682437539100647,
0.3691856563091278,
0.24152547121047974,
-0.029953422024846077,
-0.20738904178142548,
-0.22026650607585907,
-0.7374038696289062,
-0.8197119832038879,
-0.17911869287490845,
0.49740102887153625,
0.5647688508033752,
0.8864148855209351,
0.9479684233665466,
0.6083602905273438,
0.21383999288082123,
-0.5500608682632446,
-0.05410223826766014,
-0.5286138653755188,
-0.041314348578453064,
0.017177648842334747,
-0.5918720960617065,
-0.38262325525283813,
-0.23748956620693207,
0.8737713694572449,
0.7034286260604858,
-0.05960430949926376,
0.4853414297103882,
-0.12407182157039642,
0.40714237093925476,
-0.11848723888397217,
0.10383661091327667,
-0.5660997629165649,
-0.08924578875303268,
-0.3257151246070862,
0.24339410662651062,
-0.6219979524612427,
-0.1363585740327835,
-0.20838478207588196,
-0.1113518550992012,
0.5378015041351318,
0.387652188539505,
0.7120224237442017,
0.1085423082113266,
-0.26088112592697144,
-0.06206510588526726,
-0.9122464060783386,
0.9879105687141418,
-1.1433990001678467,
0.5997080206871033,
0.16475741565227509,
0.14716985821723938,
-0.06383208930492401,
-0.7540181279182434,
-0.5011996626853943,
-0.3509473204612732,
-0.2789539694786072,
-0.43459513783454895,
-0.24974499642848969,
0.06171836331486702,
0.26889297366142273,
0.3335844874382019,
-0.4929170310497284,
0.3670915365219116,
-0.2830175459384918,
-0.0025903021451085806,
0.6412684917449951,
0.5278049111366272,
0.11263123899698257,
-0.16067375242710114,
0.07164780795574188,
0.2953784763813019,
-0.9174919724464417,
-0.20058570802211761,
0.1329398900270462,
0.6443319320678711,
-0.1525546908378601,
0.37414711713790894,
0.044354889541864395,
0.5769730806350708,
-0.1419186294078827,
-0.09247264266014099,
-0.39373618364334106,
-0.6937501430511475,
-0.24425068497657776,
-0.39340847730636597,
0.7187924981117249,
-0.10363117605447769,
0.08724120259284973,
-0.2611905336380005,
-0.2407645434141159,
-0.134805828332901,
-0.07403410971164703,
-0.8788353800773621,
-0.22113803029060364,
-0.13897041976451874,
-0.7939790487289429,
-0.3829677402973175,
-0.4240332245826721,
-0.4413549602031708,
-0.3449627161026001,
-0.474357008934021,
0.19985665380954742,
-0.5374892950057983,
-0.2913057208061218,
-0.05977890267968178,
0.10595576465129852,
0.15667128562927246,
0.1345742791891098,
-1.367229700088501,
0.5951361060142517,
0.6324109435081482,
0.7718198299407959,
-0.060409948229789734,
-0.1047467291355133,
-0.3314279019832611,
0.12161259353160858,
-0.45575541257858276,
0.5823740363121033,
-0.7930182218551636,
-0.579156756401062,
-0.2589333653450012,
-0.1721433699131012,
-0.21651417016983032,
-0.6122825145721436,
0.41253355145454407,
-0.553061842918396,
0.05901053920388222,
-0.04571877047419548,
-0.6181487441062927,
0.19851264357566833,
-0.16976298391819,
-0.6641813516616821,
1.304985761642456,
0.09463532269001007,
-0.5459355115890503,
-0.0042108818888664246,
-0.6279930472373962,
-0.4763341546058655,
0.19337716698646545,
0.06680050492286682,
-0.1653677523136139,
0.8257271647453308,
-0.08664824068546295,
0.39242202043533325,
-0.5736552476882935,
0.11803556233644485,
0.13836047053337097,
-0.5431543588638306,
-0.06473230570554733,
-0.3912988007068634,
0.5193747878074646,
0.214243084192276,
-0.016483964398503304,
0.425080806016922,
-0.7532691359519958,
-0.13115788996219635,
0.32205745577812195,
-0.41548046469688416,
-0.3822372853755951,
-0.1231766864657402,
0.17599564790725708,
0.2656530737876892,
0.18255415558815002,
-0.42709797620773315,
0.311702698469162,
-0.6390933990478516,
0.6658333539962769,
0.47790685296058655,
-0.2108772099018097,
0.5779072046279907,
0.022207049652934074,
0.3620494604110718,
-0.1344260424375534,
0.46877896785736084,
-0.21514581143856049,
-0.4107893407344818,
-1.1806696653366089,
-0.3482431173324585,
0.7658306956291199,
0.09910331666469574,
-0.7079344987869263,
0.3291475176811218,
-0.4227089285850525,
-0.7234119176864624,
-0.7226895093917847,
0.22753821313381195,
0.41388019919395447,
0.18388043344020844,
0.32210487127304077,
0.07581514120101929,
-0.6757884621620178,
-0.9303265810012817,
-0.3108755946159363,
-0.1692747175693512,
-0.13355067372322083,
0.17008158564567566,
0.5740729570388794,
-0.1603500097990036,
1.0755212306976318,
-0.1892242282629013,
-0.06345118582248688,
-0.9046008586883545,
0.05555076152086258,
0.15023867785930634,
0.524716317653656,
0.5254496932029724,
-0.700775146484375,
-0.4914969801902771,
-0.12076812237501144,
-0.3114834427833557,
0.1884208470582962,
0.2555387318134308,
0.36034801602363586,
0.3508712947368622,
0.6633151173591614,
-0.8604792356491089,
0.2793249487876892,
0.5335774421691895,
-0.16911138594150543,
0.6216670274734497,
-0.3024781048297882,
-0.406715452671051,
-0.7940674424171448,
-0.12528929114341736,
-0.08237139880657196,
-0.31089988350868225,
-1.053339958190918,
0.36368852853775024,
0.06045875325798988,
-0.11533299088478088,
-0.8111399412155151,
0.72543865442276,
-0.4724861979484558,
0.013744796626269817,
-0.37783586978912354,
-0.1060175746679306,
-0.2179601490497589,
0.40405505895614624,
0.002013817895203829,
0.7695713043212891,
0.47758573293685913,
-0.6159273982048035,
0.23557955026626587,
-0.12527917325496674,
-0.013962185010313988,
0.06297464668750763,
-0.7935556769371033,
0.10698331147432327,
-0.12490011751651764,
0.1758105605840683,
-0.976226806640625,
0.02309507131576538,
-0.17991985380649567,
-0.19699762761592865,
0.4934048652648926,
-0.260428249835968,
-0.8852319121360779,
-0.5697728395462036,
-0.36496683955192566,
0.26949694752693176,
0.6166406869888306,
-0.36430099606513977,
0.5553419589996338,
0.4898037910461426,
-0.38709309697151184,
0.04569796845316887,
-0.6959809064865112,
0.2506372630596161,
-0.32548806071281433,
-0.38022616505622864,
0.1668311506509781,
-0.1538466066122055,
0.02789432927966118,
-0.07781265676021576,
-0.015012568794190884,
0.22217434644699097,
0.02036793902516365,
-0.04108496755361557,
0.3752899169921875,
-0.459907203912735,
0.268520325422287,
-0.22018025815486908,
-0.42021146416664124,
-0.3465038537979126,
-0.37427666783332825,
0.6999072432518005,
-0.5224087238311768,
-0.0019214451313018799,
-0.33501264452934265,
0.4085541069507599,
0.5428182482719421,
-0.06187235563993454,
1.102345585823059,
0.4842168390750885,
-0.5564045310020447,
-0.047728199511766434,
-0.6003820300102234,
-0.23122788965702057,
-0.4854987859725952,
0.3196302652359009,
-0.47431519627571106,
-1.3308976888656616,
0.5305187702178955,
0.1499607264995575,
0.10485415160655975,
0.3712431490421295,
0.6426233649253845,
-0.024633733555674553,
1.2527769804000854,
1.0112611055374146,
-0.017847366631031036,
0.6255582571029663,
-0.23757439851760864,
0.46973344683647156,
-0.7273440957069397,
0.10918782651424408,
-0.656314492225647,
-0.13476639986038208,
-0.4369150996208191,
-0.7304807305335999,
-0.033004771918058395,
0.30060631036758423,
-0.2512137293815613,
0.6758235692977905,
-0.357474148273468,
0.6680141091346741,
0.5590643882751465,
-0.46128877997398376,
0.3215504288673401,
-0.20700742304325104,
-0.3828178644180298,
-0.29088759422302246,
-1.1114904880523682,
-0.7822617292404175,
0.8338152766227722,
0.6223005652427673,
0.7803245186805725,
0.01375157106667757,
0.4568966031074524,
0.2264975905418396,
0.496724396944046,
-0.8558928370475769,
0.8766101598739624,
-0.5029486417770386,
-0.6415339708328247,
-0.6319619417190552,
-0.5091114044189453,
-0.6745662689208984,
0.5107787847518921,
-0.03591495752334595,
-0.7887656688690186,
-0.1387331634759903,
0.21853294968605042,
-0.49059709906578064,
0.5002564191818237,
-0.71095210313797,
0.8525925278663635,
-0.12369371950626373,
-0.1759723275899887,
-0.10361137986183167,
-0.6689983010292053,
0.29365575313568115,
-0.014828024432063103,
0.2979426980018616,
-0.022948233410716057,
-0.1776820570230484,
0.8363527059555054,
-0.5921154618263245,
0.7686182856559753,
-0.1649036407470703,
-0.09677387773990631,
0.2921817898750305,
0.21561792492866516,
0.8071777820587158,
-0.22367683053016663,
-0.16254517436027527,
0.35282638669013977,
0.03247538581490517,
-0.4006742835044861,
-0.3758646249771118,
0.6692569255828857,
-0.5021111369132996,
-0.5241420865058899,
0.07899363338947296,
-0.629468560218811,
-0.27014797925949097,
0.3731740713119507,
0.2614017128944397,
0.3267083168029785,
-0.005717940162867308,
0.4455086290836334,
0.7448489665985107,
0.04854432865977287,
0.7986558079719543,
0.6206948161125183,
-0.31550800800323486,
-0.1255026012659073,
1.1181674003601074,
0.5093508362770081,
0.21760541200637817,
0.281834214925766,
0.3722624182701111,
-0.47578880190849304,
-0.9546518921852112,
-0.5286751389503479,
0.5728028416633606,
-0.36777475476264954,
-0.127147376537323,
-0.5901083946228027,
-0.32552677392959595,
-0.7168614864349365,
0.08121303468942642,
-0.6930919289588928,
-0.624925971031189,
-0.31655022501945496,
-0.2598396837711334,
0.09440385550260544,
0.7880815267562866,
0.08360837399959564,
0.7808995842933655,
-0.9984184503555298,
0.27169156074523926,
0.3335830867290497,
0.47544533014297485,
0.21009856462478638,
-0.8143619894981384,
-0.6761518120765686,
-0.3426448404788971,
0.04595470800995827,
-0.3210577666759491,
0.43507063388824463,
0.09530795365571976,
0.526424765586853,
0.18206317722797394,
-0.12410732358694077,
0.6332860589027405,
-0.774842381477356,
0.9655300974845886,
0.3079354465007782,
-1.033710241317749,
0.47371041774749756,
-0.24281080067157745,
0.06264110654592514,
0.3238826394081116,
0.09791673719882965,
-0.577738344669342,
-0.4413914978504181,
-0.9174730777740479,
-0.8434754014015198,
0.7919331192970276,
0.19171136617660522,
0.3662484586238861,
0.1164490357041359,
0.19412364065647125,
0.10125009715557098,
0.260532021522522,
-0.5354524850845337,
-0.3961184322834015,
0.1689814180135727,
-0.45264312624931335,
-0.09111828356981277,
-0.59317547082901,
0.11902250349521637,
-0.3154299557209015,
0.7290340065956116,
-0.2601245641708374,
0.13689295947551727,
-0.34972456097602844,
-0.14556115865707397,
-0.21650391817092896,
0.32674136757850647,
0.7121614217758179,
0.2844002842903137,
0.06588519364595413,
0.29300639033317566,
0.6001847386360168,
-0.4009884297847748,
0.3028688430786133,
-0.263114333152771,
-0.2636326551437378,
0.10170532763004303,
0.357349693775177,
0.8773976564407349,
0.601590633392334,
-0.6241827607154846,
0.39772382378578186,
-0.21866782009601593,
0.09783507138490677,
0.10030379891395569,
0.20389717817306519,
0.5310030579566956,
0.029875967651605606,
0.28426817059516907,
0.10613474249839783,
-0.09000305831432343,
-0.28288760781288147,
0.08023349940776825,
0.33587646484375,
-0.5832319855690002,
-0.44443559646606445,
0.63788902759552,
0.22682738304138184,
-0.6493179798126221,
0.1831662952899933,
-0.12130791693925858,
-0.17020069062709808,
0.5008622407913208,
0.7243666052818298,
0.4757941663265228,
-0.2893999516963959,
0.05093910172581673,
-0.14006073772907257,
0.5910180807113647,
-0.3047747313976288,
0.037268660962581635,
0.056465473026037216,
-0.5455165505409241,
-0.309465229511261,
-0.8156377077102661,
-0.45503759384155273,
0.34101611375808716,
-0.43547359108924866,
0.19220934808254242,
-0.5167518854141235,
-0.21145306527614594,
-0.07685552537441254,
0.16701176762580872,
-0.5976610779762268,
0.23747707903385162,
0.26804596185684204,
1.2703323364257812,
-0.7394187450408936,
1.1025713682174683,
0.5847553014755249,
-0.25884974002838135,
-0.7987188696861267,
-0.2694733738899231,
-0.22829341888427734,
-0.5620471835136414,
0.6505902409553528,
-0.07191181182861328,
-0.1472368985414505,
0.35968273878097534,
-0.5648511648178101,
-1.1258372068405151,
0.7369012832641602,
0.5472118854522705,
-0.5268331170082092,
-0.35018545389175415,
0.3414827883243561,
0.7951024174690247,
-0.42592519521713257,
0.3084490895271301,
0.9903364181518555,
0.3196171522140503,
0.11210763454437256,
-0.8785640001296997,
-0.04347634315490723,
-0.13489069044589996,
0.6944898962974548,
0.1351974606513977,
-1.0560269355773926,
0.9663398265838623,
-0.11752218753099442,
-0.28810831904411316,
0.30777424573898315,
0.8090065717697144,
0.3519428074359894,
-0.058783646672964096,
0.37551867961883545,
0.47439879179000854,
0.5533018708229065,
-0.028051862493157387,
0.8117840886116028,
-0.3929498493671417,
0.5140479207038879,
0.9773701429367065,
-0.34839028120040894,
1.0126514434814453,
0.6272660493850708,
-0.31598901748657227,
0.2526298761367798,
0.4023542106151581,
0.16046255826950073,
0.20353975892066956,
0.36017367243766785,
-0.07148223370313644,
-0.3331342339515686,
-0.3524559736251831,
-0.2768365144729614,
0.1458354890346527,
0.48008885979652405,
-0.22810833156108856,
-0.018774596974253654,
0.14446978271007538,
-0.01697656698524952,
-0.17776887118816376,
-0.49062347412109375,
0.6237591505050659,
0.1755484789609909,
-0.1101626306772232,
0.3925667405128479,
0.3348129987716675,
0.9027658104896545,
-0.6476119756698608,
0.3225727081298828,
-0.5278563499450684,
0.1168794110417366,
-0.020153146237134933,
-0.2498592585325241,
0.36007362604141235,
0.2910999059677124,
-0.31339699029922485,
-0.34125521779060364,
1.1206510066986084,
-0.18224027752876282,
-0.7680469751358032,
0.25188469886779785,
0.5216925144195557,
0.21167579293251038,
0.21956801414489746,
-0.5495482087135315,
0.18965886533260345,
-0.29769188165664673,
-0.5095707178115845,
0.4310501515865326,
0.408359169960022,
-0.09566977620124817,
0.7911891937255859,
0.6404006481170654,
0.4439837336540222,
0.36105090379714966,
0.2773189842700958,
0.8112897872924805,
-1.0329527854919434,
-0.6288073658943176,
-0.8331776857376099,
0.3548940420150757,
0.07715467363595963,
-0.03152851387858391,
0.8632761836051941,
0.678952157497406,
0.6005195379257202,
-0.31105202436447144,
0.7457970976829529,
0.1254979372024536,
0.768219530582428,
-0.313359797000885,
0.6670960783958435,
-0.3547167479991913,
0.3573485016822815,
0.09297852963209152,
-0.6392652988433838,
-0.5941575169563293,
0.32049810886383057,
-0.22871963679790497,
0.03201032057404518,
0.3916730582714081,
0.8573427200317383,
0.0093668382614851,
0.14124974608421326,
0.7124057412147522,
0.22164180874824524,
0.4056791663169861,
0.4639582633972168,
0.9140475988388062,
-0.6841755509376526,
0.8293368220329285,
-0.10666767507791519,
0.050816621631383896,
-0.7451937794685364,
-0.7093887329101562,
-0.8549743890762329,
-0.0908326730132103,
-0.17081333696842194,
0.13396501541137695,
-0.20774205029010773,
0.7650260329246521,
1.0904399156570435,
-1.080374836921692,
-0.30186134576797485,
-0.15633000433444977,
0.29623672366142273,
-0.06047821044921875,
-0.25492435693740845,
0.2050601691007614,
-0.27618521451950073,
-0.6885481476783752,
0.5600462555885315,
0.4908798635005951,
0.3190062642097473,
-0.45843127369880676,
-0.16443568468093872,
-0.05830790475010872,
0.5419501066207886,
0.7260376811027527,
0.23254308104515076,
-0.7045962810516357,
-0.4109092950820923,
0.07452291995286942,
-0.4332580864429474,
-0.15694019198417664,
1.0397382974624634,
-0.7724619507789612,
-0.20631186664104462,
0.4732804596424103,
0.3727642297744751,
0.3264518976211548,
-0.1056111603975296,
0.19555653631687164,
-0.9775890707969666,
0.13318632543087006,
0.28597742319107056,
0.36195722222328186,
0.3397006690502167,
-0.1336755007505417,
0.5190402269363403,
0.44991010427474976,
-0.2604549527168274,
-1.1456879377365112,
0.26398181915283203,
-0.38368552923202515,
-0.24920453131198883,
0.8834631443023682,
0.07308410853147507,
-0.15344519913196564,
-0.15403567254543304,
-0.24580118060112,
0.29066798090934753,
-0.034944020211696625,
0.3923855423927307,
0.6296554207801819,
-0.44485825300216675,
-0.420897513628006,
-0.4449005424976349,
0.3895564675331116,
0.521304726600647,
-0.5693231821060181,
0.49381667375564575,
0.1686912626028061,
0.1883213371038437,
0.27646854519844055,
0.7235251665115356,
0.030758989974856377,
-0.19103248417377472,
0.299043744802475,
-0.04971475154161453,
-0.126159206032753,
-0.7429705262184143,
-0.5442344546318054,
0.4537079930305481,
0.13954542577266693,
0.007752244360744953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14150v1
|
jp-evalb: Robust Alignment-based PARSEVAL Measures
| 2024-05-23T03:54:25 | 2024-05-23T03:54:25 |
Jungyeul Park, Junrui Wang, Eunkyul Leah Jo, Angela Yoonseo Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce an evaluation system designed to compute PARSEVAL measures,
offering a viable alternative to \texttt{evalb} commonly used for constituency
parsing evaluation. The widely used \texttt{evalb} script has traditionally
been employed for evaluating the accuracy of constituency parsing results,
albeit with the requirement for consistent tokenization and sentence
boundaries. In contrast, our approach, named \texttt{jp-evalb}, is founded on
an alignment method. This method aligns sentences and words when discrepancies
arise. It aims to overcome several known issues associated with \texttt{evalb}
by utilizing the `jointly preprocessed (JP)' alignment-based method. We
introduce a more flexible and adaptive framework, ultimately contributing to a
more accurate assessment of constituency parsing performance.
|
[
-0.26434585452079773,
-0.8120133876800537,
0.5874961614608765,
0.24437226355075836,
-0.17989519238471985,
0.4297446310520172,
-0.07393723726272583,
0.05637136101722717,
0.5644491314888,
0.3578375577926636,
-0.21871908009052277,
-0.3250651955604553,
-0.39495331048965454,
0.1565939486026764,
-0.37756800651550293,
0.5979421138763428,
0.012301269918680191,
0.5310991406440735,
-0.3273138999938965,
-0.41839250922203064,
-0.26877596974372864,
-0.16140657663345337,
-0.2715483605861664,
-0.1248435229063034,
0.38632744550704956,
0.3559613823890686,
0.6864007711410522,
0.7909949421882629,
0.826328694820404,
0.3948151171207428,
0.023551659658551216,
-0.07318858802318573,
-0.26573115587234497,
0.2367234081029892,
-0.3686267137527466,
-0.4965852200984955,
-0.7228872776031494,
-0.18136480450630188,
0.9513581395149231,
0.8653695583343506,
-0.47352439165115356,
0.1736132949590683,
0.16783922910690308,
0.7719549536705017,
-1.0453671216964722,
-0.12219085544347763,
-0.6542364954948425,
-0.04591149836778641,
-0.45750921964645386,
-0.4038059115409851,
-0.5459703207015991,
-0.5334280729293823,
-0.41039764881134033,
-0.23532786965370178,
-0.0830390527844429,
0.3870146572589874,
1.1501317024230957,
0.13946013152599335,
-0.16805975139141083,
-0.03306535631418228,
-0.03295197710394859,
0.7086601853370667,
-0.5681988000869751,
0.6341672539710999,
0.19518838822841644,
0.46508756279945374,
-0.09864147007465363,
-0.6787201762199402,
-0.29749032855033875,
-0.16338001191616058,
-0.26013311743736267,
0.19653992354869843,
0.07574231177568436,
0.32272255420684814,
0.06022121012210846,
0.4131075441837311,
-0.8047533631324768,
0.0016348600620403886,
0.19165144860744476,
-0.1673351675271988,
0.3408268392086029,
0.4435180723667145,
0.3268687129020691,
-0.558813750743866,
-0.9417482018470764,
-0.1906212419271469,
-0.5271949768066406,
0.222684845328331,
0.6037582755088806,
0.39747029542922974,
0.09054377675056458,
0.6752110123634338,
-0.1160738542675972,
0.8435237407684326,
0.265838086605072,
0.04891453683376312,
0.07033757120370865,
-0.5725981593132019,
-0.40426763892173767,
0.33823278546333313,
0.9502694010734558,
0.28105077147483826,
-0.1781013458967209,
0.16403065621852875,
-0.4773408770561218,
0.21399684250354767,
0.43451106548309326,
-0.5064013004302979,
-0.2765601575374603,
-0.09930269420146942,
-0.5668847560882568,
-0.26946336030960083,
0.3204047679901123,
-1.2763280868530273,
-0.25628334283828735,
-0.4367060661315918,
0.5079984068870544,
-0.517560601234436,
-0.14205360412597656,
-0.20180872082710266,
-0.12640561163425446,
0.3191426992416382,
0.23412899672985077,
-0.8476465940475464,
0.38862156867980957,
1.0569761991500854,
0.6185126900672913,
0.020953895524144173,
-0.42502325773239136,
-0.9542452692985535,
-0.26463499665260315,
-0.34488752484321594,
1.0064082145690918,
-1.1391892433166504,
-0.2187766581773758,
-0.28452232480049133,
-0.1273520141839981,
-0.4182758033275604,
-0.4019886553287506,
0.5216585993766785,
-0.29468777775764465,
0.3758733570575714,
-0.5934375524520874,
-0.8789383172988892,
0.36018380522727966,
0.3603599965572357,
-0.32603150606155396,
0.8011701703071594,
0.7993115186691284,
-0.7514503598213196,
0.6469737887382507,
-0.6368964910507202,
-0.1301129162311554,
0.28774169087409973,
-0.13718126714229584,
-0.5346935987472534,
0.26557207107543945,
0.3908126950263977,
0.09463272988796234,
0.016381023451685905,
0.5812801122665405,
-0.4762348532676697,
-0.5965010523796082,
0.08601295202970505,
-0.5895081162452698,
0.9450603127479553,
0.39328533411026,
-0.33858272433280945,
0.2548810839653015,
-0.8074496984481812,
0.5241451859474182,
-0.11692764610052109,
-0.1652950495481491,
-0.5432447791099548,
-0.0399988628923893,
-0.09747400134801865,
-0.49460911750793457,
0.27238374948501587,
-0.4564134478569031,
0.13507388532161713,
-0.4834215044975281,
-0.19159862399101257,
0.85445237159729,
-0.17934398353099823,
0.43390917778015137,
-0.11768513917922974,
0.9181502461433411,
-0.27994459867477417,
0.06934899091720581,
-0.5062832236289978,
-0.13007700443267822,
-0.6108129024505615,
-0.45589157938957214,
0.9357958436012268,
0.5047486424446106,
-0.48839500546455383,
1.1697964668273926,
-0.3981797993183136,
-0.559924840927124,
-0.731413722038269,
-0.1597379446029663,
0.605448842048645,
0.7818230390548706,
0.3659839332103729,
-0.46643972396850586,
-0.587909996509552,
-1.030826449394226,
-0.7297760248184204,
-0.5889105796813965,
0.2696177363395691,
-0.23841707408428192,
0.08264272660017014,
0.13371267914772034,
0.8959944844245911,
-0.19153067469596863,
0.1898832470178604,
-0.34345269203186035,
0.2153012454509735,
-0.09535254538059235,
0.48655879497528076,
0.39041492342948914,
-0.5272391438484192,
-0.5764144659042358,
0.06999561190605164,
-0.419846773147583,
-0.8513103723526001,
-0.393658310174942,
-0.384086936712265,
-0.06937848776578903,
0.05616716295480728,
-0.18704918026924133,
0.3381058871746063,
0.5287832617759705,
-0.8217484354972839,
0.36555051803588867,
0.43481889367103577,
0.7403295040130615,
-1.2208902835845947,
0.11449248343706131,
-0.034531399607658386,
-0.7895699143409729,
-0.3079613149166107,
0.3985148072242737,
0.5987424850463867,
0.015145798213779926,
-0.39769425988197327,
0.278687059879303,
-0.3795357644557953,
-0.4143126606941223,
0.06610049307346344,
0.03655221313238144,
0.6056234240531921,
-0.0296916626393795,
-0.2871708571910858,
1.0205520391464233,
0.32120048999786377,
0.02617853507399559,
0.3984951972961426,
0.2994115948677063,
-0.49247634410858154,
1.3214874267578125,
-0.2186705470085144,
-0.11968415230512619,
0.1243678629398346,
0.006110850255936384,
-1.043330192565918,
-0.204213947057724,
0.30461716651916504,
-0.3424874246120453,
0.7203744649887085,
0.035865072160959244,
-0.11562491208314896,
-0.08977162837982178,
-0.4474218487739563,
0.10242623090744019,
0.2721714377403259,
-0.6851710677146912,
0.33433178067207336,
0.2617180347442627,
-0.3990538716316223,
-0.6825466156005859,
-0.5427859425544739,
0.24137279391288757,
-0.5296663641929626,
-0.4280362129211426,
0.16184121370315552,
0.5225242376327515,
-0.3334784209728241,
0.302897572517395,
-0.08583345264196396,
-0.03834715485572815,
0.11336879432201385,
-0.2253728210926056,
0.30206161737442017,
-0.7376893162727356,
-0.32111236453056335,
0.12063737213611603,
-0.07247114926576614,
-0.03741597384214401,
0.30670756101608276,
0.6514466404914856,
-0.5251466035842896,
-0.9309826493263245,
-0.43491798639297485,
0.5221512913703918,
0.46065443754196167,
-0.2137390375137329,
0.6465165615081787,
0.48210033774375916,
-0.2590356469154358,
0.20514677464962006,
-0.7282136678695679,
0.12149780243635178,
-0.5050865411758423,
0.35535603761672974,
-0.277473121881485,
-0.6910555958747864,
0.5147470831871033,
-0.09102405607700348,
-0.3144378364086151,
0.4301113486289978,
0.32389551401138306,
-0.12680788338184357,
0.9176148176193237,
-0.03202369064092636,
0.10386230796575546,
0.3686377704143524,
0.608998715877533,
0.42371878027915955,
-1.1160070896148682,
-0.20940755307674408,
-0.9274364709854126,
-0.6744223833084106,
-0.2789396643638611,
-0.03349470719695091,
0.179321750998497,
0.4549233317375183,
-0.33144310116767883,
0.7276102900505066,
-0.6124864220619202,
0.5626766681671143,
0.2914268374443054,
-0.2906881272792816,
0.035357940942049026,
-0.10746175050735474,
-0.12768259644508362,
-0.3964464068412781,
-0.4299713969230652,
-0.623340368270874,
0.7846031785011292,
0.26264891028404236,
0.9362964034080505,
-0.06981958448886871,
1.0109437704086304,
0.12180230021476746,
0.30408257246017456,
-0.6432986855506897,
0.7205591201782227,
0.14807666838169098,
-0.2090958058834076,
-0.25896593928337097,
-0.7130383253097534,
-0.9319825172424316,
0.4710322916507721,
0.18055017292499542,
-1.112205982208252,
0.1540033519268036,
0.060860972851514816,
-0.3570846617221832,
0.40705278515815735,
-1.071340560913086,
1.0618464946746826,
-0.6608964204788208,
-0.37367528676986694,
0.23624923825263977,
-0.5619039535522461,
0.21752940118312836,
0.06450509279966354,
-0.13706786930561066,
-0.15938396751880646,
-0.021770378574728966,
0.5906310677528381,
-0.43674802780151367,
0.34253358840942383,
-0.5228915810585022,
0.3365953266620636,
0.32912778854370117,
0.1763380914926529,
0.2694416642189026,
0.018417514860630035,
-0.11490198969841003,
-0.02055744268000126,
0.31683269143104553,
-0.3708317279815674,
-0.6415977478027344,
0.8458559513092041,
-0.20560809969902039,
-0.6134786605834961,
-0.5309004187583923,
-0.1988220065832138,
-0.32231906056404114,
0.19192473590373993,
0.08422867208719254,
0.40958666801452637,
-0.4051837623119354,
0.6268123388290405,
0.07688113301992416,
-0.08611223101615906,
0.411928653717041,
0.3304409682750702,
-0.4645320177078247,
-0.6790903210639954,
0.8146790266036987,
-0.1031837910413742,
0.16418425738811493,
0.6350165605545044,
0.37923890352249146,
-0.7835211157798767,
-0.030913930386304855,
-0.5131698250770569,
-0.36548957228660583,
-0.5585819482803345,
-0.6734915375709534,
-0.42406708002090454,
-0.033251337707042694,
-0.4924728274345398,
-0.4831351041793823,
-0.6474618315696716,
-0.26988330483436584,
-0.007797082420438528,
0.02909562923014164,
-0.2041454166173935,
0.27674347162246704,
0.07850898057222366,
0.15693873167037964,
-0.9658986330032349,
0.1937338262796402,
-0.10233420133590698,
0.6011747717857361,
-0.6862562894821167,
-0.2688702940940857,
0.0921049565076828,
-0.04758718982338905,
-0.6022731065750122,
-1.1923576593399048,
0.2616342306137085,
0.22751736640930176,
0.5783666968345642,
0.42052456736564636,
-0.011836262419819832,
1.309935212135315,
-0.4988710284233093,
1.1733354330062866,
0.5337761640548706,
-1.3967934846878052,
0.8040927648544312,
-0.1479705274105072,
0.14918017387390137,
1.216354250907898,
-0.15828916430473328,
-0.22410070896148682,
-0.269781231880188,
-0.7855454087257385,
-0.6824887990951538,
0.5006358027458191,
0.21967315673828125,
-0.014322832226753235,
-0.18395377695560455,
0.05910208076238632,
0.2250135987997055,
0.337035596370697,
-0.47854095697402954,
0.20390358567237854,
-0.18952085077762604,
-0.5191888213157654,
0.4143233299255371,
-0.03400333598256111,
-0.0893840566277504,
-0.4655994772911072,
0.46344906091690063,
-0.17085832357406616,
0.369202584028244,
0.08494710922241211,
0.06055021286010742,
-0.48591452836990356,
0.704515814781189,
0.4311436116695404,
0.8350793719291687,
-0.16194777190685272,
0.17167261242866516,
0.08544506132602692,
-0.042431339621543884,
0.39167144894599915,
0.08175975829362869,
0.02721690572798252,
0.10110203176736832,
0.4211536943912506,
0.8053030371665955,
0.44115787744522095,
-0.4656497836112976,
0.8761525750160217,
0.02068280056118965,
-0.12588070333003998,
-0.01669497974216938,
0.15537676215171814,
-0.08990039676427841,
0.12587378919124603,
-0.12824410200119019,
0.41969913244247437,
0.24274739623069763,
-0.341448038816452,
0.4918544888496399,
0.6075762510299683,
-0.3868871331214905,
-0.17707650363445282,
0.6652794480323792,
0.18106132745742798,
-0.6453272700309753,
0.3559311628341675,
-0.2891143262386322,
-0.503226637840271,
0.5577965974807739,
0.7316648960113525,
0.8195816278457642,
-0.7459767460823059,
0.12192364782094955,
0.08251608908176422,
0.28452032804489136,
-0.007873068563640118,
0.4119322597980499,
-0.029161352664232254,
-0.5144252181053162,
-0.33214476704597473,
-1.021369218826294,
-0.4937435984611511,
0.126925989985466,
-1.2945611476898193,
0.4289449155330658,
-0.2581113278865814,
-0.134879007935524,
-0.3296037018299103,
-0.19455277919769287,
-0.5642431378364563,
0.03635650873184204,
-0.028989678248763084,
0.8819592595100403,
-0.9805656671524048,
0.4815642535686493,
0.9546743631362915,
0.023133881390094757,
-0.9264189004898071,
0.17073582112789154,
-0.009850351139903069,
-0.8727519512176514,
-0.07978764176368713,
0.3429473638534546,
0.1465366929769516,
-0.2717052102088928,
-0.016321726143360138,
-0.7224897742271423,
0.8615755438804626,
0.7998444437980652,
-0.945216178894043,
0.24597348272800446,
0.15803056955337524,
0.5349480509757996,
-0.2507396340370178,
0.32150211930274963,
0.7826635837554932,
0.8158998489379883,
-0.34803831577301025,
-0.8305540084838867,
-0.14727352559566498,
-0.1372181624174118,
-0.0005788640701211989,
0.7725221514701843,
-0.6789036989212036,
0.308480829000473,
0.4666617810726166,
-0.11809409409761429,
0.06124335527420044,
0.44217368960380554,
0.2461884319782257,
0.5904214978218079,
0.6007850766181946,
1.06334388256073,
0.8853370547294617,
-0.48930075764656067,
0.9873632788658142,
-0.28321850299835205,
0.6691802740097046,
1.182105541229248,
-0.7313591241836548,
0.826745331287384,
0.7597282528877258,
-0.5838367938995361,
0.4233348071575165,
0.35077759623527527,
0.07015450298786163,
0.600400447845459,
0.06347240507602692,
-0.15794411301612854,
-0.2692703604698181,
0.0005431860918179154,
-0.3558447062969208,
0.8333266973495483,
0.43999484181404114,
-0.4023778736591339,
-0.4490814507007599,
-0.39867261052131653,
-0.1405046135187149,
0.5256819725036621,
-0.17408457398414612,
0.6437239050865173,
0.026447635143995285,
-0.8939381241798401,
0.28487128019332886,
-0.23022149503231049,
0.25446274876594543,
-0.6726391911506653,
-0.05613090842962265,
-0.07401912659406662,
0.10045108944177628,
-0.14689010381698608,
-1.0790311098098755,
0.6869276762008667,
0.12239209562540054,
0.34214892983436584,
-0.4748586118221283,
0.8380255103111267,
-0.3358824849128723,
-0.6761389374732971,
0.20399850606918335,
0.5515335202217102,
-0.15739977359771729,
0.2255672663450241,
-0.8530616760253906,
0.3260640799999237,
0.13437603414058685,
-0.6329634785652161,
0.522211492061615,
0.22591546177864075,
0.3525926470756531,
0.05261782184243202,
0.3110848665237427,
0.30097097158432007,
-0.07813283801078796,
0.22523553669452667,
0.7257689833641052,
-0.5080944299697876,
-0.5828972458839417,
-1.0219537019729614,
0.8103793859481812,
-0.4231797158718109,
-0.3730466663837433,
0.5582177639007568,
0.686599612236023,
0.7149912714958191,
0.2127334326505661,
0.4707925021648407,
-0.26073017716407776,
0.5020837783813477,
-0.6877344846725464,
0.625592052936554,
-0.6344471573829651,
0.22823141515254974,
-0.4390895962715149,
-1.4753574132919312,
-0.3168732821941376,
0.7955603003501892,
-0.05330361798405647,
0.006617969833314419,
1.0668416023254395,
0.803560733795166,
-0.4326856732368469,
0.18239428102970123,
0.59641033411026,
-0.33079826831817627,
0.29948553442955017,
0.42730849981307983,
0.9389095902442932,
-0.309335321187973,
0.02588398940861225,
-0.17721357941627502,
-0.19398663938045502,
-0.16033996641635895,
-0.9168305397033691,
-0.6008505821228027,
-0.5885921716690063,
-0.337997704744339,
-0.2639046907424927,
0.188404381275177,
1.0674694776535034,
0.4134235382080078,
-0.9251474738121033,
0.2566166818141937,
-0.19154393672943115,
-0.2798977196216583,
-0.11369872838258743,
-0.3975118398666382,
0.3641088604927063,
-0.620395839214325,
-0.6728149056434631,
0.8630596399307251,
0.6890162229537964,
-0.4536289572715759,
-0.06611490249633789,
0.08807935565710068,
-0.05015534162521362,
0.044664863497018814,
0.023111863061785698,
0.010154460556805134,
-0.8393239974975586,
-0.7865496873855591,
-0.20353873074054718,
-0.2513446509838104,
0.45457327365875244,
0.6210343241691589,
-0.6532657146453857,
0.7149922847747803,
0.6842537522315979,
1.0553405284881592,
-0.29127418994903564,
0.7626890540122986,
0.42872536182403564,
-0.9622347354888916,
-0.021965282037854195,
0.4073847830295563,
0.8658129572868347,
0.49940839409828186,
-0.49404090642929077,
0.43135973811149597,
0.11378900706768036,
-0.7085894346237183,
-1.0245684385299683,
0.05786503106355667,
-1.070823073387146,
0.18114733695983887,
0.9705936908721924,
-0.39333704113960266,
-0.29162901639938354,
0.3609650433063507,
-0.28604796528816223,
0.1670064777135849,
-0.36343273520469666,
0.5202914476394653,
0.8032249212265015,
-0.1840885728597641,
-0.3187384605407715,
0.1322190910577774,
-0.14345520734786987,
0.8254324197769165,
-0.8405076861381531,
-0.16060297191143036,
0.3746545910835266,
0.12968327105045319,
0.2569001019001007,
0.5505592823028564,
-0.3880051076412201,
0.19496768712997437,
0.21912965178489685,
-0.2172582596540451,
0.126606747508049,
-0.3355798125267029,
-0.45195460319519043,
0.48977693915367126,
-0.09250567853450775,
-0.25608396530151367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14141v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14141v2
|
ViHateT5: Enhancing Hate Speech Detection in Vietnamese With A Unified Text-to-Text Transformer Model
| 2024-05-23T03:31:50 | 2024-06-04T09:51:41 |
Luan Thanh Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in hate speech detection (HSD) in Vietnamese have made
significant progress, primarily attributed to the emergence of
transformer-based pre-trained language models, particularly those built on the
BERT architecture. However, the necessity for specialized fine-tuned models has
resulted in the complexity and fragmentation of developing a multitasking HSD
system. Moreover, most current methodologies focus on fine-tuning general
pre-trained models, primarily trained on formal textual datasets like
Wikipedia, which may not accurately capture human behavior on online platforms.
In this research, we introduce ViHateT5, a T5-based model pre-trained on our
proposed large-scale domain-specific dataset named VOZ-HSD. By harnessing the
power of a text-to-text architecture, ViHateT5 can tackle multiple tasks using
a unified model and achieve state-of-the-art performance across all standard
HSD benchmarks in Vietnamese. Our experiments also underscore the significance
of label distribution in pre-training data on model efficacy. We provide our
experimental materials for research purposes, including the VOZ-HSD dataset,
pre-trained checkpoint, the unified HSD-multitask ViHateT5 model, and related
source code on GitHub publicly.
|
[
-0.2606700360774994,
-0.6323232650756836,
0.22581152617931366,
0.07345014065504074,
-0.3750908672809601,
-0.018846405670046806,
-0.06593446433544159,
-0.42246538400650024,
-0.069730244576931,
0.7875179052352905,
-0.4457855522632599,
-0.7500029802322388,
-0.7566784024238586,
-0.0877782329916954,
-0.5684454441070557,
1.1050148010253906,
0.3293079435825348,
-0.04439990222454071,
0.27614712715148926,
-0.23308397829532623,
-0.3876945674419403,
-0.7104175686836243,
-0.16166505217552185,
-0.06901758909225464,
0.6923531889915466,
0.5248498916625977,
0.3303918242454529,
0.6670323610305786,
0.5761692523956299,
0.22210827469825745,
0.07401926815509796,
-0.09358242899179459,
-0.7333580851554871,
0.15546686947345734,
-0.1408786028623581,
-0.20384454727172852,
-0.31490084528923035,
-0.26393866539001465,
0.2641453742980957,
0.01396955456584692,
-0.057415127754211426,
0.27376729249954224,
-0.0333016999065876,
0.056291453540325165,
-0.6903889179229736,
-0.055987775325775146,
-0.7561332583427429,
-0.18604452908039093,
-0.5715338587760925,
0.21826717257499695,
-0.2904590666294098,
-0.1860743910074234,
0.3058817684650421,
-0.5110129117965698,
0.33725231885910034,
-0.4159885346889496,
0.7860454320907593,
0.4233812987804413,
-0.45602378249168396,
0.026202844455838203,
-0.9300140142440796,
0.7187572121620178,
-0.5832746624946594,
0.5156615972518921,
0.085869200527668,
0.44368189573287964,
0.37800121307373047,
-0.6395835280418396,
-0.7498719692230225,
-0.05411238595843315,
0.381412148475647,
0.2633146643638611,
-0.4925878643989563,
0.18456049263477325,
0.26958638429641724,
0.36198413372039795,
-0.545330286026001,
0.2775048017501831,
-0.5997123718261719,
-0.41212591528892517,
0.48452475666999817,
-0.05913877487182617,
0.32071906328201294,
-0.4540051817893982,
-0.6147578358650208,
-0.08552982658147812,
-0.19707965850830078,
-0.21081189811229706,
0.22410431504249573,
0.5471891760826111,
-0.06893228739500046,
0.4515247046947479,
-0.17728544771671295,
0.405965119600296,
-0.21711286902427673,
-0.2062000036239624,
0.30201300978660583,
-0.15985198318958282,
-0.3279596269130707,
-0.10277986526489258,
0.666709840297699,
0.22117121517658234,
0.5943130254745483,
0.05876128748059273,
-0.1951548308134079,
0.668412446975708,
0.793988049030304,
-0.9327420592308044,
-0.330281138420105,
0.269687682390213,
-0.4176308214664459,
-0.6117143630981445,
-0.04858136177062988,
-0.8192117810249329,
-0.5340101718902588,
-0.3392992615699768,
0.7930847406387329,
-0.5557035803794861,
-0.5243921279907227,
-0.13137982785701752,
-0.4312659502029419,
0.17430950701236725,
0.25004759430885315,
-0.3959639370441437,
0.11687470972537994,
0.3745731711387634,
0.5639401078224182,
-0.7701306939125061,
-0.39363011717796326,
-0.7598769664764404,
0.12651142477989197,
0.13998615741729736,
0.7622408866882324,
-0.6283191442489624,
-0.5045342445373535,
0.4079670011997223,
-0.15766875445842743,
0.2357538640499115,
-0.6646531224250793,
1.1629499197006226,
-0.48999258875846863,
0.18047891557216644,
-0.0619434230029583,
-0.5553007125854492,
-0.15512427687644958,
0.1489502191543579,
-0.5426701903343201,
1.0675199031829834,
0.26428842544555664,
-0.7609621286392212,
0.2995355725288391,
-0.66004478931427,
-0.484226793050766,
0.22723835706710815,
0.05425513908267021,
-0.8849706649780273,
-0.12111472338438034,
0.22127144038677216,
0.4729602038860321,
-0.13602150976657867,
0.08293797820806503,
-0.4783600866794586,
-0.1446409821510315,
-0.33428987860679626,
-0.44456785917282104,
1.0087463855743408,
0.33813774585723877,
-0.6176472306251526,
0.7145893573760986,
-0.8373731374740601,
-0.32192671298980713,
0.15657339990139008,
-0.107192762196064,
-0.42644354701042175,
-0.14738619327545166,
0.6780657768249512,
0.23059989511966705,
0.030749939382076263,
-0.7395429611206055,
-0.18722696602344513,
0.05549293011426926,
0.05344608798623085,
0.9636237025260925,
-0.2715521454811096,
-0.010609027929604053,
-0.21611644327640533,
0.6594985723495483,
0.4487079679965973,
0.4016551673412323,
-0.29638439416885376,
-0.5491528511047363,
-0.7137343287467957,
-0.4150603413581848,
-0.08678287267684937,
0.6884800791740417,
-0.8719977736473083,
0.14630495011806488,
-0.20757050812244415,
-0.7431424260139465,
-0.6081746220588684,
-0.06379923969507217,
0.4233836829662323,
0.5203498005867004,
0.8000246286392212,
-0.015648124739527702,
-0.8615846037864685,
-0.8539367318153381,
-0.316963255405426,
-0.029309188947081566,
-0.10137771815061569,
-0.00433642091229558,
0.5147087574005127,
-0.5964722633361816,
0.8603854775428772,
-0.4493309557437897,
-0.6087846755981445,
-0.1652357578277588,
0.13575294613838196,
-0.32967641949653625,
0.09715134650468826,
0.6677618622779846,
-0.9955286979675293,
-0.5757143497467041,
-0.09450142830610275,
-0.5397900938987732,
-0.3756119906902313,
0.3529609441757202,
-0.0004290438664611429,
-0.0331995002925396,
0.47419267892837524,
-0.07998233288526535,
0.49284249544143677,
0.5698155164718628,
-0.32505175471305847,
0.7924519777297974,
0.14106400310993195,
0.06457638740539551,
-1.236392855644226,
-0.32599058747291565,
0.10458827763795853,
-0.36638596653938293,
-0.9109124541282654,
-0.03883633017539978,
-0.09343069791793823,
-0.264123797416687,
-0.6729626059532166,
0.30848821997642517,
-0.05398166924715042,
0.20058633387088776,
-0.5100279450416565,
-0.1659923642873764,
-0.41882485151290894,
0.48457133769989014,
0.13608334958553314,
0.6777293682098389,
0.3741037845611572,
-0.8531537055969238,
0.3717958629131317,
-0.01542622409760952,
-0.09202160686254501,
1.0093492269515991,
-0.6162700653076172,
-0.06556537002325058,
-0.017301883548498154,
-0.012363049201667309,
-0.8243120312690735,
-0.21709826588630676,
0.11114747077226639,
-0.5735063552856445,
-0.3359975814819336,
-0.25985729694366455,
-0.07548351585865021,
-0.5897129774093628,
-0.40453073382377625,
0.4640486240386963,
0.5646904706954956,
-0.7172470688819885,
0.6128553152084351,
0.858192503452301,
0.2020627111196518,
-0.33361735939979553,
-0.364811509847641,
-0.05433591455221176,
-0.5697909593582153,
-0.41862499713897705,
0.5214105248451233,
-0.07692509889602661,
-0.08768925815820694,
-0.29449859261512756,
0.12669968605041504,
-0.3329485356807709,
-0.08352340012788773,
0.36774885654449463,
0.050666265189647675,
-0.3573604226112366,
0.16770119965076447,
-0.13058292865753174,
0.02416106127202511,
0.03477946296334267,
-0.5620800256729126,
0.3467416763305664,
-0.028293857350945473,
-0.07931510359048843,
-0.5524985790252686,
0.27717676758766174,
0.984275758266449,
-0.3842557668685913,
0.3844519853591919,
1.0718659162521362,
-0.4288714826107025,
-0.2809295356273651,
-0.6322344541549683,
-0.030025335028767586,
-0.42480984330177307,
0.36183419823646545,
-0.29813724756240845,
-1.1090635061264038,
0.2328650802373886,
0.09618107974529266,
0.14339269697666168,
0.5084790587425232,
0.7059013247489929,
-0.20723611116409302,
0.7338210344314575,
0.9308550953865051,
-0.2791273295879364,
0.7801290154457092,
0.25619232654571533,
-0.08914302289485931,
-0.3178651034832001,
0.15211491286754608,
-0.6729725003242493,
0.15688297152519226,
-0.8668457269668579,
-0.7147079706192017,
0.5790337324142456,
-0.4861776828765869,
-0.46750757098197937,
0.408016562461853,
-0.6886115074157715,
0.26382970809936523,
0.5688877701759338,
-0.13573992252349854,
0.29069069027900696,
0.2467746138572693,
0.17135009169578552,
-0.4404769837856293,
-0.31596168875694275,
-0.34529852867126465,
1.1910297870635986,
0.19885973632335663,
0.4032432436943054,
0.10968343168497086,
0.4279681146144867,
0.705280065536499,
0.22610631585121155,
-0.5905316472053528,
0.23968125879764557,
-0.3246208429336548,
-0.49880895018577576,
-0.4625472128391266,
-0.14161911606788635,
-1.0012567043304443,
0.5002236366271973,
0.014927721582353115,
-0.5079501271247864,
0.038720451295375824,
0.20450787246227264,
-0.19452190399169922,
0.47303906083106995,
-0.7790989875793457,
0.9899857640266418,
0.004512278363108635,
-0.19298990070819855,
-0.24357931315898895,
-0.4303591549396515,
0.5312204360961914,
-0.07817600667476654,
0.31406787037849426,
-0.10774723440408707,
0.33692818880081177,
0.892139196395874,
-0.49669820070266724,
0.9794660806655884,
-0.3754115104675293,
-0.38396474719047546,
0.33095380663871765,
-0.29604777693748474,
0.24380072951316833,
-0.2831357717514038,
-0.01996942050755024,
0.3794513940811157,
-0.10900122672319412,
-0.5705128312110901,
-0.2068447768688202,
0.358381986618042,
-0.8803219199180603,
-0.39800792932510376,
-0.21213777363300323,
-0.182913139462471,
-0.06080608069896698,
0.43915125727653503,
0.5185558199882507,
0.14065252244472504,
-0.5140435099601746,
0.05424188822507858,
0.9150938987731934,
-0.23601122200489044,
0.1268775463104248,
0.47236889600753784,
-0.47668489813804626,
-0.2763282358646393,
1.2782553434371948,
0.0925142839550972,
0.12205386161804199,
0.42152926325798035,
0.22545425593852997,
-0.04286324232816696,
-0.20954930782318115,
-0.42579135298728943,
0.08245059102773666,
-0.3368411660194397,
-0.14983604848384857,
-0.9077798128128052,
-0.29548031091690063,
-0.6110879182815552,
0.095382921397686,
-0.6007587909698486,
0.008384267799556255,
0.10767205059528351,
-0.05243726447224617,
0.4745563566684723,
0.8249806761741638,
-0.12619297206401825,
0.6181599497795105,
-0.6081520915031433,
0.9819501042366028,
0.6159030199050903,
0.2762916386127472,
-0.2584432363510132,
-0.8348871469497681,
-0.3038504421710968,
0.13986094295978546,
-0.4502697288990021,
-1.081664800643921,
0.29153376817703247,
-0.29951611161231995,
0.11474575847387314,
0.5172038674354553,
0.33768370747566223,
0.43613556027412415,
-0.3673156499862671,
0.5877385139465332,
-0.11767715960741043,
-0.9623517990112305,
0.8041844964027405,
-0.8251966834068298,
0.3418443202972412,
0.14962895214557648,
0.3580981194972992,
-0.6646583080291748,
-0.4581812918186188,
-0.6597016453742981,
-0.49975457787513733,
0.61747145652771,
0.47632327675819397,
0.10902885347604752,
0.4332074522972107,
-0.2153894454240799,
0.07079711556434631,
0.21398642659187317,
-0.9103245735168457,
-0.2955528497695923,
-0.6914548873901367,
-0.11740309000015259,
0.1588696837425232,
-0.3951055705547333,
0.20219284296035767,
-0.4710533320903778,
0.5991519093513489,
0.050773970782756805,
0.2536809742450714,
-0.10172050446271896,
-0.2908436059951782,
0.2519986033439636,
0.2541806995868683,
0.6770452260971069,
0.3064637780189514,
-0.09234047681093216,
-0.01510823704302311,
0.09238509088754654,
-0.8738002777099609,
0.02073061466217041,
0.07707735151052475,
-0.22037170827388763,
0.3384627401828766,
0.31843262910842896,
0.9214915633201599,
-0.07784397155046463,
-0.5213804841041565,
0.7413755059242249,
-0.08448557555675507,
-0.11575999855995178,
-0.3978232145309448,
0.0923473909497261,
-0.1330297291278839,
0.08792511373758316,
0.28641217947006226,
-0.18048018217086792,
0.1738719940185547,
-0.15721231698989868,
0.40325093269348145,
0.09651350975036621,
-0.8000456690788269,
-0.5097863674163818,
0.8425664305686951,
0.35907256603240967,
-0.6215777397155762,
0.56277996301651,
0.031322166323661804,
-0.8985656499862671,
0.5137434005737305,
0.3104430139064789,
0.8370662331581116,
-0.918092668056488,
0.5032820701599121,
0.37070372700691223,
0.5152586698532104,
0.43065720796585083,
0.23152457177639008,
-0.13157208263874054,
-0.8450712561607361,
-0.12581641972064972,
-0.6475821137428284,
-0.24601134657859802,
0.544344961643219,
-0.7440236806869507,
0.4967498183250427,
-0.11432184278964996,
0.01822466216981411,
0.049439407885074615,
-0.3383393883705139,
-0.6435965299606323,
0.4951533377170563,
0.3907970190048218,
0.4495896100997925,
-0.7984679937362671,
0.9904489517211914,
0.49749454855918884,
-0.3526904284954071,
-0.45541077852249146,
0.1249389797449112,
0.2644825577735901,
-0.6990627646446228,
0.2790413498878479,
0.2538054287433624,
-0.3293520212173462,
0.08223465830087662,
-0.5531841516494751,
-0.4427582919597626,
0.4777873754501343,
0.3576856255531311,
-0.44659411907196045,
0.12758736312389374,
0.41879719495773315,
0.6740436553955078,
-0.0861433744430542,
0.1958754062652588,
0.6088443398475647,
0.4727208614349365,
-0.19464384019374847,
-0.9054021239280701,
-0.36651620268821716,
-0.21518705785274506,
0.037672948092222214,
-0.017615798860788345,
-0.6497899293899536,
0.7836909890174866,
-0.2166767120361328,
-0.08732941001653671,
-0.5229195356369019,
1.0325015783309937,
0.1030179113149643,
0.12340377271175385,
0.6626502871513367,
0.48501473665237427,
0.8392065167427063,
0.20407558977603912,
0.9377344846725464,
0.13410893082618713,
0.13548289239406586,
1.0824629068374634,
-0.1175580844283104,
0.8082478046417236,
0.07826213538646698,
-0.08927206695079803,
0.40951642394065857,
0.2794587016105652,
-0.1291968673467636,
0.3103954792022705,
0.18366289138793945,
-0.3969203233718872,
-0.33636474609375,
-0.3993718922138214,
-0.45729541778564453,
0.7721715569496155,
0.333833247423172,
0.06350966542959213,
-0.23811474442481995,
0.5710048675537109,
0.0330207385122776,
0.2598949670791626,
-0.11709122359752655,
0.6522679328918457,
-0.04812181740999222,
-0.40326908230781555,
0.5019643902778625,
0.1998492330312729,
1.1170573234558105,
-0.4090674817562103,
0.09373077005147934,
-0.11745560169219971,
0.3644976317882538,
0.024608345702290535,
-0.47867196798324585,
0.3602372407913208,
0.34345877170562744,
-0.3552550673484802,
-0.298557311296463,
0.7268238067626953,
-0.4934740960597992,
-0.32288265228271484,
0.5417909026145935,
0.320234090089798,
-0.027237050235271454,
-0.5831714272499084,
-0.5733678936958313,
0.3747696578502655,
0.07250610738992691,
0.08288230746984482,
0.09654147177934647,
0.511127233505249,
-0.28541868925094604,
0.37114280462265015,
0.4869336485862732,
-0.1814463585615158,
0.20623430609703064,
0.3573567569255829,
0.7688345313072205,
-0.731045126914978,
-0.6541905999183655,
-0.7972449660301208,
0.40005117654800415,
-0.09691189974546432,
-0.6432993412017822,
0.8031041026115417,
0.6010755896568298,
1.1860082149505615,
-0.15630632638931274,
1.1733877658843994,
0.3325793743133545,
1.0435949563980103,
-0.12011723965406418,
0.7335888743400574,
-0.49379080533981323,
-0.11835412681102753,
-0.6539061665534973,
-0.6941781044006348,
-0.12555402517318726,
0.4869289994239807,
0.0024078134447336197,
0.023173583671450615,
0.5358240008354187,
0.6065937280654907,
-0.18931348621845245,
0.09695839136838913,
0.5908651947975159,
0.6028138399124146,
0.7882325649261475,
0.23613624274730682,
0.6168085932731628,
-0.5925527215003967,
0.8204418420791626,
-0.19208920001983643,
0.023827724158763885,
-0.32570624351501465,
-0.33968275785446167,
-0.8847326040267944,
-0.9112961888313293,
-0.32398971915245056,
-0.2718331217765808,
0.22155457735061646,
0.4561046361923218,
0.7530094981193542,
-0.8044379353523254,
-0.4273957312107086,
0.15894372761249542,
0.30960631370544434,
0.023732099682092667,
-0.2634665369987488,
0.17596599459648132,
-0.20995953679084778,
-0.8375877141952515,
0.21328239142894745,
0.30681174993515015,
-0.04680997133255005,
-0.07335830479860306,
0.1672055721282959,
-0.13581620156764984,
0.0002217777946498245,
1.0189887285232544,
0.1937035322189331,
-0.7454402446746826,
-0.24848322570323944,
-0.11615585535764694,
-0.2947961390018463,
0.11918307840824127,
0.8586728572845459,
-0.9237009286880493,
0.44417497515678406,
0.268899530172348,
0.7826833724975586,
0.5391225814819336,
-0.036910075694322586,
0.5927768349647522,
-0.49217844009399414,
0.09146939963102341,
0.22284629940986633,
-0.07655185461044312,
0.2028491348028183,
-0.017825372517108917,
0.30774518847465515,
0.450450599193573,
-0.2921481132507324,
-0.898723840713501,
0.23286451399326324,
-0.9008024334907532,
-0.25240784883499146,
1.082616925239563,
0.2688106298446655,
-0.2399698942899704,
-0.5676308870315552,
-0.4084092676639557,
0.48719123005867004,
-0.4246419370174408,
0.7908176183700562,
0.5928378105163574,
0.3353356122970581,
-0.09589427709579468,
-0.4370039701461792,
0.7720059752464294,
0.40912115573883057,
-1.0894906520843506,
0.18874013423919678,
0.5202425122261047,
0.13047710061073303,
-0.0376618392765522,
0.6772599220275879,
0.16973038017749786,
0.4856047034263611,
-0.11181190609931946,
0.3164936304092407,
0.26798155903816223,
-0.4474680423736572,
-0.1354004144668579,
0.4521748423576355,
-0.41933953762054443,
-0.3281930088996887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.15818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15818v1
|
DuanzAI: Slang-Enhanced LLM with Prompt for Humor Understanding
| 2024-05-23T03:13:50 | 2024-05-23T03:13:50 |
Yesian Rohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language's complexity is evident in the rich tapestry of slang expressions,
often laden with humor and cultural nuances. This linguistic phenomenon has
become increasingly prevalent, especially in digital communication. However,
existing AI models, including ChatGPT-3.5, face challenges in comprehending
these nuances, particularly in Chinese slang. In this study, we present
DuanzAI, an innovative approach enhancing Large Language Models (LLMs) with
deep Chinese slang comprehension. Leveraging curated datasets and advanced
techniques, DuanzAI bridges the gap between human expression and AI
comprehension, enabling contextually relevant responses. Our experiments
contrast LLMs' performance with a custom Punchline Entity Recognition (PER)
system, integrating phonetic matching and pinyin2hanzi techniques. Applying
these insights, we developed ChatDAI, an advanced chatbot and released our code
at \url{https://github.com/YesianRohn/DuanzAI}.
|
[
0.036302655935287476,
-1.0160828828811646,
0.5027778744697571,
0.8173116445541382,
-0.5394241213798523,
0.32666367292404175,
-0.23239712417125702,
-0.33359238505363464,
0.4569370746612549,
0.34678542613983154,
-0.5476275086402893,
-0.5323864221572876,
-0.27845343947410583,
0.01894327811896801,
-0.23564717173576355,
1.0142393112182617,
0.36833107471466064,
-0.04077994078397751,
0.0931984931230545,
0.20945324003696442,
-0.8498803973197937,
-0.3536553382873535,
-1.076456069946289,
-0.36435753107070923,
0.7432909607887268,
0.41410133242607117,
0.8358137607574463,
0.24448062479496002,
0.42098841071128845,
0.34279271960258484,
-0.05362545698881149,
0.30706658959388733,
-0.6651473045349121,
0.08191805332899094,
0.28267979621887207,
-0.662121057510376,
-0.49765053391456604,
-0.4405743479728699,
0.32979822158813477,
0.8434940576553345,
-0.18601250648498535,
-0.337679922580719,
-0.20666472613811493,
0.5262751579284668,
-0.32648777961730957,
0.030246524140238762,
-0.8302777409553528,
0.10285914689302444,
-0.23997853696346283,
-0.38081246614456177,
-0.06844469159841537,
-0.24864956736564636,
-0.15744946897029877,
-0.5412954688072205,
-0.1953958421945572,
-0.1976475864648819,
0.8588548302650452,
0.6742830276489258,
-0.2975377142429352,
-0.2214113473892212,
-0.3737873136997223,
0.3990861475467682,
-0.8112889528274536,
-0.0520629957318306,
0.18210797011852264,
0.526252806186676,
-0.3591543436050415,
-0.876862645149231,
-0.8293449282646179,
-0.29520922899246216,
-0.15038052201271057,
0.33803316950798035,
-0.11187442392110825,
-0.08887943625450134,
0.1233564019203186,
0.5023643970489502,
-0.686294674873352,
0.37561798095703125,
-0.28798672556877136,
0.13721618056297302,
0.7425644397735596,
0.38920044898986816,
0.5766584277153015,
-0.31600692868232727,
-0.49832883477211,
0.23586620390415192,
-0.7654848694801331,
0.01421273872256279,
0.6003887057304382,
0.19058857858181,
-0.2526733875274658,
0.1670631319284439,
-0.06932350993156433,
0.40038353204727173,
-0.132064551115036,
-0.017622893676161766,
0.41378626227378845,
-0.30945679545402527,
-0.40662768483161926,
0.05153898894786835,
0.792692244052887,
0.16885320842266083,
0.639018714427948,
-0.1625026911497116,
-0.10156862437725067,
-0.2847110331058502,
0.24913477897644043,
-0.6380089521408081,
-0.4094866216182709,
0.45496559143066406,
-0.14136941730976105,
-0.564070463180542,
0.08791261166334152,
-0.5785604119300842,
-0.666816771030426,
0.044356588274240494,
0.15501244366168976,
-0.5810489058494568,
-0.26119470596313477,
0.19529910385608673,
-0.4526653289794922,
0.483879953622818,
0.36022061109542847,
-0.9131612777709961,
-0.18885527551174164,
0.9883884787559509,
1.2638764381408691,
-0.03802094981074333,
-0.241912379860878,
-0.4595956802368164,
0.05559153854846954,
-0.3179793357849121,
0.7964133620262146,
-0.6636435985565186,
-0.4606116712093353,
-0.04468498378992081,
-0.30500108003616333,
-0.019910652190446854,
-0.4228593111038208,
0.7083269953727722,
-0.6749657988548279,
-0.047477878630161285,
0.001965469913557172,
-0.3580257296562195,
-0.3391004204750061,
0.18473565578460693,
-0.6111758351325989,
0.839713990688324,
0.19736066460609436,
-0.6904328465461731,
-0.0892619714140892,
-0.9154858589172363,
-0.5976008772850037,
0.6469882130622864,
0.0345621258020401,
0.14335119724273682,
0.22427496314048767,
0.26719555258750916,
0.18121828138828278,
-0.010642512701451778,
0.5972685813903809,
-0.23990240693092346,
-0.685160756111145,
0.5226300358772278,
-0.7170835137367249,
1.058237075805664,
0.49400636553764343,
-0.1002369374036789,
0.16324353218078613,
-0.5208718776702881,
0.03149179741740227,
0.3216833770275116,
-0.18974672257900238,
-0.25891438126564026,
-0.29361703991889954,
0.01106908917427063,
-0.11172837764024734,
0.4812275767326355,
-0.2085917592048645,
0.2055215984582901,
-0.803745687007904,
0.7090484499931335,
0.6841323971748352,
-0.3413539230823517,
-0.1325436681509018,
-0.21359531581401825,
0.3886112868785858,
0.05623220279812813,
-0.011355040594935417,
-0.4036709666252136,
-0.5015727877616882,
-0.9560225605964661,
-0.1904534101486206,
0.44946587085723877,
0.8781147003173828,
-0.8622653484344482,
0.6154355406761169,
-0.5991286039352417,
-0.4551696479320526,
-0.735686719417572,
0.3657803237438202,
0.03763554245233536,
0.39839571714401245,
0.1490609496831894,
-0.3852959871292114,
-0.4720842242240906,
-0.8327565789222717,
-0.2717514932155609,
-0.11925726383924484,
-0.5007461309432983,
0.3924430310726166,
0.29925867915153503,
-0.4438372552394867,
0.8370887041091919,
-0.4002169072628021,
-0.272221177816391,
-0.6679892539978027,
0.13628175854682922,
0.5054590106010437,
0.13144409656524658,
0.7300066947937012,
-0.969856321811676,
-0.44025319814682007,
0.040711719542741776,
-0.6172023415565491,
-0.5107579827308655,
-0.17633597552776337,
-0.1637965440750122,
0.018598932772874832,
0.2628959119319916,
-0.48136264085769653,
0.3401182293891907,
0.4887646436691284,
-0.24717405438423157,
0.27676841616630554,
-0.13553234934806824,
0.16370835900306702,
-1.1263872385025024,
0.0585925318300724,
-0.23037868738174438,
-0.21103118360042572,
-0.9091868996620178,
0.17065073549747467,
-0.41492652893066406,
-0.028466731309890747,
-0.534112811088562,
0.5991747975349426,
0.041309937834739685,
-0.1413348764181137,
-0.6098335981369019,
0.5060446858406067,
-0.03268064931035042,
0.5563758015632629,
-0.041855838149785995,
1.0531647205352783,
0.6505828499794006,
-0.6176204681396484,
0.7087487578392029,
0.14345170557498932,
-0.3117043077945709,
0.37704986333847046,
-1.2258846759796143,
0.37509885430336,
-0.06857296824455261,
0.32264000177383423,
-1.2895214557647705,
-0.6302320957183838,
0.34749341011047363,
-0.6609475612640381,
0.16761507093906403,
-0.09831035882234573,
-0.6294034123420715,
-0.2583759129047394,
-0.3813607692718506,
0.32617318630218506,
0.6041028499603271,
-0.9343902468681335,
0.4995727241039276,
0.42024171352386475,
-0.29345786571502686,
-0.6162195801734924,
-0.7262274026870728,
0.5847235918045044,
-0.4368557035923004,
-0.8778809905052185,
0.3130618631839752,
-0.12811678647994995,
-0.38687101006507874,
-0.5570774078369141,
0.30136552453041077,
-0.3277914226055145,
0.43130114674568176,
0.23566539585590363,
0.21167528629302979,
-0.268480509519577,
0.32028669118881226,
0.11371102184057236,
-0.015154574066400528,
0.0017651718808338046,
0.006073995493352413,
1.021346092224121,
-0.1924659162759781,
-0.002104109385982156,
-0.682033121585846,
0.32536330819129944,
0.16977153718471527,
0.1315702646970749,
0.3904682397842407,
0.9294065833091736,
-0.05317286029458046,
0.08039941638708115,
-0.448422908782959,
0.1881098598241806,
-0.5860458612442017,
0.2956831455230713,
-0.5538960695266724,
-0.9241858124732971,
0.38111960887908936,
-0.06781885027885437,
-0.03495751693844795,
0.29532456398010254,
0.35494449734687805,
-0.10259038209915161,
0.9135400056838989,
0.5766779780387878,
-0.27944037318229675,
0.3856840431690216,
0.08245351165533066,
0.36399197578430176,
-0.5619357824325562,
-0.05649540200829506,
-0.3341304063796997,
-0.5506472587585449,
-0.6553821563720703,
-0.44761961698532104,
0.22185911238193512,
-0.04148542881011963,
-0.22277767956256866,
0.14811468124389648,
-0.10580173879861832,
0.6822556257247925,
0.48043549060821533,
0.056693896651268005,
0.33071374893188477,
0.035814858973026276,
0.283488929271698,
0.16687771677970886,
-0.5771584510803223,
-0.4442882537841797,
0.3882042169570923,
0.5185611248016357,
0.7382410764694214,
0.36673930287361145,
0.5507693290710449,
0.27336204051971436,
0.20364266633987427,
-1.021797776222229,
0.5450487732887268,
-0.582309365272522,
-0.08279496431350708,
-0.18362337350845337,
-0.6438742280006409,
-0.920894980430603,
0.16691915690898895,
0.196376770734787,
-0.7297645211219788,
-0.20412099361419678,
0.01246792171150446,
-0.6811891198158264,
0.008707943372428417,
-0.7277912497520447,
0.6091845035552979,
-0.645560622215271,
-0.08878755569458008,
-0.2355809211730957,
-0.5438012480735779,
0.521440863609314,
0.07463818788528442,
0.25889232754707336,
-0.1604921668767929,
-0.3064975142478943,
0.448983758687973,
-0.31578943133354187,
1.0738595724105835,
0.0600745864212513,
-0.42131155729293823,
0.1264689862728119,
-0.04412725940346718,
0.15092463791370392,
0.3606981933116913,
-0.04332540184259415,
0.690987765789032,
-0.3055691719055176,
-0.4045379161834717,
-0.8255589008331299,
1.0003682374954224,
-0.6064344644546509,
-0.9121115207672119,
0.004106624983251095,
-0.6946811676025391,
-0.0655432641506195,
-0.025371190160512924,
0.027168048545718193,
0.13676074147224426,
-0.08488395065069199,
0.06016746908426285,
0.2850528657436371,
-0.4273903965950012,
0.43904435634613037,
0.18792709708213806,
-0.04470105096697807,
-0.2615286707878113,
0.7024258971214294,
-0.37215709686279297,
-0.13429193198680878,
0.2831725478172302,
0.3135795295238495,
-0.3519632816314697,
-0.26526063680648804,
-0.471138060092926,
0.3177899122238159,
-0.7703146934509277,
-0.1740155965089798,
-0.8145934343338013,
-0.41370487213134766,
-0.6331650018692017,
-0.13910838961601257,
-0.025208473205566406,
-0.41266676783561707,
-0.2272084504365921,
0.0743623599410057,
0.6627483367919922,
0.7696323394775391,
0.01783088408410549,
0.671645998954773,
-0.7333016991615295,
0.20819170773029327,
0.3624255955219269,
0.3303203582763672,
-0.06795673072338104,
-0.8907208442687988,
0.2312624454498291,
0.23801234364509583,
-0.10791061818599701,
-0.7115175724029541,
0.7654553055763245,
0.40939199924468994,
0.3024672269821167,
0.514512300491333,
-0.0730590894818306,
1.1091827154159546,
-0.36818772554397583,
0.9025474190711975,
0.028186408802866936,
-0.9978501796722412,
0.7869580984115601,
-0.2663792073726654,
0.2517557144165039,
0.4926520586013794,
0.4314125180244446,
-0.6965487003326416,
-0.24752189218997955,
-0.3251931667327881,
-0.9161062240600586,
0.31884557008743286,
0.15069837868213654,
0.9964591860771179,
-0.14907510578632355,
0.5773457884788513,
0.1743161827325821,
0.2340947687625885,
-0.6953806281089783,
-0.1515417993068695,
-0.3669830858707428,
-0.4254631996154785,
0.17253857851028442,
-0.21614214777946472,
0.12881259620189667,
-0.1547248214483261,
0.38479116559028625,
-0.2183394432067871,
0.1254957765340805,
-0.07632039487361908,
-0.14107170701026917,
0.29251304268836975,
0.20607751607894897,
0.5482493042945862,
0.4380130171775818,
0.1210799366235733,
-0.020535411313176155,
0.2801358103752136,
-0.5850592255592346,
-0.41898173093795776,
-0.021300287917256355,
-0.035347528755664825,
0.1390594244003296,
0.2521796226501465,
1.159379482269287,
0.28048330545425415,
-1.0319312810897827,
0.45347410440444946,
-0.16707001626491547,
0.18995210528373718,
-0.7947147488594055,
0.643947184085846,
-0.055272772908210754,
0.25104400515556335,
0.35511744022369385,
-0.4598010182380676,
0.3560861051082611,
-0.814525842666626,
0.03590352460741997,
0.4139600098133087,
-0.3613213002681732,
-0.19820727407932281,
0.5477967858314514,
0.3904476761817932,
-0.442094087600708,
0.6943544745445251,
-0.057672660797834396,
-0.6090945601463318,
0.5994199514389038,
0.509609580039978,
0.8355459570884705,
-0.08537595719099045,
0.3423135280609131,
0.46091705560684204,
-0.09638145565986633,
0.26969611644744873,
0.12489938735961914,
-0.1584145575761795,
-0.6261304020881653,
-0.3669736981391907,
-0.5932453274726868,
-0.14432255923748016,
0.33282408118247986,
-0.06200089678168297,
0.5416216850280762,
-0.43680915236473083,
0.064769446849823,
0.03995625302195549,
0.06521784514188766,
-0.5483731627464294,
-0.10831034183502197,
0.27642396092414856,
0.9245800971984863,
-0.3183504343032837,
0.8655461072921753,
0.40592923760414124,
-0.48896199464797974,
-0.5131518840789795,
0.30551907420158386,
-0.287224680185318,
-1.2282277345657349,
0.9054199457168579,
0.5812693238258362,
-0.22901403903961182,
0.14560744166374207,
-0.8465135097503662,
-0.6009417772293091,
0.9500778913497925,
0.1325463056564331,
-0.5390872955322266,
-0.031495507806539536,
0.026660757139325142,
0.751666784286499,
-0.5229675769805908,
0.6664841175079346,
0.9236635565757751,
0.5999440550804138,
0.5241304039955139,
-0.8959531188011169,
-0.15023159980773926,
-0.42477285861968994,
0.08033885061740875,
-0.23626387119293213,
-0.6596614718437195,
0.7920165657997131,
-0.6425814628601074,
-0.5969139933586121,
0.46802932024002075,
0.7851009368896484,
0.1020435020327568,
0.42682236433029175,
0.553494393825531,
0.3737068772315979,
0.8540732860565186,
-0.09679384529590607,
1.0845967531204224,
-0.19815078377723694,
-0.050553206354379654,
1.1807773113250732,
-0.29266247153282166,
0.7432146668434143,
0.2665771543979645,
0.016850696876645088,
0.8562717437744141,
0.5844728946685791,
-0.17444759607315063,
0.19621071219444275,
0.3137018382549286,
-0.21444013714790344,
-0.34588250517845154,
-0.475424587726593,
-0.25406312942504883,
0.8761736750602722,
0.5751697421073914,
-0.1563122570514679,
-0.1277795135974884,
-0.16804879903793335,
0.2126624882221222,
0.08079411834478378,
-0.19880294799804688,
0.9908531308174133,
0.09348300099372864,
-0.5496537685394287,
0.7927519679069519,
-0.10089275240898132,
1.1047276258468628,
-0.49698933959007263,
-0.11939334124326706,
-0.6210806369781494,
-0.2381722629070282,
-0.15371859073638916,
-0.9415892362594604,
0.32213905453681946,
0.2555655539035797,
0.4321073591709137,
0.3450959026813507,
0.6651014089584351,
-0.5000890493392944,
-0.35421136021614075,
0.17442156374454498,
0.3961380124092102,
0.5016965866088867,
-0.002443974604830146,
-0.5924303531646729,
0.09118639677762985,
-0.255036324262619,
0.0978337824344635,
0.007990727201104164,
0.5473089814186096,
0.24528814852237701,
0.8124335408210754,
0.6502513289451599,
0.006469062063843012,
-0.3310527801513672,
0.6550900936126709,
0.8752720355987549,
-0.7705878019332886,
-0.587192177772522,
-0.9784910678863525,
0.27964308857917786,
-0.4791278839111328,
-0.31498983502388,
0.7680670619010925,
0.1418340802192688,
0.5404277443885803,
-0.07359371334314346,
0.8258368968963623,
-0.02964639663696289,
0.16104887425899506,
-0.6435591578483582,
0.8088238835334778,
-0.6630119681358337,
0.44187456369400024,
0.037889476865530014,
-0.38805630803108215,
-0.33369699120521545,
0.67843097448349,
-0.2736842930316925,
0.22231991589069366,
0.27080225944519043,
0.7837518453598022,
0.18593014776706696,
-0.017516421154141426,
0.5643271803855896,
0.34456661343574524,
0.1831735074520111,
0.8455947041511536,
1.0221446752548218,
-0.32772669196128845,
0.6616966128349304,
-0.09963943809270859,
-0.15177461504936218,
-0.30417248606681824,
-0.795626163482666,
-1.1660300493240356,
-0.3125709295272827,
-0.24137943983078003,
-0.006817180663347244,
0.04594756290316582,
0.8601067066192627,
0.3923216760158539,
-0.6109341979026794,
-0.058642350137233734,
-0.02365841530263424,
0.2502860724925995,
0.059655655175447464,
-0.3105508089065552,
0.14701426029205322,
-0.8407042026519775,
-1.0259461402893066,
0.4811444878578186,
0.4237288236618042,
0.0409928634762764,
-0.29173341393470764,
0.12656080722808838,
0.18564598262310028,
0.4276241064071655,
0.709545910358429,
0.03176223859190941,
-0.7798736691474915,
-0.23963411152362823,
-0.1466352939605713,
0.10559377074241638,
0.11292964220046997,
0.8993131518363953,
-0.821379542350769,
0.08336656540632248,
0.5462535619735718,
0.669844925403595,
-0.21838998794555664,
0.2081749141216278,
0.39869266748428345,
-0.9020516872406006,
0.2629861533641815,
0.08563897758722305,
0.3492550551891327,
0.6292182207107544,
-0.69125896692276,
0.5922188758850098,
0.19984760880470276,
-0.24945223331451416,
-0.7381222248077393,
0.3453819751739502,
-0.9487470388412476,
-0.3588560223579407,
1.2358132600784302,
-0.09953071177005768,
-0.5969966053962708,
-0.279123455286026,
-0.46603119373321533,
0.16122300922870636,
-0.3534368872642517,
1.2484819889068604,
0.3882386088371277,
0.1706668734550476,
-0.32384878396987915,
-0.6401787996292114,
0.37825894355773926,
0.3945798873901367,
-0.9250997304916382,
0.08202631026506424,
0.3632846474647522,
0.06179540976881981,
0.11430934816598892,
0.6885571479797363,
0.03280167281627655,
0.49077367782592773,
-0.17542724311351776,
-0.33538633584976196,
-0.0738033801317215,
-0.2450963854789734,
-0.4400472640991211,
0.021375445649027824,
-0.2316664755344391,
0.041899606585502625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14129v1
|
AlignGPT: Multi-modal Large Language Models with Adaptive Alignment Capability
| 2024-05-23T03:07:56 | 2024-05-23T03:07:56 |
Fei Zhao, Taotian Pang, Chunhui Li, Zhen Wu, Junjie Guo, Shangyu Xing, Xinyu Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) are widely regarded as crucial in
the exploration of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). The core of MLLMs
lies in their capability to achieve cross-modal alignment. To attain this goal,
current MLLMs typically follow a two-phase training paradigm: the pre-training
phase and the instruction-tuning phase. Despite their success, there are
shortcomings in the modeling of alignment capabilities within these models.
Firstly, during the pre-training phase, the model usually assumes that all
image-text pairs are uniformly aligned, but in fact the degree of alignment
between different image-text pairs is inconsistent. Secondly, the instructions
currently used for finetuning incorporate a variety of tasks, different tasks's
instructions usually require different levels of alignment capabilities, but
previous MLLMs overlook these differentiated alignment needs. To tackle these
issues, we propose a new multimodal large language model AlignGPT. In the
pre-training stage, instead of treating all image-text pairs equally, we assign
different levels of alignment capabilities to different image-text pairs. Then,
in the instruction-tuning phase, we adaptively combine these different levels
of alignment capabilities to meet the dynamic alignment needs of different
instructions. Extensive experimental results show that our model achieves
competitive performance on 12 benchmarks.
|
[
-0.30136504769325256,
-0.7237201929092407,
0.45664700865745544,
0.16996832191944122,
-0.2717669904232025,
0.1115800142288208,
-0.48703083395957947,
-0.38989970088005066,
-0.23532000184059143,
0.0731915831565857,
-0.7007805109024048,
-0.19532591104507446,
-0.8333731293678284,
-0.06093521788716316,
-0.22613488137722015,
1.1387919187545776,
-0.3059188425540924,
0.20810861885547638,
-0.048875823616981506,
-0.39557716250419617,
-0.7885270118713379,
-0.18058764934539795,
-0.4461548626422882,
-0.17112205922603607,
0.4191713035106659,
0.2626689672470093,
1.0330629348754883,
0.7700150609016418,
0.654358983039856,
0.3630734086036682,
0.33490127325057983,
0.24944770336151123,
-0.25375163555145264,
0.023030340671539307,
-0.18907712399959564,
-0.05149655044078827,
-0.663288414478302,
-0.039967991411685944,
0.9948256015777588,
0.4223698079586029,
-0.22160843014717102,
0.03417345881462097,
0.2313871532678604,
0.346666544675827,
-0.5073003172874451,
0.05166284367442131,
-0.7375816106796265,
-0.23071075975894928,
-0.009466246701776981,
0.022340349853038788,
-0.30060869455337524,
-0.06779724359512329,
0.14938881993293762,
-0.8317420482635498,
-0.0031855080742388964,
0.1603371798992157,
0.9227612018585205,
0.45034483075141907,
-0.4025048017501831,
-0.3862113952636719,
-0.6422154307365417,
0.8467869758605957,
-0.7802764177322388,
0.692145586013794,
0.03993982821702957,
0.324172705411911,
0.15102219581604004,
-0.5631254315376282,
-0.8076266050338745,
-0.31068453192710876,
-0.0855792760848999,
-0.015144424512982368,
-0.10270176082849503,
-0.05217882990837097,
0.15550385415554047,
0.08215763419866562,
-0.9118805527687073,
0.31501305103302,
0.021045628935098648,
-0.0649280995130539,
0.4311055541038513,
0.15356190502643585,
0.45661643147468567,
0.11942104995250702,
-0.6836814880371094,
-0.07183443009853363,
-0.3380461037158966,
0.008307546377182007,
0.18571554124355316,
0.39734920859336853,
-0.25787922739982605,
0.6481960415840149,
0.15388017892837524,
0.8993598222732544,
0.47355917096138,
-0.3391261100769043,
0.178299218416214,
-0.5282312631607056,
-0.33450067043304443,
0.0745343565940857,
0.8817940950393677,
0.2554439902305603,
0.14598263800144196,
-0.05269549787044525,
-0.27638015151023865,
-0.031802091747522354,
0.4042861759662628,
-0.6759409308433533,
-0.17189794778823853,
0.09562107920646667,
-0.2918475866317749,
-0.05007554218173027,
-0.1370730847120285,
-0.6784071326255798,
-0.3958379924297333,
-0.6750010251998901,
0.8607681393623352,
-0.7331474423408508,
-0.13064488768577576,
0.0173463337123394,
0.28405076265335083,
0.448413223028183,
0.41866418719291687,
-1.1667397022247314,
-0.03227728232741356,
0.7286551594734192,
0.8073552250862122,
-0.16649018228054047,
-0.7957707047462463,
-0.47365716099739075,
0.3085291385650635,
-0.06519890576601028,
0.5920707583427429,
-0.9563457369804382,
0.009827230125665665,
-0.07147045433521271,
0.13574594259262085,
-0.5199868679046631,
-0.11545935273170471,
0.3803430199623108,
-0.5382536053657532,
0.4814509451389313,
-0.10153123736381531,
-0.4446384012699127,
-0.16316568851470947,
0.423483669757843,
-0.39891839027404785,
0.7538158893585205,
0.19052541255950928,
-0.6976547241210938,
0.2841450870037079,
-0.5936093926429749,
-0.4968067705631256,
-0.06906191259622574,
-0.2594400644302368,
-0.579133927822113,
-0.050122857093811035,
0.38781672716140747,
0.4088495373725891,
-0.263529509305954,
0.4003160297870636,
-0.25558507442474365,
-0.336809366941452,
0.1059577465057373,
-0.5751922726631165,
0.6034289598464966,
0.0882929265499115,
-0.549119770526886,
0.5809908509254456,
-0.6584354639053345,
0.18332993984222412,
-0.03984486311674118,
-0.2916527986526489,
-0.028234893456101418,
0.052998922765254974,
0.10857661068439484,
0.3151017129421234,
0.45980823040008545,
-0.23106126487255096,
0.5688884258270264,
-0.03679810091853142,
0.5221409797668457,
0.8270683884620667,
-0.5240957736968994,
0.8163082599639893,
-0.3541797399520874,
0.5614311695098877,
-0.03407072648406029,
0.2552545964717865,
-0.19158338010311127,
-0.3264060616493225,
-0.70131516456604,
-0.44501373171806335,
0.4026589095592499,
0.8169839978218079,
-0.7435756921768188,
0.5051600933074951,
-0.5818166136741638,
-0.49652498960494995,
-0.7061275839805603,
0.2294546216726303,
0.5497170686721802,
0.43702006340026855,
0.5002848505973816,
-0.3241916596889496,
-0.38962486386299133,
-0.7875112891197205,
-0.02055750973522663,
0.1394837498664856,
0.06681888550519943,
0.1674596667289734,
0.27528589963912964,
-0.33358505368232727,
0.6353908777236938,
-0.15096323192119598,
-0.318162739276886,
0.015777669847011566,
0.204459547996521,
-0.1259506344795227,
0.6995875835418701,
0.496288925409317,
-0.8779578804969788,
-0.590188205242157,
0.47024834156036377,
-0.5867980718612671,
0.0469801165163517,
-0.20828720927238464,
-0.0788787379860878,
0.17101770639419556,
0.36308911442756653,
-0.698031485080719,
-0.09185757488012314,
0.9728574156761169,
-0.3616333603858948,
0.5384318828582764,
-0.3317616879940033,
0.2519795596599579,
-1.247415542602539,
0.1195855587720871,
0.03920745104551315,
-0.3072201907634735,
-0.6093506217002869,
0.21064819395542145,
0.37259289622306824,
-0.20972397923469543,
-0.2388843148946762,
0.3879626393318176,
-0.7054515480995178,
-0.012587767094373703,
-0.37782496213912964,
0.08335955440998077,
0.03173847123980522,
0.5547761917114258,
-0.10987862199544907,
0.9097719788551331,
0.7562770247459412,
-0.3350125551223755,
0.4942018687725067,
0.21807539463043213,
-0.3851749002933502,
0.8124421834945679,
-0.5522937178611755,
0.11935190856456757,
-0.2412160485982895,
0.1396772712469101,
-0.988328754901886,
-0.33367064595222473,
0.29242122173309326,
-0.17878146469593048,
0.7697643637657166,
-0.034422002732753754,
-0.11247794330120087,
-0.04395122826099396,
0.03810332342982292,
0.7056512832641602,
0.41592296957969666,
-0.35353559255599976,
1.0710654258728027,
0.15295597910881042,
-0.3645414412021637,
-0.870510458946228,
-0.31893885135650635,
-0.008084678091108799,
-0.31639209389686584,
-0.6927536725997925,
0.35304489731788635,
-0.09405630081892014,
0.1946456879377365,
0.1396971493959427,
-0.01060069352388382,
-0.0032040798105299473,
-0.19284096360206604,
0.1627688854932785,
0.37126344442367554,
-0.4770602881908417,
0.06397202610969543,
-0.20326103270053864,
-0.009420346468687057,
-0.4423561096191406,
-0.5132870674133301,
0.784326434135437,
-0.19656167924404144,
-0.6700656414031982,
-0.4799748361110687,
0.42645201086997986,
0.8564922213554382,
-0.7658924460411072,
0.846977710723877,
1.0875788927078247,
-0.2069898545742035,
0.1810053288936615,
-0.5994670391082764,
0.2694869935512543,
-0.453591525554657,
0.7116397023200989,
-0.2536871135234833,
-0.9337244629859924,
0.4431980848312378,
0.10645512491464615,
0.17015451192855835,
0.28289803862571716,
0.6219067573547363,
-0.19350549578666687,
1.3757151365280151,
0.6389978528022766,
-0.13096550107002258,
0.7174193859100342,
0.3209105134010315,
0.26989346742630005,
-1.0286579132080078,
-0.09854019433259964,
-0.37719354033470154,
-0.6045554280281067,
-0.5387977957725525,
-0.4112003743648529,
0.3185339868068695,
0.19613321125507355,
-0.6096689105033875,
0.2685404419898987,
-0.4651477634906769,
0.45513075590133667,
0.5375202894210815,
0.14173217117786407,
-0.010201412253081799,
-0.06572437286376953,
0.08317745476961136,
0.047371190041303635,
-0.7044433355331421,
-0.46519455313682556,
0.8304019570350647,
0.2810216248035431,
0.9806256890296936,
0.2468421757221222,
0.19095008075237274,
-0.0954059511423111,
0.26865634322166443,
-0.6070466041564941,
0.3602268397808075,
-0.5063948035240173,
-0.37157776951789856,
-0.5314009189605713,
-0.2460915744304657,
-0.7733698487281799,
0.22124214470386505,
-0.49935200810432434,
-0.6816144585609436,
-0.006032887380570173,
0.27178260684013367,
-0.3802430331707001,
0.28064852952957153,
-0.9182211756706238,
1.3092641830444336,
-0.6452929377555847,
-0.3794530928134918,
0.11486675590276718,
-0.8706826567649841,
0.2669112980365753,
-0.26075124740600586,
0.22152164578437805,
-0.13419951498508453,
-0.017593374475836754,
0.32690855860710144,
0.06934066116809845,
0.9347561597824097,
-0.14736899733543396,
-0.28776001930236816,
0.06783007830381393,
-0.026776162907481194,
0.7235312461853027,
-0.26630815863609314,
0.16152939200401306,
-0.1652044951915741,
0.0003070615348406136,
-0.4265083372592926,
-0.670203447341919,
0.7278043031692505,
-0.8090121746063232,
-0.6672816276550293,
-0.16929182410240173,
-0.993781328201294,
-0.26106810569763184,
0.3457091748714447,
0.22259756922721863,
0.4874367415904999,
-0.1397956758737564,
0.13049711287021637,
0.48521822690963745,
0.05496860295534134,
0.5335096716880798,
0.3268246352672577,
-0.13358251750469208,
-0.5056205987930298,
1.0333207845687866,
-0.03409447893500328,
0.47835400700569153,
0.3147691488265991,
0.0180815439671278,
-0.358757883310318,
-0.5968507528305054,
-0.7455799579620361,
0.022661099210381508,
-0.5768195390701294,
-0.12016510218381882,
-0.4462273418903351,
-0.07139797508716583,
-0.5573714971542358,
-0.1937420666217804,
-0.33256298303604126,
-0.1292683333158493,
-0.31058382987976074,
0.42324116826057434,
-0.06391286849975586,
0.5270566344261169,
0.17263109982013702,
0.470896452665329,
-1.0055713653564453,
0.2718784511089325,
0.5663018226623535,
0.5066735744476318,
-0.047625377774238586,
-0.6776590347290039,
-0.198018416762352,
0.28407666087150574,
-0.3860611617565155,
-0.7374387979507446,
0.15221652388572693,
0.494021475315094,
0.4884440004825592,
0.3648013472557068,
-0.3960764408111572,
0.9782760739326477,
-0.8678907155990601,
0.6397188305854797,
0.349273145198822,
-1.02793288230896,
0.1538713425397873,
-0.5292699337005615,
0.6230960488319397,
0.3687092661857605,
0.44738397002220154,
-0.5546153783798218,
-0.12036058306694031,
-0.22930121421813965,
-0.5823571681976318,
0.626230776309967,
-0.06848147511482239,
0.11999323964118958,
0.32473865151405334,
0.12505456805229187,
0.16112741827964783,
0.1590140014886856,
-0.9169894456863403,
0.24357783794403076,
-0.31447723507881165,
-0.7497004866600037,
-0.27633851766586304,
-0.14683084189891815,
-0.33376413583755493,
-0.22880513966083527,
0.7709618806838989,
-0.36030492186546326,
0.17974314093589783,
-0.09129606932401657,
-0.26185211539268494,
-0.19028279185295105,
0.3899470269680023,
1.0261770486831665,
0.7586613893508911,
0.10465899854898453,
0.15766112506389618,
0.0718311071395874,
-0.47884902358055115,
0.3468349277973175,
0.48999932408332825,
-0.0350789949297905,
-0.4606557786464691,
0.45832133293151855,
1.1906890869140625,
0.3369065523147583,
-0.5492161512374878,
0.5904406905174255,
0.00018646326498128474,
-0.17786486446857452,
-0.020816218107938766,
0.07406128197908401,
0.09666836261749268,
0.6729755401611328,
0.15048731863498688,
0.2292030155658722,
-0.4522702991962433,
-0.47349560260772705,
0.117402583360672,
0.8337396383285522,
-0.42077329754829407,
-0.30295810103416443,
0.7750679850578308,
0.023622414097189903,
-0.3096288740634918,
0.6749783158302307,
-0.10165005922317505,
-0.6293703317642212,
0.3010239601135254,
0.7639434337615967,
0.7253674268722534,
-0.5028277635574341,
0.058718644082546234,
0.13754728436470032,
0.3912819027900696,
-0.12197411805391312,
0.051540717482566833,
0.23233771324157715,
-0.870494544506073,
-0.6676117777824402,
-0.7890585064888,
-0.03184190392494202,
-0.0008387108682654798,
-0.3706895411014557,
0.28069260716438293,
-0.25447583198547363,
-0.028149880468845367,
0.10505345463752747,
-0.41879332065582275,
-0.6951761841773987,
0.1798008531332016,
0.17734850943088531,
0.5268142223358154,
-0.821890652179718,
0.9516399502754211,
0.9179665446281433,
-0.2054659128189087,
-1.0014739036560059,
0.036531317979097366,
-0.04535899683833122,
-0.923326849937439,
0.4194154441356659,
0.19530315697193146,
0.017471112310886383,
0.2204936146736145,
-0.4711606800556183,
-1.0592068433761597,
1.1766067743301392,
0.49578872323036194,
-0.698433518409729,
-0.3875328302383423,
0.15995030105113983,
0.34041354060173035,
-0.5948329567909241,
-0.05803333595395088,
0.3126419484615326,
0.6291975975036621,
0.05205390229821205,
-1.3345509767532349,
-0.018664197996258736,
-0.17575620114803314,
-0.13538606464862823,
0.45666664838790894,
-0.6741601228713989,
1.0447918176651,
-0.14178968966007233,
-0.27375736832618713,
0.10956770926713943,
0.5440353751182556,
-0.02796659618616104,
0.0651848167181015,
0.6100540161132812,
0.8542271852493286,
0.619709312915802,
-0.16117796301841736,
0.8416813015937805,
-0.21969783306121826,
0.3320273160934448,
1.3079925775527954,
-0.39516952633857727,
0.7780635952949524,
0.3582743704319,
0.07939166575670242,
0.2815245985984802,
0.3604072332382202,
-0.17184671759605408,
0.5173810124397278,
-0.30360743403434753,
-0.24570685625076294,
-0.42636948823928833,
0.09254390746355057,
-0.46886780858039856,
0.7280702590942383,
0.05406900495290756,
-0.34644177556037903,
-0.1574925184249878,
0.16443830728530884,
-0.3053169548511505,
-0.07124725729227066,
-0.4270882308483124,
0.8212007284164429,
-0.35253190994262695,
-0.8432595133781433,
0.643072783946991,
-0.07748432457447052,
0.622613787651062,
-0.7893134951591492,
0.03752099350094795,
0.20063219964504242,
0.16935469210147858,
-0.10668926686048508,
-0.8120242953300476,
0.045045286417007446,
-0.14926376938819885,
-0.24669168889522552,
-0.028341831639409065,
0.6205044388771057,
-0.8332587480545044,
-0.5295442342758179,
-0.056228529661893845,
0.41522452235221863,
-0.3681993782520294,
0.07879605144262314,
-0.802937924861908,
0.21574334800243378,
0.05094946175813675,
-0.06813760101795197,
0.5520063042640686,
0.4517836570739746,
-0.13473106920719147,
0.6052464246749878,
0.5702942609786987,
-0.21228986978530884,
0.3679175078868866,
-0.024697845801711082,
0.8241504430770874,
-0.4146827459335327,
-0.32215753197669983,
-0.9937207102775574,
0.732137143611908,
0.10633476823568344,
-0.2643110156059265,
0.5742682218551636,
0.30297914147377014,
0.7795056104660034,
-0.11530222743749619,
0.6816545724868774,
-0.15501101315021515,
0.04198417812585831,
-0.7933308482170105,
0.5812318921089172,
-0.6865671873092651,
-0.08970072865486145,
-0.17986458539962769,
-1.2496323585510254,
-0.3062826991081238,
0.5517151355743408,
-0.1287776678800583,
0.24533362686634064,
0.5943791270256042,
0.7151491641998291,
-0.40437087416648865,
0.013560584746301174,
0.23281708359718323,
0.13417914509773254,
0.2994993329048157,
0.6652923822402954,
0.8374572992324829,
-0.3650590181350708,
0.570512592792511,
-0.03280041366815567,
-0.23682467639446259,
-0.029563328251242638,
-1.0717923641204834,
-0.7356669306755066,
-0.7656080722808838,
-0.12873829901218414,
0.005008567124605179,
0.014642813242971897,
0.9305914640426636,
0.753749430179596,
-0.7126615643501282,
0.07950662821531296,
0.17243102192878723,
-0.29066476225852966,
-0.2945278584957123,
-0.14698603749275208,
0.3892163932323456,
-0.4102635383605957,
-0.8644765615463257,
0.3279879689216614,
0.3214243948459625,
0.30027416348457336,
-0.18137218058109283,
-0.1491960883140564,
-0.4293712377548218,
-0.2080329954624176,
0.4837242364883423,
0.269212931394577,
-0.7645851373672485,
-0.6610718965530396,
-0.037166938185691833,
-0.30665260553359985,
0.15395373106002808,
0.7720032334327698,
-0.30345460772514343,
0.474984735250473,
0.2001822292804718,
0.914014995098114,
0.1070064902305603,
0.28652486205101013,
0.6218252778053284,
-0.8111467957496643,
0.2156711369752884,
0.08038411289453506,
0.38536709547042847,
0.3675616383552551,
-0.24993008375167847,
0.16552786529064178,
-0.15088312327861786,
-0.9184339642524719,
-0.5025606751441956,
0.3741796016693115,
-1.209594964981079,
-0.2350963056087494,
0.9947211742401123,
-0.03246772289276123,
-0.07946823537349701,
0.2427913397550583,
-0.4947695732116699,
0.46480029821395874,
-0.05702546238899231,
0.6384559869766235,
0.8669689893722534,
-0.0787961557507515,
-0.32649022340774536,
-0.46217042207717896,
0.35459670424461365,
0.565759539604187,
-0.5776607394218445,
0.08090097457170486,
0.6262171268463135,
0.2549840211868286,
0.28526341915130615,
0.30341774225234985,
0.06961426883935928,
0.2724488079547882,
-0.1997811645269394,
0.016254518181085587,
-0.14066487550735474,
-0.36686620116233826,
-0.46650195121765137,
0.26797521114349365,
0.15229851007461548,
-0.19106513261795044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14125v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14125v2
|
ALI-Agent: Assessing LLMs' Alignment with Human Values via Agent-based Evaluation
| 2024-05-23T02:57:42 | 2024-05-24T06:38:49 |
Jingnan Zheng, Han Wang, An Zhang, Tai D. Nguyen, Jun Sun, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can elicit unintended and even harmful content
when misaligned with human values, posing severe risks to users and society. To
mitigate these risks, current evaluation benchmarks predominantly employ
expert-designed contextual scenarios to assess how well LLMs align with human
values. However, the labor-intensive nature of these benchmarks limits their
test scope, hindering their ability to generalize to the extensive variety of
open-world use cases and identify rare but crucial long-tail risks.
Additionally, these static tests fail to adapt to the rapid evolution of LLMs,
making it hard to evaluate timely alignment issues. To address these
challenges, we propose ALI-Agent, an evaluation framework that leverages the
autonomous abilities of LLM-powered agents to conduct in-depth and adaptive
alignment assessments. ALI-Agent operates through two principal stages:
Emulation and Refinement. During the Emulation stage, ALI-Agent automates the
generation of realistic test scenarios. In the Refinement stage, it iteratively
refines the scenarios to probe long-tail risks. Specifically, ALI-Agent
incorporates a memory module to guide test scenario generation, a tool-using
module to reduce human labor in tasks such as evaluating feedback from target
LLMs, and an action module to refine tests. Extensive experiments across three
aspects of human values--stereotypes, morality, and legality--demonstrate that
ALI-Agent, as a general evaluation framework, effectively identifies model
misalignment. Systematic analysis also validates that the generated test
scenarios represent meaningful use cases, as well as integrate enhanced
measures to probe long-tail risks. Our code is available at
https://github.com/SophieZheng998/ALI-Agent.git
|
[
-0.1767641007900238,
-0.5288682579994202,
0.4517979323863983,
-0.028795715421438217,
0.07917235046625137,
0.3916531801223755,
-0.11136779189109802,
-0.5563273429870605,
0.09359968453645706,
0.4735901951789856,
-0.5520204305648804,
-0.3548312187194824,
-0.17669892311096191,
-0.06747189909219742,
-0.2592155933380127,
0.821868360042572,
-0.2475784569978714,
-0.09788014739751816,
-0.1477929800748825,
-0.3715580105781555,
-0.48201850056648254,
-0.13951478898525238,
-0.5504069328308105,
-0.3675535023212433,
0.41515102982521057,
0.40363574028015137,
1.0277869701385498,
0.7130809426307678,
0.5304285287857056,
0.3257378339767456,
0.2190466821193695,
0.13952168822288513,
-0.21485535800457,
0.22578425705432892,
-0.37098705768585205,
-0.20784568786621094,
-0.8085600137710571,
0.12231617420911789,
0.616734504699707,
0.5486729741096497,
-0.21368004381656647,
0.44445401430130005,
0.022949669510126114,
0.7514837384223938,
-0.8072425127029419,
-0.17464600503444672,
-0.57143235206604,
-0.13015128672122955,
-0.02570085972547531,
-0.024482756853103638,
-0.30324190855026245,
-0.33321839570999146,
0.036745261400938034,
-0.32625681161880493,
-0.35158684849739075,
0.2102746069431305,
1.1237682104110718,
0.6255379319190979,
-0.7420396208763123,
-0.06704153120517731,
-0.5694118738174438,
0.8710955381393433,
-0.5945147275924683,
0.34443989396095276,
0.1850622445344925,
0.5555024743080139,
-0.3989843726158142,
-0.35054269433021545,
-0.6211845874786377,
-0.350873738527298,
0.21225020289421082,
0.11498257517814636,
-0.1442466527223587,
0.1556001454591751,
0.07858480513095856,
-0.06462439894676208,
-0.5706121325492859,
0.3319634199142456,
-0.00557841919362545,
-0.32249557971954346,
1.0780303478240967,
0.40377628803253174,
0.3585127890110016,
-0.002766029443591833,
-0.5361073613166809,
-0.21324898302555084,
-0.7129608988761902,
0.36980175971984863,
0.5535526871681213,
0.2957874536514282,
0.1286279261112213,
0.6174132823944092,
0.03477449342608452,
0.6023262143135071,
0.3236957788467407,
-0.2397148162126541,
0.37753280997276306,
-0.28248435258865356,
-0.2027965486049652,
0.18371857702732086,
0.6961723566055298,
0.7304090261459351,
0.31074878573417664,
-0.10000373423099518,
-0.3890661895275116,
-0.07445545494556427,
0.4743695855140686,
-0.721279501914978,
0.5223653316497803,
0.522624135017395,
-0.3111487627029419,
-0.2174680233001709,
0.04098949208855629,
-0.7688630819320679,
-0.7588116526603699,
-0.3467503488063812,
0.49030449986457825,
-0.23913462460041046,
-0.00002894501631089952,
0.11706901341676712,
0.21706044673919678,
0.5884406566619873,
0.3332611322402954,
-0.5121764540672302,
0.2722243368625641,
0.746547281742096,
0.6177788972854614,
-0.27771273255348206,
-0.5476751923561096,
-0.7578527331352234,
0.16885441541671753,
-0.37592819333076477,
0.8080559968948364,
-0.3421647548675537,
-0.008419087156653404,
-0.03896629810333252,
0.03889745846390724,
-0.013395506888628006,
-0.5655232667922974,
0.6030761003494263,
-0.5444097518920898,
-0.13755060732364655,
-0.12898100912570953,
-0.6179763674736023,
-0.06217046454548836,
0.4451662302017212,
-0.701172411441803,
1.025589108467102,
0.1926824450492859,
-0.41388973593711853,
0.3061709702014923,
-0.7732516527175903,
-0.3017684519290924,
-0.06916099786758423,
-0.2213638722896576,
-0.5158973932266235,
-0.2568545341491699,
0.03338778391480446,
0.33482080698013306,
-0.5255546569824219,
0.21220286190509796,
-0.20767223834991455,
-0.6503429412841797,
0.3755534887313843,
-0.3506767153739929,
0.731086790561676,
0.17707490921020508,
-0.5476852655410767,
0.3865453898906708,
-0.6666911840438843,
0.19711776077747345,
0.03480948880314827,
-0.1107265055179596,
-0.1654888242483139,
0.14380384981632233,
-0.095713309943676,
0.26405924558639526,
0.35987740755081177,
-0.34012505412101746,
0.2293073534965515,
-0.5141096115112305,
0.07365331053733826,
0.953413188457489,
-0.0367114394903183,
0.5580593943595886,
-0.7428311109542847,
0.9283521175384521,
-0.11541500687599182,
0.18229790031909943,
0.05631435289978981,
-0.1585574746131897,
-0.6166197061538696,
-0.25472816824913025,
0.2428969144821167,
0.7433385848999023,
-0.37284746766090393,
0.9168573617935181,
-0.42166078090667725,
-0.628033459186554,
-0.8488295078277588,
0.3771795630455017,
0.30258163809776306,
0.2825285792350769,
0.11049974709749222,
-0.5014569163322449,
-0.2696385681629181,
-0.9106131196022034,
-0.37810689210891724,
-0.48811304569244385,
-0.07552853226661682,
-0.009844111278653145,
0.5953564643859863,
-0.587914228439331,
1.1370185613632202,
-0.12127752602100372,
-0.21988804638385773,
0.017667530104517937,
0.03282538056373596,
-0.08367718011140823,
0.33931002020835876,
0.35182633996009827,
-0.4476044476032257,
-0.3712809383869171,
0.15087711811065674,
-0.4475818872451782,
-0.42097896337509155,
-0.34184855222702026,
-0.1930491179227829,
0.2817349433898926,
0.2669772207736969,
-0.5852213501930237,
0.5257891416549683,
0.49853280186653137,
-0.46876001358032227,
0.6375713348388672,
0.031556807458400726,
0.2107934057712555,
-1.0549101829528809,
0.16556861996650696,
-0.19672803580760956,
-0.37479984760284424,
-0.36456355452537537,
0.08810011297464371,
0.1063954085111618,
0.13077300786972046,
-0.5133612751960754,
0.9171266555786133,
-0.46470847725868225,
-0.3838576376438141,
-0.3748084306716919,
0.2232031673192978,
0.27885183691978455,
0.17774823307991028,
-0.3930039703845978,
0.9568700790405273,
0.07057172805070877,
-0.256996750831604,
0.460113525390625,
-0.0195930115878582,
-0.3931170403957367,
0.7925962805747986,
-0.4166872799396515,
0.22779403626918793,
0.021595655009150505,
0.13194820284843445,
-0.7411168813705444,
-0.10396098345518112,
0.2525014579296112,
-0.26749852299690247,
0.09821712970733643,
0.008410296402871609,
-0.48883989453315735,
-0.013653069734573364,
-0.5304088592529297,
0.4336467683315277,
0.46681344509124756,
-0.3097257912158966,
0.8597442507743835,
0.4298993647098541,
-0.05194380506873131,
-0.9740819931030273,
-0.2039288729429245,
0.09660866111516953,
-0.5304873585700989,
-0.7991910576820374,
0.21264708042144775,
-0.20797719061374664,
-0.6018810272216797,
-0.004992192145437002,
-0.16217513382434845,
-0.010220239870250225,
0.45004478096961975,
0.47045576572418213,
0.13549070060253143,
0.015227360650897026,
0.36755603551864624,
0.05746405944228172,
-0.06453998386859894,
0.08020313084125519,
-0.027430826798081398,
0.28232401609420776,
-0.46239081025123596,
-0.7167335748672485,
-0.4276794195175171,
0.1572459638118744,
0.7487338185310364,
-0.3709200620651245,
0.4796684980392456,
0.5194395780563354,
-0.45658260583877563,
-0.22783660888671875,
-0.5792304277420044,
0.06257998943328857,
-0.46508392691612244,
0.5267164707183838,
-0.23276564478874207,
-0.512664258480072,
0.6430548429489136,
-0.2670130431652069,
0.18782708048820496,
0.32551735639572144,
0.7334245443344116,
-0.25817957520484924,
0.963127076625824,
0.39440733194351196,
-0.16064845025539398,
0.32540348172187805,
0.05798128619790077,
0.01646541617810726,
-0.8146750926971436,
0.04603371024131775,
-0.2920967638492584,
-0.43161076307296753,
-0.357099324464798,
-0.5140593647956848,
0.3085562586784363,
-0.11086046695709229,
-0.6890590190887451,
0.20481424033641815,
-0.2791340947151184,
0.7094423770904541,
0.06936775147914886,
-0.1532081961631775,
0.31849783658981323,
-0.3519379198551178,
-0.020710062235593796,
0.12833738327026367,
-0.08314935117959976,
-1.073925495147705,
1.164361834526062,
0.6316074728965759,
0.8314831256866455,
0.23233895003795624,
0.5695658922195435,
0.5678241848945618,
0.5583134293556213,
-0.9660392999649048,
0.4555446207523346,
0.5245605111122131,
-0.7031940221786499,
-0.49417415261268616,
-0.10292457044124603,
-1.2381806373596191,
0.24680544435977936,
-0.08210732787847519,
-0.8787574172019958,
0.005297986324876547,
-0.06393376737833023,
-0.5618800520896912,
0.032837875187397,
-0.6635603904724121,
0.9676233530044556,
-0.809087336063385,
-0.6113362312316895,
-0.015845423564314842,
-0.7927448153495789,
0.13499781489372253,
-0.3181220293045044,
0.17226548492908478,
-0.43741318583488464,
-0.3748229742050171,
0.582233190536499,
-0.41261187195777893,
0.8345915079116821,
-0.03749595209956169,
-0.3369410037994385,
0.31772884726524353,
0.17325733602046967,
0.511775553226471,
-0.1496439129114151,
-0.38038134574890137,
-0.12333627790212631,
0.1855235993862152,
-0.4660954475402832,
-0.7635299563407898,
0.48186779022216797,
-0.9398289322853088,
-0.6487930417060852,
-0.6223445534706116,
-0.6793389916419983,
-0.2798215448856354,
0.16997380554676056,
-0.3543526530265808,
-0.18056051433086395,
-0.45839670300483704,
-0.2319330871105194,
0.14147572219371796,
-0.19266824424266815,
0.1477653980255127,
0.6949674487113953,
-0.34538596868515015,
-0.2352409064769745,
0.6944666504859924,
-0.06316950917243958,
0.37413570284843445,
0.09349378198385239,
0.10636187344789505,
-0.2502152919769287,
-0.36776694655418396,
-0.5238543152809143,
0.06439719349145889,
-0.6827889084815979,
-0.3972242474555969,
-0.021967384964227676,
-0.1014343723654747,
-0.20952588319778442,
-0.3609108626842499,
-0.5854527950286865,
-0.025545544922351837,
-0.063250333070755,
-0.1264886111021042,
0.11980268359184265,
0.496449738740921,
0.16372230648994446,
0.31896376609802246,
-0.7738487124443054,
-0.05770443007349968,
0.23457521200180054,
0.24468503892421722,
-0.04198014363646507,
-0.4843314290046692,
-0.36411306262016296,
0.08631619811058044,
-0.6497271060943604,
-0.9472320079803467,
0.4115573465824127,
0.07879196107387543,
0.5124084949493408,
0.5804205536842346,
0.22983714938163757,
0.7828684449195862,
-0.4377836585044861,
0.5084662437438965,
-0.15850529074668884,
-1.23870050907135,
0.296897828578949,
-0.17941336333751678,
0.0019251605262979865,
0.9589308500289917,
0.1579742580652237,
-0.4120068848133087,
-0.1730487048625946,
-0.30546945333480835,
-0.7521155476570129,
0.42382991313934326,
0.23049992322921753,
-0.19703221321105957,
0.32713571190834045,
0.4512752890586853,
-0.03791070729494095,
0.10265129804611206,
-0.6519442796707153,
0.00228104367852211,
0.0650724545121193,
-0.48899251222610474,
-0.04080487787723541,
0.15693460404872894,
-0.3335060179233551,
-0.07745464146137238,
0.5702993869781494,
-0.3830871284008026,
0.022839514538645744,
0.16259832680225372,
-0.39552485942840576,
-0.4179740846157074,
0.5058961510658264,
0.4781486988067627,
0.7139678001403809,
-0.4780969023704529,
-0.02688431367278099,
0.3177674114704132,
-0.24058224260807037,
0.7182286381721497,
0.3287350833415985,
0.029807904735207558,
-0.5113158822059631,
0.46245285868644714,
0.4203134775161743,
-0.05584268271923065,
-1.2563302516937256,
0.8387354016304016,
-0.044849757105112076,
0.23208311200141907,
-0.614263117313385,
0.014163724146783352,
0.14394153654575348,
0.4888651669025421,
0.25592002272605896,
-0.2187911570072174,
0.07243883609771729,
-0.6689387559890747,
0.2769317924976349,
0.46530768275260925,
-0.47229260206222534,
-0.3658119738101959,
0.37831974029541016,
0.32608649134635925,
-0.49982401728630066,
0.450710654258728,
-0.45750442147254944,
-0.498683899641037,
0.9366618394851685,
0.3437589406967163,
1.0344767570495605,
-0.3896711766719818,
0.018620088696479797,
-0.008800921961665154,
0.541023850440979,
0.0937587320804596,
0.18749861419200897,
0.23476926982402802,
-1.0111663341522217,
-0.38776931166648865,
-0.46745121479034424,
-0.6021182537078857,
-0.19211702048778534,
-0.5920596718788147,
0.29146140813827515,
-0.34423911571502686,
-0.35870349407196045,
-0.28291499614715576,
0.43212851881980896,
-0.6691815257072449,
0.015538248233497143,
0.09399212151765823,
0.7043647766113281,
-0.7929169535636902,
0.7931162714958191,
0.8692263960838318,
-0.3606444299221039,
-0.7741605639457703,
0.2902235686779022,
0.3410058617591858,
-0.9086443185806274,
0.5455818176269531,
0.49375367164611816,
-0.34013235569000244,
-0.31122446060180664,
-0.24865995347499847,
-0.762790322303772,
1.5261924266815186,
0.6969229578971863,
-0.5867906212806702,
0.05126045644283295,
0.30123740434646606,
0.663940966129303,
-0.6367518901824951,
0.5599642395973206,
0.758804440498352,
0.6831565499305725,
-0.19977562129497528,
-1.0465469360351562,
0.18549494445323944,
-0.2530445158481598,
-0.2576411962509155,
0.2530326247215271,
-0.8405412435531616,
0.5473524928092957,
-0.18334780633449554,
-0.276930034160614,
0.1335533857345581,
0.4294812083244324,
0.34219592809677124,
0.5210832357406616,
0.7856451869010925,
0.555546224117279,
0.933998703956604,
0.277902752161026,
0.9135434627532959,
-0.41808053851127625,
0.2721337378025055,
1.1294004917144775,
-1.0568245649337769,
0.8468369245529175,
0.47107213735580444,
-0.06024889647960663,
0.6351658701896667,
0.6149520874023438,
0.05867093428969383,
0.05531148239970207,
0.5312566161155701,
-0.165669783949852,
-0.2655412554740906,
-0.31829923391342163,
-0.056427016854286194,
0.7372648119926453,
0.15496675670146942,
-0.08451881259679794,
-0.0274770837277174,
-0.3414340019226074,
-0.05110153555870056,
0.20672233402729034,
-0.1298462301492691,
0.5003858804702759,
-0.0884975716471672,
-0.723084032535553,
0.4043700098991394,
-0.020396605134010315,
0.3405802547931671,
-0.48406678438186646,
0.07556453347206116,
-0.17595311999320984,
0.31994393467903137,
-0.14837785065174103,
-0.6868343949317932,
0.3018280863761902,
0.025455884635448456,
0.16157281398773193,
-0.11821865290403366,
0.5664991736412048,
-0.233306884765625,
-0.3372219204902649,
0.6389399766921997,
0.6626973748207092,
0.0639573261141777,
-0.059158146381378174,
-0.8624516129493713,
0.138388991355896,
-0.23034849762916565,
-0.33653977513313293,
0.44068071246147156,
0.26947709918022156,
-0.36041995882987976,
0.9084454774856567,
0.3179531693458557,
0.010758433490991592,
-0.2992551624774933,
-0.019068973138928413,
0.627345860004425,
-0.8940612077713013,
-0.07412146776914597,
-0.9228634834289551,
0.6237429976463318,
0.07830224931240082,
-0.2351592481136322,
0.5191028714179993,
0.506186842918396,
0.6213840246200562,
0.3708875775337219,
0.5300245881080627,
0.28928542137145996,
0.2326391488313675,
-0.34014827013015747,
0.8459854125976562,
-0.8176397681236267,
0.4267532527446747,
-0.36845988035202026,
-0.8409174084663391,
-0.1806119978427887,
0.4538089334964752,
-0.1759462058544159,
0.06927710771560669,
0.5391740202903748,
0.8553317785263062,
0.2525711953639984,
-0.4634260833263397,
0.3356386423110962,
0.024739643558859825,
0.43558692932128906,
0.7169538736343384,
1.2424030303955078,
-0.484470009803772,
0.388651043176651,
0.06645219027996063,
-0.22720971703529358,
-0.19177702069282532,
-1.119725227355957,
-0.9043925404548645,
-0.522685170173645,
-0.30372557044029236,
-0.2662299573421478,
0.1784835159778595,
1.485453724861145,
0.5264711380004883,
-0.5569619536399841,
-0.5898360013961792,
0.3416718542575836,
0.3257068991661072,
-0.311837762594223,
-0.24228565394878387,
0.4786655604839325,
-0.1220741868019104,
-0.6970232725143433,
0.29945242404937744,
0.301345556974411,
0.004419462755322456,
-0.3904816210269928,
-0.34220626950263977,
-0.12483333796262741,
0.2972370982170105,
0.30599716305732727,
0.23192369937896729,
-0.7518554329872131,
-0.5662966966629028,
-0.09811881929636002,
-0.256931871175766,
0.11038166284561157,
0.3547159731388092,
-0.6306861042976379,
0.5198168754577637,
0.15967977046966553,
1.0575406551361084,
-0.19429533183574677,
0.3896384537220001,
0.6956751942634583,
-0.4797928035259247,
-0.018955130130052567,
0.44759178161621094,
0.42548084259033203,
0.21326844394207,
-0.441354900598526,
0.5462128520011902,
-0.25233355164527893,
-0.8666362762451172,
-0.9059653282165527,
0.23245611786842346,
-1.1800113916397095,
0.02705894410610199,
1.0562890768051147,
-0.18304064869880676,
-0.26941558718681335,
-0.05921482294797897,
-0.21817664802074432,
0.24270418286323547,
-0.4868662655353546,
0.9518067240715027,
0.7138199210166931,
-0.06911861896514893,
0.14576008915901184,
-0.46051540970802307,
0.22196556627750397,
0.5544793009757996,
-1.0052008628845215,
0.015409659594297409,
0.46145886182785034,
0.29448336362838745,
0.16871781647205353,
0.38015511631965637,
0.1222008764743805,
0.3280709385871887,
-0.4004005491733551,
0.5187727808952332,
0.056674737483263016,
-0.09303177893161774,
-0.5921422839164734,
-0.10017171502113342,
0.4239077568054199,
-0.07760442793369293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14117v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14117v1
|
Knowledge Localization: Mission Not Accomplished? Enter Query Localization!
| 2024-05-23T02:44:12 | 2024-05-23T02:44:12 |
Yuheng Chen, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) store extensive factual knowledge, but the
mechanisms behind how they store and express this knowledge remain unclear. The
Knowledge Neuron (KN) thesis is a prominent theory for explaining these
mechanisms. This theory is based on the knowledge localization (KL) assumption,
which suggests that a fact can be localized to a few knowledge storage units,
namely knowledge neurons. However, this assumption may be overly strong
regarding knowledge storage and neglects knowledge expression mechanisms. Thus,
we re-examine the KL assumption and confirm the existence of facts that do not
adhere to it from both statistical and knowledge modification perspectives.
Furthermore, we propose the Query Localization (QL) assumption. (1) Query-KN
Mapping: The localization results are associated with the query rather than the
fact. (2) Dynamic KN Selection: The attention module contributes to the
selection of KNs for answering a query. Based on this, we further propose the
Consistency-Aware KN modification method, which improves the performance of
knowledge modification. We conduct 39 sets of experiments, along with
additional visualization experiments, to rigorously validate our conclusions.
|
[
-0.1281414031982422,
-0.7585563659667969,
0.7553630471229553,
0.050240784883499146,
0.12041459232568741,
0.064364954829216,
-0.40477314591407776,
-0.37635916471481323,
0.31283169984817505,
0.26915493607521057,
-0.10966982692480087,
-0.5380001664161682,
-0.41498664021492004,
-0.07714762538671494,
-0.26368844509124756,
0.6450141668319702,
0.05471290275454521,
0.05928368493914604,
-0.6583049893379211,
-0.205069437623024,
-0.3832104802131653,
-0.6118943691253662,
-0.5773952007293701,
-0.4737175703048706,
0.667596697807312,
0.27073222398757935,
0.6669043898582458,
0.5621622800827026,
0.35847005248069763,
0.2634313702583313,
-0.4955711364746094,
0.10897289961576462,
-0.432033896446228,
0.2512034475803375,
-0.015585629269480705,
-1.090307593345642,
-0.21411648392677307,
-0.38707178831100464,
0.6860151886940002,
1.0685299634933472,
-0.1114121824502945,
-0.15951038897037506,
-0.3248506784439087,
0.7899983525276184,
-0.5870650410652161,
0.14015395939350128,
-0.767839789390564,
0.059009287506341934,
0.206918865442276,
0.09435653686523438,
-0.279520183801651,
-0.507146954536438,
0.39800897240638733,
-0.7044238448143005,
0.439453125,
-0.0332515574991703,
0.7993141412734985,
0.25255686044692993,
-0.6582697033882141,
0.08642850816249847,
-0.765308141708374,
0.7403215765953064,
-0.8354411721229553,
0.4778030514717102,
0.643235445022583,
0.23382392525672913,
-0.364013671875,
-0.4008425176143646,
-0.5982714891433716,
-0.37814953923225403,
-0.27066168189048767,
0.08426399528980255,
0.09895786643028259,
0.10561323165893555,
0.6183501482009888,
0.11100934445858002,
-0.2452886402606964,
-0.13482116162776947,
-0.24484148621559143,
-0.4290536344051361,
0.37971699237823486,
-0.04561978578567505,
0.28990983963012695,
-0.1265990436077118,
-0.25229454040527344,
0.06065235286951065,
-0.7843783497810364,
0.11386102437973022,
0.14368057250976562,
0.13623201847076416,
-0.015907403081655502,
0.6458558440208435,
-0.6411170959472656,
0.8568878769874573,
-0.042225152254104614,
-0.2827770411968231,
0.044432055205106735,
-0.2512717843055725,
-0.038310643285512924,
0.2943771779537201,
0.7182812690734863,
0.31572800874710083,
0.1860264241695404,
-0.532724916934967,
-0.13755156099796295,
0.055327221751213074,
0.30864807963371277,
-0.4146060049533844,
-0.16590435802936554,
0.22992362082004547,
-0.34990495443344116,
-0.24352815747261047,
-0.3579552173614502,
-0.3408794701099396,
-0.46248897910118103,
-0.2491389662027359,
0.42180246114730835,
-0.31282997131347656,
-0.23972474038600922,
0.06704245507717133,
-0.1811205893754959,
0.14558260142803192,
0.19334806501865387,
-1.0139333009719849,
0.19484806060791016,
0.401210218667984,
0.5620937943458557,
-0.26772716641426086,
-0.3344959020614624,
0.2965797781944275,
0.43651285767555237,
-0.7593395113945007,
0.7724061608314514,
-0.38322901725769043,
-0.2294260859489441,
0.09626271575689316,
-0.05026913806796074,
-0.18512317538261414,
-0.6964178681373596,
0.24131463468074799,
-1.0845458507537842,
-0.1360883265733719,
-1.061811089515686,
-0.678605318069458,
-0.37249884009361267,
0.40521204471588135,
-0.4641554653644562,
0.8200147151947021,
0.03282534331083298,
-0.6696099042892456,
0.39279240369796753,
-0.5695635676383972,
-0.6026831865310669,
-0.41211119294166565,
-0.12090878188610077,
0.01581103727221489,
0.33568304777145386,
0.01748061552643776,
0.1472848355770111,
0.008165454491972923,
0.36953139305114746,
-0.25945836305618286,
-0.34474873542785645,
0.43392449617385864,
-0.10640500485897064,
0.42662864923477173,
-0.07554624229669571,
-0.3109495937824249,
-0.044641245156526566,
-0.4955040216445923,
-0.1198653131723404,
0.06888572871685028,
-0.6548569202423096,
-0.3436115086078644,
0.23059885203838348,
-0.6158660054206848,
0.00014813766756560653,
0.5463373064994812,
-0.6949344873428345,
0.5316144824028015,
-0.5672959089279175,
0.20704202353954315,
0.42354437708854675,
0.008419369347393513,
0.9144155979156494,
-0.08617465198040009,
0.2808149755001068,
0.2096470296382904,
0.07944976538419724,
0.25856688618659973,
-0.40453192591667175,
-0.9595619440078735,
0.3904273808002472,
0.40721070766448975,
0.3127555251121521,
-0.766843318939209,
-0.12471174448728561,
-0.3836999535560608,
-0.31383758783340454,
-0.20776401460170746,
-0.2085724025964737,
0.11370513588190079,
0.660048246383667,
0.25319167971611023,
0.18424049019813538,
-0.40686145424842834,
-1.1999080181121826,
-0.48712196946144104,
-0.2139585167169571,
0.24887512624263763,
0.22707900404930115,
0.3438546359539032,
0.13807527720928192,
1.0901336669921875,
-0.5592596530914307,
-0.1491679847240448,
-0.047089967876672745,
-0.0065484545193612576,
0.21522089838981628,
0.3703312277793884,
0.4942108392715454,
-0.7701345682144165,
-0.3381655514240265,
0.21733403205871582,
-1.145249605178833,
0.1829686015844345,
-0.04563942179083824,
0.10456476360559464,
0.3322513699531555,
0.6427739858627319,
-1.0248603820800781,
0.5582275390625,
0.10228520631790161,
0.026514725759625435,
0.5058438181877136,
-0.49220648407936096,
0.255167156457901,
-0.7476204037666321,
-0.22547882795333862,
-0.3457939624786377,
-0.026480646803975105,
-0.6609950661659241,
-0.06283474713563919,
0.3220546841621399,
-0.04036126285791397,
-0.11731326580047607,
0.5188160538673401,
-0.5407246351242065,
-0.38849908113479614,
-0.4333901107311249,
0.3318253457546234,
-0.11370212584733963,
0.5481327772140503,
-0.07411431521177292,
0.520062267780304,
0.7249769568443298,
-0.7713372111320496,
0.32222700119018555,
0.2714739143848419,
-0.5289451479911804,
0.10659150779247284,
-0.6377448439598083,
-0.050261251628398895,
-0.16889435052871704,
0.14293020963668823,
-0.9390047788619995,
-0.3606465458869934,
0.1693691462278366,
-0.5909597873687744,
0.3102124333381653,
-0.3417417109012604,
-0.7219363451004028,
-0.06858997046947479,
0.11397187411785126,
0.4540354013442993,
0.6459009647369385,
-0.4304291009902954,
0.6184262633323669,
0.3434637486934662,
0.15175588428974152,
-0.5363261103630066,
-0.7463576793670654,
0.00483220349997282,
0.10486816614866257,
-0.5458922982215881,
0.25068992376327515,
0.09191106259822845,
-0.2555985152721405,
0.14894011616706848,
-0.5571346879005432,
-0.04579450562596321,
0.11238174140453339,
0.031087223440408707,
-0.025955338031053543,
-0.2521347403526306,
0.5122881531715393,
0.1444876790046692,
0.09583793580532074,
0.26135486364364624,
-0.24252866208553314,
0.3021235466003418,
0.2809567451477051,
-0.5093757510185242,
-0.4296601712703705,
0.05373251810669899,
0.5773810744285583,
-0.3045520782470703,
0.8287678360939026,
0.37679287791252136,
-0.4757547974586487,
-0.018275700509548187,
-0.6452816128730774,
-0.41242608428001404,
-0.47433945536613464,
0.47711917757987976,
-0.22912664711475372,
-0.8836754560470581,
0.7048930525779724,
-0.2666720151901245,
-0.20441009104251862,
0.317866712808609,
0.029540618881583214,
-0.25242283940315247,
1.017703890800476,
0.4208226501941681,
0.010596627369523048,
0.2658681273460388,
-0.20768772065639496,
0.5298565030097961,
-1.141324758529663,
-0.33282703161239624,
-0.4469953179359436,
-0.6043166518211365,
-0.4359549582004547,
-0.1338222324848175,
0.44559040665626526,
0.46693649888038635,
-0.16111350059509277,
0.07197698950767517,
-0.28690770268440247,
0.5420676469802856,
0.48999038338661194,
0.058126263320446014,
-0.03659604489803314,
0.16463753581047058,
-0.27583548426628113,
-0.1801653355360031,
-1.2805231809616089,
-0.11913923174142838,
1.0941481590270996,
-0.07948856800794601,
0.4857341945171356,
0.143754780292511,
0.49783721566200256,
0.16317257285118103,
0.15376712381839752,
-0.9044005870819092,
0.882689356803894,
0.11506005376577377,
-0.5658876895904541,
-0.2883380949497223,
-0.5665115118026733,
-0.9623914957046509,
0.2271699756383896,
-0.22841259837150574,
-0.8934112191200256,
0.26217636466026306,
0.06865222752094269,
-0.2786383032798767,
0.49112600088119507,
-0.8013216257095337,
0.7520451545715332,
-0.2594861388206482,
-0.20569376647472382,
-0.3500722348690033,
-0.4861600697040558,
0.08726415783166885,
-0.012048227712512016,
0.10720021277666092,
0.05096658691763878,
-0.056086376309394836,
0.7704638242721558,
-0.19132378697395325,
0.9442472457885742,
-0.47946950793266296,
-0.13124877214431763,
0.21579831838607788,
0.30348697304725647,
0.7422757744789124,
-0.03414143994450569,
-0.1635192334651947,
-0.05939997360110283,
-0.13672688603401184,
-0.5019834637641907,
-1.1199462413787842,
0.9088983535766602,
-0.5938839912414551,
-0.9195808172225952,
-0.24988704919815063,
-0.8813661932945251,
-0.4026910364627838,
0.2899479568004608,
0.00243517872877419,
0.4474923610687256,
0.17162320017814636,
0.2253568470478058,
0.9016294479370117,
-0.2931080162525177,
0.3185313045978546,
0.577161967754364,
-0.38153913617134094,
-0.2087617963552475,
1.0057265758514404,
0.5494705438613892,
0.23100222647190094,
0.3838352560997009,
0.17002469301223755,
-0.2900148630142212,
-0.8662111163139343,
-0.026347054168581963,
0.3359432518482208,
-0.9533506035804749,
0.15455827116966248,
-0.619953453540802,
0.05687853693962097,
-0.501091718673706,
-0.06587248295545578,
-0.37767452001571655,
-0.4488036334514618,
-0.08337565511465073,
-0.07123396545648575,
0.33681026101112366,
0.7669194340705872,
-0.08587444573640823,
0.3220733404159546,
-0.5178869366645813,
0.39284104108810425,
0.2761061489582062,
0.2072240710258484,
0.3328809142112732,
-0.4508022964000702,
-0.6041886806488037,
0.3160477578639984,
0.11258432269096375,
-0.8692224025726318,
0.1344453990459442,
-0.1578536182641983,
0.6855642795562744,
0.10297204554080963,
0.17167730629444122,
0.4065884053707123,
-0.2630486786365509,
0.8988053202629089,
-0.029501674696803093,
-0.5255535244941711,
0.5366918444633484,
-0.37075117230415344,
0.5392687916755676,
0.2134331315755844,
0.37452468276023865,
-0.4727470576763153,
-0.2528647184371948,
-0.5978100299835205,
-0.7788572907447815,
0.5942308902740479,
-0.08555292338132858,
0.17225702106952667,
-0.20872439444065094,
0.8370468616485596,
-0.23952966928482056,
0.31645411252975464,
-0.4203498959541321,
-0.634375274181366,
0.07318219542503357,
0.11345912516117096,
0.13656920194625854,
-0.40929147601127625,
-0.18021678924560547,
-0.4452235698699951,
0.7795283794403076,
-0.05842453986406326,
0.43027013540267944,
0.5508907437324524,
-0.04172416031360626,
0.027695002034306526,
0.11696597933769226,
0.8039948344230652,
0.979194164276123,
-0.16889061033725739,
0.04038958624005318,
0.22105081379413605,
-0.21012742817401886,
-0.006733793765306473,
-0.1657913327217102,
-0.637351930141449,
0.16186121106147766,
0.23345205187797546,
0.839415967464447,
0.34105420112609863,
-0.18176235258579254,
0.3645389676094055,
0.09574363380670547,
-0.15705162286758423,
-0.19881965219974518,
0.07746591418981552,
0.3815261721611023,
0.3939651548862457,
0.15121817588806152,
0.4518091678619385,
-0.1735924929380417,
-0.3530087471008301,
-0.0819486528635025,
0.5750328302383423,
-0.46130621433258057,
-0.29798567295074463,
0.6865584850311279,
-0.2725299596786499,
-0.20842602849006653,
0.5745587944984436,
-0.2008279412984848,
-0.7063407897949219,
0.778755247592926,
0.5364283323287964,
0.5364395380020142,
-0.008609908632934093,
0.26171401143074036,
0.5882895588874817,
0.3779689371585846,
-0.21105149388313293,
0.23422083258628845,
-0.1579848676919937,
-1.052944302558899,
-0.4660460352897644,
-0.378329873085022,
-0.11238563060760498,
0.02904578670859337,
-0.5377625226974487,
-0.29894495010375977,
-0.3294050693511963,
-0.32718709111213684,
-0.08732971549034119,
-0.23855198919773102,
-0.40471187233924866,
0.2136116474866867,
-0.29859599471092224,
0.8722439408302307,
-0.4434535503387451,
0.9764977693557739,
0.8028681874275208,
-0.21751348674297333,
-0.6984956860542297,
0.10954231023788452,
-0.43340829014778137,
-0.624540388584137,
0.9666840434074402,
-0.33609747886657715,
0.2637263834476471,
-0.042594801634550095,
-0.7728442549705505,
-1.1086266040802002,
0.9263244867324829,
0.39729636907577515,
-0.448351114988327,
0.11082582920789719,
0.2896866798400879,
0.5252934098243713,
-0.1185963898897171,
-0.1548810750246048,
0.2309388816356659,
0.5732741355895996,
-0.16621433198451996,
-0.6665303707122803,
0.019074570387601852,
0.15172040462493896,
-0.04022553563117981,
0.2195199877023697,
-0.5805923342704773,
0.5438025593757629,
-0.5271902084350586,
0.03536828234791756,
-0.0011711129918694496,
0.5002651214599609,
-0.06030627340078354,
0.13835181295871735,
0.1197059229016304,
0.7730138301849365,
0.7810538411140442,
-0.21144603192806244,
1.433816909790039,
-0.2159363329410553,
0.31711646914482117,
1.2810181379318237,
-0.33212268352508545,
0.8127931952476501,
0.63313889503479,
-0.17822012305259705,
0.17752130329608917,
0.5648689866065979,
-0.08111276477575302,
0.7166271805763245,
0.22769935429096222,
-0.42158281803131104,
-0.386476993560791,
-0.2482750564813614,
-0.31026458740234375,
0.3420778810977936,
0.15476451814174652,
-0.3087038993835449,
-0.1290608048439026,
-0.1906905621290207,
-0.05448334664106369,
-0.1194375678896904,
-0.29450491070747375,
0.8130042552947998,
-0.045782703906297684,
-0.7261232137680054,
0.8829258680343628,
-0.09319368749856949,
0.26312047243118286,
-0.7701072692871094,
-0.021493181586265564,
-0.3341735601425171,
-0.0967521220445633,
-0.3195399045944214,
-0.6066120266914368,
0.254282146692276,
-0.453151673078537,
-0.5830754637718201,
-0.020705927163362503,
1.1431834697723389,
-0.32486292719841003,
-0.06822440028190613,
0.2261933833360672,
0.556790828704834,
0.17040131986141205,
-0.16375631093978882,
-0.3728509843349457,
-0.06705140322446823,
0.1813075840473175,
-0.31793102622032166,
0.5745328664779663,
0.607349157333374,
-0.017898766323924065,
0.8331149220466614,
0.8381737470626831,
0.3275389075279236,
0.1476585865020752,
0.012007368728518486,
0.7462565302848816,
-0.5765392780303955,
-0.1117657944560051,
-0.5802178978919983,
0.27524998784065247,
-0.062017884105443954,
0.013331538066267967,
0.8750129342079163,
0.5640186071395874,
0.7047808766365051,
-0.2540844976902008,
0.9034228324890137,
0.0003070527745876461,
0.20421047508716583,
-0.3579850494861603,
1.1195093393325806,
-0.6934661269187927,
0.31527820229530334,
0.20833563804626465,
-0.9122132062911987,
-0.25361958146095276,
0.5532914400100708,
-0.7313491702079773,
0.03399305418133736,
0.8576954007148743,
0.8785591125488281,
0.03711783140897751,
-0.05408035218715668,
0.6104696393013,
0.7622953653335571,
-0.06664927303791046,
0.15789154171943665,
0.9332255721092224,
-0.5639572143554688,
0.38806092739105225,
-0.4205133318901062,
0.15800593793392181,
0.051191434264183044,
-0.709968090057373,
-0.7190523147583008,
-0.48648205399513245,
-0.46391430497169495,
-0.3915298581123352,
0.06321164965629578,
0.33274737000465393,
0.6572248339653015,
-0.5330407023429871,
-0.1629217565059662,
-0.1407897025346756,
0.525492250919342,
-0.10656272619962692,
-0.1971287876367569,
0.47174155712127686,
-0.6087905764579773,
-0.15400035679340363,
0.7448164224624634,
0.19076351821422577,
-0.01924976147711277,
0.023005681112408638,
0.12795017659664154,
-0.35209915041923523,
-0.14220592379570007,
0.5855374336242676,
0.3686460554599762,
-0.6993110179901123,
-0.3566460609436035,
0.27664482593536377,
0.01219871174544096,
0.2123052477836609,
0.5574572682380676,
-1.0075634717941284,
0.6299867033958435,
0.5236510634422302,
0.8258219361305237,
0.3824659287929535,
-0.5026769042015076,
0.5822540521621704,
-0.6612721085548401,
-0.14107568562030792,
-0.08923021703958511,
0.43478506803512573,
0.37935498356819153,
-0.24088796973228455,
0.3276020288467407,
0.4022658169269562,
-0.7364874482154846,
-0.6537001729011536,
0.4142555892467499,
-1.01679527759552,
-0.24007995426654816,
1.1646931171417236,
-0.12462221831083298,
-0.545074999332428,
-0.04089190065860748,
-0.1302335411310196,
0.4218546450138092,
-0.24150313436985016,
0.9674285650253296,
0.785582959651947,
-0.1239859014749527,
0.17534580826759338,
-0.9264905452728271,
0.6202424764633179,
0.6094340682029724,
-0.5482931733131409,
-0.06613122671842575,
0.4080086052417755,
0.4597606360912323,
0.4152672588825226,
0.3779451847076416,
-0.06165803223848343,
0.22962243854999542,
-0.049404922872781754,
0.15393899381160736,
0.13683955371379852,
-0.007126535288989544,
-0.12088466435670853,
0.18916888535022736,
0.11448413878679276,
-0.14508846402168274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17459v1
|
Integrating Medical Imaging and Clinical Reports Using Multimodal Deep Learning for Advanced Disease Analysis
| 2024-05-23T02:22:10 | 2024-05-23T02:22:10 |
Ziyan Yao, Fei Lin, Sheng Chai, Weijie He, Lu Dai, Xinghui Fei
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In this paper, an innovative multi-modal deep learning model is proposed to
deeply integrate heterogeneous information from medical images and clinical
reports. First, for medical images, convolutional neural networks were used to
extract high-dimensional features and capture key visual information such as
focal details, texture and spatial distribution. Secondly, for clinical report
text, a two-way long and short-term memory network combined with an attention
mechanism is used for deep semantic understanding, and key statements related
to the disease are accurately captured. The two features interact and integrate
effectively through the designed multi-modal fusion layer to realize the joint
representation learning of image and text. In the empirical study, we selected
a large medical image database covering a variety of diseases, combined with
corresponding clinical reports for model training and validation. The proposed
multimodal deep learning model demonstrated substantial superiority in the
realms of disease classification, lesion localization, and clinical description
generation, as evidenced by the experimental results.
|
[
-0.08813626319169998,
-0.8025578260421753,
0.7152040600776672,
0.11648081243038177,
-0.568985104560852,
-0.23256632685661316,
-0.16499872505664825,
-0.9388508796691895,
0.3324047029018402,
0.4469597339630127,
-0.1796555370092392,
-0.5067911744117737,
-0.7647473812103271,
-0.14817985892295837,
0.0845087468624115,
0.8293625712394714,
0.023340502753853798,
0.8754171133041382,
-0.29491057991981506,
-0.37900683283805847,
-0.7380613088607788,
-0.2930915355682373,
-0.2963712811470032,
-0.17740707099437714,
0.5884165167808533,
0.06311501562595367,
0.8303508758544922,
0.5088038444519043,
1.1098506450653076,
0.32382529973983765,
0.4109445810317993,
0.4665129482746124,
0.15295347571372986,
0.1888715624809265,
0.09174086898565292,
-0.11937925219535828,
-0.6159468293190002,
0.07897994667291641,
0.5569185018539429,
0.7224401831626892,
0.2525261342525482,
-0.34245163202285767,
-0.2866981029510498,
0.3189747929573059,
-0.4684252142906189,
0.30436626076698303,
0.0008668135851621628,
0.5177489519119263,
-0.06928353011608124,
-0.6424932479858398,
-0.2837640345096588,
-0.19191406667232513,
0.3530687391757965,
-0.5714022517204285,
0.0048820930533111095,
-0.42843353748321533,
0.6640592217445374,
0.16247674822807312,
-0.8425265550613403,
-0.5382576584815979,
-0.5884147882461548,
0.5169021487236023,
-0.6309077739715576,
0.4460907280445099,
0.1805359125137329,
0.7364818453788757,
0.3423241078853607,
-0.989591658115387,
-0.27887842059135437,
-0.5043476819992065,
-0.32652947306632996,
0.41583362221717834,
0.07857038825750351,
0.05737783759832382,
-0.1842411756515503,
0.44311457872390747,
-0.5691256523132324,
0.24730263650417328,
-0.5367850661277771,
-0.179904967546463,
0.697593092918396,
0.6502397060394287,
0.5385825634002686,
-0.12178929150104523,
-0.7663657069206238,
0.06659191846847534,
-0.23075996339321136,
-0.09042099863290787,
-0.6514615416526794,
0.23345233500003815,
-0.3141830265522003,
0.49930447340011597,
-0.04050249606370926,
0.49637460708618164,
-0.11005166172981262,
-0.5477637648582458,
0.6608701348304749,
-0.6193277835845947,
-0.41461947560310364,
0.10200867056846619,
0.8537198305130005,
0.6112261414527893,
-0.5430118441581726,
-0.058411672711372375,
-0.021173758432269096,
0.15288586914539337,
0.16670234501361847,
-0.8877970576286316,
-0.10384581238031387,
0.2552087903022766,
-1.1693047285079956,
-0.3431660234928131,
-0.33972737193107605,
-0.8947232365608215,
-0.7606114745140076,
-0.43524232506752014,
0.3638721704483032,
-0.7128819227218628,
-0.4529916048049927,
0.2726958394050598,
0.09522172808647156,
-0.13200081884860992,
0.6291466355323792,
-0.5507872700691223,
0.023515503853559494,
0.2416733056306839,
0.6432067155838013,
0.02965501695871353,
-0.09192627668380737,
-0.6525001525878906,
0.36752381920814514,
-0.079701729118824,
0.5457268953323364,
-0.7746598124504089,
-0.29982516169548035,
0.07587170600891113,
0.15312214195728302,
-0.2830049991607666,
-0.2873094975948334,
0.21349148452281952,
-0.6098124980926514,
0.23982931673526764,
0.05178481340408325,
-0.2788514792919159,
-0.4523632228374481,
0.44068655371665955,
-0.9182285070419312,
0.273775190114975,
0.08782932907342911,
-0.4042784571647644,
0.42715689539909363,
-0.5319681763648987,
-0.641707718372345,
0.3255167007446289,
-0.5158424377441406,
-0.516381561756134,
0.21159331500530243,
0.2174638956785202,
0.8602246642112732,
-0.46581563353538513,
0.6235278844833374,
-0.22063717246055603,
0.0958242267370224,
0.43220189213752747,
-0.4199143052101135,
0.48764684796333313,
0.37624338269233704,
-0.08499976992607117,
0.15887878835201263,
-0.7384980916976929,
-0.08229777961969376,
0.15925480425357819,
-0.39109957218170166,
-0.21721944212913513,
-0.29470741748809814,
0.20916129648685455,
0.24255339801311493,
0.226241797208786,
-0.5694583058357239,
0.2601855993270874,
-0.10123027861118317,
0.0919848158955574,
0.11228129267692566,
0.07091616094112396,
0.2930656671524048,
-0.3076706528663635,
0.4447607100009918,
0.4680551290512085,
0.44563737511634827,
-0.44633257389068604,
-0.47142237424850464,
-0.24542565643787384,
-0.4919867217540741,
0.3601498603820801,
0.5944799780845642,
-0.545459508895874,
0.05128118023276329,
-0.2759518027305603,
-0.25563687086105347,
-0.6669124960899353,
-0.33897021412849426,
0.3440680205821991,
0.5704719424247742,
0.4389178454875946,
-0.37572768330574036,
-0.43300125002861023,
-0.9603486657142639,
0.3126735985279083,
0.4044521749019623,
0.13179391622543335,
0.5976533889770508,
0.35610082745552063,
-0.6672337055206299,
0.23795275390148163,
-0.42515453696250916,
-0.7357214093208313,
-0.2071245312690735,
0.30524390935897827,
0.08213462680578232,
0.577708899974823,
0.6624478101730347,
-1.007599115371704,
-0.5287328362464905,
0.614853024482727,
-1.1017968654632568,
0.4718671441078186,
-0.2987009584903717,
0.4105762541294098,
-0.038242705166339874,
0.4338926374912262,
-0.47652432322502136,
0.5394634008407593,
0.3345707952976227,
-0.2709444761276245,
0.18384477496147156,
-0.6999281048774719,
0.49087581038475037,
-1.1701290607452393,
0.12415260076522827,
0.30089694261550903,
-0.294076144695282,
-0.3291678726673126,
0.07203898578882217,
0.2563612163066864,
-0.4068046808242798,
-0.15093126893043518,
0.19129152595996857,
-0.48746877908706665,
0.29566967487335205,
0.002319696359336376,
-0.337080717086792,
0.2517886459827423,
0.13870301842689514,
0.13792675733566284,
0.09194853156805038,
0.7205628156661987,
-0.3308010995388031,
0.6044608354568481,
0.10095327347517014,
-0.26892122626304626,
0.42606526613235474,
-0.32317841053009033,
-0.012480400502681732,
-0.4884275794029236,
0.26419103145599365,
-0.9052932262420654,
-0.625048816204071,
0.255357027053833,
-0.40057608485221863,
0.7850767374038696,
0.0920129343867302,
-0.2866455018520355,
-0.22370491921901703,
-0.21462765336036682,
0.5950157046318054,
0.08361014723777771,
-0.16495281457901,
0.8225714564323425,
0.41895395517349243,
0.0017131154891103506,
-0.2967742085456848,
-1.0637967586517334,
0.12554726004600525,
0.046459972858428955,
-0.6361513733863831,
0.46281957626342773,
0.041802551597356796,
0.02076653204858303,
0.20777319371700287,
0.5247728824615479,
-0.5735841393470764,
-0.16927537322044373,
0.21796205639839172,
0.39436081051826477,
-0.5385094285011292,
0.45174893736839294,
-0.0019359085708856583,
-0.13458791375160217,
-0.1190471202135086,
0.3367627263069153,
0.2676187753677368,
-0.04573174938559532,
-0.5213029980659485,
-0.851630449295044,
1.0027090311050415,
0.9532146453857422,
-0.4354979395866394,
0.4627281427383423,
0.7147346138954163,
-0.5342527031898499,
0.44209179282188416,
-0.5333419442176819,
-0.08545148372650146,
-0.31450045108795166,
0.7526898980140686,
-0.17027784883975983,
-0.5178117752075195,
0.3755904734134674,
-0.3955066502094269,
-0.33166036009788513,
0.5720467567443848,
0.5347451567649841,
-0.24970784783363342,
1.2910847663879395,
0.6214589476585388,
0.13888171315193176,
-0.00855577178299427,
-0.23437801003456116,
0.14344896376132965,
-0.6753993034362793,
-1.0023458003997803,
-0.11246359348297119,
-0.3275633454322815,
-0.20017601549625397,
-0.5570260882377625,
0.7299320697784424,
-0.06771918386220932,
0.05643905699253082,
-0.4232095777988434,
-0.6741476655006409,
0.23922482132911682,
0.011467513628304005,
0.7708675265312195,
0.23660770058631897,
-0.11885164678096771,
-0.10582895576953888,
-0.32628577947616577,
-0.5911369323730469,
-0.025161145254969597,
1.237922191619873,
0.662199079990387,
0.8216508626937866,
0.08859720826148987,
0.399519681930542,
0.49214857816696167,
0.3578244745731354,
-0.9370020627975464,
0.07611077278852463,
-0.5388338565826416,
-0.38322335481643677,
-0.047064408659935,
-0.0037890623789280653,
-0.8502569198608398,
0.2521112561225891,
-0.3540985584259033,
-0.18687193095684052,
0.5106461048126221,
-0.11124954372644424,
-0.8346346020698547,
0.13271158933639526,
-0.7160125374794006,
0.772568941116333,
-0.6060526371002197,
-0.06744745373725891,
-0.413067489862442,
-0.9447914958000183,
0.44566234946250916,
0.21755334734916687,
0.35243237018585205,
0.08044803887605667,
-0.20137736201286316,
0.5073124766349792,
-0.1496952623128891,
1.0656015872955322,
-0.09361864626407623,
0.1675024777650833,
-0.2991153597831726,
-0.03493327647447586,
0.09328670054674149,
0.38464125990867615,
0.35980719327926636,
-0.03632599115371704,
-0.10488447546958923,
-0.2211492359638214,
-0.3877694606781006,
0.6316952109336853,
-0.6235843896865845,
-0.09380541741847992,
-0.5027145147323608,
-0.9572070240974426,
-0.2396506518125534,
0.08321703970432281,
0.04853666573762894,
0.9702223539352417,
-0.23748372495174408,
0.25927993655204773,
0.645332396030426,
-0.240143284201622,
0.41616007685661316,
0.31231197714805603,
0.030588287860155106,
-0.7263527512550354,
1.0016486644744873,
0.07293643802404404,
0.0755409374833107,
0.46296828985214233,
0.28714659810066223,
0.017267940565943718,
-0.720795750617981,
-0.5662735104560852,
0.1260731816291809,
-0.7648507356643677,
-0.47302109003067017,
-0.7055901885032654,
-0.3252728581428528,
-0.38938793540000916,
-0.08691781759262085,
-0.31492987275123596,
0.13146710395812988,
-0.4211938977241516,
0.41117924451828003,
0.2078368067741394,
0.6558982729911804,
0.058915793895721436,
0.062262289226055145,
-1.1655433177947998,
0.3634852170944214,
0.22068022191524506,
0.20643790066242218,
0.18523967266082764,
-0.10287496447563171,
-0.4743347465991974,
-0.09301461279392242,
-0.3200226426124573,
-0.8331630229949951,
0.4668447971343994,
0.27732139825820923,
0.5771406292915344,
0.6122459173202515,
-0.3241172134876251,
0.49582168459892273,
-0.2103291153907776,
0.529794454574585,
0.9268735647201538,
-0.3819384276866913,
0.6188474297523499,
-0.12898080050945282,
0.3892350494861603,
0.37593600153923035,
0.5549535155296326,
-0.3783250153064728,
0.1261603683233261,
-0.2360437512397766,
-0.4845418632030487,
0.3350079357624054,
-0.4322328269481659,
0.1089014783501625,
0.009272178635001183,
0.13581430912017822,
0.3897362947463989,
-0.08334553986787796,
-0.6607465744018555,
-0.10035231709480286,
-0.21365700662136078,
-0.25752362608909607,
0.09536709636449814,
-0.3530600070953369,
-0.5238317847251892,
-0.7590289115905762,
0.04810944199562073,
-0.3620030879974365,
0.42269080877304077,
0.4277303218841553,
-0.38655346632003784,
0.05822605639696121,
0.15065106749534607,
0.7906041145324707,
0.406942754983902,
-0.12446343898773193,
0.3202616572380066,
-0.11533854156732559,
-0.579510509967804,
-0.20353788137435913,
0.35393133759498596,
0.5067471861839294,
0.06104917824268341,
0.7436127662658691,
0.8193578124046326,
0.12959611415863037,
-0.5106205344200134,
0.8415994048118591,
-0.09729980677366257,
-0.366070419549942,
-0.04762484133243561,
-0.33139893412590027,
0.11844160407781601,
0.6294012665748596,
0.3259614408016205,
0.46275556087493896,
0.5616680383682251,
-0.5546213388442993,
0.3866330087184906,
0.4800317585468292,
-0.8141803741455078,
-0.36222854256629944,
0.5777676701545715,
0.3622705042362213,
0.260497123003006,
0.7127858400344849,
0.2929324209690094,
-0.22629311680793762,
0.7148770689964294,
0.5245503783226013,
0.3985775411128998,
-0.3603877127170563,
0.3192778527736664,
0.12361934036016464,
0.04789464920759201,
0.2785370349884033,
0.3524969518184662,
0.08262627571821213,
-0.3558877408504486,
-0.5945927500724792,
-0.1711227148771286,
0.176200270652771,
0.42721596360206604,
-0.45765143632888794,
0.15024931728839874,
-0.4802500605583191,
-0.21650053560733795,
0.48040592670440674,
-0.06203743442893028,
-0.5173093676567078,
0.7083924412727356,
0.41333308815956116,
0.6685145497322083,
-0.7743772864341736,
0.8615447878837585,
0.5666719079017639,
-0.7962787747383118,
-0.4695676565170288,
-0.20194950699806213,
-0.09367629140615463,
-0.886909008026123,
0.8571851253509521,
0.42803460359573364,
0.32966282963752747,
-0.4709798991680145,
-0.4294300675392151,
-0.49791035056114197,
1.0520442724227905,
0.26827573776245117,
-0.41999104619026184,
0.06427126377820969,
0.2859829366207123,
0.5035386085510254,
-0.8002762794494629,
0.27270519733428955,
0.14672304689884186,
0.4429127275943756,
0.346489816904068,
-1.0727325677871704,
0.27147141098976135,
-0.4669729471206665,
-0.1474326103925705,
0.05345131456851959,
-0.5989301800727844,
1.0005543231964111,
-0.5071664452552795,
0.00987846590578556,
-0.03339635953307152,
0.37248075008392334,
-0.2684835195541382,
0.6408735513687134,
0.24639664590358734,
0.673758864402771,
0.6391242146492004,
0.17163854837417603,
1.2193214893341064,
-0.04683830216526985,
0.21850919723510742,
0.7632222771644592,
-0.1458987593650818,
0.2079860121011734,
0.18537576496601105,
0.15369528532028198,
0.2914603352546692,
0.5621305704116821,
-0.08231829851865768,
0.8384459614753723,
-0.23509462177753448,
-0.6464635133743286,
-0.46217185258865356,
-0.3454534411430359,
-1.1610537767410278,
0.500126302242279,
0.4492320120334625,
-0.8883310556411743,
-0.4929274022579193,
0.7717843651771545,
-0.35229334235191345,
-0.2840006351470947,
-0.3114358186721802,
0.8739399909973145,
-0.052112314850091934,
-0.1586112231016159,
0.5697453022003174,
-0.21428945660591125,
0.5613960027694702,
-0.5752236247062683,
-0.2943825423717499,
0.06155579164624214,
0.3734842538833618,
-0.31186729669570923,
-0.6894176602363586,
0.33325135707855225,
-0.7492130398750305,
-0.36409932374954224,
0.22231638431549072,
0.6800373196601868,
-0.5761932730674744,
-0.5963967442512512,
0.2277337908744812,
0.31813639402389526,
-0.10507103055715561,
0.18452191352844238,
-0.5807225704193115,
0.17880460619926453,
-0.20227372646331787,
0.04102403298020363,
0.5815874338150024,
0.6172685623168945,
-0.007857566699385643,
0.396084189414978,
0.5115511417388916,
-0.13470686972141266,
-0.34190136194229126,
0.02011628821492195,
1.1415635347366333,
-0.4481815695762634,
-0.31536656618118286,
-0.5838497877120972,
0.6677802205085754,
-0.2860596776008606,
-0.32170361280441284,
0.22638718783855438,
0.6577306389808655,
0.09126999974250793,
-0.2260136604309082,
0.7586007118225098,
0.05007794871926308,
0.16994395852088928,
-0.5622938275337219,
0.8783794641494751,
-0.8483085632324219,
-0.10940482467412949,
0.24325823783874512,
-0.017509885132312775,
-0.7050262093544006,
0.16155968606472015,
-0.0509396567940712,
-0.09753913432359695,
0.9043301343917847,
0.3855355381965637,
-0.3806348443031311,
-0.0046377661637961864,
0.3369186818599701,
0.10384451597929001,
0.2297789752483368,
0.655383825302124,
0.5196357369422913,
-0.3490614891052246,
0.30057191848754883,
-0.3815007507801056,
-0.564390242099762,
-0.6039913892745972,
-0.49803513288497925,
-0.7497725486755371,
-0.6256858110427856,
-0.41184118390083313,
-0.4823678731918335,
-0.20851314067840576,
0.472402960062027,
0.9824728965759277,
-0.6363268494606018,
0.3422304391860962,
0.4058551490306854,
-0.2875615358352661,
-0.18458867073059082,
-0.15865415334701538,
0.7905656695365906,
-0.37713485956192017,
-0.4780537188053131,
0.3413670063018799,
0.48827221989631653,
-0.025075042620301247,
-0.1562192738056183,
-0.08406772464513779,
-0.3039725124835968,
-0.5452090501785278,
0.7763596177101135,
0.08695822209119797,
-0.5218232870101929,
0.24244818091392517,
-0.09527010470628738,
-0.6079519391059875,
0.3315771520137787,
1.1149333715438843,
-0.9026689529418945,
0.9373635649681091,
0.23839718103408813,
0.8037002086639404,
0.37595856189727783,
-0.5883026719093323,
0.39305445551872253,
-0.14684079587459564,
0.44353535771369934,
0.7419596910476685,
0.2525184452533722,
0.08584940433502197,
-0.7191889882087708,
0.04421885311603546,
0.29801034927368164,
-0.2698352336883545,
-0.6773843169212341,
0.02656681090593338,
-1.4460121393203735,
-0.6248836517333984,
0.7148826122283936,
-0.1763509064912796,
-0.12764014303684235,
-0.13564404845237732,
-0.21459321677684784,
0.26509004831314087,
-0.12456914037466049,
0.6209167838096619,
0.0169755220413208,
-0.4658256769180298,
-0.4308375120162964,
-0.5923061966896057,
0.3949620723724365,
0.1510464996099472,
-0.8291618824005127,
-0.5796036720275879,
0.6445218324661255,
0.23780304193496704,
0.3166021406650543,
0.6621579527854919,
-0.5951879620552063,
0.8514317870140076,
-0.1378040611743927,
-0.05883241444826126,
-0.482466459274292,
-0.2930528521537781,
-0.23480039834976196,
0.6053491234779358,
-0.4284488558769226,
-0.4517807364463806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14105v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14105v2
|
Distributed Speculative Inference of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T02:14:17 | 2024-06-28T15:34:26 |
Nadav Timor, Jonathan Mamou, Daniel Korat, Moshe Berchansky, Oren Pereg, Moshe Wasserblat, Tomer Galanti, Michal Gordon, David Harel
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Accelerating the inference of large language models (LLMs) is an important
challenge in artificial intelligence. This paper introduces distributed
speculative inference (DSI), a novel distributed inference algorithm that is
provably faster than speculative inference (SI) [leviathan2023fast,
chen2023accelerating, miao2023specinfer] and traditional autoregressive
inference (non-SI). Like other SI algorithms, DSI works on frozen LLMs,
requiring no training or architectural modifications, and it preserves the
target distribution.
Prior studies on SI have demonstrated empirical speedups (compared to non-SI)
but require a fast and accurate drafter LLM. In practice, off-the-shelf LLMs
often do not have matching drafters that are sufficiently fast and accurate. We
show a gap: SI gets slower than non-SI when using slower or less accurate
drafters. We close this gap by proving that DSI is faster than both SI and
non-SI given any drafters. By orchestrating multiple instances of the target
and drafters, DSI is not only faster than SI but also supports LLMs that cannot
be accelerated with SI.
Our simulations show speedups of off-the-shelf LLMs in realistic settings:
DSI is 1.29-1.92x faster than SI.
|
[
-0.26804301142692566,
-0.7622519731521606,
0.9927116632461548,
0.4584369659423828,
0.1407620906829834,
0.42132368683815,
-0.2069782316684723,
-0.48461827635765076,
0.5230097770690918,
0.3672419488430023,
-0.9498133063316345,
-0.2468656301498413,
-0.8068629503250122,
0.014665283262729645,
-0.4468623101711273,
0.4189158082008362,
0.11282572150230408,
-0.1391264945268631,
-0.2206096351146698,
0.1556190550327301,
0.36357900500297546,
-0.04147528111934662,
-0.6395664811134338,
-0.11122587323188782,
0.540826141834259,
0.33349233865737915,
0.7123103141784668,
0.8632059097290039,
0.23155666887760162,
0.42523306608200073,
-0.12206491827964783,
0.3605670630931854,
-0.5888361930847168,
0.34916388988494873,
0.16235555708408356,
-0.6631317138671875,
-0.6104193329811096,
0.04677091911435127,
0.6761464476585388,
0.813978374004364,
0.005763689987361431,
0.072284996509552,
-0.5864925980567932,
0.8252580761909485,
-1.025442123413086,
-0.19264283776283264,
-0.6719651818275452,
-0.059140123426914215,
-0.5660371780395508,
-0.09330761432647705,
-0.7286121845245361,
-0.43152835965156555,
0.06172826513648033,
-0.800362765789032,
0.2963361442089081,
0.09023693203926086,
0.39451536536216736,
0.4785979688167572,
-0.30718815326690674,
-0.16149277985095978,
-0.9489706754684448,
0.8965847492218018,
-0.816136360168457,
0.5136575102806091,
-0.017639845609664917,
0.3120501637458801,
-0.37876129150390625,
-0.8106550574302673,
-0.8019322156906128,
-0.1002652496099472,
0.29901403188705444,
0.20643559098243713,
0.16020013391971588,
0.12899944186210632,
0.4410553276538849,
0.09917338192462921,
-0.49412456154823303,
0.5566126108169556,
-0.1298108845949173,
0.07774417847394943,
0.9970611333847046,
0.15010623633861542,
-0.04227060452103615,
0.3566896617412567,
-0.2030600756406784,
0.06953000277280807,
-0.5356072187423706,
-0.49019289016723633,
0.5522608757019043,
-0.016379712149500847,
-0.1610763818025589,
0.36628520488739014,
-0.26392337679862976,
0.6709820628166199,
0.31213459372520447,
-0.3019534945487976,
0.34324783086776733,
0.000608362490311265,
-0.023500382900238037,
-0.048761721700429916,
0.7663025856018066,
0.30244898796081543,
0.19735121726989746,
-0.33287057280540466,
-0.22124862670898438,
0.1925334483385086,
-0.2757892310619354,
-0.755416214466095,
-0.025815775617957115,
0.5020413398742676,
-0.24960839748382568,
-0.06071173772215843,
-0.06191837415099144,
-1.1443378925323486,
-0.5533451437950134,
-0.04806876182556152,
0.015963202342391014,
-0.05903934687376022,
-0.5214700698852539,
0.02129838429391384,
-0.3994137644767761,
0.04652436077594757,
0.32392650842666626,
-1.1812406778335571,
0.4441477656364441,
0.9071236252784729,
0.828225314617157,
-0.41592225432395935,
-0.5778128504753113,
-0.4750182032585144,
0.23574766516685486,
-0.8591180443763733,
1.1656352281570435,
-0.7061872482299805,
-0.24420413374900818,
-0.5465217232704163,
-0.2880444824695587,
-0.3960258960723877,
-0.20345810055732727,
0.5243145823478699,
-0.8744515776634216,
-0.04694904386997223,
0.005037322174757719,
-0.9620581269264221,
0.1739497035741806,
-0.2205207496881485,
-0.5394459962844849,
0.7906861901283264,
-0.2312147468328476,
-0.9704084396362305,
0.5435807108879089,
-0.4324827790260315,
-0.30894771218299866,
0.02929505705833435,
-0.36149486899375916,
-0.2199866771697998,
0.18310672044754028,
0.31219327449798584,
0.5214019417762756,
-0.3829888105392456,
0.5295076370239258,
-0.9006083011627197,
-1.0788757801055908,
-0.08999970555305481,
-0.6036333441734314,
0.6807865500450134,
0.40638089179992676,
-0.3816704750061035,
-0.015186531469225883,
-0.5148438811302185,
0.18153245747089386,
0.08349885046482086,
0.004346752073615789,
-0.19377954304218292,
0.31019681692123413,
-0.2617162764072418,
-0.28231632709503174,
-0.04416029900312424,
-0.661768913269043,
0.33298540115356445,
-0.5739448666572571,
0.32140788435935974,
0.851530909538269,
-0.14183169603347778,
0.6889190673828125,
-0.12132333964109421,
0.37059521675109863,
-0.09474346041679382,
0.06986593455076218,
0.07679483294487,
-0.43091100454330444,
-0.5119876861572266,
-0.8643823862075806,
0.2461959272623062,
0.484282910823822,
-0.9380089640617371,
0.2450813353061676,
-0.43929439783096313,
-0.7786585092544556,
-0.5282889008522034,
-0.41681191325187683,
-0.04940076544880867,
-0.13912568986415863,
-0.17785625159740448,
0.45258384943008423,
-0.5696073770523071,
-0.7429466843605042,
-0.3198368549346924,
-0.2085031121969223,
0.0005527939065359533,
0.43082475662231445,
0.21253418922424316,
-0.42713505029678345,
0.7229482531547546,
-0.6430807113647461,
0.7421769499778748,
-0.28424763679504395,
0.33401715755462646,
0.35512253642082214,
0.2642556130886078,
0.5872350931167603,
-0.6609230637550354,
-0.5347238779067993,
-0.2585223913192749,
-0.7858951091766357,
-0.24853414297103882,
-0.25920727849006653,
-0.057247310876846313,
0.3265564739704132,
0.5539199709892273,
-0.7332594990730286,
0.14444676041603088,
0.7393113970756531,
-0.19058039784431458,
0.562747061252594,
-0.3046547472476959,
0.44680216908454895,
-1.1001214981079102,
-0.25166836380958557,
0.005422653630375862,
0.02636541612446308,
-0.573864758014679,
0.07055644690990448,
0.14119301736354828,
-0.06830795109272003,
-0.31559357047080994,
0.6975593566894531,
-0.5359334945678711,
-0.3663698136806488,
-0.4402602016925812,
0.382053405046463,
-0.13623157143592834,
0.08064750581979752,
0.025529466569423676,
1.2769964933395386,
1.1202665567398071,
-0.8158048987388611,
0.24279910326004028,
-0.26120123267173767,
-0.19851799309253693,
0.12031252682209015,
-0.543397068977356,
0.23896194994449615,
-0.3002736568450928,
0.5290389060974121,
-0.6484749913215637,
-0.020759444683790207,
-0.07818812876939774,
-0.19552643597126007,
0.2253253310918808,
0.1234925389289856,
-0.44996848702430725,
-0.6897939443588257,
-0.11306003481149673,
0.5397400259971619,
0.32548317313194275,
-0.7225252389907837,
0.6215842962265015,
0.413057416677475,
0.21074646711349487,
-0.7721940279006958,
-0.6136935353279114,
0.13096709549427032,
-0.15354414284229279,
-0.6822608113288879,
0.3212815225124359,
-0.30800026655197144,
-0.694748044013977,
-0.10393723100423813,
-0.06997568905353546,
-0.2784810960292816,
0.3225632309913635,
0.1680591106414795,
0.10078730434179306,
-0.3569350838661194,
-0.023373538628220558,
0.35390663146972656,
-0.3544553518295288,
-0.19019657373428345,
-0.43274161219596863,
0.15468859672546387,
0.021216532215476036,
-0.7135488986968994,
-0.6365448236465454,
0.46417486667633057,
0.9899812936782837,
0.22255991399288177,
0.8600999712944031,
0.2573889195919037,
-0.19578886032104492,
-0.6262651681900024,
-0.9196249842643738,
-0.24292024970054626,
-0.4934466779232025,
0.24219733476638794,
-0.6198650598526001,
-0.7780561447143555,
0.4017294943332672,
-0.5032196044921875,
0.07080113887786865,
0.5321004986763,
0.380779504776001,
0.24495403468608856,
1.1318119764328003,
0.6789630055427551,
-0.41531798243522644,
0.23497559130191803,
-0.18793736398220062,
0.2044021487236023,
-0.3898685574531555,
0.22490744292736053,
-0.5188953280448914,
-0.25903308391571045,
-0.9396060109138489,
-0.6425948739051819,
0.07749618589878082,
-0.036300431936979294,
0.1072821244597435,
0.23621229827404022,
-0.08053093403577805,
0.7288406491279602,
0.5084811449050903,
-0.08464446663856506,
0.2976037263870239,
-0.27919110655784607,
-0.20986692607402802,
0.0836910828948021,
-0.8207095861434937,
-0.15327200293540955,
0.8406981229782104,
0.3646187484264374,
0.852327287197113,
-0.0805816575884819,
0.7479044198989868,
0.41869279742240906,
0.23262552917003632,
-0.6014057993888855,
0.7743269801139832,
-0.3216194212436676,
-0.6635347008705139,
-0.18244405090808868,
-0.6013866066932678,
-0.3890121281147003,
0.15652675926685333,
-0.17220236361026764,
-0.6719221472740173,
0.3480760157108307,
-0.14552950859069824,
-0.24096772074699402,
0.5112571716308594,
-1.0362180471420288,
0.2945176661014557,
0.07180502265691757,
-0.3696916103363037,
-0.6994537711143494,
-0.27477383613586426,
0.6056665778160095,
-0.3413470983505249,
0.04233543574810028,
-0.43678775429725647,
-0.046618085354566574,
0.5527572631835938,
-0.30913832783699036,
0.7162758708000183,
-0.35874179005622864,
0.15712721645832062,
0.22382736206054688,
-0.053150348365306854,
0.6649043560028076,
0.1699652373790741,
-0.8879209160804749,
0.23320601880550385,
0.10738525539636612,
-0.6463736891746521,
-0.8908911347389221,
0.9286883473396301,
-0.6977911591529846,
-0.7885782122612,
-0.4266415536403656,
-0.6848694682121277,
-0.2875351905822754,
0.047460395842790604,
-0.010535422712564468,
0.31896767020225525,
-0.14763793349266052,
-0.40289506316185,
0.46899816393852234,
-0.03832796588540077,
0.5615505576133728,
0.7128769159317017,
0.35095176100730896,
-0.24019524455070496,
0.6460021138191223,
0.1718837469816208,
0.41987335681915283,
0.263519287109375,
0.1507292091846466,
-0.2566508650779724,
-0.8848778605461121,
-0.7137873768806458,
0.4580676555633545,
-0.44879642128944397,
0.29708409309387207,
-0.8615652918815613,
-0.30509793758392334,
-0.4469546973705292,
-0.29898688197135925,
-0.5995839834213257,
-0.4939827024936676,
-0.029018722474575043,
-0.06751605868339539,
0.5571616888046265,
0.8599322438240051,
-0.11221466213464737,
0.27762213349342346,
-0.6185112595558167,
0.18766693770885468,
-0.0012296063359826803,
0.381300151348114,
0.14514310657978058,
-0.4923369288444519,
-0.05220990255475044,
0.053974591195583344,
0.26913610100746155,
-0.5175881385803223,
0.16118024289608002,
0.22479607164859772,
0.7937147617340088,
0.7745663523674011,
0.45074987411499023,
1.163698673248291,
-0.6544790863990784,
0.6021947860717773,
-0.1500922292470932,
-0.8316214680671692,
0.18711629509925842,
-0.2230338305234909,
0.31771132349967957,
0.5343716144561768,
0.4257190227508545,
-0.43008875846862793,
-0.7552391290664673,
-0.5041499733924866,
-0.6550167202949524,
0.7468171119689941,
-0.15818758308887482,
0.018014082685112953,
-0.38779208064079285,
0.5773751139640808,
0.31031036376953125,
0.11998089402914047,
-0.13997085392475128,
-0.4335907995700836,
0.4228358268737793,
-0.05896502360701561,
-0.2948836386203766,
-0.5136784911155701,
0.2643055021762848,
-0.06432187557220459,
0.8239622116088867,
-0.3157173991203308,
0.2867739498615265,
0.2826565206050873,
0.14018559455871582,
-0.301093190908432,
0.05062338337302208,
0.584855318069458,
0.7505109906196594,
-0.13497255742549896,
0.2518611550331116,
0.2253774255514145,
-0.2820647656917572,
0.06828700006008148,
0.2299177497625351,
-0.40051934123039246,
-0.19756479561328888,
0.4613001048564911,
0.9802680015563965,
-0.037029165774583817,
-0.6713722348213196,
0.2742019593715668,
-0.3969292640686035,
-0.35858654975891113,
-0.14182870090007782,
0.08237385004758835,
0.06771569699048996,
0.7794415354728699,
0.3625089228153229,
0.3775530159473419,
0.08200522512197495,
-0.17912667989730835,
0.5111010074615479,
0.4673751890659332,
0.00022285239538177848,
-0.3332069218158722,
0.6804537177085876,
0.2175074964761734,
-0.27499711513519287,
0.5401368141174316,
-0.4081271290779114,
-0.14579521119594574,
0.6321164965629578,
0.6452537775039673,
1.0369802713394165,
-0.009761985391378403,
0.35605210065841675,
0.2163405865430832,
-0.005318520590662956,
-0.4333750605583191,
0.13196830451488495,
-0.1506211906671524,
-0.8028851747512817,
-0.7757765650749207,
-0.5335882306098938,
-0.6159006953239441,
-0.23835571110248566,
-0.27194252610206604,
-0.05095113441348076,
-0.48024460673332214,
0.07378307729959488,
0.016974367201328278,
0.155475452542305,
-0.19328144192695618,
-0.022795870900154114,
0.2779020369052887,
1.1650434732437134,
-1.0672986507415771,
0.8008311986923218,
0.36112645268440247,
0.45167791843414307,
-0.6428877711296082,
0.6932064890861511,
0.12395891547203064,
-0.7017830610275269,
0.5966399908065796,
0.1695641130208969,
-0.32369738817214966,
0.4146454632282257,
-0.28707051277160645,
-1.168648362159729,
1.089937686920166,
0.39415088295936584,
-0.8117542266845703,
0.13408750295639038,
-0.2071608006954193,
0.5586695075035095,
-0.2783293128013611,
0.9019066691398621,
0.6645440459251404,
0.40385550260543823,
0.45847299695014954,
-0.6323614120483398,
-0.014133107848465443,
-0.07904217392206192,
-0.05902532860636711,
0.2127261459827423,
-0.7288162708282471,
0.6202341318130493,
-0.6219240427017212,
-0.3119407296180725,
0.249114990234375,
0.9930881857872009,
0.628963828086853,
0.5781152248382568,
0.8146941661834717,
0.5474675893783569,
1.1229743957519531,
0.056694526225328445,
0.960131049156189,
-0.4173804819583893,
0.0075240712612867355,
0.8207913637161255,
-0.8286810517311096,
0.7707026600837708,
0.47037163376808167,
-0.10903539508581161,
0.4621415138244629,
0.8440427780151367,
0.18986409902572632,
0.40952762961387634,
0.12006182223558426,
-0.6824097633361816,
-0.2333858460187912,
-0.07449193298816681,
-0.05018504709005356,
0.24170082807540894,
0.279215008020401,
0.01537060085684061,
-0.13773734867572784,
-0.09279222041368484,
-0.24144133925437927,
0.2224102020263672,
-0.1307799369096756,
0.6241051554679871,
-0.0625220537185669,
-0.7799881100654602,
0.5707889199256897,
0.046269360929727554,
0.8017110824584961,
-0.5190534591674805,
0.3289870023727417,
-0.16773621737957,
0.4523584544658661,
-0.01871333085000515,
-0.5743672847747803,
0.5186923146247864,
-0.0771220400929451,
-0.2481728196144104,
-0.19658248126506805,
0.4749335050582886,
-0.1013825386762619,
-0.7033137083053589,
0.6554664969444275,
0.6764448285102844,
0.2556082010269165,
0.14915458858013153,
-0.6113227009773254,
0.19727842509746552,
-0.18091712892055511,
-0.5752749443054199,
0.11651965230703354,
0.7903082966804504,
-0.21459302306175232,
1.0041334629058838,
0.5789145827293396,
0.29889804124832153,
0.01776694692671299,
0.3820192813873291,
0.9933826923370361,
-0.4977208375930786,
-0.4289315640926361,
-0.9885757565498352,
0.06309881806373596,
-0.10952385514974594,
0.05844892933964729,
0.8040404319763184,
0.34550270438194275,
0.4981369078159332,
0.018096821382641792,
0.6055919528007507,
-0.04863061383366585,
0.6028806567192078,
-0.4249545931816101,
0.7719900012016296,
-0.5032954812049866,
0.38397544622421265,
-0.1176016554236412,
-0.6204795837402344,
-0.16582512855529785,
0.06015675514936447,
-0.5682125687599182,
0.028316447511315346,
0.8155010342597961,
0.9913195967674255,
-0.046693939715623856,
0.17062154412269592,
0.4521016776561737,
0.3981412947177887,
0.10383766144514084,
0.22172978520393372,
0.5918909907341003,
-0.3673696219921112,
0.08629874140024185,
-0.34735041856765747,
-0.4132157564163208,
0.2988695204257965,
-0.922839343547821,
-0.9677119851112366,
-0.20432797074317932,
-0.26686549186706543,
-0.048544757068157196,
0.41151463985443115,
0.8751697540283203,
1.0862728357315063,
-0.8747233748435974,
-0.25997015833854675,
-0.445581316947937,
0.3686428666114807,
-0.5350714325904846,
-0.22729548811912537,
0.11598324030637741,
-0.08184706419706345,
-1.132772445678711,
1.0891708135604858,
0.24731162190437317,
-0.18283085525035858,
-0.319553017616272,
-0.07045267522335052,
-0.29332470893859863,
0.37187790870666504,
0.16013933718204498,
-0.019643640145659447,
-0.7330578565597534,
-0.012803950347006321,
0.06868618726730347,
-0.041185591369867325,
-0.4195486903190613,
0.7490963339805603,
-0.7878221869468689,
0.2709408700466156,
0.6953338384628296,
0.9189119338989258,
0.6987704634666443,
0.054457902908325195,
0.7745348215103149,
-0.510236382484436,
0.6219874024391174,
0.18835851550102234,
0.08237655460834503,
-0.08090396970510483,
-0.5889285802841187,
0.06413690000772476,
0.7743678092956543,
-0.7078461050987244,
-0.8177892565727234,
0.34642294049263,
-0.46792036294937134,
-0.4121169149875641,
0.9990163445472717,
-0.04784347116947174,
-0.5488073229789734,
0.07277678698301315,
0.29516464471817017,
0.16448940336704254,
-0.5622758865356445,
0.724330484867096,
0.24354098737239838,
0.05130644142627716,
-0.2795927822589874,
-0.5240615606307983,
0.2917729914188385,
0.3090749979019165,
-0.7363494634628296,
0.3235623836517334,
0.1895493119955063,
0.04923552647233009,
-0.006519787013530731,
0.9133610129356384,
0.342422753572464,
-0.040697526186704636,
0.6172497272491455,
-0.02976139262318611,
0.03117554448544979,
-0.5215398073196411,
-0.10777121782302856,
-0.07385651767253876,
0.019068457186222076,
0.022307641804218292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14093v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14093v1
|
A Survey on Vision-Language-Action Models for Embodied AI
| 2024-05-23T01:43:54 | 2024-05-23T01:43:54 |
Yueen Ma, Zixing Song, Yuzheng Zhuang, Jianye Hao, Irwin King
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Deep learning has demonstrated remarkable success across many domains,
including computer vision, natural language processing, and reinforcement
learning. Representative artificial neural networks in these fields span
convolutional neural networks, Transformers, and deep Q-networks. Built upon
unimodal neural networks, numerous multi-modal models have been introduced to
address a range of tasks such as visual question answering, image captioning,
and speech recognition. The rise of instruction-following robotic policies in
embodied AI has spurred the development of a novel category of multi-modal
models known as vision-language-action models (VLAs). Their multi-modality
capability has become a foundational element in robot learning. Various methods
have been proposed to enhance traits such as versatility, dexterity, and
generalizability. Some models focus on refining specific components through
pretraining. Others aim to develop control policies adept at predicting
low-level actions. Certain VLAs serve as high-level task planners capable of
decomposing long-horizon tasks into executable subtasks. Over the past few
years, a myriad of VLAs have emerged, reflecting the rapid advancement of
embodied AI. Therefore, it is imperative to capture the evolving landscape
through a comprehensive survey.
|
[
-0.14188581705093384,
-0.9204966425895691,
0.5811784863471985,
-0.07435660064220428,
0.07114894688129425,
0.008747033774852753,
-0.005540675483644009,
-0.5421333312988281,
0.26414936780929565,
0.7189631462097168,
-0.594076931476593,
-0.3288195729255676,
-0.5882300138473511,
-0.13513588905334473,
-0.4279744029045105,
0.5742737054824829,
0.06351840496063232,
0.15492066740989685,
-0.05267268046736717,
-0.3342120349407196,
-0.7052940130233765,
-0.4888596832752228,
-0.3419860005378723,
-0.3925510048866272,
0.5246670842170715,
-0.026806384325027466,
0.6624796390533447,
0.16054250299930573,
0.34126749634742737,
0.44154658913612366,
0.01616726443171501,
0.43585073947906494,
-0.006423009093850851,
0.07892956584692001,
0.012989004142582417,
-0.35174044966697693,
-0.7061973214149475,
-0.06380625814199448,
0.6933214664459229,
0.9321190118789673,
-0.06032169610261917,
0.04527219757437706,
-0.03178175166249275,
0.3805749714374542,
-0.8907189965248108,
0.2628052234649658,
-0.24002932012081146,
0.3745558261871338,
0.22292020916938782,
0.18711267411708832,
-0.2410510927438736,
0.18869119882583618,
0.186091348528862,
-0.5989231467247009,
-0.1469639390707016,
-0.17569449543952942,
0.5198277831077576,
0.4690578579902649,
-0.4831605851650238,
-0.14254386723041534,
-1.0593465566635132,
0.7250869274139404,
-0.6087982058525085,
0.5569857954978943,
0.2828086018562317,
0.21256141364574432,
0.12254801392555237,
-0.782658040523529,
-0.7567575573921204,
-0.5349940061569214,
-0.09806104004383087,
0.39718934893608093,
-0.34786179661750793,
0.49890950322151184,
0.23157918453216553,
0.23513799905776978,
-0.5592654347419739,
0.24138608574867249,
-0.4427754580974579,
0.08888015151023865,
0.7281219959259033,
0.5321098566055298,
0.455417662858963,
-0.10631239414215088,
-0.4000268280506134,
-0.4225040376186371,
-0.4446124732494354,
0.28961727023124695,
0.14021365344524384,
0.10675433278083801,
-0.1739547848701477,
0.9293224811553955,
-0.2815350592136383,
0.8135725259780884,
-0.32813718914985657,
0.09788109362125397,
0.05322359874844551,
-0.6158272624015808,
-0.5154180526733398,
-0.4028598666191101,
0.79266756772995,
0.17867247760295868,
0.039548445492982864,
-0.13396331667900085,
-0.4074503481388092,
0.10096380859613419,
0.7411361336708069,
-0.36254388093948364,
-0.04430491849780083,
0.07391070574522018,
-0.5013646483421326,
-0.10686537623405457,
0.04912779852747917,
-0.6040151119232178,
-0.5418452620506287,
-0.7604383826255798,
0.6709536910057068,
-0.3004172742366791,
-0.3038090169429779,
0.2535370886325836,
0.007490635849535465,
0.7171196937561035,
0.3838689923286438,
-0.7055948972702026,
0.2807188630104065,
0.6250238418579102,
0.5934171676635742,
-0.012583439238369465,
-0.5745576620101929,
-0.391000896692276,
-0.028437303379178047,
-0.5181349515914917,
0.42570608854293823,
-0.7843920588493347,
-0.36304527521133423,
0.3443301320075989,
-0.024422839283943176,
-0.3134833574295044,
-0.2729451358318329,
0.13983920216560364,
-0.4339340925216675,
0.0690743699669838,
-0.03699452802538872,
-0.3492415249347687,
-0.7010725736618042,
0.49825429916381836,
-0.7877548336982727,
0.7221534848213196,
0.02690422534942627,
-0.1303413361310959,
0.4065679609775543,
-0.9578004479408264,
-0.640191376209259,
-0.05187707394361496,
-0.4041011929512024,
-0.2759557366371155,
0.32099127769470215,
0.19350311160087585,
0.7268906235694885,
-0.25542503595352173,
0.2741418182849884,
-0.1291542798280716,
-0.2443922460079193,
0.1691858321428299,
-0.5897026658058167,
0.6476272344589233,
0.016442762687802315,
-0.5045429468154907,
0.6596511006355286,
-0.45905184745788574,
-0.10371871292591095,
-0.05280283838510513,
-0.02015780285000801,
-0.14087854325771332,
0.25306087732315063,
0.031399454921483994,
0.14929260313510895,
0.23717869818210602,
-0.18954156339168549,
0.38828712701797485,
-0.381460040807724,
0.2871626317501068,
0.6958673000335693,
-0.33064574003219604,
0.49672582745552063,
-0.07191473245620728,
0.668308436870575,
0.0262347012758255,
0.4674513041973114,
-0.28495097160339355,
-0.36500513553619385,
-1.0090341567993164,
-0.2023826688528061,
-0.16512708365917206,
0.5523846745491028,
-0.9862506985664368,
0.46071332693099976,
-0.16584078967571259,
-0.541397750377655,
-0.45345720648765564,
0.0206157173961401,
0.6673101782798767,
0.06862880289554596,
0.31691774725914,
-0.4233922064304352,
-0.17164766788482666,
-0.7925093173980713,
0.020478082820773125,
-0.35963761806488037,
0.12773753702640533,
0.5915624499320984,
0.6870527863502502,
-0.5038203001022339,
0.5995320677757263,
-0.3696689009666443,
-0.14864972233772278,
-0.5517281293869019,
0.41488558053970337,
-0.125138521194458,
0.2137330025434494,
0.8335390686988831,
-1.0810822248458862,
0.08478683978319168,
0.02594509720802307,
-0.912273645401001,
0.39703232049942017,
-0.2613271474838257,
0.18549805879592896,
0.05132931098341942,
0.31952768564224243,
-0.7714405059814453,
0.6469552516937256,
0.5531233549118042,
-0.28290054202079773,
0.418291300535202,
-0.37740224599838257,
0.18468117713928223,
-1.039804220199585,
0.24852368235588074,
-0.1239975318312645,
0.02658875659108162,
-0.7682837247848511,
0.5189828276634216,
-0.28140169382095337,
-0.12648315727710724,
-0.4854673445224762,
0.6195201277732849,
-0.5016410946846008,
-0.5490030646324158,
-0.37470370531082153,
-0.2533676326274872,
-0.32093343138694763,
0.7499484419822693,
0.47766706347465515,
0.5686659812927246,
0.9371607303619385,
-0.9954537153244019,
0.5154377222061157,
0.283122181892395,
-0.0666506215929985,
0.1944427192211151,
-0.8813158273696899,
0.011000562459230423,
-0.2211696207523346,
0.03937802091240883,
-0.8473451733589172,
-0.406564861536026,
0.4093386232852936,
-0.2888416647911072,
0.15779145061969757,
-0.035868704319000244,
-0.31454941630363464,
-0.3643907904624939,
-0.15468156337738037,
0.5880492329597473,
0.4732939898967743,
-0.30114471912384033,
1.2123136520385742,
0.34873589873313904,
0.19383569061756134,
-0.7086197733879089,
-0.4899255037307739,
0.04464695602655411,
0.033010609447956085,
-0.1514069139957428,
0.11584451794624329,
-0.17213225364685059,
-0.11932060122489929,
-0.19277238845825195,
0.12032842636108398,
-0.24393844604492188,
0.2605136036872864,
0.37969523668289185,
0.3186432421207428,
-0.1256401538848877,
-0.0891270786523819,
-0.11015348136425018,
0.051158782094717026,
0.09376275539398193,
0.000001893576381917228,
0.613244891166687,
-0.19074511528015137,
-0.6523110270500183,
-0.4490881562232971,
0.4474238157272339,
0.9769036173820496,
-0.687408983707428,
0.4855647683143616,
0.6211183071136475,
-0.3559001684188843,
-0.09788572043180466,
-0.07256266474723816,
-0.2804360091686249,
-0.3915247619152069,
0.6376307010650635,
-0.04844934865832329,
-0.6994015574455261,
0.22484345734119415,
-0.16979023814201355,
0.32455235719680786,
0.15935274958610535,
0.6066834926605225,
-0.26886001229286194,
0.9494367837905884,
0.9153280258178711,
-0.004400979727506638,
0.8089891672134399,
-0.5900741219520569,
0.13657116889953613,
-0.7611191272735596,
-0.35341155529022217,
-0.19771933555603027,
-0.4835161566734314,
-0.5398324131965637,
-0.5448595285415649,
0.37246572971343994,
-0.32906967401504517,
-0.25677594542503357,
0.6117791533470154,
-0.2462311089038849,
0.1751815527677536,
0.6017863154411316,
0.07553429901599884,
-0.22554880380630493,
-0.20755931735038757,
0.17797181010246277,
0.3557778596878052,
-0.4538632035255432,
-0.5671359300613403,
1.0447231531143188,
0.11917110532522202,
0.7317395806312561,
0.12925876677036285,
0.44860291481018066,
0.3787439167499542,
-0.013084118254482746,
-0.8903049826622009,
0.7321860790252686,
-0.3895752727985382,
-0.5533218383789062,
-0.5071811676025391,
-0.03209590166807175,
-0.9219974279403687,
0.2779221534729004,
-0.34225550293922424,
-0.624765157699585,
0.22906802594661713,
0.34201717376708984,
-0.45434004068374634,
0.43071699142456055,
-0.34294530749320984,
0.9831959009170532,
-0.5900552272796631,
-0.1647769957780838,
-0.4582841098308563,
-0.7758639454841614,
0.295377254486084,
0.37676969170570374,
-0.17901475727558136,
0.0704900398850441,
-0.12240274250507355,
0.3366520404815674,
0.1452016979455948,
1.2627958059310913,
-0.17564460635185242,
-0.025558656081557274,
0.337259441614151,
-0.03482119366526604,
0.31597399711608887,
-0.22483086585998535,
0.3534914255142212,
0.21702870726585388,
-0.20135407149791718,
-0.2696220874786377,
-0.5504951477050781,
0.026198390871286392,
-0.7899206280708313,
-0.28352048993110657,
-0.4153802990913391,
-0.2862698435783386,
-0.23677624762058258,
0.032487448304891586,
-0.018229864537715912,
0.6153948307037354,
-0.4580806791782379,
0.2631286680698395,
0.7535056471824646,
-0.33531856536865234,
0.7771525979042053,
0.5928411483764648,
-0.16422723233699799,
-0.32641497254371643,
0.8607251644134521,
-0.07125954329967499,
0.16200029850006104,
0.6546290516853333,
-0.09843593835830688,
-0.14724108576774597,
-0.4873007535934448,
-0.502122700214386,
-0.0754941925406456,
-0.3956252634525299,
0.00036022113636136055,
-0.6431961059570312,
-0.4698830246925354,
-0.2969861924648285,
-0.1150239035487175,
-0.5376595258712769,
0.005826343782246113,
-0.32749873399734497,
-0.13327041268348694,
0.029942838475108147,
1.0160424709320068,
0.16239309310913086,
0.3426341414451599,
-0.6753504872322083,
0.8431938290596008,
0.7290470004081726,
0.03711048886179924,
0.014447049237787724,
-0.270071417093277,
0.01638346165418625,
0.21060730516910553,
-0.23133820295333862,
-0.8055183291435242,
0.3948708176612854,
0.3829595446586609,
0.6522238850593567,
0.3927879333496094,
-0.024480096995830536,
0.601622998714447,
-0.4097554385662079,
1.0922507047653198,
0.3317856788635254,
-0.596987783908844,
0.535801351070404,
-0.22647279500961304,
0.08484099060297012,
0.1211056113243103,
0.42206767201423645,
-0.49099239706993103,
-0.11609596759080887,
-0.4504588544368744,
-0.8076478838920593,
0.544524610042572,
0.15953712165355682,
0.6861682534217834,
0.20923684537410736,
0.11553580313920975,
0.09256542474031448,
0.4494888186454773,
-0.8274500370025635,
-0.12424235045909882,
-0.25360602140426636,
-0.18979789316654205,
-0.08421193063259125,
0.07232153415679932,
-0.07117383927106857,
-0.3275465965270996,
0.31548982858657837,
-0.4427835941314697,
0.32231855392456055,
-0.07349815964698792,
-0.27222713828086853,
0.4168982207775116,
0.25190648436546326,
0.9403900504112244,
0.5147367715835571,
0.3230559825897217,
-0.035612329840660095,
0.06390247493982315,
-0.4481482207775116,
0.04345063120126724,
-0.045925676822662354,
-0.24431055784225464,
-0.24459199607372284,
0.5941582918167114,
1.1295747756958008,
0.3263140916824341,
-0.9469117522239685,
0.6272501349449158,
0.060494422912597656,
-0.021967852488160133,
-0.6805337071418762,
0.4256254732608795,
-0.3422682583332062,
0.5588037967681885,
0.14651969075202942,
0.19297829270362854,
0.3418821096420288,
-0.9158222675323486,
-0.04846431687474251,
0.44361773133277893,
-0.6849883794784546,
-0.6230906248092651,
0.6232855916023254,
0.12033957988023758,
-0.2568967342376709,
0.707108199596405,
0.04207415506243706,
-0.43979018926620483,
0.7129420042037964,
0.1463136523962021,
1.2058544158935547,
0.004753515589982271,
0.36435389518737793,
0.31054744124412537,
0.3241358697414398,
0.0759478360414505,
0.44744983315467834,
-0.37314578890800476,
-0.7409218549728394,
-0.2743847668170929,
-0.5925862193107605,
-0.3263865113258362,
0.1170574426651001,
-0.4619699716567993,
-0.0210577379912138,
-0.3295016288757324,
-0.08829110115766525,
-0.05870278179645538,
-0.3668859601020813,
-0.8517664074897766,
0.3583816587924957,
0.4323311746120453,
0.42085370421409607,
-0.936123788356781,
0.6909753084182739,
1.0702102184295654,
-0.8899199366569519,
-0.46789810061454773,
-0.006434422452002764,
-0.2074844241142273,
-0.8339419364929199,
0.6721600890159607,
0.05922699719667435,
-0.3578172028064728,
-0.3037653863430023,
-0.7850063443183899,
-0.6193637251853943,
1.0930801630020142,
0.33759191632270813,
-0.3507988452911377,
-0.3359173834323883,
0.14585331082344055,
0.6284546256065369,
-0.22091074287891388,
0.26898011565208435,
0.3349784016609192,
0.3857881426811218,
-0.0786445289850235,
-0.8587806820869446,
-0.42423588037490845,
-0.2140151411294937,
-0.04669199883937836,
0.08571232855319977,
-0.724490225315094,
0.8191394805908203,
-0.1697673499584198,
0.08478196710348129,
0.3526090383529663,
0.7990682125091553,
0.16814517974853516,
0.3753935396671295,
0.45479100942611694,
0.4025970697402954,
0.37856778502464294,
0.039029866456985474,
1.018649935722351,
-0.08403181284666061,
-0.10564184188842773,
0.8848095536231995,
-0.355318546295166,
0.9198623299598694,
0.3269653022289276,
-0.005125545896589756,
0.23550808429718018,
0.3388053774833679,
0.04753348231315613,
0.37504589557647705,
-0.08513443917036057,
-0.2221081703901291,
-0.6499502062797546,
-0.08606541901826859,
-0.027856092900037766,
1.0393502712249756,
0.300545334815979,
-0.27570420503616333,
0.04842677339911461,
0.4479842483997345,
-0.23935113847255707,
-0.0323658362030983,
-0.4420784115791321,
0.9930458068847656,
-0.14301908016204834,
-0.7841216325759888,
-0.0795491635799408,
-0.23893459141254425,
0.6063424944877625,
-0.7701144218444824,
-0.46182841062545776,
-0.26481443643569946,
0.0550839826464653,
0.22667011618614197,
-0.9185785055160522,
0.03124367818236351,
-0.013537132181227207,
-0.11749699711799622,
-0.46776774525642395,
0.5824763774871826,
-0.2822225093841553,
-0.4026471972465515,
0.389649897813797,
0.5150373578071594,
0.18863607943058014,
0.025992562994360924,
-0.7116348147392273,
-0.04646218568086624,
-0.4164465069770813,
-0.19904208183288574,
0.15380144119262695,
0.11929081380367279,
-0.1730320304632187,
0.7736279368400574,
0.3316348195075989,
-0.26053500175476074,
0.30364859104156494,
-0.015109261497855186,
0.8317471146583557,
-0.8276426196098328,
-0.2731386125087738,
-0.47957444190979004,
0.8541921973228455,
-0.008082431741058826,
-0.49695926904678345,
0.31812331080436707,
0.3320038318634033,
0.7964614033699036,
-0.3091753423213959,
0.5219616293907166,
-0.21440578997135162,
-0.27380889654159546,
-0.7124125361442566,
0.6891965866088867,
-0.9658772945404053,
-0.3465754985809326,
-0.3973558843135834,
-0.7208834886550903,
-0.12512743473052979,
0.5769624710083008,
0.017435673624277115,
0.4066973030567169,
0.22936758399009705,
0.5493139028549194,
-0.15775790810585022,
-0.26068922877311707,
0.7027949094772339,
-0.10760264843702316,
0.20775622129440308,
0.45023277401924133,
0.9772663712501526,
-0.5183302760124207,
0.16265363991260529,
-0.060866162180900574,
0.12513703107833862,
-0.29451197385787964,
-0.650489091873169,
-0.7297883629798889,
-0.9485812187194824,
-0.32967931032180786,
0.3969399631023407,
0.06813150644302368,
0.8459625840187073,
0.9911417961120605,
-0.7011522054672241,
-0.23822128772735596,
-0.18370585143566132,
-0.06964807212352753,
-0.5519081354141235,
-0.08001317083835602,
0.13953830301761627,
-0.2870192527770996,
-0.869613528251648,
0.7396914958953857,
0.23969416320323944,
0.11418687552213669,
-0.47882598638534546,
-0.30502840876579285,
-0.04532526060938835,
0.025550033897161484,
0.9985532164573669,
0.6291438341140747,
-1.083967685699463,
-0.291000634431839,
0.2940239906311035,
-0.0541529655456543,
-0.2239634096622467,
0.8310028314590454,
-0.7072372436523438,
0.5489553809165955,
0.4977801442146301,
0.653837263584137,
0.2659631669521332,
-0.32759907841682434,
0.6675616502761841,
-0.5844268798828125,
0.14050385355949402,
0.4704502522945404,
0.5491818785667419,
-0.09680788218975067,
0.14076469838619232,
0.5964913368225098,
0.004260899033397436,
-0.2387453019618988,
-0.6238694787025452,
0.3886634409427643,
-1.2076759338378906,
-0.3939547538757324,
0.8676853179931641,
-0.02301088720560074,
-0.24273577332496643,
0.24867618083953857,
-0.42148613929748535,
0.25621187686920166,
0.1503220796585083,
0.5292724967002869,
0.31149256229400635,
-0.30652323365211487,
-0.45150795578956604,
-0.6659762859344482,
0.2833641469478607,
0.21974125504493713,
-0.9446624517440796,
0.2413392961025238,
0.8648200631141663,
-0.22932898998260498,
0.2185766100883484,
0.2271212637424469,
0.09826470911502838,
0.592154860496521,
-0.11647389084100723,
0.33126023411750793,
0.04063626006245613,
-0.9846242070198059,
-0.30873870849609375,
0.2325695902109146,
-0.004075334873050451,
-0.3342441916465759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14092v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14092v2
|
Large Language Models Can Self-Correct with Minimal Effort
| 2024-05-23T01:43:45 | 2024-06-23T18:30:26 |
Zhenyu Wu, Qingkai Zeng, Zhihan Zhang, Zhaoxuan Tan, Chao Shen, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Intrinsic self-correct was a method that instructed large language models
(LLMs) to verify and correct their responses without external feedback.
Unfortunately, the study concluded that the LLMs could not self-correct
reasoning yet. We find that a simple yet effective verification method can
unleash inherent capabilities of the LLMs. That is to mask a key condition in
the question, add the current response to construct a verification question,
and predict the condition to verify the response. The condition can be an
entity in an open-domain question or a numeric value in a math question, which
requires minimal effort (via prompting) to identify. We propose an iterative
verify-then-correct framework to progressively identify and correct (probably)
false responses, named ProCo. We conduct experiments on three reasoning tasks.
On average, ProCo, with GPT-3.5-Turbo as the backend LLM, yields $+6.8$ exact
match on four open-domain question answering datasets, $+14.1$ accuracy on
three arithmetic reasoning datasets, and $+9.6$ accuracy on a commonsense
reasoning dataset, compared to Self-Correct.
|
[
-0.1207808405160904,
-0.9132979512214661,
0.6920239925384521,
0.1104973778128624,
0.12940825521945953,
0.11690710484981537,
-0.3948659598827362,
-0.34476524591445923,
-0.1163676306605339,
0.5174612998962402,
-0.5201675295829773,
-0.27460235357284546,
-0.31990715861320496,
0.3511914312839508,
-0.4243077337741852,
0.6843566298484802,
-0.12910081446170807,
-0.0628727450966835,
-0.4479353725910187,
-0.15054580569267273,
-0.20958895981311798,
-0.3411266803741455,
-0.6782503724098206,
-0.2415236532688141,
0.31011098623275757,
0.5760992765426636,
0.4003274142742157,
0.4521511495113373,
0.4740089774131775,
0.40788111090660095,
-0.07948645949363708,
0.6060873866081238,
-0.3478300869464874,
-0.13203148543834686,
-0.3619507849216461,
-0.40869027376174927,
-0.4596492052078247,
-0.1930028647184372,
0.4469701051712036,
0.4619444012641907,
0.033294789493083954,
0.3671528995037079,
0.09654559195041656,
0.6060056090354919,
-0.5894860625267029,
-0.014488652348518372,
-0.7383186221122742,
-0.3480645418167114,
-0.06536485254764557,
-0.05498436093330383,
-0.5764377117156982,
-0.2743023931980133,
-0.23477311432361603,
-0.43148913979530334,
0.2554592788219452,
0.2322034239768982,
0.6873037815093994,
0.4574533998966217,
-0.47554445266723633,
-0.38417619466781616,
-0.8318131566047668,
0.5247696042060852,
-0.7070241570472717,
0.24675829708576202,
0.5612137913703918,
0.32367831468582153,
-0.16896915435791016,
-0.5952094197273254,
-0.8745196461677551,
-0.4131423830986023,
-0.19316112995147705,
-0.0070542399771511555,
-0.1996806561946869,
0.015162178315222263,
0.42118942737579346,
0.4377624988555908,
-0.5553174614906311,
0.05825585871934891,
-0.2990929186344147,
-0.5552006363868713,
0.5915502905845642,
0.1535513997077942,
0.25804999470710754,
0.05820155516266823,
0.0638720840215683,
0.10274817049503326,
-1.094233512878418,
0.2271304428577423,
0.2479952573776245,
0.207223579287529,
0.23893515765666962,
0.8187225461006165,
-0.2724361717700958,
0.7190929651260376,
0.34788721799850464,
-0.23952369391918182,
-0.13855794072151184,
-0.3954218029975891,
-0.1385250687599182,
-0.0075397249311208725,
0.709071934223175,
-0.11063635349273682,
0.28759580850601196,
0.004449114669114351,
-0.45676901936531067,
0.12969176471233368,
0.34162527322769165,
-0.6108967661857605,
-0.14895910024642944,
0.48298972845077515,
0.07018021494150162,
0.05527191236615181,
-0.22872915863990784,
-0.1643887758255005,
-0.1458328515291214,
-0.3517782390117645,
0.8205787539482117,
-0.26143887639045715,
-0.06623358279466629,
0.18967388570308685,
0.5141270160675049,
-0.053300440311431885,
0.4753235876560211,
-0.5174689888954163,
0.224023699760437,
0.7340874075889587,
0.6612439155578613,
0.31247928738594055,
-0.12010090798139572,
-0.7789942622184753,
-0.12698782980442047,
-0.7238258123397827,
0.8494296073913574,
-0.26005828380584717,
-0.0025223041884601116,
-0.03807495906949043,
0.13946838676929474,
0.11181823164224625,
-0.48409783840179443,
0.6015404462814331,
-0.7391919493675232,
0.11149315536022186,
-0.5234951972961426,
-0.7100987434387207,
-0.030880823731422424,
0.5633915662765503,
-0.48832860589027405,
0.9137109518051147,
0.03363841772079468,
-0.7475629448890686,
-0.10502634942531586,
-0.5123422145843506,
-0.3036278486251831,
0.0841459408402443,
-0.12264427542686462,
-0.45729368925094604,
0.03135025501251221,
0.2064862996339798,
0.2657410502433777,
-0.350848525762558,
0.2895888686180115,
-0.37783804535865784,
-0.2939614951610565,
0.32739022374153137,
-0.08454195410013199,
0.7406451106071472,
0.14400939643383026,
-0.5683351159095764,
0.047231998294591904,
-0.8828648924827576,
0.3192635774612427,
0.19729530811309814,
-0.1549026519060135,
-0.25246578454971313,
-0.156661257147789,
-0.8141331672668457,
0.12899456918239594,
0.13101203739643097,
-0.6912400126457214,
0.3121930658817291,
-0.4024065434932709,
0.5575360059738159,
0.9745126366615295,
-0.2746165990829468,
0.4501529037952423,
-0.16725389659404755,
0.48119938373565674,
-0.13356724381446838,
0.12064971774816513,
-0.18543557822704315,
-0.362108439207077,
-0.9416539669036865,
-0.34651848673820496,
0.5446559190750122,
0.6615951061248779,
-0.8721571564674377,
0.5039937496185303,
-0.06185701861977577,
-0.4562516212463379,
-0.47677528858184814,
0.21277494728565216,
0.485159695148468,
0.899965763092041,
0.4112793207168579,
0.10306119173765182,
-0.45285922288894653,
-0.7425214648246765,
-0.29435768723487854,
-0.4449616074562073,
-0.002365994732826948,
0.17076165974140167,
0.727501630783081,
-0.14722703397274017,
0.8813242316246033,
-0.353813499212265,
-0.21792303025722504,
0.11876234412193298,
0.2270267754793167,
0.20652392506599426,
0.2892459034919739,
0.19658677279949188,
-0.3183082938194275,
-0.4519656300544739,
-0.04221797734498978,
-0.6837671995162964,
-0.35963931679725647,
-0.05325688049197197,
0.001832611975260079,
0.09739646315574646,
0.465751588344574,
-0.513900876045227,
0.31510424613952637,
0.4025740623474121,
-0.21153704822063446,
0.7155933976173401,
-0.42012032866477966,
0.2766171395778656,
-0.32417577505111694,
0.15674640238285065,
-0.15794439613819122,
-0.42713239789009094,
-0.48850804567337036,
0.014941442757844925,
0.528404712677002,
0.04184795171022415,
-0.17863446474075317,
0.8467487692832947,
-0.5185138583183289,
0.08722863346338272,
-0.41106560826301575,
0.025018207728862762,
-0.1117108091711998,
0.2990693747997284,
-0.12226501852273941,
0.947663426399231,
0.6663851737976074,
-0.9897557497024536,
0.3288731873035431,
0.01395702175796032,
-0.4751588702201843,
0.7212715148925781,
-0.986472487449646,
0.48140791058540344,
-0.39827656745910645,
0.29721304774284363,
-1.207157015800476,
-0.2732490599155426,
0.1677514910697937,
-0.4619791507720947,
0.01813327707350254,
-0.1242160052061081,
-0.571215033531189,
-0.6942772269248962,
0.002736040623858571,
0.4565103054046631,
0.4153800308704376,
-0.7099749445915222,
0.849413275718689,
-0.07129363715648651,
-0.0040266988798975945,
-0.7712135314941406,
-0.32885676622390747,
-0.08191365003585815,
0.1865934282541275,
-0.6702131032943726,
0.14115828275680542,
-0.38172096014022827,
-0.38907390832901,
-0.11419358849525452,
-0.2577126622200012,
-0.10837936401367188,
0.11819498986005783,
0.03283857926726341,
0.22054214775562286,
-0.021104665473103523,
0.27823254466056824,
-0.13951997458934784,
-0.19925934076309204,
-0.0393679216504097,
-0.34298157691955566,
0.2648891806602478,
-0.3568042814731598,
-0.5667814612388611,
-0.43368518352508545,
0.18393868207931519,
0.518054723739624,
-0.39731892943382263,
0.33171552419662476,
0.25557079911231995,
-0.5426574945449829,
-0.22381392121315002,
-0.7213330268859863,
-0.4814874529838562,
-0.49644097685813904,
-0.036060038954019547,
-0.6942694783210754,
-1.1245874166488647,
0.5664070248603821,
0.09456382691860199,
0.12869955599308014,
0.5781745314598083,
0.626101553440094,
-0.2506939172744751,
1.2137011289596558,
0.37194061279296875,
0.4855780303478241,
-0.054749950766563416,
-0.21535798907279968,
0.4925011396408081,
-0.7409576177597046,
-0.4106190502643585,
-0.7958470582962036,
-0.058862511068582535,
-0.23581917583942413,
-0.37800633907318115,
0.4951481223106384,
0.10105159133672714,
-0.39708560705184937,
0.4246145188808441,
-0.384225070476532,
0.6429731249809265,
0.5411425828933716,
0.20653320848941803,
0.42991968989372253,
-0.33621811866760254,
-0.2899329662322998,
-0.05085475742816925,
-0.5491708517074585,
-0.5522457361221313,
0.8420397639274597,
0.2632031738758087,
0.8777597546577454,
0.23692932724952698,
0.6140609979629517,
0.21541135013103485,
0.5909212827682495,
-0.791447103023529,
0.6611077785491943,
-0.05607375130057335,
-0.8152111172676086,
-0.2638322412967682,
-0.6202723979949951,
-0.7193481922149658,
-0.044078826904296875,
-0.04015228524804115,
-0.5439267754554749,
0.08474025875329971,
0.6314467787742615,
-0.709541380405426,
0.08081331849098206,
-0.5810544490814209,
0.5982120037078857,
-0.5583311319351196,
-0.592769205570221,
-0.06381261348724365,
-0.5321123600006104,
0.5616382360458374,
-0.24051178991794586,
0.3944201171398163,
-0.19777090847492218,
0.01311712246388197,
0.40713363885879517,
-0.6639314293861389,
0.9084852337837219,
-0.049596358090639114,
-0.4916924834251404,
0.5996113419532776,
0.6840323805809021,
0.884572446346283,
0.07520090788602829,
0.10239098221063614,
0.00842859223484993,
-0.13660642504692078,
-0.3580142855644226,
-0.8981994390487671,
0.5195825695991516,
-0.5130949020385742,
-0.8486660122871399,
-0.3914560079574585,
-0.018849961459636688,
-0.3143894672393799,
0.33242228627204895,
0.17420482635498047,
0.43216460943222046,
0.06630915403366089,
0.17584845423698425,
0.9210983514785767,
-0.03435708209872246,
0.28181368112564087,
0.9586082100868225,
-0.03509598225355148,
-0.48699846863746643,
0.5755159854888916,
0.3005222976207733,
0.17689253389835358,
0.4434131979942322,
0.5164679884910583,
-0.6389692425727844,
-0.28330203890800476,
-0.5473864674568176,
0.41834184527397156,
-0.8093398809432983,
-0.4859084486961365,
-0.8051896095275879,
0.01850891299545765,
-0.4986926019191742,
0.12099434435367584,
-0.7415012121200562,
-0.28149616718292236,
-0.0020672508981078863,
0.08890400826931,
0.08190923184156418,
0.6888824105262756,
-0.44408750534057617,
0.21835611760616302,
-0.7363539934158325,
0.38722673058509827,
0.7224249839782715,
0.286327600479126,
-0.14883284270763397,
-0.874729573726654,
0.0921442061662674,
0.24386274814605713,
-0.03591931611299515,
-0.7080574631690979,
0.03991134837269783,
0.3104853332042694,
0.6077128648757935,
0.3124895393848419,
0.2808879315853119,
0.7492210865020752,
-0.5487335920333862,
0.7232025265693665,
0.19682753086090088,
-1.3654029369354248,
0.7486780285835266,
0.03954425826668739,
0.2369183599948883,
0.4585159122943878,
0.5012609958648682,
-0.41447553038597107,
-0.2763991951942444,
-0.6971886157989502,
-0.5393720269203186,
0.3269486725330353,
0.20259793102741241,
0.08349030464887619,
-0.1661011278629303,
0.5824812054634094,
-0.10288893431425095,
-0.06202522665262222,
-0.7210558652877808,
-0.030784139409661293,
-0.10261384397745132,
-0.17228229343891144,
0.08126423507928848,
-0.4333895146846771,
-0.364237904548645,
-0.19285038113594055,
0.8832851648330688,
-0.662943422794342,
0.3003160059452057,
0.5357164740562439,
-0.285595566034317,
-0.10724387317895889,
0.2691722810268402,
0.7288470268249512,
0.8234818577766418,
0.0033283422235399485,
0.5729969143867493,
0.23678702116012573,
0.1728140115737915,
0.49264827370643616,
-0.4841793477535248,
-0.03349350765347481,
-0.1698560267686844,
0.5443890690803528,
0.29941117763519287,
-0.020097270607948303,
-0.682537317276001,
0.7474047541618347,
-0.2074531614780426,
-0.2210148423910141,
-0.2625481188297272,
0.026005366817116737,
-0.03492790460586548,
0.16063857078552246,
0.2508033215999603,
-0.0710420310497284,
-0.06991656124591827,
-0.584656834602356,
0.2864648103713989,
0.38485443592071533,
-0.08152105659246445,
-0.38559582829475403,
0.6744077205657959,
0.12158088386058807,
-0.3688131272792816,
0.7398098111152649,
-0.41401317715644836,
-0.7045530080795288,
0.4946022927761078,
0.6072902083396912,
0.6226231455802917,
-0.3221800923347473,
0.29896074533462524,
0.8842742443084717,
0.4960167109966278,
-0.5305736660957336,
0.34438174962997437,
-0.15902668237686157,
-0.8670126795768738,
-0.8583895564079285,
-0.23288844525814056,
-0.5258480906486511,
0.03822711855173111,
-0.3091804087162018,
0.15325607359409332,
-0.7288643717765808,
-0.11249176412820816,
-0.006171091925352812,
-0.1191272959113121,
-0.71116703748703,
0.4857218861579895,
-0.03656803071498871,
0.8075061440467834,
-0.7424505352973938,
0.6250393986701965,
0.5787131786346436,
-0.3081069588661194,
-1.027019739151001,
-0.2432873398065567,
0.1170082837343216,
-1.1931512355804443,
0.8263282179832458,
0.1850619614124298,
-0.5232641100883484,
-0.0002906601584982127,
-1.041639804840088,
-0.8437872529029846,
0.6127409934997559,
0.4428335130214691,
-0.9481257796287537,
0.2930264174938202,
-0.15644989907741547,
0.691519021987915,
-0.18883414566516876,
0.5370436906814575,
0.28075480461120605,
0.4609938859939575,
0.4450322389602661,
-0.9967804551124573,
0.16213126480579376,
-0.07943588495254517,
-0.24144606292247772,
-0.041845012456178665,
-0.6843140721321106,
0.6901881098747253,
-0.6077318787574768,
-0.2524917721748352,
-0.053266603499650955,
0.8470856547355652,
0.18720126152038574,
0.06886465847492218,
0.7294911742210388,
0.6150534152984619,
1.2153338193893433,
-0.24920052289962769,
0.9441480040550232,
-0.32327544689178467,
0.4287711977958679,
1.201438307762146,
-0.3708708882331848,
0.6077465415000916,
0.19607895612716675,
-0.18906138837337494,
0.39144256711006165,
0.6657320261001587,
0.28130072355270386,
0.3275744616985321,
0.3329881727695465,
-0.22388963401317596,
-0.7458524703979492,
-0.04633587598800659,
-0.20764869451522827,
0.5752571225166321,
0.1228514164686203,
0.030773891136050224,
0.01457520667463541,
-0.16788499057292938,
0.14904960989952087,
0.14590327441692352,
-0.21822606027126312,
0.7251260876655579,
-0.09957697242498398,
-0.9428774118423462,
0.8203273415565491,
0.14300565421581268,
0.5479013323783875,
-0.5351386070251465,
0.1395438313484192,
-0.5637684464454651,
0.35926681756973267,
-0.21081897616386414,
-0.6947271823883057,
0.3965105414390564,
-0.005758633837103844,
-0.10131824016571045,
-0.14364710450172424,
0.7005994915962219,
-0.431026816368103,
-0.41067811846733093,
0.015270437113940716,
0.4320543706417084,
-0.02871500328183174,
-0.35851436853408813,
-0.653978168964386,
0.022752240300178528,
-0.06590757519006729,
0.05159234255552292,
-0.16645409166812897,
0.4907104969024658,
-0.10504171252250671,
1.019658088684082,
0.6058133840560913,
-0.025883451104164124,
-0.15758611261844635,
0.08301512897014618,
0.5894191861152649,
-0.43973931670188904,
-0.38281798362731934,
-0.921343982219696,
0.5208808779716492,
-0.14208348095417023,
-0.05140020698308945,
0.7309501767158508,
0.3293517827987671,
0.8402659296989441,
-0.03805060684680939,
0.6531333923339844,
-0.0542442724108696,
0.4894563853740692,
-0.564934492111206,
0.054750289767980576,
-0.7062444686889648,
0.344402015209198,
0.053697872906923294,
-0.674640953540802,
-0.3897465169429779,
0.8532363176345825,
-0.32598739862442017,
-0.03837978094816208,
0.9466346502304077,
1.1551260948181152,
0.188308984041214,
-0.11596690863370895,
0.2972576320171356,
0.4607810080051422,
0.4189184606075287,
0.5186341404914856,
1.0403681993484497,
-0.42267417907714844,
0.5124107599258423,
-0.290936678647995,
-0.4278123676776886,
-0.06884243339300156,
-0.9953963756561279,
-0.9311943054199219,
-0.4111694097518921,
-0.7099935412406921,
-0.7930941581726074,
-0.05649653077125549,
0.9017134308815002,
0.7050526738166809,
-0.8455937504768372,
0.07169050723314285,
-0.04145031422376633,
0.31509339809417725,
-0.4961305558681488,
-0.14692430198192596,
0.24668554961681366,
-0.339223176240921,
-0.6322572827339172,
0.4651893675327301,
0.4030405879020691,
0.08754826337099075,
-0.39928385615348816,
-0.02344350516796112,
0.08230439573526382,
0.3138847351074219,
0.5805739164352417,
0.46975699067115784,
-0.8431615233421326,
-0.6184973120689392,
0.30137762427330017,
-0.15192407369613647,
0.015110377222299576,
1.125680685043335,
-0.465121328830719,
0.5195616483688354,
0.5112254023551941,
0.744402289390564,
0.1763083040714264,
-0.0803147405385971,
0.39100801944732666,
-0.7122357487678528,
-0.3636513650417328,
0.28818807005882263,
0.3664349615573883,
0.3671905994415283,
-0.5762494802474976,
0.5407761931419373,
0.34299951791763306,
-0.6574288010597229,
-0.7911271452903748,
0.3028916120529175,
-0.7626082301139832,
-0.1440126597881317,
1.268810749053955,
-0.39283108711242676,
-0.4351928234100342,
-0.21827730536460876,
-0.2130361944437027,
-0.052297841757535934,
-0.02741498313844204,
0.938479483127594,
0.6662049293518066,
-0.13957016170024872,
-0.24219317734241486,
-0.08174397051334381,
0.32088300585746765,
0.5238155722618103,
-0.906893789768219,
0.21700917184352875,
0.44867223501205444,
0.5740514993667603,
0.24267295002937317,
0.9381260275840759,
-0.17475026845932007,
0.26191750168800354,
-0.1281648874282837,
-0.041627492755651474,
-0.1340590864419937,
-0.5797644257545471,
-0.07407034188508987,
0.16663675010204315,
0.11576242744922638,
0.0854116827249527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14905v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14905v1
|
Structural Entities Extraction and Patient Indications Incorporation for Chest X-ray Report Generation
| 2024-05-23T01:29:47 | 2024-05-23T01:29:47 |
Kang Liu, Zhuoqi Ma, Xiaolu Kang, Zhusi Zhong, Zhicheng Jiao, Grayson Baird, Harrison Bai, Qiguang Miao
|
eess.IV
|
eess.IV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The automated generation of imaging reports proves invaluable in alleviating
the workload of radiologists. A clinically applicable reports generation
algorithm should demonstrate its effectiveness in producing reports that
accurately describe radiology findings and attend to patient-specific
indications. In this paper, we introduce a novel method, \textbf{S}tructural
\textbf{E}ntities extraction and patient indications \textbf{I}ncorporation
(SEI) for chest X-ray report generation. Specifically, we employ a structural
entities extraction (SEE) approach to eliminate presentation-style vocabulary
in reports and improve the quality of factual entity sequences. This reduces
the noise in the following cross-modal alignment module by aligning X-ray
images with factual entity sequences in reports, thereby enhancing the
precision of cross-modal alignment and further aiding the model in
gradient-free retrieval of similar historical cases. Subsequently, we propose a
cross-modal fusion network to integrate information from X-ray images, similar
historical cases, and patient-specific indications. This process allows the
text decoder to attend to discriminative features of X-ray images, assimilate
historical diagnostic information from similar cases, and understand the
examination intention of patients. This, in turn, assists in triggering the
text decoder to produce high-quality reports. Experiments conducted on
MIMIC-CXR validate the superiority of SEI over state-of-the-art approaches on
both natural language generation and clinical efficacy metrics.
|
[
-0.14900586009025574,
-0.4657020568847656,
0.6775577068328857,
-0.023586314171552658,
-0.3374824523925781,
-0.07639524340629578,
0.2738061249256134,
-0.5511757135391235,
0.4344050884246826,
0.48928213119506836,
-0.3843191862106323,
-0.6966910362243652,
-0.43827763199806213,
0.03152603283524513,
-0.5111624002456665,
0.8128432035446167,
-0.09407420456409454,
0.06577026098966599,
-0.10114196687936783,
-0.08177923411130905,
-0.4440671503543854,
-0.39708825945854187,
-0.4590029716491699,
-0.01876336708664894,
0.332991361618042,
0.079740010201931,
0.6364414095878601,
0.899799644947052,
0.49117356538772583,
0.24824528396129608,
0.17790846526622772,
0.2449961006641388,
-0.2093852311372757,
0.18788525462150574,
-0.10937579721212387,
-0.28737422823905945,
-0.49169448018074036,
-0.22376137971878052,
0.7841284871101379,
0.37208765745162964,
-0.09446115046739578,
-0.049452830106019974,
-0.31399381160736084,
0.40587857365608215,
-0.6875224709510803,
-0.08008136600255966,
-0.2248886078596115,
0.2549789249897003,
-0.43443435430526733,
-0.8587182760238647,
-0.5954573154449463,
-0.2916129231452942,
0.4442489743232727,
-0.3365120589733124,
0.3357633054256439,
0.08604171127080917,
0.9939508438110352,
-0.11572220176458359,
-0.41459783911705017,
-0.550628125667572,
-0.5910544991493225,
0.49856507778167725,
-0.41696345806121826,
0.6698633432388306,
-0.0966772511601448,
0.4134942293167114,
0.1245495155453682,
-1.0346895456314087,
0.09542792290449142,
-0.016869403421878815,
-0.4100269377231598,
0.2873377203941345,
-0.5375434756278992,
-0.07605348527431488,
0.007922040298581123,
0.4629252851009369,
-0.9806327819824219,
0.11090484261512756,
-0.6567286252975464,
-0.37625646591186523,
0.7427961826324463,
0.18879832327365875,
0.631201446056366,
-0.5946688652038574,
-0.6340992450714111,
-0.028383860364556313,
-1.0198798179626465,
-0.31497377157211304,
-0.2309519201517105,
0.1852729618549347,
-0.21241939067840576,
0.43939223885536194,
-0.36073341965675354,
0.27915358543395996,
0.2842409610748291,
-0.20214492082595825,
0.5347102880477905,
-0.2184225469827652,
-0.4119321405887604,
0.7289575338363647,
0.5569992065429688,
0.172940194606781,
-0.5713326930999756,
-0.23876839876174927,
-0.07776015251874924,
0.13847170770168304,
0.3656318187713623,
-0.7447202205657959,
0.027571246027946472,
0.2831983268260956,
-0.9387996792793274,
-0.6262018084526062,
0.07636342197656631,
-0.5262859463691711,
-0.06984875351190567,
-0.12276361137628555,
0.3959118723869324,
-0.4103976786136627,
-0.2595219910144806,
-0.04368932172656059,
-0.2852606475353241,
0.09261929988861084,
0.021440112963318825,
-0.30802273750305176,
0.42447248101234436,
0.4077494442462921,
0.6016598343849182,
-0.012601397931575775,
0.15931278467178345,
-0.9679217338562012,
0.4983269274234772,
-0.15076501667499542,
1.0082894563674927,
-0.5296052694320679,
-0.5511366724967957,
0.11880207061767578,
0.11674431711435318,
-0.04169948399066925,
-0.5857729315757751,
0.6805160641670227,
-0.32143720984458923,
0.33101069927215576,
0.02620219811797142,
-0.41285258531570435,
-0.24956969916820526,
0.18917593359947205,
-0.8225384950637817,
0.886901319026947,
0.3787587583065033,
-0.5504843592643738,
0.34099844098091125,
-0.4041721820831299,
-0.5808030962944031,
0.15023529529571533,
-0.5472158193588257,
-0.4165559411048889,
0.42904624342918396,
0.34719544649124146,
0.5483502745628357,
-0.36127227544784546,
0.16184565424919128,
0.3615833818912506,
0.09490691870450974,
0.3853168487548828,
-0.16113631427288055,
0.6453351974487305,
0.2772473096847534,
-0.4373353123664856,
0.09786389023065567,
-0.7663348913192749,
0.23349398374557495,
0.16346925497055054,
-0.02564288303256035,
-0.42525413632392883,
-0.09600309282541275,
-0.07772981375455856,
0.202508807182312,
-0.21100588142871857,
-0.4808898866176605,
-0.21128934621810913,
-0.32101529836654663,
0.12842686474323273,
0.4250037670135498,
0.4484202265739441,
0.07953433692455292,
-0.5348714590072632,
0.7364129424095154,
0.2342556118965149,
0.011968128383159637,
-0.3611268997192383,
-0.2611134648323059,
-0.27964258193969727,
-0.42181044816970825,
0.1983942836523056,
0.43555110692977905,
-0.7021603584289551,
0.16990919411182404,
-0.40844276547431946,
-0.6155842542648315,
-0.2261761873960495,
-0.2119958996772766,
0.6737577319145203,
0.7373326420783997,
0.3201771080493927,
-0.3949206471443176,
-0.900242805480957,
-0.9063859581947327,
0.09360606223344803,
-0.050031889230012894,
-0.06155221909284592,
0.4449850618839264,
0.09364187717437744,
-0.266998827457428,
0.38377508521080017,
-0.5851426124572754,
-0.3314894735813141,
-0.3629191219806671,
0.18712516129016876,
-0.0011697564041242003,
0.3369092345237732,
0.5001751184463501,
-0.8315303921699524,
-0.49213314056396484,
0.16373324394226074,
-0.9401043057441711,
-0.14814017713069916,
-0.4899176061153412,
-0.41359028220176697,
0.33010005950927734,
0.6393970251083374,
-0.2779696583747864,
0.6364876627922058,
0.3964258134365082,
0.13945676386356354,
0.3473917245864868,
-0.15423652529716492,
0.34036967158317566,
-1.189201831817627,
0.11531416326761246,
0.366050660610199,
-0.4511567950248718,
-0.7344502806663513,
0.13184083998203278,
0.015510381199419498,
-0.2633368968963623,
-0.5145478248596191,
0.25879648327827454,
-0.8835659623146057,
0.1798112988471985,
0.0641985759139061,
0.5457513332366943,
0.20691485702991486,
0.0675932839512825,
0.49878519773483276,
0.19261251389980316,
0.47229859232902527,
-0.5010652542114258,
-0.1299590766429901,
0.33291974663734436,
-0.1342991143465042,
0.6424499750137329,
-0.7140464186668396,
0.11285647749900818,
-0.07266412675380707,
0.22223524749279022,
-0.6160544753074646,
-0.0919034481048584,
0.37684035301208496,
-0.26348838210105896,
0.842667818069458,
0.08475859463214874,
-0.04553747922182083,
-0.3192066252231598,
-0.2403591275215149,
0.39306458830833435,
0.2368525117635727,
-0.4282003939151764,
0.8916263580322266,
0.3513846695423126,
-0.2873396873474121,
-0.2627667784690857,
-0.7989856600761414,
0.07481107115745544,
-0.0024252936709672213,
-0.6740093231201172,
0.751707136631012,
0.18962696194648743,
-0.0421493723988533,
0.23231419920921326,
-0.287427693605423,
-0.210982546210289,
-0.11075720936059952,
0.39612218737602234,
0.5495271682739258,
-0.5667548179626465,
-0.1677612066268921,
0.4375509023666382,
-0.26782941818237305,
0.07342177629470825,
-0.04363167658448219,
0.3361492156982422,
-0.03888531029224396,
-0.36065539717674255,
-0.6456397771835327,
0.7621471285820007,
0.2970259487628937,
-0.12782898545265198,
0.16705967485904694,
0.35638558864593506,
-0.7134788036346436,
-0.02252247929573059,
-0.6801502108573914,
0.0324149914085865,
-0.35258710384368896,
0.4128219783306122,
-0.4830802083015442,
-0.5376835465431213,
0.25993120670318604,
-0.1102602481842041,
-0.11873354762792587,
0.5612472295761108,
0.5138971209526062,
0.07190064340829849,
1.1116108894348145,
0.241120845079422,
0.25671303272247314,
0.07039064913988113,
-0.22139160335063934,
0.3166452646255493,
-1.120282530784607,
-0.47305500507354736,
-0.6484087705612183,
-0.12593777477741241,
-0.4771532714366913,
-0.22033539414405823,
0.4721425771713257,
-0.400303453207016,
0.4719410240650177,
0.3301630914211273,
-0.7867878675460815,
0.1619642674922943,
0.02582714706659317,
0.4574951231479645,
0.24231581389904022,
0.1371123492717743,
0.24235175549983978,
-0.19850941002368927,
-0.6704173684120178,
-0.3225242793560028,
0.9627443552017212,
0.17605260014533997,
0.4698196053504944,
0.13927732408046722,
1.0816481113433838,
0.3781636357307434,
0.374020516872406,
-0.5414412021636963,
0.33010005950927734,
-0.2685130834579468,
-0.5085927248001099,
0.09807708859443665,
-0.1700042337179184,
-0.9125488996505737,
-0.045647114515304565,
-0.08460243046283722,
-0.6949206590652466,
0.6183092594146729,
-0.15606342256069183,
-0.6609819531440735,
-0.2123381346464157,
-0.5457386374473572,
0.5698097348213196,
-0.36193016171455383,
-0.05258724093437195,
-0.17870958149433136,
-0.6244205236434937,
0.1899518519639969,
-0.00827830657362938,
-0.014412310905754566,
0.2890646755695343,
-0.008675924502313137,
0.45412930846214294,
-0.460469126701355,
0.7892036437988281,
-0.0482039712369442,
0.028560562059283257,
0.2903470993041992,
0.17486572265625,
0.39799195528030396,
0.11468125879764557,
-0.009108128026127815,
0.17962698638439178,
0.1806432604789734,
-0.05479740351438522,
-0.6200882792472839,
0.5312013030052185,
-0.4797595739364624,
-0.5593976974487305,
-0.39332494139671326,
-0.4241543710231781,
0.14589248597621918,
0.2691779136657715,
0.5732787251472473,
1.111314058303833,
-0.5040467381477356,
0.2503018081188202,
0.5054595470428467,
-0.12267730385065079,
0.02259192243218422,
0.2415195107460022,
0.03851669281721115,
-0.5231134295463562,
0.9251384735107422,
0.2661892771720886,
0.15453645586967468,
0.8594313263893127,
0.22126904129981995,
-0.29362767934799194,
-0.6132722496986389,
-0.3527727723121643,
0.4079650044441223,
-0.6684989929199219,
-0.43258795142173767,
-0.6337812542915344,
-0.46051475405693054,
-0.5055830478668213,
-0.5551102161407471,
-0.12892092764377594,
-0.3333059847354889,
-0.17102482914924622,
0.010587064549326897,
-0.23890407383441925,
0.34325623512268066,
-0.04564119130373001,
0.1344490945339203,
-1.170708179473877,
0.18802209198474884,
-0.20928660035133362,
-0.321916788816452,
-0.18099355697631836,
-0.2609865069389343,
-0.336398720741272,
-0.1391994059085846,
-0.2302805334329605,
-0.9562694430351257,
0.5384080410003662,
0.23494642972946167,
0.915754497051239,
0.6105396151542664,
0.09636109322309494,
0.7371557950973511,
-0.22699852287769318,
0.49882933497428894,
0.37715595960617065,
-1.026097297668457,
0.9857282042503357,
-0.022038139402866364,
0.06664147228002548,
0.2665155529975891,
0.5357168316841125,
-0.4037540853023529,
-0.343013197183609,
-0.8456304669380188,
-0.676686704158783,
0.5118223428726196,
0.175917387008667,
-0.29653486609458923,
-0.28915321826934814,
0.49060359597206116,
0.034814804792404175,
-0.15271268784999847,
-0.4043099880218506,
-0.15963520109653473,
-0.1534339338541031,
-0.17812347412109375,
0.44577768445014954,
-0.3713902533054352,
-0.5285415649414062,
0.20750953257083893,
0.8407509922981262,
-0.2844192385673523,
0.40698495507240295,
0.7690755128860474,
-0.5052579641342163,
-0.10183966904878616,
0.23191826045513153,
0.6702565550804138,
0.7155072689056396,
0.0028213472105562687,
0.20284773409366608,
0.028878789395093918,
-0.3991006314754486,
-0.01909228414297104,
0.06163971126079559,
-0.17631873488426208,
0.2735599875450134,
0.31464269757270813,
0.49085524678230286,
0.40991032123565674,
-0.4148455262184143,
0.476297527551651,
-0.2613665461540222,
-0.1865009367465973,
-0.26571938395500183,
-0.009256123565137386,
-0.2794572710990906,
0.49048537015914917,
0.240497887134552,
0.1968996673822403,
0.5589454174041748,
-0.4676640033721924,
0.39817526936531067,
0.18182320892810822,
-0.6830280423164368,
-0.4368782937526703,
0.3809131681919098,
0.10040417313575745,
-0.012697161175310612,
0.6941092610359192,
0.0689823180437088,
-0.3347284495830536,
0.4944741725921631,
0.8717221021652222,
1.036205530166626,
-0.36299222707748413,
0.47086191177368164,
0.3895934224128723,
0.13728322088718414,
0.2661268413066864,
0.20975984632968903,
-0.047527458518743515,
-0.44527608156204224,
-0.254363477230072,
-0.09722600132226944,
0.014012563042342663,
-0.3495329022407532,
-1.072899580001831,
0.48298996686935425,
-0.4875393509864807,
0.1086261197924614,
0.11099198460578918,
-0.03080824948847294,
-0.3461187183856964,
0.5042640566825867,
0.35212427377700806,
0.9099498391151428,
-0.8137930035591125,
0.6456013917922974,
0.46346426010131836,
-0.5583997368812561,
-1.0965429544448853,
-0.1091248020529747,
0.3795214295387268,
-0.7722519040107727,
0.6409934759140015,
0.2450350672006607,
0.024732431396842003,
-0.284376323223114,
0.03466999903321266,
-0.8930922150611877,
1.4208813905715942,
0.06019073352217674,
-0.34921878576278687,
-0.18013404309749603,
-0.033310145139694214,
0.30551019310951233,
-0.8598182797431946,
0.20192621648311615,
0.40655678510665894,
0.23168835043907166,
0.14092287421226501,
-0.5372283458709717,
0.886216938495636,
-0.379903644323349,
0.11328060179948807,
0.2514069080352783,
-0.4564327895641327,
0.26856985688209534,
-0.14479897916316986,
-0.6092668175697327,
0.24381934106349945,
0.6997280716896057,
0.2598528265953064,
0.445530503988266,
0.4639071524143219,
0.5002263188362122,
0.9302700757980347,
-0.021122585982084274,
1.312687873840332,
-0.2324555218219757,
-0.13982492685317993,
1.0234761238098145,
-0.38128381967544556,
0.5121963024139404,
0.289938360452652,
0.31576669216156006,
0.8724910020828247,
0.5268478989601135,
-0.17837285995483398,
0.4512489140033722,
-0.261430561542511,
-0.1108613833785057,
-0.13858619332313538,
-0.3510604202747345,
-0.6977593898773193,
0.5062946081161499,
0.3314782977104187,
-0.7354279160499573,
-0.10346360504627228,
-0.03204749897122383,
0.13703462481498718,
-0.4131696820259094,
-0.007838970050215721,
0.6643455624580383,
-0.0035450186114758253,
-0.45018428564071655,
0.3930535316467285,
-0.383522093296051,
-0.041103895753622055,
-0.7504187822341919,
-0.03164789825677872,
0.09578932821750641,
0.06027482822537422,
-0.6765954494476318,
-0.27169039845466614,
0.6675196290016174,
-0.392010360956192,
-0.2619610130786896,
-0.008793076500296593,
0.7000505924224854,
-0.15964668989181519,
-0.3552049696445465,
-0.07174388319253922,
0.4244379699230194,
0.12821178138256073,
0.1033981665968895,
-0.3529456853866577,
0.35157808661460876,
0.10022123903036118,
-0.023698393255472183,
0.18055835366249084,
0.5069884061813354,
-0.23292659223079681,
0.1643858253955841,
0.5888150930404663,
0.28154316544532776,
-0.23830552399158478,
0.1538236141204834,
0.9822677969932556,
-0.4391651451587677,
-0.4574946463108063,
-0.3156234920024872,
0.7514622211456299,
-0.270515501499176,
-0.2656467854976654,
0.5581570267677307,
0.946912944316864,
0.5388403534889221,
0.1470256745815277,
0.7239894270896912,
-0.16466590762138367,
0.29425618052482605,
-0.7369974255561829,
0.49729952216148376,
-0.7215709686279297,
0.24728021025657654,
-0.4554397463798523,
-0.6288387179374695,
-0.6133540868759155,
0.21432682871818542,
-0.03976251557469368,
-0.17315444350242615,
1.1834365129470825,
0.8352485299110413,
0.058462295681238174,
0.20134079456329346,
0.26477378606796265,
0.39678043127059937,
0.4238866865634918,
0.27879878878593445,
0.46967801451683044,
-0.7290196418762207,
0.7866400480270386,
-0.38040974736213684,
-0.37150630354881287,
-0.33379262685775757,
-0.6803557872772217,
-0.3962634205818176,
-0.4177666902542114,
-0.9167385697364807,
-0.6009292602539062,
-0.028654426336288452,
0.5377887487411499,
0.9856621026992798,
-0.6407685279846191,
0.03663451597094536,
0.31960630416870117,
-0.06348227709531784,
-0.4380144774913788,
-0.20534314215183258,
0.6611071228981018,
-0.07783176004886627,
-0.4891880452632904,
0.5542294979095459,
0.8032327890396118,
-0.047186002135276794,
-0.1804358810186386,
-0.08693008124828339,
-0.03972829505801201,
0.04292437434196472,
0.5634186267852783,
0.39930519461631775,
-0.5517114400863647,
-0.28518712520599365,
0.2553339898586273,
-0.14934797585010529,
0.3843383193016052,
1.098183274269104,
-0.6461940407752991,
0.584383487701416,
0.4679346978664398,
0.5850380063056946,
0.6964855194091797,
-0.18252474069595337,
0.5090378522872925,
-0.6191389560699463,
0.004277748521417379,
0.1894272118806839,
0.4194144904613495,
0.057086069136857986,
-0.8714284300804138,
0.4465843737125397,
0.16426506638526917,
-0.40359872579574585,
-0.9446046948432922,
0.04446595907211304,
-1.3478761911392212,
-0.02469404973089695,
0.6745765209197998,
-0.17950133979320526,
-0.6483621597290039,
-0.1578914374113083,
-0.1538086235523224,
0.18561913073062897,
-0.3417450487613678,
0.6128767728805542,
-0.06305859237909317,
-0.5418976545333862,
-0.27860376238822937,
0.034506045281887054,
0.0060889991000294685,
0.2267216444015503,
-0.9307435154914856,
-0.4726349711418152,
0.5664687752723694,
0.10541091114282608,
0.499411016702652,
0.6451476812362671,
-0.67136549949646,
0.7969249486923218,
0.10131444782018661,
-0.05228690057992935,
-0.03457172214984894,
-0.1636740267276764,
-0.13172365725040436,
0.44650527834892273,
-0.37127310037612915,
-0.25856074690818787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00017v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00017v2
|
PTA: Enhancing Multimodal Sentiment Analysis through Pipelined Prediction and Translation-based Alignment
| 2024-05-23T01:16:45 | 2024-06-13T13:26:56 |
Shezheng Song, Shasha Li, Shan Zhao, Chengyu Wang, Xiaopeng Li, Jie Yu, Qian Wan, Jun Ma, Tianwei Yan, Wentao Ma, Xiaoguang Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM
|
Multimodal aspect-based sentiment analysis (MABSA) aims to understand
opinions in a granular manner, advancing human-computer interaction and other
fields. Traditionally, MABSA methods use a joint prediction approach to
identify aspects and sentiments simultaneously. However, we argue that joint
models are not always superior. Our analysis shows that joint models struggle
to align relevant text tokens with image patches, leading to misalignment and
ineffective image utilization.
In contrast, a pipeline framework first identifies aspects through MATE
(Multimodal Aspect Term Extraction) and then aligns these aspects with image
patches for sentiment classification (MASC: Multimodal Aspect-Oriented
Sentiment Classification). This method is better suited for multimodal
scenarios where effective image use is crucial. We present three key
observations: (a) MATE and MASC have different feature requirements, with MATE
focusing on token-level features and MASC on sequence-level features; (b) the
aspect identified by MATE is crucial for effective image utilization; and (c)
images play a trivial role in previous MABSA methods due to high noise.
Based on these observations, we propose a pipeline framework that first
predicts the aspect and then uses translation-based alignment (TBA) to enhance
multimodal semantic consistency for better image utilization. Our method
achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance on widely used MABSA datasets
Twitter-15 and Twitter-17. This demonstrates the effectiveness of the pipeline
approach and its potential to provide valuable insights for future MABSA
research.
For reproducibility, the code and checkpoint will be released.
|
[
-0.46828991174697876,
-0.5381714105606079,
0.5099935531616211,
0.3210958242416382,
-0.6851531267166138,
0.24408775568008423,
0.3760475516319275,
-0.3130352199077606,
0.6327935457229614,
0.34035438299179077,
-0.71951824426651,
-0.5002110004425049,
-0.9151454567909241,
0.03564336895942688,
-0.216400608420372,
0.7546300292015076,
0.011961012147367,
0.14047843217849731,
-0.19487923383712769,
-0.6659944653511047,
-0.6370877623558044,
-0.22707347571849823,
-0.4709928631782532,
0.06631960719823837,
0.7242546677589417,
0.2796870172023773,
0.6853829026222229,
0.4340950846672058,
0.8285243511199951,
0.26454368233680725,
0.05533329024910927,
0.462232768535614,
-0.12150765210390091,
0.34979358315467834,
-0.08731803297996521,
-0.11756603419780731,
-0.7050217390060425,
-0.006807161960750818,
0.3569473922252655,
0.36799341440200806,
0.03654535487294197,
0.21416133642196655,
-0.12792982161045074,
0.6264911890029907,
-0.6472627520561218,
0.4138743281364441,
-0.5916595458984375,
0.06455247104167938,
-0.3764934241771698,
-0.09062299132347107,
-0.32296010851860046,
-0.10896467417478561,
0.10973469167947769,
-0.2795654833316803,
-0.30661430954933167,
-0.06363344937562943,
0.8959905505180359,
0.18323060870170593,
-0.7265810966491699,
-0.008720353245735168,
-0.334590882062912,
0.9670836329460144,
-0.7354743480682373,
0.4085014760494232,
-0.031652312725782394,
0.3209265470504761,
-0.027333540841937065,
-0.530891478061676,
-0.7689325213432312,
0.4159766435623169,
0.10650308430194855,
0.36598628759384155,
-0.032935116440057755,
0.09516651183366776,
-0.09600143134593964,
0.29750123620033264,
-0.30954161286354065,
-0.08661385625600815,
-0.3120596706867218,
-0.39385169744491577,
0.2515166699886322,
0.14247407019138336,
0.14489921927452087,
-0.4932316541671753,
-0.5829504728317261,
-0.12389656901359558,
-0.477063924074173,
0.2945319712162018,
0.16932718455791473,
0.3306102454662323,
-0.20403680205345154,
0.7865041494369507,
-0.10646948963403702,
0.5067936778068542,
0.12588858604431152,
-0.5666184425354004,
0.5323268175125122,
-0.38153812289237976,
-0.16466765105724335,
-0.23444969952106476,
1.0904288291931152,
0.6595312356948853,
-0.40998077392578125,
0.08551815152168274,
-0.14871807396411896,
0.3915756344795227,
0.26644566655158997,
-0.5606340765953064,
0.0825105682015419,
0.4740022122859955,
-0.6179922223091125,
-0.29427236318588257,
0.25353145599365234,
-1.1840670108795166,
-0.5762709975242615,
-0.3311087191104889,
0.5884518027305603,
-0.38960129022598267,
-0.1604657769203186,
-0.2610577344894409,
-0.06811900436878204,
0.1633988618850708,
0.22896696627140045,
-0.4836135506629944,
-0.4113553464412689,
0.7726120948791504,
1.0812606811523438,
0.0023923388216644526,
-0.15422844886779785,
-0.5885173082351685,
0.11096593737602234,
-0.27684730291366577,
0.9994262456893921,
-0.7533668279647827,
-0.24488164484500885,
0.16615048050880432,
0.1458037793636322,
0.04012688994407654,
-0.15492555499076843,
0.35534560680389404,
-0.14063161611557007,
0.46023687720298767,
-0.23968271911144257,
-0.04848635569214821,
-0.38024285435676575,
0.335326611995697,
-0.6256933808326721,
0.7387233972549438,
0.0971287339925766,
-0.82430499792099,
0.7252020239830017,
-0.6999871134757996,
-0.20586849749088287,
-0.6622453331947327,
0.2028706967830658,
-0.6910343766212463,
0.1730373352766037,
0.634230375289917,
0.6368005871772766,
-0.06542269885540009,
0.3350995182991028,
-0.5785371661186218,
0.12708960473537445,
0.476004421710968,
-0.09865017980337143,
0.3198279142379761,
0.6847505569458008,
-0.13697539269924164,
0.3432934582233429,
-0.4621877372264862,
-0.28771069645881653,
-0.3170560300350189,
0.21303682029247284,
0.001997319282963872,
0.19341452419757843,
-0.2138288915157318,
0.522431492805481,
0.2115756720304489,
-0.7536542415618896,
0.2091549187898636,
-0.20420138537883759,
0.2639199197292328,
0.9185299873352051,
-0.11524085700511932,
0.5223146080970764,
-0.17251832783222198,
0.5773429870605469,
0.6247374415397644,
0.5157658457756042,
-0.4586555063724518,
-0.6601080894470215,
-0.5833560228347778,
-0.719415009021759,
0.2791115939617157,
0.13911835849285126,
-0.9948509335517883,
0.059193555265665054,
-0.32554173469543457,
-0.40197569131851196,
-0.9000723958015442,
0.16610747575759888,
0.3707072138786316,
0.44887080788612366,
0.1939397156238556,
-1.093888282775879,
-0.8315216302871704,
-0.8540412783622742,
0.0760945975780487,
-0.298147052526474,
0.35697904229164124,
-0.17339928448200226,
-0.0026465067639946938,
-0.38627493381500244,
1.0725010633468628,
-0.15091124176979065,
-0.6552562117576599,
-0.3052891492843628,
0.3158324658870697,
0.13931530714035034,
0.3242068886756897,
0.5325549244880676,
-0.6365606188774109,
-0.2993219792842865,
0.08016148954629898,
-0.7334367036819458,
-0.2360628992319107,
0.07341638952493668,
-0.19686828553676605,
0.3429245352745056,
0.06660651415586472,
-0.4848690927028656,
0.24842247366905212,
1.001848578453064,
-0.3038989007472992,
0.24083669483661652,
0.36081361770629883,
0.38188180327415466,
-1.588866114616394,
-0.1511870175600052,
0.39164695143699646,
-0.372802734375,
-0.37585607171058655,
0.018548138439655304,
-0.09323809295892715,
-0.24876831471920013,
-0.496622771024704,
0.34741678833961487,
-0.24612312018871307,
-0.09804826974868774,
-0.38255128264427185,
0.006706834305077791,
0.14390169084072113,
0.33584898710250854,
-0.0997639000415802,
0.7316429615020752,
0.5547665357589722,
0.011981886811554432,
0.21239374577999115,
0.0560903437435627,
-0.017425335943698883,
0.7942841053009033,
-0.1733066737651825,
0.18978112936019897,
-0.2290739119052887,
0.3687008023262024,
-1.1108742952346802,
-0.15078377723693848,
0.4696638584136963,
-0.4232259690761566,
0.3176531195640564,
-0.19132572412490845,
-0.34681904315948486,
-0.052809953689575195,
-0.5781501531600952,
0.2961603105068207,
0.32073065638542175,
-0.262296587228775,
1.1595830917358398,
0.7575676441192627,
-0.13413159549236298,
-0.8378247618675232,
-0.2940680682659149,
0.11626291275024414,
-0.42446863651275635,
-0.7051458358764648,
0.05426374822854996,
0.4044027626514435,
-0.019791290163993835,
-0.21501114964485168,
-0.1584528386592865,
-0.17419728636741638,
-0.3569742441177368,
0.6247740983963013,
0.3975653648376465,
-0.11666273325681686,
-0.12541107833385468,
0.15773378312587738,
-0.19939327239990234,
-0.1562792807817459,
-0.20402659475803375,
0.5078823566436768,
-0.051177624613046646,
-0.24808204174041748,
-0.750770092010498,
0.3443109691143036,
0.8904793858528137,
-0.22896011173725128,
0.7711552381515503,
0.9728227853775024,
0.04798661917448044,
0.5589549541473389,
-0.77544766664505,
0.08897864073514938,
-0.38376444578170776,
0.2001158893108368,
-0.3742913603782654,
-0.4324522018432617,
0.5936284065246582,
-0.09546323865652084,
0.19955378770828247,
0.3947976231575012,
0.4054393768310547,
-0.5203390717506409,
1.2399598360061646,
0.8119847178459167,
-0.110069639980793,
0.7066390514373779,
-0.28550055623054504,
0.4173232913017273,
-0.9683771729469299,
-0.4454535245895386,
-0.3515107333660126,
-0.5999714136123657,
-0.4783576428890228,
-0.5464973449707031,
0.40788260102272034,
-0.2477770745754242,
0.16240517795085907,
0.2809686064720154,
-0.18327482044696808,
0.029055306687951088,
0.38488999009132385,
0.11999406665563583,
0.17228183150291443,
0.1127670407295227,
-0.08862683922052383,
-0.17041876912117004,
-0.36391136050224304,
-0.5630292296409607,
1.0836559534072876,
0.5943707823753357,
0.6326887607574463,
0.10166807472705841,
0.4885350167751312,
0.1767154037952423,
0.20373821258544922,
-0.8736580014228821,
0.5311856865882874,
-0.34437936544418335,
-0.4033644199371338,
0.22878946363925934,
-0.27812305092811584,
-0.6565613746643066,
0.31201115250587463,
-0.35595718026161194,
-0.6915216445922852,
0.36488810181617737,
0.1433408111333847,
0.028858430683612823,
0.41248080134391785,
-0.9803555011749268,
0.8527969717979431,
0.20834846794605255,
-0.3319213390350342,
-0.2607857882976532,
-0.8711792230606079,
0.2663215100765228,
-0.06459933519363403,
0.3678816556930542,
-0.35234761238098145,
-0.1280430108308792,
0.6025387644767761,
-0.2565676271915436,
0.9582868814468384,
-0.35095569491386414,
-0.02532065659761429,
0.24690791964530945,
0.07577019184827805,
0.2702372670173645,
-0.04577566310763359,
0.041310787200927734,
0.2484736293554306,
0.3809131681919098,
-0.6228206753730774,
-0.5734578371047974,
0.5018764138221741,
-0.5865324139595032,
-0.44756805896759033,
-0.6178436875343323,
-0.695366382598877,
-0.5336846709251404,
-0.1327546089887619,
-0.11765401810407639,
0.6292692422866821,
0.2113349735736847,
0.1601983904838562,
0.2083204835653305,
0.03601231426000595,
0.5710415840148926,
0.10616748780012131,
-0.4252606928348541,
-0.6426059007644653,
1.069587230682373,
-0.06820249557495117,
0.15918399393558502,
0.3267297148704529,
0.09220949560403824,
-0.4406479001045227,
-0.525492250919342,
-0.4491686224937439,
0.14019498229026794,
-0.5839753746986389,
-0.5120424628257751,
-0.5924323797225952,
0.19346031546592712,
-0.5365453362464905,
0.03157047927379608,
-0.4671746492385864,
-0.4624251425266266,
0.023556474596261978,
0.16565106809139252,
0.12283065915107727,
0.46043333411216736,
0.03622467443346977,
0.5297682285308838,
-0.9457798004150391,
0.3166867196559906,
0.19755984842777252,
0.15821847319602966,
-0.3815575838088989,
-0.27349618077278137,
0.03437131270766258,
0.2463195025920868,
-0.695720374584198,
-0.9291598200798035,
0.4617018401622772,
0.17713358998298645,
0.14793872833251953,
0.6737277507781982,
-0.19482262432575226,
1.0386542081832886,
-0.029357070103287697,
0.9489979147911072,
0.5933175683021545,
-0.8510374426841736,
0.49304842948913574,
-0.19677381217479706,
0.27387213706970215,
0.42685508728027344,
0.2027166783809662,
-0.39995139837265015,
-0.6250036954879761,
-0.37532854080200195,
-0.5882540941238403,
0.5287261009216309,
0.031623441725969315,
0.22494865953922272,
0.010480480268597603,
-0.09053142368793488,
0.42854180932044983,
0.3257421553134918,
-0.6473041772842407,
0.08814901858568192,
-0.521060049533844,
-0.6739214062690735,
0.14805729687213898,
-0.2915242910385132,
-0.14969836175441742,
-0.11242113262414932,
0.6597704291343689,
-0.387639582157135,
0.3167937994003296,
0.052089955657720566,
0.000024416543965344317,
0.011143609881401062,
0.19611532986164093,
0.3509921133518219,
0.927484393119812,
-0.2979254424571991,
0.020972687751054764,
-0.18507230281829834,
-0.45527762174606323,
0.05376942455768585,
-0.13921622931957245,
0.09934420883655548,
0.042685750871896744,
0.15444758534431458,
0.7215770483016968,
-0.23759984970092773,
-0.6049013733863831,
0.4991629719734192,
-0.016042621806263924,
0.16510002315044403,
0.18314476311206818,
-0.39842841029167175,
-0.22699205577373505,
0.3740461468696594,
0.28629687428474426,
0.5472474694252014,
-0.0980282798409462,
-0.923581063747406,
0.028853198513388634,
0.5794888138771057,
-0.9438097476959229,
-0.5671682357788086,
0.25999388098716736,
0.3099854290485382,
0.22867906093597412,
0.1793081909418106,
-0.188332661986351,
-0.3829929530620575,
0.2603301703929901,
0.16580554842948914,
0.8747062087059021,
-0.0931430533528328,
0.4625188708305359,
-0.005220355466008186,
0.09053763002157211,
0.2340313196182251,
0.3438562750816345,
0.32488951086997986,
-0.5241266489028931,
-0.8564519882202148,
-0.7453076839447021,
-0.257091760635376,
-0.4786827564239502,
-0.3053949177265167,
0.271028608083725,
-0.3769252598285675,
-0.5848382711410522,
-0.04792732745409012,
-0.22410184144973755,
-0.32852205634117126,
0.20843245089054108,
-0.07834133505821228,
0.439086377620697,
-0.8217833638191223,
0.890067994594574,
0.8245750665664673,
-0.5459867119789124,
-0.7326099276542664,
-0.06831053644418716,
0.32430389523506165,
-0.6672618389129639,
0.4814756214618683,
0.22781482338905334,
0.015959111973643303,
-0.45550915598869324,
-0.28583353757858276,
-0.5357429385185242,
1.031717300415039,
0.39922794699668884,
-0.03542410954833031,
0.20668664574623108,
0.06264965981245041,
0.38530439138412476,
-0.6554254293441772,
0.21287058293819427,
0.22364991903305054,
0.3106459379196167,
0.48752152919769287,
-1.0041537284851074,
-0.18994228541851044,
-0.05334581807255745,
-0.045628324151039124,
0.4538019299507141,
-0.7003427743911743,
0.5183759331703186,
-0.047082945704460144,
-0.09661086648702621,
0.15552105009555817,
0.8032605051994324,
0.028542637825012207,
0.6184288263320923,
0.48046720027923584,
0.7740642428398132,
0.22101205587387085,
-0.43463942408561707,
0.8429353833198547,
-0.09134187549352646,
0.3096972703933716,
0.6296665668487549,
-0.25743812322616577,
0.8467193841934204,
0.98775714635849,
-0.25734400749206543,
0.7393186688423157,
0.544086217880249,
0.40018323063850403,
0.7426770329475403,
-0.6593791246414185,
-0.14268149435520172,
-0.12075316905975342,
-0.6218640804290771,
-0.2867514193058014,
0.7562094330787659,
0.17759184539318085,
-0.3595646023750305,
-0.06612342596054077,
0.24928885698318481,
-0.008346609771251678,
-0.15838567912578583,
-0.2503495216369629,
1.003097653388977,
0.058458440005779266,
-0.5099696516990662,
-0.13610593974590302,
-0.15629765391349792,
0.7152465581893921,
-0.5900471210479736,
0.12993930280208588,
-0.36081379652023315,
0.07894497364759445,
-0.19516584277153015,
-0.9329379796981812,
0.6023035049438477,
-0.09596997499465942,
-0.14101910591125488,
-0.14901448786258698,
0.516074538230896,
-0.15187789499759674,
-0.6426173448562622,
-0.06161721795797348,
0.4778638184070587,
-0.1953052431344986,
-0.01084901113063097,
-0.7334097027778625,
0.1897125244140625,
-0.04057861119508743,
0.316776305437088,
0.601885199546814,
0.5515397191047668,
0.10159026086330414,
0.6822964549064636,
0.6623074412345886,
0.04189801216125488,
0.1062404215335846,
0.00647703418508172,
0.7493979334831238,
-0.3756694495677948,
-0.29287853837013245,
-0.659636378288269,
0.7586609721183777,
-0.20779840648174286,
-0.1037047952413559,
0.47342726588249207,
0.3004239499568939,
0.437009334564209,
-0.050665732473134995,
0.27453407645225525,
-0.38413017988204956,
0.2675432860851288,
-0.7522727847099304,
0.27149346470832825,
-0.6436007022857666,
0.11430537700653076,
-0.647904098033905,
-1.1129642724990845,
-0.30438482761383057,
0.26807209849357605,
-0.11188831180334091,
-0.29339486360549927,
0.9252288341522217,
1.0015465021133423,
-0.2570604681968689,
-0.11202796548604965,
0.12614917755126953,
-0.08726174384355545,
0.4679540693759918,
0.23256532847881317,
0.8591672778129578,
-0.5398292541503906,
0.7048574686050415,
-0.6060181260108948,
-0.053555313497781754,
0.14471030235290527,
-0.9910204410552979,
-0.6268044710159302,
-0.942748486995697,
-0.4087478518486023,
-0.42505863308906555,
0.0807357057929039,
0.8593060970306396,
0.8580013513565063,
-0.8571305274963379,
-0.10351154208183289,
0.43418535590171814,
0.05956370383501053,
-0.3798665404319763,
-0.22816847264766693,
0.22920958697795868,
-0.5875213146209717,
-0.9406958818435669,
-0.08812865614891052,
0.6929485201835632,
-0.0424877293407917,
-0.30210641026496887,
0.16055674850940704,
-0.28924763202667236,
-0.035525720566511154,
0.7697880268096924,
-0.02428998053073883,
-1.0337064266204834,
-0.38880839943885803,
-0.02857285737991333,
0.041046466678380966,
0.3260236382484436,
0.8215789198875427,
-0.7550114393234253,
0.9408146739006042,
0.6493220329284668,
0.5024150609970093,
0.03275305777788162,
0.2571410834789276,
0.7968189120292664,
-0.8361536860466003,
0.5312864780426025,
0.020031290128827095,
0.6806522607803345,
0.393528014421463,
0.1211404874920845,
0.41888970136642456,
0.2059708535671234,
-0.22506050765514374,
-0.6204716563224792,
0.12323795258998871,
-1.571421504020691,
-0.08203151077032089,
0.8164159655570984,
-0.22178685665130615,
-0.3335116505622864,
-0.03794793039560318,
-0.6099672913551331,
0.17794160544872284,
-0.6778979897499084,
1.0557845830917358,
0.7093216776847839,
0.1440485417842865,
-0.40138933062553406,
-0.22189630568027496,
0.05317669361829758,
0.6098015308380127,
-0.5592775940895081,
-0.4071154296398163,
0.6064717173576355,
-0.19634246826171875,
0.28838035464286804,
0.35714465379714966,
-0.408488005399704,
0.13733667135238647,
-0.351103812456131,
-0.18385618925094604,
0.04220499470829964,
-0.29902204871177673,
-0.05382639169692993,
0.4016476571559906,
0.020168133080005646,
-0.5535909533500671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14075v1
|
$T^2$ of Thoughts: Temperature Tree Elicits Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-23T00:40:43 | 2024-05-23T00:40:43 |
Chengkun Cai, Xu Zhao, Yucheng Du, Haoliang Liu, Lei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools in artificial
intelligence, especially in complex decision-making scenarios, but their static
problem-solving strategies often limit their adaptability to dynamic
environments. We explore the enhancement of reasoning capabilities in LLMs
through Temperature Tree ($T^2$) prompting via Particle Swarm Optimization,
termed as $T^2$ of Thoughts ($T^2oT$). The primary focus is on enhancing
decision-making processes by dynamically adjusting search parameters,
especially temperature, to improve accuracy without increasing computational
demands. We empirically validate that our hybrid $T^2oT$ approach yields
enhancements in, single-solution accuracy, multi-solution generation and text
generation quality. Our findings suggest that while dynamic search depth
adjustments based on temperature can yield mixed results, a fixed search depth,
when coupled with adaptive capabilities of $T^2oT$, provides a more reliable
and versatile problem-solving strategy. This work highlights the potential for
future explorations in optimizing algorithmic interactions with foundational
language models, particularly illustrated by our development for the Game of 24
and Creative Writing tasks.
|
[
-0.12450403720140457,
-0.8860592842102051,
0.9203377962112427,
0.13229171931743622,
-0.5342290997505188,
0.7529237866401672,
-0.38093873858451843,
-0.32782667875289917,
0.033692870289087296,
0.06351848691701889,
-0.48815882205963135,
-0.3120036721229553,
-0.3474252223968506,
-0.051040347665548325,
0.09388808906078339,
0.47630995512008667,
-0.10177832096815109,
-0.4692080318927765,
-0.14764338731765747,
0.30604156851768494,
-0.2548149824142456,
-0.3723423182964325,
-0.8791975975036621,
-0.44977328181266785,
0.3475237786769867,
0.5305144190788269,
0.9300393462181091,
0.3675577640533447,
0.35290127992630005,
0.26780280470848083,
-0.09920525550842285,
0.3167194724082947,
-0.5632154941558838,
0.6023966073989868,
-0.5257487893104553,
-0.44494664669036865,
-0.22186726331710815,
-0.32302325963974,
0.6428167223930359,
0.3347872197628021,
-0.03792639076709747,
-0.06938176602125168,
-0.21992453932762146,
0.7258396744728088,
-0.5118706822395325,
0.2264062762260437,
-0.9911587238311768,
0.14895154535770416,
-0.05253244563937187,
-0.39593666791915894,
-0.2599770128726959,
-0.198916494846344,
0.2544410824775696,
-0.4624914824962616,
0.008824854157865047,
-0.008668079040944576,
0.5039042830467224,
0.4590812921524048,
-0.3521707355976105,
-0.21596582233905792,
-0.9745567440986633,
0.9298449754714966,
-0.8138647079467773,
0.40395358204841614,
0.10404609143733978,
0.07378080487251282,
-0.3160557746887207,
-0.33527839183807373,
-0.6392442584037781,
0.019413694739341736,
0.2921079099178314,
0.20706255733966827,
-0.37022268772125244,
-0.05990669131278992,
0.17170819640159607,
0.0369173139333725,
-0.33133891224861145,
0.09164364635944366,
-0.08922088891267776,
-0.047056008130311966,
0.6986790299415588,
0.2329787164926529,
0.27675190567970276,
-0.062143418937921524,
0.32268834114074707,
-0.10602658987045288,
-0.060592230409383774,
0.35156112909317017,
0.14094758033752441,
0.1475302129983902,
0.23103514313697815,
0.4506884813308716,
-0.02796334959566593,
0.4651023745536804,
0.02732245996594429,
-0.20201312005519867,
0.005282977130264044,
-0.3728099763393402,
-0.03371115028858185,
-0.15876075625419617,
0.6830503940582275,
0.4550093114376068,
0.18278421461582184,
-0.33826619386672974,
-0.15981170535087585,
0.2002537101507187,
0.14683859050273895,
-0.8268206715583801,
-0.5576861500740051,
0.4588949382305145,
-0.1793104112148285,
-0.5287522673606873,
-0.15221774578094482,
-0.9516094923019409,
-0.25323066115379333,
-0.1338789165019989,
0.14015786349773407,
-0.4642980098724365,
-0.6956966519355774,
0.28526008129119873,
-0.5151365995407104,
-0.038757819682359695,
0.3369174301624298,
-0.883925199508667,
0.21685773134231567,
0.7044884562492371,
0.6896202564239502,
-0.11894110590219498,
-0.005794513504952192,
0.10722801834344864,
0.2712182402610779,
-0.7164677977561951,
0.9060441255569458,
-1.1350102424621582,
-0.5783578753471375,
-0.368865042924881,
-0.5839446783065796,
-0.05610504001379013,
-0.33759668469429016,
0.3111754357814789,
-0.4852832555770874,
0.3424185812473297,
-0.3416476547718048,
-0.26519516110420227,
-0.009955222718417645,
0.15705518424510956,
-0.3273724317550659,
1.3310285806655884,
-0.009405598044395447,
-0.7152565717697144,
0.08384531736373901,
-0.810198187828064,
-0.5235908627510071,
0.16774886846542358,
-0.17433872818946838,
-0.36708831787109375,
0.2670062184333801,
0.291511207818985,
0.1720324456691742,
-0.3754369020462036,
0.10631673783063889,
-0.29468849301338196,
-0.09625105559825897,
0.19097280502319336,
0.06135519593954086,
0.5246800780296326,
0.26084208488464355,
-0.48884114623069763,
0.2963237166404724,
-0.3561045229434967,
0.404144287109375,
0.6098299026489258,
-0.32798054814338684,
-0.3211650550365448,
0.42112767696380615,
-0.6192989945411682,
-0.01839643530547619,
0.3661338686943054,
-0.37701648473739624,
0.3968167006969452,
-0.45123448967933655,
0.8152350783348083,
0.5972121953964233,
0.13262319564819336,
0.5812307000160217,
-0.22629240155220032,
0.6918110847473145,
-0.16870646178722382,
-0.171964630484581,
0.15699130296707153,
-0.5074491500854492,
-0.5388692021369934,
0.12380095571279526,
-0.11846450716257095,
0.8886857628822327,
-0.9672743082046509,
0.20180223882198334,
0.09131811559200287,
-0.8616476655006409,
-0.18926465511322021,
0.05662089213728905,
0.2875571846961975,
0.5359954237937927,
0.13882653415203094,
0.3647433817386627,
-0.5335169434547424,
-0.5976625680923462,
-0.17801889777183533,
-0.31232041120529175,
0.10637159645557404,
0.4870680868625641,
0.20982342958450317,
-0.08471828699111938,
0.8567696213722229,
-0.5300624966621399,
0.4801846742630005,
-0.2952815890312195,
-0.12152623385190964,
0.2914668023586273,
0.27662193775177,
0.6081282496452332,
-0.5786674618721008,
-0.29167744517326355,
0.034487467259168625,
-0.7083877325057983,
-0.1267598271369934,
-0.027718426659703255,
-0.4131544530391693,
0.31283053755760193,
0.4753219485282898,
-0.7868975400924683,
0.09983199834823608,
0.39451175928115845,
-0.3937831223011017,
0.4125532805919647,
-0.1746423989534378,
0.045236147940158844,
-1.118180513381958,
-0.14012257754802704,
-0.0027915011160075665,
0.08265217393636703,
-0.6208329796791077,
0.29244017601013184,
0.023929573595523834,
-0.32551297545433044,
-0.3055476248264313,
0.49255630373954773,
-0.35538601875305176,
0.0705147311091423,
-0.5181934237480164,
0.15908165276050568,
0.10557591170072556,
0.22662070393562317,
0.1489226073026657,
0.8536393046379089,
0.7002816796302795,
-0.6784416437149048,
0.7831000685691833,
0.030557524412870407,
-0.0819891169667244,
0.12815852463245392,
-0.5180976986885071,
0.6198225617408752,
-0.21413582563400269,
0.3504571318626404,
-0.9061448574066162,
-0.11179644614458084,
0.19749532639980316,
-0.33258113265037537,
-0.08931085467338562,
0.4180002808570862,
-0.868476390838623,
-0.690956175327301,
-0.41105738282203674,
0.5508770942687988,
0.6114661693572998,
-0.3501589298248291,
0.66953444480896,
0.2812665104866028,
-0.18325553834438324,
-0.04123559221625328,
-0.395943284034729,
0.15894827246665955,
-0.23544934391975403,
-0.6370782256126404,
0.42325955629348755,
-0.22687961161136627,
-0.6285526156425476,
0.02555585652589798,
-0.20521025359630585,
0.21169278025627136,
0.3348633944988251,
-0.17797431349754333,
0.12985731661319733,
-0.2347354143857956,
0.40995147824287415,
0.42188867926597595,
0.11797583848237991,
0.2353137880563736,
-0.5844174027442932,
0.7521629929542542,
-0.26163315773010254,
0.1252478063106537,
-0.3107093870639801,
0.2968975901603699,
0.5484304428100586,
-0.3359091579914093,
0.4514595568180084,
0.20823685824871063,
-0.5718122720718384,
-0.4096429646015167,
-0.3089402914047241,
-0.3332987427711487,
-0.5361739993095398,
0.3667255640029907,
-0.7320084571838379,
-0.9570959210395813,
0.5105054378509521,
-0.17787998914718628,
0.1530320793390274,
0.5231466889381409,
0.6221523880958557,
-0.3360089659690857,
1.1058781147003174,
0.3340577781200409,
0.2567393183708191,
0.5210108160972595,
0.11510251462459564,
0.5007486939430237,
-0.715980589389801,
-0.5638964176177979,
-0.4957673251628876,
-0.4695015251636505,
-0.6289501786231995,
-0.5579530000686646,
0.5107214450836182,
0.1520761102437973,
-0.310820072889328,
0.011645955964922905,
-0.8657379746437073,
0.8060317039489746,
0.6597549319267273,
0.5445007085800171,
-0.11719325184822083,
-0.11614195257425308,
-0.20365360379219055,
-0.08263441175222397,
-0.8729568123817444,
-0.38541239500045776,
0.7552869319915771,
0.3435099720954895,
0.4428368806838989,
0.2502062916755676,
0.4691172242164612,
-0.047225382179021835,
-0.35952579975128174,
-0.8096061944961548,
0.7137823700904846,
-0.14007532596588135,
-0.3889055848121643,
-0.6346628069877625,
-0.34043970704078674,
-0.8824130892753601,
0.23686696588993073,
-0.2959531545639038,
-0.8165474534034729,
-0.2796504497528076,
0.0671832263469696,
-0.5483168363571167,
0.6409996151924133,
-0.5275952816009521,
0.5517165064811707,
-0.5743792653083801,
-0.3730772137641907,
-0.6293435096740723,
-0.3487585783004761,
0.1674627810716629,
-0.35334861278533936,
0.12287518382072449,
-0.24963270127773285,
-0.339263379573822,
0.8111600279808044,
-0.2810401916503906,
0.581741213798523,
-0.031231936067342758,
-0.1321335881948471,
0.4143195152282715,
0.5586374998092651,
0.6737332940101624,
-0.006466568913310766,
-0.6327218413352966,
-0.23361794650554657,
0.1700584590435028,
-0.6055445671081543,
-0.6479655504226685,
0.673508882522583,
-0.8061097264289856,
-1.1297427415847778,
-0.5203589200973511,
-0.9210833311080933,
-0.4968804717063904,
0.3516145646572113,
-0.07727609574794769,
0.04309798777103424,
0.06138869374990463,
0.0742560401558876,
0.6722054481506348,
-0.46993404626846313,
0.6748059988021851,
0.31619709730148315,
-0.3620087206363678,
-0.2105550915002823,
0.7661557197570801,
-0.19294165074825287,
0.19681726396083832,
0.47154560685157776,
0.8068108558654785,
-0.14403092861175537,
-0.6776793003082275,
-0.2892392575740814,
0.16145780682563782,
-0.5366384983062744,
-0.1798531711101532,
-0.6429990530014038,
-0.07979602366685867,
-0.4748395085334778,
-0.2899017632007599,
-0.06474310159683228,
-0.5275629162788391,
-0.5297009944915771,
-0.2068297415971756,
0.675216019153595,
0.584611177444458,
0.06905455142259598,
0.16635046899318695,
-0.6779141426086426,
0.22953833639621735,
0.25915324687957764,
0.1931176334619522,
0.16351068019866943,
-0.36390823125839233,
0.03718644753098488,
0.013878973200917244,
-0.212387815117836,
-0.8542205095291138,
0.14954820275306702,
0.15118791162967682,
0.4547143280506134,
0.11048977822065353,
0.1525224894285202,
0.45688462257385254,
-0.38232672214508057,
0.8156959414482117,
0.013043051585555077,
-1.1251404285430908,
0.9614097476005554,
-0.6072890758514404,
0.8581193089485168,
0.33142200112342834,
0.11986743658781052,
-0.2879672944545746,
-0.5377328395843506,
-0.7278627157211304,
-0.6014612913131714,
0.6024345755577087,
0.1565946489572525,
0.2597567141056061,
0.10982968658208847,
0.5800864100456238,
-0.009222709573805332,
0.25894996523857117,
-0.1883622109889984,
0.19592450559139252,
-0.27069005370140076,
-0.011244628578424454,
0.08466760069131851,
-0.2997512221336365,
0.11839619278907776,
-0.5825297832489014,
0.6520530581474304,
-0.028246227651834488,
0.3283085227012634,
-0.09095794707536697,
0.6453492045402527,
-0.5943055748939514,
0.14302882552146912,
0.6511695981025696,
0.8338136076927185,
-0.21111823618412018,
0.4139919877052307,
0.3695621192455292,
-0.04173238202929497,
-0.1547432839870453,
-0.2365720123052597,
-0.1634555160999298,
-0.16236205399036407,
0.2651319205760956,
0.7379101514816284,
-0.009231830947101116,
-0.6013548374176025,
-0.12874837219715118,
0.16927336156368256,
-0.2663739323616028,
-0.07393182069063187,
0.38541534543037415,
0.31656184792518616,
0.5734769105911255,
0.3030655086040497,
0.12712565064430237,
-0.1078554019331932,
-0.799124002456665,
-0.01783401146531105,
0.6760441660881042,
0.1721280813217163,
-0.33068233728408813,
0.6049285531044006,
0.2257152944803238,
-0.6959659457206726,
0.670761227607727,
-0.2413555085659027,
-1.110725998878479,
0.7012805342674255,
0.7016091346740723,
0.6772342920303345,
-0.3067851662635803,
0.19491200149059296,
0.31758031249046326,
0.33286619186401367,
-0.03970218822360039,
0.7762676477432251,
-0.047807373106479645,
-0.8610495924949646,
-0.26768025755882263,
-0.44761836528778076,
-0.5927489399909973,
0.007048257160931826,
-0.07401333004236221,
0.06884454190731049,
-1.0813910961151123,
-0.1675998568534851,
0.01047825813293457,
0.09763162583112717,
-0.49980562925338745,
0.24404878914356232,
0.2516610324382782,
0.7389017343521118,
-0.5514228940010071,
0.9258416295051575,
0.6353751420974731,
-0.0032215004321187735,
-0.9243564605712891,
0.15313009917736053,
-0.00021462011500261724,
-0.8145136833190918,
0.38064494729042053,
-0.24563996493816376,
-0.5166232585906982,
0.009302124381065369,
-0.5824874043464661,
-1.0310560464859009,
0.9320366978645325,
0.35044217109680176,
-0.7682945132255554,
-0.17609034478664398,
0.1239645704627037,
0.8110260963439941,
-0.31136348843574524,
0.036255333572626114,
0.7154362797737122,
0.42847728729248047,
0.4214303195476532,
-0.9628276228904724,
0.16432084143161774,
-0.3815004229545593,
0.06225124001502991,
0.4876299798488617,
-0.8920024037361145,
0.6213804483413696,
-0.46988269686698914,
-0.18945035338401794,
-0.18180376291275024,
0.6642870903015137,
0.4780454933643341,
0.4591323733329773,
0.46512529253959656,
0.45313745737075806,
1.082385540008545,
-0.0442647710442543,
0.9402928352355957,
-0.3327980637550354,
0.05035679042339325,
0.8407583832740784,
-0.34110596776008606,
0.8939483761787415,
0.4487547278404236,
-0.18521632254123688,
0.536680281162262,
0.9572773575782776,
0.027592670172452927,
0.596854567527771,
0.3266230821609497,
-0.31304192543029785,
-0.4948251247406006,
-0.25335705280303955,
-0.17537912726402283,
0.0881853774189949,
0.6282303333282471,
-0.02410442754626274,
0.005214091390371323,
-0.019569525495171547,
0.1890697479248047,
0.385585218667984,
-0.2703332304954529,
0.7054587602615356,
0.1340268850326538,
-0.8211591839790344,
0.26832908391952515,
-0.004343010950833559,
0.503856360912323,
-0.032296597957611084,
0.20597025752067566,
-0.031685952097177505,
0.15668293833732605,
-0.2747991979122162,
-1.1559733152389526,
0.3441031575202942,
-0.019163819029927254,
-0.22430647909641266,
-0.4118194282054901,
0.6816786527633667,
-0.14580921828746796,
-0.9269641041755676,
0.1773301661014557,
0.4631512761116028,
0.12377968430519104,
-0.09397295862436295,
-0.8545846343040466,
0.4085308611392975,
0.04839972034096718,
-0.13830827176570892,
-0.10164859890937805,
0.7415928244590759,
-0.031641535460948944,
0.6063807010650635,
0.5282489657402039,
0.10937629640102386,
-0.24051736295223236,
-0.11080238223075867,
0.9714621305465698,
-0.6739343404769897,
-0.5216895937919617,
-1.0271196365356445,
-0.0025443462654948235,
0.1223796159029007,
-0.014221806079149246,
0.4599444270133972,
0.5580184459686279,
0.6736413836479187,
0.16805973649024963,
1.0045965909957886,
0.10820377618074417,
0.6211670637130737,
-0.5835806727409363,
0.20851585268974304,
-0.48688504099845886,
0.26181331276893616,
-0.1999548226594925,
-1.1256581544876099,
-0.2766043543815613,
0.3800337314605713,
-0.6887800693511963,
0.009480324573814869,
0.983741044998169,
0.48929086327552795,
-0.009736530482769012,
0.25729385018348694,
0.1164821907877922,
0.10314059257507324,
0.5399918556213379,
0.9138647317886353,
0.749613344669342,
0.009899623692035675,
0.41144993901252747,
-0.35678887367248535,
-0.3594089448451996,
-0.043325766921043396,
-0.8801807761192322,
-1.155333161354065,
-0.503260612487793,
-0.3853152394294739,
-0.4983222484588623,
0.07624347507953644,
1.1834139823913574,
0.41441646218299866,
-0.6257497668266296,
-0.15652713179588318,
-0.1641824096441269,
-0.05401178449392319,
-0.015828343108296394,
-0.18631069362163544,
0.3414415419101715,
-0.3228950500488281,
-0.5307245254516602,
0.6266467571258545,
0.3189980387687683,
0.06893721222877502,
-0.11443223804235458,
-0.0587628111243248,
0.020322265103459358,
0.5718565583229065,
0.6442340612411499,
0.12663698196411133,
-0.8431304097175598,
-0.23378315567970276,
0.21724089980125427,
-0.0035189231857657433,
0.10658540576696396,
0.8023627400398254,
-0.5922254920005798,
0.6363757848739624,
0.6574323177337646,
0.700882077217102,
0.5399218797683716,
-0.004940410144627094,
0.5389746427536011,
-0.22604213654994965,
0.16920199990272522,
0.5950171947479248,
0.11409226804971695,
0.18865825235843658,
-0.4894741177558899,
0.28239819407463074,
0.22030897438526154,
-0.4231503903865814,
-0.5908089280128479,
0.3674004077911377,
-0.9728357791900635,
-0.8039040565490723,
1.3463904857635498,
0.41032519936561584,
-0.30192500352859497,
0.296926349401474,
-0.35768967866897583,
0.3131973445415497,
-0.7917872667312622,
1.058893084526062,
0.8698492646217346,
-0.5223945379257202,
-0.6094933748245239,
-0.22188805043697357,
0.4680098593235016,
0.7353441119194031,
-0.9574326872825623,
-0.04425547644495964,
0.28693458437919617,
0.004683186300098896,
0.06665244698524475,
0.37748757004737854,
0.2447286993265152,
0.1030789390206337,
-0.0718950554728508,
-0.4189441502094269,
-0.0686267539858818,
-0.14506648480892181,
0.07298213988542557,
0.16374161839485168,
0.3783113956451416,
0.0775928944349289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00016v1
|
Exploration of Attention Mechanism-Enhanced Deep Learning Models in the Mining of Medical Textual Data
| 2024-05-23T00:20:14 | 2024-05-23T00:20:14 |
Lingxi Xiao, Muqing Li, Yinqiu Feng, Meiqi Wang, Ziyi Zhu, Zexi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The research explores the utilization of a deep learning model employing an
attention mechanism in medical text mining. It targets the challenge of
analyzing unstructured text information within medical data. This research
seeks to enhance the model's capability to identify essential medical
information by incorporating deep learning and attention mechanisms. This paper
reviews the basic principles and typical model architecture of attention
mechanisms and shows the effectiveness of their application in the tasks of
disease prediction, drug side effect monitoring, and entity relationship
extraction. Aiming at the particularity of medical texts, an adaptive attention
model integrating domain knowledge is proposed, and its ability to understand
medical terms and process complex contexts is optimized. The experiment
verifies the model's effectiveness in improving task accuracy and robustness,
especially when dealing with long text. The future research path of enhancing
model interpretation, realizing cross-domain knowledge transfer, and adapting
to low-resource scenarios is discussed in the research outlook, which provides
a new perspective and method support for intelligent medical information
processing and clinical decision assistance. Finally, cross-domain knowledge
transfer and adaptation strategies for low-resource scenarios, providing
theoretical basis and technical reference for promoting the development of
intelligent medical information processing and clinical decision support
systems.
|
[
0.09894803911447525,
-0.8372093439102173,
0.9691997170448303,
-0.1538156419992447,
-0.280508816242218,
-0.37798047065734863,
-0.30010709166526794,
-0.46626800298690796,
0.09959980100393295,
0.6860030889511108,
-0.670319139957428,
-0.5268996357917786,
-0.6683559417724609,
-0.005996525753289461,
-0.14913201332092285,
1.2576836347579956,
-0.12925982475280762,
0.4136950969696045,
-0.32265982031822205,
-0.14324969053268433,
-0.58931964635849,
-0.5057499408721924,
-0.6346606016159058,
-0.49951407313346863,
0.5489131212234497,
0.10224149376153946,
0.46272119879722595,
0.5461898446083069,
1.1610304117202759,
0.18063507974147797,
0.060654085129499435,
-0.05937260389328003,
-0.3843294084072113,
0.23153847455978394,
-0.3833724856376648,
-0.6223425269126892,
-0.652379035949707,
-0.24231649935245514,
0.29802635312080383,
0.7774955630302429,
0.07676687836647034,
0.10897550731897354,
0.22793950140476227,
0.8059819936752319,
-0.5150012969970703,
0.12091153860092163,
-0.402010977268219,
0.3728882372379303,
-0.08341090381145477,
-0.49731504917144775,
-0.21982140839099884,
0.10235980898141861,
0.49406611919403076,
-0.5334131121635437,
0.3299632668495178,
-0.11934453994035721,
0.5055217742919922,
0.7950838804244995,
-0.2577378749847412,
-0.40701189637184143,
-0.5309731960296631,
0.6925995945930481,
-0.6948488354682922,
0.28719180822372437,
0.34721091389656067,
0.23331980407238007,
-0.10133298486471176,
-1.0481789112091064,
-0.06607955694198608,
-0.26111090183258057,
-0.21956387162208557,
0.27662423253059387,
0.13559654355049133,
0.2708265781402588,
0.2442459911108017,
0.5619472861289978,
-0.31412485241889954,
0.09476058930158615,
-0.4609668254852295,
0.16642135381698608,
0.40400123596191406,
0.434127539396286,
0.36727479100227356,
-0.06365883350372314,
-0.5177209377288818,
0.37337327003479004,
-0.5254622101783752,
-0.011361007578670979,
-0.5294083952903748,
0.22425459325313568,
-0.3408031463623047,
0.48938050866127014,
-0.3100658357143402,
0.6583374738693237,
0.14945979416370392,
0.25883397459983826,
0.19102434813976288,
-0.4429335594177246,
-0.6102026104927063,
0.03437294811010361,
0.655164897441864,
0.43737319111824036,
-0.059822943061590195,
-0.11158152669668198,
0.044508468359708786,
-0.06129724159836769,
0.47615569829940796,
-0.867897093296051,
-0.32072678208351135,
0.4292784333229065,
-0.9973925352096558,
-0.438815712928772,
-0.5458155274391174,
-0.9365238547325134,
-0.6247339844703674,
-0.42698389291763306,
0.24355028569698334,
-0.5507553815841675,
-0.1540769785642624,
0.40712472796440125,
0.22291125357151031,
-0.15891161561012268,
0.22540754079818726,
-0.7781197428703308,
0.30213943123817444,
0.5859588384628296,
0.8382498621940613,
-0.4866066873073578,
0.0003341928531881422,
-0.35681137442588806,
0.19045856595039368,
0.05288367718458176,
0.7001760601997375,
-0.7286231517791748,
-0.04146643355488777,
-0.09198354929685593,
0.08894079923629761,
-0.4041689336299896,
-0.37645694613456726,
0.8755104541778564,
-0.37304428219795227,
0.2126486450433731,
-0.08887187391519547,
-0.7395381927490234,
-0.3786879777908325,
0.2575950026512146,
-0.809370219707489,
0.5252393484115601,
0.0774058848619461,
-0.9125178456306458,
0.2699993848800659,
-1.0982093811035156,
-0.6206537485122681,
0.07517364621162415,
0.02443305402994156,
-0.48878225684165955,
0.3730406165122986,
0.3637469708919525,
0.8009603023529053,
-0.5852152705192566,
0.3676826059818268,
-0.43100705742836,
-0.13848842680454254,
0.4013270437717438,
-0.21464818716049194,
0.7822237014770508,
0.21794500946998596,
-0.20354579389095306,
0.2421512007713318,
-0.6571608185768127,
-0.12192168831825256,
0.2087954580783844,
-0.3095705807209015,
-0.536902904510498,
0.04270221292972565,
-0.06642267853021622,
0.20807619392871857,
0.10697241127490997,
-0.11769799143075943,
0.10406719893217087,
-0.7310317158699036,
0.4409118592739105,
0.23727627098560333,
0.44778791069984436,
0.468332439661026,
-0.013169338926672935,
0.3393145501613617,
0.05278845876455307,
0.40330755710601807,
-0.19282183051109314,
-0.21587789058685303,
-0.5761775970458984,
0.009900780394673347,
0.5442653894424438,
0.45909354090690613,
-0.3738281726837158,
0.15517127513885498,
-0.07639028877019882,
0.04209103435277939,
-0.8375781178474426,
-0.023911403492093086,
0.3358609974384308,
0.6511795520782471,
0.5267261862754822,
-0.2909694314002991,
-0.538535475730896,
-0.6928843855857849,
-0.3550031781196594,
0.31173357367515564,
0.07928495854139328,
0.4705117642879486,
0.3764388859272003,
-0.5740094780921936,
0.3019755780696869,
-0.5220085382461548,
-0.5096839070320129,
-0.2702319920063019,
-0.14603672921657562,
0.31661882996559143,
0.3818051815032959,
0.581848680973053,
-1.0003812313079834,
-0.34237900376319885,
0.17341063916683197,
-0.9806379675865173,
0.188909113407135,
-0.04628350958228111,
-0.04604102298617363,
-0.06010874733328819,
0.5600151419639587,
-0.599254310131073,
0.30539265275001526,
0.249112069606781,
-0.22472240030765533,
-0.0515197217464447,
-0.1571686714887619,
0.20226408541202545,
-0.990546464920044,
0.24497848749160767,
0.24240678548812866,
-0.034722838550806046,
-0.9970533847808838,
0.3552689850330353,
0.13518697023391724,
-0.059823594987392426,
-0.27563464641571045,
0.657498300075531,
-0.46619874238967896,
0.26267188787460327,
-0.5123440623283386,
0.021884888410568237,
-0.005174244754016399,
0.4514600932598114,
0.059286948293447495,
0.026372244581580162,
0.6713196039199829,
-0.7096412777900696,
0.4623706340789795,
0.05463468283414841,
-0.07989322394132614,
0.686777651309967,
-0.4534739851951599,
-0.010168476961553097,
-0.12889672815799713,
-0.2131701409816742,
-0.8645597100257874,
-0.3894878923892975,
0.46846750378608704,
-0.6341646313667297,
0.5777953267097473,
-0.03561367839574814,
-0.10415491461753845,
-0.5020790100097656,
-0.23385410010814667,
0.24980689585208893,
0.25570622086524963,
-0.2387821227312088,
0.5875072479248047,
0.5148358941078186,
-0.33124494552612305,
-0.4069344401359558,
-0.6129078269004822,
0.08871472626924515,
-0.21561433374881744,
-0.2308052033185959,
0.43596598505973816,
0.02749624103307724,
-0.17726610600948334,
0.22201089560985565,
0.10270515084266663,
-0.18506678938865662,
0.16722902655601501,
0.15338553488254547,
0.297453910112381,
-0.1813378483057022,
0.6300826668739319,
0.26871368288993835,
-0.09840859472751617,
0.288859099149704,
-0.1603378802537918,
0.2624870240688324,
0.44165778160095215,
-0.0005501083796843886,
-0.5384344458580017,
0.4099588096141815,
0.5294507145881653,
-0.35168886184692383,
0.5201878547668457,
0.5396357178688049,
-0.8169145584106445,
0.12899327278137207,
-0.4204840064048767,
-0.463249534368515,
-0.34514570236206055,
0.6496675610542297,
-0.20464055240154266,
-0.5997605919837952,
0.3190123438835144,
-0.318768709897995,
-0.21536080539226532,
0.6688147187232971,
0.8609482049942017,
-0.030176790431141853,
1.0486125946044922,
0.8614392280578613,
-0.11727222800254822,
0.20521476864814758,
0.005638474598526955,
0.007160823326557875,
-1.0924891233444214,
-0.27383890748023987,
-0.2500911355018616,
-0.37656259536743164,
-0.24676023423671722,
-0.40777531266212463,
0.32610636949539185,
-0.22650963068008423,
-0.1005859300494194,
-0.14271560311317444,
-0.750430166721344,
-0.02408921718597412,
0.3607526123523712,
0.5600576996803284,
0.2744778096675873,
0.07457578927278519,
-0.11410204321146011,
-0.17086735367774963,
-0.6562678217887878,
-0.07582781463861465,
1.395992636680603,
0.6432807445526123,
0.8174973130226135,
-0.43030068278312683,
0.4055579602718353,
0.28971683979034424,
0.3357318341732025,
-0.8160136342048645,
0.14529098570346832,
-0.21256455779075623,
-0.6187933683395386,
-0.31472527980804443,
-0.13996867835521698,
-0.7546031475067139,
-0.13678213953971863,
-0.3885383903980255,
-0.4300675392150879,
0.32128316164016724,
-0.008026963099837303,
-0.7317076325416565,
-0.00791835319250822,
-0.8291452527046204,
0.8144851922988892,
-0.4140571355819702,
-0.40159177780151367,
-0.28116554021835327,
-0.7731641530990601,
0.09916310757398605,
-0.17383992671966553,
0.04162611812353134,
0.08476866781711578,
-0.179270401597023,
0.6765734553337097,
0.1223011165857315,
1.0783051252365112,
-0.2203999161720276,
0.055993080139160156,
0.05583547055721283,
-0.2607133090496063,
0.5644031167030334,
0.1257195919752121,
-0.015625976026058197,
0.03494318574666977,
-0.3257240355014801,
-0.17374786734580994,
-0.4962407648563385,
0.73853600025177,
-0.5008212924003601,
-0.600847065448761,
-0.13998886942863464,
-0.7025666832923889,
-0.14213302731513977,
0.41557958722114563,
0.2045830488204956,
0.0715443566441536,
-0.16202910244464874,
0.25881361961364746,
0.7618787884712219,
-0.11674272269010544,
0.3057515621185303,
0.4624131917953491,
0.18192437291145325,
-0.27004340291023254,
0.5122267603874207,
0.007092995103448629,
-0.010703958570957184,
0.7103599309921265,
0.06981552392244339,
-0.09172022342681885,
-0.9355617761611938,
-0.3719119429588318,
0.08081324398517609,
-0.5112223625183105,
-0.34182050824165344,
-1.1089673042297363,
-0.30090779066085815,
-0.4193229079246521,
0.23853352665901184,
-0.09947194904088974,
-0.05936896428465843,
-0.5594241619110107,
-0.19762398302555084,
0.5176553130149841,
0.4758378267288208,
0.4047972857952118,
0.12540610134601593,
-0.8092931509017944,
0.4635169506072998,
0.06533659994602203,
0.42007845640182495,
0.12161346524953842,
-0.2940944731235504,
-0.5907171964645386,
-0.14255096018314362,
-0.1918419897556305,
-0.9342635273933411,
0.31210681796073914,
-0.014710548333823681,
0.6876971125602722,
0.37745168805122375,
0.04024014621973038,
0.23783749341964722,
-0.4254741966724396,
0.28070834279060364,
0.12053805589675903,
-0.5808495879173279,
0.7487565279006958,
-0.26586151123046875,
0.12380845099687576,
0.46237629652023315,
0.4506326913833618,
-0.30371418595314026,
-0.19094358384609222,
-0.3907923400402069,
-0.6352823972702026,
0.6778416633605957,
0.09895738214254379,
-0.11892383545637131,
0.382720410823822,
0.7574313282966614,
0.2074870765209198,
0.10989827662706375,
-0.7627696394920349,
-0.12707701325416565,
0.12023692578077316,
-0.7100446820259094,
0.06642662733793259,
-0.27932074666023254,
-0.22804415225982666,
-0.12630696594715118,
0.42704126238822937,
-0.3443651497364044,
0.31472301483154297,
0.668743908405304,
-0.19648556411266327,
-0.2791326344013214,
0.2043798267841339,
0.4971083402633667,
0.4946322441101074,
-0.17851164937019348,
-0.16004034876823425,
0.3035016655921936,
-0.725376307964325,
-0.21799065172672272,
0.434589147567749,
-0.10683445632457733,
-0.26853612065315247,
0.355056494474411,
0.9048385620117188,
0.18375898897647858,
-0.5021783709526062,
0.3574668765068054,
-0.09353512525558472,
0.03361498937010765,
-0.03825795277953148,
0.13038191199302673,
0.1098974347114563,
0.48112019896507263,
0.33135271072387695,
0.11008740216493607,
0.8543421626091003,
-0.40649619698524475,
0.25178587436676025,
0.3659835457801819,
-0.9214288592338562,
-0.16146701574325562,
0.800269603729248,
0.3022627532482147,
-0.2129577100276947,
0.1870521456003189,
0.38443389534950256,
-0.1638716161251068,
0.6436285972595215,
0.3687558174133301,
0.6270354390144348,
-0.5080188512802124,
-0.12680193781852722,
0.12887299060821533,
0.08308866620063782,
0.028713596984744072,
0.18670497834682465,
-0.012807314284145832,
-0.2876669764518738,
-0.5486897230148315,
-0.34061720967292786,
-0.13365928828716278,
0.38968539237976074,
-0.5682625770568848,
0.2965278923511505,
-0.24519477784633636,
-0.2933841943740845,
0.42716410756111145,
0.09432197362184525,
-0.707075297832489,
0.7118443846702576,
0.06646421551704407,
0.644768476486206,
-0.5760498046875,
0.7807351350784302,
0.8206356763839722,
-0.20686115324497223,
-0.1396288126707077,
0.06432274729013443,
-0.07504106312990189,
-0.8992245197296143,
0.5038182735443115,
0.13930092751979828,
0.3210812509059906,
-0.21922260522842407,
-0.4121716618537903,
-0.728065013885498,
0.7706471681594849,
0.10858374089002609,
-0.7692580819129944,
-0.2508280277252197,
0.016046933829784393,
0.8208710551261902,
-0.575119137763977,
-0.03888450190424919,
0.527660071849823,
0.2973985970020294,
-0.2715880572795868,
-0.5010929703712463,
0.4967750012874603,
-0.3596111834049225,
-0.2337953895330429,
0.17366398870944977,
-0.45565280318260193,
0.8320940136909485,
-0.5369240641593933,
-0.07642149925231934,
0.058089252561330795,
0.3718210458755493,
-0.004677535966038704,
0.6027052402496338,
0.10551272332668304,
0.5423797369003296,
0.62213134765625,
0.11391519755125046,
1.1281988620758057,
-0.36509600281715393,
0.4401571750640869,
0.9342384338378906,
-0.5521356463432312,
0.3661837577819824,
0.4243029057979584,
-0.08520392328500748,
0.3672456443309784,
0.6162261962890625,
-0.1335482895374298,
0.8169146180152893,
-0.10661765187978745,
-0.18785512447357178,
-0.16346780955791473,
-0.1590520292520523,
-0.49420681595802307,
0.0863584354519844,
0.6668276190757751,
-1.0741859674453735,
0.13997195661067963,
0.485456258058548,
-0.2304157316684723,
-0.12543819844722748,
-0.579926073551178,
1.0922338962554932,
0.25749579071998596,
-0.669965386390686,
0.30336177349090576,
-0.14584232866764069,
0.25382018089294434,
-0.2249339073896408,
-0.19838322699069977,
0.05717587471008301,
0.6215345859527588,
-0.25212347507476807,
-0.7429903149604797,
0.013165153563022614,
-0.22082991898059845,
-0.6361342668533325,
0.3460651636123657,
1.2661687135696411,
-0.27417802810668945,
-0.6506795287132263,
0.5528979301452637,
0.39305442571640015,
-0.15299130976200104,
-0.14300884306430817,
-0.9862589240074158,
-0.14044958353042603,
0.19841448962688446,
-0.27321240305900574,
0.394375741481781,
0.745834231376648,
0.030497169122099876,
0.5319938063621521,
0.6150178909301758,
0.23338519036769867,
-0.31628507375717163,
0.2087179273366928,
0.8696061372756958,
-0.9726940989494324,
-0.44487765431404114,
-1.044729232788086,
0.3381745517253876,
-0.361106276512146,
-0.06812221556901932,
0.3743878901004791,
0.314557284116745,
0.3563728332519531,
-0.15182536840438843,
0.8902238607406616,
0.4354195296764374,
0.8400736451148987,
-0.6911160349845886,
0.8660096526145935,
-0.5403291583061218,
0.028636623173952103,
-0.035207007080316544,
-0.469794899225235,
-0.5575465559959412,
0.29085779190063477,
-0.23473858833312988,
0.13721637427806854,
0.9483993053436279,
0.17440195381641388,
-0.06977886706590652,
0.026660170406103134,
0.0818503201007843,
0.4547143578529358,
-0.01974169909954071,
0.9592862129211426,
0.29420801997184753,
-0.5561344623565674,
0.2466576099395752,
-0.2184339165687561,
-0.32584741711616516,
-0.5971555709838867,
-0.49368977546691895,
-1.170418620109558,
-0.3844442069530487,
-0.2346874177455902,
-0.17352063953876495,
0.26278558373451233,
0.6053465604782104,
0.6620189547538757,
-0.7266777157783508,
0.42695561051368713,
-0.053763248026371,
0.06044093146920204,
-0.3095356225967407,
-0.20421233773231506,
0.763130247592926,
-0.5321641564369202,
-0.5964317321777344,
0.10394573956727982,
0.5758525729179382,
-0.019987165927886963,
0.0154737439006567,
0.051644548773765564,
-0.14085949957370758,
-0.12761521339416504,
0.554961621761322,
0.07418595254421234,
-0.38160133361816406,
0.24908146262168884,
0.28341853618621826,
-0.2315315157175064,
0.12882539629936218,
1.0829492807388306,
-0.7625372409820557,
0.447165846824646,
0.2940118908882141,
0.7999960780143738,
0.3738475441932678,
-0.2481534779071808,
0.575957179069519,
-0.32580476999282837,
0.0805511325597763,
0.3840077221393585,
0.3503605127334595,
0.2973349392414093,
-0.9993860721588135,
0.6087512969970703,
0.023111935704946518,
-0.546884298324585,
-0.6869845986366272,
-0.10946675390005112,
-0.8413283824920654,
-0.474627286195755,
0.9221624135971069,
-0.03711024299263954,
-0.4477623999118805,
-0.28322654962539673,
-0.3160196542739868,
0.48954156041145325,
-0.225989431142807,
0.9292721748352051,
0.4007806181907654,
-0.2376684844493866,
-0.21145260334014893,
-0.8526750206947327,
0.7366170883178711,
0.3737323582172394,
-0.9263728260993958,
0.23648016154766083,
0.04167405143380165,
0.1750420331954956,
0.15736731886863708,
0.5991811752319336,
-0.4032713770866394,
0.4779249131679535,
-0.5055599808692932,
0.004647817928344011,
0.13317131996154785,
-0.17694532871246338,
-0.5076147317886353,
0.2292279601097107,
-0.29601502418518066,
-0.11513447761535645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14061v1
|
Meanings and Feelings of Large Language Models: Observability of Latent States in Generative AI
| 2024-05-22T23:18:58 | 2024-05-22T23:18:58 |
Tian Yu Liu, Stefano Soatto, Matteo Marchi, Pratik Chaudhari, Paulo Tabuada
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We tackle the question of whether Large Language Models (LLMs), viewed as
dynamical systems with state evolving in the embedding space of symbolic
tokens, are observable. That is, whether there exist multiple 'mental' state
trajectories that yield the same sequence of generated tokens, or sequences
that belong to the same Nerode equivalence class ('meaning'). If not
observable, mental state trajectories ('experiences') evoked by an input
('perception') or by feedback from the model's own state ('thoughts') could
remain self-contained and evolve unbeknown to the user while being potentially
accessible to the model provider. Such "self-contained experiences evoked by
perception or thought" are akin to what the American Psychological Association
(APA) defines as 'feelings'. Beyond the lexical curiosity, we show that current
LLMs implemented by autoregressive Transformers cannot have 'feelings'
according to this definition: The set of state trajectories indistinguishable
from the tokenized output is a singleton. But if there are 'system prompts' not
visible to the user, then the set of indistinguishable trajectories becomes
non-trivial, and there can be multiple state trajectories that yield the same
verbalized output. We prove these claims analytically, and show examples of
modifications to standard LLMs that engender such 'feelings.' Our analysis
sheds light on possible designs that would enable a model to perform
non-trivial computation that is not visible to the user, as well as on controls
that the provider of services using the model could take to prevent unintended
behavior.
|
[
-0.31910860538482666,
-0.7265340089797974,
0.9202362895011902,
0.2077879011631012,
-0.2431393712759018,
0.06720571964979172,
-0.2818092703819275,
-0.5291585326194763,
0.45712020993232727,
0.33179527521133423,
-0.5891544222831726,
-0.2181982398033142,
-0.5295053124427795,
0.07246261090040207,
-0.8231494426727295,
0.8949063420295715,
-0.15831564366817474,
-0.407507061958313,
-0.2074846625328064,
-0.13352447748184204,
-0.050033800303936005,
-0.6579664349555969,
-0.4273243248462677,
-0.36977776885032654,
0.48301687836647034,
-0.07353978604078293,
0.8466652631759644,
0.3019803464412689,
0.3468945622444153,
0.28101781010627747,
-0.19255474209785461,
-0.2566335201263428,
-0.42128536105155945,
0.39707133173942566,
-0.054130543023347855,
-0.7296347618103027,
-0.4231734871864319,
-0.020457198843359947,
0.6669707298278809,
0.7473931312561035,
-0.12018314749002457,
-0.16733615100383759,
0.0666109248995781,
0.6689736843109131,
-0.5633531212806702,
0.3886839747428894,
-0.46866554021835327,
0.3641839921474457,
-0.045988261699676514,
0.016429703682661057,
-0.3982241153717041,
-0.2790665328502655,
0.014620346017181873,
-0.19534911215305328,
-0.11927645653486252,
-0.023434985429048538,
0.7016369104385376,
0.5136032104492188,
-0.5134830474853516,
-0.37943774461746216,
-0.9547914266586304,
0.7280071973800659,
-0.7609699964523315,
0.5102324485778809,
0.06236764043569565,
-0.00588644715026021,
-0.07725764065980911,
-0.44159266352653503,
-1.0385234355926514,
-0.5704354643821716,
-0.07482197880744934,
0.20470835268497467,
-0.5426181554794312,
0.23536105453968048,
0.5436615347862244,
0.6492677927017212,
-0.5069074034690857,
0.2749881148338318,
0.026639439165592194,
0.07077708840370178,
0.5241153836250305,
0.4430043697357178,
0.4017370343208313,
-0.16275067627429962,
-0.3391968905925751,
0.07208152115345001,
-0.7816686630249023,
0.16362379491329193,
0.41918230056762695,
0.0269558597356081,
-0.4628807604312897,
0.7066054344177246,
0.020527679473161697,
0.542161762714386,
0.04153174161911011,
0.1207394003868103,
0.23310750722885132,
0.11571148782968521,
-0.40926194190979004,
-0.1907520592212677,
0.9318198561668396,
-0.12217872589826584,
0.2489311695098877,
-0.2710787057876587,
-0.4762570261955261,
0.41775408387184143,
0.3651624023914337,
-0.5100324153900146,
-0.2335306853055954,
0.3043852746486664,
-0.5450742244720459,
-0.1530531793832779,
0.11892890185117722,
-0.32177820801734924,
-0.4333079755306244,
-0.3513084053993225,
0.3234294652938843,
-0.1853996366262436,
-0.4323502480983734,
0.023540914058685303,
0.16062815487384796,
0.17583584785461426,
0.23290418088436127,
-1.0331779718399048,
0.3122578561306,
0.7084956169128418,
0.7403202652931213,
-0.3203648030757904,
-0.3867642879486084,
0.08766405284404755,
-0.09355497360229492,
-0.5712776780128479,
0.5454927086830139,
-0.4746650755405426,
-0.5667930841445923,
0.06562481075525284,
0.09586026519536972,
0.014685800299048424,
-0.3257305324077606,
-0.19844727218151093,
-0.6654117703437805,
0.025047942996025085,
-0.23545505106449127,
-0.5937471389770508,
0.07968880981206894,
0.13237698376178741,
-0.5707318782806396,
0.7048391699790955,
-0.1715995967388153,
-0.5118126273155212,
0.1541205644607544,
-0.7861136794090271,
-0.5504595637321472,
-0.0607791468501091,
-0.41739732027053833,
0.09651868045330048,
0.7367089986801147,
-0.576399564743042,
0.5335844159126282,
-0.07730426639318466,
0.2268684208393097,
-0.37107789516448975,
-0.22225458920001984,
0.582716703414917,
-0.5026699900627136,
0.641711950302124,
0.28591668605804443,
-0.5235345363616943,
0.08192064613103867,
-0.5871818661689758,
-0.11809694766998291,
0.19833751022815704,
-0.425126850605011,
-0.22108900547027588,
0.24941489100456238,
-0.17831262946128845,
0.268232524394989,
0.42209288477897644,
-0.6174232363700867,
0.5055103898048401,
-0.6264209747314453,
0.5119123458862305,
1.0318098068237305,
-0.18106625974178314,
0.5107966661453247,
0.05575549229979515,
0.6861584186553955,
0.22264905273914337,
0.14756272733211517,
-0.2536504864692688,
-0.48809799551963806,
-1.012387990951538,
-0.04436403885483742,
-0.3153201937675476,
0.21073618531227112,
-0.6233078241348267,
0.37365251779556274,
-0.03945514187216759,
-0.41906577348709106,
-0.1909748762845993,
-0.26080578565597534,
0.22371630370616913,
0.2894633412361145,
-0.10232667624950409,
-0.101621612906456,
-0.2584192454814911,
-0.9684181213378906,
-0.2907828688621521,
-0.3993348479270935,
0.13292860984802246,
0.30579450726509094,
0.5096541047096252,
-0.26399365067481995,
0.8145828247070312,
-0.7565529346466064,
0.10664620995521545,
0.04336471110582352,
0.16574442386627197,
0.35544171929359436,
0.23324929177761078,
0.41389161348342896,
-0.6078380942344666,
-0.12923933565616608,
-0.030927490442991257,
-1.1677942276000977,
0.03274976462125778,
-0.053440239280462265,
0.30110061168670654,
0.36907488107681274,
0.46588224172592163,
-0.709463357925415,
0.5906684398651123,
0.7037715911865234,
-0.4514629542827606,
0.4387553930282593,
-0.2823391556739807,
-0.027782399207353592,
-0.9337883591651917,
0.08773329854011536,
-0.33013373613357544,
-0.025607723742723465,
-0.5566926002502441,
0.1730809360742569,
-0.030822571367025375,
-0.1337001770734787,
-0.502091646194458,
0.7403575778007507,
-0.3958137035369873,
-0.43858516216278076,
-0.6286112666130066,
-0.0887133851647377,
-0.12310459464788437,
0.30872321128845215,
0.0021922020241618156,
0.7449143528938293,
0.7268662452697754,
-0.874497652053833,
0.6483189463615417,
0.1381448656320572,
-0.42059966921806335,
0.4696626663208008,
-0.6214370727539062,
0.2502236068248749,
-0.3435039222240448,
0.17903216183185577,
-0.7869926691055298,
0.025153005495667458,
0.31575438380241394,
-0.44648563861846924,
0.043674200773239136,
0.1822718381881714,
-0.6102428436279297,
-0.13972415030002594,
0.2027721405029297,
0.44508326053619385,
0.6278942823410034,
-0.4498407542705536,
0.6173694729804993,
0.2914685606956482,
-0.02763579785823822,
-0.38566556572914124,
-0.861362636089325,
0.2323956936597824,
-0.10183946788311005,
-0.2507885694503784,
-0.18508754670619965,
-0.17270348966121674,
-0.4846401512622833,
0.15948908030986786,
0.2635972499847412,
0.1487686038017273,
0.3690367341041565,
0.7806050777435303,
0.24695415794849396,
-0.01852109469473362,
0.5370973348617554,
0.01669337786734104,
-0.14244811236858368,
0.42641904950141907,
-0.43578675389289856,
0.6672221422195435,
-0.22211968898773193,
-0.7899328470230103,
-0.3226131498813629,
0.40223997831344604,
0.8149531483650208,
-0.2457568496465683,
0.7277830243110657,
0.4711569547653198,
-0.6691113710403442,
-0.1667492836713791,
-0.10872762650251389,
-0.08438892662525177,
-0.4401266276836395,
0.18721091747283936,
-0.6128577589988708,
-1.070029616355896,
0.6540260910987854,
0.15774327516555786,
-0.008683313615620136,
0.4752722680568695,
0.7921571731567383,
-0.24629774689674377,
1.0999854803085327,
0.668343186378479,
-0.19545379281044006,
0.34501078724861145,
-0.28903698921203613,
0.5372752547264099,
-0.9637871980667114,
-0.2706722319126129,
-0.5042563676834106,
-0.35131675004959106,
-0.8647712469100952,
-0.051132287830114365,
0.383838027715683,
-0.1852077841758728,
-0.37847790122032166,
-0.10104610025882721,
-0.20761728286743164,
0.19897818565368652,
0.39881375432014465,
-0.1748991161584854,
0.19156499207019806,
-0.1454411745071411,
-0.1164359301328659,
-0.06269374489784241,
-0.4159660339355469,
-0.5863262414932251,
0.7700787782669067,
0.15907375514507294,
1.19331955909729,
0.4741441607475281,
0.6418311595916748,
0.451454222202301,
0.18250353634357452,
-1.1327056884765625,
0.6425880193710327,
-0.15357469022274017,
-0.5780653357505798,
-0.28873521089553833,
-0.20721298456192017,
-1.011682152748108,
-0.039448827505111694,
-0.35107186436653137,
-1.252718210220337,
0.40517309308052063,
0.35810795426368713,
-0.2455083280801773,
0.5039253830909729,
-0.47610554099082947,
0.6275671720504761,
-0.224788635969162,
-0.19285260140895844,
-0.304878830909729,
-0.31699103116989136,
0.48752471804618835,
-0.1750904768705368,
0.0907781720161438,
-0.05806754529476166,
-0.00572730740532279,
0.5249442458152771,
-0.4080621004104614,
0.8786888122558594,
-0.12766937911510468,
-0.41949009895324707,
0.1470257192850113,
0.31228184700012207,
0.4807262420654297,
-0.3047963082790375,
0.10282035171985626,
0.0774814710021019,
-0.08004774153232574,
-0.26218098402023315,
-0.8625598549842834,
0.870938241481781,
-0.9332098364830017,
-0.6832553744316101,
-0.5349076390266418,
-0.3989618718624115,
-0.0771215409040451,
0.30609411001205444,
0.0791875422000885,
0.3823918402194977,
-0.3030337393283844,
-0.00530965393409133,
0.627052366733551,
-0.3667948544025421,
0.49855664372444153,
0.46420320868492126,
-0.5709496736526489,
0.23725782334804535,
0.889973521232605,
-0.053219206631183624,
0.41696256399154663,
0.39594417810440063,
0.1968744546175003,
-0.47342318296432495,
-0.26478952169418335,
-0.27235865592956543,
0.22063645720481873,
-0.750885009765625,
0.2501281797885895,
-0.6372519731521606,
-0.08877737820148468,
-0.13311657309532166,
0.011076726950705051,
-0.41196098923683167,
-0.18854409456253052,
-0.4369381368160248,
-0.08720863610506058,
0.2206333428621292,
1.2982033491134644,
-0.07209723442792892,
0.3572295308113098,
-0.5882121324539185,
0.3441998362541199,
0.37280938029289246,
0.49542972445487976,
0.2415398359298706,
-0.4335068464279175,
-0.2734812796115875,
0.036128684878349304,
0.03406079486012459,
-0.8842450380325317,
0.40567857027053833,
-0.18217051029205322,
0.1907455027103424,
0.8669336438179016,
-0.013877985067665577,
0.4761172831058502,
-0.4404970407485962,
1.0053086280822754,
0.2556527853012085,
-1.2047253847122192,
0.41085895895957947,
-0.2958981394767761,
0.24862007796764374,
-0.10186457633972168,
0.2858721911907196,
-0.6770078539848328,
-0.41620543599128723,
-0.6962460875511169,
-0.5225166082382202,
0.5935207605361938,
-0.18614760041236877,
0.5595149397850037,
-0.27849018573760986,
0.4433486759662628,
0.011530494317412376,
0.5031610131263733,
-0.6207481026649475,
-0.43225932121276855,
-0.24277980625629425,
-0.19604864716529846,
-0.3883437514305115,
-0.3216080963611603,
0.05607592687010765,
0.17122283577919006,
0.37996020913124084,
-0.05098859593272209,
0.5903245806694031,
-0.16420221328735352,
0.04126531630754471,
-0.21838346123695374,
0.30450865626335144,
0.5136843323707581,
0.5639863610267639,
-0.038474638015031815,
0.4445587992668152,
-0.18609753251075745,
-0.2662643790245056,
0.3810492753982544,
-0.31430700421333313,
-0.30097851157188416,
-0.1465306580066681,
0.19805794954299927,
1.0365562438964844,
0.07916251569986343,
-0.5375790596008301,
0.5631861090660095,
-0.09434989094734192,
0.15668286383152008,
-0.6688316464424133,
0.07249409705400467,
0.06963350623846054,
0.37743064761161804,
0.162821963429451,
0.023618435487151146,
0.05738015100359917,
-0.9514287114143372,
-0.17136158049106598,
0.6440767049789429,
-0.6380197405815125,
-0.7928817868232727,
0.7618544101715088,
-0.22019647061824799,
-0.5015130043029785,
0.6645049452781677,
-0.2037276029586792,
-0.4845120310783386,
0.4502682387828827,
0.42019087076187134,
1.0478547811508179,
-0.20633865892887115,
-0.03033023327589035,
-0.070892333984375,
0.33237364888191223,
0.04026784002780914,
0.4021971523761749,
0.03852197527885437,
-1.0512906312942505,
-0.27909955382347107,
-0.5248210430145264,
-0.4308464527130127,
0.20031093060970306,
-0.8145946264266968,
-0.07469262927770615,
-0.5141922235488892,
-0.23852093517780304,
0.021752040833234787,
-0.4575223922729492,
-0.8395921587944031,
0.35648679733276367,
0.30651310086250305,
0.6046984195709229,
-1.1286619901657104,
0.6815323233604431,
0.8519313931465149,
-0.302051305770874,
-0.8666915893554688,
0.03762602061033249,
-0.06867516785860062,
-0.8916025161743164,
0.7136954069137573,
-0.14957518875598907,
-0.131450816988945,
0.037565331906080246,
-0.5664767026901245,
-0.901362955570221,
0.7567666172981262,
0.2618221938610077,
-0.4138573706150055,
-0.059365447610616684,
0.1476290076971054,
0.7062411904335022,
-0.19081458449363708,
0.2259432077407837,
0.33397531509399414,
0.4660983979701996,
-0.13309508562088013,
-0.7809932231903076,
-0.06738132238388062,
-0.11496317386627197,
-0.061995215713977814,
0.2779074013233185,
-0.7171815633773804,
1.094992756843567,
-0.20245110988616943,
-0.4155689775943756,
0.10249114781618118,
0.695741593837738,
-0.021710211411118507,
0.09312227368354797,
0.45094484090805054,
0.7198581695556641,
0.5330930352210999,
-0.12243366241455078,
1.227918028831482,
-0.3658015727996826,
0.34833794832229614,
0.8219777941703796,
-0.3179316520690918,
0.741240382194519,
0.5485449433326721,
-0.4910602867603302,
0.5138914585113525,
0.3285630941390991,
0.23413342237472534,
0.2650822699069977,
0.2835109233856201,
-0.39119434356689453,
-0.31907573342323303,
-0.19085563719272614,
-0.09899923950433731,
0.7978994250297546,
0.39574530720710754,
-0.4453575909137726,
0.017162803560495377,
0.138118714094162,
-0.022155527025461197,
-0.10532122850418091,
-0.14334245026111603,
0.7292864918708801,
0.38291028141975403,
-0.564405620098114,
0.4041631519794464,
-0.14314016699790955,
0.44526585936546326,
-0.5307137966156006,
0.05230078846216202,
-0.35944685339927673,
0.08893576264381409,
-0.33720630407333374,
-0.9166175723075867,
0.3131849467754364,
0.1679367870092392,
-0.37615659832954407,
-0.25559118390083313,
0.41673073172569275,
0.04556644335389137,
-0.31286200881004333,
0.23728187382221222,
0.8610764741897583,
0.5960685014724731,
-0.07846586406230927,
-0.46500152349472046,
0.3085622489452362,
-0.09465989470481873,
-0.3373824656009674,
0.38347312808036804,
0.41345804929733276,
-0.0008995570824481547,
0.84175705909729,
0.44028139114379883,
0.3441559076309204,
0.11276530474424362,
0.09210464358329773,
0.7882177233695984,
-0.8319648504257202,
-0.5080811977386475,
-1.0029754638671875,
0.2765948474407196,
0.508905827999115,
-0.10029850155115128,
0.5815754532814026,
0.36421236395835876,
0.787176251411438,
-0.08411464840173721,
0.9641834497451782,
-0.04000096768140793,
0.269569993019104,
-0.5549471974372864,
0.7428442239761353,
-0.6240467429161072,
0.20394259691238403,
-0.30033671855926514,
-0.9418336749076843,
0.04593517631292343,
0.666293740272522,
-0.4050656855106354,
0.02518053539097309,
0.6807025671005249,
0.4501984417438507,
0.1294284462928772,
0.06621575355529785,
0.6217199563980103,
0.6126672625541687,
0.39984551072120667,
0.5510867238044739,
1.3938642740249634,
0.02804330177605152,
-0.0854552686214447,
0.1790953278541565,
-0.18626025319099426,
0.017992576584219933,
-0.7348074316978455,
-0.548008382320404,
-0.8489368557929993,
-0.16525842249393463,
-0.2464534044265747,
-0.050695378333330154,
0.7028400897979736,
0.3537629246711731,
-0.5587233304977417,
-0.24815356731414795,
-0.13178302347660065,
0.09162238985300064,
0.22173258662223816,
-0.2654775381088257,
0.34306931495666504,
-0.15560932457447052,
-0.8150253295898438,
0.27199557423591614,
0.4810884892940521,
0.3976479172706604,
-0.8767428994178772,
-0.003067795652896166,
0.23301012814044952,
0.051515351980924606,
0.7267852425575256,
0.5365854501724243,
-0.9893379807472229,
-0.5649374723434448,
0.00833361316472292,
-0.027278205379843712,
-0.03812634199857712,
0.656090259552002,
-0.9222349524497986,
0.499254047870636,
0.2641509473323822,
0.46407458186149597,
0.35972243547439575,
-0.2592790126800537,
0.36046433448791504,
-0.37764066457748413,
0.1378280222415924,
0.10559330880641937,
0.5733888149261475,
0.13559043407440186,
-0.24836759269237518,
0.04662911221385002,
0.1758069097995758,
-0.4152440130710602,
-0.5861338376998901,
0.7324255704879761,
-0.8437821269035339,
-0.040663547813892365,
1.1765151023864746,
-0.3353700637817383,
-0.1892949789762497,
0.23016878962516785,
0.29232436418533325,
0.19497846066951752,
-0.2591225206851959,
0.8738552927970886,
0.5903944373130798,
-0.5051735043525696,
-0.031405672430992126,
-0.39384496212005615,
0.2961694598197937,
0.397992879152298,
-0.7442115545272827,
0.008947400376200676,
0.6433855295181274,
0.07015261054039001,
0.18005502223968506,
0.6647239327430725,
-0.009131823666393757,
-0.08311692625284195,
-0.14629718661308289,
0.22451405227184296,
0.0675576701760292,
-0.21170209348201752,
-0.6280394792556763,
0.035987596958875656,
0.33202651143074036,
-0.15544778108596802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14057v1
|
Your Large Language Models Are Leaving Fingerprints
| 2024-05-22T23:02:42 | 2024-05-22T23:02:42 |
Hope McGovern, Rickard Stureborg, Yoshi Suhara, Dimitris Alikaniotis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
It has been shown that finetuned transformers and other supervised detectors
effectively distinguish between human and machine-generated text in some
situations arXiv:2305.13242, but we find that even simple classifiers on top of
n-gram and part-of-speech features can achieve very robust performance on both
in- and out-of-domain data. To understand how this is possible, we analyze
machine-generated output text in five datasets, finding that LLMs possess
unique fingerprints that manifest as slight differences in the frequency of
certain lexical and morphosyntactic features. We show how to visualize such
fingerprints, describe how they can be used to detect machine-generated text
and find that they are even robust across textual domains. We find that
fingerprints are often persistent across models in the same model family (e.g.
llama-13b vs. llama-65b) and that models fine-tuned for chat are easier to
detect than standard language models, indicating that LLM fingerprints may be
directly induced by the training data.
|
[
-0.39989522099494934,
-0.6967722177505493,
0.6176933646202087,
-0.31524261832237244,
-0.2730090618133545,
0.45310789346694946,
0.06855560094118118,
-0.8918840289115906,
-0.061118051409721375,
0.9327788949012756,
-0.25795719027519226,
-0.44527667760849,
-0.7818965315818787,
0.13220135867595673,
-0.8635013103485107,
1.0494494438171387,
0.3089272081851959,
-0.038707416504621506,
-0.2916056513786316,
-0.014174378477036953,
0.08119464665651321,
-0.9526495337486267,
-0.5560951232910156,
-0.4712553918361664,
0.32686683535575867,
0.16780832409858704,
0.5896215438842773,
1.0560652017593384,
0.3504618704319,
0.19392062723636627,
-0.31616270542144775,
0.3480440080165863,
-0.40605905652046204,
0.2181728035211563,
0.0646725445985794,
-0.5107802748680115,
-0.1870192289352417,
0.01113883312791586,
0.6847691535949707,
0.6440677642822266,
0.3746269643306732,
0.22399483621120453,
0.2615199387073517,
0.5459091663360596,
-0.49041399359703064,
0.1271234005689621,
-0.7894330024719238,
-0.2605288624763489,
-0.7879343032836914,
-0.2332049459218979,
-0.8114480972290039,
0.043717142194509506,
-0.1796158105134964,
-0.20813408493995667,
0.4473803639411926,
-0.037050504237413406,
1.0562069416046143,
0.15631484985351562,
-0.5809616446495056,
-0.3598771095275879,
-0.9144513010978699,
0.6731988787651062,
-0.5515740513801575,
0.3994000554084778,
0.4885750114917755,
0.2093290090560913,
-0.26336410641670227,
-0.6466178297996521,
-0.6231753826141357,
-0.44827502965927124,
-0.003695447463542223,
-0.10952278226613998,
-0.06292581558227539,
-0.05202604830265045,
0.42679983377456665,
0.37446078658103943,
-0.33394932746887207,
0.4388693869113922,
-0.13671235740184784,
-0.7075397968292236,
0.6730185747146606,
0.26873353123664856,
0.4910232722759247,
0.17903108894824982,
-0.20438168942928314,
-0.2846865653991699,
-1.0330743789672852,
0.13941964507102966,
0.45845890045166016,
0.3988846242427826,
-0.18325336277484894,
0.5799098014831543,
-0.0068253763020038605,
0.7264082431793213,
0.045391786843538284,
-0.3975253403186798,
-0.084490567445755,
-0.25133636593818665,
0.11934901028871536,
-0.27332621812820435,
0.8574532270431519,
0.1441974639892578,
0.5891510248184204,
-0.21331886947155,
-0.37091806530952454,
0.0014375337632372975,
-0.07864797860383987,
-0.7284427881240845,
-0.2642275094985962,
-0.07594802975654602,
-0.6273725628852844,
-0.3733033835887909,
-0.022236891090869904,
-0.5003454089164734,
-0.8001473546028137,
-0.2240908294916153,
0.2084505259990692,
-0.09452977031469345,
-0.1470232754945755,
-0.10925059020519257,
-0.24507838487625122,
0.12535516917705536,
0.127131387591362,
-1.2937754392623901,
0.4807279407978058,
0.7934439778327942,
0.6997396349906921,
-0.2857314646244049,
-0.12760692834854126,
-0.799433708190918,
0.03839237242937088,
-0.39945188164711,
0.7072046995162964,
-0.7557662725448608,
-0.24281656742095947,
0.09316171705722809,
-0.03735136613249779,
-0.043838754296302795,
-0.8577762246131897,
0.41650381684303284,
-0.5605250597000122,
0.06560587882995605,
-0.03220369294285774,
-0.7612279653549194,
0.06376571208238602,
-0.17361518740653992,
-0.8454182744026184,
1.1616610288619995,
-0.0896536335349083,
-0.8672241568565369,
0.49167680740356445,
-0.2786475718021393,
-0.509852409362793,
0.11977668851613998,
-0.23134271800518036,
-0.6010634303092957,
0.2667427062988281,
0.09150204807519913,
0.8022090196609497,
-0.25404515862464905,
0.1639794260263443,
-0.5597329139709473,
-0.5914442539215088,
0.45900240540504456,
-0.4023958444595337,
0.8376549482345581,
0.25664693117141724,
-0.4179295003414154,
-0.12820042669773102,
-1.0714436769485474,
-0.2129122018814087,
0.01851773075759411,
-0.628017008304596,
-0.257726788520813,
0.2660321295261383,
0.24631622433662415,
0.0886591449379921,
0.3916584551334381,
-0.6640626788139343,
0.05728275328874588,
-0.2271004170179367,
0.4698463976383209,
0.5129258036613464,
-0.07801282405853271,
0.2999947667121887,
-0.3269188702106476,
0.45616433024406433,
0.2652129828929901,
-0.1359948366880417,
-0.4251682758331299,
-0.7398070693016052,
-0.8753891587257385,
-0.4533686339855194,
0.28666284680366516,
0.45460283756256104,
-0.5421297550201416,
0.47540560364723206,
-0.2284170687198639,
-0.5503624677658081,
-0.3530355393886566,
0.21059662103652954,
0.4990518093109131,
0.23432834446430206,
-0.05616762116551399,
-0.5006890296936035,
-0.457919716835022,
-1.1069046258926392,
-0.4528375267982483,
-0.2066357135772705,
-0.23676498234272003,
0.13571064174175262,
0.5065784454345703,
-0.18530426919460297,
0.9635422825813293,
-0.17160199582576752,
0.12240395694971085,
-0.17892737686634064,
0.021662399172782898,
0.08485336601734161,
0.2643064856529236,
0.5225315690040588,
-0.7087590098381042,
-0.6127312779426575,
0.2992503046989441,
-0.6302423477172852,
-0.27614155411720276,
-0.273060142993927,
0.16796594858169556,
0.3942856788635254,
0.7474638819694519,
-0.46613824367523193,
0.33496159315109253,
0.6665813326835632,
-0.32007235288619995,
0.3123916685581207,
0.11278412491083145,
-0.05315345898270607,
-1.013150930404663,
0.2000601589679718,
0.07606635987758636,
-0.5726100206375122,
-0.7209555506706238,
0.14925919473171234,
0.10433008521795273,
-0.1059226244688034,
-0.24222742021083832,
0.8213316202163696,
-0.37188974022865295,
-0.20092284679412842,
-0.38586151599884033,
0.040244199335575104,
0.09927462041378021,
0.3816916346549988,
-0.09029442071914673,
0.9771026968955994,
0.3899572193622589,
-0.6790516376495361,
-0.00361857027746737,
0.07676974684000015,
-0.5763358473777771,
0.10316299647092819,
-0.2754664421081543,
0.3333320617675781,
0.03919046372175217,
0.17860817909240723,
-1.1159894466400146,
-0.2404959797859192,
0.0776335597038269,
-0.5875930190086365,
0.4571535587310791,
-0.2094801515340805,
-0.8765559196472168,
-0.16201528906822205,
-0.20411761105060577,
-0.028596753254532814,
0.526918351650238,
-0.6973717212677002,
0.5960296392440796,
0.6484608054161072,
0.05359094589948654,
-0.46815383434295654,
-0.6777373552322388,
0.2110193371772766,
-0.18595609068870544,
-0.5417007803916931,
0.2423081398010254,
0.20036368072032928,
-0.26340898871421814,
-0.4717350900173187,
0.13261711597442627,
-0.36975711584091187,
0.6110556721687317,
0.5852853655815125,
0.13586241006851196,
-0.21499082446098328,
0.07109265774488449,
0.07476117461919785,
-0.07040619850158691,
0.079660564661026,
-0.0181292537599802,
0.6247404217720032,
0.061648134142160416,
-0.37093183398246765,
-0.5252457857131958,
0.31112003326416016,
1.1070032119750977,
-0.3210410177707672,
0.6962361335754395,
0.5802927613258362,
-0.3942149877548218,
-0.06817198544740677,
-0.5560891628265381,
-0.4777083694934845,
-0.47526150941848755,
0.26889386773109436,
-0.5498985648155212,
-1.1576188802719116,
0.887974202632904,
0.10580208152532578,
0.036638300865888596,
0.4199395775794983,
0.7215909957885742,
-0.20608049631118774,
1.3685282468795776,
1.0267994403839111,
-0.21096263825893402,
0.5113281011581421,
0.3601909875869751,
0.42177003622055054,
-0.6161142587661743,
-0.0033891629427671432,
-0.7446710467338562,
0.10953204333782196,
-1.0579860210418701,
-0.033211179077625275,
0.06929630041122437,
0.18668894469738007,
-0.09837008267641068,
0.3952091634273529,
-0.5401387214660645,
0.6964802742004395,
0.7968779802322388,
0.0904456079006195,
0.39465245604515076,
-0.004700038116425276,
-0.2637940049171448,
-0.13267184793949127,
-0.44273850321769714,
-1.2196693420410156,
1.1995103359222412,
0.5698296427726746,
0.44608962535858154,
-0.09798242151737213,
0.909928023815155,
0.430370032787323,
0.47304174304008484,
-0.5415989756584167,
0.675804078578949,
-0.5232944488525391,
-0.9153512120246887,
0.09688819944858551,
-0.28107231855392456,
-0.8589804768562317,
0.12508462369441986,
-0.3182743489742279,
-0.9137590527534485,
-0.1020742803812027,
0.2667994201183319,
-0.16034330427646637,
0.48542916774749756,
-0.6940134167671204,
0.70448237657547,
-0.018682172521948814,
-0.3135397434234619,
0.11970463395118713,
-0.5110606551170349,
0.48846471309661865,
-0.34968075156211853,
-0.04328569397330284,
-0.313072144985199,
0.2686100900173187,
0.7116871476173401,
-0.28064191341400146,
1.2788065671920776,
-0.06906387954950333,
-0.3943444788455963,
0.3832243084907532,
0.2747035622596741,
0.30621638894081116,
-0.30545035004615784,
-0.10812930017709732,
0.2956528067588806,
0.08093788474798203,
-0.16723233461380005,
-0.0875752791762352,
0.49232247471809387,
-0.5206670761108398,
-0.576233446598053,
-0.026251977309584618,
-0.3112889230251312,
-0.12585434317588806,
0.2429598867893219,
0.4963119924068451,
0.49640777707099915,
0.000045252982090460137,
0.22879371047019958,
0.656299352645874,
-0.2618645429611206,
0.4614080488681793,
0.3532613515853882,
-0.2945622205734253,
0.08898798376321793,
1.0079309940338135,
-0.03683830797672272,
0.21881002187728882,
0.6084316372871399,
0.2747648060321808,
-0.2340250462293625,
-0.5935126543045044,
-0.7407680153846741,
0.217549130320549,
-0.8344017863273621,
-0.00896017998456955,
-0.6339477300643921,
-0.2787899971008301,
-0.22191576659679413,
0.152468740940094,
-0.18577536940574646,
-0.3972400426864624,
-0.4411366283893585,
0.10832292586565018,
0.29090505838394165,
0.8553112149238586,
0.16048479080200195,
0.40157797932624817,
-1.0821824073791504,
0.23099777102470398,
0.2881072759628296,
0.1804259866476059,
0.0025275445077568293,
-0.7096719741821289,
-0.3418272137641907,
0.09388458728790283,
-0.4150168299674988,
-0.6430994868278503,
0.3188246786594391,
0.2670542001724243,
0.3699439465999603,
0.6164510250091553,
-0.1934330314397812,
0.2533106803894043,
-0.4346948564052582,
0.8874741196632385,
-0.16469164192676544,
-1.2145910263061523,
0.1365990936756134,
-0.5970286726951599,
0.1956818848848343,
0.3096177577972412,
0.21754400432109833,
-0.5870265960693359,
-0.8870719075202942,
-0.3333489000797272,
-0.35569652915000916,
0.4774976372718811,
0.050191592425107956,
0.4360561966896057,
-0.192493736743927,
0.3282598555088043,
0.19766579568386078,
0.10728822648525238,
-0.991244375705719,
-0.1260015070438385,
0.06938906759023666,
-0.33530205488204956,
0.10763745754957199,
-0.4515507221221924,
-0.052744947373867035,
0.08495447039604187,
0.21864132583141327,
-0.18909813463687897,
0.14994457364082336,
-0.22917293012142181,
-0.019441623240709305,
0.0665193721652031,
0.03703276813030243,
0.8499512672424316,
0.24270100891590118,
0.039251770824193954,
0.323713481426239,
-0.10946294665336609,
-0.612669050693512,
0.0008400773513130844,
-0.25196677446365356,
-0.13473239541053772,
0.08805619925260544,
0.7171087861061096,
0.5626113414764404,
-0.06819793581962585,
-0.8103750944137573,
0.6010814905166626,
0.055985014885663986,
-0.09630125015974045,
-0.03366107493638992,
0.1967288851737976,
0.19243034720420837,
0.08327347040176392,
0.42376935482025146,
0.04587806761264801,
0.10589119046926498,
-0.5456956624984741,
0.27889731526374817,
0.5145193338394165,
-0.17109346389770508,
-0.5027775168418884,
0.8302729725837708,
0.3301398754119873,
-0.29742252826690674,
0.5883575081825256,
-0.07246634364128113,
-0.7619951367378235,
0.6703431606292725,
0.4468274414539337,
0.8953798413276672,
-0.035197239369153976,
-0.13517791032791138,
0.2222210168838501,
0.3732435703277588,
0.011488700285553932,
0.005672555882483721,
-0.27128779888153076,
-0.9529001712799072,
-0.5024385452270508,
-0.6550206542015076,
-0.5209731459617615,
0.3034873306751251,
-0.7080496549606323,
0.22975359857082367,
-0.47512105107307434,
-0.19782420992851257,
0.4360206127166748,
-0.07794231176376343,
-0.651090681552887,
0.044183000922203064,
0.6386673450469971,
0.5501008033752441,
-1.180641531944275,
1.0006155967712402,
0.3753000795841217,
-0.0326068252325058,
-0.5286362767219543,
0.006707958877086639,
0.19294621050357819,
-0.9388089179992676,
0.8686820268630981,
0.6065265536308289,
-0.4302828907966614,
-0.18357908725738525,
-0.7145854830741882,
-0.7773305773735046,
0.49786606431007385,
0.47055795788764954,
-0.7842356562614441,
0.28005456924438477,
0.3222668766975403,
0.826085090637207,
-0.2086847871541977,
0.044083427637815475,
0.623748242855072,
0.36584171652793884,
-0.3825337886810303,
-1.1117198467254639,
-0.1250305324792862,
-0.3218684494495392,
-0.05012941360473633,
0.352492094039917,
-0.36307787895202637,
0.9737405776977539,
-0.053519926965236664,
-0.6566175818443298,
0.2937948405742645,
0.37069031596183777,
0.258691668510437,
0.43250513076782227,
0.2862265706062317,
0.3249645531177521,
0.7732738256454468,
-0.16920258104801178,
1.1363859176635742,
-0.6020344495773315,
0.07484947144985199,
0.964364767074585,
-0.5825017690658569,
0.9720250368118286,
0.45238178968429565,
0.007347446400672197,
0.4028976559638977,
0.713126540184021,
-0.19903594255447388,
0.2584509253501892,
0.2589322626590729,
-0.37596595287323,
-0.4718284010887146,
-0.13068482279777527,
-0.014499347656965256,
0.8013452291488647,
0.39746278524398804,
-0.5233640670776367,
0.13800936937332153,
0.09362301975488663,
0.004634300246834755,
0.36883410811424255,
0.05266393721103668,
0.7767334580421448,
-0.04674940183758736,
-0.6480178236961365,
0.6019049882888794,
0.09845227003097534,
0.8163549304008484,
-0.3306626081466675,
-0.05265242978930473,
-0.32112443447113037,
0.23982863128185272,
-0.21983671188354492,
-0.7523044943809509,
0.19877378642559052,
0.0686398595571518,
-0.4570824205875397,
-0.3426922559738159,
0.7179375290870667,
-0.33557483553886414,
-0.26091450452804565,
0.18563275039196014,
0.6191295981407166,
0.3642553687095642,
-0.022676721215248108,
-0.31919628381729126,
0.2687336802482605,
0.12606889009475708,
-0.21160539984703064,
0.386616587638855,
0.3631296157836914,
-0.4226625859737396,
0.802897572517395,
0.799102246761322,
-0.13064637780189514,
0.2132387012243271,
0.1267455518245697,
0.6786920428276062,
-0.5946471691131592,
-0.08048279583454132,
-1.1257882118225098,
0.1612616330385208,
-0.0995849072933197,
-0.39346063137054443,
0.826126754283905,
0.6724230051040649,
0.9034544825553894,
-0.27320846915245056,
0.707643985748291,
0.3653184473514557,
0.7892557978630066,
-0.6490148901939392,
0.890087902545929,
-0.3443094491958618,
0.27900373935699463,
-0.02434147335588932,
-0.8818707466125488,
-0.36329931020736694,
0.5671447515487671,
0.1655099093914032,
0.0025005594361573458,
0.4921565353870392,
0.9285823702812195,
0.04523830860853195,
-0.1338641494512558,
0.5077775716781616,
-0.10467468202114105,
0.601818859577179,
0.42649006843566895,
0.9946772456169128,
-0.3655520975589752,
0.31510040163993835,
-0.1154252141714096,
-0.01045079156756401,
-0.3874260187149048,
-0.8553831577301025,
-1.2474581003189087,
-0.9319581985473633,
-0.32227978110313416,
-0.2072669267654419,
-0.3730798661708832,
0.3638196885585785,
0.9695548415184021,
-0.6429001688957214,
-0.29052734375,
-0.01114658359438181,
-0.10907779633998871,
-0.031796470284461975,
-0.21961313486099243,
0.1497315913438797,
-0.04705024138092995,
-0.8420140743255615,
0.441606342792511,
0.25387728214263916,
0.4489731192588806,
-0.3654195964336395,
0.23065567016601562,
0.3107438087463379,
0.18592578172683716,
0.562104344367981,
0.3361053466796875,
-0.8648636937141418,
-0.424444317817688,
0.026184851303696632,
-0.608371913433075,
-0.041504617780447006,
0.8653810024261475,
-0.6247628331184387,
0.4647423028945923,
0.35196465253829956,
0.7384021282196045,
0.5634399056434631,
-0.3387435972690582,
0.5664107203483582,
-0.8492543697357178,
0.17011301219463348,
0.1529284417629242,
0.36453983187675476,
0.49752238392829895,
-0.30472269654273987,
0.3582623600959778,
0.03427973762154579,
-0.4620751142501831,
-1.0348316431045532,
0.42992421984672546,
-0.8164030313491821,
-0.0907990112900734,
0.9744109511375427,
-0.06302126497030258,
-0.09089604020118713,
-0.3848731815814972,
-0.012517495080828667,
0.14685046672821045,
-0.11171169579029083,
0.8921518325805664,
0.9155391454696655,
-0.039728645235300064,
-0.09095147252082825,
-0.5301329493522644,
0.6436034440994263,
0.46010130643844604,
-0.9059391617774963,
0.4044250249862671,
0.3429586589336395,
0.31499961018562317,
0.3526259660720825,
0.500311553478241,
-0.1485527902841568,
0.2133033722639084,
0.06777079403400421,
0.14721722900867462,
0.002329514129087329,
-0.31671082973480225,
-0.33810052275657654,
0.03115200623869896,
0.3188319504261017,
-0.2366073578596115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14055v1
|
How Many Bytes Can You Take Out Of Brain-To-Text Decoding?
| 2024-05-22T22:57:04 | 2024-05-22T22:57:04 |
Richard Antonello, Nihita Sarma, Jerry Tang, Jiaru Song, Alexander Huth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET
|
Brain-computer interfaces have promising medical and scientific applications
for aiding speech and studying the brain. In this work, we propose an
information-based evaluation metric for brain-to-text decoders. Using this
metric, we examine two methods to augment existing state-of-the-art continuous
text decoders. We show that these methods, in concert, can improve brain
decoding performance by upwards of 40% when compared to a baseline model. We
further examine the informatic properties of brain-to-text decoders and show
empirically that they have Zipfian power law dynamics. Finally, we provide an
estimate for the idealized performance of an fMRI-based text decoder. We
compare this idealized model to our current model, and use our
information-based metric to quantify the main sources of decoding error. We
conclude that a practical brain-to-text decoder is likely possible given
further algorithmic improvements.
|
[
-0.26333552598953247,
-0.5678900480270386,
0.7228394150733948,
0.4940074682235718,
-0.5030269026756287,
-0.28068292140960693,
-0.4613175690174103,
-0.6356701254844666,
0.15903879702091217,
0.16972219944000244,
-0.326144814491272,
-0.25814053416252136,
-0.7422516942024231,
0.1654571294784546,
-0.41370949149131775,
0.9098371863365173,
0.3710593283176422,
0.2994130551815033,
-0.6109384298324585,
0.16859517991542816,
-0.7070490717887878,
-0.5986103415489197,
-0.5242841243743896,
-0.28419041633605957,
0.6539839506149292,
0.03197285532951355,
0.4178783595561981,
0.6268353462219238,
0.7124026417732239,
0.13088564574718475,
-0.22656476497650146,
0.07228272408246994,
-0.19376526772975922,
-0.32854560017585754,
-0.06154996156692505,
-0.5410265326499939,
-0.6214399337768555,
-0.3916390538215637,
0.5448928475379944,
0.7463256120681763,
-0.17881663143634796,
-0.10585077852010727,
0.055382139980793,
0.8135713338851929,
-0.827695906162262,
0.1918606013059616,
-0.14046423137187958,
-0.03463352099061012,
-0.11288899928331375,
-0.5991677641868591,
-0.8095166683197021,
-0.5268159508705139,
-0.061704836785793304,
-0.3386254608631134,
-0.3643152117729187,
0.002710039261728525,
0.5578580498695374,
0.2999809682369232,
-0.29509156942367554,
-0.3599708676338196,
-0.49409082531929016,
0.5588219165802002,
-0.6913976073265076,
0.6817386150360107,
0.48659026622772217,
0.2454318106174469,
-0.158506840467453,
-0.7929659485816956,
-0.5023252367973328,
0.042400557547807693,
-0.18668441474437714,
0.31937697529792786,
-0.3793752193450928,
0.2588540315628052,
0.307468056678772,
0.20714356005191803,
-0.4340516924858093,
-0.07380913943052292,
-0.3729528486728668,
0.005913366097956896,
0.452730268239975,
0.28345441818237305,
0.5104086399078369,
-0.06388179957866669,
0.12919797003269196,
-0.19798904657363892,
-0.3278457522392273,
0.09870250523090363,
0.16377118229866028,
-0.35452598333358765,
-0.008220944553613663,
0.4263836741447449,
-0.036053676158189774,
0.753666877746582,
0.07301213592290878,
-0.0816090777516365,
0.22479642927646637,
-0.4333246648311615,
0.03463349491357803,
0.19275987148284912,
0.4893169403076172,
0.5655091404914856,
0.17607523500919342,
-0.9014282822608948,
-0.062076386064291,
-0.027583574876189232,
0.48725375533103943,
-1.0600898265838623,
-0.41584092378616333,
0.32967284321784973,
-0.8303252458572388,
0.04986364021897316,
-0.11618082970380783,
-0.6517009735107422,
-0.3776826858520508,
-0.087284155189991,
0.6489245295524597,
-1.053855299949646,
-0.34235265851020813,
0.56648850440979,
-0.8421372175216675,
0.15638653934001923,
0.12135643512010574,
-0.8929240107536316,
0.4608652591705322,
0.46512743830680847,
0.9024927616119385,
-0.19334404170513153,
-0.07348459213972092,
-0.07266431301832199,
0.01498829759657383,
-0.2413068413734436,
1.227721095085144,
-0.2565852701663971,
-0.18363487720489502,
-0.3512769043445587,
-0.22315801680088043,
-0.02352445013821125,
-0.4824087619781494,
0.6244139671325684,
-0.6941350698471069,
-0.18095269799232483,
-0.4092448055744171,
-0.6512147188186646,
-0.23669706284999847,
-0.3368496000766754,
-0.7725326418876648,
0.2480052262544632,
-0.13623268902301788,
-0.9117798805236816,
0.21174435317516327,
-0.972210168838501,
-0.703615665435791,
0.1097293272614479,
0.04581224173307419,
-0.05728159844875336,
0.37348872423171997,
-0.009575541131198406,
0.2748412489891052,
-0.385505735874176,
0.1950647234916687,
-0.2217452973127365,
-0.8670021891593933,
0.7115572690963745,
-0.7738988995552063,
0.994584321975708,
0.2887752652168274,
-0.10840268433094025,
-0.283343106508255,
-1.0443207025527954,
0.29705074429512024,
-0.19533002376556396,
-0.6612556576728821,
-0.4607574939727783,
0.4635598361492157,
0.033529289066791534,
-0.28290534019470215,
0.3722776472568512,
-0.7245820164680481,
-0.22142469882965088,
-0.31598666310310364,
0.5591397285461426,
0.19818271696567535,
-0.04168395325541496,
0.17188484966754913,
-0.3192724883556366,
-0.09730643033981323,
0.11161789298057556,
-0.12372904270887375,
-0.3937707841396332,
-0.2790139615535736,
-0.6095812320709229,
-0.518156886100769,
0.7664585113525391,
0.6426582932472229,
-0.5331913828849792,
0.956344485282898,
-0.6864904165267944,
-0.4213068187236786,
-0.6133665442466736,
-0.6539906859397888,
0.09187661856412888,
0.3802400529384613,
0.424702525138855,
-0.32576778531074524,
-0.5094016790390015,
-0.7822686433792114,
-0.5137484669685364,
-0.013658511452376842,
-0.666309118270874,
-0.028900127857923508,
0.07316330820322037,
0.029770568013191223,
0.9020909070968628,
-0.2830294370651245,
0.08225475996732712,
0.3531019985675812,
0.19782276451587677,
0.2203177660703659,
0.43209394812583923,
0.29379481077194214,
-0.49989986419677734,
0.1846523880958557,
0.1703014224767685,
-1.0072157382965088,
0.0457952655851841,
0.0004999263910576701,
0.2189786434173584,
0.07566138356924057,
0.22890163958072662,
-0.49268800020217896,
0.5553054213523865,
0.26163485646247864,
-0.5015864372253418,
0.3803103566169739,
-0.5390143990516663,
0.5721129775047302,
-0.6797192096710205,
0.302799791097641,
-0.03371090814471245,
0.07880771160125732,
-0.6220163106918335,
-0.176866814494133,
0.567405104637146,
0.36183616518974304,
-0.08765588700771332,
0.052433282136917114,
-0.5295653343200684,
-0.00888050440698862,
-0.4433290660381317,
0.001950648962520063,
-0.09004092216491699,
0.5197168588638306,
0.11231739819049835,
0.8948838114738464,
0.3883666396141052,
-0.7683497667312622,
0.14615555107593536,
0.139876127243042,
-0.6295516490936279,
0.7491663098335266,
-0.5601764917373657,
0.3713902235031128,
-0.5382067561149597,
0.2614298462867737,
-0.9304766654968262,
-0.2464636266231537,
-0.23123641312122345,
-0.7036295533180237,
0.16630683839321136,
0.2740081250667572,
-0.643156111240387,
-0.06373069435358047,
-0.2209358513355255,
0.5946875810623169,
0.8135638236999512,
-0.744591236114502,
0.4921916127204895,
0.4959809184074402,
0.011776258237659931,
-0.4969341456890106,
-1.0883816480636597,
0.5450978875160217,
0.04330667853355408,
-0.7153348326683044,
0.49047234654426575,
-0.44290876388549805,
-0.029997212812304497,
0.16838926076889038,
0.03868461400270462,
-0.3481191098690033,
-0.0816933661699295,
0.24219490587711334,
-0.04878704249858856,
-0.009243560023605824,
0.2245476096868515,
0.42842668294906616,
0.04376545175909996,
0.40884026885032654,
-0.5349540710449219,
0.20813141763210297,
-0.14501899480819702,
0.019500408321619034,
-0.3932000994682312,
0.3962874114513397,
0.3947804570198059,
-0.11000427603721619,
0.6550249457359314,
0.3486262559890747,
-0.6118590831756592,
0.3938528895378113,
-0.48356541991233826,
-0.17596988379955292,
-0.45398497581481934,
0.541637659072876,
-0.501688539981842,
-0.5171809792518616,
0.21185816824436188,
-0.19556616246700287,
-0.17588301002979279,
0.15930162370204926,
0.26033124327659607,
-0.3885645866394043,
1.106716275215149,
0.8435781598091125,
0.48826277256011963,
0.43678122758865356,
0.09339471906423569,
0.21398866176605225,
-0.9526849985122681,
-0.5758068561553955,
-0.4163266122341156,
-0.30550500750541687,
-0.1630767434835434,
-0.05603475868701935,
0.6405645608901978,
0.14978234469890594,
0.07899434864521027,
0.4730507433414459,
-0.609394907951355,
0.3401060402393341,
0.10102900862693787,
0.694547176361084,
0.27774760127067566,
0.28494128584861755,
0.009767591953277588,
-0.18056067824363708,
-0.9215905666351318,
-0.2611628770828247,
0.9033628106117249,
0.36710125207901,
0.7625735998153687,
0.038346774876117706,
0.08102160692214966,
0.31441736221313477,
0.3092193305492401,
-0.892849862575531,
0.5788295865058899,
-0.3607284426689148,
-0.18172581493854523,
-0.13047689199447632,
-0.5345883965492249,
-0.7180226445198059,
-0.12581579387187958,
-0.16545429825782776,
-0.899983286857605,
0.3980938494205475,
0.017008045688271523,
-0.282794326543808,
0.18027068674564362,
-0.8714209794998169,
0.47200900316238403,
-0.02005682699382305,
-0.1798396110534668,
-0.6071285009384155,
-0.43576580286026,
0.15649579465389252,
-0.21940936148166656,
0.10601188987493515,
0.4054205119609833,
-0.30122077465057373,
0.9935686588287354,
-0.06481467187404633,
0.5138188600540161,
-0.014217113144695759,
0.15904703736305237,
0.03708816319704056,
-0.41064968705177307,
-0.08166996389627457,
-0.15650571882724762,
-0.3813744783401489,
0.7664580941200256,
0.4812033474445343,
-0.24768610298633575,
-0.8734456300735474,
0.46036389470100403,
-0.561682939529419,
-0.1064457967877388,
-0.11916327476501465,
-0.8592981100082397,
-0.0928504541516304,
0.13327892124652863,
0.5307921767234802,
0.6243036389350891,
-0.22699707746505737,
0.5023276805877686,
0.922368049621582,
-0.08463969826698303,
0.6671961545944214,
0.3297238051891327,
0.36689549684524536,
-0.7112242579460144,
0.8963966965675354,
0.34357187151908875,
-0.08105367422103882,
0.7939229011535645,
-0.034778792411088943,
-0.335930734872818,
-0.8040290474891663,
-0.31089943647384644,
0.23124679923057556,
-0.6709871292114258,
-0.19637349247932434,
-0.9012981653213501,
-0.20336206257343292,
-0.02329493872821331,
0.17241354286670685,
-0.029624052345752716,
-0.40830671787261963,
-0.15926487743854523,
0.11847742646932602,
0.5126295685768127,
0.2954375743865967,
-0.23759153485298157,
0.534729540348053,
-0.6469511389732361,
0.17260301113128662,
-0.05708659812808037,
0.7055724859237671,
-0.05461135134100914,
-0.4509405493736267,
-0.6361646056175232,
0.09601427614688873,
0.028626874089241028,
-1.1120223999023438,
0.10867442935705185,
-0.08427125960588455,
0.13157899677753448,
0.1529817283153534,
0.1438809335231781,
0.7657302021980286,
-0.5904386639595032,
0.576774001121521,
0.4238782823085785,
-0.906348466873169,
0.29921191930770874,
0.09749865531921387,
0.4942299425601959,
0.37904271483421326,
0.12501421570777893,
-0.34249645471572876,
-0.12224229425191879,
-0.29498913884162903,
-0.5040489435195923,
0.5600247383117676,
0.10454683750867844,
0.016575030982494354,
-0.01700405776500702,
0.5428085923194885,
-0.06768523901700974,
0.05513473227620125,
-0.27821943163871765,
-0.10426171123981476,
-0.17008525133132935,
-0.6172674894332886,
0.24907070398330688,
-0.21780258417129517,
0.06709007918834686,
-0.3444055914878845,
0.17966671288013458,
-0.076967254281044,
0.8872852325439453,
0.2942996919155121,
-0.051869455724954605,
0.20655013620853424,
0.3380235433578491,
0.4723609983921051,
0.563269853591919,
-0.39362412691116333,
0.18736012279987335,
0.3274189829826355,
-0.9049705266952515,
0.0316498763859272,
0.026828767731785774,
-0.06501606106758118,
0.11387952417135239,
-0.0009567683446221054,
0.8660168647766113,
-0.015196084976196289,
-0.7358201146125793,
0.50934898853302,
-0.501978874206543,
-0.15078648924827576,
-0.35166069865226746,
0.057500794529914856,
0.16162598133087158,
0.04573023319244385,
0.3679485023021698,
0.5513462424278259,
0.5366250872612,
-0.1702992022037506,
0.23004215955734253,
0.3708864152431488,
-0.4724518358707428,
-0.41223159432411194,
0.42513027787208557,
0.14642010629177094,
-0.6043930649757385,
0.3503378927707672,
0.1875748336315155,
0.119474858045578,
0.5503136515617371,
0.5993828773498535,
0.8327445983886719,
0.008001538924872875,
-0.39669281244277954,
0.3384246826171875,
0.42651933431625366,
-0.10265544056892395,
0.24602824449539185,
-0.29680749773979187,
-0.45765653252601624,
-0.5602483153343201,
-0.28421518206596375,
-0.15225832164287567,
0.20343846082687378,
-0.7373025417327881,
0.2811813950538635,
-0.2846493721008301,
-0.5162160992622375,
0.23573976755142212,
-0.2118598222732544,
-0.44216108322143555,
0.4205138683319092,
-0.27750450372695923,
1.2428970336914062,
0.01921861805021763,
0.9620841145515442,
0.638019323348999,
-0.19030511379241943,
-0.35511866211891174,
0.23677153885364532,
-0.6185447573661804,
-0.1514984369277954,
0.3035527765750885,
0.2615489661693573,
-0.3966532349586487,
0.24126043915748596,
-0.457472562789917,
-0.5029699802398682,
1.0150259733200073,
0.5327849388122559,
-0.49098435044288635,
-0.14247381687164307,
-0.3196699619293213,
0.5354827046394348,
-0.2251635491847992,
1.0837024450302124,
0.7482810616493225,
0.5952293872833252,
-0.47996363043785095,
-0.6871967315673828,
-0.007630604784935713,
-0.49241524934768677,
0.1283794641494751,
0.026173194870352745,
-0.37851402163505554,
0.3147079348564148,
-0.16317540407180786,
-0.65555340051651,
0.08008437603712082,
0.8255671262741089,
-0.11496371030807495,
0.33614739775657654,
0.49681204557418823,
0.11153295636177063,
0.6957871913909912,
-0.021873531863093376,
1.1498006582260132,
-0.5815108418464661,
-0.04188896343111992,
0.5334427356719971,
0.38892310857772827,
1.0309982299804688,
0.5904507637023926,
-0.05395680293440819,
0.454304575920105,
0.352800190448761,
0.13869193196296692,
0.7486220598220825,
0.12766173481941223,
-0.3399827480316162,
0.04477526620030403,
0.12812723219394684,
-0.06226356327533722,
0.08518712967634201,
0.6363707780838013,
-0.17844104766845703,
-0.03509611636400223,
0.31757432222366333,
-0.19103235006332397,
0.1285679042339325,
-0.14417019486427307,
0.804589569568634,
0.014748826622962952,
-0.7352554202079773,
0.7417231798171997,
0.24904586374759674,
0.9512338042259216,
-0.5090143084526062,
-0.12092471867799759,
0.04634632170200348,
0.14729510247707367,
-0.346929132938385,
-0.7466923594474792,
0.3874756693840027,
0.20060662925243378,
-0.5106545686721802,
0.15454451739788055,
0.7386269569396973,
-0.42684924602508545,
-0.1207699403166771,
0.23105542361736298,
-0.025920886546373367,
0.6094528436660767,
-0.061535775661468506,
-0.14254112541675568,
0.1995505392551422,
-0.2513997554779053,
0.0511295311152935,
0.3082696199417114,
0.2584275007247925,
0.20112480223178864,
0.3699846863746643,
0.3381790220737457,
0.12169201672077179,
-0.08088800311088562,
-0.20293886959552765,
0.6276776790618896,
-0.8469774723052979,
-0.43017199635505676,
-0.8170775771141052,
0.456109881401062,
-0.23311418294906616,
-0.046225156635046005,
0.3964381217956543,
0.4474271535873413,
0.4886557459831238,
-0.09836839139461517,
0.8859356045722961,
-0.2685883641242981,
0.2137596607208252,
-0.673430860042572,
0.9939730167388916,
-0.3594491183757782,
0.1659734696149826,
0.19201958179473877,
-0.7125236988067627,
0.03172694519162178,
0.46464207768440247,
-0.02203950472176075,
-0.04081323742866516,
1.189900517463684,
0.6668131947517395,
-0.015947537496685982,
0.5126099586486816,
0.4954651892185211,
0.05122785270214081,
-0.0004123341932427138,
0.8274001479148865,
0.6639907360076904,
-0.6904315948486328,
0.6986106634140015,
0.09932595491409302,
-0.8174248933792114,
-0.039545975625514984,
-0.8505551218986511,
-0.5969461798667908,
-0.5482494235038757,
-0.38768529891967773,
-0.41416850686073303,
0.4276731312274933,
0.37590113282203674,
0.7399696707725525,
-0.2377774566411972,
-0.3732534945011139,
-0.14432618021965027,
-0.11865182220935822,
-0.5926480293273926,
-0.1370690017938614,
0.14874167740345,
-0.32706180214881897,
-0.6202305555343628,
0.5330221652984619,
0.49734702706336975,
-0.26836955547332764,
0.009200332686305046,
-0.03944236412644386,
0.2846754491329193,
0.5638666152954102,
0.8371763229370117,
0.14728094637393951,
-0.35630977153778076,
-0.2512633204460144,
0.07060103863477707,
-0.28928861021995544,
0.33582359552383423,
0.8640725612640381,
-0.9329479336738586,
0.37667185068130493,
0.7483806610107422,
0.8670199513435364,
0.5812970399856567,
-0.16927751898765564,
0.5627188682556152,
-0.3493807017803192,
-0.0489543080329895,
0.07972031086683273,
-0.029654327780008316,
0.2092577964067459,
-0.6978415250778198,
0.15998022258281708,
0.004089138004928827,
-0.5067922472953796,
-0.6422324776649475,
-0.08594605326652527,
-1.0951815843582153,
-0.31744974851608276,
0.9239199757575989,
-0.24188612401485443,
-0.7028869390487671,
-0.03495239093899727,
-0.13357539474964142,
0.193838968873024,
-0.2856682538986206,
0.7907751202583313,
0.8389169573783875,
-0.34515661001205444,
-0.2328508198261261,
-0.4998110234737396,
0.33661824464797974,
0.47338294982910156,
-1.0543500185012817,
0.022030221298336983,
0.5464228987693787,
0.3810260593891144,
0.38984814286231995,
0.7490881085395813,
-0.3962777853012085,
0.6415632367134094,
0.31269145011901855,
0.19528593122959137,
-0.08759281039237976,
-0.35471153259277344,
-0.5669835805892944,
0.14931967854499817,
-0.3506440818309784,
-0.2520870864391327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00015v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00015v1
|
Use of natural language processing to extract and classify papillary thyroid cancer features from surgical pathology reports
| 2024-05-22T22:27:12 | 2024-05-22T22:27:12 |
Ricardo Loor-Torres, Yuqi Wu, Esteban Cabezas, Mariana Borras, David Toro-Tobon, Mayra Duran, Misk Al Zahidy, Maria Mateo Chavez, Cristian Soto Jacome, Jungwei W. Fan, Naykky M. Singh Ospina, Yonghui Wu, Juan P. Brito
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Background We aim to use Natural Language Processing (NLP) to automate the
extraction and classification of thyroid cancer risk factors from pathology
reports. Methods We analyzed 1,410 surgical pathology reports from adult
papillary thyroid cancer patients at Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, from 2010 to
2019. Structured and non-structured reports were used to create a
consensus-based ground truth dictionary and categorized them into modified
recurrence risk levels. Non-structured reports were narrative, while structured
reports followed standardized formats. We then developed ThyroPath, a
rule-based NLP pipeline, to extract and classify thyroid cancer features into
risk categories. Training involved 225 reports (150 structured, 75
unstructured), with testing on 170 reports (120 structured, 50 unstructured)
for evaluation. The pipeline's performance was assessed using both strict and
lenient criteria for accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score. Results In
extraction tasks, ThyroPath achieved overall strict F-1 scores of 93% for
structured reports and 90 for unstructured reports, covering 18 thyroid cancer
pathology features. In classification tasks, ThyroPath-extracted information
demonstrated an overall accuracy of 93% in categorizing reports based on their
corresponding guideline-based risk of recurrence: 76.9% for high-risk, 86.8%
for intermediate risk, and 100% for both low and very low-risk cases. However,
ThyroPath achieved 100% accuracy across all thyroid cancer risk categories with
human-extracted pathology information. Conclusions ThyroPath shows promise in
automating the extraction and risk recurrence classification of thyroid
pathology reports at large scale. It offers a solution to laborious manual
reviews and advancing virtual registries. However, it requires further
validation before implementation.
|
[
-0.17833763360977173,
-0.6046168804168701,
0.7860020399093628,
-0.11630574613809586,
-0.4613032639026642,
0.19544237852096558,
-0.14999759197235107,
-0.8101553916931152,
0.17420899868011475,
0.5891370177268982,
-0.5089491009712219,
-0.7136976718902588,
-0.7165027260780334,
0.13120120763778687,
-0.37361106276512146,
1.0510814189910889,
0.24162495136260986,
0.21760375797748566,
0.25455430150032043,
0.27594324946403503,
-0.11984957754611969,
-0.09863032400608063,
-0.7992000579833984,
-0.06069449335336685,
0.7026617527008057,
0.5280707478523254,
0.4294303059577942,
1.1211364269256592,
0.6221757531166077,
0.2572784721851349,
0.13554887473583221,
0.17692919075489044,
-0.005400080233812332,
0.2222287356853485,
-0.18509835004806519,
-0.11947496235370636,
-0.3946274518966675,
0.3322734534740448,
0.48430195450782776,
0.6141782402992249,
-0.4636346995830536,
0.23312532901763916,
0.13413676619529724,
0.36324936151504517,
-0.24990728497505188,
-0.05885282903909683,
-0.4795229434967041,
0.17640383541584015,
-0.5694214701652527,
-0.49498772621154785,
-0.2268950194120407,
-0.6947138905525208,
0.48042410612106323,
-0.6430494785308838,
0.31832125782966614,
-0.0026450997684150934,
0.5289403796195984,
-0.1257108747959137,
-0.5113380551338196,
-0.3060283064842224,
-0.6443803310394287,
0.7043896317481995,
-0.4900660514831543,
0.28981339931488037,
0.542360782623291,
0.45416828989982605,
-0.13655340671539307,
-1.0071890354156494,
-0.3165190517902374,
-0.0005514145013876259,
-0.07658077776432037,
0.029614368453621864,
-0.1570582240819931,
-0.014090992510318756,
0.2537723779678345,
0.7956284880638123,
-0.5881426930427551,
0.28262609243392944,
-0.7834389209747314,
-0.4854513108730316,
0.5072655081748962,
0.253862202167511,
0.4421141445636749,
-0.35633954405784607,
-0.08266406506299973,
-0.21712626516819,
-0.1961313784122467,
-0.04989662021398544,
0.08338375389575958,
0.41981804370880127,
0.19794920086860657,
0.4021340310573578,
-0.34982696175575256,
0.5783891081809998,
0.13030759990215302,
-0.36839354038238525,
0.251065194606781,
0.024423690512776375,
-0.31961148977279663,
0.31133824586868286,
0.8999146819114685,
0.20668740570545197,
-0.1149299293756485,
-0.38237208127975464,
0.6742393970489502,
-0.12667842209339142,
0.5973721742630005,
-0.4657222628593445,
-0.05699406564235687,
0.4185187816619873,
-0.6074615716934204,
-0.5747829079627991,
0.027164041996002197,
-1.1879836320877075,
-0.555046021938324,
-0.01578930765390396,
0.20873701572418213,
-0.36028531193733215,
-0.5101167559623718,
0.19370310008525848,
-0.23241007328033447,
0.21967259049415588,
0.4848118722438812,
-0.3743794560432434,
0.8334891200065613,
0.6780885457992554,
0.7602137327194214,
-0.3326760530471802,
-0.16598209738731384,
-0.8978414535522461,
0.1920761913061142,
0.08551591634750366,
0.9556881785392761,
-0.42382222414016724,
-0.3654301166534424,
-0.1731993407011032,
0.22307825088500977,
-0.2822858989238739,
-0.5101887583732605,
0.929039716720581,
0.10517925769090652,
0.6113715767860413,
0.0853637084364891,
-0.28040096163749695,
-0.3528042733669281,
0.0642302930355072,
-0.6692377328872681,
0.7579140067100525,
0.26067620515823364,
-0.5537930727005005,
0.46069657802581787,
-0.2851501405239105,
-0.6528546810150146,
0.23978263139724731,
0.1526397317647934,
-0.24003048241138458,
0.06530740857124329,
-0.08404088765382767,
0.3190089166164398,
-0.6743276715278625,
0.2927211821079254,
0.09166454523801804,
0.19720280170440674,
-0.05795716866850853,
-0.31280219554901123,
0.6456934213638306,
0.20183315873146057,
-0.5200000405311584,
0.04660535231232643,
-0.8394370675086975,
0.541700541973114,
-0.29610902070999146,
-0.16498230397701263,
-0.04257781431078911,
-0.12608061730861664,
-0.003013023640960455,
0.4960205852985382,
-0.3659123480319977,
-0.818234920501709,
-0.19019237160682678,
-0.6490470767021179,
0.06944413483142853,
0.36240354180336,
0.30392417311668396,
0.1555894911289215,
-0.4638694226741791,
0.46503400802612305,
-0.30209457874298096,
0.17479054629802704,
0.4489057958126068,
-0.831142246723175,
-0.20403307676315308,
-0.16547051072120667,
0.36797991394996643,
0.4970274269580841,
-0.1632770299911499,
0.3786652386188507,
0.04007253795862198,
-0.7162845134735107,
-0.21767771244049072,
-0.24518835544586182,
0.5535167455673218,
1.2813305854797363,
0.33642175793647766,
-0.4942917227745056,
-0.5467672944068909,
-0.7868754863739014,
-0.23248915374279022,
-0.2051098495721817,
-0.1988796442747116,
-0.07755621522665024,
-0.06225750595331192,
0.1625211387872696,
0.3178022801876068,
-0.724403440952301,
-0.687663197517395,
-0.1869114190340042,
0.5043344497680664,
0.26755791902542114,
0.5306161046028137,
-0.07015974819660187,
-0.6433722376823425,
-0.7134351134300232,
0.4854902923107147,
-0.38463059067726135,
-0.3219212293624878,
0.20246540009975433,
-0.21217362582683563,
0.2856907844543457,
0.272626131772995,
-0.7286092638969421,
0.8033384680747986,
0.31155648827552795,
-0.1525357961654663,
0.3911460041999817,
-0.07426674664020538,
0.5146735906600952,
-0.9471967220306396,
0.3112903833389282,
0.24925777316093445,
-0.3766409754753113,
-0.5812806487083435,
-0.2114749699831009,
-0.20418088138103485,
-0.0621652714908123,
-0.1773155778646469,
0.30491918325424194,
-0.16863058507442474,
0.1019752100110054,
0.03452940657734871,
-0.16260431706905365,
-0.02843053638935089,
0.2776024639606476,
0.4699491858482361,
0.13090753555297852,
0.22466394305229187,
-0.6809363961219788,
0.13600708544254303,
-0.1076158806681633,
-0.22658470273017883,
0.6068037152290344,
-0.27800890803337097,
-0.07390724867582321,
0.36927860975265503,
-0.06772759556770325,
-0.6586260199546814,
-0.7366200685501099,
0.27689114212989807,
-0.6508216261863708,
0.33574047684669495,
-0.34654179215431213,
-0.5137749314308167,
-0.4397726058959961,
-0.24236434698104858,
-0.28898587822914124,
0.5511196851730347,
0.11375647038221359,
0.6415449380874634,
0.471885085105896,
-0.5187498331069946,
-0.06903144717216492,
-0.7075808048248291,
-0.16937655210494995,
-0.4015219509601593,
-0.45935800671577454,
0.47630539536476135,
0.1299717277288437,
-0.10328778624534607,
-0.009271852672100067,
-0.3193347454071045,
-0.4202214181423187,
0.015041536651551723,
0.3544190227985382,
-0.008169269189238548,
-0.014868509955704212,
0.14596408605575562,
-0.05785409361124039,
-0.11395209282636642,
-0.03952864184975624,
-0.01050336193293333,
0.6367325782775879,
-0.04314182698726654,
-0.21687090396881104,
-0.90054851770401,
0.34886738657951355,
0.6686461567878723,
-0.1188785582780838,
0.4585641026496887,
0.7407448291778564,
-0.6996263861656189,
0.23756127059459686,
-0.8327967524528503,
-0.14573049545288086,
-0.3127695322036743,
0.17974871397018433,
0.11733511090278625,
-0.780265748500824,
0.637566089630127,
-0.05231846123933792,
0.1799980103969574,
1.1035104990005493,
0.5079743266105652,
-0.4975424110889435,
0.8908740282058716,
0.40406864881515503,
0.2610090672969818,
-0.0006341695552691817,
0.17546646296977997,
-0.0905681923031807,
-0.7763875722885132,
-0.3646283745765686,
-0.7146319150924683,
-0.26703739166259766,
-0.723279595375061,
-0.42946991324424744,
0.7199085354804993,
-0.4638235867023468,
-0.167093887925148,
0.09664270281791687,
-0.8105508089065552,
0.1917763203382492,
0.44907906651496887,
0.36671319603919983,
0.3041919767856598,
0.39231204986572266,
0.18538227677345276,
-0.2771924138069153,
-0.5116384625434875,
-0.16506245732307434,
1.3441822528839111,
0.4977479577064514,
0.11113548278808594,
0.2582189738750458,
0.7241763472557068,
0.27461960911750793,
0.44715872406959534,
-0.7381910085678101,
0.17928695678710938,
-0.6044588088989258,
-0.777162492275238,
-0.47475412487983704,
-0.6081676483154297,
-0.8092334866523743,
-0.08618400990962982,
-0.1733100563287735,
-0.9098982810974121,
0.1330047845840454,
-0.09172014147043228,
-0.705807626247406,
0.5099508762359619,
-0.5643078088760376,
0.6452269554138184,
-0.31816190481185913,
-0.3281661868095398,
-0.10073751956224442,
-0.5897166132926941,
0.4071260094642639,
-0.15416257083415985,
0.34674862027168274,
0.0896550863981247,
0.1076335683465004,
0.6627157926559448,
-0.6746125817298889,
0.8289373517036438,
0.0500948503613472,
0.17484478652477264,
0.0045148348435759544,
0.2363167554140091,
0.20849746465682983,
0.23553815484046936,
-0.39993005990982056,
-0.15571315586566925,
0.2346954196691513,
0.06604955345392227,
-0.16753250360488892,
0.6356667280197144,
-0.37772902846336365,
-0.3590162992477417,
-1.0817103385925293,
-0.2522931694984436,
-0.5410836338996887,
0.48563915491104126,
0.5036306381225586,
0.5762190818786621,
-0.1074228584766388,
0.24064630270004272,
0.6980084180831909,
-0.025533713400363922,
0.21417894959449768,
0.28855249285697937,
0.23506949841976166,
-0.7365683317184448,
0.584000289440155,
-0.11619963496923447,
0.2226913422346115,
0.20188117027282715,
0.5766452550888062,
-0.22796285152435303,
-0.7210237383842468,
-0.11451137065887451,
0.10503514111042023,
-0.3647642433643341,
-0.5118173956871033,
-0.8041453957557678,
-0.4479028880596161,
-0.5555994510650635,
0.22367820143699646,
-0.21284569799900055,
-0.4102221727371216,
-0.21710613369941711,
-0.01177722867578268,
0.44849395751953125,
0.3897032141685486,
-0.2590862810611725,
0.41879674792289734,
-0.8620217442512512,
0.3209189474582672,
0.21772801876068115,
0.6762248873710632,
-0.25308260321617126,
-0.5370566248893738,
0.0895596444606781,
-0.24178992211818695,
-0.13952551782131195,
-0.7561460733413696,
0.7377235889434814,
0.4742114543914795,
0.6380411982536316,
0.03871334716677666,
0.04218907654285431,
1.0273784399032593,
-0.20553624629974365,
0.4598047733306885,
0.3689780831336975,
-0.5190193057060242,
0.7140285968780518,
-0.4289606213569641,
0.4741716980934143,
0.8146815299987793,
0.5510433912277222,
-0.6304709911346436,
-0.34425169229507446,
-0.8523852825164795,
-0.4281960725784302,
1.1549867391586304,
0.28162023425102234,
-0.47248977422714233,
-0.07374976575374603,
0.3812355399131775,
0.15780477225780487,
0.20108242332935333,
-0.49588578939437866,
0.07066380232572556,
-0.055920470505952835,
-0.24687448143959045,
-0.017354033887386322,
-0.33514443039894104,
-0.5655027031898499,
-0.40380027890205383,
0.44751879572868347,
-0.08366352319717407,
0.26697012782096863,
0.6579226851463318,
-0.08511178195476532,
-0.6368759870529175,
0.3537445068359375,
0.47722893953323364,
0.6244956851005554,
-0.6282250881195068,
0.14901764690876007,
0.019383490085601807,
-0.9696919322013855,
-0.39668112993240356,
0.424037367105484,
0.4315393567085266,
-0.1263638287782669,
0.6672797799110413,
-0.12661036849021912,
0.1450922042131424,
-0.43415021896362305,
0.1326940804719925,
-0.3651718199253082,
-0.47393783926963806,
-0.1894649714231491,
-0.14028602838516235,
-0.21944619715213776,
0.008749499917030334,
0.5407606363296509,
0.16641953587532043,
0.57156902551651,
-0.7579461336135864,
0.258527547121048,
0.013496489264070988,
-0.6133049130439758,
-0.20803202688694,
0.05143158137798309,
0.029292862862348557,
0.042057253420352936,
0.7345139384269714,
-0.1469746232032776,
-0.3905090391635895,
0.515644371509552,
0.32612138986587524,
1.0062686204910278,
-0.3708655834197998,
0.5224000811576843,
0.7065779566764832,
0.32627400755882263,
-0.04242497310042381,
0.3874776065349579,
0.35315701365470886,
0.030058052390813828,
-0.45779114961624146,
-1.0203760862350464,
-0.1887403130531311,
0.32722100615501404,
-0.6051906943321228,
0.0900828093290329,
-0.9903324246406555,
-0.3526133596897125,
0.471866250038147,
0.14218230545520782,
-0.279928058385849,
0.5663334131240845,
0.07545856386423111,
0.7285630702972412,
-0.3847123086452484,
0.47411611676216125,
0.6648733615875244,
-0.10962343961000443,
-0.8679420351982117,
0.016194265335798264,
0.6011067628860474,
-0.2623494863510132,
0.5367906093597412,
0.09108655899763107,
-0.15160894393920898,
-0.14749778807163239,
-0.06877662986516953,
-0.9180304408073425,
1.0457794666290283,
0.08868782967329025,
-0.24609538912773132,
-0.13336189091205597,
0.10766420513391495,
0.7601047158241272,
-0.41169196367263794,
-0.045897237956523895,
0.31736457347869873,
0.28219637274742126,
0.28153571486473083,
-1.5012719631195068,
0.000507625809404999,
-0.18598739802837372,
-0.49841219186782837,
0.4164182245731354,
-0.17749424278736115,
0.5416974425315857,
0.29958316683769226,
-0.5380070805549622,
0.22022143006324768,
-0.2167162001132965,
0.09210150688886642,
0.6944467425346375,
0.3248119652271271,
0.7239026427268982,
0.701671302318573,
-0.3233121633529663,
1.3278298377990723,
0.12624624371528625,
-0.20166254043579102,
0.8724738955497742,
-0.07808995991945267,
0.7256826162338257,
0.35227182507514954,
-0.257772833108902,
0.7167652249336243,
0.6516705751419067,
0.35661351680755615,
0.40565258264541626,
-0.08757469803094864,
-0.05381700024008751,
-0.41519638895988464,
-0.09953414648771286,
-0.3992312252521515,
0.42279815673828125,
0.5599912405014038,
-0.4847257137298584,
-0.2928667962551117,
-0.15894001722335815,
-0.006732566747814417,
-0.0367874801158905,
-0.349971204996109,
0.9407683610916138,
-0.20017683506011963,
-0.7618898153305054,
0.26415279507637024,
-0.15211395919322968,
0.31658127903938293,
-0.7278043031692505,
-0.13281552493572235,
0.025561995804309845,
0.00893391203135252,
-0.6440276503562927,
-1.0750166177749634,
0.8362219333648682,
0.13164660334587097,
-0.25046613812446594,
-0.13842818140983582,
0.8004506230354309,
0.06944983452558517,
-0.7446688413619995,
-0.26850783824920654,
0.37379035353660583,
-0.02478635683655739,
-0.2409389466047287,
-0.2776414155960083,
0.05551253259181976,
0.09035845100879669,
0.2350948005914688,
0.46986767649650574,
0.3374892473220825,
-0.11584151536226273,
0.5501741170883179,
0.8690439462661743,
0.4302503168582916,
-0.1575106829404831,
-0.07210368663072586,
0.7903504967689514,
-0.6358612179756165,
-0.31489843130111694,
-0.35488325357437134,
0.6046743392944336,
-0.47209465503692627,
-0.6302717328071594,
0.47641000151634216,
0.48278123140335083,
0.5695061087608337,
0.05764543637633324,
0.3143555223941803,
-0.3820013701915741,
1.041323184967041,
-0.5178350210189819,
0.7009099125862122,
-0.35719209909439087,
0.4260633885860443,
-0.3730749785900116,
-0.5001204013824463,
-0.6905630230903625,
0.280661016702652,
-0.5207129120826721,
-0.08318672329187393,
0.9679294228553772,
0.22149913012981415,
-0.16637761890888214,
0.00989180151373148,
-0.09889198839664459,
0.120948925614357,
0.013062166050076485,
0.35027197003364563,
0.26543623208999634,
-0.35263097286224365,
0.6125648021697998,
-0.8017216920852661,
-0.34610074758529663,
0.004951094277203083,
-0.6848950982093811,
-0.48982739448547363,
-0.6218588352203369,
-0.6096804141998291,
-0.3558511435985565,
0.0769217237830162,
0.5535482168197632,
0.8956538438796997,
-0.6927070021629333,
-0.23887912929058075,
0.04708583280444145,
0.1573243886232376,
-0.3102400600910187,
-0.2603118419647217,
0.34883615374565125,
-0.1360354721546173,
-0.46638789772987366,
0.35324135422706604,
0.5330783128738403,
-0.29178136587142944,
0.2512228786945343,
0.25337737798690796,
-0.4679972231388092,
-0.7843580842018127,
0.5033988952636719,
0.6401639580726624,
-0.6772382259368896,
-0.08215393871068954,
0.09014412015676498,
0.01968764327466488,
-0.028711311519145966,
0.6639907956123352,
-0.6492639780044556,
0.7345947027206421,
0.36625027656555176,
0.3125576078891754,
0.46908512711524963,
-0.24336610734462738,
0.7169776558876038,
-0.5207279324531555,
-0.38045936822891235,
0.5146331787109375,
-0.10235194861888885,
0.07728588581085205,
-0.6787614226341248,
0.5772225856781006,
0.38209155201911926,
-0.3967024087905884,
-0.9755339026451111,
0.10161084681749344,
-1.2181665897369385,
-0.04456762596964836,
0.8038243055343628,
0.15934263169765472,
-0.35506731271743774,
-0.375732958316803,
-0.15447647869586945,
0.3822675943374634,
-0.2555055022239685,
0.7465969920158386,
0.43188369274139404,
-0.67513507604599,
-0.7056425213813782,
-0.5773318409919739,
1.0219753980636597,
-0.08422545343637466,
-0.9758856296539307,
-0.18562284111976624,
0.4954341650009155,
0.6259045004844666,
0.2878558039665222,
0.3880790174007416,
-0.8059008121490479,
0.946983814239502,
-0.45412400364875793,
-0.26102814078330994,
0.07751256227493286,
0.12207859754562378,
-0.28309863805770874,
0.2899002730846405,
-0.003760453313589096,
0.32789427042007446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14039v1
|
Trajectory Volatility for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-05-22T22:22:25 | 2024-05-22T22:22:25 |
Yiming Wang, Pei Zhang, Baosong Yang, Derek F. Wong, Zhuosheng Zhang, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Real-world data deviating from the independent and identically distributed
(i.i.d.) assumption of in-distribution training data poses security threats to
deep networks, thus advancing out-of-distribution (OOD) detection algorithms.
Detection methods in generative language models (GLMs) mainly focus on
uncertainty estimation and embedding distance measurement, with the latter
proven to be most effective in traditional linguistic tasks like summarization
and translation. However, another complex generative scenario mathematical
reasoning poses significant challenges to embedding-based methods due to its
high-density feature of output spaces, but this feature causes larger
discrepancies in the embedding shift trajectory between different samples in
latent spaces. Hence, we propose a trajectory-based method TV score, which uses
trajectory volatility for OOD detection in mathematical reasoning. Experiments
show that our method outperforms all traditional algorithms on GLMs under
mathematical reasoning scenarios and can be extended to more applications with
high-density features in output spaces, such as multiple-choice questions.
|
[
-0.2543608248233795,
-0.9397350549697876,
0.6956642270088196,
-0.11488310247659683,
-0.36885881423950195,
0.04015013203024864,
0.18325014412403107,
0.041339389979839325,
-0.05788637697696686,
0.6001203656196594,
-0.6299653053283691,
-0.6814256906509399,
-0.5203895568847656,
-0.6394255757331848,
-0.40211978554725647,
0.6046373844146729,
-0.18645243346691132,
-0.12765662372112274,
-0.41026511788368225,
-0.302207350730896,
-0.6166290044784546,
-0.5004608631134033,
-0.1625005006790161,
-0.07349143177270889,
-0.072254978120327,
0.07922975718975067,
0.7358593940734863,
0.5815155506134033,
0.761116087436676,
0.1853543370962143,
0.04633193463087082,
0.3051236867904663,
-0.39350926876068115,
0.5704909563064575,
-0.004060438368469477,
-0.5247199535369873,
0.05988152697682381,
-0.36439183354377747,
0.5856851935386658,
0.5083599090576172,
-0.3805599510669708,
-0.07014811038970947,
-0.26071301102638245,
0.6042811274528503,
-0.7561928033828735,
-0.029131455346941948,
-0.292160302400589,
0.2094065248966217,
-0.33330827951431274,
-0.44061896204948425,
-0.3862144947052002,
-0.588720977306366,
0.03162674978375435,
-0.46517905592918396,
0.07692382484674454,
-0.052457232028245926,
0.6338412165641785,
0.3876456320285797,
-0.4537295997142792,
-0.5336316823959351,
-1.13113534450531,
0.8241966366767883,
-0.41995012760162354,
0.39650464057922363,
0.5062720775604248,
0.7215936779975891,
-0.428598552942276,
-0.2141527682542801,
-0.3072934150695801,
-0.2492295205593109,
0.4194931089878082,
0.1280071884393692,
-0.14499376714229584,
-0.35403531789779663,
0.25741299986839294,
0.1992041915655136,
-0.6457134485244751,
0.06514038890600204,
0.12388644367456436,
0.06114537641406059,
0.735649049282074,
0.32534924149513245,
0.056080665439367294,
-0.007621845696121454,
0.03135165572166443,
-0.2694140672683716,
-0.7733505964279175,
0.1105038970708847,
0.9854902029037476,
0.16851261258125305,
-0.124723419547081,
0.8273064494132996,
0.1089576780796051,
0.44265666604042053,
-0.19444261491298676,
0.1490454375743866,
0.16623830795288086,
-0.4203774631023407,
-0.016357850283384323,
0.011510839685797691,
0.6503729224205017,
0.22668813169002533,
0.06341338902711868,
0.18655309081077576,
0.019134361296892166,
-0.10745671391487122,
0.014492405578494072,
-0.7567658424377441,
-0.23992356657981873,
0.05070088431239128,
-0.2901715040206909,
-0.07114142924547195,
0.16785217821598053,
-1.1833604574203491,
-0.6281443238258362,
0.1249118372797966,
0.29904744029045105,
-0.6985473036766052,
-0.29486414790153503,
0.35546427965164185,
-0.07299742102622986,
0.09672412276268005,
0.44905802607536316,
-0.7915548086166382,
-0.05583629757165909,
0.5023952126502991,
1.0351117849349976,
-0.04650997370481491,
0.16229777038097382,
-0.930998682975769,
-0.11098989099264145,
-0.5314681529998779,
0.6286584734916687,
-0.5898596048355103,
-0.5170813798904419,
0.2270013839006424,
-0.5536090731620789,
0.2222941368818283,
-0.3967495262622833,
0.34642860293388367,
-0.5403516292572021,
0.25043123960494995,
-0.17655599117279053,
-0.7478898763656616,
-0.24636223912239075,
0.08951658010482788,
-0.30247172713279724,
1.255922555923462,
0.2870255410671234,
-0.5267648696899414,
0.6713996529579163,
-0.8028332591056824,
-0.36119604110717773,
0.06707620620727539,
-0.2676263451576233,
-0.84132319688797,
0.09209170192480087,
0.4526746869087219,
0.28513652086257935,
-0.04323989897966385,
0.1800210028886795,
-0.5885262489318848,
-0.4081796407699585,
0.2780693769454956,
-0.9925457239151001,
0.9343120455741882,
0.044394899159669876,
-0.4311099946498871,
-0.03856518492102623,
-0.7349705696105957,
-0.16801974177360535,
0.09978582710027695,
-0.13011468946933746,
-0.5150076746940613,
0.35036471486091614,
-0.481399267911911,
0.0901678130030632,
-0.11764717847108841,
-0.33284279704093933,
0.38180088996887207,
-0.6028928160667419,
0.3316168785095215,
0.6649566888809204,
0.24229967594146729,
0.6000243425369263,
-0.0373249426484108,
0.760836660861969,
0.222858726978302,
0.21281787753105164,
-0.015026241540908813,
-0.8903558254241943,
-0.27380993962287903,
-0.3722165524959564,
-0.12291428446769714,
0.6625733971595764,
-0.8327093124389648,
0.802717924118042,
-0.30711662769317627,
-0.3818989396095276,
-0.24407297372817993,
-0.02927306480705738,
0.031246725469827652,
0.35011541843414307,
0.2654694616794586,
0.058356452733278275,
-0.26686960458755493,
-0.022839203476905823,
-0.14409871399402618,
-0.07349835336208344,
0.1813025027513504,
0.004917290527373552,
0.7072978019714355,
-0.08123594522476196,
1.0797593593597412,
-0.7164751291275024,
-0.28800514340400696,
-0.12493970990180969,
0.13648028671741486,
0.15037377178668976,
0.23307928442955017,
0.6708287596702576,
-0.7758129835128784,
-0.3858011066913605,
0.08596069365739822,
-0.8537536859512329,
0.20670118927955627,
-0.07899542897939682,
-0.22296680510044098,
-0.04108036682009697,
0.5627314448356628,
-0.5879175662994385,
1.235964059829712,
0.2890213131904602,
-0.4706035256385803,
0.26355984807014465,
-0.5320015549659729,
0.18658003211021423,
-0.9681205153465271,
-0.44470298290252686,
0.14817510545253754,
-0.24080969393253326,
-0.36201006174087524,
-0.15462550520896912,
-0.34262633323669434,
0.12942980229854584,
-0.41496434807777405,
0.24895411729812622,
0.008703931234776974,
-0.31184256076812744,
0.12724848091602325,
0.28995200991630554,
-0.058145634829998016,
0.060488540679216385,
-0.23937757313251495,
0.7679649591445923,
0.7331098914146423,
-0.7109814882278442,
0.7859088182449341,
0.2306867390871048,
-0.7359570264816284,
0.6651924848556519,
-0.24329181015491486,
-0.10254918783903122,
-0.4398287534713745,
0.11656375229358673,
-1.3000094890594482,
0.05642697960138321,
0.5961396098136902,
-0.45697498321533203,
-0.1702568084001541,
-0.22100025415420532,
-0.6176665425300598,
-0.23965342342853546,
-0.2380058616399765,
0.4719364643096924,
0.5810822248458862,
-0.5643161535263062,
0.5331174731254578,
0.20370908081531525,
0.36443209648132324,
-0.5221130847930908,
-0.7284195423126221,
-0.4920983910560608,
-0.5394103527069092,
-0.5455403923988342,
0.006957705598324537,
-0.0844162106513977,
-0.4779897928237915,
0.17781566083431244,
0.1613551825284958,
-0.10859206318855286,
0.08235576003789902,
0.2518949508666992,
0.01435836497694254,
-0.25754597783088684,
0.29445064067840576,
0.307221919298172,
0.02012612484395504,
0.24448160827159882,
-0.3539365828037262,
0.6199167966842651,
0.21448831260204315,
-0.9756990075111389,
-0.15665796399116516,
0.5943316221237183,
0.5720898509025574,
-0.11985325813293457,
0.6669861674308777,
0.5686608552932739,
-0.38056281208992004,
-0.3955695927143097,
0.06967562437057495,
-0.03846566751599312,
-0.4234987199306488,
0.5117043852806091,
-0.23584920167922974,
-0.2952183187007904,
0.6396414637565613,
-0.01924651861190796,
-0.016678903251886368,
0.46941718459129333,
0.7486429810523987,
-0.21457968652248383,
1.2916654348373413,
0.16910633444786072,
0.2086998075246811,
0.6589661836624146,
-0.6468804478645325,
0.5052308440208435,
-0.46767154335975647,
-0.18328168988227844,
-0.2904931306838989,
-0.10104354470968246,
-0.33859696984291077,
-0.45809492468833923,
0.47706013917922974,
0.14846786856651306,
-0.27244555950164795,
0.12364242970943451,
-0.46945443749427795,
0.3650205731391907,
0.5645313262939453,
0.04940006881952286,
0.11733922362327576,
0.03666708990931511,
-0.020187534391880035,
-0.16408854722976685,
-0.3512718379497528,
-0.00540839834138751,
1.0991967916488647,
0.08416876941919327,
0.5828295946121216,
0.5856737494468689,
0.5723052620887756,
0.46815112233161926,
0.0975860059261322,
-0.7321392893791199,
0.35203465819358826,
-0.16937853395938873,
-0.3261597156524658,
-0.7554363012313843,
-0.5941538214683533,
-0.9587438702583313,
0.21586385369300842,
0.07171416282653809,
-0.7957746982574463,
0.324720561504364,
0.07610253244638443,
-0.5190111994743347,
0.45369386672973633,
-0.32393398880958557,
0.6859472393989563,
-0.16595235466957092,
0.012279716320335865,
-0.04637995362281799,
-0.3260200023651123,
0.1878436952829361,
0.09917318820953369,
0.30810537934303284,
-0.2108529955148697,
0.3188640773296356,
0.32711753249168396,
-0.7170288562774658,
0.5523146390914917,
-0.3607441186904907,
-0.14765223860740662,
0.7088934779167175,
0.21311219036579132,
0.720342755317688,
0.4193281829357147,
-0.12170497328042984,
0.11165842413902283,
-0.21977289021015167,
-0.05101636052131653,
-0.7908808588981628,
0.4527282118797302,
-0.6537638306617737,
-0.22490637004375458,
-0.6139562129974365,
-0.6460345387458801,
-0.12022595852613449,
-0.0878738984465599,
0.8523203730583191,
0.490493506193161,
0.2733956277370453,
0.3134665787220001,
0.6833580732345581,
-0.044278375804424286,
0.5568798184394836,
-0.00017634150572121143,
-0.4815695285797119,
-0.425527423620224,
0.9106959104537964,
0.24671399593353271,
0.27648594975471497,
0.594091534614563,
0.571550190448761,
-0.777885377407074,
-0.4009649157524109,
-0.598236083984375,
-0.11855198442935944,
-1.0729581117630005,
-0.11768496781587601,
-0.2058958262205124,
-0.14175015687942505,
-0.2966378629207611,
-0.254854679107666,
-0.3595346510410309,
-0.010152284987270832,
-0.5059154629707336,
-0.0923515036702156,
0.6875722408294678,
0.5103188157081604,
-0.034087955951690674,
0.21700331568717957,
-0.4454828202724457,
0.13853423297405243,
0.18605780601501465,
0.14755471050739288,
-0.36453336477279663,
-0.8737980127334595,
-0.1652849167585373,
0.32532817125320435,
-0.5162704586982727,
-0.7412203550338745,
0.6516682505607605,
0.0654265284538269,
0.4341694414615631,
0.4573831558227539,
0.08202514052391052,
0.7233034372329712,
-0.19479608535766602,
0.7928625345230103,
0.23611128330230713,
-0.9556397795677185,
0.6762701869010925,
-0.2702959477901459,
0.08019600063562393,
0.12076439708471298,
0.2233116179704666,
0.026178918778896332,
-0.20860831439495087,
-0.33313947916030884,
-0.49523764848709106,
0.3832661211490631,
0.27648332715034485,
0.10845465213060379,
0.09309038519859314,
0.29268595576286316,
0.2111392319202423,
0.2997629642486572,
-0.2592398524284363,
-0.35520151257514954,
-0.2882518470287323,
-0.2995721101760864,
-0.10415932536125183,
0.11385805904865265,
0.004500575829297304,
-0.3284223675727844,
0.28449124097824097,
-0.203934907913208,
0.36770591139793396,
-0.04928639903664589,
0.09052213281393051,
-0.33974987268447876,
-0.10078418254852295,
0.8986384272575378,
0.6148685216903687,
-0.29692959785461426,
-0.09669224172830582,
-0.09483414143323898,
-0.6742764711380005,
0.4007072150707245,
0.02904629521071911,
-0.261916846036911,
0.23678964376449585,
0.24010680615901947,
0.8959168791770935,
-0.12744854390621185,
-0.6488672494888306,
0.8817844390869141,
0.03788022696971893,
-0.2963784635066986,
-0.6358373165130615,
-0.17008058726787567,
-0.28228721022605896,
0.2949173152446747,
0.2262430489063263,
0.4069959223270416,
0.1751914918422699,
-0.40225544571876526,
0.17435915768146515,
0.43952009081840515,
-0.511235773563385,
-0.3244931995868683,
0.6654789447784424,
-0.36409857869148254,
-0.3537360727787018,
0.730300784111023,
-0.6233087182044983,
-0.11648224294185638,
0.6539149284362793,
0.13432393968105316,
0.9666546583175659,
-0.28422811627388,
0.5349081754684448,
-0.16642704606056213,
0.1303514689207077,
-0.22017993032932281,
0.556499719619751,
0.18892024457454681,
-0.849780797958374,
-0.5907970070838928,
-0.2284589260816574,
-0.23923657834529877,
0.03909755125641823,
-0.6374359726905823,
0.4758908450603485,
-0.43426135182380676,
-0.14457568526268005,
-0.0816284716129303,
-0.3243933916091919,
-0.6387219429016113,
-0.015126192942261696,
-0.016682974994182587,
0.20443449914455414,
-0.7979896068572998,
0.7331904172897339,
0.33490610122680664,
-0.38890984654426575,
-0.35251861810684204,
0.15522105991840363,
-0.14094272255897522,
-0.6574784517288208,
0.7237390279769897,
0.027626067399978638,
-0.09949936717748642,
-0.1449338048696518,
-0.2942952811717987,
-1.0415374040603638,
0.9512389898300171,
0.82981938123703,
-0.48537030816078186,
0.09661798179149628,
0.2684588134288788,
0.3641999363899231,
-0.233013316988945,
0.23111309111118317,
0.32323697209358215,
0.14382921159267426,
0.5122920274734497,
-0.2700313329696655,
-0.415650874376297,
0.29687848687171936,
-0.030546439811587334,
0.7247216105461121,
-0.06222684308886528,
1.0772600173950195,
-0.32073092460632324,
-0.07326875627040863,
-0.10477835685014725,
0.5679466128349304,
0.2720883786678314,
0.5289178490638733,
0.35530900955200195,
0.6119197607040405,
0.8049067258834839,
-0.26121583580970764,
1.1097899675369263,
0.16953732073307037,
0.6832027435302734,
0.7580686211585999,
-0.40913233160972595,
0.8242534399032593,
0.3276096284389496,
-0.3492715656757355,
0.6461772322654724,
0.38509365916252136,
0.16447655856609344,
1.0348305702209473,
0.38321593403816223,
-0.1756463199853897,
-0.3925262689590454,
0.2734222710132599,
-0.35580259561538696,
0.4362576901912689,
0.7267566919326782,
-0.1475023776292801,
-0.39450910687446594,
0.43783336877822876,
-0.11507086455821991,
0.20032182335853577,
-0.15606999397277832,
0.3854387700557709,
0.008933628909289837,
-0.3573017716407776,
0.42754900455474854,
-0.23106952011585236,
0.17944321036338806,
-0.44850748777389526,
-0.38338834047317505,
-0.1706065684556961,
0.4343922734260559,
0.14039506018161774,
-1.0004197359085083,
0.5370475649833679,
-0.39730367064476013,
-0.02176009491086006,
-0.01962396316230297,
0.1855592578649521,
-0.2563778758049011,
-0.5660162568092346,
0.1917581856250763,
0.32859179377555847,
0.04601406306028366,
-0.221720889210701,
-0.4438466429710388,
-0.023911811411380768,
-0.30560368299484253,
-0.20620989799499512,
0.22490888833999634,
0.8628939390182495,
-0.22448915243148804,
0.8615782260894775,
0.7727675437927246,
0.056427303701639175,
0.48211848735809326,
0.13853147625923157,
0.5775566101074219,
-0.25830984115600586,
-0.9143852591514587,
-1.1220942735671997,
0.4607571065425873,
-0.08993934839963913,
-0.7044951915740967,
0.8460623621940613,
0.27282559871673584,
0.6535234451293945,
-0.06578446924686432,
0.8228892087936401,
0.20108668506145477,
0.2535947263240814,
-0.6930617690086365,
0.12012632191181183,
-0.44812890887260437,
0.3471800684928894,
-0.10028716176748276,
-0.8500464558601379,
-0.5896584391593933,
0.6836155652999878,
-0.7181946635246277,
0.02930689975619316,
0.74300217628479,
0.45750823616981506,
0.052525829523801804,
-0.07267393171787262,
0.5833967924118042,
-0.2672736346721649,
0.7899174094200134,
0.5618009567260742,
0.91877681016922,
-0.5538983941078186,
0.7419581413269043,
-0.2441699057817459,
0.09778857231140137,
-0.5946982502937317,
-0.963158369064331,
-0.9543890953063965,
-0.4994250237941742,
-0.5750724673271179,
-0.575019359588623,
0.019123418256640434,
0.7041386961936951,
0.6402513980865479,
-0.8838793039321899,
0.09561505168676376,
-0.7643862366676331,
0.23349200189113617,
-0.8036397099494934,
-0.2876526713371277,
0.5163731575012207,
0.18219684064388275,
-0.4938029944896698,
0.35814741253852844,
0.66324383020401,
0.08817259967327118,
-0.6721495389938354,
-0.14716510474681854,
-0.04061579331755638,
0.1721838116645813,
0.3800595998764038,
0.10566970705986023,
-0.685950517654419,
-0.5829779505729675,
-0.03313451260328293,
0.07508756965398788,
0.16828753054141998,
0.6593298316001892,
-0.49400594830513,
0.6089888215065002,
0.7191613912582397,
0.5232451558113098,
0.23257845640182495,
-0.028134513646364212,
0.31754395365715027,
-0.9756158590316772,
0.2618066668510437,
0.42004093527793884,
0.3758831024169922,
0.14917688071727753,
-0.6804919838905334,
0.20314902067184448,
0.5896149277687073,
-0.5422528982162476,
-0.9733155369758606,
0.42441433668136597,
-0.572493314743042,
0.029483798891305923,
1.1591335535049438,
-0.24986135959625244,
-0.03160426765680313,
-0.2580766975879669,
-0.012157796882092953,
0.03461626544594765,
-0.5945571064949036,
0.5935055017471313,
0.6195166110992432,
0.0008194862166419625,
-0.18578460812568665,
-0.6705004572868347,
0.31710538268089294,
0.023095184937119484,
-0.9310994744300842,
-0.18292562663555145,
0.1937320977449417,
-0.13186043500900269,
0.33708280324935913,
0.24785679578781128,
0.08260595053434372,
0.26893389225006104,
0.19054646790027618,
-0.3990371525287628,
0.07747788727283478,
-0.3128384053707123,
-0.32187992334365845,
0.380038857460022,
-0.3661171495914459,
-0.7882188558578491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14030v1
|
Refining Skewed Perceptions in Vision-Language Models through Visual Representations
| 2024-05-22T22:03:11 | 2024-05-22T22:03:11 |
Haocheng Dai, Sarang Joshi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Large vision-language models (VLMs), such as CLIP, have become foundational,
demonstrating remarkable success across a variety of downstream tasks. Despite
their advantages, these models, akin to other foundational systems, inherit
biases from the disproportionate distribution of real-world data, leading to
misconceptions about the actual environment. Prevalent datasets like ImageNet
are often riddled with non-causal, spurious correlations that can diminish VLM
performance in scenarios where these contextual elements are absent. This study
presents an investigation into how a simple linear probe can effectively
distill task-specific core features from CLIP's embedding for downstream
applications. Our analysis reveals that the CLIP text representations are often
tainted by spurious correlations, inherited in the biased pre-training dataset.
Empirical evidence suggests that relying on visual representations from CLIP,
as opposed to text embedding, is more practical to refine the skewed
perceptions in VLMs, emphasizing the superior utility of visual representations
in overcoming embedded biases. Our codes will be available here.
|
[
-0.45488426089286804,
-0.4608357846736908,
0.6268764734268188,
0.20661550760269165,
-0.5348581671714783,
0.11150439083576202,
-0.1633894145488739,
-0.3752930760383606,
0.3857981562614441,
0.5971022248268127,
-0.4131146967411041,
-0.3552815914154053,
-0.708274781703949,
-0.2264726758003235,
-0.5596449375152588,
0.9032958745956421,
0.01964411325752735,
0.2938963770866394,
-0.45917508006095886,
-0.3759709596633911,
-0.512877345085144,
-0.714377760887146,
-0.019681379199028015,
-0.285077840089798,
0.43188440799713135,
0.13659605383872986,
0.6735461354255676,
0.702276885509491,
0.3590371310710907,
0.09205957502126694,
0.003358348272740841,
-0.03899601846933365,
-0.8529659509658813,
0.07720055431127548,
-0.33821457624435425,
-0.5815479159355164,
0.131465345621109,
0.03984120115637779,
0.5104156732559204,
0.6467340588569641,
0.1936255842447281,
0.2692764699459076,
0.3847549855709076,
0.5652991533279419,
-0.9872353672981262,
0.1744566261768341,
-0.7703746557235718,
0.1324671506881714,
-0.24648863077163696,
-0.20034092664718628,
-0.5195527672767639,
-0.004107281100004911,
0.6591478586196899,
-0.6583771705627441,
0.3605222702026367,
0.12253442406654358,
1.0586249828338623,
0.35247448086738586,
-0.3739348351955414,
-0.21449501812458038,
-0.7722921371459961,
0.9349544644355774,
-0.5377321839332581,
0.25512903928756714,
0.12076128274202347,
0.20596376061439514,
0.2926740348339081,
-0.6402868628501892,
-0.2943592071533203,
-0.07316301763057709,
-0.015805894508957863,
0.1374204307794571,
-0.030015435069799423,
-0.2144625335931778,
0.34712183475494385,
0.13100665807724,
-0.1431693434715271,
-0.09054386615753174,
-0.5006470084190369,
-0.20118501782417297,
0.3578515648841858,
0.15789000689983368,
0.1702376902103424,
-0.1266745626926422,
-0.6582806706428528,
-0.5449386239051819,
-0.8382241129875183,
0.11650429666042328,
0.08931618928909302,
0.2044057548046112,
0.0038909316062927246,
0.5975028276443481,
0.08856094628572464,
0.5075303912162781,
0.18041054904460907,
0.031419701874256134,
0.3828545808792114,
-0.1203312948346138,
-0.2243252843618393,
-0.09197600185871124,
0.5740729570388794,
0.6612697243690491,
0.3522912561893463,
0.051703184843063354,
-0.16050976514816284,
0.21657750010490417,
0.5769941210746765,
-0.5686913132667542,
-0.37713125348091125,
-0.08228198438882828,
-0.40145811438560486,
-0.46599048376083374,
0.11851553618907928,
-0.9092382788658142,
-0.4850844144821167,
-0.4802226722240448,
0.5560166835784912,
-0.45215362310409546,
-0.08544349670410156,
-0.12100741267204285,
-0.5545880198478699,
0.2567583918571472,
0.4873552620410919,
-0.5643498301506042,
-0.04283200204372406,
0.46442878246307373,
0.876274585723877,
-0.3402568995952606,
-0.26318269968032837,
-0.4449273347854614,
0.07703355699777603,
-0.3209908604621887,
0.6915165185928345,
-0.6527769565582275,
-0.3612743616104126,
0.18819227814674377,
-0.055963240563869476,
0.14779874682426453,
-0.6364188194274902,
0.22431859374046326,
-0.2843260169029236,
-0.16743043065071106,
-0.6889804601669312,
-0.21732251346111298,
-0.15672998130321503,
0.1627461165189743,
-0.7342802882194519,
1.0895700454711914,
-0.12112559378147125,
-0.8353853225708008,
0.7649498581886292,
-0.07853881269693375,
-0.2644335925579071,
-0.13310129940509796,
-0.5602413415908813,
-0.30335748195648193,
0.363473117351532,
0.671562910079956,
0.43665754795074463,
-0.061401043087244034,
0.13822083175182343,
-0.5952070355415344,
-0.382576584815979,
0.001137089915573597,
-0.460898756980896,
0.5020840764045715,
-0.13983049988746643,
-0.5027555823326111,
-0.05156497657299042,
-0.512596070766449,
-0.08033094555139542,
0.05750980228185654,
0.21111686527729034,
-1.0363295078277588,
0.2781302034854889,
0.0973125621676445,
0.14864349365234375,
0.06732404977083206,
-0.4206741154193878,
0.10215780884027481,
-0.17257952690124512,
0.21777373552322388,
0.9276298880577087,
-0.13573889434337616,
0.6497544050216675,
-0.015039317309856415,
0.31644052267074585,
0.5308719873428345,
0.3079691231250763,
-0.27651259303092957,
-0.4156273901462555,
-0.8858092427253723,
-0.20813602209091187,
-0.14344556629657745,
0.35025110840797424,
-1.1475919485092163,
-0.2834925353527069,
-0.42195847630500793,
-0.26875004172325134,
-0.3551636338233948,
0.23935090005397797,
0.40011388063430786,
0.5914351940155029,
0.34409743547439575,
-0.3918597400188446,
-0.4283123016357422,
-1.1480309963226318,
-0.30802667140960693,
0.02525671012699604,
0.08617706596851349,
0.4383513927459717,
0.5167996287345886,
-0.10733014345169067,
1.2068085670471191,
-0.6836294531822205,
-0.2391374707221985,
-0.21698029339313507,
0.14404138922691345,
-0.038000110536813736,
0.30244988203048706,
0.8757193088531494,
-0.8645274043083191,
-0.4457826316356659,
-0.2602817416191101,
-0.7639893293380737,
-0.10504172742366791,
-0.22507797181606293,
-0.32854554057121277,
-0.27884766459465027,
0.4431845247745514,
-0.10644340515136719,
0.9004788398742676,
0.6074571013450623,
-0.31231576204299927,
0.7168179154396057,
0.011696741916239262,
-0.08456739783287048,
-0.6201714277267456,
-0.020213240757584572,
0.18077349662780762,
-0.3884350657463074,
-0.4154641032218933,
-0.00107008486520499,
0.12132531404495239,
-0.09984511137008667,
-0.5421304106712341,
0.2600795328617096,
-0.6943153738975525,
-0.2469988316297531,
-0.19267538189888,
0.2243647277355194,
0.39994561672210693,
0.4577685594558716,
0.2379770576953888,
0.9316847324371338,
0.700146496295929,
-0.668403148651123,
-0.008836645632982254,
0.23507975041866302,
-0.3289499878883362,
0.6094899773597717,
-0.7176828384399414,
-0.19222025573253632,
-0.4192931652069092,
0.08237618207931519,
-0.6297770738601685,
0.08073583245277405,
0.05198530852794647,
-0.042781371623277664,
0.13592267036437988,
-0.29013845324516296,
-0.09725523740053177,
-0.2553865909576416,
-0.47341716289520264,
0.49636349081993103,
0.579163670539856,
-0.788099467754364,
0.4816436469554901,
0.38396409153938293,
0.2886987328529358,
-0.8050021529197693,
-0.9425942301750183,
-0.14446933567523956,
-0.14543095231056213,
-0.3589119613170624,
0.24759750068187714,
0.4144417941570282,
-0.15304796397686005,
0.006814441177994013,
-0.31449759006500244,
-0.0906454548239708,
-0.24594175815582275,
0.4987989068031311,
0.5277301073074341,
-0.3423808813095093,
0.020652346312999725,
-0.06828382611274719,
0.24893492460250854,
0.043157853186130524,
-0.36828821897506714,
0.42797014117240906,
0.0055885412730276585,
-0.6714030504226685,
-0.00072603760054335,
0.29834240674972534,
0.8623238205909729,
-0.2178959846496582,
0.6490628719329834,
0.46733736991882324,
-0.025368988513946533,
-0.5234344005584717,
-0.504961371421814,
-0.12515215575695038,
-0.45126038789749146,
0.43568041920661926,
-0.060144662857055664,
-0.8288566470146179,
0.5198692679405212,
-0.16624167561531067,
-0.11982602626085281,
0.25324946641921997,
0.30624890327453613,
-0.2809772789478302,
0.8371086716651917,
0.7858406901359558,
-0.06831415742635727,
0.8144290447235107,
-0.3647858202457428,
0.2562587261199951,
-1.070643424987793,
-0.2509317696094513,
-0.09467796236276627,
-0.2696842849254608,
-0.1633870005607605,
-0.7336251139640808,
0.5040745139122009,
0.17098625004291534,
0.055703304708004,
0.3000990152359009,
-0.45079195499420166,
0.3348568379878998,
0.5224388837814331,
0.36955520510673523,
-0.03950509801506996,
0.2224765568971634,
-0.4772160053253174,
-0.3203924894332886,
-0.6040374040603638,
-0.5597764849662781,
1.1249103546142578,
0.34167957305908203,
1.0398280620574951,
-0.4035728871822357,
0.38526514172554016,
0.3114137649536133,
0.23691146075725555,
-0.6937421560287476,
0.33608487248420715,
-0.2542443573474884,
-0.352976530790329,
-0.036432407796382904,
-0.07948978990316391,
-0.4720880091190338,
0.503879189491272,
-0.2046084851026535,
-0.8882989287376404,
0.7209826111793518,
0.5798866152763367,
-0.03421253710985184,
0.36430612206459045,
-0.7986170053482056,
0.715528130531311,
-0.24180027842521667,
-0.6200883388519287,
-0.08374951034784317,
-0.3262920081615448,
0.4234524667263031,
0.14704911410808563,
0.017065634950995445,
0.018938777968287468,
0.13904084265232086,
0.47947725653648376,
-0.6141073107719421,
1.1027135848999023,
-0.23175546526908875,
0.011333132162690163,
0.40677767992019653,
0.06831533461809158,
0.5002868175506592,
0.02729382924735546,
0.16475015878677368,
0.3298119008541107,
0.09720341116189957,
-0.40757137537002563,
-0.8663226366043091,
0.5141396522521973,
-0.5474567413330078,
-0.5278019309043884,
-0.29033154249191284,
-0.20103470981121063,
-0.38331225514411926,
0.08804315328598022,
0.4276270866394043,
0.8166017532348633,
-0.13970130681991577,
0.2899262011051178,
0.6974985003471375,
-0.2974545359611511,
0.21958796679973602,
0.025580385699868202,
-0.5487400889396667,
-0.0838705450296402,
0.8793174028396606,
-0.036607056856155396,
0.4654616713523865,
0.25449690222740173,
0.055432260036468506,
-0.12261607497930527,
-0.4434700906276703,
-0.3634265661239624,
0.03169214352965355,
-0.8775697946548462,
-0.031972404569387436,
-0.36226144433021545,
-0.04149949178099632,
-0.17412583529949188,
-0.2423611879348755,
-0.6404222249984741,
-0.07873716950416565,
-0.4521327614784241,
-0.04737621545791626,
0.28631383180618286,
0.8648555874824524,
0.20927651226520538,
0.43492376804351807,
-0.5406917333602905,
0.20428280532360077,
0.2540852725505829,
0.30370110273361206,
0.31848499178886414,
-0.282674640417099,
-0.40162456035614014,
0.3151549696922302,
-0.26946017146110535,
-0.8071459531784058,
0.5102400183677673,
0.24103562533855438,
0.5869480967521667,
0.6955747008323669,
-0.007703077048063278,
1.1104596853256226,
-0.6424639225006104,
1.0664466619491577,
0.2665720283985138,
-1.0911781787872314,
0.5710440278053284,
-0.1200847402215004,
0.20916296541690826,
0.5338233709335327,
0.35644248127937317,
-0.2505216598510742,
-0.506750762462616,
-0.14862824976444244,
-0.9793125987052917,
0.502510666847229,
0.12137731909751892,
0.0969616025686264,
0.061003200709819794,
0.12990978360176086,
0.1276930719614029,
0.19070367515087128,
-0.5950176119804382,
-0.24011178314685822,
-0.7723835706710815,
-0.1181458830833435,
0.023930853232741356,
-0.39101022481918335,
0.012201052159070969,
-0.2693178057670593,
0.17924973368644714,
-0.14226919412612915,
0.26790738105773926,
0.5831577777862549,
-0.5865529179573059,
0.4596785604953766,
-0.14288653433322906,
0.5743899345397949,
0.7421677708625793,
-0.04244576022028923,
0.3986145555973053,
0.03797873109579086,
-0.9420886039733887,
-0.09252025187015533,
-0.6865582466125488,
-0.4270614981651306,
0.3103637397289276,
0.48294517397880554,
1.1004037857055664,
0.40961897373199463,
-0.7756664752960205,
0.9151002168655396,
0.21808959543704987,
0.11723598837852478,
-0.10126323252916336,
-0.1886606067419052,
-0.2559806704521179,
0.10031503438949585,
0.6364455819129944,
0.308269202709198,
0.1711532026529312,
-0.6203127503395081,
0.270943820476532,
0.4756372272968292,
-0.6534515023231506,
-0.3359449803829193,
0.4119313955307007,
0.0797070637345314,
0.3268066942691803,
0.3793971538543701,
0.32851454615592957,
-0.8537991642951965,
0.44323015213012695,
0.37592753767967224,
0.6817411184310913,
0.27734100818634033,
0.3080517053604126,
0.20052972435951233,
0.423271119594574,
-0.33889466524124146,
-0.04735487326979637,
-0.05525299161672592,
-0.6950265169143677,
-0.39288556575775146,
-0.4773409366607666,
-0.26073500514030457,
-0.1066608801484108,
-1.0570019483566284,
0.29883795976638794,
-0.5797613859176636,
-0.45315736532211304,
-0.38164398074150085,
-0.8679461479187012,
-0.9429008364677429,
0.12439224869012833,
0.2765350639820099,
0.7550368309020996,
-0.9627923965454102,
0.6512096524238586,
0.682336688041687,
-0.431946337223053,
-0.6952915191650391,
0.1457979828119278,
-0.02157782018184662,
-0.960343062877655,
1.0572421550750732,
0.061424169689416885,
-0.26535648107528687,
-0.5408121943473816,
-0.8656472563743591,
-0.9299817085266113,
0.8521250486373901,
0.42031386494636536,
-0.5898356437683105,
-0.1401349902153015,
0.18381737172603607,
0.4689248204231262,
-0.4187472462654114,
0.28287026286125183,
0.16037368774414062,
0.005152195692062378,
0.054291244596242905,
-0.8489496111869812,
0.09563259035348892,
-0.0601879321038723,
0.431475967168808,
-0.08529524505138397,
-0.5086395740509033,
0.9300815463066101,
-0.057669661939144135,
-0.3429003655910492,
-0.4476507306098938,
0.5126163363456726,
-0.027216169983148575,
0.2391633838415146,
0.3948933482170105,
0.3402961194515228,
0.40070727467536926,
-0.09791094809770584,
0.9807915091514587,
-0.06375321000814438,
0.333462119102478,
1.196695327758789,
-0.3312602639198303,
0.9980689287185669,
1.0838018655776978,
0.07083798199892044,
0.6351165175437927,
0.026836354285478592,
-0.10089889913797379,
0.8334616422653198,
0.007252185605466366,
0.08217183500528336,
-0.3365105390548706,
-0.037024300545454025,
-0.17127321660518646,
0.5708250999450684,
0.413859486579895,
-0.6174994707107544,
-0.3221285343170166,
0.371116042137146,
-0.40555211901664734,
0.09449291974306107,
-0.35159698128700256,
0.42240872979164124,
0.14209914207458496,
-0.43485039472579956,
0.4481034278869629,
-0.573768675327301,
0.9519898891448975,
-0.4482644498348236,
-0.1851726770401001,
-0.014646532945334911,
0.16280171275138855,
-0.08487354218959808,
-0.8827612996101379,
0.4637344777584076,
-0.056423742324113846,
-0.3385067284107208,
-0.533043622970581,
0.7685847282409668,
-0.1128590777516365,
-0.3680006265640259,
0.30907243490219116,
0.2961881756782532,
-0.03855558857321739,
-0.20716622471809387,
-0.4205603301525116,
0.4514566957950592,
0.19883915781974792,
-0.008716912008821964,
0.23054416477680206,
0.31343990564346313,
-0.22637470066547394,
0.8913242816925049,
0.49102964997291565,
0.2888122498989105,
0.38586747646331787,
-0.03705349564552307,
1.036557674407959,
-0.5300012826919556,
-0.5296196937561035,
-0.8427432775497437,
0.5675169229507446,
-0.3387686312198639,
-0.3338310420513153,
0.8445377349853516,
0.44453856348991394,
0.8625066876411438,
-0.511311411857605,
0.8199564814567566,
0.1825362741947174,
0.2971374988555908,
-0.6370899677276611,
0.7533599138259888,
-0.4799876809120178,
0.26719897985458374,
-0.574858546257019,
-0.7941317558288574,
0.07665422558784485,
0.7252665162086487,
-0.4732746183872223,
-0.28607484698295593,
0.7534690499305725,
0.4408552050590515,
-0.27822476625442505,
-0.09613215178251266,
0.3512829542160034,
0.13253498077392578,
0.23800988495349884,
0.4722054898738861,
0.8982537388801575,
-0.35420867800712585,
0.603064239025116,
-0.31573250889778137,
-0.139707550406456,
-0.32389700412750244,
-1.0120925903320312,
-1.129571795463562,
-0.5905364155769348,
-0.26724621653556824,
-0.10666313022375107,
0.027005044743418694,
0.4986879527568817,
0.8870906233787537,
-0.6834955215454102,
-0.000699403346516192,
0.06526840478181839,
0.02313205599784851,
-0.07096078991889954,
-0.26538485288619995,
0.13794218003749847,
-0.07519053667783737,
-0.46030890941619873,
0.007808215916156769,
0.4483788013458252,
0.05887596681714058,
-0.6367588043212891,
0.22557196021080017,
0.19042281806468964,
-0.06629907339811325,
0.7594348192214966,
0.21403709053993225,
-0.8428289294242859,
-0.4651678800582886,
0.063443623483181,
-0.1678050458431244,
0.16505838930606842,
1.0741773843765259,
-1.1155644655227661,
0.510635256767273,
0.4817097783088684,
0.4935770332813263,
0.5805230140686035,
0.03802041336894035,
1.0009278059005737,
-0.7185015082359314,
0.45972806215286255,
0.19830112159252167,
0.3976164162158966,
0.3622302711009979,
-0.3433043658733368,
0.10852512717247009,
0.3823920488357544,
-0.017459169030189514,
-0.8880703449249268,
0.2176627516746521,
-1.1175402402877808,
-0.2239888459444046,
1.109018325805664,
-0.2020581215620041,
-0.4577229917049408,
-0.028099408373236656,
-0.3727153539657593,
-0.08700981736183167,
-0.2870350778102875,
0.438689649105072,
0.6385111212730408,
0.1322297304868698,
-0.28974997997283936,
-0.4758510887622833,
0.39076364040374756,
0.4507209360599518,
-0.2581096887588501,
0.012892821803689003,
0.4319906234741211,
0.3969632089138031,
0.23811346292495728,
0.17582428455352783,
-0.17783942818641663,
-0.025203336030244827,
0.30934345722198486,
-0.07582313567399979,
-0.05403513088822365,
-0.1585838496685028,
-0.1481730341911316,
0.0865069255232811,
-0.15677744150161743,
-0.2734052240848541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14012v1
|
Prompt-Time Ontology-Driven Symbolic Knowledge Capture with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-22T21:40:34 | 2024-05-22T21:40:34 |
Tolga Çöplü, Arto Bendiken, Andrii Skomorokhov, Eduard Bateiko, Stephen Cobb
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In applications such as personal assistants, large language models (LLMs)
must consider the user's personal information and preferences. However, LLMs
lack the inherent ability to learn from user interactions. This paper explores
capturing personal information from user prompts using ontology and
knowledge-graph approaches. We use a subset of the KNOW ontology, which models
personal information, to train the language model on these concepts. We then
evaluate the success of knowledge capture using a specially constructed
dataset. Our code and datasets are publicly available at
https://github.com/HaltiaAI/paper-PTODSKC
|
[
-0.3457845449447632,
-0.6820914149284363,
1.1415653228759766,
-0.07699859887361526,
0.27427828311920166,
0.06872285157442093,
0.07819196581840515,
-0.1357244849205017,
0.27831390500068665,
0.6108313798904419,
-0.7331539392471313,
-0.5388695001602173,
-0.5188723802566528,
0.4126070737838745,
-0.2952922582626343,
0.46351826190948486,
0.023539843037724495,
-0.34721872210502625,
0.001104764174669981,
0.1336435079574585,
-0.4043692350387573,
-0.7131327986717224,
-0.7372777462005615,
-0.23642972111701965,
0.7564452886581421,
0.5289461612701416,
0.42115142941474915,
0.5172288417816162,
-0.06746841222047806,
0.26912835240364075,
0.07654214650392532,
0.2137875258922577,
-0.21249355375766754,
0.32879841327667236,
-0.08496332913637161,
-0.45146429538726807,
-0.1651402711868286,
0.08280562609434128,
0.631788969039917,
0.6988427639007568,
-0.03973006457090378,
0.23407146334648132,
0.027317481115460396,
0.0359094999730587,
-0.4512742757797241,
0.4623309373855591,
-0.2011284977197647,
0.2848101258277893,
-0.3727339208126068,
-0.4055243134498596,
-0.5753519535064697,
-0.558384895324707,
0.020716343075037003,
-0.9177725315093994,
-0.23497408628463745,
0.21586769819259644,
0.5976023077964783,
0.13977056741714478,
-0.5948761701583862,
-0.2527729272842407,
-0.648722231388092,
0.6971683502197266,
-0.7844574451446533,
0.2151859849691391,
0.6893227100372314,
0.8302978277206421,
-0.2296934723854065,
-0.8558488488197327,
-0.9163693189620972,
-0.39645254611968994,
-0.12847614288330078,
-0.12166661769151688,
-0.2006375640630722,
-0.0649847686290741,
0.5354797840118408,
-0.22089336812496185,
-0.3052964210510254,
0.12347687780857086,
-0.10250796377658844,
-0.2275456041097641,
0.4853557348251343,
0.6275789141654968,
0.2797563076019287,
-0.4869767427444458,
-0.35468152165412903,
-0.16008737683296204,
-0.6188615560531616,
0.22812631726264954,
0.25280606746673584,
0.42791321873664856,
-0.06318747997283936,
0.8010181784629822,
-0.28245389461517334,
0.9504302144050598,
0.13299086689949036,
-0.37814489006996155,
0.025718476623296738,
-0.4418357312679291,
0.13246101140975952,
-0.01961357705295086,
0.8784780502319336,
0.14452654123306274,
0.388202041387558,
-0.38005080819129944,
-0.1933096945285797,
-0.13716846704483032,
-0.13453227281570435,
-0.5899299383163452,
0.0034908156376332045,
0.3058706521987915,
-0.10989498347043991,
-0.20060747861862183,
-0.026548828929662704,
-0.5311260223388672,
-0.6315184831619263,
-0.4334564805030823,
0.01986662857234478,
-0.3225649297237396,
0.19614505767822266,
-0.15409691631793976,
-0.24599149823188782,
0.1399250626564026,
0.6179923415184021,
-0.7624752521514893,
0.22902756929397583,
0.4410616159439087,
0.919816255569458,
0.03109860047698021,
-0.32086265087127686,
-0.7971103191375732,
0.49606260657310486,
-0.03893650323152542,
0.7479799389839172,
-0.5697420239448547,
-0.3244728744029999,
0.15666751563549042,
-0.17537811398506165,
0.00846103299409151,
-0.22507344186306,
0.08610571920871735,
-0.7526633739471436,
0.47678735852241516,
-0.6821981072425842,
-0.7633754014968872,
-0.04571322724223137,
0.41749483346939087,
-0.5858647227287292,
0.768937885761261,
0.4534895122051239,
-0.6746095418930054,
0.2811153531074524,
-0.5708709359169006,
-0.2467583566904068,
0.3429158926010132,
-0.3343319296836853,
0.15155011415481567,
-0.35238373279571533,
-0.023662235587835312,
0.9094826579093933,
-0.3723708689212799,
0.21477997303009033,
-0.5438166856765747,
0.003750099102035165,
0.5872946381568909,
0.030687063932418823,
0.8843802809715271,
0.4203207194805145,
0.14118698239326477,
-0.05970509722828865,
-0.7755559086799622,
-0.1815018355846405,
0.39475953578948975,
-0.3932412564754486,
-0.44106054306030273,
-0.21468599140644073,
-0.2679324150085449,
0.6199979782104492,
0.5310063362121582,
-0.7653950452804565,
0.5500632524490356,
0.023762179538607597,
0.6103626489639282,
0.7984366416931152,
0.08235166221857071,
0.23243311047554016,
-0.16415460407733917,
0.6487587690353394,
-0.19269031286239624,
-0.0247428547590971,
-0.2436905950307846,
-0.40461820363998413,
-0.265686959028244,
0.050549156963825226,
0.21076206862926483,
0.5883262157440186,
-0.9231746196746826,
0.6491124033927917,
-0.13693729043006897,
-0.21867720782756805,
0.03549013286828995,
0.38706615567207336,
0.3935200273990631,
0.8404093980789185,
0.1184915155172348,
-0.244706928730011,
-0.4025067687034607,
-0.2687312662601471,
-0.049809131771326065,
-0.44499465823173523,
-0.37704765796661377,
0.7223142981529236,
0.17750422656536102,
-0.24758034944534302,
1.4928803443908691,
-0.9044652581214905,
-0.6517522931098938,
-0.47396597266197205,
0.2040625810623169,
0.07984700798988342,
-0.009869437664747238,
0.5963336229324341,
-0.48115047812461853,
-0.33144834637641907,
-0.1505889594554901,
-1.1354931592941284,
-0.533368706703186,
-0.05420752614736557,
0.021242521703243256,
-0.010196798481047153,
0.4357175827026367,
-0.7469732165336609,
0.19445589184761047,
0.44653600454330444,
-0.8593165278434753,
0.4425621032714844,
-0.15381170809268951,
0.1478249579668045,
-1.4095934629440308,
0.2904488444328308,
0.09218470007181168,
-0.5372462868690491,
-0.6942786574363708,
-0.4889499843120575,
-0.11583515256643295,
-0.2909049391746521,
-0.5228909850120544,
1.1753097772598267,
-0.33383357524871826,
-0.14264145493507385,
-0.20674163103103638,
0.5938418507575989,
-0.15511038899421692,
0.5872481465339661,
0.08445501327514648,
0.5152572393417358,
0.04982404410839081,
-0.7875959873199463,
0.4762369692325592,
0.6945894956588745,
-0.16615022718906403,
0.5456677675247192,
-0.4698311388492584,
0.3450401723384857,
0.060912616550922394,
0.0856957957148552,
-1.025745153427124,
-0.7193286418914795,
0.4469219744205475,
-0.4569430351257324,
0.19963453710079193,
0.0896199494600296,
-0.7943889498710632,
-0.37012234330177307,
-0.17103619873523712,
0.01795140653848648,
0.5219943523406982,
-0.5329978466033936,
0.965097963809967,
0.6452718377113342,
-0.3238854706287384,
-0.32427865266799927,
-0.5074396133422852,
0.20695696771144867,
-0.09017534554004669,
-0.5296257138252258,
0.08286464214324951,
0.20139449834823608,
-0.16050344705581665,
-0.09747806936502457,
0.3306262791156769,
0.011228346265852451,
0.0360606424510479,
0.2382938265800476,
0.11350639909505844,
0.24185149371623993,
0.33727607131004333,
0.03698739409446716,
-0.2264130413532257,
0.20183053612709045,
-0.24619024991989136,
0.8144521117210388,
0.30019432306289673,
-0.36064741015434265,
-0.8775858879089355,
0.3428228795528412,
0.33300483226776123,
0.1340237706899643,
0.5755588412284851,
0.1870299130678177,
-0.21606485545635223,
0.07492032647132874,
-0.5398324131965637,
-0.35178783535957336,
-0.4639962911605835,
0.08338663727045059,
-0.3075975179672241,
-0.8562138080596924,
0.5712876319885254,
-0.17193472385406494,
0.2116214781999588,
0.17633309960365295,
0.40309593081474304,
-0.2761777639389038,
1.1826317310333252,
0.6272204518318176,
-0.029197173193097115,
0.7089142203330994,
-0.014041928574442863,
-0.0896599143743515,
-0.5127128958702087,
-0.3744037449359894,
-0.6734834313392639,
-0.1734035313129425,
-0.03757642209529877,
0.04761449992656708,
0.32803890109062195,
-0.23656688630580902,
-0.5056350231170654,
0.3456573486328125,
0.0019657921511679888,
-0.05624748021364212,
0.7711958885192871,
0.09538333863019943,
0.5176872611045837,
-0.019190538674592972,
0.12642525136470795,
0.04024504870176315,
-0.802678108215332,
-0.6787353157997131,
0.8458580374717712,
0.17264598608016968,
1.0932921171188354,
-0.01057950034737587,
0.5178068280220032,
0.40980714559555054,
-0.12645965814590454,
-0.6304028630256653,
0.8345727920532227,
-0.1219545230269432,
-0.29546013474464417,
-0.5012240409851074,
-0.6722443103790283,
-1.0680391788482666,
-0.40205058455467224,
0.030391255393624306,
-0.8611854314804077,
0.14346037805080414,
0.6279624104499817,
-0.6550842523574829,
0.12013794481754303,
-0.7289314270019531,
0.7784480452537537,
-0.24672041833400726,
0.02668122574687004,
0.0821758359670639,
-0.9041629433631897,
0.2606732249259949,
-0.27494293451309204,
-0.11368605494499207,
-0.22703994810581207,
0.008491257205605507,
0.9929987788200378,
-0.5382473468780518,
1.508398175239563,
-0.4292582869529724,
0.022714830935001373,
0.25350630283355713,
0.2573588192462921,
0.6362063884735107,
-0.18682819604873657,
0.29443952441215515,
0.06973370164632797,
0.06911296397447586,
-0.2072729766368866,
-0.8716862797737122,
0.3808460831642151,
-0.7524645328521729,
-0.455355703830719,
-0.34977415204048157,
-0.5238593220710754,
-0.3560326099395752,
0.18981271982192993,
0.23148734867572784,
0.3207756280899048,
-0.0367557555437088,
-0.2529444694519043,
0.4927503764629364,
-0.09921272844076157,
0.24353861808776855,
0.5972108244895935,
-0.41671717166900635,
-0.05879655107855797,
0.6162292957305908,
0.4360659122467041,
0.16501086950302124,
0.47245678305625916,
0.45010465383529663,
-0.5605872869491577,
0.2480960488319397,
-0.3395496606826782,
0.48232296109199524,
-0.882192075252533,
-0.269083708524704,
-0.8531656265258789,
-0.02530050091445446,
-0.7249322533607483,
-0.13366493582725525,
0.03889087960124016,
-0.5749478936195374,
-0.43665948510169983,
0.11688563227653503,
0.7089850902557373,
0.8412160277366638,
0.21900902688503265,
0.6579396724700928,
-1.1294242143630981,
0.20790094137191772,
0.6114132404327393,
-0.14369262754917145,
-0.050615955144166946,
-0.5921746492385864,
0.12071523070335388,
-0.23510442674160004,
-0.04296635091304779,
-1.0747036933898926,
0.39587974548339844,
0.0711173489689827,
0.7103615403175354,
0.5462861657142639,
0.20485438406467438,
0.2918159067630768,
-0.10426972061395645,
0.8471434712409973,
0.2882789671421051,
-0.9445502758026123,
0.7680447101593018,
-0.11257299780845642,
0.6685028076171875,
0.4483746886253357,
0.6688354015350342,
-0.9773244857788086,
-0.26629653573036194,
-0.39285025000572205,
-0.3446506857872009,
0.8801696300506592,
-0.174597829580307,
-0.0601314976811409,
0.061455514281988144,
0.40462177991867065,
0.018666844815015793,
0.2380468100309372,
-0.3776681125164032,
0.06225019693374634,
0.030323199927806854,
-0.6028332114219666,
-0.02746494859457016,
-0.30714258551597595,
-0.13484816253185272,
0.18343155086040497,
0.1769949048757553,
-0.31194788217544556,
0.17129415273666382,
-0.060669973492622375,
-0.041664108633995056,
0.29838132858276367,
0.03694847971200943,
0.12561006844043732,
0.447115421295166,
0.07970813661813736,
0.29278624057769775,
0.22390201687812805,
-0.37135228514671326,
0.24412041902542114,
-0.03141101822257042,
-0.3739296793937683,
-0.19590802490711212,
0.3315318822860718,
0.4935227036476135,
0.21330463886260986,
-0.8758915662765503,
0.5416723489761353,
-0.23162899911403656,
0.27233031392097473,
-0.5205691456794739,
0.12532658874988556,
-0.13955342769622803,
0.28395548462867737,
-0.04720126464962959,
-0.32095494866371155,
-0.007897777482867241,
-0.3202725946903229,
-0.04708222672343254,
0.18196557462215424,
-0.32423633337020874,
-0.7376363277435303,
0.5370388031005859,
0.1235220804810524,
-0.35626786947250366,
0.7277331352233887,
-0.18290366232395172,
-0.3861923813819885,
0.1868247389793396,
0.5456746220588684,
0.6810894012451172,
-0.5474480986595154,
0.2032446265220642,
0.23980897665023804,
-0.2769642472267151,
0.1734192669391632,
0.42544785141944885,
-0.5273430943489075,
-0.7048685550689697,
-0.4482992887496948,
-0.28992384672164917,
-0.5933908820152283,
-0.2898639440536499,
-0.2562289834022522,
0.5523127317428589,
-0.5309261679649353,
-0.4002664089202881,
-0.18841734528541565,
-0.09232340008020401,
-0.754909873008728,
-0.09705063700675964,
0.014624440111219883,
1.0125229358673096,
-1.0271320343017578,
0.7692039608955383,
0.5095884799957275,
-0.4595869779586792,
-1.1905289888381958,
-0.29180270433425903,
0.16785234212875366,
-0.8858266472816467,
1.076446533203125,
-0.10238777846097946,
-0.148831307888031,
0.03108886629343033,
-0.5131485462188721,
-0.7433599233627319,
1.238684058189392,
0.6524904370307922,
-0.36771950125694275,
-0.5713241100311279,
0.17686280608177185,
0.25327014923095703,
-0.3847568929195404,
0.0579354502260685,
0.7495585083961487,
0.5569935441017151,
0.3310084342956543,
-0.7566527724266052,
0.10741405934095383,
-0.04773297160863876,
0.01938541792333126,
0.012921351939439774,
-0.4233664870262146,
0.8659431338310242,
-0.26290443539619446,
-0.42692628502845764,
-0.09265652298927307,
0.495044082403183,
0.4195355474948883,
0.266217440366745,
0.48752275109291077,
0.37035730481147766,
0.9685761332511902,
0.05879618227481842,
1.3789429664611816,
-0.3910093307495117,
0.1634424477815628,
1.0606327056884766,
-0.5515151619911194,
0.6896924376487732,
0.4140339195728302,
-0.044185709208250046,
0.2904370129108429,
0.5871586799621582,
0.22999800741672516,
0.4032706022262573,
-0.31081607937812805,
-0.29136011004447937,
-0.4035989046096802,
-0.4329964816570282,
-0.17361611127853394,
0.43461406230926514,
0.40003740787506104,
-0.329522967338562,
-0.2661344110965729,
0.2742447257041931,
0.21064752340316772,
-0.18703703582286835,
-0.11617633700370789,
0.999973714351654,
0.2853267192840576,
-0.777923047542572,
0.1316213607788086,
-0.20405922830104828,
0.19800713658332825,
-1.0273916721343994,
-0.09124398976564407,
-0.1591297686100006,
-0.013599609024822712,
-0.03218997269868851,
-1.0255829095840454,
-0.046744585037231445,
0.08691343665122986,
0.026386087760329247,
-0.4155083894729614,
0.7869083881378174,
-0.2275838851928711,
-0.1312071681022644,
0.315801739692688,
0.5704378485679626,
0.3750443458557129,
0.02834518440067768,
-0.14985334873199463,
-0.23000532388687134,
-0.2971596419811249,
-0.34420138597488403,
0.30480363965034485,
0.3561590909957886,
-0.1744590699672699,
0.8316493034362793,
0.5089603066444397,
0.059998493641614914,
0.10760825127363205,
0.06848805397748947,
0.908966064453125,
-0.8655340075492859,
-0.7553153038024902,
-0.7224061489105225,
0.11092926561832428,
-0.1675238311290741,
-0.457990437746048,
0.95405113697052,
0.16874834895133972,
0.6655962467193604,
-0.13824774324893951,
0.8876773118972778,
-0.17376774549484253,
0.84560227394104,
-0.7427220344543457,
0.5548649430274963,
-0.2986403703689575,
0.13474354147911072,
-0.0664491355419159,
-0.6198842525482178,
-0.2842444181442261,
0.24534174799919128,
-0.5025080442428589,
0.17223894596099854,
0.23544031381607056,
0.6437661647796631,
0.09119759500026703,
-0.1826811283826828,
0.39806315302848816,
0.1794717013835907,
0.41248199343681335,
0.7392728328704834,
1.1284250020980835,
0.2433365136384964,
0.42826181650161743,
-0.0781562328338623,
-0.4771368205547333,
-0.381525456905365,
-0.8566786646842957,
-0.9916585087776184,
-0.8127127885818481,
-0.10894609987735748,
-0.47957468032836914,
-0.17549987137317657,
1.103954553604126,
0.6243618726730347,
-0.6355999708175659,
-0.21658025681972504,
0.1643555611371994,
-0.11947434395551682,
0.07756658643484116,
-0.14992965757846832,
0.2600822448730469,
-0.49803808331489563,
-0.583821177482605,
0.24427376687526703,
0.12742437422275543,
0.3251006007194519,
-0.4902667999267578,
-0.1297903209924698,
0.003034432651475072,
0.052003394812345505,
0.7307060956954956,
0.667224645614624,
-0.5848357677459717,
-0.2550574541091919,
0.28886136412620544,
-0.28047335147857666,
0.012567023746669292,
1.0936204195022583,
-1.0246014595031738,
0.5475217700004578,
0.7736406326293945,
0.5457672476768494,
0.40182843804359436,
0.21133825182914734,
0.5701075792312622,
-1.0734100341796875,
-0.16283182799816132,
0.058632202446460724,
0.5410928130149841,
0.30343014001846313,
-0.6109282970428467,
0.25117170810699463,
0.2528400123119354,
-0.3387190103530884,
-0.5024040937423706,
0.26919472217559814,
-1.1076738834381104,
-0.16146056354045868,
1.2571372985839844,
-0.40553486347198486,
-0.3709012269973755,
-0.5405905246734619,
-0.41206300258636475,
0.32872897386550903,
-0.497513085603714,
0.7690828442573547,
0.5898473858833313,
-0.22348077595233917,
0.08842542767524719,
-0.2948559522628784,
0.2315698266029358,
-0.020426582545042038,
-1.0570687055587769,
0.12475110590457916,
0.494099885225296,
0.2186414897441864,
0.35154852271080017,
0.9704830646514893,
0.12929905951023102,
0.2663264572620392,
-0.15608154237270355,
0.12720225751399994,
-0.4368433952331543,
-0.48679229617118835,
-0.3779536187648773,
0.37018170952796936,
0.29774367809295654,
0.014681544154882431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14006v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models with Human Feedback: Establishing a Swedish Benchmark
| 2024-05-22T21:22:51 | 2024-05-22T21:22:51 |
Birger Moell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence, large language
models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant capabilities across numerous
applications. However, the performance of these models in languages with fewer
resources, such as Swedish, remains under-explored. This study introduces a
comprehensive human benchmark to assess the efficacy of prominent LLMs in
understanding and generating Swedish language texts using forced choice
ranking. We employ a modified version of the ChatbotArena benchmark,
incorporating human feedback to evaluate eleven different models, including
GPT-4, GPT-3.5, various Claude and Llama models, and bespoke models like
Dolphin-2.9-llama3b-8b-flashback and BeagleCatMunin. These models were chosen
based on their performance on LMSYS chatbot arena and the Scandeval benchmarks.
We release the chatbotarena.se benchmark as a tool to improve our understanding
of language model performance in Swedish with the hopes that it will be widely
used. We aim to create a leaderboard once sufficient data has been collected
and analysed.
|
[
-0.28902602195739746,
-0.5257964134216309,
0.4494273066520691,
0.24256454408168793,
-0.5282236337661743,
0.2530241012573242,
-0.7240719199180603,
-0.5155230760574341,
-0.07588993012905121,
0.5721181631088257,
-0.33114808797836304,
-0.570969820022583,
-0.5356173515319824,
0.39124155044555664,
-0.11269094049930573,
0.5831460356712341,
0.02111273631453514,
0.475532203912735,
-0.29094380140304565,
-0.2189510315656662,
-0.6000375151634216,
-0.7970726490020752,
-0.49479272961616516,
-0.5715555548667908,
0.6924594044685364,
0.1800360083580017,
0.7063618898391724,
0.500594437122345,
0.4898858368396759,
0.3681236505508423,
-0.34274497628211975,
0.14774145185947418,
-0.5913885235786438,
0.3474119007587433,
-0.34802350401878357,
-0.5495041012763977,
-0.23380699753761292,
-0.003900210140272975,
0.6947529911994934,
0.6379322409629822,
-0.10667617619037628,
0.22067606449127197,
0.2318476140499115,
0.48752105236053467,
-0.22246184945106506,
0.1771160513162613,
-0.6619940996170044,
-0.28120940923690796,
-0.2934698760509491,
0.16332320868968964,
-0.5624241828918457,
-0.46738195419311523,
0.096565380692482,
-0.16696009039878845,
-0.02130391262471676,
0.22261759638786316,
0.6800564527511597,
0.11540193110704422,
-0.3333713412284851,
-0.31505608558654785,
-0.7180572748184204,
0.8667703866958618,
-0.6399330496788025,
0.3621212840080261,
0.4159756004810333,
0.44860097765922546,
-0.23826953768730164,
-0.4031391739845276,
-0.2993069291114807,
-0.6050657629966736,
0.22307300567626953,
-0.08841677755117416,
-0.16713184118270874,
-0.10958152264356613,
0.0675949901342392,
-0.04870111122727394,
-0.34854841232299805,
0.4967445135116577,
-0.38190099596977234,
-0.17346414923667908,
0.934978187084198,
0.19054138660430908,
0.05638975277543068,
-0.26931193470954895,
-0.11982670426368713,
-0.26929017901420593,
-0.6699789762496948,
-0.18492048978805542,
0.6021441221237183,
0.5557469725608826,
0.04323393106460571,
0.6596720218658447,
-0.025517867878079414,
0.5487685799598694,
-0.280673623085022,
0.024949857965111732,
0.365117609500885,
-0.14950186014175415,
0.006163871847093105,
-0.2691839039325714,
0.8511995673179626,
0.4154282212257385,
0.34504541754722595,
-0.19239118695259094,
-0.5951639413833618,
0.16984203457832336,
0.23510201275348663,
-0.631974458694458,
-0.03185426443815231,
0.07129792124032974,
-0.6455846428871155,
-0.31136777997016907,
-0.3316405713558197,
-0.6533151268959045,
-0.7025230526924133,
-0.19532977044582367,
0.34198853373527527,
-0.2321794182062149,
-0.3825896382331848,
0.03438457101583481,
0.015226654708385468,
0.2172267884016037,
0.4681955873966217,
-0.7550718784332275,
0.27340707182884216,
0.660597562789917,
0.7579547166824341,
-0.6279153227806091,
-0.3398846387863159,
-0.17436997592449188,
-0.29259106516838074,
-0.5545061230659485,
1.0330661535263062,
-0.44554659724235535,
-0.6573648452758789,
0.20464561879634857,
-0.3332974910736084,
0.15616410970687866,
-0.9116835594177246,
0.6548217535018921,
-0.57893306016922,
0.2055089920759201,
-0.19150462746620178,
-0.7670565247535706,
-0.00439526466652751,
0.1782180368900299,
-0.6770135164260864,
1.0977340936660767,
-0.058352794498205185,
-0.41171348094940186,
0.15872226655483246,
-0.5962209701538086,
-0.3558013141155243,
0.3809209167957306,
-0.24012190103530884,
-0.1391122043132782,
0.12654033303260803,
0.05369814857840538,
0.529487133026123,
-0.5715504288673401,
0.5143296122550964,
-0.37183693051338196,
-0.3333907425403595,
0.44391438364982605,
-0.5917841196060181,
0.6167192459106445,
0.10467109084129333,
-0.21435882151126862,
0.34254005551338196,
-0.6358563303947449,
0.08914950489997864,
0.1811351180076599,
-0.6350714564323425,
-0.3184153735637665,
0.025573119521141052,
0.3767005503177643,
0.32729649543762207,
0.2137264907360077,
-0.4684363603591919,
0.22379498183727264,
-0.284801721572876,
0.44484183192253113,
0.899451494216919,
-0.11172321438789368,
0.07569929212331772,
-0.3525463044643402,
0.6038349866867065,
-0.39178404211997986,
0.06841565668582916,
0.22754855453968048,
-0.5425843000411987,
-0.6814226508140564,
-0.29716718196868896,
0.6418381333351135,
0.3780365288257599,
-0.6614087820053101,
0.45743703842163086,
-0.37177416682243347,
-0.6720518469810486,
-0.8927214741706848,
0.3424774408340454,
0.4657106101512909,
-0.13726097345352173,
0.01707462966442108,
-0.39988359808921814,
-0.5774238109588623,
-1.118148684501648,
-0.4552735984325409,
-0.2376507967710495,
-0.37633955478668213,
0.5606671571731567,
0.4807201325893402,
-0.18337076902389526,
0.7957741022109985,
-0.1487221121788025,
-0.09503322839736938,
-0.4677864611148834,
0.1366317868232727,
0.37306103110313416,
0.11189419031143188,
0.44724851846694946,
-0.5316269397735596,
-0.2963961660861969,
-0.11101705580949783,
-0.44761526584625244,
-0.09112704545259476,
0.23459473252296448,
-0.03160585090517998,
0.3993085026741028,
0.25899526476860046,
-0.5519900321960449,
0.11760931462049484,
0.7334588170051575,
-0.30213913321495056,
0.5285833477973938,
-0.3173220455646515,
0.08179761469364166,
-1.053497076034546,
0.31952521204948425,
-0.1737251579761505,
-0.2422581911087036,
-0.39892318844795227,
-0.21625129878520966,
0.013373829424381256,
0.05760569125413895,
-0.6654838919639587,
0.8931856155395508,
-0.3404604494571686,
-0.3419204652309418,
-0.14440809190273285,
0.35223835706710815,
-0.5092331767082214,
0.5422834157943726,
0.05288314446806908,
0.8026761412620544,
0.08215835690498352,
-0.5409034490585327,
0.3270602524280548,
0.2788946330547333,
-0.8796546459197998,
0.26335418224334717,
-0.7579281330108643,
0.40421897172927856,
-0.06438978016376495,
0.16063722968101501,
-1.2663497924804688,
-0.2849874794483185,
0.007126424927264452,
-0.42883309721946716,
-0.07817792892456055,
-0.06142498925328255,
-0.8036160469055176,
-0.4198291301727295,
-0.16929961740970612,
0.09320954233407974,
0.6877434849739075,
-0.41720083355903625,
0.6035349369049072,
0.5730866193771362,
-0.28725913166999817,
-0.2375662475824356,
-0.36106958985328674,
0.3293210566043854,
0.04806575924158096,
-0.4228816032409668,
0.028912672773003578,
-0.29229986667633057,
-0.5038025379180908,
-0.25261563062667847,
0.23688766360282898,
0.10792665183544159,
0.2581893801689148,
0.28199145197868347,
0.5627155900001526,
-0.06337853521108627,
0.18869735300540924,
-0.12185432016849518,
-0.00469724927097559,
0.06212400272488594,
0.2422563135623932,
0.8894373178482056,
-0.2205098569393158,
-0.264011412858963,
-0.37948110699653625,
0.0829005241394043,
0.8252164125442505,
-0.14467506110668182,
0.6182202696800232,
0.11711382120847702,
-0.17590832710266113,
-0.11767426133155823,
-0.6899121999740601,
-0.19687442481517792,
-0.44242024421691895,
0.42664989829063416,
-0.265653520822525,
-0.9319838285446167,
0.646746814250946,
-0.13603952527046204,
0.2786388695240021,
0.5620148777961731,
0.9003623127937317,
-0.017456863075494766,
1.314265489578247,
0.3155776858329773,
-0.21070998907089233,
0.33125635981559753,
0.060664936900138855,
-0.19383130967617035,
-0.5638623833656311,
-0.3051493465900421,
-0.7324772477149963,
-0.28095757961273193,
-0.6139214634895325,
-0.44944167137145996,
0.07216482609510422,
-0.11236125975847244,
-0.1368812918663025,
0.2580621838569641,
-0.25480496883392334,
0.5672361850738525,
0.417018860578537,
-0.06622554361820221,
0.3098091185092926,
-0.0269942507147789,
-0.44197165966033936,
-0.019381077960133553,
-0.7345026731491089,
-0.739530086517334,
1.1724826097488403,
0.39814305305480957,
0.7521902918815613,
0.19881783425807953,
0.5388324856758118,
0.530015230178833,
0.6766168475151062,
-0.6790615916252136,
0.7073823809623718,
-0.09119168668985367,
-0.7386369705200195,
-0.4117683470249176,
-0.35996732115745544,
-1.1202986240386963,
0.6084460020065308,
-0.20646394789218903,
-0.5716118216514587,
-0.27410197257995605,
-0.043488793075084686,
-0.15749992430210114,
0.013440754264593124,
-0.6645716428756714,
0.5350022912025452,
-0.4104635715484619,
-0.4718506634235382,
-0.43071669340133667,
-0.45656484365463257,
0.10504843294620514,
-0.06756529211997986,
0.2643808126449585,
-0.31880879402160645,
-0.2393244504928589,
0.9220725297927856,
-0.14219318330287933,
1.0884798765182495,
-0.10169660300016403,
-0.34881362318992615,
0.08881825953722,
0.015073820948600769,
0.5076282024383545,
-0.14222753047943115,
-0.363197386264801,
0.41199859976768494,
-0.24153774976730347,
-0.32176023721694946,
-0.3745824992656708,
0.6583853363990784,
-0.9588958621025085,
-0.48725056648254395,
-0.19482670724391937,
-0.28614795207977295,
-0.40223923325538635,
0.37813037633895874,
0.15552957355976105,
0.26494133472442627,
-0.3830714225769043,
0.32383957505226135,
0.4082522988319397,
-0.19526927173137665,
0.37956106662750244,
0.6273106932640076,
-0.6164625287055969,
-0.6468679308891296,
0.5567642450332642,
0.10654856264591217,
0.023433128371834755,
0.15222357213497162,
0.10189111530780792,
-0.5970189571380615,
-0.6252718567848206,
-0.5571115016937256,
0.40791094303131104,
-0.6887510418891907,
-0.09734553843736649,
-0.39624330401420593,
-0.15540623664855957,
-0.22345829010009766,
0.051602017134428024,
-0.6023197770118713,
-0.14091919362545013,
-0.08713653683662415,
0.009597758762538433,
0.08398042619228363,
1.1727207899093628,
0.34188902378082275,
0.02080903761088848,
-0.7846910357475281,
-0.05664686858654022,
0.27037549018859863,
0.6779742240905762,
0.18541640043258667,
-0.43735837936401367,
0.0002808012650348246,
-0.043124306946992874,
0.10561038553714752,
-0.6097781658172607,
0.2588534355163574,
-0.24659790098667145,
0.8797671794891357,
0.1544465869665146,
-0.035089608281850815,
0.1992972046136856,
-0.4157709777355194,
0.8499099016189575,
-0.002565619768574834,
-0.8642731308937073,
0.36296823620796204,
-0.5848000645637512,
0.49884232878685,
0.5753301978111267,
0.14214035868644714,
-0.725189208984375,
-0.42712166905403137,
-0.5158583521842957,
-0.780386209487915,
0.6431906223297119,
0.3317333459854126,
0.2879120111465454,
-0.016334934160113335,
0.1500801295042038,
0.333038330078125,
0.2562884986400604,
-0.4775661826133728,
-0.1029244139790535,
0.3656991720199585,
0.01051210705190897,
-0.31533923745155334,
-0.40791597962379456,
0.09148886799812317,
-0.12833082675933838,
0.649075984954834,
0.056802209466695786,
0.04370858892798424,
-0.1967719942331314,
-0.32927823066711426,
0.06555923819541931,
0.31890857219696045,
0.811321496963501,
0.7530415654182434,
-0.18649600446224213,
-0.047203294932842255,
0.3894486129283905,
-0.4035998284816742,
0.11895840615034103,
-0.127483069896698,
-0.05395542457699776,
0.16945910453796387,
0.5785606503486633,
0.90673828125,
0.3604988157749176,
-1.0143406391143799,
0.3799029290676117,
-0.37033528089523315,
-0.29116174578666687,
-0.1023801863193512,
0.08957183361053467,
0.3041880428791046,
0.2798782289028168,
0.331973671913147,
-0.008640650659799576,
-0.3114021420478821,
-0.18210779130458832,
-0.008219745010137558,
0.18674136698246002,
-0.28049033880233765,
-0.3400563895702362,
0.4723745584487915,
0.6550386548042297,
-0.6571650505065918,
0.6390592455863953,
0.003623933531343937,
-0.5004553198814392,
0.4371076822280884,
0.4194332957267761,
0.8040621876716614,
-0.33740925788879395,
0.21481597423553467,
0.39748233556747437,
0.22775453329086304,
-0.37934568524360657,
0.3618076741695404,
-0.03475579246878624,
-0.6971449851989746,
-0.4291200339794159,
-0.5799618363380432,
-0.6150119304656982,
0.28031468391418457,
-0.5571238398551941,
0.28698110580444336,
-0.3277705907821655,
-0.3376002311706543,
0.08548002690076828,
0.18901042640209198,
-0.7332227230072021,
-0.19575291872024536,
0.20277944207191467,
1.01090407371521,
-0.7682175040245056,
0.7885221242904663,
0.7206918001174927,
-0.1586817055940628,
-0.5877252221107483,
-0.18479175865650177,
-0.1107885092496872,
-0.8807827830314636,
0.5312026143074036,
0.1575184315443039,
-0.283195436000824,
-0.12704861164093018,
-0.6459335684776306,
-0.8342079520225525,
0.813520073890686,
0.42639097571372986,
-0.8182916045188904,
0.2667939066886902,
-0.04129844158887863,
0.905657947063446,
-0.3418010175228119,
0.3403964936733246,
0.5481325387954712,
0.46792998909950256,
0.03605986014008522,
-1.0276830196380615,
-0.12863515317440033,
-0.39569082856178284,
0.4077036678791046,
0.08161471784114838,
-0.7071168422698975,
0.49905386567115784,
-0.034331467002630234,
-0.2574772238731384,
0.2672816216945648,
0.6488404870033264,
0.24614979326725006,
-0.24019159376621246,
0.6084379553794861,
0.08238791674375534,
0.92579185962677,
0.2369687408208847,
1.205688714981079,
-0.20944707095623016,
0.2291463166475296,
1.0797897577285767,
-0.6557217240333557,
1.3250970840454102,
0.33755823969841003,
-0.35459044575691223,
0.2705497741699219,
0.6292692422866821,
-0.0125043373554945,
0.44261470437049866,
0.5207896828651428,
0.01747574843466282,
-0.5052396059036255,
-0.14042556285858154,
-0.1201198548078537,
0.6838547587394714,
0.20199935138225555,
-0.341525673866272,
-0.13202181458473206,
0.10568410903215408,
0.13729575276374817,
0.028540559113025665,
-0.21288497745990753,
0.8424255847930908,
-0.16448432207107544,
-1.0190949440002441,
0.8133729696273804,
0.01930488646030426,
0.8074902892112732,
-0.4854089319705963,
0.12871511280536652,
-0.4090441167354584,
0.26891204714775085,
0.27146920561790466,
-0.87259441614151,
-0.11416954547166824,
0.27883827686309814,
-0.04804974049329758,
-0.24510428309440613,
0.682640790939331,
-0.4685417413711548,
-0.3685932457447052,
0.42177972197532654,
0.5174616575241089,
0.34226152300834656,
0.17651551961898804,
-0.5781539082527161,
0.4451058804988861,
0.0225682333111763,
-0.34674063324928284,
0.37714114785194397,
-0.11391966044902802,
-0.22780631482601166,
0.9215946793556213,
0.6147145628929138,
0.011351966299116611,
-0.30661138892173767,
0.3271075189113617,
0.7832819819450378,
-0.5053672790527344,
-0.41118988394737244,
-0.9114746451377869,
0.11905277520418167,
-0.2872900366783142,
-0.6686055064201355,
0.7684168815612793,
0.6315600872039795,
0.659710705280304,
-0.09036505967378616,
0.9279423952102661,
0.2100105732679367,
0.7398607730865479,
-0.27670958638191223,
1.0979851484298706,
-0.30004680156707764,
0.30180448293685913,
-0.042383670806884766,
-1.0783426761627197,
-0.276857852935791,
0.29510676860809326,
-0.38616737723350525,
0.10417807102203369,
0.3718210756778717,
0.6924209594726562,
0.3400891125202179,
-0.07466289401054382,
0.501250147819519,
0.42185544967651367,
0.24628108739852905,
0.2067696899175644,
1.1373835802078247,
0.0000347868881362956,
0.5840985774993896,
0.07952214777469635,
-0.11584188044071198,
-0.4709775745868683,
-0.8018704056739807,
-1.2321810722351074,
-0.6510798335075378,
-0.09080576151609421,
-0.3785325288772583,
0.2881109416484833,
1.1538087129592896,
0.601850688457489,
-0.7050579786300659,
-0.4510345160961151,
0.427035391330719,
0.09658324718475342,
-0.06211639940738678,
-0.13663847744464874,
0.3495153784751892,
-0.09544157236814499,
-0.6927003264427185,
0.37130311131477356,
0.1706584393978119,
-0.010421082377433777,
-0.561335563659668,
-0.21424758434295654,
-0.03440345451235771,
0.3399984538555145,
0.6643907427787781,
0.05180436745285988,
-0.9191805720329285,
-0.24855607748031616,
0.003104432485997677,
-0.4334743618965149,
-0.10423634201288223,
0.6869180202484131,
-0.7364844679832458,
0.27326858043670654,
0.5975263118743896,
0.5840754508972168,
0.26345905661582947,
-0.13837830722332,
0.6900053024291992,
-0.533161997795105,
-0.11569961160421371,
0.4271114766597748,
0.1822930872440338,
0.54048752784729,
0.05953904986381531,
0.4914015829563141,
0.004289306700229645,
-0.562163770198822,
-0.9002907872200012,
-0.020617539063096046,
-0.6740641593933105,
-0.38287121057510376,
1.542879343032837,
0.10763495415449142,
-0.4378500282764435,
-0.19387389719486237,
-0.4677406847476959,
-0.05798722058534622,
-0.587861955165863,
0.892707347869873,
1.040769100189209,
-0.028991246595978737,
0.1070004254579544,
-0.48760512471199036,
0.3895711600780487,
0.4338347911834717,
-0.7848029732704163,
0.4038596749305725,
0.5049991011619568,
0.31883925199508667,
-0.09546025097370148,
0.6205787658691406,
-0.05031681805849075,
0.19051438570022583,
-0.09250900149345398,
0.30105388164520264,
0.11496832966804504,
-0.10724781453609467,
-0.5920034646987915,
0.0318334735929966,
0.3103204071521759,
-0.07658328860998154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13984v1
|
Feedback-aligned Mixed LLMs for Machine Language-Molecule Translation
| 2024-05-22T20:40:53 | 2024-05-22T20:40:53 |
Dimitris Gkoumas, Maria Liakata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
The intersection of chemistry and Artificial Intelligence (AI) is an active
area of research focused on accelerating scientific discovery. While using
large language models (LLMs) with scientific modalities has shown potential,
there are significant challenges to address, such as improving training
efficiency and dealing with the out-of-distribution problem. Focussing on the
task of automated language-molecule translation, we are the first to use
state-of-the art (SOTA) human-centric optimisation algorithms in the
cross-modal setting, successfully aligning cross-language-molecule modals. We
empirically show that we can augment the capabilities of scientific LLMs
without the need for extensive data or large models. We conduct experiments
using only 10% of the available data to mitigate memorisation effects
associated with training large models on extensive datasets. We achieve
significant performance gains, surpassing the best benchmark model trained on
extensive in-distribution data by a large margin and reach new SOTA levels.
Additionally we are the first to propose employing non-linear fusion for mixing
cross-modal LLMs which further boosts performance gains without increasing
training costs or data needs. Finally, we introduce a fine-grained,
domain-agnostic evaluation method to assess hallucination in LLMs and promote
responsible use.
|
[
-0.24927477538585663,
-0.6846023797988892,
0.5480891466140747,
0.14833872020244598,
-0.21504615247249603,
0.41365620493888855,
-0.5154945850372314,
-0.4621150493621826,
0.31684574484825134,
0.39432844519615173,
-0.6766951680183411,
-0.5121456980705261,
-0.45705848932266235,
0.43032339215278625,
-0.2326134890317917,
1.0446099042892456,
-0.3674575090408325,
0.6979097127914429,
-0.4844611585140228,
-0.14218071103096008,
-0.07573624700307846,
-0.29775094985961914,
-0.19746431708335876,
-0.5204373002052307,
0.5199622511863708,
0.32321810722351074,
0.6182708740234375,
0.5880263447761536,
0.6942537426948547,
0.25753211975097656,
-0.08252020180225372,
0.5000708103179932,
-0.6271451115608215,
0.18837326765060425,
-0.3015173375606537,
-0.41481977701187134,
-0.7026768326759338,
0.10122749954462051,
0.5970137715339661,
0.784160315990448,
-0.03681059554219246,
-0.060460902750492096,
-0.1590920239686966,
0.6024699211120605,
-0.4541985094547272,
-0.09029265493154526,
-0.5173401236534119,
0.161507710814476,
0.024841396138072014,
-0.33168870210647583,
-0.28916364908218384,
-0.0757569894194603,
0.1304771602153778,
-0.5726858973503113,
-0.062875896692276,
0.20236794650554657,
0.49019747972488403,
0.5044468641281128,
-0.36432287096977234,
-0.3125757575035095,
-0.7511516809463501,
0.9390666484832764,
-0.6974968910217285,
0.5903223752975464,
-0.11601198464632034,
0.33349815011024475,
-0.5173541307449341,
-0.45805102586746216,
-0.8078836798667908,
-0.448355495929718,
0.10770472139120102,
0.2736148536205292,
0.15926764905452728,
0.24127213656902313,
-0.22733929753303528,
0.37302830815315247,
-0.6766762733459473,
0.0024426353629678488,
-0.35401105880737305,
-0.3653041422367096,
0.8211565613746643,
0.16398712992668152,
0.2939685881137848,
0.1287100613117218,
-0.5821712017059326,
-0.0426490381360054,
-0.6189025044441223,
-0.4505213797092438,
0.04787278175354004,
0.4673633575439453,
0.026009902358055115,
0.9831109046936035,
0.016980353742837906,
0.48519155383110046,
0.20247341692447662,
-0.04970239847898483,
0.17836332321166992,
-0.9228726029396057,
-0.23764383792877197,
0.24633756279945374,
0.9556847810745239,
0.3246362507343292,
-0.020210668444633484,
-0.3451530933380127,
-0.4803291857242584,
0.20205749571323395,
0.038101375102996826,
-0.9175081253051758,
-0.031497493386268616,
0.23893064260482788,
-0.0069976807571947575,
-0.06843588501214981,
-0.2792372703552246,
-0.7726344466209412,
-0.4172270596027374,
-0.3587302267551422,
0.6170889735221863,
-0.23447036743164062,
0.056959863752126694,
-0.013036370277404785,
-0.009296122938394547,
-0.1691596508026123,
0.3951954245567322,
-0.9344649314880371,
0.2544543147087097,
0.4764922559261322,
0.6026500463485718,
-0.5777612328529358,
-0.3048376441001892,
-0.5032426118850708,
0.32760611176490784,
-0.2358289510011673,
0.5746183395385742,
-0.6285870671272278,
-0.2864718735218048,
-0.37820151448249817,
-0.24033388495445251,
0.04422565549612045,
-0.9523324966430664,
0.2567930519580841,
-0.46561768651008606,
0.3361209034919739,
-0.08529919385910034,
-0.6395524144172668,
-0.02617032825946808,
0.11278871446847916,
-0.28044772148132324,
0.999205470085144,
0.29492756724357605,
-0.19774669408798218,
0.4152710735797882,
-0.4657084345817566,
-0.37767234444618225,
-0.07205371558666229,
-0.4327809512615204,
-0.4521360993385315,
0.03989054635167122,
0.18210650980472565,
0.1903427690267563,
-0.44924044609069824,
0.28498438000679016,
-0.37050458788871765,
-0.1952357143163681,
0.5504668354988098,
-0.2108333706855774,
0.2704669237136841,
0.22264738380908966,
-0.5329294800758362,
0.6782255172729492,
-0.7465466260910034,
-0.05040553957223892,
-0.36634552478790283,
-0.4168766438961029,
-0.028553709387779236,
-0.3247015178203583,
0.38857510685920715,
0.34092599153518677,
0.3432687222957611,
-0.4972585439682007,
0.36869871616363525,
-0.1971309632062912,
0.5091825127601624,
0.6413866281509399,
-0.11261896789073944,
0.72004634141922,
-0.17581932246685028,
0.47363078594207764,
0.13523225486278534,
-0.015419852919876575,
0.2761818766593933,
-0.29742345213890076,
-0.6937150955200195,
-0.6598676443099976,
0.25573205947875977,
0.5551097393035889,
-0.6276178956031799,
0.7579727172851562,
-0.1454249620437622,
-0.3664041757583618,
-0.8056674599647522,
0.6375638842582703,
0.2557078003883362,
0.36742255091667175,
0.5670894384384155,
-0.5060832500457764,
-0.42181792855262756,
-0.8503341674804688,
-0.09595254808664322,
0.06270553916692734,
-0.05145898461341858,
0.45962095260620117,
0.38128694891929626,
-0.8743592500686646,
0.7923524379730225,
0.029743539169430733,
-0.43762141466140747,
-0.3530748784542084,
-0.04405679181218147,
0.004473178647458553,
0.3831668198108673,
0.06340332329273224,
-0.6526265740394592,
-0.41002357006073,
0.29999086260795593,
-0.7784340977668762,
-0.32704806327819824,
-0.2708464562892914,
-0.4064808785915375,
0.44373804330825806,
0.4362645745277405,
-0.8679801225662231,
0.07583674043416977,
0.5627228617668152,
-0.16166643798351288,
0.005439441651105881,
-0.046945031732320786,
0.10175751894712448,
-1.0741790533065796,
0.1164560317993164,
-0.08703140169382095,
-0.36846908926963806,
-0.640683114528656,
-0.13753096759319305,
0.05850301310420036,
0.02412707544863224,
-0.6804208159446716,
0.5402980446815491,
-0.4848124384880066,
-0.10790886729955673,
-0.3959607183933258,
0.46243080496788025,
-0.07762351632118225,
0.4329212009906769,
0.09435191750526428,
0.8208183646202087,
0.3490254580974579,
-0.4335136413574219,
0.3398509919643402,
0.014053276740014553,
0.07159081846475601,
0.5076516270637512,
-0.4226948320865631,
0.13800454139709473,
0.021323110908269882,
0.4206063151359558,
-0.8142509460449219,
-0.3346829116344452,
0.4939002990722656,
-0.35248276591300964,
0.39121565222740173,
0.4512915015220642,
-0.32716456055641174,
-0.005595813505351543,
-0.255831778049469,
0.6020781397819519,
0.34762129187583923,
-0.27942216396331787,
0.801009476184845,
0.438436359167099,
0.10115499049425125,
-0.36658740043640137,
-0.6859011650085449,
0.002392715308815241,
-0.08295003324747086,
-0.6221199631690979,
0.3998897969722748,
-0.2018771767616272,
-0.1661601960659027,
-0.0072938306257128716,
-0.4551616609096527,
0.06851371377706528,
-0.16646187007427216,
-0.026168646290898323,
0.31462621688842773,
-0.12328549474477768,
-0.19008943438529968,
0.08074851334095001,
-0.12411332875490189,
-0.08692790567874908,
-0.4434735178947449,
0.5338269472122192,
-0.1391792744398117,
-0.28600284457206726,
-0.5816710591316223,
0.37161874771118164,
0.8885864615440369,
-0.030929354950785637,
0.6593291163444519,
0.6054211258888245,
-0.2543843984603882,
-0.2481461614370346,
-0.16574636101722717,
-0.43848884105682373,
-0.48089104890823364,
0.5296428203582764,
-0.03292344883084297,
-0.9264626502990723,
0.5051075220108032,
-0.01206266414374113,
-0.23966939747333527,
0.15454216301441193,
0.9060704112052917,
-0.06481142342090607,
1.049808144569397,
0.47737982869148254,
-0.10220310091972351,
0.359801322221756,
-0.01617026887834072,
0.6702090501785278,
-0.6386685967445374,
-0.4012226462364197,
-0.12719818949699402,
-0.5876114368438721,
-0.4825413227081299,
-0.6719134449958801,
0.6310645937919617,
0.20259368419647217,
0.11000137776136398,
0.22538301348686218,
-0.4575485289096832,
0.31812939047813416,
0.3685412108898163,
0.13821682333946228,
0.3798585832118988,
0.06578747183084488,
0.007337668910622597,
0.013305079191923141,
-0.7041653990745544,
-0.2429179847240448,
1.1784405708312988,
0.1733243614435196,
1.0995458364486694,
0.03981415927410126,
0.7847509980201721,
0.1089259684085846,
0.33076363801956177,
-0.9759439826011658,
0.7298627495765686,
0.22832971811294556,
-0.5031768679618835,
-0.3025158643722534,
-0.8077287077903748,
-0.8212146759033203,
0.15881572663784027,
-0.2438846081495285,
-0.31474578380584717,
-0.033264558762311935,
0.13444706797599792,
-0.1363295316696167,
0.04386179894208908,
-0.5008321404457092,
0.7707108855247498,
-0.5577505230903625,
-0.5413854122161865,
-0.32784903049468994,
-0.7806519269943237,
0.25494712591171265,
-0.20045509934425354,
0.11185739189386368,
0.036478351801633835,
-0.22041086852550507,
0.37062832713127136,
-0.559831440448761,
0.48255112767219543,
0.11759544163942337,
-0.30153483152389526,
0.11013885587453842,
0.03154658153653145,
0.4761824607849121,
-0.10467599332332611,
0.26181352138519287,
0.14949138462543488,
-0.043630536645650864,
-0.435236394405365,
-0.8180666565895081,
0.8042750358581543,
-0.8690492510795593,
-0.5687982439994812,
-0.37150099873542786,
-1.049947738647461,
-0.1439400166273117,
0.3057333528995514,
0.08196747303009033,
-0.2234557867050171,
0.17528478801250458,
0.060877472162246704,
0.5745857954025269,
-0.007046757265925407,
0.10891301184892654,
0.5184186697006226,
-0.5260288119316101,
-0.8366352915763855,
1.1689720153808594,
-0.031038928776979446,
0.6822366714477539,
0.5103882551193237,
0.06322041898965836,
-0.30939561128616333,
-0.6063244938850403,
-0.885918140411377,
0.3481825888156891,
-0.546741783618927,
-0.04439576715230942,
-0.5298048853874207,
-0.13886068761348724,
-0.4413434565067291,
-0.21242956817150116,
-0.6348413825035095,
-0.6029388308525085,
-0.36144495010375977,
0.10117091238498688,
0.2963733375072479,
0.5347840189933777,
-0.008634460158646107,
-0.022981097921729088,
-0.8903570771217346,
0.3915313184261322,
0.021221371367573738,
0.06161188334226608,
-0.41631466150283813,
-0.3571304976940155,
-0.3742257058620453,
0.09335615485906601,
-0.1808268129825592,
-0.7941285967826843,
0.42927443981170654,
0.1931985765695572,
0.5404649376869202,
0.16306884586811066,
-0.18424536287784576,
0.6866682171821594,
-0.25145402550697327,
0.6634932160377502,
0.12213863432407379,
-0.9205289483070374,
0.3570178151130676,
-0.3608907461166382,
0.01531862560659647,
0.7326781749725342,
0.24436260759830475,
-0.4379653334617615,
-0.4612979292869568,
-0.179565891623497,
-1.1143993139266968,
0.500722348690033,
0.23492148518562317,
-0.22972112894058228,
0.3088083565235138,
0.24333150684833527,
0.1604567915201187,
0.5544517636299133,
-0.7088607549667358,
-0.32491999864578247,
-0.0689687430858612,
-0.5877192616462708,
-0.1447904109954834,
0.38845229148864746,
-0.266156405210495,
-0.4704958200454712,
0.9645187258720398,
-0.10237481445074081,
0.0028414216358214617,
0.1864534318447113,
-0.3196646571159363,
-0.5081949234008789,
0.25873762369155884,
0.8913422226905823,
0.4750573933124542,
-0.27814167737960815,
0.13735614717006683,
0.028888529166579247,
-0.49631357192993164,
0.41169512271881104,
0.09518784284591675,
-0.3814340829849243,
-0.14252765476703644,
-0.004504990763962269,
0.5789243578910828,
0.10314425081014633,
-1.0647332668304443,
0.30017581582069397,
0.22292855381965637,
-0.07660192251205444,
0.1870959997177124,
0.1186286211013794,
-0.03138230741024017,
0.44353583455085754,
0.19231057167053223,
0.2750432789325714,
0.07663127034902573,
-0.7331357598304749,
0.32009753584861755,
0.6634492874145508,
-0.39244988560676575,
-0.35750558972358704,
0.6795318722724915,
0.17863982915878296,
-0.2947585880756378,
0.42636778950691223,
-0.026693934574723244,
-0.5355349183082581,
0.20436891913414001,
0.622573733329773,
1.0116814374923706,
-0.15663732588291168,
-0.08008269220590591,
-0.10591911524534225,
0.2785096764564514,
0.10308997333049774,
0.37691405415534973,
-0.2726007103919983,
-0.5953449010848999,
-0.15296272933483124,
-0.6204210519790649,
-0.5840489268302917,
-0.07651657611131668,
-0.5162343978881836,
0.2569074332714081,
-0.4539330005645752,
0.009898284450173378,
-0.26415160298347473,
0.04090409725904465,
-0.2650628983974457,
-0.007589887827634811,
0.11728642135858536,
0.7542175054550171,
-0.8822128176689148,
0.935746431350708,
0.6731467843055725,
-0.3660334348678589,
-0.5057123303413391,
-0.05605141073465347,
0.12082617729902267,
-0.6775696873664856,
0.5267557501792908,
0.04478020220994949,
-0.3923603594303131,
-0.07316131144762039,
-0.3912707269191742,
-0.9920816421508789,
1.0163477659225464,
0.33778172731399536,
-0.6470257639884949,
0.25252243876457214,
0.47267237305641174,
0.7810872197151184,
-0.44996947050094604,
0.1700131893157959,
0.7500283122062683,
0.6173521876335144,
0.25461530685424805,
-1.0441166162490845,
0.06658024340867996,
-0.3451438546180725,
-0.19967766106128693,
0.26857709884643555,
-0.6373464465141296,
0.6650234460830688,
0.0019650824833661318,
-0.11613453179597855,
0.09418968856334686,
0.8055601716041565,
0.48547685146331787,
0.4266863763332367,
0.18874087929725647,
0.648363471031189,
0.7197065949440002,
0.06728240847587585,
0.8460848331451416,
-0.33773234486579895,
0.1495501846075058,
0.8528124094009399,
-0.6492612957954407,
0.7888886332511902,
1.1515226364135742,
-0.22546839714050293,
0.05064217001199722,
0.6744028925895691,
0.08571570366621017,
0.7348260879516602,
0.3880738615989685,
-0.41259971261024475,
-0.21664603054523468,
-0.4132424294948578,
-0.33169475197792053,
0.18717315793037415,
0.41725948452949524,
-0.2870424687862396,
0.0065223658457398415,
-0.02051452174782753,
-0.11350814253091812,
0.1575523018836975,
-0.17979805171489716,
0.6756882071495056,
0.11331615597009659,
-0.7144584655761719,
0.835489809513092,
-0.07728103548288345,
0.7048326730728149,
-0.4819280207157135,
0.06604661792516708,
-0.31751856207847595,
0.4092654585838318,
-0.2731970250606537,
-0.5059443116188049,
0.09230875223875046,
-0.23744498193264008,
-0.1814238578081131,
-0.19057966768741608,
0.23091264069080353,
-1.0529545545578003,
-0.6021450757980347,
0.3978385329246521,
0.33163726329803467,
0.1671038269996643,
0.31483760476112366,
-0.45528918504714966,
0.16024956107139587,
0.12013567239046097,
-0.150081604719162,
0.4316609799861908,
0.3325914144515991,
-0.15483324229717255,
0.5981760621070862,
0.5267537832260132,
0.16800381243228912,
0.17859524488449097,
-0.008164798840880394,
1.0666019916534424,
-0.6948205232620239,
-0.10155652463436127,
-0.8810791969299316,
0.35670599341392517,
0.2837144136428833,
-0.1752624660730362,
0.872799813747406,
0.8106651306152344,
0.9680808782577515,
0.09903808683156967,
0.7541567087173462,
0.33015501499176025,
0.15111073851585388,
-0.6713802218437195,
0.48433956503868103,
-0.6918586492538452,
0.4230906367301941,
-0.024708878248929977,
-1.1422803401947021,
-0.437652051448822,
0.49994325637817383,
0.02171412482857704,
0.07496576756238937,
0.6860017776489258,
1.2344592809677124,
-0.038120582699775696,
-0.0013421995099633932,
0.12089094519615173,
0.23200950026512146,
0.4063590168952942,
0.6890537738800049,
0.8659524917602539,
-0.37933748960494995,
0.37380385398864746,
-0.24693478643894196,
-0.10335060954093933,
-0.45459216833114624,
-0.5210632681846619,
-0.8624923825263977,
-0.22247985005378723,
-0.28539007902145386,
-0.4100024998188019,
-0.005113685503602028,
1.3558218479156494,
0.6616021394729614,
-1.0613386631011963,
-0.4401606023311615,
-0.3346681594848633,
-0.04459560662508011,
0.009202386252582073,
-0.18117454648017883,
0.09166880697011948,
-0.1866978257894516,
-0.8599313497543335,
0.8927271962165833,
0.7249909043312073,
0.2807706296443939,
-0.6757314205169678,
-0.4571570158004761,
-0.1621263027191162,
0.17572680115699768,
0.3820410370826721,
0.22976720333099365,
-0.9466306567192078,
-0.023305539041757584,
0.3412359952926636,
-0.4079975485801697,
0.20163655281066895,
0.733749270439148,
-0.6195999979972839,
0.4993997812271118,
0.6762584447860718,
0.8898352980613708,
0.5260319113731384,
-0.10731633752584457,
0.8874782919883728,
-0.5607693195343018,
0.11760266125202179,
0.4813099503517151,
0.10114443302154541,
0.38904839754104614,
-0.39542174339294434,
0.3508795201778412,
0.29864898324012756,
-0.6554493308067322,
-0.9863841533660889,
0.05007055029273033,
-1.2895383834838867,
-0.18227514624595642,
1.0251281261444092,
0.28507116436958313,
-0.4990370571613312,
0.16826751828193665,
-0.20041772723197937,
0.43793439865112305,
-0.649816632270813,
0.884641170501709,
0.5505984425544739,
-0.44006139039993286,
0.05834123119711876,
-0.2178025245666504,
0.4643819034099579,
1.0040708780288696,
-0.8028963804244995,
0.011539891362190247,
0.7268446683883667,
-0.0824439600110054,
0.22682340443134308,
0.2850208282470703,
-0.07776212692260742,
0.2288830280303955,
-0.24853232502937317,
0.19486556947231293,
0.04127059504389763,
-0.5466984510421753,
-0.39517608284950256,
-0.18423232436180115,
-0.18818485736846924,
0.016034899279475212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13974v1
|
CIVICS: Building a Dataset for Examining Culturally-Informed Values in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-22T20:19:10 | 2024-05-22T20:19:10 |
Giada Pistilli, Alina Leidinger, Yacine Jernite, Atoosa Kasirzadeh, Alexandra Sasha Luccioni, Margaret Mitchell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces the "CIVICS: Culturally-Informed & Values-Inclusive
Corpus for Societal impacts" dataset, designed to evaluate the social and
cultural variation of Large Language Models (LLMs) across multiple languages
and value-sensitive topics. We create a hand-crafted, multilingual dataset of
value-laden prompts which address specific socially sensitive topics, including
LGBTQI rights, social welfare, immigration, disability rights, and surrogacy.
CIVICS is designed to generate responses showing LLMs' encoded and implicit
values. Through our dynamic annotation processes, tailored prompt design, and
experiments, we investigate how open-weight LLMs respond to value-sensitive
issues, exploring their behavior across diverse linguistic and cultural
contexts. Using two experimental set-ups based on log-probabilities and
long-form responses, we show social and cultural variability across different
LLMs. Specifically, experiments involving long-form responses demonstrate that
refusals are triggered disparately across models, but consistently and more
frequently in English or translated statements. Moreover, specific topics and
sources lead to more pronounced differences across model answers, particularly
on immigration, LGBTQI rights, and social welfare. As shown by our experiments,
the CIVICS dataset aims to serve as a tool for future research, promoting
reproducibility and transparency across broader linguistic settings, and
furthering the development of AI technologies that respect and reflect global
cultural diversities and value pluralism. The CIVICS dataset and tools will be
made available upon publication under open licenses; an anonymized version is
currently available at https://huggingface.co/CIVICS-dataset.
|
[
-0.10759934782981873,
-0.46820172667503357,
0.31983697414398193,
0.195423886179924,
0.013266641646623611,
0.10731599479913712,
-0.6975314617156982,
-0.32597774267196655,
0.29266878962516785,
0.4673571288585663,
-0.4850764572620392,
-0.5526906847953796,
-0.6095342636108398,
0.17232348024845123,
-0.0754496157169342,
0.9234892129898071,
0.38450467586517334,
0.33233579993247986,
-0.0729338675737381,
-0.3642423748970032,
-0.2638435959815979,
-0.6560572981834412,
-0.10971950739622116,
0.36983194947242737,
0.7810823917388916,
0.6018737554550171,
0.7829023599624634,
0.45014268159866333,
0.316383957862854,
0.17848382890224457,
-0.4866504669189453,
-0.14896415174007416,
-0.6887807846069336,
0.1357126384973526,
-0.30811551213264465,
-0.4891681373119354,
-0.23762963712215424,
-0.0023983174469321966,
0.7010260224342346,
0.6736384034156799,
0.3428049385547638,
0.7029077410697937,
0.034452665597200394,
0.6204556226730347,
-0.8208330273628235,
0.36174091696739197,
-0.6838676929473877,
-0.1345934420824051,
-0.4675690531730652,
0.11450424790382385,
-0.20869380235671997,
-0.7425075769424438,
-0.2732560336589813,
-0.308510422706604,
-0.12499242275953293,
-0.30327871441841125,
0.19379200041294098,
0.1766810268163681,
-0.8719492554664612,
-0.39715394377708435,
-0.523623526096344,
0.8911502361297607,
-0.3921458423137665,
0.6185083389282227,
0.38935092091560364,
0.12156990170478821,
-0.17737673223018646,
-0.43030497431755066,
-0.5899366140365601,
-0.05580103397369385,
0.10033685714006424,
0.17025113105773926,
0.09328396618366241,
-0.24843545258045197,
0.339724063873291,
0.34149158000946045,
-0.4491061270236969,
0.2589742839336395,
-0.7896578311920166,
-0.1956770271062851,
0.750309407711029,
0.34484222531318665,
0.20065416395664215,
-0.48973366618156433,
0.08713405579328537,
-0.17031365633010864,
-0.9486191272735596,
0.8454217314720154,
0.7365532517433167,
0.7836366295814514,
-0.29865762591362,
0.9638124108314514,
-0.3193259537220001,
0.4279327392578125,
-0.27193358540534973,
0.1421854943037033,
0.3722493350505829,
-0.34995710849761963,
0.1910407543182373,
-0.008996966294944286,
0.48435381054878235,
0.36525967717170715,
0.48357677459716797,
0.21529626846313477,
-0.02419418841600418,
0.1792035698890686,
-0.07708880305290222,
-0.8251466751098633,
0.4434732496738434,
0.30251333117485046,
-0.6525754928588867,
-0.39617329835891724,
-0.0017485455609858036,
-0.9048451781272888,
-0.6080557107925415,
-0.6037342548370361,
-0.22532504796981812,
0.07621704787015915,
-0.36758124828338623,
0.039498720318078995,
0.040421005338430405,
0.2951072156429291,
0.18527640402317047,
-1.1028540134429932,
0.047449205070734024,
0.7439691424369812,
0.6378165483474731,
-0.0797615721821785,
-0.14929787814617157,
-0.6932932138442993,
-0.056774940341711044,
-0.30454739928245544,
0.4884502589702606,
-1.0755572319030762,
-0.6313066482543945,
0.20718736946582794,
0.2690393328666687,
0.3314521610736847,
-0.46634605526924133,
0.6083634495735168,
-0.4235466718673706,
-0.13599246740341187,
-0.9484949707984924,
-0.2230069786310196,
0.09112051129341125,
0.22978144884109497,
-0.7822372913360596,
0.9912530779838562,
0.0778663381934166,
-0.7205528020858765,
0.5795243978500366,
-0.7415813207626343,
-0.3319990634918213,
0.3184035122394562,
-0.5131745934486389,
0.042254913598299026,
0.23856832087039948,
-0.1755836009979248,
0.3600609600543976,
-0.0768333226442337,
0.47599470615386963,
-0.7868745923042297,
-0.16238680481910706,
0.2611403465270996,
-0.6461828351020813,
1.0577235221862793,
0.23795528709888458,
-0.18489359319210052,
0.4772146940231323,
-0.6916540265083313,
-0.20387504994869232,
0.2489299327135086,
-0.43739622831344604,
-0.2315632402896881,
0.0691411942243576,
0.2552337348461151,
0.28137609362602234,
0.3209155797958374,
-0.6737320423126221,
0.13661712408065796,
-0.05867050960659981,
0.41870853304862976,
0.9508016109466553,
-0.4169796109199524,
0.2821154296398163,
-0.1803409606218338,
0.6403205990791321,
-0.21768547594547272,
0.30825743079185486,
-0.0043079000897705555,
-0.4641282260417938,
-0.1754581779241562,
-0.2747524082660675,
0.020613335072994232,
0.5840609073638916,
-0.2547284960746765,
0.3501599431037903,
-0.3373350501060486,
-0.4013289511203766,
-0.5857973098754883,
-0.10774301737546921,
-0.14318841695785522,
0.26130756735801697,
0.10599830746650696,
-0.057385124266147614,
-0.35564395785331726,
-0.8546196222305298,
-0.2997305393218994,
-0.5384061336517334,
-0.010258653201162815,
0.4686816930770874,
0.6255368590354919,
0.04384448751807213,
1.0194004774093628,
-0.35614126920700073,
0.13258208334445953,
-0.043656542897224426,
-0.1355716735124588,
0.09311637282371521,
0.13143736124038696,
0.4714336395263672,
-0.7606260180473328,
-0.2440267950296402,
-0.19311323761940002,
-0.39775922894477844,
-0.15555736422538757,
0.24728216230869293,
-0.025228459388017654,
0.18741640448570251,
0.16166432201862335,
-0.18772383034229279,
0.6116580367088318,
0.7395252585411072,
-0.5251578688621521,
0.8378112316131592,
0.1106574758887291,
0.4462968707084656,
-1.150255560874939,
0.1780790090560913,
-0.15309828519821167,
0.13439510762691498,
-0.4078470468521118,
-0.2170696258544922,
0.08907198905944824,
-0.15087243914604187,
-0.7642479538917542,
0.8129367828369141,
-0.09050467610359192,
-0.2568705379962921,
0.05237864330410957,
-0.12251110374927521,
-0.1710895448923111,
-0.00819535180926323,
0.2749856114387512,
0.8385274410247803,
0.37692534923553467,
-0.3330903947353363,
0.508557140827179,
0.5479980111122131,
-0.2868287265300751,
0.7372660040855408,
-0.5222058892250061,
-0.1022850051522255,
-0.47310999035835266,
0.3124535381793976,
-0.6157389283180237,
-0.26442238688468933,
0.3640471398830414,
-0.449554443359375,
-0.4123608469963074,
-0.42484092712402344,
-0.5938076376914978,
-0.2755439281463623,
-0.27416136860847473,
0.6758337616920471,
0.24007678031921387,
-0.415289968252182,
0.2253991961479187,
0.7428751587867737,
-0.6824564337730408,
-0.41854962706565857,
-0.5447208285331726,
0.18472570180892944,
-0.40721824765205383,
-0.7005533576011658,
-0.21039871871471405,
-0.47173869609832764,
-0.463945597410202,
-0.11649928241968155,
0.40059566497802734,
-0.10967075824737549,
0.278917521238327,
0.18112407624721527,
0.15557748079299927,
-0.01141202449798584,
0.5264747142791748,
0.2385278344154358,
0.0057884459383785725,
0.1283644139766693,
-0.1832706332206726,
0.46494242548942566,
-0.5582523941993713,
-0.5929717421531677,
0.021674014627933502,
0.6577507257461548,
0.8268519043922424,
-0.54413241147995,
0.7453473806381226,
0.5549700260162354,
-0.5035057663917542,
0.38976967334747314,
-0.28444865345954895,
-0.061572350561618805,
-0.4261224567890167,
0.24951405823230743,
-0.2383621782064438,
-1.3622950315475464,
0.8630611896514893,
0.2542727291584015,
0.21374621987342834,
0.47980183362960815,
0.8580732345581055,
0.16082540154457092,
0.8956285119056702,
0.38246479630470276,
-0.23502783477306366,
0.41855916380882263,
0.068946473300457,
0.09568274766206741,
-0.5943726301193237,
-0.32436898350715637,
-0.9045915603637695,
-0.17924588918685913,
-0.9874492883682251,
-0.31178179383277893,
0.35477346181869507,
-0.2743232846260071,
-0.35390231013298035,
-0.2990204989910126,
-0.3222315013408661,
0.3343275487422943,
0.4239625930786133,
-0.23045092821121216,
0.36133047938346863,
-0.23282937705516815,
0.30098727345466614,
-0.2049301266670227,
-0.37429505586624146,
-0.8587878942489624,
1.1964504718780518,
0.26748278737068176,
0.7438296675682068,
0.33188989758491516,
0.2851828932762146,
0.38563117384910583,
0.38825979828834534,
-0.7631071209907532,
0.2955561876296997,
-0.18575356900691986,
-0.7535360455513,
-0.49220535159111023,
-0.4621899425983429,
-1.072371006011963,
0.09298890084028244,
-0.3233890235424042,
-0.7619684338569641,
0.2708093822002411,
-0.0014080303953960538,
-0.4123815596103668,
0.29852283000946045,
-0.22271789610385895,
0.709456741809845,
-0.46877381205558777,
-0.3809407353401184,
-0.26334092020988464,
-0.6140588521957397,
0.20980554819107056,
-0.15763777494430542,
0.6177775859832764,
-0.3236730396747589,
0.22907187044620514,
0.4478953182697296,
-0.24717845022678375,
1.0638246536254883,
-0.1137833520770073,
-0.24453739821910858,
0.2748206853866577,
-0.05955398082733154,
0.17938508093357086,
0.4240420460700989,
-0.4877825677394867,
0.36835193634033203,
0.26433441042900085,
-0.5216837525367737,
-0.19664019346237183,
0.6211302280426025,
-0.678419291973114,
-0.4271644651889801,
-0.21584290266036987,
-0.6211012601852417,
0.08670545369386673,
0.15888024866580963,
0.03338729217648506,
0.4498637914657593,
-0.3917926549911499,
0.2691943049430847,
0.5568131804466248,
-0.5796851515769958,
0.17356133460998535,
0.4339113235473633,
-0.18931469321250916,
-0.3099813461303711,
0.6256344318389893,
0.3719451129436493,
0.15990470349788666,
-0.09231770783662796,
0.33898019790649414,
-0.5000010132789612,
-0.1350851207971573,
-0.605444073677063,
0.11278870701789856,
-0.6652595400810242,
0.11094116419553757,
-0.4387212097644806,
0.009052795358002186,
-0.8095353841781616,
-0.32667264342308044,
-0.3277084529399872,
-0.3178316354751587,
-0.33035677671432495,
-0.2989465892314911,
0.5878596901893616,
0.938955545425415,
-0.1931389421224594,
-0.279628723859787,
-0.8922048211097717,
0.07005013525485992,
0.0822761282324791,
0.656746506690979,
-0.23945073783397675,
-0.35186389088630676,
0.01806049421429634,
0.42401590943336487,
0.1868932694196701,
-0.8511002063751221,
0.1172291561961174,
-0.25253140926361084,
0.5422304272651672,
0.14403055608272552,
0.35936805605888367,
0.3919401168823242,
-0.25740015506744385,
1.115013837814331,
-0.26357319951057434,
-0.8832711577415466,
0.5757809281349182,
-0.5398555397987366,
0.2966829538345337,
0.7527172565460205,
0.21104930341243744,
-1.0024627447128296,
-0.3467756509780884,
-0.38607585430145264,
-0.913774311542511,
0.45287036895751953,
0.07546775788068771,
0.4407212436199188,
-0.27182090282440186,
0.20264911651611328,
0.47615087032318115,
0.22714143991470337,
-0.7604733109474182,
-0.06652899831533432,
-0.230261892080307,
-0.41013023257255554,
0.025879669934511185,
-0.29023659229278564,
-0.02265726774930954,
-0.1807703822851181,
0.4256845712661743,
-0.34856584668159485,
-0.23955687880516052,
0.05248546600341797,
-0.1493423581123352,
-0.040787991136312485,
0.6072666645050049,
0.5723579525947571,
0.5279308557510376,
0.08861496299505234,
0.028131555765867233,
0.3257862329483032,
-0.31000757217407227,
0.08313508331775665,
-0.10780778527259827,
-0.08089733868837357,
-0.3469092845916748,
-0.001485685002990067,
0.596421480178833,
-0.20379914343357086,
-0.6428691744804382,
0.5317434072494507,
-0.3699554204940796,
0.05172006040811539,
-0.5069999694824219,
-0.3682889938354492,
0.09036558121442795,
0.18723823130130768,
0.0961499884724617,
-0.3645249605178833,
0.15537551045417786,
-0.5795676708221436,
-0.055728133767843246,
0.5401058197021484,
-0.46474942564964294,
-0.45351341366767883,
0.46322882175445557,
0.38569146394729614,
-0.2857157289981842,
0.6449461579322815,
-0.16746562719345093,
-0.4842414855957031,
0.608910322189331,
0.1357058584690094,
0.5984070301055908,
-0.13268344104290009,
0.28807324171066284,
0.3330523669719696,
0.3074183166027069,
0.15424789488315582,
0.6251625418663025,
-0.04187936335802078,
-0.6138630509376526,
-0.2827194035053253,
-0.4998105764389038,
-0.4409230053424835,
0.031500402837991714,
-0.8486681580543518,
0.3367023468017578,
-0.34294506907463074,
-0.14433103799819946,
-0.43863537907600403,
0.06806519627571106,
-0.8742979168891907,
0.09958026558160782,
0.25868991017341614,
0.9624944925308228,
-1.3299317359924316,
0.31544730067253113,
0.5838611721992493,
-0.35978496074676514,
-0.5128341913223267,
-0.07072935998439789,
0.4265383780002594,
-0.6268743872642517,
0.6378030180931091,
0.19725698232650757,
-0.23344478011131287,
-0.1296069473028183,
-0.5245475769042969,
-0.9810340404510498,
0.8016612529754639,
0.4127645790576935,
-0.30235394835472107,
0.5450366139411926,
0.6645104885101318,
0.4146462380886078,
-0.32412225008010864,
0.340281218290329,
0.5933334827423096,
0.8156204223632812,
-0.07333728671073914,
-0.747355043888092,
0.02314206212759018,
-0.37987327575683594,
-0.17910680174827576,
-0.05433328449726105,
-0.9749507904052734,
0.4009898900985718,
-0.21502842009067535,
0.0021203099749982357,
0.0053841243498027325,
0.5451496243476868,
0.4170020818710327,
0.2998696565628052,
0.5978638529777527,
0.12052793800830841,
1.0164518356323242,
0.000852527969982475,
0.8552919030189514,
-0.28236934542655945,
0.04934157431125641,
0.808485746383667,
-0.43268144130706787,
0.6786522269248962,
0.26232871413230896,
-0.12933558225631714,
0.2441098839044571,
0.9242334961891174,
0.14554406702518463,
0.04872145503759384,
0.5493919849395752,
-0.358024001121521,
-0.03874347731471062,
-0.7311697602272034,
-0.46252700686454773,
0.6625231504440308,
0.4672624468803406,
-0.08326008915901184,
0.010460994206368923,
-0.17618416249752045,
0.027865095064044,
-0.013163604773581028,
-0.36709830164909363,
0.6111010313034058,
-0.13850779831409454,
-0.4187938868999481,
-0.011364797130227089,
-0.23561672866344452,
0.5633618831634521,
-0.5755859017372131,
0.18103688955307007,
-0.18389463424682617,
-0.4223308563232422,
-0.3706776797771454,
-1.1603869199752808,
0.41749894618988037,
0.33516204357147217,
-0.4961695969104767,
-0.2139112502336502,
0.40687447786331177,
-0.45233649015426636,
-0.7084397077560425,
0.2954271137714386,
0.37443992495536804,
0.2797450125217438,
0.08525514602661133,
-0.4338369369506836,
0.5085172057151794,
-0.08857537060976028,
-0.29298681020736694,
0.21918687224388123,
0.42397797107696533,
-0.5740249156951904,
0.48379552364349365,
0.8567606210708618,
0.24970227479934692,
0.0005265164654701948,
0.4916881322860718,
0.7013819217681885,
-0.6404774785041809,
-0.5874826908111572,
-0.5878570079803467,
0.9421868920326233,
-0.04381046071648598,
-0.45129862427711487,
0.38086840510368347,
0.6487090587615967,
1.0414360761642456,
0.3063035309314728,
1.1197477579116821,
-0.026874281466007233,
0.36737728118896484,
-0.26072975993156433,
0.6200924515724182,
-0.4988013505935669,
0.17547358572483063,
-0.21169763803482056,
-0.6882064342498779,
-0.22540460526943207,
0.28555846214294434,
-0.43587353825569153,
0.2359851896762848,
0.08683232963085175,
0.7346799373626709,
0.32802659273147583,
0.203963041305542,
0.24250644445419312,
0.12388172745704651,
0.5674543976783752,
0.1118803322315216,
0.985923171043396,
0.27559810876846313,
0.4011940658092499,
0.03227100148797035,
-0.3969172537326813,
-0.0302437711507082,
-0.8840832114219666,
-0.48606547713279724,
-0.6812000274658203,
-0.06949563324451447,
-0.27809274196624756,
-0.0742119774222374,
1.2530384063720703,
0.4032573997974396,
-0.7693355083465576,
-0.2733023762702942,
0.4997539520263672,
0.09451732039451599,
0.36931493878364563,
-0.24682959914207458,
0.20013093948364258,
-0.10465123504400253,
-0.7679452896118164,
0.12203619629144669,
0.348098486661911,
-0.06552281230688095,
-0.3751068413257599,
0.03870392218232155,
0.2823200225830078,
0.054821837693452835,
0.6805379390716553,
0.3171170949935913,
-0.7169097661972046,
-0.7046392560005188,
0.18823246657848358,
-0.09341204911470413,
-0.07822668552398682,
0.8020640015602112,
-0.44768956303596497,
0.41337329149246216,
0.5841403007507324,
0.5137503147125244,
-0.03655639663338661,
-0.17436303198337555,
0.4130702316761017,
-0.31842464208602905,
0.06773955374956131,
0.3266253173351288,
0.5355820059776306,
0.4318070113658905,
-0.7007001638412476,
0.19810882210731506,
0.18646597862243652,
-0.567994236946106,
-0.585129976272583,
0.6861240863800049,
-0.794826090335846,
-0.1928110271692276,
1.41139554977417,
0.06483235955238342,
-0.028302980586886406,
-0.20767173171043396,
-0.17192207276821136,
0.19146977365016937,
-0.5284194946289062,
0.904886782169342,
0.7163759469985962,
0.27578026056289673,
0.01933451183140278,
-0.4146643877029419,
0.1633632779121399,
0.31203147768974304,
-0.8626956939697266,
0.5820960998535156,
0.8249933123588562,
0.2929486930370331,
-0.2227424681186676,
0.60973060131073,
-0.46442481875419617,
0.19468294084072113,
-0.49666836857795715,
0.22576498985290527,
0.1581427901983261,
-0.14480538666248322,
-0.8245983123779297,
-0.023731781169772148,
0.15634991228580475,
0.27132007479667664
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.